|
|
|
|
| Anonymous User (login or join us) | Upload |
This audio is available in streaming format
| Information | Format | Size |
| gd1972-11-19-all.md5 | Checksums | 1.5 KB |
| gd72-11-19.sbd.winters.17705.sbeok.shnf_files.xml | Metadata | [file] |
| gd72-11-19.sbd.winters.17705.sbeok.shnf_meta.xml | Metadata | 4.8 KB |
| gd72-11-19.sbd.winters.17705.sbeok.shnf_reviews.xml | Metadata | 8.9 KB |
| Other Files | Text | Unknown |
| gd1972-11-19.17705.txt |
4.9 KB
|
|
| md5_ok |
??B
|
Reviewer:
wisconsindead -
Subject:
72, boring? WHAT!?!?!?!!!~
i couldnt disagree more with jamminjerome. 72 trumps 71 and 73. I personally dont see all the fuss over 73 (though i've been that way with other years, and then saw the light, same story with 72). I think 73 is very good, but I prefer the sound of the instruments in 72, bobby especially, also love jerry's tone. The dark stars, playing in the band and other ones are all better in 72, at least IMO...
That being said quality show with a good dark star. There are some cool moments with just phil making really whacky noises. I personally think that nothing compares to a good 72 dark star. its bliss, no where near boring!
Reviewer:
clementinescaboose -
Subject:
bird song
just like to point out that there seems to be a glitch or small splice at 2:55 in this version...the text file does not mention it and the other copy does not seem to have this problem...i would recommend streaming that one instead since its sounds better anyway.
Reviewer:
Chris U. -
Subject:
Tomorrow is Forever
Yeah, this is one of the best fxcking versions of this great song the band ever played, bar none.
There is an essential 72 interview in Playbody where Jerry heaps some praise on Dolly Parton. This is why.
Reviewer:
Hypodoche -
Subject:
re-think this dark star!
there are some well-known jazz themes (and 2 classical themes in latter part) explored in this version, some I've never heard take over to the extent here, leading to one entire verse in a different than usual modality... even some screechy floyd-ian passages - very organic
Reviewer:
JamminJerome -
Subject:
1972 = booooring
1972 is just not my cup of tea. With 71, and to a lesser extent 73, it is a year filled with spot-on but unexploratory songs. Even the Dark Star here is boring.
But Keith is on, the band is solid, and the show is good. Just not my preference. I'll be fair and give it 5 stars, because it really isn't that bad. There are better shows from this year.
Highlights: Stella Blue, Around and Around, inventive tunings
Reviewer:
peach4077 -
Subject:
Happy Birthday to me
As I was coming out of Mom, the Dead were on stage for an amazing celebration of life, music and jamming. One of my favorites if you can get a hold of good quality. This one definitely replaces my old worn out version. A better, more well rounded set list you will be hard pressed to find. Enjoy!!!!
Reviewer:
BigRobStud -
Subject:
My favorite Dark Star
I remember getting this show back in 1993. It was terrible quality but I could still zone out while studying at York University. Long live GD!
Reviewer:
jfk62 -
Subject:
deadboots soundboard
Soundboard available at deadboots.com
The recording sounds very good. Nice versions of familiar songs. Nothing really amazing, but very solid performances. The first two songs of the concert are missing.
Reviewer:
shallwego -
Subject:
Performance: 4.0 / 5.0... Sound Quality: 2.5 / 5.0
Very low recording levels on this one makes for a lot of hiss, due to the fact that you're forced to crank it way up to hear anything at all. First couple of tunes are basically unlistenable. This one could really benefit from a bigtime remastering job!
Reviewer:
deadbroc -
Subject:
Black Throat
Black throated wind. I've listened for the Garcia runs from this tune for years. Never heard it again. I would have regretted getting a Bobby brew on this one. Thank G-D for the archive.
Reviewer:
Polka -
Subject:
Best of the Common!
I've always rated this show very highly, as it contains some of the best versions of the more common Dead songs. Black-Throated, Railroad, Jack Straw, Don't Ease and Chinarider are all excellent!
Box of Rain is Phil's best one. Both Stella and Tommorow are beautiful. I'm not worried about having a super Dark Star all the time, so don't let it bother you. Enjoy the lyrics to Around and enjoy the show!
Sound: A-
Show: A
Reviewer:
capn doubledose -
Subject:
Bird Song+
I had this on a cassete tape in 1983 that had a beer dumped all over it and then snapped so this is a first since... playin, ramble on rose, dark star (I saw what the others said and respectfully disagree) into not quite WRS first licks also note the wierd lyrics to around and around.
Reviewer:
dcain -
Subject:
Wonderful first set
A little "Stars and Stripes Forever" from Keith after Box of Rain...this is a fun, spirited performance. Garcia's playing is crisp and snappy throughout. Lots of nice piano from KG. The tune "Tomorrow is Forever" --- a Dolly Parton song! --- is a rare treat (the vocals may be a bit off, but it's heartfelt). Highly recommended.
(agreed: the Dark Star is not great; only one verse, some serious screeching feedback, no "feelin groovy" chaser, and a weak solo from Phil. Instead, it resolves into their first ever attempt at the prelude to WRS, and it is quite tentative; they fairly quickly head back into screechy, dissonant space, ultimately finding some shelter in a more straighforward number, Mississippi Half Step)(this is a very early version of Half Step, so don't expect much in the way of Garcia fireworks)(Around & A is pretty exciting, but for masters classes in Chuck Berry licks, see his work in the 1978-1982 timeframe).
Reviewer:
xonix -
Subject:
Beware of the cuts
The performance sometimes is good (Bird song, playin in the band, box of rain (this is a particular treat)), however a few songs are spoiled by a few cuts with nothing to splice into the gap. The dark star is not that great... too much in the way of quiet creepy parts (for me at least).
![[help]](/images/question.gif "[help]")
