96 A PILGRIMAGE FOR PEACE by teaching them industry and thereby removing the principal motive that leads them into the raiding habit. " I am having talks with Khudai Khidmatgars in this connection and evolving a plan in collaboration with Bad- shah Khan. If the plan bears fruit, and the Khudai Khid- matgars truly become what their name signifies, the in- fluence of their example, like the sweet fragrance of the rose, will spread to the tribes and might provide a per- manent solution of the Frontier question/' Before leaving Bannu Gandhiji allowed himself to be taken to the site of the recent raid. In the course of our brief visit several facts were brought to his attention. From what one saw and heard, It was clear that the raid could have been aborted if there had been the slightest wish on the part of the officers immediately concerned. They had notice of the coming raid. The raiders were practically under observation all the time. Why the raid was allowed to run its full course is a mystery. But the reader should have some knowledge of the theatre of the raiders' action. The fertile and beautiful Bannu plain watered by the Kurram and the Gambila rivers has a varied and woeful history. Surrounded as it is by the bleak and waterless salt range in the Kohat District on the north, by the sandy tract of Dera Ismail Khan on the south, and on the west and north-west by the howling wilderness of the Waziristan hills, where life is a perpetual struggle, not only of man against nature, but also of man against man, it naturally became an ob- ject of temptation to its fierce border neighbours. Its early history reads more like a blood-curdling narrative of the battles between hawks, kites and other birds of prey than anything else. The following excerpt taken at random from Thorburn's monograph on Bannu will serve as an apt illustration : " Now the children of Shah Farid, who was also called Shitak, were glad for they were sore pressed at the hands of men of the tribe Wazir, and they girded up their loins, and with their wives and little ones came down from the mountains, and camped at the mouth of the pass called Tochi. Then their elders assembled together and said, 'Let us send three pigeons to the