A HAPPY WARRIOR with youths and friends like Xenophon* But in less than a year the tyranny of the Thirty was over- thrown in a sharp civil war, though at their call Lysander with Spartan troops again entered the city. Thrasybulus and other citizens exiled by the Thirty then set up a new form of government, and new laws were adopted. That date (403) marks the end of Athenian glory in the material world. Under the new control the position of the followers of Socrates was no better, and it was this government that a few years later (399 B.C.) caused Socrates himself to drink the soothing poison of hemlock as a witness to those unwritten and eternal Laws of God to which Antigone appealed. What was a man like Xenophon, clear-sighted and active by nature, to do as the splendid city sank in the midst of shifting chaos and uncertainty ? We do not know whether he served in the cavalry as one of the " Knights", or on which side he may have served, though he would probably be with Thrasybulus against the Thirty. He may have taken part in some handicraft with Socrates, who always extolled manual work, and found his own tranquillity and satisfaction in sculpture. When civil strife was not actually raging, he might roam about the city, taking pleasure, like Aristophanes, in watching the country people bringing in their goods to market and discussing quality and price, as market people always have done* Thus he acquired knowledge that he was long after- wards to use in his Guide to Women on House- keeping. And besides, there were the disputations with his master and other friends about practical points of behaviour. But mere conversation, as in a modern Club, cannot satisfy anyone who longs for action, and a sudden joy must have come to him with