W/ET77F a TWENTY-SECOND NNUAL REPORT OF THE fprooblon {lark {[ommissioners FOR THE YEAR 1882. TWENTY-SECOND PINAL REPORT OF THE Cd fprooklon {ark { ommissioners mOmen dis YEAR 1882: BROOKLYN: PRINTED FOR THE COMMISSIONERS. 18832. COMMISSIONERS AND OFFICERS. JAN. 18ST TO JUNE 17TH, 1882. — ee JAMES S. T. STRANAHAN, Christian T. Christensen, Alfred S. Barnes, William Marshall, Stephen V. White, Abraham B. Baylis, Raphael C. Stearns, Darwin R. James, The Mayor, Ex Officio. OFEFICHRS. PRESIDENT, JAMES 5S. T. STRANAHAN. SHORE TARY, FRANCIS G. QUEVEDO. CHIEF ENGINEER AND SUPERINTENDENT, JOHN Y. CULYER. COMMISSIONERS AND OFFICERS. OMEN REN Go: WILLIAM B. KENDALL. D. H. Houghtaling, John Gibb, George H. Fisher, _ J. Rogers Maxwell, Charles Garlichs, George W. Chauncey, The Mayor, Ex Officio. OR RKICHRS. PRESIDENT, WILLIAM B. KENDALL. SVE CHIE TAR NE GHORGEH W. CHAUNCKY. CELE ias CIEE TE ANDREW A. SMITH. CHIEF ENGINEER AND SUPERINTENDENT, SOON VC NGG Naas, \< Mais. ] ) RHPORT OF THE Brooklyn Park Commissioners. January 1, 18853. To the Honorable the Mayor and Common Council of the City of Brooklyn : In compliance with the statute, the Brooklyn Park Com- missioners respectfully present their annual report. The present Board entered upon their duties on June 17, 1882. The books of the Commission were found to be in an incom- plete state, and a resolution was passed, July 7th, respectfully requesting the Comptroller to detail from the Board of Audit or other force at his command, competent expert clerical force to examine and balance the accounts and to report the result of such examination to this Board. In accordance with this resolution an examination was made, the result of which is shown in the accompanying report of the Comptroller. New books were opened, dating with the organization of the : I co) c=) present Board, and the system adopted therein has received the approval of the Comptroller. 6 REPORT OF THE The statements appended, exhibit in detail the receipts and disbursements for the year. It will be seen by these statements, that the entire appro- priations for the year have been expended. The balance of the appropriations which we received were found by us entirely inadequate for the work necessary to be done. For the details of the work done during the year, we refer you to the accompanying report of the Chief Engineer and Superintendent. EAST SIDE LANDS. There were sold by public auction, November 17, 1881, two hundred and eighty-six lots. Of this number, seventy-six have not been taken, and the Corporation Counsel has been in- structed to commence proceedings to compel purchasers to take title. There remain unsold seven hundred and twenty-eight lots. OCEAN PARKWAY IMPROVEMENT. Pursuant to the provisions of Chapter 247 of the Laws of 1882, the Commissioners made a report, under the direction of the Corporation Counsel, of the total cost of this improvement, including interest at the rate of six per centum, together with a statement showing the amount due upon each parcel of land respectively, under and in pursuance of the provisions of said law, which report was sent to the Board of Supervisors and the County Treasurer on the 21st day of July, 1882. That the total cost of said improvement amounts to .............. $365,634 29 Interest on same to May 31, 1882.......... oie SAAS A: SA ee hee 187,216 66 $552,850 95 CITY HALL PARK. Since the open space surrounding the City Hall has been if ] g yi paved it has entirely lost its character as a park,and the chief duty devolving on the Commission in this connection is that of ny, e BROOKLYN PARK COMMISSIONERS. a keeping it free from snow in winter; as this frequently necessi- tates withdrawing a portion of our force from more important work, we suggest that the care of this park be transferred to the Department of City Works, which has charge of all the public buildings in the vicinity. BEDFORD AVENUE. This avenue was, by special legislation in 1878, placed under the care of this Department. In 1881 the amount which could be expended upon it for cleaning and repairs was limited by Act of the Legislature to five thousand dollars per annum. The importance of the avenue as a thoroughfare, and its present defective condition, coupled with the limited means provided by law for its maintenance, compel us, after careful consideration, to recommend its transfer to the Department of City Works. To this Department, which has the care of nearly all the other streets of the city, as well as the water and sewer- age systems underlying the same, the care and control of this avenue seems to us naturally to belong; and, in making such transfer, adequate provision should be made for its immediate repair. CONSTITUTION OF PARK COMMISSION. In our judgment, the time has now arrived when a change should be made in the constitution of the Commission. The great work of constructing and developing our present system of parks naturally suggested that all sections of the city should be represented in the Commission. This work, now substantially completed, has justly merited and received the approval of all classes, and there seems to us no longer a necessity for so large a Commission. To maintain our parks as now constituted will be the chief labor of the future, and to this end constant care and direct supervision are imperatively demanded. 8 REPORT OF THE The duties should devolve upon one Commissioner, whose entire time and thought should be devoted to the work, and who should be directly responsible to the Mayor of the city. Such manugement and responsibility, aside from bemg in direct harmony with the present Charter, would, we are confi- dent, meet the approval of all who have given our parks and their government any attention. We would therefore recommend such legislation ‘as may be necessary to accomplish this result. Respectfully, WM. B. KENDALL, President. DEPARTMENT OF FINANCE, Comptroller’s Office, City Hall. Brookiyn, December 13, 1882. To the Honorable the Board of Brooklyn Park Commissioners : GENTLEMEN : In compliance with the resolution passed by your honorable body, July 7, last, and submitted to me July 8: “That the Comptroller be respectfully requested to detail from the service of the Board of Audit, or other force at his command, without expense to this Department, competent expert clerical force to examine and balance the books and report the result of such examination to this Board,” I imme- diately, after receipt of your request, directed Mr. Wm. A. Brown, the Chief Accountant of the Board of Audit, with the help of Mr. Theodore A. Drake, to examine the accounts of your Department up to the date of the commencement of your adminstration of its affairs. You will perceive, from the an- nexed report of Mr. Brown, the result of his labor, also the reason of the apparent delay in its execution. , BROOKLYN PARK COMMISSIONERS. 9 The examination has been from the books and bank accounts at the disposal of the experts, and I considered it necessary, under the circumstances, before announcing its result, and to avoid all possible mistake, to engage Mr. A. B. Martin, the expert accountant (employed by me in the examination of the accounts of the Board of Education), to revise the modus of the experts of the Board of Audit and their work. Mr. Martin, after ex- amination, agrees ‘with me as to the efficiency and correctness of the work in question, but thinks as I do, that to get at an indisputable result, an examination of the vouchers as well as of the books would be proper, and I respectfully recommend that such should be had, also that the books of the Park Department should be written up and properly balanced to the date of your administration, and then continued in the form I have heretofore advised, and which is now in vogue. Considering that the former Board of Park Commissioners (as In the case of the Board of Education), cannot be held responsible for mistakes, negligence and even dishonesty of their trusted employes, otherwise than for their own careless- ness in trusting in and supervising such employees, and in the hope that some valid explanation might still be had to account for the deficiency, I considered it proper to apprise Mr. J. S. T. Stranahan, the former President of your Board, who has eiven his whole energy and care to the Park Department since the inception of Prospect Park, and during a term of twenty-two years without any remuneration, of the distressing fact of the dis- covered deficiency in his Secretary's accounts. (I beg leave to attach copies of my corespondence with Mr. Stranahan.) The result of this communication was as I had expected, and is in keeping with his acknowledged public spirit and nice definition of his responsibility, that after a glance over the amounts and ficures compiled by the experts, Mr. Stranahan handed me, as Comptroller, his personal check for $10,604.42, the whole amount of the deficiency. I have deposited this amount with the City Treasurer upon the following receipt : “Received, Brooklyn, December 12, 1882, from Ludwig Sem- ler, Comptroller, ten thousand, six hundred and four dollars and 2 10 : REPORT OF THE forty-two cents for balance found on examination of the Park Commissioners’ accounts due the city, this amount having been paid by Mr. J. 8. T. Stranahan, subject to any corrections that may be found in the further examination of the accounts of the late Park Commissioners, to credit of Maintenance of Public Parks. $10,604.42. “| Signed. | A. D. WHEELOCK, “ Deputy Treasurer.” I think that it is proper that we should remember, in weigh- ing the burden of these deficiencies, that they are distributed over transactions extending through twenty-two years and amounting to over eight millions of dollars. Very respectfully, LUDWIG SEMLER, Comptroller. DEPARTMENT OF FINANCE, Comptroller’s Office, City Hall, Brookiyn, December 12, 1882. J. S. T. Srrananan, Esq., Ha-President, Brooklyn Park Commissioners : Dear SIR: Having been requested by the present Board of Park Com- missioners to cause an examination of the account of that Commission up to the 17th day of June last, the date of your retirement from the Commission, whose President you have been up to that time, I have had the account in question examined and find from the report of accountant Wm. A. Brown, to whom the examination was intrusted, that there is a defi- ciency in the account to the credit of the city to the amount of $10,604.42. IT consider it proper that I should notify you of this fact before I close my examination and officially report thereon. Yours, very respectfully, | Signed. | LUDWIG SEMLER, |. Comptroller. BROOKLYN PARK COMMISSIONERS. 11 Brooxiyn, December 12, 1882. Hon. Lupwie Semier, Comptroller : Dear Sir: Your favor of this date informing me that Mr. William A. Brown, the accountant appointed by you to examine the ac- count of the Park Commission while under my presidency, had reported an apparent deficiency, has been received. Acting upon the principle by which I have been guided during twenty-two years of gratuitous service to the city, I hand to you my check to cover such deficiency, so that the books and accounts of the Park Commission can be correctly balanced as of the date of the expiration of my term of office. On writing up the books, such amounts as it is now known should be returned to me, and also such other sums hereafter found that should properly be returned to me, I would thank you to remit. . Very truly yours, &ce., J. S. T. STRANAHAN. Hon. Lupwic SEMLER, Comptroller and Chairman of the Board of Audit: Sir : Herewith I present you with a preliminary report of the results of my examination of the books and accounts of the De- partment of Parks, from January, 1865, to June 17, 1882, the time at which the new Commissioners took charge. At the commencement of my labors I found that the actual balance in the National City Bank to the credit of the Park Commissioners was $29,596.52. As the Commissioners were desirous of using this money, and there being three sources of revenue from which it might have been drawn, it became necessary to know how much was appli- cable to the credit of each, and haying so ascertained, found as follows : 19 REPORT OF THE To proceeds of ‘salesiof enst/side Jamds!.1..... 2... oeel- sc eae $25,229 49 To npark TevenwUe «3. |: 32e vas sade Oe Oe mise cee wee: Cet Ue ave 534 06 To. county appropriations ...% Js ienens cesses) can ct dds ee +e oe 3,832 97 An examination of the first account haying been made, the exact amount applicable thereto was determined. Cash book items in June, 1882, furnished the second amount. The balance, or third item, necessarily belonged to county appropriations, subject, however, to a further. examination for the outstanding checks, to be deducted therefrom. Having arrived at this conclusion I at once notified the Park Commissioners that they might be enabled to place the amounts to their proper credits, and thereupon proceeded with the examination of the financial affairs in connection with the Park Commissioners in order to ascertain the proper amount which should be to the credit of the Commission on the 17th of June, 1882. The careless manner in which the accounts of the office have been kept necessitated a recourse in all instances to the books of original entry, such as cash books, check and bank books and books of the Comptroller and County Treasurer, the absence of numerous entries in the proper books making this method absolutely necessary, and as being the only source from which I could derive any information. Considering the period of time covered by the examination— nearly eighteen years—and as it has been supplementary to, and interfered with my other duties, I have been pressed for time in the prosecution of this work, and am compelled to, and herewith present, the results of a preliminary examination in tabular form, of which the following is a resumé. Total receipts from January, 1865, to June 17, 1882............. $8,439,975 83 Total payments u és BSW 168 PIs gis Ngati eRe 8,402,212 44 Balance .cy. s/se ae acento este eC Lome ha Vee $37,763 39 Lo}y zh aveyouriaky] orp allay hobav-VilyigeleisP ae, Cone neanocSaoasens $29,596 52 Less outstanding checks........ Blatt ee ere 2,437 55 $27,158 97 Unaccounted for............ eae othe error ee $10,604 42 BROOKLYN PARK COMMISSIONERS. 13 Occurring as follows: Receipts over deposits in 1866 .................-. 30 LORD CCH ee OD elo ome tiiee mon yeep aise ys $237 84 dein, Wey Wepconesoe ae AS et epee 1,021 11 INOW ESOS ISM (een cco eeccts Mahas a eles 1,075 65 Sepbe lors (9 es o se sess seeks 1,711 56 Weer (Gh US80e fee seh os 2,172 46 INGKiG: Pets acto Weeks emia ee mene ae 3,645 88 Uming, Ig, eta see = boca 462 42 $10,927 22 Wepositsioverreceipts im! WST8is 4.5... s-c2eal eee: 322 80 $10,604 42 As an explanation of the irregularities apparent in the above classification, it may be said that the balances thus shown are in consonance with the bank balance nearest to the Ist of January in each year. In regard to the outstanding checks on June 17, 1882, above mentioned, the following is a list thereof: VAGREINGTE ING = GENES iss escuchar Sa a Ee eee ol eet eee $54 80 LISTE aR es ERR ede gee ade 131 25 ANDO OMG NK ees eeepaeetenan tar deere rete tet hs SSN lae eatene. Baie 150 00 AN GO a nee ae rm ean ee een ges Che : 199 50 GL AGIG) IGS cee OR Os ae be RAE De PC Te te ea he ONE 150 00 A GG3ia ates ea tA Sean ee a uns AN g Pees Oe a. 150 00 Gk (TOLD sce 8 EM SDN imi ci Tet Ue pa 2 a hprear ag aN SN 60 00 AOD) 2 oh 3 oo aie AR ee ae Ela eran a i 150 00 db AUS en Bic. FOE OEE oe ees a ae Oe le 60. 00 Ge TAU COU eae Paice he Se ES RRO Ee TAR Pena eres ot ener ea 300 00 ALU Serpent Nee tet aee Set ens one yee eS eR ped 157 50 AN USS) 3b a Cee eo ee eee ae cae pee ter re ae 250 00 CL AZADI NN SR ah NE et ec Es i a eee Pes Ses 399 50 NTO MERIC RTS arc aoe rR ee ae ee See eoe es ne 225 00 ANY 8 a SP NAG CLEC Lh EE a ee a Se Te ae $2,487 55 Of the above checks I may state that No. 4,610, for $199.50, was issued in error and not used. No. 4,765, for $399.50, was also issued in error, the party having been paid said amount out of the Trust fund. There appears to be an indebtedness of the Commissioners to the National City Bank of $48,600, balance on a note and interest, occasioned by disbursements made by the Park Com- 14 REPORT OF THE ee — — —-+ missioners in anticipation of the issue of Bonds by the Comp- troller, under authority of the Legislature, to grade Ninth avenue and Fifteenth street, and make improvements on Wash- ington avenue; the amount expended on these improvements, together with interest, would about make that amount. Although the tabular statement specially shows the receipts from east side lands, the disbursements therefor are included thereon with the other disbursements; a detailed statement, however, has been made, of which the following is a recapitu- lation : Receipts, 10 per cent. of sales. .i..8 a. ss. sections sie ee eee $22,520 00 cf 30 re oe sievals Scans eleseh Stone ke sia «Uareee eee e 94,325 (0 36 am Pal) oe SS ke 2 as ens wes eis eae eo alee Or 31,675 00 DISBURSEMENTS. $148, 520 00 AAV BOUISIM OS craic eras cee alavocs Oak asi oe yee a mintels miseeseterorenetereyee $1,329 99 LAGS Ride Smoratar ao BOA doom ane Se ObGin 931 00 Searches 2.8 fires ae incu sie setts cues sual meee 25 00 Collectomof Dax esy cise coxrna Pane Secels aalee ee oenines 1,609 05 Repistrar Of-ATNears nein) ceteroteteiocee acacia eecrmre rs 12,230 40 COMMIssIOMEr OL MS lMikIns Hho ene ee eens 55,745 O1 National) Cityr Bank) tock) betas oh cain sang once aickoke ree 51,420 06 123,290 51 Balance’on hand June 17s L882... oe) 2 eine ee cee eee $25,229 49 There appears to be a regular set of books for these east side lands in which no entries have been made, and I found it neces- sary to collate the above information from a petty a and memorandum books. In regard to the faulty condition in which the accounts of the Commissioners were kept, and the manner in which the general business of the office was apparently conducted, I desire to state, that since January 1, 1879, some receipts and disburse- ments have not been entered, neither has the ledger been posted for some years, that the check books since 1866 do not show the entries of any deposits, neither do they show any balance in consonance with those of the bank books. In consequence of the present condition of the books, the Park Commissioners are unable to determine the balances due to the several accounts, nor can they do so until they are properly written up, and I would recommend that it be done as soon as possible. BROOKLYN PARK COMMISSIONERS. 15 In my judgement a more thorough investigation of everything connected with the Commission since its inception should be had, such a one as, under the circumstances, I have not had the opportunity of accomplishing. In the meantime the present Commissioners have had new books opened from the date of the transfer, June 17, 1882, which I may justly say are being admirably kept. In conclusion, permit me to acknowledge the every facility afforded me in the office of the Commissioners, and extreme courtesy extended to my associate, Mr. Theo. A. Drake and myself by the President and members thereof, as well the attachés of the office. a Respectfully, WILLIAM A. BROWN, Brooxtyn, Dec. 13, 1882. Accountant Board of Audit. Brookiyn, Dec. 138, 1882. Hon. Lupwic SEmMiLER, Comptroller : Dear Sir: Agreeably with your desire that I should examine as to. the facts in connection with the preliminary report of an examina- tion of the affairs of the Park Commission rendered to you by Mr. Wm. A. Brown, accountant of the Board of Audit, I find that after a careful and thorough investigation of the details of the subject matter embraced therein, aided very materially by the manner in which the papers furnished by Mr. Brown had been prepared, [ am constrained to admit the correctness of the findings in every particular as therein set forth, and, that being cognizant of the contents of a more comprehensive re- ‘port to you this day on the same subject, I desire to say that, together with its correctness as to the facts therein stated, I am heartily in accord with it in the suggestions as to the neces- sity of a more thorough investigation. Yours respectfully, ANDREW B. MARTIN, » Accountant and Auditor. 16 REPORT OF THE REPORT OF THE CHIEF ENGINEER AND SUPERINTENDENT. Brookiyyn, January 1, 1883. To the Brooklyn Park Commissioners : GENTLEMEN : The operations of the Commission during the year 1882 have been chiefly restricted to the work of maintenance. By reason of the besetting disavantages which our limited appropriation have entailed upon us, the general results corre- spond to those of former seasons. For several years past there has been no sufficient specific appropriation to offset the nat- ural and anticipated decay and deterioration of many essential features of construction, such as buildings, roads, walks, plan- tations, enclosing fences, &e. The use of the park by the public in 1882 was greater, as were also the means of enjoyment, than during any other period of its existence. To anticipate and fulfil the consequent requirements of a community that had been encouraged and educated to draw to the fullest extent upon the resources of the Commission, it has been necessary for us to expend no inconsiderable amount of money, which, while enhancing the comfort and pleasure of visitors, in nowise contributed toward that class of work from which any substantial permanent effect could be derived. There can be no doubt that the money thus expended was wisely used, as the resulting benefits accrued directly to a great number of our citizens to whom the park affords almost the only means of out-door recreation available to them. The choice of policy, in these instances enforced upon us by necessity, has undoubtedly subjected the Commission to criti- cism as to its methods of administration. The casual observer, however intelligent, can form but a vague idea of the great number of uses to which, under proper regulations, the parks, BROOKLYN PARK COMMISSIONERS. 17 —— &c., are devoted, nor can they fully realize the infinite details in connection with the daily routine and current use of the park, which tend to draw upon and dissipate the labor of the comparatively small force at our command. The winter months were remarkable for no extended periods of severe cold. All the necessary preparations for skating and winter sports had been made, involving an expenditure for con- siderable preparatory work which could not be avoided, but, owing to the absence of any protracted prevalence of an ice producing temperature, we had only three days’ skating during the season. | Numerous snow storms, however, with the anticipation of skating which the season continuously encouraged, kept us quite busy, while the frequent thawing made it necessary to do a great deal of work upon the drives, the surfaces of which it was frequently necessary to put in order. Later, with the advance of spring, the work of renovation commenced and ex- tended generally over the whole work. In Prospect Park and the smaller city parks, pruning and cleaning of plantations and the repairing of the roads and walks and buildings were done. Extensive repairs were made to the turfed areas in all the parks. The vigorous growth of the grass required constant care and attention in order to maintain it in proper condition in its relation to general park effect as well as for the various uses to which it was put by the public for rec- reative purposes. It may be desirable at this time to recount brehe the condi- tion of some of the important features of park construction to which specific reference in more or less detail has been made in former reports. Our roads, in plan of construction, were a modification of those much more expensively built upon the Central Park in New York, and, while avoiding the more costly features which characterize the preparation and foundation work of those of the Central Park, there was secured all the essential features necessary to a substantial and durable road- bed, while the superstructure over a considerable extent of our 3 18 REPORT OF THE drives in no wise differed from that of the Central Park. The surfaces of the Central Park roads and, in part, those of Prospect Park, were made of North River gravel, a superior material for roadways intended for pleasure driving, and the most desirable gravel for this purpose to be had. During the latter years of construction, however, our necessities led us to substitute for the more expensive North River gravel a much less serviceable material found within the park. This material, owing to its composition in large part of sand and clay is, for road surfacing, in every respect inferior to some other gravels of which that from the North River is one of the best types. The surfaces made of park gravel are more easily broken up by the shoes of horses, and are worn away more rapidly by the attrition of the wheels of vehicles. It is more easily affected by moisture and frost, and in summer more readily turns into dust, to which a constant application of water by sprinkling is necessary in order to maintain it in a proper condition for use. As will be inferred, the surfaces of those drives covered by this latter material have worn away more rapidly and have entailed more labor in their care than the other. In both cases, how- ever, the present unsatisfactory condition of our roads is due principally to the fact that there has been no considerable renewal of the surface material during the past fifteen years, and that this deterioration has resulted from the loss by wear, and the effect of the elements upon the original surface mate- rial, which forms the essential feature of a properly constructed drive; these surfaces have worn away in some _ instances to a depth of three to eight inches. During many years, for the want of means to supply a needed liberal renovation, the treatment has been necessarily superficial, ephemeral and un- satisfactory. To restore these roads to a condition correspond- ing to that of their original construction will require for the repairs of more or less of five miles of road, as will be inferred, the use of considerable labor and material. Our bridle roads are constructed of park gravel; horseback riding has very much increased in Brooklyn, and more labor will be needed to be expended upon the rides in order to maintain them in a BROOKLYN PARK COMMISSIONERS. 19 = suitable condition for the use of equestrians. A very considerable portion of our walk surfaces is covered with bituminous concrete, most of which was put down many years ago, at a time when much of the knowledge and experience in this new class of in- dustry was tentative and empirical. Notwithstanding this, many of these walks have proved serviceable and economical, as the work was well done and at very moderate cost. Owing to lack of experience and a want of exact information as to the combination and use of the materials of which these pavements were composed, many of these surfaces have worn away, or prematurely disintegrated. On many portions of the park their renewal at moderate expense would result advantageously, especially upon those walks where frequent variations in grade subject the surfaces to the wash of water and other effects of the elements. Upon such of the walks as are surfaced with gravel new material will be required. PLANTATIONS. A large quantity of material, in great variety, which was planted in the earlier years of the work, has outgrown the use which it was designed to serve, having been planted for nursery or protective purposes for more valuable material, and for enforcing effects to which its rapid growth and characteristic development readily conduced. This material, in the main, was composed of the coarse varieties of shrubbery purchased in large quantities at very moderate prices. It is intended to cut out much of this material, which in many places forms a now undesirabie contingent to the permanent planting and in order to suppress its unintentional domination and the intrusion of incongruous growths upon lines of site and views necessary to afford to the visitor the effects of landscape which it is in part the object of arrangements of park planting to secure. During the past season, some of this work in its primary stages has been done in order to guard against the destruction of more valuable material, and during the coming season it will claim our attention to a larger extent than it has been possible 20 REPORT OF THE to give before. Naturally, much of this material is no longer serviceable, while many other plants still good, may be trans- ferred to unfinished portions of the park. Jn the latter case, the surface to be planted will require soiling and manure. The periods favorable for this class of work are Spring and Autumn. The ordinary seasons are brief at best, and in order to accomp- lish definite and, to any degree, extended results, it is desirable to be able to concentrate a considerable force of men upon the work. It is, however, a class of work that can neither be cheaply or hastily done, and we have labored and must still labor under embarassments which our limited means and neces- sities in other directions enforce upon us. The trees planted upon the outside walks of the park, have frequently been subjected to wanton abuse by unknown parties; in some in- stances resulting in the absolute destruction of a number of choice trees. It is impossible to give these out-lying interests the supervision necessary to guard against such attacks ; in view of the limited Police force under our control I would suggest that the attention of the Police Department of the city be called to the subject by the Commission, and the co-operation of the force on duty upon the borders of the park be secured. The turf of the park, as has been noted, has required each spring a restoration in part by re-sodding ; much of this work was done in the early spring, and with the exception of areas of the park upon which the grass was permitted to mature for hay, the meadows were frequently cut and a compact turf main- tained as an element of beauty in the general design, and in order to afford every facility to the large number of our citizens, both young and old, who sought recreation in field games ‘throughout the fine weather of the yeavr. The lakes and water courses of the park have been main- tained in as satisfactory condition as possible. During the prevailing warm weather in summer the penetrating effect of the rays of the sun in the comparatively shallow water of the park lake developed the growth of a vegetable fungus hereto- fore described in my report, which, being detached by the BROOKLYN PARK COMMISSIONERS. pal agitation of the water, floats upon the surface, and being blown into the inlets and bays of the lake often present an unsightly and disagreeable feature to the eye of the visitor. Professor Silliman, after an examination of a body of water similarly affected in a reservoir in Massachusetts, reports that this fungus is common eyen to the purest water, under certain conditions of temperature and depth, and unless it is subjected to decomposition in large quantities, exerts no serious influence upon the healthfulness of a neighborhood, and is often a source of purification in the water itself. Many people visit the park at night, when the atmospheric precipitation of moisture in the vicinity of the lake tends to abnormally cool the surrounding air. Failure to adapt one’s clothing to this change of temperature in the park or else- where, as in summer resorts contiguous to water, subjects a person to influences from which ailments ambiguously attrib- uted to malarial conditions often arise. The whole park con- stitutes one of the most thoroughly drained: areas in this vicinity. Our keepers and laborers, boatmen and others, who have been employed upon and about the park waters for years, have been subjected to no special illness attributable to this cause. The water supply to the lake is derived from surface water from storms, and melting of snow over a given area sur- .rounding the lake, and an intermittent supply from the well. At rare intervals only has the level of the water in the lake reached the height originally established for the summer or maximum point, and there being no constant supply to the lake, such as would come from a living stream, there is no occasion for an overflow, the purpose of which would be simply to waste the surplus inflow above a certain level. No material quantity of impure water finds its way into the lake, and during most portions of the year it is pure enough to use for potable purposes. One considerable source of purifica- tion alone is the extensive evaporation which occurs during the warmer seasons of the year. This evaporation on warm days in summer amounts to nearly 500,000 gallons. Ap REPORT OF THE The lake contains myriads of gold fish, a large number of fresh water lake bass and perch, the latter being varieties of fish which frequent and thrive in pure water. WATER SUPPLY. Our water system has been in effective operation during the year. Repairs to the boiler and pumping machinery were made early in Spring, in order to meet with the least possible inter- ruption, the more important demands of summer upon the service. We have continued to supply water to Coney Island and along the line of the Ocean Parkway for our own use and that of hotels. A water service erected three years ago at Sheepshead Bay, by Mr. Benjamin F. Stephens, of this city, for the supply of water at Coney Island went into more effective operation this past summer, and has practically relieved the Brooklyn Park Commissioners of the responsibility of supply- ing water to Coney Island in any large quantity, except for its own purposes. It is a satisfaction to know that up to that time the great advantages which a reliable and ample supply of pure water afforded to the many thousands of people who have visited the island during the last six or eight years, was due to the foresight of the Park Commissioners. Our own re- quirements at this time are sufficient to lead us to welcome the enterprise which has relieved us of more or less further responsibility in this matter. A considerable outlay will be shortly required to be made in repairs to the well structure itself. A new boiler and some addition to the service will also be needed. The well and service has been in constant use since 1868, and has been most valuable as an adjunct to the Park maintenance. For a number of years the west woods which border upon the long meadow on the west drive has been devoted to a use little known to other parks in the country. These woods have come to be a popular resort for Sunday school picnics and other social gatherings during the Spring, Summer and Fall months. In the past year, 129 Sunday schools and church congregations availed ae BROOKLYN PARK COMMISSIONERS. 23 themselves of the privileges, and on, some days accommoda- tions at one time were provided for as many as eight parties, numbering from 100 to 1,500 children and adults. For all of these, special dates were assigned, besides several hundred formal gatherings were similarly accommodated during the “season. Throughout all the fine weather of the year it was customary, daily, thus to make’arrangements for the convenience of those who sought these special privileges. Excursions from New York City, New Jersey, and the outlying county towns by similar organizations and charitable institutions, were quite common. Fortunately our domain was large enough to enable us to grant these privileges without inconvenience, and for which cordial expressions of appreciation were returned. It is very generally understood, I think, that the policy of the Commissioners has been uniformly to extend a broad invitation to all classes of our citizens to make use of the parks in such manner as might be-most in consonance with their tastes and desires, within the necessary limits which a due regard for the proper eare of the parks would prescribe. The picnicking accommoda- tions alone, the advantages of which have been shared in by every class of the community, has tended more than any other single feature of our resources to popularize the park, while the liberal provisions which have been made for those who seek recreation in appropriate field games, such as archery, lawn tennis, croquet, &e., have been the means of developing a very extended interest in out-door recreation, the enjoyments of which can be secured with such little outlay of money on the part of the participants. The facilities for boating on the park waters are exceptional, and, besides the pleasure which has been derived by the casual visitors from this source, the lake has been a frequent resort for many ladies and gentlemen who have preterred the enjoyable exercise which rowing affords, and for the practice of which such convenient facilities are to be found on the park. 24 REPORT OF THE In the winter season the frozen surface of the lake extends an invitation which is eagerly accepted by young and old, for enjoy- ment in the exhilarating exercise which good skating affords. The lower lake is extensively used for field sports appropriate to the ice, and for ice boat sailing, curling, &e. . The park has been for years a favorite resort for students and artists, to whom special privileges are accorded in the pursuit of studies and the practice of their profession. Facilities of this nature have been sought for, and readily granted to the principal art schools and educational institutions of both cities, while a large number of special permits have been issued to students of botany, engineering, &e., &e. The several lessees have fairly responded to the requirements of the terins of their lease-hold. very building on the park has a specific public use, and this use is guaranteed to the public independent of the privileges which the lessee pays for. ‘The buildings are heated and lighted at the expense of the Commis- sioners, and are at all times open during reasonable hours for the accommodation of visitors. The facilities thus afforded therein are common to all, together with the respectful service of our employés, without cost or fee of any kind. The park carriages and other provisions for the use of visitors have been operated during the year with a view to meet the demands of the public in their several directions. The several leases, including the purveyorship of the dairy cottage, the pedestrian Concourse shelter, and the picnic wood house, the boating privilege, skating house, the carriage and pony service and the carousel, &¢., expire in the Spring, at which time it may be desirable to devise some change in their terms by which an increased revenue to the park and additional facilities to the public may be secured. ‘The floating structure known as the Rotary Yacht, for which privilege was granted several years since to Mr. D. R. Smith to place upon the waters of the upper pool, is a disfigurement to an otherwise BROOKLYN PARK COMMISSIONERS. 25 attractive feature of the landscape of the neighborhood. It is not entirely safe for children, many of whom resort to it without the knowledge of their parents. It is a primitive affair, and was placed there as an experiment, and I recommend that its future use be discontinued and that the structure be removed. A special appropriation of $10,000 was made available this year by an Act of the Legislature of 1851 for construction pur- poses. This amount has been expended in the erection of a substantial brick building to be used as a stable on the park. . It is located within the wooded area between the West Drive and Ninth avenue, on a line of Seventh street, extended. ‘This par- ticular neighborhood has been in use for many years as.a con- venient headquarters for the working force of the park, and as a storage yard for machinery and material necessary for the prose- cution of the work. The structure is built of brick, two stories in height, with slate roof, and will contain accommodations for twenty horses, together with the necessary provision for the storage of hay, &e. The site, while affording all desirable con- veniences for park purposes, is almost entirely sequestered. At the nearest point it is 300 feet from the easterly line of Ninth avenue, and will be distant at least 400 feet from any building line possible. Care has been taken to make the appliances for drainage, &e., as complete as possible, for which purpose a con- nection with the city sewer and an ample water supply will afford sutlicient security. The buildings on the Fifteenth street border of the park, at present used in part for offices, stables and keepers’ station, are unserviceable and generally unfit for further occupation by man or beast. Their early removal will obliterate an unsightly and intrusive feature of the neighborhood. An appropriation of a similar amount for construction purposes is provided for the coming year. No better use probably could be found for it than to replace the buildings now used for offices by a convenient structure elsewhere. The site would naturally be in the vicinity of the stable newly erected and near the line of Ss 26 REPORT OF THE Ninth avenue, a location most desirable in view of its convenience of access and other advantages it would afford to the public and the park. The untinished condition of the southwesterly portion of the park, extending from the Third street entrance along Ninth avenue and Fifteenth street, has frequently been made the subject ot criticism. The rapid development of portions of the Kighth and Twenty-second Wards contiguous to the park has been such as to suggest the propriety of further park improvements in this neighborhood. The suspension of the work of construction ten years ago left this area generally in an unfinished condition. Portions of its surface were hastily and cheaply brought to a temporary finish, but its walks, which are but partly outlined, remain to be constructed. The turfed areas were meagerly supplied with soil and manure and will require to be liberally treated in this respect. The opening of the entrance at the junction of Ninth avenue and I*ifteenth street, if determined upon by the Commissioners, will necessitate the grading, curbing and paving of the circle 200 feet in diameter at this point. ‘lo give to this entrance, when opened to the public, the usua! police supervision, will require the services of three keepers. In connection with the surface improvements extending along Vifteenth street to a point adjacent to the area now occupied by the oftice buildings, there is contemplated the construction of a foot bridge across the drive, between the foot entrance at Kleventh avenue and Fifteenth street and the Quaker Cemetery, to connect the system of walks from Ninth avenue with those of the lower terrace of Lookout Hill, and passing around the lake district. The planting of this whole neighborhood is generally incom- - plete, and will require extensive additions of deciduous and BROOKLYN PARK COMMISSIONERS. DAT evergreen trees in order to conform to the intended design. The expense incidental to carrying out the work above outlined would not be less than $50,000. The Litchfield mansion and grounds are occupied by Mr. E. ©. Litchfield and family on a lease, whose limitation is subject to the control of the Commission. The consideration is an annual payment of $2,500; while so occupied the Commissioners have been put to but little expense in the care of the building, and it is in a very satisfactory condition. In view of our present inability for want of means to carry on any work of improve- ment in this immediate neighborhood, no practical suggestion of use to which to apply the Litchfield mansion has occurred to the Commissioners, which would, under existing circumstances, warrant them in ignoring the advantages which are now derived from the arrangement under which the building is temporarily occupied. If, ultimately, as has been proposed, it were dedicated and opened as a museum of art, or a repository of relics and records of local or general historical importance, the interest of the public in such an enterprise could soon be tested. A consider- able expenditure of money would probably be found to be neces- sary, however, in order to adapt the building for use as a museum or art repository. The headquarters for the administration of the work over all the parks, the parkways, &c., is, for convenience, established at Prospect Park, and with the means and facilities for operating the force, and the convenient storing such of the ordinary work- ing machinery as is necessary, has enabled us to distribute the labor with greater advantage and economy. What is known as our permanent force, independent of the keepers, is a small one when considered in connection with the varied and extended field over which it is operated ; it numbers from 125 to 130 men, and consists =f a general foreman, two foremen, three carpenters, one machinist, two mechanical 28 REPORT OF THE : engineers, one painter, six gardeners and 110 laborers of all grades. ‘The largest number was employed in July, and comprised a force of 159 men. At this period the force had been temporarily increased in order to dispose of much extra work which the mid- summer seasons made necessary. ‘This temporary force was discharged on the following month, when its numbers were reduced to seventy-six men. In October, and for the remainder of the year, the working force numbered less than sixty men. The term of service of most of the men in our employ cover periods extending from five to sixteen years, and many of these were skilled in park work before they came here. Their long training has made of most of them desirable skilled workmen, whose experience and trustworthiness are a sufficient offset to the waning vigor and activity which characterized their labor in earlier years. The present organization of the Keeper Force consists of one head keeper, two assistant head keepers or sergeants and two acting sergeants, forty-one keepers, three station officers and attendants. During the months of May, June, July, August and September, the full force was employed, during the remaining months of the year, the average monthly force employed was thirty-two men. This force was distributed in night and day service upon Prospect Park, Fort Greene, City Park, Carroll Park, Tompkins Park, and for a part of the year upon the Con- course at Coney Island. While the service differs in many particulars from that of the ordinary police work of the city, the duties are no less onerous or necessary, nor are the men less serviceable and intelligent than are those employed by the city. On the other hand, the ordinary daily routine of work covers a longer period of duty than that of the city police, while the compensation of a park keeper net him annually less than seventy per cent. of that of the city police. With exception of eight appointments made within a year to fill the then existing vacancies, it will be found that the average term of service of the force will probably exceed ten years. BROOKLYN PARK COMMISSIONERS. 29 The use of the parks by the great body of visitors was marked by the observance of good order and an intelligent appreciation of the purposes for which these public pleasure grounds were designed, the occasion being rare when active intervention of police authority was necessary. The homogeneous character of our people and the frequency with which they availed themselves of the facilities for recreation which the parks afforded, rendered unnecessary the imposition of stringent rules and tended to develop an observance of comity which contributed largely to the means at our disposal for adding to their comfort and pleasure as visitors. The few occasional violations of this orderly state of things, amounting in some instances to specific infringe- ments upon the rules, may be mentioned in the order of their importance. The first, are the violations of the ordinance as to fast driving; these are not frequent, but they occur at a time of day when the roads are in greatest use and when acci- dents are mostly to be apprehended, and the persistence with which a tew reckless and thoughtless persons abuse the privileges of the road and endanger the pleasure and safety of the greater number who observe the rules in this particular, render it often- times desirable to resort to summary means of restraint. The disposition to disregard the cautions of the keeper on foot, due largely to the immunity which a fast horse affords to the driver, suggests the desirability of the equipment for occasional use on the roads, of one or two mounted keepers in order to check a practice so dangerous to others. It is the habit of many women and young people to drive alone in the park, a means of recreation much to be commended, and for which the park affords many advantages. On the parkway, the principal road is sufficiently commodious to permit of more freedom in the movement of horses and vehicles, and it has been the policy of the Commission to relax, within reasonable bounds, the restrictions upon fast driving. The driving, however, as is well known, is considerable, and accidents from one cause or another frequently occur. The use 30 REPORT OF THE of a mounted keeper on certain days of the week would prove very serviceable; [ think, also, he could be made available in regulating the extensive business traffic on the Ocean Parkway, and heavy vehicles employed in the conveyance of farm produce, lumber, manure, building material, &c., could be with propriety restricted to the traffic road on either side, which roads were constructed for the purpose. This restriction might be limited to the afternoon, from one o'clock P. M., and it would operate greatly to the comfort of those who use the road for pleasure driving, for which the Central roadway was principally designed. Another abuse of privilege less noticeable, but perhaps no less important, is the occasional destruction of plants and shrubs upon the park. The purloining of plants and the disfigure- ment of shrubs is frequent enough to entail otherwise unneces- sary responsibility upon keepers. Oftentimes rare and valuable plants are heedlessly broken and destroyed in the desire to possess a blossom or ccllection of leaves. The park is a resort for many varieties of our native song birds in their season. The number of persons, mostly boys, who are heedless enough to disturb these, are not many, but make it necessary, nevertheless, for the exercise of vigilance during the Summer and Fall to prevent injury to the birds and destruction of their nests. Other persons with morbid or very much misplaced tender sensibilities, make use of the park to dispose of surplus cats, and cats for whom a waning affection suggests this mode of compro- mise as to their disposition, subjecting, as a consequence, our birds, rabbits, squirrels, &c., to the danger resulting from the awakened instinctive predatory habit of the cat. During the year many cats are killed in the park. During the past season a fox was let loose in the park and destroyed several valuable water fowl before he was killed. On the smaller parks intoxicated and otherwise disorderly persons often seck the convenience which the semi-retirement BROOKLYN PARK COMMISSIONERS. bl of public places seems to afford them for reflection and recovery from the effects of their bad habits. Arrests of this nature are frequent, and interfere unnecessarily with the legitimate duties of the keeper. It would seem that persons in this condition should not be permitted to reach the parks through the city streets with- out having attracted the attention and care of the city police, nor are these cases always satisfactorily disposed of by the city Justices. In some instances the same individual has been arrested four or five times in as many months; their frequent reappear- ances being due to too short terms of confinement. Generally, however, the relations of the keeper to the public involve little or no conflict. The absence of disorder and the readiness manifested on the part of the public to confurm to the rules enable him to render a varied and appreciated service in assigning grounds for picnics and arranging tor the use cf swings, tables, seats and water, and for the use of fields for croquet, tennis, &e. The extent and variety of these uses render the park keeper a desirable intermediary. Many special services to the public on the park, indicate the value of experience and training which the keeper acquires. The duties connected with the annual Sunday school parade is an instance of this kind. The last children’s parade occurred May 25, 1882. Seating accommodation was specially provided for 13,000 children, together with the platform, the reviewing stand, &c., for officers, visitors, invited guests, &c. The meadow, together with portions of the woods specially assigned for picnic making purposes, after the ceremony, were enclosed with ropes and stakes, ornamented with flags and bunting. Special privileges were accorded to visitors in carriages and on foot everywhere, and it is estimated that no less than 30,000 persons visited the park. No trouble or accident occurred. The expenses thus incurred amounted to several hundred dollars. Our concert season commenced with Saturday, June 17, and ended September 30, 1882. The total cost’was $2,560. The music was furnished by the Twenty-third Regiment Band, 32 REPORT OF THE under the direction of Mr. Felix I. Eben, leader. The musie in all its details was entirely satisfactory, and the concerts themselves attracted as large gatherings as upon any previous year. SMALL PARKS. The work upon the small parks of the city comprises the re- pairing and cleaning of walks and approaches, shelters and buildings, pruning shrubbery, cleaning plantations, cutting of the grass and cleaning of snow from the interior and boundary walks. These sidewalks, while under the control of the Park Commissioners, are nevertheless entirely devoted to the public use, and their care, in addition to the duty imposed upon us of cleaning snow from the plaza and approaches of the City Hall, form no inconsiderable yearly expenditure for work entirely foreign to legitimate maintenance work of the parks, and for which the limited appropriations at our disposal are hardly applicable. As a matter of justice, the sum of $2,500 should be provided additionally for this purpose. Having necessary machinery, this work can be efficiently done by us, but for want of means it has always been done at the sacrifice of more legitimate interests, and has frequently interfered, as it did last winter, with the operations necessary to put the lake in condition for skating, During the past season a work of some importance which had long been delayed was accomplished at Fort Greene. The plantations which were crowded, overgrown and disfigured, were, by extensive pruning and thinning out, very much improved in appearance, and a promising development of substantial material secured for the future. This work will be completed in the Spring, and will add very much to the appearance of the park and the comfort and convenience .of visitors. This park is a popular resort in the summer season, and the number of vis- itors entails the necessity of a larger keeper force than it has been heretofore convenient to provide. A temporary increase in the keeper force in the Summer months resulted in increasing good order. The large use to BROOKLYN PARK COMMISSIONERS. 390 which these neighborhood parks are put during the fine weather of the year, and the attention in the way of cleaning, &¢e., that they require, makes it evident that a larger sum of money should be specifically provided to be expended upon _ them than has been available since their construction. A considerable area of walk surface needs renewal, the boundary line between the hospital, jail and park should be permanently established, and the adjoining surfaces, which have been disfigured during the construction of the jail and the re- moval of the morgue, should be put in order. In view of the permanent establishment of the jail and morgue contiguous to the north-westerly boundary of the park, I would suggest the consideration on the part of the Commissioners, of the propriety of closing up the present Canton street entrance of the park. For this purpose, including the remodelling of the plan in that immediate neighborhood, and the resurfacing of walks especially needing repair, soiling and sodding the slopes of the Battery face, together with needed protection of the stone work to the foundation of the Martyrs’ Monument, there would be required about $7,500. The small building, which was paid for by special appropriation in 1881, was opened in the Spring, and afforded accommodations for the use of visitors which had loug been needed. Carroll and Tompkins Parks have been maintained in a satis- factory condition throughout the season, and have been under the constant supervision of a small detail of the keeper force. Tompkins Park is favorably located and adapted to the wants of the thrifty and growing population of its neighborhood. It is a favorite resort for children, and the turfed areas are freely used for croquet and other appropriate field games. City Park is practically a thoroughfare ; the best use of it being made by the pupils of a contiguous public school, who resort to it as a play ground during the periods of school recess. The improvement and growing use of Fort Greene demon- strates the fact that City Park could, without at all curtailing the means of recreation for residents of this vicinity, be appro- 5 34 REPORT OF THE priated, as has been suggested by this Commission, to some more practical and desirable public use. The storm of September, which was the occasion of much damage on Prospect Park, broke the large sewer which passes diagonally through City Park, carrying away a portion of the surface within the park and the railing. This work was partially repaired by the Board of City Works, but will require further work on their part and some additional expenditure on ours to restore the railing, surface filling and turf, in the Spring. A small gore at the junction of Throop avenue and Gwinett street was some years since improved by the Commissioners under a special appropriation made by the Common Council. The area was enclosed by a substantial iron fence and the side- walks repaired. The area was insignificant in view of the ex- penditure, but no provision was made for its further mainten- ance. ‘The Commission has repaired to some extent the damage done by lawless persons, whose interference with the work should have been prevented by the City Police in that neigh- borhood. The Commission have also incurred some expendi- tures upon the triangular enclosure at the junction of Cumber- land street and Fulton and Greene avenues, for which no provision had been made. OCEAN PARKWAY. The work of the season upon the Ocean Parkway corresponds to that of previous years. In the early Spring months, a number of trees that had died were replaced by new stock, and a supply of manure was applied to them, together with others whose weakly condition suggested the necessity. Owing to the character of the material in which the trees are planted, particu- larly in the lower section, the soil spaces originally provided have not been sufficient to afford the amount of nourishment to the trees necessary to their vigorous and satisfactory develop- ment. It was intended that the application of fertilizing material should be renewed in the Spring. For like reasons, the planting at the Concourse has not been satisfactory, but no OT Ee BROOKLYN PARK COMMISSIONERS. ae experiments can be successfully tried under conditions to which vegitation is subjected at the island, without more sufficient means than has been available for this purpose. The frequent saturation by the salt water of the underlying sand, without some special provision for protecting roots of the trees, will prevent successful and uniform growth of shade trees at the island. Our experience, however, has not been without its counterpart in France and England, where experiments in sea coast plant- ing have not resulted very satisfactorily. It is evident that the roots of the trees must, as a primary condition, be protected against the effect of salt water, and that only certain kinds of trees will grow under the most favorable circumstances, in view of the artificial conditional surroundings. Probably, finally it may be found necessary to introduce supplementary plantations of coarser and more rapidly growing material as wind breaks and nurseries in order to secure to the plants intended for perma- nent development a growth beyond the age at which the sea alr, winds and blowing sands seem to be so injurious to them. ° The ordinary work of repairing and cleaning the roadways has been continuous throughout the year, a force of workmen, skilled in the management of roads, being specially assigned to this duty. Like the park roads, the superstructure has been worn away, and a surface material ground so finely by the action of the wheels and the feet of horses, as to make it diffi- cult to keep the road in form for any length of time. In dry weather the surface is very dusty and entails a large expendi- ture for sprinkling, while the mud which results from the slightest application of water is no less objectionable and anoying to riders. The gravel of which the road-bed is com- posed is intermixed with light friable clay and fine sand, is difficult to bind and readily wears out. This important thoroughfare, which has not been resurfaced since its construc- tion seven years ago, requires, in order to restore it to good condition, an application of several inches of material. To 36 REPORT OF THE properly repair it would cost about $10,000; this would be a moderate outlay for the accomplishment of so desirable a result. The Concourse, which is one of the most desirable portions of the Coney Island beach, absolutely free to the public, con- tains a single but useful improvement in the bituminous con- crete embankment which constitutes the promenade drive and walk within the area. This is the most extensively used thoroughfare on the island, and affords convenient access to the improved portions of the island. The roadway since its construction in 1876 has been subjected throughout the Summer and Fall months to constant use by all sorts of vehicles; this surface, for want of means, has never received any but the most superficial repairs during all this time ; $5,000, the sum avail- able for that purpose during 1883, will be barely sufficient to maintain the roadway in a usable condition for the season, and unless it is intended to abandon its use, its repair by a renewal of the surface with the present material, or some other form of construction, will require an expenditure of $25,000 or $30,000 as previously estimated. This improvement was built and is maintained practically at the eexpense of the citizens of Brooklyn, while the town of Gravesend, which derives much of its importance and a large share of profit from this and other improvements projected by the Park Commissioners, have, by means of special laws, been able up to the present time to collect licenses, from the revenue of which, the Commissioners derive no benefit, and which the town itself would not be able to control were it not for the Concourse, the construction and maintenance of which affords such facilities to the business enterprises and pleasure traffic of the island. Our shelters are resorts for picnic parties and other visitors throughout the season, the beach, upon the proper use of which no restriction exists, being the principal attraction. Pure water, which is carried to the island from our well at the park, is a most valuable adjunct to the enjoyment and refreshment of thousands of people who avail themselves of the privileges thus afforded at public expense. BROOKLYN PARK GOMMISSIONERS. 37 To the large number of dwellers in the city, whose means of recreation limit them to a few visits to the island, the erection of a platform furnished with seats and tables and with an awn- ing for protection against the sun would be a desirable ad- ditional accommodation upon our property. To this might be attached, under suitable regulations, a temporary structure for the purveying of cheap and wholesome food and fruit. The present danger is that the greatest usefulness to be derived from an ocean resort of this character will be lost sight of, and many of the advantages which the masses might have derived from it be practically destroyed. EASTERN PARKWAY. The construction of the Eastern Parkway differs materially from that of the Ocean Parkway. In place of ordinary gravel, the body of the superstructure is of broken stone, surfaced with stone dust and North River gravel. This surface has worn away to considerable extent, and the wear has already encroaclied upon the foundation of broken stone. Our appropriations for this work have at no time been more than sufficient to maintain it from year to year by very super- ficial treatment, but the time has come when material repairs should be made to this important roadway in order to preserve it from more serious damage. A supply of broken stone and good gravel will be needed for this purpose. The portion of the Parkway from the Plaza to Bedford avenue being more considerably used, has been kept in fair condition by repair and sprinkling during the year, more particularly to accommodate the very large number of our citizens from the East, who reach the park from Bedford avenue, by way of this portion of the Parkway. Upon the remain- ing section, all necessary work has been done from time to time. The system of temporary drainage at the terminus and junction with the city line, was quite recently almost entirely renewed at considerable expense, and a number of trees were planted to replace those which had died, or had been destroyed by malicious persons. oc 38 REPORT OF THE Property on the line has been frequently wantonly destroyed, such as trees, tree boxes, &c., and cattle, goats and swine are permitted to run at large without apparent effort to restrain them. The co-operation of the city police and the enforcement of the city ordinances would abate much of the nuisance and annoyance attributable to these sources. PARADE GROUND. The parade ground has on a number of occasions been appropriated during the year to the uses of the military. In the intervals and throughout the Spring, Summer and Fall mouths, its peculiar adaptation for field sports has made it one of the most popular resorts in the country. The regulations have been such as to encourage its use for the purpose of healthful and appropriate recreations, every facility being afforded within our means to that end. - More than one effort has been made to secure an appropria- tion with which to erect a building to be used by the various organizations of our younger citizens for dressing rooms, «&c.; a sum not exceeding $4,000 would be sufficient. The policy of appropriating public money for such use has been a subject of debate, but inasmuch as it would tend to develop and encourage a love for out-door recreation in its most unobjec- tionable form among eur own youth, it would seem to be entirely consistent to make some such provision for their accom- modation. The expense of maintenance of these grounds is consider- able, the turf is required to be kept in order throughout the season, and police supervision, &c.,is also necessary. ‘The buildings and fences are at present in need of repairs, for which the appropriation for 1883 will not be adequate. BEDFORD AVENUE. Out of the appropriations available under the law for the repairs and cleaning of Bedford avenue, there was expended in BROOKLYN PARK COMMISSIONERS. 39 July, 1882, the sum of three thousand five hundred and sixteen dollars and seventy cents, under contract with the Abhott Pavement Company of this city, for resurfacing portions of the bituminous concrete superstructure, which forms the principal part of its roadway. This work, to the extent of twenty-seven thousand five hundred and twenty-two (27,522) square feet was principally done between Rodney street and Myrtle avenue. The repairs were substantially made and this particular work, at the close of the year, was in a satisfactory condition. Had there been additional means at our disposal to the extent of $6,000 or $8,000, it would have been possible to put the whole roadway generally, in a temporarily satisfactory condition, but there were no resources known to the Commission or the law by which such an amount of work could be done. In the meantime, the deteriorated pavement has by wear and disin- tegration broken up at many points, and for want of sufficient protection and renewal, has reached a very unsatisfactory state, while at some points, its condition as a public thorough- fare, is discreditable to the city. In view of these facts and of the comparative insignificance of the work done in relation to the extended needs of the avenue, the Commission realized at the outset that it would not be possible to remedy, for the remainder of the year, the serious discomfort to which the public in the use of the roadway must subject themselves. No method of repair measurably corresponding to the require- ments of the work to be done could possibly be devised within the limit of $5,000 which the law has provided. The cleaning of an avenue of this leneth and importance in a proper manner throughout the year would cost that amount of money alone. If the present form of superstructure is to be continued, the work should be done with the best material, and the contractor should be required to maintain the surfaces in good order for a specific term of years; the repairs to be done with proper machinery at any season of the year, if required. Since the transfer of the care of Bedford avenue to the Commis- sioners, the appropriations have been at no time adequate to do the work required to be done, nor has the allowance for 40 REPORT OF THE cleaning been sufficient. The criticisms to which they and other officers of this city have been subjected, have been with- out careful consideration, and are unjust. As a thoroughfare for business, traffic and pleasure riding, it is one of three of the most importance in the city, and by reason of the character and value of the property along its whole line, and its relation, geographically, to a large section of the city, there is every justification for the most liberal provision for its improvement and maintenance. The avenue is in every essential feature a part of the street system of the city, for the care of which certain department machinery was especially devised by law, and under the cireum- stances its early transfer to the Department of City Works by such process of law as may be necessary, would be eminently proper. Respectfully submitted, JNO. Y. CULYER, Chief Engineer and Superintendent. EE ee Tabular Statement of the Brooklyn Park Commissioners’ Accounts, from January 1, 1865, to June 17, 1882. 140a. — - = _ =. SS eee | t | ReEcEIPTS. | Deposits, ) Curcrs Drawn. Crrcks Pain. From January, 1865 to January, 1866....... Oe Aer aS AGE $33,285 62 $25,700 00 $17,565 93 “4 “ WHO BOY US BOG. cus vice < dew ee aces 310,222 81 307,191 78 192,367 52 $207 835 53 £s es UOMUBD WAG UBOOS ce cscs sees ve eek 1,185,955 48 1,186,240 54 982,800 72 982,033 79 “ o Breit 7a) ) ee 941,265 62 941,266 29 | 1,180,186 83 1,171,791 61 as December 14, 1869... .......,. : 835,365 12 835,365 12 | 908,744 88 919,027 35 “s “ Weeember We UenO s. cece cass. 627,298 51 627,373 51 483,577 28 483,634 22 “ “6 oamuary 121872). ..... :.< .. wae $26,522 61 821,900 23 | 980,627 36 975,932 39 os as MUTOH is MLD Meta cele’. ste 2 save vce ere-are $59,459 61 860,560 21 858,729 17 $57,892 00 3 2 December 11, CFG, byl i ee 561,754 33 566,270 23 550,802 00 547,031 84 “6 ns Mareh 1, 1875... oor Eothereec 459,599 10 458,080 23 473,201 61 | 477,326 OL “ at December 28, 1875........... ns 418,132 96 417,895 12 } 420,785 74 423,744 70 “ “ Janmery lS) US... :--s. 2s ose. es 526,573 52 525,552 41 | 525,955 57 525,048 58 “3 NOVeEMber Oy Leits. oficcce sees 2 177,286 11 171,980 11 | | 163,020 80 166,609 60 an Sd hee he Hae 2 SOTA ER EET 114,463 97 114,786 77 113,435 05 . 113,376 32 “ ie MBPUCIUDONMO SO eri. crc. see vere 47,351 77 391 6 f From Comptroller, for pay-rolls (not entered on cash book). 69,508 78 t AAG, 1S BS | | Bry OB BD 117,313 17 MO MISGEENDETIN, THB... ....tanninisinicat Maree bein len te.e aes, «. 10 379 98 From Comptroller, for pay-rolls (not entered on cash book), 110,304 89 123,912 41 130,662 21 129,174 71 “County Treasurer (not entered on cash book)........ 6,000 00 1 To November 28, 1881 ...._.. MAPOe ds AC nDe Bevo rie (aste 7,182 96 | From Comptroller, for pay-rolls (not entered on cash book). 91,927 69 | , 7 $ ‘ “ County Treasurer (not entered on cash book)........ 4,000 00 t 131,759 77 eae 97,157 18 © Bastiside lands; Gaal book. 0.0.05 cscs s ccc seccseees 32.295 00 J To June 17, Lae seen Vonewier tate te i ercrosd shes Bbaa sete 5,285 67] From Comptroller, for pay-rolls (not entered on cash book), 56,200 50 } te x LEO OF ‘““ County Treasnrer (not entered on cash book)........ 4,595 05 r 182,200 70 pana s 186,658: 86 6 Want SiGe AaNds; CAs BOOK. 6c. a creche sone nseven 116,581 90 | —_ —- — ———-—— —_—- —_—— ——_ ——__—_Enrvor in check 349.......... .$0 10} $8,386,024 85 $8,383,587 90 $8,438,799 56 $8,413,184 42 |Difference not found.......... 50 60 | Outstanding checks ............... 2,437 55 $8,386,025 45 LN Deposits over receipts that (in 1868 ............. $0 67 Petty cash) in 1865 .. ... . $6,923 59 Petty cash ) in 1865,.... .. $6,923 59 _ $8,386,025 45 _ were not entered in the - in 1870.............. 75 00 not ‘de-;in 1866......... 3,333 28 pay- (ae 1866... .. 3,333 28 SS cash book, WINLB TEN, «score san 1,100 60 posited. ) in 1867......... 74 42 ments. } in 1867... ... 74 42 —--- 1,176 27 —__— 10,331 29 sass 10,331 29 Discount on note, in 1874.......... Ay 1,625 35 |Discount on note in 1874....... .... 1,625 35 Draft from Comptroller in 1877, not de- ORION’... Scans a cmon etter reure 4,230 35 |Draft from Comptroller in 1877..... 4,230 35 $8,429,371 41 MDB GLOOM, |: 5) <,. v aaieiera leper aisha crate eee 10,604 42 | $8,439,975 83 $8,439,975 83 $8,402,212 44 UO Or: Wistaliammonntoretecalpten. siis weak. ccse oy vo csc cceceeecccecs $8,439,975 83 | Mavelbemo yn b/Of OCB ES cynic) csi~c)- a> micas? tale aim aeteleelel eats arse orm yells ele atten seals .| $8,489,975 83 Checks drawn and petty cash paid.......................... ..| 8,402,212 44 | Motaliamonntiof cheeks: patd)....... 5... pole cedscene ct cence $8,383,587 90 | LOS ENDO TIS ae ite Srct c 7 Aes er ee ——— $37,763 39 | Roteltemount.of petty cashpaidi« 0.25 ...00n0s eoe-eacmidiie anh 10,331 29 | Discount on note of 1874, paid Maida.” MGR Rye teoale tera etayiake cis 1,625 35 | Dratt from Oomptroller'in WSi7, Paid!......... 0 aajenee ane cee e ee 4,230 35 | Oe 8,399,774 89 Siginlemiount of apasitsye... <5 5.6... ees cccceesssccscceccrccs $8,413,184 44% i} 2 er Total amount of checks drawn................-0000000000 ll, 8,386,025 45 i| $40,200 94 er 7,158 97 | Balance on deposit in National City Bank June 17, 1882.........| ...-.-..eeeeeee 29,596 52 Deficiency......... I ae en ere ee | Deficiency... er 8. es en ee toate + $10,604 42 } 41 PARK COMMISSIONERS. BROOKLYN 00 000‘s$ 00 000‘E$ Lg LEP's MES E CoGaner mute tote eta pacnienee SelGee ee tatiame oo greiner aarel OCU [eAEO —pivog yueseid jo soanytpuedxy SOE COG UT Gh os es ee OL Pze Ing COoDUGO TONDO ION OOS ay GkSh Ay re Sea's eee esr eee 2 DOLLS OOVOVOO SOO Hf OYE | —pivog 1oewt1oF Jo sornyipuodxy 00 000‘S% ‘[lounoy TomMmoD ogy Aq poyeradorddy / loppny fy 07, paryyap “AVAMUVdA NUALSVA HO HONVNELNIVIN FP SP S0I$ PP C8F‘R01$ Sots. = 09 €I1 SRistean aCe e eee +++ gouemsut 00 09'S Oar O 1 0-0 CLO O8O-G. D 2 Osavervs ° “OIsnut ce BIE ste eee cece alee enc i 6F Z1L0‘¢ OOO Ty ONY OO Ss a dat enaeteaerea OUT C ns FP Z8h‘8g 4 ——-—— ; Scie 5 ge ezg'gG citttttttts + prvog OT 1Sé 9&$ LOGV] 10,7 quosead oq} dopun poatoooy —pavog jyuoserd jo serngipusdx| 80 6C8'ZS CSO Eg SOG De PO GE ON XOKS | 06 CCl 'F98 -— IOUIOJ ot} Lapun poatsooy 98 L¥0'T Sapa reet pe SCI LCR DO OOD eh5) A —: inseary, {319 ofr ie cen Sete Roan Monon ee 10g yied puv onuoes f 7 Bie |e ea as bead —pivog tomroj jo gornjipuedxa 00 000‘00TS ‘[Loun0D TomuMOD 073 Aq poqeitdorddy /woppnpy hg op payysag ‘SMUVd AO AONVNALNIVIN ‘ “ALIO "ESS max oy7 wof quawaynjig jorounury REPORT OF THE 00 000‘s$ 00 00)‘¢$ 00 002 SLs 00 009 ‘cI$ ‘TOunoD wom TOD a3 Lq payiadorddy (00 000‘e$ 98 0S0'F PL 6F6S £0 cole Ge) 8) 8:8 0 8/6 O.6e 4.0 pT i Sao il: -W0d S.pxlojaryig ‘q “f ‘saruder 8 cRgg bas ne dangle negisis "ee sie RCT EO —pivog zitaserd jo sornqipuedxg GZ 60F "**"99BIJM0D TO GATeSaL ‘*4med tad QT ‘aurpjoyy “gy ‘samdor 0G F . SUN rachel sean isdohatsisheesitires sym CLO Ge Gees Detter eeeeeee renee eee TOqRT OMT —pirvog louttog Jo sarngipuedxgy :dopony fing 07 parlnvap “ONINVATO GNV SHYIVUHU—-AONTAVY GHOACEEA *‘[OUNOD touMODH oy} Aq poyeradorddy CF GFO 9 00 003 GIS GL 869 GL SPSS ee ae pale e6! Om oi6 x eLeru aia ‘**sartddus SSE NIOIO OS ETON EIRORS Cav (ey fe CO} | OeOnncecr cry ty —pivog qyueserd jo sormnztpuedxy 69 ISP ‘sesso atd TAABIS “GMoUTSsessE Ne) FT9'T e,al= (0.9 > (p exe) seks) wear ee . **+sattddus Preteens eeen sees eee eeeee 0QRT LOT —pivog tewtoy Jo sacngytpusd xg : wonpny fing 0} payimap 66 186 FS “AVMMUVd NVHOO JO FZONVNGLNIVIN ‘ponUulyuoH— 'ZRgT “vax ay? Hof puowmayojy porwunuriy 45 PARK COMMISSIONERS. BROOKLYN f 00 008‘1% “"T9Insvary, JUNO WoT; Poeatoo -OI puv AJUNOD SSsalyp Jo SxOSTAto “Ang jo prvog oy9 Aq *poguttdorldy 00 009‘TS c6 OLP 80 680‘TS Diese eee er sees tour tog —pivog jyueserd Aq pied ysvg 606 6L1$ 0S 8g eeeee erste ae PODOGO SO GOO KeaKeClet Dette esse reese bese eeeessToqur IO —p.avog totmroj {q pied ysxp ‘GNVISI APNOO—ASUNOONOD JO TONVNELNIVI “ALNIOO “-ornguistsery omy Aq poyeradorddy | 00 000°0T$ = ‘paivog yuoserg AGOwO OD Heesseeeesssgorr soup ‘gourt00°10,q swoppny fing of payfiptag “HTAVLIS” NOLLONULSNOD 00 00¢‘I¢ 00 00001S 00 000‘0T$ a 00 000‘0T$ 0S 6L9‘TS 0S 6L9'TS Se Oi UOTy souvpeq pepuedxeuy) 0¢ 6L9‘°TS 00 8g9‘T$ 06 TZ Ht eseneess sz0qur IO —pirog jueseid jo sornytpucdxa 00 RG9T% ‘Jovr}M00 8 yooD y stutg ‘roqpors IO,T —parog 1ouULtog Jo sornqipuedxm sdoppny hing 07 parfijrag ‘oY “GALIAHS- MUVd NOLONTIHSVM "PONUIWOQ—ZET vaK ay7 of uawanjig jmrounury REPORT OF THE 00 00¢‘TS , 00 00¢‘TS G9 LG¢'T GE SFIS 00 00OG'IS ‘'*‘deansvoery, AyUNOD WoIZ poAtoo -e1 puv Ayuno0g ssury jo SsIoOstA -1edug jo pavog oy} Aq poqeradoiddy ‘aNN0U9D AdVUVd ———— Ue a a ’ Cn ac oar y Cecchi F Sel enese.0) 6.0.0 0x0 BL erheacet ce eee TOG LON —pavog quesead &q pred ysep OL ge aialele) sie) els aLe CHO Cat: *****sartddus GZ 98$ . suede ieneigis)né ttveme gis leusisiass 25. TORT LO Tp —paeog aoor10f Lq pred ysep ‘poepnpouogn—'Zegy “wax ay)? lof quawmamjig powounury 45 PARK COMMISSIONERS. BROOKLYN ¥6 199‘GFIS 00 000°E$ 09 000‘0T 09 6L9°T 00 000'¢ 00 009 °2T 00 000°¢ FP 8h SOT$ 00 00¢‘T pe A A punory opriwg 00 00¢'T$ serees“9SINOOMOD JO sdDURMOZULLI “hyunog Sa0G0 0 SECC ERIOEE oye th ati (ol9) rrseesesr sess TOOT COUUILG ‘YAVq WOJSULTSVA\ DOG G00 erocesharer NG reese OntaAW plozpog see oe ee eoeee + eae eee re ee TOO DOOU NoTate al mv200 es CeO Ce veceecess KBMHIVT ULOISeT TP G8P'8 DOO. GND O07 200-2 quudsvAe) | PIV 00 000;00TS 77° 7" Cae E 7 “SIV jo JOUVUIJTIVYT “fing “SNOILVINdOUdd Vy 00 00¢'T 00 008'T 00 000‘0T 0¢ 6L9'T 00 000'S 00 00¢°6 00 000°¢ FP C8P SOS ‘“NOILVTNLIA VOU #6 199 ‘PIS G9 LSE‘T = "ss" sss-nIeog yueserd oy Aq GE GFIS "roseeesess neo” reus1o; ou Ag —puno1y opeivg 66 OLP "****nrieog yuoeseid ayy Ag 80 680°TR “~ '°8* paeog aeurs0j og} Ag —dSINOIUOH JO soOULUOJUIV]Y ‘fyunoy Heaps meflciameteretessiae “prog juaserd on] Sq —TOl}ONASTOH (OLE pea Gitar ck nae “h"*" nrvog queserd on} Aq 00 8G9'T# 9 pavog tetuz107 egy Ag —YAlvg{ WOJSuIYSv Ay 98 YCo'F sreeeeeess nieog yuoseid ey Ag FL 6F6S Ses aoe ac CC OST IO ULLOF eho) kg —onueay piloypog Gir ir @) — Pee ee gos ‘* “nrvog yuesord oy Ag Gg LG7P‘98 PREECE OY TONS | IOWLLOF eyeg kg —ABMyIvg wvs009 L& LES ee Ray parvsog yueserd 043 Aq e9 29S‘ TS eee er er eee es paivog IOULIOF eq} kg —AVAY AVG UI SVT ¥G 998FP “°° ''*** prvog quesead oyy Ag 06 GEL POS ‘°C t tS pawog reurtoz oy Ag —syivg jo souvuojuivpy m1) SHUN LIGNAIX REPORT OF THE Revenue derived from the Public Parks of the City of Brooklyn. Balance brought forward from December 31, 1881 Beats Carnes licenses Carousel, royalty on Old material sold... er ery Rotary.yacht, royalty on cet see eee eet twee Sioi[nlie ws odin wi © pie eye e)e x18) s} sla e)) a\ul« eMal'e/ =. oe a ,ei/p- 0 tele taly ia Telals oe ewe. 60 @ 00m) a oe) 0. e0).= bias \r ales) e,% | », 000s ere pial i ec es Imipoumded\ cattle Weert) acu sate lste este ae eB Eanes Glass broken Paid into the City Treasury. . Balance to January 1, 1883 JaNuary 1, 1883. 8,402 40 8,975 1 8,482 44 493 3 $8,975 81 BROOKLYN PARK COMMISSIONERS. AT SraTEMENT of Accounts certified to Auditor during the year 1882. DATE. Name. Jan . “Feb. Lo (Se) a POoOIWIIVAIP Re wwwrpwp rp .|John Y. Culyer eee 2\.|Kdward R. Shipman ........... .|Francis Walker : J lel. “Beal Hosford & Songs. .|Prospect Park & “Coney Island pram sp Ontatlone ema ae _|Salamander Grate Bar Company. Guabemarsi 4 cesta ‘Botanic Garden.... jl. Brandeis & Son '|Wm. Porter’s Sons i) IC. W. Keenan - |Prederick Loeser & Co.. _|Brooklyn Gaslight Company... Bieter wmarrell aos ee aml esis cee 8 ; EEN roll MPI SY cre Gabe, Sua Send ays Bes .|Botanic Garden .|Beers & Resseguie | For Railroad Company. ce ce _|Metropolitan Gaslight Company, f Brooldyn Gaslight Pas ee6 ce John Y. Culyer.... Smith & Gates ce se ee we we ee toe aoe 2) eel sie} la) si iall=) (eis luis lee fel ie nico Ofo, Foo Oooo oe ood Heusyet ON gee Miata Balen netics spetne Henry Werner se eee ee ee ee ee ee we - |Lumber Laborers, &e oe ee Feed Photographing Supplies ..... Wagon supplhes Stationery ee Lead pipe, &e Valve, &e re wicks Lamp chimneys Gas... ce Contracts =o: Employés and clerks Laborers ce Hardware {ron pipe, &e .|Incidental expenses.... OSCR Aca oe enies aeons Plants Lumber. Lumber ere eres PoIoo oO Seon ooo c.g 6 tro sees ecco ee eee eee mpmfiely oil aoi[-Nialcalel tats hwii~ tele, Z| LAveyoRMnRTONsZ, CHO, poke ooceoe Supplies and repairs... SWIOWUIGS ccccagnoevoac : eee eee - wees Cb ar obooDoaomaaogs bidiou Oban clo Goto cold Employés and clerks... esr ecoes AMOUNT. 48 REPORT OF THE Statement of Accounts certified to Auditor, 1882—Continued. Dare. _ NAME. For AMOUNT. Feb. 23./Edward R. Shipmantyssasacesat- Oats. «s o05/-)- + (se ereeenaee $140 00 Oe Et ade Were e. SCOR CODY Glovated a acne 66 as eee ne an 227 20 2a Ao Wi. Shadbolt CODE. a Ree Repairing, de. 22 ease 55 00 235 |\Wie. Dayton a SON ey eis. oe Hardware, &ceoin eee 164 45 23 .|Edward R. Shipman............ Oats: .&¢:.5 #2sen eee 173 20 Qos iWe El. Murtha a sODmaes seen. Coal 22% 07 cee eee 89 25 23 f6S) > opie athe swan 6 vs ate s\n ake Re 250 08 23./Sims & Cook....... Pye hacer ies Contract: :.. i aesske eee 655 85 March 1: |Prancis) Waller j2c-es2 Noss Coal....\..:5 503 eee 165 00 ie Pay 27 (0) Ul Dae eee tk dnp Se . . (Laborers; &@2)eeeeeeee 5,290 34 ES et CP er auc orcs con oc amen PE i Vn 142 31 Wt Cs Page eg So eS Se irae rth A [eee 368 91 2.|Metropolitan Gaslight Company.|Gas .................... 48 30 Du G:- Coming au ttre es ate Hardware. =}... .ceesennns 42 20 2.|/Henry R. Worthington aS ocho Machinery supplies .... 11 01 ONE Om Comin ae a deaaucieystenie bese: Hardware... 22 ses Sater 211 87 Qe Win. “Porters SONS) jets ss) - Lamp supplies.......... 140 35 2. 6 eeiaean agen!) ) 0 i i ne 1 25 2. Lae CaO Rt nc fC 1 ape Sane: 25 50 bd | PAK OAM OCovi Te Memes cea co nile ace Hardware....... he ese ‘ 84 67 2.|Brooklyn Gaslight Company..../Gas............ ek: Se ae ats 2. Up vies [ie* “saps i eee 27 24 2.|Metropolitan Gaslight Company.| ‘‘- .............s0es06 ’ 47 60 BIOOW. Keenatin «ace ce cere tn Supplies ..... 4c css een Gao uaes Bulogtord: &: Sons <..<2scieehees oe Stationery: . < i...a2 semen 62 25 2) Pranks). eCole see acca sca sere Keepers’ supplies. ..... 5 25 2.|John M. Bulwinkle............. Stationery. 2 ts. eee 12 29 7 |John Morton &Sons..........:-. Brick, cement, &e.....- 36 75 Sa|Johni Yo Culyerncrr poeesenie cei: Incidental expenses ..... 48 87° 16, \Hostord)é Song 1-0). 40.25 2. Stationery 2.«.2 .mueeeeee 13 90 16 BL a ee ea eee: “« 4 eo 52 40 DO Sergntonie Core ecru e. Soap:......... nce eee 13 00 20.|/Whitlock, Slover & Co.. ....... Rope... ..:..2.-)-eeeee 5 25 20. CE a Gin eRee ok. Canvas! sic .0 66 nee 1 68 20, $y eS Tie CE BALL Bunting, &c....... autos 33 85 20. C7 ay, ee en ees Canvas..t.. 2. 75) ae 3 36 20. AR rae We) Eri a Marlin:.....ctuke eee 8 22 GS) Way toll si ce eae hee eo Employés and elerks ... . 708 00 31.|Automatic Gas nae and Light Comipany +)... conte Globes... 5.4050 eee 44 00 Acoail V3 al MaveTOll : «|. con avec eam eae Laborers, &¢....: 2%. veee| 6,212 31 iit 0 OES ing Ee fara ht sa, a CPR ear ee MMS oo - 109 65 J eee ee Serres AS Ca ae MeN ae 6 Gag aoe 555 46 Dil gas Ce a ere Woscils ORE Rata eases ‘(926.6 oe 23 66 8: Joh W- Gulyer', Sau werkt, ... {Incidental expenses. 58 40 8.{Edward R. Shipman’........... Oats... 050.45. oe 245 50 8. Fak Peak ein ee vee Ot. a bene ee 242 60 8. (Peter Fatrell.i.t..-. 2.000: Cobtratt,; 2.4.5. yaa 75 00 8.|Kings County Gaslight Company Gas bouche 384 09 14,|Metropolitan Gaslight Company.| ‘© ..-- 0 wee eee ee eee 4498 AGS ley ell. ick apne Lica ee maclogss and clerks 7U8 00 29.|Department of City Works......|Water rates. ............ 66 00 at Tia eet an ie BROOKLYN PARK COMMISSIONERS. 49 Statement of Accounts certified to Auditor, 1882—Continued. Date. Nawe. For rae ee eee |e May 1-./Pay-roll........ a ee a |LaLorers, ie) Fo et es (ic ES saat ee ee eee ew eee 28 foe Lg See ee ee
Se: 2 -