XXX A ‘ \e is SY \ \\ \) \ UIA WN NAR . ANY AN \ \\ \ AA NY \\\ _ CC \\ _ \ LEA ee EEE VLG Ve i bie i iy, See he f y jie mit i vs “Le ny v aie BUREAU OF AMERICAN ETHNOLOGY BULLETIN 172 PLATE 1 ich of Angoon, 1950. “ Be The West SMITHSONIAN INSTITUTION BUREAU OF AMERICAN ETHNOLOGY BULLETIN 172 THE STORY OF A TLINGIT COMMUNITY: A PROBLEM IN THE RELATIONSHIP BETWEEN ARCHEOLOGICAL, ETHNOLOGICAL, AND HISTORICAL METHODS By FREDERICA DE LAGUNA UNITED STATES GOVERNMENT PRINTING OFFICE WASHINGTON : 1960 For sale by the Superintendent of Documents, U. S. Government Printing Office Washington 25, D.C. - Price $2 (cloth) LETTER OF TRANSMITTAL SMITHSONIAN INSTITUTION, Bureau oF AMERICAN ETHNOLOGY, Washington, D. C., March 31, 1988. Str: I have the honor to transmit |herewith a manuscript entitled “The Story of a Tlingit Community: A Problem in the Relationship between Archeological, Ethnological, and Historical Methods,” by Frederica de Laguna, and to recommend that it be published as a bulletin of the Bureau of American Ethnology. Very respectfully yours, FRANK H. H. Roperts, Director. Dr. LEONARD CARMICHAEL, Secretary, Smithsonian Institution. rm CONTENTS PAGE PerOraces Saat peyote gee eh So a ee es Sat atc ett ee te IX The relationship between Tlingit archeology and ethnology________-_- 1 Introductionmo therproblem oe Luo See a ae re it IBS AST CHORE MUSES Spat ea os a ae et th cam a he Pal Spel el aa 4 Conduct of theviteld wor kag 25.8 a ge 8 Character ofstherethnolopicalidatacwyes shemale ses lle ee eee 15 Tlingit concepts of history and geography _-___________-.---_----_- 16 AM POON PHENO AIR CeLTILOIY 922 ocean eho ei ee ones 23 PRE PANE OORMCOD le ies spree es oh eee ha Se i 23 JeXiaVeRO| Op 0 12h aXe eee ewe ee ee mR ennee ey ee eee kee Senne Sees 28 Archeolopicalsives in weneral 04. uit ek es th hs a ta 30 Admiralty Island north of Kootznahoo Inlet_______________-_-_--_- 35 AR OU ste Oy 27s) ean aE aS my le naan le etre enter ee hee re eS Soe 35 TROOCZIAN OO! ECR 2 ses otters eh tg ety Perce sl ae ee 36 ISG Ot7MAN Go males Lea sk ee Sieh re hes scene ie ccN Ms NS RB 36 OUTS VE COT pe ee re ee el Pt PS EI re SS Rn ed 38 RS Gil Lape Gee Tope ANG be TE Go apc acne ap cas a 39 Pillsbury Point and Daxatkanada Island__________________-_- 39 SS CORIO MASS Oem cary Ll ah Ips yal A 40 IMIG Gee INTs 8 yeh ee Se eed hea a mene in nay ari a 41 1SCNCISH NED BE EO a ARI SCAR ee ani rotten eee ee nn a 43 18431] 05/7941 (0) (0) oa ee me pee ence ne gepee awiey RUN © AONE Cee wd Heewteee aw espe 44 (CH iveya eye) MM 270) fa) pom anes tune meer ne Nien eee nC ne oe Seep eS yey Y 44 PSUR WANE OUN G22 yy ade ly ees Sic Mh 5 coal Ne ate a 45 JRE Oa Heh BYe fee SRNR MN ei aed Ue es ee eerie en ems ale yam eee ate 46 CCRT ODEN os ale aS oh eh chic Ts Lee at wo 46 SEAT 6 CO CAIRN at ata ae USUAL hi Maa NN OA I a Hh MN 47 Chatham Strait between Angoon and Killisnoo__-___-_____-____---- 48 TESTU UTES TOGO) oe AL I NS Sa POP Hs Pye et pe ron oe SSeeIRY l ete PYEO 49 SERIO CUIESS EY eit A rate ll OR a SL em a aha i a 51 ETO GUDTS Sau OT ba a si eae asec a ites Sf eee Se Rs 53 (OlovEN UES, IBY ag St Soh ARIES. deeb ed Oe eae oe en ott I eee aE oS SP een Taree 53 AWAIT CE WS GE Tes cay ee Aa URS, LE SRT VN cyl ncaa ag a al 55 Cie Cy AIG aie t he 58 NVI OI 1G OWN Cre ere yee ey ge fy) a ee i, ayap be ei 58 Southend? of AdminalGyelstane jy co ee ill ee Sl a A 59 ATISY CC My Liptay DAA rca k et Reve Na se Kan hs HA Sop ae the 59 Heringsand. Chapimw aye eff by dS ic epee ge a 59 BBG SNe eh TB OTe 2s gree le AB i a a 59 NEE PU StS hy he ears ar des ge hy ep A la cay pci a ef 60 Whichavorelslam So <2 Rie a gc ee a ile up ely 60 FM gerS| aR ee hes) Oa BY a mM RAL RS 1 LAN 1d Ss ot OT A Oe Pep 60 BREMA Kee MEA 6 bes. op reef Mies ys I ad oy cl ed ie Pe hh eh gL 60 FES Fis re a aga) Sy ny a a he eR ee ea wi 61 IPEMINB Lay OMG aye ey LL a Lan, UE i pat abe Lk 63 SMITHSONIAL INSTITUTION. FEBL 6 4960 IV CONTENTS Angoon tribal territory —Continued Chichagof Island—Continued Point ayes 220 e eo eke essa nas cee nee eee eee Point Crayeneea] ese see eee eos a= ea eee ae a PSE} Co) 21g 2: Se ap PR 0c DROS Ores ae a pried yee pea a a Peni Straits. 22222 325 eh a 5 Oi on Se eee Hanus’ Baye eee ee ee eee Baranor’ Island’ south of Pen! Strait’*'22 se *-* So 20228 See cee Sarmmary s0f gi terbonies= = 90 = sea aan ene ao ee Petrogly pus snd pictomrapuee 22-222 o. seen een ee Pictographs at Magpie Point near Angoon____--.------------- Pictographs south of Whitewater Bay.__-..------------------ Petroglyphs at sitkoh Bay! S0Seeeo ee. sees eee enone Summarys 2 oo 22 eee oe ee es ee ee eee Archeological sites at Daxatkanada Island and Pillsbury Point___-___-_- Daxatkanadarislands=22tse sess ees 2222 ote ee ee eee ee he shells. 222: er Dod sa ee eee ee eee eee eee [HE SAC Ae 2S a8 Se ae ee oe re a ee ea eee Other test pits = 222 22.22 ee ah ae at eee ee eee ee Contentsiof the deposits===22* 22 22222 Uses heat Sa e ee Wood-and:seeds-—2 2) 2 kee ete eae eee ee eee Archeological specimens from the Angoon area_----------------------- Introduction. 22 ei 2s see te oe eee ee eee eee Maulsvandpestless += = sea soe ede eee aoe Slate blades. dae 39 es = 28s ohn ees econ Sea ee see ea wee ea Shellamplementss229es224*"=22¥s 5-25-5242 55 see eee eee Boulder*chips. £222 Ss s2a4 see es aes. eens Se ae ee Plakes and\coress2. 222222820 See shoes eee eee eee sec ee eee Searmammalhuntingsweaponss=-——4—=—2 ses == == === a= Toggle arpoen Neauss es -)n22c=ee ==. eee—= cee a= aan ee Barbed hamoon neds]. =o sae hoe eae ele ere ee ee CONTENTS Archeological specimens from the Angoon area—Continued hand animal) hunting weapons: 5 --. 2-2-2 3 osese sss eens Barbed points=i2 2. 3s ees aes 8a et ey hehe Wnubarbedsarrowheads. 2.222525. Melle ash a pees hat Bone spearsior daggers s2c4 422 estat) eds gee lod_s ISTO CE. 2 1 el ee ees Joa ei a oe Double-poimted, bone pins._--_ 82 _---_- = eee Bird-bonewmolnta i. sce tS oe ee Barbs forgattshookse 2 Se025 2 JL 3 i Ry wen yt De Miscellaneous) bone points... -..-..2.--- ebecedsese4_2e BONG ubOO sees cele ee ee ee apenas Worked bones] 42.2255. 2aenmer eh Ae sl bee Nt ened lb b Ornaments. 22.2 5-el eee Eo Cane HE el ee eal Nose; pin (Qe 2s rat wos eet oil fet Bews UP ahh ew oes Stormers ics aoe eee eS ge ae eg PATI LOSE Wa tes aera eine Se ee ee eS JN TAU TU VE\ eS A I Ge OM NaN La AF) AME, CYTE ae Ae 3 RubpMme stone eee ee pl el ln ae Drinking tube (2) en See a fat eye tS Boy STAGES OOUG 2 oa ee ap ee oe @onclu signs 8 oe a lee ee ee ee a ee mp Date BISEOFY.Ol AN 2OONe 2 ee oe ee le ok een PD she MONG R OCU CLIO Me eae ee eee ae oleae ya te ep RRR EL pe Sy PSM eR OO Gee e te teh bese a eae ar ee eek oe Ee CORER LOGS OL CLERON ey one ese Se ges aE ADM AVES. AH Kooy o Eines a me pia a a la a ee eM 6") 2 Ue cere ine HoundinesOL AiG QO. soos. o ek Sek eeeeeek eee eee AVC TSTO Tete tes se ai nes eae ee ee ae Piel AVIS TSI O Wily 2 re Nee ee rn ae seg ade os a natty el METSION Os ee ee we oe ee ee ne tpe i apg leebd Split between the Ganaxadi and the Decitan______________- Versione ieee 3 oe nS ae ee ea gepu at Re IMersIODI 2240 2 ase MB ee Onrivinton then aqh awedimenmr we hoe wk Be Migration of the Daqvawedie 262 oo 2. kd Story, of the Hood Bay shaman. 6) 2222 see ek oes NYCSSGSTUOY ONT LS ae ee I ree ee eR VI CONTENTS History of Angoon—Continued PAGE Opigin. of sthe TeqYedice... 2.2.25 3650. ERE Be ae 143 Story about TDroubleiat Todds. i cceec eee es eee 145 Other stories:about -Angoon sibs: ...=-. =... See eee Seat. 146 Fights between the Decitan and ’Anxakhitan and the Sitka Wiksadizc i. cecodeet eee ac Stee eee ee ee ee 149 Version olin cee de ee ced 2 ee ee 149 Wersion 2222 eset coke ek eee ek et =a eee See 149 Story,of Pillsbury, Boint--== =. -.=-2--2¢e. 28 see ee 150 Siege of .Daxatkanada.- ....<-2--.2=- 25 eos eee 150 Wersion dis eh este ele eee keene =e eee eee eee 150 Mersloni 2 Leck Ane oe Coe ees =k ee eee 151 Mersion: 3222 4.ses86<2- cee eee. 6 RO ea iee 151 Sequel to Version 3, Trouble at Wrangell_____.____._.--_---_- 152 Peace between the Wrangell and Angoon people__-_____-_------ 154 Defeat of the Sitka Kagwantan at Wrangell_________________- 155 Massacre of the Wrangell Peace Party at Sitka__._.__._________-_ 155 Attack on the Angoon Wuckitan by the Sitka Kagwantan__-____ 157 Murder of the Wuckitan by the Kagwantan at Sitka__________-_ 157 Recent, history. of: Angoon....2--8225225622--022- 3225. 25 oo ee ee 158 Introductions=2-225-222 222 ceecee ote ese ee ee ee ee 158 Destructionjof. Angoon, 1882.2... 222 2 eke 2c. 22 cece ee eso eee 158 Historical backgrounds: .— 225 522523 oe Lee ee 159 Ihetteriof Morris: .+2..ccetecelseocce baeese es See ee 163 Report of Commander,.Merriman.. 2 22224022522) Some 164 Letter, of Mrs. Willard: + ..-.2. 2... 2) er ee 167 ATOM, WVETSIONS (2.2 whe Le See Es ae ae ene 168 Wersion Went ae. Pe hee ew eee ache me verre 168 WiGrSIOM Dao tal la eh ls. ee es go Oe 169 Wersion 322 ci eee Ue eek ee 171 Historic.sketches;ofAngoon2 i 22. bcc ceeoee ee ces ee ee 172 (ATI TOOMUIAT POA ees tn ee acl tS 2, cl ee 172 Angoon nel Sones. ess Bape SE ee lel ee 173 Angoon,inw8 7/9) oa i a Re Dey ee ee 174 Kallisnoo Ans SO0m ee ee eae Lee Lee eS oe ee 174 Asicoon, houses 2222 ce eececesoeeee cece su eee a ae ee 176 AMCIeRt HOUSES 2 a Sirs ee ee Oe le eis ee i 178 Decitamibouses:=< eo ataalucs! sues ees se eee 180 sAnxalchiten (Houses-. 6-2 ceb We eae kee eal ee 185 Wouckitan hotises...2 eRe fae Jorn Fe a ee aE ee pee 186 Neq@edi shousess 22226 kay Su 2 a Ee er ok eee 187 Daqhawedi Jouseses =. bss chee oes os eee ee eee 189 Summarys oo. 2 Oe ee yet ess led Bee ee 192 PAN COON AGO AG 22s ee Ss a ep ane oF cs 5 192 (ONCIUISIONS Hs 2 6 ep he sear a oth on ree ere ke 200 Bibliography 246 eo lee las oe eee 207 AD pen GiX 2228522 3455 ee Soe sce as esses SO ee 210 Hizplanation.ofplates...2 2024.22 5sbassee5 ee ee ee eee 231 ae CONAN PRWHe rODOMDNAARWNe CONTENTS ILLUSTRATIONS PLATES (All plates except frontispiece follow page 234) . The West Beach of Angoon, 1950. (Frontispiece.) . Angoon houses, 1950 and 1890. Daxatkanada Island and causeway. Artifacts and posthole. . Splitting adzes, hammers, etc. Miscellaneous stone specimens. . Stone rubbing tools and saws. Bone weapons. . Bone and shell implements. . Ornaments and miscellaneous specimens, . Petroglyphs, Sitkoh Bay. TEXT FIGURES . The home of the Angoon people and adjoining territories__________- ieaviciniGy Oh ANPOON eae Sees oe oe ee eel ee a ee eM LUcin yO 1alicn ayes Les eeel avi hee Soni Ye Lh ee hee ee a a piteror Neltushkin. Whitewater Bay.2 2-222 2-s2ul lus tee Sele MSI CORabEDASKe hua yee ees eee ea / Site near Chatham Cannery, Sitkoh Bay__..-....._.....-.-._.._- PLC LOOTA DNS are aaa ene ae eae ee aa a eee halal nae MECILORIY Diss OLUKON DAYs ao8 one ee eee Se Ae Es Oe ee peDaxackanacda Welland Skee fils Sei ia eek Sule Sere ee La ae . Bottom of midden on shelf, Daxatkanada Island____._.-.-------_--- . Cross section of midden on shelf, Daxatkanada Island____..----_-_- . Bottom of midden on saddle, Daxatkanada Island___.___-_.--_-_--- . Cross section of midden on saddle, Daxatkanada Island__._______--- asiteo Whale’s Head Nort, Pillsbury Point .22. 2-2-2 fobs 2 oes . Incised stone tablets from Daxatkanada Island_________-_-_------- SBOLCG Oly GROUSE) ORG Cy SUEALG = sen tes wes ee a Se oh Ah eee Pe SiS KEL CH IMAP OMAN OOM He see CMe sh 2h Ley eee Ma ic 8 ate a . Paintings on Killer Whale Houses, Angoon_________._------------- VII A rg oU a Jiwe ss \ Ay) ppl | Buta | = ie) » are er j ‘ nes, tu Pye ine Ay rt) naa bos tg nie ie ap 4 4 @ yi 7 ag dethiyY) Taide pea ak Oly ~gutt alewoita coer | Salts yap eahierh oy cr gpa ld ta 4 aid Be Fa, depen hey aaa na Ao Bry Monbitlt Dnsihing’) me ia sat aie oi as RNY Woe hes ca cee bas oe