!lii. liilil ilHi^ '■^^ WIJi iiii? ^iy™»e,v ^ <^'lass («.3.^....'7.3 Number. ..J/'iTS Volume I ZftHo, Zj Source Received Cost Accession No. / 4- / O | ^ 3^7J -fr^ -^=rK, NEW HAMPSHIRE AGRICULTURAL EXPERIMENT STATION, DURHAM, N. H. BULLETIN NO. 21. FARM YARD MANURES AND ARTIFICIAL FERTILIZERS. APRIL, 1894. CONCORD, N. H.: REPUBLICAN PRESS ASSOCIATION. 1894. • EXPERIMENTS WITH MANURES AND ARTI- EICIAL FERTILIZERS. The experiments recorded in this Bulletin are in part the results obtained at Hanover, N. H., previous to the removal of the Experiment Station to Durham, and in part results at the latter place. The term manures applies to farm-yard manures, and in this case means the mixed manure from cows, young stock, and pigs, with the ordinary amount of absorbents, — such as straw, sawdust, etc. The term artijicial fertilizers means either the prepared or commercial fertilizers, or chemical fertilizers such as are prepared or mixed on the farm. NATURAL MANURES. The manure produced by farm animals varies considerably in value, according to the richness of the food, also from the kind of animal producing it, as well as the condition in which the animal is ; but by far the most important factor affecting the quality of manure is the manner oi collecting" and keeping. About one half of the value of the manure from an ox or cow is found in the liquid excrement, hence at the outset it becomes necessary to adopt some plan by which this may be saved. The con)mon, and probably the best, plan is to use absorbents, which will readily take up this liquid and save it ; but the nitrogen contained in liquid manures is easily ferment- able, and when fermenting gives off ammonia, and as this nitrogen represents more than one third of the total value of both the solid and liquid excrement, it at once becomes evi- dent that it should be carefully managed, and it was in view of this tendency to loss from fermentation that the following experiments were carried on. (a) Manure in masses is almost sure to ferment or heat. Some manure, like that from horses and sheep, is more prone to fermentation than other kinds ; but all, if left for a long time in large quantities, is sure to develop more or less heat. (b) All manures contain soluble plant food, and the percola- tion of water through masses of manure is sure to dissolve out, and, if possible, carry away, this plant food. In view of these two facts, it becomes a question whether we should allow manure to collect long enough to allow fer- mentation to take place ; and, secondly, w^hether any method which allows the rains to wash piles of manure should be tol- erated by the careful farmer. The tendency of water to dissolve out the really valuable parts of manure, and carry these constituents in solution, and the further tendency of soil to sort out this material, as the water filters through the soil, and retain it, are facts which also have a bearing on the solution of the problem of how to apply manures. We are to consider then, first, when to apply manure; secondly, hovj to apply it ; and, thirdly, how ?mtch to apply. SPRING OR FALL APPLICATION OF MANURE. In Bulletin 6 of this station, page 5, two acres of land are reported on, one having 6 cords of manure on the surface in the fall, the other having 6 cords in the spring. Sound corn. Soft corn. Fodder. TV,P v,>lr1 ivn<; i ^^'^ "^^"'"■'"^'' 3.070 lbs. 754 lbs. 6,o6h Ibs. 1 he yield was ^ ypj.j^g " 1,690 " 1,084 " .S.^?! " In the fall of 1SS7 five acres of land were divided into two parts. To one part 35 loads of manure were applied on the surface; the following spring an equal amount was applied to the other half, and the whole planted to ensilage. The yield was not large, as several varieties of corn were planted, three of which did not prove well suited to the climate. The fall manured half yielded .... 58,530 lbs. The spring " " .... 57,605 " The difference here is not great, and can hardly be said to give pos itive evidence for or against either method. to"- In the fall of iS88 two half acres of land were taken and plowed at the same time. August 20 to one of these was ap- plied, after plowing, 3^^ cords of manure, or 10 common cart loads. The other was left until spring. May 20, 1889, and had applied to it 3^ cords of manure. Each half acre received the same treatment and seed, and they were harvested at the same time, with the following results : Fall manured (spread on surface in Aug.), yield of ensilage per acre, 16.48 tons. Spring " " " May), " " " 11.72 " Cuts Nos. 7 ^nd 13 show ten average stalks bunched from each lot. No. 7 gives the fall manured, and No. 12 the spring manured. Another pair of half-acre plots, where twice as many cords of manure were used, namely, 7 cords or 20 cart loads, gave the following results : Fall manured (plowed in), cut No. 6, yielded . 23.17 tons. Spring " " 2, " . 24.50 " Here we have an experiment where the spring-applied ma- nure gave best results. The plowing in of fall-applied manured on sod land is not to be recominended, and the results above recorded are no more than might have been expected, since it gave no chance for frost and rain to pulverize and distribute the manure. HOW SHALL WE APPLY MANURE.? There was a time when it was regarded as settled that the losses from manure were through the air, that is, that the escape of ammonia was the great thing to be guarded against, and, indeed, under the then prevailing custom of allowing manures to heat, — either in piles in the yard, or, worse still, in the large heaps that were so often and are now occasionally seen where the manure has been drawn from the barn to the field, to be stored unprotected until the season for planting — this was true. Here the most favorable conditions possible for fermentation, and the attendant formation of ammonia compounds from the liquid part of the manure, are to be found, and here it is that the ma- nure is really wasted in the air ; but, aside from this inexcusable method, the management of manure can hardly be planned so that the loss will be through the air, but rather will it result from the downward passage of soil waters. The drainage water from our fields carries fertility away, not rapidly, it is true^ but appreciably, and it is the brook that wanders through our fields, and not the winds that blow over them, that rob our manured and unmanured fields of their fertility. With this view of the case, we should so place our farm-yard manure that it shall have just as much soil as possible to filter through. Rain falling on a -field, whether the field is level or consid- erably sloping, tends first of all to enter the soilvjust as water falling on a sponge is absorbed, and the filtering away of this water causes it to flow along through the soil, not over its sur- face. There are exceptions ; a field may be so steep that a heavy rain-fall will rush down its surfoce and mechanically carry away soil and manure, or the land may be so full of water that rain-water does not freely filter through it, but even then the surface water is bound to crowd out that already in the soil ; so that the exceptions, while existing, are not to be considered as of more importance than the general run of cases. Surface manuring is the logical result of a study of the facts relating to fertilizing in general, but by surface manuring I do not mean that the manure should be allowed to remain on the very top of the soil, but rather that it should be mixed with the top two or three inches of soil, and the more intimately it is mixed the better. And right here is \Nh.evQ yall surface manuring derives its chief advantage. I have repeatedly seen as high as forty loads of coarse green manure spread on the surface of an acre of land in the fall. To have harrowed this quantity in so that little or no manure should have been left in sight, would have been an impossi- bility with any form of harrow that we now have ; and yet after the fall rains, the winter snows and frosts, and the spring rains had worked on that manure, an ordinary harrowing would completely incorporate it into the soil : in fact, the ele- ments had themselves mixed the plant food with the soil, and the manure had become pulverized and as fine as compost, and with none or very little of the loss that results from rotting or composting as ordinarily practised. Returning now to our experiments, I will quote from Bulletin 6, page 5, New Hamp- shire Experiment Station, — One acre, manure plowed in, fall applied, " " on surface " From our 1S90 experiments, — Sound corn. Soft corn. Fodder. 2,690 935 5.555 3,070 754 6,066 Manure per acre. Yield per acre. Surface manured, cut 5 14 cords manure 24.70 tons ensilage Plowed in, " 6 . 14 II 23.17 0 s ^ i3 ^ "^ in 5j « ^-< CJ aj l-H o 4-H ra ^ N- en ■a s> L- • Tt- "^ M OJ -• '^5: iJ 3 iT M c ^ I- a! u rt y.-r N a -J, -^ " *- F. '-H — U OJ t. "rt =^«^ ^ tfl E ^ MH C/1 O *-»-< • I^ 13 ■^ o f~\ ^ M jj O f^ cfl S ^ «= ^ M J- ~ aJ rt u i-^ w .~ N U x j;i fi 3 t^ '~~ u .y U '-J ^, ri "-" "> •yi -^'o ^ n w O ^c3 ■crude fertilizing chemicals and mixing as his soil and crops require. Any farmer in this state may, if he will, purchase these chemicals of the wholesale dealers or fertilizer manufacturers, and he is then in position to adapt his fertilizers to the crops and soil he is dealing with. A compilation of all our results thus far obtained gives us the following table, in which one may see at a glance the rela- tive profit resulting from the use of chemicals and the best prepared fertilizers : On Hanover farm $r invested in prepared fertilizers gave increased crop, valued at $i.8o. On Hanover farm ^i invested in chemical fertilizers gave increased crop, valued at $2.80. On ten New Hampshire farms, cooperative test, $i invested in prepared fertilizers, on corn, gave increased crop, valued at $0.74. On ten New Hampshire farms, cooperative test, $1 invested in chemical fertilizers, on corn, gave increased crop, valued at $1.71. On ten New Hampshire farms, cooperative test, $1 invested in prepared fertilizers, on sweet corn, gave increased crop, valued at $2.91. On ten New Hampshire farms, cooperative test, $1 invested in chemical fertilizers, on sweet corn, gave increased crop, valued at $3.03. On ten New Hampshire farms, cooperative test, $1 invested in prepared fertilizers, on potatoes, gave increased crop, valued at $2.07. On ten New Hampshire farms, cooperative test, $1 invested in chemical fertilizers, on potatoes, gave increased crop, valued at $4.20. On ten New Hampshire farms, cooperative test, $1 invested in prepared fertilizers, on potatoes, gave increased crop, valued at $4.20. On ten New Hampshire farms, cooperative test, $1 invested in chemical fertilizers, on potatoes, gave increased crop, valued at $6.05. These results represent more than 500 individual tests, and it cannot be that the results thus obtained are acci- dental: they rest on some law, and from a study of the condi- tions of the experiments we are brought to the conclusion that the prepared goods are deficient in potash. The following table shows the per cents, of nitrogen, phosphoric acid, and potash in the combinations of chemicals that in actual practice have proved best : Phos. Nitrogen acid Potash per cent, per per cent. cent. Best results on plots at Hanover came from mixtures containing ....,._.. 2.5 5.75 25.0 10 COOPERATIVE SERIES. Phos. Nitrog-en acid Potash percent, per percent, cent. Best results on seven New Hampshire farms (husked corn) 4.7 9.0 10.7 Best results on seven New Hampshire farms (fodder) 2.3 9.5 11. 9 Best results on potatoes 2.3 11.6 7.1 Best results on sweet corn 2.1 lo.S ii.o Best results on ensilage .0 4.0 24.0 Best results 011 potatoes (2d series) .... 2.8 9.7 12.4 Average composition of mixtures of chemicals that have produced best results 2.4 S.6 14.6 Average composition of fertilizers sold in the state 3.0 12.0 3.0 RELATIVE EFFICIENCY OF CHEMICALS AND FARM-YARD MANURES. Can chemical manures compete with farm-yard manures.'' Will they hold out.'' — These are questions that are asked hun- dreds of times ever}' year b_v careful farmers. The experiment begun at Hanover in 1SS5, and reported on at times as the work progressed, is now completed, the full rotation having been accomplished the year before the station was moved from that town. Two acres of land, from a field of six acres, were selected for this experiment. The land had produced hay for three years previous, to iSS^J ; oats and sugar-beets had preceded the hay. The third acre had 13 loads of manure plowed in and 9 loads harrowed in, or in cords this would be 5.6 cords plowed in and 3.8 cords on surface, or 9.4 cords in all, which would sell, as it lay under the stables, for $33. This manure was from fattening steers, well fed with hay, straw, cotton seed, and corn meal. The fourth acre had yearly applications of chemical fertilizers, inixed as follows: Dissolved bone-black 346 lbs. Muriate of potash 150 " Sulphate of ammonia 55 " The average cost of this mixture has been $11, and as there have been three applications since 1SS5, it follows that each acre has received $33 worth of fertilizer ; the third having 1] $33 worth of manure, and the fourth $33 worth of chemicals. The first year the crop was corn, the second year corn, the third oats, and the fourth, fifth, and sixth, grass. The following table shows the yield of each acre for each year, and also the value of the crop, assuming 80 pounds of corn as harvested to be worth 60 cents, 34 pounds of soft corn 10 cents, and fodder 30 cents per hundred, oats 50 cents per bushel, straw 30 cents per hundred, and hay $10 per ton : ■ r Sound* Corn J Soft-- • lvalue.. ( Grain f. Oats \ Straw .. (Value.. 3 (Yield... ^^y (Value.. 2 (Yield... ^^y j Value .. jj (Yield... "^y Value.. Third acre, — manure. 1885. 112 bu. 161 bu. 4,835 lbs. $49.75 1886. 833 bu, 27 bu. 4,435 lbs, $41.12 Fourth acre, — chemicals. 1885. 1886. 97 bu. 823 bu. 15 bu. 24 bu 5,352 lbs. 4,927 lbs $46.65 $42.00 1887. 43 bu. 4,5.35 lbs. $35.10 47i bu. 5,267 lbs. $39.55 1888. 5,880 lbs. $29.40 6,202 lbs. $31.01 1889. 4,200 lbs. $21.00 4,800 lbs. $24.00 t 1890. 3,700 lbs. $18.50 2,800 lbs. $19.00. Total crop for six years Excess of value produced by chemicals. 1953 bu. 43i bu. 9,270 lbs. $90.87 * Sound corn, 40 lbs. per bushel; soft corn, 34 lbs. t Oats, 32 lbs. per bushel. Oi (0 p a $35.10 $29.40 $21.00 $18.53 $194.87 $7.34 O J3 1793 bu. 39 bu. 10,279 lbs. $88.65 $39.55 $31.01 $24.00 $19.00 $202.21 per bushel. 12 Plots on which no manure or chemicals were used for the same six years, gave us crops valued at $128.77, ^° that we have a gain of crops on the manured acre valued at $66.10, and this is the result of investing $33. On the acre fertilized with chemicals the excess is valued at $73.44. This exjDeriment I regard as a safe one for farmers to study, as it was on a large scale, and under the most favorable cir- cumstances so far as the uniformity of soil and treatment were concerned. In the series of experiments represented by the cuts in this bulletin made in iSS9-'90, we have a comparison of the effi- ciency of chemicals, prepared fertilizers, and manure, on land which had been fertilized with ashes either in 1879 or 1880 and had since been in grass. PREPARED FERTILIZERS, CHEMICALS, AND ASHES COMPARED. Cost. Yield. Plot I had the follow- ing chemicals dissolved bone-black, 404 lbs., ) muriate of potash, 122^ lbs., > $12.25 19.85 tons, .g, v,..v.....^.*.o ^ sulphate of ammonia, 86 lbs., ) * Plot 14, the same as plot I 12.25 16.01 " Plot 13 had 6S0 lbs. of Bowker's Hill and Drill Phos- phate 12.25 Plot 10 had 244 bushels of leached ashes . . . 12.25 Plot II had 98 bushels of whole ashes .... 12.25 16.93 '' 16.88 " 13.60 " The amount and cost of the fertilizer above is per /la^J" acre, but the yield is computed per acre, as we are more accustomed to think of the amount we produce per acre. MANURE AND ARTIFICIAL FERTILIZERS. Plots 10-14 form a series which may be studied by them- selves, and as the yield of 10, 11, 13, and 14 do not vary greatly, except II, we will average them and compare them with No. 12, which was spring manured. Cost per acre. Tons. Fertilized with, riot ID, leached ashes, " II, whole ashes, " 13, Bowker's H. and D. Phosphate, " 14, chemicals, " 12, 3^ cords of manure, Gain in favor of artifical fertilizer, ► S12.25 average yield, 15.85 12.25 yield, 11.72 4-13 * Plots 10 to 14 had some six or eight years previous to this experiment been fertilized with ashes. 13 This is, however, the gain over manure spring appHed. If we take plot 7, where $12.25 worth of manure was fall applied, we get a yield of 16. 48 tons, a gain of 0.63 tons in favor of manure. Or, take plots i, 4, 7, and S, another series that may be com- pared, because the fertilizer used on each represents the same cost. Cost of fertilizer Yield per half acre. per acre. Plot 4, manured Feb. II, 3>^ cords per half acre, $12.25 10.18 tons. " 7, " fall, " " " 12.25 16.48 " " 8, " " " " " 12.25 16.13 " Average • • 14.26 p, ( bone-black, 404 lbs. per half acre, > chemcals ] muriate of potash, I22>^ lbs. " [ 12.25 IQ-SS " Chemicals, ^ s^iph^te of ammonia, 86 lbs. " ) Gain resulting from chemicals instead of manure . . 5.59 " In a series of experiments carried on at Durham, under the supervision of Mr. D. E. Stone, the following results were obtained : Cost per Yield per half acre. acre. Plot 2, (one half acre), 5 cords manure, $i7-5o '5 08 tons. " 4, " " 10 " 35-00 16.32 " ( dis. b. black, 162 lbs., ) " 3, " " chemicals ^ mur. of pot., 50 " > 5.00 13.56 " ( sulp. of am., 38 " ; " 6, " " Stockbridge manure, 250 lbs., 5.00 8.13 " " 7, " " Bowker's H. and D., 250 lbs., 4.50 8.48 " " 8, no fertilizer of any kind 5-46 " In this series we see that the comparatively small amount of fertilizer used on plot 3, costing only $5, gave a very credit- able yield, even alongside of $17.50 worth of manure; and that $10 per acre gave an increased crop of 8.10 tons, or a ton at a cost of $1.23, but this is on the assumption that all of the chemicals were used up last year, which will not prove to be the case. 14 CHEMICAL FERTILIZERS— now TO MIX AXD USE. WHAT THE CHEMICALS ARE AND WHAT THEY CONTAIN AND WEICH. Weight per *, bu. Dissolved bone-black contains 1 6 percent, soluble phosphoric acid, 30 lbs. Muriate of potash " 50 " actual potash, Sulphate of ammonia " 20 " nitrogen, Nitrate of soda " 15 " nitrogen. 34 44 STANDARD COMBINATIONS. No. I. For Corn. Dissolved bone-black . Muriate of potash Sulphate of ammonia lbs. 325 100 75 500 V. Foi- Oats. (Or use No. 1.) Dissolved bone-black . . . 325 Muriate of potash . . .125 Sulphate of ammonia . . 50 » 500 IX. For Potatoes. (Following a manured crop.) Dissolved bone-black . . . 340 Muriate of potash 160 500 No. 4. For Ensilage. Dissolved bone-black . Muriate of potasli Sulphate of ammonia X. For Potatoes. (On poor ground.) Dissolved bone-black . Muriate of potash Sulphate of anmionia lbs. 250 200 50 500 No. VII. For Hay. Dissolved bone-black . 22 c Muriate of potash . 250 Nitrate of soda . • 25 500 300 150 JO 500 These chemicals are all dry, harmless substances, as easily mixed as corn meal, shorts, and middlings. The combinations are vastly superior to the prepared fertilizers on the markej:, 15 chiefly because they are entirely soluble and contain a high per cent, of potash. The amounts are for one acre where no manure is used, and in every case on planted crops use either 300 or 350 pounds of the mixture broadcast, putting only from 150 to 200 in the hill or drill, and do not let it come in contact with the seed. This cost, on an average, about as follows : Dissolved bone-black $25-^30 per ton. Muriate of potash 42- 45 " Sulphate of ammonia 78- 80 " and may be bought of any fertilizer manufacturer. CONCLUSIONS. Manure applied in the fall to the surface, either of plowed or grass land, will, by the action of frost and rain, become so thoroughly pulverized and distributed through the soil that it acts more quickly, and is in better condition for plants to as- similate, than the same manure would be if applied in the spring. The loss from evaporation and drainage (unless the surface is very steep) will probably be rhuch less than the loss result- ing from fermentation if the manure is allowed to accumulate in cellars or the washing if left in open yards. On most soils, and for most crops, surface application is bet- ter than plowing in, and especially if manure is applied in the fall, but in any case, except for manure that is so coarse that it cannot l)e mixed with the soil by cultivation, it is a safe rule to keep the manure as near the surface as possible, and to have it as thoroughly mixed with the seed-bed as can be done. This carries with it the necessity of using only such bedding and absorbents as are of themselves fine or easily pulverized. For our common field crops — corn, oats, rye, barley, pota- toes, etc. — it is not profitable to use more than from 15 to 20 cart loads (5-7 cords) of manure per acre. On an average, on New Hampshire soils and with general crops, $1.00 invested in the best prepared fertilizers has given an increase of crop valued at $2 34, while $1.00 invested in the chemicals — dissolved bone-black, muriate of potash, and 16 sulphate of ammonia— has given an increase valued at $3. 56— a difference of $1.22 in favor of, and due entirely to, the substitu- tion of chemicals for prepared fertilizers, at equal cost. This difference is due chiefly to the wrong properties of plant food in the prepared fertilizers, and more to the defi- ciency of potash than any other cause. ( phosphoric acid Prepared fertilizer gives . . ) potash ( nitrogen . While the chemicals that give { Phosphoric acid best result contain . i potash ( nitrogen . 12.0 per cent. 3.0 3.0 8.6 14.6 2.4 " Chemicals properly mixed and used can and do give as good returns as farm-yard manure, and oftentimes better, and this in. a six years rotation. Leached ashes gave better results per dollar invested thaa whole ashes. G. H. WHITCHER, Director. .^. m fif-rirf 'W^ 'mm^ mMm mm Aiiitii mmm mmm IP iSttrnt; Mm 'mm-' mmm Piiliiiiiiiiiu liiillilili ' "mm ■. .•■ T > ? 5 r V ■ ^ ? » r HHimmi