w^ 4^ 2 1^ VO X33- ^^"^ '^'^ ■■^' ^' 0^^ / 1^'feS ^ EXPERIMENT STATION LIBRARY kfl'-: ^i 3 ^bDD DDblfl M73D 1 .^«i*,*'. il? STATION N. H. Bulletin 241 May, 1929 NEW HAMPSHIRE AGRICULTURAL EXPERIMENT STATION WHITE MOUNTAIN DEMAND FOR VEGETABLES AND POULTRY PRODUCTS By E. H. RINEAR THE UNIVERSITY OF NEW HAMPSHIRE DURHAM. N. H. WHITE MOUNTAIN DEMAND FOR VEGETABLES AND POULTRY PRODUCTS By E. H. Rinear The popularity of the White Mountain hotels and summer resorts- creates a large market for food each year. For some time there have- been frequent discussions regarding the possibility of supplying more of this demand for vegetables and poultry products from nearby sources. The present study has resolved itself around the two main cjuestions : first, what constitutes the hotel demand for vegetables and poultry- products? Second, what type of service is necessary in fulfilling it? Costs of production were not studied in the present investigation. The state-wide survey made in 1925 by the Experiment Station (N. H. Bulletin No. 222) brought out the facts as to the amounts which were being produced in New Hampshire and purchased from outside sources. The total season's purchases by White Mountain hotels during that year from farmers and weekly purchases from others outside are shown in Table 1. "It will be noticed that local farmers supply only a small por- tion of the total consumption of these hotels. The estimated value of vegetable purchases from local farmers is $42,000, while from others it is $80,000. A few products such as beets, carrots, cauliflower, spinach, string beans, peas, turnips, squash, potatoes, and sweet corn are nearly half supplied by farmers." "Local farmers furnish only a small part of the poultry and eggs. In 1925 the hotels purchased 54,720 pounds of poultry, no turkey and 1,450 cases of eggs from local farmers, compared to 260,422 pounds of poultry, 36.000 pounds of turkey and 7,070 cases of eggs purchased from others." Methods Pursued in Study In studying the hotel preferences, ten vegetables were chosen which appear to be suited to local climatic conditions as many of them are now being successfully grown: beans, beets, carrots, cauliflower, cucumbers, green corn, green peas, head lettuce, spinach and tomatoes. Demand preferences were obtained in detail from the hotel managers, stewards and chefs as to variety, size, color, shape, grade and brands of these vegetables. Similar information was secured for eggs and dressed poultry. Several trial shipments were made from southern points in New Hamp- shire to discover some of the difficulties which might arise in supplying this demand and also to learn the degree of satisfaction which such ship- ments would meet with the stewards. Ten representative White Mountain hotels were selected as a basis for this study. Some of the best summer hotels were included in the group. Their capacity ranged from 100 to 600 guests. Tourists and summer guests begin coming to hotels in the White Moun- tains during the early part of June. This transient population increases rapidly until the latter part of August and then declines very abruptly, until by the middle of September practically all the guests are gone and the hotels closed. ■3 ' 00 ■'^ ■M • • •.— cCvCM ••^OOlo ■ • -O-ODO ■ • • • fO IM • 00 ^H ^H . • • -rf ^^ 00 • • • • O -^ og 00 00 to \0 • • ■ \0 o 00 -^ • • • ^ so t^ '^ --H • • • 00 o 3 (^ (VI o oo t-^>OOO<^-tO0000-^ -LOCNI-rto^^ON ^OLOi-O ^Hl^-t-— I •sO'-H-^OOOfM (^ ^ 00 (M ,— (-HlOt^'^ r-it^LOCM •00'— l-fOOO"^ Oq l>l LO lO oCto <^ LOi-000000\Tt'~0^v0'^0v0\Or0O00t^ LOLO-t'^O <— i>OO^toON.oso •oo'-^-,—, 00 so -H LO ro 'i- t^ LO rf rsj 00 so -1- LO LO -(M • ro r^ 00 "1" '"'2 ?o ^ '^^ ^ '"'^ • LO Co r-( '-O'-O'-o'^-i-'-^'Ni^oroLoo '"or^ -t-'i- o^-i- t^ ^^ LO —I ■l-> ■*-• (U O) ■*-> +-» J! ct3 u u (J O be ° _ 03 O c/) 33 Di na ' J --^ CI. i; • I JS . I '-' ' 3 -^ N ' 0 •T3 en X o n ■ aj ti ^I t/} X! ^ Hi o ■n oj , ^ bo" 1 o N o 3 ^- 3 no — ,,;'« '^' be OJ 03 X r- '/J '71 (U tn n bfl •£S2-£.X2 o 3 u ■ri _ rj -^ U tn 03 ,,, <^-~ V- 1- a! a w, ajn 3 oi 1) '-n '-'^ r- 0-> 03 3 cr O ', o '-»; , < a, .- T. 2h O u Yj O' Mav, 1929J Dkmand for Vegetables and Poultry 5 The investigation was carried on during August 1928, which is notably the busiest part of the hotel season. In many instances, the managers and stewards were rushed, so that the time was limited which they could allow for interviews. Courteous treatment was received in all cases and appreciation of the problem often expressed. These men were not ac- quainted with agricultural problems to the same degree ; consequently, they varied in their opinions and interest in the subject. Furthermore, some of the hotels were better situated than others in that they were located near commercial gardeners. As a result, opinions differed regard- ing the satisfaction received from home-grown products, depending upon the experience of the stewards in purchasing from local sources. Ac- cording to their replies they arranged themselves quite definitely in two groups ; those who were or were not satisfied with local products. Through the courtesy of several Boston wholesalers vegetable prices paid them by the hotels were secured. Additional prices covering the same period were secured from local producers located near the hotel district. It was not convenient to obtain prices paid by each hotel as the records were not easily available. The few prices procured were taken direct from the order sheets or given by the stewards from memory. When visiting the hotels, inspection was made of the vegetables and poultry products in the refrigerator rooms. By this method, it was pos- sible to note the quality, grade and brand of products from different sources and to learn the types of containers and packs used. Checking up on the grades of the different vegetables purchased by the hotels and comparing with the grade requirements desired by the stewards showed quite definitely that all vegetables would have to be at least of U. S. No. 1 grade to satisy the demand. Many times it would require products of U. S. Fancy grade to fulfill the extra qualifications demanded by the stewards. Demand for Vegetables Although the investigation was limited in many ways because much of the information is based on the preferences of the hotel stewards, it is hoped the following outline will give a clearer idea of the require- ments of the hotel demand. By examining Table 2, it will be noted there is much variation in the amount of vegetables used weekly by each hotel. This is due to varying hotel capacities, preferences and also to the ex- tent to which each hotel had been able to purchase satisfactory products. Often a hotel used more spinach, peas, or head lettuce per guest than another because it could procure them locally. The Boston box and bushel basket were the containers generally used. Occasionally an extra charge is made for the container by Boston whole- salers. At such times the stewards choose the one which was the cheap- est. When there is a shortage of storage space in the hotel refrigerator rooms, it is necessary to stack the goods. This is accomplished in an orderly manner when the products are put up in substantial containers of uniform size and shape. When local growers supply the hotels it is customary for the boxes to be returned although one steward stated that this was a nuisance. c 3 o e a S it a g e w >—, CM 00 "T^ LO ^a\>oo T-i ^ ^oc^^c^^ ro c^ I— f .-H ,-H • Sjl-LO ■* -^ fO "0 O • hN,— 1 lO m fOrorM^<0'+r-> 3 w ^O '^J — "M O LT- t^ ro ^ (N OJ rn ^ OJ > — — — Q OCMrMroOO-t-OOOO ^ 1 — ^f— 11 — 1 T^f-HC^i— ii-OOO m -*-» C ;3 O E < • U ^^ ,_, . XN 00 -^ "^ ro CM u^ • ro -^-^Oii-iCOOOiOO CQ CO ^ < TfCM •^Ot^»J~J^O-*LO C^J TT a o t^t^':J-ro00rO'>*uT*(NJ •^OO'vCr-Hr^ONCMCNONOO CM -—I t^ X o m -*-> ston Lbs. •^ 5 o m . a; . in ■ O _ij OJ ■ s: it! u 3 (J t« C liflower umbers en Cor en Peas .d Lett lach . . . o aji_3U(i;ajni_— .-CI (J 1/2 o 0^ ^d MQ i-id ^d mp JO og ^d cqQ -lO o o oooo o o o in rNi oooo \0 lO U-) — • cm' Cvj fO t< LO O O O OO (N| rt 'O O eg CO r-J r-I eg o o •o •o OMO O vo r^ lO rn ro • o • o lO O O LO C^J r^ CD o cv) cvj lo o LO o fx. LO c\j vO eg c^i(^i vd 1 o o o LO 00 I > -r ^ Csj c\i CvU J c\j eg CMO O ro f\i t-n' •o ■ o OOOOCM lO o O LO CM C^J ^^ >— I ,— <' LO O LO C CN) LO r^ \o O O m LO 00 '-' ^ 00 r^ CM "^ CM <^ 00 '^^ .— I .— ■ (M ON • o . CV) H •^ c rt o 01 *^ ^ 03 O +-• X o ^(^ LO * >, o-^ ■^-' ■!-■ =3 o ^ 1 — , mP u. O O • oo •oo ooo LO O <0 •o (M O (M O O LO O ^ LO I^ LO iNi ^ CM I^ O LO LO LO LO LO CM rO r^ CS] oo J J fO ■\0 J3 in > o X OCQ H-1 o I -4-' o 3 O X O 6'B H u o ■!-• u --: 3 oj o a o H O OS :§ a> o 3 -o O u Ph c o en O PQ * • o>o — u-j lo o "^ ^ 6 . o r^ ■ • -c ■ t-s. rvi U-) p * o •OOOO"^ -so -u-- 3 m ^^ . 1— I . — ' O ' — ' (^l • nC O ■ •— ' M-) (_i| racN (M -^ —H — < ^ 3 < •OOO • lO o -o o o ■ , J • m O OC • rvi -^ ^d- ■O • (VJ ro (VJ ^^roCJ-^CM ■ LT^irv •iTvOO^^^^OC:' ^ o • r^*^) -r^oor^it^iri.— ^— — . .— ■ f^j — ^- -1^ (^ 3 •OOiOOO -Ou^OI^ Q • — <^r^vo\o •vocgu-y — bo ui CNCVjro^— 1 ^^CS] 3 < ■ OC O -inO VOO • • 1 .K • u-i U-, rv) • CJ Tf \0 -^ • • 1 ^ <^\'^. <^ r-H 'O fM ^- IS^ • -IT) •OlOOu^«^•J^00 ()t • • «^i • C5 r^ i/~- 00 00 1^ CM ■Jf- '— "^ ^^ (N r-i ^0 •CrOOOO -lOOO^O 3 pa Q . -- ^ LT, VC LO • t^ O lO (M bn rg (>) ro u-/ (M ^ ^ rsi 3 < . _ 3 3 . . 3 v^ — , J f ^ • O 3 fN) . - rf \o -1- • • co^co roCM— H 1 ^ a rg -oiooooooc^iCM —. r^ (M 1^ ^^ * ^ 1 ■*-• ■■ (/} • O lO O O • O O O O "^ K p C\i r^ i-^ u-j -^ ^ — H csi < ■ o --1- • -OiOO • • J o ■ — . ■ ^. ■ " ^. *> t ■ ■ ^ lO -OOOOu^/OO a CVl • O i^- O O (M O <>1 * — ' <^cvi cvi — ^cg •OOOO -OOOu-iCO ^j CD O .-^irviJO^^ .vOvOvCt^(N be rvj ro ro VO r^ »-^ .-^ CM 3 < • — ■ -1- - • CM^' O • • hJ tJ • _ . »- . . o t^ u"- • • <-^ er> ro CM ^^ -*-' O X ^ • lU D 1 . I« o - KT. • 3 > • w-i • O ••ll^ X c ■ ^ rt ri^ ■A >t: • ■;:' iJ is J^ O r "^ . - '■' ' 3 - . rt - XI be = ^ r^ 'X C CJ -^ — o ^ i; u. 3 o o ;; ■.- . " • r 3 1 =:- ! rt 3 1- u Ec; 00 H 11 C * O lO u^ •OiO o • ^a — ) .IT) •in t>> O • — ' ^^ CM "-i CM ■»(■ CM .— < (U ■*-' C. aj U) lO • >0 -ID . . .o ■ J O 1^ • r^ -CM ^ cm' — <" • . . vo • cm' 1 loo.o -o • o o -"^ cvi O O • O • O lO - O o ^O — — "^ ^ CM * • ^ O . ' u-) O O O O • irj lO O CM m P r^ ^H o NO o •CMCMO '— H ^ CM CM 00 CM ^ — CM lU ■*-' a in 1 O "~- "^ • "^ • -OO • p d o t^r^ -CM • -TJ-NO • CMCM CM ^ T-,CM . O O O U-- >-0 O O • u^ ^d CV) O O • t^ . NO NO lt; O •^ ■^ J3 . — U-, ~ — tJ~, . \0 lO -CM r-" c m P O '-C O l-H f ^ • O CM • .— ■ .— (M CM r^ — 1 .— .—1 -4-> D. 4J O "^ o • "~- • O O LO f P o O t^ "^. -CM ■ r^ 'i- oo • CM rvj CM -^ -^ — CM ^o o vn o • lo . ir; ir; O *^ OWO -so • r^ CM O O * ^ -^ CM » • 3 O • '^^ X O ^ ■ ni rtx; ■yi j'. IS J. ^ EC . o • o o X oS H = = -c«^^ OJ u. 3 '-' i. < o v; -3 T - ) 3 i- /OKa _ - o o 14 New Hampshire Experiment Station [Bulletin 241 Vegetable Prices In order to show the effect of hotel preferences on vegetable prices, it was necessary to obtain prices from a few growers in the White Moun- tain district and from several Boston wholesale houses that are regularly- supplying this demand. By further comparing these prices with the quotations given in the Boston Produce Market Report it is possible to estimate the premiums paid. It will be noted that the prices received by the local grower are always above market quotations. (See Table 3) However, this amount does not represent premium entirely because delivery was made to the hotels. In general, the stewards stated they were willing to pay as much for local products of equal quality as those from Boston would cost after all charges were paid. On this basis, the apparent premiums of local growers should be reduced by the amount of express charges and other delivery costs incurred in obtaining vegetables through Boston sources. Express rates vary somewhat from the White Mountain section ; charges per cwt. from Boston to North Conway, Bretton Woods, Bethlehem and Whitefield are $1.24; to Plymouth $1.09. The prices given under the heading of a Boston distributor are rep- resentative of those received by the wholesalers who are accustomed to supplying the hotels. Although these prices are F. O. B. Boston, it will be noted they are higher than the market quotations for all vegetables except cauliflower and tomatoes. (See Table 3) The extra margin is partly due to handling charges for services rendered. It may also be the result of higher quality goods. Any published quotation necessarily has to represent the average going price. It is possible that other price levels exist above the average price for a smaller amount of goods of high quality. Attention is also called to the fact that this house was able to supply several commodities many weeks before these products were quoted in the Boston Produce Market Report which would tend to show that they are rendering extra service in catering to the hotels. The varying margins obtained for head lettuce by the local grower and Boston distributor over market quotations are illustrated in Figure 1. The local grower furnished head lettuce of superior quality, or the hotels would not have been willing to pay a premium for it consistently over other sources. Toward the forepart of September his lettuce was of poor quality and the price was lowered. Although the local grower received a higher price for lettuce through- out the season than that obtained by the Boston distributor, this condi- tion did not hold true for spinach. (See figure 2) In the forepart of the season the local grower received a price which was above market quotations and below the price of a Boston wholesaler ; in five weeks time the price was lowered to $1.40 a box and continued throughout the season regardless of terminal market changes. During the weeks of August 30th and September 6th, he received a price for spinach over five times as great as the quotation. On the other hand, even though the wholesale house secured a large margin over quotations, it followed the general market changes. These illustrations show some hotels are willing to pay a high price regardless of market conditions when they are furnished quality products. Ma\ , 1929] Demand for Vegetables and Poultry 15 Dependable Supplies The summer hotel business changes regularly with the weather. This uncertainty causes the demand for food to vary daily. It is, therefore, necessary that the stewards establish connections wih dependable parties if the hotel is to be operated successfully. To secure the great variety of items required for such operation, it is necessary to purchase them in a terminal market. Orders are telephoned and filled on short notice. The majority of hotels are able to obtain express delivery to their nearest station within 24 hours after placing the order. The wholesalers in Boston have been catering to this trade for some time and have built up a reputation for dependal)ility in supplying products of the quality desired. Also they are willing to make any needed adjustments where dissatisfaction occurs. When the stewards are certain to receive services of this kind they are not over-anxious to drop them and experiment with products from local growers of unknown reputation. Previous ex- perience with some local growers has been very unsatisfactory and ex- asperating. The local grower may have failed to fill the orders as agreed, making the excuse that it had rained or giving some other reason of equal importance. Lack of grading or even trying to grade to satisfy the hotel demand was another common complaint made against this type of grower. The stewards stated they could not afford to bother with these men because they had to regrade the products. Two classes of local growers are supplying vegetables to the White Mountain hotels. At the present time the largest part comes from com- mercial growers who depend on the hotel trade for their main source of income. A smaller part is supplied by men who grow and sell vege- tables as a sideline. Often the large grower has kept definite time and production cost records on all the vegetables produced so that he can de- termine which are the most profitable. The small grower with vegetables as a sideline does not figure his production costs so definitely and looks on this added income as practically all gain. Usually this type of grower produces one crop. He does not make plantings at such regular intervals as the large grower who plans to furnish a dependable supply of fresh vegetables throughout the season. Competition between growers of these two classes causes difficulties to arise. The small grower is often willing to sell his produce at a price below the market, which has a demoralizing effect. Even though the small grower sells for a short time, he may cause the price to be set at a low level for a sufficient period to make the larger grower actually lose money. To protect themselves from this type of competition some commercial growers have found it advisable to contract with the stewards, agreeing to supply them regularly throughout the growing season. Through cost accounting methods covering several years one grower has learned he cannot afford to grow peas and sell them for less than $4.00 a bushel. He has made arrangements with the hotels to supply them regularly at this price regardless of market prices or local competition. From the hotel's point of view this is a very satisfactory arrangement. As has been previously shown hotels are in a position to pay for quality goods. 16 New Hampshire Experiment Station [Bulletin 241 Where these contracts have been entered into and followed, entire satis- faction has resulted. The hotels were assured of receiving a regular su])- ply, and the grower could regulate his planting areas so as to have suf- ficient amounts available to care for the contracted demand and be sure to receive a remunerative price for the product. Delivery Service Most White Mountain hotels are located some distance from railroad stations and all suplies shipped by rail have to be trucked to their final destination. This fact causes the hotels considerable inconvenience. De- cided preference is shown the local men when they can make delivery, provided their products satisfy the demand, as the local products can be delivered in less time than those from Boston. Often local men receive calls and make delivery a few hours later. In several instances, the stewards intimated they would pay a premium for this service. One remarked, "Local farmers have a distinct advantage over outside sources because they can deliver direct." Not only did the products arrive in fresher condition, but there was a smaller percentage of waste due to the fewer handlings and to the shorter time in transit. There are other important advantages which local men have through this contact. They can compare their goods with those from other sources and study at first hand the requirements of each hotel. If their products are not satisfactory, the steward will soon tell them, and any needed adjustments can be attended to before the business is lost. Hotel Gardens Several hotels included in the investigation had their own gardens and grew many of the vegetables needed. This practice is being discon- tinued where the managment is able to purchase regularly from a local grower ; for experience has proved the latter course much cheaper and more satisfactory. Occasionally gardens are kept for show purposes and charged up to advertising even though they are operated at a loss. One manager stated they were changing over from vegetables and grow- ing flowers. These flowers were placed in the guests' rooms every day. He believed the intangible benefits more than made up for the value of the vegetables which they had formerly produced. Possibilities of Development Because the growing season in the mountain section is short, there is the possibility of gardeners farther south supplying the hotel trade. In testing out this possibility the cooperation was secured of W. P. Tuttle, a commercial gardener of Dover, N. H., who supplied several boxes of tomatoes for trial shipment. These tomatoes were uniform in size and free from blemishes. All were wrapped and packed in standard Boston boxes. One steward was so well pleased that he allowed 24 cents a pound for them, which was the price for hot-house tomatoes. In the opinion of this grower, however, it is not practicable for him to furnish the hotel trade with tomatoes as he has his regular customers to supply. AEav, 1929J Demand for Vegetables and Poultry 17 On the whole the prospects are good for the development of more commercial gardens. There are sections of the White Mountain hotel district which are heing well cared for hy local growers, and there it would be unwise for other men to start in the business. In those sec- tions which are still largely dependent on Boston for their vegetable sup- plies, oi)ortunities exist for a limited number of local growers. This does not mean that everyone who tries vegetable gardening will be suc- cessful. The hotel demand is very exacting and requires a high degree of specialization in production as well as marketing. Because the hotels are open for a short time and the demand for food is so dependent on the weather, there may be times when kjcal growers will have a surplus of vegetables. There is always the possibility of sup- plying nearby New Hampshire cities which are within trucking dis- tance as the previous survey (See N. H. Station Bulletin No. 222) showed large amounts were being purchased from more distant sources during the same period. The numerous summer residents of New Hampshire provide splendid markets for those who wish to sell on a retail basis. This type of market is supplied best l)y local men when a definite route is covered daily or at regular intervals. At such times, it is also possible to sell a variety of farm products. Many instances were found where local men are taking advantage of such opportunities. DEMAND FOR POULTRY PRODUCTS Eggs A general impression of the volume of eggs required by the White Mountain hotels visited is given in Table 4. These amounts include all classes of eggs used by each hotel during a week when running at Table 4 — Eggs: Maximum amounts used in a ueek and prices paid by ten White Mountain hotels. Cases used per week Date of Purchase Price per Dozen Hotel Price Paid ! ♦Wholesale Local Other Source | Quotation A 10 July 25, 1928 .40 $.47 B 7 " 30 .42 .48 C 3 Aug. 1 .47 .48 D 23 7 .47 .50 E 10 8 .51 .50 F 6 8 .54 .50 G 15 " 9 .46 30 H 16 •• 10 .46 .50 I 5 " 21 .54 .53 J 21 " 22 .54 :54 .54 *Boston Produce Market News: Top price, nearby hennery, brown extras. full capacity. Eggs of the best quality were required for frying, poach- ing and boiling, and those of a lower grade were used for baking and for other cooking purposes. 18 New Hampshire Experiment Station [Bulletin 241 =125 40 45 50 Cents per Doz. Fig. 3 — Prices paid by the hotels for eggs on day visited, It will be noted there is a wide range in prices paid by the ^iifferent hotels; this is to be expected when eggs are purchased from many sources. (See Table 4) May, 1929] Demand for Vegetables and Poultry 19 Egg Preferences All of the stewards were anxious to obtain eggs that could be depended on not to make trouble. One bad egg could do a great deal of harm to their business. A brand of eggs put out by a large concern gave almost entire satisfaction. Three of the stewards remarked they never had any trouble with this brand of eggs, and another stated it was 90 percent perfect as to uniform colored yolks. These eggs had been caudled and graded so that they were of uniform freshness, yolks of same color, all of the same size, shape and other quality factors required to meet definite standards. Eggs from a reliable source of such high quality af- ford real competition for a New Hampshire poultryman. Local men have the decided advantage in being located nearby, as the majority of the eggs purchased come from more distant points, thus requiring greater time in handling than would be necessary in assembling and transporting eggs from local sources to the White Mountain hotels. Although freshness of eggs was given the greatest emphasis, other factors were mentioned. Uniformity in color of the egg yolks was es- pecially desired for poaching and frying. When not uniform the guests are usually dissatisfied. The stewards differed in their preferences as they liad on previous commodities. Two preferred brown eggs, two others wanted white, and six purchased eggs of mixed colors. The two desiring white eggs stated that the yolks of white eggs were more uniform in color than those of brown. On the other hand one of the stewards preferring brown eggs said their yolks were more uniform as to color than white. It shows that anyone furnishing the hotels would do well to learn the preference of each steward. Two hotels contracted ahead with Boston wholesalers for all the eggs needed during the season. The managers were well pleased with the arrangements as they evidently were obtaining a satisfactory supply. Another hotel manager refused to make such ar- rangements for fear of getting cold storage eggs. Egg Prices Egg prices paid by the hotels are compared with the same day's high- est wholesale quotation for nearby hennery brown extras as given in the Boston Produce Market Report. These prices are presented in Table 4 and Figure 3. There is a wide range in prices. Local eggs were purchased by three hotels. One paid the same price for local shipped-in eggs, which equaled the highest market quotation ; another paid one cent over quotations, and the third paid seven cents under quotations for eggs from nearby sources In each instance these eggs cames from a different collector. In the opinion of the stewards these eggs were resold as received from individual farmers; that is, they were not candled nor graded by the collector. The other low price of 42 cents a dozen was 6 cents below the quota- tion and was a contract price made with a Boston house. The white eggs which the stewards had described as "perfect" and giving splendid satis- faction were purchased for 46 and 47 cents a dozen, or 4 to 3 cents be- low quotations. 20 New Hampshire Experiment Station [Bulletin 241 Even though local eggs were bringing a ]:)rice equal to or above whole- sale quotations in several instances, the question still remains how much more the managers and stewards would be willing to pay for local fresh eggs, if they were candled and graded according to definite standards. Many poultrymen in the southern part of the state are not over-anxious to sell to the hotels because they have such a good retail market near by. Although the stewards occasionally pay a premium over the wholesale market which makes a price nearly equal to retail, apparently it has not been sufficient to attract the egg shippers from the southern sections. Dressed Poultry Demand Detailed information was obtained from the stewards regarding their preferences for broilers, roasters and fowl, the weekly amounts used and prices paid. These data are partly given in Tables 5, 6, and 7 respective- ly. The amounts of broilers used weekly by a hotel varied from 50 to 672 pounds, roasters from 75 to 400 pounds and fowl from 100 to 700 pounds. These figures represent the maximum weekly amounts needed by the hotels when at full capacity. The points emphasized by the stewards as necessary to satisfy the de- mands of the best White Mountain hotels for dressed poultry may be grouped in the following order : Milk fed birds Light colored heavy breeds Fresh, properly killed and dressed Uniformly graded as to size, color and other qualifications Neatly packed Dependable service Milk fed poultry was desired in preference to any other. The stewards claimed the quality of the flesh was much superior ; that the fat was more evenly distributed throughout the muscle fibers which caused the flesh Table 5. — Broilers: Maximum amounts used in a week and prices paid by ten rep- resentative White Mountain hotels. 1. 2. 3.' 4. 5. 6. Pounds used B roller Prices per pound Hotel Date of Price Paid *\Vholesale in a week Purchase To local To Boston Quotation source source A 100 July 28, 1928 .37 t37 B 110 " 30 .40 .36 C SO Aug. 1 .35 .37 D 400 7 .40 .37 E 275 8 .42 .37 F 400 8 .55 .37 G 189 9 .45 .37 H 180 " 10 .41 .37 I 140 " 21 .42 .38 J 672 " 22 .41 .38 *Boston Produce Market News: Top price for Western fresh broilers, dry packed, 12 to box, 21 to 24 pounds. (Express charges from Boston to hotels of approximately $1.15 a hundred pounds should be added to Boston quotations to have prices on compar- able basis with local.) Ml a\', ) ")| Demand for X'kgetables and Poui-try 21 Table 6. — Fowl: Maximum amounts used in a tveek and prices paid by ten rep- resentative If kite Mountain hotels. Fowl Prices per pound Hotel PouikIs used in a week Date of Purchase Price Paid ♦Wholesale Quotation To local To Boston source shipper A 150 1 Ti ilv 25. 1928 .33 $.32 l\ 500 1 • 30 .34 .32 C 100 ! A ug. 1 .32 .32 .32 D 600 1 ' 7 .34 .33 E 200 i ' 8 .35 .33 F 1 50 i ' 8 .35 .33 G 720 1 ' 9 .34 .33 H 400 1 ' 10 .32 .33 I 216 1 ' 21 .36 .36 .34 J 400 1 ' 22 .36 .34 *Boston Produce Market News: Top price, Western fresh killed, clr\- packed, 12 to box, 60 to 65 pounds. (Express charges from Boston to hotels of approximately $1.15 a hundred pounds should be added to Boston quotations to have prices on compara- ble basis with local.; Table 7. — Roasters: Maximum amounts used in a week and prices paid by ten rep- resentative W kite Mountain hotels. Pounds used in a week Roaster Prices per pound Hotel Date of Purchase Price Paid ^Wholesale Quotation To local To Boston source source A 300 July 25. 1928 .46 $.44t B 85 •• 30 .38 .44t C 75 Aug. 1 .40 .40 .50t D 360 / .43 .50t E 400 8 .38 .50t F 150 8 .50 .sot G 192 9 .50 .50+ H 280 " 10 .43 .50t I 216 " 21 .55 .55 .50+ J None ♦Boston Produce Alarket News: fTop price for Western fresh frozen; ^Native fresh killed. (Express charges from Boston to hotels of approxiniateh- $1.15 a hundred pounds should be added to Boston quotations to have prices on compara- ble basis with local.) of the bird to be tender, juicy and of splendid flavor. Complaints were made of local dressed poultry that it was stringy, tough, aiid not adapted to their needs. Further investigation showed that these men had not confined their poultry previous to killing nor fed it on milk rations so that the meat would be in condition to suit the hotel demand. Usually the birds were killed without any previous conditioning. Needless to say these men failed to obtain repeat orders. Broilers from the light colored breeds were desired in the majority of cases. Some of the stewards and chefs were emphatic on this point. They claimed the white feathered broilers were more attractive in ap- pearance when served than the dark feathered, because with the latter the 22 New Hampshire Experiment Station [Bulletin 241 ZZ 21 10 8 8 30 > '25 IfgW///^// ._l^ ¥MM «,^ 'M illlllllll If #MM#W^ '(' ■ ■■■■H ifeMMMM mm mm ■ i^M //////////////^^^^^^^^^ 'M^M m//M/, Ti 'Mm mm, ' ivmm l^w ■ jImm PM iimi 1 \\ 1928 §//////////, m ^ Hotel P RICE ipn m I Wholesal E Quo. 0 30 35 40 45 Cents per Lb. 50 55 Fig. 4 — Prices paid by the hotels for dressed broilers on day visited. These prices averaged above the quotations given in the Boston Produce Market Report on the same day. The highest price, 55c. a pound on August 8, and the lowest price, 35c. a pound on August 1, re- ported by Hotels F and C respectively, were for local grown and dressed broilers. (See Table 5) May, 1929] Demand for Vegetables and Poultry 23 dark pin feathers and pigment in the feather folHcles were more visible However, this color preference was not made for fowl or roasters as both classes are cooked and served differently, so that the color factor is not so noticeable. Dressed poultry was preferred from those breeds which have coarse muscle fibers and relatively less connective tissue because they give a more tender flesh. Comparisons of cross-sections of meat representative of White Leghorns, Barred Plymouth Rocks and Buff Orpingtons show White Leghorns to have the smallest amount of muscle fiber and largest amount of connective tissue ; whereas with Buff Orpingtons the reverse was true. Barred Plymouth Rocks belonged in the class intermediate between the other two ; Rhode Island Reds are in the nomenclature of Barred Plymouth Rocks, or other general purpose breeds.* Dressed Poultry Prices Since it was impossible to visit all the hotels at one time the prices re- ceived are scattered over a period from July 25 to August 22. In order to present these prices on a comparable basis, the highest wholesale quota- tions given for boxed western fresh broilers, western fresh frozen and native fresh-killed roasters and for western fresh-killed fowl in the Bos- ton Produce Market Report were used along with the top prices reported paid by the hotels on the same day. See Tables 5, 6, and 7. A wide range of prices results between hotels on the same day which would in- dicate that dressed poultry is being purchased of varying quality. The greatest range occurs with broilers and the smallest with roasters and fowl. During the second week of August prices paid for broilers varied from 40 to 55 cents a pound. It is important to note that the highest price, 55 cents a pound on August 8. and the lowest pri^e. 35 c^nts a pound on August 1, reported by hotels F and C respectively were for local grown and dressed broilers. These data are shown to better advantage in Figure 4. There was less difference in the prices paid for fowl than for broilers or roasters. The lowest price paid for local lowl, 32 ( ents a pound, equal- led the quotation on that day. The highest price, 36 cents a pound, was also paid for local fowl and was 2 cents over quotations. In the case of roasters, the lowest price, 38 cents a pound, was p^'id by Hotel E for local dressed roasters. This price is 12 cents a pound be ow the market quota- tion of native fresh killed stock. On the other hand the price reported by Hotel C of 40 cents a pound for local dressed roasters and also for roast- ers from sources in Boston, is 10 cents below the highest market quotation for th? Fpm? dav. There are s°^■eral i^:stancrs wh^e the hotels have re- ported prices 7 cents a pound below wholesale quotations when buying in Boston. It is doubtful if roasters purchased so much below the market are enual in ouality to those represented in the quotation. Hotel I paid 55 cents a pound for roasters to local men and to Boston houses, which is 5 cents over the market quotation. ♦Marketintj Pouhry Products — Benjamin,. E. W. page 89. John Wiley and Sons, Inc. 24 New Hampshire Experiment Station [Bulletin 241 ( )n the whole, it would seem that the market for dressed poultry is availahle for local men at a premium price when they actually satisfy the demand. Possibilities of Development Every year more local men in the summer hotel section are dressing poultry and are not only marketing to large hotels on a wholesale basis but are doing more retail selling. Several stewards stated that they were able to purchase more local dressed poultry now than ever before. This was more true in regard to fowl than broilers because the former class was used for fricasse purposes which do not require as rigid attention to grading as do broilers. A number of local poultrymen were visited and questioned as to their future intentions. One man stated that he expected to put in a re- frigerator the following year so as to be able to supply a number of the large hotels with dressed poultry in his immediate section. Others were planning to increase their business. However, many of the men were frank enough to admit they could not afiford to dress poultry and sell at wholesale prices. These remarks were usually the result of costly ex- perience in attempting to dry-pick and dress poultry after approved methods. They were not made by those who had become proficient and reduced such costs to a minimum. In order to test out the possibility of supplying from sources within the state, arrangements were made with three hotels to receive trial ship- ments of dressed broilers. The briolers were supplied by R. B. Thurrell of East Wolfeboro. A. W. Lohman of the Poultry Department had charge of the dressing and packing. All of the broilers were full-feather- ed and well-meated birds, weighing around 2^4 pounds alive. After dressing, wrapping heads, and packing one dozen broilers in a box, the net weight varied from 22^ pounds to 23^4 pounds per box. These boxes were placed immediately in a refrigerator and held at approximately 35° until thoroughly chilled. The broilers were inspected on arrival by the stewards. Two ship- ments gave complete satisfaction. One steward volunteered to pay two cents premium per pound over the Boston wholesale price if he could get this quality of broilers regularly throughout the season. The success of these few shipments and other instances cited does not mean that New Hampshire poultrymen can profitably supply the White Mountain hotels on a large scale. The investigation has shown it is necessary that all dressed poultry be carefully graded as to class, weight and quality ; also, that only the best grades are wanted by the hotel trade. Any future development would have to compete with the fresh killed poultry from the Middle West. Many of these packing houses are ac- customed to making fifty grades of dressed poultry at one time.* One company which operates many plants where one to three thousand head are dressed daily rei^orts average operating costs as $3.57 per cwt. of dressed poultry. Distribution of these costs are as follows : Supplies $.69; labor $1.50; fixed expense $.13; other expense $1.25. *Marketing Poultry Products — Benjamin, E. W. — Page 116 May, 1929] Demand for Vegetables and Poultry 25 At the present time, there is a small dressing and packing plant in the central part of the state doing retail and wholesale selling and operat- ing all the year round. Live poultry is purchased at the plant 1 cent under the Boston wholesale quotation. Even though this plant has been operating several years it has experienced difficulty in finding sufficient poultry to supply its regular trade. A specialty is made of dressed fowl and roasters. Broilers are seldom handled because of the extra expense. The proprietor stated he could not afiford to dress and sell broilers be- cause of western competition. It is still a matter of conjecture whether a large dressing plant could operate profitably all the year round ; it is quite certain it would be im- possible on a 3 or 4 months basis. Undoubtedly a large volume would make storing and distributing services more satisfactory. Furthermore, New Hampshire poultry men have the definite advantage of being on the ground and securing any premium which the hotels are willing to pay. SUMMARY 1. A survey was made of ten White IMountain summer hotels in 1928 to learn the demand for vegetables, eggs, and dressed poultry. 2. The investigation shows the hotel demand is very exacting and re- quires products of the highest quality during a three months period. 3. The hotels require a dependable source of suppHes. In the past the local men who did not appreciate this necessity failed to develop the hotel market. 4. The hotel managements expressed a willingness to purchase local products when they are graded satisfactorily and priced in accord- ance with wholesale prices on the terminal markets because local products are fresher, more palatable and there is less waste. In general the prices paid by the hotels are above the highest wholesale quotations due to the better quality of products required. 5. Often local products have been so much superior to those shipped from outside sources that they have brought a premium. This is especially true for beets, carrots, green peas, head lettuce and spinach. 6. Vegetables are desired which equal at least the requirements of U. S. No. 1 and in many instances of U. S. Fancy grade. 7. Seasonal contracts for vegetable supplies were mutually beneficial to the hotels and local grower. 8. There are instances where local growers are successful and are in- creasing their acreage and volume of business yearly. Hotel gardens are being discontinued as local growers increase their busi- ness. Several sections are so well cared for by established growers that there is not room for others. However, there are sections where ample opportunities exist for further development. 9. Figures are not available as to cost of production and net profit in the growing of vegetables, and it will be necessary to make further investigation and study cost factors and adaptability to climatic conditions before general recommendations can be made. 10. Demand preferences were about equal as to color of eggs. 26 New Hampshire Experiment Station [Bulletin 241 11. Eggs are desired of the best quality for frying, poaching and boil- ing; those of a lower grade are used for cooking and baking. 12. Yolks of uniform color are required in eggs used for frying. 13. Complaints were made that eggs from local sources were neither candled nor graded. 14. A brand of eggs coming from sources outside the state is giving entire satisfaction. These eggs are graded according to definite standards. 15. Prices paid for eggs by the hotels were above and below Boston wholesale quotations. 16. Local egg prices ranged from the lowest to the highest prices paid. 17. Many local producers are not endeavoring to furnish the large hotels with eggs because they are able to sell them elsewhere on a retail basis. 18. In general, dressed poultry which has been milkfed, freshly killed, dry-picked and uniformly graded as to size and quality, and neatly packed is required by the hotels. 19. Poultry meat was preferred from the heavy breeds because, with relatively more muscle fiber and less connective tissue, they have a more tender fiesh. 20. Broilers are desired from the white feathered heavy breeds because the white pin feathers and hair follicles do not detract from their appearance when served. 21. The local dressed poultry does not equal in quality and appearance the boxed and fresh dressed poultry which is shipped in from out- side sources. 22. A large percentage of fowl is purchased locally because it is used for fricasse purposes and does not require as rigid grading as broilers or roasters to satisfy the demand. 23. Prices paid for dressed poultry vary a great deal showing products of unequal quality are used. 24. Due to the variance of opinions shown by the stewards, any prospec- tive producer should learn the demand preferences of each hotel. - PAS 630i72 nOiaOG 350