.^ /h CAUFQRNIA nsH 97858 STATE OF CALIFORNIA DEPARTMENT OF NATURAL RESOURCES DIVISION OF FISH AND GAME San Francisco, California CULBERT L. OLSON GOVERNOR RICHARD SACHSE DIRECTOR OP NATURAL RESOURCES FISH AND GAME COMMISSION NATE MILNOR, President Los Angeles GERMAIN BULCKE, Commissioner San Francisco EDWIN L. CARTY, Commissioner Oxnard W. B. WILLIAMS, Commissioner Alturas LEE F. PAYNE, Commissioner Los Angeles GEORGE P. MILLER, Executive Secretary San Francisco BUREAU OF FISH CONSERVATION A. C. TAFT, Chief San Francisco A. E. Burghduff, Supervisor of Fish Hatcheries San Francisco Brian Curtis, Supervising Fisheries Biologist San Francisco L. Phillips, Hatchery Inspector San Francisco Earl Leitritz, Superintendent Mt. Shasta Hatchery Mt. Shasta Geo. McCloud, Superintendent Mt. Whitney Hatchery Independence D. A. Clanton, Superintendent Forest Home Hatchery Forest Home J. C. Lewis, Superintendent Tahoe Hatchery Tahoe Ed Clessen, Foreman Fort Seward Hatchery Alderpoint William Berrian, Foreman Fall Creek Hatchery Copco Archie Thompson, Foreman Yosemite Hatchery Tosemite John Marshall, Foreman Feather River Hatchery Clio R. A. McCloud, Foreman Kaweah Hatchery Three Rivers Donald Evins, Foreman Lake Almanor Hatchery Westwood H. E. Cole, Foreman Basin Creek Hatchery Tuolumne Peter Topp, Foreman Burney Creek Hatchery Burney C. L. Frame, Foreman Kings River Hatchery Fresno Harold Hewitt, Foreman Prairie Creek Hatchery Orick J. L Stinnett, Foreman Brookdale Hatchery Brookdale G. C. Tabler, Fish Hatchery Man, Yuba River Hatchery Camptonville Clarence Chansler, Fish Hatchery Man, Madera Hatchery Madera R. C. Lewis, Foreman Hot Creek Hatchery Bishop A. N. Culver, Fish Hatchery Man, Kern Hatchery Kernville Allan Pollitt, Foreman Special Duty San Francisco Joseph Wales, Biological Surveyor Mt. Shasta Leo Shapovalov, Senior Fisheries Biologist Stanford University William Dill, Senior Fisheries Biologist Fresno Elden H. Vestal, Junior Fisheries Biologist June Lake E. R. Varnum, Fish Hatchery Construction Estimator San Francisco BUREAU OF GAME CONSERVATION J. S. HUNTER, Chief San Francisco Gordon H. True, Jr., In charge, Pittman-Robertson Project San Francisco Donald D. McLean, Economic Biologist San Francisco Frank Richardson, Junior Economic Biologist Chino Roy M. Wattenbarger, Supervisor Los Banos Refuge Los Banos L. H. Cloyd, Supervisor Gray Lodge Refuge Gridley Russell M. Reedy, Supervisor Imperial Refuge Calipatria Ralph R. Noble, Supervisor Suisun Refuge Joice Island Joe Vlasnik, Jr., Supervisor Elk Refuge Tupman John R. Wallace, In Charge, Predatory Animal Control San Francisco Asa L. Brown, Supervising Trapper Standish John L. McDonald, Supervising Trapper Weaverville O. R, Shaw, Supervising Trapper .Springville BUREAU OF GAME FARMS AUGUST BADE, Chief YountvlUe E. D. Piatt, Superintendent Los Serranos Game Farm Chino C. Van Ornum, Superintendent Yountville Game Farm Yountville BUREAU OF MARINE FISHERIES RICHARD VAN CLEVE, Chief San Francisco S. H. Dado, Assistant Chief San Francisco H. B. Nidever, Field Inspector San Francisco CALIFORNIA STATE FISHERIES LABORATORY W. L. Scofield, Supervising Fisheries Researcher Terminal Island G. H. Clark, Supervising Fisheries Researcher San Francisco Frances N. Clark, Senior Fisheries Researcher Terminal Island Harry C. Godsil, Senior Fisheries Researcher San Diego Donald H. Fry, Jr., Senior Fisheries Researcher Terminal Island Richard S. Croker, Senior Fisheries Researcher Terminal Island J. B. Phillips, Senior Fisheries Researcher Pacific Grove Paul Bonnot, Senior Fisheries Researcher Stanford University S. Ross Hatton, Senior Fisheries Researcher Stanford University John F. Janssen, Jr., Senior Fisheries Researcher Terminal Island Geraldine Conner, Fisheries Statistician Terminal Island California Fish and Game "CONSERVATION OF WILDLIFE THROUGH EDUCATION" Volume 27 SAN FRANCISCO, APRIL, 1941 Number 2 TABLE OF CONTENTS Page The Feeding Habits of California Garter Snakes— Henry S. Fitch 2 Valley Quail Census Methods and Populations at the San Joaquin Experimental Range Ben Glading 33 "N. B. Scofield": Progress Report for 1940 H. C. Godsil 39 First Record of the Hybrid Flounder, Inopsetta ischyra, from Cali- fornia Earl Stannard Herald 44 Editorials and Notes Twenty-five Years Ago in "California Fish and Game" Richard S. Croker 47 Results of the 1940 Pismo Clam Census Phil M. Boedel 48 Black Brant in Lower California, February, 1941 Phil M. Roedel 49 Reviews California's Natural Wealth : A Conservation Guide for Second- ary Schools Richard S. Croker 50 Fishing the Surf Richard S. Croker 51 California Fish and Game is a publication devoted to the conservation of wild- life. It is published quarterly by the California Division of Fish and Game. All material for publication should be sent to Richard S. Croker. editor, California Division of Fish and Game, Terminal Island, California. The articles published herein are not copyrighted and may be reproduced in other periodicals, provided due credit is given the California Division of Fish and Game. Editors of newspapers and periodicals are invited to make use of pertinent material. 9785S THE FEEDING HABITS OF CALIFORNIA GARTER SNAKES ' By Henry S. Fitch U. S. Fish and Wildlife Service O'Neals, California INTRODUCTION The garter snakes are among the most abundant and generally distributed of any California snakes, and hence are of considerable economic importance. Like any other common and widely distributed animal species, they necessarily have diverse ecologic interrelationships which cause them to affect man's varying interests both adversely and favorably. The several kinds differ from each other, greatly in some instances, in their feeding habits, so that each must be appraised separately in any study of economic status. The feeding habits have most direct bearing on man's interest. The present report is con- cerned with the feeding habits of the kinds of garter snakes which occur in California, except that one species, Thamnophis marciamis, is not included. No data concerning its feeding habits are available, and it is unimportant because of the limited area it inhabits within the State. Its California distribution originally was restricted to the Colorado River, but recently it has spread westward along irrigation canals into Imperial Valley. (Klauber, 1939, p. 22.) Garter snakes are predatory in their habits and take small animals of many kinds. The prey includes only such animals as can be caught, overpowered, and swallowed whole. Most often the prey is swallowed alive ; rarely it may be killed by constriction, as observed by the writer in the case of a mouse attacked by a captive individual. Garter snakes rely upon the sense of smell as well as upon sight to find their prey, and will usually eat any freshly killed animals of the kinds which comprise their natural foods. It is not known how much an individual snake normally eats under natural conditions. They are able to fast for periods of weeks or even months, but probably feed at intervals of a few days, or even oftener during warm weather when food is abun- dant. The food requirement varies according to temperature; in cold weather metabolism is slowed down so that but little food is required. During the three to six months of hibernation these snakes take no food. Garter snakes are of especial interest as destroyers of fish. They occasionally attain great abundance along trout streams, and instances of garter snake predation on trout are known to many anglers. From the following account it Avill be evident that only certain kinds, which 1 Submitted for publication, July, 1940. Published by permission of the U. S. Pish and Wildlife Service. (2) FEEDING IIAMITS OF CALIFORNIA GARTER SNAKES 6 are easily recoo:nizable, prey 111)011 trout or other game fishes. Other kinds, just as abundant and widely distributed, seldom or never eat fish, but feed in whole or in i»;irt on animals whieli nvo jronerally con- sidered harmful. In California the garter snakes are the only snakes which tend to be aciuatic in habits, and the group includes all of the kinds popularly known as "water snakes" within the boundaries of this State. The data herein presented are much too fragmentary to furnish a complete picture of the feeding habits of garter snakes in California. For some kinds only a few feeding records are available and these may not be typical. Probably an even greater variety of food is utilized than is indicated by the records here compiled. Nevertheless, these records extend throughout most of the ranges, being well scat- tered over a very large area and representing all seasons during which the snakes are active. They may, therefore, be expected to yield a fairly reliable idea of the kinds of food in general used by those kinds of California garter snakes which are common and widely distributed. Acknowledgments This study of the food habits w^as carried on in the field and at the University of California Museum of Vertebrate Zoology, and the writer is indebted to the late Dr. Joseph Grinnell, Director of the Museum, for help in many ways. The writer is, likewise, indebted to members of the Museum staff and to many of the graduate students in the Museum for cooperation and assistance in the pursuit of this study. Dr. Jean M. Linsdale and Mr. Thomas L. Rodgers are due especial thanks. Specimens used were borrowed from the California Academy of Sciences, the University of IMichigan Museum of Zoology and the San Diego Society of Natural History. For use of these collections the writer wishes to thank Mr. Joseph R. Slevin, Dr. Helen T. Gaige and yiv. Laurence M. Klauber. CLASSIFICATION AND DISTRIBUTION The garter snakes are members of the family Colubridae, which includes the majority of nonpoisonous snakes, and of the cosmopolitan subfamily Natricinae, or water snake group, characterized by aquatic tendencies, keeled (ridged) scales, enlarged anal glands which produce a characteristically foul-smelling secretion (often serving to repel attacking predators) and simple, unbranched hemipenes (the paired copulatory organs of the males), which are set with rows of spines. The genus Thamnophis, the garter snake group, is entirely North American and Central American in its range, occurring northward farther than any other reptiles in this hemisphere. All the garter snakes are, of course, nonpoisonous. Members of the genus in general tend to be aquatic in their habits. Most of them have a light dorsal stripe and two lateral stripes on a darker ground color. They differ from closely related water snakes (genus Natrix) in having the anal plate (the enlarged ventral scale just anterior to the anus) undivided. There are five major groups of garter snakes, each comprising a series of closely related species and subspecies. Only two of these major groups are represented in California; Thamnophis sirtalis, represent- 2 — 97858 CALIFORNIA FISH AND GAME Fig. 22. Important structural features of a garter snake as seen from dorsal, ventral and lateral views of head, and ventral view at posterior end of body. A — anal plate ; D — dorsal stripe ; DA — dorsolateral area ; F — anterior genial ; G — gastrosteges, numbered to show method of counting ; H — posterior genial ; I — infralaljials, numliered to show method of countin,g ; L — lateral stripe ; S — supralabials, numliered to show method of counting; SIl — scale rows, numbered to show method of counting diagonally across body; U — urostege. FEEDING IIARITS OF CAT.IFORNTA GARTER SNAKES 5 \ng one group in California, occurs also throughout most of the United States. The ThaDiiiopJiis nrdinoidcs group is confined to the region west of the (ireat I'laius, and attains its greatest abundance and diversi- ficalion within tlie California Fanna. The Californian lorius ordinoidcs, hiscutatus, atraius, hydrophda, conchii, gigas, haniniondii, elcgans, and vugnDtfi are all members of this group. Key to the Garter Snakes of California In the following key attempt has been made to furnish brief diagnoses which will serve to identify specimens. If carefully used, this key should eiud)le one to identify most specimens, but every one of the characters used in it is subject to both individual and geographic variation. Hence, a nontypical individual of one form may be run down to another form in the key. In the accounts of species and sub- species, a detailed statement of the geographic range of each form is given. The statement of range should be consulted to check ideutifica- 1 ion of specimens run down in the key. 1. Lateral stripe on anterior part of body confined to third scale row Marcy's Garter Snake (Thamnophis marcidnu.t) v. Lateral stripe on second and third scale rows 2 2. Seven pairs of suprnlnliial (or npper lip) scales 3 2'. Eight pairs of supralal)ial scales 5 3. Gastrosteges (large ventral scales of body) more than 153; posterior gonials (chin scales) markedly longer than those of anterior pair; bright rod markings but no pale flecks on dorsolateral area Common Garter Snake {Thamnophis slrtalis) 3'. Gastrosteges fewer than 153 ; dorsal stripe red or yellow ; pale yellowish flecks on skin between scales (see Fig. 23B) in area between dorsal and lateral stripes 4 4. Dorsal stripe bright yellow Coast Garter Snake {Thamnophis ordinoides atratus) 4'. Dorsal stripe red Red-striped Garter Snake {Thamnophis ordinoides ordinoides) 5. Dorsal stripe bright yellow 6 5'. Dorsal stripe al)sent. faint, or discontinuous 8 6. Preocular (the scale in front of the eye) often divided on one or both sides ; scale rows 21, 22 or 23, when counted across body at a point one- third of distance from head back to anus Klamath Garter Snake {Thamnophis ordinoides hiscufatiis) 6'. Preocular not divided on eithm- side ; scale rows 1!), 20 or 21 when counted across body at a point one-third of distance from head back to anus 7 7. Hed markings often pi-esent on sides or on ventral sui-faee ; lateral sti-ipe sometimes red; iris often uniformly colored, clear gray; head narrower Coast Garter Snake {Thamnophis ordinoides airatus) T. No red in coloration ; iris dark brown with narrow yellow margin around pupil ; head wide and swollen Mountain Garter Snake {Thamnophis ordinoides elegans) 8. Doi-sal stripe absent Southern California (barter Snake {Thamnophis hammondii) 8'. Dorsal stripe present but often faint and confined to anterior part of body 9 9. Scale rows 23 or 22 when counted across body at a point one-third of dis- tance from head back to anus; size often very large (over three feet) Giant Garter Snake {Thamnophis ordinoides glgas) W. Scale rows 21, 20 or 19 when counted across body at a point one-third of distance from head back to anus; size smaller (seldom as much as three feet) 10 10. Dorsal stripe distinct for full length of body, faint, irregular, invaded by small rounded black spots ; ground color pale brown ; iris dark brown with naiTOW yellow rim around pupil Wandering Garter Snake {Thamnophis ordinoides vagrans) 6 CALIFORNIA FISH AND GAME 10'. Dorsal stripe faint, usually oonfined to anterior part of Ixxly ; dorsal stripe and dursal surface cluM-kered with larjie s(iuarish markings alternating with paler areas; iris uniformly hmwu or gray 11 11. .Scale rows 21 both in neck rcgicu and across middle of body; dorsal stripe often confinefl to neck region Moccasin Garter Snake (Thamnophis ordiiioides couchli) 11'. Scale rows only 19, either across neck region or middle of body or both ; dorsal stripe discernible, at least on anierior half of Ixxly Oregon (Jray Garter Snake ( 'I'lKiiniiophis ordiitoides hydrophila) ACCOUNTS OF SPECIES AND SUBSPECIES In the following- acconnts, a diagnosis is given for each form con- sidered Avhicli will serve to distinguish it from all other kinds and a detailed statement of geographic range is made. Under the heading "habits" for each kind the general habitat preferences and manner of foraging are described, and, by way of illustration, specific instances are cited from published accounts, and from the field notes of the writer and other observers. Feeding records were obtained from an examina- tion of a few more than 3500 snakes ; 462 of these contained food, an aggregate of 945 items. Llost of the snake.s were museum specimens, and in many instances they may have been kept alive long enough after capture to digest any food in their stomaelis. Small food items may have been overlooked in some instances. The digestive tracts could not be examined with thoroughness because it was necessary to avoid mutilating the museum specimens used. Usually food items could be readily detected by the bulges which they caused in the snakes' con- tours, or they could be felt by manipulating the ventral surface of a specimen. To examine, or, if necessary, remove food items, small incisions were made through the body walls and stomachs of the snakes. In snakes, feeding is infrequent, as compared with that of most other kinds of animals, and those which have eaten recently tend to stay in hiding, whereas those with empty stomachs are more apt to be out foraging where they will be found by the collector. In many the stomach contents were so well digested that accurate identifications could not be made. All available feeding records are summarized in a table at the end of this paper. For most of the forms records are based on specimens taken in California or in the immediately adjacent poi-tions of Oregon, Nevada, and Lower California, but for the common garter snake and the red-striped garter snake some records from northern Oregon, Wa.sh- iii"ton, and British Columbia are also included, and for the wandering garter snake the records are mostly from outside of California, over its extensive range in the Great Basin and Rocky ^Mountain regions. Common Garter Snake {Thamnophis sirtalis subsp.) Diagnostic Characters Size large in adults (up to 4 feet) ; dorsal stripe bright yellow, 1 2/2 scale rows in width, its edges straight, and sharply defined; dorsal ground color jet black, or occasionally dark gray; top of head black, dark olive or red ; l)ody marked Avith two series of transverse irregular red marks, mainly confined to skin between scales; lateral stripe dull yellow, situated on second and third scale rows; first scale FEEDING HABITS OF CALIFORNIA GARTER SNAKES A. The moccasin garter snake. This (lark-colored snake is common along many streams of the Sierra Nevada. It feeds upon fish, tadpoles and other aquatic prey. H. Tlic mountain -arter snake. This lirightly striped snake resembles in pattern the coast garter snake and tlie common garter snake, and like them it finds most of its food out of the wa- ter, cither in dam|) streamside situa- tions or occasionally in dry places. ('. The wandering garter snake is char- acteristic of the Creat Basin region but extends west- ward into Califor- nia. It is general- ized in feeding hah- its and takes as prey ho til aciuatic and lerrestrial kinds of animals. I). The Oregon gray garter snake replaces tlie closely related moccasin garter snake in northwest- ern California. It differs from tlie moc- casin garter snake in iialer coloration and more distinct dorsal stripe hut re- semliles it in aquat- ic hahits. It feeds upon trout and other fish and upon tad- poles. Fig. 23 8 CALIFORNIA FISH AND GAME row dull, slig-litly darker than lateral stripe, or dusky or even jet black ; ventral surface yellowish gray, not marked with black, rarely reddish on under side of tail (in individuals which are exten.sively marked with red dorsally) ; supralabials in seven pairs, infralabials in 10 pairs; scales in 19 lonp'itudinal rows (thi.s count obtainable anywhere on anterior two-tliirds of body). Distribution Vicinity of permanent fresh water throuo'hout most of the State, but absent from desert regions of southeastern California, and reaches southern limit in extreme northwestern San Diego County. Appar- ently occurs east of the Sierra divide only as far south as the Carson River drainage, and is absent from many small, isolated drainage systems of the arid region east of the Sierra Nevada. Geographic Variation _ As indicated in the diagnosis, the characters of this species are variable. Variation is both individual and geographic in its nature, but tlie geographic variation is the more striking. Series of individuals collected at a given locality are often fairly uniform in appearance but may differ markedly from series collected elsewhere at remote localities. At least two subspecies are represented by the California populations of sirtaJis, but it is difficult to delimit their respective ranges because intergradation between them is gradual, extending over a large area. Thus most specimens are in a sense intergrades, intermediate between typical individuals of the different races. Variation occurs mainly in nund)ers of ventral scales on the body and tail and in the shade of the dorsal ground color, but the trends of variation in these characters are not entirely parallel. The numbers of ventral scales are smallest in snakes from the northern part of the State, and there is progressive increase in snakes taken farther south. In the coastal region these snakes have paler ground colors, gray rather than black, with red or reddish-gray heads. Series from tlie San Joaquin Valley and the Sierra Nevada are of darker color but often have brown rather than black heads. Those from the northeastei-n part of the State have the top of the head and the dorsolateral ground color ,jet black. The differences between the supposed subspecies of sirtalis are minor ones as compared with those separating the members of the ordwoides complex. There is no evidence that these geographic differ- ences in color and scale numbers are paralleled by geographic dif- ferences in habits. Everywhere in California \hnt' sirtalis occurs its habits are much the same, unlike ordrnoides, whose geographic popula- tions have diverged in habits in adaptation to their various environ- ments. Habits The common garter snake is generalized in its feeding habits and apt to prey upon any small vertebrates which it can find and over- poAver. Individually these snakes are aggressive and voracious. In habitat preference the species is primarily a swamp snake, and is most abundant on low wet ground where there is dense vegetation. Along the margins of sloughs, along slow-moving watercourses, and in lush meadows along small coastal streams, it occurs in abundance seldom FEEDINO HABITS OV CALIFORNIA GARTER SNAKES V attained elsewhere by snake populations in our western states. It is an excellent swimmer, and may take to the water in eseapinj^r its enemies. It can dive and hide under water, but it is more apt to swim on the surface. It occasionally forages under water in small stag-nant pools, but it is not apt to forage in swift water as do some other kinds, notably tlie moccasin garter snake and Oregon gray garter snake. In June a few miles south of Eugene, Lane County, Oregon, these snakes were found in abundance along a nearly dry creek bed with stagnant pools. They were crawling and swimming through the shal- low water, apparently in pursuit of abimdant tree-toad tadpoles, but quickly left the water and escaped into high grass as the observer approached each pool. Late in July the writer observed these snakes along the course of Cottonwood Creek, Siskiyou County, California, a few miles from Hornbrook. At that time the creek had ceased flowing and water was confined to isolated pools along the sandy stream bed, which was densely .shaded by willow, nettle and other riparian growth. The drying pools were teeming with small fish. In nearl.y every pool which the observer approached, one or several snakes w^ere seen crawling or swimming about through the shallow water in pursuit of the trapped fish. T^sually tliey saw the observer while he was still several yards away, and then darted out of the water into nearby thickets. Several which were caught regurgitated fish which they had recently eaten. Although both the mountain garter snake and the Oregon gray garter snake w'ere known to occur in that general region, none could be found in this locality where habitat conditions were apparently unusually favorable for the common garter snake. A captive individual repeatedly attacked an adult newt {Triturus grannJosiis) in a pool in its cage, but the noxious dermal secretion of the newt each time caused the snake to drop it. At Prairie Creek Redwoods State Park, Humboldt County, Cali- fornia, these snakes were found in abundance in high grass at the edges of small meadows adjoining redwood forests. One of those caught had eaten an adult marbled salamander; another had eaten a red salamander (Enmtina cschscholtsii). They were difficult to cap- ture or follow since they darted rapidly through the concealing grass. These and other predation records as sunnnarized at the end of this paper- show the general trend of food preferences in this kind of snake. In keeping with its marshland habitat it seems to be mainly an amphibian feeder. The amphibians taken include AellowJegged find red-legged frogs, the introduced bullfi-og, the toad, tree toad, the red salamander and the marbled salauumder; apparently all these species are taken according to theii- local availability rather than through any definite jn-eference on the part of the snake. Among invertebrates, the slugs, earthworms aiul leeches are favorite foods. Several kinds of fisli ai-e included in the diet. No definite instance of the common garter snake ever having eaten trout is known to the writer. It is probable, however, that at times small trout are taken when they are crowded into small stagnant pools along drying water- cour.ses. Under such cii'cumstances, the trapped fish are not apt to survive and the snake predation can not be considered a serious factor 10 CALIFORNIA FISH AND GAME in reduc'inji' tlio siipplx' of lisli wliidi wdiiM otherwise be available to fishermen. Since sirtalis iloes not (irdinjirilx- foraji'e in swift water, it is not apt (o eateh trout under normal river p'orji'e al)ove the mouth of Spencer Creek and alon^' tlie lower portion of tlie creek's course, 30 were seen. The 'e is narrow and boulder-strewn. All the Klamatli garter snakes seen were in rocky situations and most of them were on boulders within ei.ulit feet of tlie river's ed^jre. Eleveii common garter snakes seen in the same general locality were all in grassy situations or in parts of the creek adjoining meadow habitat. On -July 4, 1934, near Adel, Tjake County, Oregon, seven were soon ill the rocky canyon of Doej) Creek, ^^•here they were found on bouklers at the edge of the water or crawling among submerged rocks in the swift current. When alarmed they attempted to escape by diving and liiding beneath rocks under water. On the same day, at the Sprague River near Beatty, Klamath County, Oregon, four were col- lected along the river, there flowing through an open, level valley, and bordered with thickets of willow and cottonwood. All were found in grass about 100 feet from the stream; two were coiled under a heavy timber, the others were on marshy ground near a willow thicket. This evidence seems to show that the Klamatli garter snake is, in general, confined to the immediate vieinitj^ of permanent streams, an ecologic restriction imposed upon it by the generally arid and inhos- l)itable character of the region it inhabits. It is also largely confined to portions of watercourses which are rocky or boulder-strewn, and it avoids the extensive areas of marshland within its geographic range. It is mainly dependent on fish and adults and tadpoles of frogs for food. Trout and other kinds of game fishes may be eaten by it, but those fish identified in the stomachs examined included only sculpins. suckers and minnows, not valued bj- fishermen. Oregon Gray Garter Snake (TJiamnophis onlinoidcs hxjdrophila) Diagnostic Characters Size medium (usually between 17 and 32 inches in adults) ; dorsal stripe dull yellow, indistinct, or sometimes entirely absent, not sharply set off from bluish gray or brownish gray dorsolateral area, Avliieh has a checkered pattern of two rows of alternately placed black blotches on each side; chin white; lateral stripe dull, grayish yellow, or absent; iris pale, uniformly grayish or brownish; scale rows on body 19 or less frequently 21 (one or the other of these counts obtain- able anywhere on anterior tAvo-thirds of body) ; sujn-alabials in eight pairs; infralabials in ten pairs; ventral surface immaculate or nearly so, pale with pinkish or purplish suffusion posteriorly. Distribution Drainages of the Umpqua and Kogue rivers in southwestern Ore- gon, and of the Smith, Klamath, Mad, Eel, Mattole, Garcia, Noyo and Russian rivers in California; also northwestern portion of Sacramento River drainage. Intergi-ades with the Klamath garter snake b}^ increase in size, increase in numbers of scale rows and ventral plates, and darken- ing of ground coloi- with accompanying brightening of stripes, along the upper Klamath River between the mouth of the Shasta River and the Oregon State line. Intergrades with the moccasin garter snake in the upper Sacramento Valley, by increase in size and in numbers of scale 14 CALIFORNIA FISH AND GAME rows and ventral plates, and dulling of stripes. A population with a bright yellow dorsal stripe and a dark ground color, somewhat resem- bling the mountain garter snake in sniHM-fieial appearance, occurs in Trinity and castci-ii .Mcndoi-ino counties, lu tliis region, the pale color of the iris and the narrow, elongate shape of the head serve to distin- guish this subspecies from the mountain garter snake. Habits The many records of stomach contents of the Oregon gray garter snake summarized at the end of this paper are supplemented by a con- sidei-able amount of evidence obtained from direct observation of the foraging. To illustrate the habitat preferences and general field behavior of these snakes, observations are recorded below for some of the localities where they were found in unusual abundance. On April 19, 1934, at Trail Creek, 16 were collected and about the same number escaped. None was more than two feet from the water; several were swimming when found but the majority were lying on rocks at the edge of the water or at midstream. A large one in the process of foraging was slowly feeling its way over and around sub- merged rocks. In escaping, some of the snakes dove and hid beneath rocks, but most of them swam to the opposite side of the creek and crawled out of the water to hide among rocks, piles of driftwood, and tangled roots. On July 27, when the locality was again visited, the snakes were nearly as abundant as before (21 collected), and all seen were in the water or within two feet of its edge. In attempting to escape they invariably dove and hid beneath rocks on the bottom; the water level had receded well below the piles of driftwood and riparian growth, which were no longer readily accessible for shelter, as they had been earlier in the season. On May 23, 1935, at Lobster Creek, Rogue River, one was caught as it was crawling into a brush fence at the edge of a plowed field about 75 feet from the creek. It contained a sculpin, and evidently had left the creek in order to find a sheltered spot where it could digest this food. Of the few others found on other occasions at similar distances from water, some, likewise, had aquatic prey in their stomachs and in every instance obviously were seeking shelter late in the day or immedi- ately preceding a storm. At the Sacramento River, seven miles north of Dunsmuir, Siskiyou County, in Juiu\ 1934, one, seen on rocks at the edge of the water, dove and escaped but later at the same place a splasliing sound revealed the presence of the snake struggling with a six-inch trout which it had caught. It was holding the fish by the throat so that the gill covers were held shut and circulation of water through the gills was pre- vented. The reptile was pushing the fish shoreward, apparently trying to slide it out of the water onto the rocks. At intervals the trout struggled vigorously and dragged its captor partly out into the cui-- rent. The snake was twisted over on its back and w^ould have been swept downstream but for the fact that its tail was securely wound among the rocks. It played the fish, using the same principle as a fisherman with rod and reel in allowing its body to yield somewhat to the fish's struggles, yet exerting constant pressure upon it. After FEEDING HABITS OF CALIFOKXIA GARTER SNAKES 15 about ten minutes the fisli appeared to be exliausted and its strn<]:jrles had nearly ceased. Then the snake worked its jaws aronnd the front of the tront's liead and coinnienced swallowing it. At Redwood Creek, TTnmboldt County, California, in -July, 1935, 25 were seen, all of them at the edge of the water, on rocks at mid- stream, or aotnally in the water. Tn eseapinir they almost invariably swam out into deep water and hid uiuler submerged rocks or swam into willow thickets overhanging the stream. A large one, cornered in a narrow inlet by the writer wading toward it from the middle of the stream, chose to dive between his legs rather than to seek shelter among boulders on shore. Another, found foraging, was feeling its way among pebbles beneath water 18 inches deep in the swift current of a riffle. Factors apparently favoring the abundance of these snakes at this locality were the large permanent stream of clear water and many large, still pools, shallow riffles, and pebbly beaches. Trout were abun- dant in the stream; yellow-legged frogs were common along the shore, and their tadpoles were swarming in the shallow water. On July 17, 1936, at the Mattole Eiver, Humboldt County. 25 were seen. One was standing on its tail in the middle of the stream, with only its head protruding above the surface. It drew back and hid beneath a submerged rock when approached. One, encountered swim- ming in the middle of a deep pool about 30 feet from shore, dove and swam along the bottom. The others were seen at the edge of the water. Those which succeeded in reaching the water almost alw^ays dove and hid among submerged rocks; some emerged after a few seconds and tried to hide among rocks on shore. In this locality the stream was 30 to 50 feet wide, with a rocky bed, wide pebbly beaches, extensive stretches of shallow water, and occasional deep pools. At Cobbs, Van Duzen River, Humboldt County, July 1, 1936, 19 were seen. One was found coiled under a rock at the edge of the water late in the afternoon; another w^as found in gravel five feet from the stream ; all the rest were found in the water or succeeded in reaching it before they could be caught. One escaped into a willow thicket after it swam across a pool. The snakes were scarce or entirely absent from extensive stretches of the stream where it was bordered by barren gravel deposits with no riparian growth. On June 29 and 30, 1936, along the south fork of the Eel River near Piercy, ^Mendocino County, 44 were seen. xVll were in the water when found or took to it in attemptino- to escape, except for one caught before it had time to dive from the boulder on which it was basking. The snakes seemed to avoid stretches of open sandy beaches but were especiallv common where there were shallow rocky pools along the shore. Trout and tadpoles of the yellow-legged frog were common there. At many other localities gray garter snakes w^ere found under somewhat similar conditions but in smaller numbers. At all places where they were found, these snakes were closely restricted to streams having rocky beds and a permanent flow of clear, swift water. They depeiid on water both as a place of refuge from danger and as a forag- ing place. Snakes of this kind seem to be restricted to the vicinity of streams where there are trees and bushes near the water, furnishing shade and ]6 CALIFORNIA FISH AND GAME shelter, but do not occur wliere the streams are continuously walled in by dense vegetation. Exposed rocks in niarjiinal streamside areas or at midstream, accessible for baskinji- places, seem to be an ecolo- -watei- aud usually to streams which are permanent thionshout the year. The moccasin •rarter snake intei-on fri-ay p-arter snake in the Sacramento Valley, and interjifades ^vitll the uiaut <>'arter snake alon^ the eastern edpe of the San Joa(|niii Valley. Tn the extreme northern part of its ranjie the moccasin crarter snake lias more ventral scales, has eleven pairs of infralabial scales, more distinct dorsal stripe, and more distinctly checkered ])attern. and ofteji has extensive black markinus on the ventral surface. All these characters underj?o j?radual change toward the southern part of the ranp:e, and in the trend of its charac- ters this subspecies approaches the southern Califoi'uia prarter snake, which occurs south of the Tehachapi Range. Habits At Lake Britton, Pit River, in Shasta County on a visit to the Burney Creek State Pish Platchery in ^May, 1934, I was told by the foreman that garter snakes of this kind were abundant in the vicinity and were a serious pest becau.se of their destruction of small fish. I was shown a preseiwed specimen killed in the act of sw^allowing a trout, and the foreman pointed out a rock pile just above high water mark where lie believed that a colony of the snakes hibernated, since they were numerous there in spring. In a letter to the late Dr. Joseph Grinnell, dated June 1, 1935, T. Tj. Ilussey of tlie California Division of F'ish and Game wrote of these snakes: "They are very plentiful along the headwaters of the Carson River and its tributaries, and take henYy toll of trout from these streams. They often invaded our hatchery at Markleeville and took fry from the troughs. One about 16 inches in length was caught by Mr. Tutt; upon opening: it he counted 21 fry from its stomach, which it had taken from a trough." At the San Joaquin Expei-imental Range in the dry foothill country of the digger pine belt, these snakes were found in an atypical habitat, for the streams where they occurred were transitory and dried up almost com])letely in spring or early summer. In the 1938 season, when observations were made, the first garter snake was found on March 22, but few were seen until mid-April. During the lattei- half of April, and continuously through May and early June, many Avere seen daily, and they could be found at almost any time by walking for a short distance along one of the small creeks. Nearly all those seen were along the edge of w^ater, but some were found in grass a hundred yards or more from water. Others were found at isolated pools, such as those in old wells or mine shafts, Avhere an abundant food supply of tadpoles was available. After the first week of June the snakes sud- denly A-anished just at tlic time when the streams were drying up. Throughout the remainder of June, July and August, only a few were seen in the locations Avhere they had been so abundant earlier in the season. Two reservoirs on the Range were tenanted all summer by a few which could be seen daily, but there were no concentrations in 18 CALIFORNIA FISH AND GAME these places. Tlie remainder of the population evidently underwent a sudden cessation of activity Avitli the (lisai)pearance of their habitat and food supply (certainly a normal seasonal occurrence there). The active season in this foothill locality is hence less than two months annually. Evidence that these snahes actually remain in the vicinity throug-jiout the year, and merely tend to keep under shelter duriufr the dry season, was furnislied by the feAV seen during the summer. One was seen in mid-July on one of the few cloudy days of the sunnner; at 5.30 p.m. it was emerp-inp: from a s(|uirrel burrow near the ed0 44 1936, Feb. 27... Mar. 4 3,600 1,637 68 24.0 0 45 1937, Feb. 24 : Mar. 2 3,600 2,123 99 21 4 0 59 1938, Mar. 9 3,600 1,545 86 17.9 0.43 Mar. 17 1939, Mar. 13 3,412 1,293 103 12.5 0 38 Mar. 17 1940,Mar. 6 3,412 873 90 9.7 0 26 Mar. 10 "New 1938, Mar. 18 1,078 1,248 424 586 36 52 11.7 11 2 0 39 Purchase Area- Mar. 22 1939, Mar. 18 0 47 Mar. 21 1940, Mar. 11 1,248 481 43 11.2 0 45 Mar. 12 • Estimated. *> Sample strip count covering only a fraction of the range was employed in 1935. 36 CALIFORNIA FISH AND GAME rate for the Range as a whole. Repeated checks on small areas have shoAVTi that the "horseback" method gives an accurate, usable count, and at the same time makes it possible to cover a relatively large area with a minimum of personnel. This method can only be employed satisfactorily where the cover is not too dense ; the general character of the topography and cover at the San Joaquin Experimental Range where it has been used is shown in figure 24. The horseback census is not applicable to areas of hea\'y brush or uniform, tall grass. It is particularly adapted to use with valley quail, because these birds have the habit of flushing or running when approached as close as 25 or 30 yards by a man on horseback. Use of a pointing dog for counting valley quail has been tried on sev- eral occasions over small areas, but without success. The "pointing dog" method is successful on other species of upland game which tend to "freeze," such as pheasants and bobwhite (Wight, 1930; Bennett and Hendrickson, 1938). The presence of a Cooper hawk in the vicinity of a covey will cause the quail to "freeze" and make it necessary to ride much closer to birds so frightened before they will flush. Concentrations of forag- ing Cooper hawks over a census area will result in observers missing many such "frozen" coveys. Five annual counts have been made by the "horseback" method. The results of all censuses are summarized in table 1.- Figure 26 illus- trates the distribution of covevs over the Range in 1939. - The services of a WPA employee in assisting in some of these counts is hereby acknowledged. ^ 5 < u a. I/) Q CD 1 \ \ • • •• •• • • • • \ \ \ \ • • • • «• • • • • • • • • • • • • \ * • •• • • • • • • • • • • * \ \ • • • • • • •• • • • • • • • • • • \ \ • • • • • • • • • • • • • • »• • • •• • • • • '35 '36 '37 '38 '39 '40 2.0 2.5 3.3 5.0 10.0 q: m a: Q. en u or O < Fig. 25. Population trends in the valley quail at the San Joaquin Experimental Range. The hatched bar represents the "sample strip" method counts made in 1935. The solid bars represent "horseback" method counts over the original Range ; and the dotted bars are "horseback"' method counts over the new purchase area. VALLEY QUAIL CENSUS METHODS 37 Just prior to the 1938 census, 1,078 acres of additional land were acquired to the north and west of the original Range. This area was counted immediately after the census of tlie original Range. In 1939, the construction of a new highway across the northwest corner of the original Range caused an area of roughly 170 acres from the original tract to be incorporated in the "new purchase," making the area to the north and west of the new road total 1,248 acres for the 1939 and 194:0 counts. In evaluating the census figures for the two areas, it should be borne in mind that the new purchase area had been hunted over to and Pig. 2(>. Map of San Joaquin ExperiniPntal Range, showing- location and size of coveys of valley riuail in iNIarch, IfllJfl. Solid lines represent pasture fences. The dotltcl lino indicates the old west and north boundaries of the original Range. The area lying between Highway 41 and the dotted line was included in the original Range for the li^SS census, but was with the new purchase area for the 1939 and 1940 counts. 38 CALIFORNIA FISH AND GAME including? the season of 1987, whereas no hunting was allowed on the original Kange after the open season of 1933. Since the start of inten- sive quail study in December, 1936, an average of 10 quail per month has been removed from the Range for food analyses. In November and December of 1938 and 1939, an experimental hunt was conducted over a portion of the original Range. In 1938, 336 birds were taken and there was a crippling loss of 57 birds. In 1939, 62 birds were taken and the additional crippling loss was 26 birds. These are not taken into account in the total census figures cited above for tlic cor- resjionding following censuses taken in 1939 and 1940. The data from the five annual horseback censuses suggest a progres- sive decline in average size of covey; this may be due partly to the relative dates of the various censuses. The five successive counts have been made at increasingly later dates in the season as viewed climati- cally and biologically with respect to the reproductive cycle of the quail. The smaller sizes of coveys recorded are thought to be due primarily to the process of covey dispersal which normally begins about the middle of March at the Range. In 1939, however, nests were discovered about two weeks earlier than in the previous two years. The 1940 nesting season was slightly earlier than that of 1939. These earlier nesting dates combined with the early cessation of spring rains in 1939, the mild winter of 1940, and the relatively advanced stage of the vegetation of both years indicated that the censuses of 1939 and 1940, although taken at a comparable chronologic date to that of 1938, were biologically later in the season as far as the mating cycle of the quail was concerned. The fluctuations in population which are exhibited in table 1 and figure 25 are not of such magnitude as is shown by the ruffed grouse in eastern states (Leopold and Ball, 1931). They do, however, indicate that variations exist in the local valley quail population in successive years. AVhether these changes signify any cyclic change in the local quail can only be determined by a much longer record. The census method herein described, if used according to the precautions indicated, will serve in areas of suitable cover and topog- raphy as a yardstick for evaluating populations of valley quail prior to and during the applicati(m of management methods. Literature Cited Bennotf, L. J., and Henrlrickson, G. D. 198S. Censusins: onail in the early fall. Journal of Wildlife Management, vol. 2, pp. 169-171. Glading, Ben 1938. Studies on the nosting cycle of the California valley quail in 1937. Cali- fornia Fi.sh and Came, vol. 24, pp. 318-340, illus. Leopold, Aldo, and Ball, J. N. 1931. British and American grouse cycles. Canadian Field-Naturalist, vol. 45, pp. 162-1G7. Talbot, M. W., Biswell, H. H., and Hormay, A. L. 1939. Fluctuations in the annual vegetation of California. Ecology, vol. 20, pp. 394-402, illus. Wight, H. M. 1930. Michigan's game dog. American Forests, vol. 36, pp. 620-623, p. 637. ''N. B. SCOFIELD": PROGRESS REPORT FOR 1940^ By H. C. GoDsiL California State Fisheries Laboratory Division of Fish and Game The function of the research staff of the Bureau of Marine Fish- eries is twofold. Its first assignment is to determine the proper rate of exploitation of our various marine fisheries. When this is known, it is then necessary to follow the trend of each fishery in order to safeguard its future. The latter task is to a large extent routine, whereas the former necessitates a great deal of investigative work, much of which must be done upon the fishing grounds. To facilitate the investigative work, the N. B. Sco field was built in 1938 and for the past two years this vessel has functioned as an integral and important part of the Division's fisheries laboratory. Built and used exclusively for this work she has, in the two years of operations, contributed immensely to our knowledge of the fisheries by extending the range of our investigations. In the past year, the N. B. Scofield traversed 17,648 miles, ranging from northera California to the Galapagos Islands on the Equator. To obtain the maximum benefit from our research vessel, it is necessary to plan the work in close conjunction with the entire research program. For this purpose the most urgent aspects of each investiga- tion are listed and an annual program drafted with the time of the N. B. Scofield allotted to the different fisheries or different areas in proportion to their importance. Such a program was formulated for the past year (1940), and it is a satisfaction to report that this pro- gram was successfully followed to completion. Each projected piece of work was accomplished. Tlio credit for this goes in large part to the crew of the N. B. Scofield, and it is a pleasure to acknowledge our continued indebtedness to Ca]itain Lars J. Weseth, Messrs. Ralph Dale, Paul Richmond, Peder Stockland, Harry Rouch, Merile Stewart, Robert MacDonald, Harry Peters, William Nyland, and to those per- sons who substituted for short periods. Successful fulfillment of the program could not have been accomplished without the whole- hearted cooperation of the governments of the countries in whose waters the vessel operated. We should like to express our appreciation of the many courtesies shown us by representatives of the republics of Mexico, Ecuador and Costa Rica. 1 Submitted for publication, February, 1941. (39) 40 CALIFORNIA FISH AND GAME Tuna In 1940 the X. B. Scofield made a protracted trip to the tuna fish- ing grounds. Every important fishing area was visited and samples of tuna obtained therefrom. The purpose of the trip was twofold: (1) the essential refrigeration program was carried to completion, and (2) a collection of both tuna and skipjack was made for the purpose of a comparative study of the populations. The results of the refrigeration ^^ ork emphasized the necessity for prompt handling of fish after capture, confirming the findings of the previous year. Furthermore, in a mimeographed report to the indus- try, we were able to inform the fishermen that storage temperatures should not exceed a maximum of 20° P. for the average length of the present trips. Maintenance of this temperature will enable the fish- ermen to deliver their loads in an acceptable condition, providing prompt chilling is practiced. However, the quality of the fish could be improved by lower temperatures, where these are practical. Other experiments indicated some deleterious effects after prolonged storage in brine and the advantages of air circulation in a dry, frozen load. The results accomplished will enable us to plan the next phase of this investigation. All the material needed for comparison of the populations of tuna on the different grounds was collected on this trip and the laboratory work is now nearing completion. Whereas, it will require many weeks of careful work before definite conclusions may be drawn concerning the populations in the different grounds, we are able to state tenta- tively at this time that there is but a single species of yellowfin tuna in the entire eastern Pacific in so far as this has been investigated. This in itself is an important contribution to our knowledge. In the case of the skipjack, preliminary results indicate that the entire stock in the northern Pacific thus far investigated represents a single species. Our own material was compared directly with samples from Japanese and Hawaiian waters. At the Galapagos Islands a single specimen of a hitherto unde- scribed species of tuna was taken. The existence of this species was known from occasional reports from tuna fishermen, but this was the first opportunity we have had to make an original examination. A second specimen was obtained subsequently through the courtesy and cooperation of a commercial fisherman, and these will be described in a forthcoming publication. The occurrence, distribution and abun- dance of this fish will be investigated as opportunity oflters. Sardines The census of young sardines was continued in 1940, with the N. B. Scofield working from central California to the tip of Lower California. This work was initiated in 1938 when young sardines were considered of average abundance. The abundance in the fall of 1940 was esti- mated as 22 per cent of 1938. In 1940 about one-half of the young fish were found off the northern half of Lower California, one-fourth in southern California waters and one-fourth in central California. "n. b. scofield" 41 Fig. 27. Sardine fishing in Magdalena Bay, Ijower California. The power launch in the foreground keeps the skiff out of the net as the men pull in the wings. The light lampara nets are hauled from the skiff whereas the heavier purse seine is fished from the N. B. Scofield itself. These nets are used for taking sardines in the young fish survey and for tagging as well as for catching tuna bait. Photograph by Merile Stewart. Fig. 28. Left, lowering metal tow net at the start of a haul. Right, the net brealcs the surface at the end of the haul. Photographs by Merile Stewart. 42 CALIFORNIA FISH AND GAME This annual census makes possible an estimate of the amount that each year-class of sardines will contribute to the fishery one to three seasons later. In January and February, 1940, sardine eggs and larvae were collected in the Gulf of California and maturing adult fish were taken. This constituted an extension of tlie known spawning grounds for the sardine. This material has contributed to the study of population differences along the Pacific coast of North America. Using the N. B. Scofield, 7,600 sardines were tagged in Mexican waters during 1940. These taggings are a continuation of similar work done in 1939, which has yielded returns in the southern California fishery during the 1940-1941 sardine season. Sardine tagging in Mexi- can waters supplements the general sardine program carried out in California waters and greatly furthers the study of sardine migrations. Mackerel The mackerel investigation along the coast of Lower California was carried out from the N. B. Scofield during 1940. Tow net hauls for eggs and larvae Avere made along the west coast of the peninsula and in the Gulf of California. Larvae were taken as far up the Gulf as Pulpito Point, about 240 miles from the entrance. Samples of adult mackerel were taken in the Gulf to determine if they are part of the same population which is taken in California. More material is needed before this point can be settled. Fia. 29. Sparchine: a plankton haul for fish eg-gs and larvae aboard the N. B. Scofield. Photograph by Merile Stewart. "n. b. scofield" 43 Along the west coast of Lower California, a total of 4,664 mackerel were tagged to aid in determining what part these fish play in the Cali- fornia fisher.y. Over 40 of tliese tagged fish had been recovered in southern California by March 1, 1941. Flatfish In 1940 an extensive survey of the stock of flatfish in northern California was conducted. The N. B. Scofield worked from San Fran- cisco to the Oregon line, sampling all the important commercial grounds. This work revealed the age and size composition of the commercial species along the coast line, and tlie results will enable us to determine the condition of the fishery and to suggest any regulatory measures needed. Scales were taken from sampled fish and will be used in determining the relative age composition of the catch. In addition, approximately 5,000 fish were tagged and liberated at selected points along this coast line. In the case of the flatfish, the tagging program has already yielded valuable results and the work conducted this past season was designed to confirm and extend these findings. Attempts were made in the course of this trip to explore grounds in deeper offshore waters. These were not very successful, but the experience gained will be used in future work. Finally, in addition to these major problems, lesser ones were tackled as opportunity offered. Throughout the year, collections of local and Lower California fish were made and identified to aid in the study of the distribution of larvae and of the commercially important species. Water temperatures were taken regularly on all trips and these are used in correlation Avith the seasonal runs of fish. All in all, the N. B. Scofield contributed largely to a busy and productive year and continued a record of which all are justly proud. FIRST RECORD OF THE HYBRID FLOUNDER, Inopsetta ischyra, FROM CALIFORNIA ^ By Earl Stannard Herald Natural History Museum Stanford University, California A study of some of the California flatfishes in the Stanford Uni- versity^ collections has recently brought to light a unique specimen which upon comparison with the published descriptions and with a specimen of Inopsetta ischyra from Puget Sound (Stanford 23738) may undoubtedly be referred to that species. This individual, taken off San Francisco about November 11, 1936, was discovered in the fish market by G-. H. Clark of the California Division of Fish and Game, and subsequently presented to the Museum (Stanford 34964). Inopsetta ischyra was first described by Jordan and Gilbert (1880) from four specimens taken in Puget Sound. From that date until 1927 no additional specimens were known. At that time Villadolid pub- lished a paper in which he announced his rediscovery of the species, the material consisting of three specimens which he had collected, two from the Seattle fish markets and the third from Holmes Harbor, Puget Sound. He also pointed out that the figure used to illustrate Inopsetta in Jordan and Evermann's "Fishes of North and Middle America" (p. 2641, fig. 927) was actually a figure of Lepidopsetta hilineata. However, it remained for Norman (1934, p. 376) to suggest that Inopsetta might be a hybrid, perhaps between the broad-fin sole (Lepi- dopsetta hilineata) and the starry flounder (Platichthys stellatus). Schultz and Smith (1936) finally settled the question as to the status of /. ischyra after they had collected twelve specimens from the vicinity of Puget Sound. By carefully comparing these specimens with the other species in the Sound region, it was decided I. ischyra, if a hybrid, must represent a cross between Platichthys stellatus and Parophrys vetulus, the pointed-nosed sole. If this hypothesis is correct, then 7. ischyra should also be found at other localities where both parent species are present. Both species are abundant in California; however, until this date, no specimens of I. ischyra have been recorded from the State. Schultz and Smith state that this hybrid flounder is well known to the fishermen of the Sound who regard it as a hybrid between the starry flounder and some other species. But in California waters, /. ischyra is a rarity, for according to Clark only about four specimens of this hybrid have ever been noticed in the San Francisco area by the fish butciiers or by the fisheries research staff of the California Division of Fish and Game. As seen from the figure, I. ischyra has the pigmented areas in the fins as does P. stellatus, but it lacks the star-shaped tubercles of this 1 Submitted for publication, December, 1940. (44) HYBRID FLOUNDER, Inopsctta ischyra 45 latter species and has instead ctenoid scales fairly evenly distributed over the body. Usually the pigmented areas of the fins are much lighter than is typical of P. steUatus. From the illustrations it will be noted that a part of the lateral line system is asynnnetric-al in that on the blind side (lower left illustra- tion) there is a lateral line branch extending in an are ventro-caudad 46 CALIFORNIA FISH AND GAME from the angle of the opercle. This branch is not present on the eyed side, nor is it present on either side of any specimen examined from a large series of both P. vctnhis and P. stellatus. Dr. Schultz has very kindly examined the specimens of Inopsetta in the U. S. National Museum. He finds only one which has not been dissected on the blind side; again, the auxiliary branch is not present on this individual. It is probable that this structure on the San Francisco Inopsetta is an anomalous condition. In presenting measurements and counts of the specimen of 7. ischyra from San Francisco, it was thought advisable to include com- parisons with the parent species and with other known specimens of ischyra. These three columns of data are taken from Schultz and Smith (1936). Each column gives the range of variation, followed by the mean value in parentheses; no series from which measurements and counts were taken was composed of fewer than 11 specimens; measure- ments are expressed as thousandths of the standard length. TABLE 1 Comparison of Parophrys vetulus, Platichthys stellatus, and Inopsetta ischyra Pacific Coast Parophrys vetulus Puget Sound Inopsetta ischyra San Francisco Inopsetta ischyra Pacific Coast Platichthys stellatus Dorsal Rays (last single) Anal Rays (last single) Pectoral Rays Vertebrae (hypural excluded) Gill-rakers (above angle) Gill-rakers (below angle) Scale Rows Crossing Lateral Line Head Length Snout Length Greatest Depth of Body Snout to Pelvic Fin Insertion Least Depth of Caudal Peduncle Lengt h of Caudal Peduncle .__ Bony Interorbital Width Height of Arch of Lateral Line Length Accessory Branch of Lateral Line 72- 54- !!■ 42. 4. n 89- 267- 56. 353- 271- 77. 97- 5- 3- 146- • 92 ( 80.96) ■ 70( 61.27) ■ 13( n.65) ■ 44( 43.21) ■ 6( 4.80) ■ 13( 11.80) ■103( 95.50) •301(282.5 ) - 69( 00.60) ■399(379.2 ) ■297(281.8 ) ■ 97( 86.8 ) ■124(107.7 ) ■ 12( 8.6 ) ■ 17( 11.0 ) ■252(186.6 ) 68- 77( 72.08) 50- 57( 53.08) 11- 13( 11.26) 38- 40( 39.18) 4- 6( 5.08) 9- 10 9.58) 76- 86( 82.40) 285-'317 294.7 ) 52- 71( 58.9 ) 447-505(466.7 ) 283-328(294.4 ) 89-108( 97.1 ) 94-126(108.8 ) 7- 12( 9.9 ) 9- 23( 14.4 ) 15-102( 61.5 ) 70 54 11 39 6 11 85 289 53 497 294 97 91 10 22 82 10- 34- 3- 52- 65( 58.54) 38- 64( 42.18) 12( 11.05) 36( 35.31) 5( 3.95) 6- 8( 7.75) 58- 70( 62.26) 284-321(304.1 ) 56- 73( 65.6 ) 459-529(496.0 ) 285-^61(307.4 ) 87-109( 99.2 ) 100-156(129.5 ) 8- 15( 11.6 ) 17- 40( 22.3 ) (Lacking arch) Literature Cited Jordan, D. S., and Gilbert, C. H. 1880. Description of two new species of flounders (Parophrys ischyrus and Hippoglossoides elassodon) from Puget Sound. U. S. National Museum. Proceedings, vol. 3, pp. 276-280. Norman, J. R. 1934. A systematic monograph of the flatfishes (Heterosomata) . Vol. 1, Psetto- didae, Bothidae, Pleuronectidae. London, British Museum, 459 pp., 137 figs. Schultz, L. P., and Smith, R. T. 1936. Is Inopsetta ischyra (Jordan and Gilbert), from Puget Sound, Washing- ton, a hybrid flatfish? Copeia, 1936, no. 4, pp. 199-203. Villadolid, D. V. 1927. The rediscovery of Inopsetta ischyra, a rare species of flounder. Carnegie Museum. Annals, vol. 17, pp. 395-397, pi. 35. Editorials and Notes TWENTY-FIVE YEARS AGO IN "CALIFORNIA FISH AND GAME" Highlig-hting the April, 1916, issue of "California Fish and Game" was an article on the shad fishery of California by H. B. Nidever. This article described the introduction of shad to California waters and the remarkable success of the project. Within a few years of the first plant, which was made in 1871, shad had become numerous enough to support a commercial fishery. At first these fish commanded a high price in the local markets but as the supply increased the price and demand dropped. Nidever and the writers of several short notes and editorials along the same lines called attention to the fine food qualities of the shad and urged greater utilization of the resource which was virtually going to waste. A number of excellent recipes for cook- ing shad and full instructions on the removal of bones were given. Much the same situation holds today and shad still constitutes a neg- lected resource which is capable of providing a great deal of excellent and inexpensive food. As in 1916 the world is today torn by war and no source of food supply should be overlooked. There will be efforts made in the name of "national defense" to relax restrictions on the taking of our more popular fish which are already sadly depleted. In the long run our national economy will be better served by retaining present conservation measures for our over-fished species and by urging greater utilization of less popular but equally wholesome fish such as the shad. By 1916 the grizzl^y bear was rather generally regarded to be extinct in California but persistent rumors still told of grizzlies in various parts of the State. One such rumor when run down proved to be an exceptionally large black bear, as recounted by Joseph Dixon. It was later shown (California Fish and Game, vol. 25, pp. 237-244), that grizzlies did exist in California as late as 1922, and even now we still hear rumors of grizzlies in the southern Sierra Nevada. Perhaps the animal which adorns our State seal yet lives. Barton Warren Evermann presented a second article on the dis- tribution of elk from the San Joaquin Valley to various parts of the State. In 1914 and 1915 a total of 146 elk was distributed, leaving between 350 and 400 in the Kern County herd. Of the number moved, 25 died, but at least three fawns were born in 1915, so that about 124 were still alive in 1916. A firsthand account of sea otter hunting in the 1880 's was contrib- uted by Chase Littlejohn. This article gives a resume of the rise and fall of the sea otter trade and describes the habits of these interesting fur bearers. A number of short notes on various subjects rounded out the April, 1916, issue. To me, nothing is so fascinating as reading these old notes on wildlife conditions with their wealth of interesting and important information. They will always be valuable references. — Richard S. Crokcr, Editor, California Fi<^h and Game. (47) 48 CALIFORNIA FISH AND GAME RESULTS OF THE 1940 PISMO CLAM CENSUS Staff members of the California State Fisheries Laboratory took the annual census of Pismo clams (Tivela sttiltorum) at Pismo Beach on November 27-29, 1940. This yearly count provides a measure of the clam population, indicating- the size of the set of the previous summer as well as the survival from year to year of the older age- groups. It gives a measure of the number of clams of spawning age and of legal size as well as information as to the probable picture for the future. The 1940 census showed first that the year's set was very small, and further that one age-group (clams now five years old) makes up slightly over one-third of the present population. This is the third successive neglible set, which means that for the next several years there will be very few clams reaching maturity, to say nothing of legal size. There have been but three good sets in recent vears — those of 1931, 1935 and 1937. The 1937 set has suffered a high mortality, and the 1931 set is now represented only b}^ a few individuals in the closed area. Meanwhile, the only numerous group — survivors of the 1935 set — is now reaching legal size and is being removed, particularly from the open area. This means that while mature clams are momentarily fairly abundant, it is onl}^ a matter of time before diggers will have taken the bulk of them. The extent to which removal by diggers already affects this group can be shown by these figures ; approximately 19 per cent of the original set survives in the closed area, but only 9 per cent remains in the area open to digging. The actual number of clams found in 1940 was the smallest since 1928. In the intervening time, only two years (1934 and 1939) showed a scarcity approaching the 1940 figure. Although the total number of clams of all sizes dropped about 21 per cent from the pre- ceding census, the actual number of mature clams on the entire beach in 1940 was about the same as in 1939, due to a good survival in the closed area. However, in the open area, the number decreased in 1940 because of the removal of the five-year-olds and the lack of replace- ments by younger clams. In the closed area, the total is up over the past two years, though still only about half that of the best years, 1935 to 1937. Mature clams make up 81.4 per cent of the total, while some 32 per cent of the total are five-year-olds. However, even with the small number of youn^ clams there, the picture is satisfactory, providing that poaching is held to a minimum and if a good set occurs within a year or two. In the open area, a definite decrease in numbers seems inevitable. With the limited numbers of young clams now present, little in the way of additions to the older and legal groups may be expected for several years. The five-year group made up almost 35 per cent of the total found, and as stated, is showing the effect of digging and will soon be removed. The best we can hope for is a good set in 1941, which will at least give some promise of relative abundance for the future. — Phil M. Roedel, California State Fisheries Laboratory, Divi- sion of Fish and Game, January li, 1941. EDITORIALS AND NOTES 49 BLACK BRANT IN LOWER CALIFORNIA, FEBRUARY, 1941 For the past eleven years, James Moffitt of the California Academy of Sciences has conducted an annual census of the black brant (Branta 'bernicla nigricans) wintering in California. In 1935, 1938 and 1940, circumstances permitted an additional count at San Quentin Bay, Lower California, at about the time of the eorresponding California censuses. The Bay is located about 180 miles south of San Diego. The research vessel N. B. Scofield of the California Division of Fish and Game spent several days in the vicinity of San Quentin during February, 1941, while making routine fisheries investigations, and it proved possible for the writer, assisted by J. G. Carlisle, Jr., and Paul Richmond, to survey the Bay on the morning of February 2. In all, 1155 brant were counted, of which 230 were in the east arm and 925 in the west. "We could not visit the upper portion of the east arm, but we were able to scan most of it with field glasses. Few birds of any sort were to be seen; however, it seems probable that some brant were there. Therefore, our total count of 1155 is a minimum. We had no trouble with birds crossing back and forth between counted and uncounted areas ; flights were, fortunately, made almost entirely in the same direction. Hence we feel that the total obtained is reasonably accurate for the area covered. On February 3, 1941, we saw one flock of 16 birds near Sacramento Reef, some forty miles below San Quentin, and another of about 100 brant, twenty miles farther south. No others were noted in the course of the trip which extended into the Gulf of California. — Phil M. Roedel, California State Fisheries Laboratory, Division of Fish and Game, March 7, 1941. eviews California's Natural Wealth: A Conservation Guide for Secondary- Schools California State Department of Education. Bulletin, Vol. 9, No. 4, December, 1940, 124 pp., illus. The need for conservation education in public schools is realized by all educators and conservationists although there is some disagree- ment as to how the subject can be best presented to the students. Recently the trend has been toward integrating nature study and con- servation with other subjects rather than to add specific courses. In many States, active programs are under way in which conservation policies and practices are made real to the pupils by means of including information and work projects on natural resources in various courses. The results of conservation education are well worth the effort as the school children are the potential conservers or despoilers of our resources. California schools have included nature study and conservation study in their curricula for years but now these subjects are being enlarged and made more vital. The State Department of Education has made a real step forward with its publication of the handbook California's Natural Wealth. This bulletin, which was prepared under the direction of the California Conservation Council, is intended for the use of secondary school teachers and pupils. It commences with a brief description of California's natural resources, which is followed by a summary of the meaning and necessity for conservation. Subse- quent chapters present the various natural resources of the State in detail: water, soil, native flora, forests, wildlife, scenic areas, and min- eral resources. Each chapter includes a comprehensive reading list. The final chapter discusses conservation in the school curriculum. It is recommended that conservation study should be made a part of reg- ular courses on other subjects rather than be set up as something spe- cial. Suggested courses in which conservation studies could be inte- grated are : general science, biology, chemistry, physics, health and safety, social science, literature, writing, public speaking, mathematics, arts, and home economics. It is stressed that nature can not be studied in the classroom, and field trips, experiments and audiovisual aids are recommended. The book is well written and should prove useful to teachers and pupils alike. The descriptions of the natural wealth of the State are uniformly good. A few more illustrations Avould have added to the booklet. — Richard S. Croker, Editor, California Fish and Game. (50) REVIEWS 51 Fishing' the Surf ]iv Raymond K. Cainp. I'.oston, Little, Brown & Co., 1941. 223 pp., iliiis. $2.00. Witli tlie i)ubli('ati()n of Fishing the Su7-f, another is added to the rai)idly growing- list of excellent handbooks on ocean fishiii!112 95 50 22 im 30 12'i 12>2 25 1,872 58 CALIFORNIA FISH AND GAME £ t-^ c — (c bp h- IC "^ CO C5 (M coco — ooo O coo CO r- cc r-f:o»oor^coOciOO'— •400c:i'^»r5::oo«o^He050cn> c^r— lOC^co'^cococo-^^^cooi-'fco^C'ic^iOOO'^O «5 aji—cO'^T'iocoTfrri oo'^co:or-to^DtrD05 C^ —« Ol ^^ r/-} -rf — CO 05 I -T O* — " lO t^ c-j oT >-*' CO <-< CS M» GO '-* QT) C*D >0 CO -^ CO *M CO 'M t^ OS O ^'— ' 3—- O CO CO ■^ OD '-' 1/5 «^TP »0 CO 05 »0 CO CO o »oo »0 M (M asco^-H I us CO 1 ThOCO F oco Ol ' '^'^'^ I CO ■^■-«" MCO oc llJ CO o 1- CO o O) f (/) CO 1- L. < « o c m ea o S ;» .^ o I 3 (/) cd a> u. > m oa a> < E n z O oc o < -2 CO C5 ^ n n z < _i A I a> a> < J u cc 111 S S o o « ° « 2 rt i- Q^ ;« S'5b IZ 5-2 1- 1— ' •«*' CO — ' (M CO on .-I CO CO O I-- CO CO -^ CO I* c« CO CO CO CO cot- iM^-i: I - -^ O (M O »0 — " CO 3; CTj CO CO fM O O t- O Cl O; CO ■^ CV] t— Ci Tt" Orfr-cocor— co<— 'jot-i-i— ix:0'— '»-' »-^" CO QC CO O '-^«^^^.-^^0 '-H CO CO ODr-^Tj^cO "^"Cocooor— Tj«co CO O T-« »o f-i o CO t- r-. OS CO ■^ GO CO OS w CO lO »o iVco t— ^(^ cw »oco t— CO "5 - C0 0 Oi OS CO T-H CO (M t>^ o CS) ,_,.-. o CO O »0 GO Tf f— I CO »o ^ o ^ CO*-"-" O -^ t— OS C?l OS CO M 00 OS 10 t- CO O 00 000 M< o OS CO (M Tp Tf* O CO OS »ooo r-H d O t-oio t- Oi OS I CO '-H to ( iC CO T-i 1 i-HCOO t— —< 00 CO OS 10 t— (M 00 »0 CO CO r— W5 o Mf-Tco >o cf 10 10 CO (M ocoo OS OS OS .-H to CO « «_D t'- ■^ «-« »0 8,295,032 1,184' 144,959 275" <— 1 ^. CO 1,443,773 45,428 32 l-H CO ■^f-^TTCOr^U^ CMCMCOCM OOCOCOCO'^CO-^-^'^tOO ^ :ar CO »o <^ r-- t* ci lO O to '^ '^ i^ cy:: »i^ o rr co t- cm O ■^ovDcccMco -^Trci— coci'— '-^^cotoccr^TT'— lira cs'^j^ CMtfi" CM CDco CO corCco^'ocM-^ oi" CD CM coco -H -H wj^ ^ 2 OD CO CO CM CM ! 1 '23 ' I Iio ! I I 1 I I 1 1 I 1 1 I . 2 ; ; ;g ; : ;^ : : : ; : <» 1 1 1"-^ 1 1 !•* ! 1 1 I 1 I 1 I I ! 1 ! ! CO CO CO 11,252 592' 570 4,838 ' "492" 53,367 75 216 76" 125 4,645 00 »o CO 261 1S5 521 '42,711 106,600 'l'l',695' 2' 19,509 CO Oi Oi *^ Oi CO " "14' " 63' 6,975 'l',483' 637 'l'4',855" 1— 1 .— 1 tg CO CM "4',084' 229 ' '5,940' 2,472 '63,639' CMO I— iTfCOCMiQCO t 1 CO'* 1 t-- CO 00 -^ CM b- ' ' ^H 1 GO CO CC<>i"^ ' ' ! |C CDCO^ I 1 U5 oi" CO 0 CM 1 . 10 1 • C^ 1.1. . ,co . ^0 ... 1 , .us , . C 1 S § C3 a a 3 . 03 c3 a; 53 , i^ . • • .^ > -5 » rt ^^ -ss-isgcsis w^ SCi- ^ "t:i cj f^ '^ o s-i .- i so l-i = ^^o5_,- o.S .: "S rt „ 3 o ;sap-!|a- C taC tn g au en oK t-.c 5'^ g°- ^ CJ •• OrJ^-— __ -'- .£3 — — — ■ — i,;i5 X i- ^- c_=: e-H: a a — — 00 a' a' B o-^- ^ .S -3 o >.>>>. 0000000 2 = KM 6C ^ OJ ; 2 ^« =■ C-S o = c = 2 = Si 60 CALIFORNIA FISH AND GAME 2 a o 03 UJ > o CO I- < O m O ^ I CQ rn ffi ii CQ > m o h < a z O cc o •o c CO u. f _J Z O I ^ to .— =: I _i ° u cc UJ S o o o o tL a Q'S) CO \n POO C5 cc "* CO WD Ol CO CO »C CO oc O ^« HO CO f-. g-g'S) 5 l3 :, t-^iotQ^H.-HOco<; CO — »CCO'— 'tOt^ t-OCOCO' OC' O O CiD ^ Cvf CO * «— 1- lO -^ CO 3i t CO r- CO 1-t 2i o CO a> C3 OS p:; i; su a bO CO O W CO »-i O »C CO OlOt--.CO co *o CO lO CO lO Oi t^ lO 00 a. i-( <:o ■^ COQOtC .-H OOi-H ^ CO W W50 CO t'- (M OS0 0>— >— «05 O iM-^t-H^co*-D>— ':>d:oco:dcD'<»"coic»— ■r'-Qc^rco r^ •—I ca r^ lo lo •"-Tie ^c^c-f CO "— "'cTcrrO'i"^— --T [^id" ■ *-H CO O 1-* •-« (>i ^O CD t-- 05 CD lO OO C^ "^ t^OOOO CS) CD t^iO CO r-T .?l.§.^ 3 1^33^ fc:S JJ J g:^ I g S^l si's 1-1 CO co»o C7S C3i oo ^O OS OS CO'-' T-t Oi O W3 •<*' Tji f»-4" lo .-I TT 00 oi_ Tt<0 CD CO lO CO O "^ OCD - CO . ■ t^ oo ca »o -^ r>. oi T-i oo CO »o ^f t^ t— CD r- -rr t-- M' .—I »o CO CD t- •— I CD C^ CO coo s^ OS oooo CO oo (>J c»q c^ OOCOOO t^ (N oo oot^t^ OSCO O CO 00 OS CO CD -^ CD iOo OOO coo -^f :C":c — > o --r t- CO -^ -^ OC CO O >o C^ Oi t^ OO CO t>. lO -^ o •-< '-0 CO — ' »ra CI '^ ^ eooo as CO ooco OO CO ^ eo ^ »c ^ !g C^l Tf t^ ^-" CO t^ »o o ^'i >o cc -^ ■^ 1-H Ci W O ^H c^ooeo •-HCVICO <:o^H £ a> a> £ o > . so i^ -^ — -. -. S TT a i|-iJI|.i 62 CALIFORNIA FISII AND GAME oc UJ DO S UJ M o III t- a f CO i/> U. 1- < c o CO tB a z O I 3 (9 «/) s u. 3 m > CO ffi t- < M z a or •a O CO ii. u .. CO at CJ > z n Q s Z J= <■ -1 2 I 0) in o UJ S o o i5 E 5Q o cc -^ r- > -si c.S " II § C3 HPi o p3 "r bO CO 5 bo"t>c Sao -m^- « A o S S S'3) a S n M art TS " 3 °i C) t^ l- r-- o (TJ r- M '«»■ d t^ »n ^ tc — ■^ o o Tf --I r- CO cc t^ *-H o ^ CO -J-t^ CI »oo o iOOO r^ CO 1-H CO CI O lOCQ OO r-- CO CO M OOQO CO CI as 1-c CO lO »ooor^ CO CO c^ 00 CO r-- CO to tOTp iOi-H CO o t-co Oco r^ «5 »oco (N U5 »0 O coo .-(CO CO M d CO oa cj cfcf 05 00 ^-" o [CO'^'" OOtCM'CCOOCOCOr-ClCOf^'O'^CO^O— '»C.— t CO C) »0 m CI O CI t^ -^ CO .-< O r-- .— cc »c -x: O Tfciic— «.— ■cicir^Ocicit^cidd'»rO •**» —I O "^ -^ cf o Tji" 1^ c/f CO cT i:^ CO o ^ »-. O ■-• " '-^ ~, .^ -, - CI CO o CO CI co« O O CO CI Tt< O CI CO OiCO OO O CC I>. CO CO CJ •^ !>■ COC CO C) o CO CO GO 00 »OrH T-T CO.-HIOCOCJ— ii— <05CDCO >— liOTfr^OciT-H— ■— 'OS Cl_CO »OCO CO^-^Ol CJ ■^ CI t'-OClGOOCCtCOCICI Tt<0 GO^HGCClCqCO»0 CO wsc*— *»OCO —t lO CO 1-1 00 CI CO O lO OS 00 GO CI r» osco r- dCO*-" C3 OS o»o ^ C5CO O t^ Tt< •O OS r-. 1-1 »-< CO O Tj* OS OS CO COOCQ ^H .—* so g^t3- ..a 2i o.^^ 5:5 -a <:m "§ s;33 °3 s fc.5 « a a s g § s-^-^ g s g £ 2^^ j3 a-B a 3 CQOJ 5 a ■aoacQcc ^2 - - - S a a a a a c a O 3 3 3 EEPORTS 63 Sooas 2r ca »/5 ■V OD o ^r c» CO 00 c^^r^o O tC ^ i~4 ^ 'zr —* »C *» O t- — • ^*5 "M t~ o o >o o ^r ClCC (M'^CCCS»-«iO . ■^00 "POCO 1 2C 05 TT 1-^ "O I ^r GC — ;r> c/: I OO (M CO CO O ■'*' M" O ^J* •^ OS »0 M GO CC O iC t^^ O t^ i— « CO 'M r^ O o >o O ^ C-J iC ifi "O O 'O CO O GO CS OS CO (M Tf GO Ol '— ' »0 1 ic r-^ . i-»00 lOO I CO lO I - ■3 a 3 a ?=?-^ o i^-2 sa a e E o^-S=:2 ^JJJJJJI 2.2,2 g. ■o