SMITHSONIAN, (ety ot a) . ‘ ob > , eis? ' " r] ’ ' F) . ta . Aig ‘ , ’ fd 5 pel ’ “4 ~~ = bad i} an 7G 4.4 PARA w DO a? : H . nw ‘ ; Ms Os bap ‘ ure « mer) We : ’ fe Sur sich. bod, cake late le 2 ®. ars ash» R ‘ ' . ‘ ' ‘ . 9 bilte. tf see een! ee ory ty i ee { , ; ‘of ws tiy) AWE} , As va a 2 Bee ser airs 5 , a ‘ ® tos . a a , ’ ’ oe ’ . 5 , ; 060 re A ah 8 ath Aland , 7 - ’ , tote ’ py 2 Pe ' mint . al ores «han oor! ed We Relea he tA athsbere er : ‘ : ete Aad aate ; se 4 ‘ , of , : ‘ vy Te | is. ® “an a Ab . stand. ® "AA a | a ° Pr . a ; . 4 } +o oes - , * 4 s aA ah? te Pee ’ a ‘ xis : ’ 4a. . ‘ B.65.4 Reb Sad "SO ALR 40 Ppaehse on Cr Sey ee , ‘ , ca “? hi wr hee | ot wre , Pat tes afta etter ee ee. Pe were re | ’ hee a) 5 ae . ore 120 . . 5 ri yer rh ‘4 terre 4 4 yr. e . yeaa ree® san bid OTT 7 rH ‘ 4 % , ste ret) . ’ POR 4 . Je ere Pade s . 78 Merry tars © ee Saga, ALO tae ‘ ' ” ’ rary Cheer ney fe bar oe Set ee Wes . ai gt a. ve eae afess sy ate Wiacate re steko \ ’ . tre ara e pte rate ate em te Pry ae yy rt wr . : . J uae ¢ iv tel MEe te toeen aa hte erry; +e sare ' rae . ' Pete le ee ee ee er ney HAH yy Bo : eo! . : . . Si La ae oe Be See eo oe ee e sha thd vy ’ . . we } 90) TE ete tas . 9.0.4 are AN OES Oe Qite eae O98 @ 8h OD! a St ag Aue, An} ’ ‘ a hath..s.09'Rs chat. hs decnthc ese, } ert ry Ms > oo ’ . $ teat ’ PPT TINT) Wh ePr ere = bo tte one A ue “ Dia Atte tee i 4 ’ . 8 ’ AMS Lan) Soe ee oe oe oe : ore: ; 3 re ere “vie ‘ ay Ree > } . edd #28 sw Cee rrrn ee ee r VPA AEP . . , DNimanwe em rater Litinee ‘ . : . ’ ote Gch. : Le LLL eat? Pere eee Sry) A : ‘ ' re poe ‘ Pe RR eg af aba cetattne ela 8 b] 4 sf «aan . o£. D . of e anse er | “ir yc ‘ PRL LH w sania Vio MDA ia te a Te) ss . Mi ‘ - . ' * BY 49) ee © thee + dr Anaee atv a Pes Tee) FIM IP COP a 48s sTT alin’ d iho tule’ of af & Dea ban ) aoe seein NSN ARr acid at: 5 ANA 5 Seer ee were ieee Were 8 1 PP soe ee tees ' 4 4 eats co we ae .% , "seni Moe ct Oo) eer fee 4 ene aes eee te es * : " ; aren eant! ai S Verde eels eee : st te ta Uae 4 . 4 +8 ws so aed w pom af o-Semns SP ak eda. 7a 4 . BAN: ita & Rem pe mmansay . . . > ty saeegeens? ah is ed . rahe} . ’ ah, we 46 i) Diem 8 phan . w]e as taht tea ots oy ote FP ey BES se Sa ok sek pe Pe % ate Pre! Med ote beth $rdayey wn ‘ te ba ee ag Shae > saan tne Pak ML rth Srp y roy ey Hey pho r a? aw wag Mey gem Sb DFA ad Sites 6 bie FS Feed pe FALE ‘ r 5 hey Awa? % at 2 gave : , Le Oia Sa) ~t lo pata. +o hard ds dias 93 Sone w Me: Stoo tone AMET, Nemes nenrtay Tes TAD Ree Deke POON Se sw Ni nave esd insen Re ble eed, erie Peer Ete T Crude ls fe rt Sent Saee 94 DES Fe S og Sp 8a 8 RN Moni nd Onlec 84 Me eae SOR Pe Ueii rs avi Serer enh aoe Bintee ay une i Pa fenb eo nes erast vreeee PIS eS Rete NS eras oe Por. et Tt nie Xs ET SN REDS i ete SMAZAC hae, aime oe Ate MALLS CAR sna Pa f A6e er . at anit dial .6 pena atest SPUN 7p pha syh erage 4! olde eA a larg i a ee . . be Vins oe ated if Sed al AG8 es! oh yp OE pF lee rs aes ot oft se - “a SOS ried : «steal es say red > shh Pe TI rs ne ifs a OE Tt 9 > = RE eee y Yala se a ik Peel) Pk ot a) I te I a Bead sid es > pase Ws gress ee 2 7 aes Be he. wy site $50 Co ¥rity TO" 9 ewes ul Er eS ene tet Fogt oe Fees. Posty ds ‘ Cee SRA ot Lk ie Oe eS Cer ak oh AE ae De ery ate bide SO A 0 Cd os 5 ’ 4 ca Pat pia h ete os 2 VM MRO of Gh et Rs : Y ‘a 4 de ae OE le” yr? ate ’ ad tL ee a ed v~ , ees Fe US oF ge Mee 18 Sr yey Ao asd ps ARON pR J a ico & highs 4 Dee bn Sade Et LP LF alld a a ee ae ees , > EP ree oN, Fa VSN FER Eager obs iy tees rea OER pe tee y Gye hgey a fie . + oS TA Ty Mobis ex, wg tatgee ele dele ah. - OY 3 ae a Fw bie! piem sis meaty s 2h st reg? oer (ty yea . Ay TO rt ot Ps | ry ed Ce br ht at vimy Ae bes Ge ee ae a ts RF eS p whrte we iO 5162788" or 3 "hy 7 a BF 515? giro e cv pt HepUT Pe seve 5 . Beg eM tk) PERE TO 8 8st Be ss ed pie AF Bt or HS r EM yh yBban orate oc FE AP sees OPP hee + a voete Pa PPE WO A AP 8 . oy sh ye fe ASSO BR ee ge a8 Sept Ate 8 FE the a il . , ON" Toes a Ly oa a ae oe aS aie Des . ; 2 PR A GIs" OE PPR eed para 2eo a% “~ PM yee pie ‘ view “gh ee nee | 9 oo gtd gt aelel’, ae ty - 2p PUPS Ht Pda sige 4 Fe ory ey tee 1 CAE eR plo tahoe oe, aH tph ater i) tie Po ds eS 0 OP ee, wv Pores Yessy + ena a? ete at os er teea Pitts bs DNs see Ee PE eee Le gL e 3 4 . © 8s EP ey ee) bt WT Hi ois ws acorer ‘ , +3 9 DSS EG 0 8 re E OT: Mayes yey Dasa gey. MS ey iss oe oR tae eye Beets ot LaLa ENG Oey uF gy 458-65 tea? sreshedrs ; ee ve toate vr tus Lh dis b alasted ee he oe ee ‘+4 * oy . ees ee et 3 + Se ew PF Oe BF err at hpi 4 a ea 40 Me r me Sah s : wR -t, ee St et eee os te Had ey pth KE CH ENE, 36 > . : rs see os oe - os 8 sa ‘ nope ty LEP EADIE AY PETRIE Or) ary .rm™ ‘ yt 6 3 a le Sa ae bell bce Jy tre ak! ay Sreces Fe ota ekgmarbane 2% #e- sats Het 3tG o2 sh wees viset +e Ss pr ett’ a5 bar aeons an cerat io 19 é Pann s pees ISTE TERME SIE SS te beens On hte i Se St oe Sieh aaie ‘ ie J cna ss sore pir were se 7 ws ee ee ae ae i 2d are? a es vit ror et pes o's yap Es od ie ik A eh | DE RW epee se Pees as BPG UT . Peis BPO TES sof Rees aro ee ens eh Oe i iS ie se ee ee ewe eer 2 ed eb ee ++ ws Oe Er Te a ae Fab I> FS ISP TIS tort Oe ee ie ee * ee 0G = ran Pees ee rte ee Ggy oo i ee see AN st” Pier ie ee eae 10 ie. ? , ; 4 They Pau Tie tet ett or eee rot © me at be eas c zt a 4 fe ae PT 0 ee ara ee TEs, ¥ Pam Nee mares Gigs gtd go ge Pees PES Te eS Ie ae Pie : co I AP Ft las FUT Uae’ & * fewer AY EM POE Te Pe Op Pigs sae | ts ened FP ds Eepinte. a. prin got ehe-oe ith Pee Jd ae La ae ps : “ . : eee ae 4 weyers yw, ntelew bee sees. sf 19 G7 . a Fy Or ery ‘ 5 Cats aa be AC Cae ie a oe See fe ’ an ap tem ere, em, apd gee AA 9 38 Pegs a= 4 were ey ae ks es OAS be bet ai 28 le Pe Ses ie sa é ‘ahd th bho ghey : ! aa tJ 2 , ‘ ete) oo ee any ison Chddare rae = SNI_NVINOSHLINS S3J!IYVYGIT LIBRARIES SMITHSONIAN INSTITUTION. NOILE 7’ Xs = r m2 RE =e fire ‘eI O ay oO wm ‘ — wo — C4, oo ng > We 5 : 5 y= : Ne ee: = is Ue fi > Ee = WY 2 ; eae o ot, nee ee in Zz a z ES SMITHSONIAN INSTITUTION NOLLMLILSNI_NVINOSHLINS Saluvuai7_ LIBR e ” ; “* = : = ay < = , =< & = x > Md z = z= Bs \ “Yh, oO ‘\ \ 3 SW i HZ: i 2 J \'3 RY 2 YG fg 9 - 4 2 = 5 2 al “N = SNI_NVINOSHLINS S3ZI1YVYGIT LIBRARIES SMITHSONIAN INSTITUTION NOILA LIBRARIES SMITHSONIAN SP a G z Zz nf ty z a =! 4 = Yin? 3 = 2 < ty Zk 3 < = S me ae pe fe) Oo a rs) = < z zs ae = ES SMITHSONIAN INSTITUTION NOILNLILSNI NVINOSHLINS S3IYVHSIT LIBR = | > > | VY = F zy = s 9 2 m 2 a = = (op) A = SHI NVINDSHLIINS (Saluvd all LIBRARIES SMITHSONIAN INSTITUTION | NOILE i = y = > > > Tp) Ps Ww”) - za w”) ; a ES SMITHSONIAN INSTITUTION NOILNLILSN! NVINOSHLINS S3INVYUSIT ” > “” > ee ep) = a 5@ es o a ” a = é « : * . hie 2 = : = = a >NI_ NVINOSHLIWS LIBRARIES SMITHSONIAN INSTITUTION NOILN. LIBRARIES JOILALILSNI LIBRARIES -IBRARIES = NOLLALILSNI NOILALILSNI LE ~~ a a8 ars fe: 4 S Cc WRN 4 re Cc “ey = apy os > & =f N ., fy = Ye a8 NDC eid 4744450 oO AYITCS> 5 z = = ‘ 9 VINOSHIINS (S31 YVeaiT LIBRARIES SMITHSONIAN INSTITUTION NOILOLILSN . ° w o Viiby FS SW = > 5 FY, = WY = 2 = CLE = MO" 5 = AA e ~ ” ce MITHSONIAN INSTITUTION NOILNLILSNINVINOSHLINS NVINOSHLINS S3IYVYdIT LIBRA NWINOSHLIWS NY ay SMITHSONIAN LIBRARIES S SMITHSONIAN INSTITUTION NOILONLILSN ens = ” \ o a ud 2 Ap a REN 4 = : mo.’ | O = Zz = =% MITHSONIAN INSTITUTION NOILNLILSNI NVINOSHLINS S3IMNVHSIT LIBRARIES SSIYVUaIT LIBRARIES SMITHSONIAN INSTITUTION Saiuvyudly Sa1yuvydiy LIBRARIES SMITHSONIAN INSTITUTION NOILNILILSN ve: NY 4g MITHSONIAN INSTITUTION NOILOALILSNI NVINOSHLINS S3IYVYSIT LIBRARIES NS NR i v INSTITUTION VINOSHLIWS , 4 NVINOSHLINS S3INYVY9IT LIBRARIE SMITHSONIAN tu I CF, en ieee NVINOSHLIWS SMITHSONIAN NVINOSHLIWS * NOILNLILSNI LIBRARIES NOILNLILSNI INSTITUTION NOILALILSN 17 LIBRARIES YVINOSHLINS S3IY¥VYUSIT LIBRARIES SMITHSONIAN \ INSTITUTION NOILNLILSNI Satyvud!i INSTITUTION INSTITUTION saluvua NOILALILSNI_NVINOSHLINS S3luvudiT_LIBRARIES NVINOSHLIWS SMITHSONIAN NYINOSHLIWS \, N \ SMITHSONIAN VINOSHLIWS LIBRARIES SMITHSONIAN INSTITUTION NOILNLILSN! .1BRARIES SMITHSONIAN JOILNLILSNI ] BRAR LES OLLALILSNI THRARTES DEPARTMENT OF COMMERCE | BUREAU OF FISHERIES GEORGE M. BOWERS, Commissioner CONDITION “AND EXTENT OF THE NATURAL OYSTER BEDS, AND BARREN BOTTOMS _> OF MISSISSIPPI EAST OF BILOXI By H. F. Moore // Assistant in Charge of Scientific Inquiry Bureau of Fisheries Document No. 774 WASHINGTON GOVERNMENT PRINTING OFFICE 1913 a) He Ke ok] CONDITION AND EXTENT OF THE NATURAL OYSTER BEDS AND BARREN BOTIOMS OF MISSISSIPPI EAST OF BILOXI By H. F. Moore Assistant in Charge of Scientific Inquiry Bureau of Fisheries Document No. 774 CON THEN T'S. Page. ee a Laie wid 2 win a Sle amen Tae seme ap Hy) NS tgs ea a aia ainsi als ca ie wa Lm Saale 6 Description of the natural beds: Et Oe Soe eee eS a he Se ake Soe Ree eo ate oO elas oan ale 11 EEE BOINOTHTY TeCOls 5. osc k ok PS a a eek 13 Pe BLOO Eo) Sa Tae SS). Sa nate ial LBS Seek ek 14 ELSE ONIG, HEU eae. 3 <2 8 eels While Leh a DWoe bigs edna dS 15 SUM EPHCEIMLORY Fey ks ee sick lis At Le we eninge baad sede AY peemrae Melow Fallroad bridge... 2... ci. - eee sete eee da Serene 18 I RMSE Soy UN aol aia alm Sicln,ch Sale ee oni ae Sino SARS 19 II ra a hg be aia 8 Sng whe aye es eis Segue ia oities Sihers 21 MMIHER ea are hoe See oo ae ee ee sa chee ne ede acemeteeme 22 names ert ret eae ila RE eT a aaa bake 27 General physical and biological conditions: I MIINMEEER ONE re lh oS So Ne Soc wise Sad Seb a see eee cdae Sele 30 TIC reer 2a) NS ay ce Ns a el 24. Malan eae ale 30 MN hs Soo ciao acme wh doce eno g PATEL NRE NN EEE DE eee Me eee ence OR 32 ERE eee re ota aio Sik eA rare tke wale Wisin d aan Greed ote aes 33 eye e tae ree eae hee e ene cua eso baatie de cae ohees 34 Nr See ee Sd as ee ee cals © 35 Summary, conclusions and recommendations..................---.+--2------- 39 j ] 4 ‘ ' ; a te at ‘ ie ? a : 4 i 1 ' 4 i i ; } ; - : 5 iY j { j { | Wi ¢ Der aU vi f} ry ths ae co gl Sted “Mes ia CONDITION AND EXTENT OF THE NATURAL OYSTER BEDS AND BARREN BOTTOMS OF MISSISSIPPI EAST OF BILOXI. By H. F. Moore, Assistant in Charge of Scientific Inquiry. INTRODUCTION. This investigation was made at the request of Hon. E. J. Noel, Governor of Mississippi, in connection with a similar survey in Alabama which already had been provided for. ad not the latter been in progress it is probable that work would have been conducted near the western end of Mississippi Sound, where the natural beds are more extensive and productive, but the economy in time effected by the contiguity of the two areas to be surveyed was a controlling factor in deciding the locus of the Mississippi investigations. There are extensive oyster interests within the area embraced by the survey, but the beds upon which they depend are principally near the western limits of the State. Formerly the largest quantity and the best quality of the oysters used in the canning and shucking houses of Mississippi came from Louisiana, but legislation in that State has placed impediments on the export of oysters to be canned or shucked in other States, with the result that the Mississippi industry has been more or less seriously handicapped for lack of proper raw material. A limited quantity of oysters is brought from Alabama for packing, principally at Biloxi. The triangulation on which the survey was based was furnished for the purpose by the United States Coast and Geodetic Survey, and is therefore accurate. All of the points established, excepting buildings and other structures of like character, are marked by substantial concrete monuments. Should Mississippi establish a system of leas- ing her barren bottoms for purposes of oyster culture these stations will furnish an invaluable basis for the survey of the leaseholds. With the reference points which they furnish it will be possible to measure the areas accurately and to locate the corners in a manner which will make impossible disputes between contiguous holders and between the lessees and the State. In all States in which oyster culture has been long established the importance of being able to refer the water surveys to permanent and accurately determined points on shore is recognized as necessary to prevent litigation, fraud, and loss to the State, and in many cases the States have been impelled to establish such marks at much expense to themselves. Thesurvey of the actual oyster beds and the barren bottoms was conducted by the Bureau of Fisheries in February and March, 1911. The work consisted of the determination 3) 6 OYSTER BOTTOMS OF MISSISSIPPI EAST OF BILOXI. of the location and extent of the oyster beds by means of biological and hydrographic examinations and investigation of the character of the barren bottoms in respect to their suitability for purposes of oyster culture. No previous investigation of this character has been made in the region covered by the survey, and there is therefore nothing on which to base comparisons with past conditions, and no way in which to determine to what extent changes in the beds have been effected by the oyster fishery or variations in the physica] characteristics of the waters and the adjacent land. METHODS OF THE SURVEY. The methods employed were those pursued in former surveys of like character, and are explained in detail in a description of the beds of the James River,* from which some of the following is repeated: A “boat sheet”? was prepared, on which were accurately platted the positions, as determined by triangulation, of lighthouses, buildings, tripods, etc.,-used as signals. These data were furnished by the United States Coast and Geodetic Survey. The oyster beds were discovered by soundings with a lead line, but principally by means of a length of chain dragged over the bottom at the end of a copper wire running from the sounding boat. The wire was wound on a reel and its unwound length was adjusted to the depth of water and the speed of the launch, so that the chain was always on the bottom. Whenever the chain touched a shell or an oyster the shock or vibration was transmitted up the wire to the hand of a man whose sole duty it was to give heed to such signals and report them to the recorder. The launches from which the soundings were made were run at a speed of between 3 and 4 miles per hour. At intervals of three minutes—in some cases two minutes—the position of the boat was determined by two simultaneous sextant observations of the angles between a set of three signals, the middle one of which was common to the two angles, the position being immediately platted on the boat sheet. At regular intervals of 15 seconds, as measured by a clock under the observation of the recorder, the leadsman made a sounding and reported to the recorder the depth of the water and the character of the bottom, immediately after which the man at the wire reported the character of the chain indications since the last sounding—that is, whether they showed barren bottom or dense, scattering, or very scattering growths of oysters. With the boat running at 3 miles per hour the soundings were be- tween 60 and 70 feet apart, and, as the speed of the boat was uniform, the location of each was determinable within a yard or two by dividing the platted distance between the positions determined by the sextant by the number of soundings. The chain, of course, gave a continuous @ Moore, H. F.: Condition and extent of the oyster beds of James River, Va. Bureau of Fisheries Document No. 729. OYSTER BOTTOMS OF MISSISSIPPI EAST OF BILOXI. 7 indication of the character of the bottom, but the record was made at the regular 15-second intervals observed in sounding. The chain, while indicating the absence or the relative abundance of objects on the bottom, gives no information as to whether they are shells or oysters, nor, if the latter, their size and condition. To obtain these data it was necessary to supplement the observations already described by others more definite in respect to the desired particulars. Whenever, in the opinion of the officer in charge of the sounding boat, such information was required, a numbered buoy was dropped, the time and number being entered in the sounding book. Another launch, following the sounding boat, anchored alongside the buoy, and a quantity of the oysters and shells were tonged up, separated by sizes, and counted. This boat at each station made a known number of “grabs” with the oyster tongs, exercising care to clean the bottom of oysters as thoroughly as possible at each grab. In a given depth of water and using the same boat and tongs, an oysterman will cover practically the same area of the bottom at each grab, but, other factors remaining the same, the area of the grab will decrease with an increase in the depth. Careful measurements were made and tabulated showing the area per grab covered by the tonger employed on the work at each foot of depth of water and for each pair of tongs and boat used. With these data, and knowing the number of ‘grabs,’ the number of oysters of each size per square yard of bottom was readily obtainable by simple calculation. The following example will illustrate the data obtained and the form of the record: DEPARTMENT OF COMMERCE AND LABOR. BUREAU OF FISHERIES. Field record of examinations of oyster beds. General locality, Mississppi Sound. Local name of oyster ground, Scranton Reef. Date, February 1, 1911. Time, 2.00 p. m. Angle, H 101. Buoy No. 6. Depth, 4.3. Bottom, Soft, over 7}’, Condition of water, Thick. Density, 1.016. Temperature, 19. Current, Stage of tide, Flood. No. grabs made, 8. Tongs, 10 feet. Total area covered, 2.36 square yards. —1 in., 20. 1 in.-3 in., 101. 1 ae 3 in.4 in., 77. 4in., 0. Quantity shells, 0. & dead. Spat per square yard, 8.8. Result; Culls per square yard, 42.2. Counts per square yard, 4.6. DB 8 OYSTER BOTTOMS OF MISSISSIPPI EAST OF BILOXI. This furnishes an exact statement of the condition of the bed at the spot, which can be platted on the chart with error in position of not more than a few yards. From the data obtained a close esti- mate may be formed of the number of bushels of oysters and shells per acre in the vicinity of the examination, and, by multiplying the observations, for the bed as a whole. Im the course of the survey 472 observations were made at various places, principally on the natural rocks, but some on the barren bottoms also. In estimating the productiveness of the bottoms it appeared desirable to use the method employed in Delaware Bay ®@ rather than that followed in the James River survey. Where tongs are used exclusively a bed with a given quantity of oysters lying in shoal water is more valuable commercially than one with the same quantity of oysters in deeper water, owing to the fact that the labor of the tonger is more efficient on the former. As has been pointed out, the area covered by a ‘‘grab”’ decreases with the depth, other factors being the same; and, moreover, the deeper the water the greater is the labor involved in making the grab and the smaller is the number of grabs which can be made in a given time. Where, however, the depth is practically uniform and shoal, as in the region treated in this report, it is unnecessarily refined and laborious to make such allowance for depth, and it is nearly as accu- rate and satisfactory to rate the bottoms in accordance with an arbitrary standard. In this report the classification of the relative productiveness of the various beds and parts of beds, as exhibited on the chart and dis- cussed in the text, is as follows: Dense crowth. 2202200 oe Bearing over 150 bushels per acre. Seatternne growta 2c 2c 5.2 cae a: Bearing between 75 and 150 bushels per acre. Very scattering growth. ......-.. Bearing between 25 and 75 bushels per acre. Depleted bottom. .............- Bearing less than 25 bushels per acre. This classification refers solely to oysters of a size assumed to be large enough for the market, in this case to those 3 inches or more in length, although the cull law of Mississippi permits oysters 24 inches long to be taken from the public beds. As the classification takes no account of the smaller oysters, certain areas bearing a heavy growth of young may be described and shown on the chart as depleted, owing to the paucity of mature oysters. A case of this character is the depleted part of West Pascagoula, where there are but 3 bushels of market oysters per acre and 279 bushels of small ones. While the charts can not indicate this, the descriptions of the beds show it in all cases. The charts show in general terms the character of the beds in respect to the product available for market, so far as mere size «Condition and extent of the natural oyster beds of Delaware. By H. F. Moore, assistant, United States Bureau of Fisheries. Bureau of Fisheries Document No. 745, 1911. o OYSTER BOTTOMS OF MISSISSIPPI EAST OF BILOXI. 9 of the oysters is concerned, at the time of the survey. If the oysters were of ordinarily good condition and shape, which unfortunately in most cases they were not, the areas indicated as bearing dense and scattering growth would yield a product sufficient to make tonging remunerative under the economic conditions existing. Where the market oysters are rated as very scattering, the growth is insufficient to support a fishery at the low price which the product would yield. The depleted bottom is that on which the product of market oysters, at the time of the survey, was very small, and is not necessarily formerly productive bottom now denuded, as might be supposed from a strict definition of the descriptive term employed. On the contrary, it may be formerly barren bottom now coming into pro- duction. The barren bottom, which is that totally devoid of oysters, and in most cases of shells, vastly exceeds the oyster bottom in extent. Its interest in connection with the survey lies in its relative avail- ability for oyster culture; that is, whether or not its general character is such as to enable it to become productive if proper measures to that end be taken. The most important consideration is, usually, the character and degree of stability of its constituent materials. If the bottom be too soft the shells and oysters deposited thereon will soon become engulfed. In previous surveys the method ordinarily used by oystermen has been employed, the consistency of the bottom bemg determined by probing with a pole. By noting the resistance which the bottom imposes to the penetration of the probe, the observer forms an opinion of its relative hardness and of its suitability, in that respect, for oyster culture. In many cases different observers will not agree as to the proper term by which to describe the bottom so tested, and it is there- fore difficult to convey to another the meaning desired. To overcome this difficulty an instrument? has been devised which gives these data mechanically, by measuring the number of inches the bottom is penetrated by a plunger of a constant weight and size falling through a uniform distance. The instrument is used from an anchored boat, from 6 to 10 tests being made at each station. Any readings which are markedly higher or lower than the others are discarded on the assumption that the plunger has fallen mto a crab hole or other depression, or that it has encountered a shell or similar accidental obstruction. The average of the remaining depths of penetration, as indicated on the scale of inches inseribed on the rod, is regarded as the measure of the consistency of the bottom. _ a Illustrated and described in ‘‘Condition and extent of the natural oyster beds and barren bottoms of Mississippi Sound, Alabama.”’ By H. F. Moore, Bureau of Fisheries Document No. 769. 10 OYSTER BOTTOMS OF MISSISSIPPI EAST OF BILOXI. The following designations used to indicate the different degrees of hardness, as shown by the instrument, are arbitrary, although based on the terms used by the oyster growers: (LE Wet begga, 2 pd Ni A el OE RC GA a! UE 4 Penetration less than 4 inches. iL OR, SRE Oe Jer ey ee Penetration between 4 and 8 inches. Sg heen 2 eee eae Pa ainey Ue nrg CI Ay | Penetration between 8 and 13 inches. DRS) | POE ON Re HOMES EN Crepe 2 la ky Ae Ua Penetration between 13 and 18 inches. OC. tee NR RN NE IR SGM oer ER OC SM Penetration over 18 inches. These various types of bottom are shown on the chart by means of circles, the relative area of black included within them indicating the relative degree of hardness, as follows: Hard, a black circle; stiff, a black semicircle; soft, a black quadrant; very soft, two cross- ing diameters; ooze, one diameter. The bottoms classed as hard and stiff, those in which the plunger will not penetrate more than 8 inches, are suitable for planting without preparation, provided they are not composed of shifting sand. As sand invariably gives a reading of less than 4 inches, and is therefore rated as ‘‘hard,’”’ it follows that all ‘‘stiff’’ bottom shown on the chart by a black semicircle can be accepted as safe for planting. Part of the hard bottom is composed of mud and part of sand. The former may be accepted without hesitation, but the latter should be examined with respect to its hability to shift. Soft bottom should be planted with care, and toward its upper or less consistent limits may require some preliminary hardening with shells or sand. Very soft bottom and ooze should not be considered, as oysters planted there will sink, and if not killed, as is probable, will be ill shaped and inferior in every respect. The ratings on which the classification is based have been checked by observation on bottoms actually used for oyster culture im Chesapeake Bay. The instrument employed has been thoroughly tested and is reli- able for the purposes of oyster surveys, but there may be errors in cases where hard bottom is overlaid by several inches of soft mud and ooze. Such bottoms are always readily detected by probing with a pole. | During the course of the survey 10,472 soundings were made and 1,826 angles for the position of the boat were taken on lines aggre- gating a length of 211 miles, over which the chain was dragged continuously. In addition to the soundings and the use of the chain on the beds, oysters were tonged, examined, and counted, and other biological observations were made at 129 places. The barren bot- toms were tested with the instrument previously described at 343 places, at each of which from 6 to 10 observations were made. The data of the survey therefore includes upward of 10,000 soundings, 211 miles of continuous chain readings, and 472 special examinations of the bottom and its contents. The whole area covered was about 75,000 acres, of which 1,708 acres were oyster-bearing bottom. OYSTER BOTTOMS OF MISSISSIPPI EAST OF BILOXI1, at DESCRIPTION OF NATURAL BEDS. SCRANTON REEF. Scranton Reef lies in the shallow water west of the mouth of Pasca- goula River. It is roughly rectangular in shape, stretching for upward of 14 miles in a southwesterly direction from the depleted bottom close to shore to a depth of 3 or 4 feet at its outer edge. Its former natural limits apparently have been greatly extended within a recent period, partly by the ordinary operations of oystering, partly through the agency of gales which have distributed oysters and shells over the surrounding mud and sand and, principally, through planting operations, reported to have been conducted by the State on the originally barren bottom contiguous to the offshore margin of the natural bed. The original reef, and practically the only part of the present bed which has reef-like characteristics, is a narrow strip of raccoon oysters having a length of about 1} miles in an approximately east and west direction, and an average width of about 200 yards. The later natural and artificial accretions to the bed lie north and south of this ridge. The bed constitutes the largest continuous area of oyster growth in that part of Mississippi covered by the survey, but the oysters at the time of examination were small, rough, and inferior, and there is every reason to believe that that has been their condition for some years. During the time of the survey practically no oysters were taken from the bed. The area, condition of oyster growth, and estimated content of this bed are shown in the following table: OysTER GROWTH ON SCRANTON REEF. Oysters per acre. | Estimated content of oysters. Character of oyster growth. Under3] Over3 ighes. iictibe. Seed. Market. Total. _—_—_————— | fe Acres. | Bushels. | Bushels. | Bushels. | Bushels. | Bushels. 44 740 1 RERUEEIN os Sonn enn nn ne ween ee ennne- Very scattering CATE CIM ieee Bi Se SR oe e eee See Sele setetecceh 169,381 | 45,760 | 215,150 The dense growth lies in the planted area outside the original reef as an arcuate strip about one-half mile long and 250 yards wide. The depth of water over this is about a foot less than on the adjacent bottom bearing a more scattering growth, and varies from about 24 feet at the northern to 4 feet at the southern end of the strip. It is 12 OYSTER BOTTOMS OF MISSISSIPPI EAST OF BILOXI. probable that included in this area may be some natural oyster beds or patches, although they may have been reduced to mere areas of hard bottom prior to the time at which they are alleged to have been planted by the State. The shoaling of the water over the strip indicates either this or an extraordinary production after planting. There are very few oysters over 4 inches long on this area and for every oyster 3 inches long or more there are 6 or more under that length, and all are poor in every respect. South of this strip and continuous with it in a depth of 4 to 5 feet is an area of scattering oysters, but the principal growth of that character lies on the old ridge previously described. On the crest of the ridge the depth is generally 1 foot or less, but the scattering — growth passes to a depth of about 24 feet at the western end in a channel running to one of the bayous. In this area there is hardly an oyster reaching a length of 4 inches and there are nearly nine times as many under 3 inches as over that. This does not mean that there is an enormous production of young, though that is also true, but that the conditions are such as to prevent oysters growing to a large size even though they may attain a considerable age. In most places examined they were densely clustered, though in one or two spots small single oysters are found in considerable numbers. There were some drills and in one or two places considerable alge or ‘‘moss.”’ The very scattering growth which constitutes about one-half of the entire bed lies in the two areas practically surrounding the denser growth. The smaller of the two is inside of the ridge in water not exceeding 2 feet deep. The larger lies outside of the ridge and on all sides of the area of dense growth previously described. In oysters of marketable size, that is those measuring 3 inches or more in length, the productiveness of the two is about equal, but small oysters are in greater abundance in the outer or planted area, especially in that part of it lying west of the dense growth. The depleted bottom is confined to the northern and eastern borders of the bed. Over the former it is characterized by the clusters of small oysters sparsely scattered, and apparently owes its existence to a set on shells carried from the more productive bottoms by storms. OYSTER BOTTOMS OF MISSISSIPPI EAST OF BILOXI. 13 DETAILS OF EXAMINATION OF SCRANTON REEF. SS Oysters cane per Shells Estimated quantity : oysters per acre. Angle oe io a Character of a al baad per y P nation. | water. growth. ae Spat. | Culls. |Counts.| Y84- | Seed. |Market.| Total. 1911 Feet. Bush. | Bush. | Bush. Feb. 1 moO%) Dense. 2. o..c.e- 18.5 87.0 10.8 0 738.5 172.8 911.3 886 | Feb. 2 2G Gl eee BOs i202 5.5 Aes: 16.0 90.0 24.0 0} 742 384 1,126 852 | Feb. 1 Zon Seatbering:...~ 55 5.5 97.5 ho 0.) 721 120 841 S60}. .G0..-.. | Ut GOdecs sse8s hee 3.0 141.0 5.0 0 |1,008 80 1,088 868 | Feb. 2 He Gt [aes UO. eecteoce 3 12.9 6.8 0 92.4 108.8 201.2 S80) 22200... .~ SAD ee Pfau eiiciae 5 6.0 41.3 AP A 0 333.1 203. 2 536. 3 Cool 2a Ce iS yl Hee Goes Ee oe, tal 55.8 5.0 0 444.5 80 524.5 T37 eae ASO e323 hie Ss ee os 2.5 9.5 7.0 0 84 112 196 843 | Feb. 1 4.3 | Very scattering... 8.3 42.2 4.6 0| 353.5 73.6 427.1 S460) 2do-. 22. 450) [etna Gols ies. 2000 23.3 4.4 0 310.8 70.4 381.2 846 |.. ae a ae : Heese ce ee yeh hai a\p ats : 37. : 2.2 0} 264. 5 7 2 me) F Ber Wo 200-... . ot ol | ite Geeoites ool oe : : .6 0 6.% .6 P Ras t200.;.. . ai al ean Se GOR ae adh = -0 16.6 1.6 OF}! -146:2 25.6 141.8 Serie. do. ..: Sek Pou. o 01 K eRe eee 20 4.7 1.9 0 32.9 30.4 63.3 Soul) Se: Cae Be one doz. .: -0 47.5 2.9 0} 332.5 46.4 378.9 869 | Feb. 2 BAO so cise 5 (0 ae YE 8 -5 75.0 2.0 0 528.5 32 560.5 Sao) |. 2000. 5. 2.91 ot 0 (ee, Spa ened 2.9 24.8 4.2 0 193.9 67.2 261.1 Sr4it. -2dou:.-. ce Gos it aes 10.7 4.4 1.9 0 105.7 30.4 136.1 Vieng eee ee “50 ae GOs2eE sees. 20.5 13.5 2.0 0} 238 32 270 Bre) ON os. 3140 ON er eats 4.1 2.7 2.3 0 47.6 36.8 84.4 Be0' |_.dos.... ASQ Meee: GOL oe a Skye 5.5 iO Har) 0 45.5 24 69.5 SSt foe s@0. 222. aeO ees GOMER: 6.8 56.8 1.9 8 445.2 30.4 475.6 Sao eGov. x M20 eee: Gotwistetaries 6.5 21.0 4.3 0 192.5 72 264. 5 Bai io-.G02..\5. PA he eee Go: S68 ees 2.5 5.4 4.2 0 Shite 67.2 122.5 888 |.. an yaar Deiiiisererts Ee cits Grepabpomiene | 7.8 86.6 202 0} 660.8 35. 2 696 889 }...do..... We) SO. 2 DRE BSC, age AIS AEs es oe | Sec k= ol (ae ant eee (eae RE A Deedee ee oe ae 2 OR Cae AON s 25 GOn see asee 1.9 15.9 ot 5 124.6 UE 142.2 894 |.. ee er. Bel) ees oo Ser ee SE 4 20. 4 7.2 0 145.6 115.2 260.8 895 )...00...... al i ee yas sear de | Wee eC MER ercty ie iaae/a eis. [sabe eraleee| lato cate ona ota e | meere tats = ‘igen in ae AAO o os ae Sea fein 4P 3 4.4 3.3 0 32.9 52.8 85.7 Se SoMaGe. LVS 9) eee YM ey Seip es | (eR Rt AMOI Ff ah ina (a SE) = A ee | ae 898i) .do.... : SOR Oe. GOe jesse -0 14.2 4.6 0 99.4 73.6 173 806 | Jan. 31 4.0 | Depleted......... AW) Hed .0 0 (ll .0 idl BO? Wat SOO. cs FS) || eee GOmMSS foe 58s -0 20 .0 0 .0 -0 .0 854 | Feb. 1 BE) eee MOK oes oe aks 1.3 CASE i 0 63 11.2 74.2 850°i1.. do... . 5 UM a Sees Geers eases -0 -6 43! 0 4.2 4.8 9 5) 6 yal SOLE Oe ashe out .0 10.3 9 0 72.1 14.4 86.5 857 ae ees PA al |e ee fe BUA S ousciem eee .0 9 8 0 3.5 12.8 16.3 865 e 2 230) ees vO) Sek a) eg of | 2 ASO A VON ARP COR al ap | Pea||e S Gl A PS) a ie RG Ni gly Ree SIT cy RN Ea my Weg aS DP ne em (Ne S67 j2.-00:...: PO eeesie es CLO Rens ar ate | 3.2 4.8 1.0 1 56 16 72 871 mone.” it Ua ae Oy jus oe ki sc 8 a) -4 0 5.6 6.4 12 Riots. edOs. .. < Garo eee GOR es NS .0 a5) 1.0 1 eied 16 19.5 875 ota teers BS ahs SE GOMES sees Same 3.0 4.4 4 0 53.9 6.4 60.3 891 dar..: SHOT | a ese GO Faces a -0 3.4 9 0 23.8 14.4 38. 2 893 otc em BL ial Keene oe GORE ese e ioe .0 4.7 .0 0 32.9 .0 32.9 899 |...do..... dee gl ake he GO eee Soe RR eee sere (eee ate lam apc ai ee cle tee Sere eee ce ne ee oe PATCHES NEAR SCRANTON REEF. At a distance of a few hundred yards from the western and south- western margin of Scranton Reef are several small patches of what appears to be a natural growth of oysters. None of these are of material importance and but one examination was made on each, although one or two lines of soundings were carried over them. The areas and productivity of these patches are shown in the table following. 14 OYSTER BOTTOMS OF MISSISSIPPI EAST OF BILOXI. OysTER GROWTH ON PatTcHES NEAR SCRANTON REEF. Oysters per acre. | Estimated content of oysters. Character of oyster growth. Are... el Under 3 | Over3 inches. inches. Seed. Market. Total. Acres. | Bushels. | Bushels. | Bushels. | Bushels. | Bushels. 840 BOREbOEINUG 0 oct eo a Suite che oie eci oe retine weit oem 10 207 77 2,070 770 , WOFWISCALLOBING . 6 lo cialis aisle mn oo ERE te 10 270 36 2, 700 360 3, 060 Demle ted... oie. eo cae cee mani ae ame ee 8 4 3 32 24 56 TOGA) etc). :2 sites se aetos ase Meine aoe Bil Hea: <) GOP esas cei .0 21.8 (As, 0 153 120 273 W4Ghie.2do... - GAO 8 Gop es ck seets 0 8.6 8.6 0 60 138 198 fie |: edo! . Lip (Ue eas Cones aanasae .0 9.4 8.1 0 66 130 196 iB GF as Fc ee SO Pees = MO se Bie eye) oe .0 33.8 6.2 0 237 99 336 i ssl eyo Pa gl paca Omen eile .6 16.5 8.0 0 116 128 244 $1GZ i. SOs... a7 AT Ee eres (0) eee ae .0 15.6 5.6 0 109 90 199 11697 |" [dO <2 Tah (js Beg Beas ie Oz ee epee | WR ee | A a De | a ae a mR KA ne | ora a | ee eR 1138 |...do....}| . 4.0] Very scattering .0 atl Bnd 0 5 59 64 1TAy |e. =do. .. G05... Couey soa 0 8.3 4.4 0 58 70 128 AIO) |e Ad Oss AnOul: be h7s Costs eese. 40 14.0 4.5 4 98 72 170 Pret ie. sdowe. = 7 AS sa ae ae Guts S35: et 3:0 0 31 53 84 BUG. Ok. EAD ioe Gos ese aa .0 1.0 2.0 0 7 32 39 Gey ps do... cares apa ORS ase ted 0 a0) a5 0 35 40 75 MAS ae Ado. - -< 4.5 | Depleted......... .0 32.8 Lal 0 230 18 248 1149 |. GO... -.. cA 4 | a (TOMES eas he se 13.0 1.0 0 95 16 111 BACK BAY, EAST BED. This bed, covering about 74 acres of bottom of varying produc- tiveness, lies about north of the draw of the Louisville & Nashville Railroad bridge. It is about five-eighths of a mile long and about 20 OYSTER BOTTOMS OF MISSISSIPPI EAST OF BILOXI. one-quarter of a mile at its widest part. It is covered by from 3 to 34 feet of water, with a somewhat greater depth on the barren bottom immediately adjacent to its borders. The productive bot- tom occupies the southern half of the bed, where a small number of tongers were at work during the survey. The oysters are badly clustered, sharp-edged, and of a poor quality. The general condition of the bed is summarized in the following table: OysTER GROWTH IN Back Bay, East BeEp. — Oysters per acre | Estimated content of oysters. Character of growth. Area. ual 5 nder 3 ver 3 Me arehaeiae i akanee! Seed. Market. | Total. Acres. | Bushels. | Bushels. | Bushels. | Bushels. | Bushels. Denise Sega Rk ole Sie ae ea 29 113 249 3,277 7,221 10, 498 Seatterne 2 ais Mere nauc ets meen waren aE 6 62 88 372 528 Merny. seatbering 2's ceri che oa te ee a 18 228 56 4,104 1, 008 5,112 Depleted sy SoMa tceee wat mene come ea aaee ae 21 47 il 987 231 1,218 TOtALE oo cocci Sea uols cue Mele Bates we wer ae LIN Ps aoa SN RC Ce ak 8, 740 8, 988 17, 728 The area of dense growth covers about 29 acres, on which there are about 249 bushels of oysters over 3 inches long and 113 bushels of smaller ones per acre. Numericaily the two classes are practi- cally equal, that is, there is a young oyster for every one above 3 inches long. In some places the bottom is fairly compact and in others the oysters lie on soft black mud with many buried shells. The oysters are generally in large rough clusters. The scattering growth lies as a narrow strip on the eastern edge of the preceding and covers about 6 acres. The young oysters are more numerous in proportion to the large ones, but both are in smaller quantity than on the dense part of the bed. On the area of very scattering growth, while the market oysters are less numerous the young are found in greater quantity than on the other parts of the bed. For each oyster over 3 inches long there are more than 9 smaller ones. The clusters contain numerous individuals, and it is apparent that the conditions are such as to retard their growth. The bottom is hard on the surface. The de- pleted bottom occupies the gradually narrowing northern end of the bed and is deficient in oysters of all sizes. The following table gives the details of the examination made on the bed: 21 OYSTER BOTTOMS OF MISSISSIPPI EAST OF BILOXI. Detaits OF EXAMINATION OF Back Bay, East Ben. Estimated quantity oysters per acre. Oysters caught per square yard. Culls. Seed. |Market.} Total. Counts. Spat. Bush. | Bush. | Bush. ees wes he .0 41.5 1525 0 290.5 248. 0 538.5 AOE ae eee .0 aso done 0 38.5 212.8 251.3 vote .0 1.4 17.8 0 9.8 284. 8 294.6 pear ere a2 O42 Ga 0 62.3 88.0 150.3 Very scattering 30 19.5 3.0 0 136.5 48.0 184.5 -0 45.5 4.0 0 318.5 64.0 382.5 ated bane .0 13s Ai 0 94.5 8.0 102.5 .0 4.0 .5 0 28.0 8.0 36.0 =f ROE .0 2.8 1S | 0 19.6 17.6 give BACK BAY, WEST BED. This bed begins about a quarter of a mile nearly west of the draw in the railroad bridge and stretches along the northern edge of the main channel for a distance of about three-fourths of a mile, its northwestern edge adjoining the boundary stakes of the planted beds. ‘The water varies from less than 3 feet near the eastern end of the bed to about 10 feet at the western edge. Among the beds of Biloxi Bay this is distinguished by the abundance of small oysters. The following table summarizes the areas, character of growth, and general condition of the several parts of the bed: OysTER GROWTH IN Back Bay, West BeEp. Oysters per acre. | Estimated content of oysters. Character of growth. Area. nee 6 nder 3 ver 3 caches Tienes Seed Market. | Total. Acres. | Bushels. | Bushels. | Bushels. | Bushes. | Bushes. [DISIS Tio. aoe ae Se ey ee Z 279 214 8, 091 6, 206 14, 297 PRE PORTIA Tee ee Sonic Ou alsia Saco cic 5 35 136 175 680 855 Meiyscrprcrimee cess! foe sleet eel bes 41 381 55 15, 621 22n5 17, 876 LS TUD IGG) Ee ee ee 20 14 1 280 20 300 TET. U8 ial es Ob Gece ae salon e cers 24, 167 9,161 33, 328 The area of dense growth is a narrow strip extending nearly the entire length of the bed and for a considerable part of the distance near its northeast edge, forming a ridge covered by very shallow water. It covers about 29 acres and bears an average per acre of 214 bushels of market oysters and 279 bushels of small ones. There are about three small oysters to each one over 3 inches long. The stock is generally of poor shape and quality and badly clustered. The area of scattering growth lies between the eastern edge of the preceding and the margin of the bed. There is a fair quantity of the larger oysters but a dearth of small ones. 28 OYSTER BOTTOMS OF MISSISSIPPI EAST OF BILOXI, The very scattering growth lies in two areas, one of about 13 acres, occupying the southern margin of the bed adjoining the channel, and the other of about 28 acres at the western end of the bed. The examination of the former indicated about 70 bushels of larger oysters and 183 bushels of smaller ones per acre. The larger area at the western end of the bed has per acre only 50 bushels of oysters over 3 inches, but is much more productive in small ones, especially in that portion which adjoins the dense growth, where examination indicated 1,120 bushels per acre. This prolificness covers but a small area and the production of both large and small oysters decreases toward the boundary stakes of the planted beds. The depleted bottom, of which there are two areas, shown on the chart, is almost bare. The following examinations were made: DerTaits oF EXAMINATION OF Back Bay, WEstT BED. Oysters epugi per Shells Estimated quantity epth squar : es st nels ee of eee ett ua quare yar an oysters per acre. ye: nation. | water. eu ar Spat. | Culls. | Counts.) Y@7°- | Seed. |Market.| Total. 1911 Feet. Bush. | Bush. | Bush. 1193 | Feb. 24 S108 Dense ya ae 0 et 10. 4 0 53.9 | 166.4 220.3 1196 |..-do-.. TOKO aes GO eiaey ee 0 65. 4 13.6 0} 457.8] 217.6 675.4 1214 |...do. CIOS eG GOS eek weeny 0 30. 0 22.0 0} 210.0} 352.0 562. 0 1215 do AOU eee GO Eee ie hen 0 56. 5 7.5 0} 395.5} 120.0 515.5 1192 do 4.0 | Scattering...._... 0 5.0 8.5 0 35.0 | 136.0 171.0 1194 |...do 3.0 | Very scattering. . 0 26. 2 4.4 0} 183.4 70.4 253.8 1197 do CWO ees Gon Aetees eae 0} 160.0 3.6 0 {1,120.0 57.6 |) Rabie 1198 do An eiaieesin ¥ GOS FS! os 0 12.8 2. 2 0 89.6 35. 2 124.8 1199 |...do (Ss (Olin eC Koy Sve era 0 18.6 3.6 0} 1380.2 57.6 187.8 1213 do 3.8 | Depleted......... 1 2.0 1 0 14.7 1.6 16.3 1216 |...do SAO aes COM elena 0 1.9 .0 0 13.3 ai) 13.3 THE BEDS IN SUMMARY. The natural oyster beds of Mississippi east of Biloxi are restricted to the waters adjacent to the mouth of the Pascagoula River and Biloxi Bay. The beds of the former locality, of which there are two and some insignificant patches, embrace almost exactly two-thirds of the naturally productive bottom; Scranton Reef, the larger of the beds, comprises nearly one-half of the oyster area of the region sur- veyed, and West Pascagoula Reef about one-sixth. The two, with the small patches alluded to, cover about 1,126 acres, of which 115 acres have a dense growth of oysters of marketable size, 115 acres a scattering growth, 531 acres a very scattering growth, and 365 acres are so sparsely covered as to be classified as depleted. All of these lie in water not exceeding 5 feet in depth and most of them, especially the more productive parts, are covered by 3 feet or less. In Biloxi Bay there are four beds of more than insignificant size. The largest of these, covering about 234 acres, lies on the west side below the railroad bridge. The others in the order of their areas —————er—ee ee SSeS eee OYSTER BOTTOMS OF MISSISSIPPI EAST OF BILOXI. 23 are near the southeastern end of Deer Island, and the western and eastern, beds, respectively, above the railroad bridge. In addition there are a number of small patches below the railroad bridge, the largest of which is believed to be a public planted bed. Altogether there are in Biloxi Bay about 582 acres of oyster bottom, of which 102 acres are classed as dense, 143 as scattering, 222 as very scatter- ing, and 115 as depleted. Of the entire area of 1,708 acres of natural oyster bottom located by the survey, 13 per cent is covered by a dense growth of oysters of marketable size, 15 per cent by a scattering growth, 44 per cent by a very scattering growth, and 28 per cent is depleted or very deficient in such oysters. The following table summarizes the distribution of the oysters on the several beds: SUMMARIZED STATEMENT OF AREAS OF MARKET OYSTERS ON Pusuic BEDs. Character of oyster growth. ) 3 Total. Name of bed glue Very otal Dense. in seatter- |Depleted. g- ing. Acres Acres. Acres. Actes. Acres. 5 ETERS TEC Ue ole ET ee See es 44 105 402 262 813 EP aPCheS Mean Seranlton ECCl. 2: . 2...) 2ss-~- sees s ne} beeen ee 10 10 8 28 OOPS EES Cree LR 2) TLL ReER eae 119 95 285 IDtte US EiG DE Sy sola: ae re, ee 5 19 35 AT 106 SHIA PALeNes, INOXd Bay... 252... 7 2s.ce. eee ee 5 7 60 1 73 Biloxi Bay, below railway bridge..............-..--.- 34 106 68 26 234 Dec) SS) EE SF | 0210 ee a a 29 6 18 21 74 SUE RIVESI DEO So. fs a oN ocala cicien Pawia saad 28 + i 29 5 41 20 95 LES Es ee a 217 258 753 480 1,708 It should be understood that the foregoing classification in respect to relative density of oyster growth is based solely on the quantity of oysters 3 inches or more in length irrespective of the quantity of small oysters present. The classification, furthermore, represents the condition at the time of examination and the several classes may and undoubtedly will undergo redistribution from time to time. The areas of dense growth may become less productive from over- fishing or other causes while a heavy set of spat may bring the lower classes into increased productivity and raise them a step higher in the scale. In some cases the number of young oysters on the beds at the time of examination was sufficient to produce this effect in the following year. On the whole, however, the general conditions shown in this report, barring accidents, should be maintained for a period of years. The estimated total content of oysters over 3 inches long on the several parts of the different beds is shown in the table following. 94 OYSTER BOTTOMS OF MISSISSIPPI FAST OF BILOXI. SUMMARIZED CONTENT OF MARKET OYSTERS ON PuBLic BEbs. Character of oyster growth. Name of bed. Total. Very Dense. | Scatter- | scatter. Depleted. ing. ing. Bushels. | Bushels. | Bushels. | Bushels. | Bushels. Serantom Reehdie: cist cea thy Meus Ne ace uM mete a aay a 12, 232 12, 285 18, 894 2,358 45,769 Patchesinear Scranton Reef ty Sees ey a es el aera 770 360 24 1,154 Wrest) Pascagoula Reenses jure Soy. caine sia iene op sna mPa. Ih GA A SEN 4,522 285 16, 948 Deer island HMastiPoimt. use ts ee eee rea 920 1,786 1,400 329 4,435 Smaillinavehes: Elomi ayes eee en eae oe 1,385 847 2,400 8 4,640 Biloxi Bay, below railway bridge...................- 10,098 12,932 3,672 442 27,144 Back Bay east bed. gaia 0 GUE) a 7, Dod 528 1,008 231 8,988 BackyBaiy,, west bedaeny ec) So AeA RR ee 6, 206 680 2, 255 20 9,161 AIS Gea 06) ON A AS NO A Pee 50, 2038 29, 828 34, 511 3,697 118, 239 Fifty-four per cent, or 63,871 bushels of the larger oysters dis- closed by the survey were found in the region adjacent to the mouth of Pascagoula River. Of these, 24,373 bushels were in dense growth, 13,055 bushels scattering, 23,776 bushels very scattering, and 2,667 bushels on the depleted bottom. The remaining 54,368 bushels, constituting about 46 per cent of the total, were in Biloxi Bay, where 25,830 bushels occurred as dense growth, 16,773 bushels as scattering, 10,735 bushels as very scattering, and but 1,030 bushels were on the so-called depleted bottom. The average product per acre on the beds near Pascagoula River was 221 bushels on the dense, 113 bushels on the scattering, 45 bushels on the very scattering, and 7 bushels on the depleted bottoms. In Biloxi Bay the averages are 249 bushels per acre on the dense growth, 117 bushels on the scattering, 48 bushels on the very scatter- ing, and 9 bushels on the depleted bottom. It is therefore evident that the oysters on the areas classed as very scattering and de- pleted are so sparsely distributed that they are at present negligible commercially on account of the time and labor which would be involved in tonging them. About 72 per cent of the oyster pro- ducing bottom is, therefore, to be regarded as of no present producing value. The remaining 28 per cent of the area of the beds produces oysters in sufficient quantity to warrant a fishery if size only is considered, but many of the oysters are so badly clustered and so inferior in quality that they have very little value. This is partic- ularly the case on Scranton and West Pascagoula Reefs. The only good oysters seen in that vicinity were in the deep water of Pascagoula River, where singles and small clusters are taken in limited quantity. In Buloxi Bay not only is the average productive- ness of the dense and scattered growth greater, but the areas of these growths are greater in proportion to the total extent of the beds, and the oysters are of somewhat better quality. OYSTER BOTTOMS OF MISSISSIPPI EAST OF BILOXI. 25 The dense and scattered growths, but especially the former, are doubtless somewhat more prolific than is estimated in this report, as where the oysters are very rank the tongs in many cases do not take up all within the extent of the “grab,” and as the estimates are based on the area covered by the open tong heads and the number of oysters brought up in a definite number of grabs, there is certainty of an underestimate. On less prolific bottom this error does not occur. It should be stated that the bushel employed, while of the legal dimen- sions, contains more than the trade bushel, because to secure uni- formity of results the oysters are culled into singles or doubles and carefully packed in the measure. It is estimated that it holds, for this reason, 25 to 30 per cent more than when filled in the ordinary way. The small oysters, on which the future of the beds is in large measure dependent, differ from the larger oysters very materially in their distribution, as is shown in the following table: SUMMARIZED CONTENT OF YOUNG OYSTERS ON PUBLIC BEDs. Character of oyster growth. Name of bed. Total. Scatter- | _ Very Dense. A scatter- |Depleted. mE: ing. S. Bushels. | Bushels. | Bushels. Bushels. | Bushel SOPEI ESE: Eo ee Bi 32, 560 46, 935 82, 812 7, 074 169, 381 baiehes dean sceranton Reel. 22... ......c-hide ceeds. S- | eee ee 2,070 2,700 32 4,802 OS Se ES) a BO; sob! fess tae 22 21, 063 26, 505 137, 099 De US SNL S| a a 670 399 1,015 47 2,131 Sita RICHES, NOX) Bay Jo.......- 0) 222. e.e 28 22 600 693 2, 280 33 3, 606 Biloxi Bay, below railway bridge..............--..- 6, 120 14,840 2, 652 4, 238 27, 850 Menomena Det. Se ee ker bl 3, 277 372 4,104 987 8, 740 TS TELE ECS AS oat 0 Le 8, 091 175 15, 621 280 24, 167 EEE Ls 8S OPS ee ee ee ee 140, 849 65,484 | 132,247 39, 196 377, 776 It will be observed that in the entire region surveyed there is over three times the quantity of small oysters as of large ones, but if the table be subjected to analysis it will be found that they are very unequally distributed between the Pascagoula and Biloxi localities. Of the total 377,776 bushels, 311,282 bushels, or over 82 per cent, are found in the former, and but 66,494 bushels, or less than 18 per cent, in the latter. In the former there is nearly five times the quantity less than 3 inches long that there is of larger ones, while in Biloxi Bay there is but little difference. On Scranton and West Pascagoula Reefs and the adjacent small patches there are averages of 1,061 bushels per acre on the dense growth, 426 bushels on the scattering, 200 bushels on the very scattering, and 92 bushels on what is called depleted bottom. In other words, for every bushel of oysters of market size there are on the dense areas 4.8 bushels of small ones, on the scattering growth 3.8 bushels, on the very scattering growth 4.4 bushels, and on the depleted bottom 13 bushels. °6 OYSTER BOTTOMS OF MISSISSIPPI EAST OF BILOXI. On the beds of Biloxi Bay, taken as a whole, the dense areas con- tain 184 bushels of small oysters per acre, the scattering 115 bushels, the very scattering 115 bushels, and the depleted 48 bushels. Com- paring the quantity of small and large oysters, the areas of dense erowth have 0.7 bushel of the former to each bushel of the latter, the scattering growth 1 bushel, the very scattermg growth 2.5 bushels, and the depleted bottom 5.6 bushels. As #% requires more small oysters than large ones to make a bushel, and as the value of the small ones depends upon their potentiality to srow into large ones, the proportion between the numbers of small and large is of more importance than the comparison of their quanti- ties. This proportion for each class of growth on each bed is shown in the following table: NUMBER OF OysTERS UNDER 3 INcHES LONG FoR EacH ONE OVER THAT LENGTH ON THE SEVERAL BEDs. Character of oyster growth. Name of bed. Very Dense. ee - | scatter- | Depleted. g- ing. SCTamMGOm VVC ST es ess Tee aT Os 0s UI iat Nee 6. 07 8.70 10. 12 7. 28 Patches meareranton Reelin ee a es 6. 16 17. 13 3. 00 West: PascagoulasReel.222 2245 fee ee i ek a Se VGYSO) easier cs 10. 70 227. 71 Deerisland sWastiPoimGe: axle wi Ok all oer. IN 1. 67 - 60 1.62 46 Small patehes, Biloxi Bay 2220-522. seco sees e ce eecce see . 99 1.86 2. 20 9. 30 Biloxi Bay, below railway bridge ............-..----.-- 1.38 2.62) . 1.63 22. 00 Backs Bay east OCG Hae ease ee TUN iS vy Re TU 1.03 1. 62 9. 28 9. 66 Back Bay westibed tga tar a ain aaa hc eee 2. 98 59 15. 76 40. 00 Analyzing this table by regions, it is found that on the beds in the vicinity of Pascagoula River for every oyster 3 inches or more in length there are on the dense growth about 11 small ones, on the scattering 8, on the very scattering 11, and on the depleted bottom 28. Most of these are between 2 and 3 inches long. On the beds in Biloxi Bay there are respectively 1.6. small oysters to each large one on the dense growth, 2 on the scattering growth, 5.3 on the very scattering growth, and 12 on the depleted bottom. In Biloxi Bay the proportion of small to large oysters is in no way unusual. On the areas of dense and scattering growth the propor- tions are such as indicate a normal condition of the beds, although there is a deficiency of small oysters on the scattered growth of Deer Island and Back Bay west beds. The high proportion of young on the depleted areas of certain beds is due not to their unusual abund- ance but to the scarcity of the larger ones with which they are compared, as may be seen by the detailed tables contained in the descriptions of the individual beds. On the beds at the mouth of Pascagoula River the condition is different. There the small oysters are superabundant almost every- OYSTER BOTTOMS OF MISSISSIPPI EAST OF BILOXI, 27 where. There appear to be three conceivable explanations of this preponderance—(qa) an extraordinary set of spat in the year preceding the survey following the destruction of the beds by freshets or other causes, (6) an unusually heavy set of spat without the destruction of the mature oysters, and (c) an average condition with respect to spat production, but general conditions of environment which prevent or retard the normal growth of the oysters. Judging from the appearance of the reefs and such information as it was possible to obtain concerning their history it appears that the third is the true explanation of the unsatisfactory state of the oysters. While the spatting conditions are good there is apparently a deficiency of the food requisite for the growth and fattening of the dense oyster population. The oysters are crowded in clusters and the individuals are unable to secure the requisite amount of nutriment. The planting of oysters on the bottom adjoining the original bed of Scranton Reef accentuated the trouble and was ill advised. Better success probably would have attended planting in deeper water and where the tidal flow is stronger. These beds densely crowded with small and inferior oysters are of no immediate commercial value. Apparently their only use is for seed beds from which the small oysters might be transplanted to localities more favorable for growth. BARREN BOTTOMS. The area of barren bottoms—that is, those which are not naturally productive of oysters even in small quantities—vastly exceeds that of the natural beds, including in the latter those so-called depleted areas which bear practically nothing. These bottoms are barren, mainly because of one character in which they differ from the productive areas—namely, that they are devoid of shells or other objects lying on the surtace. They consist of sand and mud of varying degrees of stability and consistency. Oysters, immediately after they develop from the egg, for a brief period swim or float freely in the water, settling to a fixed condition only after they reach a stage of consid- erable development.” It is not necessary to give more detail to this subject other than to say that at the time at which they are undergoing fixation the oysters are very minute, and a slight film of mud or slime is sufficient to stifle them. During the spawning season these little organisms are present in the water in untold myriads and are precipitated to the bottom in a continuous gentle drizzle of tiny specks. If they fall on an oyster bed they find firm supports on the shells and oysters, attach them- selves and grow, but if they fall on the mud or bare sand they die. a For a more extended account see ‘‘Oysters and methods of oyster culture,” by H. F. Moore, Bureau of Fisheries Document 349, which may be obtained by application to the Bureau at Washington, D.C. 28 OYSTER BOTTOMS OF MISSISSIPPI EAST OF BILOXI. The natural beds have been slowly developed on bottom similar to that which surrounds them solely because through some agency there originally lodged on the mud or sand some hard objects to which the young oysters could safely cling. Oysters developing there and their shells scattered about by the waves furnished additional places for fixation of new generations of young, with the result that the original growth extended in area and its bed became a compact mass of shells and fragments, beneath which can still be found by excavation or probing the original bottom differing in no essential particular from the adjacent barren areas. All that is required by the barren bottom in order that it may become productive is that its surtace should be supplied with hard objects or cultch, either through natural agencies or by the hand of man. The capacity of the bottom to sustain material deposited on it and to maintain it in proper condition to serve as cultch depends ~ largely on its stability and consistency. Moving sands gradually cover objects deposited on their surface and soft mud permits them to sink. It is therefore of prime importance for the oyster culturist to have information concerning the character of the bottom, and it was one of the purposes of the survey to supply it. The methods and the instrument employed have been described in the introductory part of this report and the results attained are shown graphically on the chart. The symbols on the chart designating the character of the bottom do not show all of the places at which examinations were made. They were merely representative of the general characteristics in their vicinity with respect to the bottom deposits. It will be observed that the chart shows, in general, a gradually increasing softness of the bottom toward the middle of the sound. The survey in the adjoining part of Alabama demonstrated that the very soft or oozy mud extends nearly to the islands on the south, adjoming which there is a narrow strip of sand, and, in view of the apparently similar con- ditions in Mississippi and the limited time at the disposal of the party, it was deemed unnecessary to continue the examinations beyond the line at which it was evident that the bottom was growing too soft for oyster culture. Excluding the shoal waters near shore, which it is understood are to a considerable extent subject to the control of riparian owners, the firmer bottom lies within five general areas, embracing about 23,000 acres, which are described as follows: Grand Batture Shoal.—This shoal extends in a curve, concave, toward the east, from the west end of Grand Batture Spit to a beacon in about 8 feet of water near the middle of the sound. The shoal itself hes in a depth of 6 feet or less and is composed of more or less shifting sand, apparently too unstable for oyster culture, but sur- EE OYSTER BOTTOMS OF MISSISSIPPI EAST OF BILOXI. 29 rounding it, especially between its eastern margin and the Mississippi- Alabama line, the sand is mingled with sufficient mud to give it the required consistency. ‘This firm bottom lies in a depth of between 8 and 12 feet and covers an area of about 4,200 acres. It is fairly well protected from freshets and is of a character which should permit it to be worked with dredges. Point aux Chenes.—Lying south and southwest of the western half of Point aux Chenes is a strip of stiff and soft mud stretching from the hard sand fringing the shore to a distance of about 14 miles from land and with a length of upward of 2 miles east and west. Its western extremity is near Beacon B marking the approach to Pas- cagoula. The depth of water ranges from 6 to 13 or 14 feet and the area of the tract is about 2,000 acres. ‘This bottom is softer than that previously described, but a considerable part of it is suitable for planting either oysters or cultch. Its proximity to the mouth of Pascagoula makes it susceptible to the influences of freshets. East of Round Island.—Adjacent to Round Island, especially on the east and south sides, is a sandy shoal gradually merging with the surrounding mud. The sandy bottom in depths of less than 5 or 6 feet appears to be shifting, but in the deeper water to the eastward toward the Pascagoula Channel there is sufficient mud to serve as a ‘binder,’ and enough sand to correct the excessive plasticity of the mud. In consistency this bottom varies from “hard” to “‘soft,”’ most of it being what is designated in this report as “‘stiff.”” This area, which covers about 1,300 acres, is open to the same objection _as-the area of Point aux Chenes—its exposure to the effects of freshets owing to its proximity to the mouth of Pascagoula River. Off Bellefontaine Coast—From about 1 mile west of the mouth of Graveline Bayou there is a strip of more or less hard bottom stretch- ing almost without interruption to Biloxi Channel, but for conven- ience of description it appears advisable to divide it at the shoal run- ning from the east end of Deer Island. The portion here described is a curved strip about 5 miles long and from 1 to 3 miles wide encir- cling the shoal projecting from Bellefontaine Coast. It lies in water from 6 to 11 feet deep and varies in consistency from stiff to soft. In shoaler water the bottom is composed of hard sand liable to shift and in deeper water the mud is too soft. Owing to its proximity to Dog Keys Pass and its relative remoteness from large fresh-water affluents, it is subject to less danger than the preceding two localities in times of flood. It covers an area of approximately 6,500 acres. Off Deer Island.—vhis area stretches from the western end of the preceding to the dredged channel leading to Biloxi, outside the sandy area fringing the shore and forming a bar at the eastern end of the island. In depths less than 6 feet the bottom probably shifts more or less under the influence of waves and currents, and is therefore 30 OYSTER BOTTOMS OF MISSISSIPPI EAST OF BILOXI. hazardous for oyster culture, although a few natural growth oysters are found on it in places. In depths between 6 and 9 or 10 feet, and probably somewhat greater, there is a good stiff and soft bottom, most of the area falling within the former classification. Although it is impossible to determine definitely without actual practical experiment, this area, which covers upward of 9,000 acres, appears to be well adapted to oyster culture. The streams discharging in its immediate vicinity are comparatively small, and it is in proximity to Dog Key and Ship Island Passes, therefore being guarded to a con- siderable extent from destructive reduction of salinity during freshets. The greater salinity might invite the mroads of drills or conchs, but this danger could be somewhat mmimized by planting seed oysters rather than cultch. GENERAL PHYSICAL AND BIOLOGICAL CONDITIONS. TIDES AND CURRENTS. | During the hydrographic and biological survey tide gauges were maintained at Pascagoula and Biloxi. The former was a plain staff, graduated in feet and tenths, established at the end of the boathouse at the light keeper’s house at the mouth of the Pascagoula River. The automatic gauge established by the United States Army engineers was out of order and there was no bench mark available for reference. Mean low water was established by readings from February 7 to March 14, and by comparison with observations made simultaneously during 20 days at Biloxi. At Biloxi a similar gauge was observed from February 21 to March 12, the mean low water being established by reference to the United States engineers’ gauges on channel beacons A and D, which have been referred by leveling to the United States Coast and Geodetic Survey bench mark. | The observations were made primarily for the correction of the soundings, and as the daily tidal range is small, usually about 18 inches, they are of little interest in connection with oyster culture or the fishery. The tidal currents in the region are more or less modified in velocity and duration by the winds, which often mask the lunar tides. In general the currents are sufficient to maintain the distribu- tion of oyster food. SALINITY OF THE WATER. The quantity of saline matter in solution in the water is an im- portant factor in determining the growth and character of oysters. If salt be absent entirely, or if its quantity be as great as that carried by the waters of the open sea, oysters will not live, and as these two extremes are approached the adverse effects are seen in the stunted OYSTER BOTTOMS OF MISSISSIPPI EAST OF BILOXI, 31 or otherwise inferior character of the oysters produced. The effects of the salinity of the water are not restricted to the direct influence on the oysters, but may affect them indirectly by furthering or retard- ing the occurrence of enemies and growths inimical to them. The conch, or drill, for mstance, does not thrive in water having a low salt content, while, on the contrary, mussels, the vigorous growth of which is highly detrimental to oysters, often flourish in low salinities. ; During the survey the specific gravity of the water was tested thrice daily on the Fish Hawk and in addition several observations were made each day by the party actually working on the beds. The fol- lowing table summarizes the results of these observations: Specific GRAVITY OF WATER AT VARIOUS PLACES AND DATES. Average | Average | Maximum | Minimum Locality. Daie. tempera-| specific specific specific ture. gravity. gravity. gravity. 1910-11 °F ie detente CHODOS.. 2b Lccceccceccccs- Feb: 9-11..:... 63 1.0190 1.0204 1.0164 Feb. 14-16....- 67 1.0170 1.0194 1.0128 ESPN MOIS nnn ew ana ncecvcerncissexa- Dec. 24-27..... 49 1.0196 1.0209 1.0187 Jan. 20-24..... 61 1.0122 1.0154 1.0106 Jan. 29-31..... 65 1.0169 1.0188 1.0152 Heb: ito s. ch. 67 1.0121 1.0156 1. 0063 Bebs.5-85.25-5< 71 1.0136 1.0173 1.0075 Feb. 12-14..... 61 1.0136 1.0180 1. 0084 Mar. 6-8......- 66 1.0168 1.0178 1.0139 Apr: 24s. S26 70 1.0152 1.0190 1.0146 Three miles south of Graveline Bayou....| Feb. 16-18..... 68 1.0175 1.0194 1.0133 ‘ Mar. 13-14..... 65 1.0209 1.0210 1.0208 Three miles off Biloxi Bay........--.--... Heb. WO. cactncs 70 1.0178 1, 0207 1. 0138 Three miles southwest of Deer Island..... Wier 4G). ces 63 1.0189 1.0196 1.0182 ar. 8 shes 69 1.0198 1.0212 1.0184 Mareti=13.-..2 71 1.0193 1.0203 1.0187 (3 GSED Le Se Feb. 20-23..... 54 1.0151 1.0177 1.0118 Feb. 24-27 58 1.0150 1.0156 1.0129 Feb. 28—Mar. 3 63 1.0170 1.0186 1.0127 Mar. 9-10...... 68 1.0187 1.0192 1.0182 This table embraces observations made at intervals between De- cember 24, 1910, and April 4, 1911, part of the period, from January 20 to March 10, being covered with practically no interruption. During this time the specific gravity varied from’a maximum of 1.0210 off the mouth of Graveline Bay on March 14 to a minimum of 1.0063 at Pascagoula on February 4, and the local averages for periods of several days ranged with time or place between 1.0209 off Graveline Bayou on March 13 and 14 to 1.0121 at Pascagoula on February 1 to February 4. These figures compare with fresh water as 1.0000 and ocean water as 1.0250 or 1.0260. The minima shown in the table all occurred at low water and the maxima at or near high water. The lowest readings were taken in Pascagoula River, the station being located at the railroad bridge, where there was a con- siderable difference between the salinity of successive high and low waters. The highest average, as well as the lowest daily fluctuation, 77630°—13——3 32 OYSTER BOTTOMS OF MISSISSIPPI EAST OF BILOXI. was found off Deer Island, near Biloxi. Nowhere during the survey was the salinity above or below that which oysters will tolerate, although in Pascagoula River it sometimes fell below that at which good marketable stock is ordinarily produced. In times of prolonged and very heavy rainfall undoubtedly the water in Pascagoula River becomes entirely or practically fresh, and the influence of its discharge must be felt in a pronounced reduction of the salinity of the sound near its mouth. OYSTER FOOD. In reports on previous surveys a feature usually has been made of the subject of the quantity of oyster food carried by the waters. These discussions have been confined, practically, to diatoms, minute microscopic plants, which authors generally have been prone to regard as supplying practically all of the oyster’s nutriment. Volu- metric studies of the micro-organism content of the water begun in connection with the survey of Matagorda Bay ® in 1905 revealed a quantity so small as to excite the author’s suspicion that the living matter was of less relative importance than had been generally supposed. It appeared possible, however, that the quantity of water filtered by the oyster might be greater than generally supposed and digestion more rapid, and that despite appearances the small quantity of microscopic living organisms in the water and present in the stomach at any one time might be sufficient material for the growth and gen- eral physiological activities of a sluggish animal like the oyster. To test the matter, apparatus and methods ® were devised for the volumetric determination of the organisms actually eaten during comparable periods of time. The result of this work, which has been carried on at intervals for several years by the author and Mr. T. E. B. Pope, has shown that while the quantity of water filtered is great, averaging roughly about 30 quarts daily for oysters 44 mches long, the volume of the living food is insufficient to account for the actual growth of the oyster, making no allowance for the requirements of other vital activities. It appears that finely divided organic debris or detritus, which constitutes the major part of the material ingested, plays a more important role in the oyster diet than has been con- ceded, a view which recently has been advanced by Petersen and Jensen.° aSurvey of oyster bottoms in Matagorda Bay, Tex. By H. F. Moore. Report of the Bureau of Fish- eries, 1905. Bureau of Fisheries Document No. 610. b Volumetric studies of the food and feeding of oysters. By Hl. F. Moore. (Proceedings of the Fourth International Fishery Congress, Washington, 1908.) Bulletin, Bureau of Fisheries, vol. xXvim, 1908, pp. 1295-1308. c Valuation of the sea. I.—Animal life of the sea bottom, its food and quantity. By C. G. Joh. Petersen and P, Boysen Jensen. Report of the Danish Biological Station, XX. Copenhagen, 1911. OYSTER BOTTOMS OF MISSISSIPPI EAST OF BILOXI, 33 In view of these facts and probabilities, and the present impossi- bility: of establishing a standard for the expression of the quantity of food available, the data respecting the food content of the water collected during this survey will not be stated here. A special paper on the entire subject of the food and feeding of oysters wil be issued on the completion of the studies. It may be stated from observation of the oysters and on general grounds that the food supply in Mississippi Sound and minor con- tiguous waters is ample. OYSTER ENEMIES. As the survey was carried on during the early spring, when the water was still comparatively cold, the observations made are prob- ably not to be regarded as a reliable index to the abundance of oyster enemies. None were observed but a few drills, mostly small, and an insignificant number of mussels. The low temperature of the water could have had but little effect on the latter, and it is fair to assume that ordinarily they are nowhere present in sufficient numbers to prove seriously detrimental to the oysters. As observations on other parts of the Gulf coast have shown that certain enemies to the oyster are of general occurrence, it appears advisable to furnish some general information respecting them. Drill, borer, snail, whelk, conch (Purpura hemostoma).—This animal, which bears these several names on the Gulf coast, was found very sparingly during the survey in Mississippi waters, and there was little other indication of its presence. A few small ones were taken on Scranton Reef and in Biloxi Bay, but in neither place was there found a sufficient number of drilled oyster shells to indicate that it had been recently abundant. It is liable to occur, however, espe- cially in the more saline water, and care should be exercised not to introduce it with seed oysters from infested beds. The drill or whelk lays its eggs in red or purple leathery capsules about one-half inch long and attached in clusters to shells, snags, and other firm bodies in the water. The young become destructive to the minute spat immediately upon emerging from the egg cases; they grow rapidly and progress in destructiveness as they increase in size. They destroy the oysters by drilling a small round hole through the shell, using for the purpose a flexible rasp-like organ lying at the end of a protrusible proboscis. After the shell is perforated the proboscis is thrust into the shell and the contents eaten, other drills sometimes partaking of the feast by entering the gaping shell of the dead or dying oyster. Most of the oysters destroyed are under 2 inches long, but large drills often kill more adult oysters. Mussels —The common black sea mussel is a passive enemy of oysters, through its tendency to attach to them and under favorable 34 OYSTER BOTTOMS OF MISSISSIPPI EAST OF BILOXI. conditions to grow so rapidly and in such numbers as to completely cover and stifle them. Also, as its food is the same as that of the oyster, its abundance reduces the supply and in that way deprives the oyster of the nutriment required to make it fat and marketable. Even when neither of these effects are important, mussels injure the fishery, owing to the tenacity with which they are anchored to the oyster, which increases the labor of culling and makes the oyster so unsightly from the adhering fibers of the byssus as to considerably reduce its market value if sold as shell stock. The conditions which make for the abundance of the mussel are not thoroughly understood, but on the Gulf coast it appears to be controlled largely by the saltness of the water, the mussels generally flourishing where the salinity is low for prolonged periods. Comparatively few were found in the region surveyed, and it is probable that they never or rarely become troublesome on account of the a salinity frequently occurring. Drumfpfish (Pogonas cromis).—This, the ‘‘black drum,” was not observed during the survey, but it is a destructive enemy of the oyster in other parts of the Gulf coast and is reported to destroy oysters on the adjacent beds of Alabama. It is migratory, making sudden forays and leaving, with destruction in its wake, often before its pres- ence has been noticed. It destroys the oysters by crushing them between the stout grinding teeth or bones with which its mouth is furnished, and it is peculiarly destructive to the better grade of planted beds on which the oysters have been culled and separated to permit them to grow and improve in shape and quality. It is especially hkely to attack the culled oysters within a few weeks of the time when they are planted, but they are not immune at any time. In Louisiana the drumfish is so destructive in places that the oyster- men find it necessary to exclude them by surrounding their bedding grounds with wire fences. Oysters in the natural beds, especially when they are much clus- tered and of the sharp-edged raccoon type, are rarely injured seri- ously, as the sharp edges of the shells, presented in all directions, lacerate the lips and mouth of the fish and deter them from exten- sive destruction. Occasionally the small oysters culled off by the oystermen are damaged. | The drumfish occurs in waters of all degrees of salinity, from fresh -_ or practically fresh to full oceanic density. SPAWNING. The survey was conducted at the season when the reproductive functions ‘of the oysters are in abeyance, and therefore no definite statement of the spawning season in Mississippi can be made. Vari- ous investigations carried on by the Bureau at the western end of OYSTER BOTTOMS OF MISSISSIPPI EAST OF BILOXI. 35 Mississippi Sound, where the general conditions affecting spawning are essentially the same as at the eastern end, make it possible to indicate with some precision the period during which the spawn is likely to be emitted. It is probable that the eggs may ripen even in the winter during sustained warm periods, but it is doubtful in these cases, even though the eggs be fertilized, if development ever proceeds far enough to secure a set of spat. The normal spawning probably occurs from April to October, as it does in similar waters in Louisiana, and clean shells or other cultch planted during those months should receive a good set of spat. The young oysters are free-swimming organisms during a short period of their early life, and as they are produced in untold myriads on the crowded natural beds and carried considerable distances by the currents, the water over a large part of the sound must be teeming with the fry during the favorable part of the year. Most of these embryo oysters perish through falling on unsuitable bottom at the stage of the shell formation when they are still barely visible to the unaided eye, and may be stifled by an exceedingly thin deposit of mud or slime. Those fortunate enough to alight on shells or other oysters and similar firm supports survive in large numbers, as is witnessed by the crowded condition of the beds, but over the vastly greater proportion of the bottom there is nothing to afford a haven. The only fundamental difference between an oyster bed and the surrounding barren bottom is that the former presents places for the attachment of the spat and the latter does not. Many free-swimming oyster fry are also killed by sudden drops in temperature, though this is not common on the Gulf coast, and by heavy rainfalls. The latter also tend to retard or suspend spawning through lowering the salinity of the water, and it frequently happens that heavy freshets defer spawning until summer. As freshets usually leave the shells and other cultch in excellent condition so far as cleanliness is concerned, probably through the destruction of slime- producing organisms, it frequently happens that a late spawning season produces an enormous set. OYSTER CULTURE. Oyster culture in the sense employed on the Atlantic and Pacific coasts and in some of the Gulf States is almost negligible of consider- ation, as at present practiced in Mississippi. The State conducts planting operations on the public bottoms, expending large sums annually during the years 1908 to 1911 in depositing oysters and shells on the reefs and adjacent barren bottoms, but there is very little oyster planting under private auspices, and none at al! excepting under rights accruing to riparian owners. In 1911, but 4 per cent of the oysters produced in the State came from private beds, a smaller 36 OYSTER BOTTOMS OF MISSISSIPPI EAST OF BILOXI. proportion than in any other Gulf State excepting Texas. In Loui- siana, in the same year, 44 per cent of the oysters produced were grown on bottom rented from the State, and the yield from this source alone was three times the quantity, and over four times the value, of the entire product of Mississippi. Most of the planting by the State was west of the region covered by the survey, but large quantities of shells and oysters have been deposited on Scranton Reef and the Biloxi Bay beds, the condition of which was developed during the present investigation, and is pre- sented in some detail in the preceding part of this report. It is the opinion of the author that the survey developed the almost complete futility of the State’s policy so far as the region east of Biloxi is con- cerned. Pascagoula or Scranton Reef, and West Pascagoula Reef were practically worthless as market oyster producers during the win- ter and spring of 1910-11. During a considerable period of observa- tion no boats, excepting one or two small skiffs, were seen on the former, and but one schooner on the latter. The oysters were badly clustered, ill shaped, and poor in every way. Durimg the calendar year 1911 about 28,000 bushels of oysters were taken by small boats from the vicinity of Pascagoula. Some of these came from the Pasca- goula River, where they are of good quality, and the remainder are reported to have come from the adjacent reefs. In Biloxi Bay the conditions are somewhat better, but still poor. Deer Island bed produces fairly good oysters, but on all of the other beds the stock was rough, clustered and generally inferior, although the presence of a number of tongers on the large bed below the railroad bridge and on the east bed above the bridge indicates that it finds some market. The laws of Mississippi do not permit the lease of barren bottoms for oyster culture, but in its report for 1911 the Board of Oyster Commissioners recommended ‘that they be given the right by law to lease to private individuals, firms, and corporations, citizens of the State, for a term of years to be fixed by the legislature, barren bot- toms suitable for planting oysters, on such terms and at such prices as the legislature may fix.’”? With this recommendation the author is in hearty accord, but he believes that the further suggestions that the extent of the leaseholds be limited to 100 acres for each person, firm, and corporation, and that the annual rental be fixed at $1 per acre are not sufficiently liberal. Although this survey indicates that in the region covered upwards of 23,000 acres of the bottom are pre- sumptively suitable for oyster culture, it should be remembered that until practical test 1s actually made there is no conclusive evidence that they are suited for the purpose. For this reason the first plant- ings must be in the nature of experiments with the possibility of failure. In view of this, and to induce the undertaking, the rental OYSTER BOTTOMS OF MISSISSIPPI EAST OF BILOXI. Ot during the first few years should be low, gradually increasing to a maximum of $1 per acre after time has been granted for the deter- mination of the commercially feasibility of the project under any given lease. If the practicability of private oyster culture should be demonstrated it would then be advisable to permit a somewhat larger holding than 100 acres, so as to remove any inclination to plant too thickly and thus cause deterioration of the stock. Doubtless the point will be raised that if the State’s planting opera- tions have been less successful than was hoped, the same result will accrue in respect to private undertakings. This does not follow. It is well known that a tenant is usually less careful of the soil than is the owner of a farm, and that a municipality always manages its affairs less efficiently than a private individual or corporation. Abundant experience has shown, as a knowledge of human nature would lead one to predict, that private oyster beds are more carefully and successfully managed than are public ones. They produce more, and the oysters are better. In Mississippi, in 1911, the average price of plants was twice that of oysters from the public beds, and genera] experience has shown that the better and higher-priced oysters can find a market when the inferior, low-priced stock is begging for a buyer. Oyster culture consists of more than throwing a lot of oysters or shells on an old reef or tract of barren bottom. The planted material must be properly distributed with due regard to the character of the bottom, and seed oysters must be properly separated from the natural clusters, else they will crowd one another as they grow, many of them will die and the survivors be poor in shape and quality. If through growth and subsequent sets of spat they become too dense on the bottom, they must be judiciously thinned and transplanted, and they must be guarded as much as possible from enemies and from persons taking them illegally. A private planter hoping to reap the reward of his care and industry will see to these things, but the public in dealing with a common property is indifferent, or worse, and the re- sults are unsatisfactory even though the State may spend considerable sums to make it otherwise. Aside from its production of much-needed foodstuff and its increase in the wealth production of the body politic as a whole, which are the important considerations, oyster culture has the additional advan- tage of economy in State administration. The care of the public beds is a constant avenue of State outlay. The leasing of barren and naturally unproductive bottom is a source of State revenue. In all States in which there are natural beds of considerable ex- panse the major part of the expenditures of oyster-law administration are in their behalf. The production of revenue is not the chief con- cern when the welfare of industry and the conservation of a food supply 38 OYSTER BOTTOMS OF MISSISSIPPI EAST OF BILOXI. are concerned, but when the people of the State at large are called on to pay the bills, in whole or in part, it is a legitimate and proper subject for consideration. Finally, the welfare of the public beds and of those obtaining a live- lihood from them is not threatened by the encouragement of oyster culture, as with respect to them there need be no change in the policy of the State. If care be taken to exclude the natural beds from leas- ing, it is probable that they even may be benefited by oyster culture on the barren bottom, and it is reasonably certain that, as has been the case in other parts of the country, a number of those now working on them will become oyster planters if opportunity be given them, thus replacing their present more or less precarious and uncertain livelihood by a more assured and regular as well as more profitable calling. It is not necessary to discuss in detail the methods of oyster culture, as a special pamphlet*® on the subject may be obtained on application to the Bureau of Fisheries. It appears advisable, however, to indi- cate briefly the two general methods open to prospective oyster grow- ers in Mississippi, the planting, or more properly transplanting, of young oysters from the natural or other beds and the deposit of shells or similar materials to which the spat may attach. As has been shown in the preceding pages, certain of the beds are so. densely crowded with small oysters that few of them have chance to develop into marketable stock. Transplanting.a considerable number of these from judiciously selected places to barren bottoms should not only result in saving a considerable proportion of the plants but would improve the living conditions of those left on the reefs and permit them therefore to become as good as is possible under their environment. For ordinary cannery purposes the seed oysters would require but rough culling, but if it is desired to produce oysters for shucking or shell stock the clusters should be well broken up, so that the individuals are not at all crowded as they grow. It is not neces- sary to separate them into single oysters, and where the drumfish is likely to occur it is advisable not to do so. In general, it is desirable to plant seed oysters at least 2 inches long in the more salt water where.the drillis found, as those of smaller size and thinner shells are likely to be killed. For the same reason spat setting on the shells rarely survives in drill-infested regions, and the culled seed is not likely to become overgrown with many young. Should oyster culture reach considerable magnitude in the State, or the natural beds become depleted of superfluous young, it will be necessary to resort to shell or other cultch planting to secure a set of spat. This should be conducted in the fresher waters where the drill is least likely to be found, and the material planted, in order to prevent the formation of large clusters, should be in as small pieces as will suffice as collectors. a Oysters and methods of oyster culture. By H. F. Moore. Bureau of Fisheries Document No. 349. OYSTER BOTTOMS OF MISSISSIPPI EAST OF BILOXI. 39 The section of this report dealing with the barren bottoms, together with the chart, should be consulted for the location of areas on which experiments in oyster culture may be undertaken with some assurance of success. The regions off Deer Island and east of Grand Batture Shoal are probably the most promising. On each of these the depth ‘and the character of the bottom are such that the beds could be worked with light dredges, and both appear to be adapted to the growth of oysters from seed. The work should be conducted as an experiment in the beginning, and not on a scale so large as to entail heavy loss if some of the conditions should unexpectedly prove unfavorable. SUMMARY, CONCLUSIONS, AND RECOMMENDATIONS. The following pages briefly review the conditions developed by the survey, with the deductions and recommendations based on them. 1. The survey included that part of Mississippi Sound lying be- tween the Alabama-Mississippi boundary and Biloxi, being practicaliy restricted to the County of Jackson, although including a small part of Harrison County in the vicinity of Biloxi. 2. Within these limits there are embraced natural beds aggregating about 1,708 acres, of which 475 acres, classed as bearing dense and seattering growth, bear oysters of marketable size in sufficient quanti- ties to support a fishery. On part of this area, however, the quality | was too poor at the time of the survey to permit the oysters to find a ready market at a remunerative price. On the remaining 1,233 acres large oysters are too scattered to be taken commercially with profit. 3. It is estimated that in February and March, 1911, these beds contained not less than about 120,000 bushels of oysters over 3 inches long and about 375,000 bushels of smaller ones, a total of not less than 495,000 bushels of oysters of all sizes. Of this quantity, about 80,000 bushels of the larger size and an equal quantity of the smaller ones were on those parts of the beds in which the former were present in sufficient density of growth to warrant a commercial fishery. The bushel measure used was the standard employed in the State, and as the oysters were culled into singles and doubles and compactly ar- ranged, the measure contained a larger number of oysters than is usual in commercial practice. The data furnished is therefore con- servative as to the content of the beds. 4. The quantity of small oysters on the beds as a whole is largely in excess of the quantity of large ones, although on the denser areas of market oysters in Biloxi Bay this is not the case. As, however, it requires a larger number of small oysters to produce a given quantity, the small oysters are nearly everywhere numerically equal to or in excess of the large ones, the only exceptions being on some of the 40 OYSTER BOTTOMS OF MISSISSIPPI EAST OF BILOXI, scattering growth areas of Biloxi Bay. On the parts of the beds where the large oysters are most abundant the numerical proportion of small oysters to large ones ranges from equality on the small patches in Biloxi Bay to about 17 to 1 on West Pascagoula Reef. Where the larger oysters are fewer the proportion is generally higher, reaching about 228 to 1 on the so-called depleted part of West Pas- cagoula Reef, where marketable oysters are practically absent. The young oysters are, therefore, present on practically all of the beds in sufficient numbers to insure the continuance of the present content of market oysters, and the production of some of the beds, especially those in the vicinity of Pascagoula, should be increased by a judicious removal of some of the young. 5. The demand for oysters in Mississippi is in excess of the present supply of good stock. While some of the natural beds in the region east of Biloxi may be improved by rational treatment, it is not believed that they can fill requirements. They. may supply some of the demand for cannery purposes, which do not require the highest quality, but they can not satisfactorily fill the demand for the shuck- ing and shell trade. | 6. To satisfy this demand for an increased supply, and especially for a better quality than the natural beds produce, the State should enact such legislation as will permit and encourage commercial experi- ments in oyster culture on the present barren bottoms. There are within the limits of the survey upward of 23,000 acres of bottom, now worthless but apparently suitable in stability and other require- ments for oyster culture. These bottoms, if experiment should con- firm favorable opinion as to their utility, constitute a valuable asset of the State now wasted for lack of legal authority for their rental. This defect in the oyster laws should be corrected. 7. The Gulf coast in general has advantage over the more northern oyster-producing States in its milder climate, which is less likely to impose interruption to the fishery. It has the disadvantage of afford- ing a somewhat shorter season, owing to the shorter term of cool weather in which oysters can be handled without spoiling. In respect to transportation to a large part of the interior population, it is more favorably situated than are the States of the Atlantic seaboard. It should also have some advantage in the shipment of seed oysters to a considerable part of the Pacific coast. 8. The production of spat is more to be depended on than in the great oyster-producing States of the North, in some of which the set is liable to fail for several years in succession, entailing serious loss on the planters. Moreover, growth is in general more rapid, and marketable oysters are produced in half the time required on some of the northern grounds. OYSTER BOTTOMS OF MISSISSIPPI EAST OF BILOXI, 4] 9. Oyster enemies are no more destructive than are those of the North, and some of the worst of the latter do not cause trouble on the Gulf coast. Disaster from freshets is more likely to occur, but can be, to a considerable extent, guarded against by judicious choice of location. 10. One of the most serious difficulties with which planters and oystermen have to contend, the pollution of the public and private beds by drainage and sewage discharges, is minimized by the absence of large communities adjacent to the oyster bottoms. Private beds pro- ducing oysters for the market should not be located in proximity to sources of contamination, and floating or ‘“‘fattening’’ oysters by immersion in fresh water should be discouraged and absolutely pro- hibited if the water used be open to suspicion of pollution. The future of the oyster industry everywhere depends in large measure on the guarantee of its product in respect to cleanliness and whole- someness, and not only the State oyster commissions and boards of health but the oystermen themselves, for both moral and business reasons, should require that the public health be safeguarded from the acts of the careless and unscrupulous. 11. Should a law be passed authorizing the leasing of the barren bottoms, such leaseholds as are granted should be carefully surveyed to determine their areas, the tracts should be regular in shape, and the corners located by reference to the triangulation stations or land- marks established by the Coast and Geodetic Survey. These are all carefully determined and are permanently marked, and a strict com- plance with this recommendation will guarantee accuracy in the surveys, obviate disputes, and secure an honest and correct assessment of rental. , 12. Legislation to secure these ends should be carefully drawn and based on the experience of States in which oyster planting has been successful from the standpoints of the planters and the State as a whole. O =- £: TPORTR PEG ee adieu ts eed oe abr pees Tiaras en CSET Er Arh joie ste iad tak oe aR: i ee: ob) ates Cee Bear et se a no ihe roneialey wekehte aae 3 bcc atath . oi Cid awe Cue iit, pk TRA SN de ME oh oat aM AR gon et fst ies ihe ai gs bei: aiehien taehe halts : ig bie vig mT IS RETO. aes Stage o hae | —— La Ceogleneies + egestoa bite adil Seaohead alin bate 7 ay “—? ne, ie ey Ph fonts U.S. B. F.—Doc. 774. PLATE l. OYSTERS FROM SCRANTON REEF. (Natural size.) PLATE II. Doc. 774. U5 Sy 1a IP OYSTERS FROM WEST PASCAGOULA REEF. (Natural size.) U. S. B. F.—Doc. 774 PLATE III. OYSTER FROM DEER ISLAND BED, BILOXI BAY. (Natural size.) U.S B. F —Doc. 774. PLATE IV. OYSTERS FROM SMALL PATCH, BILOXI BAY. (Natural size. ) PLATE V. U. S. B. F.—Doc. 774. OYSTERS FROM LARGE BED, BILOXI! BAY. (Natural size.) Ul, SB, Doe, 7745, PLATE VI. OYSTERS FROM BACK BAY, BILOXI. (Natural size. ) 36. me 35 88° 55. 54 53° Be 5 88° 50. 49 48 A? AG 88° 45, 4a" 43 42 Al 88° 40° 39) 38. 37 | 7 T ai ol T T } T I Ba { ie, EXPLANATION 4 NATURAL OYSTER GROWTH CHARACTER OF BOTTOM —\ CAN © SS BAIDSE PLANTED os, *} fe dense @ tard 0 4a e +46 [As] | | 3} ere Tea I z sedtlering © sti? mud | Ry oe @ soft "a so very scattering ; a very soft mud 4 depleted @ cage Koy Beacon Light 4| 12,3. Ete. Depth in feet at mean low wafer iN Landmarks Coast and Geodetic Sur- vey Triangulation stations) oe Landmarks Bureau of Fisheries (Aux Wary Triangulation stations) Scale covoo YARDS: | MISSISSIPPI EAST OF BILOXI at = STATUTE MILES NAUTICAL MILES 88° 307 29° 287 27" 26 OYSTER BOTTOMS + Survey by z 4 UNITED STATES BUREAU OF FISHERIES hs January to March 1911 Under direction of HF. Moore, Assistant in Charge of Scientific Thquiry ‘Triangulation by United States Coast and Geodetic Survey 1 yey ety Wi, ROUND | LIGHT ROUN r) 10 ace - 9 GRAND PATTURE: SHOAL BEA: CON “uf, M, 5 ae SHOAL A i“ _e . _ | 4 16 HORN L PASS UIshT 24 Document 778 Pe ‘ s re - - , a _ = * ng bane ae — e i e i ' ; ‘ é { / : , \ ’ , 4 | A inte y 4 7 4 Fe Ab 5 ‘ 7 ie oh 1) ' h ao ‘ieee, iy Cs | , Le Pika vats ae ee 0 iv 1 | ‘ 4 , ( ve ef.) ‘a wy Weird ygiq LIBRARIES SMITHSONIAN INSTITUTION NOILNLILSNI NVINOSHLIWS z us is us ze = o . = ac = <5; < : =" i : = gD aa bes TION NOILALILSNI NVINOSHLINS S3IYVYHYEIT LIBRARIES SMITHSONIAN : bY i 5 2 : : : : = e x F hs = OY KA ” m oS a m on” Cane wn pe = on = JGit LIBRARIES SMITHSONIAN INSTITUTION NOILOALILSNI NVINOSHLIWS ee ES a HF Vy = 5 2S a ie z ZED on Bh SA x WH; -) LG ane on) Se ARQ: Y fy oe 2 RN ae Ee ee a 2 TION, NOLLMJILSNI_NVINOSHLINS SZIYVUGIT LIBRARIES SMITHSONIAN z = 3 wo , : a z = - U% ac =p [ed a w ; po? = i) om rs) a zy 2 3 Zz oS 4911 LIBRARIES SMITHSONIAN INSTITUTION NOILNLILSNI NVINOSHLIWS Dp z i z i wo = -w 2 a 2 = 2 = mo Z iE 2 - = a Zz Hi z TION NOILALILSNI S3'tY¥V¥dIT LIBRARIES SMITHSONIAN op) Ve w za es w : = ms = y = = s = Zz st yn pe , = = E 2 iy * g x > G = 5 ad = ae z U3 z Ww * a Ygit LIBRARIES SMITHSONIAN INSTITUTION NOILNLILSNI NOILALILSNI LIBRARTES \N = Naas INSTITUTION NOILALILSNI LIBRARIES 7 s TION NOILALILSNI NVINOSHLINS S3iu¥vVudItT LIBRARIES SMITHSONIAP 7 Yagil LIBRARIES SMITHSONIAN wy INSTITUTION NOILNLILSNI INSTITUTION Ssaluvugi S3iuvddil ee, INSTITUTION NOILALILSNI NVINOSHLIW SMITHSONIAN Ss oT hey NVINOSHLIWS SMITHSONIAN SMITHSONIAN NVINOSHLIWS X N N 17 LIBRARIES SMITHSONIAN INSTITUTION NOILNLILSNI NVINOSHLINS S NVINOSHLINS S3I1YVYR!IT_ LIBRARIES 4 sep? rT * 1] LIBRARIES SMITHSONIAN S w 7 Ko re We ‘ Pip tc jy fis = “ie 5 a * - 7. IN NOILALILSNINVINOSHLIWS So et SS yok w ’ a Be \ ) & > ys fe — ieee 4 m os IT_LIBRARIES SMITHSONIAN - 2 = z 4 K 9 = a: O _ 2 = Ss > Ww) 3 = IN NOILALILSNI NVINOSHLIWS wo — : J YY en 2 )s : mi. oa Oo ur z Past a ° \ 2 5, | > « Gy ]} 2 - “Wh r a ON NOILNLILSNI Ww za = < z 5 wn (ep) oO ae ae = > = eee rep) 17 LIBRARIES SMITHSONIAN > Ww wn _ : \ = ar - ie oc Oo Ps | 2 ie a ON _ NOILALILSNI_NVINOSHLIWS Oo Ae > — w : At 2 IN pe it = 2 MS hs m S\N z m SS I1_ LIBRARIES SMITHSONIAN ae <= y, = AD oi a O = = = = LIBRARIES saruvugit De le z : w . = ” — INSTITUTION NOILNLILSNI_ NVINOSHLIWS 2S 2 WwW 2 Sh \ ve) Ww ON * & WM = ps. ied S3IuYVYNEIT LIBRARIES SMITHSONIAN _ Ih rs B 3 3 we = w 8 w Kb ~ ~» ~ al > - Ce: | = 2 a w” al no” om z an z wn INSTITUTION NOILALILSNI NVINOSHLINS S Pr ‘ Ww = Ww < = < = z = z 4 O fa Ae, ak ” . @ ma wn a ecm a O = z s = =y = ~ > = > 7) Le z 7) 2 S3IYVYUEIT LIBRARIES SMITHSONIAN It Zz ” Zz uJ n os 7) ms 2 es cs : 2 Ve = \ s =z 2p) a: ”) INSTITUTION NOILNILILSNI S 2 “” > w w si n J ae ined rz w =! 3 — Wr * os m n° . m & w = w NVINOSHLIWS S =. o2) ° = > wr = Py; ' Zz htt a L6G Ate: i CT OL be WTP eel Bei ery a OU As Be ee ee et a Set een oy eee terre it BPONE ed ote 8 ONL te de ite veh vied Neda tatbel Fated \Hohet Pheer. Gene . hd ia eek AYO Bim 9 BES De Seana MAN AARE 96,08 8D Rebjed ell Ir 8. nah ote A &95 7 ‘ t LDS ARDMORE TN Nh Mabe d f ; : } ; : SMITHSON AN INST TUTION LIBRARIES WARM ED Cr ath thet Lh t ate? niohe be Baty ht F Aatets five ete RP betehereh bt : HOVE TAD A te NEO de ® Ooty Ae fin hin Tet ; ‘ ' ' DUGDREI DM, A Reted ; Gas . Aclnw ty Ale wed i ‘ P r | SOR EDU VO AD Loe CGV ean Ss Lets hal, aotel eivebiet. Sai Taseee SE 3 9088 00579 AAV ape PM MIGHT A OME bn Oe The Me hah ce Lith hee Te EN. tp ett st DA Fe% We Let tratiat OS de Hehe SEB ty bt ee mat est eee, rf Aote hat Te Tb hy ost abe 40. Ord 4 fe ft CC ee eee een, Cas i . wed at rey ; vt Par eee a fit Cig A ; ONE cd Se ha! Mh . Ped ran Re Mer ’ Per Arian : (vim tSoethuthe aut itch repre cre, te PI Tt ‘ le Sauk fie 6S of bhrak i Ih oles Caer oe . ‘ ' te Ae fh Hat y Ow A feb > Lip D ttt thh . ‘ eats pete F d of ‘ , . , Fehon? Aye at! PHER Ee ty Life tbat te tr tetiot f” eek e604 i Gulls feel ty, meu’ | FON ee A ‘ ' ‘ ‘ , . ob Fabel hate te ree et ehete Monee h fortes A Oe ETAT WO) ' oo “4 ! tht ous ¢ . . CN Pe eT eee Heke 4 a Ae, Roo eh deiheh stick re fale , 1 ht Loe taal RS z he fenton t te dine Cpa hot 256 CeMe Oat fit O fee test Verte ge : ted plead of Bee bof y U shtoa ' rot 5 A io. Bin PRA One rete ORAS ot Ted het CoP ate! § Cita) PUP ees Ae ACK Se Ore De at ee et ti 4 tue . ri rir a ‘ 4 atadteth h wate s stam Care te coAhd Bis) oO Fe hele Gore het rir *, ORAL EA OR iG fabetet es ‘ Fay s ‘ rs ” lin DR Ses fended tin BS Vichy Sebel Ah OS ORO Tet abi le ft ats, 1 Pats fir of Pe ring ’ '< t : ‘ , BET E oho Pernt he RHIC Ea fos rene toe us tof of fit fale ahthed chile het feb feud . et ‘ . ‘ r Fon Ga Be tart ite ehh Gt MEO Atay t RRR Tia beter é bwne Bodh eo Fehon beth wee fiche Oo ANE Coe i Meh Wet atom met Wee yt ewete ae aS bey Hain tf at Aare ve) ot FUCA Hoth! +L Ua By of : 4 . ' . ‘ PANDA BML EOE SM COM We Pen nero ey nw, Ate Ge ahah.’ voy Porn a ae! iss i ‘ , ’ as ‘ : we! . e Pe ae ee Lee ery Tee eared oh fata Atl Fiat aT, . Pet Ta beet ake v : ri i whee thate Kiem ek ted rae) non eyele ana Le Ree & ce Pa fat ay, , Ae . See ouiveet tetas boats Cal Luatackoa ee dota ehbne dal 2 / oa ¢ A i CS ag te Seat ok, f,ce arta nledc al oo ue dA Ty : ‘ pond eS ee ae] AJ, wed stead Actrali ch fresl ’ ‘ see ten Olas ' od ate REP We are eo Getew Ohe 1a fae er ge eG 14 te rr 4 e At oy . ‘ F ‘ ‘ ‘ POE te ot dhe one lhe Eran eon ie Goh 8) bas rh Oy use foe” 2 oats . WRT he meters Medi hes S fbehy SED iL AR oq Ce AR Se GOP! (ae Se oh hel aead be 1 ia, EE Ce ne ed Meta hot at Wed th bh ts ‘tin ‘eehadoal. Sah suhag e ot Pa on oka ot : ' et ' sah shal,” ih ‘ F Fy ‘ , neten . ‘ bene Seer R TE PO Ades Dae ra Shedd dot iinet : Sif UAL Cr ee} PhS | Tad . poe 2 oF ' soe Pri 4 cnt MER oe >, ed ah hak Fata Orin Pip ae Sch, Bs . : Z h fete oe Ser rete tte 7 ' Aare ‘ . ‘ ; . ’ nee La imiekeeehintikitenbucht ice Luh & ‘ ite Here ; Fra ils F Che ee ‘ “ FA MI Z pape - t ; Fi ae} a F . on, ee FB mW Cod 4 BLOB eh Ee oN 6h Oud 8 ' rs Thy’ | ena retin bo nents eae: ; Fad pot , r ar ‘ . Tadleds rf ofa ‘ AOERROCT of / Peat : pea : : Tah hig heRntia gs t fins, wes.te . rae oles b , one ntet cent Fee FEL eit uae TLIO n eG WIC AE ' hae : . (Shee Ae oe fot ae aa oe at yee: SHOTS 4 Ty Ky he pee eee , ‘ Sie wit ea Fe ee alah a eee 7 ber ut 6 * VALE pode . ; pics - . Pete CHE ta . cee | {20,17 o6 aw Cet 7 ‘ . Cero deg ebeb vee gs wt rivera Wie | Some eens Flee ' a a D CAT uy VaR NLP ar De ee Dk : : ti: ‘ Pee seus mete ene BLY scale : FPF Se tp Oe : ‘ Pri Lon Pet mee FSH onan abut oh se Pai uit , eee ay ees HR aes ws oN se Pe is 4 sere Fy OCR Sa Ben Ore re eer q pasate P Stara “" « wyhregre ee MOU K WhOle se: i BIN Ae ey WR goes oes ki Whore 2 yey ee tan ; oy ar bsg ue Ni “ees Puba sy efny 58 ata Ure Qe” Rog wiesnsePeye a - aah “ee , YQ Grabs 3 ke Tee oe a Ce eee ee PPL x worl ey WOOO Da bey ay he 2 aL ear ie) Sak et ae | EO ELV ery Hy