Rs! ee IEE ee Bekeruh ct reat et sees SIRE Bi facet $ Biking Acs sve Bhbseks Wo a hela ete Lies, t's dat ist Narain 4 He K Bie eartesates 1 sive uaiiaye nie ht thar 7% ie Bh Ne re # < { boa RE Teh T Nears we J Melee} re Pita! ie nit at 9 is Veern 3 4 ts An athe sidteeetel iN “7 ait Pi int? fe aon oes aneatce a ok ; i 5 yee? std i va avd oe * rd : mn i ae r id : <7 p. A, > fe a vi via 4 , Wid All ie ia fi“ THE Evinburgh JOURNAL OF SCIENCE, EXHIBITING A VIEW OF THE PROGRESS OF DISCOVERY IN NATURAL PHILOSOPHY, CHEMISTRY, MINERALOGY, GEOLOGY, BOTANY, ZOOLOGY, COMPARATIVE ANATOMY, PRACTICAL MECHANICS, GEOGRAPHY, NAVIGATION, STATISTICS, ANTIQUITIES, AND THE FINE AND USEFUL ARTS, CONDUCTED BY DAVID BREWSTER, LL.D. F.R.S. LOND. SEC. R.S. EDIN. F.S.S.A. HONORARY MEMBER OF THE ROYAL IRISH ACADEMY; MEMBER OF THE ROYAL SWEDISH ACADEMY OF SCIENCES ; AND OF THE ROYAL SOCIETY OF SCIENCES OF DENMARK, &c. &c, VOL. III. APRIL—OCTOBER. WILLIAM BLACKWOOD, EDINBURGH: AND T. CADELL, LONDON. M.DCCO.XXV. PRINTED BY JOHN SPARK. CONTENTS OF THE EDINBURGH JOURNAL OF SCIENCE. No. V. ArT. I. Abstract of Experiments on the Consolidation of the Strata of the Earth, made by Str JamEs HALL, Bart. F. R.S. Lond. and Edin., with Notices of his former Writings on Geological Subjects, aE. - II. On some Phenomena of Vertical and of Lateral Mirage, observed at King George’s Bastion, Leith. An Extract of a Letter to the Editor, from Henry Home BLACKADDER, Esq. Surgeon, Med. Staff, H.-P. - III. Account of the Circumstances connected with the Discovery of the Fossil Elk in the Isle of Man, which prove that this Animal is not Antediluvian, as many Naturalists and Antiquaries have supposed. By SAMUEL HIB- BERT, M.D. F.R.S. E. and M.G.S. Secretary to the Society of Scot- tish Antiquaries, - - - . - - IV. Observations relative to the Fossil Elk of the Isle of Mann; being the Abstract of a Letter from H. R. OswaLp, Esq. F.S.S. A. &c. addressed to the Lorp BisHor oF SODOR AND Many, in Reply to certain Queries instituted by Professor BUCKLAND relative to the circumstances under which the Fossil Elk is discovered, = = = x V. An Account of the Frontier between Ava and the Part of Bengal adjacent to the Karnaphuli River. By FRaANcIs HamiLton, M.D. F.R.S. and F. A. 8. Lond. and Edin. Communicated by the Author, - VI. Account of an Improvement on the ‘* Odometer,”’ which, without increas- ing its size, multiplies its power upwards of One Hundred Fold. By JAMES HunTER, Esq. of Thurston, F. R.S. E. Communicated = the Author, = = - = s - VII. On a Singular Detached Block of Stone occupying the summit of a Hill at Dunkeld. By JoHN MacCuLitocu, M.D. F.R.S. F.L.S. and M. G.S. Chemist to the Board of Ordnance, and Professor of Chemistry in Addiscombe College. Communicated by the Author, - VIII. Notice of some of the Rarer Atmospherical Pienomena observed in 1824. Communicated by the Author, - - - IX. On the Regular Composition of Crystallined Bodies. By WILLIAM HAIDINGER, Esq. F. R.S. Edin. Communicated by the Author.— (Continued from Vol. Il. p. 93.) E é £ 4 Page 13 15 28 32 da 46 49 il CONTENTS. Page X. Facts relating to the Formation of Dew. By GEoRGE HARVEY, Esq: I’. R.S. Lond. & Edin. Communicated by the Author, - 69 XI. Astronomical Observations made at the Observatory of Paramatta in 1824, Communicated by his Excellency Sir Tuomas BrisBANE, K.C.B. F. R. S$. Lond. & Edin. - . = - - 72 XII. Account of a Stickleback that was found with a Leech alive in its Intes- tines, July 1818. By Mr Joun RamaGE, Aberdeen. Communicated by the Author, - - = - 3 + 74 XIII. Observations on the Temperature of Springs, Wells, and Mines in Corn- wall. By Jonn Davy, M. D. F.R.S. Communicated by the Author, 75° XIV. Observations on the Flints of Warwickshire. By EDwaRD GRIMES, Esq. R. N. Communicated by THomas ALLAN, Esq. - -~ Ge XV. Observations on the Habits of the Hyena. By Ropert Knox, M.D. F. R.S. E. Lecturer on Anatomy and Physiology, and Conservator of the Museum of the Royal College of Surgeons. Communicated by the Au- thor, - < A 3 - 80 XVI. Account of the capiicon of Oil Gas which took place at Edinburgh, on the 23d March 1825, with Observations on the Safety of Gas, - 83 XVII. Description of a Machine applied to a Gig, for Measuring Distances. By WILLIAM EDGEWORTH, Esq. C. E. has M.R. I. A. Communicat- ed. by the Author, ~ u d Z = E 93 XVIII. A Description of Fan-Gate Sluices, Invented and Constructed by Mr J. BLANKEN, Jun. Counsellor of State, Inspector-General of Public Works.in the Kingdom of the Netherlands. By Dr G. Mort, Professor of Natural Philosophy in the University of Utrecht. Communicated by the Author, - as y 4 F af 95 XIX. Table of the Rise of the Tide at Hobart Town, Van Diemen’s Land, in April and May 1822, and January 1823. Communicated by his Ex- cellency Sir THomMas BrisBaNneE, K. C. B. F. R. S. L. & E. &e. 100 XX. On the Application of the Expansive Power of Liquids to produce a Reci- procating Rectilinear Motion. I: a Letter to the Editor, - 101 X XI. Additiona]) Observations on Leslie’s Photometer, &c. By WILLIAM RircHiE, A. M. Rector of the Academy at Tain. In a Letter to Dr BREWSTER, - - = - - - - 104 XXII. Account of a Remarkable Explosion of Gas in a Well near Leith Fort By Mz Joun CotpstTREAM. Ina Letter to Dr BREWSTER, - 108 XXIII. Notice of a Remarkable Variety of Boracite. By W1x~t1am Har- DINGER, Esq. Ff. R. S. E. Communicated by the Author, - 110 XXIV. On a Dike of Serpentine cutting through Sandstone in the County of Forfar. By CHarLrs LYELL, Esq. Sceretary to the Geological Society of London, F.L.S. Communicated by the Author. With a Plate, 112 XXV. Notice of a Remarkable Occurrence of Serpentine at the Junction of Sienite with the Dolomite of the Tyrol. By J. F. W. HreRscuEL, Sec. R. S. Lond. and F. R. §. Edin. Communicated by the Author, 126 XXXVI. Notice of the remains of an Animal resembling the Scandinavian Elk, re- cently discovered in the Isle of Man; with Suggestions on the Importance of distinguishing this Animal] from the Fossil Irish Elk. In a Letter to ’ Dr BREWSTER, from SAMUEL HIBBERT, M. D. F, RB, S. E, and M. G. 8. Secretary to the Society of Scottish Antiquaries, - - 129 CONTENTS. Nl “a Page XXVII. Notice of Mr Christie’s Discoveries prnceee the Effect of Rotation on the Magnetic Forces, ~ - - - - 135 XXVIII. Analysis of a Mica from Cornwall. By Epwarp TuRNER, M. D. F. R. S. E. &c. Lecturer on Chemistry, and Fellow of the Royal College of Physicians, Edinburgh. Communicated by the Author, - 137 XXIX. ZOOLOGICAL COLLECTIONS, - . - 143 1. Conybeare on the Plesiosaurus. 2. Discovery of the Megalosaurus. 3. Gigantic Fossil Coral. 4, Enormous Orang-Outang found in Su- matra. 95. Aranea Domestica, -possessed of a Natural Diving Bell to assist it in Crossing Water. 6. Mode of Catching Fish by Diving, pe- culiar to the Gulf of Patrasso. 7. Rapidity of the Effects of the Poison of some of the New Holland Snakes. 6. On Changing the Residence of Fishes. 9. Structure of the Hind-Foot of the Walrus, 143—146 KXX. DECISIONS ON DISPUTED INVENTIONS AND DISCO- - VERIES, - - - - 146 I. The Rediscovery of the Comet of Encke due to Mr Rumker, and not to Mr Dunlop. 2. The Composite Structure of the Bipyramidal Sulphate of Potash not discovered by Mr Brooke. 3. The apparent Immobility of Spectral Impressions ; their Singleness by Distorted Vision ; and the Reference of the Phenomena of Vision to Voluntary Muscular Action, first discovered and proposed by Dr Wells, and not by Mr Charles Bell. 4. Professor Leslie’s Hygrometer, invented by the late Dr James Hut- ton, . - - - . - 146—149 XXXII. HISTORY OF MECHANICAL INVENTIONS AND PRO- CESSES IN THE USEFUL ARTS, - - 149 1. British Invention and Discovery Association, - - ib. 2. Mr Bryce’s Stomach or Moveable Branch Syphon, =e ee ib. _ 3. Mr Shiells’ Triangle for Elevating the Jet of Fire’ Engines, = 150 4, Account of an improved Hydropneumatic Lamp, which can be con- * structed at a smaJl expence. By Winti1am Dyce, M.D. F.R.S. Ed. 15] 5. On the Use of Granite for Railways. In a Letter from JoHN Grp, Esq. Civil Engineer, to JoHN Rosison, Esq. F. R.S. £. - 152 6. Description of a Single Valve Sluice, invented by RoBeERT Tuom, Esq. Rothsay, - - - - - - 154 7. Description of a Chain Sluice, invented by RopeRT THom, Esq. Rothesay,” - - - - - - . 155 8. Description of a Breathing-Pump, invented by W1LL1am Van Hov- TEN, Junior, Rotterdam, - . - - 156 9. Professor Amici’s Improved Camera Lucidas, > > 157 XXXII. ANALYSIS OF SCIENTIFIC BOOKS AND MEMOIRS, 159 1. The English Flora. By Sir James Fpwarp SMITH, President of the Linnean Society. 2 vols. 8vo. - . - - ib. HI. On the Effects of the Density of Air on the Rates of Chronometers. By GeorcE Harvey, Esq. F. R.S.E., &c. From the Philosophical Transactions for 1824, Part II. - - - - 170 iv CONTENTS. Page XXXIII, PROCEEDINGS OF SOCIETIES, : - - 175 Proceedings of the Royal Society of Edinburgh, - - ib- XXXIV. SCIENTIFIC INTELLIGENCE, = - 176 I. NATURAL PHILOSOPHY. AsTRONOMY.—l. Pastorff on the Solar Spots and Clouds. 2. Comet seen on the Sun’s Disk. 3. Singular Appearances in the Comet of 1824. 4. Encke’s Hyperbolical Elements of the Comet of 1824. 5. Comet of 1824 discovered at Paramatta. 6. Sir Thomas Brisbane’s Catalogue of the Stars in the Southern Hemisphere. 7. Mr Herschel and Mr South on Double Stars. 8. Miss Caroline Herschel’s Catalogue of Stars. - 176—178 Oprics.—§. Lateral refraction. 10. Mr Dunlop’s Reflecting Speculum, 178 MaGneETisM.—11. Effects of Temperature on the Magnetic Forces. 12. Di- urnal Variation of the Terrestrial Magnetic Intensity. 15. Influence of Copper on the Oscillations of Magnetic Needles. 14. Effect of Copper in Motion on a Magnetic Needle, 5 - - = 178, 179 METEOROLOGY.—15. Daniell’s Improvement on the Barometer. 16. Hy- grometric Properties of Insoluble Compounds. 17. Highest and Lowest Temperature on the Earth’s Surface. 18. Remarkable Auroral Arch on the 19th March. 19. Bosson’s Observations on Waterspouts, - 179—181 Il. CHEMISTRY. 20. Cold Produced by the Combination of Metals. 21. Refrigerating Salt. 22. On the Pectic or Coagulating Acid. 23. Iodine in Mineral Waters, 181, 182 III. NATURAL HISTORY. MINERALOGY.—24. Apatite in Salisbury Crags, Edinburgh. 25. Withamite. 26. School of Mines in Cornwall, - < : - 182, 183 Botrany.—Codium tomentosum, and Targionia hypophylla. 28. Tricho- manes elegans, - - - - - 183 ZooLocy.—29. Say’s American Entomology. 30. Annals of the Lyceum of Natural History of New York, 31, American Fauna, a = 184 IV. GENERAL SCIENCE. 32. Remarkable Dissection of a Female Mummy. 33. Discoveries in Nova Zembla. 34. Hazel Nuts found ina singular state at a great depth. 35. The Menai Bridge, near Bangor, Carnarvonshire. 36. Number of Steam- Engines in Glasgow and its neighbourhood in April 1825. 37. Number of Steam Boats on the Clyde in 1825. 38. Poisonous Effects of White Bread upon Dogs. 39. The Goitre cured by Subcarbonate of Soda. 40. Artificial Production of Pearls, = - - - - 185—187 XXXV. List of Patents for New Inventions, Sealed in England from October 7, 1624, to January 1, 1825, - - 188 XXXVI. List of Patents granted in Scotland since March 7, 1825, = 189 XXXVII. Celestial Phenomena, from July 1, to September 1, 1825, calculated for the Meridian of Edinburgh. By Mr GEorGE InNEs, Aber- deen, - 2 ™ 2 3 3 190 X XXVIII. Register of the Barometer, Thermometer, and Rain-Gage, kept at Canaan Cottage. By ALEX. ADIE, Esq. F. R.S.E. - 192 4 CONTENTS OF THE EDINBURGH JOURNAL OF SCIENCE. No. VI. ArT. I. On the Limits of the Retina in the Eye of the Sepia Loligo, one of the Cephalopodous Mollusca. By Kopert Knox, M.D.F.R.S.E., Lecturer on Anatomy and Physiology, and Conservator of the Museum of the Royal College of Surgeons. Communicated by the Author, IJ. An Account of the Frontier between the Southern part of Bengal and the Kingdom of Ava. By Francis HAMILTON, M.D. F.R. S. and F. A. S. Lond. and Edin. Communicated by the Author, - - III. On the Quartz District in the neighbourhood of Loch Ness. By GEORGE ANDERSON, Esq. F. R. S. E, &c. Inverness, - - . 1V. On the Genus Calymperes of Swartz_and Syrrhopodon of Schwaegrichen, of the Order Musci. By W. J. Hooker, LL. D.F.R.S. &c. &c. Regius Professor of Botany in the University of Glasgow, and R. K. GREVILLE, LL. D. F. R. S. E. &c. &c. Communicated by the Authors, V. Some Account of the Climate, &c. of the North of France, collected part- ly from Observation, partly from a free Communication with the Inhabit- amts of various ranks. Written during a Residence in that Country for the use of a Friend in Britain. By HENRY HomME BLACKADDER, Esq. Surgeon, - - - - - VI. Account of the Specific Grayity of several Minerals. By W1ILLIamM HAIDINGER, Esq. F. R. S. E. Communicated by the Author.—(Con- tinued from Vol. Il. p. 74.) = a Z 2 VII. Botanical Letters from J. J. Rousseau to M. Gowan, Professor of Bo- tany at Montpellier. Communicated by Dr HooKER, - VIIi. On the Construction of Meteorological Instruments, so as to register their Indications during the absence of the Observer at any given Instant, or at successive intervals of Time, = - - = 1X. Observations on the Gulf-Stream, in crossing it from Halifax to Bermuda, and from Bermuda to Halifax, in his Majesty’s Ship Jaseur, in 1821. Communicated by J. D. Boswaxtr, Esq. R. N. F.R.S. E. X. On Lithion-Mica. By Epwarp Turner, M.D. F.R.S. E. Lecturer on Chemistry, and Fellow of the Royal College of Physicians, Edinburgh. Communicated by the Author, - - ~ - 227 261 ii CONTENTS. > Page XI. Observations on the Presence of the Waters of the Gulf-Stream on the Coasts of Europe, in January 1822. By EpwarbD SaBINE, Esq. F. R. S. F. L.S. &c. &ce - - - < = = 270 XII. On the Depression of the Horizon of the Sea over the Gulf-Stream. By EDWARD SaBINE, Esq. F.R.S. F.L.S. &e. &e. “ e 274 XIII. On the Effects of Heat and Motion. In a Letter to Dr BREWSTER from M. SEGUIN, ainé = = < 276 XIV. Observations on the apparent Distances and Positions of 389 Double and Triple Stars. By J. F. W. HERSCHEL, Esq. Sec. R.S. Lond. and F.R.S. Edin., and James Soutu, Esq. F. R. S. Lond. & Edin, 281 XV. On some Remarkable Affections of the Retina, as exhibited in its insen- sibility to indirect Impressions, and to the Impressions of attenuated Light. By Davip BrewsTER, LL. D. F, R. S. Lond., and Sec. R. S. Edin. 288 XVI. On the Action of Poisons on the Vegetable Kingdom. By Mr F. Mar- CET, - - - - 293 XVII. On Two Newly determined Species of the Genus Gypsum-haloide of. the System of Mohs. By Wiri1aAM HatDIncER, Esq. F.R.S. E. Communicated by the Author, - - 302 XVIII. On the Composition of the Minerals described in the pretedrag Paper. By Epwarp TuRNER, M.D. F.R.S.E. &c. Lecturer on Chemistry, and Fellow of the Royal College of aoe Edinburgh. Communicat- ed by the Author, - - . : - 306 XIX. On the Chemical Characters of Zinc Ores, examined in the manner of Berzelius, by means of the Blow-Pipe, by M. Nits NORDENSKIOLD of Abo, - - -— - + - . 310 XX. Account of a Meteorological Phenomenon which was observed at the Summit of Ben-Nevis on the 27th June last. By the Rev Mr JoHNn Macvicar, Dundee. Ina Letter to Dr Brewster, - - 312 XXI. Description of Edingtonite, a New Mineral Species. By W1ILLTAM HarpInGER, Esq. F. R.S. E. With an Analysis by EpDwarD TURNER, M.D. F. R. S. E. &c. Lecturer on Chemistry, and Fellow of the Royal College of Physicians, Edinburgh. Communicated by the Author, 316 XXII. Description of a New Hygrometer, depending on the Affinity of Acids for Water. By Professor AUG. DE LA RIVE, - M2 320 XXI1L. On the Locality of Acmite. By N. B. Monier, Esq. of Porsgrund, Norway, - - ~ = ~! 326 XXIV. Account of Two newly-discovered Mineral Species. By Professor J. J. BerzEvius, M.D. F.R.S. Lond. and Edin., &c. &c. - 327 XXV. On some new Localities of rare Minerals. By Professor J. J. BER- zELiIus, M.D.F.R.S. Lond. and Edin., &c. &c. - - 332 XXVI. ZOOLOGICAL COLLECTIONS, - - - 334 1, Chlamyphorus truncatus, - - - - ib. 2. New and gigantic species of the genus Cephalopterus, of Dumeril, 337 3. Two new Genera of Reptiles proposed, - - . 339 4. Bilobites, ej = s 2 2 E ¥ ib. XXVIII HISTORY OF MECHANICAL INVENTIONS AND PRO- CESSES IN THE USEFUL ARTS, - - 340 1. Method of giving the Epicycloidal Form to the Teeth of Wheels. By PrererR Lecoun?, Esq. Midshipman, R. N. in a Letter to the Editor, ib. CONTENTS. it Page 2. Description of a Single Weather Sluice, invented by RopERT THoM, Esq. Rothesay, = S = #4 4 te 343 3. On coarse Paint made with Potatoes, - - = 345 4. Method of preventing the Fracture of Glass Chimneys, - 346 5. Description of Griebe]’s Portable Night Clock, - - sie 6. Description of M. Allard’s Universal Bevel, - - . ib. 7. Method of consuming the Smoke of Steam-Boiler Furnaces. By Mr G. CHAPMAN, - - - - - 347 8. Menstruum for biting in on Steel Plates for Fine Engravings. By Mr EpmMunD TURREL, - = 2 g ib. 9. Description of Lenormand’s New Chronometer, - - 348 10. On the Construction of Chimneys, - = 2 349 11. M. Ventau’s Gigantic Meteorological Eolian Harp, - - ib. 12. Natural Lamp by Incandescence, . . - - 350 13. Oil for Chronometers, Clocks, and Delicate Wheel-work, - ib. XXVIII ANALYSIS OF SCIENTIFIC BOOKS AND MEMOIRS, 231 1. On the Transverse Strain and fais of Materials. By Mr Eaton HoDGKINSON, - : - = ib. II, On the Gold Mines of Spice Citas By DENtsoN OLMSTED, Professor of Chemistry and Mineralogy in the University of North Ca- rolina, - - - - - - - 358 XXIX. NOTICES OF RECENTLY PUBLISHED BOTANICAL WORKS, : - 7 ~ *S64 Great Britain.—Transactions of the Linnzan Society of London. Prodromus Flore Nepalensis. Botanical Magazine, No. 456, January 1825. No. 459, April. Botanical Register for December, No. 118. No. 119, Ja- nuary 1825. Hooker’s Exotic Flora, Part 19, February 1825. Part 20, March. - 2 2 ~ 5 t 365—367 XXX. SCIENTIFIC INTELLIGENCE, - 367 I, NATURAL PHILOSOPHY. AsTRONOMY.—1l. Comet of July and August 1824, discovered at Paramatta. 2. Comet of September 1824, discovered at Paramatta. 3. New Comet of 1825. 4. Longitude and Latitude of Paramatta. 5. Action of the Moon on the Earth’s Atmosphere. 6. Lunar fee of 3lst May, observed at Bushy Heath, - - - - 367, 368 Optics.—7. Light produced during the Crystallization of Benzoic Acid. 8. Iridescence of Clouds, - - - - - 368, 369 ELEcTRIic1ITy.—9. Remarkable Electricity of Oxalate of Lime. 19. Electricity developed in Capillary Attraction. 11. Electricity developed in Solutions and Mixtures. 12. Electrical Gale, 369—371. MAGNETIsM.—13. Mr Babbage and Mr Herschel on the Magnetism develop- ed during Rotation. 14..On the Magnetism imparted to Iron Bodies by Rotation. 15. Mr Christie’s New Experiments on the Magnetism produc- ed by Rotation. - : 2 = J 371, 372 METEOROLOGY.—I16. Remarkable Hailstones with Pyritic Nuclei. - 373 iv CONTENTS. Page il. CHEMISTRY. 17. On a Compound of Carbon of Hydrogen with remarkable properties. 373 Ill, NATURAL HISTORY. ROTANY.—18. Overland Arctic Expedition. 19. Plantes rares du Jardin de Genéve, par Aug. Pyramus de Candolle, &c. - - 374—377 IV. GENERAL SCIENCE. 20. Lieut. Kotzebue’s recent voyage of Discovery. 21. Steam-boat Enterpriee for India, —S— - - - i. : + 377 XXXI. List of Patents for New Inventions, sealed in England since January 1, 1&25. - = 3, 3 4 378 XXXII. List of Patents granted in Scotland since June 16, 1825, - 379 X XXIII. Celestial Phenomena, from October 1, 1825 to January 1, 1826, cal- culated for the Meridian of Edinburgh. By Mr GrorGE INNES, Aberdeen, » - - - - 380 XXXIV. Register of the Barometer, Thermometer, and Rain-Gage, kept at Canaan Cottage. By ALEX. ADIE, Esq. F. R.S.E. 384 INDEX, . - - - - - . “ 385 Description of Plates in Vol. III., 5 e a L 3 388 + This day is Published, With Twenty-four Explanatory Engravings, 12mo. 7s. 6d. THE CENTURY OF INVENTIONS OF THE MARQUIS OF WORCESTER, From the Original MSS., with Historical and Explanatory Notes, and a Biographical Memoir, by CHARLES F. PARTINGTON, of the Lon- don Institution. PRINTED FOR JOHN MURRAY, ALBEMARLE STREET, LONDON. THE EDINBURGH JOURNAL OF SCIENCE. Art. l.— Abstract of Experiments on the Consolidation of the Strata of the Earth, made by Stir James Hatt, Bart. F.R.S. Lond. and Edin., with Notices of his former Writ- ings on Geological Subjects. WE have great pleasure in presenting our readers with an ab- stract of a paper lately read to the Royal Society of Edinburgh by Sir James Hall, on the consolidauon of the strata of the earth; and we recommend their attention to this notice with the more earnestness, because the volume in which the paper will be published at length, may perhaps not appear for some time, and is, moreover, by its nature, little calculated for that rapid and extensive circulation which the ardour of modern curiosi- ty demands. Sir James Hall is well known to the scientific world as a strenuous supporter of the Huttonian Theory, and as the philosopher who has most successfully attempted to rest the science of geology on the basis of experiment. As his disco- veries, however, have been published at long intervals, and in a form not very accessible to the generality of readers, we con- ceive we shall be rendering a service to science, by giving a brief sketch of the principal results to which those investi- gations of our ingenious countryman have led. Early in 1790, not long after Dr Hutton had announced his Theory of the Earth, Sir James Hall, who had desened VOL. LII. NO. I. JULY ie A 2 Sir James Hall on the Consolidation of the Strata. himself friendly to the new doctrines, came forward to grapple with one of the most formidable difficulties which were urged against them. In the History of the Royal Society, Vol. iii. p- 8. Edinburgh Transactions, there is given a short abstract of two papers on the formation of granite. It is to be regret- ted, that these papers should not have been given at length. The abstract, however, is sufficiently curious, and well de- serving of the attention of any experimentalist, who may be engaged in attempts to inntate nature in the formation of crys- tallised rocks. We have only room for a short extract :— ** In granites, which contain quartz and feldspar, it fre- quently occurs, that the feldspar is seen with the form of its crystals distinctly defined, whilst the quartz is a confused and irregular mass, being almost universally moulded on the erys- tals of feldspar. Now, were it true that all granite is formed by fusion, the very contrary, it would seem, ought always to take place, as feldspar is very easily melted, and quartz resists the greatest efforts of heat that have hitherto been applied to it. ** The difficulty is thus obviated: It is well known, that when quartz and feldspar are pounded and mixed together, the mixture may, with difficulty, be melted and run intoa kind of glass, the feldspar serving as a flux to the quartz. The same may be stated in another way, by considering the feldspar, when melted, as a fluid, in which, asa menstruum, the quartz is dissolved ; and in this view we may expect, by ana- logy, that phenomena, similar to those of the solution of salt im water, should take place. Now it is certam, that when ex- eessive cold is applied to the salt water, the water is frozen to the exclusion of the salt, the ice obtamed yielding fresh water when melted, and the salt, when the experiment is pushed to the utmost, separating from it in the form of sand. Why should not the same thing happen in the solution of quartz in liquid feldspar, when the mass is allowed to cool below the point of congelation of the menstruum? The feldspar may crystallise separately from the quartz, as we have seen pure ice formed separately from the salt; i both cases, the conge- lation of the solvent being simultaneous to that of the dissolved Sir James Hall on the Consolidation of the Strata. 3 substance. Hence the crystals may mutually interfere with each others forms, and we may as naturally capes to see eoeiay moulded on crystals of feldspar, as the reverse.” Sir James then discusses the guestion, as to the effects of slow cooling, in preventing the return of the fused substance to a state of glass—and then advances the following very in- genious views, which are incapable of abridgement. * If quartz, mica, feldspar, schorl, garnet, &c. happen to be melted together, the most fusible substance of them all may be considered as the menstruum in which all the rest are dis- solved, and we may suppose, that these various dissolved sub- stances may differ amongst themselves in their properties of solution, as salts differ from one another, so that some of them may be more soluble, when very much heated, than when it is comparatively cold, and others may be as soluble in it, when little warmer than its point of congelation, as when raised to a much higher temperature. If then we say, for example, that the congealing point of the solvent is 1000 degrees of Fahrenheit, and if the solution is at the temperature of 2000, we may con- celve one portion of the matter dissolved as held by the sim- ple dissolving power of the menstruum, and another portion as held by means of its elevated temperature. When, therefore, a mass of this kind is allowed to cool very slowly, as we may suppose must be the case with liquid granite in the bowels of the earth, those substances held in solution by the heat of the solvent, will first separate, and, being formed in a liquid, will assume thei crystalline forms with perfect regularity ; where- asthose substances, which were held by the menstruum, simply as a fluid, will not separate till the congelation of the solvent itself takes place, when the crystals of the various substances will intermix and confound the regularity of form, which each would have assumed, if left to-itself. In this manner, one of the most common kinds of granite will be produced, consisting of perfect crystals of schorl, mica, or garnet, inclosed in a confused mass of quartz and schorl.” These theoretical views, whether just or otherwise, it must be admitted, are highly curious and philosophical, and are well de- serving of being put to those experimental tests, which no man knows better how to devise than Sir James:himself:. And as 4 Sir James Hall on the Consolidation of the Strata. very slow cooling, or, which is the same thing, a perfect com- mand of the nicest regulation of high heats, is indispensable to their success, we are rejoiced to hear that he has invented an instrument, which, we are told, accomplishes this great desi- deratum completely. We look very anxiously, therefore, to his publishing some account of it, even though he should ‘not have any very decisive results, as to its power of producing imitations of crystallised rocks. Such an instrument, on many other accounts, is a desideratum in practical chemistry, and the ° scientific world are entitled to be put in possession of it forth- with. In the Edinburgh Transactions for 1798 (vol. v. p. 23.) was given an account of a series of experiments, completely es- tablisbing the identity of whinstone and lava. By this ana- logy the most important aid was afforded to the Huttonian Theory. It had been stated, that, whinstone, like the granite above mentioned, when melted and allowed to cool again, always became glass, and did not return to stone as Dr Hutton’s Theory required. Sir James Hall, however, conceived that nature would operate in this case by slow degrees, and that the temperature of the melted stone, when occurringin vast quanti- ties, would be gradually, and not suddenly reduced. He ima- gined that the effect of this would be, to allow the fused mass to remain for a sufficient length of time, durmg its descent through the various stages of heat, in that particular pitch of temperature required by its nature for its assuming a crystal- line texture. His experiments fully proved the justice of these ingenious ideas ; and we believe there is, in consequence, now but one opinion as to the igneous origin of the whole of this class of rocks. The most formidable objection, however, to the Huttonian Theory still remained, until Sir James Hall removed it by the same philosophical line of inquiry.. Dr Hutton had as- serted, that calcareous rocks, like every other, had been sub- jected to the action of heat. But it was well known that when heat was applied to this class of rocks, the carbonie acid was driven off in the shape of gas, and the remaining quicklime became infusible. Dr Hutton, indeed, had answer- ‘Sir James Hall on the Consolidation of the Strata. 5 ed this, by suggesting that the pressure of the superincumbent ocean was sufficient to confine the carbonic acid, and to cause it to act as a flux on the quicklime. This theory, however ingenious, was so abundantly gratuitous, that it by no means satisfied even his own disciples. During his lifetime he dis- couraged the experimental investigation of the subject; but no sooner was all delicacy on the subject at an end by Dr Hutton’s death, than Sir James Hall commenced a series of experiments, which in the end set the question completely at rest. He ascertained, by numerous experiments, that carbo- nate of lime might readily be fused when exposed to heat, if it were at the same time under a pressure not greater than Dr Hutton’s Theory required, or about a mile and a half of sea. These experiments, in which the subject is treated in a very masterly way, will be found in the sixth volume of the Edin- burgh Transactions. Inthe words of Mr Playfair, it may be truly said of them, “that,independently of all theory, they have narrowed the circle of prejudice and error.” So far Sir James had confined himself to the illustration of doctrines purely Huttonian; but we should be doing injustice to his sagacity and originality, were we to omit stating that he by no means followed Dr Hutton in all his ideas. On the contrary, he always considered Dr Hut- ton’s explanation of the formation of valleys, and of the pre- sent appearance of the earth’s surface generally, as quite incomplete. ‘To account for these by the diwrnal action of the elements, he thought altogether untenable. Sir James's theory, which is at once bold and original, is published in the Edinburgh Transactions for 1812, vol. vii. p- 139, 169, in two papers “‘ on the Revolutions of the Earth’s Surface,” to which we call the attention of our readers. Val- leys he conceives to have been formed at various times by a succession of heaves from below, which could not fail to rend and dislocate the solid crust of the globe in a thousand shapes, and to leave it as to the general features, in the rug- ged and irregular form it at present retains, an appearance totally inexplicable upon any view of diurnal action. But as it must be admitted that most mountains, valleys, plains, lakes, and other parts of the earth’s surface, are evidently 6 Sir Janres Hall on the Consolidation of the Strata. no longer in the precise state which they would have been left in by those violent heaves alluded to, he was led to inquire what other causes could be supposed to have reduced them to their present appearance. It was not long before he saw that a vast and overwhelming torrent or debacle (perhaps many more than one) must have passed over all those parts of the globe which he had an opportunity of examining. A little further reflection made it also evident to him, thatif the Huttonian Theory were supposed to be true, such waves became a necessary conse- quence. Forif great masses of strata be suddenly elevated to the surface from the bottom of a deep sea, waves proportionate im size must be produced, which, in their transient, but over- whelming course, would: produce all the well known pheno- mena of a diluvian character. Professor Buckland’s. recent speculations on the same subject form a valuable addition to this most interesting theory. The consolidation of sandstone was another very knotty point amongst the geologists—no theorist of either party, as far as we know, having attempted to account for it by any ra- tional hypothesis. The present paper, which we shall now proceed to analyse, goes far to supply this deficiency. Sir James Hall commences by some general observations on the nature of geological mquiries, and on the spirit in which experiments should be conducted, which have for their objeet to advance the boundaries of this science. These remarks we recommend strongly to any one engaged in similar pursuits ; and we must be permitted to say, that the timeds now surely come when it is incumbent on the supporters of the agweous doctrine to show, experimentally, that their theory 1s equally capable of representing artificially the rocks which we see in nature, so many of which the Huttonians have successfully imitated. rs Our author proceeds to say, it had often been urged, and apparently with good reason, against: this branch | of the Huttonian Theory, that. no amount of heat applied to loose sand, gravel, or shingle, would occasion, the parts to. consolidate into a compact stone. And as: all his ex- perience Jed to the same conclusion, he saw that, unless, along with heat, some flux were introduced amongst. the Sir James Hall on the Consolidation of the Strata. 7 materials, no agglutination of the particles would take place. A striking circumstance, which he describes as occurring near Dunglass in East Lothian, having suggested to him the idea that the salt of the ocean might possibly have been the agent in causing the requisite degree of fusion, he instituted a se- ries of experiments, the details of which he now brings. before the Society. By these he shows, that this material, under va- rious modifications, is fully adequate to explain the consolida- tion of the strata, and perhaps many other effects which we see on the surface of the Earth. His success, from the first, was such as to promise the aise satisfactory results ; but various circumstances occurred to re- tard his progress. “* Whoever,” he judiciously remarks, “ has had any experience in the prosecution of new subjects of experimental inquiry, knows that, owing to his ignorance of the requisite adjustment of the proportions of the ingre- dients, and of other similar arrangements, he must depend, in a great de- gree, upon chance for the success of his first results, and that he must often submit to spend much time and labour upon a subject, even after it has been made out to his own satisfaction, before he has acquired sufficient command over its details to answer for the reselt of any particular expe- riment, so as to be able to produce it with confidence to the public.”— pp. 5, 6 The scene alluded to as having first excited Sir James’ at- tention to this subject was on the borders of Lammermuir, ** where * A set of horizontal beds occur, consisting of a loose assemblage of rounded stones, intermixed with sand and gravel, which bear every ap- pearance of having been deposited by water, and which, as to their general history, seem to have undergone no change since the overwhelming, though transient, agitations of water, of which I have frequently had occasion to speak in this Society. “© Tn the summer of 1812, as I was returning from visiting the granitic range which occurs in the water of Fasnet, in the hills of Lammermuir, and riding down the little valley of Aikengaw, which deeply indents this loose collection of gravel and shingle, about two miles above the village of Oldhamstocks, and at the distance of eight or ten miles from the sea, I was struck with astonishment on seeing one of these gravel banks, fried, as above described, of perfectly loose materials, traversed vertically by a dyke, which, in its middle, consisted of whinstone, and was flanked by’ splid conglomerate ; but this solidity abated gradually till the conglutination of the rounded masses diminishing by degrees, the state of loose shingle and 8 Sir James Hall on the Consolidation of the Strata. gravel was entirely restored on both sides. The agglutinated mass adja- cent to the dyke bore no resemblance to the result of calcareous petrifae- tion ; scarcely ever gave effervescence with acid; and, by its gradual ter- mination, differed from any whinstone-dyke I have seen to penetrate the Strata ; for, in the ordinary case, the termination of the crystallite against the adjoining aggregate through which it passes, is almost always quite abrupt. “ About a hundred yards higher up the valley of Aikengaw, there occurs an agglutination similar to the last, though without any whin-dyke, and sufficiently strong to resist the elements, by which the surrounding mat- ters had been washed away, leaving the pudding-stone, or agglutinated shingle, to stand up by itself, in a manner remarkable enough to have at- tracted the notice of the peasantry as something supernatural, since they have bestowed upon it the name of the Fairy’s Castle. “Farther up the stream, other agglutinations cccur frequently, as we could see in little narrow glens cutting through the mass ; and higher still, they are so numerous as to meet and convert the whole into one unbroken mass of pudding-stone, occupying all that is exposed to view. ** These very remarkable, and, to me at least, novel appearances, were the first which suggested the idea, that the consolidation not only of this class of conglomerates, but of sandstone in general, had been occasioned by the influence of some substance in a gaseous or aériform state, driven by heat into the interstices between the loose particles of sand and gravel, where it had acted as a flux on the contiguous parts. On considering what this penetrating substance might be, and from whence it could have come, the following circumstance presented itself to my recollection at the moment, and promised to afford some assistance to these conjectures. “* A few miles lower down the valley in which the above facts were ob- served, at the distance of more than a mile from the sea; and between two and three hundred feet perpendicularly above it, there occurs a crag of sandstone, in which a numerous succession of strata are distinctly visible. Several of these beds have yielded much to the action of the air, and, in dry weather, exhibit a considerable white efflorescence, which has com- pletely the taste of common salt ; and so remarkable is this circumstance, that the rock has acquired, in the country, the name of Salt-Heugh. ** Here, then, it immediately occurred to me, was probably the source of an abundant supply of the elastic substance or fumigator, whose action as a flux had been pointed out by the agglutinations in Aikengaw above de- scribed. “© T conceived, that, if there were at the bottom of the sea a bed of sand and gravel, drenched with brine of full saturation, and that heat were ap- plied to it from beneath, according to Dr Hutton’s hypothesis, the first ef- fect would be, to drive the water from the lowest portion of the sand, and to convert the salt which remained amongst it, together with the sand, in- to a dry cake. During this operation, or until the cake became quite dry, the absorption of latent heat would prevent the temperature from surpass~ —— Se SS ee Sir James Hall on the Consolidation of the Strata. 9 ing the boiling point of brine. But no sooner was this dryness accom- plished, than, I imagined,-the temperature of the mass would begin to rise above that pitch ; the portion of it next the fire would gradually acquire a red-heat ; that then the salt, being made by the heat in part to assume an elastic form, would be sent in fumes through the dry cake just described, and thus, by partially melting the contiguous particles, produce an agglu- tination. “Such being my theoretical views, no time was lost in submitting them to the test of experiment. Taking it for granted that a quantity of sea-salt must frequently be formed and deposited, along with sand and gravel, at the bottom of the ocean, (in the manner I shall have occasion to describe at another stage of this paper), where the water has been collect- ed by its superior specific gravity, in the form of brine, I proceeded to make the following experimeuts :— *< Dry salt was placed along with sand, sometimes in a separate layer, at the bottom of the crucible, and sometimes mixed throughout the expe- riment: the whole was then exposed to heat from below. I found that the salt was invariably sent in fumes through the loose mass, and by its action produced solid stone in a manner completely satisfactory, as illustra< tive of the facts in Aikengaw ; and so as to give a good explanation of the production of sandstone in general. ‘* These artificial stones are of various degrees of durability and hard- ness ;—some of them do not stand exposure to the elements, and crumble when immersed in water ;—some resist exposure for years ;—others are so soft as not to preserve their form for any length of time ;—while some bear to be dressed by the chisel ; and, it may be remarked generally, that, as far as the results of my experiments have been compared with natural sandstone, the same boundless variety exists in both cases. A striking in- stance of this resemblance occurs in the case of the Salt-heugh, the sand- stone of which, when immersed in water, crumbles down, exactly in the same manner as those results of my experiments which taste much of salt. “© The fumes of the salt, no doubt, act, in all these cases, asa flux on the siliceous matter, and thus cemeut the adjacent particles together. The So- ciety are, doubtless, well aware of the power of salt fumes in glazing pot- tery; and the analogy, I conceive, is complete. It is the application alone that is new. _ “ So far the results were satisfactory. But it next occurred, that it might be plausibly objected, that the presence of the superincumbent cool ocean would interfere with the process, on the principles of latent heat. To put this to the test, I proceeded to expose a quantity of sand, covered to the depth of several inches with common salt-water, to the heat of a furnace, and, as the liquid boiled away, replenished it from time to time by additions from the sea. Of course it gradually approached to a state of brine. But this proved a very tedious operation, requiring a continyed ebullition, during three weeks, without ceasing, before it became suffi- 10 = Sir James Hall on the Consolidation of the Strata. ciently saturated with salt by the discharge of the fresh-water ; and I thought it much easier, and no less satisfactory,- te employ brine from the first, formed at once by loading the water with as much salt as it could - dissolve, amounting to about one-third of its weight. “* The vessels employed in these early experiments, were the large black- lead crucibles used by the brass-founders. I filled the vessel, which was 18 inches high and 10 broad, nearly to the brim with brine of full satura- tion, the lower portion being occupied, to the depth of about 15 inches, with loose sand from the sea-shore, and thoroughly drenched with: the brine. In order to have a view of the progress of the experiment, I placed an earthen-ware tube, about the size and shape of a gun-barrel, closed at bottom, and open at the top, in a vertical position, having its lower extre- mity immersed in the sand, and reaching to within about an inch of the bottom of the pot, while the other end rese a foot above the surface of the brine, and could be looked into without inconvenience. ‘* After a great number of experiments, furnishing an unbounded va- riety of results, 1 at length obtained a confirmation of the main object in view. I observed that the bottom of the porcelain barrel, and of course the sand in which it rested, became red-hot, whilst the brine, which, dur- ing the experiment, had been constantly replenished from a separate ves- sel, continued merely in a state of ebullition: the upper portion of the sand, drenched with the liquid, remained permanently quite loose, but the lower portion of the sand had formed itself into a solid cake. ~¢ 8 * On allowing the whole to cool, after it had been exposed to a high heat for many hours, and breaking up the mass, I was delighted to find the result, occupying the lower part of the pot, possessed of all the quali- ties of a perfect sandstone, as may be seen in the specimens now presented to the Society. Whenever the heat was not maintained so long, the sand- stone which resulted was less perfect in its structure, tasted’ strongly of salt, and sometimes crumbled to sand when placed in water. ** Many of these early experiments were accomplished with tolerable success. But still the result was somewhat precarious, and could not be announced with the confidence that I felt in presenting my former experi- ments to this Society. “‘ The cause of this uncertainty I traced to the chemical ‘operation’ of the salt, acting as a flux upon the porcelain vessels employed. This very action, I was well aware, was the main agent and cause of our success, when kept within proper bounds ; but, on being allowed to pass those li- mits, and to act on the containing vessel as well as on the experiment, it destroyed the vessel, and converted the whole into a confused mass of slag. «* After numberless unsuccessful attempts, and after returning again and again to the charge, with an interval sometimes of years, I at last met with a quality in some of the materials to me altogether unlooked for, by means of which may be obtained successful results, with scarcely any ous of failure. ‘* T found that the action of the salt upon the substances of the crucibles 4 Sir James Hall on the Consolidation of the Strata. 11 of clay, did not exert itself in the same manner upon iron; but that a large vessel of cast-iron, 18 inches deep by 10 wide, and a common gun- barrel welded up at the breech, and open at the top, enabled me to work with the heat of melting gold, without injuring the vessels, and at any time to produce a perfect freestone; thus satisfying our theoretical expec- tations. 3 “¢ Similar results, in all respects, were produced by exposing pure pound- ed quartz to the action of the salt fumes,—and also when gravel, or any other mass of Joose materials, was used instead of sand.” pp. 6—12. Sir James next proceeds to show, that if this theory of the consolidation of sandstone be admitted as sound, there is an adequate supply of salt to be looked for in nature, or at least of brine, which is nearly the same thing. He conceives, that in the Mediterranean, and other similar seas, where there is a greater evaporation from the surface than supply of fresh water by the rivers, rains, &c., the sea, at the bottom, will gradually approach to a state of brine. And even, without entering into any such theoretical explanation of how this sup- ply of salt is formed, he thinks it sufficient that there are known to exist in the world many large districts of rock-salt, lakes and rivers of salt water, and numerous brine-springs in this and other countries. It was objected, as SirJames tells us, to his Theory, by a mem- ber of the Royal Society, that the influence of the superincum- bent ocean would, in all cases, counteract, by its coolness, the efrect of the heat, and prevent the formation of stone: but these experiments most distinctly prove, that this effect, however probable it certainly was, would not take place, since it was easy, by means of his device of the gun-barrel, to look into the heart of the experiment, and discover the red-hot sand under the water, while, at the same time, the temperature of the brine on the top was so low that the hand could be plunged into it without injury. But whenever the same experiment was tried with fresh water instead of brine, no exertion of heat ever pro- duced a red heat. Nothing, certainly, in the history of chemi- cal experiment, is more satisfactory than this; and the ex- treme simplicity of the contrivance by which so important a fact has been established, instead of diminishing, only adds to our admiration of that ingenuity which seems always to 7 12 Sir James Hall on the Consolidation of the Strata. come to the assistance of some men just at the moment of need. Sir James concludes his Paper by adverting to some other speculations which are not yet fully matured, but which he is in hopes, ere long, to lay before the public. ‘ A simple al- lusion to one or two of these,” he says, ‘‘ may perhaps be re- ceived with indulgence.” «I conceive, that salt, in the state of fumes, and urged by a powerful heat, possibly also modified by pressure, or perhaps combined with other substances, may have penetrated a great variety of rocks, acting a8 a flux on some, as in basalt, granite, &c. ; agglutinating others, as in the case of sandstone, pudding-stone, &c. ; softening others, as in the case of contort- ed strata of greywacke. In many cases, too, 1 conceive that these fumes may have had the power of carrying along with them various other mate- rials, such as metals in a sublimed state, which would in this way be in- troduced into rents, veins, and cavities, or may even have entered into the solid mass of the rocks, which I imagine these fumes may have had power to penetrate. I have already tried some experiments in pursuit of .these ideas. Salt, for instance, has been mixed with oxide of iron, reduced to fine powder, and then exposed to heat along with quartzose sand. The iron, I found, was borne up along with the salt fumes. The sandstone, formed in this way, was deeply stained with iron, and other most curious appearances presented themselves. «* Every one who has seen a sandstone quarry, must have noticed evi- dent traces of iron, the rock being stained in a-great variety of ways ; sometimes in parallel layers,—sometimes in concentric circles, or rather in portions of concentric spheres, like the coats of an onion,—and, generally speaking, disposed in a way not accountable by deposition from water. All these appearances I would account for, by supposing the rock, either at the moment of its agglutination into sandstone, or at some subsequent period, to have been penetrated by the fumes of salt, charged with iron, also in a state of vapour. *‘ | may mention one very curious result of my experiments with salt and iron, acting upon sand, namely, that, upon breaking up the specimen of artificial sandstone, an appearance often presents itself of incipient cry- stallisation, if I may use this term ; a number of large, shining, parallel faces pervade the whole mass, and, by holding the specimen at the proper angle to the light, this appearance becomes very obvious. What the na- ture of these crystals is, I have not investigated ; but as they very much resemble what we see in different kinds of sandstone, I am of opinion that they hold out a fair expectation, of our being able to produce many of the crystalline appearances with which we are familiar in. nature. “* Common sea-salt, such as I have used, as is well known, is not pure muriate of soda; and, in my experiments, I have mixed various other il . Mr Blackadder on Vertical and Lateral Mirage. 18 substances with it. In Nature, we must suppose that various contaminat- ing substances would in like manner occur, to diversify the phenomena ; and, accordingly, we do find a boundless variety, in the aspect not only of sandstone, but of almost every kind of rock ; and I am by no means with- out expectation, that, in the course of time, we shall be able to imitate in our laboratory as many of these varieties as we choose to exhibit. I have long been engaged also in a series of experiments on the forma- tion of Crystallites, the name by which, as I have before stated, every crystallised rock might, perhaps, be usefully distinguished in contradis- tinction to Aggregates, or those formed of fragments. This great object in experimental geology, I hope to accomplish by means of an instrument which I have long had in use, for the regulation of high heats, a deserip- tion of which may probably soon be laid before the Society, together with some further results in support of the Huttonian Theory of the Earth.”— pp. 15, 16. We again repeat our earnest solicitation to Sir James Hall to make this invention known to the public. There is, we be- lieve, at this moment, more than one chemist on the Conti- nent,* if not in this country, engaged in the formation of crys- tals in imitation of nature; and as we know that the regula- tion of high heats is by far the most difficult part of the pro- cess, we trust that Sir James may be induced to lend the as- sistance of this valuable instrument to a subject which, it may be fairly presumed, he has as sincerely at heart as any man in the field. Sir James Hall stands so high as an experimental geologist, if we may be allowed the expression, and his authority is now a-days so often quoted, that we think a reprint of all his pa- pers, in a separate form, would be gratefully received by the scientific world. Arr. I].—On some Phenomena of Vertical and of La- teral Mirage, observed at King George's Bastion, Leith. An Extract of a Letter to the Editor, from Henry Home BiackappEr, Esq. Surgeon, Med. Staff, H. P. Cross along the seashore, to the north-east of the new Docks at Leith, there is an extensive bulwark, the central part of which is named King George’s Bastion. This bulwark is “ See this Journal, vol. i. p. 375, and vol. ii. p. 129. 14 Mr Blackadder on Vertical and Lateral Mirage. formed of huge blocks of cut sand-stone, and was intended both as a protection against the sea, and, if need should be, against the attacks of an enemy. When the weather is favour- able, this bulwark affords an opportunity of witnessing most of the interesting phenomena, connected with what has been termed unusual atmospheric refraction. Near the centre of the range there is a solid stone tower, and from this to the eastern extremity, the appearances are observed to most ad- vantage. From the tower eastward, the bulwark forms a straight line to the distance of about 498 feet. It is eight feet in height, on the side next to the land, and has a foot-way up- wards of two feet in breadth, and about three feet from the ground. At the top, the parapet is three feet wide, and has a slight inclination towards the sea. __ When the weather is favourable, and that is not of rare oc- currence, the top of the parapet has the appearance of a mir- ror, or rather of a sheet of ice, and, if in this state, another person stands or walks upon it, at a little distance, an inverted image is seen under him. _ If, while standing on the foot-way, another person stands on it also, but at some distance, with his face turned towards the sea, his image will appear oppo- site to him, giving the appearance of two persons talking, or saluting each other. If again, when standing on the foot- way, and looking in a direction from the tower, another per- son crosses the eastern extremity of the bulwark,. passing through the water-gate, either to or from the sea, there is pro- duced the appearance of two persons moving in). opposite .di- rections—constituting what has been termed a lateral mirage— first one is seen moving past, and then the other in an oppo- site direction, with some interval between them. - In lookme over the parapet, distant objects are seen variously modified, the mountains converted into immense bridges, &e. On going to the eastern extremity of the bulwark, and di- recting the eye towards the tower, the latter appears curious- ly modified, part of it being as it were cut off; and brought down, so as to form another small and elegant tower, in the form of certain sepulchral monuments. See Plate I. Fig. 13. a ., oa ee Dr Uibbert on the Discovery of the Fossil Eik. 15 At other times, it bears an exact resemblance to an ancient al- tar, the fire of which seems to burn with “great intensity. At some distance beyond the tower, there is'seen the chimney-top of a house for boiling pitch, or other purposes connected with the docks. _When smoke tssues from that: chimney, the ap- pearance represented in. Fig. 14 was produced. »'The black waved lines under the smoke had a rapid vibratory motion, while the motion of that which represents the fire ofthe altar, was exactly similar (excepting in colour) to the flame ofa strong: fire. * The aceompanying outlines will render the above Farsi tion sufficiently intelligible. Some hygrometrical and thermo- metrical observations, connected with this subject,: may'‘be brought forward on a future occasion. a Art. I1].— Account of the Circumstances connected with the Discovery of the Fossil Elkin the Isle of Man, which prove that this Animal is not Antediluvian, as many Naturalists and Antiquaries have supposed. By Samuet Hrezert, M. D. F. R. S. E. and M. G. S. Secretary to the Society of Scottish Antiquaries. Tuere are few subjects in Natural History more interesting than the circumstances connected with the discovery of those Fossil Animals, the several races of which are either foreign to the country and climate in which they are at present found, or have become wholly extinct. In reference to this curi- ous investigation, the Irish Elk attracts no small share of atten- tion. ‘lhe zoologist inquires, whether animals of the same kind are still to be found on the surface of the globe, or have completely disappeared :—if the latter supposition be enter- tained, the antiquary proposes a question, at what era races of them might have existed? while the geologist contents him- self with a solution of the great difficulty, whether their ex- * A full detail of the principles, on which the phenomena of Vertical and Lateral Mirage depend, will be found in the Edinburgh E — dia, ARTICLE Optics, vol. xv- p- 617. 16 Dr Hibbert on the Discovery of the Fossil Elk. tinction is not referable to a period so long prior to all histo- rical records, as to claim for them an antediluvian origin. The last question is the one that I shall at present consider. The first British naturalist who attracted the attention of - philosophers to the Fossil Elk, was Sir Thomas Molyneux, who, in the year 1726, described it with far more accuracy than had been done before. He pronounced it to be of the genus Cervinum, or deer kind, and of the sort that carries broad or palmed horns, bearing a greater affinity to the buck or fallow-deer, than to the stag or rein-deer, which has round horns, branched without a palm. * He also observed, that the Irish elks were gregarious like the elks of Sweden, or the rein-deer of the Northern countries of Europe ;—drawing this conclusion from the statement of a Mr Osborne, who, while he was trenching an orchard, found three heads and sets of horns in the compass of one acre of land. The same philoso- pher again remarked, that these animals were discovered from five to ten feet under ground, in a sort of marl. These are the leading circumstances, with which we have been long acquainted, relative to the discovery of the Fossil Elk, and they are almost sufficient for any geologist to draw from them the conclusion, that the race of this animal, so far from being antediluvian, has either been but recently extinct, or even yet exists. + And, infact, this was the very conclusion to which Sir Thomas Molyneux arrived, though he failed in his task of endeavouring to identify the Irish elk with the American moose-deer. Still, there has not for a century been wanting geologists, 4 * An accurate representation, by Mr Burman of Douglas, of a fine head of the Elk, in his possession, was sent to Alexander Seton, Esq. an able Antiquary, who has obligingly permitted it to be engraved. (See Plate II, Fig. 1.) The dimensions to which the letters in the figure refer, are stated as follows: ‘From A to B, 6 feet 11 inches; from B to C, 5 feet two inches; from D to E, 2 feet 6 inches; from F to G, | foot 2 inches ; from H to I,1 foot 74 inches; from N to O, 5 feet. Circumference at L K, 7 inches ; circumference at the root C, 11 inches.” + Dr Knox was led to entertain this opinion, from different sources of observation, namely, from the anatomical structure of the animal, and its state of preservation. - Dr Hibbert on the Discovery of the Fossil Elk. 17 who, in opposition to this plain statement of facts, have sup- posed that these Fossil remains were indicative of animals which had been destroyed by the universal deluge. Hence the transportation or drifting of their bones by an over- whelming torrent, into such insular tracts as Ireland and the Isle of Man. And, since the discovery of the bones in the Hyena Cave of Kirkdale, a similar conjecture has been hazard- ed by Professor Buckland, * though, from some subsequent conversation with Mr Weaver, he now seems inclined to re- consider the subject. After these remarks, I shall proceed to describe the geolo- gical circumstances connected with the earthy deposits in which the elk is found. A southerly, and far most considerable, portion of the Isle of Man is diversified by irregular mountainous ranges of clay slate, and micaceous schist. In this extensive district it has been affirmed that no remais of the elk are to be found ; but that they only occur in the extensive flat on the north of the is- land, named the Curragh, which is characterized by a thick deposit of clay, marl, sand, and gravel. This is, however, a mistake. About a mile to to the north-west of the Tynwald Hill, at a short distance from the Peel River, there is a low marshy piece of ground from which large quantities of shell marl have been procured for the purposes of manure; and in this mar] numerous bones of the elk have been observed in an imbedded state. But in the course of describing this site more particularly, I shall advert, in a very general manner, to the origin of the caleareous deposit in which these interest- ing relics have been found. There are several evident indications in the vicinity of the Tynwald Hill of some very ancient lakes having been formed m the low sites of this westerly part of the island, the over- flow from which was discharged into the sea by the channel that now forms the bed of the Peel River. The tributary torrents by which these lakes were supplied, had carried with them the disintegrated materials of the rocks among whic) they * Reliquie Diluviane, page 180. VoL. 11. No. 1. guLY 1825. RB 18 Dr Hibbert on the Discovery of the Fossil Elk. flowed, and, in the course of ages, had succeeded by this accumulation of earthy matter in excluding the water from these hollows, as well as in changing the course, or narrowing the bed of the river by which these lakes communicated with each other, and with the sea on the west. But another cause besides this will be found in most instances to have assisted in levelling the land, and as no one has more clearly explained this cause than Dr MacCulloch,* it would be an injustice to him not to giye it in his own words. ‘* Many fresh water shells,” he observes, ** breed in lakes, and even in the shallowest and smallest pools; and as their death and reproduction is very tapid in many cases, a considerable addition of solid matter is made to that which is brought in from the rocks and soil which the feeding waters act on in their courses. Such shells, therefore, produce calcareous beds, which are never, or rarely at least, inuch consolidated, but are known by the name of marl. This marl also varies in character, as the shells may have disappeared entirely, or it may be further intermixed with the clay or the sand introduced by the rivers.” The shell marl, which is accumulated in the low sites of ground near the Peel River, is of a milk-white colour, also, when dried, very light and porous. All the shelly parts are in such a comminuted state, and so mixed up with clay or sand, that I could not find a specimen in which the organic structure of the animals to which the marl owes its origin was presery- ed. The bones of the elk are said to be found about six to ten feet deep in this marl, and mixed along with them, particu- larly in the more superficial strata, are the remains of nume- rous aquatic plants, as of willows, ferns, reeds, &c. indicative of the ancient marshes which succeeded to the levelling of the land, and to which the elks appear to have resorted. In the upper beds the calcareous matter gradually lessens, showing that the gradual extinction of the race of fresh water shells kept pace with the filling up of the lake. A stratum of sand, the pure and nearly unmixed debris of the neighbouring hills, * Article Oncantc Remains in Dr Brewster’s Encyclopedia, vol. xv. p: 726 Dr Hibbert on the Discovery of the Fossil Elk. 19 is superjacent to the shell marl, while a comparatively modern _ bed of peat covers the whole. But a question is now naturally suggested—To what cause do the elks owe their inhumation in the marl ? Dr MacCulloch on this subject observes, that ‘* these ani- mals appear to be collected, as it were, into a herd; and gene- rally the skeletons are entire, or, at least, if bones are wanting, there is no dispersion of them. Farther, it has been remark- ed, that they are generally in an erect position, and the com- mon people of the country who have dug them out, and who have no hypothesis to serve, assert that their noses, when thus erect, are elevated as high as possible. The natural conclu- sion from these facts is, that this has been a herd suddenly surrounded by the materials in which the specimens now lie, so as to have been inclosed and preserved in their living atti- tudes. An inundation of water and gravel, or sand and mud, would explain this, when favoured by peculiar circumstances in the form of the land; while the preservation of the erect posture, no less than the very singular position of the nose, proves that the operation must have been gradual; the ani- mal’s last efforts having been those of keeping its head as long as possible above the flood.” * Now, this opinion would not, I think, have been advanced, if it were not for the misrepresentations of the labourers who had been employed in the marl pits of the Isle of Man, and who were consulted on the occasion. Nor does Dr MacCulloch offer his hypothesis with any great confidence, being himself doubtful how far the statements which he received were to be depended upon. For, how could the labourers affirm that the elk is generally found in an erect position, when an entire ske- leton of this animal has never yet been discovered? I shall take another occasion to explain, that the specimen in the Uni- versity of Edinburgh, generally conceived to be entire, is prin- cipally composed of dispersed bones. Again, in the vicinity of the Peel River, near the Tynwald Hill, the elk is found in a situation which is perfectly fatal to the notion that a herd * See Article Organic Remarns in Dr Brewster's Encyclopedia, vol. Xy. p. 727. 20 Dr Hibbert on the Discovery of the Fossil Elk. of animals of this kind was destroyed by immersion, or caught in a sudden and unexpected flood. For it is difficult to con- ceive of any ordinary torrent, however rapid it might be, which could have succeeded in preventing the elks on any such emer- gency from securing their escape by repairmg to the nume- rous eminences, which are immediately contiguous to the marl pit in which their bones are at present found. The hypothesis, then, that I would myself propose, is sug- gested by the circumstance remarked in Ireland, as well as in the Isle of Man, that the remains of the elk are commonly detected in marl,—or that they are comparatively rarein any other description of alluvial matter. For, may not a reason- able supposition be entertained, that this very general occur- rence has a reference to some particular habits of the elk when alive? Now, I have often had occasion to remark, that the pools in which marl is apt to accumulate are often the very spots that are selected by graminivorous animals, particularly of the deer kind, as watering-places ; but, whether the predi- lection which may be given to such pools, arises from calca- reous matter being diffused through the water, or from some other quality, I will not hazard a conjecture. Nor would I build any hypothesis upon this result of my own experience, the truth of which remains to be determined by more expe- rienced agriculturists than myself. I can only add, that much countenance is given to my opinion by several facts which have come to my knowledge. Thus, in the vicinity of Al- tringham, in Cheshire, remains of the common deer have been found imbedded in ancient marl: and from the marl of Wal- lisey Mere, the pool of which is in part filled up by a deposit of this kind, bones of similar animals were lately extracted. When, therefore, we reflect, that the remains of elks are chiefly found in those ancient pools which have been gradually filled up by marl, the direct question is,—are we entitled to infer, from this general circumstance, that these animals have _ met with a xatwral rather than with a violent death ? On this subject some light may be obtained by analogical examples. In my inquiries respecting the situations in which the red deer of Dunkeld are generally found, when they meet with a natural death, I have been assured that they are most fre- Dr Hibbert on the Discovery of the Fossil Elk. 21 quently discovered stuck in the soft ground of swamps .or shallow pools. An animal of this baiay languid from disease, sinks deep 1 in the marsh to which it may have been accustom- ed to repair, and not possessing strength sufficient to extricate itself, is usually left in this state to pebiah. Hence a very plausible hypothesis may account for the circumstances under which the elk is usually found. The animal, during sickness, either in company with the herd to which it is attached, or apart from its companions, may have frequented a familiar watering-spot, in order to quench its thirst, and sinking in the soft marly substance which has accumulated round the margin of the lake, may have in vain exerted its limbs, enfeebled by aia ease, to disengage itself, and in this situation have actually died. Some of its bones may have been dissipated by the action of the atmosphere, and other natural causes ; some may have been borne away by carnivorous animals ; while the remaining num- ber may have owed their preservation to rains, which had wash- ed them deeper in the lake, where they would be gradually enveloped by shell-marl in its process of filling up the basin. Such a view of the case is, in fact, attended with much fewer difficulties than if we resort to a cause so adventitious as that of an overwhelming flood, or any other expedient of this kind, as that the animal had been drowned, while attempting to elude the pursuit of its enemies; for Professor Buckland has announced, that this last opinion is entertained by Mr Weaver. The next question suggested is purely speculative : :—From what cause has this dentinal become extinct in the British islands ? Sir Thomas Molyneux conceived, that a sort of distemper, or pestilential murrain, might have cut off the Irish elks; and, connecting this view With the remains of many of them being found in one place, he supposed, that, as these animals had lived together in herds, they had died together in numbers. Headduces, in support of this view, a passage from Scheffer relative to the distemper which, at times, carries off whole herds of the rein deer. All this may be fair reasoning enough. . It is, however, questionable, if the human race has not occa- - sionally proved as formidable as a pestilence in exterminating 22 Dr Hibbert on the Discovery of the Fossil Elk. from various districts, whole races of wild animals; though we are certainly short of historical evidence, when we would prove that this has been the case with regard to the elks in the Isle of Man and Ireland. These are the various observations which occurred to me after I had examined the situation in which the elks of the Isle of Man are discovered near the Peel River; but, as I was also informed, that they were still more abundantly found in a northerly part of the country, to which geologists, from its peculiar character, would now give the name of diluvial, I was anxious to examine this district. But, before describ- ing the result of my investigation, it may be expedient to ad- vert very briefly to the general distinction that Professor Buckland draws between dilwviwm and alluvium. In a paper which I published in the last number of this. Journal, it was stated, that ‘* Professor Buckland had proposed to separate two classes of phenomena which were previously referred to one common cause. Of these, the first is, the ge- neral dispersion of gravel and loam over hills and elevated plains, as well as valleys, which he conceives to be the efféct of an universal and transient deluge. To the gravel and loam thus said to be dispersed, the name of di/wviwm, in reference to their alleged cause, has been given. The second class of phenomena includes the partial collection of gravel at the foot of torrents, and of mud at the mouths and along the course of rivers, this partial collection of gravel, mud, or sand, being distinguished from the first class by the name of allwviwm. Thus, we are said to have deposits of dilwviwm or of allwviwm, the first of these being referable to the action of an universal de- luge, the latter (or the alluvium) to that of existing causes.” Into the reasonableness of this view I shall not at present in- quire, my object being rather to show, that, as Professor Buckland claims all animals which are discovered in diluvial deposits, as antediluvian animals, the fossil elk is found under circumstances that completely prevent it from boasting so re- mote a date of origin. The strata of cligy slate and mica slate, which occupy an area of the Isle of Man amounting to almost three-fourths of it, have a line of direction that most frequently extends from Dr Hibbert on the Discovery of the Fossil Elk. 23 south-west to north-east. They assume the form of irregular mountain ridges, which at Snaefell, the highest hill of the place, attain an elevation of 2004 feet. -Keeping, then, these circumstances of the primary strata in view, if we trace a line on the map nearly regular, commencing at the east of the island at Ramsey, and continued across it in a course very nearly west, we shall find on survey that, when the lofty moun- ‘tain ridges which I have described come in contact with this imaginary line, they abruptly terminate; the remaining fourth part of the island to the north appearing as one vast and near- ly dead flat. This expanse is popularly named the Curragh, and it is on this site, as I have before remarked, that most of the remains of the elk are to be found. But before I advert to the circumstances connected with their inhumation, it will be necessary to describe, with some degree of precision, the deep deposit of clay, marl, sand, and gravel, which distin- guishes this district. The lofty ridges of primary strata which constitute the chief part of the Isle of Man, must be considered as forming, along their northerly line of termination, a part of the deep boundary of an immense depression or basin that shelves ab- ruptly to an unknown depth. The question then is, With what materials has this depression of the Curragh been filled ? An attentive examination of the nature of this deposit will prove, that the basin contains transported fragments, the geo- logical character of which is unlike that of any mountain masses that occur in the Isle of Man. Far distant hills, perhaps of Scotland, which have been chiefly composed of transition limestone, trap-rock, grauwacke, quartz, granite, and porphyry, having yielded to the disintegrating effects of atmospheric agents, an immense quantity of debris has, in the course of ages, accumulated ; and if we adopt the most ready theory which is suggested on the occasion, an immense, wave from the north (which, according to the hypothesis of Pro- fessor Buckland, has passed with an incredible velocity over the surface of the earth, and has thus given rise to the Mosaic deluge,) appears, in the course of its progress, to have forced these disintegrated materials from their native site, and while dispersing them in the direction of its current, to have at 24 Dr Mibbert on the Discovery of the Fossil EIR. length obtained a secure lodgement for them in the deep basin of the Curragh. According, then, to the view of Professor Buckland, the greatest portion of the clay, marl, sand, and gravel of the Curragh would be diluvial. But I use this geological term in a far more limited sense. I involve, in its meaning, no- thing more than the agency of an immense wave which swept the deposit, now under consideration, from far distant shores ; —but it is a distinct proposition to maintain, that this very wave, the origin of which is involved in the greatest mystery, can be the same which produced all the effects that are as- cribed to the Mosaic Deluge. After these remarks, I shall proceed to give a general de- scription of the diluvium of the Curragh, in reference to the circumstances under which the fossil elk is discovered. The disintegrated materials, which contribute most to the diluvium, are limestone, rocks of the trap series of formation, and next in order, quartz, grauwacke, granite, and porphyry. Boul- ders and pebbles of all these rocks may be detected in the de- posit. Fragments of limestone are so abundant, that it is usual, for the purposes of agriculture, to carefully collect them from the sea-shore, after they have been loosened by the inroads which the ocean is constantly making upon the cliffs. Calecareous matter is, in fact, found as a more or less abundant ingredient in all the beds of clay, marl, sand, or gravel, which, variously alternating with each other, charac- terize this deposit. Mr Oswald of Douglas has detected in the mar! the fragment of a shell which appears to be a species _of Turritella. Such is the diluvium of the Curragh, in which no remains of the elk have ever yet been discovered; the antediluvian origin, therefore, formerly ascribed to this animal by Profes- sor Buckland was, upon his own views, destitute of proof. I may next remark, that the debris, of which the diluvial matter has been composed, is accumulated in the greatest quantity on the coast. It is considerably worn away by the action of the sea, and occasionally presents to the ocean an abrupt face, where it attains an elevation varying from 70 to 100 feet. In other places, however, the height is far less. Dr Hibbert on the Discovery of the Fossil El}. Q5 But as we recede from the sea; and approach towards the range of hills which forms the southerly limits of the Curragh, we find that the surface of the bank more or less gradually slopes off, so as to form a depression or hollow of inéonsider- able depth, in which has formerly subsisted one or more in- land lakes or marshes. Accordingly, the channels of several small rivers, deriving their origin from lofty rocks of clay- slate, may be detected, to which the ancient lakes of the Cur- ragh have been indebted for their supply. These mountain- streams have, in the course of ages, carried with them im- mense quantities of the disintegrated materials of the hills from which they have had their origin, and have deposited them in the form of gravel, clay, or sand, by which means the depression of the Curragh has been in some measure reduced. Again, the lakes in their overflow have formed for themselves various narrow channels or outlets, by which they have com- municated with the ocean. These rivers have exerted a deep corrosive action on the loose materials of the diluvium; and while the lakes. of the Curragh have become more shallow from the filling up of their basins, a considerable drainage has also conspired to prevent this low tract from being overflowed. But to more particularly describe these effects would be fo- reign to my present object. Suffice it to say, that the surface of the diluvium has, from these causes, undergone very con- siderable modifications. On the north-west of the Cur- ragh a terrace of debris may be observed, such as is thrown up by ariver, when it forces its way through earthy or stony mate- rials loosely accumulated. This terrace consists of alternating layers of gravel, marl, and sand, and (if I do not mistake tne site, which has been pointed out by Mr Oswald) one or two ribs of animals, said to be of the elk, which had probably drifted thither from the neighbourhood, were, many years ago, discovered imbedded in this mass. I shall now advert to the most frequent circumstance con- nected with the discovery of the fossil elk.in the Curragh, namely, its inhumation in alluvial marl. But there are, in this case, two varieties of this substance to be distin- guished. The first is that which had once subsisted as diluvial clay-marl, but either from being exposed to the action of 26 Dr Hibbert on the Discovery of the Fossil Elk. mountain torrents has become more or less mixed with sand and gravel, or from forming the bed of ancient pools, or lakes of water, has become mixed with the remains of shells, as: well _as of vegetable substances. ‘‘ In the flats,” says Mr Oswald, ‘¢ the common marl is loaded with sand, and possesses a laminar’ structure. In Andreas it is of a reddish colour. The Jurby marl is of an earthy grey, and of a compact texture. A spe- ccimen obtained twelve feet deep, contains roots of the fern, and many thin fragments of shells.” To this description, I would add, that in mar! of this kind no remains of the elk have yet been discovered ; they scarcely appear to occur anywhere, (at least in any quantity,) except in the shell marl—a cireum- stance which, as I have stated, must be considered as connect- ed with some habits of the living animal which I have endea- voured to explain. The situation in the Curragh, where numerous remains of the elk have been found, was pointed out to me by the Bishop of Man, to whom I have been much obliged for some valuable assistance which I received in the course of my researches. The deposit from which they are obtained is in the parish of Ballaugh; but as the excavation which had been made was then nearly filled with water, I must refer to Mr Oswald’s account, inserted in the present number of this J ournal, for a more parti- cular geological description. It would appear that, in a basin shaped cavity, a bed of shell mar] reposes, which has been worked from eleven to fourteen feet deep. Below this is the diluvial deposit.* A layer of white sand three feet thick reposes upon the marl, and above the whole a bed of peat four to six feet thick. From this deposit the skeleton of the elk in the Uni- versity of Edinburgh was obtained. ‘This specimen, general- ly conceived to be entire, was the ingenious compilation of a blacksmith of Ballaugh; it was principally got up from bones that had been dispersed, and, as the osseous system of the pro- posed antediluvian animal was still incomplete, a few odd joints were necessarily borrowed from other animals. * Mr Oswald has remarked, that “ throughout this district, where a sufficient depth is attained, boulders of grey limestone of various sizes” (the transported materials of the diluvium) ‘ are found.” 1 Dr Hibbert on the Discovery of the Fossil Elk. 27 But the apparent margin of another bed of shell-marl in Ballaugh from which the elk’has been taken, was not so much concealed as the middle of it. This deposit appeared com- paratively recent. The lowest stratum which was expos- ed had a depth of three feet; 1t was considerably mixed with sand and small pebbles of clay-slate and quartz, the debris of the neighbouring hills; and in this mass several bones of the elk have at various times been found imbedded. Above this marl was a deposit, one foot thick, of the same substance, though mixed with more sand, and containing some little ve- getable matter. In a still higher bed, a layer of sand succeed- ed, one foot thick, mixed with white quartz pebbles: then a layer of drift peat, and another of black mould, each six inches thick, and over the whole, a thinner coat of drift peat. This comparatively recent origin of the deposit in which the elk is found, may be connected with another remarkable cir- cumstance, yet remaining to be noticed. The limited district named Ballaugh, from which the Isle of Man elks are most abundantly obtained, is nothing more than a corruption of the name Bala Lough. In fact, alough or lake subsisted, of so re- cent a date, as to be actually described in a map of the Isle of Man, published in the year 1656, by James Chaloner. (See Plate II. Fig. 2, where part of it is copied.) And as the elk is found imbedded at such a small depth below the surface of this lake, which has been lately filled up, two important ques- tions connected with the natural history of this animal, naturally suggest themselves: first, Have we any evidence from histori- cal records that this animal was well known at a period com- paratively recent ? and, secondly, Does any similar animal exist in Europe, or elsewhere, at the present day ? These questions I shall consider on another opportunity. The foregoing investigation is one that I consider of no small importance. If the elk can be thus shown to be decid- edly postdiluvian, may not a just suspicion be attached to the recently assigned antediluvian origin of various other animals, especially when, like those of the Curragh, they are found in districts which may, at least in part, be proved to be diluzial ? Geologists would do well to pause before they admit, as an es- tablished fact, what yet remains to be confirmed ; and I do not hesitate to add, that the circumstances under which the hyena 28 Mr Oswald's Observations relative to the and other animals have been found at Kirkdale and elsewhere, are still open for a further and very rigid examination.* *,* Having alluded to the researches of Mr Oswald on the subject of the fossil elk, the communication in which they are contained is superadded to this paper. It will be found to give a very interesting and minute detail of the shell-marl deposit of the Curragh ; and the geologist is under considerable obligations to the writer for the pains which he has taken on the subject. Art. IV.—Observations relative to the Fossil Elk of the Isle of Mann; being the Abstract ofa Letter from H. R. Oswa.p, Esq. F.S.S.A., &c. addressed to the Lorp Bisnop or Sopor anv Many, in Reply to certain Queries instituted by Pro- fessor BucKLAND relative to the circumstances under which the Fossil Elk is discovered. My Lorp BisuHop, Ix compliance with your Lordship’s note from Castle Mona, I have drawn up the following answer to Professor Buck- land’s queries respecting the relics of a species of large elk found in some of the marl beds in this island. In the extensive diluvial flat which constitutes the north end of the island, the marl is of two kinds, first, white marl of a fibrous and somewhat laminar structure ; secondly, common clay marl of a brownish grey colour, and compact consistence. The white marl, in which the elk is found, occurs only in small formations in the vicinity of Ballaugh Brewery, and about a mile from the base of the mountains. Though flat at this point, the ground is undulated, and somewhat uneven. The formations of white marl occur in detached basins, which vary from 50 to 150 yards in diameter. ‘The sites of these are frequently, but not always, indicated by shallow hol- lows and morasses on the surface. 'These deposits admit of two varieties. The first of these contains white shell marl, or rather delineations of shells in the marl; the other does not exhibit the remains of shells, and is some shades darker in co- lour, though in other respects similar to the shell variety. © See Dr Knox’s Communication on the Hyena Bones in this Number, p- 80. Fossil Elk of the Isle of Man. 29 The skeleton of the large species of elk which is now in the Museum of the University of Edinburgh, was found at the farm of Balla Terson, in a basin of the shell variety of marl, about 100 yards by 50-in extent, and situated im a wet hol- low or morass, which is filled with aquatic plants, and sur- rounded on all sides by fields of dry and fertile soil. The superficial stratum is peat of excellent quality, light and fibrous, and containing a few trees of bog-timber. It is six feet thick in the middle parts of the morass, but passes out thin, into a black peaty turf towards the margin. Between it and the marl a layer of fine bluish white earthy sand is inter- posed, from two to three feet in thickness. The marl lies at a depth of from seven to ten feet at the middle parts of the pit, but, like the peat, becomes thin at the margin, and passes out when within a foot and ahalf of the black till which forms the surface crust. Nearly one-half of this deposit has been worked during dry seasons, but I have never seen the pit completely drained of its water. According to the calculation of the workmen, the bed of marl in the middle parts of it is from eleven to fourteen feet thick, independent of the layers of turf and sand which I have noticed. A tranverse section of the deposit may therefore be delineated thus: Peat, 4 to G feet. White Sand, 3 feet Marl, 11 to 14 feet. When the workmen penetrate at any time through the mar]; the pit is suddenly inundated by water springing up- from below, from the sand and gravel which form the subsoil. This marl is highly fibrous, and somewhat laminar in its _ structure, and when dry, is as light, and nearly as white as chalk. The shells are delineated white upon a darker ground, and are seen by separating the fibrous layers, but are seldom, if ever, found in their original state. I question much whether shells exist in all parts of the basin, certainly not at its margin. In this basin vast quantities of bones of the large species of elk are found. The workmen have constantly met with them 30 Mr Oswald’s Observations relative to the since the first opening of the pit, and therefore conclude that an incalculable number still remains. These bones occur at all depths of the marl. At and towards the surface of it the bones, like the shells, are merely delineations of what they once were, with little or no difference in consistence from the mass in which they are contained, and therefore, will not bear handling ; in the bed of sand above the mar! all vestiges of them disappear. The deeper these elks are in the marl, the more fresh and perfect they seem; and near the bottom of the bed complete heads are found. ‘They sometimes, though very seldom, are observed imbedded partially in the gravel below. Those in the marl are generally charged with calcareous mat- ter, yet I have frequently seen the thick part of the stem of the horns so unchanged, as to admit of being worked. The bog tim- ber is in this instance solely confined to the peat on the surface. The skeleton now in the Museum of the University of Edinburgh, was found at the bottom of the marl, where the bed was very thick. The different bones, though partly in contact, lay irregularly, and possessed little or no relative po- sition to each other. The head lay with its nose upwards, and the other bones around it were in a state of confusion which the workmen cannot describe. This specimen is the only relic approximating to a complete skeleton which has been met with. But it was not perfect when it was set up; some bones were wanting, and I have reason to conclude that Mr Kewish (the blacksmith who put the skeleton together) availed himself of the relics of other animals. It isno uncom- mon thing to meet with two heads and a number of other re- lics lying in confusion together. One man assured me, that on a late occasion he saw appearances of a perfect skeleton lying on its side in the middle of the basin, all the bones an situ, but whether it would have borne handling was not as- ascertained. To my knowledge two other very fine heads have been raised, one of which, with brow antlers, measured eight feet and a half from the tip at one horn to that of the other, each horn being five-feet eight inches in length; it had three molar and three cutting teeth perfect on each side of the jaw. Single horns, ribs, and fragments of these and of other bones are often met with not only in this basin, but in the other pits of white marl without shells. SE ee Fossil Elk of the Isle of Man. 31 I shall, in the second place, notice the basins of white marl in which no shells now appear. These lie lower down. the plain, nearer to the deposits of common clay-marl. In one of these basins, distant upwards of a quarter of a mile from that described, the marl lies at a depth of from four to six feet only, being covered by a hard, sandy, blackish earth. The field in which it is situated is crusted over with a wet soil. Before the surface of this basin was broken up, it had a thin layer of turf upon the middle or deepest part of it, but there is none now to be seen. Between the alluvial covering and the marl there is a bed of dark turfy fibrous earth, from two to four inches thick, each horizontal layer showing differ- _ ent degrees of shade. The marl itself is darkest near the top, continuing thus to the depth of eighteen inches. In this up- per part of the marl slight veins or rents occur. This marl is also fibrous, and somewhat slaty, and exhibits between its layers white delineations like grass. It likewise contains bones, but they are few in number, and much decay- ed; of these are pieces of ribs, condyles of bones, and stems of large horns, &c. - This deposit of marl, though near the surface, and in a field almost level, is basin shaped, like that last described, va- rying in depth from seven to ten feet in the middle, and pass- ing out to the thinness of a few inches at the margin. The extent of it has not been determined. Excepting a rib and some small fragments, I have not myself seen any of these bones in situ. x * * z I have never heard of or seen any specimens of the head of the beaver in this island, but have learned that large specimens of the head and horns of the common deer have been occa- sionally met with, and that fragments of ribs of a smaller size than those of the elk usually are, have been sometimes found. * e * * * I have the honour to remain, My Lorp Bisuop, Your Lordship’s very obedient humble servant, Doucras, May 29, 1824. Fo the Hon. and Right Rev. H. R. Oswaxp. The Lord Bishop of Sodor and Mann. 32 Dr Hamilton’s Account of the Art. V.—An Account of the Frontier between Ava and the Part of Bengal adjacent to the Karnaphuli River. By Francis Hamivron, M.D. F.R.S. and F.A.S. Lond. and Edin. Communicated by the Author. Tur river called Naaf by Europeans, which enters the sea in about 20° 50 north, for a short way forms the boundary be- tween Ava and Bengal; and across it is the only communica- tion known between the kingdom of Arakan subject to Ava, and Chatigang subject to Britain. North from the forks of this river, so far as I could Jearn in 1798, there was no dis- tinct boundary ; but there extends north, along the whole of the Chatigang district, a mountainous frontier occupied by se- veral rude tribes. Through this region flow many rivers ; some into the sea, either through Chatigang or Arakan, and some into the Erawadi; and the high land at the sources of such of these rivers as run through the district of Chatigang was commonly supposed to be the actual boundary. The rude tribes, indeed, which occupy the hilly countries on both sides of the central height, claim mdependence, and support it, so far as their slender means will admit. On this account, wé cannot depend on there being no passages through this coun- try, because the inhabitants will naturally conceal them, as an intercourse by these passages would inevitably lead to their more full subjection to either one er other of their more power- ful neighbours. In a map of the Empire of Ava by Mr Walker, the rivers flowing through Chatigang are laid down as anastomosing with those which run through Arakan; and this may be the case, although | heard not the most distant hint from the na- tives of such a circumstance. Indeed none of those, with whom I conversed, pretended to know any thing of the sour- ces of the larger rivers, on the banks of which they dwelt, al- leging that a fear of the independent tribes hindered them from ever penetrating so far. Such an anastomosis, in a very hilly country, is singular, and renders uncertain the above mention- ed idea of the boundary. This would increase the probabili- ty of there being passages direct from the sources of the Kar- 4 Frontier between Ava and Part of Bengal. 33 naphuli to Ava, through the country of the Jo; but I am not acquainted with the authority on which Mr Walker has pro- ceeded ; this, however, from the manner in which it is lad down, would seem to be from an actual survey, and is there- fore probably correct, so that the height of the land can only be the boundary towards the northern extremity of the dis- trict of Chatigang, concerning which, I am now about to treat. The total width of the mountaimous region, between the Naaf on the side of Bengal, and Zhenbrugiun on the side of Ava, is about 124 miles east and west; one-half of which pro- _ bably is watered by rivers flowing into the Bay of Bengal, and the other by streams running towards the Erawadi. The whole of this space is occupied by rude tribes alone. As we advance farther north, the width of these wilds increases by low hills adjacent on the west to the Mugg mountains of Ren- nell, and which, on the Karnaphuli, extend about twenty miles west from these mountains, which, by the Bengalese, are there called Barkal. The Bengalese, and the rude inhabitants of these hills, have an utter abhorrence at each other, and their manners, in al- most every thing, are opposite, the rude tribes having more resemblance to the people of Ava, and even of Europe, than the Hindus have. Even their manner of cultivation is totally different. The natives of Gangetic India, especially, altoge- ther neglect Jand that is not level ; while the rude tribes con- sider such as nearly useless, and cultivate the hills alone. Not- withstanding their mutual abhorrence, this in some measure prevents encroachment ; and the low hills, running north from Islamabad (the abode of Faith) to the Phani, are allowed to remain in possession of the rude tribes called Tripura, Jumea, and Chakma. ‘These people seem to have no dependence on the chiefs of their respective nations. In their jooms they rear cotton, rice, and ginger, and a great part of the first and last they exchange with the Bengalese for salt, iron, earthen- ware, and fish. They have no black-cattle; but rear hogs, goats, and poultry, and seem to be in easy circumstances. They are subject to predatory attacks from the Kungkis, no- minally dependent on Radun Manik. ; To the east of these hills is a fine valley watered by the VOL. III. No. 1. JULY 1825. c 34 Dr Hamilton’s Account of the Havildar river, which falls into the Karnaphuli. This valley is level, and cultivated for rice by the Bengalese. East from this is a chain of low hills called Korilliya pahar, which ex- tends far south beyond the Karnaphuli, on the southern bank of which are two steep cliffs, that return the most distinet echo which I have ever heard. ‘These hills are of inconsiderable height ; but, like those north from Islamabad, are neglected by the Bengalese, and allowed to remain with the Muggs, who cultivate after the joom fashion. The Karnaphuli (Ear-ring) river, which Rennell calls Cur- rumfullee, forms at its mouth a good harbour for ships of con- siderable burthen, and would be of great importance, were it not so deeply embayed, that in the S. W. monsoon, ships can- not proceed to sea without danger. At Patarghat, the ferry from Islamabad towards the south, it is about a mile wide; and at Korilliya pahar, it diminishes to about 200 yards, but the tide runs up strong. East from Korilliya pahar, is a fine valley called Run- ganiya, which extends north and south from the Karnaphuli, on the banks of the Ishamati towards the former, and on those of the Silun towards the latter. Although it contains some small hills, it is well cultivated by Bengalese peasants ; and some parts still belongs, as the whole did formerly, to the hereditary chief of the tribe called Muggs at Calcutta, where they are much employed by Christians as cooks, their habits fitting them for preparing our impure diet,. which neither Hindu nor Muhammedan can approach without disgust. Be- yond the low hills, which bound the valley of Runganiya on the north, east, and south, no Bengalese cultivators have set- tled, but the hills are as fully occupied by rude tribes as the nature of the joom cultivation will admit; and, in 1798, when I visited the country, Taubbokha, the hereditary chief of the Mugg people, retained among these hills a kind of m- dependence, although in the parts of his estate, cultivated by Bengalese, he was reduced to the same footing, as the other proprietors of land (Zemindars) in Bengal. In the following account, I shall confine myself to a description of the terri- tory within the hills, which forms a part of the frontier, and, at its southern end, is not above fifteen miles wide from east mT Frontier between Ava and Part of Bengal. 35 to west; but it increases much in width farther north, to- wards the sources of the Chimay and Karnaphuli rivers, where it is probably from thirty to forty miles from east to west. Its length probably is about seventy miles; but of this a con- siderable portion towards the north, has been occupied by the Kungkis called Lusai, who are quite independent of the Mugg chief. Some miles within the western boundary of the low hills, a chain of greater height runs northerly (about N. 40° W.) from the Sungkar, and crosses the Karnaphuli, the course of which, from the Mugg mountains of Rennell, to beyond this chain, is about N. E. by N. and 8S. W. by S. with most nu- merous and great windings. This ridge of hills seems to be about 500 feet in perpendicular height ; and, being of a good soil, is well cultivated after the joom fashion. The portion of it south from the Karnaphuli, is called Sita pahar or Sita mura, and that north from thence, is called Ram pahar, and the continuation of the same ridge is probably that called by the Tripuras, Debta mura, or the Deities Head, the southern portion being dedicated to the God Rama and his wife Sita- At its northern end, Sita pahar descends to the Karnaphuli with a shelving rock, called Sitaka ghat (the landing place of Sita), which is highly venerated, and the Hindus, therefore, offer grain, flowers, and eggs, to Sita and Rama, while the Muggs worship Taung-mang, (Mountain-prince). Even the Muhammedans of this province have adopted the supersti- tion, having contrived some fable for almost every place held sacred by the Pagans, thinking probably, that it would be disgraceful for their religion, were they not provided with as many ceremonies and holy places as their neighbours. Above Sitaka ghat, the Karnaphuli is about 100 yards wide, and of considerable depth. Although the tides flow pretty strong, the water is quite fresh ; but even in the dry season, is rather muddy. The concave side of its reaches have low banks, while, on the convex low hills come down to the water-edge, as indeed is common in hilly countries and small rivers. The soil seems in general to be good, and rests on a rock consisting of thin horizontal strata of clay and sand slightly indurated. The hills are cultivated for jooms, 36 ~ Dr Hamilton's Account of the as much as the nature of the process will admit ; and on the levels, there are Mugg-villages (para) surrounded by many plantain-trees, and gardens or small plots, in which are reared ginger, betle-leaf, sugar-cane, indigo, tobacco, and capsicum. These are their permanent places of abode; but, at their jooms, they have temporary villages called Kamar, which are changed almost every year, and are only occupied by the la- bourers in the season of cultivation. Each para is under the authority of an officer, termed Dewan, who communicates his name to the place; so that the names of the paras undergo frequent changes. In the paras, the huts are better than in the kamars, although each has only one apartment; but the stage, on which it is raised about twelve feet from the ground, is about forty feet by twenty, affording a platform before the door for air and do- mestic work. ‘The ascent to the house is by a notched stick, which serves for a ladder, and is drawn up when the family wishes to avoid intrusion. Except the houses of the chief and of his brother, all the huts of the country seemed very much alike; and the wealthy, as usual in India, rather oc- cupy a greater number of huts, than build houses on a large scale. On the whole, however, the huts in the Mugg paras seem more comfortable than those of the Bengalese cultivators. The people have abundance of poultry and hogs; and, as there are many plains of some extent, which are not fitted for the joom cultivation, the Muggs keep some oxen and buffa- loes, which pasture there, and are probably fattened for eat- ing, although, to avoid offence, this is concealed from the Hindus; but they are not used in the plough. The country, however, is in a poor unproductive state ; and, if cultivated like the West Indies, which its hills equal in soil, it might become of great value. : Every Mugg cultivates as much land as he pleases, and the revenue of the chief arises from a poll-tax, and not from a land-rent. Each man pays in proportion to the strength of his family. It is said, that a married pair, living without any assistance from children or servants, pays annually five ru- pees; and that other families, in proportion to their strength, pay ten, or even fifteen rupees. If the cultivator disposes of Frontier between Ava and Part of Bengai. 37 the produce of his farm, he pays the tax m money ; but, if he chooses, he may pay it in cotton at a fixed price, so that in case of a bad market, the prince may not have. it in his power to exact too great a share of the produce. What part of the revenue goes to the Dewan, for his trouble of manage- ment, I did not learn; but it is probably small, as I saw no appearance of affluence about the habitations of these officers. The chief also receives money from the Bengalese, who’ cut grass for thatch on the plains, which abound with this ma- terial of an excellent quality; and he levies some duties on boats ascending the Karnaphulli. The people called Muggs, at Calcutta, are scarcely known by that name in their native country. By the Bengalese, they are commonly called Chakma or Sagma, or, in ridicule, Dubadse, (two-languaged), because they have in general for- gotten their original language, which is the same with that of Arakan or Roang, as they call it, and have attained a very imperfect knowledge of the Bengalese, although several of them read and write this dialect. They all, however, retain some words of the Roang language, especially their names ; and their priests use both “the character and language of Ara- kan, little different from that of Ava. They all Bilew the doctrines of the Boudhas, but have engrafted on these many Hindu superstitions, and especially bloody sacrifices offered to the Debtas, or deities of the woods, rivers, and mountains. In spite of the admonitions of their priests, this superstition is very prevalent among the Muggs. The Debtas are supposed to dance and sing in the air; and, by their manner of doing so, to render their will known to certain women, called Diyari. On all occasions, when the Muggs are strongly influenced by hope or fear, such as m saclares aud dearth, they apply to a Diyari, who consults the Debta, and is informed by him what sacrifice will be acceptable. This sacrifice is vowed ; and, if the person obtains the object of his wishes, the animal is im- molated at the place where the Diyari says that the Debta re- sides. ‘These Diyaris, by their influence with the Debtas, and by their skill in drugs, are supposed to be also able to render a joom inaccessible to tigers and wild elephants ; 38 Dr Hamilton’s Account of the which, as the natives repose the utmost confidence in this science, is perhaps a sign that these animals are not very de- structive. ‘The magical power, attributed to their Diyaris by the Muggs, by the silly Bengalese, has been extended to the whole tribe, and towards the Megna, a Mugg is beheld with a mixture of abhorrence and fear, from his eating without the observance of cast, and from his supposed power in the black art; so that he is considered nearly as bad as a Christian. The national religion of the Muggs, is the same with that of Arakan, (Rakhain), that is to say, they follow the sect of Maha Muni among the Bouddhists. The chief priest assumes the same title, Paun-do-gri, with the spiritual guide of the king of Ava. He informed me that they have two orders of pmiesthood, the Samana, and Moshang; the latter of whom are superior in point of dignity, and by the Bengalese are called Raulims. The priests, like those of Ava, use a yellow dress, and seem yery numerous im proportion to their follow- ers; but do not appear to be so much respected by the laity, as the priests of Ava are. Some of the laity assume the yellow dress for a time, and give themselves up to study ; but the books which I saw such using, were in the Bengalese character, and except a few words, they understood no other language. The name Chakma or Sagma, given to this people by the Bengalese, is evidently a corruption from Saksah, the name they give to themselves ; while, in the dialect of Ava, or Aree, as they call it, they are termed Sek. 'They seem to be the remains of the first colony from Arakan, that occupied Tri- pura on the conquest of that country from the Muhamme- dans. Many of them still remain in Arakan or Roang, hav- ing probably retired there, when the Moslem power was re- stored in Tripura, and these are distinguished from the con- quered portion by the name Sak-mi, and speak the language of Rakhain alone. The Bengalese they call Koar. The men have adopted the Bengalese dress ; but the women retain that of Arakan and Ava ; and both entirely resemble in person and . features the natives of these cities. Like the other rude tribes in the vicinity, they eat every thing, and have no objection to Frontier between Ava and Part of ‘Bengal. 39 eat along with individuals of other nations; but they do not intermarry with strangers. Although both their rivers and marshes abound in fish, they have not the art of catching these animals, and employ Bengalese fishermen for the pur- pose. Their principal men have slaves, but these are chiefly Tripuras ; nor is it allowable to hold a Saksah in bondage. Several villages, however, both of Tripuras and Kungkis, in a state of personal freedom, live in the territory of the Saksah chief, and subject to his authority. From Sitakaghat to the hills, called the Mugg mountains by Rennell, the course of the Karnaphuli, in a direct line, is between thirty and forty miles; but I took almost four days to ascend this length in a good boat, for which there was a sufficient depth of water, and I reckoned the distance eighty miles by the course of the river. For about two-thirds of the way, I had at times a slight tide with me. Above this, the river contracts to about fifty yards in width, and becomes more rapid and clearer. Where it reaches the Mugg moun- tains, at a place called Barkal, a ledge of rock running en- tirely across the river, stops boats from passiug ; and about a mile farther up, there is a higher ledge, over which the river falls in various beautiful cascades, about six feet high, which, in the rainy season, unite im one great torrent, as appears from evident marks on the banks. ‘The river in May is beautifully clear, and full of fish. The western face of the hills near Barkal is cultivated in jooms; nor is the term Mugg mountains known in the vicinity. The rock is sand- stone. . I shall now give some account of the streams which fall mto the Karnaphuli between Sitakaghat and Barkal, and which water the intermediate country, that is the proper seat . of the Saksah. About ten miles above Sitakaghat, following the course of the river, the Kapty enters, coming from hills at a consider- able distance to the southward. Canoes can ascend this rivu- jet to a village named Kamsey. About the year 1795, a large band of the Bonzhu tribe of Kungkis descended by this rivu- let, and committed great devastation on the Bengalese of Runganiya. 40 Dr Hamilton’s Account of the About eight miles above the Kapty, the Karnaphuli receives the Rain-ghiaun, coming far from the south-east. About two hours and a half rowing from its mouth, lived a Saksah chief of some note, who had several villages (para) under his au- thority. Six days journey farther up this river brings the traveller to the country of the Kungkis, called Bonzhu or Bonjugies. If Mr Walker's idea of these rivers be right, the Rain-ghiaun must be the anastomosing branch, which con- nects the Karnaphuli with the Sunkar and Peereally, which last falls into the Arakan river. The Bonzhu, in this case, will occupy the vicinity of the great peaks called the Blue Mount and Pyramid Hill, along the Peercally and Koladyng rivers. At any rate, they have the Saksah and the Longshue or Lusai tribe of their own nation on the west, and the Jo on the east, and extend, near the 93° of east longitude from Greenwich, from about the 22d to the 24th degree of north latitude. In the course of the next four miles, the Karnaphuli re- ceives from the south-east three small streams, the Duliya cherra, the Tara cherra, and the Kuburiya cherra, which run | through a country in general level, and covered with long grass and a few trees. On this account it is less populous than the more hilly parts, being mostly unfit for the joom cultiva- tion. - About twelve miles farther up enters from the north-west a river of little importance, called Manik cherra. A little higher up, on the opposite side, is the mouth of Mug-ban, which comes from a marsh of the same name. ‘This and another marsh, (jil) on the Duliya, are said to contain immense quan- tities of fish, and to be common resorts of large herds of wild elephants. Above Manik cherra about ten miles, a little above the mouth of the Ranggamati, is the principal residence of the chief, who, by his people, is called Mang, their pronunciation for what, according to the Alphabetum Barmanum, should be written Men, one of the titles usually assumed by the sons of the king of Ava, and therefore analogous to our word Prince. This residence (Rajarbari) contained not only the house of the Raja, but that of his brother, with all their families, except Frontier between Ava and part of Bengal. 41. some Bengalese servants, who had huts on the outside of a fence made of bamboo mats, constituting what is called a fort or castle. The whole habitations within were thatched huts, so far as I could see by looking in at the gate; for I did not enter, as the chiefs were absent, and as their women and pigs were alarmed. The former, I was told, might, without of- fence, be seen by strangers ; but their timidity, at the approach of an European visitant, occasioned a general scream, on which I retired. The same cause in general prevented the women of a lower rank of Saksah from approaching me. They seem to be drudges, being darker coloured than the men, who, compared with the Bengalese, are very fair. f From the chief’s residence there is a fine view of both the ridges of mountains by which the territory of the Saksah are in a great measure bounded. They appeared to me farther distant than I could allow by computing the distances travel- led. Since,I was there, to judge from Mr Walker’s map, the residence of the chief has been moved farther up the river. About two miles above the chief’s residence, a considerable river enters from the north. By the Bengalese it is called Chingay, Singay, or Chimay, and is no doubt that called Chingree by Rennell. My boatmen said, that canoes can as- cend it for six days, which will give a direct course of between thirty and forty miles. One of them, in proceeding to a resi- dence of the chief’s, had gone up five days, during which time the canoe was twice unloaded, and carried past water-falls. The “Saksah say, that this river springs from hills near Kundal, so that its total course, in a direct line, may be about fifty miles, allowing Rennell to have placed its mouth cor- rectly, which, so far as I can judge, is the case. They gave me the following account of the rivulets that they pass, in pro- ceeding up its channel, so far as canoes can go. Ist, Kanda cherra on the left; 2d, Kausgurra on the right; 3d, Guy cherra on the left; 4¢h, Tamarang on the left; 5th, Karik khung, the first on the right; 6th, Khundy cherra on the left ; 7th, Dungata on the right ; 8th, Kabutkia on the right ; 9th, Maha karung on the left; 10h, Nana karung on the left ; 11th, Poli on the left ; 12th, Incha cherra on the right ; 13th, 'Toisakma on the left; 14¢h, Karik khung, the second, l 42 ~ Dr Hamilton’s Account of the on the right; 15th, Bescherra on the left. The Raja had formerly a house at Dungata; but he has been driven from thence by fear for the Kungkis, called Lusai; and no Saksah now reside beyond Kanda cherra, half a day’s journey from the Karnaphuli.. The country, however, between the Chingay and Rampahar, is occupied by Kungkis, subject more or less to the Saksah chief. Rather more than three miles above the mouth of the Chin- gay, the Basunta enters from the south-east, and is navigable a short way for canoes. Here, again, the country becomes more hilly and more populous. About three miles above Ba- sunta, on each side of the river, there are hills higher than usual in this range; that on the south-east side, from a large black rock, is called Hattiya, (the elephant,) and that oppo- site is called Chela. The scenery here is very romantic. The strata are horizontal, and of a schistose structure. }- The composition repeated on all the homologous terminal edges of the pyramid yields a form similar to Fig. 14. where a central individual is surrounded by four others as in Tin-ore and Titanium-ore, with this difference, that here the apices of the pyramids can be more generally observed than in either of the two preceding species. Generally the surrounding indi- viduals are of a much smaller size than the central one, and appear only sticking on the terminal edges, much in the man- ner represented in Fig. 15; the occurrence of the same law on all the terminal edges of the pyramid being of itself sufficient to prove that the forms belong to the pyramidal system, as in the compositions of the two preceding species. The mineral species possessing hemi-pyramidal forms, which have been observed in regularly composed varieties, are the pyramidal Scheelium-baryte and the pyramidal Copper-pyrites of the system of Mohs. Also the Cyanide of Mercury belongs to this class of forms, and in the last species, in particular, the whole disposition of faces and the regular compositions are highly interesting. * Phill. 3d ed. p. 387. + Hoffm. Handb. by Breithaupt, iv. 1. sect. 149. Jameson's System. Ed. I. vol. ii. p. 460. It is said here to occur in octahedral crystals hav- ing a single cleavage. + M. Sage ( Elém. de Min. ii. 136:) cite encore une manganaise noiratre octaédre, dans un spath séléniteux blanc. Romé de [’Isle, yol. iii. p. 101. of Crystallized Bodies. 65 ' "Phe only kind of composition hitherto observed in pyramidal Scheelium-baryte is the one represented in Fig. 16. The face of composition is parallel, the axis of revolution perpendicular to a face of the rectangular four-sided prism, which is in parallel position with the pyramid of 107° 27/ and 118° 35’, that is of P40. The individuals are continued beyond the face of composition, so that the result assumes the appearance of a crystal belonging to the prismati¢ system. We are prevent- ed, however, from being led into error, by the observation of the striz upon the fies of P, which are parallel to the edges of combination between this form and e Se —— (b).,/They terminate abruptly at a certain line upon fads which else might- be taken for such as belong to the same individual. This kind of composition is not unfrequently met with among the large yellowish-white crystals from Schlaggenwald in Bo- . hemia, and has been first mentioned by Mr Mohs.* A fine specimen of this variety is in the cabinet of Mr Allan. The form of each of the individuals taken separately is that of Fig. 17, which, in regard to the general distribution of its faces, much resembles the rhombohedral species of apatite. The simple crystals of the Cyanide of Mercury which join in regular composition may be traced in general to the form of Fig. 18. It may be conceived to arise from Fig. 19, the same combination with the full number of its faces, by the en- largement, first of the alternating faces contiguous to both the apices, and secondly, of two of the remaining faces to the ex- clusion of the rest. Two of these crystals now are joined in one of the faces of [P+ ], in an inverse position, and com- pressed between the two faces, so that the transverse section of the compound crystal is again a square, or nearly so. The result is Fig. 20, of which Fig. 21 is a projection upon a plane perpendicular to the axis. The face of P—o, which is like- wise often found in the varieties of this species, is striated as in the projection Fig. 22, parallel to its edges of intersection with the plane in which the two individuals meet. The faces s belong to the isosceles four-sided pyramid P+1,a form which * Treatise on Mineralogy, transl. vol. ii. p. 115. VOL, I. No. 1. JuLY 1825. E 66 Mr Haidinger on the Regular Composition produces horizontal edges of combination with { P +-s ], and is frequently found in the crystals of Cyanide of Mercury. The following are the dimensions of its forms : P=134° 36’, 66° 8 ; P+1=12% 46, 85° 17. The axis of P is=./0.424. Cleavage takes place pretty distinctly parallel to [P+]. Ihave been indebted to Dr Turner for a great number of crystals in which I observed this regular composition; they had been ob- tained by the slow cooling of a solution concentrated at a pretty high temperature, but their inside was opaque, only the exter- nal coats, formed during the last stage of cooling, and the sub- sequent process of spontaneous evaporation, were perfectly transparent. Pyramidal Copper-pyrites presents a kind of regular com- position, somewhat analogous to that of the preceding species. The individuals, however, are here continued beyond the face of composition, and the hemi-pyramidal character is ex- pressed only in the alternating enlargement of the faces of P, the fundamental pyramid. Fig. 23 represents the result of this law, if the form of the individuals contains nothing but the faces of P, alternately larger and smaller. This is the rarest among the regular compositions of the species. I have observed it in some varieties from the mine of Kurprinz near Freiberg, generally associated with composition in other di- rections. By far the most frequent among them is the composition parallel to one of the faces of P, the isosceles pyramid of 109° 53’ and 108° 40’, which, if it takes place in crystals having the form of this pyramid, produces an appearance very much re- sembling the twins of the regular octahedron in Spinelle, in octahedral Iron-ore, and other minerals, similar to Fig. 24. The hemi-pyramidal character of the combinations of this spe- cies causes them, however, generally to assume a shape some- what different from this figure, which, nevertheless, also fre- quently occurs, and, besides, supposes the individuals to ter- minate at the face of composition. The 25th figure, which re- presents a crystal in the cabinet of Mr Allan, is intended to convey an idea of this composition. The combination ae. [P+ ©] (Fig. 26.) is the form of the individuals, one of which 5 of Crystallized Bodies. 67 appears as if engaged in the centre of the other in a reversed position, easily discovered at least in the present instance, if we attend to the faces of the four-sided prism [P+ ©], which are striated in a horizontal direction. Except the dif- ference in the system of crystallization, we have here a ¢ase extremely resembling the twins of Grey copper, represented Vol. I. Plate III, Fig. 18, of this Journai, and also some of Blende, a species whose crystallizations agree m general very nearly with that of the Grey copper. This composition is of- ten repeated, either in parallel plates, as in Fig. 27, which is very frequent among almost all varieties of the species, and may often be observed even in massive specimens, by the want of continuity in the cleavage, or it takes place at the same time parallel to two faces of the fundamental pyramid. A group, resulting in the manner last mentioned, is represented in Fig, 28. On account of the hemi-pyramidal character, the indivi- duals in the composition possess a different appearance from each other, so that it requires some attention to find out their shape to be that of Fig. 33.,* a combination of P, P+1, and P+ @; particularly as the relative irregular enlargement of the faces adds to the difficulty. Here, as in many other com- * The specimen in Mr Allan’s cabinet, in which this variety was ob- served, is peculiarly interesting on account of the distribution of the tars nished colours on the surface of its crystals. The tint of = (P) is gene- rally the violet or purple, frequently inclining to the yellow colours of the scale, while the tint of P+1 (c) is a distinct, and often very deep blue, that of P+. (/) being a fine green. The lustre of / is not so bright as that of the other faces i (P’) generally agrees in colour with c. In some crystals where the tint of P is a brownish-yellow, that ofc has not gone beyond the purple. This difference is probably owing to a slight difference in hatd- ness upon the faces of crystallization belonging to different forms ; it is in close connection with the physical quality of these faces themselves ; and corresponds in some respect to the phenomenon of cleavage, which often takes place parallel to two forms at once, but with different degrees of fas cility. Lead-glance and the rhomboidal Iron-ore from Elba have been de= scribed as presenting a difference in the tarnish of their faces of crystal- lization. The hexahedron in the former, and the face perpendicular to the axis (R—) in the latter, retain their natural colour and brightness, while the rest of the faces assume the tints of tempered steel. 68 Mr Haidinger on the Composition of Crystallized Bodies. pound varieties of Copper-pyrites,' the striae upon the faces of crystallization yield the means of ascertaining the situation of the individuals. Generally the number of individuals, aggre- gated according to this law, is not confined to three; but we find, that to every one of those added to the central one, some other individuals are attached. Regular composition often also takes place in this species parallel to a plane of P—1, or perpendicular to the terminal edges of P; there are particularly two varieties of this case, which, in the present place, deserve our attention. The in- dividuals are either joined in pairs, or one central individual is surrounded by four others, added in the direction of all the edges of P. The product of the first, in the fundamental py- ramid, would be Fig. 30. This has not yet been observed ; but it will serve for explaining Fig. 31, a variety of the form, S 3 district of Siegen in Prussia. This and several other inte- resting varieties of forms from the same locality, I have de- scribed, on another occasion,* from specimens in the posses- sion of Mr Sack of Bonn. If repeated in all the terminal edges of P ina form consist- ing of P— ow. P—1. P and P+1, the result is like Fig. 32, in which the re-entering angles produced by the faces of P+1, and the strize upon P, parallel with the edges of combination with P-+1, diverging in three directions from the centres of the faces of P demonstrate, that we really observe a compound crystal, while mineralogists have been long deceived by the equal brightness of the faces of P— o, in directions apparent- ly corresponding to the hexahedron. When the hemi-pyra- midal character of the combinations is more distinctly pro- nounced, a figure is produced resembling a tetrahedron, com- bined with various other forms, but consisting of six indivi- duals, the apices of which are contiguous to the edges of the tetrahedron, or of five at least, if we conceive the central in- dividual to be continued through the centre of the group. Generally the individuals are much striated parallel to the P-+1, from the mines inthe * Mem. Wern. Soc. vol. iv. part i. p. 1. Mr Harvey on the Formation of Dew. 69 edges of combination between P and P+1, which, in a form merely consisting of Bs and P +1, will produce Fig. 29, a va- riety which has been found in Cornwall. 1 have lately ob- served a composition of this kind, similar to Fig. 34, likewise from Cornwall, in Mr Allan’s collection, the form of the mdivi- Sih P duals contained in the group consisting of P—a».— 5.P+1. P+, and several other simple forms which it was impossi- ble to determine with any degree of accuracy, on account of the numerous and deep furrows upon the faces, parallel to aN : BE ates 5 their intersections with 5 and P+1, and the want of lustre of the surface, which prevented the application of the reflective goniometer. A simple crystal of the form represented Fig. 35, occurs upon the specimen which contains the compound varieties. (To be continued. ) Art. X.—Facts relating to the Formation of Dew. By Georce Harvey, Esq. F. R.S. Lond. & Edin. Commu- nicated by the Author. Tue tower of St Andrew’s Church, Plymouth, is situated about 500 yards to the east of the meadow, in which I have usually performed my experiments on the interesting subject of dew, and the elevation of its summit above the level of the field, about 110 feet. For the purpose of tracing the law which regulates the deposition of dew at different altitudes above the surface of the earth, I frequently found it necessary, in conjunction with Mr Pridham, to perform analogous expe- riments, at the same time, on the top of the tower, and on the surface of the meadow; and [ select, from many interesting results, that obtained on the night of the 21st of May, on ac- count of the remarkable states of equality which were obsery- ed, both in the temperature of the air, and in the quantities of moisture deposited on bodies of the same kind, when placed on substances having different radiating powers. The night wassereneand tranquil, but the sky not remarkable for its clearness. The first observation wasmade at 10 p.m., when the air, at the summit of the tower, and at three feet above the 70 Mr Harvey on the Formation of Dew. ground, were found to becach 51°; and it is remarkable, that no alteration of temperature took place during the night, since a register thermometer left on the tower, and another placed at the above mentioned elevation in the meadow, indicated that the quicksilver had not in either case been below 51°. At the time the first observations of the temperature were made, that of the grass indicated 491°, at which time there was laid on it equal plates of glass and tin, and on them equal masses of wool, (12 grains each,) exposing equal radiating surfaces to the heavens. On the summit of the tower, at the same time, simi- lar parcels of wool were placed, similarly circumstanced. At half-past six the next morning the masses of wool inthe meadow had gained equal increments of moisture amounting to 14 grains, and those on the tower equal increments of 75 grains. Hence it appears, that during the whole night the temperature of the air, at the respective elevations of three and one hundred and ten feet, remained stationary, and that the increments of mois- ture obtained in the meadow, by equal masses of the same substance, in contact with bodies possessing different radiat- ing powers, were the same ; as likewise, equal but smaller in- crements, by equal masses similarly placed on the summit of the tower. In the whole course of my experiments on this very interesting subject, I never before met with so many re- markable states of equality as appeared during this night. Gersten remarks,* that an horizontal surface is more abun- dantly dewed, than one perpendicular to the ground, a pheno- menon arising from the latter radiating less copiously than the former. ‘To confirm experimentally the remark of Gersten, an evening was selected, distinguished by its beautiful sereni- ty, and for the clear and perfect transparency of the sky.