7 WU i —— ———————— —— iu (Wn 3 wera > tan ~\ alr vii N a Presented to the UNIVERSITY OF TORONTO LIBRARY by the ONTARIO LEGISLATIVE LIBRARY 7 i4 “a HOW PLANTS ARE TRAINED TO WORK FOR MAN BY LUTHER BURBANK S&c.D : x GARDENING VOLUME V EIGHT VOLUMES * ILLUSTRATED PREFATORY NOTE BY DAVID STARR JORDAN P. F. COLLIER & SON COMPANY NEW YORK Copyright, 1914 By THE LUTHER BURBANK SOCIETY All rights reserved Copyright, 1914 By THE LUTHER BURBANK SOCIETY Entered at Stationers’ Hall, London All rights reserved Copyright, 1915 By THe LUTHER BURBANK SOCIETY Entered at Stationers’ Hall, London ; All rights reserved Copyright, 1921 By P. F. CoLLieR & SON COMPANY MANUFACTURED IN U. S. Ay CONTENTS Tue Cactus PEAR—A PROFITABLE FRUIT FRUITS WITH UNIQUE QUALITIES Tue NEED For IMPROVING SMALL Os 5 MEN Pn ae ay gel How THE GARDEN May BE MapE More PRODUCTIVE SomME CoMMON GARDEN PLANTS AND TuerR IMPROVEMENT | PrEAs AND BEANS AS PROFITABLE CROPS THe Tomato— AND AN _ INTERESTING E.XPERIMENT Some Priants UsED For FooD AND FLAVOR ARTICHOKES AND OTHER GARDEN SPE- CIALTIES WINTER RHUBARB AND OTHER INTEREST- TO OIC ae Aes 1 1i—Vol. 5 Bur. PAGE 129 157 189 217 239 2 CONTENTS THe CAmassta—WiL1L It SUPPLANT THE Potato? THE Porato ITtseELF —Wuo Wi. In- PROVE It FurTHER? Corn — ‘THE Kine or America’s Crops THE FAMILY OF GRASSES PAGE 261 285 311 341 LIST OF ILLUSTRATIONS A Burpank STRAWBERRY. . . Frontispiece PAGE A Cactus Fruir THat ImMIvTATES THE ORI armen SET AN EN Mant «| Cactus FRUIT ON THE SLAB ko A Goop SPECIMEN Si UE IED A WELi-ProporTIONED Fruir . . .— 20 FRuIt oF A CHILEAN MyrT1E . . .— 28 THe FRUIT OF THE STRAWBERRY TREE. 382 Fruit oF ONE oF My GREATLY IMPROVED VARIETIES OF MOUNTAIN ASH . . 386 THE Resutt oF EpucaTion . . . .. 42 A CLUSTER OF THE NEw WHITE ELDER- NER Pon cent Cate Pee re ane > OS AR 50 CoLor VARIATIONS IN THE CANES OF THE Hypreip BLACKBERRIFS . . . . 56 THE STEM FINALLY SELECTED . . =. 62 ERY FEAMPOr is MOR here ha) Th 4 LIST OF ILLUSTRATIONS PAGE PA MATTE OL MEER Oe eo ILLusTRATING LEAF STRUCTURE. . . 88 WHERE THE TREE Is ALIVE. . . . 94 ‘COMPOST FOR Youne Puiant Foop . . 102 SOME EXPERIMENTAL GouRDS . . . 108 SomME GOURDS FROM | AUSTRALIA: 65): See meee, FAMILIAR BEEP) i. ee BNOTHER OLD PRIEND 0. 6 eee PARSNIPS: sen rome ePBS avi hh 17) 6c) +6 CowpEsas UNDER CULTIVATION. . . 184 SHOWING VARIATION IN [BEANS . . . 146 A STRIPLING FROM THE Tropics . . 152 Fruits oF A Tomato Hypripy . .... 160 POTATOES WITH A STRANGE History . 166 TRANSPLANTING SELECTED SEEDLINGS . 172 A Soutn AmERICAN ALLIUM . .. . 194 A New ATAS0OE os Sua or. eo A Basket oF BuRBANK PEPPERS . . 210 BURBANK PEPPERS ())) (iw OA. 6. RS ARTICHOKES SPIN Dab eh Pieces 9h a HaA.rFr-OPENED ARTICHOKE BLossom » 84 LIST OF ILLUSTRATIONS A Wi ARTICHOKE AN IMPROVED ARTICHOKE FLOWER AND FRUIT ON THE SAME PLANT A BED oF SELECTED CROSSBRED CAMASSIAS A WuvdE RANGE OF VARIATION CAMASSIA BLOssoMs THE WILD CAMASSIA Wip Hicu ANnpbeEs PotaTors SomME SELECTED SEEDLINGS A FINE New Earty Potato A FREAK Ear oF CorRN SECTIONS OF RarInBow CorN LEAVES THREE FINE Tyres or Corn WHEAT GERMINATING ON ICE ‘A Guimpse aT My WueEat EXPERIMENTS 5 PAGE 228 234 254 264 270 274 280 288 294 300 314 322 330 344 348 THE CACTUS PEAR—A PROFITABLE FRUIT Its Fiavors Fixep, Now Worxine Mostriy FOR SEEDLESSNESS HE story of the spineless cactus has been briefly outlined in an earlier volume, and will be told in detail in a later one. There is no more important story to be told in connection with the record of my entire work, but it would not comport with the purpose of the present chapter to go into details as to the man- ner of development of this extraordinary plant. For the moment we are concerned solely with the fruit of the cactus. In the present chapter it will be considered altogether from that standpoint. It should be explained at the outset, however, that whereas the improved forms of cactus pear about which we are speaking are grown on the spineless cactus plants, yet the fruit itself is not yet in all cases altogether without spicules. To remove the spines from the cactus slabs— as the “leaves” are commonly termed—was a task 7 8 LUTHER BURBANK requiring somewhat less time than the removal of the smaller spines, and in particular of the very minute spicules, from the fruit. The reason for this is not that the spines of the fruit are more fixed and intrinsically more difficult of removal than those on the body of the plant itself, but merely that the work must pro- gress more slowly because it is necessary to wait for a term of years, sometimes four or five, before the cactus plant comes to the fruiting age when grown from seed. Unfortunately it cannot with any degree of certainty be predicted from obser- vation of the plant itself whether or not it will bear spiny fruit, so it is necessary to wait until the plant comes to fruiting age before its charac- teristics in this regard can be known. On the other hand, the character of the plant itself with regard to spine bearing is revealed im- mediately when the first tiny shoots come up from the seed. So selection may be made at once among the seedlings, and by weeding out those that show any propensity to bear spines, and selecting those that are smooth, the experiment may go forward with relative rapidity. We know that we are making no mistake in our selection as regards the bearing of spines on the flattened stalks of the plant, because their character as to this is fixed from the outset, and THE CACTUS PEAR 9 is as definitely revealed when the plant is an inch high as it will be when it has attained mature growth. But, on the contrary, our selection made in the hope of securing plants that would bear spineless fruit of excellent quality may prove eventually to have been hopelessly faulty. After waiting three or four or five years we may discover that the plants on which our hopes had been chiefly based bear fruit nearly as spiny as that borne by their ancestor whose habits we are attempting to enable the plant to shake off. Nevertheless, the work of removing the spines from the fruit of the cactus has progressed to a stage where the spicules are not only reduced in size, but are so loosely attached that they may be readily brushed from the fruit with a wisp of grass, and in several varieties are as smooth and free from spines and spicules as an orange. And the plants under observation include many in which the tendency to drop the spicules from the fruit has advanced progressively, warranting the confident expectation that in the next generation there will be many more that will present fruit altogether smooth. I expect that when the plants of the most recent generation come to bearing some will produce smooth-skinned fruit. A CACTUS FRUIT THAT IMITATES THE PEAR Fruit of this type is not quite so well adapted for packing as the oval type, but many people like a pear-shaped fruit, and this form has been retained in a number of our best varieties. THE CACTUS PEAR 11 Should this come true, my ideal of a spineless cactus variety bearing smooth-skinned fruit will at last be wholly realized. THE CHARACTER OF THE CACTUS PEAR Meantime the endeavor to improve the size and quality of the cactus fruit has met with signal success. Generation after generation the “pears” grown on the improved cactus plant have kept pace with the improvement of the plants them- selves, until the different new varieties of cactus now bear fruits almost as varied in quality as the different varieties of apples, and perhaps rather more varied than the different varieties of culti- vated pears. The fruit of the wild species of cactus varies somewhat widely in size and form, as well as in texture and flavor. My cultivated varieties, how- ever, have been made to assume an almost uni- form oval form. Or perhaps barrel-shaped would better describe the new cactus fruit. The individual fruits are three or four inches in length, and in some cases they weigh half a pound, although the average weight is consider- ably less than this. The skin of the fruit is readily removed by cutting off a thin slice at each end and making 12 LUTHER BURBANK an incision the length of the fruit, and peeling the skin back. The pulp thus exposed is as juicy almost as the pulp of a watermelon, but much more com- pact, as well as sweeter and of far better flavors. _ Pulp and skin are usually of about the same color; but the range of color is wide with the dif- ferent varieties, varying from white through the shades of yellow, green, orange, pink, purple, crimson, and the most vivid blood-red to deep purple—almost black. In flavor there is also wide variation. The flavor is characteristic but difficult of description, as it does not bear close resemblance to the flavor of any familiar fruit. There is a wide range of variation as to degree of sweetness and exact flavor, just as there is between different varieties of apples or pears. The cactus pear further resembles the orchard fruits in that it may be eaten raw, or may be cooked or variously preserved. It is an all-round table fruit, and constitutes a very important addition to the dietary. It is best eaten raw. ASTOUNDING PRODUCTIVITY Not only are the individual fruits large and luscious, but they are produced in the most amaz- ing profusion. THE CACTUS PEAR 13 Some of the seedlings begin to bear fruit the second year, but they do not come into full bearing—so that the fruit may be accurately appraised—until the third or fourth year. Then the fruit may be produced so abun- dantly as to check the growth of the plant. When the cactus has come to mature age, it puts forth such an abundance of fruit as some- | times almost to hide the slabs from which the fruit grows. Half a hundred individual fruits may grow on the edges or surface of a single slab. Looking across a field of cactus in full fruit, one sees a mass of fruit that almost hides the plants. It has been found that eighteen thousand pounds of fruit per acre is a common crop on the poorest soil. ‘The possibilities of production on good soil and with fully matured plants of the perfected varieties are probably greater than those of any other fruit-producing plant whatever. The product of a single acre may amount to the astounding quantity of twenty-five to thirty tons. Whoever has seen a field of my giant cactus plants in full fruit will not be disposed to chal- lenge the facts. CACTUS FRUIT ON THE SLAB This picture suggests the enormous productivity of our new spineless varieties. The slabs here shown are in no wise exceptional; indeed, they bear no more than an average number of fruits. Sometimes a single slab bears more than fifty of these “pears.” Se THE CACTUS PEAR 15 Analysis shows that the fruit contains about 14 per cent sugar together with a small amount of protein and fat. The precise apportion- ment of the constituents varies greatly with different varieties. It is possible to increase the sugar content and otherwise to vary the chemical composition of the fruit by breeding and selec- tion, just as can be done with the apple, the peach, the plum, the sugar beet, and most other fruits and vegetables. The cactus fruits developed at Santa Rosa are of exceptional size and superior quality, but of course they do not constitute an absolutely new departure, for it is well known that there are many varieties of spiny cactus that bear edible though very spiny fruit. Indeed, in certain arid regions, and in partic- ular about the Mediterranean, the fruit of the cactus has long been recognized as a valuable food product. Professor Leotsakos of the Greek University at Athens, who visited my grounds one summer recently, tells me that the cactus fruit is a very important part of the dietary of millions of people around the Mediterranean for about three months of the year. He declared that he himself would prefer a half dozen good cactus fruits for breakfast to the best beefsteak. 16 LUTHER BURBANK He considers the fruit both nutritious and healthful, and this estimate is universal in coun- tries where it is largely eaten. It is the custom in Greece, especially along the seashore, to collect the cactus fruits in the morn- ing and store them in some cool place, either with ice or in a basket of seaweed, which is said to improve the flavor of the fruit. Both wealthy and poorer classes eat the fruit at each meal throughout the season, according to my informer. So important is the cactus fruit regarded in Greece that Professor Leotsakos assured me he would make haste on his return to communicate with the Government officials, that they might at once take steps to obtain my improved varieties for planting; for, of course, no variety of cactus hitherto known approaches the new hybrid species in quality or productivity. It appears that the cactus fruit is usu- ally known about the Mediterranean as the Indian Fig. In this country it has been commonly referred to as the Prickly Pear. But now that the prickles are marked for elimination, this name will cease to be appropriate, and we may con- veniently refer to the fruit as a Cactus Pear, unless some more distinctive name should be suggested, THK CACTUS PEAR bi Various USES oF THE FRUIT The juice of the crimson variety of the cactus fruit is a brilliant carmine color that makes it very valuable for coloring ices, cakes, and con- fectionery. It is not only absolutely harmless but positively nutritious and beneficial, and is sure to gain popularity; taking the place of the artificial dyes that are now used so extensively, some of which are of doubtful wholesomeness. In Mexico the crushed fruit of the cactus after peeling and having the seeds strained out is sometimes cooked and dried and made into little loaves weighing from one to two pounds each. These cakes have a rich, sweet, honeylike flavor, to which the Mexicans are very partial. If carefully made, they are very appetizing and wholesome. Indeed, they constitute an impor- tant article of food, and are considered a luxury, having the qualities of a nutritious confection. Cactus fruit, indeed, is in high repute in many tropical countries, being in some regions re- garded as of especial value in renal diseases. Relatively large proportions of salts of mag- nesia, soda, potash, and lime in the fruit, in read- ily assimilable form, have been supposed to give it particular value, especially for residents of the tropics. The effect on the digestive organs is A GOOD SPECIMEN Some fruits of this size grow to the number of from twenty to fifty on a slab, and it is easy to see that the aggregate production is enormous. The amount of fruit grown on a single acre, under favorable conditions, may amount in the aggregate to more than thirty tons in a season. In this respect the improved cactus is unrivaled. THE CACTUS PEAR 19 also very favorable. Even the joints of the plant are made into pickles that, in the case of some varieties, are regarded as having a flavor equal to that of the cucumber. Most varieties, however, have a mucilaginous quality that is objectionable. This, of course, refers to the tissues of the plant itself, not to the fruit. It has been said that the cactus fruit in point _ of juiciness and texture is suggestive of a melon. Some people have compared its flavor to that of the Japanese persimmon or the cantaloupe. In other varieties the flavor suggests the raspberry. But, as already suggested, there is no standard of comparison that gives a clear conception of the taste of the fruit. The one conspicuous drawback is that the cac- tus fruit has been filled with seeds. In the case of some of the wild varieties, the seeds are large and especially hard, but even these are habitually swallowed by the people who eat the fruit. The improved varieties have seeds not larger than those of the tomato, although a little harder, and they may be swallowed with impunity. I have never known of anyone being injured by eating the cactus fruit in any quantity. It goes without saying that I have long had in mind to remove the seeds from the fruit of the perfected varieties of cactus fruit. Something A WELL-PROPORTIONED FRUIT This variety is perhaps nearly perfect in size and shape. It is not too large for comfortable handling, and it is of almost the best possible shape for com- pact storage during shipment. It has also qualities of flesh that highly commend it. ae > i ee > ee rae " = THE CACTUS PEAR 21 has already been accomplished toward this in the reduction of the size of the seed as just referred to, and in the best of the newer varieties the seeds have at last been wholly eliminated. The seeds are not collected at the center of the fruit as in the apple and pear and allied fruits, but are dis- tributed somewhat evenly through the pulp, after the manner of the seeds of the watermelon. | But as we have seen in connection with other plants, the seed is about the last thing that the plant is willing to relinquish, for the excellent reason that it is an all-essential part for the prop- agation of the species in a state of nature. But the cultivated cactus plants do not need their seeds, and as some of the newer varieties have re- linquished them, others will follow in due season. A specific account of the methods through which this was brought about, together with a detailed description of the origin of the spineless cactus itself is given in another volume. Eighteen thousand pounds of cac- tus fruit to the acre has been found to be a common crop on even the poorest soil, and twenty to thirty tons per acre of the improved varieties have been grown. Bais! ” hs a Hf vary . . re ; WAG a8 AYeet i The et + ove ee , SEY ARP AE “oR, es ¢ 1 ," 4 22 ag ite RTO: aa FRUITS WITH UNIQUE QUALITIES A CHINESE FRUIT witH GREEN FLESH —OTHER FRUITS NOTHER importation from the Orient that seems pretty certain to be welcomed here, is a plant indigenous to China, be- longing to the genus Actinidia, known to the natives as the mao-li-dzi. The English interpretation of this word is said to be something like “Hairy Plum.” As described by a missionary from whom I received the seeds of the plant, the hairy plum grows as a vine, and has a fruit with bright green flesh, containing seeds not unlike those of the strawberry, and with a thin brown skin covered with a downy coat like that of the peach. The fruit is said to resemble the strawberry in taste. It is described as delicious when raw, and also as very good when cooked. My informant further states that the seeds are obtained from a plant growing in the mountains 23 24 LUTHER BURBANK at an altitude of about five thousand feet. He declares that the fruit is popular, and that efforts have been made to induce the Chinese to make a business of growing it, but that hitherto it has been necessary to depend entirely upon plants growing wild in the mountains. The vine clambers over the underbrush on the mountainside like a grapevine. It is, of course, very hardy. The Chinese hairy plum, like its more promising relative the A. arguta of Korea, is dicecious; therefore it is necessary to have both staminate and pistillate plants, else no fruit is produced. The Korean species has borne fruit abundantly here for several years. One of the attractive features of plants of this tribe is the ease with which they may be propa- gated. Not only can they be grown readily from seed, usually producing new varieties, but they grow also from soft or hard wood cuttings, from tip cuttings, or by layering. When a new variety is produced of the de- sired type, it can be multiplied indefinitely by dividing any part of the plant into sections and insuring conditions suitable for growth. Some of the plants of the genus are true climb- ers. Many of them, however, trail upon the ground. Those that climb are valuable for covering screens, arbors, walls, and low build- UNIQUE QUALITY FRUITS) 25 ings. The trailers are valuable for decorative purposes and quite often for their fruits. In Korea and Manchuria the long, slender vines of Actinidia arguta (the species with which my experiment began) are used for cordage. | | Other species are used in the manufacture of paper. My first introduction to the genus was through a number of large plants of Actinidia polygama received in 1904 from an American miner in Korea. The seeds already referred to were re- ceived five years later. The first fruit buds ap- peared on the plants in 1912. But different species vary as to the age at which fruiting begins. Some species fruit in the first year from the seed. The ones under my observation have fruited too recently to enable me to do more than observe their attractive qualities: and form a general opinion as to the possibility of im- proving them. The vine may be grown as readily as the grape, and its improved varieties promise to be a very valuable addition to the list of American fruits. Its full possibilities of development, however, can be judged only after more extended ob- servations. 26 LUTHER BURBANK IMPROVING THE MyRrTLES More familiar exotics, some representatives of which have so long been under observation in America that they seem almost like natives, are the various members of the myrtle family. These are curiously divergent. Some of them are small trailing vines, yet the family includes also the gigantic eucalyptus trees that grow to such im- mense size in Australia and California. True myrtles are mostly natives of the South- ern Hemisphere. ‘There are representatives of the tribe, however, that thrive in the tropical and subtropical regions of our own hemisphere, among these being the plants that grow the fruit known as the guava. The species of myrtle that chiefly concerns us in the present connection is a tender shrub . with slender branches, known as the common myrtle, and classified by botanists as Myrtus communis. There are numerous varieties of the shrub, some of them bearing white or yellow or varie- gated leaves. The tendency to produce these variegated leaves may exist as a latent char- acteristic in the green-leaved variety. I have grown a beautiful variegated variety from the seed of the ordinary green myrtle. As a rule the UNIQUE QUALITY FRUITS 27 progeny of the “sport” thus produced tends to revert to the original type. And in fact it is observed that all plants with variegated foliage have a very strong tendency to produce green- leaved seedlings. The fruit of the common myrtle is small, black, and hardly edible. I have imported many species and varieties from Chile and Patagonia, how- ever, which, although appearing very much like the common myrtle, bear fruit quite different in appearance, being pink, white, or yellow. The individual berries are usually as large as huckle- berries, sometimes considerably larger, and have delightful aromas and flavors. Some of these new fruiting myrtles will grow on very dry ground; others require soil that is constantly moist. One of the Chilean and Patagonian species, M. Maytens, is used for timber, and grows to a height of fifteen feet, with a breadth of ten to twenty-five feet. ‘The branches droop grace- fully like those of the weeping willow, and are heavily loaded with oval, small, glossy green leaves. These are not the fruiting species, which grow to a height of two to four feet, and of equal breadth. Another species that bears fruit when quite young, sometimes even in the second year, has FRUIT OF A CHILEAN MYRTLE This is another of the almost number- less tropical species with which we have experimented to develop new types of orchard and garden fruits. The berry of this Chilean myrtle has a pleasant odor and taste, and there is sufficient variation. to suggest the possibility of improvement through selective breed- mg. It may prove possible, also, to cross the plant with other myrtles, stimulating variation and giving further opportunity for selection. (One-third life size.) UNIQUE QUALITY FRUITS 29 been received from South America, and is identi- fied as Myrtus ugni. This plant bears a curious resemblance to the gooseberry, except that it has no thorns. Its berry is a glossy brown or purple, sometimes slightly hairy, growing in compact drooping racemes like the currant. Some of the berries are of most excellent flavor, others woody or filled with seeds. Several thousand of the best seedlings from these exotic myrtles are now growing on my place, and there are indications that some among them will almost certainly prove of value as fruiting plants for general culture. All of them appear to be hardy enough to stand the climate of the central United States. It is to be expected that crossing experiments will further improve the fruit. The material is now in hand for such experiments. SomE NEGLECTED RELATIVES OF THE RASPBERRY Not to leave the field entirely to exotics, we must note that there are several members of the great Rubus family, closely related to our culti- vated raspberries and blackberries, that grow at our very door, so to speak, yet which have been hitherto neglected or given slight aid in the devel- opment of the latent fruiting possibilities we 30 LUTHER BURBANK may confidently expect in most members of this . family. _ Among these are plants of a group repre- sented in the eastern United States by the Flow- ering Raspberry, Rubus odoratus; in the cen- tral region by Rubus deliciosus of Colorado, and along the Pacific Coast from Alaska to southern California by the Thimbleberry, Rubus nutkanus. The eastern species is a handsome plant with large, deep, pink flowers that make it suitable for ornament. The western thimbleberry grows among the weeds of the lower hills and valleys, sometimes climbing high up the mountain slope, and in southern California seldom venturing below an altitude of five thousand feet. No other shrub on the Pacific Coast exhibits a more pleasing effect than a broad expanse of the soft, delicate, green foliage of the thimble- berry. Its Jarge, white flowers, flat, button- shaped red berries, and sweet, resinous, woody fragrance add to its attractiveness. The flowers of the thimbleberry are not so large as those of its eastern relative, but their delicate, pure white petals scattered among the large, pale green leaves add to the beauty of the banks of foliage that overshadow the other forest flowers. The thin, button-shaped berries are UNIQUE QUALITY FRUITS 31 often of a brilliant red, though sometimes paler, but are extremely soft so that they can be picked with difficulty. The fruit, though edible, is of little value, being somewhat acid, and lacking flavor. Yet the aristocratic lineage of the plant makes it seem probable that its fruit may be susceptible of development. I have attempted to cross the thimbleberry with nearly all cultivated varieties of raspberry and blackberry, but have never succeeded in effecting hybridization, unless this has been effected in some hybrid seedlings of last season, which from the foliage would appear to have resulted from a cross. The Rubus deliciosus, the Colorado species, is ’ similar to the eastern one in most respects, ex- cept that the blossoms are white. All three species are almost thornless; the Colorado spe- cies practically wholly thornless, though the fruit of none of them is of any value. The hardi- ness of the thimbleberry and its trailing habit suggest interesting and unexpected possibilities for its fruit, if a cross could be effected that would introduce the lacking elements of size and texture and flavor. Other Rubuses that seem worthy of attention are the Bridal Rose, Rubus roseflorus, and the THE FRUIT OF THE STRAW- BERRY TREE This fruit looks good enough to eat, but is not. It would seem, however, that the fruit might be developed to have edible qualities. The strawberry tree is known to the botanist as Arbutus wunedo. There are several allied species of arbutus, and it is possible that, through hybridization, varieties may be produced that will have better fruits. Doubtless a good many of our cultivated fruits were less promising in their original wild state than this fruit of the straw- berry tree. 1—Vol. 5 Bur. UNIQUE QUALITY FRUITS 33 Wineberry, Rubus phenicolasius, both natives of Japan and China. The former is a double-flowering plant, often cultivated for its flowers. It thrives well in Cali- fornia in cool, shady places. The double-flower- ing varieties, in my experience, do not fruit, but there is a closely related form that produces single flowers that mature fruit of an inferior quality. The Wineberry was introduced into America about twenty years ago by Mr. John Lewis Childs. As an ornamental plant it is quite promising. But its fruit, in its present state, is of no value. The bright, cherry-red or sometimes salmon- colored berries are usually small and _ soft, slightly acid and insipid. But the strong, graceful, recurving branches, and the large, ample leaves, with their white undersurfaces, make the Wineberry a beautiful and attractive shrub. And although the experi- ments that have been made with it on my farms have not suggested great promise as to fruit pro- duction, yet I wish to state that the experiments were not conducted extensively, nor for a long period, and do not regard them as conclusive. Pending further investigation, the Wineberry must be regarded as possibly presenting oppor- 2—Vol. 5 Bur. 34 LUTHER BURBANK tunities for the development of a new fruit- bearing Rubus. Conceivably the attempt to hybridize this species and the Bridal Rose or the ordinary rasp- berries might lead to interesting results. FRvuit-BEARING SHRUBS Among: other plants with undeveloped fruit- ing possibilities are some shrubs of the heath family (Hricacee@), relatives of the rhododen- drons among flowering shrubs and the huckle- berry among fruit bearers. Of these the best known is the form of Arbutus called the Strawberry tree. This is commonly grown both in Europe and America, and considerably prized as an ornamental shrub. It is a small shrub, varying a good deal in size, but commonly growing to the height of about six feet. It bears berries that vary in size and color, but which in general are red, suggesting the common name given the shrub. There are several other species of Arbutus, among them some of the most beautiful trees and shrubs for the adornment of lawns. One of the most prized species is the California form known as the Madrona, which sometimes grows to a height of about one hundred feet, and which UNIQUE QUALITY FRUITS _ 35 bears ovate leathery leaves not unlike those of the Magnolia. This tree is quite hardy, even in the mountains of California, its native home, and its leaves, blossoms, and fruit are ornamental and attrac- tive. The blossoms grow in clusters, sometimes erect and sometimes drooping. ‘They are white in color, and very fragrant. The berries, orange or scarlet in color, somewhat resemble those of the Unedo or Strawberry tree, but the clusters are more numerous and smaller. | _A singular thing with regard to both of these forms of Arbutus is that blossoms and ripe fruit may be seen on the tree at the same time. In this respect the Arbutus resembles the orange tree. . I have often thought that a handsome tree could be produced by crossing the Unedo or Strawberry tree with the Madrona, and I have no reason to doubt that the cross could be made. I regard the Arbutus as. a promising tree for experimentation. My own experiments with the shrub have been confined to the raising of seedlings for ornamen- tal purposes. I observed that the Strawberry tree, like the Madrona, varies in size and some- times in shape and color of leaves and fruit. I am confident, therefore, that by special cultiva- FRUIT OF ONE OF MY GREATLY IMPROVED VARIETIES OF MOUNTAIN ASH Looked at individually, these fruits certainly suggest an apple. As an abundant bearer, the plant leaves noth- ing to be desired. It is only necessary to increase the size and improve the quality of the individual fruit. This has been done, and we now have a hybrid that produces fruit as large as crab apples. UNIQUE QUALITY FRUITS 37 tion and selection the Strawberry tree might be improved and made to bear a very fragrant and luscious fruit. Various members of the genus are available, and there is good prospect that experiments in selective breeding, with or without hybridization, would reward the experimenter. Two other shrubs that give good promise are the Hawthorn and the Mountain Ash. The Hawthorn in particular is an extremely valuable shrub, and gives very great promise of the pro- duction of improved varieties of fruit through selective breeding, especially as it is one of the most variable shrubs. The mountain ash is usually raised for the beauty of its fruit. I have made experiments in selective breeding with this plant, and have greatly improved the size and beauty of the clusters of fruit. With the hawthorn also I have made some interesting experiments, but there is fine opportunity for other workers in this field. Indeed, the work of devel- oping this fruit has made only the _ barest beginnings. I would especially emphasize the fact that there are peculiarly inviting opportunities open . to the amateur in connection with this familiar but almost totally neglected plant. 38 LUTHER BURBANK The hawthorns are hardy shrubs or small trees, of vigorous growth. There are about seventy species available for crossing experiments, and some of them already bear fruit that is of good _ size and of excellent quality when cooked. Doubtless the original apple—the progenitor of all modern varieties—was no better than the best of the present native hawthorns. Who will give us a new race of fruits to compete with the apple, through bringing out the only half-hidden qualities of this responsive shrub? Largely by chance, certain plants have come under the attention of man, and thus have been brought about the familiar fruits of our or- chards, vineyards, and berry fields; who can predict the surprises which the orchards and vineyards and berry fields of the next generation will reveal? THE NEED FOR IMPROVING SMALL FRUITS AND SOME OF THE MEANS FOR MEETING It ITH the present chapter we conclude our survey of the fruits proper, and it will be well to make a brief review of the subject, in particular with reference to the outlook, and the possibilities of further progress in the near future. In making this general review, we need not confine attention absolutely to the small fruits. Much that is said will refer to fruits in general. But, doubtless, there are even larger oppor- tunities for improvement with the berries and garden fruits than with the familiar orchard fruits, chiefly because the latter have been given a far larger share of attention by the horti- culturist. The large size and varied uses of apples, pears, peaches, and plums, in particular, have made them popular everywhere, and have caused a vast ' 39 40 LUTHER BURBANK deal of attention to be given them. So almost numberless varieties have been accidentally and sometimes purposely developed which meet the most varied requirements. But the small fruits have been the Cinderellas of the pomological family. Our own’generation was first to give them proper recognition, and it remains for our successors to carry them forward to their true plane of utility. So it is these fruits rather than others that we shall have chiefly in mind, as the title of the pres- ent chapter would suggest. But it may be re- peated that much that will be said applies to all marketable fruits, and even where a particular species is referred to, what is said is often sus- ceptible of general application. Bearing this in mind, let us briefly review the story of the modern development of the small fruits, and with equal brevity outline a few sug- gestions as to the lines of future progress. THE INCREASED CONSUMPTION OF FRUIT The consumption of fruit has increased more rapidly in the United States, and perhaps throughout the world, during the last one hun- dred years than has that of any other kind of food, with possibly the exception of nuts. The increase in the consumption of both fruits and IMPROVING SMALL FRUITS 41 nuts during the past twenty years has been par- ticularly remarkable, and they are in fact coming to be regarded as food staples, as they certainly should be. As an illustration, take the case of the straw- berry. This was the first small fruit commer- cially grown in the United States to any great extent. arly in the nineteenth century a few were raised in New Jersey for the market in New York City. Those who first engaged in this en- terprise soon found that, to keep up with the in- creasing demand, it was necessary to go into the business on a much larger scale, and raising strawberries by the acre for the market became an industry. At the time it was prophesied that there would be an overproduction of strawberries, and that they could not be sold. But now whole train- loads of strawberries and other berries are brought into New York City daily during the season. Probably a carload of strawberries is con- sumed to-day in the United States to every cul- tivated strawberry that was eaten one hundred years ago. The consumption of the tree fruits, grapes, and other small fruits has increased in a some- what similar proportion. THE RESULT OF EDUCATION A cluster of one of my new hybrid mountain ash fruits. This is an exceed- ingly small cluster of a pear-shaped variety, which is acrid like the old mountain ash. Other varieties have enormous clusters of round crimson fruit of fairly edible quality. Thousands of young hybrids are yet to bear. ana ane etna IMPROVING SMALL FRUITS 48 America has had an important share in recent fruit advancement. When the immigrants came from other countries to America they usually brought with them some of the seeds, cuttings, or roots of their favorite fruits; these were planted and orchards were grown. And in the course of events, when the families began moving westward, they usually selected seeds or more often trees of their best fruits for transplanting. In this way a constant and natural selection has been going on from the very first; the poorer varieties being discarded and forgotten, while those that filled a want and had proved pro- ductive and valuable were cherished. After this sifting process of the years, only a very few of the older fruits, in proportion to the number now cultivated, are still considered standard varieties. Especially during the last twenty-five years, new varieties of strawberries, raspberries, black- berries, currants, gooseberries, cherries, plums, prunes, apples, pears, peaches, nectarines, quinces, figs, and oranges have been produced and are now favorite fruits. The older varieties of these fruits are slowly but surely being supplanted by still later productions. 44 °° LUTHER BURBANK NEw VARIETIES TO MEET NEw CONDITIONS This process of evolution is wholly imper- ceptible to the careless observer; but to one who watches closely the development of fruits there is an unmistakable and rapid change now going on. Old orchards are continually being grafted over to new and improved varieties, while the new orchards added from year to year are planted to the latest standard fruits. This is especially true on the Pacific Coast, as competition is keen and the tests given fruits are new ones and must be exacting. Luscious, sun-sweetened fruits must be pro- duced which will bear shipping long distances, to less favored climes, retaining their form, color and flavor. Transcontinental shipping is one of the severest tests that can be applied to any fruit—and it is distinctly a new test. Most of the older fruits had been selected for family use and home marketing; very few of them consequently could meet this new requirement. Notwithstanding the fact that practically all the best fruits in the world have been tested in California, only a few of the eastern or Euro- pean varieties have been able to meet the con- IMPROVING SMALL FRUITS 45 ditions here, and to fulfill all the requirements demanded. At present probably one-half of the fruits grown in California, with the exception of the French prune, are varieties that have originated, or at least have risen to commercial importance, within the State; and this statement applies with almost equal force to the States of . Oregon and Washington. There is a great field of usefulness open to the enterprising plant breeder in the adaptation of fruits to different localities and climatic condi- tions, thereby extending the belt in which certain fruits can be raised. Some regions are too arid; some too cold, others too warm, or too damp and with too fre- quent rains for certain fruits. It is the mission of the plant breeder to develop varieties that will withstand these conditions. What greater good can be accomplished than making exquisite fruits that will grow abun- dantly in sections of the country where none could be grown before? Curmate, DiseasE, AND HumaAN TASTES In creating new varieties to meet local condi- tions it is necessary to bear in mind not alone edible quality of fruit, but the constitution of the plant itself. 46 LUTHER BURBANK Hardiness is often a sine qua non, particularly with fruits intended for the new regions of the Northwest, where the winters are extremely cold. Then nearly all kinds of fruits are subject to fungous diseases of-some sort. These must be combated by developing hardy, resistant varie- ties. Advancement has already been made in this direction; but much remains to be done. The careful plant breeder will watch intently his stock and promptly discard all susceptible plants. It is in this way alone that such diseases can ever be thoroughly and permanently conquered. In some parts of the United States the sun’s heat is too fierce and the air too dry for fruits to thrive which have been accustomed to more favorable conditions. For such regions varieties must be developed which are low, compact growers, producing an abundance of thick, leathery leaves, and fruit that will not easily sunburn. Some of the east- ern varieties, having become adapted to a moist climate, are open growers, bearing rather thin, delicate leaves. Such varieties are usually total failures when introduced in the arid Southwest. In developing a new fruit, the plant breeder must not only meet the exacting demands of IMPROVING SMALL FRUITS 47 nature, but also the exacting and increasingly complicated demands of the grower, the shipper, and the consumer; for together they constitute the jury that finally determines the value of his product. The tests of these jurists are applied from different standpoints and for different purposes. The grower is solicitous for an early-bearing, prolific tree, immune to fungous diseases or in- sect pests; one that will flourish with little care, pruning, or other attention. The shipper and dealer are unconcerned about the characteristics of the trees, or their productiveness, but they are eager for an at- tractive fruit—large, bright-colored, handsome; in particular for one that is very solid—so hard that it can be handled like a cannon ball, which makes it a superb shipper. The consumer, on the other hand, prefers a reasonably tender, highly flavored, and easily digestible fruit. Unfortunately the consumer seldom obtains such a fruit unless it is grown near by or within his own community; for the ideals of the shipper and the dealer, at variance with his preferences, intervene between him and the orchardist. For instance, better varieties of strawberries for table use have been developed than can be 48 LUTHER BURBANK © found in any market; better in quality, aroma, and sweetness. The average consumer is never permitted to see them, or to experience their lusciousness. They are eliminated from the _ growers’ list of fruits, because they do not meet the demands of the shipper and the dealer. The consumer usually obtains the best that the producer, the shipper, and the dealer can furnish, under the conditions with which they have to contend; the fault is not theirs, but that of modern civilization. All this is mentioned merely to shia that varieties, the production of which is useful and profitable, are not necessarily the most desirable for food purposes. Consumers Must Bre EnucATED Yet the fault does not lie exclusivley with the dealers. When a new fruit is first introduced it is difficult for the people to become adapted or accustomed to it, if it possesses new and strange peculiarities and qualities that are not under- stood or appreciated. I have found that it is fully as difficult to adapt the people to a new fruit as it is to adapt a new fruit to the real wants of the people. New varieties that at first are condemned, may be accepted later as standards, and become IMPROVING SMALL FRUITS 49 practically the only ones grown. The same law seems to hold true with fruits as with new ideas - and new inventions in general; too often these are at first condemned, but if possessing gen- uine merit they are finally recognized and appreciated. I have met this experience in the introduc- tion of nearly all the new fruits that I have produced. It was ten years after the Burbank plum was introduced before people generally discovered that it was a valuable fruit. Now it is planted more widely than any plum on the globe, and thrives in almost all regions where plums can be grown. The excellent properties of the Wickson plum, now raised in most localities where plums are cultivated to any considerable extent, were for several years unrecognized. To-day it is ac- _ knowledged to be the best of the older shipping plums in existence, not only in America but in Africa, Australia, New Zealand, South America, and even in Japan. My Van Deman and Pineapple quinces were not very well received by some when first intro- duced; at present they are planted more than all other quinces in California, and everywhere acknowledged to be the best in quality, as well A CLUSTER OF THE NEW WHITE ELDERBERRIES This is a selected variety. There are several species of elders, and some of them show a tendency to vary—a trait that is always attractive to the plant developer, since tt gives him material with which to work. (About one-half life size.) ive Che ‘od IMPROVING SMALL FRUITS 51 as having all the other most desirable qualities in the highest degree, and in most of the Eastern States the first mentioned is considered the only variety worth growing, succeeding above all others even in the coldest climates. But little merit was seen in the Phenomenal berry when first introduced, but during the past few years until quite lately the demand for the plant could not possibly be met. When the Crimson Winter Rhubarb was first introduced, the rhubarb growers in California paid no attention to it, and for some time refused to plant it at all. More recently, fortunes have been made in California and other regions hav- ing a mild climate by its culture, and to-day it is practically the only rhubarb being planted in all mild climates. People did not understand its new and peculiar characters and qualities; time was required to educate them. The same might be said of the Shasta daisy and several scores of other plants, and nuts, flowers, fruits, and ornamental and forest trees and vegetables which have been produced on my grounds. I have learned through experience that no new fruit will be fully appreciated, or its quali- ties generally known or recognized, for at least ten or twenty years. 52 LUTHER BURBANK Corn, beans, peas, cucumbers, and similar plants can be tested in six months and accepted or rejected; but it requires years to test a new fruit so that its qualities may be thoroughly and generally appreciated. A RECAPITULATION OF METHODS We have seen that the adaptation of fruits to certain localities may be accomplished either by importation of plants developed elsewhere, or by producing the seedlings on the grounds, and selecting those that prove best adapted to the local conditions. In either case, a thorough study of each type of fruit in view of the needs and requirements of the location is absolutely necessary, in order to achieve success in the adaptation of the fruit. A section of country where strong winds pre- vail will require a fruit tree with compact form and of firm wood. In climates of brilliant sunshine the tree must be protected with an abundance of thick, heavy foliage. Some trees will not thrive in a dry soil; others cannot endure much moisture. And there may be differences as to these propensities among plants grown from the same lot of seed; and, indeed, from seeds produced by the same plant. IMPROVING SMALL FRUITS 538 Therefore not only the type but the individu- ality of the plant must of course be considered, — adapting it to certain conditions. If the quality of hardness in fruit is required, it may be attained through proper methods. . In regions where insect and fungous diseases thrive it is necessary to evolve fruit trees which are re- sistant to such pests; and there is no other way of reaching a satisfactory conclusion regarding their resistant powers than to grow them where they are exposed to their foes. All of this cannot be accomplished in a brief time. It requires the most persistent labor and unyielding patience. Any recognized “fruit quality” can be intensi- fied, almost any desired quality can be attained, through intelligent observation, selection, and patient waiting. But not without toil; nor with- out careful heed to such measures as will assure the cooperation of nature. Says Emerson: “The ripe fruit is dropped at last without violence, but the lightning fell and the storm raged, and strata were deposited and uptorn and bent back, and Chaos moved from beneath, to create and flavor the fruit on your table to-day.” Let the plant developer ponder and heed that saying, and realize that at best it is given him 54 LUTHER BURBANK not to create or overturn, but only to have a slight selective and directive influence in the great Scheme of Plant Evolution. FOUNDATIONS OF HEREDITY We have viewed in detail the story of the development of the different fruits, and have observed many anomalous products. We have witnessed the creation of new species, and have seen that rules applying to the hybridizing of certain forms appear to be quite abandoned in the hybridizing of others. But of course we know that the underlying principles are everywhere the same, and that seeming divergences in their application to dif- ferent species are but modifications of the same laws to meet varying conditions. The wise plant developer must be able to look beneath the sur- face and discover the underlying harmonies. Otherwise he will often make mistaken inter- pretations, and will perhaps give up an experi- ment when the goal was just within reach. Perhaps it may be helpful if now, by way of summary, we review in their broader outlines a few of the principles that have been illustrated by specific cases in the preceding volumes, and offer an added word of explanation that may be of aid to the general reader in clarifying his IMPROVING SMALL FRUITS 55 view of complex plant hybridizations, and to the plant experimenter in giving clews that — may prove advantageous in his work in the field. Let us recall, as the text of our first illustra- _ tion, the simplest case of plant crossing. When, let us say, a thorny and a thornless blackberry are crossed, the offspring are all thorny. But in the next generation a certain proportion of the offspring are thornless. A corresponding case is that of the ordinary blackberry crossed with the white blackberry. All the offspring of the first generation are black, but whiteness reappears among their descendants. | Let us recall, further, that the process of crossing consists essentially in bringing the nucleus of the pollen cell in combination with the nucleus of an egg cell. Also let us bear in mind a computation that we were able to make with the aid of the physi- cist, by which we were made aware that the germ cell itself is a highly complex structure with diversified component parts, each of which may be thought of as having as much individu- ality as any member of a developed organism. We saw that, even if we considered the indi- vidual parts or members of a germ cell to COLOR VARIATIONS IN THE CANES OF THE HYBRID BLACKBERRIES Not only is the leaf a guide to the kind of fruit which a plant will produce, but in many cases the stem or cane gives a reliable indication. With most berries it is the rule that the light stalk will produce the lightest colored berry—and the darker the stalk, the darker the * berry. From the variations shown above it will be seen that much time and expense may be saved by a careful examination of the young plants. Lose 8 tr IMPROVING SMALL FRUITS 57 number a thousand or more, there are avail- able many billions of atoms to make up each member. Let us then, finally, recall the teaching of the modern biologist, who gives us reason to believe that, just as each individual higher organism is produced by the union of two complementary elements, male and female, so there is union of complementary elements within the intimate structure of the ovule itself to form each new character. That is to say, using the accepted terminology, it is necessary in building up any character that is to be made manifest in the future adult organism, that there shall be a blending of two hereditary factors, which we may now think of as individual members of the germ plasm colony or organism. For example, there are factors of thorniness and factors of thornlessness in the germinal cell of the blackberry. There are color factors for blackness and for whiteness in the case of our other blackberry. It may be in any given case that the two factors united both represent thorniness, in which case the future plant will bear thorns. It may be, on the other hand, that the two factors both represent thornlessness, and in that case the future plant will be thornless. 58 LUTHER BURBANK Yet again there may be a union of a thorny factor with a thornless factor; and in this case, as we have seen, thorniness will prevail because, as we say—although, of course, our explanation only states the matter over again in another way—the thorny factor is dominant and the thornless factor recessive in this particular combination. Changing our terms to suit the case, the same principles apply to our black and white black- berries. And in each case, it will be recalled, the germ cell that bears only dominant factors will breed true to the dominant quality; the germ cell that bears only recessive factors will breed true to the recessive character; and the germ cell that bears the two conflicting factors will have prog- eny in which these factors are separated and reassembled in various combinations, thus accounting for the reappearance of the latent or recessive character. HEREDITY VISUALIZED All this is familiar to us and has been illus-; trated over and over again from practical cases in the course of our studies. And we have agreed that the really mysterious part of the entire process is the fact that the IMPROVING SMALL FRUITS 59 hereditary factors are able to combine with such certitude and grow and multiply and reproduce © themselves indefinitely. This part of the procedure is indeed mysterious and beyond the fathoming of the human mind. Yet perhaps it may be made to seem at least a little more tangible and explicable, even if not less mysterious, by an interpretation in which we are permitted for once to make use of the _ imagination. Suppose we imagine the existence within the complex structure of the infinitesimal germ plasm organism of a being of human intelligence, but of atomic proportions—an elf that has control of the hereditary factors, con- sidered now as material entities, and directs their use in the building up of a new organism, some- what as a human architect directs the use of ma- terial in the construction of a human habitation. Let us then assume that the material making up the nucleus of a pollen cell as it comes to the ovule of a flower and is brought in contact with the nucleus of the ovule, is in charge of one such elfin architect, and that the materials of the nucleus of the ovule itself are in charge of an- other elfin architect. The task of building the new structure that is to result from the union of the two nuclei devolves upon these two elfin architects jointly, They must work in cooper- 60 LUTHER BURBANK ation and their decisions will determine how the hereditary factors shall be combined in building the new organism. Suppose, now, that the particular case that is before us is that which arises when some colossal plant developer with his crude manipu- lations has succeeded in transferring a pollen grain of a thorny bramble that bears white berries to the pistil of a thornless bramble that bears black berries, and that the respective nuclei of pollen grain and ovule have come together. The elfin architects compare notes, inspect their respective blue prints and charts and tables of specifications, and set to work. For a time they get on very well. There are factors for general size and foliage and form of plant; for time of flowering and appearance of flower cells; for root system and shape of leaf and shape of future fruit, and a multitude of other details in regard to which there is perfect agreement. In all these cases the factor that A represents fits perfectly into the factor that B represents, and the work of building the future plant goes on apace. But presently, as they have built upward from the root and outward from the center, they come to the specifications for texture of stem. And here at once there is disagreement. IMPROVING SMALL FRUITS 61 Elf A finds that his specifications call for a thorny stem, but the factor that elf B represents _ calls for a smooth stem. And at once there is a discussion. “Whoever heard of a brier bush without pro- tective briers?’ demands elf A. “T have the honor to represent such a one,” says the other. “But the thing is a departure from all the traditions of good brier architecture,” insists A. “Moreover you cannot possibly fit the materials together without getting some brier material.” And this argument prevails. When the factors are examined, it is obvious that if they are put together the thorny fac- tor will overlie the thornless one, somewhat as a carved stone might overlie a smooth stone in a human dwelling. So it is admitted that the new organism must have a thorny stem. Now all goes well again until the two archi- tects come to the building of the future fruit. Character of flowers, time of fruiting, and gen- eral structure of the berry itself are all arranged. But just as the last detail was almost completed there is again a disagreement. It is discovered that A’s plan calls for a white fruit, B’s plan for a black fruit. THE STEM FINALLY SELECTED The direct-color photograph print _ opposite shows the stem of the first true white blackberry. By comparing its color with the color of other stems shown, it will be seen that the dark, purplish brown of the black Lawton has given way to the light greenish stem of the final white blackberry. The color of the stem, it should be understood, is only a guide to the color of the berry which is later to be produced. It does not form the basis of an absolute, fixed law, for outcroppings of old heredity some- times appear in the stem, but not in the fruit. The selection by the stem is, however, of sufficient certainty to warrant its use in such experiments as the production of the white blackberry. Where it failed as a guide in three or four cases, it succeeded in hundreds or thousands of cases. IMPROVING SMALL FRUITS 68 “Whoever heard of a white blackberry?’ de- mands B, turning thus rather neatly the argu- ment that the other elf used about the thorns. “The thing is ridiculous.” “I represent a white blackberry,” A replies, let us hope with dignity. “Well, there isn’t any way of blending white paint and black and keeping things white, is there?” B continues. And this argument is con- clusive. The two color factors are assembled, and it is conceded that the future plant will bear black fruit. The black pigment overlies the white like a double coat of paint, and a black fruit is provided for. When the elfin architects have finished their task, then the factors representing the materials of the two germ cells have all been satisfactorily paired, and provision has been made for a future bramble that will have a thorny stem and will bear black berries—a plant that is unlike either parent, although built of no material except factors drawn from the two parents. Recall, however, that the factors for thornless- ness and for white fruit were not eliminated. They were only overlaid by the opposing factors. They go forward in the germ plasm, each pair of factors being constantly multiplied through division in the mysterious way that characterizes 64 LUTHER BURBANK living matter, so that for each factor that entered into the original structure there are now multi- tudes of factors. And in the next generation, when new pairs of elfin architects are making their plans, it will ‘be possible to reassort the materials (in building a large number of new structures that we call offspring of the second generation), making some combinations that will include two smooth- stemmed factors and two white-fruit factors, and thus giving us a certain number of seedlings of this second generation that will have smooth stems and will bear white berries—which chances, perhaps, to be what the crude human experi- menter is seeking. THE ARCHITECTS ON STRIKE But now let us attend to a case in which a more complex hybridization was made; that, let us say, in which the pollen of an apple was brought to the pistil of a dewberry. Now we must call attention to a feature that | we have ignored heretofore—the segregation of body plasm and germ plasm at an early stage of the union. The coming together of the two germ plasms gives a stimulus to growth. The berry develops, and a drupe is formed that is like a dewberry, IMPROVING SMALL FRUITS 65 because the body plasm of the dewberry is acting as carrier. That is to say, the dewberry is the pistillate parent. The elfin architects in a single ovule get to- gether. They separate out the body plasm, and, although there is conflict, it appears that the material will permit the building of a root and stem and leaf system that will answer after a fashion—though a sad departure from tradition. A big rambling bush that will try to ape both dewberry and apple tree will result. — But in the matter of the architecture of the germ plasm for the new organism through which the race is to be perpetuated, difficulties arise at the outset that are almost disheartening. There has been trouble enough in getting the factors together to make any sort of stem and leaf and flower. But all this was nothing com- pared to the difficulties that arise when they get to the fruit. “Specifications for fruit,” says A, consulting his blue print: “A big, pulpy fruit, about four inches in diameter, called an apple.” “Not at all,” cries B, consulting his own blue print. “The fruit is a small berry about an inch long, with many drupelets each having a seed at its center—in short, a blackberry.” 8—Vol. 5 Bur. 66 LUTHER BURBANK How can two elfin architects hope to harmonize materials like that? It is like getting together two human architects to combine materials for a habitation and finding that the material one has to offer for the house are blocks of stone four feet square while the other has only pebbles. And as the conference goes on, the points of discrepancy become only the more apparent. All the differences that are manifest between a blackberry bush and an apple tree, and between an apple and a blackberry—together with a mul- titude of intimate distinctions that the crude human senses cannot fathom—are represented by factors that obviously cannot blend. So, after studying the matter over and wrangling about it till their heads ache, the elfin builders give up the thing as a bad job. Their germ factors lie in separate piles unas- sembled and incapable of being assembled; and the result is that no provision will be made for fruit in the future plant. In other words the plant will be sterile, and that particular double stream of germ plasm will cease to be per- petuated. | By Way oF SUMMARY This, then, is what may be imagined to occur when there is too great difference of materials. It may be left to the reader’s imagination to make IMPROVING SMALL FRUITS 67 for himself a picture of the various activities of the elfin architects in those cases where the diver- sity between the different hereditary factors 1s greater than that between the two kinds of black- berries, but less than that between the apple and the dewberry. We saw in such cases as that of the Primus berry and the Sunberry that when the two germ plasms were at just a certain stage of divergence the resulting hybrid presented a compromise of characteristics. We may suppose that the elfin architects in the germ plasm are in such a case to be compared with human architects, one of whom, let us say, presents blocks of stone as the chief building material while the other presents bricks. Stone and bricks cannot be blended, but they may be variously combined, for example, placed in alternate layers, to make a structure that is neither a stone house nor a brick house, although it is a house built of both stone and brick. In the same way the Primus berry is neither a blackberry nor a raspberry, although its com- ponent hereditary factors are all either black- berry or raspberry factors. | But we need not attempt to carry the illustra- tion further. The reader who has followed it may make his own application, in reviewing the facts 68 LUTHER BURBANK as to the various results of hybridizing species more or less closely related that have been de- tailed in the preceding chapters. To some readers the entire illustration of the elfin architects may seem whimsical. But it is presented in all seriousness in the hope that it may serve a useful purpose. Not that I would for a moment be understood as suggesting that any such infinitesimal creatures with human in- telligence are really domiciled in the germ cell. But to personify thus the inscrutable forces through which the building together of the hereditary factors is brought about may serve to give tangibility to the forces of heredity, and to help the reader to memorize the facts already presented, and gain clearer insight into the prin- ciples that underlie them. _It may chance that such a personification will enable the plant: developer to see a little more clearly into the nature of the phenomena that are presented before his eyes when two plants are hybridized; and that he may thus be enabled to interpret the phenomena in a way that will be to his practical benefit. As elsewhere pointed out, the incorrect interpretation of the early results of a hybridizing experiment may put the experi- menter off the track and Jead him to give up an effort which would have led to complete IMPROVING SMALL FRUITS 69 success had it been carried forward another generation. But, in any event, whether or not the reader finds the elfin architects of the germ plasm an aid in his interpretation of the phenomena of heredity, let the would-be developer of new fruits or the improver of old ones, bear in mind, as the Jast word that experience can offer on the sub- ject, the principle that progress must be sought through the careful selection of types that vary in the direction of desired progress; and that in a vast majority of cases such variation may be brought about, and in a sense directed, through hybridization. The successful plant developer must be able to look beneath the surface of his plants to discover and utilize the underlying harmonies. Fuh? F3TRS te ee Vy en ears fastbite . ry

specialization is so great that there is small pros- pect of securing a useful form by bringing them together. Such a development is not impossible, however, but it would certainly be difficult to fix the new type after it had been produced. My own experience with the cabbage tribe was chiefly gained in the early days of my experi- mental work, half a century ago, when I found that it was easy to cross the cabbage with the cauliflower and with other members of the tribe; that, in fact, it is necessary to grow them quite a distance apart in order to keep the seeds pure. But the hybrids produced were all what we were accustomed then to describe as mongrels. Some of them had small cauliflowerlike heads of in- ferior quality. At the time when these experiments were made I did not fully understand the impor- tance of the second generation, and have never found time to take this ine of experiment up again. I had good success then, however, in crossing the purple-leaved cabbage with other varieties of cabbage, developing thus a purple cabbage with a very large head. Though larger, they were somewhat less dark in color than the parent stock. COMMON GARDEN PLANTS 121 My work with the turnip has not extended beyond: the stage of experimental crossing as with the cabbages, which led to no prospect of useful results. With the radish, which might be described as a dwarf turnip, much work has been carried along the line of selection, without hybridizing. There are enough variations among the seed- lings of any given variety of radish to afford ample opportunity for selection as to form, color, and qualities in general. In the. course of the experiments a dozen or more of the most popular kinds of radish were used, the principal aim being to get the roots very uniform and smooth, all developing at the same time, instead of at different times as most rad- ishes now do; and all of uniform color. Another object was to develop varieties with the smallest amount of foliage that would be adequate to build up the roots quickly under good conditions. __ Also attention was given at one time to the flavor of the radish, in developing a sweeter pun- gency for which the vegetable is relished. As just noted, all the radish seed used in these experiments proved exceedingly variable; and even those that were selected and reselected per- sistently for several years showed a tendency to ANOTHER OLD FRIEND The radish..can claim no such economic im portance as the beet has now attained; but it is perhaps even more universally distributed in the gardens of the world. The specimens here shown illustrate the wide variation of form among the different varieties that have been developed through selective breeding. COMMON GARDEN PLANTS 128 reversion. But this variability, while it is annoy- ing to the practical gardener, should give the radish added interest from the standpoint of the plant developer. The amateur who wishes to experiment with this species can begin with plants grown from any good seed that he may secure. He might then hybridize these plants with seed of a Japanese or Chinese variety. The radish is supposed to have originated in China and the vegetable is still very popular in the Orient, where besides being eaten raw it is pickled, dried, and preserved in various ways _ somewhat as we preserve fruits. ONE OF THE ORIENTAL RADISHES The Oriental radish is of large size and may be grown readily in a soil adapted to radishes in general; that is to say, a white, clean, sharp sand, which should be fertilized with chemical fertilizers only. The plants should have plenty of moisture and sunshine, thus being urged to rapid growth. They are much more subject to disease and liable to become pithy or hard when grown in rich soil than when grown in the sand, and are also of less" satisfactory flavor. There is little doubt that by crossing the Oriental varieties with our common ones some interesting variations would be produced that 124 LUTHER BURBANK might lead to the development of new varieties not without importance. SOME OBSTINATE Root BEARERS In marked contrast with the members of the crucifer family, with their extraordinary tend- ency to variation, are the two familiar members of the garden family that are most prized for their roots, the carrot and the parsnip. . For these have assumed a characteristic shape from which they show very little tendency to vary, and even under persistent cultivation have held very true to their type. | The plants are closely related, and both are descended from wild forms that are poisonous. Moreover the cultivated species themselves, if allowed to hold over until the second season, may in some cases develop.a poisonous quality. But as ordinarily grown from the seed and used the first season, they constitute wholesome vegetables of deserved popularity. My work with the parsnip has been confined to the attempt to develop a race having roots that are smoother and of a broader or more compact form. But this was found to be a thankless task, as the roots tend to reach downward in spite of all the education that could be given them. It is a persistent quality that the plant seems very un- COMMON GARDEN PLANTS 125 willing to give up. In this the parsnip shows its retention of the habit of its wild ancestor. The carrot also is not altogether free from its wild instinets, and will pretty readily revert to the wild state. I have experimented with the wild carrot, which has a long, hard, slender root, and found that this could be brought back to the production of what might be called a civilized root. Color may be added to the carrot root or taken away from it by selection through successive generations. This is quite what we might expect. iedien we consider the difference in color between the roots of the carrot and the parsnip, which in their wild forms are very closely related. There is opportunity for some one to adie. take the improvement of both parsnip and carrot as to the quality and shape of their roots, and such experiments might very likely prove suc- cessful if carried out persistently, notwithstand- ing my own failure to produce marked modifica- tions in this regard. The flavor of the carrot could be improved, probably without any great difficulty. SALSIFY OR OysTER PLANT | There i is another root that offers a challenge to the plant developer somewhat as do the parsnip PARSNIPS Not even.a tyro at gardening or botany needs to be told that the parsnip 18 own cousin to the carrot. It is equally obvious, however, that the two belong to quite different species. The parsnip has been rather neglected by the scien- tifie plant developer and there is abun- dant opportunity for its improvement. COMMON GARDEN PLANTS 127 and carrot, by the very fact of its obstinate resistance to any change. This is the plant called Salsify, usually known to gardeners as — the oyster plant or vegetable oyster. It is a biennial plant having long, slender, light gray roots. There is only one greatly improved horticul- tural variety. This is known as the Sandwich Island Mammoth. It is fully twice as large as the ordinary salsify, which it otherwise closely resembles. | I have worked with the Sandwich Island Mam- moth with particular reference to improving the smoothness and plumpness of its root. But it was found to be one of the most stubbornly fixed of plants. This is quite what might be expected of a plant that has only one species under culti- vation. We have elsewhere seen that the plants that have many species are the ones that tend to vary. There are, however, two or three wild mem- bers of the tribe, one known as the Spanish salsify and another as the black salsify, a native of Europe. It is possible that these might be used to hybridize with the ordinary and the Sandwich Island species, and that the element of variability might thus be introduced. 128 LUTHER BURBANK Possibly through selective breeding, based on such hybridizations, new varieties of salsify might be developed and the plant might thus conceiv- ably be made to occupy a much more important position than it does at present among garden vegetables. PEAS AND BEANS AS PROFIT- ABLE CROPS IMPROVEMENTS WHiIcH PROMISE MucH VERY good illustration of directive plant breeding is furnished by the case of the Empson peas. This was a case in which I received an order for the development of a new variety of pea that would fulfill certain definite specifications, some- what as a manufacturer of cloth or of electric dynamos or of machinery of any sort might re- ceive an order for a new product to meet a special condition. It is gratifying to record that I was able to meet the specifications, and “deliver the goods,” as a manufacturer might say, as accurately and satisfactorily as if the product had been one to be turned out by factory machinery instead of by selective breeding of a living plant. _ The specifications were these: A productive variety that shall mature all its pods at the same 129 5—Vol. 5 Bur. 130 LUTHER BURBANK time; bearing individual peas of reduced but uniform size, sweet, and of superior flavor. Here, it will be observed, there are several quite distinct characteristics to be borne in mind. Perhaps the most important, or at least the ones most difficult to attain and fix, were the uniform time of ripening and uniform size of the peas themselves. How these difficulties were met will be detailed presently. First, however, let me tell just how it came about that the order for peas having just these specifications was received. MANUFACTURER AND PUBLIC The order was given by a large canning fac- tory, located originally in Colorado, but now having branch factories in other regions, with capacity to handle in the aggregate forty-six thousand cans of peas per hour. The head of this company is a man who has made a study of his public, and who aims to give the public what it wants. He discovered that there was a demand for canned peas of very small size. This had come about, probably, through the example set by the French, who can the peas when they are half grown, at which stage they are sweeter and more tender than when more fully ripened. PEAS AND BEANS 181 The American public developed a liking for these small peas, and a willingness to pay more for them than for the larger ones, but no Ameri- ean canner could profitably duplicate them in size and quality. The American canners are themselves con- vinced that peas of medium size are really better; and they were desirous that the public should have what it wanted. | So it came about that I received a letter from the management of the canning company asking me to undertake the work of developing a pea _ that would meet the specifications as to size, and yet would mature in such quantities and with such uniformity that there would not be great loss in handling, as there would be if the pods matured as then grown at different times. The reason that this specification is imperative is that peas for canning, according to modern methods, are not gathered by hand. Indeed they are not touched with the hand at any stage of their existence, even in planting. The crop must be ready all at once, because the vines themselves are harvested. A machine is drawn along the rows cutting off the roots about an inch under- ground, and raking four rows together in a windrow. 132 LUTHER BURBANK Cutting below the ground keeps the peas fresh and also insures getting the entire crop. A wagon immediately follows, gathering up the pod-laden vines like a load of hay, and hauling them to the factory, where they are fed by machinery into a sheller, which consists of two big cylinders with vulcanized rubber cups on their surfaces, so arranged that the air pressure splits the pods open without crushing them. The peas roll down an inclined plane with per- forations of different sizes, and are thus auto- matically sorted into five grades, just as oranges of different sizes are sorted in California. The peas all fall into clean running water and are im- mediately canned without being touched. It may be interesting to add that a factory of this type has a record of putting canned peas on the shelves of the grocer within two hours of the time when they were growing on the vine in the field. Peas in cans under these circumstances may be fresher and better than those purchased in the pod usually are. These details as to canning obviously have no direct bearing on the methods of the plant devel- oper. But they explain the specifications that were given along with the order for the hew variety. PEAS AND BEANS . 133 In attempting to meet the specifications, 1 followed the methods of rigid and systematic selection. There was no occasion for cross-fer-_ tilization, as the peas were of good quality, and showed enough variation as to all of the desired characteristics to offer material for selection. My plan was to pick out in successive genera- tions the vine that came nearest to meeting specifi- cations as to number of pods, uniformity of ripen- ing, and small size as well as uniform size of the peas themselves. It was necessary, as in other experiments of a similar kind, to watch the individual plants, selecting the very best individual plants, and harvesting them by themselves, counting the pods and counting the peas, and making careful record of results. : Fortunately it is possible with the pea to raise two crops in a season. Thus I was enabled to progress very much more rapidly than otherwise could have hoped to do. We could do two years’ work in one. So we were able to deal with six generations of peas in three years. And yet by that time the undesirable qualities had been so systematically excluded and desirable ones so persistently sought for that the educated pea vines fulfilled the specifications exactly. COWPEAS UNDER CULTIVATION This picture shows another form of leguminous plant that has become popular in comparatively recent years. It is of solid and compact growth, and makes a remarkable cover or forage crop. Like the other legumes, its product is rich in nitrogen, a fact long recognized but the explanation of which has been given only in comparatively recent years. Sine coon PEAS AND BEANS 135 I find in my files a letter bearing date of February 29, 1908, that may be quoted here as summarizing the results of the experiments: _ “By express to-day,” I wrote, “I send you all the peas raised from the one best of all my selec- tions. This one is the one which produced the most peas to the pod, the most pods to the vines, had the most uniformly filled pods, and in all respects was the most productive and best; on the whole, the best pea, taking quality, quantity, and everything into consideration, which I have ever seen. They are fifteen per cent smaller.on the average. One other thing which I have added to them is that they are sweeter than the pea which you first sent me. They all came from one single vine which was the best in all respects and the seed has been reselected through six generations.” MULTIPLYING THE NEW VARIETY Of course, the selected pea, as thus produced, existed only in small quantities. But it had been fixed as to type and could be depended on to breed absolutely true. It was necessary, how- ever, for the company to multiply the seed for a number of years before there was enough of it in existence to use for the purposes of the canner. By growing the crops in California, however, where from two to four crops could be raised 136 LUTHER BURBANK each year, and by using the entire product for the seed in successive years, the progeny of the single vine from which I developed the new variety had been multiplied by 1912 so that material enough was at last in hand to plant hundreds of acres and supply the cannery with the small, sweet, uniform-sized and uniform- ripening pea that was desired. I have cited this case in detail, not because it is of exceptional importance in comparison with hundreds of others of my plant developing ex- periments, but simply because it illustrates the possibility of developing quite rapidly a par- ticular plant to meet a specific commercial need. But to understand fully the conditions met even in this single experiment, it is necessary to add that I did not confine attention to the pro- duction of the single variety just described, even in the line of experiments that were undertaken specifically for the purpose of producing that variety. On the contrary, while scrutinizing the vines for small peas of uniform size, I kept vigilant watch also for other vines that varied in the opposite direction. Peas MOopIFIED IN OTHER DIRECTIONS By carrying forward several serfes of selec- tions at the same time, a number of varieties PEAS AND BEANS 137 were simultaneously developed that differed widely both from one another and from the original stock. | I found, for example, in the observation of the early generations grown from the seed, that some plants would produce four or even five times as much as others. This habit of pro- ductiveness was carried to the next generation with a good deal of certainty. So it proved possible, by careful selection, in three years, to develop new forms of peas which produced regu- larly four or five times as much as the average production of the parent form. Of course, this quality of productivity was combined with the various other qualities and was manifested in the perfected pea that was delivered along with the letter just quoted. But there were other qualities which obviously could not enter into the combination, because of variation in exactly the opposite direction from the one in which we were developing the little canning pea. Thus, for example, one variety instead of having small peas had exceptionally large ones. Another variety produced lozenge- shaped peas. These seemed to be unusually sweet, and as they were also among the most productive, I made two strains of this selection alone. One of these is a very large lozenge- 188 LUTHER BURBANK shaped pea, circular, and indented on the flat- tened sides. Both are practically fixed, coming true to type from seed. In fact, by having different ideals and bear- ing them in mind all.along, I developed four strains of new varieties that the canners were glad to purchase, in addition to the one that they had specifically ordered. And all this was done, as just noted, by selection, without the aid of hybridizing experiments. It should be explained that the pea is nor- mally self-fertilized, so that there is the closest inbreeding, and it is therefore relatively easy to fix a type. Moreover the pea is a very pliable plant, producing new varieties with little care and labor as compared with many other plants. Although I have devoted much less time to it than to many other plants, I have developed numerous varieties that are specially modified for color, for productiveness, for size, for quality, or for resistance to mildew and other affections. And other experiments are under way that will probably lead to still further developments. MENDEL’s FAMous EXPERIMENTS Although much may thus be accomplished with the pea by mere selection, it should be re- PEAS AND BEANS 1389 membered that this plant offers exceptional opportunities also for development by hybrid- ization. In particular it should be recalled that the extraordinary experiments through which the Austrian monk, Mendel, made the discov- eries that have created such commotion in the biological world, were made with the common garden pea. Reference to these experiments has been made more than once, but it will be worth while to examine them a little more in detail in the pres- ent connection. _ The discovery that Mendel first made, to which we have already referred, was that certain qualities of the pea are grouped into very con- spicuous pairs. His investigation led him to believe that there are at least seven differentiating characters that could be relied upon to reproduce themselves with certainty in the offspring of the pea. These characters, which he came to speak of as “unit” characters, are the following: (1) The form of the ripe seed, which may be roundish, either with or without shallow wrinkles, or angular and deeply wrinkled. (2) The color of the reserve material in the cotyledons or little leaves that first appear when 140 LUTHER BURBANK the seedling comes out of the ground; the colors being pale yellow, bright yellow, orange, or green. (3) The color of the seed coats; white, as is usual in peas with white flowers, or gray, gray- brown, leather-brown, with or without violet spots, etc. (4) The form of the ripe pods, whether in- flated or constricted or wrinkled. (5) The color of the unripe pods, whether light or dark green or vividly yellow, these colors being correlated with colors of stalk, leaf, vines, and blossoms. (6) The position of the flowers, whether axil- lary or terminal. (7) The length of the stem of the plant itself, whether tall or dwarfish. It is obvious that in each case the different qualities named are antagonistic or mutually exclusive. The seed cannot be at the same time round and angular; it cannot be at the same time smooth and wrinkled; cotyledons cannot be at once yellow and green; the pods cannot be at once inflated and constricted. And as each race of peas, when inbred, holds true to its type, there was opportunity to observe the effects of cross- ing the different races in relation to these differ- ent fixed characters. PEAS’ AND’ BEANS 141 The results Mendel obtained have already been outlined, and more than once referred to’in this and in previous volumes. | 7 It will be recalled that, as regards the various pairs of antagonistic characters, he found that one or the other proved prepotent or dominant in the first generation; but in the second gener- ation (when the first generation hybrids were — inbred) the submerged or recessive character would reappear in one case in four on the average. Thus he found that in the pea tallness of stalk is dominant to shortness of stalk; that -yellowness of seed is dominant to greenness of seed, etc. This was demonstrated by the fact when a tall pea was crossed with a short one all the offspring were tall, but one-fourth of the offspring of the second generation were short. Similarly when a pea with yellow pods was crossed with one having green pods, all the plants of the first generation had yellow pods; but one-fourth of their offspring of the next generation had green pods. THE SEGREGATION OF CHARACTERS A second very important feature discovered by Mendel was that the different antagonistic pairs of qualities are transmitted quite inde- pendently of one another. 142 LUTHER BURBANK For example, the relations of tall and short peas, blended in heredity, are quite independent of the question of yellowness versus greenness of pod. So observation may be made as to two or more qualities in the course of the same experiment. . Thus, if a tall variety of pea that bears green pods is crossed with a short variety bearing yellow pods, all the offspring will be tall peas with yellow pods—therefore unlike either parent. But the offspring of the next generation will such a recurrence of each of the recessive factors in one case in four, so that one-fourth of them will be short and one-fourth will have green pods. But it appeared, so far as Mendel could determine, to be a mere matter of chance—like the throwing of dice—as to the exact number of cases in which shortness of stalk would be com- bined with the bearing of yellow pods. PAIRING THE FACTORS If we assume—as Mendel finally came to do —that each of the different qualities about which we are speaking is represented in the germ plasm by a definite mechanical factor which must be paired with another factor, either like or unlike itself, in order to stimulate the development of the character it represents, then at least a pro- PEAS AND BEANS 148 visional explanation of the observed facts might be found in supposing that a dominant factor when mated with a recessive one hides or ob- secures the recessive one in that particular com- bination, but does not eliminate it. _ And when the factors are again mixed to pro- duce a new generation, they are still equal in number, and if we think of the factors as tan-_ gible things—let us say like black or white checker men—it will appear that if equal numbers of each are mixed together and taken from a bag in pairs at random or blindfold, it will come about, according to the mere theory of chances, that one time in four two of the white checkers will be paired. This accounts in a crude and mechanical but on the whole a rather satisfactory way for the appearance of the recessive character—say short- ness of vine or greenness of pod—in one indi- vidual out of four of the second-generation progeny. And when we apply the same reasoning to the case where two pairs of factors are under con- sideration—tallness versus shortness, and yel- lowness versus greenness in the present case— it appears that each pair of factors will follow precisely the same law, so that one in four of the second generation descendants will be short and 144 LUTHER BURBANK one in four will be green; but that the same law of chances, applied to this more complex case, gives us only one case in sixteen in which two factors for shortness are combined with two factors for greenness in the same group. In other words, one pea in sixteen descended in the second generation from the tall pea with green pods and the short pea with yellow pods will have a short vine and at the same time will bear green pods. This will be a new variety. It has no new quality, but it has the old qualities in a new combination. Extending the experiment one stage further, Mendel found that the second-generation peas that show the recurrence of the recessive factor will breed true to that factor. And this, again, is quite what might be expected on the theory just outlined. For the pea that contains two factors for shortness will obviously have no pro- pensity to grow tall, and the pea that contains two factors for greenness of pod will obviously have no capacity for the production of pods other than green. So our short pea vine with its green pods, although it represents a new variety, which, for the sake of argument we assume never to have existed before; and although it appeared sud- PEAS AND BEANS 145 denly as what might be considered a mutation, yet is fixed from the outset, and will breed true, and constitute an established variety. All this we have referred to in earlier chap- ters, and we have seen many illustrations of this so-called Mendelian inheritance in the case of a good many of our plant developments—the white blackberry, for example, the stoneless plum, and the thornless blackberry among others. But it seemed worth while to make spe- cific reference to Mendel’s work with the peas, in the present connection, in particular because this work doubtless represents the most impor- tant thing that has been done with the pea at any recent stage of its development. PEAS VERSUS BEANS It was perhaps fortunate that the Austrian monk chose the pea for his investigation rather than the bean, for, notwithstanding the fairly close relationship between these two, there is a rather marked difference between them as to their practical response to the efforts of the plant developer. Perhaps because the pea has been cultivated under varied conditions, and selected for a wide variety of qualities, this plant shows a marked tendency to vary, suggesting in this regard the evening primrose and Godetia, and SHOWING VARIATION IN BEANS The bean is even more variable than the pea; and as there are many species and varieties under cultivation, so there 1s almost endless opportunity for de- veloping new varieties. Here are some samples, all of which developed without crossing from a single variety. PEAS AND BEANS 147 the new varieties are often practically fixed from the outset. | With beans it is less easy to trace and classify the opposing “unit” characters, and in practice it is often necessary to select rigidly and con- tinuously for five or six successive generations _in order to fix a new variety. An illustration of the complexities that may. result when beans of different kinds are crossed was given me at the outset of my work as a plant developer. CrossInNc THE PoLE BEANS One of my first experiments in hybridizing was made by crossing the horticultural pole bean or wren’s egg with another variety of pole bean known as the red cranberry bean. The hybridization was effected with some diffi- culty, inasmuch as only one blossom in perhaps fifty responded to cross-pollenization and a part of the offspring seemed to lack vitality, as I suc- ceeded in bringing but one plant to maturity. But this was in some respects the most astonish- ing bean plant that I have ever seen. It bore long black pods and the beans within them were as black as ink. | Yet one of the parent beans had produced a crimson pod with a red seed, and the other a 148 LUTHER BURBANK crimson and white striped pod, with red and white striped seed, and no trace of blackness. Here, it-will be seen, there was no such sharp differentiation of the color factors for pod or seed into opposing pairs, with dominance in one and recessiveness in the other, as was shown by the peas in Mendel’s experiments. On the con- trary, the union of red beans with red and white striped ones produced something totally unlike either—namely, a jet black bean. But in the succeeding generation the offspring of the black bean showed a breaking up into new groups of characters suggestive of Mendelian heredity. Some of them were black, some red, some speckled, and some white. There were corresponding variations also as to size and shape of the beans, some being large and some small, some round and some. flat. And there was marked diversity in time of ripening. As to the vines themselves, the original hybrid showed the enhanced vitality that commonly characterizes the offspring of rather widely sep- arated parents. The original first generation vine (which bore the black beans) grew to enormous size, outstripping either parent by eight or ten feet, and rivaling the growth of a hop vine. The vines of the second generation were as diversified as the seed. ‘PEAS AND BEANS 149 Some of them were long and vigorous, while others were extraordinarily dwarfed, some being so stocky as to grow pods that almost immedi- ately touched the ground and were obliged to’ bend back like hairpins to find room for growth. There were corresponding variations in size, shape, and color of the leaves. — All this suggests that the beans originally hybridized were themselves of very mixed ances- try, and that a large number of hereditary traits that had been blended in them were permitted to make themselves manifest through the recom- bination and segregation of hereditary factors. ‘The reader cannot fail to note a similarity here between the results obtained and those that were obtained when the Persian walnut and the California black walnut were hybridized. There, as in the case of the beans, the immediate off- spring were of gigantic growth, but the progeny in turn showed both giants and dwarfs. The interest of both cases (and of a number of other allied ones that will be recalled) in illustrating the Mendelian principle of the seg- regation of recessive factors for size, leading to the production of a race of dwarfs, will be obvious. . Another hybridizing experiment with the beans, also undertaken in the early days of my 150 LUTHER BURBANK investigations, brought together two varieties that are even niore distantly related. Crossinc Potz BEANS AND LIMaAs In this experiment I hybridized the horticul- tural pole bean, or “wren’s egg,” with the lima bean. It proved exceedingly difficult to make this cross, but after many fruitless efforts I at last succeeded in securing a single pod con- taining four sound beans by using the pollen of the lima on the pistil of the horticultural bean. When these seeds were planted, in the sum- mer Of 1872, a very strange result was observed ——the beans themselves had in all respects the form, size, and appearance of the horticultural bean, but when their sprouts broke ground it was at once observed that the upper part of their cotyledons (varying from one-quarter to three-quarters of their length in different speci- mens) were indubitably those of the lima bean; while the lower part of each cotyledon was pre- cisely that of the horticultural pole bean. These parts were connected with serrated edges, which at last separated, allowing the lima bean part to drop away. Such separation, how- ever, did not occur until the vines had made a foot or more of growth. PEAS AND BEANS 151 The cotyledons on each side were divided uniformly in every case. | Thus the influence of the pollenizing parent was very markedly shown in the young vines from the moment of their appearance. But after the cotyledons had fallen, all evidence of the paternal parentage of the plants disappeared. The vines did, indeed, show very unusual vigor | throughout the season, this, of course, suggesting their hybridity. But as to appearance and char- acteristics in general, with this exception, they were essentially horticultural pole beans like their maternal parent. The experiment was carried on for several succeeding generations, but the progeny showed no reversion to the traits of the lima bean. The characteristics of the pole bean had seemingly been prepotent or dominant to an overwhelming degree. , This, then, would appear to be another case in which a new race was formed in a single gen- eration by the mingling of two widely divergent racial strains. These hybrids of the lima and the pole bean may be compared, in that regard, to the Plumcot and the Primus berry, to name only two of the various allied instances that have come to our attention. This is what I call a seed- graft hybrid. This and one other instance else- A STRIPLING FROM THE TROPICS In the foreground is seen the South American bean whose stalk suggests the one that Jack grew, according to the nursery legend. T'o appreciate the size of this tropical bean, it should be explained that the corn in the expert- mental bed beside it is more than eighteen feet in height. PEAS AND BEANS _158 where described are the only two similar ones that ever came under my observation, and they never, so far as I know, have been duplicated | before or since. . But the fact that the lima bean, the conspicu- ous traits of which were mostly submerged and subordinated in the mature hybrid, should have made its influence strongly felt in the seedling at the beginning of its growth is peculiarly in- © teresting. One recalls the similar case of the raspberry plant hybridized with pollen from the straw- berry. In that case, the young hybrids at first bore close resemblance to the strawberry plant, yet subsequently shot up into the air and took on the aspects of the raspberry vine. In both cases, then, the influence of the seed plant was at first submerged but ultimately preponderant. It has been pointed out that as a rule it appears to make no difference in the ultimate character of the hybrids as to which of its parents is the staminate and which the pistil- late one. In any event, the analogy between the. hybrid beans and the hybrid strawberry- raspberry, each following first the staminate and then the pistillate parent, is not without interest. 154 LUTHER BURBANK OPPpoRTUNITIES FOR FuRTHER EXPERIMENT After an interval of many years, during which I did not experiment further with the bean, I have somewhat recently found time to turn atten- tion again to this very interesting plant, and have developed a large number of new varieties of unusual qualities. ‘The recent experiments have had to do with the bush bean, and I have paid attention to a large number of attributes, including form of the plant, color of bean, and the quality and flavor. The new experiments have involved the crossing of many varieties and have brought to light many interesting developments, although none perhaps more striking than those just outlined. It has been found that it is feasible to segre- gate and recombine the traits of different varie- ties of beans in almost any desired combination. Thus, for example, it is perfectly feasible to put the pod of one bean on the vine of another, quite as Mendel did with his peas. Observation will show what qualities or characteristics are pre- potent or dominant even without directive effort on the part of the plant experimenter. It will be observed that in the second, third, and fourth generation plants will appear that show the pods and beans of one of the original PEAS AND BEANS 155 parents combined with the leaves and vine of the other, in all possible combinations. | As I have operated with about sixty varieties of beans in the course of these experiments, it will readily be surmised that the number of new combinations that have been presented is almost infinite. Among the hybrid stock can be found beans of almost every color and combination of | colors, black, brown, blue, slate, yellow, green, and white; mottled, striped, and otherwise vari- ously marked and shaded. Moreover, if beans of one color are selected and planted, as a rule all the other colors appear in the progeny. One finds the offspring bearing beans that are speckled, spotted, striped, and shaded in every conceivable way. Yet beans that show this diversity of color may be quite uniform as to size of the beans and time of ripening, as well as in regard to the size and general appearance of the plants on which they grow. ? In other words, a certain number of characters may have become fixed while other characters are still variable. And here the obvious explanation is supplied, at least provisionally, by the supposi- tion that the plants in question are unmixed as to their Mendelian factors for size and character of vine, but retain mixed factors for color of seed. 156 LUTHER BURBANK No one as yet, however, has worked out in detail the combinations of hereditary factors for the bean as Mendel worked it out in the case of the pea. Such an investigation would constitute one of the most interesting experiments in plant breeding that anyone who has time for it could undertake. It is true that the hybridizing of the plant of this genus is rather difficult, inasmuch as the flowers must be opened and the stamens removed with a pair of small forceps to avoid self-fertilization. But, on the other hand, once cross-fertiliza- tion has’ been effected there are obvious advan- tages in later generations in working with a plant that is normally self-fertilized, the pollen of which is inaccessible to insects. All in all, I think the bean offers as many inducements for improvement as any other plant under cultivation. Although much has been and may be accomplished with peas and beans by mere selection, these plants offer exceptional opportuni- ties also for improvement through hybridization. THE TOMATO—AND AN INTER ESTING EXPERIMENT A PLant WuicH Bore Potators BELOw AND TOMATOES ABOVE preserving tomato and had learned its origin was curious to know just how I came to make the hybridizing experiment that resulted in its production. I found it difficult to answer the inquiry to his entire satisfaction. One does not recall all the details as to methods, let alone motives, after an interval of twenty-five years. But so far as can be recalled, I had no very definite object in combining the common tree tomato (tomato de laye) and the currant tomato except the one of general interest in the processes of nature, and a sort of all-inclusive desire to see what would happen when plants of such very diverse char- acter were united. | My visitor felt that I must have had some definite idea in mind—some ideal tomato at the 157 A VISITING scientist who had seen my little 158 LUTHER BURBANK production of which I was aiming, and he seemed to feel distinctly dissatisfied when assured that in this particular case a result had been achieved that had not been forecast. The plant developer had been like a chemist putting together newly discovered elements. He knew that he would probably get something interesting, but just what that something was to be could not be predetermined, Two Types OF INVENTIONS This incident is recalled by way of illustrating another phase of the plant developer’s art than that illustrated by the development of the can- ning pea as detailed in the preceding chapter. In that case, it will be recalled, the plant de- veloper was in the position of an inventor called upon to meet a precise set of specifications. He knew from the outset what was to be aimed at and, having acquired a certain craftsmanship, he knew how to set about securing it. A large number of inventions in the mechani- cal world have such an origin as this. When Edison started out to find a filament that would show just the right resistance to the electric current, and yet would not be consumed with its own heat, he knew just what he was seeking, and his problem of the development THE TOMATO © 159 of an incandescent light bulb was comparable, in a general way, to the problem of producing a canning pea of just the right size and quality. But, on the other hand, a long list might be cited of inventions and discoveries of vast impor- tance that were matters of accident. Perkins’s — discovery of the aniline dye; Nobel’s discovery of | nitroglycerine; Réntgen’s discovery of the X- ray; Becquerel’s discovery of radio activity— these are instances where a man found something for which he was not specifically looking. Of course he had to be in line of discovery. It was essential that he should be handling the right materials, and working in a laboratory having the right accessories, or the discovery could not have been made. Nevertheless, in each case, the discoverer found something for which he was not seeking; his experiments had results that he could not have predetermined. And, here again, the analogy with that other type of experimentation through which, for ex- ample, the preserving tomato was developed will be obvious. _ LookINe For SURPRISES The point to be emphasized is that the plant developer is an inventor who works sometimes according to one method and sometimes accord- FRUITS OF A TOMATO HYBRID These interesting tomatoes were the products of an early experiment in _ which the so-called currant tomato was crossed with the upright-growing tree tomato. The result is here shown in the numerous forms, sizes, and colors. The “Burbank Preserving” tomato intro- duced by the Burpee seed house about 1895 is a selection from this lot. dl THE TOMATO 161 ing to another. He is dealing always with com- plex and intricate matters. Sometimes he has studied them so well that he knows what to ex- pect of them in certain combinations. In other cases he is feeling his way, and has no very clear notion of what to expect. It might be said that he is looking for sur- prises rather than for anything definite; and in that event he is pretty sure to find what he is looking for. _ Such at least was my experience in the early experiments with the tomato that led ultimately _ to the production of the particular hybrid at the moment under discussion. These experiments had their origin at the very beginning of the period of my investigations in the field of plant development, a good while before I came to California. But in those days, notwithstanding one or two successes, I was only laying the foundation for my future work—learning how to handle the tools of my trade. So although there may have been interesting discoveries within reach, I did not always know how to grasp them. I had not learned, for example, the all-impor- tant lesson that the second generation hybrid, rather than that of the first generation, is the one 6—Vol. 5 Bur. ~ 162 LUTHER BURBANK that must be looked to, in a large number of cases, for important development. THE Story OF A F'RUITLIKE TOMATO But when I came to California and found opportunity for expanding the work, from time to time I took up the old New England experi- ments where they had been left. In some cases I had brought seeds with me, and was able to complete under the new condi- tions experiments that had been begun in New England. In other cases it was necessary to start anew, but with experience as a guide that constituted an asset that often proved a won- derful timesaver. . In the ease of the tomato, experimentation was reopened on a comprehensive scale about the year 1887. It was at this time that I hybridized the tree tomato aid the currant tomato and pro- duced the interesting new form about which we have just spoken. The common tomato needs no description, but the currant tomato is much less familiarly known. It is a plant with long, slender, trailing vines and slender leaves and it bears racemes of small currantlike fruit. It oe- curred to me that it would be highly interesting to hybridize this trailing plant with an upright, compact variety of the common tomato. THE TOMATO 163 The cross was made reciprocally, pollen from each plant being used to fertilize the stigma of — the other. The fertilization was effected without difficulty and an abundant supply of seed was produced. The hybrids that grew in the next generation were many of them pretty clearly intermediate in form and appearance between the parents. But some of them were almost ludicrous in appearance. They took on twisted and con- torted forms, and in particular their leaves were curled and twisted into fantastic shapes. As to fruit, some of the plants produced long clusters with tomatoes much larger than cher- ries; others furnished small fruit like that of one of the parents. And in some cases a plant that had retained the short stocky tree form of the tree tomato bore clusters of small tomatoes in bunches similar to those of the other parent. The foliage varied astonishingly between the two types. In some there was an exact compro- mise that was very curious. The dark, blistered leaves of the tree tomato, combined with the long, slender leaves of the currant tomato, produced a most interesting effect. Other specimens showed every possible gradation between the parent forms. Here, then, was a case in which there was no conspicuous dominance of one parent or- 164 LUTHER BURBANK the other as regards any individual character that could be segregated and classified. Neither as to size and form of plant stalk, nor as to leaf, nor as to the fruit itself, was there clear prepotency or dominance of one parent over the other. : If there was an exception to this it was “per- haps that the fruit tended to be borne in clusters, as in the case of the currant tomato, rather than singly or in small groups as with the tree tomato Attention is called to these diversities because it is well to emphasize anew that the phenomena of the clear segregation of “unit” characters, with the exhibition of dominance and recessiveness— which the pea with which Mendel experimented manifests so beautifully, and which we have seen manifested in the characteristics of numerous other plants—is not a universal phenomenon that the plant experimenter may confidently ex- pect always to discover and use as an easy and simple guide along the path of plant develop- ment. Different species of plants, different varieties, even different individuals show diver- sity as to the extent to which the so-called unit characters are segregated and mutually com- bined or antagonized, and as the reader who has followed the story of various plant developments already outlined is clearly aware. THE TOMATO 165 We shall have occasion to revert to this subject more than once, and to point out various possible — interpretations of the phenomena, various under- lying harmonies that do not appear on the sur- face. But for the moment we are concerned with the story of the new tomato, and may be content to put forward the facts regarding it without great insistence on their theoretical interpretation. Suffice it that the progeny of the treelike tomato and the trailing one were a varied com- pany, giving the plant developer almost endless opportunities for selection. I chose, naturally, from among them those that bore the handsomest and largest fruit, and in planting these was enabled, in the course of several generations, to secure a very handsome plant with attractive fruit of new type which came true from seed. It required about six years to produce and make sure of the new variety, which was announced in my first catalogue of new plants, issued in 1893. The description there given of the new fruit was as follows: AN INTERESTING HypBrip “This distinct novelty and ornamental fruiting plant grows about twelve inches high by fifteen inches across. POTATOES WITH A STRANGE HISTORY These are potatoes grown on a vine on whose stalk a tomato top had been ingrafted. The potato leaves were unable, apparently, to supply just the right kind of material in abundance for the making of the best varieties of potatoes, but they made a creditable effort nevertheless. Considering that no tomato vine had. ever grown a potato at all before, the result might be said to be notable. These were produced about 1880. s t s ; { & ; t } ; f sh SIS RD irl TIN ee Taslatahane ae: ratte wo ee a Mi gs abe 99) PD, I ONG oe iuslve nes MCW we ee TON Te in hw tts ahi tnd si a ew MN a 2 st i pe Be cm a ARI on iri inn ti fella diainaaiia eS sak ¢ a ees ro THE TOMATO 167 “The curious plaited, twisted, and blistered, but handsome leaves, sturdy, compact growth, and odd clusters of fruit will make it a favorite ornamental plant.” Another account supplemented this by de- scribing the fruit as “a small, round, scarlet tomato, borne in clusters, the individual fruits measuring only three quarters of an inch in diameter; of splendid scarlet coloring and un- usually rich, sweet flavor.” The comparatively rapid development of this curious form of plant, so widely divergent from the ordinary tomato, illustrates the possibilities and suggests the compelling interest of such ex- periments in hybridizing and selecting even our commonest garden plants. The work is, of course, no different in principle from that followed by the plant developer in the orchard, whose work has been detailed in earlier volumes. But there is this important practical difference: In experimenting with such a plant as the tomato, we get results quickly because the plant grows and fruits in a single season. The results of any given experiment may be known within a few months of the time when the seed is planted. This is quite different from the case of the orchard and especially nut trees, which require, as we have seen, long periods of patient 168 LUTHER BURBANK waiting, few of them bearing, even under un- usual methods of grafting, in less than two or three years, and some of them, such as the pear and fig, requiring a much longer period. On the other hand, there is one regard in which the orchardist has an advantage. It is not neces- sary for him to fix his new varieties so that they will come true from the seed, inasmuch as his plants will propagate by division. But in deal- ing with plants of annual growth, like the tomato, it is obvious that a new variety can have little value unless it will come true from the seed. (The tomato is really a perennial that is grown as an annual.) — So the task is not completed when a new vari- ety is produced; additional experiments must be conducted to fia the variety. Even this may be accomplished, however, by careful attention to selection, in the course of a few years, as we have just seen illustrated in the case of the hybrid tomato. , NINETEEN-YEAR-OLD SEED Among my later experiments with the tomato were some that had exceptional interest because of the material used. | It chanced that when I left home in the East, many years before, I brought with me seed of several of the standard varieties of plants and of THE TOMATO 169 some crossbreed varieties; and, as has been pointed out, I was hybridizing tomatoes, pota- toes, beans, and other plants even at that time. _ The lot of seed thus brought to California included some seeds of the tomato. As was cus- tomary in those days, this seed had simply been pressed out of the fruit, and dried on a piece of paper with the surrounding mucilage still cling- ing to it. | Nineteen years afterward I planted some of these seeds, being interested to see whether they retained their power of germination. Somewhat to my surprise, almost every seed germinated. But the majority of the seeds did nothing more than form cotyledons, lacking the central bud for further development. There were a few ex- ceptional plants, however, among the large com- pany—perhaps altogether two dozen—that con- tinued their growth and in due course fruited. The fruit of some of these plants grown from nineteen-year-old seed was sent to an eastern horticultural journal, whose editor commented on the fact that seed kept for this long period still produced fruit quite equal to anything that had been developed in the intervening nineteen years. | In planting the nineteen-year-old seed, I re- tained a certain quantity from the same lot for a 170 LUTHER BURBANK further test: The following year it was planted in the same careful manner. But although a few of the seeds germinated and sent up cotyledons, not one had the power of developing beyond that stage. All of these seeds in-the twentieth year seemed to have lost the capacity to produce a central bud from which the plant stem could develop. Of course it may have been only an accident that a few seeds were able to take on mature growth after nineteen years, whereas not one could do so after twenty years. But I am in- clined to think that the seeds had reached just about their limit of suspended vitality. The facet that germination began, but that it did not ¢on- tinue because of lack of a central bud, suggests that degeneration of part of the substance of the seed had taken place. Seemingly it was only the most resistant seeds that were able to stand this degenerative process, and retain unimpaired vitality to the end of the nineteenth year. The heredity of those that grew was preserved in- tact: the seeds producing exactly such plants and fruit as if they had been planted nineteen years before. THE VITALITY OF SEEDS The interesting question arises as to whether the degeneration of germinal matter was con- THE TOMATO 171 fined entirely to the store of nutrient substance in which the germinating nuclei of the future plant are embedded, or whether it included any portion of the germinating structure itself. The fact that failure to continue growth—in the case of the seeds that put forth cotyledons and then died—-was due to a lack of the central bud that usually puts forth between the cotyle- | dons, suggests that the germinal substance itself was impaired. Of course this germinal matter is of tangible, even if very minute, size, and there is no apparent reason why it might not be im- paired as to a portion of its substance. Conceivably, the substance of the complex molecules making up the germinal protoplasm may undergo a gradual process of decay or dis- integration through the throwing out of some of their atoms, somewhat as radium and its allied substances are disintegrated. This of course is a pure assumption, yet it is not altogether with- out plausibility. But whatever the precise manner in which the degeneration of the germinal plasm is brought about, the suggestion that one portion of its structure may be affected more than another raises a question as to whether, conceivably, such a deterioration of the germ plasm within a seed, in an exceptional instance where a seed is stored TRANSPLANTING SELECTED SEEDLINGS Seedlings grown in the ideal soil are being transplanted at a very tender age. The process is very simple, being effected with the aid of a knife blade, as the picture clearly shows. There is no particular rule about it, except to be sure that you get about all the roots of the tiny plant. fox \s ie) ode ee +o ee si oe SF eee oe ef a2 us fi N ; ni thes rey B ; ae 1 Ss . ¥ A - = as x 2 r -. yt - “ < » 5 Fal OR, ‘ ‘ ch x - “ % \ 3 . 7 . . ms . oe ° THE TOMATO 178 for a number of years before being placed under conditions proper for its germination, might not result in the production of a deformed or modi- | fied plant. | | Whatever differences of opinion may be held among biologists as to the possible transmission of modifications of the body plasm, all are’ agreed that modifications of the germ plasm be- come a permanent heritage and are passed on to the offspring. So it seems at least a pos- sibility that we have presented, in the deteriora- tion of the germ plasm within the seed, an ex- planation of the appearance of mutants or sports that may become the progenitors of new races. Attempts to produce mutants by treating the ovules of plants with chemicals, including radium, have been made by several experimental botanists, notably by Dr. D. T. MacDougal, of the Desert Laboratory at Tucson, Arizona, and by Prof. C. S. Gager. Prof. MacDougal’s evening primroses, grown from seeds that were treated with chemicals while in embryo, some- times differ markedly from other plants of the species. Prof. T. H. Morgan has made similar experi- ments with the eggs of a fly, treating them with radium, and thus producing individuals strik- ingly different from their parents. 174 LUTHER BURBANK These experiments, then, although they mark merely the beginning of a new line of research, are interesting in their suggestiveness. And it occurs to me that the case of the nineteen-year- old tomato seeds may have a bearing on the same subject. It would be well worth while to conduct a systematic line of experiments in which seed of a fixed species is stored in large quantity, and a certain proportion planted each year, careful record being made of the characteristics of the successive groups of plants, with an eye to any modifications that may occur when the seed approaches the limit of the term through which it can maintain vitality under the conditions given it. ;, It is said that there are records of whaae germinating after it had been preserved for cen- turies in the tombs of Egypt, although there is no proof of this; but most seeds have far more restricted capacities for maintaining vitality. My experiment suggests about twenty years as the limit for the tomato seed under fairly good condition. So the seeds of some fixed type of tomato might very well be among those selected - for such an experiment as that just suggested. My own observations in the matter are chiefly confined to what has just been related to the THE TOMATO 175 nineteen and twenty-year-old tomato seeds; and must leave further investigation along this line to younger experimenters. GRAFTING ToMATO AND Potato _ Doubtless among the most interesting experi- ments (to the general public) with the tomato have been those in which this plant was grafted on the stalk of the potato; together with the com- — plementary experiments in which the potato was grafted on the stalk of the tomato. The grafting of herbaceous plants such as these presents no complications as a mechanical procedure. The fact that the stem is succulent throughout makes such grafting a less delicate proeess than the grafting of twigs of trees, for example, in which, as we know, it is necessary to bring the cambium layers of the bark in accurate contact. With herbaceous plants like the potato and tomato, the stem may unite at any portion where the cut surfaces come in contact. To make a neat and thoroughly satisfactory graft, however, it is of course desirable to select stems of exactly the same size. The splice graft, elsewhere described, is the _ best one to use, and if the incisions are made with care, so that the incised surfaces fit accurately together, it is only necessary to tie a piece of 176 LUTHER BURBANK cloth about the united stems for a few days until union has taken place. It is not necessary to use grafting wax, if protected from winds and too hot sun.. The operation is preferalty. per- formed in the greenhouse. By this method, I grafted the tops of young tomato plants on the main stalks of potato plants, at a time when the stems were about one- quarter of an inch in diameter. The reverse operation, grafting amputated potato tops on tomato roots, was performed at the same time. Of course the tomato and potato belong to the same family, and it seemed reasonable to suppose that such grafting might be successful. But, on the other hand, numerous attempts have been made to hybridize the two plants by cross- pollination, and these have always resulted in failure. I have tried it many times, and have never been able to fertilize one plant with pollen of the other. We know that, as a general rule, plants that cannot be cross-pollenized cannot be mutually grafted. The same barriers usually exist in one case as in the other. The potato and tomato grafts, however, proved very notable exceptions to this rule. In both combinations the union between the foreign stems took place quickly, and resulted in a stem as strong as the ordinary stem of either plant. THE TOMATO 177 Growth continued, and the plants: came to maturity at about the expected season. - But the results of the strange alliance were interesting to the last degree. They must be considered in detail as having a bearing on one of the most interesting open problems of plant development—the question of sap hybridism. PotTATOoEs GROWN ON Tomato VINES The tomatoes that grew on the root stalks of the potato developed much as other tomato vines do, although in some cases it seemed that the vines bore closer resemblance to potato vines than is usual. But the fruit that appeared in due season was a tomato differing in no very obvious respect from other tomatoes of the same variety. ‘They, however, were not of as good quality. Meantime the potato roots, which supplied water and mineral salts to the tomato vine above them, and which in turn must receive material for the growing of their tubers from that vine, showed quite unmistakably the influence of the foreign system of leaves with which they were associated. - Instead of being smooth and symmetrical like ordinary potatoes the tubers were small and ill- 178 LUTHER BURBANK shaped, and some of them had rough and cor- rugated sealelike surfaces, suggesting the skin of a lizard rather than that of a potato. More- over, they were bitter in flavor and utterly un- like the ordinary potato in taste. They further showed their departure from the traditions of their kind by manifesting a tendency to sprout even while the tomato top was still growing vigorously. Perhaps these results, as regards both the relative normality of the tomatoes borne by the grafted vine, and the abnormality of the pota- toes grown by the roots, might have been ex- pected. At least they seemed quite explicable. It will be recalled that the conditions of plant growth were detailed somewhat at length in the first chapter of the present volume, and that it was there pointed out that the plant roots absorb from the soil about them mineral salts in solution that are carried up to the leaves of the plant be- fore they are transformed into organic matter by combination with carbon drawn from the air. It was noted that the organic compounds thus manufactured in the leaves of the plant must be sent back down the stem of the plant to be de- posited, in case of a tuber-forming plant like the potato, in connection with the roots in the ground. THE TOMATO 179 It follows, then, that the tomato plant, even though its source of supply was the root system of a potato, merely gained from these roots part of the raw inorganic materials with which its leaves were to manufacture the special compounds that go to make up a tomato. Inasmuch as the tomato leaves were them- selves unmodified, there was no reason why. their product, the tomato, should be greatly modified. “In receiving its supply of raw material from a foreign root, the tomato top was in no dif- ferent condition from the ordinary cions in @ fruit orchard, which, as we have seen, are habitu- ally grafted on roots or branches of a foreign species. But the case of the potato tubers is obviously quite different. Their substance is made up of material that came originally, to be sure, in part from material gathered by potato roots; but this material had traveled up to the leaves of the tomato plant and had there been transformed; so when it returned to be deposited and form tubers it was a tomato compound and not a potato compound. It was not absolutely different in material from the material of the ordinary potato, be- cause the tomato and potato are cousins. 180 LUTHER BURBANK But the modification had been great enough to transform the tuber, and make it a deformed and perverted thing, more or less comparable, doubtless, to the tubers of some ancestral race from which both the tomato and potato have developed. The extraordinary Ta, perhaps, was that ’ the tomato should have manufactured starch in such quantity as to have supplied material for even these dwarf tubers, inasmuch as the normal tomato plant produces no tubers of its own. But seemingly the buds designed to produce tubers on the potato roots made an incessant appeal that the vine above could not resist, even though it: was able to fulfill but imperfectly the specifica- tions for a potato tuber. AERIAL POTATOE Meantime, what of the potato tops that were: grafted on the stem of the tomato? _How did these prosper? Here, it is obvious, were complications of a different order. The tomato vine obviously could bear no tomatoes because it had no tops. Meantime the potato vine was equally handicapped as to the production of sub- terranean tubers since it had not roots of its own kind. THE TOMATO © 181 ‘But the tomato roots of course sent up their supply of water and salts in solution, and the potato leaves set to work as usual developing material for the manufacture of tubers. When, however, the effort was made to send this ma- terial for tuber formation back to the roots, there was an embargo put on such transportation be- cause the tomato roots have no knowledge of the | art of tuber making. In this dilemma the potato crop, under spell of the compelling instinct of tuber formation, made the only compromise possible by growing aerial tubers at the joints where the leaves appear from buds springing from the point of union with the leaves of the stem. What would ordinarily have been leaf-bearing branches were terminated with small potatoes, which, because of exposure to the sunlight, generally took on a greenish tint, those in full sunlight sometimes being thoroughly green, while those that were shaded by leaves were of a lighter color. The potato vine growing on a tomato stem and bedecked with aerial potatoes, like some strange form of exotic fruit, was certainly one of the most curious forms of plants ever seen. It is perhaps needless to add that the potato vine produced no fruit that gave any suggestion of “189 LUTHER BURBANK the influence of the tomato. The tubers it grew were potatoes and nothing else; their modifica- tions in form and color were obviously due to the lack of their natural protective soil covering. But the fact that the vine, handicapped by lack of roots of its own kind, should have been able to transform leaf buds into tuber-growing aerial rootlets furnishes an interesting lesson in the metamorphosis of parts. How the great poet Goethe, who first expounded the theory of metamorphosis of parts, and clearly recognized the fundamental unity of stem and leaf and flower, would have enjoyed the viewing of a spectacle like that! QUESTIONS OF SAP HYBRIDISM And for the modern plant developer, the strange compound vines have no less interest, for they suggest a number of questions that are much easier to ask than to answer. How, for example, was the leaf system of the potato that grew the aerial tubers to know that tubers were not being formed about its roots in the ordinary way? It did know this, obviously, else it would not have adopted the unprecedented expedient of growing tubers in the air. It is easy to speculate, and to suggest, for example, that the potato plant producing an THE TOMATO 188 excess of sugar and starch in the usual way, must find some place to deposit it, and that as no demand came from the roots, the only available buds were made to do vicarious service. But the explanation obviously lacks a good deal of com- plete satisfactoriness. For the moment, we per- haps must be content to recognize in this another illustration of the fact of communication between | the different parts of a plant, and of the harmony of purpose through which the plant as a whole is made to respond to the conditions of thé environment in the iphess that best meets its needs. But we are forced to recognize, shou gh such an illustration, a greater capacity for adapta- tion, seemingly almost of a reasoned character, than we are commonly wont to ascribe to the plant. The case of the tomato plant growing on the potato roots, which so perverted the character of the tubers that it supplied, has practical interest for the plant breeder, and in particular for the orchardist, because it demonstrates the effect of a cion on the stalk on which it is grafted. Of course the ordinary fruit tree does not develop a system of tubers, and so it does not call for such a supply of starch, for example, as that which the tomato vine was induced to produce for the 184 LUTHER BURBANK tomato. roots. But the root system of any tree requires nourishment if it is to develop, and this nourishment, as we have seen, must be supplied by the leaves of the tree above it, even though the roots themselves first collect part of the materials. x It follows that the root system of any tree, while it is absolutely essential to the leaf system above it, is also very largely dependent on that system. In other words, there is the closest recip- rocal relation between root system and leaf system. This relationship, which many orchardists overlook, has been long recognized and re- peatedly referred to. But the case of the to- mato on the potato root emphasizes the lesson in such terms that no one can ignore it. With this illustration before us, we can scarcely doubt that the root system of any stock on which a for- eign top is grafted (as is the custom in most orchards) is modified in some measure by the cions it bears. The foreign leaves cannot supply precisely the same quality of nourishment to the root that leaves of its own kind would have supplied. In the main, no doubt, the protoplasm of the root assimilates the nourishment that comes to THE TOMATO - 185 it, and makes it over into its own kind of proto- plasm. But we know that the flesh of animals varies in quality with the food given the animal, and we cannot well doubt that the protoplasm of the root of a plant must similarly be modi- fied by the character of its food. _ And this line of thought suggests the further possibility that when more cions than one are grafted on the same branch or on the same trunk, there must be a certain intermingling of the sap from the different leaf systems in the course of the journey to the roots of the tree; and that it might very conceivably happen that a sufficient blending would take place so that the modified sap might find its way to the fruit buds of a given cion, and affect the character of the fruit ina way not altogether unlike the effect of hybridizing. This would account for the case narrated at length in an earlier chapter, in which a cion of the purple-leaved plum grafted on the stem of a green-leaved Kelsey plum tree appeared to influence the fruit of a neighboring stem so that the seedlings that grew from that fruit bore purple leaves, and smaller crimson fruit. As before stated, such a striking instance of evident “sap hybridism” is exceedingly rare; but 186 LUTHER BURBANK can we be sure that influences of a less tangible character are not constantly exerted by in- grafted limbs? May it not be possible, even, that the influence of cions from many sources on one another, when they are placed together in large numbers on a single tree, as in the case of my colonies of plums and cherries and apples, may be: very notable indeed, even though of such character as not to be demonstrable? Is it not at least possible that the improved quality of the new and splendid varieties that appear on the various cions of these multiple trees is in some minor part to be ascribed to the mutual influence of cions of many different strains of past generations, one on another? If this thought be permitted, we must ree- ognize in such fruit colonies as those in question an influence exercised by the community for the benefit of the individual that is comparable to the intangible influences through which a com- munity of human beings affects the moral char- acter of its individual citizens. All this carries us somewhat afield from the case of our grafted tomato-potatoes, but only to the extent of a natural application of principles clearly suggested by the phenomena exhibited by these extraordinary plants. THE TOMATO 187 A GLANCE AHEAD Let us repeat that the grafting of these two plants is not a difficult procedure. It is well worth the effort of any amateur to _ repeat these experiments (so far as I know, this has not been done until recently, and its signifi- cance has never been fully appreciated), and to observe for himself the curious phenomena that will result. Possibly the results of my own early experi- ments might not be exactly duplicated. But there is little doubt that interesting and en- couraging developments would result. RC) Ate by | "a Maree ont ; CY a. Sis wat ir EGE J ae ay . cae wd. bere bone te! , 3, eyes ih tas ; SOME PLANTS USED FOR FOOD AND FLAVOR .-SOME SUCCESSFUL WorRK WITH THE Lity FamILy HAT there is such a thing as being too popular, many plants have learned to their -sorrow. For popularity, with the plant, implies a kind of attractiveness that results in the plant being eaten by some herbivorous ani- mal. The animals can secure food in no other way, so they are not to be blamed for their marauding. But in the meantime the appeasing of their appetites is destruction for the succulent herbs. The only resource of the plants is either to develop extraordinary capacity to thrive under adversity, as the familiar lawn grasses do; or to develop weapons of defense. These defensive measures may take the form of a tough and indigestible fiber as in the case of woody shrubs; the studding of the plant surface with spines as with the blackberry; the produc- 189 190 LUTHER BURBANK tion of a crop of stinging hairs as with the nettle; or the secretion of oils or other chemicals that have offensive odors, or bitter, acrid, or peppery taste. In the present chapter we are concerned mostly with a conglomerate group of plants, several of which belong to the lily family, that have resorted to the last-named expedient in the attempt to protect themselves against the unwel- come attention of herbivorous beasts. The onion and its allies, the mints, mustard, peppers, and the others of this company are for the most part lowly herbs or succulent bushes that have quali- ties of flesh that make them attractive. In self- defense they have developed added qualities, chiefly through the manufacture of essential oils, or odors or flavors that are the opposite of appealing. | But as in a good many other instances, these plants by their very zeal to some extent defeat their own purposes. The unique quality of the flavors they develop, even though at first repel- lent to the palate, serve as a stimulus to the re- ceptive mind of man, and urge him to develop a taste for the very things which at first seemed repellent. So it has happened that plants that seem by the very nature of their product to be denied FOOD AND FLAVOR 191 presence on the table have come to be regarded everywhere as admirable accessories to the diet- ary, supplying flavors that pique the appetite and facilitate digestion. ‘These stimulators of jaded appetites are perhaps of somewhat doubt- - ful benefit, if we are able to accept the findings of the physiologist, but they have a recognized place in the modern kitchen, and various and sundry of them are among the most important of garden vegetables. At the head of the list, doubtless, if we con- sider universality of vogue, are the members of the onion family, including onions proper of many varieties, and such allied species as the garlic, the leek, and the chive. WoRK WITH THE CHIVE I have worked a good deal with most of these, but have found perhaps greatest interest in de- veloping the one of them that is least generally known —the chive (Allium schwenoprasum). The particular work of recent years with this plant has had to do with a variety which bore a flower that was originally dull crimson in color, and which, notwithstanding its dis- agreeable odor, appeared to combine the quali- ties of a border plant with those of a food plant. 192 LUTHER BURBANK Seed of the chive was secured in Europe and seedlings raised for eight or more years, carefully selecting in each generation the ones that most appealed. There was a considerable tendency to vary within rather narrow limits. some plants being deeper in color than others, but the diver- gence was not at first very marked. In the third year, however, there appeared a variation having a blossom of bright red color instead of the usual rather deep dull crimson. As the chive can che multiplied indefinitely by division, this single plant might have become the progenitor of a race of red-flowering chives. But I wished to see what the hereditary tendency would be, and so raised about ten thousand seed- lings from the red-flowering’ stock. Nearly all of these seedlings reverted to a pink color. There had been a faint tinge of rosy pink in the original flower, obscured by the crimson, but the new seedlings bore larger blossoms of a pleasing pink color, and constitute a new and highly attractive variety. While thus developing a pleasing flower and thereby adding to the attractiveness of the chive as a border plant, I paid attention also to the bulb and stalk of the plant itself as well as to the flavor. : FOOD AND FLAVOR 193 In the course of ten or twelve generations a bulb was so developed that the average size is __ more than twenty times that of the bulbs of the stock of the well-known ordinary chive. Thus the new race of chives not only supplies a pink flower which has a very handsome effect when massed in contrast with the characterless flowers of its ancestor, but it is also relatively gigantic in bulb as compared with them. Thus its value as an ornamental plant and its utility as a food plant were enhanced simultaneously, and somewhat in the same proportion. These results have been attained by selective breeding, without hybridizing, in the course of a comparatively small number of generations. Development has progressed along yet an- other line. The one chief objectionable feature of plants of this tribe, as everyone knows, is their odor. But it is well known also that different members of the onion tribe differ greatly in this regard. In recent years the large sweet Italian and Bermuda onions, which are very mild and relatively odorless, have been introduced, and the possibility of removing from the members of the tribe their objectionable odor has come to be more generally recognized. It appears that the Italian varieties have been rendered odorless by selection from ordinary onions. Some of the 7—Vol. 5 Bur. A SOUTH AMERICAN ALLIUM Here is a plant with a nightcap; or, if you prefer, a dunce cap. The pro- tective covering of the flower bud has burst open, but has not been discarded; hence the curious effect. This is not, as might be supposed, a mere accidental individual peculiarity, but is character- istic of the species. It might be difficult to guess, however, what protective function the nightcap subserves. FOOD AND FLAVOR 195 improved Italian varieties are so mild in taste that they can be eaten like an apple. In experimenting with the chive I have natu- rally not overlooked this quality, and some of these improved varieties show a marked advance upon its ancestors in regard to quality as in - regard to size of bulb and beauty of flower. IMPROVING OTHER ALLIUMS My work with the other members of the family has been fairly extensive, inasmuch as I have experimented first and last with about fifty species of wild and cultivated Alliums from Eu- rope, Asia, and America, especially Alaska, and with various forms from Chile and from China. The onion, a member of this lily family, is an interesting plant with which to work, and from the fact that it shows a good measure of respon- siveness. The wild onions are exceedingly vari- able and the cultivated species no less so. Indeed, this might be taken almost for granted considering the long period during which the onion has been under cultivation and the large number of varieties that are in existence. In addition to the ordinary species with its well-known qualities, there are numerous hand- some flowering varieties of Alliums. And in the Sierras there is also a variety growing along the 196 LUTHER BURBANK mountain streams which has a delicious, sweet flavor much superior to the cultivated onion. I have cultivated also a species from China which is peculiarly sweet-flavored. Some of the Chilean and Canadian leeks that I have had under cultivation differ widely in form from their northern relatives. Some of the Chilean wild garlics have been classified as leeks by the botanists and gardeners in this vicinity; whereas the same observers classify certain of the true leeks as garlics; which suggests the divergence of form of some of these South Amer- ican species. I am now cultivating a wild garlic from the mountains of Chile which is a wholly distinct species from the common cultivated garlic, hav- ing much larger bulbs and a taller stalk similar to that of the leek. My large collection of flowering Alliums from California and other countries has, of course, been made with the expectation of crossing these plants among themselves or with commoner varieties. There are interesting possibilities of development all along the line. The Spanish onion called the Prizetaker, be- cause of the extraordinary size of the bulb, some- times attains a weight of five or six pounds. That new developments, perhaps of unexpected char- FOOD AND FLAVOR 197 acter, will result when the varied races from Eu- rope, Asia, China, and Chile are blended with American stock is quite certain. The onion is not very easy to hybridize because of its small flowers. But it is only necessary to use reasonable care to effect hybridization, and the results are likely to repay the effort. Indeed, whether by hybridizing or by mere selection, the Alliums are susceptible of great improvement along almost any line one may choose. The odor, for example, may very readily be intensified or decreased, and the size and flavor modified. On the whole I regard this as one of the most interesting vegetables with which to work. But there are many other plants prized for their flavor that also merit attention. THE PARSLEY FAMILY Prominent among these are the members of the parsley. family. The common parsley and its close relative ‘be caraway vary a good deal in flavor in individual plants grown from the same lot of seed. Only persons with a developed or specialized sense of taste are likely to notice this, however. To the person who tastes them carefully, it will be obvious that some specimens are much sweeter and better flavored than others. 198 LUTHER BURBANK But as the general public is not very discrimi- nating, it is perhaps doubtful whether it would be profitable to develop these into fixed varie- ties. The market for these plants is of course restricted at best. A more tangible property, and one that is likely to appeal to the user of the plant, is the shape and quality of the leaves. I have worked on the curled parsley to some extent and have found that by careful selection it can be im- proved greatly in a short time. The different tendencies of the leaves can be fixed quite readily in three or four generations. I had also developed a golden-leaved parsley, something like the golden-leaved celery. This was a plant of great promise and I expected to introduce it. But to my regret, it was destroyed by millipeds just before it was ready to produce seed, | I have never seen another specimen, but of course similar mutants might appear at any time, for what has happened once to a plant may happen again. Another genus of the parsley family, Ligusti- cum of the botanist and commonly known as lovage, is cultivated to some extent in our gar- dens for its aromatic seeds and roots. There are several California species in the northern and FOOD AND FLAVOR 199 central parts of the State. The roots are much prized by the Chinese. I have worked with these and other allied species extensively for a number of years. The native species or varieties of this family are hard to differentiate, especially as they vary widely in different localities. All have seeds or roots with a characteristic pungent odor, but the quality of © the odor varies throughout the widest range, from the most fragrant and attractive to the most disagreeable. These wild species offer opportunities for development through cultivation and selective breeding. My own work in this regard has scarcely passed the experimental stage, however, even though it has involved a large number of species and varieties. There is opportunity for interesting and valuable work in the develop- ment of the possibilities of these bearers of flavors that appeal to the palate. MINTs AND THEIR ALLIES I think I have grown all the mints and pot herbs that have been under cultivation, and have found them without exception variable in quality when grown from the seed. Indeed, to the persons who taste them with care, it will appear that variation is the universal 200 LUTHER BURBANK rule. Each individual plant when grown from seed has a slight difference in fragrance, and in the amount of essential oil that it contains; this cil being, of course, the source of the fragrance. It is not difficult by selection alone to obtain varieties that are of exceptionally fine fragrance and that produce a relatively large percentage of the essential oil for which the plants are usually grown. When a new variety has been obtained, it is not necessary to fix it so that it will breed exactly true from the seed; for the most of these plants can be increased by division. The mints hybridize naturally where various species grow in the same vicinity, as we have pointed out in another connection. In this way natural hybrids are sometimes produced that are so vigorous as to replace the original parent plants in the state of nature, driving them out of existence on their own ground. Among hybrid mints, whether natural or produced by hand pollination, there will be seedlings that grow with exceptional rapidity, and that present peculiar shapes and much vari- ation as to roughness and smoothness of leaves and form of the spikes-and blossoms. In work- ing with all these plants, I found that quality was the one thing lacking. In any lot of seed- FOOD AND FLAVOR 201 lings grown from the potherbs or plants some individuals have odors that are positively dis- gusting, and those of some add nothing to the value of the plants, but detract when mixed with the better ones. All this is quite what might be expected when we reflect that the mints are a rather numerous family—that fact by itself proving their tend- © ency to variation. Among the mints worked on recently are species from South America that resemble the peppermint yet are in some respects quite dis- tinct. An unnamed species with a tendency to cling to the ground more closely than other mints and growing so rapidly as soon to cover a large surface gives considerable promise. This species is said to be very hardy, and was sent by my collector from the mountains of southern Chile; it has somewhat the fragrance of the native peppermint. The yerba buena (Micromeria Douglassi) is a common little trail- ing plant in the redwood forests, sometimes growing also among shrubs and along the edge of fields. It has sweet-scented, round leaves, and small, pale, insignificant, purplish flowers. This plant is fairly constant in any given locality, but specimens from different regions vary a good deal, some being rather compact A NEW ALLIUM This is another of the species of alliiums with which we have experi- mented extensively. The relationship with the onion is shown in the form of leaf and particularly in the flower head. Some of these alliwms have really hand- some flowers; and an ornamental onion is certainly an interesting anomaly. iH Sey, rons FOOD AND FLAVOR 203 growers while others produce long, runnerlike branches. A species of this plant of exactly the same flavor, but growing as a shrub, with bril- liant fuchsialike flowers, has been sent me from the high mountains of Chile. These evidently sprang from one original ancestor, but in our California varieties it is an insignificant trailing plant, and its relative of the Southern Hemis- phere is a tall shrubby plant with brilliantly col- ored flowers. The Chilean de is also there called yerba buena. I have attempted to cross this plant with the species from Chile, hoping thus to stimulate variation and perhaps to produce a plant of larger size, and through selection a variety of permanent value. But the flowers of the plant are quite small, making the process of cross- pollenization a rather delicate one, and my experiment has hitherto not proved successful. This, however, is doubtless due to operating on too small a scale. I have no doubt that more persistent efforts will result in hybridizing these species, notwithstanding they came from differ- ent hemispheres. Other mints with which some unusual re- ' sults have been accomplished are the sweet marjoram (Origanuwm) and various species of thyme. 204 LUTHER BURBANK Of the former I have raised many thousands of plants from seed, and have secured among these half a dozen in which the flavor and aroma are exceptionally pure and strong. In one of these individuals the flavor is so much more spicy than is usual that it may be said to constitute a new type of flavor. The experiments in improv- ing the plant are still under way and the response made by the plant itself is prompt, giving assurance of the production of improved varieties. And scores of other plants of similar nature have given like results, but need not be specifically mentioned here. The thyme also has been grown largely from the seed, and have noted with this as with other members of the family a very marked tendency to variation. The most interesting variety that I have developed has been produced by selection from a seedling the leaves of which showed a beautiful white center with very uniform edges of a dark green, instead of the usual yellow and green markings. This plant, in addition to its beautiful leaf, was a more compact grower than the old varie- gated thyme. By selecting through successive generations the novel leaf was accentuated and fixed until it would come almost uniformly true from the seed. This new ornamental variety FOOD AND FLAVOR 205 was offered to a well-known dealer, but he responded that the demand for thyme was so small as not to justify its purchase. So the new plant was allowed to drop out of cultivation. Tue Mustarp FAMILY The members of this family, quite unrelated botanically to the ones we have just considered, | illustrate the tendencies of different races of plants to adopt similar expedients in furthering their ends. Being succulent herbs, like the parsleys and mints, the mustards have devised a similar pro- tective measure, namely the development of essential oils that have a pungent and biting taste. But here as with the others man has cul- tivated a taste for what seemed a prohibitive quality, and the mustards, including not only the plants that give their name to the family, but such allies as the peppergrass, the cresses, and the horse-radish, have long held a secure place in the culinary department of every household. My most extensive experiments in the culti- vation of the mustard were carried out some thirty-five years ago, working quite largely with the Japanese and Chinese mustards, in combina- tion with the common European mustard. 206 LUTHER BURBANK These Japanese and Chinese mustards are quite distinct from our species. One kind very extensively used in China, and introduced by the Chinese in California, has the appearance of a large compact bunch of celery. The leaves are perhaps two inches in width or even more, grow- ing so compactly that the plant is even more solid than an ordinary cabbage head, each plant weighing from two to five pounds. The leaf- stalks are blanched like celery. They have a spicy taste suggestive of mustard that is very palatable and refreshing. The plants are cooked like other garden vegetables. Another Chinese variety has greener leaves and a looser habit of growth, the plant being also considerably larger. This also is a pleas- ant, spicy vegetable when cooked. All the Chinese mustards run to seed quickly at the approach of warm weather, so the seed is usually sown quite early in the winter. The young plants are stimulated to rapid growth by good cultivation and fertilization, and fine large plants are ready for the market in the early spring. The plants are usually grown on raised beds and are planted about a foot apart each way. These are really remarkable vegetables that should be much more generally cultivated in the United States. FOOD AND FLAVOR 207 In the Northern States, unless planted very early in cold frames, they run to seed without forming the large, succulent head that gives them value. _ Both the black and white mustard are com- mon plants in California, the black mustard in particular being prized for culinary purposes when young and tender early in the winter and_ spring. The white mustard grows in enormous quantities in the fields, especially in the region about Monterey Bay, where the seed is collected by the ton, to be ground into commercial mus- tard. The white mustard in particular may become a pest, as it is exceedingly difficult to eradicate it, the seeds sometimes remaining in the ground several years, part of them germi- nating each season. About the only way to eradicate it com- pletely from the grain and other crops, is to pull it just as it comes into bloom in successive seasons. My systematic work of selective breeding of the mustards was carried out while making simi- lar experiments with other members of the family, including the turnips, cabbages, and radishes. Some superior varieties were devel- oped by selection, and the seed was sent east and to various parts of the world. But the demand 208 LUTHER BURBANK was small and the work was presently discon- tmued, although several of these and similar varieties developed are still catalogued by some American and European seedsmen. Other crucifers that the gardener thinks of collectively, though. they represent various genera, are the peppergrass and the various cresses, including the nasturtium. The common peppergrass is as variable as the lettuce. There are large numbers of plants horticulturally called cresses, with a consider- able range of variation. One of the most interesting forms with which I have worked is a Chilean cress (Nasturtiwm Chilense), which is as tender as the common water cress during the rainy season, and which has an astonishing ability to resist drought. This Chilean variety will withstand our summer, even if exposed to the blazing sun, and after a period of dormancy will revive and grow freely as soon as the fall and winter rains come. Experiments with it have been confined to selection for the development of varieties show- ing the best qualities of the plant. With the peppergrass I have worked some- what more extensively. Some specimens of this plant have very finely dissected leaves, having worked to develop this variety which produces - FOOD AND FLAVOR 209 leaves very similar to those of the improved varieties of parsley. The plant is rather obstinate; nevertheless several varieties having many of the desired characteristics have been successfully developed and fixed. | | As the peppergrass is an annual it is of course necessary to fix the new qualities so that they will be reproduced in the seedlings. It is this rather than the mere production of the variety that offers difficulties. The familiar horse-radish offers a notable con- trast to the peppergrass and to most other mem- bers of the family in the matter of seed. For whereas the mustard, radish, turnip, cresses, and the rest produce seed in the greatest possible abundance, the horse-radish produces no seeds at all. The horse-radish does, indeed, bloom with the greatest profusion. But the blossoms prove sterile. The plant has entirely and probably forever lost the power of producing seed. Elsewhere I have referred to the fact of my having created a small commotion among amateur gardeners by the joking offer of one thousand dollars an ounce for horse-radish seed. Of course I knew that no horse-radish seeds were to be had, yet I would gladly have given A BASKET OF BURBANK PEPPERS Like most other products of the garden, the pepper has come wnder our careful attention, The large and hand- some variety here shown has been developed in the course of a few generations of selective breeding, with- out crossing. Similar results will attend the efforts of anyone who will go about the work of improving the pepper with enthusiasm and zeal, using ordinary garden varieties, FOOD AND FLAVOR 211 then, and I would gladly now pay, at the rate of $1,000 an ounce for horse-radish seed. But there is not the remotest probability that anyone will ever legitimately claim the prize. If the seed should ever be found, it will probably be dark-colored, and about the size of a common black mustard seed. I have received nearly or quite a thousand letters informing me that the parties writing could supply me with all the horse-radish seed I could wish, inasmuch as their plants were bloom- ing abundantly, and I subsequently received large quantities of dried horse-radish buds, as well as great quantities of the seeds of weeds of various sorts, and have even received what were alleged to be horse-radish seeds from market gardeners. But the plants that grew from these seeds bore no resemblance to the horse-radish. The interesting features of this loss of the power of seed production by plants that have for long periods been propagated by the root or from cuttings or tubers—including plants of such diverse races as the banana, the pineapple, the sugar cane, and the potato, and nearly all plants generally cultivated in greenhouses, along with the horse-radish—have elsewhere been referred to. I may add that the loss of power to produce seeds in the case of the potato is not 212 LUTHER BURBANK of necessity complementary to the capacity to produce tubers. For at least once in my experi- ence a potato plant that by rare exception: pro- duced seed developed at the same time some of the largest tubers.that I have ever seen. Nevertheless, there is an association between seed production and development of the root system, as we have seen illustrated. And it is not unlikely that development of the root of the horse-radish may have had an influence on its seed-bearing capacity. It may be recalled that the carrot and parsnip which produce roots somewhat suggestive of that of the horse-radish in shape and relative size, are biennials, and do not take on the functions of root and of seed development in the same season. The roots are formed in the first year partly at least to supply nourishment for the develop- ment of the stem and flowers and seeds in the ensuing season. Whatever the relation between the root of the horse-radish and its lack of fertility, the fact remains that the plant is propagated solely by division, and that hence there is no opportunity for the development of new varieties or the improvement of old ones. Each horse-radish root is in effect a part of an original plant now endlessly divided, and the variation in different FOOD AND FLAVOR 213 roots depends upon conditions of cultivation or nourishment, not upon inherent differences beween the different plants. It may chance some day that an exceptional horse-radish plant will produce seed, just as an exceptional potato plant does from time to time. In that case there will doubtless be opportu- nity to improve the horse-radish somewhat as I was able to improve the potato or sugar cane by growing plants from the seed. But until such an exceptional seed bearer is found, we must accept the horse-radish as it is, and admit our powerlessness to change it markedly. THE PEPPERS The versatile family of Solanums, several members of which have already claimed our attention, supplies an important group of plants that are prominent among the producers of pungent and aromatic flavors. These relatives of the sunberry, tomato, potato, and egg plant are the peppers, of which there are large numbers of cultivated varieties in different countries. : The different peppers vary from the size of a barleycorn to that of a very large apple and even in some cases approaching the dimensions of a small squash, and in color from black through BURBANK PEPPERS There is good opportunity for the development of new varieties of peppers through the blending of strains of various races, as several are available. Peppers grow far to the north, but they were originally of semitropical habitat. This handsome specimen was produced by selection alone from an ordinary garden variety. Sometimes these are nine inches long and five across. FOOD AND FLAVOR 215 scarlet, crimson, orange, and yellow to pure white. In form, some are nearly flat, others oval, yet others round or heart-shaped or like drawn-out cylinders. Some are annuals and others perennials. As to flavor, some are sweet and palatable, while others are among the most pungent and fiery of substances that are ever purposely put.into the mouth. My own work has included the cultivation and crossing of a large number of species and varie- ties of pepper. At least one of these will stand a very low temperature, the plants showing no trace of injury when left where ice forms a quarter of an inch in thickness, As most of the peppers are exceedingly sensi- tive to frost, this hardy Chilean variety seems to offer opportunities for hybridizing experi- ments through which other varieties of the plant which at present are of restricted habitat may be made suitable for growth in colder climates. In crossing the very small varieties with the very large ones, and the very light-colored with the very dark-colored, one produces the most unusual combinations. Even in the first genera- tion some bushes appear having diminutive fruits and others having unusually large ones; and there is a display of different colors, includ- ing stripes, that is quite beyond prediction. 216 LUTHER BURBANK Occasionally, though not often, fruit of dif- ferent colors will appear on the same plant. Some hundreds of varieties of pepper have been described, but only perhaps less than a dozen are cultivated ordinarily in the gardens of temperate climates. The large sweet peppers are becoming popu- lar. In some varieties, they are almost mild enough in quality to take the place of their rela- tive the tomato. There can be no question that selection among these and breeding through successive genera- tions would produce almost any desired com- bination of qualities. This chapter has been confined to the edible forms of the lily, mustard, and potato families. ARTICHOKES AND OTHER GARDEN SPECIALTIES Sine NEw Wiuip Foop PLants IN THE Woops OUBTLESS the greatest labor-saving scheme ever devised by any flower to meet its essential needs is that adopted by the Sunflower family—the tribe popularly represented by the sunflowers, asters, thistles, and daisies. The botanist classifies the members of this tribe as Composite or Compound Flowers. The name might be misleading if taken to imply that the flowers of this family differ essentially from other flowers. But the individual flowers of this tribe are in all essentials of pistil and stamen like other flowers. So the modern botanist objects to the name “Compound” as applied to them, although he retains the Latin title that they have borne for some centuries. But if we properly interpret the term, the name “compound flower’ seems appropriate 217 218 LUTHER BURBANK enough, inasmuch as what would commonly be called a single blossom—say a single daisy, or aster, or dandelion, or thistle—is in reality made up of a very large number of individual flowers grouped together into a floral community, which advertises its location to the insects by arranging a single circle of petaloid colored emblems that do service for the entire community. A MEASURE oF Economy The economy of this arrangement, in the matter of saving plant energy, is obvious. Flowers that have not adopted this system are obliged to supply a colored advertising emblem for each individual set of stamens and pistils. These composite flowers make one such floral emblem serve the purpose of scores or even hundreds of flowers. Of course the floral community, even though the individual flowers are very small, occupies considerable room. It is necessary, therefore, to provide a largish receptacle to hold the flowers, and in particular to hold their seeds when developed. The outside of this receptacle is usually covered, for protection, by overlapping series of scaly bracts or little leaves that form a sort of armor. A glance at a sunflower will illustrate the plan that has been pretty generally GARDEN SPECIALTIES 219 adopted in the provision of a covering to shield the flower village, particularly during its early development. | Eviste FLowrer Heaps In at least one case a plant of the tribe has been induced to develop this receptacle until the leaves of its scalelike covering have been enlarged and thickened and made succulent at their base, so that they are edible; the receptacle on which the flowerets grow being correspond- ingly developed. The flower that has thus been induced to put itself at the service of man and add to the delica- cies of his dietary is known as the artichoke. This plant is widely cultivated in southern Europe and is exceedingly popular there. In Italy, indeed, it occupies in some regions about the position in the dietary of the masses that the potato does in northern Europe and America. In this country, however, the artichoke has only somewhat recently begun to gain popularity. As the manner of its cultivation is better under- stood, it will doubtless gain wider vogue, for its leaf scales and pulpy receptacle are regarded as delicacies by epicures everywhere. I have worked extensively with the artichoke in recent years, beginning with the French ARTICHOKES This picture shows one plant of the thousands which are being improved, taken just before the buds were ready to burst. For table use the flowers are never allowed to open, as the bracts would then be practically inedible. But these are intended for breeding purposes and will, therefore, be allowed to come to maturity, and the best of them used for cross-fertilizing experi- ments, ist f as GARDEN SPECIALTIES 221 Globe artichoke and the Oval Brittany arti- choke in 1908; subsequently using also the Paris artichoke, a large green variety, and of the so-called Perpetual artichoke. The plants when grown from seed vary markedly in size and shape of the leaf as well | as in size, shape, and quality of the blossom buds. Some of the plants are thorny. The flowers, if allowed to come to maturity, differ little in color, though greatly in size. Some of the newest flower receptacles when fully matured open out to a breadth of twelve inches and more. But the flower bud is not permitted to mature to the point of opening when the artichoke is to be used as food. If it reaclies the stage when the blue flowerets begin to be visible, the head is alto- gether too old for eating. The object of culti- vating new varieties is not necessarily to increase the number of the flowers themselves, but in- creasing the size and the quality of the scalelike bud leaves and the receptacle. My work has been carried out along the usual lines of crossing and selection, and the results have been very satisfactory. Selection has also taken into consideration, as a matter of course, the succulence and especially the flavor of the edible portion. 222 LUTHER BURBANK The improved varieties have flower buds as large as a good sized fist, and are of excellent quality. When in full bloom they are sometimes a foot or more in diameter. ‘They are reproduced with reasonable certainty from seeds, but the method of propagation generally preferred is by the use of suckers which the plant puts out freely. Of course these suckers reproduce the qualities of the individual plant from which they are taken, as roots or grafting cions do in the case of other plants. | When it is understood by gardeners in general that the artichoke can be grown with comparative ease, and that it produces an abundant and never- failing crop of healthful, palatable, and nutritious food, this vegetable is sure to attain far greater st aa ech THE CARDOON The young stenis and leaves of the artichoke plant itself are sometimes eaten in Kurope. It is necessary to blanch them by covering, somewhat after the manner of celery. There is a modified form of the artichoke, known as the Cardoon, which is cultivated for the stems and leaves in- stead of for the flower buds. These are blanched by tying the tops of the leaves together and cov- ering the entire plant with straw, banked with earth. GARDEN SPECIALTIES 223 I have grown the cardoon, but have not experi- mented with it in the attempt to produce varia- tion, as the European cultivators have developed it to a very satisfactory stage. The plant is very little known in America, but is likely to be more extensively propagated when its merits are understood. THe SUNFLOWER ARTICHOKE Another member of the sunflower family is popularly known as the Jerusalem artichoke, the name having originated, it is said, in a Spanish nickname, amplified to suggest the relationship of the plant to the artichoke just described, which is generally spoken of as the Globe artichoke. The Jerusalem artichoke belongs to the genus Helianthus, of which there are numerous species, some of them growing wild in California. It is entirely distinct from the true artichoke, both in growth, appearance, and the purposes for which it is used. The part of this plant that is sometimes used as food is not the flower bud, but a tuber not very remotely suggestive of a potato. The plants of the sunflower tribe are variable, as is usual with plants represented by many species. Some of them bloom abundantly when only six to twelve inches in height, while others HALF OPENED ARTICHOKE BLOSSOM This is an individual blossom of the artichoke. The flower head has passed the period when it would have been in ideal condition for eating, but has not yet fully presented its stamens and pistils. The improvement shown in some of these crossbred artichokes is remarkable; and they are still wnder- going development. Some of the newer varieties produce blossoms four feet in circumference. The most wonderful of all is a perpetual variety of exquisite quality. GARDEN SPECIALTIES 225 grow to a height of ten to fifteen feet. They have very large, broad, heavy leaves, and some — of them produce sunflowerlike blossoms of enor- mous size. | Others have small, delicate, slender foliage, and produce small flowers. The flowers are yellow, the tubers are usually pink, but white and red varieties have been pro- duced in the past decade. Some members of the Helianthus tribe are perennials, but for the most part they are annuals. They are all easily grown on almost any soil, requiring little or no attention. The member of the tribe known as the Jerusalem artichoke is a somewhat variable plant, the tubers of which are chiefly used as food for stock, although sometimes used as a salad. My own work with the tribe has been for the improvement of both the flowers and the tubers. There is one of the annual sunflowers that has a flower quite often sixteen to twenty-four inches in circumference that, if well selected, comes per- fectly double, as double as the finest dahlia, pro- ducing a most brilliant yellow bloom abundantly. This I have worked on several years to make its flower uniformly double. Also I have worked with a large number of species of the tribe and have cultivated many field varieties collected in 8—Vol. 5 Bur, 226 LUTHER BURBANK Mexico, California, the Mississippi Valley, and nearly as far north as Hudson’s Bay. I have done a good deal of crossing and selec- tion among the seedlings to increase the grace of the plants and delicacy of bloom, and to make the silvery, graceful leayes of one species replace the rough, coarse leaves of another, There is no great difficulty in hybridizing the various species, especially if care is taken to wash away the pollen by the method described in the chapter on artificial pollination. But there is great difficulty in fixing a variety after it is formed. The hybrids tend to take on many forms, their variability in the second generation suggesting that of the gourd family. Of course this difficulty does not apply in the case of the artichoke, as this is propagated only from tubers, just as the potato is propagated. So any improved variety developed is fixed from the outset. There has not hitherto been enough demand for the plant in this country to stimulate the plant developer to work with it. But it is probable in the near future there will be renewed interest in certain less common garden vegeta- bles, comparable to that shown in recent years in the development of the orchard fruits, and in that case the Jerusalem artichoke is almost certain to ee ae GARDEN SPECIALTIES 227 receive recognition as a neglected vegetable that is worthy of being generally cultivated. | During the past few years, among thousands of crossbred seedlings, several have been produced which, though as productive as the older varie- ties, are delicious in flavor, while all those before known had a resinous, sunflower taste, not gen- erally relished. The matter of raising seedlings from the common cultivated varieties was found to be impossible, as they had been grown from tubers so long that the power to produce seed was wholly lost, yet a small amount of pollen was sometimes available for use on the wild species and from this these improved varieties were produced. Tue Lerruce TRIBE Doubtless the best known member of the Com- posite family under cultivation is the familiar lettuce. This plant has been so long under cultivation that it is impossible to trace it back to the original wild species and in token of its long cultivation, it is one of the most variable of plants. There are hundreds of varieties of lettuce described in catalogues, but those all quite naturally fall under two distinct groups—the cabbage or head lettuce and the cos or upright growing lettuce, the latter of which is mostly grown in cool, moist climates. A WILD ARTICHOKE It will be seen that this wild artichoke, in full bloom, is hardly three inches across. The flower head as a whole is strikingly suggestive of that of the thistle. This specimen gives a very good idea of the flower from which the modern improved artichoke has been developed. Contrast this thorny little flower with giant in the next. picture. GARDEN SPECIALTIES 229 The cos lettuce requires too much care in blanching, and in our dry American climate runs | up too quickly to seed:in warm weather. My work with the lettuce was done about ten or twelve years ago, when I experimented in the » endeavor to produce different forms, and _ at- tained a measure of success. In working with the cos lettuce the endeavor was to get a more solid head which would be a very tender, compact grower, and would not so quickly run to seed. The part of the lettuce that is eaten is, of course, the leaf, and the plant that runs to seed quickly develops a toughness of leaf fiber that impairs its value. In hybridizing the lettuce, my usual plan was to get two varieties to bloom as nearly as possible at the same time, and to pollenize by bringing the head of one and rubbing it against the flowerets of the other. The pollen may be removed with a dash of water, as already described, but there is always a measure of uncertainty in cross-pollen- izing composite flowers of such small size as those of the lettuce, as one cannot be sure in many cases that a certain amount of the pollen does not remain to effect fertilization of some neighboring plant, but any skillful operator should be able to know when a cross has been secured by the product. 230 LUTHER BURBANK It was found feasible to combine some desir- able qualities, but we did not succeed in combin- ing all the desired qualities in a single variety. There is greater variation as to flavor among lettuces than is commonly supposed. Of course, the different types are used for different pur- poses and at different seasons. ‘Those grown under glass must be compact growers, while those grown in the open may be permitted to develop larger heads. There are varieties of so-called perpetual lettuce which have been so educated that instead of running to seed they form new heads that can be cut again and again. As to all these matters there is room for great improvement, and there is opportunity for the plant experimenter whose experience justifies him in working with a somewhat difficult species to secure better varieties of this very popular salad plant than any at present on the market. DANDELION AND THISTLE There are other wild species of the Composite family, however, that offer greater inducements to the cultivator. One of these is the familiar dandelion, a plant usually regarded as a weed, but really having possibilities of usefulness. The dandelion is sometimes used as a green vegetable in the early spring by country folk in pia GARDEN SPECIALTIES 231 various parts of the United States, but it is per- haps nowhere cultivated except in France. In France, however, a successful attempt has been made to produce a dandelion that has much thicker, larger, and more abundant leaves than. those of the wild plant. This developed form is sometimes cultivated there and attains a certain value as a market vegetable. The great difficulty which stands in the way of cultivation of the dandelion is its exceeding pro- lifieness. ‘The heads of the flower will ripen even when the plant has been pulled up by the roots. It is even alleged that the plant will develop seed when the flowers are not pollenized. ‘This and the capacity to ripen seeds from the unopened bud makes the plant difficult to eradicate, and it becomes an almost intolerable pest in lawns. Should an attempt be made to cultivate the dandelion, therefore, the aim should be to develop the leaves at the expense of the flower. Doubt- less it would require long series of experimental efforts, but in the end it would probably be pos- sible to develop a dandelion that would produce an abundance of large, succulent leaves some- what as the lettuce does. Meantime the tendency to excessive flower production could be restricted. At least two other members of the Composite family that rank as weeds, and are generally held 232 LUTHER BURBANK to be obnoxious, deserve to be named as offering possibilities of usefulness if properly educated. These are the thistle (Cnicus) and the burdock (Lappa). That the thistle is a succulent herb that brows- ing animals have found palatable, is proved by its development of an elaborate system of pro- tective thorns. Of course, these thorns must be eliminated if the thistle is to be transformed into a garden vegetable. The thistles are not a whit more thoroughly cursed with thorns than their nearest relative the artichoke was when first brought under cultivation; and not more so than some of the recessive artichoke seedlings are at the present day, even when grown from the most carefully selected stock. I have grown various thistles extensively from seed, and although I have worked more especially for variations in color of the flower, yet I have paid attention also to the quality of leaf, and I am quite convinced that it would not be difficult to produce a spineless variety. Indeed these experiments have advanced far in that direction. The leaves and stalks of the plant may readily be developed so as to make a very palatable vegetable, comparable in its uses to spinach. GARDEN SPECIALTIES 233 It is known that some of the thistles are palat- able when cooked, tasting not unlike the dande- lion. There is a thistle raised in South America that is quite extensively used as food, and there is a California thistle with a variegated leaf that is sometimes eaten. ‘These two are certainly good as greens. Without a shadow of doubt their palata- bility could be increased by selective breeding, and this, with the removal of the thorns, would give us a new garden vegetable of a type at pres- ent rather sparsely represented. There is also an Old World thistle, known to the botanist as Cardwus marianus, that has found its way to this country, growing wild by the road- sides in California, that is sometimes used for cooking. The flower buds, roots, leaves, and leafstalks of this plant are edible—a very unusual exhibi- tion of versatility scarcely duplicated by any vegetable under cultivation. As this European thistle is not distantly related to the French arti- choke, and as it is edible even in its wild state, it would seem to furnish good material for the experiments of the plant developer. I have ob- served that cultivation and freedom from crowd- ing increase the size and succulent qualities of this plant enormously. In other words it re- sponds to cultivation readily, and have thought AN IMPROVED ARTICHOKE Contrast this mammoth blossom with the relatively insignificant blossom of the wild artichoke. The front of this wonderful flower is more than twelve inches across. It bears scant resemblance to the wild prototype; except, indeed, that the essential flower organs at its center have the same thistlelike appear- ance. So striking a modification has been brought about only through care- ful selection. pe er ae ing ae” 2 one ae GARDEN SPECIALTIES 235 many times of improving it, and even yet may undertake to do so. | I have done a good deal of work with a related naturalized weed from Europe and Australia, of — the genus Sonchus, known as the sow or milk thistle. The genus is closely related to the lettuce, and not distantly related to the artichoke. The two species with which I have worked are succulent weeds that vary greatly as to their degree of smoothness of leaves and stem. One of them is commonly known as the prickly milk thistle. But the two species are so crossed that it is hardly possible to find one in California now that is not hybridized. I have worked on the smooth-leaved hybrids, which are nutritious, making excellent greens. The plants can be raised with ease, and varieties were produced from these wild hybrids, by selection and crossbreeding, which were far superior to any specimens seen in the wild state. So marked was the improvement that I was somewhat disposed to introduce the developed smooth-leaved milk thistle as a garden vegetable, but hesitated to do so lest I should be blamed for introducing a weed. The cultivated plant retains its ability to produce a superabundance of seed; Which are drifted here and there by the wind. So 236 LUTHER BURBANK it might escape and become a pest. This of course is a danger that must be faced in the case of any wild plant brought into the garden. But it should not be forgotten that all of our present garden plants were at one time wild, and that the tendency to superabundant production of seed is likely to be Jost when the plant is pam- pered by cultivation. I have also worked with a very fine species of Sonchus from New Zealand. It was more diffi- cult to raise than the ordinary Sonchus. Possibly by combining the two a plant might be developed that would lack the objectionable qualities of undue hardiness and prolificness. At least the experiment is worth making. IMPROVING THE BuRDOCK As to the burdock, doubtless the very mention of its name suggests a highly objectionable weed. And, indeed, the common burdock, as it grows by the roadside, after it comes to maturity is not an inviting plant. And by its objectionable burs the plant is known and judged rather than by any other characteristic of the plant itself. But there are Japanese cousins of the burdock that are cultivated and have produced large and rather tender stalks and also long, fat roots which are highly prized as food. GARDEN SPECIALTIES 237 At an early stage, while these stalks retain their tenderness, they are not unpleasant to the European or American palate if, when partially cooked, the water that has extracted the bitter principle is removed and the cooking is continued with fresh water. The root is most used in Japan where it is considered one of their most valuable vegetables. The young, tender roots are offered for sale when about eight to twelve inches in length and an inch or more in diameter. They contain less of the bitter principle than do the leafstalks. The stalks themselves, at their edible stage, are about the size and form of an ordinary leafstalk of the rhubarb. Several of these Japanese bur- docks have been grown on my grounds, where the American burdock has also been cultivated more or less for the last twenty years. Great variation was noticed in the bitterness of the stalks and roots of the plants. Under cultivation they have never become troublesome weeds, as the common burdock has become in the eastern United States, responding readily to the effort to improve them, and if a systematic attempt were made to develop them along the right lines, a most valuable vegetable might be produced, which would be appreciated by those who live in a more favored climate. 238 LUTHER BURBANK The lines of selection should look to the pro- duction of a plant with large fine roots, or for a reduction of bitterness, which is the most objec- tionable quality of this plant. To anyone who has given little thought to the subject it may seem’more or less absurd to talk of the development of useful qualities in such weeds as these. But whoever has a clear concep- tion of the extent to which the vegetables now in our gardens have improved under cultivation will see possibilities in the thistle and the burdock that are not revealed to casual inspection. Poisonous plants like the tomato and the potato have been made wholesome within comparatively recent times. The thistle and burdock have no poisonous principle. Some species are wholesome and not unpalatable even in their wild state, and all that is required is to accentuate the good qualities the plants already possess to make them worthy of membership in the coterie of garden vegetables. It should not be forgotten that all of our present garden plants were at one time wild, and that to the wild we must look for countless new garden plants in the future. WINTER RHUBARB AND OTHER INTERESTING EXOTICS Tue Posstnuities WHEN PLANTs ARE BROUGHT FROM THE TROPICS HE story of the development of the Winter Rhubarb was told in an earlier chapter. It will be recalled that the plant came to me from New Zealand, and that in its original form it had a small and inconspicuous stalk and was of slight commercial value. It will further be recalled that by selective breed- ing I developed the stalk until it was of large size and of exceptional succulence. Meantime, the changed conditions of another hemisphere, with the transposition of seasons, disturbed the habit of bearing of the plant in such a way that it ultimately, by careful selec- tion, became practically a perpetual bearer, its time of greatest productivity, however, being the winter season, After the Winter Rhubarb had been developed and put upon the market, 239 240 LUTHER BURBANK the experiments were continued in selective breeding as well as in hybridization. The new rhubarb, as was stated in the earlier chapter, proved variable when grown from seed. _ The tendency to winter bearing, however, was pronounced, whatever variations the plant might show as to other qualities. In more recent years I have continued the development, and have produced new varieties of the Winter Rhubarb that differ so very widely from the original one as to merit introduction as separate varieties. The new rhubarbs have been developed by crossing the Winter Rhubarb with various races of ordinary rhubarb, in particular with the improved variety known as the Burbank Giant. The crosses were made mostly with the use of the Winter Rhubarb as the pistillate parent, but reciprocal crosses were also made. The prog- eny, as is often the case with hybrids, showed unusual vigor and rapid growth. The individuals varied as to many of their qualities, and I presently sorted out no fewer than thirty-six different types, all of them of gigantic size. The best of these has been introduced under the name of the New Giant Crimson Winter Rhubarb. WINTER RHUBARB 241 QUALITIES OF THE NEw RHUBARB _Not only does the improved Winter Rhubarb produce stalks at all seasons of the year, but these stalks are of such quality as to give this rhubarb a place apart among garden vegetables. _ The stalks have the pleasant taste of berries, and they altogether lack the tough, stringy, strong quality of the ordinary rhubarb. Meantime the stalks are as large as can be con- veniently handled and shipped, being two or even three feet in length, and from an inch to an inch and a half in thickness. The beautiful crimson color of the stalks adds also, greatly, to their attractiveness. An important quality of the improved Winter Rhubarb is that a plantation can be obtained from a few plants in a fraction of the time re- quired to stock it from older varieties. It is only necessary to dig up the plants in the fall, Sep- tember being the best month, dividing them with a sharp knife, cutting them into the smallest possible bits which have even a single bud and a fragment of a root. Each fragment will make a big, hardy, and productive plant in a twelvemonth; and it often happens that the smallest fragments will pro- duce the largest plants. 242 LUTHER BURBANK Another way to propagate the plant, if you do not wish to injure the old plantation, is to dig away the earth round the plant and cut out little V-shaped pieces of the roots, one or two inches long, with a sharp knife, including a bud. Each of these pieces will make a big plant in the course of the year, and the old plant will pro- duce larger stalks, though in somewhat reduced number, as the result of this treatment. In this way a plantation of the Giant Winter Rhubarb may be extended indefinitely without injury to the old crop. Of course, the new plants grown thus from pieces of root will reproduce absolutely the qualities of the original plant. If an attempt is made to extend the planta- tion by sowing seed, a good deal of variation must be expected, as this plant, like so many other cultivated ones, is not fixed for reproduc- tion from seed. In the matter of winter bear- ing, however, all the seedlings will reproduce the qualities of the parents. The seedlings may vary in size, quality, form of leaves, and somewhat as to color of stalks, and various minor points; but never in the matter of winter bearing. They will reach their time of fullest produe- tivity in early midwinter, two or three months WINTER RHUBARB 243 before the ordinary rhubarb begins to start into growth. The plants bear profusely the first year front bud cuttings or when raised from seed, and two generations a year from seed to seed can be raised by forcing in the California climate; but such forcing is not recommended. Unfortunately for cold climates, but very fortunately for mild ones, the Giant Rhubarb is not hardy enough to grow except in regions where the eucalyptus, the orange, and the fig can _ be grown out of doors. I have now produced hardier varieties, but it must be generally con- fined to warm climates, unless it is grown in the greenhouse. It is reported in the East that the | New Winter Rhubarb does not respond well to the forcing methods of the greenhouse, so it is not recommended for that purpose, although there should be no reason why it should not grow under greenhouse conditions, as a cool greenhouse may practically duplicate the conditions of California, where the plant is at its best. It will not stand soaking with water for any length of time, but in our California soil there is absolutely no loss from any cause, the New Giant Rhubarb being a much heavier producer than any other variety of the tribe. 244 LUTHER BURBANK ForRcING THE RHUBARB It is well known that the ordinary rhubarb may be forced in the greenhouse, and made to produce out of season by first freezing the roots. Curiously enough, after this treatment, the root develops its stalk, granted the right conditions of soil, almost equally well in the dark. Mention is made of this possibility of forcing the rhubarb by inducing abnormal conditions lest a statement of the earlier chapter in which the habits of the new variety are explained should be misinterpreted. I referred there to the impossibility of chang- ing the habits of the ordinary rhubarb, and per- manently extending its period of bearing, by merely altering the conditions of cultivation. It is of course possible to cause almost any plant to germinate out of season by greenhouse treat- ment. Such treatment, however, has no in- fluence on succeeding generations. The plant caused to grow out of season merely responds to the abnormal surroundings in which it is placed, and will immediately revert to the habits of its tribe when placed under nor- mal conditions, _ | But the crimson Winter Rhubarbs in all the perfected varieties produce their main crop in WINTER RHUBARB 245 the winter, and continue productivity through- out the entire year, because of the reappearance of a latent tendency to perennial bearing; and this revived tendency is thoroughly fixed. As already stated, all the plants retain this tendency when grown from seed, however they may vary in other regards. So there is no analogy what- ever between the winter-bearing habit of these new rhubarbs and the abnormal habit of winter bearing that may be forced on an individual plant of the old variety by growing it under hot- _ house conditions. Incidentally, the fact that the old rhubarb to be forced successfully in the greenhouse must be frozen, furnishes another interesting illustration of the value of a period of absolute rest or dor- mancy for a plant, and will suggest analogies with other cases of the same kind elsewhere cited. Apparently, the tissues of the plant root, having been frozen even for a brief period, have no way of estimating the length of time during which they have remained dormant, and thus are ready to respond to the climatic conditions about them when thawed out. So, finding themselves in the atmosphere of the springtime, they begin their regular springtime growth. In a sense, the artifice of the gardener may be said to fool the tissues of the plant, and to cause 246 LUTHER BURBANK it to take on an altogether abnormal activity. But, as just stated, this result applies only to individual plants, and no one thinks of develop- ing a race of Winter Rhubarbs in this way. Mrxep.. HEREDITIES The habit of perpetual bearing, as manifested by my perfected varieties of Winter Rhubarb, was explained as a development based on the comparatively recent residence of the ancestors of the plant in a tropical dlimate. The fluctuat- ing temperatures of the globe in successive ages— a time of tropical warmth being succeeded by an ice age—resulted in subjecting the plant at different periods to wide extremes of temperature. A vast number of species were in this way wiped out of existence. But those that survived developed powers of resistance which were in many cases subse- quently submerged or lost when the plants mi- grated to the tropics, or when tropical conditions prevailed; but which remained as latent in- fluences in the heredity susceptible of being brought out again under proper conditions of hybridization. Thus, in order fully to understand the anom- alous habit of the new Winter Rhubarbs, it is WINTER RHUBARB 247 necessary to recall that their immediate ancestors came from another hemisphere, and that traits of their latent heritage from remote ancestors both of tropical and subarctic habit were brought to the surface under influence of the new conditions of environment to which they were transplanted; and the further influence of new crosses and of constant selection through many generations. All in all, the new Giant Crimson Winter Rhubarb is a plant that presents points of in- terest for the student of heredity and for the practical plant developer no less than for the practical horticulturist. And for the latter— whose interests, of course, are those of the public at large—the new rhubarb has been declared to be “the most valuable vegetable production of the century.” The merit of that characterization we need not discuss; but no one who has seen the new Giant Rhubarb is likely to dispute that it is a plant of altogether exceptional interest. SOME EscuLENTs AND AN ANOMALOUS SOLANUM The rhubarb is one of the few plants in which the edible portion, for which the vegetable is prized, consists of the leafstalks. 248 LUTHER BURBANK There are a good many other vegetables, how- ever, in which the stalks of the leaf, along with the leaf itself, becomes a more or less valuable food product. Such, for example, are the cab- bage and its allies, the lettuce, and some others that we have already .considered, as well as the spinach and the celery. A familiar example of a plant whose stem furnishes a valuable food product if cut before it puts out its leaf stalks, is the asparagus. These plants have interest from the stand- point of the experimenter and all present certain opportunities for improvement. I have grown them all, and have done something in the way of selective breeding with most of them, but these experiments have been relatively insignificant as compared with my work in other lines, and there is little to record in connection with the work with either the spinach or celery that would have novelty or value. But with asparagus some remarkable results have been produced, and now I have perfected and widely distributed the new asparagus “Quality”; all are enthusi- astic in its praise. The methods of growing these plants are well known, and there is opportunity for develop- ment of new varieties either along the lines of selection or of hybridization. ~ WINTER RHUBARB 249 But the rules of selective breeding, as already given and repeatedly illustrated in connection with other vegetables, will sufficiently guide anyone who wishes to work with these. There is a tropical plant of a quite different order, however, to which I shall merely refer, because I have not experimented with it very extensively, but because work of considerable interest has been done with it by others, that will illustrate the possibilities of development of tropical plants even when grown in relatively inhospitable climates. The plant in question is the not unfamiliar Solanwm known as egg plant. Very interesting work in experimental breeding has been done with this relative of the potato and tomato by Professor Byron D. Hal- sted of the Experimental Agricultural Station of New Jersey. It involves no principles, how- ever, that have not been fully exposited in con- nection with other plants, and for details of the work the reader may be referred to Professor Halsted’s annual Bulletins. The Solanwm family has numerous other mem- bers well worthy of development that have been given scant attention. One of the most interesting of these obscure relatives of the potato and tomato and egg plant is the not unfamiliar, but seldom cultivated 250 LUTHER BURBANK plant known as the Ground Cherry, sometimes called Husk Tomato or Strawberry Tomato. THE INTERESTING GROUND CHERRY One of the little plants in question belongs to the genus Physalis, and it has numerous close relatives that inhabit various parts of the world. The Strawberry Tomato has been under cultiva- tion for a long time. The fruit is small, yellow, sweetish, and insipid. Other species have been received from Japan, and Korea, and South America, In general the fruit of some of these plants, especially P. Philadelphica, appears to be a curious misfit, the husk not being large enough to contain the fruit when ripe, and thus splitting open, exposes the fruit itself—a case where selection and culture have enlarged the fruit and not the envelope. | I have attempted through cultivation and selection to remedy this fault; and I have also crossed the various ground cherries. These hybridizing experiments not only were made with the common species and the foreign ones already mentioned, but also with other species from the west coast of Mexico, Arizona, South America, and Texas. But hitherto I have been unable to secure any striking results. WINTER RHUBARB 251 The plants grown from the seeds received from my collector, Mr. Walter Bryant, in west- ern Mexico, have husks of the most delightful fragrance. The aroma clings to the husk for months. It has no connection with the fruit itself. This form has proved the most difficult of all the ground cherries to germinate from seed, or to grow after the plants are pro- duced. It is well worthy of attention, even if grown solely for the fragrance of the husks. But in addition to this, the fruit is of good quality. It is about the size of the ordinary ground cherry, but a little more orange in color. Even at the present stage the fruit of the ground cherries are sometimes used for making pies, puddings, and preserves. The Peruvian species in particular produces a great quantity of superior fruit. There is sufficient variation between the different species to afford abundant material for development, and there is every reason to suppose that greatly improved vari- eties of the ground cherry could be developed, if sufficient time could be given. And the prospect of producing a really notable fruit from such a union—a fruit worthy of a relative of the potato, tomato, and sunberry —seems particularly good. 252 LUTHER BURBANK Improvine THE Passion FLOWER FOR Its Fruir There is another vine, known everywhere by name at least, and famed for its flowers, that has fruit possibilities that have been almost totally neglected. This is the celebrated Passion Flower, a plant represented by many species of tropical and subtropical habitat, of which two at least wander as far north as the southern por- tion of the United States. The name Passion Flower was given to these plants by the early Spanish missionaries, because they thought they saw in the blossoms an em- blem of the crucifixion. According to an early description of the blossoms, the filaments were thought to re- semble a blood-colored fringe suggesting the scourge; the column in the center was said to represent the cross; the filaments on which the pollen sacs were borne, three in number, represented nails; and a _ peculiar arrange- ment of floral organs encircling the top of the blossoms did service for the crown of thorns. To complete the picture, five spots or stains of the color of blood found on the petals were said to represent five wounds. WINTER RHUBARB 253 That the symbolism might lack nothing of completeness, it was noted that the leaves of the plant were shaped like the head of a lance or spear; and that there are round spots on the leaves that might be taken to represent the thirty pieces of silver, the price of the betrayal. The merits of this symbolic characterization need not concern us. But doubtless the name served to draw unusual attention to the flower, although the intrinsic merits of the flower itself are of a high order. As a hothouse vine, it has been cultivated everywhere, and is often re- garded as an important acquisition. Meantime it runs wild as a trailing vine in regions where the winters are not too severe; and in some regions it is so abundant as to be considered a weed, notwithstanding the beauty of its flower. The genus Passiflora, to which the Passion Flower belongs, is made up largely of vines and shrubs, but there are a few members that grow to the size of trees. The most beautiful flowering varieties are strictly tropical, and do not thrive in the northern climates. But, on the other hand, the species that bear the larger and more edible fruits are relatively hardy. Doubtless there is a casual re- lation between these facts. Possibly the tropical species do not find it difficult to propagate their FLOWER AND FRUIT ON THE SAME PLANT This interesting picture shows the Passion Flower bearing blossoms and green fruit and ripe fruit at the same time. Many different species of passion flower have been utilized in hybridizing experiments for its im- provement more especially as a fruit- producing plant. t otk dR ya ahi te WINTER RHUBARB 255 kind, and have not found it necessary to de- velop succulent fruits. In any event, it is fortu- nate from the standpoint of the plant developer — of the temperate zones that the fruit-bearing members of this particular tribe are the ones that are hardy enough for introduction in our climate. The common species of the southeastern United States, locally known as the Maypop, is so thrifty a plant that it becomes a very troublesome weed. It spreads in all directions by its underground rootstalks, and it roots very deeply. It is almost as difficult to eradicate as the perennial morning-glory. Deep plowing of the soil is about the only method of destroying it when it is once introduced. But this very thriftiness may become an advantage, once the plant has been sufficiently transformed to assume position as a valuable fruit bearer. This common Maypop was the plant with which my experiments in developing the fruit- ing possibilities of the Passion Flower began. But my interest soon extended to other species, Including the best Australian varieties of at least three species, and a number of new species from South America that were not named by my collector and have not been identified. 256 LUTHER BURBANK One of the most promising Australian species is known as Passiflora edulis. It produces a much larger quantity of fruit than the Maypop, but is less hardy than that plant. Several of the South American species are too tender to be - grown even in California. One of these, known as Passiflora quadrangularis, bears a fruit about the form and size of a small watermelon, yellow- ish green in color, with an attractive edible pulp. I have cultivated this species, but it has not entered to any important extent into my experi- ments, because of its extreme tenderness. The fruit of the species with which I have chiefly worked (P. edulis) is usually about the size of a hen’s egg. | The usual color is orange-yellow, but some varieties have a purplish tinge, and a purple pulp. Some of the species of the Southern Hemisphere are. recognized as producing valu- able fruit, particularly for combination with other fruits having a pleasant and unique flavor. But the fruit of the Maypop has seldom been considered worth picking. Experiments with the passion flowers began about 1895. It was not difficult to grow the plant from seeds received from different regions. It is only essential to keep the ground warm and moist. There is an astonishing difference in the WINTER RHUBARB 257 growth and vigor of the different seedlings. Moreover, some of the vines produce ten or even twenty times as much fruit as others, and the flavor of the fruit varies from exquisiteness to entire insipidity. Some specimens have a large amount of edible pulp while others are made up almost entirely of skin and seeds. The seedlings often bear during the second year, or at latest the third. The fruit does not ripen to advantage unless the weather is very warm. So from the outset those seedlings were se- lected that bore earliest in the season, attention being given also, as a matter of course, to the size and flavor of the fruit, and to the attrac- tive qualities of the flowers—for I had in mind a plant that would have not only great value as a fruit bearer, but also a recognized place among ornamental vines. The passion flowers show wide range of varia- tion, and thus furnished at the outset abundant material for the operations of the. plant developer. But in addition to this it was found easy to hybridize the different species, thus insuring fur- ther variation. The pollen sacs and the pistils are very prominent, and it is easy to effect pol- lenization by removing the prominent bright- 9—Vol. 5 Bur. 258 LUTHER BURBANK colored stamens from the flowers of one and dusting the yellow pollen on the prominent pis- tils of the other. Particular attention was given to hybridizing the Maypop with the Australian species, Passi- flora edulis, already referred to. I thought it would be possible to combine the good fruiting qualities of the Australian species with the hardi- ness of the American species. The fruit of the former has a thick, hard, shell covering the pulp, and a fragrant and highly flavored in- terior. ‘That of the latter has a thin, husklike covering, with a minimum amount of edible matter. Cross-fertilization was readily effected, and the experiment gives every promise of a success- ful issue. Several hundred hybrids that have not yet borne fruit are now under observation. Not all of these are hybrids of the Maypop and the Aus- tralian Passion Flower, but the seedlings of this cross at present appear to be most promising. The work has not been under way long enough to give anything like final results. But what has been done indicates that it is at least worth while to continue the experiments. Indeed, there seems to be little doubt of a thor- oughly successful and satisfactory issue. WINTER RHUBARB 259 Possibly it may be necessary to bring other species into the combination through further hybridization, but the material at hand is ample, and the fact that almost every variation may be found among the seedlings gives full assurance that if the experiment is carried out with suffi- cient zeal, it will be possible to assemble the best qualities of the different species in a new variety. The renewed vigor given by the combining of species from different parts of the world has tended greatly to increase the size of both the plants themselves and their fruit, and the quality of the fruits already secured leaves it scarcely open to doubt that the final product will be of value. THE CAMASSIA—WILL IT SUP- PLANT THE POTATO? AND OTHER TUBERS OF VALUE FOR F'oop OR the most part plants are cultivated | Fhe a single quality. If a plant produces beautiful flowers, we do not usually demand that it shall also produce valuable fruit. We do not ask that a plant which produces a valuable fruit like the tomato shall also produce tubers like the potato. It is only by accident rather than by special design or selective breeding on the part of man that a certain num- ber of plants, notably some members of the rose family, produce beautiful blossoms and delicious fruits as well. The apple tree in full bloom is indeed a beau- tiful object, but the apple would probably be raised quite as generally as it is if its blossoms were altogether unattractive. The Japanese, to be sure, have developed the blossoms of their fruits, but in so doing they have quite usually neglected the quality of the fruit itself. 261 262 LUTHER BURBANK And as to garden vegetables, about the only member of the clan that is cultivated for its flower as well as for its edible product is the Pink Chive that I have recently developed. There exists a tribe of plants, however, of - which we have hitherto made no mention, that possesses qualities of flower bearing of a high order, combined with the capacity to produce roots of such quality of edibility as to suggest competition with our best tuber bearers, including the potato itself. These plants are certain wild members of the lily family that have no colloquial name except that given them by the Indians; a name that has been variously transcribed as Quamash and Camass. F'rom-this name the botanist has devel- oped the generic title Camassia. ‘The not alto- gether unappropriate name of wild hyacinth is sometimes given: the species that grows in the western United States. But it will be most convenient in speaking of the tribe to adopt the generic name of Camassia, in lieu of a better. The various species of camassia grow wild in rich moist meadows and along small streams. All the species are hardy. 'The leaves of the plant are usually lance-shaped, about three-quarters of an inch in width, and of length varying according to THE CAMASSIA 263 the fertility of the soil, usually from eight to six- teen inches. The flower stalk in ordinary soil | varies with the different species from eighteen inches to nearly four feet in height. The flowers are usually purple, blue, or rarely white. In some of the new hybrid species the color has changed to rose, and in others to various shades of crimson and yellow. All the camassias are bulbous, of course, like other members of the lily family. But there is a great difference in the size of the bulbs among the different wild species, and, as will appear presently, there is enormous variation when the different species are hybridized. HYBRIDIZING THE CAMASSIAS Experiments on a large scale with the Camassia have been carried out for more than twenty years, including work with five species. So far as I am aware, no one had undertaken to improve any of these until my experiments were instituted, about 1890. The first work was done with a species known as Camassia Leichtlinii, which grows abundantly on Vancouver Island. Considered as a flowering plant this is the finest of the varieties. It grows almost altogether in crevasses of rocks, but it produces very attractive large, deep purple flow- A BED OF SELECTED CROSS- BRED CAMASSIAS The camassia is, as a glance at this picture will show, a plant having no small measure of interest as a producer of ornamental flowers, but it also has an edible bulb which, though small, is especially palatable and nutritious, even more so than the potato. er al ae — ed se egesee ie ome se sks pi fe = * a Lek, helenae ag ve 2, 4 aur, a The * Re THE CAMASSIA 265 ers, with wide petals. I introduced many years ago a modified variety of the species that was somewhat dwarfed as to leaf and stem, but in which the flowers had been greatly enlarged, the petals broadened and the color changed to a pure dark blue. As these experiments continued, my interest in the camassia increased, and attention was given to the bulb of the plant as well as to the flower and I soon began working with another species, the Camassia Cusicku, which has relatively large bulbs; and with another of the well-known native species, Camassia esculenta, the bulbs of which are much smaller, but of superior edible quality. Most of the work in hybridizing and selective breeding has been done with the three species just named, but I have also raised somewhat exten- sively two other species, known as C. Hovwellii and C. Fraseri, as well as a great number of wild varieties of all the different species from British America, Washington, Oregon, California, Ne- vada, Idaho, and western Canada. From the out- set, individual plants were selected of each species and varieties that were the best to be obtained. Here, as so often elsewhere, it was possible to produce considerable improvement merely by selecting individual plants that had the most 266 LUTHER BURBANK desirable qualities of flower and bulb, destroying the inferior ones. From the outset careful attention was paid both to the flowers and to the bulbs, as it was de- sired to produce plants that would be ornaments in the flower garden and at the same time would grow enormous bulbs that would make them valuable acquisitions to the vegetable garden. Having secured the best representatives of each species and variety by selection, an exten- sive series of hybridizing experiments were commenced. It is a relatively simple matter to hybridize the different camassias and all the species seemed to combine quite readily. The characteristics shown by the hybrids are those that experience with other plants led one to expect. In the first generation, there is rel- ative fixity, and the greater or less dominance of one parent or the other. In the second genera- tion, the hybrids break up into numerous forms, varying widely as to color of leaves and flowers, height of stalk, and size of flowers, as well as in form and size and quality of bulbs. Some of these hybrids of the second generation produced bulbs smaller than those of their progenitors. THE CAMASSIA 267 But others grew bulbs of enormous size. Even to one who is accustomed to observe the striking variations that are produced through hybridiza- tion, it was surprising to see the extraordinary impetus given to the bulbs of the camassia by the union of different species. The bulbs of the common edible species, C. esculenta, are relatively insignificant, usually growing about one-half to three-quarters of an inch in diameter. The C. Cusickii produces the largest bulb of all, but it is large only in a relative sense, being usually little over an inch in diameter and two inches in length. But among the second generation hybrids were some that produced bulbs three and a half inches across and four or even five inches in length. The difference was about that between an English walnut and a large turnip. In viewing these gigantic bulbs, sprung thus from dwarf ancestors, one was reminded of the gigantic hybrid walnut trees that came of the union of Persian and California walnuts; of the mammoth Phenomenal berry; of the Giant Ama- ryllis; and of sundry other hybrids that were stimulated to excessive growth of stem or fruit or flower by the union of parents of just the right degree of affinity. 268 LUTHER BURBANK FLOWER AND BuLB IMPROVED SIMULTANEOUSLY Meantime pains had been taken to cross dark flowers with dark flowers, and white ones with white, and pink with pink, wher- ever possible, so as to intensify the various types. As already noted, there is a pronounced tend- ency to variation even among the wild species, all the camassias sometimes producing pale greenish, almost white, flowers. These, if grown from seed and carefully selected, can be changed to snowy white. Some of the variations secured bear flowers that are truly white, while others that are called white are really of a pale greenish hue. The seedlings of these greenish white ones tend ordinarily to produce blossoms that revert to the pale blue color of the species from which they were derived. So the production of a truly white camassia required continued selection—a process of grad- ual intensification. But of course hybridizing greatly facilitated this process. It also gave opportunity for selec- tion with regard to flowers having broad petals— narrowness of petal being one of the original de- fects of the camassia as a flower. Moreover, a number of extra petals have been added in some THE CAMASSIA 269 cases, and it is only a matter of time until double camassias will be produced. All along the line, then, the flowers of the camassias have been improved by selecting from among the best of the hybrids. Twenty thousand bulbs have been under observation at the same time, and improvement has been rapid. In the end, the camassia will prove to be an ornamental plant of distinct value, highly prized for its flowers. But it will be prized also for its bulb, which, in the developed and selected hybrids, is assuming satisfactory proportions, as already pointed out, and which has undoubted food value, surpassing the potato even, both as to nutriment and flavor. And of course the work of development in this direction is only at its beginning. The results already attained justify the expectation that the bulbs of the developed camassias will be of really notable size, constituting a garden vegetable of very exceptional food value. The wild camassias generally produce but few offsets. But some of the hybrid ones not only produce numerous offsets, but tend to divide like the garlic, sometimes making five or six enormous bulbs in a season. Of course this habit has been carefully encouraged among the seedlings, as this rapid multiplication will be of obvious importance A WIDE RANGE OF VARIATION Here are camassia bulbs, small, large, and medium; thick, thin and spindle- shaped. Obviously there is plenty of material for selective breeding. Where such variation occurs, still greater variation will be shown in some of the crossbred descendants. Moreover the flavor of one, the form of another, and the size of a third may be combined in a single descendant; and all the good qualities may then be accentuated through selective line breeding. The camassia promises to furnish a very valuable addition to the rather small list of edible bulbs. Bene is manera eer o Ha Nive eA Spree ERT Set THE CAMASSIA 271 when the camassias are grown either for bulbs or for flowers. : I have also successfully hybridized some of the camassias with certain of their relatives, the squills (genus Scilla), of which I have imported many species from South America. The two tribes hybridize readily. The hybrids showed conspic- uous changes in the bulb. The outside covering of the bulb of the squill is whitish, while that of the camassia is usually darker. The hybrids pro- duced more compact bulbs of a lighter color than those of their maternal parent, the camassia. But there are all gradations in the bulbs as to color and other qualities. I have worked quite extensively also with the scillas, but with reference solely to the develop- ment of the flowers, with results that will be out- lined in another connection. Here reference is made to them only as suggesting that these plants may be of value in introducing new qualities into the strains of hybrid camassias, stimulating fur- ther variation, and thus giving opportunity for betterment both of bulb and flower. It is too soon to predict just what place these improved camassias may take in the vegetable garden. But the experiments have progressed far enough to show that the species has hitherto unrecognized possibilities. 272 LUTHER BURBANK Meantime another class of plants that is almost equally attractive from the standpoint of florist and market gardener is an anomaly that must make wide appeal to the horticulturist. There are twenty or more species of plants be- longing to the lily family wild along the Pacific Coast that make up a group which the botanist classifies under the generic name Brodica. There are allied plants in South America, re- garding the precise classification of which there is some difference of opinion. But for the purpose of the horticulturist the entire group may be ranked under the name of Brodiwa. 'The plants have not been extensively cultivated until re- cently, and they have received no popular name. The different species vary greatly in form, size, and arrangement of the flower. The color of the flower is usually either blue or rose or purple, though sometimes white. There is also a crim- son-flowered climbing species, known as Brodica volubilis, which also rarely becomes white. CROSSING THE BRODIAAS This climbing species has been crossed with the species known as Brodica capitata, and various others. Some of these crosses produce most beau- tiful flowers intermediate between the parents. Unfortunately the best hybrids were destroyed ——— THE CAMASSIA 273 by gophers before opportunity was had to save the seed. The interest of the brodizas in the present connection hinges on the fact that the plants have bulbs or corms that when cooked are very acceptable as food. Several of the species, especially the Brodica lactea, are relished by the Indians, and are often dug and eaten by children. The bulbs of some species contain a very high percentage of starch, probably greater than that of the potato. I have worked on the Brodica lactea to in- crease the size of the bulbs. When growing wild the bulbs are only about half an inch in diameter. By selective breeding, varieties have been orig- inated that will produce bulbs two inches or more in diameter. The plants can be grown almost as thickly as lawn grass, and it is probable that the yield per acre of the bulbs could be made to equal a good crop of potatoes though at a greater expense. In developing the brodiza for this purpose, it would be well to search carefully for bulbs that grow to unusual] size in the wild state—there is considerable variation in this regard. The brodiza is well worth cultivating for its flowers alone, and it would appear that the plant offers possibilities of combining flower produc- tion with the production of valuable food. Un- CAMASSIA BLOSSOMS It will be seen that the camassia has a really attractive flower. This is an unusual qualification for a plant that grows in the vegetable garden. There are several species of camassia available for purposes of the plant developer. OO EE Ee THE CAMASSIA 275 fortunately, however, there is a complementary relation between the seed and the bulbs, and in order to secure bulbs of the largest size, it is neces- sary to remove the seed stalk before blossoming time. Whether cultivated for flowers or for bulbs, the brodizas are very interesting plants that give great promise of improvement under the hands of some careful experimenter. It is a little difficult to cross them. I have pro- duced many hybrids, however, and occasional hybrids are found where two wild species are growing in the same neighborhood. They all bear seed abundantly, though it takes three, four, or even five years from seed before they bloom. They can be grown by thousands on each square yard of ground, appearing almost as thick as grass on a well-kept lawn. In the same species there is a good deal of variation in the form and size of the flower. On the heights of the Sierras, the Brodica lactea grows only a few inches high, whereas in the valleys it grows to a height of eighteen inches or two feet. Along the alluvial creek banks Brodica laxa grows very large and tall, with handsome clusters, while on the mountain sides it is dwarfed. r 276 LUTHER BURBANK Even plants of the same species in the same locality vary widely as to size of flower. Brodica capitata grows abundantly along the roadsides, and especially in grain fields. It blooms and produces seed before the grain is cut. Brodica terrestris has a stem so short that the flowers almost rest on the ground. The blossom is just the color of a blue violet, and the clusters may be mistaken for violets at a little distance. In other localities the B. terrestris bears flowers some of which have a white stripe. Sometimes half the blossom may be white, the other part deep blue. Sometimes five or six blossoms will be blue, and a single one white. In other cases the proportions are reversed. I have not observed any in the wild state that could be called pure white, but by cultivation and selection pure white varieties have been produced. I have worked extensively on the Brodica capitata, the species just mentioned as growing in the wheat fields. On a poor dry soil this plant grows about two feet in height, and on long, straight, slender, wiry stems. But on good soil, especially in the wheat fields, it sometimes grows to the height of three or four feet, or even more, bearing a much larger cluster of blossoms. In looking over a field of brodiwas of this species, one may expect to find one in ten thou- THE CAMASSIA 277 sand or perhaps one in twenty thousand that is almost white. Seedlings raised from these pro- duce a variety of flowers, white, pale or dark blue, and striped; with a constant tendency to revert to the blue when first taken under cultivation. By selection and reselection strains are pro- duced which invariably come white, and by the same process varieties are produced with flowers twice as large as the ordinary, also making the flower head larger, and the plant a much more rapid multiplier from the bulbs. From all this it will appear that the brodiwa is a very interesting plant. As already suggested, it well deserves the attention of some careful experimenter, who might develop certain strains for flowers and others for bulbs. Plants that are of interest both to the lover of flowers and to the vegetable gardener have exceptional claims on the plant developer. OTHER NEGLECTED LILIES There are two allied tribes of plants known as Bloomeria and Brevoortia, respectively, that are closely related to the brodiwa, each of which is of interest. The brevoortia is usually called the Floral Fire- cracker, from its green, crimson, and yellow flow- 278 LUTHER BURBANK ers. These plants have been grown extensively from seed, to produce new varieties, but the ex- periments were carried out only to the extent of increasing the yellow and crimson colors. I have grown the Bloomeria aurea also exten- sively and have made minor improvements in it through selection. ‘The plant has a bulb like the brodiawa, growing deep in the earth in dry, sandy places. In the wild state the stalks vary in height, and there is also a slight variation in the color of the flower. So there is opportunity for selective breeding. Moreover, judging from physiological characteristics, the plant should cross readily with the brodiza, although I have not attempted to make the cross. It is, however, certain that improved varieties might be obtained by hybridization. There is a bulbous plant called Alstrameria. that is botanically related to the Amaryllis rather than to the true lilies, which offers possibilities of tuber improvement. The plants are natives of western South America. I grew seedlings and hybrids by the ten thousand for several years, and became convinced that if the roots and tops could be taught to grow in a more compact form this would become a very popular flower, and perhaps also a very valuable food plant, as the roots are sometimes eaten and are quite palatable and THE CAMASSIA 279 nutritious. The species known as A. Chilensis, A. pulchella, and A. Brasiliense, and subse- quently on a large number of new species from Chile were grown for combination and selection. A great variety of colors and combinations occur in the hybrid forms that may be fixed by selection. A more hardy strain with improved flowers and more compact growth should be sought. At one time I crossed plants of this genus with the California lily (Lilium pardalinum) and had several hybrids, but the root and the bulb did not make a good combination. The plants bloomed the second year, then all died. The hybrid blossom was much smaller than that of the lily, and resembled that of both parents in being speckled and in its combination of colors. These hybrids produced no seed. The long, slender, white tubers of the Alstre- meria Chilensis are edible. This plant grows in very dry soil, and is peculiarly adapted to some of the California soils and climates. It is at present too tender for growth in the eastern United States, but it is possible that through hybridization and selection it may be rendered hardy, and in that event this may also become a valuable garden vegetable. THE WILD CAMASSIA This is one of the wild camassias that furnish material for experiments. A comparison with later pictures will suggest the measure of improvement that has already been attained in connection with the flower. Swucceed- ing pictures will show the response that has been made by the bulb. THE CAMASSIA 281 Tue Epau Potato The lilies and their allies are not by any means the only wild plants with bulbs or roots that are edible and of course susceptible of improvement There are several plants of different fam- ilies that offer noteworthy possibilities in this direction. For example, tuberous varieties of the genus Carum, relatives of the caraway, growing on the Pacific Coast, especially toward the North- west, the roots of which are relished by the Indians. One species in particular, called the epau potato, is dug in great quantities in the fall and stored for winter use. The roots are small, almost like those of the Ranunculus, and are similar in form to the roots of the dahlia, though very much smaller. They have a sweet, aro- matic, and pleasant flavor. In different locaii- ties they vary widely in size and quality. There are places where the plant grows almost like grass, so that hardly a shovelful of dirt can be turned over without exposing numerous roots, but generally on the hardest and most unprom- ising soil. When brought under eUicasien, the epau potato appears susceptible to the influences of 282 LUTHER BURBANK its new surroundings. The roots increase greatly in size and succulence. The seeds and roots of this plant have often been collected, and I have from time to time had _ seeds sent me from many localities during the past fifteen years. The best seeds came from Idaho. Plants grown from seed sent from Idaho developed to four feet in height, produc- ing roots three to four times as large as most of the California Carums, and seeding quite as abundantly. By selecting individual roots the species known as Carum Gairdneri improved quite rapidly, and when the blossoms are removed, so that no plant energy is required for the produc- tion of seeds, the roots are much larger. This is an interesting compensatory effect that illus- trates the close correlation between the different parts of a plant, and in particular the reliance of the roots on the leaf system. There are, as already stated, several species and numerous varieties of the plant that could — be used for hybridizing purposes, and the tend- | ency to variation could thus be accentuated. A very large number of plants can be growi.: on a small piece of ground, and if the roots could — be developed even to one fourth the size of those — of the carrot, this would prove a very valuable — THE CAMASSIA 283 addition to the list of garden plants. The roots are not only nutritious, but have exquisite flavor even when raw; and are improved by cooking. The plant is well worthy of improvement and general cultivation. The lilies and their allies are not by any means the only wild plants ~ with bulbs or roots that are edible and susceptible of improvement— there are many noteworthy posst- bilities in this direction. Pieler Ne ied aA HILD er ona OD {a was ~ 6 a an . “Gai mince ON eR eed) Sea wey i DATE DUE ~ VY NQZ RS /Y tes) ’ J, By anel® / — Y YX ieee Af a% NN UNIVERSITY oF ronowr LIBRARY wea trained to yee Ty ais) i re tPraineu vv - rW Y \VW NG KV Wea 4 WR ee CARDS OR SLIPS FROM THIS POCKET oF} \\\\V¥ q 2 a y WS Sek . RRR AVAKE LAN WA AN . * 2 | ~ AN SERN he SAS . EN i AQAA LENA Ag ~ AN VA \ ANN XX \ WS SE \ WAS NY ° » . ROY . SR \ WS \ \ S : SAR \ | \ \ Os Aw SANS : : \ VERRAN AN NY . SSN . SSAA LAY RAY WRN SX AX WR LANG \\ AK A AN NY SAN RAV SS OO WAN WS NS x AX A “NS —— AN \\ RN A \ RAY . \\ AN NAG =e =e ye AN . \\ \ \ \ MY \ RAY AY \ \\ SS NN WS WX \ WY ROY ‘ \N AN \\ y Z Ae Z b Z ign bs ‘% Le eaias es Oe a oe a. a PPE PDA ALA GEE LE ee ee ee —_ Oa ee * \ * ee > r me . *. OMA ee ne \ . SS ee :