a i U.S. Arm
Zar | \ | Coast Eng es Ctr
if ’ nent } MP 2- 69
| occ” otioty/ |
oat RADIOISOTOPIC .
ica caresses
SAND TRACER STUDY
POINT CONCEPTION, CALIFORNIA
PRELIMINARY REPORT ON ACCOMPLISHMENTS
JULY 1966 — JUNE 1968
by
David B. Duane and Charles W. Judge
MISCELLANEOUS PAPER NO. 2- 69
MAY 1969
U. S. ARMY, CORPS OF ENGINEERS
COASTAL ENGINEERING
RESEARCH CENTER
G-6
450
U3 This document has been approved for public release and sale;
its distribution is unlimited.
Reprint or re-publication of any of this material
shall give appropriate credit to the authors, the Atomic
Energy Commission, and the Coastal Engineering Research
Center.
Limited free distribution of this publication within
the United States is made by the U. S. Army Coastal En-
gineering Research Center, 5201 Little Falls Road, N.W.,
Washington, D. C.
The contents of this report are not to be used for
advertising, publication, or promotional purposes.
Citation of trade names does not constitute an official
endorsement or approval of the use of such commercial
products.
The findings in this report are not be be construed
as an official Department of the Army position unless
so designated by other authorized documents.
NIN
nny
OW Os
DOCUMENT
COLLECTION
mG
i
0 0301 9
NNN
RADIOISOTOPIC
SAND TRACER STUDY
POINT CONCEPTION, CALIFORNIA
PRELIMINARY REPORT ON ACCOMPLISHMENTS
JULY 1966 — JUNE 1968
by
David B. Duane and Charles W. Judge
MISCELLANEOUS PAPER NO. 2- 69
MAY 1969
U. S. ARMY, CORPS OF ENGINEERS
COASTAL ENGINEERING
RESEARCH CENTER
This document has been approved for public release and sale;
its distribution is unlimited.
wo . a we _ a Le
Ss ‘ib 9 pt | han eae JW bten
Brie ry a
’ :
aaa ee 2 on ee Ba pe Adie OHA
met ia fife -
eesaifiov' 40 200 Noi , |
qvipe JAVIOVS JATE: Aes a
wat visa be Onaga
ales bao saneta wild se nila or) wi By
| — cana iinee 7
il
ABSTRACT
The purpose of the_Radioisotopic Sand Tracer (RIST) study is to
develop and use radioactive tracer methods for research in sand movement
and littoral processes. Research objectives include determination of
suitable radioactive isotopes, development of mobile and stationary radi-
ation detectors, and development of suitable handling and survey programs.
Concurrent with these objectives, studies of sediment transport around
the Point Conception headland and of the mechanics of littoral transport
are being conducted. Methods developed by this program have direct appli-
cation to engineering design of such works as harbor development and beach
erosion prevention, and quasi-military application such as the location
of radioactive or other toxic materials.
To date, sand grains indigenous to the study area have been labeled
with xenon-133 which does not adversely affect the hydraulic properties
of the sand. Various devices and methods of employing the tagged sand
have been studied. A mobile detector system using cesium iodide crystals
and housed in a "ball" towed behind an amphibious vehicle detects the
quantity and areas of radiation. Computer programs have been developed
to correct and plot radiation data.
A field test of equipment and principles at Cape Kennedy, Florida,
was successful. Additional field tests were at Surf and Point Conception,
California. These tests included isotope distribution, sediment analysis,
offshore profiles, and oceanic and atmospheric environment monitoring.
In addition, model tests were conducted in the Shore Processes Test Basin
at the Coastal Engineering Research Center (CERC) to compare high and low
specific activity xenon, and to study beach development and movement under
the controlled conditions of a hydraulic laboratory.
The data density is sufficient to support tentative conclusions
regarding offshore sediment movement in the Point Conception area.
Additional field tests will extend the survey from the beach through the
surf zone. In addition, development of instruments and field programs
will continue in order to permit their routine use by technicians and
field crews.
FOREWORD
For 35 years the U. S. Army Corps of Engineers' Coastal Engineering
Research Center (CERC) and its predecessor, the Beach Erosion Board, have
been studying coastal phenomena. While -interest at CERC extends from
wave generation in the deep ocean to the original source of sediment at
the headwaters of streams in the high mountains, the practical limitation
of its work is the coastal area. The coastal area can be considered to
extend from the bluffs or sand dunes immediately landward from the present
position of the shoreline to water depths representing the outer limit of
bottom material movement by wave action.
lil
The overall direction of the RIST study program rests with CERC.
The program was initiated by N.E. Taney, formerly of the CERC staff, with
the full cooperation and assistance of G. Magin, Jr., formerly with the
Division of Isotopes Development, U. S. Atomic Energy Commission. Since
November 1966, responsibility for the program direction has rested with
D. B. Duane who succeeded N. E. Taney as Chief of the Geology Branch.
This report was prepared by D. B.Duane and C. W. Judge under the general
supervision of G. M. Watts, Chief of the Engineering Development Division.
This report was prepared as part of Contract AT (49-11)-2988 (as
modified) between the Atomic Energy Commission and CERC. Other partici-
pants in this continuing multi-agency study are the Oak Ridge National
Laboratories of the Atomic Energy Commission; U. S. Navy Pacific Missile
Range; U. S. Air Force (Western Test Range, First Strategic Aerospace
Division); U. S. Army Corps of Engineers Los Angeles District office; NASA
(Nuclear Systems and Space Power Division) and the State of California
(Department of Water Resources).
The authors wish to thank P. J. Mellinger and O. M. Bizzell of the
Division of Isotope Development, Atomic Energy Commission; F. N. Case,
E. H. Acree, and H. R. Brashear of the Oak Ridge National laboratory;
T. B. Kerr of the Nuclear Systems and Space Power Division, National
Aeronautics and Space Administration; R. R. Baray of the First Strategic
Aerospace Division, Vandenberg Air Force Base; M. M. Richman, U. S. Air
Force Western Test Range, Vandenberg Air Force Base; Colonel W. H. Lee,
U. S. Air Force Eastern Test Range, Patrick Air Force Base; E. Rhodes,
U. S. Navy Pacific Missile Range, Point Mugu, California; R. Angelos of
the Department of Water Resources, State of California; and Colonel James
Irvine, Jr., Corps of Engineers Western Area Office, Vandenberg Air Force
Base. Appreciation is particularly expressed to J. M. Bittner, T. A.
Bertin, and the various field crews and technical personnel of the Los
Angeles District without whose cooperation this project would not have
been possible.
At the time of publication, Lieutenant Colonel Myron Dow Snoke was
Director of CERC; Joseph M. Caldwell was Technical Director.
NOTE: Comments on this paper are invited. Discussion will be published
in the next issue of the CERC Bulletin.
This report is published under authority of Public Law 166, 79th
Congress, approved July 31, 1945, as supplemented by Public Law 172,
88th Congress, approved November 7, 1963.
Section
alee
Bs
30
Section
ON Wal dG) [No |
Section
Section
a0
Qo
Bre
Section
CONTENTS
Iho, TPINOIGISVAME Gg) 9 G0 16 oO 6 Ha 16! oO 0 Oo ol 0 Oo 9
Introduction SURGE NEG oan oe RGN Bc ‘ aes
SECS eiacl Oljeeuswes « 6 oo G@ 6.0 6 6 56 0.0 © 5 0 oO 6
PREVA OUSMNESCATCIM station Blcitael | leyatve ieleekel ices Mace
II. ISOTOPES SELECTION, TAGGING TECHNIQUES AND INSTRUMENTS .
Studies of Isotopes and me OF Phen
IGA Sewsaeay WSC 6 6 4 0 O06 040 Oo 6
Mobile Detector :
On-Board Data eoieecion Speen 6 fob 6 WS pod eh le 6 5
WAL G@Ulel, Spo OHA G LNSMMALTOMASTANG)) oboe on! Golo) ooo Md oo 6 9 0 OG
CEmjowehgero IIA SOE 6 9G 6 6 6 6 9 oO. 0-6 6 6 4.0.0 0 0 0-0 0
TEIEIE = APTERIAD) JANI) IWALOVAIONRNG “ABINSHES)| 9 GG iG Go Oo) oo
General Program Design . ofS) iG toy oN toca cor lone OS Soe IG. “to
Cape Kennedy, Florida - Fcoecsia "1967 a ea Ee ee Re Ser mes, eo
Surf, California (Vandenberg Air Force Base) - June 1967
Deine Conception, California, November-December 1967... .
CERC (Shore) Processes Test pBasim, May 1968) ei. ia...
HINVial) Se PROG RAMG) SUMMA VES 0a) ots ey pty ierere A oyal amulet aca irra ds
Handwaremandmrro came) Cyv.elopment a emicnemenl cj mnsiueuie ictn tenuis
Radiation Safety .... eye hret evi es temo) are
Field and Laboratory Testes
Wo URNUIRUS, OBSIHOIINS) <6 6 6 6 510.6 6 6 6 56 6 G66 00 6-0 O
IIMA U Ie (CANAD) 5 GG Goo) 6 OG oo 6 6
ISHESINIEOGRUNEEN, 6 6 6 6 0 0 0 0 © 0 OO oO 166 O16 6
APPENDIXES
2g
cca
80
Appendix A Part 1. Leaching and Abrasion Studies on Beach Sands Tagged
with Radionuclides by the NRDL Water-Glass Procedure.
Part 2. Xenonated Sand: Leaching and Abrasion studies.
Part 3. Bibliography on Radiotracer-Tagging Sand and
Sediments for Study of Mass Transport in Fluvial
and Marine Environments.
Appendix B Towing Characteristics of an Underwater Radiation
Detection Vehicle
Appendix C RIST Status Report by Isotopes Development Center
Appendix D Radiation Data Reduction and Plotting Program - RAPLOT
Appendix E Sediment Analysis Tables
Appendix F Radiation Exposure Record
ILLUSTRATIONS
Figures
Ake Point Conception, California. Vertical aerial view
from 10,000 feet
Ze Map showing Point Conception study area
35 Sieve Analysis and Rapid Sediment Analyzer Data
Ihe Comparison of Xenonated Sand with Untreated Sand from
the same area
Die Cylindrical Hopper for emplacing tagged sand .
6. Clamshell Device for emplacing tagged sand .
We Mobile Detector "Ball" and LARC-V
8. Open Mobile Detector "Bali"
),, 400-Channel Pulse-Height Analyzer
ALONG, On-Board Programmed Interrogator
dake LARC-XV Amphibious Vehicle with LARC-V .
12. DM-40 Cubic Autotape Interrogator
aLS}o Detector Vehicle at Cape Kennedy, Florida
Wh. Chart of Point Arguello - Point Conception area
alSy Aerial view of Surf, California
UG Beach at Surf, California
AL < Bathymetric Chart, Surf (Vandenberg Air Force Base)
vi
ala
12
14
14
16
18
18
18
19
Za.
28
Sil
32
32
33
Figure
18, Maclese Cie Pideraines, Swear, Celsistopadmey sy 4 4 6
One Beach Profiles, 15 and 156. Surf, Calatornia, 2...
20. Beach Profiles, 158 and 160, Surf, California .
21. Average Sea Conditions at Surf - 21-23 June 1967
22. Average Wave (Swell) Conditions at Surf - 21-23 June 1967
23. Sediment Dispersion at Surf - 21 June 1967 .......
24. Sediment Dispersion at Surf - 22 June 1967 ....
Cb Sediment+Daspersion atwourt — 2srdune MOGTN.) s7 sti).
26. Point Conception, California - Vertical view ......
Zio diatclere Ont lergopshlilicys 5 Itonibans (Cropvesiowaloia, Ge 56.6 Od oO do oo
PomeCcast at. ArcatC: tae) esanscdet Mirons ORR). . ovownn
PomenBeach atvArea © 4.< +) Saves warlaihe?, ut
30. ‘Coes eng (NBS 6 6G ou ola oO 6) oo oO) lop oe Oo) a! o
Silo: Ween ey Awe 6 5 6 o 6b 0 6 6 0 6 516 6 6b Oo 6 OF Oo GLO 6
320 Cogsig eho Age dN Glo 696 6 GO 6.0 Gi 0 6 0 ola 0 6 lo G6 6
33}. deeela eho Meee NG 5 6 G6 6) 9 80 ooo 4b On. bn-0, 6 on
So eebathumetrie Chartis wAreanChrsm seus) Su vemnsu een nee sion
7, 5020
SAN MIGUEL
‘SLAND
RY
< SANTA ROSA G
» ISLAND
°
8 ay Owen
i £1900 1450
(ONS, ee Dp -CSzakD 1672
ig
RFA,
ya 30sec Ai em
Taken from U.S.C.&6.S
Chart No. 5202
120°40' 120°20°
Figure 14, Chart of Point Arguello - Point Conception Area,
showing location of test sites
31
»
SCALE IN FEET
fo) 1000
Figure 15. Aerial view of Surf, California. Star
indicates approximate location of injection site.
At the time of the photo, the Santa Ynez River
had sufficient flow to break through to the sea.
Figure 16. Beach at Surf, California. View is
northward toward Purisima Point and shows
the change from sandy beach to rocky shore.
32
Study Area
a
n
1 QI BU) = [2G 0B
;
ies ee es
450,000
: SCALE IN FEET
Depth Contours in Feet at MLLW
California Lambert Coordinate System See ere ena p eT te a
Figure 17. Bathymetric Chart - Surf, California,
Vandenberg Air Force Base
33
120°37 30°
\ Landing _
BM 111
\Giteyl
\\
\
16°
= es
34°42' 30" Z| fk
5| /G
ele
x =
\S)
©
Se) —
NY 158
120°37 30° SCALE IN FEET
‘1000 0 1000 2000
Taken from USGS.
Chart No. N3437.5—- W12030/7.5
3000 4000
———————|
(Soo ————ESSSS=s—=
Upper Monterey Formation
Depth Contours in Feet
Figure 18. Index of Profiles - Surf, California
34
Elevation in Feet
Elevation in Feet .
| | | '
oi S Oo ine)
(oe) [o) fo) (o)
i
op)
oOo
Beach O
+10
fe)
Beach
500
500
Shell Fragments
R-154
1000 2000 3000 4000 5000
Distance in Feet
Fine Sand
Fine Sand 2.45 @
1000 2000 3000 4000 5000
Distance in Feet
Figure 19. Beach Profiles 154 and 156, Surf, California
35
Fine Sand 2.78 @
6000
6000
Medium Sand 1.51 @
Medium Sand 1.819
Fine Sand 2.009
Fine Sand 2.24 @
-10
Be Fine Sand 2.226
®
= ay Fine Sand 2.526
= Fine Sand 2.659
iS)
= 30
>
@
w
no Fine Sand 2.68 @
-50
x00 (0) 500 1000 2000 3000 4000 5000
S Distance in Feet
o
+10
Medium Sand 1.29 @
0 Medium Sand 1.98 @
Fine Sond 2.09 @
-10
ae Fine Sand 2.12 @
®
“ |-20 Fine Sand 2.316
= ‘Fine Sand 2.56 @
2
S Peo)
>
@
w
Fine Sand 2.68 @
-50
ms 500 381000 ‘2000 3000 4000 5000
Distance in Feet
0
o
c=
i=)
C4
[28]
Figure 20. Beach Profiles 158 and 160, Surf, California
36
During the period of the test (21-23 June 1967), sea conditions at
Surf, California, averaged 3 to 4 feet from the northwest. Deepwater
waves (swells) averaged 7 to 8 feet from the northwest (305°) and had an
average period of 10 seconds. (See Figures 21 and 22.) Based on these
conditions, the bottom orbital velocity (U,) was calculated by:
US H/T sinh Kd
where H = wave height
T = wave period
d = depth of water
keg 2y/ 5
L = wave length
and found to be 109.6 centimeters per second for the 30-foot water depth.
This value was believed to be more than sufficient to cause sediment move-
ment considering that from Hjtilstrom's curve a velocity of 18 centimeters
per second is required to suspend particles of 2.06 (.25 millimeters),
the mean particle diameter of injected sand at this site. It should be
noted that the average grain size at 30 feet is 2.65 (.16 millimeters),
which would require a velocity of 21 centimeters per second for suspension.
Following the approach used by Bagnold (1947) and Vernon (1965), the
sediment migration rate was calculated as 1/3 the water drift velocity
(W) where:
ial
(2a
S
iT]
i ea
\e C when d
m
Figure 38. Average sea conditions, Area C
x
AS
EZ
==
\U
Figure 39. Average wave (swell) conditions, Area C
55
Be
oun :
SHS Sate
Es
mae Zest
i IRS a
setae
on een
oe %
4 3-4 Feet
Figure 40. Average sea conditions, Area B
KW 2-4 Feet
EEE 3-5 Feet
Figure 41. Average wave (swell) conditions, Area B
56
Figure 42. Average sea conditions, Area A
10.70’
° \ oe :
W 270° he WIZE oe
| So Als
SS Sa/||\ XL
G
Figure 43. Average wave (swell) conditions, Area A
57
Field operations were conducted from 15 November to 10 December 1967
in the Point Conception complex. Actual injection and tracing operations
took place from 1 December to 10 December 1967. Information pertinent to
injection operations is summarized by Table IV below.
TABLE IV
Summary of Injection Operations, Point Conception
Total
Tagged Activity
Injection Injection Injection Injection Sand Xe-133
Number Date Area Depth (liters) (millicuries)
al 1 Dee 67 A 30 feet ho 1,200
2] 2 Dec 67 C 30 feet ho 800
3 7 Dec 67 B 30 feet ho 600
y 10 Dec 67 A Surf Zone alk 120
The actual data on sediment characteristics and observed wave con-
ditions at the study sites were used to compute the parameters summarized
in Table III. These parameters indicate sediment on the marine bottom at
each of the 3 injection sites should have moved during the course of field
operation. Significant (twice background) corrected radiation and survey
tracks of the towed detector vehicle are shown by Figures 44 through 50.
An approximation (or estimate) of the general direction of movement may
be obtained by comparing the centroid of radiation values to the initial
injection location. These directions (foi a depth of 30 feet) are sum-
marized as follows:
Area C: from point of injection toward the SW to NW
Area B: from point of injection toward the ESE to SE
Area A: from point of injection toward the SSW to SE.
Precise monitoring of the injection in the surf zone on 10 December
1967 was not attempted. For this test a small quantity of tagged sand
was placed in the surf zone and an attempt made to follow it with the
detector. This test demonstrated the capability of working in the surf
zone; and this capability will be utilized in future tests.
Results of the Point Conception tests indicate that under the ?zon-
ditions extant during tracing activities in December 1967, the rate of
Text resumes on page 66
58
+1252000 1252500. +1253000. *1253500. +1259000.
ARER C BLACK CANYON RADIATION SURVEY AFTERNOON 4712/67
ee SCALE INFECT PLOT OF CORRECTED RADIATION/ INJECTION DATE
me SS BACKGROUND RADIATION RATIOS 021267
Figure 44. Radiation Survey, Area C, 4 December 1967
59
+363000_|_ a a + =o
ie an, ® 5 oo oo
-362500_|_ 2 ofa ‘ a oa 4 dL
fm, “Sooue
Pel ae sh a at -
+361500|_ al + + +
1361300 -
71252000. +1252500. +1253000. +1253500. +1254000.
ARER C BLACK CANYON RADIATION SURVEY MORNING 5/12/67
i SCALE IN FEET PLOT OF CORRECTED RADIATION/ INJECTION DATE
AR yea a ae BACKGROUND RADIATION RATIOS 021267
Figure 45. Radiation Survey, area C, 5 December 1967
60
+353300_|_
+35300!
+352500_|_
+352400
+1257400,
+
om,
oh
+1257500.
Figure 6.
>) GwINGE
BAY
EPTION - GUVERNMENT
eee — SCALE IN FEET
6l
+
os
PLOT OF CORRECTED RADIATION/
BACKGROUND RADIATION RATIOS
258000.
DIATION 5U
RVEY
INJECTION DATE
1207675
Radiation Survey, Area B, 7 December 1967
+35330 + + +
o *e
; oa ee 83, 3°
gaa 00 =e : sib lay eur oP
a ° 3 Op P2205, 9 “6 e
: ; our, “tg oy 0
O65 Ba 6) os ° S
oe
earl ae Ee © e ecoe e ais
+352400 .
+1257400. +1257500. 42 +1258000. +1258500.
PT CONCEPTION - GOVERNMENT BRAY RADIATION SURVEY 9/12/67
SCALE IN FEET PLOT OF CORRECTED RADIATION/ INJECTION DATE
CE: BACKGROUND RADIATION RATIOS 120767
Figure 47. Radiation Survey, Area B, 9 December 1967
62
=," ofobe
“250 4 + i
392450,
+1261900 21262000. ew 1262500. +1263000.
ARER A COHO ANCHORAGE RADIATION SURVEY AFTERNOON 1/12/67
=e gS ___, PLOT OF CORRECTED RADIATION/ INJECTION DATE
i “mem BACKGROUND RADIATION RATIOS Oll267
Figure 48. Radiation Survey, Area A, 1 December 1967
63
-353000_|_ af ae ale i : E te
wy 008m
ceewke,, SS
“SRADBAR *, pune
aa ees.
: ak
+35250 Te Be aie : aie
+352450, ie - A
+1261400 +1261500 Z 1262000. +1262500-
AREA A COHO ANCHORAGE RADIATION SURVEY AFTERNOON 2/12/67
oe PLOT OF CORRECTED RADIATION/ INJECTION DATE
2ARKGROUND RADIATION RATICS O2Z67
Figure 49. Radiation Survey, Area A, 2 December 1967
64
+35300 + + +
OuNP
0 HBS
COR e “y
sul + ate +
q
#352450. : :
+1261900 +!262000-. = 1262500. +1263000.
AREA A COHO ANCHORAGE RADIATION SURVEY MORNING 7/12/76
ee PLOT OF CORRECTED RADIATION/ INJECTION DATE
BACKGROUND RADIATION RATIOS Ou2Z67
Figure 50. Radiation Survey, Area A, 7 December 1967
65
sediment movement was very slow and possibly no significant movement
occurred. However, the paucity of data does not provide any real basis
for determining whether sand does or does not move around Point Concep-
tion. Knowledge to that effect, and the manner in which it occurs, if
it does indeed occur, must wait for subsequent programs. Intangible
success accrued through additional knowledge of operating characteristics
of the equipment in the oceanographic and coastal environment,as well as
basic information which can be incorporated in future field tests.
Not enough data points are available to more precisely define dis-
persal patterns. Any of four factors may have caused or contributed to
this difficulty:
1. rapid dispersion and dilution of the radioactive sand beyond
the limits of detection (1 microcurie over 1 square foot);
en Epaaslure ico disperse or very slow rate of tagged-sand dispersion;
3. burial of the tagged sand; or
4. too widely spaced tracking, in terms of the rate of movement
and volume of sand, especially if the sand remained in a
small area.
Field procedures are designed so that monitoring begins nearly
simultaneously with injection to guard against "losing" the sand as a
result of rapid dispersion. Experience at Cape Kennedy and at Surf
indicates the procedure is sound. Scuba divers, in the water at the
time of each injection, observed a bottom surge associated with wave
passage. By means of dye releases on the bottom, a unidirectional cur-
rent of approximately 15 cm/sec (0.5 ft/sec) was measured at each location
of dye placement; too rapid dispersion of the labeled sand is therefore
unlikely. Although it appears unlikely, there is a possibility that
labeled sand was gradually removed from the point source and was, con-
sequently diluted beyond the level of detectability. Computations of
the supposed rate of sediment motion are imprecise and subject to wide
latitude of values. Therefore, while data in Table III indicate the
sand should move, it is conceivable that actual conditions on the sea
floor precluded movement or that movement was relatively slow. Burial
by unlabeled sand could mask the presence of labeled sand. The limiting
depth of burial for detecting xenonated sand is approximately 6 centi-
meters. Divers reported ripple marks on the bottom in the three study
sites; amplitudes in excess of 1.0 centimeter were only infrequently
noted. The wave lengths of the ripples were such that all labeled sand .
would not be buried. Oceanic conditions indicated that a blanket burial
was not probable. If the rate of dispersal was low, it is quite possible
that the search tracks were too widely spaced. On-board plotting of the
vessel track was done to preclude such a possibility, but proved to be a
relatively imprecise technique. It is judged that the paucity of sig-
nificant (twice background) radiation data is due to a combination of
relatively slow movement of tagged sand and the wide track spacing.
66
It was recognized that the Point Conception area would be a difficult
place to work, therefore, backup detection equipment and a much improved
on-board instrument shelter were built for this test. While the radiation
data collection system worked well, some problems developed. Bouncing of
the detector "ball" as it was towed over the rock outcrops on the beach
and offshore bottom caused gain shift and noise in the detectors which
necessitated frequent adjustments to the recording instruments. in
addition, breaks occurred in the Tygon covering for the cable and allowed
water to penetrate the high voltage lines to the detector. The backup
detector was utilized during this program so that it could continue to
the planned completion stage.
5. CERC Shore Processes Test Basin, May 1968
Small quantities of labeled sediment are generally simpler to work
with than are large quantities. Logistics and radiation safety are
simpler. An excellent way to compare high and low specific activity
sand would be a laboratory experiment under controlled conditions that
permitted duplication of factors. Such a test at CERC compared results
obtained using a large quantity of low specific activity sand with those
obtained using a smaller quantity of high specific activity xenonated
sand. Total activity remained equal in both instances. Limited test
data on beach development and littoral movement under controlled condi-
tions were also obtained. The test proved the suitability of xenonated
sand for laboratory experiments in beach and nearshore processes.
Tests were conducted in a flume 68 feet long and 10 feet wide, con-
structed in the north part of the CERC Shore Processes Test Basin. The
initial beach configuration for each test was essentially a plane beach
with a 1:10 slope. The sand was a well-sorted medium quartz sand with
an average mean size of 1.876 (.27mm) and a standard deviation of 0.42.
Waves were 0.4 foot high with a period of 1.9 seconds. Each test
(low specific activity and high specific activity) comprised a total of
22 minutes of wave action. Each test was interrupted after 3 minutes
and again after 9 minutes of total wave action to measure changes in
beach morphology and radioactivity distribution. The bathymetry of the
beach face after 22 minutes of wave action is shown by Figure 51 and the
profiles are shown by Figure 52.
When manufactured on 26 April 1968, the low specific activity sand
had a specific activity of 5.28 microcuries per cubic centimeter; the
high specific activity sand had a specific activity of 520 microcuries
per cubic centimeter. On 29 April, about 1 liter of low specific activity
xenonated sand was emplaced at O0.5-foot intervals, approximating a line
source, from stations -l through +8 along range 5; approximately 50
milliliters per interval was used.
Following this test the radioactive sand was removed and the beach
face was rebuilt. On 3 May, about 10 cubic centimeters of high specific
activity xenonated sand was emplaced at the same 0.5-foot intervals from
67
station -1 through +8 along range 5. To keep total activity the same as
in the previous test, 0.5 cubic centimeters per interval was used.
Radiation and bathymetric surveys of the basin were made after 3,
9, and 22 minutes of total wave action. Radioactivity distribution was
monitored at 1-foot intervals along ranges 1, 3, 5, 7, and 9, using a
hand-held scintillation counter with a 3 by 3-inch sodium iodide crystal.
Figure 53 illustrates the distributions obtained with low and high specific
activity sand, following 22 minutes of wave action. A comparison of these
distribution plots indicates results with high specific activity sand
were nearly identical to those with low specific activity. The radiation
distribution plots (and the profiles) demonstrate the tendency of the
radioactive sand to orient in bands parallel to the shoreline and to
accumulate and move down the left (range 9)side of the basin following
the route of return water flow.
An attempt was made to determine depth of mixing at the conclusion
of each test by taking cores and wrapping them with polaroid radiographic
film; however, the level of activity was insufficient to expose the film
even though it remained wrapped around the core for approximately 35 days.
The distribution patterns obtained using high and low specific
activity sand indicated that the use of a smaller quantity of high speci-
fic activity sand made no significant difference, at least so long as
total activity remained the same. Results of the Shore Processes Test
Basin tests confirmed that xenonated sand is ideal for laboratory tests
involving sedimentation and beach processes.
To better determine the necessary frequency of data points (and
hence serve as a guide for field programs), additional computer plots
using a Lourier transform series were made on the data from Run 3 (22
minutes total wave action) of the low specific activity test. One plot
used only even stations and another used only odd stations (every other
station was omitted). A third plot was made omitting all data for range
5. As shown by Figures 54 and 55, all three plots exhibit patterns tery
similar to that of the complete data set. From this it may be concluded
that from 20 to 50 percent fewer data points may be used to give signifi-
cant results.
68
(4984 0S)
=I
J0J0J9UIS BADM OL
uTSeg }Sa], sesseo0rg azoug OuNOD - dew oT ryouky ye °TG eansty
UOI}Iy aADM [0JOJ SajnUIW Zz
*e uny ‘uouay AJIAIY I1198dS MOF
, 94 Ul SU0I}D}S
Ol 6 8 Z ) S v (3 r4 0 ls Coe Ca Ue
yaa4 ul Sabudy
69
Elevation in Feet
Elevation in Feet
Elevation in Feet
0.8
-6 =5, -4 =} = 2 -I (0) | 2 3 4 5} 6 7 8 9 10 i 12 13 14
Stations in Feet
RANGE 5
-6 =} -4 =3 =f ={) Oo | 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 1 12 13 14
Stations in Feet
-06
-0.8
“ RANGE 9 a ee:
-6 -5 -4 =5 =o -I 0 | 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 ia 12 13 14.
Stations in Feet
Low Activity Xenon
Run 3 (22 Minutes Total)
Figure 52. Beach Profiles, CERC Shore Processes Test Basin
70
utseg 4sey, sesseoorg eazoyg oyu ‘sfaamng uoTyeTpEYy
8961 Aow | (SainuiW 22) ¢ uNY
490D1] UOUdX AjIAIJoy DIyl9adS MOF
4994 UI SUOI}DIS
I ome Ger Oe tek et re pe Ce ne | Oe Send eo Sew PR al. U0) Ol G.-Y)
jaa4 ul sabuoy
"€G eansT a
896! AOW 2 (SasnuUIW 22) ¢ UNY
39001) uoUaKX AjIAlyoy dIy!00dS YybIq
4994 UI SUO1}0}S
S Vane 2 | 0 [PGR 1
wo
!
jaa4 ul sabuoy
Ol-
al
2!
sfaammg uotzetpey ‘Apnag UOTSSTUQ eyed
( Pa}}!WO SUOI}O}S UaAZ) AJUO 0J0G UO!}D}S PPO
4224 UI SUOI}01S
ll Ol 6 8 Z 9 S v € 2 | (0) Po gps Ga. 2
000'0o!
822'91¢
— |—
if
jaa4 ul sabuoy
ZS 0\-
LOES'B6G UO!sNGisju0D SasONbs jo wWNS juadsag
Y990ie BOUDIIDA
GLEb'| YO!}OINag psOpUdIS
6226 E UDA 010G
JojOUlwoUuag 4g
pe JOJOJoWNN 4G
vI986 O0Y 4
"HS SansTY
( P8441WO SUO!I}O}S PPO) AjUQ DyOG UOIyD}S UAaAg
4224 UI SUOI}0}S
ih Ole 0S 8 Z 9 G Pe 18 2 | 0 lps sees
“90096 UOIINGI4jU0D SasONDS Jo Wns jUadIag
QbbG'Z a2UDIJOA
Z2G6G"| UO!}OINaQ P4OPUo}S
I9I2Z¢ UdsW 0}0q
O| J0joUlwoueg 4q
pe JOJOJBWNN 4G
610 O0YN 4
jaa4 ul Sabuoy
ae
sfeaang uotTyvetpey *Apngg uotsstugo eyeq °GG eanStyq
pajajag 040g G ebuoy 49S 0j0g ajajdwo9
4884 Ul SUOI}O}S 4884 Ul SUOI}D}S
él I ol 6 8 Z 9 S v € 2 0 Roe OTR Z| Il Ol 6 8 2 9 S 14 € 2@ | 0
jaa4 ul sabuoy
0066'6Z UOI;NGI4ju0D SasONbs yo WNS jUadIaq 902068 UO!}Ng!4ju0g SasONbs jo WNS jUadIagq
Ob JOjDUIwouag 4q 16812 20UDIJ0A QOS J0joUlwoueg 4q I€OE'ZY aoUoIIOA
22 JOjosawAN 4Q 862b | UOl}OIAaG P4sopUDjS pe JOjoJawNN 4G Q2|G'| UOI}DIAg PsopUd}S
2226 01404 4 EleL Ee UoeaW 040g 8p861! O04 4 pElBE UOBW 040
3
Section IV. PROGRAM SUMMARY
1. Hardware and Program Development
Xenon-133 is the only isotope used to date. This biologically in-
active isotope is diffused into the quartz sand grains at high tempera-
ture and low pressure. Tests indicate that this process does not affect
the hydraulic characteristics of the grain. As indicated by studies at
NRDL, there is little loss of xenon due to leaching and abrasion. Because
of degassing, the halflife of tagged particles used in early studies was
2. days as opposed to 5.3 days for xenon-133. However, this problem
has been nearly eliminated and the halflife for the tagged particle is
now approximately 5.0 days.
An apparatus capable of placing the tagged sand on the bottom in
deep water or in relatively shallow water of the breaker zone was re-
quired. The initial device was a cylindrical hopper which could be used
to emplace a slurry of tagged sand as either a point source or line
source. However, the sand clogged on occasion when it got wet in the
hopper. A springloaded clamshell device which opened upon contacting
the bottom proved effective for placing sand as a point source.
The detection system consists of an on-board data collection system
and a towed ball-like device which houses four cesium iodide crystals
(scintillation detectors). Tests indicate that this ball design will
track well at speeds up to 5 knots with the present cable configuration.
As built, the device works ‘to depths of 200 feet (about 6 atmospheres).
Electrical signals from the detectors are carried to a signal mixer on
the towing vehicle and then to a 400-channel analyzer. By means of a
program interrogator, other data pertinent to surveying are coordinated
with the radiation data and read into the data display.
Tagged sand is traced by towing the detector ball behind an am-
phibious vehicle. Navigational control uses a navigation system which
provides direct readout of distance in meters from two responder beacons
at established shore points. Position information and radiation data
are printed out simultaneously. Soundings are taken with a precision
fathometer located on board the amphibious vehicle.
Computer programs have been developed for processing the raw field
data. Radidactivity data is corrected for background and decay; position
data is corrected to indicate the location of the ball behind the am-
phibious vehicle. These data are subsequently read into memory, and an
additional program plots and posts the corrected data. Isoactivity con-
tour maps (trend surface) of gridded data may be made by a Fourier
transform program.
74
2. Radiation Safety
Because xenon-133 has a relatively soft radiation and is biologically
inert, hazards connected with its use are minimal. For example, a person
could have lain one week on the sand used in the Shore Processes Test
Basin tests (5.2 millicuries total activity per test) without exceeding
the AEC permissible whole body dosage. As shown in Appendix F, only
minimal radiation exposure was received by personnel handling or other-
wise close to the activity in any RIST experiment.
Although the use of xenon-133 tends to minimize hazards, certain
safety precautions are nevertheless required. Personnel were supplied
with ORNL film badges or dosimeters, and cumulative radiation exposure
records were kept. Full-scale rehearsals of all procedures were conducted
prior to working with radiated sand. Test and storage areas were marked
in accordance with AEC regulations, and access to these areas was con-
trolled. Injection devices were used for emplacing the sand. Personnel
handling tagged sand wore protective clothing. Personnel, equipment,
and the survey area were monitored throughout the test to locate possible
contamination.
3. Field and Laboratory Tests
The preliminary Cape Kennedy field test proved the engineering design
of the detector, the analyzer system, and the sand tagging process, as
well as the conceptual framework of the program. The test at Surf demon-
strated that the sediment could be traced for a period of days in an
environment harsher than Florida, and field techniques were brought to
a fully operational level. As a bonus to this test, sediment dispersal
patterns for the area were derived. For a depth of 30 feet, these pat-
terns indicate an offshore movement toward the northwest. The test at
Point Conception worked toward accomplishing nearly all of the objectives
of the program. Although there was not enough significant data to define
dispersal patterns, some tentative approximations of direction of movement
were obtained. Despite the paucity of definitive data, these field tests
were successful in that they provided additional knowledge of operating
characteristics of the equipment and basic information which can be used
to improve field procedures. The test in the CERC Shore Processes Test
Basin showed that the use of a small quantity of high specific activity
xenonated sand made no significant difference from the distribution
patterns obtained using a larger quantity of low specific activity sand
(same total activity). A data omission study indicated that somewhat
fewer data points may be used to give significant results.
75
Section V. FUTURE OBJECTIVES
While much has been accomplished to date within the context of the
original 3-year research and development program, objectives in several
categories remain to be met. Some are merely refinements of existing
capabilities; others represent major goals. Both classes are categorized
and summarized as follows:
a. Isotopes: Seek other isotopes suitable for tagging by a technique
analogous to xenonation; study field use of isotope(s) other than xenon;
and provide for detection and analysis of multiple isotopes for use in
study of depth of sand burial.
b. Instrumentation and Computer Programs: Develop in sttu stationary
detectors to serve as monitors of sand movement; modify existing detector
and on-board analyzer system to simultaneously detect and record multiple
isotopes; provide for use of oceanographic cable;- automate and digitize
water depth data; and refine computer programs for analysis and treatment
of radiation data.
c. Sediment Movement: Improve field surveying to increase collection
of data points for maps; design and conduct programs for other coastal
sectors in the study area; extend the surveys through the surf zone and
beach face; use multiple isotopes; define more precisely the mechanics
and movement (including, if possible, quantification) of sediment in the
Point Conception area; and determine the effect of sediment burial.
To be able to predict the course of sediment movement and annual
volume will provide for improved engineering design of coastal structures
and subsequent economy of maintenance. Basic techniques and technology
are now at the point where the RIST system can be considered an operational
tool for determining direction of sediment movement. However, improvements
and refinements of the system will continue only through use. Improvements
must continue to a point where the program can be operated by a greater
percentage of technicians than is now possible. Not until then will the
techniques and technology developed be fully and widely applicable to
engineering and scientific studies.
76
LITERATURE CITED
Bagnold, R. A. (1947), "Sand Movement by Waves: Some Small-Scale Experi-
ments with Sand of Very Low Density", Journal, Institute of Civil
Engtneers, London, Paper 5554, pp. 447-69.
Bowen, A. J. and Inman, D. L. (1966), "Budget of Littoral Sands in the
Vicinity of Point Arguello, California", U. S. Army Coastal En-
gineering Research Center, Technical Memorandum No. 19.
Campbell, B. L., Palmer, A. R., Seatonberry, B. W. and Zentveld, C.
(1967), "The Investigation of Silt Movements in the South Channel,
Port Hunter, Newcastle, Using Copper-64 Labeled Silt", Australian
Atomic Energy Commission, Lucas Heights, Australia.
Carden, J. E. (1966), "Preparation, Properties, and Use of Kryptonates
in Chemical Analysis", Isotopes Radiation Technology, Volume 3,
pp. 206-214,
Cherry, J. (1965), "Sand Movement Along a Portion of the Northern Cali-
fornia Coast", U. S. Army Coastal Engineering Research Center,
Technical Memorandum No. 14.
Chleck, D., Maehl, R., Currihiara, 0. and Caunrevale, E. H. (1963);
Radioactive Kryptonates: International Journal of Applted
Radiation and Isotopes, Volume 14, pp. 581-610.
Cooper, W. S. (1967), "Coastal Dunes of California, Geological Society
of America, Memoir 10}.
Crew, R. J. (1965), "Techniques and Procedures for the Preparation of Dry
Particulate Fallout Simulant", U. S. Naval Radiological Defense
Laboratory, USNRDL-TN-3, 28 September 1965. Not library material.
"No copies available".
Cummins, R. S. (1964), "Radioactive Sediment Tracer Tests, Cape Fear
River, North Carolina", U. S. Army Engineer Waterways Experiment
Station, Miscellaneous Paper No. 2-649,
Cuthill, E. H.(1964), "A Fortran Program for the Calculation of the
Equilibrium Configuration of a Flexible Cable in a Uniform Stream"
David Taylor Model Basin Report 1806, March 1964.
Emery, K. O. (1964), "Some Characteristics of Southern California Sedi-
ments", Journal of Sedimentary Petrology, Volume 24, No. 1,
pp. 50-59.
Heezen, B. C. and Hollister, C. D. (1964), "Deep-Sea Current Evidence
from Abyssal Sediments", Marine Geology, pp. 141-174.
TT
Hubbell, D. W. and Sayre, W. W. (1964), "Sand Transport Studies with
Radioactive Tracers", Journal, Hydraulics Division, American
Soctety of Ctvtl Engineers, Vol. 90, No. HY3, pp. 39-68.
Huston, K. H. (1963), "A Critical Appraisal of the Technique of Using
Naturally Occurring Radioactive Materials as Littoral Tracers"
University of California, Hydraulic Engineering Laboratory,
HEL—4=1 .
Ingle, J. C. Jr. (1966), The Movement of Beach Sand, Elsevier Publishing
Co., Amsterdam, Holland.
Ingram, L. F., Cummins, R. S, and Simmons, H. B. (1965), "Radioactive
Sediment Tracer Tests Near the North and South Jetties, Galveston
Harbor Entrance", U. S. Army Engr Waterways Experiment Station,
Miscellaneous Paper No. 2-472.
Inman, D. L. and Chamberlain, J. K. (1959), "Tracing Beach Sand Movement
with Irradiated Quartz", Journal of Geophysical Research, Voo. 64,
No. 1, pp. 4147.
Kato, M., Homma, M., Sato, S., and Sakagishi, S. (1963), "Radiotracer
Experiments on Littoral Drift in Japan: Radioisotopes in Hydrology"
Proceedings of the Symposium on the Applteatton of Radiotsotopes
tn Hydrology, International Atomic Energy Agency, Tokyo, Japan,
pp. 143-174.
Krone, R. B. (1960a), "Methods of Tracing Estuarial Sediment Transport
Processes", University of California, Hydraulic Engineering
Laboratory and Sanitary Engrg Research Laboratory, Berkeley.
Krone, R. B. (1960b), "An Underwater Scintillation Detector for Gamma
Emitters, A Manual", University of California, Hydraulic Engin-
eering Laboratory and Sanitary Engineering Research Laboratory,
Berkeley.
Lampietti, F. S. (1964), "Beach Survey, Pismo to Saint Augustin, Cali-
fornia", Report to the Institute of Marine Sciences, University
of California, by Ocean Science and Engineering, Inc. under
Contract No. AT(11-1)-34, Vols. I and IT.
Lean, G. H., and Crickmore, M. J. (1953), "Methods of Measuring Sand
Transport Using Radioactive Tracers; Radioisotopes in Hydrology",
Proceedings of the Sympostum on the Application of Radtotsotopes
tn Hydrology, Tokyo, Japan, International Atomic Energy Agency,
Tokyo, Japan. pp. 111-131.
Owen, W. L., and Sartor, J. D (1963) Radiological Recovery of Land Target
Components-Complex III", U. S. Naval Radiological Defense Labora-
tory, USNRDL-TR-700, 20 November 1963.
78
Pode, L. (1951), "Tables for Computing the Equilibrium Configuration of
a Flexible Cable in a Uniform Stream," David Taylor Model Basin
Report 687, March 1951.
Rakoczi, L. (1963), "Tracer Study of Silt and Sanddrift on Lake Balaton"
Reports on Research, Project No 121, Hydraulic Laboratory VITUKI,
Seientific Research Institute on Water Resources, Budapest,
Hungary.
Sato, S., Takeshi, I., and Tanaka, N. (1962), "A Study of Critical Depth
and Mode of Sand Movement Using Radioactive Glass Sand", Proceed-
ings of the Eighth Conference on Coastal Engineering, Mexico City,
Mexico. pp. 304-323.
Sayles, F. L. (1965), "Coastal Sedimentation: Point San Pedro to Mira-
montes Point, California", Hydraulic Engineering Laboratory,
University of California, Berkeley, HEL-2-15.
Svasek, J. N. and Engel, H. (1962), "Use of a Radioactive Tracer for the
Measurement of Sediment Transport in the Netherlands", Proceed-
ings of the Eighth Conference on Coastal Engineering, Mexico City,
‘Mexico. pp. ¥45-h5h.
Taney, N. E. (1962), "Laboratory Applications of Radioisotopic Tracers
to Foll¢w Beach Sediments", Proceedings of the Etghth Conference
on Coastal Engineering, Mexico City, Mexico. pp. 279-303.
Trask, P. D. (1952), "Source of Beach Sand at Santa Barbara, California,
as Indicated by Mineral Grain Studies", U. S. Army Corps of En-
gineers, Beach Erosion Board, Technical Memorandum No. 28.
Trask, P. D. (1955), "Movement of Sand Around Southern California Prom-
ontories", U. S. Army Corps of Engineers, Beach Erosion Board,
TEchnical Memorandum No. 76.
U. S. Army Corps of Engineers (1967), Letter from Coastal Engineering
Research Center (CEREN) of 22 September 1967 to Naval Ship
Research and Development Center, Washington, D. C. 20007.
Vernon, J. W. (1965), "Final Report on Shelf Sediment Transport System",
University of Southern California Report No. Geol. 65-2.
Wilde, P. (1965), Estimates of Bottom Current Velocities from Grain Size
Measurements for Sediments from the Monterey Deep-Sea Fan", Ocean
Science and Engineering, MTS/ASLO. Conference, Washington, D. C.
Volse2s" pp allO= (ert.
Wood, D. and Caputi, R. (1966), "Solubilities of Kr and Xe in Fresh and
Sea Water", U. S. Naval Radiological Defense Laboratory, USNRDL-
TR-988, 27 February 1966.
Wright, F. F. (1967), "The Marine Geology of San Miguel Gap off Point
Conception, California", University of Southern California,
Unpublished PhD Thesis.
79
BIBLIOGRAPHY
Arlman, J. J., Santema, P. and Svasek, J. N. (1957), "Movement of Bottom
Sediment in Coastal Waters by Currents and Waves; Measurements with
the Aid of Radioactive Tracers in the Netherlands", Deltadtenst,
Rijkswaterstaat, Ministry of Transport, Netherlands.
Beveridge, A. J. (1960), "Heavy Minerals in Lower Tertiary Formations
in the Santa Cruz Mountains, California", Journal of Sedimentary
ReEtrologunmVioly3s0,eNo ts pp S1S—53 (te
Brashear, H. R., et al, (1968), "Computer Plotting of Data from the
Mobile Amphibious Detection System used in Radioactive Isotope Sand
Tracer Studies", Oak Ridge National Laboratory, Technical Memorandum
Mog 2Zil2.
Hiranandani, M. G. and Gole, V. C. (1960), "Use of Radioactive Tracer for
the Study of Sediment Movement off Bombay Harbor", Central Water and
Power Research Station, Poona, India, Technical Memorandum No. 1.
Hubbell, D. W. and Sayre, W. W., (1964), "Sand Transport Studies with
Radioactive Tracers", Journal of the Hydraulics Diviston, American
Soctety of Civtl Engineers, Vol. 90, No. HY3, pp. 39-68.
Inman, D. L. (1963), "Ocean Waves and Associated Currents" Submarine
Geology by F. P. Shepard, Harper & Row, New York. pp. 49-81.
Inman, D. L. and Rusnak, G. A. (1956), "Changes in Sand Level on the
Beach and Shelf at La Jolla, California’, U. S. Army Corps of En-
gineers, Beach Erosion Board, Technical Memorandum No. 28.
Inose,) Shi.) KatonMs “Sato. Sao and! Shiradshi shee (1955) Themhaeid
Experiment of Littoral Drift Using Radioactive Glass Sand", Inter-
nattonal Conference on the Peaceful Uses of Atomic Energy, Geneva,
NOS eel a AY/Conttes G)/o/ LOS). adiapant
Jolliffe, I. P. (1963), "A Study of Sand Movements on the Lowestoff Sand-
bank Using Fluorescent Tracers", Geographtcal Journal, Vol. 129,
pp. 480-493.
Kidson, C. and Carr, A. P. (1962), "Marking Beach Materials for Tracing
Experiments", Journal of the Hydraulics Division, Amertcan Society
of Civil Engineers, Vol. 88, No. HY4, pp. 43-60.
Putman, J. L. and Smith, D. B. (1956), "Radioactive Tracer Techniques for
Sand and Silt Movements under Water", International Journal of
Applied Radtatton and Isotopes 1:24-32. Pergamon Press, London.
Also reported in detail in "Radioactive Tracers in the Thames Estu-
ary", U. K. Department of Scientific and Industrial Research,
Hydraulics Research Station, Wallingford, England, HRS/PLA Paper
XO. 3 Tos) QU
80
Rance, R. J. (1963), "The Determination of Quantities of Sediment Trans-
port in Oscillatory Motion by Consideration of the Dispersion of
Tracer Sediment", International Assoctation for Hydraulte Research,
Tenth Congress, London, Paper No. 1.25, 1963, pp. 181-188.
Reid, W. J. (1958), "Coastal Experiments with Radioactive Tracers", The
Doek and Harbour Authority, England, Vol. 39 (453), pp. 84-88.
Russell, R. C. H. (1960), "The Use of Fluorescent Tracers for the Measure-
ment of Littoral Drift", Proceedings of the Seventh Conference on
Coastal Engineering, The Hague, Netherlands, Vol. 1, pp. 418-444.
Sayles, F. L. (1966), "A Reconnaissance Heavy Mineral Study of Monterey
Bay Beach Sediment", Hydraulic Engineering Laboratory, University
of California, Berkeley, HEL-2-16.
Sayre, W. W. and Hubbell, D. W. (1963), "Transport and Dispersion of
Labeled Bed Material, North Loup River, Nebraska", U. S. Geological
Survey, Prof. Paper 433-C.
Smith, D. B. and Eakins, J. D. (1957), Radtoactive Methods for Labeling
and Tracing Sand and Pebbles in Investtgations of Littoral Drift,
UNESCO/NS/RIC/63. Pergamon Press, London.
Steers, J. A. and Smith, D. B. (1956), "Detection of Movement of Pebbles
on the Sea Floor by Radioactive Methods", Geological Journal, London,
122 (Part 3), pp. 343-4.
U. K. Department of Scientific and Industrial Research (1958), "Radioactive
Tracers for the Study of Sand Movements, Report on an Experiment Car-
ried out in Liverpool Bay in 1958", Hydraulics Research Station,
Wallingford, England.
U. S. Atomic Energy Commission (1960), "Regulations of the U. S. Atomic
Energy Commission on Radiation and Radioisotopes", Part 20 - Stan-
dards for Protection Against Radiation, Appendix 5, U. 5S. Atomic
Energy Commission, Radioisotopes in Science and Industry, Wash-
aiaVeRBoIals IDG (Ga
U. S. Department of Commerce (1957), "Radiological Health Handbook, Office
of Technical Services, Simon Kinsman, Editor, Washington, D. C.
U. S. National Bureau of Standards (1958), "Permissible Dose from External
Sources of Ionizing Radiation", Addendum; Handbook 59, Wash. D. C.
U. S. National Bureau of Standards (1959), "Maximum Permissible Body
Burdens and Maximum Permissible Concentrations of Radionuclides in
Air and in Water for Occupational Exposure", Handbook 69, Wash. D.C.
Wright, F. F. (1962), "The Development and Application of a Fluorescent
Marking Technique for Tracing Sand Movements on Beaches", Columbia
University, Dept. of Geology, ONR Technical Report No. 2.
8l
tian ee i
bc deme nes hae scl
f ; shawnee ND
pe omen Ges, (kee Oks yl Steet |
2 seein reat nee
7
, a 6
IB cope ihe, pare, raldon 2
Ty etd tienes y
ely: fie pean
Part 1.
Part) 2).
Raritn Sie
APPENDIX A
Leaching and Abrasion Studies on Beach Sands Tagged
with Radionuclides by the NRDL Water-Glass Procedure.
Xenotated Sand: Leaching and Abrasion Studies.
Bibliography on Radiotracer-Tagging Sand and Sediments
for Study of Mass Transport in Fluvial and Marine
Environments.
. aa
; eg :
gobe mh ve 2 a il. ray
ves
a ‘nara ite? ic
ty EEE 6 B
ney, yom,
PART 1
LEACHING AND ABRASION STUDIES ON BEACH SANDS TAGGED WITH
RADIONUCLIDES BY THE NRDL WATER-GLASS PROCEDURE
INTRODUCTION
The investigations being conducted at Point Conception, California
by the U. S. Army Coastal Engineering Research Center and associated
agencies are for the purpose of studying littoral transport of beach
materials past coastal promontories. Initially, sand labeled with radio-
active Xe-133 is being used to trace the littoral migration of the beach
materials. The xenonation technique for labeling the sand was developed
at Oak Ridge National Laboratory* and is similar to the familiar Krypto-
nation technique (Carden, 1966), a technique by which kKr-85 is diffused
at high temperatures and pressures into solid materials. Other radio-
isotopes, such as Ba~La-140 and Cr-51, will be utilized (perhaps simul-
taneously, so that several particle sizes can be followed in the same
experiment) for labeling the sand in subsequent investigations at Point
Conception. It “these latter nuclides are to be used successfully for
tracing sand, suitable labeling techniques are necessary to prevent the
radioactive nuclides from leaching or abrading away from the sand during
the experiment. The objective of the investigation reported in this
paper is to determine whether a tagging procedure developed at NRDL
some years ago could be utilized for sealing the radioactive nuclides
Ba-La-140 and Cr-51 into the sand. ;
The NRDL water-glass technique was developed to produce a fallout
simulant for evaluation of counter-measures for recovering military and
civil sites contaminated by radioactive fallout. The simulant consisted
of Monterey sand labeled with Ba-La-140 activity (Owen and Sartor 1963).
Briefly, the procedure (Crew, 1965) involved spraying the desired activity
on sand which was being rotated inside a concrete mixer. During the mixing
the sand was dried by direction of a blast of hot air into the mixer.
Next, a solution of sodium silicate (water glass) was sprayed on the sand
and the sand was dried as before with hot air. Then the labeled sand was
fired for an hour at 1900°F (1030°C). The fused water-glass coating on
the sand provided an effective seal for retarding the desorption of the
radioactivity into fresh water (i.e. from firehoses or rain) in the type
of field experiment for which it was developed.
To determine whether the NRDL sealing technique could be extended
to the Point Conception project, laboratory experiments were designed
to measure the release of activity from tagged sand to the environment
by (1) the simple static leaching action of sea water and (2) the com-
bination of sea-water leaching and the mutual abrasive action of the
sand particles as would be experienced in the surf zone. The results
of such studies with both Ba-La-140 and Cr-51 are summarized below.
* F.N. Case and E. H. Acree, ORNL, personal communication
EXPERIMENTAL
The sand was tagged in 100-gram lots for the laboratory experiments.
The sand was placed in a 16-ounce screw-cap bottle and the desired radio-
activity, in 2.25 milliliters of distilled water, was added dropwise to
the sand. The activity level of the added radionuclide per 100 grams of
sand varied from 3 to 5 million counts per minute. The bottle was capped,
and sand and radioactivity were thoroughly mixed by rolling the bottle on
a jar mill for one hour. The moist sand was then dried in an oven at
130-140°C. Then 2.25 milliliters of a 50-50 mixture of water and 40-42
Baumé sodium silicate solution was added dropwise to the sand. Contents
of the bottle were mixed on the jar mill for one hour, and then the
coated sand was dried in the oven as before. After this, the dried sand
was placed in a porcelain casserole and fired for one hour at 1900°F
(1030-1040°C).
About 5-6 grams of the tagged sand was weighed into a 15 by 125-
millimeter test tube. This (standard) sand sample was radioassayed each
time aliquots of supernates were assayed in the static leaching and the
abrasion tests; it served as a standard for calculating the quantity of
radioactivity removed in those tests.
For the static leaching study, 40 grams of the tagged sand was placed
in an 8-ounce screw-cap bottle along with 100 milliliters of sea water.
On the first day of the leaching study, 0.5-milliliter aliquots of the
supernate were removed and radioassayed 1, 2, and 6 hours after the sea
water had been added to the sand. During the following 12 to 14 days, a
daily aliquot was removed and radioassayed. Then the experiment was
terminated. Before each aliquot was removed, the contents of the bottle
were stirred thoroughly and then allowed to settle for 5 minutes.
For the abrasion studies, 40 grams of the tagged sand was placed in
a 500-milliliter bottle along with 100 milliliters of sea water. The
bottle was agitated in a Parr Pressure Reaction Apparatus. Aliquots
(0.5 milliliter) were obtained and assayed just as those for the leaching
experiment. As the abrasion experiment proceeded, a suspension developed
in the supernate. This suspension was quite stable. Therefore, the
radioassay included this suspended material.
Commercial Monterey sand was used for pilot studies. After proce-
dures had been tested, sands from the Point Conception test site were
utilized. The Point Conception sands were provided by Mr. Joseph H.
Bittner of the Los Angeles District, Corps of Engineers. The various
Point Conception sands are designated according to their geographical
and beach locations.
Because the tagging procedure could materially alter the size of
sand particles, the sand-size distributions, at various stages of the
tagging procedure and after the abrasion experiment, were checked with
a mechanically operated sieving device. In all cases the sieving lasted
for 15 minutes. The sieving results obtained are not to be interpreted
as definitive studies in sand-size distributions. They were made simply
to provide an order-of-magnitude estimate of the effects of coating,
firing, and abrasion on the size of the particles. Small, unavoidable
weight losses of the sand sample occurred as the tagging, sieving, and
abrasion routine developed. Sources of these weight losses were the
inability to transfer quantitatively the coated sand from the sodium
silicate mixing bottle to the porcelain casserole, losses due to the
high temperature firing of the sand (carbonate decomposition), changes
in the sorbed moisture on the sand, and losses in removing the smaller
sand fraction from sieves and weighing containers because of the electro-
static charge developed on the particles during the sieving. Since most
of the material losses were cumulative, the sieving routine was varied
from experiment to experiment so that the number of sieving operations
in any one experiment (and therefore also the total weight-loss error)
was minimized. The total loss caused by the sources listed above
varied from 2.5 to 4.5 grams per 100 grams sand.
The pre-tagging sieving results for Monterey sand and the various
Point Conception sands are given in Table A-I. Several Point Conception
samples consisted chiefly of coarse gravel and pebbles up to 1 1/2
inches in diameter. Because the coarse material would tend to bias
results when 100-gram sand samples were used in the experiments, only
material that passed through an 833-micron sieve was retained for the
experiments. Another objection to the retention of the coarse material
was the excessive grinding action that would be produced in the limited
eonfines of the 500-milliliter abrasion vessel. Such results would be
Similar to those obtaimed with grinding pebbles in a ball mill, and
would be much more severe than those likely to be experienced under test
eonditions. The arbitrary imposition of an upper limit to the particle
Size does not in any way invalidate the results obtained, because the
objective of the investigation was the integrity of the silicate coating
under reasonable experimental conditions and not the particle size
distribution of the sand. Furthermore, on a weight basis, the smaller
fractions are the more important because the specific activity of a
particle increases inversely as its size. Also the smaller fractions
will be the most important ones in the field since they will travel
the farthest from the deposition site in a given time.
The new size distribution data obtained after the removal of the
coarse material are shown in Tabie A-II.
RESULTS
Study No. 1 - Monterey Sand - A pilot study was made with Monterey
-sand. This study was made for scaling down the established procedure
: for concrete-mixer size batches of tagged sand to 100-gram laboratory
size batches. The study was made also for providing a standard tagged
sand for comparison with the Point Conception sands to be studied later.
'The Monterey sand was tagged with Ba-La-140 radioactivity. The leaching
"and abrasion experiments extended over 12 days, approximately one half-
l tite of the activity. After 12 days about 1 percent of the activity hed
|
|
A-5
leached off the sand in the static tests, and about 3.8 percent of the
activity had abraded away from the sand in the abrasion study.
Study No. 2 - Surf No. 2, MLLW Sand - In this study, the Point Con-
ception sand was treated with dilute hydrocholric acid (HC1) prior to
the tagging with Ba-La-140 activity. The purpose of the HCl leach was
to remove sea shells and other carbonate minerals from the sand. The
HCl was added in small portions to the sand (which was covered with water)
until gas evolution ceased. The sand was washed thoroughly with distilled
water, and then dried before initiation of the tagging procedure. The
mass-size and activity-size distributions of the sample during the various
stages of the study are given in Table A-III. The HCl leaching and the
firing losses are also given. The table includes the mass-size distribu-
tion of the original sand sample, of the sample after the HCl treatment,
and of the sample after it had been tagged, coated, and fired at 1900°F.
Also included are the distribution of the activity on the tagged sample
and the mass-size distribution of the sand at the termination of the
abrasion studies. Leaching and abrasion data were collected for 12 days.
The results for the leaching experiment showed that 1.1 percent of the
activity was lost to the aqueous phase. For the abrasion experiment the
figure was 4.2 percent. =
Study No. 3 - Surf No. 2, MLLW Sand - This study was terminated by
an accident early in the course of the experiment. The experiment was
repeated as Study No. 4.
Study No. Indes Sienene INeys 2, MLLW Sand - The purpose of this study was
to determine the effect of the carbonate minerals in the Point Conception
sand on the sealing of the tagged sand. Therefore, the carbonates were
not removed by the preliminary HCl leach. The high temperature at which
the water glass is fired decomposes the carbonate minerals. As in the
previous study, the mass-size and activity-size distributions at various
stages of the study are given in Table A-IV. After 12 days of static
leaching, 4.8 percent of the activity was in the aqueous phase. The
comparable value for the abrasion experiment was 15.8 percent. These re-
sults clearly indicate that the presence of carbonate mineral decomposition
products (basic oxides) in the sand adversely affects the sealing quality
of the water-glass tagging procedure.
Study No. 5 - Bear Creek No. 1, +5 Sand - This study was made to
check the water-glass procedure with one other Point Conception sand. This
particular sand was selected because of its fine, uniform appearance. The
carbonates were removed before the sand was tagged with Ba-La-140 activity.
The size and activity data are given in Table A-V. After 12 days of static
leaching, approximately 0.6 percent of the radioactivity had escaped into
the aqueous phase. For the abrasion experiment, 0.9 percent of the
radioactivity was in the aqueous phase.
Study No. 6z= Monterey Sand - This study was made to determine whether
Revlon nail enamel, No. 61, had adequate sealing properties for retaining
radioactivity under the conditions described in the previous studies.
(If successful, this material could have been used to seal activity on
dolomite type sands.) The experiment was discontinued after 24 hours
because of poor results. In the static leaching experiment, 26 percent
of the activity was lost to the aqueous environment. About 60 percent
of the activity was abraded away in the 24 hours.
Study No. 7 - Monterey Sand - In this experiment the firing tem-
perature for the water-glass technique was reduced from 1030° to 500°C.
The seal at the lower temperature was inferior to that obtained at
1030°C. After 24 hours, 8 percent of the activity had leached away in
the static test and 16.4 percent of the activity had been lost in the
abrasion experiment.
Study No. 8 - Bear Creek No. 1, +5 Sand - The sand was tagged with
Cr-51 radioactivity by the water-glass procedure. Approximately 1 percent
of the activity was leached from the tagged sand in the static test and
1.3 percent was in the aqueous phase due to abrasion. The experiment
extended over 14 days. No sieving data were taken.
Sieving Experiment with Beer Creek No. 1, +5 Sand - An examination
of the size-distribution data obtained with Surf No. 2, MLLW sand in the
original form shows a considerable variation in the results (cf. first
row of data, Tables A-III and A-IV). Initially this was attributed to
poor sampling, probably caused by size fractionation of unknown origin.
For a test of this thesis, Bear Creek No. 1, +5 sand was thoroughly mixed
for 15 minutes in a jar mill. Two 100-gram samples then were removed
and each was mechanically sieved for 15 minutes. The sieving results
are given in Table A-VI. These results should also be compared with the
results of the item designated "original" in Table A-V. Apparently mass-
size variations up to 5 absolute percent, which is larger than had been
anticipated, are to be expected.
FUTURE PLANS
Leaching and abrasion experiments for xenonated sand, supplied by
Oak Ridge National Laboratory, have been completed. The results obtained
will be incorporated in a subsequent report. A bibliography on sand-
tagging techniques has been completed in rough draft, and will be reported
shortly.
CONCLUSION
The NRDL procedure for sealing radioactivity to soils can be extended
to beach sands, provided carbonate minerals are absent or may be removed.
Over a 12-day period, about 1 percent of the radioactivity is removed by
static leaching processes, and from 1 percent to 4 percent of the activity
may be abraded away from the tagged sand. Losses of this small magnitude
are no cause for concern. It is inconceivable that they would either
jeopardize the results of the operation or constitute a health hazard.
These results apply to Ba-La-140 and Cr-51 activities. Presumably any
radioactive element that is not vaporized at the firing temperature
(1900°F) can be used for tagging refractory sands.
A-7
*peyou SUOTAISTASP 944 ZOF YuUMODOe suoTAoeII
jo Sutkap Tetqzed 10 sasso—T quenbesqng *sqzystem oTdwes [eVUTSTAO Jo stTseq 9y4 UO peyel[NoTeod azomM
fayy esneosq ¥O00T 0F dn ppe sfkenTe you op ‘*seTqey quenbesqns ut ssoyq se [TEM se ‘saBequeorzed ssouy, y
OSs GS°¢ co L SOS IEE c9° of €9°6€ €0°S EL’g S°9n9 G=—°S SON
Butpuey ooduoq
c000° 200° Os SO" 62° ee°e 10° OT 88°98 S* 709 MTT
So *ON Sutpuey osoduoyT
400° OK EO= 60° 26° Gh * Te 92° 9 (SAE aby “Bn9 G+ *T ‘ON
sutpuely ooduoy
OR 6H € Woo Se THOS TS‘*de 01's eOnak 88° S*€09 G- °€ “ON Yeerp reeg
10° tac OS*ET S6°9t 89° Te Gerd, 9E°T Leg S°88, MITIN ‘2 “ON Yeerp ste98g
20° OT*¢ SETS 65°19 Sore Aa AG suon ouoN S° Set G+ *T ‘ON Year re8g
0° HAE tS 66° eT B9° Ee Bi T2 el° ol 9T*? KS TEE S°*2l9 G- *€ *ON Jang
20° une = LE €98°6 6£° OE 9S ° te ALS SIE T9°¢ 09° LT *T09 MTITN ‘2 ‘ON Jang
0° wie LE OL 60° Th 1S°€€ O€° ST Giles 9e° G°€2s G+ *T “ON gang
suON TO’ 6T° Gin-se 19°98 Jee suoN SuoH 68°66 pueg Aazequoy
fal ial n n ial ial n n a
Q8> 61-88 OTe-6hT S62
=O0le- Ogi=S6¢c. €€8
% 4, Uy} g
-Oct O89T-EER
4, 4 9 9
Og9T< 4usTEM atdures
b b y
Te4OL
x(FUBTOM fq JUusdtEg)
peatTeossey se sorTdueg pues snotzeA JO UOTINGTAASTG eZTg-ssey
T-V wIdVo
I-V eTqeL Fo
eyep Wolfs peyeTnoT eo,
HE" 8g°2 Bet Qn ET G8°9E BL tt G- °€ ‘ON Sutpuey, ooduoT
800° go" ce" oS°T 02°6 18°88 MTIN ‘Z ‘ON SuUTpuey ooduoT
LT0° 0° G90" 6€° go'n Tt’ S6 G+ *T ‘ON SUTpUeT ooduoT
Lo° Eg°€ Qn HT TH’ 2S OnE? €6°S G- *€ ‘ON YeerQ sVe9eg
yoy? 962 G9° HT 96° 0S €S°€? Qa; MTIN ‘2 ‘ON Yeetp Teeg
ZO° OT’? Ciegea 66°19 €S°T¢ Drie G+ *T “ON YoomQ ree
GO° 19° € 90°ST 10°6E BE" Bz GO*4T G- *€ ‘ON gamg
0° tere GE-e1 QT’ gE 98° 0€ Qn 9T MTIW ‘2 °ON gang
10° 9T°T EOI Why BO HE 6q° oT G+ *‘T ‘ON gang
auoN TO" Gils QT"? 18°88 11°98 pueg Aezequoy
aa Sa Se en ee ee ee ee ee ee eee
~ gg> 641-88 OT2-6hT G62-0T2 O2h-S62 E€Q-Oct
% tb tb Ve th 2
(qustTeM £q 4US0IEg)
xSUOTOTW €€Q Jepun seToTyseg Oy satdueg pueg snoTze, JO UOT INgGTA4STq EezTS-sseW
II-V a1EdvL
TABLE A-IITI
Mass-Size and Activity-Size Distribution of Sand at VArious
Stages of Study No. 2 (Percent by weight or activity)
7, q, % q, % 7,
Sample Stage 420-833 295-420 210-295 149-210 88-149 <88
u u u Lu u u
Ohetistiaecl © 16.48 30.86 38.18 12.35 Gio)
After HCl leach 2 5 D D
(2.98% weight loss) 16.48 31.49 39.2h 10.84 LoS 92k
Coated and fired
(1.87% weight loss) 16.28° Beh Gia 2727 1063 sLGSe 14°
Coated and fired
(activity )3 (aS SM Ziog SIO) (eisiatsis)) (alsioys})) (3.80) (26 58)
Abrasion residue SR 26 29.96 38.81 13.08 Be, lal
TABLE A-IV
Mass-Size and Activity-Size Distribution of Sand at Various
Stages of Study No. 4 (Percent by weight or activity)
h fp fh i V, i
Sample Stage 420-833 295-420 210-295 149-210 88-149 <88
pak u Hu u u a u
Original i IO Si 33.22 36521 9.81 St 6O2
Coated and fired
(G86) Gains tess) Moye Shghe ashes Oe 7 an) ass o- Uaioe
Abrasion residue 22.81 33.62 33.46 8.82 . 93 36
Abrasion residue
(activity) 3 (au gals) SESE Sez) S52) (SO 70)
1. Surf No. 2, MLLW sample. Compare Tables A-III and A-IV. See
sieving experiment in text for explanation.
2. Percent of depleted sample.
3. Numbers in parentheses refer to activity-size distributions.
All others refer to mass-size distributions.
A-10
TABLE A-V
Mass-Size and Activity-Size Distribution of Sand at Various
Stages of Study No. 5 (Percent by weight or activity)
jb Ve js h jp fh
Sample Stage 420-833 295-h20 210-295 149-210 88-149 <88
u u u u u u
Original a Moe 18.91 62.26 oan 2.41 AOi
After HCl leach
(2.37% weight loss) LAS 18.28° 62.2h° nes ii BOBe 07°
Coated and fired
(0.29% weight loss) 1.42 20.20 60.20 15540 2.70 .09
Abrasion residue 1.18 20.74 59.12 16.74 2.10 Sill:
Abrasion residue
(activity) 3 NGICS) Pn(9 482) (46340)! (S308) Ry (9163) (548)
1. Bear Creek No. 1, +5 sample.
2. Pereent of depleted sample.
3. Numbers in parentheses refer to activity-size distributions.
All others refer to mass-size distributions.
TABLE A-VI
Mass-Size Distributions Obtained by Sequentially Sieving Two
Bear Creek No. 1, +5 Samples (Percent by weight)
fp fh ho - fo ia fh
Experiment 420-833 295-420 210-295 149-210 88-149 <88
Number u u u u u u
akg © pres 23.92 60.54 Ii Gain OG ele ex0:
De 1.60 19.72 63.61 is gOm 2.09 son!
Original from
Table A-V et 18.91 62.26 MSA 2.41 OL
PARI 2
XENONATED SAND: LEACHING AND ABRASION STUDIES
INTRODUCTION
The U. S. Army Coastal Engineering Research Center and associated
agencies are studying littoral transport of beach materials past coastal
promontories at Point Conception, California. Sand labeled with radio-
active nuclides is used to trace the littoral migration of the beach
materials. The first injection of sand labeled with radioactive Xe-133
occurred in June 1967. The technique for labeling sand with Xe-133 was
developed at Oak Ridge National Laboratory (F. N. Case and FE. H. Acree,
Oak Ridge National Laboratory, personal communication) and is similar to
the familiar kryptonation technique (Carder, 1966), in which Kr-85 is
diffused at high temperatures and pressures into solids., The depth of
penetration of Kr-85 into the host solid is 103) to 10D) VAY Kryptonated
solids remain stable (no outgassing) with time at room temperature,
barring surface reactions such as oxidation or hydration of the host
solid. Although similar behavior is anticipated for xenonated solids,
due allowance must be made for the enhanced size of the xenon atom over
that of krypton, because the labeling mechanism for both techniques de-
pends on the entrapment of the noble gas in the interstitial spaces and
structural voids of the host solid. The objective of the investigations
reported in this paper is to determine whether outgassing of Xe-133 will
occur when xenonated sand is subjected to conditions prevailing at the
water-sand interface of a marine environment.
Laboratory experiments were designed to determine whether outgassing
of Xe-133 from xenonated sand occurred. ‘The experiments were similar to
those that were used to test the integrity of the Naval Radiological
Defense Laboratory (NRDL) water-glass technique for labeling sand with
radioisotopes (Appendix A, Part 1). Static water tests were made to
determine the effect of water in causing outgassing of the xenonated
sand, and abrasion tests were made to determine the radioactivity loss
caused by the mutual abrasive action of the sand particles as would be
experienced in the surf zone.
EXPERIMENTAL
At ambient temperatures and pressures zenon is a gas with a charac-
teristic valence of zero. This property necessitates the use of a closed
system for investigation of the outgassing of Xe-133 from zenonated sand.
A desirable apparatus for this study would utilize all-glass construction
with provisions for sample agitation and for removal of outgassed Xe at
desired intervals. However, limitations on time and funding precluded
the possibility of constructing and testing such an apparatus. In place
of this apparatus simple experiments were prepared in 25-milliliter screw-
cap vials. The vials were sealed with polyethylene gaskets seated in the
caps. Six static experiments and six abrasion experiments were prepared
with these containers in the investigation of the outgassing of Xe-133
from the sand as a function of time.
A-|2
Five grams (5.00 g) of xenonated sand were weighed into each vial.
Next the vial was filled completely with distilled water. The amount of
water added was measured with a burette. Then the caps were secured, and
for insurance of a seal, the vials were inverted until they were radio-
assayed. The vials used in the abrasion experiments were placed in a
Parr agitation apparatus in an inverted position. They were agitated in
this position until they were assayed. A calibration standard was pre-
pared at the same time as the experiments. The standard consisted of
6.0787 grams of the dry xenonated sand in a 15 by 125-millimeter test
tube. The tube was not sealed. The standard was radioassayed each time
aliquots of supernate from the vials were assayed. A semilogarithmic
plot of the count rate of the standard vs. the time showed that, from 28
to 436 hours, it decayed with a halflife of 5.29 days. The good agreement
with the published Xe-133 halflife (5.27 days) indicates that no loss of
Xe-133 occurred by escape into the atmosphere during this time. Zero time
for all experiments was set at the time the vials were filled with water.
At various times after the experiment began, supernates from a static
experimental vial and from an agitated vial were radioassayed for the
presence of outgassed Xe-133. A 4-milliliter aliquot was removed from
the vial and radioassayed as quickly as possible. (Rate of loss of Xe-133
from an aliquot was determined in a collateral experiment.) The assay was
made with a Sodium Iodide (NaI) (Tl-activated) crystal scintillation well
counter. The vials were discarded after the assay. The time selected
for a radioassay did not follow a set pattern. The time was determined
more by the results of the previous assay and by the desire to extract as
much information as possible from the results than by any other con-
sideration. Altogether the time lapse for all the experiments extended
over about two Xe-133 halflives (i.e., 10 days).
The xenonated sand was provided by Mr. F. N. Case of Oak Ridge
National Laboratory (ORNL). Carbonates had been removed at ORNL prior
to xenonation. Because of a misunderstanding, the sand was not received
until the middle of May 1967. Thus only one batch of sand was available
for experimental purposes.
RESULTS AND DISCUSSION
The pertinent data for both sets of the outgassing experiments are
shown in Table A-VII. The data include the time lapse from zero to assay
time, the total activity of the sand standard, the activity (calculated
from the specific activity of the standard and the activity lost to the
water) of the sand in the vial after exposure, the volume of water re-
quired to fill the vial, the total activity (calculated) of Xe-133 in
the aqueous phase, and the percent of outgassed Xe-133. The calculated
activities (all corrected for background) were for the times indicated
in the first column.
After 28 hours the amount of Xe-133 outgassed from the sand in the
static experiment corresponded to 3.5 percent of the amount remaining in
the sand. After 219.5 hours the figure had increased to 5.5 percent.
A-I3
‘UIMTOS 4STTJZ. UT paqwvorpuT ouTy 4B AyTATQOV,
i
TE'9 GEO0*OT 0S 22 000° 6ST 00K. S07 VI G° 612
09°S "S0°OT OTE? OOT* EST 006‘ HE? Ve G°G6T
2), S Ghee 00°€2 QOL LTE 00h * 66€ VE G*66
G9°S BOT‘ Og Go? SE 001. SSE 009° 9Sh var G°So),
G0°s 16S°02 qh ES? 001° 90t 000‘ 6TS WS TS
TH tH Qnty Og GES? 005° n9n OOE * 68S v9 Fe
Sutyoesy pue uotseiqy Jo 1o8esTy “g
1S°S 298°8 02° €2 002° 09T 00t *SOg sg G* 612
EIS HES*OT 06°22 001° 298T 006‘ E72 SS G°S6T
EW? S 998°9T OgEise 006° TTE OOt * 66€ Sh G°66
0g" t CSS JE 02° €2 008° @SE 009° 9Sh SE G°S),
HEH We JOE 00S ‘60t 000‘ 6TS Sz TS
AGES GLH SOT GQ’ ed OO€ “gor O0E “68S ST gz
BSUTYOeST JO JOST “vy
(%) (uy) (es) (7s) (ce (e880)
poessezqno SUMNTOA [Te4O] UL T3IYeEM Butyoeey J3a1sy pATTATIOV atdues out,
3X ph tFATPOV pAtTATIOV pzepueys
T37eM pues
eee
pueg peyeuouex jo setdweg wer8-99°¢ wory EE€T-ax Jo BSutsseZino
IITA-V Wav
A-14
Comparable figures for the abrasion experiments were 4.4 percent and
6.3 percent, respectively. In an attempt to improve the accuracy of
the measurements, distilled water was used in the static outgassing and
abrasion experiments because Xe is more soluble in distilled water than
in sea water (Wood and Caputi, 1966). Because the vials were filled
completely with water, dead spaces were avoided and the outgassed Xe
remained in solution until the vials were opened for assay. About two
minutes elapsed from the time a vial was opened until an aliquot was in-
serted into the counter for radioassay. It is assumed that a negligible
amount of xenon was lost from the aliquot during this time because of
the extremely low concentration of the xenon in the solution. However,
in an attempt to provide an estimate of the rate of xenon escape from
the aliquot as well as to show that the Xe-133 detected in the aliquot
was the result of outgassing and not due to a fine suspension of sand in
the supernate, the activity of the aliquots from experiments 6S and 1A
was followed for 119 hours after separation, with the containers open to
the atmostphere continuously. These data are shown in Table A-VIII. The
results are given as the fraction of activity remaining in the aliquots
after various time lapses. In 2.5 hours about 39 percent of the dissolved
Xe-133 escaped from the aliquot from the static experiment and 24 percent
from the abrasion-experiment aliquot. In both cases the rate of escape
of xenon from solution is much greater than the rate of radioactive decay.
The results show that, although 24 to 39 percent of the xenon escapes
from the solution in 2.5 hours, prompt aliquoting and counting reduces
this loss to a reasonable figure. Further support for this conclusion
was obtained from another experiment in which 10 percent of the xenon
escaped from the 1S aliquot in 30 minutes. It is estimated that the
error due to xenon escape from the aliquots prior to radioassay is less
than 1 percent of the outgassed xenon.* The results thus substantiate
the findings that Xenon-133 is outgassed from the xenonated sand.
CONCLUSION
The experimental results show that Xenon-133 is slowly released from
xenonated sand in the presence of water. The amount of Xe-133 lost from
the xenonated sand to the aqueous phase was relatively small (about 3 to
5 percent). There was little difference between the static-experimental
results and the abrasion-experimental results. Comparable results
obtained with sands tagged with Ba-La-140 and Cr-51 by the NRDL water-
glass technique were 1 percent for the static leaching experiments and
4 percent for the abrasion experiments (Appendix A, Part 1).
When an aliquot of the supernate from a leaching or abrasion experi-
ment was left open to the atmosphere, the dissolved Xe-133 gas escaped
into the atmosphere. This proved that the gas was dissolved in the
aqueous phase and was not contained in sand suspended in the water.
The results show that the outgassing of Xe-133 from the treated sand
need not be of concern either as a health hazard or with respect to the
usefulness of Xe-133 as a tracer for the investigation of sand transport.
* The outgassing results shown in Table \-VII tend to substantiate this
estimate (plateau effect at later times).
A-I5
‘uumTOO 4S4TJ UT pezeoTpUT outa Iy,
020° 126 61 S00° 961 t 61T
260° HSE NPE ASO OgT‘T gE Lt
eRe H9S°T LEQ 980° oye
Laboratory, University of California, Berkeley, Annual Report 3,
1960. (From Reference 441.)
Krone, R. B., "Methods for Tracing Estuarial Sediment Transport
Processes,'' Hydraulic Engineering Laboratory and Sanitary Engineer-
ing Research Laboratory, University of California, Berkeley, 1960.
(From Reference 23.)
Lachica, F., Baro, G. B., "Study of the Movement of Sand in the
Vicinity of Puerto de Mar del Plata Using Ag!!9 Labeled Sanda,"
Comision Nacional de Energia Atomica (Buenos Aires), Report No.
100, 1963. Nuclear Sci. Abstr. 19:2676, 1965.
La Jarte, S..D. de (Patent to Saint-Gobain), "Glass Compositions,"
Me, ILRI y Welisvdls}; WOS 35 Cac, Neste 4 Giga ALCS 0)
Larras, J., "Marine Bed-Load and Displacement Studies Made by French
Engineers." In Internattonal Congress of Navigation, 20th, Baltimore,
1961. Ocean Navtgatton. Sect. II. Brussels, Secretariat General,
AV Gere CoN. A961. pps loi Nuctlear (Sei Abstr elo7eu0 OlmelOoer
Lean, G. H., Crickmore, M. J., "Methods for Measuring Sand Transport
Using Radioactive Tracers." In Radtotsotopes in Hydrology. Vienna,
International Atomic Energy Agency, 1963, pp. 111-31. Nuclear Sci.
Abstr. 18:1917, 1964.
Magin, G. B., Bizzell, O. M., "Some Applications of Radioisotope
Technology to Water Resources," Isotopes Radiation Technol. 2:12h-33,
Winter, 1964-65. Nuclear Sci. Abstr. 19:13830, 1965.
McHenry, J. R., McDowell, L. L., "The Use of Radioactive Tracers
in Sedimentation Research," J. Geophys. Res. 67:1465-71, 1962.
Nuclear Sci. Abstr. 16:17898, 1962. Chem. Abstr. 61:472h, 196}.
(From Reference 41.)
Minami, K., "Measurement of Sand-Drift on the Seabed by a Water-
Tight G-M Detector," Radioisotopes (Tokyo) 14:83-8, March 1965.
Nuclear Sci. Abstr. 19:24736, 1965.
Nakamichi, M., Shiraishi, N., “Recent Research on Sand Drift in Japan."
In International Congress of Navigation, 20th, Baltimore, 1961. Ocean
Navigation. Sect. II. Brussels, Secretariat General, A.I.P.C.N.,
1961, pp. 101-24. Nuclear Sci. Abstr. 16:24003, 1962.
A-24
65.
66.
67.
68.
69.
70.
abe
(Zo
(Se
Th.
(Bz
(6
Pedrick, R. A., Magin, G. B., "Radioisotopes in Oceanographic
Research," WNucleonics 24:42-4, No. 6, 1966. Nuclear Sci. Abstr.
20:29401, 1966.
Petersen, B. R., "Some Radioactive Surface Labeling Methods,"
Ingenigren 4:99-102, 1960. Nuclear Sci. Abstr. 17:117, 1963.
Petersen, M., "Studies on Sandy Surfcoasts with gate n Atomkern-
energie 8:285-94, July-Aug, 1965. Nuclear Sci. Abstr. 20:2060, 1966.
Pilgrim, D. H., Watson, K. K., "The Application of Radioisotope
Techniques to Water Engineering Investigations," J. Inst. Eng.
(Australia) 37:175-84, July-Aug, 1964. Nuclear Sci. Abstr.
2OR SUSI AG66 &
Popovici, A., "Hydraulic Fissures and the Use of Radioactive Isotopes,"
Petrol si Gaze (Bucharest) 7:461-4, 1956 (German summary). Chem.
Abstr. 52:4153c, 1958.
PUMA y dle Liev somMart nti Bers WLS R Serve vsn Aulelkerar ie Hiv eth OWemn i Ge 5
"Thames Siltation Investigations; Preliminary Experiment on the Use
of Radioactive Tracers for Indicating Mud Movements," Atomic Energy
Research Establishment (Great Britain), Internal Report 1576, 1954.
(From References 41 and 62.)
Putman, J. L., Smith, D. B., "Radioactive Tracer Techniques for Sand
and Silt Movements Under Water,” Intern. J. Appl. Radiation and
Isotopes 1:24-32, 1956. Nuclear Sci. Abstr. 10:11194, 1956. (From
References 41 and 62.)
Rispal, C. (Patent to Commissariat a 1'Energie Atomique), "Radio-
active Labeling of Sandy Sediments," Fr. 1,338,882, Oct. 4, 1963;
Appi’. June 25, 1962: 12 pp. Chem. Abstr.) 60:14239b, 1964.
Sakagishi, S., "Investigation of the Movement of Mobile Bed Material
in the Estuary and on the Coast by Means of Radioactive Material,"
J. Oceanog. Soc. Japan 19:27-36, 1963. Nuclear Sci. Abstr. 18:4010,
1964. (From Reference 41.)
Sarma, T. P., Iya, V. K., "Preparation of Artificial Silt for Tracer
Studies near Bombay Harbor," J. Sci. Ind. Research (India) B19:98-
101, 1960. Chem. Abstr. 55:21901f, 1961. (From Reference 41.)
Sato, 9., Takeshi’, I. >Danaka, Ni, "A Study: of Critical: Depth and
Mode of Sand Movement Using Radioactive Glass Sala Aba do, Wi
Johnson, editor, Proceedings of the kight Conference Coastal
Engineering, Council on Wave Research, University of California,
Berkeley, 1963, pp. 304-23 (From Reference }1.)
Sato, S., Tanaka, N., "The Investigation of Sand Movement Using
Radioactive Glass Sand in Kashima Harbour," Radioisotopes (Tokyo)
11:355-62, 1962 (in Japanese). Nuclear Sci. Abstr. 17:8291, 1963.
A-25
Te
78.
19.
80.
81.
82.
83.
8h.
85.
86.
Schulz, H., Stroehl, G., "Investigation of Sand Migration in the
Region of the German Coast by Means of Radioactive Tracers,"
Translated by W. Bleyberg (United Kingdom Atomic Energy Authority
Research Group, Harwell, Berks, England) from Deut. Gewasserkundl.
Mitt. 4:17-27, 1960. (NP=tr-943). Nuclear Sei. Abstr. 17722455),
1963.
Smith, D. B., Eakins, J. D., "Radioactive Methods for Labeling and
Tracing Sand and Pebbles in Investigations of Littoral Drift."
In Radiotsotopes Set. Research, Proc. Intern. Conf. Parts, 1957
2:619-33, 1958. Chem. Abstr. 53:7882f, 1959.
Smith, De Ba, Parsons), ©. Vasu Glloets Re win ,.cin invesitacatdonwUsHme
Radioactive Tracers into the Silt Movement in an Ebb Channel, Firth
of Fourth (sic), 1965," (AERE-R-5080). Research Group, United King-
dom Atomic Energy Authority, Wantage (England), Nov. 1965. Nuclear
Seip Abstia 2OralO22. al O6Gr
Sie, dq Nag Santen, Dy B., "Detection of Pebbles on the Sea Floor
by Radioactive Methods," Geograph. J. 122:343-4, 1956. (From
Reference 1.)
Taney, N.E., "Laboratory Applications of Radioisotopie Tracers to
Follow Beach Sediments." In J. W. Johnson, editor, Proceedings of
the Eighth Conference Coastal Engineering. Council on Wave Research,
University of California, Berkeley, 1963, pp. 279-303. (From
Reference }1.)
Vukmirovic, V., "The Application of Radioactive Tracers in the Study
of Sand Movements in Rivers," Inst. za Vodoprivredu "Jaroslav Cerni,"
Belgrade (Yugoslavia) 1963. (NP-14667). Nuclear Sci. Abstr. 19:
13618, 1965.
Vukmirovie, V., Filip, A., Todorovic, P., Vukotic, R.,. "Radioactive
Tracers in Studying Bed Load Movement," Translated from Saopstenja
Inst. Vodoprivredu "Jaroslav Cerni" 9:31-8, No. 31, 1964. (OTS-
GWSNn 5 0/2 eae Sl— 6) ee aNuUctcar Sc im Absitasnmel GO mloli (Gamal OOdr
Vukmirovic, V., "The Application of Radioactive Tracers in the
Study of Sand Movements in Rivers": Report No. 4 (Final). Inst.
Za Vodoprivredu "Jaroslav Cerni", Belgrade (Yugoslavia). Dec.
1965. (NP-16200). Nuclear Sci. Abstr. 20:43549, 1966.
Walsh, W. J., Hammitt, F. G., "Cavitation and Erosion Damage
Measurements with Radioisotopes," Trans. Am. Nuclear Soc. 4:247-8,
Now 2.91 96l a) Muciicary ScasoAbsitr. lor O9es 1962s
Zakrocki, Z., "Preparation of Radioactive Sand," Nafta (Poland)
Mess =4s sie). 1O5en, Chems Abstr. wos ceposa amo > Or
87. Zhuvagin, I. G., Akchas'yanov, Yu. A., "A New Method for the Control
of Hydraulic Fracturing by Radioactive Isotopes," Naftyanoe Khoz.
38.7-12, No. 6, 1960. Chem Abstr. 54:20166d, 1960.
References Without Titles
88. Crickmore, M. J., La’ Houille Blanche No. 6, 1961. Proc. Roy. Soc.
(London) A270, 27-47, 1962.
89. Gibert, A., Atome et Industrie No. IV/C/17/1, Geneva, 1959. (From
Reference 30.)
90. Pattison, A., et al., Hunter Valley Research Foundation, Monograph
No. 7, 1961. (From Reference 11.)
91. Somer, E., Ingenigren, Int. Ed., 4:88, 1960. (From Reference 11.)
References With Unknown Authors
g2. "Utilization of Radioactive Tracers at Courbet-Marine; Study of the
Stabilization of a Port on the Algerian Coast," Algerian Center of
Marine Geology and Sedimentology, Cahiers Oceanog. 14:526-42, 1962.
(From Reference }1.)
93. "Radioactive Tracers in the Thames Estuary," Great Britain Hydraulics
Research Station, Howbery Park, Wallingford, Berks, England, HRS/PLA
Paper 20, 1956. Isotopes Radiation Tech. 2:124-48, Winter 1964-65.
(From Reference 23.)
94. "The Application of Radioisotopes to the Study of Bed-Load: Movement
and Transport in Rivers," Report on a Meeting of Experts, Aug. 16-18,
1964. International Atomic Energy Agency, Vienna, Feb. 1966.
(CONF-640816). (STI-REP-101). Nuclear Sci. Abstr. 20:20904, 1966.
a
ir
a
Runiers
ce
i
Nh
APPENDIX B
Towing Characteristics of an Underwater
Radiation Detector Vehicle
(USNSRDC )
NOTE: This report represents an independent study and the results of
an investigation generated by the objectives of the RIST study.
TOWING CHARACTERISTICS OF AN UNDERWATER
RADIATION DETECTOR VEHICLE
INTRODUCTION
Appendix B is a report of an investigation to evaluate the required
hydrodynamic performance of the detector vehicle. The investigation was
made for the Coastal Engineering Research Center (CERC) by the Naval Ship
Research and Development Center (NSRDC). The program included towing the
vehicle at speeds up to 6 knots in three modes as follows: (a) in a sus-
pended attitude, (b) in a survey attitude (rolling on basin floor)., and
(c) using various cable lengths with additional weight on the vehicle.
The cable tension, cable angle, and tracking attitude were observed for
each towing mode.
This report contains a description of the detector vehicle and test
procedures, presents the results of the towing tests and observations of
the vehicle towing attitude, gives predictions of the cable configurations
assumed by the towcable, and makes recommendations for modifications.
DESCRIPTION OF VEHICLE
The detector vehicle furnished by CERC to NSRDC for the tests is
shown in Figure B-l. The vehicle, designed to roll along the bottom in
its survey attitude, consists of a cylindrical housing made of expanded
metal reinforced on its rolling surface with stainless steel rods. The
detection mechanism and electronics assembly, which is pendulous, is
attached to a shaft through the housing that provides protection for the
assembly. A tow bail is attached at each end of the shaft and provides
for a single-point towcable attachment. The electrical cables for the
detection equipment exit from one end of the shaft, are attached along
the tow bail to the towcable attachment, and then are married to a 1/4-
inch-diameter wire rope towcable. Physical characteristics of the
detector are listed in Table B-I.
TABLE B-I
Physical Characteristics of Detector Vehicle and Towcable
Overall width, inches 50
Overall diameter, inches 30
Housing width, inches ho
Height, inches 30
Distance from center shaft to towpoint, inches 82
Model weight in air, pounds 505
Model weight in fresh water, pounds 410
Towcable weight per foot in air, pounds 0.6
Towcable weight per foot in fresh water, pounds 0.4
B-2
HO OU rT |
AAA IN, nee ii \M rae
Radiation - Detector Vehicle
Figure B-1.
TEST APPARATUS AND PROCEDURES
The towing tests were conducted in the high-speed basin of the David
Taylor Model Basin. Instrumentation used for the tests consisted of a
pendulum angle indicator mounted to the tow bail to measure its angular
attitude, a 1200-pound-capacity tension gage to measure tension in the
towcable at the detector vehicle, and a pendulum angle indicator to
measure the towcable angle at the point where the towcable was attached
to the towing carriage. The tension gage was connected between the body
and the towcable, and the signal leads from both the angle indicator and
tension gage were married to the towcable and connected to a strip chart
recorder on the carriage.
For the first series of tests, the detector vehicle was towed in the
suspended mode on a 12.5-foot length of cable in the deepwater portion of
the basin at speeds from 0 to 6 knots in 1-knot increments. The tension
in the towcable at the detector and the angular attitudes of the towcable
both at the detector and at the towing carriage were measured, and the
towing behavior of the detector vehicle was observed.
In tests to determine the tracking behavior of the detector and the
maximum towing speed for the detector to remain in a survey attitude (on
the bottom), the detector was towed on cable lengths of 12.5, 25, and 50
feet of cable at speeds up to 6 knots. The angle and tension values were
monitored for each speed and cable length while observations were made of
the tracking and lift-off behavior. These tests were made in the shallow-
water portion (10 feet deep) of the high-speed basin.
In the tests to determine the effect additional weight has on the
tracking behavior and maximum survey speed, approximately 100 pounds of
sheet lead were added around the detector mechanism. The detector vehicle
was towed on 12.5 and 25 feet of cable at speeds up to 6 knots in the
shallow portion of the high-speed basin. The angular attitude and tow-
cable tensions were monitored for each speed and cable length, and ob-
servations were made of the vehicle towing and tracking behavior.
TOWING BEHAVIOR
The detector vehicle, in the suspended mode, towed steadily at each
speed up to 6 knots. There were no apparent oscillations, and the vehicle
towed directly aft of the towpoint with no yawing attitude. When the
vehicle was in its survey attitude on the 12.5-, 25-, and 50-foot cable
lengths, it tracked directly aft of the towpoint with no yaw. The ex-
panded metal housing rolled along the bottom for all speeds up to about
3.5 knots on the 12.5-foot cable, about 4.0 knots on the 25-foot cable,
and about 4.5 knots on the 50-foot cable. When the vehicle lost contact
with the bottom, it would cease to rotate. The addition of approximately
100 pounds of weight in the vehicle did not produce the desired increase
in rolling speed (speed at which the vehicle would leave the bottom) but
had no adverse effects on the tracking behavior. j
TOWCABLE TENSIONS AND ANGLES
The cable tensions measured at the detector vehicle as a function of
speed are shown in Figure B-2 for the vehicle in the suspended condition
on 12.5 feet of cable and in the survey condition of 12.5, 25, and 50
feet of cable. As shown by the figure, the tensions for the survey con-
dition are less than the tensions for the suspended condition for all
speeds less than 3.4 knots for the 12.5-foot cable, 4.0 knots for the
25-foot cable and 4.3 knots for the 50-foot cable. When the tension in
the survey condition equaled the tensions in suspended condition, the
vehicle lost contact with the bottom. This was substantiated by observa-
tions made during the tests. However, there occurred in the suspended
condition a tension difference for each speed as a function of towcable
length. This difference is attributed to an increase in vehicle drag
due to proximity of the vehicle to the bottom of the basin.
The cable angle at the detector vehicle and at the towing carriage
are shown in Figure B-3 for the suspended condition. The cable angles
obtained when the vehicle was towed in the survey condition are not shown
Since they are of no practical value.
PREDICTION TECHNIQUE AND CONFIGURATIONS
Cable configurations were predicted using the computer program
described by Cuthill (1964). The program is based on the theory of
Pode (1951) and the following conditions and assumptions:
1. All calculations are for standard sea conditions (45° North
Latitude, 3.5 percent salinity, and 59° Fahrenheit.
2. A mean cable diameter of 1.0 inch is used for the cable.
The towcable consists of two bundles of electrical con-
ductors and a 0.25-inch-diameter wire rope.
3. The weight of the cable per unit length in water is 0.4
pounds per foot.
4. The drag coefficient for the cable when perpendicular to
the stream is 3.0. The assumed coefficient is based on
iterative calculations to fit computed angle predictions
to the measured cable angle data. The coefficient is higher
than that used for single cables, but this can be expected
-because of the multi-cylindrical shapes in close proximity
to each other and because of the vibrations associated with
unfaired towcables.
5. The ratio of drag per unit length of cable when parallel
to the stream to the drag per unit length of cable when
perpendicular to the stream is 0.02.
Tension in pounds
12.5 feet deep water suspended
12.5 feet shallow water survey attitude
25.0 feet shallow water survey attitude
50.0 feet shallow water survey attitude
y
hi
Speed in knots
Figure B-2. Cable Tension at the Detector Vehicle
(Data are for conditions without 100-
pound added weight)
B-6
Cable Angle » in degrees
Towcable
Direction
of Motion
» poids dof
Be
Re SeBE
SEE
Speed in knots
Figure B-3. Cable Angles at Detector and Towing Carriage
for the 12.5-foot Cable
The computations were made for speeds from 1 to 6 knots and cable
lengths up to 240 feet. The resulting predictions are presented in
Figure B-4 as depth of detector as a function of cable length in the
water for speeds of 1 to 6 knots and in Figure B-5 as tension at the
ship as a function of cable length in the water.
Figure B-4 may be used as a guide to determine the minimum amount of
cable that must be used to reach a desired depth for a particular survey
speed. Figure B-5 may be used as a guide to determine the strength of
cable required for a particular survey speed.
CONCLUSIONS AND RECOMMENDATIONS
Based on the results of the towing tests, the following are concluded:
1. ‘The detector vehicle has good tracking characteristics for
all speeds up to 6 knots.
2. The detector housing will not rotate unless in contact
with the bottom.
3. At the design survey speed of 4 knots and a cable scope of
200 feet, the detector will maintain bottom contact in water
depths down to 80 feet. At an increased speed of 6 knots,
contact is maintained at depths down to 55 feet.
4, The addition of approximately 100 pounds of weight will
neither effectively increase the bottom contact capability
nor impair the tracking characterisitcs of the vehicle.
In using the CERC towcable during survey operations, one obvious
modification is recommended. The present towcable, consisting of a
1/4-inch wire rope and two plastic tubes containing the electrical leeds,
should be replaced by an electro-mechanical towcable. This modified cable
might be constructed of two reverse lays of steel wire wrapped around a
core containing the necessary electrical conductors. This arrangement
should simplify handling, reduce the drag on the towcable, increase the
depth capability for a shorter length of cable, and make the electrical
bundles less susceptible to wear.
Detector Depth in feet
saree
120
80
40
0 40 80 120 160 200 240
Cable Length in Feet
Figure B-4, Minimum Required Cable Length as a Function
of Detector Depth for Various Speeds
Tension in pounds
600
Figure B-5.
100 150 200 250
Cable Length in feet
Tension at Towing Ship as a Function of Cable
Cable Length for Various Speeds
B-10
APPENDIX C
RIST STATUS REPORT
by
ISOTOPES DEVELOPMENT CENTER
OAK RIDGE NATIONAL LABORATORY, OAK RIDGE, TENNESSEE
Operated by UNION CARBIDE CORPORATION for the
U. S. ATOMIC ENERGY COMMISSION
Contract No. W-7405-eng-26 ORNL-4 341
RADIOISOTOPIC SAND TRACER STUDY (RIST)
STATUS REPORT FOR MAY 1966 - APRIL 1968
E. H. Acree, H. R. Brashear, F. N. Case, and N. H. Cutshall
ABSTRACT
The Radioisotopic Sand Tracer Study (RIST) was initiated
in May 1966 as a miltiagency cooperative effort to
develop technology and survey equipment for sediment
transport studies with the objective of determining
direction and amount of sand movement. To prove the
system effective a test was planned to determine how
sand moves around a headland where a change in beach
direction occurs on either side of the headland. The
first two years of the work done at ORNL consisted
primarily in developing equipment and techniques for
studying sand transport in the littoral zone. Field
operations to evaluate the equipment and to develop
more effective procedures were conducted at Cape
Kennedy, Florida, at Surf, California, and at Point
Conception, California. In these tests sand tagged
with 133Xe was released on the ocean floor in the
study area at a depth of 30 ft. The dispersion and
transport of the labeled sand were observed with
cesium iodide detectors contained in a specially de-
signed detector transport vehicle (ORNL Underwater
Survey System). The detector assembly was towed
through the ocean by an amphibious vessel. Charts
of the isoactivity contours were prepared from some
of the data to estimate direction and velocity of
sand transport.
INTRODUCTION
The Radioisotopic Sand Tracer Study (RIST) was initiated in May 1966, and’
the work reported here covers a two-year period. The study is continuing
and as additional field tests are made, the data will be reported. The
program objective was to develop technology and survey equipment to obtain
data from a dynamic system that could be used to obtain a reasonably
accurate description of sediment transport in the littoral zone. These
techniques, when fully developed, are expected to find use in other sedi-
ment transport systems involving waterways and inland lakes.
The specific requirements to accomplish this development were to
1. develop a survey system that can be reliably operated in the field
and have a high degree of versatility relative to environmental
variables and choice of radionuclides,
2. evaluate various radionuclides to determine those that are useful
in sediment transport experiments from the standpoint of cost,
physical properties, availability, and hazard,
3. demonstrate the utility of the system under field conditions,
4. develop a technique for determination of sand burial,
5. develop suitable tagging procedures for radionuclides considered
to be useful in sediment transport studies,
6. correlate sand transport with wave and current variables.
The multiagency study, involving the U. S. Atomic Energy Commission,
Department of the Army, Department of the Navy, Department of the Air
Force, National Aeronautics and Space Administration, and the State of
California, receives technical support from the Oak Ridge National
Laboratory and the Coastal Engineering Research Center, with direct
assistance from the Pacific Missile Range, Western Test Range, First
Strategic Aerospace Division, Corps of Engineers for Los Angeles
District, Nuclear Systems. and Space Power Division, and Department of
Water Resources. Overall direction of the project rests with the Corps
of Engineers Coastal Engineering Research Center. The Isotopes
Development Center has been responsible for
_1.. designing, fabricating, and testing of a submersible detection
- system and appropriate analyzer system,
2. assisting in the selection of applicable radioisotopes,
3. developing processes for labeling sand with radionuclides,
4. developing a radiological safety program.
During this two-year period the major effort was directed toward de-
velopment of equipment and techniques for studying sediment transport
in the littoral zone (from shore line to water depths of 30 to 50 ft).
Three field tests were conducted to evaluate equipment performance and
the effectiveness of measuring and recording procedures: one at Cape
Kennedy, Florida, one at Surf, California, and one at Point Conception,
California. Instruments and methods were modified after each operation.
In order to show the rationale of the development of survey instruments
and techniques, the field tests are reported in chronological order.
Several methods have been used to study sand movements. Fluorescent dyes
tagged onto sand grains have been used extensively, and most of the infor-
mation concerning sediment transport has been obtained with this method.
There are, however, fundamental difficulties that limit the utility of
fluorescent tags in obtaining meaningful data from dynamic systems such
as the ocean. Perhaps the most serious are the limited number of samples
that can be obtained after injection of the tagged sand and the inability
to predict sampling points.
Naturally occurring minerals have been utilized as indicators of sand
transport; however, unless the source of the mineral is well defined and
known to be the exclusive source, the data obtained are often misleading.
With radioisotope tracers, which have been used to a lesser extent, use-
ful studies of sand transport have been made in laboratory flumes and
wave basins, but definitive information can come only from field tests
(See Addendum C-1)
Field testing is divided into three major efforts: preparing and dispen-
sing the tracer in a test area, which are discussed elsewhere, surveying
the test area, and treating the data. Both radioactive and fluorescent
tracing systems have common problems relative to data treatment. Radio-
isotope tracing does, however, offer considerable advantage over the
fluorescent tracing during sampling since in situ measurements are made
and a large number of data points can be obtained. In addition, readout
data are available to assist in the determination of sample points, and
thus one is able to follow the progress of the transport system on a real-
time basis. A number of radionuclides were considered for use in sedi-
ment transport studies, and the half-life, energy of the radiation, bio-
logical hazard, and tagging method specific to various elements were
evaluated. While no single radionuclide was found to meet all the re-
quirements that would make it ideal for all tracing experiments, primary
consideration was given to those radioisotopes that have a low biological
hazard. This characteristic was especially important during the early
phases of the field testing when data could be collected:to serve as a
basis for determining the concentration or dilution of tagged sand that
may occur during tracing studies. Also, radiation exposure to be ex-
pected could be determined. Such data could then be used to determine
hazards associated with the use of other radionuclides in tagging sediment.
After tagged sand has been placed in the ocean, as a point source or as a
line source, surveys are made to determine transport. This is done either
by collecting grab samples and taking them to a laboratory for counting or
by making the measurements on the ocean floor. Since the in situ measure-
ment yields data rapidly, it was considered to be the more promising method
for gathering information for littoral transport studies.
Selecting the Radioisotope
Some of the nuclear properties consideredin selecting the radioisotope for
further evaluation were half-life, type of radiation, and radiation energy.
Neutron-deficient radioisotopes, because of their low production yields,
and radioisotopes with half-lives of less than 2 days or greater than
15 days were arbitrarily excluded.Table C-1 presents some of the data
that were used for making the initial selection. Three of the radio-
isotopes, De Or realli TSN and 1°°Xe, were of special interest because
of their nuclear properties.
Table C-1, Comparative Data on Radioisotopes
Maximum
Half- Principal Permissible Comparative
Life, Gamma Radi- Burden Uptake (Fish),
Tsotope days ation, MeV (Man), wuCi relative units
131Ba 12 0.496 (48%) 50 3
0.124 (28%)
LCs i, 1248) 1.596 (96%) 4 3
cE 8.05 0.364 (82%) On 2
aA, 7.5 0.247 (1%) 20 1
0.342 (6%)
TOOK 5.2 0.081 (37%) e 0
198, y 2.7 0.412 (95%) ZO). 9 Sal
RE Sean PERS aah oe Pee eS an Sie EROS TL a Fy EES PO LL Ie
C. M. Lederer, J. M. Holland, and I. Perlman, Table of Isotopes, 6th ed.,
Wiley, New York, 1967.
Handbook No. 69, U. S. Dept. of Commerce, National Bureau of Standards,
July 5, 1959.
No retention.
Barium-140-lanthanum-140 had been used for sand tracing, and techniques for
tagging sand had been developed by the Naval Radiological Defense Labora-
tory. However, this radionuclide has two disadvantages: (1) The exces-
Sively high energy gamma rays (1.6 MeV) make handling and radiation ex-
posure control difficult. (2) Tagging sand with 14°Ba-14°%La consists of
coating the surface of the sand grains with sodium silicate containing
the radionuclide, and initially it was not known whether or not this would
affect the hydraulic properties of the sand (later experiments indicated
that little, if any, adverse effect resulted from this labeling technique).
Gold-198 has also been used on various projects, but the evaluation of the
198;y-labeled materials has been very limited. Leaching rates, efficiency
of tagging, and actual labeling procedures are not described in detail.
Also, it was believed that the half-life of this nuclide (D7 ad) would
limit tracing experiments to one week or less. However, 198, was main-
tained high on the list of useful isotopes since it can be prepared in
large quantities at a relatively low cost and the biological hazard is
low (Table c-2), (In a later study, which will be reported separately, it
Cao5
azenboapy
wet qord
sutsusedstp fskep
09-0€ pirezey
oyeTepow ‘sway
-sfs [eOTSOTOTG
uT pe yer4ZUSsDUND
yorveq
pues jo eZTs uo
YFWTT ou fpues
JO 194FT/FO 49
peqFwETun
wetTqoid
Sutsusdstp fsquow
-Ttadx9 Yyoom-T
IO} JUSTTIOxXSE
§4yteuTtT ATTeSoOTSOT
-oTq ATOATIETOY
yo veq
pues jo 9azTts uo
VEWTT ou ‘pues
JO 124TT/FO 008
azenbapy
sweTqord Sutsued
-STp JouTW fasTtTt
-JTey BuotT 07 onp
prezey TerTquezod
§qyzreuz ATTeoFSoOTOT,
pues jo
SI94TT Ot/FO 9£00°0
ayvenbepy
weTqoid Sutsued
-S—Tp ou §quow
-Tdedxe yoom
-c~ JOF JUST
-Te0xK9 f[429UT
AT TBO FSOTOTL
pues jo
STOTT O4/FO T
AVTTEQeT Peay
SoFqsTieqyoereyo 3s
aInpss0id BSut3ssey
UT pees epttTonu
-OTpez TO-OOOT Sutsn
qgndqyno euues [njyesn
04 SATYETeI poyyzeu
Sutsse1 jo AouaToTs sy
oXeer 7
PSZFETSWUIOU OFH *UT
T ysnoriyy *TeqysAro
SpTpot umppos *uUuT-¢g
9°0 fe) 90°0O T ‘KousTOTSJEe UoTzo940q
%Q ‘euuled YOOT!ST*O ?MVeer %LE°OQ ‘eumres ZO0T Seuures PTetA pue
AW-2 "0 %00T ‘HO SNVget A®W-S"0 APW-TB8O0* 0. uotyeTper [NFEsf)
P qT'S MV et
P gle PLS NWger £ )2°0T pas eITT-ITeH
TS-umTwory) 66T-Q6T-PTOD uo yd hry ¢¢T-uouex
SUTSSe], pues UT esq JOT sapT[Tonuofpey Texzevsg jo sefytedozg go uostredwog9 ‘*d-0 STI8L
was found that under the influence of high waves the transport of sediment
is rapid and that useful data can be obtained within the time available
before decay of the radionuclide seriously reduces the radiation available
for detection. )
Because *°°%xXe is biologically inert and has a half-life of 5.27 d, it met
most of our criteria for sand-tracing experiments. However, the low-energy
(80-keV) gamma radiation required that the detector system have a high de-
gree of sensitivity and imposed the limitation that only tagged sand moving
at or near the surface of a sand column could be detected. On the other
hand, the use of low-energy gamma radiation reduced the handling and dis-
pensing problems as far as radiation exposure to personnel is concerned.
Tagging procedures were developed (Addendum C-1)to adsorb *°°xXe onto sand.
Evaluation of 199Ye-Tagged Sand
Since sand tagged with a rare gas loses activity, due to diffusion as well
as_to decay of the oS xe (Ty /o = 5.27 d), data derived through use of
Xe-tagged sand must be corrected to an "effective half-life." Test
samples prepared by the foregoing procedure were counted over a period of
several days and there was little incremental loss (over decay) (Fig. C-1)
Experiments also showed that no loss of activity could be attributed to
leaching by seawater (Teble C-3).In a test of labeling uniformity, random
quantities of tagged sand were counted and compared on the basis of the
1 OEAL SOW GICB e223 quantity of sorbed *°°xe versus the
quantity of sand(Table C-4).Although
the uniformity was fair, the radia-
5 oe tion counts from the samples varied
Se from high to low by a factor of 3.
@.
ei aaa Subsequent tests have shown that spe-
INU Se eee cific minerals in sand do not tag with
2 —t
the same efficiency. This causes: the
individual sand grains to wey with
‘ _ respect to the quantity of LXer that
is adsorbed.
5
radiation counts/min
~5 days
THEORETICAL Samples were also tagged, separated
5 : into particle-size fractions, weighed,
os and counted to determine whether those
fractions making up the bulk Ch, as
“al : sand contained the bulk of the Xe.
ie As shown in Fig.C-2, the correlation
fe)
between size distribution and xenon
sorption is good. The slight tailing
@,
io N off of the large particles is prob-
100 200 300 400 500 ably due to specific minerals that
ee tend to concentrate in the large-
Fig. C-1. Apparent Half-Life pai‘ticle fractions.
of 133x¢_Tagged Sand
Table C-3. Seawater Leach Test on 133Xe-Tagged Sand
Activity, counts/min Ratio,
Leach Time, hr Control Test control/test
TMeisity «NO
Beginning Oso) 32 16> Loli? se LO 0.67
72 0.58 x 10° One) se WO 0.65
96 0.53 x 10° Oss) se Io 0.67
Test No. 2
Beginning Wen oe aor Ball se AO LZ
48 Qe se Oe BoD xe LOM i, (2
120 Meh se MO odl, xe aor ge
Test No. 3
Beginning 539), oc lOs Boy se Wor Doll,
48 Avge se Oe DoD 52 OM Theil
120 dg? sels Wo se NOS Tea?
Table C-4. Uniformity Test on 1°%Xe-Tagged Sand
Activity
Weight of Counts per
Sample Sand, mg Counts per sec” mg of sand
1 TALatl 1634 1140
2 52.8 1746 1650
3 96.9 1108 570
4 oh 3 534 1100
5 62.3 1774 1400
6 Sal 1334 1290
le 43.6 670 770
8 55740 1430 1300
9 4o.4 1512 1780
10 53.1
648 610
Based on total counts for 50-sec period.
ORNL—DWG 68-9548
400 —— =
Me
c
5
8
g 300
5
£ 133 ye
3 200}
=
a
a
jo}
wn
x 100
mM
be
)
) 250 500 750 4000
AVERAGE PARTICLE SIZE, p
Fig. c-2, -133x6 Sorption vs Particle-Size Distribution
ORNL UNDERWATER SURVEY SYSTEM
Since most of the surveying required to measure the dispersion and trans-
port of tagged sand occurs in the surf zone, the detector system was de-
signed to operate in breakers as well as in deep water. Sleds have been
used as vehicles for transporting detectors along the bottom. Because
sleds are easily tipped in turbulent water and are subject to snagging on
underwater obstruction such as-rock ledges and large rocks, an open mesh
steel ball was designed: for use as the detector vehicle (Fig. C-3). This
PHOTO 87139
Fig. C-3. Radiation Detection System
ball contains the radiation detectors and is towed behind an amphibious
vessel on a 150-ft-long cable. Operating characteristics were found to
be excellent in very rough surf and moderatly rocky bottom conditions.
While the detector ball is unaffected by heavy surf, early surveys paral-
lel to the beach were limited by the ability of the tow vessel tg oper-
ate broadside to the breakers. Survey tracks were made from ~45 to 90
to the beach face to overcome this problem.
The radiation measuring equipment shown in Fig.C-3is an underwater mobile
system that can be rolled along the ocean floor, efficiently detect the
80-keV gamma rays from Ioexer and operate on the beach, in the surf zone,
and in the ocean to depths of 200 ft.
Detector System
The detector system consists of four 2- by 2-in. sodium-activated cesium
iodide crystals housed in 0.030-in.-thick anodized aluminum cans. These
cans are mounted in a 1/2-in.-thick stainless steel plate that forms the
bottom section of a sealed chamber attached to the axle of the ball. As
the ball rotates on the stationary axle, the detectors remain oriented
toward the surface over which the ball moves. Since the canned crystais
are exposed to the water pressure, a 1/2-in.-thick Plexiglas light pipe
is used as a pressure barrier (see Fig.C-4.) Photomltiplier tubes and
preamplifiers are mounted in the detector chamber and are thus protected
from the water and pressure.
Fig. C-4. Underwater Detector Component
c-10
The photomultiplier tubes (RCA-6655A) operate with a negative voltage of
7OO to 900 V. This 200-V range permits gain adjustment of the tubes so
that the responses from all four of the detectors will be equal. The tubes
are 2 in. in diameter and have ten stages. The preamplifiers (one for each
tube) consist of three emitter-followers in cascade. The preamplifier out-
put is matched in a 50-ohm coaxial cable (RG-174-u) which carries both the
positive 24-V de power to the preamplifiers and the output voltage pulses
from the preamplifiers. These pulses are transmitted to a mixer on board
the tow vessel. The single output pulse from the mixer is fed to the amp-
lifier of the multichannel analyzer (PIP-400).
The sides of the cylinder used to transport the detector assembly are fabri-
cated with rectangular steel bars to form an open lattice with a minimum of
shielding of the detector crystals. This allows the 80-keV gamma and a
fraction of the 30-keV x-ray from Xe to reach the detectors, which are
positioned approximately 2 in. from the surface over which the cylindrical
ball travels. The entire device is covered with expanded metal to exclude
stones and other debris and to provide mechanical protection (Addendum C-4).
The detector housing is weighted with lead to maintain the detectors in a
vertical position('see AddendumC-5 for description of the device that indi-
cates the position of the detector assembly). At a speed of 3 mph, however,
the forward motion of the rolling device causes the detector housing to be
~5° off-center toward the back. Since the count rates are a direct func-
tion of geometry, an experiment was designed to determine the difference
between the count rates obtained when the detector housing was in the vert-
ical position and when it was off-center. The following results were ob-
tained for three variations from vertical:
Og 910 counts/sec
5° 880 counts/sec
Oe 800 counts/sec
The difference of 30 counts/sec or ~3% for an angle of 5° (normal operating
angle) indicates that the count rate is not appreciably affected by an off-
center movement of the detector housing.
The towing characteristics of the detector assembly were determined by the
Naval Ship Research and Development Center, Tests proved
that with a tow cable 200 ft long the detector assembly was stable and re-
mained on the bottom at a depth of up to 80 ft at a speed of up to 6.7 fps.
Changing the length of the cable will modify the speed at which the assembly
can be towed and still remain on the bottom. It was also established that
the assembly would remain in the survey position (detectors pointed toward
the bottom) ‘even when it was pulled rapidly through the water column. How-
ever, the tow cable and the plastic tube containing the conductor cables
oscillated, and it was evident that. the conductor cables would be damaged
if they. were towed rapidly through the water for long periods of time.
Gil
Data Collection System
Individual signals from the four detectors are fed through cables to the
surface vessel and into a mixer. A differential discriminator sorts the.
proper signals and feeds a multichannel analyzer (PIP-400) (see Fig.C-3)
that can operate in a pulse-height mode or in a multiscaler mode (normal
operating mode for survey is the multiscaler). This system stores counts
from the detector for a time set by the operator. The possible accumula-
tion times are 10, 1, 0.1, and 0.01 sec. The information can be displayed
on an oscilloscope, typed out on a teletype unit, or punched on a tape.
In the multiscaler mode the analyzer operates as 400 individual counters.
A counter stores the signals from the detectors for the time set by the
operator. The analyzer automatically changes from counter to counter
according to the preset time intervals. With a data accumulation time of
10 sec, an uninterrupted survey can be conducted for 4000 sec, or approx-
imately 65 min. At the end of the period the data must be typed and
punched on tape, which requires approximately 4.5 min. With this system
the starting time as well as the position coordinates must be logged. All
data must be correlated with the time and position log.
CAPE KENNEDY FIELD OPERATION (APRIL 1967)
Purpose
The operation was conducted in the beach area adjacent to Cape Kennedy,
Florida, and was the initial field trial for the ORNL Underwater Survey
System. The major objective was to check the operating characteristics
of the detector system and the towing characteristics of the cylindrical
detector housing.
Operational Procedure
A 1.45-kg batch of sand that had been tagged with 30 mCi of 1°°Xe by the
techniques described in Addendum C-2 was used.Scuba divers placed the sand
within a 3-ft-dia area at a water depth of 30 ft, approximately one-half
mile off the Florida coast. The underwater detector was towed through the
area by an amphibious vessel (LARC V). No navigation system was used, and
no established search pattern was followed. The purpose was merely to de-
termine whether the detectors could detect the 133Xe-tagged sand that had
been placed on the ocean bottom. Initial passes through the injection
area showed no activity. The search was expanded, and the tagged sand was
detected approximately 100 yards from its original injection area.
A device to inject 40-liter batches of sand onto the ocean bottom was
tested for shipboard operation. Sand placed in a hopper was flushed from
the hopper through a l-in. hose that reached to the ocean bottom in about
30 ft of water. A pump with a flow rate of 12 gpm was used to supply salt
water to the injection system, and no difficulty was experienced in trans-
ferring sand from the hopper to the bottom.
Ca\2
Observations
The underwater detector system appeared to be very stable in the surf
zone, and broadside breakers had little effect on its tracking ability.
The 80-keV gamma rays from the 1°°Xe-tagged sand were detected with
reasonable efficiency; counts in the tens of thousands per second were
observed. The system was stable, and all detectors functioned properly.
No malfunctions were observed in the sand-pumping device. The sea con-
ditions were mild, with ocean swells ~1 ft high. The tagged sand ap-
peared to be in patches that formed a pattern. Liberal interpretation
(since the survey was very limited) of the data revealed a series of
waves running perpendicular to the beach. No significance was placed
on this interpretation in regard to sand transport mechanisms.
Alterations Indicated by Test
Since it was known that large rocks are located near the area selected
for the next test (Surf, California), it was decided to utilize a weak
link in the tow cable so that the link would break if the detector
assembly became lodged in the rocks. Breaking of the link would allow
additional tow cable to play out and thus give the LARC operator time
to stop. Also, it was recognized that sea conditions would be less
favorable at Point Conception, California (the last test), and plans
were formulated to provide a metal cabin shelter for the instruments, as
well as for housing all the on-board equipment, to afford some protection
from ocean spray.
SURF FIELD OPERATION (JUNE 1967)
Purpose
The operation at Surf, California, was a full-scale sand-tracing experi-
ment conducted in order to test all developmental components and to
establish operational techniques for handling 58-kg quantities of tagged
sand. This area was chosen because all access is controlled by the U. S.
Air Force and because future requirements at Vandenberg Air Force Base
indicate a need for additional informaticn concerning sand transport in
the area.
Operational Procedure
Considerable difficulty was experienced in making the first 116-kg
injection. Tagged sand in the hopper of the injection device became wet
with ocean spray and would not flow properly; therefore the sand was
dumped into the water from the surface. Because of ocean currents this
caused the sand to disperse over a large area, and omly background radia-
tion levels were detected. For the next injection the sand-pumping de-
vice was again used, but in a siightly different mammer: the sand was
pumped to the bottom in a water slurry. Here again, however, very little
Cras
133Ye radiation was detected. These injections and the associated surveys
were hampered by very large rocks. Therefore the third, and last, injec-
tion, which was placed on the ocean floor by scuba divers, was made in an
area that was relatively free of rocks. This injection was successful,
and surveys were made in the area for three consecutive days.
A radar navigation system was used in this survey. Navigational fixes were
taken at 2-min intervals and the data were entered in a time log, as were
the starting and stopping times of the analyzer. Recorded count levels
were corrected for background and decay and then plotted.
Observations
The Surf operation established that 133ye-tagged sand can be traced for
several days over relatively long distances. Charts of isoactivity con-
tours (Fig.C-5)showed that the tagged sand from the last injection had been
dispersed over an area approximately 600 by 1200 ft when surveillance ended
(after 3 days). From all indications the batch could have been traced for
a much longer period of time, perhaps up to ten days after release.
The detector system worked well. Tracking performance and towing stability
were good; however, several changes in equipment and in operational proced-
ures were indicated, such as better correlation of data. Analysis of the
data showed areas that should have been covered.more extensively and areas
that required less coverage. Also, slight variations in the time log and
in the recording of the starting and stopping times of the analyzer made it
very difficult to analyze the data. Although some protection was afforded
by a metal shelter available at the test site, it was evident that better
protection would be required for the electronic instruments.
Alterations Indicated by Test
Following the Surf operation a system was designed and built to integrate
and record location, time, and radiation data (see Fig. C-6). A real-time
readout of typewritten and punched paper-tape records allowing instantan-
eous evaluation of results, as well as a more sophisticated analysis at a
later time, was provided.
An instrument shelter was built (Fig. C-7)which incorporates enclosed motor
generators and a complete forced-air handling system to keep the instru-
ments dry. The instruments and the shelter are completely self-supporting.
Since it was recognized that the Point Conception area would be a very dif--
ficult area to survey because of extensive rock outcropping and severe surf
conditions, backup equipment was built. A complete spare detector assembly
was fabricated. The electronic equipment has been fabricated with enough
flexibility to permit the interchanging of components. This feature ensures
the accumulation of radiation data. For example, since each detector is an
independent unit, one or all four can be operated at any given time. Two
data-recording systems exist, and if the automatic data-correlation system
should fail, data can be accumulated manually by using the multichannel
analyzer.
C-14
ORNL-DWG 67-8504A
ZX <7 1
=f =e
WAVE DIRECTION
C = CZ |
Figure C-5. Dispersion Pattern of 133x¥e-Tagged Sand. (a) 1 day
after release of sand; (b) 2 days after release of sand.
RT Tt i La a
a MN TMERNTINRIEM MRT
iss i a hh a st Neca lA
if Pie Lith
ie
Figure C-6. Shipboard Data Collection System.
C=I6 °
PHOTO 901924
Figure C-7. Shelter for Shipboard Instrumentation.
A new sand-dispensing apparatus was built which operates on the clamshell
principle (see Addendum C-6).
It was decided to make all future sand injections directly on the ocean
floor, since even in shallow water sand released above the bottom spreads
considerably before it settles to the bottom. Treatment of the data in
this test indicates that the data should be manually plotted on board the
survey vessel as they are collected. This is not considered to be an ac-
curate display of data, but it will permit surveyors to change the survey
pattern to yield maximum information.
POINT CONCEPTION FIELD OPERATION (DECEMBER 1967)
Purpose
The Point Conception experiment was designed to obtain information that
could be used to answer the question: Does sand move around a headland
(Point Conception)? By making three injections and.determining the trans-
port from one injection area to another, long-distance transport patterns
could be determined in a relatively short time.
(CON7/
Operational Procedure
Injections were made at three locations: one northward of Point Conception,
one on the Point, and one southward of the Point in ~30 ft of water. In
each injection 40 liters of sand tagged with ~1.2 Ci of +°"ye was used. The
sand was placed on the bottom with the clamshell device, and surveys were
made of all three sites by alternating from one site to the next.
The first injection was southward of the Point and all equipment functioned
properly except the detectors, which required frequent calibration. This
calibration problem was due to gain shift, which resulted from severe vibra-
tions caused by pulling the equipment across large rock outcrops. These
outcrops made surveying extremely difficult.
The second injection was made northward of the Point, and survey conditions
proved to be even more severe than those of the first injection.
The third injection, which was delayed several times because of bad weather,
was placed directly on the Point. Because of a large rock cutcrop (~12 ft
tall), the detector could not be pulled to the survey area from the beach
but had to be lowered to the bottom from the survey vessel. This proved to
be extremely difficult because the winch did not have adequate power to
properly control the detector assembly, which weighs approximately 400 1b;
however, the detector assembly was successfully placed on the bottom sev-
eral times and surveys were accomplished.
A fourth batch, which consisted of only 1 liter of sand tagged with 200 mCi
of IES was placed in the breaker zone as a preliminary pce to observe
the dispersal rate chet would be encountered in future tests planned for
the surf zone.
Observations
All the injections were successful. The new data system worked well but -
the 10-sec collection period seemed to be too long. Rocks in the survey
areas and the necessity of pulling the detector assembly from the beach
to the area caused some difficulty with the detectors. Because of gain
shift and noise, frequent adjustments were required, making it difficult
to correlate radiation data on a day-to-day basis. Although survey areas
were covered many times, very little radiation data were collected (see
pages 59-65). Two explanations are possible: either the sand was buried
or it was not transported. In the latter case, radiation detection would
be obscured because it is virtually impossible to place the detector as-
sembly directly on the injection point. In future tests an attempt will
be made to determine which explanation is valid.
The preliminary test (fourth injection) for determining whether there
would be any future problems associated with surf zone surveys went well.
Initial conclusions are that the system can functicn in the surf zone.
C=18
Alterations Indicated by Test
Since sand transport is rapid in the surf area, the surveys need to be
done in the shortest time period possible. Data wiil be useful only if
the data collection period is short compared with the time required for
the tracer pattern to develop. Our present accumulation period is 10 sec.
Since the detector surveys a strip 2 ft wide, at a tow speed of 3 to 5
fps the radiation data are averaged over an area of 50 to 100 ft=. We
believe that this area is too large and are therefore modifying the sys-
tem to print out every second. This will permit a larger survey ina
mach shorter time span. Models of experiments indicate that this survey
time will be a definite improvement.
The photomultiplier tubes will be changed to high-shock-resistant tubes.
An electromechanical cable will be purchased and adapted to the survey
system. This cable will make it possible to use a power winch and drum
to raise and lower the detector assembly. Slight modifications and ad-
ditions will be made to accommodate multiple photopeaks.
Calg
ADDENDA C-1 to C-6
to
APPENDIX C
7894 PLets
SeT 3899 jo sqrnsey
soqTdures
UIM a4eTetIOD 04
JFMoTFFETD SYED pe,eToy
weqysks ofTweuAp jo
uote IUesSeIdet pood
uTeIqgO O04 STQTSssod
qou ‘mots Buyptdueg
SoTdwes TenpTATput
uo pedtnber stskTeuy
eusuoueud ytodsuerq 04
peyeTer ATTseea you uoty
-ei1jUusou0D pue BUT yA10S
4Fatuxse Aeu TetsutTw jo
SoTYSTdezyoereyo fszaqumu
peyrwtt ‘setdwes qeag
‘9TNOTSJTpP sutTdueg
SUTTpuey Tetoseds
ou soitnbar £4800 Moz
7894 PTets
SeT 4899 fo sqtssey
so Tdures
UYTIM S4ZeTet{od 07
FTQOTFFTD SYED PSPETOY
weyisfhs otweufp jo
uot ee UUSeseidazt poos
uteyqo 04 9eTqTssod
qou ‘mots Suptdweg
STerouTw
punoszsyoeq [Tein7eUu
WOTf sdUaTEeTIE4UrT
‘peritnbez stsATeuy™
PIETS UE AQTPTTeA
eTdwes ou fsizequmu
peqrwtt ‘setdwes qeas
'QTNoOTSIEp Suptdureg
SuTTpuey
Tetoeds ou sartnbes
$4so00 YSTYU 04 eqetTapop
TY
tHé~ uoTyeNTeAS TeTyTUT
fptdez 4s94 jo sqtnsey
eyep
TOYO YT po ,eT
-eitoo ATTsee soetduresg
weqs As
ofFweufp ut Sut {dures
ofuweutp {yess Suptdweg
n4TsS UT
SuyTdwes pue stsATeuy
AYTPTTeA eTdues jo uoty
-BoTpPUuy ajZeTpeuMT FTeT4
-usjod eyep peyTwtTtun
Spexitnbeaz quewdtnbe
Tepfoeds fAsea BSutqtdures
SUTSUSOTT
pue Sut~Tpuey Tetoeds
§4s00 YSTYU 04 a4etIepoW
Suttdues pTtety
SeT 4894 jo sy tnsey
soTdures
UTM S4eTATIOO 04
FTQOTIFTP SYED PozVeToy
weqyshs otTweutp jo
uoTIeAUesSeAdet poos
uzeyqgo 04 9a TqtTssod
q0u ‘Mota Buptdurag
STeISUTU
punoiwsyoeq [Tem yeu
woly sodUsTETIO4UT
‘soTdwes TenpTATput
uo peitinbar stsATeuy
PTOTS UT AYTPTTeA
atdwes ou fetqtssod
SsZequnuU peqyTWTT
pue seTdues qeas
S4TNOT SIT But Tdures ,
sutTTpuey Tetoseds
ou Sseritnbet £4800 MOT
STelsuTW TeindeN
stsfTeuy UOTVeATIOW
pueg pessey-eTqeqs
pueg pesseyz,-edo7O0s ToT pey
pueg pes2ey,-queosazon Ty
Spou,oW BuToer, Jo uosTredwuog
T-0 WOUNHadY
BoIB
4se4e2l Jo uot yeUWIOy
-UF JZodsueltq4 07 dUWTy
ust=sse 04 OTqQFTSsod JON
s4soq omyng
Joy peyeutTwezUoo
oq Aew vate ASAIN
ATeyFTun swetqoad
SUOTPETSOL OFTANG
ATeYTTun swetTqosrd
SUOTPETOL OFTAN
szUuowertnbat
TeoTystyeqys pues Tet,
-uszyod otdues paytwtt o4
onp UTey1e0un ATUSTY 93q
07 paAdstTeq yrodstesy
420d ‘queutpes jo A£yTyuenb
-sueveI}, JO s0UeISTp pue pue ‘pesds ‘uotT1.8zTP
UOTJOSATP JO UOTAeUTW ufeiqo of ATessooou
-J3YeP 04 PSeYTWTIT ee UOFZOST TOO Byep Te oO]
quasqe oq
qsnul sa9dcnos ayeureite
pue peysttqeyse oq
qsnul [TetouTW JO 2d.mog
pextnbedt 1380874
JO sotgtquenb esireq
UOFPEWIOJUT TeTImq IoOF
pertnbsir Buttdwes 3.109
UOTYSWIOJUL TetTImq Ios
peitnber SuttTdwes a209
STeISUTW Teme STSATeCUY UOTICATTOVW
pueg pesse],-eTqeqs
sodo OST
SFTT-FTeY YAtoys
UTM eare ABAINS
jO SupIeeTo prdey
(TorqU00 sedoud YyyTM
PEeZTWEUTW oq ued WOdT
-qoid) 48fxe suatqoad
SuoTyeTet oF Tang
squswpzzedxe yuey
SACM PU STEPOW TeoTyeu
-oyyzeu Aq poeyeoTput
se otqtssod fqzodsues4
‘quowtpes jo Aatyuenb
pue ‘peods ‘uotyoaaTp
uTeyqO0 04 ATessaoau
UOFJZOETTOO B4ep TeLO],
peitnberz 1380874
go setytquenb [Tews
UOT} BCUTUWLIE79p
Tetinq Loy sTqtssod
SuTTdwes nqts ut
pues possey,-9do 0s ToFpey
SpouxeW SuToery, Jo uostTazeduog
(°9U09) T-0 WnaNnaay
$4894 amyng
IO} peyeutwequoo
aq Avu earte AeA
ATeYTTun swetTqoszd
SUOFVETSEI OTTANg
sqyuowertnber Teoty
-stqyeqs pue TetTque10d
aTduwes peiittT o4 enp
uteyze0un ATYSTY 9q
04 poAeTTeq 110dsuerz4
fquoutpes jo AaTaUenb
pue ‘peeds Suot1o.e1Tp
ufeqyqo o4 ATesssoeu
WOFZOSTTOO BAep TeVOL
perztnber 1390874
JO sotqytquenb esieqT
UOTPEWIOJUT TeTIMq oF
pearzg~nbet Sut{Tdures e109
pueg pessey,-jUusosazonT A
C-22
AYTTTIN YSTY TOF TeTI
-uejod queTTeoxe fe .ep
SUT IIaUTsUS BuTute.qo
uT SsouTNygesn fo 1UTOd
pedoTeaep [Tem pue suatqoid AYTATITSuas 3} 0f PSUTser you 4nq pedoTeaep [Ten pue
peusttqeyss onbtuyoay, fpezerysuowep enbtuyoay, peyverysuowsep enbtuyoay, peusTTqeyse onbpuyoay,
STetsuTW Temyzeyt stsTeuy UOTYeATIYOV pueg pesBey,-edojosfTotTpey pueg pexssey,-yusosetontTaA
pueg pesse],-eTqQe4S
SpoyuyeW SuToerz, Jo uosTszeduog
(°9400) T-9 WndNadaay
23
ADDENDUM C-2
Xenon-133 Tagging Procedure
Preparation of Sand
Sand from the test area which had been shipped to ORNL for treatment
and labeling was screened with a 10 mesh screen to remove debris, washed
with tap water, and covered with hydrochloric acid. The acid concentra-
tion was not critical but should be >6 N. The mixture was held in a well-
ventilated area for ~24 hr and occasionally stirred,’ until all signs of a
reaction with carbonates had ceased. After the sand was thoroughly washed
to remove the acid and dried, it was ready for high-temperature tagging
with 15%xe.
Tagging Procedure
A 58-kg batch of prepared sand was loaded into a specially designed
furnace (see Addendum C-3), The furnace was placed in a shielded cell
equipped with manipulators, connected to a gas purification system (see
Fig. C-8), and heated to 600°C. The gases evolved from the sand during
heating were removed with a vacuum pump. At 600°C, pumping was discon-
tinued (pressure is ~0.03 cm of Hg), and 1°°Xe was admitted into the
furnace. The furnace was further heated to 850°C (requires ~3 hr) and
was then cooled, first to 150°C by circulating Ns gas that had been cooled
with liquid Ns through the cooling coils, and then to ~80°C by water.
The excess 195Xe was recovered by pumping the gas mixture through traps
cooled with liquid Ns. These traps recovered 19°Xe and allowed the bulk
of the gas contaminants (No and 05) to. pass through. The gas pressure
in the furnace after 1°°Xe addition was Lave
oes
sv)
ais ce
4-261040 375 3H
cor ra = 3 a
=e aw re TS
t 0008 em AIHGn
ERIE. De
=e
sis oF
wiRynon
RreeT er
GRA HL TIVLId
‘
mn
oe ie 9+ ciras
a JOa42 s1WH 3. ivT
Boab
SIMVA M3400 450 OxE/1
0
Om 2. 632ve0 oT
> Wouno
1 suve
el IWS
(93K51N9N4) 1.0902 200
Wars 50) eon
WaIH 2A atm 238702 749: Fer ives rucr
Wins opivad
G29
*SuTSsnoy 104098 4eq JayYeMTopuy TOJ BuUTYUNOH
aNassY
O 23M 1 13318 JL 14 Y3AI0_
Dosw
*TI-0 eansty
dow!
BEC)
3019 HOW
SINK 6
a4
ono
Soar T bivng eee pe j=
E a zi se
om al wore ee
+
C-30
ADDENDUM C-5
Detector Position Indicator
The device shown in Fig. €-12 which is used to indicate the position
of the detector housing, is floested within the watertight detector housing
and functions as a weighted pendulum. The pendulum is connected directly
to a 3-turn 5000-ohm potentiometer by a small pinion gear. This potenti-
ometer is connected to an identical potentiometer on board the vessel.
The readout is shown in the following sketch:
With the detector housing in the vertical position the ammeter, A, is
zeroed with the potentiometer, Ps. As the pendulum moves, it changes
the potentiometer, P,, which causes the ammeter pointer to move to the
right or left. This ammeter is calibrated in degrees and reflects the
position of the detector housing.
2 3/4CL
POTENTIOMETER
ole
OSTON GEAR NO. 32 60
Poona CUT FR
3/8
PINION
ie
z
” '
ae coe
z li
=)
On {
oa |
ja
at
Oo
A eH ‘ )
18 LEAD
“+ [GROovE
BREA atch wl eae aE ee ely
eae SST STRIP
' 17A6 3/4 1 YF" DRILL 2 HOLES V4
is ee COUNTERSINK Pana
! ae! 5 |
| a
>
Figure C-12. Level Indicator for Detector Housing.
ADDENDUM C-6
Clamshell Dispensing Apparatus
The clamshell dispensing apparatus, shown in Fig. C-13,was designed
to dispense 40 liters of sand on the ocean floor. The basic construction
is 16-gage stainless steel. A bridle constructed of 1/4-in.-thick nylon
rope is used to lower the apparatus to the ocean bottom. The length (03
ft) of the bridle must be adjusted under load to ensure that a proper
opening force exists. When the device is lowered and makes contact with
the bottom, the latching pins are disengaged. ‘The weight of the drum
and contents causes the apparatus to open, releasing the sand. ‘Two plugs
located in one end of the device are used for filling. In order for the
device to sink, three small plugs in the top of the device must be opened.
ae See
20.
ill
vil
i
Clamshell Dispensing Apparatus.
Figure C-13.
APPENDIX D
RADIATION DATA REDUCTION AND PLOTTING PROGRAM - RAPLOT
Prepared by
P. A. TURNER
Geology Branch
Engineering Development Division
Coastal Engineering Research Center
°INNOD NOTLVIGVY aNnousyove ¢e-8T 109 9)
*L0043 LSSYXVSN OL 2)
1333 NI NOTHONVLS 318V9 OL LSVW YVOVY WOUS ADNVLSIQ 9T=-ST 109 2)
°1004 3)
ASSYVIN 3SHL OL ¢13455 NI GuvOs8s39us SNId HLdsGd YALVM CT=-2T 109 2)
°1004 LSSYV3SN SHL OL 41435 NI HLON|AT 318V9 OT-8 109 2
*ASAYNS JO YVSA ONY AVO4HLNOW 9 =T 109 2)
GQYVD TOYLNOD VIVO NO SSIYNLNS ONY LVWHOS 2)
*AWIL NOTLOAFNI SONIS AVIS 2)
GNV GNNOYSAIVE YOS GALISYYHOD SANTVWA NOILVIGVY 40 LO1d TOEWAS 2)
(ASAUNS AGNNOYNSHIVE) SSNTVA NOTLVIGVY G3SLISYYOINN JO LO 1d 2)
TaSSAA ASAYNS AG GAMON1I0OS SANIWOVEL 9)
oLAdLNO SHL 3YV SLOTd ONIMOTN104 SHL “°YSLLONd WILNSW3SYONT 2)
YANH3T=NOSN34 VW NO ASAYNS SHL LOTd GNV LOACOYd LSTY 3HL WONS VLVG 2)
ASAYNS ALTAILIVOIOVYE AHL 39NGSY O1 SI WWH90Yd SIHL 40 3SOdYuNd JSHL 2)
LOIWdWY == AILIL 2
2n0TS *heLOeo¢TslOldvYy 11d &
910000
st0000
T0000
€T0000
270000
110000
0t0000
600000
800000
400000
900000
$00000
400000
£00000
200000
TO00000
°TASSSAN ASAYNS Ad G3M07104 ANITMOVUL 101d = T
°g
T WYSWNAN SHL HINNd *“3SN OL
13S Vivd 1S
ONTQVSY GIOAV OL Y30NO NI 13S
SLVITONI NWI105 SHL NI
*TONLNOD NOILdO LOTd
GYVD TOYLNOD LOId NO S3SIYMLN3S GNV LYWwHYo4
V1 S3HL NO 3Y3H L HONNd
*VLVG QGVY JAWOS NI
ViVO VW dO ONINNIO
-4Y 3H1 LV GaddIMS 3H OL SI9VWI GUvD JO Y3EWNN 3HL
°1SVOD dN SAVM
-W SI TNOOVSY °10045 1S4