REPORIe: FOR: IOs.
ON THE
LANCASHIRE SEA-FISHERIES LABORATORY —
ar
THE UNIVERSITY: OF LIVERPOOL,
AND THE
SHA-FISH HATCHERY AT PIEL,
=
DRAWN UP BY
Professor W. A. Herpman, D.Sc., F.R.S.,
Hon. Director of the Scientific Work,
Assisted by Mr. Anprew Scorr; A.L.S., and
Mr. James Jonnstrone, B.Sc.
WITH ILLUSTRATION
LIVERPOOL :
PrRintED BY C. TENLING AND Co., Lrp., 53, VicrorRIA STREnt.
LES O5O:s
ty . in
4
AY
ry,
I
NIVERS
:
4
U
With Complim
jul Use Ceca
Rerorr on the INvesricaions carried on during 1905
in connection with the LancasHrrE SEA-FISHERIES
Lasorarory at the University of Liverpool, and
the Sra-Fisnh Harcuery at Piel, near Barrow.
Drawn up by Professor W. A. lerpMaAN, F.R.S., Honorary
Director of the Scientific Work; assisted by Mr.
Anprew Scort, A.L.S., Resident Fisheries Assistant
at Piel; and Mr. James Jonnsronr, B.Sc., Fisheries
Assistant at the Liverpool Laboratory.
(With plates, charts and figures in the text.)
CONTENTS.
1. Introduction and General Account of the Work. (W. A. H.) 1
9. Sea-Fish Hatching at Piel. (A. S.) - = = - == ale!
3. Classes, Visitors, &c., at Piel. (A.S.) - = = = ily
4. Report on the Tow-nettings. (A. S.) - - - - 20
5. Faunistic Notes. (A.S.) - - - - - AT
6. Mussel Transplantation. (Andrew Scott and Thomas Baxter) 58
7. Trawling Observations. (J. J.) - - : - - 88
8. Marked Fish Experiments. (J. J.) - - - - - 108
9. Parasites of Fishes. (J.J.) - - - - - - 151
10. Ichthyological Notes. (J. J.) - = - - = - 186
11. Sewage pollution at Llanfairfechan. (J.J.) - - - - 192
12. Oligodyn amic action of” Copper (W. A. hae anc - = ler
18. Sea-Fish Hatching at Port Hrin. (W. A. H.) - - = 203
INTRODUCTION AND GENERAL ACCOUNT
OF THE WORK.
Tuts Record of 1905 naturally starts with three events
of considerable importance in connection with scientific
sea-fisheries work in the Irish Sea. These are :—
Ist. A renewal of the agreement between the Lanca-
shire and Western Sea-Fisheries Joint Committee and the
University of Liverpool confirming the appointment of
the Professor of Zoology as honorary head of the scientific
work, and giving an improved status and tenure to the
two scientific assistants.
2nd. The completion and formal inauguration of the
new Laboratories of Zoology at the University, which
provide greatly increased accommodation and _ facilities
for both laboratory investigation and museum work on
the fisheries of the districi,
254
pansy
Ff
9
~
3rd. The recognition of these laboratories by the
Board of Agriculture and Fisheries, and the award of a
grant to the University, towards expeuses, on account of
the scientific fisheries work carried on in the department.
The new laboratories were opened on November 18th,
1905, by the Right Hon. the Earl of Onslow, formerly
President of the Board of Agriculture and Fisheries—
“the first Minister for Fisheries ” this country has had—
in the presence of a large gathering of Zoologists and
Fisheries Authorities, including Mr. James Fletcher,
Chairman of our Local Joimt Committee, Mr. J. R.
Ragdale, Chairman of the Scientific Sub-Committee, and
other representative men; and amongst those who gave
addresses on the occasion were Sir Thomas Elliott, K.C.B.,
Permanent Secretary of the Board of Agriculture and
Fisheries, and Sir John Murray, K.C.B., the eminent
Oceanographer.
In the accompanying fig. 1, showing the front
elevation of the building, the arrows at the side point to
the windows of the floor devoted to the Fisheries Labora-.
tories, and the plan (fig. 2) shows the accommodation—
three rooms, one large and two smaller, in addition to
the Fisheries Museum. One of the smaller rooms is at
present devoted to bacteriological work, the other is Mr.
Johnstone’s laboratory, and the larger room will accom-
modate two additional investigators.
As a result of conversation and correspondence with
the Chairman of the Joint Committee and the Chairman
of the Scientific Sub-Committee, I have been led to make
the suggestion that it would be to the advantage and
convenience of the members of the Scientific Sub-
Committee that they should be brought into more intimate
and more constant relation with the details of the work
carried on in the Fisheries Laboratory by having periodic
Wert Hove
STA “FISHERIES
LABORATORY
FIRST FLOR
Fie. 2,—Sea Fisheries Laboratories and Museum,
|
Reports printed and submitted at the quarterly meetings
of the Sub-Committee. This suggestion has been
approved, and the remainder of this Introduction,
summarising as it does the work carried on during the
past year, will serve as the first quarterly report to be
submitted at the February meeting. Succeeding Reports
will deal naturally with the quarters to which they refer,
and each will bring the account of the work up to the
end of the month preceding that in which the meeting 1s
held.
Sra Fisu HatcH ine.
Mr. Scott’s operations at Piel have resulted in very
much the same measure of success as in the previous two
years—we cannot expect any marked increase upon these
numbers or any extension in the work with the present
accommodation at the hatchery. The tanks will not hold
more fish than the number now dealt with.
Although Port Erin is not in the L. and W. District,
it is impossible in thinking of broad results to discriminate
between the young fish set free in Lancashire waters and
those set free round the Isle of Man. The Irish Sea is
one natural sea-fisheries area, and whatever benefits one
part is likely to benefit the whole. True economy and
efficiency will be best attained by working the two insti-
tutions, Piel and Port Erin, as much as possible together,
so that each supplements the other and both contribute
to the common good. Lancashire can help Port Erin,
and has helped this year by getting a supply of adult
plaice to stock the spawning pond; while Port Erin can
help Lancashire by carrying on rearing experiments
which are impossible at Piel in the absence of a pond.
Consequently it will be of interest to the members of the
Lancashire and Western Committee to know that over
5
five millions of young plaice were hatched in 1905 at
Port Erin, and were set free in the sea round the south
end of the Isle of Man. It is important also to note that
large numbers of fry from the previous year’s operations
which were left to develop in the pond passed through
their metamorphosis and grew rapidly, being found of
various sizes from one to five inches in length during their
first year of lite. The largest of these young plaice,
spawned, hatched and reared in captivity, which we have
taken from our pond, measured over six inches.
Markep-Fisu EXPERIMENTS.
This work was commenced by Mr. Johnstone last
year, and has been carried on further with the co-opera-
tion of Dr. Travis Jenkins on the steamer. The essence
of the experiment is that certain picked living fish are
marked with distinctive numbers in the manner described
further on by Mr. Johnstone, and are set free at localities
duly noted—those of such fish which are subsequently
captured being returned, with particulars, to our labora-
tory for observation and record. The object of the
experiment is three-fold. The results may be expected
to give us information :——Ist as to the growth of the fish,
2nd as to the migrations of the fish, and 3rd as to the
numerical proportion of the fish caught, and consequently
as to the intensity of the fishing in our seas. The results
are rather startling. For the details Mr. Johnstone’s full
account given below should be read, but the following
may be taken as a summary of the matter:—-In the case
of the Lancashire stations about 50 per cent. of the
marked fish have been re-captured—which may be an
indication that the fishing is so intense that half of the
available fish are captured in the year. Whether this is
“ over-fishing ” it is impossible at present to say, but the
é
6
numbers certainly suggest that we may be getting
dangerously near to the local extinction of the species.
Of course in other parts of the district where the fishing
is not so intense the proportion of the marked fish
re-captured is not nearly so high. It is interesting to
note that in the similar experiments carried on off the
Hast coast of England during the International investiga-
tion of the North Sea 40 per cent. of the marked small
fish transplanted from inshore to the Dogger Bank were
recovered in the same neighbourhood. The total per-
centage of the marked fish recovered in the North Sea
from all parts of the area was 19 per cent. per annum.
In our experiments in the Irish sea the total over the
whole area was 23°25 per cent., but in a number of the
experiments a full year has not yet elapsed.
The evidence so far tends to show that the plaice
grows about 3 inches in the year, during the summer
(May to September), and that a fish 8 inches long in April
and weighing 1 lb. will by September be 11 inches long
and will have doubled or trebled its weight with a corre-
sponding increase in value—a strong argument for the
protection of undersized fish.
Important information as to the migrations of the
fish throughout the district seems forthcoming, but
observations during another year at least are desirable
before we draw conclusions. In winter they travel into
the sheltered estuaries and bays, and chiefly in a northerly
direction. In the summer they move offshore into deeper
water, and chiefly in a southerly direction. The cost of
these experiments is comparatively slight, and the
information gained is most valuable—I have no hesitation
in recommending to the Committee that the work be
continued during 1906 on the same lines as in 1905.
g
ScHEME OF ScrentTIFIC Work.
At the quarterly meeting of the Scientific Sub-
Committee held at Preston on November 8th, 1905, I
submitted a scheme of scientific work in progress and
contemplated. The headings of this scheme (as drawn up
in November) were as follows :——
“L—Distrrbution of Fish Eggs.
“ This has been attentively studied during the present
year, and from one to two hundred bottles of plankton
have been examined. In regard to future work, tow-
nettings should be taken by the steamer as formerly, and
surface and bottom gatherings made every time the net
is hauled. Bottom tow-nettings need not be made at
(1) Blackpool Closed Ground, (2) aear Nelson Buoy,
(3) off the River Mersey. Tow-nettings should be sent
regularly by the bailifis in the Western District. One
should be taken every fortnight by the bailiffs at
Carnarvon, Pwllheli, and New Quay.* So also with the
bailiffs at New Brighton and Fleetwood. Hensen net
collections should be made by the steamer, beginning
early in January, and continued as often as is practicable.
2-H is bel ovoid a
“The food of the plaice, dab, and sole have been
studied during the present year from the point of view of
the competition between fish on the same ground. A
large number of observations have been made and
recorded, and will be published in the next Report. This
work should be continued. It is best done by a scientist
on board the steamer, but when neither scientist is on
board a parcel of fish containing half a dozen soles, dabs
* The investigation of the plankton of Cardigan Bay is most
important from the point of view of immigration of species into our
area, and it would be well to obtain as many tow-nettings as possible
from these parts.
8
and plaice not less than 9 inches long, FROM THE SAME
catcH, should be sent every fortnight either to Piel or
Liverpool as is most convenient. _ Uncommon Inverte-
brates should be preserved and sent to the Liverpool
Laboratory for identification.
(3-H xamination of olheliiis by Betas
“The Morecambe mussel beds and the cockle beds near
the Ribble Estuary should be examined at intervals.
Other shellfish beds should be treated in a similar manner
as time permits. The transplantation experiments should
be continued, and samples of the transplanted shellfish
should be sent to Liverpool as often as they are taken.
The usual bacteriological examinations will be made
from time to time as the Committee requires the informa-
tion. But if desirable any one bed can be systematically
examined and reported upon. Several inspections have
been made during the present year of the Morecambe
mussel beds, and a_ bacteriological examination has
already been made of the mussels at Llanfairfechan.
“4.—Fish-marking Experiments.-
“Nearly 1,000 fish will have been marked and
liberated before the end of the present year. SO O010)
eee ey OO000
eel: (rae. OOOO
re Pat POU OOL
ae | as fe eee 10 8 OLOTO)
April 4. Lf 90000
# 6 .= 90,000
., LOTS OOOO
i 12 £>, 902060
b= 2.21 SO:000
i ee Se ON)
iS EO: ® a iZO000
i 2 forO00
53 OA 2 60000
2 267 =. 60:000
As 98° Vy 20R000
May ee 51001018)
a Dies 0,000
Total Eggs 1,400,000
Fry Set Free.
133000 2... April
XSF 0K0) gee re
34,500
35,000
44,000
51 500
66,500
79,000
79,000
79,500
(2:000K) 2... i
1925009)... “Max
79,500 fy
70 000
79.000
62,000
66,500
52,000
52,500
35,000
44,000
26,500
1,230,000 Total Fry
«
3
”
”
3
iyi
16
Frounper (Plewronectes flesus, Linn.).
Hges Collected.
March 10... ~=200,000
» ld =. 260;000
ow VG. 280 0G0
5 16) 2 300000
a ce, 23601000
2 6d 2 4505000
ik es 00,000
2 See OO 000
Be Bl Se See 001000
April 4 2 1£000;000
. Gre tace ne FOOLO00
i 10... 1,000,000
_ 12 .. 900,000
i 14... 900,000
o 17... 800,000
5 OTe, 2 OO 000
i Dil 100000
“A 24 ... 650,000
. 26, =... cO00;000
x 250 Se O00;008
May 1 ... 800,000
‘3 5 ... 300,000
Total Eggs 13,470,000
CeTGeeen, She
Total Number of Eggs
Total Number of Fry
Fry Set Free.
177,000... April
243 0007s. =e
248, COO-* 2... es
266,000 i
330,000
400,000
486,600
PHN SOLOS Fae ae
TAZ 300 Sen.
SSO00) 222 ae,
800;0007 24,
SS000. Se: a.
800,000) se."
SOG O00 easy
TL OO. as
622,000 ... May
622,000
577,500
6215500" ==
55116910) 0 Rae te
445,000
267,000
11,972,000 Total Fry.
14,870,000
13,202,000
17
‘CLASSES, VISITORS, &c., AT PIEL.
By ANDREW Scorr.
The Education Committee of the Lancashire County
Council again placed at the disposal of the Sea Fisheries
Committee the usual sum of money for forty-five student-
ships, open to fishermen residing in the Administrative
County of Laneaster. The studentship holders were
divided into three classes of fifteem men in each, as shown
by the following lists :—-
Class held March 6th to 17th—J. Butler, Flook-
burgh; R. Johnson, Bolton-le-Sands; J. Threlfall,
Morecambe; A. Woodhouse, Morecambe; J. Johnson,
Junr., Morecambe: J. Moss, Fleetwood; N. Leadbetter,
Fleetwood; D. Leadbetter, Fleetwood; RR. Birch,
Lytham; C. Whiteside, Lytham; H. Robinson, Marsh-
side: M. Johnson, Marshside; J. Foster, Marshside; R.
Johnson, Banks; J. Bond, Banks.
Class held March 20th to 3lst—R. Butler, Flook-
burgh; W. Wilson, Baicliff; J. Bell, Morecambe;
D. Bell, Morecambe; A. Wilson, Morecambe; J. Lead-
better, Fleetwood; H. Macmillan, Fleetwood; J. Meadows,
Fleetwood; N. Johnson, St. Annes; T. B. Harrison,
St. Annes; R. Rimmer, Marshside; H. Wright (Hutch),
Marshside; J. Wright, Marshside; B. Abram, Banks:
W. Leadbetter, Banks.
Class held April 5rd to 14th—G. Thompson, Baiclitt ;
W. Woodend, Bardsea; H. Shaw, Flookburgh; J. Wood-
house, Morecambe; T. Woodhouse, Morecambe; J.
Wilson, Morecambe; Rd. Brown, Morecambe; John
Raby, Overton; R. Roskell, Fleetwood; R. Atkinson,
Fleetwood; D. Herbert, Fleetwood; R. Wilson, Fleet-
wood; D. Abram, Banks; W. Rigby, Southport; B. Ball,
Southport. In addition to the men originally selected
for the third class, two fishermen, S. Rimmer, and W.
5
18
Parr, from Blackpool, were also present, the studentships
being granted by the Blackpool Education Committee.
The usual votes of thanks to the Sea Fisheries Com-
mitee and to the Education Committee of the Lancashire
County Council were proposed and carried by the fisher-
men. One of the most noteworthy fishermen students
we have ever met with was a member of the third class,
James Woodhouse, of Morecambe, a fisherman close on
eighty-two years of age, and still following his arduous
vocation with surprising activity. On several occasions
during the summer, when fishing im the vicinity of Piel,
he paid us a visit. Mr. Woedhouse proved an attentive
student, and in a short speech stated he had learned much
about the habits and life of fish that was new to him.
A class in Nature Study for school teachers was held
on two week nights and Saturday afternoons during the
last two weeks of April and first week of May. The class
was attended by seventeen students, all teachers in the
schools under the Barrow Education Committee. This
is the fourth class in Nature Study for teachers that has
been conducted at Piel.
The dates for the next classes for fishermen are
practically settled. Two will be held before Easter--
March 12th to 25rd, March 26th to April 6th —and one
after EKaster-April 25rd to’May 4th. of Crustacea of Norway, By G. O.
Sars—purchased.
British Hydroid Zoophytes, Hincks— purchased.
British Sessile-eyed Crustacea, Bate and Westwood --
purchased.
British Starfishes, Forbes-—purchased.
British Sea Anemones and Corals, Gosse-—purchased.
The Study of Fishes, Gunther—purchased.
American Food and Game Fishes, Jordan and Kver-
mann—-purchased.
Nordisches Plankton, Brandt u. Se |e 5 5 3 Ss 5
Bie Peele | Sle |e) eeil sce, | Salpe
@ fae | eo) S| AS aie 2 ae eke ac | eee
A Salsa Smog alozlozion|aal a) 4 | 3
| | 4 | ts! | ~ AA | — ae —
—. - : ! — — —- - —-
(CUEEYE eels) fo'sis wy soe aon acorReenecicod Recesn HEeesE Hocdod Hacmcerencd pocsec nae: Vere Bacecn bpeaoe sR Sy -
oeeiceedpiten, #sees aie esa s.s, tte tetera sleet Nene uk alae Sees eet ete eee
PI ZOSO EMI tee acta s aces ooce mek ioe cease aaetee tae eel ace cee vcoee | fecanes i aaa ate Lat ae ol ome alle ges tb a.
OSGINOGISCUS: Ws asee dooms es sisee Hel eee scents! teres sie] eets stele emisote =f eesaes Seo Rees Ree |e en te eee + a
(CRIED Het 80) adage rodedsso5ea hooead Hades booaoal bic Gans Boss beso [eonae Poon: edBod EAnsse|hacshel bessss + ne
Gematimm ShUSUSs! ar cadet osms sce lprerecte |sars-cte|sexce Gls |sciv.ceperesonre| seen ES-aen tea PeeAa Rocaad Sumrel babce + | an
Ceratium Pura se ceesccecneccecctsloceee le snetial sees acct saerice| ameete Detebal Barden bragce Baracs| Bart. 4 hosece BE
Sagitta bipunctata ............)..feeafeceeleeeees Were clap Pape iieere [bots pete, | hee Wee Pa ie
Autolytus prolifer............... 2 oe cei Peer eee | + | + |... ees Fees Hogar Hesse boone ee Were
barnvalmeolychaetamre sens. cscel terse c S eal Baacna Baccod Gnccoe
Myton: Simislise |. ).0¢..2-c0r002)0-<02 peel catia Dice ee fe) eee a eee es ee ee
Orcllay site, UMKCITS Coecossoetod baoooa bancod baqoss horton sacnes oe BARRE Been cera RGceaE mopeen Mesote teocta paesoe
Giardella thompsoni .........|......|....+. ast Ree OA eee nea Se ae ee BR ee Oe ieee toed ee Paes
Alteutha interrupta............ | = | BOBO SOO Sa borete Hanada Reeree Beneae lear lsat la We eral Sooeec|meaeee Ge ctce
Elaithalestnise cromiserrss saute see Aeeeel oe | eee ae Seno le Pe [See BI ee eer ae ee ae |e Mr a
Copepod mma np lite Arete a s-cecesleeee secrete saeece Jo ee Se Ale tee a = au aera 6 layin lartares | Sater Poe
Barnacle nauplii .....:......... Pesci le nerraty Gate fet Hatome “fe Wise) ote seiwche sine mic eciemoc | Sareacrs |seseena lees et Feces
Barnacle ostracod stage Ali YBa sont I ate DS Aa DON aia oe EERE eee Wea daasaeelavesnaleceasat eens [Masks
Crab zOeay seers ke ate ees A ae eed Ae ite a eS eV Soy eee BS ty Rotten | Pe cee botece
Mikamleura Mey. ah s.c noite eect auely Bick We cticl heEe eee Beattie ea Seine eae ame ted besarte os ie ee
PAS CIOIAM KOO OSW rosa hater cero) see nealleat sie ee eae PRs ae Bit eae tern al Reta coneol Becca Buona Sone
Mish enon Wt eh Atos tev acc: 2 all eee Ree make Be Woot dled yt he SC es Oy I ee pe en A
IDRIS eboc hoes enn aoe eon UC BPERE aa IEEE are Tce aa ea ae de 08 fetes cates eaeees eaeees eneees
| | | |
Eco Pca oT a FS
13) |=) = | 1d slero ue OY A) ABS | 15s 3)/—]—
| | |
SSS B22...
38
April.
a
1O >
i = | . las A = aa! zz
[os ca SEs tsstiiues | stsos auites =
) @ (Os se Pala Be ge
| x ERE ESEEE Fe Aa
@haetocerOsy, sii. cecssesoacoe eros |-seaee | Be eBan ficaar| Honso| Basaac ssaneol badness
Bidduliplia myc .sserseess eae Bice ee a (Oe cael PAB Elam | ener
INIA AGSOIS THE morons 357 Secononds 0d boomed] Reseed booacol daaraal Sabape RBEsAE| saeacs
Coscinodiseus | sss-eessee se fie wcres fe ti Ste lbevanine SP Koodo
(CYP (iki cath IWS ieee eee ceereeee ec Rtoadel BESSanl Aascannl hBbaaa patoas bemecs| Reeroe
Pleurobrachia pileus ......... fai Nerds id ae al soesieal seen Cee
Medusoid gonophores ......... Sel Wiis 2 [boon ste a Elec el totale
Alcyonium eggs |.:...........+. SI DRrAgS LS Nica sie |[brerabinall asicemial Merstelee
Sagitta bipunctata ............ i= poppet Sl Mier aan Boden? Sh bopans
Autolytus prolifer............... =f 4 sedeine| ze emiore 2 Fl bona hodeoslhaaaas
anvalePolyehcetareesn-cosstes acess sade veces Soot banat bosses SaRaor
POOR ATLA! 5. cones tenoeeeissereaal swear 4] de dles|soeectd|saeceal acess + Jeeeee
Pasiphaea:, SIVAAO s; .io5c.<00- safes srinc|iesescleoered 1 \|bobooe|hobbo0|bxbo08
Meganyctiphanes Morvepica.. .\0oi2..|.s.2.|222- |boades|4 ~os6alyocono|boosor
JNCENABIE TOIRNUISIS So Setins sdocgonese ol bosded|Hacase |e ect -iepteteeleete ess qe. |besorslhnasarlessahs fra |tatebatel aeeeevaliasoae eects
Aicantiang discadatal gene. eeeerc eases ketess ase Pasaod weanee aii bo ascol eaten Nansen EeSaac encchal Enonas| KaGacalaqbaon
Gentropages: Wamatus seeecet|seeeee|see sees << a= |bosder Ol Nessie lscusial yee Sa oobsal oaeare| sscanol boreee
(CSIMTHOYORYEEIS! THYAOKELIS ao sacanod boosee| socabelbocsec booborl hadage ard gooselsas60el perooolbadqodl sasanel baoaec lateral | Semesters
Anomalocera patersoni ......|....../...... Lseoak Eee mee pe te ae WF ee ieee Waa UpePehreal a at tole ie ets a etal ae
(Onulaoyateh afsitatil HEP SES6 on sacn sk oasiod| Esoned| tb oodod| Zosbod| be odecal Reamer =f eal Mere ctor Soxacinvel qeunianl tise selemieseG Senet oa Ganon
(Crojseqerersl, MERON Gpesocopocopoed| bape oo bopdonl hossddlMeered|eppeea aie Dente bo aceel aeecen: =e liens eonsclBevedalaedesz
Barnacle matipliiiy s,s escogss24s|qe- ese seseds sass. feat [seeeiss staapegs sse's |aepsisio|aitee atilnastias \saatee |. neeceleeeees
Bamacle ostracod stage’ ...:0.|s.-s8\aoacse\-eroa STEAK es al ee RUE a ded enter IEE Sa Jeveeee i Beat sonsoe
Podonwinitermedinm’ ,, ).3.s. cores + eee SEA te ls aenvalseeteae Ted | Seco ferent aah One
ANUTIGIN AUDI [OHO NR et ce penn ssobe| poasoo bospoalboeson 4 ponnbel Honore| Hoobod hasand Penna bacodd bean be [:isiesice| sates tpaeotat
Mamvallwpolychaetay Seip scr c-2as|eec seem. saloiset «s arta Beers SS Baten Paneer beseec mocoecl Baaace Be pbbr | sRoodlarasee
ANIC ATED too. ajo esiccviestsre eee ase lee veer sate fe We seeclelsatderse fa Moen Reread bocca’) Sconce Burana BerscAboscoolpacace
Mepanyctiphanes norvegica...|...---|......|----0s|-.+-se)ses=+6)- eo sR hee one Pecees| Bagaca Baasor | civcloe name oes
OCHO ER, WDE TE meee ace gues ear seosec) be deed Ndas-oboecgs|eacuor “fo “| siciestois | ae sil Satsarcia| Steereta| Sctes oe |neeeee|soeese|eceees
Mysis stage of Crangon ......|...... hea 0 eased bonaad Raboce Sei potSod heiceee pabbe ay enews apie Heitor sce
MORRO RZOCE ules coccstee eee dte ons TF» |PEREOL 2B | SR bsobse Goal Wimeel feecer pean ait boacbe IsaGsec Se |Posscc
(Cinzio) Nukeremallehohy Borsasonanseadense| hosson|hoosor S| an a peepee a mar nau Apes poenee a bungee Sal oor
Calanus helgolandicus .........|......|....++ BE Nes pa) Bonds Betene HooeoH Romie Heoser Sacred Rocona iascco boteod Hore
Pseudocalanus elongatus ...|......|......|.-.=- a a Baer SP ecal SCeAEl beeaee, okaoe a a ene ec eet ae
Parsicalanus ParVvus) cesses. -l| bes sof-riesl- Ste ectat Mstess Sl HEArOn Babee Bator STi) seve et eee Lowe Binder
iNevaaroydas Woymkeatefoyn als} socsoqanesse poasnc|so055 ete sll etal setae a pel ee cael Sethi soee ne 3 Noigsten | aaeies 1B sean
J NCERAD ECE NETSI Eee nisn sade bones Heaton] RoGsae Se et: sees =| Wl serecis.s/emecticl ements Sal Peco tec a eulkeerer
ANCRTTE SCIEN ITO AIAN See aneeeecel batecc| seeesel race a| ba toc acooee a}: [oaibea iba sballtcaeae| Namertel tepaer Memes | Piteee [ere
Centropages hamatus .........]......|...... Sn le ae Cee af lPesees Locale tidy ee ae eeicacel Heeb:
Centropacesmtypiciis ccc. .cccleeseee|Sesmeel eee) eeeee| sees SF) lboosae Liatsck ech Gael eae ele |overealeweeee
abidocera, wollastoni .jss..:--.|--..--|+-e-2- eas Beets) Aasee Romie Bacar aateaes eee eas here dead aed tach
SITLHOMAV SIMMS: cals sccathncas tls ecbel tween setee =te ell seracrstal Socewe = Lsjelic vonlca tea coheed eee ene aimed Bereoe
Copepod nauplii 500. Seon) es |BOssos Nanane | bopseb|Racaas a ie cena Rapa Soon ss pace. Bapros beds =F hl eseeee
Barnacle ostracod stage ......|......|......[..... S| Bochincl Bacear | Beare houtee Faeesso Mock heebinn borooe Sac) Basane
IRodongintermediuml. esis ee alae acd| ner olor eee eels ete ts cee Woe 1 Ree oe | Retin Wa Sora bes Se
HV PMe PHOLHIMANL.< 4°. 9, odie cate | sosesio= | Setow nin -.se anal oelzotem paternal vee te MleeaseG eB BseascBecaen [Sete rneuees af Altos te
(Crilzayay SU eB ceancncesonsecetnae| paecea bosses a Tl pete walocse ef ai scteciaal eateete Berane cfrathanectealtecats Ee cise
PASCICMAIM EL OS © ayacetes aneaeesee re [eorbisn)| se derals aeetaafseteseal| eee eae ate wilerctoatets ReanAq| Hossog) hooked Becadal Bocce ai bocdae
LSU) Gif erence epoca Soacknn Beste al sntpas ar || ae [bese SHE u[e Sgteteal ete atte rece | Rete Meee te Sil ketttes
REE MLATIED iy ios acs cgceeee eer ateos decors aimee accep abe |boosos alert rears Pepe St [Seis sitste siecle eee |e
fi a OPP fee ee Lae
St 234) 0s Ge lle te ie oa
| '
4]
July.
- aaa | ante |
| les = lf |2 | ,
Pa See eerie. hea ler bamile | 3) 2 |e
& |salSeiec|salk oe sla dja cla cia 2] 8/5 | 8
isa) Fa A OOO ee BR IOAIOZ OGRA) 4 a js
1 ! | 1
a | im | _
Biddiligiiag gee wera st foe. oe Bk 5:1 Oe Orgel ev ieee Bato Papel Aeon ae alae arate
[RIAD ATEY, Sousscnccdcoscoshoner Lae eel Me bee) | ee tael aa si Steet (ae leo Neier ae areemee a ee
Gelatinous algae ............... Lio: ee lseanae bees joc lbeoade (alate alte a fipesae's mal Berroco acacac| hema
Cera tiMmMtripOse eye Neti ce ea eee Pte [sas eae ae [etl ams a ctectels ei ereetere
Werabiimlmusus)eesss-e- 2 seek am eee |ericesdlbeveeien |Loss 2 aesthetic [tlle = RS ee Lean
CETTE TRITHCES, Sebeoscobnoos GEaalsoonce| baron Reece Zee eee a OR (Eee MeN TSee ove acres ee | aay
Z ; | Med
NOctilwGalae piesa os oe een bey ieee ta tet an aa eas eres |erererc| aia tae!| Pera ae | eae liseada ees
Bichinwsy Pluteus: 2255. eee |cosbod Sacccnl Se Bertie 2 Ret bee Goadoe Goehncuec asta Goksosesoaseoceod beacet
Mysis stage of Crangon ...... ie (i ed Ree Sel epee SS BEEN Gaaeel GREE A tea eacicy a all Berar hocae
Roca, of Crabs® 65.5 2)..0.0...205: Re Aiea Ie ce pe stew rae [era me epee) ot leads el eat. Sera Se Les hen ee ee
Megalopa of Crabs ............ beaies SES aa BTS SL ces el Pee yl Wes Sena beeper i Pls Aa ged [toot
Calanus helgolandicus ......... bate [adaealearasts podacEl Nosnete eee eee onan BEER caeey Maren) Eben. os | |yaeeek
Bseudqcalamusselonsatusa taclaatesaledss: (eee ce seca saneiienaes Boch Be posnna npr meraa sandy peices ie sRoc oe \iiattan baaeee
Paracalanus parvus............ parse Hl TSE eda E oiel HOSAEE S| AM las es OR ane Sa lacs al Reerio
Temora longicornis ............ | Se ese les oe aod + | seed bea or allee aera oe, oh i ei en eee lsat
Acar tiaaclausiemssas en tees ee i | El ae aar neve Ca Gare Her nH RRR BERL apenas Pacitel cece Scooeal becacd
Centropages hamatus ......... eee a ee BE aad Fe AL nl LACEA Kat Batee coe aaa nc EAE 14 (a
Anomalocera patersoni ............, ae | asrestst + Boreed badkad bopedH bodead adorei aaae adeno = sil ASRS poe
Labidocera wollastoni .........)...... Se tenaee TIE, 1 ae Al tal Dee! ae Ane Le aR Lut ae AL le Oi ted a ati
44
October.
—_ | | 1 | ~
= 3'| nN R R = _ ;
| g] x} eloSle ig fe le le p 2 | 8) eee
Blo a palPu| & 5 |o OS | Sy eats ete talesit slash 122!
ee PS | OCS | EEN | GO GM | Cl) es akg
2 Sa) 6 Bl Pe S| Boel ope le 2 rel Gaels
|g lm | O m(Scleaa aie SESE SSS eal] 3 o 3
| Salsa e Oa SaEmozlozioziaa 41414
val rehicare,
IBiddiuoll phan mec cce eens nce enieate a ence Bomaae Be Scdensberad noeaed acaan Sraape Beers Bee aonencscd Sass ae ++
UIZOSOleMia yee se eae echelons PTS | MN bare roe Cae rd ere aoe bee a eae {se se
Chaehocerostaus sere scseeees cee eeee ee reeticesee [seaee Sees soee ae | Ed eet Reereal boceicnl Ace ereaecr ieee. +} +
Coscinodiscus ...............-+. EN be | ea | ae We) PD ie a eh ties) hee |ge | ae
IBRChe AS unLUMe eo eceee secon eee ee ee eae Wertige Maceion Sere Mespedes bce Peete en) MR cop pen ead oe
Bellenoehwe. accep oe ree oy Bape enacts Pe asain feces eo eel Seeecel Skeecs Reman Ranaan Rees alt, amet Eo
LOTS RYAITIONG) {535 sonsnegosacsupsseece codaca Gbae0c ee. Be ctod| Sects Pomecol Bansnd haental nbcere Ba tene Baaca pomeus Sco: 2 =F
SUCHIERGTauithe hc Jecadepueeaessnees codeod Saaeed Laccad bacsen Heaeod Hacsed sosdual besos Betis aces peccnic aurora Saaces +
Ceratium tripos.................. Be) Bee ies Smal Bole De aed bor teed Em oe eden oe Weaias |botood Sontag Npeenc + | +
CeratrumenususS :..-c-ccosseo ss = ee eae a ee eee te eer leat Fea cu) Sod-cd 9 scade Stack so 00
Ceratium dura) <:....5--.------ yal tenet Soe Wee Berea) amen Hae arse Jeo noes peter barra pees Seen + +
INoeiibicate Soc acstesmeoesee cae cee See Yk OSE We eseheorsatellaaete ncteers [Parser | bo] AD feveree seeeseleeesenleeeee
SLOWe TILA a TUE TSS Sapa esecnAcdsno sobeod Boceoe Se) en BCR neg Hens al Las oa oasoul Satoh peewee Mnackc BE a
Pleurobrachia pileus ......... S i Poses Mass Sorbet Ae cso |easiee ee een ene \roeagal haem “fey [eats
Medusoid gonophores ......... BSE Desig | MC el Lee eee No er Ura Be tab baoe ee ae | jeone toate ae
Sagitta bipunctata ............ SP) SP) SP) SR soca So Ber Nicer ap | Rosse BArene Ba see +/+
Autolytus prolifer............... Spl BERS Rosrne) SSArod cesere Herren Hota Heard hacoot Bereta Ssaeed ReeRes Boeous “ocho:
Larval Polychaeta ............ gt Be peor| MERE corsod sees salen Src, Rasa tiaaca faSasaettes nies ede aaads
CGA, NUTS Se aa ee sir FD Eee Socnad Sconue Hathod sobsne Se SEES CR naneco boaiec PPR ee iets beer +) +
Mysis stage of Crangon ...... Sal ened seems ee ic taee adsoh Speck ertcc + RordcH Berecd Noord ne seog eqeckr
Meranyc tiphanes mORVenI Casale. soctsecae | seissee bceosio ese [terials tree n aS B Paral. ota oal fees bape +
MeralOparObaGhas. qs.ssesse celoneacetoeses|vecntee S| babes Sousa Nccadd hooad: eats | pep oad Baton Saescs scoebul neeeoc
Calanus helgolandicus ............... We cee Feprsse en gal SEPP PPepenrere Preers Stee Rocke ere oe BS) +
Pseudocalanus elongatus ...|......|......|...... Re peas Hotnod Rarrog sseecn Bocsod hoceog Hdsecd Acasco RagsSclusnnde =f
Paracalanus parvus............ 2 nl Reece | ol Ab cere afi Wcsie tt |eieses|seeeae Se eres ieee + | +
Temora longicornis ............ ah" eaceees Fae) aie ketone a gel BEEBE BecEO| Senet i, ar2e| Baden eocend Sons =
AlGarita, ClAUSL © 25. .c2082s 6. c0-3% “fe [Pa se Beesae Sf cs = ae Beer Hera ita wale Neo we ected Belge | + | +
Centropages hamatus ......... +} +e] + | # pene. S| Beaeead bacccc| ae) Seem acrelctsectss | sieiate eeteeae
Anomalocera patersoni ......|......|...... sie ond Cerny etree Meeeiad Hea Hace G Baber | eats eee Reel eee
Labidocera wollastoni ......... Se Be oc BaaDe ibe beseee Locke damacy becca ccs | Sr Ieee FR el ae Pee
Ouphonassimilise pessoa eee Sd pe baed Retecn oO hasan a Oe emer eed ees |e ees eae + +
Euterpina acutifrons ......... $e sopsoo|| SP || aR -\boocos Sil paaseg Bacean reese Badsoc baabed Seon +/+
Herahodes littoratis) 200.2008: {is scnstos soa |saxnce ae i SELEY ee eee ee Pees Bails pee eects 2
Copepod nauplii ............... Races wie esc BSE Fees Daas Mego [ace [see Tego Reed Bees 7 ie cvaaieecene
Idotea marina .................. ee oa Scere laeoee [een Scosche ancp tee eas tineoms jasisiaw Reger Beasee, Bec Hee NCeN ic
CRS GUI Se oo. os< voy ccs eaten onan Bevan eee ie oe eee Wipes oie eesaery ee een ae [ie Gieeaaee +) t+
Asuidinn (Ogg8 |<... .....+.dien-|sacen eee le acts See |anceel cst acle aee oeeee Peades | Kaen ena ReneS. | a fected
|
November.
| | | | ¢ |
era { S tp) \F 2 4 . .
8 | sy ofialé Bele th ee Wee et la eit ial te | 2
Bile glee als [a 16 (oe leosla.| |= |e
ge 5/2 Sip Sle els Pla jal |s4! o |] . | ¢
S 2S SR eS/5 25 Bia Pie cle cle olS $| S$] 8! &
| eelSaeelOmiSmlEMlOzZlozlogiaa| 3 | aes
| J ihe dl mes | | | i . ; | | |
) |
Bidduilphitag see -caecctecess [P scsracial| sarenistel potayare | Hoesan BECcael Heodael Henobo Hteaeel bescee aeenee heeres heened Ae ee ite
[PUR AO OME ANE), sulondscdsoctonsonsed be eto BdoteH MaeHae aed Fie ae oo Ne Pe ccf storage os [ee ee Bee Wee a
(CIMAEHOEOROE “noasadencscomsododnee ean eee cece eae cl MERA ey a Settee ee ete Meme | Se Aan Mette el itcpad oleate as
CORCINOGISCISHMEechonestee nse: ceeeelt orcas = a | ea eee evil eloerelNeserss Ear Ate ee ee + |i...
(QereninigIA, WANDCE Ko oenoscbs0H/onbes Hob000|/soc550 hoedoo a0. |kecsealsoosb: boosca|bocone AP |koos00|bocoonl bocce =f al scsaaits
(CEH THSUE! cece cosssebbopecol aceetel Heeeeel eet allt | Meee || Soni sd eee gaat sol bake ona Ue Le BEM sce
(ChiAANTHAT) GRIROE! 4caecsqanadadenad| Nobaua Heaadel NecapS aime heaps slate ole Sonosileiecctes ator Ne cpeil tates aa leant ate tA ey,
IN(@retiniliiet Bese susad acaasetnunecaeel Honacel Neemee Seo se fe SEA ea aceel ee + | tay beeen Sat | ke ae
JACRTD NOTIN, | cacckdbaSoDSNeNceel POSED SOeae BEBE Geiceaal MOBAAe leery les Sis cmeiel peat al Kee sy nel Fn an un | eS ees
Rieurobrachiampileds se.ss- ce s|oecess|sece: Fadl cir al noeaecnitornc sanaam cored beceee sponte eee alas ote Pease 8 we
Medusoid gonophores .........|......]......|-..--- nl beree eacene Benet. Haxdbiste bates ince cinlatey he, | Scena ee
Saeiititan ip umetata merce sen. -sse)- elec lsn see STL esl lai te on | a SN See rate Ih eam alin tees + (eas
Atuito lyase EG er eas. cscs = |eemeysle|crossele acme Sun | Gasetoc| SHBawe Pararie Aborcs| Rasmesl peace Me ohne) Seensel MmeanelLASeoe
Tomopteris onisciformis ...... eaebes| erica Secsne pooreel Saanee fee Seteacts apes Heeemee Hctets| Benen baaoe hese anel Baca
Larval polychaeta Be heaeN mcea heoed ae) mere NS aera 8 del co iret oe ok Nepalese thy cba ee ee ae ede
SAVING ATUL AM a eoe-ee as cins zee oIe Print tic seal eameelle cease le eas ck ee od aa ee a aa le ape adee
Meganyctiphanes norvegica |...... Ihe, Atal gael ne Wee acs oll leer [nts her Beer lettre alle akon (ae ee
Miysism stage Ole Cramp Onl ler 1ac|scecra) ceaseless ae Ste || fstectes = ea Peete [esisaretell ace eSostc eonitial Haba ca Peonoal bees
Miemalopa, Of Grabs is. . 20-5. se5|eer deloeasne|soeres eae eee Se ae HE eee ec e Pecl ane lee
Calanus helgolandicus ......... lhe ce sling lace Wid ete [eaees: + | Ste Paes a (Fb or [eae OE ee PEO PEs
Pseudocalanus elongatus ...|......|......[....00|.0006 et ol ed eles ecto ee rae a eet Re el Be Web ceoc
Paracalanis. parwus ssc se -se-sleecerleewertlesse ac Seeds [Poesia eee ee Senece cere ier oe es
Memorag lon eicomnisy sees eaeeaes|-eece| sees + | + |... alee | rata rate sateskec Sf SA arte Faecal BaRSnel botoar
NcartianClauSivias seocceeeetocee serie cena nccsen sles it eae ee Se tesa emee SES ol Ea ee era (a ee a ha eee
Centropages hamatus ...............|...... SE) |) SS ye ee oe | et ee) = OP) (ae ral eee Se sl ed lr:
IRSTENS: COBIAN esi" kelaneenaddaedoesec] mabodt Heceoe “16. |Hacedd Paccod neseos Bacdss pooace Hebe) bias hemeec ete eed eer
Anomalocera paterson ~..-..}.....0):.2..-|...0.. leasees|eeeae rime | Banaao| Bcanad aaeee RAneea Hesanecdcnee sted |Noteeets
Labidocera ‘wollastont s..c0-0-|: occ scsccec closes es Pe ELT ADE HE AIOE ig ol ent Fal ter (ee) Et vl etl
Orthonarsinilistsscescss eee eceeae spouses SES [Pe Le TLR otal eased ee a se aah we vataneerns ta |E aes
Euterpina acutifrons ......... Bea) Macc Hamer eae sd ae FOND aaee hecee Ramee peers es ease eel Mah oes
Hersiliodes littoralis .........|...... \igaeae etd Me galas Sr» Rae PRE FED Male || AL AAA anal 68
CorycaensPameh Cusine. .csccearcles eel eaeealancoesl: cece k tmeleeneas ETS A UR te Wie ll ad Nedac eral Seen setae
Rodonvinbermecdiumy | see stee reece ltecneeloasces aay Bpcoadl SonoE Hoaeoe eres IGS a el orate lL tae Bacson Gepasalsonaae
Oni 6) 0) (SUI?) consdcedodooon bas oLeeeET ponsed Meee Hate + | Wee is 4 a ae 2. eee Je) ae le =e eee
|
| | ae ee ae | aa
Sethe OME 20 eT eat, | ae |
1 (
46
Blackpool.
Off Shore Stn. —
Lune Deep.
Port Erin.
Luce Bay.
Coscinodiscus
Biddulphia
Rhizosolenia
Cheetoceros
Cerartinica bel OSs asey ieee detect =
Gerahiumy GSS)... cins
fact that various fish-salesmen throughout the county,
and especially in Manchester, place orders at the
beginning of the season with many of the Morecambe
fishermen for a definite number of bags each week.
Consequently we find from the returns supplied by the
Midland, and London and North Western Railway Com-
panies, at Morecambe, that large quantities are sent away
annually. The average quantity sent off during the past
five years, up to the end of March, 1905, amounts to close
cn one thousand nine hundred tons per annum.
Although we have not been able to find very much
information that could throw light upon the point, we
regard the mussel beds at Heysham as having been in
existence for a very long time. It is possible that many
of the ancestors of the present mussels were used in
59
making the mortar for building the first church at
Heysham. The mortar consists of burnt sea-shells and
is almost indestructible. The original church, traces of
which are still discernable, is supposed to have been
founded by a colony of Trish Christians in the sixth or
seventh century. Heysham or Hessam is mentioned in
the Domesday Survey, and was one of the towns of the
Saxon Manor of Halton. The salmon fishery of the Lune
at Lancaster was granted to the Abbey of Furness by
Stephen, Earl of Boulogne, confirmed by Henry I., and
further confirmed by Henry III., but we are unable to
state whether this grant also included the fishery at
Heysham or not. At any rate, it is well known that the
mussel beds of Heysham were at one period farmed by the
Lord of the Manor, and receipts over six hundred years
oid, for farming the beds, ave preserved with the early
documents of Hornby Castle. | There is also evidence that
the beds were in existence three hundred years ago. From
an interesting work ‘ An History of Richmondshire in the
“ North Riding of York, together with those parts of the
“ Kverwicschire of Domesday which form the Wapen-
“takes of Lonsdale, Ewecross, and Amunderness, in the
“Counties of York, Lancaster and Westmoreland, by
“Thomas Dunham Whitaker, LL.D., F.S.A., Vicar of
“Whaley and Blackburn, Lancashire,” Volume II.,
1825, we quote the following statement compiled from a
survey of Heysham parish im 1584, which throws a good
deal of light on the customs of former days. “ This
‘“ manor (Heysham) was divided between free tenants and
“tenants at will, of whom the free tenants paid annually
“to the lord £18 6s. 9d. and a pair of spurs; tenants at
“will, £18 11s. 6d. . . . . Boon journeys were due
“to the Barton of Heysham. .-. . There were four-
“teen persons who farmed the mussel fishery for the rent
60
“of £11 5s. in return for which, they were free to gather
“mussels on the lord’s sands. . . . The lord had also
“ profit of court, estrays, goods of felons, and wrecks of
“the sea, the last of which might be very productive.”
The manor of Heysham in the time of Henry VIII. is
stated to have been worth rather more than £50 per
annum. It thus appears that the mussels in those remote
days were of considerable importance and money value
to the local fishermen. They were also a valuable asset
to the lord of the manor, producing fully one-fifth of the
profits of the whole manor. In the article on mussels in
the Encyclopedia Britannica, Vol. XVII., 1898, p. 110,
it is stated, ‘ The chief localities of natural scalps on the
* British coast are Morecambe Bay in Laneashire, the
‘flat eastern shores, especially that of the Wash in
‘“ Lincoln and similar shallow bays.”
Coming to our own experience, we find, from con-
versations with the older fishermen in Morecambe, that
the conditions of the mussel skears to-day are practically
the same as they were fifty and sixty years ago. This
area, like all other shellfish beds, is subject to various
influences over which man has no control. New banks
are formed by the action of the tides, and growth of the
shellfish. The channel may alter a little and smother
the mussels with sand, or undermine the outlying beds
so that they are gradually disintegrated by the currents.
Every winter many hundreds of tons are swept away by
the gales into deeper water and lost. An invasion of
starfish may depopulate a whole skear, leaving only a mass
of empty shells behind them. Before the advent of
‘ailways or the institution of Sea Fisheries Committees,
the fishermen and local farmers used large quantities of
the smaller mussels for manure. This system of destruc-
lion, which may be regarded now as an extremely
61
wasteful one, perhaps did more good than harm. It
helped to secure a better quality of mussel than could
possibly be derived from an over-populated bed. The
clearing away of large quantities of small mussels gave
those that were left more room to spread over the skears,
increased growing space and a better chance to obtain an
efficient food supply. The result eventually, as we find
now, would be a larger mussel, and a well-filled shell,
instead of a stunted one with very little inside it.. We
look upon the removal of the smaller mussels in days
gone by, as a crude attempt to improve the condition
of the skears, and a forerunner of transplanting now
conducted, with the authority and assistance of the Sea
Fisheries Committee. In former days all the mussels
removed for manure were utterly lost, but the present
system involves no waste of any kind. The mussels are
simply removed from an over-populated or starved bed to
a fresh area where there is plenty of growing room and
food.
In the pre-railway days the large mussels were
hawked about the neighbouring villages and sent inland
in great quantities. On the completion of the railway,
then known as the Little North Western, to Morecambe,
in 1847, a better and more rapid method for distributing
- these shellfish was opened to the fishermen which was
quickly taken advantage of. The improved facilities
for conveying the mussels to the large towns of the
county gave rise to an increase of the fishing population,
and was one of the causes that led up to the great trial
in 1874 between the fishermen and the lords of the manor.
The original grant of the fishery at Heysham, which
is thought by some people to have been given in the tenth
century, included all the area from the middle of the
Kent flowing into Morecambe Bay, to the middle of the
62
Lune, and no fishing could take place without the consent
of the lords of the manor. Thus Morecambe, or Poulton as
it was formerly called, had no free fishery. The enhanced
value of the mussel beds through the opening of railway
communication became apparent, and led to much friction
between the lords of the manor and the fishermen. The
former asserted their right to claim rents for permission
to remove the mussels, while the latter disputed the
existence of any documents that gave the lords of the
manor control of the fishery. The dispute ended in a
trial at Lancaster, when the verdict went in favour of
the fishermen being entitled to free fishing. Shortly
after this verdict was given, the lords of the manor asked
leave to appeal against the decision of the court on the
erounds that important evidence had been secured since
the trial. The judge, however, ruled against the lords
and from that time onwards the fishing has remained free.
At the present time considerably over 100 men, or
fully one per cent. of the present population of Morecambe
are more or less engaged in mussel fishing. At the last
census the population was 11,798.
The following statistics of the mussels sent off by rail
during the last five years, are supphed by Mr. Edward
Gardner, Honorary Fishery Officer at Morecambe :-
1900-01. 1901-02. 1902-03. 1903-04. 1904-05,
Cwts. Cwts. Cwts. Cwts. Cwts.
September ... 24319 ... 2063} ... 68822 ... 48572 ... 3747
October ...... 74594 ... 6143} ...10051} ... 65024 :.. 78173
November. @..\ 73344...) 72440) <6 7612 0) .aeie. G0ebs
December ... 4062} ... 44364 ... 59764 ... 4162 ... 3488
January ...... 62024 ... G1312 ..: 64654 .:: 3761 4: 48073
February ...... 38802 ... 4659} :.. 54952 ... 4240)... 39314
Marchy. .sdists 34224 ... 2703% ... 44884 ... 3873 ... 29403
BPN, “shit gep ZOOSE »..5 DUAIA AIS eens a=
63
DESCRIPTION OF THE SKEARS.
The mussel beds at Morecambe are locally known as
‘“skears,’ aterm which is also apphed to any rough
ground, and each has a particular name amongst the fisher-
men. ) MORES E 2 tie ene Sah 9. 2 175 2—6
Dabsi tases a secere se dll 14—9
Brills aia act ones 8 24 —5
Arnoglossus laterna ...... it 44
RAV SR a esueiac sete seats 6 44—104
Coding re rarstes::: elas... 3 3—4
Grey Gurnardsi pn a.c-. 4 | 3
Siphonostoma typhle ........ LO =
Gasterosteus spinachia ...... Numerous. —
Cotiuststonpie cere eee a tec: { —-
Agonus cataphractus ......... 12 | —
Callionymus lyra .........e es Numerous. —
Centronotus qunnellus ...... 6 | —
Gobius MinutUs ........cee eee Very numerous. _
Acanthtas vulgaris........ ie 1 | -
Sato dy (Seb ee a ane Ree rerBe 1 Gill. o
Pandalus aunulicornis ...... 2 Gills. ---
90
Four hauls on the 12th and six on the 13th were
then made with a fish trewl consisting of a net with a
7-inch mesh throughout bent on to a 30-feet beam. There
was considerable difficulty in working the trawl on this
occasion on account of the extraordinary amount of
seaweed on the ground. In 1904 the same part of Luce
Bay was comparatively free from weed; but in 1905 it
was in parts very foul, so much so that it was found
quite impossible to get the net aboard on the third haul
on October 12th, owing to the great mass of weed which
it had taken and which had caused the net to catch also
a quantity of sand. It was, therefore, necessary to cut
the tails, and the catch was almost entirely lost. Then
other parts of the same area were tried so as to avoid this
debris, but it was found that the largest plaice were
among the seaweed; hauls IIf. and IV. were made on
comparatively clean ground, and it will be seen that the
proportion of large plaice taken was much lower than in
the other hauls. To avoid the fouling of the net, and
the damage to the fish entailed by the weight of the weed
and the time it required to get the haul aboard we were,
therefore, obliged to resort to the foul ground again.
Short hauls, varying from three-quarters of an hour to
50 minutes were made, and by this means Captain
Wignall was able to steer between the Scylla of too much
rubbish in the net, and the Charybdis of too many small
and useless fish. But even with all due precaution some
of the plaice obtained were badly crushed and scarred
and subsequently died.
Tables If. and III. shew the results of the trawling
on 12th and 15th October.
ot
DBR hh
Luce Bay, 12th October, 1905. Fish Trawl. 4 hauls.
Fishes caught. Ii IEE TV
OPC Sip eet ween Ue M A ot an a teene ue == a= 1
BPlaicerover Itimehes! “io:2.4.. 16 ee il
ere vinden titer lh 5 Zod 8 10.0 | 59 120
1B) Oye dae Aiea Bere a Tie, Prarie 5 bn, d4 16 | 26
IIe SAR UU Renae: 10h
Flounder [3 ree ee eneee ck 1 | —
Grey gurnardor pene sate zee a7) ]
Nellowzs 7:dox BRS es here 9. = | 1
Herring... ioseeed aes tet a8 | = | I
Raiaeatist 2 ee ee ae = | ey | 5)
Raia clavata, cireularis and
WUACULAUH 1 fare ty ae aul | (even) fal
es ee |
Total Edible Fishes...... 86 Sy a
Jesh some Gl i
Luce Bay, October 18th, 1905. Fish Trawl. 6 Hauls.
Fishes caught. V. WALES S| AVA | NANO Nec x.
Plaice over 14 inches., 19 26 1 18 17 ils}
do. under 14 do. 76 12 ) 10 Tee} os
Dash tele eee ae 38 WD) 7 14 12 oy
Brill WW eae orate eee jl = =e 22 = 4
ur both hoses eee == a —_ — iI ==
IOUNGETS) are cere ree vat - 10 mths ==
Whiting 222 ans. ahs eee - yl 9)
5-bearded Rockling Li} = |
IAG: UGE tsb aoohoanenauecout: = — 1 = —— =
Raia clavata, circularis |
and maculata ......... 34 nih 14 4 13 | 12
Total Edible Fishes... 169 | 87! 39) 56; 64 | 114
Q9
va
Sizes of the Mish Caweht:
D
As a general rule the fish caught on board the
‘John Fell” and the Bailifis’ cutters are not measured
individually; only the largest and smallest fishes caught
are measured and recorded. On the present occasion,
however, an attempt was made to determine the character-
istic sizes of the plaice on the “ large-plaice”’ grounds
which we were seeking. Hauls 2, 7, 8, 9 and 10 were
made on this ground; it is obvious from an inspection of
the tables that Hauls 4, 5, 6 and 11 were made on a
ground which was different in respect of the distribution
of plaice. In Hauls 2, 7, 8, 9 and 10 all the plaice
caught were measured and the sizes recorded.
The average size of the plaice taken in these hauls
is 14-44 inches. But this number gives us no clear idea
of the sizes of the fishes present on the ground, and I
have therefore prepared a chart (p. 95) which shows the
numbers of plaice taken in these hauls arranged in groups
in which the size varies from inch to inch.
This Chart shews that the greater number of fish
taken in the hauls selected were from 11} to 16} inches
in length. Few were caught which were smaller than
113 inches or larger than 165 inches. The “ mode” or
predominant size of the plaice present is 13} inches. If
the curve is “smoothed” the position of the ‘“ mode”
changes slightly and is about 14 inches.
It should be observed that no one form of fishing
apparatus used alone gives a representative sample of
the fish present on a fishing ground. In the haul of the
shrimp trawl quoted it will be seen that only four plaice
were caught which were larger that six inches. This is
because the
oe
draught ” of water through the shrimp net
is so much less than through the 7-inch mesh employed
in the other hauls that very few large fishes were retained
93
in the net. It will also be seen that slight changes in
the position of the ground trawled over influence the
nature of the catch very greatly; and that the presence
of weed or debris in the net has also a great effect. To
obtain a true picture of the kind of fish even on such a
small area as the shallow waters of Luce Bay, a number
of hauls would have to be taken, employing not only a
shrimp net but also such a large-meshed net as was used
in the present experiments, and perhaps also, a net of
intermediate mesh—say four inches.
3c
ot
15
ov
=)
is}
U
fish
ea
of
inch groups
Rape Vinee ioe ee ISO, | Tie. IG. Bae
Fia. 8.—Sizes of the plaice caught in Hauls 2, 7-10.
Strict account was, however, kept of the plaice over
and under 14 inches in length. ‘Those over 14 inches
are usually mature, and with the exception of a few males
those under that size hmit are immature. The results
are :—
Plaice over 14 inches im length... 2.)
Plaice under 14 inches in length ... .. 343
94
The larger fish were therefore 27:3 per cent. of the
total quantity caught.
The largest dab caught was 152 inches.
The largest flounder caught was 172 inches.
Both were unusually large fishes.
A turbot was also taken which measured 50 inches
and weighed 20 Ibs.
Dabs and Plaice.
Except in the single haul with the shrimp net com-
paratively few dabs were caught. The ratio of dabs to
plaice was 1 : 2°5.
The usual Physical Observations. were
taken. These were:.
Wind: N.W., ight to fresh.
Weather : Rainy and dull at first, fine later.
Sea Temperature: 10°1° C. to 11°8° C.
Aw Temperature : 46° F. to 55° F.
Specific gravity of the sea water at the surface: 1026°3
to 1026-4.
Transparency of the sea water : 16 to 18 ft.
Invertebrates taken in the nets.
Simple and compound AscipIaNs (very numerous).
Motiusca:-—Mactra stultorum, Pecten opercularis,
Modwolus, Holis sp., Loligo media (common), L. vulgaris (7
specimens), Buccinum, Fusus and Cyprina (dead shells).
Crusracka: Pandalus annulicornis, Crangon vulgaris,
Cancer pagurus, Carcinus meenas, Portunas holsatus, P. puber,
Stenorhynchus longirostris, Porcellana longicornis, Hupagurus
bernhardus, Homarus vulgaris, Hyas araneus.
Potyzoa :—Flustra was taken and other encrusting
forms were observed but not identified.
EcHtnopERMATA: -Solaster papposus, Ophiura spp.,
95
Astropecten, Asterias rubens, Echinus miliaris, Echino-
cyamus pusillus, Thyone sp., and Cucumaria plancei
(very abundant).
C@LENTERATA :— Actinia equina, Alcyonium digitatum
and Fhizostoma pulmo. Many zoophytes were, of course,
taken but were not identified.
Five Hauls on December 6th and
hth os Oo:
On this occasion the same fish-trawl net was employed
as on October 12th and 13th. All the plaice taken which
were over 15 inches in length were retained for hatching
purposes and taken to Port Erin. No special observations
were made on this occasion and I give only a table
shewing the results of the five hauls. The plaice caught
were, as a rule, smaller than in the fishing operations in
October of this year.
Luce Bay, December 6th & 7th, 1905. Fish Trawl.
5 Hauls.
Fishes caught. lk Wee eal Le IDG, JIN. V.
\
Plaice over 13 inches.) 28 2 15 24 20
do. under 13. do. 94 56 15 48 46
Dabs.teas: eee ee Bach 0 2 49, 28 27
Brill oe eee == — aes 1 if
Lemon sol6sse-esn-se — Sr ah ene foe ee 3
Cod fore eee at Ay i Srey SAE USS 5
Herring: -.-.avasstheensee: aeage | eer eran ta | 3
Gadus minutus er. eves — |. 1 | i —
Raia batts entree 2h 2 — | 4 3
Raia clavata, circularis
ana maculata... 222 ea® 200. 265) 48 34
Total Edible Fishes...| 196 | 88 Nand
96
2. Haul with a Shrimp-trawl in Fishguard Bay, Milford
Haven Fishery District, on June 23, 1905.
1—Physical conditions, &c.
Wind: calm.
Weather: fine.
Sea: smooth.
Bar.: 30°6.
Air temp.: Dry 66°5, wet 64°5.
Sea temp.: 14°2 at surf.
Spec. grav.: 1026°2.
Transp.: 18 feet.
Net used: Shrimp trawl net, 3in. mesh, 50ft.
beam.
1 hour haul, 3°55 p.m.—4 p.m.
131 to 8 faths.: bottom of black sand becoming
hight later.
2. 26 aAcean
Soles: 10, 8%in.-153in.
Plaice: 16, less than Sin. :
Plaice: 75, over 8in.
Dabs: 22, less than 8in.
Dabs: 30, over Sin.
Ray: 5, under 4in.
Ray: 6, over 4in. J Mostly R. clavata.
Brill: 1, 234in.
Grey gurnards: 4, 103in.-12in.
Grey gurnards: 15, 4in.-9in.
Sprats: 1,890.
Iimneidible Hashes.
Solenettes: 11.
Galeus vulgaris: 1.
Callionymus lyra: very numerous.
oF
Invertebrates caught.
Motiusca:—Nucwa, Scaphander lignarius (feeding on
Nucula), Mactra stultorum, Psammobia sp., Natica catena
(one specimen var. alba), Loligo media (very numerous),
Sepiola atlantica, Rossia macrosoma, Philine aperta, Natica
spawn.
Crustacea :—Corystes, Portunus, Atelecyclus heterodon.
EcHInopEeRMs :-—Ophiura spp., Asterias rubens, Echinus
esculentus and I). miliaris.
Just outside Fishguard Bay, in water of 16] to 20
fathoms, we had another haul with the shrimp trawl on
the 24th June. The results were:
Dabs: 2; ‘tim. to 9in.
Whiting: 4, 74in. to Llin.
Raia maculata: 2, 144in. to 15gin.
Sand eel: 1, Gin.
Onus trieirrhata: 3, Gin.
Gadus minutus: 35, 5in. to din.
Shrimps: 1 specimen.
Callionymus lyra: not abundant.
The invertebrates were very few indeed. One
specimen of Pasiphea sivado was taken: Loligo media was
numerous; Pecten opercularis, Echinus esculentus and
I). miliaris were the only other invertebrates noticed.
It is mteresting to compare the three closed areas:
Luce Bay, Blackpool Closed Ground, and Fishguard Bay.
In the former we have a rich fish fauna (rich in point
of number and species) and a peculiar distribution of
plaice and other flat fishes in respect of sizes—-plaice of
all sizes being found on the same shallow-water area.
Blackpool Closed Ground presents a great abundance of
individuals belonging to a very few species, and this
G
98
abundance varies exceedingly from season to season, the
variations in the nature and abundance of flat and other
fishes being greater than can possibly be accounted for by
accidental circumstances; again, during the months of
October, November and December, im which we have
trawled in Luce Bay we have observed hardly any
variation in the numbers and kinds and sizes of fishes
which might not be due to the accidents of the
observations. In Fishguard Bay there was a fish fauna
both abundant and various. It ought to be stated,
however, that we have only one or two observations
of the fish on this ground, and it may easily be the case
that variations in distribution as marked as those on
Blackpool Ground may occur in different seasons of the
year. Obviously, closure of an area does not always
produce the same results; many other circumstances-
physical conditions, fishing im adjacent water, and the
like, must operate in masking the effects of the closure.
The haul outside Fishguard Bay presents no features
worthy of note.
q 3. Food of Plaice and Dabs.
The following observations relate to the examination
of the stomachs of plaice and dabs taken together on the
same ground, and in the same hauls with the trawl-net.
Comparatively few fishes have so far been examined, but
it is hoped to devote considerably more time in the future
to this branch of work. The examinations have been
made from the poimt of view of the supposed competition
of the two species with each other in respect of food. » The
individual sizes of the fishes examined are not given, but
in the great majority of cases the plaice were from Sin. to
about 12in. in length (9in. would represent the average
size), while the dabs were rather smaller (about 8in. lone).
5
i)
The quantities of the two kinds of fishes taken in the
hauls are also given.
June 20th, 1905.—-Near Puffin Island. 109. plaice
and 110 dabs:
No. examined. Food.
6 plaice ... ... Serobicularia (common), ,
Solen, Pectinarta, I’chinocyamus.
6 dabs_... ... Hermit crabs (common),
Ophioglypha (common), polychaetes.
23rd June, 1905.— Fisheuard Bay. Shrimp trawl;
7 plaice over 8in., 30 dabs over Sin.:
3 plaice ... ... all Mactra.
3dabs_... ... all young Carcinus moenas, } to + meh
in breadth.
July 6th, 1905. Beaumaris Bay. 101 plaice 6hin.
to Lliin.; 53 dabs 94in. to 12im. :
10 plaice. 10 dabs.
All feeding on Mactra 1. Ophioglyphaand Natica,
and Serobicularia, 2: do. do.
1 also on polychaete worms. — 3. do. do.
4. do. do.
5 do. do.®
6. Hermit crabs.
7. Soft crabs.
8. Polychaete worms.
9. Mactra and Scrobicularia.
10. Scrobicularia.
In this case three of the dabs and three of the plaice
were feeding on the same animals.
July 12th, 1905. Bahama Bank. 29 plaice and three
dabs :
3 dabs.
1. Hermit crabs. All the plaice caught were
2. Solen, Hermit crabs. used for the marking
3, Solen, Polychaetes. experiment,
100
20th July, 1905.—Three miles W.N.W. from
Llandwyn. Six plaice and 20 dabs :—
5 dabs examined.
1. Crabs. $. Solen.
2. do., Solen. 5. Ophiuroids, Solen,
8. do., Mactra.
2lst July, 1905.=-Three miles W.S.W.—-trom
Tremadoe Bar Buoy. 11 plaice and 316 dabs : —
8 dabs examined.
iL Soft crabs.
2 Polychaetes, Portunus holsatus.
3. Porcellana longicornis.
4, Aphrodite, Philine aperta, erabs.
5 & 6. Mactra.
i Ophiuroids.
Crabs.
24th July, 1905—17 miles 8.W. by W. from Calf
of Man. No plaice, 14 dabs :—
11 dabe’ examiumed.
oaks
i Ophiura albida, Nereids, small crabs.
2&3. Ophiura albida, small crabs. :
4, Crabs, large quantity of some zoophyte.
5. @ Ophiura albida, Hulima bilineata.
6,7 & 8. Ophiura albida.
9 & 10. Ophiura albida and hermit crabs.
els Ophiura albida, hermit crabs, small Carcacrus.
13th September, 1905. Red Wharf Bay. 50 plaice
and 75 dabs:
6 plaice examined. G dabs examined,
All feeding on Scrobicularia. 1. Carcimus,
2. Carcinus and other crab
remains.
3. Crabs and polychaete
worms.
4. Corystes, Tellina, Solen*
5. Ophiuroids and Scrohi-
cularia.
6. Tellinaand Scrobicularia,
1o1
12th October,
dabs :
ad
(/ plaice examined.
1& 2. Nucula.
3.& 4. Polychaetes.
5 Pectinarta, Cucumarta.
6. Solen.
7 Solen and Serobicu-
laria.
25rd November, 1905.—
plaice, 36 dabs :-
1&2. Pellina:
3. Tellina and Serobicu-
larta.
4, Nercids.
5 & 6. Neretds and Scrobicu-
laria.
7th December, 1905.—
dabs :-
6 plaice.
10 plaice.
1 to 8. Stomachs empty.
9. Small Amphipod.
10. Errant Polychaete.
1905.—Luce Bay.
59 plaice, 16
6 dabs examined.
Pecten, Carcinus, Car-
dium, Solen, Serobi-
cularia.
2 & 3. Solen and Hyas.
4, Ophioglypha, Solen.
5. Scrobicularia & Solen.
6. Scrobicularia and
Nucla.
Off Conway Bar Buoy. 122
5 da bse
1. Virgularia miralilis,
Obelia longissima,
Bougainvillea ramosa,
Hydrallmania falcata,
Lafwa dumosa.
Crabs.
Crabs and Ophiura sp.
Crabs and Psammobia.
. Shrimp and Psammobia.
Luce Bay.
bo
ce ce
as
oO
>
~/
66 plaice,
°
il i
1 & 2. Empty.
3&4. Cardium echinatum.,
Crab, simple asei-
dians.
Hermit erab, Solen.
dabs.
6. Philine, 2 simple asci-
dians.
fe Five Simple ascidians,
8. Ophiuroids.
2. Hermit crabs and
Stenorhynchus.
10. Actinian, foot of large
lamellibranch.
libs Foot of (2) Cardium.
to?
In this last haul, nearly all the stomachs of the dabs
examined were half empty.
16th December, 1905. Off Patches Buoy, Aberyst-
with:
8 plaice. 8 dabe:
i, Solen and poly- ly Ophiura albida.
chaetes. 2 to 4. do. do.
2. Amphipod and Solen. 5. Nereids.
3 to 8. Empty. 6. Solen, Serpula, Eupa-
gurus bernhardus.
is Bupagurus bernhardus
8. Ophiura albida,
Philine aperta, erabs
One cod, caught off Blackpool on 8th December,
1905. The fish was a female 37din. long, was in bad con-
dition when received, and the contents of the stomach had
undergone considerable post-mortem digestion. They
were :
+ dabs, Gin. to 8in. long;
7 other pleuronectid fishes ;
3 herrings (or sprats), 5in. to Sin. long;
9 other round fishes—not herrings ;
15 shrimps.
There was, in addition, a large mass of semi-digested
food matter in the stomach, most of which consisted of
the disarticulated bones of fishes.
4, Reproductive condition of Herring in Cardigan and
Carnarvon Bays in Winter.
* Three lots of herring caught m these areas were sent
to me by the bailiffs on Dr. Jenkins’ instructions. They
were examined for the condition of the roes, and for the
food contents of the stomachs. The details are :—
108
(1) 13 herrings caught in Nevin Bay, Carnarvon Bay,
one mile from shore in three fathoms on December Ist,
1905
S were spent females:
) were spent males,
In all cases the stomachs were empty.
(2) 12 herrings caught off New Quay on December
4th, 1905, at night
1 was a spent female:
+ were spent males;
+ were full females:
4 were full males.
All the stomachs were empty.
(5) 12 herrings caught close inshore in Nevin Bay,
Carnarvon Bay, on sand and on gravel on 15th December,
1905—
+ were spent females ;
were spent males:
1 was a full female;
3 were full males. 2
All the stomachs were empty.
These results are extremely interesting. It is
evident that full herring are to be found off the Welsh
coast in winter, and probably deposit their spawn there.
It is most desirable that samples of herring from all the
Welsh fisheries should be obtained and examimed.
5. Sea temperature and catches of Whitings.
The connection between hydrographical observations
and the abundance of food fishes is well illustrated*™ by a
discussion of the sea temperature and the catches of
haddoek made by steam trawlers fishing off Granton on
the East coast of Scotland. A curve is given in the
** See D’Arcy Thompson, Granton Trawling Statistics. Report
on North Sea Investigations, p. 265, 1905,
104
article referred to, which shows the closest correspondence
between the catches of this fish and the temperature ot
the sea. I have tried to see if a similar correspondence
existed between any food fish and the sea temperature in
our own area, but we do not possess data to enable such
a comparison to be made as it should be. The shrimp
trawl. statistics taken by Mr. Eecles on the Liverpool
Shrimping Ground during the years 1895-1899 do,
however, yield a reliable series of figures. | Most unfortu-
nately we have no good records of sea temperatures. On
board the * John Fell” the temperature of the sea at the
surface is always taken at the beginning of a haul with
a trawl net, and the thermometer, which is a reliable one,
is always correctly read to one-fifth of a degree centi-
grade. | Untortunately the “John Fell” has a wide
district and the number of temperature observations in
Liverpool Bay are rather few for our purpose. The
average monthly temperatures are calculated from the
records of the “ John Fell” and the New Brighton police
cutter. I think the latter temperature data are not quite
reliable but they are the best we can obtain.
The figures shewing the variation in the abundance
of whiting from month to month during the year are,
I think, quite reliable. All the figures for each month
during the period 1893-9 have been grouped together and
averages have*been calculated. Accidental fluctuations
are got rid of by the statistical device of taking three-
monthly averages for every month. ‘That is, the average
for January is really the average for the three months
December-January-February; that for February is the
average of the months January-February-March, and so
on.
The figures so obtained are as follows:
105
Average catches of immature whiting on the Mersey
Shrimping Grounds during the years 1895-9; with the
temperature of the sea for the year 1905 :-
Average tem-
No. of Average perature of the
hauls. catch.* sea at the
surface (°C).
JADUAT VE | see s: 39 | 33 orl
Kebriiary 2 38 | 62 6-4
March 4... sin Wi 2S 5b
Anh 2 ane 56 99 8-6
Ea ore eater ane 75 83 1
JMC zee woke ee 74 | 28 15
Jil, gt | ee aa! 17-7
AUSUShe Pate yor 90 | oie 17°3
September... ... ay) | 759 14-5
October=— 5, =: 68 466 10-1
November... ... 45 250 8:3
December 5 Wie ot | 48
* *€3-monthly averages taken monthly.”” io
That they may be the more easily understood I have
represented these results on the chart. The curve has
been * smoothed.”
Now, one must remember that the temperature obser-
vations are few and imperfect, and that the form of the
curve might be different if a more extensive series of
observations were available. Nevertheless, it will be seen
106
that there is a correspondence between the abundance of
whiting and the temperature of the sea water. It must
be confessed that results hke this are very tantalising and
make one wish for more extensive series of statistical
figures.* I think, too, that they indicate the value of
exact hydrographical investigations.
The form of the curve for whiting should be noticed.
This curve is constructed from a great number of observa-
tions and probably yields a tolerably accurate picture of
Jany, Feby. Mar April) May. dune. July Aug. Sept. Oct Nov. Dec.
Big. 9. Relation between abundance of immature whiting and the
temperature of the sea.
the abundance of young whiting en the Mersey Shrimping
Grounds. There is a minor maximum of abundance of
whiting in the month of March. This is due to an
immigration of fish of the previous year’s spawning.
Then in June the fish become scarce and immediately
begin to become more abundant, attaining the maximum
* It ought to be possible to obtain daily temperature records
from the yarious lightships off the coasts of Lancashire and Wales.
I would suggest that this be attempted.
LO7
for the year in the month of August. The fish present
at this time are probably those resulting from the same
year’s spawning. Then when the temperature of the
sea falls whiting become less abundant, and a minimum is
reached in December and January.
6. Occurrence of large Plaice at New Quay.
Two hauls made by Mr. E. Williams, the Bailiff
stationed at New Quay, are of interest as shewing that
large and mature plaice are not necessarily confined to
comparatively deep water, but may occur close in shore.
The hauls were :—
ith March, 1905.—Oft New Quay head, four miles
INGE:
Bae be eC aaa het -
Plaice: 80, 251m. to Tin. in length.
Brills: 2, 19im. to 16in. im length.
Whitings: 15, 18in. to I4in. in length.
Skates: 2, 19m. in length.
27th March, 1905.—-Near the same place:
Soles: 5, I4in. to 12in. in length.
Plaice: 50, 17im. to Sin. in length.
Whitines: 6, 16mm. to 151m. in length.
Skates: 7, 12in. to 8in. in length.
That large and mature plaice occur only sporadically
in inshore waters is due, I think, to the fact that such
large fish are necessarily few in number, and are easily
fished out in comparison with those of smaller size, and
not to any necessary connection between the habits of
the fish and the depth of water.
108
REPORT ON EXPERIMENTS WITH MARKED
FISH DURING THE YEAR 1904.
By Jas. JOUNSTONE.
A preliminary account of these experiments was
given im the report for 1904,* and the methods adopted
(which were those elaborated by the International Fishery
Investigation Staff) were explaimed. At the time when
this preliminary report was written, 591 fishes had been
marked and liberated, but since then +64 other fish have
been dealt with. Many of the latter experiments are still
incomplete; inasmuch as sufficient time has not yet
elapsed to allow of the recapture of the fishes. Tt is only
with regard to Experiments I. to X., which were made
before the end of March, 1905, that any conclusions can
be drawn, and many more fish will doubtless be recaptured
from the later experiments.
The first few batches of fish marked and liberated
were to some extent experimental, as we had not at that
time sufficient experience of the method to enable us to
avoid errors. Much difficulty, for instance, was
experienced im finding suitable labels. he first hundred
of these were obtained from the Marine Biological
Association, and were used in the first Luce Bay
experiments. Then 100 aluminium labels were tried, but
these proved to be most unsuitable. The colour of the
metal and its lightness induced us to try it, but we soon
found that the corrosion caused by electrolytic action
between the label and the silver wire was very rapid, and
only a small percentage of these was returned. Then
some hundreds of thin brass labels were obtained, but
again these were imperfect, inasmuch as the metal was
* Report Lancashire Sea Fisheries Laboratory for 1904, pp. 91-97.
109
soft and the label was too thin. None of these had
resisted corrosion in the sea for a longer time than 12
months, and even after six months the corrosion was, in
some cases, so great that it was difficult to read the
number. The later labels obtained were made of thicker
and harder brass, and have been quite satisfactory.
The great majority of the fish marked have been
plaice. A dozen soles were marked and liberated, but I
did not regard the method as suitable for this fish and no
more were dealt with. None of these soles has been
returned. A few other fishes were also marked, and out
of four dabs so treated one has been returned. The only
flounder marked has also been re-caught. There is no
reason why these marking experiments should be
restricted to plaice and flounders, but it must be said that
the difficulties of marking other fishes are very much
ereater, and suitable methods will take some time to
devise.
It was hoped that 1,000 fish would be marked before
the end of 1905, but the stress of other work interfered,
and two or three trips were abandoned because of
unsuitable weather.
I give below a summary of the experiments made up
to the end of 1905, and of the results obtained.
It gives me great pleasure to acknowledge the
assistance received from all who have been asked to
co-operate im these experiments. Both Dr. Jenkins and
Captain Wignall have given me every facility which was
possible, and have been most kind. We are: greatly
indebted to those who have returned marked fishes. The
Officers of the Committee, Messrs. Wright, Gardner,
Kecles, Jones, Pritchard and Williams, have given all the
assistance possible. Several Members of the Committee,
Messrs, Dean, Garnett and Harley in particular, have
110
GE aoreld Fy GO/E/LT 7" diysqyysry Avg oquiewootoyy wo.y “yy sop © YX
ZI aore[d OG Go/T/ee J * Aong reg uoATeUTYD WoT * SOT OL | “XT
aoreld ZZ oore[d 6F GO/T/FE Pe dtysyy sry rege foodroary wosry “yy soptun §z ‘TTA
poo | |
ooreyd Q aoreyd iw F0/TU/RT Ce ire IRS MR ta aoe ce eS NT Avg eon] TIA
dapunoy |
Lopunoyy | Sv[OS G
AINE : aoreyd Re ooreyd QL $0/T 1/E1 Pee cere reece nsec sesso verecece punowy pesop) joodypeig ‘lA
| ‘QJOS |
OOF lz ooerd gg | FO/TT/ZT | Song [fou oWoomany Wody “yy AG “AY NY sepTUE Z| “A
"SaTOs G |
706 I aoreyd g sored 6F | FO/TI/EL fo PReH eWGQ yverH Wor “MN soptur FT | “AT
| “SulOS G |
YolG eared g | sored gp | PO/TI/EL [Pe pussy ung wos oN SLU Teck TET
ZI J ooreyd Fe FO/OI/6I ne) \8 110166 B\0\e)a) sie leielee ssa alsiele[p\s\e\ale|eis alsin stelsie)piniaiaieslalciele Arg AOSV Tl
ag e anleid OG=| FO/OWST ioe eg eae Ee WRU OUTS ex ea elon
ey et Be eri = = |
“pouanyoyy Pou e: pep Bioqt TA
agn. YSsty ysly | |
aorjuoodleg) — _t mee: | . :
yO caquiMy i jo Joquny | nn @ | UOTGRAG
CUNGOLAY GNV CHLIVYUEIT HSI HO WAANWON CNV NOLLVLS—: AUVAINOS IVYANTD
Sh hava
G61 sousy Es |
— == poo T | |
as = | eet aE
— I lapunoy |
— I sqep +
— — ABI G
— a So[OS e| |
%Z-kS C6] goreyd O€R a eee ee OG jo pue 0} [RqQO]
a) ¢ aoreyd oF co/ot/9z Fee cen aR US So.
AQUIOY 0f ooURAZUB, “AON LeT[Iq Worf “N soptue | | TIXX
oe fo | I ooreyd 0Z Go/OL/E1 eg Ov grr ee Geer oe og ais ene Avg oowy IXX
a 0 0 ooled TY] G(s Wes. ae baa aE WOT “AA AG “MA'N SOTTO G | “XX
0 0 ooieyd 6 GO/L/TS | agAwgsAtoqgy utory “yy Aq “MS Se[TU € | “XTX
ABI G |
0 0 aoreyd g COP OGiigalne eo ee ae | VO Np LO We Nees oes eeu Ae
IT C oorerd TE GO D/C |e teeta “5 HUNG pasoyy joodyoriq | ‘TTAX
ese
qep sqep ¢
2G oreyd | aorerd 1 Z GNIS le. te eee ene ees OUST US Tay) UWE UEC a PRO Noni aNg
4G I oored ¢] Go/L/1T | dtysqysry Avg oquivoor0yy wlory “AQ septum Z | “AX
qep |
OOF Q] aoreld E¢ GO/L/9 | duysqysvy avg yoodieavy woray “Ay'o7 MA Septtte Z| “ATX
OT G aoreyd Oe GO/S/SG |e a eee pra coe moro Teme ye ETN
() () ooreyd TT] co/e/Tg | aysry sueyotyH ory “Ay “S Sell FT | ‘TTX
ORI 8 ooreyd FF co/e/6z °° dtysqysvy Avg oquiedo10py UWOaE “AQ Sopa FT | TX
112
most kindly acted as our agents and received marked
fishes and paid rewards. Finally, many gentlemen not
connected with our Committee have given us much
assistance. I refer more particularly to Mr. R. Knox, of
Douglas, Mr. G. Holmes, of the Cumberland District, and
Mr. Rust, of the Milford Haven Fishermen’s Association.
Both the Irish Department of Agriculture and Technical
Instruction and the Fishery Board for Scotland have
instructed their officers to give us every assistance. It is
needless to say that without this cordial co-operation the
experiments would not have been possible.
The total number of plaice returned is, therefore,
195, or 254 per cent. of the whole. But of the 855 fishes
dealt with 142 were liberated in Luce Bay while trawling
there for spawning plaice, and as’ there is very little
fishing (and no trawling) in this area, it was not expected
that many of these fish would be recaught. Again, 290
fish were liberated since the end of March, and many more
of these will doubtless be recaptured. If we consider only
the fish which have been liberated in the Lancashire and
Western District area before the end of March, 1905, the
results are very encouraging. Of 452 such fishes 148, or
542 per cent., have been returned.
It is quite certain that a number of fish have been
recaptured and have not been reported. I have heard of
several such cases. One was only discovered after being
exposed in Douglas Fish Market, and several were sent
from other markets or fishmongers’ shops. In some cases
the approximate localities where these fish were caught
could be traced, but this was impossible in others. In one
case a fish-label was sent to me which had certainly been
fried. In this case the mark could not have been noticed
until the fish had been cooked—a fact which does not say
much for the care with which the cook cleaned the fish.
118
.
In another case three labels were sent to me which had
certainly lain in the finder’s waistcoat pocket for some
months. They were accompanied by a very unconvincing
statement of the circumstances under which the fishes
were caught. Another case was reported to me as follows:
“.... I heard yesterday from a fish hawker of .. .
that he bought some fish of a trawler at... . and he had
a marked fish and he laid it to one side and the cat ran
off with it. He says the No. was L 307. Of course I
said ‘ No label, no pay’... .’ Other analogous leakages
have no doubt occurred.
Then again, the proportion of fish caught depends
obviously on the amount of fishing which goes on in the
areas to which the marked fish migrate. Thus, the small
proportion of fish returned from Luce Bay is to be
attributed simply to this cause; and the same may be
said of the relative lack of success which has attended the
marking of fish in Carnarvon and Cardigan Bays.
Bama ia a | AGL 4) TO POU Oe swoyyey F ‘Avg FILYM PY | 16 Eo'T “AI
Re Saas tat SE [FR se b= Mg 2 OT een ee Ne agi age a cad Pe PEA eh oe
“To[ MBI} | | : ‘yoo 8
SSB[O PUG e099) OT € co/Z/el | ‘jeuueyD pjoyurg ut ‘Aong [[epsuy rvayy Ol 6FT
“yORUg | IG GFI | i6 | L | c0/9/11 eo eee ce cree reeseces eeeceee Keg UOAIvUIeD tg Ze
| — |¥6 | 1 | F0/et/og |" eeq ‘deo udysoyy “pjoyuoery | $6 6IT
SOBUS 3 | tI | IT | ¥0/TI/LT hat aes smoyyey 2 ‘Avg javyAy poy | FI1 VT
| | | | | ‘SWIOYIL 9 “puRpa[qey, pue oajpooyy
yoemg | F | — | for I £0/Z1/F pes Avg jreyM poy Fo sopra FT | TOT 981
cee = dlme(y 1 £0/Z1/F1 |rtrraeeeseeceseeeseeeeenes Avg ary pow Ol Cry "ga[0S Z
s | | ‘gored Zp
youuly | a OTs ARO So ee oo kegs mee bod. Ot, | crn "BO6T
| | | | ‘AIQUIDAON UIZT
yorwug | — |) 400 1 PO/Z1/E | sWOYZRy L—p ‘Avg JreyM poy | {OT Olt *puvlsy uygndg
| | | *SULOY} RT WOdj *N ol 7
Mormg | { == | 401 LT | FOZT/T | SI ‘pureiquy, yo ‘Avg jreyM poy | TOL | 6T ‘Ill
| |
Lenser *SunAs Resnaret ‘sqyuoul “soyoul
| ‘ezIs | ‘pega | *poao “vag | ‘PeteAooed “poy “aqe7]
*peunjdvo MoH sUL KODA | -A09AT | oy Oy usyM *poel9A000d BIO M VDVIG -B123qI] Gio *u0lIYIg
|esvodo | UsyM | “DUM Ae . aeq usyM J N
| -ur |yysiem| ezis NL | azig
117
jou oye
‘S00, .,
oe
“you ORIG
“LO[MVY ‘
diu1yg
“YORULG
“yoRulg
“ORUIG
“yORUIG
“yorurg
“yoRUtg
“LO[ MRI}
SsR[o pug |
“LOT MBIT}
ssRlO pug
6
FFE
+0/11/81
F0/11/81 |
4 €0/8/S
F0/11/61
i GO/8/¢
$0/T1/81
¢co/T/¢
0/S/8%
Go/Z1/¢
G0/8/Z%
FO/ZI/9L
¢0/6/01
|
F0/Z1/6T |
F0/21/L1
FO/ZT/1
CO/Z/T
ee ees * jou ayRIG ul o10YG Aosv]TBAL
_ 899} ,, UO a10YG AosVITR AA
¢
Hecate. sumoyyey 6 ‘Aong “AWN MOTogy
pace sacsicre “oreerees OMOSBOT 7B JOU OYRIG
Ss ounre smoyyey 6 “Aong “MAN Ope
‘sumoyzey g ‘ong
G ‘ON avou ‘Aosdapy ‘jouueyy yoory
a
‘SUMO G SUOAIRUIRD puR
IMIOULT JLOg UdaMjJoq ‘S}1e1}g TRUDI]
ss MOqIey peoyAyoxy ‘puvIs, ITB |
lets" SULOTZR, LT “peof{ soutrg 49) FO
"SULOYZRT 1
‘purl woif sop Fy] ‘Avg paey AA poy
srreeeeeres SuOyVEE p ‘Avg JIVyAA Per |
‘SuOIRE Lo
‘purpayqey fo ysvoaqe ‘Avg Jaey A, poy
poy ‘eaoyy pur puey sqey, woomjog |
ht eee rests SULOYYRFT Gc ‘Avg Fle MA ped |
‘suLoyyey Z “yaodyynog |
euueyg yng ‘Aong |jepsuy aay, |
yaod yy nog
‘jeuuvyD jus) ul ‘Aong ppoyulg aveyy |
c9l'T
I9TT
LPIT
OFT
LIVE
Sell
CELT
SéT'T
6STT
6811
Pell
1&1
Gol'T
6ITT
PRI'T
sl
‘aoretd gy
“POG
“TIQUIBAON IGF
‘Kasaoyy ‘Aong
[[ouy = euOD
-MON WOdy
Aq "MN Seltur Z
7,
aquiRoao;y Feou AlQeqorg
‘SULOI}RT f
“ANOGIVFY VGULBdIWOPW WiOTL “AA SoTTUL ¢
a{WRoWWIOPY Twa ATGQRqQorg
Joo} (VE foUURYL) UOJSIOATE)
eclee 2 Yoo uosseyy) avou “yusiy Aoqqy
aouvrry ‘prox AoaqydunpY oaoqe oyiu |
Aong % ‘ON ‘jouueyH Uuozs.10AT—
suoYyzR} OZ “Avg woareure)
“ss ag9f g ‘Aong ‘9 ‘ON avon ‘ouny
., ARG oqurBdoI0yy ‘sTRoYs ,,
‘SULOYIVT OT
‘peap] ppoysuryy wow “op Qay SoTL ZI]
“SULOYQR] OT
‘diyg JySV] Vureyeg Wlodg “HYG SoTL g
— ace htm COKE) O
|
| |
“LO[ MRI} | |
SSE[O PUT a = 6 é CO/T/§
“1O[MRIY i |
ssvjo pug | { ne We € ¢o/z/
Woes = 6 z CO/1/6
‘jou yYySNRAg | aay ull Ss 8 i | 0/11/92
‘sjou OyRIG | == a 16 I | $0/11/61
‘Jop mea} dys; — | — i8 G £0/61/6
| |
| |
“LOT MBI} | | ;
: SSO) Owe || | 8 I £0/11/1%
oe
| gpa eo a aE | | Sea a | See MSL | ——
T= | | :
youurg | tz | 81! fol 8 ¢0/L/61
Sy eee OE € | £0/z1/z
“JOpMea] WRAIG = — = Il g c0/3/F
, | |
“OPM B.A LUROIG = — FTI i | $0/Z1/9%
| |
‘JopMeA] WIRA}G = — = = € GO/1/8
“sououl *sumas “poTOUL beer ary
‘ezIs | ‘pede | "pede | .45, | *PedeAooed
*peunjdes MOH ul | Koved | -AODaL | 54 5 usm
esvoro | uoym | UdYM tal a1eq
“Ul TUSIEM| 22S z
*pelahooad V19yM 99VIq
él
*SoqoUl
*pa}
~Bd2qtI
ueym
az1g
LOST
Loe
SOUT
O6TT
PST
OLIT
CAL
OOUT
sSIT
69T'T
OLUT
OO
Fell
"[2qe'T
JO ‘ON
“S9[OS G
‘Tapunoy F
‘go1eid gy
“PO6F
‘AIQUISAON UIST
‘punouy pesoj9
jocdyoelgq
TA
119
“YORUIG
“YORVULG
"yorulg
“TO[ MRT}
SSR[O pug
“T9| M81}
ssejo pug
To] Me]
SSRIO pug
“IOTMB.1}
SSR]O pug
“yneq aspoyxyT
“19[MeIY
SSRI pug
“OTM ey
Sse[o puz
‘sod cay
LO] MRI}
SSR[D puUzg
“IO[MP1}
SSE[D puz
I9[ MRI}
ssepo pug
bn)
be
ir)
bien)
¢0/6/8
¢0/9/8
£0/Z1/8
60/8/%
CO/G/EI
CO/G/&%
¥0/11/8T |
FO Z1/LZ
co/e/LI
¢0/ 1/01
$0/Z1/S1
F0/TT/1
#0/1 1/08
GO/E/Gz
¥0/Z1/€1
¢0/1/0€
cos stroggey § “AB FRY AL Poy
*SULOY}RT
| L ‘Sosseyy ‘Aong [[ouy euroomen YO
“yueysip
sop 2 “W'S sSutveq ‘prop, s.outG
Aeg udMjog
yooy g “aod
“Yynog ‘euueyy ployurg ‘Aong qjapsuy
Aong oquing
Song oquing
swuoyyey 2 aodyynog ‘jeuuryy ny
UOSSET) “SpuRsieyoo,) ‘yyNeq s.Aqeyy
Aong # ‘ON «eou ‘ounT
‘SUIOUZRT &
“MOqIeH{ IUWBdIIOFY ULOAF “AA SOTTUE Z
‘Suey g ‘osueTy ‘peop Aorydamp YO
‘aq UIBoeIO;Y pue oduURI4y
“oo taemMjeq AVM FRY ‘ouuvyD ssuery
SULOYAR} g ‘aquuRoa10py 071s0ddo soprut z
“ suULOIgRT & ‘aquIRoeIO;Y ‘ofoFY Suryy
‘smOyyey G ‘oq uIRdaI0]Y WOAT “Ay Sop g
&
uw
| E61'T
|
| uesteae
| coe
| 1éeT
| O¢e'T
| sIeT
|
CSTT
Jopunopy
| 8PéT
Pel
CPE
8éeT
FEET
O€e'T
eae |
e1eT
120
= = ee ea,
=e get a
"yoRuULy | t le essacibetl Oss
-youud | £ = | £0 8
‘youug | — Peel eee § (el
Sorel. viee
“o[ MBI} |
ssepo pug | — | 2.96 | T6 I
|
fd | lea
lie 86 | 16 | 9
|
‘yorulg | #Z | SFG ie
| | |
ge |
“yoeulg | £3 = OL pail
|
‘youug | f1 | 822) II | 8
| =
—* | &Gy 18 | €
‘youug | ¥€ | O08 | 21 | OT
| |
ie | |
“yorug | $1 +891} OL | 8
“yoRulg | #€ | HIT | €1
|
| *SoyoUL| “sumtd | “‘SaT{OUL |'SyyuUOUL
| 1821S | "pede | "pads | wpog
*peanjdeo Moy | Ui | -AODded | -AODIA ou} uy
\aseouo | uayM | UsyM oul,
c0/S/9
CO/6/E
60/9/65
FO/TT/LE
G0/6'Z
FO/ZL/61
cQ/¢/1
CO/O1/8e
Go/L/O1
CO/E/E1
G0/6/8
*potsA0o0d
uoyM
aye
| puvpory ‘paoyxoAy"o,) ‘ARG UAOZANO/)
"7" Tayseole'] woaz aorejd Jo xoq uy
“dys
VYSr] AV sq UIRdd1O[Y WHOAT “GP SoTL Z
‘drys yor]
Avg oqureoodoyy WLO1} “AAS” AA SOLE 9
“SUOMI RY
OT ‘oquiooyoryg pos Aq “AA Sept g
« [BOYS ,, UO ATQRqorg
“-suLoyyey & ‘vac? ‘joodmeG YO
‘SULOYyey G
eeq ‘atAy jo JUIOg “nx S_UBUITS[O AA
suroygez QL iyspysry seg joodaeary YO
“SULOUIRE TT]
‘SpuRIS]T oOdJfoOTY puv UTpNg Woomzogd
Jrseseees-ee* SuTOyqey Q ‘ABET JARIAA Pedy
Atq HRY Podk PRwog
srererses soouges B “ABE JV AL POY
SWOYyIe, GL “G Suneoq, purysy ulgng
“‘pursy
uyjng pure prop sould 44) UeeAyjoq
*Po19AO0ed D1IYM 99V[q
| ig | 3987
| #11 | 9611
is | peer
Ol ciel
| ETI | FIST
aa | 96 UT
\¥6 | s1e7
| #8 OFT
}%8 | per
| 8 [Fe
6. 1 Cee
| Fs | Seer
is | 9BET
| #8 11¢1
18 CPE
Sy 2
eZIS
“uoTzeIS
“uleyyATT pure jaod
|
‘you youruery, | F LL | #5 z | eO/t9 -YyNog UsoMjoq ARMPIT you JOUTTUTRAT, 8 | FIST
‘you oyeqg | rat) Ey, S en/e/1e Sspueg-ef-UO4og wtory sop F | Fy | LOFT
“Lo[MB1} 109} | |
ssepo pug = a 6 I [li GT-SL ‘shong 9 ‘ON 0} % ON Woody ‘ouN] 6 S9eT |
you oye7g | — Zolt| $6 Zz C0/E/ZZ_— Ig EQWIRdoA10]_ JO pus “Gf WHOAZ opIUL [ | FG 9987
& ell £6 j CO/F/Z OG URDBIO PY WOT SOTIUL G “SJOU OYBIG | G Z1G1
| gored GP
“Lop MR} | “GOG6T
SSRlD pUuz —_ — | fe I VPA TE JRobeEBPOcUSCECOLORLOS syHitg, Wit AONIKE, Ce) CON| Ol@y | ‘Aaenuepep 99%
: | . drys ust T
‘you oyRIS — OG Fy c GO/E/ZS Jatq 9GlUeBoaIO;Y JO pus “HT WIOdF o[L UT | 602] | aeg joodasary
: | HO "M Sop +%
eet EGS 18 I E99} 23s Ploy Moods) LO@'T | TITA
pny ee) fate pee mee eh ae oe ee
> | .
SUOTIR, ©
you sunwopy | = CZe aan 01 GO/OL/§ “WeAAL) Jo"N sop F ‘oroys YosparPA OOS FOL | FEST |
‘SOU — Fol I — FO/ZL/OT °° Stuoypey F ‘uossoajodeyy “ARG VNT TOT ZLZI |
|
syou [TH | $6 62 || tal 6 | GO/L/6T | SwloyzeF g pveypuBy wolf YY ofr | OL COC |
‘sqou JI) | 2 FCT | FOI G VGA OE |/RPveezee= uossoajadeyyy yo ‘Avg oon] | FG egeT |
= ce == | 9 e9/e/LI See re ea Avg ou] ‘Qonpue]s) 6 6Sa" |
‘syou [LD — |GeIl | $6 Z GO/T/ez | swoyyey g ‘uossoajodeuy) Yo ‘Aeg sony §G liksedap | “poo fT
‘gored TL
TEHEE [MS aan LL 18 g GO Pico | cas eS OULU NT Le Ae oona ers OFCT | “PO6T
| “AIQUIaAON UIST
LO] MBL} ‘jouuRyy JO apis qo}0og | ‘Req gon]
dwiqg = — CL 8 z co/ 1/01 uo Aoug G ‘ON aeou ‘uRUUy ‘ARM[OG 6221 TIA
122
“LOMB |
SHGOM DUG ea
| | |
| | | | .
IGP EES) || Gee hoe ey abst | Sk ¢0/8/8
i | | G | 7 /
"yoeug ¢ er yOl (le GO/¢/0€
|
‘youurg | — | — ah es) CO/L/61
| |
|
‘youug | #1 | — | ¥6 | 9 |: e0/L/e1
“LOM B1Y | | | . |
ssvpo pug TI | 98 | 6 L Go/L/9 |
1 g6 | 16 I | go/z/or
|
= oa = = EOS S
| | |
‘you eyeyg | | See lb O =. AOS
‘gorug | { Sha bee oh ay | safe
“LO[MBIy | | |
ssejo pug | — Ss | tee |e |
Ov
—
[ee FOr
) } |
= igh See ES
you ayeqg | F | got | #8
“19}9N9 VoTfOg | | |
poomqea,y & — 8
‘op a | Cte Lol
‘op — — ==
‘op | — |g 9zr| 6
‘op | t (01 | tS
‘op t. | oot | ¥
‘sjou oyeyg | ¢ 2°66 | ¢8
‘SOU OYRIG | — | PL | 8
*19}4Nd Vol[Og | |
poompoa|y | $Z €8i | tol
op | Ff | oreo ite
‘sjou oyxyg tt | kS | Il
‘yorug | — | Se.) 8
“suma3 “SOTOUL
/*soqour
‘ezIs | ‘pede | ‘pave
‘poanjdeos Moy uf | -A09ed | -A0D0d
asvold | USM | UsYM
-Uu puarem | aZIS
‘syyuoul
CO/L/S81
eo/e/{
c0/9/1
¢0/9/z
CO/G/#%
GO/¢/Ss
CO/¢/8%
GO/G/8%
¢0/¢/GE
c0/¢/8z
CO/Z I / l L
¢Q/¢/LI
CO/e/L1
C0/9/8z
*por9Aoo01
uoym
ajeq
iene ia * swoqzey gt ‘joodyortg YO | f8 | O9F'T
era cattaenT womreg | £ 70971
acessories senomyg Moueg | Fo, | IeOnT
‘dryg yq5rT
Avg oquivooloyy JO “AN Sof OT] ¢8 | S8FT
; ieee 7
*pol9A0081 B19YM 99BIq ea aioe
8ZI§
“U013837§
125
“YORUIG
YoBulg
“yoRuUlg
“HORBULG
“AITMBIY LURAY
“yorulg
“yORUIG
“yoRUIg
“yoRug
“yORUIG
“IO[MBIY UR94G
|
|
|
|
mou
I
I
ricr
0
86
6
na
o
¢o/s/¢
c0/9/F °
co/9/¢
¢0/9/%
c0/¢/$z
cO/TT/91
GO/L/81
G0/9/LG
C0/8/$z
c0/¢/§
GO/L/8%
G0/9/E1
¢0/6/0
G0/€/9%
DOOD0E ““suLoyyRy g “mmoqaepy peroyAjoy
‘suLoyyes ZZ ‘diyg qysry Avg
OGUIBIIIOPY WI, “ASM SOT ET
‘suloyyey ZZ ‘diyg yysry Avg
aquiRoaIopyY WOIT G “Aq “AA SOLU ZT
[
loncacaonodoe ‘SULOTIRT ST ‘digg wry
Avg oquieoa10py UWlOIZ “AQ Sop TT
‘SULOUIRE ZZ ‘Salut GE “oy
Surmeeq diyg yysry Avg aqureoa10;y
“SULOUYRT ZT
‘peop ploysneyy wow, “BEG Sop FT
‘digg ysry
Avg oqureoo1opy WOI “AAS” MA SOTLUU OT
SHIO A [9034 MOLIVE WOI “AA SOL CT
Ioig UaARYopI AA WOAZ “AN Soplta F
“TMOG Ae
UOARYOHY AA WOIZ “AYN Sop OT
Jdig UOPSUIYIOAN JO “AWN Sopa ¢
‘soptul LM
Aq “MN Sutaeog ‘diyg yysry vurreyeg
‘drys
qysry Avg oqureoosoyy tvou A[qeqoig
“‘SULOYIRT OT
‘digg yYySr] vuUeYyeg woud ‘G'S So[It g
SLFT
069'T
989'T
O89'T
9691
GoCT
FIGT
66FT
00
SOFT
COT
€8PrT
69F'T
OFT
126
| | | | | | | *U0174S
| | | | | Sty} Woda
| | | | | | poIuanjoa Ys ON
| | | a
| | | | | anreyd py
| | | ‘GG? ‘AeW 9878
| | | | WOT 9U8I7
| ; | | wayoryg jo
| | *M'S seta PP
| | “TX
|
Pa <6 peer val ga cs Se © lpse dc Re ee a ee Ue eee ee
| =x | : ; | |
| 45 | OZ OT + co/6/6T eee e cece ees eteeseceeces aeeeee . jouuey) asl0 }] | 8 | LOOT
“LOMB | | |
ssvjo pug §¢ eg g e | cog/eg “CTT smoNaRZ ¢ ouueyQ Aquiog | Fy | S69'T
|
‘sutoy yey Ze ‘digg yysry | |
Aevus) | > = 1 76 I ¢0/9/¥ Avg, aquumoosoyy JO “MSA SOP ET | T6 | O69T
| | ‘sumoyyey Zz ‘drqg
Bi. eal Moe 8 I ¢0/9/¢ "TG WNW wo -g Aq “M sop ZT) 8 | 989T
| SULOUQRE |
‘youug fT seat (ies) ¢ | GOo/Ol/6t | St ‘dtqg yysvyT Avg oqureooi0yy Joy | TL | F891
| ‘smoyyey ST ‘diyg agqary | |
‘youug | — — _ I ¢0/9/Z AVG oqlleooIopY UOIF “AA SOTUL ZT-OL | #6 | O89 ‘201e|d pp
| G06) ‘AVN 62
. ‘sumoygey eT ‘digg yq8ry “drys
‘yoeurg fT] = | 46 € co/6/T Avg oqurwoodoyy toa "g’g sop Gg | g | FOOT «=F 4BIT Keg
| | equeooqd0
| ‘digg qysry Avg | JO *M Bb wo y.
Again we are comforted by finding that the results
of the experiment are uniform. Of 50 plaice liberated in
Carnarvon Bay 12 were found. Nine of these went South
and eight were caught in Tremadoe and Cardigan Bays.
One at least left the district and was caught in St. Bride’s
Bay, in the Milford Haven Fishery District, 20 weeks
after liberation. The single inevitable exception to this
general Southerly migration was observed by a fish which
found its way into Liverpool Bay (probably through the
Menai Straits) and was caught in a stake net on Wallasey
shore. It is remarkable that so many fish from this and
other experiments should have rounded the rocky,
precipitous coast of the Carnarvon Peninsula.
Station X.—Morecambe Bay Lightship.
This also was a very remarkable experiment. At the
time when it was made I was busy at Piel conducting the
135
Fishermen’s Classes and could not go to sea except for a
day at the week end between the beginning of March and
the beginning of May. On March 16th, Mr. John
Wright, the Chief Fishery Officer at Fleetwood, came
over to Piel and trawled in Barrow Channel for plaice,
which were brought into the Hatchery and marked there.
The fish were then kept alive in the tanks for a day, and
were put on board the “John Fell” and taken out to
beyond the Morecambe Bay Lightship, where they were
liberated. For about a week nothing was heard of these
fishes, and then they began to come back into Barrow
Channel again, and within the first two months 16 marked
plaice from this experiment alone were caught in this
area. It is not, as might appear, the case that this
abundance of recaptures depends simply on excessive
fishing, for practically all these fishes were caught by
two or three men working stake nets. It is evident that
there was a general inshore migration towards Morecambe
Bay, and that most of the fishes participating entered the
Channel. ‘Two fish travelled North along the Cumberland
coast, and crossing the head of the tide were caught in
the Solway Firth. I think it probable that the fish, after
leaving the Lightship ground, struck the Cumberland
coast and most of them came South but that a few went
North.
It will be seen from Chart 1., where these results are
represented by the blue circles, that quite a number of
marked fish were caught on the ground round the Light-
ship. But it will also be seen that these fishes were mostly
caught there three months after liberation, and taken
together with the results of the Blackpool Experiment,
this indicates that the fish, after finishing their first
inshore migration ‘and feeding for a time on the shallow
water grounds, began to migrate outwards again.
136
The exceptions to these general conclusions are
represented by two fish which went at once directly North
and were caught near the Bahama Lightship, and by one
which at once went South and was caught in Holyhead
Harbour about seven weeks after liberation, having in
that time travelled at least 55 miles.
Station XI—Morecambe Bay Lightship.
It was thought advisable to repeat the above experi-
ment, so in May 44 plaice were liberated near the same
place but a little further to the West. None of these fish
(which had also been caught in Barrow Channel by Mr.
Wright) returned to that area, and in one month three of
them were caught to the South-East of the place where
liberated. Very few of these fishes have been returned,
but such recaptures as have been reported show a general
tendency of the fishes to travel to the South and East into
shallower water. While trawling in Barrow Channel for
these fishes, Mr. Wright caught two of those which he
had already trawled there. These were measured and
taken out to sea to be used in this experiment, and one
of them has already been recaptured.
Station XII—Off Chicken Rock, I.O.M.
At the end of each hatching season the plaice
remaining in the tanks at Piel are turned back again into
the sea. We thought it might be useful, however, to
mark some of these fishes and liberate them in deep
water. Accordingly 11 large mature fishes were taken out
from Piel in the “ John Fell” and marked and liberated
in the deep water South-West of the Calf of Man. None
of these fishes have been returned to us. But after a
sojourn of two months in small tanks large plaice are not
137
possessed of great vitality, and I think it possible that
the transportation and handling and the marking
operation may have killed these plaice.
Statien “PR _Off, Memmaes, Head.
Thirty plaice were liberated on this station, which is
at the Southern extremity of the Lancashire and Western
Sea Fishery District. Only five have been returned, and
these were caught immediately to the South-West of the
station.
Station XIV—Near Liverpool Bar
Lightship.
Hearing that plaice were plentiful on this area in
July last we caught and marked 35 fishes. Up to the
present all the fishes returned from this lot have been
found in the immediate neighbourhood of the station, no
migrations of any extent having taken place. ‘The results
are represented on Chart II. by the blue circles.
Station XV—Near Morecambe Bay
Lightship.
Nineteen plaice were liberated here, but only one has
been returned, and this was caught near the station but
about five miles 8.W. by 8.
Station XVI—Near Bahama Lightship.
Twenty-one plaice, three dabs, and one brill were
liberated here on July 7th. Only one plaice has been
returned, but one of the three dabs set free was sent back
on 8th November last. This is the only dab out of four
marked which has been returned to me.
138
Statiom XVIL—Blackpool Closed
Ground.
Thirty-one plaice were liberated on this station in
July last, and five have been returned. With the
exception of one fish (which went offshore) all these were
recaught on the inshore waters North and South of the
station.
The fish liberated on the three last stations were not
all in a perfectly sound state. They were caught in the
vicinities of the three stations and kept on board in the
tanks for a short time only. When we caught them the
surface of the sea, and the waters for some depths down,
wele swarming with the jelly-fish Awrelza—-so much so
that the sea was literally carpeted in places with these
creatures. When the net was hauled an enormous
quantity were always included among the catch, and the
fish caught were always very sickly. Even when great:
masses of seaweed ox mud were taken, the fish caught
never exhibited the same lack of vitality as was shown in
these catches, and the result is probably due to the contact
of the fishes with the poisonous stinging cells of the jelly-
fishes. I think it quite probable that a large number of
these fishes died some time after liberation.
Stations XVIII. to XX—Nevin and
Aberystwyth, Carnarvon and
Cardigan Bays.
‘Thirty-one fish were liberated on these three stations,
but none has been returned so far. Five of the fish
marked were small rays, but the rest were plaice and in
good condition when liberated. These poor results are
due, I consider, to the fact that the amount of fishing on
139
the Welsh coasts is so very trifling, and that the fish have
simply not had a chance of being caught. Most of the
fishes liberated on the Welsh stations have been caught
on the grounds round Kilan Head, in Tremadoc Bay, and
on the trawling grounds extending from New Quay to
Dinas Head. That the comparative lack of success
attending these experiments is due to the absence of
fishing on the part of the local Welsh population may be
seen by considering the tables where I] have given the
port of registration of the vessels catching the fish (when
ascertainable). In the case of the fish caught off Kilan
Head the captors were Southport half-decked boats, and
the fish caught in the waters South of Kemmaes Head
were taken by Liverpool, Milford, or Brixham boats. In
only one case was a marked fish taken by a Welsh boat—
a Carnarvon smack. Kven in the case of the Red Wharf
Bay fishes, the captures were usually made by Hoylake
vessels registered (for some reason or other) out of
Douglas.
Station XXI—Luce Bay.
On the occasion of trawling the Bay for spawning
plaice for Piel, 20 plaice were marked and liberated. Only
one has been reported to me, and this was caught on the
shore of the Bay.
Station XXII—Formby Channel.
Several attempts were made to mark a number of fish
in October last, but on two occasions very rough weather
was experienced and the experiments were abandoned.
The last lot of plaice marked in 1905 were set free in
Formby Channel on October 26th. It is, of course, far
too soon to discuss the results of this experiment.
Hitherto only six fishes have been returned. Three have
140
been caught im the neighbourhood of the station, and
other three (not included in the tables) from Morecambe
Bay.
Intensity of fishing.
It is customary, in investigations of this kind, to use
the results for making deductions as to the intensity of
fishing in the areas dealt with. If, say, 100 plaice are
liberated and spread themselves over a comparatively wide
area, and if within a certain period, say one year, 50 of
these are recaptured, it may be argued that of all the
plaice present on the same area 50 per cent. have been
captured during the same year. Information to form such
estimates of the intensity of fishing on the East side of
the Irish Sea is afforded by the summary table. In the
case of nine experiments the data are complete—a
complete year having elapsed between the time when the
fish were liberated and the time when the summary was
drawn up. ‘The last column gives the percentages
recaptured, and the figures may mean that in the course
of one year 6 per cent. of the plaice in Luce Bay and
the adjacent waters were captured, 12 per cent. of those
on the fishing grounds round the Isle of Man, and so on.
Now we may leave the Luce Bay experiments out of
consideration, and those made on Stations III. and IV.
may also be ignored, since these two experiments were
vitiated by the faulty nature of the labels employed. On
the other hand, Experiments V., VI. and VII. may be
considered together, since most of the fish liberated on the
stations so numbered have apparently spread themselves
over much the same area—the Irish Sea North of Holy-
head, South of St. Bees Head, and Hast of the Isle of
Man. Within this area about 80 plaice out of 180 have
been recovered—a percentage of about 45. That is to say,
141
in this area fishermen have captured, in one year, about
45 per cent. of all the plaice present on the ground which
were over eight inches in total length.
I think that too much may easily be made of this
argument. It would be justifiable to make the percentage
of marked plaice returned indicate the intensity of plaice
fishing 7f the marked fish behave normally; 7f, when
liberated, they spread themselves uniformly over wide
areas. Then it may reasonably be contended that the
proportion of marked fishes re-caught represents also the
proportion of the unmarked fishes caught. I think
that the marked fish behave normally, but it is the case
that there is a certain amount of segregation in the distri-
bution of the marked fishes. The figures indicating
“intensity of fishing” are to be regarded only as
approximate indications of the degree of exploitation of
the local fishing grounds.
On the other hand, the results of the Luce Bay and
the Welsh experiments indicate a much less intensity of
fishing. In Luce Bay and the adjacent waters this is
accounted for by the anti-trawling legislation of the
Scottish Fishery Board. Plaice are only caught in this
area by lines, trammels, and other forms of fishing, which
are very ineffective when compared with trawling. But
in the Carnarvon Bay experiment this is not the case.
The low proportion of fish returned, 12 per cent., is due
only to the fact that there is very little fishing indeed in
Carnarvon and Cardigan Bays when compared with the
Coasts of Lancashire, Cheshire, and that part of the North
Welsh Coast exploited by Hoylake smacks. The same is
to be said of the other Welsh experiments, for though the
complete year has not yet elapsed it is apparent that
nothing like the same proportion of fish as in the case of
the Lancashire experiments will be returned,
142
These estimates agree generally with what we know,
from other considerations, of the intensity of fishing on
the East side of the Irish Sea. It is well known that
there is a very great amount of fishing on the Lancashire
Coast proper, that the Coasts of North Wales are not
exploited to the same extent, and that the two great
Welsh Bays are fished to a very much less extent again.
These estimates must be regarded as_ only
approximate ones. It is no doubt the case that a certain
number of the fish liberated in each experiment must die
from injuries received during trawling which were not
at first apparent. On the other hand, there is also no
doubt that a certain proportion of marked plaice have
been caught by fishing boats and have escaped notice and
so have not been included in the above summary.
Influence of different kinds of fishing.
The tables give information as to the kind of vessel
or fishing instrument by which most of the marked fishes
were caught. This information was not always given, so
that all the cases are not included. The figures are :—
No. of
Method of fishing. | gee:
| returned.
Ist class sailing trawlers (smacks) ... oe 66
2nd class sailing trawlers (half-decked boats) aa) 47
Stake-nets ... — + ae ake | 25
Steam trawlers 10
Lines, ‘“‘ tees,” trammels, hedge- balks, * draught-
mets et (iit ay 6
Information not given wr 43) £2. +7 4]
; 195
This table gives one a rough idea of the relative
importance of different methods of fishing in the area
embraced by the experiments. It must be remembered,
145
in appraising the relative influence of sail and steam, that
marked fish may have been overlooked especially aboard
steam trawlers. On the other hand, it has to be
remembered that steamers are excluded from the
territorial waters in which the majority of the marked fish
were recaptured. On the whole, the figures in the table
agree fairly with practical experience of fishing methods
in the district.
Rate of Growth of Plaice in the Irish Sea.
This is very variable, as might be expected. The
growth of a fish depends on the amount of food present on
the ground which it inhabits, and it is well known that
different grounds vary greatly in this respect. The
present experiments were not favourable for observations
on the rate of growth. In order to study this to the
ereatest advantage, a large number of fish would have to
be marked and liberated before the period of the year
when growth begins. We did, indeed, set free 566 before
the end of March, but of these the great majority
captured were taken before the end of July, and only a
comparatively small number after that time. In May,
June and July we set free 227 plaice, but few of these
have been recaptured. Conclusions as to the general rate
of growth based on these are not reliable. Up to the end
of July, however, our figures afford reliable indications
as to the growth rate. These figures are :—
Average increase in length up to the middle of January...... 0:04 inch.
Do. do. do. February ...0°04 _ ,,
Do. do. do. WER Vereced 0-07
Do. do. do. 2) ENvprall sRecabted 0-2
Do. do. do. May?) o:ice0. 0-42
Do. do. do. AA bEOKe) soqeeanece 0:86
Do. do. do. AWN? eanoonter 15
Do. do. do. August ...... 1:95
Do, do, do, September...2°62
144
These figures will be more easily understood by
consulting the diagram below. In this the black columns
represent the actual increase in length of the plaice
captured from month to month.
Inches. Cents.
|
| |
un M0 AD Ky | | | | Ht !
Jany - Feby- Mar: Abril -May-JunedJuly- Auq-Sept-.
Fic. 10. Actual increase in growth of the plaice during the months
January—September. The figures on the left hand indicate
inches of growth, and those on the right centimetres.
It will be seen from the chart that the growth of the
plaice is very slight during the months January,
February and March; practically the fish does not grow
at all during this period. Then from April to September
the growth is very rapid, and it is only during this season
of the year that growth really takes place. By the end
of September the average increase in length of the fishes
8
On
—e
ro
=
145
liberated before the end of March was about 22 inches.
I think, however, this number is too low. If we consider
also the fishes liberated during the summer, and include
them in the calculation of the growth rate, we get a
curve which, however, is not represented in the diagram.
This indicates that by the end of September the average
increase in growth was just over three inches; and,
moreover, the slope of the curve indicates that im
September the fishes were not growing nearly so fast as
in the two preceding months.
In a few cases exceptionally large increases in length
have been observed. One fish, set free on the Mersey
Deposit Ground on 12th November, 1904, and
recaptured by a Hoylake smack off Great Orme’s Head on
3rd December, 1905, about 124 months afterwards, had
grown 51 inches. Perhaps a more extraordinary
instance, however, is that of a plaice set free near the
Liverpool Bar Lightship on 6th July, 1905, and
recaptured by a second-class trawler on 23rd September,
1905, only a mile or two from the place where it was
liberated. In 11 weeks this fish had added 4 inches to its
stature. These, however, are quite exceptional cases.
The “ Homing-theory.”
It was suggested to me by A. Scott that the facts of
Experiment X. lend some support to the theory (which
has been more favoured in relation to fresh water than
sea fish) that fishes tend to return to the places from
which they are taken. At first sight this is very plausible.
It is true that 17, or about 25 per cent., of the fishes
caught in Barrow Channel and taken out to the
Morecambe Bay Lightship returned again to Barrow
Channel; and if we consider only the fishes which were
KK
146
reported during the first eight weeks the supposition is
still more plausible. Again, of the plaice caught in Red
Wharf Bay and liberated off Puffin Island and Gt. Orme
Head, a fair number did go back into the Bay. But I
think that the theory (which is a priort improbable) is
discounted by the other migrations observed. ‘Thus the
Newcome Knoll fish, which were caught in Red Wharf
Bay, scattered everywhere, when they might more easily
have returned into the Bay, and the Blackpool fish also
caught in Red Wharf Bay went North, for the most part.
It is more likely that there was a migration already in
existence, in each of the cases of apparent “ homing,”
into the areas into which the “ homers” travelled, and
that these simply obeyed the impulses which led to this
migration.
Fish caught in intra- and extra- territorial waters.
It will be obvious from a glance at the charts that the
greater number of fish returned have migrated along the
shallow waters within the territorial limits. The line
defining the seaward limit of the Lancashire and Western
Sea Fishery District is indicated roughly on the charts,
and it will be seen that, of the fish returned, the place of
capture of which could be defined without doubt, by far
the greater number have been caught within the
territorial waters. Of 173 fish, the places of recapture of
which are marked in the charts, 124 or over 71 per cent.
were caught within the district, and 49 or over 28 per
cent. were caught outside the limits of the latter. It must
be remembered that some marked fish recaught by steam
trawlers may have escaped identification, but I have
reasons for concluding that comparatively few have been
allowed to escape notice. It is also to be borne in mind
that there is more fishing along the coast and within the
147
territorial waters than on the offshore grounds, and that
there is a greater chance that a fish will be recaptured in
the former area. However, it seems most probable that
the migrations made by the majority of marketable plaice
on this side of the Irish Sea are mainly along shore and
in territorial waters.
Influence of size on migration paths.
Nevertheless a fair proportion have been recaptured
from places well outside the territorial waters, and in
some cases at considerable distances from the place of
liberation. If the sizes of these fish be compared with
those caught in the territorial waters, it will be seen that
the sizes of those taken outside are usually greater than
those caught inside the district. But the difference is not
very striking, and is to be seen only when considering
averages. The fish dealt with in these experiments have
for the most part ranged from 8 to 12 inches in length,
and though the very smallest of these do not migrate to a
marked extent, nevertheless it is difficult to draw. any
distinction between plaice of different sizes within the
limits indicated above. Other influences—the season,
abundance of food, &c., operate more powerfully than the
exact age of the fish.
General conclusions. °
The experiments here described have so far been
made on too small a scale to yield conclusions of a high
degree of probability, and it is advisable that they be
repeated on a larger, scale before any inferences of a
practical nature be made from their results.
The value of these conclusions obviously depends on
whether or not a marked plaice behaves normally, that is,
like an unmarked healthy plaice. Fishermen express two
148
views: (1) that the marking stimulates the fish to travel
further than it would otherwise have done: and (2) that
the marking makes them sluggish. I do not think that
either of these views is correct; they are, indeed, only the
usual kind of conjectures made by fishermen with regard
to matters outside their experience. Nearly everything
we have seen of the behaviour of marked plaice indicates
that they behave normally. Marked plaice have never
been caught by themselves. Where they have been
caught in unusual numbers there have also been large
catches of unmarked plaice made. In the case of
Experiment XIV., for instance, an unusually large
number of marked plaice were returned, and all, with one
exception, from the locality where they were originally
eaught. But during all this time plaice were very abun-
dant here and large catches were made by the fishing
boats. The marked plaice, in fact, behaved just as the
other fishes on this ground did.
Again, it is not uncommon to catch perfectly healthy
plaice and other flat fishes which have suffered mutilation.
I may also instance the case of a marked plaice re-caught
a few weeks ago in Luce Bay, after 15 months from the
date of liberation. This fish was in excellent condition,
and the wound made by the mark had not become greater
than at first. The fish had grown 3} inches.
In the meantime one may summarise the results as
follows : —
1. The number of fish returned depends on the
intensity of fishing in the area into which the fish have
migrated, and gives a measure of the latter. Thus of the
fish liberated on the Lancashire Stations, where fishing
is actively carried on, from 25 to 50 per cent. have been
returned within the year following liberation; while on
the Welsh Stations, where there is very little fishing, the
149
highest percentage recovered was 25, and in three of the
experiments no fish whatever have been sent back.
2. The average percentage of marked plaice
returned from all the experiments is 25°2. This may be
regarded as indicating the extent to which fishing goes
on on the Hast side of the Irish Sea. It suggests
about 25 per cent. of the plaice present on the fishing
grounds at any time will be caught by fishermen before
the expiry of one complete year.
3. The majority of the fish returned have been
recaught by smacks. But it must be remembered that it
is more likely that marked fishes would escape recognition
if taken by a steam trawler.
4. The increase in size of the fishes recaught agrees
well with previous estimates. Roughly speaking, this
may be put down at three inches in the year; that is, for
plaice between eight and 15 inches in length. This
increase in growth takes place almost exclusively during
the months May to September. During the other months
of the year plaice do not grow at all.
The increase in weight is, of course, much more rapid
than that in length. The weight of plaice of eight inches
in length varies:from 75 to 90 grams (from three to four
ounces), while that of a plaice 11 to 114 inches long may
vary from 240 to 280 grams (95 to 114 ounces). That is,
a plaice which in April is only one quarter of a pound in
weight will, if allowed to remain in the sea, attain a
weight of from one-half to three-quarters of a pound by
the end of the following September. Marked plaice shew
much the same relationships of weight and length as
unmarked fishes.
5. Migration paths can, so far, only be roughly
determined, and many more experiments will have to be
made before the main tacts of fish migration can be
150
rendered clear. In the meantime, the main migrations
made by plaice on the Lancashire and Welsh Coasts
during the winter are along the shore and within the
territorial waters; the estuaries and bays are greatly
frequented by the fish. We have observed a_ general
Northerly tendency during the winter. In the summer,
while the along-shore migration, within the territorial
waters, still continues to some extent, an offshore and
Southerly migration has been noticed. There are, of
coursé, many exceptions to these general tendencies. Fish
liberated within the waters of Liverpool Bay remain there
for the most part. Only in two cases have fish liberated
on the West Coast of England crossed the Irish Channel.
Only three cases are recorded, so far, of fishes which, have
migrated out of the Irish Sea, and all of these are, most
probably, fish which were set free in Luce Bay.
EXPLANATION OF THE CHARTS.
Prats XIV.
=
Shews the results of Experiments V., VI., X.
Prare XY.
Results of Experiments I.-II., [V., VII.-VIIL.,
uy
In all cases the large cireles indicate the positions
of the “stations” on which the marked fishes were
liberated. Each of the smaller circles indicates the
position where a marked fish has been re-caught.
Obviously these latter positions can only be represented
approximately on the charts. The figures inside the small
circles represent the numbers of months (4-weekly periods)
between liberation and recapture.
Plate XIV
The lines and arrows relate only
, to the Blackpool fishes.
00 The thick lines indicate roughly
the main paths DEON VISIES
iy
ew,
qrerighton
Hoylake
XPERIMENTS.
tcome Knoll. RED.
kpool closed ground. BLACK.
les W from Morecambe Bay Li ght-ship. BLUE.
itor of the stations.
Wealely the postttors where the trish have
2liqDers TEepreseMnt The o7tlsts DELIWECEIE
Sea Fisheries Annual Re
Luce Bay
The lines and arrows relate only
‘ ta the Blackpool fishes.
OrkiNgION The thick lines indicate roughly
the mau paths laken by the fishes
we the winter ard the thir lines
those pursued tn the summer
Burrow Head
Mull of Galloway
S'BeesHead@
Point of Ayre
@0O
0)
QO ®
Wy
WD /Morecamee,
of”
e
Chicken Rock |
Om
NEW)
Brighton:
loylake
Marke FisH EXPERIMENTS.
Station V: Newcome Knoll. RED.
yprarnervon Station VI: Blackpool closed ground BLACK.
ff
| WA Station X: 5 miles W from Morecambe Bay Lightship BLUE
© 4 ;
® CA At ARVON |) Large circles diate the pasitton of the stations
IB AY by Small circles wudicate appraximately the postlions where thetish have
| bY beer recaptured, the enclased numbers represcrt the ots DELwveete
Wf liberation and recaplure.
Plate XV
=) © é ~ Yj,
a (iff NEW
gpyerighton Ys
oylake = % ) Liverpool.
4 Y
Ayre. WY Ax
y ty ®>5 Lh
WW UY Mp OO Sy
»
$
<
U
Y
XPERIMENTS. Y)
eBay, ( Black & Red f Hj
Red
Black.
rpool Bar Light Ship, Black.
ecambe Bay Light Ship, Red
Liverpool Bar Light Ship, “us
t of the stations.
wey the postions where the ish have
sea Webaciaa Minos Report. aie (3) Near Annan.
2 b a ) Sf Sotway FIRTH
hye WIGTON
25 Bay
Luce Bay 3
le Burrow Nead.
Mull of Galloway 2)
(2) Near Annan
"de
S'BeesHead ew
i
Ii
® y
Yporrow/7 MORECAMBE
yi
Ag
Chicken Rock
»
4
|
§
@ © s
@° .
y qe
wy jaylake
4 i
ae MarKeD Fish ExPERIMENTS.
iN STATIONS | &VII; Luce Bay, Black & Rea
oN STATION II: Ramsey Bay, V Black
ON STATION III; OFF Puffin Island, © Rea
STATION IV: OFF GtOrmes Head, © Black
STATION VIII;2% miles W. from Liverpool Bar Light Ship, Black
STATION XI: 14 miles W. from Morecambe Bay Light Ship, Rea
STATION XIV: 2 miles W.S.\W. From Liverpool Bar Light Ship, ©
Large ctreles kc. widuate the position of the stations
Small circles &c., radiate approximately the postlions where the fish have
bese recaptured,
CARINARVON
Bay
G) Off KilanHeoa
(3) Newport Bey
@ Newport Bay
© New Quay
2553
151
INTERNAL PARASITES AND DISEASED
CONDITIONS OF FISHES.
By Jas. JOHNSTONE.
1. CESTODA.
2. TREMATODA.
5. FUNGI.
{. TUMOUR FROM SKIN OF DAB.
fam describing here a small collection of cestodes
and trematodes made last summer from trawl fish caught
by the s.s. “John Fell.” As a rule the species collected
were taken from skates and rays. The usual method of
collection was to take the whole gut from the fish to be
examined and place it in a dissecting dish containing
fresh water. The gut was then slit up longitudinally and
examined bit by bit. Ina short time the fresh water
causes the worms to relax and they can then be detached
from the imtestinal wall without injury to suckers or
hooks. If they are kept in fresh water for about a
quarter of an hour complete relaxation takes place before
death, and in the case of cestodes bothria are expanded,
while with trematodes the animals die without any trace
of wrinkling. In the case of the latter animals it is
always necessary to make stained preparations in order to
determine the species and this is greatly facilitated by
gently pressing the worm, while alive, between a slide
and cover glass, or between two slides, according to its
size. The whole is then put into a flat dish containing
fresh water and in a short time the animal dies in a
beautifully flat and thin condition. I have found that
about 5 per cent. formalin makes the best general preserva-
tive for cestodes if it is desired to display the auimais in
152
as natural a condition as possible, or to make general
stained preparations of the proglottides. Before pre-
serving it is, however, desirable to rinse the animal very
gently in fresh water in order to get rid of the mucus and
chyle with which it is surrounded. In the case of many
species the strobila generally comes to pieces on being
preserved and if the whole organism is to be studied it is
necessary to preserve such worms, each ina separate tube.
I, GCESTODA:
BoTHRIOCEPHALID.
Bothriocephalus (=Dibothrium) punctatus, Rudolphi.—
Fig. 11.
Hosts: Rhombus maaimus and R. laevis; at all
stations.
Every turbot and brill examined has so far proved
to be the host of one or more of this cestode. Generally
the brill harbours only two or three worms, but im the
case of the turbot the number is much greater. One
turbot 303 inches in length, caught in Luce Bay in
October, 1905, was greatly infested, and I counted over
60 Pibothria in the gut exclusive of several which had
become detached. All were attached to the walls of the
pyloric ceca.
Two distinet varieties of Dibothriwm punctatus are to
be noticed (see fig. 11, A and B), and it is hard to resist
the impression that we are dealing here with two distinct
species. The general morphology of the scolex and
proglottides is, however, so similar in both cases that it
is probable that we have to deal with varieties only, or
at most physiological species, the difference being due
to the different habitat. The differences between the two
cestodes are (1) the length and thickness of the head and
168
the succeeding proglottides: and (2) the general appear-
ance of the strobila on preservation. In the case of the
two specimens figured the measurements are :
A (from the turbot )—
Length of head: 5°5 mm.:
Length of strobila: 49 em.;
Width of strobila at the widest part: 4 mm.
Ye
Fic. 11. Bothriocephulus punctatus, Rudolphi., A: from the turbot ;
B: from the brill. Mag. 22 dia.
B (from the brill)-
Length of head: 2°5 mm.;
Length of strobila: 69 cm. ;
Width of strobila at the widest part: 6 mm.
154
On preservation by killing in water and pickling in five
per cent. formalin, the whole strobila is more transparent
and thinner in the turbot than in the brill, and in the
latter case the edges of the proglottides are very usually
more or less crenulated. These differences are very
obvious and are generally constant. The smaller head
of the cestode from the brill is, in particular, a very
striking point of difference.
TETRAPHYLLIDEA.
ONCOBOTHRITD 2.
Oncobothrium uncinatum, Rud (Figs. 12).
Hosts: Raia maculata and R. microcellata, Cardigan
Bay: and R. clavata, Bahama Bank.
ey C
Fic. 12. Oncobothriwmn uncinatum, Rudolphi. A: the scolex
seen from above, mag. 32 dia.; B: the scolex seen from the side,
mas. Ji dia. , © > nooks:
This species has been recorded by van Beneden from
the coasts of Belgium as a parasite of Raza clavata, and
Trygon pastinaca, while Linton records it from the
Wood’s Hole region from Trygon centrura. According to
van Beneden it is very rare. I have obtained five
specimens altogether.
ees
155
The measurements of the largest of these are :-
Greatest diameter of head: 1°75 mm. :
Total length of strobila: 10:7 em. ;
Width of widest proglottis: 5 mm. ;
Length of widest proglottis: 17 mm. ;
but this worm is obviously incomplete.
The shape of the head is very characteristic of this
species but identification is made practically certain if the
top of the scolex be shaved off and cleared so as to display
the hooks. There is one pair of these on the margin of
each bothrium and the two hooks of the pair are connected
together at their bases.
Fig. 12 shows the scolex from the side and the same
seen from the top.
Acanthobothrium coronatum, Rudolphi.—Fig. 13.
Hosts: Raia clavata, Carnarvon Bay, and R. batis,
off-shore grounds.
Most of the specimens of this worm were very small,
measuring from 5 mm. to 20 mm. One, however, was
much larger, and I give the principal measurements as
taken from this specimen.
Length of head: 1:18 mm.;
Greatest diameter of head: 1:16 mm. ;
Length of head and neck: 3°5 mm.;
Diameter of hook apparatus at the apices:
0°24 mm.
This species is easily recognised by the general shape
of the head and the presence of the three large accessory
suckers above each bothrium. These accessory suckers
are not easily observed in such a view of the head as is
represented in fig. 13, but if the latter is propped up in
a watch-giass so that oue may look down on it from above
their disposition can easily be seen.
156
P. J. van Beneden in diagnosing the genus says:
* The four bothria are each armed with two hooks, united
at their bases and biturcated at the apices.” IJ have not
been able to see this union of the hooks. The extremities
(fig. 15) are closely apposed and one seems to fit into the
intel; als} Acanthobothrium coronatwm, van Ben. Scolex mag. 22
dia.. hooks mag. 200 dia.
other, forming a kind of ball and socket jomt. There is
apparently no fusion of the substance of these structures.
Calliobothrium verticillatum, Rudolphi.—Figs. 14.
Host: Galeus vulgaris, Cardigan Bay.
P. J. van Beneden recorded this species from Galeus
canis, Mustelus vulgaris, and Squatina angelus; while
157
Linton found it in J/ustelus canis m the Wood's Hole
region.
This cestode is very small and not easily seen among
the mass of food debr?s usually filling up the spiral valve
of the hosts. In the part of the strobila following the
scolex the diameter is often no greater than that of a
human hair. The following measurements apply to the
largest of four specimens found in the two fishes
mentioned above :
Length of head: 0°54 mm.;
Greatest diameter of head: 0°32 mm. ;
Length of hooks: 0:095 mm. ;
Width of proglottides immediately succeeding
head: 0°085 mm. ;
Width of proglottides about anterior third of
strobila: 0°16 mm. ;
Width of proglottides about midway between
head and extremity of strobila: 0-19 mm.:
Width of proglottides about posterior third of
strobila: 0°2 mm.;
Total length of strobila: 50 mm.
In spite of its extreme tenuity this worm is easily
recognized by the peculiar modification in shape of the
proglottides, and by the characters of the head. Hach
bothrium is divided by two transverse costz so as to form
three loculi, of which the most anterior is the largest. The
cost are situated rather far back so that the two posterior
loculi are very small. Fig. 14 is a view of the head
showing one of the bothria in face, but when the head is
rotated through 45° so that two bothria only are seen, and
these in profile, the latter are then seen to project very
considerably, giving the animal a most characteristic
appearance. At the summit of each bothrium there are
5
158
three accessory suckers, the margins of which I have
represented as seen from the side. These are, however,
very inconspicuous, and their existence would hardly be
suspected except on very careful study of the specimen.
Fie. 14. Calliobothriwm verticillatum, Rudolphi. Mag. 132 dia.
hooks mag. 366 dia.
I have not seen them so distinctly shewn as is represented
in van Beneden’s fig. 3, pl. XII.* The hooks are very
characteristic of the species. There are two pairs on the
lateral and anterior margins of each bothrium, and each
*s “¢ Vers Cestoides.’’
pair is united at the bases. They project considerably
from the margin of the head and are very conspicuous.
The shapes of the proglottides vary from region to
region of the strobila and give the worm a unique appear-
ance. There is no neck and the proglottides immediately
posterior to the head are each provided with four laciniate
lobes or lappets. A section of the worm is given in fig. 14
A, and shows the situation of these lobes. A litle way
further back (fig. 14 B) an additional rounded lobe appears
at the middle of the posterior margin of each proglottis,
and these median lobes characterise the region of the
strobila about one-third of the distance between head and
extremity. Further back than this (fig. 14 C) this
median lobe sub-divides into two, and further back yet
these subsidiary lobes disappear and the posterior margin
of the proglottides shew only a blunt rounded prominence
at each lateral and posterior corner. Towards the posterior
extremity of the strobila the proglottides lengthen out
ereatly until they are about thrice as long as they are
broad, and the terminal proglottis is always pointed.
The whole strobila withstands preservation in formalin
very well and does not break up on immersion in this
fluid.
PHYLLOBOTHRIID®.
Phyllobothrium lactuca, van Beneden.—Fig. 15.
Hosts: Raia clavata, Carnarvon Bay; R. circularis,
Beaumaris Bay; R. batis, off-shore grounds.
This worm, which is usually very commonly present
in the intestines of various rays, is easily recognised by
the extraordinary shape of the head and by the appearance
and length of the strobila. P.J. van Beneden’s figure of
this species in the “ Recherches sur les vers Cestoides ”’
(also in Bronn, Taf. XLI., fig. 10), is drawn from a
160
specimen in which the bothria have undergone extreme
contraction and the head has assumed a spherical appear-
ance, presenting very little indication of the true shape of
Fira. 5. Phyllobothriwmn lactuca, van Ben. Scolex seen from beneath.
Mag. 18 dia.
the bothria. Fig. 15 is drawn from a specimen which
was killed in fresh water and shows the bothria fully
expanded. The head is seen from underneath, being bent
over at right angles to the longitudinal axis of the
strobila; and fig. 16 is a view of the same scolex seen
Hia8
a ih
Pry dj
yp Wey
7
Fig. 16. Phyllobothriwm lactuca, van Ben. Scolex seen trom above.
Mag. 18 dia.
161
from the top. There are four bothria present, though it
is usually very difficult to observe the boundaries of each.
The edges of these organs are deeply wrinkled and
crenulated. | Even when a number of these cestodes are
killed in the same manner, the form of the scolices is often
extremely variable. The term “ lettuce-like,”’ however,
describes the general appearance very well.
The measurements of the specimen figured are : —
Greatest diameter of head: 3°
Length of strobila: 183 mm.;
Least width of proglottides (just behind the
neck): 06 mm.
5 mm.;
Greatest width of proglottides: 2 mm. ;
Greatest length of a proglottis: 175 mm.
The terminal proglottis is always the longest: it
generally tapers to a blunted posterior point.
Phyllobothrium thridax, van Beneden.—Fig. 17.
Hosts: Raza clavata, Carnarvon Bay and Bahama
Bank.
I refer a number of smaller cestodes to this species
principally because of the difference in the general
appearance of the scolex and strobila. Neither in
Ph. lactuca nor in Ph. thridax is there any myzorhynchus,
and I have been unable to discover any trace of accessory
suckers in the former species. In the worms identified
as Ph. thridax there are, however, small accessory suckers
on the anterior borders of the bothria as shewn in van
Beneden’s fig. 4, pl. 5 (“ Vers Cestoides ’’). The appearance
of the bothria is very variable, but there is never the
highly complex folding which is to be observed in the
scolex of Ph. lactuca: the bothria can generally be seen
to be four in number, with comparatively simple outlines.
The strobile in the specimens obtained were always
L
162
shorter and more delicate in appearance than in the case
of Ph. lactuca. In the median proglottides the irregular
alternating position of the penes on the margins of the
segments can usually be made out.
The measurements of the specimen figured are : —
Greatest diameter of head: 2:0 mm.;
Length of strobila: 36 mm.;
Greatest width of a proglottis: 1-6 mm.
iy Fi
Fig. 17. Phyllobothrium thridax. Mag. 40 dia.
Crossobothrium laciniatum, Linton.—Fig. 18.
Host: Rata batis, off-shore grounds.
The genus Crossobothrium was founded by Linton*
for the reception of a species having the following
characters: ‘‘ Body articulated, slender, flattened, sub-
quadrate; neck short or none; bothria four, opposite,
pedicelled, unarmed, each provided with one auxihary
acetabulum on the anterior border; faces of the bothria .
with a raised rim or border, which becomes more or less
** Commissioner’s Rept. U.S. Commission of Fish and Fisheries,
part xiv., Washington, 1889, Pp. 470-4, Pl. 3, figs. 4-18,
168
free, cut, or frilled as the worm grows weak, or when
placed in fresh water or alcohol.”
From this diagnosis it appears that Crossobothrium
is closely related to Phyllobothrium, and indeed the
cestode figured here resembles greatly Ph. thridaz. The~
~e
IC oS, 7 f Wy fi: up
EG a ao Auxiliary
d 4: ak
WI acefabulum
Fia@. 18. Crossobothrium laciniatum, Linton. Scolex seen from above.
Mag. 100 dia.
differences, however which Linton emphasises as consti-
tuting the distinctive features of the genus are (1) the
bothria pedicelled here, imstead of being sessile as in
Phyllobothrium, and (2) the absence of a distinct neck.
I refer a worm obtained from the large intestine
of Raia batis very doubtfully to this species. The
specimen is indeed very different in appearance from
Ph. thridax, but in dealing with such highly variable
structures as the bothria of these cestodes too much
164
caution can hardly be exercised. In this specimen the
bothria are placed on short but distinct pedicels round
a large dome-shaped myzorhynchus. On looking down
on the latter structure from above, the insertion of the
bothria is well seen. The outlines of the latter structures
are fairly simple. Each is bounded by a raised rim or
border, which is most prominent on the anterior margins.
This rim is very slightly cut into or folded. The bothria
are set exactly opposite to each other. On the anterior
margin of each, and, as seen from above, apparently lying
on the myzorhynchus, is a large accessory sucker, or
acetabulum. Anteriorly this acetabulum has a thickened
rim: posteriorly this rim appears to be much thinner.
The single specimen obtained by me is a very young
one, and it apparently possesses a distinct neck, thus
differing in what appears to be an essential feature from
the worm described by Linton. But the age of the
specimen probably accounts for this difference. Linton’s
fig. 17 represents a young stage of Crossobothrium
laciniatum, and in this specimen there is a distinct neck:
that is, segmentation does not begin immediately behind
the head as in mature worms, but at some little distance
posteriorly.
I conclude then that this specimen is_ probably
Linton’s species, but may possibly be only a young stage
of Phyllobothrium thridaz, in which the preservation has
influenced the form of the bothria so as to give the worm
an appearance different from the typical one.
The measurements are :—
Diameter of head: 0°79 mm.;
Greatest width of strobila: 0°19 mm.;
Length of strobila: 8 mm. ;
Greatest diameter of accessory suckers: 0°15 mm,
165
Echeneibothrium variabile, van Beneden.—Figs. 19, A, B.
Hosts: Raza cavata, Carnarvon Bay, Duddon Banks,
Bahama Bank, and off-shore grounds; QR. batis, off-shore
grounds; Galeus vulgaris, New Quay. This is, perhaps,
the commonest and most widely distributed cestode
obtained during the past year. ;
The genus Lchenetbothrium was founded by van
Beneden to receive cestodes with the following charac-
ters: —The four bothria of the scolex carried each on a
Jong and protractile pedicel; bothria extraordinarily
variable in form; each distinguished by regular trans-
verse folds along the entire length of the bothrium.
These folds resemble the transverse lamelle of the
adhesive sucking organ of the fish Mehenezs, a resemblance
which suggested the generic name.
The most striking character of this species is its
astonishing variability. Figs. 19 A, B represent the two
most common varieties which I have observed. All these
cestodes were preserved in the same way: that is, they
were killed by immersion in fresh water for about a
quarter of an hour, and then put into 4 per cent. formalin.
The difference in the characters of both bothria and
myzorhynchus is such as almost to lead one to suspect
that the worms belonged to different species.
Variety A (Fig. 19 A) best answers to the
characters given by van Beneden in his original diagnosis
of the species. In these worms the myzorhynchus 1s
long and slender and is provided with a small accessory
sucker at its tip. In the figure it is almost concealed,
owing to the necessity of so arranging the scolex as to
get a good view of the most characteristic bothria. Each
of the latter structures is thin and leaf-like, but the
posterior extremities are rolled up and present a
characteristic notching of the edges and backs. The
166
lamellar structure of the bothria is not shown well either
in this or in any other specimen of the species that I have
seen. Instead one finds that the face of each bothria is
divided up into a number of separate loculi by means of
one axial, and several transverse ridges. Only at the
tip of one of the bothria are the transverse ridges con-
tinued across the whole face of the former. Five or six
loculi on each side may be counted and there are also
several in the broader, posterior, rolled-up part of the
bothrium, but the number and shape of these latter
cannot easily be seen.
oe EPO ese |
Fic.19. EHcheneibothriwn variabile, van Beneden. Varieties A and
B. Mag. about 40 dia.
I
Variety B.
This variety, which is represented in fig. 19 B was a
very common one. ‘The myzorhynchus is always more
rounded and club-like than in Var. A, and I have not
observed any indications of a sucker at its tip. The
bothria are thin and leaf-like, and are borne on compara-
tively long pedicels; their anterior extremities are more
ed
167
tapering than in Var. A. As in the former case their
posterior edges are rolled up and notched at the margins
and backs. Each bothrium bears from seven to nine
separate loculi which was distributed much as in Var. A.
A central, and four transverse ridges divide up the face
so as to form four loculi on each margin of the bothrium.
One loculus is nearly always apical, as shewn in the
figure. At the posterior edge two strong ridges, running
out radially, separate the face of the bothrium into three
cup-shaped loculi.
Seen from the side, as in the case of the bothrium at
the top left-hand of fig. 19 B, each of the latter structures
presents a very characteristic appearance when seen in
profile.
Variety C.
The cestodes identified as Var. C of Heh. variabile
differ so much from those already described that I hesitate
to place them in this species. But it is more probable
that they are only an extreme variety of the species than
that they are specifically distinct from the worms figured
as Vars. Aand B. The appearance of the strobila is very
like that of the others, and the anatomy of the proglot-
tides, so far as studied, is not different. The scolex
(fig. 20) is at first sight most dissimilar. The myzo-
rhynchus is very large, and is either tabular or flatly
dome-shaped. Its outline as seen from above is some-
4imes (as in the figure) roughly quadrangular with
rounded angles, but more often it is circular. At times
radial lines may be seen which appear to be folds dividing
the upper surface of the structure into separate compart-
ments. The bothria are placed on very short pedicels,
or may be almost sessile. Each is small compared with
those in Vars. A and B. It may be derived from such
a bothrium as is shown in Var. B, by the complete rolling
168
up of the anterior tips. The posterior margin shows the
characteristic notching of the edge and back, and the
division of the face into the three deep cup-like loculi by
two radial ridges.
P. J. van Beneden’s figs. 3 and 9, pl. III., “ Vers
Cestoides,” represent much the same condition as is
represented in Var. A. Fig. 2, pl. III. of the same book
shows the condition of Var. B. Variety C has been
Fic. 20. Echeneibothrium variabile, van Ben. Var. C. Mag. 40 dia.
figured by Olsson,* whose fig. 15 is very similar to fig. 20.
The variety is there described as “ Forma singularis
floribus Rosarum similis.’
Such ‘‘ varieties’ as are spoken of here are to be
regarded as conditions produced by the manner in which
the animal has died. he effect of the killing in fresh
* Hintozoa iakttagna hos skandinaviska hafsfiska. Acta Univ.
Lundensis. Lunds. Univ. Aarskrift for 1866. Lund. 1866-7.
169
water, and perhaps also the subsequent preservation, must
depend, to some extent at least, on the condition of
nutrition of the worm before death, and this would be
greatly influenced by the condition of the host, and,
perhaps, also by the nature of the material on which the
latter had been feeding.
Echeneibothrium, sp.—Fig. 21
A single specimen of a cestode belonging apparently
to the above genus was taken from the large intestine of
a Raia batis caught off the Calf of Man in July, 1900.
Fig. 21. Echeneibothrium sp. A: the scolex from the side; B: a
single bothrium seen from the sucking face. Mag. about 40 dia.
I at first identified it as Heh. dubswum van Beneden, but
a more careful examination showed that it could not be
this species. In Meh. dubium there are only about a
score of proglottides and the last one is about one-third
the total length of the strobila. In the worm described
here the characters of the strobila and proglottides are
rather those of Heh. variabile, to which species indeed the
specimen probably belongs.
170
Fig. 21 is a general view of the scolex. The myzo-
rhynchus is very long and slender and bears at its tip a
“cephalic bulb.” ‘The four bothria are each borne on a
long and highly mobile pedicel. In the figure one of
the bothria is seen from above, and close to it, on the right
hand, is one seen from the side; fig. 21 B is a view of one
bothrium seen from above and should be compared with
the right hand bothrium in fig. 21 A. The structure appears
to be a kind of hollow bulb with a triangular opening on
the top. Round this opening, but at some distance
from its margin, is a raised rim from which a series of
five or six radial ridges pass inwards towards the large
central opening.
In this specimen the latter portion of the strobila
is missing, and the characters of the proglottides actually
present are of little value for the purposes of identification.
Anthobothrium auriculatum, Rudolphi.—Pl. xvi., Figs. 1, 2.
Four specimens of a cestode were obtained in 1905,
which appear to be identical with the cestode described as
above. ‘l'wo of the specimens were obtained from Raza
clavata caught on Duddon Banks, but I have no record
of the host of the other two worms.
The measurements of the worm figured are :—
Greatest diameter of the head: 3 mm.;
(sreatest diameter of one bothrium: 1°3 mm.;
Least diameter of one bothrium: 1 mm.;
Length of strobila: 86 mm. ;
Width: ot proglottides behind the head:
048 mm.;
Length of proglottides behind the head:
0:04 mm.;
Width of terminal proglottis: 2 mm. ;
Length of terminal proglottis: 2.5 mm.;
Diameter of largest ovum: 0°043 x 0°040 mm.
171
Hive pie o be.
Fig. 2 is a view of the scolex with the bothria turned
to one side so as to expose their sucking faces. The
rayzorhynchus is very short and bears no terminal sucker.
In all the specimens it is a mere protuberance on the
anterior surface of the head. The bothria are four in
number, arranged in a cruciform manner, carried on short
but very evident pedicels. Each bothrium is oval in
shape, and their longest diameters are at right angles to
the axes of the pedicels. The sucking face of a bothrium
is surrounded by a strong rim or tip which is indented at
two places on each margin, and adjoining these indented
parts of the rim there are two transverse septa which
divide each bothrium up into three separate loculi. The
cavities of these loculi are very deep.
Lhe (Nee le
‘ This is very short. Segmentation almost immediately
follows the part where the pedicels are inserted. The
average distance apart of the segments is about 0'04 mm.,
and the edge of the strobila is thus finely and regularly
serrated.
Anatomy of the proglotiis: Fig. 1, Pl. XVI.
This corresponds very well with that of Antho-
bothrium auriculatum (Rudolphi), as described by
Zschokke.* The chief difference is the position of the
genital cloaca, which in my specimen is slightly further
from the posterior margins of the proglottis than in
Zschokke’s figures. These openings alternate from side
to side of the strobila in a very irregular fashion. ‘The
single genital cloaca contains both male and female
orifices. The cirrus sac is oval in shape. ‘The vas
* See Zschokke, Recherches Structure Anat. et Histol. des
Cestodes. Geneve, 1888; p.p. 261 ex. seq. Pl. vii., Figs. 106-107.
172
deferens is greatly convoluted. The vagina is a nearly
straight tube running transversely across the proglottis,
near the posterior margin. ‘The ovary is confined also to
this posterior part of the segment, and consists of two
lateral lobulated masses. The uterus appears to be a
greatly convoluted tube, but the walls of this where in
contact with each other appear to have broken down so
that the organ is a large sac, occupying the middle of the
proglottis. In the ripest segments the uterus, densely
packed with eggs, occupies almost the whole volume of
the proglottis, and only traces of the other organs can be
seen at its periphery.
The testes are situated on either side of the uterus as
two irregular bands. Immediately external to the testes
are the vitellaria, which consist of small densely packed
glands.
The anatomy of the proglottides in the specimens
described here corresponds fairly well with that of A.”
auriculatum. The identification of my specimens with
this cestode is, however rendered rather doubtful by
some characters in the scolex. Anthobothrium ‘appears to
possess bothria which are unilocular, that is, are
undivided by internal septa. But in the specimen figured
here there are certainly two transverse septa, not, how-
ever, very conspicuous, and these cross each bothrium,
dividing the cavity of the latter into three. This appears
to be a character which hardly warrants the identification
with the genus . and the longitudinal one about 60.
The teeth in both jaws are conical. In the upper jaw
there are two canines on either side, with four smaller
teeth in the symphysial space between the canines. In
the lower jaw there are three teeth on each side which
are longer than the rest.
In one specimen dissected there were tour large
pyloric czeca.
There are about six transverse bands on each side of
the body.
5. Ray showing arrested development of the pectoral
fins. :
An immature specimen of Raza clavata, caught off
Blackpool by the ‘* John Fell” in September, 1905, shows
in an interesting manner an arrested development of the
?
“wines” or pectoral fins. Fig. 24 represents this speci-
g P g Pp p
* Holt and Byrne Report Sea and Inland Fisheries for Ireland
for 1902-3, Pt. ii., 1905, pp. 156-161, Pl. xxvii.
189
men, which is a small ray measuring 4 inches across the
wings. On either side of the head is a deep notch which
causes the pectoral fins to stand well out from the body.
The dorsal side of the specimen is figured, but I have
indicated the position of the gill openings by dotted lines.
The median line of symmetry is disturbed, so that the
pO OO 0 0 6 62
-—: 2.*
Fic. 24. Raia clavata, showing arrested development of the pectoral
fins. Reduced.
head of the fish is bent to the left side by about 5 inch.
So far as can be seen without dissection, the external
borders of the notches are formed by the propterygia, and
the malformation is evidently due to the assumption,
during development, by the latter skeletal structures, of
a position which is much more nearly related to the
190
primitive position of the Elasmobranch pectoral fin
structures than the latter normally occupy in skates -or
rays *
The fish was alive, and apparently in good health
when caught.
6. Flounder (Plewronectes flesus) showing arrested
metamorphosis.
A flounder caught in a stake net near Piel, Barrow-
in-Furness, and sent to me some time ago, exhibits
Fic. 25. Flounder showing arrested metamorphosis. Nat. size.
several characters worthy of record. The fish was
pigmented on both sides, and it was this bicolouration—
the most perfect I have seen—which caught the attention
* A similar malformation is recorded by R. H. Traquair, Ann.
Scottish Nat, Hist. Jan. 1902, pp. 29-30, 1 fig. in text.
191
of the fisherman. The fish, however, is noteworthy in
other respects. Fig. 25 is a view from the right side, and
indicates the characters in question. The left eye does
not occupy the normal position, but is very distinctly on
the (secondary) dorsal margin of the head, and, indeed, is
easily visible from the “blind” side of the specimen.
The right eye occupies the usual position. The anterior
extremity of the dorsal fin is the most interesting
character exhibited by the specimen. It was first
suggested by Traquair that the forward extension of the
dorsal fin in the median, or pseudomesial, dorsal line,
irrespective of the asymmetry of the head, took place after
this asymmetry, due to the translocation of the eye, was
completed; and that the fin, though apparently arising
from the head region, does not really belong to that
region at all. In the specimen before us this hypothesis
is verified, so far as the facts go. The eye not having
crossed the pseudomesial line of the head, it is obvious
that the forward extension of the dorsal fin to its normal
position, with the anterior extremity just over the middle
of the eye, cannot take place. But we find that, though
the arrested shifting of the eye has prevented this forward
extension of the fin, the latter has still grown, and now
arches over the eye so that its anterior extremity is nearly
in the position it would have occupied had the eye
attained its definitive position.
192
REPORT TO THE CHAIRMAN OF THE SCIENTIFIC
SUB-COMMITTEE ON THE EXAMINATION OF
THE LLANFAIRFECHAN MUSSEL BED.
By Jas. JOHNSTONE.
Some time ago Dr. Jenkins suggested to me that it
would be desirable to make an examination zn situ, and
a further bacteriological analysis of the mussels from the
Llanfairfechan shore. The mussel bed there has very
little commercial importance, but it is alleged to be
seriously polluted, and circumstances arose which made
it advisable to examine it in detail. Avcordingly, Dr.
Jenkins and I visited the locality in question on the
afternoon of May 18th and collected a sample for analysis.
Strictly speaking, there is no mussel bed at
Llanfairfechan. The shellfish, however grow on the piles
supporting a sewer-pipe, and have frequently been
gathered and sent to the markets. The case of this mussel
supply has previously attracted some attention, and was
referred to in the proceedings of the Royal Commission
on Sewage Disposal (Rept. 4, Vol. 2 [Cd. 1884], 1904,
Question 16325).
All the sewage from the village of Llantfairfechan is
conveyed out to sea through a 9 inch iron sewer pipe,
which runs out over the sands in a direction nearly
N.N.W. from the patch of stones in front of the
village. The pipe is supported on wooden piles driven
into the sand at regular intervals. It is about 1,500 yards
in length and terminates very near the low water mark of
high spring tides. A pumping station is connected with
it, but there is no intercepting tank, and the sewage,
which is quite untreated, flows continuously through the
pipe and discharges on to the sands. About six months
(we were informed) before we visited the locality a block
198
had occurred in the lower third of the sewer and, as it was
impossible to clear the pipe, the latter had been cut; it
was, however, still found impossible to remove the block,
and a further cut was made in the pipe about 500 to 600
yards from the outfall. The crude sewage was, therefore,
flowing from this latter break in the pipe at the time when
we made our visit.
The ground round the pipe for the greater part of the
length of the latter consists of hard clean sand, which
affords no holding for the mussels. But the vertical and
horizontal wooden piles supporting the pipe are covered
with a thick growth of the shellfish, and here and there
the shellfish were attached to the pipe itself. The mussels
are mostly large, well-nourished animals with fairly
clean shells. They were generally well over the gauge
size, and, apart from the question of their contamination,
appeared very suitable for food or bait.
The sample for analysis was collected by taking one
mussel at regular intervals from the vertical piles on the
Rastern side of the pipe all the way up from the outfall.
Those which were collected from the piles in the vicinity
of the break in the pipe were kept apart from the others
and examined separately. The primary inoculations were
made on the morning of the 19th. The method of analysis
was that previously adopted in similar cases, and consisted
in inoculating about 0-1 to 0°25 ce. of the contents of the
stomach of each animal on separate plates of neutral-red,
bile-salt, lactose agar; and in further testing the colonies
formed on this medium for Bacillus coli communis by their
reactions on various sugar media. In every case
inoculations were also made to determine the presence or
absence of the spores of an anaérobic bacillus, presumably
Klein’s B. enteritidis sporogenes. The results were as
follows :— =
N
194
RESULTS OF PRIMARY CULTURES ON NEUTRAL-RED AGAR.
Mussel. Number of ‘* Colon-like”* Colonies.
Mussels | i :
from near | 2 About 98
the break - 3 0
in the 4 | 76 with several diffuse patches.
sewer pipe. | 5 60
F
Mussels ( a :
from below val 0
the break | 8 One diffuse patch.
in the 9 | with a diffuse patch.
sewer pipe. | 10
Primary cultures were also made from the stomach
contents in litmus milk under anaérobie conditions with
the following results :—
PRIMARY ANAEROBIC CULTURES IN LITMUS MILK.
Mussel. Enteritidis reaction. | Mussel. Enteritidis reaction.
es 4 6 4
2 | + 7 No reaction,
3 No reaction. 8 +
4 + 9 de
5 + i 0 Sr
The results of the tertiary cultures on the various
sugar media showed that Bacillus colt communis was
present in mussels 2, 4, 9 and 10, and probably in all the
195
others with the exceptions of mussels 3 and 7, which were
sterile both to this microbe and to the microbe usually
identified as B. enteritidis sporogenes.
A further analysis by Houston’s method of decimal
dilutions was also made. Five mussels selected at random
from all those collected were pounded up in a sterile
mortar with sterile water and three primary cultures were
made, both in neutral-red agar and in ltmus milk
incubated anaérobically. The results were : —
No. of
*Colon- | Enteritidis
like” | reaction.
Colonies.
wpe | LS ee eee ee ee ee a >
A: inlece.(= {35th part of a mussel) 26 | +
|
Milk de-
‘ | colorised
Bie in 1 cc. (== iwosth ” ” | 4 | but not
clotted,
: | No
. oO Pa ee a | .
C: in 1 ce. (=zgdaath sf 3 1 } etneeee
B. coli was therefore present in 1-1000th part of a mussel
in small numbers, but absent in 1-10000th part of a
mussel. £2. enteritidis sporogenes was present in 1-100th
part of a mussel, but doubtfully present in 1-1000th part,
and certainly absent in 1-10000th part.
Conclusions.
It will be seen, then, that Bacillus colt was isolated
from the majority of the mussels examined. The presence
of this microbe indicates the contamination by faecal
matters of the shellfish in which it is found. But
unhappily this organism must now be regarded as present
196
almost everywhere in shellfish bedded on our coasts, and
its significance les not so much in its mere presence as Mm
its relative abundance. It will be seen from the results
stated above that 73. coli was very abundant in several of
the mussels examined: these were they that were
collected from the piles in the neighbourhood of the break
in the pipe. ‘lwo mussels were quite sterile, and in one
or two others the microbe was present im very small
quantity; these latter shellfish were collected from the
piles some considerable distance from the break im the
pipe. Only in one or two of the mussels examined was the
degree of pollution at all excessive.
It is probable that the faulty condition of the sewer
pipe is the cause of the greater part of the pollution of the
mussels. The eddies caused by the tide round the piles
have excavated a shallow gutter directly beneath the
sewer pipe. As the tide lays bare the sands, this gutter
becomes filled with a mixture of sea-water and sewage
flowing from the break in the pipe. Then when the tide
begins to flow, some of. this water becomes washed up
against the mussels on the piles, and the former become
polluted. If the sewer pipe were in proper repair, so that
all the discharge Howed from its extremity, and still more
if there were an intercepting tank at the pumping station
and the sewage were only liberated on the ebb tide, I
think that the pollution of the mussels would be very
shght, and would be due only to the shght amount of
general pollution of the sea caused by the sewage from
the towns at the entrance to the Menai Straits,
197
NOTE ON THE OLIGODYNAMIC ACTION OF
COPPER UPON CERTAIN ORGANISMS.
By W. A. Herpman.
In connection with the investigations upon copper in
certain oysters and upon the pollution of certain oysters
by sewage, and so possibly by disease germs, which were
discussed fully in these Reports a few years ago, it may
be of interest to put on record now the recent remarkable
results that have been obtained in America, and else-
where, in destroying intestinal bacteria by means of
exceedingly minute traces of metallic copper.
The botanist C. von Nageli seems first to have
observed, some time in the eighties, that even the copper
dissolved by distilled water during its passage through the
copper still might have a toxic effect upon certain plants.
He then experimented with water in which copper coins
had been placed, and determined, for example, that one
part of copper in about a thousand million parts of water
is poisonous to some species of the water plant Sperogyra.
Other investigators, both in Germany and the United
States, have since extended the experiment to the action
of copper upon bacteria and upon protozoa. They used
copper foil in the water, and found that Bacillus typhi
was especially sensitive, and that at a temperature of
35° to 40° C. the toxic effect was manifested in one hour.
Pharmacologists as well as biologists have recognised the
importance of these facts, and their possible application
to the treatment of disease. Copper, while being
excecdingly toxic to micro-organisms and certain
parasites, 1s comparatively harmless to man. Professor
Cushing (1899) says :—‘* Copper thus seems to have a very
198
powerful poisonous action on certain living forms and to
be harmless to others, and the subject deserves further
investigation. It is possible that it may prove to act
prejudicially to some human parasites, and it is certainly
less dangerous to man than many other remedies used as
parasiticides and disinfectants.”
Kraemer, in a recent paper,* commenting on this
says:—* While various explanations might be offered to
show why such extremely minute quantities of copper in
solution are sufficient to kill unicellular and filamentous
algae, bacteria and unicellular animal organisms, and yet
not affect multicellular plants and animals, whose cells
are as delicate in structure as those of the unicellular
organisms, it seems that this is in a measure due to the
fact that in the latter the entire individual is comprised
of a single cell, which performs all the vegetative as well
as reproductive functions, and being entirely surrounded
by the copper solution all the hfe processes are affected,
there being no way for the organism to distribute the
solution to other cells, and thus by a dilution minimise
the toxic action of the copper. Or if some of the cells in
the multicellular organism are destroyed or injured by
exposure to the solution, others are formed to take their
place from the more or less deep-seated meristematic cells.
It is true that the idiosyncrasies in these organisms should
also be borne in mind, some of them being more resistent
than others.”
It has been shown, however, by Locket that the
poisonous action of minute traces of copper is not confined
to unicellular organisms. Merely placing strips of quite
clean metallic copper in water in which tadpoles are kept
* Proc. Amer. Philosoph. Soc. vol. xlix,, No. 179,.p. 51, April,
1905, where full references to the literature of the subject will be
found,
+ Journ, of Physiology, 1895, vol. 18, p. 319.
199
leads in a few hours to the death of the tadpoles. This
observation has been confirmed by Ringer,t and more
recently by Roaf and Whitley, who have also shown that
a trace of colloidal silver in suspension leads rapidly to a
fatal result, while colloidal platinum under like conditions
is quite harniless.
It has been suggested to me by Professor B. Moore
that possibly the cause of the poisonous action in some
organisms and immunity in others, may be due to those
organisms which are poisoned throwing out excretory
substances which dissolve copper and form soluble
poisonous compounds which are absorbed, and so lead to
the toxic effects.
The matter has also been discussed recently as one
which may be of importance in killing algae and
pathogenic organisms in water supplies. Dr. G. Moore,
of Washington, found that one part in fifty millions was
sufficient to kill off fresh-water algze in water-cress beds,
and that 1 in 100,000 would kill cholera and typhoid
organisms in + to 5 hours. Rideal and Baines (190+)
found that 24 hours in a copper vessel was sufficient to
free the water from typhoid and colon bacilli. Bassett-
Smith,* as the result of a number of experiments, states
that “ Bacillus typhosus is more easily killed than others
of the coli group, being destroyed in 12 hours with the
1 in 10,000 dilution ” [sulphate of copper]. He also finds
that “ Zinc, or iron coated with zine, though less rapid in
its action than copper, yet after 24 to 48 hours appears to
free the water from typhoid organisms, and is the most
Holibrdi, USOT vol. 22), p- xiv. (Physiol. Soc. Proc.)
+ Communicated by the authors (Biochemical Department, University
of Liverpool)—the paper not being yet published.
* Journ, of Preventive Medicine, July, 1905.
200
valuable storage tank for all purposes that we possess.”
Finally, Kraemar has, during the last year, carried out a
series of most elaborate and interesting experiments in the
Philadelphia College of Pharmacy, “with a view of
testing the efficiency of metallic copper tor destroying
typhoid and. colon bacilli in water.” He writes as
follows :
‘From the experiments thus far conducted, as well
as the results obtained by other writers, the following
conclusions may be drawn :
“1. Certain intestinal bacteria like colon and
typhoid are completely destroyed by placing clean
copper foil in water containing them, or by adding the
organisms to water previously in contact with copper
foil.
“2. The toxicity of water in which either copper
coins or copper foil has been added is probably due to
a solution of some salt of copper, as first suggested by
Nagel.
“3. The copper is probably in the term of a
crystalloid rather than that of a colloid, as it has the
property of permeating the cell walls and organised cell
contents of both animals and plants, thereby producing
the toxic effects.
“4. While the effects produced by the oligo-
dynamic action of copper are apparently different from
those of true chemical poisons, the difference is
probably in degree only, and not im kind.
“5. Certain lower organisms, including both
plants and animals, possess a specific sensitiveness to
minute quantities of copper, and it has been shown that
they are not restored on transferring them to water free
from oligodynamic properties.
“6. Ohgodynamic solutions of copper are
en
201
obtained by adding either copper coins, copper toil, or
salts of copper to water: when copper foil is used
sutlicient copper is dissolved by the distilled water in
one to five minutes to kill the typhoid organisms within
two hours.
~
“7. A solution of copper may lose its toxicity by
the precipitation of the copper as an insoluble salt or
compound, by its absorption by organic substances, or
by absorption by imsoluble substances.
“$8. The oligodynamic action of the copper is
dependent upon temperature, as first pointed out by
Israel and Klinegmann.
“9. The effects of oligodynamic copper in the
purification of drinking water are in a quantitative
sense much like those of filtration, only the organisms
removed, like B. typht and B. coli, ave completely
destroyed.”
Now if these results can be extended to the case
of marine shell-fish, it may be argued that if
the typhoid organism is killed in two hours by
distilled water m which copper foil has been placed for
five minutes, a comparatively simple measure of washing
ought to be sufficient to render contaminated oysters
innecuous. The importance of such a result is obvious.
It may be asked why, considering the rather large amount
of copper that may be present in the tissues of the oyster,
should the copper foil be necessary. It is known, how-
ever, to be the case that in the normal oyster the copper
of the blood is united with a proteid to form an organic
compound, haemocyanin, in such a way as to be unable to
oxercise its toxic properties. It is probable that that is also
the case in these abnormal green oysters which Professor
Boyce and I investigated” some years ago, and where we
* Ona green Leucocytosis in Oysters. Proc, Royal Society, vol.
Ixii,, p. 30 (1897),
202
found copper stored up in greatly increased quantity in
the numerous leucocytes which characterise this diseased
‘
condition; so that probably these ‘“ copper” oysters even
cannot be trusted to free themselves from pathogenic
organisms through the action of their own copper.
In dealing with such a case as that of the oyster,
however, it must be noted that there are two further
conditions which may effect the successful application of
the above-mentioned methods. In the first place the
pathogenic organisms are not necessarily free in the
water, but may be im or upon the living tissues of the
molluse so as, possibly, to be protected from the toxic
action of the copper. Secondly, the washing of the living
oyster must be carried on in. sea-water: there is
apparently a difference in some of the experiments
between distilled water and tap-water, and what further
complications may be introduced by the salts im the
medium surrounding the oyster has still to be determined.
In conjunction with Professor B. Moore, of the Depart-.
ment of Biochemistry, we propose to investigate the whole
question of this oligodynanmue action of copper and other
metals upon the organisms in shell-fish—with special
reference to oyster culture.
203
SEA-FISH HATCHING AT PORT ERIN IN 1905.
By W. A. HErrpman.
As the Reports of the Isle of Man Fisheries Board
have only a limited circulation and are probably unknown
to members of the Lancashire and Western Committee,
it may be found convenient to have recorded here the
portion of the last report which deals with sea-fisheries
work in 1905. It occurs in the ** Report from the Hon.
Director,” as Appendix I. to the First® Annual Report of
the Fisheries Board.
The Report is made to Tynwald Court, and was drawn
up in June, 1905, and signed on July 5th. The Report
contams the following sentences :
“The Board entered into negotiations with the
Laneashire and Western Sea Fisheries Joint Committee,
with a view to obtaining the assistance of the Committee's
s.s. “ John Fell” in policing the territorial waters of the
Isle of Man, and, having made a preliminary arrangement
with the Committee, applied for and obtained from the
Tynwald Court a grant of £50 for the purpose of
carrying out such arrangement.
“The agreement is now in operation, and Dr. J.
Travis Jenkins, Superintendent of Fisheries to the Joint
Committee, and Capt. Wignall, of the s.s. “‘ John Fell,”
have been appointed Fishery Officers under the provisions
of the Sea Fisheries Act, 1894.”
The Appendix on the Sea-fish Hatchery and
Aquarium at Port Erin runs as follows: —
** The three previous reports were made by a Cominittee appointed
by Tynwald Court—this Committee and others being now replaced by
the ‘‘ Fisheries Board,”’
204
* Report rrom tur Hon. Direcror ror THE YEAR 1904-4.
(Drawn up June, 1905.)
“Last year, I considered that I was able to give a
satisfactory report to the Sea-fish Hatchery Committee
when I recorded the production and liberation of about a
million young plaice as the result of the first complete
vear of working with the necessary equipment. This
year IT am able to report that over five millions of young
plaice have been set free in Manx waters. This grati-
fying result is due primarily to the considerable increase
in our stock of spawners, eftected partly by the kind
co-operation of the Lancashire and Western Sea-Fisheries
Joint Committee, and partly by our own fishing operations
off Port Erin. The notable advance is due also in part
to improvement in the hatching mechanism and_ to
increased experience and skill on the part of our curator
(Ma. Chadwick) and his assistant (Mr. T. N. Cregeen),
whereby some wastage that occurred in the previous year
has been wholly avoided, and the inevitable loss in
working very greatly reduced. — It is hoped that our stoek
of spawners will be still further added to during the
present stunmer, and that the output next year will be
correspondingly mereased.
* A good deal of detail that was printed last year for
the information of the Hatchery Committee need not be
repeated. The condition and continued success of the
Aquarium has been very satisfactory.
*'The stock of adult plaice which furnished the eggs
hatched during the past season consisted of (1) 99 out
of the 105 fish with which the season of 1904 was begun ;
(2) 110 fish brought from Luce Bay by the s.s. ‘John
Fell,” on 19th November, 1904; and (3) 118 fish caught
in two trammel nets, efficiently worked by the assistant
curator (Mr. T. N. Cregeen) during July, August, and
September, 1904; making a total of 327. All the fish
were placed in the spawning pond as soon as possible after
capture, and no difficulty was experienced in keeping them
im a healthy condition throughout the year. They were
fed daily upon mussels, with the addition of lug-worms
as often as the latter were procurable. ©The worms are
dug, for the most part, by the assistant, at Port St. Mary:
but the mussels have to be obtained from Laneashire, and
about one ewt. per week is required to keep the fish in
good condition.
“The state of the pond has been quite satisfactory,
It was emptied and examined caretully in September,
1904, and again at the conclusion of the present spawning
season, in May, 1905.
“The hatching apparatus was carefully overhauled
and put into working order during the latter part of
January, and was in continuous operation, without
mishap of any kind, from 14th February to 15th May.
The improvements in the structure of the tanks and boxes
alluded to in last report have now been effected, and have
resulted in a great saving of eggs during this season.
“The first fertilized eggs of the plaice were found in
the pond on Mth February, 17 days earlier than last year:
and on the 17th there were 12,500 incubating in the boxes.
The daily yield of eggs gradually increased, until the
maximum was reached on 5rd April, when 515,600 were
collected. After this date the numbers ranged from about
224,000 to over 100,000 daily, until 25th April, when a
marked diminution was observed, and the last bateh of
the season, numbering 45,000, was placed in the boxes
on Ist May.
“The method of estimating the number of eggs was
essentially the same as that of last year, Ten dips with
206
a measure of known capacity were taken from each day’s
collection, and the number of eggs in each dip carefully
counted. The average of the ten countings was then
divided by the number of cubic centimetres in the measure
in order to obtain the average number of eggs per c.c.
This figure was then multiplied by the number of cubic
centimetres of water im the hatching box in order to
obtain the total number of eggs.
“The larvae were taken to sea in a fishing-boat by
the assistant, and were liberated at various points either
on the east or on the west side of the southern end of the
Island, at distances of from 1 to 5 miles from land.
“The numbers of larve in this manner set free
during the season were as follows : —
NMareh. vt 4.5 a ae vee | £4,000
ret eee i ea ctf he O00
PAT VA cat Paes oS sat -=, 20,000
TMC. weet pe ee sat i SOBDUU
on th ae Ae sa €93000
by Parte ws He ... 289,000
eS crcl pe Oe See sk od ... 204,500
a ae Mase =. ... 661,000
hy we 7 sh ... 40,000
rT, OO | 44 a ... 224,000
si Oy th ies a fe ... 415,000
batsle Vee nee led ... 240,000
Cah hee aa a ... 296,000
Spe | le wr se ... 048,000
sob aia Ae $8 sab ... 892,000
ero ci pene Le Bs ... 346,000
oe POL an i uy) ... 325,000
May 94." os at Bi ioe 2S s500
Le Phe Bee na $1; ... 106,500
;, Bee: rom ne A (96,000
are | ey nA wie 2.) 24k. 000
oo eager 7, a As me a. 80,000
oe es va «92,000
otal: 2 i ... 0,097,500
207
“At the close of the hatching season, in May, the
pond was drained to within 18 inches of the bottom, and
all adult plaice found in the smaller western portion were
transferred to the larger portion nearest the hatchery,
in preparation for the reception of a stock of adult soles.
“ During this operation, it was discovered that eight
of the adult fish had died since the pond was last drained,
at the end of September, 1904, leaving a total of 519
healthy fish. It was also found that a large number of
the young fish hatched during the season of 1904, which
had been left to undergo their metamorphosis in the pond,
were still present, and evidently thriving. Thirty-one of
these were taken at random, and were found, on measure-
ment, to range from 2} to 54 inches in length; but, while
the pond was being re-filled, a few others of the same
generation were seen which were certainly larger than the
largest measured.
“Tt is evident from these observations (1) that the
artificially hatched fry are perfectly healthy, and capable
of continued life and growth; and (2) that the young fish
which have undergone their metamorphosis in the pond °
have found there healthy conditions and abundance. of
their natural food.
“Tn accordance with an intention of extending, so far
as is possible, the hatching operations to other suitable
fish, steps have been taken to commence, on an experi-
mental scale, with the black, or true English, sole (Solea
vulgaris), which spawns rather later in the summer than
the plaice. Forty-six adult soles were brought by the
s.s. ““ John Fell” on May 31st, and are now confined in the
western portion of the pond. A number of these are
spawners, and although it is now getting late in the
season, it is hoped that sufficient fertilized eggs for our
purpose may stil] be obtained. It is proposed, unless some
205
unforeseen difficulty oecurs, to increase this stock, and to
deyote more attention to the hatching and rearing of the
sole during next season.
“Tt is a pleasure to report to the Board that Mr.
Chadwick, the curator; Mr. T. N. Cregeen, the assistant ;
and the boy, Willie Christian, have been most energetic
and efficient in their several spheres of work; and I
should like to add that Mr. Chadwick and I feel much
indebted to the secretary to the Board, Mr. R. Okell,
F.L.S., for his valuable help and for the large amount of
attention he gives to the affairs of the institution,
I have now to add that during last summer, after the
above Report had been issued, a curious epidemic,” caused
by a fungus which invades the liver and kidneys, attacked
the fish in the pond, and resulted in considerable mortality
of both plaice and soles. The fish that survived were set
free, as it was thought best under the circumstances to
clear out the pond completely, and start this season with
a fresh stock of fish free from infection.
“(Siened) W. A. Herpman.”
* Described by Mr, Johnstone in another part of this Report.
nn
3