BOSTON PUBLIC LIBRARY 3 9999 06317 740 4 TUPTS^ONpZ^JTY LIBRARY COCprrT^JT COLL^ICTIQN SANDHILL CRANE STUDY IN THE CENTRAL FLYWAY 'H<^,\ UNITED STATES DEPARTMENT OF THE INTERIOR FISH AND WILDLIFE SERVICE BUREAU OF SPORT FISHERIES AND WILDLIFE SpiciaJ Scientific Report— Wildlife No. 113 United States Department of the Interior, Stewart L. (Jdall, Secretary Stanley A. Cain, Assistant Secretary for Fish and Wildlife and Parks Fish and Wildlife Service, Clarence F. Pautzke, Commissioner Bureau of Sport Fisheries and Wildlife, John S. Gottschalk, Director SANDHILL CRANE STUDY IN THE CENTRAL FLYWAY By Raymond J. Buller, Wildlife Biologist Special Scientific Report— Wildlife No. 113 Washington • December 1967 CONTENTS Page Abstract 1 History of study 2 Objectives 2 Plan of study 3 Results of study 3 Fall migration 3 Peak population at congregation sites 5 Racial composition of migrating sandhill cranes 6 Correlation of fall migration of sandhill and whooping cranes. . 9 Crop depredations by sandhill cranes 12 Management implications of study , . . . . 13 Whooping cranes 13 Greater sandhill cranes 14 Lesser sandhill cranes 15 Summary 15 References 16 ii SANDHILL CRANE STUDY IN THE CENTRAL FLYWAY By Raymond J, BuUer, Wildlife Biologist Abstract.-Fall-migiating sandhill cranes arrived at congregation sites in southern Canada and in the States of the Central Flyway between late July and early October. Sandhills peaked at about 100,000 birds at way stations in Saskatchewan during the fall of 1962. A similar peak was recorded at stateside way stations during the fall of 1964. Footprint measurements indicated that the lesser sandliill was by far the most numerous subspecies at way stations in Montana, North Dakota, South Dakota, and Colorado. These measurements also indicated that flocks stopping over in Wyoming, Kansas, and Oklahoma contained a significant number of the Canadian sandhill or the greater sandhill or both. A selective collecting program indicated that the footprint measurement technique overemphasized the incidence of the greater sandhill at way stations in North Dakota and South Dakota. Whooping cranes and sandhills were occasionally observed together during the early part of the fall migration. At times, fall-migrating sandhills fed on standing and harvested grain crops in Canada and in the States of the Central Flyway, but seldom were depredations considered serious. Cranes (the family Gruidae) are protected internationally under the migratory bird con- ventions between the United States and Canada (1916) and between the United States and Mexico (1937). Hunting of migratory birds in the United States is regulated by the Migratory Bird Treaty Act (40 Stat. 755; 16 U.S.C. 703) which gives effect to the international treaties. The treaty with Canada in 1916 listed "Gruidae or cranes, including little brown, sandhill, and whooping cranes." Subsequently, the little brown and sandhill cranes were shown to be subspecies of a single species (Ober- holser, 1921), and it was shown also that there are intermediates between the lesser and greater subspecies. The "little brown crane" is now called the lesser sandhill crane and the "sandhill crane" is now called the greater sandhill crane. The intermediate population has been described and named the Canadian sandhill crane (Walkinshaw, 1965). Another subspecies in the United States, the Florida sandhill crane, is outside the concern of this report. A general closed season was established on all cranes in the United States, May 20, 1916, and remained in effect until January 1, 1961, when a 30-day season was authorized on lesser sandhill (little brown) cranes in eastern New Mexico and western Texas. Sandhill cranes have been hunted in Mexico for years. During the fall of 1959, Saskatchewan farmers were permitted to shoot these birds under general crop depredation orders. This report summarizes the results of the 4-year (1962-65) study designed to determine the feasibility of extending the hunting of lesser sandhill cranes to other States of the Central Flyway. An earlier paper summarized the results of the first 3 years of the study (Buller and Boeker, 1965). This report is possible because of the efforts of many individuals throughout the Central Flyway who painstakingly collected data for the study. I am especially grateful to AlexDzubin, W. R. Miller, and W. J. D. Stephen, Canadian Wildlife Service, for supplying data from the Prairie Provinces; to U.S. Game Management Agents W. Ashton Brann, Harry A. Jensen, David W. Fisher, R. E.Meyer, Loren J. Bonde, Charles R. Hayes, H. B. Lyman, and Alfred J. Robinson, Jr., for coordinating the study within their assigned districts; to Research Biologist Jerome H. Stoudt for collecting many of the cranes; and to numerous national wildlife refuge managers and State technicians for supplying fall migration and population data and footprint (midtoe) measurements. HISTORY OF STUDY For many years the Central Flyway Water- fowl Council requested an open season on sandhill cranes. In 1960, the National Flyway Waterfowl Council joined the Central Flyway Council in its request for consideration of a limited season on lesser sandhill cranes in the United States. The Saskatchewan Depart- ment of Natural Resources and the Canadian Wildlife Service recommended favorable con- sideration of the Councils' proposal. Studies by Aldrich and Burleigh (1958), Huey (1960), and Allen (1952) concluded that few, if any, greater sandhill cranes or whooping cranes occur in the proposed hunting area in eastern New Mexico and extreme western Texas. In view of these considerations, the Secretary of the Interior authorized the first hunting season on lesser sandhill cranes in these portions of New Mexico and Texas. of the hunting area would not jeopardize the endangered whooping cranes.''" These internationally famous birds have been sighted in Montana, North Dakota, South Dakota, Nebraska, Kansas, Oklahoma, Sas- katchewan, and Alberta during fall migration. Sandhill cranes stop over in many of these same areas. Another consideration of extending the range of the lesser sandhill crane hunting season con- cerned the incidence of the rare greater sandhill crane. The greater race was present in col- lections of cranes made by T. D. Burleigh in the Horsehead Lake region of south-central North Dakota during the fall of 1959 and I960. The possibility that this race may be present in other areas favored by fall-migrating lesser sandhills was also recognized. The first lesser sandhill crane season was held in eastern New Mexico, January 1 to 30, 1961. Texas was unable to participate at that time since cranes were not classed as game birds by State statute. This was followed by 30- day seasons in Alaska (September 1-30) and in New Mexico and West Texas (November 4- December 3) in 1961. Similar seasons have been authorized in succeeding years with minor changes. The area open to hunting in New Mexico and Texas was enlarged slightly, and the hunting period in Alaska was increased to 45 days during the 1964-65 waterfowl sea- son. Residents of Saskatchewan and Manitoba have been permitted limited seasons on sand- hill cranes each year since 1964. Harvest data obtained during the 1961 lesser sandhill crane seasons in New Mexico and Texas (Boeker, Aldrich, and Huey, 1961; Boeker, Huey, and Uzzell, 1962) prompted the Central Flyway Waterfowl Council to request an enlargement of the hunting area at its August 1962 meeting. The resolution proposed that the Council and the Bureau explore the feasibility of extending the season to other States of the flyway. It was agreed that before this proposal could be accepted it would be necessary to firmly establish that enlargement OBJECTIVES The objectives of this study were — 1 . To determine the number, time of arrival, and departure of sandhill cranes through- out the Central Flyway (New Mexico and Texas excluded) during fall migration. 2. To locate the major congregation areas of sandhill cranes in the Central Flyway during the fall migration. 3. To determine the racial composition of sandhill crane flocks in the Central Fly- way during the fall migration. 4. To correlate data concerning the fall migration of sandhill cranes and whoop- ing cranes in the Central Flyway. 5. To locate and document crop depredations by sandhill cranes during the fall migra- tion. * The whooping crane is classed as endangered and the greater sandhill as rare in Rare and Endangered Fish and Wildlife of the United States, U.S. Bureau of Sport Fisheries and Wildlife, Resource Publication 34, July 1966. PLAN OF STUDY Standard waterfowl survey techniques were used to gather data for objectives 1, 2, 4, and 5. Information pertaining to the racial com- position of fall-migrating cranes (objective 3) was obtained from a selective collecting pro- gram and a recently developed field technique which involves measuring footprint impres- sions. In 1960 and 1961, 302 sandhill crane foot- print measurements were obtained on Bitter Lake and Bosque del Apache National Wildlife Refuges in New Mexico (U.S. Bureau of Sport Fisheries and Wildlife, 1961). Measurements were made from the posterior edge of the ball of the foot to, but not including, the claw of the anterior end of the midtoe. At Bitter Lake, a known wintering area for sandhill cranes which are almost exclusively lessers, 160 measurements ranged from 76 mm. to 95 mm. in length and averaged 86.5 mm. At Bosque del Apache, a wintering area for sandhills which are predominantly greater, 142 measurements ranged from 100 mm. to 123 mm. and averaged HI mm. These data suggested that footprint measure- ments could be used to grossly separate the greater sandhill crane from the lesser race. But the Canadian race confounds the issue. Footprint measurements known to be from this race are not available. Consequently, the possibility exists that this subspecies is in- cluded with either the greater or the lesser race or both when they are separated on the basis of footprint measurements alone. RESULTS OF STUDY Fall migration Fall-migrating sandhill cranes were ob- served at congregation areas (sometimes called way stations or stopover areas) in south- ern Canada and in the northern States of the flyway between late July and early October (fig. 1). Migration data indicated that first migrants are erratic and sometimes over-fly congregation sites in Saskatchewan en route to sites in McLean, Kidder, and Stutsman Counties, North Dakota. From there the mi- gration proceeds in a more orderly fashion to the wintering grounds in New Mexico and Texas. First arrivals reached congregation sites in Alberta, Saskatchewan, and Manitoba be- tween early August and mid-September, Ear- liest observations of migrants reaching the Grassy Island-Gooseberry-Sound Lake region near Consort, Alberta, and the Kindersley District, Saskatchewan, occurred from late August to mid-September. They were preceded by migrants reaching the Last Mountain-Quill Lakes region of south-central Saskatchewan and the Big Grass Marsh area of Manitoba in the forepart of August. Fall migrants reached Montana and southeastern Wyoming 1 or 2 months later. Migrating sandhills arrived in Kidder and Stutsman Counties and the Turtle Lake region of McLean County, North Dakota, between mid- July and mid-September. That segment of the population which used the Missouri River between Montana and the Nisson Bottoms east of Williston arrived the latter part of Septem- ber. Sandhill cranes arrived in the Pollock- Mobridge area of South Dakota about Septem- ber 10 each year. The DeGrey area was used as a way station until it was inundated in 1964 by Big Bend Reservoir. Fall- migrating sand- hills rarely stopped over in Nebraska. First arrivals reached Prewitt Reservoir (Washington County), Bonny Reservoir (Yuma County), and the Arkansas Valley, Colorado, between mid-September and mid-October. Ar- rivals at Kirwin and Quivira National Wildlife Refuges, Kansas, and Salt Plains and Washita National Wildlife Refuges, Oklahoma, occurred between early October and late November. In most instances the fall migration proceeds at a leisurely pace, and the numbers found at congregation sites build up over a period of several weeks. Sandhills depart Canadian way stations in mid-October. Departures from con- gregation sites within the States occurs throughout November and the forepart of De- cember. The fall migration is sometimes hastened by late fall and early winter storms. V-/ Congregation area or way station Figure 1. — Sandhill crane arrival dates at congregation sites, 1962-65. 4 Peak populations at congregation sites Peak populations of sandhill cranes at fall congregation sites were recorded 3 to 8 weeks after the arrival of the first migrants (table 1). Peak numbers differed between years as did the period of use and length of stopover. In 1962, an estimated 100,000 sandhills were recorded at the Saskatchewan congregation sites the last week of September. Peak num- bers using the Last Mountain- Quill Lakes complex fluctuated between 7,000 in 1963 and 35,400 in 1965. Cranes using the Big Grass Marsh area of Manitoba ranged from 3,200 to 5,000 birds. The greatest number of cranes stopping over in Kidder and Stutsman Counties, North Dakota, ranged between 8,000 and 16,000 birds. Sandhills using the McLean County way station peaked at 7,000 in 1964. Migrating sandhills stopping off at way sta- tions in Montana peaked at 5,000 to 17,500 birds. Departures in 1962 and 1963 ranged from early November to early December. Similarly, Wyoming did not host large num- bers of fall-migrating sandhills. Reservoirs in Albany, Platte, and Goshen Counties served as way stations for 1,600 to 6,000 birds. Table 1. — Peak populations at fall congregation areas Location 1962 Date Number 1963 Date Number 1964 1965 Date Number Date Number Alberta: Grassy Island Saskatchewan: Kindersley District Last Mtn. -Quill Lakes So. Saskatchewan R Manitoba: Big Grass Marsh Montana: Bowdoin NWR Medicine Lake NWR G. M. Russell NTO North Dakota: Kidder & Stutsman Cos McLean County South Dakota: Mobridge-Pollock Nebraska: Western portion Wyoming: Southeastern portion Colorado : Prewitt Reservoir , San Liois Valley , Arkansas Valley , Kansas: Kirwln NWR , Quivira NWR , Oklahoma: Washita NWR , Salt Plains NWR , Red River (Jackson Co.)...< Cimarron River (Major Co.), 9/23-29 9/23-29 9/23-29 11/9 10/12-18 10/20 10/28 50,000 25,000 25,000 3,200 4,500 2,000 5,000 11,000 10/18 20,300 10/9 9/25-10/2 10/11 9/5 10/20-26 10/23 10/12-22 9/26 10/30 10/30 10/21 11/1 10/20 11/7 11/6 12/6-U 11/6 3,000 13,000 7,000 4,000 5,000 1,000 12-15,000 4,800 12-18,000 3,000 1,600 20,000 2,000 250 810 7,000 2,000 9/3 10/8 10/15 10/11 10/5 11/2 10/17 10/10 10/9 10/4 10/12 10/6 11/25 10/20 11/1-15 11/1-15 5,000 3,000 10,000 4,500 16,000 7,000 9,500 1,200 5-6,000 3,000 500 1,850 15,000 7,900 7,500 2,500 9/6 9/28 10/11 9/25 10/20 9/8 10/15 10/9 9/15 10/17 10/16 10/9 10/20 35,415 4,420 5,000 250 14,000 2,000 3,500 2,750 5,000 3,000 1,000 3,000 2,600 600 Fall migrants using the Mobridge- Pollock way station in South Dakota peaked at about 18,000 in 1963. In 1965, 3,500 birds was the greatest number recorded in that area. Western Nebraska is not an important way station for fall- migrating sandhills. The peak number of birds stopping off ranged from 1,200 to 3,000, and then only for a few days. Sandhills using Prewitt Reservoir, Colorado, peaked at about 20,000 birds in 1962 and 1963. In 1962, these birds stopped off for about 1 week, whereas the 1963 migration used this way station for about 4 weeks. The 1964 and 1965 fall migrations practically bypassed Prewitt Reservoir, with but 5,000 birds stop- ping overnight in 1965. Bonny Reservoir and the Arkansas Valley serve as way stations for smaller numbers (500 to 2,000) of mi- grating sandhills. Kansas way stations also host small numbers of cranes. Congregation sites in Oklahoma were used both as way stations and wintering areas by various segments of the migrating population. In 1963 and 1965, the sites were used pri- marily as way stations, and the population peaked at 2,000 to 7,000 birds. Aerial surveys conducted between October 1964 and January 1965 indicated that the population peaked at about 30,000 in early November (Gilliam, 1966). During the last 2 weeks of December 1964, 14,000 cranes were counted in western Oklahoma. Of these birds, 4,000 wintered on Washita National Wildlife Refuge. Population surveys which were conducted 1 to 2 days before the season in those portions of New Mexico and Texas open to the hunting of lesser sandhill cranes indicated a popula- tion ranging from 185,000 to 214,000 birds in late October, 1962 through 1965. Racial composition of migrating sandhill cranes A total of 3,981 sandhill crane footprints (midtoe) were measured as an aid to deter- mining the racial composition. These were obtained on refuges, lakes, reservoirs, sloughs, sandbars, mud flats, and grainfields within the areas of greatest use (table 2). These measurements indicate that the cranes^ using the principal way stations in the Central Fly- way have the following composition: Bowdoin National Wildlife Refuge and vicin- ity, Montana (294 measurements): 73% lesser j 27% greater. Kidder and Stutsman Counties, North Dakota (960 measurements): 86%lesser; 14%greater. McLean County, North Dakota (279 measure- ments): 92% lesser; 8% greater. Campbell and Walworth Counties, South Dakota (726 measurements): 97% lesser; 3% greater. Goshen County, Wyoming (157 measure- ments): 59% lesser; 41% greater. Prewitt Reservoir, Colorado (550 measure- ments): 100% lesser. Arkansas Valley, Colorado (147 measure- ments): 92% lesser; 8% greater. Kirwin and Quivira Refuges, Kansas (347 measurements): 50% lesser; 50% greater. Washita Refuge, Oklahoma (200 measure- ments): 68% lesser; 32% greater. Salt Plains Refuge, Oklahoma (137 measure- ments): 50% lesser; 50% greater. Red River bottoms, Oklahoma (142 measure- ments): 77% lesser; 23% greater. Measurements obtained during August, Sep- tember, and October in Kidder and Stutsman Counties, North Dakota, were analyzed to determine whether the races of sandhill cranes show different migration patterns. Of 277 measurements obtained in August and September, 18% fell within the range of the greater race; of 683 obtained in October, 13% fell within the range of this race. This in- dicates that the sandhill crane population that occurs in Kidder and Stutsman Counties during October may contain fewer greaters than the August and September population. ^ The number of Canadian sandhills that may be in- cluded in these measurements is unknown. Table 2. — Sandhill crane footprint measurements at fall congregation areas Location Montana : Bowdoin NIIVR 10 mi. S. Bowdoin NTO.. North Dakota: Kidder & Stutsman Cos. Do Do Do Do Do McLean County. Do Do South Dakota: Can^Jbell & Walworth Cos Do Do Do Do , Wyoming: Goshen Coimty Do Colorado: San Luis Valley Prewitt Reservoir Do Arkansas Valley Prewitt Reservoir Do Kansas: Phillips County Stafford Coimty Oklahoma: Custer County Do Jackson County Alfalfa County Jackson County Date Oct. 1963 Oct. 1965 Oct. Sept, Oct. Aug. Sept, Oct. Sept, Oct. Fall 1962 1963 1963 1964 196