Dve paradigmi resheniia indoariiskoi problemi

BJIACTb M HAPOfl

B yCflOBHflX BOMH

M COIIMAJIbHblX KOH4H1KKTOB

MaTepiiajibi leiBepTOK pern oHajibHOM
HayiiHOHieoHipepeHmiN

r. BopomiK, 2 frmmm 2010 r.

rocyflapcraeHHoe oGpaaoBaxejiBHoe ynpeaweHHe
Bbicmero npo(j)eccHonajibHoro o6DaioRan HO

^OPOHE^CKHHrOCyMPC^I^&^EPCMTET,

HCTOPHHECKHK OAKYJlbTE

ET

BJIACTB H HAPOfl

B yCJIOBBWX BOHH

H COIJHAJIBHBIX KOH^JIHKTOB

MaxepHanbi HerBeprofi perHonajibHoM
HayqHofi KOHcpepeHijHH

r. BopoHOK, 2 (peBpajia 2010 r.

W-{ BOPOHE>K
«~J HGTOKH

2010

VRK 930.1
GEK 63.3
T 55

PeflaKUHOHHan Kojuieraa:

B.H. Dia3bee (otb. peAaierop),

AT. FjiedoGjJ.B. Akumob (otb. ceKperapb), r.ft MuCpoea

20 i 0. - 470 c. r Jla 3beBa. - Bo P oh« K : H 3fl aTej,bCTBo «Hctokh»,

ISBN 978-5-88242-784-8

— i".=;:-i==: - — — •■»■ —

y^K 93o.i

GBK 63.3

ISBN 978-5-88242-784-8

© Kojijickthb aBiropoB, 2010
© H^flaTejibCTBo «Hctokh», 2010

,0. Wiue, M H^^OoSoS/B^OoSoaiSiUi^ "

11. Kazanas in a n ( http 7/ www .OmilosiDektQn£L/Bd£nepdr);

n d te»f"c'ft>»« M»r P a U »« » npo„c M >K«H« „ w po„*„x ».p M ».

CH6., 2007. C. 20-29.

14. Anro M. KjiaccHMecuaa Mhwhh. M.,2007. C. 39.

mphhuo Bcex Uep >kh3hk. Hacmwmee - Cxo/maa xpoHonorHa(2500 - 1600 it. flo
Ta 1500 1 106 r Ao h.3. *op M HpoBaHHe KBasnropoAOB b yoHO.H«x HenpepuBHUX
Sh ol» e .eflKH o6aicTBa - nneM», -, e^meceMefiHa., narp.apxa.b-

Sw-ulfS^r , cocywecTBC— c fl BopuoBb,MH OHH-h^ h hx 3a-
11 S Iy» An« npHcnocoSneHH. 3 aHMcrBO B aH„MX xpawn couua, -

xbo np a rnpHoGpexeHHe uapcKofi uu». U a P cTBO fl a P Hr eJ1 bH„ub 1 . Oftunu-
ScTh «— ropo.a-Kpenoc™. Cxo.cxbo ^-^^.
n „a l. TnflMHiiMOHHbix crpyicryp BJiacxH: uapb, re T anpbi, HapoflHoe cobpanue, leppn

h npaKTH^ >KepTBonpHHOU,eHHr, Cm,. A^hmcoh MX. MMfenonn. C. 195.

ABE nAPAAHFMbl
PEUIEHMfl HHAOAPHMCKOH IIPOEJlEMbl

A.A. CeMeHeHKO

BopOHOKCKHH IOCyAapCTBCHHblH yHHBepCHTeT

napawnM - ™ « M0 ^ ejlb nocrraHOBKH npo&ieii h hx peujeHHfi» (1).

R 6 r y A >KOHC O&MIBHJl, MTO HHAOeBpOIieRCKHe H3b.KH npOHCXOJWT H3

o6uiero 6oi.ee ho cymecTBy.omero hctomhhkb (2), a c8HCK P kt npHHeceH b Mh^io
SeBaxenHMH hum (3). B 1792 r. V. A™ msvw npapo^HoM 3toh .bukokh.

ZZ"4« Aa THpoBa, Be fl b, BpeMeweM noce coctbbwhh,. H^khjukh;
mL ce, (5) Tax bcL.1 HHBasHOH*™ napa^a pe— «"

nmfijieMW B 1805 r T.r. KonGpyic enepeue on H eaji PHruefly (PB) (6). B 1808 ..

CBMblM ApeBHHM, H HCTOHHHKOM, H3 KOTOpOfO Bb.BOflSTCa W rHe» (7). «Bce 31 H

"eHHTue HauHH nponoujo. ot oahopo naeMeHH... hhahhckopo npo H cxo>KAe-

242

ct> M MroJinep noMemaJi npapoAHHy HHAoeB P onenueB

ApaHbHK h ynaH«iuw 800-600 <J° >^ OM Ml0JIJiep c . Iimui 3T y

(1000-800 rr. ao h.3.) h PB (1»'™ v'enwnaj! mto (nmraiaw CHJia Ha
xpoHO.orH.0 «cyry6o npw*^™^^^ coqHHe „ bl 3a 1000 huh

3eM,e HHKor A a He onpeflerorr, 6«m m. ^™™ 3HaBanH „ A pyrHe (14).

,500 hhh 2000 «.» 3000 »ex ao XpHcra (T ). 3xo ,, P h3H HC ^ M ,, TeJIbH0

d> M Miojuiep yicaajui, mto flsmipoBKa PB 11 twc. ao h.3. hbji

MHorne noABepn.*. Kp.rn.Ke xpoHono, h.o cPJvL ^ OJ, ^ a J, efa B

onacHOcn. npeepau^HH- phho^m - flojMS ; <^ ™™S 200-800 r, ao

. tom, -no xaKa* oueHKa... ^^^ e fZZo k X urn XI b. ao h.3. (19)
MaH , ApaHMK h VnaHMUiaA AO "ZZZlZl^ZToporK^ „ yw-M ne P H-
r. *ko6h enbi AByxcoxj.exHHe MHHHMyMb c— oM k p y hcao _

o fl Bpax M aHAO .000 ,ex (20). rftojep ^ ™^°™ a . 5 , reJlbli0 H (2,). Ho
nycxHMO KopoxKOH, HenorHHHoB h pa< ™ / ^^ ^

M. BHHxepHHxuy, nxw* "*™ *' w. -300 40 ^ ^_

c 800 r. Ao h.3. (aapowfleHHH wKawmuMa) (22). 1 10 »a~

jiacb ox 500 ao 1000 jieT (23). naTM noBKa PB <P.M. Miowiepa «6e3 Ka-

Ka.< mean M. BuHrepHuru b 1909 r., AWE™ At >* h

khx -,h6o ho-ux apryMenxoB «a. «^J™*'SS^VEu«l Ao6asL:
T ex „ xapaKxep HayMHo AOKasaHHoro *aKra» (2^Hep« £* y ^ 6ojib _

<< „eKoxopb 1 e ,oah -^^'S^^^cSl: «2000 r. Ao h„. ocxa-
uiyro apeBHOCTb BeAb.» (25). Tow a > 1 „ MaH ,. pbl

g4 Hacx OJ1 bKO >Ke B 03MO>KHb,M, Ka.< h 1200 uao h.3. W H 1 HaMHoro pal ,ee

P„rBeAbi» (26). Oxhoch rb HaMajio coswrow PB k 2000 r. ao
ero npeA— MEonje hh^oph (27). noTpe6H ocxb oncptm..

B 3TOH CBH3H X A ~ OA « P y ^ Hom , TaKHe flaH .

Hbie c oHCBHAHocrbK, ^^: p :z:^:sz 2L*.

^TsTnOO rr L h 3 ao™ "o^oHeHHe Hhapc Bapyne, Mnxpe, Ha-
MuxaHHH 1500-1300 rr. ao h.3. AOKa MHT aHHHHneB hsjiJuic wnuuieK-

caxb^M h PHxe-Apxe ao XIV b. ao h.3. (29) M3 ( ^ /?>> (3())

T0M , xecHO gbmbhum c H P aH«H« ho ^°»1 e ^ ceBep0 - 3 a n aA» (3D.J10-
A .X. MoynroH ronopHx o6 <« Hh«j h . .«« aA h T _ ^^ fc qkojio

rHKa aeroxTOHHCXOB xa.coBa: ao XV b. ao h.3. ap y

243

fleH o ot 3ana fl „o-a3Ha T cKoro ^-^™^ n ^ n , 10 MO)KHO HH xepnpexH P o B ax b
eciiH 6« npoH3B0WU.ocb ox Satta) i »° *™ a * accHMHiWiUHH V CMewnbiM

„ T XapanncKo. „» H„„«_«o», a ™^J%^££ZLJ:~J»
uiiiiui oraepr „oxapanncK»H xapaKiep Bw. ™« »« "" xaaKomrre, Be

„»■ 6po„» » *>ww. » o„o*ecT,™» 6«K» (34> Horn. W I ^

,„ spy™ „».a,„o„„CTU » e„OBa caMOro ft J**""™" ^ J? „„««,
apnea paapyrcimM.." Moxe«o-»apo me <ta » « ^

„ r „.o„™ o Taao» « >».ac™ Xapanna, (36 ). Ho „oaUH »» MoraTO „.

re.-.' sss - *- — »« c=*-. 3 rx=

BpeMeHH eg Bb.CblXaHHH AM AaTH P OBKH PB (40). HeKO v KMUHM

pS T0 HC3Ha„ HM .HMoapHHMH mo P » '^^Z^T^mZ^ b A*raHH-
B0A [ P eK]» h ownuor. -m. C ^™J!o« S Ao™«a jkkh 6bi.a uenxpoM

apeana HHfloapweB PB (43). U uipacBdii J> 3 corJiacyeT c5i

C HCTe M a»; « noceJieHHH 1900-1700 rr. flo ^ P MoJ1HCTa „a

MTO TOBOpUT O P e3KOM CHH^CHHH ypOBHH BOflbl B peKe (4/^

„ ceBepHoro Parana yl u J!H ™ "^^^^^^2 Cap'acBaxH

co.nw.HH. hx p«M H. K« npHH J^ ^.^

i^.^-^S^- » ~ (5 ' } n <™ aPH6B B HH " ,K> B ° Tb ' C '

244

2001

1824.

1824.

/to h.3. onpoBepraeTCSi orcyrcTBHeM hx apxeojioninecKHx oiieAOB (52) h MOJiManueM

flpeBIieHHAMHCKKX TCKCTOB 06 3T0M (53). I lenpepblBHblH PUR OflHOTIlllHblX KOCTHblX

ocraHKOB >iejiOBeica b 4500-800 rr. ao n.3. roBopirr o CTa6iuibiioM o6nTannn 'iejio-
BeMecKofi nonyjiHUHH b penione 6e3 omyiHMbix BJiiiBaHHfi n3Bne (54).

MtifloapHH ne Momi-i iipnfirn b Hhahio nowie 4500 r. ao h.3. PB Moraa 6biTb
cocTaB/iena okojio 3 100 r. ao h.3. b Aoxapaniici<yio snoxy (55). 3th BbiBOflw Tpe6y-
K)T nepecMorpa HHAOJiorHH, npanncTHicn, HHfloeBponencTHKH h ncropnn flpeBiiero
BocTOKa b ue^oM.

nPHMEMAHMil:

1. KyH T. Crpyiaypa HayiHbix peBOJiiouHH / Hep. c aHrji. H.3. HaJieroBa. M.
C. 17.

2. Jones W. Discourses delivered before the Asiatic Society. Vol. 1. 2nd ed. L.
P. 28-29.

3. Ibid. P. 28.

4. Jones W. Discourses delivered before the Asiatic Society. Vol. 11. 2nd ed. L.
P. Sand 10.

5. Ibid. P. 7.

6. Colebrooke H.T. On the Vedas // Asiatic researches. Vol. VIII. L., 1808. P. 388-

407.

7. Schlegel F. The Aesthetic and miscellaneous works. L., 1849. P. 428-429; cm.
TafOKe: P. 456.

8. Ibid. P. 505; cm. raioKe: P. 500.

9. Curzon A. On the original extension of the Sanskrit language // JRAS. V. XVI.
1856. P. 172-200.

10. Latham R.G. The Germania of Tacitus. L., 1851. P. CXXXIX-CXLIV; Idem.
The ethnology of Europe. U 1852. P. 154-155 and 160-163; Idem. Ethnology of
India. L., 1859. P. 374-375; Idem. Opuscula. L., Edinburgh, 1860. P. 126-127.

11. Mueller M. Lectures on the science of language, delivered 1861. NY, 1869. P.
212 and 239.

12. Mueller M.F. A history of ancient Sanskrit literature. L., 1859. P. 70, 313, 435,
445, 497 and 572; Idem. On ancient Hindu astronomy and chronology. Oxford, 1862.
P. 1-3; Idem. Chips from a German workshop. V. I. NY, 1876. P. 12- 15; Idem.
Physical religion. L. and NY, 1891. P. 91-97.

13. Ibid. P. 91; cm. raioKe: Idem. On ancient Hindu. P. 3, 4 and 9; Idem. Physical
religion. P. 96.

14. Oldenberg H. The study of Sanskrit // Epitoms of three sciences. Chicago,
P. 3 1 and 52; Macdonell A. A. A history of Sanskrit literature. NY, 1900. P. 1 1 .

15. Mtojuiep M.cl>. UlecTb ciicxeM hhahhckoh (1)hjioco(|>hh / Hep. c aunt. M.,
C. 47.

16. Whitney W.D. Oriental and linguistic studies. 1st Series. NY, 1873. P. 73-79;
Goldstuecker T. Literary remains. V. 1. L, 1879. P. 282-283; Ghaate V.S. Lectures
on Rigveda. Poona, 1915. P. 222-223.

17. Wilson H.H. A History of Ancient Sanskrit Literature. By M. Mueller // The
Edinburgh Review. October, I860. JVe 228. P. 379; The Ailareya Brahmana of the

245

1890.

1995.

Rigveda. Ed., tr. and expl. by M. Haug. V. I. P. 1 M2; Vidyarthi G. Om. Wisdom of

(he Royal Society of Edinburgh. V. XXill. P. II. For the sess.on 1862-63. 1 . 264.

19. Wilson H.H. A History. P. 375-376.

20. Jacobi H. On the date of the Rig Veda // The Ind.an Antiquary. V. XXIII. June,

^Bu'ehle^G. Note on professor Jacobi's Age of the Veda and on professor Tilak's
Orion // The Indian Antiquary. V. XXIII. September, 894. 1 246.

22. Wintemitz M. Geschichte der Indischen Litteratur. 1 B^2. Ausgabu Le.pz.g,
1909. S. 258; Idem. Some problems of Indian literature. Calcutta, 1925. r\ 5.

23. GhaateV.S. Lectures on Rigveda. P. 222-223.

24 Wintemitz M. Geschichte der Indischen Litteratur. S. 149-150.

£ rhS 1 Ar^hUotgica. argument for an upper limit to the A^fthe
Rigveda // Proceedings & transactions of the First Oriental Conference, Poona. V. 1.
Poona, 1920. P. XIX; Ibid. V. 11. Poona, 1922. P 33^ f p 1 1 22

27. Whitney W.D. Oriental. P. 21; Kaegi A. The R.gveda. Boston, 1886 I 1 1 22
and 110- Schroeder L. Indiens Literatur und Cultur. Leipzig 188, S. 29
Bold M. The religion of the Veda. NY and L, 1908. P 20; Edgerton , F Fhe
rehgion of the Veda // Religions of past and present. Philadelphia and L., 1918. P.

i^Sstold^Tl^dVaruna in the Rig-Veda „ B uUetin of the Society of

Comoarative Theology and Philosophy. No 1 . NY, 19 10. P. I -A

29. Sab. The Sigion and philosophy of the Veda and Upan.shads Harvard

Oriental Series ed. by C.R.Lanman. V. XXXI. Cambridge, L., 1925. P. 5 and 35

30 Btoomfield M. On some alleged Indo-European languages » cuneiform character

// American Journal of Phililogy. 1904. V. XXV. P. 11.

31. Moulton J.H. Early Zoroastrianism. L., 1926. P. 7 'and 26

■W 1 achhmi D K The Home of the Aryas. Delhi, 1930. P. 84-8/.

33' NotaT^R Dialect variation in Old and Middle Indo-Aryan // The Indo-Aryaiis

of Anient South Asia: language, material culture and ethnicity (wnce 1AASA).

SSS* and the Indus civilization. V. I. New Delhi-Chennai,

35°ibi P d I P. 28 and Note 1; Wheeler M. The Indus civilization. Cambridge 198JJ.
60 and 69- EjmsapeHKOiia TJl. TpaMMarmca B eA«ttcKoro «bnca. M, 198.. C. 3; 4U
t 42 Idem «PHr Befla » - Be.H.coe HaHUio hhahhckoB ^reparypb. n Ky^xypy //
12£S£L f-IV. M, 1989. C. 450; E.HsapeHKoaa m. Tonopoe ^ Mnp
Beuieii no flauHbtM Phi-b^h // Purina. Maw«uibi V-VUI. M., 1999. C. 30/

C I Q

16 Wheeler M. The Indus civilization. P. 90-92.

37'. An encydopaedia of Indian archaeology ed. by A. Ghosh. V. I. Leiden, 1990. P.

89.

246

38. Possehl G.L. Indus civilization. Walnut Creek, 2002. P. 249; Witzel M. Rama's
realm // Archaeological fantasies. L., 2006. P. 214; Mcintosh J. The ancient Indus
valley. Santa Barbara, 2008. P. 40.

39. Kenoyer J.M. Culture change during the Late Harappan period at Harappa // The
Indo-Aryan controversy. L., 2005 Cuanee IAC). P. 23, 30, 36 and 43.

40. Vedic hymns tr. by F.M. Mueller. P. 1. Oxford, 1891. P. 59-60; Mueller F.M.
India. What can it teach us? L„ 1883. P. 165.

41. Hillebrandt A. Vedische Mythologie. 1. B. Breslau, 1891. S. 100-101, 106 und
1 15-1 16; Ibid. 3. B. Breslau, 1902. S. 372 -378; Hock H.H. Whose past is it? //
Studies in the Linguistic Sciences. V. 30, No. 2. Fall 2000. P. 58-59; Witzel M.
Indocentrism: autochthonous visions of ancient India // IAC. P. 376-377; Idem.
Rama's realm. P. 222.

42. Wilson H.H. Preface // The VishNu PurANa. V. I. L., 1864. P. CIV-CV; Oldham
C.F. The Saraswatl and the lost river of the Indian Desert // JRAS. 1893. P. 49-54;
Stein A.M. On some river-names in the Rigveda // Commemorative essays presented
to R.G. Bhandarkar. Poona, 1917. P. 21; Keith A.B. The religion. P. 3; EjiH3apenKOBa
T.J1. «Pnri3e/ia». C. 442; Kenoyer J.M. Interaction systems, specialised crafts and
culture change // IAASA. P. 231; Allchin F.R. The end of Harappan urbanism and its
legacy // Allchin F.R., Erdosy G. et al. The archaeology of early historic South Asia.
Cambridge, 1995. P. 28-29; Erdosy G. The prelude to urbanization // The
archaeology. P. 78-79; EjnwapenKOBa T.il. npuMenaHHa // Puree^a. Marwajibi IX-
X. M., 1999. C. 476; Possehl G.L. Indus civilization. P. 8-9.

43. Wilson H.H. Preface. P. CIV-CV; Lassen Ch. Indische Alterthumskunde. 1. B. 2.
Auflage. Leipzig, L., 1 867. S. 6 16; Thomas E. The rivers of the Vedas // JRAS. New
Series. V. XV. 1882. P. 378; Hopkins E.W. The Punjab and the Rig-Veda// Journal
of the American Oriental Society. 1898. V. XIX. 2nd half. P. 19-28; Hopkins E.W.
India old and new. NY, L., 1901. P. 30-31; Keith A.B. The religion. P. 3; Gonda J.
The India hymns of the Rigveda. Leiden, 1989. P. 1; Bryant E.F. The quest for the
origins of Vedic culture. NY, 2004. P. 168.

44. Mueller M. Lectures. P. 239 and 248-249.

45. Bryant E.F. The quest. P. 133.

46. Wilson H.H. Introduction // Rig-Veda SanhitA. The first Ashtaka. 2nd ed. L.,
1866. P. XXXV and XLI; Das, Abinas Chandra. Rig- Vedic India. V. I. Calcutta,
1921. P. 32-36; Ibid. 2nd ed. Calcutta, 1927. P. 33-37 and 45-46.

47. Possehl G.L. Indus civilization. P. 2, 9, 63 and 239.

48. Erdosy G. The prelude. P. 78-79; Allchin F.R. The end. P. 28-29; Shaffer J.G.
and Lichtenstein D.A. South Asian archaeology and the myth of Indo-Aryan
invasions // IAC. P. 84-85, 89, 92 and 97, Note 8; Heitzman J. City in South Asia. L.,
2008. P. 3 and 7.

49. Lai B.B. Aryan invasion of India: perpetuation of a myth // IAC. P. 65.

50. Cm. era crarbH ria cafire http: // www.omilosmeleton.gr.

51. Lai B.B. Aryan invasion. P. 57-58; Shaffer J.G. and Lichtenstein D.A. The
concept of "cultural tradition" and "palaeoethnicity" in South Asian archaeology //
IAASA. P. 126; Shaffer J.G. and Lichtenstein D.A. South Asian archaeology. P. 82-
83 and 92.

247

52 Shaffer J.G. and Lichtenslein DA. The concept P. 129; Erdosy G Language,

cany "»"" .. „ ,. -, t om i p <o- iHpni Rama s realm, P. 213, mem.
Journal of Ved.c Stud.es. 7-3. 2001. P. 58 Idem. Kama s

.j < • ,„ p V7<v Kennver J M Culture change. P. 22, List K.. Linguistic di>peci5
Indocentrism. P. 375, Kenoyei j.iv lu £ ordona G , ain D . The lndo-Aryan

of the Aryan non-invasion theory // 1 AC. P. 236, ""ctona u., jdi
i =o i ?nn7 P 38- Mcintosh J. The ancient. 1 J . 40.

TSn^ 1 cLhe Alt^humskunde. LB. Bonn, ,847 S 51 1; ^ Auflage.
S 6 2 Saraswati S.D. Satyarth Prakash t, by D, Prasad. ^nJTJu^H

SnfteSnS / P IS of the 10th Annual UCLA Indo-European
Sr nee. Los Angeles, May 2.-23, .998 // Journal of Indo-European Stod.es
Monograph Series. No. 32. 1999. P. 208; Erdosy G. Language. P. 15, Possehl G.L.
Indus. P. 249 Bryant E.F Thequest. P 197. ^ ^^

SblT^St^^^'^- been identified in the prehistoric
1991. i.-i« r/*, rvc ■> i a asa P 49 and 54; Idem. God-Apes and

pS^.^i^^t^h!^^; S00. P. 304; Wit Z e, M. Rama's

S'dI Acltedic India. V. .. 2nd ed. P. XVil; Pusa.karA^D. Authors o f the
^Culture // ABOR1. V. XVIU. P. .V. July 1937. P. 39.-394; Bryant E.F. The
quest. P. 193; Elst K.. Linguistic aspects. P. 253.

HBEPHfl M rPEKO-KATOATEHCKOE nPOTMBOCTOJIHHE
B 3AnAAHOM CPEAH3EMHOMOPbE B VII - VI BB. ^O H. 3.

O.O. LUajiaeB
BopoHeKCKHH rocyflapcTBennbiH yHHBepcurer

TenpuTopHH M6e P Hn mbho np«BJieKana BHHMauHe flpeBHHX kojtohhctob -
AhhukITh h rp'eKOB. llpe^e ecero, hx uHxepecoBSUiH 6ora™e »«h no™
"elx 'no nau.,0 orpine . amnmioH xpaflHU.HH. A«W>P Cuhj.mhc.chh
( "nnmev o ««aw Jo- b HfepHH "cepeSpHHUX npHHcax, nocKO^Kv 3 ra
Jrouia DiioncHianier aa^aMH cepeGpa cbmumh KpynwuMH, Koropue npHHoarr fl o-
Sr» M i tl e «.". O SoraxcTaax H6ep«H roBopux h IOcthh
(X IV I 5-6)' "B HcnaHHH ..Meexc* orpoM„oe KO^necrBO ne xonwco 3e P Ha, no
« ' a6yL Shctphx Kouen. C W x B03flaxB nox B a.ny 6oraxeH.UHM sa—

Me ~Ha K o npuxoflnxca KOHcrarHpoBar., mto, uecMoxp* ,.a npnpoflHue Goraxcx-
B a h£?Z, neple oxKp.xH* rpeKOB r, ,„« 3an W 6«jj ^"JJJ^
uhBho Okojio 638 rofla fl o H.3., no cBHflexej.bcxBy TepoAoxa (IV, 152), Kojien H3
CaTca « I oxK,l,oe «ope h HanpaBH^ a Ernnex. OflHaKO bocxomiu.m bcx-
poM ero emieeno uasa;., h t.k. 6ypa ne cxuxajia, to, MHHOBaa Pepai^oBB, Ckuuim,

248

3ojwmyxmi A.IO., Mamicocoe A.M. fl,efl-rejifaHOCTb opraHOB BJiacTw KypcKofi 06-
jiacTH no yBei<0Be'iennio naMHTH norn6iunx bohhob Kpacnofi Apmhh b 1943-

1944 rr ■ ...200

PA3/IEJ1 V. I ocyflapcrBO h oGiuec tbo b Houeuiiieii OTeMecTBennoii nciopnn
PcBUHbKoe M.E. ]"lpnpo/ia h soiiHa: ncc;ie,aoBanne no MarepnajiaM BocnoMHHa-

HI1H yiaCTMMKOB rpa>KAaHCKOH BOHHbl 205

BaximiH B.B. MeuiomiHMecTBO - cnoco6 caMOBbi>KHBaHHa HacejieHna b roflbi

rpa>iyianci;oH bohhw 209

TuMouie'iKiiHa E.M. HenoBHHOBenne BjiacTH KpecibflH cejia TpoiiHH b AeBpajie

•930 r V _ 213

JlaemtHCKiiii C.A. ripo6jieMbi cobctckoh BHeumeH hojihthkm b 70-e roflw

XX Bei<a 217

MenbiiiUKoaa T.B. 3amnTa MarepMHCTBa h aeTCTBa b ycjiOBHJix couHajibHbix

Tpanc<])opiviauHH (Ha MaTepnanax Kypcicofi o6jiacTn) 223

flpyzoeciccBi A.IO., &pojioea E.B. Kypci<aa npaBocjiaBHaa riiMHa3Hfl Kaic ueHTp
o6pa30BanH» h flyxoBHO-iipaBCTBennoro BocriHTaHHH mojioaokh b coBpeMeHHbix
ycjioBHJix 228

PA34.EJ1 VI. BceoGmasi nc ropim. 3noxa apeBHocTti

K03.1106CK01 B.I-I. 3B6eFmbi XajiKHAbi h hx npeABOAirrejib Oyicn: npooneMa

B3anMo^eiicTBna b opranH3annn nojinca b chuhjiuhckom HaKcoce 232

IJucapeeCKiiii H.fl. ^peBHeHH/MHCKHH ropo/i 11 aHTHMHwii nojinc: CTpyKTypa th-

iiojiormi h THnojiorna BjiacTH 237

CeMeneuKO A.A. JX&e napaflHi'Mbi peiueHHfl HH/ioapHHCKoft npo6;ieMbi 242

LHajtaee O.O. H6epnH h rpeKo-i<ap(])aiKHCKoe npoTHBOCTosHHe b 3ana.0H0M

CpeaHieMHOMopbe b VII - VI bb. j\o h.3 248

Medeedee A.fl. BoccTanne jiHMnrairroB b KOHTeKCxe cou,najibHofi HCxopnH cap-

MaroB 253

Bemycoe B.B. Bofina b >kh3hh capiuaTOB (no .aaHHbiiw aura'iHOH Tpa,nnu,nH) 258

Ulemjoe ME. K Bonpocy 06 ochobhoh npmiHHe nopawenHsi jnbmec-raa b nepn-

o/i i<pn3iica Phmckoh MMnepHM 261

Kopoiwaix JIM. ricupo Boiu-rHMnepa: cy^bGa ryMannTapns-aHTHKOBe,aa b koh-

reKcie commjibno-nojiHTH'iecKofi HCTopnn XX Bexa 265

PA3J.EJI VII. Bccooiuan Hciopun. 3noxa CpeAiieBeicoBbH
Cycmiia il.Jl UpoGjieMa xapaicrepa KpecTMiHCKHx bohh b KwTae b coBpeMemiofi

oieHecTBeHHOH MCTopiiorpacJHiH ;...; 269

Medeedee A.B. EpHTann*i na py6e>i<e am-HMHoc™ a cpeflneBeKOBba: 3THonojin-

TH'iecKMii K0ii(|).niiicT 272

3tiHbi<oecK(ifi If. B. "CeBepiibie Hapcnu" Mopaana- npo6jieMa iweiiTH(|)HKau,nn ...277
3ojwmapea A.IO. CKaH^HHaBCKHe BTopweiina b Ahijihio b Komje X - Hanarie XI

bb. h iia'iano nopivraTHBHO-npaBOBoro orpami'iemia Kopo.neBCKoH Bjiacra 281

Cojiodomtmoea O.C. B3aHMooTHOUjenna rocnoacTByiomero KJiacca 11 rocy^ap-

CTBenHOH B/iacTH b Eochhh b nepnoji ())eo^ajibHofi pa3flpo6jiennocrn 285

Kanudojio'jKon E.A. rpawaancicasi BOHHa b Ahhihh XV11 seKa w 3bojik>uhh 06-
pa3a Ajibcfipefla Bejini<oro b o6aiecTBemiOM co3HaHHn 289

467

Haymioe mdamie

BJlACTb H HAPOA

B yCJIOBHflX BOHH

H COLJMAJIbHblX KOHO>J1MKTOB

Marepnajibi HeTBep-roM perHonajibiioM
nayMHoii KowpepeHUHH

r. Bopoiioic, 2 cpeBpajia 2010 r.

HiflaTe^bCTBo «MCTOKM»

JlHueH3n» Cepn;i J\P N« 040229 ot 21 oK-raSpji 1997 r.

394087, r, BopoHeac, yji. MimypnHa,l

Tejiet])on/(])aKc (4732) '53-57-97

E-mail: istoki-vrn@mail.ru

llofliiHcano b ne'iarb 29. 06. 2010 r. Oopiuar 60x84 1/16.

rapinnypa «Times New Roman». rienarb ocpceTHaa.

Byiwara ra3eTHaa. O&beM 29,375 n. n. THpaw 150 3K3.

3aica3 No 788.

OtneilataHo b ROjihom cootbctctbhh c Ka'iecrBOM
npeflocraSjtenHoro opurHHan-MaiceTa.

Tnnorpa(])iin "HCTOKM"

394087, r. Boponoic, yji. MunypnHa, 1

TanecpoH (4732) 53-77-28