Skip to main content

Full text of "Behind The Type: The Life Story of Frederic W. Goudy"

See other formats


■"% 



BEHIND THE TYPE 



smt 




Life size portrait-bust in bronze, by Jo Davidsoi 
Photo par Kollar,! 



behind The Tape 



THE LIFE STORY OF FREDERIC W. GOUDY 

BY BERNARD LEWIS 

ISSUED BY THE DEPARTMENT OF 

PRINTING ■ CARNEGIE INSTITUTE 

OF TECHNOLOGY ■ PITTSBURGH 

NINETEEN FORTY-ONE 



G>>(0 



250 
A2. 
L4?> 



Copyright 1941 

Carnegie Institute of Technology 

Department of Printing 

d 

Printed in the United States of Ameri 






250 
LA'S 



960047 



CONTENTS 
&<® 

Behind The Type: 

The Life Story of Frederic W. Goudy 

by 

Bernard Lewis 



The Ethics and Aesthetics of 
Type and Typography 



Frederic W. Goudy 





Portrait 
Preh 




Goudy 
Be 




Studei 

1 

In the 


1 





LIST OF ILLUSTRATIONS 

Portrait-bust in bronze by Jo Davidson, Frontispiece 

J0hnF.G0udy.1883, 3 

Amanda Goudy, about 1878, 4 

Goudy at age eight, 7 

Goudy at age twentyseven, 8 

Freliminary sketches of a Goudy typeface, 25 

At work in the mill, 26 

The pantagraph, 43 

William Morris' Kelmscott press, 43 

Goudy as author, and part of his large library, 44 

Bertha and Fred on Sunday afternoon, 61 

A study in contentment, 62 

Student admirers: Carnegie, February ig38, yg 

Approaching a Goudy 'punch line,'yg 

In the Carnegie design studio, February 1338, 80 

The ruined mill, gy 

Goudy at Deepdene, g8 



PREFACE 

©>(0 

In February of 1938, the guest speaker at the celebration 
of the twenty-fifth anniversary of the founding of the 
Department of Printing at the Carnegie Institute of Tech- 
nology was Frederic W.Goudy Inspired by the life and 
work of Mr. Goudy Bernard Lebovit, a student in the de- 
partment, began preparation of the life story of America's 
foremost type designer.That story as presented here is a 
biographical narrative set forth in interesting style and 
replete with incidents and anecdotes hitherto untold. 

While the essay was being prepared, Mr. Goudy gave 
freely of time from a busy life.When it was finished and 
offered to Mr. Goudy for comment he stated with charac- 
teristic modesty and singular praise, "I think you have 
handled a very ordinary life with skill and have given 
it a quality not attained by other ambitious attempts' ' 

The task of putting the essay into book form was begun 
by Mr.Lebovit in the fall of 19 3 9. Printing the book was 
undertaken as a student project and its publication was 
planned for the spring of i94o.However, unforeseen dif- 
ficulties prevented publication as promised; Mr.Lebovit 
graduated, entered upon a career in the graphic arts, and 
became known professionally as Bernard Lewis. Publi- 
cation became the responsibility of the 1940-41 seniors. 

Delay in publication, which was disheartening at first, 



brought good fortune. Laurance B. Siegfried, at one time 
editor of the American Printer (now University Printer at 
Syracuse University) showed galley proofs to Melbert 
Carey, the President of the American Institute of Graphic 
Arts.Mr. Carey immediately suggested that the edition be 
increased to provide copies of the book for distribution 
as keepsakes for the A.I.GA.members.That suggestion, 
when mentioned to Walter H. Fredrick of the Fredrick 
Photogelatine Press, brought an offer to contribute pro- 
duction work on the illustrations. Wishing to encourage 
the undertaking, the Russell-Rutter Company offered to 
co-operate in the binding of the book. A member of that 
organisation, R.WBergmann, gave helpful advice while 
the book was being printed. Valuable technical assistance 
in the adjustment of our casting equipment was rendered 
by S. E. Haigh,Lanston Monotype Machine Company; 
A. D. Scott, Carnegie Institute Press; William F. Bremer, 
Pittsburgh Mono-Lino Company; and by Frank Bradlaw, 
Edwin H. Stuart, Inc.To all these men and to the organ- 
isations they represent, we extend our sincere gratitude. 
Many students of the Carnegie Department of Printing 
have -worked on the composition and presswork of the 
book. The services of these enthusiastic devotees of the 
graphic arts and the untiring efforts of the staff members 
who acled in an advisory capacity are acknowledged in 
the colophon. 

GlenU.Cleeton, 
Head, Department of Printing 



BEHIND THE TYPE 

C>>rO 



THE LIFE STORY OF FREDERIC W. GOUDY 



behind The Tape 



It was three a.m. in bloomington, and a mournful 
chorus of bells reminded the townsmen that the fu- 
neral train was approaching. Dancing yellow lights be- 
gan to appear in the windows, and shadows silently 
glided across the drawn shades. Soon the houses emp- 
tied, and their occupants walked toward the centrally 
located railroad station. The train was due to arrive in 
Bloomington at 4:43. Among the thousands that stood 
in the darkness on the edge of the tracks was Amanda 
Gowdy, a thin, well-knit woman, who held her infant 
son, Frederic, in her arms. 

There was hardly a person in Bloomington that had 
not played some part in Lincoln's life. Even children 
had become aroused when a guest at one of the town's 
hotels had remarked that the great man had deserved 
his death. A general demand for a lynching followed, 
and the loose-tongued man had to be smuggled out of 
town. To express their great sorrow on Lincoln's assas- 
sination, the townsmen had held an indignation meet- 
©>i<© 



ing in the Court House Square, and men who had been 
considered Abe's closest friends told of his associations 
with Bloomington. Lincoln had owned property there, 
had practiced law there, and it was there that the state 
meeting had been held during which his Bloomington 
friends had overcome his objections to being proposed 
for the presidential candidacy. Little wonder that thou- 
sands waited in the darkness, and that all schools and 
business houses were closed for the day 

It was after sunrise that Lincoln's body passed through 
the town.The throngs waited for a few minutes after the 
slowly moving coach had disappeared, and then started 
back to their homes. 

Amanda Gowdy left with the rest. She was the wife 
of the Bloomington superintendent of schools, John F. 
Gowdy, a bearded, clean-cut, intelligent-looking man; 
stern, silent, and dignified, like the modern conception 
of the typical pioneer. Amanda with her dark hair part- 
ed in the middle and combed straight back, with her 
strong eyes, and steady gaz,e, seemed like an idealization 
of the typical pioneer woman. Strangely enough, they 
were what they seemed to be. John had been born on a 
farm in Ohio, one of nine children. He was a good stu- 
dent and persisted as far as his junior year in Knox Col- 
lege, which he left when offered a teaching position. He 
moved from place to place to find better positions and in 
that way came to Bloomington as principal of the high 
school, later being made the superintendent of schools. 

®>2<® 



I 




John V. Gaudy, 1883 




mda Goudy, about 1878 



Amanda's story might have been similar to that of most 
girls of her day, had she ever thought of her life in terms 
of words. 

The Gowdys lived simply, for John's salary was nev- 
er more than they could easily spend. He had his school, 
his books; she had her home; and they both had friends, 
family, and church. There were very few opportunities 
for recreation— even for so precocious a town as Bloom- 
ington. Week-days meant work, Sunday meant church 
followed by a grand occasion— dinner— with perhaps 
Sister Belle and other guests attending. 

It was those times and this environment that saw the 
birth of Frederic William Gowdy on March 8, 1865. 
He was too young to know that he was being held in 
his mother's arms when Lincoln's remains were being 
transported to Springfield, but he heard many stories 
of the great man during his youth, and he later became 
acquainted -with Herndon, Lincoln's law partner. He 
often watched one of Lincoln's three closest friends, OP 
Jud Davis, who bounced down Bloomington's uneven 
streets in a buggy that sagged heavily on one side; and 
he knew the second of the three friends, Jesse Fell, the 
man who built and beautified Bloomington. He was lat- 
er a guest at the hotel in Shelbyville that Lincoln once 
visited, and he expressed the opinion that he pitied Lin- 
coln if the accommodations were as poor in his day 

Frederic was as unspectacular as his background, and 
demonstrated only the usual abilities and talents to be 



expedted in a child of his age. He did show a waddling 
interest in the doings of the neighborhood whenever he 
could escape for an exploring trip, and Amanda had to 
tie him to the door-knob to make sure that he would be 
there when she wanted him. When the knob stopped 
rattling it was a danger signal. Like all normal boys he 
played, grew, and went to school. When he was about 
seven years old his family moved to Tuscola, in Illinois, 
to Rushville, to Rock Island, and back to Bloomington. 

As he approached his ninth year, he began to evolve 
a personality of his own. It consisted of a love of play, 
an interest in reading, and a certain amount of forget- 
fulness.The family could never count on him to do any- 
thing that he promised, because he would always find 
something that would interest him more than the thing 
that he was asked to do. 

Going to the store was a duty that usually fell on his 
shoulders. His older brother worked and was a little 
too old for the indignity, and his sister, "Jo," was too 
small. One cold fall day when he was about ten years 
old, he was sent on a five block trip to the baker shop 
and returned with both arms wrapped around the five 
loaves of bread that he had purchased for a quarter. The 
bag was breaking, his arms were frozen, and tears were 
streaming down his face. He was not comforted by his 
mother, who stood on the porch laughing at him. Fred 
evened the score when he later chose to carry a water- 
melon home from the grocery shop, allowing a delivery 
Gy6fO 



boy to engineer the other food. There was little left of the 
melon when Fred reached home. It would be difficult to 
believe that his mother laughed on this occasion. 

Young Gowdy played baseball, skated a great deal, 
and enjoyed his daily morning and evening excursions 
to and from pasture with a neighbor's cow. When he 
was nine or ten, he could draw quite well, and enjoyed 
copying pictures from the illustrated magazines of the 
day He developed a photographic mind by looking at 
a picture and reproducing it from memory with con- 
siderable accuracy some time later. About this time his 
father went to Wichita, Kansas, to assume a position as 
superintendent of schools, leaving the family in Bloom- 
ington. He stayed a year or two, and when he returned 
he brought, as a gift for Fred, a bow and arrow set that 
had been used by an Arapaho Indian. 

Fred retained at least one tendency of his infancy— 
his wandering habits. One day he disappeared in the 
morning and his father spent hours combing the town 
for him. The prodigal son returned in the evening limp- 
ing, in agony because of a stone that had worked itself 
into a cut in his foot. But his suffering saved him from an 
ordeal in the woodshed. When the pain had subsided 
and the family had calmed, Fred's simple explanation 
was that he had found an Episcopalian picnic, and since 
the good churchmen did not know his affiliations, they 
fed him sandwiches, and as long as they fed him sand- 
wiches, he stayed. 



Mark Twain might easily have used young Fred as 
the hero of one of his stories, for when Fred was ten 
years old he duplicated Tom Sawyer's fence white- 
washing stunt with five cords of hickory wood. His 
father had bought the wood, had paid a man to cut it 
with a circular saw driven by a horse on a treadmill, 
and for a quarter Fred's mother hired him to pile it 
neatly in the woodshed. Fred was not as clever a busi- 
ness man as Tom Sawyer because he in turn hired five 
boys at five cents each and did more work than any of 
them, only to find, when the time for the distribution 
of wages came, that he had nothing left for himself. 

The spiels of the patent medicine sellers always ap- 
pealed to Fred's imagination. Tools and mechanical con- 
trivances of any kind also had a strange fascination for 
him. It was indeed a risk to send him on an errand when 
something was needed in a hurry. One day on his way 
to the grocery store he digressed in favor of a man who 
was demonstrating a pantagraph, an arm-like device for 
copying pictures and reproducing them in crayon or 
pencil, either enlarged or reduced. He persuaded his fa- 
ther to give him money to buy one, and later he made 
good use of the toy. 

His father often found opportunity to play croquet 
with him. Aside from contacts like this, Fred had no 
really intimate associations with his parents. Displays 
of affection were not part of the Gowdy make-up. But 
Fred felt the influence of his father's interest, for he 






made good use of his library. He never touched the 
dime novels that were so popular in his day, but read 
novels of romantic influence like Vathek, Undine, Gulli- 
vefs Travels, Picdola, and plunged randomly into books 
of historical interest. 

When Fred was thirteen the wandering Gowdys left 
Bloomington, moving to Macomb, Illinois, where they 
stayed for about a year. His experience here was merely 
an extension of his life in Bloomington. He occasionally 
strolled down to one of the numerous potteries to watch 
the workmen at their handwheels. He continued draw- 
ing, reading, and playing. Before he had time to become 
really settled, the Gowdy "whirlwind" moved to the 
town of Butler, Illinois. 

In Butler, John Gowdy became the town's first high 
school principal. It was an interesting little place con- 
sisting of about 900 inhabitants, thirteen saloons, two 
churches, a grain elevator, four general stores, a mill, a 
hotel, three creameries, a cheese factory and three base- 
ball teams. 

It was in Butler at the age of fifteen that Fred made a 
short but satisfactory contadt with politics. He saw an 
advertisement of a lathe with a scroll saw attachment 
in the Youth's Companion for only ten dollars. But ten 
dollars was exactly ten dollars more than he owned. He 
brought his problem to his father who told him that the 
grammar school needed a janitor. When John Gowdy, 
the much-esteemed high school principal, suggested to 



the Board of Education that his son be given the posi- 
tion of janitor, the worthy members grinned and con- 
sented. The job was a good one for a lazy boy like 
Fred. He came early in the morning to sweep out the 
few rooms, rang the opening bell, recess bell, and the 
closing bell. At the end of the month he pocketed ten 
dollars. He wasted no time in sending for the lathe. 
When it came and was set up, he immediately initi- 
ated it by making a set of croquet mallets, and some 
spools for an elecTro-magnet that he constructed. 

His lathe did not remain anchored very long, for in 
a year the family migrated to Shelbyville, a flat middle 
western town, -where John Gowdy took a position as 
superintendent of schools. 

It was not long before Fred made new friends in Shel- 
byville. They went skating, swimming, and played ball 
together. But the lure of social recreation did not detract 
from his strong interest in creative work, for when his 
lathe was set up, and his tools in order, he built a flat- 
bottom rowboat which he completed successfully and 
floated on a nearby river. 

He brought many of his carpentry problems to Frank 
Broyles, a newly made friend, who did all of the wood 
work for a plough factory in town. Broyles allowed 
Fred to use his lathe and showed him the use of other 
tools. Fred watched the craftsman for hours on end, 
took note of the deliberate exactness with which he 
executed each phase of his job. Broyles was unsullied 

0>12,0 






Broyles' influ 






by book learning and he analysed each problem of his 
work intuitively. He taught Fred that the good crafts- 
man followed a definite tradition in any piece of design 
or construction, and he showed him the subtle differ- 
ences between a good and a bad plough beam. Fred 
watched Broyles plan and build a very difficult stair 
rail, and he noticed that his first step in the process was 
to lay out the job carefully with pencil and paper. 

He soon found opportunity to apply the random train- 
ing that he received from the carpenter. He was quite 
friendly with Jennie Trower, the daughter of the editor 
and publisher of the local newspaper, and he was once 
at her home during a time that it was being redecorated. 
Asa Blankenship, the paperhanger, was having trouble 
trying to fit the ceiling border around a curved space at 
the head of the stairs, and had almost given up his futile 
attempts. Fred watched him closely and involuntarily 
began to plan the job the way Frank Broyles would have 
planned it. He saw that he could measure the space, lay 
it out on paper, and cut the wall paper to fit his pattern. 
It seemed simple enough so he told Asa that he thought 
he knew how it could be done, and the thwarted paper- 
hanger was not averse to letting him try. Fred took the 
measurements of the problem home, laid it out on brown 
paper, cut and pasted the wallpaper to this foundation, 
and gave it to Asa who had nothing more to do but use 
Fred's pattern to finish the job. 

Broyles' influence was evident in another triumph of 
Q> 13 <© 



building that the seventeen-year-old dabbler enjoyed. 
Fred had ambitiously started the construction of a steam 
engine but was unable to perform the intricate metal 
work involved in the piston and cylinder. His solution 
came when he thought of a substitute for the conven- 
tional metals, for Broyles employed Babbitt metal when 
he worked as a wheelwright. This metal had a low 
melting point and Fred could handle it by turning out 
molds with his lathe. He planned the job carefully and 
succeeded in constructing an efficient engine. 

His high school days in Shelbyville were quite pleas- 
ant although in his actual school work Fred could not 
have been accused of being an overly brilliant student. 
There were no extra-curricular activities such as inter- 
school sports, or clubs, and schools were generally con- 
sidered tedious affairs. He was interested in the library, 
an after-school activity that his father had helped inno- 
vate on a system in which the students' parents loaned 
books that were redistributed among other students. 

He was still interested in drawing, and became pro- 
ficient in copying, as well as portraiture. When he was 
eighteen he did a good original crayon rendering, and 
a life-si^e crayon portrait of one of Shelbyville's citi- 
zens which was exhibited by Mr. Launey, the town 
photographer. The year before he had exhibited a copy 
of a wood engraving from one of the current magazines 
in the Shelbyville County Fair and had won first pri^e, 
earning an award of three dollars and a blue ribbon. 



L 






To any who congratulated him he observed that there 
was little competition, but he admitted that he had a 
good eye and copied well. And to prove it he repeated 
another pri^e performance at the next annual fair. 

He later demonstrated his artistic ability in a manner 
that brought him praise from many people in Shelby- 
ville. His friend, Asa Blankenship, was papering the 
Sunday School room, and Fred noticed that between 
the ten windows in the room there were ten perfectly 
blank spaces that formed small panels. It occurred to 
him that it would help to fill them with the Ten Com- 
mandments, and it suggested the possibility of cutting 
out letters to form the words. He thought that he could 
do it so he spoke to some of the trustees of the church 
who finally and doubtfully consented. Fred drew an 
original alphabet of capital letters about three inches 
high, and strangely enough they looked something like 
a current alphabet called "Ornate," drawn by a man 
living today whose name is quite similar to Fred's. He 
went to the paint store and chose a solid-color maroon 
paper with a rough surface. By cutting out master letters 
he traced to the maroon paper, cut out the letters, and 
spaced them on a piece of paper the exact siz;e of the 
panels. He spread out the work on Asa's tables, and 
used the paperhanger's tools. 

This was an accomplishment in itself, but when Asa 

had finished Fred decided to fill the large panels on the 

walls with Bible quotations. He borrowed a type speci- 

0>i5<0 






men book from the newspaper office of Mr. Trower, and 
from it copied initial letters and decorative pieces; cut 
out letters for tracing, and with the help of a girl whom 
he knew, he made over three thousand letters from gilt 
paper and pasted them in the panels inside a gold rule. 
It took him a month to complete the work. 

He then left Shelbyville for the neighboring town of 
Bethany, to help his friend, Behymer, a contrador-car- 
penter, who was building a church. Fred's job was to 
convert plain glass into stained glass. He painted the 
glass to give it a frosted effedt, and then painted in color 
over the frosted surface. When he returned home from 
Bethany, he found a twenty dollar check waiting for 
him from the Shelbyville church for his work on the 
Sunday School room. A little later, Colonel Smith, a 
very religious man, and one whom the citizens of the 
town greatly admired, said in a talk at the church that 
he had never seen a Sunday School room so beautiful. 
The trustees sent Fred another twenty dollars. 

His parents and sister, "Jo," looked upon him rather 
indulgently despite all these successes. He didn't seem 
steady enough, and these little accomplishments were 
in the nature of play. No one ever granted Fred very 
much of a chance for success of any kind. But some 
admitted that he might possibly become a good sign 
painter. 

Among the many things that he attempted to under- 
stand was electricity comparatively undeveloped com- 



i 



mercially in 1883. After graduation from high school he 
went to work for a sign painter and later a photographer 
in Springfield, Illinois. He spent his leisure hours in an 
eledtrical plant and became friendly with a worker who 
gave him burned-out carbons that would otherwise have 
been discarded. When he came home and his mother 
unpacked his luggage, she found the trunk full of the 
carbon rods, and his clothes squeezed in a small bundle 
that he carried with him. He used the rods to construe! 
a galvanic cell. 

In Springfield he had become well acquainted with a 
minister who had offered to obtain a scholarship for him 
at Blackburn College, a seminary, but Fred had experi- 
enced too much difficulty trying to refrain from undig- 
nified behavior in church even to think of becoming 
a minister. He -was never a very religious boy, and he 
even struggled against the compulsion of going to Sun- 
day School. Now, as a young man, he felt even more 
strongly on the subjecT:. 

His father thought that his natural capabilities fitted 
him for a civil engineering career, and he encouraged 
him to study that profession. After the completion of 
his junior year at high school, young Fred thought of 
taking an examination at the Illinois Industrial School, 
intending to study mechanical engineering if he passed. 
But his high school preparation had not included some 
required study and he did not attempt the entrance ex- 
amination. Later, after he had completed his high school 






work, he could have been admitted on his diploma, 
but his family was preparing to move once again. This 
time it was in the nature of a pioneer's trek to the new 
frontier country. 

John Goudy (the spelling of their surname changed at 
this time since someone discovered that Goudy was the 
traditional Scotch spelling) was motivated by a double 
purpose in planning a trip to the Dakota Territory. He 
was not in good health, the change in climate was ad- 
vised, and he was intrigued by the new country and 
an opportunity to open an office as a real estate agent. 
Many other people from Illinois were going, among 
them the Davis family with whom the Goudys were 
quite friendly. 

John Goudy went first, followed later by Fred. John 
settled at Plankington, Dakota, where he took up a 
quarter sedtion of land, and proved upon it. He had 
heard of Highmore, a little prairie cow-town of about 
500 people, located on the highest point of ground be- 
tween the Mississippi and the Missouri Rivers on the 
Chicago and Northwestern Railway. It was a more 
attractive community so John left his Plankington hold- 
ings and moved to Highmore. 

Under the arrangement with the government at that 
time, a man could pre-empt 160 acres, which was in 
effect an option on the land he chose. He cultivated the 
land, not less than five acres, and when he had lived 
upon it for six months, he could obtain a patent from 



the government on payment of $1.25 an acre. In High- 
more, John Goudy set up a real estate office with a part- 
ner, E. O. Parker, and made loans to farmers who had 
obtained their patents from the government. The con- 
cern also transacted legal matters for the farmers, and 
acled generally in the capacity of advisor. They even 
planned a village in the northern part of Hyde County 
that is still known as Goudyville. 

When they were settled in Highmore, Fred returned 
to Illinois to bring back the rest of the family. They 
arrived during a turbulent period of reconstruction. A 
month before they came, John was sitting in his little 
cottage with his feet dangling in the hatchway leading 
to the cellar. He suddenly heard the rush of wind and 
felt pressure being exerted on the cottage. Through an 
open door he could see a phenomenal column of mist 
or dust approaching rapidly. Before the cyclone hit, he 
jumped into the cellar. It came with increasing noise 
and violence straight for the house, but struck a rise in 
the ground and was defledted over the roof, and only 
moved the cottage a foot or two. Other homes in the 
vicinity were shattered. The roller skating rink was 
disintegrated and its skates were distributed for miles 
around on the prairies. The next day John walked into 
his real estate office and found a dead man lying on the 
floor, carefully placed on a blanket. The victim, Mr. 
Thompson, was the only person killed during the cy- 
clone. He was a Highmore farmer who had ventured out 



from a storm cellar a few minutes before the danger had 
passed, thinking that the storm was over. 

In addition to his real estate office, John Goudy held 
two public positions. Dakota was a territory and a su- 
perintendent of schools from civilised country was held 
in high regard. John was appointed county treasurer by 
the governor, and was later eledted judge of the Probate 
Court. 

As the son of a superintendent of schools from the 
East, Fred had a certain social position in the town of 
400 or 500 people, and he went out with the bankers 
daughter. There were about twenty boys and girls of 
his age in Highmore and when he wasn't working in 
his fathers office, he went out with "the gang." Fred 
was husky and acflive, and could handle himself well 
on horseback. He mastered the difficult art of riding a 
bucking bronco, and owned about five or six while he 
lived in Highmore. 

During the summers, Fred and some of his friends 
went out on camping trips to a Sioux Indian reservation 
a few miles south of Highmore. The Indians paid no at- 
tention to them, but Fred managed to become friendly 
with some who had been in the Custer fight. Once a 
week a government agent distributed flour and sugar 
to the Indians, and the sight of these once self-sufficient 
people waiting patiently in line to receive food from 
their conquerors was the prime attraction of these occa- 
sional expeditions. 






I 






In 1885, when Fred was twenty years old, a news- 
paper was started in Highmore, called the Hyde County 
Bulletin; and from the very first issue on December 26, 
items of interest began to appear about Fred Goudy. 
The first read: ' 'We are under obligation to Fred Goudy 
for assisting in putting up our press. Fred is an old 
hand at pressing, and was of material aid to us, as our 
experience in that line is limited." 

About this incident Goudy later said "I do not have 
any recollecflion of the matter. At most it could have 
been little more than a desire to help set up a hand press, 
because I was probably more mechanically inclined 
than the publisher— not that I knew anything about a 
press or was interested in it or printing. The 'pressing' 
was intended to be facetious." 

In an issue on February 13, 1886: ' 'Fred Goudy has our 
thanks for a fine crayon sketch of President Cleveland.' ' 
And on March 27, 1886: "Fred Goudy is now a full- 
fledged notary. Come in and be sworn." 

Goudy later said: "I was notary public for some years, 
as the work of preparing deeds, mortgages, etc., for my 
father's business made it convenient. But in those days 
you couldn't throw a stick without hitting one or two 



The editor of the Bulletin also reports that Fred Goudy 
had been asked to design a "fancy insurance policy for 
some promoters and produced a very creditable job." 

On Ocftober 16, 1886, a column was started, headed 
©>2i ,0 



"I. O. of G . T." (Independent Order of Good Templars) 
and the editor's introduction read: "This column, under 
the management of Fred W. Goudy, D. G. C. T., is de- 
voted to the interests of the Good Templars and all in- 
terested in temperance work. Items calculated to ad- 
vance the cause are earnestly solicited." 

March 12, 1887: "Fred Goudy is agent for the Guion 
line of steamers and can furnish passage to Liverpool, 
Havre, and continental points cheaper than any other 
agency in the northwest." June 4, 1887: "Fred Goudy is 
taking lessons in shorthand under G. W. Fitzgerald." 

September 3, 1887: "Fred Goudy killed a rattlesnake 
Sunday morning, on the back road from Fort Thomp- 
son, with the butt end of a buggy whip. It measured 
three feet and eight inches and was as large as a man's 
wrist. It had eleven rattles." 

John Goudy was mentioned in the October g, 1886, 
issue: "We saw Judge Goudy going out northwest last 
Sunday. We presume that he is getting acquainted with 
strange roads, preparatory to an electioneering journey. 
The Judge is an old hand at the biz;." 

An item of general interest refers to a J. R. Goudy, a 
distant relative of the Goudy s. This appears in Novem- 
ber, 1886: "Rev. J. R. Goudy has taken his new ap- 
pointment, the Howell M. E. Circuit in Hand County. 
Mr. Goudy was among the pioneers of Hyde County, 
and with whom in days gone by we had many cour- 
tesies. Should the preaching of any man change our 

0>22,0 






thoughts from what they now are, it would be Brother 
Goudy, as we know he is honest in what he says or 
does, a gentleman in all respects." Fred later said: "J. 
R. Goudy. . . took up preaching and -was a pretty punk 
preacher at that. He did break off his drinking." 

February, 1887: "At a meeting of the Highmore W 
C. T. U. new officers were elected. Mrs. J. F. Goudy 
was elected treasurer." 

August, 1887: "Fred W Goudy, A. E. McCune, Miss 
Eva Warner, and Miss Charlotte Root rusticated at Fort 
Thompson this week." 

February, 1887: "The members of the 'Social Glass' 
drama have decided upon Friday evening, February 2, 
as the time for presenting their play to the public. It 
will be one of the most thrilling dramas ever presented 
in Highmore, and while radical in temperance, still will 
be interspersed with comedy and pathos, and will be a 
very interesting play throughout. Let everyone attend, 
and thus help on a good cause." Fred was "the villain" 
in the play. 

June, 1887: "We don't wish to buy any farms, but we 
will give you as large a loan as your improvements will 
warrant. (Signed) John F. Goudy and Son." 

In his father's office Fred learned a little about keep- 
ing books; he drew deeds and mortgages, and occasion- 
ally took Easterners to the government office at Huron 
to secure a list of the available tracts of land on which 
the newcomers could settle. Young Fred knew the land 
0*23^0 



well, and he mastered die complicated maps of tradts 
and townships so that he could take a settler to the 
exacT: location of his quarter section. Their real estate 
office was large, and when the county commissioners 
hired a man to draw a map of Hyde County, the job 
was done there. Fred watched him at his work and no- 
ticed how he handled his instruments. 

His knowledge of the use of surveying instruments 
surprised the county surveyor who was attempting to 
lay out a cemetery near Highmore. He needed someone 
to lay out the lines for him and Fred said that he would 
like to help him. The surveyor was unconvinced, and 
Fred had to do a great deal of talking before he was 
even given a trial. He used the transit well, calling the 
inclination accurately each time. The surveyor admitted 
finally that Fred could use transit and line proficiently. 
After this incident his services were conscripted when- 
ever the surveyor needed an assistant. 

When he was about twenty-three years old, Fred at- 
tempted a business venture of his own. With an English 
preacher named Walton he established the Anglo-Da- 
kota Loan and Trust Company. Fred wrote the initial 
literature for the firm, and instructed the printer as to 
the style of the typography. The preacher was not suc- 
cessful in selling stock for the company, so they never 
made any loans, and soon stopped trying. 

Hard times descended on the Dakota lands. Hail and 

drought killed crops and farms were in the discard. 

0>24(0 













trails 






o the 


(T* , 


-, | 


oners 
e job 


Krf 


1 ^ L 


dno- 


1 \\ ; 






v^»? 


: 1 








ngto 






leone 






/ould 






, and 






was 






gthe 






lined 






endy. 






alien- 






ed at- 


iV=xs fS] 


K^^? 


lglish 




( 1 


o-Da- 


i '■ j* ^ 




nitial 


. ;-_=- - 




as to 


, j 




t sue- 






never 


WEt 




land 






card. 


Preliminary sketches of a Gou 



His father's firm suffered, since its major business came 
from the farmers. Fred -was twenty-four years old and 
had to begin thinking of a profession and a future for 
himself. While working with his father's firm he had 
taught himself bookkeeping, and after carefully consid- 
ering possible openings at home and abroad he decided 
that his best opportunity was in a large city. It was not 
easy to bring to an end his happy life in Highmore— the 
happiest years of his youth— but the necessity to attain 
something by himself was stronger than mere sentiment 
and he left his family and friends and went to Minne- 
apolis. His first trip was in the nature of an excursion. 
He stayed at the home of a man who had bought land 
from his father's firm a little earlier, and with whom 
he had kept up a correspondence. When he came back 
to Minneapolis to stay, he again visited with his friend 
for a few weeks, remaining there until he found a posi- 
tion and was able to support himself. 

In the city he became a cashier and bookkeeper in a 
large department store. He didn't care very much for the 
work, no more than he had liked the routine work in 
his father's office in Highmore,but he did like Minne- 
apolis. It was a large city, the first in which he had ever 
lived. There -were theaters and many facilities for rec- 
reation which appealed to him. 

He stayed in Minneapolis almost a year, then went to 
Springfield, where he worked in the office of a man 
named Wilson whom he had met some years before. 



His previous experience in Springfield, when his fam- 


at her Chicago hon 


ily was still living in Shelbyville, also led him there. 


ing in Lincoln Par 


But this time he only stayed for two or three months. 


His next positioi 


Wages were low and the work did not interest him. 


oughly familiar, fo 


He decided to write to Richard Alden, a Chicago finan- 


assistant in a real 


cial broker, with whom he had had business contacts in 


business, real esta 


Dakota. He applied for a position with Alden and was 


rising. In Dakota, 


made "private secretary." 


number of small a 


In January he left Springfield for Chicago. His new 


had no training in 


work combined many of his capabilities and interests. 


sign, but he apprc 


Alden attempted to get capital from prospective inves- 


naivete and simpl 


tors for the financing of a new machine or process, and 


wallpaper and the 


Goudy wrote and designed prospectuses describing the 


ville. In his appro* 


mechanical functioning of the apparatus. Alden liked 


to anything, he sir 


Goudy 's typographic arrangements. They were simple, 


achieve and did t 


neat, and logical, and appealed to Alden, who insisted 


problem 'was a ch 


on perfection in the appearance of the correspondence 


peded by a sense c 


and literature of the firm. But his difficult requirements 


After about a mc 



in the way of perfection were rather unplea 
for both Goudy and the firm's competent stenographer, 
Bertha Sprinks, a charming young lady who had been 
employed by the firm about three weeks after Fred. 

Goudy 's salary was as small as his title was grand, 
and after a few months he left Alden to take a better 
position. Bertha Sprinks left a little later. They had be- 
come quite friendly and occasionally went to the theater 
together. More often, because of the rather unhappy con- 
dition of the Goudy pocketbook, they spent an evening 






at her Chicago home on the North Side, or went walk- 
ing in Lincoln Park. 

His next position was one with which he was thor- 
oughly familiar, for he became bookkeeper and general 
assistant in a real estate firm. For the success of their 
business, real estate agents depended on good adver- 
tising. In Dakota, Goudy had written and designed a 
number of small advertising pieces for his father. He 
had no training in merchandising or in layout and de- 
sign, but he approached each problem with the same 
naivete and simplicity with which he had solved the 
wallpaper and the steam engine problems in Shelby- 
ville. In his approach to advertising, as in his approach 
to anything, he simply saw what he was attempting to 
achieve and did the best he could to achieve it. Each 
problem was a challenge and he was certainly not im- 
peded by a sense of inferiority. 

After about a month in the real estate office, occasion- 
ally writing copy and designing small folders or news- 
paper ads, an incident occurred that made Goudy even 
more conscious of the possibilities of advertising; and, 
more important, it made him conscious of his possibili- 
ties in advertising. A client of his firm was attempting 
to sell an old farm in Massachusetts and indicated that 
he would like to put an ad in the Chicago Tribune. The 
real estate agents frankly told the client that he stood lit- 
tle if any chance of selling his property. But Fred, with 
characteristic ingenuousness, felt that it could be done, 



and he was given permission to write and design an ad 
that would be run for one day. He found a woodcut of 
a farmhouse, and neatly arranged his copy under the cut 
using the appealing caption "In The Family 150 Years." 
The day after the ad appeared no one came to ask about 
the farm. But on the second day two interested prospe&s 
came, and one of them traveled to Massachusetts to see 
the property. After succumbing to the romantic appeal 
of the advertisement, the hopeful buyer found that the 
old New England mansion had been over-described by 
the advertisement. 

The outcome of his efforts in advertising amazed the 
young bookkeeper, for none other than A. H. McQuil- 
kin, the editor of the leading printing journal, the Inland 
Printer, came to the company's office to tell Goudy how 
much he liked his unusual taste in design, and to ask for 
an article on advertising. His ads were unusual for they 
were simple, whereas the rococo design of that era was 
as intricately inane as it could possibly have been. 

Soon after this Goudy met Cyrus Lauron Hooper who, 
he found, had lived in Shelbyville. Hooper was an in- 
structor in English at the Northwest High School in Chi- 
cago. They became very friendly and saw each other oft- 
en. Goudy was talking and thinking a good deal about 
advertising and conceived the idea of publishing a small 
magazine devoted to problems of advertising. In a short 
while Goudy and Hooper began to plan Modern Adver- 
tising. Hooper conferred with an "expert" who advised 
©>30f© 






him against starting such a venture with a man as inex- 
perienced as Goudy. But Editor McQuillan had already- 
introduced Goudy to Will Bradley, a young illustrator 
and designer, whose work was becoming increasingly 
important. Mr. Bradley had promised to design the cover 
for the magazine and the young advertising missionary- 
was not interested in the opinions of experts. 

The first issue of Modern Advertising carried the follow- 
ing editorial announcement: "Modern Advertising is de- 
signed to fill a hitherto unfilled niche and will be free 
from captious criticism or wish to displace any similar 
journal . It is the aim of the publisher to promulge the best 
thought on the art and science of advertising, dealing 
with the practical side of the subjecT:, with just enough 
of the theoretical to enliven the necessarily dryer details. 
The study which goes to make the best efforts will be to 
the advancement of the advertiser's interest.' ' The first is- 
sue which was sent to prospective advertisers contained 
reading matter with blank spaces showing positions in 
which ads could be placed. 

The first issue brought some encouraging correspon- 
dence. One rabid Westerner wrote: "Dear Sir: We think 
there is a great big field for ModernAdvertising providing 
it is published from a Western standpoint. If vim, vine- 
gar and snap are put into it, it will arrest the attention of 
the effete East in a manner that only the West is capable 
of doing." 

Modern Advertising met misfortune from the very first 
0>3KO 



issue when Associate Editor Hooper mixed up a few- 
dates in a short biography, and it ceased to exist after 
a few months. It served as a good laboratory for Goudy 
who through it began to collecl: information on print- 
ing and design. 

Bookkeeping and unsuccessful magazines were not 
helpful to the pocketbook of a young man with a large 
appetite, and Fred Goudy was again, as often was the 
situation in his life, on the borderline between have 
and have not. Opportunities for recreation were scarce 
and money for the existing diversions was even more 
scarce. But he occasionally enjoyed the company of Ber- 
tha Sprinks, who after leaving Alden's real estate office 
had moved with her parents to another part of Chicago. 
They both owned bicycles, and they often went out to- 
gether on Sunday picnics to the outskirts of the city. 

He had continued his reading since childhood, and his 
interest in reading now became localised in books about 
books and printing. He soon became a naturalised mem- 
ber of the tribe that haunts bookstores, the greatest attrac- 
tion at the time being the shelves of A. C. McClurg and 
Company, then located at Wabash Avenue and Madison 
Street. Here he bought Early Illustrated Booh by Alfred 
Pollard and Early Printed Books by E.Gordon Duff. His 
empty exchequer compelled him to peruse many more 
books than he bought, but he slowly picked up infor- 
mation about this new interest. He also bought some of 
the more advanced magazines on art and literature, such 



as the Chapbook and the London Studio, ventures of Amer- 
ican and English publishers. 

Onedayin 189 2 Fred received a letter from Highmore, 
saying that his father was sick. He hurried home, but he 
found his father already dead; he had succumbed to the 
then fatal peritonitis, due to gall bladder trouble. John 
Goudy was county superintendent of schools at the time 
of his death. Fred stayed in Highmore for two days, then 
returned to Chicago. 

The friendship between Fred and Bertha continued. 
They spent many Sunday afternoons together during the 
summer of 1893, wandering through the exhibits at the 
Chicago World's Fair. 

When he was thirty years old, Fred was still work- 
ing as a bookkeeper, but now it was in a second-hand 
bookstore. He had by this time become deeply inter- 
ested in typographic art and craft through his visits to 
McClurg's and he met many noted bibliophiles in the 
Saints' and Sinners' Corner, presided over by George 
Millard, a friend whom Goudy called ' 'the Patron Saint 
of the Corner." He wanted to learn more about practi- 
cal printing; he wanted to start a press of his own. He 
spoke to Hooper about it, and the pair decided to at- 
tempt another venture together; or rather, Goudy con- 
vinced Hooper that they should do so. It was a print- 
ing shop this time, and they called it the Booklet Press. 

In space sublet from another printing establishment, 
the Booklet Press blossomed out in 1894 with an 8x12 



Gordon press, a small stone, a half-do^en fonts of type, 
a little money from Hooper, and a vast amount of en- 
thusiasm from Frederic Goudy. From the very begin- 
ning they were in debt for the equipment, and in 1895 
business was in the trough of the cycle. Goudy knew 
almost nothing about the mechanical problems of pro- 
ducing a printed page and his early attempts were in 
the nature of experiments. Hooper was still teaching 
school and he could do nothing more than supply the 
cash and come down to watch Goudy use it. But people 
liked Goudy 's experiments and business increased. 

A business increase meant purchase of equipment to 
Goudy, not better food or improved sleeping quarters. 
During these days he ate at times and at times did not. 
A friend of his owned a restaurant and Fred often paid 
for his meals by printing commutation tickets for him. 
He sometimes went to a dime museum or to a "bur- 
lesque," which, in 1894, was a variety or vaudeville 
show, and not particularly interesting. When he had 
nothing to eat he fed his mind at McClurg's in con- 
versation with George Millard or one of the customer 
bibliophiles. He also continued his acquaintance -with 
the doings of William Morris and other masters. By 
then he had become a recognised fixture in the Saints' 
and Sinners' Corner. Bertha Sprinks was by no means 
lessened in importance by these activities. Goudy con- 
tinued to see her, and their friendship deepened. 

Goudy the man was not very much different from 



Goudy the boy. He was still like the tyke who forgot 
the things he promised to do in favor of things that he 
enjoyed doing more. His methods of work were sub- 
ject to much jesting among his friends. Robert Ballou, 
later editor and publisher of the Ben Franklin Monthly, 
reports at "second hand" that ' 'A customer would come 
into Goudy 's office, perhaps at two o'clock in the after- 
noon with a job that must be completed the next morn- 
ing at eight. Goudy would take it on and give the most 
solemn promise in the world, planning to devote the rest 
of the day to the job. But about the time the customer's 
footsteps died away, one of the boys would come in and 
suggest gallery seats at the Majestic, and Goudy would 
go. Then it would be dinner time and there would be 
some friends to talk to. About bed time, the eight o'clock 
promise would be remembered, and Goudy would go 
back to the office and start his work; perhaps at three 
o'clock he would leave with the job finished." 

Goudy was characterised by an enviable directness, an 
objective, non-emotional approach to all his problems, 
and a rich sense of humor.This could be seen in his work, 
in his speech, and in the things that he liked . He disliked 
affectation. When he thought that a thing was wrong, he 
would condemn it in no uncertain terms. He was impa- 
tient with unintelligence and excessive ritual or submis- 
sion to fetishes. He applied his direct, simple analysis to 
anything that presented itself to him. In his youth reli- 
gion annoyed him. His father was religious and forced 



Fred to go to Sunday School. But he could find little evi- 
dence to convince him of either ability or intelligence in 
most ministers, and he saw too much of the"old ladies 
who knew the Bible word for word, but who knew lit- 
tle of the actualities of life." As he grew older, he quit 
going to church and did not hesitate to call himself an 
agnostic. He didn't believe in reincarnation and he was 
also very doubtful of the existence of a hereafter. 

At this time in his life he might have starved to death 
and conclusively solved his doubt as to the existence of 
a hereafter had his work not been good enough to at- 
tract a steady customer to the Booklet Press. Goudy had 
been collecting copies of the new and neatly designed 
Chapbook. W. Irving Way, a friend of Goudy's and an ad- 
mirer of his work, introduced him to the Chapbook pub- 
lishers, Stone and Kimball, who were then planning to 
locate in Chicago, and were seeking a printer. This was 
an excellent occasion for a demonstration of good typog- 
raphy, for the material in the little Chapbook demanded 
the companionship of careful printing. Some of the con- 
tributors were well-known writers , such as Hamlin Gar- 
land, Bliss Carmen, Louise Guiney and Nathan Haskell 
Dole. The price of the magazine was as modest as its siz;e, 
five cents the copy. 

In printing the Chapbook Goudy engineered a simple 
stunt that amazed printers and made him the subject of 
much discussion. He at first could find no type suitable 
for printing the Chapbook because of its small sizje, but 






n 



after taking measurements he ordered nine point ' 'Orig- 
inal Old Style" cast on an eight point body, achieving 
an admirably close fitting of type. The magazine was de- 
signed and set by Goudy but printed by a larger plant. 

As a printer he was well acquainted and thoroughly 
disgusted with the ivy-covered type faces in use. He felt 
that he could design a face at least as good, perhaps bet- 
ter, if he tried. So one night when he could think of no 
better amusement , he seated himself near the window of 
his room and sketched an alphabet. He sent the drawings 
to the Dickinson Type Foundry in Boston, with a mod- 
est note stating that he thought the design was worth five 
dollars. He knew that his letters were as good as most of 
those in use, but he hardly expected the ten dollars that 
the manager of the foundry sent him in consummating 
the sale. 

With the Chapbook to set and a few other good custom- 
ers the Booklet Press was moved to the Caxton Building, 
then in the heart of the old printing district of Chicago, 
and the name was changed to the Camelot Press. Later 
Goudy's type face was called "Camelot"— suggested by 
the name of the press. The Camelot Press had as a mem- 
ber of its ' 'staff' ' a young artist, Berne Nadall, who could 
draw decorative material when it was required. Goudy 
studied Nadall as he had studied Broyles in Shelbyville 
and the surveyor in Dakota, and said, just as he had on so 
many other occasions, ' 'It looks easy, F 11 try' '— and when 
he tried he discovered in himself a sensitivity to correct- 
or l© 



ness of line that helped him to develop an unusual skill in 
rendering appropriate decorative drawings. 

In 1 8g 5 , Goudy saw an essay entitled ' 'The Black Art,' ' 
which he liked so much that he reprinted it, with an in- 
troduction of his own, in a sixteen page pamphlet. Gou- 
dy 's introduction shows clearly the lines along which he 
was thinking. 

"In the Engraver and Printer for January, 1894, appeared 
an article from the pen of D. B. Updike, which so nearly 
voiced our own idea as to taste and style in printing that 
we have endeavored to bring it (slightly abridged) to 
some who probably didn't see it at that time. 
"Not all printers will agree with him. Some prefer to 
work along the florid lines demanded by many custom- 
ers. We hope to inculcate in those for whom printing is 
done a love of harmony and simplicity. We propose to be- 
come the exponents of a style that cannot be assailed. 
Bizarre effects may have their place, few know the place; 
uniqueness may be desirable, but if it cannot be had ex- 
cept at the expense of good taste, then it had better be un- 
attempted." 

Daniel Berkeley Updike later became one of the great- 
est figures in the graphic arts. About the future of the 
young printer who liked Updike's ideas— we shall see. 

The young printer did not print very much longer The 

business was in need of capital, and Goudy habitually 

undercharged his customers— and overworked himself. 

Jobs took a great deal of time, especially at the beginning. 

©>38,0 



Hooper had become a high school principal and could 
give very little time to the firm. But Goudy 's downfall 
came when, at the suggestion of Hooper, the firm took in 
George L. Hunter, a foreign rewrite man on the Chicago 
Tribune, who became the "outside man." Hunter knew 
nothing about printing except that the cost of materials 
and labor must be kept as low as possible and the price 
must be an extreme in the other direction. In 1896, Gou- 
dy sold his share in the firm for $100, and a few months 
later the sheriff's notice announced to all who cared to 
know that the Camelot Press was history 

Goudy then returned to his old standby, bookkeeping, 
and attempted designing only asasideline. After the sale 
of Camelot, he designed another face which he hoped to 
sell to the Dickinson Foundry. He went to Clarence Mar- 
der , of Marder , Luse, and Company, and asked him what 
he would suggest as a selling price for the face. Marder 
suggested $35 and added that if Goudy didn't sell it to 
Dickinson, he would buy it from him. Goudy did sell it, 
but he quickly designed another that Marder liked and 
bought . He also sold Marder some decorative ornaments . 

During all of this period Goudy continued to seek the 
companionship of Bertha Sprinks. She had moved with 
her family to Berwyn, Illinois, in 1894, and Fred often 
rode out on Sunday to visit with Bertha and her family. 
Later she was employed in the office of a metal company 
in Chicago and they frequently met during lunch hour, 
Goudy sometimes calling for her at the office. One day 



Mr. Winchell, the manager of the company, said to her, 
"You don't want to marry that man, he'll never amount 
to anything." But Bertha thought otherwise for in June, 
1897, they were married at her home in Berwyn, and 
that night they left for Detroit, where Fred had secured 
a position as bookkeeper-cashier for The Michigan Farmer. 

By this time Goudy's interest in books and book design 
had become thoroughly aroused. In McClurg's Mr. Mil- 
lard had shown him a Vale Press copy of the Poems of Sir 
]ohn Suckling and Goudy immediately recognised its su- 
periority over any book he had ever before seen. George 
Millard pointed out other books, such as those of Emery- 
Walker, William Morris, St. John Hornby, T.J. Cobden- 
Sanderson, Charles Ricketts, D. B. Updike, and others. 
The Newberry Library collection provided Goudy with 
an opportunity to study early books and book design. 

In Detroit Goudy continued designing ornaments and 
initial letters. Bertha was interested in his work and 
when he received an order from a St. Louis foundry for 
two sets of initial letters, she inked in his pencil designs 
as she had done even before they married. The Camelot 
design appeared while they were in Detroit. His duties 
as an employee of The Michigan Farmer left him little 
time to be applied to his avocation as designer. But the 
bookkeeping did not interfere with the designing very 
long, for in 1899 he lost his position and moved back to 
Chicago where he established himself in the Athenaeum 
Building as a free-lance designer. 



i 



A record of his work during the next three years of his 
life could easily have filled a volume. He helped Ralph 
Fletcher Seymour with a hand-lettered copy of Sonnets 
from the Portugese and he independently hand-lettered a 
volume of Mother Goose, the letters of which were later 
used as the model for an alphabet cast by a St. Louis 
foundry, and labeled "Hearst." He also did an article, 
some reviews, and a cover for the Inland Printer. He de- 
signed book covers, bookplates, head pieces, title pages, 
"dingbats," and some commercial lettering and design- 
ing. Some of his clients were Hart, Schaffner & Marx, 
Marshall Field and Co., The A. C.McClurg Company 
and H. S. Stone and Co. For McClurg's he specialised in 
book covers. His first was a shamrock leaf design for the 
Dear Irish Girl. Another early book cover design, that for 
Fables in Slang, by George Ade, is remembered because 
of the thrill the designer experienced when he walked 
past McClurg's window and saw it filled with copies 
of the newly published book. Goudy's book cover de- 
signs showed his love for and knowledge of traditional 
design. Usually they were appropriate drawings of en- 
twined leaves or branches. He took great pains with his 
work and nothing left his drawing board until he was 
thoroughly satisfied with it. He experimented, erased, 
and shifted lines, to produce results he could accept. 

Bertha kept busy all this time in an art-craft not en- 
tirely dissociated from her husband's work. Goudy had 
seen and read to her an article on hand weaving, and 
©>4i <© 



they both became interested in it. They bought a loom 
from someone in Boston and studied some books on the 
subjecT:. They made many rugs and succeeded in selling 
some of them. 

Not long after they returned to Chicago from Detroit, 
a son, Frederic Truesdell Goudy was born. During that 
month the breadwinner had earned a total of eighteen 
dollars. Later to round out their family they adopted a 
girl, five hours old, whom Dr. Louise Acres, Bertha's 
family physician, had recommended to them. They had 
spoken to her about such a possibility after Frederic's 
birth. They loved the child as if it had been their own, 
and her death five months later was a severe blow. 

In 1900 Frank Holme, a newspaper artist, started the 
Frank Holme School of Illustration and asked Goudy to 
teach lettering and illustration. Through Holme he met 
many men who later gave him commissions, and became 
friendly with some whose work was later to make them 
famous in various branches of the graphic arts. Among 
them were the artist, WA.Dwiggins, the cartoonist, Har- 
ry Hirshfield, and the type designer, Oswald Cooper, all 
of whom were pupils at the school. His work as an in- 
structor at the school compelled him to do the research 
and reading that formerly he had done as he pleased. He 
actually had to study to keep ahead of his students, and 
to preserve the illusion of omniscience that students at- 
tach to those that teach them. 

Goudy did not end his career as type designer with the 



I 





William Morris' Kelmscott press 




I 



Camelot design. He followed it with DeVinne Roman, 
Pabst Old Style, Pabst Italic,and Powell. In 1903 Kup- 
penheimer and Company asked Goudy to design an ex- 
clusive face for use in their advertising.The result was 
a pleasing alphabet that has been described by Goudy as 
"generous in form, with solid lines and strong serifs, and 
without preposterous thicks and thins." Kuppenheimer 
liked the design, but they could not be convinced that 
they should pay the price required to have the matrices 
manufactured, and type cast. They returned the design 
to Goudy with a small payment for his time.The design 
seemed excellent for book use, and Goudy wished that 
he could cast it and see how close he could come to the 
book work of some of the private presses. 

As his early years demonstrated, there was little differ- 
ence between his wanting to do something and his doing 
it. He kept his ear to the ground until he found an oppor- 
tunity of starting a private press of his own. It came in 
the person of Will Ransom,a young printing enthusiast 
who was studying at the Art Institute in Chicago. Ran- 
som had operated a small press of his own, the Handcraft 
Press, in Snohomish,Washington.While in Washington 
he had seen samples of Goudy design reproduced in the 
Inland Printer, and he learned more about Goudy and his 
work from W Irving Way whom he had met in Seattle. 
In Chicago, Ransom was disappointed with the instruc- 
tion at the art school because there was little taught about 
typography and design, in which he was particularly in- 
G> , 45' <0 



terested. In the spring of 1903 he went to the Fine Arts 
Building to meet Goudy, and his diary entry for that day 
records the fadt that "He (Goudy) is very pleasant and 
treated me extremely well." 

In about two weeks Goudy, seeing Ransom's interest, 
suggested that he come up to his office and help him 
with his work on the "possibility "that he might learn 
something. Ransom occupied the desk recently evacu- 
ated by Billy Dwiggins, who had been helping Goudy. 
Both Goudy and Ransom were deeply interested in the 
work of the private presses and they often discussed 
the possibility of modifying and casting the Kuppen- 
heimer type and starting a private press of their own. 

Goudy, who avidly insisted on the project, had little 
money to spare; Ransom likewise had little but he ap- 
pealed to a friend for help. The friend replied that he 
too had little money but would help them get some. 
By this time they were so anxious to get started that this 
quasi-promise was all the encouragement they need- 
ed to bring Goudy 's alphabet design to Robert Wieb- 
king to be cast into type. In about a month they had the 
type in their cases, and they bought a Schniedewend 
and Lee proof press that in Goudy 's words was "only 
a glorified Washington hand press for newspaper use." 
They set up their modest equipment in the barn behind 
the Goudy's home in the village of Park Ridge, a sub- 
urb of Chicago. Even before all the type was in the 
cases, they set their first circular, an announcement of 
GV46(0 



the opening of the press. They called their venture the 
Village Press, for Goudy was thinking of printing the 
"Village Blacksmith" and the word "village" suggested 
the name, which he thought simple and suitable. 

The friend who had vaguely promised to help them 
get money was unable to do so, and before they could 
claim their type Ransom had to borrow money from a 
bank, using insurance policies for security. Ransom 
made this entry in his diary: "The type finally all ar- 
rived Monday night (July 20) and Tuesday morning 
we went to press with the first circular. The tympan 
and frisket sheets gave us a great deal of trouble on ac- 
count of the paper not being stretched properly, and 
the ink, for a part of the time, refused to work at all so 
that we had a pretty hard time of it, making poor work 
of the circular. . . . Decided to reprint the whole thing 
on Alton Mills Handmade and that is on the press now 
ready to be run first thing in the morning." This de- 
scribes the troublesome birth of the Village Press. Nor 
was it the end of their troubles. They were struggling 
with strange equipment, determined to get perfed: re- 
sults and they were satisfied with nothing less. 

It was not long before Bertha Goudy began coming 
into the shop rather regularly, often finding something 
to do. Within a week after the type was in the cases 
she began learning how to set it, and according to all 
records she learned the job rapidly and thoroughly. 
With Bertha's interest in the press and with the burn- 



ing enthusiasm of the male participants, it was not sur- 
prising that often shop and home changed places. Since 
the barn had no lights, a type frame was carried into 
the dining room so that type could be distributed and 
set at night. 

Ransom lived with the Goudys for the three months 
that he was connected with the press. Among the items 
in his diary he recorded this otherwise forgotten side- 
light: "... Little Frederic was a toddler that summer 
but occasioned much less distraction than the several 
pets. A single memory of two Blenheim spaniel pups 
concerns their being carried in my coat pockets on trips 
for the mail, to the delight of the neighborhood chil- 
dren. And there were 'thousands of cats' (well, four 
anyway) eternally underfoot. Two of them are dim in 
recollection but the black angora had a fiendish temper 
and the white Lady Jane was, euphoniously, tempera- 
mental. It was she who achieved typographic immor- 
tality by a trip across ink slab and table when we were 
putting dust wrappers on Printing. My copy still bears 
her footprints. And so close were home and shop affairs 
that her eventual departure for the feline equivalent of 
Nirvana (via chloroform and wash boiler) was accom- 
panied by communal grief." 

C.Lauron Hooper, remembering an episode during 
a visit prior to the Village Press period, also tells of cats: 
"On at least one occasion when we sat down to dinner 
a long-haired, fluffy-tailed Persian whose a 



blue blood had ooz,ed through his skin and tinted his 
fur, leaped confidently upon the table and made for 
Fred's plate. I was horrified. What could I do if that 
beautiful animal should try to share my dinner! Fred 
was not horrified— not at all. He treated the cat with 
perfect courtesy. Seeming to regret its possible disap- 
pointment in being thwarted, he picked it up tenderly, 
talked to it soothingly, petted it, and put it down upon 
the floor. Up came the cat again, and the program was 
repeated— how many times I do not recall." Frederic 
Goudy's handling of the cat was typical of his gentle- 
ness in treating both animals and people. He was very 
approachable, eminently sociable, and people could not 
help liking him. He retained his directness of speech 
and intellect among their friends; he began to gather 
a kind of fame to himself for his humorous stories and 
his unfailing modesty. 

Their first book, Printing, an essay by William Morris 
and Emery Walker, was completed by the middle of 
September. By printing this Goudy recognised his ob- 
ligation to William Morris, the great poet-printer, from 
whom he had learned so much. Their second book, 
The Blessed Damoz,el, was printed for Clarence Marder, 
an old friend of Goudy's, who took one-half the edition 
and distributed the books as Christmas gifts, Goudy 
selling the others. Toward the end of September when 
they started work on Tfie Hollow Land, Goudy bor- 
rowed money and repaid Ransom for his loan. Ransom 



then left the Village Press, and Fred and Bertha Goudy 
continued the work alone. It had become apparent that 
they would never earn enough from the Press to sup- 
port all three so Ransom withdrew. By this time Bertha 
had become an indispensable helper. She demonstrated 
exceeding adeptness in composition and helped with 
the binding and presswork. The Village Press became 
a husband and wife adventure, for the Goudy s worked 
side by side, sharing every problem of shop and house- 
hold. Their work made them companions, and fellow- 
workers, and although the Village Press was supposed- 
ly a business, the beauty derived from their combined 
lives and their combined, intense enthusiasm invested 
the Press with a personality that made the products of 
their labor much more valuable than merely beautiful 
books. An enviably perfect marriage, theirs. 

Stories that have drifted down from those early days 
of the Village Press show that the Goudys laughed to- 
gether perhaps as much as they worked together. Once 
some little boys in the neighborhood came to watch 
the strange activity in the barn, and one of them asked 
Goudy what type metal was. Goudy said "an alloy of 
lead, and tin, and antimony." Another boy came and a 
member of the enlightened crew asked the newcomer 
the same question. He said that he didn't know and 
claimed that the interrogator didn't know either, which 
brought the prompt reply: "I do too, it's lead, and tin, 
and alimony." 



On another occasion Bertha registered a "last laugh." 
During a bicycle trip before they were married, Bertha's 
machine hit a stump and she had executed a somersault 
over the handlebars, much to Fred's delight, and her 
chagrin. But in the Village Press Fred matched her fall 
with a back-flip through the barn door when his per- 
spiring hands had slipped from the hand press lever on 
the extreme point of impression. He landed on his back 
with his feet up in the air. Fortunately only the press 
was injured. 

During the time that book production at the Village 
Press was in full swing, money was a very scarce item 
in the Goudy household. Goudy kept his ofEce in Chi- 
cago and continued his designing to pay for the mate- 
rials used by the Press. Mrs. Goudy continued working 
with her loom and they occasionally sold one of the 
beautiful fabrics that she wove. 

Their work was in keeping with the best traditions 
of the Arts-and-Crafts Movement of the day which was 
based on the belief that perfect craftsmanship was an 
expression of the personality of the^worker, manifested 
by hand labor. The Goudys were acquainted with the 
broad movement through an occasional purchase of the 
magazjine, Handicraft, published by the Boston Society 
of Arts and Crafts. It seemed to them that the eastern 
section of the country would be more sympathetic to 
their craft ideals than the mid- west. Goudy was attract- 
ed by an advertisement in back of Handicraft and an 





of the foundii 


article on "Village Handicrafts" both of which spoke 


of the Hingham Society of Arts and Crafts, Hingham 


ham Interlude 


being a small village on Boston Bay in Massachusetts. 


of the Goudy 


Fred was anxious to learn more, and with some money 


story of their 


derived from the sale of some of Bertha's rugs he made 


without it. Re 


a trip to Boston to "spy out the land." He came back 


"In 1904 Hin 


convinced that there were greater opportunities in the 


fifteen miles J 


East. Bertha realised that she would be leaving her 


habited by sta 


family, and that both -would be leaving their friends, 


had settled th 


but when Fred asked her if she would like to make the 


sole aim in lif 


move, she answered that she would go toTimbuctoo if 


other people's 


he wanted to go. 


in the world 


They moved in early March, 1904. Later in that year 


ham was gooc 


they received news that encouraged them to seek even 


not of Hingha 


greater perfection in their bookmaking. For their first 


initial impadt 


three books, completed at Park Ridge, they had been 


be overcome, 


awarded a bronze medal by the Louisiana Purchase 


to make this t 


Exposition held in St. Louis. 


the recent org 


In Hingham they became friendly with the minister 


had something 


of the New North Church, Rev. Charles E.Park, who 


They took a 


was interested in printing and actually set the type for 


down. 


his Sunday School lessons. He often came to the Goudy 


"There were 


shop or the Goudy home— there was no difference- 


little Frederic 


to visit or to set type. The Goudys were amazed at the 


Inquisitive ne 


way he could tie up a block of type. He took the type 


on their ilk a 


in his hands and holding one end of the string in his 


instance; wha 


teeth he would tie it as though it were a package. It 


which four m 


was Mr. Park who, for a later anniversary celebration 


Such questior 


cy52r<D 


i 



of the founding of the Village Press, wrote his "Hing- 
ham Interlude" that so wonderfully catches the spirit 
of the Goudys at -work in Hingham as to make any 
story of their activity during this period incomplete 
without it. Rev. Park wrote: 

"In 1904 Hingham was a typical New England town, 
fifteen miles from Boston, almost as old as Boston, in- 
habited by staid self-sufficient families whose ancestors 
had settled the place eight generations ago, and whose 
sole aim in life seemed to be just to exist and supervise 
other people's existence. They had the kindest hearts 
in the world and the most restricted horizons. Hing- 
ham was good enough for them, and whatsoever was 
not of Hingham they viewed with a curiosity whose 
initial impact of disapproval might in the course of time 
be overcome, but not easily. Why the Goudys elected 
to make this town their home was a mystery. Perhaps 
the recent organisation of an Arts and Crafts Society 
had something to do with it. At all events, they came. 
They took a little story-and-a-half cottage and settled 
down. 

"There were just four of them: Mr. and Mrs. Goudy 
little Frederic, and Roxy the beautiful Persian kitty. 
Inquisitive neighbors had an exciting time speculating 
on their ilk and calibre. There was the furniture for 
instance; what could be in those great solid crates, 
which four men and a set of rollers could just budge? 
Such questions were speedily answered. The crates 



blossomed out into a huge Franklin press, about half 


things to be le. 


a ton of type, and all the paraphernalia of a print shop. 


"Mrs. Goudy 


The Village Press had moved to Hingham. The local 


how she set i 


printer at first took alarm. But he soon learned that here 


she replied, 'I 


was no ordinary job printer to compete with him, but 


they were usi 


a Press with an ideal and a burning determination to 


Fred. It was a 


fulfill that ideal. This point having been properly set- 


his letters wi 


tled, Hingham accepted them, and went serenely on. 


seemed to con 


"Yet to a chosen few, the advent of the Goudys was 


once combine 


a momentous event.Their little house was a fascinating 


You did not i 


combination of home and workshop. The front parlor 


whole. Mrs. C 


was the shop. A small middle room was occupied by 


accurate. She 


Billy Dwiggins, who arrived a few months later, and 


a pair of unfc 


still later brought the new Mrs. Billy who proved to be 


long, sensitiv 


a quiet, gracious little body, always reading. Hingham 


cacy of their 


had never seen people who lived with such z;est.They 


"The work c 


were the soul of friendliness, but had little time to in- 


lets that shou 


dulge the emotion for its own sake. For them life had a 


There were \ 


purpose: to create beauty and to be thorough about it. 


Governor John 


They threw themselves into their work with a kind of 


sachusetts and 


ferocity; laboring, criticising, cursing mistakes, discus- 


by designing 


sing, speculating, sometimes disagreeing, sometimes ex- 


and occasions 


ulting, always with a fierce intensity of idealism that in- 


dry. Once in 


vested life with new meaning for delighted onlookers. 


program or 1 


/ "Could it be very important that there should be no 


meeting. One 


'rivers' in a page of text? or that the color should be so 


came to Hing 


exacl? or that the paper should be just so damp? or that 


program and 


the register should split a hair? Here were a great many 


have down h 


cy54<o 





things to be learned about the 'art preservative of all arts.' 
"Mrs. Goudy was the typesetter. Once she was asked 
how she set a page so clean and even.' I don't know,' 
she replied, 'I just seem to have the knack.' At that time 
they were using the Village type, designed of course by 
Fred. It was a revelation to observe how he had imbued 
his letters with a kind of mutual affinity so that they 
seemed to combine of their own accord into words, and 
once combined the words became units in themselves. 
You did not notice the letters, you saw the word as a 
whole. Mrs. Goudy was a rapid worker, and incredibly 
accurate. She was slender, nervous, full of gaiety, with 
a pair of unforgettable eyes that missed nothing, and 
long, sensitive fingers that told her, through the deli- 
cacy of their touch, as much as most persons could see. 
"The work consisted of getting out dainty little book- 
lets that should be flawless gems of the printer's art. 
There were Browning's Rabbi Ben Ezra, The Foems of 
Governor John D. Long, President Eliot's Address on Mas- 
sachusetts and so on. The necessary pot-boiling was done 
by designing display advertisements for some big store 
and occasionally redrawing a type face for some foun- 
dry. Once in a while Fred was induced to print the 
program or order of service for a local conference or 
meeting. One day a Boston architect, Edwin J. Lewis, 
came to Hingham for such a meeting. He picked up the 
program and exclaimed,'What bully good printing you 
have down here in Hingham.' Even he did not know 



how good it was, or what pains had been taken over 
that simple job. 

"That was the trouble: the work of the Village Press 
was too good to be appreciated by any save the illumi- 
nati. How could people know, or what could they care 
that hours had been spent tramping Boston streets to 
get just the right ink; or that the paper had been kept 
for days in the damp cellar; or that the job had been 
run on a Colt's Armory press with its even squeeze, 
aad not an ordinary jobber of the clamshell action? 
Money came slowly for these reasons, and one must 
suppose that money was as necessary in that household 
as in any other. It was another case of voluntary self- 
sacrifice at the bidding of the ideal. 
"There were moments of deep depression. One eve- 
ning a friend called, and found the Goudys exhaust- 
ed after a hard day's work. They had set and run, on 
the hand press, five hundred sheets of a four-page form. 
The caller read the sheet with his fresh eye and had the 
poor taste to discover four errors. Instead of keeping 
his mouth shut, he called attention to these errors. At 
first he was all but murdered; but later he was wearily 
thanked, and the next day five hundred corrected sheets 
were run. 

"Once in a while they did stop to eat. Mrs. Goudy 
would wash her hands, vanish into the kitchen, and in 
fifteen minutes announce that dinner was served. But 
even at meals, the topic of prime interest was not the 
G>>56,0 



ken over 


food but the job. Fred's favorite dessert was coffee jel- 
ly with plenty of coffee for flavoring. It was a striking 




age Press 
lie illumi- 


dish to look at, almost jet black and almost snow white, 




just the way a printed page should look. And when he 




they care 


served it, he would inquire, 'Will you have some of the 
roller composition?' 




)een kept 


"Our New England towns have strong character and 




lad been 


need a lot of understanding. A stranger taking residence 




squeeze, 


is greeted by a kindly suspicion: 'What right have you 




1 action? 


to intrude?' On taking his departure, he is looked upon 




3ne must 


with incredulity: 'Having sampled our town, how can 




ousehold 


you leave?' 




tary self- 


"The departure of the Goudy s from Hingham was 




received with an apparent indifference which perhaps 




One eve- 


they misunderstood. It was not indifference, but bewil- 




exhaust- 


derment that anyone should voluntarily go away when 
they could stay. To their friends, however, their remov- 




age form. 


al was a cause of profound regret, only dispelled when 




i had the 


the future proved the wisdom of the step. ..." 




keeping 
rrors. At 


Goudy had continued his occupation of hand-letterer 




and designer throughout the Hingham period, for their 




3 wearily 


book printing, interesting though it was, was not lucra- 




ed sheets 


tive. He received a few commissions from Boston and 
New York, and even from Marshall Field and Company 




s. Goudy 


in Chicago, but these were not sufficient to keep them 




n, and in 


going. They completed five books in Hingham, and the 




ved. But 


last two financed their move to New York after two 




s not the 


years in Massachusetts. 






0>57<® 





In New York, Goudy set up an office on East 28th 
Street and began doing free-lance work for advertisers. 
His activity as a printer did not start for several months, 
until he and Everett Currier, a Hingham friend, went 
into business together. Business failed to materialise, 
but Goudy established a very valuable friendship with 
Mitchell Kennerley publisher, who had an office in the 
building. Kennerley was familiar with Goudy's work 
and he soon learned to like the man as much as he ad- 
mired his work. Goudy met Morgan Shepard who had 
just come from San Francisco, and who made an arrange- 
ment with Goudy to establish the Village Press in his 
quarters in the Parker Building on 19th Street, taking 
his rent out in trade. Goudy then began doing printing 
and designing for Kennerley and others. 

But the Goudys still did not eat regularly. On many 
occasions they were forced to open poor little Freder- 
ic's penny bank to borrow money for the subway trip 
downtown. Once they were able to avoid a five-mile 
walk home, after they had "fasted" all day, by a visit 
from a man who bought a fifteen-dollar book. Legend 
has it that the prospedt of food was so welcome that the 
Goudys ran pell-mell down the twelve flights of stairs 
and reached the street ahead of the customer who had 
taken the elevator. 

Fred Goudy's genial companionship and his famous 
stories, and Bertha's sincere manner and excellent din- 
ner parties won them many friends in lonely New York. 
0*58,0 



Friendship and business were inseparable items to the 
Goudys. About that time the famous Stowaway Club 
first came into existence composed of "kinspritz;"in the 
graphic arts. Goudy was recognised by all as the "mas- 
ter raconteur" (a reputation which he thought not fully 
deserved) of the club, an organisation for the bolster- 
ing of pure comradeship. 

Later Goudy formed a partnership with Ivan Somer- 
ville, in a publishing business called Ivan Somerville 
and Company but this did not last very long, for the 
relationship was not very satisfactory and the produces 
of their press were not the type of books for which 
Goudy cared. It seemed that partnerships were meant 
for men with less stubborn individuality than Frederic 
Goudy and he learned that if he were ever to achieve a 
lasting success, it must be achieved alone. 

In 1907 Kennerley moved his quarters to that famous 
bookstore, "The Little Book-Shop Around the Corner." 
The "quiet, Old World atmosphere" of the place ap- 
pealed to Goudy, and he was a frequent visitor Through 
Kennerley he met Laurence Gomme, a member of the 
"Little Book-Shop" firm. The book shop was, in true 
English tradition, at once the office of a publisher and a 
store where the books of the publisher were displayed. 
It was here that Goudy met Edward Dickson, publish- 
er of Platinum Print, later called Photographic Art. Goudy 
had designed a cover for Platinum Print and his knowl- 
edge of the structure and history of letters prompted 
G>>59<© 



m) 



Dickson to request him to write a series of articles on 
the alphabet. In addition to his other numerous activi- 
ties, Goudy now became a writer. 

A visitor to the Goudy office in the Parker Building 
could have had no doubt but that someone was work- 
ing there. His desk was strewn with papers, and in 
order to find something he usually had to go through 
the entire pile. He attached small value to the work 
over which he had spent such painstaking hours. His 
precious matrices and drawings were carelessly scat- 
tered about, and he could not afford insurance for his 
equipment. One day Oscar Shaw, superintendent of the 
building, dropped in as he frequently did to talk with 
Goudy, and noticed the matrices for the Village Type 
in a pigeon hole in his desk. When he learned their 
value, he suggested that Goudy put them in a safe place 
in the superintendent's office. 

When the customary revelry tokened the arrival of 
the year 1908, the Goudys were just finishing Bliss 
Carman's Gate of Peace and a week later 150 copies of 
The Lover's Hours were printed and ready for binding. 
Late in the afternoon of January the tenth, Eva Dean, a 
friend of the Goudys came up to the office and invited 
Bertha to go shopping with her. Since they had reached 
a lull in their work, Bertha went, and Fred and little 
Fred went home early. For a few weeks previous, they 
had been working until quite late in the evening. This 
evening they spent quietly at home, Bertha sewing, Fred 
GV6o(© 






reading. At 8:30 the telephone rang, Bertha answered. 

"It's Everett Currier," she said. "Yes, Fred is here. 
Is the Parker Building burning?" Goudy was stunned. 
Bertha calmly reported, "Currier says the Parker Build- 
ing is on fire, you'd better hurry down." 

Goudy dressed rapidly, and took the downtown sub- 
way at 116th Street. He emerged from an exit within 
the fire lines and the police ushered him to safety. The 
"fireproof " building was a veritable furnace, the brick 
walls neatly trapped the white hot interior, and only 
occasional spurts of flame shot out from the windows. 
Goudy stood on the corner and watched the Village Press 
melt and disappear. All their books, their equipment was 
gone. He stayed for a few minutes, and then called Ber- 
tha, who was waiting anxiously at home. "The joke is on 
us," he said, "every thing is gone." 

Everything was gone except the matrices for the Vil- 
lage type which were in Shaw's safe, that luckily was 
housed in an unburned portion of the building, and 
twenty-four copies of Bliss Carman's Gate of Peace which 
had been mailed to subscribers. But the Goudy family 
was still alive— they escaped the fate of some who stayed 
after the elevator had stopped running— and in other 
respects the fire was not the tragedy that it first seemed 
to be. The Goudys had lived from hand to mouth dur- 
ing the existence of the Village Press. All the money that 
Fred earned through his designing had been used to buy 
materials for the books, and so much time was taken up 
©>63,<0 



in the production of books that their sale hardly made 
the effort worth while. NowGoudy was forced to start 
a business where no large outlay for rent and materials 
was required and almost immediately after the fire he 
was making more money than during the existence of 
the Press. At the time, of course, they did not realise 
that the fire might have beneficial results, all they knew 
was that something they had loved and owned was gone . 
Shortly after the fire, Alfred Bartlett, a friend living 
in Boston, sent Goudy $25 and told him that he could 
repay it in work. The manager of the Society for Improv- 
ing the Condition of the Worthy Poor, a man for whom 
Goudy had done a little work, called the day after the 
fire and offered him $100, which Goudy refused. Other 
friends also offered help, but he accepted only the $25 
and a loan of $20 from another friend. 

Goudy worked at home after the fire, and later estab- 
lished himself in the offices of Kendall Banning and 
Company where he again free-lanced and paid for his 
rent by doing work for Banning. It was during this 
period that Goudy completed his sixteenth and seven- 
teenth type faces, the 38E Roman and Italic, which he 
drew for the Lanston Monotype Machine Company. Aft- 
er producing the Village Type he had designed Cush- 
ing Italic, Engraver's Title, Boston News Letter, Cop- 
perplate Gothics, Globe Gothic, Caxton Initials and the 
Caslon Revised. Most of his types were good, but none 
had been received with the popularity of some of the 
G>>64f© 






faces of the old masters; he had not earned the fame of a 
Garamond, Caslon, or Bodoni. 

Early in 1909 Fred expressed a desire to go to Europe 
and encouraged by Bertha's "Well, why don't you?" 
he resolved to earn enough by the summer of that year 
to pay his expenses to Europe and back and still leave 
Bertha with enough to keep her and Frederic until his 



The plan was successful, so in July he left for Liver- 
pool on the White Star liner Cedric. He quickly made 
friends on shipboard, especially among the many school 
teachers that were taking the trip. He traveled second 
class, and he and his friends enjoyed themselves so much 
that the crew had a difficult time keeping the first-class 
passengers from joining them. Something went wrong 
with the boat as they neared England and they land- 
ed at Holyhead, in North Wales, instead of Liverpool. 
This provided an opportunity for him to enjoy an unex- 
pected trip through Wales, a country that he otherwise 
■would never have seen. 

Goudy stayed at a boarding house in London where 
he paid the equivalent of $3.75 a week for his room 
and breakfast. He bought a map of London and planned 
an itinerary for his trips each day. After breakfast he 
walked to the designated place— he never took a bus 
or tram unless the distance was entirely too great— he 
■would return about 11 a.m., eating only a piece of un- 
sweetened chocolate for luncheon. He rested for an hour 






or two and went off again until 5 p. m. when he ate a 
full, inexpensive dinner at Lyons, ABC, or Slater's res- 
taurants. In the evening he usually went to the vaude- 
ville—and then to bed. 

He took with him to England two letters of introduc- 
tion. One of these was addressed to Alfred Pollard, then 
Keeper of the Books of the British Museum and the au- 
thor of the first book on printing that Goudy ever pur- 
chased, and another to Emery Walker, who shared with 
William Morris the authorship of Printing, the first book 
that Goudy ever printed . Pollard showed him things that 
the tourist would ordinarily never see. Walker showed 
him the Kelmscott and Morris items in his large collec- 
tion. On their first meeting Walker said, "Morris would 
have liked knowing you," a remark that was to Goudy 
ample recognition of his hard work. 

Goudy also spent much of his time in the British Mu- 
seum, and many of London's bookstores. From London 
he traveled to Brussels, where he stayed overnight, and 
then to Switzerland. He spent part of the week in a small 
Swiss hotel in Interlaken, in the shadow of the Jungfrau. 
It was noon of a cloudy, overcast day when he arrived at 
his hotel. His room faced west, a fog bank being the only 
visible scenery. He sat down to write a letter. When he 
raised his head, the fog had cleared, presenting full view 
of the white-crowned majesty of the Jungfrau, bathed in 
pure sunlight— a sight that completely entranced him. 

From Switzerland, he went to Paris where he spent a 
0>66(0 



: spent a 



week. He met an American friend, Orville Peets, who 
was studying art there, and who helped him understand 
many things that he would have missed because of his 
lack of knowledge of the language. Orville met him dur- 
ing mealtimes at a restaurant in the Latin Quarter, and 
planned an itinerary, giving him directions for finding 
spots he wanted to visit, then went back to his classes. 
Each evening after dinner, and after school, they visited 
interesting parts of Paris that Goudy would not other- 
wise have seen. He sat for hours in the Luxembourg Gar- 
dens, watching people, and listening to the orchestra. 
He saw the palace, visited the gallery, and snubbed the 
National Printing Office. 

He returned in August and rented an office on 28th 
Street where he again free-lanced his designing and his 
lettering. Later in their Brooklyn home, the Goudys in- 
stalled a small Golding press, a type cabinet, and began 
book printing with The Songs and Verses of Edmund Wal- 
ler, employing as substitute for the Village Type, which 
had not been recast since the fire, the Original Old Style 
Italic. At an earlier date, Goudy had drawn some miss- 
ing letters of this face for the founders. Mrs. Goudy set 
the type for this book as she had for all the other Village 
Press books except the first. By this time she had earned 
a solid reputation for her skill in composition. 

Next summer the entire Goudy family took a trip to 
Europe. Frederic T was eleven years old by this time. 
Holland and Italy were the only countries that they vis- 



ited that Goudy had not seen the year before. Although 
this was purely a pleasure trip, they benefited by what- 
ever of typographic interest they chanced to see. In the 
ancient Louvre, greatest of the palaces of Paris now used 
as a museum, Bertha kept guard while Fred clandestine- 
ly took a rubbing of three Roman stone-cut letters that 
later became the Hadriano alphabet. 

Later in that year an incident occurred that brought 
Goudy international recognition almost overnight. The 
story has been engagingly told by Mitchell Kennerley 
in his Metropolitan Memo: "Late in the winter of 1910 I 
asked Mr. Goudy if he cared to plan for me a volume of 
ten short stories by H.G.Wells. I furnished him with 
a dummy made up by Alvin Langdon Coburn, who 
was to illustrate the work with photographs. Mr. Co- 
burn had already made the photogravure prints, and 
they gave us a key to the siz;e of the volume. Mr. Goudy 
made the layouts for two pages and sent them to Nor- 
man T.A.Munder in Baltimore, asking him to set them 
in 18-point Caslon, 38 ems wide. This would make the 
page siz;e about eleven inches by fifteen inches. 
"The specimen pages set by Mr. Munder were excel- 
lently well done, but a certain feeling of 'openness' in 
their appearance bothered Mr. Goudy. (He did not then 
realise that it was the wide fitting of Caslon that pre- 
vented the solid, even effect he was so intent upon secur- 
ing.) Mr. Goudy explained to me the kind of page he 
would like. He wanted an appearance in the whole page 
0>68<0 






•lepage 






of solidity and compactness, but he wanted it -without 
putting more color in the individual letters than was 
already in the Caslon type shown in the specimens from 
Mr. Munder. Mr. Goudy knew of no type that seemed 
to possess exactly this character— those available were 
either too formal or refined or too free and undignified 
for use in a book of this sort. 

"No other solution of our difficulties being at hand, 
Mr. Goudy suggested the making of a new face which 
might have its first use in this book and which after- 
wards might be offered to other printers for their work. 
We agreed upon this course of adtion, and the drawings 
were begun for the alphabet now known as 'Kennerley 
Old Style.* 

"Mr. Goudy had always been attracted by the type 
imported by Bishop Fell for use by the Clarendon Press 
(Oxford) and from it he took his inspiration for the new- 
letter. As the drawings progressed he soon drew away 
from the pattern letters in an endeavor to modify the old 
form and give it a new expression of beauty and useful- 
ness. The drawings were about one inch high and were 
completed before February 18, 1911. By March 25 the 
type had been cut and cast in the 16-point sizje, and Mrs. 
Goudy began setting trial pages for the book." 

It took Goudy only a week to draw the complete al- 
phabet, lower case and capitals— and the same week he 
completed drawing his Forum Title capitals The cost of 
cutting the Kennerley type was at first a problem, but it 
©>6gr© 






was settled by Goudy paying for the cutting out of the 
weekly fee that Kennerley agreed to pay him against the 
printing. But later when the type -was offered to printers 
it was received with such enthusiasm that the financial 
details worked out with little difficulty Kennerley type 
was to receive great praise at home and abroad, and it 
was the start of a growing fame for the man who at one 
time was granted a grudging success as a sign painter 
and against whom his wife-to-be had been warned as 
one who would never amount to anything. Paul John- 
ston, author of Biblio Typographica has said: "American 
printing, helped by the activities of a group of artists 
located in Boston and New York was now showing 
signs of improvement, most marked in the work of a 
group devoted to the production of 'fine' and 'limited' 
editions. Goudy 's offering of Kennerley to the general 
printer gave much force to the first wedge to break the 
reign of sordidness in general American typography." 
There was no doubt now but that he was a "Type 
Designer." He displayed both Kennerley and Forum 
/ Title in a small magazine format which he called Typo- 
graphica and undertook the sale of his types himself. 
They sold well, but Goudy sometimes despaired when 
he saw how badly they were being used by printers. 
One day a man came to him and said that he had heard 
of Forum Title and wanted to buy some. He picked out 
some fonts which totaled about $25 and for payment he 
drew from his pocket a roll of bills two inches in diam- 
G>>70<© 



of the 


eter. The sale was quite satisfactory, but as the man was 


ist the 


leaving, he handed Goudy his card, printed on a cheap, 


inters 


colored circus bristol combining seven or eight types 


ancial 


in a new bid for the booby pnz,e in typography. Most 


Ptype 


printers thought that in some mysterious way a good 


and it 


type would mean good design no matter how used. 


atone 


With an increase in his business, he moved his office 


ainter 


from his home to a shop on Madison Avenue in Man- 


led as 


hattan -where he printed, designed, and sold his own 


John- 


type. Printers don't sell type, and since he owned the 


srican 


matrices from which the type was cast, he opened an 


artists 


additional department which he called the Village Let- 


wing 


ter Foundry. In 1912 the Foundry issued another Typo- 


kofa 


graphica showing the Goudy Oldstyle and a new sizje 


nited' 


of Kennerley with small caps for the three si^es. Acting 


:neral 


as salesmen for Goudy, the little magazine fulfilled its 


ikthe 


intended purpose and through Mr. Earle, publisher of 


phy." 


the Lotus magazine, who admired and used the Ken- 


Type 


nerley, news of Goudy 's types spread to England. On 


orum 


a trip to England in 19 12 Earle showed one of the Cas- 


Typo- 


lons a copy of something set in Kennerley and this rep- 


nself. 


resentative of the Foundry asked Earle if he thought 


when 


Goudy would sell the English rights to the face. 


titers. 


During the summer of 1913 Goudy and young Fred 


leard 


again took a combined pleasure and business trip to 


dout 


England. They landed at Plymouth and, sending their 


nthe 


luggage on to London, they began walking, carrying 


iiam- 


with them only a haversack holding necessary clothes. 




O>7i<<0 






The first day they made eighteen miles, but they aver- 
aged only ten to twelve miles a day from then on. They 
walked through Salisbury Romsey Christchurch, Ex- 
eter, and other quaint English towns, remaining over- 
night in old inns. As they walked, the father said to the 
son, "Do you see the top of that hill yonder? It's far 
away, but little by little, one step at a time we'll get to 
it. And that is the way with everything in life." Fred 
T. was not convinced. "You can't build a battleship that 
way," he answered. But his father thought differently 
for he stated, "If given enough time, you could." From 
Plymouth they visited beautiful Christchurch, not far 
away, and while the father admired the splendid archi- 
tecture of the old Priory, the son watched a speed boat 
on the river. In London, Goudy met the Caslons who 
advanced him one hundred pounds on account in ex- 
change for the English rights to Forum Title, Kennerley 
and a partly finished text. 

From Brooklyn the family moved to Forest Hills Gar- 
dens on Long Island, where Goudy had bought a plot 
of land on Deepdene Road. Later in a booklet issued by 
the citizens of Forest Hills entitled "Why We Chose 
Forest Hills Gardens for Our Home," with typography 
by the Goudys and printing by D. C. McMurtrie, Fred 
Goudy said that they came there because of "the desire 
to live on a road with individual characteristics, with 
wayside greens and flowers, to have unrestricted view 
of distant country, trees with birds to sing in them, and 






i 



space for our own flowers and garden, fresh air and a 
home— Forest Hills Gardens seemed to offer all these." 
Goudy continued his designing and Village Press activ- 
ities in his Forest Hills home. 

In 1914 he made another trip to England with his 
friend, Clarence Marder, of the American Type Found- 
ers Company, and sold the Caslons the British rights to 
several more of his types. War was about to break and 
the government already had English trade clenched in 
the military vise. Transactions involving the sale of met- 
als -were handled by the government, and in order to 
get his money, Goudy had to go to the War Office with 
a Caslon representative to explain that the money was 
being given for materials purchased before any actual 
demonstration of hostilities. Part of the arrangement had 
been that the Caslons would keep the punches and ma- 
trices from which to cast type for themselves and him, 
but since they were unable to ship any metal out of the 
country, he had to recut a set of matrices for himself. The 
Caslons gave him two duplicate bills of exchange, one 
to carry with him and one to mail, in case any of the ac- 
tive German submarines should take a fancy to his boat. 
By accident both bills went over on the same boat that 
carried Goudy, one in the mail, and the other in Gou- 
dy 's pocket. Goudy, thinking of the money, later said 
that it would have been bad if the boat had been sunk, 
characteristically forgetting that he too had some value. 

With Goudy selling his types to English founders, and 



r 



English authorities praising his work, some American 
foundries also began to notice him. Through Clarence 
Marder , the American Type Founders Company learned 
of Goudy's transactions with the Caslons and he was 
asked to call on the president. As a result of this inter- 
view Goudy designed several faces, the most famous of 
which, his Goudy Oldstyle, became the "parent design' ' 
for the "Goudy Type Family"— most of the "family" 
being drawn by American's designers without Goudy 
knowing about it. Later the American Type Founders 
prosecuted another foundry in Goudy's name for steal- 
ing Goudy's Forum Title. The case was dismissed be- 
cause the defendant proved that Goudy had once stated 
that the Forum was based on an ancient stone-cut letter. 
Types are not nor can they very well be copyrighted, 
and the lack of sympathetic understanding on the part 
of the courts has not made it any easier for designers to 
profit from their efforts. Goudy often suffered because of 
this attitude. 

By 1916 he had issued two more small pamphlets. 
One, A Novel Type Foundry, showing some of his types, 
initial letters, and ornaments; and the third Typographi- 
es showing all the available siz;es of Kennerley. By the 
end of the war, Goudy began to pass on to others his 
working knowledge of letters and letter design, for as 
editor he issued "a miscellany of printing lore in the 
form of a quarterly," called Ars Typographic^. Kenner- 
ley published Goudy's first book, The Alphabet, which 
G>>74<0 



Goudy wrote in his third year as instructor in the New- 
York Art Students' League. 

By this time his types alone were performing mira- 
cles in changing American typography. Peter Beilenson 
summarised clearly the part played by these new types 
when he said: "Goudy. . .was primarily a mellow, 
friendly fellow-human, who had risen from the ranks 
through taste and skill; and what he offered to printers 
was the friendly, mellow beauty of types they could 
appreciate. And appreciate them they did." 

Unfortunately, not all printers were so affected. There 
are many stories like the one of the southern printer 
who was astonished when he found that Goudy was a 
real person (not a mere name) and was responsible for 
more than just Goudy Oldstyle. Furthermore, with the : 
advent of the post-war "modern" style in advertising 
and printing, types from foreign lands seemed more at- 
tractive than the work of American designers, and some 
considered Goudy "old-fashioned." But among those 
men who "kept their heads when all about them were 
losing theirs" there was a place set aside in the -world 
for Fred Goudy which was shared by few men at the 
time and shared by fewer still as time passed. 

The following editorial which appeared in the second 
number of Ars Typographica reveals more of Goudy the 
man, than would the results of a psychologist's person- 
ality test. It was his modesty and charming directness 
that made him such an "unconscious publicist" and in 
G>>75<0 



later years brought to his door an astounding a: 
attention. 

"The editor of Ars Typographica labors under a consid- 
erable disadvantage as he is in no sense a literary per- 
son -with any gift of expression. He is a craftsman and 
designer more interested in his work as a designer of 
types and their use than in mere writing. What writing 
he does is solely with a view to setting down in a def- 
inite form the conclusions of a craftsman in the hope of 
helping some printer who has an imperfect understand- 
ing of the principles underlying design and typography. 

"He does not feel that he is on equal ground with 
the captious critic whose business is -writing, nor will 
he make any attempt to controvert criticism. The editor 
does not doubt that this magazine might be better if 
edited by another hand, but having conceived the idea 
of presenting his thoughts in this form he prefers to do 
so in his own way, hoping to find his account with 
those readers who will look for the wheat in the chaff 
and bear with his idiosyncrasies. As far as possible he 
wishes to please his readers, but on the other hand the 
publisher's announcement clearly outlined what he pro- 
posed to furnish. Up to the present, 'artists, engravers, 
authors, and enthusiastic collectors have monopolized 
the literature of bookmaking.' Will you not allow the 
craftsman his turn and read between the lines if per- 
chance literary expression fails him here and there?" 

Late in 1919, Goudy was in Philadelphia, and the 

0)76 <<o 



I 






of 


president of the Lanston Monotype Machine Company, 




Mr. Dove, told Sol Hess, type designer in the employ of 


id- 


Lanston, that he would like to see Mr. Goudy Hess told 


er- 


Goudy; and in an interview, Mr. Dove offered him a 


nd 


position with the company. Goudy told the Lanston 


of 


president that he would talk it over with his wife. At 


n g 


home the Goudys put their heads together and Goudy 


ef- 


wrote back to Philadelphia suggesting an arrangement 


of 


whereby he would have the title of art director with 


* 


general supervision over matters typographic and was 


W- 


not to be compelled to offer them every face he designed. 


th 


He named a salary, characteristically underestimating his 


ill 


own value, and Mrs. Goudy made him ask for more. 


or 


Lanston accepted, Goudy was called to Philadelphia, 


if 


and contracts were signed to the satisfaction of all the 


ea 


parties concerned. 


io 


The first face that Goudy designed for the Monotype 


th 


Company was an immediate success. In four months 


iff 


over sixty thousand dollars worth were sold in the Unit- 


le 


ed States. The face, Garamont, is a reproduction of an 


le 


alphabet thought to have been drawn by Claude Gara- 




mond. Writing about the face, Goudy has said: "I made 




no attempt to eliminate the mannerisms or deficiencies 


d 


of that famous letter, realising they came not by inten- 


le 


tion but through the punchcutter's handling, his lack 




of tools of precision, crude materials, etc., working by 




eye and not by rule. I did, however, find it impossible 




to eliminate from my drawings the subtle something we 




C>>77<0 



call personality— that something made up of items so in- 
tangible as practically to be imperceptible when indi- 
vidual types are compared yet clearly manifest when the 
page as a whole is viewed— items that are the outcome 
of a mind firmly fixed on the end aimed for and not mere- 
ly an exhibition of his skill as a copyist." 

Goudy closely followed his Garamont success with 
a success in his next type, the Italian Old Style. In ad- 
dition to his duties in type design for the Monotype 
Company, he was often asked by the company to ad- 
dress Craftsmen's Clubs and similar organizations all 
over the country. 

The Goudys had been living in Forest Hills for nine 
years, and during that time the community had been 
growing rapidly. It began to show signs of contractor's 
mass developments. No longer did they have "unre- 
stricted views of distant country." Other things had 
been happening, too. At the age of fifty-seven, Goudy 
had become possessed of the desire to do more than just 
design type. Once it had been the ideal among type de- 
signers that to preserve the personality of their work, 
they must cut the punches by hand. Goudy believed 
that to preserve the personality of his work, he must 
reproduce his drawings more faithfully than they were 
being reproduced at that time, and in order to do this 
he knew that he must master the use of the machines 
for matrix engraving and type casting. He received no 
I encouragement from those with whom he spoke of his 

0*78 <o 



"-I 




Student admirers: Carnegie, February 1958 





«» 






a flH 


■■J 




£ v *J 


# V Jl 


■l .«-'- 




JlfcJ 


-*r 


L 9 






■ > 1 






B^"^ 


i "~'~ 






►' « ** 


H^B'V 




^> 


CBSSW /« 



Approaching a Goudy 'punch-li 




In the Carnegie design studio, February 1938 



new idea, and even Bertha told him that he was not a 
machinist. But he knew that he could do it, so Bertha 
and he began to watch for a combined home and work- 
shop in the country where they could live in peace. By 
this time his Forest Hills plot had appreciated in value 
so that he was able to obtain a tidy profit from its sale. 
In 1922 they were referred to an advertisement of prop- 
erty in New York State just above Newburgh, near 
the Hudson River. It had been owned by Dard Hunter 
who had "erected a replica of a 16th century paper mill 
on the banks of the creek, where he made paper, cut a 
font of type and printed two books by hand." This 
property had sounded attractive but on inspection it 
proved to be not quite what they wanted. The land 
was part of an originally large and historic estate on 
which, before 1790, a sawmill had been eredted. In 
1809 the property adjacent the mill had been adver- 
tised as "23 acres of good land with a handsome grove 
of timber and a young orchard of the best ungrafted 
fruit, a never-failing run or rill of water, and a good 
mill." The trip was an important one for the Goudys 
because through the visit to the Dard Hunter property 
they heard of the property near the mill, an old but 
solid house, and a large barn and carriage house. It was 
precisely what the Goudys were looking for. Spacious 
and quiet, set away from the main highway, beautiful 
grounds and a creek running through the property, ex- 
cellent accommodations for their work— nothing else 






was needed so they sold their Forest Hills property and 
became citizens of the village of Marlborough. 

Later, in an article, Goudy said: "The gathering to- 
gether of the various paraphernalia of typefounding 
was one thing; the operation of engraving machines, 
making patterns to use for cutting matrices with them, 
et cetera, after I had reached sixty years of age,was quite 
another. Looking back now I am amazed at my temeri- 
ty in rushing in where angels might well fear to tread." 
But rush he did, as the steady stream of type faces from 
the new foundry soon attested. It required every talent 
that Goudy possessed to succeed in his new venture. He 
recalled the mechanical proclivities of his youth and his 
later mature directness and ingenuity, and put them to 
■work. The result was a foundry of unconventional ma- 
chinery for the production of type, but one of extreme 
precision and efficiency. He adapted equipment meant 
for other uses or designed entirely new machinery so 
that the new Village Letter Foundry was as uniquely 
individual as any previous Goudy-saturated achieve- 
ment. Within the sixteen years of its activity the foun- 
dry produced about fifty-three new type faces. Mrs. 
Goudy figured in the new enterprise as she did in the 
Village Press. And Frederic T. also worked with them. 
No outsiders were necessary. 

By this time recognition of his work was general. In 

1922 he brought honor to himself and to his craft by 

being awarded the Craftsmanship Gold Medal by the 

0>>82(O 







American Institute of Architects for his "distinguished 
achievements in the art of typography." This was the 
first time that printing had been recognised by archi- 
tecture as a sister art. In 1923 three of his books were 
honored by the annual American Institute of Graphic 
Arts ' 'Fifty Book' ' exhibit, followed by one each in 19 24 
and in 1925. During the first ten years of the exhibit a 
total of fifty books selected were set in Goudy types. 
In 1923 he was invited by the Grolier Club as one of 
"six eminent printers" to make a book for the "print- 
ers series." He was president and later honorary pres- 
ident of the American Institute of Graphic Arts, and 
held honorary memberships in at least seven printing 
clubs or printing societies . His book, Elements of Lettering, 
the logical continuation of his Alphabet, was published. 
It was well received, reaching its third printing when 
Alphabet reached its sixth. 

In 1925 he and William Rudge were appointed by 
President Coolidge to represent the printing industry, 
among notable delegates representing other American 
industries, at the Exposition Internationale desArts Decora- 
tes et Industrials Modernes in Paris. He and Mrs. Goudy 
went together, this making his sixth European trip. The 
Exposition was similar to a world's fair, but it confined 
its interests to commercial and industrial exhibits. The 
delegates were expected to make reports but Goudy and 
Rudge found little of interest to the graphic arts. Rudge 
consented to "cover" the Exposition and the Goudys 
G>>83(0 



made their first airplane trip— to London. The London 
Monotype officials tendered Goudy a dinner, attended 
by many of London's typographic notables. 

The years that followed were comparatively quiet 
ones for the Goudys.They no longer had to open Fred 
Junior's bank for carfare: first because their shop was 
right on the grounds; second because young Fred was 
now married and no longer had a bank; third, and most 
important, because their work was profitable enough 
to satisfy their financial needs. Goudy kept designing 
and producing type. And he also had his grounds to 
look after. He had hired a man who planted corn and 
other vegetables, and his grape and strawberry vines 
supplied all of his friends. 

Paul A. Bennett has said: "To know Goudy is a privi- 
lege that many share. The man is completely democrat- 
ic; has no consciousness of his importance in the graphic 
arts today." Goudy would stop his work to greet any- 
one, and this helped make "Deepdene" a "shrine" to 
which "pilgrims" came in increasing numbers as the 
years progressed. There is a sharp line of distinction 
drawn between those who are interested in the graphic 
arts and those who are not. Among those who are, there 
is a feeling of clannishness that is unique in many of its 
manifestations. One of these manifestations has been a 
growing adoration of this simple, lovable man. 

In a pamphlet entitled The Friendly Goudy s, Sidney S. 
Wheeler tells of a visit to Deepdene that was typical of 



the reception accorded all visitors. On the way to Marl- 
borough Mr. Wheeler relates that he and his compan- 
ion rehearsed what they should say upon arrival, but 
Bertha and Fred Goudy met them at the driveway with 
such warmth that they found little need of formality 
"Mr. Goudy is of vigorous appearance, genial of man- 
ner and wide-smiling in countenance. He displays a 
boyish enthusiasm and 2;est for living which belie the 
evidence of his snowy hair. Mrs. Goudy is a most gifted 
woman , charming and kindly in manner , keen and quick 
in her thoughts, and spontaneous in speech. Her bright 
eyes sparkle with cheer and friendliness." The visitors 
were then taken through the shop. "On the first floor 
of the mill were machines for matrix making and a desk 
full of drawings, manuscripts for books, etc." Then Mr. 
Goudy explained the process of matrix cutting and they 
went through the process, going to each of the three 
floors housing the foundry's machinery. The Goudys in- 
sisted that they stay for supper, and the guests were treat- 
ed to one of Bertha Goudy 's excellent meals and a ses- 
sion with Amos 'n' Andy. Mr. Wheeler told of the dogs 
that followed Goudy everywhere, and Mrs. Goudy 's 
collection of birds in the aviary. In the evening they set- 
tled in Mr. Goudy 's library and talked, the guests listen- 
ing to some of the famous Goudy stories. The Goudys 
insisted that they remain overnight: that they should 
drive home at night was inconceivable. 
Among the numerous commentaries which have been 
0>8 5 <0 



about the man, no one has dared publish a list 
of Goudy's achievements in type design without also 
saying that the list was "complete up to the moment." 
The almost phenomenal productivity of the Village Let- 
ter Foundry was amazing in some respects, and natural 
in others. It was natural because there never before had 
existed a typographic artist who owned and also oper- 
ated the equipment necessary to translate his designs 
into type. No one before in the history of the graphic 
arts had devoted his life solely to that occupation, and 
it may easily be seen how, with the desire to produce 
new types and with excellent equipment on hand to 
produce them, Goudy was tempted to design more and 



In 1929 Goudy made his seventh trip E 
again accompanied by Bertha. In the famous Station- 
ers' Hall, in London, he was given a luncheon by Eng- 
land's outstanding men in the graphic arts. During the 
trip he was again tendered a dinner at the Hotel Savoy. 
When someone asked Goudy if there was anyone he 
would like to invite, he immediately thought of Ed- 
mund Gress (then editor of the American Printer) who 
was passing through on his way from Paris. Fred called 
him and swept aside a "no dress suit" plea and Gress 
promised to come. Goudy arrived at the hotel just in 
time to rescue Gress from the hotel porters who were 
ejecting him because of the lack of formal clothes. The 
Inland Printer article at the time of the Stationers' Hall 
O>86((0 






luncheon stated: "Indicative of the continued recogni- 
tion of his leadership in the art of the alphabet was the 
reception recently tendered our own Frederic Goudy in 
London ... Sir Ernest Benn, who presided, paid a well- 
deserved tribute to Goudy when he introduced him as V 
one of the greatest forces in the new power known as 
advertising, which, he said, owed much to the genius 
of our great designer." 

Mr. Goudy, Bertha, and Bruce Rogers, who also was 
in England at the time, were guests during this trip at 
the homeof Emery Walker. Mr.Walker, a little later Sir 
Emery Walker, was old and somewhat deaf. He wished 
to give Goudy a print of an engraving of "Kelmscott"; 
turning to Rogers, and in a stage whisper which every- 
one in the room could hear, he asked, "What are Mr. 
Goudy 's initials?" During the stay in London Goudy 
also met May Morris, the talented daughter of William 
Morris. 

In 1931, when the Limited Editions Club held an ex- 
hibition of fine books of three continents, the de luxe 
edition of Rip Van Winkle, hand-set by Bertha Goudy in 
Kaatskill, the then newest type design of Fred Goudy, 
was considered one of the finest there. Two years later 
while Mrs. Goudy was in the midst of the setting of 
her largest undertaking, Frankenstein, the Goudys were 
honored by the American Institute of Graphic Arts in 
a celebration of the thirtieth anniversary of the Village 
Press. Meantime individual honors for Fred Goudy had 
0>8y<<0 



come from many sources. From Syracuse University he 
received a medal "symbolic of distinguished achieve- 
ment in one of the branches of journalism." In 1932, 
began the annual Goudy birthday celebrations in which 
men vied with each other to do honor to the "master" 
whom the menu described as "having attained another 
year of work beautifully done, of honor gracefully re- 
ceived, and of life joyously lived." 

It would be difficult to estimate the importance of the 
part that Bertha Goudy played in the life and work of 
her husband. From Fred Goudy himself and the friends 
that knew her we learn that her part was a tremendous 
one. She was the kind of a woman who kept encour- 
aging her husband. When Goudy so often said to her 
what Morris said to Emery Walker, "Let's design an- 
other font of type," her inevitable response would be, 
"Why don't you?" When Goudy wanted to go to Eu- 
rope, she said, "Well, why don't you?" When a guest, 
Robert Ballou, said that it would be nice to sleep under 
the stars at Deepdene she said, "I'll get you a mattress." 
Food becoming scarce in the early, difficult years was 
not a matter of a husband failing to bring money from 
the outside to his wife in the kitchen; rather it was a 
matter of husband and wife failing together in their 
work because of an ideal that was, perhaps, not under- 
stood by people other than themselves. 

In December of 1933, Bertha Goudy was stricken ill 
at the Grand Central Station and was not entirely well 



for two years. On Sunday, October 20, Paul Bennett, 
friend and associate of the Goudys, was a guest at their 
home. In an article written later for the Publisher's Weekly 
Mr. Bennett stated that: "Mrs. Goudy. . .had seemed 
brighter, more cheerful, than at any time since her ill- 
ness. We joked at dinner over her gaining four pounds 
the previous week, and hoped her valiant fight toward 
recovery was to progress in similarly rapid fashion the 
coming months." 

Speaking at the celebration of the thirtieth anniver- 
sary of the Village Press two years before, Goudy had 
told his friends something they already knew: the meas- 
ure of his obligation to his wife. "Bertha has aided and 
encouraged me with constant devotion for over thirty- 
five years, and without her help I should not have ac- 
complished a tithe of what I have been privileged to 
perform. She has been the staff that I have leaned upon 
so many times, the courageous partner who smiled and 
gritted her teeth when we had no funds, who renewed 
my faith and revived my spirits when they sagged so 
often. In many of the activities of the Press her work 
ranks in aclual accomplishment above my own. I could 
not, probably would not, have attempted the details of 
type composition forwhich she is, in fad:, celebrated." 

Later, Earl Emmons, a close friend of the Goudy fam- 
ily said: "Her achievements were of practical beauty; 
her art was masterly, her principles sound, and the 
things she did will live as long as printed words are 
0>8c;<0 



revered on this earth. Her life of great labor was like- 
wise of great achievement ... her beautiful spirit, her 
fine energy and her great genius will ever be an inspi- 

Mr. Emmons spoke in the past tense because Bertha 
Goudy died early in the morning of October 2 1, a few 
hours after Paul Bennett had left Deepdene confident 
that she -would regain her health. 

If you could walk down the path at Deepdene next to 
the brook today, and pass the site where once the old 
mill stood and Fred, Bertha, and Fred Junior worked 
together, and if you could get by the friendly overtures 
of Alice Goudy 's great Dane, Eric, without bringing 
Mr. Goudy to the door to meet you, you would prob- 
ably find him working at his littered desk in the new 
studio addition to his home, completing a new book 
which he thinks he will call lypologia or working on 
his 111th type face. 

He is working in a new studio because on a frosty 
morning in January of 1939 his mill— containing his 
machinery, his matrices, his press, and many priceless 
drawings— completely burned, and settled in the mill 
stream, ironically leaving intact only an unused brick 
vault which had been built to protect many of the things 
that had been destroyed. A great many people in Amer- 
ica heard of Goudy for the first time in a dramatized 
version of the fire, and newspapers all over the country 
carried stories that told of his son waking at 4:30 a.m. 
C>>90,0 






a frosty 



suggesting that Goudy look out the window. They re- 
lated that when he saw flames shoot out from the west 
end of his workshop, he -was so stunned that he tried to 
draw his stockings over his shoes. Nothing could be 
done to save the mill. Water fro^e as it hit the stru&ure, 
and for the second time he was forced to stand by and 
watch fire ruthlessly destroy the products of his labor. 

"A body blow," he said at the time. 

"Rebuild the shop? It would be sort of foolish. I will 
just have to sit back and let the world go, until some 
day a better designer comes along or printing from type 
becomes non-existent." 

"I do not see much of anything I can do unless some 
one is foolish enough to commission a new type." 

In the summer of 1939, at the time that the new stu- 
dio was completed, a 10x15 Golding Press was being 
moved into one of the rooms of the large barn and car- 
riage house at the side of the Goudy home. Mr. Goudy 
bought a portable typewriter which he intended to learn 
how to use. He was busy with designing and busy with 
his new book; the site of the wrecked mill had been 
cleared and only the scarred trees around the mill bore 
outward witness to the fire. Visitors to Deepdene could 
find no evidence of a "fatal blow" in Mr. Goudy 's in- 
terests or disposition. Instead there was even a certain 
optimism, for now he had time to finish his Typologia. 
And yet there even were some "people foolish enough 
to commission a new type." Goudy is doing no "sitting 



back"or "waiting for a better designer to come along." 
He may find time now, he says, to complete his auto- 
biography, begun some years ago. 

In one of his novels Thornton Wilder has said: "The 
public for which masterpieces are intended is not on 
this earth." But Goudy's masterpieces are decidedly in- 
tended for the public which is on this earth, and if his 
work has not received overwhelming support from all 
American printers, its merit is at least recognised by 
those people who appreciate the subtle difficulties of 
his art and his consistent triumphs over them. Many of 
his best types are not widely circulated. This is partly 
Goudy's fault and partly the fault of those who buy 
and use types. Mr. Goudy has never attempted to ex- 
ploit his types by the commercial methods used by 
American and foreign foundries. He has not dangled 
his types and the names of his types under the noses of 
printers, nor has he sent out hordes of salesmen to "stir 
up the bush." Some of his best types are exclusives 
and printers could not buy them at any price. The ma- 
trices of some were destoyed in the 1939 fire, and no 
attempt has been made to restore them. A few have 
been salvaged from the fire but probably not enough 
to make up any complete fonts. There has been little 
demand to have them recut. 

About two years ago, Mr. Goudy was asked to speak 

at an American Institute of Graphic Arts exhibit of the 

"Fifty Books." He refused, but said that he would like 

G>>92<0 






to ask a question. He wanted to know if anyone present 
could conceive of a German exhibit of the best fifty 
books of the year in which forty-seven out of the fifty 
books were set in American types. At that exhibit for- 
ty-seven books were set in foreign types, predominant- 
ly German. Some of the people present thought he was 
making political references, but Mr. Goudy was think- 
ing of the plaint that had been his for so long, which 
he summarised when he once remarked: "I've probably 
gotten more praise during my lifetime than any other 
type designer. But the trouble is you can't take it to the 
bank and draw on it. Here I've given forty years of my 
life to the service of printing, but at a time when I need 
the help of the printers, they fail me. Instead of using 
native type, they import it from Germany. How can 
you establish an American school of type design unless 
you give American designers a chance to live? I'd have 
starved if I had been forced to depend on the printers 
of the United States." 

Mr. Goudy has certainly lost nothing by lack of for- 
mal college training. His writing is excellent despite 
the fact that he himself thinks little of lt.When he pens 
his theories of design or type arrangement, his pithy, 
well-planned statements show a keen mind. His Eve- 
ning at Deepdene, a sentimentalised description of his es- 
tate, is worthy of W. H. Hudson. Goudy has even tried 
fiction in The City of Crafts, a fantasy; and has written 
numerous small bits and essays, like The Type Speaks, To 
0^93(0 



-7— 



Squeeze or Not to Squeez,e,TypeDesign: Past and Present, and 
similar works. 

In June of 1939, Syracuse University conferred the 
honorary degree of "Dodtor of More Humane Letters," 
an honor for which Goudy had long hoped, with the 
belief that his hopes would never be realised. At the 
presentation ceremony he felt regret only for Bertha's 
absence. 

For years his husky voice and his capable pen have 
been carrying on a one-man campaign for simplicity 
and intelligence in the design and use of type. Head- 
lines in newspapers and trade magazines have carried 
the following and similar headlines: "Goudy, Design- 
er of Type, Decries Modernism,' ' "The Tendency Away 
From Simplicity and Beauty Is Deplored," "Frederic 
Goudy Urges Simple Type,' ' ' 'Fancy Typography Is Im- 
pertinent." His plea is that of a calm, intelligent schol- 
ar, despite the fact that his remarks often look bombas- 
tic in print. These arrows he has often shot from his 
well-stocked supply: "Modernism is the wrong use of 
good materials." "When the typography develops in- 
terest and pleasure for itself alone and draws to itself 
the attention that belongs to the author's words, it be- 
comes typographic impertinence.' ' ' 'Bad printing in the 
past was due largely to bad types; today both to bad 
types and the bad use of good types." He has never 
retreated or wavered since he announced to the world 
in 1895 d 1 ^ he was going to become the proponent of 
©>94<0 



a style which "cannot be assailed." He still cries out as 
hedid in 1895 that "Bizarre effedts may have their place 
—few know the place.' ' 

People have always expressed the same curiosity about 
Mr. Goudy's creative secrets as they express about those 
of any artist. The curious expedt an almost metaphysi- 
cal explanation, a "burning light" of some kind that leads 
the artist to make superhuman efforts . When the old mill 
foundry was adtive, Frederic Goudy's customary half- 
humorous, half-modest explanation was that he merely 
had the ideas, a pair of hands, some machinery, and put 
them all to work. But in the design of type, as in any art, 
there is more involved. Goudy has found in type design 
as others have discovered in the writing of prose, poetry, 
or music, or in the painting of a piclure, that there is a 
co-ordination of parts, a pull toward the finale. Just as 
in music where the whole completes itself in temporal 
expectation so in letter design does the whole complete 
itself in spatial expectation. In music one tone pulls to- 
ward its successor; in type design, one stroke or move- 
ment leads to the next. Goudy has found that in order to 
design an integrated alphabet in which each letter has a 
mutual affinity for its companions, he must get in on the 
beginning of a swing or a visual or kinesthetic "set." 
This may occur as a result of observation of other let- 
ters or it may be initiated by such an unrelated experi- 
ence as a ride on a trolley car. When he has been inactive 
for any considerable time, he finds that it becomes diffi- 
©>95<° 



cult to lay the basis for this "set" toward c 

Type is meant to be seen as a whole, and unless the 
design is defective only conscious analysis should re- 
veal the parts. This has been expressed in psychologi- 
cal literature in the following terms, "The part-whole 
relationship of an integration lies in the fad: that the prop- 
erty of the whole is so different from the properties of 
each of its ingredients that it can be determined only 
by forming the integration itself, and the slightest mod- 
ification of any one of the parts will produce a radical 
change in the quality of the whole. A bit of salt added 
to a plate of soup may not change its taste sufficiently to 
become noticeable, but the taste has nevertheless been 
destroyed." Goudy himself found empircially that this 
was an essential quality that his types must possess, and 
he once wrote: "I think of design as the inventive ar- 
rangement of abstract lines and masses in such relation 
to each other that they form a harmonious whole to 
which each separate part contributes, but in such com- 
bination with every other part that the result is a unity 
of effed: which satisfies the artistic sense." And his types 
prove that his knowledge of this idea is more than the- 
oretical, as is his knowledge of every problem in type 
design. There is nothing theoretical either about him 
or his work. He has aptly said that he "debunked the 
type-founding mystery." 

His work is distinctive because it is inseparable from 
his personality. It is more than merely a "style;" there 






is something deliberately Goudy about it. His foundry 
was born because he was not content just to design 
types . He insisted that they lose none of their individual 
characteristics in being unsympathetically handled by 
strange workmen. So he cut the matrices and cast the 
type himself. It doesn't end there.Hiswriting,especially 
samples like that above in which he reveals that he dis- 
covered empirically what psychologists have found only 
through experiments, shows that like his old Shelby 
ville friend, Frank Broyles, he has an intuitive grasp 
of the subjedt under analysis. The entire history of his 
mid- western boyhood, and the obviously random train- 
ing that he received, coupled with natural artistic abil- 
ity equipped him for success in the vocation into which 
he drifted. His direcl manner, his faithfulness to princi- 
ple, his stubborn individualism, are as true of his work 
as they are of his life, since his work is his life, and his 
life his work. And it is here that Frederic Goudy is in- 
teresting and outstanding. For in a world where tech- 
nology so often smothers the individual, his individ- 
ualism has triumphed. 

Fame is strange and fickle. Goudy has been hailed a 
genius, and yet there are people who have never heard 
of him. Nevertheless, stories like this one are gratifying. 
The Princess Veronica Emoukhvari, of Santa Cruz,, Cali- 
fornia, an American woman who married a Russian no- 
bleman, knows Goudy well, and tells the story of a little 
twelve-year old boy, the son of a neighbor, who owns 
C>>99 (O 



a small printing press. The boy showed her some speci- 
mens of his work and she told him that she knew a print- 
er back East. He thought that was very nice. Then she 
said that he was also a type designer. The boy inquired 
■who it might be. When the Princess replied, "Goudy," 
the boy brightened and asked, "Do you mean Frederic 
Goudy?" The Princess reports that from that day on 
the little printer followed her around like a pet dog. 
Her title had not impressed him one bit, but the fa<5t 
that she knew Fred Goudy made her a person of great 
importance. 

In his fantasy, The City of Crafts, Frederic Goudy says 
that it is "a city peopled only by workers in the art pre- 
servative of all arts, and toward which place journey 
all -who excel in good work.' ' There is a discussion in the 
City by men who bear the names of the world's great- 
est printers. "Not, indeed, every printer's name, but only 
the ones who had been judged worthy of the honor: As 
often as one among the earthly craftsmen is found to ex- 
cel above others the Court is convened." At the end of 
the fantasy the "names of Rudge, Munder, and March- 
banks were ordered set down in the books by the Court." 
But where is the name of Frederic W. Goudy? 
We forgot; he wrote the story. 



THE ETHICS AND AESTHETICS OF TYPE 
AND TYPOGRAPHY 







THE ETHI 






Anac 
Tech 






TAST FALL W 

jL me to be 






accepted glac 






iz;e that throu 




1 


depth, the we 






run dry, and 




J 


am able to br 






I also seem to 






But having 






together some 






I hoped to pr 




. 


ble, and the c 




mind. At this 






to me the sul 






this phrase an 






By this time, 






like the youn 






wedding cak 






might dream 




1 


• 













THE ETHICS AND AESTHETICS OF TYPE 

AND TYPOGRAPHY 

An address delivered at Carnegie Institute of 

Technology, Pittsburgh, February 12, 1938 

by Frederic W. Goudy 



IAST FALL WHEN PROFESSOR GLEN U. CLEETON invited 
-/ me to be one of the speakers at this Celebration, I 
accepted gladly, but I fear not wisely. I did not then real- 
ise that through the steady drafts upon its not' too great 
depth, the well of my typographic thought had so near 
run dry, and it is only by considerable priming that I 
am able to bring up any fresh wisdom, and worse yet, 
I also seem to be running out of priming material. 

But having promised, I set about the work of getting 
together some odds and ends of typographic lore which 
I hoped to present in as interesting a manner as possi- 
ble, and the question of a title for my talk came into my 
mind. At this time, Professor Cleeton had not suggested 
to me the subject printed in your programs, so I tried 
this phrase and that without finding one that pleased me. 
By this time, after discarding a number, I began to feel 
like the young woman who had been given a piece of 
wedding cake to place under her pillow so that she 
might dream of her future fiance. The next day when 
O>io 3 ,© 



she was asked of whom she had dreamed, she replied, 
' 'What do you think: I dreamed of the 6gth regiment.' ' 
For more than twenty-five years, I have preached the 
gospel of simplicity, of dignity, of legibility, of beauty 
in type and typography, and only now am I beginning 
to feel that my words— so freely dispensed through the 
years, those arrows of typographic thought shot into the 
air— have not all fallen to earth entirely unnoticed nor 
completely disregarded. 

I am glad to be here at this celebration of the silver 
jubilee of the Department of Printing. I have watched 
the growth and work of the department and have re- 
ceived with interest many of the items produced by the 
students. Myself denied the opportunity for collegiate 
or university training, I consider it a great honor to be 
asked to speak before the officials, the students, and the 
alumni of this institution. I do not consider myself a 
printer, nor even a typographer, although occasionally 
I do print; but I have studied assiduously the work of 
the great printers and of the great type designers of the 
past. I have studied them that I might pursue my own 
work intelligently inasmuch as I am no heaven-born 
genius. Yet even a great genius does not trust entirely to 
the resources of his own mind. Just as a great composer 
borrows another's theme only to make it his own by 
the originality of the setting, so the great designer ran- 
sacks a thousand minds, and uses the findings and wis- 
dom of the ages to amplify and extend the boundaries 
C>> 104 <© 



of his own mental and artistic limitations. The genius 
who wisely recogniz.es precedent does not find that it 
is necessary to imitate his exemplars slavishly; he stud- 
ies their achievements that he may add to his own store 
of ideas, and he draws with independence from the most 
varied sources. 

No art, no great printing, nor any great type ever de- 
veloped by the rejection of the canons of good design 
found in the work of preceding generations. Style, dis- 
tinction, and originality have grown invariably out of 
a preceding style, not merely by taking thought, but by 
gradual modification of the older work to meet changed 
conditions of a later time-the new work hardly betray- 
ing its origin. 

A little more than fifty years ago William Blades, an 
English printer and writer on typographical history 
-an authority, too, on the life and work of William 
Caxton-wrote a book entitled The Pentateuch of Print- 
tng. The title seems somewhat fanciful, yet there is, after 
all, an analogy between the Genesis of the World and 
the genesis of printing. The spread of printing is not in- 
aptly typified by Exodus; the laws set out in Leviticus 
have a parallel in the laws and principles that govern 
book-making; Numbers suggest the great names on the 
Printer's Roll of Honor; and Deuteronomy may signify 
the second birth of the vital conditions introduced into 
printing by more highly improved appliances. For my- 
self, I do not wish you to imagine that I am attempting 
C>> 105^0 



to preach to you, but if this paper were intended as an 
homily I might selecT: as my text a portion of a passage 
from St. Paul's letter to the Philippians-"whatsoever 
things are true; whatsoever things are honest, whatso- 
ever things are just, whatsoever things are pure, what- 
soever things are lovely, whatsoever things are of good 
report, if there be any virtue and if there be any praise, 
think on these things.' ' I draw your attention more espe- 
cially to that portion of my text which refers to things 
"honest" and "lovely" and will speak of the ethics and 
aesthetics of types and typography, with little refer- 
ence to the historical side. And now, having announced 
my text, we need not refer to it again. 

First, as some of you know already, I am a designer 
of types. Now type design is a minor art, if it can be 
called an art at all. One thing, however, is certain; good 
type design may be practiced only by an artist with pe- 
culiar capabilities. One of the most essential of these is 
the ability to discover beauty in abstract forms (forms 
on which he lavishes his art), the shapes that have de- 
veloped from the hieroglyphs of ancient Egypt to the 
work of the Carolingian scribes which now constitute 
the medium of communication. They recall to us the 
wisdom of the past and preserve the knowledge of to- 
day for future generations.The shapes we call letters are 
now classic, and we may not tamper with their essen- 
tial forms unduly, lest we compel readers to acquaint 
themselves with a new literary currency. The letter- 



norm, that is, the mere letter stripped of everything ex- 
cept its primitive and essential corpus, we may— if we 
have taste, culture, and feeling— clothe and make more 
modest and presentable, yet not necessarily more useful, 
but better suited to the thought it is to convey. But alas: 
letter-norms may be badly clothed, and by that I mean 
the clothing that gives us the tawdry, the bizarre, the 
fanciful atrocities— I had almost said "monstrosities" 
—so often seen; their use disturbs my sense of fitness 
and actually decreases their usefulness in my eyes. 

The types intended for fine printing, in the main, are 
not different in form from those intended specifically 
for commerce; the difference lies more in the handling 
of them, and the commercial printer will do well to 
avoid any effort toward pseudo-aestheticism. He should 
attempt, rather, to present printing with its own proper 
goodness for the purposes intended, studiously plain 
and starkly efficient. Printing for commerce, to be good, 
requires types and the handling of them to be free from 
studied exuberance and fancy. Too often, types, good 
enough for certain uses, are employed in the attempt 
to produce a piece of work really better than the ex- 
igencies demand— that is, to attempt to give to adver- 
tising or mere commercialism the manner and aspecfl of 
a fine book. Understand me, I am not intending to de- 
cry or belittle the importance of printing for commerce, 
but the printing of an advertisement or even a simple 
narrative should no more be given the form or treat- 
ed 107,© 



ment of an epic poem or dignified essay than a farm 
house should be built to look like a city mansion, or a 
cottage be given the air and character of an ornate vil- 
la. When printing for industry is too elaborate or too 
fanciful the more inexcusable it becomes, the greater is 
its vulgarity of display, and its impertinent indecency 
I find almost nauseating. 

There was a time in the golden age of type design 
when a page decoration, a head-piece, a fleuron, a new 
type face might have proved a key to typographic dis- 
tinction because it was recognised as the work of a mas- 
ter and respected accordingly. But by this I do not in- 
tend to imply that deference must necessarily be given 
to old types or old work of little merit merely because 
they are old. Many, unfortunately, possess shortcom- 
ings even as those of later vintage. Yet even the best of 
the old types should not be revived, imitated, adapted, 
reproduced, or copied for present day use with camera- 
like fidelity— prima facie evidence of modern poverty 
of invention (or artistic or mental laziness). The orig- 
inals had matchless charm because they were stamped 
with the personality of their makers. The reproductions 
invariably lack the spirit of idealism of the originators 
and cannot fail to betray the fact that the faker can never 
do entire justice to the distinctive qualities that made 
the original designs great. 

My own feeling in regard to this endless reviving of 

old type is the same feeling I have toward dead and liv- 

Q> 108^0 



ing literatun 
ergy that is i 



progress ai 



i, or a 

revil- 



ing literature; the new never transcends itself and is al- 
ways imitative, never moving with the spontaneous en- 
ergy that is indicative of freshness and originality. 

Professor Cleeton suggested a topic for my remarks. 
I imagine he had something in mind which I have not 
touched upon; he probably wished me to speak of the 
progress and development or improvement in type de- 
sign that may have taken place in the past quarter cen- 
tury I have chosen, rather, to ignore his suggestion and 
speak generally of past work and more specifically of 
my own conclusions as to types and typography. Yet, 
to be frank, I cannot honestly say that for me the years 
since 1913 have brought forth many outstanding types 
by American designers. It has been largely our German 
contemporaries who have produced the bulk of orig- 
inal type work, and it is a lamentable fact that for the 
past ten years foreign importations have almost driven 
our own productions into the limbo of the forgotten. 

Printers, and especially users of advertising, have not 
been kind nor even fair to native talent; they have in- 
sisted on the importations of foreign types to gain the 
elusive touch of novelty. What incentive is there for the 
young designer to enter the lists if his efforts are sure 
to receive little or no encouragement in America? As I 
have frequently maintained it is much easier to design 
a type than it is to sell it and, thereby, put it to use. 

The inexperienced designer says to himself, "I will 

design a new type.' ' He does not as yet realise that who- 

Q>> 109 <<D 



ever imagines a tree must also imagine a sky or a back- 
ground against which to see it standing. He cannot im- 
agine a type unless he imagines also its destination. He 
must have visions whose power is his power. He must 
deal with what is logical as if it were a miracle; yet, as 
a matter of fact, what he is attempting to produce is 
something which should long have been in his mind, 
perhaps without his being conscious of the fact, and 
from what he has studied and arranged he has now 
only to read and project what already is there. 

And now I will say a few words about fine printing 
in its relation to fine literature. Fine literature, being 
permanent, demands a dignified and beautiful typo- 
graphical setting, a setting that will preserve the au- 
thor's words in monumental form suited to their worth. 
Printing may be adequate and entirely satisfactory for 
commercial necessities; yet, even that printing on which 
the craftsman has exercised more than usual thought 
and care for technical requirements, or upon which 
more elaborate details have been lavished, may, after 
all, be merely good printing. Fine printing requires 
even more than the points I mention; for it, type, dec- 
oration, proportion appropriate to the subject treated, 
its destination, and its purpose should receive equally 
the craftsman's most scrupulous and fastidious atten- 
tion. Where the types are correctly chosen and their 
arrangement good; the capitals harmonious and suited 
to the type and the text; the paper pleasing to the eye 
C>> nofO 



in tone, pliable to the hand, its surface kind to the types 
and unobtrusive as to wire-marks; and the presswork 
admirable— in that printing, the result may be altogether 
charming and yet not fine, in the sense that a work of art 
is fine. / 

Print, to be fine and not merely charming, must in- 
clude a beauty of proportion. Therein, the trained taste 
finds ever an appeal to delight; a beauty of form and 
rhythm in consonance, showing the control of the crafts- 
man over every detail of the work; and a well-propor- 
tioned leaf whereon type has been handsomely placed, 
the lines well-spaced, the decorations harmonious (no 
detail pretending or seeming to be more important than 
the thing adorned), of like origin with the types, cut 
with like tools, and with similar strokes. Fine print- 
ing, too, is simple in arrangement, but is not the sim- 
plicity gained by pretending simplicity; it is the result 
of simple thinking. The work must be fundamentally 
beautiful by force of the typography itself, its beauty 
organic and a development of its construction. It must 
be done on a fine type, and must have style— the living 
expression controlling both the form and structure of the 
vehicle which reveals and preserves the author's words. 
Printing becomes only then an art and a means to high- 
er aims and higher ideals. 

I have spoken of a fine type in the foregoing. Summing 
up, I am tempted to repeat what I have so often said 
about the type I regard as"fine."Type,tobefine,mustbe 



legible, not merely readable, but pleasantly and easily 
legible; decorative in form, but not ornate; beautiful in 
itself and in company of its kinsmen in the font; austere 
and formal, but with no stale or uninteresting regularity 
in its dissimilar characters; simple in design, but not the 
bastard simplicity that arises from mere crudity of out- 
line; elegant, that is, gracious in line; fluid in form, but 
not archaic; and, most important, it must possess unmis- 
takably that quality called "art," which is the spirit the 
designer puts into the body of his work, the product of 
his study and taste. How many of the types demanded by 
advertisers or the typographic advisers would be able to 
stand analysis of this sort? 

And speaking of legibility, I am reminded of a proof- 
reader on the Tribune who is reported to have said of 
the illegible handwriting of Horace Greeley, ' 'If Greeley 
had written that dread inscription on the Babylonian 
palace wall, Belshaz^ar, himself, would have been more 
frightened than the Bible account says he was." I hope 
somewhere in these rambling remarks will be found 
here and there grains of real thought among the chaff, 
and that what I have said may not fall entirely on deaf 
ears. I realise that I have little facility of expression, 
yet my words are not those of an aesthetic theorist; 
they are the conclusions of a practical craftsman— prac- 
tical in the sense that with my own hands, from blank 
paper to the printed page I perform every detail of my 
work, and the principles presented here are those that 



guide me in my work. I endeavor by precept and ex- 
ample to bring about a greater public interest in good 
typography, to arouse a more general esteem for better 
types, and I have never intentionally permitted myself 
to utilise the message I was attempting to present to 
serve as a mere framework upon which to exploit my 
own handicraft, nor ever to allow my craft to become 
an end in itself instead of a means to a desirable and 
useful end. 

I have been too long winded, I fear. I remember hear- 
ing of a lawyer arguing a case in Superior Court. He 
noticed that the judge was rather inattentive and he 
caught a suggestion of a yawn. Rather sarcastically he 
remarked, "I hope I am not trespassing unduly on the 
time of this Court." 

"There is some difference," His Honor replied, "be- 
tween trespassing on time and encroaching on eternity' ' 
A man was asked to make an address, something he 
had never done before. When he wrote out what he 
wanted to say he couldn't seem to make a satisfactory 
ending, so he asked a friend accustomed to giving talks 
how to end his speech. His friend said, when he had 
reached a place where everything had gone off well and 
his audience was still interested, that was a good place 

to stop, but if he reached a point where he sensed the 

audience wasn't with him and he wasn't doing so 

well, that was a damned good place to stop. 

I seem to have reached that point. 



This volume was produced as a student project in the 1540-41 
class in Printing Production of the Department of Printing at 
Carnegie Institute of Technology. Student assignments were as 
follows: machine composition, Walter Pretz,at, Lip King Wong, 
and Bernard Lewis; hand composition, makeup, and lock-up, 
Walter Pretz,at, Donald H. Opel, and Kenneth M. Macrorie; 
proofreading, Howard N.Keefe;presswork,John S.Anderson 
and Donald H. Opel; correcting original galleys, Irwin Copier. 
Supervision assignments: typography and production, Charles 
W. Pitkin; Monotype composition, Stanley Hlasta; illustrations 
and binding, Homer E. Sterling; presswork, Kenneth R. Bur- 
chard; proofreading, Glen U.Cleeton.The illustrations in collo- 
type were printed by the Fredrick Photogelatine Press of New 
York City. The Russell-Rutter Company of New York bound 
the book. Six hundred copies were distributed as keepsakes by 
the American Institute of Graphic Arts, and one thousand 
copies were issued to individual subscribers by the Carne- 
gie Department of Printing. Monotype Goudy Village 
410 was used for text pages. The paper used both 
for illustrations and type pages was Worthy 
Sterling Laid; printed on a Miller 
Simplex Press. 



■■& m the 1940-41 
H 0/ Printing at 
ignments were as 
, Lip King Wong, 
i'up, and lock-up, 
eth M. Uacrorie; 
'ohn S.Anderson 
eys, Irwin Copier, 
idudion, Charles 
asta; illustrations 
Kenneth R. Bur- 
titrations in colic 
:inePressofNew 
Sew York bound 
I as keepsakes by 
id one thousand 
> by the Came- 
ioudy Village 
r used both 
Worthy 
Her 



- flRSJ StMtSftrN 

- SECOND SEMESTER 

- Summer semester 

521S1U08 OO'l 



liil