Full text of "Aristotelis opera"

3 jm 




v 




ARISTOTELES 

f 

GRAECE 



EX RECENSIONE 

IMMANUELIS BERRERI. 



EDIDIT 



AGADEMIA REGIA BORUSSICA. 



VOLUMEN PRIUS. 



BEROLINI 

APUD GEORGIUM REIMERUM 
. A. 1831. 



KX OFFICINA ACADEMICA. 






gf.S/f 



PRAEFATIO. 



A, 



cademia Berolinensis cum Friderico Schleiermachero auctore consilium ce- 
pisset Aristotelis ex diutino situ excitandi novaque editione celebrandi, opefae 
pretium se non facturam videbat, nisi plures quam adhuc manassent et uberiores 
lectionis Aristotelicae fontes aperiret; quin perquirendas esse quotquot paterent 
bibliothecas, eruendumque si quid in libris manuscriptis rei bene gerendae utile 
aetatem tulisset. id quibus datum est negotium, Immanuel Bekkerus et CHRISTIA- 
nus Augustus Brandis in perlustrandis Italiae Galliae Britanniae copiis litterariis 
plus quam triennium consumpserunt, multam illi quidem multorum experti bene- 
volentiam, sed a nemine aut amantius aut utilius quam a jSiebuhrio adiuti. iidem 
reduces, quod supererat operae, ita inter se partiti sunt ut alter opes criticas ad 
emendandum scriptorem conferret, alter, quae ad recte intelligendum facerent, ex 
commentariis Graecis cum editis tum etiam ineditis excerperet. prodit iam pars 
a Bekkero accurata: subsequetur scboliorum volumen. de codicibus autem donec 
commodiore loco pluribus verbis exponatur, eorum qui textui conformando inser- 
vierunt infra positae sunt notae. 

A. codex Urbinas 35. 

B. Marcianus 201. 

C. Coislinianus 330. 

D. Coislinianus 170. 

E. Parisiensis Regius 1853. 

F. Laurentianus 87 7. 
Q. Laurentianus 87 6. 
H. Vaticanus 1027. 



IV 



/. Vaticanus 241. 
K. Laurentianus 87 24. 
L. Vaticanus 253. 
M. Urbinas 37. 
N. Vaticanus 258. 
O. Vaticanus 316. 
P. Vaticanus 1339. 
Q. Marcianus 200. 
R. Parisiensis 1102. 
S. Laurentianus 81 1. 
T. Vaticanus 256. 
U. Vaticanus 260. 
V. Vaticanus 266. 
W. Vaticanus 1026. 
X. Ambrosianus H 50. 
Y. Vaticanus 261. 

Z. Oxoniensis collegii corporis Christi W. A. 2 7. 
A a . Marcianus 208. 
B a . Palatinus Vaticanus 162. 
C a . Laurentianus 87 4. 
D*. Vaticanus 262. 
E a . Vaticanus 506. 
F a . Marcianus 20 7. 
G a . Marcianus 212. 
H a . Marcianus 214. 
I a . Laurentianus 57 33. 
K a . Marcianus append. 4 58. 
L a . Marcianus 263. 
M a . Coislinianus 173. 
JV d . Marcianus 215. 
O". Marcianus 216. 
P a . Parisiensis 2069. 
Q a . Urbinas 38. 
R a . Vaticanus 1302. 
S a . Laurentianus 60 19. 
T a . Laurentianus 86 3. 
XJ a . Ottobonianus 45. 
V a . Urbinas 108. 
W*. Urbinas 44. 



X*. Vaticanus 1283. 

Y a . Parisiensis 2036. 

Z a . Laurentianus 87 21. 

A h . Laurentianus 87 12. 

B h . Laurentianus 87 18. 

C h . Laurentianus 87 26. 

D h . Ambrosianus F 113. 

E b . Marcianus 211. 

F h . Parisiensis 1876. 

G h . Parisiensis 1896. 

H h . Parisiensis 1901. 

l h . Coislinianus 161. 

K h . Laurentianus 81 11. 

L b . Parisiensis 1854. 

M h . Marcianus 213. 

iV*. Marcianus append. 4 53. 

O h . Riccardianus. 

P h . Vaticanus 1342. 

Q h Laurentianus 81 5. 

R h . Laurentianus 81 6. 

S h . Laurentianus 81 21. 

T h . Urbinas 46. 

XJ h . Marcianus append. 4 3. 

V h . Palatinus 160. 

TV h . Christinae reginae 125. 

X h . Vaticanus 342. 

Y b . Vaticanus 1340. 

Z b . Palatinus 23. 

A e . Parisiensis 1741. 

B e . Urbinas 47. 

a. Vaticanus 251. 

b. Parisiensis 1859. 

c. Parisiensis 1861. 

d. Vaticanus 250. 

e. Vaticanus 1025. 
/. Marcianus 206. 

g. Ottobonianus 152. 

h. Baroccianus 79. 

/". Parisiensis 2032. 



VI 



k. Vaticanus 499. 

/. Parisiensis 1860. 

m. Parisiensis 1921. 

n. Urbinas 39. 

o. Coislinianus 166. 

p. Coislinianus 323. 

cj. Urbinas 76. 

/*. Urbinas 50. 

s. Palatinus 164. 

t. Palatinus 295. 

u. Christinae reginae 124. 

i>. Laurentianus 87 20. 

w. Laurentianus 87 15. 

x. Marcianus 259. 



y- 



Parisiensis 2277. 







API2TOTEAOT2 



• 



7r*pi ki<r8rjreu<; v.ax xltrS^Tui . . . pag. 436 

7T£pt ' kxOVq-UI - 800 

'kva.hvuy.ix. xpoTepa, - 24 

VqepO, - 71 

xep\ ' ' kia.xioi\s — 470 

xep\ ' kpeTui x«u xttxtui .... - 1249 

•xepi ' kToiiui «jpa,p.jjLui -968 

xep\ Teieveus ko,\ tpQop&t; - 3l4 

■xep\ 'ErvTrriui — 45 S 

xep\ 'Epfj.qieia.<; - 16 

xep\ Zurjs x*t 8o.ioLtov - 467 

7tep\ ra, Zifia, iqoptxi — 486 

7tep\ TLuui *fei(<reut - 715 

xivricreuf - 698 

[JLOptUI — 639 

xopetxt; - 704 

'HtW E«%«* - 1214 

IxeyoLXa, -1181 

Nixo/xofoej* - 1094 

xep\ Qa.vfia.trtui a.xovtTjji,a.Tuv ... - 830 

KaTrj^opjeu - 1 

Xep\ K.OtTfJ,OV - 391 

xep\ M*xoo/3isTijTfl? xx\ /3pe(.%u/3ioT»jTo? - 464 



7ttp\ M&VTtxrj? Trj? ii Tot<; Zxvetf pag. 462 

T* MeTi* TO, tpVffMO. .... - 980 

MeTeupoXo^Mci - 338 

M*!P6«vjx* - 847 

Ttepi Mvrj/xrjs- xou u.ia,f/.rtictus . . - 449 

xep\ Nsotjjto? xai fi\pui ... — 467 

7tep\ ^eiocpdiovt; . . . . . - 974 

Oixove/xixc* - 1343 

•xip\ Oupavou - 268 

7tep\ JlievfA.a.TOt; - 4S1 

7tep\ IloiriTjxrTf - 1447 

IloXn-ixa - 1252 

Hpo@Xr,fA.XTa, - 859 

Tk%in] 'P»)Top»xrj' - 1354 

'Prjropixrj 7rpoV 'AAs£*vSpov . . - 1420 

So^Ji^ixo^ iXefXjOi - 160 

Tottix* - 100 

7tep\ "Txiov xol\ i^p^optreut; . . - 453 

<l>v<nxrj a.xpcct<n? - 184 

<£>ucno7v!»>ju,ev(xx - 805 

7T£pl &VTU1 - 8l4 

7T£pi Xpw/tarsov ...... 791 

7tep\ Tvxvi - 402. 



KATHrOPIAI. 



VJfxuvvfxa, kiysTcu uv tvofXtt, fxdvov kolvov, o c% kolto) kiysTcu kcu b vroKetfxivu icjlv, cTov y\ i7tt<CY\fXY\ ev vtco- 

Tcvvo/xtt, koyog -TYig cvrL<xg eiepog, cTov Xuov o ts <xv$pu- Ketfxevu fxev icrt ty\ ^xy , kol^' v7C0Ket/xivv cfe kiysTOLt 

icog kol\ to -yeyparfxfxivov. tovtuv yap cvofxa, fxovov kolvov, TY\g ypa.fXfxa,TiKY\g' t<x <$e «t iv v7C0Ketfxivu) icjiv kte kol$\ 

6 $e ko,tol TcwofXtt, koycg TY\g cv<TL<xg eTspog' clv ycxp vTcoKeLfxevt Tivog keyeTcu, ciov 6 ti$ o,v$pu7cog kcu o Tig 

Tig <X7Coh<)U Tl i<TTLV OLVTUV EKtt.TEpU) TO X^UU sTvOLL, tfrtOV 5 TTCTCCg' i$EV y<Xp TUV TOLVTUV 0VTE iv VTCOKeLfxivU) icr\v «T£ 
EKO,TE / pOV Koyov OLTCofruTeL. TVVUVVfXO, $£ XsySTttL UV TQ T£ Ktt,$' VTCOKELfxivCV kiyETCU. OtTCkug $S TO, O,T0fA,O, KOU EV 

cvojuLtt, kolvov ko\l o Karca, Tcwofxa, kdyog ty\<; cv<TL<xg o a,vTcg, d\pL$fxu kolt tscfevog vTcoKeLfxiw vkiyeTa,.L, iv vTcoKeLfxivu <5e 
c-Tcv X^uovo Te a,v$pU7C0.g ko,l o /S»?. o ya)p a,v$pu)7ro5 koli evta, &8sv Kukvet sTvo,l' y\ y<xp Ttg ypa,fXfxa.TiKY\ tuv iv vtco- 
o- |S«? Kotvu ovcfXcLTi 7\pocra,ycpsvETtt,L Xjuov, kcu 6 kdyog <£e Ketfxivu fxiv i<rt, k<x$' vTCCKetfxivx os ^Evdg kiyETOLl. 
tyi$ cvrixg o a,vTog' i<xv ya,p oltcc^u Tig tov EKOLTipov 10 c/ Oto,v eTspov kol$' hip^ KOLTY[yopY\Tcu ug kol$' vtto- 3 

XoyoV, TL S<TTLV CLVTUV EKOLTEpU T0 X^UU sTvcU, TCV OLVT0V KELfXEVY , C<TO, KO,TO, Ttt KCt.TYjyopXfA.iw kiyETOLL, 7C0LVT0, KCU 

kdyov oltcq^uo-ei. 7rctpuvvfxa, Se kiy£Ta,L o<ra, 0,7:0 Tivcg frta,- kolto, t« VTCOKEtfxiv^ pY\$Y\<rsT<xt, oTov a,v$puffcog ko,t<x t« tl- 
(pipovTO, ty\ 7tTu<TEL ty,v KttTtt, Tovvofxa, 7rpo<TYiyopLa,v e%et, vog a\v$puTL- , 6 Ktt,TYiyope?Tcu , to <£e Xjuov ko,to) T« CtV^W7r»' 
■cTov a,7ro ty\s ypa,fxfxtt,TiKY,g 6 ypa,fx/xa,TiKog kcu 0,7:0 tyis ovkovv koll ko,to, tov tlvo? a\v$pu7rx Ktt,TY\yopYi$Y\<reTtt.L to 
dvo^pELccg d\vo^psLog. iSl^uov' ya,p tls a,v$pu)7ro<; kcu a.v$pu7rog icrL kcu X^ucv. 

2 Tuv Ksyofxivuv t<x fxsv KeXTa, <rvfX7rXoKY\v kiysTcu, tol, Tuv sTspoysvuv kcu (xy\ u7r' a,KkY\ka. TeT<xy fxivuv tre- 

&■ oivev <rvfX7rXoKY,g. Ta, fxev cvv Ktt,TO, <rvfX7cKoKY\v oiov pcu tu etfrei kcu cu $LO,(popa,i, cTov Xooov ko,\ E77LcjY\fXY\g' 
a,v$pu7ro; Tpi~X£L, a,v$pu7rog vikcX' to, o^ a,vev <rvfX7rXoKY\s Xut fxsv ya.p c\a,<popa,t to ts 7teCpv kcu to frtTnsv kcu to 
oTov clv$pu7rog, fiovg, Tpi%ei, vlkcL. t:ty\Vcv kckl to svvcfpov, i7CLcjY\fXY\<; Ss io^SfXLa, tmtuv' cv ya,p 

Tuv cvtuv Ttt) /xev koB vi:oKSLfxivov TLVog \iysTO.L , 20 <$La,cpipsi i7:L<~Y\fXY\ ETLg-Y\fXY\g tu biTCOvs sTvcu. tuv fri ye 
iv vTOKELfxsvu he bfrevt ic;tv, olcv a,v$po)7cog ko,B vT^OKeLfxen vtc a,WY\ka, yevuv ibev Kukvei Tccg a,vT<xg $La,<popa)g etva,t' 
fxev kiysTcu t» Ttvog a\v$pu7C6, iv vTcoKEtfXsvu <^e «<5evf i<?t' t<x ya,p i7ca,vu tuv vtc a,vTtt, ysvuv KttTYiyopehcu , uqs 
tcx frs iv v7C0K£ifxtvu fxsv iqL, kolS' v7:oK£Lfxiw c% ifrsvog c<ra,t t« KoLTYiyopovfxivov S~ttt,(popa,t el<rt, To<ra,vT<xt ko,\ tov 
keyeTcu (iv vTOKeLfxevu <^e keyu, ev Ttvt fXY\ ug fxipog v7C0KeLfxiv\; ecrovTcu. 

vTcapxfiv cho\iva,Tov %upig eivoLL tov iv co icriv), cTov y\ Ttg 25 Tuv koltol fXYjcfefXLa.v <rvfX7:kcKY,v keyofxivuv eKHcrcv y\tol 4 

ypa,fXfxa,TiKYi iv vTcoKeLfxevu fxev ecri ty\ ipvxv-> KA ^ vtco- io-LOLv <TY\fxcuvet v\ tcotov y\ Tcctcv y\ Tcpog ti y\ tva y\ tcots. y\ 
Ketfxsw _^' ifrevog keyeTttt, koli to t; kevKov iv vTcoKeLfxivu Ke7<r$a,i y\ e%eLV y\ ttolelv y\ 7ca,<rxetv. scrt <5e vtlo, fxsv ug 
fxsv tu crufxa,TL icTLV (olttolv y<xp yfiufxtt, iv <Tufxa,Ti), Kofi tvtcu ELTCELV oTcv <xv$pu7ccg , t7C7cog' 7coTcv $e cTov bl-KYiXP, 
v7:oKeifxew <Je cvbevog keyeTcu' to, 6% k&W vT:cKeifxiv* te TptnYiXp' ^ ^" %* °? ov kevKcv, yp&fXfxoLTiKov ' ncpog ti oe 

. Codices Organi.^C, et C ubi deficit, D. . 

Tit. y.a,Tr\^op(M 7T£pi w ¥.x.«, <yeYixuTci,TWY yswY C. II 2. Ao^o? post uvtrja? ponit C. II A. ka,Y B. IK 9«. <& om AC II 11. ixoc- 
Tipy. 0,-jtujy C. II 25. y tU B. 

4. ■ jivki om BC. II 7. inroxvfjiivv ph XL^tcu C. II 8. xs/^Jn .oajtwy -uym C. II 9. y,\v om B et pr A. II xa.3' — XI«/ztm om 
pr B. II ; 12. olov .0 .«.vQpaxcs pr.C ■ II ' x*t» .ora C. -II- l4, to £$ov ft^mpfX^tr^ C II 18, ha,<popcd o~ov ro BC. II ts te tttvyoy xctl 
7r£^sy kcu to himv axi '{wrjpoY A, t'o Tf 7rT»jycy xxi 7rz£bv xotX t& 'ivvSpov vccCi to ihVyy C. II 29- PW om pr A. 

A 



2 KATHTOPIAI. 

oiov otTKartov , v\fxirv, fxeTZpV 7r« cfe otov h AvKeioo, h cfevog roov rtvoov dv$pooToov, cvcfs Kard av$pcoTov oKoog. toC- 
dyopa' Tors cfe oiov ex$e<;, Tepvrtv xeTrSai cfe oTov dvaxetrat, Ktv ro xp£>fJ>oo & rodfxarf ovkovv ko,) h rtv) rcdfxarf el 
xa$v,raf ex m °^ °^ ov vTocfecferat , uoTKtcaf ToteTv cfe oiov yap fxv\ h rtvt rdov Ka$' eKaca, ovcfe h rodfxart oKoog. 
refxvet, Kaief Tarx^v tfe otov rifxverat, Katerat. e-xacov boce ra, aKKa Tavra v,roi Ka$' vTOKetfxevuov Keyerai roov 
8e roov eipv\fxevoov avro y,ev Ka$' avro h icfefxta Karaipa- 5 Tpooroov ovrtuiv v\ h vTOKet/xevatg amat<; eciv. fxv] ovruiv «v 
ret Keyerai v\ aTocparet, rr, tfe Tpap aKKr,Ka r^roov rvix- ' ruv Tpooroov ovrtoov dcfvvarov roov aKKoov rt etvat. 
tKoxv\ xaracpartg v\ dTocpartg yiverai. S,Tara yap tfoxeT Tcov cfe tfevrepoov ovridov /xaKKov ovria ro eTtfog rov 

•xardcpartg xcu a.To<partg v,roi dKv\$v\g v, ^evtfv)g eTvaf roov yivtg' eyy tov ydp rv\g Tpodrv,g ovriag eciv. edv ydp aTO- 
tfe xard fxvfiefxtav rvfXTKoKv,v Keyofxevoov xcfev vre aKvfieg cftcfco rtg rv)v Tpddrv\v ovriav ri eci, yvooptfxodrepov xa\ ol- 
ire ^evtfog ectv, oiov av$pooTog, Kevxov, rpe%et, vtxa,. 10 xetcrepov aTotfodret ro eTtfog aToMovg v\Tep ro yevog, oTov 

5 Ovria tfe erTiv v\ Kvpiodrard re ■x^i.-Tpporoog x.a) fxd- rov rtvd clv$pooTov aTOcftcyovg .yvoopifxodrepov dv .aTotfoiv\ av- 

K-Krra, ..■.Keyofxsvvj, y : jxv\T$ : xa$'~ vT'oKeifxivov'._ nyog Keyerat $poorov r^ TJdoov &Tocftcfo-jg' rd -fxev ydp ttftov fxaKKov tov 
fxv,r h vToxetfxlvco . rtvi irttv,oTov b.r)g- lv$pu>Tog $ « -r)g rtvog _ dv$pooToy , rg ^e xomrepov. xa) ro r) ^vtyov dTocfi- 
TfTog. frevrepat <$e oixrtcht Keyovrajt., h oTg ethcriv a,t. Tpoo- frovg yvooptfxoorepov dTocfoocret devcfpov dTocftfrovg v) cpvrov. 
rug ovrtat Keypjxevat, vTapxov<rt, raZrd, . re xa) r-d roov t5 trt a,[ Tpoora-t ov<rtai S"td ro roTg coKKotg a,Ta,<rtv vToxeT- 
slboov rovroov yevv,., ^i*;^!^«^^f^^<A'Cl^^3^0u^ij|^ <r$at xat Tcivra,; rd pLKK* x-ctrd rovroov xarv,yopeT<r$a-t v) 
Xet roo dv$pu>Tco, .ye\og $e rov.etcfovg e<rr)'r<)-.^wov'. cfev- ii) .-dvr^Tg ^Tvoa fod rovrp . fjuaKicria, ovcrtat Keyovrau obg # 
repctt oiiv ebiirctf. Keyoyrcu ■. ovn.a,t, oT<xv o ri-dy$pooTog xa) ye ai T.poorat ovriat Tpog rd. d?.Ka TcLvra, ex°'~><rtv, ovroo 
ro X^ooov. .. (pavepcv cfe ex ruv e'tpv\fx(vw "ortroov xa$' vtp- xat-. <tl : .eTc\og Tpog ro yevog exet\ vToxetra,t ydp r.o eTftog 
xetfxevov Keyofxevwv dvayxaTov xa) rovvofxa, xa) rov Koyov 20 ru yevef rd fxev ydp yevv, xa,rd roov elcfcov xarv,yopeTra.t, 
xarvf/opeTr$a! Tov VTroKSifxdvpv , oiov o av$pciOTog _xa,$' vto- rd Se eicfv, xard roov yevoov ovk dvri^pdpu. ooce Ka) ex 
X$ty,eyov .Keyercu rov .rtvog dv$pcvTov, Ka) xarr,yopeTrai ye rovroov rp' etfag ri ymg fXciKKov ovria,. avroov cfk toov el- 
rovvofxa,' 'tpv ydp wfywtoy 7pv rtvh dv$poorov KcirviyopY\- $pov : Jora,' fxv\ ect yeyv\, _ ovfrev.. (xdKKov erepov erepov ovria, 
•r-etg-, xat o Koypg <fe 6 rov dv$pcvTov Kard -.rox> rtvog- dv- hciv .ovcfey. ydp otKetdrepov dTocfuireig Kard tk rtvog 
SpooTov xa.rv,yppv\$v\rera,f b.yap rtg clv$pooTog xa)'_ a:\4poo- 2$ $pooTov rov ctv$pooTov dTocftcfovg vj xard rov rivog r, 
Tog ect xat ^uov. cot^e xa) rovvofxa, Kat b Koyog Kdrd vs tov Ittov. oora,vroog Se Kat roov Tpooroov ovrtoov icfev fxaK- 
vToxeifxevov. Ka,rv\y6py,$r,rerat. Toov cY h .vToxetfxlvoo ovroov Kov erepov erepov ovricp eciv ovcfev ydp fxaKKov b r)g a,v- 
£Tt /xev roov TKetcoov ovre rovvofxa, ov$' b Koyog xarv,yo- $pooTog ovria, v\ b t)? fiovg. 

peTrat t» vToxeifxevx ' st' htoov.cfe rovvofxa, fxev ovcfev xoo- Etxoroog cfs fxsrd rdg Tpoora,g ovriag fxova, rooy a,K- 

Kvsi KarnyopeTr$at T.ore fS vTOKetfxew , rov cte'Kdy.ov dtfvr 30 Koov rd eicfv\. koa rd yevv, cfevrepai ovriat Keyovra,f fxdva, 
varov, oiov' ro Kevxov h \ uToxeiyJvco h rco rovjoia-Tt' x&rn- ydp. Sv,KoT rv.v Tpodrv,v iriav roov Karv\yopovfxevoov. rov ydp 
yopeTrat t» vTOKetfxevov (KevKOv'ya,p rcvfxa, Keyerai), h nva, dv$pooTov edv dTocficfco rtg ri ect, rofxev eTcfog v) ro 
oe Koyog b tk Ksvkpv ovcfeTore Ka,ra, rodfxctrog Karv,yopv\- yevog dTocftcfovg otKetoog dTocfcoret kcu yvooptfxoorepov toiv\- 
6v\rerat. ra, o a-KKa, Tavra, v\rot Ka$' vTOKeifxsvoov Ksys- rst av$pooTov yi.^coov dTotftcfovg' roov cf a.KKoov o rt ctv 
rat rcov Tpoorcov ■ ovriiov v\ ■ iv vmxetfxevatg ajvrcug efiv. t«to 35 -dTO&tfbp rt.g, dKKorpioog ecat dTocfecfooKodg, oTov KevKov v) 
oe tpavepov ex roov Ka$' exaca TpoxeipiCofxevoov , oTov ro -rpeXet h hrtovv ruiv rotovroov drocftcfovg. doce elxdroog roov 
\ooov xara, tk dy^pwTX xarviyopeTrctf «xkv xcu Kard t» doKKoov rdvra, fxdva, ovriat Keyovrat. eri a,t Tpuirpu iriai 
Ttvog dv$pu)T* Karv\yopvi$v\rerat rd XJ^oV ei ydp Kard fxv,- hd rd roTg aKKotg aTartv vTOKeTr$at Kvptodrara ovriai 

- 1. rj/*'<ni om pr B. II h fyopS, h Xvxstu BC. II 2. %U? C. II 4. codices rif*.mi xocieiv. II TifMsirScu xot,U<r6cu BC. II 9. y.xrd 
liY,fep(cM 8-k C. II 10. Xsvxc; C. II 21. o om C. II 22. XfyTcu] ^kv Xfyemi C. II M om pr C. II 23. t«] xocrci rox! BC. II 
26. axX ^ov.om \>r BC. \\ 30. Trare- om £..'11 36. y.oCTcl tS av%J*v, rs ^ov C. II 3.8. Mttigipp^atMl ro ^ov om C. ■ ■ 

4. Xtyercu post ovcnujv ponit C. II 6. post eXicu ABC addunt haec : Trdnct ^clp rd ciXXcx. r\rot xxff vTroy.eiy.eiM t&tw Xtyercu fj h u7rox.eiy,(wu<; 
u-jTcus k?k. *n?e p>r) bc-wv \uv '-xpuTojv lnrt& ^mtm tuv-cXxauv rt evcU. I\ 11.' v,7rchty\ rtf civQpuiroy C. II 12. &7roMvs rj '(uov C. II l4. jpupipu- 
repov y.tu dxeatepbv &*&* C. II 15. ht c% cu C, II 17. tdxmBG^W \% ^ip wutrl C. -H 21. yccTx om C. II 27. ovhe fortasse A. II 
36. Tpe%et A. II tavta yova, rw p,XXtiv C-> II. -38. pOst VTroyeto-QcU editi x.&\ rd cXxXd, 7r*vrcc kcktcI TVMW x.st,Tr i yope7<T$cu rj sv <*ut*7s eTvou. 



av- 

ITTOV 



KATHTOPIAI. 3 

ksyovTcu. ug <f( ye a,i TrpuTni i<rtou Trpog to, a,kka, 7txvto, u<ra,vToo$ c%. Ktxt a,l Bicupoptu xutx, tuv sl$wy x&it yut,Ts& 

eXpriVi ktu tcI stSyi -kcu r* y(vv\ tuv TrpuTuv i<nuv rrpog tuv. d-oixuv Ka,TY,yopovv~cu.. kcu -dy koycv '<fs s7ri<f(xovTcu 

to> kotird irdvra, e%er Ka,raj tvtuv ya,p ttxvto, tcl \onra, a.1 TrpuTtxt itricu tov tuv st^Tov xcu tov tuv ysvuv, kcii to 

K&TYiyopiiTcu . tov yocp riva, a,v$pu7rov epeTg ypa,[XfxarriKOV ' (Tfrog <fe t.ov t« yevovg' o<r<x ydp kclto) t« ■xa,TY l ycpcvfx(vM 

cvxovv kcu kvQpoo-Kov xcu Xuov ypa,fx/xa,Ttxov kpeTg. u<r<xv- 5 keysTou, ircLvTa, xa,\ k<xt<x tov vTrcxstfxsvcv pY,$Y\<rsTa,t. cog- 

rug <fs xa,\ eiti ruv akkuv. ccvTug <fe. xa,\ tov tuv cftoupfipuv .koyay. vjutob&sciu rd sio\ 

; Kotvdy .<fe xoord 7r<x<rv\g ov<ria,g tq fXY\ ev vTrcxstfxevu kcu.to, txTCfxa,. <rvvuvvfx.a> &( ye %v w kcu rwofxa, kqivov 

eTvcu. y\ fxsv ydp 7rpurY\ ovtria, ovresv vTroKstfxsvu erriv x.cu o kcyos b ccvTog, u<~e irciyTa, rd d-ird ruv i<rtuv xcu 

cvTe xaff vTroxetfxevov ksysrcu ' ruiv <fs cfsvrspuv ovo-tuv ra, a,iro ruv fooccpcpuv <rvvuvvfxug k(ysra,i. 

(pccvspcv fxsv kou xrug oti ix sl<rtv sv vTrcxufxsvco. b ya,p 10 Hx<ra, '<fe itrta, froxsT toS~s ti <rY\fxa,ivsiV. eVi usv ?v 

ctv$pu7rcg xcc$" vTroxsifxsvov fxsv rv tjvo? dv$'pu7r>s ksysrou, ruv TrpuTuv cvriuv dva,fx<pi<r$Y\TY { rcy xoTi dkv\$(g ecriv oti 

ev vTroxetfxevu cfe ovk ecjiv' ov ya,p ev roo Tm a,v$pco7ru) o Tofre Ti .o~YjfAa,ivei' o,tojij,ov yctp xcu : h dpSfxu to &yi\xuo£- 

a.vSpoo7rog ecjiv. oorchvToog <5e kcu to ^uov ko,(? v7r.0Ksifj,(vov vcv scriv' sttI <fs toov. (fsvTepoov ^cvnooy. '(pciivsTcii fxsv Ifxoioog 

fjJsv KsysTcu tov Tivog dv$poo7rov, ovk ecji tfs to ^iocv sv too <rXYifj,a,Ti TY,g 7rpo<rYiy{,.p$a,g. : T-p$s Tl 'rY^&lvsiv^ %Tcty enri\ 

Tu-TiVi dv$poo7roo. hi 8s toov sv v7roksifj,(voo ovjoov tc fj,ev i$ a,v$poo7rcv *j XJ^cv, ov /xy^v dhv\$(g ys, dkhd fxdXkov ttoiov 

cvojuoa, ovc)sv kooKvsi KarrY\ycpsi<r$a,i ttots tov v7roKsifJ,svcv , Ti o-Y\fj,a,ivsi' « ya,p sv e<~i to v7rox.etfj,evoy coo-^ep y\ 7rpooTY[ 

tqv <W koy-ov d$vv<x,Tov. --toov tfe tfevTepoov ovcnuiv KctTYiyopeT- cvo-ia,, dKka, kccto, 7rokkoov o dv$poo7rog ksyeTcu ko,\ to 

TiU ko,i o koycg ko,t<jo tov v7rcKsifJ,(vcv . kcu Tovyofxa,' tov XJ^ov. ovx d7rkoog <^e 7roiov ti <ryifj,a,ivst , oo<r7rsp to ksvKov. 

ya,p tov dv$poo7rov koyov ko,to, tov Ttvog dvQpooTrov xa,T¥r i(fsv ydp dkko <rY { fxa.ivsi \to ksvxov dhX r) nr.atcv. to <fs 

yopYj<rstg, ko,i tov tov Xjyov oo<ra,vToog. oocrs cvx, a,vsir\ y) 20. sTcfog kcu to yevcg Trspt icriccv to Trotcv d<bopiTsi' Trotdv 

QVQ-ta, toov sv v7TOKetfj,(voo. ovx icftov <Te TovTO TY]g ovcria.g^ ya,p tivo, x<ria,v o-Yjfxaivei. e7r\ 7rkeTov <fs : t£> yevsi y) tCo effrst 

dkkd xcCt y\ tfia.<popd toov fj,v\ ev viroxsifxevu) icriv. tq ydp tov d<popto-fxov 7roisha,r o ydp ^uqv StX&v S7r\ TrksTov tts- 

ttsQov kou to <yi7rovv ko.S' v7roKStfx(vov fxev keyeTou tk dv- pika,fxfia,vei y\ b tov a.v$poo7rov. 

QpuoTr*, ev vTroKetfxevoo <fs *k scriv' . » ya,p sv too dv$poo7roo tr £7ra,px^ <^e TaiTg &<ricug xcu to fXY\(fsv a,vTa,Tg svolv- 

etjt to (fnrcvv v\ to 'ttsQov. xcu o koyog <^e xa,TYiyopsiTcu b. 25 tiov sTvcu. ty\ ya,p irpooTY\ Wta, t/ a)v sTy\ sva,VTiov,. oTov roo 

jXn (ftcupcpdg, Kct,$' ov dv ksyYjTcLt v\ ^iot,<popcc, oTov et to Tiv\ dv$poo7roo Y t Too Ttvt ^ooui ; *<fsv y<xp scjiv hoovTiov. cvU 

TrslJcv Karrd t« dv$pooir*. keyeTcu, KcCt o koyog b t« 7re^5 ye too dv$poo7rco y\ too Xcooo ov<f(v scjiv eva,VTiov. qvk tcftov §s 

KfrTKy opY[$Y\<rsT a,i t« dv$pco7rx' 7rsCpv ya,p scrtv b a,v$pco7rog. tSto TY]g b<na,g, dkka, kcu stt cikkooy -Trokkoov, oTov eVz 

fXY\ Ta,pa,TTSTOo 8s Yifxdg to, fx(pv\ tcov cvQ-toov cog sv V7TC- t« 7roo-«* Top yacp hirY\XM *I Tpnrqxei icfev scriv sva.vTiov, 

Kstfxsvoig ovTO, ToTg okoig., (xy\ ttots dva,yK<i<r$oofXsv ovk cv- 30 H<^e ys ToTg c\(ko,, icfe toov TOMTooy ifrsvi, el (xy\ Ttg to 7rokv 

Q-ia,g O.VTO, <pa,<rKsiv sTva.1' ov y<xp qvtoo to, sv vTroKstfxsyoo tco bkiyco <p<xty\ sva,yTtcv eTva,i y\ tq fxsya, too fxiKpco. tcov 

sksysTo to, oog fxspvi v7ra,pxovT<x sv Ttyt. &s d<pcopt<rfx(vcov 7ro<roov iSsv y&svi syocvTiov scriv. •' 1 

'T7ra,pxei <& t&Tg irioug koa Toug htxipopaTtg to ttxvto, AoksT <^e y) ov<ria, (xy\ eVf&^etr&tf to fxdkkov kcu to 

trwcovvfxoog d^ ocvtoov keye<r$cu, Trcxtrcu yocp a\ dir^ oovtoov y,ttov. keyoo cfe &x ° Tl ovcria, ov<ria,.g &k scri fxcLkkov vstria, 

Ka,TY,yopiOU Y\T0l KO.TO, TOOV dTOfXOOV KO,TY,yopovVTCU Y\ KO,TO, 35 KOU YjTTOV OVtrio, (TOVTO fXSV ydp sipY\TO.l CTl S<TTtv) , dkk' 

twv el<foov. diro fxsv ya,p TY\g 7rpooTY\g ovricxg ov<fs/xia, scrt ort skchcty, v<ria, tW "cnrsp scriv, & ksysTcu .fx&kkcv kcu 

KO,TY,ycpia,' ko,t ov^svog yxp v7roKsifx(vov keysToot' tcov (fs %ttov. cTcv sl scrtv civty\ y\ itrTa, cXv$poo7rog, xk scr<xt fxdk^ 

frsvTepoov ovrtoov to fxsv sifrog koltou tov dTOfxov KO,TY\yo- kov kcu y,ttcv dv$pco7rog, «Te ctvTog savrls »T£ sTspog STS- 

pmcu, to frs ysvog kcu ko,to, t« s'to%g kcu Karrd t» dTOfx^. pov » ya,p ecjtv srspog hsp* fxxkkoy a.v$pco7rog, u<T7rep to 

2. to. ylvri xou t* £i^»j C. II 3. 7*p cL-zouno, C. II 10. w £iViv] «§£/*«* corr C. II 21. t^? om BC. II 25. rc ^Vsv i<r\v C. II 
27» tS posl xsira om B. II 28. o om C. II 34. o.tt'] ra. in' C. II o.tco tovtw BC. . . - . 

1. hia,(f>opo,\ xo\ y.o.ro, C. II 5. Trdna, ora B. II 6. to, tz illt\ B. II 7. ye om A. II 13. km & tuv] tuv bl B. II n.XiysTu.t om 
C. . II 1$. hl yhos y.o.\ to ttfo; C* II 22. 7ro,oa,~Aa,u@cLm A. II 26. y to ££ov pr C. II ydp om pr C. ■ -II 2,8. t«to post wto,? po- 
nuut BC. .11 t-?? om.A*\\a.X~Aa, <ya.p %oh ABC. II 29. n tou tchvyxv C,_ om B. II 30. fs om AB. \\ 34. i<rio. xa\ t\ttbv om C. II 
37. *2t*i C. II Xn C. 

A2 



4 KATHrOPIAI. 

Xvjkov erspov krspn fxclXXov icrt kou YiTtov Xevkov, Kat Ka- y/xarog KWYi$(vrog brs /xev dXv$Y,g cre §£. ^ev$Y]g Xeyerou. 
Xov irepov irspov fxaXXcv '• xolXov koli y\ttov Xeyetau. kcju coo-avroog Se Kat 'etti TY\g frcfyg. ' oo<rr£ roo-rpoTroj ye tfrio.v 
covto Ss tvjvi /xXXXov kou yittov Xsysrat^ oiov ■ to <roo/xa, olv ewj TY\g i<rtag ro kooto, ty ; v fattnvfi y.sra^>oXY]v c\sKTtK%v 
XevKov cv /xaXXcv Xsvkov sTvat XeyeTcu vvv v\ Trporspov, kcu toov ivavrioov Eivat. el frs rtg Kai tolvtol 7rapac\(xoiro , rov 
Gspfxov ov fxaXXov $sp/xov kou y\ttov Xsysrat. y) <5e ye io-ta, 5 Xoyov kou tyjV ho\\a,v Ssktiko, tuv ivavrtoov sTvat, wc scrtv 
icfsv /xaXXcv ko-1 yittov XeyeTou' &$e yap av$poo7rog julciX- dXY[$sg t«to. o yap Xoyog kol\- y\ ■ c\o%cl ov tw dvrd $(xe- 
Xov vvv <Lv$poo7ro$' y\ Trporspov Xeysrat, ovfre ye roov a,XXoov <r$at rt toov sv&vTioov eTvou cfsxrtxd Xsysrat, clXXa) tw 7rsp\ 
&<f(v, o<ra, iqtv icrtcu. cocrs ix dv £7rt$(xciTo 4 wia, to fxcLX- sr-spov ti to-7ra,$og yeyevY^cl-t. roo ydp Ts Trpay/Xa, eTvou 
Xov kcli V[TT0V. *j /xy\ sTvat, rttco xat -& Xoycg c\Xy$y]<; y\ ^svSyi? sTvatXe- 

MolXi^o, 8e 'icfiov tyis i<nag cfcKS? eTvou to ravrov koa lOysrat, & roo avrog cfekriKog eTvat ' rcov eva,vrioov. dirXoog ydp 
ev cipifaop ov roov iva-vrtoov sivai Ssktikov, oiov iirt fxh roov iSsv v7t ' ovcfsvog ovre b Xoyog Kiveirai ovre v\ ^o^ol, wrre 
ctxXoov ovk dv ,e%oi rtg To TtiiovTo TrpoeveyKetv, o<ra, y>Y[ &k'clv s\'/\ ■ c\eKT-iKa r&v evavrtoov ' fXY\$evog ev av.ro?g yivofxev<i 
elcrtv ov<rtat, o ev apt$[xu> ov roov kvavrtoov c\ektikov ectiv, 7ra$ovg. y\ c$e ye wta, ruj cfjrr] ra. svavrta $i-XjE<r$ai , tk- 
o/ov to xpoo/xa,-, o ecrtv ev Kat ■' ravrov roo apt$fxu>, &k ecrat roo c\eKTtKY[ roov ivavttoov sTvat Xeyerat' vocrov yap Kat vyteta,v 
Xsvkov Kat fJLeXav, icY y\ avTY\ Trpafyg ko-i fxia tw aptQfjooo iS t\sxercli, koli XejyoorYfra, Kat fjLsXoLvtav' Kat EKacrov roov 
ovk £<rrat tyavXvi Kat <T7rovcfata,' cocravroog <^e Kat~ S7rt toivtoov o-vtyi ^expfievyi rSsv evavrtoov eTvai $eKTiKY\ Xsysrat. 
ruv clXXoov, ocrafXYj slcriv ovcnai. y\ t\s-~ys ovcrta, ev Kat oocre i&tov clv iriag eiY\ ro ravrov koi- ev apt$fxoo ov freKTt- 
ravrov apt$/JLU ov freKTiKov roov eva,vrioov ecrtv, oTov o rig kov eTvat roov evavrtcov Kara, rr,v eavTY\g fJLerafioXYiv. Trepi 
kvSponrog , eTg ko,i o cwrog oov, bre fxev XevKog bre <5e fx(- fAv ovv cv<rla-g'TO<ra,vra> sipy\<r$oo. 

>^a? ytvErat, Kat Sspfxog xat \pvxpog, Kat cpavXog Kat 20 T? (fs 7ro<rx' to fxiv ecti- htooptcrfxivov, ' ro £e o-W£%sg,^ 

tT7rovc\atog. £7ri <5e roov clXXcov ovcfsvog (paivsrat ro rotov- koli to fjCkv ek $(<rtv s-Xfivroov 7rpog aXXyXa, roov iv covrotg 
tov, ei fXY\ rtg ivicratro rcv Xoyov xa\ ty\v c^o^av cparxoov fxopioov ' crvvscr^KE , ro Se vk i^ ixovroov Beq-lv. (crt cTe cftoo- 
roov ivavTtoov eTva-t cfexrtxa. 6 yap a-vrog Xoyog aXv\$Y\g pto-fXEvov fxkv oiov d,pt$fxog xa\ Xoyog, <rvvsxsg cfs ■ oTov ypajtx- 
KoCt ^j£v$Y\g Etvat &oxeT, oTov si dXYi$Y[g eiyi b Xoylg ro xa- fx-/[, i7r-upavsta,, crufxct, eti <5e Tra-pd ravra XP^ VC<; K< u 
6Yi<r$at rtva, dva-cravrog a-vvt b cturo? ovrog Xpyog ^svc^Yfi 2i roTrog . toov fxh - yap t£ dpt$fxx fxopioov iS~£tg icrt xotvog 
(cja.i. coQ-avroog tfs ko\ srrt t>5? frofyg' eI yap ttg dXY[$oog~ opog,- Tr-pog ov <rvv a7rr ei ra fxopta, a,vrx, oTov'rd ttevte e\ 
bo^aCpt ro Ka$Y[Q-$at rtva,, dvacravrog olvtv ^Evcfoog cfo^ao-Et, ecrt roov\heKa fxoptov, irppg «^evet koivov opov <rvv-cL7rr£i td, 
ty\v a,vtY\v e%wv tr£p\ <*ut» t\o£av. sl <5e rtg koa t?to xct- 7revTe Kat ra, ttevte, dXXa S~tooptcrai' koa rd rpta- y£ Kai 
pac\(xoiro, aXXd rco ye rpoTrco c\ia,<p£p£i. ra, fXEV yap iirt to. e7TT«- Trpog &£(vol koivov opov Q-vvd,7rT£f cvcY oXoog dv 
roov ovQ-tuiv cxvra fXETa-ftdXXovra, Ssktiko, toov ivavrtoov icrt' 30 sxotg eV dpt$fxov koivov opov XafiEtv r&ov- fxoptcov, dXX' 
^jvx?^ y&P ."**• $spftov ysvofXEvov /xsrEfiaXsv (yiXXoicoto-i clsi c\tooptcra,i' oocte b /xh .dpt$/xog roov 3~tcopi<rfx(vcov icrtv. 
yap) xai /xsXa,v ix Xevkv Kai o-Tr^aTov iK cpavXx. ooq-- co<ravroog <^e kcoi b Xoyog roov S~toopi<rfx(voov icrtv. ort /xh 
dvroog &e Kat eTrt ruiv a,XXoov sko-ctov a-vroov /xeto,^)oXy\v yap ttoq-qv icrtv b Xoyog, (pavspov' KarafXErpETrAi yap q-vX- 
SexofJLevov roov ivavrtoov cfexTixov icrtv. b <5e Xoyog xa\ y\ X&fiy iSpaxsia- xat /xa-xpoi: X(yoo c% a,vrov rov /XErd cpco- 
Sofca, avroj fXEV dxtwira Travr^, Travroog cfta/x(v£i, rov Se 35 vvjg Xoyov ytyvo/xEVov. Trpog xt\(va yap xotvov opov «,vt» td 
trpayfxatog Ktw/XEVti ro ivavrtov rrEpt avra, ytvETo-t' b /xh /xopta, o-vva,7rTsi' & yap scrt KOtvog opog Trpcg ov a't crvXXa,- 
yap Xoyog cftafxsvEi b cxvrog to Ka$Y\<r$at riva,, tk <^e Trpa- @a,t crvva,7rTov<rtv, dXX' exolctyi $tooptcra,i o,vty, Ka$' avTY\v. 

1 . I^iv antc i'rec07 ponit C. II xxi %ttcv om SC. II 'xaci xctXcv — 3. XlyeToLi om C. II 6. 7*p o a,vQpu7rc; C. II 7. Xlysrxt rj -kcctzoov C. II 
•ye om C. II vHv A. II 9. xa\ to y,ttov C. II 10. foxu ante uW ponit C. II 12. tc toioxjto om C et pr B. II 13. l?-(v «<rt* C. II 
14.' T'm om C. II \qt C. II 15. hQ' C. II 17. otcci A. II 18. fo*Tv/.r\ C. II 20. xpavlos te «yiVerai xou. C. II 22. p? ap* n? iv^a.TO,t 
C. II 23. ivMTivv] toic-jtmv AB. II chXriSr.g tb xod C. II 24.' boKsi ewcu C. II ro om C. II 25: o xvto? t^eu^? A070? '& M C. II 27. ^eu- 
hog C. II 31. 7iv8 i u.g / vsv C. II i uer£/3ot.XX£v C. II 33. cwri C. II 34. ■ k<r\ hnTixcv C. II 36. r* hoLvrtot, C. 

3. avrjj? C. II 4.- 'dv' AB el pr C. II 5. post Iqtv in C litura est litterarum duarumv II 8. to posl n om A. II ^ivso-Sm C. II 
10.- air* foy.Tty.dAC et corr B. II 11. ifo A. II om: A. II 18. kavrS B, uvt?,; C. II 22. toL C. II k% U BC. II 23. kx\ c 7\o- 
7«? C. II cnov om AB. II 27. ifova. 7*3 xomv B et pr C. II 31. det om A. II 34. pxxpcZ x*\ fipccxsta. C. 



KATHTOPIAI. 5 

v\ $e ypct[XfXY\ TvveXW ecriv s<ri yctp kct(3s?v koivov cpov a,7rc$ke7rovTeg kcu Totkkct ttcto. keyc/xev, cTov 7rokv ; '.to kevKov 
Trpog oi/ Tct fxdpta, ctvTY\g TvvctTTTet, <rtyfXY\v, kcu TY\g eTrt- keyeTcti tco tyiv S7rt(pctvsictv i:oXkY i v stvcu, kcu y) Trpafctg fxctKpa\ 
tpctvsictg ypctfXfxyV to) yctp rov sirt7rs$ov fxopict nrpog Tivct tco ye tov XP 0V0V Trokvv sTvcu, kcu y\ KtvY\Tig ttoKKy\. & ycXp 

KOIVCV OpOV 0-VVcllTTSl. • C0TO,VTCOg <$£ KCU S7Tt T€ TOOfXOLTOg KCtff CtVTO SKCtCTOV TSTOOV 7TCT0V XsySTCU. 0T0V SCtV CL7T0tfltfu> 

sxoi? ctv Ka,$s?v koivov opov, ypctfxfxy\v y\ sTTitpctvetctv , nrpog 5 Ttg ttoty\ Ttg y\ TrpoJfctg scrt, tw XP 0VU} opts?, evtctvTicttctv r) 

Ct TCt T6 TcdjXCtTOg (XOpiCt trVVCtTTTSl. S<Tt <$S KCtl XP 0V0 $ * TU} ™? a,7TOt\lt\ovg. KCtt TO KeVKOV 7T0<r0V Tl Ct7TOtfttfovg TY[ 
KCU T07T0? TOOV TOTHTUlV yctp VVV XP 0V0< > TVVa,7TTei TTpcg E7Tl<pOLVSlCt OptS?' 0TY\ yctp OLV . Y[ e7Tl(pCtVeiCt Y, , T0T6TCV KCU 
TOV 7TCtpekY\XvQcTCL . KCU TOV [XekkOVTCt. TTCtkiV 6 T07T0£ TUV TO KSVKOV (pY\T£l£V CtV BareU. COCTS fXOVO, KVptCOg KCti KCtff CtVTCt 

(rvvex^ v *${' T07T0V yctp nvct Tct t« Too/xctTog [xcput kol- ttoto, keyeTat to, elpY\fxevct, tcov tfe ctkkoov icfev Kctff olvto, 

T£%£<, * ^pog Tim X°l vov °P 0V TVV0L7TTSI' &KOVV KCtt TCt TK 10 cLkk' sl Ctpct, KCtTCt . TVfX$S$Y\KOg. \ 

TG7T» . fXCptCt, OL KCtTlX^ SKOLCTOV TCOV T» TOOfXCtTOg [X.OpiCOV, ~ETt TUO 7T0TOO OVcfsV SCTIV SVCtVTlOV. STTl ftev ydp TOOV 

TTpcS TOV CtVTCV. .opOV CVVCtTTTSt 'TTpog CV KCU TCt T6 OrWfAO,-* Ct(pCOptTfJ,eV00V (pOOVepOV "oTi OvfreV eCTlV eVCtVTiOV, 0T0V TU &17TYI- 

to<; fxcpict.' oocrs cvvsx^ ctv sty. Kctt.o tctto<;' 7rpc<; yctp;. x a h Tpnr*iX el *I 7 V ^^^ ve ^ % ™ v toicvtoov tivi' ovcfh 
svct koivov %pov ctvri Tct fxopta, cvvctTTTSU ydp ecjtv ctvro?; svctvrtcv, st y,Y\ kpa, to ttoKv tu> oKiyco 

ETr Se rct fxsv sk Qsrtv sx°vtoov 7rpo<; ctKKY\Kct tcov 15 (pa,iv\ Ttg sTvctt svctvTtov v\ to ftsyct TOO fXtKpdp. tovtoov Se 
sv ctvTo?; fxcptoov <rvvsqY\KS, to, cfs \iK s^ exdvToov Qs<riv, ovcfsv scri ttocov ctKKa, tuv 7rpo<;. ti ' ovcfsv ya,p o,vtq Kct$' 
ctov Tct /xsv tyiS ypa,fj,fj,Y i g fxcpta, <$s<rtv fp^gj Trpog ctKK.Y\Ka,' ctvTC fxsyct KsysTcti r, fxiKpov, ctKKct t<2 7rpcg hspcv ctvct- 
sKctcroy yctp ctvroov Ke?rcti x», kcu sx°i$ & v Sta,Ka,^s?v ' Kctt (pepe<r$a,i , oTov opog fxsv fxiKpov KsysTcti, Keyxpos Ss fxs- 
ct7Toc%vat "cttcv SKctcrcv KS?Tcti ev tu) . e7Tt7TeSco Kctt 7Tpog yctKv\ Too ty\v fxev toov cfxoyevoov fxetXpvct sTvctt, to tfe sKctT- 
7trc?ov fxoptov toov Koittoov crvvctTTTet. dxrctvTcog <Je Kctt to, 20 tov toov ofxoyevuiv. ovkovv Trpog sTspor y\ dva,(popa,, sttsi stys 
t« sTTtTTeS^ fxopta, $s<rtv sx^ Ttvct' cfxoioot; yctp kv euivcSo- n.a.G' avro [jux.pov yi fxeya, sKeyeTo, cvk a,v TTCTe tc fxev 
6etY\ eKctcrcv « Ke?Tctt, Kcti 7rc?ct <rvvct7TTei irpog aKKY\Kct. opog fxiKpov eKeyero, v\. cfe Keyxpos fxsya,KY\. TTctKtv sv fxev 
kcu to, tk crepex 8s chvctvTcog, Kcti to, t» to7t». e7Ti Se ye rjj koojxyi <pa.fxev TroKKovg a,v$poo7rovg sTvctt, sv ' 'A8yva,i<; §e 
T» a,pt$fxv vk cXv ex°i Ttg eTTtSzi^ctL 00$ to. fxoptct ctvTov oKtyovg 7roKKct7rKct<ricvg ctvToov ovrct?, ko,i ev fxev ty\ oIkio, 
bectv Ttvct ex et ^P^ ctKKviKa, .v\ KetTcti ttov , y\ 7To?a, • ye 25 ttoKKov; , ev Ss t<2 $sa,Tpco cKtyovg 7ioKKw TrKstov? cvrctg. 
Trpog ctKKrtKct <rvvct7TTet roov [xoptoov. ovcfe to, tcv XP 0T6 ° eTl T0 / w-£1/ &*V?(P k& 1 TptTTY^x^ >tou eKctcrov toov toicvtoov 
vTrcfxsvsi yctp cvcfev toov t» XP rM fJ-optoov' tfe fXY\ ecriv. ttccov crifxcttvei, to tfe fxeyct y\ fxtKpcv cv crYifxctfvet ttocov 
vTTCfxevcv, 7Tcog olv t«to $(<rtv Tiva. sxoi', dikKcL fxctkKcv dkka, fxcLkkov 7rpog Ti' nrpog yctp hepcv $ecope?Ta,t to fxeyct 
Tct^iv Tiva, etTTctg olv exerv tuj to fxev TrpoTepov slva,i tov ko,i to fxtKpcv. docre (pavepov oti toajto, toov Trpcg t{ ecrtv. 
XP 0V * t° &' vcrepov. kcli em t« ctpt$fxov tfe docctvTcog tc% 30 eTi ectv ts ti$y\ Ttg.ToJvTa, Trocra, sTva,t sa,v ts fxvj ti$y\, &k 
tc sv TrpoTepov a,pi$[xe?<r$a,t tcov Svo kcli tol c\>o toov rpi- ecrtv ctvTO?g evctvTtov iSsv yctp (xy\ scrtv ctvTo Kct$' ctvTo 

UV KCtl CVTOO TCt^lV TlVCt CtV it%Oiy $£<TIV $S OV 7TCtVV . kct- kct(Bs?V Ctkkct TTpcg STSpOV CtVO,(pSpSTa,l , TTOOg CtV (pCtiY[ Tig 

fiotg ctv. Kctt kcyog Se do<rctvroog' cvt\ev yctp v7T0[xevei tvtco ti eva,vTtov; eTL tfe et ecrcu to fxsyct Kcti to /xiKpcv 

TOOV [XOpiOOV CtVTOV, Ctkk' StpYlTCti TS KCtl «JC SCTIV STl T«TO SVCtVTlO,, <rVfX^)Y\<reTCtl TO «tUTO CtfXCt TCt eVCtVTiO, STTiSsX^Ctl 

ka,@s?v, cocrs xk ctv siy\ $(rtg toov fxoptoov ctvTv, elye /xvitfev 35 Kcti ctvTct ectvTo?g eTvctt evctvTtct. cvjx^ctivst ydp ttots ctfxct 

VTTCfXSVSl. TCt fXSV CVV SK $STiV e^OVTWV TCOV [XOptOOV <TVVS- T0 OLVTO fXsya, TS KOLt fXlKpOV sTvoll' SCTi ydp TTpdg fXSV T6T0 
(TYjKS, TO, tfs &K £% f^OVTWV $(<TIV. fXlKpCV , TTpcg STSpoV tfs TO CtUTO T»TO fXSyO, . C%TTS TO CtVTO 

Kxiptoog os ttoto, toJvto, fxova, keysTa,t to, stpYjfxsva,, kcu /xsyct kcu /xiKp.ov kolto) tcv olvtcv XP 0V0V e ^ VAl tv[x- 
to, Ss ctkka, 7ra,vT0, koltol rv[xfis@Y\Kog' slg tolvto, yd,p fictivst' u<rs a,[xa, to, sva,vTia, S7rtt\(x^$cti. ctkk' vtfsv c%ks? 

1. cvnyjs C. II 6. ov C. II 7. rpo? ts tov BC. II 13. cwsxU C. II l4.' sviiTrrSf toL (tajkut C. II 15. 0% xcu ttl C. II 16. I| vtt 
C. II 17. ^jfli AB. II 19. oZ BC. II 28. l%ot tlvh, C. II 37. i| i* C. • 

5. hia.vita.ia, A. II 8. «/njcrej? B et pr C, <pri<rei corr C. II -xvpius '■ itocaL xct.6' ccvtcI BC. II 9. itib ocvto xa.8' B. \\ 10. «] codices 
%. II y.a,Tx om A. II 14. 0,-jt'mv ABC. II cXpa, om BC. II 15. tov y.i^a,v pr B. II 19. y.ziX,w pr B, pvZ.ov corr B, p£fyv pr C, peiXu 
corr C. II 29. xctl to om pr C. II 32. a.va,<p(pona. pr C, a.va,<p(£ i ovTa,t pr B. II 36. ' eivou om B. 



6 KATHrOPIAI. 

ttfxct ta, httvTta. e7rM%ST6cti, cTov £t) t*i? tta-ik?' 'etacn>c>i t<vo? y&p S~t7rkctTiov keyeTcu. ooTctvrug cfe xet) ota <*XA.<* 

/aev twv hctvriuv $ox.e? eTvcti^ dkk' ytl ye ct/xa, voTeT kcu TotcwTct, ect cfe Kttt tcI toicwto, tuv rrpdg ti oTov sj^ig, cW- 

vyttttvet. dkK icfe kevKov Kctt fxekctv ec\v ctfxct. dkK cvcfe Secrtg, cUT$v\TLg , e7ricv\fxv\, $ertg. TrctvTct ydp rd eipv t fxsvct 

tuv ctkkuv ovcfsv ectv o afxa, tcl evclvticl errtMxeTcu. xcu oovtcl direp ecrtv erepuv eTvcu keyercu kcu ovk ctkko tl' v\ 

ctvTa, $ ectvToTg Tvfx^ctivei hctvria, eTvcu. ei ytlp sci to 5 ydp sfctg Ttvog e\tg Xeyertu kcll v\ exiTTY\fxv\ Tivog e7rtcv\fXY\ 

fxiya, tw fxiKpw hctvTiov, to &' ctvrd ectv otfxct fxeyct kcli koli y\ Secrtg rtvog $sTig, kcll tcl ctkka, Ss uTavTug. rrpog ti 

fxiKpdv, ctvro sclvtu eiv\ ctv evcovrtov. dkkd tuv dcfivaruv «v etrty otcl clvto, kirep ecriv errspuv eTvcu xiyertu, v\ 'ottu- 

eclv ctvro ectvru eTvcti ti hctrriov. ovk ectv dpct to fxeya, triv ctkkug itpog srrepov, ofov opog fxiyct ksyerctt irpog erepoV 

tw fXiKpu h'a,VTtov, cvSe to Trokv tu bkiyu. u<rre et xcti Trpog ti yctp fxsya, Keyertu to opog' Ktu to "cfxoiov tivi 'dfxoiov 

fxv\ tuv rtpog Tt tcwtcl Ttg epe? dkka, tov ttotov, ov&ev 10 keyerou, koli Tct ctkkct t\e tcl toicwto, uTavTug Trpog Tt ke- 

evaMTtov efcet. yercu. ert cfe kcli y\ dvctKktTtg kcu y\ trroKrtg Kcti v\ KaAe- 

MolkicrTd, Se v\ evctvrtoTVig tov Ttarcv irept tov toitov bpa, 6eretg Ttveg, v\ $e Mtrtg tujv -npdg Tt. to cfe dva,Ke?<r$cu 

$oKe? v7ccLpx m ' 70 7*P ^ 00 7 V K'*' 700 svctvTtov Tt$ea,o-t, tv\v v\ ecrcovcu v\ ko,$v\o-Qcu oovto, juoev cvk el<ri 6e<retg, Tra.puvv- 

Tpog to fxe<rov %<j)pa,v ko,too keyovreg foa, to 7rkstcrv\v t& fxug tfe d\rro toov eipvifxevoov ftetreoov keyeTtu. 

fxe<roo hicurao-iv irpog to, TrepaTO, tov Kotrfxov eTvtu. eocKcurt 15 lr tirtLp-)(ei tfe kcu eva,VTtoTv t g ev ToTg 7rpog ti, olcv 

8s kcu tqv tcTiv ctkkcov hoiVTUjov opio~[xov o,7ro TovToon eTrx- a\psTv\ KooKta, havTiov, sKarrepcv ov toov Trpog ti, ko,i eirt- 

tyepetv' to, yctp Trketcrov clkkv\koov §tetjv\K0Ta, toov h tQ ctv\jxv\ cLyvoia,. ov ira.trt he Tcig rrpog ti v7ra,p%et to evoov- 

tWToo yevei hctvTioo bpiXovTcu. tiov.' tw ysxp ^iTrkcurioo ovc\ev ecrtv hctvTiov, cvfre t<2 rpt- 

Ov froxe? cTe ro 7roo"ov e7riSexe<rScti to fxctkkov kcu TrkctTico , ovcfe toov toiovtoov ovfrevt. 

vjTtov, clov to ($i7rvi%v' ov yctp ecrtv erepov errspov fxa.kk.ov 20 Aoks? cfe koa to fxoXkkov kcu to vrrTOV s7rit\sx J strdctt 

biTrviXV. ovt\' erri t« dpiSfxcv, oTov Tct Tpia. roov 7revre i&ev rd. vpxn; tl' "cfxoiov yctp kou dvofxotov fxakkov kou vcttov 

fxakkov T& Tpict, ovcfe to, Trlvre tuv Tpiuv. cv&e xpovog keyercti, ko,l \<rcv kcu avicrov fxcLkkov kou v\ttov keyeTttt> 

erepcg erepov fxakkov xpovog eTvctt ksyeTcti. ovcf' sm tuv sKctrspov ctvruv Trpog ti ov' to ts yctp cfxotov Ttvl ofxotov 

elpv\fxevuv okug xfrsvog to fxctkkov Kcti to v\ttov ksysrcti. ucre ksysrcti Kctt to dvofxotov Ttvt dvofxotov. ov TrctvTct Se to) 

Kttt to Trocrov xk sTatSHxsTttt to fxaJ^kov kcu to tittov. 25 Trpdg ti eiri(}e%eTcti to fxa.kk.ov kou v\ttov to ydp .bnrkci- 

v ltftov t% fxctktcra, tov rrotrov to Ttov te kcu clvitov <rtov ov keyercti fxctkkov Ktti vjtov <^7rXcttr;ov, .ovcfe tuv 

ksye<rSa,t. eKttcrov ydp tuv eipv^fxivuv ttotuv 'itrov re kou toiovtuv ovcfev. 

cXvttrov keyerctt, oTov trufxct kcu 'itrov xctt avttrov ksysrcti, HctvTct tfs Ttt Trpog TtTrpog dvTicrpscpovrct ksysTttt, oTov 

hola xpovog Kcti \<rog kcu ttvi<rcg. utrctvTug cfe kou eiri tuv 6 bovkog t\e<r7roTov tfovkog ksysrcti kcu b $e<T7roTYfi t\ov- 

ctkktov tuv py$evTuv eKctTTov Ttov Te Kctt dviTov ksysrcu. 30 kov t^strTroTv^g, Kcti to StTrkttTtcv v\fxirsog ti7rka,<riov Ktti to 

tuv tfe kotrruv otra, fxv\ scri Trotr.ct, ov Trctvv ctv tfofcau 'itra, %/XLtrv S~t7r.kctTiov y\fxtTv, kool to fxs?Xpv skctTTovog fxs^Xpv 

Te kcll ctviTct ksysT$ctt, otov v\ $ict$eTig « TTCtVV 'tTV\ T£ KCtL KCU TQ ekctTTOV fXeiXjiVOg ekclTTOV. UTctvTug tfe KCtL e7ri TUV 

ctviTog keyeTtu, dkka. fxoikkov ofxoict, kcu to kevKOV "ltov dkkuv, 7rkv\v tv\ TTTuTet evLore tftoiTst kolto, tv\v ksj^tv, oTov 

TS KCtL CtVLTOV CV 7T.CtVV , dkk' OfXOlOV. UTTe TOV 7T0T0V fXCt- V\ eTTiTTV\fXV\ e7rLTTV\T0V keyeTCtL eTTLTTV\fXV\ KCtl TO e.7riTTV{r0V 

ktcra, ttv e'iv\ 'tfoov to "ltov Te Koti dviTov keyer6ai. 35 e7ritrv\fxv\ e7TLcrv\Tov , Kcti v\ ct"T$v,TLg cut$v\tov ctiT$v,Ttg kou 

7 Updg tl tfe to, TOLctvTct keyeTctt, ora, ctvTd a,7rep ecjiv to a,\T$v{rov cUT$v\Tet cut$y\tqv. ov fxv\v dkk' hioTe « tfd^et 

stsouv sTvtu ksyeTcti, v\ ottutovv ctkkug Ttpog erepov, oiov dvTiTTpecpeiv , ectv fxv\ oiKetug 7rf>og o ksyercti d7rot\o$v\, 
to [XitCpv tovcj' 07Tep ec\v sTspx ksyercti' Ttvog yctp keyercti dkktt ^ta.fxa.pTVi b d7ro$t$ovg, otov to TTTepov ectv d7roc\oc% 
fxe?"CfiV Kctt to tfnrkttTiov tS#' "direp ectv srspov ksysrctt' cpvt&og, ovk dvriTTpscpsi opvig Trrepov. cv yctp otKeiug to 

5. oajto?; B. [| 6. (L}x.a.'\ u.uu. xai B. II 7. aurc] HaX outo B. II 8. ti om BC. II 14. to] t^v pr A. II 16\ kyu,ntov pr A. II 
19. Jwi ra jjTTsy BC. II 22. t»] 7T£VT£ # B, om C. II -Kinz\ rpiu, B. II \ii%\ *M 75 B. II 27. Ttoo-Qi\ ttoo-m x«i AC. II 29. %o'otog\ 
dptfyic? BC. II owicrc?] wnffu; XiysTcu, y.u\ %pivo$ kaI \'<tos xuX oLvictos BC. II 31. (ti\ iq-i\ k^iv » C. II taoy ts kcu a,vto~ov ABC. II 34. 7rclvv\ 
■vdrj As-yeTat C. II 38. ztvc;] ^teT^ov Ttvc? AB. 

11. IV' B. II 12. av«,K£/cA<V6cu corr A. II lf5, cIssti?; y.u.v.iu, C. II 19. *fcvt\ TtvtC. II 24. u.vojJLOtov tiv\ av^aoisv] clvtcov tiv\ u.vt<jov B, chvoft.ciov nvt kvo- 

fJLOlOV XCU TO U.VKT0V TlVt U.Vi<TOV C. II TCt 7Tp5? Tt OIIl A. II 25. XU,\ TO Y\TT0V C. II 26. &X i7Ti(}i%ZTCl TO fJLcZXXoV XU.\ (jO C) YjTTOV, i:h% AC. II 30. i\fiicTeuJi BC. 



K A T H T O P I A I. 7 

nrpoorov drroMforctt irrepov opvt$og' ov yctp v\ opvis, rctvry\ yercu. edv <o¥ ye fxy\ otKeioog d7rofo$y\ Trpog o rrore Keye- 

to Trrepov ctvrov Keyerctt, dKK' y\ rrrepoorov ecjt' ttoKKwv rctt, Trepicttpovfxevoov fxev roov dKKoov, KotTctKenrofxevov fo 

ydp kcu aKKoov Trrepct ecjtv, c\ ovk ettrtv. opvt$eg. oocje ectv fxovav rov irpog o direfo$Y\, ov pv\6y[<reroii 7rpog ctvro. diro- 

et7rofo$y\ ohteioog, Kctt dvrtcjpscpei, oiov fgo 7T7epov TrrepooTov foforSoo ydp b fovKog dv$poo7rov kcu to 7T7epov opvtSog, 

nrrepov kcu to 7T7epoo7ov 7rrepco Trrepoorov. evtore fo kou. bvo- 5 kcu Treptrtpwboo rov dv$poo7rov ro fo<r7roTY\v ctvrov eTvctt' ov 

fXctroTroteTv H<roog dvctyKcuov, ectv fxv\ Ketfxevov y\ ovofxct irpag o yctp ert b fovKog nrpag cXv$poo7rov p^Verac fxy) ydp ovrog 

otKeioog dv d7rofo$eiy\, oiov.ro 7ry\cfctKtov tk. irKoii ectv d^ro- forTrorov ovfo fovKog- ecjiv. oorctvroog kcu rov opvt$og Trept- 

fo$y t , ovk otKetct y) d7rofo<rtg ytvercti' ov yctp' y\ ttKoTov, y\py\<r$oo t.o Trrepooroo eivctf ov ydp trt tcjctt to 7rrepov roov 

rctvry\ ctvri 70 TTY^cthtov Keyerctt' ecjt yctp 7rKoTct oov ovk irpog 7t' fxy\ yctp ovrag nrrepoorov ovfoe mepov ecjctt rtvog. 

tsji TTY^ctKtct. foo ovk dvrtcjpepei' ro .ydp 7rKoTov » Keye- 10 oocje foT fxev .d7rafofovctt.7rpog o Trore otKeioog Ksyercti. koLv 

rctt 7rY\$ctKiov ttKoTov. dKK' 'iroog otKetorepct ctv v) d7rofo<rtg -fxev 'avofxct v\ Keifxevov, .pctfrtct y) drrofoo-tg yiverctt' fxy) tv- 

sirj, el ovroo rroog d7rofo$etY\, ro 7rv\^ctKtov TrYifrctKioorx tty\- rog fo dvctyKcuov i<roog bvofxctT07roteTv . ovroo fo d7rofofo- 

&clKjov, y\ O7roocrovv dKKoos' ovofxct ydp ov KeTrctt. kcu dv- fxevoov cpctv.epov "ort Trctvrct T<* irpog rt irpog. dvrtcjpefyovrcu 

rtcrpetyei ye, ectv otKetoos d7rofo(fir\' ro yctp 7rY\$ctKtoorav Keyerctt. 

7r%^ctKtoo TTYi^ctKtoorov. corctvroog fo kou eirt roov ctKKoov, 15 AoKeT fo rct 7rpog rt ctfxct tjj (pv<ret eivctt, Kctt £7r: 

oTov y\ KecpctKv\ otKetorepoog dv d7rofoQe{y\ KecpctKoorx y\ X^w fxh roov TrKeicroov dKr\Seg ecrtv. ctfjoct yctp fo7rKct<rtov re eqt, 

otTro^tfofxevYi' ov ydp v\ Xwov , Ke<pctKY t v e^et' TroKKd ydp x.cti v\fxt<rv, Kcti Y\fxi<reog ovrog fo7rKct<rtov icrt' kcu fo<nron 

roov ^cooov Ke<pctK.Y\v ovk exet. ovroo fo pctcrct av.'i<roog ng %vTog fovKog ecrt, Kcti fovKov ovrog fo<r7rorv\g ecjiv hfxoioog < 

Xctfiot oig fXY\ KeTrctt . ovoptctrct, et d%o roov Trpooroov kou fo rovrotg kcu rct ctKKct. Kctt crvvctvcttpeT fo rctvrot ctK- 

roTg .Trpog ctvrct dntcrpe(pov<rt rt$eiy\ rct ovofxctrct, oo<T7rep 20 KYiKct ' fXY\ yap ovrog fo7rKct<riov w ecrtv Y\fxt<rv , Kcii v\fxt- 

£7rl roov TrpoetpYjfJtevcov diro ri 7r7spv to 7T7spoo7ov Kctt d7ro <reog fXY\ ov7og vk ecji S~t7rKctnov • u<rctv7oog fo Kcti e7r\ 7<Zv 

■rav 7ry\&ct,Xiov ro TrY^ctKioorov. Trctvrct ovv rct Trpog rt, ectv ctKKtov orct rotctvrct. «>t e7ri Trctvroov fo roov izpcg rt dKv\$eg 

irep otKeioog d7ro$t$ooTctt,. Trpog dvricjpepovrct Keyerctt, eTret foyceT ro kfxct ry (pvret eivcti' ro yctp e7rtcjYiTov Trporepav etv 

ectv ye nrpog ro rvxpv d7roc\tc\oorctt kcu (xy\ Trpog ctvra o fojfcete ry\g hrtcjy\fxy\g eivctt. oog yctp eTrt ro ttoKv TrpovTrctp- 

Keyerctt, ovk dvrtqpepet. Keyoo fo ortovfo roov bfxoKoyx- 25 x ovru}V ™ v Trpctyfxctroov rctg e7rtcjy\fxctg Kctfx@ctvofxev' e7c* 

fxevoog irpog dvTtcjpe<povrct Keyofxevoov, kcu ovofxctroov cwroTg oKiyoov yctp dv y\ e.7r ovfovog \fot rtg dv dfxct ru> e7rtcjy\Tco 

Ketfxevoov, vfov dvrtcjpepet, edv Trpog rt roov <rvfx$e$Y\KOToov ty\v e.7rtcjY\fxy\v ytvofxevY\v. ert ro fxev e7rtcjY\rov dvcttpeSev <rvv- 

dTrofo^oorctt Kcti (xy) Trpog ctvro o Keyerctt, oTov o fovKog ctvcupeT ty\v e7ri<jY\fXY\v, y) fo e.7rtcjY\fXY\ ro hrtcjY\Tov av ovv- 

edv fxv\ <5£0"7tot« d7rofoSy\ dKK' dvbpooTrx y\ fotTrofog y\ otov- ctvcttpeT' eTrtcjyjrov fxev yctp fxy\ ovrog ovk ecjtv e.7ricjY\fXY[ 

ovv roov rotovroov, ovk dvrtcjpecpet' av yctp otKeict v\ dxo- 30 ( ovfovog yctp ecjctt e7rt<jY\fxy\) , e7rt<jY\fxy\g fo fxy) av<ry\g vfov 

$o<rig ecjtv. ert tf ectv fxev rt otKeioog dTrafofofxevov y\ rrpog KooKvet krr tcjyjrov etvctt, oTov kcu 6 tou. kvkKov rerpctyoo- 

o Keyerctt, Trctvroov Treptcttpovfxevoov roov dKKoov ocrot <rvfx- vt<rfxog eiye ecjtv -z7rt<jy\rov, e7rtcjy\fXY\ fxev twrov ovk ecjtv 

$e$Y { KOTct ecjt, KctrctKeiTrofxevov fo fxavov ravrov irpog o ov$e7roo, ctvrog fo e7ricjY\rav ecjtv. en t^ooov fxev dvcttpeSevrag 

d7refo$Y\ otKetoog, det irpog ctvro py\$Y\<rercti , oTov b fovKog ovk ecjctt e7rt<jy\fxy\, roov F e7rtcjY\Toov 7roKKct evfoxercti 

edv Trpog fo<r7rory\v Keyy\rctt , Treptcttpovfxevoov roov dKKoov 35 eTvcu. bfxoioog fo ravrug Kcti rd eTri ry\g cu<r$y\<reoog e%e,i- 

dTrctvroov o<rct <rvfxPe@Y\KOTct ecjt tw fo<nroTv\, oTov ro fo- ra yctp ctWSyjrov Trporepav ry\g ctt<r&y l <reoog fo^eT eTvcu. ro 

7rofo etvcu Kctt ro eTricjYifXYig foKTtKU Kcti.ra dvSpooTroo, kou- fxev ydp . ctt<r$YjTov dvcttpeSev arvvctvcttpsT ty]v ct"t<r$y\<rtv , y) oe 

rctKetTrofxevov fo fxovav rav fo<r7rorYiV etvctt, de\ b fovKog cti<r$Yi<rtg ro ctlr$v\Tov ov <rvvctv.cttpeT. ctt ydp ct\<r$y\<retg 7rept 

Trpog ctvro pY\$y\<rercti' b yctp fovKog fo<r7rorav fovKog Ke- troofxct kou sv rroofxctrt elcrtv , ctt<r$Y\rx fo dvcttpe$(vrog ctvcu- 

2. »vkw corr A. II 3. tptfa A. II 7. t» om B. II 13. <y<ip mth » C. II 19- A^ujSxwt B. II 20. «,uto].* pr B. II .31. m 
C. II 36. ixMTuy om. C. II 37. t<2 Mfyuiru pr AC. II 39. I^cstoa BC. 

5. fceiroTv oJiTui B. II 6. o om A. II 7. xaVJ h\ nod BC. 11.8. ri corx' A. II . TiTspuTui wrwi J5, mspuTh C. II l4. 'cn&iOSTcu 
B* .11 16* ig-iv, W hiw l\ «<t &**& C. II 26. m post n? om B. II 29- ph om BC. II ^a* AC. II 30. ify ht h<u B. II 
31. oXci ti kcx\ C. II 33. M B. II &] o% to C. II 39. wf,ip\rM B. ... 



8 KATHTOPIAI. 

pshcu Kcu 70 Tcofxa (toov ydp oit$y\tuiv 70 Tcofxa) , tco- 7rpcg ti Troog e%ew, KaKe?vo ci$e Trpcg o touto to? «%ei* 

JM.CCT0? <5e fxr] ovrog dvatpe?Tai kou y\ a1.T$r\Ttg, oocje <rvv- el yap ovk oTfrev oKoog Trpcg o touto ttw; e%e«, ovfr' el 

avatpe? 70 atT$r(rcv 7vjv oit$y\tiv. y\ §( ye aiT$r\Ttg to nxpo<; n 7roog e%ei e'i<re7cu. kcu e7r\ tcov kcc$' e^acja 6% $%- 

cu<r$Y[7ov ov Tvvavatpe?' £wk ydp dvatpe$(vrcg cu<r$vi<rig fxev Kov to Toiotrrov, olov Tofre 7i el oTfre d(pcopiTfx(vcog oTi ecji 

dvatpe?rai, cu<t$yi7cv <fe ecjat, otov Toofxa, $epfxov, yKvKv, 5 hTrKaTtcv, kcu ot\s frnrKaTtov ecjtv ev$vg d<pcoptTfx(voog oT- 

7riKp6v, kou TaKKa 7rccv7cc oTa ecj\v atT$r,Ta. ht y\ /xev <5ev* el yap fxr\frevog 7oov d<pooptTfx(voov cTfrev av7c btTrKa- 

cu<r$Yi<rt<; afxa 700 atT$r\TtKOp yiveTaf dfxct ydp tw "Qcooo <riov, ov<¥ el SnrKaTtov ecjtv oKcog oThv. ooTavTcog <fe kcu 

yivercu koCi a'i<r$vi<rt? m to <5( ye a'tT$r,Tov ecji kcu irpo tov Tofre Tt el oTbev oti KaKKtcv icjt, xcu "ctcv KaKKtov ecjtv 

Ycocv y) cJ<r$Yi<rtv eTvcu' Trvp yap kcu vfroop kcu too TOtavTa, ev$vg d(pooptTfx(vcog dvcoyKcuov elhevat <$ta toovtcu cvk do- 

e£ oov kcu to XJuov TvvtcjaTat , ecjt kcu irpc tS Xuoov oKcog 10 picjoog <fe etreTcu oti tkto ecjt "Xjetpovog KaKKtov. v7r6K.Y\^ptg 

eTvcu y\ cu<r$Yi<rtv, oocje TrpoTepov dv Tr\g cUT$r\Teoog to atT$r\- yap to toicvto ytveTcu, cvk e7rtcjr\fxr\' & yctp ert aKptfioog 

tcv eTvcu frojretev. e't<reTcu oti ecjt %jeipovo<; KaKKtov. el yap cvrcog Itu^Ev, 

^%et (fe dTroptciv TroTepov ov^efxich-ov<r{<% toov Trpog ti ovSev ecji x/tpcv ctuTK. ucje (pavepcv oti dvayKcuov ecjtv, 

KeyeTcu, Koo$oo7rep froKe?, y\ tovto ev^xeTcu katol Tivag o dv etfrr, Ttg toov Trpog ti d<pcopt<rfx,evoog, K&Ke?vo Trpcg b 

7cov <$ev7epoov v<rtcov. erri fxev ydp 7cov 7rpoo7cov &<rtoov dXr r 15 \eye7cu d(pcopt<rfxevcog eifrevou. 7y\v <$l ye Ke(paSKY[V kou t*iv 

$eg ecjtv' «Te yccp Tct oAct «Te Tct fxepr[ Trpog 7t \eye7cu. 'X J e?poi kcu eKcujcv 7oov 70tov7cov, ci el<rtv ov<rtcu, cujto /xev 

6 yap Ttg c\v$pco7rog ov KeyeTcu Ttvog Ttg dvSpcoTrcg, ovSe %7rep ecj)v coptTfxevcog ecjtv elbevat, Trpcg o <^e KeyeTat, ovk 

6 t!s fiovg 7tvog 7-tg fiovg. oo<rav7oog $e Ka\ 7a fxepY[' y[ dvayKa?ov. 7tvog yap av7Y[ y[ Ke<pa\Y\ y\ 7tvog y\ %etp, xk 

ydp 7tg %e\p ov \eye7at 7tv6g 7tg x/tp dKKa 7tvog %et/3, ecjtv etfrevat oopt<rfxevcog. oocje yk dv etY[ TavTa tcov Trpog xL 

Kat v[ Ttg Ke<pa\Y[ ov XeyeTat Ttvog Ttg Ke<pa\.Y[ aKKa 20 el <Je y,Y[ ecjt Tca/ra. tcov Trpcg ti, d\r\$eg av etY[ Keyevv 

Ttvog Ke<paky. oo<ravTu>? <fe Ka\ e7r\ toov SevTepuov ovcrtoov, oti x&sfxta itrta toov 7rp6g rt ecjtv. "ivcog 8k %aXe7roV 'J7rep 

e7Tt ye tcov 7rXetcju>v, oTov 6 dv$poo7rcg « XeyeTat Ttvcg <xv- tcov 70tov7cov <r<potycog d7ro<paive<r$at fxr] 7roKhax.tg eVre- 

$poo7rcg, &<fe o jSou? 7tvcg (2ovg, «<Je to fyjhov Ttvog %v\ov, (TKefXfxivcV to fxevTci $tr,7ropYiK(vcu e<p' eKctcjov avTuv ovk 

dKkd Ttvog KTr,fxa KeyeTat. eTrffxev «v toov TotovToov (pa- axpYi$6v ecjtv. 

vepcv^oTt ovk ecjt tcov Trpog Tt' i7f' evicov §e tcov bevTepoov 25 WotcTrjra <Je Xeyco Ka$' r\v Trotot Ttveg etvat heyovTat. 8 

ov<rtcov ex,et dfX(pir^YiTY,Tiv, oiov v\ KetyaXr, Ttvog KeyeTat ecjt 8e y\ 7rotcTrtg tcov 7rXeovaxu>g Keycfxevcov. ev fxev cvv 

Ke<pa\rt Ka\ v[ x ei P T ' vo? Xeyercu- X £l P Kct< eKacjov toov eTS~og TrotcTrjrcg e^tg KOt $td$e<rtg \ey(<r$oo<rav. <$ia<pepei 8e 

TOtxToov, oocje TctuTco toov Trpcg Ti &o£eiev av eTvat. el fxev e^tg ha$(<reoog too ttoKv XP CV1 ^ 7£ P 0V mm k& 1 f^ovtfxcoTepov. 

Zv tKavoog 6 toov Trpog ti optcfxcg aTroMboTat, y[ toov iravv roiavTat $e ai te e7rtcjr\fxat Ka\ a\ dpeTai' y\ Te ydp errt- 

X&Xe7rcov r\ toov do\ivaToov ecjt To t^eT^at oog ifrefxia i<ria 30 cjY\fxr\ &OKe? tcov 7rapafxovifxcov eTvat kcu S^jtkiv^toov, edv koi 

tuv Trpog Tt KeyeTat' et $e [xy[ UaVoog, aKK' ecjt to. Trpog fxeTpioog Ttg e7ricjYifXY,v Kafty, edv Trep fxr\ fxeydKr, fxeTa- 

ti cig to eTvat Tamov ecjt tu> Trpog t{ Trcog e%e/v, 'iroog dv fioKr] yevrrat vtto votov y\ aKKov Ttvog Totovrti' wravToog 

prfietr, Tt Trpog ctuT*. 6 Se TrpoTepog optTfXog 7rapaKoKov$e? <$e koi r\ dpeTri, oTov Y[ btKaiorvvr, Ka\ y[ roocpporvvri koi 

fxev TraTt Tc?g Trpcg ti, ov fxry Tamov ye ecjt rui Trpog ti eKacjov tcov rotovToov, ovk evK{vr,Tov froKe? eivat ovrf ev/xe- 

avTc?g eivai to ctuTct a7rep ecjtv ejepoov Keyer$at . Ik he 35 TaftoKov. S~ta$(retg 3e KeyovTat a ecjiv evKtvrjra ko\ Tct^t) 

toutwv frr[Kov ecjtv cti eav Ttg ei<Kj ti ooptTfxevcog toov Trpcg fxeTafiaKKovTa, oTov $epfxoTY[g kcu KaTa^pvfyg jcctl voTog 

rt, KaKe?vo Trpcg o KeyeTai ooptTfxevcog etreTat. (pavepcv koi vyieta kcu ora aKKa TotavTa' haKevrat fxev ydp 

fxev ovv Kat ejr amcov ecj{v. el ydp oTS~( Ttg Tofre ti oti 7roog KaTa TctuTct? o dv$punrog, Tct^O <Te. fxeTafiaKKet e.K 

ecjt toov Trpog Tt, ecjt fe to sTvat To?g Trpog 7t 7av7cv tw $epfxov ^vxpzg yevcfxevog Kat e.K 7ov vytaivetv eig to vo- 

1. a,(c--6j)T^ xuX to BC. II 2. av^jpijrat B. II 5. aWjJpjjTcu B, a.voupiiTXi oclaSrjcv h\ 'i corr C. II hfti C. II 6. eu<r$yiToi om C. II 

7. tw ^wa/] H^wioy re B. ll 9. ^ov % om B. II eXvoct ante rj ponit C. II 10. <nmV*T*i to oX<t$y]t'ov Igt pr B. \\ 26. oTov el i) C- II 
32. t£>] to II 34. TauTo B, tSts C et corr A. II to BC et corr A. II 35. tw pr C. II 39- rf] to A. 

4. «'] £(' ti; C. II 8. k?iv a.<pupi<rptm; .xo& BC. II 11. to&tov. C. II lL o]ctiB..\\.IoIiAB. II 15. a&WJ dwjxoiiov slUvxt ABC. II 

16. cu B. II 22. kiTS<jvtsfA,jA.viuv pr C. II 28. [ionfiUTspov xou xponuTepov wou C. II 30. koii v.cCi] koii ts B, kii A. II 38. y.x,tovito\$ B. II 
39. ^(v^evfl; B. 



KATHTOPIAI. 9 

treTv, uTcivrug <fe kcu stti ruv a,kkuv, et fxv\ rtg Kat a,v- orY\Ta,g 7re7rcv$evat rt ' ovre yap ro fxikt ru 7re7Tov$ivai n 
ruv riruv rvyx^ VOi $ l< * t XP 0V0V TrkY^cg y\6\ 7re<pv<riufxevY\ kiyerat ykvKv , »re ruv dkkuv ruv rotovruv vfriv. ofxotug 

KOA dvi&TOS Y\ 7TO.VV SvTKtVYJog CVTO,, Y\V OtV Ttg t<TU$ ejflV <fe TKTOtS KOt Y\ $epfX0TY\g KCU y\ ^pvxP 07 ^ 7ra,$Y\rtKa,) 

Y t 6\\ TtpoTctyopevot. cpavepov 6~e ort ravra, (Bovkovra,i ezetg 7rotoTY\Teg kiyovrcu ov ru a,vrd rd o^e^eyfxiva. TreTrov- 
kiyetv, <% ecrt TrckvxpovtUTepa. xcu $v<rKtvY\TOTepa.' tvs yap 5 Uvat rt, ru <fe Kard rdg ai<r$Yi<reig eWg-vjv ruv etpvjfxi- 
ruv etrtcjYiixuv [xy\ Travv Ka,Texovra,g dkk' evKiVY\rcvg ovrag vuv ttoxotyituv 7rd$<tg etvcu 7rotY\TiKY)v 7ra$Y\riKa,) 7rotoTY\Teg 

■>/ , VY '/ /■ Sk. jf / / V \ s / . " \ , / /A \\/v/ 

ov <pa<riv efyv £%£<v, Kcttrot otaKetvrat ye irug Kara, ty\v Keyovrat y\ tz yctp ykvKVTY\g 7ra,6og rt Karra, ty\v yevrrtv 
e7rtcryfXYiV v\ x e fy ov ^ ftikrtov. ucrs <fia<pepet sfyg o^taQivsug sfxiroist kcu y\ $spfxoTY\g Ka,rd rv\v a,<pY\v, o/xoiug §e kcu 
ru ty]v fxev svKtVYiTOV efvcu, ty)v <fs Trokvxpovturipav re KO,t cu a,kkai. ksvKCTY\g <$s kcu fxska-via, kcu cu dkkat %pota\ 
b^vTKtvYirorepav. sl<r) <fs at fxev efcetg kou 6~ta$i<reig, a\ $e 10 ov rov a,vrcv rpoTrov rotg eipYjfxevcig 7ra$Y\rtKa) 7rctoTY\reg 
friaStreig ovk e^ dvayKY\g e^etg' ct fxev yap e^etg exovreg keyovrat, dkka, ru a,vrag OjTto 7ra$ovg yey ovevcu. ort /xev 
Kat cftaKetvrat ye Trug kOjT a,vra,g, ot <Te ^taKeifxevoi ov %v ytvovra,t $ta, 7ra,$og 7roKkcu fxera,^>cKa,t ^w^orwv, ^- 
TrdvTug kcu efyv exovTtv. XoV alcrx^^ y&P ri $ epv$pog eyevero kou (po^Y^eU 

c/ Erepov <?e yevog 7rctorYiTog ko,$' o 7rvKTtK%g y\ tyofxt- uxpog koa eKacrcv ruv tciktuv ucre kou et rtg <pv<ret ruv 
K%g Y[ vytems y\ vorucfeig Keyofxev, ko,\ a,7rkug oca, Ka,ra,15 rotxruv rt 7r<x$uv 7re7rov$ev eK,rtvuv <pv<rtKuv crvfXTrrufxa.- 
6\jva,fxtv <pv<rtKYiv y\ a,o\iva,fxtav Xeyerou. ov yap ru <fta,- ruv, ty\v hfxciav xP 0ia - v eiK0 ^ & v £ X slv *^ov Y\rig yap 
Ke7<r$at ye Trug sKacrov ruv rcicvruv Trotov r\eyera,t, cikkaj vvv ev ru a,\o-x^ v $^ v ^ $ta$eo~tg ruv Tfept ro <rufxa, eyeverc, 
ru b\>va,fxtv £%s*v cpvctKYtv y\ a,o\jva,fxtav rov 7roiY\ra.t rt kcu ko,to, <pv<rtKYiv <rvcra,<riv v) o,vty\ yevotr ctv, ucre cpvcet 
pctfrtug y\ fXY^ev 7racrx eiV i mw •rvKTtKo) v\ tyofxiKo) ov ru kcu ty)v xp oia,v ofxotav y{yveo-$a,i. ora, /xev »v ruv toivtuv 
<ftaKe?o-$at Trug keyovra,t dkka, tw $vva,fxtv e%£iv <pv<rtKYiv 20 crvfX7rrufxa.ruv a,7ro rivuv 7ra,$uv 6^jo-kivyituv kcu 7ra,pa,fxc- 
rov 7rotYi<rat rt pafrtug, vyteivo) Se keyovrcu ru 6\iva,fxtv vifxuv r\\v dpxYiv etkY\<pe, 7ra,$YiTixa,) 7rotoTY\reg keyovrcu. 
eXstv <pv<riKr,v tov jxyjSsv 7ra,o-xstv V7T0 ruv rvxovruv pa,- etre yap ev tyi Ka,ra. <pv<rtv <rvcrcL<ret uxporv t g y) fxekOjvia, 
Siug, vo<ru£eig <fe ru a,o\iva,fxiav ex^tv cpvrtKYiv rov fxyfrh yeyevYirat, 7rotoTY\Teg keyovrat {jroto) ydp Ka,rd ravrctg ke- 
7rd<rx £iV p&biug v7ro ruy rvxovruv. cfxoiug Se rovrctg kcu yofxe$a), e'tre §ta, vocrov fxaKpav y\ frtd Ka,vfxa, ro a,vro 
to o-KkYipcv kx) to [xakaKcv l%£i * to fxsv yap a-Kkypcv 25 T6T0 <rvfx$e@)Y\Kev uxpoTY\g y\ /xekcivta, ko,) /xy) pqcfiug a,7ro- 
kiyerai ru b\jva,fxtv £%£iv tou fxr) pqbiug frtaipsTfr^ai , ro Ka$icra,vrat y\ Kat bta, fitv Trapafxiv^o-t, TrotoTYiTsg ko,) av- 
6% fxakaKov ru dSvva/xiav l%£iv t« a,vrk rtvi. ra\ kiyovra,t' cfxotug yap Trotot Kara, ravTa,g ksyo/xsSa,. 

Tpirov <fe yivog 7rotoTY\Tcg 7ra,$YiTtKoi 7roioTY\reg koa ocra, <fe oXtto pqfriug frtakvcfxivuv koi ra,xv a.7roKa$icra,fxi- 
7rd$Y,. ecrt <fe ra, rota^e ciov ykvKvTY t g re ko.) 7rtKporY\g Ka) vuv yivera,t, 7ra$Y\ keyerat, 7rotoTY\Teg <fe «* « ydp kiycvrai 
<rpv<pvoTYig Kai 7ra,vTa, ra, Txroig <rvyyevY\, ert <fe $epfxorYig 30 ixotci rtveg Kara, ravra-g. »T£ yap o epv$piuv foa, ro ad- 
Kat ^vxpoTY\g Ka) kevK0TY\g koi fxekavia,. crt fxev w a,v- <rxw$Y\vat epv$piag keyera,t, kte o uxpiuv foa, ro <pc^Y\- 
rat TrctoTYcrig el<rt, <pavepov rd ydp frecfeyfxeva, a,vrd Trotd $Yiva,t uxpi&g, dkka, fxakkov 7rs7rcv$iva,t rt. ucrs 7ra,$Y\ fxev 
kiyerat Kar avrag, ofov to fxekt ru ykvKVTY\Ta, frefrix- ^d rctavra, keyerai, 7roioTY\reg he k. hfxciug <fe Tcvrcig 
$at ykvKv kiyerat Kat ro. crufxa, k&JKcv ru kevKoTYjTO, S~e- koi Karct ty\V ^ajx^ 'T&Qyitmcu 7rotoTY\reg Kat 7ra,$Y\ ks- 
&ix$cu' ucavTug frs Kat S7rt ruv dkkuv -sxst. 7ra$Y\riKa,) 35 yera,t. c<ra, yap ev ty\ yevicret ev$vg diro rivuv ira$uv 6\i<r- 
<fe 7rcioTY\Teg keyovrat « ru avra, ra, ^e^eyfxiva. rdg irci- KtvY\ruv yeyivY(rat,, 7rotoTY\reg keyovra,t, olov v\ r& fxavtKYi 

2. ru7%oiv£t C. II A. Trpocrct.yopEvo-Ei A, jTpc<rct.<yope-jo-oi B. II 5. 7&p tu, tmv rc C. II . 6. 'cvrxg om C. II 7. 7^ om C. II 9- to ph — 

TO 8~k jTO\VXpOnvTSpoV T£ J£«i 8~UCTXiy»ITflT£p(5V B ' C. II 12. ^S OITl C. II XXToL TWJTOf BC. II 16. XlyoVTOU C. II TO A. II 17. ^i Om C. W jTOih 

ova.BC. II 19- Tro-flsH' C. II 20. XiyovTcu ante i (19) ponunt BC. II <\>vimy\v om C. II 21. pouftu? y y.v\hh 7r*ff%ety v^. B. \\ htjTsB. II 
23. toI] fou, to A. II pj&sv 7r«ff%£iv corr C. II 24. pochw? om C. II u7ro t£jv tv%ovtojv om B. II 26. rCf\ to B. II 27. t£] toAB. II 29. te 
omC. II alteram kou om C. II 30. h\] h\ xati C. II 31. oZtou Tra^Tixcti sribetjTiS C. II 32. ocvto, om B etpr A. II 33. Xtyoncu xxrol 
Tovro-s C. II 34. XiysTou ^Xvxv C. II 35. eyji om C. 

2. ihe A. II 7. ts om C. II 11. malim ocvtcu. f| ^zvrjO-Qou C. II 18. av hi^eci? &fr C. II 21. Traflxnxai om B. II 23. flvrircu, 

■KOiOTYfi Xl«/£TCU C. II 24. OCVTO TVTo] TO&TOV C. II 26. OCVTCU C. II 29. Xi^OVTOU A. II #«6TjfT*S Ss « ODl B et pi' A. II 30. T*-JT* 

C. II 32. /J.CX/O.0V tu TrtwovQivou ABC. II 33 et 34. Xi^ovTou C. II 35. cW] ha, ^ev B, oVct Te C. II i#i\<rti B. II EvQjgomAC. II hv<r- 
xrniXdr» om BC. II 36. ypylvrivTou C. II Xfyovrau xou ocvtou oiov C. 

B 



10 * KATIITOPIAI. 

Ixcjao-Lg kol) y\ hpyv] kcu t<* TotavTa' 7Colc) yap KOra tcvj- Tcapoovvfxoog heyeTai' « yctp ksTtoll ovofxaTa TaTg Svvafxeo-L 
Tag hiyovTai, hpyihoi ts kcCl fxaviKci. cfxoioog <$e koll o<rcu kol$ cXg \stoi tcolol XeyovTcu, oo<T7C£p Tcug ixLcjvifxaLg kcjl^ 

SKCjdoSLg fX% (bvO-LKCli, dhh' oL7rO TLVOOV dhhpOV CTVfX7CT00fXa- c\g 7TVKTLK0L V\ TTahaLCjpLKCL KCLTOL $LCi,Qso-lV hsyoVTaf 7TVK- 

TOOV ysysWtVTCU o\j<ra7cdhhaKT0l Y\ KCU "ohoog CKKiwiTOL, 7X0L0- TLKY\ ycip XsyST&L S7CLCyVifXVI KOLL 7XCU\cKLCjpLKV\, 7T0LOL £' cLtTO 

TVjTSg KCU Tcl TOLOVTa' TTCLo) ydp KClTcl TCVJT&g KsyoVTCU. 5 TOVTOOV TCapOOVVfXOOg 01 frtaKsifXSVOL XsyOVTClL. SViOTS <5"e KCU 

OCTOL $S OL7T0 Tdp^V O.7T0KCt6lCJ-0LjULSV00V yivSTOLl, 7T0,$VI KtysTOLl, OVOfJ.OLTOg KSLfASVV H XsysTCU 7TO,pOOVVfX'jOg TO KOLT OLVTViV 

otov ei hvTTKfAsvog TLg opyLhooTspog ecjtv vcfl ydp hiysTai ttolov heyo/xevov, olov oltto t*5? dpsTv^g o cnr^oLLog' tw ya,p 
opyihog o sv tootol4tu) 7Tcl&sl opyihoorepog oov, cLhha, fxah- dpsTv^v s^slv <r7rtsc\aTcg hsysTcu, dhh' \s Tcapoovvfxoog o\tto 

hOV 7TS7T0V$SVCU Tl. U/CJS 7Ca$Yl fXSV hsysTCLl TCt T0LO.VTO,, TY\g 0,pSTV\g. \SK ilTL 7T0hho0V $£ TO TOLXTOV icjlV. 7T0LOL TOL- 
TTOlOTViTeg <? «. 10 VVV hsySTOLL TCt TTapOOVVfXOOg OL7T0 TOOV elpv\fX£V00V TTOLOTVfCOOV 

ThapTov <5e yevog 7roLOTY\Tog cr^uct ts koll y\ 7T£pi h£yo/x£va v\ o7coo<riv ahhoog dic avToov. 
exacjov V7cdpxjjv<ra [jLop<f)vi, eTi $e Tcpog TovToig evbvTY\g 'T7rcto;£ej- Ss kol) svolvtlotys kolto, to ttolov, olov <5j- 

KCU Ka,fJL7TVhOTY t g , KCLL SL Tl TOVTOig OfXOLCV SCJIV. KO,$' SKO,- KaL0<TVVY\ OL^LKLOL eVctVTJOV KO.L hsVK0TV\g fXShoLVLOL KO.L TOLhha, 

(jov ydp tovtoov ttolov tl hiyeraL' to yap Tpiyoovov v t T£- b% ooo-ajvToog, ko,l to, kolt avToog ttolo, h£yo/x£va,, oiov to 

Tpa,y0OV0V eTvoU TTOLOV TL hsySTCLL, Kai TO SvSv . Y\ Ka,f/^7Tvh0V. 15 a,$LKOV TW C^LKOLLCO KOLL TO hSVKOV TU> fXShOLVL. 0VK S7TL 7T0,V- 
KOLL KOLTO, TY\V fXOp(pY\V $S EKOLCTOV 7T0L0V TL hiy£TO,L. TO Ss TOOV &S TO TOTSTO' TU> yO-p TTVppoO Y\ OO^PV *1 Tct ^ TOLOAJ- 
fXCtVOV KOLL TO 7TVKV0V KOLL TO TpOLyp KCU TO hsToV (fo^SLS TOLLg ^O/Ct?? icfsV SVOLVTioV TTOLolg i(TLV. STl $S, SOLV TOOV £VO,V- 
fXSV OLV 7T0L0V TL 0^V\fXO,iv£LV , £OLKS $£ cihhoTpLO, TCt TOiCtUTl* TLOOV $CLT£p0V Yj 7T0L0V , KO,) TO hOLTTOV £CJO,L 7T0LOV. TKTO 0£ 

iTvcu tys Tcep) to ttolov S~Loupi(reoog' &i<riv yd,p fxdhhov tlvo, frvihov Trpo-XjsLpLX^ofxivoo Ta,g dhha,g KOLTYiyopLOLg, olov ei ecjLV 
(pa,iv£T0Li toov fxopioov eK&Tepcv bvihovv. TTVKVov /xsv ydp too 20 v\ &LKcuo<rvvY\ tv\ dc^LKia, evcLVTiov, 7tolov £s y, (\lkolioq-vvyi, 
Tct fxopLO, trvvsyyvg sTvcu dhhv\hoLg, fxa,vcv b% tco $lscjo,vcu ttolov apa, kcu y\ d$LKia,' \sc\sfxia, ydp toov dhhoov KO,TV\yo- 
ct7T dhhvihoov' koa hsLov fxsv tw s7c svQsiccg Tcoog Tct fxo- pioov scpapfxoosL ty\ dc^LKia,' %TS yap to tcovov »re to Trpog 
pia, KsTcrScLL, Tpa"/p cfs too to fx\v v7repixj£LV to <Je ih- tl «Te 7r« \s$ ohoog tl toov tolktoov &$iv, dhh' v\ ttolov. 
hsiiT^LV. oo<ra,vToog <5e kal £Ti toov ahhoov toov xctTct ts 71'oioi' evcty- 

J/ I<roog fx\v Tsv xa) ahhpg dv TLg (pav^ivj TpoTrog iroLOTYr 25 tloov. 
Tog, dhh' oi ye fxdhicja heyofxsvoi trx^ov XsToi sl<riv. 'Y/KL^ixsTaL $s to fxahhov kol to yjctov Tct Troict. 

TioLOTYiTsg fx\v %v £L<r)v al £Lpv\fxivaL, 7coia c% Tct xa- hsvKov yap fxahhov Kai y\ttov eTspov hspov heysTai, Kai 
Tet TctuTct? Tcapoovvfxoog hsyofxsva yi o7Coo<riv dhhoog ct?r ctu- o^tKaLOV hepov hep>s fxahhov. Kai avTo cfe e7ci(>o<rLV hafxfia- 
toov. S7c) fxsv tfv toov Tchsicjoov kcu o-)(,sc\ov e7c) TcdvToov Tca- vsl' hsvKov yap ov £TL ivSep^eTai hevKOTspov ysvi<r@aL. ov 
poovvfxoog hiysTai, oTov ct7ro t>j? hsvKOTvjxog hsvKog xa) aTco 30 7cavTa <5e, ctXXct Tct 7chsTcja. $LKaLO<rvvvi yap t\LKaLO<rvvvig 
Tv\g ypafXfxaTLKv\g ypafXfxaTLKog xa) aTco T>5f o\KaLO<rvvvig el hsysTai fxdhhov Kat yjctcv, a7ccpvi<rsLsv av TLg' dfxoioog 8e 
^ixaLog, ooravToog $£ kol) etc) toov ahhoov. ex ivioov §£ Std kcu £tcl toov ahhoov ^tadi<r£oov. Ivlol yap hafX(pL<r\2>Yfc>s<ri 
To fxv\ xiTrQat TaTg 7coLOTY\<rLV ovifxaTa \sk iv^i^sTat xct- 7re<3i toov tol\stcov' $iKato<rvvYiv /xev yap friKaLOfrvvvig « 7rctn; 
poovvfxoog a-Tc avToov hiyso-Qai, oTov bpofXLKog y) 7CVKTLKog d (par) frsTv hiysoSai /xahhov kol v\ttov, «<5e vyisiav vy.siag, 
xctTct frvvafxiv (pv<riKv)v hsyofxevog ct7r' ifrefXLag TCOLOTYfcog 35 vjttov fxivToi sxslv eTepov hip* vyieiav, k^l o^LKaiorvvviv ere- 

2. eVcti] caxi %KKm C. II 4. <tXhu<; B. II 5. 7*p] 7*p Kftfc C. II Xiyonoci. bpythoi te xctX fMnxot. otrct, B. II 6. <X%o \,u,i¥tw; y.cti T&yjj C. II 
7. fvi om jBL II liriv] ^evjjrcw C. II «<%] s C. II 8. pSCXXov t£ xskoMim C. II 9- Myonou. C. II 15. %] rj xoti C. II x#.[a,7fS\oy tha hx\ 
AB. II 16. ti om C. II 1S. Tt om A. II 19- fMclXXoy om C. II 20. ixa.<?ov C. II v^p Xi^erou -ru C. II 25. 9.1 rtg om C. II 26. roav- 
W BC. II 27. xcit olvtcI; C. |l 30. Ksvxbs] b Xsvxb? C. qui et mox b ^pa^ccTixs? et o ^txcuog. II 34. oiov b fyopixb? v\ b tv. C. 

2. Toctg] xcu teLts C. II 4. £7riipjju.-/! Xkfe&u C. II 5. hcL^ntv l%onz<; C. II 7- Xryopmv om C. II 9- Totnv] «v C. II 10. 7rocpa;vuju.wf rcl 
AB. II 14. 8-V om C. \\ xoltcI tcvjtols B. II UAiTois h\ X^ofjtevc», notl C. II l6. toiStov C. II 17- *biv e<fiv kvo.niov C. \\ bz om C. II 
19- ftriXov kx tSv xct,S' ixocg-a, 7rpo%. C. II 22. xts ycif] owv ww C, Ztz B. II 25. tt»] to tts C. II i<Y AB. II ti om C. II %] i) Ti3 
C. II 26. Oe] 6 s z xciX BC. II 27. xm y\TTOv om B. II 28. cWjorepoy A. II irepov fripv y.cZK\ov] juotXXoy hepov kripv Xi^erxi B, hzpov 
hifn X^jtocj fjccZXXov xa,\ vjttoy C. II txvtcx, C. II Ittitolq-ly C. II 29. Iv^eraj erj C. II 31. hfyitro B. II xa\ t,ttov om B et pr A. II 
33. hxa,to<rjYr\ B. II 34. (pcccA fj.cZXXov xod v\ttov Xiyea-Qcu C. II 35. vytei&v - fcipvl v^ieiciv (jjolcti xcCl cJixolioctvv^v y.ttoy hipov krip* i%etv C. 



K A T H T O P I A I. 11 

pov hepv, obravToo? &e kcu ypa,fxfxa,TiKY\v ko,i Ta,g dkka,g 'E7rj£e%eTctJ <5e kcu to noutv ko) to 7rct<r%e<v evctv- 9 

foo,$e<retg. dkk' «V T<L ys KCtTO, TCtUTCt? keyofXeVO, dvAfX- TIOTY\TO, KO,t TO fXO,kk0V KCU TQ YftTOV T0 ydp $£pfXO,lV£iV 

(pt<r$Y{tY\Tcog £7n&%eTcu to fxakkov ko,\ to y\ttov' ypa,fx- tw ^vx^iv havTtov ko,\ tq $epfxa,tve<r$cu too ^vxs<r$a,t kcu 

(XO.TlKCOTepog yclp ST£pog £T£/3« k(y£TO,l KO,t vyt£lVOT£pog KCU TO Yl$£lT$CU TU> kV7t£?<T$CU, %<?£ £7n£g%£TCU SVcCVTlOTYlTCt,. XCU 

dixcuGTepog, kcu S7t\ tu/v dkkoov oo<ra,vToog. Tptyoovov bs ytcu S to fxcikkov 3e kcu y\ttoV $epfxa,iveiv ydp fxak^.ov ko,\ y\t- 
T£Tpciyuvov « cfoKE? to fxakkov £iri$£X£V$cu , ifo toov a,k- tov scrt, kcu $epfxa,ive<r$a,i fxakkov kcu y^ttov. eTrtftexjeTcu 
koov o-xyifxciTcov ib^ev. to, fxh ya,p E7rt$£X° /*&<*' tov tk Tpt- iv to fxakkov kcu to y\Ttov tq 7toie?v kcu to TtLcrx^v. 
ytoYt kdyov v\ tov tk KVKKi 7ta,v$' ofxottog rptyoova, y\ kv- 'Titep fxev ouv tovtgov totuajta keyeTcu' e"tpY\Tcu <$e 

ytkot slcry, toov <£e fxr} htib^sx^htov »<Jev fxdkkov sTspov kcu virep tov Ke?tr$a,t sv To?g Ttpdg ti, oti 7ta,poovvfXtog et7ro 
ere/JK pY\$Y\<reTcu' icfh ydp fxakkov to Tsrtpayoovov t» erepo- 10 Ttov $e<recov keyeTcu. vTrep 8e toov kontobv, t« ts 7roTe kcu 
fx^Kxg KVKkog ecrtV b&eTepov ya)p e7rt^sx^cu tov rk kvkKs t« 7tk kcu t« e^eiV, frta, to 7tpo<pa,vY\ etvcu ib^h intsp a,v- 
kdyov. drtkoog cV, sdv fXYJ sTttfrsxYiTcu dfxcpoTspa, tov t» toov a,kko keyerat r\ ocra, sv cipxy eppe$Y\, oti to exetv fxh 
7TpoKstfX£Vti kdyov, « pY\$Y\o-£TO,t to sT£pov tk eTep» fAOjkkov. o m YifA,o,tv£i to v7roo£0£<r$a,i , to to7rkt<r$<JU , to <5e 7V6 ofov ev 
i ttLvto, ovv to, Trotd, exf<5e%eToii to fjtcikkov kcu to y\ttov. Kvkuoo, Ka,t to, a,kka, <5e 'ora, vTrep o,vtoov eppe$Y\. 

Twv fJth ovv £tpY[fJO£Voov io^h to^tov 7roioTY\Tog, ofxota, &e 15 'T7rep' f^ev »v twv 7rpoTs$svroov yevoov ikcovo, to, elpY r 10 

ko,} dvdfjtota, ko,tL fjodvcog Tdg 7rotoTY\Ta,g keyeTcCi' of^oiov fxeva,' Trept <Je twv ctvTijtejjaevwv, 7ro<ra.x^ s'too$sv dvTtKei- 
ydp sTspov hipoo *k £<?i jcctT cikko ^ev y\ ko,$' o 7rotov c$a,t, pY[Tsov. k£y£TO,t <5e eTepov eTepw dvTtKe?cr$a,i TeTp&xw, 
ecrtv. oocre tfrtov dv stY\ ty\s 7rotoTY\To? to r 'ofxotov KO,t dvo- *j oog to, Trpoq Tt, v\ tog to, iva,vTta,, v\ obg cr/pvio-ig kcu s^tg, 
fjtotov keyeo-$cu kcit ccvty\v. y\ oos Ka,Ta,(pa,crig KO,t d7ro<pa,<rtg. dvTuetTai §s skcocjov toov 

Ov fe? <^e Ta,pa,TT£cr$a,i , fxv\ Ttg Y\fJta,g (pY\rvj \nrep 20 tomtoov oog tvttoo etTretv tog fxev to, 7rpog ti, oTov to frnrka,- 
TrotoTYiTog ty]v 7rpo$ecrtv 7rotY\o-a,fJtevtig Trokka, tcov irpog ti crtov to Yifxtcret, tog b% to, evavTta,, oTov to ko,kov too dya,$u\ 
cvyKO,Ta,pt$fX£t(r$a,f Tdg ydp s^etg kcu §~ta,$ecretg toov Trpog tog b\ to, ko,to, crspYi<riv ko,\ e^tv, oTov Tv<pkoTY\g Kcxt t"d,tg, 
7t etvcu ekiyofxev. trx^ov ya,p stti 7ra,vToov toov toimtcov to, ug <^e KO,Tacpa,o-tg Kctt d7ro(pa,crtg, oTov kL$y[Tch - « ko,$y[Tcu. 
yevv\ Trpdg ti keyeTctt, toov cfs ko,$' sKctcra, »<5ev. y\ fxsv ya,p "Otra, fX£V »v obg to, Trpog Tt dvTtK£iTO,t, avTd a,7rep 

hrtqYifirt], ysvog \<ra,, cwto 07rsp scrlv hsp* ksysTcu (Ttvog 25 scrt toov dvTiKetfxevoov keyeTcu y\ O7roocriv dkkwg Trpog o,vt<L, 
ydp e7rt<7YifjtY\ keyeTcu), toov <5e ko,$' skclcto, b&h o,vto "oTrep otov to <)t7rka,<rtov, covto o7rep scrtv, hspov $t7rka,<rtov keyeTcu' 
scrlv hepx keyeTcu, oTov r\ ypa,fXfxa,TtKY\ « keyeTO,t Ttvog Ttvog ya,p btTrkcurtov. ko,i y\ s.7rtqY\fXY\ b\ too s7rtt7Y\Too obg t«6 
ypafXfxa,TtKY\ bc¥ v\ fxx<rtKY\ Ttvog fxy,<rtKY > dkk el a,pcu, Ttpog ti dvTuetTat, kcu keyeTcu ye y\ e7ricrY\fXY\ oiuto 07reo 
HctTct to ye^vo? kcu o,vto,i toov Trpog ti ksyovTou, otov v\ ecrt t» e7n<r*;T». ko,i to sTrtcrYjov §s o,vto owsp e<rl 7rpcg dv- 
yprxfXfxa,TiKY] kiy£TO,t Ttvog e.7rtcrY\fXY\, i Ttvog ypa,fXfxa,TiKYi, 30 ztKetfxevov key£Ta,t, ty\v kTricrYifXYcf to ydp sTrtcrYiTov tiv) keye- 
ko,\ y\ fxtriKY\ Tivog s7rtc;Y\fXY[ k(y£Ta,i, « Ttvog fxxcriKYi. oocre tcu s7rt<rY{rov, ty\ e7ricrY\fXY\. 

a,i Ka.$' sKO,cra, vk st<r\ tcZv Ttpog ti. ksyofxs$a, &e Ttotot "0<ra, w ctVT»teiTct< oog to, Ttpog ti, a,vTd a,7tep scr\v he- 

Tcug ko,$' eKctcra,' Ta,vTO,g ya,p kcu e^o/^ev s7ticrY\fxovsg ya,p poov keyerai v\ o7toog^Y\7toTs itptg dkkyka, keysTou. t& <Je obg 
keyofxe$a, tu e^eiv toov ko,$' sKO,cra, E7ticrY\fxoov tivcu docrs to, svcovtio,, ojvto, fxh c%7tep ecr\v icfotfxobg Ttpog a,Kkv\ka, ke- 
avTcu dv kcu TtQiGTYfteg eiYj<ra,v, a,l kcl$" sKcLcra,, ko,$' <Lg 35 yeTO,t, svavTta, fxsvToi dkkY\koov keysTcti' tns ydp to etyct- 
7roTe kcu Troiot ksyofxs$a,' o,vto,i Se &k el<r\ toov Trpdg ti. $tv t» ko,km keyerat dya,$dv, dkk' evavTtov, xTe to kevKOV 
£Tt £t Tvyx&voi to ctvTQ Ttpog ti Kcti Ttotov ov, ifev o.T07tov t» fxikavog k£VKOv , dkK evctvTiov. oocre tftcKpep^criv CWTClt 
sv dfx<poTepotg To?g yev£<rtv ojvto Ka,Ta,pt$fX£?<r$a,t. a,t dvTi$£T£tg dk>-.Y\koov. o<ra, Ss tgov svavTtoov toiojvtL £<riv 

1. 7pct i u 1 u6(.Ti^v yp&fipaTixyi; xuX C. II 3. alterum to om B. II 4. hy.Moxzco<; xch ^iEivcTspa? C. II 6. jjlS.XKov y.oci to y,ttoi kmt. C. II 
8. v tov] y.MTaC. II 9. ju.<*AXov ante \y\b{<iiTM C. II 14. \.-k\.U%ztm tci 7rcidt C. II 16. xo>X] rj C. II 17. 8k iy» srepoy hipoj C. II 18. t^? 
om C. II y.a\~\ »i C. II 20. (pycrii Ji. II 22. y.vX roi? t. C. II 23.kX(^oij.ev ante tmu ponit2?, om pr C. II ■Ka.crwv t£v toivtojv ttoiot^tojy tu. 
•y£v») tw itpos C. II 24. sWov C. II ^sv om A. II 28. a] r, corr AC. II 31. X^tww om C. II 34. nvoi; C. II 37. « om AB. II 38. mjto to?? yCvecnv C. 

5. fj.cZXXov y.c/X to r\TT0V C. II 6. y,ttov, y.x\ A-j-stcrScu pu.XKov y.ci\ rjrsv. in. C. II 22. m om C. II ofov] u<; ABC. II 25. Xt^ov- 
t*i C. II 26. u.vtc] tS rpfaeo; ciItc C. II 28. 75] h\ AB. II' 29. npU to cIvt. BC. II 32. inter erlpojv et XiysTou B locum relinquit 
litteris 4 aut 5. idem in margine habet t£v o\vTiy,eip(vojv. 

B2 



12 KATIirOPIAI. 

cocje h oTg 7re(pvxe ytveoSat vj oov xaTy\ycpe?rat dvayxa?ov §e i&afxwg Keyerat o avSpcoTrog. dvrtxe?rSat 8e xa\ Tavrct 
avrcov Sdrepov virdpx^v, r4rcov ifrev ecrtv dvd /xecov. cov M S~oxe?, ro scrspYjoSai xa\ to ty\v e^tv £%£iv, cog crepY\<rtg xa\ 

ye fAYi dvayxatov Sdrepov vrrdpxei-v, rircov e<rt rt dvd /xe- ejrtg' o yap rpoTrog TY,g dvrtSe<reoog 6 avrog' cog yap v\ tv- 

crov Trdvrcog, oTov vccog xa\ vyteta h <roofxari £wk 7re<pvxe (pKorY\g ty, o\pet dvrtxetrat, irco xcu to rv(pKov eivcu tw 

ytveoSai, xa\ dvayxa?ov ye Sdrepov vTrdpxew rco tk £wk 5 cp/tv e^etv dvrixetTcu. 

ccofxari, vj vccov vj vytetav. xcu Treptrrov Se xcu dprtov dptS- Ovx ecri &e iSe ro vtto ty\v a7ro(pa<riv xcu xara- 

fxov xctTYiyopeTrcu , xcu dvctyxcuov ye Sarepov rw dptSfxoo (pactv a7ro<pa<rtg xcu xara<pactg' v\ fxev yap xara<pa<rig 

v7rdpxeiv, v\ Treptrrov v\ ctprtov. xa\ ix ecrt ye txtcov ifrev Koyog ecrt xara<partxog xcu v\ d7rc<pa<rtg Koyog d7ro(pcLTt- 

dvd fxecov, tre voom xcu vytetag ire Treptrri xa\ dprtx. oov xog, rcov $e vtto ty\v xaracpactv xcu d7ro(pcLo-iv *ioev ecrt 

$s ye fxq dvayxatov Sarepov vrrapxetv, rxroov ecrt rt dvoL 10 Koyog. Keyerat $e xou ravra dvrtxe?<rSat dKKY t Kotg cog xol- 

fxerov, oTov fxeKav xcu Kevxov h ccofxart Trecpvxe ytve<r$at, ra(pa<rtg xa\ a7ro(pa<rig' xcu yap eVl tovtcov 6 rpcTrog TY\g 

xcu ix dvcLyxcuov ye Sarepov avroov inrapxetv rco <rcofxart' dvTtSeo-ecog o avrog. cog yap rrore v\ xcLTctcpcLo-ig Trpog tyiv 

i ydp rrav vrrot Kevxov v\ /xeKav ecrtv. xou (pavKov o% xa\ a7ro<pao-tv dvTtxetTcu, oiov to xcl$y,tcu tco » xclSyctcu, vtoo 

o-XMfraLtov xcLTY\yope?Tcu fxev xcCi xclt dvSpco7f6 xcl\ xcltcl xcu to v(p' exoLTepov TrpcLyfxcL dvTtxeiTcu, to xclSy,o-$cu tw 

clKKcov ttoKKoov, xx dvcLyxcuov fre Sdxepov clvtcov vTrcLpxeLV 15 fxv\ xolSyioScu. 

exetvctg oov dv xcLTYiyopYjcLt' i ydp ttolvtcl y\toi (pcLvKcL v\ c/ Oti <& v) qepY^o-tg xcu y\ e^tg ix dvTtxetTcu cog to, 

tnt^cLtcL ecriv. xcu ecrt ye Tt tktcov dvcL fxicrcv, oTov tk fxev Trpog ti, (pcLvepcV & yocp Keyercu olvto oTrep ecri tk clvti- 

Kevxx xcu [xeKcLvog to (pcuov xcu to coxpcv xcu otol dKKco xetfxevx. v\ yocp cpjtg xx ecrt TV(pKoTY\Tog o-pjtg, &&' cLKKcog 

XpOOfJLCLTOL, T« <^£ (pCLvKX XOLl (T7rK(Jctii< T0 »T£ (pCLvKoV »T£ ifrdLfJLOOg Ttpcg OLVTO KeyeTCU. COO-OLVTCOg fre i$e 7] TV(pK0TY\g 

CTTtibcuov. E7T htcov fjch %v ovofJcoLToL xe?Tcu Totg dvd fjcerov, 20 KeyotT olv TV(pKoTY\g cpjecog, dKKoc crlpYptg fxev cyecog y\ 
olov Kevxx xoli /xeKoLvog to (pcuov xcu To coxpw xcli ocol TV(pKcTY\g Keyercu, TV(pKoTY\g S~e o^eoog « KeyeTcu. ert tol 
clKKcl XPtofAoLToL' e7r htcov Se. ovofxcLTt fxev vx evTropov to rrpog ti ttclvtcl rrpog dvTtcrpecpovTcL Keyercu, uicre xcu v\ tv- 
dvd ueo-ov d7rocfivcu, ty, <^' excLTep* tcov cLxpcov d7ro(poL<ret (pKoTY,g enrep y\v tcov Trpog rt, dvrecrpe(pev dv xdxs?vo rrpog 
to dvd fxecov bpiXeTcu, oTov to kte dyocScv We xclxov xcu o KeyeTcu. dKK' ix dvrtcrpecpei' « yocp KeyeTcu v\ 'cpjtg 
%.Te Sixcuov '{rre cthxov. 25 TV(pKoTY\Tog o-pjtg. 

^TspYptg Se xcli efyg KeyeTcu fxev rrep) tolvtov tl> oTov e/ OTt fre icf cog tcl hcLVTtcL dvrtxetTou tcl xctrd crepn- 

Y\ 'cpjtg xcu v\ TV(pKoTY\g rrepi o(pScLKfxov' xclSoKx 8s elrre?v, ctv xcu efyv KeyofxevcL, ex rcovcfe $y\Kov. tcov fxev ydp hcLv- 
h u> v\ efyg 7ri(pvxe ytvecScu, 7rep\ tkto Keyercu exdrepov rtcov, oov fXY^ev ecrtv dvcL fxecov, dvcLyxouov, h Z 7re(pvxe 
clvtcov. ecrepYioScu c% rore Keyofxev exctcrov tcov TY\g e^ecog ytveoScu r, cov xcLTY\yope?Tcu , ScLTepov olvtcov vTroLpxeiv det' 
frexTtxoov, otolv h co 7re(pvxev vTrdpx™ k& 1 ° T£ ne^pvxev 30 tktojv yocp ifrh y\v dvcL fxecrov, cov Sovrepov y,v dvocyxcuov tco 
exetv fxv\t\cLfxoog v7rcLpx"A- vcociov Te ydp Keyofxev k to fxr, (iexTtxoo vircLpxew , oiov eirt vow xcu vytetag xcu 7reptTT6 
ex°v obcvTcLg, xcu TvcpKcv & to fxv\ £%ov o^tv, dKKd to xcli dprtov. cov c% ecjt ti dvcc fxecov, ic\e7roTe dvocyxYi ttclvti 
fXY\ exov oTe 7re(pvxev exeiv' Ttvd ydp ex yeveTY\g ktc 'cp/tv vTrapxetv ScLTepoV kte yap Kevxov y\ peKcLv dvayxYi Trav 
exet »T£ oc\oncLg, dKK' i Keyercu kt£ voofrd «T£ Tv(pKcL. etvcu to frexTtxov, ire Sepfxov ire ipvxP 0V ' ™™v yctp 
to Se ecrepYioScu xcu to ty]v ejrtv exetv ix ecrt crepY,<rtg xcu 35 dvd fxecov ti iSev xooKvet vircLpxew. errt 0% xcu tk- 
efctg. sjrtg- fxev ydp ecrtv y\ t-p/tg, crepY\<rtg Se y\ TV(pKoTY,g' tcov y\v ti dvd fxecov, cov jxyj dvayxcL?ov ScLTepov v7rcLpxetv 
to $e exerv ty]v c-pjtv ix ecrtv o-pstg, i£e to TvcpKov eTvcu y\v t£> frexTtxco, et /x-/\ oig (pvcet to ev v7rapxet, oiov 
7V(pKoTY,g. crepY,<rtg ydp Ttg y\ TV(pKoTYig ecrtv, to c% TV(pKov tco irvp\ to Sepfxco eTvat xat ty\ x iovl T0 ^evxYj. eirt Se 
eTvat ecrepY,<rSat, i crepYi<rtg ecrtv. ht el y,v y\ TvcpKoTYig Tcw3- tktwv d(pcopt<ryJvcog dvayxa?ov Sarepov v7rapxeiv, xat i% 
tov tco TV(pKov etvat, xaTY t yope?To dv dfX(porepa xard t«40 oTroTepov hvxev i yap hbexeTat tc irvp ^vxp^v etvat 
avri' aKKa TvcpKog fxev Keyerat 6 avSpcoTrog, TV(pKoTY\g ovcfe ty\v x iom fxsKatvav. cocre rravTt fxev ovx avayxvi 

11. Ix tu <7u>pa,Ti C. II 18. xoti tk y.il.<Mo<; C. II 28. £}* u\. «\ AB. II Tttyvv.v i\ e£i? C. II 35. !%£iv Tr[V e|iv C. 
9- xa v t] n C. II 16. & xoc\ v C. II 22. Mistou v¥ o^u TwpXcTyTo;. h\. rc C. II 30. w&ymlov b C II 34. -^vxpov vts fectxov C. II 
36. v GoiTspoy viroipxm C. 



KATHTOPIAI. 13 

too tfeKTiKco $arepov avToov vird,px m -> *^* /W-cvov oig <pv- tpavepov %Tt kclt i$(va toov elpv\fx(voov TpoTrcov dntKetTa? 
tret to ev v~rdpx £ h kcu TVTotg d<poopt~fx(voog ro ev Kat £% exi yap fxovcov tvtoov dvayKatov de\ to fxev aKv\$eg to §e 
oTxoTepov eTV%ev. eih tfe vfc c~epv\<reoog kcu TY\g eteoog it\e- ^pevtfog avToov eTvat. ire ydp e-ri toov ivantoov dvayKaHov 
Tepov toov elpv\fx(voov dKvi$(g' itfe yap det tw freKTtKU dvay- dei $arepov dKv\$eg eTvat Qcnepov cfe 'ipevcfog, »re e~r\ toov 
kcuov $dxepov avroov V7ra,p%etv' to yap . fxv,7xoo 7xe<pvKog 5 nxpcg Tt, \sts e7n t*j? efceoog kcu tvi? erepv,<reoog. otov v\ vyteta 
c^ptv exetv »re Tv<pKov KTe cp/tv e%ov Keyerat, oo~e iK dv kcu y\ vco~og evavrta, KO,t ifrerepov ye vre aKv\$eg «Te ipevt\og 
eh TO.VTO, toov TotxToov ivavrtoov oov it\(v ecrtv dva fxerov. ecrtv. oocavToog tfe kcuto tfi7xKao~tov kcu to v\fxt<rv oog tou Txpog 
dKK' itf Zv Tt ecrtv dva fxecrov dvayKOtov yap nxoTe Txavrt ti dntKeirat, ko,i ix. Kcriv avroov itferepov ire aKv\$eg «re 'p/ev- 
Tco tfeKTiKW $drepov avrcov v7xapx £ W %to,v yap vit\v\ Txe- t\o~. it\e ye to, ko-to, crepv\~tv xdi ejrtv, oTc? v\ ''cp/tg kcu y) 
(pvKog v\ o-pnv e^ejv, Tore v\ TvcpKov v\ o-p/iv e%oV pY\$v\ceTai, 10 TV<pKoTY\g. oKoog &e tcov kccto. fxv\t\efxtav cv[X7xKoky\v Keyofxe- 
Ka\ t&toov s-oc d<pooptcfx(voog $arepov, dKK^ OTXOTepov (tvx £V ' voov ifrev «tc aKv\$eg KTe ipevfrc' eq-tv' -rcLvra, o% tcc etpv r 
i ydp dva,yKOA0V v\ TvtpKov v\ e%ov oiptv eTva,t, dXX' otto- fxeva, civev trvfXTxKoKv]^ KeyeTO,t. « fxv\v dKKa. fxaKtc-a, dv 
Tepov eTvx^' ^ 1 <& T ^ v eva,vTtoov, oov ec~i ti dva, fx,e<rov, Sojrete to tokto trvf/,(3a,tveiv eTTi toov Karra, o-vfX7rKoKv\v evetv- 
iM-roTe dva,yKa2cv v\v Trobvri $clrepov V7ra,px^, dKKa, Tttri, tioov KeyofxevooV to yap vytaivetv %coKpa,Tv\v tu> votreTv ^oo- 
koo) TKTOt' dcpoopio-fAevoo' to ev. coc-e tfv\Kov oti kclt bfreTepov 15 Kpa,TV\V evasvTtov ecrtv. dKK' itf eVi tvtcov dva,yKa,?ov dei 
toov TpoTroov oo5 T& evcovTto, dvTtKetTcu to> ko,to, qepv\trtv koci $d,Tepov fjiev dKv\$eg $arrepov o% ^pevt^og eTvooi. cvTcg f/,ev yap 
e^tv dvTtKetjuoeva,. '£ooKpa,Txg ecrcu to fxev dKv\$eg to &% \pev$og, fxv\ orrcg <Je 

Et^ e7Ti ^aev- twv eva,VTtcov, vTra-pxovTog t» tfeKTtKX, dfXtpoTepa, "p>evtfv\' «Te ya,p to vocetv %coKpa,TY t v «Te to 
Svva,Tov etg ccKKviKa, ju.eTa,(BoKv\v ytve~$a,t, el fxv\ Ttvt <pv~et vytaftvetv e<~tv dKv\$eg ctuT» fxv\ cnog oKoog th ^ooKpa,T)ig. 
to ev vTrdpxet, oTov tw 7rvp\ to $epfxoo eTvcu' kcu ydp to 20 m o% t^? crepvicreoog Kcti tJfe 5 ejreoog fxvj ovrog ts "oKoog itfe- 
vytcuvov ' frvvcLTov voQ-Yi<ra,i ko,\ to KevKov fxeKa,v yev(<r$a,t repov dKvi$(g, ovrog Te iK de\ $d,Tepov dKv\$eg $a,Tepov tfe 
kcu-to ypvxpw Q £ Pf J --' y i K0 " £K o" 71 "^*^ 7 £ <pa,vKov koa eK \pevfog' to ya,p c-pstv exetv ~%ooY.pdTY { v tw TvcpKov eTvcu 1%oo- 
tpa,vKv <n™&cuov $vva,Tov yev(<r$a,t. o ydp tpavKog etg (3eK- Kpa,Tv\v dvTtKetTa,i wg ~-(pv\<rtg ko,\ efyg, kcu tvTog Te iK 
rtxg tfta,Tpt(2a)g dyofxevcg kcu Koyxg Kdv fxtKpov y( rt hci- dvayKcuov $a,repov dKv\$eg eTva,t v\ ^pevbog (oTe ydp fxviTru 
froiY\ etg to fieKTtoov etva,t. ea,v tfe a,7ra,^ Kdv fxtKpa,v eriifrotriv 2$ TretpvKev e^e/v, dfxtpcTepa, 'tpevtfvj), fxv) cvTcg Te %Kcog t« 
Xct|S»7, <pa,vepov %Tt v\ TeKecog dv fxeTa,Ba,Kot v\ ~xa,vv -~toKKy\v ^ooKp&Tttg , kcu »tw "^evtfii dfupcTepa, , kcu to o^ptv ep^ejv 
e7rt$o<rtv Kaftct' dei ya,p evKtvv,ToTepog ~rpog dpeTv\v ytvercu, kcu to TvtpKcv cwtcv eTvcu. e~Tt tfe ye Tv\g Ka,Ta,<pd<reoog 
Kctv ^vTivouv e7rtt\o<rtv etKv,(poog e^ dpxAS fl> &~~ £ >t*' TrKetoo kcu t^? d~TO(pa,o-ecog det, ea,v Te v\- ea,v Te fxv) v,, to erepov 
etKog e7rtfroctv o,vtov Ka,fxfia,vetv. ko,i tkto cte< «yivo^tevov Te- e<~a,t \pevfrog kcu to erepov dKv\$(g. to ydp votreTv ^ooKpd- 
Ketoog eig ty]v evccvTtav e^tv d7roKa,$i<-v\~~tv, ea,v Trep fxv\ XP QV V 30 7Y i v Kct ' 1 ro {W voo ~ £ i y ^coKpa,TY\v, ovTog re a,vT6 tpa,vepcv %ti 
i^etpyviTOOi. e~r\ fre ye TY,g ejreoog kooi TY\g <~epv\cecog dthva,- to erepov clvtoov dKvfieg v\ 'p/evtfog, kcu fxv) 'ovTog ofxotoog' 
tov elg aKK'/\Ka, fxeTa,(2oKv\v yeve<r$a,t. d^ro fxev ya,p t»j? to fxev ya,p voceTv f/,v\ ovrog •p/evfrog, to o% fxv\ vccetv dKvi- 
ejreoog i-xt ty,v <~epvi<rtv ytveTcu fxeTa,$cKv\, d-xo fre trfs ~e- $(g. oo~-e i~xt fxcvoov tktoov \t\tcv dv etv\ to det $aTepcv a,v- 
pviceoog eTxt tvjv ejrtv dt\wa,TOv. ktc ya,p TvcpKog yevofxevog toov dKv\$eg v\ \pevt\og eTvou, oca, oog Ka.Ta.tpoLCtg kou- d-xo- 
rtg TxaKtv dvefiKerpev , VTe cpaKaKpog cov TxaKtv KOfXY\TYig 3> tpactg dvTtKenat. 

eyevero, «Te voot\og cov hbovrag e<pv<rev. 'Evantov fre ecrtv e^ : dvdyKv\g dya$oo /xev KaKoV wroll 

^Oov* tfe cog KaTatpactg Kat a7xo<pa<rtg dntKenat, tfe tfv\Kov tv\ Ka$" eKacrcv i7xayooyy\, oTov vyteta, vocog koa 

4. bT£ BC. II 8. 7T0TS om B et pr C. II 10. t%w %-pvt C. II £%sv e^jy C. II 12. a,vx^xa,iuj' COIT C. II 'o-piv z%m C. II «v*j] ff- 
fitifl-sraj corr C. II 13. Sk] U ^s B. II tj om AB. II 18. "cno- B. II 20. i--<£f%a corr in ej B. II tb om BC. II Sep/xov B. \\ siW] 
V7r«.p%eiv C. II 24. tcj C. II 25. tib ftk] ctlVe yoip rc A. II 26. (pxvspov k-iv Sfri C. II 27. ot,h\ B. II 28. i£ a.pxr,- slXt\<puif C. II 29. is\ 
om C. II 30. h C. II 31. ^s om A. II 33. -yjWaj £7rl g-ipw/ C. II 34. tj? -vcpXo- ysvopsvo' C. II 35. «ye/SXr^ey eJ pr~i ye Sstou b\>vd- 
pei A, d.vt@X~psv el y.r\ tjvj fiej* ffvva.y.si C, qui rc supra I^^jjt». 

1. -pc-Kov A. II 2. fA.ovuv 7*p C. II 4. Si~epov ph a,\r,Ge; C. II 5. allerum ~r,' om C. II 6. prius «T£ om C. II 9- V TvfXoTr,- xa\ c-pig 
C. II 13. tmktov C. II 14. ~uxpa.Tvi B et hic ct postea. II 16. eTvaj post d,Xr/js' C. II 20. te] ph B. II 21. ts] SsAB. II SccTspov post 
uii om B. II &tT£fov t% -psvffo? om A. II 23. te] codices^e. II 26. o-piv cwtov e%£jy C. II 30. Xuxpi^v om C. \\ 31. n B, t3 os sts- 
pov C, om A. II 37. voffO' xa,\ Ttj b'ix«.to<-vrti dffixta, xa\ C. 



14 KATHTOPIAI. 

dvbpeia fretXia, ofxoioos 8e xcu }it\ toov aXXoov. ko.koo ($e toov ty\ Tafcet, xcu evi ty\s ypafXfXaTtKY\s rd $&)%$*, rrpo- 

ote fxev dya$ov evavriov, cre $e KaKoV t*J yap evfreta xaxcjj Tepa toov trvXXafioov), htii Te toov Xcy oov hfxoioos' tq ydp 

cvti *J v7repfioXY\ evavriov kakov oV cfxoioos h kcu *j fxe- Trpcotfxtov ty\s t\tY\yY { <recjos Trporepov ty\ Tafcei eciv. 
voty^ evavria eKarepco, ov<ra dya$ov. eir cXtyoov (f av Et* Tt&pau ra etpYifxeva to (BeXriov kcu to TtfxuJoTepcv 

tc to&tov 'iSot tis, eir\ 0% toov rrXeictov det too kcckcZ to 5 irpoTepcv eTvat t*J <pvo~ei <5o>cs?. eloo$a<rt 8e xcu ct 7roXXo\ 

dya$cv evavricv eciv. tv? evTifxcTeptg kcu fxaXXov dya7roofxevtig vir avroov rrpo- 

j/ Et* eir\ roov evavrioov %k dvayytcuov , eav $arepov *), repvs cpacKetv irap avroTs etvcu. ect fxev <$*} kcu <rxe$ov 

kcu ro Xcittcv eTvat. vytatvovroov fxev yap a,7ravToov vyieia dkKoTptooTO,Tog toov Tpoiroov «to?. 

fxev ecat, vd<rog <£e S* cfxcioos <fe Kat XevKoov ovtoov dira,v- Ot fxev iv Xeyofxevot Tpoirot t» nrpoTep* trxebov to- 

tcov XevKoTY\s fxev ecat, ju.eXa.via, $e ». eTt el to ^ooKpaTY\v 10 crtToi ettrtv. frc^ete (f av nra.pd tms elpYifxeviS ko,\ hepcg 

vytaivetv tco ~%ooKpd,TY[V vocreTv evavricv eci, fXY\ evfrexerat fre eTvat nrpcrep^ TpoTrcs' toov yap dvTicpe<povToov ko,to, ty\v tS 

(Lfxa, dfXfpcTepa, tw «/jtw V7rapxetv, vk dv evMxjuTo tS eTvat dKoX^$Y\<riv to aHrtov oTroorriv &a,Tepop tk etva,t irpoTe- 

krep^ toov evAvrioov ovro? Ka,t to Xctirov etvcu' ovto? ya,p t« pov etKoroog Ty fpvcet KeyoiT dv. oti $' ecji Ttva, tcioZto,, 

"%ooKpa,TW vytcuveiv «>c dv etvj to vocetv %ooKpa,TY\v. SyiXov to ya,p eTva.t a,v$poo7rov dntcrpecpei kckto, t%v tk eT- 

&y\\cv $e oTt kcu nrepi toajtcv yi e^et v\ yevet irecpvKe 15 va,t dKo\x$Yitrtv irpcs tov dXY t $Yi irept a,vvri Xcyov. el ya,p 

yiveoScu to, eva.vTta^ vocc; fxev ya.p kcu vyieta, ev croofxam ecrtv a,vQpoo7ro;, dXYi$Yi; 6 Xoyo; to Xeyo/xev oti ecrtv a,v- 

Xoox irecpvKe yive<rQa,t, XevK0TYi<; <Je kcu fxeXoovia, d7rXu>s $poo7rog. ko,i dvrtcrpecpet ye' el yap dXY$Y[<; c Xoyc? u> Xe- 

ev croofxooTi, &Ka,ioo-vvYi (fe ko,\ d&Kta, ev -<pvx^ dvQpooTr*. ycfxev cti ecrtv av^ptoTro;, ecrtv av$poo7rog. e<rt 8e o fxev aXv[- 

'AvayKYi 3/e Travra t<* evavria yi ev too' clvtco yevei $ng Xoyog ^afxoo; atTto; t« etvat to Trpayfxa, to /xevrot 

eTvat y\ ev ToTg evavriotg yevetrtv, v\ avra yevY\ etvat. XevKov 20 7rpayfxa cpaiverai Trcog atTtov t« eTvat o,Xy\$y\ tcv Xcycv 

fxev yap Kat fxeXav ev too avrco yevet (xpwfxa yap av- tco yap eTvat to irpayfxa y\ fXY\ dXY\$Y t g o Xcyog v\ ^ev- 

70ov tq yevog), S~tKato<rvvY\ (fe koi a^tKia ev ro7g evavTtoig <$Y\g Xeysrai. oo<re Kara Trivre Tpomg Tfpcrepov erepov erep* 

yeye<rtv (r« fxev ydp apeTY\, t« <fe KaKta to yevog)' dya$ov Xeyerat. 

8e Ka\ KaKov ix e<rtv ev yevet, dXX' avvo, Tvyx^et yevv\ v Afxa t t% Xeyerat a7rXoog /xev Ka\ Kvptoorara, oov >j.13 

Ttvoov cvTa. 25 yevetrtg ' etrtv ev tco avroo XP 0VU> ' ^erepov yap TrpoTepcv iSe 

12 IlpoTepov eTep* hepov Xeyerat Terpaxoog, nrpuoTcv fxev vcrepcv ecrtv amcZv. dfxa tfe Kard tov XP 0V0V tccutcc Xeye- 

Ka\ KvptooraTa Kara xP 0V0V -> Kai ^ *° ^pec^vTepcv erepov Tat. <pv<ret <£g dfxa, %<ra dvrt<rpe<pet fxev Kard ty]v t» eT- 

sripx Ka\ TraXatoTepov XeyeTat" too yap tov XP 0V0V "xXeioo vat aKoX^tnv, fXY^afxoog Se ahtcv Qarepov $aTepoo t« eTvai 

etvat Ka\ 7rpe<r(BvTepov koa TraXatorepov Xeyerat. bevrepov ecrtv, oiov eirt tk &t7rXa<rii kcu t» v\fxireog' dvTtcrpecpei fxev 

<$e to fXY\ dvTt<rpe<pcv Kara ty { v tk eTvat aKoXov$Y\<rtv, ciov 30 ydp ravra (<ft7rXa<rix yap ovrog ec\v r.fxttrv Ka\ v\fxi<reog 

to ev toov c%jc TrpoTepoV (%o7v fj*ev yap ovtoov aKcXcv$et ovrog frtTrXacrtov ectv), i^erepov ($e vcfeTepco airtov t» et- 

ev$vs to ev eTvat, evog Se ovrog *k dvayKatov Svo eTvat, vai ectv. 

ooce «x. dvTicpe<pet diro tk evos $ aKoXcv$Y t o-ts tS eTvat to K.at ra eK tS avrt <Ye yevris dvTt^iY\pY[fxeva aXX^- 

XctTrcv. nrpoTepov <fe $0Ke? to ToixTov eTvat, dtp' « fx r /\ dv- Xots dfxa ty\ <pv<ret Xeyerat. dvTt$iYipY\<r$ai. tfe Xeyerat 

Ttcpe<pet y\ tS eTvai aKoX)i$Y\<ris. 35 aXXv\Xots Tct Kora ty x v avTv\v c^taipetrtv, oTov to ttty^vcv tQ 

Tpirov <5e Kara rtva Ta^tv to irpoTepcv Xeyerat, ko- TreCoo Kai tco evvfrpor Tavra yap dXXY\Xots dvTtcfiY,pY t Tat 

6d,7rep £7Tf toov e7riCY\fxdov Kat toov Xoyoov. ev re yap Tats Ik tS avri yev>is' to yap XJoov ^taiperrat els ravra, eis 

arr c^etKTiKOAS e7rtcY\fxaiS VTrapxet tc Trpcrepcv Kai to vce- re to ttty^vov koa to TreCpv Kat to evvtfpav, Kat ifrev ye 

pov ty\ Ta%et (rd ydp coix^ Trporepa toov haypafxfxa- tktwv Trporepov v\ vcepov eciv, dXX' afxa ty\ <pv<ret t* 

1. wtytx C. II 2. kmnioy a.ya.ftcv C. II 3. oi om C. II 7. £7n om C. II a.vnyxoci.ov igtv ktiv C. II 11. rc A. II 13. ETvcti] \>7t.<Loyj-u 
C. II 15. to. cw-j-3 C. II 17. 7ri<j)VK£ ^ivsvScu om B C. II 19- a.vocyy.ouov ^k «7ravT* C. II 27. xocl om^. II x&ra] ■/.o.xa tsv J3C. II 31. ch- 
t7v AB. II ovTcfv C II 36. Tivct] t^v pr A. II ro om BC. 

7. r.a.o' o.vto?5 fTvott om C. II 10. a.v n? 7ra,pa) C. II 11. £wa,i t3 ■Kcoripv C. II 18. dX^? om C. II 29. t}jj.tosu? pr AB. II /*sy om 
AC. il 30. c~t7rXa,o-iv y.h *ja,p ABC. II yi/jlicsu? pr B. II 34. a.vrtha.tpsto-^a.t C. II 36. a.vrtota,tp{ira.t C. II 37. 7sv« ovra, ro BC. 



KATHrOPIAI. 15 

roictvra b^oKet eTvai. hatpeSeir, o^ av Kat exacrov roov rot- 'Ecrt <fe a7rKoog /xev Ktvv\<ret r,pefxia, evavria, ra?g 8e 

iroov eU el&r, TraKtv, oTov ro reCpv Y,at to 7Tty,vov xat 10 xaS' exacra at xaS' eKacra, yeveret fxev <pSopd, av^r\<ret 
ewcfpov. ecrat *v xdxelvcL dfxa t*j <pv<ret, o<ra ex t» avr^i oe fxetoortg, ty) <$e Kara tottov fxeTaftoKr) v\ xa/xa. tqttqv 
ytvng xard ty,v avrr\v ^taiperiv ecrtv. ra fre yevr\ roov el- v\pe[xta. fxaKtcra <Y eotxev avrtxetrSat v\ Trpog rov bavriov 
froov de) Trporepar i yap dvrtcrpe<pei xara, rr,v t» eTvat 5 tqttqv fxeraj3oKr}, otov rr\ KarooSev v\ ctvoo, rv\ <$e ctvosSev v\ 
aKoKovSr,<rtv, otov *£w<fpv fxev ovrog ecrt XJoov, £w« oe ovrog xaroo. rr, <5e Kot7rv\ roov aTroboSeiQ-oov xtvyyreoov « hclfriov 
ix dvayxY} evvtyov etvat. aTTofrovvai ri ttot4 e^-iv havriov, eotxe <fe iSev etvai o,vty\ 

r ' Afxa «V t*j <pv<ret Keyerat, %<ra dvrtcrpecpei /xev xara evavrtov, el fxv\ rtg ym e7rt ra.vry]g rr)v xard to irotov v\pe- 
ty,v t» eTvat dxoKxSri<rtv, fxr,<fafxcbg <fe atrtov ro erepov rco fxtav dvrtrtSetY] v) ty\v eig ra evavriov t« xoiK fxera$oKY]v, 
erepoo th eTvai ecrt, xa) rd ex t» avT<s yew$ dvTifrtYipY]- 10 KaSa-nep xat eTrt rr]g Kara tottov fxeTaftoKYig rr)v aara) 
fxeva dKKviKotg' aTrKobg <fe afxa, Cov v\ yevecrtg ev rw ocv- tottov v\pefxiav v\ rr\v e\g rov evavriov tqttov fxeraftoKviv ecri 
roo %povoo. yaf v\ dKKotoort? fAerafioKv) xara, ro rtotov. uicre dvrtxei- 

14 JHivY]o~eQo<; <Je ecrtv e?6\ e%, yeveo-i;, <p$opa, avfyio-ft- (rerai rr\ xara ro %otov xivr,<rei v\ xard ro ttqiov v\pefjt,ia, 

fxeiooo-tg, dKKoioocrig, v\. xard tqtxov fJoerafioKv]. v\ v\ eh ro evavrtov vk Troii fxeTa(3oKv\, otov ro Kevxov yi- 

At fuoev w aKKat xtvr,o-etg' (pavepov ort erepcu dKKv]- 15 veoSat ru fxeKav yivecrSat' dKkofarai yap eU ra, evavricti 
Koov elriv & yap ecrtv v\ yevertg (p$opa ifre ye v\ av^vjTi? tw ttqik fxeraftoKrfi ytvofxevr\<;. 

[xeioortg &&e r\ xard ro7tov fxeTafioKv}, oo<ravroo<; fre. xa\ al To $e e%eiv xara, 7tKeiova-<; Tpo7T6<; Keyerai. v) yap 15 

aKKaf e7u 8e ty]<; aKKotooreoog ex ei TIV< *' diropicLV, fxv\ 00; e£tv xa) frtaSeriv v) coKKvtv rtvd 7ro~torr}ra,' XsyofxeQat 
7Tore dvayxalov v) ro dKKotxfxevov xara, rtva, roov Kot7Toov y<xp xat e7:icrY,fXY]v Ttvcc e%etv xat dperv\v. v) obg Txorov^ 
xtvr,<reoov dKKoixoSat. t«to Se yx aKrfies ecrr crx^ov yctp 20 oTov Tvyxavet xtc exoov fxeyeSog' Keyerat yap Tpnrvixp 
xard Trdvra rd ttcCQy} v) rd TrKeTcra dKKoi^oSat ovfxfte- /xeyeSog exetv v) rerpd7TY\xv. v\ obg ra, rrep\ ro croofxa, 
@r,xev vifxTv icfefxtdg roov ooKKoov xtvr,<reoov KotvoovvcriV are mov tfxartov v\ x n -*> va " *l ^ ev ^P^V^ °^ ov * v X ei ?i ^ax- 
yap avjreo-Qat dvayxauov ro xara, nra$og xtwfxevov tre rvKtov. v) obg fxepog, otov x^P^ V wfra,. v) oog ev dyyeioo, 
fxetvrSat, oocravroog Se xa\ eV* roov aKKoov, oooS' erepa, dv otov b fxefrtfxvog t»$ Trvpvg v) ro xepcCfxtov rov oTvoV oTvov 
e'iv\ irapd rdg aKKag xtvr]<retg v\ aKKoioortg' et yap r\v v\25yap e%eiv to xepafxtov Keyerat, xa\ 6 fxecftfxvag irvpig' 
avrv}, efret ro aKKoiK/xevov evQvg xa\ av^eoSa-t v) [xeiirSat ravr iv TTavra. e^eiv Keyerat cbg ev dyyeico. v) obg Krrifxa,' 
v} rtva roov aKKoov dxoKxSeTv Ktvv\<reooV aKK' vk dvayxr\. e^eiv yap otxtav v) dypov KeyojtxeSa. . . 
u<ravTcog Se kou to av^avofxevov v) rtva aKKr,v Kivr\<rtv ki- Aeyo/xeSa, 6% Kat yvvauKO- e%e^ xa\ v\ yvvv) dvcfpar 

vifxevov dKKoiirSat ecfet' dKK' ecrt rtva, av^avofxeva a, vk eotxe 8e dKKorptoorarog vvv pr,6e)g rpoTrog T« e%eiV isfrh 
dKKoixrat, oTov ro rerpayoovov yvoofxovcg 7reptreSevt%g . v}v^r\- 30 yap a-KKo r<2 e%ef yvva?KO, <rr,fxaivofxev v) ori <rvvotKeZ 
rat fxev, aKKoiorepov 8e i<%v- yeyevr\rat' cbcravToog ^e Kat l<roog b^ dv Ka) dKKot rtveg <paveir,<rav rv e^e^v t^o- 

e7r\ roov aKKoov twv TotMrcov. obo-Q' erepat av eivyrav at Kt- irot' 01 <& etooSoreg KeyeoSat (rx^ov a,7ravreg Karv\piS- 
vr}<retg dKKriKoov. fxv\vrat. 

1. Tuv TOtvTuyj txtuv C. II 2. TTT^h xcCiTc 7te'£ov Jt3. II 4. o,il tujv slftwv C. II 10. uaitv h\ <v(ms C. II 11. o.fjLUj XiyeT&t uv C. II l4. r{\ 
xai v C. II 16. 7£ om £. II 17. post fitToc^ohrj vctus interpres aAAoiWij. II 22, vfopix pr C. II xoivwtxcrys fortasse A. II 26. tov 
C. II 30. dAAoiifvTou C. 

1. xir-jc-i,- ABC. \\ bocmov JB. II 4. *)] xa\ r) AB. II 7- & simt Tt oc-jt^ C. II 12. fomsvrvu AC. II 27. rj xoc\ C. II 28. h ora 
C II 30. I'%eiy codices. II 31. ^scysisv corr C. 



IIEPI EPMHNEIAX. 



JLLpooTOV cfs? 6s<r&cit t/ cvo^ttct xcu ii pvjfXd, ETTEiTd t/ ToictuTct, vk ovofXdTd dhhd TTTooTEtg IvofXdTog. hoyog cfs 

ECTIV d7TO(pa,Tig KCti KdTd(pdTtg Kdt dTtCrpdVTig Kdl hoyog. ECTIV . CtUT« Tct fXeV dhhd JCCtTct Tct Ct'JTCt* OTJ $£ //t£Tct T« 

• '^EcTl ^EV «V TCt EV TYI (pO0VY\ TOOV £V TT\ '^W)Q\ 7tdQv\- ECTIV V\ Y\V Y) ECTdl «>C dhr,$£Vtl Y\ ^EVC^ETdl, TO $E OVOfXd 
fXdTOOV TVfxftohd, Kdl TCU ypdlpOfXEVd TCOV SV TY\ (pOOVYj. dEl' OIOV QlhOOVog ECTIV Y\ «>C ECTIV' VC%V ydp TtOO «T£ dhr\- 
Kd\ OOTTtEp YcTe ypdfXfXdTd TtdTi Tct CtUTCt, *C% (pUOVOA CU 5 $£V£l «Te ^pEV^ETCU. " 

dVTdi' U)V fxivTOL TdVTd TY]fXE?d TtpOOTUOg, .TdVTd 7X0,71 TtO- 'PvifXCH, <$i ECTL TO 7tp0TTY,fXd?V0V %p0V0V , « fxipog Xcfsv 3 

$Y,fXdTd TYjg ypvx^ ncu oov TdVTd 6/xoioofXdTd, TtpdyfXdTd TY\fXdLVEi X u P l $i K0U £ i" iv <* e ' ™ v Kct ^' eT£ ^ hsyofxivoov 

Y\<h\ TdVTd. TTEpi fXSV «V TiTOOV eipYCtdi EV TO?g TtSpi ^JV- TY\fX£?0V. hiyoo (? Ctt 7tpOTTY\fXdiv£L XP 0V0V i °^ 0V vyieid fXEV 

X*iS' dhhv,g y&p . 7rpa,yfJt,a,TEidg. scri cY, uoTTtEp h T*j ^pvxv cvofxd, to Ss-vytdivst pr\fxd' 7tpoTTV\fxaiv£t ydp to vvv vitap- 

CTE fXEV VOYifXd dVEV T« dh.Yj$£VElV *) ^EV^SoSdt, OTS <5e Y\$Y\ 10 X £lV ' Ka>l &? 1 ™ V x *^' STE^» hsyOfXEVOOV TY,fX£?0V ECTIV, OLOV 

CO dVdyXYl TMTOOV VTtdpX™ QdTEpOV, XTOO Xdl EV TY\ (pOOVY)' TOOV Kd$' VTtOKEtfXEYti Y\ EV VTtOKElfXEVOO. 

TtEpt ydp o-wSeviv Kdt S~idtp£rtv ectl to ^psvSog Kdt to To Sk &x vyi&tvei Kdt to i Kdfxvsi « prjfxa, Ksyoo' 

dkriQsg. Td fxsv %v ovofXdTd dvTd xd\ Td pvifXdTd soiks Ttpoo-tTYifXdLVEL fxsv ydp XP 0V0V Kcil ^ £L K&ttti Ti vo $ VTra>PX ei -> 

TW dVEV TVvSsTEOOg Kd\ $LdLpEQ-£OOg VOYtfXdTl,- oTov TO dvQpW- TYI $£ $Ld(pOpa OVOfXd K KELTdt' d\K ECTOO dOptCTOV ffifXO,, 

TtOg Y\ TO XeVKOV., CTdV fXYJ . 7rpOTT£Sy TL' KTS yap '^EvSog 15 OTi OfXOLOOg £(p' OTWV . VTtdpX^i XCU OVTOg Xd) fXY] ovTog. 

»T£ aXYiSig Ttoo. o-YifxsTov <5"' ect\ tvSe' xd\ ydp 6 Tpdyshd- hfxoioog c% xd\ to vyldvsv y\ to vyidvs7 & prifxa, ctXXco 

(pog (TYifXdLVEt fXEV Tl, V7tOO $E dXY\$£g Y\ ^pEvSog , ectV fXYl 7tTOOQ~ig pv\fXdTog' Sld(p£p£l Ss T» pvifxdTog, OTL TO fXSV TOV 

TO sTvdl VJ fXY\ sTvdl 7tp0iTTE$Yl, Y) d7tkoog Y\ XdTd XP 0V0V - TtdpOVTd 7tpOQ-crY\fXdLVEl XP 0V0 * ', Tct $£ TOV TTEpt^. 

2 'OvofXd fxsv h ect\ (poovv\ <rY\fXdVTiKY\ KdTd q-vvSy\ky\v . Aut* fxkv «V jtct^' ectuTct Xsyofxsvd Tct pyfXdTd ovo- 

ttvEV XP 0W -> fc fMlSh fXSpog SCTl Q-YifXdVTtKOV KSX^P^f^ £V0V ' 20 fXdTd ECTl Kd\ (TYIfXdlVSL T< (JqYl<rt ydp \sy0CV TY t V Sld- 

h yoip too K.ahkL7t7tog to iitTtog i$sv dVTo Kd$' sdVTo voidv, Kdt o dKXQ-dg vipEfXYio-£v), d\K si scrtv y\ [xy\, tntoo 

<rY,fXdLV£l, obtTTtEp EV TOO XoyU) TOO KdXog HTtTtog. « fXY,V bc¥ Q-YlfXdivEL' &C% ydp TO sTvdl Y\ fXY\ ELVdl 0-Y,jX£?0V ECTl T« 

coo-JtEp h Tolg d7t\6tg ovofXdrtv, %Toog £%e< Kdt h ToTg <rvfx- TtpdyfxdTog, &c¥ eo,v to ov s'i7tY\g dVTo Kd$' mvro ^lKov. 

TtETtXsyfxlvoLg' h EKEtvoig fxsv ydp to fXEpog icfdfxoog o-y,- avTo fxh ydp icfsv ectl, Ttpoo-Q-YifxdivEL Se <rvv$s<riv Ttvd, y\v 

fXdVTiKov,. h (Te TXTotg /3»/\eTcti fxsv, ctXX' bfrevcg Kexuptv- 25 etveu toov <rvyxeifxeyoov ix Ictl vcY,<rdi. 

fXEVOV, 0L0V h TOp E7ta,KTpCKEhY,g TO KShY\g &$EV <rv\fXaiv£L Ka$' Koycg Ss ECTl (pOOVY, <rY]fXdVTLXYI XdTd Q-VV$Y]KY]V, r,g toovA 

eavTo. to Ss jtctTct, q-vvSy\ky,v, cti (pvost toov cvofXdToov vcfsv fxspoov Tt Q-Y]fXdvTtKov scTi KEXwpivfXEVov , oog (pd<rig, ctXX' 

ectlv, aW' oTav yivY\Tai o-vfxfioXov, ETtEt $Y]fc6Q~i yi ti ko\ &x W KaTa<pa<rtg y\ d7to(pd<rig. Xiyoo Si, oTov dvSpooTtog <ty\- 

cl dypdfX/xdTOL \po(poi, oTov Qvipioov, uv x$iv scriv ovofxd. fxdivst fxiv Tt, dTOl &x 0Tl £< ? lv V * K £C > IV ' *^-' ^V"*' Kct ~ 

• To $' &x av$poo7rog &x ovofxa. i fxy,v icfs XEtrai ovojtxd 30 Td<pd<rtg r, d7ro(pdrtg, sav ti 7rpoTTE$r,. dkh' &x i T ^ & v ~ 
"0 Tt $£? xdksTv dVTC «Te ydp Koyog «Te d7ro(pdTig ectlv. SpooTrx TvKhdftr] fxid. vcfe ydp h too fxvg to vg TYifxdvTixov, 
dhX ecroo ovo/xd dcpLcrov, otl ofxoioog i(f ot««v virdpx^ dXhd (poovr, ecri vvv fxovov. h Se To?g $L7rho?g Tr,fXdivei /xiv, 
Kd\ ovTog Kd\ fxr\ ovTog. to ^e Qihoovog r\ Qihoon Kd\ oTd dhX « >tct5' cwto, u)g 7rpostpY,Tdt. 



5. «31] Stw? ih\ C. II 6. <n?ju.£?* t&vto, C. fl 12. •^Eu&fe tb x«i BC. II 20. (iv\$h C. II 22. to pr C. II 24. &fay.clj? M <rv\y.«.m- 
xoi C. II 26. Gi\y.a.Uu y.o$ Iuhto om HC. II 30. xeTt«i' ^e oyofA.0, C. II 32. cti — 33. /J,rj "orro<; om AB. II 33. oc* «XX* toixvto, C. 

1. 7ZTw<n? A. II 4. l^ii ^i-ty y A. II 10. i<?iv ante «e1 C. II 11. v7rox£i l uhu'] v7rox£L/j,£vu> ovtuv C. II 16. xxi to v^mvsl xcbl to iyiocvsv C. 
I! 20. tyiv foxvom o ?Ayuv C. II 22. 7«p om C. II 26. x«t*" <rvv^r\xr,v om BC. II 28. rj *7rfle/>*<ns om BC. II 29. ph om AB. II 30. v% 
r\ corr A. II 33. l«vTa C. II ucnrep e\'pr,TXL C. 



nEPI EPMHNEHS, 17 

E<r< 8e Kcyog xTrxg fxev TYifxa,ntxog, &x u? opyavov tcov xcL$oKti, KxKKtxg $e twv x&$' sxclctov)' cLvdyxYi ^e 

<»Y, cLKK' oog 7rpoetpv\Txt , xcltcl tvv$y\xv\v. cLirocpxvTtxog <% a,7ro<pa,ive<r$a,i oog inroipxei ti v) yu.»].6Tg fxev tcov xcL$oKti 

« ttcls, cLKK' ev u To aJKvfievetv v) -*pev<fe<r$a,t vircLpxei. ix Ttvt, oTg <fe tuv xcl$' sxclctov. ea)v fxev ?y xcl$qK* <L7ro<pa,w\- 

iv cL7rcL<ri £e vTrapx^, oTov v) evx^i Koyog fxev, cLKK' «Te tcli b*1 th xcl$o\v oti vTrdpx^ TJ »1 jtvwf, gcrovTcu. evavr/cti 

<xX>j0*)c; »re ■^/ev6 S Y\g. ot fxev «v «.X.X.OJ cL<pet<r$oo<ra.v pvjTopi- 5 «u <X7ro<pcLV<retg. Keyoo <fe ev) rk xa$6Xti cL7ro<pxtve<r$xi xa,$6- 

xr,g ydp v\ 7rotv\Ttxv\g otxeioTepa, v\ <rxe-^/tg' o $e a.7ro<pxv- Kts, oTov %xg <xv$poo7rog Kevxog, vfre)g a,v$poo7rog Kevxog, .otclv 

rixog t>jV vvv $eoopixg. fre e?rl toov xx$qK>s fxev, fxv) xx$oKts <$e, txuTcci fxev wc et<r)v 

5 Ecrt 8e etg nrpcoTog Koyog cLirccpcLVTtxog xcLTcL(pcL<rtg, evxvTtxt, tcl fxerrot ^Kvfxevx ecrtv etvxt evxvria, ttotL Keyoo 
etTcL d7ro(pcL<rtg' ot cf a,KKot ircLVTeg <rvv<\e<rfxoo elg. a,va.yxv\ &e to fxv\ kx$qK>s cL7ro<pcLtve<r$cLi eVt twv xcL$oXts, otov e<zi 
§e ttclvtcl Koyov cL7ro<pcLVTixov ex pvifxcLTog etvcLi v\ 7TTco<recog 10 Kevxog cLv$pco7rog, ix ecrt Kevxog <Lv$pco7rog' xx$oK>s ydp IvTog 
pv\fxcLTog' xcl) yacp 6 t» cLv$pco7r\i Koyog, eocv fxv\ tq ecrtv v\ th a,v$poo7rog &x °°g xa,$oXts xexpv\TcLt tvj cL7ro<pxv<rei' to 
v\v v\ ecrcLt v\ Tt tov6tov 7rpocre$v\, \sttoo Koyog cL7ro<pcLvrtxog. ya,p Trxg « to xcl$o\\4 <rv\fxcLtvei cLxX oti xcL$oK\i. S7r) <fe r$ 
frtoTi §v\ ev t{ ecrtv ci\X » ttoXKcl to XJZov xe^ov friTrnr xcLTYiyopvfxevtf xcl^oXk xcLTV\yope?v to xcL$oK\i ix ecrtv clKvi- 
& yocp <fv\ tco o-vveyyvg etpv\<r$cLi eTg ecrcLt. e<rt <fe cLXkv\g $(g' vcfefxicL y<xp xcLTcL<pcL<rtg cL\v\$v\g ecrcLt, ev *j t» xcltv\- 
irpcLyfxcLTetcLg t»to elirelv. ecrt <% etg koyog cLTrocpcLVTtxog v) 15 yopx/xew xcL$ok\i to xcl$oKh xcLTYiyopetTcLt , otoy ecrt. 7roXg 
o ev <tv\Kcov v) o <rvvM<rfxco eTg, ttoXXo) <fe ot 7ToXXcl xcli cLV$pco7rog ttclv X&ov. cLVTtxeto-$cLi fxev vv xcLTcL<pcL<rtv cltto-. 
fxv\ ev v) ol cl<rvvfreTot. to fxev kv ovofxa, v) pvifxcL <pcL<rtg <pcL<ret Keyco cLvTKpcLTtxoog tv\v to xcL$o\\i <rr\fxcLm<rcLv tw. 
ecrco fxovov, e7retfrvi ix ecrtv etTretv «toj <\v\hMvrcL Tt Ty (poovvi clvtu ort « xcl$oKm, oTqv nrcLg cLv$poo7rog Xevxog - « irxg 
oocre cL7ro(pcLive<r$cLt, v\ epcoToovrog Ttvog, v) fxv\, ctAA' cmjtov cLv$pco7rog Kevxog, ifretg cLV$pco7rog \evxcg - ecrt Ttg cLv$pco- 
TrpocLipxfxevov. txtcov <5e v\ fxev clttXy) ecrtv cL7ro<pcLv<rtg, oiov20 7rog Xevxog' evcLVTtoog fre tv\v t« xcl$oKv xa,TcL(pcL<riv xcli 
ti xcltcl Ttvog v) Tt oXtto Ttvog , v\ <% ex tvtoov <rvyxei[xew\ tvjv t« xcl$6\<iS A7r6<pcL<riv, oTov 7rc2g cLV$pco7rog Kevxog - bfrets 
oTov Koyog Tig v\o\ <rvv$eTog. e<rt <fe v) cLTrhv) cL7ro<pcLVO-tg a.v$pco7rog Kevxog, irtxg xv$pco7rog ^lxxtog - &<fe)g <tv$pco7rog 
(poovYi <TY\fxcLVTiXYi TTept tk v7rxpx^v Tt v) fxvi vTrxpx^v , cog frtxcLiog. foo TcLVTxg fxev *x oTov Te cZfxcL 6iKvi$eig eTvcLiy 
o/ XP° V01 ^ipwr&i' t*>$ <& cLVTixeifxevxg cLvTXtg evcfexsTXt iroTe eir) t« clvt~ 

6 ~tfLcLTcL<pcL<rig &e ecrtv cL7r6<pcLV<rig Ttvog kcltcl Ttvog. cL7ro-25 ctfxcL <LX.Y\$e7g eivcLt, olov i irclg xv$poo7rog Xevxog xcl) eqt 
(pxrtg <fe ecrtv cL7ro<pxv<rtg Ttvog xtto Ttvog. e7re) <fe ecrt xcli Ttg xv$pco7rog Kevxog. o<rcLt fxev »v cLvTtcpcLcreig tcov xcL$oK\i 
to V7rxpx°v cL7ro<pcLive<r$cLi cog fxv) vTrxpx^v xcl) to fxv) et<r) xcl^cKx, cLvxyxvj ty\v eTepxv clKy\$y\ eivcLt v\ \pev<fv), xcl\ 
tnrxpxov cog virxpxov xcl) to vTrapxov oog vircLpxov xcn octcli enrt tcov xx$' excLcrcL, oiov ecrt %ooxpcLTv\g Kevxog - wc 
to fxv) vTTcLpxov cog fxv\ vTrxpxov, xcl) Trep) tk? g>cTo? <fs e<Tt ^ooxpcLTvig Kevxog' ovcli oe eTrt toov xx$oKti fxev, fXY\ XCL- 
t« vvv XP ^ ooo-avTcog, clttxv clv ev<fexoiTo xcl) o xcLTe<pv\cre 30 $oKti <Je, ix cLet y) /xev cLKv\$v\g v) cfe ^evo%g. cXfxcL yxp cLKy\- 
Ttg cLTrocpYcrcLi xcl) o cL7re<pv\<re Ttg xxTa<pv\<rxi. uxre <fv\Kov $eg ecrtv ejVeTv ot< ei^iv cLV$poo7rog Kevxog xcli oti ix : ecrtv 
%Tt 7rx<rv\ xcLTcLcpcLcret ecr)v <L7ro<pcL<rig cLvTtxeifxevY, xxt 7rx<rvi cLV$pco7rog Kevxog, kcli ecriv cLV$poo7rog xxKog xcli tsx ecrtv clv-- 
cL7ro<pcL<rei xxTx<px<rtg. xcl) ecroo <LvTt<px<rig t«to, xcLTxcpcL- $poo7rog xooKog. el yxp cLt<rxpog, xcli » xxKog' kcli et ytveTcLt 
<rig xcl) cL7Tc<pcLcrig clI AVTtxeifxevxi. Keyco <fe a\vTtxei<r$xt ti, xat ix ecrtv. cfo^eie <T clv e%a,t<pvY\g a,T07rov etvxt fria, to 

Ty)v T« CLVT6 XCLTCL T« CtUTK, fXv) QfXCOVVfXOOg $i, XCLl 0<TX 35 <pXiVe<T$Xl CTYIfXCLlVetV TO &X ecrtV CLV$pC07rog KeVXOg ctfXCL XCLt 

clKKx tcov tciktoov TrpQo-^topiQofxe^a, nrpog tcc?; <ro(pi<rtxcLg otl i<fe)g xv$poo7rog Kevxog' to <fe «Tg tccutov <rv\fxa,ivei a$\ 
evoxMo~stg. ilfxa, e^ ctvccyjojf;. 

7 'E7rei <^' ecrt tcl fxev xcL$oK)i tcov Trpxyfxarroov tx <fe $a,vepov <fe oti xcli fxia, a,7ro<pcL<rtg fxiag xa,TO,<p<L<reoog 
xaff excLcrcv (Keyco 8e xx$oKv /xev o e7r) TrKeiovoov Trecpvxe ecrt' to yxp o,vto <Je? a,7ro<pv)<rcLt tv\v a,7ro<px<riv oTrep xcvre- 
xa,TV\yopet<r$a,t , xa,$' exxcrov <Je o fxv\, oTov a,v$poo7rog fxev^O <pv\<rev v) xa,Tx(pa,<rig, xcl) cLttq t« clvtv, y) toov xcl$' excLcra, 

2. wWfp tfimaA BC. II 12. roivro B. II 13. h\ C et fortasse B. II 17. ol om C. II | ro pfy* C. II 20. *7rc>t*o-i? C. II 22. fj 
tlfihB. II «,7r<3</b«,o-i; C. II 26. i^ om C. II 30. xpcvw BC. II 31. ti? alterum om BC. II 35. xocroi, rx t» C. II 36. Trpo? ompr C. 

h. n om pr C. II 5. <*/ om BC. II a.%'c$&nii BC. II 13. ro anle prius y.a,6oXv B, ante x<*Tjjyopf?iV C. II l4. <*X»j^? om 
B. II 17. tw jturtf otiJ rri.ro B. II 19. fft om C. II 21. th*,- <*. X. «6\ «. X. om BC. II 2k. r«,vra.a C. II nort om B. II 25. <*>* 
t*x»jfl£<5 eTvcci] <*Xij<9euBy C, om B. II 39. h<u pr C, om B. 

c 



jg IIEPl EPMHNEI AS. 

Ttvog yj a,7to tuiv xaSoKtt Ttvog, y\ oo$ Ka$oK>s y\ oog fxv\ Ka$oK\i. %n i KevKov ecfiv, dvayKYi etvat KevKov y\ » KevKov, xou el 
Keyoo 8e oTov ecrt %uKpaTY,g KevKog - ix. e<ri ^UKpaTYig Kev- ecrt Kevxov v\ « KevKov, dK.Y\$eg y,v cpavat y\ a7to<pavat' xa\ 
xog. edv tfe aKKo n vj ctV aKK\i to avTo, ix V dvrtKei- el fxy\ tntapxei, ^evcfeTcu, xai el ^ev&erat, &x vTtdpxei, 
tiewi dKK' ecrai 'exe{vY\g hepa. ty\ cfe Ttag dv$poo7tog KevKog ucre dvayKY\ y\ tvjv KaTa<pa<rtv y\ ty,v d7to<pa<rtv cIXy\$yi eTvai 
7\ w Ttdg dv$poo7tog- KevKog, ty\ cfe rU av$poo7tog KevKog v\ k^ 5 y^^evhr]. i$h dpa- «re sq-iv t-re yiveTcu \sts d-no tvxW «$' 
cfe\g av$poo7tog KevKog' ty\ Se ecrtv dv$poo7tog KevKog y\ *k ecrtv oTtoTep' Jru^ev, k&e ecrat v\ «>c e<rat, aKK' e£ avayKY\g aTtav- 
av$poo7tog Kevxog. Tct xa\ &x o-KOTep eru%ev. y\ ydp b <pag dK.Y\$ev<Tet y\ b cwro- 

r/ OTi fxev %v fxta xaTa<pa<ret [xta d7to<pa<rtg dvTtKsncu <pag. b[xotoog yap av eytveTo v\ ix eytveTo' to yap OTtoTep eTu^ev 
dvTt<bciTtKoog, kcU' Ttveg el<r\v avrat, e'ipy,Tat' kcu oti ai evav^ xcfev [xaKKov XTOog v\ /j,y\ %TOog exe<-Y\ e£et. eTt et ecri KevKov 
Ttcu aKKat, koa Ttveg ei<rtv civtcu, eiprrtat' kcu oTti tx a<ra 10 vvv, aKy\$eg y,v eirteTv TtpoTepov oTt ecrat KevKov, oocre det dKr,- 
chhY\Qv\g y\ ipev^Yig dvTt<pa,<rtg, kcu foa. Tt, koa %0Te d\Y\$Y\g $eg -y{v eiVeTy omv toov yevofxevoov oti ecrtv v\ ecrcu. el c^e dei 
y\Apevch\g. • ■'■ dKyfieg Y\v elTtelv oti ec;tv y\ 'ecrcu, *X om Te T ^ T0 f^ ^vcu 

8 Ml* cV ecrt Ka,Ta,<pa,<rtg koa ditocpcKTtg v\ ev kol$' svog §<^e fxy t e<re<r$at. o cfe fxy] otov Te fxy\ yev(<r$a-t, : d^vvarxov fxy\ 
(TYifXdtvticroi, y\ KA$o\>i ovTog ko,$oXh y\ u,Yi bfjootcog, oTov it&g yeve<r$at'^o&dc\uva,TovfXY]yeve<r$a,t,dvayKY\yeve<r$a,t.d7:a l vTa, 
&v$poo7rog KevKog e<rtv - isK ecrt 7tdg dv$poo7rog XevKog, ecriv^ZvTa, ecrofxeva, dva,yKO,?ov yeve<r$a,t. icfev apa, o7:oTep' eru%ev 
dv$poo7rog XevKog- vk ecrtv av$poo7tog KevKog, xcfelg a,v$poo7rog »<5"e d^zo tvx^ ecrcu' et ya,p dixo tvx^, «" % dva.yKYfi. cCh- 
\evKog - e<ri Ti£ dv$pooicog XevKog, et to XevKov ev o~Y\fXciivei. Xd fXY\v xcY oog icferepov ye dkY\$eg evdexeTa,t Keyetv, oiov oti 
el cfe cfvotv ev ovofxa, Ketra,t, e£ oov fxy\ ecrtv ev, « fxta kooto,- «Te e<ra,t :*ts yk ecrcu. TtpwTov fxev ya,p v<ry\g TY\g Ka,Ta,<pa,<reoo$ 
<pa,<rig icfe dTto<pa,<ng fxta,, oTov el Tv; $etTo ovofxa, tfxa,Tiov ^pevc%g y\- d7tocpa,<rtg &k d\Yi$v\g, ko,i Ta,vTY\g ^evc&g x<rY\g ty\V 
r t7t7tco ko,i dv$poo7too, to e<Tiv Ifxa/xtov KevKov, o,vty\ « fxia, Kci-2Q yoa,Ta,pa,<rtv <rvfx(3a,tvet [xv\ d\Y\$Y\ eiva,t. ko,l Ttpog T6T0tg, ei 
Ttupa,<Tig K<Je d7to<pa,o~ig fxia,. vcfev ydp ^tcupepet tkto el7te7v- a\\Y\$eg et7te?v oti Ksvkov ko.\ fxeya,, <$e? a,[X<poo V7ta,px siv - £i 
y) ecriv i7t7tog kcu a,v$poo7tog KevKog. tkto cfe icfev c\ta,<pepei cfe v7ta,p\\ei eig a-vptov, vTta.p^ei eig cwptov. ei cfe fxy\Te ecrcu 
T6 eiitetv ecrtv r t7t7tog KevKog kcu ecrtv a,v$poo7tog Kevxog. ei fxv(te fxv\ ecrcu ajvptov, mk dv e'tv\ to oTtoTep Itvx £ v, otov va,v- 
%v cwtcu TtoKKd <ry\fxa,m<rt koa ei<r\ 7toKKa(, SV\Kov oti ko,i jxcjux^' ^eot ya,p dv [XY\Te yeve<r$a,t va,vfxa,x^v a,vptov fxyfte 
y\ 7tpooTY\ yrtot 7toKKd v\ icfev 0-Yifxa.ivet' « ya>p ecrtv b Ttg a,v~ 25 fxy\ yever$a,t. 

$poo7tog IttTfog'. oocre icf ev Ta,vTa,ig dva-yKvi ty\V fxev dKY\$n Tct fxev $y\ . o-vfx(5a,tvovTa, artOTta, toajto, ko\ toioZto, 

vy\V cfe ^evcfq eTvcu dvTt<pa,<rtv. eTepa,, etTtep.7ta,<TY\g Ka,Ta,<pa,<reoog kcu d7to<pa,<reoog y\ e7t\ toov 

9 'Etu fxev vv toov ovtoov kcu yevofxevoov dvayKYj ty\V ko,- ko,$oKh Keyofxevoov oog Ka,$oKx y\ entt toov ko,$' eKctcrov dvdyKYi 
Td<pa,<rtv v\ ty]v d7to<pa,<rtv dKrfi^ v\ ^evcfty etvcu, ko,i eitt fxev toov dvriKetfxevoov eivcu ty\v fxev dKY\$Yi ty\V cfe "^jevcfy\, fXY\cfev 
toov KO,$oK i tt oog ko,$oKx de\ tvjv ^aev dKy\$Y\ ty\v cfe -^evcfy] et-i^ cfe oTtoTep' eTvxev eTva,i ev To7g ytyvofxevotg, dKKa, 7ta,vT0, 
vcu, ko,\ e7t\ toov ko,$' eKa,crct, uxntep e'ipv\Ta,t, e7t\ cfe toov eTva,t koa yiyve<r$a,t e£ dva,yKY\g. oocre «Te (3>iKeve<r$cu cfeoi 
ko,$oKh fxy\ Ka,$oK\i KeX$evToov vk dv<LyKY\' eHpyjcu cfe koa dv «Te 7tpa,yfxa,Teve<r$cu, cog edv fxev Tocft 7totY\<roo[xev, ecrcu 
ttept V6T00V. eTtt oe toov ko,<j eKcura, kcu fxeKKovToov txofAotoog. Toot, ectv oe fxy\ Toot, kk ecrou Toot. Moev ya,p KOoKvei ko,i etg 
el ya,p ~rd<ra, Ka,Ta,<pa,<rtg koa d7to<pa,<rtg dK.Y\$y]g y\ -^evo\\g, fxvptocrov erog tov fxev cpavcu tkto e<re<r$cu tov fre fxy\ <pa,- 
KO,t d-ta-v dva^yKYi ' v7ta,pxetv y\ fxv\ vTta-pxetv, uxre ei b [xev^vcu, oocre e^ ctvcty>c>j<; e<re<r$cu oTtoTepoviv o,vtoZv dKv\$eg y\v 
fpy\<rei e<re<r$a,i ti b c% /xyi <pyj<rel to o,vto tkto, Sy]Kov oti ei-re?v TOTe. dKKa, [xy\v icfe t«to cftcupepet, et Ttveg eT-tov ty\v 
dva,yKY\ dKy,$evetv tov ertepov uvtoov, ei itdcra KaTa<pa<rig dvripacrtv y\ jxy\ eTitov' <fy\Kov yap oti XToog e^e< Tct, itpay- 
Kai d7to<pa<rtg dKy\$Y\g y\. ^evfryig. a/xcpoo yap &x vTtap^et fxaTa, Kav fxy\ b [xev KaTa<pY\<rn ti b oe a7to<pY\o-y\' ioe yap 
kfxtt, e7t\ To?g TOiHTOtg. ei yap aKv\$eg e't7te?v oti KevKov-v\ <fta to KaTa<pa$Y\vat y\ a7topa$y\vat ecrat y\ «k ecrai, «^* eig 

1. 5 ante w? x«,9. om corr JD. II rj us fj.r\ xxGcXv om C. II 3. avro fj.-)j wito t» o.utw v% C. II 8. fita, xa.rii<pa.<rtg fj.tu. a,7ro(pa,<rsi BC. H 
18. bitiv B. It 19. ih% a.7ri<pa.crt; otn B. II fudk om BC. II &ftro corr in s* B. II 21. *ts. A. II 22. t{\ « en BC. II 23. Xsvkos post 
"tTnro? om C. II 25. o om BC. II 32. MfyS-nw A. II 34. xa\] rj BC. II 36. ^ (pr,o-r\i A. II 38.^ x*Vj r\ C, om B. II a-Ko^aat^ om B. 

1. <m om A. U 4. prius r, om B. II 7. a,Xr\Ssv£t B. II 11.. I<riy fora AB et corr C. II 16. 'ig-at aXA' l£ a.vd.Y^ ana-rta,' zl 
A. II 22., U7r*p^£ty AB. II 2i. igat ei? aZptoi C. II 24. a,vf,tov om BC. II 28. /wyofj.ivw post w~ x.a,bc\v C. II txa^a. C. II 35. o>vtoi 
C. II 36. ibh fortasse pr A. II 38. a C. II 39- xa.Ta.<pa,yQha,t rj a,7-ocpa.v6riva.i ABC. 



nEPI EPMHNEU^ 19 

fxvpiocrov ero? /xakXov y\ ev o7roTU)ivxP ov V' oocre et ev &7rctvTi oti &k dvctyKY, 7ra,TY,g KctTct(pctTecog kou d7ro(pa,Teujg toov dv- 
tuj XP 0V V * ru} ? £ ?X SV °^^ s T0 STS P 0V d/\y\$eveT$cti, dvooyKcuov TtKstfxsvoov ty\'v /js,ev dk.Y\$Y\ t*]v $e ^evcVvi eTvcu' v ydp uoTTrep 
v\v tkto yevsT$a,t, kcu eKO,crov tujv yevcfxevujv det XTtog eTxev em toov ovtcov, KTUjg ex £ i xcu £7r t toov fxv\ ovtoov fxev SvvctTtov 
uicje e£ cLvctyKYjS yeveT$cti. o te yap d/\v\$ujg etTre Ttg oti $e eTvcu v\ fxv\ eTvcu, dh/\ ujTirep etpYjTcu. 

eqcUy &X °^ ov T£ fW yevev&cu' kcu to ytvofxevov dkv\$sg v\v 5 'E-xei Se scrt ti Karra, Tivog y\ KotTotcpctTig TYifxafmTO,, 10 

smeiv a,et oti ecra,i. tkto oe ecrtv y\ ovofxa, y\ to ctvcowfxov, ev oe ost etvcu kcu kcw 

Et Sv\ TctvTct dSvvaxa, — bpoofxev ya,p oti ecrtv dpx^ &og T ° & T *l Koncufxta-ei (jo Se ovo/xa, etpyrrcu kcu to dvcowfxov 
tujv eTO/xevoov kcu d-Ko t« @K/\eve<r6cu kou d-xo tk Trpa^ctl nrpoTepov' to yotp vk a,v$pco7rog ovofxa, fxev vXeyoo d/\)\ doptcrov 
rt, kou oti oktog tcrtv ev Tolg fxv\ de\ evepyOsTt to Svvoctov ovo/xot' ev yatp Truig TY\fxa,ivet kcu to doptcrov ujTrcep kcu to &x 
eTvcu kcu /xy) bfxoioog' ev oTg dfxtpoo evSs^x^ctt , kou to eTvcu 10 vytcuvet « pY\fxot dX\' dopicrov pvifxa,), ecrcu TratTat KotTa^potTig 
kou to fXY\ eTvcu, oocre kcu to yevevScu kcu to fHY\ y£V£<r$cu. ncCt d7ro(pct,<rtg y\ ejfc ovofxarrog kcu p l Y\fxarrog v\ e^ doptcrx ovofjta,- 
ko) TroXkd Yifjuv $Y\)\a, ecTtv vToog ex°VTO,, oTov oti tht\ to Tog kcu pv\fJcarrog. dvEV cfe pY\fx.a,Tog ifrefua, KO,Ta,(pa,<rtg «<Je diro^ 
lfjca,Ttov &vvo.t6v etri b K i&Tfji.Y,&Y l vou kcu w cfta,TfJCY\Sn<reTO,t, dX/\ (pa,<rig' to ya,p ecrtv y\ ecra,i y\y\vy\ ytvETa,i, y\ oto, akXa, tqiavto,, 
efi7rpo<r$ev Ka,Ta,TptfiY,<reT.a,t. bfjcotcog Ss kcu to /jcy) harryrrr pY\fJccna, ek tujv Ketfxevujv ecrt' 7rpo<nTY\fxa,tvei ya,p XP 0V0V - ^T £ 
6y\vo,i o\jvo,tov' i ydp dv v7rY,px £ T ° ey,7rpo<r$ev o,vto ko,to,- 15 7rpuiTY\ ecra,t KO,Ta,(pa,<rtg ko,i d7ro(pa,<rtg to ecrtv acvBpunrog - yk 
Tpi@Y\vcu, .etye fxvj b\iva,Tov y\v to fi.Y\ c\ta,TfXY\&Y\vcu. cocre kcu ecrtv dv$pu)7rog, eTra, eeriv &k a,v$pco7rog - vk ecrtv vk a,v$pco7rog, 
E7rt tujv aXkujv yevereoov, o<rcu Korra, b\iva,fjuv Ksyovrou ty\v iraXtv ecrt 7ra,g a,v$pco7rog - »>t ecrt TraJg a.v$punrog, ecri TroLg fc 
Tota,vTY\v. (pa,vepov dpa, oti ^x a,7ra,vT0, ejr dva,yKY\g kt' scrtv dv$pu)7rog - vk ecri nrcLg kk a,v$pco7rog. kcu e7ri tujv SKTog £e 
kte ytveTcu, dKha, to, fxsv biroTep' eru%e, kou xbev fJtclWov XP 0VU)V ■ ccvTog Xoyog. %to.v %e to ecrt TptTov 7rpo<rKa,TY\yo- 
y\ KO,Ta,(pa,<rig y\ y\ d7r6(pct<rig dt\Y,$r\g, Tet be y.9LWov fjcev kcu 20 pyjT/cu, vi&v\ b~txujg KeyoVTctt ctt dvTt$e<retg. /Xeyoo oe otov ecrt 
cog e7r\ to ttoXv Sctrepov, « ju.y\v ctXA.' ev^xeTou yeveo~$a,i kcu S~tKa,tog a,v$pu)7rog' to ecri Tprrov (pY\fJU <rvyKet<r$a,i ovofJta, *] 
Sctrepov, SctTepov Se fx.Y\. pY\fJtct ev tvj KctTct(pa,<ret. cocre S~tct tSto TSTTa,pa, ecrau TctvTct, 

To fJtev %v sTvcu to ov oto,v y\, kou to fJtv\ ov fjtv\ eTva,i vov to, fJtev Svo Trpog ty\v KctTct(pa,<riv ko,i d7ro(pa,<riv Tfcei Karrd 
%Tctv jutY\ r,, dvctyKYi' « fJtvjv «Te to ov a,7rctv dvctyKY[ eTvcti VTe to croixiv oog ctt crepY,<retg, to, Se Svo «. Ksyu) S~' ofi to scriy 
to /utYJ ov fjtvj sTvctt. i ya,p tojvtov scri to ov ct7rctv eTvou e£ 25 y\ tco S~tKa,tu) 7rpo<rKet<reTott v\ tuj » S^tKouuj, oocrs kcu y) diro^ta,- 
dvctyKY\g ote ecrt, x,ou to drXujg eTvott e^ dvctyKY\g. bfjtotoog <rtg. TETTctpa, w scrctt. vo\s[aev <Je to Xeyofievov Ik tujv vTroye- 
SiE Kctt exl t» fjtv) ovTog. Kott e7r\ TY\g dvrt(pa,<reu)g b otvTog ypa,fjtfjtsvu)v. scrt c\tKcttog a,v$pco7rog' d7ro(pa,<rtg t»tv, \$k etrc 
Koyog. eTvau fjtev *] fxv) sTvott a,7rotv dvayKY), kou e<re<r$ott ye S^tKouog dv$punrog. ecrtv « frtKcttog ctv$poo7rog' t«t» d7ro(pa,<rig, 
*l fx,Y\' « fJtsvTot S~isXovTa, ys shrslv $a,Tspov dva,yKO,7ov. Ksyoo vk ecjiv » StKcttog ctv$pu)7rog. to yctp scrtv evTctv$a, ko,i to h>c 
Se otov dva,yKY\ fjtsv sos<r$a,t va,vfjta,x^ v ctvpiov y\ /JtYJ s<re<r$ott, 30 scrt tuj t\iKO,tu) TrpoTKStcreTou ko,i tw i b s iKa,tu). TctvTa, fJtev 
» fxevTot eo-e<r$a,t ye aJjpiov vctvfxctx^v dvctyKcuov v,S\ fJtY\ w, uj<nrsp sv ToTg ' AvotKvTiKoTg t\sysTa,i, xtoo TSTa,KTa,t. bfxottog 
yeve<r$a,t' ysve<r$ctt jutevTOi *j fjtvi yeve<r$ctt dvotyKCUov. cocr' eVet S~e e%ei Kctv KO,$o/\\i t» ovofx,arrog y\ y\ KotTa,(pa,<rig , olov irdg 
bfxoicog ot Xoyot d\Y\$elg uj<nrep ta 7rpd.yfx.arra,, SyXov oti ecr\v a,v$puj7rog S~tKO,tog. d7ro(pa,<rtg t«t«, » 7ra,g ecrtv ctv$puj7rog 
oto, XToog exei uicre oTTOTep' eru^e Kott Tdva,vTta, evSex £ v$cti, StKcttog. TrcXg ecr\v ctv$punrog » StKouog - « 7r« ecrtv a,v$pco7rog 
dvdyKYj bfxoiuig e^etv ko,\ ty\v dvTi(pa,Ttv. 07rsp TVfx(2a,ivsi S7r\ 35 » S~iKO,tog. 7tXy\v &x ofJtoioog Tctg KctTo, b^tctfxsTpov ev<Je%eTrt.r 

TO?? fXY\ ds\ ilTlV Y\ fXY\ ds\ fXY\ VTIV. T8T6JV ydp dvctyKYj fXEV TVV0t/\Y\$eV£lV evSs^X^Otl Ss 7T0TE. a,VTO,l fXEV «V SvO dvTlKSiV- 

SaTspov fxoptov TY\g dvrt(pa,Teu)g dXY\$\g eTva,t *j ^svbog, » Tott, a,/\/\ott Se Svo Trpog to kk ctvSpcoTrog cog viroKstfxevov ti 
fxsvTot TcSe y\ ToSe dk/\ oTroTep' ervx £ -> x<*<\ fx&Kkov fxev 7rpocre$eV ecrt S^tKctiog &k dv$pu)7rog - vk ecri b^iKctiog xk.civ- 
dhY\$Y\ ty\v errepctv, » fxevTci y\Sy\ d/\Y\$Y\ y\ -^pevSyj. oocre Syhov $pco7rog, etriv » StKctiog wt otv$pco7rog - &k etriv k StKcttog vk 

2. tw om AB. II 15. *v om pr A. II 16. allerum pr, corr A. II 31. ^s post ^inct C. II tkwiKt&ov ya,vfit*.x(a.v C. II 33. ol 
Xoyoi opofaf C. II 34. cttoo-o. C. II 35. SjttuiV «*7xii C. II 36. n /*») «» p ?<nv om A. II 37. i*eoo\?A. II 38. cTtorspov B. II 39- ^v&J 
ttveu cuce A. 

3. pb om C et pr AB. II 6. »j ante 'ovofia, om C. II 7. ™ oz—kciX to] editi plerique t/ 8k— «' ri. II 26. ve£/*£v C. II 
30. irpoa-xuo-tnxi ante t«.ut<x, C. II 36 v avmX^sueo-Qcu B. II xmxwrcu B. II 37. M>o om A. \\ 38. -npocdh corr AB, TcpcctUi- 
To? C. II 39. ^tiv — wApwros om C. , 

C2 



20 IIEPIEPMHNEIAS. 

d,v$pco7rog. -xKeUg Ss r4roov \sk ecrovTcu dvrt$sostg. ctvrat <5e MercCTt^e^eva, $s ra, ovofxarra, ko,i ra, pY,[xa,ra, tolvtov 

X^P^ sKsivoov a,vra,\ ko,$' eavra,g ecrovTou, cog ovofxa,rt to o-Y\fxa,tvst , otov ecrt KevKog a,v$poo7rog, ecrtv a,v$poo7rog KeyKog* 
vk dv$poo7rog ^p'J)i/.evctt. e<p' "oo~oov be ro ecrt fxv\ dpixorret, el ya,p fxv\ riro ecrt, t» civtOs TrKekg eo-ovrcu d~ropa,o-etg. 
cTov e~r\ t« vytoiivet kcu fia,b y T(ei, i~r\ thtwv to oovro Ttotel dKK' ecfecfetKTo ort fxta, fxidg. tk fxev yap ecri KevKog a,v$poo- 
wtw rt$efxevov oog dv et ro ecri -Tpco-Y\7rreTo , oTov vytcuvet Tr&g 5 Txog d-rocpa-rtg ro xk e~-i KevKog dv$poo~rog' th <^e scrtv. cuv- 
ctv$poo~rog — «% vyta-ivei TxcLg dv$poo~rog, vytcuvet rrdg vk a,v- $poo7rog KevKog, ei fxv\ v) ct,vrv\ ecrt ty\ ecri KevKog a.v$poo-rog, l 
$poo~rog - ix vytc/btvet 7rc%g yk kv$poo~rog. h yoop scrt ro i TrcLg sqcu d-ro<pa,~-tg v\roi ro &k ecrtv wc a,v$poo~rog KevKog v\ to 
dv$poo~rog Ksktsov, dKKa ro «, ty]v d~Tc<pa,o~tv, rw a,v$poo~rog wc scrtv a,v$poo7rog Ksvxog. dKK' v\ erepa, fxsv scrtv d-ro(pa,crtg 
7rpoo-$ereov. ro ya,p ~ra,g « ro KO,$oK>i ~-v\fxatvet, dKK' ori ko,- t« ecrtv yk a,v$poo~rog KevKog, v\ erepa, fre tk ecrt KevKog dv- 
$oK>i. SyjKov be eK rib^e, vytouvet a,v$poo~rcg - &x vyta-tvei a,v- 10 $poo~rog, oocre eo-ovrcu b\/o jtxioig. ort fxh w fxera,rt$efxev)i t« 
6poo7rog, vytcctvet vk av$poo~rog - vx vytcctvet \sk a,v$pco~rog. cvofxoorcg kcu tS pYjfxarog v\ a,vrv\ yivera,t Ka,ra<pa,o-tg kcu 
raZra, yap exetvoov frtajcpepet roo fw\ Ka,$oK>i eTva,i. oocre ro 7ra,g d7ro<pa,o-ig, ^Kov. 

v\ icfetg icfev a,KKo 7rpocro-v\fla,lvet v\ ort ko£oKv tk ovofxa,rog To ■ cfe ev ko,to) 7rcKKoov v\ ttoKKoX ko,$' ivog Karra,<pcL- 1 1 

t\ Ka,ra,<pa,crtv v\ d7ro(pa,o-tv. ra, fre olKKoo ra, ccvra, freT rrpog- vcu v\ d7ro<pctvcu, edv fxv) ev ri v\ ro e.K roon ttoKKoov Sy\Km- 
rt$eva-t. 15 fxevov, xk ecrt Ka,ra<pa,o-ig fxta, xcfe d7ro<pa,o-tg. Keyoo c% ev 

'E7T£i fre eva,VTta, dTrocpa-crtg lcrt ty\ a,7ra,v ecr\ ^wov frt- yk ea-v ovofxa, ev ri Ketfxevov^ fxv\ v\ <Je ev rt e^ SKetvoov, otov 
natov v) o-v\fxa,tviio-a, ort ifrev ecrt XJjoov $tKa,tov, aiircu fxev <pa,- o a,v$poo7rog tcoog ecri kcu XJ^cv kcu <^/7tkv kcu v\fxepov, dKKa, 
vepov ort ^e7rore eo-ovrat xre dKvfielg cLfxa, KTe gVi t« o,vt6, aat ev "rt ytvercu e.K rxroov' eK Se- tk KevKX Kat ri dv$poo7Tii 
cri oe dvriKeifxevcu ra,vTa,tg eTovra-t -7rore, oTov & 7ra,v XJjoov. ko-) t« @a,c\tCetv &x ^ v - ^T^ ^ T ' ^ ^ Ti kclto, tktoov kcc- 
oiKatov kcu ecrt rt "C^uiov frtKcuov. -dKoKv^vo-i £e a.vrcu, ty\ fxev20 ra,<pY\o-Y\ ri$ fxta, x.&Ta,(pa,o-ig, dKKd cpoovv\ /xev fxta, ko,to,- 
ircLg dvSpooTrog » o x tKa,tog ecrtv y) vfretg ecrtv 'a,v$poo7rog frtKatog, cpa,<retg &e 7roKKa,t, tre ea,v ko,$' evog raZra,, dKK' ofxotoog 
rv\ o% ecrt rtg av$poo7rog cftxcuog v\ dvTiKStfxew\ crt i ircLg a,v- ttoKKOjI. et w v\ epooTY\o~tg v) oia,KeKTtKV\ d7roKpicreoog ecrtv cu- 
Spoo7Tog ecjtv « frtKciiog' dva,yKY\ ya,p etva,t rtva,. (pa,vepov cfs TY,o-tg, v\ t^? 7Tpora,osoog v\ $a,rep>i fxoptM TY)g dvrKpdveoog, v\ 
y,a\ %rt e7r\ fxev roov ko,$' eKO-crov, el d,Kv\$eg epooTv\$evra. d%o- t% 7rpora,o-tg dvripcureoog fxioog fxoptov, «jt dv eiv\ diroKpto-ig 
(py,Tcu, oTi kcu KO,Ta,(pY\0-a,i dKv\$eg' olov dpa, • ysW%ooKpa,Tv\g 25 fxiai' 7rp og raZra,' &$s ya,p v) spoorY\o-ig fxia,, icV sdv v) dKv\- 
trocpog; «. \%ooKpa,rv\g apa, ■« o~o<pog. stti <\e roov ko.$oK* mk $v\g. eipv\Ta,t be ev ro?g To~TtKoTg Trept cwroov. dfxa, oe StjKcv 
dKyfivig v\ ofxoioog Keyofxevy\, d,Kv\$Y\g S~e v\ diroipao-tg, olov dpa ■ %ri vfrs ro rt scrtv epoorv\o-ig ecrt hta,KeKTtKv\' $st ydp frs&oo-^ou 
ys 7Toig a.v$poo7To'g tropog; «. ircLg apa, a.v$poo~rog « vocpcg' sk rY t g epoorv\o-eoog sKso~$ou oTrorspov fixKsrou TY\g dvrKpAosoog 
T6T0 ya,p -^svbog. dKKa, ro k to? a,pa, a.v$poo7rog crocpog fxoptov d7ropv\va,o-$cu. dKKa. c\sT rov spooroovra. 7Tpo~~$topio~cu 
dKr,$eg' a,vrv\ b s e'e~~iv v) d^tKsifxsvY t , sKStvv\ frs v) sva,vria,. 30 -rorspov robs ecrtv o a,v$poo7rog v\ « tkto. 

A/ fre KO/ra, ra, doptcra, dvrtKsty.svcu ovofxa-ra, ko-i pv\- '^ttsi os ra, fxsv Ka,TY\yopsTra,i o~vvri$efxeva , Cog ev ro 

fxa,ra,, olov e~rt tS fxv\ a,v$poo7rog Kat fxv, StKa,tog, ooo~~rep d~ro- rrcLv KarYiyopYifxa, roov X U P^ Ka,rv\yop\ifxevoov, rd <$' «, rig v) 
(pa,~stg civsv ovofxa,rog Ka,t pv\fxa,rog So^eta-v dv 'sTvat. &k etc~t cftacpcpa,; Karra ya,p t« dv$poo~r>i dKv\$eg etTreTv kou %wo)? 
M' det ya-p dKv\$evetv dva,yKY\ M -ipev&ec-$at rv\v d7ro<pa,criv, TJipov xa,\ X°°P^ ^i-TW, koCi ravra, ug ev, koa ctv$pco7rov kcu 
o cf ehroov xk a,v$poo7rog icfev fxdKKov t« eiTovrog a,v$poo~rog 35 KevKOV, kou to,v$' oog ev. dKK' ix^ £ ' o-Kvrevg kcu dya,$og, 
dKKa. Kai y\ttov Y,Kr,$evKe rt v\ e-pev~~a,i, ea,v fxv\ri 7rpo~-e$Y\. kcu o-Kvrsvg dya$og. st ydp, ort SKO,repov dKv\$sg, sTvcu frsT 
~-Y\fxa,ivst <ie to ecrt ~ra,g kk a,v$poo~rog b^i-Kaiog i&sfxioL SKsivoov koa to o-vva,fx<poo , TroKKd Kcti a,ro~ra, scrat. KO,rd ydp t« 
ra/jrov, K6^e v) dvrtKStfxsvY\ to,vty\ y) kk ecrt -roig vk a,v$poo~rog dv$poo~r\i kcu to dv$poo~rog dK.Y\$eg kol\ to KevKov, oocre kcu to 
cYtKatog' ro be- 7Tclg « cfiKcuog xk dv$poo7Tog rco icfe\g bUouog a,7ra,v. -ra,Ktv el ro Kevx.ov' ctvro, KoCt ro d~ra,v, cocre e<rcu ctv- 
yk a,v$poo7Tog tckvtov ~-v}fxaivet. 40 $poo~rog KevKog KevKog, kcu riro stg cX~rstpov. koa 7ra,Kiv 



3. TTOotrxcuy. evo.1 B. II i;pa.pyJ TTe i A. II 4. vyocivsiv xcA Qccbii^siv C. II 8. ru civQpunru C. II 12. t-Tvcu om BC. II 13. y jA.r\Mg 
B, P, to ^jj^a? C. II 23. ii;\v ante &itpanr^ C. II 24. Xtk om C. .11 eKcig-ot, B. II 33. §af«ev ABC. II 35. elz-cvro- om BC. 

8. Xsvno? Zifymti A: tl 16. ev ante f om C. II 24. jiufc ic-i popuv C. ... 



nEPI EPMHNEUX 21 

/uctsrtxog Kevxog fta.fr tC,oov' xctt toajto, 7roKKa,xtg TreTrKeyfxeva, th eTvou a,v$poo7rov a,7ro<pa,rtg to fXY, eTva,i a.v$pco7rov, « to £jvc« 
«V a,7reipov. ert el 6 %ooxpa,TY,g '%coxpa,TY i g xo,l a,v$pco7rog, xo,l /xy, a,v$pcoxov, xa,) tk eTvai Kevxov a,v$pui7rov to fXY\ eTvau Kev- 
^ooxpa,TY,g \%ooxparrY\g a,v$poo7rog. xa,i el a,v$pco7rog xa,t frnrxg, xov a,v$poo7rov, a,KK' « to eTva,t jxy\ Kevxov a,v$pco7rov. et ya)p 
xa,) a,v$poo7rog a,v$pco7rog frnrxg. xa,Ta, 7ra,vTog y\ xa,Ta.<pa,rig y\ y\ a,7ro<pa.rtg, to ^rpKov ecctt 

r/ Ort fxev «v ei Ttg a\irKoog <pY\ret Ta,g rvfX7rKoxa,g yt- 5 a\K.Y,$eg ehrstv eTva,t fxv\ Kevxov a,v$poo7rov. el fre tkto xToog, 
ver$a,t, ttoKKo) rvfxftociveLKeyeiv cltotto,, frY\Kov "oTroog fre $e- xau orotg ro eTvctt /xy\ 7rpoci$eTO,t,. to o,vto 7roiyrei to cLvt) 
reov, Keyofxev vvv. toov frv\ xa,TY,yop6fxevu)v , xau e<p' olg xa,- t« eivou Keyofxevov, otov t« <Lv$pco7rog ftacfriCei « to ix a,v$pco- 
rv\y ope?r$a,t rvfxfta,ivet, ora, fxev KeyeTO,t xarra, rvfxfteftvixog rrog fta,frtCet a,7ro<pa,rtg ecctt, cLKKa, to « fta.friCe.L a,v$poo7rog' 
y\ xa,Ta) T6 a.vri yi $drrepov xa,Ta) $a.Tepts, tojvto, \$x eca,i ifrev ya,p fria.cpepei ehrelv a,v$punr.ov . fta.friC^etv y, a.v$pco7rov /Sct— 
ev, oTov ctv$poo7rog Kevxog ect xou fx>srixog, a\KK' \$x ev to 10 frtCpna, eTvou. ooce el \sroog 7ra,VTa.^, xa,t. t« Aivoltov eTva,t 
Kevxov xa,) to fx\$rtxoV rvfxfteftvixoTa, ya)p a,fx<pui tuo ojvtc^. a,7ro<pa,rtg eca,i to frvvarrov fxv\ eivou, cLKK' & to fxv, frvva,Tov 
vfr' et to Kevxov fx\$rixov a,Kv\$eg et7relv, o/xuigix ecctt . to eTva.t. <foxet . <$e to ojvto o\>va,r$at xa.t eiya.t xa.t fXY[ eTva.t' 
fjvtsrtxov Kevxov. ev rf xo.to, rvfx$e$Y,xog ya.p to fitMrtxov Kev- 7ra.v ydp to (fvva.Tov Tefx,ver$a.t y, 'fta.fr tCjetv xa.) fXY, .fta.fr tCen 
xov, oocre \sx eqa.t.To Kevxov f/.\srtxov ev Tt. frto >$<f o rxvTevg xa.) fXY, Tefxver$a,t frvva,Tov. Koyog fre, oti a,7ra,v to \stoo frv- 
a,7rKuJg a.ya,$og, a.KKa) C^uov frtTrW « ya.p xo,to. rvfxfteftY,- 1$ vo,tov ix a,e) evepyet, oocre V7ra,pzet ojvtoo xa,t y\ a,7ro<pa,rtg' 
xog. e.Tt ifr' %ra, h/VTrdpyjet ev tu eTepoo. frto kte to Kevxov frvvarra,t ya,p xa,) fjLYJ fta.frtCetv to ftafrtcrtxov xa,t ju,y, opa,r$a.i 
7roKKa,xig vre o a,v$poo7rog a,v$poo7rog (^wov ecriv y, frt7rw ew- to oparrov. a.KKa, fXY,v d\frvva.Tov xarra, t« o,vt6 a.KY,$ever$a.i 
7roipx si -y&p & too a,v$pco7roo to XJ^ov xou to frtTpsv. a.K.Y,$eg Ta)g a.vrtxetfxeva,g <pa,retg' ix ctpa, t« frvva,Tov eTva.t a,7rc<pa,- 
fre ecriv elirelv xarra. t« Tivog xa.) a,7rKu>g, olov tov tlvo. a,v$poo- rig ecrt to fruva,Tov fxv\ eTva.t. rvfxfta.tvet ya.p ex tktcov y, to 
ttov a,v$pco7rov vj tov Ttva) Ksvxov ctv$poo7rov civ$pco7rov Kevxov 20 ctuTo <pa,va,t xa,i a,7ro<pa,va,i cLfxa, xa.) xarra, vk o,vt*$, y\ fXY[ 
\sx che) fre, oiKK' oto,v pcev ev tcZ 7rporxetfjcevco tcov. cLvTixei- xarra, to eiva.t xa.i fxv, eTvcti to, 7rpocri$efJL£va, yiver$a,i <pa,retg 
uevcov ti ewTrdpxy V zteTa.t a,vri<pa.rig, \sx a,K.Y,$eg oLKKa. xa,t a,7ro<pa,retg. el \sv exetvo a,frvva,Tov, t«t' a,v etY, a,ipeTov. 
'Jjevfrog, oTov tov Te$vecoTa, a,v$pco7rov a,v$poo7rov etTrelv, oto.v fre eg-tv a.pa, a,7ro<pa,rtg tk ^bvctTov eTva,t to fJCY, frvva,Tov etva,i, 
fXY[ evv7ra,px$-> chK.Y,$eg. y, otocv fxev evvTra.pxY,, a)e) ix oLKy,- o fr' ocvTog Koyog xa,t irept t» evfre-Xfifxevov eTva,i' xaX ya)p 
$eg, 'ora.v fre fxvj ew7ra.pXYi ,. {$x cLe) a\Kv\$eg, cor7rep c/ OfXY,pcs 25 t«t» a,7ro<pa.rig to fXY\ evfrex^^vov eTvout. xa.) e7r) toov a,KKoov 
ecri Tt, oTov 7rotYiTyg. a,p w xa.) ecrtv, y\ \$; xa,TO, rvfxfteftv,xog fre ofxotoTpo7rcog, oiov a,va,yxa.t\$ Te xa,t a,frvva,Tt$. yiveTctt ya.p 
ya)p xa,TY,yopeiTcit Ts^OfXYipx to ecr.iv' "otl ya,p 7rotY,TY,g ecrtv, corTrep ex' exetvoov to eTva.t xa.t to /xy, eTvau 7rpor$eretg, to, <f 
a)KK' « xa,$' a,vTo, xa,TY,yope?Ta,t xo,to, t« 'OfXYipx to ecrtv. vTroxeifxeva, 7rpa.yfxa.Ta, to /xev Kevxov to fr' a,v$pco7rog, \srcog 
cocre ev orcttg xa,TY,yopia,ig fXYfre eva,VTtoTY,g evectv, ea,v Koyot evTO.v$a, to fxev etva.t xa,t fXY, eTvau oog vTroxeifxevov ytveTOU, 
cbvr ovofxa,Toov KtycovTa,t, xa.) xa,$' eavTa, xa,TY,yopYrra,t xa.i3Q to ^e frvva,r$a,i xa,t to evfrexer$a,t 7rpor$eretg frtopiCjsra.1, 
fXY, xarra. rvfxftefty\xog , e.7rt tmtcov to tl xcct d,7rKoog a,KY,$eg oor7rep £7r' exetvoov to eTva,L xccl fXY, eTva,i, to a.KY\$eg xo.l to 
£CO,l ei7retv. to fre fxv\ ov, otl fro^a.cov, \$x a.KY\$eg ehrelv ov ^evfrog, ofxoioog a.vTa.i eTri tk eTva.L frvva,Tov xau eTva,L i frvva,- 
tl' fro^ra, yacp a,vT6 ix eciv otl ecLv, ccKK' oti ix ectv. tov. t» fre frvva,Tov fXY, eTva,L a.7ro<pa.rig \$ to » frvva,Tov eTva,t, 

12 T»tojv fre fricoptrfxevcov rxeTrreov "oiroog ex^riv a.1 a,7ro- ocKKa, to & frvva,Tov fXY\ eTva,t, xa,i t« frvva.Tov eTva,L i to frvva,- 

<pa,retg xa,t xa.Ta.<pa.reig Trpog a.KK.Y\Ka.g a.1 t« frvva.Tov eTvau 35 tov jxy, eTvau, cLKKa, to jxy, frvva.Tov eTvau. frto xa.i a,xoK6$etv 
xa.1 fXY, frvva-Tov xa,t evfrexoftevov xou [xy, evfrex^fxevov, xa.) ocv fro^eta,v a,KKY\Ka,ig a.1 tk frwa.Tov eTva,i xa.) frvva.Tov fxv\ 
TrepL tk a.frvva,Tt$ re xckl .d.va.yxa.fis ' exet ya.p a.7ropiccg Tiva.g. eTva,t' to ya,p o,vto frvva,Tov eTvau _ xa.) fxv\ eTva,L' & ya,p cLvrt- 
el yacp tcov rvfXTrKexofxevcov a.vTa,i a.KKY,Ka.tg a.vTixetvTa,i a.v- cpocretg o,KKy\Koov oa TOia,vTou, to frvva,Tov eTva.L xcCt frvvarrov 
Tt<pa,retg, ora,i xarra, t.o eTva.1 xou fXY, eivau Ta,TTovTa,t, oTov /xy\ eTvctt. oiKKa) to frvva,Tov eTva,t xa.) [xy\ frvva,rov eiva,i ifreTrore 

2. £i? cLwetpov om BC. II 3. alterum ^uiy.pdrvn om AB. II 4. altcrum a.v5punro? om AB et corr.C II 12. kg-t C. II 14. >.su- 
xov x.uX pvq-lxcv B. II o om C. II 17. alterum cLvSpuiros om B. II 20. mdpco7rov xoti Xewov C. II 21. -KpoKZLpivu pr C. II 23. tov om 
pr C. II 27.'*tS] Y.cKxa. tb C. II oTt — 28. to ecrtv om pr C. II 28. ■ko.tcI om margo C. II 33] mtou igtv i% 2tj B. 

5. H C. II 2i. £»ui, a,AX' ixt to ffwctTov fxri Btvcu. o C. II 29. Wi to tt^ C. II \ntoy.e.ty.zva. C. II 31. X«i to prj C. II 33. « T^ — 
d,XXd om BC. II 34. fiy etvot.tj ^r, wct.i, d)X i%t to & ow&toy wi C. II xou t» - ju-<j ovvxtov stvcu om BC. II ts] to « A. II 36. h- 
%etzv AB. II td — pr, slvou om AB. II 38. to — pr, tlyou om BC. 



22 HEPI EPMHNEU^. 

&7U ri ctvri cXfxa, d\Yi$evovrau' dnixeivrau yctp. i% ye to d7ro<pa.o~tg ri dvctyxvi fxv\ eTvat.ro ix dvdyxY\ eTvctt' evM^ercu 

Svvctrov jxy) eTvou xoti i %va,rov fxv\ eTvou i%7rore kfxa hri ya)p d\Y\$eveo-$at ein ri ctvrov dfx<porepa,g' to yap dvacyxouov 

t» ccut». d\Y\$evovrat. bfxotcog cfe xau t« dya,yxa,?ov elvou d-ro- [xv\ eTvou ix dva,yxa,?ov sTvcu. cutiov % ri \xy\ dxo\M$e?v ro 

(bcurig i to dvotyxouov /xy) elvcu, d\>.ot to fXY\ dvctyxouov eT- dvctyxcttov bfxotcog ro?g erepotg, Irt hctvrtcog to d%varov ru 

Vcu' ri <fe dvccyxcuov /xy\ eTvcu ro /xy\ dvayxcttov /xy\ eTvou. 5 dvctyxaico d7rocfi%Ta,i, to olvtq %va/xevov. el yap d%varov 

xou ri dSvvotrov eTvcu i ro d%votrov \xy\ eTvcu, d\\a, to fXY\ eTvcu, dva,yxouov rovro ix eTvou aWa, fXY\ eTvou' el Se d%vct- 

dcfvvctrov eTvou ' ri Se d%varov /xy\ eTvctt ro ix d%vctrov fXY\ tov [xyi etvat, rovro dvayxY\ eTvcu' coc-e el exeTva, b/xotcog rco %- 

eTvcu. xcu xa,$o\\i %, cocnrep etpYrrctt, to fxev eTvcu xat fxvi yarco xou fXY\, ravra, e£ ha,vrta,g, eVei i crY\fxatvei ye ravrov 

eTvcu S~e? rt$eva,t cog ra, vTroxetfxeva,, xctra<pa,o-tv % xau diro- ro Te dva,yxa,?ov xa,\ to d%va,rov, d\\' oocnrep e'tpY\rat, dvre- 

<ba,Q-tv TcivTa, irotivTa, irpog to eTva,i xou fXY\ eTvcu o-vvra,rretv. 10 crpctfxfxevcog. y) d%vctrov ovrcog xe?r$a,t ra,g rov dvayxcttvi dv- 

xcti ra,vra,g o'teo-$a,t xpvi etvat rctg dvrtxetfxevctg <pao-eig, %- Ttcpctcretg; to fxev yap dvayxouov eTva,t %voltov elvcu' el yap 

va/rov - i %varov, ev^ep^o/xevov - ix h%xafxevov, d%vctrov - /xy\, y\ diro<ba.o-tg dxo\x$Y\crei' dvayxv\ yap y\ <pava,t y\ d,7ro- 

ix d%va,rov, dvctyxouov - ix dvayxcttov, d\vi$eg - ix d\v\$eg. <pava,t' oocp el /xv\ <hva,rov eTva,t, dcfvva,Tov eTva,t' d£vva,Tov dpa, 

13 K.OU 0,1 dxo\\i$Y\Q-etg Se xarra, koyov ytvovTou ytco Tt$e- eTvou to dva,yxa,?ov eTvou, o7rep &T07rov. dh\a, /xy\v tco ye <%- 

fxevotg' tu fxev ya,p Svvcctqv eTva,t to evfrex l eo-$a,t eTva,t, xa.ilSya.Tov eTvou tq ix d$vva,Tov eTva,t dxohx$e?, t«tw <£e to fXY\ 

t»to exetvco dvrtq-pecpet, xcu to fXY\ dfrvvctTov eTvcu xou to fxv\ dva,yxa,?ov eTva,t' oocje o-vfxfia,tvet to dva,yxa,?ov eTva,t fxv\ dva,y- 

dva,yxa,?ov eTvcu' tco Se S~uvo,tov /xy\ eTva,t xou evcJe^ofxevov fxv\ xouov eTvcu, %7rep a,T07rov. dhha, /xy\v ou<5e to dva,yxa,?ov eTvcu 

eTvcu to /xy\ dva,yxa,?ov /xy\ eTva,t xdt to ix d8vva,Tov jxy\ eTvdt, dxokvSe? tw <%vo,tov eTva,t, i$e to dva,yxa,?ov fXY\ etva,t' tw fxev 

tu> <5e fxvi <fvva,Tov eTvat xa,t /xy\ h^e-Xfi/xevov eTva,t to. dvccy- ya,p a,/x<pco h&ixeTcu o-vfx(Ba,tvetv, t^stcov <% oTroTepov a,v dX.v\- 

Ktt,?ov fxvi eTvou xcu to dcfvva,Tov eTvcu, tw <Te /xy\ <hva,Tov /xyi 20 $\g r,, ixeTt eqa,t exeTva, dXv\$y\. cX/xa. ydp Svvoltov eTvcu xcu 

eTvcu xou ixy) hbrxfifxevov /xy) eTvou to dva,yxa,?ov eTva,t xoct /xy\ eTvou' ei <¥ dva,yxY\ eTvcu y\ /xy\ eTvcu, ix ecpou <%vo,tqv 

to d£vva,Tov /xy) eTvcu. $ecopeto-$co be ex vng v7roypa,<pY\g cog dfx<pco. XenreTact Totvvv tq ovx dva,yxcuov /xy) eTva,t dxoX>i$e?v 

Xeyofxev. tco ^vvovrov etvou. t«to ya.p dXv\$\g xoci xarrd t« dvayxouov 

Svva,rov eTva,i i <fvva,Tov eiva,t eTva,i. xa,t ya,p o,vty\ y(vera,t dvr(<pa,Q~tg tyi eTrofxevvi roo i frvva,- 

hbe-xpfxevcv eTvou ix hfrexofxevov eTva,i 25 rov eTvau' exeivoo ydp dxoX>i$e? ro d<yvva,rov eTva,t xcu dvcty- 

ix dcfvva,Tov eTvcu dbvva,rov eivcu xouov fxv\ eTvou, i y) d7ro<pa,o-tg ro ix dva,yxa,?ov fxvi eTvcu. dxo- 

ix dva,yxa,?ov eivou dvocyxcuov fXY\ eivcu X^rt re apa, xau a,vra.t a,t dvrt<pa,o-eig xocrd rov elpvifxevov 

$vva,rov fXY\ eTvou i <%va,rov /xy\ eTva,t rpoTrov, xa,t iSev d%va,rov o-v/xfiocivei rt$efxevcov "ircog. 

h^eyfifxevov fXY\ eTvcu ix hcfe%ofxevcv fxv\ eTvcu ' A.7ropY\o-ete &' dv rtg et tw dva,yxouov eTvou ro <%va,rov 

ix dcfvva,Tov fXY\ eTva,t dc%va,rov fxy\ eTvou 30 eTvou £7rera,i. ei re ya,p /xy\ e7rera,t, y) dvrt<pa,o-tg dxo\>i$Y\Q-ei, ro 

ix dvctyxouov {xy\ eivcu dva,yxa,?ov etva,t. fXY\ tfvva.rcv etvcu' xcu et rtg to.vty\v /k,y\ <pY\Q-etev etva,t dvrtipa,- 

To fxev «v dc\vva,TQV xcu ix dcfvvarov rco ev^e^o/Aevy <rtv, dva,yxv\ Xeyetv ro <%vo,tov jxy) eTvcu' direp a,/x<pco ^evcfvi 

xcCt %va,ru xou ix hcfexo/xevco xou /xy\ %va,rw dxo\>i$e? xarra, ri dva,yxa,?ov etva,t. d\\a, fxv\v TraXtv to a,vro eTva,i 

fxev dvrt<pa,Tixuig, dvTeqpa,fXfxevcog c\e' roo /xev ya,p %va,rov eT- froxe? %va,rov refxveo-$a,t xa.) /xyi re/xveQ-$a,t xcu eTvcu xou /xy\ eT- 

mt y) d7ro<pa,Q-tg ri d%va,r>i dxoXv$e?, ty { <% d7ro<pa,o-et y) xa,- 35 vcu, oog-e eqa,t ro dva,yxa,?ov eTva,t h^exfifxevov fxvi eTvcu' riro 

T&cpctQ-tg' rco ya.p i %\a,rov eTvou ro d%va,rov eTva,t' xa,ra,<pa,- <% "^evcfog. <pa,vepov cfvi ort ov ttoLv ro %va,rov y\ eTva,t y\ @a,<}t- 

<rtg ydp ro d%va,rov eTva,t, ro cf ovx d%va,rov eTvcu d7ro<pa,rtg. Zetv xcu ra, dvrtxeifxeva, %va,rat, d\\ ecjtv e<fi covix d\Y\$eg, 

to $"' dva,yxa?QV Trcog, oTrreov. cpavepov <% %rt i% %rcog e%et, 7rpcorov fxev exl rcov jxy) xocra \oyov %va,rcov, oiov ro Trvp $ep- 

d\\' au ha,vTtau e7rovra,t' a,t cf dvrtcpa.cretg %copig. i yap etrtv fxa,vrtxov xcti e%et %votfxtv ctXoyov. ctt fxev %v fxera Xoyx 

1. «.vTtV.siTou. C. II 14. a,l om C. II 15 et 17. h\va.rw ABC. II 17 et 19. hhe^ofJLiiu ABC. II 20. hva,Ta pr C: corr cura 
AB &vvoltu} II 21. hfexofA.iwi AB. II 24—31. haec ut nunc sunt, rccentior manus in margine v4Z?C disposuit: antiqua eodem 
tenore fruva.Tov £i'v*i , lvh%oiJ.sm wou — a* xva.yx.a.hv fA,r\ ewou, » ftvvoCTcv bwm, in hfr. — wocpicuov eTvok. II 34. ftvv&Tto ABC. n 35. omo- 
tefol' om BC. II 36. fovxTujABC. II 37. allerum ewi om BC. 

3. To xva.^y.cuoy om B et pr C. II 6. £%t BC. II 12. % ante ^avctt om C. II 18. fova,Tui AB. II 21. dvct/yx»! « eTvsw C. II 
24. &jv&t£i AB. II 27. ts om C et corr A. II 31. pj to,vty\v C. II 32. post to deletum aliquid B. II 33. eTva,i u?s tu avat.y- 

KOAOV stvO.1 TO 0~VVO,TOV £7T£T0U. 0,\\t>L C. II &>t£j' £1^*1 C. ■ 



IIEPI EPMHNEIAX 23 

Svvctfxets au a,vrau 7rXetovu)v Kcti roov ivoLvriuov, ctt <? ctXoyot ort «x dyot$ov ^pev^r,s, erepct b% ort kakov. irorepct b~Y\ riruv 
* Tr&Tat, etAA' u)T7rep : etpv\rctt, ro-irvp « ■frvvctrov $epfxctivstv ivctyria, rvi, dXvfieT; Kai el ecjt fxia,, kol$' bxorepctv y) ivctvricti 
kcu fxv\, \scf %to, ctXXa, ivepyeT dei. evict fxevroi b\ivctrcti kcu ro- fxev byj t«tw cter$cu ra,s ivavria,s ^o^cc; upioScu, ru ruv 
roov Ka,rd rds dXoyovs hjvctfxets oLfxa, ra, dvriKetixevct $i%0LT$ai. ivctvriuov etvcu, 'psv&os' t« ydp dya$x orl dya$ov kcu t« xctKV 
dXXd rvro /u.ev rvrv xapiv elpYtrcu, ori-i 7ra,<ra, b\vctfxts roov 5 oT< kolkov y\ a,vrr, "itoos kcu dXY\$r\s eqcu, eire nrXsiovs she 
dvrtKeifxevoov, «<^' %toli XeyovroLt Kctra, ro ctvro eTt\oSi eviat&e fxta, icjiv. ivdvria _be ra,vra,. dXX' « tw ivavrioov eTvcu ivctvrict, 
b^vvctfxets bfxoovvfxoi etTtv. ro yoop biivarov ovx dirXws Xeye- dXXa, fxaXXov ru havrioos. si <Jv) ecjt fxkv t« dyaM ort iqw 
rcu, dXXd ro fx.lv %rt dXv\$es tos evepyeia, ov, oTov b\)varov dya$ov ■ do^ct, dxXr, £' %rt «>c dya&ov, ecjtcfe ciXXo rt o &% 
fi&frCC^etv ort ftctbtCei, ko,i %Xoos Bvvarov etva,t %rt r\b\ ecji vTrapx^ &£' olov re vTTctp^at , roov fxev &r\ ctXXoov ibiefxictv 
Kctr ivepyetav o Xeyerat eTvcu b^vvotrov, ro <Je otj ivepyr\Teiev 10 0eTeov, «Te 'otcu vTrapxetv ro fxr, v7ra,px°v fro^aCpTtv «tS 7 otcu 
ctv, otov b\ivarov eTva,t fia.friCeiv %rt (SafriTetev dv. kou ' ctvrr, fxr, vizapyjuv ro V7ra,px°v (oLTreipot yap dfX(porepat, kcu otcu 
fxev eVl ro?<; Ktvr,ro7<; iqt fxovotg r\ $vva,fxis, iKetvr, Se kou e7fi vTcapxetv frojraXpTi ro fxr\ vTtapxpv ko,) %Tat fxr, v7ra,pxetv ro 
ro?s dKtvr,rots. a,fxcpu) <5e dXr,$es et7re?v ro fxr, dc\iva,rov eTvat v7ra,pxov), dXX' iv %to,is icjtv y\ dncLrr,. abrat fre etTtv ifc uv 
fiafrtC^etv r] eTvat, ko\ ro fia,btCpv r\o% kcu ivepyw kcu ro fia,- cu yeveTets. iK ruiv dvrtKetfxevuv 8e au yeveTets, oosre kou cu 
frtqiKov. ro fxev «i/ «tw ch)va,rov ovk dXr\&es Ka.ro, rov dva,y- 15 d7xa,rat. et w ro dya$ov kou dya,$ov kcu « ko,kov icyt, kcu 
KaiK A7rXu)S etTretv, $a,repov 8e dXrfies. uiqe eVe! ruj iv fxe- ro fxev ko,§ eavro ro <5e KO/ra, TVfx@e@r,Kos (TVfx@e(3r\Ke ya,p 
pei ro Ka$oX\i eirerat, tw e^ dvayKY\s ovrt e7rera,t ro ovva,- ctvru) « ko,ku) eTvat), fxclXXov 6% eKacps dXr,$r\s r\ k&& ecwro, 
crdcu eTvcu, « fxevrot ira,v. kcu eqt S~yj dpxA ^tuos ro dva,y- kou ypevo\\s, e v nrep kou dXr\$r\s. r, fxev «v ot< yk dya&ov to 
kcuov kcu [xy} dvayKcuov 7ra,vru)V r, eTvou r\ fxr\ eTvcu, kcu dya,Qov t« k&>9 eavro V7ro,pxovros ^pevo^s, v\ $e t« art ko,- 
rcXXKa, u)s rovrois dKoXvS&vra, £7r itkotteTv freZ %) kcv t« Kctrd . TVfx(3e(2r\Kos. uoqe /xaXXov a,v etr, \pev6\is t« 

$>a,V£pov o^vj ek roov slpYifxevcov %rno i% dvctyy.v\? ov xa,r dya,<% y\ ty\s d7ro<pa,T£U)S v\ v\ t« iva.vrt^ frofca,. hripevcfcu oe 
ivepyetoiv iqtv, oog-e et Trporepa, rd dtfrta,, ka) y\ ivepyeta, b\>- fxctXtga, Trept EKctqov 6 rry iva,vrta,v s-xjjov ho^ajv' rd ydp ivctv-r 
vdfXEoos irporepa,. xa) rd fxev ctvev 6\iva,fxeoos ivepyetat etTtv, rta, ruiv xXeTgov frtacpepovroov rrep) ro a,vro. el «v ivavria, fxlv 
oTov a,t Trpuirou vticu, ra, <& fxera, b\>va,fxeu)S, c\ ry. fxev tpv- rxrcov v) erepa,, iva,vrtu)repa, <& r\ rr\s dvrtcpoLTeoos, b^Xov %rt 
Tet Trporepcoroo b\ %povoo vcjepa,,ra, b\ «<5e7roTe ivepyetcu et- 25 aZrr\ dv etr\ evavria,. v\ be t« ot: kcckov to dya&ov TVfxrre- 
trtv dXXd b\jva,fxets fxov&v. ; rrXeyfxevr, icjt ' koli ya,p r ort vk dya,$ov dvJiyKY\ Xtoos vttq- 

\f^ Xlorepov be ivavrta, igtv r, KctracpctTiS rr, d7ro(pa,Tet r, Xa,fx(5a,vetv rov ctvrov. ert fre, el xat ixt ruov dXXoov . bfxotoos 

7\ KctrctfpOLTis rr\ Ka,ra,(pa,Tei , Kat b Xoyos ru .Xoyu) b Xe- freT ex,etv, xou ravrrj olv frofcete kolXuis etprfl-$a.t' v\ ydp irctv- 
yoov ort ttols dv$pu)7ros ttxcttos roo v$e)s ctv$pu)iros o^ikolios, ra,~)Q<,~ro rr,s dvrtcpctTeoos v\ vb'a,fxv. %tois Sb /xr, icjtv ivctv-- 
v\ ro ttcXs dv$pu)7ros frtKcttos roo TTcts dv$pu)7ros ol&ikos, olov 30 rtct, 7rep) rtroov .eq-t fxev '>pevb X Y\S v\ ry dXr\$eT dvrtKetfxevy\, 
eq-tK.a,XXtcts btKOLtos - vk sqt TLa,XXia,s frtKcuos-TLctXXtcts ct&t- oiov-b rov dv$pu)7rov %k dv$pu)7rov mo/xsvos he^evqou. ei Zv cw- 
xos icjt' Trorepct &r\ ivctvria, rxroov; et youp ra, fxeviv ' rr, (poovy rctt ivctvrtctc, xol) oli dXXcu au rr\s dvrt(pctTEU)S. iri bfxoioog 
dKoXxSsT roTs iv rr, b~ia,vota,, ekeT bs ivavrta, b\,^a, v) .rov ivav- gj^ei v) t« dyct$* %rt dyct$ov koa y\ t« fxr\ dyct$x %rt xk dyct- 
rU, olov %rt 7ra? a,v$poo7ros b^tKouos ry\ rrcLs dv$pu)7ros ctb^tKOS, $ov, kcu Trpos rotvrous v\ t« dyct${i ort «x. dya,$ov kou y) tv (xy\ 
Kctt irrt ruov iv ry (poovri KctrctcpctTsoov dvctyKr, bfxotuos £X eiv - 35 dyct$\i %ri dyctSov. rr, w t« fxv) dya$x %rt «>c dya,$ov dXr,$sT 
sl cfe fxr, eKeTv) t« eV&vm c\o%ol ivctvrta, icjiv, icfe y) Kctracpa,- vtyi bofyi ris dv eir\ v)- ivotvrict; i ydp &y) y) XeytTO, %rt kcl- 
tis rv\ KctrctcpctTSi egat ivctvrta, ctXX r) s\pr,fx(vY\ d7ro(pa,Tts. koV c%fxct yap dv 7roTe eiv\ dXr,$r,s , ^sTrors b~s dXr\$r { s dXv,- 
ucj-e TKSTrrsov irota, b^o^ct dXr\$r,s -psvb^sT b^o^vj ivctvria,, Trors- $sTiva,vrict' scrt ydp n'fxr\ dyoi&cv -kclkov, ' uocjs iv^s^xsrai ctfxct 
pov v) rr,s d7ro(pa,Tsu)S y\ y) to ivavriov eTvctt b^o^cLQiTct. Xeyoo dXr,$eTs eTvat.-ib' ctv vj %rt b kctkov' [dXY,$Y,s yap xa\ avrr,' 
Se oofre. ecjt rts cfo^ct dXv\$Y\s t« dyct$\i ort dyct$ov, otXXr, cfe 40 ctfxct ydp kol) rctvrct ctv etr,. Xeiirerctt ovv rr\ t« fxr\ dyam 

3. ^j'voc.y™t AB. il 8. lv6D7£io<- C. II a om C et pr A. II l4. acti rb mpfiv B. fl to om corr ^.11 1S. fiincno ttm corrA. II 
22. i'&a pr C. II 30. n o to pr C. II 36. pr,h% C. II 38. ^euftjf »X^ti corr B. II fcfgci C. 

5. h-M om C. II 17. ol-jto C. -II 19/ mto C. II 23. owto ^svs,-. sl C. II 2k. ATrocpdcsu? C. II 21. iet om pr C. II 38. ^ 
«■7*5cv corr B. 



24 IIEPI EPMHNEIAX 

oTi w coyoLUov svavTtoL v\ tk ^avi cty^&K ct< a,ya,bov' \pevdvis <%yoLW. cotr.e £/7T£/j e%i dctys mtoos s%st, eltl 6e cu.sv tyi tpoovy 

ydp avrvi. ooqe kcu y\ t» dya,$v oti xk dya,$cv ty\ t» dya,- KOLTcup&Teis kcu d7xc(poLTeLS Tvfxi3cXoL toov ev Ty ipvxy, Sr r 

#a ot< dya,$ov. (pavepov 6s qtl &6ev cWcra &$' dv x&Sohv tl- Xov qtl kol\ Ka,Ta,(pa,TeL evoLVTLa, /xev d7xo(pa,TLS v) 7xep\ t» 

Qoo/xev ty\v KO,Tcl(pa,TiV v\ yap kol$qXv dTxocpoLTLS evo,vtlo, clvtx Ka,$oX\s, olov tyi otl txolv dya&ov dya,$ov v\ oti nxds civ- 
ecjcu, oTov ty\ (fo^vi Ty c\o^oX^>ty\ qti ttcXv o dv vi dya,$ov dyct- 5 $poo7xcs dya,$cs v\ %tl icfev v\ \sSe(s, dvTKpoLTLKoos 6e otl v\ « 

$dv ecj-LV y\ ctl \s6sv toov dyctSoov dya,$ov. v\ ya,p t« dyoL&x otl 7xdv v\ i Txds. (poLvepov 6% "otl kol\ dXv\$v\ dXv,$£? wc ev&xstcu 

dycoSdv, st kcl$oX\s to dya,$ov, v\ clvtv\ ecri tv\ qtl o dv y\ evclvtlolv eTvoLi kte So^clv «T£ d7xd(pa,Tiv. evclvticll fx\v ydp cu 

dya,$cv So^olC^tyi otl dya,$ov tkto <$£ xSh S~toL(pepei th otl ixept tcl dvTiKetfxeva,, 7xepi tclvto, Se svSsx^toll dXY\$evsLV tcv 

txoXv o c%v v\ dya,$ov dy<x$ov scriv. ofxoMS cfe kcu £7n t» fxv\ olvtov dfxct cfe $k evSe^eTcu, t* evoLVTict, V7ra.px^v 7y ol-vtQ. 



ANAATTIRQN IIPOTEPQN A. 



1 JipooTov SL7re?v 7tep\ tl kcu tivo? ier)v v\ o-Ke-ipis, "otl irep\ 10 v7tc$eo~eoov elXyifXfJLevvi, <fta,KeKTiKvi cVe 7rvv$oivofxevtc fxev epoo- 
ditcbei&LV kcu e7ricj-vifxv\g dTrocfetKTLKYig' sTtol ^LoptTOLi tl ty\o-ls dvTKpoLo-ews, crvXkcyL^ofJLevct) $e KvrpLS t» (pcuvcfAevtf 
ecji ixpcTcurLS kcu tl opos kcu ti <rvX\oyL<rf&os , kcu txoHcs kcu evcfo^s, Ka.$a,7tep ev to?s To7tlko?s e'tpviTcu. tj fJLev «y ecji 
rekeios kcu ttolos dreX^s, fxerd <fs tolvtol t( to sv %Kco eT- TxpoTcUTLS, kcu tl (fia.^pspsi <rvKkoyLcriKY\ kcu d7rocfsiKTtKYi kcCi 

VOLL y) fJLYi sTv&L TO<fs TUK^S, KCU TL KsyCfJLSV TO KOLTOL 7TOLVT0S S~LOL/\SKTLKYj , Sl' dKptftstO,? fJLSV SV TO?? eTXOfXSVOLS pY\$Y\<rSTOLl, 

Y\ fJLY\<fsVCS KOLTYiyops?0-$OLi. 15 TXpoS <% TY\V TtoLp^frclLV "XtfStcLV LKOLVUS v\fX?V cflLOpL<r$CO T«t VVV. 

JJpCTOLO-LS fJLSV KV SCJl KoyoS KCLTcUpOLTLKOS Y\ d7X0(pOLTLKQS ^pOV <$E KOLkOO SLS <jV foa.kveTCU Y\ 7XpOTOL<rLS, 0T0V TO T£ KOLTY r 

Tivos Karxa, tlvos. vtos 6e r\ kclSoXv y\ ev fxepei v\ dS~LopLcros. yopv/xevov kcu tq ko,& k Kd,TYiyope?Tcu, v\ 7xpccrt$efxev>i v\ thcu- 
Xeyco <% ko,$oXx fxev to txclvtl y\ fjLY\Sevi v7xa,pxjeLV, sv /xepei p^fxsw t« eTva.L ko,l fxv\ sTvcu. TvXXoyLTfxos oV ecjL Xoyos ev 

$€ T0 TlVt Y\ fXY\ TLVL Y\ fXY\ 7X0LVTL VTX&p-XJSLV, dcflopLCTOV cfe TO 00 TS$SVT0OV TIVOOV hepOV Tl TOOV KeifXSVOOV f£ dvoLyKYlS <TVfX$CU- 
VTXcLpXeLV Y\ fXYi V7Xa,pXJELV OLVEV T« KOL$oX)i, Y\ KOLTOL fXEpOS, 0T0V 20 VEl TOO TOLVTOL ELVCU. XsyoO 6e TOO ToZtOL eTvcU TO frld TOLVTCt, 
TO TOOV eVOLVTlOOV eTvcU TY\V OLVTY\V eTXLCJY\fXY[V Y\ TO TY\V Y\6^0VYiV fXY\ EL- (TVfxfioLLVElV, TO 6% cflCL TOLVTOL CTVfxfioLlVELV TO fXYI&EVOS E^OO$EV 

vcu dya,$ov. $ta.<pspEt 6s v) d7xo$EiKTLKY\ 7xpcTa,Q-LS ty\s ho,XsK- opv 7xpocr$£?v Txpos to ysvE<T$cu To dvctyKcuov. teXelov fxev %v 
7lky\s, otl v\ fxev d7xc&eLKTiKY\ Xy^ls $a,Tep\s fxcpea ty\s dvTL(pa,- kolXoo <rvXXoyi<rfxov tov fXYiSevos olXXx 7Xpc<rhofXEVOV TXOLpd TOt, 
treoos ecrtv (k ya,p spooTct dXXa, XoLfx^OLvet o d7xofrsiKVvoov), r\ <Je e\Xv\fXfxeva, Txpos to <pa,VY\va,i to dva,yKcuov, dreXv] 6e tcv Txpocr- 

S^LOLXSKTIKYI spoOTYjTLS dvTKpOLTEOOS ' ECTLV. &6sV Ss &LOLTEI TXpoS TO 25 ^EQfXEVCV Y\ EVOS Y\ 7xXetOVOOV, OL e<Tl /XeV dvOLyKCUOL 6*L0L TOOV 

yeveT$a,L tov eKarxep* TvXXoyiTfXov kol\ ydp o dTxo&eLKWoov vTxoKeifxevoov opoov, « fxv\V etXv}7XTcu foa, 7xpoTo,Teoov. to $e ev 

KCU 6 SpOOTOOV TvXXoytCtTCU XolfioOV Tl KOLTOL TIVOS VTXOLpXeiV OXOO eTvcU ETEpCV ETEpOO KOLl TO KATOL 1X0.VTQS KCLTY\yops?T$CU 
y\ fXY\ V7X<Xp%SlV. OOCTE ECJOLL TvXXcyiCJLKY\ fXEV TXpoTOLTLS dTxXoOS SoLTEpV $OLT£pOV TOLVTOV SCJLV. XeyOfXeV 6s TO KOLTOL 7XOLVT0S 
KOLTXCpOLTLS Y\ d7X0(pO,TLS TLVOS KO.TO, TLVOS TOV slpv\fXEVOV Tpo- Ka,TYjyopE?T$CU, %TO,V fXV\SsV Y\ XOL^ELV TOOV T« V7X0KElfXEV\S, 
TXQV, d7XC§ELKTLKY\ ^f, EOLV dXv\$Y\S ^ KCU Sid TOOV £% dpXtfS 30 KOL$' « $0,T£pOV bt Xfi^tJfTETCt/ KCU TO KOLTOL fXYl^EVOS OOTOLVTOOS. 

1. Zti — otl a^oiSsv rc A supra lituram II aJhvfth 1 ; A, uXyQr.s "^rj^? B. II 6. ii — on ky&boi om A. II 7. t5jj 7r*v Ixt A et pr 
B. II % om C. II 9. o% om. A. 

4. Trj om BC et pr A. II 5. a.m<\>tMTMc2i A. II cti rj — 7r«?] i\ « 7rav x«i i\ v %5k C. II 6. a,Xr\Ss7 ctArjS^ C. 

29. v\ a.7!-o<pa,<rig om pr C. 

18. xa.\] * C. II 19. -n— «w/yx»!? rc A supra lituram. II tw xsi^vwv omB. II 20. tu C. II 21. tZ h\ ABC. Jl 26.h—29.y 
rc A supra lituram. II 27. rrepov Iv ixiout BC. II 29. xtSv om BC. 



ANAATTIKftN IIPOTEPftN A. 25 

2 '. 'Et« U 7ru<ru 7rpoTa<rig scrtv v\ t« v7rdpx*tv y\ t» e£ 7ram *] Tm tw B evUxsrat, xa) to B tm tw A svUxoito 
dvdyxY\g virdpxstv y\ t» svUxs<r$at virapxstv, txtoov U a\ av sl ydp /XY\Uvi, icf ctv to A &Uv) to) B* UUtxTat ydp 
/xev KctTcupciTixcu al U dirocpaTtKai Ka$' eKa<rY,v 7rpo<rpY\<rtv, tovto irpoTspov. ev U ToTg a7ro<paTtKO?g &x oo<ravToog, dkk' 
Traktv cfe toov Kara<paTtKoov Kat a7ro<paTtKoov cu fxev Ka$ok* "ocra, fxev evM%er$cu keyerat y\ too e£ dvdyxY\g fXY\ vTrdp-vstv 
ttl <fe sv fxspst cu U d&toptcrot, ty\v fxsv sv to) vTrapx^tv xa- 5 v\ tw fXY\ e£ dvdyxY\g virdpxstv, bfxoioog, cTcv s'i Ttg <paiv\ tov 
$6kx cyepYiTtxY]v dvdyxY, To7g cpotg dvTtcrpecpetv, otov el fxr,U- dv$poo7rcv evUxscr$ai fxv\ eTvat "tirirov rj to ksvxov fxr,U) tfxa- 
fxia Y\cfov/\ dya$ov, icY dya$ov iUv scrat y\<\ovy\' ty[V U xaTr,- tioo vrrapxetv. txtoov ydp to /xsv e£ dvdyxY\g &x VTrdpx^h 
yoptxY[V dvTtcrpscpstv fxsv dvayxatcv, & fXY\v xa$okx dkk' ev to U &x dvayxr, vTrapxstv, xa) bfxoioog dvTtcrpscpst y\ Trpc- 
fxepet, otov et rrara y\Uvy\ dy<x$ov , xcu dya$ov ti eTvcu y]U- Tartg' el y<xp evcfexsrat fXY,Uv) dv$poo7rop Tirirov, xa) ctv$poo- 
vy\V toov U sv fxepst T'/\v fxsv xara<paTtxY\v dvTtcrpscpstv dvayxr, 10 7rov syxupst fXY\Uvt Tttttoo' xcu sl to ksvxcv syxoops? fxv\Uv) 
xctTct fxspog (st y<xp y\$ovy\ Ttg dy<x$ov, xcu dya$ov ti s<rat 1/xaTtop, xcu to Ifxartov syx^psl f^Y\Uv) ksvxcp' sl ydp tivi 
y,Uy\), %y\v U cjepY{rtxY\v ix dvayxaLicV & yap el <xv$poo7rog dvayxr,, xcu to kevxcv tfxaTico tiv) ecrat e£ dvdyxY\g' t«to 

fXY\ VTTlXpXSt TlVt XjUOOO, XCU TJupOV &X V7rctpXSl TtVl dv$pOOTTOO. yctp UUlXTcU TTpOTSpOV. OfXoioog U XCU S7r) TY\g ev fXSpet «,7T0- 

IIpwTov fxev vv ecroo cr$pY\TtxY\ xol^oXk y\ A B 7rpoT<xo-tg. <pctTtxY\g. oo-ct U too oog S7r) 7rokv xcu too 7rs<pvxsvou KsysTcu 
el W fXYiUvt twBto A V7rctpxst, &U toov A &Uv) vTrcxpfcst 15 sv§exs<r$cu , xa,$' ov TpoTrov btopiXpfxsv to evUx^evov, &x 
tc B. et yap Ttvt, otov too Y, &k dkY^eg ecrcu to /xY\Sevt toov ofxotoog s^st sv Tcug <rspv\Ttxcug dvTtcrpo<pcug, dkh! y) /xev kcl- 
B to A vTrapxstV tq y<xp Y toov B t/ scrtv. el U ttclvt) to $oK)i <repY{rtxY[ TrpoTacrtg &x dvTtcrps<pst , v\ U ev /xepet dvTt- 
A too B, xcu to B Ttvt tu A v7Tapx^. sl ydp /xyUvi, &U <rps<pst. tovto U scrcu (pavspov, %t&v 7rsp) tov svUxofu^ev^ 
T.b A cvoevi too B V7ra,pzet' ct-AA' vTrexetTO ttcuvti vTrapxstv. Keyoofxsv. vvv U toJ&tov y\/x7v scroo wpog ToTg slpn/xsvotg tVy,- 
bfxotoog U xcu sl xarra, /xspog scrtv y\ 7rpoTa.<rtg. si yap to A 20 Xov, oti to svUxs<r$a,t /xy\Uv) y\ tiv) /ixy\ vTrapxstv xctTcicpctTi- 
Ttvt toov B, xcu to B tiv) tuv A dv+yxv\ vTrapxstv. ct yap xcv £%e/ to <rx^fxoo' to yap svUxerat too scrtv b/xoioog t«ct- 
fXY\Uvi, &U to A iUv) toov B {nrap^et. et U ys to A tivi tstcu, to U scrtv, oTg dv 7rpoTxa,TY,yopY\Tai , xarrdcpao-tv ds) 
toov B fXY\ vTrdpx^, &k dva,yxY\ xa.t to B Ttvt too A fXY\ tt o tsT xcu Travroog, otov to ecrtv wc dya,$6v v\ ecrtv « Kevxov y) 
vTrdpx^tv, oTov si to (xsv B s<rt XJupov, to U A ccv$poo7rog' d-jrXoog to ecrtv & t«to. Utx$"f.<reTat U xooi tSto cftd toov eTro- 
ctv$poo7rog /xev yap & xavt) ^ww, XJupov U ttclvti dv$pooiroo 25 fxivoov. xcoto, U rdg dvTtcrpocpdg bfxoioog sfyn ia,7g ctKkcug. 
virapxst. Atoopto-fxsvoov U txtoov Ksy ofxsv y\U\ <fta Tivoov xat xoVe4 

3 Tcv «,'jtci' U TpoTrcv s%st xat S7r) toov dvayxaioov Trpo- xcu xoi? yivsTcu Trag crvKkoyto-fxog' vcyspcv U Ksxtsov Trsp) 
txtsoov. y\ fxsv yap xcc$okx <rspY\Ttxv\ xaSokx dvrtcrpecpei, toov diroUt^eoog. Trpcrepcv U Trept o-vKkoyto-fx& kexTecv y\ 7rep) 
U xciTacpaTtxoov sxarspa xara fxspcg. sl fxev yap dvayxY\ aTroUt^soog bta to Ka$okv fxakkov etvai tov <rvkkoyio-fxcv 
to A tco B fXYjUvt vTrapx^tv, dvayxv\ xat to B tu A fxv\- 30 y\ /xsv yap aTrcUt^tg crvkkoyicrfxog Ttg', b crvkkoyicrfxog U 
Uvt virapx^tv' st yap Ttvt svSs^Tat, xat to A too B t^v« ev- & Trag aTrcUtfyg. 

Ux^tTo av. sl U sjr dvayxv\g to A 7rctvT< y\ Ttvt tco B vTrap- '"''Otciv »v %pot Tpstg 'iroog sxwct irpog dkkY\kxg oocre tov 

Xst, xat to B Ttvt T<p A dvayxvj vTrapx^-tv' si yap fXY\ scrx&TQV svokoostvatToo fxscroo xanov fxs<rov svokcp tw TrpooToo 
dvayxr,, icY dv to A Ttvt toov B e^ dvayxY,g vTrapx^t. to <Y y\ stvat v\ fxv\ sTvat, dvayxv\ toov axpoov sTvat <rvkkoyt<rfxsv 
sv fxspst crspYiTixov &x dvTtcrpecpst <fta ty\v a\)TY\v ahiav U y\v 35 reketov. xakoo U fxeo-cv fxsv o Kat avTO sv akkoo xat akko 
xa) TrpoTspov s<pafxsv. ev tktoo ecriv, o xat ty\ $e<ret yiveTat /xscrov " axpa U to avro 

'Ex< U toov evUx^l^voov , exe^yj Trokkaxw XeysTat ts sv akkcp cv xat ev cp akko ecrtv. el yap to A xaTa tto-v- 
To svUxs<r$at (xat yap tq dvayxcuov xat to jxy\ dvayxalcv Tog t« B xat to B xaTa iravTcg t« T, dvayxv\ to A xaha 
xat to UvaTcv evUxscr$ai keyo/xev), ev fxev Totg xaTa<paTtxolg Travrog tov Y xaTYiycpsTo-$at' Trporspov yap etpv\Tai 7roog to 
bfxcioog efcet xaTa ty,v dvTicrpo<pY\v ev aTracrtv. el ydp to A 40 KctTO, TravTog ksyofxsv. bfxoioog U xat sl tc /xst A xaTa fxr,- 

12. * 7*p a] el 7*p pr C. II l avflpa/7rc? pr A. II 16. t£ corr B. II 18. tu B] t^v /3 A. II 19. ru\ tw corr A. II 
21. kii<i*i\ uTTctpxsiv] vTci^si C. II 23. t^v C. II 30. t£ B] twv /3 corr AC. II xcu om AC. II 31 et 32. t£v C et corr A. H 
33 et 34. w C. . 

1 et 2. tujv C. II A. p}\ om pr A, supra versum ponit B. II 8. U7rctpx£iv] pj xnrdfxsn C. II 14. iiri to 7roXu C. t 
30. Ti?] ti? l^-iy C. 

D 



26 ANAATTIKaNIIPOTEPftNA. 

frevog T» B, to c^e B jt&Tc* 7rotvTo? t» T, ofjl to A tfcWt tw tw fxetCcvi dxpoo kxQoKk yevvjcu v\ xaryycptxcv v\ crepY\Ttxcv, 
r virtxphet. el $e 70 fxev Trpoorov itouvri tw fxeroo virapx^ ro cfe Trpog rco eKarrovt crepvcrtKcv Kara. fxepog, wc ecrcu rvK- 
ro Se fxerov fxvjdevi roo eV%<trw vTroipx^, ix e<rcu rvKKoytr- Koyirfxog dfrtoptcps 7e x<xt ev fxepet KY\cp$e'v7og, olov et to fxev 
rxcg 7cov ctxooov' ic%v ydp dva,yxa,?cv rvfx(2<xtvet tw tauta A 7rctyTt tw B vTrxpx^, to cVe B Ttvt tw V fxv\, v\ et fxvi 
etvcu' x<x\ ya)p Trxvri kcu fxv,cfev\ eV<Je%eTctt to Trpoorov tw 5 7tavt) virapxet' -co y<xp <xv Ttvt [xv\ v7r<xpxy to yJrov, tkt-w 
eV%otw v-ndpxetv, oocre ure ro xa,r<x fxspcg kts tc ko,$cKx yi- x<xt irxv7t xxt xfrsvt dxokvfaosi to 7rpco7cv. v7rcKstr$oora,v 
ve7txi oLvciyx<xTov' fxvfievog Se cv7og dvayxa.M frta, tktwv ix ycip cl vpot XJ^cv-a,v$pco7rog-KevxcV elra, xai cov /xvi xarvf 
ecrat rvKKoytrfxog. opot rov 7to,vti v7rapx s tv XJjoov-av$pco7rog- ycpe?r<xi Kevxoov b <xv$pco7rcg, eiKv\ip$co xvxvcg xou X lC0V ' 
iTTTrog, 7X fxvjfrevt Xuov-av$pco7rcg-Kt$og. &$' %rtxv [xv t re ro ixw ro XJooov tk /txev TravTog x<xrv,yope?ra,t , tk cfe xfrevcg , cocrs 
rrpcorov 700 fxerco [xv\re rc fxerov roo eVp^cww fxvfievi vTra.pxn, 10 wt ecrai <rvKKoyt<r[Xcg. 7r<xKtv 70 fxev A fxv\&evi tw B vTrxp- 
&&' vroog ecrat <rvKKoyt<rfxcg. opot tk v7ra,pxetv e7rtc^fxv r %erw, to c% B 7tv\ tw T fxv\ vTrapx^oo' x&i 01 opot eccorav 
ypafxfxv\-lxrpixv\, t« fw\ v7ra,px^tv e7rtc7v l fxv\-yp<xfxfxy-fxc- a^vx r ->v-a,v$poo7rog-Kevxcv' etra, etKv\<p$corav , cov fX'/\ xa,rv\- 
v<xg. x&QoKx fxev &v cvtojv rcov %poov, cVyJKov ev tktw tw <rx Y r ycpehxt Kevxoov b <xvQpoo7rog, xvxvog xa.\ %<wv to ya.p a,^pv- 
fxa,7t 7ro7e ecrcLi xcu 7ro7e ix ecja,t <rvKKoytr;xog, xa,\ %7t ov- x ov T ^ i a£y ^^^to? xarrv i yopelrra,i, tk cfe idevog. ht exe< dcfto- 
rog 7e <rvKKoyt<rfX)f 7ovg opovg <xva,yxa,?ov e^eiv cog etTrofxev, 15 ptcrcv 70 7tvt t<£ F 70 B fxv\ v7r<xpx^iv, a.Kv l Ssvs7<xt $e, xa,i 
rxv & V7oog ex^rtv, %7t ecrcti <rvKKcyi<rfxcg. el [X"/\frev\ vTrxpx^ "<*' » [^A 7r<xv7t, %7t 7tv\ *x vTrtxpx^h 

Et cY b fxev xa.ScKx 7oov cpcov b $' ev fxepet Trpcg tcv hepcv, Kv\(p$ev7cov oe 70M7cov opoov coere fxv\Sevt vTrctpx^ « ytyeT** 
670,v juev 70 xaScKx 7e6y 7rpog 70 fxelfyv <xxpcv v\ xa,7Yiyoptxov v\ <rvKKoyt<rfJLcg (tkto yoip etpvjcu 7rpo7epov), <p<xvspov iv on 
crepv\7ixov, ro $e ev fxepet Trpcg to eKa,77cv xa,7v\yoptxov, a\v<xy^ 700 K7oog e^etv 7cvg cpovg xk ecrcu <rvKKoyi<ry.,cg' v\v ya-p <xv 
kv\ <rvKKoyi<rfXov etvcu 7sKetov, %7<xv Se Trpog ro eK<x7rov v\ 20 k<x\ e7r\ 7cvroov. bfxoicog $e c\etxSv\<re70.t k<x\ et to ko,$oK>< 
xa,t ctKKoog 7roog ex^o-tv oiopot, <xc\iva,70V. Keyoo £s [xe^X^cv 7s$stv\ crspv\7tKcv. xM y' s<xv cLfxcpoo 7<x $ia,cryfAa,7<x k<X70, fxe- 
fxev a,Kpov ev w to fxirov ecrtv, sKa,77ov t\e 70 vttc to ^teo-ov pcg v\ Kcn^yoptxoog v\ crep-/\7iKoog, v\ 70 fxev Ka,7v l yopiKcog 70 cW 
ov. v7r<xpx^ u 7*P T " V&* A Ttcvrri T(5 B, t? ^eB Xm tw I\ crep-/\7ixoog Keyvjcu, v\ tc fxev dhoptcrov 70 $e fooopio-fxevov, vi 
vxovv et scrt 7r<xv7og Ka,7Viyope?r$<xi to ev cipxy Kex$ev, <xva,yxv\ afxcpoo acftcptcra,, ix scrcu rvKKoytrfxog x^a.fxug. opot S'e xotvo\ 
ro A Ttvt 700 V vTrapx^v. x<xt et to fxsv A fxv,Ssvt tw B 25 7TctvTwv ^wov-Xe , j>cov-t7r7ro?', ^uov-Kevxov-KtSog. 
V7r<xpx^ to <Je B Ttyt tw T, a,va.yxv\ 70 A Ttvt 700 T fxv\ <&a.vspov «y ex twv elpv\fxevoov oog e<xv y rvKKoytrfxog ev 

V7r<xpx^v ooptcrcu y<xp xcu 70 xa,7<x fxv\<$evog 7rw? KeycfXev 7x700 700 rx y \ r Ka, ' Xi Ka,ra ' ^po?, 071 a,va,yxv\ 7ovg %povg %7oo$ 
oocre ecrcu rvKKoytrtxog 7eKetcg. b[xctoog £e xcu et ixfrtcpicrcv e%etv oog eiircfxev ocKKcog y<xp e%ovTwv x&afxoog ytvertxi. o^- 
e»1 to B r, xa,rviycptxov ov b y<xp a,vrcg ecrat rvKKoytr- Kov <$e xat %rt Travreg 01 ev txvru rvKKoytrfxoi reKetct etn' 
fxog dhoptcrx re xa,i ev [xspsi Kv,<p$evTcg. exv <$s Trpcg ro sKtxr- 30 7rctvTe? yap s7rt7sK^V7at fritx 7wv sjr dpx^i? Kv\<p$svrcov. xxt %rt 
tcv cot^ov to xa,$oK)< rs$v\ v\ xa,rv\yoptxov v\ crspv\rixov, vx scrat nrxvra, to, 7rpo@KvifxaTa, SstxvvTai cfta, tktk tou rxv^Tog' 
rvKKcytrfxcg, xrs Ka,ra<partKov xre d7ro<partx^ yts d^iopt- xat ya,p ro Travri xai ro fxvjcfsvi xa,\ ro rtv\ xa\ ro fxv\ rtvi 
crov v, xara, fxspog ovrog, oiov et ro fxev A Ttvt roo B vwa-p- vTrapx^v. xaiKu tfe ro roivrcv rx^lf^ci 7rpcorov. 
X^t v\ fxv, v7rcipx", to <5e B 7rctvTt tw T V7rtxpx^' %pot tk 'Grav cfe ro ocvro roo fxev Trtxvrt roo <Je fxv^evt v7rap-& 

V7ra,px£tv dyx$ov-e^tg-<ppovvirig, tk fxv, vTrapx^v dya,$ov-e^tg- 35 xy > v\ exarepco 7ra,vr\ v\ [xvfim, rc fxsv rx^fxa, rb TOt«Tcv 
dfxa,$i<x. 7ra,Kiv ei rc fxev B fxv { hev\ rcZ T, ro Se A rtv\ ru> B v\ kolKoo cfevrepov, fxsrov Se ev txvru Keyoo ro KaTv,yop^fxevov 
VTrapx^ v\ fXY\ vTrtxpxet v\ fxv\ Travrt V7ra.px^, &<¥ "ircog ecrtxt dfx<po?v, dxpa, cfe xa,& cov Keyerat tkto, [hs?Xjjv cfe a,xpov ro 
rvK}xyirfxcg. opoi KevKcv- nrTrog - KVKVog, KevKOV-nr7rog-KC- Trpog roo f>,eroo xstfxevov, eKxrrcv cfe ro Troppcorepco tk fxsrx. 
pc$\ ct txvTo\ Se xa,\ elro AB dStoptcrov. iS' %ravrc fxev rpog rtSerat Se ro fxercv ejroo [xsv tcvv axpcov, Trpcorov cfe rv\ $erei. 



19 



13. Sy om C. II 24. 7ta,noi\ ■xoinu? xclto, ttxjtci; C. II 29. tn om C. II 31. prius y om C. II 32. £rs aS'.] ra «3". editi. II 
;] t5 C et corr H. II 37. prius % om C. II 38. cpoij opoi ra /xh u-7r«p%£ty C. II «uxye?] xuKys?* rSf 5'£ pi>i v-Trdioyj^ C. II 39- aJSto- 

, £1>I C. 

2. ix, — Arj(pQ(vTog rc A supra lituram. II 4. py] fj-r, \nrcLpxzi C. II tl om C. II 7. ol om C. I! 10. V7rccpyjTu tu /3 C. II 
tcu — 'opv{\ Ztvs i-yjnui rJy Ipui C. II (nhXoytcrucs Y^a.y.m- r,i C. II 20. xeu ei] acly AB. II 21. 7 0111 C, corr habet A. II 
>; r,t r\ C. II 29. xai hi] hi k«,1 C. II 32. d anle jw.»;5-evt om AB. II 38. 'iXxTTov—y.icrv om pr B. 



33. { 

ptcpoy iir, C. 



ANAATTIK^NnPOTEPftNA. 27 

TsKsiog llsvZv yksctoli <rvKKoyL<rLtog iSctfxcog sv mwiw ^X^' ttolvt) too £ vTrcLpxsLV vttsksito Ss rm lly) vTrctpxstv. kol) sl 

fJLCLTt, S^VVOLTOg S* SCTCtt KCLl KOL$cK)i KCtl LLY\ KCL$oXti TUV OpOOV TO M TW fJLSV N TrttVTl VTTCtpXSL TUl Sl % fJLY\ TCOLVTL, SCTOLt 

ovtcov. kcl$6Xh llsv Zv cvtoov scrou cvXXoy i<r LLog , otclv to lls- <rvXXoyt<rfjLog ot. « 7roLVTt tw S to N" dTrcSsL^ig S~' v\ olvty\. 

<T0V TOO LLSV TTCtVTL TW Ss LLYjSsv) V7rcLpX\]-> dv TTpog 'oTrOTSpOOW SOLV Ss TV fJLSV & TXCLVTOg Ttt Ss N fULv] TTCLVTOg KCtTY\yopY\TCLl, 

*I to crepYvriKoV cLXXoog S~' bSctfAoog. KctTY\yopei<r$oo yctp to M 5 «*, ecrcti trvXXoyi<rfj.6g. cpot X^cZov-itrict-Kopct^, XJ?ov-Xsvkcv-k6- 

7» /LLSV N fJLY^SVog, 7» <$£ £ TXOLVTOg. S7TSL W dvTLCTpeCpSL TO pct^. &P "cTCLV Ttf fJLSV £7 [JLY\fov6g, TtS Ss N TLVOg. OpOL Ttt VTroLp- 
CTSpY\TLKOV, iSsVL TOO M VTrctp^SL TO N" TO $S yS M. TCCLVTL TW X SlV X,£>OV-&<r{cL-fJLOVcLg, Ttt fJLY\ VTtCLpXSLV TJjOCV-WLCL-STrL- 

& VTreKeLTO' cocrs to N kSsvi tco JEJ' tvto ycxp SeSetKTcLL Trpo- cty\lly\. 

Tspov. ttclXlv s\ to M too /ulsv N ircLvrt toZ Ss £J lly\Ssvl, v Otolv llsv kv cLVTtKstfAsvov y\ to Kct$oXtf too koltcl [ispog, 

«oe to S tw N xosvt vTrcLp^et. et yccp to M xoevt too JSJ , *os 10 stpv\TcLt ttot sctcli kcli ttot *k scrctt <rvXXoyio-Ltcg' otolv os 

TC % iSsVl TOO M" TO Ss ys M 7TCtJT} TOO N UJ^SV' TO Ct^Jl* bfJLOlO<rX^^VSg CO<rtV OLL 7rpOTOL<rStg, OIOV dfJLfpOTSpcLL <TepY\TLKCU 

& iSsvi tw N v7ra.p'£ef ysyevYfrctt yocp 7tclKiv to 7rpooTov v\ koltcl^cltlkcll, iScLLtoog ecrcu cvXXoyLo-Ltog. ecrooccLV ydp 
rrxyftcL. stts) Ss dvTicrpscpst to crspY\TtKov, iSs to N \tfoyi tu -irpooTov crepY\TiKcLi, kcli to kclQoKk KeL<r$oo Trpog to llsiXov 
E VTTcLp^st , coq ecrcLt b cLVTcg <rvKKcyL<rfxog. ecri £s o^slkvvvcli cLKpov, oTov to M t<2 llsv N lly\<$svl tw 8s £J tlvl /uly\ v7r<xp- 

TCLVTCL KCLl Stg TO CLo\)VcLTOV CLyoVTcLg. "oTt fJLSV Zv yLVSTOLl <TVK- 15 X eTC0 ' SV^SXSTCLL 0Y t KCLl TTCLVTL KCLL fJL7\0SVL TW S TO N VTTCLp- 

KoytrrjLLog \iTcog sxovtcov tcov %poov, (pcLvspcv, dKK' i TsKsiog' i X siV ' °P° l "™ P sv P* v7rcLpxstv {asKclv-xmv-XJjoov' t» <^g TrcLvrt 

ycLp LLOVOV SK TCOV SJr CLpX^ CLKKcL KCJLl SJr OLKKoOV STT LT sKsIt CLL TO VTTCLpXSLV «)C SCTl Kcl(Bs?V, Sl TO M TW J& TlVt fJLSV VTTCLpXSt 
CLVCLyKcLLOV. SCLV Ss TO M TTCLVTog T» N KOLt TeS % KCLTY\yopY\TCLl, TtVi 0% LLY\. St ycLp TTCLVTl TOO % TO N, TO Ss M fJLYi^Sv) TCO N, 

hk scrcLt <rvKKoyt<rfJLog. 'opoi t» vttclpxslv vo-lcL-XJ{iov-<lv6pco7rog, ro M v&svt tw S vTrcLpfcet' dKK' vttsksito tivi V7rctpxstv. 

T« fJLY\ VTTCLpXSLV ^TLCL-X^WOV - olpiOfJLCg' LLS<TCV V<TLCL. «<£"' OTCLV 20 KTOO fAeV «V XK eyXOOpS? Kcl(3s7v OpOVg, SK (^£T» OL^LOpLCpi BsLTO- 
fJLY\TS T« N JULYjTe TX S LLY\^SVOg KOLTY\yopY\TOLl TO M. Opot T« T£OV £7T£i yctp dKYj$eVSTCLt TO Tiv) fJLY\ VTrcLpXSlV TO M TOO 
VTTcLpXSLV ypcLfALLY r XJjOOV-OLV$p007rog, T» fJLY\ VTTCLpXSLV ypOLLLfATr E KCLl sl fAYjfrsVL VTTCLpXSt, LLY\$SVl b\ VTTCLpXOVTOg VK Y\V <TvK- 

XJoov-KtQog. (pcLvepov xv "otl clv yi <rvKKoyL<rfJLog kcl^oKh toov KoyLTLLog, (pcLvepov otl vfrevvv ecrctt. ttolKlv ecrco<rctv KctTY t yopt- 

opoov ovtcov, dvctyKYj Tovg cpovg exstv cog sv ctpx\\ slttollsv' koll, koli to KctSoKd kslcSoo oLLOLcog, olov to M too llsv N 

cLKKcog ydp sx ovTU3V *. yivsTctt to dvctyKctlov. 25 ttolvtl too Se S tivi vTrctpxsToo. evSexsTctt Sy\ to N too % kcu 

'Ectf Ss Trpog tov sTspov y\ kclQoKx to fxs<rov, otolv /jlsv ttclvti kcli fAY\Ssv) vTrctpxsLV. "opot t« llyjSsv) vTrctpxsLV Ksvkov- 

Ttplg TOV fASiXoO ysVY\TOLL KCtQcXti Y\ KOLTY\yoptK<2g Y\ CTepYft IKOOg, KVKVOg-Kt$Og' T« <^£ TTCLVTL YK eCTOLL Kct(2e7v SlOL TY\V CtVTYJV CLL- 

Trpbg Ss tov sKclttoo kcltcl fxspog kol) dvTiKsifJLSvoog too kclSoKis tlolv Y\V7rsp TrpoTspov, dKK' SK T» dS~LOpLcpt frstKTSOV. sl Ss TO 

(KsyOO Ss TO dvTLKSLfASVOOg, Sl fJLSV TO KClSoKk crepY\TLKOV, TO KCL$oX>i TTpog TO eKctTTOV OLKpOV eCTL, KCtl TO M TCO Ltevft jULY\- 
SV fAepeL KCtTCtfpCtTLKOV sl Ss KCLT^yopLKOV TO KCL$6XX, TO SV 30 Sev) TW Ss N Ttv) LLY\ VTTCtpXSt, SvSsXSTCLl TO N TW JE? KCtt 

fjLspei crepYjLKov), dvctyKY\ yivs<r$ctt <rvXXoyt<rLLov crspY\TtKov ttolvti koll lly\Ssvi vTrcLpxstv. opot T« VTrctpxstv Xsvkcv -XJyov- 

KCLTd (JLSpog. SL ydp TO M T(S jULSV N fJLYjS^Sv) TW Se S TlVl KOpct^, T« LLY\ VTTCtpXSLV XsVKCV-Xt^Og-^KOpCty^. sl Ss KOLTqyopt- 
VTTCtpXSL, dvOLyKYj TO N TLVl TOO & fJLY\ VTTCtpX^V. S7TSL yctp KCtl CLl 7CpOTCL<rSLg, 'opot T« fJLY\ VTTCLpX^V XSVKOV ' -XJoOV ' - X^V, 

dvTLcrpecpsL to crspY,TLKOV, kSsvl t<2 M vTrctp^sL to N" to Ss ysM t« v7rctpxsLV XsvKov-XJoov-KVKVog. (pcLvspov KV, OT&V bLLOLO<rX*T 

VirSKSLTO TLVL TW S VTTCtpX^V COCrS TO N TLVL TOO & «% VTTCtp- 35 fJLCVSg OOTLV Ctl TTpOTOLTSLg KOLl Y\ fJLSV KcL$oX)S Y\ S'' SV fJLSpSi, CTl 

%er yivsTcLL yctp <rvXXoyL<rfxcg Slcl t« 7rpooT\i-<rx^fxctTog. Trd- vSoLLtoog yLvsTcti <rvXXoyL<rLtog. dXX' vS' s\ tlvl skoltsoco vTrctp- 

XlV SL TOJ fASV N 7T*VTi TO M, TW <$£ S TtV{ LLY\ VTTCtpXSL, X Si *> i""* 1 VTTCtpXSt, Y\ TU> /LLSV TUI Ss fJLY\, Y\ LLf^STSpCO 7TAVTL, 

dvctyKY\ to N tlv) tw £J lly\ v7rapx^V sl yctp 7rctvTt vTrctp- y\ dSiopicroog. "opoL S\ KOtvot TroLVToov KsvKov-XJZ>ov-cLv$poo7ros, 

XSl, KCtTY\yopSiTOLl Ss Kct) TO M TTCtVTOg T« N, dvctyKY\ TO M KFJKOV-X^WOV-CL-^pVXOV. 

3. (ih ovtwv tSm opour l$<u C. H 4. rc 3k pr B. II »<Vi C. II iw C. II 8. Trpcref.oi/] Trpcrepav zl 7*p ts \i 6<W tw ^ ibe to £ 
firM r£ /j. ABC, sed B t\ «/xp corr. II 9- o\ g et 10. n] S] $ r et w r C. II 9. ife— 11. ttwti tQ rc supra lituram A. II 
10. £t — ±i tu M am B. II 11. t« apa] oig-s ts C. II 15. ivi&idrm C II 35. uTrcWcti BC. II tS S o'j%] tZi | *%AB. II v-nipxn 
C. II 37. ts] rtS C. II v-Kxpxvji AB. II 38. V7rcl.p£u C. 

4. 7T*VTS; TO pi TSU C. II 7. TSU 8k prj C. II l4. TO 8k A. II 17. KcL0UV Jp»? ti C. II 18. f4 VTTcipX^- 4 C. II vfcv\ C. II 19- ^p- 

yji C. IItiv^ pv\ vTrclpxM C. II 27. to C. II 33. xiwy— ^wey om pr C II 34. t?] t« ^ rc <C. II on Ifa C. II 37. \ fA v-KcLpx* omB. 

D2 



28 ANAA¥TI.K_-N nPOTEPflN A. 

Qctvepcv w sk roov sLpvifxsvoov 'ort ectv re-*Toog exwiv ot -scrcti. otolv. tf o jxsv v\ crspvcxtKog o _e KctrcttpctrtKog, edv fxev 

■ opot Txpog dKKv\Kovg cog eKsx$vi, yivsrctt crvKKoyitrfxog e\ o fxsiXoov ysvvfxctt crspv\TtKog ttrspog tfs KctrcttpctrtKog , _jre__ 

dvctyKY\g, ctv t v t crvKKoyio-fxog, dvctyKv\ rovg opovg vroog 'sx^v. o-vKKoyto-fxog ort rtvt *x vnapxei to ctKpov ru ctKpco, ectv 

tfviKov cfe kcl\ cti Txctvreg dreKeTg slcriv ol ev rvrco tco ct^/x.c.t. cY dvctrxctKtv, xk scrctt. 

-trvKKoyio-fxoi (Txctvrsg yctp £7XltsKwtoli TxpocrKctfx^ctvofXsvoov 5 'Ectv tf o fxev y Kct$oK\i izpog ro fxecrov o tf ev fxspst, 

rtvuv, c% v) kvvKctpxet rolg cpotg i^ dvctyKYjg v>, .riSevrctt cog KctTYtyopLKoov fxev ovtcov dfxtpoTv dvctyKv\ yiveo-$ctt o-vKKoyttr- 

v7XO$eo-etg, oTov orctv tfid tk dtfvvctTti frstKvvcofxev), kcu ot. x fxov, ctv 07Xorepocriv *]' kcl$oK^ rcov 'opcov. el yctp to fxev P 

yiverctt KctrcttpctrtKcg crvKKoytcrfxog otct t_tk t_ o-xVfxcLTog, -7xctvrt rw ^ to ^£.IIt.v. , dvctyKY, to II rtvt rw. P vTxctp- 

ctKKct Txctvreg crepvjTtKoi, koll ot kolSoKx Kctt ot KctTct fxepog. X £IV ' £7r£l Y*/ 3 dvrttrpetpet tc KctrcttpctriKov, v7Xctp%et to 2 

6.-r- \ w ~ ' ~ \ \ \ \ m ^\t/ «»__. '\ ' ___ v _f_r '<* ■ *■ A_ A V v t« \' * -c« - _,V •__ -e \ ~ 

Eotv oe rco ctvTcoTo fxev TtctvTt .to. oe fxv,oevt vTXctpx^, 10 t.v. rco II, cocr eTxet ro fxev P 7rctvTt rco 2j, to oe _§ Ttvt rco 

v\ ctfxtpoo TXctvTt v\ fxVj&evL, ro fxev o-^^aa to to.ktov kclKoo II, koll ~to P tivi tw H.vTxctp^et' oocre to II Ttvt tw P. txcl- 

rpirov, fxeo-ov.fr' ev-ctvTco Keyco kcl$' k ctfxtpco rct KoLTYiyopx- Xiv el to fxev. P w) tw._$ to fre IL 7tolvti vTxctpx^-, dvctyKYj 

fxevct, ctKpoL &e tol KctTviyopovfxevcL, fxeiCov cf ctKpov to Troppco- to II Ttvt tco P vTxctpx^V o yctp ctvTog TpoTrog T>J? CtTTofret- 

-Tepov tk fxecrM, eKctTTov Se to eyyvrepov. TL&eTctL cfe To.fxecrov ^eoog. ecrt <P ctTxofreL^ctt.Kctt frtct t« ci&vvctTX Kctt ty{ eK$ecret, 

-e£oo fxev toov ctKpcov, 'eo-x&Tov fre Ty Secret. TeKetog fxev w « yi-15 ■Kct$ct7rep £7x1 tcov ixpo-xepcov. ectv cf fxev f, KctTY,yopiKog frs 

.vstoli crvKKoytcrfxog *(? ev txtco tw o-^/^ctTi, cfvvctTog cf 'ecrctt crepviTtKog, kclSoKk cfe KctTY\yoptKog, "oTctv fxev eKctTTcov yj 

-Kcti KctdoKv Kctt fxvi KctQoKx Tcov^opcov ovtcov 7xpcg to fxecrov. Kct- KctTYi.yaptKcg, ecrou crvKKoytcrfxog. et yctp ro P 7rotvT< tw _$, 

QoKt fXeV «V OVTWV^ OT.<XV KCtt TO II KOLt TO P TXOLVTt TW_; VTXCKpX^-, TO cfe II TtVi fXY\ V7X0LpX s h CtVCtyKYj TO II TlVl TCp P fXYl VTXCtp- 

oTt Ttvt ra P to II vTXctp^et s^ ctvctyKYjg' e7xe\ yctp ctvTtcrpecpet X £lv - £l y*P nctvTi, . koli to P. 7zuvt( .tw ]_$ Kctt to II TXctrxt 

•TO -KCtTYiyoptKOV, .VTXCtp^ei TC _$ TtVt TW P, COCr' £7X£t TW fA£V _^ 20 T £) _§ VTXCtp^Sl' 0,KK\ «% U7T»)/J%eV. frsiKVVTCtl tfe KCtl CLVeV TY\g 
TTCtVTL TO II, TW Se P Tivl TO _^, CLVCtyKYj TO II TlVl TCO P V'7XCtp- CL7X.CtyC0yYig , £ctV Kv\lp&^ Tl TCOV _£ W TO II ^U.»] VTXcipX^' 

X £iV ' yiverctL yctp crvKKoyLcrfxog b^Lct t% TxpooT^ o-X"AfxctTog. ecrt crctv tf o fxstX^cov v\ KctTv\yoptKog, «>c sctcli crvKKoyto-fxog, oTov 
cfe Kctt frtct t5 cicfjvctTov Kctt tw eK$ecr&ctt Txotelv Tv t v ctTxofreL^LV' el to jO.gv.II TrctvTi tw _$, to __ P tu'< tw _$ ^a>j .Tra^.i. o^joj 

_i ycip CtfXCpCO TXCtVTl TU _$ VTXCtpXet, OLV KYI(p$Yl Tt T00V%ol0V TK TTCtVTZ V7XCtpX £ W- SfX^JXOV- CtVQpCCTXOg-TJtJOV. T« b\ fXY^SVl 
.TO N, T«TW )tai TC.Tl KOLL TO P -. 7XCtp£eL, -OOCTS TLVt TW P. TO II -_ _>C l^*Z Kct[3e?V tpOVg, U TtVt fXeV V7XCtpX £ l TW _^ TO P, TiVi _£ 

-U7rct^ei. >tcti dv -to /^ev P 7tuvtz tco __), to _g II fxv t frevi fxv\' ei .yctp TxctVTt ro IT tw _£ vTxctpx^i, "^o _"g P t<v; tw _?, 
■vTxdpXYl-, ecrctt crvKKoytcrfxog oti to U tiv\ tw P k^ vTXctp^ kcu to IT tzv) tw P vTxctp^et' vTxeKeno frs fxvifrevi V7xctpxetv. 
\et e^ dvctyKY,g' o yctp ctvrog TpoTxog TY]g dTxofret^ecog dvTt- dKK' u>T7xep £v To7g TxpoTepov K.Y\7XTeoV dfrtopLcr^ yctp ovTog t« 
crpctcpsirvig t*j? P ■_§. TxpoTctcrecog. frstx^i^ <-"' ctv kcu frtct t« tiv\ fxv, vrxctpx^v Kctt to fxv\frsvt vTxctpxov dKv\$sg sltxsIv Ttvt fxv\ 
d&vvctTX, KctSct7X.sp £txl tcov Txporepov. £ctv cfe to fxev P fXYjfrevt 30 v7xctpx^V fxvfievi cfe v7xctpxovTog &k y\V crvKKoyicrfxog. tpctvepov 
■ro tfe II TxctVTt VTxctpxy tw _$, „>c ecrcti crvKKoyto-fxog, opot Zv otl vk ecrctL crvKKoyLO-/xog. £ctv tf o trepvfXLKog y\ kolSoKx toov 

■T6 V7XCtpX^V TcOO-V- tTXTXOg- CtV$p0O7X0g, -TK fXY\ VTXCtpX^V T^OOOV- opCOV, QTCLV fXSV fXSL^OOV Y\ CjepYjTLKOg o _~_ eKctTToov KctTv,yopt- 

cf^Aixov - ctv$poo7xog. vtY otolv ctfxtpco KcLTct.fXYifrevog th _$ Ke- y.og, ecrcti vvKKoyto-fxog. et ycip to II fxv\tfevi tw_J, to _£ P 
yviTcu, ' wt strctL crvKKoyLQ-fxog. "opot tS v7x-o.px £lv XJjoov-tTXTxogr- tlvl v7xctpx si r <f> -^ 5 to IT Tiv) tw P *x vKctp^ei' txolKlv yctp 
ct^vxov, T6 fxv\ v7xctpx^v ctvSpcoTxog - ItTXTxog - d\pvx°v fxscrov^ scroLL to TrpcoTov trxrifxct Tv,g P _$ TxpoTctcrsoog dvTicrpcttpeicrY\g. 
cf^AJX°. v ' ty&vepov _v >ccti ev txtco tw tr^jaaTi 7tot ecrctL koli otolv .tfe o £Kclttcov y\ crepv\TtKog, _>c ecrcti crvKKoytcrfxog. opoi 
txot wecrctt trvKKoyLo-fxog kcl^cKx tcov opcov ovtcov. crctv fxev tk vTxctpx^v TJjoov- ctv$poo7xog- ctypLov, tk fxv\ vTXctpxziv Xooov- 
ydp djUtporspoL ol opot.coo-L .Kctrr [ yopLK.oi, sctcll crvKKoyLo-fxcg s7XLcr^fXY,-ciypLov' fxecrov dfxtpoTv ro ctypiov.. «_"' otccv dfxtpo- 

%TL TtVt V7X0LpX£l T° CLKpOV TOO CtKOCO, /oTOLV _£ trepY\TLKoi, OVK TSpOL trspY{XtKo\ TS$OOCTLV, Yj fr' fXSV KCt$o7^ & £v /XSpSL. OpOl 

3. I«v C. II 4. cti y.cCi C. II 9- AJ-f «fcrams C. I! 11. toj.to B. II 17. /~-v ovtwv t_?v tpuv C. II 23. t£] t. coit C. II 24. e*v 
C II 25 et 26. u*-<_p*3« 4- 'I -6. W» C. II 28. tcotts? _$ta t5; ? C II 30. twv] tS C. II pjeVt tc <r to C. II 38. r"_3_?_-f C. 

2. -ZTEpo;. AC. II 8. 0- .i_tp^B, TO C II 11. W(T£ K^l TO C et COrf i?. Jl 15. -7ri] «*1 Wl C. II 17. -" -7TC4p%-l, to C. II 

20. V7rrjp%s -kimtI. o~siy.v\iTcu C. II 22. xa/r^optJtoV, o ^' I>.*ttwv fispMo? g-spyTixo;, _)c ycAB. II 28. v.optg-n A. II 30. ntipxom pr C. II 
ouh ?v ffvXKo^KTy.U om :C. li 31. -v om ..'_?. II 32. e 6 X . lAi/T7„y . it*T^opix_S om -4. II 38. j~.cr-y Iv ciu(po7v AB. II 39. -f-' 
T. jit^ v-xo.p%tvi ctxv C el rc A. 



ANAATTIKS2N IIPOTEPP-N A. • 29 

2wv o ekctTTOov vj xctSokts: 7rpog to fxesrov , Xjuov - e-ir icrv\fxv\- -; - T>crt <$e >tct{ dvctyaye?v TravTctg Tovg <rvkkQyt<rfxovg e\g 

ayptov, ^wo.v-.ctvSp'j07ro§-ctypiov.': oTav.S' o fxetCuiv, th. ytt£V Tovg ev .tu npooToo .■o-x/ipctTt KOtSokx . <rvKKoyt7fxovg. ot fxh 

■fxv} V7xdpx £ iv xopctlfc- xtuv-/\ev>tov* . t« .£' vTra.pp^etv . «>t £cr* yctjO £i> tw b^evrepoo cpctvepov otl tV eKeivuv TekeiivTcti, 7rkv t v 

ka@e?v, el to P hv) fxh V7rapx £ i tu %, tivi Se fxv\ virapx^- *% ofxoiug 7rctvTeg, dkk ot fxh KaQokov t» crepv\TLKM dvrt- 

€L ydp to. II TX&VTt too P, to Se P Ttvt tw 2, **•*. T.oJlTtvt jf$ 5 xrpacpevTog, tuv <f iv |tt£p£j eK&Tepog Std fy\g elg TO dSvVCt- 

2 ' vTreKeLTo Se fxv^evi. dkk Ik t« dSiopicr>s freiKTeov. iS)' dv tov d7tctyuyv\g. ot S? ev tu irpuTU, ot Karrd /xepog, e7rtTekw- 

■ eKctTepog vm tu fxeru virctpx{i "n^r) uxa^rj,. v\ o fxev vTrap- T.at fxev kcoi cV ctvTuv, ecrt Se ko.) frtci t« bevTep* <rxVf<ta,Tog 

X*l o $e /W-^ ^7r*/3%*?» 1 o /tey Tm d.-^e /tu} 7rctrn, v\ dSiopicrug, oeiKVvvat elg dSvvaTov . dTxdyovTag, oTov el to A xctvTi tw B, 

\sk ecrat crvkkoytrfxog icfctfxug. opot Se. koivo) txcxvtuv TJuoy- to Se B Ttvt twT, oti to A tiv\ tw F. el ydp fxviS^evi, tw 

<xv$pu7rog-kevKov, ^uov-d-^vxfiv-kevKoVi 10 $e B 7ra,VTt, .iSev) tw T to B vTxap^et' rho. ydp v t<rfxev o^ta) 

^ctvepov h Kct) ev tktw tw. cr^ttctTf ttot ecrct< >cct) 7roT t» frevTepov cr^ctctTo?. pfxoiug Se Kctt 1%) tx. .crepv\TiKM ecrctt 

xk ecrctt trvkkoytTfxog , ko,\ ot.i- sx ovTUV 7e T0 ^ v °'P rj0V °°* % cLTto&etfcig. et yctp to A fx^Sevt t£> B, to $e B tlv) tu> T 

iKex^ ytveTctt <rv>^Koyt<rfJtog- e£ . a\vd,yKV\g, c%v t *j <rvKKoyto~- inrapxeL, to A tjw tw T .»% w^sf elyctpTxctyTL, too o\ 

fjtog, ctvctyKV\Tovg opovg vToog ex siV ' <pctvepov.Se kou oti tto.v- B fxviSevt V7ta,pxet, iSevi tw T to B uTra^er tkto. <^' «p 1 to 

T£? aTeKetg etrrtv ot ev tktw tu o-x^iy^Tt <rvKKoyt<rfA,oi {jxctv- 15 f/,eo~ov o-xvfLa,. oocr' e7xei ot fxev ev tw fjteo-oo <rxrifAa,Ti <rvK- ■ ' 

T£? ya)p TeKetwTa,t 7xpo<rKctfxficivo[Aevoov tivoov) Ka,t oTt <rvKKo- Koyto-fxot TxoovTeg dvctysvTat eU Tovg ev tu> TxpooToo KctSoKov 

ytQ-aoSctt to Kct$oK>s. Sta, txtqv tk <t%>] / «.c(,to? w ecrctt, \sTe-cre- <rj'KKQyto-fji.ovg, ot Se KctTct ju,epog ev too -rpooTco etg Tovg ev 

fYfXiKQV «T£ KctTctipctTLKQV. . ■ tw fxe<roo , cpavepov oTL KctL ot KctTO, fxepog dvctx^^Q^^ £l ? 

7 AvjKov Se KctLOTt ev c%7xcto-i To?g tr^^ctcriv, oTctv fJL.v) yi- Tovg ev tw TxpooTOo <rxyif^ctTtKa,$oKov Q-vK.Koyio-fA.pvg. ot o 

vviTal <rvKKoyto-f/,og, KctTviyoptKwv. juth vt crepviTiKoov cLf*<poTe- 20 ey tco Tptrco ko,$oK\s /uev ovtoov' toov opoov ev$vg eTXtTeKtvTctt 

poov ovtoov toov opoov xSev oKoog yiveTctt dvctyKcitbv, KctTviyopLKX .01' eKetvoov toov <rvKKoyL<rfA.oov, orctv <Y ev fxepet Kvi<pSoo<ri, b^LO, 

Se Kctt crepviTiKV, KctSoKv KvjcpSe^VTog tk qepv\Ttw. det yiveTctt toov ev fxepet <rvKKoyi<rfxoov toov ev too -xpooToo <rxr\fxa,Tt' xtoi 

<rvKKoyto-fxog rs eKctTTovog ttKpx nrpog ,to fxeTCpv, oTov el to -fre dyv l xSv\<ra,v etg hoeivovg, oocre ko.) ot ev too Tpiroo <rxvy<a,TL, 

fxh.A. 7to,vt) toB »] Ttvi, TO.Se B fxvi^ev) too T' dvTicrpe<po- ot KctTct fxepog. (pctvepov w oti -rctvTeg dvctx^WOVTcti etg Tovg 

fxevoov ydp tuv 7TpoTao-eoov dvdyKV\ to T Ttvt tw A fxv\- vTrap- 25 & fty TrpooToo <rx^,yxTt Ka,(joK\s <rvKKoyt<rfxovg. 

Xetv. Qjxoioog. Se Kd-r) toov hepocv cr^yi^actTwv* cte< yctp ytveTctt , Ot fxev \sv toov <rvKKoyi<rfxuv vTxapxetv v\ fxvj v7xa,px^ 

$td Tv t g dvric-po<pY\g <rvKKoytcrfxdg. Sv\Kov Se ko.) oti .to dSto- oetKWVTeg etpv\Ta.t Troog ex*°~ 1 ' Ka ' v-^ eavrovg ot Ik t» ctuT» 

pLcjov dvTL t« >tctT"/iyo^i>t« t» ev fxepet TibefxevQV rov ctvTov crp^vj^actTOc; >tct* Trpog dKKv\Kovg ot e.K toov erepoov. 

7Totv\<ret crvKKoyirfxov ev a,7rct<rt To?g cr^/x-ctcriv. . 'E7rei <¥ hepov ecrty vTTctpxetv Te ko.) e^ dvctyKV\g v7ra.p-Q 

Qavepov Se ko.) oTt.TrdvTeg ot d^eKelg <rvKKoyt<rfXQ) Te- 30 X £IV Kcl1 hSexeo-$cti vTrdpx^ (ttoKKo, yctp v7ra,px £ i ft/v» « 

KeirsvTcti Std Tt.TrpooTts o-XKfx-ctTog. v\ ydp SetKTtKOog v\ frtd t« fxevrot ej^ dva.yKv\g' tol cf «t e^ dyctyKv,g \s$' V7ra,px £ i, oKoog, 

ct<5bvctT« TrepctivovTcti TravTeg' dfxxpoTepoog Se yiveTctt to TrpooToy eyc^ex^cti &' V7xapxetv), Sv]Kov %jt ko.) <rvKKoyio-fxog eKctcrv 

cr^vj|ttct, SetKTiKoog fxev TeKeftSfxeyoov, oti <ftd t^? dvTicrpo<pv]g tqvtoov eTepog e<ra,i, kcu \sx ofxoioog ex onu)V ?£>v opoov, dKk 

eTTepctivovTO 7rcti/T£c;, v\ S' dvTLcrpo<pv\ tq Txpoorov eixoiet crx^f^ct, -0 ftw e]r dvayKaioov, S~'. e^ vTxctpxovToov, <¥ e^ eY<Jep£0- 

t^ict Sl t>s ct<5uvctTK c^efttvu^uevwv, vti TeS.evTog t» -^e-jcfovg 6 <rvk- 35 ftevoov. 

koyt<rfxog yiveTott Stct .t« Txpoort cr^/A.ctTo?, oTov ev tw TeXeu- 'E7ri fxh »v toov dva.yKO.ioov . cr^et^oy ofxoioog e%ei >ccti 

Tctiw <rx^f^ctTt, el to A >tctz to B 7rctVT< twT vTxapxeL, "oti tq eTxt toov vTXctpxovToov uxrctvToog yctp TiQefxevoov Toovopcov ev 

A Tm tw B u7rctp^£r el yttp fj^Sevt, to Se B 7rctm tw T, te Tw^Trct^fiv >cct) too e^ dva.yKv\g V7rctpx £iv V fM V7ra,p- 

iSevi too r to A' ■ dk>l v\v TTctVTi. o/xoioog Se Kct) e7x) toov ctkkoov. x £iv ^T^ T£ Kcli VKecrctt <rvkkoyt<rfxog, 7rkv\v ^ioto-et toJ 

1. i>M<-<rwv C. \\ 2. Xyptov, t« U7rap%£(v I^ujiov C. II jjlsi^uv yt xu,Qe\v, t? C. II 6. <r VTrtLpfcsi.' vTrixeiTO C. II ioptgv A. II lcLv S. II 
7. r c — H-yi v-7tip%v\ om J3C. II 13. Uv C. II 16. to ko.QcXv avXXo^iaocaSxt C. II 17. Ui> C. II ih% A. \\ 21. "cnwv \ih pipv? tuv 
rc A, ovtujv *<Lt kir\ fiip^ tvv C. II 26. aoci ciri C. I| 2f. ht k<a\ C. II" 29. Trsisi' C. II 30. ctl xoti C. II 35. ^evSovs B. II 36. h 
tm—tco /3 rc supra lituram A. , 

9. 7 v-Ko.p^u. ei C. II 20. TpiTu <jV>.}.oyifA.o\ KxSsAa C. 11*22. ayjr^yt xvcL^ovtm eU tvs xcx,Qc?.v. vtol C. II 24. oi om B. W 
27. eipy\na.i BC. II 28. aXAo-jf AB. - ; 



30 ANAATTIKHN nPOTEPfiN A. 

irpotrxeTtrScu roTg opotg ro e£ dvctyxr,g V7raipx eiv r\ fxr\ virap- vizr\px^ %£ dva,yxr\g. bftoiug be xctt et <repr,rivlg eir, b trvk- 
%e\v. ro re ydp <repr\rtKov ucrctvrug dvrttrpicpet, Kctt ro ev kcyurfxog' r\ yccp ttvrr, ecrctt dTroSei^ig. el cfe ro Kctrd fxi- 
%ku eTvctt kcu ro Kctrd iravrog bfxoiug d7rotfu<rofxev. ev fxev pog ecrtv dvctyKouov, ovx e<rcu ro trvfX7repct<rfxct dvctyKcuov' 
ttv ro?s cLkkotg rov ctvrov rpoircv tfetx$r<rerat frta, rr\g dvrt- ovcfev yap dthvarov <rvfX7rixrei, KaSanrep ovcf ev roTg KttSc- 
~<rpotpr\g ro <rvfj,7ripa<rfxa dvayKaTov, u<rrrep eirt t» yTAp%«v 5 kov <rvkkoyL<rfxoTg. bfxoLug cfe xcLtti ruv <repr\rLKuv. opot kU 
h cfe ru fxi<ru <rxyfJt>a,rt, "orav r\ ro KaSokov Kara<partKov vr\<rtg-XJ*>ov-kevKcv. 

To tf ev fxipet creprfrtKcv, kou Trakiv iv ru rpiru, "orav ro 'Exi cfe tk frsvrspov trx^ftarog, el fxev r\ crepr\rtKr] 7rpo-10 

ftev Kadokov xa,rr [ yoptxov ro tf ev fxepei trsprfrtxov, &x bfxotug rarig etrtv dvayxata, xai ro <rvfX7repa<rfxa etrat dvayxcuov, 
serat r\ a7rocfstfyg, dkk' dvayxr\ sxdsfxsvovg u rtvt exarepov el cf r\ xarr,yopixr\, ix dvayxaTov. e<ru yap irpurov r\ <ri- 
fxr\ v7rapx ei > x&ra, t»t» izotelv rov <rvkkoyL<rfxov e<rcu yap 10 pr\rtKr\ dvayxaia, xat ro A ru fxev~E fxr\$sv\ evfrexicrSu, ru 
dvctyxaiug sttl rovruv' el tfs xara t« sxrsSsvrog s<riv dvay- &s Y vTrapx^ru fxovov. eitet «v cLvrtcrpicpet ro <rspr,rLxov, &$s 
xaTog, kcu Ka,r sksivov rtvog' ro yap sxrsSev 'orrep sxsTvo n ro B ru A xfrevt -ev&exsrat' ro 8e A 7ra,vrt ru V ildu^; 
e<rtv. ytverau cfe ruv <rvKkoyt<rfiuv eKa,repo? ev ru olxsiu ucr' b&evt ru T ro B evMx^rat' ro ya,p Y vtto ro A e<rtv. 
<rx v if^ (X ' Tl - utra,vru<; he K<xt el 7rpog ru V reQy ro tjepryxtKoV el ya,p to 

g %vfA$a,tvei hi rrore xcu rr\g erepctg 7tpora,<reus a,va,y- 15 A /u,r\tfev\ ru V evcfixsrou, itfs ro Y ifrevL ru A eyxupeH* 

Kttia,? v<rr\g cLva,yKouov yLvetrSan rov <rvX\oyL<ry,ov, 7rkriV ovx ^ro tfe A 7ra,vri ru B v7ra,px^, ^' *&evi ruv B to Y evtfex^- 
OTztnipa,; ervx^, ciWa) rr\g rrpog ro fieT^ov axpov, olov el ro -rcu' ytvercu ydp ro Trpurov <rxr\fAot, TraKLV. ix apa, itfe ro B 
fjt>ev A ru B e^ cLvayxrs etXriTrra.i vTrctpxw % f^f\ vTrapxpv, ru Y ' dvrtcrpitpei ya,p cju-olu?. el $s r\ xa,rr,yopLxr\ Trpora,- 
To tfe B ru Y vircCpx^ ftovov ovrug.yap elkrifxfxivuv ruv vl$ 1<tlv dvctyKctta, , ^k ecrou ro <rjfX7ripa,<rfxa, dvctyKcuov. 
rrpord<reuv efc dva,yK-/\<; ro A ru Y vTrapfcei n &x vTrap^st. 20 v^a^pxiru ydp ro A 7ra,vr\ ru B i^ dvdyxr\g, ru tfe Y fxrr 
S7re\ ydp rravrt ru B e£ dvcoyxr,? V7ra,px^ »1 *X v7ra,pxzL frevt vTrapx^ru fxovov. dvrtcrpcupivrog Sv t» crepr\rix>s ro Trpu- 
ro A, ro tfe Y rt ruv B e<rt, tpavepcv ort xou ro Y e\ dva,y- rov ytvercu crx^tt' &i&eiKrcu tf ev ru irpuru "ort fxr, dva,y- 
x,v\g ecra,L Sdrepov rnrw. el $e ro y,ev A B ftr\ ecjLV dvccy- Ka,ta,g Wr,g rr,g irpog ro fxeTCov <repr,rtKr\g icfs ro <rvfX7repa,<rfxa, 
>ia?ov, to tfe B Y dva,yKcuov, »>c 'icrtu ro <rvfX7ripa,<rfxa, dvccy- ecrtu dvayKouov, uc- icf S7r\ rvruv ecrcu ejr dvdyKr\g. eri cf 
kcuov. et ydp e<rou, trvfx^o-erou ro A tjvj ru B vTrapx^ 25 el ro trvfXTripacrfxa, ecjtv dvayKcuov , <rvfj,fia,iveL ro Y rLv\ ru 
i? dvclyxr,g c\lo, rs tS Trpurov ko,l tfia, t» rptrv <rxYtf-ttrog. A fxr] v7ra,px £iV &<% dva,yxr\g. st ydp ro B ru Y fx^evi 
riro cfe -^evtfog' evcMx^rat ya,p ro&rov eTvcu ro B u eyx^ vTrapx^ % dva,yxr\g, btfe ro Y ru B b$ev\ vTrap^eL e£ 
peT ro A fj,r\$evL vTrapx^. vtl xcu ex ruv "opuv cpobvepov ari dva,yxr\g. ro $e ye B rtvi ru A dvayxr, vTrapx^-, emep kou 
yk ecrctt ro <rvfX7ripa,<rfxa, dvayxcuov, oTov el ro fxev A sir\ xi- to A 7ra,vrL ru B e^ dva,yxr,g v7rr,px £ v. u<re ro Y dvdyxr^ 
vr,<rLS, ro cfe B XJqov, ecf> u cfe ro Y dvdpurrog' i^uov fxev^ riv\ ru A fxr\ V7ra,px £ tv. dk\' idev xukvei ro A rofeirov Xr,cp- 
ya,p o a,vSpu7rog e^ dva,yxr\g ecri, xLveTrou cfe ro ^wov ix e^ 6r\va,i u 7ra,vr\ ro Y evfrixercu v7ra,px £ tv. ert xdv opovg ex- 
dva,yxr\g, ovtf o dvQpuTrog. bfxoiug cfs xou el <rspr,nxov eir, bifxevov e\r\ c^et^ciL ort ro <rvfX7ripa,<rfxa, ix e<rtv alvayKouov 
to A B* r\ ya,p a,vrr\ dTrotfet^Lg. e7r\ cfe ruv ev fxipei <rv\- d-irXug, dWa, rvruv ovruv dvayKouov. otov e<ru ro A £wov, 
Koyi<rfxuv, el fxev ro xadckov s<r\v dvayxcuov, xcu ro <rvfx- ro tfe B a,v$pu7rog, ro $e Y kevxov, xa,t a,t 7rpora,<retg bfxoiug 
iripa,<rfxa, e<rcu dvayxcuov, el $e ro xa,rd fxipog, ovx dvcty- 35 eikycp$u<ra,v evc^ixsrou ya,p ro TJuov fxr,$evL kevxu V7ra,pxeiv. 
xcuov, «Te <rspr\rLxr\g «ts xa,rr\yopLxr\g K<rr,g rr\g xa,6okov Trpo- «% vTrapfcet &r\ icf b a,v$pu7rog icfevt kevxu, dkk' ix e^ 
racreug. e<ru 3r\ Trpurov ro xa,$okov dvayxouov, xou ro fxev dvayxr,;' evhexsrtXL ydp a,v$puirov yeve<r$ou kevxov, v fxevroi 
A Trctvrt ru B vTrctpxiru e^ dvctyxr\g, ro cfe B w) r-u Y sug ctv Xjuov fxrftevi kevxu v7ra,pX'{l- &<7 e rovruv fxev ov- 
vTrapxiru fxovov dvayxr, c\r\ ro A t/v< ru Y virapx^v efc ruv dvayxcuov etrctt ro <rvfX7reptt<rfxct, drrkug tf &k dvcty- 
ctvctyKr,g' ro yctp Y viro ro B e<ri, ru cfe B 7rctvrt ro A40 kcuov. 

1. 7rpM«(a-&>M A et pr C. II 5. tc] otj to C. II 6. t^ ph xxQoXv C. II 7. eVa* r,t- «8 C. \\ 10. ts-jts G. II 11. ci xa\ xamjB. II 
16. tcV om C. II 21. 7*p to a, ttxvti C. II 22. to a, om C. II xa\ tc] x&\ t£i AC et pr B. II 24. ts ante av/j.7r. orn C. K 
25. £?-i AB. II 36. <repyTix%s—TY,s et 38. tw B — 1. avXXa^icrfjic? rc snpra lituram A. II 40. &' 7£ |S rc A II to a, om B. 

1. e£ a,yx^xf\? vTrrjfxw rc A. II 17. oipa. <Ys i<Ys C. II 23. tZl ^ei^o/i C. II 28. ytomB. II 31. twi B. II 33. a.ra,'p'.a,iu!r]>rB. II 35. Xevxlv J5. 



ANAATTIKflN nPOTEPHN A. 31 

'Ofxotoog <$"' e£ei xcu em tw ev fxepet rvkkoyto-fxoov. £e T Ttvt toov B, to A 7tvi toov B ix vTcap^et' dkk. yk e£ 

ctclv fxev ydp r, creprjtKr) xpoTO.<rtg KO,(jokcv t *; kcu dvasy- dva,yKY,g' $i$eiKTcu yap ev tw TrpooTco o-xripcnt oti Tr\g <re- 

Kafia,, kou to <rvfX7re / pa,o-fxa, ecrcu dvooyKouov' ctcov <Se r\ xa,- pY\Ttxr,g 7rpoTa.<reoog fxr, dva.yKO,ia.g ovo-r\g \sSe to <rvfX7repa,Tfxa. 

TYiyopiKvj Ka,Sokov, r) §e <repY\TtxY\ koltco fxepog, ix ecrcu to ecrcu dva,yxa.?ov. eTt kc\v frtd toov %poov etr, <pa,vepov. ecroo ydp 
<rvfX7cepa.o-fxa, dvouyKcuov. ecroo hr, TcpooTcv r\ crepr,T-iKr, ko,- $ tg fxev A dyccSov., to £~' ecfj ui B Xjuov, to Se T lir-Kog. to 

6oktt Te ko.) dva.yxa.ia,, kou to A tu> fxev B fxrjfrev) ev&x/- /xh iv dya,$ov &$£jQtTXk* fxr\Bev) "tinzco v-KcLpxetv , to $e T&ov 

rr$oo v-Kapxetv, too Se T tiv\ v7ra,px^oo. ettl W dvTicrpetyet dva,yKY\ 7vo.vt) vTrdpxetV dkk' vk dvdyKY, Xjuov ti fxr) eTvcCt 

to creprfctKov, iSe to B tw A b&ev) ivfrexotT a,v vTxa-pyjitv' dyctQov, enrep ev&xercu itcLv eTvcu dya,8ov. y\ el fxr) tkto 6\)- 

to oV ye A tiv) too T i)7:,a.py( j ei , uicr' i£ dva.yxr\g Ttvt toov T vcctcv, dkka, to eypr\yopeva,t *j K&Qevfretv opov ftereov' c%7ra.v 

^X VTTclpXei TO B. TT&XtV eCTOO r\ KCOTYiyoptKYj XO,6o?\.'ti T£ KCU 10 ya)p XJUOV freXTtXOV TtfTWV. 

dva,yxa,ia,, xct) KetoSoo Trpog tw B to KO,TYjyoptKOv. ei frr, to - Ei fxev w m opot kxSoKov 7rpog to fxecrov elo-{v, eipr,Tcu 
A irctn) tu B e£ a\va,yKr,g vTzcLpyjzi, tw Se T Ttv) txr]v7ta,p- xot^ scrau to <rvfX7repa,o-fxa, covcoyKcuov' el fr" 6 fxev kcvSoKou 
%ei, oti fxev k% V7ra,p$et to B Ttvt too T, cj)a,vepov, cl>X vk 6 o? ev fxepet, KO.TY,yoptKoov /xev ovtoov dfxcpoTepocv , oto,v to 
e^ a,va,yKY,g' ot ya.p ojvto) opot e<rovTa.t irpog tvjv o\7co^et^tv ko,$o\ov yevr\Ta,i a,va,yKO,?ov, ko,i to o-vfX7tepa.o-fxa, ecrcu clva,y- 
otTtep e-Kt toov kooSoXv <rvKkoyto-fxoov. ctXX.' b^' el to crepr\Tt- 15 kouov. oiTrofreifyg $' r) ocvtyj r\ kou TvpoTepoV oLvrtcrpecpei ya.p 
kov d.va,yKa,?ov ecrtv ev fxepet kriCpSe^v, xk ecrou to crvfXTrepa.o-fxa, ko,i to ev fxepet KO,Tr\yoptKov. el w a.va,yKr\ to B 7ra>ni tcZ 
dvayKcuov' frta, ya,p twv o,vtoov opoov r) a,7ro^et^tg. T vTra.pxetv, to <$e A u7ro to T ecrtv, a,va,yKY\ to B Ttvt tu 

11 'Ev St too TekevTtxtop o-x^^i KcoSok* /xev ovroov toov Kv7ra,px^- sl $e to B too A t^vj, kcu to AtwE tw 

opoov Trpog tc fxecrov Ka,t Ka,TY\yopiKoov cLfxcpoTepoov toov rrpo- V7ra,p-Xjnv a\va,yKct,?ov' civTicrpecpei ya,p. hfxotoog $e ko,i el to A 
Tareoov, ea)v oxoT£pov«v r, d,va,yKouov , kou to o-vfX7repa,o-fxa,2Q T etr, cLva,yKO,?ov KO.Sokx oV to ya,p B vtto to T ecrtv. el ot 
ecra.i dva,yKa,?ov. edv c% to fxev f, crepY,TtKov to cfe KO,Tr,yopt- to ev fxepet ecrtv dva,yKO,?ov, vk ecrctt to o-vfXTrepa.o-fxa, dvcty- 
kov, OTO.V fxev to crepr,TtKov dva,yKO,?ov v\, kcoi to o-vfXTrepa.r- koaov. ecroo ya,p to B T ev fxepet re kou dv&yKcuov, to <$e A 
fxa, ecrcit dvcoyKa,?ov, otocv $e to KO,Tr,yoptKov, *k ecrou dvcoy- 7T0,vti t<2 T VTroopx^oo, fXY, fxevTot e\ dvdyKY\g. dntcrpas' 
kcuov. ecroo<ra,v ya.p dfxcpoTepcu Ka,TY,yopiKa,t TrpooTov a,i Trpo- xpenog Ht t«BT to TrpooTov yiveTO,t <rxyfA<a,, koa y\ fxev ko,- 
Tciretg, ko.) to A kou to B 7ra,n) too T vTra.pxztw, dvooy-K 6okn 7rpoTcurtg &k dva.yKa.ia,, r\ ^' ev fxepet dva.yKa.ioo. otc 
kcuov $' ecroo to A T. erre) Zv to B 7Toi,vt1 tw T VTroopx^ $ KToog exotev eu 7rpoTa,o-etg, vk y,v to <rvfX7repa,o-fxa, dvcoy- 
Kcu to T tiv) tu B vTrdp^et ha, to dvTtcrpecpetv to KooQok* koaov, oocj &$' erri tktoov. eTt &e kcu ho to/v opoov <pa,vepov. 
too Kard fxepog, oocr' et 7ra,vTt tu T to A e^ dva.yxY,g v7ra,p- ecroo ya,p to /xev A eypr,yopo-tg, to <$e B gVttkv, e<p> Co o\ to T 
Xet ko.) to r tw B Ttvi, kou tu> B tivi dvo,yKO,?ov v7ra.px£w XJ<pov. to fxev «v B tivi too T dva,yKY\ v7ra,px^v, to m A toJ 
to A* to yap B u7ro to T ecrtv. ytveTcu «v to 7rpooTov o-^^tct. 30 r evSex^ou, ko,i to A too B xk dva,yKouoV v ya.p dva,yKYj 
ofxotoog $e Setx$Y\reTa.t kou el to B T ecrtv dva.yxa,?ov' dnt- bnrw Tt KO.Oev&etv y\ eypr\yopeva,i. hfxoioog <Je kou frta, twv 
crpetyet ya,p to T tw A Tivt, obe~ et 7Z0,vt) tw T to B i£ oovtoov opoov ^e^^treTcti ko,i el to A T etr\ ev fxepet Te kou 
dva.yxY\g v7ra,px^h K& 1 ™ A- tm vTrctp^et e^ dva,yKY\g. to,- dvctyKcuov. el 8' o fxev Ka,Tr\yopiKog 6 de creprfctxog toov cpoov, 
ktv ecroo to fxiv A T crepr\Ttxov, to o\ B T xa,Ta,<pa,Tixov, oTetv fxev r\ to KO.&okv <repY,Tixov Te kcu dvayxcuov, kcu to 
dva.yKa?ov <5e to crepYfrtKov. eTiet vv dvTtcrpecpet tivi too B to T, 35 <rvfX7repa,7fxa, ecrcu dva,yKO.?ov' el ya,p tq A too T fXY^evt ev- 
to freAv&evi tw T e^ dva,yKr,g, xfre twB tivi vTrap^ei e^ dvay- ^ex^cu, to o\ B Ttvi too T V7ra,px^ to A tiv\ too B dva,yxy\ 
KY\g to A" to ya.p B vtto to T ecrtv. el $e to xa.TY\yopixov dva,y- fxr, v7ra,px^ v - 'oto.v $e to KO,Ta,<pa,Ttxov dva,yKcuov Te&fi, n 
kouov, vx, ecrat to o-vfX7repa,o-fxa, dva.yKalov. ecroo ya.p tcBT Kahokov ov r\ ev fxepet, r\ to creprfctxov xo,to, fxepog, ix ecrcu 
Ka,TY\yopiKov ko.) dvayxouov, to $e A T crepYfrtxov kcu fxr, dvcty- to <rvfX7ripa.rfxa, dva,yKO,?ov. tco fxev yoop dkka, to,vto. a, kcu 
kouov. eTret «v dvTtcrpecpet to KO.Ta.cpa.Tixov, V7ra,p^et kcu to ^ e7r) toov TrpoTepov epifxev, opot o^ oto,v fxev f, to KO,$okov koj- 
T Tivt tu B ejr dva,yKr,g, oocf el to fxev A fXY\£ev) toov T to TY\yoptxov dvooyxouov, eypyyoprtg-X^wov-dvfipooTCog, fxecov cxv- 

2. t' om pr B. II 9. r& B. I! 10. u7r*p|«i BC. H 27. r&t tutMxw to C. H 32. 7 kA t^i * A et pr C. II 33. t3 B. II 

4l. TsDv] Tt5i B. 

11. oi om A. II 40. irpoHpw C. II 4l. jweVov $k oLvSpuTrof C. 



32 ANAATTIKfJN IXPOTEPftN A. 

$poo7rog, cTctv^' iv fxepet 70 xa7r s yopixov dvayxa?ov, iypr\yop- a7roBei^ig . etrt <? at tol&vtcii rrpoTaretg xaTr\yoptxai xai 
mg-Tjooov-KevxoV XJZov fxev ydp dvdyx.r\ rm Kevxoo vTrap- & crepriTixaf tq yap iv^exerSai too etvat bfxotoog TctTTETctf, 
%e\.v , eypryoprtg (? ivSexerat pribevi, xa\ ix dvayxr\ 7tvi xa$a7rep iKex$f\ nrpo7epov. 

Toooo fxr\ vircioxeiv iypr\yoprtv. oVctv 8e 70 crepr,Ttxov iv fxe- Atooptrfxevoov <$e 7ov70ov TraKtv Keyofxev 07 1 70 ev&e^e- 

pet ov dvayxa?ov r\, (fdr^v -.xtvovfxevov-Tooov , fxerov Tooov. . 5 r$at xara hvo Keyerat Tporrovg,. eva fxev 70 00? e7r) to 

12 . Qavspov w o7t t» fxev virolp-xetv ix eqt rvKKoytrfXog, ttoKv yiver$ai xcu oiaKeiTreiv 70 dvayxa?ov, otov 70 rroKvir 
eclv fxr) d/xcpcTepat oortv al nrpoTaretg iv -700 vvrapxetv, t« r$at avSpoonrov r\ 70 av^aver$at r\ (pStvetv, r\ "oKoog 70 7re(pv- 
$' dvayxad ecri xdt rr\g erepag fxovov dvayxatag t<rr\s. iv xog vTrapx^ (tkto yap K rvve^eg fxev e^et 70 avayxatov 
dfxcpoTepotg o(, xcu xararpaTtxoov x<xt crepYiTixoov .ov7oov toov bta, 70 fxr\ dei eTvou av$poo7rov, ovTog fx(v70t dv$poo7r<ti r\ i^ 
rrvKKoyir/xoov, dvayxr\ Tr t v erepav rrporartv bfxotav eTvat 700 10 dvayxr\g r\ oog ern 70 ttoKv icrtv), aKKov be 70 dcptcrov, xa,i 
rvfXTreparfxan. Keyoo $e to bfxotav, el fxev vTrapx^, vnrap- ov7oog xat fxr\ ovroog b\)varov, olov to fiafrtTetv Topov r\ 70 
Xprav , et &' dvayxa?ov, dvayxatav. oocre xou t«to o^yjKov, (BafrtT^ovTog yev(r$ai <retrfxov, % oKoog 70 a,7ro tvxvs y,vo- 
ot< vx ecrai to rvfxrreparfxa »t' a,va,yxa4ov %$' vTxapx^ etvat fxevov icfev yap fxaKKov. xrcog Trecpvxev r\ ivavTioog. dntcrpe- 
fxr) KricpSeirng dvayxatag r\ v7rap%prrig Trporareoog. (pet fxev w xat xara 7ag dv7ixetfxevag 7rpo7aretg exaxepov 

Tlept fxev kvt« dvayxaU, 7roog ytve^at xa\ 7tva $ta(po- 15 7oov ev^e^fxevoov, » fxr^v. tov amov ye 7po7rov, aKKa 70 /xev 

13pav e%et 7rpog.7o vTtapxov, eipr\7ai crp^g^ov Ixavoog ' 7rep\ Se Trecpvxog eTvat tw fxr\ e^ dvayxr\g v7rap%etv (%7oo yap evoe- 
t» evb^e^fxevov fxeTa TctuTot, Klyofxev Trore xa\ Trug xa\ frtd %erat fxr\ 7roKtirQat avdpooTrov), to $' doptcrov too [xr\oev fxaK- 
tIvoov ecrat crvKKoytrfxog. Keyoo (V evoe^erSat xa\ to evfrexo- Kov KToog r\ exeivoog. e.7rtqrifxr\ b\ xat crvKKoytrfXog aTrob^etxTt- . . 
fxevov,.'* fxr\ ovrog dvayxaoi, 7eS(v7og 8 vTrapxetv, ifrev ecrat xog toov fxev dopitroov ix ecrt foa 70 araxrov etvat to fxerov, 
bha tkt' a<5bvctTov to yap dvayxaTov bfxoovvfxoog ev$(x,er$at 20 twv Se rrecpvxoroov (<rt, xa\ crxeBov 01 Koyoi xat ai rxev^etg 
Keyofxev. c 07t $e tkt' ecri to ev&exo/xevov, cpavepov ex re toov ytvovTat rrep) toov %7oog evfrexo/xevooV exetvoov fr' eyxjjopelfxev 
d7ro(pdreoov xa\ twv xaracpdreoov toov dvTtxetfxevcov' to yap yevtruat crvKKoytrfxov, k fxr\v etoobi ye Tr\Te7r$ai. 
ix evMfteTat V7rapxetv xaA dbvvaTov V7rapx,eiv xal dvayxvj Tavra fxev «v b^toptrSvireTat fxaKKov ev ro7g eitofxevoig' 

fxv) v7rdpx sLV Wrot Tavrd ecrtv v\ dxoKxSe? dKK^Kotg, oocre vvv $e Keyo/xev Trore xa,t Ttg eqat <rvKKoytrfxog ex toov . evS~e- 
xdt ta dvTtxeifxeva TXTOtg, to evMxerat vrrdpxeiv xdt vx 25 %0/a/vwv rrpoTareoov. eTrei $e to ev^exerSat ro&e Tufre vrrdp- 
■db\ivaTov VTrapxetv xai ix dvdyxr\ fx-/\ vTrapxeiv, r\rot X SiV ° l X^ z<T lv exKafielv (r\ yap 00 vTrapxet. rofre r\ 00 ev- 
Tav7a e<rai r\ axoK^v^a dKKr\Kotg' ^ctTct ttavto^ yap r\ frexe^at av7o virapxeiv' 70 yap, xa$' ov 70 B, to A ev- 
xardcpartg r\ r\ aTro^parig eqtv. ecjat dpa to ev^exofxevov SexerSat t«twv rr\fxa(vei $a7epov, r\ xa$' « Keyerrat to B 
wc dvayxatov xai 70 fxr\ dvayxalov ev^exofxevov. rvfxfBaivei v\ xa$' ov ev&exe^ai Keyer$at' 70 &V, xa$' ov 70 B, to A 
<^g nrdrag Tct? xa7a 70 evMxer$at rrporareig dv7i<rp((peiv 30 evcfexer$ai r\ 7rav7t 700 B to A eyxupelv &$ev btaxpepet), 
aKKYiKatg. K(yoo <5e « Tct? xa7a(pa7txag 7aig a7ro(pa7ixa?g, (pavepov oti Six^o? cxv Keyotro to -A tu> B 7rctvTi evb^exerSat 
dKK' crat xa7a<pa7ixov exovri to rx~W^ xa7a 7Y(v dvriSenv, V7rapxetv. 7rpoo7ov «v eWoofxev, el xa$' ov to T to B ivfre- 
oTov 70 ivSexer$ai vTrapxeiv 7ui evMxerSai fXY\ vTrapx^t uat ^emz, >ccti xa$' ov 70 B to A, 7tg ecrat xdi 7ro?og rvKKo- 
to 7rav7t evSexerSat 700 ivSexerSat fXYi^evt xat fxr\ rrav7t, xat yir/xog' «tw <yct^3 cri rrporaretg dfX(po7epat Kafx@avov7ai 
70 7tvt 700 fxr\ 7tvt. 7ov ctuTov Se 7po7rov xdi £7r< 7oov aKKoov. 35 jtctTct to ivb^exerSai , oTctv <^e xct#' k to B vTrapxet to A 
£7T£{ yap 70 ivc\ex^f^evov xx ecriv dvayxa?ov, 70 <fe fxr\ dvay- ivoex^Tai, r\ fxev v7:apxovra r\ &' ev^exofxevri. &<~ ct7ro 
xct?bv iyxupe? fxri v7rapx^ v -> (pavepov ct/., el iv&zxerat to toov bfxoiorx^l^v dpxreov, xa$a7rep xat iv ro?g aKKoig. 
A TiS B virapx^-, ev<^£^£Tcti xat fxr\ v7rapxeiv' xat el r OTctv «v to x A 7rctVT< tw B £v^£^vjTct< >ccti to B 7rctVTil4 

7rctvTi ivb~(xe7at v7rapx^ v -> ^at xctvTi £v$£;££Tcu fxr\ vTrap- tw Y , <rvKKoytrfxog ecrat reKetog 07t 70 A xctvTi tw Y iv- 
Xeiv. bfxotoo? rfe xa7r\ 7<2v iv fxepet xa^acpareoov r\ yap av7r\k§ &(xe7at vTrapxeiv.^ t*70 &e (pavepov ix tS bptrfxx' 70 yap 

5. ixtcrov] diTrvv fA,(vo</ A. B ^Siov ante jjl.(<jov ponit in litura. II 17. X^w^ev JBC. II 25 et 26. xx\ to ix. C. II 27. v <f><x,o-i<; A, 
V $i<si; B. II 40. >jk om BC. II xai btl C. 

4. XeyjufiEv B. II 9. £i>'«" rcy a,v$puj7roy C. II 11. alterum tc om C. II 21. kxtivuis B. II 24. Xfyuusv -kcts xaX ttZs y.c/a B. B 
37. hfA.oiorsxrijj.cvMV BC. 



ANAAYTIKftN IIPOTEPfiN A. 33 

svMxs<r$cu irctVTi v7rctpx siV ^Toog eKeyofxev. ofxoioog M Kctt vre fxv\Mv) kts tiv) vts fxv\ Ttvt evMxcTctt to & vica,px* lv •> £ *~ 

sl to fxh A evMx^Tcti fxv\Mvt raB, to M B 7rctvTt too T, irep dvrtcrpecpovTiv cti kcctx to evMx£<r$cti TrpoTctTetg Kcti to 

CTt to A evMx^Tcti fXY\Mvi tu T' to yctp Kct$' k to B evM- B 7rKeioTtv evMxsTcu v\ to A vitctpx^- %Tt M kcu Ik toov 

X^tcu, to A fxv\ evMxsT$ctt, tkt' y\v to fxv\Mv diroKeiTreLV opoov (pctvepdv' ovroo ydp exovToov toov TrpoTctTeoov to npooTov 

TOOV V7TO TO B evMxOfXeVOOV. OTCtV M TO A TXCtVTl TU B h- 5 TW £(T^0tTW KCtl OvMv) hMx^TCtl KCt) TTCtVTt V7TctpX^ v dvcty- 

^xVTctt, to M B evMx^Tctt fxv\Mvi too T, cftct fxev toov el- kcuov. opot M ' koivo) ttcLvtoov t» fxh v-ndpx^ e\ dvdyKV\g 
Kv\fXfxevoov 7rporctTeoov &Mig ytverctt TvKKoytTfxcg, dvTtcrpct- TJxov -KevKcv- ctv$poo7rog , t« M fxv) evMx^T^ctt Tooov-KevKOV- 
tpeiTY\g M tv\<; B I* KctTct to evMxsT$cti yiveTctt b ctvTog IfXctTiov. cpctvepov ovv tovtov tov Tpdirov exdvToov toov opoov Ztl 
0T7rep TtpoTepov. eTtet yctp evMx^Tctt to B fxv\Mv) tu T VTrctp- ovMtg ytverctt TvKKoytTfxog. y\ ydp vk vTtcipxetv v) tk e£ 
X £lv > evdexztctt kcu irctVTt virctpxw tktq &' e'ipv\Tcti TrpoTe- 10 dvctyKY\g v\ tk evMx^$cu 7rc%g ecrt TvK?^oytTfxdg. t» fxh 
pov. oocj el to fxev B Trctvrt too T, to <¥ A TrctvTt tw B, ovv VTrctpx^ **< t« dvctyKctiX (pctvepov oTt ovk ecrtv' o fxh 
irctKiv o ctvTog ytvercu TvKKoyiTfxog. bfxoioog M kcu el Trpog yctp KctTctcpctTiKog dvctipelrcti too <~epv\TtKoo, o &e (-epviTtKog 
dbfxcpoTepctg Tctg TrpoTctTeig v) ctTrbcpctTtg Te$etv\ fxerct vk evM- tw KctTctcpctTtKoo. \et7reTctt bv) t? evMx^ctt etvctt' t»to 8* 
Xzvdctt. Xeyoo cf oTov et to A evMxsTctt fxv\Mv) toov B Kcti ctMvctTov' MMiktcu yctp qti ovToog ex^vToov toov %poov Kcti 
to B fxv\Mvt toov r ' cftct fxh yctp toov elkvjfifxevoov TrpoTctTeoov 15 TrctvTt too Itx^too to TrpooTOV dvctyKVj Kctt ovMv) evMx^Tcti 
voeig ytveTctt TvXKoytTfxog, dvTicrpecpofxevoov 8e ttcLxiv o ctv- v7rctpx £tv - %<?' °vk *'' e "I ^ov evMx^ctt TvKKoytTfxog' Tb 
Tog ec~ctt oog Kctt Trporepov. cpctvepov ovv oti t5?? ctirocpctTeoog yctp dvctyKcttov ovk v\v evMxof^evov. 

Tt$efxevv t g Trpog to eXctTTOV ctKpov v\ Trpog ctfxcpoTepctg Tctg Qctvepov cfe oTt KctSoK^ toov opoov ovtoov ev Tcttg evM- 

TTpoTctTetg v\ i ytveTctt TvWoyiTftog, v\ yiverctt fxev dw' x°l JU£vctl ' ; TrpoTctTeTtv det yiverctt TvKKoytTfxog ev too irpoo- 
« TeKetog' Ik yctp Ty\g dvri<-pocpY\g yivsTctt to dvctyKcttov. 20 too TXViftctTt, kcu KccTY\yoptKOOv kcu <-epv\TtK0OV ovtoov, 
'Ectv cf v\ fxev KctOoKov toov TrpoTctTeoov v\ M ev [xepet KY\cp$Yj, 7rKv\v KctTY\yopiKOuv fxev TeKetog, c-epvjTtKoov M dTeKv\g. fre? 
7T pog fxh to fxelX^ov aKpov Ketfxevv\g Tv]g Kct$oKov TvKKoytTfxog <% to evMxzv$ctt KctfxfictveLV fxv\ ev Tolg dvctyKcttoig, dK- 
ecjctt TeKetog. et ydp to A 7T*m twB evMx^ctt, to 8e B Kd Kctrd tov elpv\fxevov <fioptTfxov. evioTe <fe KctvSctvet to 

TiVi TU r, TO A TlVl TOO T ev^iX^Ctt. TOVTO <fe CpCtvepoV eK T« TO{0'JTOV. 

cptTfxH tk evMxeT$ctt. irctKtv et ro A evMx £ Tctt fxv\Mv) too B, 25 '~Ectv <¥ v) fxev virctpxzw v) <¥ evMxsT$ctt Kctfx(3ctvviTctil5 

To cfe B Tivt toovT evMx £ Tcti v7rctpx^ v -> dvctyKY\ to A evMxe- toov TrpoTctTeoov, orctv fxev v\ Trpog to fxe7Zpv ctKpov evMxeT$ctt 
T$cu Ttvi toov T fxv\ vTrctpxzw- d7roMi^ig <¥ v\ ctvTv\. edv <¥e cre- TY\fxctivv\, TeKeioi t eTovTctt TrctvTeg ot TvKKoytTfxot kcu t« 
pY\TiKY\ Kv\<p$v\ y) ev fxepet irpoTctTtg, v) <¥e Kct$oK"6 KctTct(pctTiKY\, ^evMx^att KctTct tov eipv\fxevov frioptTfXov, otolv <¥ v) Trpog to 
ty\ M $eTet ofxotoog ex^tv, otov ro fxh A 7rctvr) too B evM- eKctTTOv, dreKetg Te TrctvTeg, Kcti ot cjepvfrtKoi toov TvKXoyiT- 
Xztcu, to SeB tivi too T evMxtTctt fxvj inrctpx^tv, <$id fxh 30 fxoov ov th KctTct tov <ftoptTfxov evMxofxew, dKKct t« fxv\Mv) 
tuv elKv\fXfxevoov TrpoTctTeoov » ytveTcti (pctvepog TvKKoyiTfxog, v\ fxv\ TrctVTt e^ dvctyKV\g vTrctpxW «' Y*/ 5 fJ>v\Mvt v\ fxv\ 
dvTt<-pctcpeiTY[g M t^? ev fxepet kcu Te$evTog tov B tlv) tu T TrctVTt e^ dvctyKv\g, evMx^$ctt cpctfxev Kctt jtxv\Mvi Kctt fxv\ 
evMxe<r$cti vTrctpxw to ctvTo e<~ctt TVfXTrepctTfXct o Kcti Trpd- TrctvTi V7rctpx^ v - evMx^^o yctp to A TrctVTi too B, to <¥e 
Tepov, Kct$ct7rep ev To?g e^ dpx^- ectv <¥ v) Trpog to fxeTCov B 7rctVTi tw T KeiT$oo V7rctpx^ v - tiret »v u7ro to B ecrt to 
ctKpov ev fxepet Kv\(p$Yi, y) M irpog to eKctTTov k<x$oKov , ectv 35 T, tw^B 7r*vTi evMx^Tcti to A, cpctvepov ort kcu tco V 
t dfX(poTepcu KctTcKpctriKcti Te$ooTtv ectv Te <-epY\TLKcti ectv ts 7rctvTL evMx £ Tcu. yiveTctt cfv) TeKetog TvKKoyiTfxog. bfxoioog M 
/xv\ ofxoLOTXV\f-oveg ectv t dfXcporepctL d^iopicroi v\ Kctrd /xe- kcu t-epv\TiKv\g ovTv\g TY\g A B TrpoTctTeoog, T*i? ^B T Kctrct- 
pog, i&ct/xoog ecrcti TvKKoytTfxdg' ovMv yctp KOoKvei to B (pctTLKY\g, Kct) Tv\g fxh evMxs<r$ctt Tvig <$' V7rctpx^ v Kctfxfia,- 
vTrepreivetv tk A kcCi fxv) KctTv\yope?T$cti e7r' "tToov' u <¥ vxep- vi,TY\g, TeKeiog TvKKoyiTfxog oti to A evMx^Tcti fxv\Mvt tw 
retvet to B tou A, elKv\(p$oo tq T' tovtoo ydp VTe ttcvit) 40 T vTrctpxzw- 

9. o!i<r~io A, uj<j-ep xm C. II 11. k-e\ B. II 17. ^?] o<j-£p B . II 20. 7iv£T«.i] -epociverou corr A. II 25. post hhl%e<sBcu ABC 

a/3"y, sed B ab eadem manu delela suprascripto -a,ni. II 37. o^tscr%i«^ov6? AB. II 39- t5] to ABC. II vocis (Vaiv litteras w 
corr A. II wi corr B. 

18. <yY] 8k xsti BC. II 29. rs ora C. II 38. Xa,p@<mplni<; B et corr C. II 39. t(\uo<; fctti avXK. B. 

E 



34 ANAATTIKftNIIPOTEPaNA. 

v Otl /xsv %v tS v7tdpx £iv rit)efxivM 7tpog ro ekorrov oxpov tw T ev^xerQof ~^ev$ovg yop reSevrog xol ix dchivorv ro 
rekeioi yivovrcu <rvkkoyi<rfxot, (povepoV ori £' evovr(oog e%ov- <rvfx(3o7vov ecrtv do\>vorov. syx°°P £ ? ^ £ Ketl ^-* T * Ttpoorx 
to? ecrcvTOi <rvkkoyio-fXOL, <W tS dbvv&rov frsixrsov. ctfxo crxyifxorog 7tctY\<rot ro d&worov, 6evrog roo F ro B vitop- 
8' ecrot $Y,kov xdt ori drekelg' v\ ydp frelfyg Sx. hi roo:' el- x £lv - £i !&? T0 ^ 7tccvt} rw F vitopx^-, ro cfe A 7ra.vri roo 
kY\fXfx4voov 7tpord<reoov. Ttpoorov Se kexrecv ori el tS A "ovrog 5 B iy^e^eTot j , >cocv tw T 7ra,vri ev$ex oiTO T0 -^- *^' uttwcejto 
dvdyxv\ ro B eo-oti, xot tivvctrov ovrog tS A ^uvocTcy ecra.i fXY\ Ttovrt eyx^peTv. 

ro B i£ ctvcty>c*K' IV W yop ovroog exovrcov ro fxev e(p' w ro Ae? <Jg kofxfioveLV ro ttovtl VTtopxov fx-/\ KO.ro. X? ovov 

A frvvorov, ro <$"' et^)' w toB ct<JuvetToy. ei kv to yu-ev ^t/vot- bpicrovrog , ojov vuy *j ev Tw<^e tw x? 0V!j ?-> ccAA.' OTtkoog' fria, 
rov, %re frwoTov 4Tvol, yevoir ov, ro cf d&worov, ot ct^b- tojoutwv yot^o 7tporo<reoov xcu rovg <rvkkoyt<rfxovg TtoLovfxev, 
vorov, ix ccv yevoiro, cifxo tf el ro A <Juvcctov >ccc} to B 10 exe} >ccctcc ye ro vvv ka,fx$a.vofxevY l g TY\g 7tporo<reoog ovk ecroi 
dfrvvorov, evfrexoiT dv rc Ayev4<r6oi ovev tSB, el cfe yeve- <rvkkoyt<rfxog' ovcfev yop lcroog Kookvei Txore kol ttovtl kivx- 
<r$ot, xot eivot' ro yop yeyovog, ore yeyovev, ecriv. Se? 8e /xevoj dv6poo7rov vTvopx^-, oiov el fXYjfrev okko kivoito' ro oe 
kofxftoveiv fxvi fxovov ev ty\ yevecrei To dcfvvorov ko) bvvarcv, xivovfxevov ev&xercii 7rovril7r7rui' dkk' ov$poo7rov cvfrevi L7r7ru 
dkkd xo) ev ru dkY\6evecr6oL xo\ ev ru v7topx £iV i K& 1 ccro- Ev<5e*^£Tcti. eri ecrco ro fxev Txpmov Xcoov, to Se fxerov xlvov- 
X&g okkcog keyercu ro Svvorcv' ev cXtvoo-l ydp bfxoicog §&a* 15 fxevov, ro cY eV^ctTov ov6pco7xog. o\ fxev ovv TtporocreLg bfxoicog 
eTL to ovto? tk A to B etvoL , *x °°^ £V0 ^ riV0 $ ^VTog t« A to ejrovcrL, to ^£ <rvfX7repoo-fxo dvoyxoTov, ix ev^exofxevov e£ 
B ecrcti ^e? v7roko(3eTv « ydp ecriv icfev e^ dvdyxvjg evcg dvdyxYig ydp b viv$poo7rog X^ccov. (povepov xv on ro KoSokov 
nvog ovrog, dkka, o\>o?v ekox^oiv, oiov otocv cu Ttporoo-eLg kY\7treov O7tkoog, xol ov XP ov V ^opL^ovrog. 
tvrcog excocrLV cbg ekex^Yi xora, rov <rvkkoyi<rfxov. el ydp ro ILokLV ecrco crepYiTLKYi 7tpcro<TLg KoSokov y\ A B, >cccj 

r xctTct t« A, to <^£ A xctTcc tk Z, >ccc} to r >cccTcc tS Z 20 elkY,<p6oo ro fxev A fXYicfevi rco B vTtdpx^LV, ro Se B 7rctyT< 
e£ ctvcty>c>i?. >ccc} el o\jvotov cY sxarepcv, xol to <rvfX7tepo<rfxo ev$exe<r6oo vrtopx^v rco T. T6tcov «v re6evrcov dvdyxvi ro A 
o\)Votov. uxrrtep «v ei rig 6eLY\ ro fxev A rog TtporocreLg, ro Se ev$ex so ~6oL fXY t SevL ru> F vTtopx^v. fXY\ yop evSexe<r6co , to 
B to <rvfX7tepo<rfxo, crvfxfioivoL dv « fxovov dvoyxoicv t« A Se B rw F xeL<r6co vTtopxov, xo6o7tep Ttporepov. dvdyxv\ Sy\ 
ovrog xo) ro B eTvoi dvoyxoTov, dkko xol Svvori Svvorov. ro A tivl rco B vitopx^V yiveroL yop <rvkkoyL<r[xog hd 

TouT« ^£ SeLX^vTog, (povepov ctl '^evSovg v7tore6ev-25 t« rplrcv cr-^/x.ctTO'"' tSto Se dSworov. cocr' evSexoir a,v ro 
rog xo) fXY\ dchvorx xoi ro <rvfx(3o?vov Slo ty\v v7tc6e<TLV A fxycfevL rco F ' ^evSovg yop re6evrog dSworov ro <rvfx$o7- 
'ipevfrog ecroi xo) isx dSworov. oiov el ro A \pevSog fxev ecri vov. ovrog »v o <rvkkoyLO-/xog ovx ecri tS >ccctcc tov ^LopLcrfXov 
fXY\ fxevroL dSworoy, ovrcg Ss t» A to B ecrl, xol ro B ecroi evbexoft*™, dkko tS [XYiSevi et dva,yxY\g (ovty\ ydp ecriv *j 
'ipevSog fxev cv fxevroi dSworov. eiteL yop MSeLxrtu ffn el dvricpoo-Lg rvig yevofxeVY,g V7to6e<reoog ' ere6v\ ydp e*r dvdy- 
tS A ovrog ro B ecri, xol ^uvcctS ovto? tS A ecrciL ro B Sv-30 xv\g ro A Tm roo F vitopx^v)' b h\ Slo tS dSvvdrv cvkko- 
vorov, VTtoxeiroi Se ro A Ajvcctov ervcc^, >cccj tc B ecrctJ Sv- yicrfxog TY\g dvrLxeifxevY\g ecriv dvTL(po<reoog. eri cfe xo) ex rcov 
voroV el yop doworcv, oifxo frworov ecroi ro ovro kol %pcov (povepov otl S>c £<^ccj to <rvfX7tepo<rfxo evSexofxevov. scrco 
dSvvcLTOV. ydp ro fxsv A xopo^, ro &' e(p' Z B hovoovfxevov, e<p' 

ALCopLo-fxevoov Sy) tovtcov vTtopx^oo ro A 7tccvt} tco B, co Ss F dv6pco7tog. iSsv) Sy} tw B to A vitdpxeL' xo\v ydp 
ro os B 7rccvTi Toi r evSex^oo' dvoyKVj w ro A 7tccvtz tco 35 Siovoifxevov xcpo^. ro Se B 7rctvT< iv^e^fTccj tw r* 7tccvt} 
r evoexe<r6oL vitopx^v. fXY\ yop evSex^oo , to <fe B 7rccyT< ycc^o dv6poo7tui ro S~LOvoeicr6oL. dkko ro A ejr dvoyxv\g icfev) 
rco r xe(r6co oog vTtopxov' tSto 8e ipevSog fxev, ov fxsvroL twT" S>c cc^cc to <rvfxxspotrfxa, evSexofxevov. dkk' iS' dvoy- 
curuvorov. el Sv to fxev A fXY\ evSex^roL rao F, ro b^e B >ccc?ov del. ecrco ydp ro fdev A ^ciyoD/x-evov, to Se B exLqY\fxv\, 
ntovTL vrtopx^ twT, to A S 7tccvt} tw B evo¥-^eTctr y(- ro 8 ecp' u F ov6poo7tog. ro fxsv w A ScW tw B vTtdp^eL, 
veroL yop o-vkkoyiTfxcg Slo tS rpLTX <rxYif*>orog. dkk' vrte- 40 to Se B 7tccvt} t<2 F evSe^roL, xoi ix ecroi ro <rvfX7tepo<rfxa, 
xeLTO TtovTL evSex £ o~6oL vTtopx^. dvoyxY\ opo ro A 7rctvT* ctvccy>cct?ov ov yop dvoyxY\ fXY t Mvo KLve7<r6oL ov6poo7tov , dkk' 

2. vocis t%ono<; litteras 0? corr A. II 9- hi A. II oV dc^.] ots h-.wov pr B. II 14. primum v.vX om C. II 18. oW/ B. II 
21. h' om. C. II 24. ovtos Ijjlo, holX JB. II 28. o\ to\> — Wi, v.m rc supra lituram A. II 30. chva.Tov to /3 C. 
5. xav] codices xuX. II 11. xgt om C. II 18. (cttAw?] a.ofrus C. II hopfyvn AB. 



ANAATTIKftNIIPOTEPftNA. 35 

«>c dvdyKY\ rtvd. tfy\Kov %v crt ro rvfXTreparfxa etp t« fxv\hvi ol tfe cfta ry\g dvrtcpo<py\g ry\g t« evtfexsr$at, Ka$a7rep ev 
e£ dvdyKyg vTrdpxstv. K.Y\7rreov c\e fteKrtov rovg opovg. roTg Trpcrepov. ecat tfe rvKKoytr/xog cftd ry\g im^o^ xcu 

'Ectv tfe ro cepv\rtKov re$y\ 7rpog ro eKarrov axpov ev$e- orav y) [xev jcct$oA.« irpog ro [xeTX^ov ctxpov re$e?ra o~Y\[xaivY\ 
Xeo-Qou ry\[xa?vov, e£ avroov fxev roov eiK.Y\[Xfxevoov Trporareoov ro vTrdpx^v y\ /xy) vTrdpx^v, »?%' ev fxepet cepY\rtKY\ «<r«, 
vcfe\g ecat rvKKcytrfxog, dvrtcpa<petry\g tfe ry\g Ka.ro. ro 5 ro ev^xerSat Ka[x(3dvy\, otov el ro fxev A 7Ta,vr\ roo B vTrdp- 
ev&xeo-dcu rrporareoog ecat, Ka.8a.7rep ev ro?g Trporepov. vTrap- x si *1 IW virdpxei , ro tfe B rm rw T evcfe'xerai /xvj vTrdp- 
%erw 7&P ?° A 7ra,vri twB, ro ^B evc\ex^r$oo fxy\cfev\ x siv ' dvrtcpa<pevrog ydp t« B T >tctrct ro evcfex^rSat yiverat 
roo r. vroo fxev «v ex^vroov ™ v r °P uv *^ sv Sf T& 1 d.va.yKO.?ov' rvKKoytrfxog. orav <fk ro fxv) vTrdpx^ Kafx(BdvY\ y) Korrd. 
eav tf dvrtcpa<pY\ ro B T ko,i Kyi<P$yi ro B 7ra,vrt roo T ev- fxepog re$e?ra, «>c ecat rvKKoytrfxdg. opot t« [xev vTrdpx^v 
cfexer$at, yiverat rvKKcytrfxog oorTrep rrporepoV ofxoioog yap 10 KevKov-X^uov-x^v, T * tfe fXY^vTrapx^v KevKov-XJ^ov-Trirra' 
ex°v°~ iv 01 dpot ry\ $eret. rov avrdv cfe rpoTrov ko,i cepy\rtKcov tfta yap t« dcftoptcx K.Y\7rreov ry\v aTrocfefetv. edv Se ro kolQoKv 
ovroov dfxcporipoov rdov <ftacY\[xaroov , eav to fxev A B [xy\ re&y) Trpog ro eKarrov aKpov, ro <f ev fxepet rrpog ro /xeT^ov, 
V7rapxvi, to <Je B r fXY\bev\ ev^x^rSat o-Y\fxatvy\' 8t' avroov eav re creprfrtKov eav re KararpariKov ectv t' evbexofxevov edv 
fiev yap roov eiKYjfXfxevoov itfafxoog ytverat ro dvayKO?ov, dv- $' VTrapx^v cnrorepoviv , itfa/aug ecrat trvKKoytrfxog. ic? 
rtcpatpetrY\g . Se rr\g Kard rt) evtfex^r$ai rrporareoog ecat i5 orav ev fxepet v\ dcftoptcot reSooriv al Trporaretg, etr eV&^e- 
trvKKoytrfxog. etKv\tp$oo yap ro fxev A fXY\cfevt rco B vTrap- tr$at Kafxfiavovrat effl virapx^ £*t' evaKKa^, »<5' ovroog 
X eiv '. T0 ^ s B evt\exer$at fxr^evt roo T. tta fxev Zv rovroov ecat rvKKoytrfxog. aTrobefytg tV v) avrY t y\ KaTr) roov rrpore- 
icfev dvayKa?ov' eav cfe K.Y\tp$y\ ro B Travrt ruT evMx^$at, pov. r 'opot cfe KOtvot t« ^aev vTrapx^ ^ dvayKY\g Zooov-Kev- 
%7rep ectv aKvfieg, r) Se A B rrpdrartg ofxoioog exp, TraKtv Kov-dv$poo7rog, t« tfe [xy\ evSexer$at XJyov -KevKov-lfxartov. 
6 avrog ecat rvKKoytrfxog. eav cfe julyj virdpx^ iz$% T ° B 20 cpavepov w ort t» /uev Trpog ro fxeTCov aKpov Ka$oK\i re$ev- 
iravrt tw T koa ■[xy\ evSex^r$at /xy\ inrdpx^v, vk ecat rvK- rog det yiverat rvKKoytrfxog, t« cfe Trpog ro eKarrov iSe 
Koytrfxog iS~a[xc2g, xre cepy\rtKY\g wyi? «ts KaratpartKY\g T^j? 7tot' ovSevog. 

A B Trpordreoog. opot tfe koivo} t» [xev e^ dvayKY\g vTrdpx^v ^Otccv tf r) [xev e\ dvayKY\g vTrdpx^v y\ <¥ evSex^r$at 16 

KevKov-l^oZov-XMv, t» cfe fXY\ evhex^$at KevKOV-XJoov-rrtrra. rYi[xatVY\ roov rrporareoov, 6 fxev rvKKoytrfxcg ecat tcv ccutov 

Qavepov «v ot^ Ka$oK.M roov cpcov ovroov, Kat rv\g fxev 25 rpoTrcv ex^vroov rcov opoov, Kai reKetog, orav Trpog ru eKar- 
v7rdpx^ v tys ^ evSe^x^rSat Kajix^avofxe^g' rcov Trporarecov, rovt aKpoo re$v\ ro dvayKaTov ro tTe rv[X7repar'[xa Karviyo- 
orav Yj rrpog ro eKarrov aKpov evSex irT $at Kafx(3avY\rat Trpo- ptKoov fxev ovrcov roov opoov t» ev^x^rSat Kat « t« vTrdpx^v 
rartg, det yiverat rvKKoytrfxog, ttKy\V bre fxev e^ avrcov ecat, Kat Ka$oKv Kat [xy) Ka$oKx rt$e[xevoov, eav cY Y\ro[xev 
cre c¥ dvrtcpatpeir^g rY { g Trporareoog. rcore he rovroov eKare- KaratpartKov ro tfe cepY,rtKov, orav fxev y\ ro KaratpartKov 
pog ko\ tfta riv atriav, elp^Kafxev. eav Se ro fxev jcct^o/.«30 ccvccy>cct?ov, t« evc\ex^$at Kat ov tk fxv\ vTrapx^-, orav <$e 
to tV ev fxepet Ky\<P$y, roov hacY\[xaroov , orav fxev to rrpog ro cepyrtKov, Kat t« evt\ex^r$at fxv\ inrapx^v xai tk fXY\ 
to [xeT^Qov av.pov Ka$oKov re$y t Kat ev^exofxevov, etr aTrotpa- vTrapx^v , Kat Ka$oKov Kat [xy\ Ka$oKov roov %poov ovroov. ro 
rtKov eire Kara.<partKov , ro cf ev [xepet KaracpartKOv >ccti <^' ev^x^rSat ev roo rv[xnrepar[xart rov avrov rpoTrov Kyj7rreov 
vrrapXjOV, ecat rvKKoytrfxog reKetog, Ka$airep Kat KaSoKx ov7rep ev roTg rrporepcv. t« <^' e^ ctvcty>c*i? [xy\ vTrapx^v ovk 
ruv opoov cvroov. aTroSet^tg cY v\ avry\ y, koi Trporepov. 0Tctv35 gc^cti rvKKoytrfxog' erepov yap ro fxv\ e^ dvayKY\g vTrapxw 
8e Ka$cKx /xev y\ ro Trpog ro fxeTCov aKpov, inrapxov tfe Kat Kat ro e^ ctvcty>c>ic; /xv\ vTrapx^v. 

fxy\ ev^e^aevov, ^ctTepov cY ev fxepet Kat evSexofxevov, eav r "Ort fxev «v KaratpartKoov ovroov roov 'opoov ov yiverat to 

a7ro<partKat eav re Kara<partKai re$oortv dfx<porepat, eav rvfxireparfxa dvayKaTov, <pavepov. vrrapx^oo yap ro A 
Te y\ fxev a7ro<pariKY\ y) cfe Kara<partKY\, rravroog ecat rvK- rravrt roo B e^ ctvcfy>t»i<;, to c% B evS~ex^r$oo nravrt roo T. 
Koytrfxog dre,..\g. ttKy\V 01 fxev cfta t« ct<5bvctT« <5et^>;rovTcti, 40 ecat rvKKoytrfxog dreKv\g 'ort evfrexsrat ro A Trctra TCt» T 

6. xct.Qa.7rec — 15. IV*' om A. II 8. vut C. II 16. u7rdp%ov AB. II 21. allerum fir\ om C. 

1. 3h xa\ fooi C. II 4. to \>TtcLp%m, omissis fj y.r) vTrdpxstv AC. II 5. vnt/.pxzw r) pr) V7rdpxw C. II 11. «.opig-ov A. II to om C. II 
17. h] v.Tttp C. II 30. bl r\ to ceprjMov o.io.^ymaoi x«A C. II 3-4. cWsp xou kv C. II 38. tc om C. II to fih <* C. II 40. lq<*.t truXX. <*t.J 
tiftd \)v\ avXX. o\t. JB, VTroLpxztv C. 

E2 



36 ANAATTIKftN IIPOTEPftN A. 

V7rctpx £ tv. ° ri ^ &' T ^yS-> £K T *K dTrocfsi^soog SviKoV tov clv- SoKov sv tw KcLTY,yoptKoo , olov to A B, wt scrctt tk u7rctp%ejv 

tov ydp rpoTvov cfEtxSwsTcLt %v7rsp kcl-ki toov TrpoTEpov. irctXiv crvKKoyio-fxog. dTroc^Et^tg cf v) clvty, y\ kcli ettl toov irpoTspov. 

to fxsv A ev^e^ecr^w ttckvti twB, to <% B tt&vti tco Y vir&p- ectv $e to fxev kclSoKov teSy, 7rpog tw eKclttovl ctKpco, y\ kcl- 

%st&o e£ dvctyKY\g. ecrcLl Sy) crvKKoyLcrfxog oti to A tt&vti TctcpcLTiKOv v\ crepvrrtKov, evc^ep^o^aevov, to cf sv fxspst dvcty- 
tw r ev^xstcli V7rdpx £ w> *AA' &x oTi ^&pX* 1 * K <* 1 Te ~ S xeuov Trpcg tw fXEtXovt cLKpoo, vk tcrctL o-vKKoytcry,og. opoi <fe 

kstog, dKK' «« ctTskYjg' svSvg ydp ettlteKeltcll cftd tcov e^ t« fxsv virctpx^v e£ dvctyKY,g X,u>ov -Ksvkov - cxvSpooTrog , th <Je 

dpx^ 7rpoTctoscov. sl cfs fxv\ bfxoiocrx^f^ovEg ctl TrpoTctosig, fxvi svSsx £ oScti X^uiov -Ksvkov - l/xcltlov. otclv cf ctvctyKctiov v\ 

SCTCO 7TpcOTOV v) erspYjTlKYj CtVCtyKCtlCt , KCLl TO [XSV A [XY^EVL SV- TO KClSoKX, TO cf EV fXSpSl SVcfsXOf^SVOV , CTEpY]TlKM [XEV. OVTOS 

cJsx £ oSoo tw B s]r ctvctyKY\g, to cfs B 7rctVTi too Y svcfsx £ - tS KctSokx t« fxsv VTrctpx^ opoi XJjOOV-ksVKOV-KOppl^, Ttt 

Cr&CO. CtVCtyKYj <5>) TO A fXV\cfsVL TW r V7rctpX£lV. KsioSw yctp 10 cfs fXY] VTTCLpX™ XJoOV-KsVKOV-TTLTTCL, KCLTCtCpCtTLKX $S T« 
VTTCtpX^ Y\ 7rCtVTl Y\ TlVl' TW cfs B V7TSKSIT0 fJCV\$SVl £vS~£X £ - flEV VTTCtpX^ XJ^OV -KsVKOV-KVKVOg , TK cfs fXv) £V$SX £ oScLL 
oScLl. E7TEL «V dvTLCjpsCpSl TO CTSpY,TLKOV , OVcfs TO B TW A icfsVL X^UIOV- KEVKOV - X^V . XcY OTCtV CtfrlOptCrOL XYj(pSoOO-LV Ctl TTpOTCt- 

evc\sxsTctL' tc <^e A tw Y y\ ttclvtl v\ tlvl KELTcti vTrctpxw crsig y, ctftcpcTspcti KctTct ftspog, icY xToog scrctL crvXkoyLo-fJcog. 

COCr' OVcfsVL Y) OV TTCtVTL TOO Y TO B EvMxOLT CtV VTTCtpX^' OpOL cfs KOIVOL T« fJCEV VTTCtpX^ XJoOV- XsVKOV - CtV$p007T0g, T« 

t;7re>ce<To cfs TrctvTL sjr ctpx^- (pctvspov cY "otl kocl t« ev<5e%e- ^ Ss ftY\ vTrctpx^ XJZov - Kevkov - cf^/vx^v. koll yctp to XJoov 

A \ I / / .. / '/ \~\ \. IM \A, \!l/ \\> -V. t / 

cracti fA.Y\ vTrctpx^ ytvsTctL crvKKoyio-fxog , stTrsp koll tv /xy\ tlvl Kevkoo koll to Kevkov atyvxy twi Kcti ctvctyKctiov vTrctp- 
VTTctpXeiv. irctKLV scroo y\ KctTct<pctTLKY\ nrpoTctcTLg ctvctyKctLct, x eiv Ket,t * K ev<^e%eTctz tJ7rct^e<v. >tct7r< t« sv^xsoSctL bfxotoog, 

KCtl TO fXSV A EV<f£X£0-$00 fJCYlcfsv} TOO B VTTCtpX™ ', T0 ^ £ B OOCTE TTpog C%7rctVTCt XP^^L 01 opOL. 

ITCtVTL TW r VTTCtpX^OO EJr CtvdyKY\g. fXEV %V CrvKKoytO-fJCOg <I>CtVEpOV W SK, TOOV EtpY\fXSVOOV OTi oftotcog exovtoov TOOV 

ecrcti TsKsLog, ctKkl ov t» [xy\ vTrcipx^ ctKKcl tk EvcMxEcrSctL 20 %pcov ev te tw v7vctpx£tv kcll iv TO?g civctyKctiotg ytvsTcti te kou 
fXY\ vTrctpxW y\ Te yap TrpcTcto-Lg vtcos eKy\<PSy\ y) ct7co tx ov ytvsrctL crvKKoyLcrfxog, ttKyw KctTct fxsv to V7rctpx £ w TtSe- 
fxstXfivog ctKpov, Kcti stg to d&wctTov &k ectiv ciyctystv el yctp fxevY\g TY\g crepv\TiKYis TrpoTctcrecog t« Evcfsx^oSctL v\v 6 crvKKoyi- 

VTTOTsSstY] TO A TW Y TLVL VTTclpX^ , KEtTCtt (Ve KCtL TW B EV- CTfXOg, KCtTct <$£ TO CtVCtyKCUOV TYfi crspY\TLKY\g KCtL TK EV^EXEoSctL 
MxtvBcU fXY\cfEVL VTTCtpX^, &8sV CTVfxftcttVEL c\tCL TOVTCOV Ctcfv- KCLL T» /XY\ VTTCtpX^- OVJKOV cfs KCLL OTL TTcLVTEg CLTSKslg OL CTvK- 
VCLTOV. ECLV cfs TTpog TW EKctTTOVl CtKpU TsSyj TO CrspYjTtKCV, 25 KoytrfXOL KCLL OTl TEK£tivTCLt OlCt TOOV 7rpOEtpV\fXEVCOV CTXYlfACLTOOV. 

otclv fxev sv&xeoSctt o-Y\fXctivv\ , crvKKoytcrfxcg scrcti $lcl ty\s 'Ev Se tw frsvTspco (T^aetTi otclv fxsv ev^xecrScti Kctfx-Y\ 

ctVTicrpocpYig, KctScLTrsp sv rotg TrpoTspov, otclv cfe fxv\ ev<5e%e- Qclvooo-lv dfXcpoTepcti ctl TrpoTctcrstg , icfelg 'ecrcti crvKKoyLO-fxog^ 

cScti, yk ecrctL. &<¥ otclv ctfxcpco fxsv TsSvj crspvrrtKcL, fXY\ v\ cY «Te KctTYiyoptKoov 8Te crepv\TiK0ov TtSsfXsvoov, KTe kclSoKov »T£ 

evcfexopevov to Trpog to eKclttov. opoi cf ol clvtol, t» fxev kcltcl fxspog' otclv Se v) fxsv vttclqx^v y) <¥ svcMx^Scu o-v\fxcLivv\, 

VTTCtpX^ KSVKOV -XJ>O0V - X^V , T6 <^S fXY\ VTTCtpX^ KeVKOV- 30 TY t g fXEV KCLTCLCpCLTtKYig VlTCtpX^V <TY]fXCLLVOVCry\S ^ETTOT ECTcLl, 

XJioov-TTtTTcL. Tvig <Ys crepY\TLKYig Tr,g kclSoKx dst. tov clvtov cfe TpoTTOV KCt\ 

TOV OtUTOV $S TpOTTOV S^St KCL7t\ TOOV EV fXSpEL CTvKKoy ICT fXOOV . OTCLV Y\ fXEV S^ dvctyKYig v) cf EV^EX^oScLl KcLfx(2cLVYjTcLL TOOV 
OTCLV yctp Y, TO CTSpY,TtKOV CLVCLyKCLLOV, KCLl TO CTVfXTTSpcLCrfXCL SCTCLl TT pOT CLCT EOOV . <$EL <fs KCLL SV TXTOtg KcL/xfictVElV TO SV TO?g CTVfX- 
TK fXY\ VTTCtpX^V. OLOV El TO fXEV A jUCYtcfsv) TOOV B EV^XSTCLL VTTCLp- 7T SpcLCT fXCLCT tV SVcfsXOfXEVOV , 00CT7TSp SV TO?g TTpOTSpOV. 

X £lv i T0 ° £ B T<y< toov Y svcfex^TcLi V7rccpx £ i v , dvctyKYi to A tlvi 35 II^aiTov w Sslktsov otl xk dvTtcrpscpsi to sv too svMx^oScti 

TOOV Y fXY\ V7rcLpX £ lV. Et yctp TTCtVTt V7TCLpX £ l, TW Ss B fXY\S~SVL CTEpY\TlKOV, OtOV s! TO A EVcfsX £ TCLl [XY\c\eVL TOO B, tfjt dvctyKY\ KCLl 

evcfsX £ TctL, icfs to B iSsv) tw A evcMx^tcu v7rcLpx £ rv. oocr' sl to to B evc\ex £ cScli fXYic$£v) tw A. KsioSoo ydp txto, kcl) svc\ex £ oSoo 

A TTCtVTt TW r V7TCLpX £ t, X&EVl TOOV Y TO B EV&EXETCLl. dKK' V7TE- TO B fXY^EVL TW A V7TcLpX £ tV. «>C«V E7TEI dvT LCJ plcp^cr LV CLl EV 
KELTO TlVl £Vc\£X £ vSctl. OTCtV cYe TO EV fXSpSL KCLTCLCpCtTtKOV dvcty- TU) EV^EX^oScLL KCLTCL(pCLO-£ig TcL?g d7TO(pCLO-£0-L, KCLL CLL EVCLVTLCLl 
7LCU0VY,, TO EV TOO CTEpYiTtKOO crvKKoyLCTfXOO, ofoVTO B Y, Y,TO KCL- 40 KCLl Ctt dvTlKsifXEVCLl , TO <fs B TW A EVC^EX £ TCLL fXV\c\sv) VTTCLQ- 

2. x«i bri C. II 7. o^o(r%r'ju.ove? A. II 9- e£ av*7>»j? om C. \\ 11. to A et pr C II 18. tujy AB. II 22. kitajy&^tiii C. II 23. /*>;- 
M ABC. II 33. hwt ph 7*p C. II 34 et 35. t£ C. II 40. to /3 — oim om A. 

2. xai omC. II 5. xpog tu iiei^ovi ctxpou omA. II 9. opoi omC. II 21. tov C. II 24. oti xoci C. II a,TeXetg sW\v o\C. II 31. al- 
terum t5«? om C. II 34. o/Wep xoci kv C. II 7rpoTepoy 7rsp\ Trfi ctvTt^potyrfi rth hhi%ofj.(t'MV TrpoTticTVjjv. TtpuToiB. II 36. TcSyB. II 37. w C. 



ANAATTIKfiN nPOTEPfiN A. 37 

X SLV , <pctvspov oti xdt 7ta,vTi evb^exotro dv T0 B twA vTtctp- yjxtpel. xctTcupctTixv fxev ydp Te$evTog <fetx$riO-efctt t\td toov 
%eiv. t»to <fe ^pev&og' h ydp ei To$e too&s TtctvTt evfrex^cti, opoov oti \sx evhex s rcti vTtdpx^v, crepr,Tixx M, oti to trvfx- 
Kttt Tofre Tuicfe dvctyxaAov' ootr tx ctvTttrpepei To-trepr\Ttxov< 7tepcto-[xa. ix evbexoftevov dKK' dvctyxcttov etriv. ecru> ydp ro 
ht tY'*tYsv xooKvet To fxev A raB ey<5e%e<r0cu ftrfisvi, to cfe fxsv A Ksvxov, to cfe B <xv$poo7tog, sp' u tfs T "iTtTtog. ro 
B Ttv\ toov A e\\ dva,yxr,g f*>r\ V7ta,px s ^v, 0i °v ro ft sv Aeu>cov 5 b\ &, to Kevxov, ev^x^fctt tw /xev tt&vtI too cYe fxrib^ev) 
7fa,VTt dv$poo7too eV<Je%eTcu [XY, vir&pxw (k&i y&P vTrcipX eiv )-> VTtctpx^v. cLKKd to BtwT kts V7tdpx s <- V sv^x^cti vts fxy\ 
ctv$pu)7tov cY ix dkYjSeg elixelv oog evcfex^oa fxvfisvt Ksvxuj'- V7fctpx s ^- QV f* sv * v V7tdpx siv «» £yX u P £ ?> pctvspov' ib^s\g 
TtoKKoTg ydp efc, dva,yxr,g ovx v7tdpx si -> to cY dvctyxa.7ov yctp t7t7tog ctv$poo7tog. d>J\! ovcY evMx s o-$ctt fxr) V7tdpx s ^' 
vx r,v evcfexofJ-evov. dkXa) fxr]v ovcY ex th d&vvdTK $etx$riO-e- dvctyxr, yctp fxr$sva, itvkov ctv$poo7tov sTvctt, to cY dvctyxcuov 
Tctt dvTicrpspov, olov ef Tig d\^iu)<rstsv, STtst ^psvt^og to evcfe- 10 ix y\v svfrsxofxsvov. ovx ctpa, yivsTat <rvKKoyt<r[xog. bfxoioog 
X s °-$ctt to BtwA fXY,t\sv\ VTtdpx^v ' ■> dKn$eg to /xrj ev<Je%e- cYe c^etx^creTcu xctt dv dva,7ta,Kiv Te$r\ to treprrttxov, xa,v dfx- 
tr$ctt [Avifrsvi' (pctrig yctp xctt d7ro(pa,crig. et cfe t«t', dX.Y\(kg cpoTepa,i xa,Ta,(pa,Tixa,t Xvj(p$oocriv q c~epY{xtxa,t' $td ydp 
e£ dva,yxY l g Ttv\ toov A to B v7r&pxW oocre xa,t to A. tivi toov o,vtoov opoov scrcu r\ d7:oc\s^n.g. xcu oto,v r\ fxsv x&QoXv 
luov B. tSto cY dc\vva,Tov'. « yclp sl [xr] evMx^ctt ,f/,Y[c\svt y\ cY sv fjjpst, y, dfxcpoTspctt xojto, ftspog y\ dhoptqot, y\ ocra,- 
to B too A, dva,yxY\ rtv\ v7rctpx^v. to ydp ptY\ evhsx^ctt 15 %w? dWoog ev^x^a.t [xsTa,\a,(3elv ra,g 7npoTa,cretg' det ya,p 
fXY^evt cftxws XeyeTa,t, to fxev et s\\ dvdyxY\g Ttvt vifcipx^ tcrtu c\td toov o,vtoov "opoov r) dTvt^et^tg. (pavepov kv %ti dfx- 
to cY ei e^ dva,yxY\g Ttv\ fxr] V7rdpx �� i' r ° yctp e^ dva,yxr\g porepoov toov 7tpoTa.creu)V xa,Td to ev$ex£o~$cu TtQefxevoov ovcfsts 
Ttvt toov A fxr\ v7roopx°v &x d\v\deg «xert u)g 7ra,vTi evcfs^x^cu ytveTcu crvkkoytcrfxog. 

fxr, V7ta,px^ v , LxTTtep bcfs to Ttv\ V7rcipx° v £ \\ dvdyxr t g oti Et <^' r), fxev V7ra,px siv V ^ evcfsxe&Qcu <rr\fxa,tvst , Tr\g\Z 

lfa,VTt svfrsxsTcu vTfcLpx^' et iv Ttg d^totYj , e7r£i isx ev^e^e- 20 /u,sv xa,TY,yoptXY\g V7fd,px s! - V Ts$si<rv\g TY\g <Je ^epr,Ttxr,g ev<Je- 
TcutoT Tto A7ra,VTi vTvdpx^v, e\\ dvdyxr,g Ttvt /u.y\ v7ra,px si V %e<r^«,{ »<Je7roT ecra,t <rvKKoyto-fxog, «Te xcxSokx toov opoov 
ctvTo, ipevfrog dv \a,fx@a,vat' 7ra,vTt y,dp v7ta,px si -> clK?^ 'oti ev ovt ev fxepet Ka,fx(3a,vofxevoov. dTtobeify.g cY r\ o,vty\ xcu <$id 
ivtotg ejr dvdyxr\g vitdpx^t $<■<*, tkto / <pa,fxev i 7ta,VTi evoe- roov cxvtoov opoov. otcxv cY r, fxev xa,Ta,pa,Ttxr] svc\exeo-$a,i % 
X s o~$cu. cocrs tu> svc\sx s o~$tu 7ta.rf\ v7ta,px s ^v to t e^ dva,y- cYs tjspYrtixY, V7ta.px s ^v, stra,i trvKhoyt<rfxag. sthY\p$u) ydp to 
xr,g tiv\ V7t dpx £ iv dvTtxstTa,i xoa to sjr dva,yxY,g tivi fXY\ vTtctp- 25 A tw ^w-ev B fXYi&svi v7t<xpx s iv, tw <5"e r 7TctVT) sv^xeoScti. 
X SiV . bfxotoog cfs xttt too svc\sx s o~$ctt fXYitfsvi. tYqkov w oTi Ttpog dvTt$pa,(psvTog ovv t« trspr\Tixov to B too A av$sv\ V7tdp\\si' 
70 vTUjg evb^exoftevav xa,t /xvj evb^exoftevov , cog ev dpxy btoopt- to oe A xctvTi tw T eve<Je%eTo * yiveTO,t frrj o-vXKoyio-fXog 
(Tctfxev , & to e^ dvdyxr\g tivi V7tctpx siv dwd to ejr dva,yxr,g oTi evoex^cti to B fxr,c\evi too T fod tv TtpooTov o-x^ctTog. 
tiv\ fxr\ V7tdpx siv \r\7tTeav. tktk <^e Kr\p$evTog «<^ev o-vfx[3cuvet bfxotoog frs xctt sl Ttpog Tuj T ts$siy\ to crspY\Tixov. sdv cY dfx- 
do\jvctTov, u)cj & ytvsTctt o-vKhoyto-fXog. poovspov w sx toov si- 30 poTepa.i fxev uxri tjepYrttxctt, <rr\fxa.ivr, cY r\ fxev fxr) V7ta,px £ iv 
pYjfxevoov c oti ix dvTttrpepet to trepY\Ttxov. r\ cY ev$ex s o~$cti fXY\ V7tctpx s <-v, cfi' ctvToov fxev toov etKY\[Xfxevoov 

Toutk <Jg S~etx$ s vTog xetoSoo to A too fxev B ev^e^eo-c^cti ovb\v a-vfxfia,tvet dvctyxcuov , dvTitrpa,pei<rY\g cfe TY\g xctTd to 
fxr,c^svi, tw <Je T 7ta,vTi. frta, fxsv kv Tr\g dvTttrpopY\g ix etrctt evMx s o~$cti TtpoTcto-eoog yiveTctt <rvKKayio-fxag %Tt to B tw 
trvKKoyto-fxog' etpY\Tcti yctp 'oti vx dvTitrpepei r\ Tota,vTv\ Ttpo- T ev^x^cti fxrifrevi VTtdpx^v, xct$dxep ev TOtg TtpoTepov'- 
TO,o-tg. dKK* ioe oia, t« dovvctTX' Te$evTog ydp th B 7rctvT< 35 ecrctt ydp 7tctKtv to 7tpooTov o-XY\f*ct. edv cY dfxcpoTepcti Te- 
tw r evoex s o-$ctt v7tctpx s ^v K<^ev o-vfx@a,ivei ^pevbog' evM- $ooo~t xa,TY l yoptxa,i, ovx etra,t o-vKKoyio-fxog. opoiTX fxev v7tdp- 
Xoito yctp ctv to A tw r xctt 7fa,vTi xa,i [XY^evt v7tctpx s iv. X SLV vyieia.-XJjOQv-a,v$poo7fog, t» Ss fxr\ V7tdpx si - V vyistct- 
c oKoog cY si strt <rvKKoyicr[xog , Sy\Kov oti t« svc\exe<T$cti dv l7f7fog-ctv$pu)7fog. 

sir, cna, to fxr,oeTepctv toov TtpoTotreoov eiKr\<p$ctt ev tuj VTtdp- ToV ck-utov cYe Tportov s£st xd7t\ toov sv [xspst <rvKKoyt- 

X slv -> X& 1 'wrps h KctTa,pa,Tixog r, crepr,Ttxog' ib^sTspoog &' sy- 40 g-[xoov. oTctv fxsv ydp y\ to xctToopctTixov v7tdpxov, trti xct- 

I. £7 om A, ante IvgV%cito ponit C. II rc B om C. \\ 3. oux] oix <*y A. II 6. VTrdpx^ C. II 12. (pdai?] x*T^a<n? C. II 
13. e£] xcLi i% B. II tc B \>7ra,px' lv ] V7tcm%eu> £, ■inrcLp^eiv to B C. II 15. i£ dmyxrii; rm v-xcipxei C. II 16. £i om AB . II l^ — 17. &' 
OYO.A. II 26. to pi C. II 28. i povov to B. II clXXa, aod ro BC. 

II. y.cu A. II 15. tJ.eTu,fidXXw A, y.£Tot,^xXe7v C. II 19. aripctivoi C. II 20. TiSsju.(vr\? C. II 26. vTtdpxu AIB. II 29. h\ om C. II 
30. uatv a,l ?-. pr B. II 31. (jly) V7rdpxw om AC. 



38 ANAA¥TIKftNIIPOTEP£2NA. 

66hx eet' h fxspeL hY,(p$iv, ovSeig 'icrcu <rvhhcyi<rfxog (tkto xv\g xivv\<rig, ^ww oe itcuvTi hSixeTcu' koul xctv to sypv,- 
cf bfxoioog xcu hd toov cuvtoov cpuov SsixwTcu Tolg irpoTspov), yopog X^ooov. (pouvepov ovv cTi cvSe tov fxv) vTtoLpxeiV •> st- 

OTCUV 6e TO crepY\TLXOV , tqcUL SloU TY\g dvTLCrpO(pY\g , X0U$CL7tep 7tsp OVTUg SXOVTOOV dvcUyxV, V7Tct,pXeiV. CXjSs Sy) toov dvTL- 

h ToTg TxpoTspov. TtoLhLV ecuv cufxcpoo /uusv ta cficucrvi/xcuTou crspv,- xsifxsvoov (pouosoov, ooctt' ovSstg scrcu o-vhhoyio~fxog. bfxoioog 

TlXol hY\(p$Y), XOL$ohX Ss TO fXv) VTt.cLpX^ •> ejr CUVTOOV fXSV 5 Se C^SIX$Y,TSTCU XCl) dvOUTtCUhlV TS$SiO-Y}g Tr]g XOLTOL(pOUTLXv]g. 
TUJV 7tpOTCtOSUV VX SCTOUL TO cXv&yKVAOV , dvTlCTptUpivTOg OS TK SOUV OfXOtOO-XYIfXOVSg OOCTIV CU TtpOTcLoSLg , <TSpY,TLXOOV fXSV 

hcfixe<r$cu, xcu$cu7tsp h Totg TtpoTspov , scrcui o-vhhoyL<rfxog. cvcroov dsi ytvsTcu crvhhoyLO-fxog dvTicrpcu(psio-Y\g TY\g xoltou 
edv cfs V7tdpx 0] ' f*<ev vj to crepvjTLxov, h /xipei oe hY\(p$Y\, vx to hcfixeo-$cu TtpcTouosoog , xcu$oU7tsp h Tc7g TtpoTspov. sl- 
scrcu o-vhhoyio-fxog, ovts xcuTcupcuTixY^g ovts crspYiTtKY\g 'y,<rv,g hv\<p$oo youp to A tw fxsv B s^ dvcuyxv\g /xv) vTtoupxeiv, toZ 
rv]g sTspoug TtpoTouosoog. ovcf oTctv dfMpcTspcu hY\(p$ooo-iv dfric- 10 <^s r svSixeo-$cu /xy\ v-7tc(pxeiv' dvTicrpcupsiToov w toov Ttpo- 

piCTOL V\ KOUTcUpCUTlKCU Vj d7t0(pcUTLKCU Y\ XOTtd fxipog. dTtO- TOUOSOOV TO fXSV B TOO A OvSsv) V7tcupxet, TO cfe A TtcUVTL 
frsij^Lg (Y V, CUVTYj KCU OICU TOOV CUVTOOV opOOV. TOO Y SvSixeTOUL ' yLVSTcUL Svj TO TtpOOTOV O-XYifAcU. xdv sl 

19 'Ectv cf v) fxsv i^ dvdyKY\g y) cf hcfsxeo-$cu o-y\juuciivyi Ttpog tw T ts$siy\ to crspY\TiKov, ooo-ouvToog. sdv Se kcuty\- 

toov 7tpoTou<rsoov , TY\g fxsv .crspY\TLKY\g dvouyKouicug cvo-Y\g ecrcu yoptKcu ts$ooctlv, ovk scrcu crvhhcyLo-fxog. tov /uuev ydp fj*v) 
crvhhoyLO-fJUog, ov fjuovov 'ctl hMxeTcUL /juy) y7toupxetv, dhhd 15 vTtcupxew y\ tov s^ dvouyKY\g fxy] vTtclpxeLV (pouvepov otl ix 

XCU OTL ix vl S&?X U i 7 W ^ KOUTcUpCLTLKYjg KK tcTCU. KeiO-$00 eCTCU (fiCU TO fXY\ eihY\(p$OUL qSpYiTLXY^V TtpOTCUCTLV fJUY\T SV TW 

ydp to A too fjuev B e% dvcuyxY\g fj,Y\SsvL v7toupxeiV, too cfe v7toupxeLV ^t' h too s\\ dvcuyxY\g vTtoupxeiv. dhhou /u,y\V 
r TTctVTi hSexe<r$ouL . dvTicrpcU(pei<rY\g ovv TY\g crepY\TLXY\g ovcfe ovoe tov hfrexeo-^cu fXY\ vTtcupxew' e^ dvcuyxv\g ydp VTOog 

TO BtwA OvSsVL VTtcip^SL' TO 0% A TtCUVTL TU) Y SVS^XeTO' i^OVTWV TO B TOO Y OVX V7tOUp^SL, 0L0V sl TO fJUSV A T£- 

yivsTcu Sy) TtcLhLt cfid tov TtpooTov <rxvfJuouTog b <rv>\J\oyi<r[xog 20 $siv\ hevxov, ecp' co oe to B xvxvog, ro os Y ouv$poo7tog. 

OTl TO B TOO Y SV^XSTCUL /JUYiSsv) VTtcLpXeiV. cXfJUCU Ss Sy\hOV OvSs ys TOOV dvTLXSLfXSVOOV d7tO(pOUVOSOOV, S7ts\ friSsLXTCU TO 

otl ovcf V7tcLpc\eL TO- B ovSsv\ toov Y. xsi<r$oo ydp vTtcupxeiv' B too Y g£ dvcuyxY\g ov% v7tcLpxov. ovx ctpcu yivsTcu crvh- 
ovxovv sl to A tw B fXYjcfsvL ev^e%eTcti, to^ cfs B u7Tct/3%£i hoyLO-fxog ohoog. 

TiviTwvT, tq AtoovY Tiv) ovx hSs^xsTcu' dhhd TtcuvTi VTts- 'Ofxoioog o ezsL xd^tL toov ev fxspsL o-vhhoyLO-fJUoov' 

xeiTo hSixer$cUi. tov ouvtcv Se TpoTtov ^siX$Y\osTcu xou) sl25otcuv /uusv ycup y\ to crspv\TLxov xcu$ohov ts xcul dvouyxcuov, 
Ttpcg tw r TS$siY\ To crspYftixov. TtoLhiv sctoo T8 xouTY\yopixo\ dsi <rvhhoyio-fxog scrcu xcu tv hSixe<r$cu xcu tov /uuy} 
dvcuyKcuav, $ouxepov cf hSsxofxevov, kcu to A too /uuev B h- vTtdpxew {dTtooeiQg oe olcu TY\g dvTi<rpo(pY]g) , "otouv cfe to 
cfexeo-^oo fxySsvi, too hs Y TtcuvTL vTtcupxeToo i^ dvouyKY\g. ov- KcuTcucpouTiKOV, cvosTtcTs' tov cuvtcv ydp TpoTtcv SsLX$Y,<rsTcu 
Toog «v sxovtoov toov opoov ovfrsLg scrouL o-vhhoyio-fxcg' <rv/uu- ov kcu h Tc7g Kou^ohv, kcu S~lcu toov cxvtoov opoov. xcf otcuv 
ftcuveL yaup to B too Y s^ dvctyKY\g /uuy) VTtcLpxeiv- ecroo ydp 30 dfxcporspoui hY\(p$ooo-L xouTcupouTLXouL' xcti ydp' tovtov y\ cuvtyj 
to fxsv A hsvxcv, s(p' u) oe to B dv$poo7tog, e(p' oo Ss dTtoSsifyg y\ xcul TtpcTspov. otouv Ss dfJucpoTspcu fjusv crspv\TL- 
to Y xvxvcg. to oy\ hsvxov xvxvuo /jusv e^ dvcLyxv\g vrtcup- xcu, xcu$ohov oe xcu dvouyxouLou y) to fjuv) vTtcLpxeiv o-Yi/JUcui- 
X^l, dv$poo7too S' hhixeTcUL fXY^svi' xoui dv$poo7tog ifrsv) vovcrcu, S~l' ouvtoov fxsv toov slhYjfJUfJuivoov ovx sctcul to dvcuy- 
xvxvoo e\ dvcuyxY\g. otl /xev w t« hSixeo-$cu ovx ecri xcuov , dvTLcrpcupei<rv\g be TY\g xcuta to ho^ixeoScu Ttpo^d- 
uvhhcyLrfxog, ipcuvepcv' to ydp e^ dvcuyxY\g ix y\v hSe-35 treoog ecrcuL o-vhhoyio-fxog, xcu$cu7tep h Tolg TtpoTepov. edv 
Xofxsvov. cuhhcu fXY\v ovfrs t» dvouyxouix' to ydp dvouyxcuov cf dfxcpcTspcu dSLcpLcroi v\ h fxipsL Ts$ui<riv, ovx scrcu <rvh- 
7}v s e? cufxcpoTspoov cuvcuyxcuioov v\ sx TY\g crspY[TLXY,g <rvvificuL- hoyLo-fxog. dTtobsify.g S' v) cuvty) xcul fod toov cwtoov opoov. 
vev. stl cfs xcUL syxoopst tovtoov xsLfxivoov to BtwT VTtcup- 3>auvspov ovv ex toov elpYi/uuivoov ctl TY.g /xev crepY\TLxv\g 

Xeiv' *Sev youp xoohvsL to fxsv Y v7to to B sTvcu, to oe Tv]g Kou$ohov TL$efxivv\g dvcuyKcuioug de) yiveTcu o-vhhoyi- 
A too fxev B TtouvTL hc\ixeo~$cUL , too oe Y e^ dvoLyKY,g 40 o-fxog, ov fxovov tov hSixe<r$cu fxv] VTtcLpxe^v , dhhd xaX 
VTtcupxeiv, olcv £i to fxev Y .sly\ eypv\yopog, to Se B ^wov, tov fxv) vTtcupxeiv, t^? $£ xouTcupouTixY,g ovSiTtoTs. xcu otl 
to a scp' oo A xivv,o-ig. tw /xsv ydp sypY,yopoTi s^ dvouy- tov ct-UTc v v TpoTtov ep^oVrwv sv ts Tclg dvcuyxouicLg xcu h ToTg 

■ 8. hs ij.r, foajpxoi A. II 20. o om C. \{ 22. virdpxti B. II 42. « b * C, 

6. a<xc<j-xApon<; AB . II 11. u-cwfsi B. II 16 et 17. nv\<Y A. II 21. um<pdy<rsuv A. II Ixst^ C. \\ 2&. xod- i-m C. 



ANAAtfTIKftN nPOTEPUN A. 39 

VTtctpxtvTi ytvETctt ts Kcti ov ytvercu TvKKcyiTfXcg, $y)Kcv fxivoov cvk' ecjcti TvKKcyiTfxog , civrtcjpctcpEtToov t¥ tcjcti, Kct- 
$e Kcti oTt 7tctv7£g ctTsKstg 01 TvKKoytTfxot, kcu cti teKei- $ct7tsp sv TcTg itpcTspov. orctv Ss ctfxcpcTspcti dfoopicjoi y) 

CVVTCtl t^lCt TOOV 7tpOStpY[fX£VOOV (T^W-CtTW»'. EV fXSpSl K.Y]<p$O0TlV , CVK ECJCti TvKKoyiTfXOg ' KCU' yctp TTAVt) 

20 'EV $£ 700 7sKsV7ctlOO <r%VI{ACtTl KCti CtfX(p07£pOOV SV- OLVCtyKY] 70 A TW B KCtt fXY]Mv) VTtCtpXEtV. %'pCl T» VTtCtp- 

8'eXo/u.e'vcvv Kctt Tr\q htepctg Ecrctt TvKKoytTfxcg. oTctv fxev 5 x eiV X^oocv- ctvQpuntog-KevKov, t« fxv) V7tctpx £iv 77t7tcg-ctv- 

OVV EVcM-XfiC^Ctt TY[fXctlV0OTlV Ctl 7tp07CtT£tg , KCtt 70 TVfJ.Ttlpct- 6p007TO$ - KSVKOV , fXSTOV KeVKOV. 

TfXct ECJCti £V$£X l 0/U.EV0V' KCtt CTCtV Y[ fXEV EV^E^^Ctt Y[ O 'E*V <$£ Y[ fXSV VTtdpX^ V ^ E v ^£X£T$Ctt TY^fXctiVY]^ 

V7VctpXW- 'oTCtV t¥ Y\ ETEpct T£$y CtVctyKCtiCt , ECtV fXEV Y[ KCt- TOOV TtpCTCtTEOOV , TO fXEV TVfXTtSpctTfXct ECJCtl OTt SvMxETOU 

TctcpctTtKYi, ovk ECTcti Tc TVfXTtspctTfxct ovte ctvttyKcttov Kctt ^x 0Tl v7r ctpx£i, TvKKoytTfxcg c¥ tcjctt tov ctvTov Tpc- 

CV$' VTXCtpX^-, £c tV $' f? CJspYftiKY], TOV fXY} V7tCtpX elv ECJCtt i® 7T0V f^OVTWV TWV CpOOV OV KCtl £V TO?g TTpCTSpCV. SCJUiTctV yctO 

TvKKoyiTfXOg, KCt$Ct7TSp KCt) EV ToT; TtpOTSpCV. KY\7t7E0V c\e TtpOOTQV KCtTY\ycptKOl, KCti TO fXEV A TtCtVTt ,TW Y VTTctpXETU), 

KCtl EV TOVTOtg OfXClOOg TO EV TCtq <rVfX7t£pct<rfXct<riV £Vc\£XC- 70 M B TtCtVTl EvfrEXttQbO V7tctpx^ v ' ctv7tcjpcttp£v7og 'ovv TH 

fXEVOV. B r TO TtpoOTCV ECJCtl TX^lf^Ct, KCti TO TVfXTTEpctTfXCt %7l EV- 

' 'Ecjootav $yj TtpooToy Evc^EXofXEVctt, y.ct) to A Kcti to b^EX^ctt to A tivi toov B V7tctpx^ v ' cte yctp y\ ETspct toov 

B TtCtVTl TOO r EVc\sX£^^ V7tCtpX £ l v - £7rel °^ v CtVTl<rp£(p£l l^ TtpCTCtTEOOV £V TOO TtpOOTOO O-XYif^Ct^t <TY\fX<XtVOi EV&EX^vQcti, KCti 
70 KCtTctCpCtTlKCV £7t\ fXEpOVS, 70 0% B TtCtVTl TOO Y £V$E- 70 CTVfX7tspct<rfXCt Y[V EVC^EXOfXEVCV. CfXCiOO<; b% KCti £1 TO fXEV 

%£Tcti, Kcti to Y Ttvt tu B £v<^;oiT ctv. oo<r' st to fxsv BT vitctpxew tc cYe AT EvcMxEo-Qctt , KCti £i TO fXEV AT 

A TtCtVTl TUI Y EV^XE^Cti, TO $£ Y TlVl 700V B, KCti TO A CJEpYftiKOV 70 hs B Y KCt7YiyoptKO V , VTtCtpXCi ' $ C7t07EpOv£v, 

7in 7oov B EV$EX£7ctt' yivsTcti yctp to TtpooTcv (T^^a. Kcti ctfxcpoTE^poog svfrsxofXEVov scTcti 7o <rvfX7tspct<rfxct' yivsrctt yccp 

£i 70 fXEV A £V'^£;££Tca fXYifrsVl 7<2 Y V7VctpX £ tV., 70 &S B 20 TtCtKiV 70 7tp<MT0V TX^lf^Ct , C^SO^ElKTCtl tY CTt T>J? £T£pct<$ TtpO- 

TtCtVTl 7UI Y, CtVCtyKYl 70 A TiVi TW B hMx^Ctt fXY[ VTtCtp- ^CtTEOO? EV^EXET^Ctt <TY\fXctm<TY\<; EV 0LV7C0 KCti 70 <TVfX7tSpct<TfXCt 

X SIV ' e ^Ctl yctp TtcLXtV 70 7tp0070V TX^f^Ct $ldi 7Yfi CtV7i- ECJCtl EV^EXOfXEVOV. £t cfs 70 EVt^EXOfXEVOV CJzpYftiKOy 7E&EIY] Ttpo^ 

CjpC(pY,c;. Et cY CtfX(p07Epctt CJEpYYtiKCti T£$£tY]<TctV , £^ CtVTOOV 70 sXtt770V CtKpOV ', Yj KCtt CtfXCpOO \Y}(p$SiY} CJspYYTiKCt, <5i ' 

fXEV 700V ElhYlfXfXEVOOV OVK ECJCtl 70 CtVctyKCtlOV , CtV7lCjpct<p£t- CtV700V fXEV 700V KEifXEVOOV *K ECJCti <TvWoyi<TfXO<; , CtV7iCjpct- 

(TOOV <$£ 700V 7tp07ct<T£0OV ECJCtt <TvWoytTfXC<; , KCt&Ct7t£p EV 25 (pSV700V £' ECJcti , KCt$Ct7t£p SV 70l<; TtpCTEpOV. '. 

7cTg 7tp07£pOV. £1 yctp 70 A KCt) 70 B TW r EV^XE^Ctl fXv) Ei &' y) fXEV KCtSoKoV TOOV TtpoTCtTSOOV Y\ $' EV fxlpEt, 

VTtxLpX^-, ec tV fX£TCt7\.Y](p$Yi 70 EvMx^Ctt VTtCtpX^ •, TtCtKtV KCt7Y]yoptKOOV fXEV CVTOOV CtfX(p07EpOOV , Y[ 7YIS fXSV KCtBcKoV 

SCJCti 70 7tpO07CV TX^lttCt $lCt 7Y\g CtV7iCjp0(pY]<;. Et t¥ fXEV CJEpYJT tKY^ TYfi $' EV fXEpEi KCt7ct<pCt7iKY[<; , 6 CtV705 7p07t0<; 

ECJl KCtQcKi 700V %pOOV t¥ SV fXEpSl, TOV CtV7CV 7p07tCV SCJcU 700V TvKKoy iT fXOOV ' 7tCtV7£g yctp TtEpctlVCVTCtl $lCt TOV 

EX° vruv r ^ v ^P fj0V 'cVTtep £7t\ TCV V7tCtpX^ v ■> ECJCtl T£ KCti 30 TtpoOTCV TX^CtTCg. UICJE (pCtVSpOV OTl T» £vMx£C"$Ctl KCU W 

OVK ECJCtl TvKKoytTfXcg. £V^£^£Cr^ yctp TO fXEV A 7TctVTf TK U7TCt^£(V SCJctt TVKKoytTfXOg. £1 C>' r) fXSV ~KCt7ct(pCt7tKY\ 

700 Y , 70 <Jg B T(Vt 700 Y VTtCtpX^- ECJCtl h'f[ TtCtKlV 70 KCtSoKOV Y] $£ CJEpYftlKY] EV fXEpEl, $10, 70V Ctb\lVCt70V ECJCtt 

Ttpu)7cv TXVftct 7Y\g ev fxepet Ttpo7ctTeoog ctv7icjpct(peiTY]g' el y) ctTtcMt^ig. v7tctpx £T ^ yctp to fxev B 7T«,vt< 7u>Y, 70 $e 

ydp 70 A 7TctVTi 700 Y, 70 <^£ Y 7tv) 700V B, TO A 7lVi A £V^£%£Cr^ 7tv) 7U.Y fXY} V7tCtpX& v ' CtVctyKY] t\r\ 70 A £V- 
TWV B £V$£X£7ctl. KCtl Ei Ttpog 70 B Y 7£$£iY[ 70 KCtftoKtS, 35 MxEoS^l 7tv) 700 B fXY[ V7tCtpX^ V ' 8* 7*^ TTCtVTl 700 B TO 
C0TCtV7Uig. CfXCiOOg frs KCtl Sl 70 fXSV AT CJEpY]7lK0V EtY[, 70 A V7tCtpXEt e\\ CtVctyKY]g, 70 t¥s B 7rc£,VTt 700 Y KElTctl VTtCtp- 

h\ B r KctTctcpctTiKcv' Ecjctt yctp TtctKtv 70 7tpoo7ov Txvptct X elv ■> T ° A Tictn) 7uj Y e\ ctvatyKYig vTtctp^Et' t«to yctp 

tftCt 7Y[g CtV7iCjpC(pY\g. £1 t¥ CtfX(pC7£pctl CJ£pY]7lKCtl 7£$£iYiTctV, M&ElK^Ctl 7tpC7SpCV. CtKK' V7tEKEl70 71VI EvMx^Cti f^Y[ 

v) fXEV KCt$0K0V Y[ t¥ EV fXSpEi , t\i CtVTOOV fXEV TOOV EiKY]fX- V7tctpX^ V ' 

10. ij C. II Toy] ncti ro-j C. II 11. 7rpirspov x /3 Y- ^tttsov C. II l4. Ttparzpoi C. II 16. ro 8k] xocl ro C. II 18. x*VJ hi^ xx\ 
C. II xct\-B omi. II 19. lv&&Kr&u C. II 20. B iMxoiro Tt<Mr\ C. II .21. rw /3 C. II 23. Uv-te8<SJw C. If 26. B v<m\ r$ C. II. 
27. ri BY els tffi&M&u C. II 32. nv\ r£v C. II ik. ™ C. II 35. r£i AB. II 38. reflJffjy C. 

5. Xevxcs A. II 10. ov nou] if C. II 12. twti t<2 T ivfcx,(<rdu C. II l4. ru C. \\ 16. fv om A. II 31. fau I cuXA. B. II 
34. extr. r'v\ rui /3 hM%z<iQu.i C. 



40 ANAATTIKHN nPOTEPftN A. 

"Otav <f dcftoptcjot vj ev fxepet Kv\<pSuirtv dfxcporepctt, (porepoov t« ev^xsoSctt xctt v t« vnrctpx^ ^cjctt <rvKKoyi- 
ovk ecjau rvKKoytrfxog. dTrccfei^ig <Y v) ctvrv) v) kcu ev roTg rfxog, kcu orctv ro fxev cjepv,rtK0V Kv,<pSvi ro 6% Kctrctcpct- 
KctSoKov, kol) <ftd roov ctvroov opoov. tikov, dvctyKcuov cYe ro KctrctcpctTiKov. orctv Se ro cjepv\TtK0V 

11 Et cY ecj)v vi fxev dvctyKcttct roov nrpoTctreoov v\ cY iv- dvctyKcttov, Kcttro rvfXTrepctrfxct ecjcttrk fxv)v7Tctpx s tV o ydp 

^evou/v)!, K&rviyoptKOOv /xev ovroov roov opoov dei t» evcfex^- 5 ctvrog rpoTrog ecjctt TY\g cfet^eoog kcu kooSoKh kcu fxv, KctSoKov 
oSctt ecjcu rvKKoytrfxog, orctv <Y v, ro fxev Kctrv\yoptKOv ro roov opoov ovroov. dvctyKv, yctp cftct tS %poorov rx^ctrog re- 
3e cjepvfztKOV, edv fxev vj ro KctrctcpctTiKov dvctyKcttov, tk ev- KetxrScti rovg rvKKoytr/xovg, oocje KctSctTrep ev eKetvotg, kcu 
(Yex^oSctt fxv) v-KcLpx^tv, ectv <Ye ro cjepv\rtKov, kcu t« evc\e- eiTi rovroov ctvctyKcuov rvfX7Tt7netv. orctv fre ro cjepv,riKOV 
Xeo-Qctt fxv) v-Kctpx^v Kctt t» fxv, v-Kctpx^tV t« cY e^ ctvcty- KctSoKov Kv\<pSev reSyj nrpog ro eKctrrov ctKpov, ectv fxev ev- 
XY,g /xv) VTTctpxztv \sk ecj-ctt rvKKoyirfxog, o%rnrep icY ev rolg io cfexofxevov, ecjctt rvKKoytrfxog cftct TY,g dvricjpopY\g, ectv <Y 
erepotg rx^ctrtv. ecjoorctv cty Kctrv\yoptKOi nrpoorov ol opot, ctvctyKouov, ovk ecjou. <\etxSv,rerctt cYe rov ctvrov rponrov ov 
Kctt ro fxev A irctvrt roo T VTTctpx^oo e^ civctyKV\g, ro c\e xctt ev rotg Kct&oXov, Kcti (ftct roov ctvroov opoov. (pctvepov 
BtwT irctvrt evhx^Soo vTtctpx^tv. eTret «v ro fjoh A Txctvrt ovv Kctt ev rovroo roo crxY\!^ctTt itore Kctt 7tu>g ecrctt <rv\Xo- 
ru r dvctyKYi, ro cfe V rtv\ tw B evMx^ctt, kcu to A ytcr/joog, xcti Trore t« ev^x^oSctt Kctt irore ri vTrctpx^tv. 
rtvt roo B evcfeXofJoevov ecjctt Kcti &x v7rctpxov' «tw yctp 15 <^Xov tfe xcu ort irdvreg drekeTg, Kctt ot/ reKetovvrctt $tcu 
cvveTrtTTTev e.7Xt t» Trpoorov <rxVf*-°orog. hfxotoog <fe <feix^o-e- t» irpoorov crx^f^ct-og. 

tctt Kcti el ro fjoev BT reSet^ ctvctyKctTov , ro <5e A T ev- c/ Ort ftev ovv ol ev rovrotg rotg crxYif^ctTt <rvXkoyt-13 

frexofjoevov. 7rcL\tv ecroo ro /joev KctrvryaptKOV ro cYe crepv\TtKOV, crfjuo) reXet^vrctt <ftct roov ev tw Trpooroo <rxY\ftctrt KctuoKov 
civctyKct7cv <Ye ro Kctrv\yopiKOV' kcu ro fxev A evc\ex^oSoo [xv\- crvXXoyto-fxoov Kctt etg rovrovg civctyovrctt, ov\Kov eK roov et- 
frev) tw r vTTctpx^tv, ro 8e B Trctvri. vTTctpx^oo e^ civcty- 20 pv\fK,evoov' ori <Y ct7rKuig irdLg crvWoyicrfXog ^roog e^et, vvv 
KV\g. ecrctt cfvi TTctXtv ro Trpoorov crx^f^ct' kcu yctp v) crepv,- ecrctt (pctvepov, orctv (fetx&y Kctg ytvofxevog cfia, rovroov rtvcg 
tiky) Trporctrig evMx^bctt r^fjoctivei. cpctvepov ovvori ro rvfx- roov crxKf^ctroov. 

ixepctrfjoct ecrctt ev&exofLevov ore ydp xroog exotev ctt irpo- 'Avctyxvi <$v\ nrcXrctv ctTXocfeifctv Kctt Trctvrct rvWoytrftov 

rctretg ev roo Trpooroo rXYif^ctrt, kcu ro rvfXTrepctrfxct v\v v\ virctpxov rt v, ftv, virctpxov (feiKvvvctt, Kcti Ttrov, KctSokov 
evcfexofJosvov. el <Y v\ crepY\Tixv\ Trporctrtg dvctyKcttct , ro rvfx- 25 v, Kctrct fxepog, ert v, <feiKTtKuig v, i£ vTroSereoog. rk <Y ejr 
7repctrfJ0ct ecjctt kcu on evcfex^ctt rtvt fjov) V7tctpx^tv kcu oti viroQereoog ftepog ro cftct t« ctovvctrov. irpoorov ovv etTroo- 
YXV7rctpx s i- x-strSoo yctp toAtw T fxvj V7rctpx s tv e'% civcty- fxev nrept roov cfetKTtKoov' rovroov ydp cfetx^vroov <pctvepo\ 
xv\g, ro <Ye B rrctvrt bMxzoScu. dvrtcjpctcpevTog ovv rov B ecjcu Kctt e-irt roov etg ro dovvctrov Kctt oKoog roov e^ vtto- 
T KooToupctriKV ro Trpoorov ecjctt rx^f^ct, Kctt dvctyKcttct v) Sereoog. 

cjepYjTtKYi TrpoTctrtg. ore cY iroog etxov ctl Trporctretg, rvve- 30 E/ ^ <feot ro A Kctrct tk B rvWoytrctrSctt v, vTrctp- 

ficttve ro A too T kcu evcYex^Sctt rtvt fxv) vTrctpx^tv kcu fxvi X ' *! H^ V7rctpxov, dvctyKY, hctfteTv rt Kctrct rtvog. et jxev 
v7Tctpx £ iv, oocje Kctt to A too B dvctym rtvt fxv) vTrctpx^v. «v to A Kctrd t» B KvjCpSetY,, ro e^ dpx^g eqctt e\\v,fx- 
orctv cfe to .cjepYiTtKov reSv, nrpog ro eKctrrov ctKpov, edv fxev fxevov. et 0% Kctrct ri T, ro <5g T Kctrd fxv^evog, fxv,$' 
evfrexo/Aevov, ecjctt rvKKoyirfxog fxeTctKY\<pSeirv,g t>5? nrporct- ctKKo Kctr eKetft, fxv,c\e Kctrct rt A erepov, i&etg ecjctt 
creoog, xctSctTrep ev roTg irporepov, ectv <Y dvctyxcttov, ix ecjctf 35 rvKKoytrfxog ' roo ydp ev xct&' evog KY,<p$Y,vctt ovcYev rvfx- 
kcu yctp TTctvrt dvctyxvj xct) ifrev) evb^ex^ctt vTrctpx^tv. opot ficttvet e£ dvctyKV,g. oocje 7rporKY\7rreov kcu erepctv irporct- 
T« TTctvri vTTctpx^tv vTTVog-tTrTrcg KctSevcfoov- ctvSpooTTog, rov rtv. edv fxev ovv Kvi<p$Y\ ro A koot' ctKKov v\ ctKKo Kctrd 
[xvfievi vTrvog- tTnrog eypv,yopoog - txvSpooTTog. ri A, v, Kctrd tk T erepov, elvctt fxev rvKKoytrfxov ovcYev 

'Ofxotoog <Y efcet kcu et fxev KctSoKti roov opoov <Y KOoKvet, Trpog /xevrot ro B cvk ecjctt <Ytct ruv etKvifx/xevoov. 
ev fxepei nrpog ro. /xerov Kctrv\yopiKoov fxev yctp ovroov dfx- 40 ovcY orctv ro T ere^pop, K^KeTvo ctKKoo, Kctt txtc erepoo, fxv\ 

i. aopitroi A. II 13. ru V om SC II 20. tuh AB. I! ■7rot.n\ tu 7 v7rocp%(roj C. II 25. to\ xx\ to C. II 28. 7tttn\ tS 7 hte%z- 
nhtu C. II 29. x*i} x*\ 7*p C. II 31. x&\ prj ut«'p%eiv om A. II 32. xod om C. II 37. tov Sk fj.rtfcn C. 

5. xa\ stctfleXou om pr C. II x.oc\ fjir) y.a,SoKov om AB et pr C. II lh. lv&%rrow C. II 18. T&eiovncti Te cjia) BC. II 19. ayov- 
rcu- A, II 26. fiipos ic;\ tc C. II 27. tovtuy «jdp fcixQevTw om C. II 31. rj fjcr) v7Ttt.p%oi om pr A. II 33. c% to a, y.XTtt) C. II 
35. ts C. 



ANAATTIKGN nPOTEPftN A. 41 

cvvct7rrYi <5e Txpcg to B, «<$"' hto><; £<px,< 71730? to s B <rvK- Qecreoog. e\ $e tkt' dKvfieg, 7xa,<rctv dTxdfreifyv Kcti Txdvrot, 
Koynrfxog tk A. oKoog yctp eiTxoftev otl ifreig ov$£txote ecrcti rvKKoyLTfxov dvctyKY\ y(ve<r$cti fod rpiuv roov 7xpoeLpv\fxevoov 
cvKKoyLTfxcg dKKv ko,t' aAXou fxv\ Kv\<p$evrog rivog fxe- crxAf^ctroov. rovrov be feixfievrog Sv\Kov oog outxck; re <rvK- 
<rov, o 7xpog eKoorepov l%« ixoog ra,7g KLtrv\yop(ctig' b fxev KoyLVfxog einreXeircu &<* t» Txpoorov <rxAf*,a,Tog kcu dvdr 
ydp <rvKKoyL<rfxog dwKug Ik 7xpcra,<reoov eq-iv, b oe nxpog 5 yercu e\g rovg ev rovroo kcl$o\x <rvKKoyL<rfxovg. 
rocfe <rvKKoyL<rfxog eK rodv Txpog rofrs itporcvreoov , 6 be rib^e Etl re ev ouna,vTL fre? KctTY\yopLKOv riva, roov %poov eT-2& 

Txpog ro&e fod rodv Ttfre nxpog rocfe 7xporct<reoov. dbi/vctrov fre vcu kcu to ko,$oKov vTxdpx^' ctvev ydp t« ko,$oKov y) 
rxpog ro B Ka,@e7v ixporcvrLV fxv\bev /XY\re KctTv\yopovvrctg vk ecjcu <rvKKoyL<rfxog v) i irpog to Keifxevov, v) ro eP-dp- 
auT« fxv\r' dTxocpwfxevovg , v\ TXctKiv t« A ixpog ro B fxv\- x%$ ctLTY\<rerctL. Ke(<r$oo ydp rvjv fx\s<rLKv)v v\cfovY)v eTvcu cttxv- 
8ev kolvov KctfxfBoovovrctg dKK' eKctrepov Tbia, drra, ko,ty\- 10 frctLctv. el fxev «v dfyoocreiev v t cfovY\v etvcu tr7x\sc\ct(ctv fxv) ixpo<r- 
yopovvrctg v\ d7xa,p\vfxevovg. oocfe \v\7xreov ri fxecrov dfxcpolv, Seig ro Txdrctv, vk eqa,i <rvKKoyi<rfxdg' el <% rivd Yjfrc- 
o <rvva,^peL rdg KctTv\yop(ctg , eTxep eg-cu rifre Txpog rofre trvK- vy,v, el fxev dKKv\v, ibev Txpog ro Ketfxevov, el <? a,VTv)v 
Xoyio-fxog. el w dvctyKYj y,ev TJ X&fislv ixpog ct/xcpco kolvov, to,vtv[V, to efc dpxA$ Ka,/J.i3dvei. jxdKKov tfe y(vera,L <}>a,- 
tkto <^' iy^/^eTct: rpixoog {v\ ydp ro A t« T kcu to V vepov ev ro?g 6 K La,ypdfx/j,a,<rLV , oTov ori t« lcroo-KeXovg Tcrcu 
V6 B Ka,Tv\yopv\<ra,vrcig, v\ ro T ko,t' dfxcpolv, v\ dfxcpoo 15 a,t rxpog rv\ i3a,<rei. ecjoocrctv elg to Kevrpov v\yju,evcu cu AB. 
Kctra. tk r), tolvto, cf' ecjL rd elpY\fjciva, crxKf^ctra, , cpa,- el ovv t<rv\v \a,fJL-&a,voi rvjv AT yoovLctv ty\ BA fxv) okoog 
vepov ori Txavra, <rvWoyt<rfj,ov dva,yKY\ y(ve<r$a,i Slo. tovtoov dfyoocrctg 1<ra,g rdg roov y\jj,lkvkXloov , ko,l txo,Xlv ty,v T 
Tivog roov <rxv,f/,a,Toov. d ydp covrog Xoyog kcu el hd TxKeL- rv\ A fx,r) 7xd<ra,v 7xpo<r\a,fioov tv)v t» Tf/,v\fxa,rog, eri o 
ovoov <rvva,7xroL Txpog to B' tccuto ydp ecjctL <rx^l^ Xct ' d^x' i<roov icroov rodv %Xoov yoovioov ko,i T<roov d<pvipY\f/.evoov 
eTXi roov txoKKoov. 20 T<ra,g eTvcu rdg \oL7xdg rdg EZ, ro e^ dpx^S curv\<re- 

"OrLfAv ovv ol cfeLKTiKo} 7xepa,(vovra,L frid roov 7xpoeipv\[A,e- to,l, edv fxv) Xct/3>j d^xo roov T<roov i<roov dcpcupovfievoov 
voov cxvif^oiroov, fpcivepov' ori <Je kcu oi e\g ro dc\vva,rov, %v\- \<ra, \eL7xe<r$a.i. <pa,vepcv ovv otl sv o,7xo,vtl c\e7 ro ko,$o\ov 
Kov ecjcu fod r4roov. ixdvreg ydp 01 cfid ri dbvvdrM Txepai- vTxcxpx^v, kocl otl to y,ev kocSoKov e\ d7xa,vroov roov "opoov 
vovreg ro fxev •pev&og crvKKoyti^ovrcu , ro cf e^ dpx*is ^C, ko,$oKov cfeLKvvra^i, ro &' iv fxepei kcu vroog xoxt&otf, oocf 
v7xo$e<reoog cfeLKVvxcriv, orctv dcfvvctrov ri <rvfx$a,(vv\ TY\g dvri- 25 eccv fxev v\ ro <rvfX7xepa,<rfxa, ko,$oKov, ko,l rovg opovg dva,yKY\ 
(pdreoog re$e(<rv\g, oTovotl d<rvfxfxerpcg v\ b^Lctfxerpog c^lo, to y(- ko,$oKv eTvcti, ectv cf ol opoi ko,$oK\s, ev&exsrou ro trvfXTxe- 
ve<r$ctL rd Txepvxrd Tcra, roTg dprioig cvfxfxerp^ re$e(<rv\g. ro fxev pcto-fxa, /xv\ eTvoll ko.^oKv. bv\Kov &e koll otl ev a,7xa,vri crvKKoyL- 
ovv Tcrct y(ve<r$cu rd Txepvrrd roTg dpr(oig crvKKoyLXsTctL, ro o-fxoo v\ dfx<porepctg v\ rv\v erepctv Txporctriv ofxo(a,v dva,yKv\ y(ve- 
&' do-vfxfxerpov eTvcti rv)v ^dfxerpcv ejr V7xo$e<reoog tfeLKVvvLV, <r$ctL r£> <rvfX7xepa,<rfxa,TL. Keyoo cV k fxovov roo Ka,rct<pa,TLKV\v 
£7xei 'pevcfcg <rvfx(Ba,(vei hd rv)v dvrL<pa.<riv. t«to ydp v<v 30 eTvctL v\ <r-epY\TiKY\v, dKKct kool too dvocyKouctv v\ v7xapx^^oiv v\ ev- 
to hd t« dbXivctrov <rvKKoy(<ra,<r$a,i , ro cfe?^a,( ri dcfvvct- hex^^vv^v. e7XL<rKe\pct<r$<ti cfe freT Kcti rctg a,KKa,g KctTY\yopictg. 
rov fod ty)v ejfc dpxhs v7Xo$e<TLV. odcf e7xe\ t« ^evc\avg y(- ^ctvepov be kccl dTxKoog txot ecjcti kal txot ovk ecrcu 

verctL crvKKoyLcrfxog freLKTiKog ev roTg e\g ro dcfvvctrov dTxct- <rvKKoyL<rfxog , ko,l txots biivctrcg ko,l 7xore reKetog, Kcti ort 
yofxevoLg, ro & ejfc dpx^S e£ v7xo$e<reoog b^eiKWTcti, rovg cfe crvKKoyLcrfxv ovrog dvctyKcuov e^eiV rovg opovg Kctrct tiva 
freLKTLKcvg Txporepov eLTxofxev otl bict rcvroov 7xepct(vcvrctL rodv 35 roov e\pv\fxevoov rpoTXoov. 

crXAf^otroov , cpctvepov otl kou ol fod tou dbvvdrov <rvKKo- Av\Kov cfe kou %tl Txdcra, dTxcb^eL^Lg eqctL b^Lct rpLoov opoov2S 

yLcrfxoL foot, rovroov erovrou roov cxvi^oltoov. oo<ra,vroog <% kou & 7xKeLovoov, edv fxv\ <w ttKKoov ko,l a,KKoov ro ctvro 
Kcti o\ ctKKcL TXctvreg o\ e^ v7xo$e<reoog' ev dTXctcrL ydp b <rvfX7xepct<rfxct y(vv\raL, olov ro E cfict re ruv AB KctL olo, 
fxev <rvKKoyL<rfxog yiverau Txpog ro fxerctKctfx^aovdfxevov, ro twvTA, v) <W twv AB kou BT* 7xKe(oo ydp fxira, roov 
$' 'e\\ dpxyg 7xepct(vera,L b~T bfxoKoy(ctg v\ rivog dKKv t g vtxo- 40 ctvroov cvcfev eTvou kooKvel. tovtoov &' ovroov &X «S ctKKct 

2. tou a, omAC. II thrufitt B et pr A. II 7. tsVS* <W pr B. II 12. U A. II 15. *a,Tr\«joa-!\<Ta,nz<; C. 16. <pa,vspcv »y cti C. II 
18. ei om pr C. II 36. <f>ocvepcv Sv trti B. 

2. ruv rpiSv C II 6. tcv opov B. II 7. 7*p ctv t« C II 8. ■Kpov.iipviov C. II 10. Ttpoi^ B. II. 12. 7rponetf4.svov G II 16. Aoty*- 
/3*v£i C. lP 18. 5' om AB. II 21. alterum fow om A. II 39. *jQ **\ *7 xa,\ 1Q7 C. II 40. W c - 

F 



42 ANAATTIK&N nPOTEPftN A. 

Ttkeiovg etriv ot rvkkoytrfxoi. r\ 7taktv orav iKarepov tujv AB KctTct ju-ev ovv ra,? Kvpiag TtpoTaretg kafxfiavo/xevujv 

$td rvkkoytrjxov kricp$r\, otov 10 A cftd toov AE Kat Tta,- tuv rvkkoytrfxujv, drtag ecrai rvkkoytrfxog ex. itpoTareujv 
kiv to B Sta tuiv Z 0. r\ to /xev eTtayuiyy , to Se rvkkoyt- fxsv dpriujv e£ Zpuiv cYs TteptTToov' ev\ ydp Ttkeiovg o\ opoi tujv 
rfxoo. dkkd ko.\ ovruig Ttkeiovg 01 rvkkoyirfxof 7tketui yap Ttporareuiv. ecrat cYe xcu ra rvfXTtepdrfxara r,fxtrr\ toov Ttpo- 
rd rvfXTtepdrfxaTct ecriv, olov to Te A kcu to B xcu to Y. 5 Tareuiv. oTcty cYe cftd Ttporvkkoytrfxuiv Ttepaivrrtat v\ cfta 
el cY ovv fxrj Ttkeiovg dkk' eTg, outw fxev sv^xerat yever$at Ttkeiovuiv fxsruov /xrj rvvsx^v, oTov to AB cftd tuiv Y A, to 
cftd 7tkei6vuiv to ai)To rv/XTteparfxa, uig Ss to Y frta. tujv /xev 7tkY\$og tuiv opuiv uravTuig sv\ V7tepe%et rdg Ttporareti 
AB, dcfvvaTov. s<rru) yap to E rvfXTtsTteparfxsvov sk tuiv (y\ ydp e^ui$ev v\ elg to fxerov Te$Y\rerat 6 7ta.pefX7tt7tTuiv %pog' 
ABTA. ovkHv avayKY\ ti avruiv akko Ttpog akko e'tkY,cp$at, dfxcporepuig cfe rvfx^aivet ev\ ekdrtTui etvat rd hacrr\fxaTcu 
to fxev oog okov to cY oog fxepog' tkto yap SehtKTat Ttpo- 10 tuov opuiv), a\ cYe_ Ttpordretg "trat rolg c\iacrr\fxartv' « fxevroi 
repov, oTt ovTog rvkkoytrfxov avayKatov VTuig Ttvag exetv de\ cu fxev dpTtcu srovrat 01 cYs TtsptTToi, a}^k' svakkd^, 
tujv opuiv. e%eTO) ovv to A VToog Ttpog to B, ecrtv apa ti e£ oto,v fxev a\ Ttepordretg dpTia,t, 7teptTTo\ 01 opot, qto,v cY ot 
oovToov rvfX7tepa,rfxa,. ix,ovv rrtot ro E y\ toov TA $a,repov y\ opot aprtot, TteptTTat a,t 7tpordretg' clfxa, ydp tuj opui fxta. 
ctkko ti Ttapa, TO.VT0,. Kctt et fxev to E, eK toov AB jxo- 7tpocrt$eTa,i Ttporartg, dv o7to$eviv 7tpocre$Y\ opog. uocf eitei 
vov av ert\ rvkkoytrfxog. to, &e T A el fxsv e%ei ovruig oocr' 15 a,t /xev dprtcu 01 Se 7teptTTo\ wav, dvdyKv\ 7ta,pa,kkdTTetv 
elva,t to fxev oog 'okov to cY oog fxepog, 'ecrcu Tt kcu e^ e>cei- TY,g amrfi 7tpor$ereoog ytvofxev^g. rd c^e rvfX7tepdrfxa,Ta, VKeri 
voov, ko,i y\toi to E y\ Toov AB $ortepov y\ a,kko tl Ttctpa, ty\v o,vty}v ejret ra%tv xts Ttpog rovg opovg «Te Ttpog rdg Ttpo- 
TctvTct,. ko,i et fxev to E 1] toov AB $a,Tepov, y\ Ttketovg erov- rdretg' evog ydp "opov TtpocrtSefxevov rvfX7tepdry.a,T0, 7tpo- 
Tcu 01 rvkkoyir/xoi, y\ oog eve<Je^eTo to-uto bta, 7tketovoov cje$Y\rera,i ev\ ekdrToo toov TtpovTtapyJmuiv "opuov' Ttpog fxovov 
opuiv 7tepcuver$a,t rvfx(3a,tvet ' el <? a,kko Tt 7ta,pd tclvto,, 20 ydp tov erx^rov & Ttote? rv/x7tepa,rfxa,, itpog <fe Tovg a,k- 
Ttketovg 'erovTcu kcu drvva,7tTot 01 rvkkoytrfxot Ttpog dkkv\- kovg 7ta,vTa,g, oTov el t<2 ABT 7tporKetTa,t to A, ev$vg kcu 
kovg. el $e fXY\ KToog exot to Y 7tpojg to A ooere itotelv rvk- rvfX7tepa,rfxa,Ta, frvo TtporKetrat, to re Ttpog to Ako,\ to Ttpog 
koytr/xov, fxa,TY\v e<ra.t e\k-/\fXfxeva,, et fXY, e7ta.yooyr i g r\ Kpv- to B. ofxotoog Se Kdrn toov dkkoov. ko,v etg to fxerov Se 7tctr- 
ipeoog y\ Ttvog dkkov toov rornToov %a,ptv. el cY sk toov AB pe/x7tt7tTri , tov o,vtov rpoTtov' Ttpog eva, ydp fxovov i 7totr\ret 
fxr\ to E dkk' ctkko Tt ytvercu rvfX7tepa,rfxa,, s.k S~e toov 25 rvkkoytrfxov. oocre 7tokv Ttketoo rd rvfX7tepdrfxa,Ta, kcu toov 
Y A y\ tovtuiv $a,Tepov r\ a,kko Ttapa, toZto,, Ttkeiovg re o\ 'opuov ecrat kcu toov Ttpordreoov. 

avkkoytrfxot yivovrcti kcu v t» vTtoKetfxevv ' inteKetTo yctp 'Exel cY exo/xev 7tep\ uiv 01 rvkkoytr/xot, kcu Ttolov ev2S 

etvctt t» E tov rvkkoytrfxov. et cfs fxv\ ytvsrctt sk tuiv Y A fXY\cfsv sKdcroo r%^ctTt ko\ Ttoraxoog Mkvvtcu, cpavspov Y\fx7v ecr) 
rvfXTtepctrfxa,, fxa,Tr\v re elkr\<p$a,t ctvra, rvfx^cttvet Kctt fxr\ Kctt Ttolov 7tp6fikr\fxa, xctkeTtov kcu Ttolov eveTttxetpriTov' to 
t« e^ dpxr\g etva.1 tov rvkkoytrfxov. oocrs cpctvspov tat Ttara, 30 fxsv ydp sv Ttksiort r-xy\fxa,rt kcu Std Ttkstovoov TtTdorsuiv ite- 
ditoSst^tg Kctt Ttag rvkkoytrjxog scrcti cftd rptoov opuiv fxovov. pcttvdfxsvov paov, to cY sv skdrrort Kcti cft' skctTTovcov cfvre- 

T«TOD cY QVTOg CpctVepOV, SqkOV Uig Kctl Ik SvO Ttpo- TtlX^P^OTSpoV. TO fXSV OVV KATCtCpCtTlKOV TO Kct$6k0V fod T« 

Tctrsuov Kctt » 7tkstovoov o\ yctp rpsTg opoi cho 7tpoTctrstg, sl Ttpunov rxvfxctTog SsiKvvTctt fxovss, ko,\ Siatovtov fxova,x%S' 
fXY\ TtporkctfxfictvotTQ , Kct$a7tsp ev Tolg sjr dpx^ eksx$'f\, to cYe crepr\TtKov c\td re t» Ttpoorov Ka\ Std t» fxerov, Ka\ 
Ttpog ty,v Teketuinv tuov rvkkoytrfxuiv. tpavepov w uig sv u> 35 cYtd fxev t« Ttpoorov /xovaxug, cftd cfe t» fxerov Stxuig' to n 
koyoo rvkkoytcriKUi fxr, aprtai elrtv a\ Ttporaretg h' oov yi- cY ev fxepet KaTacpaTtKov Std t« TtpuoTov Kctt Sta t« srxd- 
vsTat to rvfXTtsparfxa to Kvptov (evta yap tcov avui$sv rv/x- rov, fxovax^g f^ev cftd t« Ttpuorov, rptx^g Se Std tS erxd- 
TteparfxaTuiv avayKatov etvat 7tporaretg), ovrog koyog r\ tov. to cfe crepY\TtKov to Kard fxepog ev artart rolg rx^fxan 
« rvkkekoytcrai r\ Ttketui tuiv dvayKatuiv Y,puiTr\Ke itpog rr,v cfeuvvrai, 7tkr]v ev fxev tui Ttpuoroo aTta^, sv cYs too fxsru) 
» e<r " / « 40 Kctt too srxctroo ev tuj /xev Stx^ eV tw cYe Tptx&g. cpave- 

6. 7(W5ou C. II 9. alterum aX>.s om pr AB. II 14. powv C. II 21. TrXifa re honu C. II oi om AB. II 26. tvto Mt. B. II 
28. T«] to A. II 31. ftsw C. II 34. ixixh om A. 

11. «i ph om A. II 27. xm Ttolov— 28. ^iV \<;\ om A. II 30. rocis tstJxsiw lilteras titui corr B. II 36. Ka.r<*.<pMty.h y.oc\ 
M B. 



ANAATTIK^N nPOTEPflN A. 43 

pov ovv on ro xa,$okov xa,rr,yoptKov xarta,<rxsva,<rai fxsv x*- Ae? <5*7 ra,g Ttporarstg rtspt eKacrov outw? iKka./xfidvetv, 

ke7tcora,rov, dva,<rKevd<ra,t <Ye pacrov. okcog <Y icrtv dva,tpwri v7Co$e/xevov ctvro Ttpoorov koci rovg bpto-fxovg re xal "o<ra, "tha, 
fx\v ra) xaSoKov rcov ev fxepei paoo' xa,i ya,p r,v fxr\frevt xa,i rov Ttpayfxartcg icrtv, etra, fxerd rovro 'otra, e-nei a,t roo itpd- 
r\v rtv) fxr) vTra,px$-> dvr\pr,ra,t' rovrcov <5e ro fxev rtvt fxr\ iv yfxartt, xa,) 7ta,ktv otg ro Ttpayfxa, dxokttQe?, xa.) %<ra, fxr) 
<%7ta,<rt ro?g crx^^t &£txwra.i, ro be fxr,cf£vi iv ro?g <fv<rtv. 5 iv<fs'xera,t ocvrop v7td,pxsiv. oHr <Y ojvto fxr) ivc\sxsra,t, ovk 
toV a,vrov <Ys rpcTtcv xd,7rt rwv crsprrttKCov xa,t ya,p et Ttavrt £Kkr\7tT£ov c\ta, to dvTtcrpicpEiv ro crepr\rixov. b~ta,tpereov cYe xcu 
kcu el rtvi, dvr,pr,ra,t ro e£ dpx^' tkto <Y r,v iv ovo <rx^r rcov eTtofxevoov ora, re iv rco rt icrt xct) o<ra, oog 'icfta, xa,) otra, 
fxa,<rtv. £tx) cYe ruiv iv fxipEt [xova,xwg, h 7ta,vrt r) [xy\$svi frst- oog <rvfA(3e{3r,Kcra, Kartr,yops?Ta,t , xa.) tovtcov txoIo, cfo^a.crtxoog 
Pccvra, vixdpx^' xa,rarxevdXovrt cYe paco ra) iv fxspet' xa,i xa,t 7to?a, xa,r' dkr\$eta,V o<rco fx£v ydp a,v Ttketcvoov rotovroov 
ya)p iv 7tkeio<rt <r;£»f//t£t<n >tctl frta) 7tketovoov rpoTtcov. okcog re 10 svTtopr, rtg, $a,rrov evrevfy.ra.i <rvfX7tspa,<rfxartt , r o<rco <f ctv 
ov $£1 ka,v$dvstv oti dva,rKsvdra,t fxev oY dkkr\kcov scrt xa\ dkr\$scrspcov , fxcZkkov OtTtobetfcei. bet <f exkeyetv fxr) t* e7ro / - 
ta) xa,6okov cfta) roov ev fxlpu xa,t TaZra. frta, roov xa,$okov, fX£va, rtvt, a)kk' otra, okco rco 7tpa.yfxa,rt £7t£Tcu, otov fxr) ri 
xa,ra,<rK£va,<ra.t <Y ovk tcrt frta) roov Karta) fxepog ra) KO.Sok^ rm cLv8poo7tco a,kka, rt 7ta.vrt a,v$poo7too e7tera,f bta, ya)p toov 
o^i' EKetvoov <fe ra,vr ecrtv. 0,/xa, <5e b^kov ori xa,) ro a,va,- xa,$okov 7tpora,<recov 6 <rvkkoyt<r[xog. db^toptcrov fuev ovv ov- 
xrxevaXetv ecr) tk Ka,ra,<rKevaX s etv pciov. 15 to? a,<fr,kov et Ka,$okov r, 7tpora,<rtg, bioopio-fxevov <Te <pa,vepov. 

Iloog /xev ovv ytvera,t 7ta,g <rvkkoyt<r[xog ko,i bta, Ttoroov bfxotoog <Y £Kk£Kr(ov xa,t otg a,vro e7tera,i okotg, cfta, rr,v el- 
opoov ko,) 7tpora,<recov, Koct 7toog exov<rcov Ttpog a\kkr,ka,g, ert pr,fxevr,v a,\ria,v. a,vro <$e ro £7tofX£Vov ov kr\7tTeov okov eTte- 
o% Ttolov Ttpo$kr,[xa, h £ko,ctco cr^yjyw-ctTi Ka,t Ttolov h 7tk£to<rt <r$a,t, kiyco <Y olov'a\v$pco7too 7ta,v XJ*>w r\ f/M<rtx^ 7ta,<ra,v ETtt- 
xa.) Ttotov sv £ka,TT0<rt b y £iKwra,i, br]kov ek roov £tpr\[X£vcov. <rr,fxr,v, dkka, fxovov dxkoog cLKokov$£tv, xa,$a,7t£p xoot Ttpo- 
21 7toog <Y EV7topr,<rofXEV a,vro) Ttpog to tiSsjxevov de) <rvkkoyt- 20 T£tvo[xs$a, ' xctt ya,p a,p^pr\<rrov Sxrspov xa,t db\iva,T0V, otov 
<r[xoov, xcCt fod itotxg ofrov kr,^po[X£$a, ra,g Ttspt EKaocrov dp- 7ta,vTa, a,v$poo7tov sTvxt 7ta,v ^uiov r\ <\tKO,to<rvvr\v a,7ta,v dya,$ov. 
%d,g, vvv r\b\ kexrEOV ov ya)p [xovov \<rcog <5e? rr\v y£V£<rtv dkk' oo eitETXt, £7t' sksivov ro 7txvTt ksysra,i. ora,v <Y vTto 
6ecops?v rcov <rvkkoyt<r/xoov, dkka, kcu rr,v b s vva,[xtv e%eiv tou rivog 7t£pisxrira,t ro v7toKst[X£vov S> rd eTtofxeva, fre? ka,fie?v, 
TtctE?v. ' ra) fxkv roo Ka,$okov ETtofxsva, *j fxr, eTtifxeva, vk eKkeKreov sv 

'h.7td,vrcov bS\ roov ovtcov ra, fxev ecrt rotaZra, oocre ko,to, 25 Ttrotg (e\kY,7tra,i ya,p ev eKetvotg' ora, ya,p Xuco, ko,) dy- 
fxrifrevog a,kkov Ka,rr,yope?<r$a,t dkr,$cog Ka,$okov, otov K.keoov ftpco-itco EitET&t, ko,i ora, fxr\ intdpx^h co<ra,vrcog) , rd be 
xa.) Kxkktxg ko,) ro ko,$' eKoccrov xctt a,l<r$r\Tov, xoora, b~e Ttep) exa,crov 'tfoa, kr,7tr£cv scrt ya,p drra, rco eic^ei fcfta, 7ta,pa) 
rovrcov oXkka, (xa,) ydp a,v$poo7tog xa.) XJuov exartepcg rovroov to ysvog' dva,yxr\ ya,p to?? ETspoig £i<f£<riv 'tcfta, cltto, V7ta,p- 
kcrt)' ra) <Y a,vrd fxkv xari dkkcov Ka,rr\yops?ra,t , Karta, <5e X eiV ' ovoXe W T< ? KO,$okov IxkEXTEov oig s7tEra,t to TtEpi- 
rovroov dkka, TtporEpcv » xa,rriyope?ra,i' ra, b~e xa,t a,vra, ctX-30 e^o^o-evov, otov X^cpco ctg e7tera,t a,v$poo7tog' dva,yxr\ ya,p, el 
koov xa.) a,vToov erepa,, otov a,v$poo7tog K.a,kkiov xa,t dv$pco7tov dv$poo7tcp dxokov$e? ro XJ^ov, ko,i rovrotg a,7ta,<rtv dKokov$e?v. 
X^cpov. ort fxev ciiv evta, roov ovrcov ko,t ovcfsvog 7t£tpvK£ Xeye- otKEtoTEpa, o^e roovra, TY\g t« dv$pco7tov exkoyr\g. kr\7tr£ov 8s 
<r$a,t, tirjkov' roov ya,p a,\<r$r,rwv <rx^ov £KO,crov scrt roi&rov xa.) ra, cog £7tt ra Ttokv ixofxsva, xa,t ctg ETtsrat' roov 
oocrs [xr\ KO,TY\yops?r$a,t Ka,ra, [xyfisvog, 7tkr\v cog Karta, <rv/x- ydp cog ex< to 7tokv 7tpo$kri[xartcov ko,i <rvkkcyt<r [xog 
|8ejSv])to?" <f)o,[X£v yap TtorE tg ksvKov eke?vo ~%coKpa,TY\v Etva,t 35 e>c tcov cog i^tt rc Ttckv 7tpoTa,r£Cov , v\ 7ta,ruiv r\ rtvoov' o/xotov 
xctt to Ttportov TLa,kkia,v. ort o^e xa,t ETtt ro a,vco 7top£vo[xevotg ydp ixdcrcv ro <rvfX7ttpa,<rfxa, ra,?g dpx<*?g. erzt rd 7tc2<rtv 
lcrarai TtcTE, Ttaktv ipovfxsv vvv <Y scrco tkto kei[xsvov. ko,to, iTtofXEva, «>t e>t^e>tTeov' » ydp Ecrat <rvkkoyt<rfxog e^ avroov. 
fxsv ovv tovtcov ovk srTtv dit ob^sl^at Kortriyopcvfxsvov ETspcv, <\t r\v <f a,\ria.v , iv ro?g iTtofxsvotg scrat br]kov. 
Ttkyv et [xr, xxto, b^o^a.v, dkka, raZra, ko,t' aXkcov b&s ra, 'Ka,Ta,<rK£va,X > Etv [xsv «y fiovkofxsvotg kcoto, rtvog ckov 28 

xaff EKacra, ko,t dkkoov, dkk' erepa, Kort 'eKsivcov. rd <Ye 40 t« /xev KXTa.<rKEva,Xa[xsvtf ftkeTtTeov tk rd v7toKsi[X£va,, ko,$' 
fXETa^Qj br\kov cog dfxcpcripcog iv^exerxt' xa.) ydp avrd kotc oov avro rvyx&vet keycfxevov, » <Ye c\e? KO,rr,yope?r$a,t, otra, 
■ukkcov koa dkka, ko,to, rcvroov. kex$vrsTa,i, xa,) srxsbov ct tstco ETtsTXf dv ya,p rt rircov r\ toajtov, dva.yxr\ Sarspov 
koyot xat a,l FKSipEtg e\o~i fxaktcra, itept rovroov. $a,Tspcp vTtdpx^- W bs fxr, "crt 7ta,vrt dkk crt rtvt, olg sits- 

1. to otn A. II 10. Iv om C. II 3'1. koltI om A. I! 35. o-awjMt/ni B. II 43. 7rsp v ( tvtuv eidl fA.dXnra, C. 
10. m om C. II 11. u.\i\fc<;Epov pr B. II 13. r( rut 7r*vT» C. II 39. y-h ora A. 

F2 



U ANAA¥TIK&N nPOTEPflN A. 

icli SKOLtspov' el ya,p ri tovtoov tolvtov, dv&ym tivi v7ra,p- to K.T v\ etg to T fxovov. el fxev ya,p raK2 v7rcLpX £ <- to 
Xeiv. otciv Se fxv\Sev\ &ev\ vTrdpx^ ■> § f* £V » $e? V7ra,px £tv , A, kcu tw Z koa too E V7ra,px £ i' « $£ tovtoo fxv) ettstcu, 
etg Tct STrofxsva,, o <5"e <$s? fxv) v7ra.px £tv -> «V * /*-*? eV<$e;£eTcu eyx^pe? too Z e7reo-$ou. ofxotoog $e kou e<p' oov ccvto ako- 
dVToo 7ra,pe?va,t' v\ dvcL7ra,ktv, u fxev $e? fxv\ v7ra,px £tv -> * Xtf^e? <r>ce7rrsov' e/ fxevyap To?g TrpooTotg, kcu T0?g vir' eKe?va, 
fxv) ev$e'x£Tcu covtoo 7ra,pe?va,t, o ^e fxv) V7ra,px £ tv, e\g Tct 5 E7reTO,t el be fxv\ TMTotg, dkka, To?g vttq tcwto, syxups?. 
ETrofxsva,. tovtoov ydp ovtoov toov ojvtoov oTTOTspoovovv, ovfrevi Av\kov <Je kou oti cfta, toov Tptoov opoov -koa tuiv 8vo Trpo- 

ev&xeTcu $a,Tspoo $a,Tepov V7ra,px £ tv' yivsTOU ydp ots fxsv o Ta,osoov v\ Q-KS-^tg, kcu $td toov 7rpostpv\fxsvu)V <rxY\fxcLTjOv o/ 
h too TtpooToo <rxYifxa,Tt o-vkkoyto-fxog , oTe <? o ev too fxscroo. o-vkkoyto-fxot 7ra,vTeg. Ssikvvtou ydp V7ra,px £tv (Lev 7ra,vr\ tw 
ectv $e Ttvt fxv\ v7ra,pxstv, oo /xsv fxv) vTrdpx^ •> oTg eWrct/, E to A, oVctv toov T koa Z TctuTov ti kvi<p$v[. thto <f ecrca 
o <Je fxv\ v7ra,pxEW, & fM[ o\)vonov ojvtoo v7ra,px £tv ' « y&p 10 fxevov, aKpa, b% to A KO,t E* ytvsTa,i ?v to TrpooTov Q-x^f^cu 
Ti tmtoov e\v\ toovtov, dvooyKVj Ttvt fxv) vTrcLpxzw- y-aXkov $' Ttvt $e, otolvtoT koa to H \vj<p$v[ toovtov. t«to <^e to etr^cc- 
iTcog co$' ecrou toov Xeyofxevoov eKdcrov <pa,vepov. ecroo ydp Tct tov tr%^//.a* fxecrov ydp to H ytveTou. fxv^evt <fe\ otoov to A 
fxev eTrofxeva, too A e<p' oov B,ojV & oovto eireTat, e<p' oov kcu Z t&utov. xtoo $e kcu to TrpooTov cr^^act kou to fieo-ov, 
r, a, <5e fxv\ ev$e'x£Tou covtuj vTroopx^v, e<p' oov A' 7ra,ktv to fjoev TrpooTov oti ov<fev\ too 7* vTrdpx^ to A, enrep dvTt- 
$e Tui E Tct fxev VTrdpx^TO,, e<p' oTg Z, oTg &' oovto exe- 15 crpstyet to <repv\TiKov, to 8e Z xctVTi ra E, to <5e fxecrov 
Ta,i, e<p otg H, a, ^e fxv\ sv$s'xsTa,t o,vtuj v7ra,px s ^ '■> £<p' oti to A too /xsv A vfrsvt too §e E 7rctvTi v7ra,pxei- Ttv\ <Ys fxv) 
olg 0. et /xev ovv to,vto ti ecrouToov T Ttvt toov Z, ctvcty>c>i Oxct/?%eiv, otccv to A >ccti H TctuToV jj. tovto Ss to etr^ct- 

TO A XCtVTi TOO E V7TO,pXW T° f^V ya,p Z 7TO,VTt TwE, TW TOV CT^/X-Ct * TO fXSV ya,p A 0V$eVL TU H VTT&pfcet, TO $£ 

oe T TrajvTt tw A, oocre 7ra,VTt tw E to A. el Se to T kcu E Tretm tw H. (poovepov ovv oti <Jict toov 7rpostpv\fxsvoov 0"%»]- 
to H TctuTov, ctvcty>c>j t/v< toov E to A v7ra,px elv ' T( ? fxsv2Q fxa,Toov ot Q-vWoyto-fxot 7ra,VTeg, ko,i oti ovk eKkeKTeov ccrcfc 
ya,p r td A, too <% H to E 7rctVTi dKokov$eZ et Se to Z vrcio-tv s7rera,i, hd to fxv\8sva, y(vs<r$a,t o-vWoyto-fxov s£ a,v- 
kou to A TctuTov, ovfrevi toov E to A tJ7rct^ej e>c 7rpoo-vKko- toov. KO.TO.o-KsvaXetv fxev ydp okoog ovk y\v Ik toov eTrofxe- 
yto-fxov' e7re) yct|3 dvTtcrpepet to crepvfctKov kooi to Z tw A voov, dTrocrepetv &' ovk ev&xstcu frtd tov 7ra,o-tv eTrofxevov' 
TO.VT0V, ov^evt tuiv Z UTTct^ej to A, to <fe Zi ira,VTt too E. t^e? ydp too fxev VTrapx^ too Ss fxv] vTrdpx^. 
ira,kiv s\ to B >cou to TctuTov, v$ev\ toov E to A V7ra,pfcet ' 25 Qoovepov <Je kou oti oa dkkou o-Keypeig toov Kcnd T&S 

to yap B Tu> /xev A 7ra,vrt, to <¥ e<p' Z to E ovfrev) V7ra,p- htkoydg ct^ejoi Trpog to Trotelv Q-vkkoyto-fxov, oTov el Ta) 
%ef TcivTo ya,p v\v tu> 0, to <fe ouo^evl toov E V7rv,px^. eTrofxeva, eKO,Tepu) toovto, eo-Ttv, v\ et oTg e7reTcu to A, >ccti 
el <fe to A >ccti to H TctuTov, to A tzv) t<Sv E »% U7rct^ei* ct fxv\ eV&%eTctj tw E, y\ oq-o, irdktv fxv) syxoops? SKonspoo 
tuj yoop H oi>x VTra.p^et, oti ovSe twA" to Se H eV<v u7ro u7rct^e{V ov ydp ytveTou o-vkkoyto-fxog <5ict toutwv. el fxev 
to E, oocre tivi toov E ovx V7ra,p^et. el S~e tw H to B Tctu-30 ydp Tct eTrofxeva, toovtoo, oTov to B >tctt to Z, to fxe<rov 
■tov, dvTecrpoofXfxevog ecrou crvkkoyto-fxog' to fxev yoop H tw ytveTou o-xhfxa, KcoT-^yoptKdg e^ov TctV TrpoTcLo-eig' el fr' oTg 
A vTra.p^et 7ra,vTt (to ydp B ™ A), to <5e E tu B (TctuTo E7reTou to A, kcu a, fxv) evMx^Taut too E, oTov to T kou 
ya,p v\v twH)" to ^ A tw E TrctvTz fxev ovk dva,yKV\ V7ra,p- tq 0, to TrpujTov o-xVfAO, <repv\TtKv)v e^ov tv)v nrpog to ekciT- 
X £tv * 7tvl &' dva,yKv\ frta, to dvTtcrpecpetv ty\ KO,$okov ko,tv\- tov oLKpov TrpoTooo-tv. el &' oo-a, jxy) evoYxsTou SKOLTspoo, oTov 
yoptco tv\v kojtoj fxspog. 35 to A >ccu to 0, cr£pv\TtKcu dfxcpoTspcu a,t 7rpoTO,o-sig, v) iv 

^avspov ow oti stg to, 7rpostpvjfxsva, (Bks7TTsov sKO/rspv tuj TrpooToo v\ sv too [xsq-oo o"^/x.ctTi . VTOog <¥ i<fa,fxoog ovk- 
KaA' EKcicrov 7rpo(Bkvifxa,' <ftd tovtoov ya,p a,7ra>vTsg ot o-vk- koyto-fxog. 

kOytQ-fXOt. <}s? 3s KOA TU)V STTOfXSVOOV, KOU oTg ETTSTOJl EKCUTOV, Av\kOV <& KOA CTl 07T0?Oj TCtUTCt X»J7rT/oy Tct >CCtTCt Tv)v 

sig Tot 7rpu)Ta, kou Tct Ka,$okov fxa,ktcra, jSXe7re/v, otov tov sTrto-Ker^tv , >cctl ovx OTrota, ETspa, v\ £va,vTta,, 7rpooTov fxev 
fxev E fxojkkov etg to KZ y\ e\g to Z fxovov, t« <Je A e*V40 oTi tou fxerov x<*P iV V entfike^ptg, to Se fxerov *x erepov 

3. o Vk corr A. II b%fT»u A. H 4. rf om pr B. II 5. l\ M fitj C. II 6. cmripur/ AB. II 9. ^ p}] ph M corr B et 

pr C. II 17. txIw C. II 26. tq <y C. II 27. v ri B. II 29. tnrdpfri ro a. ln C. II 31. jj-h om C. II ij] t AC. II 32. xnrdpxa 
C. II Ta /A,h 7*p C. II /3 9fftyr\ t«.'jto C. II 34. t^i xccfioAy x&Trryopiou t^v B. 

9. xcu T'Xi Z, C II 13. xou ro X[ C. II 14. ro jwev] kou to ph C. II 23. tSv 7r*<riy brofjLdui B. II 26". o\%p£ioi C. II 38. ori om 
ABC. II TutuTft AB. II t<». om corr C. II 40. 'nrio-xtr^v; C. 



ANAATTIKftNnPOTEPftNA. 45 

dKKa) Tolvtov &sT KctSsTv. elrot ev oo-otg xou <rvfx(2a,(vet yi- otz ovcfev) ra E to A V7ra,p£et. TraJKtv el htKTtKoog <rvKKe- 
ve<r$ou <rvKKoyt<rfxov tu> Kvicp^^va.i evoovrta, v\ fxv) evbsxofxeva, Koytcrou :o A tw E fxv^svi xjTrctpx^v, v7ro$sfxevoig inrctp- 
Tw ctvTto vTrdpx^v, £ is r °vg 7rpoetpY\fxevovg d,7ra,vra, cLva,- x siv Ttvt frta) tov d\t\)va.Tov Setx$no-eTa,i ovt\ev) V7ro,pxov. 
X$y\TeTO,i TpoTrovg, olov et to B ko,i to Z eva,vTta, v\ [xv\ bfxotoog 8e ko,tt) toov dKKooV ev 0.7x0,0-1 ya)p d\vayKv\ Kotvov 
iv^XeTcti tco ojvtoo vTva.pxetv* eo-tou fxsv yap tovtoov Kv\- 5 T tva, Ka,(3s7v "opov aiKKov toov vTroKstfxsvoov , Trpog ov scrou t« 
(p$evToov <rvKKoyt<rfxog %ti i&svi toov E tq A v7ra.pxet, a,KK' ^pevfrovg <rvKKoyt<rfxog, oott' d\vTt<rTpa,(ps(<rv\g Ta,vTv\g ty\$ 
ovk e\ amoov a,/\K eK tov nrpoetpv\fxevov Tpoirov' to ya,p B -rpoTa,<rsoog, tv^ 8 eTspctg bfxotoog EXov<rv\g, t\stKTiKog scrou 
too fxev A ~ra,vTt too t\s E it\svi vTta.pfcsi, uicr' d\va,yKY\ toajto <rvKKoyi<rfxog foa, toov oajtoov opoov. Stoupspst ydp 6 $st- 
sTvoot to B Ttvi tujv 0. nra,Ktv e't to B kou H /xvj syxoopsT KTtxog tov slg to a\t\)va,Tov, "oTt ev fxsv tw t\etxTtxod xa,T 
tw oajtuj Tro.pelva.1, oti rtvt toov E ovx vTtdp^ei to A" xou 10 d\Kv\$eta,v dfupoTepou Tt$evTOU a,i 7tpoTO,<retg, ev tfe too elg to 
ya)p ovTtog to /xe<rov etyoa ir^act * to ya,p B tlo fx\v A d\o\iva,Tov -^pevcfoog v\ fxta,. 

TtOiVTt too &e H av&evt V7ra,p%ei, Sd<-' a\va,yxv\ to B to,vtov T.o.vto, fxsv ovv scrctt fXotKKov (pavepa, bta, toov e7ro- 

Ttvt eTvo.i toov 0. to ya,p fjuv) ev^xsoSa.t to B ko,i to H fxivoov, 'oto,v Trept tov a,$vva,Tov KeyoofxeV vvv <$e to<tovtov 
tu> a,vToo v7ro,px^v icfev hoocps^pst v\ Tci B toov Ttvt to,v- v\fjuv ecjoo 8v\Kov, oti elg tcwto, $KeTTTeov fretKTiKOog T£ |S«- 
Tov eTvou ' iro.vToo ya)p etKv\7rTou t<* y,v} evcfsx°f Ji ' sm T V -^ ^ Ko/uoevoo o-vKKoylX 3 e<rQa,t kou elg to a,<fvva,TOV a\ya.yelv. ev $k 
\)Tta,px £ tv. Tolg o,KKotg o-vKKoyto-fxo7g toT? i^ vxoQe<reoog, oiov 'o<rot 

$a,vepov fxev w oti e% covtoov fxev tvtwv toov eTTtfiKe- kootoo fxeTaSKv^tv v\ kooto) 7toiotv\to,,, ev toTs v7roKetfxevotg , 
ipeoov ovcfetg ytveTcu <rvKKoyt<rfjoog, ectv 8e to B kou to Z «k ev ToTg e^ dpxw *^A' ev ToTg fjLeTa,Ka,fJo(2a,vofxevotg ecrcu 
evccvrta,, toovtov tivi eTva,t to B toov ko.) tov crvKKoyt- v\ o-Ke^tg, b Se Tpo7rog 6 a,vTog t^? E7ri$Ke-^ec>jg. e7rt<rKE- 
Cfxov ytve<r$a,t cfta) tvtoov. <rvfA@a,(vet &vj Tolg ovToog e7rt<rKO- 20 \pa,<rQa,t Se &e? koa cfieKeTv 7ro<ra,x^ ol efc V7ro$e<reoog. 
Trovri Trpo<re7rt@Ke7retv a,KKviv bbov rv\g a,va,yKa.ta,g foa, to AetKvvTO,t fxev ovv eKxo-Tov toov 7rpo^Kv\fJoa,Toov ovtoo? , 

Ka,v$a,vetv tv)v to,vtotv\to, toov B ko,) toov 0. ecrt $e ko,i a,KKov TpoTrov svta, <rvKKoy(<ra,<r$a,t tovtoov, oTov 

129 To\ ctmov cfe TpoTrov sxovcrt kcu ot e\g to o,c\)VO,tov to, ko.^oKx foa, t»;? Karra, fxepog e7rt@ksypsoog s\ v7ro$s<rscog. 

ctyovTsg <rvKKoyt<rfxo) Totg c\stKTtKo7g' koi ya)p ovtoi ytvov- et ya,p to, T kou to, H to,vto, e(v\, fxovotg cfe Kv\<p$e(v\ ToTg, 
TO,t &ta) toov eTrofxsvoov ko,i otg eireTou eKa,Tepov. ko,i v\ o,vty[ 25 H to E V7ra,px £ tv, 7ra,rri a,v too E to A v7ra,pxot' k<*\ 
e7r(@Ke^ptg ev a,fx<poTv' o ya,p beiKWTcu frsiKTtKoog, kcu Sta, ira.Ktv si to, A kou H to,vto,, fxovoov c\s toov H to E kot 
tov dfrvvcLTV scrt <rvKKoyt<ra,<r$a,i cfta) toov o,vtoov opoov, ko,i Tv\yopo7ro, 'oti ifrsvt tuiv E to A V7rd,p£si. (poovspov »v ot* 
o tfta) tov a,c\vva,Tov, ko,) frsiKTtKoog, oTov oti tc A ovfrsvi kou ovtoo? eTrtftKeTrTeov. tov olvtov 8e TpoTrov kou e7r) toov 
toov E V7ra,px^' KSt<r$oo ya,p tivi V7ra,px s iv' ^kovv e7ret to a,va,yKO,(oov ko,i toov evc\exofxevoov v\ ya)p covtyj o-Ke^ptg, kol) 
B 7ra,VTi to A, to 8e A tivi toov E, to B tivi toov E 30 frta, toov o,vtoov cpoov ecrou tv\ Ta,^et tov t svds / xs<r$a,t xou 
VTra.pfcet' a,KK' ov&evi inrvipxsv. 7ro.Ktv oti Ttvt v7ra,px^' f* tou V7ra,pxstv o <rvKKoyto-fj,og. Kv\7ttsov cY efr) toov svcfsx°~ 
yoop [AYibsvi toov E to A, to ^e E 7to,vti too H, ifrsvt toov fxevoov ko.) tci fxv\ v7ra.pxovra, c\vva,To. &' VTrdpx^v,' M- 
H V7ra,p%et to A' a,KKa, 7fro,vri V7rv\pxsv. bfxoioog 8e kou eTrt cfetKTa,i ya,p oTt ko,) foa) tovtoov ytveTOu o tou evc\ex £ o-$ou 
toov ooKKoov 7rpo^iKv\fxaTooV o\et yap ecrcu xa-i ev a,7ra,<riv v\ <rvKKoyt<rfxog. bfxotoog cf e^et xa,) Itt) toov clKKoov koltyi- 
frta, tov a\c%va,TQv c\e7^ig Ik toov eTrofxevoov ko\ oTg e7reT0,t 35 yopioov. 

tKarrepov. ko,i ko,$' eKcurov 7rpo(2Kvifxo, v\ o,vty\ <TKv\/tg %et- §o,vepov ovv ek toov elpv\fxevoov ov fxovov oti eyx^T 

XTtKoog Te fixKofxevoo <rvKKoyt<ra,T$a,i KO,t elg a\§vva,Tov a\ya,- frta) Ta,vTv\g t^? bc\ov y(ve<r$cu 7rd,vT0,g Tovg <rvKKoyt<rfxovg, 
yeTv sk ya,p toov ojvtoov opoov a\fX(poTepa,i a,t a,7roc\ > e(£stg, oTov a\KKa) kou %Tt bt' a,KKv\g a\bvva,Tov. a.7ra,g fxsv ya)p <rvKKo- 
el t\et\eiKTO,t fXYi&ev) V7ra,px^tv too E to A, otj <rvfx$a,(vei yt<rfxbg M&sikto,i tftot Ttvog toTjv 7rpoeipv\fxsvoov <rxv\/xdToov yt- 
xa,i to B Ttvi toov E V7ra.pxetv, OTrsp d\fruva,Tov ea)v Kv\(p$Y\40 vofxevog, toZto, tv' ovk eyxoopeT frt' a,KKoov <rvtra,$Y\va,i 7rKv\v 
Too fxev E [XY\hv) tu> 0l A 7ro,vTi V7ra,px^v to B, (potvspov foa) toov e-irofxevoov kou otg e7reTou eKctcroV ex tovtoov ya)p 

3. lit<M Ivctx^atTM JB, i-ocvocx^creTou A. II 8. T*i5rev C. II 9. xxi to ij C. II i^/xutfi A. II 10. xoti <y*p] ko.1 7<*p K«i C. II 
12. 1] £ pr B. II 18. \fo h%\ «raVl 0% d B. II 21. 7rpa£7n/2A£7re<v AB. II 24. 7*p] 7*p xaX C. II 26. imo-xe^i? in' C. 

3. tiv^ om AC. II 8. piius om C. II 12. ^ewfp&n-ep* C. II l4. t*ut* corr C. II 20. M om A. II 26. tu)] to A. II pom C. (I 



46 ANAAtfTIKftNIIPOTEPfiNA. 

Ctt TTpOT&VElS KCt) V\ TOV fterOV kvr^tg , OOcf CU<$£ CTOkkoyi- ftrftog, KCtl YjTTOV dst EtVCtl KCtt ftv) KCt$6k0V TOV TpooTOV 

crftov iyxoopE? yivsr$ctt cV ctkkoov. twv ctKpooV v\ h\ c\tctip£rig t&v&vtiov (BvKetcu' to ydp koo- 

30 'H fth ovv bhog Kctrct Tctvfoov v) ctvTvi kou 'itept tpi- 6okov kctftfictvet fterov. ecroo ydp Tpoov ftev etp' ov A, to 

korotpictv kcu Tept T£%v^v b-nrotctviv Kctt ftct$Yift<t' c^eT yctp cfe Svyitov e<p' ov B, kcu d$dvctrov etp' ov F, b tf av$poo- 

Tct vi~ctp%ovTct Kcti ot~ vTctpxei Tzpt EKctrTOV d$pe"tv, Kctt 5 7rog, « tov koyov cfeT kctfizft, zcp' « to A. ct-rctv bv] TJ*>ov 

T6Toov oos Tkzicroov evTopetv, Kctt TctvTct cftct toov rptoov 'opoov kctftfictvet v\ 6vy\tov vj dSctvctTov' tovto t¥ ecrtv, o ctv vj A, 

CKOTelv, dvctrKevctTpvTct ftev ooot, KctTctrKZVctCpvTct oz ooot, ctTctv zTvctt v\ B v\ Y. TctKtv tov dv$pooTOV cie) h^tcttpiftevog 

Kctrct ftev dkv,$etctv ek toov koot' dkvfiztctv cftctyzypctftftzvoov TtSsTctt Tpoov sTvctt, oocre KctTct tk A to A kctft&dvet vTctp- 

VTctpX £lv -> £ ' l $ <& ™? foctksKTtKvg rvkkoytrftvg Ik toov KctTct %etv. b ftev ovv rvkkoytrftog ecrtv %.ft to A y\ B v\ Y ctTctv 

frohtv TpoTct<reoov. ctt cf ctpx&t toov rvkkoytrftoov Kct$okov 10 ecrctt, oocre tov ctvSpooTov v\ $vyitov ftev v\ d$dvctTov dvcty- 

f/Jev eipviVTcti, ov TpoTOV T exovrt Kctt ov TpoTov 8e? $vipev- kcuov eTvctt, TJyov Qvy\tov cfe ovk dvctyKcuov , cikh' cthelTctt' 

etv ctvTctg, 'oToog ftv\ fikeTooftev e\g ctTctvrct Tct keyoftevct, tovto cf' v\v o 'ecfet crvkkoyi<rct<r$ctt . kcu Tciktv Sepoevog to 

ftYicf e\g TctvTct KctTcto-KevctCpvTeg Kctt ctvcto-Kevctfyvreg , ftv^e ftev A ^wov $vv t Tov, e<p' ov cfe to B vtotovv, etp' x>v fie 

KctTcto-KevctCpvTeg Te KctTci Tctvrog v\ Tivog Kctt dvctrKevctCpv- to Y dTovv, tov cY dvSpooTov to A, oocrctvToog kctftftdvei 

teg dTo TctvToov v\ Ttvoov, dkk etg ekctTToo Kctt oopto- ftevct, 15 to ftev A yitoi ev too B y\ ev tu T eTvctf {dTctv yctp Zpoov 

HCtS' EKCtCTTOV cfe EKkiyeiV TOOV OVTOOV, OtOV TEpt dyctQoV Y[ SvYlTOV V) VTOTOVV Y\ CtTW eCTl) , KCVrd C% TOV A TO A (TOV 

kTt<ry\ft%g. ISict cfe KctS' eKctcrvy elriv ctt Tkelcrctu $to Tctg ydp ctv$pooTov TJuov Ovyitov eTvctt ekctfiev) ' oocr' vtotw ftev 
fxkv dp%dg Tdg Tept eKctcrTov EftTEtpictg scrt Tctpctbovvctt. v\ ctTovv sTvctt Zpoov dvdyKY\ tov ctvSpooTov, vtotovv cY ovk 
ksyoo $' oTov ty]v d<rpokoytKv]v ftkv eftTetpictv t^? dcrpokoyt- dvdyKY,, dkkd kctft^ctvet' tsto cf v\v o ecJei Tdktv cfeT^ctt. 
yjYfi eTicrYiftYig' kvitpQsvToov ydp tKctvoog ruiv <pcttvoftevoov vroog 20 Kcti tovtov <$v) tov TpoTov ds\ cftcttpovftEvotg to ftkv KctQokx 
EvpeSvirctv ctt dcrpokoyiKct) dToSei^stg. bftotoog &s Kctt Tspt <rvft(2ctiv£i ctvrolg fticrov kctftfidvEtv , Ktt$' ov <y' zcJzt bzlfccu 
ctkkyv oTotctvvv z%zt Te%v^v te kcu eTtcryftYiV. oo<r' edv kycpQy kcu rdg cftctcpopdg aKpct. Tekog §{, "oti tovt' scrtv dvQpooTog 
-rd vT&pxovTct Tsp) EKctcrov, viftzTzpov v\b\ Tdg dTobzt^ztg v\ o Tt tot dv yj to TviTOvfJuevov , x$ev keyovo-i crctcpzg, oocf 
sroiftoog zatpctvTCztv. et ydp ftYicfh Kctrct ty { v tcropictv Tctpct- dvctyKcttov eTvctf kcu ydp ty]v ctkkviv bfrov toiwtcu xatrctv, 
ketpSeivi toov dkviScTig vTctpxovroov To7g Tpctyftct<rtv, s^oftev 25 ovc% Tdg evcfsxo usmg evTopictg vTokctftfidvovTeg vTdp%etv. 
Tep) aTctvTog « ftev ecrtv dTocfeifyg, TctvTYjV evpelv Kctt dTo- tpctvepov cf oti »t' dvctcrKevdcrcti TctvTY\ tv\' /u.e$6S'op ecrtv, «T£ 
SetKVvvctt, « <fe ftv) T^tpvKev dTohtfyg, t«to Totztv tpctvzpov. Tzpt o-vftfizfiyKOTog vi tcfiov <rvkkoyi<rcto-$ctt , ovrz Tzp) ye- 
}Lct$6k\i ftev ovv, ov cfet rpoTov Tctg TpoTctcretg eKke- vxg, «t' ev olg dyvoerrctt to Torepov 6o£e vj oob^e e%et, oTov 
yetv, eipv { Tctt <r%eh6v cY dKptftztctg cfz cftzkv\kv$ctftsv ev tyi cip v\ htdfterpog drvftfterpog. edv ydp kdfiv\ oti axctv 
vrpctyftctTeict tyj Tzpt ttjv cftctkzKTiKYiV. 30 ftv,Kog v\ crvftfteTpov v\ dcrvftfterpov, v) 8e cftd/uoeTpog ftY,Kog, 

31 v Oti <Y v\ hd toov yevoov &icupe<rig fttKpov Tt ftoptov o-vkkekoytcrTcti oti d<rvftfterpog v\ crvftfxeTpog v) frtdfte- 

ecrt Tv,g e\pviftevY,g fteSofrov, pctfrtov lh7v zcrt ydp v\ foctips- Tpog. et cfz ky-pzTctt dcrvftfxzrpov, o z&zt <rvkkoyi<rcttr$cti, 
trtg olov d<r$svYJg crvkkoytrftog' o ftzv yctp oz? ^zi^ctt ctt- kY,'*pzTcu. ovk ctpct ecrt cfeYjrctt' v) ftzv ydp b<$6g cvjtyi, frtd 
*re"tTctt, o-vkkoytCpTctt <$' dei Tt toov <tvoo$ev. Tpoorov cf ctvTo TctvTYig cf' ovk ecrtv. to dcrvftftzrpcv yi crvftftzTpov ztp' ov 
tovto skskviSst Tovg xpooftsvovg ctvTYi TctvTctg, Kctt T£t$£iv35A, ftv,Kog B, hctftZTpog I\ tpctvzpov VV OTt ovtz Tpog TCt- 
ETzy/tpvv oog ovrog cfvvctTov Tspt ovcrtctg dToo^st^tv yivscr$ctt crctv ctkz-^iv dpftoCet Tvig "Cv,TY,creoog b TpoTog, »t' ev oTg ftdr 
Y.ctt tov t/ ecrtv. uxr' ovTe 6 ti evcfz^eTctt <rvkkoyirctcr$ctt ktcrct S~0Ket TpzTztv, ev TovTotg e<r) -xpvirtftog. 
btcttpovftevot ^vvierctv, ovre oti ovroog zvz<$z%zto uirTzp z\- 'Ek Tivoov ftzv ovv ctt dTocfsi^stg yivovrctt kcu Toog, 

pViKctftsv. sv ftsv ovv TctTg dToh^zi^zrtv , otolv cVvj ti rvkko- KCtl z\g OToTct fikZTTZOV KCt$' EKctcrov Tpo(3kY,ftct, tpctvEpov 
yirctr$ctt vTctpxstv, cfsT to ftsrov, h~t' ov yivsTctt b rvkko- 40 ek toov E\p7,ftsvooV Toog <f dvct^oftsv vtg rvkkoytrftovg £ig32 

5. Ixotrepsy ABC. II 12. vcLna, C. II 13. clItoL A. II v-aX a.va.cry.s-jaX^ovTZi; om A. II 17. S"k y.ctl ■/.&$' JS et pr C. II 19. o\<?pov"- 
uay.v/ -C. II /j-h om C. II t?i pr C II olcrpsXo^ixt' STns-r/**!' -dC. II 38. crvviscrM C. II 39- Mipvu ABC. 

16. T 5 5] ri A. II 20. ym om B. II <f< C. II 21. c>' 'iht] h\ fc? C, Sk B. II 28. uh\ B, hi Zes A. II *j ^ om A. II 29. u.^- 
■cc? y G-JuutTfo?. kxv B. II 34. !?-jv] sVt &£(^«i C II to crjnixzTooi rl a.o-j/j,ixcTpo)i C. II 35. B] k(p' ov /3 C. II 7] 'tf>' oZ' 7, a /3 7 C. 



UfTi 



ANAATTIKftNIIPOTEP&NA. * 47 

70, 7rpoetp'/ifxeva crxy/JLciTd,, keKTeov av etr\ fxera ravra' KaTY\yopY\ kou KaTr\yopriTai ro y,e<rov, r\ avro fxev KaTY\* 
konrov ydp ert tovto tJj?' o~Ke\peoog. ei yctp rr\v re yeveo~tv yopr\, akko <T ejcsjvh d~rapvr\Tat, to Trpoorov e~~at o~xyifj,a,' 
7oov <rvkkoyt<ry,oov $eoopo7yev Kat tk evpio-Ketv exotfxev ovva- sdv 6% KcCt KaTr\yopr\ Kat d~rapvr\Tat diro Ttvog, to fxea-ov' 
fxtv, eTt Se tk? yeyevriysvovg dvakvotfxev eU ra ~rpoetpY\y,eva kav S~' akka eKeivov KaTY\yopY\Tat, v\ to fxev dirapvYfrat to 
cr^ t uaTa, rekog dv e%ot y\ e% dpxvs -rpo$eo~tg. <rvfx{Br,<re- 5 Se K<tTY\yopY t Tat, to ecr^arov. ovtoo ydp et^ev ev eKacjoo 
Tat <V dfxa Ka\ Ta irpoTepov eipY\fxeva e~rt(2e[3aiov(r$at Kai o-fflfxaTt to fxeo-ov. dyoioog Se Ka\ edv fxr) Ka$okov uxrtv 
cpavepoorepa etvat, qti %Tu>g s%£*,. Sta toov vvv kex$'A~"oy,e-- at ~rpoTa<retg' o ydp avrog Stopto-fxog t« y,eo~ov. (pavepov w 
vooV Se? yap ~rav to dkv\$eg avro eavroo dfxokoyovfxevov dig ev oo koyoo y,Y\ keyerat ravTo -rkeovaKtg, oti k yiverai 
etvat 7ravTY\. <rvkkoyto-y,og' « yap etkr\~nat y,e<rov. eire\ S' e-x.oy.ev -rolov 

JJpooTov fxev «v Se? nretpa<r$at ta? o\iq -rpoTacretg eK- io ev eKaqoo o~x J Y\y,aTt -repatverat toov ~rpo(3k.Y\y,aTu>v , koi ev 
kafxftdvetv T6 a-vkkoyto-fxi (paov ydp eig Ta y,ei'(oo ote- jfvt to Ka$okov ko) ev iroico to ev fxepet, (pavepov uig ovk 
ketv y\ ra ekaTToo, fxetCoo Se Tct, <rvyKeiy,eva y\ e^ oov), ek airavTa ra Q-X/^fxaTa fike~TTeov, dkk' hoaqov ~rpofikr\- 
erra o-KOiretv -rorepa ev okto Kat iroTepa ev fxepet, Kat et fxarog ek to otKetov. oo-a &' ev -rketoQ-t irepatveTat, ty\ va 
fxv\ dfX(poo elk.Y\fXfxevat eXev, avrov Ti$'evra ty { v errepav. evtors fxecrov $e<ret yvooptifxev ro o-)$iy,a. 

yap ty\v KaSokov irpoTetvavTeg ty\v ev ravTY\ ov kafxfiavti- 15 UokkaKtg fxev «v a~raTdo-$ai. o-vfX@aivet irept t«? ctuX-33 

o~tv, ovre ypatyovTes ovt epooToovreg v\ ravrag fxev irpoTet- koyto-fxx' ota to avayKatov, uxrirep etpv\Tat -rporepov, evtore 
vovq-i, fo' oov &' avrat -repatvovrat, ~rapaket~rovrtv, akka $e irapd ty]v dfxotoTY\Ta TY\g toov opoov $ereoog' o~rep « p^p*! 
fre fxaTv\v epooTooQ-tv. o-Ke-rTeov oitv et Tt nreptepyov etkY\~rTat kav$avetv v\fxag. olov et to A Kara t« B keyerat Kat ro B 
Kai Tt toov dvayKatcov -rapakekenrTat , Kat to fxev $ereov Kard tov T' So^ete yap av ovroog ep^ovToov toov opoov etvai 
70 &' dcpatpeTeov, eoog av ek$v\ rtg eig Tot? &vo ~rpoTa<retg' 20 o-vkkoyt<ry,og, » yiverat &' »t' dvayKOtov iSev hte Q-vkko- 
avev ydp txtoov kk e~~tv dyayeTv t«? VTOog Y\pooTr,fxevvg ko-~ yto-fxog. tqoo yap e<p' u> A to de\ etvat, e(p' ui &e B frtOe 
yovg. evtoov fxev vv pacftov ifeTv to evfreeg, evtot &e kav$aw<rt vor\Tog' Kpt-~oy,evr\g, to &' e<p' 00 Y ' Kpt~-oy,evr\g. dkr\$eg &y} to 
kou SoKovcrt o-vkkoyi^eo-Sat fod to dvayKalov ti <rvfxfiat- A tw B v~rapx^' det yap e-~t friavoY\Tog ' Kpt-~oy,evr\g. 
vetv Ik toov Ketfxevoov, otov ei kr\<p$eir\ fxr t i<rtag dvatpovfxe- akka Kat to B tco V ' yap ' ' Kpt~-ofxevr\g e~~\ &tavor\Tos 
\r\g fxr\ dvatpel<r$at i<riav, e^ oov fr' e~~tv dvatpovfxevoov, Kat 25 'AptcrofxevY\g. tq &' A tu T ovx virapx^' (p$aprog yap 
70 Ik tovtoov (p$eipeo-$at' tovtoov yap reSevroov dvayKOtov lo-Ttv ' A.pto~Toy,evY\g. ovk apa eyivero o-vkkoyto-fxog ovtoos 
/xev to icriag fxepog eTvat Wtav, « y,r\v <rvkkekoyt~-at frta exovroov toov cpoov, dk>l efret Ka$okov rr\v AB kY\<p$Y,vai 
7oov eikvifxyevoov , dkk' ekkeiirovo-t ~rpoTa<retg. Traktv ei dv-- -rpoTao-tv. tHtq 8e \pevS~og, to djrtovv iravra tov havoriTov 
$poo~rov ovTog dvdyKr\ XJuov etvat Kat l^coov iriav, dv$pcoir\i ' Apt~~oy,eyY\v de\ eTvat, <p$apri ovrog ' Aptqofxevovg. iraktv 
GVTog dvayKY\ xo-iav eTvat' dkk' xttoo o~vkkekoyt--ai' » yap 30 ecjoo to fxev e<p' u> T MtKKakog, to &' e<p' u) B fxovTtKog 
£%«<nv a\ -rpoTaretg oog eiirofxev. d-raTooy,e$a 6* ev Tolg rot- MiKKakog, e<p' oo ^ to,A to <p$eipe<r$at avptov. dkr\$e<; 
YTotg &ta to dvayKOtov ti <rvy,^aivetv e.K toov Ketfxevoov, oti Sr\ to B t« T KaTY\yope7v d yap MtKKakog ecjt y,ovo~tKog 
Kat c (rvkkoyto-fxog dvayKatov e~~tv. eirt irkeov Se to avay- MiKKakog. dkka Kat to A t« B' <p$etpotTo yap dv av- 
KaTov v\ Q-vkkoyt<ry,og' d y,ev yap o-vkkoytrfxog irag dvay- ptov fxovtrtKog MiKKakog. to &e ye A t» T -^eZ&og. t«to 
koiov, to <>' dvayKoitov i irav o-vkkoyto~fxog. ucr' xk el Tt35o\ Tamov eqt too irpoTepov i yap dkr,$eg Ka$okx, MtK- 
<rvfx(3atvet TeSevroov tivoov, iretpaTeov dvayetv ev$vg, dkka Kakog fxovo-tKog oti (p$eiperat avptoV tovtov <& fxr\ kr\- 
irpuiTov kri~TTe'ov tcc? 6\io ~rpoTao-etg, ei$' xtu> btatpeTeov eig (p$evrog vk y\v o~vkkoyt<ryog. 

Tovg opovg, y,(<rov Se $ereov toov opoov tov ev ay<poTepatg Avrr\ fxev ovv r\ d~raTr\ yiverat h tw irapa fxtKpoV 

7a?g ~rpoTa<re<rt keyofxevoV dvayKr\ yap to y,e<rov ev dfx- ug yap ovfiev foa^pepov eiirelv rofre roo&e v~rapx £iV V T0 " e 
(pore^patg v-rdpxetv ev airao-t rolg o-^^actfrtv. edv fxev ovv 40 TcZSe rrravTt vrrapx^i <rvyx^p^y^v. -rokkaKtg 8e oictyeu-34 

2. Tfl"ro to Hfi AB et pr C. II 11. p<*»o/ ABC. II 12. &VJ uv <-v*jxeitcu corr A. II 14. rtQivou C fortasse corr II 16". te ypci- 
<porre<;— 17. -T-pcttyorrxi rc supra lituram A. II 21. dwyovyw B. II 25. p;] ovx C. II 33. dvx^xoclo? C. II 34. itccpuuo- C. II 38. rui 
opuvj tov opov C. 

3. x<t,Tvrjopoii\ ABC. II 4. c\ti ■ccpw -<u A. II 8. \(*f\t<m AC. II rax/Tov C. II 17. 6(<rsuis tuv cpuv C. II 21. A] to a, A. II 26. cb 
•folp BC. II 29. atptg-o{ji.(vfi B. 



48 ANAAtfTIKGN nPOTEPHN A. 

&e<r$ctt <rvfX7re<re?Tcti irctpd to fxrj KctXcog eKTi$e<r$ctt tovs \cov r\ d/xotoog to te TrpcoTov tk fte<rov Kctt t«to t» eV%ct- 

HctTct Tr]v irpoTcttriv op\sg, otov el to fxev A e\r\ vyietct, to tov. Kctt eiti t« /xr\ v-nctpxeiv tf' corctvTcog. d\\\ o<rctx^i 

^' i<i>' w B voo-os, etp' u tfe Y ctv$poo7rog. d\r\$eg yctp el- to eTvctt XeyeTctt Kctt to d\r\$eg e'nre7v ctvTo tSto, Tocrctu- 

ire?v oti to A ovtfev) tco B ivtfex^Tctt vTrctpx^v (ovtfefxtct Tctx^ ofe<r$ctt XP^ o-r\fXctivetv Kctt to virctpx^v. oTov oTl 
ydp vd<rco vyietct v7rctpx £ 0-> **' '<rct\tv oti to B TrctVTi tco 5 twv evctvrioov ecjt fxict e7rtcjr\fxr\. ecjco yctp to A to /xictv 

r vTctpX £l (kcZ? ydp dv$poo7rog tfeKTtKog voo~ov). tfo^etev ctv eTvcti e7r tcjr\fxr\v , Tct evctVTict d\\r\\otg etp' ov B. to tfr\ A 

ovv <rvfxfictivetv fXY\tfev) dv$poo7roo evtfe'xso-$ctt vyietctv virctp- too B virctpx^ °^X <*>$ Tct hctvTict, to [xictv eTvctt ctvToov 

X eiv ' tovtov tf' cUTtov to [tY[ Kct\oog eKKe?<r$ctt Tovg opovg e7rtcjr\/xr,v , d\\' otj ctX.Yi$eg elTcetv KctT ctvToov fxictv eTvcti 

XCtTCt TY[V X/^iV, £7Tgl [XeTCt\r\tp$eVTCOV TCOV KCtTCt TCtg e^eig CtVTOOV e7TtCjr\fXY\V. 

»x ecyctt <rv\\oyi<rfxog, oTov cLvti [tev Tr]g vyteictg et Te$eiv[ 10 'Xv/xfictivet tf' oTe fxev eTrt tov [xe'<rov to irpooTov \e- 

to vytcttvov, ctvTi tfe Tr\g vo<rov to vo<rovv. cv yctp d\r\$eg ye<r$ctt, to tfe fxerov eVl tou Tpirov fxr) \e'ye<r$ctt, oTgv el 
et7re?v cog \sk evcfe'x£Tctt tw vo<tovvti to v vytctivetv vTrctp^ctt. r) <rotpict ecj)v e.7rtcjr\fxr\, tk tf' dyct$\s ecj)v r\ <ro<pict, crvfx- 
t&tov tfe fxr] \r\<p$evTog « yiveTctt <rvXKoyt<r[tog, el [xy\ t« 7repct<r[tct oTt t» ctyct&v ecjtv e.7rtcjr\[XY\' to /xev ^ dyct$ov 
£Vt^eX£o-$cti' tovto <y' ovk ctfrvvctTov' evbexeTctt yctp [XY\oevt ovk ecrtv hrtqr\[XY\, v\ b\ <ro(pict ecjtv e7rig-r\[xr\. ot\ cVe to 
ctv$poo7rco vTrctpx^rv vyietctv. TrctKtv eTrt tv [xerov o-^/x-ctTo? 15 /xev [xetrov e%t tk T^)iT« KeyeTctt, to &e nxpooTov etrt tk [xe- 
o/xoicog ecrctt to ^pev&os' Tr\v yctp vytetctv vocrco fxev bfrefxtct <rov ov KeyeTctt, oiov el tov 7roiov TrctvTog ecrtv e7rtcjr\fxr\ v\ 
cLv$poo7rco $e irctVTt ev$e'x£Tcti virctpx^rv, uxr' tscfevt ctv$pco7rco evctvTK, to &' ctyct$ov Kctt evctvriov Kctt Trotdv, <rv[X7repct<rfXct 
vdtrov. ev cfe tw Tpfrco crx^^Ti KctTct to evc\exe<r$ctt crvfx- /xev oti t» ctyct$^ ecjtv e7rtcjrifxrj , wt eqt b\ to dyct$ov errt- 
fictivet to ^evfrog. Kctt yctp vyietctv Kctt vd<rov Kcti e7rtcrr\- cjr\fxr\ iSe to ttoiov «&V to evctVTtov, dXKct to dyct$ov TctvTct. 
fxr\v Kctt ctyvotctv Kctt okoog Tct evctvrict tw <xvtco evfrexerctt 20 icjt c% ote fxrfre to Trpcorov KctTct t« fxeo-t* fxr\re t»to KctTct T» 
V7rctpx eiV '■> dWr\Xoig fr' dchvctTov. tSto ^' dvo/xoKoyovfxevov TptTif, t« 7rpcoT\s KctTct t» T^iTK OTe fxev Xeyofxevts oTe Se fxr) 
ro?g 7rpoetpr,fxevoig' oTe yctp tco ctvToo irXetco eveoV^eTO VTTctp- Xeyofxevov. oiov el ov e7rtcjr,fxri ecjiv, ecjt t«t» yevog, tk &' 
X^iv, evit\exeTo k<x) dXXr\Xoig. dyct$^ ecjtv e7rtcjY\[XY\, <rvfX7repct<rfxct oti tk dyct$H ecj) yevog. 

Qctvepov «v ot< ev d7rct<rt TtTotg r) ctxct t>j yiverrctt nrctpct KctTr,yopeiTcti £' ovt^ev Ktvr' ovfrevog. et cy' ov ecj)v e7rtcjr\fxr\, 
Tr]v tcov %pcov e.K$e<rtv' fxeTctXr\<p$evTcov yctp tcov KctTct Tdg 25 yevog ecj) tovto, t» c^' dyct$v ecjtv e7ricjr\[xr\, <rvfX7repct<rfxct 
zfcetg «<5ev yiveTttt \pevtfog. br,Xov kv oti Kct^d ^dg TotctvTctg oti Tdyct$ov ecjt yevog. KctTct fxev trr\ tk ctKpov KctTr,yope7- 
irpcTct<retg det to KctTct Tr\v e^tv dvTt Tr\g ejreoog fxeTctXr\- Tctt to TrpcoTov, kcxt' dXXr\Xcov tf' & XeyeTctt. tov ctvTov trr) 
irTeov Kctt $eTeov opov. TpoTrov Kctt eTri t« fxr\ vTrctpx^ Xr\7rTeov. ov ydp det <rrt- 

35 O^ &? $e Tovg opovg det Xr\Te7v ovofXctTt htTi$e<r$ctt' [xctivet to fxr\ vTrctpx^ ^otre Tutfe fxr\ eTvctt ToSeTotfe, dXX' 
TToXXctKtg yctp e<rovTctt Xoyot oig « Kehctt ovofxct. tfto %ct- 30 evioTe to [xr\ eTvctt Totfe Ttstrer\ Tooe Tutfe, oTov oti \sk ecji 
XeTrov dvctyetv T\sg TonsTtsg <rvXXoy«r[x\sg. evioTe tfe kcu ctTrct- Ktvr t <recog Ktvr,<rtg r\ yeve<recog yevectg, r\cfovr,g tf' ecjtv' \sk dpct 
TcL<r$ctt <rvfx(Br\<reTctt tftct ty,v ToictvTr\v Xr\Tr\<rtv, oTov oti tcov y\ r\tfovr\ yevertg. r\ TTctXtv oti yeXcoTog fxev ecjt <rr\fxetov, <rr\- 
dfxe<rcov ecjt <rvXXoytrfxcg. ecjoo to A tfvo op$cti, to eip' u fxetov tf' wt ecjt <rr\fxe7ov, oocj' ov <rr\fxe?ov 6 yeXcog. dfxoicog 
B Tptycovov, etp' co tfe Y lo-o<rKeXeg. tco fxev %v T inrctpx^ <fe Kdv To?g ctXXotg, ev orotg dvctipeTrctt to 7rpo^Xr,[xct tco 
To A tftct to B, tw <5e B \sk{ti tft' dXXo' Kct$' <xvto yctp 35 Xeye<r$cti Trcog Trpog cxvto to yevog. irctXtv oti 6 Kcttpog \sk 
to Tptycovov ex^ tfvo cp$ctg, cocj' ovk ecjctt [xecrov tov AB ecjt XP 0V0I > tfecoV $ew yctp Kcttpog fxev 'ecjt, XP OVO $ ^' °^ x 
ct7ro^ei>tTou ovto^. tpctvepov yctp oti to fxe<rov *x KTug det ecjt tfecov tftct to fxr,tfev etvctt $eco cotpeXtfxov. op\sg fxev ydp 
\v\7rTecv oog Totfe Tt, dXX' evioTe Xoyov, "oTrep <rvfx(octivet Kd^rt $eTeov Kcttpov k<x) XP 0V0V tfeovTct Kctt $eov, tyjv tfe 7rpoTct<rtv 
T« Xe^^evTo?. \Y\7rTeov KctTct ty]v t« ovofxctTog 7rTco<rtv. d7rXcog yctp tovto 

36 To tfe v7rctpx^ v to TrpooTov tco fxecTco Kcti tovto tco 40 Xeyofxev KctTd Trctvrcov, oti T«f • fxev opovg det $ereov Kcvrd 
ctKpco ov tfe? Xctfx^tctvetv cog det KctTY\yopY,$Y\<rofxevcov dXXr\- Tctg K\r\<retg tcov ovo/xo.tcov, oiov ctv$pco7rog r\ dyct$ov r\ hctv- 

3. l\ om B. \\ 18. t<£ om pr A. II 21. <m cfioy^ai/Jtmi B. II 33. tc V ty' C. II 34 <Jk io 7 A. II 37. <*7rodWtxeu ABC. II 
7*p] oZi corr C. II 40. to fiiaov pr B. 

6. T£i] tcc c>' corr A. II ly«.vTi"«, toj? «AXjjAoj? AB. II 12. Mv Itt. — 13. ert tou rc supra lituram A. II 20. ht om AB. II 
to-j om C. II 4l. KXtaeit; AB. 



ANAAYTIKnN IIPOTEPflN A. 49 

-TKt, vk dv$poo7rov vj dyctSov y\ hctvrtoov, rctg <$s 7rporct<rstg ort ov, sp' u> B ov, sp' 'u> V dya,$ov. pa,vspov ovv ort h 

\v,7rreov Kard ro,g eKctcrov rrruxretg' v\ yctp ori tktw, oiov ro?g h fxepet <rv\\oyt<rfxo?g vroog \v\7rre0v rvg opvg. 
to fcrov, v\ ort rirv, oiov ro at7r\ct<rtov , v\ ort rovro,- olov As? os kcu fxsra,\ctfx@dvstv k ro ctvro ovvarcu, ovo-39 

ro rvirrov v\ bpoov, v\ ort \rxog, olov 6 ctv$poo7rog TJZov, v\ fxorra, dvr' bvofxdiroov koa Xoytg dvri \oyoov Kct) ovofxo* Kcti 
et Ttoog ctWoog rrtTrret rwo/xa, Kctra. rv\v itporctcnv. 5 \oyov, kcu ds) dvr) ri Xoy* rtvo/xa, \a,fx(BdvstV pctoov ydp 

37 To &' v7ra,px £iv roQs rwas Kcti ro d\vi$svs<r$ctt rooe y) roov opuiv eK$e<rtg. otov sl fxv\&\v o^tctpspst s't7rs?v ro v7ro\v r 
Kard rovfrs roo-avrct^oog \v\7rreov ocraxuig^ 0,1 KO,rv\yopta,t wtov-tk <Jb£a<f« /xvj eTvctt yevog v) fxv) eTvat a-irep v7To\y\7TTov 
o~typv\vra,t , ko.) rctvrctg v\ 7rv\ v\ d7r\oog,- srt d7r\&g v\ <rvfx- rt ro 6 K o^a.cov (rctvrov ydp ro <rv,fxctivb/xevov), dvri t« \6y\i 
7xe7T\ey/xevag' b/xotujg &s ko.) ro /xv) vTrajpx^- s7tto~KS7sriov t» \ex$hrog to v7ro\.v\7rrov Kctt ro frofcctcov opxg $ereov. 

<$e t«-ut* Kcti ^toptceov fis\rtov. j 10 'Exez cY ov rctvrov ect ro slvctt rv\v v\qovv\v dya,$ov KcttAO 

38 'To<$° e7ra,va,b y t7t\oufJLsvov hra.?g Trporctrstrt nrpog tw to sTva,t rv\V *j<5bv*jv ro dyct$ov, ix bfxotusg $ereov tk? "opovg, 
Trpooroo ctKpoo $srsov,v rrpog roo.fj.scru>. \eyu> cf' oTov el ye-> dw' el /xsv scrtv b <rv\\oyi<r/xog ott v\ v\bovv\ rdya,$ov, rd- 
votro o-vK\oyio-fxog:<brt rr t g 6^tKcttorvvv\g scrriv sTr.tcrrvifxvi ori ya,$ov, st % %rt dyct$ov, dya$ov. vruig KaTrt ru)v aX\u>v. 
cuyctVov, ro ort ctya,(jov v\ v\ a,ya,dov irpog roo 7rpu>ru> vereov. Qvk ecrt oe rctvrov ovr eivcti ovr et7recv , ort u> ro JJ41 
ecru) yctp ro A e7ncrvifxv\ %rt dyctSov, e<p' u> 8e B dya,$ov, 15 vTrapx^-, r*ru> Trctvrt ro A vTrctpx^-, Kcti ro ehreiv to w 
e<p' u> Se r c\tKcttoo-wv\. ro ftv) A d\v\$\g t» B Kctrv\yopv\- Trctvri ro s B vTrctpxu, x*' ^o A rravrt vTrapx^' ov6%v yctp 
crcti' tk ya,p dya,$x ecr)v S7rtcv\fxv\ on dyct$ov. d\\a, Kctt ku>\vsi ro B ru V v7ra,px^v, fJLv) Trctvrt c\L oTov ecu> ro B 
70 B tk r* v\ yctp S~iKcttco-vvY\ %7rep dyct$ov. >§TW fxev «v y(- ko,\ov, ro cfe F \evKov. st 6% \evKU rtv) virapx^ kcl\ov, 
yera,i.a,va,\v<rig.. ei 6)e Trpog tw B Te^ewj to ot^ dyahov, ovk d\v\$\g et7re?v in tw \evKU v7ra,px £l ko,\ov d\X ov 7ra,vri 
%ca,V ■ro ftev ydp A Ka,rd rov B dXvfisg ecctt, ro cfe B 20 tccog. el fxev %v ro A tw B vTrdpx^-, yA Trctvr) $e Kct$' ov 
Kitrct rov r 6vk d\v\$\g ecat' ro. ydp dyct$ov %rt dyct$ov ro B, out' el 7rctvri tw P to B, out' el fxovov v7ra,px^-> 
Kctrv\yope?v t»j? cftKcttocrvvvig ^peuaog Kct) « o-uveTov. bfxotuig <5e dvctyKv\ ro A »% ori ov 7ta,vrt, dW. qu<^' vTrdpx^' «' 6% 
Kcti et ro vytetvov «Jef^enj ort ectv e7rtcv\rov v\ dya,$ov, v\ Kct$' ov dv ro B \eyv\ra,i d\v\$oog, rovrw 7ra,vr) V7rdpx^, 
rpa,ys\acpog do^oocrrov v\ fxv) ov, v\ b dv$punrog <p$a,prov v\ <rvfx(3v t <rercti ro A, ko,$' ov 7ra,vrog ro B \eyerctt, Kctrd 
ctl<r$vrrov' h d7rct<rt ydp ro?g e7rtKctrv\yopovfxevotg irpog roo^ rxrov Trctvrog \eye<r$cti. et fxevrot ro A \eyerat , ko,$' •« ctv 
ctKpco rv)v e7ra,vac\'.7r\oo<riv $ereov. - . - To B \eyv\rctt, KO,rd 7ra,vrog, bfrev Ku>\vet ru V vTrdpx^v 

Ovx v)ctvrv) 8e $ecrtg roov opoov, orctv d7r\u>g rt o~v\- ro B, fxv\ Trctvrt <5e to A v\ %\oog fxv\ yTrctpx^v. h ov\ ro?g 
\oyt<rdv\ Kat orctv rooe rt v\ ttv\ v\ 7rug, \syu> o otov orctv rpt<rtv opotg ov\\ov ort ro KO,tj » to B, 7ra,vrog ro A Aeye- 
rdyct$ov s7rtcv\rov &stx$vi Kct) %rctv sTrtqvrtov rt ort dyct- &$ctt, t«t' sqt, Kct$' oroov ro B \sysrctt, KO.ro, Trctvroov \e- 
$ov' d\)C ei fxev d7r\u>g eTrtcvcrov Mhsoorctt, fxicrov $ereov Ta30 ye<r$at ko,i ro A. Kctt ei fxev Kctra, Travrog to B, Kctt ro 
ov y ei £' "ort dya$ov, ro r) ov. ecoo yctp ro fxev A e7rtcv\<xv\ A vruig' ei $e fxv\ kotco, 7ro,vrog, ovk dvctyKv\ ro A Kctrcu 

<r \ ■*/ >■> r M 75'' \ *\> >i> V -r» ' f\/ >^ ^ 

ort rt. ov, e<p u> t)e & ov rt, ro exp u> V ctycttiov. ct\v\- Trctvrog. 

$\g 6\ to A t» B Ka,rviyape?v' v\v ydp e7rtcv\fxv\ t« rtvog ov- Ov 6~e? fr* ote<r$ctt 7ra,pa, ro eKri$e<r$o,t rt <rvfx@a.tveiv 

rog ort rt ov. d\\ct Kctt tc B tk T' ro ydp ep' u> F ov droTrov' ov6\v yctp 7Tpo<rxpufxe$a, rto robe rt eTvctt, dW' 

rt. u)<rre Kctt to .A t« V' errctt ctpa, hrt<rrvifxv\ rdya,$x ort 35 ooo-irep b yeu)fxerpv\g rv)v 7ro6'ta,ia,v ko\ ev$e?a.v rv^vo^e Kctt 

dyct$ov viv ya,p ro rt ov t^? ivtov <rv\fxs?ov H<rta.g. si cfe ro d7r\ctrv\ eTvctt \syet ovk ov<rctv, d\>\ ovx ovruig xp% ra ' 1 ^S 

ov fxeo-ov srs$v\ Kctt Trpog ruo ctycpoo ro ov ct7rXc2? kol) fxv) ro sk. rovroov <rv\\oytCofxsvog. o\u>g ydp fxv\ s<rrtv ug 'b\ov 

r) ov s\ix^-> vk dv v\v <rv\\oyt<rfxog ort ectv S7rtcv\<xv\ rd- Trpog fxspog kcu £\\o nrpog rovro ug fxspog irpog o\ov, sjr 

yct&S prt dya.$ov, d\K ort ov, oTov sp' u> ro A S7rtcv\fxv\ ifrsvog roov rotovroov frstKwrtv fretKvvoov, ooce ot>6e ytvercti 

iA. $ om pr C. II 20. tpu om C. II 24. fofah om ABC. II 29. to «,7*fi*y C. II 31. tt B. II 38. t» «.«y^S C. II 39. oTot 
Ofli A. . 

8. ro\ xohs pr B. II t*'jto C. ' U 16;. xa.1— U7r*p%n om pr A. II 18. 7 to Xevxov AB. II 23. Tt<mi t<j * VTroLpyji B. II 26. kui- 
Xiu el tQ T xjtcmx^ C. II 27. >) om pr C. II §\ C II 28. to ante x<t5' om A. II 29. -rtinui tvtw X(ye<r6a,i corr C. II 32. ttxy- 
to? ABT. ABC. II. 36.- wu om C. II *W ABC. II «% om AB et pr C. 

G 



50 ANAATTIKHN HFQTETfiN.A. 

orvKKoytTfXos. too S'. \xT$ecrSttt •xroo xpaofXeSct 'iooTrsp Kttt i&icttpopcoi to-jt&iv;, xar Troiret$^e; y;yeTcti ra J£ vTroSecrsco.S:, 

100 ctlcrSctvetrSctt , . rov fXctySctVQVTtt KsyovTes " » -yctp \iToos ■&.$ vcspov iptfxsv.' wv- ^t tocthtov v\fx7y scoo cpttvspcv, on xx 'sciv 

■ttvev txtqov i% ™ y T - et-7ro<$£{;£(5?!ycti, cocrTrep e£ oov ii ovK- cLvctKvetv eis to, <r%v\fxu,Ta,-T.iss tolvt.qvs ovKKoyicrfxovs. Kcti 

ikoy t&fxos. . ■ : J '- v . ' . - " -..::.:• $t Mv cthtctv, eip^Kctfxev. 

42 M^; Kw&.cmTco .$' y-vctts .%rt iv tw ctur&p '■ crvKXoytcrfXtSj $ r/ 0w cK ev 7rKeiocn cr.xvifxxcri : ^sixvvTcti raov 7rpo@Kv\-A5 

is% rxTrctnct': rvL crvfx-irspctcrfxctT.ct ' $t ': Avos .-<r*&if/,ooTXiS evrtVi fxctrcov^ .r\v. h •S.&Tepoo: o:uKKQyi<r£r}.., sctv. ctvctyttystv rov o~vK-. 

cLkKoo ' t.o ■fxsv. $100 tvtovto .Se. cV ctKXv. SyiXov ouv ■oti.xou k&yiq;pw.\els.:SxTspoY^-ciov :rov. iv roo jrpQoroo- ■ cepY\Tixsv sk to 

ra)s ' dvctXvoreis ovrco 7roiY\Teov. iiret p' ov itcXv 7rpo(BXY\fA<2, h ■SsvTspoy^tttTTQV.sy Tw-.fxerrao. ezV ro Trpaorov, »%- .evxctvTets 

cXttcovti oxvifxctTi cLkX iv ey.ctcoo TSTcty/xsvcty cpctvspov iit rif Se .cLKK' hiovs. jccti: Sh^ctTepovh . tq7s- S7r.ofjJvots. sl ryttp 
o-ufXTTspctrfxctros sv oo o-x^^Tt X^TYcnoy.: (0 to A /xy\Ssv) raB, to Ss B.^avt) t<£ F, ■ To- A cvSsvl TU 

43. T ht Te TT.pos optrfx.ov*Tuv r :Xs).yooy.,.oc-ot Ttpos sy rt rvyr ^j a&vpa /xsv:onv.T.o irpoxrov? <r%y\.poct,. ictv S~'' oLvTicpctipY, ro 

%ecvxiri S~istXsyfxevo'i toov -iv rao opco.,'.ftpos *b SteiXsKTcu >'$£-■ ^MtKaKJe Ta fxe<rov. ecctt'-'To r/a)pS, -tu> fxh A'>sSevi,:-Tcp 

reov opov, Kctt ov':tqv ct7rctv.Tct Xor/oV : ytttqv \ya,p crvfx(o<Vi<T£~ j5^r. otbcft) vTTap^ei: OjUaaW «3t£ kcd ei -fx% xctSpKov ctXX ? h 

Tctt TctpctTTsoSctt Smo) -to- fishtQS; oiov el :to vS~aop tfrsfesv ott fxepst o vxiKKoyco-fJoas.; oToysrro <fjoev A /JtYjfrevt too. B, to h\ 

vypoV 7T0T0V, TO 7T0TQV:%Cti TO vfroop ~OpQVS SeTSQV.. *. 15 B:TOtlTTW P* •■CtVTirTpCtCpeWoS ^Ctp TQU CVtmtbtOV TO fjJjTQV 

44.. Etj (J| tou? e^ .vTroQereoos r.v/xKoy.io-jutovs B TeipctTeov -scpctt tr^jU-st. 

ctvot.yg.v* o-j yctp eg-iv . «t Toiv xei/x/vwv ctvctyeiv. ov yctp foa, \i ■•. ..-T&i^ ^: iv: f^ ^evTtpoo: .<r>jkKoyi<rptutv ol ftey k&SoXov 
o-vKKQiytp-f^Qv.-^e^eiyjoievoi elriv, ctKKct ifa ruvSYtwiS : u>'fi:0r ^vct^S^rxiVTsu elsTQ xpujTov , roov- £' :iv. fzepft •■cLrepos- fJtcvov. 
KoyY\fxsvol.7rctvTes.. oiov .el u7nSefjtsvos, ctv tktvctuis Tf? fXtct scroo yaup: ro k. :rcp. y>h B /tbj$kn7*UR w> t 7feCtTi Juxet^ov. 
fJOY\ y\ roov iv.ctvTtoov, fXYicf en -ic-yijotYiV fxictv eTvctt, ehct ^ictKe- 20 a.vTtcrpct^isvr.QS »v :tk .crepYj.7ixZ:.-o:o: 7*pu)Tav 'ecpctt rr^fxcl''. To 
"XjSetY\ oTi w e^i yttiet. frvvctfJtiS T<2v £ve6VT^v,-.fliQV t« -OyiSivoy fxh y'xt.p:1& ^euroo A^ ta. Se. A.7Tctvr) ru T vTrctp^et. ictv 
Kctt.rov vocrco^ovs' ctfjoct .yctp ecrctt to_ ctvjo yyteivov Kctt .yo- <fe ro KctTY,yopiKov yi Trpns - roo ..B-, to Se cjepYfrtKov Trpos Tio 
odochs. :ori .fxh.iv w :e.c~i fxict lr$tvxoov Tooy' hctvrtcov ovvctfxts.i T, .TrpaoTov opov Sereov to.T' t»to yetp x&evl too A, to Ss 
<&7ro$.s / ($siKTcti , 'ori S~' iTri^yifxyi ovk kcrtv., x' &s$£iKTcti.. kcoitoi A 7ravTi.T<S--B". u>.cr:; ifrsvt tlo B to T. vr^' ctp.ct' tq B tST 
ofxoKoysiv- ctyctyKcttov. cLKK\ovx e» ; cruXKo.ytcffxov^ chKK\s%'Z$ou$evt': -eLvrtcrpecpei ycip ro qspYfaKov. ictv fr' . iv . fXepet %\ 6 
VTToSereoos. Ttrov jxev »v xk ecrtv ctvctyctyetv,, MH b' i fxict ovKKoyicrfxos, "orctv fxev y\ .to '■ • crep^TiKov Trpos' tw -fxsi^ovi 
Svvct/xts, ecrtV vtos yxpicraos v-ctt y\V crvKKoyicrfxos, ekeTva ctkpoo, .vLvttxSricreTctt. elg tq Trpaorov; oTov et ro A [xvfievi toZ 
£' v7ToSe<ris. . . B, tw b% T nvi' cLvricrpctcpevTos yctp tk crepY,TLKi ro Trpao- . 

'Ofxoioos ^h-.Kctt iTTt toov c^tct t» Qtc^uyctTfc; 7repcttvofxevcoy' rov icrcu : vxnfxct' T.o.fxh ydp. B x&evi too A, 'tc Se A Ttv\ 
»^e yctp TMT6S.\iK ecr.tv cLvctKuetv, ctKKct rr,v .fxev eis tq cLou- 30 t® T.~ cTctvcfe to ■KttTY\yopiKov, vk ccvctKvS^crsTctt, oTov el ro 
vctTQV cLlrctyooyYxV itrt (•o-uKKQytrfxuJ r/ctp cfeiKVJTcti) , - ^xrepov A tw fxev B 7rctvT/, rao Se. T . av . Trctvri' oure ydp Sexerctt 
& ovk etrtv' i^ vttoSsq-scos yctp TrspctiveTctt. StctcpepovTt ■$£ dvr isr p o<priy t.q AB, vrf yevofxevr,s ecrctt crvKKoyi<r/xQs. ■ 
twv 7rpoeipY,fxevaov %rt iv exsivois fxh <$s~t 7rpoSiOfxoKoyY\crct- ■ ~ HctKtv ot fxh h too rpiroo trx^fxctTt 'mk cLvxKvSy\q-qv-. 
oSctt, sl fxeKKet o-vfxcpY\reiv , oiov etv SsixSvi fxict Svvctfxis rctt Trctvres els to TrpaoTov, ot c? iv roo Trpuoroo TTctvres ets to 
toov evctvTtoov, Kctt i7rt.crqfXY,v sTvctt ty,v ctvr^v irrctvSct ch Kctt 35 Tpirov. VTTctpxeToo.-yttp ro A Trctvri roo B, to c% B Tiy} too 
fxv\ 7rpot\iOfxoKoyY\crctfxevoi crvyxoopvcr-t Stct ro cpctvepov sivctt T. \sxmv i7Tst$Y\ cLvTtcpscpsi ro iv fxepet xctTY,yopiKcv, vTrdp-; 
to ^euSos, oiov reSeicrris ty,s frictfxerpov o-vfXfxerpov tq rct ^et to T rtvi rao B' to Se A x«,vt1 TjTr^^ev, cocs yiverctt 
TreptTTct tcr-ct sivctt roTs ctpTiots. ■ to rpvrov o"x%fxct. Kcti si cepvrTixcs o crvKKoytcrfxos, cocrctv- 

UoKKot oe Kcti erepoi Trepcttvovrcti i^ vTroSereaos, ovs rcos' cLvricpscpsi yctp to eV fxspsi.KctTY\yoptKov, aocs to fxh 
sTricrKe-^/cto-Scti fre? Kctt ^tct<rY\fJjY\vcti KctSctpaos. rives fxev h ctt 40 A xcfevt rao B , to ^e T rtvt vTTctpPet. 

3. tovtov AC. II 7. xod om AC. I! 9. ■ctra^ix.iioi B. II 11. opivpov? pr C. II 20. pri om pr C. II tiocXix^ C. II 21. fi(«.'Y<S 
ABC, 7rZccf, pi- B, 7rdnujy corr A. II 24» ImKhiMrcu B et pr A. II 26. tSto C. 4). a.A^Eii C. II 37. olov] ow hi C. II "40. ph 

■ti)TU>V cti hot.(p4p\Li C. 

6. F ut videtur B. II 18. fxoyog BC. II 27. tW.-j&ja-ercii corr B. II 33. h om ^.11 34. oi &'] oW ol B. 



A.NAATTIKQN nPOTEP^N A. 51 

' Toiv <T sv tw Ts\€<JTd,{u) (rxyijtrUZTi crvkkoyirfjLcov eTg xrti oti elg TCTrpuoTov crxYifta, toov <rvkkoyi<r[Aoov dva.yofjL&-< 
ttovog. «>c dvctkveTcti e\g to TrpcoTcv, Itclv fj.Y\ KctSokx TS$y , VU)V VTOl fJLOVOt $ld TK dcfvVctTOV TTSpcLLVOVTCLt. 
70 crepYiTiKov, ot cf ctkkct irdvTeg dvctkyovTctt. ■ KctTYiyopei<r$co TLcog [A.sv \sv <Yet Tovg crvkkoyitrfXovg dvdysiv, xcti qtc. 

ydp TrctvTcg t« r to A kcl\ to B* &KW dvTicrpe^pet to T dv&kvsTcu Ta, cr^YiucLTd ■ slg oikkYikoL, (pcLVspov SK TCOV sl- 
itpcg. sKcLTspov syn jxepoyg' vjfattfXfy *)?* . Tm . T( ? B*. .&"*'- 5 pYifJ.svoov. <Yict<pspst <fs tl sv too. kcltcutksvcjl^slv y\ dvct<rKevct-A6 
ecrcti to TrpooTov <r%yi[A,cC, ei tc : ftsy A ttclvtl too T, tq .oe l^sjlv to v7roka,fj>^><tvsiy- q-.TctvTQV; y\ 'STspcv <ry\fxcLLvsLV to (jly) 

r TLv)_ TOOV B. KOLL el TO fJ.SV A 7TC(,VTL TU) T, TO <& B TLVL X SLVCLl TOcYi KCLl . eJvOLl fJ.Y\ TOVTO % 0T0V ffi fX$ eJv.OLL ksVKOV TU) 

a civTog koyog' dvTtcrps^cpst ydp Trpcg tq.T to B. sctv ,cYs sivcti fx% ke-jKcv. ov. ydp Tctv-Tfiv o-Y\fj.cLLysL li qvcy' ecriv dTfo- 
70 fxev B TtcLVTt tw r,' ro cfs A tlv\ tw r, TrpooTog %pcg <pcL<rtg tov sTvctt keyKov to : sTvoll. [j.y)- kevKov.,. dkkd to y.r, 
&STeog To B' to ydp B 7Tclvt\ twF, to cfe T Ttvt tw A, ucre 10 sTvcli kevKOv. koyog cfe tktov o<Je. ofjLotoog ydp s^st t.o <Sv- 
70 B Ttvt Tui A. exe) $' dvTLcrpecpei to ev fxepet, kol\ to A vaTcu fioL&tl^eiv Trpcg to <\vvcltm .« ^clcyTQeiv r<2 ecrt kevKov 
7tv\ tw B v7rcLpPeL. kcu et qepy^iKcg; o <rvk.koyLo-fj.og, kcl-. ^poi to sctlv ov kevKyy, koli .eTrtrT.cLTcn 7a\yct$ov irpog to 

6okO'J TOOV.OpOOV OVT-OOV., OfAO.iOOg k^TfTSOV. V7T0LpXSTU) yctp . T.O S7ri<^0LT0Ll;TQ \}K dyct$OV. T,Q. ydp .S7TicrCtTCH. Tdyct$QV. \ scrt* 

B 7tc6vt). tw r, to cfs A fXYihvL'- VKKV Ttv\ tw B vTt.ctp^et STttcTctfxsvog TdyctSdv vcfsv c^tctcpspsi, ovcfe to chvcLTctt . (2>d<$t- 
70 T, To.de A utoTw T, uxr scjcti fJiecrpv to JL\ ofJboiuig 15 l.slv y\ scrTt ovvctfJjeyog pttot^eiy;' :.u).cre- xcti 7ct- ctvriKSifxsvct, 
<5e Kcti sl to ftev crspY,TiKoy xftSckv, to Se xcLTY\yoptxcv sv » SvvctTctt ficthL^siv - ix scrt Svvctftsvog ^cl^lXslv. st »v 70 
fjLepef tc' julsv ydp A v$ev\ tw T, to cfe T tiv\ toov B vTrctp- ovx ecrt cWjvctfjLevog ftcthti^etv tolvto crYiftctLveL xcti s<ri <%vct- 
fy-i. sdv $' sv fJLspst .kYifp&q tc cjspY\TtKOV,. ip scTctt dvclkv-; ftsvcg « fi.ctfrtCsLV y\ fjjY\ ^tk^CQw > TctvTct. ye CtfJLCL vTtctp^ei, 
crtg, cTqv e{ to jjlsv B: tclvt\ tc& T, to. g%_ A Ttv\ fjLYt vTfctp- t.clvt^ (q ydp .ctvTog chjvctTctt kol-I tSctSil^etv Kcti; jlly] jStt^- 
%ef dvTLcrpctcpsvTog ydp tov BT djJL<poTepcti cli TrpcTctostg 20 Zetv y kcl\ s7rLq-Y\uu)v Tdycttfi, kcll.tx fj,v\ dyct6v scrt)'. <pcL<rtg 
erovTctt Kctrd fJL.epos. Q$ kcll d-n:o<pcLcrig »% v>Tctpx^v ctl dvTtKsifxsvcti ctfxct Tty 

^ctyspcv cfs Kcti "ort Tzpog to dvctkvsiv etg akkY\kaj tou clvtoo. oorTrep w ov tolvto ecri to ftY\^ e7rI<rct<rSctt TdyctScv 
^XKfJLctTct y) Tzpog Tui ekctTTOvi. &Kpu) 7rpQTct<rig . dvTtcjpeTTTect. jtctt e7rtcrcL<r$cti to fx,Y\ dyoL$ov, ovcf' eTvctt fJLv) dyctSov Kcti 
eV dft<poT&poig To7g.<rxAr A,it4ri ' tclvty\s ydp fLterctTt$eftevY\g fxv\ eTvcti dyct&ov TctvTov. toov ydp. dvd koyov. edv $ctTepct 
y\. fjLeTd&cvrig syivsTO*. . .( 25.»? erepct, kcll SctTepct. Mflp tq eTvctL f/,r\ Xq-qv xcl) to (jly) eT- 

Tuiv. $' ,ev Tui fjLs<ru) ff%J1^WM drepog ftev dvctkveTctt, vctt 'itqv tuj fxev yctp v7roKeiTcti rt, tcZ. ovti jjlyj 'lctu), xct\ 

ttTSpOS ()' OVK zdvctkvSTOLL. sk TO TptTOV, OTCtV fJ.h ydp Y\ 70: T¥T. SCJ.t T0 CtVKTOV , TW <^' X$ev. <YlC7rep, ilVOV fJLSV y\ ctVlCTQV ». 

jcct^o^.K cref)Y\TLxcv, dvctkveTOLi* el ydp to A . fJ.Y\c\sv\ tu> B, 7rctv, \<r.ov <\' y\ ovx ?<rov 7rctv. sTi. to ecrtv ov kevxcv £vkov 
7u cfe T -7ivl, dfJL<poTepct ofjLoicog dvT.to-Tpscpsi irpog to A, txctt ovk ecrt kevkov ^vkov ov% ctfJLct V7rctpx^- " yctp ecri 
cocre to fxev B v<fev\ tw A, to <5e T tlv(' fti<rov dpct. tq A. 30 %vkov i kevKov , .ecrcti £ykov to Se /uly) ov kevKov £ykov wc 
r cToL,v.cfe to A TrctvTL .tu) B, tco <fe T .tlv\ ftY) vTrcLpXK* ** dvctyxY,: ^ukov eivctt. uicre. <pctvepov oti &k ecrt 7% ecrtv dyxt-i. 
ecrcti dvctkv<rtg' ovc\sTspct ydp tcov. 7rpoTct<rsu)y ex 7Y\g- dvrt- .■ $ov jc ecrtv «jc. dyct$ov. d7ro<jict<rig. .sc ovv xctTd ■TrcUTCg evog 
<rpo<pY\s KctSokov, ■ : Y r <pct<rig v\ d7r.d.<pctrig dk.Y t $v\g, et /jly\ ecriv d.7ro<pct<rig , cf/r 

. Ka-i ol s.k t» TptTov <fs Qrx^drcg dvctkv$Y\<rovT.cti e\g kov cog xctTctcpctcrig ctv Ttoog eiv\. KctTctcpctcrecog <fe 7rct<rY\g 
70 fJLsrov, ctclv y\ Kctaokov to crepY\TiKov, oiov et to A {Jly\- 35 ct7ro<pct<rtg ecrTt koli 7ctvTY\g ctpct 70 ovx ecrtv ovk ctycwov. 

^ \ ~ -n \ K t» \ '\ ' \ \ \ -n ~ \ * V $s f Y ' h \ J/ i \ \ >' \ T< ' /1\ 

oevt tco r, to os B Ttvt y\ TrctvTi. Kcti yctp to T Too ftsv A e^e< os Tct^iv TYjVde Trpog ctkk.Y\kct. scttco to sivcLt ctyctaov. 
ovosvi, Tco oe B 7tvt vTrcLpfcet. ectv o ex< ftepovg y\ to <re- s<p ov A, to oe /xy\ eivctt ctyctoov e<p ov B, to oe sivctf 
pv\7LKcv, «>c dvctku$Yi<r.e7cti '■ cv ydp cfe^x^cti dmcrpocpYiv tq (jly\ dy.ct$ov e<p' «T, inro to B, to <fe- fj,v} eTvctt /uly) dyct- 

J / > , / A\ > , > V . t \ \. . \ ^\ ( / V * V . ■ A \ 

ev ftepsi cL7ro<pctTixov. • vov scp ov A, ti7ro to A. 7rrt,vr< ov) vTrctp^st. yi to A v\ to 

fyctVSpOV QVV- CTl 01 OLVTOl <Tvkkoy 1<T fJ.0 1 «>C dvctkvOVTCtlJlQ'B, KCtl OVcfeVl TW CtVTU) ' KCtl Y\ TO T Y] TO A, >Crt,i OV^SVt 

ev TYTotg Totg <rx^ct<rtv Q r/ nrep ifr' etg to 7rpcoTov dvekvovTO, tw clvtoo. kcli oo to T, dvctyKY\ to B 7Trt,vTl virctpx^v. tl 



om AB. 



7. ra rS (2 C. fl 8. to B tc T C. I! 9. irpuJror opov. falm C. H 18. hu pr A. II 19- ^ioy^y B. II 25. «yfWai C. II 34. 18 

AB. 

13. 67riVa(rfl<*i to ovx cLy. B. II 20. kirKpiy-nv C. II t^i\ t%sn C. II .21. oiy.it om B. fl 22. t*utsV C. 

G2 



62 AftAA-TTIKflN nPOTEPiiN A. 

ydp dkYi$eg uTreTv oriov kevKov, kcll "otl ovk etri kevkov pov, kcll nrxkiv tc Y kcll to A coTxvrcog, e7rvjTcu Sk tw Y 

dkYi$eg' dfrvvcLTov ydp ctfXtx eTvtLi kevKov kcll eTvcu fXYi kev- ro A kcu /xyi dvTLcrpe<pvi, kcll tu B -to A dkokx$YtTet kcl\ 

kov, yi eTvcu fcykov ov kevKov kou eTvou fcykov kevKov, cocr' xk dmtrpe^pei' ■ -kcli tq fxev A k<x\ A ev^(%eTcKi tw <*wto>, 

el fXYi v\ KctrcLcpctTLg, r, dTrotpXTig vTrtxpzeL. tw oe B to Y to Se B kou Y ovk ivfrexereu; TrpuTov fxev ovv- ori tw B 
vk dei' o ydp %koog fxvi fcykov, «<5e fcykov etrtLi i kevKov. 5 eirerou- to A, iv$evt\e cpttvepdv. eire\ ydp -ttclvtl toov Y A 

dvcL7r<xkLV tolvvv, u> to A, ts • A ttxvtl. v[ yctp to Y yi to 6<XTepov i^ .clvtxyKYts, u> Se to B, &k ivbexjsxcu to Y $lcl 

A. e7Te\ &' ovx °i°v f € <X[xcl eivou fXYi kevKov kcLt kevKov-, : to -rvve7fitpepeiv-' to A,to tfe A-'kcl\ B fXYi ivM-Xj-trftcu ■ tw 
to A vTTctpirei. kcltcl yxp tov ovrog kevKov dkvfieg elrreTv clvtco, iptxvepov %tl to A~ d%okv,$YtTeL. TTttktv iite\ tw- A to 
otl kk etrtv i kevKov. kcltcl ' b% t» A « nrxvTog to A' kcltcl Y ' &k dvTL<rpe<p>ei , ttclvtl tfe to Y yi-to A, e^£%£Toti to A 
«yo^j t« oAws ju.^ ovto?' zykov &k dkvfieg to A elireTv, dog 10 »&; to A tw <*vtw virtxpxeiv. to Se ye B Jtcu to Y ovk 
ecri fcykov & kevKov. docre to A dkvfieg, to t¥ A &k dkv,- evfrexercu <$z* tq TvvctKok^$eTv tw Y to A' <rvfx(Stxivei ydp 
6eg, otl fcykov kevKov. ofykov &' otl xou to A Y ovfrevl tl cL$uv<xtov. <pxvepov ovv otl icfe Tto A to B eivTLcrpecpei , 
t<2 (Xvtoo kcu to B kcu to A cVo^eTou Tm tw ayTw meiitep iyxwpeT cZfxou ts A kou 'To A virdpx^. 
virtxpQXL. ■ '^vfxfttxlyeL ■<)'■ ivfoTe ktxi iv ty\ tolccvtyj Tci^ei tojv ""opoov 

'Ofxoioog o exovTL k<xl <xl crepYttretg irpog T<xg kcltyt 15 ci7rtXT^,<rSxL fritx to fXY, tx dvTLKeifxevtx ktxfxftcLveLV opSug, uv 
yopLtxg txvtyi tyj SstreL. l<tov icp' ov to A, «>c \<rov i<p' ov dvxyKYt ttxvtl Sarepov virxpx^-, ofov el to A k<x\ to B (xy\ 

TO B, tXVKTOV i<p' » r, &K CtVLTOV i<p' K A. £V<Je^ETOU clfXtX TOO tXVTU/, dvtXyKYI <¥ VTT/XpX^lV, £> fXYl $<X- 

Keu iiTL TTokkuiv fre, oov ToTg fxev virxpx^ toTg &' »% Tepov, -Stxrepov' k<x\ iroukiv to Y kcu to A u<r<xvToog, S> <fe 
V7Ttxpx £ t TctvTo, y\ fxev ct7ro<p<x<TLg bfxoLoog dkYjSevoLT ctv, otl to Y, TrctvTL eTTerctL to A. <rvfx$Yt<reTtXL yctp Z TO A, TO B 
&k ecri kevKct ttxvtcx y[ otl yk ecri kevKov eKctcrov otl <? 20 vTrctpx^tv ijr dvctyKYig, 07rep icri •^eVc^og. e!kq<p$oo ydp ct7ror- 
icr\v ov kevKov eKctcrov »j tt<xvt<x icjLV ov kevKct, 'pevcfog. <px<TLg tcov AB y\ i<p' u> Z, kcll irxkLV ioov Y A y\ i<p' 
ofxOLOog ^e kcu tou ecri ttxv Xjuov kevKov « to ecrtv « kev- u> 0. dv<xyKY\ &y\ tt<xvtl \ to A y\ to Z ' ^ ydp Tqv <pct- 

KOV CXTTCtV X^OOOV dTTO<p<X<TLg (ctfXCpOO ydp 'ypeVC^eTg), dkkct TO TLV V\ TYiV dTTOCptXTLV. KCtl TTCtklV Y, TO Y YJ TO ' ipctTig 

vk ecrL ttcLv X^uov kevKov. eW <^e (fiikov oti erepov TYifxxt- ydp kou dTTocpctTtg. kcl\ u> to Y, ttclvti to A VTroKetTcu. 
vei to ecrtv « kevKov kcll ovk ecrt kevKov, kcllto fxev kcl- 25 wcre u> to Z, ttclvtl to 0. TTctkiv i7re\ toov ZB ttclvt\ $cL- 
TcupcLTLg to &' dsocpcLTLg, (pctvepov oog &x ° ^Tog TpoTrog repov kcll toov A (JorcLvToog, dKokov$eT cfe too 7i to 0, 
t« 8eiKVvvcu eKtxrepov, oiov otl o dv yi XjZov, ovk ecrt kev- kcll tw A dKok^Tei to B* t»to ydp 'iTfxev. el ctpct too 
kov yi ey<Je%eTcti fXY\ eTvctL kevKov, kxl otl dkvi$eg elTreTv fXYi Y to A, kou too A to B. t»to Se "pevbog' dvtX7Tctktv ydp 
kevKoV tovto yctp icrtv eTvcu fxvi kevKov. dkkct to fxev y,v iv ToTg vroog ex*TLV yi dKok4$YiTig. » ydp 'iToog dvcLyKYi 
dk.Yi$eg elireTv ecri kevKov ene fXY\ kevKOV o cLvrog TpoTrog' 30 ttclvti to A yi to Z, &<fe to Z yi to B* & ycLp icriv ctTro- 
KctTcLTKevcLcrLKoog ydp dfxcpoo c\lcl t» TrpooT* Mkvvtcll tx^- <pxTig t» A to Z. tov ydp dyctSov to ovk dyx$ov dTrd- 
fxcLTog' To yctp dkYi$eg tco ecriv bfxoLoog TctTTeTctL' t« ydp <pctTtg' « tclvto &' icr\ to &k dyx$ov tw «t' dyx$ov %t' 
dkvi$eg elTreTv kevKov & to dkvi$eg e'i7reTv fXYi kevKov d7ro<ptx- &k dya$dv. bfxotcog <$e kou e7rl toov Y A' txt ydp d7ro<p<x- 
Tig, dkkoo to fXYi dkvi$eg e'i7reTv kevKov. el c\r) ecjiv dkYi&eg Teig ctl elkYifXfxevcLL frvo eWlv. 

ZLTCeTv, dv Yl OLV$p007T0g, fXKTLKOV eLVCLL VI fXYJ fXYTLKOV eTvcLL, 35 

CLV VI X^LpOV, kYj7TTeOV Y[ eTvcLl fXYTtKOV Y[ eTvcLL fXYJ /XVTLKOV, X) 

\ >/w v w \ f \ is. * v J a > *-' • 

KCLl OedeiKTCLL. TO Oe fXY[ eLVOU fXKTLKCV CLV Y, CLVOp007T0g, CLVCL- 

TKevtxcriKdog tfeiKWTcLL kcltcl rtg elpYtfxeng rpoTrovg TpeTg. [ 'Ey ircTOLg fxev ovv txv/u-clti kcll <W ttoloov kcll nrd- 

'ATTkdog b' OTCLV XTCOg eXYI TO A KCLL TO B COT$' tXfXCL TCOV TTpOTCLTeCOV KCLL TTOTe KCLl TTOOg yiveTtXL TVkkoyLTfXOg, 

fxh 7$ clvtoo fXYi ivhx £ T$ou, ttclvtl <fe i% dvtxyKY,g $ctTe-WeTi tf' elg iroTtx fikeTTTeov dvxTKevtxXpnt kcll KcLTcLTKevoC- 

4. i, ante xarittp. om B. II 9- Trdvtus pr BC. II 11. eu supra versum B, om corr C. II 17. ro om BC. II 19. Ta.vrh 

B. II 32. Tctc-fl-rrcu C. II 36. «YJ e*v B. II 36. alterum eivm om B. II 39. evr»? hxv C. 

2. amtrpfysi B. II 4. xxi rc 7 C. II 5. tpttvepov 'ig-cti. i-rrii C. II 8. xe A rm B et fortasse pr A. H 15. m pr A. H 

32. rttxirov C. II tit. xpt<?oTgXov; tXv&Kvrixuv irporipuv ro tsvrepov ' C. 



ANAATTIK^NnPOTEP^NB. 53 

"CoVTl,KCLl 7TC0S Sst' "CvireiV TTEpt TK 7TpOK€tfX€V\i KCL$' 07TOICLV- $OLT€pOV <¥ SCfcLl, 7tX,V\V OV friCL TOV CTvXXoy 'KT /XOV , Y[ KOLl eV 
OVV fX£$0(foV, €Tl Ss frtd- 7T01CLS 0&0V XY,-^/0fX€$0L TOLS TTSpt TOIS KOL$oXoV f£ civcnrofrsiXTOV TY[S 7rp0TOLOS0Og Tct U7T0 TO 
EKOLCTOV dpX^i ^&l ^l€K^KV$CLfXeV. S7TSt tf' 01 fX€V KOL$oK\i fXeCTOV etfetKVVTO' COCJ Y[ fc<^' SKS7 eCTCLl Y[ KOLl S-Kl TtiTOOV. 

tcov o-vKKoyio-fxoov : eto-)v 01 th kcltcl fxspos, ot /xsv kclScXv Ecrt fxsv ovv vtcos exeiv cocj' dXY[$eis sTvai tas Trpo- 2 

7TOLVTSS ds) TTXsicO (TvKKoyifyvTCCl , TCOV &' SV /XSpEl Ot fXEV 5 TeLQSlS $1 UV (rvXXoyiQ-fXCS, ECTl <K COCTE \pSV<$E?S, ECTl tf 
KOVTY,yoptKo\ TrXsiOO, 01 $' CtTT OtpCLTiKo) TO (rVfX7rspcLO"/XCL fXO- COCTE Ty]v jXEV o\Ky0Y[ TY,V <fs ^EV&YI. TC 8s Cr.VfXTTEpcLQ-fXOL *} 

vov. cLt fxev ydp dXXcLt TTpoTcLosts dvTtcrpetpXQ-iv, Y[ Ss <re- dXvi$es y[ %//eu£b? k\ dvdyKYiS. s\ oLKyiScov fXEV ovv kh scri 

pY,TlKYJ OVK cLvTtg-psfpSi' TO $E Q-VfJ.7TSpolQ-fJ.OL Tl KOLToL TIVCS ^€Vt\oS Q-vXXoytQ-CLQ-$OLl, EK \^£TJ<$£iv £' SCJiV cLKy,$SS , 7TKy)v 

ectiv. ooc$' ol fxsv olKKoi vvXKoyio-fxoi TrKsico o-vXXoyiXpv- » Sioti dX>l oti' tk y&p $ioti «>c ectiv ek ■^ev^cov trvXXo- 

TOLi, OIOV Sl TO A ^S^EiKTOLt 7TOLVTI TCO B Y[ TlVl , KOLl TO B 10 ytQ-fJ.CS ' $l' Y[V <¥ CLiTlOLV, SV TOIS STTOfXSVOlS Xsx$W£TCLl. 

tivi too A cLvoLyy.cuov vTTOLpxetv' kcu sl fJ.Yi$svi tw B To A, rfywTOV /xev. ovv oti e£ cLKyi$lov ovx G(OV T£ •V^£U<5b5 

«<Je TO V B icfsvt TW A. TKTO $' STSpOV T6 SfJ.7TpOQ-$£V. sl <$£ <rvKKoyLO-OLQ-$CLl , E\TEV$SV $Y,KoV. El yoLp T» A OVTO? cLvOLyKY[ 

TlVl fJLY] VTTOLpX^-, OVK cLvOLyKY[ KOLl TO B TtVl TOO A fJLY[ TO B eTvoLl, T« B fJLY[ OVTOS cLvcLyKY[ TO A fJLY\ sTvoLi. el W 

V7T0LpX£W SV^XETCLt yoLp 7T0LVTI V7TctpX^- cLK.Y[$ES ECJl TO A, OLVoLyKY[ TO B cLKY[$SS sTvcLl , Y[ Q-VfA$Y[- 

AuTV] fXEV OVV KOIVYI 7TOLVTC0V OLiTtOL, TCOV T£ KOL$oKoV i5 QSTOLl TO CLVTC CLfJ.OL eTvOLl T£ KCLliK eiVOLl' T6T0 cf' d$VV0L- 

KOLl TCOV KCLTOL fJLEpOS' tqi <^£ 7Tep) TCOV KOL$oK)S KOLl CtKKOOS TOV. fJ.Y[ OTl <^E X£?TCti TO A sTs CpCS, V7T0KY[(p$Y[TCO £V^£j^£- 

ei7TElV. QcroL yd.p Y[ V7T0 TO fJLSTOV Y[ V7T0 TC crVfJ.7TEp0LQ-fJ.0L Q-$OLl SVCS TIVCS CVTOS £^ CLVOLyKY[S Tl crVfJ.(3oLtVetV' OU ydp 

SCTIV, cLtTOLVTCOV ScrcLl 6 OLVTOS Q-VKKoyiQ-fXCS , SCtV TOL fXSV SV oToV TS' TO fXEV yotp 0-VfX@OL?V0V s^ cLv<xyKY[S TO <rVfX7T£poL- 

TUfXSTCO TCL fr' EV-TU) Q-VfXTTEpoLQ-fXCLTl TS$Y[ , OIOV Ei TO AB (TfXOL ECTl, $i' COV t\\ TOVTO yiVETOLl sKdLXiCTCOV , TpsTs OpOl, 

CVfXTTEpcLQ-fXCL &10L TOV T, 0<T* V7T0 TO B Y[ TO V ECTTiV, 20 &V0 Se &ICLCTYI/XCLTOL KOLl 7TpOTOLQSiS. £t KV CLKyi$€S, W TO B 

cLvOLyKYI KOLTOL 7T0LVTC0V Keyecr$OLl TO A* « yOLp TO A €V 'oKcO V7T0LpX^ 1 -, T0 A 7T0LVTI, U) <& TO T, TO B, Z TO T, OLVoLyKY[ 

Tco B, to cfe B ev tw A, kol) to A scrcci ev tw A. ttol- to A vTrdpx^ *■&) *X °^ v Te touto -^sv&os eTvcti' oXfXoU 
Kiv £t to E ev oKco tw T, to $e T ev tw A, koli to E ydp vTroLp^et tolvto koli vx VTroLp^et. to %v A ooQmep sv ksi- 
h tco A scroLt. bfxoicos <$e koli el <repY[TiKos b o-vKKoyto-fxos. toli, <hio 7TpoTOLQ-ets <rvKK^<p$etQ-OLt. bfxotcos <fe kol) €7t) twv 

£7t) tfe T6 fo-JTSp* (TX^CLTOS TO V7T0 TO (TVfXTTepoLQ-fXOL fXO- 25 CrepY[TlKCOV S%jtt ' V yOLp €CTtV e\ dKY[$COV &?£&< ^SVt\oS. 

vov scroLi <rvKKcyt<roLQ-$cLi, otov sl to A t<S B fXYi^Evi, tu> 'Ek ^svboov fr' dKY[$ss scri <rvKKoyiQ-oL<r$oLt kol) dfX- 

$e T 7T0LVTI' CrVfXXEpOLQ-fXOL OTt V&EVl TCO T TO B. sl 6% TO (pOTEpCOV TCOV TTpOTOLQSCOV ^SvSoOV XQ-COV KCU TY[S fXtaS , TCCy- 
A V7T0 TO r ECTt, (pOLVepOV OTl OVX VTTOLpX^ CLVTCO TO B. TY[S <Y «% CTTOTepcLS ETVX^ dKKoL TY[S $EVTEpoLS , sdvTTSp 
TO?S <$' V7T0 TO A %Tl *X v7ra *pX el i & ^KOV cflOL T« <TVK- oKy[V XoL/xficLVYI •^JSvSy] ' fXY[ oKy[S 8e KoLfxficLVOfXEVYlS SCJil 
KoytQ-fXOV. KOLlTOi OVX V7T0LpX^ ™ E, s't ECTIV V7T.C TO A. 30 67rOT£^Ct<rOUV. ECTCO yoLp TO A OKCO TCO T V7TCLpX0V, TCOV $£ 
dKKd TO fXEV TCO T fXY^SVl VTTOLpX^ T0 B <5"<CC TOU Q-VK- B /XYI&EVI, fXYl<Ts TO B TCO T. EV($£X£TOLl <$£ TKTO , 0T0V Kl$U} 

KoytQ-fxov t\ec\eiKTOLi, to t% tco A fXYi vTTctpx^ dvoL7Totfet- itfevt Tjuov, iS~e Kt$os itfsvi dv$pco7roo. ecLV «v K.Yi<p$Y[ to A 

XTOl' £ik>]7rTCt,< , COCr' OV tflOL TOV 0-vKKoyiQ-fXOV 0-Vfx(BcLtVSl TO TTCLVTl TU B KOLl TO B 7TCtVTi TW r, TO A 7TCtVTi TW V 
B TW E fXY] V7T0LpX^V. E7TI ($£ TCOV SV fXSpEi TCOV fXEV V7TQ VTTOLp^El, COCr' £^ d/X(pO?V "^EVtfoOV dX.Y[$\s. TO <rVfX7T£pcL- 
TO Q-VfXTTEpoLQ-fXOL OVK ECTOLt TO CtVCtyxCt?OV ( OV yOLp ytVSTOLt 35 Q-fXOL ' TTCLS ycip OLV$pC07T0S XjfOV. COCTOLVTCOS <$£ KCtl TO CTepY[- 

o-vKKoytQ-fxos, otolv olvtyi Xvj(p$Y, ev /xepet), tcov <¥ vtto to tikov. ecri y&p tw T /xyits tq A viroLpx^v fXYi$svi fXY[Te TO 
fxecrov ecroLi ttolvtcov, ttXy^v « ^<ct tov crvXXoyio-fxov, oTov st B, to /xsvtoi AtwB 7rctvT<, 6tov eolv toov olvtcov opcov KVf 

TO A XCtVTt TW B, TO <^£ B TtVl TCO T' T« ^tt£V ycip V7T0 <p$EVTCOV fXEQ-QV T€$Y[ OLV$pC07TOS' Xl$CO ycip 0VT€ ^UOV VT£ 

tq T reSevTos vk ecrai trvXXoyirfxos, t« <¥ v7ro to B ecrcLt, cLv$pco7ros xtfevt vTroLpx^-, dv$pco7rco t\e ttclvti XJoov. cocr eoiv 
dXX' « ^ict tov 7rpoyeyeVY[fxevov. bfxoicos tfe Kd^ri tcov dXXcov 40 00 fxev vTTcLpx^-, Kol^ fXY\t\evi U7rct^eiv, co 8e /xv[ vTTctpx^ 

(T^^tCtTWV ' TOU fXSV ycLp V7T0 TO <rVfX7TSpcL<rfXCL OVK ECTCLl, TTCLVTi VTTCLpX^ , SK ^pEVtfcOV d/Xtpolv dXY[$£S £CTcLl TO OVfX- 

11. tw( a, tiv\ C. (1 24. h cXut r£i B. H 26. <V» C. H cvWoycrfu.k A. II 36. clvt) C. 

i.i[A,i! C. II 9. <>{>&' ort pr^. II 16. {jTroK^i r£t AB. II 19. kXx X ^of C. II 20. x*t] eu C. II 21. \>irio%iti C. II 23. \i xutcu] ixxtirxi B. II 
25. o\hYikU<; C. II 26. a^'(5ei«y C. II 21. tui om ABC. II 28. iXKoL t^ fc\nip«* om B. II 36. &u C. II 39- 'w ^ *' wpX 1 » w*M Xdfat p. C. 



54 ANAATTIK.^N nPOTEPSlN B. 

iripcurfxct . cfxatoog cfe cfetx^STctt K * L - edv Ittl ti ^pevcfvig v\ fxavr.iKv) lctTpiKY\. kv\(p$ivTcg «v Tt.ftev. A fxv\cfev\ ra. B,. 

&ULTEpa kv\cp$Y\. edv cf v) eTepct.Te$v\ -^evcfv^g, Tv\g. fxev Trpoo- tm cfe -B.7ravTi ,ra T, dkv\$eg 'icrctL .' tq rvfXTT.ipctrfxct. Kcti el 

iv\g .oky\g. 'pevcfcvg «<n#, »f<» t*k AB, »x ecrcti tc rvfxiri- fxv) r okn. ipevtfris v) B T dkk' eTrt Tt, Kctt XToog ecrctt to rv/x- 

pctrfxct ctkv\$ig, ty\s cfe B T ecr.ctt. kiyco cf' r okv\v -pevtfv\ ty)v Tripctr/xct dkv\$ig.. icfev ydp Kookvet to A koci tw B Kctt tw 

ivctvTtctv, oTcv el fxr,cfev\ inzctpx^ TTttvTi eikv\7rictL v\ ' ,el TrctvTt 5 r Ikco vrrdpxjtv, tc fxivTot B Tiyl toS T, cTov to. yivog tZ> 

u,Y,cfev\ v7rdox slv - 'icroo:ydp to A tw B fxv\cfev\ virctpx^-, to eTcfet Kcti ty\ cftctcpopct' tc ydp X^oocv. TTctvrt dv$.pco7rco kcu 

$1 B TCO T TTCtVTL. CtV cfvj Ty)v fX£V B T TTpOTCfTW kctftoO TTCtVTL 7T£^W, .0 <f dv$pC07TOg TlVl TTeQop KCtt K 7TCLVTI. tl KV .TO 

dkv\$v) 7 t/jv tfe to AB •pevby, r oky\v, kol\ TTctvrt vlrctpx^ tw A tt.clvtl too B koli to B TVctvTi tw PA^fel, to A nrctVTi 
B to A, dcfvvctTav Ta rvfXTripctrfxct dkv\$eg .eTvcti' icfevi ydp too T vTrctpfcei' 07rep. v\v dkv\$eg. ofxc.icog cfe Kctt <repy,Tt.KY\<; 
i)7rv\px e 7 & v r, eiTrep wto B, fxycfevi to A, to cfe B TretvTf 10 »«r>i? TY\g A B. 7rpcTctreoog. evcfix £ Tctt. ydp to A fXv\Te tw.B 
tw P. ofxctoog cf' itf el to A tw B 7rctvTi u7rcto;££i >ccu to fxr\Te.Too T fxv\cfevL v7r<xpx £ w, to ftenot B tjv<.tc2 r, oiay 
B t.w F TTctvTi, lk.Y><pSv\ y y) fxev to B T dkv,$Y,g TrpoTcttrig., v\. to yivcg too e^ ctkkov. yevovg etfrei Kdi foixcpopct' to .yctp 
i% to AB \pev$Y\g okq, kcu fxyftevi co to B., to Ay to trvfx- XJ^ocv ovre. (ppovY,<rei ovhfxict inrctpx^ xts. .$efjopY\TiKY\, y) m 
Trepcto-fxct -pevbog ecycti ' TrctvTi ydp vTrttp^ei t£o T to A r (ppovY\<rig tivi $eoopy,TtKY\. el «v kY\(p$eiYj to fxev A. fxv\^evt tw 
Ei7rep u> to B, nrctvTi to- A, to fre B TrctvTt. too T. cpctyepat^B, to cfe B 7W,'Ti t.w T, ifreyi too T to A vTrctp^ei.' tovto 
?r ot< Tv\g 7rpcoTY,g ^okng kctfx(Sa.vofxevY\g -pev^g, ectv ts Kot-r ^'.»jv dkvfieg. * ... 

7ctcpctTiKY\g ectv Te crepv\TiKY\g , Tv\g cr' erepctg dkv\$\ig, i ytve- 'ExL <^e twv ev ^gpei <rvkkoyt<rfxoov evdiexeTcti Kct\ tyJs. 

Tctt dkY\&eg to cvfxnrepctrfxct . fxv) okY>g cfe kctfx(3ctvafxevYi.g: 7rpooTv\g TrpoTdreoog okY t g M<rv,g \p£v^g rv\g d" hepctg dkv\(Bs. 
ipev^xg ecrctt. el ydp to A tw' fxev T 7rctVTt vircipx^ T( ? dkv\$\g . eTmxi. to <rvfX7Tepct<rfxct, Kctt eTrt ti •yevboug Mrv\g Tv\g. 
^B Ttvi, tc cfe B 7r*VTi tu/ T, cTov ^aov kvkvoo fxev 7rct\/Ti 20 7rpcoTY\g Tvig cr' eTepctg: r 'ckv\g dkv\<%g^ Kctt t*;? fxev dkY\<%g TY,g 
kevKOo cfe Tivij to cfe kevKov TrctVTt kvkvoo, edv k'/\cp6y\ to A cf' ev fxepei "^evci^g, Kctt dfxcpcTepcov \pevfruiv* iSev ydp koo- 
Tfctvri t"oo R-Kcti to. B TTctvri tu T,.to A TrcuvTt tw T inrdp^eu kvet. to Ara fxev B fxv^evt vTrctpxetv tw Se T Ttvt, Kcti 
dkvficog' TTctg ydp KVKVcg ^uav. ofxotcog Se Kcti el <repv,TtKov to B t<2 T tivi, oiov XJjiav ovcrefxtcZ x ion kevKW cre tlv) 
etv\ to AB* eyxup s ? 7^f To: A tco fxev B. Tm V7rdpx^ vnrctpx^y **** % X L( ^ V ^svku Ttvt. el i fxercv Te$etY\ y) X l ^ v y 
ru 8e T fXY^evt, to cfe B irctnt tu T, cTov "Quov Ttv\ .kev- 2 $ TrpooTcv ck to "Qcoov, Kctt kY[(p$eiY\ tq fxev A ckoo tw B vTTctp- 
ym X^ n ^' x£ e i ul %> kevKov cfe TrdcrYi x LCVl - ■* * v XY\<p$etY\ X ZiV -> 7 ° ^ ^ TlVi T V -^' ** j u,gy -^- -^ °^ 'pevcrY,g^, v) 8e 
to fxev A fXYjfrevi too B, to v cfe B 7T«,vt! tw T, to A ovc)ev\ B T oi>i.»i5>]?, Kctt to <rv.fX7repctrfxct dkvfieg. ofxcicog cfe Kctt 
tw r V7rctp\\ei. edv cf' v) ■ fxev A B TrpcTctcrtg okvi kvjcp&Yi cr-epY\TiKY\g wv;? t>j? AB 7rpoTct<reoog ' eyx°°P £ T ydp to A tw 
dkY\$v\g, v) cfe B F okv\ "p/evcfvg, ecrcti <rvkkaytrfxog. dkr,- fxev B okco vTrctpxEtv tw cfe T rtvt fxvj vTTctpx^-, to /xev- 
6v\g' icfev ydp Kookvet to Ara-B Kctl tu T tt^xvti V7rctp-3Q roi B -Ttvt too T V7rctpx^ v r ctiov to ^wov dv$pco7rco fxev TrctVTi 
X £LV i ™ fxenot B fxv\cfev\ tw T, cTov crct -tov ctvrov yevovg vrrctpx £ ^ kevKCo cfe. tlvi ovx eTrerctt, o cf dvQpooxog tlv\ 
zicfvi fxv) vtt' dkkvjkct' to ydp X^cocv Kcti Ttt.ttoo Kcti dv$pco7r.co kevKU V7rttpx e h %cr' et fxerov re$evTog t« dv$pco7TH kvicp$eiYi 
V7rdpx eL -> r t7T7rog cf' ovcfevi .dv$poo7rcc. edv ovv kYi<p$Y\ to A to A . [XY)c\evL tw B V7rctpx^ v •, to cfe B Ttv\ tu . T vTrdpxetv, 
TntvTL tco B Kcti to B 7rctvTl TcS T, dkv\$eg ecrctL- to- rvfx- dkv\$eg ecrcti rra rvfXTrepctrfXct -pevcfxg Yrv\g r akv\g rv.g A B 
Tripctrfxct, Hptunf okY,g \irY,g. rv^g B T TrpcTctreoog. cfxoioog^ TrpcTctreoog. kocl el eiri tl 'pevcfvfi v) A B 7rpoTctrLg, ecrcti to. 
ok Kcti crepY t TiKV\g ar-fig TY,g A B TrpoTctreoog. evcfixerctt ydp rvfXTripctrfXct dkv\$ig. icfev yctp Kookvei to A Ktti tco B. Kcti 

TO A fXY\Te TW B fXVjTe TW r fXY,cfeVL V7TctpX £LV -> f-V,cf\ TO^ B TCO T TtVi V7TCtpX £ l- v , XOU TQ B TW r TlVl V7TCtpX £ L v -> CjTcV TO 

fxv\cfev\ too T, cTov roTg e^ dkkov yivcvg etcferi to yevag'- XJocv tlvl Kctkco Kcti tlvl fxeyakoo, Kctt to Kctkov tlvl fxeydkco 

TO* yctp XJfOV OVTS fXOVrLKY\ OVt' LCtTpiKY\ V7TCtpX £ t, CVcY V-7rctpX £ lV. edv W kY\(p$Y, TO A 7roWTt TOO B KCtL TC B TiVi TW F, 



8. rh om JBC. II 12. X^fl?i B. II 13. w AB. II 22. 7 xx\ rh C. H rh A-T oml II 23..dx»j&? AC. II 37. rl <t om C. tl 

jwr^] ju.iJt£ codices. 

4. kcCi alterum om pr A. H 7. o — %s^u om pr A. II 20. oXrj? om BC. II p.h pzi^ows *X»j3flv? C. H 28. »cj-jj; cA»js t?s. B. II 
35.- to om ^J?. 



ANAAYTIKHN IIPOTEPftN B. 55 

v\ fxh i.B 7tpo7curig ewt.fi ipevcfr.gEcrdi, y\ : $t B. T -dkrr tu'T *x vTtdpxzi- tc fxh w ' <rvfX7te / pa<rfJ,& dkvftk, cu <5i 
$yg, kou-70 <rvfX7tspa<rfXcL 'dkr,$sg. optctug h Kctl <r~£pr\T tw\g .7tpoTa<retg -psvhlg. 

ovrr,g Tr\g AB TtporacrEug' 01 yap avTot opoi Ecrcviat kcu 'Ey cfe tu> fxecru cr%>5/ActT/ 7ta.vr.ug eyxwpet ^* *^£U-3 

u<ravrug Kstfxsvot Ttpog 7r,v dTtc&stfyv. 7taktv sl.^.fxh AB <$uv dkr\$eg <rvkkoy(<ra<r$at , kcu d/x<po7spuv tuv 7tpo7a<rsuv 
<&kr,$r\g r\ c% B T -p^svcfrtg, dkr\$sg scrrxt to\ <r.vf*,7t£pa,<rfla. 5 okuv Tpsv&uy kajxfiavcfxevuv kou ht 71 SKa7epag,- kcu 7r\g 
i<fev ydp Kukvsi to.A tu fxsv. B Zku. WKOqZpff i tu rSe F -fxh dkr&g Tr,g 6% -ps'jb%g.'io-r,g 'dkr,g,o TtOTsp/XTW -psv<Yig 7i$e- 
Ttvt, kcu .70 B tw-_T fxrcfevi. v7rcCpxstv,: ohv "C^uov kvkvu -fxevr\g, kou el dfxcphepat ht ti -Lpev&eTg,. KcCt el ri.fj.ev <wtku$ 
fxh Ttawt fxikavt 3s Ttvt, -kvkvos .cfs icfsvt fxskavt. .ucf tt .dkr,$r]g- r\ -<)' aririft .'ptvdyg; Tctti ei r\ /xh ckr, -pev$r]g -^ 
k%<p$e(r\ Ttavn. tu) B to A kcu to. B tivi-tu T, .dkv\$eg <¥ ht ti dkr,$r\g, kou ev. Tolg KctAokv kcu h\ tuv ev fxepei 
ecreu -70 <rvfX7teparfxa, 'pevbzg ovrog tk B F. :bfxa(ug <fe Kat io <rvkkcyt<r/xuv. et ydp.70 ;A tw ^uev B firfievi vTtdpxet 7U 
qEpr\7txr,g kafj,(2avofxsvr\g 7r\g AB 7tpo7av£ug. iyxupe? yap .fre.T /nav7i, vtov "^uov k($u fxh v<kvt-T7t7tu <fs Ttavrij edv 
Tb A .7U fjJev B .fxr\cfev\ tw Se T 7tv\ fxr, .V7rdpx > stv, tv kvantug 7s$u<rtv cu TtpoTdrstg ■ kcu krj<p$f^ to A tw f*h .B 
fj,sv70t B fxrtSen tw T, oioy- tq iysvog.-7u e^ eLkkcv ysvovg TravTt tw <fe T p,r\<kv(, ek .'psvfruv okuv 7uv Ttpo7<&reuv 
e(<ht Kat'.7u <rvfJ,(3efir,KC7i 7o\g.:xw7^ stSecrt' tc ya,p Z,uov a,kr\$\g .scrat to <rvfj,7rip<urfia. if/,o.tug M kcu el tw fj,h B 
a,pt$fj,U fj,h i&svt vTtapxst kevKU <fe- 7tv(, o xV dpi$fj.e.g 1S itavrt 7.u<j% Y fw&evt vTtapx^ -70. A' .h yap amog t<rtu 
vfrsvt kevKU' • ea,v w fj,e<rov 7s$r\ o zipt$fj,ogj K<tt kr\<p$r\ 70 <rvkkoyttrfj,og, 7taktv si r\ /a,h hepa, 'dkr\ -p/ev$r,g r\ <)' e7epa, 
fj,ev A 'fj,r\Sevi tu B, to <^g B rttv) 7u T, to A 7tv\ t.<Z T ckr, d\kr\$r,g' ov<fh yap Kukvet td A xcu. tu B kcu tu T 
QvX-VTtap^et, 07t£p.r,v a,kr,$sg' Kat r\ fj,h AB TtpoT.acrtg otayTt vTtapxttv., 70 fcevTot B fj,r,t\£y\ tu T, oTov to yevog 
oLkr,$*/\g , --vi &e B T "ipev<fr\g. Kat .el htt Tt -^ev<fr,g r\ AB, 7o7g fj,r\ V7t'. akkr\ka eiSertv. 70 yap Z,uov Kat litTtu 7tav7t 
%p£v<fr\g.^£.:Ka\ .r\ B T, Etrat 70 xrvfj,7te / pa<rfj,a,dkr\$s / g. icfey 20 Ka\ dv$pu7t'u, x.at i<fsig kv$pu7tog 1"it7tog. eav i>v kr\<p$y to 
yap Kukvst 70 A 7u B 7tvt v.at ru.T 7tv\ vTtapx^v eko- T^toov tu fxsv Ttavrt tu\<% fj,r,<fsvt vTtapxstv, $ fjJev lky\ T^ev- 
TepUj 70 c% B fj,r,hv\ 7u T, 'oTov . el £vaV7tov:7o B 7u ' F, <fr\g : £<pat r\ <¥ okr, -<akr,k\g, >ko-\:70 <rvfj,7tepa<rfj,a dkr\$eg 
a,fj,<pu & <rvfu,(Ssfir,KC7a 7$ av7u ysvsf 70 yap \uov 7tvt ytpcg o7t^7spuiv 7s$sv7og t« qspr{ttw. .koa eI r, hspa eti( *tt 
kevKu Kat :7tv\ fiskavt .uTtap^et,: kevKov <$'\ ichvi. fiskavt. ^g-j^/,?, r\ ■(? hspa 'okr\ dkr,$r,g. . eyx^P^- 7&P ?o A tw 
edv ovv kr\cp$r, to .A--7tav7i tu :B kcu to B rrtvt tu T, 25 fJ,h B -rtvt v7tapx £iV T( ? 4* P 7tavTt, to ■ju.snot B. fx,r,<fev) 
dkr\6eg s<rdt 70 <rvfj,7tspa<rfj,a. Kat crspr-tKng ■ t% ka/J,(Bavo- tu T, .oiov ^ov kevKu /u,ev Tm- xopaKt <Te 7t.av7t, Kai 70 
fj,evr,g 7r,g AB u<rav7ug ' . 01 yap- avro\ %poi ko\ uravTug ksvv.ov ibsvt Kopaxt. eav iv kr\<p$r\ to A :7u :fj,h B fj,r\^ev). 
7e$r\rov7at Ttpog 7r,v d7to<fei^tv. Kat- dpupo-epuv : fre ^ev$uv 7u $e T 'cku. v7tcLpx siv > -V- f^ sv - A^B Ttporracrtg hri rt.-^wr 
i<ruv scrat to a-vfj,7tspa<rfj,a dkr\$tg' eyx 00 ?^ 7&P T0 A 7u <fr\g, r\ &' A F okr, dkr\.$r\gj k<u to ■vvfj,7tepa<r/xa, dkr\$eg. 
fxh B fj,rj<fevt 7u $e T 7tv\ v7t.apx^ v ->'To:fJ,sv70t B fJ,r,<\svt 30 Kat fj,£7a7t$£fj,svM <\s 7ov tzzprrttKM u<r<x,vtug' <fta y.ap 7urv 
tw r, oiov 70 ysvo?' T(J5 e£ akkov ysvovg stcfst Kat xu rvfj,- clvtuv 'cpuv r\d7to^si^tg. Kai sl r\ Ka7xt,<pa7tKr\ 7tpo7ao~tg erti 
(£efir\K07i 7olg e't<$s<rt 7otg :av7cv' K^ujiv ya,p- dpt$fxu fxkv 7t r ip£V.<Jr[g, r[:<fe.<repY,TiKvi 'vkv\ d,kr\$r\g. i<Tey yap Kukvet T.o 
i£ev\ kevKU £e 7tvt vitapx^j Kat dpt$fxog i<fevi:kevKU. A tw fxh B . 7tv\ V7tapx^ v -'TU <fe T oku /xr) v7ta,px*w, 
eav vv kr\<p$Y, to A Ttavrt tu B Kat to B .tiv\ tw F, to Kat 70 B [xr\&svi 7.u T, oiov 70 X,ugv kevKu fxh 7ivt tottij 
fxh o~vfX7tspa<rfxa dkr\$eg, at oe 7tpo7a<r£tg a/x<pu •pEv&sTg. 35 <f' iS~efxta, ko,\ 70 kevKov icfefxta 7tt77r\. ucr' eav kr,<p$ri 70 
hfxotug $e Ka\.<rspr,7tKr,g M<rr\g 7r\g A B. ovcfev.ydp Kukvet A oku 7u B V7tdpx^ v tu Se T .fxr\$Ev(, r\ /xh AB htt 7t 
70 A.7U fxh B oku v7tapx^ v tu <$e T tiv\ fxr) vTtdp- r p£v<i>r\g, r, £' A F okr, akr,$r,g, ko\ 70 <rvfX7tepa<r/x,a dkrf 
X £lv i fwi&e 70 B fxricfevt tw T, oicv X^uov kvkvu fxev 7ta,v7t $eg. kcu et dfxcpcrepat at TtpoTcLo-stg E7t( ti \Psvcfs7g, scrat 
fxs?.avt <5e Ttu i'x V7tapxet , KVKVog <T «^evi fxskavt. ucr' e\ to <rvfX7r£paorfxa, a,kr&(g. kyxupst ydp to A ko\ tu B kcli 
kr,<p$£ir\ 70 A [xrfavt tw B, to ^e B Ttv) 7u T, to A 7tv\ 40 tw T 7tv\ vTtdpx^tv, m <5e B fxr^evi 7u T, otov Zuov kcli 

6. tS W] to Sk A. II 12. jAi om C. II 16. ?v om B. II 17. to A tiI tu T om A. U 34. Zv om C. 

1. i7rap|si C. II 3. \A.ivu\ Sevripui C. II 20. to ^oi om JBC. II 24. SXr\ om C. II 27. to A om JB. II ^ev om C. I) 
35. «V A. 



56 ANAAYTIKflN nPOTEPflN B. f 

Xsvkoo Ttv) ko,\ [xiXa.vt Ttvt, to <fs Xsvkov vfev\ [xixa,vi. ecLvZv edv ovv Xy\<P&y\ to A tw [xev B %Xw inrapxw, tw <fe V Ttvi 
XYi<p$r) to A tw fxev B ir&vTi too <fe T fxr\hsvt, ctfxcpoo fxsv a.1 fxr) S7rsr$cu, cu [xsv TrpoTcLostg •psvfrsTg, to os <rv[X7ripa.<T[xa, 
TTQOTcLreic, S7TLTI -psvcfslg, to os <rv[X7ripa,<rfxa. dXv\$ig. b/xoLoog dXv\$sg. 
<fs kcu /xsTa,Ts$sL<rr\g Tr\g <rspY\TLKr\g <ftd toov ccvtoov opwv. *E<rTa,i oe ko,i sv tw sVp^aTW <rXY}f*cni ha. •p/sv&oov b 

$ctvepov <5e kcu sttl tuov ev [xipet <rvXXoyt<r/xoov' ovbsv 5 dXr\$ig, KO,t d/x<pOTipu>v -psv&oov icroov oXoov kcu £7rt Ti sko,- 
ydp kcoXvsi to A t<5 fxsv B ita.vTt tw <fe V Ttvt V7rdpxstv, Tipa,g, ko,\ Tr\g fxev erripa.g dXr\t%g oXv\g Tr\g <Y errepcxg -pev<&g, 

KO.\ TO B TW r TtVt [Xy) VTTcLpX^tV ', 0T0V XwOV TTOjVTt dv$pOO- KO,\ tSj? [XSV S7TL Tt ^pevSovg TY\g <¥ "o>\.Y$ dXv\$OVg , KO.i dvO." 

ttoj XevKoo <fe tlvl, ctv$punrog 6s tlvl Xsvkw *x vTra.p^ei. vraXtv, kcu bcrctxuJg dXXoog syx u P e ^ [*>ETc<,Xa,@e?v Tctg irpo- 
edv w Te$Y, to A tw [xev B [xv\<fsv) vTrctpx^tv tw <fe T Ttv) TO.<retg. ovbev ya,p KOoXvet /xyits to A [Xr\Te to B [xr\<\evt tw 
V7rcLpx £l > '•> *l P** v ko.QoXk TrpoTcurtg oXy\ •pev$Y\g, y) £' ev fxe- 10 T v7ra,px^^, to /xsvtoi A Ttvt too B V7ra.px^ v ■> ol0V ** <w~ 
pet dXr\$y\g, ko,\ to <rv[X7ripa,<r[xa. dXr\$ig. oo<ra,vToog 8e ko,i Bpooirog «Te ireXov irfsvt d-pAJXV zKeT&t, a,vbpooirog [xevTot tivi 
KO,Ta,<pa,TtKY[g ka,[xpa,vo/xivY[g Tr\g A B * ey^w^e? ya,p to A 7re£w vira,px^- ^v ovv Xyi<P$yi to A kcu to B 7rct.m fw T 
Too [xev B [XY[$ev\ tw <5"e T Tiv\ [XY[ V7ra,px^v, ko,\ to B tw V7ra.px^^, a,t [xev 7rpoTa.<retg oka,t ypevfrelg, Td <^e <rv[X7rspc(r- 
r Ttvt [XYJ v7rdpx£W> mov to XJZov ovfrevt ct^tj^w , Xeu>cw <r[xa. dkY,$eg. dbra,vToog <fe ko,i t>j? /xev crepr,TtKY[g Tr\g ve ko,- 
8e Ttvt &x V7ra,pxei > *«•) to v aipvx ov *X vnclp^st Ttvt Xsvku. 15 Ta,<pa,TiKY[g «en-i?. eyx^psT ya.p to [xev B [xrfievt tw T V7ra,p- 
edv ovv ts$y\ to A tw [xsv B 7ra,VTi tw <fe T tiv\ /xy, vircLp- x HV > 'to ^e A 7ra,vr\, Ka.t to A tivi tw B [xy\ VTra.px^ 
X £LV -> V f^ v A-B 7rpoTa.<rtg, r) ko,$oXov, oXy, 'psevbrig, y) <% cTov to [xiXcvi i$sv\ kvkvui, X^coov <fs 7ra,vri, ko,i to Xuovtro 
AT dXY,$Y\g, kcll 7o o-j[X7ripa,<r[xa, dXY[$ig. kcu Trk [xsv ko,- 7ra.VTt fxiXa,vi. ucr' dv XY[<p$Y, to /xsv B 7TO,vtl tw T, to h 
6oXov dXY[$ovg Ts$et<rY,g, Tr,g <f sv [xipst ipsvfrovg. ov<fsv ydp A [xy,$svi, to A tiv\ tw B *X vnctptst ' kcu to [xev <rv[X- 
KioXvst to A ^re tw B ^Te tw T ovfrsvi sTrs<r$a.t, to [xiv- 20 Tripcurfxa, dXvfiig, a.1 <fs 7rpoTa,<rsvs \^eu<5e??. kcu el sttl ti 
toi B Ttv\ tw f fXr) v7rcLpx^ v , °?° v X,t>jov ov£sv\ dpt$/xoo &<Y sKa.Tipa, 'psv^g , scra.i to <rv[X7repa,<r/xa. dXv[$sg. ioev ya,p 
d-pvx^-) K£t ' c dpt$fxog~Ttv\ d-pvxy &x i^^cu. sdv ovv rs$y kooXvsi ko,i to A kcu to B Tm tu> T V7ra.px^ v , xcu to 

T-0 A TW /XSV B fXYI<fsv\ TW <fs T TtVt, TO [XSV O-VfXTripclO-fXOj A Ttv\ TW B, OIOV TO XsVKOV KcCt TO KO.X0V TtVt XjpOO V7rO,p- 

ecrcu dXY,$eg kcu y, ko,$oXov 7rpoTacrtg dXY[$r\g, y) <f sv /xipst %ei, ko.l to Xsvkov tivi kccXw. sa,v ovv ts$y,. to A ko,\ to 
•pev<fr\g. kcu Ka,Ta,<pa,TiKY[g <fe Tr\g Kd$oXov Tt$efxivr\g oo<ra.v- 25 B 7ra,vTt tw T V7rapx^ v , <*-' [xev 7rpoTa,<retg S7rt ti -p/evfreTg, 
Tug. eyxwpz? y&p ro A ko,\ tu> B kcCl twT oXco V7ra,px^ v , to <fe <rv[X7repa,<r/xct dXr\$ig. kcu <repY\TLKr\g <fs Tr\g K.T tl- 
to fxivTot B Ttv) too T [xy\ s7rs<r$a,t, oTov to yivog tw ef^ei $sfxivY[g bfxoloog. *<fsv ya,p kooXvsl to fxsv A t<v} too T fxr) 
kcCl TY,.S~ta,<popS,' to ya,p Xjuov ttcivtl dv$poo7ru ko.l "oXw TrsXJo V7ra.px^ v •, to <h B tzw V7ra.px^ v , x&l to A twB [xy\ 7ra,VTi 
e7rsTa,t, dv$poo7rog <¥ i 7to,vt\ 7re^w. ucr' 1 dv Xr\<p$r\ to A too uxap^etv, otov to Xsvkov tlvl [ww &x v' K a,pxei, to <fs ko,- 

fXSV B OXU) V7TCi,pXStV, TW <fs T TLVL fXY\ V7rO,pX^ v , ■ r) fXSV KO,- 30 XoV TLVL VTTOjpX^, K0.1 TO XeVKOV & TTOjVTL KO,XoO. COCr' dv 

SoXov TrpoTao-Lg dXr\$Y\g, r) <J' ev fxipei \pevSr\g, to <5e <rv[X- Xy\<P$y\ to fxev A [XYi&evt tuj T, to <fe B 7ra.vTt, d[x<poTepa,i 
iripa.<r[xa. dXY\$ig. <pa.vepov <fe kcu oti e^ d[x<poTipoov \psv3'oov fxsv cu nrpoTa.o-sig sttl Tt ^psvbslg, to <fe <rvfX7ripa,<rfxa, dXr\- 
scrcct to <rv[X7ripa,o-fxa, dXr\$ig, e't7rep ev<fixsTO.t to A kcu $ig. u<ra,vToog <5e kcu Tr\g fxsv oXY,g •p/svfrovg TY\g <f oXr\g 
Too B >w1tw r oXu) V7ra.px^ v , to [xivTOt B tiv\ t<2 T fxr\ dXr\$ovg Xa,/x(Ba,vo/xevY i g. eyx^p^ y&P k&l to A KO,t to B 
S7re<r$a.t. Xr,<p$ivTog ya,p tk A tw /xev B ^^evl tw <fe T Ttv\ 35 7rotvri tw T e7re<r$a,t, to /xivTOt A tivi tw B /xy\ v7ra,pxstv r 
V7ra.px^ v -> dX /xev 7rpoTa,<retg dfx<poTepctt "pevfreTg, to <5e olov X^wov koll XevKov ttclvtl kvkvoo S7rsT0,i, to (xsvtol "Quov 
<rv/x7rspa,<rfxa, dXv\$ig. o/xotoog b% kcu KO,TY\yoptKr\g ov<rr\g Ty\g & TrctvTt vTraupx^ "Xsvkco. Ts$ivToov wopoov tovtoov, ea,v Xv\<p$^ 
k<x$oXov 7rpoTa,<rsoog , Tr,g <f sv fxipst <rspr\TtKr\g. syx^p^y^p to fxsv B %Xw tw T v7ra,px^ v -> t° ^s A 0X00 fxv\ v7ra,px^ 
to Atw fxev B fXY,<fev\ too <fe T 7r<xvTt e7re<r$ctt, kou to B y) fxev BT 'oXy\ scrcu dXr\$Y\g, y) frs K.T oXr\ -pevc\Y t g, kcu 
tiv\ tw r fxr\ vTta.pxWy °l° v XJjjiov g7rtcrY\/XY\ fxev ov<fsfxi£, dv-40 to <rv[X7ripa,7fxa, dXr,$ig. b/xotoog <fs K<xt el to [xsv BT 'psv- 
$poo7ru) <fs 7ra.vTL s7reT0,t, y) <5"' s7rtcjY\[XY, ov 7ra,vr\ dv$pu)7roo. <fog, to <fs KT dXr\$ig' ot ya,p <xvTot opot irpog ty\v d^ro- 

15. v% vTr&pyjiJ '« jx C, om B et pr C. II 2h. a&q&r/s om JBC. 

5. &hi]Qi.s— ovo-uy om C. II koX h' a.j.irporipooy A. II 7. xa,\ rfs /xh 'rrri ti ^eu^s om 2?. II 29. Xsvxovj xdXey AB. II xctAev] Xey-. 

Y.01 AB. II 37. fy TWY opuv TOIVTUV B. II 4-1. 01 7*pl X«i 01 C. \\ 0\,\)ToC\ TOLVTOL COfr C. 



ANAATTIKttN nPOTEP^N B. 57 

foifyv, fxiXctv-KVKVog-ct-pvx ^ *^* *«" £L dfxcporepctL "ori orctv Svo ex$ %roo 71720? ctXXv\Xct obcre Qarepv ovrog & 

Xctfx(2ctvoLvro KctrtupctriKctL. ovfrev yctp KtoXvei ro fxev B dvdyKV\g eTvcu Sdrepov, rovrov fxv) tvrog fxev &<Te Sdrepov ecrctt, 

rrctvr) rto T e7re<r$cti, ro <fe A oXcp fxv) v7rdpx £L v, kcu ro ovrog &' &x dvdyKY\ etvctL $drepov. rov <¥ ctvr* tvrog kcu fxv) 

A riv\ rco B vircLpxw, oTov kvkvco fxev nrctvrL £wov, fxiXctv tvrog, dSvvctrov e\ dvdyKV\g eTvcti ro ctvrd. Xiyco tY oTov ts 

cY «<W kvkvco, kcu ro fxeXctv v7rctpx £L riv\ ^cpcp. oocf dv 5 A tvrog Xevxx ro B eTvcu fxiyct e£ dvdyKv\g, kcu fxv) cvrog 

Xv\<p$v\ ro A kcCi ro B 7rctvr\ rcp T virdpx £LV -> v\ fx-ev BT XevKV t« A to B eTvcu fxiyct ej dvdyKv\g. orctv ydp rvcfi ov- 

oXv\ dXv\$Y\g, v) <Je.Ar oXy\ "pevchg, kcu ro <rvfX7ripct<rfxct rog Xevx% ts A to<5j dvdyKY\ fxiyct eTvcu ro B, fxeydXov 

dXv\$ig. b/xoitog <5e kcu rv]g AT Xv\(p$ei<rY\g dXv\$ovg' &cl Se tk B ovtos ro T fxv) XevKov, dvdyKVj, el ro A XevKOV, 

ydp roov ctvrtov opoov v) d-Ko^eL^ig. rrctXiv rv]g /xev oXvjg dXv\- ro T fxv) eTvcu XevKov. kcll orctv $vo ovrtov Qctripov ovrog 

6ovg wv\g, rng &' errL ri ypevcfovg. eyxoope? yctp ro fxev B 10 dvctyKv\ Qdrepov eTvcu, rovrov /xv) ovrog dvdyKvi ro A fxv) 

7rctvrt rtp T v7rctpx £L v, to <fe A rivi, kcu ro A nv\ rco B, eTvcu. tk c\y) B fxv) ovrog [xeydXov ro A ix °^ v T£ XevKov 

olov Mirovv fxev Tt&vri dv$pco7rco, kolXov & « -nctvri, kcu ro sTvcu. t« c% A y,v) ovrog XevKX, ei dvdyKv\ ro B fjciya elvcu, 
k&Xov rivL friTTofo vTt&pxzi- ectv ovv XvjcpSyj kcu ro A kcu o~vfxficLivei e% dvdyKY\g t« B fjceydxov fxv) ovrog ccvro ro B 

to B oXco rco T v-napx^v, r) fxev BT oXyj dXv[$v\g, v) h eTvcu fxeyct. t«to & ddvvarov. el ydp ro B fx-v) ecji fjceya, 

AT eiti ri ^evc\v\g, ro cfe <rvfj,7repcto-fA,cc dXvfilg. ofxoicog <Je 15 to A *k e^cu XevKov e£ dvdyKv\g. el ovv jxy) ovrog t»t» Xev- 

kcu Trf? fdev AP dXv,$ovg t^? SeBT ^pev&ovg eixin Xctfx- kov ro B ecrcu /xeycv, o-vfx^aivei, el ro B fin ecri fxeya,, 

ficcvofxevYig' fxerccreSevrcov ydp ruv ctvrcZv opcov ecjcu v> diro- eTvcu fxeya, cog &d rpioov. 

Seifyg. xcu Ttj? fdev qepv\riKvs rv\g $e KarcupariKYig i<rv\g. To §e kvkXco kcu e% dXXv\Xcov freiKvvoScii icri ro ^*5 

exei y&p 'ey%copel ro fxev B %Xco rco T v-Kapx^t T0 & e A tou <rvfJL,7:epdo-fJca,rog kcu rov dvdir&XLv rr) KacrviyopicL ty)v 

rivl, kcu orxv xrtog e%w<riv, « x<xvt< tw B to A, e&v Xvr 20 erepctv Xctftovra, 7rporct<riv <rvfJL,7repdvao-$cu rv)v Xonrv\v, v\v 

(p$v\ rc fdev B oXco rco T vTtapx^v, ro ok A fxv\<fev{, v) eXdfx(3avev ev Sarepcp <rvXXoyi<rfxcp. oTov el ecfei cfe7£cu ori 

fdev crepY\riKYi e7r( ri '*pev<$Y\g, v) <¥ erepa. oXv\ dXv\$v\g kcu to to A rco T 7xa,vr\ vTtdpx^-, ebei^e <W frid rov B, 7rdXLV el 

<rvfA,7repaj<r/xct. TrdXLv e7re\ MfteLKrcu ori T» fdev A fxv\c\evL Mlkvvol otl ro A tw B v7rdpx^-> Xaficov to /dev A rco T 

vTrapxovrog rw T , t» <^e B tw, eyxoope7 ro A nvi rco B ti7rapx £iV to <^e F tw B, kcu to A t<2 B* Trporepov cY dvd- 

fxr) vTrctpxzw, cpctvepov ori kcu t^ fxev KT oXv\g dXv\$ovg 25 ttclXlv eXct(3e ro B rco T v7tdpx £LV > v) el ori ro B rco T <Je? 

\so-Y t g, rvig cfeBT eTrl ri ipevtfovg, 'eyxcopet ' ro <rvfX7repct<rfxct t^el^cti VTrctpxov, el xdftoi ro A x<*t<* tk T, y\v <rvfX7re- 
eTvctL dXv\$eg. ectv yctp Xv\<p$v\ ro fxev A fxv\hevL rcoT, ro <Je pcto-fxct, ro tfe B Kctrd t» A v7rdpx £LV ' Trporepov cY eXv\- 

B irctvri, v) fxev AT "oXy\ dXv\$v\g, v) SeBT Ittl ri ^evcfvig. <p$v\ dvdTrctXLv ro A Kctrct t« B. ctXXtog cY ovk ecriv e£ dX- 

Qctvepov &e KctL Ittl TaJv ev fxipei <rvXXoyL<rfxcov ori ttclv- Xy\Xcov tfeT^ctL. eire yctp ctXXo fxicrov Xy-percu, ov kvkXco' 

rtcg ecrctL foct "pevfroov dXv\$ig. ol yctp ctvroL opoi Xv\7rreoL 30 ovcfev ydp XctfxftctverctL rcov ctvroov' eire rovrtov ri, dvdywi 

KctL orctv KctSoXov cotlv cu 7rporct<reLg, ol fxev ev ro?g kcvzyt Sctrepov fxovov' el ydp ct/xcpto, rctvro ecrcti <rvfX7ripct<rfXct, 

yopLKoTg, Kctrv^yopiKOL , 0/ cY ev rolg crepv,rLKo7g crepv\rLKOL. <5e? <^ erepov. ev fxev ovv ro7g fxv) dvrtcrpicpovo-Lv e^ dvctTro- 

\i<tev yctp $Lct<pipei fxv\<fevi v7rctp%ovrog Trctvri Xct(2e?v vTrctp- ^ewcTou rv\g eripctg 7rpord<retog yiverctL (rvXXoyi<rfxog ' vyctp 

%e.v, kcll rivL v7rctpx° v rog kcl$oXov Xct(2e?v v7rctpx £LV npog ecriv dTrocfet^ctL hd rovrtov roov %ptov ori ruj /xi<rco ro rpirov 

rv\v roov "opcov eK$eo~LV. ofxoLtog <5e kcll Ittl rtov crepviriKoov. 35 v7rctpx £L h rcZ Trpcorco ro fxirov. ev cfe ro?g dvri<rpi(povo-LV 

fyctvepov ovv oTi <iv ^ev v\ ro <rvfX7repct<r/xcL "pevc\og, ecri nrttvrct Se.KVvvctL &C dXXv\Xcov<, oTov el ro A kcu ro B 

dvctyy.vi, e^ oov Xoyog, 'pev&v) elvcti v\ Trttvrct v\ evLct, orctv kcu roT dvricrpi(povo-LV dXXv\XoLg. ^e^eix$oo yctp ro AT 

cY dXv\$ig, &k dvctyKYj dXv\$eg eTvctL vre ri tre 7rctvrct, dXX fod fxi<rov rov B, kcll ttclXlv ro AB fod re t« <rvy,7repct- 

ecri fXY\<fevog ovrog dXv\$ovg roov ev rto o-vXXoyio-fxcp ro <rvfx- <rfxctrog kcll (Tlcl rv\g BT Trpordcretog dvrL<rpct(pei<rv\g, clxrctv- 

Tripctcrfxct bfxoioog eTvcti dXv\$ig, » /xv\v e\ dvdyKv\g. ctirLov cY 4o roog cfe kcu ro BT hd re rov <rvfX7repd<rfxctrog kcll t>)? AB 

3. oXu? B. II 4. pb om Ji. II 13. tjvI tul Mvoh, A. II 16. Wl xi om pr C. II 20. hb ?y Mffi C. I 23. <rM i %7cioujx^a. aXtfls. 
■soiXn C. II 24. t£ T] t« 7 B. II 36. -^eu^? B. 

5 et 6. /*67* om AB. II 7. Asvxa o7ov t» C. II ttkt ofov rb C. II 8. pj r\ Xevxov C. II 12. wal fii^at C. II l4. <??•<« C. II 
22. Trctm rcS 7 C. II 23. fcixnis. C. II 25. vwxpy^ot BC. II on corr A. 

H 



58 ANAAYTIKHN IIPOTEPQN B. 

7xpo7c6rscog dvTecpa,fXfxevY\g. Ss? $e ty,v ts TB kcu tyjv BA rvKKoytr/xog dvrtcpa,(peirr,g Tr,g ixpoTa,recog' ev fxepet ydp 
7xpoTO,rtv d-KO&ethu' tclvtcus ya,p dvonxoSeiKTotg KsxpyfAsSa, dfxcporepou ytvovTou 0,1 7xpoTO,retg. Tr,v tf enxt fxepovgectv. <3e- 
/xovoug. edv ovv Kri<p$ri to B 7xo,vt) tco T vir&pxetv kcu to T <$eix$v y&p to A ko,to, Ttvog th Y tfta, tk B. ea,v ovv Kv\- 
txomt) tu. A, rvKKoytrfxog eccu th B npog to A. 7xa,Ktv <p$v\ to B 7xa,nt tw A ko,i to rvfX7xepa,rfxo, fxevr,, to B tw 
ia)y \Yj(p$YJ to fxev T txclvt) tco A, to tfe A 7ra,vTt tw B, 5 tco V vTxa.p^sf yivsrou ya-p to Txpcorov crp^vj/xct, kou to A 
7xa,vTt tuj B to r a,va.yKY\ v7xa,px^v. sv dfxtporspotg tfr) tov- fxerov. el tfe cepr\TtKog o rvKKoytrfxog , ty\v fxev ko,$oKx Txpo- 
Toig To?g rvKKoytrfxo?g v) TA 7xpoTa,rtg siKr\7XTa,i dv.o,7xo- Ta,rtv &k eci Se?^cu, tfto kou Txporepov sKex$V ty\v tV ev fxe- 
SstKTog' a,l ya)p erspou Ssbetyfxsvou v\ra,v. coc' c\v to.vty\v pst, sa,v fxsv hfxotcog dvTtcpa,(pr\ to AB oorTxsp ko,7ti tcov ko,- 
d7xotfsi^cofxev , o,7xa,ra,i erovTcu SeSetyfxevo.Lt\i dKKyKcov. eoov $oKx, &k ect, foa, TxporKrr^ecog <¥ ectv, oTov co to A tivi 
dvv KY\(p&Yi to r 7ra,vTt tco B kcu to B 7ra,VTt tw A v7xa,p- 10 fi,Y\ v7xa,px^, to B Ttvt vTxa.px^V d?J.cog ya,p ov ytveTcu 
%etv, dfxcporepoii Te a,t 7xpoTa,reig dTxoSeSstyfxsvcu Ka,fx(Ba,- rvKKoytrfxog Sta. to d7xo(pa,TiKY\v sTvcu Try kv fxspsi Txpo- 
vovToUy KO,t to T tco A dva,yKY\ vTxojpxstv. (pa,vspov ovv oti 7a,rtv. 

iv fxovotg Totg dvTtcpscpovri kvkKco kcu frt* dKKrfKcov svSsx^- 'Ev cfs tco SevTepco <rxY\fxa,Tt to fxev KctToccpctTiKov ovk6 

7a,i ytverScu rdg a,7xoc\et%etg , ev cfs To?g a,KKotg cog Txporspov ecrt &s?]ra,i tfta, toutk t« rp.o7xov, to cfs crspviTiKov scrtv. to fxev 
etTxofxsv. <rvju.@a,tvet <Ve kou sv Tovrotg o,vtco tw cfetKWfxevco 15 ovv Ka,TY\yoptKov ov fretKWTcu t\ta, to [jcy\ cLfupoTepctg etvcu 
Xpy\oSou Txpog ty)v ctxo<5ei^«v" to fiev ya)p T kocto, tk B ko,i ra,g 7xpoTa,o-etg KO.Tcupa.TtKdg' to ya,p <rvfX7xspa,<rfxa, <rspy\Ti- 
70 B ko,to) tk A tfstKWTai KY\(p$svTog tov T ko,to) t« A Ke- kov ecri, to 8e Ka,TY\yoptKov e^ dfxtporepcov etetKWTo KO/xor- 
yer$ou, to tfe T kccto) t» A foa) tovtcov fretKwrcu roov rxpo- (pcCTiKUV. to cfe creprfxtKOV cofre tfeiKWTcu. v7Xa,pxeTco to A 
7a,<recov, cocre rw <rvfX7xspa,<rfxa,Tt xpcojucsSa, ixpog ty\v d,7xo- 7xa,VTt tco B, tw 8e T fXY\<^svf <rvfX7xepa,<rfxa, to B ovt\evi 
Sefetv. 20 tw F. ea-v ovv KrttpSri to B 7xa,vrt tco A V7xa,px^v, tw tTe T 

'Tt7x\ 8e toov crspY\TtKcov <rvKKoyto-f/,cov oo&e ^sikvvtcu e^ fXYjtfsvt, dva,yKY\ ro A fxv\cfsv) tw T v7xa,pxw ytvsra,i ya,p 
dKK.Y\Kcov. ecroo to fxsv B 7xa,VTi tw T v7xa,pxov, to cfs A ov- to frevrepov tr^yj/Act, fxe<rov to B. et Se to AB <repY\TiKOV 
frevi twvB" <rvfX7xepa,<rfxa, %Tt to A ifrevt toov T. et oy\ txo,Kiv eKv\(p$Yi, $a,repov &e KO,TY\yoptKov, to Txpoorov e<ra,t o-xy\f^ct,. 
$e? <rvfX7xepocva,r$ou %Tt to A ovcfevi toov B, o 7xa,Kau eKa,- to fxev yocp T 7xa,vrt tw A, to tfe B avfrsvt tw T, uxr' ov- 
jSsv, ecrcu to fxev A fXY\<fev) tw T , to &e T 7xa,vTt tco B" r {rxco 25 $e v) 7co A to B* ovtr' dpa, to A tw B. tftd fxev %v t» 
ydp dva,7xa,Ktv v) 7xpoTct,<rtg. et tf oti to B tw T &e? <rvfX7xs- <rvfX7xspa,<rfxa.Tog Ka,t Trfi fxtcig 7xpoTa,<rscog ov yivsTo,t <rvK- 
poiva,<r$cu, ovk($' ofxoicog dvTtcpsrxrsov to AB* y) ydp o,vty) Koyto-fxog, 7xporK.Y\(p$ei<rY\g tV erepoug eccu. y\v tfe fxv) ko,$6- 
7xpoTa,rig, to B fxr,tfevt too A koi to A fXY\c\evt tw B V7xa,p- Kov o o-vK>voyt<rfxog Y\ y i\ fxev ev oKco 7xpoTa,rig ov deiKWTou 
X slv ' dKKa, KY\7XTeov, w to A fxvjtievi V7xa,px £ h T0 B txo,vtl tfta, ty\v clvty\v atTictv r\v7xep enxofxev ko,i Txporepov, y) t¥ ev juce- 
V7xa,px eiv ' e: >oo to A fX7\tfevt tcov T vTxccpx^v, OTxep v\v to 30 pet t\eiKWTcu, oto,v y) to ko,$oKov KonriyoptKov. v7xa,pxeTco 
avfXTxepocrfxa,' co fre to A f/,r\t\evi, to B etKr,(p$co Txctvri ydp to A 7xa,vrt tco B , tw tfs T fxv\ 7xa,vr'f rvfj,7xspa,rfj,a,'ET, 
v7xa,px £iv ' dva,yKY\ ovv to B txo,vti tu T vTxapx^- &cs sa.v ovv Krj(p$Yi to B 7xa,vTt tw A, tw Se T & 7ra,VTi, to A 
rpiuv ovtcov eKa,<rov rvfA,7xepa,rfj,a, yeyove, koii to kvkKco tiv) tui T ovx V7xa,pfcef fxerov B. el t¥ s<r)v v) ko,$6Kov <re- 
dTXotjsiKvvvou tSt' e<rt r to rvfX7xepa.rfxa, Ka,fx@a,vovTa, KO,t pr,TiKY\, ov Setx$vireTa,t r\ AT 7xpora,rtg dvTtrpcupsvTog t»AB* 
dva,7xa,Ktv ttiV erepa,v Txporccrtv ty)v Konxr)v rvKKoyil^erScu. 35 rvfx$a,tvet ya,p r, dfX(poTspa,g y) ty\v srspocv TxpoToirtv yivsr$cu 

'JL7Xt &s tuv sv fxspst rvKKoytrfxwv Trjv fxsv ko,$oKx 7xpo- d7xo(pa,TiKY\v, oocr' ovk eccu rvKKoytrfxog. dKK' ofxoicog 
Tsto"tv cvk scrtv d7Xo<5s?!ra,t fod tcov erspcov, Tr,v tfe ko,to, fxe- &etx$Y\reTcu cog kcu e7x) toov KO,$oK'ti, ea,v Kr\(p$Y], co to B 
pog ectv. oti fxev ovv &k eciv d7xoc\ei^a,i ty\v ko.$oK^, (pa,ve- rtvt fxr, V7xa,px e h to A tivi V7xa,px^ v ' 

pov' To fxev ya,p ko,$oKx beiKWTcu frta, tcov ko,$oKx, to tfs 'Etxi Se t? Tpirov rxv\f*>a,Tog %to,v fxev dfxcpoTepcu a.l'] 

<rvfX7xepa,rfxa, ovk eci ko,$oKh, tfe?^' hc tov rvfX7xepa,rfxa,- 40 TxpoTcLretg Ka,$oK\i K.Y\(p$urtv, xk evfrexeTau tfe?^cu S~t' dKKvi- 
7og $e?%cu kou TY\g sTepa,g 7xpoTo,rscog. tti %Kcog «<5e yivsrou Kcov to fxsv ydp ko,$6Kov SsiKWTcu tftd tcov ko,$oKov, to 

23. tZv B] tS /3 C. II 25. twv 7 JB. II 32. t3 7 ■xu.nl C. II Ai. ovVk ?Xu 9 C. 

7. fi(pu 6tw £cl» Q\xoiwsAB. II 9. fcx eV', && 7rpoa->,ri-^euji; cj' 6f» om AB. II u omA. II 10. pi \>iru.pxyt A. II 20. TtS <Jk 7 pjcW 
om B. II 24. 7*p om B. II 30. to om AB et pr C. II 33. V7rac%£i BC. II 40. *AX^Aw T>jy xclQqX* ■xacTtortv. ro A. 



ANAATTIKfiN nPOTEPflN B. 59 

<£' iv tovtco <TVfX7tepctTfXct de) KctTct fxepog, ooce (pctvepov oTt To <$"' dvTtcpe'(peiv ic) to fxeTctTt$evTct to TVftTripctTfxctS 

oKcog ovk ivfrexeTctt betfcctt btct. tovtov tov TXKfActTog TYiY 7rote?v tov TvKKoytTftov oti y\ tc ctKpov t<2 fteTCO o\>x vTroip- 
kcl&oKov irpoTctTtv. idv <$"' y) fxev y\ kcl$oKov v\ <f iv ftepei, ^et v\ tkto T'2 TeKevTctico. dvctyxY\ yap t» TVfXTrepcLTfxctTog 
7:ot\ /xev ecctt iroTe <¥ ovk ecctt. oTctv fxev ovv dfxcpcTepctt dvTtcpctcpevTog kcl) TY\g hepctg fxevovTY\g irpoTctTeoog dvcupet- 
KctTYiyopiKcti K.Y\<p$wTt Kctt to kcl$oKov yevY\Tctt Trpog tw ikciT- 5 <r$cu tyiv Konryv' ei yctp eccu, kcl) to TVfxirepcLTfxcL ecctt. 
tovi ctKpco, ecctt, otclv <$e Trpog $ctTepco, oxk ecctt. virctp- otctcpepet b% to dvTtKetfxevcog v\ evctnioog dvTtcpecpetv to tvu,- 
"Xj-Tif) yctp to A irctvTt tco Y, to <5e B Ttvt' TVfXTrepctTfxct Txepcto-ftct' ov yctp 6 ctmog ytveTctt TvKKoytTfxog exctTepcog 
to AB. ictv ovv KY,(p$Y\ to Y Txctvrt tw A vTTctpx^, to /xey dvrtcpctcpevTog ' byKov Se t«t' ec^ctt foaL tcov e-rofxevcov. Keyoo 
Y be&etKTctt Ttv) tw B vTtctpxov, to <$£ B Ttvt tw T ov fre- &' dvrtKe?T$cu ftev to Trctvrt tw ov -tclvt) kou to tiv) too ov- 
fretKTctt. KctiTot dvctyKYj, ei tc Y tiv) tw B, kcl) to B tiv\ 1° Sevt, ivctvTtcog 8e to 7ram tw ifrevt Kcti to tm tw ov tiv) 
tu Y vTtctp-xjetv. dKK' ov tclvtov ict Tccfe Tcofre kcu Tcfre vTtcLpx^v. ecoo ydp fre&etyfxevov to A KctTct t« Y frtoL /xe- 
TooSe v-rctpxetv' dKKct 7tpoTK.Y\7tTecv , ei to^£ tivi Tcpbe, Kctt cov t« B. ei <5»i to A kYicpSetYj fXYifrevt tw Y v7rctpx,etv, tu 
SctTepov Ttv) Twcfe. tovtov 0% XvicpQevTog ovKeTt yiveTctt iK t» b% B 7tctvTt, ovfrevt tw Y vTtctpfcet to B. kcu ei to fxev A 
cvfXTrepcto-fxctTog Kctt TY\g hepctg TzpoTcto-ecog o crvWoyto-fxog. fXYi^evt tco Y , ro <$p B 7rctvTi twT, to A ov TtctvTt tu B 
ei <fe to fxev B Ttctvt) twT, to b\ A Ttv) tco Y, ecpctt &e?- ^ kcu ov%t "oKcog ovbevt' ov yctp i&etKWTo to KctQokov b^tct T6 
jrctt to AT, oto-v kYjCpSvi to fxev Y 7tctvTi tco B vTtctpxetv, io"XjCtTov vxYifxctTog. o\cog fre ty\v Ttpog tw fxeiXpvt ctKpoo 
to 0% A Ttvt. ei yctp to Y TtctvTt twB, to o% A tivi tco B, itpoTcto~tv ovk eqtv ctvctTKevcto-ctt KctSoKov hct T>fc dvrtc?po~ 
dvctyKYi to A Ttvt tco Y vTtctpxtw' fxeo-ov to B. kcu oTctv ri <pY\g' ctet yctp ctvcttpelrctt Stct t» Tpnov o-XYifxctTcg' cLvctyKY} 
vi ftev KctTviyoptKYi y\ (fe cjepY^ttKYi, kclSoKov <5"' y\ KctTYiyoptKYi, yctp Ttpog to erxctTov ctKpov ctfxcpoTepctg Kct(2stv Tctg TtpoTct- 
b^etx^TeTctt y) eTepct. vTtctpxeToo yctp to B 7ravTi tw Y, to 20 cretg. kcu ei e^epYiTtKog o crvKKoyto-fxog, coo-ctvTCog. be&eLxfioo 
c% A tiv) fxv vTtctpx^u' o-VfX7tepctTfxct oTt to A Ttvt tw B yctp to A [XYi&evt tw r vTtctpx^v (ftct tov B. «>tw ioiv Kvr- 
oi>x vTtdpx^' ioLv °v v 7tpoo-KYi(p6^ to Y Ttctrti too B V7tctp- cp$Yi to A tw Y TtctvTt vTtctpx^v, tw 8e B fXYi&evt, ovfrev) 
X £ w> ctvctyKYi to A Ttv) tu Y fxvj vitctpxw fxeo-ov to B. tcov Y to B vitctpfcet. Kctt ei to A kcu to B 7r*vT{ tCo T, 
ot<*v <£■' v\ qepYfttKY] KctSoKov yevYiTctt, ov fretKVVTcti y\ krepct, to A Ttvt tw B' cLKK' ovfrevi vxYipx^v. 
ei /xy) uTTtep ern twv TtpoTepov, ictv KvicpS^, Z tovto tjw 25 'Ectv <$"' cLvriKetfxevoog ctvTtc^pctcpij to <rvfX7tepct<rfxct, Ktxi 

ixy] vTtctpx^i QctTepov tiv) vTtctpx^t °iov ei to fxev A fXY\- ot (rvKKoyio-fxot dvTtKet/xevot kcu ov KctboKov ecrovTctt. ytve- 
(Jfcy) twT, to (fe B Tivi / * <rvfX7tepct<rfxct oti to A Ttv) tco B Tctt ydp *] erepct TtpoTctcrtg iv fxepet, ooc^e K<tt to <rvfX7tepot- 
ovx v7t<tpx el ' iw ovv bfnffif'* wto A tzw fXYi vTtctpx^i <rfxct ecjctt KctTct ftepog. ecrco yctp K<tTY\yoptKog o <rvKKoyt- 
toY tiv) vTtctpx^-, dvcty-KYi to Y Ttvt twv B vTtctpxziv. ctK- (Tfxog, Kctt dvTtcpe<pe<r$co ovTcog. ovkovv ei to A ov TtctvTi 
Kcog <y ovk ectv dvTtcpicpovTct tvjv K<t$oKov TtpcTctcrtv b~e?£ctt 30 ?£ Y, t£> <$£ B 7r«,vr/, to B ov Ttctvrt tw Y' kcu ei to fxev 
Tr)v eTepctv' ovcfct/xcog yctp ecctt <rvKKoyi<rfxog. A ftYJ Ttctvr) tco Y, to fre B 7rctvT}, to % A ov TtctvTt tu B. 

Qctvepov «v ot< iv ftev tw TtpooTco <rx / l/ J ' a '' Tt *l & ^" ofxotcog <Je Kctt et cepY\TiKog o o-vKKoyto-fxog. ei yctp to A 
Ky\Kcov ftetfyg Stct Te t» Tphov Kctt b^tct t« Ttpmx ytveTctt 9JQ& tiv) too Y vTtctpx^-, ?$ $e B fXYifrevt, to B Tivz tw Y ovx 
fXctTog. KctTY,yoptKov fxev yctp ovTog t« <rvfX7tepct<rfxctTog (ftct intctp^ei, ovx ditKoog ov<fevt' Kctt ei to fxev Atw T Tivi, 
Tes Ttpcorov, cep"/jTtKov <5g 8tct th i<rx<tTov ' Kctfxj2ctveTctt 35 to <^g B 7rctvT<, oocTtep h dpxy iK.Y\(p$YI, TQ A Tivl TCO B 
yctp , oo tkto ftYibevt, $ctTepov TtctvTt vTtctpxztv. iv b% tco ftecco vTtcLpfcet. 

K<t$oKov fxev ovTog t« <rvKKoyto~fx\s &' ctvT* Te kcu frtoL t% 'Ettj tfe toov ev fxepei <rvKKoyt<rfxcov oTttv /xev dvriKet- 

TtpooT* crXAf^^og, oTctv <¥ iv fxepet, oi' ctvTet Te Kct) tou fxevcog dvTtcpecpYctctt to <rvfX7tepct<rfxct, dvcttpovvTcu dfxcpoTe- 
irx 017 *' i v °^ e T V 7 P lTC 9 $ 1 ' *wtk 7rctvT££. (pctvepov $e xcti pctt ctt TtpoTctretg, oTctv <$' ivctrticog, ovbeTepct. ov yctp eri 
oti iv tco Tpirco kcu tco fxecrco ot fXYi b~t' clvtcov ytvoftevoi^ <rvfx(2ctivet, Kct$'ct7tep iv To?g Kct$oKov, dvcttpeTv eKKet-rovros 
<rvKKoyio-fxo) v\ ovk ei<r) Kctrtd tyjv kvkKoo betfctv n dTsKelg. tou <rvfX7tepct<rfxctTog KctTd ty)v dvTtcpo(pY,v , dKK' ovfr' oKcog 

8. vTtoLpxw, t° H * tivI tS @, ro C. II 15. (Ai om JSC. II 26. vi-ic-yx C. II 28. ^r omA. II vTtipm tvtco t<5 C. II 38. <-%i\- 
pttro' x*i St* ra iT%i.r\s, "ctci,i AB. II 40. T<y prius om C. 

4. «,nig-pl(povTos A. II 6. oinurpcupuv JB. II 8. o\ir^pi^oiro<; C. II 19. ts ctxpov ro io-%ctroi C. II 21. rwi 7 v~rct,p%w AB. 

H2 



60 ANAAVTIKaNnPOTEPfiNB. 

dvcupetv. tfetfetx$oo ydp ro A >c*Tct nvog rov T. cvxovv a,v oocf ovx dvcttpetrctt ro AB. ictv tf dvrtxetfxevug dvrtcrpe<pY\- 
K.Y\<p$v\ ro A fxv\cfev\ tw T vTrdpx^v, ro <fe B rtvt, ro A tcu, dva,ipovvrcti dfxcporepat. el ydp ro B irctvrt tw T, ro 
tw B tw ou% vTrdp^ef xcti el ro A [XY\tfev\ twT, tw! £e A ju^evl tw B, ou<5ew t<2 T to- A* v\v tfe rtvi. irdKtv 
B 7rwn, cvtfevi rcp T ro B. <£><rr' dvcttpovvrctt d/xcporepctt. ei ro B x<*vt! rop T, to <5e A t/v) t<£ T, tw tw B to A. 
edv <f evctvrioog dvrtcrpa,<p% , itferepa. el ydp ro A tw rtp $ y\ ctvTY),tf d-xofotfyg xat el ro xaQoKov xctTY\yopixcv. 
r ixy) vvdpx^t rcp tfe B 7ra,vrt, ro B tw rcp T $x '^' <5e r* rptrov cx^ctrog orctv fxev evctvrtoog dvrt- 10 

vTrdpfyet. dKK* ovttoo dvatpstrou ro e% dpxhg' £v<5e%ero« crpetpY\Tcu rc <r'vfX7repct<rfxct, icferepa, roov 7rporct<recov dvatpet- 
ydp rtvt v7rdpx ei v xcu nvi fxvj virdpx^v. rv\g tfe xa,$oKv, tcu xctr' cvcfeva, roov <rvKKoyt<r/xoov, orctv tf dvrtxet/xevoog, 
TY { g AB, cKoog ovtfe ytverou <rvKKoyt<r/x6g' sl ydp ro fxev dfx<porepai xou ev cLircurtv. <fetfetx$u yap ro A rtvt rop B 
A tw twv r jxy) vTtdpx^i ro tfe B tw vxdpx^t, cvtferepct 10 virdpxw, fx(<rov <¥ eiKycpQoo ro T, ecroocrctv <fe xa,Qo\ov cu 
x&SoKov roov irpordceoov. bfxotoog tfe xcti sl crepY\rtxog b <rvK- irpord<retg. ovxovv edv Ky\<P$y\ ro A rtvt r<2 B fxv\ vTrctpx^v, 
Koyt<rfx6g' ei /xev ydp KY}<p$etY\ to A 7rara rop T virdp- ro <fe B nra,vr\ rip T, ov yiverou <rvKKoyi<r/xog t« A kcu 
X £iV > dvcupovvrcu dfxtporepai, ei tfe rtvi, ovfoTepa,. dTro&et- T6 T. ov<f ei rc A T<3 fxev B rtv\ {xy) virdpx^t, ru <fs T 
Ptg &' v\ o,vty[. Travrt, cvx scrcu tk B xa/t tk T <rvKKoyt<r/x6g. o/xotoog oe 

9 'Ev tfs to) cfevTspop crx^ctrt rv\v fxev nrpog ru (xetCpvt ^ htx^ercu xcti ei jxy) xaSoKts ctt Trpordcreig. v\ ydp dfxtpo- 

ttxpoo irporctcrtv ovx ecrtv dvsKetv svctvrtoog, oirorepoo<rovv TY\g repctg dvdym ycard fxspog sTvat fod TY\g dvrt<;po<pY\g, y\ to 
dvrtcrpo<pY]g yivofxevvig' de\ ydp ecjctt ro crvfx-rrepao-fxa, ev rca ko,$oKov Trpog r<2 eKctTTovfaxpoo yive<r$a,i' ovroo a ovx. yiv 
rpt-roo o-xyp&rt, xct&oKov <$' ovx y)v ev rovrcp <rv>-JKoyt<ffx6g. <rvKKoyi<rfxog cvr' ev ru irpooroo <rxf\f^ctrt ovr ev tw ^ecrc»;. 
T»5v <r' erepctv bfxoioog dvcttpY\<rofxev ty\ dvTtcrpo<pY\* Keyoo 8s sdv <¥ dvrtxstfxsvoog dvTi<rpe<poovrcti cti 7rporot<retg, dvatpovv- 
70 bfxotoog, ei fxev evctvrtoog dvTtcrpecpsTcti, evctvTtoog, si cf' 20 tcu dfxcpoTepctt. ei yctp ro A fxvicfevi tw B, to ^e B 7t<*vt< 
dvTtxeifxevoog, dvrtxetfxevoog. vira,px6roo ydp to A 7ra,vr\ tw tw T, to A ouoev* roo T' TrctKtv ei ro A tw fxev B fXY\- 
B, tw <5e r /xYicfevt' <rvfX7repct<rfxct BT. edv «v Ky\<P$y\ to S~evt, rw cfe T 7rctvrt, ro B cvcfevt tu T. xdt ei v\ erepa, 
B 7T«,vt} tw r virdpx^ xcti to AB fxevYi, to A 7ravTi tw fxvj xa.QoKx, oo<rctvroog. ei yctp tq A ^wj^evl tw B, to ^e B 
r vTrdpfcet' yivercti ydp ro Trpoorov <rxy\fxct. ei <fe ro B Tivl rcp T, ro A nvt rw T ovx vTrdpfcet' ei tfe ro A t<2 
<7rctvr\ tw r, to tfe A fXY\t\ev\ twT, to A « 7juvt} t<2 B* 25 jxev B fXY^evt, roo tfe T Trctvrt, ovtfevt tw T ro B. bfxotoog 
trXftfxa, ro erxctrov. edv <f dvrtxetfxevoog dvrtcrpct<pY\ to BT, tfs xctt si crspviTixog b <rvKKoyi<rfxog. tfetfeix^co ydp ro A 
jj ^t-ev AB bfxotoog tfsix%<rsrcu , v) Ss AT dvrtxetfxevoog. ei rtvt rcp B (xy) vTrctpx^, ecroo tfe xctrv\yoptxo\ fxev to BT, 
ydp to B Tivl roo T, ro tfe A fXY\Sev\ rcp T, to A tw tw dTrotpctrtxov tfe to AT' cvtoo ydp eyivero b <rvKKoyt<rfx6g. 
B ovx VTrdp^et. nrdKtv ei ro B Tivl twT, to tfe A 7T<*vTi orctv ^tev w T» evctvTiov KYitpQy rop <rvfX7repd<rfxctTt, ovx ecrai 
twB, to A Tivl rcp T, oocr' dvrtxetfxevoog ytverat b crvKKo-^ <rvKKoyt<rfxog. ei ydp ro A tw tw B, to tfe B 7iuvt< t<2 
ytcfxog. bfxotoog <% Ssix^ceroti xcti si dvdTrctKtv e%oiev ctl T, W y\v <rvKKoytrfxog t» A xat t« T. icV ei ro A rtvt rop 
irpordretg. ei tf ecrtv eVf fxepovg b <rvKKoyt<rfxog, evctvrioog B, tw <Je T fxv\hvt, vx y\v t» B xcti rv T <rvKKoyt<rfx6g. 
fxev dmcrpe<pofxevov t« <rv/x7repct<rfxctrog cvtferspa, roov 7rpo- cZcre ix dvatpovvrcu ctt irpor&cretg. oto,v <5e to ctvT^ei^evov, 
Tct<rewv dvatpetrctt, xct$a,7rep cvcf' sv ru Trpdorop Q~XKft>ctTt, dvatpovvrctt. st yctp to A TrctvTt rcp B xctt ro BtwT, to 
dvTtxeifxevoog tf' dfxtporepctt. xet<r$oo ydp ro A rcp fxev B 35 A 7rctvri tw T ' dKK' ifrevt V7r^px^v. TrctKtv ei to A 7tuvt! 
fXY\tfev\ vTrdpxetv, rcp tfe T rtvi' <rvfX7repa<rfxct BT. edv «v twB, tw tfe T fxv\tfevt, to B ovtfevi rop T' dKKd Trctvri 
re&vi ro B tw tw T xnrdpx^tv xctt ro A B fxevv\ , <rv/x7re- u7r^%ev. b/xotoog fre tfetxvvrat xat ei fxv\ xctOoKx ei<r\v cu 
pctcfxct ecrcu ort ro A tw rop T ovx v7rdpXM- dKK' ovx irpordcetg. ytverctt yctp ro AT xct$oKsi re xat crepY\Ttxov, 
dvv\pY\Tcti to e% dpxy\g' evtfexerat ydp rtv\ virdpx^ xou fxv) Sdrepov tf eirt fxepvg xctt xa,TY l yoptxov. ei /xev «v to v A 7rctVT} 
VTrdpx^tv. TrdKtv ei ro B rtv\ tw T xoa to A tw tw T, ix 40 ru> B , to ^e B tw t<2 T , ro A tw tw T <rvfx(Ba,tvei ' 
icrctt <rvKKoyt<rfx6g' ovoferepov ydp xctSoKv roov eiKYjfx/txevuv. dKK' icfev) v7rY\px £V ' rrctKiv ei ro A 7rctvri twB, rtp Se T 

3. nv\ rS (2 C. II 9- » C. II 11. e!] ote C. II 12. Xr\<pGr\<f£T«,i BC. II 30. amxe^evo? A et fortasse pr B. H 38. V7r<tp£si C. 
5. xnnyoptxoY elij. B. II 13. tui ph A. II 15. k^oTi^ post p(po<; C. II 24. ro a, rn\ ru y om A. II 31 et 32. xaVJ 
>Mtr* B. 



ANAATTXKftNnPOTEPftNB. 61 

/jtyfrevt, 7o B cvfrevt tw T* enetro tfe Ttvi. et $e to A tivi ytcfxcg broTepco$evcvv vfc TrpoTdcecog Ka,fx@avofxevY\g , el 8e 
tw B kcu to B tw) tco T, cu yiverat <rvKkcyio~fxog* ovcV [XY\$evi, oTav fxev r) BA 7rpc<rk.Y\tp$y , <rvk>-.oyt<rfxog juev eereM 
ei To A tw tw B, tw c^g r /xvifrevi, ovtV ovTCog. cof eKet- th "^pevcfovg, ov cfetKWTcu Se to TrpoKeifxevov. et ydp to x A 
vw? ^aev avenpouvTflM, htw t¥ vk dvatpwTat at TrpoTacetg. [XYi&evt tco B, to Se-H-Tr&vri tco A, to x A cvc\ev\ tco A. 

Qavepov ovv $id tcov elpvifxevcov ircog dvTtcrpetpOfxevov 5 tovto tV ecrco dbvvctTov* ipevfrog dpa to fXYifrevi ra B to A 
T» <rv/x7repd<r/xctTog ev hcacrco <rxKfA,aTt ytveTcu *<rvkkoyt- v-rapx £ i v - dkK ovk et To fxvifrevt ^evfrog, to Travft dkxfieg. 
tr/xdg, kcu iroT evavricog ty\ TrpoTacet kcu ttot dvTiKetfxevug, edv &' y) T A 7rpo<rkY\tp$Yi , ov ytvercu <rvkkoyt<rfxog , ovcY 
kcu oTt ev fxev too Trpcorco o-XftfAarrt cftct t» fxecrov kcu t» otccv v7roTe$Y\ fxr) 7ravft tw B to v A v~rdpx £ t v - cocre tpavepov 
e<r%ctTK yivovTctt ot trvkkoytcfxoi, kcu y\ fxev Trpog too ekctT- %ri to -ravrt V7rap%etv ov ^ettcvvTcu ev tw irpcoTco <ryy[fKa,Ti 
Tovt a,Kpco de\ $td tk fxecov dvatpeTrcit, y) <§e Trpcg tco fxet- 10 frta, th db\jvctT<s. to tfe ye Ttvt kcu to fXYtfrevi Kctt /xy) -xctvft 
X^ovt ($td ts etrxdvi* ev cfe tw frevTepco <ftd #6 TrpcoTov kcu b^eacwTctt. v7roKei<r$co ydp to A fXYibevt tw B vTrdpxetv, to 
tk Io-XjcLtov, KcCt y) fjcev 7rpog tw ekoLTTcvt aKpco det cfta, t» ^g B el/\Yj<pQco TravTt y\ Ttvt tco T. ovkovv dvdyyjyi to A fjcvr 
irpcoTcv <rxflfA,aT0<;, y) <fe 7rpo\ : tco fA,etCovt $id tv eo~%a,Tov* $ev\ y\ [a,y\ TravTt tco V vTrapxetv. t«to tV dcfvvarov. ecrco 
iv cfe tco TptTco frtd t« TrpcoTov kcu fod tov fA,e<rov, Kat y) ydp dK^e;, Kai cpctvepov oti TTOJVTt v7rap%et tco T to A, 
fiev 7rpog tco fxeiXpvt t\td tov TrpcoTOv dei, y) $e 7rpo? tco 15 &cf et t»to ipev$o<;, dvayKYi to A t<v* tco B V7rap%etv. eav 
EhaTTovt tftd tcv fxecov. 8e 7rpog to A Kyi<P$yj y) errepa, 7rpoTa,<rt<; , ovk ecrat crvKko- 

11 Ti [A.ev ovv ecr\ to dvTtirpetpetv kcu 7rco<; ev eKa,<rco yt<r[A,og. ovcf otocv to evocvTtov tw <rvfA,7repa,<rfxa,Tt v7roTe$yj, 

<r%Y\fxa,Tt kcu Ttg yfverat crvX/\oyt<rfxo5, tpavepov. o oe oi* otov to tjv) fxvi V7ra,pxetv. tpavepovw oti to dvrtKeifxevov v7ro- 
tov dcfvvaTov crv/Woytcrfxo; Stacvi/rctl fxev, otav y\ dvTttpa- $eTeov. TraXtv v7rcKei<r$co to A tivi tw B V7rapx £ tv, et\Y\- 
trtg Te$Y\ tk cvfXTrepcto-fxarroq x,a\ 7rpo<r\Y\tp$Yi ctK/\Y\ TrpoTct- 20 tp$co ^g ro T 7rctvr) tw A. dvdyKY\ ovv to T tivi tco B 
ctg, yiverat t¥ ev ctTracri tc7; <rx^fJca,<rtv' ofxotov yap ecrt v7rdpx^v. tovto t¥ ecrco dfrvvaTov, uxre "ipevtfog to v7T0Te$ev. 
ty\ dvTtcrpotpYi, 7rXviv tftatpepet TotrovTov oti dvrtcrpetpeTctt gj £ ovtoos, d/\Y\$e<; to [xr\o)ev\ virdpx^' bftoicoi; tfe kai el 
ixev yeyevYjfxevcv trvKkoytCfxov Kctt etkYjfxfxevcov d/xtpoTv tcov t-epviTiKov e/\^tp$Y\ to T A. ei tf y) 7rpo<; tw B etkY\7TTat Trpo- 
nrpoTacecov , dirdyeTat <? ei? dcfvvctTov ■ ov 7rpoofxokoyY\$evTo<; rctcrtg, ovk ecrctt crvkkoytcrfxog. edv tfe to evavriov v7roTe$^, 
tov dvrtKetfxevov TrpoTepov, dkkd tpavepov ovTog oti dk.Y\$e;. 25 trvkkoytcrfxog fxev ecrai kcu to dtfvvaTov, ov MKvvrctt 8e to 
ot &' opot bfxoicog exovtriv ev dfxtpoTv, koi y) avty\ kvrytg 7rpoTe$ev. v7roKei<r$oo yap TrctvT) tw B w A v7rdpx £ w-> *di 
dfxtpoTepcov. otov et to AtwB TrctvTi v7rdpx £ h fte<rov oe to T tco h. eikY\tp$co TravTt. ovkovv dvdyKY\ to T Travrt tco 
to T, edv v7roTe$v\ to A y\ fxvj xctvrl y\ fXY\$evt tco B virap- B v7rdpX £iV - ™ T0 • d$vva,Tov, cocre ^evcfog to xavt; tw B 
X £lv i 7 V <& P ttavt/, 07rep v\v dk.Y\$eg, dvayKY\ to T tcj ^o A v7rapX £ w- dkK ovttco ye dvayKcuov, et fxv\ Trctvrt, 
B v\ fXYi&evi y\ fXY\ TravTt uxctp^eiv. toGto tV do\ivaT0V, cocre30 fXY\hv\ vrrapx^' bfA,otcog $e koi et irpog tco B kY\tp$etY\ y\ 
"^/evfrog to v7roTe$ev' dkv\$eg apa to dvTtKeifxevov. bfxotcog oe erepa, nrpoTactg' trvkkoyttrfxog /xev ydp ecrat koi to do\j- 
xdi e7r\ tcov akkcov <r%KfJ<>dToov' ocrct ydp dvTt<rpo<pY\ v &ex £ - \arov, ovk dvatpekat <¥ y\ v7ro$e<rtg, uxrTe to dvTtKeifxevov 
Tat, Kat tov b^tct tov db\>vaTov <rvkkoyi<r/xov. v7ro$ereov. nrpog t\e to [xy\ TravTt b^eT^at v7rapx ov T V ^ T0 

Tct fxev ovv dkkct 7rpcfik4fxaTa> Trdrra fretKWTai frta, A, u7ro^£Teov TrctvT) vTrdpxW « ydp to A ?rctvT X tco B 
t» db)jvdTov ev a7ra<rt To7g <rxY\fJca<rt, to tfe Ka,$okov Ka-35 KA ,i io T Travrt tco A, to T 7ra,vr\ tco B, cocf et tcvto 
Tv\yoptKov ev fxev tw fxecrco ko\ tw Tpircp freiKWTat, ev &e dbvvaTov, "^evbog to v7roTe$ev. bfxoicog $ ko,\ ei Trpog twB 
tco TrpcoTco « freiKWTat. v7roKeio-$co yap to A tw B fXY\ Trarrt ekY\tp$Y\ y) erepa 7rpoTa<rtg. Kat ei tjepvrrtKov y\v to T A, cocr- 
y] fXY\bev\ v7rdpx £ i v , Ka\ 7rpo<retkY\tp$co akkvi irpcTa<rtg biro- ctvTcog' Kctt yap ovtco yiveTat crvkkoytTfxog. ectv <fe Trpcg tco 
Tepco$evw, eire tw A 7rct-vr< vTrapxw to T ene to B 7rctVT< B y\ to <~epY\TiKov, ovcfev ^eiKWTat. eav Se [XY\ Trant akkct 
T& A' ovtco yap dv Hy\ to TrpcoTov 0"%i?jU.e6. el fxev ovv v7rd-^ Ttv\ V7rdpx £iv v7roTe$^, ov b^eUwTat oti ov TravTt akk oti 
KetTat /xy) Travft V7rdpx £ t v to A tw B, ov yiverat trvkko- cvbevl. et ydp to A t^v) twB, to tfe T Travrt tco A, tivi 

1. h.uno h\ Tiv! om AB. II 7. iyownij? A. II dvnxE/^sya; A. II l4. alterum xal om AC. H 39. to/j /3 7t<m\ ro B. 

2. alterum ptb om C. II 5. fcw C. II 16. rm BC. II 23. TA. i\ 7*p p^w t<r*i vru?. ei C. II 26. vwctpxw om BC. II 
27. prius rS om ABC. II 3o. ^Af C. II 37. ctf C II 39. ji om C. 



62 ANAATTIK^N IIPOTEP&N B. 

tio B ro Y vTtttpfcei. et »y tovt' dt\wctTov, 'pevbog to tivi §e Y fXY\&evt. dvctyKY\ ovv to V fXY^evi tw B vTtcLpx^v. thto 

V7tdpx siV r V & T 5 -^» ^'r' *^^? T0 fXY^evi. tovtov $e &' dfrvvctTov, tocj' dkvfieg to /xy\ Ttctvr) vTtdpx^v. (pctvepov 

$etx$ sv tog 7tpoo-ctvctipe?Tcti to dk.Y\$eg' to yotp A tco B tivi ovv oti Ttctvreg ol <rvkkoyio-[xot ytvovTctt t^tct t» fxeo-ov v/jfr 

fxev vTtYpxs, tiv) $' ovx VTTYipxw. ert ov Ttctpct tyiv v7to$e- [xcnog. 

o~iv rv/xficttvsi to doX/vctTov "pevfrog yctp clv e'iv\, entep e£ 5 'Ofxotoog $e kcu frtct, tov erxotTOv. xetrQw ydp to Al3 

dkv\$oov fXY] ecjt •pevt^og o-vkkoyto-cto-$cti' vvv <F ecjtv dKrfieg' tivi too B [xy\ v7tdpx siV -> T ° ^ s T TtctvTi' to dpct A Ttvt tw 

viTctpx^ y A P T0 A Ttvi tu B. Locj' ovx v7to$eTeov Ttvt vTtctp- Y ovx vTTctpx^' £ i ovv T * T ' cto\jvctTOV, •pevbog TO TlVt fXY\ 

X Elv i dkkct TtctVTt. bfxotoog &e Kctt el Ttvt [xy\ v7tctp%ov too B V7tctpx siv i &<j' dkv\$eg to TtctvTt. ectv &' v7toTe$v\ [XY\$evi 

70 A freiKVvoifxev' et yctp TctvTo to tiv) /xy\ vTtctpx^v Kct) v7tctpx^ v -> o-vkkoyio-fxog [xev ecjcti kou to dbvvctTov, ov $ei- 

[XY[ TTCtVTt V7TCtpX£lV, Y\ CtVTYj d[X(pO?V <*7TO^£<£j£. 10 KVVTCtt 8e TO 7tpOTe$eV ectV yctp TO hctVTtOV V7tOTe$yj , TCWt' 

Qctvepov ovv oti. ov to evctVTtov dkkct to ctVTtKeifXevov ecjctt 'ditep eitt toov TtpoTepov. dkkct Ttpog to tiv) V7tctpx siv 

v7ro$eTeov ev k%cto-i To?g o-vkkoytrfxo?g. ovtoo yctp to ctvcty- ctvTY\ KffrtTect v\ v7to$e<rtg. et ydp to A [XY\c\ev) ra B, to $£ 

kcuov ecjctt Kctt to ct^iwfxct evfro^ov. et yctp KctTct TtctvTog vi V tiv) ra B, to A ov tvclvt) tw Y. el ovv tovto -pevcfog, 

(pctrts *i ct7to(pcto-tg, $etx$svTos qti ovx V ct7to(pct<rig, cu\Y\&eg to A tiv) tw B vitctpx^' ots &' ovfrev) tw B vTtctp- 

CtVctyKYj TY[V KCtTCt(pCtO-lV CtKY,SeveO-$Ctl. 7tCtkiV £i fXY\ Tl$YiQ-iV 15 ^£l jq A, V7tOKet<r9cO TlVl VTtCtpX™ , etkY,<p&CjO $e KCtl TO Y 

chkY\$eveo-$cti ty\v KctTctcpctrtv, evc\o^ov to ct^tuxrcti tyjv ctTto- TtctvTi tw B V7tctpx° v - ovkovv dvctyKYj tw Y tiv) to A VTtctp- 
(pctrrtv. to &' evctvTiov ovfreTepoos dpfXOTTei d^tovv' hte yctp X SIV ' *^' ovfrev) v7tY\px £ v, tocj-e 'pevfrog tiv) tw B vTtctp- 
dvctyKcttov, el to fxv^evi 'pevc^og, to TtctvTt dK*\$eg, ovt %v- X£ IV T0 &-• SAV ^ v7toTe$y\ TtctvTt tw B vTtctpxetv to A, w 
oozpv cog et $dTepov •pevfros, oti $ctTepov dK/\$eg. o^etKWTcti to ntpoTe$ev , dKkct ntpog to fxv\ TtctvTi vTtctpx^ 

12 $ctvepov ovv oti kv tw TtpwTco <rXK, u ctTi Tct fxev ctkkct^O o,vty\ k.Y\7tTect v\ v7to$eo-tg. el ydp to A 7tctVTt tw B Kcti to 

7TpO@kYjfXCtTCt TtCtVTCt freiKVVTCti tfld T» dSwctTOV, TO t% KCt- Y Tiv) TW B , 70 A VTtctpX^ 7tv) 700 Y. THTO <$£ OVK Y\V, 

6okov KctT<t(pctTtKov ov foiKWTctt. ev b\ tw [xIq-qo Kcti tw u<re ypev&og to TtctvTt V7tctpx^v. el &' ovTcog, dkviSeg to uy\ 
erXci^to Kctt tkto t\eiKW7cti. KetoSoo yctp To A fxv\ TtctVTt 7tctvTi. ectv fr' v7toTe$yj tivi VTtctpx^ v -> 7<xvt ecjctt a, kcu 
yto B vTtdpx^t etkY,(p$to he tw Y TtctvTt vTtctpx^ T0 A. eiti tuiv TtpoetpYifxevoov. 

ovkovv el tu> fxev B fxv\ 7tctvTt, tw <Js r TtctvTt, ov TtctvTi 25 Qctvepov ovv oti ev ctTtctcri 7o?g frict 7ov dtfvvct70V trvk- 

tu B to r. t«to fr' do\>vct70V e<Too yctp (pctvepov 07i Ttctv^) koyio~fxo?g to dv7tKetfxevov v7to$e7eov. ^kov 3e Kcti oti ev t<2 
tu B V7tctpx £ t 70 r, tocre •pevfrog to VTtOKetfxevov. dkv\$lg /xeo-ui o-x^^t &eiKW7cu Ttoog to Kct7ct<pct7iKov kcu ev 700 

Ctpct 70 TtCtVTi V7tCtpX^ v - £*" <^ £ T0 fi^^^TtOV U7TOT£^>5, <TVk- eCTXCtTtO TO KCt$okOV. 

koyto-fxog /xev ecrcu kcu to dhjvovtov, « fxv\v freiKvvTctt to Aictcpe^pei &' y\ elg to dovvctTov ditobeifcig TY\g SeiKTiKY\g\A 

itpoTe$ev. e\ yctp to A fXY\t\ev) tw B, tw b% Y TtctVTi, «<5ev) 30 tw Ti$evcti (BovkeTcti dvcttpetv, d7totyx<rct etg b[xokoyov[xe- 
700 B to r. tkto 8 d^vva/tov, cocre ^pevt^og 70 [XY\t\ev) vitctp- vovpevbog' v\ &e freiK^iKY^ ctpx £ Tcti e^ ofxokoy^fxevuov $eo-eoov 
%etv. dkK ovk el t«to "pevfrog, to 7r*VTi dkY\$eg. %Te 8k dkYj$oov. kctfX\3ctvov<ri [xev ovv dfxcpoTepctt &vo TtpoTcireig 
Tivt 700 B vTtctpx^ T ° A, v7toKeto-$oo to A fXYifrev) tu> B ofxokoy^fxevctg' dkK v\ fxev e% oov b <rvkkoyio-[xog, v\ h\ 
V7tdpx^v, too Se Y Ttctvr) v7tctpx £ Too. dvctyKYj ovv to Y fXY,- /xtctv fxev tovtoov, fxtctv fre ty\v dvTt<pct<rtv tk <rvfX7tepctr[xct- 
frevi tw B. oocr' et t»t' do\ivxTov t dvctyKY\ to A tiv) too B 35 ? g. Kcti ev$ct fxev ovk dvctyKY\ yvooptfxov etvctt to <rv[X7ti- 
vTtctpx^- sotv tf v7toTe$Y\ tiv) fXY\ VTtctpx^v, TctvT ecjctt pctrfxct, ovfre 7tpov7tokctfx(3ctveiv tog ecjtv v\ ov' ev$ct Ss 
ixTtep eTti T6 TtpooTov o-xv/ActTog. Ttcikiv v7toKet<r$oo to A 7tv) dvctyKY\ tog ovk ecjiv. hotcpepei $' ovoev (pcto-tv y\ d7to(pcto-iv 
700 B vTt&pxuv, tw o\ Y fXYifrevt vTtctpx^oo. dvctyKYi ovv etvcti to o-vfX7tepcto-fxct, dkK bfxotoog exet Ttept d/ut(po?v. ct7tctv 
to F 7tvi T(S B [XY\ vTtctpxeiv. dkkd Ttctv^) v7tY,px £ v, ucje $e 70 freiKTiKoog 7tepcttvo[xevov Kcti frict t« do\ivctTV S~etx$y<rs- 
ipevbog to v7toTe$ev' ovbevi ctpct tw B to A VTtctp^ei. ote40 Tcti, kcu to frtct t» dfrvvctTOv fretKTiKwg hct toov <xvtoov opoov, 
5"' ou TtctvTi to AtwB, v7toKet<r$oo TtctvTi v7toipx slv * 7 V cvii sv T0 ^ ctvTo?g Se o-x^^tv. OTctv [xev yctp <rvkko- 

5. 7<*p om ACet pr'jB. II l4. v\ ti kixo^^ C. II 20. tw om C. II 21. ^ktotoi C. II 3o. to h\*iA. II 32. on AliC. II 40. hi B, ti C. 
10. to 7rxn\ -rraoTsSir C. II 12. t£i ^ T nv\ ro B. II l4. hi ABC. II 16. tc 7 Tivi rui <tAB. II 21. Wi] Trot,n\ AB etpr C. II 
F— A] *— 7 C. II 32. akriSvv om BC. II 37. »1 a,7ro(j)x<rtv supra liluram rc A. II Al. ow — ax^oiaiv om ABC. 



ANAAOCTIKftN nPOTEPftN B. 63 

ytr/xog sv tw TrpuTu frx^t %axt yevrjtu, ro dkY,$sg e<~ou sv A vTraipx^v, EtkY\7rT<xi 8s ro T ttocvt) tw B koc) to A 7T<wt 

tw ^tteVy »j tw £ff"^*TW, to ^uev crspYjrtKov sv tuj fxsru, to twT' outw *yctp ecfeti to ct<JbvctTov. tcjto 8e to Trpurov 

Ss KoLTYiyopiKov sv tw etx^c)). oTcty <$"' ev tu fxsru y, o <rj$i[A(t. u<ra,vTug <5e koc) el eirl Ttvog v\ dTrobsfetg' v) fxev 

<rvkkoyt<rfxog, to dkvj$sg ev tw TrpuTu etti ttocvtuv tuv yccp v7ro$s<rtg fxY^sv) tw B to A vTrocpx^tv , EtkY\7rTou Sk to 

-rpofikvifxocTuv. 'otocv b~' ev tu eV^ctrw o <rvkkoyt<r/xog, to 5 T tiv) tu B kcc) to A 7rctyT} tw V. el 8e <rspY\TiKog 6 <rvk- 

dkY,$sg ev tu Trpuru kou tu fxsru, Toc fxsv KOCToccpocTtKOC koytcrfxog, v7ro$s<rig fxev to A tw tu B v7r<xpxetv , stkY,- 

iv tu Trpuru, Tct bs crepYiTtKou ev tu fxe<ru. e<~u yocp $£<$£t- tttou bs to T tuj fxkv A fXY^evi, tw $e B 7tolvti' tSto Ss 

y/xsvov to A fXY,b~svi v\ fxv, ttocvti tu B bta, th Trpur^ o"xy[- to fxs<rov cr-^ttct. bfxoiug &e kcu sl /xy) KO.$okov y) ctTrofret- 

jULccTog. ovkovv y) /xsv v7ro$e<rig y\v Ttvt tw B v7ra,px^v to A, jrtg. (nr o$s<rtg fxsv yccp s<~a,t 7ra,vTt tw B to A vTrcLpxjitv, 

to be T ska.fx8a.vsT0 tw [xkv A ttclvti vTracpxetv, tu <5e B 10 el/\.»j7rTctt 8e to T tw fxsv A fXY\$svi, tw bts B t<vj /# thto <$g 

cv&svt' ovtu) yocp sytvsTo b <rvkkoyi<rfxog kcx) to dhvva.TOv. t% fxso-ov 0-%^/Act. 

TKTO bs TO fXETOV CT^CytCt , St TO T TUJ [XSV A 7T<XV~t TU <5g $CLVep0V OVV OTl $10, TUJV CCVTUJV opUJV KCU C^StKTlKOOg £<~t 

B [XY,^£vi V7ra,px£t. koa <pa,vepov Ik txtujv oti ov&evt tw B c^etKvvvou tcov 7rpofiX.Y,/ji,a,TU)V eKcccrov kcu bia. t« d&jycCTou. 
VTrocpxet to A. b[xotujg c% koc\ et [jcy] -ra.vr\ b^shtKTou virccp- ofxotoog F scrou kou ^siktikuv ovtoov toov <rvKkoytir[Jcoov stg 
X,ov. r\ [xsv yacp v7ro$s<rtg scrt 7rocvTt v7ra.p%stv, to <5e T 15 ccSwcctov ccTrccystv ev To?g EtkY[JC[X£Votg opotg, otccv % ocvTtKEt- 

EkcCfxfioCVETO TUJ [JLEV A TTOCVTt, TU) Se B OV TTOjVTt. KOU St fJLEVY, TTpOTOCCTtg TW <rvfJL7rspoLO-fJLO,Tl kY,<p&v]. ytVOVTOU yOCp 01 

erspYiTtKov kacfj,(3acvotTO to T A, urocvToog' Ka,i ya,p ovtoo yt- o,vto) <rvkkoyt<rfJLo) Tolg hac TY\g acvTt<-po<pY]g, ucr' svQvg 

vstou to fxsrov rryyifxa,. Trccktv b^E^Etx^uj Ttvt v7ra,pxov tuj exoficev ko,i tc. «r^^ctTcc <&' uv skccctov ecrcct. 'SVikov ovv oTt 

B to A. Y[ y,ev ovv v7ro$eng fjLYi&ev) V7ra,pxetv, to os B 7ra,v 7rpo(3kY,fJLoc g^slkvvtou koct' ocfjupoTspovg tou? Tpo7rovg, 

skoc/Jc(3ocveTo 7ra,vT) tw T vTrtLpxsvt ko.) to A y\ 7ra,vrt v\ Ttvt 20 frta, ts tov a,b\jvocT0V kou frstKTtKug, koc) kk EvfrsXETou xju- 

tu T ' \stu yocp s<~a,t to cc&jvcctov. tvto &s to so"X j o,tov ptXs<r$a.t tov erepov. 

GXJAfxoc, et to A kcc) to B 7ravTi tu T. kou <pa,vepov e.K 'Ev Trolu bs cr^^tctTZ ecrtv e^ ccvTtKetfJcevuv 7rpoToc<reuv 15 

tovtuv oti d,va,yKY\ to A Ttv) tu B v7ra,px£W- bfxotug oe <rvkkoyt<ra,<r$act koc) ev Trotu &k scrtv, ub^ scrou (pocvspov. ksyu 

KO.) n TJv) TU T kYCpSstYj VTTO.pX^ TO B Y, TO A. h' dvTlKSlfJL£Va,g EtVO,t 7rpOTO,<rStg KOCTO, fJLEV TY\V ki^tV TETTOC- 

IloLktv ev tu fxs<ru cr^/ActTi b^sb^six^^ to A 7rctyTt too 25 ^jcts, oiov to 7rccvTt tu ovfrsvi, ko.1 to ttccvt) TU i TrcCVTt, KCU 

B VTToCpX^- OVKOVV y) fJLSV V7TO$EO-ig Y\V fJLY\ TTOCVTt TU B TO TO TJVi TU vfrsVi, KCU TO TtVt TU » TtVt, KCCT dkY\$Sta.V Se 
A V7r0CpX^V, E V tkY,7rTO.t &S TO A 7TCtVT{ TU T KOCt TO T TTOCVTt TpStg' TO yccp TlVt TU « T^i JCCtTCt T>JV ks£lV dvTlKEtTCU fJCO- 

ru B* ovtu ya,p scract to dbvvacTov. rkro §s to rrpurov vov. tvtuv b'' sva,VTtacg fxsv Tocg Ka,$okov, to TrctvTi tw jxy,- 
(T^^ttct, to A xctVTi tu T kou to T 7ra,VTi tu B. ofJLotug &£vt v7ra,pxetv, otov to 7ra,o-ccv E7ri<rY\fXY\v sTvou <r7rovb s a,{<xv tu 
bs k<x) st Ttvt &E&EIKTCU vTTccpx^' V {A£v ya,p v7ro$s<rig y\v 30 fjLY\b'EfJLia,v sTvou o-Trovb^a.ta.v, Tocg &' akka,g dvTiKStfxsva,g. 

fXYifrsv) TU B TO A VTTCCpXZtV, SikyyKTOU bs TO A XCtVTi TW 'Ev fJLEV OVV TU TTpUTU (T^^ttCtTf W>C ECTIV E^ dvTlKEl- 

T kcu to T Tivt tu B. el &e crspYjTtKog b o-vkkoyiorfjLog, v) fxsvuv TrpoTocosuv <rvkkoyt<rfxog, vte K<xTcc<pa,TiKog *te drro- 
fjcsv v7ro$s<rtg to A Ttvi tu B U7rct^eiv, Eik.Y\7rTa,i be to A (pa.TtKog, KO.Ta,<pa,TtKog fjcev oti dfX(poTspa,g frst K<xTa.(pcXTi- 
fjcYjfrsvt tu T kcu to T 7rocvTi tu B, ucrs yivsTcu to Trpu- Kclg sTvoct Tctg 7rpoT<x<rstg, ccl b~' dvTtKsi l u,sva,i (pacrig kcu 
tov trxYil^oi. kou sl fJLY, Koc$okov b o-vkkoyt<rfxog , dkkct to 35 d7ro(poco-ig, <rspY\TiKog frs oti oci fxsv dvTtKsifxsvou to ocvto 
A Tivt tu B b^sb^siKTcu fXY, v7rocpx £iv i utrocvTug. v7ro$s<rtg tk ct*JT» K<xTY,yopov<rt kou d7ra,pvovvTcu , to b~' sv tu Trpurru 
fxlv yocp ttocvt) tu B to A V7rocpX£iV, EikY\7rTcu b\ to A fxsrov » kiyETat koct' dfxcpoTv, dkk' eke(v6 fxsv cckko dTrap- 

[XYlfrsVl TU T Kcx) TO T TlVi TU B" OUTOJ yct^J TO TTpUTOV VS?TCU, OCVTO Ss OCkkov KOCTY\yop£lTOU' CWTOU b* VK dvTl- 
<rX*p#" KEIVTOU. 

TicckiV EV TU TpiTU <rXy\f^OCTt ^E^EiX^U) TO A XCtVTl TW 40 'Ey <Je TW fXE<TU 0~X'A[Xa,Tl KOCi EK TUV dvTlKElfXEVUV KOU 

B vTrcxpx^v. ovkovv i) fxsv v7ro$s<rig y\v [xy, xctnrl tu B to e>t tuv evccvtiuv svbs^xsTcu yivs<r$ou Tvkkoyto-fxov. scru ya,p 

3. I om BC. II 11. o om C. II l4. v7r*c%oy ro ec i\ A. II 33. V7rdp%eiv om BC. 

13. xoCi &* rou <ko\>v<£rv omAC. II 22. <-iXXoyi<rac~8cu ~-poToL<jeuY C. II 25et26. to] tuiB quater. II 28. ph Xs«yo/*£/ tx? A. l\ twi 

B. II 38. CtUTo] TO CtUTO B. 



64 ANAATTIK&N nPOTEPQN B. 

dyct$ov fxev e<p' « A, hcurnfm Se «</>' « B >cat Y. el Sy) tuv opuv, otov to A Trctn) ?w B, tw ^ T fxy\Sevi, % 7w 
wcww exif^ 1 ' <nre&t/*v eXctjSe kcu fXY\Sefxictv , to A tw T tt*vt/', tw £e B ^<5en, *j tw fxev Trctni, tw c^e ^ 
B 7juvt) vTrcipx^ '**' T( ? ^ «tW, wg-e to B tw T iSevi' nrctni, kcu TrctXtv tvto dvTtcrpeApcti Kcvrct Tovg opovg. bfxoiug 
iSefxict ctpct sTricrffAYi 'e7rt<ry\fxy\ icriv. bfxoiug Se kcu el 7rct<rctv Se Kcti e7r) t« rpiTov (rx^fxctTog. ucre cpctvepov brctx^ Te 
■Xctfiuv crTrovSctictv ty)v lctTpiKYiv fxv) <r7rvSctictv eXctfie' tw 5 Kcti iv Troiotg <rx*\f^ct<rtv evSIxmctt Sid tuv dvTLKeifxivuv irpo- 
jucev ydp B 7iuvt; to A, tw Se Y iSevi, ucre y) Tig hri<rv\fXY) Tctcreuv yevi<r$ctL <rvXXoyL<rfxov. 

$k ecrcu i7rtcrY\fXY\. Kcti el tu fxev Y 7r«,VTl to A, tw Se B Qctvepov Se kcu oti eK^jevSuv fxev ecrtv dXv\$eg <rvXXo- 

-fXY\Sevi, ecrt Se to fxev B i7rLcrY\fxy\ , to Se.Y \cvrptKY\, to Se yi<rct<r$ctt , Kct$ct7rep eipy\Tctt irpoTepov, ht Se tuv dmKeifxi- 
A v7ro/\Yiipig' ovSefxictv ydp e7rLcrY[fXY\v vttoXyy^jlv Xctfiuv. eH- vuv ovk ecriv' det ydp ivctvTtog b <rvXXoyt<rfxog yivercti tu 
Xv\(pe Ttvd e7ricrY\u,Y\v etvcti v7roXv\iptv. SictcpipeL Se t5 7rctXcti 10 7rpctyfxctTL, oiov el ecriv dyct$ov, fxy) eTvcti dyct$ov, y\ el Xjuov, 
tu eVi tuv opuv ctnicrpe(pe<r$ctt' TrpoTepov fxev ydp irpog tu fxv) TJuov, Sid to e£ dni<pct<reug eTvctt tov crvXXoyiTfxov kcu 
B , vvv Se Trpog tu Y to KctTctcpctTiKov. kcu ctv y\ Se [xy) Kct- Tovg v7roKet[tevovg opovg y\ Tovg ctvTovg elvctt y) tov [xev okov 
$o/\ov y) hepct TrpoTct&tg, urctvTu.g' che) yctp to [xetrov ecr)v tov fre fxepog. 3y]/\ov c% kcu %ti ev Totg 7rctpctXoyt<rfxo7g v&ev 
o «t7ro $ctTepov [xev chrocpctTtKug XeyeTctt, Kovrct $ctTepov (h KuKvet yive<r$ctt TY\g v7ro$e<reug dvTicpctrtv , otov el ecrt ireptT- 
KctTctcpctTtKug. ucr' ev^x^ctt TdvTtKeifxevct 7repctive<r$cti, 15 tov, fxy) eTvctt TreptTTov. Ik yctp tuv dvTLKeijxevuv TrpoTctcreuv 
7r\y)v ovk de) ov<& TrdvTug, d\\' ectv ovTug ex\\ tcc u7ro ivctniog r,v 6 <rvKkoyL<rfxog' edv «v Xct$Y t TOLctvTctg, eerctt TY\g 
7o fxetrov uq y) TctvTd etvctL v\ oXov irpo.g /xepog. ctXXug cY v7ro$e<reug dvTtcpcto-tg. Set Se KctTctvoeTv oti %,tu fxev &k ecrtv 
dcfvvctTov i'ydp erovTctt icfctfxug cu 7rpoTct<retg W evctVTicti evctvTict crvfX7repdvct<r$ctt e^ evog <rvXXoyt<r[xov, ucp' slvctt to 
»t' dntKeifxevctt. crvfX7ripct<rfXct to fxv) ov dyct$ov dyct$ov y\ ctXXo ti tolktov, 

'Ev Se tu Tpiru crxVfAcvTt KcvrctcpctTLKog fxev crvXXo- 20 e*v fxv) ev$vg y) 7rpoTct<TLg ToictvTY\ Xy\<P$yi, olov 7rctv X^uov Xev- 
yicrfxog ySIttot ecrcti e£ dvTLKeifxevuv 7rpoTd<reuv Sid ty)v el- kov eTvctL Kcti fxvj XevKov , tov S' ctv$pu7rov TJuov. dXX' y\ 7rpo<r- 
py\[xevY\v ctWtctv k<x) e7r) t» TrpuTov crxYlfxctTog , dTrocpcvrtKog Xctfietv Se7 ty\v dvTtcpctcrtv , otov oti 7rd<rct e7rtcry\fxy\ v7roXy\- 
S' ecrctt, Kcti Kct$oXx Kctt fxy\ Kct$oXov tuv opuv ovtuv. ecju 'ptg Kctt $x vTroXvi^l/tg , etTct Xct(3eiv otl y) ictTpiKY\ e7rtcrYsfxyi 
ydp e7TtcrY\[XY\ e<p' ov to B Kctt Y, tctTpiKv\ S' ecp' « A. el [xev icjLV, xSefxict S' v7roXY\^ptg, u<T7rep ol eXeyxoi yivovTctt, 
ovv xdfioL 7rct<rctv .lctTpLKY\v iirLc;Y\fXY\v kcv) .[XY\Se[xictv lctTpiKYiV 25 y\ eK Suo <rvXXoyL<r[Xuv. ucre cf eTvctt evctVTtct Kcvr dXy\- 
i7rt<ry\[XYiV , to v B 7rctvT) tu A etXyicpe Kcti to Y iSevi, ucr' $eLctv ta e\Xy]fXfxevct, «>c ecrtv ctXXov TpoTrov y\ T«Toy, Kct$cC- 
ecrctt Ttg i7ri<ry\[xy\ ht i7ricrYifxy\. bfxoiug Se Kctt ctv fxy\ Kct$o- nrep eipy\Tctt TtpoTepov. 

Xov Xy\(p$Y! y) AB 7rpoTct<rtg' el yctp e<ri Ttg tctTpiKy) eVf- To S' iv dpxy cttTe7<r$cti Kctt XctfxfictveLV ecri jxiv, ug 16 

<CY\fXY\ Kcti irdXtv [xv\Se[xict tctTpiKYi e7rtcry\fxy\, <rv fxfictivei iirL- iv yivei Xct(3e7v, iv tu fxy\ d7roSeiKVvvctL to TrpoKeifxevov , tSto 
cty\[XY\v Tivd [xy\ eTvcti iii 'Lcr.Y\fXY\\ '. et<rt Se Kct$oXov fxev tuv 30 S' i7ri<rvfx@ctivet TroXXctxug ' Kctt ydp et oXug [Xy) <rvXXo- 
opuv Xctfxftctvofxivuv ivctvTtctt ctt irpoTctcretg, idv S* iv fxipet yiZeTcti, kcu et St' dyvucroTepuv v\ bfxoiug dyvucruv, kcu 
ctTspog, dvTLKeifxevcti. . el Slatuv vcrepuv to TrpoTepoV v) ydp dTroSei^Lg ex TrtcroTi- 

Ae7 Se KcvrctvoeTv oTt evSIxercu /xev ovtu Td dntKei- puv ts kcu TrpoTipuv icriv. txtuv fxev ovv iSiv icrt to ctheT- 
fxevct XctfxftctveLV , u<T7rep eLirofxev 7rcL<rctv i7ricrY\fXY\v <r7rov- <r$cti to e^ dpx^' dXX' irret Tct /xev Si' ctvTuv 7ri(pvKS 
Sctictv elvcti kcv) TrctXtv fXY\Se/xictv , y\ Ttvd fxv) (nrovScucW ZS yvupiXe<r$ctt ta Se St' dXXuv (ctl fxev ydp dpxcu St' ctv- 
%7rep *k e*u$e Xctv$ctveLV. ecri Se Si ctXXuv epuTY\fxcvruv <rvX- tuv, ta S' v7ro Tdg dpxdg St' ctXXuv), orctv to fxy) Si' 
Xoyi<rct<r$cu $dTepov, v\ ug iv To7TLKo7g ixix$Y\ XctfieTv. i^ret ctvrk yvucrov Sl' ctvvtt Tig e7rtxetpy SeiKVvvctt, tot ctkeTrcti 
Se tuv KctTct(pct<reuv ctt dvTt$I<retg Tpe7g, e^&xug cvfxficti- to. e£ dpx^g. t»to <^' ecrt fxev %tu 7rote7v ucr' ev$vg dfyu- 
vet TdntKeifxevct Xctfxfictvetv , y\ TrctvTi Kctt [xv\Sevi, y\ Trctnt crctt to TrpoKeifxevov, ivSixeTcu Se kcu fxerct(3ctVTctg 67r' 
Kct) fxv) Trctni, y\ Ttv) Kcti fXY\Sevi, Kcti T6T0 dntcrpirpctt 'eTrthO ctXXct ctTTct tuv 7re<pvK0Tuv St iKetvx SeiKW<r$cti Sid txtuv 

1. >c*i om C. II 6. to a] tw A. II 12. alterum <% om C. II 15. t<£ arnxs^eya C. II 17. t*ut* B. II t\ tc /xh oXov rh (Jk f*(- 
p»; C. II 26. rSi 7 B. II 28. /3 a C. II 37. w tol<; totimok BC. II 39. roi iniKet^eva, C. 

3. T«Toy Bi II 9. o kvxmo? C. II 18. tru^TspaiW&ju C. II 21. rj om C. II 23. xctl i% vttoM^k om B. II 25. t* e!^»i^^y* x*t 
«ATjfifiav C. II 33. te om A. H 36. pj ri ABC. II 40. IxaW AB. 



ANAAtfTIK^N IIPOTEPftN B. 65 

d7roS~SiKVVVCtt 70 £% dpXWi' C ' i0V e( ' T0 -A- <^>CVU0iTO &ct TOU TOUTOTJ ecVjCVUTO Tr £{? TO dcfvVCtTOV. HTS «yctfl /W->J CtVTI- 

B, to <£e B <$ict tou r, to <£e T TrscpvKog eflj feixwq-Qcu <py<rctg speT 70 ov Trctpd tkto, dhh' oti ^evcfcg t< eVeUi 
&oc t.ou A* crvfx^cttvet yctp ctvTc <V ctvvt to A freiKWvai tcov 7rpo7epcv, »t' ev tv; freixwvo-vj' « -yctp t/^ct; t^v ctVTt- 
Tou? «tw o-vhhoytZpfxevovg. cTrep 7rciov<riv 01 7ctg TrctpcthhY,- (pctrtv. ht & %7ctv dvctipeSr, 71 $eix7txoog $td twv ABT, in 
hovg cio/xevot ypctcpetv' hctvOctvovrt yctp ctvrot ectv7ovg 701- S ecrtv eirrsTv cog eu Trctpd 70 xetfxevov ysyew,7-ctt crvhhoyt- 
ocvto. hctfxfictvovTsg , 00 ov% otov ts ct7ro£e?£cu [xy\ &<roov twv crfxog. to ydp }xy\ orctpd tovto yivsoSsu tots hiyofxsv, oTctv 
7tcLpctkk.Y,kcov. cocjs o~vfxfieuvei TcTg vtco o-vkkoytfy/xevoig sxct- dvcupsdevrog tovtov /XY,bev y\ttov 7rspct(vY,Tcu crvkkoyto-fxog, 
trov eTvcu keyeiv, el ecrtv exctcrov vtco $' cWctv ecrcti cV ctv- 07rep ix ecrtv ev ToTg frsiXTixcTg' dvctips$ei<rY\g ydp Vffi Seoscog 
Tou yvcocrov' 07rep dfrvvctTov. vt¥ b irpog t<%vty,v ecrctt o-vkkoyto-fxcg. tpctvepov w 071 ev 7oTg 

Ei cvv 7tg db\kov ov7og %7i to A vTrctpx^ 700 P, 10 etg to dfrwct^cv keye^oct to fxv\ Trctpd tSto, kcu oTctv xtoos 
b/xotcog <$e kcu oti 700 B, ciItoTto tco B virctpx^ to A, e%*? irpog to dfrvvctTov y\ e£ dpx^ v7ro$s<rtg, cocrs xcu «0-^5 
\t7rco $y\kov st to sv dpxy cthsTrctt, dkk' %n xk drro^stK- kcu jlcy] ovo-Yig TctvTYig «<5ev ^ttov o-vy,fi&tvetv 70 d^vvct7ov. 
vvrt, Syi\ov ov yap dpx^ dTroo^efyewg to ojJtotoog &c\i\ov. 'O fAv Zv (pAvepoo7cc7og 7po7rog ecr\ t« /u,vj 7rctpd 7y)v 

st fxsv^oi 70 B Trpog 70 Y \$7oog sx^ w<re tccuto v ' eTvctt , y\ Seo-tv sTvcu to ^svfrog, oTctv a7ro Tr\g vTrobeo-eoog do-vvctTrrcg 
OY\kov oTt dvTtcrps(povo~iv, v\ vTrctpx^ SctTspov SctTepoo, to ev 15 y\ d^ro toov [xeo-oov irpog to dfrvvctTov b o-vkkoyto-[xog, 07rep 
ctpxy cttTeTrctt. Kctt yctp ctv, cti tco B to A U7r<t^ei, <5<' e^vjTcti jccu sv To7rtKoTg. to yctp to dvottTtov cog cutiov tiQs- 
SKStvuv tisiKWot, et dvTtcrpecpot. vvv ^e tkto Kcokvet, dkk' vou 7*70 ecrtv, otov st (3ovko[xevog freTjrctt 07t d<rv[X[xe7pog 
VX '° Tpoftog. et os tkto TrotoT, to stpYjyJvov dv TrotoT xctl r\ $tct[xsTpog, s7rtx^po("A tov ZYjvcovog koyov o^siKvvvcit, oog 
cLv7tcrps(poi cog frtot 7ptcov. coo-ctv7cog cfe k&v el 70 B tw Y vk ecrt KtveTrSctt, kcu etg tovto dTrctyot to db\ivctT0V ovfrct- 
hct[A$ccvot'v7rctpX s i v i bfxotcog cto^vikov ov xctt et to A, yttco 20 y,cog yctp ovo^ct/x^ cvvexeg ecri to ipev8&g ty\ (pctost T% e? 
co e£ dpx^l? cttTeTrcti, dkk' vk dTro^etKwo-tv. ectv bs Tctv- dpxn$- otkkog oe TpoTvog, et o-vvex^g y>ev ety\ to d&vvctTov- 
tov q to A. Kcti B y\ tco dvTtcrpecpetv y\ tco e7recr$cti tw B t>j u7ro5ecre/, [xy\ [xsvTot <5*' sks(vy,v <rv[Jt^ct(vot. toto ydp 
to A, to i^- dpx%$ cttTsTTctt frtct ty\V ctv7Y,v cthictv' 7o yctp eyx^peT ysvsoScu KCU S7rt 70' ctvco Kcti e7r\ to kcitco kctuu- 
£^ dpx%$ fi bvvovrcu, stpviTcti r)[xTv, oti to &' ocvth fretKVvvcu fictvovTi to truve^e^, oTov et tq A tco B >ce?Tcti U7rctp- 
to [xy\ $t ct*jT« <5^vOV. 25 ^ov, to n <^e B tw r, to <5e F tw-A, t«tc <^' etY, ipsvfrcg, 

Et ouv ecr) to' ev dpxy ctheToScu to bh' ctvri hetKWvcu to to B tw A vTrctpx^' « y&p dcpcupeQevTog t« A ^^Jev 

TO [XY\ <$i' CtUTK 0%kOV, T»TO <^' SCTl TO [XY, &SIKVVVCU, OTCtV YjTTOV VTTCtpXOt TO B T<S T KCtl TO Y TCO A, &K dv StY\ TO 

b/xotcog d$Y\kcov ovtcov t« b s etKvv[xevx kcu fo' « ^ewcvurcti y\ ipsvfrog $id ty\v e^ dpxvs V7ro$so-tv. v\ TXctktv st Ttg S7r\ to 
too TctvTct too otvTco y, tco TctvTov ToTg ctvTcTg vTTctpx^-i & *vw kctfifictvoi To o"*jve%s?, ciov el TO [XSV A TW B, TW §5 
[xev Tu> [xecrco <r%*i^ctTi Kctl TptTco d[X(poTepcog ctv ev<^e%oiTo 30 A to x E >cctl tw E to Z, ^evbog <¥ stv\ to .vTrctpxetv tco 
to sv- dpxjj ctiTsTcr&cti, sv bs xctTY,yoptKc7i o-vkkoyto-[xu> sv A to Z' kcu ydp ovrcog cvbsv ctv y\ttov siy\ to ctcSuvctTOV 
Te Tw TptToo xcu tw TTpcoTco. oTctv $' d7ro(pct7ixcog , oTctv Tct dvctips$eio-Y\g 7Y\g e£ dpx^S v7ro$sosoog. dkkd &sT Trpog 7pvg 
a.v7ct diro t« cfJTK, xctt &x bfxcicog dfxcpo7spctt cu 7rpo7ct- e^ dpx%$ opcvg o-vvctTrTstv to dbvvctToV xtco ydp scrctt frtd 
ostg, coo-ctvTcog <5e jccu ev tw jitgcrct; <^ict to ^tt^ dvTicrpecpsiV ty,v v7rc$eo-tv, ciov eTrt fxsv to xcctco kctfxfictvcvTi to cruve^e? 
rovg opovg xctTct Tovg dTrocpctTtxovg o-vkkoytrfxovg. errt b\ 35 7rpog tov KctTY\yopovfxevov tcov opcov st yctp dbvvotTov to A 
To ev dpxy ctiTeTo-$ctt ev fxev TctTg ct7ro<5e^ecr< Tct >cctT' dkv\- tco A vrrctpx^v, d<pcups$svTog t« A «JceTi ec^ct* to \psvbcg. 
Qetctv VTCog e^ovTct, ev <^e to?? cftctkeKTiKoTg toc Kcvrd b^o^ctv. exl be to ctvw, >cctc^' « jcctT^yo^ierrctr ei yctp tco B [xy, sy- 
17 ■ To <5e fXY, Trctpct T6T0 (rvfxfictiveiv to ipsvfrog, o 7roX- X W P £ ^ T ° Z uTrct^ejv, d(pctips$svTog t» B hieTi ecrctt tq 
hctKtg ev ToTg kcyotg eicoQctfxev keyetv, 7rpcoTov fxev ecrtv ev dbvvctTov. bfxotcog oe xctt crepY\TiKcov tcov o-vkkoyio-fxwv 
ToTg sig to db y vvctTov o-vkkoyto-fxoTg, otccv irpog dvTtcpcttriv y\4oIvtcov. 

' 1. fetnvBi T3 C. II 14. -^j tl coyyAC. II 18. tjw* C. II 9r«ij jaCt «m<>p«<fc C. II 20. S^Aoyi?. II 21. ctkeHrisu omB. \\22,rSln.] 
ri kn, C. II 28. Ta ts foixwiihv C. II MxwwJBC. II -29. oc-jtuj \cip@dmv y, AC. II r£ om C. II 30. xxt ru rpircj C. II 32. Tcom^ II 
33. xcti om C. 

1. «yctp o pr, A. II dm<pri<Ta,i corr B. II 3. t^v dni<pA<Tiy] b chn.<pr]<rw A, o dnfyricriv JS et corr A. II 16. h ro"ti T07nxs<V JB. II 
ri allerum om B. II 18. fctxrjvM om BC. II 34. r£. xdrcu B. 

I 



66 ANAATTIK&N nPOTEPflN B. 

$ctvepov ovv on ra dcfvvctTov fxvi Ttpog Tovg e'£ dpx^S Tct kontct. xctv cft' evog fxeorov yivY\Tctt b crvkkoyto-fxdg , o,tto 
opovg ovTog « Ttctpd ty\v $e<rtv <rvfx@ctivet to "^evftog. y\ vcf t« /xetov ctpx£<r$ctt' fxdktcrct ydp dv %too kctv$dvot tov 
VTOog ds) bitd ty,v v7to$s<rtv ecrctt to ^pevcfog. xctt yctp ei fxv\ drKoxptvofxevov. 

tw B dkkd tu K he$Y\ to A vTtctpx^v, To b% K tw V 'E7rei & £%o / u.ev ttote xcti 7toog e^ovTuv toov opoov yi-20 

xctt tvto tu A, xa,t htw jxsvst tq db\>va,T0V ofxoioog 8e xct) 5 veTctt <rvkkoyt<rfxdg, (pctvspov xcti txot scrctt xctt TtoT ovx 
entt to ctvco kctfxftctvovTt Tovg bpovg, oocr' eTtet xcti ovrog xcti ecrctt eksyxog. Ttdrtoov fxh ydp (rvyxoopxfxsvoov , y\ svctKkct^ 

fXY\ OVTOg TKTOU <rVfX@CtlVSl TO db\)VCtTOV, OVX CtV e'lY\ TtCtpct Tl$SfXSVOOV TOOV Ct7COXpt<reOOV , ofov TY\g fXEV Ct7CO<pCtTtXYj? TY\g b% 

ty\v $e<rtv. v\ to fXY\ ovTog tvtov fXY\bsv y\ttqv yivs<r$at to ^ev- xctTct<parttxY[g, eyx^p^ yive<r$at ekeyx r ->v. r t v ydp (rvkkoyt- 
frog &x *tcv kY\7tTeov oocf ctkXx Tt$efxevov <rvfxficttvetv to crfxog xcti %too xcti exeivoog exdvroov toov opoov, oocr' el to xeir 
dovvarxov, dkk' oTctv d<pcttps$svTog tovtov frtd toov koi7toov 10 fxevov y\ evctvTiov t£> <rvfX7tspd<rfXctTi, dvdyxv\ yivs<r$ctt eksy- 
TtpoTctreoov TctvTQ 7tepcttvY{tctt doXivctTov, stts) TctvTo ye ^psv- X cv ' ° 7&P '^ksyx^ dvTt(pct<rsoog <rvkkoyt<rfxdg. ei Ss /xy\- 
oog <rvfx(3cttvetv ota, TtKetovoov V7to$e<reoov icfev tcroog dToitov, b\v <ruy%wpo?To, d$vvctTov yivs<r$ctt eXeyxov ov ydp v t v 
otov Tctg 7tctpctK>s.Yi/\ovg crvfXTtiTtTetv xcti et fxei^Coov ecyiv v\ <rvKkoyt<rfxog TtctvToov toov opoov crepYiTtxoov ovtoov, oocf &<Y 
evTog TY\g exTog xctt ei to Tpiyoovov l%« 7tXsiovg op$ctg eheyxw £' f^sv yctp sKeyx^, dvctyxv\ <rvXkoyt<rfxov etvcti, 
ovetv. 15 <rvKhoyt<rfxov <? 'ovTog ix dvctyxv\ ekeyxov. oorctvToog h\ xcti 

18 'O ^e ^sv^g Xoyog yiverctt Ttctpd to TtpooTov "^evfrog. el fXYjSh te$e{y\ xct^d ty\v d7tdxpt<rtv ev %Xoo' b ydp o,vto<s 
Y\ yctp ex roov 6\jo TtpoTctreoov y\ ex TtXetdvoov 7ta,g ecr) <rvk- scrctt frtopi<rfxog ekeyxov xcti <rvkkoyto-fxov. 

koyio-fxog. et fxsv ovv ex toov o\io, tvtoov dvayxvi ty\v srtepctv 'Xvfx^ctivet <¥ evioTe, xct$ct7tep ev ty\ $sost toov %poov2\. 

v\ xctt dfxcpoTspctg eivctt ^pevfrelg' ejr d/\7i$<2v ydp ix y\v 'pev- d7ta,Toofxs$ct, xcti xartd ty[V v7tokrrptv yivs<r$ctt nnv. d7tctTY\v, 
OY\g cvkkoytrfxog. ei cf ex Ttkstdvoov, ofov tq fxhV b^tdToov^ oiov st svStxsTctt to ctvTo 7tksio<rt TtpooToog vTtdpx^v, xcti 
A B, TctvTct £e S~td toov A E Z H, tovtoov ti ecrctt toov to fxev kskYi$svctt Ttvd xcti ois<r$ctt fxvicfevi vTtdpxsiv, to 8k 
htctvoo •p/evfrog, xcti Ttctpd T6To o kdyog' to ydp A xcti B elMvctt. ecroo yctp to A too B xcti tu V xct$' otvTd V7tctp- 
S~t' exetvoov TtspctivovTctt. oocre Ttctp . exetvoov ti uvfxfictivet to "Xfiv, xctt TctvTct 7tctvTt Tcy A oocrctvToog. el oSj tw fxh B to 
(rvfXTtspctrfxa, xcti to *\zEv$og. A Ttctvri oieTctt vTtcipx^v, xcti tkto tw A, tu> cfs T to A 

19 Hpog o% to fXY\ xctTct<rvkkoyiCe<r$ctt 7tctpctTYipYiTsov,?& fXYifrsvi, xctt t»to tu A TtctvTi, t% ctvrk xct^d tcovtov ePet 
oTctv ctvev toov <rvfX7tepct<rfxctToov epooTct tov kdyov, oTtoog fxy\ e7ttcjY\fx^v xctt dyvotctv. Ttdktv eH Tig dTtartY^siY^ 7tsp\ rd ht 
froSvi fog TctvTov sv rctig 7tpoTct<reo-iv, s7tet^Y\7tsp Xo-fxsv oTt TY\g ctvTY\g <rvcrotxictg, oTov et to A vTtdpx^ too B, t»to 8k 
ctvev fXEQ-ov <rvkkoyi<rfxog « yiveTctt, fxs<rov cf scr\ to 7tke- tw V xctt to T tw A, v7tokctfxfidvot cfe to A Ttctvii too B 
ovcxxtg keyofxevov. oog cfe cfet Ttpog exctcrov <rvfX7tepao-fxct ty\- VTtctpxstv xcti Ttctktv fXY^svi tw V' ctfxct ydp stosTcti ts xct) 
pe7v to fXETov, (pctvepov ex t« eibevctt 7to?ov ev sxdcrcp <rx^r 30 °v?k V7tokYf^eTctt V7tctpx^v. cXp' ovv \sb%v dkko dfyo? ex T»- 
/xctTt oetxvvTctt. t«to <^' YifxcZg « k.Y\rerctt c\tct tq ei&evctt 7toog toov y\ o e7ticrctTctt , t»to fxv\ v7toka,fxj2dveiv; eTticrctTcti yctp 
vTtsx^fxsv tov kdyov. Ttoog qti to A tw T vitctpx^ ^td t« B, oog ty\ xct$dkov to 

~Kpv\ cf QTtep (pvkctTTe<r$cti ttctpctyyskkofxev dTtoxptvo- xartd fxspog, oocre o Ttoog e7ticrctTcti , TXTo^okoog d^tot fxv\ 
[Xevovg, ctvTvg e7ttxetpovvTctg 7tetpa.<r$cti kctv$ctvetv. t»to &' v7tokctfxfictvetV 07tep dbvvctTov. S7t) <5e t» TtpoTepov kex$(v- 
eqctt TtpooTov, ectv Tct <rvfX7tepct<rfxctTct /xy\ Ttpoo-vkkoyil^oov- ^ Tog , ei jxy\ ex TY\g ctvT^g crvcroixictg to fxs<rov, xct$' sxctTS- 
Tcu ctkk eikYifXfxevoov toov dvctyxctioov ctb^Yikct y\, eTt b\ ctv pov fxh toov fxs<roov dptcpOTspctg Tctg 7tpoTct<rsig vx eyxoopeT 
(xq rct crvveyyvg epooTcX, dkk' oti /xctktcra, Td fxs<rct. otov v7tokctfxfia,vsiv, oTov to A tuj fxh B TtctvTi, t<2 <& V fxt^- 
ecroo foov <rvfX7tepctive<r$ctt to A xartd tk Z " fxscrct B T A E. cfsvi, tcxvto, cf dfxcpoTspa, TtctvTt tw A. <rvfx\2>aivsi ydp yj 
ost ovv spooTav ei to A tw B, xctt 7tctktv fxv\ ei to B tw aTtkoog y\ eTti ti evctvTictv kctfx(Bctver$ctt ty\v 7tpooTY\v TtpoTOr 
r, ctkk et to A twE, xctTtetTct et to B too V, xctt xtoo 40 <riv. ei yctp wtoB vTtctpx^, TtctVTi to A vTtokctfxftctvet 

2. opvi om pr C. II Xoty.l3cLv£i A. H 5. roirait B. 7. tc~to pr C. n ov/ajSa/vo» S. U 13. irocpxWfav; corr (in V?) A. !1 
14. l%ot AB. II 16. Trpoh-oy om B. II 17. &m C. II 21. & om BC II 23. vepaAtru C II 35. vpemvXK^urrM B. II 37. ri 
fj.(a~ocJ ^aec-» corr C. 

8. xctTiryapixft BC. II 20. TtpwTOis ABC. II 22. ^xp om AC II 24. A] & 7t*n\ C. II rS- 25. ttxvt! om C. H 25. fcar* 
etuTcy B. 



ANAATTIKnNIIPOTEPaNB. 67 

V7tdpx £ w, to ^ B tw A of^e, xcu otz tw A ro A oJ&v. <r$Y\tuv efcu TY\g cu<r$Y\<reug yevofxevov tcrfxev, \scY ctv y\q-$y\- 
w<r' « 7taKiv, w wF, fXY\hvL o\etcu to A 'J7retp;££iV, w to jM-evoi Tvyxdvufxev, el fxv\ ug tu ko,$oKov ko,) tu ex,eiv tyjv 

B TM VTCtpXei, T6TU &K o'lETCU TO A V7tCtpX £ lV. TO <^£ OlKElCtV E7TLCJY\fXY[V , CtAA' 0U% W£ TW EVEpyELV. TO ydp ETtl- 

•KctvTL ciofxevov wto B, xaAiv tw /x-yj offiT&u u to B, 71 <jct<r$cti KsysTcti TpiXM, h ug ty\ ko,$oKov y\ ug ty\ oiKSLa, 
dTtKug y\ ETti ti evcivTiov ecjlv. «tw /xev ovv vk svcfsx^tcti $ v\ ug tu svspysLv, ucje ko,l to Y\7ta,tY\Q-$a,i torctvtctx^' &^ £ v 

V7toKa.(3siV , KCt$' SKCttEpOV Ss tY\V fXLCtV Y\ KCttd $Ctt£pOV dfX- VV KUKVSL KCU sicfsvctl KcU Y\7ta,tY\Q-$Ctl TTSpl tCtVtd , 7TKy]v \5K 
(pOtEpctg icfsv KUKVEL, OLOV TO A 7T0LVTI tU B KCtt TO B TU EVCtVtLUg. %7VSp <rv[A@cLlVEl KCU TU XCt$' SKO,tspctV Stcfotl Ty)v 

A, Kcti txcoKiv to A fXYjcfsv} tu T. bfxotct ydp y\ TOiavTYj 7tpoTa,<rtv kcu fxvj er eo-KefXfx.lv co 7rpoTepov. vTtoKctfxfidvuv' yclp 

Ct7CCVTYI KCU ug d7tCtTUfXS$Ct Ttspt TCt EV fXSpst, 0T0V sl TU B K.VEIV TY\V Y\[X10V0V MK £%£f Ty]v KOJtd TO EVEpySlV STtLCJY^fXYy, 
TtCtVTi TO A VTtcLpXZL ■> TO <& B TU T TtCtVtt, TC A 7IUVTJ 10 OVcY CtV c\id Ty]v V7toK.YfpiLV EVCtVtLCtV d7tdtY\V TY\ ETf LtJY\fXY[' 

tu T vTtctp^ei. ei «v Ttg cTfrsv 'oti to A, u to B, vTtctp- trvKKoytcrfxog yctp v\ svctvTtct d7ta,TY\ ty\ ko,$oKov. 

X £ i txOjVtI, oTfrs kcu oti tu T. dx^l vcYsv kuXvei cXyvoslv 'O tV vTtoKccfx^ccvuv to dyaSu sTvcu k&ku eTvcu, to 

T0 r OTJ SCJLV, cToV si TO fXSV A &V0 hpScLL, TO $' ECp' <f) B CtUTO VTTOkYI^STcU dya,Su ELVCU KCU KAKU. ECTU ydp TO jtAey 

rpiyuvcv, tc cY scfj u T o,Iq-$y\tov Tpiyuvov. v7roXa,(3oi yap dya,$u eTv&l s(p' » A, to os kcjlku eivcu ecp' » B, TrdXtv 
(tv tl<; fJ,Y\ eTvcu to T, ei(}ug oti ttcXv Tpiyuvov exjei cfvo op-15 cfs to dya,$u sTvcu scp' « T. eVej ovv tccvtov v7ro\a,fx,(3cl- 
$a,g, u<r$' djuca, ettreTcu kcu dyvoY\<reL tccvtov. to ya,p eic\e- vei to B kou to T, ko,l eTvcu to T to B v7ro\Y\ipercu , kcu 
vo,l 7ra.v Tptyuvov oti c\to op$cu<; &x dTtXovv ecjlv, dKka, Trctktv to B to A eTvcu uxrctvTu'?, oocre Kcti to T to A. 
to fxev tu ty]v Kct$okov e%eiv e-KLcjY[fx,Y\v, to h\ ty]v ko,$' u)<r7rep ydp si y\v dKv\$sg, K,ct$' ov to T, to B, k,o,l ko,$' 

eKCtCJQV. %TU fXEV «V US TY\ Kct$o\0V oTcfs TO T OTl b\jO hp- « TO B, TO A, KCU KCtTO, T» T TO A^dXy\$S^ Y\V, OVTU KCU 
$Ctl, Ojg ^e TV\ KCt$' EKCtCJOV YK oThv, UCj' *X *& Ta?20£7T< T« V7T0XctfX.(BctVSlV. OfXOlU? <fs KCtl £7tl T« ELVCtl' TO.VV6 

h/ctvTictg. ofxotus <Ye kcu o ev tu Msvuvl \oyos, otl y\ fxa,- yctp ovTog t» T kcu B, kcu TtaXiv T« B ko,l A, kcu to T 
$Yi<rL<; dvdfxvYiQ-L;. &cfa,/xv ydp <rv/x(Ba,Lvsi 7tpos7:Lcjct<r$cti to tu A t<xutov y\v. Iocje ko,l stkl tk c^q^xZslv ofxofug. a,p «v 

KO,$' EKCtCJOV, d\X dfXCt TY\ E7tCtyuyY\ XctfxfictVELV TY\V TUV T6T0 fXEV dvctyKOAOV , EL Ttq &UQSI TO TtpUTOT, *Ct>wX' ftTUS EKslvO 

KO,rd fxspog £7ticj^fXY\v ucTTtep dvctyvupiXpvTcti;. evict yctp ev- ipsvfrog, to v7to\ct(3s?v Tivct ko,ku sivcti to dya,$u eTvcu, 
$vg t<rfxsv, oTov oti c\vo lp$cug, kdv sibufxsv "oti Tpiyuvov.25 el jxy\ kcctco <rvfx(3£(3Y\Ko<;' TtoKkctx^? ydp kyxupEL tW 

OfXOLUg Ss KCti S7t\ TUV dXkUV. V7t0\a,fx(BdvELV. E7tl<rK€7tTeOV &E THTO fiskTLOV. 

1y\ fXSV «V KCt$QkX SsupVfXEV Td EV fXspSL , TY\ <f 01- ^OTAV <Y dvTLCjp((pY\ TCt CtKpct, dvctyKYj KCtl TO fXS<T0V 22 

Ksia, xk to-fxsv, ucj svhsx^tcu Kcti d7tctTcL<r$cti Ttspt ctvTct, dvTLcjpicpstv Ttpog ctfxcpu. si yctp to A KctTct T» r frid T« 
vKy\v v,k svctvTiug, clXA.' e%£iv ^aev ty\v Kct$o\ov, dTtartcX- B VTtdpx^i £ i dvTicjpscpsi %o,l v7tctpx £ i-> oo to A, 7rctVTf 
<r$ctL <Ys ty\ Kartd fxspog. bfxoiug «v kcu st:l tuv 7tposipv\fxs- 30 to T, kcu to B tu A dvTicjpecpei, xcti vTtctpx^-» oo to A, 
vcov' « ydp svctvTLct y\ Kctrd to fxs<rov d7ta,TY\ t^ kocto, tov ttctvTi to B &d fxs<rov t« T, xa,i to T tu B dvTicjpscpei 

<rvKkoyi<rfXOV e7tL<JY\fXY\, VcY Y\ KCt$' EKCtTEpOV TUV fXSTUV VTtO- fod fXEQ-QV T» A. KCtL ETtL T» fXY[ VTtCtpX^tV UrctVTUg, OLOV 

"kfjpLg. icYsv <£e kuKvei eiboTct kcu oti to A oKu tu B ei to B tu T i)7tdpx £ h tu e% B to A &X V7tdpx £ i, »^e 
V7tdpx £ i »<*' tt&KLV T6T0 tu T, oiY\$Y[Vcti fxv[ v7tdpx £ tv to To A tu T ovx v7ta.p%£L. ei c\y[ to B tu "A. dvTicjpetpei, 
A tu T, oTov otl 7tdo~a. Y\fx(ovog ctTOKog koa cwty\ yfxiovog 35 kcu to T tu A dvTicjpe^pei. ecju yctp to B {xy\ v7tctpx ov 

cts<r$Ctl KVEIV tCtVtY\V' & yctp £7TLCja,tCtl Otl TO A TU T, fXY\ TU A' OVcY Ctpct TO T' TtCtVTL yctp TU T TO B V7CY\pX £V ' 

<rvv$£upuv to ko,$' EKdTspov. ucje <Yy\Kov 0Ti Kcti si to fxsv Kcti si tu B to r dvTLcjpscpEt, Kcti TU A dvTLcjpscpEL' KO,$' 
cTcJs to <Ye fXYj oTcfsv, d7tctTY$Y\Q-£TctL' 07t£p sxovriv cu Kct- » yctp d^tctvTog to B, xcu to T. Kcti el to T Ttpog T0 A 
SoKov ttpog Tdg KctTct fxspog £7ticjY\fxctg. icfsv yctp tuv cti- dvTicjpe(pei, ko,l to B dvTicjpecpei Ttpog to A. u yctp to B, 

2. 7 7r*vT v i pqM C. I 6.xaTO flctTEpov] x*fi£x*T£poy AB. II 9. tx] toL<; ABC. I! tS] Zi ro B. 11 11. rh /3 corr^. II l4. u] 
5 AC. II 18. tS om AC. II 25. otov om C. II i^sv C et corr A. II 29. p&t om B. II 32. irspoy A. II 35. oZtki $ ^iom A. II 
37. ix&rspov >.YiiA,pi,a,. J?-e A, II 39. xaSoAv 7rpoTa.(T£i? 7rpo; A. 

3. »j roAB. II 5. to A. II 11. <yclp i<r»h C. II 12. ro prius corr AC. II 13. ri corr AC. II 2k. rl fy.] xx\ fy. B. II 37. tc @tm 
pr AB et corr C. II to pr AB. 

12 



68 ANAATTIKaN IIPOTEP&N B. 

ro T* w ds 70 T, ro A b% vrapxet. kol .y,ovov t«to to y,Y\ 'towtov WJWififoii x^pK^^ 1 T ° s '^' * ^, <^°»' ° T < 
cc7ro' t« <rvy.7repdry,a,7og dpX £T ' a,l i r d cY oKKa, &x oycotoog 70 A to tozStov sTvcii atpszurepov ecrtv y\ to x^pK,^^ 1 - to 
xctl eVl t£ . jcccTJjyo/Httoy <rvKKoyi<ry,^. TrctKtv el.ToAxcM apct, . (ptKeT<r$a,L ..'7%$ <rvvov<rtog citpermepov Karrd tov epooTct. 
to B clvricj-pe(pei,-}icu to Y ko\ to. A oorovToog, drrovTt <^' y,o}.Kov a,pa, b epoog e<ri TY,g (ptKtog vj tov crvveTvot. el cYb 
cLvccyKYi to A v\ to/T v~ropxeiV, kol to B xo\ A xToos e£ei S. y,oKL<ra,'7ov7ov, kcu 7eKog t?to. to ctpct o-vveTvcu y\ &k ecrtv 
cocre ir&v-X Qclrepoy V7rdpx £ iv. e~re\ ydp cp to A, to v B, y.ct) oKoog n T« (pi\eT<rScu eveKev'. kcu ydp 0,1 a,KKoi £7rt$vfXioi 
ct> to\I\ to A, ~ron\ 6% to A n to Y kcu- ovx. dy,ct, (pa,- kcu Texvcu cvtoo ytvovjcu. 

vepov o7i KcuTo B .y\ to A ttovtl kol vx dy,a.. oTov el tq Jloig y-ev ovv exovcriv ot opoi Karxd TctV dv7icrpo(pdg23 

dyevYjTov cupQapTov kcu to ■ a,<p$opTov dyevviTOV, dvdyy.vi to kcu ' tq oJpeTooTepov v\ ipevKToTepov eTvoi,. (pctvepov of* cY cv 
yevoy,£vov <p$opTov kcu to (p$opTov yeyovevof $vo ydp <rvK- iQ fAovov ol ' $loK£ktlkol kcu cl7ro^etKTtKo\ <rvKKoyt<ry,o\ hd 
Xoyicry,o\ crvyKetvTcu. yroKtv et txovti y,ev to A y\ to B kcu toov 7tpoeipY l y,evoov ytvovTcu <rx"^y-oo70ov, dKKd kcu ot pYcxopi- 
to r 7i to A, dyca, Se y,v\ v7ropx £ L, el dvftcrpecpet' to A koi kcil ctTrXoog r]Ti<royv Trtqtg kcu r\ y,ct$' QTroictvw [xeSocfov^ 
Kcti to F, Kctt to B Kctt 70. A civTtcTpecpet. et yctp 7tv\ y-vj vvv clv ttY\ XeKTsov. ct7rctvrau yctp ir : icjevoy,ev y\ cfta) <rvK?\0- 
v7rcLpx £ t-.7o B, w 7o A, 8y\\ov%7l. 7o A V7rctpxsL. ' el 8& yt<Ty,ov yi ejr eTr&yooyYiS. 

7o A, .^ctl.To r* ctv7tcrp{(pei ycip. ucre ,cty,ct Tp. T. Kct} A. 15 'E7rct^coyYi y,ev-w ecri Kcti o e^ eTrctyooyng crvXKoyt- 

T670 cY d$vvct7dv. %7ctv Si 70 A.okoo 7oo B Kctl TcJ; r cyo$ 7Q hct t» hepov QctTepov ctKpov tu> y,eroo <rvKhoyt<rctr 
vTTctpx^ y-&\ ytYifrevog ctKKov KctTYiyopYiTcCi, ' VTrctpx^ <& K&t fQcti, ojov et Tooy AY-fxecrov to B, foa) t« T cfeT^cti 70 A 
70 B tto-vu tw r> ctvctyKYi to A Kcti B oLvTicrpeipeiV e%e\ tw EyjrctpxeLV . «tw ydp 7rotxy,e$a, 7a,g e7rctyooyct<;. olov 
yctp KctTct fXovoov 70ov 9 B r \eye7cti to A, Ka,TYiycpeTTa,i o% ecroo : 'to A-fAa,Kpo$LOV, to cf e(p' wBw %oX^v y,^ exov, 
ro B kcCl ctvTo. O.VT6 ko,\ jv V ,- (pa,vepov oTL Kct$' oov tq.A, 20 i(p' oo cfe V to Kct$' eKctcrov y,ctKpo(3tov , oTov a,v$poo7rog KCti 
Kcti to B kex$Yi?$7cti TrdvToov 7tXyiV .ctv7^ t? A.~ .TrctXiv oTctv i7r7rog'Kcti Yiy,tovog.- tw $yj V oKop V7ra,px^ to A* 7rctv ydp 
7o A Kcti 70 B oKoo 7oo r vTrdpxy, dv^icrpecpYi ^e.To-F 70 ctxoKov /A.a,Kpo(2iov. dKKa, ko,l7qB, to y,Y\ exeiv %oX>jv, 
7uB, dvdy.KYj 70 A tto,v7\ tw B vTrdpx^LV er^L ydp tto-vtl ira,VTL vrra,pxeL tw V. el w dvTicrpecpeL to T tm B kcu y,vj 
7u V 70 A, 70 | T tw B cftd 70 &v7icrpe(p£iv t kcu 70 A V7rep7etvet 70 y,ecrov , dva,yKY\ 70 AtwB virdpx^v. M$etK~ 
7ra,VTi 700 B'v7rdppeu oTctv cfe frvoTv ov7otv 70 A t« Bctl-25 7cti yctp nrpo^epov o7L dv Svo 0,770. tw o,v7oo vTrdpXA x&\ 
pe7oo7epov yj, cv7oov dv7tKety,evoov, kcCl to A tS Y oo<rctv7oog, Trpog $a,7epov ctmoov wmcrpecpy 70 OKpov, c7i 700 dv7tcrpi~ 
el 'ctipe70o7epct Ta AT twv B'A, to A t« A a,tpe7oo7epov. <pov7t Kctt $a,Tepov vTXctp^ei toov KctTYiyopovy,evoov. cfeT c% voeTv 
oyooLoog ydp $looktov'to A ko,\ (pevKTov to- B* dvTiKetyeva, to F to e^ dna^vTcov twv ko,$' eKctcrdv <rvyKety,evoy' r) ydp 
ydp. Kcti 70 r rw A* Kcti ydp toZto, dvTtKetTa,i. ei ovv £7ro,yooyYi otd TrctvToov. 

TO A tw A cytotoog cttpeTov, ko\ to B too Y (pevKToV eKct-30 Ecri cY ToiovTog crvKXoyio~y,og TY t g 7rpooTY\g ko\ dy,i- 

Tepov ydp eKOTepcp by,otoog, (pevKTov biooKTop. oocre.Kctt ta o~ov 7rpoTo<recog' oov y,ev yctp ecri y,e<rov, cftd tov fxerov a 
ctfxcpoj 7d AT 7oTg B A. £7T£< M 'y,d.KKov, ovx oiov 7£ cvKKoyt<ry,og, oov <Je y,v\ £<ri, cft' s7ra,yooyY,g. ko,\ 7po~rov 
bfxotoog' kcu 'ydp dv 70 B A byootoog- r^ctv.. el &s t.o A t» A TiVct, ctv7tKet7a,i y\ e7ra,yooyY\ tw <rvKKoyi7y,u>' b y,ev yop hd 
ctlpeTooTepov , kcu to B tk Y y\ttqv (pevkToV to yctp 'eKctT-r tk y,erov to clkoov 700 Tptrop c\ s etKW<rtv , y\ c\e frta, t5 Tpfrox} 
tov 700 eXar-Tovf dv7tK£t7o,i. cttp£7oo7£pov <£e to fxit^ov dya,- 35 to ctKpov 7op y,£<rop. (pv<r£i y,ev kv 7rpo7epog Kctt yvoopty.oo7~- 
$ov Kctl eKct77ov kokov v\ 70 eKo77ov dyct$ov ko,\ y,e7tpv pog b Slo, t» y,e<rov <rvKKoyL<ry.og, Y t y,Tv cY evopyecrepog o 
KctKoV kcCl 70 d-rov dpo , 70 B A, cupe7oo7epov tk AT. §lo, 7Y t g e7royooyY\g. 

vvv fr' xk .ecrLV. 7o A ctpct oJpeTwTepov t« A, kol tq Y ctpct YiopocfeLyy,ct &' -ecr)v otov too y,e<rop to ctKpov v~rop-2^ 

T« B »Jttov <pevKTov. £t $?] eKotTo Trog p epoov koto, tov x ov ^ ei X^V ^* T ^ oy,OLOV T'cp TptTop. SeT c\e kol tq y,e<rov 
epooTo, to A to 0'jtw? ex slv ^~~ £ x^pK 617 ^ 1 ^ KcL ^ T0 f xy ' 40 T( ? r P^V tct) to 7rpoo7ov tw by,oiop yvoopty,ov eTvoi v~rdpxov. 
XoptX^r^oL 70 e(p' « Y, y\ to ^ct/j/^eo-fScu to etp' v A, k<m olov ecroo to A kokov, to cfe B nrpog by,opovg dva,ipeT<r$ctc 

9. wftmro- C bis. fl 15. noci to c> C. II 33. BA] /9 7 C. II 37. t3 BA om C. 
. 2. %bipfcu.7'-u.i . IiC. !l . 7 . fivdrtiu] ^ivsyrja «/37c> A, om BC. II 10. hihv/.Tot pr A. II 12. n om BC. W 13. "rt<?cvfi& C. II 
18. •J7rcif%ov B, om C. II 35. h om C. II 39. M— 40. r ? hu om C. 



ANAAtfTIK^N IIPOTEPfiN B. 69 

<jroXefxov, i(p' Z Se Y ro 'A$yiVcllov? irpog QY\@cucvg, to 8* kcl$oXov rvXXoyirfxo?g. (pepeTcu $e y) svcjcLrtg &%w? kcl\ 
i<p> Z A &Yi(3cctovg Trpog 3>ooKs?g. 'eclv w (BovXoofxsScL frsl^cu $lcl 3vo ryy^cvxoov , $i%u<; fxsv ot; y\ kcl$oXov y) iv fxepei 

OTL TO OYiftcClOl? 7ToXefXS?V KCLKOV i<JL, \Y{KTS0V OTL TO TTpog TTcXrcL EVCJcLrLg, SK <$V0 Ss rXYifAcCTOOV OTl CLVTLKsifXEVCU <p£- 

rovg o/xopcvg 7roXsfxs?v kclkcv. tovtov &s TTLcjig sx, toov povTcu ty\ TrpoTcLrsL, Tcl t¥ dvTLKsifxsva, iv tw TrpooToo kcl) 

OfXOLOOV, 0T0V OTL 0>}/3ct<Of? TTpcg $>OOKS?g. ETTEL «V TO TXpoC, 5 TW TpiTCO rXYIfXcLTL TTSpcilVOVTCU fXOVOig. %TcLV ydp dfyoorYl 

rovg ofxopxg xclxov, tq frs Trpcg Qy,(3cuovs Trpcg ofxopcvg ecjt, otclvtl vTrapxsLv, ivL<j<Lfxs$cL otl cvfrsv) v\ %Xi tlv) &x vTrcLp- 

<pCLV£pOV OTl TO TtpoS QyiP&LOVS TTOXsfXSLV XCLXQV. OTl fXEV *V %EL' TttTWV 8e TO fXSV fXY\8sv) ix TK TTpcoTOV CT^VjjttetTO?, TO 
TO B TW r KCLL TW A V7r<Lp%El, (pCLVSpOV (cL[X(pOO ycLp ECJl 8s TLVL fXY\ EK Ttt glT^CtTK. 0T0V ECJOO 70 A fxicLV sTvcLL 'sTTLCJYr 

Trpog rovg bfxopovg dvcups?r$cu TroXsfxov)^ kcll otl to A too [xy\v, i(p' u to B evclvtlcl. TxpoTsivcLVTog 8y\ /xiccv eTvcll toov 

A (QYtficLLOLS ycLO « rVVYj VEyKSV TZpoS $>0OK£?g 7toKs'fXOg)' OTL 10 EVCLVTLCOV 'sTTLCJY^fXYiV, Y\ OTL oXoOg &% Y\ CLVTy) TOOV dvTLKELfXEVOOV 
<% TO A TCp B V7TcLpXEL, &LCL TH A C^g^^crgTct/. TOV CLV- ivicjCLTCLL, Tct 8' fiVCtyTJCt CLVT LKSlfJ.SV CL , UCJE ytVSTcU TO TTpoOTOV 
TOV C^e TpOTTOV KCLV sl &LCL 7rXSLOV0OV TOOV OfXOLOOV Y\ TXLCJLS yL- V)Q\fXCL, V\ 'oTl TK yvOOCJOV KCLL CLyVOOCJX « fXLcL' T6T0 $S TO 
VOITO T« fXSroV Ttpog TO CLXpOV. (pcLVSpoV VV OTl TOTTCLpcL^SL- TpLTOV' KCLTCL ycLp T» V, T« yvOOCJX KCLL dyvOOCJV, TO [XEV 

yfxoo ecjlv «Tg oog fxspog Ttpog oXov kte cog okov_ Txpog (xspog, svclvtlcl sTvcll d\Y[$sg, to $s fxlcLV clvtoov E7ricjYifXYiv sT/cu ^psv- 
dXX' oog fxspog 7tpog fxspog, otclv oofXfpoo fxsv y\ v%o tclvto, 15 frog. ttclKlv stzl TY\g cjspYfrLxrig TtpoTcLrsoog oorcLVTcog. dfyovv- 

yvOOpLfXOV Se $CLTSpOV. XCLL ^LCLCpspEl TY\g ETT cLyooyYfi , OTL Y\ TOg ydp fXY\ sTvcLl fXLCLV TOOV EVCLVTIOOV , Y\ OTL .TTcLVTOOV TOOV dv- 

fxh s^ dircLVTcov toov drofxcov to cLxpov ec\eixvvsv v7rcLpX £ W tlxel/xsvoov y\ otl tlvoov svclvtloov y) clvty) Xeyofxev, oTov vytei\% 
Tu fxeroo xcu Trpog ro oLKpov « o-uv^7rT£ tov rvXXoyirfxov, kcll voroo^ovg' to fxev vv ttclvtcov ex t« TrpooTov, to &s tlvoov 
to c% kcll rvvcL7TTEL kcl) &k i^ ctTTct^Twv c^siKwrLV. ek tk T/jjTov r%Y\fxcLTog. d7rXoog ydp sv rrcLri KCL$0\0V fXSV 

25 ' A.7rccyooyYJ cY ecj)v qtclv tw fxsv fxsrco to 7rpooTov 8yJ- 20 EvtcjcLfxsvov dvccyxYi 7rpog to xclQcXov toov TrpoTELVOfxsvoov ty)v 

XOV Y\ VTTCLpXOV, TOO cY £0"^CtTWTO fXSfOV CL$Y\kOV fXSV, CfXOlOOS dvTKpCLrLV EL7rS?V, oloV EL /Xy) TY\V CLVTYJV dfyc? TOOV SVCLVTLOOV 
Se 7TLCJOV Y\ fXcLXXoV T» rvfXTTSpCLrfXcLTOg , STl CLV oXiycL V\ 7TCLV700V, EnroVTcL TOOV dvTLXSLfXEVOOV fXLcLV. VTOO c¥ dvcLyXYj TO 

Tct fxsrcL V6 sr-xjxTov xcll tk fxsrcv' 7rcLv7cog yap syyvrepov Trpoorov elvcll ryjifxcL' fxsrov y<xp yivsrcu to xclSoKov rrpcg 
eTvcu rvfxftcLivsi TY\g E7rtcjY\fXY\g. oTov ecjoo to A to ^c^ctKTov, to e^ dpxY\g. sv fxspsi $s, Trpog o ecjl kclSoXov kcl$' ■ ov Xg- 

E(p' OV B S7TLCJY\fXY\, TO Y C^LKcLLOrvVY\. Y[ fXSV VV ETTLCJY\fXY\ OTL 25 ySTCU Y[ TTpOTcLrLg, OICV yVOOCJX KCLL dyVOOCjd fXY\ TY\V CLVTY\V 
^LC^CLKTOV, (pCLVEpcV Y[ fr' dp£7Y\ EL £7TlCJY\fXY\, CLOYjXoV. EL ilV 700 ydp EVCLV7LCL XClSoXoV TTpog TctUTct. >CCtl yiv£7CU 70 TpiTOV 

ofxoioog y\ fxdkkov 7Tlcjov to B Y t« AT, d7rcLyooyvi ecjlv' rx^fxcc' fxsrov yctp to iv fxspsiXcLfx^cLvofxsvcv, oTcv to yvon- 
eyyvTspov ydp t« 's7ricjcLr$cLL S~lcl to TrpcrsLXY^evcu ty,v AF cjcv kcll to uyvoocjcv. s^ oov yccp scjl rvXXcyircLrdcu tovvclv- 

ETTLCJ^fXYy TTpoTSpOV YK EXOVTcLg. Y\ TTCLKlV sl okLycL TCt jtt£0"Ct TiOV, £>t TCVTOOV KCLL Tct? SVCJcLrstg iTTLXeipOVfXSV XsySLV. &L0 

toov BT' >cctl ydp XTOog iyyvTepov t« fic^vcti. olov si to A 30 >tcti sx fxcvcov tovtoov toov rx^iy^Toov (pspcfxsv' iv fxovoig ydp 
eiYi TETpcLyooviXsr$cLL, to cf i(p' co E EvSvfpcLfitfxoVy to <$"' ol dvTLXsifxsvoL rvXXoyLrfxci' c^ct yct^j t» fxsrov xx Y t v kol- 
i(p' u> Z xvxKog' sl wEZ £V fxovcv eiy\ fxsrov, tq fXsTco TcL(pcLTLxoog. stl c^s kclv Xoyov Ssolto TrXsiovog y\ hd tk fxs- 
[XY\virKoov 'irov yivsrScLL svvvypcLfXfxoo tcv kvkXcv, iyyvg dv rov o-XY\y<cLTog, olov sl fxr] S~o[y\ to A tw B V7ra,pxeiv Slcl 

ElYl T« eISsVcU. OTCLV Se fXYfTE TTLCJOTSpOV Y\ TO B Y T« A r fXYJX* TC fXYl dKOXoV$S?V CLVTOO TO Y. T8TO ydp S~l' CLXXoOV TTpOTcL- 

oXiyoo Tct fxsrcL, % Xstyoo dircLycoyY^v. icY otclv cL/xsrov v\ to 3$ rsoov SVtkov' ov Ss? c% slg clXXcl iKTps7rsr$cu ty)v svcjccriv, 

BT* i7TLCJY\fXY\ ydp TO T0V6T0V. d,XX' £V$vg (pcLVSpdv EXSLV TYJV STEpcLV TrpoTCLrtV. S~LQ KCLl T0 

26 y Evc7cto-jc; cV icj) TrpoTccrLg TrpoTcLrsL ivcLvricL. hLcL(plpu rY\fX£?ov ix fxovcv tovtov t« rxYifxcLTog &k ecjlv. 

8s TY\g TrpoTcLreoog, otl ty)v fxev evcjcLrtv iv^ExeTcu eTvcLL i^ri 'Y,7rLrKS7rTsov Se kcl) Trsp) toov clXXoov ivcjdrsoov, olov 

fxspovg, ty)v 3e TrpoToorLV v\ oXoog %k ivSexeTcu v\ &x iv T0?g rrep) toov sk tk ivcLVTK kcl) t» o[xom kcl) tv kclt& So^clv , xou 

11. tw /3 t3 * C. H 12. 7&WTI C. II 13. *y om C. I! 15. th Itto to afrro C. II 25. cv & i3 B. I ts ^ 7 C. II 28. TrpoeiM- 
4>(m C. II 31. §•' prius om C. II 32. l<p' £ om B. II 34. j[J eir\ C. II 35. y om C. 

1. &%£; T£ xcti C. II 3. ix\ hci C. II 6. cTi — V7rclpxei] r\ oti Ti-h rj ou ibev\ y.r) V7ra,px,ei C. II 9- ui B, v C. II to om C. II t-m 
h/ccniuv }jl((M £t'v*j C. II 15. ccfyovncu A, cifyoZnsc; B. II 16. «jclp toj jxy) C. II 17. A^/wfi» i?. II 19- cI-k&gl C. II 20. mg-ctyivuiv B. II t'm l 

vrpOTUVO[A.tVUl AB. II 28. TC Oin C. II T& kvXVTtCt C. II 30. Cr^^cCTWy, TVT(^L Ta -KpuiTV XCCl TB TftTV, (fjfyoftll/ C. II 31. XCCTCCtpXTiyJ; C. II 

32. tj] ei C. II 38. clov x&\ 7te^ t» ivccvtU C. 



70 ANAATTIK^N nPOTEPflN B. 

£t TY,V EV fXEpEt £K V6 TtpOOTCV y TY\V CTepY\TlKY\V £K T6 fXeCOV H Sv\ OVTCO StatpeTeOV TC <TY,fXe?0V , TdTWV <% 70 fAE<T0V 

Svvoltov kafie?v. TeKfxv,ptcv kv\7tTeov (to yap TeKfxv\ptov tc elSevat 7totovv <pdr- 

27 Eikos 6% kcu <rvifxe?ov cv TavTov icrtv, dkka to fxev <rtv eTvat, tcicvto <fe fxaktcra tq fX£<rov), y\ to, /xev ek toov 

« etKcg icri TtpoTartg svSofyg' o yap 00; iitt tc Ttokv 't<ra<rtv aKpoov <TY\fXE?a ksKTsov, to <f ek th jxercv TeKfxv\ptcV evSo- 

ovtoo ytvofAsvov v\ fxv\ ytvofxsvov v\ ov v\ fxv\ cv, tSt' icrtv el- 5 jtotcitcv yap xcu fxdktcra dkv\$\g to Std ts TtpcoTov <rx*r 

Kog, otov to fu<retv Tcvg <p$ovovvTag y\ tq (ptk£?v Tcvg ipoo- fxaTog. 

fxevovg. <TY\fxe?ov h\ i3ovkeTai etvat TtpoTartg aT: c$etKTtKY\ To <% <pv<rioyvoo/xove?v SvvaTov icrtv, et Ttg SiSoocrtv dfxct 

cLvccyKctia, v\ evSo^og' ov yap ovTog ecrtv v\ » yevofxevov ntpo- fXETafidkkEtv to croofxa kcli ty)v ~^vX^ v -> ° <rct ' <pvo~ M d i''' 
repov y\ vcrepov yeyove to Trpayfxa , tSto <rv\fxe?ov icrt t» ye- 7ta$Y,fxaTa' fxa$oov yap tcroog fxov<rtxv)v fxeTafieftkviKe tl ty\v 
yovevat v\ eTvat. iv$v[XY\fxa fxev ovv icrt <rvkkcyt<Tfxog e£ eIkc- 10 *^%>fv, dkk' cv toov (pvost v)fx?v icr\ t?to to 7ta$cg, dkk' 
ruv v\ <rv\fj,£toov , kafxfiavETat c\e to <TY\fxe?cv Tpt^oog^ o<ra- oTov opydt Kat iitt^vfxiat toov <pv<ret Ktvyreoov. el <foi tkto ?a 
"Xfiog kcu to fAecrov iv Tc?g <TX"f\(^<x<rtV v\ ya)p oog ivToo 7tpcoTco <}o$eiYi KO,t ev evog <rv\fAe7cv eTvou^ xa,\ <}vva,tfA£$a, \a,fA.fia,veiv 
v\ oog iv tw fA.e<roo y\ Cog iv tw TptTco, otov to fAev <feT^a,t kvy,- to ifoov eKa,crov yevovg 7td$og ko,\ o~v\fAe?ov, $vvYi<rofA,e$a, <pv- 
<roiv Sta, to ya,\a, ex^tv iK tov TxpooTov o-XflfAcvtcg' fxe<rov <rtoyvoofAove?v. el yaup icjtv Ibta, tiv\ yevet v7rapx°v a,TofA,co 
ya)p to ydXa, g%ew. e<p' 00 to A Kvetv, to B yaXa, e%e/v, 15 7r&#o?, ofov Totg Kecvctv dvt\peta,, chva,yKv\ ko,\ o~Y\fAe?ov mcu 
yvvv) icp' to r. to o' oTt 01 <ro<pot o-rcv^OAct, JIiTTa,Kog ya)p tl' <rvfA7tci<rx^tv ya)p dXXyXctg v7toK£tTa,t. ko,i £cjoo t»to to 
(TTtovScuog , ha, t« eV%«,Tou. i<p' 00 A to <T7tovcfa,?ov, i<p' £> [A-eydiXa, to, ciKpooTypta, 'ex^tv' ko,i a,Xkotg vTtapx^ y*~ 
B o\ <ro<pot) i<p' 00 r ILtTTAKog. a\\v\$\g cfv\ vcau to A kcu v£<rt fAvj okotg iv^x^Tcu. to ydp <rY\fX£?ov ovToog icftov itrtv, 
To v B t« r KciTYiyopvirctt' 7-\y\v tc (xev « Xeyov<rt bta, ro elfrs- oti oKov yevovg 'tfriov ecrt to 7tcl$og, kcu ov fxovov i<fiov, 
vcu, to <$k Xa,fA.(Ba,vov<rtv.^ tq Se xvetv, oti coxp<*"> <$td tcv 20 oo<r7tep e\cc$afxev Xeyetv. VTtdpfcet Sy) koi iv aXKco yevei 
fxecrcv crxyfAaTog (iovKeTat nvai' i~r Et yap e-rerat Talg xv4- TavTo, xat ecrat dv<5~pe?og av$poo7tog koa aWo Tt Tooov. 
<ratg to ooXPWi aKo\ov$e? c\e Kat TavTY\, &e<)e?x$ai ctovrat efcet apa to o-vifxeTov' ev ydp evcg y]v. el tcivvv TavT ecrt, 
OTt Kvet. to dxpw ecp' cv to A, to xvetv i(p' cv B, yvvv) Kat SvvYpofxe^a TotavTO, <rv\fxe?a crvWe^at iTti tovtoov toov 
i(p' ov r. idv fxev «v v) fxta Xex$y 7tpoTa<rtg, <rv\fxe?ov yive- "Qdcov cX fxovov ev 7td$og ex^t Tt tfrtov, eKacrov <Y £%e; <rtf 
zat fxovcv, idv t\e Kat v\ eTepa <7tpo<rKY\(p$^ , <rvKkoyt<rfxog,2S fxe?cv, iitei-Kep ev ex^tv dvdyKY\, Svvvpofxe^a cpvtrtcyvoofxo- 
oTcv otl JJtTTaKog e\ev$eptcg' ot yap (ptXoTtfxoi i\ev$iptot, ve?v. el-cfe bvo exet 'tbta okov to yevcg, oTov 6 Keoov dvc\pe?cv 
TLtTTaKcg 8e (ptXoTtfxog. y\ Ttaktv oti 01 <ro<pot dya$oi' ILt- Kat fxeTacfoTtKov, Ttoog yvco<ro/xe$a TtcTepcv TtcTepcv <rYifxe?ov 
TaKcg ydp dya$og, aKka Kat <ro<pog. cvtoo fxev w ytvovTat toov lc\ia aKCkov$cvvToov o-Yifxeioov 3 y\ el akkco fxv\ %koo Ttv\ 
<rvkkoyt<rfxoi, 7tkY\v 6 fxev &ta t« TtpooTCV <rxf\fxaTcg akv- dfx<poo, xdi iv cTg fxv] "ckctg eKaTepcv, "oTav to fxev exvi to 
Tcg, av dkY\$Y,g v\ (Ka$okcv yap i~rtv), <fe <}td t? eo-%otT«30 <fe fxv\' ei ydp dv<}pe?og fxev ikev$(ptog <fe fxv\, e%ei <fe toov 
kvrtfxog, xav dkvfieg v\ to o-vfX7tepa<rfxa, ota to (xy) eTvat o\jo tc£{, Sv\kov oti koi iitt V6 keovTcg t»to <TY\fxe?ov ty\$ 
Ka$okov fxv^e Ttpog to Ttpayfxa tov <rvkkoyt<rfxcV ov ydp dvb^peiag. ecrt $y\ to (pv<rtoyvoofxove?v toov iv too TtpooToo cx^r 
el JIiTTaKog <r7tovoa?og, ota t«to xat Tcvg akkcvg dvdyxv\ fxaTt tq fxirov tw fx\v TtpooTco axpco dvTtcrpecpetv, tk §e Tpt- 
<ro(povg. <5e frta tS fxe<rov <rx^fxaTog det xdi itdvToog kv- tov VTtepTeivetv xa\ fxv) dvTt<rpe(peiv , otov dvo^peia to A, t* 
<rtfxcg' «oWoTg yap ytveTat <rvkkcyto-fxcg ovToog ixovToov 35 aKpooTvipia fxeydka i<p' ov B, to Se T keoov. 0% Sv\ to V, 
tuv opoov' ov yap el v) Kvovra ooxp<x, ooxpd <fe koi Y\Se, to B TxavTi, dkka Ka\ akkotg. £> 6% to B, to A 7tavTi 
xvetv dvayxY\ TctuT>iv. dkY\$\g y,\v %v iv a,7ta<rtv vTtdp^et To?g koi cv 7xkeio<rtv, dkk' dvTicrp£<p£t' el 8e fxv\, cvk ecrat ev 
-TYifxetotg, Stacpopag <¥ exovcrt Tct? elpvjfxevag. evog <rv\fxe?ov. 

7. o.t-6Gzmtmy\ v a.ia.^Ka.U C. II 10. /j-h »v] Xk C. II cruXXoYJtr^c? a,T8Xi]? e^ pr C. II 11. % xeci trri^siaiv C. II 15. * to xveiv, tc /3 
to <y*X* C. II 16. ywrj b?k k<p' Jw^C II 17. tftig,C. II 18. B] ts /3 AC. II T] to 7 C. II 23. xvei r\ f^ C. II B] T07 C. 1124. Y] to 7 C. II 
y\ pia.] rftiV pr C. II Xe%fief>j C. II 26. fol TnTTMcs C. II 29. 7rXr\v] -xi Xiv A. II 33. «.vcfyoj ante ^i* C. II 38. cnj^frioi?] tr%^ auxi. pr C. 

1. vfa A, ei ty C. II 3. toiStov C. II A. c-^eTov AB. II to. AB. II 5. to om B. II 8. M fwxci. C. II 9- fcuf tj? fiv<nxr\v C. U 
12. hvu.ixe8ct, B. II 13. ^uv^o-o^efict xai tpvinoyvupoveiv C. II 15. avfyi* C. !l 19. to om AB. II 20. iv om C. II 21. touto C. II 24. ct 
x&\ povov C. II 28. ehe AB. II tiv\ pij oXu C. II 3o. el—he \*.v\ om B. Il 31. cr^eroy toGto a,y8)»a? eqiv. %?i C. II 32. tuv] to C. H 36. aXAot?] dXKus A. 



ANAATTIKGN TXTEPQN A. 



1 \.a,<ra, hfrcMrKctkta, ko,) 7rcX<ra, fxa.$v\<rtg $ta,voY\TiKY) sk irpov- fcrcurt fxev ovirep ty)v d7rbdei^iv exov<rt kcu » skafBov, sket> 

irapxov<rv\g ytvsToot yvoorrsoog. tpoovspov cfs t«to $Eoopx<riv E7ri /3ov cY &x i Travrog » dv slcfoocriv otj Tpiyoovov v\ on dpt$fxbg, 

va,<roov' cu ts ydp fxa,$Y\fxa,TtKOA toov E7rtcrv\fxoov t\td tovtov dkk' dirkoog kooto, 7ra,vTog dpi$fxov kcu Tpiyoovov' icfsfxia, 

tv Tpo7m Tr&pcoylvovTcu kcu toov cokkoov sKacrv} tsxvwv. ydp 7rpoTa,<rig ka,fxfia,vsTa,t Toia,vTv\, oti ov <rv oTt\a,g dpi$- 

o/xoioog cfs kcu 7rspi Tovg kbyovg ot Te hd <rvkkoyt<rfxoov kcu 5 fxov v\ o <rv cTfrtxg svbvypa.fXfA.ov, dkka, Karrd TrcovTcg. dkk' 

ot oY s7ra,yooyY\g' dfxcporspot ydp cfta) 7rpoytvoo<rKOfxsvoov nrot- «oVv (oTfxcu) Kookvst, o fxa,v$a,vsi, scrtv oog s7rtcra,<r$a,i , scrt 

vncu ty,v h$'a,<rKa,x(a,v , ot fxsv kctfxfidvovTEg oog Trctpd £yvtsv- cY oog dyvostv' oltottov ydp &k sl ofoY Troog o fxctv$ctvst, dkk' 

toov, ot 3e cfstKvvvTsg to KO,$okov frta) t« b^kov sTvcu to ko,$' sl oofrt, oTov 'v\ fxctv$ctvei kcu oog. 

acctcrov. oog cY ctvToog Kctt ot pv\TopiKo) <rvfX7ret$ov<riV r\ yotp 'E7ricrct<r$cu <5e oio[xe$' eKctcrov dirkoog, dkka, fxv\ tov2 

ota. TrctpotcfetyfxctToov, o ecrtv e7ra,yooyv\, v\ oY ev$vfxv\fxctToov, 10 trotptcriKov TpoTrov tov Karrd <rvfxfiefiv\Kog, otoov ty,v t ctiTtctv 

QTrsp scrt <rvkkoyt<rfxog. c^t^oog cY dvctyKcttcv 7rpoyivoo<rKstv* oioofxs$ot yivoozrKsiv oY v\v to Trpayfxa, scriv, oti eksivs cuTtct* 

Tot fxsv yctp, ort scrt, 7rpov7roka,fx^dvstv dvotyKotTov, tcc fre, scrt, kcu /xy) £v$£XE<r$cu t»t' ctkkoog sxstv. cYqkcv Tfitvvv oTt 

tj to ksyofxsvov scrt, ^vvievcu &s?, ta cY d/x<poo, ofov oti toiovtov ti to E7rfcra,<r$a,t icrt' kcu yctp ot /uoy\ s7rtcra,fX£voi kcu 

fxsv cXttoov y\ <pv\<rcu y\ d7ro<pYi<ra,t dkv\$(g, oti tcrt, to cYe Tpi- o\ s7rtcra,fxevoi ot [xsv oIovtcu <xvto\ ovroog sxstv, ot a sTrtcra,- 

yoovov, oTt tocYi <rv\fxa.ivst , ty]v cYe fxovoL^a, d/uocpoo, koa rl crvi- 15 fxsvot ko,i EXJd<riv, oocte « dTrkoog ecr)v hrtcry\f/,Y\, t»t' dc\jvctTOV 

fxcttvet KoCt oti ecrtv' v ya)p bfxotoog tovtoov eKcocrov cYv]kov aikkoog e%etv. e\ fhev ovv KO,t erepog scrt t» S7rtcra,<r$a,t TpoTrog, 

%fxtv. scri cfs yvoopfCstv T& fxsv TrpoTspov yvoopiZpvra,, roov &s vcrspov spifxsv, tpcofxsv cYs kcu o^i' dTroSstyscog slcMvcu. dTro- 

kcu cXfxoo kcifxficovovTa, ty)v yvuxrtv, oTov %<ra, Tvyx^st ovra, bsifyv fre ksyoo <rvkkoyt<rfxov s7rtcrv\fxoviKov. E7ricrY\fxovtKov c% 

V7T0 TO KO,$QkiS, OOV l^ei TY\V yvUXTtV. CTl fXEV ydp 7T0,V Tpt- ksyOO K0.$' OV TOO I^EiV OOVTOV E7Ttcra,fXS$a,. Et TCtVVV Scr) TO STTt- 

yoovov ex h o\xr\v op$cug f<ra.g, 7rpov\cf£t' oti tfs ToS~e to ev tw 20 cra,<r$a,t oiov eSefxev, dva,yKV\ ko,i ty]v d7rofretKTiKYjv e7ricrv\fxv\v e^ 
tlfxiKVKktio Tptyoovov Ecrtv, dfxa, sTrcxyofxsvog syvooot<rsv. svtoov dkv\$oov t sTva,t ko,i TrpooToov kcu dfxscoov ko,i yvooptfXooTEpoov 
ydp t«tov tov TooTrov v\ fxct,$Y\<rig scrt, kcu k tftd t» fxscrov kcu TrpoTspoov kcu ahloov t» <rvfX7rspa,<rfxa,Tog' xtoo ydp scrov- 
to E<rx&Tov yvooptQsTcu, o<rct, y\Sy\ toov ko,$' EKa,cra, Tuy%ct- to,i koa cu dpx&i oIksTcu t« 3~eikvv[xevov. <rvkkoyt<rfxog fxsv 
yst ovto, kcu fxv) ko,$' vTTOKSifxsvov Ttvog. Trptv cY £7ra,x$^ou ydp tcrcu kcu oovsv txtoov, d7rocfst]rig cY ovk scrcu' v ya,p 
tj ka,(3stv <rvkkoyt<rfxov TpoTrcv fxsv Ttva, 'tcroog tparrsov £7rtcrdo-2$ 7rotY,<r£i E7ricrYifXY\v. dkv\$Y\ fxsv «v frsT sivcu, oti tfc scri to fxv\ 
tr$a,t, TpoTrov cY dkkov «. o ydp fxv\ vjc^ei sl scrtv dTrkoog,. ov S7rtcra,<r$a,i, oTov ort v\ ha,fXETpog <rvfXfxsTpog. sk nrpooTOdv 
T6T0 Troog Ytcfst oTt Svo op$dg e^si dirkoog; dkkd cYqkcv oog tY dva,7roc\ELKTOov, ort &k s7rtcrq<rETcu fxv) sxoov dTrbbsttyv cw- 
cocYt fxsv E7rtcra,Ta,i, on Ka,$okx s7rtcra,Tcu, d7rkoog cY ovx, tuv' to ydp E7ricra,<r$cu oov dTrobsfylg scrt fxv) Karrd <rvfxi3s- 
errtcrctTcu. si bs fxv\, to ev tw Mevoovi d7ropv\fxou.<rvfx[3Yi<r£Ta,t' (2v\Kbg, to £X elv dTro&Eifciv scrtv. curia, ts ko,i yvoopifxoorspct, 
m ya,p \idsv fxa,UY[<rsra,i v\ a, ciosv. ov ya-p ov\, oog ys Ttvsg30 dsi sivcu kooi 7rpcTspa,, cuTta, fxsv oti tcts ETrtcrcofXE^a, otc\v 
eyX^pwvi kvEtv, kEKT£ov. dp cT$a,g d7ra,<ra,v frva-fra, oti ty\v cutIcov Eifroofxsv, kcu irpoTspa,, stTrsp ahta,, kcu Trpcyi- 
dpTia, v\ a; <pv\<ra,vTog bs 7rpoY\vsyKa.v Ttva, ovoofra, v\v vk oost vooCKOfxsva, » fxbvov tov sTspov TpoTrov tw ^vvtsvcu, dkka, kcu 
eTvou, ucr' itY dpTicov. kvov<rt ydp « <pa,<rKOVTsg siMva.t xct- tw siHva.t oti scriv. TrpoTspa, cY ecjtKctt yvooptfxoorepa, otX w ^ 
tra,v cYjoocfa, dpTtctv ovrav, dkk' v\v fcra,<riv oti b\ja,g. ko,itci « ydp toovtov TrpoTepcv tyi <pv<ret kcu Trpog v\fxa.g TrpoTepov, 

Tit. ug-ipujY ») hvripujv a, C. 

9. ukxhvtu? JB, wcmtus <% C. H 11. orep] o C II 13. ffwtivitt C. fl 14 tt-KM pcb 2?. fl 17. TtpoTzpa. C. t 28. oTt rh KctGoXmt G 
13. ti om C. II 14. «uro C. II 20. lUpsU C. II 21. x*\ alterum om C. II 24. 7<*f &t C. II 25. fo7 tTm covrA. II 30. fc~ slim 
n*t ffporep* corr B, ubi locus paucioribus. 



72 ANAATTIK&N T2TEP&N A, 

«$£ yvoopifXooTspov kcu v)fx?v yvooptfxooTepov. Xsyoo o£ rtpog dXXa, fXY\<¥ aXXo <xvtoo rrtcrdTspov eTvcu /tXY,<fe yvoopifxooTspov 
v\[xdg fxev Ttpdrepa. xcu yvoopLfxoorspa, ta syyvTspov Tvjg oa- tuv dvTiKSi/xsvoov TOAg dpx<us, e\ uv ecjat <rvXXoyi<rfxog b 
<r$v\<reoog, d7tXoog <fe TtpoTspa, xcu yvooptfxwrepa, to, Ttoppoore- 7Y\g evavrtag ditaTY\g, editsp $sl tov srtLcjdfXSvov drtXHog dfxe- 
pov. scjt Se -TroppooTccTco fxev to, ko$qXqv fxaiXtcja- , eyyvTdroo Tcliteicjov sTvcu. 

<fe t&ko$' eKctcrcb' kcu dvTiKeiTcu tcvvt dXXv\Xotg. SKitpco- 5 'Eviotg fxsv h £td to S~s?v t<* Ttpooroo eit{<jaT$cu « oW?3 

70ov $' ecj) to e\ dp%wv o\ksiooV to-vto ya,p Xeyoo rtpooTQV e7ti<rv\fXY\ eTvcu, 7o?g <Y sTvcu fxev, itdvroov fxevTOL dito<fs{£sig 
kcu dpx^- dpxA <? ep* dito^si^soog 7tpoTa<rig dfxs<ros, eTvcu' dov ibsTspov kt' dXv\$sg \st dvayKcuov. 01 fxsv ydp 
<x/xs<rog <fs v\g fxv\ scjlv ooXXyj Ttporspa,. TtpoTang c? scjlv dito- v7to$sfxevoc fxv) eTvcu oXoog e7t{<ja,<r$ai , %tol slg 'drtsipov d^ia- 
<pdv<rsoog to srspov fxopiov, sv Ka$' svog, foaXsKTLKv) fxev v) <riv dvayer$ai oog £k dv erttcjafxevovg T<* vcjspa, <ftd ta 
b/xoioog Xafxfiavovtra, bitoTspoviy, ditocfstKTtKVi <fe v) copt<r- 10 TtpoTepa,, Cov fxv\ scji rtpooTa,, bp$dog Xsyovrsg' dbvva-Tov ydp 
fxsvoog ScoTepov, otl d^$sg. drtocpavo-Lg <fs dvrnpa,<rsoog brto- 70, antetpa, <$~isX$s?v. et T£ lcjartcu koa etrtv dpx&U 7avra,g 
7epov\iv fxoptov. dvTt<pa<rtg $e dvr{$s<rtg v\g kk ecjt /xerafcv dyvoocjovg eTvcu dTtoSst^soog ye fxvj isryg a,vrdov, oitsp <pa<Av 
y.a$' (Xvtv\v. fxoptov <Y dvTicparsoog to fxev 7) kojtcL Ttvog ko,- eTvcu to s7tLcra,<r8a,i fxdvov' el $e fxv) scri to) TtpooTa, slMvcu, 
7d<pct<rig, 70 os 71 drto 7tvog d7to<pa,<rtg. dfxs<rqv $' dp- we 70, Jk tovtoov eTvcu eit{qa,<r$a,i drtXoog i<fe Kvpioog, dkX 
X^g <rvKKoytcrtKVig $s<rtv fxsv Ksyoo v fxv) s<rt Ssl^cu, fxvi<f 15 e£ vitoQsosoog, sl eKetvd ecriv. 01 <fs 7tsp) fxsv tS S7t.L<ra,6cu 
dva,yKV\ eXW rQV fxaSv^ofxsvov Tf v\v fr' dva,yKV\ sx^tv tov bfXoXoyx<ri' <ft' d-xoSst^soog ydp sTvcu /xdvov dXXd TtcLvrooy 
otlvv fxa$v\<rdfXsvov, d^toofxa,' s<rt yap svlo, tolcwto,' t«to eTvcu ditd^sL^AV &<Vsv KooXvstv' ev^xsvScu ydp kvkXoo ytvs- 
ydp fxaXtcr' eitt Tolg TotVTotg etoo$a,fxev cvo/xa, Xeyetv. Ssrecog <r$ai ty)v dTto^et^LV kcu e% dXXv\Xoov. v)fxe7g <}i <pa,jxev vre 
<y v\ fxev brtoTepovovv 700V fxoptoov T?j? dito^pdvreoog Xa/xfia,- 7ta,ra,v e7tL<rv\fxviv dito^stKTtKvy sTvai, dXXd tv)v toov d/xsroov 
VOV70,, olov Xsyoo to sTvai tl v\ to, fxv\ sTvcll ti, V7td$s<rig, y\ 20 dva,itdSetKTov. koa tW oti dva,yKOAOV, <pa,vspdv el ydp 
£' oovev tovtov bpto-fxog. b yap bptrfxcg $e<rtg fxev ecrf T f t$e- dva,yKV\ fxev e7t{<ra,<r$cu t& Ttpdrepa, kcu e^ oov v\ ditd^eL^Lg, 
tat ydp b dpt^fxvjiKog fxovafra, to dha{petov eTvat Karta, tq icrarat cfe 7toTe to) dfxsra,, toZt dva,7tdo s stKTa, dvciyKV\ sTvat. 
Ttordv v7td$e<TLg §' w e<ri' to yap tl ecrt fxovag kcu 70 eT- toJvto,, t »c ovtoo Xsyofxev, ko)l & fxdvov e7tL<rv\fxviv dXXa) 
\cu fxovacfa, « TavTov. y„at dpxw e7tL<rYifxv\g eTvai Tivd <pa,/xev, >J rovg dplvg yva- 

'E7te) <}e $eT 7tt<reveiv Te Kat elMvat to Ttpdyfxa, tco.25 ptCpfxsv. kvkXoo <? oti dbvva.rov d7tc<fs{KVvr$ai ditXcog, <%- 
ToixTOV sx £ w <rvXXoyL<ffxov W KaXxfxsv dTtd^st^tv, scji <V Xov, eiitep Ik TtpoTepoov $ei tv,v dTtd^ei^LV eTvai koa yvoopL/xoo- 
vrog tco to,<¥ eivat i£ oov b <rvXXoytr/xdg, dvdyKV\ fxv) fxdvov TspooV dfrvvaTov yap scri ta a,vTd toov ccvtoov dfxa, Ttpdrepcu 
TtpoytvoorKetv Ta, TtpooTO,, v\ Ttavra, v\ evta,, dXXd ko) fxaX- nat vcrepa, eTva,t, el fxv\ 7ov erepov Tportov, cTov T<* fxsv. 7tpo<g 
Xov' dsL yap $1' vTtapx^ eKcurov, eKeTvo fx&XXov vrtdp- v)fxag t& ^ ditXoog, cvirep Tportov v) eitayooyv) rtote? yvoopt- 
X^, oJov <$t cpLXovfxev, sks?vo <piXoy fxaXXpv. docr' sirtsp m /u-ov. el o^' ovroog, vk dv s'tv\ to ditXoog sl&svai KciXoog dopt<r- 
1{<rfxsv <ytd to, TtpdoTa, ko,i Tttcrsvofxsv, kxksTvo, "tTfXsv T£ KOA fxsvoy, dxxd cftTTov' v\ *x drtXoog v) sTspa, dTtd&si^Lg yivo- 
TrtcrsvQfxsv fxaXXcv, cti oY sks?va kcu to, vcjepov. &x oTdv fxevv\ Ik toov v)fx7v yvooptfxooTspoov. <rvfx(BaivsL Ss TQ?g Xsyd<ri 
T£ Se 7tt<revetv /xdXXov oov otoev, a, fxv\ 7vyxdvet fxvctz et&oog kvkXoo tv\v dTtcbsfytv sTvat ov fxovov to vvv slpv\fXsvov, aXX' 
/xvyte QeXTtov StaKstfxevog v\ st srvyxavsv slfrcog. cvfxfivpsTcu iSiv aXXo Xsysiv v\ cti t«t' sqtv el tkt' ecjtv xtoo c%7tdvrcL 
<Js tkto, et fxv\ Ttg TtpoyvoorsTcu toov Si' dTtoSst^tv rttcrsvdv- 35 paStov <^s?^xt. SyjXov (V oti tkto o-vfxftatvst Tptdiv opoov ts- 
700V fxdXXov yap dvayKY\ TtLcrsvsLV 7cug dpx&Tg v\ 7td<ra,tg $evToov' TOfxev ydp frtd TtoXXoov v\ St' bxiyoov dvaKdfxitTeiv 
v\ Ttri t« <rvfX7teparfxarog. tov Se fxeXXovTa, s^stv Tv t V sTti- <pavat icfsv hacpspsi, oY bx{yoov <Y v\ frvo^v. otav ydp tqv 
(ryfXYjV 7v,v oV dTtoSeifceoog « fxdvov Se? 7ag dpxdg fxaXXov A ovrcg e% dvdyKv\g v\ to B, tovtov §e to F, t« A ovto^ 
yvoopiCetv kou fx&XXov avTcug 7ti<reveLV v\ tu SeLKWfxevoo, scrcu to V. sl oV t» A cvTog dvdy/cv\ to B eTva,t, tqvtov o^ 

6. TO'JToy $( Ig-t TTpuroi C, II 12. tg-i ti jjlzt&Q x&F icf,VTr\v. jxdcia C. II \6. tov ctm •xa.^c^iov C. II 17. tccvtcc C. II 18. "cioyLct, 

om C. II 20. to post i) om C. II 21. ph om C. II 30. sfaep] ehrs7y A. II 31. btskeb C. II 32. vgipa, C. II 33. mgevo/xsy pr A. II 
35. >»' om B. 

5. t7T(Va<7&u . Td TrpuTct, C. II 8. 'ciWw; ABC. II 10. ?f*i C. II 11. a ht C. II Iqcurrcu C, 'i<ra,TO.TXt A. II 14. hricrowbu etycu B. If 

17. b8&er*i C. II 18. v8k B. II 22. Td dy.ic-i ttcte C. II 23. t om A. II 25. ¥ cn] to n AB, t\ ht C. II 32. w~\ v bt BC. II 
33. tcv B. II 34. pcu&or itJina, C. fl 37. h' om C. 



ANAATTIK..N T^TEP&N A, 73 

ovro? to A (rovro ydp v\v ro kvkKu)), Ketr$oo ro A, e<p' _ pov Kcti erepofXYiKeg' koa Trdrt rovrotg ewTtdpxww £v roo 
ro r. ro %v tou B ovro? ro A etv&t Keyetv et~l ro V etvcu Ke- Koycp tw t( ecrt Keyovrt ev$a, fxev ypcofXfxv) ev$a, <¥ dpt- 
«yejv, touto o otz tk A ovto<? to 1 e<rr ro oe L raA to Vfxog. o/xottog de ko,i eitt roov aKKoov ra, rotavQ eKcurotg kolQ 
ctvro. uxrre <rvfx$aivei Keyetv rovg kvkKuo <pa,<rKOvra,g etvat covra. Keyoo, %<ra, __ fXY\<yerepu)g inrdpx^, <rvfx$e$v\KQTa,, 
ty]v dTtocreifyv __.v erepov 7tKY,v ort t_ A ovto? to A ecrtv. _ oiov ro /xovrtKOV v\ KevKOV roo [ww. ert o fxv) ko,$' vTtOKet- 
vroo tfe Ttdvra, creTj^cu patvtov. _ fxv\v dKK' _e_ t_to b\)va,rov, fxevv Keyerat &KKx rtvog, otov ro ftatvTQiv erepov rt ov (2ct- 
ttKv)v £7rl t_tc_v ora, cLKKyiKois eiterat, uoritep ra, 'ttYta,. evog trtQov ecrt kcu Ksvkov, v\ cY i<rta,, kcu %<ra to__ rt <rY\fxa,tvet, 
fxev _v Ket/xevov <yitreiKTa,t ort icyeTtor dvdyKY\ rt eTvcu ere- _;_ erepov rt ovra, ecrtv %-irep ecrtv. ra) fxev try) fxv) ko,$' vtco- 
pov (Keyoo cY evog, %rt _t_ opov evog _Te $ereuog fxtag re$et- Ketfxevov kol$' olvto, Keyoo, rd __ kol$' viroKetfxevov crvfx- 
<rv\g), Ik __o __ $ereoov 7rpooru)V kcu eKaxicrtov _v_-%eT_u, 10 (3e@v\KQTa,. en <y' cuKKov rpoirov ro fxev trt clvto vitdpx^v 
eiitep kcu <rvKKoyiTa,<r$cu. ea)v fxev «v to te A tw B kcu tw eKAcrto ko,$' covto, to fre fxvi frt' covro <rvfx@efiYiKc<; , ofov el 
r eirY{ra,t, kcu raZr cLKKyiKois ko,i tw A, «tw fxev evt\e* ^oi^tCovTog yicrpa,ype y trvfxfie(3Y[Ko?' i ydp cfta) ro fia,t\tCeiv 
X,ercu ejr dKKyKoov freiKWva.t 7ra,vra, ra) curYfievra, ev tw Y^parfyev, ciKKa. <rvve$Y\, <pa,fxev, riro. ei tfe <rt uvro, 
irpdorcp <r"Xflfxa,rt, tog M<reiKTa.t ev roTg nrept <rvKKoyt<rfXov. ko,$' ckvto, oTov et rt <r<pa,Trofxevov d7re$a,ve ko,) Kctrd ty)v 
o^etfetKTcot t% kcu ori ev roTg dKKotg <rxY\fxa,<rtv yj ov ytvera,ti5 <r<pa,yY[V, ort <ftd ro <r<pa,Tre<r$cu , dKK' & <rvve(3Yi <r<pa,TTo- 
trvKKoyttrfxog y\ ov irept roov K.Yi<p$evruiv. rd tfe fxv) dvrtKO,TYr fxevov d7ro$a,ve?v. ra, a,pa, Keyofxeva, eiri roov d7rKoog e7rt<TY\- 
yopvfxeva, &<ya,/xoog ecrt freTfc&t kvkKui. oocr' eVez^ oKtya, rot- roov ko,$' avra, vroog oog evv7ra,pxetv roTg Ka,rv\yopovfxevotg 
cwra, ev Tcug dizociei^ert, <pa,vepov 'ort Kevov re koa dtrvva,- »j evv7rdpx^$^ ^t' cwra, re ecrt KO,t e^ dva,yKYig. « ydp 
rov ro Keyetv e£ dKKY\Ku)V etva,t ty)v dTrocxei^tv ko\ <ftd t«to h<yex£Ta.t fXY\ V7ra,pxetv y\ dTvKoog v\ ra, dvrtKetfxeva, , otov 
rravTtov ev<fe / xe<r$a,i etva,t a,7to<yet^tv. 20 ypa,fXfx^ ro ev$v v\ ro Ka,fX7rvKov ko,i dpt$fxu> to Treptrrov 

l_ 'E7rel £' d<ivva,rov dKKoog exetv ov ecrtv eTrtcjY t fXY\ dTrKuog, »j to ooprtov. etrt ya,p ro eva,vrtov v\ <?epy\<rtg y\ dvri<pa,<rtg ev rto 

dva,yKO,Tov a,v etv\ ro e7rtcrY\ro\ ro Ka,ra, ty\v d7ro<yeiKTiKY\v eTrt- ctvrco yevet, otov aprtov ro fxv\ Treptrrov ev dpt$fxoTgv] eVeTcu. 
tjY,fxv\v. d7ro<yeiKTiKY\ <y' ecr)v v\v exofxev roo e%eiv dTrobeTfy.V uitr' et dva,yKY\ <pa,va,t v\ d7ro<pa,va,t, dvooyKY, kcu rd ko,$' 
e£ dva.yKaftuov dpa, <rvKKoyt<rfxog ecrtv v\ d7ro<y~efytg. KY\7rreov avto, v7ra,px^v. 

dpa, eK rtvoov koa Trotoov cu dTtocyetfcetg elcrtv. 7rpu)rov <fe <ytopt- 25 To fxev Zv Ka/rd 7ra,vrog Ka,t ko,$' a,vro <ftoopt<r$ui rov 

<ru)fxev rt Keyofxev ro Karrd 7ra,vrog kooi rt ro ko,$' a,vro kcu rpo7tov tktov* ko,$oKov cre Keyto o dv ko/to, nra,VTog re 
rt to ko,$oKov. V7ra,pxxi xet ' Kct @' ^ 70 7Ca ' 1 *) ctvro. tpavepov a,pa, %rt ora, 

K.a,rd Travrog fxev w tkto Keyoo o dv v\ fxv) eirt rtvog Ka,$oK<s, e^ dva,yKY\g vTrapx^ T°Tg 7rpdyfxa,<rtv. ro ko,$' 
fxev rtvog cre fxv\, fxv\cfe Ttore fxev Ttore b\ fxv\, oiov el Karrd ctvro 8e kcu y\ oovto tcovtov, oTov ko,$' o,vty\v rij ypafXfx^ 
iravrog dv$pu)7tov TJyov, el dKv\$eg rovtr' et7teTv a,v$pu)7tov, 30 vTtapx^ ^y/"-*? k<u to ev$V KO,t ya.p yj ypa,fXfxv\. kcu tw 
dKv\$\g Kat X^ooov, koli el vvv $a,rspov, KO,t $a,repov, kou et ev rptytovoo v\ rpiyuovov <)vo op$a,t' KO,t ya,p ko,$' dvro ro rpt- 
rrd<rv\ ypafXfXY, crtyfxv\, toravrtog. <rv\fxeTov <ye' kou ydp rdg yoovov <%o op$a,Tg fcrov. ro Ka,$oKti <ye vTrapx^ rore, orav 
evcrdretg xroo cpe^pofxev oog ko,to, Ttavrog epooroofxevot, v\ et eTtt htt t» rvx°vrog ko,i 7tpooT\f <yetKWY\Tcu. oiov ro <yvo op$a,g 
rtvt fxv\, v\ et Ttore fXY\. ko,$' ttvrd cf ocra, VTtdpx^ re l%eiv «Te tw c^^at/ ecrt ko,$oKov ' KO,trot ecrt creT^cu 
ev roo rt ecrtv, otov rptyoovu) ypa,fxfxv\ ko,i ypa,fXfXY\ <rtyfxv\ (Y)35KO,Td trXYifAarog ort <yvo op$a,g e%e<, dKK' i t« Tu^ovTOt; 
ya)p irta, olvtoov Ik tovtoov ecrt, kcu ev roo Koyoo tuj Keyovrt <rxYi^rog' &<ye xp^l 7a ' 1 T V rvxovrt <rxY\f^art o cyetKwg' ra 
rt etrtv evv7rdpx s Kcuorotgroov ewTtapx^vruov auvroTg covrd ydp rerpayuovov trxW**' ^ v -> ** *X eL ^ £ ^ op$dTg Trag. 
ev roo Koyop evvTtdpxwt ?$ T* *W b\\KxvTi, oiov ro ev$v ro tY IrozoceKeg l%e« fxev ro tu^ov b\io op$a,Tg f<ra,g, dKK 
vTtapx^ ypcofxfxvi kcu ro 7tept<pepeg, ko,i to Tteptrrov KO,t « Ttpoorov, dKKa, ro rptyoovov Ttporepov. o Tomjv to tu%ov 
tt/3T<ov dpt$fxuj, kou to TtpooTov kcu <rvv$eTov ko,i itro TtKev- 40 Ttpoorov <yeiKwra,i tho op$a,g ex°v v\ omv a.KKo, tktoo 7tpu)ru 

2. toj om A. II rl rl -y A et corr C. I! wou om AB. J\ 4. A^ystv post irepov C. !l 12. x*\ t£ A om pr C. II 15. ou 
xcd JS. II 17. toixutx JX/7* C. II 20. hhixtrau HC. II 33. Ip-T^jugvou AB. II 38. v7r~p%oti<rt C. 

6. to /S„^£iy B. II 29- avT? B et pr C. H tijv 7pa/*^ijv pr C. II 34. vrs] ore A. II 36. om BC. II 37. op0„? B. 

K 



74 ANAATTIKftN tfSTEPftN A. 

vitclpx ei x&$o\v, x&i »J dTxocfstfyg xa$' clvtq t«tk x&SoXx UvTog xat t» \rorxs\sg. d\\' « t« cr^a&TO? tj Txsparxog. 

Sttf, TCOV $' ctWCOV TpOTXOV Ttvd « XO,$' O.VTO' &$S TK trcrXS- d\\' » TXpoOTCOV. WO? W TXpcOW, « <5)J TptycOVtf , XOTxd THTO 

Xous «>c e<7< xa$o\ov d\\' e7x) tx\sov. vTxapx^ kou To?g d\\oig, xa) tvtov xa,$o\ov scrtv v\ cIttq- 

5 Ae? Ss fxv) \av$dvstv qti TxoWdxig rvfx^aivst b s i<xfxa,p- foifyg. 

rdvsiv xdi fxv) vizapxsw to fretxvvfxevov TxpooTov xa$o\ov, v\ 5 Et iv ecr)v v) dTXcb^sixTtxvi e7Xi<-Y\fXY\ e£ dvayxaioov dp-$ 

froxs? &eixwr$at xojQoXk nxpooTov. d7xa,Todfxs$a, b% Tavxv\v ty)v %wv (o ydp s.7xicra,Ta,i, i bvvaTov aWcog sx siV ) > ta <£e xa$* 
c\ptd,Tv\v , oTav v) fXY\biev v\ \a,@e?v dvooTepov Txapa. to xa,Q' ojvto. vTxa-pxo^Ta, dva,yxa?a, TO?g Txpayfxartv (a, /xev yap ev 
sxacrov v) Tct xa,S' sxacra, v) v) fxsv. d\\' dvcovvfxov v) stxi tw ti scrtv V7xapx £ t' TO?g o a,vTa, sv tw ti scrtv V7xapx £ i 
$ta(popotg si&st Txpayfxartv , v\ Tvyx<^ v ^l ov cog sv fxepei %\ov xaTY\y optfxevotg avxcov, oov $arepov toov dvTtxetfxevoov dvayxv\ 
ed>' u b~eixwTat' TO?g yap ev fxepet vTxap^et fxev v) dTxo&si- 10 u7ruo%ejv), <pavspov oxt sx toivtuv tivoov dv etv\ 6 dTxoostx- 
Pig, xdt scrat xa.Ta, TxavTog, dW. ofxcog ix scrai t«t« itpoo- Ttxog rvWoytrfxog' eW&v yap v) XToog v7xapx sl *3 xcna, 
tov xa$oXti v) dTro^e^tg. Xeyoo o\ t«t« TxpdoT^, yitxto, dnxo- vvfx$s$v\xog , to, $s <rvfx@s@v\xoTa, ix dva,yxa,?a,. 
fetfyv, oto,v v\ TXpcoTX xa,$oXov. st w Ttg cisifcsisv otl a,t op- *H o\ vtoo Xsxtsov, v\ dpx^v Ssfxsvotg %ti v\ d.Txob^stzj.i 

6a) » <rvfX7xi7XTt$<rt, So^stsv dv t«t« sTvat v) dTxohtfyg Sta. to dva,yxa,?ov scrt, xa,i st d7xoMb s eixTa.t, &x otov T a,XXco$ 
hx) 7xa,coov eTvctt rcov cpQoov. ix scrt bs, stTXsp fxv\ qti oocfi 15 sxstv e^ dva.yxa.ioov a,pa, b s e?stvat tov <rvXXoyt<rfxov. s^dXvf- 
1.<ra,t yivsTat t«to, dXX' v\ otxooo-hv f<ra,t. xa.) st Tpiycovcv fxv\ Qoov fxsv ydp scrt xa.) /xvj dTXob^sixvvvTa, <rvXXoyt<rarda,i, s£ 
v\v clxXo v) l<ro<rxsXsg, v\ l<ro<rxsXsg dv eboxet vTxdpx^- *ou dva,yxa,ioov b~' ix ecrtv dXX' v\ dTXOcfeixvvvTa,' t«to ydp v\b\i 
to dvdXoyov QTt svaXXd^, v\ dptSfxo) xa.) v\ ypafxfxat xat dTxobsi^eoog scriv. o~v\fxs?ov b~' oti v\ dTXobsfctg s£ dvayxatcov, 
v\ crspsa xat v\ xp ov °t, oo<T7xsp sb~sixvvTo txots ^WjOj?, svb~s- oti xa,i Ta? svcraosig xtco <pepcfxsv Txpog Tovg ctcfxswg dTxo- 
Xofxsvov ys xa,Td TxdvToov fxia, dTXofrsi^si $stx$W<Xi' dXXa,2Q frsixwvat, OTt ix dva,yxv\, dv oloofxsQa, v\ oXoog svb s exso"$a,i 
frid to fxv\ sTvat covofxao-fxsvov Tt TxavTa, tcwto, sv, dptSfxoi ccXXoog v\ svsxa. ye tk Xoyx. br)Xov &' sx tvtoov xoa oti svyx~ 
\xv\xy\ XP°' )I0 '> ^ s ? S( L-> ^ 1 £ ^ £i ^ta.(pspstv dXXv\Xoov, X u P l $ @ sll > o'i Xafx(3a,vstv olofxsvot xa,Xoog Tdg dpxdg, sdv svfrofcpg 
sXa,fx@dvsTO. vvv bs xa,$oXx frstxvvTai' « yap v\ ypa,fxfxa,t r, v) TxpoTarig xa,t dXv\$v\g, otov ot ro<pi<-oLt oti to sTxicrar- 
v) v\ dpt$fxo) v7XYipx sv y dXX' v\ Tofri, o xci$oXtS v7xcTi$svTai r$a.t to S7xi<-Y,fxv\v sxstv. « ydp to svcfc^ov v\ fxv) dpxv scrtv, 
V7xdpx stv - ^d t«to icf av Tig b^ei^vf xa$' sxa<rov to Tpiyoo- 25 aXXd to TxpooTov t« yevovg Txept o b~eixvvTat ' xdt Td\rfi\$ 
vov dTxobsifcst v\ fxtd v\ STspa, oti frvo 6p$ag sx s <- sxarov to « %dv otxs?ov. oti &' s^ dvayxaicov sTvat §s? tcv rvWoyt- 
lro7x\svpov X (/) P l< > Kct< T0 n " t ^1 1 '^ **' T0 trorxs\eg, ww rfxov, cpavspov xat sx Toovfrs. st yap o fxv) sxoov \oyov t£ 
oTfrs to Tpiycovcv oTt b\io 6p$a?g, st fxv) tov ro<picrtxov Tpo- frid Tt xry\g dTXob^etfcecog ix s7Xi<rvifxcov, etv\ b~' dv core tq A 
txov, xbe xa,$o\K Tpiycovov, ib~' sl fxv\oev ecrt 7xa,pa, Ta,vTa, xaTa, tS Y e^ dvayxv\g vTxapx^ ■> r o & s B to /xerov, <Ji' 
Tpiyoovov sTspov. cv ydp v\ Tpiycovov oifrsv, ifrs Txav Tptyoovov,30 « dTxsb^six^V , fxv\ s^ dvayxv\g, ix cifrs b~ioTt. i yap scrt t«to 
d\\l v\ >cat' dptSfxcv' koJ/t' sTb~og b~' « Txdv, xa,t st fxvifrsv ftid to /xsrov' to fxev- ydp svcfs^xsrat fxv) sTvat, tq frs rvfx- 
scriv o «>c cTfrsv. txot «v «>c oT&s xa$oX>i, xat txot oTb^sv nxsparfxa, dva,yxa?ov. sti st Ttg fxv\ oTb~s vvv e%wv tov \oycv 
d7x\uig; bv\\ov bv\ oTt st to-vtov V\V Tptycovoo etvat xat tro- xat rooCpfxsvog, rcoZpfxev6 t» Txpayfxarxog, fxv\ S7xi\s\virfx&- 
7x\svpoo v\ exa,crop v\ Txartv. st bfs fxv\ ravTov d\\' eTepov, vog, ifre TxpoTspov Y\bet. (p$apsiv\ &' dv to fxercv, el fxv\ 
v7xa,px sl b~' v\ Tpiyoovov, ix oTfrev. Txoxspov b~' v\ Tptyoovcv v\ 35 dvayxatov. cocrs sfcst fxev tov \oyov rooCpfxevog rcoXpfxevcv 
v\ IrorxeXeg, v7xapx s <.\ kci) txqts xarxd t«#' V7xa,pxst 7xpco- t£ Txpdyfxarxog, ix oTbs b~e. ib~' a,pa, Txpoxspcv v\$st. el be 
tov; xixi xa$oXti Ttvog v) d7xob~sifyg; bv)\ov orz oTotv d<pat- fxv) s<p$apTat, svfrs^xsTat frs <p$apv\vat, to rvfx(3a?vov a-v stv\ 
pxfxsvcov V7xap$y\ TxpooTco. oToy too \rorxs\s? x^\^ Tptyoovco bvvaxov xa) svb^sxofxsvov. d\\' scrtv dfrvvaTov xTcog e%o.VT* 
VTxapfyrt b\>o 6p$a,i, d\\a xd) t« %ctX>c«v sTva,t dcpatps- slbsvai. 



7. fj.f]5h C. II 8. r\ t* xo.9' tKoc^at, om C. II 9- tut%*/£» £. II 16. «jUonau. pr C. I! 17. ^v] Zi A. U 19- coa-rrsp xaiX kMxrvTO C. II 
21. tccjto, iiina. C. II 2.6. ocTTofcifyi om B. fl 27. crxcLhwh 2}C. II 33. t*vto BC. II rpi^uvov B. II 36. >j om B. il 37. dab*i- 

pOVfA.(vCd C. 

3. t£t»] tw A. II 10. v-nipxzi A. II 13. Sstiov corr C. II 24. post ^aLp et 25. toh B et pr C. .H 34. ovb\ SLpa, mpoTipin C. H 
35. <suCc r £to') q-. B. II 37. £s om B. II str\ xaX hv&Toy C. 



ANAAtfTIKftN VSTEPflN A. 75 

v Orctv ftev Zv ro TvftTrepctTftct e£ dvctyxr\g »j, «^ev >tc<;- ju.evov, » t& 7rct#vj >tca to, X.&&' ctvrct rvft@e(Br\KCTct o\Xo? 
A.ve* to fterov ftr) dvctyKcttov eTvctt, &' » ic\eix$r\' *T< 7^ ^ d7rohi\\ig. i\\ oov ftev Zv r) d7ro<fei^tg , ivt$ex £ Tctt rd ctvrd 
70 dvctyxcuov xct) ftv) ejr dvctyKctit <rvXXoyiTctT$cti, coTTrep eTvctt' cov c% ro yevog erepcy, uoTTrep dpt$ftY\riKY\g kcu yeco- 
xct) dXr : $eg ftr) e£ dXv\$oov. orctv fre to fteTcv e£ dvctyKr\g, fterptctg, xk ecrt rriv dpt$ftr\TtKr\v diroc\e^.v icpctpftoTctt eVi 
xcti ro TVftrrepctTftct i% dvctyxr,g, coTTrep Kctt ejr dXr\$oov dXv\- 5 ?& rcTg ftey($eTt TVft^e^Y\Korct, el ftr) rct fteye$r\ dpi$ftot 
tfeg dei. ecroo ydp ro A Kctrct t« B i\\ dvctyKrjg, Kcti tSto etTt' tkto cY cog iv$ex £ Tctt irri rtvoov, vcrepov Xex^W £ "rat. 
Kctrct T» r * dvctyKcuov roivvv Kcti w A tw T V7rctpx^ v ' v) <Y dpi$ftr\riKr\ dTrccfeifyg de\ l%ej T0 y £ vo$ Trep) o r\ drrc- 
crctv cYe Ktr) dvcty-Kcuov r\ ro TVftxepctTftct, icYe ro fteTOV bet^tg, xctt ctl ctXXctt bftcioog. uxr' y\ dTrXuog dvdyxvi ro 
dvctyxcuov ctov t eTvcti. ecroo ydp ro A roo T fxr\ e£ dvcty- ctvro elvcu yevv; v\ nrr\, ej fteXXet i) dTrcSefetg fterct^ctivetv. 
Kr,g v7rdpx £ w ■> tw cYe B, kcu riro roo Y i% dvctyxr\g' Kcti^ dXXoog <Y ort db\ivctrov, cYyjXov' sk ydp th ctvri yevovg, 
ro A ctpct tw r e^ dvctyKr\g vTrctpjret. dXX' »% u7re>te<To. dvctyKr\ rct ctKpct Kctt rct fterct eivctt. et yctp ftr\ Kct$' ctvrct, 
eTre) rcivvv el iTricrctrcti dTrocfeiKTiKoog, fret e\ dvctywg inrctp- <rv[A(Be@r\Kora, ecrcti. c\ict t«to rr\ yeuifterpict vk ecji c\ei^cti 
%eiv, $r\^ov'aTi Kct) hd fteo-x dvctyKctit &e7 ex £ w W a,7ro- oTi tujv ivctvnuv fuct iTricrv\fM\, d\\' icY ori oi cho kv@oi 
fteifyv' r\ \sk i7ri<r°/\<reTctL 'ire hori «Te ori dvctyKYj iKelvo et- Kvfiog' &&' ct\/\v\ irriqnfv^ ro erepctg, d\\' r\ 'ocrct vroog 
vcti, dhX y\ clr\<rercu &k elfroog, idv v7roXct(2r\ u)g dvctyKcuov ^ e%ei rrpog ct/Wr{Kct ucf eTvcti Bctrepcv vttc Octrepov, olov rct 
« ftr) dvctyKcuov, y\ icf cl"/\<reTcti oftcioog, ictv re ro ori elcfij 07rriKct nrpog yeoofterpictv Kcti Tct dpftoviKct nrpcg dpi$ftv\Tt- 
bid fte<ruov ictv re rc biori kcu <^i' dftecoov. kt\v. &cY ei ri v-Kcipx^ ^cug ypctftftctTg ftr) r\ ypctftficu Kctt 

Toov Se o-vfJi$e$Y\KOToov ftv) Kct$' ctvrct, ov rpoTrov Stoo- v\ sk toov dpx^v roov tcfioov, olov el KctKKtcrr\ roov ypct/xftulv 
pi<r$r\ rct Kct$' ctvTct, &k ecrtv i7ti<-YiftY\ d7rcc\etKTiKr\. « ydp y) ev$eTct r\ et ivctvrioog e%e* rr\ 7rept(pepeict' & yctp *j to 
ecrtv e\ dvdyKY\g cfeT^ctt ro <TVft7xepct<rftct m ro <rvftfie(Br\xog2Q tcftov yevog ctvroov, i)7rctpx £ h d\\' v\ koivov rt. 
ydp ivMx £ ~r&i ft*) V7rdpx £ w' irep) tozkt» ydp Xeyoo crvft- Qctvepcv 8e Kctt ictv ujctiv ctl 7rporct<retg Kct$o/\x ijr oovS 

@e$r\Korog. Kctirct d7topr\retev dv rtg tcroog rtvog eveKct rctvrct 6 <rvKkoyt<rftog, ort dvctyKY\ Kctt ro o-vftTxepcto-ftct dtStov 
$e? ipoordv rrept rvroov, el ftvj dvctyKY\ ro o-vftrrepctvftct etvctt ' etvctt rr\g rotctvTY\g dTroSei^eujg xct) rr\g dTrXoog et7re?v ct7ro- 
\sg%v ydp cftctcpepet ei rtg ipoftevcg rd rvx^rct eTrct eiTretev ro Bet^eoog. vk ecrtv ctpct dTrccietfy.g tujv fp$ctpruiv icY i-Ktc:YiftY\ 
crvft7repct<rftct. fre? cY ipoorctv ^x &g dvctyKctlov eTvctt St& rct 2$ dTrXuog, dXK vroog uxnrep Kctrct <rvft(3efir\Kcg, ort x Kct$o- 
v\pu)rr\ftevct, d\K ort Xeyetv dvdyKY\ tuj iKetvct keycvri, xctt Xov ctvrx icrtv dXXct rrcre Kctt nruog. orctv <? *;, dvctyKYi 
dXY t $oog Xeyetv, idv dXvfioog y\ V7rctpx^rct. ty)v erepctv ftv\ Kct$oXv etvctt 7rporct<rtv xctt <p$ctprY\v, <p$ctp- 

'E7rel <^' i\\ dvctyKr\g \j7rctpx £ i ir £ p) eKctcrcv yevcg o<ra> rr)v ftev %rt Kctt ro <rvft7repct<rftct v<rrig, ftv\ KctSoXv fre. 
xct$' ctvrd V7rdpx £ h ^ctl y\ exctcrov, cpctvepov ort rrept tujv oti u> ftev ecrctt uj <f vk ecrctt i<p' oov, cocr' yk ecrt crvX- 
xct$' ctvrd vTrctpx^roov ctt iiricrr\ftoviKcu dTrocfei^etg Kctt «t 30 Xoyi<rct<r$ctt Kct$oXov, dXX' crt vvv. hftoioog <f ex £ t Kcti 
roov rciirujv el<riv. rd ftev ydp o-vft(Be(2r\Korct «>t dvctyKcttct, rrept cpi<rftcvg, iireiTrep iqtv o bpio-ftog r\ dpx*! dTrcfret^eoog 
ojq xk dvctyKYj ro <rvft7repct<rftct elMvctt c\tort v7rctpx £ ^ ^' v\ dTrocfetfyg $e<ret cftctcpep^crct y\ <rvft7repct<rftct rt d7ro$ei£ > eu)g*. 
el de) «», ftr) Kct$' ctvro <fe, c?ov o/ <$td <rr\fteiujv <rvXXcyt- ctt cfe roov TroXXctKtg yivoftevuov dTrohifcetg y.cti i7rtcrY\ftcti , clov 
crftoi. ro ydp kcc$' ctvro « Kct$' ctvro iTrtqY^erctt, icYe <ftort. <reXY,VY\g iKXei-^eoog, fryXov "ort r\ ftev rctcttcY et<rtv, det et<rtv, 
to cYe cftoTt i7ricrct<r$cti ecrt ro fod t« ctlriti i7ricrct<r$cti. <ft' 35 r) cY vk dei, Kctrd ftepog el<riv. ujcnrep cY r) eKXer^/tg, co<rctv- 
ctino ctpct cfel Kct) ro fte<rcv roo rpiroo xctt ro Trpoorov ruo fte<roo roog rctg ctXXotg. 

\)7r<LpX £ W' 'E7rel cYe cpctvepcv ort exctcrov d7ro<fe?^ctt &K ecrtv dXX 9 

7 Ovx ctpct ecrtv e^ ctXXv yeVK?; fterct^ctvrct Set^cu, ctov v\ iK roov IkcLcjcv dpx^v, ctv ro cfetKvvftevov virctpxy V £ x- £ Tvo, 

to yeoofterptKOV dpt$ftY{rtKY\. rpict yctp icrt rd iv rcttg d^ro- yk ecrt ro iricrctr$ctt rirc, ctv e£ dXr\$oov kou dvctTrooetKToov 
&eihe<rtv, ev yiev ro dTrcbetKVjftevcv ro o-vftirepctTftct' tkto 40 <fetx@y x& 1 dfteTuov. ecrt yctp ytoo hT^ctt, coTTrep BpvTuov 
<$' icr) ro vTrcipxw y £ v £ i w) Kct$' ctvrc. ev <fe rd dfyoo- rov rerpctyuovtTftov. Kctrct KCtvov re yctp SetKWtiTtv 01 rorarot 
ftctrct' dfyuiftctTcc cY icr)v e\ oov. rpircv ro yevog ro inroKei- Xoyot, kcu erepoo v7rctp\\et' hto kcu err ctXXuov ecpctp- 

2. tcv C. II 5. xcti ante ri om A. II 21. tt£s\ t? toj«t» BC. II 22. h m om C. II ivus u? rim B. II 35. ^fiVt im^\ax<rSM A. 
9. [iiXKot B. H 23. xa.\ Tfc—a.Trofc;t;svs om pr C. II 29. tZ—tZ pr C, to-to rc . II 34. y.lnoi W A, pb to£S' B. II 40. uavep fy-jwv C. 

K2 



76 ANAAOCTIKftN ¥2TEPflN A. 

fxoTTOWtv ol Koyoi « <rvyyevoov. ixovv «% ri exe?vo eirtcra,- rei, xouv /xv\ ko.to, itoovtoov Xct/3»j dKK' eV) fxeye$oov [xovov, 

tou, dKKa, KO,Td <rvfx(3e@Y,Kog' « yct/J a,v e<pY\p[XOTTev r\ diro- tw cf dpt$fXY\Ttxu eir' dpt$fxoov. 

<?ei£iS >tct< e7r ct^Ao <yevo?. Eg-i o tota, fxev xou a, Ka,fxpa,vsTO,t stvou, irspt ct Y[ 

c/ Eko,c~ov &' sirtcra,[xs$a, [xr\ Karrd <rv[x(3s^Y\Kog , oTctv Eirtcrr\fxr, $soops? to, vira.px^VTa, ko,$' olvto,, otov /xovd.^a.g r\ 
kolt exelvo ytvoo<rKoo/xsv xa,$' o virdpx^h ex toov dpx&v 5 dpt$/xriTtxv\, r\ b\ yeoo/xeTpta, ~~Y\/xe?oL xou ypa,/xfxa,g. tolvto, 
toov exefvov y exeivo, olov to b\><rtv bp$oug fo~a,g exeiv, <*> ya,p Ka,fx(3a,vti<ri to eTva,t ko,i Tofrt eTvou. to, &e txtoov ira,$Y\ 
V7rctpx el "*- a $ ctvTo to etpr\fxevov, ex toov dpx^v toov tktk. x.o,$' olvto,, t( [xev o~r\fxa,(vei sxa,crov, Ka,fx(3a,vovo~tv , olov r) 
oocr' el xa,$' clvtq xdxs?vo vira,pxet co vira,pxei, dvayxr, [xev dpi$/xr,Tixr, t( irsptTTov r\ copTtov r\ TETpa,yoovov r, xvftog, 
70 /xs<rov sv Ty olvtyJ <rvyyeveia. eTvcu. el be /xr\, dKK' oog r) <$e ysoo/xsTpta, t( to ooKoyov r, to xex\a,<r$a,i r\ vsvstv, eu 
Tct dp/xovixd fo' dpt$fxr\TtKr\g. T* <5e TotcwTO, cfstxvvTou 10 fr' scrt, freixwxtri btoi Te toov xoivoov kol) ex toov diro^shty- 
[xh ov<ra,vToog , b^toLcpspst &s' to [xsv yoop oTt ETepa.g sirt~~r\- fxsvoov. xa,) r) dcrpoKoyta, oo<ra,vToog. ira.<ra, ydp dirobsixTixri 
[xr\g (to ya,p viroKstfxsvov ysvog sTspov), to b\ fooTi Tr\g covoo, eiricjri[xr\ irept Tpia, ecriv, ora, Te eTv&i Ti$eTO,i (toajto, &' 
v\g xa,$' olvto, to, ira,$r\ eqlv. oocrs xou ex t4toov <pa,vepov ecji to yevog, « toov xa,$' civta ira,$Yi[xoLToov ecr\ $eoopr\Tixr\), 
%ti &x ecriv dirofrelfyui exoocrov dirXoog, ctAA' r\ sx toov sxa,- xa,i n xoiva, Ksyofxsva, dfyoofiona,, sjr oov irpooToov dirobsi- 
crov dpx^v. dWa, tovtoov a,t dpx<u exovtri to xoivov. {ixvvri, xou rpkov to, ira,$r\, oov t( crr\[xa,(vei exa,crov ka,[X- 

Et <^s (f>a,vepov t«to, (poovepov xou oti ix scri Ta,g sxa,- fioovsi. sv(a,g fxivToi siricrr\[xa,g iS~ev xooXvei evia, tovtoov iroopo- 
crov WioLg dpx&S diro^ei^ou' e<rovTou yoop exeTvou dirdvToov pa,v, oiov tq ysvog /xrj viroTi$so-$a,i sTvou, a,v r\ (poovepov oti 
dpx&(-> KM eiricrr\[xr\ r\ sxe(voov xvpia, iravToov. xou ya,p sir(- scriv (» ya,p ofiotoog dr^ov oti dpt$fxog scri xou oTt ~pvxP° v 
cra,Teu [XoiKhov b ex tuv dvoorepov oohtoov etfroog' ex toov xou $ep[xov), xou Tct ird$r, fxr\ \a,[xfiavetv Tt <rr\fxa,(vei, a,v r\ Sr,- 
irpoTepoov ya,p oTfrev, oto,v ex /xr\ ouTtovroov etSvj ahtoov. oocr' 20 Ka,' oorirsp &§s t* xotvd £ \a,fx@avst t( <rY\[xa,(vst tq 'tcra, diro 
et [xdWov oTcfe xcCt [xaXtcja,, xoov sirtcrr\[xr\ sxe(vr\ etr\ xa,t \<roov dcpsXsfv, oti yvoopt/xov. d\}' iSsv y\ttov ty\ ys <pv<rst Tptcu 
[xoiWov xou [xdXtcra,. r\ c¥- diro&stfyg ix scpcopfxoTTst eV Tctum scrt, irspt o ts ^stxvvc-i xou « htxvv<rt xou e£ oov. 
clXko yevog, ctXX' r\ oog etpr\Tou ou yeoofxeTptxou eirt Toog Ovx ecrt &' viro$s<rtg vfr' aATr\fxa,, o dva,yxv\ sTvou fo' 

[xriX&vMolg r) oirTtxdg xou ou dpt$[xr\Ttxou sirt rdg dp- clvto xou c\oxs7v dva,yxY\. « ydp irpog tov s^oo Xoyov r) diro- 
[xovtxdg. 25 frstQg, dkka, irpog tov ev tv\ '^pvxy, sirs) «<5e ovKkoytrfxog. 

XooXsifiov fr' ecrt to yvoovou et oTfrev v\ [xr\. ;£ctXe7ro\ det ya,p ecrtv evcrr\va,'t irpog toV e^oo Xoyov, dwd irpog tov 
ydp to yvuivou et ex toov exoocrov dpx& v "urfxsv r, /xr\' oirsp etroo Koyov ix det. otra, /xev w fretxTd ovto, Xa,/x(3dvet a,v- 
ecr) to el^eva.t. otofxe$a, fr' , a,v sx^/^ev e^ d\Y\$tvoov rtvoov Tog /xr\ frst^a.g, toovt', sdv /xsv froxwTO, \a,/xfia,VY\ tu /xa,v- 
<rvKKoyt<rfxov xa\ irpooroov, eir(cra,<r$a,i. to cf vx ecrtv, dKha, $a,vorrt, viroTt$erou, xou ecrtv ix dirkoog viro$e<rtg dXXd 
o~vyyevr\ o^eT etvou TQ?g irpooTotg. 30 irpog exetvov /xovov, dv &e r\ [xr^efxtdg ev4o~r\g hofyg r\ xod 

10 Keyoo fr' dpx&g ev exa,~~oo ysvst ToovTctg, a,g oti scrt sva,vrta,g svvtrng Ka,[x(3a,vr\ to o,vto ot,hs?Ta,t. kou tovtoo hor- 

fxr] evbsxeTO.t b^el^ou. t( [xev %v Q~v\[xa,(vet xa,) Tct irpooTO, xou <pepet viro$eo~tg xou oUTYjfxa,' ecrt ydp ouTr\[xa, to virevoviTtov 
Tct ex tovtoov, Ka,fx\3a,vsTou' oti cf' scrt, Tct? [xev dpx&S t« /xa,v$a,vovrog ty\ So^yi, r, o a,v Ttg dirofretXTov ov Xa,/x- 
dvooyxr\ \a,fxfia,vetv , Tct <$"' ctXXct fretxvvva.i , oTov t( /xova,g $a,vr\ xou XP^ Tcil M ^et^oig. 

r\ ti to evav kou TptyoovoV etvou oe Tr\v /xova,oa, Ka,petv xa,t35 Ui /xev w opot kk eto~tv virovevetg («oe ya,p etva,t r\ /xr\ 

[xeye$og, to, tf erepa, b^stxwvou. KsyovTou), dK>' sv Toug irpoTa,<rso~tv a,t viro$sc~stg. Tovg cY 

'Ecrt &' oov xfovTO,t ev Toug diro&etxTtxoug eirtcrr\fxoug opovg [xovov £yv(eo-$a,i fre?' t«to <^' *x viro$e<rtg, et [xr\ kou 
Tct [xev t&ta, eKa,crr\g eiricrrtfxrig to, b~e koivo,, KOtva, <Je xctT' to dKOvetv viro$er(v Ttg eTvou <pY\<ret. dKK' o<roov ovtoov tco 
dvooKoytoov, eiret XP 7 ! " 1 ^ y e oo~ov ev tw viro ty\v eirtc-r\[xr\v exe?va, eTvou ytvsTou tq o~v[xirspa,<r[xa,. icY b yeoo/xeTpYig^pevbri 
yevet. tfoa, fxev olov ypa,fxfxr\v eTvou Tota,vb~(, xou to ev$v, 40 viroTt$eTa,t, uo~irep Ttveg e<pa,o~a,v, KeyovTeg oog » <Je?Tw^eu- 
xoivct b\ otov to \o~a, diro to~oov a,v dcpiKn, oti f<ra, Tct Kotira,. &st ^prjo-^ctr , toV <Je ysoofxsrpr\v r psvb'so~$ou KeyovTa, irob}- 
ixa,vov fr' sxa,crov txtoov 'ocrov ev too yevef toovto ya,p irotY\- oua,v Tr\v « irobta,(a,v r\ ev$e?a,v ty\v yeypa,fx/xevY\v ovk ev$e?ctv 

8. xo-xsiwi ABC. II 26. %0.\'T<h 7*p ts <ywv<*j om C. H 35. x«i ri t^woi C. II 37. o'i corr C. fl 40. "rowfo C. II 4l. t* C. 
31. Ivfluim? om B. II 35. svttr AB. 



ANAAXTIKnN Hf^TEPflN A. 77 

ov<ra,v. o 8e yeufxerpYis ibev <rvfX7repctiveTa,t tw TY\vh eivctt uv v\ b~eiKWTcti ti 7rep\ uv y\ yeufxeTpia, igfr t v\ Ik tuv 
ypa,fXfXYiv , fjv clvtos ecpSeyKTou , dkka, to, ota, tovtuv o\~ ctvTuv beiKWTctt t*j yeufxerpict, u<r7rep T<* OTTTtKoi. dfxcius 
kifxeva,. rrt to cttTY\fxct Kctt v7ro$e<ris 7ra,<ra, y\ us okov y\ us oe ko,i e-Ki tuv ctkkuv. Kctt irep\ fxev tktuv ko,\ koyov vcpe- 
h fxepet, ol &' opot ib~eTepov tktoov. KTeov ex, tuv yeu/xeTptKuv dpxoov ko,\ o-vfX7repa,<rfxa,Tuv, 

11 Etb\ fxev iv eTvctt y\ ev ti Trctpa, Tct Trokka, £k dva,yKY\, 5 irept fre roov dpxoov koyov i% vfaxreov tu yeufxerpvi v\ 

« dirofetfys ecjctt, eTvcu fxevTOt ev ko,to, 7rokkuv dkvi&es el- yeufxeTpv\s' dfxoius 8e kcu £7rl toov ctkkuv e7rtcjY\fxuv. »re 
iretv dvooyKYj' i ya,p ecjctt to K&Ooktf, a,v fxy\ TbTo y\' ectv ttcLv ctpa, eKctcjov hrtcr^fxovoi epoo7Y\fxct epooTY\Teov, *&' a,7ra,v 
6% to K&Qokv fXY\ w, to fxecrov yk etjctt, ucj' ib? dTrob^et^ts. 70 epuTUfxevov dTTOKpneov 7rep\ eKoiqov, dkkd rd KO/rd ty]v 
$e? ctpoo Tt ev kcu to o,vto £7n 7rketovuv eTvcu fxv} dfxuvvfxov. e7rtcjY\(XY\v hoptcQevra,. el b~e foooke^eTcu yeufxerpYi *j yeoo- 
to $e fXY\ evfrexerdcu dfxa, ipdvcu kcu d7ro<pa,va,t ifrefxta, 10 fxerpYis ovtoo?, tpoovepov oTt kcu Kotkus, edv Ik t4tuv ti 
kctfxfictvet diro&eifys , dkk' v\ edv S~ev\ hi^at kcu tq TVfXTre- fretKVvy, el $e fxv\, « Kookoo?. cfiikov o^ "oTt i$' ekeyxfit 
pooo-fxoo '&too<;. freiKVVTcu $e kcofixo-t to TrpooTov kootoo tS fxe- yeoofxerpY\v dkk' *j Kovrd o~vfxfie(3Y\Kos, u<?' £k c\v Hy\ ev 
cov, oti dkviQes, d7ro(pctvcu $' vk dkvfies. to $e fxeo-ov ov- dyeoofxeTpv\Tots 7rep\ yeoofxeTpt&s foookeKTeov ' kY\o-ei ydp o 
Sev hcupepet etvcu kcu fXYJ eTvcu kctfielv, Cos <f cwtoos kcu (poovkoos fri&keyofxevos. hfxoioos b\ kcu eirt toov akkwv e%et 
to Tpirov. ei ydp e^Y\, kcl$' « dv$poo7rov dkv\$es elirelv, et 15 e7ricpifxooVj 

kou fXY\ kvQpooTrov dkvjSes, dkk' el fxovov eov$poo7rov "C^uov eT- "ETret b^ ecjt yeoofxeTptKou epooTYjfxctTcb, ap' e<~t kcm 

vctt, /XYJ XJZov <5e fxvj ' ec~cu yctp dkvjSes et7re?v K.ookkta,v, et dyeoofxeTpY\Tct,; kcu Trctp' Ikcu-y\v e7rtcjY\fXY[V ra, kooto, ty\v 
y.cu fXY\ K.ct,kkiav, ofxoos XJ^ov, fxv\ XJZov $' «. cutiov $' oti ctyvoictv ty\v ttoioiv yeoofxeTptKa, ecjiv v\ dyeoo/xeTpYjToo; kcu 
70 TrpooTov » fxovov Kctrd t« fxeo-ov keyeTcu dkkd Kcti kclt' 7roTepov d kootoo ty]v dyvotoov ovkkoyto-fxos o eK toov dvTt- 
ctkkov $id to eTvat eTci 7rketovoov , oocf &$' el to fxecrov kcu 20 Ketfxevoov o-vkkoyto-fxos, v\ 7rct,pa,koyi<rfxos, KciTct, yeoofxerptctv 
oovto ecjt Kcu fxvj ctvTo, irpos to rvfXTrepcoo-fXct, iSev frtcupepet. S~e, y\ e^ a,kkY\s Te~xyY\S, otov to [xovo-ikov ecjtv epooTY\fxa, 
70 & c%7ra,v (pdva,t vi dTrocpdvctt v\ ets 70 db\jva,Tov dTrofreifcts dyeoofxeTpv\Tov Trept yeoofxeTpia,s , to <Je rds 7ra,pa,kkykovs 
ka,fx$dvet, koli toZto, &$' de\ KO,Qokov, dkk' %<rov iko,vov, o-vfXTrtTTTetv oter6a,t yeoofxerptKOV ttoos ko,\ dyeoofxeTpviTov a,k- 
ikavov &' £7rl tov yevovs. keyoo $' e7c\ t» yevovs oiov Trept kov TpoTcov; bmov yoop tkto, uxnrep 70 dppv$fxov, kou to 
o yevos 7&S dTroSetfcets (pspet, uxnrep e v tpY{ra,t Koot 7rpo7epov. 25 fxev hepov dyeoofxerpY\Tov too jxy\ exetv u<nrep to appvQfXov, 
'~E7rtKOivoov\io-i fre 7roL<ra,t a,'t e7rtcjY\fxa,t dkkv]ka,is Karra, to h' eTepov tu cpoovkoos $%UV' k&u y\ a,yvota, cCvty\, y\ bc 
7& KOivd. KOtvd <& keyoo ots "xpoovT&t oos Ik tvtoov diro- toov toivtoov dpyj^v, evoovTta,. ev $e to?s fxa,$Y\fxa,<rtv \sk ec-tv 
fretKVvvTes, dkk' ov 7rep\ oov fretKVvovvtv cvfr' o freiKVvovo-tv. dfxoioos d 7ra,pa,koyt<rfxcs, oti to fxetrov eqtv det $ittoV 
kcu y\ frtookeKTiKq 7rd<ra,ts. kou eX tis KcoSokov iretpooTo oet- kcoto. Te yoop t«t« ttgvitos, koa t»to 7ra.ktv koot' cokkov 
kvvvou ta KOtvd, otov oTt a,7ra,v cpdvoot y\ d7ro(pa,va,i, y) oti 30 keyeToot 7To,vtos. to $e Ka,TY\yopxfxevov i keyercu 7ra,v. tcwto, 
f<ra, dTro truf/y y\ toov toktoov atto,. y\ b\ $ta,keKTtKY\ £k ecjtv b~' ecjtv oTov dpciv Ty vcY\<ret, ev $e tc?s kcyots ka,vSa,vet. dpa, 
vtooS upto-fxevuv tivuv, ibe yevovs Ttvos evcs. & ydp a,v YipuTa,' 7ra,S KVKkos crxhf^cu; dv <5e ypa,tpYi, bfykov. Tf ^e; T<* £7r>? 
dTrob^etKvvna, ydp *k ecjtv epu7a,v b~td to 7uv drriKet/xevuf KVKkos; (poovepov oti vk ecjtv. 

ovtuv fXYJ b~eiKW<r$a,t to clvtq. b^eb^eiKTou bie t»to ev to?s Ov fre? b' evcja,<rtv ets olvto (pepetv, dv v\ v\ 7rpoTa,<rtS 

nrept <rvk? oyio-fxov. 35 e7ra,KTtKV\. ucrirep ya,p vbe 7rpoTO,<rts ecjtv *j /xy\ ecjtv e7ri 

ao Et bfe to cvvto ecjtv epuTYifXct <rvkkoyicjiKov Kctt 7rpo- Trketovuv (« yctp eqctt e7r\ Trctvruv, ek tuv Kot,$okv b~' 6 

Toxrts dvTi(pct<reus, 7rpoTa,<rets &e ko,$' eKctcjY[\ e7rtcjY\fXY\v o-vkkoyi<rfxos), bykov oti ib'' evcjct<rts. ctt ctvTcti ya,p irpo- 
e^ uv o <rvkkcyt<rfxos d Katf eKctcjYjV, etv\ ctv 7t epuTY\fxa, Ta,<rets Kctt evcja,<rets' y\v ya,p (pepet evcjctctv, ctvTvj yevon 
E7rtcjY\fXQViKov, e\ uv o Kah' eKO,cjY,v otKetcs yiverctt <rvkko- ctv 7rpoTct<rts y\ d7ro$eiKTiKY\ y\ hookeKTtKYi. 
yto-fxos. bvikov ctpa, 07t ov tt&v epooTYjfxa, yeufxeTptKov dv 40 %vfx$a/tvet b? eviovs d<rvkkoyicjus kiyetv otct tq kctfx- 

ztY\ ib~' lctTptKov, hfxoius b% kou e7r\ tuv ctkkuv' dkk' e^ fidvetv dfxcpoTepots t<* eTrcfxeva,, otov km d K.a,ivevs 7rote?, 

14. u<r<t,iTus C. II 16. ei] r\ B. II tbtu km pr\ AC. H 18. oy.ofu? B. H 2k. Xiyu ¥ e7r\ t« *ihov<; om C. 

1. r\ x U pr C. II 7. i.y.x<;o-i im^ri^ovct, om pr C. H 13. ocysufierptiTu C. II 18. r, if&uphptr*. orn ABC. U 20. v o 7r«p*<rvXXo7i- 
Cfiot AB. II 26. ccut») koCi r\ ABC. II 28. 7rot,cot,<nXXoy<riA,o? A. II i& t« forrov AB et pr C. II 29. <ye B. U t«tou B. II 32. S*/; t<5 hnt C. 



78 ANAAVTIKttN VSTEPON A. 

oti 70 ntvp ev tv\ 7tokka,7tkaTia. dvockoyfa,' xa,t yocp 70 Ttvp 7o syyvg eiva,i, 70 A 70 fxv) <rtk(3siv* vitoipx^ &v) kou to 
ra%t) ysvvaTou, cos (pv\Tt, xcu cCvty\ v\ dva-koyia,. vtco <Y B twT, xou 70 A rw B to fxv) crtkSstv, cocre xoci 700 Y 
ix s<ri TvkkoytT/xos' dkk' s\ tv\ to.x^vi dva,kcyta. ETts- 70 A. aou «jti t» <$ioti vvkkoytTfxos' s'ikY\7tTa,i ydp 70 
tou v) 7tokka,7tkdTios xou 700 nxvpt v) 7ct%icpyi sv ty\ xivY\Tst ntpcoTov ctmov. Ttaktv oos tv\v <rskv\VY\v b^sixvv^Ttv, oti <r<pa,i- 
dva,koyia,. evtoTs fxsv kv ix evMx^o.i TvkkoytTa,T$cu sx 7cov 5 poEtbviS, ota, tuiv o,v^y\tecov' sl yacp 70 a,v^a,vofXEvov xtco 
stkvifxfxsvcov , ots cY evfrexeTou, dkk' «% opctTou. el $' v\v cr<pa,ipoEicf£S , a.v^dvEt cY v) T£kv\vv\, cpccvspov oTt <r<pa,tpoEi- 
dc\vva,Tov sx 'ipev&ov? dkv { $\s b^st^ou, pa,b~tov dv v\v to dva,- hv\s. xtco fxsv «v t« oti yiyovsv crvkkoytTfxos, dvd.Ttcikiv 
kvstv dvTscrpscps ydp dv s^ dva,yxv\s. ecrco yocp to A ov' $e te$svtos t« fx&ov t« <fioTt' « ydp <ftd Tds ccv^teis 
70V70V <f OV70S 70.0^1 scrtv, a, oTfra, o7i scriv, oiov 70 B. sx (rcpoupoEibYis scriv, dkkd $td 70 T<poupostbY\s sTvou kccfxftoo- 
T0V7COV dpa, cfsffcco oti 80» sxs?vo. dvTicrps<pst §£ fxockkov 10 vst to,s o,v£y\teis toio,vto,s. TEkv\vv\ s<p' co r, T<pa,tpostb'v]s 
Tct ev to?s fxa,$v\fxa,Tiv , oti ^ev TVfx(3s(Bv\xos ka,fx(Ba,vovTiv s<p' u> B, ck,v^y\tis £<p' co A. i<p' oov bs Tec fXsTa, fxv) 
(dkkd xdi tktw <fta,<pspovo-i tcov ev to?s t\ta,koyois) dkk' dvTtc;pe<pet x.a,t scji yvcoptfxcoTspov to dva,tTtov, to oTt fxsv 

optO-fXOVS. OElXVVTa,t, TC OiOTl «. STl S<p COi TO fXSTOV sfcco TiUSTCU, 

Av^STOU O^ « $10, 7COV fXEQ-OOV, dkkd 700 lXpOO-kO,fX- X.a\ ydp EV TOVTOIS T» OTl XOU « T« frlOTi y) dTto^st^ts' « 

(BctVSlV, OIOV TO A T« B, TKTO <^£ T« Y, TtO,kiV TKTO TK A, 15 ydp ksysTCU TO CCITIOV. OtOV $10, Ti &X dva,7tVS£l T0?%0S' 9 

xou t«t' els a,Tteipov. xa,t e\s to itka,ytov, olov to A xou oti « "C^uov. el yocp tkto t« fxv\ dva,7tveeiv octTtov, s&si to 

KO,Td ri r xcu xarta t« E, oTov ectiv dptSfxos 7to<ros v\ Tooov eTvcu outiov t» dva,7tvs?v, oTov sl v) d7to<pa,<Tis ahla, t» 

xa\ ocTtEipos t5to e<p' w A, o ntepiTTos dpi$fxos 7to<rcs e<p' [xy\ vTtcLpxpw, v) xa,Tci(pa,ris tv V7ta,pxeiv, uxntsp eiTo d<rv(x- 

ov B, dpt$fxos TteptTTOS e<p' ov F' ecriv apa. to A xarta, fxsTpa, eTvou to, $spfxd xcu ipvxpf' T « (M\ vyia,tvsiv, to 

ri r. xa,\ scrtv o dpTios itoo-os dptSfxos s(p' ov A, o a.p-20 o-vfx/xsTpa, sTva,i t» vyia,tvsiv. ofxctcos os xoci sl v) xa,Ta,(par- 

Ttos dptS/xos s(p' ov E* icriv a,pct to A xarta, t» E. <ris t» V7ta,px^t v) d7to<pa,<ris T« fxv) V7ta,px^. S7ti <& 

13 To <$■' oTt b^tcupspst xa,i to Sioti s7ticra,o-Sa,t , ntpcoTov toov ovtcos dTtofrs&ofxsvoov ov crvfx(2a,ivei to kex^v ov ydp 

fxsv ev ty\ a,vTY\ e7ti<rv\fxvi, xcu sv to.vtv\ Stxus-, evo, fxsv a,7ta,v dva,7tve? X^coov. 6 oe <Tvkkoyto-fxos ytveTcu ty\s Totocv- 

TpoTtov edv fxv) fo' dfxs<rcov ytvv\Ta,i 6 crvkkoyto-fxos '(» y<xp ty\s a,h(a,s sv tco fxs<rco o-xv\f*>a,7t. oTov scrco to A ^wov, s<p' 

ha,fxfid,VS7a,l 70 7tpcO70V OUTIOV, v) OE T» Si07t S7ttcrY\fXY\ XO,70, 25 K TO B T0 V dva,7tVS?V, S<p' 00 r 70?X0S. 700 fXEV OVV B 7tO,V7\ 

70 7tpco7ov cciTtcv), dkkov os sl fo' dfxstruv fxsv, dkko, vTtcLpx^ ™ A (7tdv ydp 70 dvocTtvsov X^coov), 7u bs r ov- 
fxv) frtd t» a,t7iov dkkd 7cov dv7icrps(pov7cov $td t» yvcopt- $svi, uicrs ibs to B tw T ovSsvi' ovx olpa, dva,7tvs? 6 70?- 
fxoo7spov. xcokvEi ydp bbsv 7cov dvTtxa,TY\yopovfxevcov yvcopi- ^o?. sotxa,<ri <^' ou toio,vtou tcov outicov to?s >ca,$' v7tsp- 

fXOOTEpoV sTvOU EVtOTE TO fXV\ CUTiOV , COCr' ECTOU $10, TOVTOV v) (3okv,V slpY\fXSVOtS' TKTO &' ECTl TO TtkeOV dTtOCJY^Ta.VTO, TO /XS- 

dTtofreij^is, oTov oTt iyyt)? ot 7tka,vv\Tes ha, t» fxv) crtkfietv. 30 troi' e'i7te?v, oTov to t» 'Ava,xdp<Ttos, oti ev ^xv$ous itc eU 
ecrco s(p' Z Y 7tka,vv\Tss, s(p' 00 B to fxv) crtkftstv, s(p' co <rtv avkvjToci, ibs ydp kfXTtskou 

A to syyvs sTva,t. dkv\$ss &v\ to B xartd t» T st7t£?v' 01 'Ka.Td fxsv Svj tv\v o.vtyiV E7ti<rY\fXY]v xcu xartd tv\v tuv 

ydp 7tka,vv\Tss » <rik(5xTtv. dkka, xou to A xa,Ta,ra B* to (xetcov $etiv a,vTou &ta,<popa,t eIti t» ot^ itpos tov t» <^iotj 
ydp fxv) crtkfiov syyvs scri' tkto <^' Etkv\(p$co h' sTtctyco- TvkkoytTfxov' a,kkov bs TpoTtov b s ta,(pspsi to frtoTi t» oti 
«yv;£ v\ h' o,\t$v\tscos. dva,yxv\ kv to A tw T v7ta,px^, cocr' 35 to <^i' akkv\s E7ticrv\fXY\s sxa,7spov $scops?v. TotocvTa, t¥ scfiv 
d7tob x e$'EixTa,i oti 01 7tka,vv\TES syyvs e\tiv. ovtos kv Tvk- oto, vtcos £%ei 71^0? a,kkv,ka, uocr' stvcti $a,Tspov vTto $octe- 
koytTfxos » t« &otj dkka, t» oti scrtV « ya,p foa, to jxy\ pov, oiov to, oTtTtxa, Ttpos yscofxsTpta,v xa,i to, fxv\X<xvixd 
crikfisiv syyvs eitiv, d^kd frtd to syyvs sTvcu « crtkfixTtv. ntpos <rspsofxsTpla,v xou to, dpfxovtxa, Ttpos dpi$fxv\Ttxv)v xou 
syX^ops? be xou cfia, $a,Tepov $art£pov S~£tx$vjva,i, xcu ecrou tcc <pa,tvofxeva, Ttpos dcrpokoytxY\v. tx^ov b~e Tvvcovvfxot si- 
T« btoTt v) dTtobei^ts 1 otov ecrco to F Ttkdvvrtes, e<p' co B 40 tiv evia,t tovtcov tcov eTttcrYtfxuov, olov d<rpokoy(a, v\ te fx<%- 

2. &' om pr C. II 18. Z rb a, C. II 25. y,—26. ounoi ora C. 11 30. Si*-31. ttAcm-te? orai. II 30. ri C. II 31. k 7 — Z /3 C U 
35. r] /3 A et pr B. 

2. xai rh A rZ B rs ^ ^jSr.y post 3. A ABC II ro a, rZ 7 B. II 7. ouv om B. II 11. £k om pr C. II i4 ro cu B. II 
15. oTov oii fotx. C. II 16. - a,W7rv£7y C. II 19> '^%p* x.&\ 8epfJ.d C. II ra) ABC. II 21. 67ri] ei B. II 25. ro alterum om C. II 26. rw &l 
Tj ro <yk J3 A. II 27. vre AB. II 30. a.va.xa,p<jt<)os C. I! 32. tw om C. II 33. picuy] a.vrw AB el pr C. li 40. faa, B. 



ANAATTIKON tf^TEPfiN A. 79 

6v\fxa,TiKv) xcu v\ va,VTtxv\, %(Ci dpfxovixv\ v\ re fxa,$Yifxa,TLXYJ A 7rccvTi to r, rop Ss B fxv[hvi, ovfrsy) roov B to A. bfxoiooi 

KO,) Y\ XOOTa TY[V 0,XOY[V. SVTavSo, ya,p TO fXeV 'oTi TCOV CUQ-$Y[- <& XCU SL TO B £1' okup TLVL SCJiV ', 0T0V SV TCO A* TO fXSV 

tikujv el&evat, to <fe b^tcri rcov fxa$Y[fxa,rixcoV 'vroiyap ejQiVL yocp A Travr) tw B V7ra,px £ i, ro <% A «<5ev< twv A, uicjs 

tuov ourtcov ra,g a,7rcoetzetg, kcu 7rokka,Kig &k \o-a,Q-t to ort, xa,- to A ovfrsv) roov B V7ra,p%st frta) <rvkkoytQ-fxov. tov a-vrov 

$a,7rep ot to xa$okv $eoopwreg 7rokka,Kig evia, roov ko,$' exa,cjov 5 fre rpoTrov o^etx^o-eTat xou sl ctfxcpco ev 'dkoo tlvl scjiv. "otl 

ix to-a,cri &' aJveTTLTKerJjtav. eqt h% ravra, "oq-o. srepov tl ovra, <Y IvMx £ to,l ro B fxvj eTvaL ev oo okco ecr) ro A, y) 7raktv 

ty\v M<rta,v KepcpviTou roig eioe<rtv. ra, ya,p fxa.OYifxa.TOo TrepL etov\ to A ev cp to B, <pa,vepov ex toov q-vcjclxloov , o<rcu fxv\ e7ra,k- 

i<jfv' xya)p xa,$' vTroxetfxew Ttvog' et ya)p xcu xa,$' viroxet- ka,Trov<riv a,kkY\kaig. el yap fXY[§ev rcov ev ty\ AT A o~v- 

fxevd Tivog ra yecofxerpixa, ecriv, cLkk' &x v\ ye xa,$' vTroxstfxe- fttf£$fl£ xovra. fxv\<}evog xa,TY[yope?ra,t roov ev rv\ BEZ, to 

vx. e%eL <5e xocl Trpog ty\v otttlxv\v, uig a,vrv\ Trpog ty\v yscofxs-10 <Y A ev okcp ecri roo crvcjoixop ovtl, <pa,vspov otl to B 

Tpiav, a,kk.Y\ 7rpog tccvty^v, olov to Trepi ty\s \ptfrcs' to fxev ix ec^cu ev tuj 0' e7ra,kkafyo-L yap a\ o-vcroixta,t. ofxctoog 

ya,p otl cpvQ-tK^ etoevat, to oe otoTt oTTTtKt, v\ a,7rkoog v\ oe xo,l ei to B ev okco tlvl ecjiv. ea,v oe fXYioeTepov v\ ev 

Y.a,Ta, to fxa,$Y t fxa,. 7rckka,t Se xa) toov fxv\. u7r' cLkkY\ka,g okco fXY[&ev{, fXYJ v7ra.pXY\ <% to A tco B, cLva,yKY\ arsofxooS 

£7rtcrY[fxoov exovQ-tv ovTcog, olov la,TptKY[ 7rpog yecofxeTpta,V otl fxv] V7ra,px^v. et ya,p eg-a-t tl fxeo-ov, a,va,yKY\ ba-Tepov a,v- 

fxev ya.p to, ekKY\ to, 7rept(pepYi (2pao\iTepov vytaZeTa.t, tov 15 rcov ev okco tivi slvou. y\ ya,p ev too TrpooToo QrxyfX&TL v\ ev 

Xarrfis elc\eva,i, focTt o% tk yecofxerpv. tuo fxecrco ec;a.t 6 o-vkkoyto-fxog. st fxev %v ev tw 7rpooToo, 

14 Tcov <fe a-x^f^ocTcov e7rtcjY\fxovtKov fxookig-a, to orpooTov to B ecrcu ev okco tlvi (Ka,Ta,<pa,TtKY]v ydp be? ty)v irpog t«to 
sqtv. o,l Te yap fxa,dY\f/,aTiKa,t tcov eirtcjYifxujv <$ta* tovtov ytveo-$a,i 7rpora,Q-tv), sl <T sv tw fxeo-co, oTroTepov eTVX £V ' 
(pepKFt Tct? a.Tro^ei^etg , olov a,pi$fXY[TtKY\ xa\ yecofxeTpta, xcxt Trpog dfxcporepotg ya,p kv\(p&evrog rov cyepv\rtx^ ytvercu Q-vk- 
07rrtxY[, xcu o~x^ov cog etTrelv oo-ou t« &otz 7rotovvra,i ty\v 20 koyLQ-fxog' d,fX(porepcov <Y a,7ro(pa,rtKuiv io-cov &K ecja>i. 
CKeiptV y\ yap %kcog Y[ Cog e7ri ro orokv xai ev ro?g 7rket- ^a-vepov kv "otl evMx^Tcit re a,kkco fxv\ v7ra,pX £ W * To " 
<fotg S~ta) rovrou t« o-x^fJoarrog 6 t» <^otj o-vkkoyto-fxog. oocre fxoog, xa,i ttot evo s e'x£Ta,L xa,) Truig, elpqxa,fx J ev. 

xctv foa) txt etY\ fxaiktcja, e7rtcrY[fxovtK0V xvptoora,Tov ya,p Ayvota, <P v) /xy\ xo,t a,7ro(pa,o-LV ookka) xa,ra) <Jict5e-16 

t« elbeva.L ro frtort SecopeTv. eTra, rv\v t« tl scjlv s7TLcrY\fXY[V trtv keyofxevv\ ecji fxev v\ Slo, o-vkkoyiQ-fxov ytvofxevY\ «,7iut>j, 
frta) fxovov tovtov $Y\pevQ-a,L <Jvva,rov. ev fxev ya,p tuj fxeo-co 25 a,vrv\ <Y ev fxev ro?g 7rpooroog v7ra,px ov Tiv v\ fxv\ vTrchpx^i 
<rxv[fxa,TL ov ytvera,L xa,TV[yoptxog o-vkkoyto-fxog, v\ fre t» o-vfx@a,tvet <$z;_w£* v\ ya,p ora,v a,7rkcog v7roka,^Y\ vTrdpx^ 
Tt ecrtv eTrtcjYifXYi xa,ra,(pa,o-ecog' ev <Te roo evxaoTop ytverou v\ fxv\ V7ra,px £ ^, v\ 'ora,v frta, o-vkkoyto-fxov ka,(3Y\ ty\v vtto- 
fxev dkk' « xa,$okov, ro <% rt Icjl rcov xa,$okov ecrlv ov kvj^.ty. ty^ fxev w a,7rkv\g vTrokvr^eoog a,7rk.Y\ v\ a,7ra,TY\, TY\g 
ya,p txy\ ecrt TJopov Snrovv o a,v$pco7rog. ert tvto fxev exetvoov &s Slo, o-vkkoyto-fxov Trkstovg. fxv\ v7ra,px £ Too ya,p to A fxv\- 
ovfrev 7rporSe?ra,t, exe?va, <?e frta, rovrov Ka.ra.TrvKVovTa.t xa,t30 frevt rcov B cLrofxoog' ixxv ea,v o-vkkoyiXv\ra,i V7ra,px siv T0 
ouv^ercu, eoog dv etg ra, cxfxeo-a, ek$v\. <pa,vepov xv otl xv- A tw B, fxe<rov ka,fioov ro Y, v\7ra,rv\fxevog ecrcu fria, <rvk- 
ptooTO,Tov rov e7rtcja,Q-$a,i ro Trpuirov crx^f^^» koyto-fxov. evb y ex £ Ta,L fxev iv cLfx<porepa,g ra)g 7rpora,Q-etg eT- 

15 "£Lo-7rep})ev7ra.px £ w to A tw B evecfe^x^ro ciTofxoog, %roo vcu ^evbe^g, evo s e'x £ Ta,i <fe rv\v erepa,v fxovov. et ya,p fxrjs 
xa,t fxv\ v7ra,px £ w £ yx w P s ^' ^ £ 7 W ^ £ T ° a,rofxoog V7rapx £ w h to A fxv^evt ruiv T v7ra,px £ L fxv\rs ro Y fxv\S~ev) roov B, et- 
fxvj v7ra,px £ w to fxv\ eivou ctvruov fxeo-ov %rroo ya,p ixert ecjcu 35 kv\7rT0,i o^ eKarrepa, cLva.Tra.ktv, kfX(puo ^evbe?g eo-ovra,t. ey- 
xarr akko ro V7ra,px £ w V fW V7ra,px £ ^. ora,v fxev w v\ ro A X 00 ?^ ^ *™g sx £ lv to Y Trpog ro A xou B oocje fxvrre vtto 
v\ to B ev 'okco rtvt v\, v\ xat ctfxcpco, ix evfrex £ Tai ro Atw to A eTva,L fXY\re xa,$okov roo B. to /xev ya)p B a)o\iva,TOV 
B 7rpooroog fxv\ v7ra,px £ w. ecjco yctp ro A ev okup tw. Y. eTva,t ev okcp rtvt' Trpooroog yoop ekeyero cuvrcp ro A fxvj v7ra,p- 
vkovv st ro B fxvj ecjtv ev 'okco rup Y (eyxoope? ya)p ro fxev X £lv ' T0 ^ £ A &k a\vdyKV\ ttcLq-l ro?g %q-lv sTva,i Ka,$okov, 
A sTvo,l sv rm 'dkco, ro <% B fxvj eTvou ev tovtco), <rvkXo-40 oocp cLfxcporepcu ipev£e?g. cLkka) kou ty\v erepa,v svo s eX £ ra,i 
yLQ-fxog ecjctL t» fxv\ v7ra,px £ i- v to A tw B' el ya,p rop fxev cLkv\$Y\ ka,fx(3o£vetv , ov fxevrot oTrorepav ervx £V i cLkka, tv\v 

4. ouTivi C. ft 9. yetd/jiETpyTx AB, «j£'jiy.zTpiTu. pr C. II i-x, ^] i%l B. H 3.5. tuj pr C. 
. 3. T£r—4.*SW1 om AB. II 7. ov^otxut B. I! 9. x«,t*J xaX v.&tu. AB. II 11. Q]e8 A. il 16. b om C 8 24. ^ey0fi(n\ B. II 25. n 
[ii\ v7rdpxvot om pr C. II 34. vxc4p^£iv A, \>i:ipx r t B. II 37. tS~\ tcu corr C. \\ 4l. fA.inoi\ \l{hto\, «js C. 



80 ANAATTIKON V^TEPfiN A. * 

AT* *j yctp TB 7tpdra,<rts de) ^evcf^s ecrou cftd ro ev fxv\- 70 T, ru cfe B oku fXY\ v7tdpx^ v -> v\ fxev F A dkY\$Y\s ecrou, 
frev) eTvou ro B, rv]v cfe AT eyxupeT, ofov et to A xctt tw »} <^e TB r pevtfY\s. 7tctktv tw B fxv\cfevi vTtdpx^i vc% tw 
r kcu ru B V7tdpx el drofxus. 'orctv yctp rtpurus Kctrvj- A 7Tctvri vTta.pfcet' el ya,p twA, xcu t£B* dkk* »% v7tY\p- 
yopYircu rctvro Ttketdvuv, ovcferepov ovcferepu ecrttt. cftcttpe- x ev - ^dv * v M<p$l ro T ru /xev A oku U7rctp%eiv, ru cfk 
pei cf vcfev, itf' el /xy\ drofxus vTtopx^- 5 B fXY\cfevi, v\ fxev TB 7tpdra,<rts dkv\$Y\S, v\ cf erepa, -<pev- 

C H fxev «v t» vTrctpxsw o\itastY\ cfta, rovruv re kcu cfv\s. bfxoius cfe kcu fxero,re$evros t» trepY\riwi. ydp fXYf 
%ru yivercu fxovus (i ya,p y\v ev cxkku o-xftfi&ri rov vitctp- cfevt V7tdpxei ru A, icfe ru B icfev) vTtdp^et ' edv vv kv\- 
Xeiv <rvkkoyt<rfxos) , v\ cfe rov fxv\ V7ta,px^v ev re ru Ttpu- <p$Y\ ro T ru fxev A oku fxv\ V7tdpx^ v -, t§ & B oku 
ru kcu ev ru fxecru <7%*}/ActTt. itpurov w entufxev 7to<rct- vTtctpx^ '■> »3 pev AT 7tporct<rts dk.Y\$Y]s etrctt, v\ erepa, c% 
Xu? ev ru rtpuru yiverou, koli itus exov<ruv ruv 7tpora,- 10 ^pev<fv\s. kou 7ta,ktv, itctvr) ru B vTtdpx^-, fxv\cfev) kctr- 
creuv. evcfexereu fxev w dfxcporepuv ^pevcfuv &<ruv, olov el ro fieTv ru A VTtdpx^ ^pevcfog. dvdyKY\ ydp, el ru B 7T«,vt£ 
A kcu ru r Kctt ru B vTtctpx^ droftug' ectv ya.p kv\(p$Y[ koli ru A Ttvt V7ta.pxetv' edv kv kY\cp$Y\ ru fxev B 7rctyTi 
to fdev A tw r fJLY\hvt, ro <fe Y 7ta.vr) ru B, ipevfreTg fa«f%/u» ro V, ru §e A [Mifrevt, y\ fxev TB dkv\$Y\g eqa.t, 
cu 7tpordo~etg. hc\(xera.t $e kcu rY\g erepa.g ^evcfovg vo-Y\g, y\ cfe V A ipevc%\g. cpctvepov %v ort kcu dfJicporepuv vvuv 
koa ra,vrv\g c7torepa,g eru%ev. eyx^pe^t ya,p rv\v fxev AT iS-^pevcfuv kcu rY\g erep&g fxovov eq-cu <rvkkoyt<rfxog d7ta,rvt- 
dkv\<% etvou, t^v cfe T B ^eu^i, t»5V ^aev AT dkY\$Y\ ort rtKog ev to?? droftotg. 

« Tratrt Tot? %<rtv vTt&px^ T ° A, t>iv ^ TB ^pevcfvi ori 'Ev cfe ro?g fXY\ drofxug V7tdpx°v°~i v V f*A v7tdpxov-\'] 

dcfvva,rov v7ta,px el T( ? B to T, u fA.Y\cfevi vTtapx^ ?<> A* crtv, otccv fxev cfta, t« ot>tet» fxecrov ytvY\rcu t» 'pevfrovg 6 
& ydp ert dkY\$Y\s ecrou v\ AT 7tpora,<rtg' dfxa, cfe, ei kou <rvkkoyt<rfxog, &x ^tov re dfxcporepa,g "pevcfeTg eTvcu rds 
el<r)v dfuporepojt dkv\$ets, kou ro <rvfX7tepa,<rfxa, ecjctt dkvfies. 20 7tpora,<rets, dkkd fxovov ryv Ttpos ru fxetXpvt asKpu. keyu 
dkkd kou T^v r B evcfe^x^cu dkv\$Y\ eTvou rv\s erepa,s *<rY\s ef oheTov fxevov <5t' ov yiverou rY]s dvrtcpd<reus <rvk- 
ipevcfovs, otov el ro B kcu ev ru V kcu ev ru A eqiv koyto-fxog. VTtctpxeru ydp ro AtwB cftd fxe<rov t» T. 
dvdyKY\ ydp $drepov v7to $a,repov eTvou, ucj' dv ka,$v\ to eVet ?v dva.yKY\ rv]v TB Ka,rcupa,rtKY\v ka.fx(Bdve<r$ou <rvk- 
A fXY\<fev) ruv T uW/)%etv, r ipevS'Y\g ecrcu y\ Ttporcurtg. cpa,- koyt<rfxov ytvofxev*, <}y\kov ort de) a,vrY\ ecrcu dkY\$Y\g' ov 
vepov «v oTt kcu rY\g erepoug ipevcfovg ov<rY\g ko,i dfxcpoTv ecrou 25 ydp dvrtcrpecperou. y\ cfe A.T ^ev^g' ra,vrY\g ydp dvrt- 
ypevcfvig 6 <rvkkoyi<rfxog. crpe<pofxevY\g evctvriog yiverou <rvkkoyt<rfxog. hfxoiug cfe kol) 

'Ev c% ru fxe<ru <r%r /; a«.Ti oka,g fxev eiva,t ra,g 7tpora,<retg el e^ a,kkv\g <rvqoixta,g kv\cp$eiY\ ro fxe<rov, oTov ro A el 
dfxcporepoig -pevcfeTg &k evcfexerou ' oTctv ya,p ro A tiuvti ru kou ev ru A oku ecp) kcu Ka.ro, t» B KO,rY\yopeTra,t Ttctv- 
B vTtdpxy-) *<& v Z5& 1 ka,@eTv ru fxev erepu 7ta,vrt $a,repu rog' dva,yKY\ ydp rv\v fxev AB 7tpdra,<rtv fxevetv, rv)v $ 
<f vfiev) \,7tdp\et' cfeT c¥ ovru ka,fx(Ba,vetv ra,g 7tpora,<retg 30 eTe^ctv dvrtq-pe<pe<r$cu, u<r$' v\ fxev de) dkY\$Y\g, y) <f de) 
wcj-e ru fxev V7ta,px^ v ru <fe [xy\ v7ta,px^ v ■> etTtep ecrcu <rvk- ^evcfY\g. kcu <rx^o v % y& rota,vrY\ d7tdrv\ y) a,vrY\ ecrt t5J 
koyto-fxog. et «v vru ka,fxfia,vofxeva,t ^pevcfeTg, c$Y\kov ug eva,v- cfta, t» otKeix /xe<rov. ea,v cfe fxvj cftd t» otxet« fxerov yivYf 
riug dva,7ta,ktv e^ovcrt' riro cf dcfvvorov. eVt Tt ^' e>cet- Tctt <rvkkoyt<rfxog, orctv fxev v7to ro A y\ ro fxe<rov, ru 
repa.v icfev Kukvet •^eu<5»j' etvctt, otov et to T ko,i ru A >tott cfs B fxv\cfevi vTta.pXQ, dva,yKY\ ipevcfeTg eTvou dfxcporepog. 
ru B Ttvi V7to.pxot' a,v ya,p ru fxev A xctvTt k.Y\<p$Y t v7tctp-35 kY\7treot yctp evctvriwg y\ ug exovcrtv ctt 7tpord<retg, ei fxek- 
Xov, ru cfe B fxv\cfevi, ipevcfeTg fxev dfxcporepou a,t Ttporo,- ket <rvkkoyt<rfxog e<re<r$a,t' "iru cfe ka,fxfia,vofxevuv dfxcpo- 
<retg, « fxevrot okctt dkk' eTtt rt. kcu dva,7ta,ktv cfe re$ev- repa,t ytvovrau \pev<feTg. oTov et ro fxev A oku ru A VTtda- 
rog th tjepY\rtKM u<ra,vrug. rv\v <f erepov eTvcu 'p/evSvi Kctt %et, to <fe A ^vi^evt Ttt>v B* dvrtcjpocpevruv ydp rovruv 
67torepa,wv ev^e%eTctt. ya,p V7ta,px^t ru A 7rctvTt, >tctt crvkkoyto-fxog r ecrctt Kctt ctt 7tpora,<retg dfxcporepctt •vLeu- 
ru B vTtdpfcet' ectv «v kY\<p$Y\ ru fxev A oku v7ta,pxetv 40 cfeTg. ora,v cfe (xy) y\ v7to ro A to /xecrov, otov ro A, v\ 

2. ru] to B. \\ 3. 7*p corr C. II TrpSroy AB. II 4. h&fylatt — 5. \nrlf%<u om B et pr AC. II 8. re om C. U 16. /3 7 B. II 
29- fc» C. II 33. iY.incoi AB. II 37. l\ om C. R 40. \>%cL ? %<-i BC. 

5. (B7 B. II 17. «n/uK B. II n fir\ vraifwtm om AB. II 23. £7 BC. II 24. M» C. II 35. pt^Xij C II 36. ei^oripwv B. II 
39. t' om C. 



ANAATTIKfiN TSTEPQN A. 81 

fxev AA dkr\$r]g ecrctt, y\ cfe AB •pevt\r\g. y\ fxev yctp AA %tg Ik roov Kct$ok>s, y\ tV e7rctyu)yY\ £k roov Kctrd fxipog' 

dkr\$r\g, ort vk r\v ev tw A to A, y\ <fe A B •p/evo\g, ort, dthvctrov <fe rd Kct$ok\s $eoopr\<ra,i /xr] <$i' e7ra,yu>yr\g, lne\ 
ei y\v dkY\$Y\g, Kotv ro <rvfX7ripa,<rfxa, r\v dkr\$ig' dkk' r\v kcu rd e£ d<pcttpi<reoog keyofxeva, ecrctt &' e7rctyooyr\g yvoo- 
"yzvbog. ptfxct 7rote?v, "on v-Kcipx^ £Ka,crop yivet evta,, kou el [xr\ x^" 

Atd Se rov [xi<rov <rxw*,rog yt\ofxivY\g tij* d7ra,rY\g, 5 ptcrd ecrtv, r, rotovtft eKctcrov. e7rctx$wctt 0% ^ exovrag ctt- 
dfxtporipag [xev &k evfrexerat ipevfreTg eTvcu rdg 7rporct<retg <r$r\<rtv dcfvvctrov. roov ydp ko,$' eKctcrov y\ ct'i<r$r,<rtg' i ydp 
"okctg (orctv yctp r\ ro B vko ro A, K<$ev evbexerttt ru> fxev evMx^ttt ka,(Be?v otvroov rr,v eKi<rr\[xr\V tsre ydp e>c roov ko- 
rrctvrt rcp Se [xr\Mvt v-Kctpx^v, Kct$a,Kep ekix$A x&) rrpore- $ok>s ctvev e7rctyu>yr\g, 'ire &' eTrctyooyr^g ctvev rr\g cti- 
pov), rv\v eripctv <f' eyxoope?, kcu oKoripctv eru%ev. ei yotp <r$r\<reoog. 

70 r kcu rcp A kcu rcp B V7ra,pxet, edv kr\<p$y rCo fxev A 10 'Ecrt Se irag <rvkkoyt<rfxog frtd rptoov opoov, kcu yU.evl4 

VTrdpxew rcp <5e B fxr\ inrctpxeiv, V f^ev AT dAr\$r]g ecrctt, MiKvvvctt Mvafxevog ort vTrapx^ ro A ru> T frtd ro vTrotp- 
v\ tY eripa, -pev^r\g. Trotktv tf ei roo [xev B kr\<p$eir\ ro Y x siv T <? B **' T * T0 tw T, . 8e crepY\rtKog, rr\v [xev erepa,v 
vxa,pxov, rw <Je A [A,r\<}evi, y\ [xev TB dhr\$r\g ecrcu, y\ <^' 7rpora,<rtv exoov ort v7ra,px^ T ' a,Kko d/\Koo, rr\v &' erepav 
erepaj •p/ev$Yig. "ori &x V7ra,px f -i' <pa,vepov w ort a,i [xev dpx&i kou a,i Ke- 

'Ea,v fiev w crepY\rtKog 07 rr\g dra,rr\g <rv/\/\oyiT[xog, 15 yo[xeva,t v7ro$e<retg a,vra,l ei<rt' \a,fiovra, ydp raZra, ovroos 
etprira.t Trore ko,i ha, rtvoov ecra,t v\ d7ra,rr\' edv <fe Kctra,- dva,yK-/\ <>eiKVvva,t, otov ort ro A ru V VTrdpxei foa) t» B, 
<pa,rtKog, ora,v [xev <ftd tk ojWk [xe<rov, d$vva,rov d[x<pori- 7ra,ktv <¥ %rt ro A r$ B &' a,Wov y,e<rov, kcu ort ro B 
pa,g etva,t •p/ev<$e?g' dva,yKr\ ya,p rv\v Y B [xevetv, etTrep ecrcu roo Y u)ra,vroog. KO/ra, fxev vv ^o^a,v <rvWoytCp[xevotg koX 
cv?\koyt<rjxog, K0,$a,7rep ekex$"A >"*' Trporepov. cocre r\ T A /xovov $ta,keKrtKoog 8r,kov ort riro [xovov <TKe7rreov , ei e£ oov 
dei ecra,t •>pev<$r l g' aZrr\ ya,p ecrtv r, dvrtcrpe<po[xevY\. cfxotoog 20 eV<£e%eT<Ai e^o^oTctTwv ytvercu <rvkkoyt<r[xog, oocr' ei kcu 
<$e kcu ei e^ a,kkr\g <rvcroix^g kctfxfictvotro ro fxetrov, oo<r- /xr\ ecrt rt rr\ dkrfieta, roov AB fxecrov, boKe? 8e etvctt, 6 
rrep ekix$^l x&i ^ T»fc <repr\rtKr\g d7ra,rr\g' dva,yKY\ yap frta, tout» <rvkkoyiCpfxevog <rvkkekoytcrctt S~ta,keKrtKoog' irpog 
tv\v [xev A B [xevetv, rr\v ^' A A dvrtcrpe<pe<r$a,t , ko,) y\ h' dk.Y\$eta,v m roov v7ra,pxovroov &e? <TK07re?v. exet <$"' vroog. 
d7ra.rr\ y\ a,vrr\ rr\ irporepov. ora,v cfe fxr) cftd t« oUet^, ectv e7ret$r\ ecrtv ocuto fxev Kctr' ctkkov Kctrr^yope^rcu fxr\ Kctrd 
fxev r\ ro A v-rro ro A, ctvrY\ fxev ecrctt dkY\$r,g, y\ erepa, <Ye 25 <rv[xfiefiY t Kog, — keyoo <fe ro Kctra, <rv[xfiefir\Kog, oTov to kev- 
Tpev$r\g' eyx^pe? yctp ro A 7rketo<rtv V7rctpx^v, k «>c ecrtv kov Tror eKe?vo cpctfxev eivctt ctvSpooxov, &x ofxotoog keyovreg 
V7r' ctkkr\ka,. edv <fe fxr] y\ ro A v7ro ro A, a,vrv\ /xev det KO,t rov a,v$poo7rov kevKOV 6 fxev yctp &x &£pov rt oov kev- 
§r\kov %rt ecrctt -^ev^g (KctrctcpotriKrj ydp ka,fxfiavera,t), kov ecrt, ro fre kevKov, ort <rvfxfie{3r\Ke roo dv$poo7ru> eTvcti 
rr\v cfe B A ev^exsrctt kcu dk"/\$r\ etvctt kcu ^pev^ri' ov/fev kevKui. ecrtv ?v evtct rotaZra, oocre ko,$' ctvra, Kctrr^yope^o-^ctt. 
ydp xookvet ro fxev A rui A fXY\t\ev) vTrapxerv, ro Se A30 ecroo <$y) ro Y rotovrov, ctvro fxev /XY\Kert vTrapx^ a\kkop, 
roo B 7ra,vrt, otov XJpov e7rtcrr\[x^, e7rtcjr\[xr\ Se [xov<rtKr\. icf' rovrop <$e to B irpoorop, Kctt \sk ecrtv a,kko [xeraJQj. Kcti 
ctv /XY,re to A fXY\t\ev) roov A ^Te to A fXY\cfev) rcp B. 7rctktv ro E rcp Z uxrctvroog, Kctt riro rcp B. a,p' Zv r%ro 
(bctvepov \sv ort /xrj ovrog rov fxe<rov vtto ro A Kctt d[X<po- dva,yKr\ crr\vctt, y\ evc\ex^ttt eig a,7retpov ieva,t; ko,i Traktv el 
repctg eyx^pi? ^p£vtfe?g eTvat koa oTroripav ervx^. t« fxev A [xy\c%v Kctrr\yope?rctt ko,$' ctvro, ro fre A rcp 

JIo<rctx^? ftsv ovv Kct) cftd rtvoov eyx^pi? ytve<r$a,t rdg 35 vTrapx^ rrpoorop, fxera^v cfe [XY\c\evt Trporipop, Kctt ro ru> 
Kctrd crvkkoytrfxov dirarag 'iv re ro?g d/xi<roig koa ev ro?g H, kcu riro ru B, apct Kctt riro fcrct<r$ctt dva,yKY\, y\ kcu 
<5i' <*7ro<^e/^ew?, tpctvepov. Ttsr evMxerctt eig ctrretpov ievctt; friacpepei fre v!sro rov Trpo- 

13 §a.vepov <fe Ka,)trt, ei rtg <u<r$r\Tig eKkekot7rev, dvayKr, repov ro<rovrov, ort ro fxiv ecrtv, dpct evMxerctt dp^ctfxevco 

Kcti e7rtqr\[xr\v rtvd eKkekot7rivctt, r\v dhvvctrov ka,@e?v, etTrep d-no to<«t» fXY\cfev) v7ra,pX El ^ipcp dkk' dkko hietvcp, em 
[Xctv$a,vofxev y\ e7rctyooyr\ v\ dTrobefyet. ecrt <$"' y\ fxev dKobet-AOro dvoo eig d-Ketpov iivott, Sctrepov cfe dp^ct/xevov ctTro rotvrts 

1. r<r*« om C. II /S5- C. II t, iAv-2. ^eu^s om C. II 2. &ZAB. II 3. ™\AB. II 7. pb * i:a,n\ C. fl P- *' m'p*v B. II 13. 187 
B. II 18. /37 B. II 25. Sk frip* C. II 36. te om C. II 38. <p«.vep3v] ^Aov C. 

5. £i<riv C. II 6. twv om B, post 7<*p ponit A. II 21. pj om C. II 8k ^ wcu coit C. II 30. o xo <*uto C. II 31. ro] rQtB. II 
32. ts? e to t> C- II 3 7. TpoTlpou CD. II 38. <£p* hU%zT<u om C. II apl^syov C. II 39- <*">" rov toioutou D. 

L 



82 ANAAYTIKON T^TEP^N A. 

ci avto fLev dhhov, sxstvov Ss [XY\cfev xa,TY\yope?Tcu, eTtt to fA,Y\<fevt V7ta,px^, ixetvuo <fe a,hho, olov to Z) fxvfte dito t» 
vlcLtu) o~x.07re7v el svcfexeTcu eig cnreipov ieva,t. eTt ra. [AeTctfcv TtpooTX eiti ro vcrartov (heyoo <$e itpuoTov o clvtq fLev ko,t 
ctp' evM^eTcti a,7tetpa, eTvou uopto-fjJvoov tuiv a,Kpu)v; heyuo $' a,hhov, ko,t s.Ksm c% fJt,v\cfev a,hho). el o\ toajt ecrt, kcu 
oTov el to A tu T v7ta,pxei, fxeo-ov <f' covtoov to B, tov eiti. TY\g d7to<pa,Q-eoog crvjQ-eTcu. Tpi^oog ya,p cfetxvvTcu [Hy\ 
h% B ko,\ tov A erepa,, tovtoov <Y ahha,, a,pa, ko,i toajto, 5 v7tctp%ov. v\ yap uo jxev ro T, to B V7ta,px s ^ 7ta,vTt, uo <^s 
eig a,7tetpov evfrexeT&i ieva,t, v\ do\iva,Tov; ecrt $e t«to ctko- to B, bfrevi to A. tk fxev rotvvv BT, kcu dei t» htepov 
iteiv to,\)to ko,i el cu dTtobetfcetg eig a,7tetpov epxovTcu, ko,i c\ta,crY\f)*a,Tog, dva,yKY\ (Ba.c^C^etv «? dy.eo-a,' Ka,Tv\yopiKov ydp 
el ecrtv dTtobetfyg a,7ta,VTog, »| Ttpog a,hhv\ha, 7tepa,tveTa,i. tkto to cfidcp^fxa,. to &' hepov <$v)hov oti et dhhuo &x v^dp- 

'Ofxotoog $e heyuo kcoi eTtt toov crepvftiKuov o-vhhoyto-fxuov x sL ^poTtpuo, oiov tw A, tSto <fev\o-ei too B 7ta.vTi vTtdp- 
kcu 7tpoTct,o-eu)v, olov et to A y,v\ V7ta,px s ^ too B fJOY\cfevi, y\toi 10 X slv ' h°"-s* 7tdhtv a,hhoo t» A TtpoTepuo %x v7ta,px sl -> exe?vo 
TtpooToo, v\ ecra,t Tt [AeTctfcy ch TtpoTepuo &x V7ta,px s ^ oTov ei $eyo-et tw A 7ta,VTt VTtdpx^- &5 ttet v) eTti to ko,tu) Tcjar- 
To H, o tu) B v7ta,px s i. "n&vTi, ko,i 7ta,htv tovtov eri a,Kku) tcu b&o$, koa v) e7ti to clvu) cjY[0-era.t, xcti ec^a,t ti TtpuoTov, 
7tpoTepup, oiov el to 0, o tw H 7ta,vrt V7ta,px s ^ n&t y&p 4 1 *X V7ta,px £l ' 7tct,htv ei to [xev B TtajVTi tw A, tw &e T 
e7ti tovtuov y\ a,7tetpa, oig V7ta,px^ TtpoTepotg, v\ Iqastau. [xvtSevt, to A tw T «<5ew V7td,px s ^ Ttdhtv t«to ei c^et bet- 

'T.7tt $e twv dvrig-pecpovToov &x bf/,oioog £%£f. ov ydp 15 ^a,t, Sv]hov oti y\ bta, t» clvoo TpoTtov S~etx^o-eTO,t v\ $t& 
eqtv ev To7g KartY\yopov[x,evotg ov TtpooTov KO,TY\yoperta,i v\ tovtx y\ tov TptTov. b [Cev ovv TtpuoTog etpv{ta,i, b $e c^evTs- 
TehevTa,t>s' TtctvTO. ya,p Ttpog 7ta,vTa, to.vty\ ye b/xotoog exet, e'tT pog ^etx^W^^t- ovtuo <? a,v betKVvot, oTov oti to A tw /u,ev 
ecjtv a.7tetpa,Ta,Ka,T o,vtx Ka,Tv\yopov[xeva,, etT OLfxcpoTepd, eqt B 7ta,VTt v7ta,px sl -> T( ? <^ £ T ^ij sl a,va,yKY\ V7ta,px s ^ Tt 
To, a,7topv\$evTa, aTtstpa,' 7tXv\v ei fxv) b/xotoog evbexeTcu dvTt- tw B. kou TtaXtv ei tSto tw T [xy\ V7ta,p^et, a,Kho tw A 
cppecpeiv, dhha, to /u,ev oog o-v[x(Be(BY,Kog, ro cY oog Ka,Tv\yopta,v.2Q i)7tdpx s ^ o t<? T ovx V7tdpx si ' xkovv e7te\ to V7ta,px s ^ 

20 ' Oti fiev w to) fxeTd^y &k ev$exeTO,t a,7tetpa, eTva,t, ei de\ tus dvooTepoo Tcja,Ta,t, cfv\o-eTa,t ko,i to [xy\ V7td,px s ^' o 

SJtt TO KO.T00 K0.1 TO O.VU) lCJ-0,VTO,t 0,1 KO,TY\yopta,l , C^YjhoV. <$£ TptTOg TpOTtOg Y\V ei TO [JieV A TW B 7tO.VTl V7tdpX si -> ro 

heyoo <? avoo [xev ty)v eitt ro K&Qohov [Xcihhov, ko,too Se 3e T [xv\ \)7tdpx s h °^ tt&vti V7ta.px s <- toTuo to A. Ttd- 
ty\v e.7tt to ko,t& /xepog. ei ya,p t» A Kartv\yopov[i.evov kclto, htv <Ye tkto *; frta. toov a,vuo eipv\[xevu)v v\ bfiotoog (feix^wercii. 
t» Z a,7teipa, ra) fxeTa^v, e<p' oov B, <$\hov oti evMxoiT 25 eKetvoog fLev Sv) Tcra.Ta.1, ei <¥ ovtoo, Ttdhtv hY^eTcu to B 
o,v uocre kcu dito tk A e7ti to ko,too erepov hepov Ka,Tv\yo- tw E V7ta,px s ^i u) to T f/,v\ 7ta,vTi V7ta.px s i' **« t«to Tta,- 
pe7oSa,i eig a,7tetpov (7tp\v ya,p eTtt to Z eh$e7v, a.7tetpa. to) htv bfiotoog. e7te\ <Y VTtoKetTcu tcra,o-$a,t ko,\ e7t\ to ko,too, 
fKeTafyv) KO,t d7to t« Z eTti to a.vu) a,7tetpa,, 7tp\v e7t\ to A Sv\hov oti cryo-ercu kcu to T &x v7tdpxov. 
sh$e?v. docr' ei tcwto, d^vvarta,, kcu t« A kcu Z d<$vva,TOV Qa,vepov cV ort kcu edv fxv) fjua. bcfuj S~eiKVvv\Ta,i dhha,7td- 

a,7teipa, eiva,t fxeTaJ^y. ovfre ydp ei Tig heyoi oti to, [xev ecri30 o~cug, otI fLev sk t» TtpuoT* o-x^^og, qts fre Ik tk SzvTep-6 
T&wAB exofteva, dhh.Y\hu)V uocre fM\ eTvcu fxera^y , to, <f \sk v\ TptTt, oti ko,\ vtoo crY\o-eTou' 7te7tepa,o-fxeva,i ya,p eicriv cu 
scrc ha,fie?v, ovcfev $ia,<pepei. o ya.p dv ha,(2oo toov B, ecrcu bcfot, Ta Se 7te7tepa,o-f/,eva, 7te7tepa,rfxevdKtg dva.yKv\ 7te7te- 
itpog to A y\ Ttpog to Z y\ a,7tetpa, to, fxeTcLjry v\ «. d<p' pa,v$a,t TtdvTO,. 

y oy\ TtpuoTov a,7teipa,, etT ev$vg ehe fUY\ ev$vg, \i<fev o K ia,<pe- '"''Ot; fLev Zv e7t\ t55? crepv\o-eoo? , st7tep kcu eitt vi V7ta,p- 

pef 70, ya,p fxe^d toajto, a,7teipa, ecrtv. 35 X slv -> ^citcu, frvihov. oti <T ht eKetvuov, hoytKoog fLev 

21 Qa.vepov he ko,i eiti TY\g crepv\TiKY\g d7to<Je(^eoog oti cty\- Seoopovcriv oocfe <pa,vepov. 

<reTa,i, etTtep eTti t^? KO,TY\yopiKY\g Tcra,Ta,t S7t' dfupoTspa,. 'T,7t\ fLev »v tuov sv too ti scrt xa,TY\yopovfA,evoov b^hov' 22 

scroo ya,p fjt,v) evcfexofievov fj.Yfte e.7t\ to avoo d^to t» vcrd- ei ydp ecrtv bpto-a,o-$a,t r) ei yvoocrov to t/ y\v sTva,t, t& <¥ 
tov eig cntstpov ieva,t (heyoo & vqartov o ccuto fJtkv dhhco a,7tetpa, fjt,v) ecrt heh^e^v, dvdyxv\ 7te7tepa,v$a,t to) s\ too xi 

1. [JiyiSh D. U 7. cl om JS. I! 13. 8 r o A. fl 14. of? v% inrapxsi -D. [1 1(5. tg-iy om A. f! a.mKa,T^spv(A.{yoi? D. II 17. 7ravT* 7*p] 
toJuto, <Y«;p B. II 18. gfr'] ett' D. II 22. y.cti stti to D. II 26. t* D. II 28. to an t* habeat B non liquet. II 29. xuX tou ^ D. II 
34. iSh D. 

1. VTtl AB. II 5. 7 tS $ B. II 6.i8zv\ D. II 9- vperepot B. II 10. vperipu toZ fr D. II Ixwui AB. II 11. £m AB. H 12. lycJ] 
> AB, c^D. II TrpuTm AB. II 13. B] 5 D. II A] A D. II 14 psfoA D. II tm AB. H 16. rj hi t» D. II 17. &«vwi» ABD. II 

18. B] _« D. II 19. aAX' o A. II 20.»% uT*p%it D. f 29. ko> idy] x<2y D. II fetxftroi D. H 33. cZttovto D. II 37- rwy om D. 

/3 * 



ANAATTIKONtfSTEPftNA. 83 

icrt xctTYiyopovfJiem. xct$oKov oe ooos KsyofXEV. ecri yotp ei- creTcu, oTov y\ yevog ov y\ oia,<popa, t» xa,TY\yopHfX£Vti. tolvtcl 
7t£?v o,Ky\$oo; to Kevxov (BcLfrt^etv xcli to fxeya, exe?vo fcyKov <fe oeoetxTcLt oti ix ectcli cxTteipa,, ht' e7ti to xoltoo ovt eiti 
eTva,t, xa,\ 7tdtKtv To £yKov /xsya, eTvcct kcu tov a,v$pco7tov (2a,- to otvco. olov a,v$poo7to; ontovv, t«to X>ooov, tSto <Y shepov 
otXetv. erepov $q £<rt to ovtoo; etirelv kcli to eKeivoog. "ctolv &$e to £wov kolt' dv$poo7tov, tkto b\ Kartd KetAXte, thto 
fxev ydp to KevKcv eTvon <pco %vKov, tots Keyco 'oti co rvfx- 5 oe kclt clKKov eV tw t( ecriv. ty\v fxev yctp ovriotv ot7totra,v 

@efiY\Ke Kevku eTvoli fyjKov lcjlv , dKK' «% cb; to vTtoxeifxe- ecrtv opira,r$ctt ty\v toiclvty\v, tcl o' cLiietpcL ovx ecrt ote^eK- 

~ y /. \. / > \ v # . \ * j //i) v /j -v „„ ~„ , <■/ » v > > \ \ v y > > \ \ / y 

vov tco tyKco to Kevxov e<rt' xcLt yctp «Te Kevxov ov »& oTtep aetv voovvtcl. cocr out eirt to clvoo ovt eTtt tq kcltoo cLTtetpcc' 

Kevxov Tt eyevero %vKov, oocr' ix ecrtv dKK' *j kcltcl rvfxfte- eKetvv\v yap vx ecrtv optra,r$a,t, v\? tol onxetpcL xotTY\yope?TO,i. 
$YiXO$. otclv oe to fcyKov Kevxov eTvcLt <poo, ovx oti erepov cbg fxev ov\ yevv\ dKKv\Koov ovx dvTtxa.TY\yopr\$Y t rera,t' ecron 
ti ecrt Kevxov, exeivco o\ rvfJc(Be{3Yixe £yKco eTvcu, otov otclv 10 ya,p clvto onxep clvto ti. voe fXY t v t« ixotov vt tcov clKKoov 
ToV fxovrtxov Kevxov eTvcLt <pco' tots yclp oTt o cLvQpooirog ifrev, c\v fXY\ xoltcl rvfA.Pe@Y\xo? xcLTYjyopv\$Y\' txclvtcl ya)p 
Kevxog ecrtv, u rvfA$e$Y\xev eTvcct fxovrtxco, Keyco' d.KKa) tclvtcl rvfx$e$Y\xe xcLt xclto, tcov irtcov xa,TY\yope?TcLt. clKKo) 
to %vKov ecr) to vitcxeifxevov , oTrep xa)t eyeveTo, «% erepov <5»I 'cti &$' eU to a.voo cLTtetpa, ecrcLt' exa,crov yctp xartYyopet- 
Tt ov % r o7tep iruKov y\ fcyKcv Tt. et $y) c^et vofA.o$eTY\ra,t, ecrco TcLt o a.v rY\fxa,tvY\ y\ itotov ti y\ ntorov ti v\ Tt tcov toiovtcov 
to ovtco Keyetv xa.TY\yopetv , to e^' exetvco? Yftot [JtYi$a,fjtoos 15 y\ to, ev ty\ ovrta,' toajto, $e 7te7tepcLvra,t, xa,t to, yevv\ tcov 
xa,TY,yope7v , y\ KctTqyopeTv fjtev /jly} d,7tKco?, KotTd rvfJt@efiY\- xa,TY\yopicov 7te7tepa,vTa,t' y\ ya.p Ttotov y\ Ttorov y\ 7tpos Tt y[ 
xog <fe KotTY\yope?v. ecrt <f oog fJtev to KevKov to KctTY\yopov- itotovv y, xctcr%oy y\ Ttov y\ ntoTe. v7toKetTott fre ev Kct$' evos 
fjtevov, cbg 8e to £yKov to ov Ka,TY l yopelra,t. v7toKe[r$co <5») xa,TY\yope?r$a,t , clvtcl 8e clvtcov, orot fxv\ t/ ecrt, fxv\ kcctyi- 
to KO,TY\yopovfJtevov KctTY\yope?r$a,t det, ov Ka,TY\yope?Ta,i, yope?r$a,t. rvfx^e^YKOTO, ya,p ecrt Ttctvra,, dKKa, to, fxev 
d7tKcog, dKKd /jly] kocta rvfjt(2e(2Y\Kog' ktco ydp ott d7to£et- 20 ko,$' clvtcl, t* <fe ko,$' eTepov TpoTtoV toajto, oe 7ta,VTa, 
^etg dTtobetKVvMrtv. cocre y\ ev tco ti ecrtv y\ oti 7totov vj Tto- kcc$' v7toKetfxew Ttvog KccTY\yope?r$cct <pa.fA.ev, to <fe rvf/,(2e- 

<fOV Yl 7tpO? Tl YJ TTOliv Y\ 7TCt(T%0V Y[ TtOV Y\ TtOTe, 0TO,V eV K0,$' (By\K05 iSK elva,i V7tOKetfK,eVOV Tt' \ic\eV yotp TOOV TOtOVTOOV Tt- 

evos KO,TY\yopY$Y\. $efxev eTvcLt, o «% erepov ti ov KeyeTott o K(yera.t, dKK' 

*Eti ta jutev irtotv rY\fxa,tvovTot 07tep htetvo y\ %7tep clvto otKKov kooi a,KK clttcl kcl$ erepov. out' elg to kvoo 
exelvo ti rvjfjtottvet , xct$' ov KotTY\yope?Totf ora, <% y,Y\ ou-25 otpot e\ ko,$' evog «t' elg to ko,tco vTa,p%etv Kex$Y\reTOti. 
rtotv rvifjtotivet, dKKd ko,t clKKov vitoKetfxevov KeyeTctt, ko,$' oov fxev yctp KeyeTctt to, rvfxfie(BY\KOTa,, ora, ev ty\ ov- 
o fXY\ ecrt fxv\Te 07tep hce?vo fXY{te 07tep e.Ke?vo ti, rvfxfie- rtct eKctcrov' tclvtcl %e wc ctTtetpa,. a,voo &e TctvTot Te ko,\ 
P>y\koto,, oTov KctTd t« dv$pco7tov to KevKov. ov yotp ecrtv T* rv/x(3e@Y\K0TOt, dfx<poTepa, vk anteioa,. dvctyKY\ otpa, eTva,i 
6 otv$poo7tog tiTe 07tep KevKov '{ne 07tep KevKov ti. dKKd TJjoov ti « TtpCoTov ti KctTY\yope?Tcti Ka,t tovtov a.KKo, ko,i t»to 
Hrcog' 07tep ydp TJoov ecrtv o a,v$poo7tos. orot cfe fXY\ ovrtotv 30 Tcrotr$a,i , xctt eTvoti Tt o vxeTi «Te xart ctKKov ntpoTepov «Te 
r^fXcLivet , he? xcltcl Tivog vTtcxeifxevov xa,TY\yope?r$oti, xeti :mt' exeivx otKKo ntpoTepov xa,TY\yope?Ta,t. 
fXY\ eTvoti ti Kevxov, o cv% erepov Tt ov Kevxov ecrtv. ta Ef? fxev vv TpoTtog KeyeTcti d7toht^ecog ovTog, eTi <Y 

ydp etb\i %a,tpeToo' TepeTtrfxctTot Te yotp ecri, xctt ei iscriv, ctKKog, n oov 7tpoT£pot cltto, xa,TY\yop£?TcLt, £<rt tovtoov a,7to- 
ovb\v Ttpog tov Koyov £<riv' ctt ydp dTtohi^m mp} tc&> toi- hifys' tov ^' icr\v d7to^et\t<;, «Te QiKTtov exetv t Jyxcop£? 
ovtcov £trtv. 35 7tpog ctvTd t» £$evoti, «t' elbeva.i ctvev dTtohl^eooc;. el c^e 

v Et< el fXY\ ecrt t«to tol»^1 7totoTY\g xdxe?vo tout«, fXY\cfe TcSe hd Toovbe yvooptfxov, Ta.be 8e fXY\ 'trfxev^fXYibe (BsKtiov 
7toioTY\Tog 7toioTY\<;, dbvvcLTCv dvTtxotTY\yop£?r$oti dKK.Y\Kcov exopw npct; otvTd tk elbevcLt, voe to ota, txtoov yvcoptfxov 
VTcog. dKK' dKvfie; fxev evbex^Tcti e'nte?v, dvTixcLTY\yopYira,i e7ticrY\rofxe$cL. el Zv ecri ti eloeva,i ot d7too£tz,£cog a,7tKcog 
o' dKv\$oog ovk evMx^Ta.1. v\ ydp toi cb? ovrta, KotTYtyop^- xoti [xy\ kx tivoov fXY\cf e£ v7to$er£oog, dva,yxv\ tcra,r$a,t Ta,g 

i 

11. t3 £D. II Xevxoy om A. 13. t2 -jTroxe^fvoy l^tt D. II 14. y> hoy.a.rokr^a.1. D. II 21. $ b corr B. II 25. (TtyM&W A. II 
27. /*i't£ ?7r£p lx£(yo om D. II 34. ouSb D. II 36". toijto] Tc'^£ D. 

2. IV'v D. II 5. Troco-w A. I! 8. ^m D. II 9- «vr^o^^cr^ A. II 11. Mh D. II l4. t« alterum oraD, tertium AB. II 18. cV 
^t^v D. II rf alterum om A. H 24. aAAoi? ABD. II «.XXa, t* xxQ' B. II 27- w*^ ^B. II 33. U<u ABD. II 34. w b' 

icrw u,Trofei£is om D. 

^ L2 



84 ANAAYTIKflN X^TEPfiN A. 

X,CLTY\yop{cLg TctV fXETCL$V. El y<tp fXY\ TcjCtVTcU, dXX' ECJIV du TYjyoptCtl E7TI TO CLVOO KCtt TO KCLTCO. OTl (fs tcjcLVTcu, $E$£tK- 

t* XYi(p$£VTog ettclvoo, d-rcLvroov ecjcli d-roSEt^tg ' cocj' £i tcl Tou XoytKoog fxsv 7rpcT£pov, dvctXvTtKoog $£ vvv. 
cc7T£ipct [ay) hfxyipu StEX$stv, cov sqiv d-ToSsi^tg , Tcttrr' yk AsSsiy/xsvoov Se tovtoov <pdvepov oti, eotv Ti to clvto23 

£io~ofxe$cL cft' d7roSet\eoog. el yv fXY\6e (3e\tiov sxof^ev 7rpog 6\)<riv v~rdpxXi-> oiov to A tw te Y kcli too A, fxv\ kcltyj- 
dVTol t» eISevcli, &k ecjcli xSsv E7r{cjcLo~$cu cfi d-ToSst^Eoog 5 yopovfxevv $cLTspK kcltcl $ctTspov, v\ fXYiSctfxoog v\ [xy\ KctTct 

d~rXoog cLXX , e£ U7ro0e<r£t«;<;. txclvtc;, %ti \sk dsi koctou koivov ti vTtctp^et. oTov too l<ro- 

AoytKoog fxev vv hc tcvtoov clv Ttg TXtcjevvete 7rept tov (tkeXeT kcli tu o-kclXy,vS) to Svriv bp$cug \<rcLg e%etv kcltoo 

XeyfievTog, dvocXvTiKoog Ss Stct toovSe <pctvspov o~vvTOfxooTS- Kotvov ti V7roopxei' y\ yctp <r%YifAct ti, v7tctpx^-> "*' ovx 

pOV, %Ti MT £7Tt TO CtVOO Kt' £7T< TO KCtTOO CtTTetpct TCt KCLTY\- Y\ ETSpOV. TttTO (f OVK cLit OVTOOg £%£{. SCJOO yctp TO B KCtS* 
yoptfAEVCL EV$£X£Tctl stvcU SV TCLtg cL7rO$£lKTtKCttg ETXtCJYifXCttg, 10 TO AtwTA V7TCtpX si ' 6~Y\X0V TOIVVV OTl KCLi TO B TW 

nrspt cov y\ (TKE^pig scjtv. y\ /xsv yctp d-roSsifctg e~~i tcov orct r kou tw A KctT ctXXo koivov, kcLksIvo KCt$' ETEpov, oocje 

V7TCtpX sl **$' CLVTCL Tolg 7TpctyfXCt<TtV. KCL$' CtVTCt OE StTTOOg' $V0 OpOOV fXSTcL^V CtTVStpOt CtV EfX7ri7rT0lSV "opOl. CtXX' d6vVCL- 

'oo~cl Te yctp h EKEtvotg evv7rctpx si w tw Ttecjt, kcu otg clvtoo tov. kcltcl fxev Totvvv koivov ti vTrctpx^ ovk cLvctyKY\ cLei 
iv Tui Tt ecytv v7rctpxov<rtv ctvToTg, oTov too cLpiQfjcu to ireptT- to ctvTo 7rXeio<rtv, hrenrep ecjctt ctfxerct ^tctcjYifJcctTct. h fxev- 
tov, o V7rctpx s t fth cLptQfJuT), hvTTctpxti & ctvTcg b cLptQ- 15 toj too ctmoo ysvst kcu sk toov clvtoov cLto/lloov cLva,yKY\ Tovg 
fjtbg h TUi Xoyoo clvtH, kcu 7tclXiv 7rXYjQog y\ to c\tcupsTov opovg sTvcu, stTrsp toov kcl$' clvtcl v7rcLpxovToov scycu TO KOl- 
iv tu Xoyoo t« dpt$fjoov ew7roipx s ^ txtoov &' v$eTepcL h- vov' ov yap y\v ejr clX?\X yevovg etg clXXo foctffivcu tcl $eiK- 

hsXZTCU CLTTStpcL sTvcLl , xQ' OOg TO TTSptTTOV TK cLpSfXOV' 7TCL- VVfXEVCL. 

XlV yctp o\v h TCV TTEpiTTCO CLXXo EtY[, 00 SVV7rY\pX s V VTTCLp- QcLVEpOV $E KCLt 'oTi, OTCLV TO A TW B VTTcLpX^-) e ' 

XOVTt' T6T0 <¥ Et Sqt, TTpOOTOV cLpt$/LLOg EVVTTCLp^Et VTTCLp- 20 fXEV ECJl Ti fX£0~OV , ECJt (feT^CLl OTl TO A TW B V7TclpX si - >t*' 

Xov<rw clvtoo. et oiiv fXY\ hfrsxzTcu cLTretpcL toiclvtcl vTTcLp- q-oix^ tovtov ecjt TctvTct Kcti too~clv$' %<rcL fxercL ecyiv' (U 
fteiv h too ev{, &(f' e7r\ to clvoo ecrcu ctTrstpct. cLXXct fXY\v ydp cLfXsroi 7rpoTcL<rsig croix^, M ~rcL<rcu y\ cli kclSoXov. el 
dvctyKY\ ye -tclvtcl v-TcLpx s w tw TrpooTco, olov too dpt$fxoo 8s fxv\ scjtv, ovketi ecjtv d-ro^ei^tg, dXX' v\ eir) Tct? dpx^S 
ndKsivoig tcv dpt&fxov, oocr' dvTicrpe<povTcL scrcu, dXX' &x ocfog clvty\ icrtv. bfxo{oog Ss kcu el to A tw B /xyj u7rct/3%«, 
w7r£^T£/vovTct. «$£ fXY\v o<tcl h tw Tt ecjiv hvTT ctpx si ■> «<^£ 25 £i fxev ecrtv y\ fxerov v\ -rpoTspov u> &x V7rctpx s h tqw d~ro- 

TCLVTCt CLTTEipcL' H&E ycip CLV EIY\ bpi<rct<r$CLl. COCr' Et TCL fXSV hstfctg , £1 &E fXY\, XK SCJIV, dXX' dpXV K°U c 70lX e ? ct ' T00~CLVT 
HCLTYiyopOVfXEVCL KCL$' CtVTCt ~TCLVTCL XiyETcLl, TCLVTCL (fs fXY\ ECJIV 00~0l OpQl' CLl ydp TOVTOOV -TpOTCLOSig dpX^ ^ Ct7T0- 

tLTrStpcL, {crcUTO CLV TCL £7rt TO CLVOO, OOCTS KCLt ETTt TO KCLTOO. <\s{^SO0g slo~lV. KCU 000~7rsp EVICU dpX^ Sl"~lV dvcL7T0cfsiKT0l , OTl 

E> w <•/ \ \ j ~ y \ ^/ <•/ ' \ v /\ s>\ \ < / /\ f\/ !•/ \ <•/ > v 

i OVTOO, KCU TCL EV TW ^ETCt^U OVO opOOV CLSl ~TE- ECTl TOOE TOOi KCLl V~TcLpX £l TOOS TCOOl, MTOO KCU OTl MK ECTl 

-TSpcLO-fXEVCL. £1 <^£ TKTO , 0V1X0V Y\b\ KCLl TOOV d-TOC^El^EOOV OTl 30 T0<^£ T0&1 &£' V7TCLpX si T0<5g TOOC^l, 000~$' CLl fXEV eTvcl{ Tt, CLl 

dvctyKYi dpx^? te eTvcu, kcli fXYJ -tclvtoov sTvcLt d7ro$£ittv, Ss fxv\ sTvcl{ ti srovTcLi dpx&i 'otclv cfs $e'y\ frsTjrcLt, XYjXTSOV 
%-TEp scpcLfxsv Tivoig Xsystv kclt dpx&S- K y&p sl -"-tv dpx&t, o t» B -rpcoTov KcLTY\yops?TcLi. Ecroo to r, >cctl tout« bfxotoog 

VTS TTCLVT d-TOcfstKTcL »t' eU CLTTEtpOV oloVTS ^)CLc\t(ElV' T0 TO A. >tCU OVTOOg dsi fictMl^OVTl ^S~TOT sjroOTEpOO 7rpoTCLO~tg 
ycLp EtVCLl TOVTOOV 07rOT£por6V \SC%V CtXXo ECJtV Y\ TO EtVCLl fXY\- ifr' VTTcLpXOV XctfxftctVSTCtl T» A SV TOO cfsiKVVVCtl, dXX' dst 
&EV OlCLCTYlfXct CtfXS<r0V KCLl dSlCLipETOV , dXXd -TCLVTCL SiCUpSTcL. 35 TO fXEO~OV -TVKVOVTCU, EOOg d^lCL^pSTCL yEVY\TCLl KCLi SV. S.CJi (V 

too yctp evTog sfx\3cLXXEr$cu %pov, dXX' ov too 7rpoo~XcLfx- sv, otolv cLfxsrov ysvY\TcLi Kctt fxict 7rpoTct<rig d~rXoog y\ dfxe- 
ficLVE~-$cu d-TooEiKWTcu to d-r oc^EtKVv fXEV ov . tiocj' e\ t«t' e\$ o~og. kcli oo<r~TEp h Totg oXXotg y\ dpx^l d~rXw , TOUTO i^' 

CL~T£ip0V h^EX^TCLi ISVcU, EV^EXOIt' dv 6\)0 OpOOV CL7r£tpcL fXE- OV TcLVTO TrcLVTcLXOV , dXX' EV fictOEi fXEV fXVCL, EV Ss fXsXst 

Tctjgj sTvcLt fX£o~cL. dXXoo tovt' dSvvcLTov, £t "tcjcLVTcu cti KcL- Skrig, ctXXo S' h ctXXco , ovToog h <rvXXoyt<rfx<2 to ev 

4 y.r,frh JB. II 5. Igti D. II 6. «.AX' om A. II 11. twv] aZxi\ AB ', om D. II 15. o «pifl^oj om D. II 15. -\h<tip-roi pr D. II 
17. iw7-a.p%-tv B. II 19. otv om AB, post -r-pnru jjonit D. II h om D. II 20. 7-pujros D. II 28. TgcLmo B. II rx xdru) D. tl 
31. T£ om D. II 32. xo,t'] xa,\ ra.g AB. II 34. «fisv D. II sTv*i tou'twv jtzfjfikv D. II 35. foaup-rh A. II 38. a.i-ztpa. ra. juet«,£0 D. 

1. Y.a\ W\, to D. II 8. v% r\ i%L B. II 11. ru om AB. II x*x«vo om pr D. II ih. fi(<-a, B, a^-ca. ra. D. II 16. «..jtc AD. II 
17. ra.] xa.ro. ra) B. II 20. ti] to D. II 27- M» om A. II cctoj oi cpoi D. II 28. x*i— eiVw om B. II 29. x*' i~r.] W xitt. 
pr D. II 30. T*i& B. II i x B. II 33. jQ*a^wv AB. 



ANAATTIKftN T^TEPfiN A. 85 

irporcurig a,fxs<rog, sv cV dTtob^Et^Et xcti e7ticrY\/xy o vovg. ev 7re<5ov, dkkd 7tctpd tolvto, ti) ei %v xa,$okov /x\v fxoikkov 
fx\v w Tolg o^stxTixoTg <rvkkoyio~fxo?g tk v7ta,pxovTog *<Tsv efcoo cCvty\, Ttspt ovTog cY y\ttov TY\g kclto, fxspcg xa,\ EfXTtcts? bofyxv 
TtirtTsi, sv <% To?g <rspY\Ttxo?g , sv$ct fxsv o S~s? V7ta,px^t 'ipevSvj, xeipuv dv s'iv\ *j xct$bkcv TY\g kcltcI /xepog. 

i$ev TOVTOV E^OO TtlTtTSl, OIOV El TO A TU B frtO, T» r fXY\. 'H 7tpOOT0V fXEV tf<5ev fxoikkcv eiti t« xa.Sokx *J TK XOjTO* 

el ydp tu fxev B itctvri to Y, too <Je Y fXYifrevi to A, Ttct- 5 fxspog artspcg kbyog scriv. eI yctp to o\j<t\v bp$a,?g vTtcxpx^ 
ktv ctv frey oti tu Y to A x&evt v7ta,px^-> f^e<rov Xyi-kteov /xy\ *j l<ro<rxek\g dkk' *j Tpiyoovov, b elcfoog %Tt t<rorxek\g *jr- 
t« A x<x\ Y, xcu VToog dsi 7topev<reTctt. sa,v $e <5e*j Ssl^cu tov oibsv *j ccvto y\ o slboog ort Tpiyoovov. okoogTs, sl fxsv fXY\ 
oti to A tw E &x V7ta,pxu tw to r tw fxsv A 7ta,VTi cvTog *j rpiyoovov sTta, freixwrtv, ix dv etY\ d,Tto$etfctg, el $e 
intctpx^tv, tw $\ E fxv\frev\ *j jxy\ ita,vTt, t« E ibeitcT efcoo ovTog, b slfroog sxctqov *j exctcrov V7tctpxei /xcXkkov oTfrev. el <$*) 
7tE<rEiT0,t' tSto cY scrtv u ov <5e? v7tctpx^iv. ertt Ss t« T^iTK 10 to Tpiyoovov eTtt Ttksov scrt, xcu o ctvrog koyog, xcti /xy\ xct$' 
TpoTtov, cvte d<p' ov $e? ovTe o SeT crepY\<rcu iSeTtcT efyo ofxoovvfu<xv to Tptycovov, xcu vTtapx^ Tta,VTt Tptyoovoo to Svo, 
(3a,SteTTa,t. ix a,v to Tptyoovov *j l<ro<rxekeg, d,Kka, to trorxeXeg *j Tptyoovov, 

24 Ov<rv\g $' a,7tcSet^Eoog TY\g fxev xa,QoXov TY\g $s xato, ex°i Tota,vTa,g Ta,g yoovt<xg. oocye c xadoXov elSoog fxa,Kkov 

fxepog, xa,\ TY\g fxev xa,TY\yoptxY l g TY\g 8\ cj-£pY\TtXY\g , oifX(pi- oTSev y\ V7ta,pxzi *i b to xo,to) fxepog. fteXTtoov a,pa, *j xaho- 
<rfiYiTe?Ta,t TtoTepa, (SekTtoov oog &' a,vToog xa,\ itept TY\g d,7to- 15 kov TY\g xa,Td fxipog. eti sl fxkv e'tY\ Ttg koycg etg xa,i fxn 
$etxwva,i kEycfXEVY\g xa,\ TY\g stg to dSvva,Tov dyov<TY\g d^to- bfxoowfxta, to xa,$ckov, s'tY\ dv ov$\v y\ttov svtoov toov xarta, 
$et£eoog. TtpooTov fxev w STttcxer^oofxeSa, Ttept 1% xa.Cokov fxspcg, dkkd xa,\ fxakkov, o<rco to, d(pQa,pTa, sv sxstvoig 
xa,t TY\g xo,to, fxepog' $Yjkoo<ra,vTsg $\ tovto, xa,\ 7tsp\ TY\g lcji, t<* Se xartd fxepog cp$a,pTd fxdkkov. eti te ovcfsfxta, 
$stxvvva,t ksyofXE\Y\g xa,\ TY\g slg to dcfvva,Tov etTttofxsv. dvdyxv\ v7toka,fx@a,vetv tj sTva,t t«to 7ta,pd toajto,, oti sv 8y\- 

Ao^ete fxev w to-x & v 7 i°~tv obfo <rxo7tov<rtv y\ xo,to, 20 kot, &$\v /x&kkov *j S7t\ toov dkkoov, o<ra, [xy\ ti <rY\fxa,tVEi 
fxspog sTvau (3skTtoov. el ya,p xa,$' y\v fxcokkov e7ttcja,fxe$a, dkk' *j Ttotov *j Ttpog ti *j Ttotetv. e't <5e dpa,, &x °1 d7tocfst- 
dTtbds&tv (3skTtoov dTto^st^tg (o,vty\ ya,p dpsTY\ d7to$st%soog), fyg dhut, dkk' b dxovoov. 

fxakkov cY S7ttc7ct[xs$a, sxtxcjov, oto,v o,vto sifroofxsv xa,$' FjTI st y\ dTtobetfyg fxev ecri <rvkkoyt<rfxog cfetxTtxog cu- 

OjVTq *j otclv xOjT dkko, oTov tov fxovrtxov K.opt<rxov, oTtxv Tto,g xa,i rS c\ta, ti, to xa,$okov cf' cuTiooTepov oo yap xatf 
oTi b K.opi<rxog fxovctxcg *j oT<*y oti oov$poo7tog fxov<rtxog' 25 o,vto vrtaupx^ ti> tvtc o,vto ojvtoo cutiov to &s xa,$okov 
b/xotoog 8e xa,\ e7t\ toov aXkooV v\ &e xa,$ok^ oti a,kko, &x TtpooToV 0,'itiov dpa, to xa,$okov. oocre xa,\ *j dTtcftetfy.g /SeX- 
oti a,vTo TeTu^Jcev e7tic\eixw<riv, ctcv oti to 'trocxekeg &x ^ 71 tiooV fxoikkov ya,p t« oiItiov xcu t« frta, Tt ectiv. eti fxsxpi 
l<rc<rxsk\g dkk' oti Tpiyoovov, v\ c\\ xarta, fxspog oti oovtq' el tovtov "Cy\TtifXEV to c\ta, t(, xou tcts o'tbfxe$a, e'tc\eva,i, ot<xv 
8'y] fiekTtoov fxev *j xa,$' o,vto, toioovtyi cY y\ xooto, /xepog TY\g fxv\ v\ oti ti dkko tovto y\ ytvbfxevov *j ov' Tskog yoop xcu 
x,<t$bkov fxcXkkov, xcu fiekTtoov a,v *j xxtco fxepog dTtobetfcig 30 Ttepctg to eV^ctTov *j<5*j ovToog ecriv. oTov Ttvog evexa, v\k$ev; 
siy\. eTi et to fxev xa,$okov fxv\ sqt ti 7ta,pa, to, xa,$' exa,<ra,, %7toog Xct/3*; Tdpyvpiov, t«to <^', "cTtoog dTtoboo o oocpetke, t»to 
y\ o a.TtooeiQ.g oo^OjV efXTtoiet etva,t ti t«to xa,u o a,7tooetx- 6, oTtoog fxv\ a,otxY\<rY\' xcu tToog tovTeg, oto,v fxv\xeTt oi 
w<ri, xai Ttva, <pv<rtv v7ta,px £ w & to?? ovcrt t<xvty\v, oTov a,kko fXY\<y' dkkov ■ evexot, , hd tovto cog Tekog (poofxev ek- 
Tptyoovov 7ta.pa, to, tivo, xa,t tr^wetTos 7ta,pa, to, Tiva, xa,t $eiv xa,\ eTva,t xa,\ yive<r$cu, xcu tots elfrevcu fxctktqa, hd ti 
dpt$fXov Ttctpa, Tcvg Ttva,g dpi$fxovg, (SekTioov c¥ y\ 7tep\ ov-35 Y\k$ev. st Sv} bfxoioog e%ei e7Ti 7ta,<roov toov aitioov xa,\ toov cha, 
tog *] fXY\ ovTcg xa,\ h' v\v fxv\ d7ta,TY\$Y\<rETa,i *j fo' v\v, scjt t/, e7rl b\ toov o<ra, cutia ovroog oog ov evexa, cvToog f<rfxev 
&' *j fxev xa,$okov toio,vty\ (Ttpoicvreg ya.p beixwovo-tv , oo<ntep fxoiktcrct, xcu e7t\ toov kkkoov dpa, totb fxooktcra, 'i<r/xev, ortxv 
Ttept t« dva, koyov, otov cti o dv *; ti toiovtov ecrcu dva, wvfittTi V7ta,px^ tovto oti a,kko. oTctv fxsv w ytvoo<rxcofxev 
koyov, o ovts ypctfXfXY\ ovt dpt$[xog ovts crspsov ovt hti- oti TeTTctp<rtv ctt efcoo 'i<rctt, %ti l<ro<rxekeg, eti ksntsTcti otcb 

4. cvSh D. II pt] pii ? D. II 5. t|] to AB et pr D. II tJ] tSi AB. II t£] xo B. II w8ev\ D. II n] t&t B. II 21. /ScXt&w 
0L7tcfcifys. ti D. II pd\w D. II 22. a,Tt'oh^ii om D. II onrofeifc @£\tiuy D. II 2.3. ifruipEv A. II 26 et 28. y] ti AB. II 38. % om D. 

3. r\ om A. II k. ouflev D. II 5. U7T*p%£iv AB. II '% y,] el D. II 8. &\ ij XTrofcifrg AB. II 10. ttXeioy D. II 11. OWp%oy D. II 
h\h D. II 12. I W.] cnj W. B. II 13. £*% ei o D. II 14. to om BD. II 15. eU om AB. II 16. M r oly AB. II ouQto D. II 20. ovSb 
D. II oictD. II 21. % primum om A. II 23. ei om A. II 24. to om D. II 29. tout" D. II 31. to ocpyjptoY D. II xTtoc^S ixpethui u D. 
et u etiam A corr. II 34. $& toJtiti D. II 35. rwi alterum om D. II 36. m\ u<ritep AD. II 38. y.h om A. 



86 ANAATTIKftN T^TEPON A. 

71 70 lcTOCKEKsg , 071 7pty0OV0V, KCU 70V70, 071 (TXAf^OL EV- BTA 071 TO A TW E V7rapx £l i "h $£ ^ct twv ZH 0T< 

$vypotfXfxov. et 8e tSto fxv,Ke7t $tc7i clKKo, tote fxoLkicroL to A tw E. b/xotoog 8e «%« to ot: to A t<2 A vTrotpx^ 
tcrfxev. kcli kcl$oKov $e tot£* 77 kcl$oKov ctpot fiekrtoov. e7i KOtt to A tw E. to <^' oti 70 A tw A 7rpo7epov kcli yvoo- 
o<roo ctv fxoiKKov Kctrot fxipog v\, eU 7x ATteipaij £fX7ri7r7Ei, v) pifxoo^spov r\ otj to A tw E' $iol yctp 7ov7ov eke?vo d^ro- 
8e kcl$oKov stg 70 dTrKovv koli to TTEpcLg. scjt $\ r\ fxev 5 &eikvv7cu, TrtcjorEpcv <5e to <ft' cu. kcu y) <5iot, twv eKcl7- 

CLTTEtpcL, &K £7TlcrV\7Ct, V\ <5e 7rE7rEpcLV7CLl, £7ricrY\7ct. Y\ CtpcL KOt- 70VOOV OtpcL d7rO^£^tg fi£K7lOOV 700V OtKKoOV 700V CLV700V VTTCLp- 
QoKX, fXctKKoV £7riqY\7cL V\ Vj KOtrd [xipog. d7rC<$EiK7cL CtpOO %flV700V. d/X(p07£pctt [XEV «V <flOL 7£ %poOV 7piOOV KCU 7Tp070L- 

[xcLKKov 7a) kol$oKov. 7oov <Y a,7rofreiK7oov /xclKKov fxaKKov <reoov <%o SeiKvvv^ou, dKK' v\ fxh eTvoli 71 KcLfxfictvEt, v\ 8s 
dTrobefyig' c%fxot yotp fxcLkXov 700 Trpog 7i. @EK7toov ctpct v\ kcu eTvcu kcu [xv\ eTvcu 7i' Stot ttKsiovoov ctpct, oocrs XEipoov. 

KCt^oKX, ETTEiTrEp KCLl fXOtKXoV dTTO^El^ig. £71 OLipE70O7SpcL KCtff 10 Et< E7r£l<fv\ $£$'£IK70U 071 dc\lVCL70V dfX(p07SpOOV OV<TO0V 

Y\V 70V70 KCti dkKo V\ KCL$' V\V TtfTO [XOVOV ol$SV <fl 7V\V erspY\7lK00V 700V 7rp07CLOS0OV yEVE<r$OLi <rvkkoyt<rfXOV ', dkkct T*]V 
KCL$ck0V £%00V oT&S KOU 70 KCt700 fXSpog , 0V70g <$E 70 KOL$0- fXEV &£? 70lCtV7Y\V eTvcLI, 7V\V (f 071 VTTCtpXEt, £71 TTpog 70V700 

kov »>c oTfrsv. oocre kolv V70og otlpe7oo7epa, eiv\. e7L (fs oo$e. $e? to<Js XctfisTv. 7ctg fxsv yctp Ka,7Y,yoptKctg ctv^ctvofxsvv,g t*;s 
to yctp KOt$o\ov fxotkkov (fsiKVvvcu ecr\ 70 frtd fxecrov $ei- dTro&eCfceoog dvctyKcttov ytve<r$cti TrXstovg, 7ctg &s <r£pv,7iKctg 
Kwvoti eyyv7epoo ov7og t^? dp%v\g. eyyv7ot7ui 8e to ctfxe- 15 ct^uvctTov TrXetovg elvott fxtotg ev ot7rctv7i <rvKkoyt<rfxov. ecroo 
<rov' t»to (Y dpx*l' e* w V ^ dpXAS ^ j"-*) &, <^PX^ l^? fxv^evt vTrctpx^v to A e(p' ocroov to B, 7u h T vTrctp- 
v) [XcLWov e^ dpx%S ?%$ v\77ov dKpt^ecrepot dTro^et^tg. ecri %ov ircwri to B. dv ^Vj hv\ ttclXiv otv^etv dfxcporepctg 7otg 
8e 7ototv7v\ v) KctSoXov fxolkXov' Kpet77oov o\p ctv eiv\ v) kcl- 7rpo7cL<rstg , fxs<rov £fx(3\v\7£OV. tk fXEV AB E<roo 70 A, t« <5le 

60XOV. 0T0V £1 £$£1 dTTO^Elhxt. 70 A KOVtd T« A" fXETOL TA B Y 70 E. TO fXEV $y) E (pCLVEpOV 071 KCt7Y\yoptKOV , 70 $£ A 
Ed) OOV BT* dv007EpOO $y) TO B, OOCJS V\ &d 70V70V KCtSoXX 20 T« fXSV B KCt7Y,yopiKOV, TTpog (fs 70 A O0g-CJEpY\7tK0V KSiTCtl. 

fXcLhXov. 70 fxsv ydp A x&vto? tou B, to Se A «<Jevf $st 7oov A 

'AXXrt TWV fXSV EtpYifXEVOOV EVICL KoytKCL £$1' fXCLKlCTCL VTTCLpX^' ytV£7CU «V fXiCL CT£pY,7lKY\ 7rp07ct<rtg V\ 70 AA. 

^e bqkov 07i v) kclSoXov Kvptoo7EpcL, 071 7oov 7rpo7cL<r£oov 7v)v (f otv7og 7po7rog Kctt ETTt 7oov E7spoov <rvWoyi<rfxoov. ds\ yotp 
fxsv 7rpo7spotv sxonsg v t<r[XEv Troog kcli 7y\v vcjspotv kcli f^o/^ev to fxs<rov 7oov KcL7Y\yopiKoov opoov KcL7Y,yoptKov ett d[X(pc7epcL' 
Svvotfxet, oTov ef 7tg oTfrev %7i nr&v 7piyoovov <k)<rtv op$ot?g, 25 tou <fe crepvrxtKov eTrt $ct7epct cjEpvrriKov dvotyKot?ov eTvou, oocrs 
oTfre TToog kou to l<ro<rKe\eg o7t Svo op$ct?g, ^vvotfxsi, Kctt ctv7Y\ fxtot 70tctv7Y\ ytvs7ctt 7rpo7ot<rig, ctt &' cLkkou Kot7v,yo- 
el fxv) oT<fs 70 lo-oo-KsXsg 071 7ptyoovoV 6 <$s 7clv7y\v sxtov piKcti. sl <Yy\ yvooptfxoo7spov &t » <fstKW7cu Kcti 7rtcrc7spov^ 

7Y\V 7rp07CL<rtV 70 KCL$0K0V OV^CLfXOOg oTfrsV, M7S <fvVOt[XEi 0UT' &EIKVV7CLI <f V\ [XEV CJspY\7iKY\ frlcL 7Y\g KCL7Y,yoplKY\g , CLV7Y, <5~£ 

evepyetct. kcl\ v) fxev kcl$oKov voy\7y\, v) <% kcl7cl fxspog elg &t £K£tVY\g ov §EtKW7cLt, 7rpo7£pot kcli yvoopifxoo7spcL ov<rct> 

cLi<r$Y,<riv TeXeuT*. 30 kcli TrtcrorEpcL ^skrioov dv e\v\. e7i el dpx^l <rvXkoytTfxi v\ 

25 r/ 07t /xev ovv v\ kcl$oKov jSeXTiOJV t^? kcl7cl fxepog, 70- KcL$oK)i Trporctctg otfxe<rog, ecri <^' ev fxev rv\ &EtK7iKY\ kcl- 

<rdtV$' VjfX?V £tpY\<r$00' OTJ <f v) <}£IK71KY\ TvV CJEpY,7lKY\g, SV7SV- 7Ct(pCL7lKY\ SV &S 7V\ CJ£pY\7iKY\ d7rO(pCL7lKY\ v) kcl$oKov 7TpO- 

$ev <$y\Kov. tcroo yotp otv7v\ v) dTrohi^tg jSeXTiwv to/V olKKoov 7ct<rtg, v) <Ye KcL7ct(pcL7iKV\ 7Y]g d7ro(pct7tKY,g 7rpo7spct Kctt 
roov cLV70ov V7rotpxov7oov , v) sjr eKcl77ovoov cli7y\/xcl7oov v\ v7ro- yvooptfxoo7£pot' friot yotp 7Y\V KcL7cL(pcL<nv v) drrocpcLcrtg y.oo- 
$s<rsoov v\ 7rpo7ot<rEoov. £t yctp yvooptfxot hfxotoog, to $a.77cv 3$ pifxog , kcli 7rpo7spot v) KovrctcpcLo-ig , ooo-rrsp kcli to eIvcli 

yVOOVCLl (tiCL TH700V VTTCLp^El' T»TO ^' Ottp£7007£pOV. Koyog <Je TOU fXYj eTvctt' OOCje jSeXTiWV V\ dpxn T*J? (}£tK7lKY)g v) 7Y\g 

7Y\g 7rpo7cL<rsoog , ort fisK7toov v) e^ eKcL77ovoov, kol$oKov <fs' crspv\7tKY\g' v) ^e fisKrtoo-tv dpx&?g xpoofxsvY\ $sK7toov. srt 
el yotp b/xoioog stv\ to yvooptfxct eTvoli tc* fXE<rot, 7cl <5e Trpo- dpx^^EcjipcL' kvsv yotp 7r\g <j£tKVvov<rY\g ovk lcrtv v) crs- 

TEpCL yV0OptfX0O7£pcL> ECTOO v) [XSV fricL [X£<TO0V dTrofreifyg 700V pV\7tKY\. 

1. to omD. I! 2. rcrs omD. II 4. t* omD. II 6. im^Toi tx a,7rchi>iTa, f\ D. II 8. twv a.nofcty.Tuv h\ D. II pZWov alterum om 
ABD. II 10. xx\ om AB. II ^XXov i\ imtsifcAB. II Jfo] ht elAB. II 17. iiriiei^k ka- Ui D. H 18. Zp' om ABD. II 19- &? B. II 
20. Sr] «V x D. II $] el AB. II 23. hi t5c— 24 ph] wl-^v 7* P D. II 25. Mo D. II 33. IV*' D. II 37. M] cfc D. II 39- ™»] t?j AB. 

2. cpotws — 3. t£ E] V7rdpx£i D. II V7rxp%si — 3. tw A om A. II 11. to/v omJ5. II 16. y.y8sn D. II 17- &j] M AB. li 20. ph 
om D. II wi om D. II 21. ejfisvl D. II 24, II Twr^h x*Tjj«yoptxa/y D. II 27. »] codices o. II 38. n? et ij om D. 



ANAATTIKS2N T^TEPQN A. 87 

26 'Ette) <$"' y) KctTY\yoptKY[ ry$ cjepY[TtKY[g*$ekTtcov, ovikov toov fxv\$' erepctt Ik toov errepcov. tktov 8e <rv[fxeTov, otav etg 

IbTi kou Tys elg to dchvctTov dyov<TY,g. freT cf eiMvau Ttg v) t<x dv<X7ro$etKT<x ek$v[' fre? yctp ojvtcu ev too <xvtoo yevet et- 

frtctcpcpd covtoov. ecjco o\ to A fXYjO^evt vTrctpxov ra B, tu vcu ToTg d7rocfecfetyfxevotg. <TY[fxeTov oe xcti tcvtov, otolv Tol 

oe T to B TrctvTt' dvctyKVj oyj tw V fxv[^evi vir&pxjuv to A. t\etKWfxevct t\t clvtoov ev tclvtco yevet uxrt kol\ <rvyyevY[. 

vtco fA.lv Zv kvjCpSevToov ctetKTtKY, v) cjepvjrtKY, dv etv, d7rocfeify<; 5 Jlketovg cY d7ro$e'tfcetg etvctt tk ctvri eyxoopeT ov fxovov29 

oti to A tco T &% vTr&pxjei. v) tY elg to dchvctTov cocY Ik ty\<; o,vty\<; crvcjotx^ctg kctfx(2ctvovri fxv) to <ruve%e? fxe<rcv, 

%xei. el $£ot $e?jrcu xm to A too B ix VTt<%p%ei, kvjKTeov oTov toov AB to r kcu A kol\ Z, dkkd kcu e'£ errepctg. oTov 

VTtctpxeiv, kcu to B tw T, oocje crvfxficttvet to A tw Y ecjco to A fxeTctfictkketv, to cY e<p' Z A KtveT<r$ctt, to cYe~B 

VTTixpxeiv. T6T0 cY ecjco yvcopifxov xcti ofxokoyov/xevov oti Y[<>e<r$<xi, xcti Trctktv to H v)pefxiXe<r$<xt. dkv\$eg Zv kcu to A 

do\ivctTov. yk <xp<x olov T£ to A too B vTrctpx^tv. el «v to 10 t« B K<xi to A tS A KctTYiyopeTv' o ydp Yj&ofxevog KtveTrou 

B tw r ofxokoyeTrou vTrctpx^v, to A tw B <*<$uv<*tov vTrctp- xcti to Ktvovfxevov fxeTctfioLkXet. 7rctktv to A tk H kcu to H 

Xjnv. ot fxev ovv cpot ofxotcog tolttovt<xi, frtctcpepei cYe to tov B d/\Y,$eg xctTYiyopeTv itcXg y<xp o Y^ofxevog Y\pefxtCp<xi 

07C0Tep<x dv y yvcoptfxooTepct y\ 7xpoTx<rtg y) xjepYji hkyi , TroTepov kcu o YipefxtCpfxevog fxeT<x(3<xKket. oocje c\t errepoov fxe<roov kcu 

OTl TO A TW B K% V7r<Xp%et Y, "oTt TO A TOO F. OTCtV fx\v &K Ik TY\g <XVTY\g <TVCJOfX}<Xg <TvWoyt<TfXog. OV fXY,V OOCje fXY\- 

w y\ to crvfX7rep<x<rfx<x yvooptfxooTepov oti »>c ecjtv, v) etg to 15 cfeTepov K&nd fXY^eTepov \eye<r$<xt toov fxeroov' dv<xyKY\ yctp 
dcfvvctTOv ytveTctt dTroBet^tg, ot<xv cY y\ ev too vvKhoyto-fxoo, too ojvtoo Ttvt ctfxcpoo VTrdpx^' e7rt<TKe^pct<r$ctt cYe Kctt otot, 
y\ d7rohtKTiKY\. (pvtrei cYe TrpoTepct y) oti to A.to B t| otj toov ctKhoov <rxY\fxctToov, ctrctx^ evMx^ct^ i"» ctvri yeve<r$ctt 
to A too r. TrpoTepct yctp eqt tk <rvfX7repct<rfxctTog, e^ oov trvKkoytrfxov. 

to <TvfX7rep<x<rfxct' eqt Se to fxev A tw T jxy) VTrdpx^ TvfX- Tov cY d7ro tvx^ ovk ecjtv e7rttTY\fXY\ oi' ct7ro<Jgigew?.30 

irepcto-fxct, to cYe A too B e\\ » to <TVfX7repct<rfxct. ov yctp 20 «T£ ydp oog dvctyKcuov ov$' oog e7rt to 7roXv to et7ro TvXVS 
el <rvfxfi<xtvet dvcttpeT<r$ctt Tt, tvto <rvfX7repct<rfxd ecjtv, hceTvct ecjtv, dKkct to Trctpd TctvTct ytvofxevov v) cY dTrobetQg $ct- 
cYe e£ oov. dkkct to /xev e£ ov, <rvkkoyt<rfxog ecjtv, o dv Tepov tovtoov. 7r<xg yctp <rvkkoyt<rfxog v\ n dvctyKcttoov tj 
ovToog exv ucje y\ okov Trpog fxepog v\ fxepog Trpog okov e%eiv, cftd toov oog e.7rt to 7roXu 7rpoTct<reoov' Kctt el fxev ctt TrpoTct- 
cu cYe to AT Kctt AB 7rpoTct<retg &k exovrtv ovtoo Trpog tretg dvctyKcuctt , kou to <rvfX7repct<rfxct dvctyKcuov, el cY us 
dkkY\kctg. et ovv y) ex yvooptfxooTepoov Kctt TrpoTepoov xpetTToov,25 eTrt to Trokv, xctt to <rvfX7repct<rfxct toiovtqv. oocj' et to d^ro 
el<r\ cY dfxcpoTepctt ex t« /xy) eTvctt ti Trtcjctt, dkk' y) /xev tvxW ^$' oog eTrt to Trokv fXYjr' dvctyxcuov, wt dv eiv\ 
ht TrpoTepov y) cY e£ vcjepov, fiekrtoov d7rkoog dv e'iY\ ty,s ctvvt dTrcbeifyg. 

eU to dbvvctTov y\ cjepY\TtxY\ dTrobefet