li
®I|c ^. ^. pll pfamrg
U /^
^orll] Cctroltna ^tate College
OH307
BaiaB—iiii>ii*iH'Ma£
Date
Due
4F'26
20 F '2<^
^ ^
60ecS2
V
244pf'5J
■" * ^ \jt
J
M"/w 1
;'" ' ' ^ '...
mS"
"^■^^
1
1 , i
! _
s
L. B. Cat. No. 1 137
John James Audubon -
1785-1851
From a portrait in oil by George P. A. Healy, London, 1838.
Courtesy of Mr. Ruthven Dcane.
BIOLOGY
IN AMERICA
R . T. YOUNG
WITH MORE THAN
TWO HUNDRED ILLUSTRATIONS
BOSTON
RICHARD G. BADGER
THE GORHAM PRESS
Copyright, 1922, by Richauu G. Badger
All Rights Reserved
Made in the United States of America
Press of J. J. Little and Ives Company, New York, U. S. A.
• LIBRARY
fl, C. state College
To
THE MEMORY OF
MY MOTHER
11 J 11
PREFACE
To the "man in the street" the biologist, with his "bugs"
or his ' ' germs, ' ' frequently appears as a harmless but equally
useless individual. Thus in an issue of the "New Republic,"
shortly after America's entrance into the world war, a serio-
comic writer in criticizing the action of President Wilson in
appointing a committee on national preparedness from the
National Academy of Sciences says, "I doubt if any other
nation ever responded to the prospect of war with a scheme
of national defense which included a Committee on Zoology
and Animal Morphology."
What excuse then has the biologist for his existence ? What
can he say for the ' ' truth that is in him ' ' ?
When half a century ago the Austrian monk, Gregor
Mendel, was "puttering" over his sweet peas in the garden
of the monastery at Briinn in the Tyrol, the world took small
notice of his work, little realizing that he was laying the
foundation stones of a science which was to place animal and
plant breeding on a scientific basis, and teach us how to build
a better race of man himself. When the English army sur-
geon Ross in India in 1898 was studying a microscopic organ-
ism in the blood of the owl, he could not foresee that his work
would in a few years' time virtually abolish malaria in
Ismailia on the Suez Canal, where in 1902 there were 1548
cases in a population of about 6,000; that it would render
possible the building of the Panama Canal, and convert
Havana into a health resort.
Of what particular practical importance was Harrison's
discovery that a bit of nerve cord transferred from a tadpole
to a drop of frog's lymph would develop nerve fibres there?
Yet Harrison's method of making that discovery has opened
to science an entirely new field in the study of tissue growth,
both benign and malignant, has enabled us to observe the
growth of the cancer cell, and determine some of the con-
ditions of that growth, and may some day lead us to a solu-
tion of the cancer problem.
When a fish embryo is developed in a solution of magnesium
chloride it gives rise to various malformations, most conspicu-
ous of which is the ' ' cyclopean eye. ' ' Of what possible value
to a workaday world is such a discovery? Very little in
' 7
8 Preface
itself. But if the young fish can be distorted into all sorts
of monstrous shapes by chemical treatment, why may not the
monstrosities observed in man, some of which are not neces-
sarily fatal, but which entail on their victims sorrow and suf-
fering, be due to a similar cause? And may not the discovery
of the cause lead to its control?
But the primary aim of science is not utilitarianism. Were
this so, it would still be wearing rompers instead of seven
league boots. It is a commonplace to say that the aim of
science is truth, regardless of what practical value such truth
may have. But the "man in the street" frequeiitly fails to
realize the connection between purpose and accomplishment
in science. Perha})S never has this relation been made more
clear than in the recent war. The German Government, recog-
nizing the value of science for its own sake, encouraged it
with every means in its power, and the German university
became a Mecca for scientific students throughout the world.
England, on the contrary, was more interested in develop-
ing good cricketers and diplomatists than in training scien-
tists, and when war came upon her "like a thief in the night"
she found herself under a well-nigh fatal handicap.
It was farseeing statesmanship which led President Wilson
to call for a council of national defense from the National
Academy of Sciences on America's entrance into the war. It
would have been still farther sighted had this council been
established long years ago.
American biology, with the lusty vigor of youth, has ad-
vanced by leaps and bounds in recent years; and today a
wonderful future opens before it. From the days when the
early naturalists went hand in hand wuth the pioneer into the
depths of our great forests, crossed the boundless prairie and
pierced the trackless labyrinth of mountain peak and canyon,
to the present, w'hen the names of American biologists stand
throughout the world as synonyms of biological progress, their
record is one of which our nation and the world may well be
proud.
It is in the hope of recording, in some small measure, the
story of this progress that this book is written. Most of the
facts herein recorded have already appeared in the many
books dealing with the biological problems of the last few
years, but nowhere, so far as I know, has a brief, compre-
hensive and simple story of the work of American biologists
been told. It is in the hope of presenting such a story that
this work has been undertaken. To give a comprehensive as
well as simple account of so complex a field as biology is,
however, far from easy, A full account of so wide a field
would require many volumes, but I shall attempt to touch only
Preface 9
upon th3 more salient points. The avoidance of technical
terms is in many cases impossible, but I have endeavored
to reduce them to a minimum.
It is of course impossible in such a story to avoid referring
to the work of biologists in other lands. Nor is it desirable.
Science is not bounded by political and racial lines, and the
work of American biologists can only be appreciated in the
light of what their colleagues in other lands have been doing.
The book is, however, a record of American biology, so that
reference to the work of other biologists will be only incidental
to the main trend of the story.
A zoologist should perhaps apologize for the title, since
the main emphasis will naturally fall on that branch of
biology with which he is most familiar. The great principles
of life, however, apply equally to plants and animals, and
even though the examples which illustrate these principles
have been drawn mainly from the animal world, nevertheless
the title will be justified if the discoveries recorded are those
which in the main illustrate the laws which govern plants
aiid animals alike.
The writer is indebted to numerous sources
for the illustrations and quotations found in this
book. Due acknowledgment for each is made
in coimection with it.
To his wife, Ellen F. P. Young, and sister,
IMary Farrar, grateful acknowledgment is due
for assistance with the proof and index.
CONTENTS
CHAPTER PAGE
I. Work of Early Biologists. Explorers and Travel-
ers, Collectors, Field Naturalists and Museum
Men. Early Surveys, State and National ... 19
II. Biological Institutions in America. Universities and
Colleges, Museums, Botanical and Zoological Gar-
dens, Biological Stations and Endowed Labora-
tories 47
III. Descriptive Biology. Development of Plants and
Animals; of Sex and Sexual Reproduction, and Al-
teration OF Generations. The Path of Vertebrate
Evolution 88
IV. The Story of the Rocks. Contribution of Paleon-
tology TO Evolution. Rise and Fall of the Faunas
of the Past 116
V. Geographical Distribution of Plants and Animals.
Relation Between Organism and Environment.
Methods of, and Barriers to the Spread of Plants
and Animals. Plant and Animal Societies. Life
Zones op North America 151
VI. Experimental Biology. Preformation in a New
Dress, Organization of the Egg, Regeneration and
Grafting, Plastic Surgery, Tissue Culture, the
Problem of Death, and Immortality of the Cell . 188
VII. Experimental Biology Continued. The Role of the
Chromosomes in Inheritance. Inheritance of Sex
and Sex-Linked Characters 202
VIII. Experimental Biology Continued. Influence of En-
vironment IN Determining the Development of Or-
ganisms. Effects of Temperature, Light, Moisture,
Chemicals, and Food upon the Form of Animals and
Plants. The Control of Sex 219
IX. Experimental Biology Continued. The Factors of
Evolution: Natural Selection, Mutation, Ortho-
genesis, Isolation, Inheritance of Acquired Char-
acters. Experimental Modification of the Germ
Cells 234
X. Experimental Biology Continued. Mendelism and
the Multiple Factor Hypothesis. Human Inherit-
ance and Eugenics 257
XI. Experimental Biology Continued. Mechanism Versus
Vitalism. Physico - chemistry op Vital Processes,
Metabolism of Animals and Plants 278
11
12 Contents
CHAPTER PAGE
XII. Experimental Biology, Mechanism Versus Vitalism
Continued. Tropisms, Instincts and Intelligence.
Hormones. Artificial Fertilization 301
XIII. Color in Nature. Colors of Flowers and the Inter-
relation OF Flowers and Insects. Colors of
Animals and Their Physico-chemical Causes. The
Theories of Pjiotective Coloration, Warning and
Alluring Colors, Mimicry and Recognition Marks 330
XIV. Aquatic Biology. Oceanography, Life of the Sea and
Its I']nvikonment. Biology of Inland Waters.
Methods of Studying Aquatic Life 349
XV. Economic Biology. Dependence of Man upon Nature.
Ignorance of Nature the Cause of Economic Loss.
Conservation and Increase of Natural Resources . 385
XVI. Biology and Medicine. Microscopic Life and Its Re-
lation to Human Health. The Role of Animals in
Spreading Disease. Animal Experimentation and Its
Contributions to Human Welfare. The New Medi-
cine, Safeguarding the Health of the Nation . . 440
XVII. The Outlook. Some Unsolved Problems of Biology.
Possibilities of Larger Service 478
ILLUSTRATIONS
1 John James Audubon, Frontispieo
e
PAGE
2 Alexander Wilson 21
3 Rafinesque 29
4 Lewis and Clark, Thomas Jefferson, Thomas Nuttall ... 35
5 Louis Agassiz 38
6 James Dwight Dana, Joseph Leidy, Edward Drinker Cope,
Othniel Charles Marsh 41
7 Asa Gray 43
8 Spencer Fullerton Baird 44
9 The Academy of Natural Sciences of Philadelphia .... 53
10 The American Museum of Natural History in New York . 54
11 Blue shark and school of young 55
12 Duck hawk at nest 56
13 Florida swamp 56
14 Woolly rhinoceros, saiga antelope and mammoth .... 57
15 Monarch butterfly 58
16 New sources of aquatic food 60
17 The U. S. National Museum 61
18 The Now York Botanical Gardens 64
19 The laurel bank in the Arnold Arboretum 65
20 The "forest primeval" in the Arnold Arboretum 66
21 Marine Biological Laboratory at Woods Hole, Mass. ... 68
22 View of Woods Hole 69
23 Animal community of a New England wharf 70
24 The Station for Experimental Evolution of the Carnegie In-
stitution 74
25 Desert Botanical Laboratory of the Carnegie Institution . . 75
26 Old shore line of Salton Sea 78
27 Tortugas Laboratory of the Carnegie Institution 82
28 The yacht "Anton Dohrn" of the Carnegie Institution ... 83
29 Types of Protozoa 90
30 Types of Protozoa 91
31 Lower plant life 93
32 Amoeba proteus 94
33 Life cycle of malarial organism 97
34 Phlox, liverwort and moss 99
35 Invertebrate types 102
36 Vertebrate embryos 104
13
14 Illustrations
FACE
37 Head of lamprey, and sucker showing scars made by lamprey 109
38 Lungfish and fossil shark, Cladoselachc 112
39 A trilobite 117
40 A king crab 117
41 Ostracoderms 118
42 Cestracion, Polyterus and Hatteria 121
43 Footprint of a primitive am[)liihi;in 122
44 A stcgoccphalan 123
45 Landscape of the coal-forming period 124
46 Dinosaur tracks 126
47 Brontosaurus 127
48 Stegosaurus 128
49 Triceratops 128
50 Rhamphorhynchus 129
51 Arc'ha'opteryx 131
52 Hesperornis 132
53 Part of feather, showing details 133
54 Tooth of dinosaur and jaw of contemporary mammal . . . 137
55 Opossum 138
56 Spiny ant-eater 139
57 Uintatherium, Coryphodon, and Dromocyon 141
58 Eohippus 143
59 The tarsier 144
60 The saber-toothed tiger 146
61 Excavation of a tar pit at Rancho La Brea, California . . . 148
62 Early days in the tar pools of Southern California .... 149
63 The arctic tern 152
64 A group of lichens 159
65 A glacial pond 160
66 Zoogeographical realms 161
67 Life zones of North America 162
68 Profile of San Francisco Mountain, showing life zones . . . 163
69 An alpine dwarf 164
70 Pika, or Rocky Mountain hare 165
71 Ptarmigan in summer plumage 166
72 Ptarmigan in autumn plumage 166
73 Ptarmigan in winter plumage 167
74 Clarke's crow 167
75 Timber line in the Rocky Mountains 168
76 Polar bears 169
77 Cariboo 169
78 Musk oxen 170
79 Wolverine 170
80 Canadian zone forest in Colorado 171
81 Woodchuck 172
82 Weasel 173
83 Snowshoe rabbit 173
Illustrations 15
PAGE
84 Canadian and transition zone landscape 174
85 Beaver 175
86 Beaver pond 176
87 Cypress swamp 177
88 Cotton rat 178
89 Alligator 179
90 Water moccasin 179
91 Burrowing owl 180
92 Prairie dog 181
93 Prairie dog at burrow 181
94 Horned toad 183
95 Kangaroo rat 183
96 Gila monster 184
97 California big trees 185
98 Mountain beaver 186
99 Beroe 189
100 Organ-forming substances in the egg 190
101 Four-legged tadpoles 195
102 Combination frog 196
103 Reconstruction of wounded soldier's face 198
104 A piece of growing tissue 199
105 Mitosis in a sea urchin's egg, showing chromosomes .... 204
1C6 Diagram of inheritance of size in sweet peas 205
107 Diagram of combinations^ of three pairs of chromosomes . 206
108 Photographs of chromosomes, showing sex chromosomes . . 208
109 Gynandromorph fruit flies 209
110 Diagrams showing distribution of sex chromosomes in ma-
turation 211
111 Fruit flies, showing mutations 212
112 Diagrams showing chromosomes in relation to sex linkage . 213
113 Chromosome map showing distribution of linked characters
in the fruit fly 216
114 Diagrams of chromosomes in the fruit fly showing result of
non-disjunction 217
115 Influence of environment on plants 221
116 Effect of diet on body form in Amblystoma 225
117 Scarlet tanager and bobolink, showing sex differences . . . 226
118 Cyclopean fish 228
119 Human twin monster 229
120 Types of human faces 229
121 A human monster 230
122 Moulted skin and egg case of daphnid 231
123 Diagram showing pure lines in beans 237
124 Hooded rats 238
125 Mutation in (Enothera 239
126 A rumpless fowl 240
127 Diagram showing height variation in man 241
16 Illustrations
PAGE
128 Mutations in the potato beetle 247
129 Deer mouse 250
130 Inheritance of color in the four o'clock 258
131 Inheritance in Andalusian fowl 259
132 Inheritance of ear length in rabbits 260
133 Inheritance in guinea pigs 261
134 Diagrams showing Mendelian inheritance of one, two and
three pairs of characters respectively 262
135 Hornless cattle 267
136 Diagram showing osmosis 279
137 Effect of diet on man 288
138 Effect of diet on dogs 291
139 Pursuit of food by Amoeba 302
140 Compass plants as seen from different positions 307
141 Mimosa or sensitive plant 308
142 Sundew leaf 309
143 Sagging in a stem 310
144 Relative amount of bending in stems due to unequal growth 311
145 Effect of the kinetic drive on a soldier 322
146 Effect of the kinetic drive on the tissues of the body . . . 323
147 Sebright poultry, normal and castrated 326
148 Relation of bee and flower 331
149 Flatfish photographed on different backgrounds 334
150 Protective form and color in animals 335
151 Leaf insect 336
152 Walking stick insects 336
153 Dead leaf butterfly 337
154 Imitation of an orchid by a mantis 338
155 Skunk 339
156 Porkfish 339
157 Mimicry of monarch by viceroy butterfly 340
158 Biuiiblebee mimicked by fly 340
159 Mimicry in butterflies 341
160 Mimicry of leaf cutting ant by tree hopper 341
161 Antelope 343
162 Male and female wood ducks 344
163 Sexual difference in beetles 345
164 Sexual difference in fish 345
165 The "Albatross" 350
166 A radiolarian 352
167 Deep sea fishes on a light background 354
168 Deep sea fishes on a dark background 355
169 Angler fish and Chiasmodus 356
170 Giant squid and tentacle marks 356
171 Portuguese man of war 357
172 Vellela 358
173 Sunfish and crustacean larva 359
Illustrations 17
rAOF
174 Salmon at hn^c of falls 362
175 Leaping salmon 362
176 Sigsbee sounding machine in use on the "Albatro.--.s" . . 364
177 Bigelow water bottle 368
178 Blake deep sea trawl 369
179 Tow-nets in use on the "Albatross" . . 371
ISO Jaws of whalebone whale 373
181 Hensen's net 374
182 Synura 378
183 Gypsy moths and caterpillars on trees 386
184 Trees stripped by gypsy moth caterpillars 386
185 Alfalfa field ruined by mice 387
186 Red-tailed hawks 388
187 Barn owl . 389
188 Skulls disgorged by barn owls 389
189 Meadow mice 394
190 Apple tree girdled by mice 395
191 Cottontail rabbit 397
192 Brown rat 399
193 Gray wolf and pups 401
194 Ground squirrel 401
195 Pocket gopher 402
196 San Jose scale 403
197 Mass of San Jose scales on tree tnmk 404
198 Apples infested with San Jose scale 405
199 Pitiful ladybird beetle 406
200 Screw worm and cattle ticks 408
201 Bamboo grove 410
202 Udo 411
203 Udo stem, blanched 412
204 Tung oil tree . , 413
205 Fruit of tung oil tree 414
206 Pistache trees 415
207 Indian mango 416
208 Date plantation 417
209 Bunch of dates 418
210 Herd of buffalo 419
211 Elk in Yellowstone Park 420
212 Egret colony 421
213 Group of fur bearing animals 423
214 Otter 424
215 Mink 424
216 Seining salmon 428
217 Salmon eggs 429
218 Interior of salmon hatchery 430
219 Developing fish . . . ' 431
220 Seals on Pribilof Islands 433
18 Illustrations
PAGE
221 Glofliidiuia larva 435
222 Dianiorul-back terrapin 437
223 Carroll, Lazcar and Rwd 451
224 War on the mosquito 454
225 Trifhina in mviscle . 462
226 Tapcnvorni of man 463
227 Hookworm 465
228 Hookworm (lisprnsar.v 468
229 Hookworm patient before and after treatment 469
BIOLOGY
IN AMERICA
BIOLOGY IN AMERICA
CHAPTER 1
Work of the early biologists. Explorers and travelers, col-
lectors, field naturalists and museuni men. Early surveys,
state and nationul.
The evolution of human thought parallels that of the indi-
vidual mind. Man sees first the effect and then seeks the
cause. The falling apple pointed the way to the discovery of
the law of gravitation; the amber wand, when rubbed with a
bit of fur, to the discovery of electricity, and the "pebrin"
disease of the silkworm to the modern science of bacteriology.
The story of all science is one of observation of phenomena,
speculation as to their cause, and finally the determination
'6f cause by means of experiment. The recording of phe-
nomena is not however limited to any given sidentific age,
but necessarily goes hand in hand with philosophy and experi-
ment, forming with them the trinity of scientific progress.
It is but imtural, then, that the early history of biology in
'America should be written in the bold characters of stirring
adventure. Across the sea in the first years of the last cen-
tury came adventurous spirits, keen-eyed and lusty hearted,
with the "call of the wild" in their souls. Some of these,
llfte the Scotch peddler Wilson, and the eccentric Audubon
W&re "ne'er do weels" filled wdth the primitive instinct of the
ii'dtead. Others were men of high station in the Old World,
tike Lucieii Bonaparte, nephew of the great imperialist, who
idame to 'this country, like their humbler comrades, impelled
by a spirit of scientific adventure. There were still other
naturalists in the early days in America, like the Bartrams,
Who Were natives of the soil.
'These early biologists were naturally collectors and field
Naturalists, but with the establishment of learneil societies
they were soon joined by museum men, who worked up the
material collected in the field. The interest of these latter,
then as now, was primarily in classification and distribution,
but the writings of the field naturalists are replete with
interesting accounts of the liomes and habits of the animals
10
20 Biology in America
and plants which they collected. Oftentimes collector and
classifier were the same, as with Baird, Coues and many
othei-s.
On tho banks of the Sehnylkill River in Philadelphia stands
an okl stone luansion, over whieh the pleasant ivy clambers,
and in the garden round about, now a city park, are still
growing many of the plants set out there nearly two centuries
ago by John Bartram, who was the first American botanist
of note, and whose garden, laid out in 1728, was the first
botanical garden in America. His old rock wine press is
there still, from which the host provided refreshment for
Washington, Franklin, Hancock, Rittenhouse, Morris and
many others whose names are written large on the pages of
our nation's story; and to his home also came many notables
from abroad, for his reputation for learning and hospitality
was well known. Bartram acted at one time as American
botanist to George III, and corresponded with Linmeus, who
considered him "the greatest natural botanist in the world,''
as well as with other leading European naturalists of his time,
with whom he exchanged many plants for the books which
could only be obtained in Europe. Provided with independ-
ent means, he made extensive journeys through eastern
America, from Lake Ontario to Florida, in search of plants,
accounts of which were published by him, as well as several
minor papers on natural history.
Here was born and died the son, William, a botanist and
ornithologist of note. Like his father, he was an extensive
traveler, and published an account of his travels, as well as
a list of American birds, w^hich was the first extensive work
on American ornithology.
Over the counter of a little store in Louisville, Kentucky,
there occurred in INIareh, 1810, a chance meeting between two
men who have stamped their names in indelible letters on the
pages of American Science. They were Alexander Wilson,
the Scotch weaver, and John James Audubon, the French
artist. In his "Ornithological Biography," Audubon has
given us an interesting account of tiiis meeting and of his
impressions of his co-worker in the field of ornithology. "One
fair morning," writes Audubon, "I was suri)rised by the
sudden entrance into our conntiug-room at Louisville of Mr.
Alexander Wilson, tlie celebrated author of the American
Ornithology, of whose existence I had never until that moment
been apprise<l. This happened in ]\Iarch, 1810. How well
do I remember him as lie tlien walked up to me! His long,
rather hooked nose, the keenness of his eyes, and his promi-
nent cheek-bones, stamped his countenance with a peculiar
character. His dress, too, was of a kind not usually seen in
Early Naturalists 21
that part of the country ; a short coat, trousers, and a waist-
coat of g-rey cloth. Ilis stature was not above middle size.
He had two volumes under his arm, and . . . immediately
proceeded to disclose the object of his visit, which was to
procure subseiiptions for his work. ... It happened that he
lodged in the same house with us, but his retired habits, 1
thought, exhibited either a strong feeling of discontent or a
Alexander Wilson
From a painting by James Craw.
Courtesy of Mr. Ruthven Deanc.
decided melancholy. The Scotch airs which he played sweetly
on his flute made me melancholy, too, aiul I felt for him.
I presented him to my wife and friends, and seeing that he
was all enthusiasm, exerted myself as much as was in my
power to procure for him the specimens which he wanted.
We hunted together, and obtained bii'ds which he had never
seen before; but, reader, I did not subsci'ibe to his work, for,
even at that time, my collection was greater than his. . . .
22 Biology in Amrrica
Some time elapsed. {luii)ig wliicli 1 iicvei- heard of him, or
of his \v()i-k. At lengtli, liaviiig- oceasioii to go to Phihidel-
I)liia, I, immediately after my arrival there, iiuiuired for him,
and paiel him a visit, (but) . . . feeling, as 1 was forced to
do, that my company was not agreeable, I parted from him;
and after that 1 never saw Iiim again. J>iit judge of my
astonishment some time after when, on reading the thirty-
ninth page of the ninth volume of Americcui Orniihologij, 1
found in it the following paragraph:
" ']\Iarcli 28, ]i)10. 1 bade adieu to Louisville, to which
place I liad four letters of reconnnendation, and was taught
to expect much of everything there ; but neither received one
act of civility from those to whom 1 was recommended, one
subserilx-r, nor one new bird; though I delivered my letters,
ransacked the woods repeatedlj^, and visited all the characters
likely to subscribe. Science or literature has not one friend
in this place.' " ^
Alexander Wilson, the "father of American ornithology,"
was born at Paisley, Scotland, on July G, 1766. lie was the
son of a weaver, who, together with liis regular trade, com-
bined farming, distilling and smuggling. Destined by his
parents for the church, his studies in this direction were early
terminated by various vicissitudes in the Wilson family, such
avs the advent of a step-mother and sundry children, and the
young Wilson became a weaver apprentice, from which pur-
suit his raml)ling propensities soon diverted him into the
paths of the peildler and poacher. Indulging himself in a
little fun at the expense of the master weavers during a trade
dispute, he paid i)enance therefor with a brief sojourn in
jail, after which he emigrated to America in 1794. Here he
earned a precarious living as peddler, printer, and school
teacher, the latter profession seeming to have stood as high
in ])ublic esteem then as now, until he nuide the acquaintance
of the younger Bartram and the engraver Lawson, under whose
advice and encouragement he gave himself up to his passion
for natural history and learned to draw the objects of his
search. lie now devoted liimself to the preparation of his
"American Ornithology," in the course of which he roamed
the wilderness of the then West, crossing the Alleghanies,
sailing down the Ohio, sleeping under the stars or in the fron-
tiersman's "shack." In the course of these journeys "in
search," as he says, "of birds and subscribers," he made tlie
acquaintance of Audubon in the iiuinner above described.
The first volume of his work appeared in 1808 and six others
followed prior to his early death in 1813, as the result of
*Aiutubon's Ornithological Biograpliy, quoted in "Life of Audu-
bon," pp. 22-24.
Early Naturalists 23
hardship and exposure incurred while seeking the birds he
loved so well.
To the careful observation of the scientist, Wilson joiueil
the literary enthusiasm of poet and nature lover. His account
of the passenger pigeon is full of fascinating interest.
"In descending the Ohio by myself in the month of Feb-
ruary, 1 often rested on my oars to contemplate their aerial
manoeuvres. A column eight or ten miles in length would
appear from Kentucky, high in air, steering across to Indiana.
The leaders of this great body would sometimes gradually
vary their course, until it formed a large bend of more than
a ndle in diameter, those behind tracing the exact route of
their predecessors. This would continue sometimes long after
both extremities were beyond the reach of sight; so that the
whole, with its glittery undulations, marked a space on the
face of the heavens resembling the windings of a vast and
majestic river. When this bend became very great, the birds,
as if sensible of the unnecessary circuitous course they were
taking, suddenly changed their direction ; so that what was
in column before became an immense front, straightening all
its indentures until it swept the heavens in one vast and in-
finitely extended line. Other lesser bodies also united with
each other as they happened to approach, with such ease and
elegance of evolution, forming new figures, and varying these
as they united or separated, that I was never tired of contem-
plating them. Sometimes a hawk would make a sweep on a
particular part of the column, from a great height, when
almost as quick as lightning that part shot downwards out
of the common track ; but soon rising again, continued advanc-
ing at the same height as before. This intiection was con-
tinned by those behind, who on arriving at this point dived
down almost perpendicularly to a great depth, and rising,
followed the exact path of those that went before. As these
vast bodies passed over the river near me, the surface of the
water, which was before smooth as glass, appeared marked
with innumerable dimples, occasioned by the dropping of their
dung, resembling the commencement of a shower of large
droi)s of rain or hail.
"Happening to go ashore one charming afternoon to pur-
chase some milk at a house that stood near the river, and while
talking with the people within doors, I was suddenly struck
with astonishment at a loud rushing roar, succeeded by in-
stant darkness; which on the first moment I took for a tor-
nado, about to overwhelm the house and everything around
in destruction. The people, observing ray surprise, coolly
said, 'It is only the pigeons;' and on running out, I beheld a
flock thirty or forty yards in width sweeping along very low,
S«r
s
fi
1
r
t*
^
^5"
— ,
o
-J
s:
*v*
«
24 Biology in America
between the house and the mountain or height that formed
the second bank of the river. These continued passing for
more than a quarter of an hour, and at length varied their
bearing so as to pass over the mountain, behind which they
disappeared before tlie rear came up."
And these lines from his verses to the bluebird are full of
the sweet freshness of the out-of-doors, and bring back to our
minds the days of our care-free, bare-foot, boyhood:
"Then loud-piping fi'ogs make the marshes to ring;
Then warm glows the sunshine, and fine is the weather;
The blue woodland tiowers just beginning to spring,
And spicewood and sassafras budding together:"
"The slow lingering schoolboys forget they'll be chid,
While gazing intent as he warbles before them
In mantle of sky-blue, and bosom so red,
That each little loiterer seems to adore liim."^
A charming picture of Wilson has been given us by James
Lane Allen in his "Kentucky AVarbler, " where we see him,
traveling twelve hundred miles on foot through the wilder-
ness to visit Niagara Falls and reaching "home 'mid the deep
snows of winter with no soles to his boots." And again as
he sets forth on his solitary voyage down the Ohio :
"... It is the twenty-fourth of February : the river, swol-
len with the spring flood, is full of white masses of moving
ice. . . . They warned him of his danger, urged him to take
a rower, urged him not to go at all. Those who risked the
passage of the river floated down on barges called Kentucky
arks, or in canoes hollowed each out of a single tree, usually
the tulip tree, which you know is very common in our Ken-
tucky woods. But to mention danger was to make him go to
meet it. He would have no rower, had no money to hire one,
had he wished one. He tells us what he had on board : in one
end of the boat some biscuit and cheese, a bottle of cordial
given him by a gentleman in Pittsburgh, his gun and trunk
and overcoat; at the other end himself and his oars and a
tin with which to bail out the skifit", if necessary, to keep it
from sinking and also to use as his drinking-cup to dip from
the river.
"That February day— the swollen, rushing river, the
masses of white ice — the solitary young boatnum borne away
» Quotations from the "Passenger Pigeon" and the "Bluebird" in
the "American Ornithology."
Eaiiy Naturalists 25
to a new world on his great work : his heart expanding with
excitement and joy as he lieaded toward the unexplored wil-
derness of the Mississippi Valley.
"Wondrous experiences were his: from the densely wooded
shores there would reach him as he drifted down the whistle
of the red bird — those first spring notes so familiar and so
welcome to us on mild days toward the last off February.
Away off in dim forest valleys, between bold headlands, lie
saw the rising smoke of sugar camps. At other openings on
the landscape grotesque leg cabins looked like drg-houses un-
der impending mighty mountains. His rapidly steered skiff
passed flotillas of Kentucky arks heavily making their way
southward, transporting men and women and children — the
moving pioneers of the young nation : the first river merchant-
marine of the new world ; carrying horses and plows to clear-
ings yet to be made for homesteads in the wilderness ; trans-
porting mill-stones for mills not yet built on any wilderness
stream. . . .
"He records what to us now sounds incredible, that
on March fifth he saw a flock of parrokeets. Tliink of parro-
keets on the Ohio River in March ! . . . Once he encountered
a storm of wind and hail and snow and rain, during which
the river foamed and rolled like the sea and he had to make
good use of his tin to keep the skift' baled out till he could put
in to shore. The call of wild turkeys enticed him now toward
the shore of Indiana, now toward the shore of Kentucky, but
before he reached either they had disappeared. His first
night on the Kentucky shore he spent in the cabin of a squat-
ter and heard him tell tales of bear-treeing and wildcat-hunt-
ing and wolf-baiting. All night wolves howled in the forests
near by and kept the dogs in an uproar ; the region swarmed
with wolves and wildcats 'black and brown.'
"On and on, until at last the skiff* reached the rapids of the
Ohio at Louisville and he stepped ashore and sold his frail
savior craft, which, at starting, he had named the Orni-
thologist. The Kentuckian who bought it as the Ornithologist
accepted the droll name as that of some Indian chief. He
soon left Louisville, having sent his baggage on by wagon,
and plunged into the Kentucky forest on his way to Lexing-
ton.^
After Wilson's death, the remaining volumes of his work
were completed by his friend, Charles Lucien Bonaparte, the
Prince of Cannino and nephew of Napoleon, who in early
* From the ' ' Kentucky Warbler, ' ' pp. 82-88, by i>eriiiission of the
author and Doubleday, Page and Co.
26 Biology in America
life came to America, where he gained reputation as an or-
nithologist.
Tlie other of these two remarkable men, while an American
by birth, was Frencii by parentage and education. Born in
Louisiana in 1780, his family shortly lifter removed to the
estate of Aux Cayes in St. Domingo, where his mother was
killed in the insurrection of the blacks in 1791, his father, with
tlie chihlreii, escaping to France, where he remarried, entrust-
ing tlie tutelage of his children to their step-mother. She
was an easy mistress and the young Audubon was reared in an
atmosphere of indulgent plenty. AVith more foresight than his
wife, the boy's father insisted on his education, originally
intending him for a maritime or engineering career. Tlie tine
arts were not, however, neglected in his education, music and
drawing being included in his studies, the latter under the
famous French artist, David. His studies, however, did not
prevent many rambles into the country, from which he "re-
turned loaded with objects of natural history, birds' nests,
birds' eggs, specimens of moss, curious stones, and other ob-
jects attractive to his eye." Audubon also began in his early
boyhood to draw birds, completing sketches of two hundred
specimens.
Finding his son's interest fixed upon other than maritime
or military pursuits, the father sent him to America to super-
intend his estate of iMill Grove on the I'erkiomen Creek near
Philadelphia, where in Audubon's own words, he found a
"blessed spot" and where "hunting, fishing and drawing oc-
cupied my evpi-y moment, cares I knew not and cared nothing
for them." Here, too, he met his future wife, Lucy Bake-
well, the daughter of an P^nglish gentleman, residing on an
adjoining estate.
Before his marriage, Audubon returned for a year t(i
France, where he served for a brief time as a midshipman in
the French navy, and where he met a young man named
Rosier, who later became his partner in his business ventures
in America.
Subsequent to Audubon's return to America the future
partners essayed a business apprenticeship in New York,
which Audubon signalized by the loss of several hundred
l)ounds in speculation; Rosier similarly losing considerable
money. His connncrcial enterprises, however, did not pre-
vent Audubon from devoting himself to his favorite pursuits,
which caused such a disagreeable odor in liis rooms that \\h
neighbors demanded, through a constable, an abatement of
the nuisance !
Leaving New York, Audubon journeyed to Louisville, where
he invested the proceeds of the sale of the Mill Grove prop-
Early Naturalists 27
erty in Ijushioss with Rosier and where lie shortly after
brought his wife.
Space does not permit us to follow all the wanderings of
this brilliant, but eccentric man. His various business ad-
ventures were foreordained to failure, and from comfort, it'
not opulence, he and his ever brave and loyal wife were soon
reduced to penury, Audubon earning a meagre penny by
giving lessons in drawing, music, fencing and dancing, while
his wife acted as governess in a private family.
His roving life in a new and sparsely settled country was
full of wild and interesting experiences which are vividly
depicted in his journal. His account of an Indian swan hunt
in Tennessee gives us a lively picture of the abundance of
wild life in America in the early daj^, and some idea of the
cause of its rapid disappearance.
"The second morning after our arrival at Cash Creek,
while I was straining my eyes to discover whether it was
fairly day dawn or no, I heard a movement in the Indian
camp, and discovered that a canoe, with half a dozeii squaws
and as many hunters, was about leaving for Tennessee. I
had heard that there was a large lake opposite to us, where
immense flocks of swans resorted every morning, and asking
permission to join them, I seated myself on my haunches in
the canoe, well provided with ammunition and a bottle of
whisky, and in a few minutes the paddles were at work,
swiftly propelling ns to the opposite shore. I was not much
surprised to see the hunters stretch themselves out and go to
sleep. On landing, the squaws took charge of the canoe,
secured it, and went in search of nuts, while we gentlemen
hunters made the best of our way through thick and thin to
the lake. Its muddy shores were overgrown with a close
growth of cotton trees, too large to be pushed aside, and too
thick to pass through except by squeezing yourself at every
few steps; and to add to the ditficulty, every few rods we
came to small nasty lagoons, which one must jump, leap, or
swim, and this not without peril of broken limbs or drowning.
''But when the lake burst on our view there were the swans
by hundreds, and white as rich cream, either dipping their
black bills in the water, or stretching out one leg on its sur-
face, or gently floating alone. According to the Indian mode
of hunting, we had divided and approached the lagoon from
different sides. The moment our vidette was seen, it seemed
as if thousands of large, fat, and heavy swans were startled,
and as they made away from him they drew towards the
ambush of death ; for the trees had hunters behind them, whose
touch of the trigger would carry destruction among them.
As the first party fired, the game rose and flew within easy
28 Biology in America
distance of the party on the opposite side, when they again
fired, and I saw the water covered with birds floating with
tlieir backs dowjiwards, and tlieir heads sunk in the water,
and tlieir legs kicking in the air. "When the s])ort was over
we counted more than tifty of these beautiful biixls, whose
skins were intended for the ladies in Europe. There were
plenty of geese and ducks, but no one condescended to give
them a shoot. A conch wa.s sounded, and after a while
the squaws came dragging the canoe, and collecting the dead
game, which was taken to the river's edge, fastened to the
canoe, and before dusk we were again landed at our camping
ground. 1 had heard of sportsmen in England who walked
a whole day, and after firing a pound of powder returned in
great glee bringing one partridge ; and I could not help won-
dering Avhat they would think of the spoil we were bearing
from Swan Lake."
His picture of the Mississippi in flood is wonderfully im-
pressive.
"I have floated on the Mississippi and Ohio when thus
swollen, and have in different places visited the submerged
lands of the interior, propelling a light canoe by the aid of a
paddle. In this manner I have traversed immense portions
of the country overflowed by the waters of these rivers, and
particularly whilst floating over the iMississippi bottom lairds
I have been struck with awe at the sight. Little or no current
is met with, unless when the canoe passes over the bed of a
bayou. All is silent and melancholy, unless when the mourn-
ful bleating of the hemmed-in deer reaches your ear, or the
dismal scream of an eagle or a heron is heard, or the foul bird
rises, disturbed by your approach, from the carcass on which
it was allaying its craving appetite. Bears, cougars, lynxes,
and all other quadrupeds that can ascend the trees, are ob-
served crouched among their top branches; hungry in the
midst of abundance, although they see floating around them
the animals on which they usually prey. They dare not ven-
ture to swim to them. Fatigued by the exertions which they
have made in reaching dry land, they will there stand the
hunter's fire, as if to die by a ball were better than to perish
amid the waste of waters. On occasions like this, all these
animals are shot by hundreds."
In his journeys Audubon fell in with many interesting
characters. One of these was the naturalist Rafinesque. Dur-
ing Audubon's residence in Kentucky, Rafinesque visited
him, presenting a letter of introduction in which he was
described as an "odd fish" as yet undescribed in published
works. Audubon's innocent inquiry as to where the *'odd
fish" was, led to much amusement and a cordial entente
Early Naturalists
29
between the two. "His attire," writes Audubon, "struek me
as exceedingly remarkable. A long loose coat of yellow nan-
keen, much the worse for the many rubs it had got in its
time, and stained all over with the juice of plants, hung
loosely about him like a sack. A waistcoat of the same, with
enormous pockets, and buttoned up to the chin, reached below
over a pair of tight pantaloons, the h)wer parts of which were
buttoned down to tlie ankles. His
beard was as long as I have known
my own to be during some of my
peregrinations, and his lank black
hair hung loosely over his shoul-
ders. His forehead was so broad
and prominent that any tyro in
phrenology would instantly have
pronounced it the residence of a
mind of strong powers. His words
impressed an assurance of rigid
truth, and as he directed the con-
versation to the study of the natu-
ral sciences, I listened to him with
great delight. He requested to see
my draAvings, anxious to see the
plants I had introduced besides the
birds I had drawn. Finding a
strange plant among my drawings,
he denied its authenticity ; but on
my assuring him that it grew in the neighborhood, he insisted
on going off instantly to see it.
"When I pointed it out the naturalist lost all command
over his feelings, and behaved like a maniac in expressing his
delight. He plucked the plants one after another, danced,
hugged me in his arms, and exultingly told me he had got, not
merely a new species, but a new genus.
"He immediately took notes of all the needful particulars
of the plant in a note-book, which he carried wrapt in a water-
proof covering. After a day's pursuit of natural history
studies, the stranger was accommodated with a bed in an attic
room. We had all retired to rest ; every person I imagined
was in deep slumber save myself, when of a sudden I heard a
great uproar in the naturalist's room. I got up, reached the
place in a few moments, and opened the door; when, to my
astonishment, I saw my guest running naked, holding the
handle of my favorite violin, the body of which he had bat-
tered to pieces against the walls in attempting to kill the bats
which had entered by the open window, probably attracted by
the insects flying around his candle. I stood amazed, but he
Eafinesque
From Popular Science Monthly.
Copy furnished hy Conrad
Lantern
Chicago.
Slide Company,
30 Biology in A))irrira
contiiuu'd ,jmni)ing and riiniiiii<i:: rouiul and round, until \\v
was fairly exhausted, when he begged me to procure one of the
aninuils for Iniu, as he felt eonvinccd they belonged to a 'new
species.' Although 1 was convinced of tlu; contrary, 1 took up
the bow of my demolished Cremona, and administering a smart
tap to each of the bats as it came up, soon got specimens
enough. The war" ended, I again bade him good-night, but
could not help observing the state of the room. It was strewed
with plants, which had been previously arranged with care.
"lie saw my regret for the havoc that had been created, but
added that he would soon put his plants to rights — after ho
had secured his new specimens of l)ats. "*
Rafinesque was a marked example of the combination of
brilliance with eccentricity; his career, filled with striking
contrasts of light and shade, forms one of the most pathetic
pictures in American science. Born in Constantinople,
of Franco-German parentage, traveler, zoologist, botanist,
chemist, geographer, archaeologist, historian, philosopher,
economist and poet, professor in Transylvania ITniversity at
Lexiiigton, Kentucky, medalist of the Geographical Society of
Paris, associate and correspondent of many of the leading
scientists of his day, dying at last in penury, unbefriended
and alone in his garret home in Philadelphia ; his very corpse
seized by his landlord for sale to the dissecting room, rescued
by friends and buried in an obscure burial ground, now in the
heart of the great city; his course was marked by flashes of
brilliance, but ended in obscurity and gloom.
Like many another Rafinesque was ahead of his generation.
When he submitted to the Academy of Natural Sciences in
Philadelphia a paper describing two genera of fossil jellyfish,
it was rejected as unworthj^ of publication, such a thing as a
fossil jellyfish being considered an impossibility in those days.
He had clearly in mind the idea of evolution at a time when
the doctrine of the fixity of species was firmly entrenched in
men's minds. In the title page of his poem on "The World or
Instability, ' ' published in 1836, he writes :
"If Solomon did say, that nothing new
Under the sun was seen, 'tis not (piite true:
Since we contend that every hour and day
Brings novelties, with changes due array.
Whatever had a birth must change sustain,
Unsteady ever be ; but not in vain :
Enjoying life must die to live again,
In after lives perfection to attain."
* The foregoing quotations are from Audubon's diary in Buchanan's
"Life of Audubon."
Early Naturalists 31
Living a lonely life, embittered by disappointment, with the
memory of a faithless wife behind him, and the ever elusive
will-o'-the-wisp of ungi-atified ambition before him, it is no
wonder that his disposition became soured and that he some-
times indulged in caustic criticism of his fellows, winning him
their enmity and embittering his own life all the more.
Despite his financial failures Audubon seems never to have
lost heart in his ambition to publish his studies and drawings
of the birds of America, And in this ambition he was en-
couraged and materially aided by his ever loyal wife. In the
furtherance of this project he visited Philadelphia in 1824,
where he met many men prominent in scientific and artistic
circles. Among them were Lucien Bonaparte, Le Sueur, the
ichthyologist, Murtrie, the conchologist. Sully, the artist and
many others. Of his meeting with Titian Peale, the artist-
naturalist, he speaks in the following bitter words :
"Showed all my drawings to Titian Peel, who in return
refused to let me see a new bird in his possession. This little
incident fills me with grief at the narrow spirit of humanity,
and makes me Avish for the solitude of the woods. ' ' ^
Fighting his way through repeated failure and discourage-
ment, and with the aid of his ever faithful wife, Audubon
was finally enabled to reach England and to obtain the funds
necessary to the publication of his monumental work, the
"Birds of America."
Publication of a book in those days was a different matter
from what it is at present. There were no publishers willing
to incur the financial risk of printing and illustrating so costly
a work as the ' ' Birds of America. ' ' For the author then, with-
out independent means, it was necessary to secure enough
subscriptions in advance to defray the costs of publication.
He, of necessity, became his own book agent. To this end, as
well as to supervise the preparation of the elaborate colored
engravings illustrating his work, Audubon made several trips
abroad, visiting both England and France, where his merit
as naturalist and artist gained him ready entrance into the
highest circles of art and learning.
. Audubon was accompanied on his visit to France by his
friend Swainson, one of the prominent ornithologists of the
time, and later one of the authors of the "Fauna boreali-
Americana," descriptive of the natural history of northern
North America, studied by Richardson, naturalist to Sir John
Franklin's exploring parties. Swainson 's reputation indeed
was greater than Audubon's at this time, as he was known in
France, where the latter, prior to his visit, had not been
heard of.
'Locus Citatus. .
32 Biology in Amrn'ra
In tlie interims between his journeys to England, Audubon
Avas l)usy ill liis search for liirds and also iiiaimiials, visiting
aiiiong other places, Labrador aiul Fh^rida, and liiially making
his last expedition, that up the Missouri Kiver to the mouth of
the Yellowstone, primaril\- to collect material for his "Quad-
rupeds of America," one volunie of which was published
before his deatii, and tlie other two, by his sons, Victor and
John, subserpient thereto.
In the early morning of dan. 27, 1851, in tlie country home
of "JMinniesland" on the hanks of the Iliidson, there passed
away the pi-emier of America's early pioneers in science.
Today towering apartment houses, and a splendid driveway,
look down on "Minniesland," but his work lives after him
and his spirit pulses still in the "Audubon Societies" through-
out our land.
Both of Audubon's sons followed in their father's foot-
steps as naturalists and artists, and were early associated
with him in his ornithological work, and later in his work on
the "Quadrupeds," in the course of which the younger of
the sons, John, visited both Texas and California, making the
journey overland in search of specimens of natural histoiy.
Following the Louisiana Purchase in 1803, both public and
private interest awakened in the unknown resources of the
vast territory beyond the Missouri and its head waters. An
expedition to visit this region, cross the Rockies and descend
the Columbia to its mouth was early planned by President Jef-
ferson, under the leadership of his secretary Captain Merri-
wether Lewis, accompanied by Francois Andre Michaux, a
French botanist visiting America under the auspices of the
French government. ]\Iichaux had traveled extensively
through eastern North America on botanical explorations, the
result of which were his "Flora boreali- Americana," and his
' ' North American Sylva. ' ' Before this plan could be executed,
however, he was recalled liy his government to Fi-ance. Noth-
ing daunted by failure Jeti'erson i)lanned a second expedition,
and in 3 804-5 Captains Tjewis and ('lark of the IT. S. Army
crossed the continent via the^ Missouri and Columbia Rivers.
On this (>x|)edi1ioii they collected voluminous scientific data
dealing in ])art with the natural history of the region trav-
ersed.
It is worth while at this point to glance for a moment at
the scientific work of that remarkably versatile man, Thomas
Jelferson, a man Avho in many respects was the i)rototype
of that other statesman-naturalist who has so recently de-
l)arted from iis. Jefferson's interests were very broad.
Astronomer, ])hysicist, engineer, anatomist, geologist, zoolo-
gist, botanist, palaioutologist, litterateur, educator, lawyer,
Early Naturalists 33
farmer, economist and statesman, he indeed was a man of far
vision and high achievement, dreamer of dreams and doer of
deeds. Writing in the "Magazine of American History" for
April, 1885, Mr. Frederic N. Luther says of him :
... In Febrnaiy, 1801, when Congress was vainly
trying to untangle the difficulties arising from the tie vote
between Jefferson and Burr, when every politician at the
capital was busy with schemes and counter-schemes, this man,
whose political fate was balanced on a razor's edge, was
corresponding with Dr. Wistar in regard to some bones of the
mastodon which he had just procured from Shawangunk,
Ulster County. Again in 1808, when the excitement over the
embargo was highest, when every day brought fresh denuncia-
tions of him and his policy, he was carrying on his pahTonto-
logical studies in the rooms of the White House itself. . . .
Never for a moment, however apparently absorbed in other
work, did he lose his warm sympathy with nature."
It is amusing to read on the other hand the tribute which
his studies called forth from Bryant, then thirteen years old.
"Go, wretch, resign the Presidential chair,
Disclose thy secret measures, foul or fair.
Go, search with curious eyes for horned frogs,
'Mid the wild wastes of Louisianian bogs ;
Or, where the Ohio rolls his turbid stream.
Dig for huge bones, thy glory and thy theme."
One of Jefferson's scientific contemporaries was Buffon, the
French evolutionist. Buffon had an idea that the animals of
the new world are smaller than their near relatives in the old,
and that domesticated types are degenerating in the former as
compared with the same types in the latter. These conten-
tions were refuted by Jefferson, who exported to Paris speci-
mens of several of our large animals as evidence of his
contentions. As a result Buffon wrote to Jefferson, "I should
have consulted you, Sir, before publishing my 'Natural His-
tory,' and then I should have been sure of my facts."
Jefferson was one of our pioneer plant importers. While
minister to Paris he sent to America large numbers of seeds
and plants of various sorts. Most of these were failures,
among them the olive, the cork oak and the caper. With rice
however he was more successful. Noting the gi-eat demand
for this cereal during Lent in France, and noting further the
small importations of American as compared with Italian
rice, he set about discovering the reason, and soon a.scertained
that it was due to the superior quality of the latter grain.
In those days importation of plants from one country to
34 Biology in America
another was (liffifult, owinj; to the selfish Jack Horner policy
of keopiiifi: all the ])liiins at home. Jefferson however visited
Italy and carrie<l off: successfully some pockets full of rice,
which he sent to tlie Charleston planters, and from which
have develop(Hl the rice crops of the South today.
Among Jeil'erson's important contrihutions to biology were
his discovery of the remains of a giant sloth in the mountains
of Virginia, which bears his name and which is mentioned
elsewhere in this book ; his discovery of the bones of the
mastodon in Ulster County, N. Y., and his account of the nat-
ural history of Virginia, published in his notes on that state.
In 1810 an expedition fitted out by John Jacob Astor set
out for the Columbia, which reached the infant village of
Astoria near its mouth on February 15, 1812, after suffering
untold hardships in the wilderness. On this expedition were
two naturalists, both Englishmen; one, John Bradbury sent
out by the Botanical Society of Liverpool to collect American
plants; and the other, Thomas Nuttall, the ornithologist, and
botanist, who was traveling independently. They accom-
panied it for several hundred miles above St. Louis, but
returned before the main party crossed the Rocky Mountains.
Later Bradbury visited several of the central western states,
the results of all his journeys being interestingly recorded in
his "Travels in the Interior of America." Nuttall 's travels
also took him along the shores of the Great Lakes into Wis-
consin, down the Mississippi to St. Louis, up the Arkansas
River and finally in company with the naturalist Townsend,
across the continent to the Columbia, whence he returned
east by the Hawaiian Islands and Cape Horn. On this expedi-
tion they traveled with the party of Mr. Nathaniel J. Wyeth
of Boston, who in 1833 made a well conceived but ineffectual
attempt to recover for the United States the trade lost when,
twenty years previously, Astoria passed into the hands of the
"Northwest Company," a Canadian company and rival of the
"Hudson Bay Company" for the trade of the Northwest.
In 1819-20 Major Stephen H. Long, from whom one of the
most inspiring peaks in the Rocky Mountains takes its name,
made an expedition under the direction of the War Depart-
ment to the Rocky Mountains. He was accompanied on this
expedition by Thomas Say, the conchologist and entomologist,
and Edwin James, a botanist and geologist. Say also accom-
panied Long on his survey of the Great Lakes region and the
valleys of the upper Mississippi and Red River as far as Lake
Winnipeg.
The life of the far West in the days when the pioneers blazed
their trails for civilization and science through its wildernesses,
was one to appeal to the hardy and adventurous. Its virgin
Above, William Clark Above, Merriwether Lewis
Below, Thomas Jefferson Below, Thomas Nuttall
Copies supplied hy Handy, photo.
35
36 Biology in America
wilds too offered a rich reward to the scientific explorer. Its
dangers and hardships however presented an effective barrier
to all but the most resolute and dauntless. Vivid pictures of
this life, with its fascinating beauty and danger, the intense
rivalry of the different fur companies, the savage attack and
wanton ravage of the lurking Indians, the midnight revel
about the roaring camp tire, the g^nnes and frolics, feuds and
friendships of men without rcsti-aiut ; the challenge of the
chase, the elk's whistle and the howling wolf, the magnificence
of boundless plain, of towering peak and roaring river, the
glory of the sunset and the starlit sky and the terror of the
tempest, have been drawn for us by many writers, especially
Irving in his "Astoria" and "Captain Bonneville"; and the
journals of these early adventurere are as full of enthralling
interest as they are of historical and scientific information.
In the early days of American exploration, adventurous
eyes were turned to the frozen north, and in the Elizabethan
age of English glory her mariners penetrated the frozen seas
as far as latitude 72° N., leaving a record of their daring in
the names of Frobisher's and Davis' Straits. In the following
century. Sir Henry Hudson explored the bay which bears his
name, and perished upon its inhospitable waters. A shorter
route to India, through the Northwest Passage, was one of the
motives of these early voyages. It was on this quest that the
famous voyages of Ross and Parry were made, early in the
last century.
In 1819-22 Sir John Franklin, who had been second in
command of Buchan 's polar expedition of the preceding year,
undertook the exploration of the Canadian Coast bordering
the Arctic Sea. On this expedition he was accompanied by
Richardson as surgeon and naturalist, whose name was
destined to become famous in the annals of early American
biology. The party left York Factory on Hudson Bay on Sep-
tember 9, reaching Cumberland House on October 23, where
they wintered. The following year, greatly handicapped by
lack of provisions, Franklin and his party pushed northward
to Fort Enterprise, where they spent the second winter, and
in the summer descended the Coppermine River to the Arctic
Sea, whose coast they explored as far as Bathurst Iidet. On
the return to Fort Enterprise the party suffered untold hard-
ships, a glimpse of which may be obtained from Franklin's
own narrative. The fifth of September, without food or fire,
was spent in bed, while a raging storm covered them with
several inches of snow. "Our sufferings (writes Franklin)
from cold, in a comfortless canvas tent in such weather, with
the temperature at 20°, and without fire, will easily be
imagined ; it was, however, less than that which we felt from
Early Naturalists 37
hunger." Living largely on lichens, they were fortunate
enough to kill a musk ox on the tenth. ' ' To skin and cut up
the animal was the work of a few minutes. The contents of
its stomach were devoured upon the spot; raw intestines which
were next attacked, were pronounced by the most delicate
amongst us to be excellent." Finally when Fort Enterprise
was reached it was found deserted and provisionless ! Here
Franklin and his men spent several weeks awaiting succor
from Fort Providence, to which a few of the party had pushed
on for help ; subsisting meantime on lichens, and bits of skin
and bones from the refuse heaps of the preceding winter.
They were so weak that even when game appeared, none of
them were able to go after it. "We saw," continues Franklin,
"a herd of reindeer sporting on the river, about half a mile
from the house ; they remained there a long time, but none of
the party felt themselves strong enough to go after them, nor
was there one of us who could have fired a gun without
resting it. " *^ Finally, early in November, relief came from
Fort Providence, enabling the party to reach Fort Chipewyan,
where they wintered, returning to York Factory the following
summer. Such were the surroundings, and such the men, in
which, and by whom American biology was made.
Richardson also accompanied Franklin on a subsequent
expedition in 1825, together with Drummond, another nat-
uralist, to Great Bear Lake and down the ^Mackenzie River
to its mouth, whence one party under Franklin explored the
coast to the westward, while another under Richardson went
some nine hundred miles eastward. In 1848-9 Richardson
was in charge of one of the expeditions sent in search of
Franklin, who never returned from his fateful voyage of 1845.
In the course of this search he further explored the coast
between the mouths of the Mackenzie and Coppermine Rivers.
The natural history results of Richardson's explorations
were embodied in liis vohimes of the "Fauna boreali- Ameri-
cana," published with tlie assistance of the ornithologist,
Swainson, and the entomologist, Kirby.
Beginning with 1830 and for many years subse(iuent
thereto, different states organized surveys of their natural
resources. Of still greater value, however, to natural science
were the various government surveys leading up to the Pacific
Railroad Surveys and those of the territories, and finally
culminating in 1879 in the establishment of the U. S.
Geological Survey,
"Quoted from Wright, "The Great Wliite Nortli," \>\>. Sd-S, l)y jicr-
mission of the Maemillan Company.
38
Biology in America
While these surveys were primarily topographical and
geological in purpose, they were usually accompanied by
naturalists, whose duty it was to investigate and report upon
the wild life, both plant and animal, of the region visited, and
to them much of our knowledge of the natural history of the
United States is due.
Of prime importance in the work of these naturalists were
the discoveries of the paliEontologists. The western plains
and mountains constitute a veritable storehouse of buried
treasure, and the pick and shovel of the paUeontologist un-
covered here a large part of the material for writing the
history of ancient life.
These were days too when it was
lint impossible for one man to cover
an extensive field of science. Tlius
we find the elder Agassiz equally
famed as a geologist and zoologist,
and Dana, the noted geologist, i)ro-
tVssor at Yale from 1850 to 1890,
writing a monumental work on the
Z()oi)hytes and Crustacea of the
Wilkes Exploring Expedition ; Cope,
master not onl}' of vertebrate
palaeontology but of modern fishes,
am])hibia and reptiles as well, and
Lcidy, botanist, mineralogist, geolo-
gist, paleontologist, parasitologist,
protozoologist and comparative
anatomist.
A notable event in American
science was the advent of Louis
Agassiz in 1846. Born in 1807 at the little town of Motiers in
Switzerland, the son of a clergyman, he early displayed that
love of natural history, which made him famous. Champion
fencer and jolly comrade, as well as gifted student, his uni-
versity days at Zurich, Heidelberg and Munich found him a
leader among his fellows and his room in Munich dubbed
by them "The Little Academy." His scientific work early
attracted the attention of Humboldt and Cuvier, who gave
him all possible assistance in his career. While professor
of natural history in the University of Neuchatel, Agassiz
gained world wide fame by his studies in zoology, palaeon-
tology, and especially on the glaciers of the Alps. In 1846 he
came to America, where he remained until his death in 1873.
During most of this time he was professor of natural history
at Harvard, where he gathered about him a group of men and
Louis Agassiz
From Popular Science Moiitlily
Copy furnished ty Con/rod
Lantern Slide Company,
Cliicago.
Early Naturalists 39
sent them forth to become leaders of biology in America.
Indeed, it was as teacher, rather than as investigator, that
Agassiz's influence was most widely felt. Possessed of a
compelling personality, remarkable diction and inspiring
enthusiasm, he left an impress upon biology in this country
that can never be effaced. He was the founder of the Museum
of Comparative Zoology of Harvard University, while his
summer school at Penikese in 1873 was the forerunner of
biological stations in America. A disciple of Cuvier, he was
ever an ardent champion of his views and an opponent, albeit
a warm personal friend of Darwin.
Pupil of Agassiz at Neuchatel, and later his co-worker in
America, was Girard, who prepared the report on the reptiles
of the Wilkes expedition. Girard was better known, however,
for his work on flslies, in the course of which he studied much
of the material collected by the U. S. Surveys.
While exploring naturalists were busy gathering the un-
known fruits of our virgin fields and forests, their colleagues
in the dim and dusty rooms of museum and college were no
less busy in making known the results of their harvests. Dr.
Joseph Leidy, a Philadelphia physician, professor of anatomy
at the University of Pennsylvania and later professor of
natural history at Swarthmore College, was one of the most
noted of these early college and museum men. He is a striking
example of the "all around" naturalist of the early days, his
writings embracing a wealth of subjects of both extinct and
living animals, and ranging from the unicellular animals to
man. Of his notable works one of the earliest was his account
of the fossils from the "bad lands" of Nebraska, collected by
one of the surveys of the then (1850) Northwest Territory,
conducted by the geologist, David Day Owen, under the
direction of the U. S. Treasury Department.
Colleagues of Leidy in the study of the fossils brought back
from the West by the government surveys, and by exploring
parties sent out by museums and colleges, were two men
whose names stand in the front rank of our palaeontologists —
Othniel Charles Marsh and Edward Drinker Cope.
As professor of palaeontology at Yale, Marsh inaugurated
in 1870 a series of scientific expeditions into the Western
States, the results of which were the splendid collections of
vertebrate fossils of Yale and the U. S. National Museum, and
the stores of information about the pre-historic life of our con-
tinent which Marsh gave to the world and which soon made
him famous. His earlier expeditions were undertaken and
largely supported by himself, but after the organization of the
U. S. Geological Survey in 1879, he became connected with it
40 Biology in America
as pala?ontologist and thereafter worked under its auspices.
His expeditions took him into the western plains country and
the Rocky ^louiitains, where lie discovered the reinarkalile
birds witli teeth, lles})erornis and Iclitliyornis, and a host of
dinosaurs, the lizard-like reptiles, many of them giants of the
animal world, whose bones have been unearthed in such
numliers on our western plains, and are now reposing in so
many museums both here and abroad, and whose biographies
fill so many ponderous volumes on the shelves of our libraries.
Here too he collected a series of skeletons of fossil horses
which has fnrnislied one of tlie strongest evidences for evolu-
tion knuwji, and which served to recast the views regarding
the descent of the horse which were current at that time.
In 1876 when Huxley visited America, he spent a week with
Mai'sh inspecting his collections of fossils at Yale. Huxley
was at this time preparing to deliver a lectui'e in New York
on the evolution of the horse, and as a result of his study
of the Yale collections this lecture was largely rewritten.
When ]\Iarsh had brought out box after box of specimens to
illustrate various points in their discussion, Huxley finally
turned to him and said, "I believe you are a magician;
whatever I want, you conjure it up."
As a further result of this conference Huxley predicted
the discovery of the then unknown five-toed ancestor of the
horse, and sure enough, less than two months later Professor
Marsh ' ' dug up ' ' the renowned Eohippus in the Eocene strata
of the West.
Cope, one of the most indefatigable, brilliant and versatile
of American biologists, was born and died in Philadelphia.
When a young man he served as professor of natural science
in Haverford College, later becoming connected with the
government surveys of the territories under AVheeler and
Hayden. For several years he was curator of the Academy
of Natural Sciences of Philadelphia, and finally professor of
geology in the University of Pennsylvania. In the literature
of modern fishes, and especially of reptiles and amphibians,
Cope's work will ever be classic, but it was chiefly in the
field of vertebrate palaeontology that he became famous. As
a member of government surveys and the Philadelphia
Academy his work on the fossil vertebi-ates of the AVest was
both able and voluminous, and contributed largely not aloiie
to his own fame, but to that of the institutions which he
represented. As illustrative of American idealism, a trait
for which our people have not hitherto received due credit,
it is both pleasant and stimulating to think of Cope on his
deathbed putting the finishing touches on his report upon
Above, James D wight Dana Above, Joseph Leidy
Below, Edward Drinker Cope Below, Othniel Charles Marsh
Cuurtt'sy oj Dr. Qeo. P. Merrill.
41
42 Biology in America
the fossils of the Port Kennedy cave, then recently discovered
on the Schuylkill River near Philadelphia.
But if the labors of Leidy and his colleagues were actuated
by high-spirited and idealistic love of science, they were none
the more free from the comedy of petty selfishness. Ever
eager to forestall the others in the announcement of their
"finds" they occasional!}^ made ludicrous mistakes through
their haste in publication. On one occasion Cope got hold
of some bones of an ancient reptile from Kansas. The ani-
mal's head was missing and certain other bones which are
usually included in the skeleton of any orthodox beast, but
Cope in his enthusiasm, and apparently in a state of headless-
ness resembling his subject, described them under the dignified
title of Elasmosaurus platyurus. But Leidy, ever keen to
detect a slip on the part of an opponent, made a more care-
ful examination of the defunct and announced an error in
the epitaph which Cope had written, as the remains belonged
to a different creature altogether, namely Enaliosaurus,
Cope's mistake being due to having reversed the animal end
for end, and imagined a head where the tail rightfully be-
longed.
In his early recollections of Leidy, Marsh and Cope, Osborn
says that "whereas in Leidy we had a man of the temper of
an exact observer, Cope was a man who loved speculation;
if Leidy was the natural successor of Cuvier, Cope was
the follower of Lamarck, a man of remarkable inventive genius.
. . . Marsh . . . was a comparative anatomist of a high
order, and had a genius for appreciating what might be called
the most important thing in science. He always knew where
to explore, where to seek the transition stages, and he never
lost the opportunity to point out at the earliest possible mo-
ment the most significant fact to be discovered and dissemi-
nated. . . .
"I had the pleasure of knowing Leidy slightly and of a
long personal ac(|uaintanee with Marsh ; I knew Cope very
intimately. . . . On one memorable occasion when I visited
his house he pulled out a drawer of his black walnut work-
table, where he always sat and wrote his papers, and brought
out a packet carefully done up in paper and twine, saying,
'Osborn, here are some records that you have never seen
before.' I said, 'Well, what are they?' He replied, 'These
are my ]\Iarshiana, here is everything relating to the mistakes
which that man Marsh has made; and when the time comes,
Osborn, I am going to launch this on the world.' Well, he
did ; the bombshell was exploded in due time, and this great
mass of information regarding the supposed incapacity of
Marsh was spread on the pages of the "New York Herald" in
Early Naturalists
43
one of its Sunday issues. The very next Sunday, however,
Marsh, who, it appears, had likewise been accumulating
a private stock of Copeiana, proved with equal success
that Cope's life was one long string of errors from first to
last.
"Heredity makes strange bedfellows. It is only by the
most extraordinary combination of personal characteristics
that we find among scientific men of the greatest capacity,
such strange mixtures of personal qualities side by side with
genius." ^
Possibly it was some of these early rivalries which prompted
Bret Harte 's classic little gem of comedy, ' ' The Society upon
the Stanislow."
A pathetic figure among the makers of American science is
Lesquereux, the Swiss botanist, and associate of Louis Agassiz,
He was born in the province of
Nenchatel, Switzerland, in 1806,
emigrating to America in 1848.
His interest was at first in living
plants, but he later devoted himself
almost entirely to a study of fossil
forms. After coming to America
he was connected with several state
surveys, and later with the terri-
torial surveys under Hayden. His
work on the coal forming plants of
Pennsylvania, Ohio, Illinois, and
Arkansas served chiefly to make his
reputation. He worked nnder
peculiar disadvantages, being but a
poor master of English, and becom- ^^^ Gray
ing deaf at an early age. He once From Popular Science Monthly.
said of himself, "My deafness cut copy furnished by Oonrad
me off from everything that lay cMca'^o ^^^^ company.
outside of science. I have lived
with nature, the rocks, the trees, the flowers. They know me.
I know them. All outside are dead to me. ' ' ®
It is in connection with these early surveys that we first
meet with the names of many men famous in the annals of
American science, who are still living, or have but recently
passed away — Jordan, the ichthyologist, and more recently the
philosopher and apostle of pacifism, Coulter, the botanist,
Gilbert, the ichthyologist, Scudder, the entomologist, Coues,
the ornithologist, and Asa Gray, premier botanist of America,
and author of the well-known manual of American plants.
'"' Proceedings of the Academy of Natural Sciences," 1912, p. xxxiv.
•Locus citatua.
44 Biology in Ayncrica
Here too Ave meet with Sir Josepli Hooker, director of the Kew
Gardens, Eiifjlaiid. l^arwiu's elder brother in science, and the
man wlio, with I^yell, Ihe freolo<rist. was more than any other
responsible for tlie publication of the "Orifjin of Species."
In the introduction to his scholarly an<l at the same time
interestinpr work "A History of Lan(l IMammals in the West-
ern HtMuispliere, " Professor Scott tells us tluit "One afternoon
in June, 1876, three I'rinccton uu(lcr<2:ra(luates were lying
under the trees on the canal bank, making a languid pretence
of preparing for an examination. Suddeidy, one of the trio
rcuuirked : 'I have been reading an old nuigazine article which
describes a fossil-collecting ex])edition in the West; why can't
we get up something of the kind?' The others replied, as
with one voice, ' We can ; let 's do it. ' This seemingly idle
talk was, for Osborn and myself, a momentous one, for it
completely changed the careers which, as we then believed,
had been mapped out for us. The random suggestion led
directly to the first of the Princeton pahpontological expedi-
tions, that of 1877, which took us to the "Bad Lands" of
the Bridger region in southwestern Wyoming."® In this
trivial incident lay the germ of the collections of vertebrate
fossils of Princeton University, and the American Museum of
Natural History, and led to many of the most imporant
palaeontological discoveries in the world.
Next to Audubon, Agassiz and Gray, no name is more
prominent in the early annals of American biology than that
of Spencer Fullerton Baird. In his early career Baird was
professor of the natural sciences in Dickinson College,
becoming assistant secretary of the Smithsonian Institution
in 1850. While in this position he founded the National
Museum and prepared the monumental reports upon the
mammals and birds collected by the several Pacific Railroad
surveys during the decade of the fifties. On the latter reports
he was assisted by the well-known ornithologists, John Cassin
(of Pliiladelphia) and Geo. N. Lawrence (of New York).
He was also joint author with Brewer and Ridgway of the
splendid "History of American Birds," published from 1874
to 1884.
T^aird was tlie Nestor of economic zoology in America.
Tlirough his activity, aided hy otiier scientists and fish cul-
turists throughout the United States, the U. S. Fish Commis-
sion was established in 1874, and he was appointed its com-
missioner, a post wliich he tilled without salary for a number
of years. Tlie organi/ation of this great institution, whose
work is briefly mentioned in another chapter, we owe to
Professor Baird.
"Quoted by permission of the Macmillan Company.
Early Naturalists
45
A hundred years ago the scientific thought of America was
as firmly rooted in the belief in the fixity of species as was
that of Europe. American colleges were almost, if not
entirely, presided over by doctors of divinity, and there was
even a feeling in many quarters against the sciences, especially
of geology, as tending to unsettle the belief of the young in
the Mosaic account of creation ; and yet, even so early as
1833 there appears to have been an underlying current of
unrest present in the minds of some, for in the second Amer-
ican edition of "Bakewell's Geology," published in this year,
under the editorship of Silliman,
the lawyer, chemist and geologist,
who was professor of chemistry and
natural science at Yale, we read
"Any attempt to disprove the
truth or genuineness of the Penta-
teuch, and Genesis in particular, is
wholly superfluous, and quite aside
from any question that can in this
age be at issue between geologists.
No geologist at the present day
erects any system upon the basis
of the scripture history." The
editor however accepted the Mosaic
account as true and endeavored to
bring it into accordance with the
geological record. In the first
edition of the same work published
four years earlier, Silliman con-
sidered the discoveries of geology
as consistent with the bH:)lical
story, stating that "respecting the deluge, there can be but one
opinion . . , geology fully confirms the scripture history of
that event. ' ' ^" Archaic as these views appear today, they show
none the less the leaven that was beginning, slowly, yet none
the less surely, to work in men's minds, preparing them for
the acceptance of the gospel of truth. The anti-Darwinian
attitude in America was supported largely by the influence
of Louis Agassiz, who, in spite of his personal friendship for
Darwin, was ever his bitter opponent in the arena of science.
But Darwin found an equally powerful champion in Asa Gray,
the botanist, and colleague of Agassiz on the Harvard College
faculty. Darwin had met Gray on a visit of tlie latter to
England, some years before the i^ublication of the "Origin
of Species," and in its preparation he frequently consulted
^"Merrill, "Contributions to the History of American Geology,"
Eep. U. S. N. M., 1904, pp. 292 and 317.
Spencer Fullerton Baird
First U. S. Fish Commissioner.
Courtesy of the U. S. Bureau
of Fisheries.
in
46 Biology m America
him. Gray, on his part, staunchly supported Darwin in the
bitter attack which was launched against him after the
appearance of his work, although he was unable, on account
of his religious views, to accept it in its entirety. Ilis opinion
of Darwin's work is evidenced in a letter to Hooker written
in 1860. "It is done in a masterly manner. It might well
have taken twentj^ years to produce it. It is crammed full
of most interesting matter . . . au<l . . . makes out a better
case than I had supposed possible. . . . Tell Darwin all this.
... As I have promised, he and you shall have fair play
here.""
In science, as in every other field of human endeavor, it is
the individual who counts most in progress. Nevertheless
the individual works most effectively in co-operation with his
fellows. And so in the development of American science
organization has been a powerful factor.
About 1840 there was organized the Society of American
Naturalists and Geologists, which in 1848 was expanded into
the American Association for the Advancement of Science,
which has a present membership of over 12,000, divided into
twelve sections and having twenty-six societies affiliated with
it, several of which are organized in biology. The annual con-
vocation of this Association and its affiliated societies during
Christmas week serves as a "get-together" meeting, and is
a splendid stimulus to scientific work.
Fragmentary as is the foregoing account of the rise of
biology in America, it nevertheless shows us something of the
men who were pioneers in this great field, their endeavors and
achievements, their friendships and their petty jealousies;
it gives us a glimpse of the major trends of biological research
and may serve perchance as a background for the later history
of biology, its institutions, its discoveries and theories, which
is to follow.
"Darwin's "Life and Letters," p. 238. D. Appleton and Company.
CHAPTER II
Biological institutions in America. Universities and colleges,
museums, botandcal and zoological gardens, biological
stations and endowed laboratories.
Biology's service to the world has been rendered under
many auspices, chief of which has been the college and the
university. Harvard College was the first of these to be
established in America. No sooner were the early colonists
of Massachusetts Bay domiciled in the wilderness than they
began to think of education, not only for their own sons, but
also for those of their savage neighbors, hoping doubtless to
convert them to civilization as readily as they turned the forest
into fertile fields of grain.
Amidst the struggle for existence with savage men and
barren nature, in the face of privation, hardship, danger and
death; while ''the sounding aisles of the dim woods rang"
not alone to "the anthem of the free" but also to the war-
whoop of the Indian, and the gleam of burning thatch lit up
"the depths of the desert gloom;" the pilgrim fathers forgot
not posterity while thinking of themselves, and in the midst
of the wilderness established institutions of freedom, religion
and learning.
"About midnight we heard a great and hideous cry, and
our Sentinell called, Arme, Arme ! So we bestirred our selues
and shot off a couple of Muskets, and noyse ceased ; we con-
cluded, that it was a company of Wolues or Foxes, for one
told vs, hee had heard such a noise in New-found-land. About
fine a clocke in the morning wee began to be stirring, and
two or three which doubted whether their Peeces would goe
off or no, made tryall of them, and shot them off, but though
at nothing at all.
"After Prayer we prepared our selues for brek-fast, and
for a journey, and it being now the twilight in the morning,
it was thought meet to carry the things downe to the Shallop :
some sayd, it was not best to carry the Armour downe, others
sayd, they would be readier; two or three sayd, they would
not carry theirs, till they went themselues, but mistrusting
nothing at all : as it fell out, the water not being high enough,
they layd the things downe vpon the shore, & came vp to brek-
47
4S Biolofjif in A))Krlca
fast. AiKuii', ill! \ poll a sudden, we licai'd a {xrcat & strangle
(*!-y, wliicli we knew to he the saiiie voycos, tlioiigli tlioy vai'i(Ml
tlit'ir notes. One of oiu' ('oiiij)any hoiiifi: al)i'oa(l came niiniiufij
iu, and eryod Thoy ar men. Indians, Indians; and withall,
tlu'ir airows camo flying amongst vs, onr men ran out witli
all sjx'cd to reeovor their amies, as hy tlie good Providence
of God they did. In the meane time, Captainc IMiles Standish,
liaviiig a snaphanee ready, made a shot, and after liim an-
other; after they two had shot, other of vs were ready, but
lie wisht vs not to slioot, lill we eonhl take ayme, for we
knew not what need we shouki liaue, & there were fourc only
of vs, which had their armes there redie, and stood before the
open side of our Baricado, which was first assaulted ; they
thought it l)est to defend it, least the enemie should take it
and our stutt'e, and so haue the more vantage against vs;
our care was no lesse for the Shallop, but we hoped all the
rest would defent it ; we called vnto them to know how it
was with them, and they answered, AVell, AVell, every one,
and be of good courage: we heard three of their Peeces goe
off, and the rest called for a fire-brand to light their matches ;
one tooke a log out of the fire on his shoulder and went and
carried it vnto tliem, which was thought did not a little dis-
courage our enemies. The cry of our enemies was dreadfull,
especially, Avhen our men ran out to recover their Armes,
their note was aftei- this manner, Woath woach ha ha hach
woach : our men were no sooner come to their Armes, but the
enemy were ready to assault them.
"There was a luslie nmn and no whit lesse valiant, who was
thought to bee their Captaine, stood behind a tree within
halfe a musket shot of vs, and there let his arrowes fly at vs;
he was scene to shoote three arrowes, which were all avoyded,
for he at whom the first arrow was aymed, saw it, and stooped
downe and it flew over him, the rest were avoyded also: he
stood three shots of a IMusket, at length one tooke as he sayd
full ayme at him, after which he gaue an extraordinary cry
and away they went all ; wee followed them about a quarter
of a mile, but wee left sixe to keep our Shallop, for we were
carefull of our businesse: then wee shouted all together two
severall times, and shot off a couple of muskets and so
returned : this wee did that they might see wee were not
afra^^d of them nor discouraged.
"Tims it pleased God to vanquish our Enemies and giue
vs deliverance. ' ' ^
(January 23, 1697)
"T attempted, this Day, the Exercises of a secret Fast before
the Lord. But so extremely cold was the weather, that in a
>" Journal of the Pilgrims of Pljonouth," 1620, pp. 44-46.
Biological Institutions 49
ward Room, on a great Fire, the Juices forced out at the End
of short Billets of Wood, by the Heat of the Flame, on which
they were laid, yett froze into Ice, at their coming out. This
Extremity of the Cold caused mee to desist from the purpose,
which I was upon; because I saw it impossible to serve the
Lord, without such Distraction as was inconvenient.
< ( I
(January 11, 1719-20)
Tis dreadful cold. My Ink-glass in my Standish is froze
& splitt, in my very stove. My Ink in my very pen suffers a
congelation : but my witt much more. "...
"Sabbath, Jan. 24, 1686, Friday night and Satterday were
extream cold, so that the Harbour frozen up, and to the
Castle. This day so cold that the' Sacramental Bread is
frozen pretty hard, and rattled sadly as broken into the
plates. — Samuel Sewall.
"Lord's Day, Jan. 15, 1715-6. An Extraordinary Cold
Storm of Wind and Snow. Blows much worse as coming
home at Noon, and so holds on. Bread was frozen at the
Lord 's Table. . . . Though twas so Cold, yet John Tuckerman
was baptised. At six a-clock my ink freezes so that I can
hardly write by a good fire in my Wive 's Chamber. Yet was
very comfortable at Meeting. Laus Deo. — Samuel Sewall. ' ' ^
Such was the cradle of higher education in America.
In 1636 the Colony Court "agreed to give £400 towards a
schoole or collidge," which in 1637 was located at Cambridge
and later received its name from its first patron, the Rev.
John Harvard, who died in Charlestown in 1638, leaving one
half of his estate (about £800) and his library to the infant
college. The first of the buildings erected was known as "The
Indian Collidge" with rooms for twenty youthful savages,
several of whom attended, but only one of whom graduated
from it. History repeats itself in the case of many of the
"youthful savages" within its walls today. Here the first
college text-books were printed, including the Apostle Eliot's
translation of the Bible into the Indian language, primers,
grammars, tracts, etc. It is possible that the missionary spirit
of the founders of the college was not a wholly disinterested
one, since many of its funds were obtained abroad for the
express purpose of converting the heathen; or in more
materialistic terms, making a bad Christian out of a good
savage.
Harvard College was followed by William and Maiy's
College (1692), Yale (1700), Princeton (1746), the University
'Hanscom, "The Heart of the Puritan," pp. 29-30, 210. By permis-
sion of the Macmillan Company,
50 Biology in America
of Pennsylvania (1749), and King's College (now Columbia
University) in 1754. These early colleges and their succes-
sors, prior to the early part of the last century, were sup-
ported mainly by private funds, given largely in the form of
endowments; but since 1837, when the University of Michigan
Avas founded, most of the states maintain universities at public
expense. The private institutions have been, almost exclu-
sively supported by religious societies, even some of the great
universities, which today are non-sectarian, such as Harvard,
Yale and Princeton, having been originally established on a
religious basis.
The early instruction in our colleges and universities was
strictl}'^ classical. The appointment of Benjamin Silliman as
professor of chemistry and natural science at Yale in 1802,
therefore marks an epoch in the history of American educa-
tion. It is interesting to note that the young professor, at
the time of his appointment but twenty-three years of age,
was a lawyer by profession, with no knowledge whatever of
the sciences he was to teach. He says of his appointment that
it ''was of course the cause of wonder to all, and of cavil to
political enemies of the college. Although I persevered in
my legal studies ... I soon after the confidential communi-
cation of President Dwight (informing him of his probable
appointment) obtained a few books on chemistry and kept
them secluded in my secretary, occasionally reading in them
privately. This reading did not profit me much. Some gen-
eral principles were intelligible, but it became at once obvious
to me that to see and perform experiments and to become
familiar with many substances was indispensable to any
progress in chemistry, and of course I must resort to Phila-
delphia, which presented more advantage to science than any
other place in our country." ^
As Yale was the pioneer in breaking away from "the tra-
ditions of the elders," and establishing a professorship in
science, so too was it the pioneer in establishing soon after-
ward (1824) a distinct organization or school, the Sheffield
Scientific School, for scientific instruction. In 1847 a similar
organization (the Lawrence Scientific School) was established
at Harvard, and soon the teaching of science in American
colleges and universities was placed on an equal footing with
that of art and letters. At the present time indeed science,
tried alike in the fires of war and the sunshine of peace,
stands preeminent, both in education and in industry.
Biology in American schools owes its birth primarily to
Agassiz and Gray, colleagues on the Harvard faculty at the
' Merrill, * ' Contributions to the History of American Geology, ' ' after
G. P. Fisher, "Life of B. Silliman," p. 215.
Biological Institutions 51
middle of the last century. After the impelling influence of
these two great teachers, it has made a lusty growth. In early
days the college professor was supposed to be as many sided
as the country "school marm" of the present day and genera-
tion. No man was sufficiently well educated to occupy a
professor's chair unless he was an authority in at least two
major sciences, while the idea of a professor confining liis
attention to a single branch of one of these sciences was
unheard of. Today all our great universities have two en-
tirely separate departments of l^iology (botany and zoology)
each with a staff of from five to ten or more members, each
one of whom has in charge his own particular branch of the
subject. To appreciate the multiplicity of modern science
one need but turn to any recent program of a scientific society
where the papers are arranged by subjects. Thus at the 1921
meeting of the American Society of Zoologists there were
papers presented in the following branches of zoology : embry-
ology, cytology, parasitology^ evolution, genetics, ecology, dis-
tribution, general physiology, and comparative anatomy. The
average college catalog contains such a "feast of fat things"
as to impair the digestion of even the most voracious of stu-
dent "sharks."
But with the passing of the "good old days" when every
college "prof" was supposed to be a "walking encyclopedia"
has come a far more exacting age for teacher and investigator
alike, for modern standards of success demand of both a far
more encyclopedic knowledge of science, than was expected
of their forbears. The inter-relations of the many branches
of science, and their intimate dependence one upon the other,,
demands a much more extensive, and withal exact knowledge
of their subject on the part of biologists today, than was
needed in the past. Especially is this true in the field of
experimental biology, which has made such remarkable strides
in the last two decades, and which employs as its handmaidens
its sister sciences of chemistry and physics. Today indeed
chemistiy and biology are united in the new science of bio-
chemistry, one which, for possibility of discovery of the most
elusive secrets of nature, gives more promise than any other
field of scientific quest and conquest.
With this ever increasing specialization and complexity of
biology (and the same is no less true of other sciences) have
come ever increasing demands for equipment on the means
of our higher institutions of learning. Time was when the
biological laboratory was considered equipped if it possessed
a few old microscopes, hand lenses and dissecting instruments,
a little glassware, a few chemicals and some pickled caricatures
of things which were once alive. Today the work shop and
52 Biology in America
class room of the well equipped biologist contains not only
the most modern microscopes (the instrument par excellence
of biological research) but microtomes for cutting sections
of microscopic material down to a twenty-five thousandth of
an inch in thickness; electrically controlled incubators, where
cultures of microscopic organisms and growing tissues can
be held within one degree F. of any desired temperature;
electrically driven centrifuges running at speeds of from three
to four tliousand revolutions per minute; projection appa-
ratus for projecting pictures, microscopic preparations, and
even living animals themselves upon the demonstration screen,
or drawing board ; apparatus for taking photographs of these
preparations at magnifications of from one to two thousand
diameters; delicate balances for weighing down to a twenty-
five thousandth of an ounce or less, and hot houses and
aquaria where living material for study may be always avail-
able.
Such is some of the more common apparatus of the biolog-
ical laboratory. In laboratories devoted exclusively or pri-
marily to research, such as those at Woods Hole, Cold Spring
Harbor and elsewhere, reference to which will be made below,
apparatus of a special, and often costly type is usually found
in addition to the more common equipment outlined above.
The biological laboratory of college or university is not
however a separate institution especially devoted to biology,
but merely a part of a larger institution dedicated to the dis-
semination and advance of all knowledge. Yet it is through
this channel that the greatest contributions to biology have
thus far come. In considering biological institutions however
we are primarily interested in those devoted exclusively to
this science, including our museums, government and endowed
laboratories, and others of similar character.
The early history of biology in America was as we have
seen closely associated with the museums. From their mem-
bers in many instances went forth the collectors who accom-
panied the early explorers into virgin forests, across trackless
prairies and through the wild defiles of mountain fastnesses.
And it was to the museums that these collectors returned to
study and describe the treasures whicli they had found.
Numerous as are the splendid natural history museums
in America, space limits us to a brief consideration of but
three, as typical of the achievements of American science in
this field. Of our larger museums, especially those devoted
primarily to natural history, the earliest established was the
Academy of Natural Sciences in Philadelphia. The dawn of
the year 1812 was darkened by the cloud of war which hung
low over America, The one amusement house in Philadelphia,
Biological Institutions
53
the old Walnut Street Theatre, was seldom open, and the
city's youth were wont to gather in tavern and oyster house
to discuss the momentous events of the times. Under circum-
stances such as these a few young men who were interested
in natural history met at the home of one of their number on
January 25, 1812, for the organization of a society whose pur-
pose, according to the minutes of the meeting, should be "the
rational disposition of otherwise leisure moments." Their
collections at this time comprised "a few insects, corals and
The Acadkmy of Natural Sciences of Philadelphia, 1912
From the Academy "Proceedings."
shells, a dried toad fish, and a stuffed monkey." From this
primitive beginning has come the great institution which has
contributed, perhaps more than any other factor, to making
Philadelphia one of the homes, as it was the birthplace of
American biology. In the early years of the last century
Philadelphia was the Mecca of American biologists. From
here Alexander Wilson started on his ornithological travels.
Hither came Audubon, seeking support for the "Birds of
America," and through the generosity of Edward Harris, a
Philadelphian, he was enabled to nud^e his journey up the
Missouri River. Lucien Bonaparte, who continued the work
of AVilson, after the latter 's death, was for' a time resident at
54
Biology in America
Philadelphia. The early naturalist explorers, Say, Nuttall
and Townsend, were associated with the Academy at Phila-
delphia, two of whose members accompanied the famous
Wilkes Expedition to the Antarctic. The Academy was as-
sociated also with the early Arctic expeditions under Kane
and Hayes, while Peary's Greenland expedition of 1891 was
conducted under its auspices. Many are the names famous
in the annals of American biology which have been associated
with the Academy of Natural Sciences, Leidy, Cope, Cassin,
Bachman, Le Sueur, Gill, Osborn and a host of others.
The collections of the Academy, descendants of the stuffed
monkey and the dried toad of its founders, have grown to
occupy the first rank among biological exhibits in America.
While they are surpassed in size and display by those of the
American Museum of Natural History and the tj. S. National
4'm^imM^
The American Museum of Natural History in New York
Courtesy of the Museum.
Museum, for reference purposes along certain lines they are
second to none in the world. Its library too is one of the
best in America in biology, ' especially in the works of
the early writers. Pioneer among American museums the
Academy of Natural Sciences of Philadelphia has blazed many
a trail for biologists into the unknown.
It would indeed be difficult to assign a premier place to
any one museum of natural history in America, but were one
to undertake such a thankless task, his choice would be likely
to fall on the American Museum of Natural History in New
York City, which in breadth of purpose, in the extent and
value of its collections, and in its scientific achievements is
second to none in this country. Founded in 1869 it now
occupies a $4,000,000 structure in Central Park, which was
built and is maintained by the city, while the expense, of the
collections and investigations is provided for by an endow-
ment, by dues of members and by private contributions.
Biological Institutions
55
Truly may it be said of the American Museum that its
"lines have gone forth throughout all the earth, and its (men)
to the ends of the world." From frigid pole and torrid
equator, from rain-soaked forest and from sun-baked desert,
from Andean height and Amazonian jungle have come the
treasures, which constitute today one of the finest exhibits of
natural history in the world. To attempt any adequate ac-
count of the Museum and its work in this place would be out
of the question, but brief mention may be made of a few of
its more important features.
The progress of American palaeontology, outlined in another
chapter is largely due to the Museum, and its splendid col-
The Blue Shark with School op Young
Photograph of a group in the American Museum of Natural History
in New York.
Courtesy of the Museum.
lection of fossil vertebrates bears witness to the story of the
past, which its investigations have revealed.
Until comparatively recent years we have been accustomed
in our museums to display case after case and row upon row
of more or less indifferently stuffed specimens, with jar after
jar of ''pickled" snakes and turtles and case upon case of
pinned butterflies and' moths. But no hint was there of the
activities and home of the living thing. Today our best
museums, largely under the inspiration of the American
Museum, are exhibiting groups of birds and mammals, rep-
tiles, fish and other forms, illustrating their homes and lives
in Nature's setting. Here one finds for example the duck
hawks, with their nest and young perched among the rocks
The Home of the Ducit Hawk in the Hudson Palisades
l^hotoyrapli of :i gioup in the Aineiican Museum of Natural History
in New Voik.
Conrtcxii of ihc Munvum.
A Florida Swamp
Photogra})!! of a reptile group in the American Museum of Natural
History in New York.
Courtesy of the Museum.
56
Biological Institutions
57
of the Palisades, with their great walls painted in the back-
ground and the lovely Hudson flowing at their base. There
is the reedy border of a lake from central Oregon filled with
the wild fowl and their nests. Another exhibit shows a bit
of a Florida cypress swamp, with alligators of various ages
and the mother guarding the nest in which the young are
hatching from the eggs. Here too are shown many species
of snakes, and amphibians, all modeled in wax and colored
from living specimens. Yet another group illustrates the blue
shark with a school of young among the sargassum weed of the
Gulf Stream, while still another displays an oak tree in leaf
with its branches covered by hosts of the beautiful monarch
butterfly as it appears when migrating.
A unique feature in the Museum's exhibit is Darwin Hall
The Game of the ' * Men of the Old Stone Age ' '
The woolly rhinoceros, with the saiga antelope and mammoth in the
distance.
Copyrighted ty the American Museum of Natural History.
wherein are displayed groups of invertebrate animals illus-
trating the evolution of this portion of the animal kingdom
from the Protozoa to the ascidians. Among the former are
models of disease producing types such as the organisms
causing malaria and the deadly African sleeping sickness.
Here too are wax and glass models of the Malaria mosquito,
reproducing with wonderful delicacy even such minute parts
as the bristles on its body. The work of man in molding the
form of animals to his will is illustrated by cases of pigeons
and other domestic animals, while the results of modern
research in heredity are shown among other ways in the
offspring of a pair of rats, and in a demonstration of the
inheritance of color in the four o'clock.
In the Hall of the Age of Man is depicted by painting and
model the story of the "Men of the Old Stone Age" as they
lived in their cavern homes and hunted with implements of
Monarch Butterflies
Photofjraiili of a group in the American Museum of Natural History
in New York.
Courtesy ^0} the Museum.
58
Biological Institutions 59
flint the woolly rhinoceros, the mammoth, mastodon and royal
bison, which roamed the world when the glaciers held much
of the northern hemisphere within their grasp.
But the mere exhibition of nature 's wonders is by no means
the only, or even the primary function of the American
Museum. The discovery of her workings and her secrets is
fundamental to their demonstration in its halls. And so
with the gathering of material for its exhibits has gone hand
in hand the gathering and publication of information relative
thereto, much of which is rehearsed in other chapters of this
book. The spread of knowledge through research, publica-
tion and exhibition is the comprehensive function of every
museum. As further illustration of this function is the work
of the public health department of the Museum, whose pur-
pose can best be stated in the words of its curator. Its plan
is to "present a fairly comprehensive picture of the life of
man as an animal, his place in the general scheme of natural
history, his relations to his geographical and meteorological
surroundings, the parasites which cause his diseases, and the
animals and plants which serve him for food and clothing.
The plan . . . giving a survey of the cycle of human life, its
dangers and its safeguards, complete enough to satisfy the
curiosity of the ordinary man and to teach him what he needs
to know in order to keep sound and well, is an extensive
one. ..." In partial fulfilment of this plan the department
has installed exhibits of the disposal of sewage and garbage,
the water supply of cities, its relation to rainfall and the
ways of safeguarding it from pollution; the composition of
water and the microscopic organisms which it contains. Some
of the exhibits in this department are a series of models
of different sorts of bacteria, models of insect carriers of
disease, the flea, louse, yellow fever mosquito and the house-
fly. The mosquito exhibit shows among other things the
condition of the French hospitals in Panama, as compared
with those installed by the Americans, the life history of
mosquitoes and methods of combating them by oiling, drain-
age, fumigation, etc. The department also maintains a grow-
ing collection of living bacteria including hundreds of
different varieties, from which were sent out in 1918 over
3,000 cultures free of charge to laboratories throughout the
country.
During the Great War the Museum aided in the food con-
servation movement by the preparation of a food exhibit
illustrating the character of food, its use in human metabolism,
the adjustment of the daily ration to meet the increasing cost
of living, and showing some new and as yet little used sources
of food, such as seaweeds, snails, mussels, cuttle fish, etc.
60
Biology in Ama'ica
Sueli in brief arc a few of the activities of this splendid
institution.
One of tlie best additions to the architecture of the new
"Washington is tlie buildin<j: of the National Museum located
on the "IMall" or park, which stretches westward from the
Capitol to the Potomac River. The building is a simple, but
imposing structure of white granite and so arranged as to
provide the greatest amount of floor space possible in the
IS'ew iSouRCES OF Aquatic Food, Kelp, Snails, Mussels and Squid
Photograph of a group in the American Museum of Natural History
in New York.
Courtesy of the Mu^'^eum.
area covered. Here are housed the natural history and an-
thropological collections of the U. S. Government, whose
formation was begun by the Wilkes exploring expedition
around the world in 1838-1842.
In 18-46 the Smithsonian Institution was established by
act of Congress in accordance with the will of the English
mineralogist James Smithson, who left an estate of about a
half million dollars to the United States for the "increase
and diffusion of knowledge among men." This act made the
National Museum a part of the Smithsonian Institution. The
early collections of the government were augmented partly
Biological Institutions
61
through the personal efforts of Professor Baird, the then as-
sistant secretary of the Institution, and partly througli the ef-
forts of the scientists wlio accompanied the ji'overmneiit sur-
veys sent out about the middle of the last century. Professor
Baird awakened the interest of officers of the army and navy,
fishermen, fur traders, private explorers and members of the
Hudson's Bay and Western Union Telegraph Companies in
the collection of natural history objects, and in this way a
large amount of valuable material was secured by the
Institution. Since its establishment the National Museum
The U. S. National Museum
One of the architectural features of the new Washington.
Courtesy of the Museum.
has become the regular repository of the splendid collections
made by the U. S. Biological Survey, the Bureau of Fisheries,
the Bureaus of Animal and Plant Industry, and the U. S.
Geological Survey. IMuch material has also been gathered
through the expeditions of the Smithsonian Institution itself.
The ethnological exhibits of the Museum are perhaps its
finest productions, but it has many beautiful groups of birds
and mammals as well, and a splendid collection of fossils.
Its research work and resultant publications are largely
technical, consisting of the monographing and description of
groups and species of animals and plants in its collections.
One of its important educational features is the distribution
62 Biology in America
of duplicate sets of specimens to schools and colleges through-
out the country. It also fills an important place as a conven-
tion center, not only for the scientific societies of Washington,
but for national and international gatherings as well.
Another group of biological institutions are the zoological
and botanical gardens and aquaria, upon the possession of
one or more of which nearly every city of any size in America
prides itself.
Established primarily for purposes of display, some of
these institutions have performed a much more important
service in adding to our knowledge of the animals and plants
which they contain. A brief account of a few of them will
serve to illustrate their place in American biologj'.
A leader in this, as in other lines of science, Philadelphia
established a zoological garden as early as 1859. Along the
banks of the Schuylkill River in Fairmount Park are housed
the extensive collections of the Zoological Society, which are
supported in part by the city, in part by memberships and
partly by paid admissions to the garden. The grounds of the
Society and its financial means are too small to admit of
either the best enclosures for its animals or their proper
scientific study. It furnishes considerable material however
to the Academy of Natural Sciences of Philadelphia, and
maintains a pathological laboratory for the study of diseases
infecting its stock.
In 1807 the United States built a fort called the Southwest
Battery, and later Castle Clinton, on the lower end of Man-
hattan Island, from which this section of New York has
derived its name of "the Battery." In 1823 it was given
to the city for an amusement hall known as Castle Garden,
which welcomed several presidents and other distinguished
visitors, including the Hungarian patriot, Kossuth ; and its
walls frequently echoed the wonderful notes of Jenny Lind.
From 1855 to 1890 over 7,500,000 immigrants passed through
its doors. In 1896 it became a public aquarium, passing in
1902 under the control of the New York Zoological Society,
which was chartered in 1895. While the housing and equip-
ment of the aquarium are wholly inadequate, it nevertheless
maintains one of the largest and best aquaria of both salt
and fresh water fishes in the world.
The Zoological Society maintains gardens in Bronx Park,
in New York, which have in a few years joined the ranks of
the leading zoological gardens of the world, and share with
the National Zoological Park in Washington the first place
for institutions of this kind in America.
The old style zoological garden was an animal prison
where animals large and small were confined in cages just
Biological Institutions 63
large enough to permit them to turn around easily, and
where the "convicts" dragged out a miserable existence for
a few years until relieved by death, seldom leaving offspring
to inherit their unhappy fate. Today, in gardens such as
those in New York and Washington, the animals are kept,
as far as may be, in large open enclosures, where they can
live under as nearly natural conditions as possible. Under
such conditions they are healthy and contented and frequently
rear families.
But the New York Zoological Society has not confined
itself solely to the show business. Its studies of wild life
have been its most valuable contributions both to science and
popular education, and today our inhabitants of land and
sea, our dwellers in forest, field, and lake and river are be-
coming objects of familiar acquaintance through the writings
of Hornaday, Ditmars and Townsend, as well as through the
splendid collections at the "Bronx" and the "Battery" in
New York City.
A recent and important enterprise of the Society is the
Tropical Research Station at Kalacoon, near Georgetown, in
British Guiana, with C. W. Beebe, curator of birds at the
New York Zoological Park, as its director. The object of
this station is a study of life in the tropical jungle, with
the more ample equipment of the permanent laboratory
taking the place of the scanty means of the exploring
naturalist, through whose labors our knowledge of tropical
life has thus far mainly been acquired. The recent estab-
lishment of this station, with its more or less improvised
equipment, has not led to any large results thus far, although
a number of delightful essays by the director recently pub-
lished under the title of "Jungle Peace" form a distinct
^.ontribution both to literature and to popular science.
The first botanical garden in America was that of John
Bartram in Philadelphia, to which brief reference has been
made in the previous cliapter.
One of the pioneer figures in American botany was Geo.
Engelmann, the St. Louis botanist-physician, contemporary
of Gray at Harvard and Torrey at Columbia. Engelmann
had a friend in Henry Shaw the wealthy merchant and lover
of plants. During his extensive travels in Europe Shaw
formed the idea of a botanical garden at his country place
on the outskirts of St. Louis. From Engelmann he obtained
advice and encouragement, and through him started a library
and herbarium. Upon Engelmann 's death in 1885 Mr. Shaw
founded the Henry Shaw School of Botany in Washington
University and in it established the Engelmann professorship
in memory of his friend and tutor. On Mr. Shaw's death
64
Biology in America
the garden passed into tlic hands of a board of trustees to be
administered as a public garden and a research school of
botany.
On this foundation has risen the Missouri Botanical Garden
of the present, with its splendid conservatories and her-
barium; its library containing among thousands of modern
botanical works some of the rarest of those dealing with the
earliest studies on the exploration of plant and animal life
in America ; and its research laboratory where the faculty
and graduate students of botany in the university may
A Glimpse of the New York Botanical Garden
Courtesy 0/ the Garden.
prosecute their studies. The popular conception of a
botanical garden as that of a museum of living plants for
display purposes is admirably realized in the arboretum and
conservatories of the garden, while the less popular, but far
more important function of research is equally well per-
formed in its well equipped laboratories. The field of
activity covered by the garden is limited only by the bounds
of botanical knowledge. No problem is too abstruse or too
practical for its attention. In all of its educational features,
in display as well as in research, the Garden occupies one of
the most important places in American botany.
Biological Institutions
65
Similar in conception to the Missouri Botanical Garden
is the New York Botanical Garden in the Bronx Park in
New York City, which was established in 1891 through the
initiative of the Torrey Botanical Club, which takes its name
from one of its founders, the pioneer botanist, John Torrey,
who, like others of his early colleagues, was well versed in
other sciences than that in which he earned his reputation.
Commencing his career as a physician he subsequently
became professor of the natural sciences at West Point, the
A View of the Arnold Arboretum with Bank of Laurel on the Left
Courtesy of Professor Sargent.
College of Physicians and Surgeons, the College of the City
of New York, Princeton and Columbia, and was for many
years assay er in the New York assay office. On Torrey fell
the duty, among others, of working up the collections of
plants gathered by the many exploring expeditions, which
at this time were pushing the frontier of America out
through the trackless west.
On the outskirts of Boston is one of the most beautiful
and unique collections of plants in the world. The Arnold
Arboretum is the joint product of Boston and Harvard
A Bit of the "Forest Primeval"
A hemlock grove in the Arnold Arboretum.
Courtesy of Professor Sargent.
m
Biological Institutions 67
University. It was established about fifty years ago by a
gift of $100,000 by James Arnold of New Bedford, and the
setting apart of a tract of some 200 acres by joint arrange-
ment between the city and the university. It forms at the
same time a part of the splendid park system of Boston, and
a "museum of living trees." Here are gathered together
trees and shrubs from temperate climes in all the world, the
old New England hemlocks, a bit of the "forest primeval"
of the Pilgrim fathers, the firs and spruces of the Rocky
Mountains, the oaks of England, the cedars of Lebanon, and
the funereal cypress of China, with roses and cherries from
far away Japan.
In the arrangement of the grounds formality has been
thrown to the winds. AVell trimmed lawns, rows of trees
and flower beds with square corners have been subordinated
to Nature's beautiful carelessness in the planning of the
gardens. And yet through all the apparent disorder, there
runs an orderly arrangement whereby related plants are
brought together, and each family of tree and shrub has its
own appointed place in the general plan.
Under the direction of Professor Sargent, head of the Ar-
boretum, has been developed a museum, library and herbarium
containing specimens of the wood of all American trees,
showing its structure when cut with or across the grain, and
when polished or smooth. There are records also of the
physical character of different woods, their specific gravity,
heat value, amount of ash, etc. The herbarium contains a
collection of woody plants from all parts of the world, while
the libraiy is one of the best collections on trees in existence.
From the Arboretum have come Professor Sargent 's ' ' Silva
of North America," a classic on American trees. Here too was
written his "Forest Flora of Japan," the result of extended
travel and research in that country. As author of the report
on our forests in the tenth census, the director of the Arbor-
etum brought to the notice of the people of the United States
their wonderful, but rapidly vanishing timber resources, and
paved the way for the development of forest conservation and
the establishment of our forest reserves.
The Arboretum also has served as pioneer and guide in the
establishment of botanical gardens elsewhere, both private
and public, aiding notably in the development of the New
York Botanical Garden. JMany new importations from
abroad have been tested here, including those of commercial
as well as artistic value. Of these might be mentioned among
many others, the tung oil, lacquer, pistachio and hardy rul)her
trees of China, brought from the Celestial Kingdom by the
68
Biology in America
indefatigable and hardy explorer of the Arboretum, Mr. E. H.
Wilson.
Devoted to the study of biology, both here and abroad, are
numerous institutions or biological stations, which have, and
are exercising a wonderful influence upon its growth.
An exact definition of a biological station is impossible.
The term is generally referred however to institutions, apart
from college laboratories, dealing usually with aquatic biology
and often operating only a part of the year, but such a
definition is by no means exclusive.
The Main Building of the Marine Biological Laboratory at Woods
Hole, Mass.
This is porliaps the leading center of biology in America and one of
the foremost in the world. There gather here each summer many of the
leading biologists from all parts of the United States; and in it have
been made some of the most important discoveries in biology.
In America the seed from which biological stations have
sprung was the primitive laboratory of Louis Agassiz at
Penikese, conducted during the summer of 1873 ; where in an
old barn, with the twittering swallows flying in and out
beneath the eaves, and from whose open door a glimpse of
cloud-flecked sky and foam-flecked sea could be seen across
the heather, this great student-teacher gathered a little band
of enthusiasts to catch the fire of his imagination and carry
it throughout the land. Anointed with the spirit of the master
Biological Institutions
69
this little group of apostles went forth to spread his teach-
ings across America, and a Jordan and a Brooks have passed
the torch to their students, and they in turn to others in an
ever widening circle of living truth.
The laboratory at Penikese was abandoned the following
year owing to the death of Agassiz, but a worthy successor
was soon to follow in the Marine Biological Laboratory at
Woods Hole, which was founded in 1888 by Professor Alpheus
Hyatt of Boston, and a group of naturalists and their friends.
Woods Hoi^, Mass.
In the middle background is the ' ' Fish Hawk, ' ' and to the right the
buildings of the U. S. Bureau of Fisheries. In the foreground is the sea
bottom, with a group of its inhabitants.
Courtesy of the American Museum of Natural History.
For many years the work at Woods Hole was, and to a
large extent still is conducted in flimsy wooden buildings, of
the cheapest sort of temporary construction. But in 1914
through the generosity of Chas. R. Crane, the patron saint
of the laboratory, a substantial and commodious building was
erected, which is well furnished with modern equipment in
biology.
A detailed account of the work at Woods Hole would
require several volumes in itself, and is out of the question
here, but its principal results are mentioned elsewhere in
70
Biology in America
connection with the general account of biological progress in
America. Its character has been as varied as that of the men
who have conducted it, a list of whose names would include
Typical Wharf Pile Community of the New England Coast
Submerged timbers form the home of a wide variety of sessile animals
including sponges, hydroids, sea anemones, barnacles, mussels and sea
squirts. The immobility of the anemones and hydroids, and their deli-
Rate flower-like habit, led the great Greek naturalist, Aristotle, to give
the name of zoophytes (animal plants) to these and similar forms. It
was such surroundings as this which attracted Agassiz to Penikese.
Courtesy of the American Museum of Natural History.
the leaders of American biology from the Atlantic to the
Pacific and from Canada to the Gulf of Mexico.
Woods Hole may well be called the ' ' Naples of America, ' '
the Mecca to which in ever increasing numbers biologists
make pilgrimage each year. Who that has been there does
Biological Institutions 71
not carry away with him a memory and an inspiration? A
memory of the "hole" with its foaming eddies, of the "eel-
pond" with its landing stage and launches, and the "stone
building" where the genial head of the supply department
presides over an incongruous medley of flopping dogfish, five-
rayed starfish and bristling sea urchins, which the "Caya-
detta" has just brought in from the fish trap in Buzzard's
Bay, or dredged from the rocky bottom of Vineyard Sound.
A. memory of wind swept heath, where the song sparrow
rears it brood, of gently curving beach, white shining in the
summer's sun; of rocky headlands, where the seaweeds grow
and the sea anemone clings fast to its home uncovered by the
falling tide ; of the lighthouse on the point and the buoy
with its never silent bell ; of white sails upon the Sound, and
the dim shores of Martha's Vinej^ard fading into the soft
gray blue of the summer haze and sky. An inspiration of
the bigness of things, of all there is to do and the joy of doing,
of knowledge sought for the sake of knowing, a touch of the
fire from the altar of Penikese, lit by the hand of Agassiz,
the master.
Fast following the pioneer of biological stations in
America came a number of lesser stations, at first along the
Atlantic seaboard, and later in the Mississippi Valley, on the
shores of the Pacific, and in the Rocky Mountains. These,
for the most part, have been merely summer schools conducted
in conjunction with the department of biology in some college
or university. In some however notably La Jolla, Calif.,
Havana, 111., and Casco Bay, Me., the emphasis has 'been
placed upon research, and much original work of great value
has been done. The first of these, under the title of the
Scripps Institution for Biological Research, because of the
generous patronage of a wealthy La Jolla family, is an
adjunct of the Department of Zoology of the University of
California. In the earlier years of its existence it was, so to
speak, a traveling laboratory, occupying temporary quarters
at various points on the California Coast and finally locating
permanently at La Jolla. The Scripps Institution is one of
the few biological stations in the country whose physical
equipment is adequate to the work it tries to do. The
laboratory building is simple, almost to harshness in its
architecture, in fitting harmony with the barren landscape
round about ; but its interior appointments and equipment are
very complete. Its principal etforts thus far have been
directed to the study of the smaller marine animals or
plankton of the southern California Coast, and the factors
in their environment which determine their distribution, but
attention has also been turned in recent years to certain land
72 Biology in America
animals (wood mice of the genus Peromyscus) and the
influence of climate on their evolution. The Seripps Institu-
tion is probably unique among similar institutions in America
in the enlistment of both private and public agencies in its
support. Recently the legislature of California has con-
tributed substantially to it and this in spite of the fact that
its work is avowedly of a purely scientific character, and that
no attempt has been made to arouse interest under the
specious plea of some practical end to be gained at some
future time.
"Two years ago when the first allotment was made by the
state to the university for the institution, and this year when
an increase was asked, representatives of the state visited
the institution, went over with the scientific staff and business
manager in considerable particularity the work being prose-
cuted, and were unequivocally assured that the problems
under investigation are all first and foremost scientific, and
that only some of them might be expected to have a money
value to the state.
"Great emphasis was, however, laid by the men of the insti-
tution on the two facts that all increase of knowledge of
nature is capable of being made useful to the people of the
commonwealth in one way and another, either for their
enlightenment or pleasure or material gain ; and that the
institution holds itself under as much obligation to make its
discoveries utilizable in some form as it does to prosecute the
investigations themselves. . . . From what California has
done toward maintaining the Lick Observatory through a
considerable term of years, and is now doing for the Seripps
Institution, the conclusion seems justified that the state is
definitely committed to the principle of state aid to scientific
research, even though such research has no direct and primary
industrial aims. In discussing these matters with officials, I
stoutly contend that in the long run about the most telling
criterion of success of popular government will be the extent
to which it contributes to the highest development, spiritual
and physical, of the naturally best endowed persons who live
under and who participate in such government. The facts
and reasonings that can be presented in support of this
proposition, particularly those touching the question oi
leadersliip in scientific discovery, seem to appeal with special
force to men grappling earnestly with the practical problems
of government for a modern community.
"Experience strongly. inclines me to the view that the seri-
ous dereliction of our national and several state governments
in the support of scientific investigation is chargeable quite as
Biological Institutions
73
much to scientific men themselves as to government officers
and the people at large. ' ' *
Surely it is cause for congratulation to science in general,
and to this institution and its director in particular, when
our strictly practical legislators can be made to see the value
to the state of science for its own sake.
In addition to the Scripps Institution several other
laboratories have been privately endowed within recent years.
Apart from the Marine Biological Laboratory at Woods
Hole, which is of much longer standing, these laboratories
^Ml^l^^^l^^..
'----^
1
i,..-, ,; — ,-,.. ,„
• .rT%^
^^K^SS^^^B^K^^BBttBBB
.
•
Buildings of the Station for ExPERiiiENfAL Evolution of the Car-
negie Institution at Cold Spring Harbor, L. I.
Here are being conducted important researches into the laws of in-
heritance in plants and animals, and in conjunction with this station
the Eugenics Record Office is laying the foundation for an intelligent
treatment of marriages and the breeding of a better human race.
After Davenport. Year Book of the Carnegie Institution for 19Vf.
have contributed more to biology than all other biological
stations in America combined, and their promise for the
future is correspondingly greater. These are the three
biological laboratories of the Carnegie Institution and its
Department of Embryology, and the Rockefeller Institute
for Medical Research. It is true that the latter is primarily
a medical institution, as its name implies, but the intimate
association of medicine with biology, and the fact that one of
its departments is devoted exclusively to biology, entitles it
*Eitter in "Science/' Vol. XLII, 1915, p. 245-246.
74 Biology in America
to consideration here. The Wistar Institute of Anatomy in
Philadelphia, and the Bussey Institution of Harvard Univer-
sity should also be included.
Tlie three Carnegie stations are known respectively as the
"Department of Experimental Evolution" at Cold Spring
Harbor, L. I., the "Department of Botanical Research" at
Tucson, Ariz., and the "Department of Marine Biology" on
tlie Dry Tortngas Keys oft' the Florida Coast. These were
all established between 1903 and 1906, shortly after the found-
ing of the Institution by Mr. Carnegie. The first of these
is, as its name implies, devoted to a study of evolution and
its twin sister, or better, its right hand, heredity. As early
as 1617 Francis Bacon advocated an institution for studying
evolution experimentally, but not until the early years of
the twentieth century was his suggestion realized. Its major
w^ork has been the study of inheritance in many kinds of
animals and plants, the influence of external factors, such
as alcohol, light, etc., upon the structure and evolution of
animals, the influence of selection in evolution, the role of the
chromosomes in inheritance, and the underlying factors of
sex.
The physical equipment of an institution such as this
emphasizes the specialization of biology today, and its
dependence upon other sciences. Apart from the usual
apparatus of the biological laboratory and the extensive pens
and stabling required for housing the stock, there is an
artificial cave with aquaria for studies upon cave animals, a
well equipped chemical laboratoiy, and constant temperature
rooms arranged in pairs, one pair for dry and one for moist
air, so that experimental animals can be kept in warm or cold,
dry or moist chambers.
The site of the station and the adjoining laboratory of the
Brooklyn Institute of Arts and Sciences are the picturesque
shores of Cold Spring Harbor, a long narrow inlet from Long
Island Sound. On the opposite shore is tiie straggling little
village of the same name, which in days gone by was one of
the whaling ports of Long Island.
Perhaps the most important outcome of the station's work
has been the Eugenics Record Office, established at Cold
Spring Ifarl)or in 1910, through the generosity of Mrs. E. H.
Harriman. The function of the Ofifice is the recording of
human inheritance, to the ultimate end of gaining greater
knowledge tliereof, which may lead to its improvement.^ It
collects recoi'ds of family traits, which records are kept in a
sextuple card index of persons, traits and localities; enabling
an investigator to readily trace a given trait in both the
families and the localities of its occurrence, to determine the
Biological Institutions
75
families and traits occurring in any locality, and finally to
find the location of a given family and the traits peculiar to
it. The Office has extensive collaboration with charitable and
penal institutions throughout the country, by means of which
it obtains very valuable data regarding the occurrence and
inheritance of many defects in man, both mental and physi-
cal ; and finally it conducts a training school for workers in
human inheritance, with a view to preparing them for service
in such institutions.
Baked in the scorching rays of the Arizona sun lies
Tumamoc Hill, the Hill of the Turtle in the Navajo tongue.
Desert Botanical Laboratory
The deserts of Arizona have been invaded by the biologist, offering
as they do a specially attractive field for studies of the influence of
environment on both animals and plants. At this station of the Carnegie
Institution of Washington at Tucson, Arizona, many important discov-
eries have been made as to how plants adapt themselves to a desert
environment.
Courtesy 0/ the Bureau of Commerce of Tucson.
On its slopes, covered with the rocky debris of some convul-
sion of the earth long past, grows the giant cactus, gaunt and
misshapen by day, spectral and weird by night. Its summit
overlooks a tumbled junk heap of hills and hollows suggestive
of the thought that the Creator became hurried at the last
moment and did not have time to put the finishing touches
on the wilderness. At its foot lies the Santa Cruz Valley
with the city of Tucson, and across the valley, sharply out-
lined against the deep azure of the desert sky, rise the bold
commanding shapes of the Santa Catalina Mountains, with
7fi Biology in America
the lure of the forest and its cold fresh streams within their
depths.
Ilerc has the Desert Lahoratory of the Carnegie Institution
found its home in a long, low stone building on the summit of
Tumamoc Hill, with an adjoining greenhouse, and a small
photo-chemical laboratory nearl)y. Tlic efforts of the Depart-
ment have been devoted to a study of deserf^ conditions and
their effect upon the plant life of the region. In conjunction
with a small branch laboratory at Carmel, near Monterey,
California, extensive studies have been carried on upon the
influence of climate on the form of plants. Various species
of plants have been transplanted from their cool, moist home
in the Santa Catalina Mountains to the experimental gardens
at Tucson, and vice versa, and interchanged between the
Arizona Desert and the cool, dani]) California Coast Avith
consequent marked changes in their form. In order to see
how "the other half" of the plant world lives, expeditions
have been sent to the Sahara Desert, and the tropical forests
of Jamaica. Studies on the revegetation of the Salton Sea
area have been carried on for several years. This is a brackish
water lake in southern California, originally over 400 square
miles in extent, which was formed in 1905 by the overflow
of the Colorado River through an irrigation canal leading to
the Imperial Valley. In the arid climate of southern Cali-
fornia this lake has fallen to about one-half its original depth
of 84 feet, leaving wide stretches of lake bottom exposed,
where new vegetation may arise. From such studies much
can be learned as to the development of plant life in our arid
southwest.
At one time Great Salt Lake extended over a much wider
area than now, reaching an extent of nearly 20,000 square
miles, and a depth of 1,000 feet, as can be determined by the
old shore lines on the mountain slopes in northwestern IJtah.
To this greater Great Salt Lake the name of Lake Bonneville
has been given, from the doughty captain, whose wanderings
in the far west have been so picturesquely portrayed by
Irving in his "Captain Bonneville." To the southwest of
Lake Bonneville stretched the wide expanse of Lake Lahontan,
named from the explorer La Hontan. In the heyday of their
existence, following the retreat of the ice of the Glacial period,
these lakes received a copious supply, but Nature early put
into effect some "bone dry laws" in this region, and now the
site of Lake Lahontan is an arid waste clothed in sage brush
and cactus and inhabited by the coyote, prairie dog, burrow-
ing owl, rattlesnake and horned toad, with here and there a
'The term "desert" as applied to this region is a misnomer; arid
tableland or steppe would be better.
Biological Institutions 77
lonely, but optimistic ranchman and a few salt ponds, rem-
nants of its former glory; while Great Salt Lake is but a
vestige of its former self.
Today one may find in Salton Sea a repetition of the story
of Lakes Bonneville and Lahontan, while on its shores Nature
is showing us how she clothes the desert.
We are all familiar with the "oldest inhabitant" and we
enjoy listening to him as he smokes his pipe and conjures up
memories of the past through the curling wreaths of blue
smoke, but we are wont to be a bit skeptical when he tells
us of the ''old-fashioned New England winter," when fences
presented no barriers to the sleighs, and the farmer had to
tunnel through snow in the morning to reach the barn, and
feed his cattle. But now comes the scientist to the aid of
the "oldest inhabitant" and tells us that after all climates,
like peoples, do change, and that the pictures of the "good
old days" may not be as highly colored as we sometimes fancy
them to be. To gain his information Professor Ellsworth
Huntington of Yale has quite rightly gone to the "oldest
inhabitants" of America, dwellers of the forest, some of whom
were living at the time of Moses, and were creatures of
antiquity in the days of Jesus Christ. To most of us indeed
the Sequoia, or California "big tree," is a veritable Sphinx,
a creature of the past whom we revere both for its lordly
mien and its great antiquity, but one with whom we cannot
hold converse. But Professor Huntington has learned to read
the "riddles of the Sphinx" and in his monogi'aph on the
"Climatic Factor" he has told us its story. Each year's
growth of a tree leaves its mark upon its stem in the form of
a ring of wood, so that, not only does the stem give us a
record of the age of the tree, but also of the amount of each
year's growth, which is measured by the thickness of the ring.
From a study of the stumps of many fallen trees, Professor
Huntington has reached conclusions relative to the "fat
years," when the trees made a good growth, and the "lean
years" of the past, when growth was slight. But the amount
of growth of a tree depends upon the amount of moisture
which it receives, and thus Professor Huntington has deter-
mined the relative amounts of annual rainfall for several thou-
sand years in the past.
But not alone in the trunks of the big trees can the story
of the past be read. In the waters and the old shore lines of
lakes may a record too be found. The water of every river
contains a certain amount of dissolved substances, washed
from the land by rain, which finds its way as "run-off" into
the rivers. Thus through countless ages has the ocean
acquired its salt, the contribution of land to sea. When a lake
78
Biology in America
has both inlet and outlet, its water is being continually
changed, and consequently it contains nearly the same amount
of salt from year to year. But if a change of climate occurs,
sg that evaporation exceeds precipitation, the lake begins to
shrink, its outlet is lost and the salts which are carried into
the lake by its tributary rivers accumulate, and a little inland
sea is formed. Thus have arisen the various salt lakes and
inland seas such as the Caspian, the Dead Sea and Great Salt
Lake. If now we measure the amount of w^ater carried by
the tributary rivers of a closed lake, and determine the amount
of salts cai'i-i(^d by them, wo cnii estimate the number of j-ears
Shore op Salton Sea, Showing Old Lake Level ix Background
The character of the beaches of extiuct lakes gives a ckie to the
weather of the past.
After MacDougal.
required for the lake to acquire its present degree of saltiness
since the time when it had an outlet. Such measurements are
at best approximate, due largely to the fact that when rain-
fall was greater the rivers carried a greater amount of salt
than they do at present, but Avhen compared with the testi-
mony of the old shore lines, they furnish a means for
determining probably to within 50 or 100 years the periods
of heavy and light rainfall in the past.
These ancient lake beaches can often be traced for miles
with the greatest ease. When a lake maintains the same level
for a number of years it leaves an unmistakable record "on
the sands" or gravels ''of time" in a clear-cut beach or
terrace, where the waves have undermined and cut away the
Biological Institutions 79
banks, and the stronger the wave action, the more ch-arly
marked will the terrace be. AVhen, on the other hand, llic
lake is receding;, the terraces will be wanting or ill-deliiicd,
and the shores gradually sloping. Thus a series of terraces,
in an old lake basin, with intervening slopes, means a suc-
cession of alternating wet and dry periods in the past, during
the former of which the water supply was sufficient to main-
tain the lake at a constant level, while during the latter the
level was steadily falling. Still further evidence may be
obtained from submerged forests. The bottom of Stump
Lake, N. Dak., at one time part of the much larger glacial
lake, Minnewaukon, was years ago covered by a forest, as is
evidenced by the stumps, many (f which are still lying
on the old lake bottom, now being exposed by the progressive
shrinkage of the lake from excessive evaporation. This
forest contained trees probably very similar to those at present
growing about the lake shore. Thus, within comparatively
recent times,^ Stump Lake was successively part of a con-
siderable body of water, then dry land (at least in part, the
extent of the submerged forest not being known) for a suffi-
ciently long period to allow of the growth of forest trees of
considerable size; again it became a lake submerging the
forest and now for the second time it is disappearing. This
evidence is borne out by terraces beneath the present lake
level and by piles of boulders in the lake which show evidence
of the work of ice in their formation.
And so Professor Huntington and his colleagues have
called npon Pyramid and Winnemucca Lakes, in western
Nevada, remnants of the old glacial Lake Lahontan, and
Owens and Mono Lakes in California to testify ; and their
evidence has supported that of the "big trees," and the words
of earth and tree have in their turn been verified by the pages
of history. According to the evidence it is about 2,000 years
since these lakes had an outlet, so that during the Christian
era they have been gradually shrinking, oscillating up and
down with the varying rainfall of the centuries.
"The lakes do more than indicate a change of climate
within two or three thousand years. They also show that the
change has been highly irregular. This is proved by a large
number of strands lying below the level of the outlets, and
by the way in which these vary in character and in the extent
to which they have been covered by fresh detritus washed
down from the mountains. At Owens Lake there are four
series of strands. These apparently correspond to the four
chief periods when the climate has grown moist as shown by
the growth of the big trees. , . . Fortunately, Owens Lake
* Since the Glacial Epoch.
80 Biology in America
lies only fii'ty miles east of the region where the trees were
measured. The general climatic fluctuations of both districts
are the same. The uppermost strand, the huge gravel beach
at the level of tlic outlet, must date from about the time of
Christ, for both the chemical evidence and the trees point to
this conclusion. A series of similar, but much smaller
beaches at lower levels record the approach of a dry period
during which the lake fell to a low level whose exact position
cannot be determined. Judging by the trees this must have
culminated about 650 A.D. During this period gravels were
washed in by mountain streams and deposited in what are
known as fans, or low, flattened cones, which may be several
miles long. These covered the old strands in many places,
and extended far below their level to the diminished lake.
"Next the waters rose again, but not halfway to their
former level. They formed two small strands, 2iot gravelly
like their predecessors, but faint and sandy as if the winds
were weak. They must date from about- 1000 A.D., when the
trees indicate a wet period, for they are younger than the
gravel fans of the preceding dry time. The next phase of
the lake was a dry period, which was most extreme about
1250 A.D. More gravels were then deposited, and the fact
that they cover the preceding strands and extend to a much
lower level shows that the lake then stood low, as would be
expected from the trees.
"The next high period of the lake, about 1350 A.D. accord-
ing to the trees, is unusually interesting. The water did not
reach so high a level as formerly, because the rainy period
was short, but it formed a large, high beach of gravel quite
different from the preceding beaches. This seems to indicate
great storminess, a condition which is also suggested by the
fact that the growth of the trees at this time increased more
rapidly than at any other period for nearly 3000 years. In
Europe during the same century, unprecedented storms
caused great floods in France, while the severity of the waves
was so intense as to break through beaches and sand dunes,
and convert large marshy areas into portions of the sea along
the coasts of Holland and Lincolnshire. During the winters
the rivers froze to an unheard-of degree, and three or four
times men and animals passed from Germany to Sweden on
the solid ice of the Baltic Sea, an occurrence unknown in our
day. In England the summers were so rainy that the average
yield of grain diminished disastrously. In self-defense many
landowners gave up gta in-raising, and turned their attention
to sheep and cattle. Distress and discontent were the inevit-
able result among the peasants. Far away in central Asia
the Caspian Sea and the lake of Lop Nor both rose with great
Biological histihitions 81
rapidity between 1300 and 1350 A.D. Thus from California
to China evidence of various kinds unites to indicate that
during the fourteenth century there occurred a short period
of unusual stormiuess. Such conditions, if intensified and
prolonged, would probably cause the accumulation of enor-
mous glaciers. ' ' ^
Professor Huntington's studies on the influence of climate
upon human life form one of the most interesting and valuable
contributions to history of recent years. He has shown for
example that the wonderful civilization of the Mayas in
Guatemala and Yucatan, in a region where today death stalks
through the jungle and human energy is at its lowest ebb, is
explicable on the hypothesis of a different climate in these
regions in past years, an hypothesis supported by his evidence
obtained from lake and tree. He has similarly traced the
histoiy of man in Asia and Europe and likewise discovered
there the profound influence of nature upon his ways.
These climatic changes appear to be in some way determined
by solar activity as evidenced by the number of "sun spots."
But these most interesting hypotheses would lead us too far
aside from our proper path were we to pursue them further.
Much of Professor Huntington's work was carried on
through the Department of Botanical Research, and his
results are among the most interesting and valuable of its
contributions to science.
On a small tract of land in the Santa Cruz Valley belonging
to the Department are the experimental gardens, where for
a number of years Professor Tower of the University of Chi-
cago has been conducting his experiments on the potato
beetles, reference to which is made elsewhere. In the physico-
chemical laboratory extensive investigations are in progress
on the physical and chemical factors involved in the process
of photosynthesis ; or the work of the sun through the chloro-
phyl of the green plant in taking the raw materials of earth
and air and Avater and constructing from them the starches
and the sugars which the plant uses as its food. Many other
are the activities of the Department which occupies a unique
and indispensable place in American research.
Surrounded by the blue waters of the tropical sea,
scorched by the sun, deluged by the torrential rains and
swept by the cyclones of the tropics lie a string of little
islands off the southern extremity of the coast known as the
Florida Keys. On one of the gi-oups, named by the early
Spaniards, from the abundance of their aboriginal inhabitants,
the sea turtles, the Dry Tortugas, is located the Department
^Huntington, "Civilization and Climate," pp. 235-7. By permission
of the Yale University Press.
82
Biology in America
of Marine Biology of the Carnegie Institution. Surrounded
by coral reefs, where lurk the countless denizens of the
southern seas, in a healthful environment, and with the
resources of the Carnegie Institution behind it, the Tortugas
laboratory has enjoyed a situation unique in the histoiy of
biology. How well it has profited by this opportunity e^an
best be told by the results which it has produced, many of
which are referred to in other chapters without especial
The Garden of the Tortugas Laboratory
Much has been done to render this wind-swept isle a spot of beauty.
The coral reefs surrounding these islands abound in tropical plants and
animals, many of great beauty and all of fascinating interest.
Courtesy of Dr. A. G. Mayer, Director of the Latoratory.
reference to the source whence they have come. It would be
impossible in this place to mention these results in detail, or
even to single out those of seemingly most importance. No
general line of research has been pursued, the only limiting
conditions being that the researches should be devoted to
problems of tropical life.
In addition to the local researches of the laboratory, visits
have been made in its staunch little ship, the "Anton Dohrn,"
to distant regions, through the Caribbean Archipelago, to
Jamaica, Porto Rico, and even to the Great Barrier Reef of
Biological Institutions
83
Australia, to study how the world is made, at least that part
of it contributed by corals.
While our knowledge of the structure of the human body is
more complete than that of any other animal, our information
regarding- the beginnings of man is extremely fragmentary.
As a matter of fact our knowledge of man's earliest stages
is a blank. The reasons for this state of affairs are sufficiently
evident. For many years anatomists have been striving to
The Yacht, "Anton Dohrn, " of the Carnegie Station on the Tor-
TUGAs Islands
Named after the founder and life-long head of the world-famous
station at Naples, Italy.
Courtesi/ of Dr. A. O. Mayer, Director of the Tortufjas Station.
supply the deficiencies in our knowledge by collecting human
embryos and fetuses, and one of the leaders in this eifort was
the late Professor ]\lall of Johns Hopkins University. In the
course of many years Professor Mall brought together some
2,000 embryos and fetuses, and his studies of them have
thrown light, not so much on the unknown stages of human
development, as upon many curious malformations in man,
which are apt to occur in the material which the anatomist
secures, and knowledge of the causes of which are of the high-
84 Biology in America
est importance in our efforts toward the making of a better
human race.
In 1913 this work was taken over by the Carnegie Institu-
tion and organized in its Department of Embryology, which
was under Professor Mall's direction until his death in 1917,
and since then has been conducted by his successor, Dr. Geo. L.
Streeter. The work of the department, while not limited to
human development, has that as its focal point.
When Dr. Casper Wistar was teaching anatomy at the Uni-
versity of Pennsylvania in the early part of the last century,
and discussing with President Jefferson the bones of the mas-
todon which the latter had discovered in Shawangunk County,
N. y., he little foresaw the institution which the future
was to raise upon the foundation he was laying. The col-
lection of anatomical specimens which he gathered has since
grown into the splendid museum of the Wistar Institute in
Philadelphia, founded by Dr. Wistar 's grand-nephew in 1892.
While the Institute was established primarily as a home for
the W^istar Museum, its usefulness has far outgrown the func-
tion of mere display. In research, and especially as a center
for dissemination of its results through scientific journals, it
tills a place unique in American science.
While its researches have been largely of a technical char-
acter, chiefly upon the nervous system, they form the basis
for future investigations, which are likely to prove of the
highest importance to man. The rat has been used as the
experimental subject for these researches. For this purpose
the Institute maintains a rat colony of many thousand
individuals, and from April, 1917, to April, 1919, it furnished
thirty-five thousand rats to government and other laboratories,
or one rat every thirty-five minutes during this period. A
comparison of the growth of the body as a whole, of the
nervous system and of twenty other organs in rat and man,
has shown a general similarity in both animals, if comparison
be made at the same relative stage of development in both.
The rat grows approximately thirty times as fast as man and
lives approximately one-thirtieth as long a life (three years).
The rat is weaned at twenty days, man at fifteen months
while the development of the nervous system is approximately
the same at this age (i.e. when weaned) in both animals. Simi-
lar studies, both of the nervous system and of other organs,
have given similar results. The rat furthermore is almost as
omnivorous as man, and requires much the same food con-
stituents to keep him healthy.
If then the growth of the nervous system in the rat can
be increased for example by exercise or retarded by poor
food, we may logically expect similar results in man. To
Biological Institutions 85
solve these problems the Institute is beginning a series of
studies upon man in the training school for the Feeble
Minded at Vineland, N. J., where records are being made of
the growth, behavior, and clinical history of some four hun-
dred inmates. In conjunction with this work post-mortem
examinations will help to explain human behavior in terms
of the structure of human tissues, both normal and diseased ;
while continued studies of the rat will, it is hoped, throw
further light upon the influence of an animal's surroundings
on its structure and activities.
The effect of inbreeding in plants and animals is at present
but little understood. The general belief is that its results
are highly injurious to ths offspring. In some species of
plants however we find special devices of nature to insure
self-fertilization, and the results of inbreeding various kinds
of domestic animals and plants are by no means uniform in
showing its harmful character. It has been stated that among
the Ptolemies and the Incas marriage of brother and sister
frequently occurred, while in ancient Persia the marriage of
parent and child was permitted.
Hence the studies which Dr. King has been carrying on at
the Institute for several years upon the effect of continued
inbreeding on the growth, health, fertility and sex ratio of
animals, are of peculiar interest. As a result of these studies,
which are the most extensive hitherto made, Dr. King finds
that mating of brother and sister rats for thirty generations
produces no ill effect upon fertility and general health of the
offspring, provided the best animals are selected for breeding.
One of the most important and interesting researches of the
Institute has been its studies on the refractive index of the
blood serum, which has been shown to differ, not only at
different ages, but also under differing conditions of health
and disease. Thus blood from persons afflicted with syphilis,
tuberculosis, cancer or Bright 's disease, has each its own
characteristic index; and the method, which is very simple,
gives promise of being a very valuable aid in the diagnosis
of disease.
In the publication of journals the Institute performs one
of its greatest services to biology. The publication of such
journals, with their limited circulation, is always difficult
financially; but by systematizing and standardizing its
methods for several of them the Institute has been able to
reduce the expense of publication to a minimum, while at the
same time increasing their circulation and widening their
influence throughout the world. In 1919 nearly five thousand
copies of five journals were distributed to libraries and in-
dividuals in virtually every country in the world, at a net
86 Biology in America
expense of only about $6,000 annually. In addition to this it
publishes a card index with a brief abstract of every article
published in its journals as well as in several published else-
wliere.
In 190] there was established in New York City an institu-
tion unique in character and destined to do more in alleviating
human suffering than any other institution in America. While
the Rockefeller Institute was founded primarily for medical
research, its department of experimental biolog:y under the
direction of Jacques Loeb is devoted to the study of biology
pure and simple, and is furnishing biologists with an ample
supply of food for thought as well as controversy. Its de-
partments of physiology, bacteriology and protozoology have
also made invaluable contributions to biological science. In
the field of medicine proper the unique feature of the institu-
tion is a splendid hospital, in charge of a staff of highly
trained experts, the majority of whom are devoting their
entire time to this work, concentrating their efforts at any
given time on special diseases and with the resources of the
experimental laboratory at their command.
Thus far the diseases selected have been of common
occurrence, including some of the worst scourges of man, such
as infantile paralysis, syphilis, pneumonia and spinal menin-
gitis. Bulletins are issued at intervals by the director of the
hospital informing physicians of the diseases selected for
study at any given time.
Patients are admitted to the hospital from all classes of
people, rich and poor alike, without charge. In some cases
however wealthy patients have been permitted to donate
money to the hospital in recognition of their indebtedness for
its services. But although the services of the institution are
freely given, and while its primary function is the study of
disease, the right of the patient to receive the best possible
treatment is fully recognized, and no one on entering the
Institute surrenders in any way his right to such treatment.
An important feature of the Institute's work is the publi-
cation of the "Journal of Experimental Medicine," which is
one of the leading medical journals in this country, and in-
cludes in its pages much material of primarily biological in-
terest as well.
In addition to its studies upon human diseases the Institute
maintains a department of animal pathology at Princeton,
N. J., where animal diseases are being investigated.
There are many other institutions in America devoted to
the study of special diseases, such as the Henry Phipps Insti-
tute of Philadelphia for the study of tuberculosis and the
Barnard Free Skin and Cancer Hospital of St. Louis. Their
Biological Institutions 87
work however is primarily medical in character, and limits
of space prohibit further mention of it here.
On a fine old estate in Forrest Hills, a suburb of Boston, at
one time the residence of the late Benjamin Bussey, is the.
Bussey Institution, an adjunct of the department of botany
and zoology in Harvard University, where much of the pioneer
work in genetics in America has been done. Forest conserva-
tion and increase, and insect control also form part of its
program. The purpose of Mr. Bussey, the founder of the
institute, was to support the teaching of agriculture at
Harvard. His funds are now being devoted almost wholly
to research in subjects fundamental thereto, reference to
some of which is made in other chapters.
A fourth class of institutions which have contributed in no
small measure to the great structure of American biology,
are the biological bureaus of the U. S. Government —
the Bureau of Fisheries, of Animal and Plant Industry, of
the Biological Survey and of Entomology; but inasmuch as
their work has been mainly along economic lines, it may be.st
be discussed in another chapter.
In these few pages have been briefly sketched the history
and scope of American biological institutions. Much has of
necessity been omitted, but it may be that enough has been
given to outline the extent to which wealth and human effort
have been expended in this broad and fertile field.
CHAPTER III
Descriptive hiologij. Development of plmits and animals; of
sex, and sexual reproduction, and alternation of genera-
tions. The path of vertebrate evolution.
Science as we have seen is cosmopolitan and impossible
of limitation by geographic lines. Especially is this true of
descriptive biology. With the increasing specialization of
modern science it is to a certain extent possible for one man
or a group of men to work out more or less independently
some particular problems or group of problems of far-reach-
ing interest and importance. Thus our knowledge of animal
reactions we owe largely to Jennings, Rhumbler, Mast and
Loeb; the physiology of digestion immediately calls to mind
the epochal work of Pavlov, while Chittenden's researches
have made scientific nutrition matter of household knowledge.
The new science of genetics we owe largely to the work of
Bateson, Punnett, Cuenot, Castle, Davenport and Morgan,
while the structure and function of the cell, have been in great
part unraveled by the skillful touch of Wilson and Boveri.
To a certain extent this is likewise true of purely descriptive
biology. Amphioxus and the name of Willey are indissolubly
linked together in our minds ; the oyster has been exhaustively
studied by Brooks, the alligator by Reese, the Ascidians by
Ritter and the crayfish by Andrews. We have the splendid
researches of Allen, Merriam and Stone on the classification,
distribution and habits of birds and mammals; those of Jor-
dan, Dean and Eigenmann on fishes, of Mayer on Medusae and
of hosts of other specialists on various groups of animals and
plants; while the names of Osborn, Cope and Scott will ever
be associated with the extinct life of ages long gone by.
Many of these studies however are of but small value in
themselves. Information as to the structure, classification and
distribution of a given organism or group of organisms, gives
us comparatively little information as to the great laws of life,
except in so far as these facts are correlated with similar facts
relative to other groups of organisms, whereas the research
in physiology (using this term in its broadest sense) of a single
man, may lead to discoveries of profound and far-reaehing
88
Descriptive Biology 89
significance. And thus it comes to be that the whole fabric
of morphology, or the science of form, is a mosaic of individual
bits of knowledge, some greater, some less, but none of great
importance except when considered in relation to all the
others. Of what particular interest for example is the dis-
covery of a connecting ligament between the arteries which
supply the lungs and those which supply the trunk in higher
vertebrates, apart from the existence of a functional blood
vessel representing this ligament in some of their more lowly
aquatic cousins (the lungfishes and Amphibia) ? Or how
can the parts of a flower be understood without a knowledge
of the process of reproduction in the ferns and mosses ?
To follow adequately the course of descriptive biology in
America would carry us too far afield, and into paths wherein
many of us perchance would not care to wander. "We may
however trace in a few words some of the main lines of
morphological research, noting the discoveries to which they
have led and the problems which still confront us.
Since Darwin's epoch-making work, the golden thread of
evolution has linked together the labors of morphologist and
physiologist alike, and the efforts of the former have centered
around the genealogies of living things. What have been the
lines of ascent from the one-celled animals and plants to those
of many cells? Are animals and plants of common ancestry
or do they belong to two distinct groups of living things, each
with its own origin? What has been the origin of the germ
layers and the ccelome in animals, and how have those of many
segments become modified to those of few? How can sexual
be related to non-sexual forms, and hermaphroditic to those
of separate sex ? AVhat is the origin of alternation of genera-
tions, and how has the non-sexual gained so great an ascend-
ency over the sexual form in higher plants ? These are a few
of the great questions which the morphologist has to answer.
In this solution however he must call to his aid the experi-
menter, for after all observation and experiment are but two
phases of the same science, working together toward a common
end.
All living things may be divided into the two great groups
of the one, and the many-celled, the Protozoa and Protophyta
on the one hand, and the Metazoa and Metaphyta on the
other. Each many-celled animal or plant begins its career
as a single cell, containing within itself all the possibilities
of the adult plant or animal. So too does the one-celled
organism contain the possibility of evolution into a new
creation of beings yet unknown. Most of these lowly creatures
to be sure have deviated from the straight and narrow path
90
Biology in America
whicli leads to high estate, and have wandered off into byways
of specialization, some of which may perchance cause their
undoing and lead to their extinction.
If one go to any wayside pool or pond, gather a handful of
weeds and allow them to stand in a laboratory jar for a few
days^ he will soon have a new creation at his hand, a little
world of swarming life, tense with the keen struggle for
existence. Here he will find dwarfs and giants, the tiny
"monad" and the sac-like Bursaria which reaches the rela-
Protozoan Types
1, Dileptus; 2, Traehelophyllum ; 3, Bursaria. After Conn,
tively enormous size of one-twelfth of an inch; and all the
bizarrerie of evolution running riot. One sliaped like a rib-
bon, yet others like cornucopias or bells, and still others with
long, extensile necks, veritable giraffes of the microscopic
world. One great group of Protozoa, the eiliates, derives its
name from the delicate rapidly beating processes or cilia which
cover the animals, and by means of which they move so
rapidly through the water as to drive many an amateur
microscopist to drink, in desire at least, if not in practise.
In many of these the cilia, instead of being uniformly dis-
tributed over the body, are limited to definite areas. Occa-
'^m/':<
Protozoan Types
1, Paramcecium; 2, Coleps; 3, Didinium feeding on ParanKTN'ium;
4, Clathrulina; 5, a monad; 6, Volvox; 7, Stentor; S, Htylonichia;
9, Peridinium; 10, Ceratium.
Figs. 2 and 8 after Conn; 4 after Leidy; 5 and 7 after Edmondson;
9 modified from Schilling after Huitfeld-Kaas; and 10 after Laukcster;
the rest original; 3 from a j)reparation by Powers.
91
92 Biology in America
sionally thoy form one or more rings about the body, wbile
again they are condensed into several long flexible processes
by means of which the animal crawls abont over the weeds
or bottom. Still others possess long slender spines, which may
either have no apparent use, or may serve as springing organs,
the animal lying still for a time and then suddenly starting
to roll and tniiilile abont as though possessed of a veiy devil
of unrest.
Yet another great group of Protozoa, the flagellates, derive
their name from the flagella or whip-like processes by means
of which they swim. Most Protozoa are actively motile, but
some are attached by stalks, either singly or in branching
groups. These are sometimes fixed, and sometimes furnished
with delicate muscle fibrils, which contract suddenly when the
animals are disturbed.
Usually naked, some Protozoa are enclosed in cases or shells.
One lives in a tube, with a lid Avhich -closes as the animal
retracts, and opens as it expands. Many of these shells are
of great beauty and complexity. The infusorian Coleps bears
a shell comprised of numerous plates arranged in circles
around the body, the flagellate Peridinium has a delicately
sculptured shell of twenty-one plates and Ceratium is en-
closed in a shell bearing long, horn-like processes. But the
most remarkable development of shells is found in the
Foraminifera and Radiolaria, whose remains form so large
a part of the ooze covering the bottom of the sea, and which
have produced valuable deposits of building stone and chalk
in the past.
Many Protozoa have developed primitive organs of diges-
tion, excretion and respiration, while some have contractile
fibrils in the outer layer of the body, which serve as primitive
muscles. Yet others have the suggestion of eyes in the form
of pigment spots, which doubtless are responsive to light.
In these early differentiations of structure we have forecast
for us the conditions in the Metazoa or many-celled animals
with their special organs and corresponding "division of
labor" or work which these organs have to do.
Not alone in structure are many Protozoa highly specialized.
In manner of life they vary widely. Many of them are
exclusively marine, others inhabit only fresh waters, while
still others may be found in fresh and brackish water alike.
Mostly free living, a few have developed the habit of com-
mensalism, or close association with some other organism.
The ciliates, Triehodina and Kerona, are usually found gliding
over the surface of the fresh water polyp Hydra. The Radio-
laria harbor symbiotic algffi, by means of which the synthesis
or construction of carbohydrates is possible, after the manner
Descriptive Biology
93
of tlip green plant. Yet others contain within tliemselves the
magic chlorophyl, whose beautiful green delights our eyes in
the early verdure of the spring, and by whose means Nature
performs her wonderful chemistry, converting carbon dioxide
and water into sugar, which plants and animals alike may
use as food. Many, notably the Sporozoa and some flagel-
lates, are parasitic, and in some cases are the cause of plagues
of man and beast.
In the world of the little as well as in that of the great,
Lower Plant Life
1, Spirogyra; 2, desmids; 3, a diatom.
1 and 3 original, 3 from a preparation by Elmore, 2 from Needham &
Lloyd's "Life of Inland Waters," Comstock Publishing Company.
we find the role of the hunter and the hunted. Usually it is
the smaller fry which are the victims, but sometimes it is they
which take the hunter's part, attacking and destroying animals
much larger than themselves. Chief among these is Didin-
ium, a little creature about 1/150 inch in length with a bor-
ing proboscis by means of which it attacks and engulfs other
Protozoa from three to six times as large as itself. The cus-
tomary daily ration of this little gourmand is one or two
Paramoecia, but when especially hungry it may consume as
many as four or five of these animals.
As protection against their insatiable foes many Protozoa
94
Biology in America
have developed structures known as trielieysts. or secretions
contained in the surface protopUisra, wliieh when ejected form
a mass of tangled threads and serve as an abattis to repel the
attacker.
Among the unicellular plants also high degrees of special-
ization occur, which are represented mainly by variations in
general body form, by development of shells, filaments and
spines, and by changes in chromatophores and nuclei. Typ-
Amceba Pkoteus, One of the Most Primitive Types of Life
Photograph of a model in the American Museum of Natural History
in New York.
Courtesy 0/ the Museum.
ically spherical or ovate in form the algae may become linear,
club-shaped, discoid, spiral or crescentic, while the shell mark-
ings of desmids and diatoms are among the most delicate and
beautiful objects of microscopical study.
The chromatophores or chlorophyl carriers of the algffi are
one of their most specialized features. In its simplest form
the chromatophore is disk- or plate-like, but it varies from the
more generalized form to the specialized star-shaped, spiral
or netted ones. Typically possessing but a single nucleus,
Descriptive Biology 95
the algas may have many or none. In the latter condition,
shown by the bacteria and blue-green algaB the nucleus prob-
ably consists of numerous granules scattered throughout the
cell.
While the majority of unicellular organisms show a more
or less high degree of specialization, there are a few which
still remain more nearly in what was undoubtedly the primi-
tive condition and which may therefore be regarded as pos-
sessing greater possibilities of advance to higher types. Such
among animals is the Amoeba, while among plants the most
primitive are the Protococcacea'. The minute flagellate forms
known by the non-committal term of "monads" are undoubt-
edly however very close to the bottom of the ladder of life,
and it is quite possible that they represent the starting point
for both animals and plants. Whether these primitive forms
are very ancient, representing the direct descendants of the
original progenitors of living things, or whether they are
recent, and represent one of many evolutions of living from
lifeless matter is an interesting problem for speculation, but
one offering small possibilities of solution with our present
knowledge. In view of the great variability of most forms
of life the likelihood of any group of organisms persisting with
but little change throughout biologic time seems most improb-
able. But on the other hand we have no evidence of the
origin of living from lifeless matter at the present time, and
we know further that some forms of the present day (i. e.
Spirifer, one of the Brachiopoda) are indistinguishable save
in minor characters from their representatives of the Cam-
brian period, which may have lived some four hundred mil-
lions of years ago.
Among both the Protozoa and Protophyta are many species,
in which the cells instead of remaining distinct are grouped
in colonies. In many of these the association is loose and
indefinite, the group increasing in size for an indefinite time
and finally breaking up to form other groups. This is espe-
cially true of the numerous filamentous algae, but is also true
of other algae and Protozoa. In some however notably in the
Volvocaceae the size and the number of cells comprised in the
colony is more or less definite, foreshadowing the conditions
in the many-celled animals and plants.
Among both unicellular plants and animals reproduction
occurs typically by simple cell division. At the time of divi-
sion the parent cell loses its identity but does not die, con-
tinuing to live in its two descendants. The theoretical
possibilities of increase of these microscopic forms are beyond
our powers of imagination. According to Professor Morgan,
a protozoan Stylonichia "produced in 6Y2 days a mass of
9G Biology in America
protoplasm wcigliingr one kilogram. At the end of 30 days,
at the same rate, the number of kilo<j;rams would be 1 fol-
lowed by 44 zeros, or a mass of protoplasm a million times
larger than the volume of the sun." ^
But in many of these forms another process of reproduction
has developed, wherein two cells, or in any event two luielei
play a part, a process known as conjugation or fertilization.
A simple example will illustrate this. If a single individual
of the ciliate Paramo^cium be placed in a suitable culture fluid
it will divide rapidly, forming in a few days a countless
progeny. After a time if one examine a drop of the culture
he will likely find some of the individuals united in pairs.
They remain thus united for possibly 24 hours, after which
they separate and each resumes its rapid multiplication.
Briefly told, what happens during their union is as follows :
Paramecium contains two nuclei, a larger, or macronucleus
and a smaller, or micronucleus." The latter divides three
times and several of the parts thus formed disappear, but
two remaining. Of these one, the larger, remains quiescent,
while the other migrates across the protoplasmic bridge unit-
ing the two animals and fuses with the quiescent nucleus in
the other cell. This fusion nucleus then divides several times,
some of the daughter nuclei enlarging to form new macro-
nuclei which are distributed to the daughter cells, the old
macronucleus having disappeared in the meantime. Some
of the daughter nuclei degenerate, w^hile one remains to form
a new micronucleus. We have here probably the beginnings
of sex as indicated in the difference of size and activity of
the two micronuclei, which fuse with each other during the
cell union. Externally however sexual difference between
the cells is not evident.
The meaning of this process is not clear. It has been sup-
posed to have a rejuvenating influence upon the cells taking
part in it, but this interpretation is i-endered doubtful by
recent experiments of Professor Jennings at Johns Hopkins,
who suggests that it is rather a means of producing variation
and thus leading to evolution.
The union of similar gametes or reproductive cells is com-
mon among the alga>. Frecpiently these cells bear cilia and
are motile, while the ordinary form is non-motile. In some
cases a slight difference in size between the conjugating
gametes is suggestive of the differentiation between egg and
sperm cell of higher forms.
* These figures are given by Morgan in "Heredity and Sex." He
disclaims responsibility however for tho mathematical computation in-
volved.
' There may be one or two of these latter.
Descriptive Biology
97
A still further stage in sex development is shown by a
distinct difference in size and activity of the copulating cells.
The malaria organism multiplies asexually in the blood cells
of its host. After a time, under conditions not well under-
stood, some of the malarial cells enlarge. If now the patient
is bitten by one of the Anopheles mosquitoes, which transmit
the disease, some of these enlarged cells remain quiescent,
forming the female cells in the mosquito's stomach, while
others cast off a number of small active filaments or male
cells. These latter then unite with or fertilize the former,
;© «5' ©I
Life Cycle of the Malarial Organism
a, parasite in red blood corpuscle; b and c, spore formation; d, female,
and e, male cells, which are uniting at f ; g, sporozoites in cyst; h, sporo-
zoite free; i, ameboid parasite developed from h, prepared to enter red
blood corpuscle, j. Original.
and from their union a large number of minute motile cells
or "sporozoites" are formed, by which the asexual cycle is
repeated when the infected mosquito bites a new victim.
Yet a further and final step in sex differentiation among
the unicellular forms is found in Volvox, an organism which
is on the fence, so to speak, between Protozoa and Protophyta ;
and which forms a bone of contention between the botanists
and zoologists, each claiming ownership to it. Volvox is a
hollow spherical group of cells, numbering in some cases over
20,000, and reaching a diameter of 1/25 of an inch. The cells
carry a pair of cilia each, by means of which the organism is
98 Biology in America
au active swimmer. Tliey also contain elilorophyl, enabling
it to manufacture its own food, so that physiologically it is
a plant, but in respect to the possession of cilia, and a red eye
spot which is sensitive to light, it resembles more nearly an
animal. Its reproduction is partly asexual and partly sexual.
In the former method, some cells multiply to form sec-
ondary colonies, which lie in the cavity of the mother colony
and tinally break tlirough its wall to form new colonies. In
the latter, certain large cells lacking cilia are ditferentiated
as eggs, while other cells divide to form a varying number
of motile sperms. Fertilization results in the formation of
a resting cell or "zygote," which after a period of inactivity
develops into a new colony.
In definiteness of form, close association of cells and espe-
cially in the differentiation of sexual cells, Volvox stands as
a stepping stone between the unicellular types with their
typically asexual reproduction and the many-celled forms
which typically reproduce by fertilization. In yet another
respect does Volvox approach the higher types. Some species
are hermaphroditic, producing both eggs and sperms in the
same colony, while in others the two sexes are lodged in
separate individuals. There are many other forms, both
single-celled and colonial, which resemble animals in having
flagella and eye-spots, and plants in possessing chlorophyl.
Sometimes it is only the reproductive cells which have all
of these features, the ordinary cells being typical alga^ with
chlorophyl but neither flagella nor eye-spots. It is passible
that the "monads," to which reference has already been made,
have developed chlorophyl, giving rise to the plant kingdom,
on the one hand ; and have assumed an ameboid form, pro-
ducing the animal kingdom on the other. This is suggested
by the occasional occurrence of flagellates which are either
ameboid at all times, or may assume an ameboid form at
certain times in their life cycle.
Through the entire series of plants from the lowest to the
highest runs a curious phenomenon known as alternation of
generations, or the alternate succession of sexual and asexual
methods of reproduction. How many of us stop to think
when we pluck a violet or smell a rose that the flower was
not made to delight our eye or nose, but has developed as a
means for the perpetuation and increase of its kind? And
how does the flower perform its function? Hidden away at
its center, where but few of us ever see them, are the female
organs or ovaries, bearing at their summits little processes
known as styles, which end in small expansions, the stigmas.
Surrounding the ovaries are a ring of delicate filaments, the
stamens, each bearing at its tip a sack, the anther. In the
Descriptive Biology
99
anther the pollen grains are formed, and these when ripe
are scattered by the wind or carried by insects to another
flower, where, lighting upon its stigmas, they germinate and
send fine tubes down through the styles to reach the ovaries
at their base. Through these tubes pass the male nuclei
formed within the pollen grain, which unite with the female
nuclei within the ovaries, the pollen tube representing the
last remnant of the body of the sexual plant in lower forms.
Similarly there are contained within the ovary, beside the
r
Eeproduction of Plants
Left: A phlox blossom showing flower parts. Ca, calyx; eo, corolla;
sta, stamens; sti, stigma; sty, style. Original.
Right: Alternation of generations in 1, fern, showing the sexual form
or prothallus bearing the asexual fern, fe; and 2, moss, showing the
spore capsule, c.
female nucleus, several nuclei, which represent the body of
the female sexual plant in mosses or in ferns.
The moss plant is the sexual form, which bears the egg and
sperm producing organs. From the egg, after fertilization
in the ovary springs a slender stalk bearing a capsule at its
summit. When this is ripe it bursts, casting forth the tiny
spores, which generating give rise in turn to the sexual moss
plant. Similar conditions obtain in the liverworts. In
these forms therefore the gametjophyte or sexual plant is
the chief generation, the sporophyte or asexual form the
smaller, secondary one.
In ferns the reverse is the ease. If one examine the under-
100 Biology in America
side of an ordinary fern leaf he will find its edges? pimpled
with rows of little brown capsules somewhat smaller than a
pin head, which on bursting scatter to the wind a fine brown
dust. This consists of the spores, which after germination
produce a leaf-like body, the prothalhis, about a quarter of
an inch in diameter. This is the gametophyte, which bears
the sexual organs. It grows only in moist places, moisture
being necessary for the transfer of the sperm to the (^^^.
From the fertilized egg develops the sporophyte or ordinary
fern plant, tlius completing the cycle in the life of the fern.
Alternation of generations also occurs in some algffi. Here
it is the gametophyte which is the conspicuous plant, the
sporophyte being usually a smaller structure.
Passing upward from the lower to the higher plants we
see then the sporophyte progressively increasing and the
gametophyte decreasing in importance.
While alternation of generations is characteristic of plants
it occure occasionally among the many-celled, as well as in
unicellular animals. Many of the delicate and beautiful jelly-
fish, with which any observant visitor to the seashore is
familiar, are the sexual phase of the life cycle of an animal
whose asexual form consists of an attached series of disks,
which in the course of development separate from one another
to form the sexual form or medusa. In certain marine worms
(Polycha^ta) also alternation of generations occurs. The
anterior part of the body does not develop sex organs, while
posteriorly the worm divides into several part ;, whi.-h becom-
ing sexually mature separate from the parent stock to form
the sexual generation. In some of the curious "sea squirts"
or tunicates also this process is found.
The tunicates derive their name from the mantle or tunic
surrounding the body. Some are fixed, and others free swim-
ming as adults; while in the former the animal is frequently
free-swimming as a larva. The name of "sea squirt" is
derived from the habit of the fixed forms of squirting out a
stream of sea water when touched.
The larva of the fixed forms is totally different from the
adult and the true relationships of the latter could not be
understood were it not for the existence of the former. This
is a tadpole-like animal with a long tail through which runs
a supporting rod, the notochord. At the anterior end of the
animal is an adhesive disk by means of which it attaches
itself at the time of metamorphosis. The wall of the pharynx
is perforated by a number of openings or gill slits which lead
into a waste chamber or atrium opening to the exterior by
a pore. Dorsal to the pharynx is a nervous mass or primitive
brain, and between the two a small duct opening into the
Descriptive Biology 101
former which is known as the ''sub-neural gland," and has
been compared to the vertebrate hypophysis, which is part
of the pituitary body or gland attached to the base of the
brain, one of those problematic organs of "internal secretion"
which is playing so large a i^art in medicine today. The
larva swims actively by means of its long tail, but at metamor-
phosis the latter is lost together M'ith its supporting rod or
notoehord, and the animal abandons the wandering ways of
youth and settles down to its future monotonous existence.
In those tunicates in which an alternation of generations
occurs, the asexual form gives rise by budding to a colony
of "zooids" which more or less directly produce the sexual
animals.
The meaning of this strange and interesting life history
remains for the future to disclose. Until we understand the
underlying significance of sex, it is hopeless to attempt to
solve the ri<ldle of alternation of generations. In our attempt
to find an answer to both of these two great questions of
biology, the experimental, rather than the purely morpho-
logical method gives the greater promise of success. There
is already at hand evidence to show that the appearance of
sexual reproduction can be to a certain extent at least con-
trolled by experiment. Details regarding such experiments
may be postponed however to a later chapter.
The most likely interpretation of alternation of genera-
tions however is that it is a "device" of Nature to increase
the spread of the species and thus enhance its chances of
survival. It occurs typically in attached forms such as most
plants, and the hydroids, Polyzoa and some tunicates among
animals, while in those marine worms in which it occurs the
asexual generation often lives a retired and inactive life in
the recesses of some rocky shelter, only the sexual generation
swimming freely at the surface of the sea. It obviously
increases the chances of distribution of a fixed form to have
a sexual free-swimming form which may carry the repro-
ductive cells and scatter them far and wide. A difficulty in
such an interpretation however is that in some of these forms
the sexual generation is not free-swimming but attached to
the asexual one. This may of course be a degenerate con-
dition.
In the case of the plants on the other hand, it is the asexual
form with its numerous spores, which is most important in
the distribution of the species, these spores being readily
carried by the wind and thus better suited to spreading a
land form, than the flagella-])eariiig sperms, which recpiire
water for their distribution.
Among the Protozoa alternation of generations frequently
Invertebrate Types
1, Hydra; 2, earthworm; 3, a troehopliore larva; 4, a rotifer; 5, Ba-
lanoglossus; 6, Trochosphara; 7, Aiiipliioxus; 8, a tunicate; 9, Bonellia;
10, a fresh water annelid reproducing by fission. Fig. 3, from Korsehelt
and Heider after Hatsehek; 4, from K. & H. after A. Agassiz ; 6, from
K. & H. after .Semper; 9, from Doncaster; the others are original, 9
from a preparation by Powers. Fig. 1, i, intestine ; m, mouth ; t, ten-
tacles. Fig. 2, c, crop; ce, coelome; g, gizzard; i, intestine; m, mouth;
n, nerve cord; np, nephridium (kidney) ; sv, seminal vesicles; sr, seminal
receptacles; ph, pharynx. Figs. 3 & 4, a, anus; ev, contractile vesicle or
bladder; e, excretory duct; i, intestine; m, mouth; mx, niastax (grind-
ing pharynx) ; pr, pre-oral, and po, post-oral ciliated rings; pg, pharyn-
geal glands; s, stomach; o, ovary. Fig. 6, c, cloaca; e, excretory duct;
m, mouth; mu, muscle; pr, pre-oral, and po, post-oral ciliated rings;
o, ovary; pg, pharyngeal gland.
102
Descriptive Biology 103
occurs, especially in the parasitic forms. Here the production
of numerous spores undoubtedly increases the distribution of
the organism, but the meaning of the sexual phase in the life
cycle is as obscure as is that of sexual reproduction among
living things in general. The whole problem of reproduction,
in all its manifold phases is one of the most perplexing which
biology has to solve.
In the majority of animals the sexes are distinct, but in
some, notably flat worms, annelids, some molluscs, etc., they
are found in the same individual, which is then known as an
hermaphrodite from Hermaphroditus, the Son of Hermes and
Aphrodite, who became joined in one body with the nymph
Salmacis. How comes it that in some animals we find distinct
sexes, while in others, not distantly related to them, they are
united ? Here again we are face to face with one of Nature 's
inscrutable mysteries. A possible clue is found however in
the fact that in animals of separate sex, the early stages of
the sex organs may be apparently "indifferent," that is,
neither male nor female, becoming differentiated into either
sex as development proceeds. Even though sex may be, as
we shall see later, predetermined in the fertilized egg, never-
theless all the essential parts of both male and female may
develop in the embryo. Furthermore, there are many in-
stances, some of which will be mentioned in another chapter,
of so-called "sex intergrades" where the animal or plant may
be predominantly of one sex and yet show some of the
characteristics of the opposite sex ; and further, when the sex
glands cease to function, either from disease, removal or old
age, certain characters of the opposite sex may appear, as
noted in a later chapter.
Apparently then the hermaphroditic condition is primitive
and the bisexual one derived, through suppression, but not
loss in either sex of the characters peculiar to the opposite sex.
But why this differentiation has occurred and the advantage
thereof we do not know.
Passing from the unicellular to the multicellular animals
or Metazoa we find one of the simplest of the latter in a
little creature which strangely enough beai*s the name of the
many-headed monster, Hydra. Its body consists of two layers
of cells and contains a primitive digestive cavity with a
mouth, which is surrounded by several tentacles, giving the
animal its fanciful resemblance to the horrid monster of
fabled story. The space between the layers contains an almost
negligible jelly and the muscle processes of cells lying in the
two layers.
From Hydra the next step in advance is very uncertain.
The reader may best be spared the mental contortions neces-
104
Biology in America
sary to follow the feats of the imagination performed by the
morphologists in leaping the gap between Hydra and higher
animals. Suffice it to say that an imaginary ancestor has
been created to serve as the starting point of the latter, from
which these have diverged, each upon its several way.-
A Series of Vertebrate Embryos
I, II, III, 1st, 2n(l, aiul Hid stage. From Eomanes "Darwin and
After Darwin."
By permission of tlit: Open Court PuMisliin§ Company
If one compare a series of the early stages of animals, which
in the adult form are widely different from one another, he
may find it difficult or impossible to tell them apart. The
embryos of fish, frog, bird and mammal are almost identical
with one another at a certain stage of development.
■ The above statement must not be interpreted as an oversight of
the higher coelenterates and the ctenophores. But even taking a
ctenophore as a "jumping off point" there is still a wide and as
yet unfathomed abyss to cross.
Descriptive Biology 105
Man begins his life as a single cell, corresponding to the
protozoan stage of evolution. Later lie consists of two layers
of cells, corresponding to a greatly moditied Hydra. Then
he possesses three "germ layers" and numerous segments like
a worm, from which stage he passes to that in which he has
gills like a fish, and later on a tail and coat of hair like a
monkey.^ These and many other facts of like nature have
led to the law that the development of the individual is a
replica in miniature of the development of the race, a law
which has been much abused by its friends no less than by
its enemies. While this principle is unquestionably sound it
must not be pushed too far. In its main features the develop-
ment of the individnal does reproduce that of the race, but
in all its details certainly not. At no time in his development
does man ever resemble an adult fish, but there are certain
stages in development which are common to both ; man in his
earliest stages having certain fish-like features.
To follow the trail of animal evolution through the develop-
ment of the individual calls for all the cunning of a biological
Sherlock Holmes. Nature has, as it were, cleverly concealed
her footsteps, and made many a false move to throw the
pursuer off the track. But her trail, is there and can be
followed if we have the necessary acumen and patience.
In the development of many worms, molluscs, echinoderms,
tunicates and other invertebrates there occur certain larval
forms known as trochophores. All trochophore larv^ are by
no means alike, but all have the same general plan of struc-
ture, and the presence of these larva; in the development of
so many different groups of invertebrates has led to a belief
in an ancestral "trochophore" from which these groups have
radiated, like the spokes about the hub of a wheel.
Very closel.y resembling in many respects the trochophore
larva is the group of rotifers or "wheel animalcules" so called
because of the circles of rapidly beating cilia leading to
the mouth, which in their activity resemble the motion of
a wheel, and by means of which the rotifer obtains its food
and swims through the water. One of these, Trochospha^ra,
resembles the trochophore larva in its general form so closely,
as to have misled some biologists into the belief that this was
an ancestral type, and that the rotifers were the hub of the
animal universe. But the absence of a body cavity renders
such an interpretation more than doubtful, the rotifers hav-
ing more likely been shoved off onto a side track from the
main branches of evolution, where they stand, nearly related
* This does not mean of course fully developed gills, tail and hair,
but their beginnings may be seen. If the development of a lish
or a mammal were arrested at a certain stage these organs would
not be better developed in them than in man.
106 Biology in America
to the ancestral form, but not in tlie direct line of evolution
of any of tlie liiglu'r tyi)es of animals.
J*rogres.sijif^ upward from our ancesti'al tioehophore, we
come to forms whose geiu'ral ])hin of structure is that of a
double cylinder, somewhat fiattened along one axis, with two
sides alike giving it bilateral symmetry, and the upper or
dorsal differentiated from the lower or ventral surface. The
anteri'or end of this cylinder is dift'erentiated as a head, with
mouth, sense organs and primitive brain, while the posterior
end lacks sense oi-gans and contains an anus. The outer wall
of this double cylinder is made up of "skin" and muscles,
the inner is the wall of the digestive tract, with a body
cavity or ca4ome between. The cylinder is further divided
into rings or segments, each of which bears one or more pairs
of appendages for locomotion.
Of such a form the annelid worm, of which the common
angle worm is an example, is typical, and from here onward
in our progress to the vertebrates and man we are on surer,
though still insecure footing. The annelid or annulate is as
its name indicates a series of joints or rings, all more or
less alike, wdiich are very numerous in the typical form, but
in the more specialized groups are greatly reduced. In fact,
evolution from the annelid upward consists very largely in
the concentration and specialization of these segments. While
the annelids are probably not to be regarded as the direct
ancestors of the vertebrates, their general plan of structure,
with a cfplome and a segmented body, is fundamental to that
of all higher types, even though it may be greatly modified
in some.
The origin of the vertebrates is still shrouded in the mist
of hypothesis and dispute, and indeed may ever remain so,
since their invertebrate ancestors probably no longer exist.
Nevertheless a clue to their origin . may be found in the
tunicates described above and in a little animal with a big
name, Balanoglossus, or the acorn-tongue. This is a worm-
like creature living in bui-rows in the mud or sand of the sea
bottom near low tide level, and in its development passing
through a trochophore stage. The anterior end is marked by
a contractile and very sensitive proboscis, from the shape of
which the animal dei'ives its name, behind which is a collar
region, which in turn is followed by the trunk. Between the
proboscis and collar opens the ventral mouth which leads into
the pharynx, which is perforated by a large number of paired
openings to the exterior, the gill slits. Uorsal to the mouth
is a diverticulum of the pharynx which projects into the pro-
boscis, and which Bateson has identified as the notochord.
The nervous system presents features of peculiar interest.
Descriptive Biology 107
Its primitive character is evidenced by the superficial net
work of nerve fibres extending all over the body, and resem-
bling- in these respects the nervous system of a sea anemone.
Along the mid-dorsal and mid-ventral lines this network is
thickened to form definite nerve cords, thus relating the
animal to the invertebrates with their ventral nerve cord on
the one hand and on the other to the vertebrates, whose
central nervous system is dorsal. This latter resemblance is
still further enhanced by the hollow character of the dorsal
cord in the collar region (at least in young animals) and its
separation from the surface and deeper situation in the body
in this region. The dorsal and ventral cords are joined by
a ring surrounding the pharynx at the base of the collar
similar to that of an annelid.
There are then certain points -of fundamental importance
which are common both to the tunicate and Balanoglossus,
and to the vertebrates. These are the notochord, the gill slits
and the dorsal nerve cord. The opposite position of the
mouth in the two former (dorsal in the tunicate and ventral
in Balanoglossus) introduces an element of uncertainty, and
indeed the origin of the vertebrate mouth is a question of
great difificulty. It is improbable that vertebrates can claim
either the tunicate or Balanoglossus as a direct ancestor. In
fact "direct ancestors" in the animal world are at a premium.
In the very nature of the case, if living things are labile and
not stabile, this must be so. Otherwise all organisms would
become "stand patters" and evolutionary progress cease.
But, regardless of direct ancestry, both of the organisms dis-
cussed show distinct vertebrate affinities and indicate the way
which the latter have gone in their advance.
Further on the path of vertebrate development stands yet
another sign post to mark the way. Burrowing in the sand
of shallow seas throughout temperate and tropical regions
is a little fish-like animal about two inches in length, which
on account of its shape has been named Amphioxus, or pointed
at both ends. Its world wide distribution in the face of its
inadequate means of dispersal, and its comparatively slight
specific differentiation, suggest that it is both a very ancient
and very conservative sort of creature.
Running from tip to tip of the body extends a stiff rod
which serves as a skeleton and aids it in its rapid burrowing
in the sand. The body is marked by numerous V-shaped lines,
indicating the divisions between the segments into which the
muscles are divided. Just dorsal to the notochord is the hollow
nerve cord from which paired nerves run to various parts of
the body. Along this nerve cord are distributed numerous
little spots of pigment, which probably give the animal its
108 Biology in America
extreme sensitiveness to Ijnjlit, to avoid which it quickly with-
draws into its burrows in the sand. At the anterior end of
the body arc a number of delicate fingers or tentacle-like
processes surrounding the mouth, wiiich is ventral in position
and which opens into the pharynx, whose walls are perforated
by numerous gill slits, opening into a common branchial cham-
ber or atrium. These are, briefly put, the principal features
of this very curious and interesting little creature. In com-
mon with the vertebrates it has a hollow, dorsal nerve cord,
a notocliord and gill slits, w^hile the absence of vertebrae and
of anything resembling jaws, and its extensive segmentation
relate it to invertebrates. Its organization is however dis-
tinctly more vertebrate in character than is that of either the
tunicate or Balanoglossus.
The first of the vertebrates proper however are the cyclo-
stomes, so named from their circular mouths, which lack jaws.
They include both marine and fresh water forms and are
dangerous parasites of fish, attaching themselves to the latter
by means of the suctorial mouth, and rasping away the
scales with their powerful tongue, armed with numerous horny
teeth, and sucking the blood and soft tissues until their victim
is destroyed. The hagfish Bdellostoma of the California
coast is an example. This is an eel-like creature which is
persona non grata to the Chinese fishermen, entangling their
nets and destroying their fish. One individual in a pail of
water will quickly convert it into a jelly-like mass due to
the abundant slime secreted. In these animals we find the
first typically vertebrate structure, namely the vertebral
column^ incorrectly called the "back bone," since it is not
necessarily bony, Ibut may consist of cartilage, and in some
instances is not a continuous structure at all, but consists
merely of a series of disconnected cartilaginous pieces, par-
tially surrounding the nerve cord at the base of which lies
the notochord. Whether or not the cyclostomes are primitive
or degenerate types is a bone of contention among zoologists.
In their i)rimitive vertebiu', persistent notochord, extensive
segmentation of nerves and muscles and numerous gills their
primitive character is clearly indicated ; but in their suctorial
mouth, and poorly developed eyes there is evidence of degen-
eration, correlated perhaps with their parasitic habits.
Not until we reach the true fishes do we find fully developed
the vertebrate plan of structure, with a complete vertebral
colunm built around and replacing the degenerating notochord,
and surrounding the nerve cord; with paired upper and lower
jaws and paired fins, and a fully developed brain case or
skull. The origin of most of these structures is shrouded in
mystery, and unless paleontology comes to our aid, re-
A. Mouth of Lamprey
fSliowing the rasping tongue and toothed liood.
B. Sucker With Scars Madk by Lamprey
From Surface, "The Lampreys of Contr.il New York,"' in Bulletin
U. S. Fish Commission for 1897.
109
110 Biology in America
vealing new links in the ehain of life, it is likely ever to
remain so. How arose the vertehrate mouth and jaws, through
what steps has the skull evolved, how have the paired fins and
their sueeessoi-s, the limbs, developed? These are some of
the problems with which the student of vertebrate develop-
ment has to stiiiggle.
Is the vertebrate mouth a modified invertebrate one, and if
so is it derived from the dorsal mouth of the tunicate or the
ventral one of Bahinoglossus, or was it made anew when the
vertebrate was fashioned in Nature's work shop? Are the
jaws new structures, swi generis, or are they second-hand gill
bai's employed by Nature for the purpose because they were
the handiest structures she could find?
A possible clue to this question is found in the peculiar
development of the anterior end of Amphioxus. When the
mouth of this animal first appears it is not in its final position
in the median plane of the body, but tilted far up on the left
side, while vice versa the first gill slits make their appearance
on the right side and secondarily are shifted over .to the left.
This larval asymmetry would be produced by any force twist-
ing the anterior end from left to right; i. e., in the opposite
direction to that in which the clock hands move. But if, as
the result of such a twisting, the mouth is carried over to the
left side its original position must have been dorsal. Now
what evolutionary change could have produced such a twist-
ing? In the early stages of the larva the notochord does not
reach the tip of the body, only later extending there. Further-
more, neither in the tunicate lai'\'a nor in Balanoglossus does
it extend to the tip of the body. If, in correlation with the
burrowing habit of the animal, the notochord extended forward
in the course of evolution, thereby stiffening the anterior end
of the body, and aiding the animal to wriggle through the
sand, the tendency would be to displace the anterior organs,
and among them the mouth. Such an assumption seems very
reasonable. If correct, then the mouth of Amphioxus must
originally have been dorsal, and if this animal represents a
primitive vertebrate type, then the vertebrate mouth must
originally have had this position, secondarily migrating to
the ventral side. But what of the origin of the jaws which
are such characteristic features of all vertebrates above the
cyclostomes ?
As we have already seen a characteristic feature of all
higher animals is their segmentation. This is seen in many
parts of the body, — muscles, nerves, blood vessels, gills, etc.
We have further seen that one phase of advance is the reduc-
tion in number of these segments and their specialization, or
modification for the performance of other work than that
Descriptive Biology HI
which they were originally called upon to do. In Ampliiuxus
and the protocordates (timicates, Balanoglossus) the number
of gills is large, occasionally reaching as many as 180 pairs in
the former. In the cyclostomes the number varies from six
to fourteen while in higher fishes the number is typically
five, varying from three to seven. In land vertebrates gills
are absent in the adult, but occur more or less developed in
the embryo, even man himself at one stage of his existence
showing indications of them, a heritage from some remote
fish-like ancestor. In their disappearance have these gills
left any traces behind them ? There are some undoubted rem-
nants of the gills and their associated structures, and others
which can be so interpreted only with great doubt. Of the
former may be mentioned the spiracle in fishes, an opening
from the pharynx to the exterior just back of the head. In
land vertebrates this becomes the cavity of the middle ear,
which is closed externallv by the tympanum and internally
communicates with the pharynx by means of the Eustachian
tube. The delicate ear bones, which transmit the vibrations
of the tympanum to the inner ear, are probably in part
derived from the first gill arch, while from the other arches
develop the hyoid bone and some of the laryngeal cartilages.
The blood vessels and nerves supplying the gills of the fish
are also in some cases directly modified to form other nerves
and vessels in the land vertebrate. If then, gill arches have
been so markedly reduced in number and can be so profoundly
changed as to form parts of the organs of hearing and of
speech, why may they not also have been changed to form
even more distant parts? Hence the origin of jaws, paired
fins and fin supports or girdles have been attributed by some
theorists to former gill bars, while even the lungs have been
derived, according to one theory, from a pair of gill clefts.
While there is but little evidence for the latter theories,
the former is not an unreasonable one. The position and
arrangement of the jaws is such that they can be readily com-
pared to a pair of gill arches united below and hinged in
the middle to form the upper and lower jaws. Furthermore,
the arrangement of the nerves supplying the jaws is very
similar to that of those which supply the gill arches.
For the origin of the paired fins of fishes we have a more
likely theory in that of the paired fin fold. The vane of the
fish extends discontinuously along the median dorsal line from
head to tail, and ventrally is represented by the anal or
ventral fins, between tail and anus. Anterior to the anus we
find the paired fins occupying varying positions in different
fish. According to the paired fin fold theoiy the ancestral
fish possessed a continuous median fin, extending dorsally
112
Iliology in America
from hoad to tail and veiitrally as far as the arms, where it
divid'd In pass forward aloiip: the sides as a pair of folds
to the liead. Sueh a condition we aelnally iind in Ainplii-
oxus, wlii'e the fossil shark ( 'ladoselache possessed paired
fins placed exactly as we shonld expect them to be had they
been derived fiom snch hypothetical fin folds. In the
Jai)anese goldfish the anal fins, which are ordinarily single,
are paired, as would happen if the paired folds extended
further back than nsnal.
These folds are supposed to have acted as balancing: organs
originally, but later they became stiengtliened at their
anterior and posterior ends while their middle parts dropped
til&IXtfc.-.
(Above) A Lung Fish
Frtini I'irsson juid ydiuclicrt 's Geology, by perniissiou of John Wiley
& Sons.
(Below) Cladoselache
A fossil shark, whose paired fins give evidence of the origin of these
structures from a pair of continuous fin folds. From Dean 's ' ' Fishes,
Living and Fossil," by permission of the Macmillan Company.
out and the parts remaining were modified to form the paired
fins of the modern fish.
The origin of the vertebrate limb is shrouded in the mists
of the past. Whence it came, and how, we may never know ;
for there are as yet no links to connect the fin of the fish
with the limb of the amphibians. True it is that the impress
of a foot has been found in Pennsylvania in sandstone rocks
of the Devonian period, when fishes were the dominant types
of life; which is supposed to have been made by some lowly
ancestor of the amphibians. This represents only the foot
however and tells us little or nothing as to the origin of the
limb as a whole. Various hypotheses have been advanced to
take the place of facts, but about the most that can be said
for any of them is that they are hypotheses, and one is per-
Descriptive Biology 113
haps as good as another. The conditions of the earth and its
climate under which the amphibians arose are considered in
the following chapter, but their earliest history is still a
blank.
One of the most difficult, but withal interesting problems
of vertebrate morphology is the origin of the head. The
ancestral vertebrate lacked a head. How have its descendants
acquired one? This question involves in the first place one
fundamental to all evolution. Is an organ developed because
it is used, or is it used because it is developed? While this
question has ever been a terra incognita in biology we know
at least that fonn and function go hand in hand. This is
the corner stone of adaptation and survival. The animal is
a beautifully adjusted mechanism, in most cases built for
forward movement. The anterior end is the one which first
meets with changes in the animal's surroundings. Here food
is taken and danger encountered. Hence the development
at this end of a mouth and of special sense organs. In cor-
relation with the development of these parts, there is a
corresponding development of a brain or enlarged and spec-
ialized portion of the central nervous system, for receiving
the nerves coming from the organs of special sense, and for
sending out nerves controlling various parts of the body. En-
largements of the central nerve cord are not limited to the an-
terior end of the body. In the segmented worms and in arthro-
pods for example there are many such enlargements or ganglia,
one for each segment of the body, and when several of these
segments are combined into one, as occurs in the latter group,
notably in insects and crustaceans, the ganglia also fuse to
form compound structures. In the vertebrates, in corre-
spondence with the development of paired fins or limbs, there
are enlargements of the spinal cord opposite the latter, which
in some cases may even exceed the brain itself. Thus the
enormous dinosaur Stegosaurus had a "brain" in the sacral
region controlling the hind limbs which was larger than that
in the head.
With the development of mouth, sense organs and brain
there is a corresponding development of parts to enclose,
protect and operate them. The development of jaws which
operate the mouth has already been briefly mentioned, as
have also the changes experienced by the gill arches in
the land vertebrates. The most difficult questions of head
development concern the brain case and especially the
muscles.
The German anatomist Oken sought to solve the problem
of the brain case very simply by supposing that Nature had
enlarged and shaped three of the anterior vertebrae for this
114 Biology in America
purpose, but this primitive theory has long since been laid
to rest. Ail tliat we know of the major part of the skull
is that as the eyes, ears, nose and brain develop the sur-
rounding? tissue molds itself 1o lit them, forming hard parts
(cartilage and bone) as a firm support and protection. But
there are occasionally found some curious bones at the base
of the skull or occiput which strongly suggest that the verte-
bra; may after all liave had something to do in the building
of the skull, or at least a part of it.
Of world-Mdde distribution, with representatives in South
America, Africa, and Australia is a group of fishes known as
the lungfishes, which prol)cil)ly re]n'esent a connecting link
between fishes and Amphibia. In their cartilaginous skeleton,
and in their notochord, which persists in the adult, they are
very primitive types, while lungs and certain other features
mark them as far -advanced along the path of evolution.
These fishes live in pools which dry up wholly or in part
during the dry season and are filled again in times of abun-
dant rain. Both lungs and gills appear to be used for res-
piration even when the pools are full of water. But when
the pools begin to dry up in summer and the water becomes
foul with decaying vegetation, the ability to breathe air saves
the fish from suffocation. Some species during the dry season
settle comfortably into the mud, retaining communication
with the outer world by means of a hole in the mud, at the
•bottom of which they lie. Here they breathe air, resuming
the gill habit when the rainy season once more replenishes
their pools. In these fishes there is a "cranial rib" attached
to the base of the skull somewhat resembling the true ribs
of the fish and suggesting that a vertebra bearing this rib
has been united with the skull.
The cyclostome skull forms but an incomplete, basket-like
frame work for the brain and does not extend behind the ear,
leaving the ninth and tenth nerves outside, which in higher
fishes become enclosed in the skull. When Ave come to the
land vertebrates, the reptiles, birds and mammals, this process
of inclusion of nerves within the skull goes a step further
and we find twelve instead of ten nerves issuing from the
skull. AVhile this process of telescoping as it were the head
end of the animal is going on many of the nerves and muscles
are being crowded out, while others are so modified as to bear
but little resemblance to their former selves. Evidence of
the loss of nerves and muscles in the evolution of the verte-
brate head may be found in the presence of more numerous
nerves and muscles in this region in adult cyclostomes than
are found in the adults of the jawed vertebrates, and espe-
cially in the development of the latter, where a varying num-
Descriptive Biology 115
ber of nerve and muscle rudiments appear in the embryo,
which disappear in the adult.
The modifications which nerves and muscles undergo in
evolution are perhaps nowhere more beautifully shown than
in the evolution of the muscles and nerves of the human face.
These muscles, known as the "mimetic" or mimicking muscles
of higher apes and man, produce the wonderful play of expres-
sion of which the human face is capable, and through control
of the lips aid very largely in speech. They are controlled
by the seventh or facial nerve, which in lower animals sup-
plies the upper neck and lower jaw. In both racial and indi-
vidual development the association of muscle and nerve is
very constant. Each motor nerve is, as it were, assigned the
duty of controlling a certain muscle, and regardless of the
wanderings of its muscle, it remains faithful to its charge,
so that the best criterion for the comparison of muscles in
two animals and for determining the segments to which they
belong, is the nerves which supply them. So it comes to pass
that when the muscles of the neck wander out over the face,
or when those of the shoulder region spread themselves over
the back, their nerves must needs go along with them, and we
are in this way enabled to tell the original source of most
of the complicated muscles of the higher vertebrates. And
so when we speak or smile or frown we are using muscles,
which, in some ancestor of the long forgotten past, controlled
the throat and jaws and probably served it in chewing and
swallowing its food.
Thus in a few words we have outlined the field of the
morphologist. Perhaps some of my readers may deem the
sketch one worthy of cubist art, or modern poetry. If per-
chance however we have gained even a glimpse of the mani-
fold problems here involved and of some of the larger facts
thus far discovered, the attempt will not have been in vain.
CHAPTER IV
The story of the rocks. Contributions of palce ontology to
evolution. Rise and fall of the faunas of the past.
Not alone by a comparison of the structure of living forms
and their development, can we decipher the writings of
evolution upon the page of time. Perhaps even more con-
clusive is the story of the life which is no more, of the faunas
and the floras of the past. For in the record of the rocks
there pass in review before us the generations of the ages
telling us the story of how life has come to be. Therein we
can read in a moment the tale of a million years.
Among other facts it was the existence of the extinct faunas
of South America which first turned Darwin's thought into
the channel of evolution. Yet in spite of its contribution to
our knowledge of evolution, there are many pages missing
from the record, many of which doubtless may some day be
found, more probably lost forever. These "missing links"
of the palaeontologist have ever been a ready refuge for the
dwindling forces of the opposition, attempting with broom-
stick arguments to hold back the rising tide of facts. Many
species of animals and plants, especially the more minute and
the more primitive forms are lacking in hard parts and are
not readily preserved. Some may have been destroyed in the
upheavals of the earth. Still others are doubtless awaiting
the pick of the geologist, which has as yet but scratched the
earth 's surface here and there. Thus does the paleontologist
explain the gaps in his record where the story is not complete.
The student of world history written in the text book of
the rocks need not trouble himself with dates, for the sequence
and causes of events rather than their times are what nature
strives to teach us. But the mind of curious man never is
content unless speculating regarding the unknown, and so
geologist, biologist and physicist have all endeavored from
different data to form estimates of the age of the earth and
its geological periods. Without detailing their methods it is
sufficient to say that no very close agreement exists among
them, the geologists claiming from 100,000,000 to 800,000,000
years' since the oldest rocks were formed, the biologist asking
for hundreds of millions of years for the development of life,
116
!rhe Story of the Rocks
111
while the physicist is yet more extravagant, asking in the light
of recent experiments on radium 1,600,000,000 years for the
age of the earth since it attained its present diameter.
So in rehearsing brietly the story of the roeks perhaps we
cannot do better than employ the words of the old story books
and say that "once upon
a time" when the waters
covered most of Nortli
America and the earliest
Lauren tian rocks of
northeastern Canada
were beginning to be
lifted up above the sur-
face of the sea, life prolj-
ably came upon the earth
ill the form of unieelluhir
plants and animals. But
regarding the birth (f
life the rocks are mute.
We have no record of its
advent or its cradle.
Its earliest remains
known are those of the
Huronian period, where
liuried beneath rock strata
several miles in thickness are marine algie, radiolarians and
the tubes and burrows of annelid worms. Following these
there appeared in the Cambrian period all the principal
branches of inverte-
brate animals, with
the trilobites, the cu-
rious crustacean fos-
sils resembling the
modern king crabs,
and so named from
the two longitudinal
grooves which divide
the body into three
parallel lobes, occu-
jiying the dominant
phice. Hence this
period is known as
the age of trihibites.
Tlic "Ordoviciau" pe-
riod, whicli succeeded the Cambrian, witnessed tlie rise of
laud plants and corals, the marvelous nautilids, witli their
chambered shells, and the armored "fishes" or ostracoderms.
A Trilobite
Original photograph from a specimen
in the geological collection of the Uni-
versity of North Dakota.
Courfrsj/ of Dr. A. O. LeoiKird.
A King Crab
A living ' ' fossil, ' ' related to the trilobite
on the one hand, and, according to Professor
Patten of Dartmouth, to the vertebrate, on
the other. Photo by Elvvin R. Sanborn.
Cuurtcs!/ of the New York Zoijloyical Society.
118
Biology in America
Tlic latter are cnrions fish-liko croatnros whose remains liave
been i'ouiid in several parts of this t'ountry and abroad. They
had no jaws, and were abundantly protected with coats of
mail, their heavy armoring of plates and spines giving them
both their scientific and common names. The ostracoderms
have long been a knotty problem for the palaeontologists. By
some they are related to the king crabs, by others to the as-
cidians, while yet others regard them as kin to the cyclostomes.
But whatever their relationships may be they were inidonbt-
edly highly specialized forms and have no direct bearing on
the problem of vertebrate descent. They were at one time the
Ostracoderms
From Pirsson and Schuchert 's ' ' Geology, ' ' after Koken.
dominant forms of life in the ancient seas, for though small
of size their stout coats of mail evidently served as efficient
means of preservation. Their abundance is shown by the
numbers of their shells, which in some places, notably in Caith-
ness, Scotland, occur piled together in great masses, where
their decaying bodies served to bind together the shell into
compact masses, which today form the hard tough flagstones
of this region.
The cause of this great destruction is difficult to surmise.
Similar instances of the present are however by no means
unknown. The Mississippi lowlands are annually converted
into numerous lakes by the spring overflow from the river.
Into these lakes come numerous species of fish to breed, which
The Story of the Rocks 119
when the river recedes would be destroyed in vast numbers
annually, were it not for the work of the U. S. Bureau of
Fisheries and other agencies, which rescue thera from the
receding lakes and return them to the river, or use them for
stocking other waters. An instance of the destruction of
fishes in this manner is cited by Lucas in his "Animals of the
Past," from the observations of Mr. F. S. Webster in Texas,
"Where thousands of gar pikes, trapped in a lake formed by
an overflow of the Rio Grande, had been, by the drying up
of this lake, penned into a pool about seventy-five feet long
by twenty-five feet wide. The fish were literally packed to-
gether like sardines, layer upon layer, and a shot fired into
the pool would set the entire mass in motion, the larger gars
as they dashed about casting the smaller fry into the air, a
score at a time. IMr. Webster estimates that there must have
been not less than 700 or 800 fish in the pool, from a foot and
a half up to seven feet in length, every one of which perished
a little later. In addition to the fish in the pond, hundreds
of those that had died i)reviously lay about in every direction,
and one can readily imagine what a fish-bed this would have
made had the occurrence taken place in the past. ' '
Devils Lake is a remnant of the glacial lake Minne-
waukon, which at one time covered some hundreds of square
miles in North Dakota. Due to various factors this lake is
gradually drying up. Formerly pickerel abounded in it in
countless numbers. Old settlers tell of catching the fish
through the ice in winter with pitchforks and shipping them
out by carloads. But between 1885 and 1890, coincident with
a marked decrease in lake level, the fish suddenly disappeared.
In 1879 there were discovered along the edge of the Gulf
Stream off the coast of Massachusetts members of a group
of fishes having their home in the Gulf of Mexico, known as
the tilefish. In the spring of 1882 they were found dead and
dying by tlie million over an area estimated at from 5,000
to 7,500 square miles. This catastrophe is believed to have
been due to a continuation of northerly and easterly winds
which drove the cold arctic current from the north out of
its usual course, overwhelming the fish with disaster. For
many years no more appeared in this region, but about 1900
they reappeared and are now being taken in considerable
numbers.
In the preceding chapter we have taken a glimpse at the
lungfishes, which point the way from water to land inhabit-
ing vertebrates. One would naturally expect such creatures
to have a comparatively high standing in aquatic society, but
strangely enough their position is a lowly one indeed. This
is evidenced not alone by their structure but by their
120 Biology in America
appearance very early upon the stage of life, for the more
primitive the creature the earlier its appearance in the strata
of the earth. Thus we find ancient luiigfishes in the Silurian,
and in the Devonian, the period succeeding, they attained
their greatest prominence; wliile the sharks, which in many
respects are most primitive of the true fishes of the present,
appeared at about the same time as the lungfishes, but did
not attain dominance in the seas until much later.
Tlie ancient lungfishes, like tlie o. tracoderms, were heavily
armored; some possessed powerfid crushing or tearing jaws,
and some may have attained a size of twenty-five feet and a
gape of four feet.^
The fossil sharks include many forms of peculiar interest.
One of these from the Devonian period Gladoselache gives
strong evidence in its paired fins for the lateral fin fold theory,
as noted in the preceding chapter. The vertebrae lacked
centra, resembling in this respect the cyclostomes and dip-
noans. Perliaps nowhere else have fossil forms reproduced
so faithfully their structure as in this shark, for Dean has
shown that sections of its muscles, magnified one thousand
times, showed very clearly the finer structure of the muscle
substance (cross striations and sarcolemma). The modern
shark is covered with teeth-like scales known as shagreen
denticles, from the shagreen leather made from the skin of
the shark. From these scales have arisen on the one hand
teeth which are covered with enamel, and on the other scales
and plates in which this is lacking. Large scales or bony
plates are common in the skin of many fishes. "We have
already seen them in the ostracoderms and the armored fishes,
but they are absent in modern sharks. In fossil forms how-
ever they were frequent and closely resembled those of the
fossil lungfishes, which were probably cousin to the sharks.
The evolutionist is accustomed to thinking of life as ever
changing. Yet there are some forms which have come down
to us unchanged through untold ages. The shark Cestracion
is such an one. It roamed the seas in early Mesozoic days,
the dawn of the "age of reptiles," possibly 100,000,000 or
more years ago. • i vi
The Australian lungfish Neoceratodus has persisted Avith
but small change for an even greater length of time, while the
Foraminifera, Orlmlina and (Jlobigerina, whose shells comr)osc
much of the ooze on the sea bottom, are found as far back as
the Ordovician, perhaps 200,000,000 to 300,000,000 years ago,
and possibly existed long before. Living on some small
islands off the coast of New Zealand is the last representative
^ I am assuming here the somewhat problematical relationship of
the Arthrodiia to the Dipnoi.
The Story of the Bocks
121
of a decadent race of lizards, the Khyncliocephalia, whose
members were among the earliest of the reptiles to appear
upon the earth, and whose descendant differs but little from
the ancestral types.
^- ,■ '■/,. •-'."■.'."■'A'.k'. .'.'-'VJi/,'/- t.' ■'' ■• '•
A. The Shark Cestracion
From Pirsson and Schuchert, after Gannaii.
B. The Crossopterygian Polypterus
From Dean, ' ' Fishes, Living and Fossil. ' '
C. The New Zealand Lizard IIatteria
From Gadow, "Amphibia and Eeptiles, The Cambridge Natural His-
tory. ' '
Band C hy permission of the Macmillan Company.
Copy furnished by Conrad Lantern Slide Company, Chivago.
Other relatives of the early sharks were the Crossoptery-
gians, whose descendants are found today in the Nile, Niger
and other African rivers. In the arrangement of the dermal
head plates they are suggestive of the Stegocephala or extinct
amphibians which flourished in the Carboniferous or coal-
122
Biology in America
forming period, and which, from their abundance and that of
the <z:iant club mosses, is known as the "age of amphibians
and lycopods. "
The modern club moss is an inconspicuous humble plant,
usually creeping upon the ground in the forest, and covered
witt small pointed leaves. It is most familiar to us in the
decorations of the Christmas time. But the club mosses which
we burn today as coal, were princely trees in the carboniferous
Footprint of a Primitive Amphibian
Courtesy 0/ Professor It. 8. Lull.
forests, one hundred feet in height and five to six feet in
diameter. Associated with them along the borders of lake
and pond were giant forerunners of our "horse tail ferns,"
slender plants, sixty to one hundred feet in height, though
but one or two feet in diameter. Their descendants of the
present are for the most part only a few feet in height,
though a few of the South American forms may reach thirty
or forty feet.
During the Carboniferous period, when the earth 's surface
was covered by vast swamps, wherein the decaying vegeta-
I
The Story of the Rocks
123
tion was forming the future beds of coal, conditions were
ripe for the advent of new types of life upon the earth, and
here occurred the birth of a new creation. What were the
creatures that linked the fishes to the amphibians Ave do not
know, but we have already noted indications of a change in
* the ancient lung fish and crossopterygian.
The earliest traces of amphibians known are some "foot-
prints on the sands of time" left for our information in the
sandstone of the late Devonian period by Thinopus, and pre-
served for our further instruction in the museum of Yale
University, to which reference has already been made in the
preceding chapter.
The creatures which marked the coming of the new race
were many in number and varied in kind. Some were great
in length if not in stature, measuring up to seven or eight
feet, while others were minute, not exceeding a few inches
in size. Some were limbed and others limbless, some had
A Stegocephalan
After Williston, "Water Keptiles of the Past and Present'
(adapted from Neumayr).
By permission oj the University 0} Chicago Press.
simple teeth, while in others the tooth was infolded from the
sides producing so complex a pattern as to have given to one
group the name of labyrinthodont. This character is also
found in one of the crossopteiygian fishes, the Devonian
Holoptychius, a further indication of a possible relationship
between them and the early amphibians. They all however
possessed in common the heavy complicated coats of mail upon
the head which has given the group its name of Stegocephala.
In these early armored forms as well as in many recent ones
(i. e., sturgeon and other ganoid fishes) the animal carried
much of his skull, like a helmet, on the surface of his head.
This was developed in the skin, while underneath was a casing
for the brain developed in cartilage. In higher forms the
dermal bones have sunk below the surface becoming intimately
united in development with the cartilaginous brain case, the
whole forming a compact structure in which in the adult it
124
Biology in America
is impossible to distinguish by structure alone the two types
of bone. While the adults were terrestrial in habit they
nndonbtedly possessed aquatic larva? in many cases, as is
showu by the presence of gills in the fossil remains of the
latter, and their kinship to aquatic forms is clearly shown by
a groove in the dermal bones of the head, indicating the pres-
ence of a series of sense organs peculiar to fishes and known
as the lateral line organs.
The Carboniferous period likcwis,' witnessed a great develop-
ment of nuiny other types of animal life, spiders, scorpions,
p^-'--
J
-«.*i
An Imaginary Landscape of the Coal-Forming Period
Showing stegocephalans and a giant insect in the foreground, with
coal-forming plants in the background. After Williston, "Water Kep-
tiles of the Past and Present'' (adapted from Neumayr),
By permission of the University of Chicago Press.
centipedes, insects and snails, while the plants indulged in
a veritable riot of luxuriant growth.
We may perhaps picture to ourselves the conditions of the
evolution of land from water vertebrates in some such way
as this : With the gradual recedence of the sea and elevation
of the land extensive swamps were formed in which developed
a luxuriant vegetation consisting of giant club mosses, "horse
tail" and tree ferns and primitive representatives of our
modern pines and spruces. In the dense forests bordering the
stagnant pools, no touch of bright color was there to enliven
the monotony of the scene, for neither bird nor butterfly
The Story of the Rods 125
had yet appeared upon the earth. All Nature was clad in
somber garb of gray and green. The air was moist and mild,
with seasons same the year around. Those were indeed the
"dog days" of the world. The beating wings of many giant
insects filled the air, some of which, resembling our modern
dragon tlies, having a spread of over two feet. In the swamps
the decaying vegetation was laying down the future stores of
fuel.
Succeeding the warm moist climate of the early Carbonif-
erous came the ice age of the Permian period with its
change to a colder climate throughout the earth. The vast
swamps gradually disappeared and in their place the Appa-
lachian Mountains, today mere relics of their former selves,
reared their vast bulk perhaps some 15,000 or 20,000 feet above
the sea. With the adoption of a life on land the amphibian
stem branched out, giving rise in one direction to the reptiles,
in another to the modern amphibians, while yet another line
led to the mammals. The earliest reptiles appeared in the
Pennsylvanian or upper Carboniferous period, but not until
the Mesozoic, did tliey attain a position of dominance.
In 1802 a Connecticut farmer named Moody ploughed up
some pieces of rock bearing some small imprints, which became
popularly known as the tracks of Noah's raven. Later on
these tracks came to the attention of Doctor James Deane and
Professor Hitchcock of Amherst College, who published exten-
sive descriptions of them. The tracks were made mostly by
three-toed beasts and were at first thought to be those of
birds. But occasionally, similar tracks of four- or five-toed
animals were found, and they were later shown to be those
of dinosaurs, extinct reptiles, which at one time thronged the
earth. These tracks appear to have been made in a long
narrow estuary of the sea where we may picture to ourselves
these creatures roaming over the mud flats left bare by the
receding water, and leaving their impression on the mud to
be hardened by the heat of the sun and preserved throughout
the ages as a record of the life which was. The tracks of
some 150 species of various animals (not alone dinosaurs)
have been recorded by Professor Hitchcock from this old
estuary, one slab alone in Amherst College INIuseum showing
forty-eight tracks of one species of dinosaur, and six of
another species. Strange to say but few remains of the
makers of these tracks have been found. It is possible that
most of them have been washed out to sea and destroyed, only
those few left upon the shores being preserved.
But the happiest hunting ground of the dinosaurs was not
the shores of the Atlantic but the borders of the lakes and
rivers which occupied the present Rocky Mountain-Great
126
Biology in America
Plains area of the West. In the early Mesozoic rocks of this
region are found some of the most extensive dinosaur remains
throujxhout the woi'ld. althoupfh these are of virtually world-
wide distri])uti()n. And here too has been the happy hunting
ground of the palaeontologist, whose labors have revealed to
us the life of the long ago.
In size the dinosaurs ranged from little fellows about a
foot or two long to enormous beasts, veritable Goliaths among
animals. The largest of all was Brontosaurus, the thunder
lizard, who reached a length of sixty feet, and stood fourteen
feet high, with a thigh ])one the height of a man. ^lany of
them were armeil wath great knife-like plates and spines u])on
DixosAUR Tracks
(ointisii of the Amcriiiin Miixcum of Xdlural Hintonj.
the back and tail. Among these were the stegosaurs nr
armored lizards, the largest of whose plates were two feet in
height and length, w^hile near the end of the powerful tail,
eight or ten feet long, projected two pairs of vicious spines
nearly three feet long. The three-horned dinosaur, Tricer-
atops, who S(jme millions cf years ago inhabited what are now
the plains of the Dakotas, Wyoming, Montana and Colorado,
bore a horn over either eye and one on his snout, like the
horn of a rhinoceros, and a great fringed shield upon his
neck; while many another was equipped with armor more
bizarre perhaps than practical in the battle of life. Many
however were naked, so that as a protective adaptation these
various plates and spines seem to have had but doubtful value.
The Stary of the Rocks 127
Some of the dinosaurs browsed on the abundant vegetation
of lake and river shore, while others were eaters of flesh and
may have preyed upon their weaker brethren or fed upon
their decaying carcasses.
Unfortunately for the dinosaur and vice versa for their
prey and their enemies, if they had any, their brains did not
keep pace with their brawn. Thespesius, who was twenty-five
feet long and a dozen high, had a brain weighing less than a
pound, while Triceratops, who probably tipped the scales at
something over two tons, did not possess over two pounds of
gray matter. Some indeed had more nerve in their hind quar-
^^^pjhr
ife" -^B^H^QIl«»«kr ' --iM
»,. /s^jK^^JISfc^
■ft. ^^^p^^^^^^^^^l
L
^^^^^^^^^^^^^r^^^^^l^^^^^^^^l
Ik- ''^
^^^^^^^^^^BjJr^^BK^H
^HHB
^^
^^
^^^C?|^^
m^^^Jj^mBSlM
Si^S^*-"^ ♦ " - '■<' '
Brontosaurus, the ' ' Thunder-Lizard ' '
From a restoration by Chas. R. Knight.
Courtesy of the American Museum of Natural History.
ters than in their head ; in Stegosaurus, the sacral enlargement
of the spinal cord, which controlled the powerful hind legs,
being twenty times as large as the brain. Corresponding
with their paucity in brain substance the intelligence of
these creatures must have been low indeed, and this, together
with the vast bulk of many of them, may have contributed
to their extinction.
But the dinosaurs were not the only members of the reptile
tribe which dominated the world in Mesozoic days. There
were reptilian aeroplanes and submarines as well. In ^ the
great Cretaceous sea which divided North America into
eastern and western continents, covering the fertile plains and
r=*^:
'
^AM^
i
:^iil
aIP^^'-^-^^^H
: .v^^riMs
*
* '^MT^J
'#'
'-■'■ ' ■■■w
■^■" rJtl
^s^iB
A
0
'.ki*"!
>»fl^.
^
1
1
Ti iTriimTOwrrnrn^ri
T*: «?•.«"-. .■--in-a'
w
Stegosaurus
From a restoration by Chas. E. Kniglit.
Courtesy uj the American Museum of Natural History.
Triceratops
A former inhabitant of our western planes. From Lucas, "Animals
of the Past. ' '
Courtesy o/ the U. S. National Museum.
128
The Story of the Bocks 129
arid plateaus which lie between the Mississippi River and the
Rocky Mountains, were swarms of giant lizard-like reptiles
known as mososaurs, whose remains have l)een unearthed by
thousands in the chalk bluffs of western Kansas.
While the mososaur was playing the role of Neptune in
the Cretaceous sea, some of liis relatives took to flying and
as pterodactyls or flying lizards competed Avith the first of
the birds for the mastery of the air. The old classification
of beasts that fly and beasts that swim and beasts that walk
w^as about as logical as that of the small boy who divided
people into men, women and college professors, for many
different animals have aspired to fly and most of them
Khamphorhynchus, a Winged Reptile
From Ncumeyer after Zlttel.
have met with eminent success. The success of the reptile
at aviation was but short-lived however speaking in terms
of biological time, for the pterodactyls soon joined their
cousins the dinosaurs, the mososaurs and most of the other
antique saurians, and sank to a watery, which later became
a rocky, grave, to be resurrected after untold ages by the
prying eye and patient pick of the paleontologist. The ptero-
dactyls had wings of a thin skin or membrane stretched
between fore and hind limbs somewhat like the wings of a
bat. In the pterodactyls however only one of the fingers was
lengthened as a support for the membrane.
While the pterodactyls could not compete with the dino-
saurs or mososaurs in respect to size, nevertheless one at least
130 Biology in America
attained fairly respectable dimensions, Pteranodon having a
winf? spread of twenty to twenty-tive feet. This creature
with its long arms outstretched, a slender body and narrow
neck, at the top of which was poised a long narrow head, about
half of which was beak, might well have served as a model
for some P^gyptian or Assyrian god or goddess. Rhampho-
rhynchus, on the other hand, with his long tail, semi-human
form and claw-like fingers, would have made a very good
model for a winged Satan.
AVhile the pterodactyls are not directly related to birds,
they nevertheless show certain distinctly avian features, one
of the most notable of which is the hollow bones. In birds
air sacs extend from the lungs throughout the body even into
the bones, while the lungs themselves are small, but richly
supplied with blood vessels. These air sacs serve as reservoirs
for air, somewhat after the manner of a rubber bulb on a
pipette, serving to force strong currents in and out of the
body through the lungs, and thereby gain efficient aeration for
the blood ; which in birds is kept at a high temperature b}- the
active oxidation which takes place in the body in correspond-
ence with their great activity. Not only do these spaces in the
bones serve as air reservoirs, but they also serve to lighten
the bones, increasing their size, relative strength, and surface
for attachment for muscles, without unduly increasing their
weight ; just as the greatest strength in a pillar for a given
amount of material is obtained by making the pillar hollow.
AVhile we know very little about the lungs in the ptero-
dactyls it is interesting to find precisely the same adaptation
for lightness and strength of bone as we find in the birds.
This suggests Lamarck's idea that use (flight) produces
change (lightness of bone) in flying reptile as in flying bird.
But let us not be too hasty in swallowing alluring hypotheses.
We find to a certain extent the same air spaces in the bones
of the crocodile, which has never had any aspirations for
flying, Avhile the lizard, which is also in the main satisfied
with a mundane existence, has small air spaces or reservoirs
attached to its lungs. Thus we are driven to the conclusion
that the pterodactyl and the bird have made use of their
opportunities and have learned to fly because they "were
built that way,'' while the opportunities for flight of the lizard
and the crocodile are too small for them to use.
But there are yet other j)oints of resemblance between bird
and pterodactyl. In ])irds of flight the sternum or breast
bone has a prominent ridge or keel like a boat, which has
given them the title of Carinata? or keeled. This keel fur-
nishes an additional surface for the attachment of the power-
ful wing muscles. So too the pterodactyl had a keeled ster-
The Story of the Rocks
131
num. The pterodactyl's skull is prolonged into a prominent
beak like that of a bird, while in some instances its teeth
are as scarce as those of the proverbial hen. Yet others pos-
sessed numerous strong, sharp teeth lodged in sockets in the
jaw. The cavity of the skull bears a great similarity to that
of birds, while the sutures or lines of union of the skull
bones, as in the bird, have largely disappeared. The zo-
ologist believes this to be a case of "parallel evolution."
The pterodactyl had dreams of becoming a bird, but never
quite achieved his ambition.
But if the attempt at
aviation by the true rep-
tile was short-lived, he
yet produced the great-
est aviators among ani-
mals— the birds.
In the famous Solen-
hofen quarries in Ger-
many there was discov-
ered on August 15, 1861,
the print of a single
feather, and a few weeks
later the impresdon of
the bird itself was dis-
covered. Archaeopteryx,
the primitive or ancient
bird, as his name signi-
fies, was indeed primi-
was distinctly
for he wore
a distinction
Restoration of Arcii^opteryx
From Lucas, ' ' Animals of the Past. ' '
Conriid Lantern Slide
<'i)l>jl fuDiislieil hi/
CoiniHtity, Cltii-ayn.
tive, but
a bird,
feathers,
possessed by none of his
reptilian ancestors that
we now know. And yet the improbability of a bird
hatching full-fledged out of a reptile's egg, as St. Ililaire
suggested, is so unlikely, that we must assume many
intermediate stages in avian development; stages, which
Mother Earth has as yet declined to reveal. While Archas
opteryx is a full-fledged bird so far as its feathers are
concerned, it shows its reptilian parentage in several ways.
The modern l)ird possesses only a few small vertebra in
lieu of a fully formed tail, from which the tail feathers
radiate fan-like; Archaopteryx however liad a long reptilian
tail, with numerous vertebrae, and the feathers arranged in
a row on either side. It still had a full set of teeth like the
other early birds, Hesperornis and Ichthyornis, which were
discovered by Professor Marsh in 1870 in the chalk beds of
132
Biology in America
western Kansas, which were once at the bottom of the old Cre-
taceous Sea. Traces of teeth still occur in the embryos of some
birds of the j)resent, a heritage from some ancestor of the
distant past. While Icthyornis still had teeth, it had pro-
gressed much further along the path of avian development
than Archffiopteryx in the structure of the hand. Nature in
her experiments is prodigal in the production of variations,
most of which she will never use in the development of new
species ; but once she is on the track of a useful variation she
becomes a strict conservationist and wastes no energy in the
Hesperornis
extinct diving bird with teeth, an inhabitant of the great Creta-
sea wliif h once covered our Great Plains. From Lucas, ' ' Animals
Au
ceous
of the Past. ' '
Courtesy of the U. -b'. yatiuiuil Museum.
maintenance of useless parts. So in the hand of the modern
bird and in Icthyornis as well, we find one of the fingers
being greatly strengthened for the support of the wing
feathers, and the others correspondingly reduced. The typical
reptile has five fingers, which in the modern bird are reduced
to one plus two rudiments, while Archa?opteryx had dropped
only two of his digits and still remained in possession of the
claws on his wings wliich the modern bird has dispensed with
as entirely out of date. There is however one conservative
member of the class who still retains a reminder of his rep-
tilian past in the form of a claw at the angle of the wing,
The Story of the Rocks
ii^
Apteryx, or the kiwi of New Zealand, a country which in
its fauna is a sort of old curiosity shop, retaining such relics
of the past as the Port Jackson sliark, the tuatara, the kiwi
and until recently the moas. Yet a further legacy from his
reptilian ancestry did Archaiopteryx possess. This is a set
of abdominal ribs, or rib-like bones in the ventral wall of the
abdomen, which he shared in common with the New Zealand
lizard and the crocodile.
As to how birds took to flying we of course have no certain
knowledge. But we have some very ingenious and interesting
theories. In the first place what was the probable origin of
the feathers? A feather consists of a central shaft or quill
from which extend two rows of branches or barbs, and these
Part of a Feather
Showing shaft, barbs, barlniles and liooks. Original.
in turn give rise to a series of little barbs or barbules which
interlock with one another by means of rows of small hooks;
the whole forming a firm resistant membrane serving as a
propeller in the case of the wing feather, a rudder in that
of the tail feathers, and a protective and insulating covering
for the general body surface. At the base of the quill is a
small papilla or projection of the dermis, or lower layer of
the skin, which carries nerves and blood vessels and serves to
nourish the growing feather. The feather itself arises as a
tube of modified horny cells derived from the epidermis, or
outer skin layer, whicli splits into several parts in develop-
ment, which spread out to form the barbs and barbules. This
134 Biology in America
applies to the ordinary or "contour" feather. The ''down"
and "liair" feathers differ in development, although all have
essentially the same structure. Hairs are also developed
fundamentally in the same way as the feathers, with a dermal
papilla, or core, at the base and a horny shaft, which however
is solid and not hollow as in the feather.
Both of these structures, being derived from the horny
layer of the skin, are believed to be modifications of the horny
reptilian scale, which in its turn probably owes its origin to
the epidcniial layer or enamel of the placoid scale of the shark,
from which also has evolved the enamel of the mammalian
tooth.
But to return to the original question of the origin of the
birds. The theory of the Plungarian palaeontologist, Nopsca,
supposes the bird to have arisen from a long-legged, long-
tailed, short-armed running reptile, which as it ran flopped
its arms to aid its motion, on somewhat the same principle
that a man uses his arms in a race. If some of the scales along
the posterior angle of the arm and along either side of the
tail were to enlarge, they might readily aid the forerunner
of the bird in its motion and by further enlargement and
modification give rise to feathers, and the arm become a wing,
and the reptile a bird.
Another theory, advocated by Osborn, and more recently
by Beebe, assumes an arboreal reptile as the ancestral bird.
This creature is supposed to have been gifted with four wings
instead of two and a long tail, which it used much as a flying
squirrel uses its tail in sailing from tree to tree. AVitli loss
of the hind pair of wings and strengthening and improvement
of the front pair, the sailing reptile became a flying bird.
In support of this theory Beebe adduces a veiy interesting
fact. lie points out that in the newly hatched bird there is
a row of quills running along the outer side of the leg, in
such a position that, if developed, they would produce a
miniature wing. And further, just as in the case of the
"secondaries" (the smaller of the flight feathers in a bird's
wing) there develops above these quills and alternating with
them a second row of quills, which if developed would produce
"covert" feathers. Similar tufts of feathers occurred in
Archffiopteryx, which is strong evidence for Beebe 's theory,
for as we have already seen, higher animals tend to repeat
in an abbreviated way the structure of their ancestors.
Yot others adopt a compromise theory and assume that
while ArcluL'opteryx lived in trees, using his wings as well as
his feet for grasping the branches, yet his flight was not
merely a sailing one, but that the wings were actively used
for this purpose.
The Story of the Bocks 135
But whatever may have been the development of feathers
and origin of tiight in birds we find in Archieopteryx one of
the best "links" between two great groups anywhere to be
found in the animal kingdom.
While Archa3opteryx was smaller than a crow many of his
extinct relatives maintained the reputation of their reptilian
connections for size. Among these are the moas of New
Zealand, which must have become extinct within the memory
of man, for less than a century ago the Maoris firmly believed
in their existence. Their largest representative was the giant
moa, Dinornis maximus, which was at least ten feet high.
Another giant of the bird world was ^pyornis of Madagascar,
legends of which may have served as the basis for the roc
in the tales of Sinbad the Sailor ; but this was equalled by
Phoreracbis, the giant of the Patagonian pampas, who flour-
ished in Miocene days, long before the advent of man, and
who was seven or eight feet in height and had a skull
larger than that of a horse. Another although smaller bird
was the vulture, whose remains have recently been unearthed
or rather untarred from the tar pits of Rancho La Brea near
Los Angeles, Cal., whose spread of wing was probably greater
than that of the great condor, which today circles about the
Andean peaks of South America.
And so for the present we may leave the extinct reptiles
and their feathered kin, who in days of yore ruled earth and
sea and sky. "For the wind passeth over it and it is gone
and the place thereof shall know it no more." So passed
these creatures of antiquity, to give place to races better
fitted to cope with the new environments of the passing ages
and the changing earth. Many if not all of them will in their
turn go down in life's struggle before the advancing armies
of future generations, these in turn giving place to others,
until life itself shall be no more.
The reptiles and the birds form one of the topmost branches
of the vertebrate tree, while the mammals form the other.
The latter, while less spectacular in their evolution than the
former, are of even greater interest since man himself is one
of them, and since they are the latest, and in many ways
dominant group among the vertebrates of today.
As in the case of all great groups of animals and plants
the actual ancestor of the mammals is unknown. Nor is it
certain whether they are the offspring of amphibian, reptile
or some intermediate stock. Their first appearance was near
the beginning of the Mesozoic era, when the reptilian dynasty
was arising to rule the earth. The first of the mammals were
small creatures and were probably the prey of the carnivorous
reptiles, although they in turn may have been one cause of
136 Biology in America
the extinction of many of the latter, by destroying their eggs
with sharp gnawing teeth which well served them for this
j)urpose.
Although the origin of mainiuals is uncertain we find a
possible source in a group of reptiles known as cynodonts
from the dog-like character of their teeth, which occur in
triassic rocks in South Africa. The skull in many respects
resembles that of a mammal, while in othei^ it shows reptilian
characters.
But the cynodonts are found in the Trias, at the very be-
ginning of the Mesozoic era, at a time when the great rep-
tilian tree was but a slender sapling, while the "age of mam-
mals" does not commence until the close of the Mesozoic
era many millions of years later. What happened then to
retard mammalian development during the a;ons of time in
which ' ' great oceans waxed and waned and tiny hills to moun-
tains grew"? It is possible that during all this time our an-
cestors were living, like the Israelites of old, in bondage to the
Pharaohs, who in this instance were represented by the car-
nivorous reptiles; but when the "first born" of the reptiles
were cut down and the reptilian stock smitten by the inex-
orable hand of time, then the mammals arose, to take their
"place in the sun" and become the "lords of creation." Or
perchance the available food supply was not abundant at the
time of their birth and thus their development was checked
until a more favorable season.
"Perhaps the most remarkable thing which the history
of the Mesozoic brings forth is the immense period of evo-
lutionary stagnation on the part of the mammals. They are
first actually recorded in the Upper Triassic rocks of three
rather remote localities. North Carolina, Germany, and South
Africa, and are already differentiated in dietary habits.
During the Mesozoic, they develop in numbers and to a cer-
tain extent in tooth specialization. They do not, however,
increase markedly in size, but are humble folk, so far as our
records have revealed them, until the extinction of the dino-
saurs has been accomplished. One cannot but associate the
idea of mammalian suppression with that of dinosaurian
dominance in the relation of cause and effect, unless it shall
some day be revealed that the mammals were undergoing a
marked evolution beyond the temperature-limited habitat
of the reptiles. That the former showed no marked evolu-
tionary advance in the place where the dinosaurs actually
occurred is an attested fact, and the significance of the dino-
saurian check is no more graphically shown than by two
specimens in tlie Yale Museum. . . . The figure here repro-
duced is from a simultaneous photograph of these two sped-
The Story of the Roclcs
137
mens, which are therefore on exactly the same scale.
The single dinosanrian tooth p-ceatly exceeds not only
the tooth of the nianniial, but the (•< ntaininj; jaw or
even the entire creature as the imaj>ination conjure.-; it
up. "2
As to the cause of mammalian development we can again
only conjecture. Lull has suggested that increasing dryness
of climate and corresponding desert conditions, necessitar-
ing speed on the part of animals in search of food and water,
or in flight from their enemies, coupled with the extensive
glaciation in the Southern hemisphere in late Palaeozoic times,
Tooth of a Dinosaur Compared with the Jaw of a Coxtempuraky
Mammal
From Lull 's ' ' Organic Evolution. ' '
Courtesji of Professor Lull mid tlit' Miicmilhiii ComiJiniii.
which glaciation would mean increasing cold and the nred
of a furry covering, were the inciting causes. But apart
from the fact that this explanation implies, if it does not
state, an acceptance of Lamarck's doctrine, which at the
present time is in the discard with most zoologists, is the
further fact that the succeeding or Mesozoic era was one
which witnessed the remarkable development of reptiles,
which are distinctly types not adapted to aridity and cold-
ness of climate. Perhaps the best we can do after all, when,
as so frequently happens in pliilosophy and science, we find
^Lull, "Evolution of the Earth," pp. 133-134. By permission of the
Yale University Press.
138
Biology in America
ourselves "up a stump," is to accept the philosophy of Topsy
and admit that they "jest grew."
Tlie ]\Iesozoic and early Eocene mammals were all primi-
tive types and most of them disappeared from the face of the
earth without leaving any descendants.
"It is the mammals which were the strangest element of
Paleoccne life, and (an) imaginary observer would find no
creature tliat he had ever seen before. The difference from
modern mammalian life was not merely one of species, genera
or even families, but of orders, for only one, or at most two,
The Opossum
The only marsupial at j)reseiit found in the United States.
Photo hij Elu-iih /'. Sa)iJ)orn.
By permission of the Neic York Zoological Society.
of the orders now living were then to be found in North
America, and both of these (marsupials and insectivores) were
primitive and archaic groups, which seem like belated sur-
vivals in the modern world." ^
It is possible however that the marsupial types of these
early mammals have come down to us as the marsupials of
the present. The marsupials derive their name from the
marsupium or pouch in which they carry the young for some
time after birth. These latter are born in a very undevel-
oped condition and at birth are transferred by the mother
'Scott, "History of Land Mammals in the Western Hemisphere," p.
284. By permission of the Macmillan Company.
The Story of the Rocks
139
to her pouch where their mouths become temporarily attached
to the mother's teats and where they grow in safety until
ready for their second debut in the world. AVell-known ex--
amples are our own opossum, and the Australian kangaroo.
The distribution of modern marsupials is very peculiar and
with otlier facts has given rise to interesting speculations re-
garding the earlier form of Mother Earth. Their repre-
sentatives are found today exclusively in Australia and ad-
jacent regions, South America and tropical North America,
with the exception of the opossum of the United States. In
The 8riNY Ant-Eater
A luoiiotreme, one of the most prii)iitive of. mammals.
Photo by Elivin R. Sanhorn
By permisawti of the Xeiv York Zoological Society.
Mesozoic and Eocene time however the marsupial stock was
distributed over North America and Europe and possibly
Asia as well.
The distribution of the ostrich in Africa and its relatives,
the rhea in South America, and cassowary and emu in Aus-
tralia and the East Indies and the recently extinct moa of
New Zealand, is similar to that of the marsupials. These
facts and other similar ones have led many biologists and
palaeontologists to the belief in a migration of life from the
northern hemisphere into the southern at some very early
period in the earth's history. They have also suggested the
existence of former land connections between South Amer-
140 Biology in America
iea, Africa, Tndi.i jiikI Australia known as Antarctica and
Gondwana Land wliii-li is sniijxisod to account for the simi-
larity of many of the forms of life in the two reg:ions, not
oidy of birds and mammals but of reptiles, amphibia, fishes,
invertebrates and plants as well.
Wliih' the early luaniinals disappeared for the most part
without issue there were amony them some which were elected
to serve as pro«jenitors of the mighty tribe which has since
peopled the ciirlh. Whence came the present monotremes
and marsupials is matter of much doubt, tlieir relationship
to the pi-imitive members of these groups being uncertain,
but the origin of modern carnivores is pretty certainly to be
found in tlie ancient creodonts.
After the close of the Cretaceous period with the rise of
the western part of the North American continent and con-
sequent draining of the great inland sea, which formerly
stretched from the Arctic Ocean to the Gulf of Mexico, there
appeared extensive swamps or fresh water lakes in what is
now North Dakota, Montana and the Rocky Mountain and
Great Basin regions and British Columbia. These various
lakes did not all appear at once, but succeeded one another
with succeeding changes in elevation and form of the land.
It was now that the lignite beds of North Dakota and Mon-
tana were laid down, covering an area approximately 60,000
square miles in extent.
"The clijnate, as shown by the plants, was much milder
and more uniform than that of the Recent epoch, though
some indication of climatic zones may already be noted. The
vegetation was essentially modern in character; nearly all
our modern types of forest-trees, such as willows, poplars,
sycamores, oaks, elms, maples, walnuts and many others, were
abundantly represented in the vast forests which would seem
to have covered nearly the entire continent from ocean to
ocean and extended north into Alaska and Greenland, where
no such vegetation is possible under present conditions. Nu-
merous conifers were mingled with the deciduous trees, but
we do not find exclusively coniferous forests. Palms, though
not extending into Greenland, flourished magnificently far to
the north of their present range. On the other hand, the
Paleocene fiora of England points to a merely temperate cli-
mate, while that of the succeeding Eocene was subtropical."*
Upon the land and in the lakes were laid down deposits
of wind-driven dust or loess and volcanic ash or tufa, while
the streams deposited in their deltas sand and gravel carried
down from the higher lands in which they took their rise.
The majestic Rocky Mountains of today were then in their
* Scott, locus citatus, pp. 102-103.
'jt
•
4
[|gjp*-SN.\ SR^^Rr^B^^^H^F^jEpA^ "■SWftW'' ^^B nB
^^pc
' ^^w ^W'^llm i
"jh^Wi-r
Top — Restoration of Uixtatherium
Center — Restoration of Coryphodon
Boifom- — Restoration of the Creodont Dromocyon
From (Irnwings by Horsfall in Scott's " Mjiiunials of the Western
Hemisphere. ' '
Bi/ permission of the MacmilUin Company.
Copy furniished by Conrad Lantern Slide Company, Chicago.
141
142 Biology in America
infancy, and great was the travail of the earth in bringing
them forth, for several active volcanoes marked their course.
From these, great clouds of ashes were hurled forth to set-
tle upon earth and water. Such was the home of the creo-
donts, the forerunners of modern Carnivora. Of these the
j\Iiacid;i? are believed to represent the progressive branch des-
tined to flourish and bring forth fruit, while the other
branches have withered and died. They were creatures much
like the modern carnivores in general appearance, but with
small brain-case and a very high ridge on the upper side of
the skull for attachment of the powerful jaw muscles, and
the teeth were not so well formed for eating flesh as in mod-
ern carnivores. Remains of the LliacidiE have been found
from "Wyoming to New Mexico. As in many another case of
evolution in animals, the old adage "great oaks from little
acorns grow" applied to the iNIiacidae, for the forerunners
of the "king of beasts" and the man-eating tiger were little
fellows content to prey on smaller fry of field and forest.
Many of their relatives however were larger fellows, equalling
in size a small bear. Associated with the creodonts were
other creatures, many of them of huge size and ungainly
form. Here shambled the coryphodonts, ugly brutes, equal-
ling a small rhinoceros in size and somewhat resembling a
hippopotamus in form, with heavy tusks, elephantine feet
and short, heavy legs, and Uintatherium, a creature so bizarre
in form that it seems as if Nature had designed it to grace a
pala^ontological dime museum. The skull of this beast, not
being able to find room for growth along ordinary lines, ran
riot in the matter of horns. He had horns on his snout and
horns on his forehead and horns at the back of his head and
as if these were not enough to gratify his propensity for
horny embellishment, his upper canine teeth were prolonged
into gi'cat tusks, or horns turned upside down. The female
however Avas much more conservative in the matter of horns,
while she lacked the tusks entirely. The general form of
the beast was quite similar to that of its relatives, the cory-
phodonts. Beside these ungainly beasts there were othei'S
resembling the present sloths of South America and repre-
sentatives of the modern shrews and moles.
As in the case of man the aborigine has given place to
the invader from distant lands, so too the primitive mammals
of North America, which were natives of the country, have
been displaced by more recent types which have immigrated
from other regions. "Whence they came cannot certainly be
determined, but probably Asia was their birthplace, whence
like the human race they have wandered throughout the
world. It has repeatedly happened in geologic history that
The Story of the Rocks
143
North America has been connected with Asia by a mass of
land or "bridg:e" across Behrin<if Sea. It apjjcars likely
that there was a similar "bridge" joining America and Eu-
rope at this time (Lower Eocene), for many mammals were
common to both continents.
The canse of their migration is likewise nncertain, but nat-
ural increase and competition for food may have been one
of the compelling causes tlien as they are now in determin-
ing animal movements. We need oidy recall the move-
ments of the herds of bison, which formerly roamed across
v^-^.^'.
.. #
,^||PPi|i^
^5^3r^
Ciit'm^'':
'^^^~'-
fiw-K,V
EoHipPus, THE ' ' Dawn Horse ' '
From a restoration by Chas. K. Knight.
Courtesy of the Amerwan Museum of Natural History.
our western prairies in search of food, the plague of locusts
which overwhelmed the early settlers in Kansas, or the spread
of the English sparrow from east to west to find an explana-
tion for animal movements in the past. But possibly an-
other, and even more potent factor was the gradually in-
creasing refrigeration of the polar region, which occurred
subsequent to the Eocene, and which culminated in the gla-
eiation of the "great ice age" of the Pleistocene epoch. In
the latter there is abundant evidence of the movement of
northern mammals before the advancing ice, for we "find re-
mains of walruses in New Jersey, of reindeer in southern
France and of the musk ox in Kentucky.
144
Biology in America
Among these inniiigrants of Ihc past were members of the
rodent or rat order, tiny forerunners of tlie artiodaetyls or
mammals Avith paired toes, inelnding eattlc, sheep, eamels,
goats, pigs, etc., ancient tapii-s, and Kohippus, the tirst of
the horses, a graceful little creature about the size of a do-
mestic cat, with four front, and three hind toes and indi-
cations of a fifth toe in the front, and possibly two extra toes
in the hind foot. In the Wasatch beds which cover large
areas in New Mexico, Colorado, Utah, Wyoming and Mon-
tana their remains are found in great numbers, so that they
must have been common inhabitants of this region in early
Eocene da^^s.
The Tarsier
Whose relatives in rlays gone by inhabited the forests of North
America, but today is found in the East Indies and the Philippines.
From Lull, after Brehm.
But perhaps the most interesting of the early invaders of
North America were small monkey-like habitues of the tree-
tops in the Wasatch forests. Their invasion however was
but temporary, as they died out later in the Eocene, never
to reappear in North America. Inhabiting the forests of
the Malay Aichipelago is a little squirrel-like monkey, the
tarsier. "The particular interest which Tarsius possesses for
the student of American mammals is its resemblance to the
Wasatch genus Ana])toniorphus, the type of a family which
was abundant and varied in the lower and middle Eocene.
This genus was remarkably advanced in view of its great
antiquity. . . . The face was very much shortened ; the orbits
were very large and encircled in bone, but without the pes*
The Story of the Rocks 145
terior wall. This produces a decided likeness to the Tar-
sier and is no doubt indicative of nocturnal habits. The cra-
nium was remarkably large, and no other Wasatch animal
had a brain-case so capacious in proportion to its size. . . .
It is hardly likely that these American lemurs were the actual
ancestors of the anthropoids, but they closely represent what
those ancestors mnst have been. ' ' ^
With the passing of the Eocene epoch the early mammals
vanished from the face of the earth. The cause of their ex-
tinction is as uncertain as is that of the disappearance of
the great reptiles. Undoubtedly the broad underlying fac-
tor was lack of adaptability to new conditions, both physical
and biological. With changes in climate and in the form of
the earth's surface (rise of mountains, formation of seas and
lakes, islands and archipelagoes forming out of continents,
etc.) new environments develop and animals which cannot
meet these new conditions are bound to perish. Physical
changes also produce new conditions of food and these in
turn lead to new competitions among animals themselves.
Osborn believes that three of the main factors in the extinc-
tion of the ancient mammals were their small brains, their
deficient teeth and poor feet, all of which are serious handi-
caps today in human evolution. INIarsh has shown that sur-
viving races of animals have in general larger brains than
dying ones, and while it is not a hard and fast rule that the
larger the brain the greater is the intelligence, still brain
power and brain size do in general go hand in hand, and
these in turn are good indices of success, or survival in the
struggle for existence.
From the northern invaders have come then in great part
the mammals of today. In a brief review such as the pres-
ent, space does not permit a consideration of any but a few
of many interesting forms whose remains have been made
known to us by the labors of the paleontologist. But we
may catch a fleeting glimpse in passing of some of the crea-
tures of the past which once roamed upon our hills and dwelt
within our valleys.
One of the most picturesque of these was Smilodon or the
saber-toothed tiger, which stalked his prey over the western
continent from Pennsylvania to Argentina, during the
Pleistocene epoch, when the polar ice cap successively invaded
and retreated over northern North America. This power-
ful and ferocious beast was the size of the present tiger, with
shorter, stouter legs than those of modern cats, a heavy body,
powerfully muscled, and a short tail as in the modem bob-
cat. But the most striking feature were the tusks in the
•Scott, locus citatus, p. 581.
146
Biology in America
upper jaw which are eight inches long or more. These tusks
have sonicwliat the shape of a scimitar, being flattened on the
sides and narrow transversely, with a saw-tooth edge behind.
The opposing teeth of the lower jaw were undeveloped. How
the animal eonld have handhnl these enormous tusks is a
problem, but it has been suggested tliat they were used some-
what as a venomous snake uses its fangs, to strike and kill
the prey rather than for cutting and biting it, Tliis theory
is supported by the relatively weak lower jaw, as compared
with that of a modern cat, and the large mastoid process at
the base of the skull, in which were inserted the great mus-
B
i
w^jt *^^^SSKt
ki^^!^^^^^^^^^^^^^^!
i^E *
m
^'^^^^^^^1
1 i^^^H
m
■fl
The Saber-Toothed Tiger
From a restoration by Chas. R. Knight.
Courtesy of the American Muncum of Natural History.
cles used for lowering the head and striking the prey. The
gape must have been enormous to allow free play for the use
of these great fangs, and indeed it is not impossible that the
animal owes its extinction to overgrowth of these teeth, which
finally became a hindrance rather than a help to their pos-
sessor.
And what were tlie victims of this cruel tyrant of the
past? Its occurrence with the thick-skinned cumbrous beasts
like the elephant and the giant sloth, and the fact that it
must have been less agile than its modern cousins, to judge
from its thick-set legs and body, have been advanced by Lull
as reasons for supposing that these animals formed its prin-
cipal prey ; while the swifter footed, more agile cats of to-
The Story of the Rocks 147
day, like the lion and tiger, are adapted to preying upon
swift-footed beasts sueli as deer or horses.
In the oil flekis of southern California there was recently
discovered one of the most remarkable ' ' finds ' ' of bones ever
made in America, and the Kancho La Brea beds are now
famous the world over. About fifteen feet below the surface
of the ground is a layer of oil-bearing rock, from which oil
and tar issue and evaporating and oxidizing form beds of
asphalt. These tar pools are intermingled with pools of
water at many points, and many of them are partly covered
with water. In these tar pools animals are occasionally
trapped, several species of wild animals having recently come
to an untimely end in this manner, while domestic animals
are frequently caught and liberated only with great diffi-
culty. Professor Merriam of the University of California
who has studied these pools more extensively than anyone
else, cites the following amusing incident of the efficacy of
the tar as a trap for animals. ''A number of workmen were
engaged in covering a piece of road with asphalt, and had
left their work only partially completed in the latter part
of a warm afternoon. A drunken man passing a short time
afterward fell by the roadside and remained there to take
a nap. By chance he extended himself on some of the partly
softened asphalt. Falling asleep quickly he evidently lay
for a long time without moving. During this time his body
sank part way into the sticky mass. After the sun went down
and the atmosphere had cooled, the tar hardened somewhat,
and by morning it was practically solid. When the man
awoke, he found it impossible to extricate himself. His cries
attracted a number of persons, who attempted to free him.
Unfortunately the whole side of his body and his head were
firmly set in the asphalt, and it was very difficult to give
him any assistance. With the aid of an axe and Various
other fools, they finally succeeded in cutting and prying him
out, but not without injuring him somewhat. He was taken
to a hospital nearby, where numerous attempts were made
to separate the tar from his body. Only after shaving his
head and scrubbing him with benzine was it possible to give
him an aspect of respectability, ' ' "^
The presence of bones in tliese tar pits has been known for
a half-century, but until recently they were generally as-
sumed to be the remains of modern animals and but little
attention was paid to them. About twenty years ago how-
ever they came to the notice of Professor Merriam, and since
then have been excavated, and carefully studied and de-
scribed. The pits are filled with a heterogeneous collection
'"Harper's WeeJcly," Dec. 18, 1909.
148
Biology in America
ERTY
. State
of bones, ^eat and small, saber-toothed tigers and giant
wolves, imperial elephants, camels, bison, horses and ground
sloths mingling their remains with those of mice, rabbits and
squirrels. Many of these bones are those of modern animals,
but a large number represent extinct forms. Of bird re-
mains the most striking are those of the giant condor, but
even more interesting are those of a peacock, an immigrant
from Asia, and unknown elsewhere in America.
The frontispiece to Scott's beautiful work on the mammals
1 IBRAR^ ^^^^ western hemisphere is a drawing by Ilorsfall repre-
jiseiUing one of these tar pools of southern California in Pleis-
Cotlflfcene time, which is of fascinating interest, especially to
one who has seen these wonderful collections of prehistoric,
Excavation op a Tar Pit at Eancho La Brea near Los Angeles,
California. Original.
mingled with modern life. Mixed in the tar at the edge of
the pool lies the carcass of a giant elephant, over which a
giant wolf and a saber-toothed tiger are quarrelling for pos-
session, while another wolf caught in the tar nearby snarls
defiance at the others. In the background, perched on a
dead tree, or soaring overhead, are expectant condors, wait-
ing to feast upon vanquished and victor, when they like
their prey shall have fallen victims to the relentless tar,
while on the shore are the bleaching bones of some fonner
visitant to the fateful pool. And thus may we picture to
ourselves the tragic fate of creatures whose remains have
come down to us today to tell the story of the life that was.
Here too are found the bones of camels which once inhab-
ited North America, and migrated thence to the old world
probably via the Behring Isthmus, which at various times
The Story of the Rocks
149
formed the route of migration of many fonns between the
old world and the new. Why the camels should have left
their birthplace in North America and wandered forth to the
ends of the earth is a mystery, as are so many other prob-
lems in the history of animals as well as in that of man. So
too the horse, whose earliest home is uncertain, underwent
his great evolutionary development in North America, whence
he migrated from time to time into South America, Europe,
Asia, and Africa, and finally disappeared from his ancestral
home, only to be re-established there by the agency of man.
Early Days in the Tar Pools of Southern California
A saber toothed tiger and giant wolf coniestiiig llie carcass of an
elephant while condors are waiting nearby, until victor and vanquished
alike shall have fallen victims to tiie tar. From an illustration by
Horsfall in Scott's "History of Land Mammals in the Western Hemi-
sphere. ' '
Bii permifinion of the Mdcmithin Company.
Here we encounter another unsolved problem in palasontol-
ogy — the extinction of the horse in the Americas. Glacial
conditions alone would seem inadequate, nor does there seem
to have been a sufficient development of larger carnivores to
explain it. So some sort of a pestilence has been called in
to aid in the explanation, but this is merely a recourse to the
unknown, a last stand of the defeated philosopher, when no
available facts will serve his purpose.
Thus in the "sands of time" as well as in flesh and bone
1'50 Biology in America
and sinew of living creatures may we trace the ways of evo-
lution, whose workings "declare the glory of God." Many
indeed are the blank pages in the rccor^l, which must be left
for the future to fill in ; but in spite of all the gaps the voices
of rock and flower, of the "bird of the air" and the "beast
of the field" tell the same story — a tale of attempt and
achievement, of progress and of promise for the days which
are to be.
i
i
CHAPTER V
Geographical distrihutian of plants and anhnals. Relation
between organism and enviromnent. Methods of, and
barriers to the spread of plants and animals. Plant and
animal societies. Life zones of North America.
Ill surveying the organic world today one is struck by
the fact that the lower organisms as well as man are distrib-
uted in societies, each of which has its characteristic aspect.
From the wind-swept tundras of the north to the sunlit ever-
glades of the south, we may pass in review one succession
after another of plant and animal societies, each more or
less distinctive of the region in which it occurs; and if we
encompass the earth from east to west we encounter an even
greater diversity of living things, even though the physical
characters of every realm are more or less alike. And fur-
ther, if we survey the past history of life upon the earth, we
find an ever-shifting panorama, as fascinating in its chang-
ing scenes as is the restless sea of human life, whose ebb and
tlow make history. And what the cause of all this change?
"Where may we find a key to the checker-board puzzle of
the living world? How have arisen the organic societies of
past and present, and why their ceaseless succession like the
play of light and shade? AVliile the immediate causes of the
movement and association of plants and animals upon the
earth is as yet in many instances obscure, we may seek for
the ultimate cause in the great principle of competition among
living things and in their adjustment to their environment.
Not alone does the fitness of the organism to its environment
determine its survival, but the fitness of the environment to
the organism and the ability of the latter to find its proper
place in nature. Many a square peg has gone down in the
battle of life because it failed to find a square hole, among
lower organisms as well as among men.
The problem of geographical distribution then is that of
finding the place of origin of any given type of life, the rea-
sons for, and the routes and methods of its spread from its
center of origin, as well as the manner of its adaptation to
the surroundings, both biological and physical, in which it
lives today.
151
152
Biology in America
As the explorer setting forth upon an unknown journey
concerns himself first of all with his equipment and means
of travel, so must tlie student of l)i()-gcography consider pri-
nuirily the factors wliieli th^terminc the dispersal of plants
and animals throuf^hout the world. Animals of strong
Hight, like most birds and bats, are relatively unhindered in
their movements and coiisequently these groups are of world-
wide distribution. The greatest travelei- in tlie world is the
arctic tern which spends its summers amid the arctic snows,
where its newly hatched young have been found surrounded
by a wall of freshly fallen snow scraped out of the nest by
the parent bird, and journeys south 11,0(JU miles to spend
its winter on the shores of the antarctic continent. Many
The Aectic Teen
The greatest traveller in \\\v world. !■ rom Cuoke, "Bird Migration,"
in Bulletin Bureau of JViological Survey.
other birds make semi-annual journeys of close to 10,000 miles
and the great majority of them travel long distances on their
migrations. Bats also migrate long distances, this fact of-
fering a possible explanation of their presence on some oceanic
islands, otherwise destitute of native mammals.
Marine animals, especially fishes, are often widespread in
their distrilnition because of their powers of migration and
the relative absence of barriers within the sea, but fresh
water fishes are generally limited more or less closely to the
area in wiiieli Ihey occur. No general rule however can be
laid down.
Among terrestrial animals the greatest travellers are the
mammals and these often perform long journeys, a habit
characteristic of the bison "that ever-journeying animal,
which moves in countless droves from i)oint to point of the
/ Geographical Distnhution 153
vast wilderness; traversing plains, pouring through the in-
tricate defiles of mountains, swimming rivers, ever on the
move. . . . These great migratory herds of buffalo have their
hereditary paths and highways, worn deep through the coun-
try, and making for the surest passes of tlie mountains, and
the most practicable fords of the rivers. When once a great
column is in full career, it goes straight forward, regardless
of all obstacles; those in front being impelled by the moving
mass behind. At such times they will break through a camp,
trampling down everything in their course.
"It was the lot of the voyagers, one night, to encamp at
one of these buffalo landing places, and exactly on the trail.
They had not been long asleep when they were awakened by
a great bellowing, and tramping, and the rush, and splash,
and snorting of animals in the river. They had just time
to ascertain that a buffalo army was entering the river on
the opposite side and making toward the landing place. With
all haste they moved their boat and shifted their camp, by
which time the head of the column had reached the shore,
and came pressing up the bank.
"It was a singular spectacle, by the uncertain moonlight,
to behold this countless throng making their way across the
river, blowing and bellowing, and splasliing. Sometimes they
pass in such dense and continuous column as to form a tem-
porary dam across the river, the waters of which rise and
rush over their backs, or between their squadrons. The roar-
ing and rushing sound of one of these vast herds crossing
a river, may sometimes in a still night be heard for miles. ' ' ^
The common house rat is sometimes a wide traveler. "]\li-
grations of rats have often been recorded. Pallas narrates
that in the autumn of 1727 the brown rat arrived at Astra-
khan in southern Russia from the east in such numbers and
in so short a time that nothing could be done to oppose them.
They crossed the Volga in large troops. The cause of the mi-
gration was attributed to an earthquake ; but since similar
movements of this species often occur unattended by earth
disturbance, it is probable that only the food problem was
involved in the migration which tirst brought the brown rat
to Europe.
**In nearly all countries a seasonal movement of rats from
houses and barns to the open fields occurs in spring, and
the return movement takes place as cold weather approaches.
The movement is noticeable even in large cities.
"But more general movements of rats often occur. In
1903 a multitude of migrating rats spread over several coun-
* Irving, ' ' The Adventures of Captain Bonneville, " U. S. A., p. 354.
By permission of G. P. Putnam's Sons.
154 Biology in America
ties of western Illinois, They were noticed especially in
jMercer and Kock Island counties. For several years prior
to this invasion no abnormal numbers were seen, and their
coming was remarkably sudden. An eyewitness to the phe-
nomenon informed the writer that as he was returning to his
home by moonlight he heard a general rustling in the field
near by, and soon a vast army of rats crossed the road in
front of him, all going in one direction. The mass stretched
away as far as could be seen in the dim light. These animals
remained on the farms and in the villages of the surrounding
country, and during the winter and summer of 1904 were a
veritable plague." -
Even the humble field mouse may perform long pilgrimages.
"The lemings, also, a small kind of rat, are described as na-
tives of the mountains of Kolen, in Lapland; and once or
twice in a quarter of a century they ajjpear in vast numbers,
advancing along the ground and 'devouring every green
thing.' Innumerable bands march from the Kolen, through
Northland and Finmark, to the AVestern Ocean, which they
immediately enter; and after swimming about for some time,
perish. Other bands take their route through Swedish Lap-
land to the Bothnian Gulf, where they are drowned in the
same manner. They are followed in their journeys by bears,
wolves, and foxes, which prey upon them incessantly. They
generally move in lines, which are about three feet from each
other, and exactly parallel, going directly forward through
rivers and lakes ; and when they meet with stacks of hay or
corn, gnawing their way through them instead of passing
round. These excursions usually precede a rigorous winter,
of which the lemings seem in some way forewarned. ' ' ^
Reptiles and Amphibia, because of their inadeijuate means
of locomotion and their sluggish habits, are poor travellers
and their dispersal must be due in the main to natural in-
crease or to i)urely passive causes such as transfer of eggs
by currents of water or to the agency of man.
Apart from the insects the invertebrates are for the most
part inactive migrants, and here too dispersal is mainly pas-
sive, though some animals, such as the squid or octopus, are
active swimmers, and probably travel considerable distances
"under their own steam," so to speak.
The means of passive dispersal of animals are numerous
and varied. In the transport of marine animals currents
play the greatest part. In this way animals are carried
great distances at sea, distances Avhich are limited only by
the animal's power of survival and by the extent of the cur-
='Laiitz, "The Brown Eat in the United States," pp. 16-17.
"Lyell, "Principles of Geology," 11th cd., Vol. II, p. 361.
Geographical Distribution 155
rent itself. Even land animals may be carried over wide
stretches of water by winds and currents. The late Alfred
Russell Wallace records the transjjort of a boa constrictor
from Africa to St. Vincent, two hundred miles away, on a
floating cedar tree. Polar bears have occasionally been
stranded upon the shores of Iceland by icebergs. Lyell quotes
an early observer to the effect that "wolves, in the arctic re-
gions, often venture upon the ice near the shore, for the pur-
pose of preying upon young seals, which they surprise when
asleep. When these ice-floes get detached, the wolves are
often carried out to sea ; and though some may be drifted to
islands or continents, the greater part of them perish, and
have been heard in this situation howling dreadfully, as they
die by famine. According to the same authority travellers
in the Amazon country have on several occasions observed
monkeys, squirrels, crocodiles and other animals journeying
down that river on rafts of floating trees and tangled vege-
tation. Four pumas from such rafts are reported to have
visited ]\Iontevideo in one night."*
Fresh water invertebrates may be carried by currents of
water or attached to the feet of birds, or by the wind in the
case of the eggs or cysts from the bottom of diy pools.
JNIan's role in the spread of the animal inhabitants of the
earth is a very important one. The early Spanish explorers
brought horses to South America in 1537, "and the colony
being then for a time deserted, the horse ran wild ; in 1580,
only forty-three years afterwards, we hear of them at the
Strait of Magellan!"^ The spread of the English sparrow
and the brown rat, both introduced species from Europe, is
too well known to need repetition here, while the devastation
wrought among the trees of New England by the brown-tail
and the gypsy moths, is a warning example of the danger of
disturbing the scales which Nature ordinarily holds so nicely
balanced.
The spread of animals and their occupation of the earth
resolves itself into a gi-eat obstacle race, and "the race is not
always to the swift." The barriers to the spread of animals
are manifold — temperature, moisture, sunlight, chemical char-
acter of water, mountains, rivers, lakes or seas, deserts, for-
ests and treeless plains are all barriers to various kinds of
animals. Temperature is probably the greatest obstacle to
the dispersal of marine animals. AVere it not for the trop-
ics intervening between the temperate and colder seas of
north and south their distribution would probably be world
* Lyell, locus citatiis, p. 366.
^Darwin, "Voyage of a Naturalist," p. 233. D. Appleton and
Company.
156 Biology in America
wide, but temperature is usually, though not always, a very
effective barrier to their spread. This was strikingly illus-
trated by the disappearance of the tiiefish off the xVtlantic
coast some years ago, which has been described in a previ-
ous chapter. Currents may serve not alone as a means of
transport for inactive forms, but through temperature dif-
ferences as a bari'ier to their spread, as well. Northern ani-
mals drifting southward in the Atlantic under the influence
of the Labrador current, sweeping past the shores of Labra-
dor and Newfoundland, may be caught by the Gulf Stream
moving toward the northwestern coasts of Europe, and their
southern journey terminated.
During the cruise of the U. S. Bureau of Fisheries steamer
in 1884, Captain Tanner reports that on July 20, when off
the mouth of Chesapeake Bay "we passed numerous dead
octopods floating on the surface. This unusual sight at-
tracted immediate notice and no little surprise among those
who knew their habits, as it was not suspected at first that
they were dead. . . . These dead cephalopods were seen fre-
quently on the 100-fathom line and outside of it, from the
position given above to the meridian of jMontauk Point, a
distance of 180 miles. They were less numerous however as
we went to the northward and eastward. Several dead squid
were seen also, and two specimens were picked up with a
scoop-net."*^
"From the Barents Sea we know many instances of a sim-
ilar destruction of animals on a large scale. The case of the
boreo-arctic fish, the capelan ... is specially striking, niil-
lions of this fish having occasionally been found drifting
dead at the surface. In the Barents Sea very sudden changes
of temperature occur, and it is natural to conclude that the
death of the fish is caused thereby. The greatest destruction
of this kind probably occurs among the young stages, eggs
and larvae of fishes. As we shall see later, these young
stages may be removed by currents very far from the places
where they are capable of developing, and in all probability
they are liable to encounter catastrophes which sweep them
off in enormous numbers."'^
So too the chemical environment prevents the invasion of
inland waters by marine forms and vice versa, although this
is not true of those fish like the shad and salmon, which
ascend the rivers at spawning time. In such cases however
the age and sexual maturity of the fish determine their move-
ments, so that at most times of the year with these fish as well
•Tanner "Eoport of U. S. Fish Commissioner for 1884," p. 32.
'Murray, "The Depths of the Ocean," pp. 707-8. By permission of
the Macmillan Company.
Geographical Distribution 157
as others the salt eontent of tlie water does limit their distri-
bution. The extent to Avhieh fresh water fisli can with-
stand salt water and vice versa is still a moot question, but
the salt content certainly does i^\n.j a determining role in the
distribution of all fish.
The inhabitants of inland w^aters also find the chemical
environment one of the determining factors in their distri-
bution. Here one may find all degrees of salinity from fresh
or slightly saline waters, to those such as the Dead Sea in
Palestine or the Great Salt Lake of Utah, containing much
greater amounts of salt than does the ocean. Correspond-
ing to the differences in the saltiness of these inland waters
there are marked diiferences in the kinds of life inhabiting
them.
The barriers to the spread of land animals are more nu-
merous than are those which affect aquatic forms. As with
the latter so too with these does temperature play an impor-
tant part. Every one is familiar with the great differences
between the animal life of the tropics and the poles, and
equally marked are those which strike the observer as he as-
cends some lofty mountain, and the more so the farther south
the mountain lies. Mountain ranges have a notable influ-
ence in separating one fauna from another. The animal life
of the Great Plains of the east is distinctly different from that
of the Great Basin to the west of the Rocky Mountains.
Wide stretches of desert present an impassable obstacle to
most forms of life, while bodies of water may with equal em-
phasis say to the animal wanderer "Thus far shalt thou go,
and no farther."
Plant journeys are wholly passive ones, and affected mainly
by the carriage of fruit or seed by wind, water and animals.
The tumble-weed driven across the prairie by the wind and
heaping itself up in great piles along the fences, the down of
the dandelion as it floats idly through the air on a summer
afternoon to settle softly in some protected corner of your
front lawn, and the long-awned heads of the fox-tail grass
tumbling merrily over field and roadside all bear emphatic
testimony to the part played by wind in the spread of plants,
especially those which are an unmitigated nuisance ; while
any one who has watched a dog disentangling himself from a
coat full of burs will realize the important role played by
animals in plant distribution. One of the most important
factors in plant distribution is man himself. To prove this
one need only follow a railway track or a highway and note
the never-ending succession of Avecds, which are distributed
thereon. ]\Iany of the most common and pestiferous mem-
bers of plant as well as of animal and human society are im-
158 Biology in Anio-ica
migrants from Europe — witness the Eussian sow thistles, the
wild radisli and the barnyard grass.
To discuss in any detail the past movements and distribu-
tion of plants and animals in North America would in itself
fill a more than ample volume. In the preceding elmpter
some of the great movements of animal life in North Amer-
ica have been briefly mentioned, and under the present head-
ing it must suffice to consider briefly some of the facts and
problems of present day distribution and of the relations of
plant and animal societies to one another and to their sur-
roundings.
The study of plant ecology, that is, the study of the plant
at home, as an individual and as a member of society, owes
its inception in America to the work of Pound and Clements,
who in their " Phytogeography of Nebraska" in 1897 de-
scribed the plant societies of that state and developed new
and more accurate methods for their study. This was fol-
lowed in 1905 by Clements' "Research INIethods in Ecology,"
in which the whole field of plant ecology and the methods for
its investigation were presented. Following the appearance
of these works came a host of papers dealing with various
phases of plant ecology, the most comprehensive of which is
that of Clements on "Plant Succession."
When an area of land is denuded of its plant covering, as
happens far too often in our fire-swept forests, or as a result
of fioods or landslides ; or when a new area appears as in the
case of the drying up of a lake or the shifting of a river,
there is an inrush of plant settlers to occupy the virgin soil.
The character of the new settlers depends upon many fac-
tors— the character of the new soil, the relative proximity of
adjacent species of plants, the ease with which the seeds or
runners' of these plants can reach the new territory and their
readiness to establish themselves there after their arrival.
The arrival of the new settlers will depend upon all the many
factors which determine plant dispersal — strength and direc-
tion of wind currents, presence of streams and rainfall, drain-
age which may carry seeds on to the new area, and the abim-
dance and movements of seed-bearing animals.
In the broken chasms of mountain fastnesses, where the
shattered peaks that were, now lie in a mass of tumbled ruin,
or upon the sheer slopes of granite cleft by some contortion
of the earth, the humble lichen finds its home. In some small
chink or crevice of tlie rock where a few drops of water lin-
ger from the winter's snow, its filaments take hold, and when
the breath of summer dries its niche it lies dormant waiting
for the rain or melting snow. Through the acids secreted
by these lichens, and by the hardy, drouth-resistant mosses
i
Geographical Distribution
159
which soon join them, and by the more powerful action of
the frost, and the ever-wearing action of the dust blast driven
by the wind, the rock is gradually crumbled into dust, which
together with the decay of moss and lichen forms a little
soil, in which other mosses may take root ; and by and by the
seeds of a few hardy grasses find a place, and by their roots
the wind and rain-borne dust is caught and soon a little turf
A Lichen Society
Lichens are among the earliest invaders of a rocky surface, preparing
the way for higher plants to follow.
Courtesy of the Con/rad Lantern Slide Company, Chicago.
is formed. Now some hardy perennials wander in, and their
stouter roots serve as wedges to pry apart the smaller chips
of rock and aid in making new soil. And in course of time
a heather society is formed, made up of grasses and the low-
growing matted bodies of perennial herbs, mingled with a
few annuals, which live but a single year. And now some
hardy shrub, perchance a mountain willow, or it may be a
seedling pine comes in, and ever and anon new trees take
root and grow, decay of root and leaf and fallen stem adds
to the humus soil, and in the shadow of the growing trees
sun-loving plants die out and shade-lovers take their place;
and now a forest stands where once was barren rock.
160
Biology in America
So too the deathbed of a lake is the birthplace of a new
cormminity of plants. In the sliallow margins of the lake
rises a niiniatnre forest of cat-tail, rnsh and sedge. With the
gradual shrinkage of the lake through evaporation or drain-
age, and the slow accumulation of wind-borne dust and debris
on its bottom, runners of rush and sedge press further from
the shore. Their decaying stems and leaves, together with
wdnd-borne sediments form ever-increasing mud in the shal-
low water, which with the recession of the lake forms a fer-
tile field for the advancing grasses along its shores. And
thus a meadow is formed into which soon come the moisture-
A Glacial Pond in the Eocky Mountains
Showing the encroaching forest. Original.
loving herbs, and then from near or far wind-driven catkins
come and willows grow from these, the vanguard of the for-
est ; which soon are joined by other trees, of various sorts,
dependent on proximity and ease of carriage of their seeds;
and thus a young forest takes its stand upon the old lake
bottom and meadow herb and grass give place to trees and
plants which love the dark — the victors in the "struggle for
existence." Where however forests are far away or soil and
climate are not adapted to growth of trees, the grasses per-
sist and a meadow marks the graveyard of the lake.
The inter-relationships of the various members of plant
communities, both to one another and to their environment,
Geographical Distribution
161
are well nigh as varied as are those of human society. Tem-
perature, moisture, wind and light are the four principal
parts of the plant's environment, but these in turn are de-
pendent on other factors, such as altitude, topography and
soil. The structure of the plant itself determines its re-
sponse to these factors and its survival or extinction, while
the relation of plant to plant in determining such factors
as light, food supply, growing space, etc., and the inter-
relationship between plants and animals, affecting transport
of seeds, and forage for herbivorous animals, all have a life
and death meaning in the existence of the plant.
Not only is the distribution of plants determined in large
measure by that of animals, but even more is the occurrence
of the latter dependent upon that of the former. Especially
/so I2a 30 iO JO
/?«? ISO 160
Diagram of the Six Great Zoogeographical Eealms of the Earth
After Sclater and Wallace.
is this tiiie of herbivorous types, which necessarily are de-
pendent upon the presence of their forage plants. The move-
ments of grazing animals, such as horses and cattle, are in
particular dependent upon the abundance of grasses, and in
the early days of the West, Indians and white men alike
guided their movements in the search for buffalo largely by
the condition of the prairies over which the bison roamed.
Not only are the herbivorous types dependent on the vege-
tation in their movements, but also the carnivorous animals
which prey upon the former. In the northern forests the
movements of the deer in winter largely determine those of
their enemy, the wolf. During the mouse plague in the Hum-
boldt Valley in Nevada in 1907-8 the abundance of the mice
attracted thither large numbers of hawks to feed upon them.
Based on the distribution of their animal inhabitants the
162
Biology in America
zoogeographer divides the earth into five great rcahns, which
are more or less overlapping but which show in a broad way
the arrangement of animal life upon our globe. These realms
are the Iloloarctic, including North America to Mexico, Eu-
rope, northern Africa, and most of Asia; the Neotropical,
comprising South and Central America and Mexico; the
Arctic- Alpine | ]
Hucisonian
Canadian
Transition
Upper Sonoran
Lower Sonoran
Tropical Hi',' I
After U. S. Biolocical ISukvey
Ethiopian, Africa, south of the Sahara; the Oriental, India and
most of the Malay Archipelago ; and the Australian, Australia,
New Zealand, the southeastern portion of the Malay Archi-
pelago and the South Sea Islands.
In the study of the geographical distribution of animals
(especially birds and mammals) in the United States and
in the correlation of their distribution with that of plants,
the principal agency has been the United States Biological
Geographical Distribution
163
Survey, although the studies of other workers, especially
those of Allen on mammals and Jordan on fish, have contrib-
uted largely to our knowledge of this subject.
The Biological Survey divides North America into zones of
plant and animal life based primarily on temperature, which
zones may be subdivided to a large extent on the basis of mois-
ture. These zones follow in a very broad way the parallels
of latitude in the lower country and the levels of altitude in
the mountains. Let us take for an example San Fran-
cisco Mountain in northern Arizona, whose life zones have
been studied by Doctor Merriam, the former chief of the Sur-
vey. The zonal distribution of life shows somewhat more
Arctic Alfine
Cdna'^ion
Trjfisition
upper i>onora/t Lo^ar ionoran
Profile of San Francisco and 0 'Leary Peaks in Arizona
To illustrate their life zones. The left side of the diagram is S. W.,
the right is N. E. The horizontal lines indicate contour intervals of
IjUUU feet. Modified after Merriam 's "Biological Survey of the Sail
Francisco Mountain Region . . . Arizona," North American Fauna,
No. 3.
clearly in the case of an isolated group of mountains such as
those of which San Francisco Mountain forms the principal
peak, than it does in an extended range such as the Rockies or
the Sierra Nevada, where the zones are more or less broken up
by the irregular contour of the mountains, with their jum-
bled masses of peaks and valleys. These mountains further
include more zones from base to summit than do those of like
altitude further north, where the temperature range from
base to summit is less.
San Francisco Mountain is located in north central Ari-
zona on the elevated plateau tlirough which the Colorado
River has cut its titanic chasm. The town of Flagstaff, site of
the Lowell Observatory, from which the late Professor Lowell
164
Biology in America
brought us so many wonderful messages from Mars, is located
near its southern base. The mountain, 12,794 feet in height,
marks the grave of an extinct volcano, and several lesser vol-
canic peaks rise from the plateau near the main peak.
If we reverse the usual order of things and fancy ourselves
deposited by aeroplane on the summit of the peak we shall
find ourselves in a treeless, wind swept area of "bare vol-
An Alpine Dwarf
At 13,000 feet on Pike's Peak, Colorado. From "Plant Indicators."
Courtesy of Doctor F. E. Clements and the Carnegie Institution.
canie rock," which even in this southern latitude (35°N.) is
snow-clad for three-fourths of the year. Here many of the
herbs tend to form spreading rosettes, their leaves keeping
close to the earth, and sending up a short flower stalk from
the center. In the intense sunlight of the clear mountain
air, growth is rapid and flowers and fruits mature early.
To paraphrase an old saw the plants make fruit while the
sun shines. Most of th=em are species occurring on high moun-
Geographical Distribution
165
tain summits and arctic lands in North America, while some
extend around the world. On the mountain summits they
form isolated groups, cut off from their congeners of the
north by the wide intervening plains and valleys. How have
they come there? In glacial days, when the ice sea swept
southward to New Jersey, Illinois and Nebraska, and gla-
ciers covered the higher slopes of our western mountains,
plants and animals were forced to move before it ; for the
Ice King is an inexorable landloi-d, and when he undertook
to dispossess the tenants of the lands there was no gainsay-
PiKA, OR EocKY Mountain Hare
An inhabitant of rock slides both above and below timber line. Photo
by E. R. Warren. From Metcalf, "Organic Evolution,"
By permission of the Maimillan ComiJany.
ing his wishes in the matter. But with the retreat of the
ice the former tenants returned to their old abodes. Some
of them however instead of moving north once more after
the retreating ice, found a more convenient path up the
mountain sides and thus came to settle in a new home, on
the bleak mountain tops where they found the climate to
their liking.
So too the animal life of alpine summits contains many
species, common alike to inonntain top and ban-en ground of
tlie far North, tiiongh the number repoi'ted for the San Fran-
cisco Mountain is too few to allow any generalizations con-
ITARMIGAN IN (SUMMER PLUMAGE
Photo hy E. R. Warren.
Ptaemigan in Autumn Plumage
Photo ly E. R. Warren.
166
Ptarmigan in Winter Plumage
Photo hy E. R. Warren.
Clarke's Crow
A characteristic bird of the high mountains.
Photo by E. R. Warren.
167
168
Biology in America
cerning them. On alpine summits of the Rocky Mountains
and Sierra Nevada however one meets with several more or
less characteristie species. Here the marmot's whistle and
the sharp call of the pika or mountain hare, mingled with
the harsh note of the leucosticte, and the pipit's plaintive call
are carried across the barren slopes by the rush of the wind.
Here too is the home of the ptarmigan, whose changing fash-
ion with the changing season — white in winter, mottled black,
-
w^
l^tf'''^^
'f^SHKS
.^
■-^■lijf-ssr .v.^4
^
&rfi^'^
.'■^^
■-',•■■'■
H^Bj^^^BPi- — .^"^
oMm
..-^^'^ -1^
^ ^-^
.t-'". *i
^^•ffeS- '•>*-i*»3>'f"
^
't^t.^immmi-^
■-■••' '."^V^yr-o-.V
^-•^;;.i^^;(^:.^
..>iys?.>- ■ .-1-.- . ;>/» ^ \% -i
^
©Ifgpi
g^^
:*^^
^p' '
H^^
0--
'^^b^9^^^?^i^^^^^^^Bjflnl^|R
.>--^ """'^'^■t;^:''
^^p^*^^^
%
^2^^::'^
^^^^
Timber Line in the Rocky Mountains
Alpine firs at 11,000 feet altitude on Long's Peak, Colorado. From
"Plant Indicators."
Courtemj of Doctor F. E. Clements and tite Carnegie Institution.
buff or white in summer — matches them so closely with their
background, that one stumbles upon them before he is aware
of it. The birds seem to realize their protection, for they
are very tame and may sometimes be killed with a stick or
stone. This lameness is however more likely due to infre-
quent molestation. The ptarmigan is also a characteristic
member of the arctic community nesting on the tundras of
the far north, together with the little lapland longspur and
the snow bunting, wliofie change of coat in spring and au-
tumn resembles that of the ptarmigan. Even the gauzy-
Polar Bears
Courtesy of the National Zoological Park.
The Cariboo
Photo hy Elwin R. Sanborn.
Courtesy of the Neio York Zooloyiral KocUty.
1G9
-Mmr^^-^
>ft5*>-.- .-
Musk Oxen
Inhabitants of the barren lands. Photo by Elwin E. Sanborn.
Courtesy of the New York Zoological Society.
The Wolverine
A prowling marauder of the north woods.
Courtesy of the New York Zoological Society.
170
Canadian Zone Forest in Colorado
The spruce tree in the middle foreground is a striking example of
symmetry. Original.
171
172 Biology in America
winjred butterfly may be found flitting over the barren lands
of the Arctic and the highest mountain peaks. Many other
types of insects may also be found here.
Over the ice and snow fields of the Arctic the polar bear
holds sway, the mortal enemy of the seal, while the arctic
fox plays the part of a hanger-on at court, feasting upon
the remains of seal which <lrop from the royal table. Over
the tundras of the barren lands, covered with an abun-
dant vegetation in the brief summer, roam the musk ox and
the barren ground carilxni, while the arctic hare, the mar-
mot and the lemming or northern mouse, find a table plen-
tifully spread with roots and grasses.
The Woodchuck
Photo by Eltcin R. Sanhorn.
Courtcmj of the Neic York Zoological Society.
Descending from the barren summit of the mountain to
timber line one encounters the outposts of the forest at an
altitude of 11,500 feet in the form of stunted spruce and pine,
"whose gnarled and weather-beaten forms bear testimony to
the severity of their struggle with the elements."
Below timber line one comes to a rather indefinite zone
characterized by spruces and fox-tail pines. IMany of the
plants characteristic of this zone on San Fi'ancisco Mountain
are represented by the same or closely related species in the
"upper spruce belt of the higher Alleghenies, the Rocky
Mountains, the Cascades, and the Sierra Nevada, and ... the
great northern spruce forest of Canada." Here live several
The Weasel in Its Winter Dress
Photo by Elwin R. Swiborn.
Courtesy of the New York Zoological Society.
The Snowshoe Rabbit
So named from its large feet.
Photo by Elwin R. Sanborn.
Courtesy of the New York Zoological Society.
173
174
Biology in America
animals which extend further down into the following zone,
the Hudsonian possessing so little that is characteristic that
it may perhaps best be included in the following or Cana-
dian, and the two grouped together as the Boreal zone. The
Canadian zone, which on San Francisco Mountain lies between
9,500 and 8,200 feet, is characterized by the Douglas spruce,
the limber pine, balsam fir and aspens. In the Boreal zone on
San Francisco Mountain occur a number of animals charac-
teristic of this zone in Canada and the mountains in the
Am'^' >
Canadian and Transition Zone Landscape
Fir forest of Canadian zone at left, open pine timber of transition
zone at right, showing effect of slope exposure.
Courtesy of the V. S. Bureau of Biological Survey.
United States. Some of the better known which inhabit it
throughout the United States and Canada are the elk, moose
and woodland caribou; the weasel, fisher, martin, mink, red
fox, wolverine, gray wolf; the marmot or woodchuck, por-
cupine, pika and snowshoe rabbit; most of the mountain
sheep and the Rocky Mountain goat, which is not a goat at
all, but a relative of the European chamois or antelope.
"The mammals of this sub-region (boreal) are largely of old
world origin, many of them coming in with the great immigra-
tions of the Pliocene and Pleistocene epochs, but there are
also native American elements and even one genus of South
Geographical Distribution 175
American origin, the short-tailed or Canada porcupine."^
Of birds there are a large number of characteristic species, a
mere enumeration of which would hardly carry conviction
to the general reader.
Leaving behind us the forests of Douglas sprace and bal-
sam fir, we enter an open "forest of statelj^ pines . . . which
average at least ... 100 feet in height. There is no under-
growth to obstruct the view, and after the rainy season the
grass is knee-deep in places. ..." This forest covers the
mountain side between 7,000 and 8,200 feet, some of its trees
extending even to 8,800 feet among the spruce and fir. It
■^ K' '■
. mm^n
m^
The Beaveb
From a group in the American Museum of Natural History.
Courtesy of the Museum.
marks a debatable area, where boreal forms come down co-
mingling with southern types, and hence has been aptly
termed the transition zone. It has but few distinctive spe-
cies either on San Francisco jMountain or elsewhere, being
characterized rather by a mixture of types. In general it
occupies the northern half of the United States, bending far
southward along the mountain ranges, and running north
along the river valleys, which serve as paths of northern in-
vasion for southern forms. Southern animals which cross
'Scott, "History of Land Mammals of the Western Hemisphere," p.
151. By permission of the Macmillan Company.
176
Biology in America
the transition zone inclndo tlio mountain "lion" or puma,
whit'h extends liis j)ro\vIin<j: patli fi-oin I'atagonia to (-anada,
the Canada lynx, a skunk, the raeeoon, hadger and one of the
deer. Viee versa Canadian mammals extending across the
transition zone southward into the Sonoran include the chip-
munks, l)eaver. meadow mouse (Microtus) and the muskrat.
Grove of Aspens Overflowed by a Beaver Pond
WiUi the (l.Miii and stumps cut by beaver in the foreyrouud. Original.
Below the yellow pine forest on San Francisco IMountain
we reach the icgion of pinon pines and red cedars which ex-
tends between 6,000 and 7,000 feet, while below this we leave
the mountain and enter the desert. Both of these latter
areas belong to the southern or Sonoran life area in North
America, so named from the province of Sonora in ^Mexico,
which is at or near the center from which its characteristic
Geographical Distribution
177
species have inig:rated into the United States. There are
several birds (jays and titmice) which are characteristic of
the piiion belt on San Francisco Mountain and a few mammals
(mice and ground squirrels), while several lizards come in
from the "Painted Desert" to the east. Two species of liz-
ards however appear to be characteristic of this zone, and
one (a horned toad) wanders up into the transition zone
above.
Cypress Swamp, Arkansas
Courtesy of the U. S. Bureau of Biological Hurvey.
But temperature is not the sole factor regulating the dis-
tribution of animals and plants. Moisture, light, the char-
acter of the soil and the surface of the countiy — these and
other factors, all work together and influence one another to
determine this distribution. Perhaps the most important of
these is moisture. The traveller passing across the United
States from east to west, finds himself at the outset of his
journey on the moist plain of the Atlantic Coast, a region
w^hich has but recently (in geologic time) been raised above
the level of the sea. Along the New England Coast, the cold
Labrador current in its southward sweep, produces the fogs
which so often shroud these shores, while the Florida penin-
sula receives the moisture laden winds from both the Atlantic
178
Biology in America
Ocean and the Gulf of Mexico, and is drenched with the abun-
dant rainfall of the tropics. Characteristic of the coastal
plain and the eastern slope of tlie Appalachian Range to the
west are several species of pines, the low sandy areas of the
plain being largely characterized by these trees, which have
given their name to the New Jersey "Pine Barrens."
Upon the slopes of the mountains and in the valleys of
their intersecting rivers, are the remains of some splendid
hardwood forests of maple, oak, elm, linden, hickory, beech
Cotton Eat and Nest
Courtesy of the U. >S'. Bureau of Biological Survey.
and chestnut, while in the swamps of the South are the cy-
press, magnolia and palmetto.
In its large features the animal life of this region does
not differ from that of the Canadian, transition and upper
Sonoran zones of a western mountain, which has already
been described; although differing therefrom in many minor
details. But along the southeastern coast occur a few spe-
cies which distinguish this region from other parts of the
country. In the rice fields of the South occurs the rice rat,
while the cotton rat is another animal characteristic of the
South Atlantic and Gulf States. The Florida Everglades are
Alligators Enjoying a Quiet Siesta
Photo by Ehvin R. l^anhorn.
Courtesy of the New York ZoUloylcal Society.
The Water Moccasin
An inhabitant of the lowhuuls of tlie South Atlantic and Gulf States.
Courtesy of the A'civ York Zoological Society.
179
180 Biology in America
included in tlie tropical zone, which except here and at the
mouth of the Rio Grande does not enter the United States.
In the streams of southern Florida lives the alligator, while
the dark forests are the home of the parrakeet, an intruder
from the numerous family of parrots in South and Central
America. A hundred years ago this bird ranged as far north
as the Great Lakes, but it is at present restricted to a few
areas in our Southern States, if indeed it is not wholly extinct
at present.
Crossing the Appalachians our traveler descends into the
The Burrowing O'vvl
Photo by Eiwin R. Sunburii:
Courtesy uf the A'e/r York ZoiiJoniiul Hoviity.
great valley of the IMississippi River, with its branches stretch-
ing far to east and west and draining nearly half the total area
of the United States. Here he at first encounters a climate
not greatly different from that of the eastern seaboard, al-
though subject to somewhat greater extremes of temperature.
The fauna and the flora too are similar to those of the At-
lantic Coast. As he passes westward however out of the basin
of the Mississippi, rising over the slope of the Great Plains
to the foothills of the Rockies, the climate changes, the rain-
fall materially decreasing and the temperature extremes in-
creasing.
Accompanying these changes of climate occur marked
changes in the life of the land. The eastern forests disap-
Prairie Dog
Prairie Dog at Burrow
The **dog towns" of the West are familiar objects.
Courtesy of the U. S. Bureau of Biological Survey.
181
182 Biology in America
pear save for a fringe of timber along the stream bottoms,
giving place to the vast prairies of the west. New types of
animals also appear upon the scene. Squatting on his
haunches outside the entrance to his subterranean home the
prairie dog squeaks defiance at the passing traveler, and the
burrowing owl utters its shrill cry in protest at the pres-
ence of the intruder. Several species of ground squirrels or
gophers are characteristic members of the animal commun-
ity, some of which extend eastward across the Mississippi.
The black and white of the lark bunting is a conspicuous fea-
ture of the landscape, while the magpie in his coat of green
and white lends color as well as noise to the cottonwood
groves along the rivers. The Great Plains form an inter-
esting "tension line," as the biologist calls it, "where east
is west and west is east and ever the twain shall meet. ' ' ^ The
eastern and western movement of the western and eastern
flora and fauna respectively is one of the most interesting
features of this area. The dicksissel, one of the sparrow
family, a characteristic bird of the Mississippi Valley, has
only in recent years ventured from his ancestral home across
the vast prairies to the west. Conversely the magpie appears
to be moving slowly eastward. The red-eyed vireo, whose
home is in the eastern United States, appears within recent
years to have followed the Missouri Valley westward, crossed
the Rocky Mountains and established itself in the northwest-
ern United States and British Columbia.
An interesting suggestion as to how the migration routes
of various birds may have become established, many of which
are very devious and hard to explain, is to be found in the
route of this bird. Wintering in South America, it moves
northward in spring following the course of the Mississippi
River to near its headwaters, whence it turns northwestward
across mountains to its breeding grounds in the North. A
much shorter route lies west of the Rockies ; but inherited in-
stinct (or is it parental example?) carries the bird in the
path of its forefathers far from the course which is most
easy and direct.
Another interesting case of recent extension of a bird's
breeding range is furnished by the bobolink, which is an in-
habitant of marsh and meadow land. With the settling of
the arid territory of the West, accompanied by its irrigation,
the bobolink is accompanying the western march of empire,
and settling itself in Nevada, Oregon and other western states.
Between the Rockies and the Sierras lies the Great Basin,
scorched with the torrid heat of summer and frozen with the
icy blasts of winter, a land parched with endless drouth.
"With apologies to Mr. Kipling.
The Horned Toad
Which is not a "toad" at all, but a lizard, resembling in its scaly
attire a miniature monster of the past.
Photo hy Eltoin R. Sanborn.
Courtesy of the Netv York Zoological Society.
The Kangaroo Rat
Characteristic of the arid Southwest.
Courtesy of the U. S. Bureau of Biological Survey.
183
184 Biology in America
The life of this region is widely different from that of the
East, but the mere enumeration of the names of its inhabi-
tants would be of little interest. Many of its species are in-
habitants of the ground and buslies and are more or less
bleached in color corresponding to the backgi'ound upon which
they live. IIow this adaptation has been effected no one can
surely say. But more of this in a later chapter. One of the
most characteristic of its inhabitants is the "horned toad,"
which is not a toad at all, but a lizard. This little creature
with its horned head is a miniature Triceratops, the giant
dinosaur which once shambled across our plains.
The towering Sierras rising like a mighty wall shut off
the Great Basin from the interior valleys of California, and
these in turn are separated from the Pacific Coast by the
Coast Kange of mountains, which while pygmies compared
The Gila Monster
Characleristic of the arid Southwest. Froui Ditmars, "Reptiles of All
Lands," in "National Geographic Magazine," Vol. 22.
with their mighty neighbors to the east, nevertheless form a
very efficient climatic barrier to the moisture laden winds
sweeping landward from the sea. The climatic diff'erences
thus caused are reflected in the life of the interior valleys and
the coastal slope. In no similar area in North America are
there such gi-eat extremes of climate or more marked dif-
ferences in the corresponding life. Especially is this true
of Death Valley in the interior of southern California, whose
lowest point is 276 feet below the surface of the sea. Here
the temperature in summer frequently reaches 125°F. in the
shade, and the relentless sun scarce ever hides its shameless
face behind a cloud. Here lives a little community of desert
dwellers, for the most part characteristic of their arid home.
The fauna and flora of California are peculiar to them-
selves, following however the general principles of distri-
bution of life elsewhere. Here occur the Goliaths among
plants — the California big trees. At one time in the past
Geographical Distribution
185
these trees were widely distributed over North America, but
today they are restricted to our western coast/° and it may
be are doomed to extinction,
Amono- the most characteristic, and witlial attractive mem-
bers of California society are the hummiii<^ birds, a group
occurring only in America. The several species found along
A California Big Tree Grove
Courtcny of the U. t>. Bureau of Bioloykul Surrey.
the Pacific Coast and the few occurring elsewlierc are in-
vaders from the tropics where most of the more than four
hundred species find a home. Another interesting inhabitant
of southern California and Arizona is the great condor,
which spreads its wings from eight and a half to eleven feet.
Dwelling in the damp forests of Oregon and Cialifornia
"Sequoia gigantea is limited to a few small areas in California, while
S. sempervirens or the "redwood" extends north along the coast into
Oregon.
ISfi
Biology in America
is the last representative of a once thriving family, which at
one time had a much wider distribution than at present. The
sewellel is an animal somewhat resembling a large rat, which
digs his home among the roots of the forest trees and stores
therein the harvest which he gathers from its herbs.
Several million years ago, more or less, there lived in North
America a numerous race of animals related to the opossum
and kangaroo, the marsupials, to which reference has been
made in the preceding chapter. Then they disappeared from
what is now the United States, for what reason we do not
Mountain Beaver, or Sewellel
Courtesy of the U. 8. Bureau of Biological Survey.
know— a mysterious disappearance of the past, which the
palffiontological sleuth may never solve. The most likely ex-
planation is that they were driven south by the wolves and
tigers and others of their ilk, the robber barons of the ani-
mal world. More recently one of their number, the opossum,
has once more ventured northward as far as the northern
United States (Michigan and New York).
Have all these facts laboriously gathered by many men
in many years any practical value? Even had they none
they would still be well worth while because of the light which
they, in conjunction with the "hard facts" of palaBoutology,
Geographical Distribution 187
throw upon llie great questions of evolution, adaptation and
the vicissitudes and changes of plants and animals in the
past. But apart from this purely ''theoretical" interest they
have an important hearing upon human life today, for they
give us a clue to the suitability of any region for crops of a
given type. Thus if a settler in a given region wishes to
know what kind of crops will grow best in his region, it is
essential for him to know, not only the character of the soil
in his area and the amount of rainfall, temperature range,
etc., but the type of plants which will grow well in that par-
ticular climate, or in other words the life zone in which his
area lies. To make this information available to our farmers
the Biological Survey has prepared a life zone map of the
United States and Canada, together with a list of the various
cereals, fruits and vegetables best adapted to each zone.
Thus does the biologist seek to make his knowledge "prac-
tical" in the rendering of service to the world.
CHAPTER VI
Experim^ital hiologt/. Prcfannation in a new dress, organ-
izaiimi of the egg, regeneration and gmfting, plastic
mrgery, tissue culture, the prahleni of death, and im-
mortality of the cell.
The last thirty years have seen remarkable developments
in the field of experimental biology. True it is that the
method of experiment was a very early one, especially among
human and plant physiologists. Nevertheless experimental'
biolog\^ has lagged behind experimental physics and chem-
istry and has but recently found its proper place among the
other branches of biological science. In the development of
this field Germany and America have played the leading
part, while with the recent upheaval in Europe, and conse-
quent check to scientific progress there, the coming era of
reconstruction finds this country better fitted than any other
to lead in the development of the new science.
"While the earlier biologists were in the main satisfied with
the observation of phenomena, and speculation as to their
causes, the experimental biologist demands that these pl^e-
nomena shall be analyzed under certain imposed conditions,
in order that their causes may be scientifically ascertained.
Thus the method of transmission of yellow fever could only
be conjectured until the Yellow Fever Commission in 1900,
by exposing subjects to all possible conditions of infection,
proved that the bite of the mosquito (Stegomyia) was the
only natural means of transfer.
Experimental biology has followed a few main lines of
thought, with many side lines which are branched and in-
terwoven with one another in an intricate maze. A gen-
eral review may best be given by tracing the main lines, the
branches being folloAved only so far as they are essential to
an understanding of the former. The principal questions
then with which we shall deal are the following:
Are the factors which determine the development of an
organism internal or external ? AYhy does an organism grow
old and die? What are the factors of organic evolution?
Is the organism a machine, governed by the laws of physics
and chemistry, or is there a "vital principle," an "en-
telechy" or a "soul," transcending in its activity the bounds
of the purely material universe?
A century and a half ago Caspar Friedrich Wolff overthrew
1
The Organization of the Egg
189
the generally accepted doctrine of piefoniialion, according
to which the adult animal was present in miniature within
the egg or the sperm cell, both of which had their advocates,
so that embryologists were divided into the rival schools of
"ovists" and "spermatists. " One enthusiastic and imagina-
tive observer even pictured a miniature human body within
the spermatozoon.
sp
BERoii
Showing tlie four rows of swiinuiing ]>lntes, sj
Chun.
Vrom Lankosfcr, after
While such fancies have long since been laid to rest, pre-
formation, in a new dress, is playing a very important role
on the biological stage today. The importance of this theory
is due largely to the work of two American biologists —
Morgan at Columbia and Conklin at Princeton.
In modern form preformation assumes the presence in the
sex cells of certain formative stutfs or entities (more exact
terminology is impossible in the present state of our knowl-
edge) which determine the development of parts or features
of the adult organism. These things, whatever they are, may
reside either in the nucleus or the cytoplasm. In the former
190
Biology in America
case tliey are present in both sperm and egg cell ; in the latter
case only in the egg, the amount of cytoplasm in the typical
sperm being too small to contain the ''organ-forming sub-
stances."
If such formative stuffs are unequally distributed to dif-
ferent daughter cells in the division of the egg, then we should
expect each of these cells to give rise to a definite part of the
embryo and to that part only. If, on the other hand, these
••y-:»lv.---.-. . ■ ;,'-A:'5;
I P'
(Left) The Egg of thk Tunicate Cynthia
Showing the ' ' organ forming substances ' ' and their distribution in
different stages, a, anterior; p, posterior pole of egg; c, clear proto-
plasm; cr, yellow crescent; e, cortex containing yellow pigment; g.v.,
germinal vesicle; k, chorion; p. b., polar bodies; t, test cells; y, yolk;
y. h., yellow hemisphere; 6, sperm nucleus. Prom Kellicott, after Wilson.
(Eight) Development of the Mollusc Dentalium
A, distribution of materials in undivided egg; B, commencement of
division showing the "polar lobe" p, which in C and D (division stages)
is found at D and X respectively. In E the cell X is absent, the polar
lobe having been removed at an earlier stage. F and H, normal larvae
of twenty-four and seventy-two hours, respectively, G and I, larvae of
the same ages lacking the "polar lobe" material. From Kellicott after
Wilson.
stuffs are equally distributed to the daughter cells, then these
cells should be mutually interchangeable, and any one of
them, if isolated from its fellows, should give rise to com-
plete, though dwarfed embryos. Is the egg a mosaic, or is
it uniform in its structure?
The ctenophore Beroe has normally eight rows of ciliary
bands. After one division of the egg, if the two resulting
The Organization of the Egg 191
cells are separated, each one will develop into a half larva,
with only four rows of bands. Similarly each cell of the
four and even the eight cell stage may be made to develop
into a partial larva with two or even only one row of bands.
And further if a part be removed from the egg before divi-
sion, a defective larva is the result.
The egg of the aseidian Cynthia has been shown by Conklin
to contain at least five different "organ-forming substances,"
distinguishable by color and texture, which are symmetrically
placed with reference to the median plane of the embryo,
but differentially located antero-posteriorly. If one of the
first two cleavage cells (for example the right) is killed, the
other develops into the opposite (left) half of the body, which
contains all the normal part>;, but of one-half the norn'ial
size. But if in the four cell stage, when the second cleavage
has differentiated the anterior from the posterior ends of the
body, one or both of the anterior or posterior cells is killed,
the resulting larva lacks those parts which are present only
in the cells which have been destroyed.
A similar result has been obtained by Wilson in the egg
of the mollusc Dentalium, in which three different substance.^
can be identified. Thus the yolk is here at first located at
one pole of the egg, and later in a single one of the cleavage
cells. If this "yolk lobe" be removed from the egg, when
it starts to divide, the resulting larva lacks certain parts
(foot, mantle, shell, etc.) normally formed from the yolk
cell.
Centrifuging the egg of Cynthia with consequent dis-
arrangement of the organ-forming substances may so
disturb the development that the resulting larva may be
turned inside out, with entoderm on the outside and ectoderm
within.
At the posterior end of one of the chrysomelid beetles
(Calligrapha) occurs a disk of granules, which seemingly
function as germ cell determinants, for if the end of the
egg containing this disk be pricked, and its component gran-
ules allowed to escape, or if the disk be destroyed with a hot
needle, and the egg is then allowed to develop, the resulting
embryo lacks germ cells.
There are many experiments however which point to dif-
ferent conclusions. Thus in eggs of fresh water snails and
certain annelids, substances of different color and specific
gravity occur, but these may be displaced from their normal
positions by centrifuging, without in any way affecting the
development. This has led Lillie and others to the conclusion
that the so-called organ-forming substances are not in
reality such, but merely an accompaniment of a more pro-
found organization resident in the protoplasmic framework
192 Biology in America
of the egrfr, which cannot be mechanically rearranged by
centrifuginj? or otherwise.
The foregroing experiments seem to show conclusively that
the developing animal is in some sense at least prefonned
in the egg. No less conclusive however is the evidence of
a directly opposite character. In Amphioxus and many
Ilydromedusa' isolated cleavage cells give rise to complete
though dwarf larvfp, while on the contrary it has been pos-
sible in some eases (Ascaris, Sphterechinus) to produce nor-
mal, though giant larvae, by the fusion of two eggs or embryos.
Many intermediate forms exist between those eggs in which
one of the cleavage cells produces a partial, and those in which
it forms an entire larva. In some cases, as for instance in
certain echinoderms, an isolated cleavage cell may undergo
at first a partial development, but later a process of regula-
tion may ensue, resulting in the formation of a complete
larva. Different results may be obtained in the same animal,
depending on the method of experimentation. Thus if one
of the first two cleavage cells of a frog's egg be destroyed
with a hot needle and the egg left in its normal position a
half embryo results, but if the position be inverted a whole
embryo develops in the majority of cases.
In this maze of conflicting evidence a final word can scarcely
be spoken. Undoubtedly different eggs differ in the extent
of their organization. If a part of the egg of the nemertine
Cerebratulus be removed prior to fertilization, no disturbance
of development ensues. If the two cells of the first cleavage
are separated, they undergo for a time a partial cleavage, but
very soon the normal development is resumed. But if one
of the four cells, resulting from the second cleavage, be iso-
lated, partial development proceeds for a longer time than
in the preceding case, the normal process not being resumed
until much later. We find here a possible explanation of the
divergent behavior of different eggs. In some the embryo
may be preformed in the egg, in others only in later stages
of cleavage.
The phenomena of regeneration speak strongly for the
uniformity of both egg and adult. If the parts of the or-
ganism are predetermined in the former, then when one of
these parts is lost its replacement should be impossible; but
if the egg be isotropic (one part the same as another), and if
this uniformity persist in the adult, then a lost part should
be replaceable.
The ability of regeneration in many animals has long been
known, being mentioned by Aristotle and Pliny. In the mid-
dle of the eighteenth century, the famous work of Trembley on
Hydra attracted widespread attention and several workers
entered this field.
Tho Organization of Ihc Egg 193
Rpgeneratioii occurs to a greater or less extent in all the
great groups of animals and plants. If Hydra be cut into
several pieces each will develop into a new animal. Earth-
worms and flatworms can regenerate either head or tail if
these be removed. The starfish can have a new arm made to
order; the lobster a claw; the snail may acquire a new head,
and the sea cucumber a new stomach. In higher plants a
piece of leaf or root may give rise to an entire new plant.
Among animals the regenerative power decreases with in-
creasing specialization. The relative size of a piece of Hydra
necessary to produce a new animal is much less than that
of a crab or a frog. In vertebrates the amphibians have
been most used for regeneration experiments. There are
many salamanders which can regenerate legs or tail, but
there appear to be differences in the regenerative ability of
different forms. Age has an influence, as well as degrees
of specialization, for while the tadpole will readily regenerate
a lost limb the frog is unable to do so.
In man the power of regeneration is relatively slight,
although skin, muscles^ bone and other tissues show this power
to some extent in the healing of wounds, while the lens of
the eye may occasionally regenerate. There are some remark-
able cases on record of regeneration of internal organs in
mammals, although these are sometimes merely cases of hyper-
trophy of part of an organ, in compensation for the loss of
another part of that same organ, rather than instances of true
regeneration. Thus the removal of one-half or even three-
fourths of the liver of a dog or rabbit may result in the
enlargement of the remainder, without any replacement of
the lost part. It is well known that in man injury to a
lung or kidney may be compensated by increased growth and
activity of its opposite. There are recorded instances how-
ever of true regeneration of internal organs in mammals.
In the rabbit removal of as much as five-sixths of a salivary
gland may be followed by complete regeneration, and the
kidney of a rat or a rabbit may develop new tissue to a
certain extent, after part has been removed.
The regeneration of the lens in vertebrates ha« been a bone
of contention among zoologists for many years. In the
development of the normal eye there first arises an evagina-
tion of the primary forebrain forming a primary optic cup
or vesicle, wliich is shoi-tly followed by an invagination of the
adjacent ectoderm to foi'm a secondary cuj) or vesicle, from
which is formed the lens. The question at issue is: Is the
lens dependent upon the presence of the primary vesicle for
its development, or may it arise independently of the latter?
Many ingenious expei'iments have been performed, prin-
cipally on amphibian larvaj, in the attempt to solve this
194 Biology in America
problem, with unfortunately widely divergent results. The
ectoderm has been eut around the developing primary vesicle,
and the tlap folded back so as to expose the latter; vidiich has
then been excised, the tiap replaced and the wound allowed
to heal. In other experiments the primary vesicle has been
supposedly destroyed by pricking it with a hot needle; and
in still others the vesicle has been transplanted to a strange
area of the same, or a different species, such as the abdominal
wall. In the latter experiments lenses have been formed from
parts of the ectoderm which never give rise to them in nature,
and similar results have been obtained by destroying a lens
already formed, thereby causing its regeneration from the
iris.
In the former experiments the results have been incon-
sistent, a lens sometimes regenerating and sometimes failing
to do so, after the removal of the primary vesicle. Werber
has suggested that this apparent inconsistency is due to the
incomplete destruction of the vesicle in some cases in which
it had supposedly been entirely removed, and the consequent
formation of a " lens stimulus ' ' by small pieces of the vesicle
which remained. Of interest in this connection are the experi-
ments of Stoekard, Werber and others in the production of
Cyclopean and other monsters, which will be considered later.
In some of these experiments a single median eye has been
produced in place of two lateral ones, with the resultant
formation of a single lens associated Avith the single eye, and
the absence of any lateral lenses. In other cases lenses have
developed at almost any place on the monster, apparently
unassociated with any optic material. Werber has suggested'
however that these so-called "independent lenses" owe their
origin to the stimulus of microscopic bits of optic vesicles
scattered over the body of the monster, through a process of
blastolysis or tissue destruction induced by chemical or
osmotic action, and in some cases he is able to demonstrate
what he considers bits of such material in close proximity
to these lenses.
Whatever the truth of the matter may be, the evidence is
I think conclusive that lenses, and presumably other organs
also, are not iji any sense preformed, but result from the
interaction between the parts of the organism itself and their
environment.
Nearly related to experiments on regeneration are those on
grafting. The custom of grafting in plants has been prac-
tised by horticulturists for a long time. Trembley with his
celebrated woik on Hydra was a pioneer in this field among
animals. JMoi'e recently this work has been continued by
King, Rand, Peebles and others in this country. The an-
terior end of one Hydra may be grafted onto the posterior
The Organization of the Egg
195
end of another ; two Hydras may be united by either anterior
or posterior ends, or one Hydra may be o-rafted onto the
side of another. The results differ depending upon the condi-
tions of the experiment, and the speeies of Hydra employed;
but the general result is that a process of regulation ensues
whereby a new animal is formed, similar in size and pro-
portion to the normal individual. One of the most interest-
ing results l)earing on the question of predetermination of
parts is that obtained by grafting two Hydras by their
anterior ends and then cutting off' the posterior end of one
near the graft line. In this case a new head forms on the
Four-Legged Tadpoles
Produced by transplanting the limbs from one tadpole to anotlicr.
After Harrison, "Journal of Experimental Zoology,'' Vol. 4.
(originally) posterior end of the graft, where a head, in the
ordinary course of events would never develop.
Some of the most interesting grafting work of recent years
has been done by Harrison, in connection with studies on the
developing nerve fiber. Two positions have been held on this
question — one, that the axone of the nerve cell, the conducting
part of the nerve fiber, arose in situ from surrounding cells ;
the other, that the axone was an outgrowth from the nerve
cell itself. The latter view appears to have been definitely
established by Harrison. Our interest here however centers
primarily upon certain secondary results of Harrison's work
rather than upon the question of nerve fiber development.
In these experiments Harrison has shown that limb buds can
be transplanted from one tadpole to another, the tail of one
196
Biology in America
species of tadpole can be grafted on that of another species,
two entire animals may be united, and even the head of one
species (Rana virescens) can be united to the body of another
(R. palustris), and a young frog reared from the combina-
tion. Similar results have been obtained by Crampton in
the union of tlie puinn of moths, (■()ml)inations of ceeropia
moths with promethea and polyphenuis mollis having been
successfully made.
Most remarfeable of grafting results witli higher animals
A Combination Frog
With the head of one species grafted onto the body of another. The
tadpole to the left, the adult to the right. From Harrison, in the
"Anatomical Record,'' Vol. 2.
have been those of Carrel on mammals. lie has removed
sections of arteries of one animal and replaced them with
pieces of vessels taken from another. He has even made
this graft successfully with vessels which had been kept in
an ice chest for several weeks after death. Thus a piece
of a human artery taken from an amputated leg and pre-
served for twenty-five days in cold storage was used to replace
a piece of the aorta of a small dog. The graft took and the
dog recovered and lived for over four years, during which
time she bore several litters of pupi)ies, finally dying during
The Organization of the Egg 197
labor. A post-mortem examination sliowed the p^rafted vessel
to be slightly dilated and lacking muscular tissue, but other-
wise normal. Carrel's success in grafting vessels enabled him
to transplant entire organs. He performed this operation on
cats' kidneys, with a certain amount of temporary success,
the transplanted organ functioning for a number of weeks.
Ultimately however the animals died. But even the tem-
porary success of so daring an operation gives ground for
hope that complete success may ultimately be possible.
Grafting on the human body or plastic surgery is supposed
to have been practised by the Egyptians as early as 1,500
B. C. In recent years great advances have been made in this
branch of surgery, and not only have skin, bones, muscles,
fascia and tendons been transplanted, but parts of internal
organs have been used to repair defects in other parts. Thus
the urethra has been replaced by the appendix and a vagina
has been made from a piece of intestine. A piece of cornea
from a human eye kept in cold storage for eight days has
been successfully used to partially restore the sight of a man
blinded by alkali.
The story of the recent achievements of surgery in repair-
ing the features of soldiers, who had been so badly wounded
as to be merely caricatures of their former selves, reads almost
like a tale from the "Arabian Nights." Jaws, noses, ears,
cheeks, almost entire faces have been remade, so that the vic-
tims have in the end presented a fairly good facsimile of their
former selves. While details cannot be given here, a brief
outline of the method may be of interest. A former picture
of the patient if available is taken as the model of what the
surgeon aims to make. Then a piece of bone of the proper
size and shape to refit the lost part (a jaw or nose) will be
cut out of a rib or shin bone and inserted beneath the skin
of an adjoining part (the neck or forehead). After the skin
has attached itself to the inserted bone, the latter is cut out
on three sides, leaving a stalk on one side to maintain the
circulation, the skin is now cut open around the scar and
the new member inserted in the open cavity. The adjoining
skin is attached to the insert, and after the graft has "taken,"
its stalk is cut away, and when finally healed the skin is
massaged, and the scar removed in this way as far as possible.
Thus a fairly natural part may be made to replace a jawless
mouth or a repulsive hole where a nose once grew.
Carrel and others have shown that not only blood vessels
and cornea, but also skin, fascia, tendon, bone and cartilage
may be preserved in a condition of latent life for weeks or
months in cold storage, and still be used successfully for
transplantation. Thus pieces of skin taken from the body
198
Biology m America
of an iufaiit, which died during labor, and preserved in
vaseline at a temperature of -|-3°C. were successfully used
for grafts after forty-two days; and pieces of fat, bone and
cartilage taken from amputations have been similarly pre-
served in cold storage for varying lengths of time, and later
used in grafting operations. Seemingly the day is not far
distant when cold storage will supply us with our tissues as
well as our foods.
The liberties which may be taken with living tissues and
their ability to grow in strange surroundings is I believe
strong evidence for the plasticity of the cell, showing as they
do the profound influence of environment on its development.
Such a view of course must not be pushed too far. It would
Three Stages in the Eeconstruction of a Wounded Soldier's Face
From Esser in ' ' Annals of Surgery, ' ' Yol. 65.
By pennisskm of J. li. Liiiitincott Company.
be absurd to expect that every cell could be modified by its
surroundings so as to form every other kind. With high
specialization the cell loses j^ari passu its adaptability. But
in the lower organisms there is abundant evidence of the
ability of cells to be molded into new structures, even after
they have reached the usual limits of their development.
Further evidence in favor of this view is afforded by the
apparently unlimited power of reproduction possessed by
certain cells. If the development of the organism were pre-
determined in the egg, then the growth of its parts should"
be limited, and there should come a time in its development,
as ordinarily there does come in the life of the individual,
when growth should cease and the power of repair should not
exceed the need created by waste. But in some cases, notably
The Organization of the Egg
199
in cancer, certain cells possess the power of seemingly un-
limited growth, increasing- at the expense of other tissues,
running wild within the body, and finally destroying it as a
result of their riotous living. This power of seemingly un-
limited growth of the cell may in many cases be initiated
artificially.
Unquestionably the most important of Harrison's results
A Piece of Growing Tissue
The (lark center is the original tissue, the brandling boilies radiating
out from it are the growing cells. It has been possible to cultivate in
glass cells many different kinds of tissue, including those from man
himself. This method has been used for studying the growth and
reaction of cancer cells, and may throw light on the cause of this dreail
malady. After Lambert and Hanes, "Journal of Experimental Medi-
cine." Vol. 13.
on nerve growth was his development of the method of grow-
ing tissues outside of the animal body. He transplanted bits
of the central nervous system of the tadpole to drops of
coagulable lymph from the frog, and by placing these in a
glass cell under the microscope, he was able to follow the
growth of the nerve fibers. More recently a large number
of workers, mostly Americans, have developed Harrison's
method and applied it to both embryonic and adult tissues
of birds and mammals. The method has been applied to the
200 Biology in America
study of tlio growth not only of normal but of pathological
tissues, such as tumors and cancers.
When a bii of tissue is removed from a living, or recently
killed animal, and placed in a suitable medium (blood plasma
is the one mostly emjjloyed) at a pr()i)er temperatun^ it
sooner or later, depending on the age of the animal from
which it is taken, begins to grow, sending out sheets of cells
in all directions into the surrounding medium. After a time
however growth ceases, but may recommence if the tissue be
removed, washed and transferred to a fresh medium. In
this way tissues have been kept alive for more than nine years
and carried through nearly two thousand transfers. Carrel
has grown chick tissues in this way, which had been kept in
cold storage for six days, and even human tissues taken from
a cadaver several hours after death may grow.
But what is death if our tissues, as well as our actions, will
live after we are gone? Does the grim specter lie in wait
for us in the coils of our intestines, as jMetsehnikolf would
have us believe ? Or is it the hardening of our arteries which
ushers us into the great unknown? Is death inherent in life,
or were the first living things immortal, and death an adapta-
tion secondarily acquired for the benefit of the race, although
working to the detriment of the individual, as AVeismann has
suggested ?
For an answer to these questions let us turn to the uni-
cellular organisms and see what they have to teach us. If
a single Paranuecium be put in a fresh infusion of hay in
water it soon divides to form two daughter cells, which divide
again in their tuin, and so on ; until the infusion is teeming
with millions, all offspring of one cell, which is still living
in its descendants. For this reason Weismann maintained
that the Protozoa were immortal. But after a time repro-
duction ceases and the Paramo'cia begin to die off. The cul-
ture has passed its climax and begun to retrograde. Finally
the Pai'am(ecia disappear entirely, unless fresh material be
meantime added to the culture. But if this be done the
cells ac(iuire a new lease of life and connnence to multiply
again as merrily as ever.
By using a varied culture of hay, leaves, moss, etc. in
rotation and transferring his animals daily to fresh culture.
Woodruff has carried a race of ParauKccia through some seven
thousand generations extending over a period of twelve years,
without any evidence of degeneration. While an exact analy-
sis of the different stimuli controlling the Paramo^cia in a
hay infusion has not been made, it has been shown ])retty
conclusively that waste products materially check their
growth, while purity of the culture in this respect stimulates
The Organization of the Egg 201
growth and keeps tlie animals healthy. The food supply-
must also exercise a controlling influence, the growth of
bacteria, which serve as food, being also cheeked by waste
products (toxins) in the culture. It can be shown however
that even in the presence of abundant food supply, stale
culture will inhibit tlie growth of ParanKecia.
We can compai-e the metazoan with a culture of Paramrecia,
all descendants of one cell. The former, as well as the latter,
starts as a single cell (the fertilized egg). After a period of
active division or growth the climax is reached, when the
processes of repair can only keep pace with those of waste,
and from then on the organism passes through the decline
of old age followed by death. But if a few cells be removed
from the parent body and transferred to a fresh medium
(blood plasma) they forthwith start to grow abundantly, and
this growth can apparently be maintained indefinitely, if the
transfers be repeated from time to time.
The influence of the age of the animal from which the
plasma is taken is very marked. In that from young animals
growth is much more active than in that taken from adults,
but if an extract of the tissues of a young animal be added
to the latter the growth is materially increased.
May not then old age and death be caused by waste prod-
ucts excreted by the cells of the metazoan body? May it
not be a process of auto-intoxication, not localized as Metseh-
nikoff suggests, in the intestines, but generalized throughout
the entire body? Whatever answer to this question the future
may make, the faculty of unlimited growth possessed by most,
if not all the tissues of higher animals, suggests not only the
indeterminate nature of development, but also the inherent
immortality of the cell.
CHAPTER VII
Experimental hiology continued. The role of the chromosomes
in inheritance. Inhcritanee of sex and sex-linked char-
acters.
In the preceding chapter we have considered the question
of the influence of the cytoplasm upon development, par-
ticularly in respect to the "orfi,an-formin«i' sub.tances" winch
it contains ; and the ability of one part of an organism to
regenerate, not only itself, but some other part normally
foreign to it. We shall now consider the role of the nucleus
in development, especially that of the chromosomes.
Whether or not development be locally predetermined in
the egg, there is of course no question that the latter is pre-
determined in its general development. J\Ien do not gather
"grapes of thorns or figs of thistles," nor can the specific,
e. g., characteristic of the species, development be altered by
any change in the environment. AVhat is it then which deter-
mines the specific characters of the organism?
While the theory of cellular units responsible for the
hereditary transmission of specifie and individual characters,
originated with Darwin as the well known "pangenesis"
theory, in an attempt to explain the origin of new characters
by environmental influence, and was amplified and more
definitely formulated by Weismann, it has never received
stronger support than througli tlie ejioch-making work of Mor-
gan and his students at Columbia University within the last
decade.^
In order to appreciate the significance of this work, it is
necessary to turn back the pages of time for a half century
and pause a moment to look into the garden of the monastery
at Briinn in the Tyrol, where the monk Gregor Mendel was
busy with his peas.
Mendel was monk and later abbot at Briinn, and for a time
^I do not wish in this statement to accuse modern biologists of
accepting Darwin's theory of "pangenesis" in its entirety. Darwin-
ian and modern viewpoints have in common however the assumption
oi some sort of cell units, be they physical or be they chemical, which
are responsible for reappearance in the offspring of characters pres-
ent in the parent.
202
The Role of the Chromosomes 203
taught tlie physical and natural sciences in the monastery
school. While monk and teacher he was essentially a great
investigator, and in spite of his other duties, he found time
to perform a large number of breeding experiments with
sweet peas, the results of which he published in 1865 in the
' * Proceedings of the Natural History Society of Briinn. ' ' This
paper, which he sent to his friend Niigeli the botanist, made
no impression on the latter and attracted no attention, until
thirty-five years later, when Mendel's principle was inde-
pendently discovered by three botanists — DeVries, Correns
and Tschermak. Since then, Mendel's discovery has been
recognized as one of the greatest in biology, and his paper
has become a great scientific classic.
The results of his work have been so extensively quoted,
and are known so widely and so well that their rehearsal is
needless here. There are certain features of his results how-
ever which, while well known to biologists, are perhaps not
fully appreciated by the general reader, and which it may
therefore be worth while to emphasize. Thus it is commonly
known, for example, that a cross between a tall pea and a
dwarf produces only tall offspring, which, when bred to-
gether, produce, on the average, three tall and one dwarf
descendants. But the meaning of this well-known Mendelian
ratio is possibly not widely understood. A ready explanation
is found however in the behavior of the chromosomes of the
germ cells, prior to, and during fertilization.
The nucleus of an undividing or resting cell contains a sub-
stance known as chromatin, which, when the cell is sectioned
and stained for microscopic study, appears as a mass of deeply
stained blotches and specks scattered indiscriminately over
a very delicate network of threads or "linin" fibrils. When
the cell becomes active and starts to divide this chromatin
material is gathered together into an irregular twisted thread
known as the "skein" or "spireme," which is at first long
and thin, but soon shortens and thickens and then breaks up
into a number of segments in the form of rods, loops or
balls, the number of which is characteristic for any given
species of plant or animal. ])ut which varies in different
species from two to upwards of two hundred. In division
these chromosomes are equally divided so that each new cell
receives the same number as the parent cell contains.
But when the animal or plant is ready to reproduce there
is a striking difference in the behavior of the chromosomes—
a difference to which is probably related all the varied and
wonderful phenomena displayed by Mendelian inheritance.
Nearly forty years ago Van Beneden ascertained that the
germ cells of Ascaris, an intestinal parasite of the horse, each
contained, at the time of fertilization, one-half the number
204
Biology in Amrrica
of chromosomes characteristic of the species; which number
was thci-cfore restored at the time of fertilization by the
union of tlie egg and sperm inielei. Now, if this reduction
in number can be shown to involve the separation of definite
mwmmh
Photographs of Chromosomes
Showing various stages in the division of a sea urchin 's egg. The
minute dark masses at the center of the egg are the chromosomes. The
light areas, surrounded by dark radiations to either side of the chromo-
somes are the "asters," so-called from their star-like appearance.
Biologists are still in the dark as to the cause of this wonderful process
of cell division. In certain respects it closely resem))les an electro-
magnetic phenomenon, the poles of the magnet being located at the
centers of the asters. These chromosomes are more delicate than the
finest filament of a sjjider 's web. Fig. B is magnified 3,000 times, the
others 1,500. After Wilson, "Atlas of Fertilization and Karyokinesis
of the Ovum. ' '
Bi/ pcrminKion of the Macmlllan Company.
chromosomes from one another so that different sex cells
receive different chroinosonie combinations, then an ideal
arrangement exists in the cell, for realization of the Men-
del ian results. Referring to the case of the tall and dwarf
peas, let us suppose that both partners in the cross are "pure,"
The Role of the Chromosomes
205
T
t
T
It
Tt
t
It
tt
e. g., that all the germ cells of the tall pea carry the deter-
miner for talliiess (T) and all those of the dwarf pea the
determiner for dwarf ness (t). If now we cross the tall (T)
with the dwarf (t) we shall have in the cells of the hybrid
both T and t, and the resnlt will be a tall pea (since tallness*
dominates dwarfness) carrying latent the determiner for
dwarfness.
Before the germ cells of the hybrid are ready for fertiliza-
tion they must undergo a process of ripening or maturation
in the course of which the chromosomes of each are reduced
to one-half the number in the l)ody cells of the species. This
reduction is effected by the union of the chromosomes in
pairs and their subse(iuent division as apparently single,
though in reality double elements. One of these divisions,
kiiown as the "reducing division" is as-
sum,ed to separate the paired elements
from each other. If now we assume that
the determiner for tallness be carried by
one chromosome and that for dwarfness
by another, and that these two chromo-
somes pair with one another in the matu-
ration of the germ cells of the hybrid,
separating from each other in the reduc-
ing division, then the germ cells of the
latter will be of two kinds, e. g., those
containing the T chromosome and those
containing t. Now when the hybrids are
crossed with one another there will be
three possible combinations resulting from
the union of their germ cells, in the fol-
lowing ratio (ITT, 2Tt, Itt), which re-
sults from the chance combination of T and T with t and t.
These chance results may be demonstrated by a simple ex-
periment. If four billiard balls, two black and two white,
be shaken together in a box and drawn out in pairs, one- fourth
of the drawings will be two blacks, one-fourth tAVO whites
and one-half a black and a white. If then the behavior of
the chromosomes at the time of maturation and fertilization
is as assumed, and if secondly the chromosomes carry "deter-
miners" (whatever they may be) for the characters of the
organism ; then the Mendelian results must follow as a
mathematical necessity of the chance separation and recom-
bination of till' chromosomes in the maturation and fertiliza-
tion of the germ cells.
We have used a iuntil)er of "ifs" in the above discussion.
Are our conclusions based purely on assumptions? Let us
see. In the ease cited we have assumed in the first place
Diagram to illus-
trate inheritance of
size in' the sweet pea.
A cross of a tall
with a dwarf pea
produces 3 tall and
1 dwarf pea in the
second generation.
200
Biology in America
that chromosomes carrying: the alternative determiners for
tallness and dwarfness pair with each other and later separate
in the maturation divisions, goin<? into different gerin cells.
Now it is manifestly impossible to loeate directly the deter-
miners for any character in any particular chromosome, or
in the chromosomes at all, for that matter. The direct
analysis of the chromosome is as yet impossible. Nor can we
prove directly that the paired chromosomes separate from
each other in the maturation divisions, instead of retaining
their paired character and dividing equally.
We have however certain indirect evidence which strongly
supports our assumptions. In many species of animals and
plants, notably among insects, the chromosomes differ mark-
dHlllllh
® fllllllllb
aiiiiiiift
fliiiiiiit)
®
Diagram Showing Eight i'ossible Distributions of Three Pairs of
Chromosomes in the Maturation of the Germ Cells
After Morgan, Sturtevant, Muller and Bridges, ' ' The Mechanism of
Mendelian Heredity. ' '
By permission of Henry Holt and t'umininy.
edly in size or shape. In the equatorial plates of most
mitoses these chromosomes are very definitely arranged in
pairs with similar members. But after the reduction division,
when the chromosome number is reduced by half, the result-
ing cells each receive similar groups of chromosomes, so that
each chromosome of one cell, has its exact counterpart in its
sister cell, with certain exceptions in the case of the sex
chromosomes to be noted later.
Seemingly then we are warranted in our conclusion that
in the reduction division the members of each pair are
separated from one another and distributed to sister cells.
And further, since the male and female sex cells each con-
tain similar groups of chromosomes, it is reasonable to assume
that similar or "homologous" chromosomes from male and
female pair with each other in fertilization, remaining paired
until the next generation of germ cells matures, when they
separate to be recombined once more in the succeeding fer-
tilization.
The Role of the Chromoaumcs 207
In this way, and in this way only, may be roas()iia1)ly
explained the results of ]\Iendelian inheritance, in which tiic
characters of the parents are shuffled, and dealt to the off-
spring- like the cards in a pack. Mother Nature is an invet-
erate gambler, and every living thing a pack of cards.
But is such a scheme of chromosome distril)ution adecjuate
to account for the infinitude of characters sliown by so com-
plex an organism as man, no two individuals of whom are
ever exactly alike, with the possible exception of the very
rare cases of identical twins? Chromosome counts in man
are hard to make as may be readily understood from the
difficulty of securing fresh and undiseased material for micro-
seoi)ic study. If, as seems probable hcwever the numl)er is
48, which in maturation unite to form 24 pairs, then the
number of possible arrangements of these chromosomes, deter-
mining their distribution to the different germ cells, is 2-* or
16,776,116, and the number of possible combinations re-
sulting from the union of the germ cells in fertilization is
(16,776,116)- or about 2S0,0(}0,00(),0()0,()()0. This calculation
is based on the assumption that each chromosome carries but
a single determiner. It is highly probable however as we
shall see later, that each chromosome carries a large number
of determiners, and that these are mutually interchangeable
between the members of each pair of chromosomes. Allowing
ten determiners to every chromosome, which is probably a mod-
erate estimate, and the last stated figures become about 3,-
000,000,000,000,000,000, 000, 000, 000,000,000, 000,000,()00,0()(),-
000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,-
000,000,000,000,1000,000,000,000,000.000,000,000,000,000,000-
000,000,000.'- If any reader cares to form a mental pictui'c
of this number he is welcome to try !
It is by no means certain however that the determiner is a
fixed and unchangeable unit. In fact, the very reverse U
undoubtedly the case. Chemical analysis of the exceedingly
complex components of the cell is very difficult, and the results
vary widely. All observers are agreed however as to the great
complexity of protoplasm. According to Miescher, nuclein,
wdiich forms the major part at least of the chromosome, has
the formula C^g H4n N^, Pg Oo. Now there are certain sub-
stances, especially among the compounds of carbon, that
wonderfully kaleidoscopic element, which analysis shows to
have the same structure, but which nevertheless exhibit dif-
ferent properties. These ditferences are explained on the
assumption that while the molecules of these substances con-
^ Computed by Professor E. F. Chandler, of the I^nivcrsity of Xortli
Dakota. Even should the above figure be greatly redueed by linkage it
would still be so large as to be absolutely incomprehensible,
208
liioluijij in America
tain tlio same iiuinhci- and kinds of atoms, tlie latter are
ditH'crently arranjied in the molecnles. Such molecules dif-
fering in the arrangement of their component atoms, are
known by the somewhat formidable term of stereoisomers.
Miescher has shown that serum albumen for example has a
possibility of 1,()0U,U()(),()(J() stereoisomers. Now if nuclein has
one-tenth as many and if eacli determiner in the human
chromosome consists of but a single molecule of nuclein, the
number of possible arrangements within the nucleus of the
fertilized egg becomes so great as to be wholly beyond the
range of human ken.
0
2
3
4
•?<•
%'*•
D
i$
lO
->
0
^.
It
It
13
/#
7S-
Photographs of Chrojiosomes
From an insect magnified 1,500 times. The pair of sex chromosomes
is shown at x in Fig. 3. In Figs. 14 and 15, which show the chromo-
somes divided into two groups, each of which passes into a new cell,
the larger one of the pair, which ' ' determines ' ' the female sex, is seen
passing to the loAver group. After Wilson, ' ' Journal of Experimental
Zoology, ' ' Vol. 6.
Still stronger evidence of the behavior of the chromosomes
as outlined above is afforded by that of the sex chromosomes,
which have been found in a large and ever increasing number
of animals. Like the devils in the herd of swine on the
shores of Galilee, the number of hypotheses regarding the
cause of sex, which have in times past infested the human
mind, is legion. As early as the eighteentli century- Drelin-
court enumerated 262 untenable theories of sex determination,
and as Blumenbach aptly said, "Drelincourt's theory formed
the 263rd." Since then, possibly as many more sex theories
have blossomed and Avithered without bearing fruit. Recent
investigation indicates that sex determination is in Nature's
The Role of the Chromosomes
209
hands, and that tlio most wliich niaii can experimentally
accomplisli is to intlnence tlie survival ratio between males
and females.
In many animals, including insects, myriapods, arachnids,
nematodes, echinoderms, fowls, amj)liil)ians, rats, guinea pigs
and man, difiPerences occur in the number or size of the chro-
mosomes of the male and the female. In some cases one sex,
usually the female, has from one to several more chromosomes
than the male ; in others there is a size difference between
two chromosomes of a corresponding pair, which consists in
the female of two large chromosomes, in the male, on the
Gynandromorph Fruit Flies
Courtesy of Professor T. H. Morgan.
contrary, of a large and a small element. The ** accessory"
or sex chromosome may occur either free or attached to
another chromosome, while the relative differences in size
between the unequal members of a pair of sex chromosomes
varies all the way from equality in the two members to
absence of the smaller one.
The process of sex determination in these forms is briefly
as follows : In the reduction division in the maturation of the
sex cells in the male, the members of the unequal pair of sex
chromosomes separate from each other, the larger passing into
one cell and the smaller into another cell; or one or more
elements may pass into one cell, while its sister cell receives
none or a smaller number. The details vary, but the general
210 Biology in Amryica
result is tlio samo, namely, an uneven distribution of chromo-
somes to (litiferent sex eells, judical in<>' clearly a separation
of entire clirumosomes from one another in maturation, and
the production of different kinds of sex cells as a result
thereof. Now when a sperm carrying a larger nmnber of
chromosomes, or a lai'ger member of an nnequal pair, unites
with an egg, the resulting oftspring is a female; while those
sperms which carry fewer or smaller chromosomes, upon
fertilizing an egg, give rise to males.
In most cases studied thus far the differential divisions
occur in the male, the spei'm being of two classes, male and
female producing; but in a few animals, notably birds, m( tl.s
and butterflies, the eggs are of two classes and sex determina-
tion occurs in the female.
While the greatest mass of evidence available thus far
indicates that sex is predetermined in the fertilized egg, there
is some recent work which does not apparently agree with
this theory. A consideration of this evidence however may
best be deferred to a later chapter.
There are also two sexual conditions of more or less common
occurrence in plants and animals, which are dif^cult to explain
on the basis of sex chromosomes. One of these, hermaphro-
ditism, is of very general occurrence in plants and certain
groups of animals; and the other, gynandromorphism, occurs
occasionally in animals. In the former case both sex glands
are normally present in the same animal ; in the latter vary-
ing conditions of the glands occur, sometimes male, sometimes
female, sometimes both are present, while externally the body
may be of different sexes on opposite sides, or opposite ends,
or one-fourth may differ from the remaining three-fourths;^
in fact, almost any mosaic of external sex characters may
occur.
Hermaphroditism is characteristic of most worms, and some
molluscs, and occurs occasionally elsewhere. In vertebrates
it is rare, l)eing characteristic only of the hagtish (Myxine).
In mammals true hermaphroditism is not known, so-called
hermaphrodites having only the external sex organs hermaph-
roditic. Various hypotheses have been advanced to bring
these conditions into line with the chromosome hypothesis, but
thus far without any marked degree of success.
By far the most valuable contribution of recent years to
the chromosome theory of inheritance is the work of ^Morgan
and his students at Columbia on the fruit fly, Drosophila.
By a combination of breeding and cytological studies they
have carried this theory almost to the point of fact. Droso-
phila is a little fly, about half the size of the ordinary house
fly, which breeds abundantly in decaying fruit and vegetables,
The Role of the Chromosomes
211
and may be reared ad libitum on ripe bananas to whicb a
little yeast has been added. The fly has many variable char-
acters which are well marked and readily Mendelized. Tiie
chromosomes also are well defined, so that it furnishes an
exceptionally good subject for studies of this character.
The fruit fiy has typically four pairs of chromosomes, and
thus far more than 400 distinct characters have been found.
Now if these characters has each its determiner in one of
the chromosomes, it is obvious that each chromosome must
A
►>*
•;•
#^^
'•^1 —
lilMiTill
m
■''I'll
'illllll
•••••
B
Diagrams Illustrating the Distribution cf the Sex Chkojisomes
AT Maturation
A, in the female; B, in the male; C, the resulting possible combina-
tions in fertilization. A and B from Morgan, "Heredity and Sex,"
by permision of the Columbia University Press; C from Loeb, after
Wilson.
carry a large number of characters. That being so, all those
characters which are lodged in one chromosome should be
inherited as a unit. And that is precisely what happens in
many cases, giving rise to the phenomenon known as "link-
age." One of the best known examples of this is shown by
certain sex-linked (sometimes incorrectly called "sex-limited"
characters.)
Fruit Flies
The two uj)per figures show the male (right) and female (left) of the
fryit fly. The six lower figures show some of its 200 ami uiore muta-
tions, some of the most striking of which are shown by the wings.
Note the wingless individual in the lower riglitliand corner, and the
one with asymmetrical wings just above. By their extensive studies of
this humble insect, Professor Morgan and his students have added vastly
to our knowledge of tlie laws of inheritance, which luild true not only for
lower animals, but for num himself. After Morgan, "Heredity and
Sex, ' '
By permlf:xion of the Cohimhia Univcrk-iii/ Press.
212
The Hole of the Chromosomes 2l3
Usually the fruit fly has red eyes, but occasional individuals
occur with white eyes. If a red-eyed male be mated with a
white-eyed female the offspring will be of two classes of
approximately equal numbers, namely, red-eyed females and
white-eyetl males. If now the first generation be inbred, four
classes will appear in the second generation, of approximately
equal numbers each, namely, white-eyed and red-eyed nuiles
and females. If the reciprocal cross be made, i. e., white-
eyed males by red-eyed females, the results will differ depend-
ing upon the purity or impurity of the mother in respect to
eye color (i. e., whether or not she carries the white-eye color
latent). In the former case (the mother pure red) the first
generation will all have red eyes, while the second generation,
xY XX
xY^Xx XY Xx
Xx XX XY xY XX Xx XY xY
Diagrams Eepresenting the EOle of the Chromosomes in Deter-
mining Sex and Eye Color in the Fruit Fly
The female of this fly carries a pair of chromosomes, represented by
XX or XX in the diagrams, and the male a pair differing in respect
to one member, thus represented as XY or xY. The factor for red
eye color is represented as carried by X. Thus a red-eyed female has
the formula XX or Xx and a white-eyed female xx, while red-eyed and
white-eyed males are respectively XY and xY. In the right-hand
diagram is shown a mating between a white-eyed male and a red-eyed
female, all of the offspring of which are red-eyed. If these are mated
with each otlier, four kinds of offspring result, which are sliown in
the third row, all the females having red eyes, while half the males
have white eyes. The reciprocal cross and its results are shown in the
left-hand diagram.
resulting from inbreeding the former, will have red and
white eyes in the ratio of three to one. In the latter ease (the
mother red-eyed with white latent) the results will be the
same as those obtained by inbreeding the first generation of
the red-eyed male by the white-eyed female cross.
Sex in the fruit fly appears to be determined by a pair
of chromosomes, which differ slightly in form and size from
the others. This pair is called the XX pair in the female
and the XY pair in the male.
214 Biology in America
The results of the crosses above described can be most
readily explained by assnining that one of the X chromosomes
cariics the determiner for r(\l eye color and another X the
determiner for white. They are shown graphically in the
accompanying diagrams, in which the chromosomes carrying
the determiner for red eyes ai-e shown as capitals, and those
carrying the white eye determiner as small letters.
Many other cases of sex-linked inheritance occur in animals,
notably in moths, fish, birds and mammals, including man.
In the latter, color blindness and hfemopliilia (imperfect clot-
ting of the blood causing continuous How from wounds) are
examples, although the manner of inheritance here is slightly
different than that of eye color in the fruit fly.
While the phenomena of linkage are clearly shown in the
fruit fly, not only in the eye color but also in color of wings
and body, size of wings, etc., the linkage in many cases is
imperfect, some of the combinations of characters in the off-
spring being different from those shown by the parents.
Some fruit flies have vestigial wings and black bodies,
while the ordinary type has long gray wings and a light yellow
body, banded with black on the abdomen. Black body and
vestigial wings tend to stay together in inheritance, indicating
that their determiners are both lodged in the same chromo-
some. But there are some exceptions to this rule. If a
black fly with vestigial wings be crossed with one having long
gray wings, the offspring will all have long gray wings, this
type dominating the former. If now we "back cross" these
offspring with the black vestigial parent, we obtain a curious
result. If on the one hand we back cross a hybrid male with
a black vestigial female, we obtain only black vestigial and
gray long flies. The characters have "stuck together," com-
ing out of the cross in the same combination in which they
entered it. The linkage is perfect and the evidence is strong
that the determiners for the characters tested are lodged in
the same chromosome (black vestigial in one, gray long in
another), which retains its identity throughout the matura-
tion and fertilization processes. But if, on the other hand,
we back cross a female hybrid and a black vestigial male we
obtain a very different result; namely, 41.5% of black ves-
tigial and gray long offspring respectively, and 8.5% of black
long and gray vestigial. In other words, some of the charac-
ters have become mixed in the shuffle and the cards are not
dealt "according to Hoyle."
Is such a result a fatal blow to the chromosome hypothesis ?
On the contrary it furnishes indirectly one of the strongest
evidences in its favor.
We have seen above that the chromosomes pair with one
I
The Rule of the Chromosomes 215
another in maturation and then separate in the reduction
division, so that dififerent germ cells receive different contri-
butions. We have not however considered how the chromo-
somes pair, whether end to end, or side by side. INIuch dis-
pute has arisen over this question, which is probably due to
the occurrence of different methods in different species. In
some cases at least there is definite evidence of a side by side
conjugation or " parasynapsis, " and in some of these it has
been shown that the chromosomes do not lie parallel but wind
about one another, forming a more or less twisted braid.
When this occurs it is probable, although not definitely proven,
that in separating the chromosomes do not unwind but rather
pull apart irrespective of the twist, so that a part of one
chromosome may now be switched over into another chromo-
some and vice versa. This phenomenon of "crossing over"
as it is called, would readily explain the 8.5% of gray vestigial
and black long files obtained in the last experiment ; for if
the chromosomes carrying the black vestigial and gray long
determiners were occasionally to wind about each other and
then separate without untwisting the determiners would be
apt to get mixed up and find themselves in the wrong pews,
so to speak. Why this should occur only in the female and
not in the male is a problem. Possibly more extensive experi-
ments would show it to occur in the male also. However, the
lack of cross-overs in the male of another species of Droso-
phila (viriles) suggest that it is a constant feature of this
genus.
Now if this explanation of crossing over be correct, we
should expect those characters to cross over most frequently,
the loci of whose determiners in the chromosomes are most
widely separated, for in the twisting, points at either end of
a pair of chromosomes would be more apt to interchange
places from one chromosome to the other, than closely adjoin-
ing points. And as a matter of fact, great differences do
exist in the amount of crossing over between diff'erent charac-
ters. On the basis of these differences Morgan and his
students have made a plan of the chromosomes, locating with
a high degree of probability in tiny threads of protoplasm,
possibly the diameter of the finest filameit of a spider's web,
the determiners of more than two hundred characters already
studied in the fruit fly.
The fact that all these characters fall into four groups in
respect to their linkages, thus corresponding to the four pairs
of chromosomes in the fruit fly; and further, that the cal-
culated separation between the extremes in each series, based
upon the frequency of the cross-overs, corresponds to the
relative lengths of the chromosomes, is very strong addi-
^o'
216
Biology in America
tional evidence for the cliromosome hypothesis as outlined
a])()ve.
In the course of their experiments tlie students of the fruit
fly were suddenly confronted with an unexpected, and at
first sight unexplaiiuihle case, which seemingly set the chromo-
some hypothesis on its head. As already explained, if a pure
0 0 VI I LOW. SPOT
II 7 I.MHAL I
I ..WHITF.iOMN. CMERKy
I.U AnSOKllAL
'.0 BKIU
14 7 CLUB
■ 100 SHlfTED
•«.•• I mm V.
■»v» iniiM IV,
f 0!>EPIA
-loo DACHS
:S.U PINK PEACH
•■MBOSr.VJOTT.
'1 ''.WOftULA.
Chromosome ATap Hhowing Distkiiuition of Linked Characters in
The Fruit Fly
After Morgan, "Heretlity and Sex."
By permission of the Columbia University Press.
white-eyed female be mated to a red-eyed male, red-eyed
daughters and white-eyed sons in approximately equal num-
bers are the result. But in one set of experiments this cross
produced, in addition to the expected classes of . offspring,
about 2.5% of white-eyed females and an equal number of
red-eyed males. Such a result is readily explainable how-
ever "on the assumption that the two X chromosomes of the
The Role of the Chromosomes
217
female stick together in the reduction division, so that
one class of eggs receives two X and the other none. A
detailed analysis of all the possible combinations resulting
from snch a case is rather too complicated for consideration
here. Suffice it to say that the unexpected class of white-
eyed females could be obtained by tlie fertilization of an XX
egg by a Y sperm, and that of red-eyed males by the union
of an egg lacking an X with an X sperm (the X being the
important chromosome in sex determination, the Y ai)i)arently
l\.
I\
^.^
/»^
Diagrammatic Kepresentation of the Chromosomes of the
Fruit Fly
The female (left) and male (right). The chroinosomos are shown in
pairs, the sex jjairs being indicated by XX (female) and XY" (male)
respectively. In the lower figuie is shown tlie peculiar case of a female
carrying 2 X and 1 Y, owing to the failure of the 2 X to separate from
each otlier in the ripening divisions of the egg. This condition explains
certain unusual results found by Morgan and his students in bree<iing
these flies for eye color. After Morgan cf al.
non-functional in this connection, 2 X giving a female and
1 X a male). It is also possible theoretically to obtain a
female with foitr sex chromosomes, 2 Xs and 2 Ys. Not only
can the unusual breeding results be explained theoretically
in this manner, but cytological research shows that such cases
actually occur, some exceptional females having been found
which contained one or two Y chioiuosomes in additiou to
the usual XX.
218 Biology in Amei'ica
While there are some objections to the chromosome theory,
and while it as yet has only the status of a theory, it never-
theless serves better than any other to explain the observed
results of IMendelian inheritance. To what extent the cyto-
plasm shares with the chromatin the role of determination,
and whether all the characters of livin<>: things, or only the
more superficial are determined by the latter, cannot at pres-
ent be said.
In this tinj'' workshop of the cell wonderful things are
taking place. Here is recorded the liistory of the past, and
here is meted out the fate of generations yet unborn.
CHAPTER VIII
Experimental biology continued. Influence of environment
in determining the development of organisms. Effects of
temperature, light, moisture, chemicals and food upon the
form of ammals and plants. The control of sex.
And what of the development of this marvelous cell ? What
hand glides the growth of the future organism in all its
wonderful detail from this apparently simple, but unspeakably
complex drop of protoplasm? Is it predestined, or is it
plastic, to be molded by the experimenter at his will 1 These
two possibilities are in no wise incompatible with each other.
While the pattern of the cloth may be fixed, the form of the
garment to be shaped therefrom is as variable as the caprice
of fashion. Nor can the former be permanently fixed, unless
evolution is a myth.
As we have already seen in IMendelian inheritance the char-
acter determiners are apparently distributed according to the
laws of chance. But there is evidence showing that this dis-
tribution can, to some extent at least, be controlled.
If the female fruit i\y be exposed to temperatures ranging
from 50° to 86° C. at a certain period during the maturation
of her germ cells, it is found that the amount of crossing
over between two factors may be increased by more than
100%, That external factors may profoun(ily influence
Mendelian results has been clearly shown by Tower. The
genus Leptinotarsa, of which the common potato beetle is a
member, shows several color variations, which have been
designated as species. When the female L. signaticollis is
crossed with the male L. diversa at an average temperature
of 75°-79° F. and a relative humidity of 75%, the hybrid
offspring fall into two distinct groups of practically equal
numbers, one of them indistinguishable from the mother and
the other intermediate between the two parents. The former
group breeds true for several generations ; but the latter when
inbred give the typical Mendelian ratio of 1 signaticollis,
2 intermediate and 1 diversa, the first and last of which breed
true, but the second continues to split up in further breeding,
into the two parent and the intermediate types. If however
the crossing be done at an average temperature of 50° to 75°
219
220 liioloyii ill America
F. aiul ivl;itivc linmidity of 50-80% only tlic intonnediate
form is obtainod. Not only ai'o llioso rosidts jriven by dif-
ferent pairs of elosely related individuals, brothers and sistei-s,
l)ut 1h(" same pair wlien mated under different conditions give
ditfereut I'esults.
While ^lendelian eliaraeters are evidently represented by
definite determiners in the germ cells, there is abundant evi-
dence that the development of these characters can be con-
trolled by enviroument. There is a sex-linked dominant
chaiacter iti Drosophila known as abnormal abdomen, in which
the usual black bands upon tiie abdomen are irregular and
broken and may even be absent. That this character depends
on the type of food (whether wet or dry) for its development
may be shown by tiie following experiment. If an abnormal
male be crossed with a normal female and the larvae fed on
wet food, the daughters will be abnormal and the sons normal ;
but if the food be drv^, both daughters and sons will "be
noi-mal. From these latter daughters however abnormal off-
spring may be obtained if the conditions are favorable, show-
ing that the determiner for abnormality is present, regardless
of external conditions, but the development of the character
itself is dependent upon tliis latter factor.
The influence of environment in determining the form of
the individual animal or plant is so well known as to be
connnonplace. Food, temperature, pressure, moisture, chem-
icals, radiation may, one or more, so profoundly change the
development of an organism that two differently cultured
individuals may not be recognizable as members of the same
species.
The effect of environment on individual development is
perhaps nowhere more strikingly shown than in many species
of mountain plants, which range froni the low moist valleysi
to the high arid slopes above timber line. Seeds of the same
species will produce in the former situation tall stemmed
plants, with large thin leaves, small roots and pale flowers,
which require from two to three months to mature seed ; while
in the latfer environment they develop plants with short stems,
small, thick leaves, and bright colored flowers, which set seed
within a few weeks after the blossoms open ; all of which,
possibly excepting the flower color, are adaptations to their
different environments.
A test of the influence of the environment upon plants has
been made by the Department of Hotanical Eesearch of the
Carnegie Institution, by the introduction of various species
of ])lants into areas having very different climates, in the hot
dry <lesert at Tucson, Arizona, in the cool climate of the
neighboring mountains, and in the cool moist climate of the
The Infll'kxlk uf I-^n vikonmkxt on Plants
A, Campanula from 8,300 feet altitude at the left and one from 14,100
et at right. B, from left to rijrht, gentians growing in shade and
sunlight at 8,300 feet altitude, and alpine form from 13,000 feet. 0, at
the left, alpine form, at tlio center, sunlight, and at the right, shade
forms of Androsace.- From "Plant Indicators."
feet
sunligl
Courtesy of Doctor F
E. Clcmrntu and the Carnegie Institution.
221
222 Biology in America
California Coast near Monterey. A very pretty exanii)le of
the response of plants to such climatic changes is given by
the common iioke-weed (Phytolacca) of the eastern United
States. In California the body of the plant grows well, but
the flowers are usually reduced and seed is not formed, while
at Tucson, on the contrary, the plant body grows low and
prostrate, and flowers and fruit are abundant. There are
many other changes also, both of leaf and flower. In this
instance at least the variations appear to be temporary and
not inherited.
The common water-cress of our eastern ponds and streams,
when cultivated out of water, develops enlarged roots, and
marked changes in the form of the leaves, the submerged
leaves having very narrow, almost thread-like leaflets, while,
when grown in the air, the leaflets are broader.
The results of experimental modification of the form of
animals are too numerous for full discussion here. ]\Iany
of them are cited by Darwin in his different books, and the"
majority of them have been obtained by European workers.
The seasonal variations (summer and winter) of certain
butterflies can be produced at will by temperature control
during the pupa stage. Similarly local varieties (northern
and southern) of butterflies can be produced by temperature
control during the developing period. Differences of color
between the sexes can similarly be controlled. The seasonal
changes of arctic birds and mammals are well known, and
are supposed to have selective value, either for offense or
defense. That these changes are at least secondarily depend-
ent upon temperature was shown by the experience of the
arctic explorer Ross with the lennning, or arctic mouse;
which when kept in the ship's cabin in wdnter retained its
gray coat, but when put on deck promptly changed to white.
The celebrated experiment with the Porto Santo rabbits
recorded by Darwin is supposed to illustrate the influence
of climate in changing animals. These rabbits are believed
to have originated from the progeny of a single female pro-
duced on shipboard about 1418 or 19. According to Darwin
these rabbits, when examined b.y him in 1861, showed marked
differences from domestic rabbits, being much smaller and
differing in the form of the skull and in color. Four years
later however under the influence of the English climate, they
had resumed the color of the domestic form. Kecently how-
ever Mr. Gerrit S. Miller of the U. S. National ]\Iuseum has
claimed that the celebrated Porto Santo rabbits are nothing
more nor less than the rabbits native to southern Europe.
Even if this is so however it does not invalidate Darwin's
The Hole of the Chromosomes 223
observation on the change induced by transferring the rab-
bits from Porto Santo to England.
Great differences also have been produced in butterflies
and moths by changes in the food of the caterpillar, while
light, electric and chemical stimuli, etc., show marked effects.
The results of some American workers will now be con-
sidered in more detail.
The salamander Amblystoma has gills and fins and lives
in the water during its larval or axolotl stage. At metamor-
phosis it loses fins and gills, leaves the water and thereafter
lives upon the land. In some cases however metamorphosis
does not occur, and sexual maturity appears in the larval
form. Although the relationship between the axolotl and
some terrestrial form was suspected by Cuvier, it was not
discovered until 1865 in the Jardin des Plantes at Paris,
when the young of some axolotls gradually lost their gills,
their fins disappeared and they came forth upon land to live
thenceforward as Amblystomas. All the factors controlling
the metamorphosis cannot at present be stated with certainty,
but apparently a regular but small supply of food as opposed
to abundant but irregular feeding tends to prevent meta-
morphosis. It has been generally supposed that drying up
of the water, with consequent lack of oxygen, forced the sala-
manders to an air-breathing habit and induced metamorphosis.
But Powers has shown that the axolotl will metamorphose in
abundant and well-aerated water, if its food supply be cut
off, and conversely forcing the salamanders out of the water
will not induce metamorphosis unless accompanied by a
change from an abundant to a meagre diet. His explanation
of the control of metamorphosis by nutrition is that, when
suddenly deprived of food, the salamanders are forced to
live on their own tissues, and that those of gills and fins
being the first consumed, causes the reduction of these organs,
and induces metamorphosis. His interpretation is supported
by the fact that during metamorphosis the animals are gener-
ally in a state of semi-starvation.
As is well known, Amblystoma is an exceedingly variable
animal, and Powers has related these variations in large
measure to nutrition. Kegular, but moderate amounts of
food, produces slender and agile animals, while heavy feeding,
on the contrary, produces fat and lazy beasts, which spend
most of their time on the bottom of ponds or aquaria. Most
marked of all the varieties are certain animals of large size,
very broad heads and frequently emaciated appearance,
which result from cannibalism. Axolotls ordinarily feed
upon microscopic life in the water such as larvaB of insects,
224 Biology in America
etc., l)iit ooeasioiially tliey take to preying? upon each other,
oftentimes witli results fatal alike to cannibal aiul to prey.
Towers records his observations of some cannibals as follows:
"It was curious that in every instance where two or more
of tlie cannibals Avere placed at close quarters, even though
other larva} were present, the result was the destruction of
one or both of the cannibals, while the others frequently
remained unharmed. This result is not due to the natural
enmity of competitors or to a wise foresight with regard to
a limited food supply, but purely to the strongly modified
reactions of the cannibals themselves. "While an ordinary
larva instinctively avoids close contact with another, and
beats the most precipitate retreat at the merest touch of
cannibalistic jaws, the possessors of these weapons them-
selves are apparently wholly divested of this innate fear.
Unless decidedly hungry they lie sluggishly at the bottom,
either ignoring the chance contacts of other specimens, or
savagely nabbing the intruder. The violence and instan-
taneousness of their occasional movements contrast strongly
with their sluggish inactivity between whiles. Even com-
plete satiety does not usually check their savage attacks, pro-
vided that the proper stimulus is offered ; the prey is then
seized and held some time or half swallowed, to be then as
quickly rejected by a sudden jerk much like the one by which
it was seized. Thus it is that cannibals in close proximity
almost invariably prove each other's undoing, the swallower
frequently succumbing as Avell as the swallowed. Even when
taken in the reservoir, not a few of the broad-heads were
sadly bitten or abraded, some having been, it would seem,
nearly swallowed before meeting with the resistance, no doubt,
of some friend who had just gone before."^
Not only may ordinary individuals be induced to assume
the cannibalistic habit, with resultant change of shape, but
cannibals may occasionally be reformed and made to resume
the ordinary shape. Obviously the larval form is very plastic
and readily amenable to the influence of habit. The greatly
exaggerated head with its wide gape is clearly the result of
swallowing large prey, while the emaciation of other parts
of the body, especially gills and legs, Powers ascribes to the
"energy — absorbed in the heroic efforts of ingestion" and
the nourishment required for the excessive development of
head, digestive tract and body length.
The change of plumage in birds in the spring and fall
months is a commonplace, but none the less wonderful phe-
nomenon, a satisfactory explanation for which has not yet
^"Studies from the Zoological Laboratory," University of Nebraska,
Vol. IV, pp. 57-58.
The Role of the Chromosomes
225
been given. One of tlic most striking of these color changes
occurs in the male scarlet tanager, which during the breeding
season wears a uniform of brilliant scarlet with black wings;
after which he assumes a dull olive drab like the female,
which he wears during the winter, resuming his brilliant garb
in spring. Another bird with a pronounced difference be-
tween summer and winter plumage is the male bobolink.
We hail with joy his return to our northern fields in spring,
with his bright livery of black, buff and cream, and his ring-
ing, cheery song. In the fall, when in his dull drab coat
Effect of Diet on Body Form in- Amblystoma
Fig. 1, young cannibal after full meal. Fig. 2, typical larva. Figs.
3-5, young cannibals. Fig. 6, normal larva, typical of the ordinary
specimens among ■which the cannibals were found. From Powers,
"Morphological Variation and its Causes in Amblystoma tigrinum. "
Studies from the Zoological Laboratory of the University of Nebraska,
Vol. IV, No. 71.
he gathers in flocks of thousands upon our marshes, we shoot
him as the plump little "reed bird"; while over the rice fields
of the Carolinas, upon his return from his summer sojourn
in the North, he meets an even worse reception from the rice
grower as his inveterate enemy, the "rice bird."
Immediately following the breeding season, i. e., at the
time of the fall molt, birds are usually in poor condition
both in respect to feathers and flesh. Some male tanagers
and bobolinks in the New York Zoological Gardens were pre-
vented from breeding for one season, during which time they
remained in full song and excellent physical condition and
retained their full breeding plumage. About a month previous
226
Biology in America
to the time of the fall molt the birds were put in a darkened
room and their food supply slightly increased. On this regi-
men the birds grew fat and lazy and ceased to sing. Most of
them passed the winter thus in full summer plumage, but
one of the tanagers molted into the winter plumage as a
result of a siidden change of temperature. In the spring
the birds were brought under normal conditions again and
promptly molted into the spring plumage, the winter molt
having been entirely suppressed, a beautiful example of
environmental control of an hereditary trait.
The Scarlet Tanager, Male and Female (Right)
A striking example of sexual difference in birds. The winter dress
of the male is similar to that of the female. From Cooke, "Bird
Migration," in Bulletin Bureau Biological Survey.
The Bobolink (Left)
A bird of many aliases, admired in the North, detested in the South.
From a drawing liy Louis Agassiz Fuertes in Cooke, "Bird Migration,"
Bulletin Bureau Biological Survey.
The effects of light on the color of animals are clearly
marked in some instances, and in others seemingly negligible.
The typical fauna of caves comprises animals, which have
little or no pigment, and either partly or wholly degenerate
eyes. The amphipod Eucrangonyx gracilis occurs both in
the open and in caves. In the latter situation its eyes alone
are pigmented, while in the former, other parts of the body
The Bole of the Chromosomes 227
are pigmented also. If the young of specimens living in the
open are kept in the dark during development, the pigment is
more or less absent. Different species of salamanders show
differing results when reared in artificial caves ; in some there
is very slight reduction of pigment and in others this reduc-
tion is temporarily almost complete. These latter however
may develop the normal amount of pigment at metamorphosis.
Vice versa, cave animals lacking pigment may or may not
develop pigment, when reared in the light. Possibly the less
responsive types are those which have lived longest in their
respective habitats. However the fact that there is consider-
able individual variation in this respect suggests that some
other factor is involved.
An interesting adaptation of certain cave animals is their
greater sensitiveness to tactile than to light stimuli as com-
pared with their free-living relatives.
Animals respond readily to chemical treatment. Some of
the most noted experiments along this line are those of
Stoekard in the production of Cyclopean fish. By treating
developing minnows with magnesium salts, alcohol, chloro-
form, etc., he has replaced the paired eyes with an unpaired
median one resembling that of the fabled Cyclops, and similar
results have been obtained by McClendon and Werber. Not
only may Cyclopean monsters be formed by chemical treat-
ment, but deformities of many kinds. Eye deformities may
range all the way from various stages in the approach and
fusion of the eyes, through Cyclopean eyes, to no eyes at all.
The eyes may be rudimentary in size and displaced dorsally ;
or there may be inequality of the two eyes, leading to the
absence of one of them. An eye may even be developed
entirely outside the body of the embryo, on the surface of
the yolk sack. Abnormalities of the eyes are usually accom-
panied by those of nose and mouth, which are frequently
drawn out into a snout-like projection. In cases in which one
eye is lacking its place may occasionally be taken by the
mouth. The nasal pits may fuse into one, and the same
may be true of the ears. Or these latter may be enormously
swollen, or on the contrary exceedingly small, when one or
more of the semi-circular canals may be defective or lacking.
Partial embryos may occur, or the parts of the embryo may
develop separately, as in the case of a yolk sack eye, already
mentioned. In fact every imaginable deformity may be pro-
duced by chemical treatment, from very slight defects- to those
so great that the resulting creature is merely a formless
mass of living matter.
Abnormal development may sometimes run a more orderly
course and produce symmetrical, relatively perfect creatures
228
Biology in America
which Professor Wilder calls ' ' cosmobia. ' ' Thus in man there
exists a whole series of duplicities from a slight cleft of the
spinal cord to those in which the cord is doubled for its entire
length and is more or less rudimentary. The doubling
process may go furtber, resulting in a double-headed monster,
or one with two heads and four arms. Or if the process
proceed in the reverse direction a single body and head may
possess tAvo pairs of legs ; while if the doubling process occur
at both ends simultaneously "Siamese twins" result; until
finally if the body be completely separated "identical twins"
Cyclopean Pish
Produced by treatment with magnesium salts. From Stockard, in
"Journal Experimental Zoology," Vol. 6. Mouth; yolk sack.
occur, which are always of the same sex, and resemble each
other as closely as the proverbial "two peas in a pod."
The experiments on fish embryos strongly support the
theory of Mall, that monstrosities in man are due to diseased
conditions in the mother's uterus, with resultant metabolic
disturbances and the formation of toxins in the embryo and
fetus.
We have seen in the last chapter that our present evidence
very strongly indicates that sex is predetermined in the egg,
so that most of the supposed instances of its artificial control
are at the present time of historical interest only. One of the
most popular tbeorios of sex determination ascribes to food a
sex determining influence. Experiments of this nature have
A IIl'MAX Twix AlnXSTER
Types of Human Facks
From the sinjjle "Cyclopean oye" type (I-V) tlir()U<,'li normal (VI-
IX) to (hiplicate (X-XIV), showing intergi-adatioiis. From Wilder,
"The Morphology of CosnioLia/' "American Journal of Anatomy,"
Vol. 8.
229
230
Biology in America
been performed on insects, frogs, birds and mammals. Better
nutrition is supposed to produce more females and vice versa.
In this way the attempt has been made to explain the increase
in males in France during the Napoleonic wars. One observer
has cited data showing that among the nobility of Sweden
the proportion of males to females is 98-100, while among the
clergy the ratio is 108.6-100. Another has shown on the
contraiy that in London the more well-to-do have a larger
percentage of sons than daughters. Temperature, age of
parents and ripeness of eggs are other popular factors in
sex determination. But one of the most naive of recent
theories supposes that there is a regular alternation of male
A Human "Monster "
Courtesy of Dr. Oeo. L. Streeter.
and female producing ova in man, the former coming from
the right, and the latter from the left ovary, and that sex
might be determined by the position of the prospective mother,
whether lying on her right or left side.
Extensive experiments have been conducted on the influ-
ence of external factors in determining the sex cycle in par-
thenogenetic animals. The most familiar example of this type'
is the bee, in which the unfertilized egg gives rise to a male
(drone) and the fertilized to a female (queen) or an unde-
veloped female (worker). Here sex depends upon the act of
fertilization, and is probably determined by the chromosomes,
which differ in number in the two sexes. The influence of
food in controlling development is here most beautifully
The Role of the Chromosomes
231
shown, for the fertilized egg becomes either a queen or a
worker, according to the kind of food which it receives.
In other parthenogenetic forms the sex relations are not
so clear. Among the fresh water Crustacea the daphnids pre-
sent a well-known example of parthenogenesis. When the
daphnids appear in spring or summer only females are found.
They lay thin-shelled eggs which develop without fertilization
into other females which in turn lay parthenogenetic eggs,
and so the story goes for several generations ; when suddenly,
males make their appearance, together with the "winter" or
"resting" eggs, which are fertilized, and surrounded by a
thick shell, in which they pass the winter inactive in the ooze
at the bottom of the water. AVith the advent of warm
weather the following year these eggs hatch, giving rise to
Molted Skin and Liberated Egg Case op a Daphnid
Photo by Lloyd, from Needham and Lloyd's "Life of
Waters," Comstoek Publishing Company.
Inland
parthenogenetic females, which repeat the story. The time
of appearance of males varies in different species. In some
it appears to be correlated with the lowered temperature of
autumn, and in others with the drying up of the pools in
which the animals live. A similar life history is presented
by the rotifers, or "wheel animalcules," so called from the
circlet of vibrating cilia at the anterior end.
The group of nematodes or thread worms present some
curious modifications of the sex cycle. Some of these are
parasitic, others are free-living and yet others present a
so-called "alternation of generations" in which one genera-
tion lives parasitically and the other free. Moreover some are
hermaphroditic, others bi-sexual. Among the bi-sexual, free-
living forms, parthenogenesis is of common occurrence, having
gone so far that in one species, males occur only in the ratio
of 13 to 100,000 females, while in others they have not as
232 Biology in America
yet been discovered. Furthermore in some cases the males
have lost the sexual instinct and the females have partly
developed hermaphroditism, producing sperms, which enter
the eggs but take no further part in their development, the
latter developing by parthenogenesis.
The principal American workers on control of the sexual
cycle in parthenogenetic forms have been ShuU and Whitney.
It has been claimed by some European zoologists that tem-
perature or food are controlling factors in the production of
males in daphnids and rotifers. The influence of the former
factor is seemingly borne out by the occurrence in nature
of differences in the cycle in different races of the same
species. Thus Chydorus spha^ricus, a European daphnid,
reproduces both parthenogenetically and sexually in the low-
lands of central Europe, while in the mountains, reproduction
is said to be exclusively parthenogenetic. The influence of
these factors is denied by the former workers. They have
demonstrated however a marked influence of the purity of
the culture medium on production of males, the proportion
of males to females in Hydatina senta being greater the
more the culture medium was diluted with spring water.
Possibly the controlling factor here was the relative acidity
of the medium, for Banta has shown the influence of this
factor in controlling the production of males in daphnids.
It has been argued that these experiments have nothing to
do with sex control, that all they prove is the possibility of
shifting one way or another the time of appearance of males,
in an alternating sex cycle, in support of which argument
is presented the fact that the same mother will produce males
or females from the same eggs, depending on whether or not
these are fertilized, similarly to the case of the bee mentioned
above. But is not this begging the question, for what is it
that determines the appearance of the males in the first place?
The evidence indicates that it is an external factor, and in
so far as this is true we certainly are controlling sex.
There is some recent work by Riddle which indicates that
sex in birds is a question of metabolism, males arising from
germ cells of higher metabolism, larger water content and
less fat and phosphatides. Riddle claims the sex may be
controlled by controlling these factors in spite of the sex
chromosomes, which are "but a sign or index, not an efificient
cause of sex." His results, while seemingly conclusive, need
to be extended, and correlated with those of the cytologists
before any certain conclusions can be drawn however.
The conditions found in some of the Crustacea and gephy-
reans indicate that sex is not a predetermined, unchange-
able condition. Some of the parasitic isopods are first males
The Role of the Chromosomes 233
and later become females. In the sand hopper (Orchestia)
occur alternate periods of maleness and (partial) femaleness,
while in Bonellia, one of the gephyrean worms, the larva
develops into a male or female, depending upon whether it
lives attached or free. "While sex appears, in many cases at
least, to be predetermined in the egg, it would not be safe
at present to say that this predetermination was in all cases
irrevocable.
A curious condition has been discovered by Banta in some
of the daphnids (Daphnia and Simocephalus) in the form of
" sex-intergrades. " In these animals the sexes are readily
distinguishable externally by several secondary sexual char-
acters, such as size and form of body and appendages, hair-
iness of ventral surface, etc, Banta has found a complete
series of intergrades, ranging from normal males on the one
hand, through males with one or more of the secondary char-
acters of the female, to hermaphrodites and females with
certain secondary male characters, and finally to normal
females on the other. A similar condition has been found
by Goldschmidt in the gypsy moth, and by Stout in the
common plantain weed. How far these results agree with
the chromosome hypothesis of sex determination is very much
"up in the air" at present.
Reference has already been made to Hydra, a name classic
in biology as in mythology. Hydra may reproduce either
by simple division of its body into two parts, by forming
buds which develop into new Hydras and are then pinched
off the parent stock, or by developing sex organs followed by
fertilization. "Whitney has shown that the appearance of
sex organs can be controlled by external factors, such as tem-
perature and food. Thus, if Hydra be kept for a time at a
low temperature, and the temperature be then raised and the
animal starved, testes and ovaries develop. Sexual repro-
duction in lower plants (i. e., Vaucheria, etc.) has also been
controlled by external factors. These latter experiments how-
ever deal with the control of sexual, as distinct from asex-
ual reproduction, and not with the determination of sex
itself.
In the foregoing pages we have sketched very briefly a few
of the facts bearing upon the relative roles played by hered-
ity and environment in the development of the organism.
Needless to say the two factors are in no sense antagonistic
or mutually exclusive, but both work together in fashioning
the final product. The inheritance of the organism may be
compared to the molten metal; the environment, the mold
in which the metal is cast.
CHAPTER IX
Experimental 'biology continued. The factors of evolution:
natural selection, mutation, orthogenesis, isolation, inherit-
ance of acquired cliaracters. Experimental modification of
the germ cells.
The search for the beginnings of things was one of the ear-
liest tasks of the human mind. Man, like a little child, with
a ' * why ? ' ' ever present on its tongue, has never ceased to ask
the questions, "Whence came I, and whither am I bound?"
With the latter question science, with her present limitations
of time and space, has naught to do, but the latter ever has
been, and perchance ever will be the focal spot of human
thought. Strange and curious are the many fancies with
which primitive philosophy has invested the problem, and in
spite of all the wonderful achievements of modern science she
is still but playing with the pebbles on the seashore. We
smile complacently as we read of the fat turtle of the Iroquois
philosopher, which, waddling along one hot summer day,
found his shell too great a burden, and throwing it off became
a man; or of the crude philosophy of the early Greeks who
imagined a fish coming upon land, bursting its horny capsule
and stepping forth a man ; or yet of the old French philoso-
pher who related a tale of a wonderful tree, whose leaves,
falling on the one hand upon water, gave rise to fish, and on
the other upon land, took wings and flew away as birds,
naively remarking that while this magical tree was not, to
be sure, to be seen in France, yet it was said to be common
in Scotland, a land, which to the reader of those days, was a
terra incognita. And we shake our heads learnedly as we
talk today of "fortuitous variation," "internal perfecting
principles," "entelechics" or "orthogenetic evolution." But
when, in the language of the street, we "get down to brass
tacks" are we really any wiser than our forbears? And yet
the denser our ignorance the more alluring becomes the field
of research, while the frontiers of knowledge ever recede as we
approach, impelled by the primeval instinct to explore.
While the theory of evolution has become axiomatic among
thinking men of every school, the ways and means of evolu-
tion are as great a bone of contention as ever. It is but nat-
234
The Factors of Evolution 235
ural therefore that the factors of evolution and heredity, for
the two processes are of necessity indissolubly united, should
be the center of modern biology.
The success of Darwin in establishing the theory of evolu-
tion was due primarily to his explanation, by the theory of
natural selection, of a reasonable process by which evolution
could be effected, and his support of this theory with a vast
array of facts, and of logical arguments deduced therefrom.
And yet the theory of natural selection or survival of the
fittest antedates Darwin by more than two thousand years.
The Greek poet-musician-naturalist, Empedocles, who lived
in the fifth century before Christ, fancied living creatures as
arising from the four elements — earth, air, fire and water, un-
der the action of the forces of love and hate. The animals
first formed, "appeared, not as complete individuals, but as
parts of individuals, — heads without necks, arms without
shoulders, eyes without their sockets. As a result of the tri-
umph of love over hate, these parts began to seek each other
and unite, but purely fortuitously. Thus out of this con-
fused play of bodies, all kinds of accidental and extraordinary
beings arose, — animals with the heads of men, and men with
the heads of animals, even with double chests and heads like
those of the guests in the Feast of Aristophanes. But these
unnatural products soon became extinct, because they were
not capable of propagation." ^
These crude ideas of Empedocles are interesting historically
because they show how early the survival idea arose in man's
mind. By many other writers also, previous to Darwin, this
idea was expressed, notably Hume, Buffon, Kant and St.
Hilaire, and when Darwin's thesis itself was presented to the
world it appeared as two papers published simultaneously in
the Journal of the Linnean Society by himself and Alfred
Russell Wallace.
In spite of the splendid exposition given by Darwin of the
theory of natural selection, and its very general acceptance
by scientific men of a few decades ago, the pendulum of sci-
entific thought is swinging today in the opposite direction,
and the consensus of opinion is distinctly adverse to the ac-
ceptance of the theory in all its important points.
Before considering the experimental work which has largely
induced this reversal of opinion, let us see what the essen-
tial features of the theory are. Three factors are involved,
namely, variation, inheritance, and selection or survival. Let
us illustrate their co-operation to produce evolution by a con-
crete example from Darwin's ''Origin of Species." "The
^Osborn, "From the Greeks to Darwin," p. 38. B7 permission of the
Macmillan Company.
236 Biology in America
pirafTe, by its lofty stature, inucli elongated neek, fore legs,
head and tongue, has its whole frame beautifully' adapted for
bi'owsing on the higher braneiics of trees. It can thus ob-
tain food beyond the reach of the other , . . hoofed animals
iidiabiting the same country, and this must be a great advan-
tage to it during dearths. ... So under nature with the nas-
cent giratfe, the individuals which were the highest browsers
and were able during dearths to reach even an inch or two
above the others (variation) will often have been preserved
(selection). , . . They will have intercrossed and left off-
spring, either inheriting the same bodily peculiarities, or with
a tendency to vary again in the same manner (inheritance) ;
whilst the individuals, less favored in the same respects, will
have been the most liable to perish."^
One of the strongest evidences cited by Darwin in support
of his theory was that of artificial selection. If man, he said,
in a few hundreds or at most thousands of j^ears, could pro-
duce, by selection, all the manifold varieties of domestic plants
and animals which we know today, why could not Nature,
working through the countless ages of biologic time, perform
the creative wonders of the past and present kingdoms of ani-
mals and plants inhabiting the world? It is difficult however
to subject the work of the practical breeder to scientific
analj'sis, based as it is upon purely economic grounds. Fur-
thermore, we have today a mass of information regarding in-
heritance which was not available to Darwin. Within re-
cent years therefore the problem has been attacked scien-
tifically by a number of workers, the pioneer being the Dan-
ish liotanist, Johannsen.
If one choose any group of organisms, be they men or be
they microbes, and carefully aiTange them according to size,
he will find that they form a series, with an average and
two extremes — a greater and a lesser. If now, on the one
hand, the largest individuals, and on the other the smallest,
be chosen for breeding, and from their offspring in turn the
largest and the smallest be again selected, can finally two new
races, a larger and a smaller, be developed? This question
forms the crux of the selection theory.
To test it Professor Johannsen of Copenhagen chose at ran-
dom 12,000 beans and measured the length and breadth of
eacli to obtain an average. From these he chose nineteen, rang-
ing from the largest to the smallest. Breeding these for seven
years, and selecting the largest and smallest seeds for each
planting, he found that, while the largest beans produced
seed larger than the average of the 12,000, and the smallest
produced seed smaller than the average, bubsequent selection
» Pp. 276-7, 6th ed.
The Factors of Evolution
237
availed nothing to increase or decrease tlic size of each "pure
line" as Professor -lohannsen called the progeny of his nine-
teen seeds, "('an a man add one cubit unto his stature," or
a bean one millimeter unto its length? Professor Johannsen
thinks not.
Population
Diagram Showing the Effi ct of Selection Upon a Mixed Lot of
Beans or ' ' Po(Pulation ' '
If several thousand beans, selected at random, are sorted ac-
cording to size and placed in test tubes, the lower figure will result ;
those beans of an average size will be greatest in number, while
the larger and smaller sizes will be fewest. If beans from different
test tubes be selected for planting the "pure lines" 1, 2, 3, etc. will
result. Further breeding of these "pure lines" will not serve to change
the average size of the population^ selection serving merely to sort out
the varieties jumbled together in a inLxed "population." From Walter,
after Johannsen.
Similar results have been obtained by several American
workers, notably Professor Pearl, who, while at the Maine
Agricultural Experiment Station, attempted by selection to
increase the laying capacity of hens — and failed ; and Pro-
fessor Jennings of Johns Hopkins, who has likewise shown
that selection is powerless to change the size of the one-celled
animal Paramcecium.
238
Biology in America
But tlie voice of the selectionist is not yet stilled. Perhaps
tlie chief American exponent of tlie tlieory has been Professor
Castle of Hai^'ard, whose work on hooded rats is well known
to all biologists. The hooded rat is a color variety of the
common brown rat, with black head and shoulders and a black
stripe on the middle of back and tail. By persistent selec-
tion of individuals with more black and more white respec-
tively, Castle has obtained individuals ranging all the way
from those with a small median stripe of white upon the belly
to others with only a small patch of black upon the snout. ^
For over twenty years a selection experiment has been
conducted at the experiment station at the University of Il-
linois, which also appears to give strong support to the the-
" Hooded" Eats
Showing the results of experiments by Professor Castle of Harvard in
selecting these animals for extent of black and white in the pattern.
After Castle & Phillips, "Piebald Eats and Selection," Carnegie In-
stitution, Publication No. 195.
ory. In 1896, Professors Hopkins and Smith began selecting
seed from ears of corn which had on the one hand a high, and
on the other a low protein content. This continual selection
has resulted not only in producing grades of high and low
content, but each succeeding year shows on the average a wider
divergence in the two grades. Thus, starting in 1896 with
an average per cent (in weight of grain) of 10.92 they pro-
duced the first year a high grade of 11.10% and a low of
10.55% with a difference of only 0.55%. By gradually in-
creasing steps these figures after twenty years' selection
reached 14.53% for the high, 7.26% for the low and 7.27%
for the difference. Similar results were obtained by them in
selecting for oil content.
The anti-selectionists however have explained these results
as due merely to the sorting out of variations already pres-
ent in a very mixed stock. A better understanding of the
•Eecently Professor Castle has modified his original contentiou.
The Factors of Evolution
23!)
whole question of selection can be had after a discnssioii of
the next factor of evolution, namely mutation.
The mutation theory is not a new one to biolofjists. A
century ago St. Ililaire suggested the origin of birds fi'om
reptiles, the first formed bird hatching full-fledged from a
reptile's egg. The existence of mutants or "sports" were well
known to Darwin, and are cited by him as a source, although
a minor one, of evolution. The cases wbicli lie gives are how-
MUTATION IN QDnOTHEKA
The original stock laninrkiana to the left, gigas a mutant to the right.
From Castle, ' ' Genetics and Eugenics, ' '
By permission of Harvard University Press.
ever of a striking and unusual sort. The A neon ram is one
of these. In 1791 a Massachusetts farmer discovered in his
flock a ram with short crooked legs and a long body. The
thrifty farmer bred from this ram in order to obtain a flock
of sheep which could not jump fences, and would thereby
save himself much worry, and his sheep dog much exercise.
This was the origin of the famous breed of Ancon sheep, which
is now however extinct. The merino sheep, a breed having
long silky wool, which originated in 1828, is another exam-
12K)
/iinio;/)/ ill Aiiirrica
j)le filed by Darwin. Si ill other iiislaiiees are tiiose of liorn-
less eatlle, hairless clogs, l)oi)-tailecl cats, web-footed chiekens
and extfa-finjrered men. These however are exceptional
cases; the <i:reat mass of mntations, tliose mainly productive
of evolution, are of the minor sort, appreciable only by care-
ful measurement and statistical analysis.
The presentation of the mutation theory in its present form
we owe nuiinly to tiie Dutch botanist, DeVries. A brief
resume of the hitter's work will bring the subject fairly be-
iN 1 example of mu
Poulry, " Carncyie Instil u1 ion, PuliKcation
A RuMPLESs Fowl
ton. J''roiii l)a\ i'n|iort,
No.
Inherit a nt-e
in
fore us. Over thirty years ago DeVries found certain well-
marked varieties of the evening primrose, a native of Amer-
ica, which had been introduced into Pairope and was grow-
ing as a weed around the city of Amsterdam. Specimens of
these varieties and of the parent species were transplanted
in his garden and bred for many years including eight gen-
erations, during wdiich time he discovered and recorded over
800 variations from the parent type, whose possessors bred
true to themselves. By selection of these variations he was
able to produce a large number of distinct types of prim-
rose which he called "elementary species,"
The Factors of Evolution 241
Since tlie publication of DeVries' work on the mutation
theory the attention of biologists has been focnssed more and
more on this factor of species building, and large numbers
of cases have been recorded in both animals and plants.
These cover the whole garant of variation and are both (juali-
tative and quantitative in kind. They include variations in
color, markings and size ; in form ; length and number of
hairs, bristles, etc. ; ditferences in shape of parts such as leaves
of plants, wings of insects, horns of cattle, etc. ; differences
in habit of plants, whether erect or procumbent, straight or
branching, etc. ; differences in the number and union of parts,
such as syndactylism and polydactylism in man and other
animals ; differences in presence or absence of parts, such as
absence of a tail in cats and chickens ; in fact, virtually every
character known of either animal or plant is liable at some
time or other to show mutation. INIutations vary moreover
in size, from the large "sports" already mentioned, down to
variations so small that it is mere hair-splitting to attempt
to distinguish between them and Darwin's "fortuitous" vari-
ations on the basis of size alone.
What distinction then if any can be made between these
two classes? Darwin did not attempt to define "fortuitous"
variations, but speaks of the term as serving "to acknowl-
edge plainly our ignorance of the cause of each particular
variation." His distinction between them and "sports" or
mutations was one of size alone. More recently however we
have learned to recognize in the small "fortuitous" varia-
tions of Darwin two distinct kinds of variability, one of which
we call "continuous" or "fluctuating" and the other "dis-
continuous" or "mutating." If the sizes of any group of
organisms, let us say men, be plotted on a chart, as Ave
shall find a point which is called the mode, at which
fall a greater number of measurements than at any other,
while the remainder graduate to either side of this point
until the limits of the series are reached. Such a chart is
called a frequency polygon (or curve, if the measurements are
sufficiently numerous and close together). Such a chart rep-
resents graphically "fluctuating" variation, the variations
falling indiscriminately on either side of the mode. If indi-
viduals from either end of the series be mated, their off-
spring will be widely diff'erent from the average of the series,
but will nevertheless approach that average more nearly
than their parents, and no amount of selection will serve to
raise or lower the limits of the series, that is, to increase the
original variability. In the cases of Johannsen's beans and
Jenning's Parama?cia and similar cases above cited however,
selection does serve to sort out groups of individuals whose
242
Biology in America
cliaractors (weip:lit, length, etc.) center around a new mode
wliieli is higher or lower than the original. If the character
1 /"-■
fOO
1
\
1
\
\
\
160
\
/
tAO
-f
\
l
\
1
\
\
fio
1
\
\
1
ico
/
/
\
/
-\i
/
\
fio
/
/
/
\
60
1
.. . . 1
\
r
\
1
\
40
1
\
1
\
?.n
/
-h
\
/
\
_^
0
~f»— 1 —
(Se /S3 tez 1€6 /69 /7/ /7i /77 130 /B3 /06 I8S fSZ /35B8
Frequency-polygon and Curve
Showing variation in height of one thousand Harvard students of
ages 18-25. Number of individuals shown by ordinates, and heights
(in centimeters) by abscissae. After Castle, "Genetics and Eugenics."
By permission of Harvard University Press.
of each of these groups be plotted, a series of curves is ob-
tained, each of which represents "fluctuating" variability of
the smaller group and has its owu mode. If all of these
The Factors of Evolution 243
smaller curves be compounded they produce the large curve
representing the larger group. In some instances the
existence of several modes is seen in the original chart of a
group of organisms. In other eases however mere inspection
fails to reveal the compound nature of a variability curve, and
only experimeiital analysis will tell the story.
These minor groups which when selected breed true to their
own type, are the "elementary species" of DeVries, or dis-
continuous variations, while the "fluctuating variations" are
those which fluctuate about a mode and which cannot be re-
solved into smaller components by selection. From this view-
point "species" and "elementary species' may be compared
in a rough way to the molecule and atom of the chemist.
The objection has been raised to DeVries' theory that his
mutations are the results of hybridization, producing a new
combination of characters already present, but not anything
really new in itself. The wide range of mutation however
among both plants and animals, wild as well as domesticated,
from the large "sports" of Darwin down to those so small
that they cannot be distinguished at sight from "fluctuat-
ing" variations, the fact that in some species there are peri-
ods of frequent mutation, alternating with those in which
it is absent or rarer, and the possibility of inducing them
artificially all speak in their favor as something new, and
not due to a mere mixing and rearrangement of characters
already present. Unless indeed we accept Bateson's view
that most if not all variation is due to the loss of something
already present, which, carried to its logical conclusion,
brings us face to face with the reductio ad ahsurdum that
all the possibilities of man were wrapped up in the original
iV*nioeba, or whatever it was that initiated the long line of life
upon the earth.
But having analyzed the species into its component parts,
having found the blocks from which the organism is built,
are we any the wiser? Whence came these ultimate units,
if indeed they are such, and how does Nature fashion them
to her use? Are we any nearer an understanding of varia-
tion today than was Darwin?
The attack on the problem of variation has been made
along two distinct lines, that of Aristotle and Nageli, with the
assumption of an "internal perfecting principle," or in-
herent tendency in the organism itself to vary along certain
definite lines, for iinhnown reasons, and that of Kimer and
his school, who believe that variation in the organism is a
very definite physico-chemical response to physico-chemical
244 Biology in America
changes in its environment, either internal * or external. The
former metliod is metaphysical and unscientific; the latter,
while beset by many difficulties, is the only one of promise.
What then has been done to discover the influence of en-
viroiunent upon variability? In a previous chapter we have
briefly surveyed tlie influence of environment upon individ-
ual development, and have seen that this influence is often
of a profound character. But is such influence lasting, does
it through heredity control future as well as present gen-
erations? And this brings us face to face with one of the
greatest stumbling blocks in biology ; namely, the inheritance
of acquired characters.
In the first place what is the meaning of the term? V{e
owe the theory to the great French naturalist Lamarck, one
of those lonely and pathetic figures who look down upon the
pathway of human progress unheeded by the passing throngs.
Lamarck as.sumed first, what is universally granted ; namely,
the influence of use and disuse of organs upon individual de-
velopment, and second, what is generally denied; namely,
the perpetuation of such influence by heredity. Thus let us
suppose a grouj) of early race horses to have increased their
speed by training until they were materially faster than their
parents. If now such increase in speed were handed down
to their offspring, and these in turn improved by further
training, aiul so on from generation to generation, there
would evolve in time the speedy animal of today. Or if, on
the other hand, a race of fishes living at one time in the open,
for some reason or other, perhaps to escape the attack of ene-
mies, took to dwelling in caves, where sight was of little ad-
vantage; there would in course of time, through lack of use
of sight, develop the blind cave fishes of the present. The
theory is the prettiest and simplest of the modua operandi of
evolution which has been proposed, and could it be proven,
would remove many difficulties in our path. Unfortunately
however proof thus far is lacking. Skepticism toward the
theory has been mainly founded on failure of mutilations of
various sorts (circumcision among the Jews, cramping of
feet by the Chinese, docking of horses' tails), and finally Weis-
mann's classical experiments in amputating the tails of twen-
ty-two geiu'rations of mice, to produce any inheritable modi-
fication whatever in the parts so mutilated. It should be
noted however that while Lamarck's theory postulates use
and disuse as the prime factors in causing change, some of
the mutilations above cited do not involve the factors of use
■* Ultiniatoly "internal" chantros tlu'iiisc'l\es are prol)aT)ly roforalile to
external causes. I have in niiml tlie manifold metabolic changes, which
may produce variation. Regarding this we have no certain knowledge.
The Factors of Evolution 245
and disuse and consequently have no bearing whatever on
the question at issue. Whoever heard, for example, of a
horse with a docked tail ceasing to use the stump just as vig-
orously in fiy time, as though possessed of the complete mem-
ber? What was there in the mutilations of Weismann's mice
to prevent the use of the muscles at the hase of the tail ? With
the bound foot of the Chinese woman this objection would not
apply, because the muscles of the foot are intrinsic to the foot
itself ; but in this case we have to consider the intluence of the
father as well as the mother upon the children, and the prac-
tise of foot binding in China has been limited to the female
sex.
Are there then no environmental influences which are trans-
mitted from parent to child? Is environment a negligible
factor in evolution? On the contrary it is undoubtedly the
most potent factor, either indirectly in the preservation of
those variations (however caused) best fitted to survive, or
directly in the induction of variation itself.
The seed of a flowering plant is the plant itself in minia-
ture, containing more or less "endosperm" or nourishment
for the growing seedling, until it is able to take root, unfold
its leaves and obtain its own sustenance from the soil and air.
If the chemical environment of the developing plant (the
young ovule) be modified, what effect will this have on the
adult plant? This question led MacDougal, director of the
Desert Botanical Laboratory of the Carnegie Institution, to
inject various solutions of zinc, calcium, iodine, etc., into
the ovaries of many species of plants, with the result that the
ovaries so treated produced seeds from which developed
plants showing many modifications in form of leaves and
flowers and markings of the latter, as well as in the form of
the plant as a whole, and some, at least, of these variations
have persisted through several subsequent generations.
The common potato bug has in part redeemed its shady
reputation, by materially aiding us in our search for the ulti-
mate factor of evolution, namely, the origin of variation.
This beetle was originally an inhabitant of ]\Iexico. Feeding
upon the night-shade, it followed its food plant northward,
and the early settlers found it establislied on the eastern
slope of the Rocky Mountains. The spread of its food plant
is attributed by Professor Tower, who has made an exhaustive
study of the beetle and its habits, to the movements of the
early Spanish explorers, and to the migrations of animals,
especially the buffalo, whose mighty herds in early days were
wont to wander north and south across the plains with the
changing seasons, and in whose furry coats the burrs of the
night-shade might readily have been entangled. The eai-ly
246 Biology in America
settlors bronglit with them plenty of English grit, Scotch
whiskey ;iml Irish ])otatoes; and the beetles, finding the lat-
ter more to their liking than their native food, soon showed
proper appreciation of the good things set before them, and
became inveterate potato feeders. After this change in the
diet, it was not long before they had overrun all of the
eastern United States and lower Canada.
There are many species of these beetles, distributed in
different parts of the range of the genus, and most of them
show considerable variation. There are two generations each
season, the duration of each varying both with the species and
the locality. The beetles retire for the winter underground
and upon emergence in spring, seek out the potato plants,
upon which the eggs are laid. From these hatch the grub-
like larvae, which after a varying period cease feeding, and
drop to the ground into which they burrow and there pupate,
surrounding themselves with a thin shell. From this the
adult beetles escape, make their way to the surface and pro-
ceed to a repetition of this performance, the second brood
of beetles hibernating in the earth at the end of summer. If
the larvae are taken soon after hatching and kept in experi-
mental cages at higher or lower temperatures than normal,
or in more or less humid atmospheres, or in various combina-
tions of temperature and humidity, until development is com-
plete, the adult beetle developing from them will be lighter
or darker in shade and will show many differences from the
usual color pattern, these differences in many cases closely
corresponding to differences in beetles from different locali-
ties. Thus it was possible to produce in the laboratory in
Chicago beetles resembling closely those occurring in nature
in Arizona, The same stimulus produced different results
depending upon its strength. Thus a moderate increase of
temperature made the beetles darker in color, while a greater
increase made them lighter, and precisely similar results were
obtained by lowering the temperature, and by raising and
lowering the relative humidity.
But these results were temporary, lasting for one genera-
tion only, and were not inherited. If on the other hand the
beetles, shortly before egg-laying occurred, were subjected to
similar conditions, variations were produced which persisted
in subsequent generations. In the former case only the
"soma" or body cells of the individual were affected; in the
latter, the germ cells at a sensitive stage in their develop-
ment— at least so Professor Tower interprets his results.
Samples of some of his "creations" are shown in the accom-
panying figure.
Not alone by laboratory experiment is it possible to control
The Factors of Evolution
247
evolution in the potato beetle. The same experiment has been
performed in Nature 's laboratory by transferring beetles from
the relatively cool, moist climate of Chicago to the hot arid
air of Tucson, Arizona. As a result of this transfer not only
are morphological (color) changes induced, but physiological
ones as well. ' The beetles gradually acquire the power to re-
MUTATIONS IN THE PoTATO BEETLE
2 represents a type derived experimentally from 1 by the use of high
temperature. 5 was derived from 4 by using high temperature and
relative humidity and 7 from 8 by high temperature and low humidity.
From Tower, " li]volution in Chrysomelid Beetles," Carnegie Institution,
Publication No. 48.
tain more water in their tissues during hibernation, and
thereby to resist the effects of the dry climate. They show
also certain changes in their responses to stimuli. These
changes moreover are not reversible, but persist when the
beetles are returned to their original home at Chicago. They
248 Biology in America
behave furtheniiore as definite, fixed characters in inherit-
ance, Mendelizing when crossed with the original stock.
It is well known that the X-rays and those of radium and
related substances exercise a profound influence on living
tissue. In general the influence of such agents has been de-
structive, inducing abuornml developments of various sorts.
The careless use of X-rays has been the cause in some in-
stances of cancer, while on the other hand their use, and es-
pecially that of radium rays lias been advocated as a cure for
this disease. Unfortunately the results in this direction are
as yet unsatisfactory.
In some instances it has been possible to produce changes
in the developing organism without any apparent injury to
it. One of the prettiest experiments of this sort is that of
Gager, who exposed the pollen of one of the evening prim-
roses to radium rays, and obtained a few individuals with
thick, leathery leaves from ovules fertilized by this pollen,
which character reappeared in their offspring. That such
radiations produce profound effects upon the structure of the
cell is shown by exposing growing root tips to their influence,
the mitotic figures in the dividing cells being greatly distorted
thereby.
The probable influence of environment upon animal form
and color is very clearly shown in the extensive collections
of birds and mammals made by American ornithologists and
mammalogists, especially those of the U. S. Biological Sur-
vey, in which an almost endless series of gradations may be
seen between the various "geographic races" of one "spe-
cies"''' from different i)arts of North America. These varia-
tions are so great in some cases that specimens from, extremes
of the geographic range would not be recognized as members
of the same species, did not a complete series of intergrades
exist.
If one compares a mammal, a field mouse let us say, from
Florida or tropical Mexico with its nearest relative from
Labrador or Alaska, he will find the legs, ears and tail of
the former a trifle longer, and the fur a little lighter than
the same parts of its northern cousin. Is it mere accident
that the northern mouse is more warmly clad, and has ap-
pendages which are shorter, and consequently less liable to
freeze, than the southern one? Or is it a question of sur-
vival, has Nature selected those individuals best adapted to
the regions where they live? Or yet again, is this a case of
the influence of environment, and if so, has the latter di-
'^ Accord inj;; to soiiio writers these " jreographic r.Tces " are accorded
the status of ' ' species. ' ' Tlie question of terminology does not how-
ever influence the facts in the case.
The Factors of Evolution 249
rectly affected the germ cells, or has such influence been trans-
mitted to them indirectly, by affecting first the body cells of
the parent, which effect has been secondarily transmitted to
its germ cells? If the latter is true, it would go far to es-
tablish Lamarck's theory of the inheritance of acquired char-
acters.. In an attempt to solve this problem, Sumner has
reared several generations of white mice under different con-
ditions of temperature and relative humidity. The mice were
kept in unheated and heated rooms respectively, in the for-
mer of which the relative humidity was much higher than in
the latter, although in neither were the conditions at all con-
stant. As a result the mice in the cold room developed a
greater amount of hair and shorter tails, feet and ears. These
differences however diminished as the mice grew older. Un-
fortunately his equipment did not enable him to control his
factors properly, so that his comparisons were made between
the general conditions of greater and less heat and moisture
respectively, and not between definite degrees of these factors.
However his results do show a rather definite influence of
temperature and humidity, not alone upon the parents, but
also upon their offspring of the first generation. These re-
sults, so far as they go, show then that environment may di-
rectly affect not only the organism itself, but also its off-
spring.
When we come to the question however of how these re-
sults were obtained, we are very much at sea. In the case
of Tower's experiments described above there can be little
doubt that the influence of the external factors upon the germ
cells was direct, because inheritable variations were obtained
only when the experimental factors were operative at a cer-
tain definite time in the development of the germ cells. Here
too the latter, in the body of an animal whose temperature is
not constant, but varies with that of its environment, are
readily subject to environmental influence, at least so far
as temperature is concerned. In the case of humidity it
is more difficult to see how the germ cells could be directly
influenced. In mice however whose body temperature and
moisture is constant under normal conditions, regardless of
external factors, it is impossible to postulate a direct ac-
tion of such environmental factoi-s upon the germ cells, and
the only possible interpretation to be placed on Sunnier 's
results, assuming their accuracy, is that of an indirect in-
fluence of external factors upon the germ cells, through
changes primarily induced in the body cells or soma, and sec-
ondarily transmitted from them to the germ cells; i.e., the
inheritance of acquired characters.
Unfortunately Sumner's results have not been, so far as
250
Biology in America
I know, substantiated by any other investigator, and his own,
more reeent work in California has strikingly failed to sup-
port his previous experiments. In his later work Sumner
has been studying the relatioji between climate and color of
several races of California deer mice (Peromyscus). The
climate of California presents all possible gradations, from the
arctic conditions of the Sierra summits to the torrid heat of
the southern valleys, and from the humid air of the northern
coast to the parched atmosphere of the interior deserts.
Widelv distributed over the state the ubiquitous deer mouse
The Deer Mouse, Peromyscus
Photo l)ij E. R. Warren.
is found with three distinct varieties of one species, one of
which occupies the cold humid coast region from San Fran-
cisco northward, another the interior, including both moun-
tains and valleys, and the southern coast, while a third lives
in the hot, arid deserts of the southeastern part. Possibly
a more ideal region for studies of environmental influence on
variation could not be found. Sumner has reared several'
generations of mice taken from the humid northern coast, and
the desert to the southern coast at La Jolla, and to Berkeley
on San Francisco Bay, but thus far without obtaining any
definite results. The imported mice remain true to their an-
cestry.
The Factors of Evolution 251
Far back in the dim shadows of the past, primitive man is
represented as asking his Creator, "Am I my brother's
keeper?" And that qnestion has come down to ns through
all the ages, with ever-growing insistency. What measure of
responsibility do we bear for the well-being, not only of our
brothers of the present, but our children of the future ? Does
a man's conduct influence for weal or w^oe the lives of his
children ? Alcoholism is a well recognized inherited trait.
But what is its origin? Can a man through indulgence in
the "cup that cheers" affect the inheritance of his children?
AVhile abundant data are available from human inheritance
to show its inheritability, evidence regarding its origin can-
not be readily obtained here. And so the experimenter has
turned to the long-suffering guinea pig, the rat and the
chicken for an answer to his question. And here only indi-
rect evidence at best can be obtained. We cannot induce an
alcoholic tendency or fondness in a lower animal, or at least
it has not yet been done ; but we can determine whether sub-
jecting the parent to alcohol will in any way influence the
offspring, and whether such effects, if any, will persist in
future generations.
Trial of several methods of subjecting animals to alcohol
has shown that the best method is to allow them to breathe
the fumes for stated periods daily, the length of the period
being determined by the ease with which the animal is in-
toxicated by the fumes. The method is objectionable because
of the tendency of the animals to become blind under the in-
fluence of the fumes. This does not however interfere wdth
their breeding, nor does it reappear in the offspring. Using
this method on guinea pigs Stockard has found that of one
hundred and three matings between parents, either one or
both of which had been treated with alcohol, forty-three were
either sterile or resulted in abortions; in fourteen matings
the young were stillborn, while in the forty-six matings pro-
ducing a total of eighty-nine young, thirty-seven of these
died soon after birth and only fifty-two survived, many of
which were undersized and nervous.
MacDowell has carried out a long series of experiments to
test the effects of treating rats with alcohol upon the ability
of their young to learn a path through an intricate passage
or "maze," which indicate that the grandchildren of young
so treated learn less readily than do those of normal rats.
MacDowell has also obtained a very definite effect upon
the rats so treated, their weight and fecundity being ma-
terially reduced. Pearl, in a similar series of experiments on
fowl, "found that while the proportion of fertile eggs laid
by alcoholized parents was nuicli lower than in those from
252 Biology in America
normal paioiits, these whicli wci'c I'crtik' wore more re-
sistant (fewer died before hatching) and the chicks hatched
were heavier than those of normal chickens. Pearl has ap-
parently pnblished no resnlts dealin*? with the effects of alco-
holism on {^generations later than the first, but Stockard's ex-
periments seem to show that such effects are transmitted to
the grandchildren.
In the light of these contiadictoi'y results no final word can
be said regarding the intfuence of alcohol .on animals and
the transmission of such influence to subsequent generations.
In neither the experiments of Stockard nor of Pearl did the
treated animals themselves show any conspicuous effect
(apart from blindness in the guinea pigs, which was the di-
rect result of the action of the alcohol fumes upon the eye)
although the alcoholic chickens increased somewhat in flesh
and became rather lazy, a result easily paralleled in some
cases in man.
Recognizing then the occurrence of variations produced
by physico-chemical factors either internal or external to the
organism itself, and granting that such variations may in
some cases be preserved, but probably neither increased nor
diminished by selection; are there other factors which may
influence evolution ?
In 1868 ]\Ioritz Wagner suggested the influence of geo-
graphic isolation as a factor in the evolution of plants and
animals, and this theory has more recently been advocated
by David Starr Jordan in this country.
One of the objections to the theory of natural selection is
the swamping effect of intercrossing betw'een nascent spe-
cies. How this "swamping" is effected if new varieties are
discontinuous or mutating, breed true and do not blend when
intercrossed, is difficult to understand. It is possible how-
ever that the dominant types being more numerous have
caused the reccssives to be overlooked, and that consequently
the "swamping effect of crossing" is more apparent than
real. If however such objection is valid, the danger to the
new species could be removed were a barrier to such inter-
crossing to arise between nascent types, thereby preventing
them from interbreeding. That such isolation does play an
important role in evolution, there is good reason to believe.
Isolation may be of several kinds: psychical, physiolog-
ical, structural, habitudinal and geographical. It is well
known that many species of nearly related animals will re-
fuse to interbreed. In other cases in which different species
of animals do interbreed the offspring are ordinarily infer-
tile, perhaps the best known instance being the mule, which
is a hybrid of the jackass and the mare. Mulatto women,
The Factors of Evolution 253
while fertile, are said to have frequent miscarriages, and
after a few generations to be generally barren. In more ex-
treme eases, while fertilization is possible and development
may proceed for a time, the offspring of the cross do not at-
tain maturity. This is especially true of crosses between
widely divergent forms such as the salamander and the frog,
or the sea urchin and the starfish.
In some instances isolation is effected by a difference in
the time of mating of different individuals. There are many
species of butterflies which have different color phases, to
which reference has already been made. These color phases
are apparently due to the time of year at which the eggs
are hatched, whether in spring, summer or autumn. It is'
probable that those butterflies which hatch at the different
seasons mate together, thus producing isolation of the dif-
ferent color phases of the same species, due to the different
hatching seasons of the eggs. Inhabiting the Kermadec Is-
lands northeast of New Zealand are two varieties of a spe-
cies of shore bird, which flock together but breed at different'
times, thus producing isolation between them.
In other cases structural differences, notably of the external
sexual organs, such as occur in various species of insects and
other arthropods, effectually serve to prevent interbreeding;
while yet again structural differences in the germ cells them-
selves interfere with cross fertilization.
Habitudinal isolation may be effected by the preference of
different groups of animals for different modes of life (dif-
ferences in food or habitat). Inhabiting the southern hemi-
sphere are several species of albatrosses, which mingle with
one another throughout most of their range, but breed in
separate localities. Professor Kellogg, whose name is famil-
iar to us all for his services to Belgium, some years ago made
a study of the bird lice, a group of wingless, biting insects
living on birds and mammals, similar in habit, though dif-
fering in structure from the "ugly, creepin' blastit wonner,
detested, shunned by saunt an' sinner," but immortalized by
Burns. In this study he found that while the similarity of
the environment in which these lice live tends to keep the
different species unchanged, nevertheless the isolation pro-
duced between groups of individuals living, it may be for
years on the body of the same bird, tends to fix the minor
variations which occur in all living things, and thus pro-
duce slight but noticeably distinct variations within the spe-
cies.
The student of geographical distribution of plants and"
animals recognizes as axiomatic the fact that the more widely
separated are any two regions of the earth's surface, the more
254 Biology in America
divei'freiil will be llu'ir J'aiiiias and floras, liy ''separation"
in this sense is meant separation in time and environment
ratlun- tlian space. Thus the fauna of Australia and New
Zeahuid shows a vastly jrreater difference from that of th^
Asiatic nuiinland, although separated therefrom by less than
2,000 miles, than does that of Japan from England, which are
about 8,000 miles distant from each other. By some biolo-
gists these differences are referred to the effect of isolation,
by others to the direct influence of environment (tempera-
ture, moisture, etc.), natural selection in either case exercising
the veto power or final control over the other factors. Prob-
ably all three factors are so closely inter-related in deter-
mining the final result in most cases that an exact analysis
of their relative roles is impossible. The inhabitants of cen-
tral Africa, separated from those of northern Africa by less
than 2,000 miles, differ more widely from each other, than do
those of North America and Siberia, separated by several
times that distance. But between the former intervenes the
wastes of the Sahara, impassable to most forms of life, while
the latter have an almost continuous land area between them,
broken only by the narrow Behring Strait, which freezes in
winter. Prior to the Miocene epoch a few million years ago,
which is comparatively recent, geologically speaking, tlie At-
lantic and Pacific Oceans were connected, where now ex-
tends the Isthmus of Panama. The elevation of the isthmus
has thus separated an originally single fauna into two, with
the result that many of the species on either side of the isth-
mus are represented by nearly related ones on the opposite
side, both doubtless derived from one ancestral form.
In the instances already cited it is impossible to distin-
guish between the possible effects of environment, selection
and isolation ; in fact, it is very probable that all of them
have worked together in producing the final result. But in
the case of the land snails of the Hawaiian Islands, the two
former factors are seemingly ruled out, and isolation appears
to have been the only factor involved. The Hawaiian Islands
are a group of volcanic origin, the chief of which, Oahn, con-
sists of a long mountain ridge, rising to an elevation of 4,000
feet above the sea, from which extend inimerous lateral ridges,
with deep intervening valleys. Inhabiting these valleys are
800 or 1,000 different varieties of land snails (Achatinellidae),
over 200 of which the conchologists recognize as ''good spe-
cies." These snails feed upon the vegetation in the valleys
and seldom cross the high rocky ridges of the intervening
slopes. Each valley therefore has its own community of
snails, which is effectively isolated from neighboring com-
munities, but a few miles distant. As a result of such iso-
The Factors of Evolution 255
lation there have developed in each valley varieties peculiar
to it. In some cases a species is restricted to a single valley,
while in others it may extend over two or three adjacent
ones. The most nearly related forms are found in adjacent
valleys, and the most divergent in those widely separated.
Gulick, who has made a special study of these snails, says, "I
had found not simply a large section of the world, within
which peculiar species had originated, but ascending a certain
mountain ridge a few miles from Honolulu, and looking down,
I could say, 'That valley to the right, a couple of miles in
length and half a mile in width, is the birthplace of the
Achatinella producta and Achatinella adusta ; and within the
groves of this valley upon which we look on our left were
created Achatinella stewartii and Achatinella johnsonii;
while behind us a mile to the northeast, in the jungle that
clings to the almost precipitous cliffs on the other side of the
backbone of the island, is the secret home of the very rare
and beautiful Achatinella versipellis. ' ' ^
Crampton, who has made an extensive study of the distri-
bution, variation and evolution of the land snails of the
genus Partula, inhabiting Tahiti, one of the Society Islands
of the South Pacific, forms closely related to the Achatinel-
lidse of Hawaii, has reached conclusions similar to those of
Gulick. He finds that "with only one exception each group
of islands has its own characteristic species which occur no-
where else," while with few exceptions each island in the
different groups "possesses distinct species not found in the
others," and the species "may vary from valley to valley
of an island; one form sometimes extends over a wide range,
while another may be restricted to a few valleys or even to
one."^
In many of the habitats of the different species of snails of
Oahu and Tahiti, the environment is seemingly identical. In
two adjacent valleys, but two or three miles apart, different
species of snails may be found, feeding on the same trees at
similar altitudes and experiencing the same degrees of tem-
perature, humidity and- barometric pressure. In some cases
contiguous valleys present greater differences in vegetation
than those more widely separated, and yet the diversity of
the snails in the former ease is less than in the latter. Di-
vergence of environment is therefore obviously not the cause
of the differences involved. Nor is there any apparent in-
fluence of selection. When two environments differ widely,
'Gulick, "Evolution, Racial and Habit udinal," Carnegie Institution,
Publication 25, pp. 1-2.
'Crampton, "Variation, Distribution and Evolution of the Genus
Partula," Carnegie Institution, Publication 228, p. 11.
256 Biology in America
selection may step in to eliminate a species which is not
adapted to one or the other of them. But as we have just
seen there is no correlation between differences in the snails
themselves and amount of difference in their surroundings.
Nor do the possible enemies of the snails differ in their dis-
tribution in the different regions.
Isolation however cannot of itself have caused these dif-
ferences which must have arisen by spontaneous variation of
the snails themselves, due to factors as yet unknown ; isola-
tion playing merely a preservative role in maintaining the
variations tluis originated, which tend to increase by "ortho-
genesis," for reasons equally obscure.
For several years past Dr. Paul Baartsch of the Smith-
sonian Institution has been carrying on an interesting and
significant experiment, when taken in conjunction with the
studies of Gulick and Crampton on the snails of the Pacific
Islands. Baartsch has employed a genus (Cerion) of land
snails found in Florida, the Bahamas, Porto Rico and neigh-
boring islands. Several colonies of these have been trans-
planted to the Florida Keys, and while the plantings have
not in every case been successful, many have thrived and
after some years in their new home, the snails in some in-
stances have shown marked differences in size from the orig-
inal type. His results are as yet too incomplete to permit of
generalization however.
Out of all the haze of evolutionary theory do any facts loom
large against the background of the past? We may I think
safely say that evolution itself is such a fact ; that organisms
tend to vary for reasons in the main as yet obscure, but un-
doubtedly due in the last analysis to the influence of environ-
ment, either internal or external to the organism itself ; while
natural selection and isolation play an important, but sec-
ondary role, by preserving those variations which are fitted
to survive.
CHAPTER X
Experimental biology contimiect. Mendelism and the mul-
tiple factor hypothesis. Human inheritable and eugenics.
We have considered in a previous cliapter the physical basis
of inheritance and have seen that the manifold characters
of organisms are probably determined by certain entities in
the cell, which are shuffled about at the time of maturation
like the cards in a pack or dice in a box, and recombined in
fertilization so as to produce entirely new combinations of
characters in the offspring. In the present chapter we shall
consider the applications of these facts to inheritance in or-
ganisms in general and man in particular, with especial ref-
erence to eugenics or the improvement of the human race.
"While variation is the foundation of evolution, inheritance
may be likened to the keystone of its arch, without which*
permanence would be impossible. The truth of inheritance
has been recognized throughout the ages. Aristotle and other
early writers discuss it. ' ' Plutarch mentions a Greek woman
who gave birth to a negro child, and was brought to trial for
adultery, but it transpired that she was descended in the
fourth degree from an Ethiopian." ^
Many types of inheritance have been recognized in the past
(reversion, atavism, telegony, particulate, blending, etc.), but
modern research points strongly to a single method, modified
indeed by many factors, but nevertheless unifonn in its un-
derlying principle. So far at least as higher types of life
are concerned. When we come to the beginnings of life, to
the unicellular forms and the simpler metaphytes and
Metazoa, our knowledge is too limited to admit of anything
approaching generalization. In the unicellular forms the
mechanism of inheritance itself is evolving, and the type of
inheritance must therefore of necessity be indeterminate.
The essential feature of Mendelian inheritance is not the
dominance of one trait over another, but rather the persist-
ence of identical traits from generation to generation (un-
^Eibot, "Heredity," p. 167. T>. Appleton and Company. While
Plutarch's information was i)robably faulty, viewed in the light of
modern research, his statement nevertheless sliows the belief of his day
in the controlling influence of heredity in human life.
257
258
Biology in America
luodilird by oilier trails) in the make-up of the organism.
The basis of this persistence we liave already seen to bo the
chromosome. In those cases in which one character domi-
nates anotlier (tallness vs. dwarfness in peas, color vs. al-
binism in animals, etc.), we have the phenomenon known
as latency, in which the determiner of a character may be
passed along for several generations, without the character
itself coming to expression. In such cases the character is
definite and the individual is distinct in respect to its pos-
session. There is no uncertainty for example, as to whether
InHEKITANCE of COLOIi IN THE FoUR O'CLOCK
F], Fo, first and second generations. From Morgan, Stiirtcvtint, Mul-
ler and Bridges, "Mechanism of Mendclian Inheritance."
By permission of J. B. Lippincott Company.
a guinea pig is spotted or uniform in color, or a man's liair
is curly or straight. There are cases however in which the
organism is neither "fish, flesh, nor good red herring," or
speaking scientifically dominance is imperfect or incomplete.
The four o'clock (INlirabilis jalapa) has a white- and a red-
flowered race, which when crossed produce plants with pink
flowers. When these pink-fiowered plants however are bred
inter se they produce 1 red to 2 pink to 1 white offspring,
the firet and last classes of which breed true, while the mid-
dle class when inbred continues to "throw" red, white and
pink plants in the above ratio. A crude chemical analogy
to these phenomena may be made in the following way : At
Mendelism
259
ordinary temperatures chromic sulphate forms a violet-col-
ored solution in water, but at lower temperatures the salt
crystallizes out leaving the water colorless as before. A con-
centrated solution, deep violet in color, may be taken to rep-
resent the color of the red-flowered four o'clock, while water
may represent the color of the white-flowered variety. By
mixing the concentrated solution and water in equal quanti-
ties, a solution of light violet color is obtained, which may
represent the pink-flowered hybi-ids of tlie first generation.
If this dilute soliilion be now divided into four equal parts,
Inheritance in Andalusian Fowl
P„ parents; F^ and Fj, the first and second generation offspring of
the cross. From Morgan, "The Physical Basis of Heredity."
By permission of J. B. Lippincott Company.
to one of which a sufficient volume of salt be added to restore
the original color, while two are left unchanged and the fourth
is cooled, thereby separating the salt from the water and leav-
ing the latter colorless, a superficial analogy to the phenom-
ena of color inheritance in the four o 'clock is obtained. I say
''superficial" or "crude" analogy, because the physical proc-
ess outlined above is far too simple to represent the compli-
cated bio-chemical processes involved in that of inheritance.
One of the liest known cases of imperfect dominance is that
shown by Andalusian fowls, although as we shall see this
case is not strictly comparal)le to the preceding. The "blue"
Andalusian is a chicken in which black is mixed with white
260
Biology in America
in very small flecks. If two blue Andalusians are crossed
they produce one black, two blue, and one white splashed
with black ; while when the first and last of these offspring
are interbred, only "blue" fowls result — a Mendelian pro-
ceeding, which is strictly "according to Hoyle." Here we
have two factors, black and white, which instead of blending
in the cross enter into it unmodified, but distributed in such
a way as to produce a result different from that of either
parent. Furthermore, the ' ' recessives ' ' Tiere carry a little
of the "dominant" factor in the splashes of black on a white
background.
Inheritance of Ear Length in Eabbits
Figs. A and B, parents; C and D, offspring of the first and second
generations, respectively, with ear lengths intermediate between those
of the parents. From Castle, "Genetics and Eugenics."
By permission of Harvard University Press.
A closely similar case is that of red and white cattle, which,
when interbred, produce "roan" offspring, these latter in
their turn "throwing" red, roan and white in the proportion
of 1:2:1.
In some cases of supposedly complete dominance careful
measurements show that the dominant factor is slightly modi-
fied by the recessive. Thus when wild fruit flies are crossed
with those having small wings, the long wings of the for-
mer dominate the short wings of the latter ; but not com-
pletely, for the wings of the hybrid average slightly less
than those of the wild parent. And this gives rise to the ques-
tion whether dominance is ever perfect, even in those cases in
Mendetism
261
which it appears to be so. The fundamental fact in Men-
delian inheritance then is segregation, not dominance.
In the cases just cited segregation is perfectly evident in the
second generation, but there are cases in which it is not.
There is a breed of domestic rabbit known as the "lop-
eared" rabbit in which the ears are very long and pendant.
When such a rabbit is paired with the ordinary kind, the
ears of the hybrid are intermediate in length, and this condi-
tion persists in succeeding generations. Is this not a true
3
J3
Inheritance in Guinea Pigs
Figs. A and B, the parents; C, the first generation, the second gener-
tion containing animals of all four types, A, B, C and D. From Castle,
' ' Genetics and Eugenics. ' '
By permission of Harvard University Press.
"blend" between different degrees of ear length? The mu-
latto is another example of an apparent blending of charac-
ters in inheritance. Is a different interpretation possible?
There are certain varieties of corn with yellow kernels,
which when crossed with white corn give yellow offspring.
These latter, when mated with each other, give, instead of
the usual Mendelian ratio of 3 :1, fifteen yellows to one white.
This is exactly what we should expect if there were two char-
acters involved in producing the color of the yellow variety,
for when two pairs of factors are involved in a cross — i.e.,
tall, red peas x dwarf whites; long-winged, gray fruit files x
black, dwarf -winged ; black, rough ("rosette") haired guinea
B
b
B
BB
Bb
b
Bb
bb
BP
Br
bR
br
Bf?
BR
BR
Bp
BR
bR
BR
br
BR
Br
Bfr
Br
Br
Br
bR
Br
br
Br
bR
BR
bR
Br
bR
bR
bR
br
bR
br
BR
br
Br
br
bR
br
br
br
BRS
BR3
BrS
Brs
bRS
bRs
brS
brs
BRS
BRS
BRs
BRS
BrS
BRS
Brs
BRS
bRS
BRS
bRs
BRS
brS
BRS
brs
BRS
BR5
BRS
BRs
BRs
BR5
BrS
BRs
Brs
BRs
bRS
BRs
bRs
BRs
brS
BRs
brs
BR«
BrS
BRS
BrS
BRs
BrS
BrS
BrS
Brs
3r5
bR5
BrS
bRs
BrS
brS
BrS
brs
BrS
Brs
BRS
Brs
BRs
Brs
BrS
3rs
Brs
Brs
bRS
Brs
bRs
brS
Brs
brs
Brs
bRS
BRS
bRS
BRs
bRS
BrS
bRS
Brs
bRS
bRS
bRS
bRs
bRS
brS
bRS
brs
bRS
bf?s
BRS
bRs
BRs
bRs
BrS
bRs
Brs
bRs
bRS
bRs
bRs
bRs
brS
bRs
brs
bRs
brS
BRS
brS
BRs
brS
&r5
brS
Brs
brS
bRS
brS
bRs
brS
brS
brS
brs
brS
br5
BRS
brs
BRs
brs
BrS
brs
Brs
brs
bRS
brs
bRs
brs
brS
brs
brs
brs
Diagrams Illusteating Inheritance in Guinea Pigs
Of one, two and three pairs of characters respectively. B=black,
b = white, R = rough coat, r = smooth coat, S = short hair, and s =
long hair. The second generation results are, respectively, 3 black, 1
white; 9 black-rough, 3 black-smooth, 3 white-rough, 1 white-smooth;
and 27 black-rough-sliort, 9 black-rough-long, 9 black-smooth-short, 9
white-rough-short, 3 black-smooth-long, 3 white-smooth-short, 3 white-
rough-long, and 1 whitesmooth-long, which result from the summation
of the combinations in the above diagrams.
262
Mendelism 263
pigs X albino, smooth-haired; dark, curly x light, straight
hair in man, etc., there is only one out of sixteen offspring
in the second generation in which both of the recessive factore
come to expression. Thus in the case of black rough x white
smooth hair in guinea pigs, only one in sixteen second gen-
eration offspring will be white with smooth hair. This re-
sult follows as a mathematical necessity of the chance com-
bination of two pairs of characters, just as the 3 :1 ratio re-
sults from the combination of one pair. Similarly if three
pairs of characters are involved in a cross, i.e., black, rough,
short and white, smooth, long hair in guinea pigs, there will
be only one out of sixty-four offspring in the second genera-
tion, which will show all three recessive characters. And if
four pairs are involved, only 1 in 25G, etc. A graphical rep-
resentation of these results is given in the accompanying dia-
grams, which make sufficiently clear the chance combination
of characters in Mendelian inheritance.
That two factors may be involved in the production of an
apparently simple character is conclusively shown in the case
of the sweet peas described by the English naturalist, Bate-
son. Bateson found that when two white peas were crossed
they produced colored offspring, which he interpreted as due
to the presence of two factors, one in each of the white par-
ents, which, uniting in the cross, produced a colored pea.
The results obtained by inbreeding these colored offspring,
details of which need not figure here, showed clearly that two
pairs of Mendelian factors were concerned. In the case of
the corn cited above a single factor for yellow produces the
same apparent result in the first generation, as do two fac-
tors, but in a variety of oats described by the Swedish breeder
Nilsson-Ehle, a different result is obtained. In this case a
variety of oats characterized by dark brown glumes or husks,
when crossed with a white-glumed variety produced in the
second generation nine plants with dark brown, six with light
brown, and one with white glumes. This result may be ex-
plained as due to the presence of two factors for brown in
the dark-glumed plants, one only in those wath light brown
glumes and none in those with white glumes. It is obtained
in the same way as in the second diagram, two factors for
brown being substituted for black, rough.
The theory that two or more factors may in some cases com-
bine to produce an apparently simple result is known as the
"multiple factor" hypothesis. In the case of lop-ear in rab-
bits and color in man, the results are readily explicable by
means of this hypothesis on the assumption (1) that several
factors are involved in the production of the character in
question, (2) that in order to produce the maximum result
2G4 Biology in America
the full number must be present, and (3) as a corollary to
(2) if less than the full number are present the result will
be more or less intermediate or "blending" between the
maximum of the character and its total absence. Thus, let
us assume with Davenport that the African negro contains
four factors for blackness, while the white man has none.
Two factors produce a "mulatto," one a "quadroon," and
three a "sambo," while the "octoroon" and the "near-
white" resemble the pure white, so far at least as skin color
is concerned. The offspring of a cross between a full black
and a white will be a mulatto containing two factors for
black. If the latter marry a white the offspring will be of
three classes, 1 mulatto, 2 quadroons and 1 " near- white. " A
cross between two mulattoes will result in 1 black, 4 sambos,
6 mulattoes, 4 quadroons and 1 "near-white," a result readily
derived from the second diagram on page 262 if for the domi-
nant factors we substitute the factors for negro color BB.
Thus the chance of either original color (black or white) ap-
pearing in the second generation is only 1 :16, Avhile there are
14 chances of an intermediate or "blending" color appearing.
If more than four factors are involved, the chance of either of
the original characters reappearing in the second generation of
a cross will be correspondingly lessened. Thus if six factors
(3 pairs) are involved the chance will be 1 :64, with 8 fac-
tors (4 pairs) 1:256, with 10 factors (5 pairs) 1:1024 and
with 12 factors (6 pairs) only 1:4096. Such an hypothesis
readily explains on a Mendelian basis the case of the lop-
eared rabbit if we assume the necessity of several factors in
the production of a superficially simple, but fundamentally
complex result.
An interesting corollary of Davenport's main thesis,
founded on a study of more than a hundred negro-white fam-
ilies in Jamaica, Bermuda and Louisiana, is the overthrow, or
at least serious weakening of the popular belief that a mar-
riage of two "near-whites" may result in children of negro
color. His results indicate that the offspring of a cross be-
tween persons of negro ancestry, can in no event have
more than the sum of the factors for black of the two
parents; so that the children of two "near- white" parents
can never produce other than w^iite children, while a near-
white and a quadroon can at most have only quadroon
children.
The basis of Mendelian inheritance is, as we have seen, the
chance combination in calculable proportions of definite char-
acters, which are segregable from one another, and do not
form permanent "blends." How well do the calculated or
Mendelism 265
"expected" results agree with those actually obtained in
breeding experiments? Obviously the larger the number of
individuals the greater the probability of agreement between
expectation and realization, and when the former is small,
say 1 :64 or 256, a very large number of tests may be neces-
sary before it can be realized. While the correspondence be-
tween expectation and realization is seldom exact, the agree-
ment is nevertheless generally close enough to furnish a sub-
stantial basis for the theory. A few random examples may
be cited. In the common weed, the shepherd's purse (Bursa
bursa-pastoris) there is a variety with round and another
with triangular fruits. The latter dominates the former and
is determined by two factors. Therefore the expectation for
round vs. triangular fruits is 1 in 16. In a total of 2907 sec-
ond generation hybrids Shull found 2782 with triangular and
125 with round fruits, a ratio of 23.3 to 1, as compared with
an expectation of 2725 of the former and 182 of the latter, a
ratio of 16 to 1. In crosses between quadroons and whites
Davenport found out of 99 children there were 42 "near-
whites," 56 quadroons and 1 mulatto, whereas the expectation
was an equal number of "near-whites" and quadroons and
no mulattoes. In another series of matings between quadroons
he found out of a total of 134 children, 24 "near-whites,"
87 quadroons and 23 mulattoes, the expectation being 3.5, 67
and 33.5 respectively.
Any rabbit breeder knows what a mixture of colors and
markings he may expect in his product. Professor Castle,
who has recently analyzed the color varieties of rabbits, clas-
sifies them as follows: gray, black, yellow (with white belly
and tail), sooty (a variety of yellow with the belly and tail
colored like the rest of the body), and white. The first four
of these may in turn be modified by intensity of pigment (dark
or light), by its uniformity, or lack of uniformity (spotting),
and the white may be either wholly so or cream colored with
black nose, ears, feet and tail (the so-called "Himalayan"
of the fanciers). This makes a total of eighteen varieties
in all, which when interbred can theoretically produce 243
different varieties, different, that is, from the viewpoint of
their hereditary structure, not in their external appearance,
for things "are (very often) not what they seem" in genetics.
Many of these varieties have been obtained, others still re-
main to be "created." There are thirty-two possibilities in
gray rabbits, many of which are already known. As a com-
parison of the results realized with those expected when one
variety of these grays is crossed with itself, the following
table from Professor Castle 's paper is of interest :
266 Biology in America
Color Observed Expected
Gray 24 27
Black 8 9
Yellow 16 9
Sooty 2 9
Blue-gray 8 3
]31ue 2 3
Cream 3 3
Pale sooty 2 1
Another cross between two grays of a different sort gave
the following results as compared with those to be expected:
Color Observed Expected
Gray 20 27
Black 8 9
Yellow 12 9
Sooty 1 3
Blue-gray 7 9
Blue 4 3
Cream (?) 3
Pale sooty 1 1
White 8 21
"The categoiy yellow is probably too large because of a
failure on our part to discriminate between yellow and cream,
a difference which at first we failed to record. It is possible
also that albino young were not enumerated in all the rec-
ords which we have combined, and so albinos are apparently
deficient in number. "2
What is the new science of genetics doing for the world in
a practical way? It is scarcely necessary to suggest that a
knowledge of inheritance is fundamental to the practice of
breeding animals and plants. But the new genetics is scarce
two decades old, while during the preceding centuries man
has produced the wonderful diversity in domesticated varie-
ties which we know today. Has all this earlier improvement
been due to chance alone? Is the scientific breeder a prod-
uct of the last twenty years? Hardly, for we are using
today the same principle of selection which has been the
magic wand of the breeder in the past. But to this prin-
ciple has been added more accurate knowledge of kinds of
variation and the laws of their inheritance, so that today the
breeder can work more surely and swiftly than his predeces-
sor in the past.
='(;:istlo " Inhoritaiicc in TJabliils," Ciriiegie TiistitutioTi, Publica-
tion No. 114, p. 5'J.
Mendelism
267
A few examples of what breeders have accomplished may
be of interest. Professor Castle has shown that there is in
guinea pigs a factor which restricts black and brown pigment
to the eyes, while yellow pigment is unaffected by it. When
a brown pig is crossed with a black-eyed yellow one con-
taining this factor, some of the offspring receive it in com-
bination with the factor for brown and are consequently
brown-eyed yellow — a new "creation" unknown before Cas-
tle's experiments were made. "While brown-eyed yellow
A Herd of Hornless Cattle
Hornlessness may be bred in cattle by proper attention to Mendelian
laws.
Courtesy of the U. 8. Bureau of Animal Industry.
guinea pigs may not mean any more to the fancier in dol-
lars and cents than do black-eyed yellow ones, nevertheless
the experiment demonstrates the possibility of scientific
breeding in the production of varieties which do have eco-
nomic value.
The presence of horns on a vicious bull, or a refractory
cow, has always constituted a serious menace to tlie owner's
peace of mind, and often such animals have to be dehorned.
But the breeder has a better means for dehorning his stock,
for lack of horns in cattle is dominant to the horned condi-
tion, and by crossing horned cattle with hornless ones of other
268 Biology in America
breeds it is possible to produce hornless cattle in breeds which
are usually horned.
The "upland" cotton of the South has a short fiber which
is worth much less than the long fiber of the "sea island"
variety. The former however is a much better bearer than
the latter, and has a pod which opens widely, rendering the
cotton more easy to pick, while the latter is more easily ginned,
tlie fibres not adhering so tightly to the seeds. By crossing
"upland" and "sea island" plants, the U. S. Department of
Agriculture has produced a prolific race of "sea island"
cotton, with wide-opening bolls, thereby adding hundreds of
thousands, if not millions of dollars annually to the value
of the cotton crop in the United States.
We are all familiar with the frequent alarms that come
from Florida to the effect that the orange crop is a failure
due to some recent freeze. And we can never be quite sure
whether the freeze is genuine, or faked for the purpose of
making us pay a premium for Florida's delicious fruit. Oft-
times however the danger to the orange grower is very real,
and many a sleepless night he spends tending the bonfires in
his groves to save his crop from ruin. And so the plant
breeder has come to his rescue and by crossing the hardy,
frost-resistant orange of Japan with the Florida orange, has
produced a fruit known as the citrange with many of the
good qualities of the orange and yet capable of resisting a
temperature as low as 8°F.
These instances might be multiplied many-fold, but they
must suffice as a suggestion merely of the possibilities open
to the scientific breeder of the future.
But in no direction has Mendelism better served than in the
development of the new science of eugenics, concerning which
we hear so much today, both of fact and fancy. The germ
of the eugenic idea is contained in the witticism of Oliver
Wendell Holmes, who, when asked for advice on how to reach
a good old age, replied that the best way was to select long-
lived grandparents.
It is indeed true that, as Kimball says in his fascinating
essays on the "Romance of Evolution": "The scientific way
of selecting a wife and falling in love, going first to a phrenol-
ogist and getting a chart of her skull with all its bumps, com-
bativeness, destructiveness and the like marked upon it, then
to the physiologist to find out whether her temperament is
bilious or phlegmatic, then to the family physician to make
sure she is free from scrofula and consumption and then to
the woman herself to exchange, not vows but charts and cer-
tificates, is not certainly on the face of it quite so romantic
as where Arthur and Amelia fall in love with each other at
Mendelism 269
first sight, and after the requisite number of haunted castles,
diabolic rivals and cruel partings rush exactly at the end of
the second volume ecstatic into each other's arms. But this
destructive and prosaic side of science is only its beginning,
only the clearing away of the old rubbish to lay the founda-
tion of a nobler and fairer structure. Its first object is in-
deed truth, truth whatever the ugliness and humility of its
outlines may be. But truth and beauty in their final result
are always sure to blend together and always nourish and
require in those who follow them to the end something at
least of their own grand and heroic qualities. Truth here,
the same as elsewhere, is found to be stranger than fiction,
the world effect, however prosaic its surface may be, to have
roots which go down to infinite depths of mystery. And sci-
entific discovery dealing with these truths and facts has come
already to a revelation, lit up the world too with a light, that
for romance and wonder surpasses all that was ever seen or
dreamed of in the grandest days of old. ' ' ^
We speak of eugenics as new and yet as a matter of fact
the eugenic idea dates back to the time of Plato, who advo-
cated in his republic the building of a better state by the
elimination of the unfit, and who urged the appointment of a
state official for this purpose. Since Plato's day many vi-
sionary schemes have been suggested for the improvement
of the human race, but the modern movement is due to the
great English geneticist. Sir Francis Galton, who, in his
"Hereditary Genius" published in 1869, pointed out the
desirability of improving the human race. His suggestions
fell upon stony ground, but with the confidence bred of con-
viction he returned undaunted to the struggle, and the out-
come of his efi^orts was the establishment of the Eugenics
Laboratory of the University of London in 1905, which under
the direction of Karl Pearson is collecting data on human
inheritance, and publishing them in its "Treasury of Hu-
man Inheritance. ' '
In America the movement for race betterment has been
largely in the hands of the Eugenics Section of the Amer-
ican Breeders' Association and the Eugenics Laboratory, a
brief account of the work of which latter institution has
been given in the chapter on American Biological Insti-
tutions.
In the following pages we shall consider briefly a few
examples of human inheritance, both mental and physical,
and the burden of the unfit which society has to bear, to-
gether with an outline of what the practical eugenist pro-
^ Kimball, "The Eomance of Evolution," pp. 3-4. American Uni-
tarian Association.
270 Biology in America
poses for the amelioration of social ills and the building of
a better Iminan race. The cases of the Jukes and the Kal-
likaks on the one hand, and the family of Jonathan Edwards
on the other, are classics and have been cited so widely as
to require no repetition here. An equally instructive case is
that cited by Goddard from his studies of the inmates of the
New Jersey Training School for the Feeble-minded. The his-
tory of this case is described by Goddard in the following
words: "Here we have a feeble-minded woman who has had
three husbands (including one 'who was not her husband'),
and the result has been nothing but feeble-minded children.
The stoiy may be told as follows:
"This w'oman was a handsome girl, apparently having in-
herited some refinement from her mother, although her father
was a feeble-minded, alcoholic brute. Somewhere about the
age of seventeen or eighteen she went out to do housework
in a family in one of the towns of this State (New Jersey).
She soon became the mother of an illegitimate child. It was
born in an almshouse to which she fled after she had been
discharged from the home where she had been at work.
After this, charitably disposed people tried to do what they
could for her, giving her a home for herself and her child
in return for the work which she could do. However she soon
appeared in the same condition. An effort was then made
to discover the father of this second child, and when he was
found to be a drunken, feeble-minded epileptic living in the
neighborhood, in order to save the legitimacy of the child,
her friends (sic) saw to it that a marriage ceremony took
place. Later another feeble-minded child was born to them.
Then the whole family secured a home with an unmarried
farmer in the neighborhood. They lived there together until
another child was forthcoming which the husband refused
to own. When finally the farmer acknowledged this child
to be his, the same good friends (sic) interfered, went into
the courts and procured a divorce from the husband, and
had the woman married to the father of the expected fourth
child. This proved to be feeble-minded, and they have had
four other feeble-minded children, making eight in all, born
of this woman. There have also been one child stillborn and
one miscarriage.
"... This woman had four feeble-minded brothers and
sisters. These are all married and have children. The older
of the two sisters had a child by her own father, when she
was thirteen years old. The child died at about six years
of age. This woman has since married. The two brothers
have each at least one child of whose mental condition noth-
ing is known. The other sister married a feeble-minded man
Mendel ism 27 1
and had three children. Two of these are feeble-minded and
the other died in infancy. . . ,"*
Not alone in her descendants, but also in her ancestry and
collateral relatives does this woman illustrate the influence
of defective germ plasm in a family. Of twenty-seven chil-
dren, one or both of whose parents were feeble-minded, twen-
ty-four showed the defect, the character of the other three
being unknown.
The following eases cited by Davenport are further exam-
ples of the blight which defective inheritance so often casts
upon a human life.
This case "is an eleven year old boy who began to steal at
3 years; at 4 set fire to a pantry resulting in an explosion
that caused his mother 's death ; and at 8 set fire to a mattress.
He is physically sound, able and well informed, polite, gen-
tlemanly and very smooth, but he is an inveterate thief and
has a court record. His older brother, 14, has been full of
deviltry, has stolen and set fires but is now settled down and
is earning a living. Their father is an unusually fine,
thoughtful intelligent man, a grocer, for a time sang on the
vaudeville stage ; his mother, who died at 32, is said to have
been a normal woman of excellent character. There is how-
ever a taint on both sides. The father's father was wild
and drank when young and had a brother w^ha was an in-
veterate thief. The mother's father was alcoholic and when
drunk mean and vicious. Some of the mother's brothers stole
or were sexually immoral,
"A healthy man employed on a railroad as a fireman and
using neither alcohol nor tobacco married a woman who was
born in the mountains of West Virginia near the Kentucky
line and who shows many symptoms of defectiveness. She
has epileptic convulsions as often as two or three times a
week, has an ungovernable temper, smokes, chews and drinks,
is illiterate and sexually immoral. There are 10 children, of
whom something is known about seven. One died early of
chorea, one of the others seems normal ; one has killed two
men including a policeman; another had her husband killed
and lives with the slayer; one was an epileptic and cigarette
fiend, convicted of assault ; another has hysterical convulsions
and is afraid in sleep ; while still another has migraine. The
combination in the fraternity of migraine, chorea, hysteria,
epilepsy and sexual immorality and tendency to assault is
striking and appalling.
"A 10 year old boy who was precocious as a raconteur at
22 months, does well at school except for inattention ; is fond
of reading and athletics, cheerful, and polite. But he prefers
* '"'American Breeders Magazine," Vol. I, pp. 176-8.
272 Binlor/jf in Amrrica
the companionship of okler, wild boys and cannot be weaned
from thom. lie lies, iniiis up accounts in his parents' name,
is acquiring bad sexual habits, and runs away from home.
lie has two, fine, studious brothers. His father is a strong
character and a successful lawyer, his mother an excellent
woman, intelligent and firm. She has a brother who left
home at 14 to seek a life of adventure. He finally settled
down to a steady life. Their father's father was erratic.
He loved Indian outdoor life, always used an Indian blanket
and at over 70 years swam the IMississippi River. He traced
back his ancestry to Pocahontas. He has another grandson,
who is an unruly character with a roving disposition ; he
joined the navy and his whereabouts are unknown ; his father
was a lawyer and a fine character.
"An intelligent physician with training abroad as well as
in this country and of a good family (his brother is a college
professor and his father a Methodist preacher) married a lady
of good family, with much musical talent, but subject to
migraine and formerly to chorea. They have two sons born
in the best of environments. The younger is still in the
kindergarten, seems wholly normal, truth-telling and lovable ;
the other, now 13, developed normally, has had no convulsions,
and lias never been seriously sick and ordinarily sleeps well.
He has regular, refined features and a normal alert attitude
and is very industrious. He attends Sunday school regu-
larly, has excellent talent for music. At 3 years of age he
walked to a nearby railroad, boarded a train and was carried
12 miles before the conductor discovered him; since then he
has run away very many times. From an institution for
difficult boys, where he was placed, he ran away 13 times.
He escapes from his home after dark and sleeps in neighbor-
ing doorways. His mother used to make Saturday a treat
day. She would take a violin lesson with him and spend
the afternoon in the Public Library which he much enjoyed
but he would slip away from her on the way home and be
gone until midnight. He is an unconscionable liar. He con-
tracts debts, steals when he has no use for the articles stolen
and has been convicted for burglary. Much money and
effort have been spent on him in vain. His mother's father
(of whom he has never heard) was a western desperado, drank
hard and was involved in a murder, but finally married a very
good woman, and has 2 normal daughters in addition to this
boy's mother." ^
As examples of the inheritance of physical defects may be
cited that of deaf -mutism, hare lip and cleft palate, imperfect
"Davenport, "Heredity in Kelation to Eugenics," pp. 85-90. Bj per-
mission of Henry Holt and Company.
Mendelism 273
clotting of the blood resulting in the persistent bleeding of
wounds, cretinism or infantile imbecility and dwarfism, and
many others.
But the picture has also a brighter side, for physical and
mental ability are inherited just as surely as are their oppo-
sites. The families of the Edwards, the Lees, the Corbins
and the Fitzhughs have put the stamp of beauty and of
strength upon the face of America. The family of the great
musician Bach included twenty eminent musicians, and twice
as many of lesser eminence.
Macaulay's father and grandfather, two uncles, a cousin
and a nephew were all noted writers. The records of the
Pomeroy family date back to 1630. "The first of the family
in America was Eltweed Pomeroy at Dorchester . . . and
later at Windsor, Connecticut. He was by trade a black-
smith, which in those days comprehended practically all
mechanical trades. His sons and grandsons, with few excep-
tions, followed this trade. 'In the settlement of new towns
in Massachusetts and Connecticut the Pomeroys were welcome
artisans. Large grants of land were awarded to them to
induce them to settle and carry on their business. ' ' The pecu-
liar faculty of the Pomeroys is not the result of training and
hardly of perceptible voluntary effort in the individual.
Their powers are due to an inherited capacity from ancestry
more or less remote, developed for generations under some
unconscious cerebration.' There was Setli Pomeroy (1706-
1777) an ingenious and skillful mechanic who followed the
trade of gunsmith. At the capture of Louisburg in 1745 he
was a major and had charge of more than twenty smiths who
were engaged in drilling captured cannon. Other members
of the family manufactured guns which in the French and
Indian wars were in great demand and in the Revolution,
also, the Pomeroy guns were indispensable. 'Long before the
United States had a national armory, the private armories
of the Pomeroys were famous. There was Lemuel Pomeroy,
the pioneer manufacturer of Pittsburg, stubborn but clear-
headed, of whom a friend said : ' There would at times be no
living with him if he were not always right. ' There was also
Elisha M. Pomeroy of Wallingford, a tinner by trade. He
invented the razor strop and profited much by its success.
In the sixth generation we find Benjamin Pomeroy a suc-
cessful lawyer entrusted with important public offices. 'But
he was conscious of powers for which his law practice gave
him no scope. He had a taste for mechanical execution
and as a pastime between his professional duties undertook
the construction of difficult public works — the more difficult
the better he liked them. The chief of the United States
274 Biology in America
Topogiaphit'al Engineers was a friend of Mr. Pomeroy and
repeatedly eonsnlted liim in emei'gencies wlierein his extraor-
dinary capacity was made useful to the government. By
him were constructed on the Atlantic coast beacons and
various structures in circumstances tliat had baffled previous
attempts.' The value to this country of the mechanical trait
in this one germ plasm can hardly be estimated. Especially
is it to be noted that, despite constant out-marriages, it goes
its course unreduced and unmodified through the genera-
tions. ""^
Well, what is the eugenist "going to do about it?" In
the first place gather data upon which to base a constructive
program. While our knowledge of inheritance in plants and
animals has grown by leaps and bounds in the past twenty
years, and data concerning human inheritance are accumulat-
ing rapidly, the science of genetics, and especially eugenics
is yet in its infancy. Our knowledge of human inheritance
is still very fragmentary; comparatively few characters have
yet been studied, and these by no means exhaustively. Recog-
nizing information as the primary need of the social student of
today, the Eugenics Laboratory in London and the Eugenics
Record Office at Cold Spring Harbor are devoting their
energies chiefly to a study of the laws of human inheritance,
with the ultimate view of formulating from those laws a con-
structive program of eugenics, supported by a public opinion,
alive on the one hand to the menace, and on the other to the
splendid possibilities of human inheritance.
But while gathering more information are we to sit idle
and not use the information which we have? What can we
"do about it" now? First of all, we need more sanity and
less self-confidence, more cool calculation and less hot enthu-
siasm. The advocates of the "rabbit theory" of society, who
cry out from the house-tops against the suicide of the race,
should realize that propagation is as dangerous as propaganda
if the subjects thereof are unworthy or unfit. On the other
hand, the advocates of "birth control" should not forget that
"a little knowledge is a dangerous thing" and that knowledge
of this practise by the selfish, the ignorant or the unwise might
prove to be a match in the hands of a child.
The fundamental principle of eugenics is the promotion of
a better race by the marriage of the fit, and the elimination
of the undesirable members of society by the prevention of
their increase. But in a matter of so highly personal a nature
as marriage, where personal tastes and emotions play so large
a part, how is anything like scientific control possible? The
only answer is that it is not possible, nor desirable. If men
' Davenport, locus citatus, pp. 55-57.
Mendelism 275
and women chose their partners as they choose a pet dog
or a suit of clothes, the divorce courts would have to work
overtime. But on the other hand no one has the right to
insure his own temporary happiness at the risk of the misery
of those who are to follow him. And here is where eugenics
has its major role to play — namely, in the education of the
youth as to the inflexibility of inheritance, the methods of its
operation, and their duty to generations yet unborn.
The rights of the individual form one of the corner stones
of a democracy, while those of society, or the group of indi-
viduals, form the other. In so far as the former does not
conflict with the latter it must be fully insured or democracy
becomes an empty name, but no man has a right to personal
freedom when that freedom encroaches upon the welfare of
society, and one of the functions of eugenics is to preserve
that welfare by preventing the increase of the feeble-minded,
the alcoholic, the sexually immoral and the diseased — or in
general, the unfit. The simplest and safest way in fact, is
sterilization. This can be accomplished by a very simple and
harmless operation in man, requiring only a few minutes of
time and the use of a local anesthetic. In woman it is a more
serious operation, but in neither case, if carefully performed,
is it dangerous or productive of evil after-effects. Needless
to say, the practise of sterilization should be surrounded by
every precaution to protect the rights of the individual, and
should not be practised except by expert and responsible sur-
geons. Thus far eleven states have sterilization laws, though
but few operations under these laws have as yet been per-
formed. In some instances individuals have voluntarily sub-
mitted themselves to the operation.
The first of these to be adopted was the Indiana law, which
is here quoted: "An Act, entitled, An act to prevent pro-
creation of criminals, idiots, imbeciles, and rapists — providing
that superintendents, or boards of managers, of institutions
where such persons are confined shall have the authority,
and are empowered to appoint a committee of experts, con-
sisting of two physicians, to examine into the mental condi-
tion of such inmates.
"Whereas, Heredity plays a most important part in the
transmission of crime, idiocy, and imbecility;
"Therefore, Be it enacted by the General Assembly of the
State of Indiana, That on and after the passage of this act
it shall be compulsory for each and every institution in the
State, entrusted with the care of confirmed criminals, idiots,
rapists and imbeciles, to appoint upon its staff, in addition to
the regular institutional physician, two (2) skilled surgeons
of recognized ability, whose duty it shall be, in conjunction
276 Biology in America
with the chief physician of the institution, to examine the
mental and physical condition of such inmates as are recom-
mended by the institutional physician and board of managers.
If, in the judgment of this committee of experts and the
board of managers, procreation is inadvisable, and there is
no probability of improvement of the mental and physical
condition of the inmate, it shall be lawful for the surgeons
to perform such operation for the prevention of procreation
as shall be decided safest, and most etfective. But this opera-
tion shall not be performed except in cases that have been
pronounced unimprovable: Provided, That in no case shall
the consultation fee be more than three (3) dollars to each
expert, to be paid out of the funds appropriated for the
maintenance of such institution. ' '
The question of elimination of defectives, by preventing
their procreation, leads to the delicate one of elimination of
human misery by taking the life of children, so hopelessly
deformed or diseased, that they can never by any possible
chance be anything but sources of suffering to themselves,
and of unhappiness to their friends. The practise of destroy-
ing those infants considered unlikely to develop into vigorous
men, and good soldiers is well known as the policy of Sparta
in ancient Greece, and among savages infanticide has some-
times been practised for a similar reason. In India the kill-
ing of girl babies to save them the dishonor of remaining
unmarried or of marrying below their caste, as well as to
avoid the excessive expense incident to marriage ceremonies,
was prevalent among many tribes previous to the middle of
the last century, when it was terminated by the British Gov-
ernment. Among civilized peoples infanticide is generally
regarded as a crime equal to, or but slightly less than murder.
Abortion, unless practised to save the life or health of the
mother, is criminal, though of a much lower degree than
infanticide. The logic of a distinction between a foetus a
few days before birth and a baby a few days after, is some-
what difficult however to appreciate.
The reverence for human life has even extended to the dead
body, so that in the early days of anatomy, cadavers for dis-
section could only be obtained by devious means.
The sacredness in which we hold life has led us to take
every means for its preservation, even to abolition in many
states and foreign countries of capital punishment, the forcible
restraint of attempted suicides, and the most careful nurture
of helpless cripples and hopeless idiots. Because of our
reverence for human life we sometimes practise the most
refined cruelty to those we love the best, a cruelty we would'
not tolerate for a moment if practised upon the dumb brute.
Mendelism 277
It was therefore with a feeling akin to horror that many-
read in the public press in 1915 of the action of Dr. Haiselden
of Chicago; who, with the consent of the child's parents,
refused to perform an operation which would have saved to
a life of suffering, an infant, which by his refusal was allowed
to die. This question however is not one of eugenics proper,
although closely related thereto. But it is one which the
thoughtful student of human life will do well to ponder
carefully.
And yet a final duty of the eugenist is to combat those
anti-social measures which put a premium on celibacy, and
a discount on parenthood, such as the payment of non-living
wages to workmen, the industrialization of women, the
penalization of teachers for marriage or motherhood. A for-
ward step in the right direction has been the payment by many
states of mothers' pensions, while further action should be
taken to relieve the mother during the early months of
maternity from the necessity of bread winning.
We have come already a long way in the paths of social
righteousness, but the way is never-ending and the forces of
selfishness, reaction and ignorance beset us on every hand,
so that it behooves us to gird up our loins in order that we,
like Paul, may ' ' run with patience the race that is set before
us."
CHAPTER XI
Experimental biology continued. Mechcmisni versus vitalism.
Physico-chcmistnj of vital processes, metalolism of ani-
mals and plants.
Is tliere one law for the living and another for the dead,
or is tlie universe a unit in its working and all matter gov-
erned by universal law? The former is the contention of the
"vitalist," the latter of the "mechanist." What is life?
Is it some inscrutable process, controlled by a "vital prin-
ciple" operating outside the realm of physics and of chem-
istry ? Or is it merely a special expression of the forces which
control inorganic matter? Our only answer to these ques-
tions is that we do not know. Neither the substance nor the
energ}' of life has ever been analyzed, and the only way in
which we can identify life is by its manifestations. What
are these manifestations, and what light if any do they throw
upon the ultimate nature of life itself?
Firstly, what is the stuff of which living things are made?
An analysis of living substances or protoplasm is exceedingly
difficult if not impossible. In order to analyze it, it must be
killed, and the readiness with which protoplasm breaks down
into innumerable simpler substances leads us to suspect that
after protoplasm is killed it is protoplasm no longer, so that
we are analyzing not protoplasm at all, but something else.
Our analyses are sufficient to show us however that proto-
plasm contains the same elements of which inorganic matter
is composed, united into a marvellously complex whole. All
life is "of the dust, and turn(s) to dust again." The mani-
fold varieties of life which we know lead us to believe in as
groat a variety of protoplasm which determines this variability
in living things. In spite of its variability however all proto-
plasm alike contains protein consisting of carbon, hydrogen,
nitrogen, oxygen and sulphur, without which it cannot exist.
Protein however is founcl outside of protoplasm in egg albu-
men for example and in the various albumens and globulins
of the blood. These substances while protoplasmic products
are not protoplasm itself ; hence we see that in its composition
at least living matter does not differ fundamentally from non-
living, since both contain the same materials.
278
The Living Machine
279
One of the most characteristic features of life is its power
of waste and repair and growth. It is folly to attempt, as
some have done, to compare these processes in their entirety
with any process in the non-living world. There is nothing
with which they can be compared. And yet if we analyze
them into their component processes, we find that they are
composed of a series of chemical and physical reactions, many
of which at least can be exactly reproduced in the laboratory.
In the warm spring days when the remnants of last j'car's
crop of potatoes in the cellar start to sprout, and those wliieh
are served upon your table have an unpleasant sweetish taste,
you are the victim of a ferment known as diastase, of wide-
Diagram illustrating osmosis through an egg membrane. Original.
spread if not universal distribution among plants, which
changes starch, the stored-up food stuff of the plant, into
one of the sugars. When the maple sugar sap is flowing in
the spring we know that a similar action has been taking
place within the tree, and all the beauty of the young spring's
growth depends upon it. A similar action takes place in our
own stomach, under the influence of an animal ferment known
as ptyalin, and present in the saliva of many mammals. But
a similar result can also be obtained in the test tube of the
chemist by boiling starch in dilute acid.
In order that the water of the soil with its dissolved salts
may enter the root, or the digested food stuffs in the intestine
pass into the streams of blood and lymph, the process of os-
280 Biology in America
mosis, or the passage of solutions through membranes must
occur. But if the shell be chipped off from both ends of a
hen's egg, the shell membranes being left intact at one end,
and the yolk and white removed from the other, into which a
glass tube is sealed Avith a few drops of sealing wax; and if
now the egg be filled with a solution of sugar, and then im-
mersed in water, until the water is at the same level with the
solution in the tube, the latter will soon be seen to rise due to
the passage of water through the egg membrane into tlie sugar
solution; while more slowly the sugar will ditt'use in the re-
verse direction. Here we see in non-living matter the same
phenomenon of osmosis, which is so fundamental a factor in
all living processes.
In the exchange of materials between the cell and its
environment, its membrane determines what substances shall
enter and leave the cell. Thus an uninjured beet may be
placed in water without losing any of its color. But cut
the beet and its color readily diffuses outward. So in the
absorption by roots of substances from the soil and by the
walls of the intestine from the digested food stuffs, the cell
membrane exercises what is known as "selective absorption,"
taking some and rejecting others. In the passage of sub-
stances between mother and child, through the walls of the
placenta, the cells of the latter exercise a selective function,
allowing food materials and oxygen to pass from mother to
child, and waste materials to pass in the reverse direction.
This selective activity of living membranes is strikingly
shown by experiments on barley seeds, which are not killed
by sulphuric acid because it cannot penetrate them, but are
destroyed by bichloride of mercury, which readily enters.
In the burning coal of the furnace and in the forest's
decaying logs, one of the final products of combustion or
decay is carbon dioxide. So too when we exhale the carbon
dioxide from our lungs we are casting off one of the end
products in the combustion or oxidation of our foods and
our tissues.
Throughout the entire process of metabolism, of growth,
repair, decay, the body of animal or plant is a physico-
chemical laboratory in which are taking place the processes
of the non-living world.
Another characteristic feature of living things is their
power of movement. This is not evident at firet sight in
all organisms, notably plants. In fact, one of the criteria
formerly presented as distinguishing plants from animals was
the fixity of the former as compared with the motility of the
latter. This distinction we now know to be false however,
for even in the apparently non-motile plants there is circu-
The Living Machine 281
lation of cell sap, and movements of leaves and roots in
response to stimuli ; while among animals, the attached forms
such as sponges, sea anemones, barnacles, etc., either lack
locomotive power or possess it in very slight degree.
All living things then are motile to greater or less degree.
But is this quality lacking in the non-living world ? Place a
diluted drop of ink under the microscope and it becomes a
microcosm of violent activity. Wind and water are ever
active. The earth is flying through space at the rate of 18i/^
miles a second, and the universe is a realm of eternal motion.
Light and sound are expressions of movement, and the elec-
tronic theory of matter postulates that matter itself is a
cosmos of ceaseless energy. But the vitalist tells us that
living matter possesses '"spontaneity," which is lacking in
the non-living world. The living thing moves of its own
''volition," the non-living only under the influence of forces
external to itself. But what evidence have we of "volition"
on the part of an Amoiba or bacterium, while the energy
of the living machine is as truly the result of oxidation of
fuel as is that of the steam turbine or the automobile. Any
distinction then on the basis of motion alone between the
world of the living and the non-living is a fallacy.
Adaptation is one of the most characteristic features of
life. The bird and bat are adapted for flight, the flsh for
swimming, the monkey for climbing: one need not enumerate,
for one cannot name a single living thing which is not
adapted to the conditions of its existence; otherwise it would
not exist. Adaptation is the very keynote of life, and the
tablets of the past are crowded with the records of creatures,
which, serving well their day and generation, failed to adapt
themselves to changing conditions, and so were trampled
under foot by the onrush of the fit in the bitter struggle
for existence.
But are living things alone adapted to their environment?
Does not the river adapt itself to its channel, the lake to its
basin, and the gas to the fonn and size of its container?
Ice exists in winter because it is adapted to the cold and dis-
appears in summer because it is not adapted to the heat.
Adaptation indeed is merely an expression of action and re-
action, of cause and effect. But, argues the vitalist, these
are merely examples of the direct physical influence of one
thing upon another, while life adapts itself only in indirect
and as yet unknown ways. The fact of adaptation in the
inorganic world remains however, and when the riddles of
life have been solved it is not unlikely that the process of
adaptation of living things can be resolved into simple
physico-mechanical terms, just as surely as can the adjust-
282 Biology in America
ment of the river to its channel, or the snow drift to the
wind.
Yet another manifestation of life is its irritability or power
of response to stimuli. Examples of this are so common that
it is merely trite to repeat them. There is no form of life
so primitive or so sluggish as to escape this universal law.
But is tliis phenomenon limited to life alone? Does not life-
less matter also respond to stimuli, or changes in its environ-
ment? Examples of such changes must occur to the mind
of everyone — changes in volume or in state, whether solid,
liquid or gaseous, in response to changes in temperature or
pressure, are among the most familiar instances of these
responses. If a metal be heated its electrical conductivity
is decreased, sound travels faster the higher the temperature,
while atmospheric conditions will materially affect the
messages flashed from the wires of the radio. While the
responses of living things and changes in their environment
are infinitely more complex and indirect than are those of
the non-living, yet the same principle holds true for both,
and when we know more of the mechanism of life it may be
possible to resolve its complex reactions into their simpler
terms.
Yet one great characteristic of life remains, namely, repro-
duction. The development of a human being with his myriad
cells, more varied in form than the manifold parts of the
most complicated machine, ranging in size from the tiny
corpuscles of the blood, less than one four-thousandth of an
inch in size, to the motor nerve cells of the spinal cord, which
may reach a length of over three feet; and including the
intricate structures of the brain by which are performed all
the wonderfully complex functions of the human body, in-
cluding the as yet inscrutable processes of thought ; all these
coming from an apparently simple cell a little more than one
one-hundredth of an inch in size, is a wonder beside which the
magic of an Aladdin or the miracles of holy writ fade into
ghostly paleness. The enthusiast in the ranks of the mech-
anists has attempted however to remove even this most
distinctive feature of living things, by showing that non-
living matter may in a certain sense reproduce itself, as new
crystals form in an evaporating salt solution. However feeble
such a comparison may be, it is nevertheless true that all
phases of reproduction — the growth of the germ cells, their
union, the entrance of the spermatozoon, the division of the
fertilized egg, the growth and differentiation of the tissues
are all intimately associated with physico-chemical changes
taking place in these cells, and can, as we shall see later,
to a certain extent at least be induced by artificial means.
The Living MacJiinc 283
"Whatever the answer to the riddle of life may ultimately
be it is at least certain that our present most hopeful line
of attack lies in the, at least partially known, fields of physics
and chemistry, rather than in the unknown metaphysical one
of ''vital principles," "entelechies" and other hypothetical
factors. What information then does the bio-chemist have
to give us which may help us in the solution of our problem ?
The writer once accompanied a class of school-boys through
a Colorado mine. On the mine track stood a string of empty
cars, and one of the boys asked the conductor of the party
what kind of fuel they used for their engines in the mine.
"Hay," replied tlie conductor, which somewhat puzzled the
boys, until they learned that mules furnished the motive
power for the cars. One of the earliest speculations of physi-
ologists was regarding the nature of animal heat. Some
animals (birds and mammals) have a constant body tempera-
ture which is usually higher than that of their surroundings.
"What is this heat, and whence does it come?" the early
investigators asked themselves. It was at first supposed
that heat was a substance which entered and left the body
in some unknown way. Toward the beginning of the eight-
eenth century speculation began to call experiment to its
aid, and Mayow, Boyle and Priestley tried keeping small
animals in closed chambers, with the result that they soon
died. They also tried introducing lighted candles into similar
chambers and found that just as the "flame of life" was
soon extinguished, so too the candles went out, if denied air.
They further found that an animal could not live so long in
a jar in which the air had been exhausted by a burning
candle as in one in which the air was fresh; and vice versa
the candle would not burn where an animal had exhausted
the air before it, nor would one animal live as well in a
chamber formerly occupied by another, or one candle burn
as well where another had been previously burned, as in one
containing air which had not been used up previously. These
experiments led them to suspect that the breathing of the
animal and the burning of the candle were similar processes.
Soon after followed Priestley's discovery of oxygen which
he called by the sophisticated title of dephlogisticated air,
from the Greek word phlogiston or inflammable. Now fol-
lowed Lavoisier's discovery that when a candle was burned,
or an animal breathed, the oxygen or dephlogisticated air of
Priestley, which formed one-fifth of the volume of ordinary
air, was converted into what was formerly known as "fixed
air," a compound of carbon and oxygen. Lavoisier now
assumed that the heat of the animal body was produced in
a manner analogous to that of the burning candle, namely
284 Biology in America
by the combustion of the carbon in the body, or its union
with oxvf^en to j)ro(luee carbon dioxide. In support of this
assumption he pointed out that in birds, whose temperature
is higher than that of mammals, there is a greater production
of carbon dioxide in respiration.
To test tliis hypothesis Lavoisier constructed a primitive
calorimeter for measuring the heat production of the animal
body. This consisted essentially of two chambers, an inner,
for holding the animal whose heat production was to be
measured, and ^n outer of double walls, the space between
which, as well as that of the outer chamber itself, was packed
with ice. Knowing the amount of heat required to melt a
given quantity of ice, and measuring the carbon dioxide and
water produced by the animal, it should be possible to deter-
mine whether the respiration of the animal was of the proper
amount to account for the heat produced. Without going into
details regarding these experiments of Lavoisier, and his suc-
cessors Dulong and Depretz, it is sufficient to say that the
results of these early experimenters showed a very close
correspondence between the heat calculated from the respira-
tory products formed, and the actual production of heat in
the calorimeter and led to the conclusion established by later
observers that the production of energy in the animal body
is dependent on the oxidation of the food consumed, and
further that conservation of energy is just as true of the
latter as of any non-living machine.
The work of these early experimenters has been continued
in recent years by Benedict and Atwater at the Nutrition
Laboratory of the Carnegie Institution in a series of brilliant
investigations with the aid of a very ingenious and intricate
respiration calorimeter. This in brief consists of a chamber
large enough for a man to live in for several days at a time,
and containing apparatus (i. e., a bicycle) on which exercise
may be taken. The chamber is constructed of a double metal
wall with a contained air space and is surrounded with a
double wall of wood containing a second air space, while
between metal and wooden walls is an intermediate air space,
the whole very effectively preventing any exchange of heat
between the interior and exterior of the chamber. As a fur-
ther precaution to prevent such exchange of heat special
electrical devices are installed for keeping the two walls of the
metal chamber at the same temperature, and any difference
in temperature between them is recorded on a galvanometer
on the observer's desk in the laboratory. Connected with
the chamber are various devices for measuring the intake of
oxygen, the outgo of carbon dioxide and water, the heat lost
by the subject during the experiment and the amount of
The Living Machine 285
energy expended in muscular activity. To illustrate the
extreme care taken to avoid error in the use of this apparatus
may be cited the precautions used in measuring the amount
of heat generated by the subject in the calorimeter. This is
determined by reading the temperatures of a stream of water
which circulates through coils of pipe in the chamber. To
the ordinary person it would seem as though it were suffi-
ciently accurate to read these temperatures as given by
accurate thermometers. But in order to eliminate all possible
error corrections are made for the effect of pressure of water
on the bulb of the thermometer. "Within the chamber is a
folding cot, chair, table and other conveniences. During an
experiment the entrance to the chamber is tightly sealed by
glass which serves as a window, while a small opening serves
for exchange of food, water, excreta, etc. A telephone en-
ables the occupant to talk to persons on the outside. The
apparatus is so delicate that the slight rise in temperature
caused by the subject rising from his chair is recorded by it.
The respiration calorimeter is used for investigating the
many intricate problems of human nutrition and especially
for determining the relation between different kinds of food
and the energy furnished by them. To test its accuracy its
designers performed a series of check experiments in which
alcohol instead of human tissue was burned, and the amounts
of carbon dioxide, water and heat produced, and oxygen con-
sumed, were measured and compared with the amount re-
quired by calculation from the amount of alcohol used. Four
such experiments showed an average difference between the
calculated and experimental results of less than one-half of
one per cent.
Experiments with the calorimeter can be made to show what
proportion of the energy available in the food consumed is
used in the work done by the subject. It is a fact well known
to all mechanical engineers that no machine can utilize all
the energy of its fuel. This is largely due to loss of heat by
radiation from the surface of the machine and in friction.
Our best engines can use perhaps not more than one-tenth
of the energy available in their fuel. In this respect the
human machine is a more perfect mechanism, for it can use
about 15-20% of the energy available in its fuel (food) for
mechanical (muscular, nervous, etc.) work.
The subject of human nutrition is one to fill volumes in
itself. We can only note here in passing a few of the most
interesting and important results obtained from experiments
in this field.
Two of the perquisites which the Englishman of past
generations has regarded as his inalienable right have been
286 Biology in America
liis meat aiul liis ale, and his descendants on this side of
the water have maintained fairly well the reputation of their
ancestors. But "those who dance must pay the fiddler" and
higli living has hrought in its train not only higli grocer's,
l)ut high doctor's bills and mortality rates as well. The advent
of meat cards and meatless days during the war brought
about a cut in the size of our steaks if not of our butcher's
bills. If this seeming privation teaches us that an excessive
meat diet is not essential to our health and happiness the
game will indeed prove ' ' worth the candle. ' ' But there were
even in early days voices raised in warning against prevalent
excesses in diet. One of these was the plea for moderation
in eating by the English physician Thomas Cogan, published
in 159G under the title "The Haven of Health," in which he
says: "The second thing that is to be considered of meates
is the quantitie, which ought of all men greatly to be re-
garded, for therein lyeth no small occasion of health or
sickness, of life or death. For as want of meate consumeth
the very substance of our flesh, so doth excesse and surfet
extinguish and suffocate naturall heat wherein life con-
sisteth." Again, "Use a measure in eating, that thou maist
live long : and if thou wilst be in health, then hold thine hands.
But the greatest occasion why men passe the measure in
eating, is varietie of meats at one meale. "Which fault is
most common among us in England farre above all other
nations. For such is our custome by reason of plentie (as I
think) that they which be of abilitie, are served with sundry
sortes of meate at one meale. Yea the more we would wel-
come our friends the more dishes we prepare. And when we
are well satisfied with one dish or two, then come other more
delicate and procureth us by that means, to eate more than
nature doth require. Thus varietie bringeth us to excesse,
and sometimes to surfet also. But Phisicke teacheth us to
faede moderately upon one kinde of meate only at one meale,
or at leastwise not upon many of contrarie natures. . . . This
disease, (I mean surfet) is verie common: for common is that
saying and most true: That more die by surfet than by the
sword. And as Georgius Pictorius saith, all surfet is ill, but
of bread worst of all. And if nature be so strong in many,
and they be not sicke upon a full gorge, yet they are drowsie
and hcavie, and more desirous to lo.yter than to labor, accord-
ing to that old master, when the belly is full, the bones would
be at rest. Yea the minde and wit is so oppressed and over-
whelmed with excesse that it lyeth as it were drowned for a
time, and unable to use his force, " ^
1 Quoted from Chittenden, " The Nutrition of Man, "pp. 166-7.
The Living Machine 287
In recent times physiologists, both pseudo and scientific,
including a great variety of cranks of all sorts and sizes,
have been turning their attention more and more to matters
of diet, and the layman is beginning to learn that it is
possible for him to select his food, not only with respect to
price and palatability, but also for its value as a fuel for
the human machine. The principal elements in human diet
are proteins (meat, eggs and, to a less extent, milk, grain and
vegetables), carbohydrates (sugar and starch) and fats. One
of the greatest services rendered by modern students of human
nutrition has been to show that a high protein diet is not only
unnecessary, but actually in many cases detrimental to health.
Studies of this sort have been largely conducted in this coun-
try by Professors Chittenden and Fisher at Yale, the results
of two of the most striking of whose experiments are here
summarized. The first of these was conducted upon a group
of thirteen United States soldiers, for a period of six months,
and the second on eight college athletes for five months.
The ordinary diet of the soldiers prior to the experiment
may be illustrated by the following average day's menu:
Breakfast — Beefsteak 8 oz., gravy 2.4 oz., fried potatoes 8.2
oz., onions 1.2 oz., bread 5 oz., coffee 24 oz., sugar 0.6 oz.
Dinner — Beef 6 oz., boiled potatoes 12.3 oz., onions 2 oz.,
bread 8.2 oz., coffee 32.3 oz., sugar 1 oz.
Supper — Corned beef 6.9 oz., potatoes 6 oz., onions 0.7 oz.,
bread 5.5 oz., fruit jelly 3.7 oz., coffee 15.0 oz., sugar 9.7 oz.
During the experiment the amount of meat was gradually
reduced until the men were living on a diet of which the
following day's menu is a sample:
Breakfast — Wheat griddle cakes 7 oz., syrup 1.7 oz., one cup
coffee, with milk and sugar, 12.3 oz.
Dinner — Codfish balls (4 parts potato, 1 part fish, fried in
pork fat) 5.3 oz., stewed tomato 7 oz., bread 2.6 oz., one cup
coffee 13.3 oz., apple pie 3.3 oz.
Supper — Apple fritters 7 oz., stewed prunes 4.4 oz., bread
1.7 oz., butter 0.4 oz., one cup tea 12.3 oz.
As a result of this change of diet some of the men showed
a slight loss of weight which occurred at the start, and in
others an actual gain for the entire period. In only one case,
that of a stout man, was there any noticeable decrease, which
in his case was to his advantage, rather than the reverse.
Not only was there no harmful loss of weight, but the
general health was maintained and in some cases improved.
"Most conspicuous, however, though something that was
entirely unlocked for, was the effect observed on the muscular
strength of the various subjects," which showed not a loss,
but on the contrary a decided gain, "and furthermore," says
288
Biology in America
Professor Cliittenden, "tlioro was a noticoablc gain in self-
reliance and conrage in their athletic work, both of Avhich
are likewise indicative of an improved condition of the body.
How far these improvements are attribntable to training and
to the more regular life the men were leading, and how far
to the change in diet, cannot be definitely determined. AVe
may venture the opinion, however, . . . that the
change in
A Soldier after a Six-Months' Diet Low in Meat
After Chittenden, "The Nutrition of Man."
By permission of F. A. Stokes Company.
diet was in a measure at least responsible for the increased
efficiency. As the writer has already expressed it, there must
be enough food to make good the daily waste of tissue, enough
food to furnish the energy of muscular contraction, but any
surplus over and above what is necessary to supply the^se
needs is not only a waste, but may prove an incubus, retard-
ing the smooth working of the machinery and detracting
from the power of the organism to do its best work."
The Living Machine 289
Concerning the second experiment above mentioned Profes-
sor Chittenden says: "Here, again, we see that a relatively
small intake of proteid food will not only bring about and
maintain nitrogen eqnilibrium for many months, and probably
indefinitely, but that such a form of diet is equally as effective
with vigorous athletes, accustomed to strenuous muscular ef-
fort, as with professional men of more sedentaiy habits. Fur-
ther, these many months of observation with different individ-
uals all lead to the opinion that there are no harmful results of
any kind produced by a reduction in the amount of proteid
food to a level commensurate with the actual needs of the
body. Body-weight, health, physical strength, and muscular
tone can all be maintained, in partial illustration of which
may be offered two photogi*aphs of one of the eight athletes
taken toward the end of the experiment; pictures which are
certainly the antithesis of enfeebled muscular structure, or
diminished physical vigor."
Similar results have been obtained with professional men.
Altogether they show very conclusively the possibility of not
only maintaining, but also of improving human health with
a diet relatively low in proteid matter.
What now will be the result if an animal, which in its
natural state was exclusively carnivorous, and even in domes-
tication is still largely so, be fed on a proteid-poor diet?
Some of the earlier experimenters in Europe found that a
reduction in the meat of a dog's diet resulted in gastro-
intestinal disturbance followed by death. These experiments
however were conducted with dogs kept in close confinement
and as Chittenden says "It is doubtful if there is full appre-
ciation of the possible effect of monotony, in the ordinary
dietary experiments on dogs. Man quickly feels the effect;
the sportsman camping in the woods by brook or lake enjoys
his first meal of speckled trout and has no thought of ever
becoming tired of such a delicacy; but as trout cooked in
various ways continue to be placed before him three times a
day, and with perhaps very little else, he soon passes into a
frame of mind where salt pork would be a luxury, and where
he would prefer to go hungry rather than eat the delicacy,
if indeed he has appetite to eat anything. Is it strange that
dogs confined in cages barely large enough to permit of their
turning around, and fed day after day and month after
month with exactly the same amount of desiccated meat, fat,
and rice, should show signs and symptoms, if nothing worse,
of disturbed nutrition? It is necessary in experiments of
this kind that the animals be confined for given periods, at
least. ... It is possible, however, to limit the time of close
confinement to, say, ten consecutive days, this to be followed
290 Biology in America
by a like period of comparative freedom, thus insuring oppor-
tunities for an abundance of fresh air and exercise."
In order to test the effects of a proteid-poor diet on dogs
living under conditions as nearly ideal as possible a series of
experiments were carried out on some twenty animals,
some of these lasting an entire year, ''AH of the . . . dogs
. . . were fed on a mixed diet, with some fresh meat each day ;
bread, cracker dust, milk, lard, and rice being the other foods
drawn upon to complete the dietary. The animals were fed
twice a day, each meal being accurately weighed and of defi-
'nite chemical composition. A large, light, and airj^ room, kept
scrupulously clean, and in the winter time properly heated
by steam, served as their main abiding place. In this room
were a suitable number of smaller compartments, the walls
of which were composed of open lattice work (of iron), so
as not to interfere with light or air, and yet adequate to keep
the dogs apart. These compartments were not cages in the or-
dinary sense, but were truly large and roomy. ... In pleas-
ant weather, immediately after their first meal, the dogs were
taken out of doors to a large enclosure near by, where they
were allowed perfect freedom until about four o'clock, when
they were taken in for their second meal (between four and
five o'clock in the afternoon). The outdoor enclosure was
inaccessible to every one except the holder of the key, and
the dogs while there were wholly free from annoyance. Once
every month, during a period of ten consecutive days, each
dog was confined in the metabolism cage so as to admit of
the collection of all excreta, in order to make a determination
of the nitrogen balance. Practically, therefore, each dog
was in close confinement only one-third of the month, the
remaining two-thirds being spent in much more congenial
surroundings."
While details regarding all of these experiments cannot be
given here one case may be selected as an example. "The
animal employed in this experiment . . . was apparently full
grown, but was thin and had the appearance of being under-
fed. At first, it was given daily 172 grams of meat, 124 grams
of cracker dust, and 72 grams of lard. . . . (Later) a radical
change was made in the diet, by reducing the amount of meat
to 70 gi-ams daily ; . . . the cracker dust and lard being kept
at essentially the same levels as before . . . the dog in the
meantime gaining in body-weight. ... In this manner, the
experiment was continued with frequent changes in the char-
acter of the diet, but always maintaining essentially the same
(food) values . . . (for) just eleven months, with the ani-
mal at the close of the experiment still gaining in body-
weight, . . . and with every indication of good health and
The Living Machine
291
stren^h." The results of his entire series of experiments
led Chittenden to the conclusion that: ''These experiments
on the influence of a low proteid diet on dogs, as a type of
high proteid consumers, taken in their entirety, afford con-
vincing proof that such animals can live and thrive on amounts
of proteid and non-nitrogenous food far below the (usual)
standards. . . . The deleterious results reported by these in-
vestigators were not due to the effects of low proteid or to
diminished consumption of non-nitrogenous foods, but are to
be ascribed mainly to non-hygienic conditions, or to a lack
of care and physiological good sense in the prescription of a
narrow dietary not suited to the habits and needs of this
Effect of Diet on Dogs
Left — A dog fed on a diet containing one-half pound of meat daily.
Eight — The same animal after several months on a diet with less
than half as much meat. From Chittenden, "The Nutrition of Man."
By permission of F. A. Stokes Company.
class of animals. Further, it is obvious that the more or less
broad deductions so frequently drawn from . . . experiments
(on dogs) . . . especially in their application to mankind,
are entirely unwarranted and without foundation in fact.
Our experiments offer satisfying proof that not only can dogs
live on quantities of proteid food per day smaller than (are
usually) . . . deemed necessary, and with a fuel value far
below the (usual) standard . . . ; but, in addition, tliat these
animals are quite able on such a diet to gain in body-weight
. . . , thereby indicating that even small quantities of food
might suffice to meet their true physiological requirements.
"The results of these experiments with dogs, which we
292 Biology in America
have recorded in such detail, are in perfect haiTDiony with the
conclusions arrived at by our experiments and observations
with man, and serve to strengthen the opinion, so many times
expressed, tliat the dietary habits of mankind and the dietary
standards based thereon are not always in accord with the
true physiological requirements of the body. ' '
There is one experiment in the foregoing series regarding
which a further word may be said. In this experiment a
dog which had been fed on a diet of meat, milk, bread and
lard was changed to a diet of bread and lard only, the food
and fuel value however of the diet remaining unchanged.
"In four days' time however a change began to creep over
the animal ; the appetite diminished, and there was apparent
a condition of lassitude and general weakness which deterred
the animal from moving about as usual.
"During the next week the animal grew steadily worse,
and would eat only when coaxed with a little milk or with
bread softened with milk, the diet of bread and lard being
invariably refused. There was marked disturbance of the
gastro-intestinal tract; bloody discharges were frequent; the
mucous membrane of the mouth was greatly inflamed and
very sore ; body-weight fell off, and the animal was in a very
enfeebled condition. This continued until December 4, with
every indication that the animal would not long survive, but
by feeding carefully with a little milk and occasionally some
meat, improvement finally manifested itself, and by December
18 there was good appetite, provided bread was not con-
spicuous in the food. Body-weight . . . was . . . slowly re-
gained (until finally) ... in general condition there was
nothing to be desired." ^
Similar results have been obtained by Hopkins and Nevill
who kept twenty-four young rats on a diet of protein, starch,
lactose (milk-sugar) and salts. They ate well and took
sufficient food to supply them with needed energy, but soon
ceased to grow and in a few days actually began to lose
weight, fourteen of them dying in forty days. With six of
the rats there was added to the diet, after the decline in weight
had commenced, a small portion of milk daily, which was
followed by an immediate improvement in health, and re-
newed growth.
There are certain problematical diseases in man, which'
may be due to a lack of something in the food. Beri beri, a
disease common among Filipinos, Japanese and East Indians,
and characterized by paralysis, swelling and degeneration of
the muscles, has been attributed to an extensive diet of
*The foregoing quotations arc from Chittenden, "The Nutrition of
Man," pp. 187 et sot]., Ity permission of Fred'd A. Stokes Co.
The Living Machine 293
polished rice which lacks the reddish husk of the kernel. If
fowls are fed on an exclusive diet of this they die after some
weeks. If fed on unpolished rice, they do not contract the
disease, and if an extract of the husk or bran be injected into
fowls ill from eating the polished grain they will recover.
Similarly men who eat the unpolished rice are not subject to
beri-beri. It seems then that the rice husk contains some
substance which is essential to life.
Pellagra, a disease common among the poorer classes in
tropical and sub-tropical countries practically throughout the
world, is characterized by weakness, pains, digestive disturb-
ances, skin eruptions and mental disorders, terminating in
insanity and finally death. In its earlier stages the disease
is recurrent, appearing each spring for several years with
increasing severity until it becomes a permanent condition.
It has been ascribed to a too extensive diet of corn or to eating
spoiled corn. It has also been laid at the door of the villains
of so many sanitary (or insanitary) tragedies — the insects.
One investigator has recently attempted to find an hereditary
basis for the disease. Whatever the ultimate cause it is
clearly a disease of disturbed metabolism, and evidence is
accumulating to show that imperfect diet is responsible.
Scurvy has long been known as a disease of mal-nutrition,
common especially among sailors, who were forced to live on
a diet largely of salt meat, so that in the maritime laws of
many nations captains were required to furnish their seamen
with a ration of vinegar, lime juice or other acid as a pre-
ventive.
While the subject of human nutrition is yet in its infancy,
especially as regards our knowledge of these problematical
substances, which are essential to health, and to some of
which, especially those present in milk, the term vitamine has
been applied ; the evidence is clear that to furnish the living
machine with the fuel needed for its proper working, it is not
sufficient merely to supply the necessary material for energy,
repair and growth, but that other things are needed to enable
it to properly utilize this fuel. While therefore excesses
in eating are but little if any less injurious than those in
drinking or other indulgence, there is no place in the regime
of the sane and normal individual for the dietary fads and
foolishness which some enthusiasts have advocated with great
eclat. While most of us undoubtedly eat too much meat,
there is small excuse for adopting a strictly vegetarian diet.
Our teeth are made for service, and not for the exclusive
benefit of the dentist, but while thorough mastication is un-
doubtedly essential to a ripe old age with good digestion,
most of us will hardly find it necessary to chew by the stop-
294 Biology in America
watch, or to reflate our bites as we do our setting-up exer-
cises. In the feeding of hens for egg productivity Pearl has
shown that hens witli a mixed diet, from which they were
permitted to choose at will, maintained better health than
those limited strictly to certain articles. ''Eeason in all
things, excess in none," is a fundamental rule for sanity in
diet as in other of our life activities.
What of the mechanism whereby this wonderful machine
of life utilizes its fuel? Herein lies one of the fundamental
differences between the living and the non-living machine.
"Whereas the latter uses its fuel solely in the conversion of
potential energy into heat and work, the former, in addition
to these two functions, also converts some of its fuel into its
own substance to take the place of worn-out parts, and to
build new parts and enlarge those already formed in develop-
ment and growth. We have already seen that the living
engine is much more efficient in the conversion of the potential
energy of its fuel into work than is the non-living machine.
How convenient it would be if the latter like the former were
automatically repaired as it wore out ! Given a good machine
to start with, proper fuel and draft, and preventing anyone
from throwing in dirt (disease) and the living machine will
run without repair for the time of its natural life.
How is this done? In the non-living machine the process
of converting fuel energy into work energy is comparatively
simple. The carbon of the fuel is in such shape that it can''
be more or less directly oxidized to carbon dioxide, and heat
energy thereby released. But in the utilization of the food
or fuel of the living machine a large number of intermediate
steps are necessary, which steps often consist of a cycle of
changes which are partly degenerative (breaking down com-
plex substance and thereby releasing energy) and partly
constructive (building up simpler into more complex sub-
stance and storing energy thereby). The food as taken into
the body of most animals is in such shape that it cannot be
directly burned to furnish energy^ or built up into body
substance. While our knowledge of the many complicated
changes undergone by food stuffs in the animal body is as
yet very meagre, we have nevertheless enough information to
enable us to follow in a general way these changes. Probably
the food most readily convertible into energy is fat. Some
fat is an exception to the statement made above that food
is not directly convertible into energy. The Esquimaux use
seal blubber both as food and fuel for heating their igloos,
* I refer here to ordinary conditions of combustion. Any food sub-
stance may be burned in a special apparatus known as a bomb calorime-
ter and its energy content thereby determined.
The Living Machine 295
and various vegetable oils can be burned in a lamp. "When
taken into the digestive tract however the fat is not usable
as fuel any more than any other food substance, but must
first undergo digestion.
The function of digestion of all food is to put it into such
shape that it can be absorbed by the blood and lymph through
the walls of the digestive tract. This transfer or absorption
of the food through the latter takes place, as we have seen,
by a process of osmosis. The food as eaten is not ordinarily
in solution and cannot be passed through a membrane or
dialyzed, the function of digestion being to render it soluble
and dialyzable. This is accomplished by a process known as
hydrolysis which consists in the splitting up of the food into
simpler, compounds by the addition of water. This process
is effected by means of certain remarkable substances formed
by all animals and plants and known as enzymes or ferments.
When a little yeast is added to a solution of sugar and certain
salts and kept at a proper temperature, bubbles of gas (carbon
dioxide) soon begin to rise to the surface of the solution.
The sugar is being broken down into two simpler substances,
carbon dioxide and alcohol, by the ferment secreted by the
yeast cells. So far as we know the ferment itself does not
change, but acting as by magic affects a change in certain
substances with which it comes in contact. Yet even this
remarkable activity of the living cell has its counterpart in
inorganic nature. If hydrogen and oxygen be brought to-
gether at ordinary temperatures there is "nothin' doin' " —
to use the English language up to date. But introduce a
little finely divided platinum into the situation, and under
its seemingly magic influence combination occure and drops
of water form where before there was but gas. The heat
generated by this reaction soon raises the platinum to a red
heat and this principle was employed in the construction of
a self-lighting lamp, in which a jet of hydrogen played upon
a bit of spongy platinum, which soon heated — igniting the
gas. The platinum here is known as a catalyzer. Its action
is similar to that of the ferment since it in some way brings
about a change in other substances, without itself entering
into that change. The activity of the ferment-forming cell
is responsible to itself for its continuation, for when the
products of ferment action become too great this action ceases,
and will not recommence until these products are removed,
or at least lessened in amount.
Among vertebrate animals the digestive ferments are
formed chiefly by the stomach, pancreas and intestine, al-
though the liver, and in some instances the mouth glands
play a minor part; while the simplified and soluble (digested)
296 Biology in America
food stuffs are absorbed mainly at least by the walls of the
intestine, whence they are carried by the body fluids (blood
and lymph) to the tissues of tlie body, where probably under
the influence of other ferments they are again built up into
complex substances, which compose the protoplasm of the
body cells.* Thus the kernel of the wheat, or the muscle of
the beef, is iu some mysterious way transformed into the
muscle and the nerves, the blood and bone of the animal
which consumes them. The various steps in the digestive
and absorptive processes are extremely complicated and their
character is not fully understood. The large number of prod-
ucts formed in tlie digestion of the proteid molecule form
one evidence of the complex nature of protoplasm. Leaving
out of consideration the simpler processes of digestion of
starch, sugar and fat, and dealing with proteid digestion
alone; passing over also the many and complicated stages in
the journey of the proteid molecule through the digestive
tract, we come to the end products of digestion, the amino-
acids or "l)uilding stones of proteid," as they have l)een
called. Tliese amino-aeids include a large number of sub-
stances, all built around the common nucleus of NHo. Witli
these as a basis the constructive ferments of the l)ody build
up its marvelously complex materials.
A comparison of the animal body with a machine, the food
of the former corresponding to the fuel of the latter is only
partially exact, for in the machine, as we have seen, the fuel
is directly consumed to furnish energy, while in the animal
the change of food energy into work energy is effected in
part only through the medium of the body substance
itself. After the conversion of the digested food stuffs into
the protoplasm of the l)ody this must in turn be broken down
through the action of the oxydizing, or destructive ferments,
into a whole series of decomposition products, of gradually
decreasing complexity, the principal end results being carbon
dioxide and urea.
Some of the food stuffs, notably those with the highest
energy content, the fats and carbohydrates, and to a less
extent the proteids also, may after digestion be directly
oxidized to furnish energy; or may in the case of fat and
glycogen be stored by the body as a reserve supply for future
need. Thus a hibernating animal, such as a bear, during the
summer lays up for himself a bountiful supply of fat upon
whieli to draw during the long winter's fast. This storage
of energy in the form of reserve food stuffs by the living
*Sueh a brief statement as the above naturally overlooks the many
intermediate steps in this very complicated process.
The Living Machine 297
machine finds a parallel in the storage of electrical energy
in a storage battery.
Turning from the world of animals to that of plants, we
find in the latter a parallel to all of the metabolic processes
of the former. The average person is accustomed to think of
a plant in terms of the green thing which he finds in garden,
field or forest. But when we go a-hunting mushrooms, or
poke aside the rotting remains of a fallen tree, we discover
other plants which live a different sort of life from that of
tree or shrub or herb. And should we delve yet further into
Nature's recesses, and penetrate that hidden world to which
the microscope gives entrance, we should discover creatures
concerning whom no one can say whether they are plant or
animal. Some of these uncertain forms are claimed by both
botanist and zoologist as belonging in their own especial field
of study, for in some respects they are distinctly animal, in
others plant in nature, as we have already seen in an earlier
chapter. But while one stands at the portals of life in a
realm which is neither plant nor animal ; advancing into either
kingdom he must follow ever more widely diverging paths;
until when he reaches the farthest bounds of this wonderful
world he finds its two kingdoms, while governed by the same
fundamental laws, nevertheless differing profoundly in their
expression.
Perhaps the most fundamental difference between the higher
plants and animals is in their metabolism. "While the latter
are spenders, the former are hoarders of energy, taking raw
materials, carbon dioxide from the air and water from both
air and soil, and from these constructing by the energy of the
sun, acting through the green chlorophyl of leaf and stem,
their own food-stuffs; thereby converting the radiant energy
of sunlight into the chemical energy of sugar and of starch.
From the soil and air the plant obtains its nitrogen, and from
the soil the other inorganic substances which it needs to build
its protoplasm, and combining these in some as yet but little
understood way, with the sugar, by the action of constructive
ferments, it builds up its protoplasm. This is what is hap-
pening in the blade of grass, the spreading leaf and the stag-
nant pool, covered with a thick green scum, a little chemical
laboratory, where Nature is busily at work making sugar and
releasing oxygen. Some day perchance the chemist, imitat-
ing Nature, will learn to make our starch and sugar for us,
and bid defiance to the "man with a hoe." This indeed is
the possibility, perhaps not immediate, but none the less ulti-
mate, of the studies on photosynthesis now under way at the
Desert Botanical Laboratory of the Carnegie Institution at
298 Biology in America
Tucson, Arizona, whose work we have considered in a previous
chapter. Synthetic chemistry may well doff its hat and bow
low before the greatest creative chemist in the world — the
green plant.
Tlie world today hungers and thirsts after nitrogen. We
must have nitrogen to fertilize our fields, in order that we
may not starve, and we must have nitrogen to rend asunder
the bowels of the earth and lay bare the treasures hidden
therein, and we must have nitrogen that we may slaughter
our fellow men. So we have cleaned the guano beds of Chile,
where the sea fowl have been laying down treasure and stench
for years untold. We have dug deep into the nitrate beds
of Cliile and Peru, and today we are harnessing the water-
fall and bidding it harvest for us the nitrogen of the air.
Meanwhile the silent plant has been putting man 's ingenuity
to shame, and in its laboratory working wonders, whereat
science well may marvel. Truly should man "consider the
lilies of the field. ' '
But the green plant is not unassisted in the wonders which
it works. On the roots of plants of the pea family occur little
swellings or "nodules" which are fonned by bacteria which
have the power of extracting the nitrogen from the air in the
soil and using it to build their own bodies. Hence they are
known as the "nitrogen-fixing" bacteria. As these bacteria
die they give to the soil compounds of the nitrogen which they
have taken from the air. Thus it is that peas and their
relatives such as beans and alfalfa are such valuable plants
for crop rotation, for if a soil from which the nitrogen has
been largely exhausted by continuous cropping with grain be
planted for a year or two to beans or alfalfa, the nitrogen-
fixing bacteria on the roots of the latter will replace the
nitrogen and give to the worn-out soil a new lease of life.
But what share does the bean or the alfalfa and the bacteria
have in this co-operative association ? The latter during their
life probably absorb sugars and other substances formed in
the leaves of the former and passed down into the roots, while
on their death some of the nitrogenous material formed by
the bacteria is absorbed Ijy tlie green plant. The heirs to
the riches laid up by these two industrious partners are the
plants which follow the peas, beans or alfalfa in rotation.
There are other soil bacteria which aid the farmer by changing
the ammonia in the soil into nitrites and nitrates, in which
form it becomes available as food for the green plants, while
vice versa other soil bacteria perform exactly the reverse
operation and change nitrites and nitrates into ammonia.
All life is a cycle. No sooner does one agency build up than
The Living Machine 299
another tears down, and so it goes, in the lives of the unseen
bacteria of the soil, as well as in the affairs of man.
But while most animals and plants differ so widely in their
metabolism, fundamentally their ways of life are alike. Both
must have food, from the combustion of which their energy
is derived, and from which their wastage is replaced and
growth material obtained. And this food must be rendered
soluble and dialyzable in order that it may pass through
membranes which surround each cell, i. e., must be digested.
While in the higher animal there is a special place where
digestion and absorption occur (the digestive tract) and the
digestive ferments are formed by special glands (liver, pan-
creas, etc.), in the plant there is no such specialized tract or
glands for the functions of digestion and absorption, these
taking place generally in the leaves. There are however cer-
tain specialized tubes of cells in the root and stem which
taken together form "conducting paths," for the water, with
its dissolved salts ascending from the soil, and the sugar
descending from the leaves to root and stem, there to be stored
as starch for future use. And after digestion the food must
circulate through the plant to all its parts, and be built up
into its tissues by constructive ferments analogous to those
of animals.
In this circulation of water with its dissolved substances
through root and stem we see one of those marvelous, and
as yet inexplicable phenomena of life, which have caused
so many biologists to throw up their hands in despair and
ascribe to life some occult power undiscoverable by the sci-
entific methods of the physicist and chemist.
From the leafy surface of humblest herb and mightiest tree,
transpiration takes place, or the loss of water absorbed by the
roots from the soil. During the day this water is usually
quickly evaporated, but in the cooler air of night evaporation
is reduced and some of the transpired water remains as dew
upon the leaf. The pressure lifting the water from the soil
to the leaf may be as great in some cases as that which would
be exerted on the earth's surface by an atmosphere six to
eight times the thickness of the present one, a pressure suffi-
cient to support a column of water between two and three
hundred feet high.
Various attempts have been made to explain the rise of
sap in plants but as yet with no great success. The evapora-
tion from the leaves and the absorption of water by the cells
are the principal factors claimed as causing this wonderful
phenomenon. Neither factor however is adequate, and the
best we can do here, as in so many other cases, is to confess
our ignorance, and press onward in the search for knowledge.
300 Biology in America
In this marvellous laboratory of the living body with its
countless millions of little test tubes or cells, and its manifold
reagents, many of which we do not know, wonderful reactions
are continually taking place, whose complexity is at once
the joy and the despair of the chemist, and whose study is
one of the newest, most fascinating and withal most difficult
fields into which chemistry has been privileged to enter. And
yet marvelous as are the transformations within the body
of the living being they are all without exception undoubtedly
effected by physical and chemical means.
CHAPTER XII
Experimental biology, mechanism versus vitalism continued.
Tropisms, iyistincts and intelligence. H&rmanes. Arti-
ficial fertilization.
But can physics or chemistry explain the as yet unknown
processes of nervous action; the bewildering pei-plexity of
the instinct of bee or bird or beast, or the yet more amazing
intricacies of human thought? To answer this question, as
indeed to solve any of the problems of living matter aright,
it is essential that we turn to the lowest rather than to the
highest organisms, to those which present to us in their
simplest terms, all the fundamental processes of the living
thing. If the extended process or pseudopodium of an Amoeba,
one of the simplest types of living things, be touched with a
finely drawn out thread of glass, the process is retracted and
the direction of movement of the animal is altered thereby.
If on the other hand Amceba comes in contact with some
object, which serves as food, it reacts positively toward it,
thrusting out its processes and engulfing the object. Further-
more Amceba can pursue its food, so that to the observer it
seems as if this tiny bit of protoplasm, so small that the
largest specimens appear to the naked eye as mere specks of
white, were endowed with a sort of primitive intelligence.
This pursuit of food has been described by Jennings as
follows : "I had attempted to cut an Amoeba in two with the
tip of a glass rod. The posterior third of the Amoeba, in the
form of a wrinkled ball, remained attached to the body only
by a slender cord, the remains of the ectosarc. The Amceba
began to creep away, dragging with it this ball. I will call
this Amoeba a, while the ball will be designated b, A larger
Amoeba (c) approached, moving at right angles to the path
of the first Amoeba; its course accidentally brought it into
contact with the ball b, which was dragging past its front.
Amoeba c thereupon turned, followed Amoeba a, and began
to engulf the ball b. A large cavity was formed in the an-
terior end of Amoeba c, reaching back nearly or quite to its
middle, and much more than sufficient to contain the ball b.
Amoeba a now turned into a new path; Amceba c followed
(4). After the pursuit had lasted for some time the
301
302
Biology hi America
ball b had become completely enveloped by Amoeba c; the
cord connecting it with Amoeba a broke, and the latter went
on its way (at 5) and disappears from our account. Now
the anterior opening of the cavity in Amoeba c became partly
closed, leaving a slender canal (5). The ball b was thus
Pursuit of Food by Amceba
From Jennings, "Contributions to the study of the behavior of lower
organisms." Carnegie Institution, Publication No. 16. For description
see text.
completely inclosed, together with a quantity of water. There
was no union or adhesion of the protoplasm of b and c; on
the contrary (as the sequel will show clearly) both remained
quite separate, c merely inclosing b.
*'Now the large Amoeba c stopped, then began to move in
another direction (5-6), carrying with it its meal. But
The Livhuj Machine 303
the meal, the ball b, now began to show signs of life, sent out
pseudopodia, and indeed, became very active. \Ve shall
henceforth, therefore, speak of it as Amu?ba b. It began to
creep out through the still open canal, sending forth its
psetidopodia to the outside (7). Thereupon Am(eba c sent
forth its pseudopodia in the same direction, and after creeping
in that direction several times its own length, again c()ni|)l('tely
inclosed b (7-8). The latter again partly escaped (D), and
was again engulfed completely (30). Amoeba c now started
again in the opposite direction (11), whereupon Amieba b,
by a few rapid movements, escaped entirely from tlie posterior
end of c, and was free, being completely separated from e
(11-12). Thereupon c reversed its course (12), crept up to
b, engulfed it completely again (13), and started away.
Amoeba b now contracted into a ball, its protoplasm clearly
set off from the protoplasm of its captor, and remained quiet
for a time. Apparently the drama w^as over. Amoeba c went
on its way for about five minutes, without any sign of life in b.
In the movements of the Amoeba c the ball b gradually became
transferred to the posterior end of c, until finally there was
only a thin layer between b and the outer water. Now b
began to move again, sent out pseudopodia to the outside
through the thin wall, and then passed botlily out into the
water (14) . This time Amoeba c did not return and recapture
b. The two Amoebae moved in different directions and re-
mained completely separated. The whole performance occu-
pied, I should judge, about 12 to 15 minutes (the time was
not taken till several minutes after the beginning) .
"After working with simple stimuli and getting always
direct simple responses, so that one begins to feel that he
understands the behavior of the animal, it is somewhat
bewildering to become a spectator of so striking and com-
plicated a drama. . . . The action is remarkably like that of
a higher animal. Doubtless we must assume chemical and
mechanical stimuli as directives for each of the movements
of c, but the analysis so obtained seems not very complete
or satisfactory. " ^
Injurious chemicals cause Amoeba to withdraw from them.
Similarly, if the water on one side of an Aiiueba be warmed,
the animal will contract on that side, and thrusting forth its
pseudopodia on the other side, move in the opposite direction.
If a weak electric current be passed through the water con-
taining Amoeba, its behavior is similar to that under a heat
stimulus. The side toward the anode or positive pole con-
tracts, while from the opposite side pseudopodia are extended,
^Jennings, "Contributions to the Study of the Behavior of Lower
Organisms," Carnegie Institution, Publication No. 16.
304 Biolofjy in Am eric,
and the animal moves toward the cathode or negative pole.
Tlio hrhavioi- of Amoeba moreover is not stereotyped, l)ut can
be adapted to suit varying conditions. If a bright light be
thrown upon it, it contracts into a small inactive mass, but
after a time the psendopodia are again thrust out and activity
resumed. When starved, Amceba l)e('omes more active than
usual, while after a heavy meal it becomes sluggish.
"All these responses are purposive in that they are adapted
to the preservation of the organism. Simple as AuKcba ap-
parently is it manages to cope very effectively with the condi-
tions of its existence. One might conceivably construct a
machine which would run itself, gather tlie food needed to
supply the energy used in its workings, avoid automatically
contact with obstacles which would impair its running, move
away from regions too hot or too cold for its efficient opera-
tion, protect itself by producing coverings in unfavorable
situations, and guide itself into the most favorable regions
for its maintenance ; but Avhat a wonderfully complicated
mechanism it would have to be! Yet a simple, apparently
almost structureless mass of jelly does all this and more.
And if our mechanism had the property of repairing its own
injuries and producing other pieces of mechanism like itself,
its structural arrangements would be almost if not quite
beyond our power to conceive. One cannot, therefore, but
look with a feeling of admiration and wonder at so com-
paratively simple a creature as Amoeba, which is capable
of performing so much. . . .
"The behavior of Amoeba is essentially like that of higher
animals : it avoids things which are injurious ; it seeks things
Avhich are beneficial and it adapts its behavior to new condi-
tions. Life is very much the same sort of thing whether in
an Amceba or a man." ^
One must not however be too sure as to the simplicity of
an Am(pba. While to the eye of the microseopist it ajijieai-s
as an "almost structureless mass of jelly," nevertheless the
complexity of the molecules composing this jelly is such as
to defy analysis by the most skillful chemist. And even were
it possible to obtain an exact analysis of the Amoeba molecules,
the number of atoms composing the latter is so great as
to render possible several million combinations of these
atoms, each in a different way and each possibly resi)0]i-
sible for every ncAV response which it makes to its sur-
roundings.
While the behavior of Amoeba is generally such as to benefit,
rather than harm it, this is not invariably true of all organ-
Mlolinos, "The Evolulion of Aiiinial Intelligence," pp. 70-71. By
permission of Henry Holt and Company.
The Living Machine 305
isms. Thus a one por cent solution of morphine attracts
certain bacteria even though it is fatal to them. This is an
unusual condition however as morphine is a substance not
encountered in nature by bacteria. A similar behavior is
to be found, as we shall see later, in higher animals. Nature
sometimes plays the role of the enchantress C'ii'ce witii the
humblest, as well as the proudest of her creatures.
A step hig:her on the stage of life we come to Paramoecium,
whose acquaintance we have already been privileged to make.
Here we have an animal with definite organs of locomotion
(cilia) arranged in definite (spiral) lines upon the body; "an
oral groove or food trough, leading to a gullet or primitive
digestive tract, a definite anal spot for the discharge of
undigested materials, specialized organs (contractile vacuoles)
for excretion, and specialized nuclei which play a complicated
role in the processes of metabolism and reproduction. Para-
mceeium swims in a spiral path, directed by the spirally ar-
ranged cilia, and oblique oral groove. Its active movement
and peculiar form have caused many an unhappy hour to
the tyro in biology. If one place a drop of weak acid in the
dish of water in which Paramcpcia are restlessly zig-zagging
to and fro, they will be found after a time to have gathered
in the drop ; while vice versa a grain of salt will soon be sur-
rounded by a zone of water free from Paramoecia save for the
dead bodies of a few, which have ventured too near the fatal
spot and failed to extricate themselves therefrom, ere death
o'ertook them.
How are these results accomplished? Are Paramcecia at-
tracted by, and do they swim into the drop of acid because
they ''like" it? And, similarly, do they avoid the salt be-
cause they "know it is bad for them"? Let us follow their
maneuvers a little more closely. If a Paramoecium in swim-
ming at random through the water, happens to approach a
drop of acid it is not repelled by it, and hence goes into the
drop if its direction of movement happens to take it there;
once inside the drop however should it ''attempt" to escape
it cannot do so, for when it approaches the water outside the
drop it is seemingly repelled by the latter, for it backs up,
turns on its tail and swims away. Thus it can enter the
drop but cannot leave it, and in a short time a large number
of Paramoecia may be trapped in this manner. This behavior
of Paramoecium has been likened by Jennings who described it,
to a sort of "trial and error" behavior, similar to that of
the dog who learns to open a gate by putting his paw on the
latch, as a result of numberless fruitless pawings, in an at-
tempt to escape from the yard in which he is penned up.
Loeb however sees in this behavior something yet more simple
306 Biology in America
than doos Jciiiiiiifrs;, ascribing tlio backing and tnrning
movement of tlie animal on its approach to au unfavorable
environment, to a reversal of the ciliary movement on the side
stimulated, and to the asymmetrical shape of the body. The
controversial pliase of the snl)ject is one which does not
interest tlie general reader; the important point is that a
primitive animal like Paramoecinm, lacking any specialized
sense organs or nervous system, is nevertheless as sensitive to
stimuli as the higlier organism, with its indescribably complex
organs of sense, and intricate maze of nervous paths.
Many of the unicellular organisms, both plant and animal,
are exceedingly sensitive to light. This is especially well
shown by the ciliate Stentor. This is a gourd-shaped cell,
completely covered with cilia, except at the basal end or
"foot" by means of which the animal occasionally attaches
itself. At one end is a flattened or hollow disk surrounded
by a band of strong cilia which guide the food to a depression
in the tlisk, the mouth. Close to the outer surface of the
animal are a number of delicate contractile fibrils which func-
tion as muscles, in which respect Stentor shows a marked
advance in structure over Paramnecium. If the water in which
this ciliate is swimming be suddenly illuminated, the animal
reverses its movements, turns always in the same direction
(in respect to the sides of the body) and then goes ahead once
more. This reaction may be repeated a number of times, with
the final result that the animal, through a series of ' ' trials and
errors" is finally brought into a region of less light.
Many of the unicellular plants and animals are provided
with little spots of red pigment which are sensitive to light.
In these forms, which belong to the group of flagellates, or
forms bearing one or more long, whip-like cilia, and many of
which are on the problematical fence between plants and
animals, light reactions are well marked. The reactions may
be either positive or negative, vigorous or weak, and may vary
with the physiological state or condition of the organism at
different times; but all serve to bring it into that strength
of light which the organism "likes" best, i. e., to which it
is best adapted.
We are accustomed to think of unicellular organisms as
expressing life in its simplest terras, but we have seen never-
theless that many of them are indeed very complex creatures,
possessing organs of locomotion, digestion, excretion, contrac-
tion and even in some cases of special sense ("eye spots").
Kecently Kofoid and his students working at the University
of California have discovered structures in certain Protozoa
which they believe represent a primitive nervous system.
These are delicate fibrils which can be clearly brought out
The Living Machine
307
by appropriate staining, and are connected on the one hand
with the tiagella or cilia and on the other with certain deeply
staining granules in the body of the animal. To operate on
creatures less than 1/150 inch in length is a surgical
"stunt" of no small difficulty. Yet this has been done and
these delicate fibrils cut, with the resultant cessation of move-
ment of the connected fiagella. It is clear then that these
fibrils represent a primitive nerve-muscle structure such as
occurs in more diff'erentiated form in some of the simpler of
the many-celled animals.
The ability of higher plants to respond to stimuli is a
Compass Plants as Seen from Different Positions
From Kerner (translation by Oliver), "Natural History of Plants,"
Henry Holt and Company.
Print furnished hii Vnunnl I. (intern Slide Couipmnj , Chicago.
matter of common knowledge. We place a i)lant in our win-
dow and soon leaves and stems are bending toward the light.
The compass plant is a devoted worshipper of the sun. In
the dawn it turns its opening flowers eastward to greet the
rising sun, while at eventide they face the west attendant
on its setting. The mold Piloljolus grows upon horse
manure. When its spores ripen they are thrown by the plant
with considerable force, surrounded by the spore cases, in
the direction of the light. Jf a little fresh horse manure be
placed in a box with a small window, the filaments of the
mold turn toward the window, and as the spores ripen
they are thrown in their cases against the window to which
they adhere. A tree is felled by a land-slide or a tornado
308
Biology in America
and some of its roots are left embedded in the ground. Soon
the young flexible branches turn and grow upward opposite
to the direction of gravity. Roots, on the contrary, when
placed in a horizontal position, or inverted so as to point
upward, will soon respond to the pull of gravity and grow
downward. A seedling is suspended with its rootlets im-
mersed in a stream of water, and soon they bend and grow
against the current of the stream. Touch the leaves of the
Mimosa or sensitive plant and almost immediately the paired
MiNOSA OK Sensitive Plant
From Kerncr (translation l)y Oliver), "Natural History of Plants,'
Henry Holt and Company.
lobes of the leaflets fold together and the leaf itself droops
slightly, soon however resuming their original position if un-
disturbed.
The flowers of some plants serve as insect traps. In the
sun dew (Drosera) the leaves are covered with numerous little
hairs or tentacles, which secrete a sticky fluid, v;hich glistens
in the sun like drops of dew, whence the plant derives its
common name of "sun dew." Certain glands in the leaf
secrete a digestive enzyme similar to the pepsin of an animal's
stomach. If a drop of rain, or a grain of dust blown by
The Living Machine
309
the wind, fall on the leaf, there is no movement of the ten-
tacles or secretion of digestive fluid, but should an unlucky-
insect alight on a sun dew leaf attracted by the honey-like
drops upon the tentacles, they bend over and figuratively
speaking seize upon the intruder, while the edges of the leaf
fold together, thus wrapping the leaf about its body. The
digestive glands complete the tragedy and what was once an
insect now becomes incorporated in a leaf. Here we find a
relatively complex series of reactions co-ordinated, or working
in harmony, in an organism lacking any special nervous or
co-ordinating system altogether.
:.-->diL:
- -3
^^^^^^^^^
• F 1
if
i!5!^^^^^^"
Sun Dew Leaf
Showing sticky hairs and entrapped insect. From Needham and
Lloyd, "The Life of inland Waters," Comstock Publishing Company.
Can these responses of the unicellular animals and plants be
explained on a physico-chemical basis? This the leader of
the mechanist school in America, Jacques Loeb, endeavors
to do with his "forced movement" or "tropism theory'."
According to this theory every organism is in a state of
physiological equilibrium or balance with respect to a median
plane of symmetry, until it is subjected on one side or the
other to a stimulus, such as heat, light, electricity, etc. ;
which stimulus induces certain physico-chemical changes,
differing in degree on either side of the body, this difference
forcing the organism to respond unequally on the two sides,
and then perform a "forced movement" or a "tropism"
(turning). While a great many of the one-celled organisms
310
Biology in America
are not strictly symmetrical they may be assumed to be so
for the purposes of the theory. Thus if a Paramoecium be
acted upon by an electric current whose direction is oblique
to the long axis of its body, the cilia on the side toward the
negative pole beat more vigorously than do those on the
positive side, and in the opposite direction, causing the animal
to turn until it is in line with the current when it swims
ahead, toward the negative pole. The stem of a plant turns
toward the light, or bends upward, because of a difference
in amount of chemical substances on the two sides, and ''this
causes a difference in the velocity of chemical reactions be-
tween (the two sides)." The organism has no control over
its behavior but is so to speak blown about "by every wind
that blows" as helplessly as a derelict ship upon the sea.
Sagging in a Stem
Due to unequal growth on the two sides. From Loeb, "Forced Move-
ments, Tropisnis and Animal Conduct."
By permission oj J. B. Lippincott Company.
But what proof have we that such chemical changes as Loeb
asvsumes do occur in the organism? If we suspend a stem
of a plant in a horizontal position, it soon bends downward,
taking the form of a U. This bending is not due to sagging
of the stem as a rope sags, but rather to unequal growth of
the two sides, which can be proven by marking equal dis-
tances on upper and lower sides by lines of India ink and
later measuring the amount of growth occurring between
the marks. If the amount of bending in such a stem with
leaves attached be compared with that in a stem lacking
leaves, it will be found to be much greater in the former
due to the greater amount of growth material available, and
similarly there is greater bending in a stem furnished with a
The Living Machine
311
complete leaf than in one with a leaf which has been partly
cut awa3^ "What has been demonstrated in this case explains
probably also why the apex of many plants when put into
a horizontal position grows upward, and why certain roots
under similar conditions grow downward. It disposes also
in all probability of the suggestion that the apex of a posi-
tively geotropic root has 'brain functions.' It is chemical
mass action and not 'brain functions' which are needed to
produce the changes in growth underlying geotropic curva-
ture. "^
Such an explanation however is difficult to apply to many
Eelative Amount of Bending
Due to unequal growth in stems with and those without leaves.
Loeb, "Forced Movements, Tropisms and Animal Conduct."
By permission of J. B. Mppincott Company.
From
of the reactions of a Stentor or a Paramoecium. AVhile the
latter animal reacts to an electric current by a cjifference in
the beat of the cilia on the two sides, and the animal is thus
turned so as to swim with the current, by a process seem-
ingly as mechanical as that of turning a boat; in other
cases, as when running into a salt solution, the behavior of
Paramoecium is not so simply explained, for in this circum-
stance it always turns in the same direction, regardless of
the angle at which it meets the salt current, and even though
* Loeb, "Forced Movements, Tropisms and Animal Conduct," i)p.
121-2. By permission of J. B. Lippincott Company.
312 Biology in America
this turning may bring it towards, rather than away from
tlie unfavorable medium. Its behavior in this case is fixed in
character, and not so clearly mechanical as in the former
case.
A remarkable imitation of a living creature responsive to
light stimuli has been invented by the American engineer
John Hays Hammond, Jr. It "consists of a rectangular box
about 3 feet long, li/o feet wide and 1 foot high mounted on
three wheels, two of which are geared to a driving motor,
while the third and rear wheel can be turned by electro-
magnets and thus serve for guiding the machine. Two 5-inch
condensing lenses on the forward end appear very much like
large eyes. ' ' The operation of the machine is affected through
the action of light on two selenium cells controlling electro-
magnetic switches. "When one cell or both are illuminated
the current is switched on to the driving motor ; when one cell
alone is illuminated an electro-magnet is energized and aifects
the turning of the rear steering wheel . . . thus bringing the
shaded cell into the light. As soon and as long as both cells
are equally illuminated in sufficient intensity, the machine
moves in a straiglit line toward the light source. By throw-
ing a switch which reverses the driving motors, the machine
can be made to back away from the light in a most surpris-
ing manner.
"Upon shading or switching off the light the 'dog' can be
stopped immediately, but it will resume its course behind the
moving light so long as the light reaches the condensing
lenses in sufficient intensity. Indeed, it is more faithful in
this respect than the proverbial ass behind the bucket of
oats. To the uninitiated the performance of the pseudo dog
is very uncainiy indeed."*
But what is the case with those animals with a nervous sys-
tem by means of which their complex functions are made to
work in orderly fashion? It would take us too far afi<'ld to
attempt to trace, as Professor Parker has recently done in his
admirable little book on the "Elementary Nervous System,"
the relation between the specialization of the latter, and the
(delicacy) of their nervous responses. Suffice it to say that
even in animals with a highly developed nervous system such
as insects the responses in many cases at least appear to be
purely mechanical. The attraction of the candle flame for
the moth is proverbial, and even so highly organized an animal
as a bird fre(|uently appears to be as much a creature of cir-
cumstance as the moth, for birds often beat themselves to
death in great numbers against light-houses. The purely
mechanical response of an animal to stimuli is beautifully
^Mit'ssner, "Electrical Experimenter," Sept., 1915, p. 202.
The Living Machine 313
illustrated by the behavior of the caterpillar of the butterfly
(Porthesia chrysorrhcea). "This butterfly lays its eggs upon
a shrub, on which the larvae hatch in the fall and on which
they hibernate, as a rule, not far from the ground. As soon
as the temperature reaches a certain height, they leave the
nest; under natural conditions this happens in the spring
when the first leaves have begun to form on the shrub. (The
larvaB can however be induced to leave the nest at any time
in the winter provided the temperature is raised sufficiently.)
After leaving the nest, they crawl directly upward on the
shrub where they And the leaves on which they feed. If
the caterpillars should move down the shrub they would
starve, but this they never do, always crawling upward to
where they find their food. What gives the caterpillar this
never-failing certainty which saves its life and for which the
human being might envy the little larva? Is it a dim recol-
lection of experience of former generations, as Samuel Butler
would have us believe? It can be shown that this instinct
is merely positive heliotropism and that the light reflected
from the sky guides the animals upward. The caterpillars
upon waking from their winter sleep are violently positively
heliotropic, and it is this heliotropism which makes the ani-
mals move upward. At the top of the branch they come in
contact with a growing bud and chemical and tactile influ-
ences set the mandibles of the young caterpillar into activ-
ity. If we put these caterpillars into closed test tubes which
lie with their longitudinal axes at right angles to the window
they will all migrate to the window end where they will stay
and starve, even if we put their favorite leaves into the test
tube close behind them. These larva? are in this condition
slaves of the light.
* ' The few young leaves on top of a twig are quickly eaten by
the caterpillar. The light which saved its life by making it
creep upward where it finds its food would cause it to starve
could the animal not free itself from the bondage of positive
heliotropism. After having eaten it is no longer a slave of
light but can and does creep downward. It can be shown
that a caterpillar after having been fed loses its positive
heliotropism almost completely and permanently. If we sub-
mit unfed and fed caterpillars of the same nest to the same
artificial or natural source of light in two different test tubes
the unfed will creep to the light and stay there until tliey
die, while those that have eaten will pay little or no attention
to the light. Their positive heliotropism has disappeared
and the animal after having eaten can creep in any direction.
The restlessness which accompanies the condition of starva-
tion makes the animal leave the top of the branches and creep
314 Biology in America
downward — which is the only direction open to it — where it
finds new young leaves on which it can feed. The wonderful
hereditary instinct upon wliicli tlie life of the animal depends
is its positive heliotropism in the unfed condition and the
loss of this heliotropism after having eaten. The chemical
changes following the taking up of the food abolish the
heliotropism just as CO, arouses positive heliotropism in
certain Daphnia," °
Such an instinct as that of this caterpillar is however a
relatively simple one. Can those wonderfully complex in-
stincts of so many animals which are connected with the pro-
duction and care of the young be likewise relegated to the
realm of the purely mechanical? To bring the reactions of
so complex an organism as a vertebrate animal with its highly
developed brain, nerves and sense organs into line with those
of a unicellular form or a non-nervous plant in the present
state of our knowledge is a matter of great difficulty. It can
be shown with a reasonable degree of probability however that
even here what we call "instinct" may be purely a response
to physical or chemical stimuli, modified by certain substances
secreted by the body and known as "hormones" from the
Greek verb hormao to excite.
The role of tliese substances and the bearing which they
have on the "mechanistic conception of life" we shall dis-
cuss later, merely bearing in mind their existence at this
point, in order to appreciate what follows. ^
In many fish, as for example the minnow Fundulus, the
act of mating consists in the sexes pressing their bodies close
together in such a way that as the eggs are laid by the fe-
male the sperms are pressed out by the male and are thus
mixed with, and fertilize the eggs in the water. That this
behavior on the part of the female at least is similar to a
response to a solid object is shown by keeping the sexes sepa-
rate at the spawning season, in which case the female will
mate with the glass wall of the aquarium, when she happens
to come in contact with it. This reaction is usually devel-
oped only in the spawning season through the influence of
the hormones secreted at that time, but if the female is kept
permanently isolated from the male she may perform this act
at any time of year.
Loeb quotes the late Professor Whitman to the effect that
male pigeons isolated from the females will attempt to mate
with any solid object in their field of vision, e.g., glass bot-
tles, and even with objects which give only the optical im-
pression of a solid, namely their own shadow on the ground.
And Craig has shown that male pigeons under these eircum-
" Loeb, locus citatus, pp. 161-2.
The Living Machine 315
stances will respond to a human hand. ." 'The dove was kept
in a room where several men were at work, and he directed
his display behavior toward these men just as if they be-
longed to his own species. Each time I put food in his cage
he became greatly excited, charging up and down the cage,
bowing and cooing to me, and pecking my hand whenever it
came within his cage. From that day until the day of his
death, Jack continued to react in this social manner to hu-
man beings. He would bow-and-coo to me at a distance, or
to my face when near the cage ; but he paid greatest atten-
tion to the hand — naturally so, because it was the only part
with which he daily came into direct contact. He treated
the hand much as if it were a living bird. Not only were
his own activities directed toward the hand as if it were a
bird, but he received treatment by the hand in the same
spirit. The hand could stroke him, preen his neck, even pull
the feathers sharply. Jack had absolutely no fear, but ran
to the hand to be stroked or teased, showing the joy that all
doves show in the attentions of their companions.' When
this pigeon was almost a year old it was put into a cage with
a female pigeon, but although the female aroused the sexual
instinct of the formerly isolated male the latter did not mate
with her, but mated with the hand of his attendant when the
hand was put into the cage, and this continued throughout
the season. Thus the memory images acquired by the bird
at an impressionable age and period perverted its sexual
tropisms. ' ' '^
Light response is a common phenomenon among the fresh
water crustaceans. During broad daylight the upper levels
of a lake may be almost uninhabited by these little animals,
while at greater depths they occur in large numbers. As
night comes on they return to the upper regions which they
have deserted by day. Loeb has shown that the behavior of
some of these animals with respect to light can be totally
changed by chemical treatment. Thus the fresh water Daph-
nia, Gammarus and other Crustacea when in a condition in
which they do not respond to light can be made intensely
positively heliotropic by adding some acid to the fresh water,
especially weak CO,. If carbonated water or beer be added
to water containing some of these animals they "will collect
in a dense cluster on the window side of the dish." Other
chemicals including alcohol give the same results. The light-
minded reader may be inclined to draw an analogy between
this behavior and the tendency of some individuals to enter
into close communion with a lamp post in the "wee sma'
hours." The alkaloids caffein and strychnin on the other
' Quoted from Loeb, locus citatus, pp. 168-9.
316 Biology in America
hand will Tiiak(> the "fresh water Crustacean Diaptomus in-
tensely nefjatively heliotropie." Changes of temperature and
osmotic pressure may bring about similar results.
The social life of the wasps, bees and ants has long been a
subject for wonder and admiration. In the busy ant hive
is a nest full of conundrums for the student of animal be-
havior, the half of which have as yet scarcely been stated.
The life of these social insects is seemingly so complex that
we are accustomed to think of it in terms of human life and
so we have ''castes" of "drones" ' and "queens" and "work-
ers." Some of these latter are "soldiers," among whom we
find "scouts" and "officers," others are "nurees," still oth-
ers are "harvesters" whose duty it is to fill the "granaries,"
while yet others are "slave-makers," whose duty it is to go
out and capture "slaves." Some ants play the part of
"thieves" in other ants' nests. Yet others act as "hosts"
entertaining other species of ants as "guests," while some
keep aphids which they milk as "cows." Some give to other
ants a "shampoo," in return for which the "delighted" ant
yields a drop of honey, which the shampooer licks up greed-
ily. Ants are "brave" and fight with "ferocity," while all
are "industrious" and endowed with "wisdom," Mark Twain
to the contrary notwithstanding.
Can such ' ' human ' ' behavior be removed from the realm of
poetrj^ and relegated to the prosaic one of purely mechanical
reflex ?
One of the most remarkable periods in the life of the ant
is the swarming time, w'hen the winged males and "queens"
perform their "nuptial" flight, rushing forth in "ecstasy"
from their nest to found new colonies. After this flight the
males die, the females pull off their wings and crawling into
the ground either alone or accompanied by a group of work-
ers, settle down to the humdrum duty of egg laying. Is such
behavior a response to a purely physical or chemical stimu-
lus? According to Loeb this "wedding flight" is a "helio-
tropie phenomenon presumably due to substances produced
in the body during this period, . . . (for) at a certain time
— in the writer's observation toward sunset, when the sky is
illuminated at the horizon only — the whole swarm of males
and females leave the nest and fly in the direction of the
glow"* After removing her wings the female loses her
heliotropism and becomes strongly stereotropic, responding
to touch stimuli, for if placed in a dark box containing folds
of cloth, she is found snugly tucked aw^ay among the folds.
' This term belongs of course properly to insects, and is applied sec-
ondarilj' to man.
' Loeb, locus citatus, p. 158.
The Living Machine 317
It is this stereotropism which causes her to seok a hidinj?
place ill the earth wherein to lay her eggs. This explanation
would be very simple and satisfying did we know what it is
which makes the ant at one moment responsive to light and
at another to touch. "Presumably" Locb's explanation is cor-
rect, but so long as it is founded on presumption only, it can
hardly be said to be strictly scientific.
Professor Vernon Kellogg has however made some observa-
tions on the swarming of bees which prove pretty conclu-
sively that this behavior is due to positive heliotropism in
this insect. Professor Kellogg 's bees were kept in a cloth
jacketed hive, with a small opening at the bottom. He says,
"Last spring at the normal swarming time, while standing
near the jacketed hive, I heard the excited hum of a begin-
ning swarm and noted the first issuers rushing pellinell from
the entrance. Interested to see the behavior of the com-
munity in the hive during such an ecstatic condition as that
of swarming, I lifted the cloth jacket, when the excited mass
of bees which was pushing frantically down to the small exit
in the lower corner of the hive turned with one accord about
face and rushed directly upward away from the opening
toward and to the top of the hive. Here the bees jammed,
struggling violently. I slipped the jacket partly on ; the ones
covered turned down ; the ones below stood undecided ; I
dropped the jacket completely ; the mass began issuing from
the exit again ; I pulled off the jacket, and again the whole
community of excited bees flowed — that is the word for it,
so perfectly aligned and so evenly moving were all the indi-
viduals of the bee current — up to the closed top of the hive.
Leaving the jacket off permanently, I prevented the issuing
of the swarm until the ecstasy was passed and the usual
quietly busy life of the hive was resumed. About three hours
later there was a similar performance and failure to issue
from the quickly unjacketed hive. On the next daj^ another
attempt to swarm was made, and after nearly an hour of
struggling and moving up and down, depending on my
manipulation of the black jacket, most of the bees got out of
the hive's opening and the swarming came off on a weed
bunch near the laboratory. That the issuance from the hive
at swarming time depends upon a sudden extra-development
of positive heliotropism seems obvious. The ecstasy comes
and the bees crowd for the one spot of light in the normal
hive, namely, the entrance opening. But Avhen the covering
jacket is lifted and the light comes strongly in from above
— my hive was under a skylight — they rush toward tlie top,
that is, toward the light. Jacket on and light shut off from
above, down they rush; jacket off and light stronger from
318 Biology in America
above tliaii })clo\v and tlicy respond like iron filings in front
of an eleetromagnet which has its current suddenly turned
on."«
Our knowledge of what occurs when an impulse is sent over
a nerve is very vague, but we have certain knowledge that
physical and chemical changes take place in nerve cells and
fibers coincident with such impulses, so that we are justified
in believing that these impulses are physico-chemical phenom-
ena. At the University of Chicago a young Japanese,
Tashiro, a few years ago designed a very delicate little in-
strument which he calls the biometer, or measurer of life.
By means of this instrument he is able to detect traces of
carbon dioxide as small as one thirty-millionth of an ounce.
If a living nerve fiber be placed in the biometer and stimu-
lated by an electrical current it is found to give off carbon
dioxide as the other tissues of the body when they are made
to work. There is combustion of living matter then when
an impulse travels along a nerve. In the body of a nerve
cell are certain peculiarly staining masses known as the
Nissl bodies. When a nerve cell is stimulated successively
several times these bodies disappear. Some chemical sub-
stance has been consumed in the activity of the cell. Nervous
activity develops electrical currents which can be meas-
ured on a galvanometer, and with very delicate instruments
electrical currents can even be detected in the resting nerve.
The impulse is not instantaneous but requires measurable
time for its transmission. The intensity of the impulses
can be measured, as one measures the intensity of sound,
light, electrical energ>^ or other physical energy. Nerve ac-
tion can be checked by means of suitable chemicals (anes-
thetics), while on the other hand certain substances, such as
sodium, increase it. Anesthetics may produce similar ef-
fects in non-nervous tissues and even in non-living matter.
Thus Osterhout has shown that small quantities of anesthet-
ics in the sea water decrease the electrical conductivity of
seaweed, and several obseryers have shown that they check
the passage of substances through cell membranes. If char-
coal made from blood be mixed with a solution of oxalic acid
containing free oxygen, the acid is changed to carbon diox-
ide and water, the charcoal acting as a catalyzer. This
catalytic power of the charcoal can be retarded by certain
substances (i.e., carbon bisulphide) which act as anesthetics
and which can also check the action of finely divided plat-
inum in the separation (catalysis) of hydrogen peroxide to
w^ater and oxygen. If therefore anesthetics produce effects
in non-nervous and even in non-living substances similar to
» Kellogg, V, "Some Insect Keflexes," "Science," XVIII, pp. 693-4.
The Living Machine 319
those which they produce in nerves, we have good reason to
believe that their action on the latter is similar to that on
the former or that the prevention of nervous action, and
therefore that action itself is fundamentally a physico-chem-
ical one.
But can physics and chemistry explain all the complicated
instincts of the insect, bird and mammal, or the as yet un-
solved riddle of human thought? Frankly we must admit
that at present we do not know. According to Loeb these
are merely ''tropistic reactions" modified by "memory
images," which have an "orienting effect" upon the organ-
ism, and which he attempts to explain by an illustration
from the behavior of the solitary wasp Ammophila, which
digs a hole in the ground in which to lay its eggs.
Ammophila, a solitary wasp, makes a small hole in the
ground and then goes out to hunt for a caterpillar, which,
when found, it paralyzes by one or several stings. The wasp
carries the caterpillar back to the nest, puts it into the hole,
and covers the latter with sand. Before this is done, it de-
posits its eggs on the caterpillar which serves the young larva
as food.
"An Ammophila had made a hole in a flower bed and left"
the flower bed flying. A little later I saw an Ammophila
running on the sidewalk of the street in front of the garden,
dragging a caterpillar which it held in its mouth. The
weight of the caterpillar prevented the wasp from flying.
The garden was higher than the sidewalk and separated from
it by a stone wall. The wasp repeatedly made an attempt
to climb upon the stone wall, but kept falling down. Sus-
pecting that it might have a hole prepared in the garden,
I was curious to see whether and how it would find the hole.
It followed the wall until it reached the neighboring yard,
which had no wall. It now left the street and crawled into
this yard, dragging the caterpillar along. Then crawling
through the fence which separated the two yards, it dropped
the caterpillar near the foot of a tree, and flew away. After
a short zigzag flight it alighted on a flower bed in which I
noticed two small holes. It soon left the bed and flew back to
the tree, not in a straight line but in three stages, stopping
twice on its way. At the third stop it landed at the place
where the caterpillar lay. The catei-pillar was then dragged
to the hole, pulled into it, and the hole was covered with tiny
stones in the usual Avay. ' ' ^°
Aside from the fact that we have no explanation of the
physico-chemical processes underlying these "memory
images," it is difficult to apply the theory to many of the
"Loeb, locus citatus, p. 170.
320 Biology in America
common reactions of higher animals. Can "memory images"
teach a bird liow to build its nest for the first time, or guide
the bees in the eonstruetiou of theii* wonderful condjs? Can
tlieir "oi-ientiug effect" explain the return to its nest of the
terns 'whieh AVatson carried from the Florida Keys to Cape
Ilatteras, a distance of 150 miles from their houu\ into a re-
gion never before visited by the birds? Possibly, although
it requires a mighty effort of the imagination to unite cause
and effect in this instance. But it is easy to find flaws in
any theory Avhieh boldly ventures into the comparatively
uncharted sea of animal reactions, and endeavors tliere to
lay down a course which we may in safety follow ; so let us
comfort ourselves with believing that "free will" has no
place in science, but is merely an expression of the "verbal-
ists," and tliat we simply "go where our legs carry us," a
theory which has at least the advantage of enabling us to
smile complacently, while ancient preachers hurl their an-
athemas at the damned.
We have spoken above of certain substances secreted by
the animal body and known as hormones, which exercise a
determining influence in animal behavior. What are these
substances, how are they formed and what role do they play
in animal physiology?
The recognition of the value of various organs in curing
disease goes back to the days of Hippocrates, the "father
of medicine," and since his time many such remedies have
been proposed. Thus the liver of the pigeon or the wolf were
used in cases of disease of the liver, the rabbit's brain was
given for tremors, and the lung of the fox for difficulty in
breathing. The testicles of the donkey or the stag were rec-
ommended by Pliny foi- the renovation of the debauchee, and
even today (castoreum) a preparation obtained from the
prei)utial glands of the beaver is sometimes employed for
colic, hysteria and other disorders. In more recent days the
French physiologist Claude Bernai'd advanced the view that
all tissues give some secretion to the blood, which is of use
in the nutrition of the body, and while our knowledge of
these substances is as yet very fragmentary, their great im-
portance in the life of the animal and their usefulness in the
treatment of various disorck'rs, are widely recognized. It is
known for example that diabetes, which is marked by the
presence of sugar in the urine, is not a kidney disorder, but
is due to improper actio]i of the pancreas, as a result of
which a specific secretion, passed by the latter into the blood
stream and functioning in sugar metabolism, is absent or re-
duced in amount.
Imperfect development of the thyroid gland leads to the
The Living Machine 321
condition of under development both mental and physical,
which is known as cretinism from tlie French word cretin.
Feeding the extract of the thyroid gland of a sheep, or the
gland itself, either raw or cooked, results in great increase in
growth and development of both mind and body in such cases.
The use of adrenalin (extract of the adrenal ghmd of some
animal) is a common practise in certain diseases and in-
juries as, for example, asthma, in which injections of the
drug relax the bronchial muscles, and greatly relieve the suf-
ferer. Attached to the lower, central part of the brain is a
small gland, the pituitary body, which some enthusiastic the-
orists have fancied to be the seat of the soul. If this gland
be partly removed from a young puppy it ceases to grow ex-
cept for the accumulation of fat. It keeps its puppy hair
and milk teeth, while the development of the genital organs,
and of the intelligence is much retarded.
After partial digestion in the stomach, the food is further
digested in the upper end of the small intestine. The di-
gestive juices come in part from the liver and wall of the
intestine itself, and in part from the pancreas. When the*
partly digested and acid food passes from the stomach into
the intestine, it causes the pancreatic juice to flow as auto-
matically as the movement of the piston in a gasoline engine
causes the intake of gasoline from the supply tank. The
pancreas is activated by the acid food in the intestine. It
was formerly supposed that this activation was effected by
reflex nerve action, but we now know of an entirely differ-
ent mechanism for this function. If an acid extract of the
lining of the intestine be injected into the blood it causes the
pancreas to secrete its juice as surely as does the presence
of acid food in the intestine ; while similar extracts of other
organs have no such effect. Here there is clear evidence of
an internal secretion formed by the intestine, which reach-
ing the pancreas via the blood causes the latter to act. A
beautiful example of the chemical control of bodily func-
tions.
On the run of any through train between the terminals
of a great trunk line there is a change of engines about once
every 200 or 250 miles. Neither engine nor crew can give
as effective service if operating for greater distances. The
non-living, as well as the living machine needs rest after a
certain period of work.
Recently the well-known surgeon, Crile of Cleveland, has
advanced an interesting theory which he calls the "kinetic
drive" to explain the running down of the human mechan-
ism. In the "kinetic drive" of modern life, when the hu-
man machine is being driven at top speed, stored or poten-
322
Biology in Ame7'ica
tial eiierfry is convert chI into active or kinetic energy, and the
tissues of the body sutler corresponding loss. According
to Crile certain pai-ts of the brain furnish the nervous en-
ergy, which is probably identical with electrical energy, and
wliich controls muscular, and otlier activity. The adrenal
ghiiids furnish adrenalin, which in some way determines the
oxidation processes in the brain to which the nervous energy
is due. The thyroid gland, which Crile calls the ''pace-
maker" of the body, furnishes iodin to the tissues and ren-
Effect of the Kinetic Drive
Photograph of a sohlier under extreme mental and physical stress.
From Crile, " Tlie Kinetic Drive." "Journal of the American Medical
Association," Vol. LXV.
ders them more permeable to the nervous impulses. In the
conversion of energy in 'the body certain acid waste products
are formed which are eliminated by the liver, kidneys and
lungs. The blood is thus kept alkaline, in Avhich condition
only is the carriage of oxygen to the tissues possible.
If the production of adrenalin, the secretion of the ad-
renal glands, be prevented, either by removal of these glands,
by cutting the nerves which supply them or by narcotizing
the latter Avith morphin, activity is reduced. On the other
hand administration of adrenalin produces results similar to
The Living Machine
323
those of exertion, emotion, injury, etc., all of which lead
to increase of energy change, while its continual adminis-
tration leads to symptoms of exhaustion siuih as disorders
of heart or kidney. Excessive doses of iodine also "cause
Effect of the Kinetic Drive on The Tissues op the Body.
Above, left to right, section of normal cerobelhun, adrenal and liver;
below, sections of the same organs of a soldier who ' ' had snffered
from hunger, thirst and loss of sleep, had made the extraordinary forced
march of 180 miles from Mons to the Marne; in the midst of the great
battle was wounded by the explosion of a shell; lay for hours awaiting
help and died from exhaustion soon after reaeliing the ambulance. ' '
From Crile, "The Kinetic Drive," "Journal of the American Medical
Association," Vol. LXV.
all the phenomena of emotion and exertion, and inversely
. . . emotion, infection, exertion, etc., cause changes in the
iodine content of the thyroid."
The results of the kinetii; diive are evident in changes of
the tissues. The brain of a man who has died from exhaus-
324 Biology in America
tion gives a very different picture from that of a man killed
accidentally, certain of the cells having almost disappeared
in the forme?'. The injection of poison (i.e. diphtheria toxin)
into a dog- will produce similar changes in the l)rain, hut these
changes can he in large measure prevented by the injection
of mori)hin at the same time as the toxin, the former check-
ing the nervous action induced by the latter.
"Never before has there been such an opportunity for
studying the behavior of the human mechanism uiidci- the
strongest physical and psychic stress as in wari-ing Europe
today. Tlioi-e ol)servations of the injured, of soldiers in the
field, of ])i'isoners and of refugees gave me an unparalleled
opportunity for studying the human kinetic drive on a vast
scale. The illustration shows the gross effect of the combina-
tion of extreme emotion and exertion as they are manifested
in the faces and bearing of Belgium refugees and of wounded
soldiers.
"Turning now from the individual acutely driven by in-
jury, by infection, by emotion, let us consider the individual
chronically driven by the stinuili of want, ambition, anger,
jealousy or grief, by infection, by pain and by autointoxica-
tion. In the acute kinetic drive the individual is endan-
gered by death from exhaustion or from acid intoxication,
whereas in the chronic drive, the danger is that one or an-
other of the overdriven organs or tissues may be perma-
nently injured.
"The common chronic drives are mental and physical over-
work, chronic infections, excessive diet and pregnancy, the
emotions of fear, hate, jealousy, shame and despair, and for-
eign proteins, as in intestinal stasis. These conditions pre-
sent every-day problems and demand but little discussion.
Since the lesions of these various driving causes are the same,
however; since infection, emotion. and overwork produce iden-
tical end-effects; since usually two or more of these operate
simultaneously, and since the emotional states are most amen-
able to control, it becomes obvious why these conditions have
often been controlled by means which have apparently no
direct therapeutic value, such as faith in the physician, travel,
diversion, prayer, healing springs, philosophy and Christian
Science. Again and again, in the domain of regular medi-
cine as in the domain of irregular medicine, the exclusion
of worry has relieved the drive sufficiently to allow the body
processes to overcome the primary disease. But the reverse is
true also — innumerable men, under tlie strain of a chronic
drive, are pushed beyond the narrow limits of safety by the
added drive of grief, worry or shame. Is it not possible that
when it is understood that the various kinetic stimuli have
The Living Machine 325
interchangeable physical values, the game of health will be
more skilfully played f"^^
Not only may poisons, emotion and fatigue induce the
kinetic drive, but surgical shock, while the patient is an-
esthetized, coupled with the terror of the knife before the
operation, are also powerfidly inducing causes. While the
jjatient may be entirely unconscious during the operation,
there is nevertheless a great drain upon tlie nervous system
induced by the action of the knife. To overcome these as
much as possible Doctor Crile takes every ])ains to render the
patient mentally at ease before the operation and block the
kinetic drive by the use of morphin and by local anesthesia.
Doctor Crile's theory and this operative method are gen-
erally known as that of "anoci-association," or the pre-
vention of the exhaustion of nervous energy through opera-
tive shock. Experiments upon which it is based have led
him to many other discoveries in the field of operative sur-
gery, which have rendered his name famous, but this brief
sketch must suffice as an illustration of the automatic and
mechanical operation of the human machine.
One of the most striking examples of the role of hormones
or internal secretions is the action of the sex glands in con-
trolling both body form and mental activity. The physical
and mental changes occurring in both boj^s and girls at the
time of puberty are too well known to require even passing
mention here, while the dependence on the proper function-
ing of the sex glands of the secondary sexual characters, such
as the horns of the deer, the comb and feathering of the
cock, the size of the stallion, and innumerable others, is equally
familiar to everyone. Horses and cattle are castrated to ren-
der them docile and serviceable as draft animals, and the
cock is castrated in order that he may take on more flesh and
become a welcome member of our dinner parties. A curious
case is that of the race of poultry known as sebrights where
the male goes masquerading in female attire, while the fe-
male wears the habit of the male. Castration of either sex
of these chickens results curiously enough in their adoption
of their proper garb, either male or female.
We are accustomed to think of the control of mind over
matter and to regard the processes of thought as transcend-
ing the bounds of the purely material universe, and yet where
could we have a more beautiful example of the chemical (and
therefore purely material) control of living processes, men-
tal as well as physical, tlian in the case of the hormones or
internal secretions of the animal body?
"Crile, "Journal of the Aiuerican Medical Association," LXV, p.
213 2.
Sebright Poultry
Photoj^raplis of a normal scbrijjlit cock (ahovo), Avhich has the
plumage of the hen, and castrated cock (below), which has male feathers.
After Morgan, "Physical Basis of Heredity."
Courtesy of Professor Morgan and the J. B. Lipphuott Company.
326
The Living Machine 327
Of all the features characteristic of living matter, none is
more so than reproduction. Attempts have, it is true, been
made to compare the growth of many crystals of salt in a
concentrating solution with this miracle of life, but such at-
tempts sound like a mere play upon words. There is noth-
ing in the inorganic world in any way comparable to this
wonderful phenomenon. Here then, if anywhere in the world
of life, we should tind evidence of some force higher than
the physical forces, did any such exist. But what do we
find? We have seen in a previous chapter that the method
of reproduction (bi-sexual or parthenogenetic) can be altered
by external means; furthermore in Hydra it can similarly
be changed from asexual (budding) to sexual. In some
plants likewise the kind of reproduction may be determined
by external factors. But beyond the mere shifting of the
mode of reproduction by physical or chemical stimuli, it
has been found that the process of sexual reproduction itself
is a physico-chemical one and can be accomplished by arti-
ficial means. In the first place the attraction between the sex
cells is in some cases, though apparently not in all, a chem-
ical one. If a capillary glass tube containing a weak solu-
tion of malic acid (the acid found in apples and other fruits)
be placed in water containing the sperms of ferns and mosses,
the latter are attracted by the acid, and will enter the tube
in great numbers. The action here however may be similar
to that described above of "trapping" Paramoecium in a drop
of acid. With the spermatozoa of the sea urchin however
such chemical attraction appears not to exist. The union of
egg and sperm in cases where chemical attraction cannot be
proven appears to be due to chance. It is a well-known
fact that it is very difficult to cross different species of ani-
mals, this difference indeed being made the basis for a physi-
ological definition of species, those animals which breed to-
gether and produce fertile offspring being grouped as one
species ; and those which do not interbreed, or do not at least
produce fertile offspring being classed as distinct. In lower
animals union of egg and sperm of different species may be
prevented by physical differences such as size, or -ihemical
differences may prevent the development of an egg into which
by chance a foreign sperm has entered. In some cases it is
possible to fertilize the egg of species A with the sperm of
B, but the reciprocal cross is impossible. Among higher types
there appears to exist a mutual repugnance to union, which
effectually bars intermingling. Yet even here occasional in-
stances of crossing and the production of fertile offs]iring
are known, in crosses of hares and rabbits, various species of
fish, etc. Crosses between members of widely distinct groups
328 Biology in America
of animals are practically unknown in nature, and yet Loeb
has succeeded in cross fertilizing tlie sea urchin's egg with the
spenu of several s])ecies of starfish and one of tlie brittle
stars, by simply adding a little sodium hydroxide or car-
bonate to the sea water containing the eggs.
The entrance of the sperm into the egg induces changes
in tlie latter which can likewise be induced by chemical
means. When the sperm of a sea urchin strikes the egg the
two adhere to each other, due prol)al)ly to a sticky secretion
of the latter. A few moments later the very delicate mem-
brane surrounding the egg is pushed off from the surface
and considerably thickened, due probably to absorption of
water. The cause of this membrane formation (or better,
membrane extrusion) is the li(iuefying of the surface of the
egg just beneath the membrane and its consequent absorp-
tion of water. Subsequent to this membrane formation the
sperm head or nucleus penetrates still farther into the egg
leaving the tail adherent to the egg membrane, while the egg
nucleus advances to meet it, the two fuse and fertilization^ is
accomplished, to be followed shortly by the division of the
egg into first two, then four, eight, sixteen cells, and so on.
INlany Avorkers have succeeded in imitating the processes of
fertilization and causing the eggs of a large number of spe-
cies of animals to develop parthenogenetically by various
methods of treatment. In the case of the sea urchin Loeb
fii'st treats the egg with some chemical (i.e., butyric or other
monobasic fatty acid) which induces membrane formation,
and then follows this treatment by placing the egg in sea
water containing a little more salt than usual, or into nor-
mal sea water lacking oxygen. The two procedures are es-
sential to development, for if the first alone be employed the
egg disintegrates after extruding its membrane, without fur-
ther development. A similar result sometimes occurs when
a sea urchin egg is fertilized by starfish sperm. Here the
entrance of the sperm is very slow, some ten to fifty min-
utes compared with about a minute in the case of sperm of
the same species. In the former case, owing no doubt to the
slow penetration of the spcimi, the latter does not always en-
ter the egg, but remains attached to the extruded membrane.
It seems therefore that the sperm secretes two distinct sub-
stances, one of which causes liquefaction of the surface layer
of the egg, with consequent al)sorption of water and extru-
sion of the membrane, while the other causes the initial de-
velopment (division of the egg) to ensue. The action of this
second substance is not yet clearly understood but apart
from the experiments in artificial parthenogenesis and the
occasional cessation of devcloijuient after membrane forma-
The Living Machine 329
tion in the cross fertilization experiments just mentioned,
there are numerous other evidences of the action of two
substances in fertilization. If, for example, the sea urchin
egg be treated with the sperm of sharks or roosters, or with
the blood or extracts of the organs of some invertebrates, or
the blood sera of cattle, sheep, pigs or rabbits, membrane
extrusion is induced but development soon ceases, unless the
egg be transferred to a strengthened solution of sea water,
in which development progresses for a time at least. The
initial effect here (membrane extrusion) is the same as that
obtained by the use of a fatty acid in artificial partheno-
genesis, the second effect (division of the egg) being obtained
in the same manner in both cases. There are many other
ways in which eggs can be made to develop without fertiliza-
tion: brushing the surface of the egg with a tine brush, plung-
ing it for a few moments into concentrated sulphuric acid
and pricking the egg membrane have all been successfully
employed. The egg of even so highly organized an animal as
the frog has been made to develop simply by pricking the
egg membrane, and the resulting embryo reared to the adult
state.
What more striking evidence could be asked of the physico-
chemical nature of life, than the development of a new be-
ing by these means ?
Far distant though we be from a solution of the "riddle
of life" our only present hope of ultimate success is to pro-
ceed from the known to the unknown, working on the hy-
pothesis that nature is a unity and not a duality, and that
the same fundamental laws control organic and inorganic
worlds alike.
CHAPTER XIII
Color in Nature. Colors of floivcrs and the inter-relation
of flowers and insects. Colors of animals and their physico-
chemical causes. The theories of protective coloration, warri-
ing and alluring colors, mimicry and recognition marks.
But few American naturalists have entered the broad and
fascinating field of Nature's colors. The subject was one
of intense interest to Darwin and his co-workers, Wallace,
Bates and Fritz Miiller, and has been largely developed by
the recent Darwinians in Germany and England. A few
Americans however have made valuable contributions to the
subject w4iich w'e shall consider in this chapter.
What is the cause and what the function of the bewilder-
ing array of colors which we find on every hand? Are they
useful to their possessors, and hence preserved through se-
lection, or are they simply an expression of a reckless gener-
osity of Nature, who lavishes her gifts with wild prodigality
upon her creatures, regardless of whether they are bene-
fited thereby or no? In the case of chlorophyl, the green
coloring matter of leaves, and haemoglobin to which the red
color of the blood is due, we know of course the physiolog-
ical value, but most colors (those of flowers and insects for
example) are of uncertain value, although many very pretty
theories have been invented to account for them.
The colors of flowers are formed as by-products of their
metabolism. Their function is possibly to attract insects and
thus aid in their fertilization. We have all of us been fa-
miliar since childhood with the "busy little bee," and how_ it'
"employs each shining hour" has ever been set before us for
our edification and emulation; but the beautiful manner in
which Nature has fashioned her children, both bee and flower,
for the accomplishment of her "purpose" is not so familiar
to us all. To attempt to recount here even in small measure
the life of the bee would carry us too far aside from our
main theme, and would moreover be a thankless task for one
following in the footsteps of a Maeterlinck or a Fabre. We
may however pause for a moment to consider the relation
between a single sort of bee and a single kind of flower, in
order to gain some notion of the wonderful co-adaptation
330
Color in Nature
331
existing between them. The body of a worker honey bee,
which gathers the honey and the pollen for the hive, and
performs all the other "chores" of the bee community, such
as those of nurse maid, house cleaner, biitler, architect, po-
liceman, and even executioner and undertaker, is clothed
with numerous branched hairs, to which the pollen adheres
as &e bee goes crawling about in the cups of the flowers
which it visits. On one of the joints of the middle leg of
the bee is a groove, overhung by rows of stiff bristles, form-
ing the "pollen basket," while another joint of the same leg
carries several rows of bristles or "pollen combs," by means
of which the pollen is combed out of the hairs and trans-
ferred to the pollen basket where it sticks in the form of a
large ball. The "basket" enables the bee to carry more
Eelation of Bee and Flower, a Salvia.
1, flower parts in usual position; 2, anthers ereet; 3, anthers tipped
down; 4, bee entering flower; 5, flower with extruded style. From
Kellogg, after Lubbock.
pollen to its hive than it could if it depended solely on the
hairs for this purpose. A part of the bee's esophagus is
enlarged to form a "honey sac" in which is stored the nec-
tar which it sucks from the flowei-s, and which in the hive
is evaporated to form the honey.
As the bee goes buzzing about from flower to flower, in
search of nectar, some of the pollen from one flower is trans-
ferred to another, and fertilization is thus effected. The
manifold modifications of various types of flowers to ensure
transference of pollen by insects, and to admit only those
species which will pay for their supply of honey by trans-
ferring pollen, the insect Bolsheviki and I.W.W.'s, which
would appropriate the honey but carry no pollen in return,
332 Biology in America
being debarred from entrance, are so numerous and won-
derful as to need for their description a volume in itself.
We must content ourselves with a single instance.
In one of tlie Salvias (S. officinalis) the stamens ripen
before the pistil, so tliat the flower cannot fertilize itself
with its own pollen/ Tlie corolla of the flower consists of
two lobes or lips, an upper and a lower, the former enclos-
ing the style and stamens and the lower serving as a landing
stage for insect visitors. Before the ovary ripens the style
is withdrawn within the upper lobe of the corolla, as shown
at 1 in the preceding figure; after ripening it hangs down
over the lower lip, 5. In the former position it is not ordi-
narily toiiclied l)y an insect entering the flower, while in the
latter it obviously must be. The functional stamens are two
in number, placed close together at the base of the hood.
Each stamen bears two anthers, separated by a long connec-
tive, which stands upright beneath the hood. The lower
pair of anthers contain little or no pollen, while the upper
pair are full of it. If a bee alights on the lower lip and
attempts to make his way into the flower tube, where the nec-
tar is hidden, his head must first of all encounter the lower
pair of partly developed anthers. As these are pushed before
him in his effort to enter, the upper pair are swung down
upon their hinge, striking the bee's back and depositing
thereon their load of pollen. Thus the bee, visiting this
Salvia, is either besprinkled with pollen to be carried to an-
other flower, or deposits some of its pollen upon the hanging
styles ready to receive it, according to the stage of develop-
ment of ovaries and stamens.
The question of the part played by flower color in these
transactions is very perplexing, and calls for much more in-
vestigation. Some authors maintain, while others deny, the
power of insects to distinguish color, and more especially
to discriminate between color i)atterns in flowers. An in-
sect's power of sight is probably very limited, so that its
distinction of the form, and possibly also of the color of
flowers at any considerable distance is doubtful. There are
however some very clear experiments showing ability on the
part of insects to distinguish color, but the whole question is
still very doubtful.
Animal colors fall into two classes — the chemical and the
physical, or a combination of the two. The chemical colors
are due to pigments diffused inainly through either the sur-
' In sonic species of plants tlic flowers are on the contrary so con-
structed as to insure self-fertilization. The whole question of the in-
fluence of inbreedinjj upon virility in both plants and animals is very
uncertain at the present time. See page 85.
Color in Nature 333
face cells, the cnticula or elsewhere, or else lodged in spe-
cial cells knowu as chroniat()j)hores, the absorption of cer-
tain rays of light by these pigments, and the reflection of
their complementary rays causing the various colors. Pig-
ments develop through the action of an oxidizing ferment
upon a color-forming substance or chromogen, and numy
different pigments may be merely different stages in the mcxli-
fication of a single chromogen. Thus the brown and black
pigments of animals pass through yellow, orange and red
stages, before attaining their final color.
The influence of external factors in producing more or
less permanent color changes in animals has been discussed
in a previous chapter, dealing with the influence of the en-
vironment upon the development of the individual. Tem-
porary changes in the hue or color of animals may resultin
response to external stimuli. The chameleon is the class-
ical example of this. Temperature and light appear to be
the controlling stimuli although their effects differ in differ-
ent species. Fear may affect the color of an animal. Thus
it is possible to cause a frog to "turn pale with fear" by
continually disturbing it with a stick or otherwise. The color
changes in these cases are due to changes in the distribution
of the granules of pigment in the chromatophores ; when the
pigment is distributed throughout the cell the color is darker,
when concentrated around the nucleus the reverse is true.
One of the most remarkable cases of color adaptation
known is that of the flatfish. Symmetrical both in form and
color in its early stages this fish soon turns on its side and
thereafter lies on the bottom of the sea. Accompanying this
change in life the eyes, fins and mouth shift to the upper
side of the body, and the lower side loses its color. But,
as the English naturalist Cunningham has shown, the color
will return to the lower side in fish kept in an a<iuarium
which is lighted from below. Living on tlie bottom the flat-
fish finds itself from time to time on differently colored back-
grounds, now on white and now on dark sand, and again
on gravel of various shades and patterns. Tn an extensive
series of experiments Sumner has shown tliat this species
adjusts its color to match that of its background with won-
derful accuracy; and that further this change is affected in
some unknown way through the nervous system in response
to sight, for if the eye be removed the power of adjustment
is lost with it.
The physical colors of animals are due to the form of the
body surface, causing refraction and the fornuition of "me-
tallic" coloring, or interference of the reflected light rays,
thus producing the wonderful iridescence characteristic of
334
Biulogy in America
many boetlos and birds. Metallic colors and iridescence are
generally super-imposed on pigment color producing a com-
pound eil'ect, white being the only purely physical color that
we know in animals.
The functions of animal colors are doubtless manifold, but
concerning them our knowledge is unfortunately very frag-
mentary. Omitting those internal i)igments such as haemo-
globin, bile pigments and the like, which are intimately re-
lated to the physiology of the animal, and pigments derived
from tlie animal's food, such as the green or yellow color of
some caterpillars fed on green leaves or yellow flowers re-
One of the Flatfishes
Animals having remarkable powers of adjusting their appearance to
the bottom on which they lie. The same fish jjhotographed on different
backgrounds.
Courtesy of Dr. F. B. Sumner.
spectively ; and considering surface color only, we are struck
with the apparent lack of any physiological use of such color.
One might expect arctic animals to bo black so as to absorb
the maximum of heat energy from the sun, and tropical ani-
mals to be white, thereby reflecting the sun's rays and avoid-
ing absorption of heat; but the reverse is true of the for-
mer, Avhile the latter are widely variable in color.
How then may the multitude of colors and markings in ani-
mals be explained? The follower of Danvin bases his an-
swer on the efficacy of selection in preserving those forms
Color in Nature
335
whicli are best adapted to their environment. AVith seleetion
then as a framework a number of theories have been ad-
vanced in explanation of animal colors.
The first of these is that of protective color which may be
Protective Form and Color in Animals
A. Woodcock on her nest. From a photograph by Dugniore.
B. Night hawk on a log.
C. Toad on ground.
1). Tree toad on hark.
E. Tree lizards on oak bark.
F. Caterpillar on twig.
From Metcalf , ' ' Organic Evolution. ' '
By permission of the Macmillan Company.
either general or specific. '^ Camouflage" is not a new art
to animals, and man in adapting it to his own use has been'
merely following the advice of Solomon, and learning wis-
dom from the humbler creatures of field and forest. The
existence of a close resemblance between many animals and
3.1G
Biolof/ii i)i America
A Leap Insect
Courtesy of the U. S. Bureau of Entomology.
their backgroinid must be evident to anyone who has ever
wandered afield in search of Nature's creatures. Whoever
is skeptical as to this statement may readily verify it by a
Group of Walking Stick Inskcts
Courtesy of the U. S. Bureau of Entomology.
search for the "peeper," the first of the frog orchestra to
give melody to our marshes in the spring. Or let him look
for a grasshopper after it lias jumped, for a night hawk on
Color in Naturo
337
the ground or a tree toad on bark. But yet more striking
examples of i)rote(dive eolor are furnished l)y those ani-
mals whicli closely resemble some particular object. There
are certain caterpillars commonly known as "measuring
worms" which progress by a series of looping movements,
first attaching themselves by the fore feet and then drawing
up the hind feet, thus forming a loop of the body between.
Sometimes these attach themselves to a twig by the hind
feet, extending the body in the air, when they almost exactly
imitate a dead twig. In our Southern States is found the
Dead Leaf Butterfly
Left, with wings folded; right, expanded. Original photograph from
a preparation by Kny-Schcercr Company.
"walking stick" insect, a creature with slim body and long
legs, which when resting upon a dead branch merges with its
twigs so closely as to appear like part of them. One species
of moth, resting on the edge of a leaf, is almost indistin-
guishable from the dry, curled u]) edge of that same leaf;
while another resembles a bit of bird's dung so closely as
to deceive any but the most careful observer.
But the most beautiful example of animal "camouflage"
is furnished by the "dead leaf" butterfly, Kallima, of the
East Indian jungle. When in flight this butterfly is a beau-
tiful creature with blue and orange wings; but when at
rest, with the wings folded together above the body, it imi-
tates a dead leaf so closely, even to the minute details of
338
Jiiolofjy in America
mid-rib and veins, as to deceive, at a little distance, the
closest observer. AVben in t\i^ht the Ixitterfly is a striking
object, bnt let it aliy:lit, and lo, it vanishes i'roni si<j;lit as
suddenly and completely as though the earth had swallowed
it up.
Hut some animals, who liave no enemies, unless it be man,
wiio has appeared on the scene of action only recently, in
terms of biological time, closely resemble their surroundings.
Perhaps the most notable example of this is the polar bear,
who lives among the snows and ice fields of the Arctic. His
color is readily explained, according to the Darwinians, on
the assumption of an aggressive resemblance. If the seal,
upon which the hviw preys, cannot see the latter as he ap-
Imitation of an Orchid (left) by a Mantis (right)
Courtesy 0} Thomas Y. Croicell Publishing Company.
proaches lie Avill be more readily caught, so that in this way
a resemblance to liis surroundings is of advantage to the
bear.
Closely allied to this theory is that of alluring resem-
blance, according to whicli certain animals play the part of
a "wolf in sheep's clothing." One of the worst of these
hypocrites is the Indian mantis, which so closely resembles
an orchid blossom as (supposedly) to attract unwary insects,
who, alighting on it in search of honey, thereby come to an
untimely end.
But by no means all animals are thus protectively colored.
Some on the contrary are so conspicuous that it seems as
if Nature had intentionally singled them out for objects of
remark. The monarch butterfly in his brilliant livery of
black and orange, the skunk in striking garb of black and
The Skunk
An example of "warning color" among mammals.
Courtesy of the Conrad Lantern &lide Company, Chicago.
PORKFISH
One of the many strikingly marked and colored fish of the tropica,
whose colors and markings have been supposed to liave warning sig-
nificance.
Courtesy of Professor W. II. Lonijley.
339
340
Biology in America
w
^iltf
^t T^ ...^^amm'^m
w^^^^^^^KBf IS 11^ i'^XNuoI^Bb
Mimicry op the Monarch (left) by the Viceroy Butterfly (right)
Pliotos from water color drfiwings by Mrs. Edith Eicker. From Bulle-
tin University of Montana, Biological Series No. 5.
white, and the coral reef fish of the tropics with their- ''coats
of iiiaiiy colors," all seem designed to attract, rather than de-
tract attention. To explain such facts as these a new theory
was necessary, and so Wallace suggested that these conspicu-
ous colors were developed as a danger signal to the ene-
mies of their possessors, warning them of an unpleasant taste,
or odor, or other disagreeable feature pertaining to the lat-
Bumblebee (left) Mimicked by Fly (right)
Photos from water color drawings by Mrs. Edith Eicker.
Bulletin University of Montana, ^Biological Series No. 5.
From
ter. Thus, according to the theory, the black and white
stripes of the skunk serve as a pictorial warning to his ene-
mies to stop, look and sniff' before crossing his track. This
theory is known as that of warning color.
One of the most remarkable of color phenomena in ani-
mals is that known as mimicry. In some cases there occurs
a resemblance so close as to amount almost to identity be-
tween two species belonging to totally distinct genera, fam-
Mimicry in Butterflies
At the left a series of stinking or unpalatable forms, the "models";
with a series of imitators or "mimiL-s" at the rJght. From a prepa-
ration by Kny-Scheerer Company.
Mimicry of Leap-Cutting Ant by a Tree-Hopper
From Romanes, ''Darwin and after Darwin."
B}i permission of the Open Court J'ublisliiinj Company.
341
342 Biology in Amci'ica
ilies, or even orders of animals. The "monarch" butterfly
already mentioned is imitated by the "viceroy," a species
belonging to another genns. In South and Central America
occur groups of inedible butterflies, the Ileliconidte and
Danaida,', which are imitated by various species of edible
butterflies and moths, mostly the Pierida?, the chief repre-
sentative of which in the United States is the common cab-
bage butterfly. jNIany a fly has adopted the habit of a wasp
or a bee, and the resemblance is so perfect that only the
closest scrutiny reveals the deception. But perhaps the most
curious of Nature's masquerades is that played by an ant
and a "tree-hopper" in the Amazon region, the latter very
closely imitating the former as it carries on its back a leaf,
which it has cut for food.
Why all this counterfeiting in nature? Of what advan-
tage is it to two animals to be almost exact replicas of one
another? Or is it counterfeiting? JMay not these remark-
able resemblances be mere accidents of variation, after all?
The Darwinians are, as usual, ready with an answer. Ac-
cording to Bates, a very real advantage in the life and death
struggle of the animal world is afforded certain innocuous
species by their resemblance to other species which are pro-
tected from their enemies by foul taste, or odor, or other
unpleasant quality. A bird which has learneil to respect a
wasp by reason of its sting, will be very wary about seizing
a fly which resembles a wasp, even though the former might
prove a delicious morsel, did the bird only know it, while*
the "tree-hopper" is protected by its reseml)lan('e to a leaf-
cutting ant, because of the bitter taste of the latter.
Occasionally two species of insects, each protected by some
disagreeable quality, resemble each other. What advantages
here, if both are self-protected species, in mutual resemblance
between them? But the staunch Darwinian is at no loss
for an explanation ; for, he argues, if two unpleasant insects
look alike, their enemies will have only one pattern of color
to learn in order to avoid them both; whereas if they each
had a different pattern they would have two patterns to learn,
and in doing so would sacrifice twice as many insects as under
the present arrangement.
There are a few species of animals which wear a white
patch on the rump or tail ; for example, the white tail of
some species of deer and rabbits and the white rump patch of
the antelope. Could anything so conspicuous be without*
significance? Certainly not, according to the Darwinians,
for were it not for such "recognition marks," how could the
young follow their mother or the herd its leader, when pur-
sued by some swift and savage foe?
Color in Nature
343
There are yet other instances of striking color which are
not covered by any of the explanations which we have given
so far. "Why should the males of many birds be so si)lendidly
attired that "even Solomon in all his glory was not arrayed
like one of these"; while the females mnst be satisfied with
a modest coat of drab or brown? The male scarlet tanager
in flashing lively of black and scarlet, the male of the rose-
breasted gi'osbeak with its breast of gorgeous rose, and the
saucy little male goldflncli in coat of black and yellow, are
m '"1
m-
_ 7^^^^^^
«Hi
■ml
'^rm^m
™" "^
^iH^jj^ttH^^
^^^^^^?^^S2iAlH
yr^
^ f-'X- V -.-;, •
k ^''^^^Z ,• ./ ?
1 r^-'i' '
■.r^- ■•:•' i/A":^
^
Bl
i
¥1
^
^.>"x;^^
r- ' ': -^
Ws
^■i''^' ' '-^"'^- ^'"^ "^ '*- ■»'•*'' '^M
w
■.<•': ,-.---■•
V - -.V
IMIt. ■
The Antelope
Which carries a recognition mark ui)ou its rump. A vanishing species
which once thronged our western plains.-
Courtesy of the National Zoiilof/ical Park.
among the most striking and beautiful objects in nature ; while
the females must be content with quiet colors, remU'ring them
wholly different in appearance from their mates. Once again
the Darwinian comes to rescue us from our dih-mma witli
his theory of sexual selection, which was proposed auii ably
defended by Darwin himself in his "Origin of Species."
"This form of selection depends, not on a struggle for
existence in relation to other organic beiiig-s or to external
conditions, but on a struggle between the indivitluals of one
sex, generally the males, for the possession of the other sex.
344
Biology in America
The result is not death to the unsuccessful competitor, but
few or no offspring. . , . Generally, the most vigorous males,
those whicli are best fitted for their places in nature, will
leave most progeny. But in many cases, victory depends not
so much on general vigor, as on having special weapons, con-
fined to the male sex. A hornless stag or spurless cock would
have a poor chance of leaving numerous offspring. Sexual
selection, by always allowing the victor to breed, might surely
give indomitable courage, length to the spur, and strength
Male and Female Wood Ducks
Showing sexual differences in color, from an illustration by Louis
Agassiz Fuertes.
Courtesy of the U. 8. Bureau of Biological Survey.
to the wing to strike in the spurred leg, in nearly the same
manner as does the brutal cockfighter by the careful selection
of his best cocks. How low in the scale of nature the law
of battle descends, I know not; male alligators have been
described as fighting, bellowing, and whirling around, like
Indians in a war-dance, for the possession of the females;
male salmons have been observed fighting all day long; male
stag-beetles sometimes bear wounds from the huge mandibles
of other males; the males of certain hymenopterous insects
have been frequently seen by that inimitable observer M,
Fabre, fighting for a particular female who sits by, an ap-
Sexual Difference in Beetles
The males to the left, and females to the right. From Darwin's
"Descent of Man," D. Applet on and Company.
Sexual Difference in Fish
The male above, the female below. From Darwin's "Descent of
Man," D. Appleton and Company.
345
346 Biology in America
parently unconcerned beholder of the struggle, and then re-
tires with the conqueror. The war is, perhaps, severest be-
tween tlie males of polygamous animals, and these seem
oftenest provided with special weapons. The males of car-
nivorous animals are already well armed ; though to them and
to others, special means of defense may be given through
means of sexual selection, as the mane of the lion, and the
hooked jaw to the male salmon; for the shield may be as im-
portant for victory as the sword or spear.
Amongst birds, the contest is often of a more peaceful
cliaracter. All those who have attended to the subject, be-
lieve that there is the severest rivalry between the males of
many species to attract, by singing, the females. The rock-
thrush of Guiana, birds of paradise, and some others, congre-
gate ; and successive males display with the most elaborate
care, and show off in the best manner, their gorgeous plumage ;
they likewise perform strange antics before the females, which
standing by as spectators at last choose the most attractive
partner. Those who have closely attended to birds in con-
tinement well know that they often take individual prefer-
ences and dislikes : thus Sir R. Heron has described how a
pied peacock was eminently attractive to all his hen birds.
I cannot here enter on the necessary details; but if man can
in a short time give beauty and an elegant carriage to his
bantams, according to his standard of beauty, I can see no
good reason to doubt tliat female birds, by selecting, during
thousands of generations, the most melodious or beautiful
males, according to their standards of beauty, might produce
a marked effect. ' ' -
These various theories of animal color are unfortunately
mainly founded on an "anthropomorphic" basis. If it is
difficult for us to discover the frog in the grass or a lizard
on a stump, assuredly it must be so likewise to the natural
enemies of these creatures. If a butterfly or a toad has a
foul taste, or an unpleasant odor to man, it must imj)ress
its enemies with the same unpleasant feature. If the white
tail of the rabbit renders him easier for us to follow as he
dashes away, it must also aid the young in their flight to
keep near the mother. It does not follow however that be-
cause an object is difficult for man to see, it is likewise difficult
for the eye of bird or beast to follow it, or because another
object is unpleasant to man's senses, that it is also unpleasant
to those of the creatures of the wild.
Recent experiments tend in particular to refute the theory
of warning color. This is based very largely, though not
=■ Darwin, "Origin of Species," 6th eel., pp. 108-109. By permission
of D. Appleton and Company.
Color in Nature 347
exclusively on the colors of certain butterflies, whose natural
enemies are assumed to be birds, to which they arc supposedly
obnoxious through unpleasant taste or odor. Two distinct
assumptions are involved in the theory — first that butterflies
are the natural prey of birds, and second that certain species
are avoided by the latter by reason of some unpleasant
characteristic. The first of these hypotheses is founded on
very slender evidence. There are, it is true, a few scattered
records of birds feeding; on butterflies in nature, but, consider-
ing the extent to which birds and butterflies have been studied
in the field, these records are few and far between. But,
confronted by the paucity of evidence in one direction, the
ever facile mind of the Darwinian turns immediately in an-
other. Butterflies carry with them, he maintains, evidence
of the peril in which they live, in the form of nicks in the
hind wings; which, since they frequently have the form of
a bird's beak, must be the result of unsuccessful attacks by
birds, from which the butterflies have made hairbreadth
escapes. But if one studies a series of butterflies taken in
late summer or early autumn, he will probably find the wings
of nearly all of them torn and broken in such a way that
only a little Darwinian imagination is required to conjure
up out of all these tattered wings a tale of the tragedies
which might have been. The more natural interpretation is
however that the butterflies' wings merely show the result
of the wear and tear of a summer's flight through field and
thicket.
If butterflies are the natural prey of birds an examination
of their stomachs should prove it. Such examinations have
been made for many years by the U. S. Biological Survey,
in the study of the relation of birds to agriculture, but out of
some 80,000 examinations made butterfly remains have been
found in but very few.
The second point involved in the theory has rather more
evidence in its support. There are a number of observations
on record of birds refusing the strikingly colored and evi-
dently distasteful species of butterflies. These observations
cover not merely butterflies but other insects also.
But there is also much evidence to the contrary. Thus
Judd, in a number of feeding experiments, has shown that
obnoxious forms such as various species of bugs (TIemiptera)
whether warningly colored or not are occasionally eaten, as
well as stinging insects such as bees. Judd's results must
however be accepted with caution, having been obtained with
caged birds. It is not certain that captive animals show
normal tastes. In some of my own experiments I have found
that young birds will eat almost anything which is offered
348 Biolofjy in America
them, and in some cases will pick up bits of leaves, etc., which
never in any likelihood form part of their normal food under
mitural conditions. Stomach examinations however show
that supposedly disagreeable insects form a considerable part
of birds' food. Thus hairy caterpillars, stinging bees and
wasps, ants and species of foul-tasting or smelling bugs and
beetles are eaten by a great variety of birds.
Greater doubt is cast upon the theory of warning color by
the work of Reighard at the Dry Tortugas. These are isolated
groups of coral islands lying off the Florida coast, and sur-
rounded by coral reefs. Inhabiting these latter are many
species of brilliantly colored fishes, which supposedly come
within the category of warningly colored forms. Living in
the same reefs is a predaceous fish, the gray snapper. Reig-
hard has shown that the brilliantly colored fishes of the reefs
are readily eaten by the snapper, once they are outside the
protection of the reefs. That the snappers can distinguish
different colors how^ever and can learn to associate them with
unpleasant tastes was proved by attaching the stinging ten-
tacles of a jellyfish (Cassiopea) to a small fish upon which
the snappers commonly feed, and coloring the prey red.
After several unpleasant experiences the snappers learned
to leave the red fish severely alone, whether with or without
the tentacles attached, while they took fish which were colored
white even though the stinging tentacles were attached to
them.
Longley also has made extensive studies of these fishes, as
a result of which he finds that the apparently conspicuous
and contrasting colors of so many coral reef fishes are really
protective, harmonizing their possessors with their surround-
ings and have no relation to warning color whatever. Long-
ley strongly inclines to the hypothesis of Thayer that the
greater the contrasts in an animal's color, the more readily
will it harmonize with its background, a principle most
strikingly illustrated in the bizarre effects of our camouflaged
ships in the recent war.
CHAPTER XIV
Aquatic hiologij. Oceanography, life of the sea and its
environment. Biology of inland waters. Methods of
studying aquatic life.
The development of aquatic biology, especially of its marine
phase, both here and abroad, has gone very nearly hand in
hand with the development of interest in the fisheries". Per-
haps nowhere else in biology has there been a better recog-
nition of the dependence of commercial interest upon scientific
knowledge — of the national stomach ii])on the national brains.
The recognition of this fact in Europe led to the establishment
of the marine stations at Kiel, Lowestoft, Boulogne and else-
where, and to the development of the International Council
for the Investigation of the Sea, conducted jointly by Great
Britain, Norway, Sweden, Denmark, Holland, Germany,
Belgium and Russia, an enterprise which before the great
war was achieving results of vast scientific and practical
value, and which it is to be hoped will soon be re-established,
following the advent of peace.
The earliest attempts at exploration of the sea were obser-
vations on currents, tides, waves and temperature. Tliere
were however occasional efforts to determine the depth of tjie
ocean by the earlier navigators, some of them undertaken
with very ingenious, but not very successful apparatus.
The first map of the Gulf Stream was published by Ben-
jamin Franklin in 1770, and a few years later temperature
observations along the north Atlantic coast, were made by
the Englishman, Blagden.
The U. S. Exploring Expedition in 1839-42, under the
direction of Captain AVilkes, accomi)anied by the geologist
Dana, made a number of deep-sea dredgings. The U. S.
Coast Survey has made important contributions to our knowl-
edge of the sea since the early part of the last century and
the first successful apparatus for deej) sea sounding was
devised by Midshipman Brooke of the U. S. Navy. As the
result of dredgings conducted by tlu^ Survey off the coasts of
Florida and Cuba between 1867 and 1870, uuder the direction
of the elder Agassiz, he reached tlie conclusion that former
oceanic and continental areas were similar to those of the
349
350
Biology in America
prosojit. Expoditioiis hy several sliii)s of tlie U. S. Navy
and Coast ►Survey during tlie latter iialf of the last century-
have made valuable additions to our knowledge of the sea,
among Avhieh may be mentioned the cruises of the "Blake"
in th(> ('ari))beaii Sea and tlie Gulf of Mexico from 1877 to
18SU under the direction of the late Alexander Agassiz, of
the ]\Iuseum of Comparative Zoolog;\^ of Harvard. University,
and son of the great Swiss-American naturalist.
The establishment of the U. S. Fish Connnission in 1871
early led to marine expeditions conducted under its auspices.
The ' ' Albatross ' ' of the U. S. Bureau op Fisheries.
The pioneer American vessel engaged in oceanography. She was in
charge of Alexander Agassiz during his cruises on the Pacific and has
added much to our knowledge of the fisheries of the Pacific Coast, espe-
cially Alaska. After Smith, in Bulletin of the U. S. Bureau of Fisheries
for 1908.
although partly financed by private money. The Commission
was at first dependent upon vessels loaned to it by the U. S.
Revenue Cutter Service, the Navy, and the Coast Survey,
but in 1880 it accpiired for its own use the steamer "Fish
Hawk," which has since then been used on the Atlantic coast,
partly for scientific investigations and partly as a floating
fish hatchery; and two years later the "Albatross," which
has been mainly employed in scientific and practical investi-
gations on the Pacific Ocean, but during the recent war was
in naval service on the Atlantic, and is at present temporarily
out of commission at Baltimore.
Much of the hazard of the fisherman's trade is due to the
Life of the Waters 351
dangerous construction of his craft. In order to minimize
so far as possible this danger the Commission constructed a
model fishing- schooner, the "Grampus," designed to overcome
some of the defects in the okler type of boat hitherto in use.
The construction of this vessel has largely revolutionized
that of the New England fishing boats and some idea of its
influence in the saving of wealth and life may be gained by
comparing the loss of 82 vessels from Gloucester alone during
the decade previous to 1883, at a cost of $400,000 and 895
lives, with that of the period from 1898-1907, in which only
one-fourth as many vessels and lives were sacrificed. Besides
serving as a model fishing boat, the ''Grampus" has also been
used in scientific investigations along the Atlantic coast.
In addition to tlie more extended researches of the "Alba-
tross" in the Pacific considerable local work has been done by
the boats of the marine station of the University of California,
now known as the Scripps Institution, and some desultory
observations have been made by occasional workers elsewhere.
There has been however no systematic or concerted program
by American workers in the great field of oceanography
similar to that undertaken by the European countries already
mentioned prior to the war, a neglect which is scarcely
pardonable in view of the richness and extent of our oceanic
domain, the ever-growing cry for food, and the financial
resources of our nation both public and private.^
The biology of inland waters has also been largely depend-
ent upon economic interests, in part those furthered by the
Bureau of Fisheries, and in part by various state surveys.
The work of the oceanographer' as related to biology is
concerned with investigating the physical and chemical con-
ditions of life in the sea, and in determining how marine life
is related to these conditions. The economic phase of the
science deals with those forms useful to man for food_ or
otherwise, in their relation to their environment both physical
and biological, and endeavors to discover the best meansof
obtaining, protecting and increasing them. A consideration
of this latter phase may best be left to another chapter.
In a review like the present we must needs pass over much
that is interesting and important in this great field, touching
briefly however on some of its most salient features.
If one were to construct a model of the earth with a
diameter of six feet, a scratch on the surface of the globe,
about one-tenth of an inch deep would represent the greatest
irregularity of the earth's surface, from the summit of Mt.
Everest, rearing its yet unconquered front nearly six miles
into the clouds, to the abysmal depth of 31,614 feet or 2,600
» Plans are at present on foot, looking toward such an end.
352
Biology in Americo.
feet greater than the height of Everest, which is the greatest
depth yet recorded in any ocean. This deptli was found by
tlie U. !S. 8. "Nero," in the north raeiiic near the island of
Guam.
The floor of the ocean is covered with fine ooze composed
largely of the fragments of shells of many kinds of animals
and some plants, predominant among which in many places
wm
^d//.J^,.
«
1 ■. -^SIB
o
H^k^R
■ • ,-- t '
"4
Hipwil ■: jggggi
r-^
t'^'-
■ /
^ / -
E^KKm'^^/^^^B^&^b
1*
.•*-J-
. : !
■<^ . \
A Eadiolarian
Courtesy of the American Museum of Natural History.
are the minute and wonderfully sculptured shells of uni-
cellular animals, Radiolaria, and Foraminifera, which in life
are floating at the surface of the sea. The shells of these
minute creatures often make up so large a part of the bottom
deposits, that the latter are named from them. One of the
commonest of them is Globigerina, which has given its name
to extensive bottom deposits in the sea. The shells of
certain small species of molluscs, the pteropods or "wing-
Life of Ike Waters 353
feet," so named from the wiiig-like expansions of the muscuhir
foot whicli protrnde from Uie shell and by means of whieh
they swim, make up the great mass of tlie ooze in other places,
hence the name pteropod ooze, while the marvellously beau-
tiful little diatoms, so named from Ihe two parts of the shell,
which fit together like the two halves of a pill box predominate
in other places, producing the diatom ooze, which is com-
mon in the circumpolar regions, both north and south.
Not only do the shells of animals and plants settle to the
ocean floor, but contained within these shells are their dead
bodies, which serve as food for bottom living animals, whose
digestive tracts are found full of mud from which the suitable
food material is digested and absorbed, the greater amount
being discharged as waste. It is thus that oysters and clams
are nourished, and as we enjoy our "bluepoints" and "little
necks," on the half shell, we may relish them all the more
to know that we too are scavengers of the sea.
Far to the eastward from our southern coast extends the
"Sargasso Sea," so called from the sargassum weed, which
floats in great masses at the surface of the ocean, and is borne
out from the warm waters of the Gulf of Mexico by the Gulf
Stream to the northeast. Making its own food from the
inorganic materials in the sea, by means of the action of
sunlight on its chlorophyl, it contributes largely through its
death and decay to the food supply for animals upon the
ocean floor. Then too organic dust, containing the decayed
remains of land plants and animals, is carried by wind and
current far from land and gradually settles to the bottom
as it goes. How far this detritus may be carried out to sea
we do not know. It probably varies greatly in different
oceans, dependent on wind and current. Volcanic dust
however has been carried around the world.
What are the conditions of life for the "dwellers in the
deep"? How do they "live and move and have their being"
in the abysmal depths of the sea? While by far the greater
number of marine organisms are found in comparatively shal-
low water, or floating and swimming freely at the surface,
there are a few "dwellers in darkness," who, in the struggle
for existence, have sought out the "fathomless depths" as
an abiding place, there to live their lives unknown, save when
the trawl of the explorer brings them forth from their retreat.
Even at depths of over 24,000 feet life has been found
within the sea. At such a depth any object is under a pres-
sure of over 10,000 pounds per square inch. The pressure
on the ordinary concrete foundation for a bridge pier or a
New York "skyscraper" is only 350 pounds per square
inch, so that some of the inhabitants of the sea have to
'J
354
Biology in America
sustain roufjlily llircc times the pressure on the foundations
of the Woohvorfli Building or the Metropolitan Life. To
withstand such a pressure tlie body of an animal would have
to be surrounded by an exceedingly strong shell, or else it
must be of such a character that the pressure is easily ren-
dered the same Avithin and without. The latter method is
the one Avhich Nature has adopted, and the bodies of deep
sea animals are so soft and permeable that they lose their
Deep Sea Fishes as Seen Against a Light Background.
Photograph of a group in the American Museum of Natural History
in New York.
Courtesy of the Museum.
are
shape very easily when brought to the surface and
consequently hard to preserve in their natural form.
Below depths of three thousand feet light is virtually absent
in the sea. Animals therefore living below this comparatively
shallow depth are in perpetual darkness, save for such light
as they themselves generate. Many of these deep sea forms
carry their own lanterns about w'itli them in the form of
phosphorescent organs. The firefly is an object of common
experience to many a country dweller, but only the ocean
voyager or the inhabitant of its shores, who has seen the
Life of the Waters
355
crest of a wave break into myriad opalescent drops, can fully
appreciate the beauty and the wonder of this strange, un-
canny light. The physiology of light production in animals
is not yet well understood. It is known to be due however
to some secretion which combines readily with oxygen, this
action producing the light. Phosphorescence is by no means
limited to deep sea animals, nor do all of the latter possess it.
One of the most interesting cases of light production is
Deep Sea Fishes as Seen Against a Dark Background
Photograph of a group in the American Museum of Natural History
in New York.
Courtesy of tfie Museum.
that of the deep sea angler fish, Gigantactus, where the snout
is modified to form a luminous organ, suspended on a stalk
above the head of the fish. This organ is supposed to act
as a lure to attract smaller fish which readily fall victims
to the angler's appetite.
The occurrence of eyes in deep sea fishes foniis a very
perplexing problem. In some the eyes are large, and in others
extremely small or entirely lacking. By analogy with the
cave dwellers among land and fresh water animals, we sliould
expect the deep sea fishes to be blind. But on the other hand
356
Biology in America
Two Dknizens of the Deep
Left. An angler fish which carries a lure on its head to entice its
prey within reach of its capacious jaws. From the "National Geo-
graphic Magazine," Vol. 21.
Right. Chiasinodus niger, champion cannibal among fishes. From
Murray, "Depths of the Ocean,"
By permission of the Macmillan Company.
of what advantage would it be to a species of fisli to have
light forming organs, and no means of seeing them? The
whole question of sight organs and light production by deep
sea forms is a veritable ' ' Chinese puzzle, ' ' which no one has
yet had ingenuity enough to solve. It is not merely a ques-
GiANT Squid
And skin of Avhale showing marks of giant squid tentacles. From
Murray, ' ' Depths of the Ocean. ' '
Bj/ permission of the Macmillan Company.
Life of the Waters
357
tion of two animals of the same species seeing and recognizing
one another; but of one species finding its prey and another
escaping from its enemies ; while in many cases light produc-
The Portuguese Man of War, an Animal "U-Boat "
The balloon-like float filled with gas secreted by its walls floats at the
surface of the sea, so that the colony is carried hither and yon by wind
and tide. Each of the thread-like processes pendent from the float is
an individual member of the colony having its own special function to
perform, some having stinging cells for capture of prey, others serving
as feelers and still others as feeders, the mouths and stomachs of the
colony. By contraction of the float the gas is expelled and the animal
can submej-ge. A southern form, it is often curried by the Gulf Stream
into the North Atlantic.
Courtesy of the Amcfican Museum of Xatural Hustory.
tion may be purely incidental to other processes in the life
of the animal. And furtlicr, the same ends are attained in
different ways in different species. Nature knows "more
358 Biology in America
than one way to kill a cat," and, vice versa, to save its life
and preserve its kind.
The depths of the sea are the scene of many a drama.
If Science but had the key to Davy Jones' Locker, what a
wealth of secrets, tragic as well as comic, she might reveal!
There is the fate of the flatfish who fell over on his side
before he grew up, and remained lop-sided ever after. And
there is the champion cannibal of the animal world, Chias-
modus niger, who swallowed his elder brother, acquiring
thereby a portly figure of which the most accomplished gour-
mand might well be proud.
Many a terrific battle has been fought upon the sea —
titanic struggles of giant squids and mighty whales, battling
to the death. Some of these squids have a spread of tentacles
of over eighty feet, and the whales, which are probably the
invariable victors in these encounters, bear with them well-
Velella
Ori^jinal from a specimen in the zoological collection of the Univer-
sity of North Dakota.
earned decorations as evidence of their prowess, in the form
of circular scars left upon the skin by the suckers of the
squid.
Floating at the surface of the sea is a host of beings large
and small, "creatures of circumstance" driven hither and
yon by "every wind that blows." Delicately tinted jelly-
fish, Velellas with their tiny sails, the "Portuguese Man of
War" with its balloon-like float and its vicious stinging
tentacles trailing below, the rotund sunfish, and a legion of
crustaceans, molluscs and many others, live at or near the
surface. What enables them to float so easily? Some are
lighter than the water, as the jellyfish and the sunfish, with
its jacket of fat beneath the skin. Still others have floating
sacks or bladders containing gas, like the "Portuguese Man
of War," while others still, the great majority, have pro-
jections of some sort, which increase their "specific surface,"
i. e., the ratio between surface and weight, and hinder their
sinking. A tin plate will sink slower than a leaden bullet
Above. An Ocean Sunfish. Photo by C. H. Townsend.
By permission of the New York Zoological Society.
Below. A Crustacean Lakva, slio\vin<f flotation spines.
Steuer, after Glaus.
Prom
35ii
360 Biology in America
of equal weight, and a feather or sheet of paper falls more
slowly through the air than a tiny lead shot, which weighs
no more. Wonderfully varied and beautiful are the devices
with wliich Nature has furnished both plants and animals to
buoy them in the water. JNIany diatoms are provided with
long and exceedingly fine spines. The Radiolaria previously
mentioned also have numerous spine-like processes projecting
from their shells. Many molluscs have plate or wing-like
extensions of body or shell, secretions of slime, or air cham-
bers which aid in flotation. But perhaps the most beautiful
floating structures in the animal kingdom are found in the
Crustacea where antenna, feet and tail may be greatly length-
ened and finely branched, forming long, feathery processes
which, when extended, offer great resistance to the water and
serve admirably in keeping the animals afloat.
AVhile many marine animals, and the same is true of fresh
water forms, are inactive swimmers, floating idly at the sur-
face of the sea ; or living a monotonous existence hidden away
in some obscure niche of coral reef, or groveling on the ocean
floor ; there are others, mariners bold, who fare forth in quest
of prey, making long journeys across the sea. Naturally the
chief of these are the whales and fishes, most of whom are
powerful swimmers, which follow their food from place to
place and whose presence can usually be predicted from the
presence of the latter.
Experimental evidence of the migration of fishes has been
obtained in recent years by the International Council for
the Investigation of the Sea by marking fish, and then record-
ing so far as possible the number of marked fish caught.
This has also been practised on our Pacific salmon and a
similar method has been employed by American ornithologists
for studying the migration of birds. This has been employed
especially in studying the spawning migration of fish, and it
has been shown for example that the Iceland plaice mi-
grate hundreds of miles to and from their spawning
grounds.
In 1888 and '98 two whales were taken off the coast of
northern Norway, each of which contained bomb lances of
American manufacture. These lances had evidently been
used by American whalers, which do not ordinarily cruise
off the Norwegian coasts, and the capture of whales contain-
ing these lances in Norway is probable evidence of ioug
journeys made by them.
Even more interesting than the more or less sporadic move-
ments of aquatic animals in search of food are their periodic
journeys to and from their spawning grounds. The annual
run of the salmon, wliieh is described in another chapter.
Life of the Waters 361
produces one of the principal industries of the Pacific Coast,
while the migration of the shad in the rivers of the Atlantic
Coast, in former days brought wealth to the fisherman, and
delight to the palates of those fortunate enough to feast on
this delicious food. Now unfortunately owing to various
factors this fishery is much decreased.
The underlying cause of these breeding migrations of fish
is still as much an unsolved problem as is that of bird migra-
tion. We have already seen the profound influence which
internal secretions exercise upon the metabolism and growth
of animals. We have also seen how external chemical agents
may influence the reactions of animals (i. e., light responses
of Daphnia, etc.). The cause therefore of these movements
of certain fish is undoubtedly to be sought in the action of
a secretion of the sex glands causing primarily restlessness
and movement from place to place on the part of the fish,
and secondarily a change in response to the chemical environ-
ment. Thus the ripening of the sex cells in an adromous fish
such as salmon and shad with the coincident formation of
some internal secretion by the sex glands, probably induces
restless wanderings on the part of the fish, in the course of
which they come into regions of fresh water discharged by
some river. Turning in the direction whence the fresh water
comes, they are guided to the mouth of the river, which they
ascend, due to their inclination to swim against the current.
The restlessness which bring-! them originally into fresher
water finds further expression in the leaping of the salmon
when they encounter a fall on their course up stream. This
instinct develops even in fish which have been kept from
birth to maturity in ponds, for such salmon have been known
to leap out of the water onto the bank to die.
After spawning and cessation of the internal secretion the
fish lose their tendency to swim up stream, and are either
carried helplessly down by the current, dying as they go,
in the case of the adult salmon on our Pacific Coast, or in tlie
case of the young salmon and the young and adults of other
fish (sturgeon, shad and Penobscot salmon) they swim with
the current back to their home in the sea.
Eels have a different history, living in fresh Avaters and
descending the rivers to the sea to spawn. The mysterious
habits of the eel have given rise to some very curious tales of
early writers, according to whom eels are spontaneously
generated in mud and elsewhere, or are formed from horee
hair, old eel-skins, etc. After spending several years in fresh
water, the ripening of the sex organs probably induces the
wandering habit in the eel, and it descends the river to the
ocean, where it spawns in realms unknown, but in any event
WM^Kf-A,
•
V-' •^•.-
.'"""" ■ v*
■j
y j^
L4
Mi
^
Kl?^^
1
■
M
f^^^g^
11
r
>*
m t ' "1^1^ ftrB^
■■
m^B
^'„..._
r ■■. V'
1:*
Salmon at Base of Falls En "Route to Their Breeding Grounds in
Alaska
"Caught in the Act," a Leaping Salmon
Courtesy oj the U. 8. Bureau of Fisheries.
362
Life of the Walcrs 363
in water more than 15,000 feet deep.^ Where the eggs are laid
IS not known, but they hatch at the surface of the sea, into
ribbon-shaped, transparent Iarva3 of about the thickness of
a visitmg card. After about a year's time, during which
they are said to take no food, the larvfe lose their ribbon
shape and assume the eel-like form. They now approach the
coasts and ascend the rivers in large numbers, forming what
are known as the "eel-fares" of late winter or early spring.
Like the Pacific salmon, the adults die after spawning,
though the manner of their demise is unknown.
But the spawning and feeding migrations of marine animals
are not their only active movements. Many species seek the
deeper layers by day, coming to the surface at night. The
depth of this diurnal movement varies for different species,
but does not in general exceed 100 to 150 feet. In some
species, the wandering habit is restricted to the young, while
in others migrations are performed by the males only. Similar
diurnal movements occur in fresh water animals, as already
noted.
There are also many species in which the young are found
at one level, while the adults occur at some other. This is
notably true of many bottom-living fishes, such as the cod
and halibut, Avhose eggs and young are found only at the
surface. Here it may be that differences in specific gravity
at the different ages explain these differences in distribution.
A word here may not be amiss as to the tools of the
oceanographer. By what means has our knowledge of the
depths of the sea been obtained? In the study of oceanog-
raphy, as indeed in many other of the complex fields of
modern science, the biologist must be a physicist and chemist
as well. One of the most important implements of the
oceanographer is his sounding line. This is used not alone
for measuring depth but for carrying instruments of various
sorts. In the earlier deep sea expeditions, notably those of
the British ship "Challenger" (1872-76) rope lines were
used for sounding. On account of the heavy strain (the
weight of 20,000 feet of the line itself in water was nearly
250 pounds) a rope one inch in circumference was used.
The necessary length of this rope (over 30,000 feet) rendered
it awkward to handle and necessitated large space for its
accommodation. For trawling still heavier lines (up to three
inches in circumference) were required, which were still more
difficult to handle and to store. At the time of the "Chal-
lenger" expedition. Sir AVilliam Thompson (Lord Kelvin)
"Recently the Danish oceanographer, Johannes Schmidt, has appar-
ently discovered the spawning grounds of both European and American
eels southwest of the Bermuda islands.
364
Biology in AmcTica
was designing a sounding machine to be employed with wire
line, but wire was first actually used for this purpose by
two American captains, Belknap and Sigsbee, of the explor-
ing vessels, "Tuscarora" and "Blake" respectively. They
employed piano wire about one-tenth of an inch in circum-
ference, Avith an obvious saving of space. For trawling
Sigsbee used a wire rope made up of forty-two piano wires
twisted about a tarred rope at the center.
For sounding at great depths a heavy weight is necessary
to hold the line plumb against the currents of the sea and
Sigsbee Sounding Machine in Use on the "Albatross"
Courtesy of the U. S. Bureau of Fisheries.
the drift or swing of the ship even when at anchor, and this
descends at a rapid rate. With a weight of thirty to forty
pounds, the line runs out at the rate of about seven feet a
second, while with weights up to four or five hundred pounds,
which are employed in deep sounding, the speed is much
greater. The depth is determined from the number of revo-
lutions of the wheel which carries the line, and the end of
the sounding is noted by the sudden slackening of the speed
of the line in its descent. This point is naturally very difficult
to observe in a rapidly moving line. To overcome this diffi-
culty sounding machines of various types have been devised,
all of them founded on the principle of Lord Kelvin's original
Life of the Vi^aicrs 365
machine, in which a counter-weight serves to check quickly
the speed of the wire, when the sounding weight reaches tlie
bottom. The types empk)yed by the " Albatro.ss" and otiicr
vessels of the U. S. Bureau of Fisheries, in which adjustable
spnngs are used as brakes, instead of counter-weights, are
known as the Sigsbee and Tanner machines from their
designers, Commanders C. D. Sigsbee and Z. L. Tanner of
the U. S. Navy. These springs also serve as "accumulators"
to relieve sudden strains on the sounding line, due to tossing
of the ship in rough weather.
Another means of checking the descent of the line is the
detachment of the sinker when the bottom is reached. This
is usually accomplished by means of a catch to which the
sinker is attached. While the sounding line is taut this
catch is automatically held in place, but when the former
is slackened the catch drops, releasing the sinker and thereby
relieving the pull on the line.
For taking samples of the bottom there is frequently
attached below the sounding weight a metal tube lined with
tallow, which is driven into the bottom by the impact of the
sinker, and when drawn up retains some of the bottom
material adherent to the tallow. Some samplers are made
with valves at the upper and lower ends of the tube, which
are automatically closed when the sample is taken, thereby
preventing the escape of the catch. For taking larger sam-
ples of the bottom, devices similar to the ordinary grapple-
dredge used in excavation work are sometimes employed.
The measurement of ocean currents is made with various
types of current meters, some of which are constructed on
the principle of the instrument used by the U. S. AVeather
Bureau for measuring the velocity and direction of the wind.
These carry a vane or rudder for holding the meter in line
with the current, and a series of revolving cones, the number
of revolutions of which are transmitted by a telephone to
the ear of the observer at the surface, and from their mimber
per minute the velocity may be computed. In the Eckman
current meter named from the Swedish naturalist, V. W.
Eckman, which is much in use, both here and abroad, the
velocity of the current is registered by the revolutions of a
propeller, connected to a dial whose hands are turned by a
set of cog-wheels, and the direction recorded by means of a
magnetic needle, a box divided into thirty-six compartments,
and a tube full of shot connected to one of the cog wheels
of the dial. As the latter turns it feeds the shot into the
needle box where it falls onto the middle of the needle, and
then runs through a groove to drop into one of the thirty-
six compartments, depending upon the position of the needle
366 Biology in America
in the box. Thus the direction of the current with reference
to the magnetic meridian is recorded by the number of shot
in the different compartments of the needle box.
The early occanographers attempted to determine tempera-
tures in the depths of the sea either by bringing up a sample
of water from any given level in an insulated container and
recording the temperature of the sample on the deck of the
ship; or by insulating the thermometer itself so that it ac-
quired the temperature of the water very slowly, leaving it
for a time (several hours) at the desired level and then
hauling it up very quickly, so that its temperature would
change but slightly, if at all, in the ascent. The former
method of taking temperatures was employed by Nansen on
his polar expeditions and is still used to some extent, but
the principal method at the present time is the use of some
type of deep sea thermometer, which shall record the tem-
perature at a given depth, and give the same reading when
drawn to the surface. One of the earlier types of instru-
ment employed, and the one used by the "Challenger" expedi-
tion, was a modification of the ordinary maximum and mini-
mum air thermometer. For moderate depths, or in cases
where the temperature changes uniformly from the surface
downward, this type of instrument gives fairly satisfactory
results ; but for great depths, where the temperature does not
change uniformly from top to bottom, the results are un-
reliable.
The later types of instrument used are all constructed on
essentially the same principle. They consist of a thermometer
with a neck which is twisted and very narrow just above the
mercury bulb. This is enclosed in a jacket of very heavy
glass hermetically sealed for protection against the enormous
water pressure at gi'eat depths, the mercury bulb being sur-
rounded by a special mercury jacket so that heat may be
rapidly conducted between the former and the water. After
lowering the thermometer to any given depth, it is reversed,
or turned upside down by a special mechanism, when the
mercury column breaks at the constricted point and drops
to the opposite end of the tube, where the reading is given
on a standardized scale. Before reversal the mercury can
pass up or down the tube through the constricted neck de-
pendent on the raising or lowering of the temperature ; but
after reversal and consequent breaking of the mercury column,
no more mercury can pass through and the reading gives the
true temperature except for a correction which has to be
made. During the ascent of the thermometer, if the difference
in temperature between air and water be considerable there
will be a slight change in the volume of the broken off column
of mercury and the reading will not be strictly accurate. A
Life of the Waters HGT
correction can be made for this error however if the tem-
perature (liiference be known, and so in one of the best
types of instrument an accessory thermometer is mounted
alongside the principal one, and thus tlic < liiference in 1cm-
perature between the water and tlie air at the moment of
reading can be taken and the correction applied.
The reversal of the deep sea tliermometer is effected eitlier
by means of a small propeller wliich commences to revolve at
the moment of raising the thermometer, or more usually by
means of a weight or "messenger" whicli is dropped down
the line and trips a catch, releasing a spring .and upsetting
the ttermometer.
An estimation of the light penetrating the ocean may be
made by lowering a white, or variously colored disk and
noting the point at whicli it disappears, and vice versa by
raising it from lower depths and noting the depth at which
it can first be seen. By taking the mean of these two read-
ings, and comparing it with some empirical standard, an
estimate may be made of the transparency of the water.
Electric lights are also employed for this purpose. A better
method is the use of a photometer. Various types of these
are employed, mainly designed on the principle of exposing
photographic plates or films contained in a water-tight holder
for varying periods of time and noting the density of the
exposure after development. By comparing the density of
these exposures with a standard set made in the air for
different lengths of time, and taking into account the angle
of the sun's rays with the horizontal and the turbidity and
color of the water, an estimate may be obtained of the in-
tensity of the total illumination at various depths. If it is
desired to determine the relative penetration of different
rays of light (red, green, blue), plates of colored glass, with
a known capacity for absorbing (and therefore cutting off
from the plate or film) certain rays and admitting their
complementary rays, may be placed over it. Such an appa-
ratus is crude at best, and it remains for the investigator of
the future to devise a machine presumably of electrical con-
struction, which will give an accurate determination of the
light at different depths in the sea."''" Even with the
crude apparatus thus far devised however many interest-
ing results have been obtained. The depth to which light
penetrates the sea has already been mentioned. It has also
been found that night-time comes much sooner for the chil-
dren of the sea than for those of the air, for when the sun
is yet many degrees above the horizon, the surface of the
water acts as a mirror and totally reflects its rays. The
=''Sucli apparatus has been devised, but has not yet come into general
use.
368
Biologij in America
reflection too is greater the greater the depth, so that at
depths of a few hundred feet daylight may last but a few
minutes, wliile at de])ths of more than 3,000 feet is a realm
of perpetual niglit. The character of the sea also, whether
smooth or rough, materially affects the results — the rougher
the surface, the greater the number of mirrors, placed at many
and eonstantly changing angles,
and the greater the reflection of
the light.
In collecting samples of water
from various depths of the sea
for chemical analysis, o'r for
studying the microscopic life
which it contains, various types
of "water bottles" are em-
ployed. These can be closed at
the desired depth and the con-
tained sample then drawn to the
surface for examination. The
type in most common use at
present is the Eckman bottle,
another piece of apparatus de-
signed by the naturalist, V. W.
Eckman, to whom reference has
already been made. This is a
reversible instrument consisting
essentially of a metal cylinder
with two lids. In lowering the
cylinder the two lids are held
open so that water can pass
freely through it. After it has
reached the desired depth a mes-
senger is sent down the line re-
leasing a catch, when the cyl-
inder upsets itself by its own
weight and the lids are auto-
matically closed at the same time.
Held in the frame beside the
water bottle is a reversible ther-
mometer, so that the apparatus serves for taking water samples
and temperatures at the same time. A second messenger
may be attached to the bottom of the frame in such a way
ihi\\ when the first messenger reverses the bottle, the second
messenger is released, which in its turn reverses a second
bottle and thermometer at a loAver level, and so on. In this
way a number of simultaneous observations may be made
on a single line.
JiiGELow Water Bottle
With deep sea thermometer
reversed at the right, and '
sengcr" at top.
CourtvHji of flir
V. S. liurcau o} Fisheries.
mes-
Life of the Waters
369
And liovv does the biologist obtain his knowledge of the
denizens of the deep, of their comings and goings, their num-
bers and their whereabonts? The science of oceanography
goes back to the earliest days when men went "down into the
sea in ships" and east their nets into the great waters,
and the earliest instrnnicnts of the oceanographer were the
compass, the plnmmet, tlie seine and the trawl. From all
depths of the ocean are bronght forth creatures, great and
small. With harpoon and bomb lance, with heavy dredge
Blake Deep Sea Trawl
Courtesy of the U. S. Bureau of Fislieries.
and trawl, with hand line, seine and nets innumerable, down
to those of the finest gauze used for sifting the whitest of
our flours, man has searched the seven seas from top to
bottom and from pole to pole in quest of hidden treasure.
The inhabitants of the ocean floor are brought up from
their hiding place by means of dredge and trawl. The dredge
is essentially a long rake or hoe attached to a stout iron frame,
with a bag of steel or twine netting projecting beiiind. If
the latter, it may be protected by an external covering of
canvas open behind. As the toothed or straight bar which
acts as rake or hoe is dragged over the bottom, it scrapes
370 Biology in America
up' the surface of the hitter, wliieh is caught by the bag, the
size of ()I)j('('ts retained de])ending upon its size of mesh.
The grai)i)le-dre(lge or scoop may also be employed for this
purpose, with tlie advantage of deeper penetration and con-
sequent capture of burrowing animals which might escape
the ordinary diedge. The trawl is constructed on much the
same plan as the dredge except that it is designed to skim
over the bottom taking those animals which live on, rather
than in the latter. This is effected by supporting the bag,
made of fish netting in the trawl, on runners like those of a
sled, whicli slide over, rather than penetrate into the bottom.
The smaller dredges in shallow water are operated by hand,
but for the larger apparatus, which may bring up tons of
material at one haul, heavy lines and steam winches, operated
on the deck of a large vessel are essential.
For collecting the organisms present in the different levels
of the sea a large variety of appliances have been devised,
the details of which are too many and too intricate to describe
here. For merely qualitative work, that is, for determining
the kinds of organisms present at different depths, the appli-
ances are relatively simple. Surface collections are made with
tow-nets, of materials of various degrees of fineness, from
coarse fish netting down to number 20 silk bolting cloth,
with spaces only 1/400 of an inch in diameter. These are
usually of conical shape, with a large metal hoop at the
opening and a small metal cup or bucket at the lower end,
for holding the catch as the net is towed through the water.
For collections at lower levels similar nets may be lowered
to any desired depth and held horizontally while towed, by
a weight attached to the tow-line .iust in front of the net.
Or several of them may be attached to one main line at any
desired points by means of side lines, the main line being
carried down by a weight attached to its lower end. The
kinds of organisms present at different levels may also be
roughly determined by lowering tow nets to different depths
and drawing them vertically to the surface and then com-
paring the catches taken in each. If, for example, certain
organisms are present in the deeper hauls, which are absent
in the shallower ones, it may safely be inferred that these
occurred only in the lower levels. The relative abundance
of organisms at different depths may also be roughly deter-
mined in this way.
Both of these methods however are open to the objection
that the nets catch not only the organisms present at the
particular depth whicli it is desired to study, but also at
all depths intermediate between it and the surface, as the
nets are draAvn in. To overcome this difficulty various types
Life of the Waters
371
of closing nets have been designed, so constructed that they
can be lowered closed to the desired depth, and then opened,
either automatically by the pull on the net itself, or by a
messenger sent down a cable, and closed again by a mes-
senger, after Avhich they are drawn to the surface without
danger of mixing the catch with organisms present at other
levels.
For qualitative work the loss of a few organisms is a
matter of small consequence, and accordingly the net bucket
Tow-Nets
In use on the ' ' Albatross ' ' of the U. S. Bureau of Fisheries.
Courtesy of the liiircau.
is a simple affair merely screwed into a ring at the loWer e'lld
of the net, or tied into the net itself. But for quantitative
work every organism possil)le must be saved, and the bucket
is accordingly more complicated, is readily detacliable from
the' net, and can then be opened and drained into the con-
tainer for receiving the catch.
The problem of determining the number of organisiiis
present in a given volume of water, at any given time and
place, is one of the most important, and withal difficult prob-
lems in oceanography. The quantitative study of the animals
and plants in the sea is essential to a knowledge of their rate
372 Biology in America
of reproduction, their increase or decrease under varying
conditions of environment and their movements from place
to place. It is essential, not alone to a science of the sea,
but also to a knowledge of its economic resources and the
best means of their utilization.
The dependence of tish and other animals, which man
appropriates to his own use, upon the lower forms of life
within the sea is matter of common knowletlge. On our
Atlantic Coast is an industry with a value in round iinmbcrs
of $3,7UU,U(JO annually, and giving employment to 5894 people,
the menhaden fishery. The menhaden produces 6,600,000
gallons of oil every year which is used in making paint and
varnish and for other purposes.^ After the oil has be?n
extracted from the fish their remains are dried and
ground up for fertilizer. They are also eaten to some extent.
Professor Peck, in his study of the food habits of this fish sev-
eral years ago, found that it fed exclusively on the minute
plants and animals fioating in the water. In feeding, the
menhaden swims through the water with open mouth, at the
rate of about two feet per second; and as it does so the water
is filtered through the gills which form a fine sieve, allowing
the water to pass freely but straining out the small organisms
it contains, which are swallowed by the fish. In this way it fil-
ters about seven gallons of water per minute, obtaining from it
about a cubic inch of food material in five minutes.'' From
this it may readily be seen that the size of a menhaden's meal
is limited only by its industry in eating it. The abundance
of oil in this fish is due to its food, and thus we have a
beautiful example of the value to man of the unseen and
often unconsidered wealth of the waters.
The menhaden is not a large fish, weighing but little over
a half pound on the average, but one of the giants of the sea,
the blue whale, which reaches a length of nearly ninety feet
and an estimated weight of seventy-five tons, and is probably
the largest animal which ever lived, is likewise dependent on
the small creatures of the sea for its food. The fast vanish-
ing whalebone, which in years gone by played so large, a
part in shaping the fate as well as form of women, is obtained
from the massive plates of bone-like baleen which fringe the
palate of this and some other whales, and serve them as a
strainer by means of which they obtain their food. The
whale in feeding takes a few barrels of water into its capacious
mouth ; then as the mouth is closed and the tongue raised the
»Data for 1912 from U. S. Bur. Fish. Doc, No. 811, 1917.
* This amount was estimated by Professor Peck in the month of July
at the mouth of the Acushnet River at New Bedford, Mass. It would
naturally vary greatly at different seasons and in different places.
Life of ike Waters 373
water is forced out through the baleen sieves, while the little
animals it contains are held and then swallowed by the whale.
The mouth of a whalebone whale is a wonderfully efficient
mechanism. Were the whalebone stiff and inelastic, retain-
ing a fixed position in the mouth of the whale, when the
mouth was opened there would be left a wide space for tlie
escape of the water between the strainer and tlie lower jaw.
But the plates are both pliable and elastic fohliiig backward
in the mouth when the jaws are closed and springing into
position when these are opened "like a bent bow," thus
closing completely the mouth opening. But the tips of the
plates are thin and easily bent, and were they not protected
in some way might be bent outward by the force of the water
when the jaws are closed, allowing some of its contents to
escape. To guard against such a mishap Nature has pro-
vided the whale with a large lower lip, which overlaps the
tips of the plates and holds them in place.
Jaws of Whalebone Whale
From Sedgwick after Cuvicr in " Eegne Animal."
Even man has tried the plankton of the sea and found it
good, as testified by no less a personage than tlie Prince of
Monaco himself, who found that the plankton c()})epods, wlien
roasted in butter, made very good patties.
About thirty years ago it occurred to the German zoijhtgist,
Hensen, to study the productivity of the sea as a source of
human wealth, much as one would study the productivity of
the land, llensen thought of this productivity in terms of
the smaller forms (chiefly microscopic) of plant and animal
life, which constitute the food of fish, and which he named
plankton from the Greek word planktos, wandering. In order
to study its abundance, he constructed a net which is known
from its inventor as the llensen net. This consists of an
inverted canvas half cone at the top supported by two rings,
374
Biology in America
to tlie lower and larger of which is attached the net proper,
composed of fine bolting cloth, and terminating below in the
detachable bucket which receives the catch. To relieve the
strain on tlie silk this bucket may be supported by strings
attached to the larger ring above and the silk may be sur-
rounded by netting to protect it from injury. The object
of the inverted cone is to insure the passage of all the water
through the net which enters its mouth, a large part of which
would otherwise flow over the edge of the net, rather than
Hensen's Net
For collecting plankton in the sea. From Steuer after Chun.
through its meshes, due to the resistance of the latter to the
water. By lowering the net a given distance and then hauling
it to the surface Hensen expected to filter all but the most
minute organisms out of a column of water, whose height
was the length of the vertical haul, and whose diameter was
the diameter of the net opening. In this way he attempted
to compute the number of organisms present beneath any
given area of the sea's surface down to any given depth.
Experiments have shown however that not all of the water
assumed to pass through the net does pass through, and that
Life of the Waters 375
further this amount is a variable quantity depending on the
rate at which the net is hauled through the water, the extent
to which it has been used and various other factors, all of
which introduce an error which is inconstant and is not
exactly known.
Many kinds of quantitative plankton nets, both open and
closing, have been designed since Hensen's original device
was conceived. They are all however subject to the same
errors as is Ilensen's net, and for exact work, especially on
the smallest forms or nanno-plankton (from the Greek word
meaning dwarf) are very unreliable.
To obviate the uncertainty of the net method in quanti-
tative plankton work, the water bottle described above has
been used for small samples, while larger samples have been
pumped from shallow depths and the water strained through
a net to concentrate the catch. The former method is open
to the objection that a small sample is not necessarily repre-
sentative of a large area, as the organisms (especially the
larger ones) may vary in abundance from place to place,
while the pump method is only applicable to shallow depths,
because of the great amount of hose required at lower levels,
and is furthermore subject to one of the errors involved in
tlie net method, namely that the smallest organisms in large
measure press through the net, while a further error is
involved in the tendency of many actively swimming, though
minute animals, to swim away from the suction current
created by the pump, and thereby give the eager and hard-
working biologist the slip. For great depths and large catches
therefore the net method, with all its faults, is the only prac-
tical one as yet devised.
But having made his collections how does the biologist
determine the number of organisms which they contain? To
do this the method in use among physicians for counting
the corpuscles in the blood has been adopted. Knowing the
amount of water filtered through the net, the catch is brought
to a known concentration, say 1/50 or 1/100 part of tlie
former, and a small quantity (usually one cubic centimeter)
of the latter is placed in a glass cell on the stage of the micro-
scope, and the total number of organisms (in the case of the
larger forms) is counted. In the case of the very small
organisms, such as the unicellular forms, the number present
in several small parts of the cell is counted and by averaging
these and multiplying by the ratio between the area of the
cell and the total area of the parts counted, the number con-
tained in the former can be estimated with a fair degree of
accuracy. The size of the parts is determined by means of
squares ruled on a small disk of glass in the eye-piece of the
376 Biology in America
microscope, each square covering a known area of the cell
at a given magnification. Suppose, for example, the amount
of water filtered through the net to have been 1,000,000 cubic
centimeters (rougiily 1100 quarts) and tiiat the catch is con-
tained in 100 cubic centimeters of fluid. Suppose further
that file volume of the cell is one cubic, and its area ten square
centimeters, and the area of each one of ten parts counted is
1/10 of a square centimeter. If these ten parts contain 100
specimens of some species, then the number of individuals
of that species in the 1,000,000 cubic centimeters strained by
the net would be 100 (number of individuals counted)
X [10-^ (10 X 1/10)] (ratio of total cell area to area in
which specimens were counted) X 100 -^ 1 (ratio of volume
of concentrated catch to volume of cell) = 100,000, or one in
every ten cubic centimeters of the water filtered; assuming
of course that the organisms are uniformly distributed
through the concentrated sample and through the counting
cell, an assumption which is only approximately true. The
method of counting, like that of collecting, is subject to a
large error and the whole method is necessarily a very approxi-
mate one. In the case of larger forms, which can readily be
seen with the naked eye, such as shrimps, jellyfish and small
fish, and which are never very numerous in these quantita-
tive collections, the number taken in the entire catch is gen-
erally counted.
For counting the very minute animals and plants, if they
are abundant, a more accurate method is the use of the
centrifuge, by which all of the organisms may be obtained
in the concentrate, if the speed of the centrifuge be sufficiently
high and the time of centrifuging long enough. Centrifuges
are now made which will run at a speed of 3,000-4,000 revolu-
tions per minute and carry 100 cc. of water. In general how-
ever the centrifuge method is applicable only for the study
of the most minute organisms in small samples of water.
For general quantitative studies of the organisms present
in the sea it is quite impracticable.
Yet another method of determining the number of organ-
isms present in water, is the Sedgwick-Rafter method, so
named from Professor Sedgwick of the Massachusetts Institute
of Technology, the Avell-known sanitary biologist, and JMr.
Geo. W. Rafter, C. E. This has been employed quite exten-
sively for studying the organisms (especially the microscopic
plants) present in drinking waters. In this method a given
quantity of water, usually about a pint, is filtered through a
plug of fine sand about three-fourths of an inch deep, which
is held in the funnel-shaped end of a tall, narrow cylinder
Life of the Waters 377
by a perforated cork covered with a circle of fine bolting
cloth. After the water has been concentrated to 1/50 or
1/100 part of its original volume, the cork is removed, the
sand washed and the washings, containing the organisms to
be counted, preserved. Tliis method, like all others, has
its advantages and disadvantages, principally tlie latter, but
for general purposes is perhaps as little objectionable as any.
But the biologist relies not alone upon devices of his own
cunning. In his search for the creatures of the sea he employs
the whale as a retriever and in its capacious maw finds stores
of undigested information. The most primitive, but withal
the most efficient plankton trap known, is the phaiynx of
the ascidian or sea squirt, which is perforated by numerous
minute openings through which water is strained, the animals
and plants which it contains being retained in the pharynx to
serve as the animal 's food. By studying the stomach contents
of these forms much has been learned of the microscopic life
of the sea.
In studies of fresh water life many appliances are used
similar to those employed for marine work, and but few of
a special type are required. The methods employed here are
necessarily simpler than those used in investigation of the
sea, with its profound depths, its mighty waves and powerful
currents. In work upon large bodies of fresh water however
such as our Great Lakes, conditions are found resembling in
many ways those of the sea, and here especially must the
methods and apparatus of the oceanographer be largely re-
sorted to. Such apparatus as is peculiar to fresh water
research is described in various technical and special works,
and does not call for special mention here.
Fresh water studies in the United States, apart from those
of the most general character, have been prosecuted mainly
by the Massachusetts State Board of Health, and the water
works department of Boston, Mass., and Brooklyn, N. Y.,
the U, S. Bureau of Fisheries, the Illinois State Laboratory
of Natural History and the Natural History and Geological
Survey of Wisconsin, The first two of these agencies have
studied the drinking waters of their respective eonnnunities
primarily from the sanitary standpoint; the Bureau of
Fisheries is interested primarily in the commercial utilization
of our aquatic resources, while the other institutions have
approached their problems from primarily tlie i)urely scien-
tific angle with secondary reference to the practical results.
We are accustomed to think of the suitability of water for
drinking and general domestic purposes in terms of bacterial
and chemical character, overlooking the fact tiiat there are
378 Biology in America
many plants other than the bacteria which may render water
unsuitable for consumption or other household uses. Ani-
mals too, especially mosquito larvas, present in drinking
waters, may play an important role in human health. At
various times the people of Boston have noticed an odor of
cucumbers in their drinking water. However delectable the
odor of cucumbers may be in a salad, the inconsistency of
human nature is such that Boston people strongly objected
to it in their drinking water, the more so as it suggested cer-
tain unsavory things such as garbage cans, or a vegetable push
cart in Salem Street. Investigation proved however that the
Synura
Which imparts the odor of cucumbers to water. From Conn, "Pro-
tozoa of Connecticut. ' '
cucumber was entirely blameless in the matter, the guilty
party being an innocent looking little animal, the protozoan
Synura. Professor Whipple has compiled a list of twenty-
two unicellular plants and animals which are responsible for
various odors in water, ranging all the way from the delicate
perfume of the violet to the disgusting smell of the piggery.
Some organisms indeed run the whole gamut of odor, de-
pending on the number present and the amount of decom-
position, from the odor of a violet or a geranium to that of
a fish, or from the smell of newly cut grass or corn to that of
the pig-pen. "Things are not always what they seem." On
one occasion seven out of ten people declared that highly di-
luted kerosene smelled like perfumery, which observation may
be interpreted either as a libel on certain "perfumery" or
vice versa.
■When the shirt of your bosom returns to you an hour be-
fore dinner stiff and glossy, but with dull brown stains upon
■it, do not blame the Chinaman or the laundry maid; go rather
Life of ike Waters 379
to headquarters and call the culprit Crenothrix before the
bar of outran:ed ])rivate opinion. This is a mieroscopic fila-
meiitous plant allied to the bacteria, which sometimes devel-
ops extensively in water pipes and deposits iron in its sheaths,
and to which the stains on clothes are sometimes due.
The work of the sanitary biologist in connection with waters
for drinking and other domestic uses has been to ascertain
the effect of various organisms present in the water, and
the means of control and removal of those which are in-
jurious. But it would take us too far afield to go into this
subject, which is largely a technical one of sanitary engineer-
ing.
The work of the Bureau of Fisheries, being primarily of
an economic character, may perhaps best be discussed "else-
where, which leaves us the more purely scientific phases of
fresh water biology for consideration here. The problems
of the biologist who studies the life of inland waters, are
much the same as those of the biologist upon the sea. His
work is to ascertain the kinds of life inhabiting these waters
and their abundance and behavior in relation to their en-
vironment. His first undertaking then is to study the physi-
cal and chemical character of inland w^aters and to deter-
mine the species of their animal and plant iidiabitants, while
secondarily there opens up to him a vast field of questions
relative to the structure, nutrition, reproduction and move-
ment of these inhabitants, and the way in which their activi-
ties are related to the. various factors in their environment.
Most of these problems find a place as well in other fields of
biology to which reference has been made elsewhere. AVe
may here consider a few which belong especially in this dis-
tinctive field.
In the yearly life of lake or river there occurs a cycle of
changes even more marked than those of the ocean. During
the warm bright months of summer the plants and animals
enjoy the heyday of their existence and may uudtiply so
rapidly that the water appears "soupy" from them. Espe-
cially is this true of the algae, which may form a thick green
scum on the surface of lake or pool. But with the advent
of the cold, when lakes and ponds pass into a period of win-
ter "sleep," the life which they contain seems almost to
vanish, so that where in summer one might find a thousand
individuals of animal or plant, in winter he may find one or
two or even none at all. At this time changes occur in the
water which may have a profound (even a life and death)
influence in the life of its inhabitants. AVhen a lake is frozen
over to a thickness of several feet, and when on top of the ice
sheet is laid a blanket of snow, several more feet thick, the
380 Biology in America
oxygen content of the water may be so reduced as to smother
many of its inliabitants. Tlic sliores of shallow lakes in the
north, after an unusually lonji', hard winter, may be lined
in spring with the deca3'ing bodies of hosts of fish, which
have thus perished. For aquatic animals require fresh air
as well as those who inhabit terra firma, or rather the oxygen
which is dissolved in the water from the air. At least most
of them do. Professor Juday at Wisconsin has however re-
cently made the very interesting claim that many species of
animals, Pi-otozoa, worms, insect larvfe and even molluscs
may inhabit the oxygen-free ooze at the bottom of lakes.
While Professor Juday 's observation needs confirmation,
there is no question that many aquatic animals can live in
water with a very low oxygen content. This does not mean
however that they are living without oxygen, which is a sine
qua nan for all living things, but merely that they obtain
it in some other way, possibly through breaking down oxy-
gen-containing substances in the water, or it may be directly
from their food.
Another effect of winter upon shallow lakes is the con-
centration of dissolved substances in the lower levels. When
ice forms on the surface of water, any substances dissolved
in the latter are in some mysterious way filtered out of the
freezing water and as a result become more concentrated in
the unfrozen water, and very much less so in the ice, sea ice
containing only about one-fifth as much salt as sea w^ater.
This increase in concentration of the salt content of brackish
lakes in winter may materially affect the life which they
contain, and may even be a crucial factor in determining the
presence of various species of animals in the water. In
Devils Lake, North Dakota, we have a fine example of one
of these shalloAv, brackish lakes, which are characteristic of
much of our western territory. It has a maximum depth of
not more than eighteen feet, while much of the lake is so
shallow that it freezes solidly in winter. In earlier days
when the lake was deeper it abounded in pickerel, and in
recent years many efforts have been made to restock it. In
many of these experiments fish were kept alive for weeks
during the summer, but with one or two possible exceptions
no results of these experiments were evident the following
spring. The probable explanation of these failures is that
the lake had about reached that degree of concentration (14,-
000 parts of solids in 1,000,000 parts of water) which the ex-
perimental fish can stand, and that with a considerable increase
in this concentration in winter, due to a three-foot layer of
ice, they were unable to survive.
Not alone are dissolved substances separated from freezing
Life of Ike Waters 381
water, but bacteria also suffer a "freeze out," so that ice har-
vested from sewage-contaminated water may be fit for drink-
ing. Analyses made by the Massachusetts State Koai-d of
Health and the North Dakota Public Health Laboratory have
shown that clear ice taken from polluted water may contain
as low as 1% of the number of bacteria present in the water.
This is not true in all cases however as there are many fac-
tors influencing the result.
Small bodies of water may undergo other changes than
those due to cold and heat, freezing and thawing. Many
pools, formed in spring from rain or melting snow, and
swarming with life in the early months of summer, dry up
completely during late summer or early autumn, with re-
sultant destruction of the life which they contain, except
those forms which are able to survive long periods of drouth
with consequent extremes of heat and cold.
But in spite of the destruction of life, which occurs in
these temporary ponds each year, every succeeding year they
are swarming with living things again as though nothing
had happened. What has become of this life meanwhile, and
how is its cycle maintained in winter when Jack Frost seizes
the waters of the North in his icy grasp ?
Some aquatic animals and plants can over-winter in their
ordinary condition, their rate of increase being merely slowed
down temporarily. Many fresh water copepods may be
found beneath the ice in winter oftentimes even carrying eggs,
and consequently actively reproducing. Fresh water beetles
and some other insects live over winter, and the same is true
of rotifers, molluscs and other fresh water forms of both
plants and animals. There is a case on recoid of a frog re-
viving even after being frozen in a solid block of ice. Sir
John Franklin records the revival of frogs and fish after
freezing, a specimen of carp recovering sufficiently to "leap
about with much vigor after it had been frozen thirty-six
hours." An Alaskan fish has been reported by one observer
to survive freezing for "weeks" and "when thawed out they
will be as lively as ever. The pieces (which have been
chopped out of a frozen mass with an axe) which are thrown
to the ravenous dogs are eagerly swallowed, the animal heat
of the dog's stomach thaws the fish out, whereupon its move-
ments cause the dog to vomit it up alive. ' ' A Jonah among
the fishes ! '^
On the other hand some algas have been found living in
hot springs with a temperature of about 17()°F. and some
» The writer would hesitate to accept this story without corroborative
evidence. It has been cited however by Eigenmann in Ward & Whip-
ple's "Fresh Water Biology."
382 Biology in America
bacteria in tlic spore stage can survive boiling. Some fish
even may witJistand a temporatuie of 128°F. Many forms
of aquatic life however can api)arently only survive the win-
ter as eggs or other resting bwlies, which settle to the bottom,
there remaining quiescent until the advent of the spring.
The eggs of some crustaceans apparently require to be frozen,
whiU; others apparently inust be dried as well as frozen in
order to hatch. Many of them doubtless can survive long
periods of drouth and cold. Those of Estheria have been
hatclied after being kept dry for nine years.
Some aquatic animals survive unfavorable conditions by
surrounding themselves with a shell or cyst and lying dor-
mant for a time. The deeper waters in some lakes are ap-
parently entirely free from oxygen in summer. At tliis time
Professors Birge and Juday have found in certain Wisconsin
lakes a Cyclops, which surrounds itself with a gelatinous
shell, and goes to sleep until the cooler weather in the fall
causes the surface water to gradually settle to the bottom,
carrying with it the oxygen which it has absorbed from the
air; whereupon, the Cyclops wakes up, and throwing off its
sleeping jacket, resumes the ''strenuous life" once more.
Many crustaceans, rotifers and worms lay two kinds of
eggs — a thin-shelled "summer" c^^ which develops quickly
without fertilization, and a thick-shelled "winter" egg, which
after fertilization passes the winter at the bottom of pond
or pool to hatch in the succeeding spring. Fresh water
sponges and Bryozoa fonn resting bodies known as "stato-
blasts, " which over-winter in a resting condition, resuming
active growth in the spring. Flowering aquatic plants such
as the ditch grass, the crowfoot or the water-cress, may like
land plants, live for either one or more seasons. In the for-
mer case the life of the species is continued by seeds or re-
sistant buds, which, like the "winter eggs" of various spe-
cies of animals, live over winter at the bottom of pool or pond
to become active when the face of spring smiles again upon
the waters. In plants which live for more than one season
much of the plant dies in the fall, leaving mainly the under-
ground parts persisting over winter, from which the aquatic
and aerial stems and leaves are renewed the succeeding year.
Some plants however such as the hornwort (Ceratophyllum)
and the water- weed (Elodea) may retain their leaves through-
out the winter beneath the ice, and aid in furnishing oxygen
to support the animal inhabitants of the water. Plants and
animals living in temporary' pools can only persist through
the formation of resting bodies of some sort — seeds, eggs,
etc., which can withstand a prolonged period of drying.
Life of the Waters 383
Such temporary pools may be restocked, perhaps chiefly from
the outside by the action of wind, birds or other agencies.
But not only do inland waters show an annual cycle in
their life, dependent on the changing seasons; there may be
several cycles, some greater and some less, in the life of lake
or pond or river. These cycles depend in large measure
upon changes in amount of food-stuffs in the water. They
are initiated by the plants upon which the animals are pri-
marily dependent for their food. When the melting snows
and rains of spring are washing the surface of the land and
draining through the soil into lakes and rivers, they carry
with them large quantities of mineral and organic matters
in solution ; which substances, especially the latter, with their
high nitrogen content, furnish abundant food supply for
plants, which in turn serve as provender for animals. Rainy
periods later in the season may be followed by temporary in-
crease of life in inland waters. Even the phases of the moon
are seemingly reflected in the abundance of the plankton, for
Professor Kofoid, in his extensive studies on the plankton of
the Illinois River, found a series of monthly increases or
"pulses" of the plankton, corresponding roughly at least
with the periods of full moon, and possibly due to the in-
crease of light at these periods resulting in increased activity
of chlorophyl-bearing plants in the water.
The movements of fresh water animals, to which reference
has already been made, furnish a fascinating field for study.
They display vertical and horizontal migrations similar to
those of marine animals. The surface of a lake which may
be swarming with animals by night, may be almost depopu-
lated by day. In the cool days of spring and fall the shal-
low shore waters, readily heated by the sun, uiay be an at-
tractive haven for animals of many sorts, wliich in the^ hot
days of midsummer seek the cooler waters farther out from
shore. But not only are the movements of auimals coutroUed
by evident physical and clu'mical factors, thei-e appear to be
biological factors also which determine them, which is prob-
ably only another way of saying physical and chemical fac-
tors in a less evident form. But however that may be, fresh
water animals often congregate in great swarms, just as do
insects, fishes, birds or mammals. One region of a pond may
be almost free from some species of aninuil, while anotlier
region only a few feet distant may be so thickly populated
as to appear "milky" or "soupy" to the observer. In one
such swarm of the crustacean Moina the writer has estimated
more than 80,000 individuals in a quart of water. The cause
of such swarms is as yet unknown.
384 Biolof/y in America
Such in brief are a few of the methods, discoveries and
j)robleins of the acjiiatic biologist. Since time immemorial
men have turned to the water as tlie source of life, and to-
day the study of its life, in spite of difficullies nnd perplexi-
ties, is one of the most compelling fields of human interest.
CHAPTER XV
Economic biolufjtj. Dependence of nuin upon nature. Ig-
norance of 7iature the cause of economic loss. Conservation
and increase of natural resources.
An ardent French entomolog-ist in IMedford, IMass., was
one day eagerly inspecting some caterpillars which he had
reared from eggs brought by him from Europe, when some
of them, growing tired of his society, made their escape
and went on their way rejoicing. This was in 1869. From
1890 to 1900 :\Iassachusetts spent about $1,000,000 to fight
the gypsy moth. At this time the pest being partly under
control the efforts were relaxed, with the inevitable increase
of the pest, and its further spread over a large part of New-
England and into Canada. At the present time large sums
are spent annually by national, state and local agencies for
its repression, but in spite of these efforts large areas of for-
est are denuded every year and the pest is still spreading.
In 1850 caterpillars were devouring the trees of the eastern
United States. But in England there was a merry, if not
melodious little sparrow, who Avas supposed to enjoy nothing
so much as a meal of luscious juicy caterpillars, and so what
was more natural than to bring sparrows from the old world
to enjoy the rich feasts of caterpillars provided by the new?
But no sooner was the immigrant comfortably established
in his new home than he proceeded to follow the injunction
which the Creator gave to primitive man — "Be fruitful and
multiply and replenish the earth," and today ho has spread
over virtually all of the United States and nuich of Canada,
and is emulating the example of his fellow countrymen by
driving before him many of the native inhabitants and in-
heriting their patrimony; so that today the English sparrow
is one of the few recognized pests among our birds.
Inliabiting the wheat fields of the greater pai't of tlie
United States is a little fly known as the Hessian ily, about
an eighth of an inch long, which lays its eggs on the leaves
of the wheat, and whose larvaj as they hatch crawl down
tlie leaves to their base, where they burrow into the stem
and kill the plant. This fly is supi)osed to have come to
America as an unintentional ally of King George with his
385
The Gypsy Moth
(Rijjht) — Gypsy moth caterpillars on trunk of tree below band of
sticky material. From Burjiress, ' ' The Gypsy Moth and the Brown-tail
Moth and their Control," Farmers' Bulletin, No. 845.
Trees Stripped by Gypsy IMoth Cateki'ii.i-aks
Courtesy u] the U. S. Bureau oj Entomuluyy.
386
Man and NaUire
387
Hessian solcliors ; henee its name. Another immigrant which
came to us in Revolutionary days was the brown rat.^
This rat first crossed the Russian frontier of Asia in 1727
in such numbers that it soon overran Kurope, whence it came
to America. With the rat came its parasite, tlie deadly
Trichina, while more recently the j^et more deadly Bacillus
pestis of the bubonic playue has become established in Cali-
fornia, brought in by rats from oriental ports. What a pity
we cannot return to Europe with our compliments all of our
Field of Alfalfa
Ruined by meadow mice in the Humboldt Valley, Nevada, 1907.
Courtesy of the U. ih'. Buriuu of Biohujicdl Sinn ij.
undesirables, four-legged, as well as two-legged and winged
ones as well !
An old Welsh legend tells of the frantic father, wlio upon
returning to his home found his child missing, and the dog
which he had left to guard her dripping with blood ; and
thereupon slew the faithful creature, only to find his child
safe and the body of a great wolf which the ilog luul sla^in,
' There are two other si>ef'ies of naturalized rats in the United States
— the black and tlie roof rats. Both are too few and restricted in dis-
tribution to be of tiuich (Vdiiiiuiic importance, bciii",-- liehl in subjection
by the stronger and lierccr liroun rat.
388
Biology in America
lying nearby. Somewhat akin to liis feelings may have been
those of the farmer after sliooting the hawk which he thought
liad been preying upon his chickens, only to find in its talons
a rat, which was the real culprit. To kill a hawk is, in the
minds of most of us, a laudable act, for are not all hawks
"hen hawks," the inveterate enemies of the poultryman and
of smaller creatures of their own kind? So at least tliought
the farmers in the Humboldt Valley in Nevada, which in
1907 was visited by a plague of mice, which ate up every-
Eed-tailed Hawks
One of the commoner ' ' hen hawks ' ' of the farmer, from an ilhistra-
tion by Louis Agassi/. Fuertes.
Coiirttn!/ of the U. S. ISurciiu of Biological Survcp.
thing in sight, gnawing the bark from fruit trees, burrowing
in the alfalfa fields and destroying the potatoes and other
crops. Out of 20,000 acres of alfalfa, 15,000 were so badly
damaged that they had to be ploughed under. At the heifdit
of the plague in November, 1907, it was estimated that there
were from 8,000 to 12,000 mice to every acre, while the total
loss to the valley was estimated at $300,000. Such mouse
plagues are no new occurrence. Numerous outbreaks of these
pests have occurred in Europe at various times, their num-
bers sometimes becoming so great that the simple-minded
peasants half believed that they had been rained upon them
from the clouds.
The Barn Owl
I'liuto hji Elwin li. ^(nihorn.
Courtesy of the Seiv York Zooloijirnl Sorieti/.
A Pile of Skulls of Mice and Rats
Contained in the pellets disgoi-jjed by a family of l)ani owls. Fruin
Lantz, Fanners' Bulletin, No. (!70.
Courtesy of the U. S. J'.iireiiii of liioloyhal Sum i/.
389
390 i^iology in America
The abundance of the mice in Humboldt Valley attracted
hawks iu large inimbers to feast upon the good things which
Nature had so bountifully provided for them. But failing
to recognize in the hawks their best ally in their war against
the mice, the ignorant residents seized their guns and pro-
ceeded to slay their best friends; so that a traveler through
the valley observed twenty-nine of these birds hanging on
the fences.
So too thought the legislature of Pennsylvania when in 1895
they passed the notorious "scalp act," providing for a bounty
of fifty cents for every hawk or owl killed within the state,
as a result of which half-baked legislation more than 100,000
valuable birds were killed, at an expense of nearly $100,000
to the state for bounties and notary fees, and an estimated
loss of more than $4,000,000 from the increase of harmful
rodents resulthig from the destruction of their enemies, the
hawks and owls. And yet all this in the short space of a
year and a half. Fortunately the legislature soon recovered
its equilibrium and the law was repealed.
But how do we know that the hawks and owls, or at
least most of them, are the farmer's friends rather than
his enemies? A few specific facts will best answer this
query.
Hawks and owls have a habit of throwing up the undi-
gested parts of their food in the form of pellets containing
the hair, bones, feathers, etc., of their prey. For many years
a pair of barn owls were wont to nest in the tower of the
Smithsonian Institution in Washington. An examination of
two hundred pellets found beneath their nesting site revealed
451 skulls, of which 412 were those of mice, 20 of rats, 20
of shrews, one of a mole, while only one was that of a bird
(sparrow).
In the "Pacific Eural Press" for Oct. 23, 1897, is an account
of a pair of these same birds nesting in a pigeon house, whose
owner, supposing that they were feasting on his pigeons, shot
the male and trapped the female. Upon examining the nest
he found ten young "gophers" (ground squirrels?) in it,
whereupon he promptly released the female.
Of 146 stomachs of the great-horned owl examined, only
31 contained poultiy and 8 other birds, the remainder con-
taining various mammals, insects and miscellany.
An examination of 562 stomachs of the red-tailed hawk
showed remains of poultry or game birds in 54, other birds
in 51, mice in 278, other mammals in 131, insects in 47, mis-
cellany in 59, and nothing in 89.
It was primarily to answer questions such as these that
the U. S. Biological Survey was organized in 1885, becoming
Man and Nature 391
a bureau of the Department of Agriculture some twenty years
later. This bureau has contributed more to our knowledge,
both scientific and economic, of tiie birds and maimiials of
North America than any other agency. We cannot in so
brief a compass do justice to its work, but a bird's eye glance
at it may be of interest. At the outset it nuist be admitted
that, like a lusty youngster, the Bureau has fre(iuently out-
grown its clothes, and frequently also has it wandered far
from its parental home. In how far the hair-splitting re-
finements in the classification of birds and mammals in wliich
it has often indulged itself may be of value either to science
or agriculture is open to question, but there can be no ques-
tion of the value l)oth to science and agriculture of the great
bulk of its work. The vast amount of data which it has
gathered relative to the classification and distribution of
North American birds and mammals are indispensable to
any study of the influence of environment upon their evolu-
tion and spread, wliile its studies on the migration of birds
have furnished invaluable data not oidy for the study of the
causes of this as yet inexplicable phenomenon, but also for
the formulation of laws for their protection.
Prior to the establishment of the Bureau our knowledge
of the food habits of birds was the result of a few sporadi(
investigations. Since its inception it has conducted a sys-
tematic study of this question, including the examination ot
some 80,000 stomachs of many species of birds, as a result of
which we now have very definite information regarding the
economic value of most of our wild birds, and can pursue a
rational program for their protection. I\Tany instances of
the value of birds to the farmer which have been sliown by
these investigations could be cited, in addition to those al-
ready given of the food habits of hawks and owls. One of
the worst foes of the horticulturist, especially the fruit grower
of California, is the scale insect. This, as its name implies,
is a tiny scale-like creature of no resemblance externally to
an insect, but containing evidence of its relationshi]i in its
internal structure and its development. I have no data rela-
tive to losses from scale insects, but an estimate of a cost of
10 to 25 cents a tree as a protective tax against the San Jose
scale, gives some idea of the burden they put upon the fruit
grower. We shall have more to say regarding Ihese insects
later on, but for the present we note that the Bureau has
shown, what was formerly unknown, that many species of
birds prey upon them, while of some species they form the
favorite food.
The habitue of field and fon^tst, who seeks his favorite haunts
after the first snow fall of the winter, is likely to encounter
392 Biology in America
companies of little birds, who, in spite of winter and its snow,
are busily engaged in reaping the plentiful harvest of the
weeds. Flitting from stem to stem, they pick out the seeds
from their siiells, wliile others follow in their wake to pick
up the gleanings from the snow. The late Dr. Judd of the
Survey, in his studies of the food liabits of sparrows, exam-
ined a piece of ground eighteen inches square in a patch
of smartvveed where several species of sparrows had been
feeding. On this patch he c(mnted "113U half seeds and
only 2 whole seeds. During the ensuing season no smart-
weed grew where the sparrows had caused this extensive de-
struction."- It has been estimated that in Iowa alone a
single species, the tree sparrow, destroys in one year 875 tons
of weed seed, and tliat in tlie United States as a whole
the clilferent species of native sparrows, numbering more
tlum one hundred, save $35,000,000 for tlie farmers every
year.
Heretofore the protection of our birds has been more or
less of a hit or miss undertaking, principally the latter.
"While the birds might be fairly well protected in one state,
they received little or no protection in another. Realizing
these inequalities and injustices in our local laws, the Sur-
vey, aided by bird lovers throughout the ccnntrv, drew up
and put through Congress in 1913 the m'grarory bird law,
which gives the nation control of all m'^rrating birds within
its domain. \^y this aet all such are afforded uniform pro-
tection throughout the United States, and while the law is
imperfect in itself and as yet inade(}uately enforced, its re-
sults even so have been very gratifying. Especially is this
true of game birds. Previous to the passage of this law the
shooting of game birds during the spring migration, when
the birds were en route to their breeding grounds, and in
many instances had actually begun to breed, was permitted
by some states. With the abolition of the spring shooting has
come a notable increase of the birds in the fall, which is the
legitimate time for hunting. In 1916 a treaty was drawn up
between the United States and Canada, providing for the
protection of migrating birds between the two countries. This
treaty has recently been made effective through the passage of
the necessary legislation by both countries. The Lacey Act,
passed in 1900, which controls the shipment of game from
one state to anotlicr, and has been an efficient check to the
pot hunter who ships his game to large cities for market, is
another outcome of the Survey 's efforts to protect our wild
birds and mammals.
^'Judd, "Tlie Kelatinii of Sparrows to Agriculture," Biol. Survey,
Bull. 15.
Man and Nature 393
But the protection of the farmer's friends is only one of
the Bureau's manifold activities. Many a wild creature is
the farmer's inveterate enemy and does untold damage to
his cattle or his crops. Witli the drain on the world's re-
sources caused by the great war and its aftenuath of an-
archy and ruin, and the ever-mounting cost of existence, it
behooves us to close up every leak where natural wealth is
wasted. Within the borders of our country today, we are
harboring a host of jiarasites, who are "eating us ont of house
and home." On our western ranges we are feeding our
wolves and coyotes $20,(U1U,()()() worth of stock every year;
to ground squirrels, mice and other rodents we contribute
i|>ir)U,0()(),0()0 worth (;f f(()d crops, vvliilc the brown rat levies
an additional toll of $2()(),UUU,0U0. These figures perchance
sound excessive. Let us analyze them a little closer.
"As an indication of the losses due to ])r,'(latory animals
it may be stated that the ehairman of the State Live Stock
Board of Utah estimates an annual loss in that region amount-
ing to 500,000 sheep and 4,000,000 pounds of wool. Tlie presi-
dent of the New Mexico College of Agriculture, as a result of a
survey of conditions in tliat state, estimates an aiuiual loss
there of 3 per cent of the cattle, or 34,000 head, and 105,000
sheep. A single wolf killed by one of the Bureau hunters in
southern New Mexico was reported by stock owners of that
vicinity to have killed during the precediug six months 150
head of cattle valued at not less than $5,000. In July, 1917,
two male wolves were killed in Wyoming which in May had
destroyed 150 sheep and 7 colts. Another pair of wolves
killed near Opal, Wyoming, were reported to have kiUed about
$4,000 worth of stock a year. Another Wyoming wolf,
trapped in June, 1918, had killed 30 cattle during the
spring. ' ' ^
"In the Arnold Arboretum, Jamaica Plains, ^^.Tas-;., dnriiig
the winter of 1903-4, meadow mice destroyed tl' uisands of
trees and shrubs, including apple, maple, sumac, barberry,
buckthorn, dwarf cherry, snowball, busli honeysuckle, juniper,
blueberry, dogwood, beech, and larch. Plants in luirsery beds
and acorns and cuttings in boxes especially were harmed. . . .
During the winter of 1905-0 a small orchard of apple and
pear trees near Washington, D. C, was under observation
from October to Ai)ril. Attacks by meadow mice l)egan in
the early fall, possibly in August. They were contiiuied dur-
ing every succeeding montli, being greatest during two short
periods of snow. . . . Adjoining the orchard was a tangUnl
thicket on low, moist ground, in which meadow mice were
abundant.
'Eeport of Chief of Bureau of Biological Survey, 191S, p. :5.
394
Biology in America
"On IMarch Ifi, 1906, I found that of 380 apple trees,
164, or over 43 ])(>r cent, were ruined, being completely gir-
dled, some to a height of 8 to ]() inches above the ground.
Thirty-six others, nearly 10 per cent, were less badly injured,
while 180, or 47 per cent, apparently, were uninjured. Of
200 pear trees in the orchard 50 were more or less seriously
damaged. The injury to these was intlicted early in the
fall. . . .
"In December, 1903, I examined a large orchard in Marion
Meadow Mice
A great pest wliicli sometimes become so numerous as to form veritable
plagues. From an illustration by Morita.
CotirtiHU of the U. ;S'. liurcitii of Jiioloyicul Purvey.
County, Kan., where field mice were causing much damage.
. . . The orchard comprised 480 acres and contained about
26,000 trees, mostly apple, eight to ten years transplanted.
The trees averaged about 4 inches in diameter, but many
measured 5 or 6 inches. The majority were headed low, their
outer drooping branches touching the ground. In the spring
of 1903 corn had been planted by listing it in the open spaces
between the rows of trees ; but owing to an unusually wet sum-
mer, the crop had been abandoned, and sunflowers and other
weeds and grasses luid made a luxuriant growth throughout
the orchard. Over much of the area, ai)parently, no attempt
Man and Nature
39;
had boon made to cut down tlie weeds; and where tliey liad
been mowed they liad been raked into piles and not burned
or removed.
"In this neglected orchard field mice — the prairie vole —
had found a congenial home. Already abundant in 1002,
they bred plentifully in the open fall of that year and in the
early warm spring of 19();i The ensuing moist sununer also
was favorable for continued- reproduction, and by llie fall
of 1903 they were present in hordes. All the orchards of
the neighboriiood — a comparatively level upland prairie — had
Apple Tree Girdled by Meadow Mice
CoiirtcsD of the I'. S. liurtitu of Blvlogivnl Sum if.
been neglect<'d and all were invaded by mice; buf the one
above mentioned was the largest and most neglected, and
therefore it suffered most severely. By Decend)er 18, the
date of my first visit, mice had wholly or partially girdled
at the surface of the ground fully 5, 000 apiile ti'ces and had
denudeil of bark numy of the low branches. The owners of
the orchard, thinking that none of the trees could survive the
injuries, then estimated their loss at fi-om $'25,000 to $30,000.
"Examination showed that the ground evi'rywhere was
honeycond)ed by mouse burrows and tunnels to a depth of
3 or 4 inches, and that the surface was almost covered by a
396 Biology in America
network of rninvays of the prairie vole. Upon di<2:ging into
tlie burrows at the base of apple trees, I found many twigs,
4 to H inclu'S long, that had been entirely stripped of bark
and left lying in little piles. I had no difficulty in finding
where the twigs ha<l been severed fi-om low-growing branches
and the ti])s of sj)routs, and in distinguishing, by the smaller
tooth marks, the cutting done by mice from that done by
rabbits. Whether the twigs had been first stored and after-
wards fed upon in cold weather, I was unable to determine,
for 1 found none with bark remaining upon them. Piobably
they were carried to the burrows merely for leisurely but
innnediate consumption,
"Contrary to the usual habits of voles in our Northern
States, this injury had been done during mild weather. Up
to December 18 the season had been very warm and open. No
snow lay on the ground for more than twenty-four hours.
Ordinary food, such as grass, seeds, and grain, was abun-
dant, so that the only explanation for the injury to trees
seems to be the vast numbers of voles present and their pref-
erence for a partial diet of bark.
"Voles, however, were not the only animals abundant in
the orchard. Rabbits, both cottontails and jacks, were there
in great numbers, and already had begun to eat the bark on
the trunks of some of the trees and on the low limbs, and to
cut the tips of branches and sprouts within their reach.
Later, when cold weather set in and snow covered the ground,
they also seriously damaged the trees. " *
"Experiments show that the average quantity of grain
consumed by a full-grown rat is fully 2 ounces daily. A
half-grown rat eats about as much as an adult. Fed on grain,
a rat eats 45 to 50 pounds a year, worth about 60 cents if
wheat, or $1.80 if oatmeal. Fed on beefsteaks worth 25 cents
a pound, or on young chicks or squabs with a much higher
prospective value, the cost of maintaining a rat is propor-
tionately increased. Granted that more than half the food
of our "rats is waste, the average cost of keeping one rat is
still upward of 25 cents a year.
"If an accurate census of the rats of the United States were
possible, a reasonably correct calculation of the minimum
cost of feeding them could be made from the above data.
If the nund)er of rats supported by the people throughout
the United States were equal to the number of domestic ani-
mals on the farms— horses, cattle, sheep, and hogs— the mini-
mum cost of feeding them on grain would be upward of $100,-
000,000 a year. To some such enormous total every farmer,
^Lantz, "An Economic Study of Field Mice." Biol. Survey, Bull,
31, pp. 25-9.
Man and Nature
397
and indeed every householder who lias rats upon liis prem-
ises, contributed a share.'''
"(Corn) sufit'ers <ireater injury Iroiii rats than any other
crop in the TTnited States. Besides depredations on newly sown
seed, the animals attack the grrowino; jyrain when in the milk
stage. They cliinb the upright stalks and often strip the
cobs clean of grain. The writer has seen whole fields of corn
so destroyed and in many cases has observed parts of fields
amounting to several acres practically ruined. A writer in
the "American Agriculturist" reported an instance in which
> ■•^^* '^
The Cottontail EABurr in its Form
From Lantz, ' ' Cottontail Rabbits in Eolation to Trees and Farm
Crops," Farmers' Bulletin, No. 702.
Courtesy of the U. S. Burvmi of Biolof/icul Kuririj.
rats destroyed three-fourths of the com on 13 acres of land.
In 1905 a large portion of the crop grown on the I'otomac flats
near Washington was destroyed by rats. . . . A farmer liv-
ing near Grand River, Iowa, relates the following experience:
" 'We had about 2,000 bushels of corn in 3 cribs to which
rats ran, and they ate and destroyed about one-fourth of the
corn. IMuch of it was too dirty to put tliruugli the grinder
until it had been cleaned an ear at a time. All the time we
were poisoning and trapping the rats. We killed as high as
300 rats in two days and could liardly miss them. They de-
^At the present time these figures would be considerably greater.
398 Biology in America
stroyod iiinro llian enough corn to pay taxes on 400 acres
of land.'
* ' The destruction of feed stuffe by rats is a serious loss not
only on the farm but in almost every city and village in the
wliole country. Often through carelessness or the indiffer-
ence of servants, the bin or barrel in which feed is kept is
left uncovered, and rats fairly swarm to the nightly feast.
In some cases investigated in Washington, D. C, the loss was
e<iua] to 5 or 10 per cent of the grain l)()ught. A grocer was
buying feed for two horses and several hundred rats; the
horses were fed at regular intervals, the rats nearly all the
time. In the cases of establishments keeping from fifty to
a hundred horses, the loss of feed in the course of a year
often amounts to a large item.
"Rats destroy also many eggs both on farms and in cities.
Fresh as well as incubated eggs are eaten by these rodents.
Commission men and grocers complain much of depredations
upon packed eggs. Those at the top of a case are broken by
these animals, and parts of the yolks run down and stain the
unbroken ones. Often, however, rats carry away eggs with-
out breaking them, and display much ingenuity in getting
them over obstacles, as up or down a stairway. On a level
surface the rat rolls the egg before him, but he can easily
carry it between a paw and his neck and chin, while going
upon three legs.
''A commission merchant in "Washington relates that he
once stored in his warehouse 100 dozen eggs in a wooden tub
with a lid of boards nailed on. Rats gnawed a hole through
the tub at the top and carried away all but 281/2 dozen, leav-
ing no shells or stains to show that any had been broken. . . .
"Rats are very destructive to tame pigeons, attacking es-
pecially young squabs, but destroying eggs, also. They often
show great cunning in finding entrances to the cages. A
fancier residing in Washington, D. C, missed many of his
squabs and was satisfied that the only opening by which an
animal could enter was the exit at the top of the flying cage.
He closed the opening and set a trap there, in which he caught
a large rat. The animal had climbed the wire netting on the
outside and descended it on the inside to reach the pigeons. ' ' ^
And all these like so many other losses, are largely the re-
sult of ignorance or carelessness.
Not only are these destroyers living at our expense, but
many of them are repaying our indulgence by spreading dis-
ease among man and beast. We shall see elsewhere how the
rat, and to a lesser extent, the ground squirrel in California
are a constant menace to our health, while in many of the
"Lantz, "The Brown Eat in the United States," pp. 18-23.
Man and Nature
3!).')
western states, the wolf and coyote are spreading rabies anions
our stock and thus indirectly endan{z:eriii<i: human life itself.
One of the most important activities of the l^ureau at the
present time is the destruction of these noxious aniinals. It
keeps a force of about thi-ee hnn<li-ed men in the field traj)-
ping, shooting and poisoning ])redatory animals, mainly
^^^^!'f*^'^
.Fi. h'Ai-.'^'f:- 'CP -ff
The Common Eat
Whose board bill is costing us i7i the neighborhootl of .^^OOjOOOjOOO
annually. Prom a drawing by E. R. Kalnibach.
Courtesy of the U. H. Ruremi. of Hioloyicdl Hurvey.
wolves, coyotes, wild cats, aiul to a lesser extent, bears and
mountain lions. Definite results are difficult to show as a
result of this campaign, but a very nuirked reduction in
stock losses has been noted in those regions where it has bern
consistently carried on.
Let us turn aside for a moment and follow one of the Sur-
vey's hunters on his lonely way as he pursues the big gray
400 Biology in America
wolf of our western plains. AVhetlicr tliese animals are in-
telli<;eiit or not we shall leave to the psychologists to decide,
if they can: their actions in any event certainly appear so.
The wolf is a highly picturesque and interesting outlaw. His
teeth arc turned ''against every man and every man's hand
against hiiu." With every sense rendered keen by the sharp-
ness of liis struggU' for existence lie lias become on the one
lunul a most skillful thief, and on the other a most elusive
criminal. The most tempting bait will not decoy him into
a trap, while the least scent of man is a warning of dan-
ger. The trapjier as he goes afield soon strikes some cattle
path or trail, winding in and out among the hills. He fol-
lows this until he finds two bushes growing a few inches apart.
Between these he makes a little hole in which he sets his trap
and firinly fixes it to a sunken stake or heavy stone. Upon
the trap he lays a sheet of paper which is well covered with
fine earth and bits of sticks or leaves or straw, causing the
surface of the ground over the trap to appear as natural as
possible. Over all a little water is sprinkled and nearby a
few drops of wolf perfume or scent. Xow^ a wolf's notions
as to perfume are not exactly in accordance with our own. A
very choice preparation for a wolf is prepared by allowing
a chuid< of raw meat to rot until it "smells to Heaven." To
this is addetl some animal oil such as sperm or lard oil and
then a little musk or beaver castor. In preparing the trap
great care must be taken to avoid leaving any trace of hu-
man scent. This is prevented by wearing old, well scented
gloves and covering the shoes with scent.
Or the trapper finds beneath some overhanging ledge of
rock, high on the slope of a barren hill, tracks it may be
leading to a den, or the bones of some unfortunate victim,
and digging out the den a family of puppies is discovered
and their earthly career is quickly ended. Or the freshly
killed carcass of beef or sheep is found, which is poisoned
witli strychnin and when the wolf returns for a second meal,
this meal becomes his last.
The war on prairie dogs, ground squirrels, pocket gophers
and other rodents is largely conducted with poisoned grain.
A few kernels of grain poisoned with strychnin placed in a
burrow will effectually dispose of the occupants in short
order.
"As an illustration of the effectiveness and economy of the
methods of destroying these pests, a badly infested plot of
320 acres was chosen for a demonstration in northern Ari-
zona. One man spent a day distributing poison over this
area, at a total cost for labor and material of $0.79. The
following day 1,641 dead prairie-dogs were picked up from
Gray Wolf and Pups
Killed by one of the government hunters.
«. -•»
OxE OF THE Many Species of Ground Squirrels
Against which the government is now waging an active campaign.
Courtesy of the U. t>. Bureau of Biological Hurvcy.
401
402 Biolog]/ in Awrrira
tliis trai't. AVitli tlie imraber which must have (lied in their
holes, tlierc can he litth' question that more than 2,000 prairie-
dogs were destroyed in this experiment.
"More than 3,5()(),()()0 acres of Government land have been
practically freed from these pests. "^
One of the worst ])()achers in the West is the jack rabldt,
which one may occasionally see from the railway, loping leis-
urely across the prairie, or sitting up on Ins haunches to gaze
w^ith fearless curiosity at the passing train. Besides helping
himself libei-ally to the farmer's grain and hay, he varies his
diet now and then by nibbling a circular strip of bark from
the fruit trees, "girdling" and thereby killing them. A fa-
vorite pastime in the Southwest has been the rabbit drive.
On a given day a troop of boys and men with dog.s and
horses form a line about a given area and then riding to
■5^
■^ ■ ■ ^--- J)
The Pocket Gopher
One of our numerous mammal pests. From an illustration by E. T.
Seton.
CoiirtiKi/ of the f. ,S'. Hiircdu of liiol<)<jlc<il t^urici/.
and fro, with the aid of the dogs, proceed to "beat up" the
doomed rabbits, and gradually converging, drive them toward
the town where the residents are waiting to receive them, not
with open arms, but with clubs and shot guns. In this way,
not only is the neighborhood rid of a host of pests, but a large
supply of meat is provided.
The trap is also an effective weapon in the campaign against
the furry pests of field and orchard.
Through the watchful activity of the Bureau it is probable
that many another catastrophe similar to the introduction of
the English sparrow, gypsy moth, and Hessian fly has been
averted. Some years ago the mongoose applied for admis-
sion to the United States, and a few iiulividuals did in fact
gain an entrance. The mongoose has been called the "cat
of I'haraoh" and strangely enough it has also been named
"Pharaoh's mouse." It is a traditional enemy of serpents
and "according to Aristotle and Pliny (it) first coats its body
' Keport of Chief of Bureau of Biological Survey, 1918, p. 4.
Man and Nature
403
with a coating of mud, in wliich it wallows, and then with
this armour can dci'y the s(>ri)('nt. Topscll icjls the tale bet-
ter. The lehneuiiion burrows in the sand, and 'when the
aspe espyeth her threatening rage, presently turning about
San Sost Scale
a, Adult fenialo sr-alo; b, male scale; e, younjj scales; d, larva just
liatdied ; d', same, much enlarged; e, scale removed, showing body of
female beneath; f, body of female insect, more enlarged; g, adult male
of the San Jose scale. From Quaiutance, "The San Jose Scale and its
Control," Farmers' Bulletin, No. 050.
tUiurivsy 0} the U. >S'. ISiinnii of Kntnmnliiiiti.
her taile, provoketh the ichneumon to combate, and willi an
open mouth and lofty head doth enter the list, to her owne
perdition. For the iciineumon being nothing afraid of this
great bravado, reeeivetli tlie encounter, antl taking the head
of the aspe in his mouth biteth that off to prevent the east-
404
Biology in America
ing out of her poison.' In the "West Indies the animal has
been described as fearlessly attacking the deadly Fer de Lance
and receiving its bites with inipnnity; it is also added that it
will eat the leaves of a particular plant as an antidote ! The
real explanation of the result of these encounters is of course
the agility of the Ichneumon." ^
The mongoose preys on mice and rats, but unfortunately
attacks poultry and wild birds as well. It has been intro-
duced into Jamaica where it has proven a nuisance through
Mass of San Jose Scales on Tree Trunk x 30
From Quaintance, ' ' The San Jose Scale and its Control, ' ' Farmers '
Bulletin, No. 050.
Cmtrtcsy of the U. .S. Biircaii of Entomology.
its dei)redations. By the passage of a law placing the im-
portation of foreign animals under the control of the Sec-
retary of Agriculture, the Bureau has been able to prevent its
establishment in the United States.
Monstrous as is the tax which we pay to our four-footed
foes, it is small in comparison with the tribute levied by our
winged enemies. Estimates of so uncertain a sum as the loss
caused by insects are bound to vary, but even accepting the
'"Cambridge Natural History," Mammalia, p. 409. By permission
of the Macnullau Company.
Man and Katur6
405
minimum figure of $1,000,000,000 annually, the amount is
surely ample. Early awake to the danger from insect posts
Congress in 1854 appointed an entomologist, whose work was
at first conducted under direction of the Commissioner of
Patents, but upon the organization of the Department of
Agriculture in 1889 was embodied in the Division, now the
Bureau of Entomology.
Apples Infested with San Jose Scale
From Quaintance, "The San Jose Scale and its Control," Farmers'
Bulletin, No. 650.
Courtisi/ of tlin T'. ."?. liiirrdit of lUitomology.
In the eighties the orange and lemon groves of California
were threatened with ruin by, the innocent looking, bnt de-
structive scale insect," to which Ave luive already referred.
Soon the Bureau of Entomology had experts on tiie ground
learning all they could about the vicious stranger. In tlie
course of their studies they h'arni'd that the scale insects were
natives of Australia, whence they had been imjiorted into
California on young orange trees in 18G8. Now it occurred
"The lluted scale.
4(J()
Biology in America
to them tliat in tlio native liome of the scale might perchance
be found some natural enemy, wliieh if introduced into Cal-
ifornia migiit drive out, or at least hold in cheek the terrible
scale. And so one of them journeyed to Australia and there
he found the ladybird beetle, Vedalia, which i)reyed upon the
scale. Ami this he brought back with him to California,
The Pitiful Ladybird
a, Rootle ; b, larva ; e, pupa ; d, blossom end of pear, showing scales
with larvco of ladybird feeding on them, and i)upic of ladybird attacdied
Avithin the calyx. From Quaintance, ' ' The San Jose Scale and its Con-
trol," Farmers' Bulletin, No. 650.
CoHrtcsij uf the U. .S". Biircait uf Entomoloffy.
wher(^ it throve; and making war upon the scale it has ever
since heUl it in check, delivering the orange and the lemon
from their threatened destruction.
Similar attempts have been made for several years in the
war on the l)rown-tail and gypsy moths, which are so destruc-
tive to fruit and shade trees in New England, and while the
results have been less spectacular than in the ease of the
Man and Nature 407
scale insects, tlie prospects for the ultimate control of these
pests in this way are promising.
In Hawaii the ravages of the sugar-cane weevil, wliicli
bores its destructive way into the sugar canes, have been ma-
terially reduced by the introduction of a pai'asitic fly from
British New Guinea. Anotlier dread enemy of the Hawaiian
sugar planter is a little bug known as a "leaf hopper," which
was probably introduced from Australia about 1898. Soon
it was doing so much damage that the production of one large
plantation fell from 10,954 tons in 19U4 to 82G tons in 1906.
Meantime however the expert entomologists were on the trail
of the leaf hopper, pursuing it with jjarasites, furnished by
Australia. Their first attempts were failures, but these were
shortly followed by success. The parasites throve and soon
had the pest so well under control that this same plantation
yielded in 1907 11,630 tons of sugar.
But the path of the experimental entomologist is by no
means always strewn with roses. There is in P^urope a fly
which parasitizes the caterpillar of the brown-tail motli, which
is covered with poisonous hairs. These hairs are sufificiently
poisonous to produce a serious eruption in man known as the
"brown-tail rash." Now there is in this country a variety
of the same species of parasite, which does not attack the
brown-tail's larva because apparently it is susceptible to the
poison of the latter 's hairs. Upon the discovery of these facts,
the European race was imported into the United States in
large numbers, and in the following year was found to be at-
tacking the caterpillars of the brown-tail moth. The enthusi-
asm of the entomologists aroused by this discovery was short
lived however, for the next year none of the caterpillars was
attacked. The explanation of this unfortunate state of af-
fairs proved to be that the foreigners were interbreeding with
the natives, and their offspring had lost the immunity enjoyed
by their European cousins.
In 1796 an epidemic broke out among Pennsylvania cattle,
which was traced to a herd from South Carolina which al-
though healthy themselves were infectious to olher animals.
In 1868 Texas cattle shipped into Illinois and Indiana brought
disease into these states causing such extensive ravages that
the eastern states became alarmed, not only because of the
loss to stockmen themselves, but because of dreaded injury
to human health from the consumption of tliseased meat.
The cause of all this trouble is a protozoan, parasitic in the
blood of cattle, where it produces a disease somewhat sim-
ilar to malaria in man; while the disseminator of infection is
the cattle tick, tlie life history of which is briefly as follo\ys.
After gorging itself upon the blood of its unfortunate vie-
408
Biology in America
tim, the fertilized female drops to the ground, and deposits
on the avoi-age about 2,000 sliiny brown eggs about 1/50
inch in diameter. These hatcli in about three weeks in
summer, while in winter incubation may require nearly six
months. After hatching the young tick becomes ambitious,
crawling up blades of grass, stems, or posts and there waiting
like Mr. Micawber "for something to turn up." Meantime
it keeps its forelegs waving to and fro ready to grasp the
"Screw Worm" and Cattle Tick
A — A "screw worm," the larva of a fly, so-called from the rings of
spines about tlie body.
C and B — Cattle ticks before and after feeding.
donrtiKji itj the V. S. liiiniiK of Kiitomolog}/.
hair of the first animal which comes its way. It may thus
patiently await its victim for more than five months, under
favorable conditions, but the victim failing to arrive it finally
dies. If an unlucky steer comes its way it grasps its hair
and crawling up attaches itself to the skin. Here it molts
twice, is fertilized, gorged with blood, and drops to the ground
to repeat the vicious cycle.
Man and Nature 409
By careful quarantine measures and the treatment of tick-
infected cattle with an arsenical dip the Department of Ag-
riculture has freed some 500,000 square miles of the quaran-
tined area in tlie southern states from a pest, which at one
time was estimated to cost the nation from $-10,1)00,000 to
$100,000,000 annually. For the cattle tick not only does vast
damage by transmission of disease, but as a blood-sucker
levies a tremendous toll upon the cattleman. It has been es-
timated that as much as 200 pounds of blood may be lost by
an animal in a single season, while in the case of the horse
tick, as much as fourteen pounds of ticks have been dropped
from one animal in three days, and probably as much more
was still attached. But further, the tick has a companion
in villainy, for in the sores which it makes the screw-worm
fly deposits its eggs, from which the larvas burrow into the
body of the unfortunate victim.
Our knowledge of the Hy and the mosquito, upon which
the campaign against these pests has been based, is largely
due to the work of the Bureau of Entomology.
But space will not permit further discussion of our prog-
ress in wealth, health and happiness, due to the work of the
economic entomologist.
The work of ridding the South of the cattle tick is in
charge of the Bureau of Animal Industry in the Department
of Agriculture, whose duty also it is to wage increasing war-
fare upon the animal diseases which are a constant mciuice
to the nation's supply of meat, leather and other animal
products. Scab mites, which in years past levied a heavy
toll upon the cattle grower, have been nearly exterminated ;
the foot and mouth disease, which in 1914 was epidemic in
twenty-two states, and was seriously threatening the live stock
industry of the country, was stamped out after a hard fight ;
hog cholera, ever a serious drain upon the hog industry, is
gradually being brought under control by the use of a serum
and other measures, and an active campaign is now under
way for the suppression of tuberculosis in hogs and cattle,
a disease serious not alone to the animal industry, but, wiien
present in dairy cattle, a very probable nuMuice to human
life itself. The work of the Bureau in safeguarding our
meat supply is mentioned in another chapter.
In addition to its campaign against diseases both animal
and hunum, the Bureau is also actively engaged in the in-
crease and improvement of our supi)lies of meat, milk and
other animal products, ])ut details concerning this work would
carry us too far afield.
But the economic biologist is concerned not alone with
holding fast that which he hath. 1 1 is duty it is likewise to
410
Biology in America
seek "fresli fields to eonquor" and to lay new tribntes npon
the altar of coninierce. Tlic earliest record of the ini})orta-
tion of animals of eoinmercial importance from one country
to anotlier is the story of the Chinese princess, who, defyinf?
imperial edicts for love of her betrothed, bronji'ht some eggs
The Quarter-Acre Bamboo CIrove at the C. J. Edwards Place
Near Abbeville, Louisiana. Planted in 1898, in 1915 it produced
over 200 large shoots.
Coiirtcsir of Die I'. S. Hiircdii oj I'Innt Induntrii.
of the silkworm over the mountains to her Indian lover, while
in the days of Justinian silkworms were brought to Con-
stantinojjle by Persian priests, who concealed the eggs of the
moth in hollow canes.
America is a great experiment station for the breeding of
new animals and plants, where the "stranger within our
Man and Nature
411
gates," whether man or lieast or flower, is jriveii tlie best
opportunity for niakiii<;- the most of himself. When we tliink
of our immigrants solely in terms of pettieoats and pan-
taloons we should not overlook the fact that many of thciii
are clad in furs or feathers or in the raiment of the lilies,
and among- these innnigrants we find not only tlie Knglish
sparrow and the rat, the pugilists and sneak thieves of the
lower strata of animal society, hut the ring-necked pheasant
The Udo
Thrives in the eastern United States and California. The bhuiched
shoots make a very delit-ions salad vegetable. Introduced by the l^. S.
Department of Agriculture from Japan, where it is a very pojjular
article of food.
Courtesy of the U. S. lUirrdu of Phnit IniUtslfy.
and the reindeer, the aristocrats of the animal world; while
if Russia has contributed her thistles as well as her anar-
chists to our society, no less has she given us her alfalfa and
her fruits, as well as her musicians and her scholars.
With the inrush of the eager throngs of Europe and of
Asia to our shores, with our rapidly growing population, and
occupation of our public donuiin ; it behooves us to "take
thought for the morrow" in order that we may have the
wherewithal to feed and clothe and shelter our future liordes.
So Uncle Sam, ever mindful of the welfare of his children,
412
Biology in America
has establislicd ainoiig liis many agencies for this purpose, the
Offi('(^ of Forci*:!! Seed and Plant Introduction of the Uureau
of IMant industry in tlie Department of Agriculture, whose
duty it is to go into the "uttermost parts of the earth" and
bring back to us its treasures. From the Asian steppes to
the jungh's of the tropics its exph)r(M-s liave gone, and from
the fertih' ish^s of Japan to tlie (k'serts of Arabia, in their
search for the useful and the beautiful, to enrich our fields
and adorn our dwellings.
A Single Crown of the Udo after Blanching
Cmirtcsy of the I'. S. Bureau of Plant Industry.
To even name, let alone describe all the manifold varieties
of plants whose introduction the Office has attempted, would
be out of the question in these pages, but a few of them may
be mentioned.
We are accustomed to think of the bamboo in terms of
wicker work or fishing rods, but how many of us realize that
the young bamboo shoots, which grow at the rate of a foot a
day, are succulent and may be eaten like asparagus tips, while
the seeds of some species may be used as grain, and the fruits
of others cooked and eaten? How often do we think of the
Man and Nature
413
bamboo as serving; such varied uses as pulp for paper, masts
for vessels, pipes for \vat(M- and timber for buildinfrs? Says
JNIr. David Faiieliild, in eliarge of the plant introduction woik
for the Bureau of Plant Industry: "... there is no plant
in the world which is ])ut to so many uses as the bamboo, and
Thk Tung Oil Tree
One of the many valuable plant ininiigrants introduced into the
United States by the U. S. Bureau of Plant Industry.
Courtesy of the Bureau.
in the regions where it grows it is apparently the most in-
dispensable of all plants." Strange as it may seem, the
bamboo is not a ti-ee in the ordinary sense of the word, but'
a grass, the rings on the stem marking the points of inser-
tion of the leaves.
About twenty years ago Mr. William Tevis of San Fran-
cisco bought a specimen of the giant Japanese bamboo from
414
Biology in America
a Japanese inu-seryinan, which he planted in Bakersfield,
and from whieh in a few years sj)rang a heautit'ul grove of
trees over fifty feet in height. Several species of bamboo
have been introduced into California, while in Florida and
other southei'n states are bamboo groves planted by the
Bureau in its experimental gardens.
In the markets of Japan are for sale the stalks of the udo
which is used by the Ja})anese and foreign residents as we
Branch of the Tung Oil Tree
Tlie large kernels inside these fruits form the wood oil nuts from
which one of the most valuable drying oils known is extracted. These
trees will grow in the Gulf States.
CourtiKii of tliv r. .S'. liiinau of Plant Itiduxtnj.
use asparagus, but the udo has the advantage of the aspara-
gus, in that its stalks, which are often two feet long and over
an inch in diameter at the base, are completely edible, in-
stead of the tips alone as is- the case with the asparagus. It
is a hardy plant and can probably be raised throughout the
United States, though at i)resent it is raised chiefly in the
Sacramento Valley. The udo was introduced into the United
States by Fairchild and Barbour Lathrop of Chicago in
1903.
Those of us who have enjoyed the delightful hospitality of
Man and Nature
415
the South, may liave been victims of a little practical joke on
the part of our friends, when we accepted from them a fruit
somewhat resembling a plum or large cherry of a yellowish
or pinkish color, which made our mouths water in anticipa-
tion and pucker in realization. But the Japanese long ago
learned how to take the pucker out of persimmon by packing
it in barrels saturated with sake or Japanese "booze," and
experts of the Bureau of Chemistry have found a means of
similarly de-puckering the persimmon with carbon dioxide.
But this process is unnecessary with a new variety of Chi-
A View of the Avenue of Pistache Trees
At the Plant Introduction Station at Chico, California. In the
autumn the leaves of this Chinese pistache turn a beautiful scarlet.
Uourtesi/ of the U. iS'. Bureau of PUint Industry.
nese persimmon found in the valley of the Ming Tombs west
of Pekin, by Mr. Frank Meyer, one of the plant explorers of
the Bureau, who has traveled extensively in China, whence
he has sent us some 2,500 new varieties of plants. The Japa-
nese persimmon has also been introduced, and is thriving
at many points in our southern states.
The tung oil tree of the orient, from the seeds of which is
obtained one of the best drying oils known, the importation
of which in 1911 amounted to $3,000,000, has been introduced
into California and the Gulf States, where it appears to bo
thriving; while the pistache tree, a native of central west-
ern Asia, is doing nicely in California, so that in the near
416
Biology in America
future it may not be necessary for us to go to the Asiatics
for flavoring for our pistache ice cream. Yet another find
in China is a cliestnut tree, which is to a consi{leral)le extent
7-esistant to the chestnut bark disease which has been playing
sucli liavoc in our ciiestiuit groves in recent years, and which
may some day replace our vanishing native species.
An Indian Mango Growing in Florida
Coiirtisi/ of the U. ^'. BiD-Kiu of I'laiit Industry.
Into southern Floi-ida, California, Porto Rico, Hawaii,
and the West Indies has come the p]ast Indian mango, a fruit
long held sacred by the people of this teeming land. In
India it is very prolific, some trees bearing between $100
and $200 worth of fruit, even at the low rate for which the
fruit sells in that country.^ The mango is described in Bai-
"$6.(50 a hundred for the best varieties in 1910. At the same time
mangos were selling in Florida for $3.00 a dozen.
Man and Nature
417
ley's "Cyclopwlia of Horticulture" as follows: "In size and
character of fruit the mango is extremely variable ; there are
varieties which are scarcely larger than a plum and there
are others whose fruits weigli as much as four or five pounds.
The shape varies from rountl to long and sU'iidcr, some of tlie
commonest types being reniform, obliquely heart-shaped, oval
or elliptical. The skin is smooth, somewhat thicker than that
of a peach, commonly yellow or greenish-yellow in color, but
in some varieties bright yellow overspread with scarlet or
crimson, and of extremely beautiful appearance. Other types
are uniformly pale lemon-yellow. The aroma is often de-
<J»-.J^i»..v,<V
A Six-Year Old Date Plantation in California
Courtesy of the U. S. linn mi of Plant I niliisl ri/.
licious, spicy and tempting, and this added to the brilliaid
color, makes some of the finer varieties of the mango among
the most attractive of all fruits." ">
The date palm, that Avondeid'ul tree of the oasis in tlie
scorching deserts of Arabia and Africa, is now domesticateil
in Arizona and Southern California and lias taken kindly to
its new home. In the countries of the East the date is a sta-
ple food for the dwellers in the desert, and not a luxury as
it is with us. With some trees bearing more than 100 pounds
of dates an average profit of $100 to $150 per acre is a fair
estimate.
^"Bailey, "Cyclopedia of Horticulture," p. 1986. By pennissiou of
the Macmillan Company.
418
Biology in Amrrica
And so we iiii<:;lit continue ad iuutsc<ii)i, if not ad infinitum,
to rehearse the aehievenieiits of Uncle Sam lu levying tribute
on the flowers and fruits, the grain and timber of all the
\\(H'\d to ])eautify and enrieh liis country, but this brief sketch
A Bunch of Dates
liilKMiiii^i ill the (li'sert reg'.ou of s'juthcrn C.ilifornia.
Courtesy of the LI. H. Burcdii of finnt Jndiistri/.
must suffice as a suggestion merely of the past accomplish-
ments and future possibilities of the economic biologist in
the discoveiy and cultivation of Nature's wealth of plants
throughout the world.
The finds of the plant explorer must be carefully packed
to ensure their safe arrival after a journey halfway around
the world oi- more. Dry seeds such as grains or beans can
be shipped in bags or boxes without any special precau-
tions. Some nuts however which are liable to be parched or
Man and Nature
419
frozen in transit, must be protected by moist material such
as sphagnum moss, whieli seems to have an antiseptic func-
tion, and to protect the plants from infection and decay ; and
packed in strong boxes to protect the young si)routs in case
of germination en route. Entire plants, or cuttings from
them, are covered with the sphagnum and then carefully
packed in bales or boxes for shipment.
Arrived in Washington each package is carefully inspected
by an entomologist and plant pathologist to guard against tlie
importation of insect pests or plant diseases, and if any im-
migrants are found concerning whose health the inspectors
are in doubt, they are kept in quarantine in gardens near
Buffalo on National Blson Range, Montana
One of the few remnants of the once mighty herds wliich lunnorly
roamed the West.
Courtesy 0/ the I'. S. liiinnn 0/ Biuloiiicdl l^urvcy.
Washington until all danger of infection is passed. Those
which pass inspection are entered in the records of the office
which include data giving the source of the plant, its uses,
inspection, consignee, etc., and are then forwarded to tlie
experimental gardens where they are to be propagated, or to
the special experimenters in various parts of the country for
whom they were obtained.
But not alone in foreign lands is the economic biologist
seeking to increase the nation's wealth. JMany are our nat-
ural resources unused as yet, while many anotlier fast dis-
appearing can be restored in part at least to its former abun-
dance, not only by the negative measures of conservation, liut
by the active ones of propagation as well.
420
Biology in America
In the days of the pioneer the United States was teeming
with game. Today the flocks of wild pigeons, the herds of
buffah), elk and anteh)pe are but memories of the past, but
a few wanderers renuiining among the graves of their de-
parted kin. Of the wild pigeon not one wild bird remains
toilay to boar testimony to tlieir departed glory. To save
the others from a like fate the Biological Survey in co-opera-
tion with our National Park Service and the Audubon Soci-
ety has established havens of refuge throughout the country,
where the remaining herds of large game are safe from the
Ei.K IN Winter in Yellowstone National Park
Photo by Haynes, 8t. Paul.
Courtesy of the U. S. 'National Park Service.
depredations of man, and others where our wild fowl may
breed in safety and replenish their fast thinning ranks. The
best known of these is the Yellowstone National Park, where
the bears and elk, due to plentiful food and lack of molesta-
tion, have become almost as tame as domesticated animals.
All of our national parks are ''out of bounds" for the sports-
men, except for the ever increasing number of those who hunt
only with the camera. In addition to the national parks
there are five other big game reservations, all of them in
charge of the Bureau, containing herds of elk, buffalo, ante-
lope, and deer. All but the antelope are apparently thriv-
ing, thanks to adequate prote(!tion and winter feeding, when
Man and Nature
421
the snow lies so deep on the ranges that the animals cannot
forage for theinselves ; and llic hulTalo, which fonncrly ap-
peared to be doomed, liave probably been saved, altliongh
they are today more like domestic cattle, retaining little of
the picturesque cliaracter of their foi-i)cai-s. which ranged in
such magnificence over our wcslein domain, liut the ante-
lope at present appears to be doomed. Even with the most
careful protection the young often fall victims to the wily
An Egret Culuny in 8outh Cakglixa
The aigrette which formerly adorned women's bonnets so e.\timsiv( ly
was obtained from tiiis Vdni, whicli was nearly exterminatcil as a result.
Photograph of a group in tlift American Museum of Natural History in
New York.
Couitisy uj the Miisium.
wolf and coyote, and the destruction which man began, Na-
ture seems determined to finish.
Until comparatively recent times the swamps of our South
Atlantic and Gulf Coast were the home of countless thou-
sands of snowy herons, bearers of the beautiful "aigretti', "
which woman in innocent l)ai'l)arity was at one time pi-oud
to wear. The story of the aigictte ti-ade with all its wanton
cruelty, has been told so often as to need no rejietition here,
but a word nuiy be said regarding its sn|)])i(ssion. .\boli-
422 Biology in America
tion of the feather traffic was one of the primary factors in
the organization of the Audubon Society; and since the in-
ception of the latter it has played a prominent part in the
salvation of the few herons still preserved from their ruth-
less pursuers. Through its activity the Audubon model bird
law has been passed by every state (among many others)
where the egret colonies were found. But this law was
inadequate because, like many another law, it proved in many
places to be but a "scrap of paper." Especially was this
true in the conservative and easy-going South, where public
opinion was not yet alive to the necessity for bird protec-
tion, and so the Society turned its attention to the source
of the trade, namely the millinery interests of our great cit-
ies, and after many a hard fight these interests were defeated,
and laws were passed by many states prohibiting the sale of
wild bird plumage. The Society, with the aid of other or-
ganizations interested in bird life, also secured a provision in
the tariff act of 1913 prohibting the importation of feathers
into the United States, which for a time created much con-
sternation among certain aigrette-bedecked ladies returniiig
to this country from abroad.
The passage of this provision through Congress was only
effected after a bitter fight against the forces of sordid greed.
A fine example of the spirit of its opponents is afforded by
the speech of a man who still figures in our legislature as a
champion of reaction.
"I really honestly want to know why there should be any
sympathy or sentiment about a long-legged, long-beaked, long-
necked bird that lives in swamps, and eats tadpoles and fish
and crawfish :and things of that kind ; why we should worry
ourselves into a frenzy because some lady adorns her hat with
one of its feathers, which appears to be the only use it has."
... If the young are then left to starve, it would seem to me
the proper idea would be to establish a foundling asylum for
the young, but still let humanity utilize this bird for the only
purpose that evidently the Lord made it for, namely, so that
we could get aigrettes for bonnets of our beautiful ladies." "
But not content with mere repression of the feather trade,
the Society has devoted itself to the protection of the herops
on their breeding grounds, establishing and patrolling many
reserves along our coast, where they now live in peace and
are multiplying rapidly.
In guarding these reserves two wardens of the Society have
been shot by plume hunters angered at the interruption of
their illegal trade.
" From remarks of Senator James A. Eeed of Missouri. Cong. Eec,
Vol. 50, p. 3426.
Man and Nature
423
While the Audubon Society has been the foremost agency
in egret protection, it has been aided by the U. S. Biological
Survey, which now has in charge a number of government
reservations, where not only egrets but other sea fowl breed
in large numbers.
Private individuals also early came to the rescue of the
birds and have aided in their protection both by contribu-
tions of money and by protection of the birds' nesting sites.
One of the largest egret heronries existing today is tlie one on
Some Valuable Fur Bearers
A, Mink; B, Arctic fox; C, Silver fox; D, Red fox. From Jones,
' ' Fur Farming in Canadfi. ' '
Commission of Conservation, Canada.
Avery Island, Louisiana, established some twenty years ago
by Mr. John Avery Mcllhenny and Mr. Charles AV. Ward with
a few birds, and where there are now reported to be large
numbers of these l)eautiful creatures.
The furry denizen of the north was the charm wliicli lured
the French adventurer into the depths of the Canadian for-
est, while an early map in which Newfoundland is described
as "the land of the codfish" is evidence of tlie spell wliieii
the wealth of the waters cast about the early mariner. Tu-
Utters in >.atioxal Zouloukal Pakk, Washington
The otter is one of our wild auiraals which is being cultivated for it?
fur.
Mink Eaised on a Fur Farm
Fur farming is being developed cxtonsiveh', especially in Prince
Edward Island, and while still largely in the experimental stage gives
promise of becoming a great and lucrative industry.
Courtesy oj the U. kS. Bureau of Bioloyieal Purvey.
424
Man and Nature 425
day the role of the beaver is being played by his humble
cousin the muskrat, while fox and fislici-, mink and martin
are following' in the l'o(jtsteps of liie bulTah), tlic elk and the
antelope. The codfish still manag'cs to hold his own, hut
many of his congeners are less fortunate.
The rapid dimiinition of our fur-bearing hosts, with the
consequent lise in i)riee of furs, has led to experiments in
breeding these animals for market, which, while scarcely
beyond the experimental stage as yet, give promise of future
success. The prim ijial site of these experiments lias been
Prince Edward Islaiul, where the golden possibilities of fox
farming have so seized upon the imagination of many of the
local farmers, that they have mortgaged their farms to ob-
ta n the necessary capital for undertaking this venture. In
1911 the value of the captive foxes was twice that of all other
live stock on the island. That enormous profits are possible
in successful fox farming is shown by the value of the best
animals for breeding, as high as $25,000 having been i)aid
for a single pair of silver foxes for this purpose. Not alone
foxes, but fisher, martin, mink, skunk and other animals have
been cultivated for their furs, and to aid this industry in
the United States the Biological Survey maintains an experi-
mental fur farm in Essex County, N. Y., where several spe-
cies of fur bearers are being raised.
When those of us who are privileged to pay a surtax on
our incomes and can accordingly indulge our appetites with
such delicacies as blue points on the half-shell, lobster a la
Newburg, or, shades of hpicurus defend us!, diamond-back
terrapin stew, how often do -we think of the part played by
our benevolent Uncle Sam in providing us with such de-
lights'? Were the wealth of Nature used, but not abused by
man, her resources would be never failing. But man is as
stupid as he is greedy and gluttonous, and ofttimes destroys
just for the sake of seeing the smash. Hence Artifice imist
come to the aid of Nature, and learning skill from her may
soon come to outdo her in the production of her own wealth.
Nowhere has the pro])agation of wild aninuils been under-
taken with greater effort or larger success than in the Tnited
States. Our waters, both iidand and marine, form a vast
aquatic farm wherein fish and other aquatic animals are be-
ing reared by the billion every year. Our biggest fish farmer
is Uncle Sam himself, but a nmjority of the states are also
engaged in the busiiu'ss on a more or less extensive scale.
The American Fish Cultural Association was organized in
1870, later becoming the American Fisheries Society, and
several states had already established fish conunissions.
Through the activity of these agencies the Federal Govern-
426 Biology in America
ment was induced to establish the U. S. Fish Commission
in 1871, under the leadership of the late Professor Baird,
whose name occupies so prominent a place among the makers
of American biology. In 1903 the Commission became the
Bureau of Fisheries in the newly organized Department of
Commerce and Labor.
To describe in detail the work of the Bureau since its in-
ception would in itself require a small library. All that can
be done here is to touch briefly on a few of its activities il-
lustrating the achievements of biology in the conservation
and creation of wealth. Fish propagation was not one of
the functions included in the original program of the Com-
mission, but was undertaken by it shortly after its incep-
tion, and has since become its most important service. The
first fishes propagated were the shad, Atlantic salmon and
the whitefish of the Great Lakes. The success of these early
efforts has caused the extension of the practise to most of our
important food and game fishes. In 1921 the number of eggs,
young and adults of some fifty species of fish and the lob-
ster distributed by the Bureau totalled 4,962,489,405. At
least that is the figure given in its annual report. To at-
tempt to estimate to units so inconceivably large a number is
in the nature of the case an absurdity. Five billion in round
numbers would probably be as nearly accurate as the figure
given. We cannot here describe the various methods em-
ployed in propagating these many species. To illustrate the
methods of the Bureau however, we may describe its work
in the propagation of the Pacific salmon.
There are five species of salmon found on our Pacific Coast,
which were described as early as 1768 by the naturalist-ex-
plorer Steller, and a Kussian investigator with the appalling
name of Kraseheninikov. Since the life history of each
differs only in minor details, we may tell the story of all in
giving that of the principal one, which passes under several
aliases, namely, ''king," "quinnat, " "chinook, " "spring,"
"tyee," "Columbia River," "Sacramento," "tchaviche" and
last and worst of all — Onchorhynchus tschawytscha. The
"king" salmon occurs on both coasts of the Pacific from
California and China north to Behriug Straits. The aver-
age weight is twenty-two pounds, but one giant was taken
in Alaska in 1909 weighing 101 pounds minus the head.
During the winter the fish sojourn in the sea, but in early
spring they slowly gather in tlie rivers, especially the large
streams like the Sacramento, Columbia and Yukon, and begin
the k)ng and arduous journey to their breeding grounds,
which in the Yukon may be over 2,000 miles from the sea.
In the ascent of tlie rivers they perforin prodigious feats,
Man and Nature 427
ascending falls 10-15 feet in height. Arrived on the spawn-
ing grounds in autumn the male excavates a little hollow in
the gravel of the stream bed, where the female deposits her
eggs, upon which the male sheds the "milt," after which
they cover them with gravel; and then the function of re-
production performed, which is the crowning act in the life
of either animal or plant, they float downstream to die.
Perhaps nowhere else among animals is there shown a more
striking example of the influence of the sex organs upon
body form and general metabolism than in the male
salmon. In the spring he is a perfectly respectable looking
fish, but as summer advances and his sex glands ripen, the
jaws become greatly distorted, so much so in fact that in
some cases, it becomes impossible for the fish to close them.
Some of the teeth may disappear, while othere grow very
long. The body becomes compressed and assumes a distinct
hump in the back.
The average number of eggs laid by a female salmon is
four thousand. If one-half of these developed into females
and reached maturity in four years, and if their progeny in
turn were all to reach maturity, one-half being females, this
rate of increase remaining constant from generation to gen-
eration, there would result in 32 years 256,000,000,000,000,-
000,000,000,000 salmon weighing 2,816,000,000,000,000,000,-
000,000 tons or 468 times the mass of the earth.
Why is it that such increase is impossible? Let us see
what are some of the dangers which the salmon encounters
in its journey to its spawning grounds far distant from its
ocean home, and what those which await the eggs and fry.
Near the mouth of the salmon stream lurk the trollers seek-
ing to entice them with shining lure. Here too, and in the
broad reaches of the lower river, are the seiners, sweeping
the waters with their nets. Where the river begins to nar-
row so that a definite channel is established, the fish encounter
traps and weirs to stop them in their course; while higher
up, where the river narrows still more, the fish wheel bars
their progress. This is an ingenious device constructed some-
what on the principle of a Ferris wheel. It is placed where
the river is narrow and the current swift, and the river is
usually still further narrowed by means of a net or barri-
cade of some sort to oblige all ascending fish to pass through
the channel where the wheel is placed. Upon its rim are wire
baskets which catch the fish as they try to pass through
the narrow channel, and as the wheel turns empty the fish
into a spillway or sluice which carries them to a po<il where
the fisherman is waiting to receive them. Some of these fish
wheels are movable, being attached to the tail of a scow, if
428
Biology in America
a scow can properly be said to possess such an appendagie,
and can be taken from point to point, at the will of the fish-
erman. And if any luckless fish chance to pass all of these
devices for his destruction, he must yet run the gauntlet of
the Indian waiting with his s})ear upon some platform in
the i"iver, or foUowing his finny prey in swift canoe.
i)Ut the wih's of man are not the only danger which the
salmon must overcome in his struggle for existence. There
is the danger of the fungus which takes such a heavy toll of
the eggs, and there is many a lurking enemy of the finny
Seining Spawning Salmon for an Alaskan Hatchery
CourtvHij of the U. 8. Bureau of Finheries.
tribe to whom a meal of young salmon or of salmon spawn
does not come amiss. INIany an enemy too is there in feathers
and ill fur, waiting by the salmon streams for their share of
the fishing, among which are the gulls and bears, while the
seal is not averse to a meal of salmon ; and many a smaller
member of tlie furry tribe skulks by the streams to prey upon
the harried fish.
From the data of the canning industry between 1866 and
1915, published in a recent report of the Bureau of Fisheries,
there appears to have been no material decrease in the number
of cans of salmon packed on the Pacific Coast during that
period. Indeed there has been on the contrary a consistent
Man and Nature
429
increase, due probably to increased facilitiL's for taking and
preserving the catch.
The survival of the salmon in the face of so great difficulties
is undoubtedly duo in large measure to the extensive propa-
gation carried on maiidy by the government, but also by state
and private concerns.
From California to Alaska the l>ui-eau of Fisheries main-
tains salmon luiteliei'ies, -which annually distribute in our
waters some 2(H ),()(>( ),()()() eggs, fry ami older lish. Since tl)e
start of propagation work in 1872 to the end of 1921 a total
of about 4, ()()(), ()()().()()() salmon eggs have been hatched aiul
"planted'' in Pacific waters, besid(>s those which have been
sent to the Atlantic Coast and to foreign countries. The
hatcheries are located on some salmon stream, where there
Tray of Salmon Eggs
Courlcsy of the U. S. liitrcftit of Finlicrirs.
is an abundant supply of good water and plenty of fish from
which to strip the eggs. The fish are caught on their way
to the spawning grounds, either by seining them from the
river, or in a trap, and if not "ripe'" (i. e. ready to siied their
sperm and eggs) they are i-etained in a pound or enclosure
until the proper time. In obtaining the eggs two methods are
employed, either the living fish is "stripped" of her eggs,
or she is killed, opened and the eggs removed. The latter
method causes no loss of fish as might appear at first sight,
since the fish die after spawning in any case; and is more
efficient than the former, since all of the eggs are obtained,
which is not the case in "stripping." In "stripping" the
female, she is held in the hand or placed in a si)ecial frame
for this purpose, while the "stripper" runs his thumb down
her belly and squeezes out the eggs into a pail. The sperm
or "milt" of the male is obtained in the same way. After
430
Biology in America
the eggs and sperm liave been taken they are mixed together
either in their natural condition or in a little water. The
eggs are then allowed to harden for an hour or so before
they are transferred to the hatching troughs. In tliis mixing
of eggs and sperm fertilization occurs, while the hardening
process renders them tougher and less liable to injury than
if they were transferred to the troughs directly after fer-
tilization. These latter are long shallow troughs divided
into compartments about two feet long, a foot wide and six
inches deep. In each compartment is a wire basket in which
Interior of a Salmon Hatchery
Courtesy of the U. S. Bureau of Fisheries,
are placed about 30,000 eggs. Any eggs which become
fungussed or otherwise diseased are removed daily to pre-
vent communicating the infection to other eggs.
At first the young fish is a sack filled with yolk. Soon
the body appears as a narrow band extending a third or
half way around the sack. This little band represents mainly
the brain and spinal cord, back-bone and muscles of the future
fish. Soon the brain begins to enlarge and the eyes appear
as two black spots on either side, and the little fish is now
all head and eyes. Meantime the body is being lifted up and
constricted off from the yolk sack, which becomes covered
with a network of delicate blood vessels, connected with the
heart which bulges out beneath the head, for the young fish
Man and Nature
431
may be truly said to liavc "its hoart in its tlirnat." The
tail meanwhile is forming and liead and tail Ix'nd toward^
each other until they almost touch, while Die yolk sack appears*
like a great tumor upon the belly of the young fish, which
soon begins to try its muscles in sjiasmodic jerks and
twists. Prior to hatching the little cMuhryo is surrounded
by the delicate and highly extensible membrane which sur-
rounded the egg. At time of hatching this membrane is
broken, the food stored in the yolk sack is soon absorbed,
and the young fish begins to "rustle for a living." At this
stage the fry may be set free in the river, or if suitable ponds
are available, they may best be kept at home and fed on
chopped liver, meat, milk curds, etc., for several months until
they are better able to take care of themselves. For the whole
Developing Fish
Showing yolk sack. From Kunz & Eadcliffe, Bulletin of the U. S.
Bureau of Fisheries, Vol. 35,
principle of fish culture is that a greater per cent of egg^ will
be fertilized artificially than in nature, and a larger number
of them will develop safely in the care of the hatchery than
if exposed to their hosts of natural enemies.
While the seal and whale are not fishes, the Bureau of
Fisheries, on the basis of the old scriptural classification of
"beasts that swim," has included them and all other creatures
aquatic in the field of its activity. The fur seal industry is
but one among many examples of the influence of natural
wealth upon human history. The fur seals of the Pacific are
grouped in two main herds, those of the Pribilof, and those
of the Commander Islands. The former are part of Alaska
and the latter of Siberia. The former herd was discovered in
1786 by the Russian navigator Pribilof, whose name is borne
by the islands of his discovery, and the latter in 1741 by the
naturalist Steller who accompanied the ill-fated Beh)-ing on
his second and final voyage in 1741. A few years ago the
seals were threatened with extinction, the Pribilof herd having
suffered reduction from its original number of four or five
432 Biology in America
million animals to about four luuulred thousand. The early
abortive efTorts at protection of the seals are but one of many
striking; illustrations of the folly of so-called "practical"
economists and amateur le<]^islatoi-s to control natural wealth
without any adequate knowledge of the methods of its pro-
duction.
The fur seal leads a roving and picturesque existence. As
a pup he gains ac(iuaintance with Nature in a wild and savage
mood. Ilis puppyhood is spent amid the rocks and breakers
of the bleak and barren islands of the north Pacific. When
a few months old he makes a long sea journey with his mother
to the south and spends his first winter fishing off the
California Coast. Early each summer he returns as a young
"bachelor" to the ancestral home, where he lives with fellow
"bachelors," while the old seals are rearing a new lot of
puppies. When five or six years old the mating instinct
gi'ows strong within him and on his arrival at the breeding
grounds he selects for himself a little patch of rocks in which
he establishes a "harem," which may number from thirty
to one hundred females, depending on his success in "round-
ing up" the "cows." During this time, like a jealous lover,
he stands guard over his "harem," engaging ofttimes in
combats to the death with intruding "bulls," not leaving his
stand for about two months, even to feed, and becoming
greatly emaciated during the summer as a result of his long
fast. Soon after the arrival of the females the young (usually
but one) are born, shortly after which mating occurs, gesta-
tion lasting a year. During the nursing season the mother
seals frequently leave their puppies and make long journeys
to sea in search of food, and it is at this time that the destruc-
tive effects of pelagic sealing are most apparent.
Sealing privileges in Behring Sea have long been a bone of
bitter contention between Americans, Russians, Canadians
and more recently the Japanese. The Pribilof Islands, the
principal sealing grounds, originally belonged to Russia, the
sealing rights on the islands, being a perquisite of the govern-
ment. With the sale of Alaska to the United States in 1867,
these rights passed to our government, and for forty years
were leased by it, as had been previously done by Russia,
to private concerns. For this lease the government received
$50,000 annually besides a royalty of $2 a head, and it is
an interesting commentary on the foresight of the opponents
of the Alaska purchase proposition, that from 1870 to 1890
our government received in leases, royalties and duties on
furs made up in London, but most of which came originally
from Alaska, some $13,000,000, or nearly double the price
paid for the entire territory.
Man and Nature
433
Sealing on tlie islands is restricted to tlie "Ijachelor" herd,
the number taken each year being determined by the go
ment. The seals are rounded up and driven by a nu
of native drivers to the killing pens whei'e they are slangli
by a blow on the head with a club. Tiie skins are
removed and packed in salt for shipment to market.
Despite the restrictions on the killing of the seals,, the
rapidly diminished to about one-tentli of its original
It was simply a repetition of "watcliing the spigot"
the "bung-hole" was allowed to take care of itself.
vern-
mber
lere<l
then
herd
size.
while
The
A Seal Rookery on the Pribilof Islands, Alaska
Courtesy o/ the U. 8. Bureau of FishcHes.
seals may be ever so well protected on their breeding grounds;
but if allowed to take care of themselves elsewhere they are
doomed to destruction.
Realizing the threatened extinction of the herd by pelagic <
sealing^ our government decided to avail itself of a right
claimed by Russia in 1821, but never tested, of seizing all
vessels engaged in pelagic sealing in Alaskan Avaters, whether
within the three-mile limit or not. This immediately brought
on a controversy with Great Britain, whose Canadian subjects
were the ones chiefly affected. The result of this controversy
was arbitration before the well-known Behring Sea Tribunal,
which sitting in Paris in 1895 decided adversely to the United
434 Biology 'in America
States, and then proeeeded to fornmlate regulations, govern-
ing both parties to the controversy, and designed to furnish
adequate future protection to the seals. But, like most third
parties to any controversy, the seals were inevitably the
sufiferers. The regulations prohibited pelagic sealing witliin
sixty miles of the breeding grounds, but since the female
seals wander far outside this limit, their destruction con-
tinued as before. Now the death of one female during the
summer means the destruction of three seals — the mother,
her unborn young (for most females are gravid at this time)
and the young of the year, left to starve in its rocky home
on the breeding grounds. The matter was finally adjusted
by Eussia and the United States, the owners of the rookeries,
granting to the Canadians and the Japanese, who had entered
the field in 1903, fifteen per cent each of the profit from land
sealing, in consideration of their abandoning pelagic sealing
altogether. As an additional protection the United States
declared a closed season on the Pribilofs from 1912 to 1917,
at which time the herd had shown some increase, numbering
over 450,000 individuals. Sealing was resumed in the latter
year and is being prosecuted at present under the direction
of the Bureau of Fisheries.
In respect to the whaling industry, which formerly played
so large a part in our maritime industries, the Bureau has
done little more than publish annual statistics and some data
relative to the utilization of whale products. In the nature
of the case propagation of these animals is impossible and
the most that could be done is the imposition of a closed
season, which would be exceedingly difficult owing to the
cosmopolitan character of the whale. Only through inter-
national agreement could this be effected, and hitherto, so
far as the writer is aware, no steps have been taken in this
direction.
The use of whales thus far has been limited mainly to the
skin, oil, "whalebone," ambergris, bone meal, tallow, glue,
etc. The use of the meat has been restricted largely to
"pemmican" for the Esquimaux and arctic explorer, although
the Japanese have used it as food for some time, and_ it is
now finding a place on the tables of Europeans and Americans.
One of the recent activities of the Bureau has been, as one
wag expresses it, to "knock H. out of the High Cost of
Living. " In so doing it is finding new food supplies among
our aquatic animals and educating a highly prejudiced and
fastidious public regarding their use. "What's in a name!'\
If offered "dogfish" we are highly incensed at the indignity,
but "canned grayfish" sounds, and therefore tastes, much
better. Just as Milady takes greater pride in a beautiful set
Man and Nature
435
of "black marten" than in the same set of skunk fur. In
a recent pamphlet issued by the Bureau we find tliirty-two
recipes for the preparation of whale meat, some by so liij,'h
an authority as Delmonico himself. In anotlier we are given
seventeen methods of preparing "grayfish" alias "dogfish"
or shark, while still others tell us of the gastronomic pcjssi-
bilities of "goosefish," "bow-fin," and other hitherto neg-
lected possibilities of human aliment.
"Acres of diamonds" are indeed on every hand. It is
not many years since dwellers along the Mississippi and its
tributaries were accustomed to cast aside as "worthless" the
mussel shells which they found on the banks of the streams.
But in 189-4 two button makers from near Hamburg visited
A Glochidium
The larva of a fresli water mussel. By nieans of tlie valves of its
shell it attaches itself to the gills or fins of a fish and grows there as a
]/arasite until it reaches the adult form. After Lefevre and Curtis in
"Journal of Experimeivtal Zoology," Vol. 9.
the Mississippi and today more than $3,000,000 are invested
in establishments for the manufacture of buttons from
mussel shells, with an annual output of over $5,000,000 and
employing about 8,000 people in 1918. But in this case,
as in so many others, the greed of man soon bade fair to
ruin a promising industry. So closely were the river bottoms
raked for shells, that in a few yeai-s there were not enough
mussels left to keep up the supply, and the end, or at least
serious curtailment of the industry appeared probable in
the near future. But now enters Uncle Sam upon the scene,
calling upon biology to aid him in finding a remedy, l^o
prescribe a remedy the physician must fii*st be able to diag-
nose, his case. And so the first thing which the biologists
did was lo study the life history of the nnissels in order
to. learn how Nature herself maintained the supply.
After fertilization the eggs are lodged in special chambers
436 Biology in America
in the gills of the mussel which hang in sheets between either
valve of the shell, and the internal organs. Here they grow
until they attain what is known as the glochidium stage,
when the young mussel possesses a shell of its own, with
paired valves. They are now set free in the water, and
slionld they be so fortunate as to come in contact with cer-
tain speeies of fish, chiefly those of the sunfish family,
they attach themselves to the gills or tins by means of
their valves and force the fish to become their foster
parents. The food of the young mussel at this stage is
obtained from the tissues of the fish whi.-h acts as foster
parent, in which they become embedded', living as parasites
upon the latter. After ten to forty ^~ days of this indolent
existence, during which time the glochidium is metamorphosed
into a mussel, it drops to the bottom of the river or pond
and burrowing into the mud or sand, proceeds thereafter
to find a living for itself. This it does by means of a tube
or siphon, which it thrusts up to the surface of the river bed,
from the bottom of its burrow, and through which there
circulates a stream of water carrying in oxygen, and food
in the form of minute plants and animals or finely divided
bits of organic matter of any sort, and carrying out carbon
dioxide and other wastes.
The task for the mussel culturist then is to secure the
glochidia from the gravid mussels ^nd find foster parents
for them. This is done by placing the young glochidia
obtained from the mussels in tanks containing the proper
number of fish of the right species to carry successfully the
number of glochidia provided. The extent of infection by
glochidia which any given fish can stand is a matter of
importance, for if loaded too lightly, there is a waste of time
and effort in securing more fish than necessary, while if
loaded too heavily the fish may not survive the strain put
upon it, and both fish and glochidia are lost. The optimum
number of glochidia varies for different species of fish. A
young bass or sunfish, three to four inches long, will carry
successfully as many as 1,000, a number which will kill many
other species.
Our knowledge of the life history of the mussels is largely
the result of the investigations of Curtis and Lefevre at the
University of Missouri. Their studies have been continued
and amplified at the Bureau of Fisheries station at Fairport,
Iowa, where the practical propagation of mussels has been
conducted for several years. In 1918 fish carrying more
than 200,000,000 glochidia were set free, but no definite facts
of mussel increase as a result of the work are yet available.
" In one case a period of six months has been recorded.
Man and Nature
437
While the primary function of this station is mussel propa-
gation, it interests itself also in saving the multitude of tish
found in the overflow waters of the INlississippi bottoms, and
to which reference has already been made.
Living a humble life in the salt marshes of our Atlantic
and Gulf Coast is the delight of the epicure — the diamond-
back terrapin. So precious is this creature in the eyes of
some persons of elegant and expensive tastes that the best
grade of Chesapeake terrapins were bringing about $70
per dozen in 1917. Here surely was an opportunity for
the economic biologist. The Bureau promptly rose to the
The Diamond-kack Tkkrapix, ax Expensive TluiiiT
Piwto by R. ir. Shujeldt.
emergency and in 1902 established a station at Beaufort,
N. C, for the study of various economic and scientific i)r()b-
lems relative to the flsheries of the region, and more esi)ecially
those concerning the propagation of the terrapin. In the
pens connected with the station are more than two thousand
terrapin including some ten generations, wliich have been
raised in captivity. Man}- of these are now large enough
for market, and some have in their turn produced young.
The experiments, the details of which cannot be given here,
demonstrate the possibility of terrapin farming on a com-^
mercial scale, and establishing in this nuinner a lucrative
industry. A terrapin farm on a commercial basis has been
conducted for many years near Savannah, Georgia, by Mr.
A. M. Barbee, where terrapin are raised for market by tlie
thousand, so that terrapin fanning may now be fairly said
to have passed the experimental stage.
438 Biology in America
But not alone in commerce has biology played its part.
It has entered tlie courts of justice and aided in disentangling
the knotty problems of the law.
In murder trials the guilt or innocence of the accused
may hinge upon the kind of blood in a stain upon his clothes,
whether human or not. Until recently there was no certain
test. But through the discovery of the blood test, made
chiefly by the English physiologist Nuttall, we now know
how to determine this. For if human blood be injected into
a rabbit, there develops in the blood of the latter an "anti-
body" which produces a white precipitate with human blood.
All that is necessary then, in diagnosing a blood stain, is to
soak the piece ^f clothing in salt solution and mix a little of
the latter with the "anti-human serum" from the rabbit,
a resultant white precipitate indicating the presence of human
blood. An interesting corollary of this discovery is the fact
that "anti-human serum" will produce a precipitate, though
not so marked, with an ape's blood, and that the amount of
precipitate formed decreases progressively the less close the
relationship between man and the animal tested.
Not many years since the U. S. Department of Justice
found itself in a muddle over the status of certain lands in
the Mississippi "bottoms" in eastern Arkansas. These lands
were covered by timber of great value and were furthermore
very valuable for agriculture after the timber was removed.
Now it so happened that certain lumber "barons" having
exhausted the supply on neighboring lands began casting
covetous eyes upon the rich "bottoms." In 18-17 when the
original survey of this district was made the land in question
was entered on the maps as "permanent lake." So the
barons decided to gain possession, not by purchase of the
lands, but by purchase of "riparian rights" along the old
' ' lake ' ' shore, which according to the law would entitle them
to possession of the "lake" bottom, when the latter receded
or dried up. But Uncle Sam threw a clog into their nicely
oiled machine by bringing suit against them on the grounds
that the survey was wrong and that lakes had existed there
in the imagination of the surveyors rather than upon the lands
themselves. Then the Department of Justice turned to the
biologist for assistance and asked Professor Cowles of the
University of Chicago to appear as an expert witness.
There were many lines of evidence which Professor Cowles
found, all closely related and corroborative one of the other.
These 'were in part botanical and in part physiographic. He
found for example that at the time when these supposed lakes
existed there was an upland forest standing there of great
age. The lumber interests tried to show that many trees
Man and Nature 439
such as the cypress and tupelo gum may grow in standing
water, but Professor Cowles countered by siiowing that even
these hydrophytie or water-loving types are killed by too
deep or too long submergence, and that further the timber
occupying the disputed ground was composed of oaks,
hickories, cottonwoods and other upland types, rather than
by the swamp dwellers of the forest. Physiographic evidence
likewise supported the story of the trees. The disappearance
of a lake is due to one of three causes, evaporation, draining
and filling. The rainfall of the lower Mississippi Valley is
too great to admit of the first explanation, and the cliai-ai-ter
of the land is such as to preclude the second, leaving the last
as the only one of the three explanations possible. Hut in
these bottoms there lie the unburied trunks of trees over-
thrown in a great earthquake of a century ago. Had they
fallen in lakes, which were subsequently filled in by debris,
they must surely have been covered during the disappearance
of these lakes.
Other evidence there was, the details of which need not
be elaborated here, but to make a long story short the judge
of the district court at Little Rock, gave a verdict against
the lumber companies in spite of the fact that some of tiie
"oldest inhabitants" testified at the trial to having actually
seen the lakes in question. In the words of Professor Cowles
— ' ' It is safer to believe a tree than a man. ' '
Why were the "lakes" originally recorded on the survey?
The old surveyors received so much per mile for their sur-
veys, and "per" meant more for their purse when lake
shores were surveyed because of the greater difficulties in-
volved in such surveying. Hence many of the old maps
are probably more or less "scraps of paper" and not repre-
sentations of fact.
In the preceding pages we have hastily sketched a few of
the achievements and opportunities of economic biology in
America. Much has of necessity been passed by, but enough
has been given to illustrate the indispensable place wiiich
biology has in our economic structure.
CHAPTER XVI
Biology and Dudicine. Microscopic life and- its rclat'on to
human health. The role of animals in spreadi^ig disease.
Animal experimentation and its contributions to human
welfare. The new medicine, safeguarding the health of
the nation.
Nowhere has the service of biology to man been so con-
spicuous as in the field of preventive medicine and public
sanitation. While the entire field ' of medicine is strictly
speaking a biological one, yet the study of the human mech-
anism in health and disease holds a special place in science,
peculiar to itself, and it is only in so far as our knowledge
of plants and lower animals contributes to human health that
we shall consider meilicine, or more properly speaking,
sanitation, a province of biology.
In days gone by the doctor's chief duty was to heal the
sick; today his main function is to keep men well. The
greatest medical progress of all time has been in the pre-
vention of disease. It is ^the knowledge of microscopic life
that has rendered this progress possible, a knowledge for
which the world is indebted to biology.
In bacteriology no American ranks with Pasteur, Koch or
Jenner. Yet America has not lacked men noted in bacteri-
ological science, and in its practical application she ranks
second to none. Nowhere in all the fields of human endeavor
has a greater contribution to human welfare been made than
in the discovery of the world of unseen things about, and
within us, the bacteria and the Protozoa, and the recognition
of the part they play in causing human disease. This dis-
covery has revolutionized medical practice, created the new
science of sanitation, reclaimed vast areas formerly uninhab-
itable by the white race, virtually wiped out of existence
some of the worst scourges of mankind and saved countless
human beings from death and misery. This debt we owe
to biology. The story of this revolution would in itself fill
volumes, and is in its general outline so widely known that
its repetition here would be prosaic. And yet of common
knowledge how little there is that each of us can call his
440
Biology and Medicine 441
own! We are so accustomed to things as they are, that only
the historian thinks of things as they have been, while tlie
constructive prophet is as rare among us as the proverbial
hen's teeth. How often do we go back in memory to the
days of the market basket, when the telephone was not at
hand to bring our dinners to our doors, or the coal oil lamp,
and the gas lamp post; while the days of the horse car and
horse carriage, will soon be classified as the "age of horses,"
not clearly distinguishable in our minds from the "age of
reptiles," "Amphibia" or "fishes." It may not then be
amiss to contrast for a moment some pictures of the past
and present in medicine and public health.
At the time of the great smallpox epidemic in 1752 Boston
had a population of 15,684, of whom 5,998 had had the disease,
leaving 9,686 persons who were susceptible to it. Of these
7,669 contracted the disease, 5,545 by contact and 2,124 by
inoculation (in order to produce a mild type of the disease
and escape its danger) and 1,843 persons left the city, leav-
ing but 174 who, without the immunity furnished by
a previous attack, faced the disease, but were not stricken.
The history of smallpox in the cities of Europe in pre-
vaccination days is one long' record of despair and death.
In America the disease introduced by the early explorers
swept like wild-fire among the natives who proved pecu-
liarly susceptible to it, carrying away, according to early
historians, whole tribes, and reducing others to mere rem-
nants of their former selves. One of these writers (Catlin)
gives it as his opinion that at least one-half of the Indians
of North America were taken by smallpox. Quoting from
Parker he says of the Indians below the Falls of the Columbia
that at least seven-eighths, if not nine-tenths, were destroyed
by smallpox between 1829 and 1836. Prior to the advent
of the United States in the Philippines there were more
than 6,000 deaths in seven provinces annually from small-
pox.
Turning now to the other side of the picture we find a
conspicuous decrease in snudlpox after the introduction of
vaccination, while in countries where vaccinafion is com-
pulsory, the disease scarcely exists. In 1905 and 1906,
3,094,635 vaccinations were performed by the II. S. Bureau
of Health in the Philippine Islands. In the report of the
director (Doctor Victor (i. lleiser) of 1907, he says: "In the
provinces of Cavite, Batangas, Cebu, Bataan, La Union. Kizal
and La Laguna, where heretofore there have been more llum
6,000 deaths annually from smallpox, it is satisfactory to
report, since the completion of vaccination in the afore-
442 Biology in America
mentioned provinces more than a year ago, not a single death
from smallpox has been reported."^
From 1901 to 190-4 smallpox was epidemic in Philadelphia.
During that time the Municipal Hospital received 3,500 cases,
about 80% of all eases in a city with a population of 1,293,000
and of these not one had been recently successfully vaccinated.
Compare this record with that of Boston in the epidemic of
1752. In this same hospital "during a period of thirty-
four years, in which time almost 10,000 cases of small-
pox were treated, there was no instance of a physician,
nurse or attendant, who had been successfully vaccinated
or revaccinated prior to going on dntv contracting the dis-
ease. "^
The earlier method of protection against smallpox by inocu-
lation from a person who already had the disease met with
strenuous opposition in many quarters. During an outbreak
of smallpox in Boston in 1821-3 this practise, which was
advocated by Cotton Mather 6nd others, aroused such intense
feeling that an attempt was made to assassinate the worthy
divine by the time-honored method of throwing a bomb into
his house, which fortunately however failed to explode. It
was accompanied by a message couched in these affectionate
terms: "Cotton IMather, yon dog. Damn you: I'll inoculate
you with this, with a Pox to you."
When Jenner introduced his method of vaccination with
eowpox, it was supposed by the ignorant that i-hildren when
vaccinated "developed horns, hoofs and tails and bellowed
like cattle."
Such primitive prejudices may be pardoned, but what
shall we say of those who, in supposedly educated and civilized
connnunities, oppose a remedy which has done so much in
the relief of human misery and the prevention of death.
In a recent examination given by the writer to a class in
elementary hygiene, one of the questions was "State the
most important information gained by you in this course."
In reply to which he was surprised to receive from several
students answers which summarized ran about as follows:
"The most important information I gained in the coui-se
was that regarding vaccination and similar remedies. I had
always been rather afraid of, or at least skeptical about it,
but now that I have learned its results, and the care taken
in its use, I believe in it, and have no further fear of it. ' '
A mysterious remedy such as vaccination might be expected
to frighten or repel the primitive and the uneducated. An
^Schamberg, "Vaccination and Its Kelation to Animal Experimenta-
tion," Defense of Research Pamphlet, 1, p. 34.
^ Locus citatus, pp. 35-9.
liiology and Medicine 443
amusing instance of tliis is cited by Bennett in liis "History
of the Panama Canal": "When it was announced that they
had to be vaccinated, one of their number, a voodoo doctor,
led a mutiny against inoculation, in which a hundred and
fifty took part. He pronounced it an attempt to put 'the
inextinguishable mark' upon them, so that they could never
escape from the isthmus. They declared they would rather
suffer martyrdom abroad than to be held captive ashore, and
it was only after three days of unsuccessful parleying that
the mutiny was broken up by their being driven ashore by
the police. Still protesting they were rounded up, in spite
of their efforts to escape, vaccinated, and the next day sent
to work. " ^
And yet more astonishing is the fact that much of the
organized opposition to vaccination should emanate from a
city which prides itself upon being the intellectual center
of America. Surely extremes have met, when so-called
"Science" and Voodooism walk hand in hand.
Prior to the days of Lister, the great surgeon of Glasgow
and Edinburgh, the discoverer of antisepsis and the creator
of modern surgery, the work of the surgeon was a continual
nightmare.
The condition of a patient after operation was often too
horrible for description. Erysipelas, lockjaw, blood poison
and gangrene were frequent consequences, but since the com-
ing of antiseptic surgery such conditions have been unknown.
There is nothing wonderful or difficult about the modern
antiseptic treatment of wounds and operations, nothing but
the painstaking observation of scrupulous cleanliness and the
careful sterilization -of the wound or skin itself and of every-
thing coming in contact with it, but today, blood-poisoning,
tetanus or gangrene following an operation are virtually
unknown.
In the pre-antiseptic period the surgeon dared not operate
upon the brain, or upon the internal organs except as a
desperate "last hope," for death was almost sure to follow..
Today abdominal operations are an everyday occurrence and
brain surgery is a common practise. In the olden days
ovarian tumors in women were left until death appeared
inevitable if the knife were not used, and the most famous
surgeon in America lost two out of eveiy three of sucli cases,
while today tumors, weighing in some cases twice as much
as the patients themselves, are removed, and the death rate
instead of being over sixty is about one per cent.
Prior to the days of antiseptic surgery the Caesarean opera-
' Bennett, ' ' History of the Panama Canal, ' ' p. 124. Historical Pub-
lishing Company.
444 Biology in A7ncrica
tion, or opening of tlie abdomen of the mother to i-cinove the
child, was so fatal tliat even as late as 1887 Harris, an Amer-
ican physician, stated that the operation could be performed
more successfully by a mad bull than by the best surjijeon in
the best hospital in America, supporting his statement, with
evidence from nine cases in which the abdomen of pregnant
women had b(>en gored by bulls, in five of which the victim
recovered, whereas in the eleven Cii'sarean operations pre-
viously performed in New York there were but two recoveries.
Today, on tlie contrary, Caesarean operations are relatively
common, and the mortality has been reduced to about two
per cent.
In the days before the practice of antiseptic methods,
every woman who entered a maternity hospital truly went
down into "the valley of the shadow of death." Conditions
in the lying-in hospitals of Europe were horrible in the ex-
treme, while in America we were but little better off. For
thirty years prior to 1833 in the Pennsylvania Hospital in
Philadelphia fifty-six mothers in everj' thousand were victims
of puerperal or 'child-bed fever, while in the Bellevue Hos-
pital in New York in 1872 nine out of every fifty mothers
succumbed to the disease, and similar conditions prevailed
elsewhere. It M^as this awful fatality which called forth
Dr. Oliver Wendell Holmes' famous paper on the "Conta-
giousness of Puerperal Fever." "With the coming of antiseptic
methods the mortality from this scourge of women has been
reduced in good hospitals to less than one-fourth of one per
cent, wheieas formerly it ranged from two to twenty per cent,
or even more.
But it was not alone the mother who suffered from this
dread scourge. The child likewise was its victim, with almost
invariably fatal results. Tetanus or lockjaw also levied its
toll upon the new-born babes. Today in properly conducted
hospitals puerperal fever in infants is almost never seen,
while Professor AVilliams of Johns Hopkins says that he has
never seen a case of tetanus in more than 10,000 new-born
infants under his care.
One of the most wide-spread, insidious, and appalling dis-
eases common to man is syphilis, the so-called "red plague."
Exact data regarding its prevalence in the United States
are lacking, but the best available estimates place the figures
at from 2% to 20%. If we accept 5% as a fair average,
this means that over 250,000 in New York City are victims
of the disease.
Two and twenty-three hundredths per cent of the recruits
drafted into our national army in 1917 were found on
examination to be infected with gonorrhea, while of 1,300,000
Biology and Medicine 445
(in round numbers) iiu'ii inducted into all branches of the
army that year 71,955 men or five and a half per cent were
found to have venereal disease of some sort, most of which
was brougrht with them on their entrance into camp. After
eidistment the rate niat<'rially decreased, due to the vij^onms
methods adopted by the army, both for repressing vice about
the army camps, and for educating the men and otherwise
guarding them against this evil. Perhaps the worst fea-
ture of syphilis from the standpoint of its prevention is the
difificulty of recognizing it in its latent form. Its trans-
missibility from husband to wife and vice versa and from
parent to child is well known. But the disease is curable
and marriage of a former syphilitic is permissible when such
cure is definitely established. The difificulty is to determine
when such cure has been established. An individual with
no apparent symptoms of the disease may yel be infected
and capable of infecting consort and children. Here too has
lain the chief medical difficulty in the control of prostitution.
Another very serious feature of the disease is the difficulty
of recognizing it in its incipient stages. The earliest symptom
of the disease is the chancre or sore, which appears usually
about three weeks after exposure, and then often cannot be
diagnosed with certainty. If treated immediately upon its
appearance it disappears, a positive diagnosis cannot be made,
and treatment will probably be relaxed or abandoned alto-
gether, leaving the disease latent in the body, to break out
anew at some future time. On the other hand, if treatment
is delayed until a positive diagnosis is established valuable
time is lost, and the disease may obtain so firm a hold upon
the system that its eradication becomes extremely difficult if
not impossible. Biology has largely solved these difficulties
by providing means of diagnosis, even in the absence of all
external symptoms.
If a small amount of sheep's blood be injected into the
body of a rabbit there develops in the blood of the latter the
power to break down the red corpuscles of the sheep, liberat-
ing the coloring matter or luemoglohin wliidi they contain. In
this rabbit's blood are two chemical substances, one of which
destroys the sheep's corpuscles in the presence of the second
substance, the three forming a chain (according to modern
bacteriological theory) a-b-c, a being the sheep's corpuscles,
b, the go-between substance or ''amboceptor," and c, the
destructive substance, or "complement." The latter is prol)-
ably present normally in the blood of any higher animal,
it is the former or "amboceptor" which is formed by the
injection of the sheep's blood into the rabbit. This rabbit's
blood is now heated to 133° F. in order to destroy its "com-
446 Biology in America
plement." If the liver of an unborn or newly born eliild
infected with sypliilis (such bodies may frequently be obtained
from autopsies) be extracted with alcohol a substance
"antigen" is obtained which has been secreted by the germ
of the disease, the Trepoiu'ma pallidum. This substance we
may designate as a'.'''*^ It likewise forms a chaiii with comple-
ment c in the presence of amboceptor b, which we may repre-
sent as a'-b-c. In the language of the bacteriologist it
"fixes" or "anchors" the complement. Tlie blood serum of
the person suspected of an infection with syphilis is also
heated to 133° F. to destroy its "complement." The "anti-
gen" is now mixed with the blood serum of the suspect and
a definite amount of guinea pig serum containing free
"complement," which has not been heated, is added and
the whole placed in an incubator or oven for an hour and
a half. If the suspect is syphilitic, his blood will contain
the amboceptor b, which has been developed there through
the presence of the germs of the disease. In this case the
antigen a' will combine with the complement c of the guinea
pig, through the medium of the amboceptor b, present in the
suspect's blood. If, on the contrary, the suspect is free
from infection no amboceptor Avill be present and the antigen
will not be able to fix the complement in the guinea pig's
serum. A definite amount of the rabbit's blood mixed with
the sheep's blood is now added and in the former case
(presence of syphilis) no reaction will occur, the complement
being fixed. In the latter case however (syphilis absent)
the complement will be free to combine with the amboceptor
in the rabbit's blood, the first reaction (a-b-c) will occur and
the red corpuscles of the sheep will be broken down with
liberation of their hemoglobin.
This test, known from its discoverer as the Wassermann
test, is not absolutely certain, but it is efficient in probably
90% of the tests made. If it is repeated at intervals for
two years after the disappearance of all active symptoms,
and a negative result obtained each time, the patient may
with reasonable certainty be considered cured.
There has recently died in Germany a man whose name
is destined to be ever bright in the annals of science. Paul
Ehrlich, famed for his researches on cancer and immunity,
the latter based upon his theory of the chemical affinities of
living cells, was the discoverer of a specific remedy for syphilis
— salvarsan or "606", successful after 605 substances had
been tried and failed! This remedy, a compound of arsenic,
is now widely used in the treatment of the "red plague."
^ This was the original niethod. It is now known that "antigen" a
is non-siiecific. Hence extracts of various normal organs may be em-
ployed.
Biology and Medicine 447
One of the most fatal diseases in days gone by was menin-
gitis, caused by the bacterium Diplococcus intracellularis,
which develops in the meninges or membranes surrounding
the brain and spinal cord, setting up an inflammation result-
ing in death, or, if the victim is spared, often leaving paraly-
sis, imbecility or some other dread condition in its wake.
With the discovery of the causative organism some thirty
years ago, biology set itself to find a remedy.
It is a well-known fact that both among men and lower
animals there are many instances of natural immunity and
susceptibility to disease. The native cattle of Austria-
Hungary and Japan are relatively immune to tuberculosis,
while other breeds are very susceptible. The Algerian sheep
are comparatively immune to anthrax, to which all other
sheep are extremely susceptible. Field mice are immune to
glanders, while the house mouse is susceptible. The negro
is more resistant to yellow fever and susceptible to tubercu-
losis than the white race. Malaysians are very susceptible to
beriberi, while other races are much less so.
"While some immunity to disease is thus "natural" or in-
born, other immunity may be "acquired." After recovery
from typhoid fever the subject is unlikely to have a recur-
rence of the disease for several years. The victim who has
successfully withstood an attack of smallpox is thereafter
usually protected against its ravages, while we are all familiar
with the measles and whooping cough of childhood, which once
experienced, give us comparative protection against further
attacks. Modem theories and practice of immunity are of
very recent date, and yet methods of immunity have been
practised from an early date and by primitive people. The
Chinese and other orientals were wont to protect themselves
against smallpox by putting the scabs of patients into the
nose of persons who had not yet taken the disease. In 1721
a similar method was introduced in England by Lady Mary
Montague, and was practised there until the discovery of
Jenner's method of vaccination. The Moors used to protect
their cattle from pleuropneumonia by sticking a knife, which
had been previously inserted in the lung of an animal which
had died from the disease, under the skin of healthy animals.
One of the tribes of central Africa, the Vatuas, are reported
to immunize themselves against snake venom.
The various theories of immunity are too complex to be
discussed in detail here, but the brief general statement may
be made that immunity depends upon certain cheiiiical sub-
stances in the blood which either aid in the destruction o£
bacteria or counteract the poisons which they produce (or
both). The former process occui-s in vaccination either with
448 Biolorjy in America
a weakened (smallpox) or dead virus (typhoid fever) ; the
efTicieiicy of anti-toxins in diplitheria, and tetanus depends
upon the latter, while meningitis serum acts both as a means
of destroying the meningitis bacterium and of neutralizing
the toxin produced by it.
But to return to the discovery of a cure for meningitis.
For several years experimenters had been attempting to
render animals immune to the disease, and then by injectiiig
some of their blood serum into other animals to make these
latter immune in their turn. Various species of animals
were employed for this pui-pose, but the horse M'as the one
finally selected, partly because normal horse serum, when
injected into human beings produces no ill effects, and, partly
for the reason that the horse is readily immunized against
meningitis, and partly because of the large amount of serum
obtainable from one animal. In immunizing a horse the first
step is to secure the bacteria from some victim of the disease
and grow them on some culture medium such as agar impreg-
nated with beef bouillon and other nutrient materials. After
a good growth has been obtained, the culture is scraped off
from the agar and heated to 55° or 60° C. in physiological
salt solution, to destroy the bacteria. A drop or two of this
solution, containing the dead bacteria and some of their prod-
ucts, is then injected into a horse which has been kept under
observation for some time and rigorously examined to deter-
mine its healthfulness. After eight days a second and larger
dose is given and this is repeated at similar intervals for
periods of from four months to a year, until the horse can
withstand large injections, not of dead, but of living bacteria.
The horse is then bled under aseptic conditions and the
serum so obtained put in sterile vials and sent out to
physicians for use.
The treatment with this serum was not at first successful
however. The world-wide epidemic of cerebro-spinal menin-
gitis beginning in 1904 stimulated the search for a remedy
and these experiments were soon successful. The credit for
the first successful use of anti-meningitis serum probably
belongs to a European — Jochmann, but the principal devel-
opment of the method is due to Flexner, working at the
Kockefeller Institute in New York.
Early in his experiments Flexner employed monkeys as
more likely than the lower animals to react to human disea'^es
in a manner similar to men. By injecting cultures of the
meningitis bacterium into the spinal column of monkeys Flex-
ner infected them with the disease. Following these experi-
ments he similarly employed intra-spinal injections of the
curative serum, at first on monkeys and later on man, with
Biohf/!/ (Did Medicine 449
marked success, tlie comparative i'aiJure of the earlier experi-
ments being apparently due to the fact that the injections
were not made directly into the space surrounding the H\miid
cord, so that the anti-serum did not gain direct access to the
seat of infection.
While the results with anti-meningitis serum are not per-
fect, they are nevertheless very encouraging. Whereas the
mortality in the disease previous to the introduction of anti-
serum treatment was about 75%, mounting in very young
children to over 90% ; in 1294 cases treated with the anti-
serum the mortality was only 31%, and when the injection was
given early in the disease this was reduced to 18%. Even
more striking results have been obtained in the case of
diphtheria anti-toxin, while in the use of vaccines as preven-
tive agents the immunity secured is virtually perfect. The
practically complete elimination of typhoid fever from our
army in the recent war, and in the wild goose chase after
Villa in 1917, is sufficient testimony to the effectiveness of
anti-typhoid vaccination, while the prevention of tetanus in
the wounded, when injected with anti-tetanus serum in time,
tells clearly the story of the blessing of this remedy to man.
With the extent to which trench fighting was developed
in the great war, men, with rats and like rats, buriowing
and living undeiground in trench and "dug-out," came new
diseases and we heard for the first time of "trench foot" and
"trench fever." The first of these was clearly an individual
indiction due to imperfect circulation caused by long standing
in the wet. But the latter was apparently communicable,
caused by some sort of micro-organism. Here was a new
problem for biology to solve. Suspicion quickly fell upon
the "cootie," and conviction soon followed. Twenty-two men
allowed themselves to be bitten ])y lice from trench fever
patients, as a result of which twelve of them acquired the
disease; while four who were bitten by lice from healthy
men did not contract it, and eight others living in the same
quarters as the bitten men, but kept free from lice, also
remained free from the disease, proving conclusively the guilt
of the "cootie" as the carrier of infection.
In the field of protozoiilogy, medical entomology and ])ara-
sitology America has rendered conspicuous service both in
discovery of new facts and in their application to human
welfare. AVhile the proof of the role of the mosquito in the
spread of malaria is mainly due to English. French, and
Italians, the extension of that proof to include the relation
of the mosquito to the yet more deadly yellow fever is duo
to the devotion and courage of four young Americans (one
a Cuban), as a result of which two of these suffered an attack
450 Biology in America
of the deadly scourge, and one of them (Lazear) hiid down
his life as a sacrifice to science and to mankind/
The Italian Grassi and the Englishmen Low and Sambon
had shown the necessary causative relation between the mos-
quito and malaria, and the relation between the distribution
of 3'ellow fever and the mosquito genus Stegomyia, led to a
strong suspicion of the latter as the villain in the plot.
The demonstration of the theory was simple enough, but
one requiring heroic self-sacrifice on the part of the demon-
strators. The story has been so often retold that it may
be passed over here in briefest outline. The theory of a
causative relation between the mosquito and disease is not
a new one. The very ancient literature of India contains
suggestions of such a relation, particularly in regard to
malaria. Many primitive peoples have had a dim idea that
mosquitoes were to blame for the fevers prevalent in low-
lying, marehy regions. The Mschamba tribe in Africa avoid
such regions for fear of fever. In their language the same
word (mbu) is used both for fever and mosquito. "When
Humboldt visited the region of the upper Orinoco he found
that the natives attributed their fevers to mosquitoes.
As early as 1848 Dr. Nott of New Orleans suggested the
mosquito as the transmitter of malaria and yellow fever, and
in 1853 Beauperthuy published an article in the "Gaceta
Oficial de Cumana" (Venezuela) in Avhich he advanced a
similar theory. Beauperthuy pointed out that yellow fever
prevailed when there was a good mosquito crop. He sug-
gested that the mosquito injected into the blood of its victims
a poison which broke down the red corpuscles, mixing their
coloring matter with the blood serum. This poison was
obtained by the mosquitoes from decaying matters along the
seashore or in swamps.
In 1881 Dr. Carlos Finlay of Havana, as the result of a
careful and extended study of the life history and habits
of the Stegomyia mosquitoes and their relation to yellow
fever concluded that they were the agents in the spread of
the disease, and in 3897 Dr. A. C. Smith of the U. S. Marine
Hospital Service, tried an experiment at the national quaran-
tine station on Ship Island in the Gulf of Mexico, which was
a forerunner of the later work of our government in Cuba,
and which strongly supported Finlay 's conclusions. Dr.
Smith comi)letely screened the quarantine station where he
had under treatment some thirty cases of yellow fever, taken
from incoming vessels, and no new cases developed there.
The final and definite proof of the theory however was made
*SubsoqueTitly both Rccd aud Carroll dictl, probably as the indi-
rect result of their work.
Biology and Medicine
451
by a U. S. Army Commission appointed by Surgeon-General
Sternberg in 1 !)()(), during our occupation of Cuba. Tlie
commission consiste<l of three Ainericans, with Walter Kecd
in charge, assisted by James Can-oil and Jesse I^azear and
a Cuban, Aristides Agramonte. Two wel^ built houses were
erected in the same situation, and fully sei-eened. In one of
these soiled bedding, brought direct from yellow fever patients
in Havana, was placed, and here a number of men lived for
several weeks without a single case of yellow fever developing
among them. In the other house were' two rooms separated
only by a mosquito proof screen. One of these rooms was
kept free from mosquitoes, while in the other were placed
■mmW
JB
Carroll, Lazear and Eeed
Members of the U. S. Yellow Pcver Gominission, which (ieiuoiistiateil
I he role of mosquitoes in the carriage of yellow fever.
Coui-tcsy of the U. 8. Bureau, of Entomology.
mosquitoes which had bitten yellow fever patients. Among
the men occupying the former no case of the disease devel-
oped, while one-half of those in the latter room developed the
disease. In another experiment seven men were bitten by in-
fected mosquitoes contained in a glass jar, and five of them
contracted the disease. The subjects of these experiments
were volunteers, meml)ers of the ('(»ininissi(.n t heniselves,
U, S. soldiers and three Spaniards. Doctor Lazear died of the
fever, as the result of an accidental bite by an infected
mosquito. Dr. Carroll, contracted the disease, as the result
of his experiments, and while he i-eeovered from the fever,
his death, four years later, was probably indirectly tlue to
this attack. The first soldier who volunteered was John R.
452 Biology in America
Kissinger of Ohio, concerning whom Doctor Eeed says in his
report :
"I cannot let this opportunity pass without expressing my
admiration of the conduct of this young Ohio soldier who
volunteered for this experiment as he expressed it 'solely in
the interest of huitianity and the cause of science' and with
the only proviso that he should receive no pecuniary reward.
In my opinion, this exhibition of moral courage has never
been surpassed in the annals of the Army of the United
States.""' The iSpaniaids who volunteered did so for tlie
money offered them, and because they had little faitli in the
theory. After three had contracted the disease however no
more of tlieni volunteered.
Let us look for a moment at a few of the results of these
discoveries and sacrifices.
The failure of the French under DeLesseps to dig the
Panama Canal was due to many factors, chief of which were
dishonesty, extravagance and fever. With no knowledge of
the causes of yellow fever and malaria it was naturally
impossible for them to successfully combat these plagues.
The exact mortality figures for the period of the French
occupation are not available, but the rate is known to have
been very high. The contractors who were doing the work
for the Canal Company were charged $1 a day for each
of their men cared for in the company's hospital. Conse-
quently when a laborer was taken sick his employer often
discharged him in order to save hospital expenses^ and many
of these unfortunate men were left to. die upon the roads
leading into Panama and Colon. Of thirty-six Catholic nuns
brought from France to serve as nurses twenty-four died of
yellow fever. Seventeen out of eighteen young French engi-
neers who came over on one vessel died within a month of
their arrival.
"When the United States undertook the canal work in 1904
Colonel W. C. Gorgas of the army medical corps was placed
in charge of sanitation. The drinking water in the canal
zone was almost entirely obtained from cisterns or water
barrels. In the city of Panama alone there were four thou-
sand breeding places for mosquitoes. These were immediately
covered to prevent the entrance of mosquitoes, and in eight
months' time there were less than four hundred receptacles
containing mosquito larvpe. In addition to covering the rain
barrels, about 700,000 gallons of oil were used for oiling pools,
and nearly four hundred miles of drainage ditches cleaned
out every year in order to destroy the breeding grounds and
'Howard, "Mosquitoes of North nn<l Central America," Carnegie
Institution, Pub. 159, p. 244.
Biology and Medicine 453
to kill the larvae in those remaining. In order to ferret out
every possible breeding spot more than 4,000 acres were
cleared of grass and 2,000 of brush annually. And as a
further protection against the remaining mosquitoes, and
other insects, about $1,000,000 were spent in screening resi-
dences, hotels and hospitals. As a result of this work "not
a single case of yellow fever was contracted during the first
two years under Doctor Gorgas, although there were con-
stantly one or more yellow-fever cases in the hospital, and
although the nurses and doctors were all non-immunes. The
nurses never seemed to consider that they were running any
risk in attending yellow-fever cases night and day in screened
wards, and the wives and families of officers connected with
the hospital lived about the grounds knowing that yellow
fever was constantly being brought into the grounds and
treated in nearby buildings. Americans, sick from any cause,
had no fear of being treated in the bed immediately adjoin-
ing that of a yellow-fever patient. Colonel Gorgas and Doctor
Carter lived in the old ward used by the French for their
officers, and Colonal Gorgas thinks it safe to say that more
men had died from yellow fever in tliat building tban in any
other building of the same capacity at ])i'esent standing. He
and Doctor Carter had their wives and children with them,
which would formerly have been considered the height of
recklessness, but they looked upon themselves, under the now
recognized precautions, as safe almost as they would have
been in Philadelphia."'^
Similar results were obtained in Havana during the occu-
pation of Cuba by the United States. Two "brigades" of
mosquito fighters were oiganized, one to make war on tlie
Stegomyia or yellow-fever mosquito in the city itself, and one
on the Anopheles or malaria mosquito in the suburban dis-
trict. The city was divided up into sections to each of which
an inspector and two laborers were assigned, whose duty it
was to see that all rain barrels were protected against mos-
quitoes, all cesspools oiled, and other receptacles of fresh
water emptied. In tiie suburbs ditches and gutters were
cleared of debris, new ditches dug where necessary, and the
little puddles of water in the footprints of cattle or horses
and other depressions in the field were drained, but little
oiling being necessary.
Prior to the United States' occupation Havana was a pest
hole and a serious menace to the health of our country. Tliis
condition indeed was one of the factors leading up to the
Spanish-American War. In 1!)00 it was visited by a severe
epidemic of yellow fever, deaths from wliieh nuiiibere<l '.Vlh;
" Howard, locus citatus, pp. 431-2.
454
Biology in America
in 1907 as a result of the auti-mosquito campaign there were
but 28 deaths, and the disease is now virtually unknown
there,*'^
Within the United States anti-mosquito work has been
sporadic and local in character, in many cases being under-
taken privately rather than under national or state direction.
Wherever it has been consistently pursued however it has
given striking success. One of the most notable instances of
this local work is that undertaken on Staten Island in 1901
War on the Mosquito
Filling in salt marshes with the contents of Brooklyn ash barrels.
Cottrtcsy of the U. tS'. Bureau of Entomology.
by the New York Health Department under the direction
of Dr. Doty, health officer of the port of New York. Staten
Island is a long narrow island on the opposite side of New
York Bay from the city, and between it and the Jersey shore
a ridge of low hills forms the backbone of the island, with
the land sloping down to salt marshes along the shores.
Malaria has been epidemic there for many years, and its
mosquitoes have been almost as famous as the New Jersey
brand. The details of the work are similar to those already
described, except that more extensive ditching operations were
'" Noguchi has recently discovered a probable cause of yellow fever
in the Leptospira icteroides. He has also devised a successful pro-
tective vaccine and a curative serum, which latter in several experiments
reduced the mortality from 50% to 9%.
Biology and Medicine 455
required in the drainage of the extensive marsli areas. The
results were most gratifying. The Anoplieles mosquitoes were
virtually exterminated, with a consequent reduction in the
number of malaria cases from thirty-three in 1905 to five in
1909/ while other mosquitoes also have been greatly reduced
in number.
But insects play not only a necessary role in the spread of
disease; the incidental part which they take is on the whole
far more dangerous than the other. In its discovei-y of this
part biology has made one of its greatest contributions to
human welfare. The trail of the fly has been followed so
often and with such care in the literature of recent years
that it seems superfluous to repeat what is so well known.
And yet a few of the more striking facts concerning the
relation of flies and other insects to the spread of disease, and
especially the results of preventive measures may not be
amiss ; the more so since we still find in some quarters among
supposedly educated and intelligent people an almost total
disregard of the most common and fundamental laws of self-
defense against disease.
While we are all sadly familiar with the reproductive
capacity of the fly, probably few of us realize the theoretical
possibilities of such increase — theoretical, because, owing to
the inevitable loss of eggs and young, the possibilities are
never realized. They are interesting and instructive liowever
for if such possibilities exist theoretically, the realization must
at least be very great. A fly lays on the average 120 eggs
at one time, which come to maturity in ten days, and in the
latitude of Washington, D. C„ there may be as many as
twelve broods in a season. If every other egg of every brood
gave rise to a fertile female (assuming an equality in the
number of males and femaleis) and this in turn produced
broods of its own in due season, one mother fly would produce
2,568,034,296,513,029,664,000 « flies, which if strung end to end
on a thread would reach some 400,000,000,000 times around
the earth.
The fly's body is clothed with fine hairs and a single
fly has been estimated in some cases to carry more than
6,000,000 bacteria.
In 1898 there were concentrated in army camps in the
South thousands of men gathered there for our campaign
against the Spaniards in Cuba. These men ate in unscreened
mess halls near which were the similarly unprotected latrines
of the camp, affording free passage for, the millions of flies
'Prior to 1905 there are no satisfactory data on the number of cases.
'Computed by E. F. Chandler, Professor of Civil Engineering, Uni-
versity of North Dakota.
456
Biology in America
which swarmed from latrine to mess table. Typhoid fever
developed in the camp and the resultant roll of 22,420 cases
and 1,924 deaths told all too plainly the work of the fly as
tile agent of death. Bacteriological examination of the bodies
of flies confirmed the evidence of the siek list, showing beyond
peradventure the responsibilitj^ of the fly. Contrast this with
our record in the recent war. In the army camps an almost
entire absence of flies, even though nearby towns and villages
were furnished with an ample quota, no uncovered garbage
piles, loose refuse, or unscreened mess halls and kitchens ; no
poorly built and unsanitary toilets, no dirty streets and ill-
scrubbed floors. A returned soldier put the situation in a
nut-shell when he said that he wished every civilian could
have a dose of sanitary training in the army. And the result ?
A reduction of the death rate from all diseases, prior to the
influenza epidemic in 1918, to less than one-half that of the
healthiest part of the United States. This epidemic levied
a terrible toll upon the crowded army camps, serving to illus-
trate man's utter helplessness in the face of an enemy who
fights with unknown weapons.
As a further specific example of the results of the "swat-
the-fly" campaign in America, when consistently carried out,
let us take the experience of Wilmington, N. C, in 1911.
During the summer of this year all manure piles and other
possible breeding places for flies were several times sprinkled
with pyroligneous acid to destroy the developing eggs and
larvifi. The result of this work is shown in the accompanying
table in which + indicates the time of sprinkling.^
Typhoid Cases
Date of sprinkling with
pyroligneous acid
June 1-7
11
8-14
22
+
15-21
50
+
22-28
42
29-
July 5
10
+
6-13
11
14-20
3
+
21-
0
In 1907 the Merchants' Association f)f New York City
appointed a committee to study among other things the work
'From Hlockljridge, "How to Make a P'lyless Town," World's Work,
vol. 24.
Biology and Medicine 457
of t^je fly in spreading disease. Tlieir findings showed that
where the sewage was tliickest there tlie flies were most
•ibundant and further that tlie number of deaths from various
intestinal diseases corresponded very closely to the abundance
of flies from week to week.
A similarly incidental role in the spread of the dread
bubonic plague has been traced to the rat and its boon
companion, the flea. While the plague is a native of the
East, its ravaging march has often extended over Europe and
it has even crossed the Pacific and visited our shores.
The role of the rat in the spread of plague was suspected
by the ancients centuries before the Christian era. Samuel
tells us that in one of the numerous wars Ix'tween the Philis-
tines and the Israelites, the former made ofi' with tlie national
emblem of the Hebrews, the Ark of the Covenant; whereupon
as a sign of His displeasure the Lord visited upon the thieves
a scourge of plague. To assuage the wrath of tlie offended
Deity the priests of the Philistines told them to return the
stolen goods and to make a peace offering to the Lord of
"five golden images of the emerods (boils) in their secret
parts, and five golden images of the mice (rats?) that marred
the land." 1°
The early Greeks recognized Apollo as the sender of the
plague and the mice (rats?) as his messengers. During the
reign of the Roman Emperor Severus a great epidemic of the
plague broke out in Asia ]Minor. A coin made at Pergamos
at this time shows on one side an image of the god of
medicine ^sculapius, with a dead rat at his feet and by his
side a naked human figure in an attitude of supplication.
Since the days of Justinian down to recent times the
plague or "black death" of the Middle Ages has swept re-
peatedly over Europe leaving death and desolation in its
trail. "Truth is indeed stranger than fiction" and neither
the "Rienzi" of a Bulwer nor the "Romola" of an Eliot has
outdone, in their wonderful pictures of the pestilence which
overwhelmed Italy in the fourteenth century, the colorless
facts recorded by history. From time immemorial plague
appears to have been of frequent occurrence in Asia and
Africa, but only in recent years has it invaded the western
hemisphei-c. The outbreak in San Francisco in 1905 brought
home forcibly to Americans the truth that in these days of
rapid and easy communication between our own shores and
those of Asia we are living not to ourselves alone, but are in
truth our "brother's keeper." AVith the opening of tlie
Panama Canal and consc'quent shortening of the voyage
between the orient and our Gulf and Atlantic ports, llie
" 1, Samuel, vi, 5.
458 Biology in America
danger of an occasional recurrence of the disease among ns
becomes still greater.
"Without the aid of biology we should still be living in the
Dark Ages so far as plague is concerned. With the discovery
of the bacillus causing the disease in 1894 it was shown that
mice, rats, guinea pigs, rabbits, monkeys and many otlicr
animals can be infected by inoculation as well as by feeding
with infected material. But how was the disease trans-
ferred from man to man? Was it a "miasma" or foul air
which did the damage? Was it by "fomites" or infected
clothing and other articles that contagion was spread? Or
was personal contact necessary for infection? Here enters
the ubiquitous flea. The Indian Plague Commission appointed
by the British Government to study the scourge in India
found that it was only in the presence of fleas that con-
tagion was spread from one animal to another. Young rats
may even be suckled by plague-infected mothers witliout con-
tracting^ the disease, provided fleas are absent from their
cages. Rats and guinea pigs may be kept healthy in cages
hung in rooms where animals have recently died of plague.
But if the cages be hung near enough to the floor to permit
the fleas to jump in, they become infected. On the other
hand the cages may be placed upon the floor without danger
of infection, provided only they be surrounded with "tangle
foot" thereby preventing ingress of fleas. Furthermore con-
tagion may be spread through the transfer of fleas from
infected to healthy animals without any contact between the
latter. In the light of these experiments proof appears to
be conclusive that the flea is the most important, if not the
only direct intermediary in the spread of plague. ^"'^
But the flea does not confine his attentions to rats alone.
He believes in a varied diet, and an occasional meal of human
blood is quite to his taste. Consequently in rat-infested and
dirty dwellings, where fleas abound, if plague breaks out
among the rats, their human co-habitants are almost certain
to be stricken likewise.
Previous to 1900 plague had never occurred in the United
States although it had visited IMexico and South America.
In this year there was an outbreak of plague in ' ' Chinatown
in San Francisco, followed in 1907-8, a year after the great
earthquake and fire, by a second outbreak, in both of which
there was a total of 281 cases and 85 deatlis. When the
disease was discovered the city authorities at first adopted
the ostrich policy and endeavored to suppress all information
relative to it.
"In San Francisco plague met politics. Instead of being
confronted by a united authority with intelligent plans Jor
"* Pneumonic plague niay be transmitted direct by the breath.
Biology and Medicine 459
defense, it found divided forces among which the question
of its presence became the subject of factional dispute. Tliere
was open popular hostility to the work of the sanitarians,
and war among the City, State, and Federal health authorities.
"A federal health officer was arrested for trying to do his
duty as he saw it. Eugene Schniitz, wliile nuiyor, refused to
approve the printing of health reports and vital statistics
and attempted to remove from office four members of the
Board of Health who persisted in the statement that plague
existed in the City. The State bacteriologist, Ryfkogel, found
plague germs and lost his position and part of his back salary.
"The public drew its inferences from the voluminous mis-
information furnished by the disputants. Plague was said
to be a medieval disease" It belonged to the days of Charle-
magne or James II before the common people had soap. It
was an Oriental disease, peculiar to rice-eaters. It was, a
Mongolian or Hindu disease, and never attacked whites. In
San Francisco it was not a disease at all — it was graft.
Landlords of Chinatown rat warrens contended fiercely that
their premises were perfectly sanitary because the plumbing
was vented.
"For a while the people were in the gravest danger and
it seemed impossible to convey any adequate warnings to
them. Intimations from medical conventions of Eastern
State boards of health that unless San Franciscans got to-
gether and stamped out the plague, it would be necessary
to enforce a general quarantine against the City, actually
brought forth a demand from certain quarters that the
Marine Hospital fellows go back to Washington where they
belonged." ^^
Without the necessary power to act in the case the local
health authorities called upon the U. S. Public Health Serv-
ice, with the result that Doctor Rupert Blue was placed in
charge with full authority to act. Doctor lilue immediately
instituted a relentless war upon the rats which infested the
city, with the result that the disease was soon entirely eradi-
cated. As illustrative of the role of the rat in the spread of
plague in San Francisco the following data are quoted from
Doctor Blue's reports.
"Two small boys (October, 1907) while playing in an
unused cellar found the body of a dead rat. The corpse
was buried with unusual funeral honors. In forty-eight
hours both were ill with bubonic plague. A laborer finding
a sick rat on the wharf picked it up with the nakiMl luuid
and threw it into the bay. He was seized three days later
with plague. Doctor C. and family lived in a second-story
""Eradicating Plague from San Francisco," Eoport of tho Citizena'
Health Committee, pp. 30-31.
460 Biology in America
fiat over a grocery store in the residence section. Being
annoyed for some days by a foul odor the doctor caused the
waniscoting around the plumbing to be removed. One or
two rat cadavers v^^ere found in tne hollow wall. In two or
three days the two membeis of the family who used the room
hickened, one dying on the fifth day of cervical bubonic
plague. It is probable that infected rat Heas were set free
by the removal of the wainscoting. Dead rats were frequently
touncl in or near houses waere plague had occurred." "-
An outbreak of plague in rats occurred in New Orleans
in 1914. As the result of prompt measures for the destruction
of rats and the fumigation and rat-proohug of the infected
premises the disease was suppressed with but a snigle case
occurring in man.
An eftective piece of plague control work is that conducted
by the Bureau of Health in the Philippines. The method of
plague control piactised m ivianila is (_t interest as showing
how it is possible practically to suppress the disease even
though it may be impossible to completely exterminate the rat.
"A list of the places at which plague-infected rats were
found was made. Each was regarded as a center of infec-
tion. Radiating lines, usually five in number, were pro-
longed from this center, evenly spaced like the spokes of a
wheel. Rats were caught along these lines and examined.
Plague rats were seldom found more than a few blocks away.
The furthermost points at which infected rats were found
were then connected with a line (and) the space inclosed by
the dotted line was regarded as the section of infection. The
entire rat-catching force, which had heretofore been employed
throughout tlie eity, was then concentrated along the border
of the infected section; that is, along the dotted line. They
then commenced to move toward the center, catching the rats
as they closed in. Behind them thorough rat proofing was
carried out. One section after another was treated in this
way until they had all been wiped out. Once weekly there-
after rats were caught in the previously infected sections and
at other places which were insanitary and which had been in-
fected i!i years gone by. This was coutinned for one year." ^^
But not alone is the rat responsible for the spread of plague.
At least two species of ground squirrels as well as the tree
squirrel have been shown to be susceptible to the plague ba-
cillus, and the occurrence of plague in the first of these has
been shown in nature, as well as its probable relation to the
""The Knt :uul Its Relation to the Public Health," p. 147. The U. S.
Public Health Service.
"Locus citatus, pp. 205-G.
BioloQjj and Medicine 461
occurrence of the disease in man. In 3904 a case of human
plague occurred a slioi-t distance east of San Francisco, and
in lUOG a boy near Oaldand was attacked by the disease after
handling some ground squirrels which he had shot a few
days previously. In July, 1908, two cases of human plague
were found in the same region in California, and an ('xaiiiiua-
tion of 425 ground squirrels collected in tiie vicinity showed
the presence of the disease in four. In August of the same
year a boy was stricken with plague in Los Angeles after
being bitten by a sick ground squirrel, and a dead s(|uirrel
taken in the vicinity was found to be infected with plague.
The woodchuck has been suspected as a plague spreader, but
its relation to the disease has not been proven as yet.
Not only are ground squirrels a source of danger in the
spread of plague, but the loss they cause in the destruction
of grain is very serious. Their destruction therefore is of
first importance for both sanitary and purely economic rea-
sons. To the accomplishment of this task both the U. S.
Public Health Service and the Biological Survey are devot-
ing their energies. Many methods are employed at present
for the extermination of both rats and ground squirrels,
which have been discussed in a previous chapter. In the de-
struction of rats, trapping, poisoning, inoculation with
viruses or bacterial cultures, shooting and rat-proofing have
all been employed more or less successfully. Space does not
permit a detailed discussion of the use and merits of these
various methods, but it may be said in a general way that the
rat-proofing of buildings and systematic trapping are the
most effective means of control.
There are many diseases of man and lower animals, some
of them among the worst scourges of the human race, which
are caused, not by microscopic organisms, either plant or ani-
mal, but by parasitic worms. One of the most terrible of
these diseases is trichinosis, caused by a minute worm, about
1/20 inch in length, the Trichina spiralis. The devas-
tations of this disease have been greater among some of the
poorer classes of Europeans, who were accustomed to eat-
ing raw pork, than among Americans. Nevertheless the dis-
ease is not unknown in this country, and the occasional oc-
currence of the parasite in American hogs led about 1880 to
the prohibition of their import into several European coun-
tries. The woi-m is a parasite of man, the hog and the rat,
its life histoiy being similar in each. Let us trace this, start-
ing with a pair of adult worms living in the intestine of the
hog. Here the female is fertilized and gives birth to some
thousands of progeny, which promptly bore their way through
462
Biology in America
the wall of the intestine, and then migrate, probably through
the blood vessels to the muscles. Here they encyst, surround-
ing themselves with a capsule which is partly secreted by
themselves and partly by the irritated tissue surrounding*
them. If now, the improperly cooked flesh of a hog, infected
with these trichina is eaten by man or the rat, the sheaths are
dissolved by the digestive ferments of the second host and the
^^.^
,.'"... .v
Trichina Imbedded in Muscle
Courtrnii o} the U. .V. Bureau of Animal Industry.
worms are set free in its intestine to repeat the cycle occurring
in the hog. It is during the course of their migration and en-
cystment in the muscles that occurs the terrible suffering
caused by this disease which is usually relieved by death
alone. If however the infection be light, the patient may
recover, the worms finally dying, and being absorbed, leaving
only the connective tissue scars to mark their place. Since
hogs rarely have the opportunity of eating human flesh the
rat becomes in one sense a necessary agent in the persistence
Bwlogij (iiul Medicine
4fi3
and spread of tlio disease. There is no remedy known, save
that of prevention, and it is here, in the safeo;nardinfr of onr
meat supply tliat the proteeting liaiid of Uncle Ham is
stretched forth to save both tlie lives and the dollars of his
children.
Other parasitic worms of occasional occurrence in tlie
United States but of minor importance from a medical stand-
point, because of their relative benignity, are the tapeworms
transmitted to men in the flesh of both hogs and cattle.
The stoiy of the tapeworm brietiy told is as follows: This
is as its name implies, a tape or band-like animal, divided
into segments which become progressively larger and riper in
A Tape Worm op Man
Courtesy of the U. S. Bureau of Animal Industry.
passing from the "anterior" or "head" end posteriorly. The
beef tapeworm lives in the intestine of man, and its ripe
proglottids are passed in the stools of the patient. Tiiese east
proglottids are virtually nothing but a sack full of embryos,
each surrounded by a horny sliell. If one of these embryos
is taken by the beef in its food or water, it loses its shell in
the beef's stomach and passes into the intestine as a tiny em-
bryo about 1/80 of an inch in diameter. This is armeil with
three paired hooks by means of which the larva rapidly works
its way through the intestinal wall and into the blood vessels,
through which it is carried to the muscles or "flesh" of the
animal where it grows to a considerable size, acquiring the
"head" or attachment organ of the adult worm. The larva
1R4- Biology in America
now consists of a sack-like bladder filled with fluid, which has
griven this, and similar larvfe the name of "bladder-worm,"
inside of which is the head in an inverted position like the
intunied finger of a glove. In the muscles the larva is sur-
rounded by a connective tissue sheath similar to that surround-
ing the Trichina larva already described. If a piece of
improperly cooked beef containing one of these larva? is eaten
by man, the "bladder-worm" loses its "bladder," turns its
"head" inside out, thus bringing it into the proper position
for a frontal attack on the intestine of its host, to which it
attaches itself by means of four "suckers" on its "head,"
and now proceeds about its business of growing and produc-
ing ripe segments, which may in their turn infect another
beef.
For the benefit of those who enjov a nice juicy piece of
rare beefsteak it may be said, that with the very efficient in-
spection service of the U. S. Bureau of Animal Industry the
occurrence of tapeworms in this country is decreasing, and
m(>at coming from an inspected slaughter house may be eaten
with impunity. This of course does not apply to meat
slaughtered by country butchers.
Living in our Southern States is a community of people
cfdlrd with contempt by negroes and whites alike the "po'-
whites." They are a shiftless, lazy lot of "ne'er-do-wee's"
living in utter disregard of health or decency. Many of them
have never been to school, and those children who do go to
school stand from forty to ninety points lower on a scale of
one hundred in their ability to improve, than their comrades.
They are found in rural communities and the smaller towns
and villages wherever unsanitai-y living conditions occur. In
Porto Rico about ninety per cent of the poorer inhabitants
are of this type. "Slany of them are what are known as "dirt
eaters," rivaling even the traditional goat in their fondness
for paper, old rags, earth, lime, etc. For generations these
people have presented an insoluble problem to physician and
philanthropist alike. Was the cause of their condition hered-
itary ? Had some outcast from the slums of Europe escaped
to America with the early settlers and peopled the South with
his degenerate progeny? Or was the hard environment too
heavy a handicap for them to overcome ? AVas weak mental-
ity and feebleness of purpose to blame, or yet was the cause
a physical one, some insidious disease which inappreciably,
yet none the less certainly was sapping the energy, both men-
tal and physical of its victims ?
The answer to these questions came to us indirectly from
Europe. In cutting the St. Gothard tunnel through the
Alps it was observed that many of the miners who were bare-
Biology and Medicine
465
footed were
and the Ital
the liookwor
the Geniian
infected soil
of biological
years an in
of "gronnd
anemic, run down and unable to do good work,
ian Perroncito at that time traced the disease to
■m Ankylostomum duodenale. Some years later
Looss, traced the eouise of the worm from the
to the intestine of its victim by a very clever bit
detective work. There had been known for many
itation of the skin of the feet under the names
itch," "foot itch," "dew itch," etc.
(a) Female, (b) Male, and (c) Mouth of the Hookworm
An animal which is mainly responsible for the condition of the "poor
whites" in the Soutii, and wliii-h causes an economic loss of perhaps
$500,000,000 annually. The disease can be effectively and easily cured,
while its prevention is merely a jnatter of a few simple sanitary pre-
cautions. (After Stiles.)
"AVhile experimenting with hookworm larvie he spilled
some of them on his liand ; he noticed a burning sensation
and in a few minutes the larvae had disappeared. After the
proper interval, about two months, he found himself sutfcr-
ing with the hookworm disease. To determine what had be-
come of the larvffi that were spilled on his hand he poure<l
some larvffi on the leg that was about to be amputated from
a boy; on sectioning the skin of this leg, after amputation,
he found the larva3 had worked their way through the skin
466 Biology in Avicrica
by way of the liair follicles, sweat duets, etc. To follow the
further course of the larva; he placed some of them on the
skin of a number of dogs which were killed and examined at
various intervals. In this way he worked out the entire
course of the larva; from the skin to their final resting place
in the intestine." ^*
Where a number of poor and ignorant miners were col-
lected in narrow underground quarters, as in the building of
a tunnel, with no proper arrangements for the disposal
of bodily wastes, it is plain that the most elementary rules
of health would be disregarded and that tilth would abound.
The hookworm derives its name from the slightly bent or
hooked anterior end. In the mouth are four hooks and two
conical teeth by means of which it attaches itself to the mu-
cous membrane of the intestinal wall. Here it is said to live
for several years, during which time it produces an enor-
mous number of eggs. If these chance to be deposited in a
moist place, as in the pools of water in a mine or tunnel, they
hatch into larva; which live in the water or moist earth until
they meet the bare skin, usually of the feet, of another vic-
tim. They then bore through the skin into the blood ves-
sels where they are carried by the blood stream to the heart
and finally to the lungs. Here they leave the circulation,
enter the iungs, and crawl into the bronchial tubes, up which
they crawl to the throat and thus reach the oesophagus. From
here they pass through the stomach to the intestine. The
hookworm may also reach the intestine directly in unwashed
fruit or raw vegetables.
Knowledge of hookworm disease and the part it plays in
deteriorating so large a proportion of our southern popula-
tion is mainly due to Dr. Charles W. Stiles, the parasitolo-
gist of the U. S. Public Health Service. Stiles has studied
the disease extensively in. the South and found the cause to
be the same as in Europe although the American wonn is
somewhat different from its European cousin. Stiles' re-
searches, aided by the liberality of the Rockefeller Founda-
tion, and by the activity of state boards of health throughout
the South, have made widely known the cause, and means of
prevention and cure of the disease. The abolition of the
unsanitary privy on the one hand, and thymol and epsom
salts on the other, will rid the world of a scourge infesting
an area in which live about 1,000,000,000 people, or more than
half the total poulation of the world, with an infection rate
in some countries as high as ninety per cent among the labc^r-
•*' Reese, "Economic Zoology," p. 35. By permission of P. Blakiston's
Son and Company.
Biology and Medicine 467
ers, and causing an economic loss in sickness and death of
untold millions.
The announcement by Dr. Stiles of the part which the hook-
worm was playing in undermining the mental and physical
health of multitudes of people in the South, in causing in-
calculable financial loss and retarding the development of
the country, was at first greeted with amusement or indiffer-
ence, followed by active hostility. He at once became the
subject of the usual campaign of the newspaper reporter and
cartoonist, which greets every innovator, especially in an un-
progressive and conservative community. In an early con-
ference at Raleigh, N. C, "an incredulous physician in the
audience asked him if the disease existed there. 'I see sev-
eral pronounced cases in the room now,' he replied. A local
newspaper declared that the Commission was slandering the
community ; the Governor gave out an interview in praise
of the health of the fair land that he ruled over and de-
nouncing its slanderers. Sketches of the lives of aged men
of the neighborhood were published, to prove the healthful-
ness of the community, and much other such nonsense and
ignorance was put forth." ^^
The opportunity for service in the fight against the hook-
worm was early brought to the attention of Mr. John D.
Rockefeller, and the result was the organization of the Rocke-
feller Hookworm Commission in 1909. Brieflj^ the work of
this Commission, in co-operation with state boards of health
throughout the South, has been the establishment of travel-
ing dispensaries for treating the sufferers and educating the
people in general regarding the danger, prevention and cure
of the disease. The following quotations taken from the Com-
mission's report for 1911 illustrate better than mere figures
what the Commission has done in its service to tlie South.
"AVhen the work began two years ago the people did not
know hookworm disease as a disease. The announcement of
its prevalence they had not taken seriously. It was ex-
tremely dif^cult to induce them to be examined, and even
more difficult to get them when found infected to consent to
treatment. The physician could not treat them until they
had been shown that it was to their interest to seek his aid.
For two years systematic effort has been made to give theni
the facts. The educational activities outlined in the report
for last year have been persistently pursued in each State;
the people have been taught by public lectures with charts
and lantern slides, by bulletins and folders, by the public
press, by exhibits at State and county fairs, by the examina-
" ' ' World 's Work, ' ' Vol. 24, p. 505.
468
Biology in Anierica
tion of children in the schools and students in the colleges,
by examinations made at the State laboratories, by the cele-
bration of public-health day ; and most effective of all has
been the teaching of the people by demonstration through
the treatmwit of large numbers at the county dispensaries.
... At times the clinics are small when the dispensaries are
new or in communities where the infection is light; but in
communities where the infection is heavy and after the dis-
pensary has had a few days within which to demonstrate its
effectiveness, the people come in throngs ; they come by boat,
])y ti'ain. ])y private conveyance for 20 and 30 miles. Our
A Hookworm Dispensary in Kentucky
The people travel for miles to obtain treatment.
Courtcsij 0/ the Rockefeller Foundation.
records contain stories of men, women, and children walking
m over country roads 10 and 12 miles, the more anemic at
times falling by the way, to be picked up and brought in by
neighbors passing with wagons. As many as 455 people have
been treated at one place in one day. Such a dispensary
group will contain men, women, and children from town and
country, representing all degrees of infection and all sta-
tions in life. A friend who had just visited some of the dis-
pensaries said to me recently: 'It looks like the days of
Galilee.'
"The people usually begin to arrive early. I visited one
dispensary at 8 o'clock in the morning and found 43 per-
sons there waiting for attention. They linger; they gather
Biology and Medicine
469
in groups around the tables of exhibits; they listen to the
stories of improvement as told by tliose wlio have been treated,
and return to their homes to report to their neiglibors what
they have seen and heard. . . . The effect of these edi^x-a-
tional activities is seen nist of all in the transformation which
has been wrought in public sentiment. This change of senti-
ment shows itself in the co-operation of the press — which is
now practically universal in all the States — in the growing
co-operation of the physicians, of the educational agencies.
The Kesllt of lia kworm Treatment
(Left) — A victim of hookworm.
(Eight) — The same girl after treatment.
Courtesy of the Rockefeller Foundation.
of the whole people ; it shows itself in an increasing support,
not only of this particular work, but of all public-health in-
terests.''^'^
Probably in no field of medico-biological research have ani-
mals played a larger part than in the investigation of can-
cer. Rats and mice have been the principal subjects for
these experiments, because of the readiness with which can-
cerous and other growths can be transplanted in them, and
""The Rockefeller Sanitary Commission," Second Annual Report,
pp. 17-22.
470 Biology in America
because of their small size, fecundity and the ease with which
they can be reared in captivity. Many other animals how-
ever have been employed, including the long-suffering guinea
pig, dog, cat and chicken.
The study of cancer dates back into far antiquity. The
early Greek and Roman physicians, Hippocrates, Celsus and
Galen, thought of diseases as due to a disproportion in the
amount of the four cardinal "humors" of the body — the
blood, mucus, yellow bile and black bile. Cancer was fan-
cied as caused by an excess of the latter, while even as late
as 1874 the noted English surgeon and pathologist, Sir James
Paget, ascribed cancer to a morbid condition of the blood.
At the beginning of the seventeenth century one writer put
forth the view that cancer was caused by a spirit (the
Areheus) resident in the stomach and spleen. Unless this
spirit was purified it was apt to intrude itself into parts of
the body where it did not belong, thereby producing cancer.
Green frogs have been associated with cancer in the minds
of the credulous for hundreds of years, and Bonet of Geneva
in 1682 gave a formula for a cancer ointment made of green
frogs, while in a book published recently (1905) in South
Africa occurs the following interesting item (as translated) :
"An example of a woman who had cancer of the breast,
which was already so severe that eight holes had been eaten
into it, and who recovered through the following expedient:
She took eight frogs applied to the breast in a muslin bag,
which attached themselves instantly thereto as firmly as
leeches. When they had sucked to repletion, they dropped
off in violent convulsions without the sucking causing pain.
This was repeated until 20 frogs were used, which all from
time to time, sucked until they died. And the breast was not
only cured, but returned again to its normal size absolutely.
Another remedy of the same author is tortoise liver "laid
on the cancer and used continually."
About the beginning of the seventeenth century one healer
put forth the following receipt which he asserted from cer-
tain experience to be excellent for "ulcerous cankers."
"Take suckling Puppies, put them in Wine, and distill it
half off in Balneo; then take the puppies out, and boil them
in a sufficient quantity of Golden-Rod Water, or common
Water with Golden-Rod in it; when the Decoction is made,
add the Water that was distilled off the young Dogs and boil
them together till the flesh comes from the Bones. Then
distill them all in Balneo. Keep the Water for use. Wet
dry clothes or rags in this, and apply it to the ulcerous car-
cinoma. For from certain Experience it heals the sore by
cleansing and drying."
Biology and Medicine 471
"Since the beginning of recorded medical history, and
doubtless before, imagination was given full play in the
treatment of cancer. The 'witch doctor' combined the secrets
of the 'black art' with the brewing of the 'witch's broth,'
and the unfortunate victim of cancer was given doses of the
mixture. Throughout the centuries the sufferer from this
disease has been the subject of almost every conceivable form
of experimentation. The fields and forests, the apothecary
shop and the temple have been ransacked for some success-
ful means of relief from this intractable malady. Hardly
any animal has escaped making its contribution, in hair or
hide, tooth, or toe-nail, thymus or tliyroid, liver or spleen, in
the vain search by man for a means of relief. The hand on
the dial has turned many times to the same point of effort
during the progress of the centuries, and it is possible to
find in remote districts today the same remedies being used
that were employed by 'cancer eurers' of long ago."^'
Apart from these early fancies what we may call the mod-
ern theories of cancer have been many and varied. We
know that its immediate cause is an unlimited growth of
certain epithelial cells which run riot in the body, encroach-
ing upon and finally destroying the other tissues and pro-
ducing death. But what it is which causes this growth we
do not know. It has been supposed to be the result of the
growth of a wandering germ cell which has become misplaced
and undergone a sort of parthenogenesis within, rather than
without the body. In this connection the observations of
Professor Allen of the University of Kansas on the germ cells
of certain fish, Ampliibia, reptiles and mammals are of interest.
Allen found that the primitive sex cells in these animals in-
stead of arising in the sex glands appeared first in the wall of
the gut, whence they wandered into the ovary, where they ex-
perienced their final development. It is quite conceivable
that such a wandering germ cell might "get lost" in its mi-
grations, and finding itself in strange surroundings, develop
abnormally, producing a cancer.
Closely related to this theory is that which explains can-
cer as the result of the type of division of epithelial cells
which characterizes the germ cells at a certain stage of their
development, and which is explained in Chapter VII deal-
ing with the physical basis of Mendelian inheritance. Yet
another theory of somewhat similar character, proposed by
the late Professor Boveri, the noted Cerman cytologist, re-
lates cancer to some abnormal type of cell division in which
the chromosomes become misplaced and unevenly distributed
'■^ Above quotations from Bainbridge, "The Cancer Problem," pp.
2-3. By permission of the Macmillan Company.
472 Biology in America
to different cells. Respecting this theory, it may be said that
while there undoubtedly is abnormality of cell division in
cancer, it may more likely be its result rather than its cause.
Still another hypothesis attributes cancer to some parasitic
organism presumably bacterial, of which many have been de-
scribed by entliusiastic investigators, but none proven.
Finally we have the explanation of cancer as due to chronic
irritation of some part of the body, stimulating abnormal cell
growth of that region. There is much more evidence for this
than for any of the preceding theories. One of the most fre-
quent locations of cancer is the mid^ gland, an organ which
IS apt to be under continual irritation from an ill-ntting or
tightly laced corset, in sniokeis the tongue and lip are fre-
quent sites of cancer, regions apt to be irritated by the pipe
stem or cigar. Cancer or the abdomen is prevalent among tlie
natives oi i\ashniir who carry snmll earthen jars, surrounded
by basket work and containing a charcoal nre, under their
robes next to the skin as a means of warmth.
That cancer is ndierited in mice has been recently claimed
by ^liss Slye of the Otho S. A. Sprague Memorial Institute
of Chicago, as the result of an extensive series of breeding
tests ; and her results have been apparently accepted by some
members of the medi.'al profession. They lack substantia
tion liowever and it would be well to travel slowly over a path
so newly blazed into the unknown, lest we stumble and fall
into error on our way.
The past twenty years have witnessed remarkable devel-
opments in the study of cancer in both xVmerica and Europe.
This study has been conducted both in the clinic and the lab-
oratory. At present its net result is a negative one. It h.i ;
.served to explode many promising theories of cancer, and to
reveal our ignorance, but as yet we are still fighting blind-
fold one of the most terrible enemies of man.
In America this work was instituted in 1898 when the
State of New York made a small appropriation for cancer re-
search at the University of Butfalo. Since 1901 the laboratory
at Buffalo has been known as the Cancer Laboratory of the
New York State Board of Health. The following year saw
the inauguration of the Cancer Commission of Harvard Uni-
versity, whose work is conducted jointly in the laboratories
of Harvard University and in the CoUis P. Huntington ]\Ie-
morial Hospital of the same institution.
These initial undertakings have been followed by many
others, such as the Research Department of the New York
Skin and Cancer Hospital, the George Crocker Special Re-
search Fund of Columbia University, the Barnard Free Skin
and Cancer Hospital of St. Louis, and the Research Hos-
Biology and Medjicine 473
pital of the New York State Institute for the Study of Malig-
nant Disease.
Cancer-like growths are of frequent occurrence in animals
other than man. Rats and mice are especially prone to have
them, but they are also known in dogs, cats, horses, mules,
asses, cattle, hogs and in a host of wild mammals. Among
birds they occur commonly in chickens and have been re-
ported in others, both wild and dom'^stic. They have been
noted in various reptiles and amphibians, while artificially
reared fish are especially susceptible.
Great as is our ignorance regarding many of the scourges
of mankind, the advances in our knowledge in the last fifty
years have been phenomenal, and the promise of the future
was never so bright.
By what means have these revolutionary advances in our
knowledge of disease been made possible? Chietiy by experi-
ments on animals. Bacteriology has developed methods pe-
culiar to itself and the development of these methods has
been possible only through animal experimentation. When
the bacteriologist announces the discovery of a "germ," as
causing some disease, it is only after putting his new find
through a long series of experiments, which demonstrate con-
clusively its relation to tne disease in question. First, it
nuist be found consistently in the bodies of patients afflicted
with the disease. Second, it must be isolated from such pa-
tients and a "pure culture" in some culture medium (gela-
tine, broth, etc.) obtained. Third, it must be possible to in-
fect some animal with this culture, and thereby produce the
disease in it. Fourth, the same germs must be found in the
infected animal. Fifth, from this animal a pure culture
must be obtained witli which the disease can be reproduced
in another animal, and this cycle must be repeated with suffi-
cient frequency to prove tiiat the relation between the germ
and the disease is a necessary, and not merely accidental
one. Sixth, no other germ tested in the same way must give
similar results.
AVithout experiments on animals most of these results would
have been impossible, and yet there are today many seem-
ingly rational people, who would restrict the use of animals
for the saving of human life, and alleviation of human mis-
ery, under the specious plea of preventing sutfering — to
animals !
In whose hands is the administration of this new knowl-
edge? Who are responsible for safeguarding the nation's
health ? Many are the agencies involved in this great work
and many the objects of their care. International, national,
state and local in scope; public and private in support;
474 Biology in, America
philanthropic and commercial in purpose, the character of
these agencies is as varied as are the objects of their con-
cern. Space forbids any adequate consideration of them all,
but we may glance for a moment at the work of one or two,
wliicli are broadest in scope and foremost in accomplishment.
When we are enjoying our roast beef or leg of mutton, how
often do we stop to consider the care which Uncle Sam takes
to insure our safety in partaking thereof? At every slaugh-
ter-house and packing plant engaged in interstate trade the
U. S. Bureau of Animal Industry maintains inspectors whose
duty it is to prevent diseased meat from entering into this
commerce. When the animal arrives at the slaughter-house
it is examined "on the hoof" before butchering, and if passed
separate examinations are made of neck glands and viscera,
and finally, if the animal passes muster, the meat itself when
cleaned and dressed is inspected, and the government's ap-
proval is stamped upon it, before it enters refrigerator car
or room preparatory to shipment and sale.
In the preparation of the many biological remedies on the
market today, such as vaccines, antitoxins and glandular
extracts of various sorts (pituitrin, thyroidin, adrenalin,
etc.), yet greater care is exercised to guard against con-
tamination of any sort. All establishments preparing such
materials for interstate commerce must obtain a U. S. license
before the government will permit them to do business. Be-
fore gi'anting such a license an inspection is made of the
premises where the work will be done by an agent of the
U. S. Public Health Service. Such inspection is repeated at
intervals to see that the plant is up to standard, and the
products themselves are tested for purity (both chemical and
biological) to determine their efficiency and safety.
As an illustration of the care which is taken to safeguard
the user of these products, let us follow for a moment the
method of preparing one of them, namely, smallpox vaccine.
This vaccine is the pus which forms in little pustules on cat-
tle infected with cowpox. The animals used in its prepara-
tion are usually young bulls or heifers. These are quaran-
tined for several weeks, during which time they are care-
fully inspected for any possible disease and tested for tu-
berculosis. If found healthy they are given a careful scrub-
bing with soap and water, and some weak antiseptic and
then taken to the vaccine laboratory. The operating and
propagating rooms are constructed with a view to the utmost
cleanliness, the floors being of concrete and the walls and
ceilings enameled. The interiors and fittings are washed at
■frequent intervals with disinfectants. In the laboratory the
animal is placed on a special operating table, the abdomen
Biology and Medicine 475
shaved, washed with sterile water, and cut in a series of paral-
lel lines with a sterile knife. Into these cuts the virus, taken
from another animal under aseptic conditions, is introduced
with a sterile instrument. The animal is now placed in the
propagating room, where an attendant is at hand night and
day to keep the room in the cleanest condition possible. After
about a week, when the characteristic pox pustules have de-
veloped, the animal is killed, its abdomen washed with sterile
water, the pus removed with a sterile instrument and placed
in 50% glycerine in a sterile vessel which is then placed in
a refrigerator.
The carcass of the animal is examined and the vaccine is
tested for any possible contamination by inoculation of guinea
pigs and culture media. Its efficiency is tested by trial vac-
cinations of calves, rabbits or guinea pigs. If found to be
both pure and potent it is placed in small, sterile glass tubes,
or on ivory points, which are sealed in sterile glass contain-
ers, labeled, dated and returned to the refrigerator until
ready for the market.
The activities of the U. S. Public Health Service cover
practically every phase of the nation's health. From guard-
ing our ports against the entrance of infection with its
quarantine service, to examination of rats and mice for plague
bacilli at Seattle and New Orleans, or ground squirrels in
California, the Service is waging a nation-wide and relent-
less warfare against every enemy of human health.
A gipsy family camped on the outskirts of a country town
is taken sick with what is suspected to be typhus fever. The
Service details an officer to study the cases and endeavor to
discover the cause. Intestinal trouble breaks out in an in-
dustrial plant. The Service makes an investigation and dis-
covers typhoid fever, and the necessary steps follow for its
extermination. Trachoma is present among the school chil-
dren in some locality ; a surgeon is sent to investigate the
disease and advise measures for its control. Influenza sweeps
like wildfire across the country. The resources of the Serv-
ice are mobilized to meet the scourge. Lack of definite knowl-
edge regarding the cause of this disease has as yet rendered
inefficient any efforts for its control. The Public Health
Service was aware of the danger before it came but was
powerless to prevent it, as influenza is not a quarantinable
disease. The spread of the disease was so rapid and exten-
sive that doctors and nurses in every community were over-
taxed, most places finding themselves without a sufficient num-
ber, especially as so many were enlisted in the army. To
meet this difficulty a special appropriation of $1,000,000 was
passed by Congress, and the Service, together with the Red
476 Biology in America
Cross and local health org^anizations thronghont the country,
organized, as best they could, a teuii)orary corps of doctors
and mirses, which were sent to points of greatest need.
IMeantime data were being gathered by means of a house to
house canvas in certain chosen localities, in the effort to as-
certain the factors involved in the spread of the disease.
Laboratory 'studies were made on the possibility of trans-
ferring the disease from man to lower animals and from man
to man, but no definite information obtained except as to
the dit^culty of the artificial transfer of the disease. Tests
were also made of several anti-influenza and pneumonia vac-
cines, but with no very satisfactory results.
These few instances, which could be multiplied many times,
will illustrate the work which is being done by the Service in
the study and control of disease in the United States.
In this work it employs not only fixed laboratories, but
laboratories on wheels, having two cars, which can be sent to
any point for a study of disease in the field, as occasion arises.
The determination of the cause of pellagra, a disease of
faulty nutrition, of which mention has been made in a pre-
vious chapter, is largely due to the work of Goldberger, one
of the Service Staff.
When the youth of our nation were concentrated by the
hundreds of thousands in army camps, the Service was called
upon to protect them from disease in the extra-cantonment
areas. Within the camps themselves the army was responsi-
ble for their protection, but in the regions about the camps,
especially in the towns and amusement centers visited by the
men when on leave, the responsibility fell upon the Public
Health Service, aided in many cases by the Red Cross.
Realizing the terrible menace of venereal diseases, and un-
der the stimulus of patriotic enthusiasm, Congress in 1918
established a Social Hygiene Board for the study and con-
trol of these diseases, consisting of the Secretaries of War,
Navy, and Treasury and the Surgeons-General of War, Navy
and Public Health Service or their representatives, and ap-
propriating nearly $2,000,000 annually for carrying on the
work. The administration of this act has been largely in
the hands of the Public Health Service, which by co-operation
with state boards of health in the establishment of clinics
for the treatment of venereal patients, by the establishment
of an interstate quarantine against infected persons, restrict-
ing their privileges of travel from state to state, and by
means of a widespread campaign of education has made a
splendid start in the battle against these social plagues.
In the field of industrial hygiene the Service work looms
large. When we realize that to change one employee in a
Biology and Medicine 417
factory or stnro costs the employer from $35 to $70, we
api)reciate the iinportauce of tlie worker's health from the
standpoint of dollars and cents alone. Add to this the dan-
ger of the crowded factory as a center of contagion and con-
^ ecpient menace to an entire community, and we can realize
tile necessity of industrial hygiene as a public measure.
During tlie recent war this work became even more than
usually imperative, for the city of ordinarily 20,000 or
30,000 was suddenly swelled to one of 100,000 or more. The
housing problem became acute and with it arose the even
more serious ones of water supply, sewage disposal and of
all the factors which make for health or disease in any
connnunity. Then too the great munition factories, ship-
building plants, and all the other war activities sprang up
like mushrooms over night, bringing with them teeming life
in new locations and consequent menace to the public health,
and increasing the opportunities as well as the responsibilities
of the men of the service.
If we drink water, and most of us do nowadays by virtue
cither of choice or necessity, we will be interested to know
that when we travel on a train from one state to another
our drinking supply is safeguarded by the watchful care of
the U. S. Public Health Service. These supplies are under
constant supervision by agents of the Service, and if they
do not meet the standard set they are condemned and the
carriers obliged to improve them or obtain new supplies
elsewhere.
In addition to a station in Hawaii for the study and treat-
ment of lepers, whose investigations in the treatment with
derivatives of chaulmoogra oil, are meeting with a consider-
able degree of success, the Service has established a national
home for lepers in the United States, a number of which un-
fortunate people live among us.
The Service also maintains a tuberculosis sanitarium at
Fort Stanton, N. M., and numerous hospitals for the care of
sick or disabled soldiers, sailors and other government
employees.
One might continue indefinitely to rehearse the activities
of the U. S. Public Health Service, not to mention those of
the many other agencies for protecting public health, but the
foregoing must suffice as a bird 's eye view of this great and
ever-growing field.
In all the great work which biology has done for man
there is none more splendid than its service in the field of
preventive medicine.
chaptp:r XVII
The outlook. Some unsolved prohlenis of biology. Possibil-
ities of larger service.
It is as profitable for Science as for the individual to pause
now and then and take an inventory ; to view in retrospect
its successes as well as its failures, and in prospect its possi-
bilities and its problems — such a backward glance over the
pages of biology in America has been taken in the preceding
chapters. In closing let us draw aside the veil for a moment,
and view the opportunities for future service of biology to
man.
The most urgent demand upon biology today is for a
study of the factors of evolution. In spite of Darwin, Weis-
mann and DeVries and the host of splendid workers who have
devoted their lives to a solution of this problem in the past,
the final answer, or answers, for there are doubtless many, is
still shrouded in mystery. The ultimate causes of vanation,
the creative power of selection, the possibility of the inherit-
ance of characters acquired during the lifetime of the indi-
vidual— these and many others are still unsolved problems.
Closely allied to, nay, inseparable from the problem of
evolution is that of inheritance. Is the "unit-character" the
Ultima Thule of the explorer of life's mysteries? Or is it
in itself a little cosmos of characters acting and reacting
upon one another to produce the end result? Is the behavior
of "unit characters" fixed and immutable, like the laws of
the Medes and Persians, or is it subject to environmental
influence, yielding different results according to the condi-
tions imposed upon it? And what is the nature of the
"determiners" of these "unit characters"? Are they con-
stant physical or chemical entities, pereistent from generation
to generation of the cell, or are they variables, which pass
through a complex series of developmental changes beginning
in the fertilized egg and reaching fruition only in the adult
organism? Are these determiners restricted to the chromo-
somes or ai'e they present in the cytoplasm as well? And if
restricted to the former does the latter exercise no influence
upon them? Is the entire organism a complex of unit char-
acters, or is it the superficial characters alone, such as color,
478
The Outlook 479
size, hair form, etc., which behave as units in inheritance?
Is sex purely an inherited character, subject to Mendelian
laws, or is it determined by conditions of metabolism or other-
wise, and if so is it subject to experimental control? And
what is the significance of the curious sex intergrades which
have recently been described, and which are "neither fish,
flesh, nor good red herring"? How and why did sex arise?
There are some animals, such as Hydra, which reproduce both
sexually and asexually. What are the factors inducing sexual
reproduction in such forms ? And what is its function ? Does
it exercise a rejuvenating influence upon the race, or does it
serve to produce variation and thereby lead to evolution and
adaptation? Or do both of these, or yet other explanations
contain the truth?
Why do some animals reproduce by parthenogenesis at one
period in their life history and sexually at another? And
what is the significance of parthenogenesis, which in some
cases has gone so far that males are extremely rare, and may
possibly in some species have disappeared entirely ? At any
rate if they occur, they are yet to be discovered.
Surrounded as we are by speculation and uncertainty in
the realm of evolution and inheritance, we enter a veritable
terra incognitoi when we come to speculate upon the essence
of life itself. Is life purely a physico-chemical process, and
the organism a mere machine controlled by forces extraneous
to itself ? And if so, what are the physico-chemical reactions
which constitute life ? Or is life a process outside the realm
of physics and chemistry? Are our concepts of consciousness
and intelligence, of volition and of soul, realities, or mere
figments of the imagination? Or is there yet some middle
course which we may steer between the Scylla of "mechanism"
on the one hand and the Charybdis of "vitalism" on the
other ?
If life be an unsolved problem, equally so is the cessation
of life or death. Is death inherent in life or was life pri-
marily unending, and death secondarily derived from factors
outside of life itself? And what of the origin of life? Is
Harvey's dictum ''Omne vivum ex vivo" necessarily true?
Or may lifeless matter to-day be generating life and continue
to do so throughout the ages, as it did at some time in the
past ?
If we are some day to solve the riddle of life, we shall then
be able to create life. While some enthusiasts have from tirne
to time claimed that they have done this, their claims are yet
unsubstantiated, but the possibility of such an achievement
looks less remote to us today, than would have seemed the
Rontgen ray or the wireless telegraph to our forefathers.
480 Biology in America
IMucli as we liave already learned i-ejifai'diiijj^ the stnietui-e
of the cell, it is but as a drop in the biieket compared with
our ignorance of this marvelous mechanism of life. What
is the origin of the nucleus? Is it primary and the cytoplasm
formed from it, or vice versa. Or yet are both nucleus and
cytoplasm, co-ordinate parts of the cell in time as well as in
function? Do such apparently anucleate cells as the bacteria
and the blue-green algffi contain nuclear material, and if so
what is its condition in these cells, and is such a condition
primary or derived? If primary, how has a definite nucleus
arisen in higher cells? Is the distributed nucleus as we find
it in certain Protozoa a stejp in this direction, or is this in
turn a specialized condition derived from the more generalized
one in which but a single nucleus occurs within the cell?
Similarly how has the green coloring matter of the majority
of plants and a few animals been evolved, what is its chemical
composition, and by what physico-chemical processes does it
utilize the sunlight in building up the complex starches and
sugars from carbon-dioxide and water?
Our existing knowledge of the cell has been obtained mainly
from fixed and stained material. Does such material tell us
a true story? AVhat of the living protoplasm— its physical
structure and chemical composition? And what of the won-
derful cell products known as ferments, which play so large
a role in all processes of life? What is their chemical char-
acter, and in what way do they do their remarkable work ?
AVhat are the factors regulating the growth, and determin-
ing the size of organisms ? What enables them to regenerate
lost parts? And why does regeneration in some cases repro-
duce the part lost, and in others a wholly different one?
In medical biology, great as have been the advances of the
past, yet greater still may be the progress of the future.
AVhe'n' Christ said to his disciples, "Among them that are
born of women there hath not risen a greater than John the
Baptist: notwithstanding he that is least in the kingdom of
Heaven is greater than he,"' he clearly referred to the
blessings conferred upon men by the coming of that kingdom.
While it is scarcely possible to conceive of discoveries of
greater value to mankind than those made by Pasteur, never-
theless "lie that is least in the kingdom (of modern sanita-
tion) is greater than he." Py the application of the dis-
covei-ies ()f a Pasteur, Metsehnikoff and Koch or Flexner is it
chimerical to dream of a future world from plague set free?
There is much remaining to be done however and none
need eomi)lain that the Ciolden Age of Discovery has vanished,
and that the frontier in biology exists no more. The filter-
* Matthew xi, 11,
The Outlook 481
able viruses, tliose dise;is(>-formino' or.uaiiisins so niiuute
that they can pass through the pores of the finest filters, yet
remain to be isolated; the cause of cancer, and many otlier
diseases to be discovered, and the functions of the ductless
fjlands more clearly determined than they are at present.
These are a few of the more urgent tasks which the medical
biologist has before him today.
The palaeontologist still has awaiting him untouched areas
of the earth's surface, where may lie concealed the key to many
a riddle regarding the evolution and relationships of animals
and plants, and their distribution in past and present time.
The embryologist may aid the palteontologist in his studies
of animal phylogeny by describing the embryology of many
of the rarer, and as yet unstudied forms, while the compara-
tive anatomist is partner to them both in solving the problems
of animal descent.
IManifold are the unsolved problems relative to the life
histories, distribution, and economic relations of animals and
plants. Which are our friends, and which our foes, how best
can the former be protected and propagated, and the latter
exterminated, and what new sources of wealth can biology
discover for mankind?
With such a job on its hands, and the foregoing outline
is but a glimpse of its burden, how best can biology "carry
on"? Helpful and encouraging as is the endowment of great
institutions such as those founded by a Rockefeller or a
Carnegie, the establishment of research chairs, and equipment
of laboratories in our universities, and the devotion of govern-
ment bureaus to biological research ; nevertheless the hope of
biology is in its followers. "God give us men," is now as
ever the prayer of progress. The spirit of Agassiz must still
fill our laboratories, or their equipment will represent but so
nuicli waste of money and of effort.
Hut the spirit of investigation needs both encouragement
and guidance. It is indeed true that investigation is its own
reward, but in the keenness of the social struggle for existence
the young man or young woman of today is not likely to
choose a calling which has glory for its sole reward. lie is
too likely to recall the words of Gray anent "the paths of
glory." If our research institutions are to secure the best
men they must offer sufficient inducement to at least provide
for the ordinar}' needs of life and enable the research woikers
to enjoy some of its pleasures. Herein lies the need for the
liberality of wealth toward science. Otherwise science is bound
to become connnercialized and turned to purely economic ends.
Another great need of biology is unification of effort.
Co-operation in biology is not lacking today, but co-ordina-
tion of effort is conspicuous chiefly by its absence, A dozen
482 Biology in America
men in as many places may each be working on the same
problem, wholly oblivious of the work of the others. Our
journals and societies do indeed serve as channels of com-
iiinnication between workers, but usually not until their
problems are well under way, or perhaps completed. INIight
not these societies, through committees appointetl for this pur-
pose, serve to at least put workers along similar lines in
closer touch with one another than they are at present?
Such a suggestion is not new, but so far as the writer knows,
it has not yet received sufficient consideration:'- To attempt
to dii-ect research in the sense of limiting individuals in their
choice of problems, would have a deadening, if not deadly
effect on all scientific progress. But guidance along the line
of co-ordination of effort should be as stimulating as the other
would be depressing.
Might not institutions also combine with advantage in the
prosecution of special researches? A striking and salutary
example of such co-ordinated effort between governments was
afforded by the International Council for Investigation of
the Sea, prior to the great war, whose work has been men-
tioned in a previous chapter. It was organized in 1902 to
eliminate waste of effort and of money in the study of the
physics, chemistry and biology of the ocean and its economic
resources. While each government prosecuted its own re-
searches in its own territory, all of the results were turned
in to the central office at Copenhagen for collaboration and
publication, and the general plan of the investigations was
outlined by a central committee chosen from representatives
of all the governments concerned. By means of this co-ordi-
nation results of great scientific and economic importance
were achieved, with material saving of time and effort.
It would appear both feasible and desirable to effect a
similar co-ordination of effort in our own country. On our
western coast for example are several institutions engaged
primarily in a study of the biology of the Pacific Ocean.
Why might not these institutions combine; and, with theaid
of tile U. S. Bureau of Fisheries, prosecute this research in a
svstematic and comprehensive way, rather than in the present
sporadic and disjointed fashion ?=^ Why also might not the
^ The establishment of the National Eesearch Council during the war
was a stop in this direction.
^ Looking toward such an end, a conference was held at Honolulu in
August, 1920, under the auspices of the Bishop Museum, which was
founded in 1889 by the late Charles Eeed Bishop of New York, for the
study of the natural history and ethnology of the Pacific islands.^ The
Museum was a memorial by Mr. Bishop to his wife, who was Princess
Bernice I'auahi, great grand-daughter of tlie Moi of Hawaii wlien Cap-
tain Cook visited the islands. The Museum is now co-operating with
Yale University in the exploration of the Pacific and several other
institutions are also interested in the project.
The Outlook 483
life of our inland waters be studied in a similar comprehen-
sive and connected manner, by the several aquatic biological
stations working under the general direction of the Bureau of
Fisheries? Or is our American science so sectarian in char-
acter that co-ordinated effort ia impossible?
Today American biology is preeminent. Its growth and
achievement in the past have been phenomenal. But yet
greater possibilities lie before it, in the coming reconstruction
of the world.
• 1
INDEX
Abdominal ribs, 133
Absorption in intestine, 299
Academy of Natural Sciences, 40;
beginnings, 52, 53
collections, 54
workers, 53, 54
ill. 53
Accessory, see Cliromosonies
Achatinellidae, see Hawaiian snails
Acquired characters, see Inherit-
ance
Adaptation, non-life, 281-2
organisms, 281
Adrenal gland, 321-3
Adrenalin, function, 321-3
see Biological remedies
^pyornis, 135
Agassiz, A., 350
Agassiz, Louis, 349, 481 ; life, 38-9
opponent of Darwin, 45
ill. 38
Age, see Amphibia, fossils; Lyco-
pods; Reptiles; Trilobites
Agramonte, 451
Aggressive resemblance, 338
Aigrette, see Egret
Air sacs, see Birds
"Albatross," 350-1, 365; ill. 350,
364
Albatross, see Isolation
Alcohol, 295; influence on chick-
ens, 251-2
guinea-pigs, 251-2
rats, 251
see Crustacea, light response
Alfalfa, destruction by mice, 388
see Nitrogen fixation
Algae, alternation of generations,
100
blue-green, 95, 480
fossil, 117
liot springs, 381
reproduction, 96
symbiotic, 92
see Chromatophorea, Nucleus,
Shells
Allen, B. M., 471
4S.
Allen, J. A., 88, 163
Alligator, distribution, 180
ill. 179
see Sexual Selection
Alluring resemblance, 338
Alternation of generations, 98
significance, 103
see Algae; Ferns, reproduction;
Liverworts; Medusa; Mos-
ses; Polychaeta; Polyzoa;
Protozoa ; Tunicates
Amblystoma, metamorphosis, con-
trol, 223, 224; ilh 225
Amboceptor, 445-6
American Association for Advance-
ment of Science, 46
American Breeders' Asaociation,
269
American Fish Cultural Associa-
tion, 425
American Fisheries Society, 425
American lemur, see Tarsier
American Museum of Natural His-
tory, collections, 44
exhibits, 55-9
founded, support, 54
work, 55-9
ill. 54
American Naturalists' and Geolo-
gists' Society, 46
' ' American Ornithology, ' ' see
Wilson, A.
Amino-acids, 296
Ammonia, 298
Ammophila, nesting instincts, 319
Amoeba, 95, 243; reactions, 301-4
complexity of structure, 304
volition, 281
ill. 94, 302
Amphibia, blood vessels, 89
foot prints, 123
fossils, 121-2
regeneration, 193
sex determination, 209
spread, 154
see Germ cells, origin
Amphioxus, indeterminate devel-
opment, 192
larval asymmetry, 110
486
Index
Ampliioxus, mouth, 110
relation to vertebrates and in-
vertebrates, 108
structure, 107, et seq.
Amphipod, 226
Anabolism, see Metabolism
Anadromus, see Fish
Anaptomorphus, see Tarsier
Ancestral, see Fish; Troehophore
Ancon ram, 239
Andalusian fowl, see Inheritance
Andrews, 88
Anesthesia of non-life, 318
Angler, see Gigantactus
Animal, color, cause, 332-4
functions, 334 et seq.
theories, 335 et seq.
heat, 283-4
Industry, see U. S. Bureau
migration, 143
organs, remedies from, 320
phosphorescence, 354-5
reactions, 301 et seq.
Animals, aquatic, diurnal move-
ment, 363
horizontal migrations, 383
survival, 381-2
swarms, 383
arctic, color, 334
cave, color, 226-7
sensitiveness, 227
compared with plants, 297
dependence on plants, 161
dispersal, 152, 154-5
interdependence, 161
polygamous, see Sexual selection
tropical, color, 334
see Distribution; Pools, tempor-
ary
Ankylostomum, see Hookworm
Annelids, fossils, 117
organ-forming substances, 191
regeneration, 193
structure, 106
typical invertebrates, 106
Annulate, see Annelids
Anoci-association, 325
Anopheles, 453
Ant leaf -cutting, see Mimicry; ill.
341
Antelope, 174, 425
extinction, 421
preservation, 420
see Eecognition marks
Anther, see Flowers, reproduction
Anthrax, 447
Anti-bodies, see Syphilis, Wasser-
man test
Antisepsis, results, 443-4
Antigen, 446
Anti-human serum, 438
Anti-toxin, see Biologiical reme-
dies; Diphtheria; Tetanus
"Anton Dohrn," 82, ill, 83
Ants, see Instincts
Aphids, see Instincts of ants
Appalachian Mountains, see Per-
mian period
Apparatus, deep-sea, see Bottom-
sampling ; Current meters ;
Projection; Sounding;
Thermometers ; Trawling
Apteryx, 133
Aquarium, N. Y., see Zoological
Society
Arachnid, see Sex determination
Arboretum, see Arnold
Arehaeopteryx, 131-3; 135 ill.
131
Arctic fox, hare, distribution, 172;
tern, ill. 142
Aristotle, 192, 243, 257, 402
Armored "fishes," 117
Arnold, Arboretum, 65, 67, 393
ill. 6.5, 66
Arthropods, see Isolation
Ascaris, giant larvae, 192
see Germ cells
Ascidians, see Tunicates
Aspen, distribution, 174
Asthma, see Adrenal
Audubon, J. J., account of Indian
swan hunt, 27-8
Mississippi in flood, 28
birth, 26
commercial enterprises, 26
death, 32
education, 26
emigrates to America, 26
failure and poverty, 27
journeys to Florida, Labrador,
Missouri Eiver, 32
marriage, 26
meets Rafinesque, 28-9; Wilson,
20-2
publishes "Birds of America,"
31
plans "Quadrupeds of Amer-
ica," 32
visits England, France, Phila.,
31
ill. Frontis.
Audubon bird law, 422
Society, 32, 420, 422-3
sons, pursuits and travels, 32
Axone, see Nerve fibre
Index
487
B
Baartsch, 256
Bacillus pestis, see Eat, parasites
Bach, inheritance, 273
Bachman, 54
Bacon, 74
Bacteria, 95, 480; nitrogen-fixing,
298
reactions, 305
related to disease, 440
resistance to boiling, 382
water, 378, 381
Bacterium, volition, 281
Badger, distribution, 176
Bailey, quoted, 417
Bainbridge, quoted, 470-1
Baird, work, 44, 61, 426
ill. 45
"Bakewell's Geology," 45
Balanoglossus, structure, relation
to vertebrates, 106, 107
mouth, 110
Baleen, see Whalebone
Balsam fir, distribution, 174, 175
Bamboo, 412, 413, 414; ill. 410
Banta, 232
Bantam, see Sexual selection
Barn, see Owl
Barnacles, see Movement
Barnard Free Skin and Cancer
Hospital, 86, 472
Barren ground caribou, distribu-
tion, 172
Barriers to migration, 152, 155-7
Bartram, John, 20, 63
Bartram, William, 20, see Wilson,
A.
Bat, see Adaptation; Animals, dis-
persal of
Bates, 330, 342
Bateson, 88, 243, 263
Bdellostoma, 108
Beans, see Nitrogen fixation; Pure
lines
Bear, see Polar
Beaufort Biological Station, 437
Beauperthuy, 450
Beaver, 425; distribution, 176; ill.
175-6
Bee, see Mimicry; Sex cycle
Beebe, 63, 134
Bees, relation to flowers, 330; ill.
332
worker, structure, function, 331
see Heliotropism ; Swarming ;
Color, warning
Beetle, ladybird, see Vedalia
Beetles, chrysomelid, see Calli-
grapha
potato, distribution, 245-6
experimental production of
variation, 246-8
food, 245
habits, 245
ill. 247
Behring, 431; Isthmus, 148
Sea Tribunal, see Seal contro-
versy
Strait, barrier, 254
Belknap, 364
Bennett, quoted, 443
Beriberi, 447; symptoms, cause,
292-3
Bernard, 320
Beroe, 190; ill. 189
Big trees, see Sequoia
Bile pigment, see Pigment
Biological bureaus, U. S., 87
remedies, 320; inspection of, 474
Biological Station defined, 68
see Beaufort, Fairport, Havana
Stations, locations, 71
see Marine
Biological Survey, see Survey,
U. S.
Biology inland waters, 379 et seq.
needs, 481-2
problems, 478 et seq.
Biometer, 318
Bird laws, see Migration, Lacey
lice, see Isolation
of Paradise, see Sexual selection
Birds, air sacs, 130
bones, 130
classification, distribution, see
U. S. Biological Survey
feather, development, 133
origin, 134
structure, 133-4; ill. 133
flight, origin, 133-5
food, 347-8; see Hawks, Owls,
U. S. Biological Survey
lungs, 130
migration, 152, 360 ; see U. S.
Biological Survey
sex determination, 210, 232
sex-linked inheritance, 214
skull, 131
sternum, 130
temperature, 130
wings, 132
see Adaptation; Color, warning;
Instincts; Isolation; Sexual
Selection
Birge, 382
488
Index
Bishop Museum, 482
Bison, 148, 420, 421, 425
migration, 152-3, 245
ill. 419
Blagden, 349
"Blake," 350
Blending, sec Inheritance
Blood serum, refractive index in
Bright 's disease, cancer,
syphilis, tul)ercnk)sis, 85
test, 438; see Syphilis, Wasser-
man test
Blue, 459
Blue-green, see Algae
Blumenbach, 208
Boa constrictor, transport, 155
Bobolink, spread, 182
molt control, 225-6
ill. 226
Bob-tailed cat, 240
Bonaparte, 19, 31, 53
Bones, see Birds, Crocodiles,
Pterodactyls
Bonneville, see Lake
Boreal zone, 174
Bonellia, see Gephyrea
Bonet, 470
Boston, see Water-works
Botanical Gardens, 62; see Bart-
ram, Missouri, N. Y.
Bottom-sampling apparatus, 365
Boveri, 88, 471
Bow-fin as food, 435
Boyle, 283
Brachiopod, see Spirifer
Bradbury, 34
Breeders' Association, see Amer-
ican
Brewer, 44
Bridges, see Land
Bright 's disease, see Blood serum
Brittle star, see Cross fertilization
Brontosaurus, 126; ill. 127
Brooke, 349
Brooklyn, see Water-works
Brooks, 88
BroAvn-tail, see Moth
Briinn, Natural History Society,
203
Bryozoa, statoblasts, 382
Buljonic, see Plague
Buffalo University, 472
see Bison
Burt'on, 235; see Jefferson
Bugs, see Color, warning
Bunting, see Lark, Snow
Bureau of Animal fndnstry, see
U. S.
Bureau of Entomology, see U. S.
Fisheries, see U. S.
riant Industry, see U. S.
Public Health, see U. S.
Burrowing owl, distribution, 182
ill. 18(1
Bursa, see Inheritance, shepherd 's
purso
Bursaria, ill. 00
Bussey, 87
Bussey Institution, 74, 87
Butler, 313
Butterflies, distribution, 172
influence of environment, 222-3
see Color, warning; Isolation;
Mimicry; ^Monarch; Sex de-
termination; Viceroy
Cabbage butterfly, see Pieridae
Caesarean operation, 444
Caffein, see Crustacea, light re-:
sponse
Caithness flagstones, 118
California, climate, fauna, flora,
184, 185; see Sequoia
Calligrapha, germ cell deter-
minants, 191
Calorimeter of Benedict and At-
water, Lavoisier, 284-5
Cambrian period, life, 95, 117
Camel, extinct, 148
migration, 149
Camouflage, see Color, protective
Canada lynx, distribution, 176
Canadian zone, 174
forest, ill. 171
Cancer, 481 ; animal experimenta-
tion, 469-70
chromosomes, 471-2
Commission, Harvard, 472
effect. X-ray, radium ray, 248
in animals, 473
inheritance, 472
institutes, 472-3
Laboratory, N. Y. State Board
of Health, 472
theories, 470-2
see Blood serum
Capelan, destruction, 156
Carbohydrate, energy production,
296
synthesis, 92-3
see Diet
Carbon dioxide, end product, 280,
294. 296
Index
489
Carbon dioxide, sign of life, 318
sugar synthesis, 93
see Crustacea, light response
Carboniferous jxiriod, life, 121-5,
ill. 124
climate, 124-5
Caribou, see Barren ground,
Woodland, ill. 109
Carinatae, 130
Carnegie Institution, biological la-
boratories, 73-4
Dejiartment of Embryology, 73
Nutrition Laboratory, 284
Carnivores, origin, 140, 142
Carp, survival in ice, 381
Carrel, 196-7
Carroll, 451, 452; ill. 451
Carter, 453
Cassowary, distribution, 139
Cassin, 44, 54
Cassiopea, 348
Castle, 88, 238, 267; quoted, 266
Castration, 325; see Sterilization
Cat, see Bob-tailed
Catalyzer, 295, 318
Caterpillars, color, 334; see Mimi-
cry
Catlin, 441
Cattle, color, horns; see Inherit-
ance
Cave, Port Kennedy, 42; see Ani-
mals
Cecropia moth, grafting, 196
Cedar, see Eed
Celsus, 470
Cell, growth, 198-99
immortality,. 201
problems, 480
see Germ
Centipedes, fossil, 124
Centrifuge, 52, 376
Cephalopods, destruction, 156
see Octopus
Ceratium, 92 ; ill. 91
Ceratophyllum, see Hornwort
Cerebratulus, development experi-
ments, 192
Cerion, influence environment, 256
Cestracion, invariability, ill. 120
"Challenger," 363, 366
Chameleon, color changes, 333
Characteristics of life, see Life
Characters, acquired, see Inherit-
ance
Chaulmoogra, see Lepers
Chemical treatment, see Seed
Chestnut, Chinese, bark disease,
416
Chiasmodus, 358; ill. 356
Chicken, see Web-footed
Child-bed, see Puerperal
Chipmunks, distribution, 176
Chittenden, (luoted, 286-92
Chlorophyl, 81, 93-4, 98, 297, 330,
383
composition, function, origin,
480
Cholera, see Hog
Chorea, 271-2
Chromatin, see Chromosomes, Mi-
tosis
Chromatophores, 333
algse, 94
Chromogen, 333
Chromosomes, 478
accessory, 209
homologous, 206
in development and inheritance,
202 et seq.
sex, 206, 208
ill. 204 et seq.
see Cancer
Chydorus spha?ricus, 232
Cilia, specializations, 91-2
Ciliates, 90; ill. 90-1
Circulation in plants, 299
Circumcision, 244
Citrange, 268
Cladoselache, structure, 120
fins, 112
ill. 112
Clams, 353
Cleft palate, 272
Clements, 158
Climatic factor, see Huntington
Closing nets, 371
Coast Survey, see U. S.
Cock, see Sexual Selection
Codfish, 423, 425
Coleps, shell, 92
ill. 91
Colleges, see Harvard, Kings,
Pennsylvania, Princeton,
William & Mary 's, Yale
Color, adaptation, 330 et seq.
blindness, 214
cause, see Animal
flowers, metabolic by-product,
330
man, -see Inheritance
jjrotective, 335 et seq.
warning, 346, 348
Columbia University, 50, 202
Commander Islands, see Seal
Commensalism, see Protozoa, mode
of life
490
Index
Compass plant, ill. 307
Complement, 446
Condor, distribution, 135, 185
see Giant
Conduction in plants, 299
Conklin, 189, 191
Cootie, see Trench fever
Cope, 38, 39, 54, 88
rivalries, reminiscences, 42
work, 40
ill. 41
Copepods, 381; see Plankton
Coral reef, see Fish
Corals, fossil, 117
Corbins, inheritance, 273
Corn, influence of selection, 238
see Inheritance
Correns, 203
Coryphodont, 142; ill. 141
Cosmobia, 228 ; ill. 229
Cotton, hybridization, 268
Cotton Mather, 442
Cotton rat, distribution, 178
ill. 178
Cottonwood, distribution, 182
Coues, 20, 43
Coulter, 43
Cowles, 438-9
Cowpox, see Vaccine, preparation
Coyotes, 421; damage, 393; see
Rabies
Crab, see King
Craig, 314
Crampton, 196, 255-6; quoted, 255
Cranial rib, see Vertebrates, head
Creodonts, 140, 142; ill. 141
Crenothrix, 379
Cretaceous, period, 140
sea, 127, 129, 132, 140
Cretinism, 273; see Thyroid
Crile, 321-2; quoted, 323-5
Crocker, George, Special Eesearch
fund (for cancer), 472
Crocodile, bones, 130; transport,
155
Cross fertilization, 327-8; see Sal-
via
Crossing over, 215
Crossopterygians, distribution, re-
semblance to Stegocephala,
121, 123
Crowfoot, 382
Crustacea, 358; eggs, relation to
temperature and moisture,
382
fossil, see Trilobite
light response, 315-6
sex determination, 232-3
Ctenophore, 104; see Beroe
Cuenot, 88
Cunningham, 333
Current meters, 365-6
Curtis, 436
Cuvier, 38, 223
Cyclopean monsters, 194; see Fish
Cyclops, relation to oxygen, 382
Cyclostomes, structure, 108, 111;
skull, 114
Cynodont, 136
Cynthia, 191; ill. 190
Cytoplasm, 189, 202, 478; origin,
480
D
Dana, 38, 349
Danaidae, see Mimicry
Daphnid, ill. 231; see Sex cycle
Daphnia, light response, 315, 361
heliotropism, 314
see Sex intergrades
Darwin, 45, 46, 116, 202, 222, 239,
240, 242, 330, 334, 478
quoted, 155, 235-6, 343-6
Date palm, 417; ill. 417, 418
Davenport, 88; quoted, 271-4
Dead leaf butterfly, see Kallima
Deaf-mutism, 272
Dean, 88
Deane, 125
Death, cause, 200-1
origin, 479
Valley, climate, 184
Deep-sea, see Fish, Apparatus
Deer, distribution, 176
preservation, 420
see Recognition marks. Wolves
Defectives, elimination, 276-7
De Lesseps, 452
Dentalium, 191; ill. 190
Department of Botanical Re-
search, Carnegie Institution
see Desert Botanical Labor-
atory
Embryology, Carnegie Inst., 84
equipment, establishment, loca-
tion, work, 74
Experimental evolution, Car-
negie Institution
Marine Biology, Carnegie Insti-
tution, location, 81-2
work, 82, 83
ill. 82
Depth, see Ocean
Index
491
Dermal bones, see Stegocephala
Desert Botanical Laboratory, 76
location, 75
work, 76-81, 220, 222, 245, 297
ill. 75
Desmids, shells, 94
Destruction, see Capelan; Cepha-
lopods; Fish, death; Gar
pike; Jack rabbit; Octopus;
Eodents; Tile fish; Wolves
Determiners of characters, 202 et
seq., 478
Development, determinate, 190-2
indeterminate, 192
see Chromosomes
Devils Lake, N. D., 380
disappearance of pickerel, 119
Devonian period, Amphibia, 112
lungfish, 120
DeVries, 203, 240-1, 243, 478
Diabetes, see Pancreas
Diatom ooze, 353
Diaptomus, light response, 316
Diatoms, shells, 94, 360
Dialysis, 295
Diastase, 279
Dicksissel, spread, 182
Didinium, 93
Diet, experiments
athletes, 289
dogs, 289-92; ill. 291
hens, 294
soldiers, 287-8 ; ill. 288
requirements, 287 et seq.
Digestion, 295-6, 299, 321
Dinornis, see Moa
Dinosaurs, 40
distribution, 125-6
extinction, 127
food, 127
intelligence, 127
structure, 126
tracks, 125-6
ill. 126
see Mammals
Diplococcus, see Meningitis
Diphtheria, 448-9; see Serum, Tox-
in
Disease, see Bright 's. Chestnut,
Foot and Mouth, Venereal
Dispersal, see Animals, Plants
Distribution, animals and plants,
factors, 177
horizontal, see Animals, aquatic;
Cassowary; Emu; Moa;
Ostrich ; Khea
Ditch-grass, 382
Ditmars, 63
Diurnal movement, see Animals,
aquatic
Dog, see Diet, Hairless
Dogfish, see Sharks
Dominance, 258; imperfect, 258-
261
Doty, 454
Douglas spruce, distribution, 174,
175
Dredge, 369-70
Drelincourt, 208
Drosera, reactions, 308-9; ill. 309
Drosophila, 210 et seq., ill. 209,
212; see Inheritance
Drummond, 37
Duck, see Wood
Ductless glands, function, 481
Dust, organic, volcanic, 353
Dwarfism, 273
E
Ear bones, relation to gills, see
Vertebrates, structure
Earth, age, 116-7
Earthworms, see Annelids
Eating, healthful, 293-4
Echinoderm, development experi-
ments, 192
Echinoderms, larva}, 105; sex deter-
mination, 209
Eckman, 365, 368
Edwards, inheritance, 270, 273
Eels, migration, spawning, 361,
363
Eggs, fish, distribution, 426, 429
membrane formation, 328-9
union with sperm, 327
see Crustacea, Estheria, Organ-
forming, Eeproduction, Eo-
tifers. Summer, Winter,
Worms
Egret, preservation, 421-3; ill, 421
Ehrlich, 446
Eigenmann, 88, 381
Eimer, 243
Elephant, 146; see Imperial
Elk, 425; distribution, 174
preservation, 420
ill. 420
Elodea, see Water-weed
Embryos, 104; see Vertebrate
Empedocles, 235
Emu, distribution, 139
Enamel, see Teetli, Mammalian,
Placoid scale
Endosperm, 245
492
Index
Kniielnian, fi3
English siiiirrow, 411; iiitroduc-
tidti, spread, 385
Eiitolci-liy, 189, 234, 1383
Entoniology, see U. S. Bureau
Environment, influence on develop-
ment, 220; ill. 221
relation to variation, 244 ct scq.
Enzymes, 205, 480
constructive, 296
digestive, 299
oxydizing, 296, 333
see Drosera
Eocene epoch, climate, 140
earth changes, 140
life, 138, 142-5
Eohippus, 40, 144
Epilepsy, 270-1
Epoch, sec Eocene, Miocene, Plio-
cene, Pleistocene
Equatorial plate, see Mitosis
Era, see Mesozoic, Palaeozoic
Estheria, egg, 382
Eucrangonyx gracilis, effect of
light, 226-7
Eugenics, 268 et seq.
Laboratory, 269, 274
Record Office, 74-5, 274
Eustachian tube, see Vertebrates,
structure
Evening primrose, influence of
radium, 248 ; see Mutation
Everglades, see Florida
Evolution, 234 et seq.
blood vessels, 89
factors, 478
invertebrates, 103-7
land from water vertebrates,
124-5
relation of morphology and
physiology to, 89
vertebrates, 106 ct seq.
see Darwin
Existence, see Struggle
Extinction, see Reptiles
Extra fingers, see Man, polydactyl-
ism
Eye, control of color, 333; devel-
opment, 193
F
Factors, see Inheritance, Mendel-
ian
Fairchild, 413
Fairport Biological Station, 436-7
Fat, digestion, 295-6
Fat, energy ])roduction, 294 6
reserve, 29()
see Diet, food changes
"Fauna boreal! Americana, " sec
Richardson
Feather, contour, down and hair,
srr Birds
Feathers, iiHj>()rtation, sec Plum-
age
Feeblemindedness, 270-1
Feeble-minded, see Training School
Fer de lance, 404
Ferment, see Enzyme
Ferns, horsetail, 122
reproduction, 99-100
spermatozoa, chemical attrac-
tion, 327
Fertility, see Rat inbreeding
Fertilization, artificial, 328-9
mechanics of, 328
see Cross, Protozoa, Salmon,
Volvox, \y inter eggs
Fever, see Puerperal
Fins, see Fish
Finlay, 450
Fir, see Balsam
Fish, anadromus, 361
ancestral. 111
commissions, state, 425 ; see
U. S.
coral reef, 340, 348; ill. 339
culture, 425; see American
cyclo}»ean, production, 227
death in overflow ponds, 118,
119, 437
deep sea, 354-7; ill. 354-6
development, 430-1
gills. 111
hatclieries, see Fish culture
migration, 360-3
monsters, production, 227; ill.
228
j)aired fins, 111-2
resistance to temperature, 382
scales, 120
sex-linked inheritance, 214
spiracle, 111
survival in ice, 381
sec Ada])tation, Dean, Eigen-
mann, Germ cells, In-
stincts, Jordan, Origin,
Plankton
"Fish Hawk," 350
Fisher, distribution, 174
Fisher, 287
Fisheries, see U. S. Bureau
Fitzhughs, inheritance, 273
Fixity of Species, belief, 45
Index
493
F1;i<;p11:i, 92
Flagellates, 92-3, 95, 98; liglit
reactions, 30G
Flagstones, see Caithness
Flatfish, 358; color adaptation, 333
Flatworni, regeneration, 193
Fleas, sec Plague
Flexner, -148, 480
Flics, and disease, 455-7
control, 456
increase, 455
see Mimicry
Flight, see Birds
' ' Flora boreali-Aniericana, ' ' see
Miehaux
Florida Everglades, 178
Flotation, means, 358, 360
Flowers, reproduction, 98-9; ill., 99
see Color, Insects
Fluted scale, see Scale
Fly, see Hessian, Mimicry
Flying lizards, see Pterodactyls
Food changes in body, 294-(5
Foot and mouth disease, 409
Foot binding, 244
Foraminifera, 352
fossil, 120
shells, 92
Forced movements, see Tropism
Forests, hardwood, swamp, dis'.ri-
})ution, 178
Fortuitous, see Variation
Fossil, see Algae, Annelid, Centi-
pede, Coral, Crustacea, For-
aminifera, Insects, Inverte-
brates, Land plant. Lung-
fish, Nautilids, Ostracoderm,
Kadiolaria, Scorpion, Shark,
Snail, Spider, Trilobite,
Vulture, Worm
Four o 'clock, see Inheritance
Fowl, Andalusian, see Inheritance
rumpless, sec Mutation
Fowls, sex determination, see
Birds
Fox farming, 425; sec Arctic,
Red
Fox-tail p!ne, distribution, 172
Franklin, Benjamin, 349
Sir John, 36, 37, 381
Frog, artificial parthenogenesis,
329
cleavage cell experiments, 192
color changes, 333
grafting, ill. 195-6
regeneration, 193
8ex determination, 230
survival in ice, 381
Frog, see Intercrossing
I'^rwit files, see Drfisojdiila
i'^undulus, mating reactions, 314
Fungus and fish eggs, 428, 430
Fur farming, see Fox
G
Galen, 470
Galton, 269
Game and Bird reservations, 420,
423
Gametophyte, see Algae; Alterna-
tion of generations ; Ferns,
reproduction ; Reproduction
Gammarus, light response, 315
Gardens, see Zoological and Bo-
tanical
Gar pike, destruction, 119
Genetics, practical value, 266 et
seq.
Geographical distribution, see U.
S. Biological Survey
Geographic race, see Species
Geotropism, plants, 308, 311
Generations, see Alternation
Gephyrea, sex determination, 232-
233
Germ cells, see Sex cells
Germ layers, 105
Giant club mosses, see Lycopods
Giant condor, 148
Giant sloth, 146
Giant wolf, 148
Gigantactus, 355
Gilbert, 43
Gill, 54
Gills, see Amphioxus; Balanoglos-
sus ; Cyclostomes ; Fish ;
Lungfish ; Man ; Stegoce-
phala, larvae ; Tunicates ;
Vertebrates
Girard, 39
Glaciers, influence, see Plants
Glands, mouth, ferment, 295
see Adrenal; Internal secretion;
Kidney; Liver; Pancreas;
Sex; Thyroid; Tunicates,
structure
Glanders, field mice immune, 447
Glandular extracts, see Biological
remedies
Globigerina, invariability, 120
ooze, 352
Gk)chidium, 436; ill. 435
Glycogen, storage, 296
Goat, sec Rocky Mountain
Goddard, quoted, 270-1
494
Index
Goldberger, 476
Goldfinch, color, 343
Goldfish, see Japanese
Goklschmidt, 233
Gonorrhea, extent, 445
Goosefish, as food, 435
Gopher, see Ground Squirrels, Owls
Gorgas, 452-3
Grafting experiments, 194-8
Grampus, 351
Grapple-dredge, 365, 370
Grassi, 450
tJray, and Darwin, 45, 46; ill. 42
Grayfish, see Shark
Gray snapper, 348; wolf, distri-
bution, 174
Great-horned, see Owl
Great Plains, tension line, 182
Great Salt Lake, 76-8, 157
Grosbeak, see Rose-breasted
Ground, sloth, 148
squirrels, damage, 393
destruction, 400, 402
distribution, 177, 182
ill., 401
see Owls, Plague
Growth, 279, 280, 361 ; see Rat
Guano, 298
Guinea pigs, sex determination, 209
see Inheritance
Gulf stream, 349, 353
Gulick, 255-6; quoted, 255
Gynandromorph, 210; ill. 209
Gypsy moth, control, 406
introduction, spread, 385
ill. 386
see Sex intergrades
H
Hemoglobin, 330, 334, 445
Haemophilia, 214, 273
Hagfish, see Bdellostoma, Myxine
Hairless Dog, 240
Haiselden, 277
Hare lip, 272
Harris, 444
Harrison, 195, 199
Harvey, 479
Harvard College, 47, 49, 50
University, see Bussey Institu-
tion
Hatteria, see Tuatara
Havana, 111., Biological Station,
71
Cuba, sanitation, 453-4
Hayes, 54
Hawaiian Islands, topography, 254
snails, isolation, 254-6
Hawks, 161
benefits from, 388, 390
ired-tailed, 390; ill. 388
Head, see Vertebrate
Heat, see Animal
Heiscr, 441
Heliconidse, see Mimicry
Heliotropism, 313 et seq.
Hemiptera, see Color, warning
Hens, see Selection, Diet
Hensen net, 373-5; ill., 374
Hermaphroditism, 98, 103, 210,
231-2
Heron, R., 346
Heron, see Egret
Hesperornis, 40, 131; ill. 132
Hessian fly, introduction, damage,
385
Hibernation, 296
Hippocrates, 320, 470
' ' History of American Birds, ' ' see
Baird, Brewer, Ridgway
Hitchcock, 125
Hog cholera, 409
Holmes, Oliver Wendell, 268, 444
Holmes, S. J., quoted, 304
Holoptychius, 123
Hopper, see Leaf, Tree
Hooded rat, selection, ill. 238
Hookworm, abundance, 466
control, 466, 469
effect, 464
experiments on infection, 465-
466
life historv, 466
ill. 465, 468-9
Hooker, 44
Hopkins, C. G., 238
Hopkins, F. G., 292
Hormones, 314, 320; sex, 325
Hornaday, 63
Horned toad, distribution, 177,
184; ill. 183
Hornless cattle, see Inheritance,
cattle; Mutation
Hornwort, 382
Horse, evolution, 40, 149
extinct, 148
extinction, 149
migration, 149
Horse-tail ferns, see Ferns
Hospital, see Barnard, Hunting-
ton
Howard, quoted, 453
Hudsonian zone, 174 _
Index
495
Human, Jiiachiiie, economy, 285
use of fuel, 294
nutrition, 285 et scq.
Hume, 235
Humming-birds, distribution, 185
Humboldt, 38, 450
Valley, see Mouse plague
Huntington, 77, 79, 81; hospital,
472
Huronian period, life, 117
Huxley, 40
Hyatt, 69
Hybrid infertility, 252
Hybridization, see Cotton, Muta-
tion, Orange
Hydatina senta, 232
Hydra, 92; grafting, 194-5
regeneration, 192-3
reproduction, control, 233, 327
structure, 103
Hydrolysis of food, 295
Hydromedusse, indeterminate devel-
opment, 192
Hygiene, see Industrial, Social
Hyoid, see Vertebrates, structure
Hypophysis, see Vertebrates
Ice age, 143
Ichneumon, see Mongoose
Ichthyornis, 40, 131
Identical twins, 228
Illinois Eiver, plankton, 383
Illinois State Laboratory of Nat-
ural History, 377
Images, see Memory
Immorality, sex, 270-2
Immunity, practices, theories, 447-
448
Imperial elephant, 148
Impulse, see Nervous
Inbreeding, see Rat
Incas, marriage customs, 85
Indian Plague Commission, 458
Indiana, see Sterilization
Industrial Hygiene, 476-7
Infertility, see Hybrid
Influenza, experiments, 476
work of U. S. Public Health
Service, 475-6
Inheritance, 478; acquired char-
acters, 244-5
Andalusian fowl, 259-60; ill. 259
beans, pure lines, 236-7
blending, 258-64
cattle, color, 260; horns, 267-8;
ill. 267
Inlicritance, corn, 261-3
Drosophila, 260-1
four o'clock, 258-9; ill. 258
guinea pigs, 261, 263, 267; ill.
261-2
kinds, 257
man, color, 264-5
examples, 270, et scq.
Meudelian, 203, et scq. 257 et
scq., 479
Motaphyta, 257
Metazoa, 257
oats, 263
peas, 203-5, 263 ; ill. 205
Protista, 257
rabbits, 265-6; lop-eared, 261.
263; ill. 260
ratios, expected and realized,
264-6
segregation, 261, 264
shepherd's purse, 265
see Chromosomes, Selection
Inland waters, see Biology
Inoculation, see Smallpox
Inscctivores, 138
Insects, fossil, 124
larvffi, oxygen requirements, 380
ireactions, 312, et seq.
relation to flowers, 330-2
sex determination, 209, 230-1
see Hawks, Instinct, Isolation,
Mimicry, Scale, Sexual Se-
lection
Instincts, ants, 316
birds, 319-20
fish, 314
insects, 319
mammals, 319
pigeons, sexual, 314-5
see Ammojjhila
Institute, see Carnegie, Phipps,
Eockefeller, Wistar
Institution, see Bussey, Scripps,
Smithsonian
Intercrossing, salamander and
frog, sea urchin and star-
fish, 253
Internal secretions, 320, 361; see
Glands, Salmon, life history
Internal perfecting principle, 234
International Council for Inves-
tigation of the Sea, 349,
360, 482
Intestine, see Absorption, Diges-
tion
Introduction, animals and plants,
410 et scq.
Invertebrates, ancestral, 104
496
Index
I ir crlebnites, dispersal, 155
fossil, 117
iiiifxration. 154
Tr^fl'Ti, srr Thyroid
IrritaVilitv, characteristic of life,
282
Trvmsr. rjuoterl, 153
Ls:ilati()ii, arthropods, liird lice,
birds, butterflies, 253
frcofjraphic, 252-6
habitudiual, insects, 253
kinds, 252
structural, temporal, 253
Isthmus, see Behring, Panama
Kelvin, Lord, 363-4
"Kentucky Warbler," quotation,
24-5
Kerona, 92
K'dney, excretion, 322
Kimball, quoted. 268-9
Kinetic drive, 321-5
King, 85, 194
King crab, ill. 1 17
Kings College, 50
Kissinger, 452
Kiwi, see Aptervx
Koch, 440, 480
Kofoid, 306, 383
Krascheninikov, 426
Jackass, see Hybrid
Jack rabbit, see Rabbit
James, 34
Japanese goldfish, fins, 112
Jaws, see Vertebrates, structure
Javs, distribution. 177
Jefferson, contributions to bio-
logy, 34
corresnondence with Buffon,
with W=star, 33
interes's, 32
L(>\vis and Clark expedition, 32
pioneer plant importer, 33-4
+-•■'"' o from Bryant, 33
ill. 35
Jell>tish, see Medusa
Jenner, 442
Jennings, 88, 237, 242, 305-6;
quoted, 301-3
Jochmann, 448
Johannsen, 236-7
Johns Hopkins University, see De-
partment of Embryology
Jordan, 43, 88, 252
Juday, 380, 382
Judd, 347, 392
Jukes, 270
K
Kalacoon, see Tropical Research
.Station
Kallikaks, 270
Kullima, camouflage, 337-8; ill.
337
Kane, 54
Kangaroo, see Marsupial
Kant, 235
Katabolism, see Metabolism
Kellogg, quoted, 317-8
Laboratories, biological, see Bus-
sey, Carnegie, Marine Bio-
logical Laboratory, Rocke-
feller, Scripps, Wistar
Laboratory, biological equipment,
52
see Eugenics
Labyrinthodont tooth, see Stego-
cephala
Lacey Act, 392
Ladybird beetle, see Vedalla
Lahontan, see Lake
La Jolla, Calif., see Scripps Insti-
tution
Lake beaches, old, 78, 80
Bonneville, 76, 77
Lahontan, 76, 79
Minnewaukon, 79, 119
Mono, 79
Owens, 79, 80
Pyramid, 79
Winnemucca, 79
Lakes, disappearance, 78-80, 160
Lamarck, 244, 249
Land bridges, 143
Lantz, quoted, 154, 393-8
Lapland longspur, distribution,
168
Lark bunting, distribution, 182
Larva, see Echinoderms, Molluscs,
Trocophore, Tunicates,
Worms
Larvas, see Mosquitoes
Larynx, see Vertebrates, structure
Latency, see Recessiveness
Lateral fin fold theory, 111-2, 120
Lateral line, see Stegocephala
Lathrop, 414
Laurentian period, 117
Index
497
Lavoisier, 283-4
Lawrence, 44
Lazear, 450; ill. 451
Leaf -cutting ant, see Ant
Leaf hopper, 407
Lees, inheritance, 273
Lefevre, 436
Leidy, 54, petty rivalries, remi-
niscences, 42
work, 38, 39, ill. 41
Lemming, distribution, 172
color control, 222
see Mice, migration
Lens, regeneration experiments,
193-4
Lepers, care, 477
Lesquereux, 43
Le Sueur, 31, 54
Leucosticte, distribution, 168
Lewis and Clark expedition, 32
Lice, see Trench fever
bird, see Isolation
Life, characteristics, 278 et seq.
energy, 281
explanation, 479
origin, 117, 479
oxidation, 280
see Metabolism, Motility, Proto-
plasm, Eeproduction, Ee-
sponses
Life zones. North America, 163 ct
seq.
see TJ. S. Biological Survey
Light, apparatus, 367
in sea, 354, 367-8
machine, 312
production; see Animals, phos-
phorescence
response, see Daphnia
Lillie, 191
Limber pine, distribution, 175
Limbs, see Vertebrates
Linin, see Mitosis
Linkage, 211, et seq.
Lion, see Sexual Selection
Lister, 443
Liver, excretion, 322
ferment, 295, 321
Liverworts, alternation of gen-
erations, 99
reproduction, 99
Lizards, distribution, 177
flying, see Pterodactyls
Lobster, regeneration, 193
LockjaAv, see Tetanus
Loeb, 86, 88, 305, 309-10, 317, 327-
328
quoted, 311, 313-6, 319
Longley, 348
Jjongspur, see Lapland
Looss, 465
Lop-eared rabbit, see Inheritance
Low, 450
Lull, 146; quoted, 137
Lungfish, Australian, 120
blood vessels, 89
distribution, 114
fossils, 120
habits, 114
relation to fish and amphibian,
114
structure, 114
ill. 112
Lungs, see Lungfish, Birds
Luther, quoted, 33
Lycopods, 122
Lyell, 44; quoted, 154-5
Lynx, see Canada
M
Macauley family, inheritance, 273
MacDougal, 245
MacDoAvell, 251
Magpie, distribution, spread, 182
Malaria, organism, life cycle, 97
see Mosquitoes
Mall, 83, 228
Mammals, development, cause, 137
Eocene, 138
classification, distribution, see
U. S. Biological Survey
extinction, cause, 145
grafting, 196-8
hermaphroditic, 210
Mesozoic, 136, 138
origin, 135
recent, 142
regeneration, 193
relation to Dinosaurs, 136-7; ill.
137
sex determination, 230
sex linked inheritance, 214
see Chromosomes, Hawks, In-
stinct, Owls
Man, development, 105j 282
monstrosities, cause, 228 ; . ill.
229-30
polydactylism, 240, 242
regeneration, 193
sex determination, 209, 230
sex linked inheritance, 214
syndactylism, 242
see Inheritance, color
Mango, 416, 417; ill. 416
498
Index
Mantis, ser Alluring resemblance;
ill. 338
Mare, sec ITybrid
Marine Biological Laboratory,
buildings, G9
environiiiont, 71
founded, 69
Avork, CO, 70
ill. 68, 69
Marine Biological Stations, Eu-
rope, 340; U. S., see De-
partment Marine Biology,
Marine Biological Labora-
tory, Scripps Institution
Marine Hospital, see IT. S.
Marmot, sec Woodcliuck
Marsh, 145; discoveries, 40, 131
expeditions, 39
meeting with Huxley, 40
reminiscences by Osborn, 42,
145
ill. 41
Marsupials, 138; distribution, 139,
140, 186
Martin, 425; distribution, 174
Massachusetts State Board of
Health work, 377, 381
Mast, 88
Mastodon, 34, 84
Mating reactions, sec Fundulus,
Pigeon
Maturation, 203-6, 209-10
Mayas, civilization, see Hunting-
ton
Mayer, 88
Mayow, 283
Meadow mice, see Mice
Meadow mouse, see Microtus
Measles, see Immunity
Mechanism, explanation of life,
278 et seq. 479
Medical Eesearch, see Kockefellcr
Institute
Medusa, 348, 358; alternation of
generations, 100
Memory images, 319-20
Mendel, 202-3
Mendelian characters, experi-
mental control, 220
see Inheritance
Mendelism, see Inheritance
Menhaden, food, industry, 372
Meningitis, 447-9
Merino sheep, mutant, 239
Merriam, C. Hart, 88, 163
Merriam, J. C, quoted, 147
Mesozoic era, life, 125-7, 135, et
seq.
Metabolism, 279-80, 294, et seq.
fish, 301 ; sec Food changes
Metamerism, 105
Motapliyta, 89 ; see Inheritance
Metazoa, 89, 103 ; compared with
Protozoa, 201; sec Inherit-
ance
Meters, see Current
Motschnikoff, 200-1, 480
Meyer, 415
Miacidfc, 142
Mice, climate, influence, 248
damage, 393-6
deer, California races, distribu-
tion, 176-7
influence of environment, ill. 250
field, house, see Glanders
meadow, distribution, 176; ill.
394-5
migration, 154
variation, experimental, 249
see Hawks, Mouse plague. Owls,
Sumner, Weismann
Michaux, 32
Michigan University, 50
Microtus, see Mice, meadow
Middle ear, see Vertebrates, struc-
ture
Miescher, 207, 208
Miossner, quoted, 312 ,
Migraine, 271-2
Migration, bird laws, 392
see Animals, aquatic; Dispersal;
Barriers; Bison; Birds;
Eel; Fish; Mice; Octopus;
Plaice ; Rat ; Salmon ;
Shad; Whales
Miller, 222
Mimicry, 339, et seq.
Mimosa, reaction, ill. 308
Minnewaukon, see Lake
Mink, 174, 425; ill. 424
Miocene epoch, 254
Mirabilis, see Inheritance, four
o 'clock
Miscarriage, see Mulatto
Missouri Botanical Garden,
founded, 63-4; work, 64
Mite, see Scab
Mitosis, 203, 206; abnormal, see
('ancer
radium, influence, 248
ill. 204
Moa, 135; distribution, 139
Moina, swarms, 383
Moles, see Owls
Molluscs, 352; flotation, 358, 360
hermaphroditic, 210
Index
499
Molluscs, larva, 105
over -wintering, 381
Monaco, Prince, 373
Monad, 90, 95, 98
Monarch butterfly, sec Color,
warning ; Mimicry
Mongoose, 402-4
Monkey, transport, 155; see Adap-
tation
Mono, see Lake
Monotremes, 140
Monsters, see Cyclopean Fish
Montague, 447
Moose, distribution, 174
Morgan, 88, 189, 202, 210; Stylo-
nichia, 95-6
Morphin, narcotic, 322, 324-5
Morphology, problems, 89
Mosaic, structure of egg, 190
Mososaurs, 129
Mosquitoes, Anopheles, malaria,
97
control, 454-5
disease, early ideas, 450
larvae, 378
malaria, 449-50
yellow fever, 450-2
Mosses, alternation of generations,
reproduction, 99
spermatozoa, chemical attrac-
tion, 327
Moth, brown-tail, 155 ; control,
4U6-7, parasites, 407
gypsy, 155; control, 40G-7
parasites, 407
sex-determination, 210
sex-linked inheritance, 214
silkworm, China, 410
color, protective; see Gypsy,
Mimicry
Motility of life, 280-1; non-life,
281
Mountain lion, see Puma
Mountain beaver, see Sewellel
Mountain sheep, distribution,
174
Mouse, plague, IGl, 388, 390
see Mice
Movement, see Motility
Mulatto, hybrid; see Inheritance,
man
Mule, see Hybrid
Muller, 330
Multiple factors, 263-4
Murray, quoted, 156
Murtrie, 31
Museum, U. S. National; see U. S.
National
Museum of Natural History, see
American Museum
Musk ox, distribution, 172; ill.,
170
Muskrat, 425; distribution, 176
Mussel, destruction, 435
life history, propagation, 436
shells, use, 435
Mutants, see Mutation
Mutation, 239, et scq.
ill. 239-40
Myriapods, sex determination, 209
Myxine, hermaj)hrodilism, 210
N
Niigeli, 203, 243
Nanno -plankton, see Plankton,
counting
Nansen, 366
Natural History Surveys, State,
37
Nautilids, 117
National Park Service, 420; see
Yellowstone
Natural History Laboratory, see
Illinois, Wisconsin
Natural, see Selection
Negro, susceptibility to disease;
see Tuberculosis
yellow fever color, see Inheri-
tance, man, color
Nematodes, sex determination,
209; see Sex cycle
Neoceratodus, invariability, 120
"Nero," 352
Nerve, facial, relation to muscle;
see Vertebrates
fibre development, 195-9
Nervous impulse, 318, 322
system, 312
see Eat
Nets, see Tow, Closing, Hensen
Nevill, 292
New Jersey Pine Barrens, 178
Training School, 85, 270
New Orleans, see Plague control
New York, Aquarium, see Zoologi-
cal Society
Botanical Garden, 65; ill. 64
Skin and Cancer Hospital, 472
State Board of Health, see
Cancer Laboratory
State Institute for Study of
Maligant Disease, 473
Zoological Garden, see Zoological
Society
500
Index
New Zealand, inhabitants, 120-1,
133, 135, 139
Night hawk, color, 33G
ill. 335
Nilssou-Ehle, 263
Nissl bodies, 318
Nitrites, 298
Nitrogen, fixation, alfalfa, beans,
peas, 298; sources, 297-8
in water, 383
Non-life, see Adaptation
No])sca, 134
North America, see Michaux, Sil-
va
Nortli Dakota, see Devils Lake;
Public Health Laboratory
Notochord, see Balanoglossus,
Tunicates, Amphioxus, Ver-
tebrates
Nott, 450
Nuclein, see Protoplasm
Nucleus, algffi, 94-5, 189, 202-3
origin, 480
see Paramctcium
Nutrition, see Human
Nutrition Laboratory, see Carne-
gie Institution
Nuttall, T., 34; ill. 35
G. H. v., 438
f
O
Oats, see Inheritance
Ocean, depth, 351-2
environment, 353
floor, composition, 352-3
life, 353
light, 354
pressure, 353-4
Oceanography, scope, 351
Octopus, destruction, 156, 358
migration, 154
ill. 356
Odcjr, see Water
CKnothera, .see Mutation
Onchorhynchus, see Salmon
Ooze, see Foraminifera, Pteroi)od,
Radiolaria
Operations, see Antisepsis, Ca;sa-
rean
Opossum, see Marsupial
Orange, hybridization, 268
Orbulina, invariability, 120
Orchestia, sex determination, 233
Ordovician period, life, 117-8, 120
Organ-forming substances, 189-91,
202; ill. 190
Oragnic, see Dust
Organism, see Adaptation
Organisms, destruction, see Pools,
temporary
growth, 480
marine, quantitative determina-
tion, 371 et seq.
size, 480
Orientation, see Tropism
Origin, see Life
' ' Origin of 82)ecies, ' ' 44, 45, 235,
343
Ortliogenesis, 256; see Evolution
Osborn, 42-3, 54, 88, 134, 145;
quoted, 235
Osmosis, 279-80, 295, 299
influence on heliotropism, 316
ill. 279
Osterhout, 318
Ostracoderms, 117-8; ill. 118
Ostrich, distribution, 139
Ovary, see Reproduction
Ovists, 189
Owen, 39
Owens, see Lake
Owl, great -horned, food, 390
barn, food, 390; ill. 389
Oxidation, see Life
Oxydizing ferment, 296
Oxygen, carriage by blood, 322
content of water in summer, 382
in winter, 379-80
discovery, 283
phos])horescenee, 355
relation to aquatic animals, 380
Oysters, food, 353
Pacific R. R. Surveys, 37-8, 44
Paget, 470
Palaeozoic era, climate, 137
Panama, Canal, sanitation, 452,
453
Isthmus, barrier, 254
Pancreas activator, 321
in diabetes, 320
ferment, 295, 299, 321
Pangenesis, 202
Paramecium, 93, 327; life cycle,
200-1
reactions, 305-6, 310-2
reproduction, 96, 200
structure, 305
see Pure lines
Parasynapsis, 215
Parker, 312
Parrakeet, distribution, 25, 180
Parrot, see Parrakeet
Index
501
Parry, 36
Parthenogenesis, 479
artificial, 328-9
see Sex cycle, Summer eggs
Partula, see Tahiti
Pasteur, 440, 480
Pavlov, 88
Peacock, extinct, 148; see Sexual
selection
Pearl, 237, 251-2, 294
I'eary, 54
Peas, see Inheritance, Nitrogen
fixation
Peck, 372
Peebles, 194
Pellagra, cause, 293, 476; symp-
toms, 293
Penikese, see Agassiz, L.
Pennsylvania University, 50, 84
Pennsylvanian period, reptiles, 125
Peridinium, shell, ill. 92
Period, see Cambrian, Carbonifer-
ous, Devonian, Huronian,
Laurentian, Ordovieian,
Pennsylvanian, Permian,
Silurian, Trlasslc
Permian period, climate, earth
changes, 125
Peromyscus, see Mice, deer
Perroncito, 465
Persimmon, 415
Pheasant, see Ring-necked
Philadelphia, scientific center, 50,
53
zoological garden, see Zoological
Philippines, see I'lague Control
Phipps, Institute, 86
Phororachis, 135
Phosphorescence, see Animals,
oxygen
Photometer, see Light apparatus
Photosynthesis, 81
Phytolacca, see Poke-weed
" Phytogeography of Nebraska,"
158
Pickerel, see Devils Lake
Pierida;., see Mimicry
Pigeon, mating reactions, 314-5
Pigment, 332-3; bile, 334
Pika, distribution, 168, 174
Pilobolus, spore discharge, 307
Pine Barrens, see New Jersey
Pine, see Fox-tail, Limber, Piiiou,
Yellow
Piuon pine, distribution, 176
Pipit, distribution, 168
Pistache tree, ill. 415
Pituitary, influence on growth, 321
see Vertebrates, hypophysis
Pituitrin, see Biological remedies
Placoid scale, 134
Plaice, migration, 360
Plague, bubonic, bacillus, 458
control, 460-1
and fleas, 457-8
ground squirrels, 460-1
history, 457
and rats, 457-61
and woodchi'.cks, 461
see Mouse ; Rat, parasites
Plankton, collection, 370 ct seq.
counting, 375-7
l)ulses, 383
relation to other organisms, 372-
373
see Illinois River
Plantain weed, see Sex intergrades
Plant Industry, see U. S. Bureau
Plants, alternation of generations,
100-1
aquatic, overwintering, 382
compared with animals, 297
dispersal, 157-8
distribution, 164, et seq.
interrelation with aninuUs, 161;
With plants, 160
introduction, 412, et seq.
reactions, 307-11
regeneration, 193
societies, 158, 160
stems, unequal growth, ill. 310-1
succession, 158-60
see Circulation; Conduction;
Pools, temporary
Plastic Surgery, 197; ill. 198
Plato, 269
I'lelstocene epoch, climate and
mamnuils, 143, 174
Pleuroi)neumonia, cattle, inocula-
tion, 447
Pliny, 192, 320, 402
Pliocene epoch, migration of mam-
mals, 174
Plunmge laws, 422
Pocket gopher, destruction, 400,
402
ill. 402
Poke-weed, influence of environ-
ment, 222
Polar bear, color, 338
distribution, 172
1raiisj)ort, 155
ill. 169
Pollen, 331 ; see Flowers, reproduc-
t ion
i'olychu'ta, alternation of genera-
tions, 100-1
Polydactylism, see Man
502
Index
Polyphemus moth, grafting, 196
Polyzoa, alternation of genera-
tions, 101
Pomeroy family, inheritance, 273-
274
Pools, temporary, life of, 381-3
Porcupine, distribution, 174-5
Porthesia, response to light, 313-
314
Portuguese man of war, 358 ; ill.
357
Potato bug, see Beetles
Pound, 158
Powers, 223, 224
Prairie dog, 182; destruction, 400,
402
ill., 181
Preformation, 189
Pribilof, 431
Priestley, 283
Princeton College, 49
Principle, see Vital
Promethea moth, grafting, 19G
Protective color, see Color
Proteid, digestion, energy produc-
tion, 296
see Diet
Prothallus, see Ferns, reproduction
Protoplasm, 296-7
analysis, 278
chemistry, 207
composition, 480
structure, 480
Protophyta, 89; specialization, 94,
95
reproduction, 95, et seq.
Protococcaeeae, 95
Protozoa, 89 ; alternation of gen-
erations, 101-3
colonial, 95
compared with Metazoa, 201
conjugation, 96
fertilization, 96
immortality, 200
interrelation, 93-4
mode of life, 92-3
primitive type, 95
nervous system, 306-7
nucleus, 480
organs, 92
oxygen requirement, 380
related to disease, 440
reproduction, 95, 96, 103
shells, 92
specialization, 90-4
ill. 90-1
see Amoeba, Paramcecium, etc.
Ptarmigan, distribution, color, 168
ill. 166-7
Pteranodon, 130
Pterodactyls, resemblance to birds,
130-1
structure, 129-31
Pteropod, 352; ooze, 353
Ptolemies, marriage customs, 85
Puberty, 325
Public Health Laboratory, N. D.,
381
Puerperal fever, 444
Puma, distribution, 176
transport, 155
Puunett, 88
Pure lines, selection, 236-7, 242-
243
ill. 237
Ptyalin, 279
Pyramid, see Lake
E
Rabbit, damage, 396
cottontail, ill. 397
jack, damage, destruction, 402
Porto Santo, 222-3
see Inheritance, Eecognition
marks, Snowshoe
Rabies, spread by wolf and coyote,
399
Raccoon, distribution, 176
Race, see Species
Radiolaria, 360; fossils, 117
ooze, shells, 92
ill. 352
Radium, see Cancer, Evening prim-
rose
Rafinesque, meets Audubon, 28
career, 30-1
description, 28-30
evolution, 30
fossil jellyfish, 30
ill. 29
Rana, see Frog
Rand, 194
Ranunculus, see Crowfoot
Rat, colony, see Wistar
damage, 396-8
diet, 292
growth, 84
inbreeding, 85
introduction, 387
nervous system, 84
parasites, 387
sex determination, 209
spread, 153-5, 387
ill. 399
see Cotton, Hawks, Hooded,
Kangaroo, Owls, Plague,
Rice
Index
503
Eeactions, see Amoeba, Bacteria,
Compass plant, Crustacea,
Daphnia, Diaptomus, Dros-
era, Flagellates, Fundulus,
Geotropism, Heliotropism,
Insects, Mimosa, Paramoe-
cium. Pigeon, Plants, Por-
thesia, Rheotropism, Sten-
tor, Tropism, Unicellular
Realms, see Zoogeographic
Recapitulation, 105
Recessiveness, 258
Recognition marks, 342
Red cedar, distribution, 176
Red Cross, work, 476
Red-eyed Vireo, migration, spread,
182
Red fox, distribution, 174
Reducing division, 205-6, 215, 216
Redwood, see Sequoia
Reed, J. A., Senator, quoted, 422
W., Dr., 451
quoted, 452
ill. 451
Reese, 88; quoted, 466
Refractive index, see Blood serum
Regeneration, 192-4, 480
Reighard, 348
Rejuvenation, see Protozoa, con-
jugation
Religion, see Science
Repair, living matter, see Metab-
olism
Reproduction, asexual, 98
characteristic of life, 282, 325,
327
non-life, 282, 327
sexual, 98
see Algae, Ferns, Flowers, Liver-
worts, Mosses, Paramoecium,
Protophyta, Protozoa
Reptiles, extinct, 125 et seq.
extinction, 127, 136
spread, 154
see Sex cells, origin
"Research Methods in Ecology,"
158
Resemblance, see Aggressive, Al-
luring
Reservations, see Game
Responses of life, of non-life, 282
Resting bodies, animals, plants,
382
Resting, see Sex cycle, daphnids
Reversion, see Inheritance, kinds
Rhamphorhynchus, 130; ill. 129
Rhea, distribution, 139
Rheotropism, roots, 308
Rhumbler, 88
Rhyncocephalia, invariability, 121,
ill. 121
see Tuatara
Ribot, quoted, 257
Ribs, see Abdominal Vertebrate,
head
Rice, polished, see Beriberi
rat, distribution, 178
Richardson, 31, 37
Riddle, 232
Ridgway, 44
Ring -necked pheasant, 411
Ritter, 88, quoted, 72-3
Rockefeller, Foundation, 466
Hookworm Commission, 467
Institute for Medical Research,
73, 86, 448
see Hookworm control
Rock thrush, see Sexual selection
Rocky Mountain goat, distribution,
174
Rodents, damage, 393 et seq.
destruction, 400, 402
Rose-breasted grosbeak, color, 343
Rotifer, 105, 381; eggs, 382
see Sex cycle
Rotation of crops, see Nitrogen
fixation
Ruppia, see Ditch-grass
S
Saber-toothed tiger, see Smilodon
Sahara, barrier, 254
Salamander, light influence, 227
see Amblystoma, Intercrossing
Salmon, canning, data, 428-9
catching, 427-8
fecundity, 427, 430
life history, 426-7
migration, 156, 360-1
propagation, 429-31
spawning, 427
see Sexual selection
Salton Sea, 76-7
Salvarsan 447
Salvia, ill. 331; see Insects, rela-
tion to riowers
Sambon, 450
Sand hopper, see Orchestia
San Francisco, Mountains, life
zones, 163 et seq.
profile, 163
see Plague
Sargasso Sea, 353
Sargassum weed, 353
504
Index
Sargent, 67
Say, 34
San Jose, see Scale
Scab mites, 409
Scale, insects, 391; control, 405-6
fluted, 405
San Jose, ill. 403-6
Scales, see Fish, Placoid
"Scalp Act," Pennsylvania, 390
Scarlet Tanager, color, 343
molt control, 225-6
ill. 226
Schmidt, 363
Science and Religion, 45
Scripps Institution, 351 ; location,
71
support, work, 71-2
Scudder, 43
Scurvy, cause, prevention, 293
Scorpions, fossil, 124
Scott, W. E. D., reminiscences, 44,
88
quoted, 138, 140, 145, 174-5
Screw worm, 409 ; ill. 408
Sea anemone, see Motility
Sea cucumber, regeneration, 193
Sea island cotton, hybridization,
268
Sea-squirt, see Tunicates
Sea urchin, artificial parthenogene-
sis, 329
cross fertilization, 328
union of egg and sjterm, 327
see Intercrossing
Seal, controversy, 432-4
destruction, 433
discovery, 431
distribution, 172
killing, 433
life history, 432
profits, 432
ill. 433
Sebright poultry, secondary sex-
ual characters, 325; ill. 326
Secondary sexual characters, 325
Secretion, see Internal, Sex glands
Sedgwick-Rafter method, 376
Seed, chemical treatment, struc-
ture, 245
Segregation, see Inheritance
Selection, 266, 330, 334; natural,
235-9
see Sexual
Sensitive plant, see Mimosa
Sequoia, climate, 77
gigantea, sempervirens, distribu-
tion, 184-5
ill. 185
Serum, meningitis, 448-9
tetanus, 449
see Anti-human, Blood, Diph-
theria
Sewellel, distribution; ill. 186
Sex, 89; beginnings, 96
cells, 203-0
origin, 471
union, 327-8
chromosomes, see Sex determina-
tion
control, 232
cycle, bee, 230-31
daphnids, 231
rotifers, 231
determination, 208-10, 228, 230-3
see Birds, Crustacea, Gephy-
rea, Orchestia
differentiation, 97, 103
function, 479
glands of fish, secretion, 361
inheritance, 479
intergrades, Daphnia, gypsy
moth, plantain weed, Sinio-
cephalus, 233
linked, see Linkage
nematodes, 231-2
organs, see Hydra, Vaucheria
origin, 471, 479; see tancer
theories
Protozoa, 96-8
ratio, see Rat, inbreeding
see Hormones, Immorality,
Secondary sexual characters
Sexual characters, see Secondary,
selection, 343-6
Shad, migration, 156, 361
propagation, 426
Shagreen denticles, see Sharks,
scales
Sharks, as food, 435
fossil, 120
Port Jackson, 133
scales, 120
Sheep, see Ancon, Merino, Moun-
tain
Shells, see Diatoms, Desmids, Pro-
tozoa
Shrews, see Owls
Shull, A. P., 232
G. H., 265
Siamese twins, 228 ; ill. 229
Sigsbee, see Sounding
Silkworm, see Moth
Silliman, 45, 50
Silurian period, lungfish, 120
"Silva of North America," 67
Simocephalus, see Sex intergrades
Index
505
Skein, see Mitosis
Skull, see Birds, Cyclostomes,
Head, Vertebrates
Skunk, 435; distribution, 17G
fur, 425
warning color, ill. 339
Sloth, see Giant, Ground
Slye, 472
Smallpox, inoculation, 442, 447
Indians, 441
Philippines, 441
Phila., 442
Boston, 441-2
N. D., 442-3
see Immunity, Vaccination
Smilodon, distribution, 145
extinction, 146
prey, 146-7
remains, 148
structure, 145-6
Smith, A. C, 450
Smith, L. H., 238
Smithsonian Institution, estab-
lished, 60
Snake venom, see Immunity
Snail, organ-forming substances,
191
fossil, 124
regeneration, 193
see Hawaiian, Tahiti, Cerion
Snow-bunting, distribution, 168
Snowshoe rabbit, distribution, 174
ill. 173
Social Hygiene Board, see U. S.
Society, see American Naturalists
and Geologists
Societies, see Plants
Solenhofen quarries, 131
Sonoran zone, 176, 178
Sounding apparatus, 363-5
Sparrows, weed destruction, 392
tree, 392
see English, Tree
Spawning, see Salmon
Species, defined, 327
and geographic races, 248
elementary, see Mutation
Sperm, union with egg, 327-8
see Reproduction, Spermatists
Spermatists, 189
Sphaerechinus, giant larva;, 192
Spiders, fossil, 124
Spinal cord, see Vertebrates, struc-
ture
Spiracle, see Fish
Spirifer, constancy, 95
Sponges, Statoblasts, 382
see Motility
Spores, function, see Reproduction
Sporophyto, see Reproduction
Sporozoa, 93
Sports, see Mutation
Spruce, distribution, 172
see Douglas
Squid, see Octopus
Squirrel, transport, 155
see Ground
St. Hilaire, 235, 239
Stag, see Sexual selection
Stamen, see Flowers, reproduction
Starch, synthesis, 81, 297
digestion, 279
storage in plants, 299
Starfish, regeneration, 193
see Cross fertilization, Inter-
crossing
State Board of Health, see Massa-
chusetts
Stations, see Biological
Statoblasts, see Sponges, Bryozoa
Stegocephala, 121; larvae, 124;
ill. 123
structure, 123-4
Stegomyia, 188; see Mosquitoes
Stegosaurus, brain, 113, 127
ill. 128
Steller, 426, 431
Stentor, structure, 306
reactions, 306-11
Stereoisomers, 207-8
Stereotropism, ants, 316-7
Sterilization laws, 275-6
Sternberg, 451
Sternum, see Birds, Pterodactyls
Stigma, see Flowers, reproduction
Stiles, 466-7
Stockard, 194, 227, 251-2
Stomach, ferment, 295
Stone, 88
Stout, 233
Streeter, 84
Struggle for existence, 90, 281,
353
Strychnin, see Crustacea, light re-
sponse
Stump Lake, N. D., 79
Styles, see Flowers, reproduction
Stylonichia, see Morgan
Sub-neural gland, see Tunicates,
structure
Sugar, 81, 299
cane, see Weevil
conduction in plants, 299, '
formed from starch, 279
metabolism, see Pancreas
synthesis, 81, 297
506
Index
Summer eggs, 382
Sumner, 249-50, 333
Sun dew, see Drosera
Sunfish, 358; ill. 359
Suprarenal, see Adrenal
Survey, U. S. Biological, 87;
geolographical distribution,
162
life zones of N. A., 163 c< seq.
U. S. Geological, 38
Surveys, state, 37; territories, 38
Survival, see Selection
Swainson, 31, 37
Swamping effect of crossing, 252
Swarming, bees, 317
Swarms, see Animals, aquatic
Symbiosis, see Algae
Syndactylism, see Man
Synura, odors in water, 378; ill.
378
Syphilis, diagnosis, 445-7
extent, 444-5
prevention, 446-7
Wassermann test, 445-7
see Blood serum
T
Tahiti, snails, isolation, environ-
ment, 255-6
Tanager, see Scarlet
Tanner, quoted, 156; see Sounding
Tapeworm, control, 464; life his-
tory, 463-4
Tar pools, contents, 148; origin,
147; ill. 148-9
Tarsier, 144-5; ill. 144
Tashiro, 318
Taste, see Water
Teeth, bird, embryo, 132
fossil, 131-2
crossopterygian, 123
mammalian, 134
Stegocephala, 123
Temperature, deep sea; see Birds,
Thermometers
Tension line, see Great Plains
Tern, homing instinct, 320; see
Arctic
Terrapin, diamond-back, value,
culture, 437
Tetanus, 444, 448; see Serum
Tevis, 413
Texas fever, see Tick
Thayer, 348
Thermometers, deep sea, 366-8
Thespesius, 127
Thinopus, see Amphibia, foot-
prints
Thompson, see Kelvin
Thought, 319, 325
Thyroid gland, internal secretion,
320-3
Thyroidin, see Biological remedies
Tick, cattle, life history, 407-8
control, damage, 409
ill. 408
Tigers and marsupials, 186; see
Smilodon
Tilefish, destruction, 119
Timberland lawsuit, see Cowles
Timberline, 172; ill. 168
Tissue growth, 200-1; ill. 199
Titmice, distribution, 177
Tooth enamel, pattern; see Teeth
Torry, 63, 65; Botanical Club, 65
Tower, 81, 245-6, 249
Tow-nets, 370; ill. 371
Townsend, C. H., 63
Townsend, J. K., 34, 54
Toxin, diphtheria, effect on brain,
324
Trachoma, 475
Tracks, see Dinosaur
Training school for feeble-minded,
see New Jersey
Transition zone, 175-6; ill. 174
Transpiration, 299
Transjjort of animals, see Boa con-
strictor. Crocodile, Mon-
keys, Polar bear, Puma,
Squirrel, Wolves
Trawling apparatus, 363-4, 369-
70; ill. 369
Tree-hopper, see Mimicry; ill, 341
Tree sparrow, see Sparrow
Trembley, 192, 194
Trench foot, 449; fever, 449
Treponema, see Syphilis
Trial and error, 305-6
Triassic period, mammals, 136
Triceratops, 184; brain, 127; ill.
128
Trichina, cause of disease, 461
life history, 461-3
ill. 462
see Eat, parasite
Trichocysts, 94
Trichodina, 92
Trilobites, age of, ill. 117
Trochosphffira, 105
Trochophore larva, 105; ancestral,
106
Index
507
Tropical Eesearch Station, Zoologi-
cal Society, N. Y., 63
Zone, 180
Tropisni theory, 309 et seq.
Tschermak, 203
Tuatara, 133
Tuberculosis, 409, 447; sanitarium,
477
see Blood serum
Tung oil tree, 415; ill. 413-4
Tunicates, alternation of genera-
tions, 100-1
development, 100
larva, 105
mouth, relation to Balanoglossus
and Vertebrates, 107
structure, 100-1, 377
see Organ-forming
"Tuscarora," 364
Twins, see Siamese; Identical
Tympanum, see Vertebrates, struc-
ture
Typhoid, 475, 448; see Flies, Im-
munity, Vaccination
U. S. Fish Commission, see U. S.
Bureau of Fisheries
U. S. Geological, sec Survey
U. S. National Museum, building,
60, ill. 61
collections, 39, 61
founded, 44
Avork, 61-2
TJ. S. Navy, ships, 349-50
U. S. Public Health Service, 459,
461, 466
work, 474-7
U. S. Social Hygiene Board, 476
Unit character, see Inheritance,
Mendelian
Universities, State, 50
University, see Buffalo, Columbia,
Johns Hopkins, Michigan,
Pennsylvania, Yale
Upland cotton, hybridization, 268
Urea, end product of metabolism,
296
Use and disuse, see Inheritance, ac-
quired characters
U
Udo, 414; ill. 411-2
Uintatherium, 142 ; ill. 141
Unicellular, animals, 352, 378
see Protozoa
organisms, see Plankton
reactions, 306, 309
plants, 378 ; see Protophyta
U. S. Biological Survey, 87
collections, 61, 248
established, 390
work, 162 et seq., 347, 391 et
seq., 420, 423, 461
U. S. Bureau of Animal Indus-
try, 87; collections, 61
work, 409, 464, 474
U. S. Bureau of Entomology, 87;
established, 405
work, 405-7, 409
U. S. Bureau of Fisheries, 87; col-
lections, 61
vessels, 156, 350-1, 365, 482-3
work, 350-1, 377, 426 ct seq.
U. S. Bureau of Plant Industry,
87; collections, 61
work, 412 et seq.
U. S. Bureau of Health, Philip-
pines, 441
U. S. Coast Survey, 349-50
U. S. Exploring Expedition, see
Wilkes
Vaccination, results, 441-2
opposition, 442-3
smallpox, 448
typhoid, 448-9
Vaccine, influenza, pneumonia, 476
preparation, 474-5; see Biologi-
cal remedies. Smallpox
Van Beneden, 203
Variation, cause, 243 et seq., 478
curve, ill. 241
fortuitous, 234
influence environment, 244 et
seq.
kinds, 242-3
see Geographic races. Selection
Vaucheria, sexual reproduction,
control, 233
Vedalia, 406
Velella, flotation, ill. 358
Venereal disease, control, 476; ex-
tent, 444-5
Vermin, damage, 393 et seq.
Vertebrates, embryos, ill. 104
ferments, 295
head, origin, 113-4
hermaphroditic, 210
hypophysis, 101
jaws, origin, 110-1
limbs, 112
mouth, 107, 110
508
Index
Vertebrates, nerve -inusclc relation,
115
segmentation, 110
strncture, 108, 110
see Aniphi])ians, Aniphioxus,
Balanoglossus, Cladosclache,
Cyclostonics, I'^volution, .la])-
anese pjoldfish, Lungfish,
Tnnicates
A^i^ceroj Initterflj, 342; ill. 340
Vireo, see Red-eyed
Virus, filterable, 481
Vitalism, 278 et seq., 479
Vital principle, 188, 278, 283
A'itamines, 293
Volvocaceae, 95
Volvox, structure, reproduction,
97-8
Volcanic, see Dust
Voles, see Mice
Vulture, fossil, 135
W
Wagner, 252
Walking st^ck insect, 337; ill. 336
Wallace, 155, 235, 330, 340
Warning, see Color
Wasps, see Mimicry
Wasp, solitary, see Ammophila
Wassermann, see Syphilis
Waste products, elimination, 322
Water, tastes, odors, 378
Water bottles, construction, ill.
368
Water-cress, 382; influence of en-
vironment, 222
Water supplies, examination, 377,
477
Water-weed, 382
Water-works, Boston, Brooklyn,
377
Waters, inland, cyclic changes, 379
et seq.
food relation, plants and ani-
mals, 383
Watson, 320
Weasel, distribution, 174; ill. 173
Web-footed chicken, 240
Weevil, sugar cane, 407
Weismann, 200, 202, 478; experi-
ments on mice, 244-5
Werber, 194, 227
Whales, and squids, 358
migration, 360
stomach contents, 377
use, 434-5
see Whalebone
Whalebone, 372-3; ill. 373
Wheel animalcule, see Rotifer
Whipple, 378
Whitefish, 426
Whitman, 314
Whitney, 232-3
Whooping cough, see Imnnmity
Wilder, 228
Wild pigeon, extinct, 420
William and Mary 's College, 49
Williams, 444
Wilkes exploring expedition, 38, 39,
54, 60, 349
Willey, 88
Wilson, Alexander, account of pas-
senger pigeon, 23-4
acquaintance with Bartram and
Lawson, 22
"American Ornithology," 22,
25
birthplace, 22
death, 22-3
early life, 22
emigration to America, 22
lines to the bluebird, 24
meeting with Audubon, 19
travels, 22
ill. 21
see ' ' Kentucky Warbler, ' '
Wilson, E. B., 88
Wilson E. H., 68
Winnemucca, see Lake
Wings, sec Birds
Winter eggs, 382; see Sex cycle
Wisconsin Natural History and
Geological Survey, 377
Wistar, 33, 84
Wistar Institute, 74; established,
84; work, 84-6
Wolf, see Giant
Wolff, 189
Wolverine, distribution, 174; ill.,
170
Wolves and antelope, 421
deer, 161
damage, 393
destruction, 400
marsupials, 186
transport, 155
ill. 401
see Gray, Rabies
Woodchuck, distribution, 168, 174;
ill. 172
see Plague
Woodland, caribou, distribution,
174
Woodruff, 200
Woods Hole, see Marine Biological
Laboratory
Index
509
Worms, oxygen rcciiiircMiciit, 380
Cf^gs, 382
fossils, 117
heniiuphroditic, 210
larva, 105
see Screw
Wright, quoted, 37
'^'ellow fever, e])i(leniic, Havana,
454
Negro, ininiuiiity, see Mosqui-
toes, 447
Yellow ])ine, distribution, 176
Yellowstone National Park, 420-1
Yolk lobe, sec Dentalium
Z
X-ray, see Cancer
Yale University, 49, 50
Yeast, enzyme, 295
Yellow fever. Commission, 188, 451
control, 452-4
Zone, see Canadian, Hudsonian,
Life, Sonoran, Transition,
Tropical
Zoogeographic realms, ill. 161-2
Zoological Gardens, 62
Park, U. S., 62
Philadelphia, 62
Society, N. Y., 62-3
Zoologists, American Society, 51
i