Skip to main content

Full text of "Butler Alumnal Quarterly"

See other formats




yjr ^'{ 

APRIL, 1926 


Entered as second-class matter March 26, 1912, at the post 
office at Indianapolis, Ind., under the Act of March 3, 1879. 


The Beginnings of Butler College Lee Burns 

The Founders op Butler College Demarchus C. Brown 

Founders^ Day Dinner Talks 

Journalism at Butler College H. E. Birdsong 

The Modern College Professor Arthur G. Long 

The Divine Right of Alumni 

Monticello George A. Schumacher 

The Duffer's Hope — A poem Clarence L. Goodwin 

College News 

Harlan 0. Page 

From the City Office 


Recent College Affiliation 

Honored Students 

A Loved Landmark 

Moores' Lincoln Collection 

Butler Publications 

''Butler Day" in Chicago 

Women's League 

Alumni Scholarships 


Class Reunions 

Butler DRIFT 

Personal Mention 





Digitized by tine Internet Arciiive 

in 2010 witii funding from 

Lyrasis IVIembers and Sloan Foundation 


Vol. XV APRIL, 1926 No. 1 


By Lee Burns 

A characteristic of the American people has been their con- 
stant interest in the cause of education. In a record made in 
1636 by the founders of Harvard, it was said: "One of the 
things we longed for and looked after was to advance posterity, 
dreading to leave an illiterate ministry to the churches after our 
present ministry shall be in the dust." 

With the development of the territory west of the AUeghanies, 
the settlers soon realized the importance of providing educational 
facilities that would be accessible to their own people. They 
knew that successful self-government must be intelligent govern- 
ment and, although there was little wealth in the new settlements, 
efforts vvere soon made for the establishment of schools and col- 

This work was carried on in most instances through the 
churches. Their leaders recognized the need of scholarly men in 
the ministry and also realized that they could make no greater 
gift to mankind than an opportunity for education. 

In Indiana the members of tlie Christian or Disciples Church 
took an early interest in the advancement of education. Alex- 
ander Campbell, the founder of the Church, had been an able 
advocate of good schools. In the Virginia Constitutional Con- 
vention he had urgrri a provision for free popular education; 
later he founded Bethany College, of which he was president 
until his death ; and his views in regard to the importance of edu- 
cational institutions had great influence. 

A definite movement for the establishment of a college in In- 
diana was made at a state meeting held at Flat Rock in 1848. 

4 Butler Alumnal Quarterly 

At that time Hanover and Wabash had been founded by the 
Presbyterians, Depauw by the Methodists, and Franklin by the 
Baptists, and at this meeting it was resolved to be "the duty of 
the Christian Brotherhood in Indiana to proceed to found and 
endow a college." 

The educational facilities in Indiana at that time were meagre. 
The census of 1840 had shown that one-seventh of the adult popu- 
lation of the state were unable to read and write, and there was 
urgent need for schools, colleges, and well trained teachers. There 
was no uniform system of common schools, nor any general taxa- 
tion for their support, and the private schools and county semi- 
naries that had been established were good, bad, or indifferent, 
depending upon the ability of the individual teachers. 

Yet, it was a period of intellectual activity, and attempts were 
constantly being made to systematize and improve the schools. 
Such friends of education as Caleb Mills of Crawfordsville, Ovid 
Butler, and his law partner, Calvin Fletcher, of Indianapolis, 
and Daniel Reed, of Bloomington, had begun their great cam- 
paign for a public school system, and in 1847 there had been held 
in Indianapolis the first of a series of public meetings to provide 
for a general convention of the friends of education. The chair- 
man of this meeting was Ovid Butler, and among those active in 
the movement were such able men as Isaac Blackford and Henry 
Ward Beeeher. 

Ovid Butler at once took an active interest in the movement to 
establish a college under the auspices of the Christian Church, 
of which he was a member. He had lived in Indianapolis since 
the early thirties, had been connected with every forward move- 
ment of the little community, and was passionately devoted to 
the cause of education, to which he gave, freely and whole-heart- 
edly, the greater part of his life. 

The problem of a location for the proposed college was difficult 
to decide. Citizens of Rush county urged that it be located 
there, members of the Church at Bedford offered to subscribe 
$10,000 if the school were built within a mile of their public square, 

The Beginnings of Butler College 5 

while others were in favor of a location nearer the center of the 

At the next annual meeting, the secretary reported that a can- 
vass of the churches had been taken which showed that they wanted 
a college and that a large majority preferred Indianapolis as a loca- 
tion. After some discussion it was resolved : ' ' That a Northwest- 
em Christian University be founded at Indianapolis, as soon as a 
sufficient amount of funds can be raised to commence it, and that a 
committee of seven be appointed to take preliminary steps in ref- 
erence to the founding and endowment of such an institution. ' ' 

Within a few months this committee, of which Ovid Butler was 
a member, had gone before the legislature and secured a special 
charter, whose broad and liberal provisions, that reflect the spirit 
of the founders of the school, have often been quoted. 

To found a college, and to endow and maintain it, are two very 
different things. Many ambitious educational projects that were 
started with fine enthusiasm have fallen by the wayside for lack 
of funds. However, the committee in charge of the new university 
began at once a campaign to raise by the sale of stock a minimum 
sum of $75,000, one-third of which, as provided in the charter, was 
to go into a building fund, and the balance was to be set aside as 
endowment. The interest on the stock was to be payable in tuition. 

John O'Kane, a man of energy and ability, was appointed spe- 
cial agent and by July, 1852, when the first Board of Directors was 
elected and the corporation formally organized, he was able to 
report that he had sold over $75,000 worth of stock. 

After a number of sites had been suggested and voted upon, the 
location chosen was one offered by Mr. Butler on a wooded tract of 
about twenty-five acres adjoining the Butler homestead near 
the edge of Indianapolis, at what is now the corner 
of Thirteenth street and College avenue. Plans for the 
college building were prepared by William Tinsley, an 
architect then living in Cincinnati. Mr. Tinsley had de- 
signed a number of important public buildings and was at one 
time president of the National Association of Architects. Christ 

6 Butler Alumnal Quarterly 

Church, Indianapolis, is a surviving example of his work. Con- 
tracts were let for the west wing, the only portion of the original 
design that was ever built, and Mr. Tinsley moved to Indianapolis 
to superintend its construction. It was completed in 1855. 

There had been no free public schools in Indianapolis until the 
year 1853, when the first free schools were opened for a session of 
two months. There were a few private schools of varying degrees of 
merit, but in order to have the students properly prepared for a 
course in the new college, it was thought necessary to open a 
Preparatory school, and in May, 1853, this department of the col- 
lege began in the St. Mary's Seminary building, near the center of 
town with R. K. Krout, of Crawfordsville, as instructor. This pre- 
paratory department, which was enlarged from time to time, was 
continued for many years, until the development of adequate high 
schools rendered it unnecessary. 

The college itself was opened on the first day of November, 1855, 
and was dedicated with considerable ceremony. The principal ad- 
dress was made by Horace Mann, the great educational liberal, who 
had, two years before, been made the first president of Antioch 
College. Other addresses were made in the chapel by Allen R. 
Benton, John Young, and Samuel K. Hoshour, and special exercises 
were also held at Masonic Hall, as the college chapel was not large 
enough to hold the crowd of citizens and distingTiished visitors. 

Horace Mann was intensely interested in this new school, which 
represented so many of his own educational ideas. Three years 
later he was elected by the board of directors as president of the 
college, with which office was to be combined the duties of pro- 
fessor of ethics and moral philosophy. In a letter advising him of 
his selection, and urging his acceptance, Mr. Butler expressed 
regret that the salary must of necessity be small, but also ventured 
to hope that ''the advantages of this position, to a man of your 
enlarged philanthropy, may be regarded as an equivalent for the 
deficiency. ' ' 

After some consideration, Mr. Mann declined the offer because 
of his obligations to Antioch College, which was then struggling 
for existence. 

The Beginnings of Butler College 7 

The selection of Mr. Mami for the presidency is evidence of the 
liberal spirit of the first board of directors of the college. Al- 
though he was a member of a different religious body, his inspiring 
ideas in regard to the methods and purposes of education were in 
full accord with their own. 

The faculty, at the opening of the school in 1855, consisted of 
John Young, professor of natural science and law; Allen R. Ben- 
ton, professor of ancient languages and literature ; George W. Hoss, 
professor of mathematics and civil engineering; J. R. Challen, 
professor of English, and L. H. Jameson, assistant professor. They 
were scholarly men and able teachers. 

During the first year there were over one hundred students. The 
first graduation class, of three members, was that of 1856. One 
member of this class, Mrs. Nancy Burns from West Virginia, after- 
wards Mrs. A. M. Atkinson, was one of the first women in America 
to graduate from a college that admitted both men and women. 

Until within the last century there had been no colleges that 
provided for the education of women. As there came to be a 
demand from them for greater opportunities, separate schools had 
been opened, notable ones being the seminary at jMount Holyoke, 
and the school founded by Emma Wiilard at Troy. At Oberlin 
Institute, there was a preparatory department for women, and 
Oberlin afterwards received women into its classes on substantially 
the same terms as men. The Northwestern Christian University 
was, however, among the first of the institutions of college standing 
in the United States to offer the same advantages to women as to 

The college authorities seem to have been puzzled as to how to 
describe the degrees offered to women. In some of the early cata- 
logues it was said that upon the completion by the women students 
of the "female collegiate course", which required only three years, 
the degree of Mistress of Science would be conferred and that upon 
completion of the "male collegiate course" of four years, there 
would be conferred the degree of Mistress of Arts. 

This co-educational experiment, so unusual at the time, must have 

8 Butler Alumnal Quarterly 

caused considerable comment. The college announcements spoke of 
the regulations that required the young ladies, during the recita- 
tion hours, to be under the immediate care of the "lady professor" 
and permitted them during those hours to meet students of the 
other sex only in the recitation rooms. The belief was announced 
that, "with only the restrictions demanded by propriety, the asso- 
ciation of the sexes in the collegiate career will greatly promote 
the social, moral and intellectual culture of each." 

The university was also among the first to abandon the old rigid 
courses of study and permit students to elect the subject best 
suited to their needs. The first catalogue announced that "those 
who did not wish the full classical course would be permitted, with 
the consent of their parents or guardians, to pass through the 
schools of mathematics, natural sciences, and ethics, and receive 
the degree of Bachelor of Science". This elective system, now 
in such general use, was then a decided innovation that had been 
tried only at Brown University and at Bethany. 

Writing of those early days when he was a student, John H. 
Holliday said: "A great thing was being done, the evoking of a 
great and beneficent force that should pervade the lives of many 
generations, exert an incalculable influence upon the community 
and the commonwealth and touch distant lands. It was the begin- 
ning of an institution that would instill high purposes in the hearts 
and minds of men and women and fill them with a courage to 
live life bravely and serviceably. " 

Another student, writing of those early college years, has said : 
"The contact of the boy with the faculty was principally with 
Professors Hoshour, Benton, Hoss and Brown. Professor Hoshour, 
ranked in age, seemed indeed quite elderly. He deserved credit 
for his intellectual strength and attainments; and was a faithful 
and helpful teacher. 

"The other three professors were good men and true: Brown 
sometimes abstracted, but strongly practical with a large store of 
useful information; Hoss nervous and oratorical; Benton, calm, 
always master of his subject, clear in setting it forth, and sue- 

The Beginnings of Butler College 9 

cessful in making it attractive; the best scholar and educator of 
the group." 

Mr. Benton came to Indiana seven years before the college was 
established and had founded in Rush county the academy of Fair- 
view, an admirable classical school with high standards. Another 
distinguished teacher, William M. Thrasher, who soon became a 
member of the faculty, also came from Fairview Academy, which 
has aptly been called the "cradle of Butler College." 

Each year the number of students increased. The catalogue 
of 1859 shows the number that year, including those in the pre- 
paratory department, to have been 265. Mr. Holliday says : *'We 
soon learned to address the teachers as 'Professor', and in turn 
to be addressed as 'gentlemen', not 'boys'. The object of going 
to college was to get an education, not to have fun. There was 
nothing else to go for. There were no sports, no glee clubs, no 
rival fraternities, no social distractions to divert one from the 
main issue. Therefore, most of the students were in deadly earnest 
and worked hard." 

However, the minutes of the faculty meetings, that have been 
kept year after year, show that the problems and details of college 
management are much the same from one generation to another. 
In an old record of fifty years ago, interspersed with plans for 
the arrangement of recitations and courses of study, are occasional 
reports of discipline of students for hazing and other infractions 
of the college rules. On one occasion two meetings of the faculty 
were required to determine who had put red pepper on the stove 
in one of the class rooms. The records show that the culprit was 
detected and severely censured and the dignity of the faculty 

While there were no intercollegiate athletics, as we know them 
today, yet the game of baseball was played at the college as far 
back as the seventies. Both the faculty and the students would 
play. Harvey W. Wiley, who was then a member of the faculty, 
took a great interest in the game and David Starr Jordan is re- 
membered not only as an able teacher but as a great first baseman. 

In an old time ordinance, for the "Government and Police of 

10 Butler Alumnal Quarterly 

the University", adopted in 1856, it was provided that "the stu- 
dent do not bring, or use upon said premises, any fire arms, dirk, 
bowie-knife, or any other kind of deadly weapon". While there 
is no evidence that such a regulation was necessary, it was included 
in the catalogue each year for twenty-five years or more. It was 
also provided that "the marriage of any student, during the term 
times, shall be regarded as sufficient reason for the disconnection 
of such student Vvith the institution during the balance of the 

The Civil war caused the attendance at the college to decrease. 
Each year the numbers grew less and less, until in 1863 there 
was but one graduate. But there were no less than one hundred 
and eighty-four of the students enlisted in the Union army, 
eighteen of whom died in service. Tuition was made free to any 
young man permanently disabled in the army. 

The limited financial resources of the college in those days is 
shown by the fact that the highest salary paid to a professor 
was nine hundred dollars a year and the salary of the president 
was only one thousand dollars. Yet the faculty included teachers 
of marked ability who Vvere devoted to their work and willing to 
accept meagre compensation in order that the school might carry 
on. This same condition existed at many other colleges. Times 
were hard and money for endowment was very difficult to secure. 

After the war, the attendance increased little by little until, 
by 1870, there were 345 students, and at that time there were 
twenty members of the faculty. During that year the Law school 
was established as a separate department, although a law class 
had been maintained in the college from the first, and the Demia 
Butler Chair of English literature was endowed by Ovid Butler 
in memory of his daughter, who had been the first woman to be 
graduated from the full classical course of the college. It was 
provided that this professorship should always be held by a woman. 
This was the first English department established in an Indiana 
college, the second being the one at Wabash. 

The first to hold the new chair was Catharine Merrill, a teacher 

The Beginnings of Butler College 11 

of rare ability, beloved by all who knew her. She was the second 
woman to hold a position on the faculty of an American college, 
the first having been Maria Mitchell, professor of astronomy of 
Vassar. Under the direction of Miss INIerrill, the English depart- 
ment soon became one that had an influence extending far and 
wide. Her scholarship and breadth of view were recognized by 
such men as Charles Eliot Norton and Edward Everett Hale and 
she was in correspondence with them and with many other leading 
educators of the country, all of whom were intensely interested 
in her work. She introduced into her classroom the lecture sys- 
tem, then a decided innovation, and Andrew D. White wrote ask- 
ing her opinion and advice before adopting it at Cornell. 

At about this same time a chair in Greek language and literature 
was endowed by Jeremy xVnderson, of Missouri, and was first 
held by John 0. Hopkins, an able and forceful teacher who in- 
sisted that every student who entered his classes should work at 
all times to the best of his ability. 

With the increase in attendance during the early seventies, the 
college became urgently in need of money. The growth of the 
city had made the campus a valuable piece of ground and it was 
suggested to the directors that it be subdivided and sold, and the 
school moved to a new location. Two sites were considered, one 
at Carter's station, six miles northeast of town, where forty acres 
of ground and a considerable sum of money were offered, and the 
other a tract of twenty-five acres, west of the new suburb of 
Irvington, with which there was also offered a bonus. 

The Irvington offer was accepted, a new building was begun, 
and while the panic of 1873 retarded both the sale of the old 
campus and collection of subscriptions, the college was able to 
move to the new location by the fall term of 1875. The removal 
of the college to Irvington did not have the approval of Ovid 
Butler, who not only had an affection for the original site, but felt 
that the school would be more accessible and of greater service at 
that location. Yet he never swerved in his loyalty nor ceased to 
give it his attention and financial aid. 

12 Butler Alumnal Quakterly 

In recognition of the many benefactions of Ovid Butler the 
name of the institution was changed in 1877 to Butler University, 
a university of which the present school of liberal arts, known as 
Butler College, is but a part. This change of name was a fitting trib- 
ute to a truly great citizen. The name of Ovid Butler rightfully 
tal^es its place with those of James Blair, Benjamin Rush, Horace 
Mann, and those other great Americans who spent the best part 
of their lives in devoted and unremitting labor in advancing the 
work of education. He was largely responsible for the founding 
of Butler and he gave to it of both his time and his fortune. For 
many years he was president of the board of directors and the old 
records of the board, written by him in painstaking detail, show 
the wisdom and energy with which its affairs were directed. 

Among the great teachers who have been at Butler were Allen 
R. Benton, Samuel K. Hoshour, Abraham C. Shortridge, William 
M. Thrasher, Catharine Merrill, Harriet Noble, Byron K. Elliott, 
Harvey "W. Wiley, Scot Butler, David Starr Jordan, Melville 
B. Anderson, Demarchus C. Brown, and Oliver P. Hay. Truly a 
remarkable list! 

Mr. Benton, who helped to found the college, and who served 
as the president for many years, resigned in 1866 to open the 
University of Nebraska. Eight years later he returned to Butler 
to remain until his retirement in 1900. It is interesting to know 
that this early president of Butler was a graduate of Bethany 
College and that the present president of Bethany is a graduate 
of Butler College. 


Demakchus C. Brown 

At all meetings connected with the Founders' Day program Dean Putnam, 
in the absence of President Aley, was presiding officer. The soloist on Sunday 
afternoon in the chapel was JNIrs. Roy Metzger, of Lebanon; the Butler Col- 
lege Hymn, written by Mrs. Wesenberg, was simg by a quartet of students 
consisting of Miss Helen Payne, Miss Mildred Johns, Mr. Paul Fink, Mr. 
Joseph Gremelspacher. The invocation was pronounced by Dean George W. 
Brown of the College of Missions and the benediction by Rev. George W. Alli- 
son of the Irvington Presbyterian Church. The Founders' Day address was 
made by Dr. Ralph Emerson Heilman, Dean of School of Commerce, North- 
western University, and may be given later to the readers of the QUAR- 
TERLY, it is hoped. 

There is some risk in quoting a classical writer in the modem 
college, but I '11 venture a line from Horace, because it is immortal 
and because it fits this occasion. You remember (of course you 
do) the poet, as he speaks of what he has written, says ''Exegi 
monumentum aere perennius" — "I have built a monument more 
lasting than bronze. ' ' Bronze and stone are enduring — they with- 
stand the ravages of time and the rust of decay. The Pyramids 
seem indestructible. The Parthenon and the Propylaeum have 
stood in their majesty and their beauty in spite of decay and 
gunshot, and still charm the world. 

Many ideas of men are not equal to "the dignity of bronze 
and the peace of marble." Men must and ought to found things 
for the joy and the betterment of their fellow human beings. 
What shall they found? A home, a city, a government, a library, 
a gallery, a well by the side of the road because they love men 
(to quote again from a greater than Horace), a poem, a book, a 
school? Yes, all of these. These may last longer than bronze 
and stone. The Psalms may be more enduring than the founda- 
tions of the Temple ; a line from Homer more vital than the walls 
of the Parthenon. When men build with the bronze of noble 
ideas and the stone of helpfulness to the world, the structure 
built will be too strong to be pulled down. 


14 Butler Aluainal Quarterly 

This meeting today is to celebrate the founding and honor the 
founders of a school, a place of learning and scholarship, which 
acquirements were very meagre in that day three-fourths of a 
century ago, and sad to say not any too great now nor even very 
highly regarded by the mass. They were far-seeing men, the 
present Avas not enough for them, they longed for educated men 
and women in all ranks of life, and to quote the great words on 
the Harvard gate, they "dreaded to leave behind an ignorant 
ministry." The charter asked for and granted to them is broad 
enough to educate students in all the arts and sciences and in the 
deepest and best sense. I quote : 

"An institution- of learning of the highest class for the educa- 
tion of the youth of all parts of the United States, and especially 
of the states of the Northwest ; to establish in said institution de- 
partments or colleges for the instruction of the students in every 
branch of liberal and professional education; to educate and pre- 
pare suitable teachers for the common schools of the country; and 
for the promotion of the sciences and arts. ' ' 

There were four other church schools in Indiana when this one 
was started. The "Northwest" was far away from the center of 
education and learning in those days. It moved afterwards to 
the great Northwest. It was real enough, however, to first copy 
the name given — Northwestern Christian University. In 1848, at 
Flatrock, Rush county, a meeting was held and it was declared 
to be the duty of the Church of the Disciples to found and 
endow a college. In 1847 Ovid Butler had presided at a meeting 
which was in favor of improved facilities for schooling. At the 
next sitting of the Legislature the charter was granted. In July, 
1852, John O'Kane, special agent, reported more than $75,000 
subscribed. As usual, there was rivalry about the location. Rush 
county, Lawrence county, and Marion county wanted it. The 
result of course you know. 

Other names besides those mentioned above must not be forgot- 
ten: Elijah Goodwin, George Campbell, Ambrose D. Hamrick, 
Milton B. Hopkins, J. B. New, L. H. Jameson, Paris C. Dunning, 

Founders' Day 15 

A. B. Cole — whose names along with others appear in the incor- 
poration act. 

William Tinsley, the architect, completed the building in 1855. 
November 1, 1855, the first session was held. Men and women were 
admitted. The Faculty was A. R. Benton, John Young, S. K. 
Hoshour, and George W. Hoss. I wonder if there are many here 
who have any personal interest or recollection of any of these 
men. Of the fine scholar and gentleman, Benton, there are many 
in this room who bless the memory. He was an instructor and a 
colleague of mine for many years. Peace to his beautiful spirit! 
And S. K. Hoshour — who ever saw him can forget him? If per- 
sonal knowledge is absent, then read ''Altisonant Letters" and 
learn about him, and something about words, too. These are men- 
tioned because as teachers they helped to found this College. Cath- 
arine Merrill began in those early days. Who can ever forget 
her? And later on, 0. A. Burgess, John 0. Hopkins, W. M. 
Thrasher, Scot Butler? 

I remember when a Senior standing at the old pump at the 
northwest corner of this building (Why did we destroy that 
pump ? ) when John 'Kane came downstairs from a meeting and 
asked me to pump him a drink. He looked like one of the Apos- 
tles to me. After he had satisfied himself he said: "I have 
pumped for others all my life, now I suppose it is time for you 
youngsters to pump for me." It was an awful blow to me, a 
Senior, to be called a "youngster" — but it was good for me. 

These people, I believe, were building for the future. They 
loved and appreciated learning and scholarship — tolerant scholar- 
ship, without which a school were better not founded. 

Did you ever see a foundation go to pieces before the upper 
courses of stone are built upon it? There is something inex- 
pressibly sad about it. To dig deep and then see ruin and desola- 
tion before a superstructure appears. Blessed be the founder 
who lives to see and enjoy the completion of the foundation he 
has laid, of whom it cannot be said — "He has failed." Some- 
times the blessing does not come because his sucxiesors fail. They 

16 Butler Alumnal Quarterly 

do not grasp the purpose of the originator; they are petty, or 
small-minded; they lack vision; they live narrowly and think, if 
at all, dogmatically, or are on ''Main Street" and never get, off 
of it. These ruin a founder's work. 

It is a joy to us that founders do not always complete their 
work. It leaves something for us. We must share their work. 
May I state the opposite of the thesis now under discussion? 
There must be destroyers as well as builders. It is better to 
destroy at times, maybe not completely, but in part. It is not 
easy to tear down, nor is it safe. Jesus was both a builder and a 
destroyer. Bigotry and hate He strove to destroy. We have never 
built up in beauty and glory and majesty what He founded. Will 
we ever? 

In our local institution here have we completed what the foun- 
ders laid down? We students, alumni, teachers and friends, have 
we the same ideals of scholarship? Do we have the vision they 
had? Dare we ask ourselves these questions? Do we ever reach 
our ideals? Perhaps not. Perhaps if we did we would stop 
developing. We want not only ancestors, but heirs. If we are 
the right kind of heirs we will also be ancestors. They as an- 
cestors and founders laid the foundation. We as heirs must put 
up the building, keep enlarging and improving it. The founders 
were not satisfied — it were deadly to be complacently content. 
They had no spirit of boasting. They could not see the whole 
structure, but they hoped we would do some building. We ought 
to ask ourselves if we are building. 

Don't you recall Housman's verses when the young man, as he 
gazed at the statue, was dissatisfied? 

"Courage, lad, 'tis not for long; 
Stand, quit you like stone, be strong. 
And I stepped out in flesh and bone. 
Manful like the man of stone." 

I mean, there are foundations not of stone, but they can be 
made so, even as the Parthenon or the Pyramids. 

Personally, I would like to continue the work of the founders. 

The Dinner 17 

enlarge it, improve it, glorify it, keep on pumping for others. I 
want the College to be known for sheer love of learning, a love 
that neither engulfing rain, nor cold north wind, nor the innumer- 
able ranks of years, nor the flight of time, can destroy. Thus 
will the dream of the founders be realized. 


It is regretted that all the good speeches, with Dr. Putnam's happy intro- 
ductions, can not here be given, but space forbids. The announcements made 
by Mr. John W. Atherton were climax to an unusually delightful program and 
all guests departed cheered by the report of financial gain, by the statement 
that building operations will begin in earnest in June, and by the vision as 
thrown on the screen of beautiful structures in stone of collegiate Gothic 
design. Music for the evening was furnished by the Claypool Trio and by 
Miss Helen Payne, as soloist. 

Dr. W. a. Shullengerger, new pastor of the Central Christian 
Church: It has been a joy to us to taste the fine hospitality of In- 
dianapolis in the last ten days, to become acquainted with your in- 
stitution and to mingle with groups who exhibit such friendship and 
fellowship as this. Personally, I count it a great joy to come 
from a university atmosphere in the city of Des Moines, from the 
church that really was the mother of Drake University, and to 
have the privilege of being with this group, celebrating the seventy- 
first anniversary of Butler University. The air we breathe tonight 
seems to be a familiar air, a congenial air, and to my own heart 
a very precious atmosphere. 

There is a peculiar significance in a meeting such as this that 
was not so noticeable ten years ago. Today people are talking 
education, more education, more and better education. One of 
the great educators of England said before the war that if one 
wished to enroll a boy in one of the English institutions it must 
be done four or five years in advance. Today they say he must 
be enrolled when he is bom. The same thing is true of American 
institutions — it is more education, more education, and better edu- 
cation. And where will you go for a finer type of education than 


to such institutions as you represent tonight — an institution that 
has behind it academic standards and fine traditions — a great her- 
itage which enables you to render great service for this com- 
munity ? 

It takes one generation to prove the worth of an institution, but 
in the second generation comes the hour when the alumni ought 
to reveal their fine fidelity to the school by putting forth their 
energy and ability to make it a success. Tonight we have that 
second generation, and this part of the country is looking to you 
folk to make good the last statement in this song we have here, 
"The Gallery of Memory", where he speaks of the scholars of 
Butler setting the pace. We of the IMiddle West have felt that 
way about you for a long time. Butler has a very fine standing 
over beyond the Mississippi River, and I say to you of the alumni 
that you have a great responsibility resting upon you, as graduates 
of the institution, to put your shoulders to the task of raising to 
the nth power the statement in this second stanza of your song, 
because, friends of Butler University, if there is any strength in a 
university it must come from the alumni. Especially is that true 
of a church school. What the State tax is to a State school, the 
alumni have to be to a church school. Many people have the er- 
roneous notion that the tuition of the students pays for the school. 
It never can do it. We have to depend on the constituency of the 
colleges and universities, the fine men and women who, after com- 
ing out of college have the joy of sending their children through 
the same institution, perhaps under the same teachers — and who 
consider it an investment in life — an investment of means and 
energy and consecration. 

May I, as a rank outsider, bring the greetings of the university 
world just yonder beyond the great river to Butler University, with 
the hope that our contacts may become closer and our understand- 
ing of one another in the bonds of friendship more intimate in 
the future days. 

Judge James A. Collins of the City Endowment Committee: 
I have served on the City Committee since the organization of 

The Dinner 19 

that group for the purpose of making possible in Indianapolis a 
larger Butler College. I do not know just what my friend, Homer 
McKee, has in mind when he suggested the need for Indianapolis 
to be a city of a million people. I do not know that I agree with 
the need for it, with what I go through every day. But I am 
tremendously interested in the City of Indianapolis having within 
its corporate limits a collegiate institution large enough to take 
care of the boys and girls graduating from her three high schools. 
That, in my opinion, is worth a great deal more than increasing 
the population to a million. I understand from Mr. Atherton — 
and he gets it from a reliable source, the Rockefeller Foundation — 
that Indianapolis is the only city of its size in this country that 
has no collegiate institution of real size. I do not want to be mis- 
understood. I never did play football — well, I did once, a good 
many years ago, but after the first tryout I was laid aside under 
the bushes to recover, and that ended my football career. But I 
have become interested in that particular form of sport on account 
of my connection with Butler College, and I could not understand 
why it made Will Irwin and Hilton Brown sore in the Butler- 
Notre Dame game when that fine young Irishman made a wonder- 
ful run — somehow they did not seem to appreciate the fact that 
he was making a wonderful run. And so with this City Commit- 
tee — I think the people of Indianapolis know something about it, 
but I do not know how well the members of the Faculty and the 
students of the school understand what this committee is doing. 

This committee is made up of business men, many of whom 
could not possibly be employed for such work — there is no system 
or plan under which Butler could secure the services of such men, 
say, as L. C. Huesmann. These men are giving their time and energy 
to make possible the ideal that has been in the mind of those in- 
terested in Butler College. And no finer work could be under- 
taken. These men need at all times the co-operation and support 
of those connected with the institution, and I believe that the work 
of the Committee would be a failure if it were not for the fact that 
on the job at every hour of the day, and at every stage of the 
game, is a secretary who is giving the best in his life to see that the 

20 Butler Alumnal Quarterly 

goal is reached and a greater and larger institution established at 
Fairview Park — Mr. John Atherton. 

The Committee in its work has not had the idea of any religious 
or denominational connection. It is made up of men who believe in 
the development of this institution, who believe in enlarging the 
present plant by substituting out where this new site has been se- 
cured a going institution as fine as there is in any city of the 
United States. There is no reason in the world why Indianapolis 
should not be able to boast in the next ten years of as fine an insti- 
tution as may be found in the West. That is the goal of the City 

Mr. Edwin E. Thompson, president of the Alumni Association; 
When I was asked to come to the speakers' table this evening I 
thought it might be because I am president of the Alumni Associa- 
tion. Then, when they began to talk so much about founders, I 
wondered whether the fact that it has been more than twenty-five 
years since I graduated had misled someone who had me confused 
with the founders of this institution. 

Our purpose tonight, my friends, is this: We are here to pay 
tribute to the founders of this great institution — the great men and 
women, many of them poor, we know, who contributed what they 
could in the way of work and energy and such means as they had, 
to found this institution. I have read at different times about 
the founders of Butler, and I have come to the conclusion that 
these men and women were in the forefront of the times in their 
day, and that the Butler College of the fifties was as fine an in- 
stitution for the city as the new Butler will be when it is located at 

What I want to say to you is this — I believe all of the students 
and friends of Butler endorse the new Butler plan, practically 
without exception. The Alumni not only endorse, but greatly ap- 
preciate everything that has been done during recent years for 
this new institution. We are proud of every department of the 
college. We have a wonderful college and it is going forward in a 
progressive way. 

The Dinner 21 

Dr. John H. Oliver: I bespeak your mercy, and I want to 
remind you that before you get through tonight you will be asking 
for mercy, because each and every one at this elevated table is 
expected to speak to you anywhere from seven to eleven minutes. 
When the gentleman who had this entertainment in hand told me 
that I was to speak from seven to eleven minutes, there was some- 
thing in those cabalistic figures that brought back memories of col- 
lege days — seven — eleven! After deliberating over his message 
the thought came to me of an anecdote concerning a distinguished 
member of my profession, Dr. Oliver Wendell Holmes. Some 
years before his demise a young lady with ambitions to become a 
great literary genius wrote him that she understood fish was a good 
diet for literary people, and as he was not only a literary man 
but a physician, would he please tell her how much, and how many 
times a week she should eat fish. He replied in a very polite note 
that he thought a whale and a half a day would be about right. 
And when I received this invitation my eyes at once turned to the 
fish market, hoping I might find whale, or some other article of 
fish diet that would enable me to fill to my own satisfaction, at 
least, this momentous engagement. 

"In the galleries of my memory there are pictures bright and 
fair", but no one brighter or fairer than the old Northwestern 
Christian University site on College Avenue — the fine old Eliza- 
bethan building with its many towers and its beautiful campus. 
Some of us who as youngsters used to live in that vicinity, prowling 
around the building discovered by peeping that they had a skele- 
ton — horror of horrors ! My gorge rises as I think of it, even today. 
How we used to run away and talk it over, then go back and 
peep in, and then hold a consultation, wondering whether they 
killed it, and how they got it in there. Wandering about the col- 
lege buildings, clad in a long robe, was dear old Professor Hoshour, 
he of the letters — a real scholar. 

Then the memories travel down a good many years of gallery 
and we find the Northwestern Christian University had wisely be- 
come Butler College. It was not a university and "Butler Col- 
lege" fitted it admirably, and the gentleman for whom it was 

22 Butler Alumnal Quarterly 

named was well worthy the honor. But what a difference from 
the old campus to that gaunt specter, that lighthouse of learning 
standing in a sea of mud in Irvington ! We had to navigate that 
sea, and believe me, it was a voyage fraught with danger. How 
frequently we had to help the girls out of the mud, but thank the 
Lord, their hair was long in those days, or some of them would be 
skeletonized in the clay of Irvington today. 

And when we come to the Faculty — Burgess was president, and 
we have never had a better one. Then there was Dr. Benton, with 
his sibilant whisper, a splendid gentleman, who let us write as 
much as we wanted to and when we got to the end of our string 
would say, "Yes, that will suffice." And then Professor Thrasher, 
who said he approached his cow to milk her by geometrical pro- 
gression, and preferred a three-legged milking stool, because it 
resembled a theodolite. Then there was Professor Hopkins, Profes- 
sor of Greek, who died in the college building. There are a num- 
ber of other names to conjure with, among them Dr. Jordan, who 
was my particular favorite. And such pranks as we used to play 
in those bygone days. Two of Dr. Jordan's students one day took 
a beetle, a cricket and a grasshopper; they dissected the beetle, 
attached the grasshopper's legs, and the head of the cricket, and 
then took it to Dr. Jordan for identification. He looked at it and 
said, "Well, well, where did you find it?" "Out on the lawn." 
"How long ago?" "About an hour ago." "W^ell, well, what at- 
tracted your attention to it?" "It v/as humming in the grass." 
' ' Humming, was it ? The identification is easy and complete. It 's 
a humbug!" 

But in the gallery of my memory, as the old Butler Faculty 
comes back to me, there is one whose name comes like a benedic- 
tion — I have only to name Catharine Merrill. 

Mr. William Forsyth of the John Herron Art Institute: I 
am very pleased to look at such an audience as this. I have often 
wondered how it would feel to sit at a promiscuous gathering of 
ladies and gentlemen, young and old, and look out upon them from 
an elevated position. I feel that a very great compliment has been 
paid to me because I do not profess to belong to the intelligensia. 

The Dinner 23 

When Professor Richardson called me and informed me of the 
pleasant time I was to have tonight, I hesitated and was on the 
point of declining, and then I asked, ''What do I have to talk 
about?" He said, "Talk about anything; you only have to talk 
ten minutes. " So I said, ' ' Glory be ! I can spoil ten minutes and 
not say anything at all." 

I belong to a luncheon club that meets here once a week. I 
sometimes come to the meetings because, being an artist, I like to 
rub elbows with the standardized man. There are new kinds of 
people to study and it keeps me interested in life — if that is neces- 
sary. We have a roll-call, and each man answering gives his name 
and his business or profession. Sometimes they give it a very 
amusing touch. One day in a spirit of mischief — although a rev- 
erend gentleman sitting next to me said I was influenced by three 
young ladies who were giving us some music — I answered, ''Wil- 
liam Forsyth, apostle of beauty", which brought down the house. 

In a sense I am an apostle of beauty. I am not a disciple. Most of 
you are Disciples, but I am an Apostle. I like the term anyhow ; it 
adds a dig-nity to me that I do not possess, because I have not spent 
my life with people who would give me a vein of dignity. I have 
spent my life mostly among young people, trying to inculcate into 
them a sense of beauty, a feeling for art. I do not have to insist on 
their feeling beauty — they can all see beauty in some form or 
other. But I try to explain to them that beauty is not art. That 
is the primary lesson — to make a difference between beauty and 
art. The road is long. It is quite serious to a great many people, 
but artists as a rule see things along the way that keep them cheer- 
ful — they are on the lookout for beautiful things. 

I do not know what I represent here tonight. I asked Mrs. 
Forsyth what I was supposed to represent, mentioning several 
things, but she said, "No, you represent the Art School", and that 
pleased me — I hope it pleases you. We have more and more peo- 
ple from Butler coming out there, but too many of them come to 
get something by which they can make a living afterwards. They 
could get that anywhere. That really is not what we would have 

24 Butler Alumnal Quarterly 

Butler students come for at all. They can make their living after 
they get out of Butler, but art is a different thing. I do not be- 
lieve in making a living out of art. I have never made much of a 
living from art. I do not encourage pupils who come out there to 
make a living from art. Of course they can sail under that flag, 
but they are not real artists. Art is differently constituted than 
that. It must soak in. We are in hopes that the connection will 
be so close that the students will gain some of the enthusiasm 
that is in the artist's heart that gives him a feeling in regard to 
the world, the whole scheme of human dreams and human ac- 
complishments — a feeling that differs from the practical. That 
is really the only reason we have for a connection between Butler 
CoUege and the Art School, It is not something you can teach 
them in so many lessons, or on which they can pass examina- 
tions at the end of a certain period. It is not that — it is an 
atmosphere, it is an air. It stimulates life and makes the world 
a pleasanter place in which to live — it gives one something to 
look forward to — makes one realize there is something else than 
living like ants or bees, who toil all winter to come out in good 
condition in the spring. The hope of the artist is that somebody 
will understand art. It cannot be bought; it can be acquired. 
Aesthetic classes will not do it. You have to live art; you must 
feel it as you do religion ; it must be a part of your life, else you 
do not understand art, and you do not get out of life that to which 
you are entitled as human beings. 

You have new buildings in prospect, and they should be a monu- 
ment to art; the grounds should be artistic; but if you do not 
carry into the life of the future Butler the real idea of art, the 
students will miss a great deal. Art is the joy of life. You do 
not have to have money, and millions of people go through life 
without knowing the things that are just outside and which they 
might acquire, which would enrich their lives before they pass into 
the shadows — the things which God gave them a right to have. 

Mr. E. U. Graff, Superintendent of Indianapolis Public Schools: 
One idea that has been running all through this program tonight 

The Dinner 25 

and which is of special significance to me, is the thought that there 
has been an enormous increase in the number of students seeking 
higher education, particularly in the last few years. It has af- 
fected not only the higher institutions of learning, but the high 
schools in ahnost equal proportion. 

It seems to me we need to consider some of the functions of 
education, or the significance of education in the 20th century. 
What kind of civilization is this, and what is the relation of edu- 
cation to it? That is a large question; we cannot solve it in five 
minutes. But I should like to give one or two hints of the trend 
of thought as I see it on this subject. 

A good many students of our day have said that the dominant 
characteristic of the civilization of Europe and America as we 
know it is the increase in the amount of comforts, the progress 
along the line of material development. Whether we consider that 
man's happiness is directly increased in proportion to the progress 
of his material heritage or not, there is a great deal to indicate 
that the contributions of science and invention and discovery to 
modern life have brought about a condition where we are in dan- 
ger of having our machinery outgrow our needs. There are a 
number of evidences before us that we are in danger of just such 
a situation. We have means of transportation today that almost 
exceed our need of it. There are people going hither and yon, 
back and forth, out and back, without very much purpose and 
with very little need. Transportation has become so easy that we 
use these machines for going about, a lot of which is purposeless. 
In other words, we are doing a lot of traveling just because it 
is easy to travel. The machinery for the communication of thought 
has also increased in like proportion. The latest child of science, 
the radio, is far more wonderful than anything that has yet been 
discovered to be communicated over the radio. We have this mar- 
velous invention which transmits thought instantly practically 
around the world, and yet very few new thoughts have been dis- 
covered to be communicated by means of it. It is like a person 
who knew several languages but had no ideas to communicate. 
The machinery of printing has become so efficient that it would be 

26 Butler Alumnal Quarterly 

perfectly possible as we leave this meeting tonight to be handed a 
printed copy of everyone of the speeches made here and every- 
thing that has transpired. We would not think anything of it — 
we would take it as a matter of course. The output of the printing 
presses, the books, are published by the ton these days, and yet, 
without reflecting at all upon either the press or the printing as 
an agency, it seems to me that our facilities for reproducing the 
thought of the world have almost outstripped the importance of 
that which we are reproducing in this way. 

I like the summary of this thing which was given by M. Berg- 
son in addressing the French Academy in 1914. He said : 

"Many years hence, when the reaction of the past shall have 
left only the grand outlines in view, this, perhaps, is how a philoso- 
pher will speak of our age. He will say that the idea, peculiar to 
the nineteenth century, of employing science in the satisfaction of 
our material wants has given a wholly unforeseen extension to the 
mechanical arts, and equipped man, in less than fifty years, with 
more tools than he had made during the thousands of years he had 
lived upon earth. Each new machine being for man a new organ, 
an artificial organ, his body became suddenly and prodigiously 
increased in size, without his soul being at the same time able to 
dilate to the dimensions of his new body." 

Without elaborating that thesis at all, what is the function of 
education in this civilization and age ? What have we people who 
are concerned with education as a profession to do with all this? 
In a phrase, it seems to me that it is the concern of all of us, 
whether we are concerned with higher education or with education 
in its more elementary and preparatory stages — that we ought to 
be concerned with the very fundamental problem of addressing 
ourselves to the world of ideas, to the discovery and communica- 
tion and production of eternal truth, so that that world of ideas 
shall somehow continue to thrive and grow and to keep pace with 
this enormous scientific and material development. 

I believe I could summarize what I should like to say about the 
office of education in such a day as this by quoting what Emerson 
says in his essay on the office of the scholar. 

The Dinner 27 

"He is to find consolation in exercising the highest functions of 
human nature. He is the one who raises himself from private 
considerations and breathes and lives on public and illustrious 
thoughts. He is in the world's eyes. He is to resist the vulgar 
prosperity that retrogrades ever to barbarism, by preserving and 
communicating heroic sentiments, noble biographies, melodious 
verse, and the conclusions of history. Whatsoever oracles the hu- 
man heart, in all emergencies, in all solemn hours, has uttered as 
its commentary on the world of actions — these he shall receive and 
impart. And whatsoever new verdict Reason from her inviolable 
seat pronounces on the passing man and events of today — this he 
shall hear and promulgate. ' ' 

Such, my friends, is the function of education. The higher in- 
stitutions of our land are under an obligation and a duty to train 
for leadership in this world of thought and idea and ideal. The 
fundamental values of the intellect and of the spirit are really at 
stake here. This matter of education is not something for the 
benefit of the present, it is a public function, it is a social function, 
it is for the benefit of all mankind. 

Me. J. Douglas Perry, of the Senior Class: Allow me to ex- 
press my gratitude to the Committee on Arrangements for its cour- 
tesy in inviting the student body to this dinner. I am sent here to 
speak, not as an individual, but as the representative of the six- 
teen hundred young men and women enrolled in Butler University, 
and to bring their greetings to this gathering. I may as well 
confess at the outset that I always approach the task of represent- 
ing other people with apprehension. In the past I have repre- 
sented other groups on occasions similar to this, and sometimes on 
returning to my constituency I have been coldly informed that my 
remarks had been such that I represented no one but myself, so I 
have been a little afraid that in what I have to say I may reflect 
only my own thought. But tonight I may speak with ease be- 
cause I speak on a theme I know something about, and that is 
what Butler students think and feel about Butler. 

The other afternoon I sat with a group of fellows about the 

28 Butler Alumnal Quarterly 

fire and the talk turned into rather serious channels. You know 
college students are not supposed to talk about serious things, but 
we were congenial spirits in a congenial atmosphere. One of these 
turned to me and said: "Perry, in all frankness, what do you 
think of Butler?" "In all frankness," I replied, "I like it. I 
do not think I shall go back to Kentucky. How do you like it?" 
"Well," he replied, "if I had great wealth, I suppose I might 
have gone to one of the eastern universities, but for one in my 
circumstances I do not know of any school in the country that is 
able better to meet my needs than Butler College, and certainly I 
know of no other school in the State of Indiana where I would 
rather be enrolled as a student than at Butler." 

I consider that a very mild and temperate statement of the af- 
fection that Butler students have for Butler University. You 
know it is amusing sometimes to hear the alumni talking in a very 
confident manner of that far-distant time when Butler shall be 
the greatest educational institution in the State of Indiana. In 
the minds of the student body she already is the greatest educa- 
tional institution in the State of Indiana. We acknowledge no 
superior. We might grant superiority to Notre Dame in football, 
but sometimes we have grave and serious doubts about that. It 
may be there are other schools with a greater enrollment; it may 
be there are other colleges in Indiana that have buildings of greater 
beauty; but what is a great university anyway? Is it merely a 
magnificent pile of brick and mortar, an aggregation of students 
running up into the thousands? Such things never have made a 
great university and they never will. A great university is to be 
measured only in terms of service rendered to the students of that 
institution, and by that single test Butler may stand without apol- 
ogy among the best. 

One thing makes me sore at heart, and that is the charge some- 
times made that Butler students are not loyal to their college. It 
may be true that there are men enrolled who look upon everything 
with a jaundiced eye, who live in a state of chronic displeasure, 
but I feel sure they are not sufficiently numerous to condemn the 
general spirit of the student body of Butler. It may be that the 

The Dinner 29 

Butler students as a whole are not expressive of their loyalty — they 
do not seek to manifest their spirit of devotedness by tearing down 
fraternity houses or assaulting members of the Faculty; but there 
does pervade the campus a spirit of fraternity and helpfulness. 
It may be true there are misunderstandings sometimes, but usually 
they pass without damage either to the College or the student body. 

You remember the condition in Great Britain prior to the out- 
break of the war — there were internal dissensions — she always had 
had trouble with her territorials and dependencies; but when in 
1914 the terrible foreign menace arose, threatening the existence 
of the Empire, old Mother England said ''Come", and all her 
stalwart sons, burying their differences, came marching home to 
save the honor and integrity of the Empire. And so, although the 
comparison may seem far-fetched, it is with the students and 
alumni of Butler — when the call comes they all come marching 
home, students and alumni and friends, and surrender themselves 
and their means to the emergency of the moment. 

I) have said very little that is particularly appropriate to this 
occasion, dedicated to the honor and memory of the founders of 
Butler College. I yield to no one in my admiration for those 
pioneer spirits who by their liberality made possible the Butler 
of today, but perhaps it is only natural that we are little inclined 
to look back upon the greatness of the past. With all life spread 
out before us, with our eyes fixed upon the sunrise, we are looking 
forward to Fairview, when the first dawn shall gild the towers and 
minarets of the new Administration building; we are looking for- 
ward to the time when Butler College shall be Butler University, 
when we may again assemble ourselves on an occasion such as this 
and say to the memory of Ovid Butler and his associates, ''We 
have been true to our trust ; we have builded on your foundations ; 
we have realized your dreams. ' ' 

30 Butler Alumnal Quarterly 


By H, E. BiRDsoNG 
Head of Department of Journalism 

The first school of journalism was founded at the University of 
Missouri in 1908. About the same time, and in some instances 
prior to this date, classes in journalistic writing were established in 
several other universities and colleges. Today there are approxi- 
mately fifty professional schools and departments of journalism. 
The achievements of these first few years of professional instruc- 
tion in journalism include the breaking down of editorial prejudice 
against college trained newspaper men and women, and the work- 
ing out of fairly well standardized courses of instruction. 

Building on this past experience in the teaching of professional 
journalism and on its own experience with classes in journalistic 
writing, Butler University added in the fall of 1924 a department 
of journalism that has as its objective the training of young men 
and women for practical work on newspapers and magazines. In 
this undertaking the new department has the full co-operation of 
the daily newspapers of Indianapolis; the full approval and co- 
operation of the Faculty; the interest of a large and energetic 
group of Butler students; the hearty support of the Board of Di- 
rectors, and the very helpful counsel of Mr. Hilton U. Brown of 
the Indianapolis News, who, as president of the Butler Board of 
Directors, was chiefly responsible for the establishment of the new 

Nine courses in journalism, which carry a total of forty-eight 
hours of credit for the year, are now being taught at Butler. These 
courses are planned to give in the freshman year a general survey 
of the field of journalism and the opportunities for specialization in 
it; to lay in the sophomore and junior years the foundation for 
actual newspaper work; and to give in the senior year laboratory 
practice on the Indianapolis papers, supplemented by a study of 
the history and principles of journalism. The Butler Collegian 
is being published daily four days a week under the direction of 

Journalism at Butler College 31 

the department. Seventy-seven students are taking work in the 
department preparatory to entering journalism as a profession 
and more than 125 students are enrolled in the department. Three 
members of the 1926 graduating class, Miss Dorothy Stephenson, 
Miss Caroline Godley, and Mr. Thomas F. Smith, will offer jour- 
nalism as their major subject, and several others will have minors 
in the department. National recognition of the work now being 
done here has been given in the establishment at Butler of the 
thirty-ninth chapter of Sigma Delta Chi, national professional 
journalistic fraternity. 

Reporting and copy editing are the basic courses in the depart- 
ment of journalism. A description of the work of these two classes 
will indicate the nature and the content of the professional courses 
in journalism. Each is a year course with five hours of credit 
each semester — for those who successfully complete the required 
work. The task is not a particularly easy one. 

The class in reporting meets five days a week for lectures and 
discussion of assigned textbook and newspaper reading. Each 
student is required to write a minimum of three news stories a 
week for publication either in the Collegian or in one of the In- 
dianapolis papers. Several practice stories based on facts fur- 
nished by the instructor are written each semester. Thirty rep- 
resentative newspapers from all parts of the country are studied 
and discussed during the year, and each student is required to 
write a 500-word analysis of the news content and the treatment 
of the news in each paper. Thus at the end of the year the student 
has gained from his study of textbooks the theory of news values, 
news gathering, and news writing; he has learned from a close 
analysis of the best newspapers what news they print and how it 
is written; he has had enough practice in reporting to learn the 
importance of giving facts accurately; and he has had enough 
practice in writing to aid him materially in the development of 
his own style. 

The class in copy editing meets twice a week for lectures and dis- 
cussion and three times a week for laboratory practice. Each 

32 Butler Alumnal Quarterly 

laboratory period is two hours. The laboratory work includes the 
editing of copy for the Collegian and practice work with copy 
furnished by the Associated Press and the United Press. This 
work is supplemented by a study of the same newspapers that were 
analyzed in reporting, but the study this time is based on the 
makeup and display of news. 


By Arthur G. Long, '27 

In a recent issue of the Saturday Evening Post I read a very 
interesting article entitled "Beans Porridge Cold", commenting 
upon the modern college professor and the reaction of the student 
toward him. The writer was a middle-aged man who had gone 
back to his university for post-graduate work. In this capacity 
it was his privilege to see through the eyes of maturity and at the 
same time sympathize with the general sentiment of the youthful 
student body. 

The writer of the article found that above all things the average 
student appreciates the "human element" in his professor, and 
dislikes the pedantic. It was this phase of the criticism which in- 
terested me, especially in its connection with the undergraduate 
in a Liberal Arts course. 

Many of the professors are apt to forget, in the pursuit of their 
highly intellectualized studies, that while their mental visions are 
defined in black and white, those of their youthful subjects are 
tinted with rose and blue, and filled with softening shadows. Youth 
is the Springtime of life, and Hope is either at the peak or in the 
depths. Young minds are swayed by feelings, and their judg- 
ments are colored by prejudice and emotion. 

Recognizing these facts the teacher with insight will not only 
appeal to the intellectual side of his pupil, but also will convert 
that undercurrent of emotion into an active, constructive interest. 
William James says that it is the emotional reaction, either of 
pleasure or displeasure, which, linked definitely with an idea, gives 
that idea its place in the scale of intellectual values. This is es- 
pecially true of the average college student. He either "likes" or 
does not "like" a certain subject. In other words the path to his 
mind is largely through his feelings. He reacts primarily to the 
personality of his teacher and secondly to the actual content of 
the subject at hand. 

This quality called the "human element" is, at best, of an elu- 


34 Butler Alumnal Quarterly 

sive nature, yet its presence is an all-powerful force in leading 
young feet along the paths of Knowledge and Culture. The aver- 
age undergraduate, though mentally quite sound, is still very much 
lilte a young animal. Rarely does he seek Knowledge for its own 
sake and of his own initiative ! He must be driven, coaxed, and 
boosted along, at least to a certain extent. The teacher who ex- 
pects his pupil to attack the problems of the course with the same 
fine enthusiasm that characterizes his own work, and who thinks 
that their relations can be established upon a purely intellectual 
basis is making a fatal mistake. 

I, being an "average" undergraduate, am in rather close touch 
with college life, and it has become my firm conviction that there 
are more students of good mental capacity making low grades 
than there are making high grades. This statement may seem 
rather startling, but I believe it to be absolutely true. This con- 
dition is a result of professors not realizing that the approach to 
youthful minds lies, for the most part, in the imaginative or 
emotional appeal. I, myself, have had the interesting experience 
of taking practically the same work under two different teachers. 
The first was coldly analytical, attempting to arouse no enthusiasm 
in his class, and displaying none on his own part. The result was 
that I looked forward to that particular recitation period as a 
time to make up sleep or to be unutterably bored. The second 
teacher was of the type that fairly bubbles over with a contagious 
enthusiasm for his subject. Accordingly I found myself inspired 
with an eagerness to make myself master of that subject. There 
was aroused in me a love for that particular branch of culture that 
I feel will never die. There were impressions made and thoughts 
awakened that have been, and are, a source of much pleasure to 
me. That is what the "human element" in the profession of 
teaching can accomplish. 

Not considering the elements of intellectual attainment, manli- 
ness or womanliness, and other necessary qualities that make a 
professor a power for good, it is this rare "human element" which 
so captivates the average college student and evokes his deepest 


The test of good humor is the ability to take a joke on oneself 
with equanimity and enjoyment. The article reprinted in this 
issue by courtesy of The Independent is a really good joke on all 
folk engaged in alumni work. We naturally emphasize to the ex- 
treme the importance of the alumni. We are constantly telling 
the trustees, the faculty, the undergraduates and the alumni them- 
selves, how wonderful the alumni body is. So when an occasional 
alumnus becomes inflated by his own importance and starts in to 
try and run the college the source of the ' ' hot air ' ' that caused his 
inflation is generally the alumni office. Naturally most of the 
wrath of the puffed-up gentleman aroused by the strange apathy 
exhibited by college administrators to his fulminations descends on 
the heads of the alumni executives. Thus is the punishment made 
to fit the crime and the joke is decidedly on us. 

The article alluded to above is chuck-full of real truth and there 
is no alumni secretary but must admit he can name "page and 
paragraph" in his own alumni records where a specific instance 
can be found to fit every one of the author's cases or generalities. 
You would not believe that human beings lived so devoid of per- 
spective as to be able to say to a college, ''If you don't do as I 
want you to I will cancel my endowment subscription." You 
would think that the very asininity of it would prevent any man 
from saying, ''Just as soon as you do things my way I will sup- 
port the college, but not before," yet these things actually are said 
by alumni of every college. The fact that a man is a thousand 
miles away from the campus and has not seen the old place for 
twenty years does not stop him for a minute from outlining min- 
utely just "the medicine the patient needs." Yea, verily, and he 
is mad as the devil if the old fogy of a college won't swallow 
the dose at once and immediately declare that it feels much bet- 
ter. Of course the fact that a college with ten thousand graduates 
would have to travel ten thousand widely varying paths if it were 
to attempt to use the road maps favored by each alumnus never 
occurs to this chap with the distorted perspective. He just says, 


36 Butler Alumnal Quarterly 

" I am running a highly successful brick-yard and if they will just 
model the old college on my patterns they will turn out as good 
graduates as I turn out bricks." Yet, if the college president or 
any of the professors would try to tell him how to run his business 
he would be more than mildly scornful of such inexperienced 

The truth is the business of education is as complicated as any 
other business and as highly specialized as any industry. The lay- 
man can't run it any more than he can any other business with 
which he is unacquainted. Alumni often can make illuminating 
suggestions and point out faults which need correction but they 
must study the educational game in general and their own college 
in particular very intensively before they can hope to give sound 

Generally speaking, running a college is like running any other 
business. You need a darned good manager who knows said busi- 
ness from the ground up. Having found such a man you give him 
freedom of action and every support possible. The one thing you 
don't do, if you have any business acumen at all, is to hamper him 
by insisting that he change his ideas and methods to conform to 
any chance notion that you or any other stockholder may have. 
You thank God you have been lucky enough to land a man who 
knows his business just as Lehigh's trustees and alumni are giving 
thanks for our luck in landing a man like Dr. Richards to manage 

However, one thing always remains true — it is a lot better to 
have an alumnus who is sufficiently interested to make a kick than 
one who never complains because he doesn't care anything about 
the place. Personally I always welcome kicks. When I receive 
one I know that I have probably found another man who will do 
some work for Lehigh. — Copied from the LehigJi Alumni Bulletin. 


By George A. Schumacher, '25 

Far removed from the noise and bustle of the world, on the top 
of a mountain and reposing in stately elegance in the beautiful 
Piedmont section of Virginia, is located Monticello. Here for 
many years lived Thomas Jefferson amid the glories of old Colonial 
days in the place which is becoming day by day a national 
shrine. As one gazes far off into the surrounding blue haze, the 
lovely Blue Ridge mountains are seen on every side, emphasizing 
the appropriateness of the name "Monticello" — the Italian "little 
mountain. ' ' 

Monticello is a most interesting place, fairly abounding in the 
wonderful days of the past. An atmosphere of reverence seems to 
envelope the grounds. Surrounding the old residence is a large 
terrace, to construct which Mr. Jefferson removed soil to a depth of 
thirty feet from the crest of the mountain. Now as one strolls over 
the front lawn large trees provide shelter. Formerly the house 
was undoubtedly exposed, but two large linden trees planted by 
Mr. Jefferson today flourish on the lawn. 

The house, as it appears from the exterior, is a beautiful brick 
structure with green shutters on the windows of the first floor. 
The bricks were manufactured on the premises while the shutters 
are said to be the originals used upon the completion of the home. 
To enter this shrine one passes to a large, open porch through por- 
tals of sandstone imported from England. Directly above the 
porch ceiling is a large compass, one of the many practical things 
about the place. 

Over the door is a great double-faced clock which showed the 
time of day to a person who chanced to be either on the outside of 
the house or within. To wind this clock Mr. Jefferson used a 
crank instead of the customary key. Attached to the clock was 
a huge gong which, we are told, could be heard at a distance of 
three miles. This timepiece was also a useful calendar as it kept 
account of the days of the week. 

In the days of his residence at Monticello, Mr. Jefferson used 


38 Butler Alumnal Quarterly 

the present main hall as his living room. The eye now rests upon 
a queer looking apparatus resembling a pole. Close observation 
shows it to be a folding ladder which the master of the house de- 
signed for convenience in ascending to the clock when it needed 

Only six original pieces of furniture remain in the home. One 
of these is the violin stand which Mr. Jefferson made with his own 
hands. This great man is known to have been a lover of music 
and he played the violin exceptionally well. During his busy 
student days when he is reported to have studied fifteen hours 
daily, this versatile youth often praticed three hours a day. When 
his home ' ' Shadwell ' ' burned in mid-winter of 1770, a fact which 
made necessary the hurried completion of " Monticello, " the only 
thing saved was his violin. Before passing out of the old living- 
room the visitor inspects one of America's sacred relics. On a 
flag-draped stand is the individual gig in which Mr. Jefferson rode 
when he made the journey from Monticello to Philadelphia to 
write the Declaration of Independence. 

One passes through beautiful folding doors to enter the drawing 
room. The simultaneous operation of these doors shows a further 
proof of the inventive genius of Mr. Jefferson. The beauty of the 
drawing room is enhanced by a beautiful floor composed of walnut, 
cherry and beech wood blocks eight inches thick and fitted com- 
pactly together. 

The dining room is large. Could the walls speak they would 
surely tell many interesting tales about the great master and his 
distinguished guests who gathered here. Over the table is a large 
skylight. Upon investigating the secrets of this room one finds a 
most interesting convenience and "relic". On the south side of 
the fireplace is concealed a dumbwaiter which Mr. Jefferson oper- 
ated with his foot by a spring under the table. By this means he 
brought up from the cellar his choice wines. One side of the 
elevator held the new and full bottle while the other half could take 
care of the empty bottle — further ingenuity. 

An interesting sight in the house is the narrow stairways. It is 
reported that after Mr. Jefferson had designed his house and 


building operations were well advanced he suddenly realized that 
stairways were needed to enable one to reach the upper floor. Ac- 
cordingly stairs had to be inserted in the very narrow space which 
could at this late time be spared. The steps are not only exceed- 
ingly narrow but are also very steep. 

The reader of this article as well as the visitor to Monticello 
must remember that not only was Mr, Jefferson a very able and 
interesting man, but also a most important citizen. Furthermore, 
he lived a great part of his life in troublous times. This fact is 
recognized when one visits the bed-chamber of Mr. Jefferson and 
observes the precautions that were adopted for his safety. High 
up in the wall and overlooking his bed were three loopholes which 
contained the pictures of George Washington, James Madison and 
James Monroe. Secreted in an alcove behind these pictures, body- 
guards watched over the master of Monticello in his hours of 

The bed was placed in a compartment dividing the room from 
his study. Therefore if Mr. Jefferson cared to go directly from 
his bed to his study he had only to leave by the left side. To 
enter his dressing room required only that he place himself to the 
right of his bed. During the day the bed was pulled up to the 
ceiling and this permitted him to pass freely at any time between 
his bedroom and his study. In his study there remain two original 
wall shelves which were used as writing desks. 

On both sides of the house may be found conservatories with 
French windows. Adjoining the conservatory on the west wing is 
the breakfast room of Mrs. Jefferson. In the east wing is the 
library of Mr. Jefferson, a spacious room containing the original 
fireplace. Fireplaces, unusually small, are found in nearly all of 
the rooms. Including the basement the house contains thirty-five 

On June 4, 1781, Monticello was thrown into consternation when 
a messenger brought word that the British were approaching. Mr. 
Jefferson immediately sent the family to a place fifteen miles dis- 
tant while he remained to secure some important papers. The 

40 Butler Alumnal Quarterly 

message proved to be authentic and in time a party of the British 
v/ere seen approaching. With dashing boldness, a captain rode into 
the house. The prints from the shoes of the horse may still be 
seen where the sharp iron cut into the floor. Meanwhile an almost 
melodramatic episode was occurring. Mr. Jefferson, by means of a 
tunnel which he required his servants to use, entered the under- 
ground passageway and proceeded to its termination where he 
mounted a waiting horse and escaped from the very hands of the 

When Mr. Jefferson was sixty-five years of age he retired to 
Monticello. His fame brought distinguished visitors from all over 
the world to the place where everyone is now permitted to visit. 
Both James Madison and James Monroe came to Monticello for 
visits and each man had special rooms which are now designated 
by the names of these men. Being so far removed from the world 
in this mountain home, visits were often of long duration and 
many were the gay scenes. However, in the midst of his loving 
and distinguished company Mr. Jefferson would not allow his 
guests to rob him of the hours which he devoted to work in his 
library or on his farm. He said, '"The sun has not caught me in 
bed for fifty years," consequently Monticello saw the master up 
and about at an early hour. 

The south terrace sloping to the rear of the house has a beauti- 
ful lawn. Running under the ground is the passageway used by 
the servants. This removed the domestics from sight and permitted 
absolute privacy for the family whenever they cared to use the 
lawn. On the west side of the house the tunnel extends to the ice- 
house. On the southeastern side of the back lawn is a small brick 
house which was used as a residence while the completion of the 
present home was rushed. Directly across the terrace is a similar 
small brick structure which was used by Mr. Jefferson as his law 
library. The servant-quarters consisted of small rooms built into 
the sides of the terrace. On a lower terrace, in a place exposed to 
the morning and noonday sun, is the plot of ground devoted by Mr. 
Jefferson to the cultivation of flowers and at another spot is the site 


of the old vegetable garden. At the present time the flower garden 
is being restored. 

Here, then, in this quiet beautiful spot amid delightful surround- 
ings lived Thomas Jefferson. Public duties called him to many 
places and it was often necessary for him to be absent much of 
the time. His final years were spent here but even during his 
absences it is certain that the spirit of the master permeated the 
premises. He said at one time, "All my wishes end, where I hope 
my days will end — at Monticello. " 

The visitor is loath to leave Monticello. After he proceeds for 
perhaps a quarter of a mile down the rustic mountain road, a 
graveyard is reached. This contains the remains of the third 
President of the United States and many of his descendants. One 
approaches this sacred spot by leaving the road and walking up 
moss-covered brick steps. Within the gate and facing the old walk 
is the grave of the great man. It is covered with a large granite 
monument and on the shaft are engraved these words : 













42 Butler Alumnal Quarterly 


By Clarence L. Goodwin 

We may have sliced our drives today, 
We may have topped our brassie lies, 

We may have dug our irons deep, 
And scattered divots at the skies. 

We may have shot them into traps. 
And smote the diabolic sand, 

And cussed the dub who left his track 
Just where our ball has chanced to land. 

We may have run them 'cross the green, 
Or putted short or rimmed the cup. 

We may have played them to the rough 
And run the score still up and up. 

But ah ! There '1] be another time, 
Hope casts her ever pleasing spell, 

Next day we'll have a new white card, 
There'll be another tale to tell. 

Some happy time in days to come, 

Some day, some day, we shall contrive, 

To put them where they ought to be, 
And shoot the course in eighty-five! 

So in life's game we mar the score. 
So much we try and fail to do. 

Too oft we slice our main intent, 

Instead of shooting straight and true. 

Each day we get a clean white card. 

Resolved that now we will not fail. 
Each morning brings another chance, 

Each evening tells another tale. 

Too many good aims putted short. 
Too many shots that don't get home. 

Too many other fellows cussed, 
For faults that mostly are our own. 

But, ever hoping, may we be 
Determined always more and more. 

That on our final card of life 
We may turn in a worthwhile score. 



Published by the Alumni Association of Butler College, Indianapolis. 

Subscription price, two dollars per year. 

Entered as second-class matter, March 26, 1912, at the post office at Indi- 
anapolis, Indiana, under the Act of March 3, 1879. 

OflScers of the Alumni Association — President, Edwin E. Thompson, '00 j First 
Vice-President, Elizabeth Bogert Schofield, '09; Second Vice-President, 
Myron Hughel, '17; Treasurer, Charles W. Wilson; appointees, Urith 
Dailey, '17, and Esther Fay Shover, '00. 

Secretary and Editor of the Butler Alumnal Quarterly — Katharine M. 
Graydon, '78. 


With deep regret and sense of personal loss the College has seen 
the withdrawal of Coach Page. A genius in his own department, 
a man and a gentleman, he has generally been recognized. Under- 
graduates and alumni from far and near have expressed apprecia- 
tion and gratitude to him. 

The College wanted athletic distinction, and when near six years 
ago athletics were at their lowest ebb brought Mr. Page here. He 
supplied that want in full measure. For this he deserves and has 
received all gratitude and praise. President Aley voiced general 
sentiment when he said: "Mr. Page has done a great piece of 
constructive wxrk for Butler in the department of athletics, and I 
have always felt that he was one of the best men in the country 
for the type of work he was doing here. I am sorry to see him go." 

Mr. Page was attached to the school and felt its opportunity. 
His spirit showed itself in expressions made at a recent dinner 
given by the Butler Men's Club, when he said in his own char- 
acteristic manner: 

"It is for the good of the whole scheme that I am leaving." 

"I don't want any one to destroy what we have started to 
build." "I know that you will carry on. You have a fine future. 
You have a reputation to uphold and it is always harder to main- 
tain a reputation than to obtain one. It will take organization, 

44 Butler Alumnal Quarterly 

but you 've got the foundation. You freshmen must stick together. 
That's the way championship teams are made." 

' ' I don 't see why you fellows should feel the way you do. Things 
will go on. I know you will carry on and give the same loyal 
support to my successor that you have given me. I want to go 

"I'm not quitting; I'm only leaving. I've always preached 
'never be a quitter.' I've always been a fighter and sometimes 
I've been in the wrong. That's all in the game. 

"We're only a small part of the plans for the bigger Butler. I 
used to think we were the whole show but I've been educated to 
see the whole scheme, recently. I feel morally obligated to Butler 
College for the opportunity it has given me. The average life of 
a coach at one institution is five years. I've been here six, so you 
see I'm a year to the good. 

"I want to take this opportunity to express my appreciation to 
the Faculty Athletic Committee. You know they have been the 
best friends we've had. Some of the Board of Directors are won- 
derful men and have been splendid. Others have not been athlet- 
ically educated, but they are learning. 

"Athletics teaches us to be good losers. Every one loves and 
cheers the winner. Real sportsmen will back a loser. It is a won- 
derful thing that Butler, several years ago, stuck by and backed 
a loser. 

"We have had years of success. You basketball men have just 
completed a wonderful season. You have won the respect of the 
State and are deserving of the State title. You can look back with 
pride on your record." 

We do look back wdth pride upon the record Coach Page's men 
have made for Butler College. The best wishes of The Quarterly 
go out to Mr. and ]\[rs. Page in all their ways, its esteem and its 


Since the last Quarterly was issued the City Office has had the 
pleasure of reporting a gift of $350,000 from Arthur Jordan, In- 
dianapolis capitalist, manufacturer and philanthropist, to the But- 
ler University building fund. The Board of Directors decided, as 
a tribute to Mr. Jordan 's generosity, to name one of the first build- 
ings at Fairview in his honor and it will be called the Arthur 
Jordan Memorial Hall. 

In connection Avith his gift, which was not the first from Mr. 
Jordan, he expressed the opinion that Butler University was the 
instrumentality through which educational advantages and oppor- 
tunities could be offered to thousands of boys and girls, especially 
in Indianapolis, who might not be able to attend college or uni- 
versity if it became necessary for them to go away from home. 
Mr. Jordan was among the first to see the advantages in such a 
site as Fairview and has been an interested and helpful worker in 
behalf of a greater Butler from the start of the present campaign. 

Tributes were paid to Mr. Jordan at the time of his gift by 
William G. Irwin, of Columbus, chairman of the General Campaign 
Committee, and Louis C. Huesmann, of Indianapolis, chairman of 
the City Campaign Committee. Mr. Irwin recalled that Mr. Jordan 
had given Butler $25,000 a year previous and that he had been 
of assistance in every way possible. Mr. Irwin pointed out that 
every venture in which Mr. Jordan had embarked had been suc- 
cessful and he regarded his support of Butler as a good omen. 
Mr. Huesmann spoke of the effect the gift should have on Indian- 
apolis business interests generally and expressed the hope that 
greater liberality would be shown locally in behalf of Butler. 

Robert Frost Daggett and Thomas E. Hibben, architects for the 
new Butler buildings, have their plans completed sufficiently to 
warrant the announcement that bids likely will be sought in May 
and if this is done actual construction work on the new plant will 
be under way before commencement in June. The first unit of 
construction will include two recitation buildings and a science 
building. The Faculty and the architects have been in conference 


46 Butler Alumnal Quarterly 

with reference to the arrangement of recitation rooms, laboratories 
and the like and members of the Faculty have expressed pleasure 
over the manner in which their ideas will be followed. One of 
the recitation buildings will house the administrative forces until 
the administration building is built. Ample facilities Mall be pro- 
vided for the president, the deans, registrar, secretary, treasurer 
and others of the administrative force. 

Attention is being given to the athletic needs of the university 
and plans are being prepared for a stadium that will seat 25,000 
persons. It will be constructed in such manner that the seating 
capacity may be doubled if necessary. There also will be built a 
combination gymnasium and indoor basketball field, capable of 
seating between 6,000 and 8,000 persons. Arthur V. Brown, chair- 
man of the Athletic Committee of the Board of Directors, hopes 
to have the first football game of the 1927 season played in the 
new stadium. If the rate of progress anticipated on the university 
buildings is made the board hopes to begin classes at Fairview in 
the fall of 1927. 

Work on the boulevard around the campus is progressing and 
will be completed before construction starts on the different build- 

The Rev. C. H. DeVoe, the Rev. R. D. Thomas, the Rev. Herbert 
J. Buchanan and the Rev. W. J. Evans are now working among 
members of the Churches of Christ in Indiana, in behalf of the 
$350,000 needed to finance the building for the Butler College of 
Religion. These field agents, under the general direction of John 
W. Atherton, financial secretary of the university, are reporting 
gratifying progress. Not only are they meeting with success in 
their efforts to raise money for the College of Religion but they 
are bringing the churches in closer touch with the university and 
are obtaining the promise of many additional students for another 

Athletics 47 


Teachers' College of Indianapolis, of which Mrs. Eliza Blaker is 
president, and Butler University are now affiliated as a result of 
negotiations which have been pending some time. 

With the affiliation of the Teachers' College the Irvington school 
has relation with three of Indianapolis 's schools: the Metropolitan 
School of Music and the Ilerron Art Institute. The teacher 's field 
at Butler will be broadened because of the action taken. The 
educational department which has heretofore been only to train 
high school teachers, principals and superintendents will with the 
affiliation afford students an opportunity to study under Mrs. 
Blaker in her classes for prospective kindergarten and grade school 
teachers. A mutual benefit will be derived by both schools, more 
than could be obtained in a special school. 

The affiliation will in no way affect the policies of either school. 
Both will continue under their present heads. Mrs. Blaker has 
said that she is impressed with the plans for the future of Butler 
and in Butler's high standards she has every confidence that all the 
contracts will be in accord with her ideals and standards. 


Meet Mr. Hinkle, the new Director of Athletics! As all eyes 
are turned toward the new Butler head of the department of ath- 
letics, Paul D. Hinkle, a little information about him should be 
of interest to Butler alumni. 

Paul D. Hinkle was born near Logansport in 1899. He was the 
son of a mathematics instiiictor, who incidentally taught this sub- 
ject at Indiana University under Robert J. Aley, then head of the 
mathematics department of that school. The Hinkle family lived 
in Goshen, Indiana; Winona, Minnesota; Madison, Wisconsin; 
Elgin, Illinois, at various times during Paul's boyhood, and finally 
settled down in Chicago, Illinois. Young Mr. Hinkle was then 
about ten years old. 

"Tony", as he was early entitled by his Windy City playmates, 

48 Butler Alumnal Quarterly 

got his start in athletics at Hamilton Park playground system of 

He entered Calumet high school in 1912, and played four years 
of baseball, four of basketball, and three years of soccer, the closest 
thing to football that they had in the school. "Hink" was also a 
trackman, specializing in the 660-yard run and in the shot-put 
during his last two years. A friend who went to Calumet high with 
him remarked recently that Hinkle was not an outstanding athlete 
in school, and that he surprised all his old school mates Vvhen he 
stepped into the limelight in University of Chicago athletics. 

The alleged banana vender was one of the best athletes the 
Chicago University ever had. He won his numerals in football, 
basketball, and baseball, plus a captaincy in the last mentioned 
sport during his first year there. 

During his next three years at the educational institution he 
won letters each year in football, basketball, and baseball. He 
captained the basketball team during the seasons of 1919 and 1920, 
and is the only University of Chicago athlete to be given the honor 
of captaining the same team for two successive seasons. He played 
end in football, guard in basketball and pitcher, shortstop or out- 
fielder in baseball. 

Sports writers picked him on an all-conference football team one 
year, and placed him on all-conference basketball teams three 
years. He had charge of the University of Chicago baseball team 
on its trip to the Orient during his senior year, after Pat Page 
resigned as assistant coach there to go to Butler, although he was 
still playing on the team. A professor acted as Faculty advisor 
on the journey. He coached freshman basketball and was assist- 
ant varsity basketball coach at Chicago during the winter 1920- 

When he came to Butler to assist Coach Page, the freshman 
ruling prohibiting first year men from playing on the first college 
teams had not gone into effect, and he therefore acted as assistant 
coach in football, basketball and varsity baseball. He was not 
officially recognized as varsity baseball coach until last year. With 

Athletics 49 

the passing of the Freshman ruling, "Hink" was put in complete 
charge of the frosh football and basketball candidates. 

Both his freshman football team and the yearling basket squad 
proved themselves to be of more than average strength, the grid- 
men winning both of their contests last season, and the netmen 
breaking even with the strong Franklin frosh hardwood organiza- 


April 16th and 17th — Ohio Relays. 

April 2'3rd and 24th — Drake and Pennsylvania Relays. 

May 1st — Dual Meet at Earlham. 

May 8th — Meet to be arranged. 

May 15th — College Meet at Greencastle. 

May 22nd — State Meet at Bloomington. 

June 4th and 5th — Midwest Meet at Milwaukee. 

June 11th and 12th — National Meet at Chicago. 

April 2nd and 3rd — ^Northwestern at Indianapolis. 
April 10th — Ohio State at Columbus. 
April 14th — Illinois at Urbana. 
April 17th — Chicago at Indianapolis. 
April 23rd — Indiana Central at Indianapolis. 
April 24th — Depauw at Indianapolis. 
April 27th — Franklin at Indianapolis. 
May 1st — Dayton University at Dayton. 
May 4th — Wabash at Crawfordsville. 
May 7th — Kalamazoo College at Kalamazoo. 
May 8th — Michigan State at Lansing. 
May 11th — State Normal at Terre Haute. 
May 14th — Depauw at Greencastle. 
May 15th — Dayton University at Indianapolis. 
May 18th — Franklin at Franklin. 
May 22nd — State Normal at Indianapolis. 
May 28th — Wabash at Indianapolis. 
June 11th — Alumni game and B Men's Banquet. 

50 Butler Alumnal Quarterly 


Making its selections from a field of applicants, representing 
colleges and universities all over the country, the Yale graduate 
school recently named two Butler men among the recipients of 
laboratory assistantships for the school year of 1926-27. The men 
honored are Shailer Bass and T. Clarence Jaleski. Both will serve 
in the chemistry department at Yale. 

This announcement brings the list of Butler students receiving 
similar awards to five. Florence Hooper, an assistant in the botany 
and chemistry departments at Butler, will go to Iowa State Col- 
lege as an assistant in the department of plant chemistry. John 
Mason received award of a scholarship in the department of 
European history at Wisconsin University, and Lowell Mullen a 
fellowship in botany at the State College of Washington. 

Jaleski and Bass, both senior scholars, received invitations for 
next year from several universities. Offers came to Jaleski from 
Yale, Ohio State and Wisconsin. Bass had a choice between Yale 
and Ohio State. Jaleski, who has majored in both chemistry and 
zoology, had the privilege of doing his work at Yale in either of 
these departments. 

The assistantships awarded to the two men each have a cash 
value of $750. 

The honors are considered as being significant as tokens of the 
esteem which the eastern universities have for the quality of work 
done at Butler. It is known that many of Yale's own undergrad- 
uate students were candidates for these awards. Victor Twitty, 
who went to Yale from Butler last year as an assistant in the 
department of zoology, has been highly successful in his work 
there, according to reports from New Haven, and this is believed 
to have reflected credit upon the high academic standards of Butler. 

*'I am gratified," said Prof. Shadinger, head of the Chemistry 
department, ''because this indicates that Butler's work is of the 
highest quality. Besides, it proves that scholarship has its re- 
wards no less than athletics or any other field of endeavor." 

These appointments are gratifying to the College, not only be- 

A Loved Landmark 51 

cause of deserved individual recognition but also because it is 
an avowed acknowledgment that Butler is performing a type of 
educational service which places her abreast of the best in the 
academic world. 

Postscript : Since going to press word has been received at the 
College of the winning of a $1,000 essay prize by Miss Janet 
Rioch, '26. This prize was offered by the American Chemical So- 
ciety. The contest is open to undergraduates in any college in the 
country and is an annual event. Contestants are permitted to 
choose one of six subjects on which to write. Miss Rioch chose 
"The Relation of Chemistry to Health and Disease." Secretary 
Herbert Hoover is chairman of the committee which conducted the 

]\Iiss Rioch is the daughter of David Rioch, '98, and Mrs. Rioch, 
missionaries in India. She will prepare herself to return to her 
native home as medical missionary. 


In a recent Butler Collegian the sentiments of the Quarterly 
were thus expressed : 

''On this campus there is a boulder that has become something 
of a landmark. Years ago it was taken from Irwin field when this 
land was being prepared for athletic purposes. Since then it has 
rested upon the corner of Butler and University avenues near the 
door of the present gymnasium. There is graven upon it hundreds 
of initials and class numerals. The surface of the stone has been 
worn smooth by the students who have paused to rest upon it dur- 
ing the balmy days of many springs and many summers. 

Within a year or two at best, Butler will have moved to Fair- 
view, and unless something is done in the meantime to save the 
old rock, it will probably be broken to pieces or carted away and 
lost to sight and memory. 

The opportunity which presents itself by which the old stone 
may be both preserved and used for a fitting purpose is a fortunate 

52 Butler Alumnal Quarterly 

circumstance. What would make Hilton U. Brown, Jr., happier 
than the knowledge that the stone which came from the field upon 
which he played as an athlete before he joined the colors should 
bear the record of his name and deed ? In what better way could 
Butler honor herself and her soldier dead than by presenting this 
stone to the city for the purpose named "1 

In 1917, Brown was one of the most promising men on the Butler 
campus. He was a scholar, an athlete, a gentleman and a friend 
to all who knew him. He died in battle like a man and a hero, and 
Butler was poorer for the loss." 

So, the landmark will soon be placed on the triangle at the cor- 
ner of Washington street and Emerson avenue, donated by Mr. 
H. U. Brown to the Indianapolis Park Board, in sight of loved 
home and native village, bearing' in bronze this dedication: 

In memory of 

Lieutenant Hilton U. Brown, Jr., 

Who played at mimic warfare on 

these grounds 

and who 

November 3, 1918, 

In the language of Petain, Marshal 

of France, 
Died gloriously in Argonne while 
serving his battery against con- 
centrated enemy fire. 
7th F. A., First Division 


There has been placed in a section of cases in the Bona Thomp- 
son Library the Charles W. Moores Ijincoln Collection, given to 
Butler College last October by Miss Emily Bishop Moores in mem- 
ory of her father. 

This collection, which is made up of books, pictures, documents 

MooREs' Lincoln Collection 53 

and souvenirs, is one of the finest, if not the finest, of its kind in 
the State. 

More than three hundred volumes on various phases of Lin- 
coln's career, besides many cases of pamphlets, have been placed 
upon the shelves of the College Library. The standard biography 
of Lincoln by his secretaries, J. G. Nicolay and John Hay, is in 
ten volumes, and his complete works are in twelve volumes. These 
alone complete a valuable addition to the library. Among the 
equipment Lincoln authorities are Carl Schurz. Ida M. Tarbell, 
Lord Charnwood and William E. Barton. 

One of the three especially good pictures of Lincoln has been 
hung in the south reading room of the library near the case con- 
taining the books. Among the souvenirs is a piece of wood from 
the Lincoln cabin. There is also a framed notice written and 
signed by Lincoln in the suit of Pearson and Anderson versus Bird 
Monroe, a case which was filed in the circuit court of Coles county, 
Illinois, May 24, 18-12. Mr. Moores was the author of several books 
and pamphlets on Lincoln, the most notable of which is the "Life 
of Abraham Lincoln for Boys and Girls." The manuscripts of 
these books and Mr. Moores' personal correspondence with the 
various Lincoln authorities and collectors of Lincolniana were in- 
cluded in the collection and constitute valuable research material. 


By Frances M. Perry 

A new text on Story- Writing just issued by Henry Holt and 
Company, is of especial interest to Indianapolis people as it is 
written by Miss Frances Perry, an Indianapolis woman. Miss 
Perry is a graduate of Shortridge High School and of Butler Col- 
lege. All students of the early nineties remember Fanny Perry. 
She was graduated in the class of '91, and was a member of the 
old Demia Butler Society when that organization was in its hey- 

54 Butler Alumnal Quarterly 

day. Miss Perry 's book is dedicated to ' ' My Students in the Uni- 
versity of Arizona and Wellesley College". From teaching a short 
time in Shortridge, Miss Perry went as instructor to Wellesley, 
where she became professor of English Composition and later was 
invited to the University of Arizona as head of the English Com- 
position department. Miss Perry visited friends in Indianapolis 
last June on her way to California after spending her sabbatical 
year's leave of absence from the University in teaching again at 

Miss Perry's book is praised in very high' terms by competent 
critics. As a text it has certain outstanding qualities that differ- 
entiate it from other texts. It combines a recognition of the stand- 
ard, approved masters of story telling with a sureness, freshness 
and daring in selection of present day writers. The book is char- 
acterized by more than the usual definiteness in the gradual pro- 
gression of its assignments toward mastery of the types of writing 
illustrated. The difference and variety in specimen is such that 
students are obliged to experiment in several widely different 
types of writing and so have an opportunity to discover their real 
aptitude instead of being inclined to adopt early mannerisms of 
style. The assignments in this volume are more specific than in 
the usual texts, the advantage being that the entire class is set to 
writing with a common aim and the resultant criticism and dis- 
cussion of one member's work will therefore be profitable and in- 
teresting to all. The general method proposed with careful direc- 
tions is that of intensive study of the technique of the authors 
suggested so that the student understands what the writer has 
tried to do and how and why he has done it. 

Miss Perry's text is, I believe, the only one where the author 
has perceived and pointed out the value of learning from the old 
ballads how to find subjects for a story that will stand the test of 
time and how to make life picturesque and poignant. The chapter 
on "The Ballad Writers" is an interesting contribution to bolii 
composition and literature teachers. 

The book seems to me admirably fitted to aid writers to acquire 
and develop literary intelligence and style. The power to touch 

Butler Day in Chicago 55 

with ease, grace and precision any note in the gamut of human 
thought or emotion, Sir Arthur Quiller Couch has said, is literary 
style, and Miss Perry's book affords opportunity to learn how 
men's varied thoughts and feelings have been given expression 
that endures. EVELYN M. BUTLER. 

By Howard W. Odum and D. W. Willard 

"The County as a Unit for Public Welfare and Social Work" 
is the title of a chapter contributed by Professor Howard E. Jensen 
of Butler College to a new book, "Systems of Public Welfare," 
published by the University of North Carolina Press, under the 
co-authorship of Howard W. Odum and D. W. Willard. The book 
is a compilation of useful information about the scope and plans 
of the several state systems of public welfare work. Professor 
Jensen presents a valuable historical sketch of the recent develop- 
ment of public welfare work organized on a county unit basis 
rather than a state or municipal basis, and explains several dis- 
tinct advantages of the county as the logical though neglected unit 
for public welfare and social work. 


Announcement is made by D. Appleton & Company of the early 
appearance of a volume entitled "The God of the Liberal Chris- 
tian", written by D. S. Robinson, '10, now head of department of 
philosophy in Miami University. In 1924 the same publishers 
issued ' ' The Principles of Reasoning ; an Introduction to Logic and 
Scientific Method" by Daniel Sommer Robinson. 


March 13 was "Butler Day" at the Salon of Indiana Artists. 
Two things combined to make this a memorable occasion in the 
history of the Butler College Club of Chicago: one was the very 
interesting Indiana Art Exhibit; the other was Miss Graydon's 
presence in our midst. 

56 Butler Alumnal Quarterly 

It was with no small amount of interest that twenty-seven But- 
lerites (with others dropping in later) gathered together for 
luncheon, and for hearing Miss Graydon's talk on present-day af- 
fairs at the Alma Mater: — the large numbers, the growth of en- 
dowment and building funds, the atheletic outlook since the resig- 
nation of Mr. Page, and other things we were all eager to hear. 
She made various definite suggestions as to the possible accomplish- 
ments of our Club, and closed asking us not to stand back and 
coldly criticize our College, but help her, think for her, feel for 
her, pray for her, for she is a living being with mind and heart and 
soul, and she is putting up a brave fight. These suggestions in 
the light of Miss Graydon's own loyalty and devotion met with a 
ready response in the group that sat listening. 

As Hoosiers, we have a special interest in the Art and Artists 
of Indiana. The Butler College Club of Chicago shared in the ex- 
hibit to the extent of raising a prize fund of fifty dollars which 
was awarded by the jury to Mr. Carl C. Graf of Indianapolis. This 
prize picture was a beautiful landscape in oils entitled "Gray 
Misty Morning". After the luncheon a tour of the galleries was 
made by the Butler people conducted by Mr. Edgar Forkner, win- 
ner of the first prize in water colors. The exhibit made by over 
three hundred and fifty artists was one of which all Hoosiers might 
well be proud. 

Those present at the luncheon were: 

Miss Katharine Merrill Graydon, Mr. and Mrs. Lawrence W. 
Bridge, Mr. and Mrs. Clifford H. Browder, Mr. Henry P. Bruner, 
Mr. and Mrs. Frank Davison, Mrs. Hope W. Graham, Miss Flora 
N. Hay, Mr. and Mrs. Frank F. Hummel, Mrs. Edith Habbe Marx, 
Mr. and Mrs. Charles F. McElroy, Dr. Earl McRoberts, Mrs. 
Gwyneth Harry Meyer, Mrs. Cornelia Thornton Morrison, Dr. 
Elam T. Murphy, Mr. M. 0. Naramore, Mr. and Mrs. H. N. Rogers, 
Mr. Frank Sanders, Miss Helen Schell, Mr. Carl Turner. 

But it was the presence of her who so completely embodies the 
living spirit of Butler that made the occasion for all of us — in 
reality as well as in name — "Butler Day". 

Secretary, Butler College Club of Chicago. 


The activities of the League, organized three years ago, have 
accomplished much on the' campus in the interest of the women. 

At the first meeting of the present year a beautiful Freshman 
Scholarship Cup was presented to that Freshman girl who had 
maintained the highest average during the preceding year. Jane 
Ogborn was the recipient. This Cup will be handed down year by 
year to the one who has achieved like honor. 

As the League purposes to support all worthy student enterprises 
it also governs the activities of the women engaging in them. This 
year the activity point system has been arranged with a view to 
limiting the number of offices which a girl may hold, thus dividing 
responsibility among the women in school. It is gratifying to state 
that several colleges have written to Butler for a statement of this 
plan to help formulate a similar system in their institution. 

A bazaar was held on December 5, the profits of which added to 
that in the Trust Fund for a Woman's Building increased the 
amount to over one thousand dollars. Another committee is work- 
ing to raise funds to purchase a piano for the chapel. The matinee 
programs have been of unusual interest consisting of such numbers 
as: a talk by Mrs. Beulah Brown Fletcher, member of the The- 
atrical Press Representatives; a musicale with Mrs. Newell Brown 
of Columbus soloist, and Miss Elsie Sweeney accompanist; the en- 
tertainment for Riley Day of William Hough of Greenfield, cousin 
of James Whitcomb Riley ; pleasant chalk talk by Chic Jackson ; a 
lecture by Professor E. Merrill Root of Earlham College on "James 
Stephens, Ireland's Poet"; a talk by Bert F. Merling, director of 
the Indianapolis Theatre Guild, on "The Scope, History and Pos- 
sibilities of Pantomime ; " a delightful talk on ' ' Poetry and the Ice 
Man" by Meredith Nicholson. The League was also highly favored 
by having as its guest Dr. Aurelia Henry Reinhardt, president of 
Mills College and of the American Association of University 

Through the efforts of the Matinee Program Committee a suc- 
cessful Citizenship School was held for two days in March at the 


58 Butler Alumnal Quarterly 

Propylaeum, for the purpose of stimulating interest in civic gov- 
ernment on the part of women. Among the speakers on the pro- 
gram were Henry Bentley of Cincinnati; Miss Charlotte Conover 
of Dayton; Professor Howard E. Jensen of Butler College, also of 
Indianapolis, E. 0. Snethen, James A. Rohbach, Walter Myers, R. 
Walter Jarvis and others. Dean Evelyn Butler was toastmistress 
at the banquet. This Citizenship School was held introductory to 
the organization of a League of Women Voters in Butler, a step 
toward educating students in non-partisan political matters. 

The final activity of the year will be the annual May Day cele- 
bration to be held at Fairview on May 21, or, if the weather be 
inclement, on May 24. The Athletic department promises a big 
inter-class track meet in the morning. From eleven to one o'clock 
a breakfast-luncheon, fifty cents, will be served. Mr. Atherton 
promises a celebration in connection with the formal opening of 
some department of the University. The Butler Band will be on 
hand. In the afternoon an elaborate mediaeval pageant will be 
presented, immediately following which will be the installation of 
the new officers of the League. The program of the full day wiU 
close with a dance. 

The alumni are most cordially invited to participate in our 

President of the Women's League. 


An appeal goes forth for the Alumni Scholarship Fund. The 
value of this movement is two-fold: it pays the tuition of worthy 
students (this year two) who otherwise could not have academic 
advantages; and it asks for an expression from every former stu- 
dent, not some great impossible amount, but just what he feels he 
can give, thus forming a bond of union between classes and indi- 

The readers of the Quarterly have received letters from their 
class secretaries stating the above facts. All have not been an- 

Commencement 59 

swered. If the secretary's name and address have been forgotten, 
send replies to Miss Graydon, Butler College. She will see the 
contribution is rightly placed. As the year nears its close kindly 
attend to this matter without delay. Do not expect your class sec- 
retary to write a second time. 

It has been pleasant to receive memorial gifts as have come in 
the name of Oliver Romeo Johnson, 78, and in the name of Kath- 
arine Jameson Lewis, '16. It is hoped increasingly such response 
may be made to the fund for remembrance of those who loved the 
College while here. 


The Commencement program will open with the Phi Kappa Phi 
dinner on the evening of June 11. Class Day and Alumni Re- 
unions and Supper on Saturday, the 12th. Baccalaureate sermon 
on Sunday afternoon, the 13th. Fuller announcements will be 
made known later. It is hoped there will be an unusually large 
return of alumni, for the number of gatherings to be held on the 
old campus is narrowing to very few. The caU, therefore, goes 
forth — Come back! 


The class of 1890 is making elaborate preparations, as it knows 
how to make, for its thirty-sixth anniversary to be held in connec- 
tion with Commencement, June 12-14. This class has the unusual 
record of having no name starred on its membership list and it is 
earnestly hoped that each of the eighteen will be able to be present. 

Other anniversaries to be especially observed are by the class of 
1875, the class of 1901, the class of 1916, the class of 1921. 


A ''Drift" that promises to surpass all previous local efforts 
will be distributed May 25. Wilson Daily is editor and Lucy 

60 Butler Alumnal Quarterly 

Ashjian, associate editor. A new note is struck in the subversion 
of activities to art, this work being student product, under Wal- 
lace Richards, by advanced students of John Herron. 

The book is divided into seven sections: Academic, Personnel, 
Sports, Extra-curricular, Fraternities, Law and Advertising. 

Academies, comprising the first thirty-two pages, editor, Jabez 
Wood, is the ''feature" section, revolutionizing conventional treat- 
ment of the ex-libris, foreword and dedication pages and stressing 
learning as the ultimate in college. Hand lettering, color initial 
letters, pen sketches and three-color plates feature it. A medieval 
design is the central theme throughout the book. 

Personnel, containing 1,000 class and faculty photographs, fol- 
lows, managed by Martha Zoercher. 

In the Athletic section, the only humor of the annual is ably 
carried out in the sub-division pages, edited by Joseph Helms. 

Club write-ups account for twenty pages of the total 320. Group 
and mount pictures with identifications follow each editorial ac- 
count. Editor, Billie Mae Kreider. 

The Greeks are given prominence in the ''Fraternities" section, 
by Maude Searcy. 

Sixteen pages are devoted to the Indiana Law School, handled 
by the art section. 

The concluding pages comprise the $1,500 advertising section, 
under Ralph Hitch. 

The covers are of Malloy manufacture, vermillion with gold 
edges. The Butler seal decorates the front cover. The paper is a 
special Strathmore deckle-edged stock of sepia tint. Engraving is 
by the Indianapolis Engraving Company and printing by William 
Mitchell of Greenfield. 

About 700 copies have been sold and it is hoped that 1,000 will 
be by date of issuance. 

The staff editing this year's book is working whole-heartedly to- 
ward the production of another prize winner; rewinning the Art 
Crafts Guild contest means permanent retention of the 1925 award. 


Miss Mattie Empson, '12, is living in West Palm, Beach, Florida. 

Mrs., W. B. Parks (Mattie Wade, '84), is living in Pittsburg, 

Miss Virginia Kingsbury, '18, spent the month of February in 

There are 1,369 students enrolled in the College for the present 

Miss Lena Weitknecht, '25, is teaching History in the Kokomo 
High School. 

George A. Smith, '20, is principal of the high school in West- 
field, New Jersey. 

Henry P. Bruner, '23, is connected with the Midland Utilities 
Company of Chicago. 

President and Mrs. Aley have returned from a ten-weeks' visit 
in California and Hawaii. 

Miss Sarah E. Cotton, registrar of the College, took a two weeks' 
respite in March in Miami, Florida. 

Frank M. Sanders, ex- '20, is connected with the American Post- 
office Equipment Company of Chicago. 

B. F. Dailey, '87, and Mrs. Dailey have returned to Irvington 
from the winter spent in southern California. 

Wood linger, '12, assistant professor in English, speaks fre- 
quently upon topics making for Good Citizenship. 

Miss Corinne Welling, '12, after several weeks spent in Roches- 
ter, Minnesota, is convalescing at her home in Indianapolis. 

Miss Nellie Moorman, a former student, is teaching history in 
the Western High School of Washington and living at the Cairo 


62 Butler Alumnal Quarterly 

Mrs. Florence McHatton Moffett has bought a home in Irving- 
ton, at 72 North Layman avenue, where she and her four sons are 

Mrs. Mary Padou Young, '18, is spending the year in New York 
City where she and Mr. Young are working at Columbia Uni- 

Dr. Rufus M. Jones of Haverford College delivered in the chapel 
in March three lectures upon "The Nature and Value of Mystical 

Miss Ethel R. Curryer, '97, has been elected treasurer of the 
Settlement School the Pi Beta Phi Sorority supports in Gatlinburg, 

John Orus Malott, ex- '17, has been appointed a specialist in 
commercial education in connection with the Bureau of Education 
in Washington. 

Miss Fannie Miner, ex- '06, is connected with the Massachusetts 
Mutual Insurance Company located in the Continental Building 
of Indianapolis. 

Roger W. Wallace, '09, is associated with Thomas A. Berling in 
the general contracting business in Miami Beach, Florida, with 
offices at 835 Lincoln Road. 

Stanley Sellick, '16, received last June his B. D. degree from 
Yale University. He holds a pastorate in Lebanon, Conn., where 
he and his family are living. 

Joseph Ostrander, ex- '15, has left Indianapolis for an indefinite 
period to live in Albuquerque, New Mexico. He has been joined 
by Mrs. Ostrander and little daughter. 

Claris Adams, ex- '10, is candidate for nomination for United 
States Senator, long term, at the next primaries ; while Oscar Ryan, 
ex- '11, of Anderson, has announced himself as candidate for the 
short term of Senatorship. 

Personal Mention 63 

Miss Maria Leonard, '06, Dean of Women at University of Illi- 
nois, will be the principal speaker at the Pi Beta Phi Founders' 
Day luncheon on April 24 in Indianapolis. 

Professor W. L. Richardson represented Butler College at 
the meetings of the National Education, being especially inter- 
ested in the sessions of the department of education. 

Mrs. David 0. Thomas of Minneapolis, daughter of Mr. Ovid 
Butler, is visiting Indianapolis friends on her migration from 
Florida, where she spent the winter, to her northern home. 

At the recent election of officers the Butler Men's Club chose 
for president. Earl T. Bowham C'Tow") ; for vice-president, R. 
W. Thompson; for secretary-treasurer, Theodore Davenport. 

On March 1 announcement was made that Austin V. Clifford, 
'17, had become a member of the law firm of Matson, Carter, Ross 
& McCord, with offices at 947 Consolidated Building, Indianapolis. 

Bloor Schleppy, ex- '12, who has been with the public relations 
department of the New Orleans Electric Bond Company for sev- 
eral years, has been appointed secretary of the Chicago Local of 
the American Newspaper Publishers' Association. 

Officers of the Women's Faculty Club elected for the ensuing 
year are : president, Mrs. J. W. Putnam ; 1st vice-president. Miss 
Evelyn Butler; 2nd vice-president, Mrs. Gino Ratti; secretary, 
Mrs. Parr Armstrong; treasurer, Miss AUegra Stewart; corre- 
sponding secretary, Mrs. Frederick Kershner. 

Marshall Davis, '90, and Mrs. Davis (Emma Johnson, '94) of 
Miami University, have been spending their sabbatical year in 
Europe. Dr. Davis took a course of lectures in Cambridge where 
he finished his textbook in physiology and then went to Naples 
where he is doing research work in the Biological Station. 

Rev. Milo J. Smith, former student, has resigned his pastorate 
of the Centenary Christian Church and gone to San Francisco to 
become superintendent of missions for the Christian Church in 

64 Butler Alumnal Quarterly 

northern California. Mrs. Smith and children will remain in In- 
dianapolis until the summer. 

Dean Evelyn Butler attended the annual meeting of the Deans 
of Women held in connection with the National Education Asso- 
ciation in Washington from February 22 to 25. She was on the 
program and received the honor of election to the treasurership of 
the National Association of Administrative Women in Education. 

Oscar C. Ries, '25, will conduct a Students' Tour under the man- 
agement of the McComb Tours. The successful handling of these 
Tours (Miss Virginia McComb, '01), for the past twenty-three 
years is generally recognized by those who wish the best in travel, 
with a minimum of care and annoyance. The McComb Tours are 
affiliated with the Union Trust Company of Indianapolis. 

Paul Randall Wright, ex- '98, war correspondent and world trav- 
eler, has been assigned to the Far East on the foreign staff of the 
Miami Daily News and the Chicago Daily News. He has been a 
member of the editorial staff of the Chicago Daily News for twenty 
years, and during the World War was its accredited correspondent 
with the American expeditionary forces in Siberia. He has trav- 
eled in Japan, Siberia, Russia, China and the Philippines. 

Eugene M. Weesner, '22, wrote from Nebraska: "Here I am 
about eight hundred miles from home, with no chance of getting 
back for another month, and I get an invitation to the Founders' 
Day Banquet! I can't think of anything I'd rather do on Satur- 
day night, or anything more difficult to accomplish. 

"The invitations were beautiful and the program sounds very 
interesting. Best wishes for an exceptionally fine celebration." 

Rev. Stanley R. Grubb, '99, has resigned his work at Columbia, 
South Carolina, and returned to his former pastorate in Athens, 
Georgia. The following editorial comment was made in the SoiotJi 
Carolina Christian : Mr. Grubb is a man of deep conviction, stem 
in his decisions and indefatigable in pushing to a successful conclu- 
sion anything he undertakes. All people respect his convictions, 
admire the stern character and love him because of his never-let-up 

Personal, Mention 65 

propensities of putting over a worth-while job. Men of his strength 
of character will be missed not only in their circle of acquaintance, 
but aii over the State in which they live and act. 

Oscar C. Helming, '88, who is professor of Economics at Carlton 
College, Northfield, Minnesota, recently spent a week-end with his 
mother and sisters in Indianapolis before leaving for Europe on 
his sabbatical year. On his way to New York he stopped at Chicago 
to present a course in "Ethical Aspects of Business" at the Uni- 
versity of Chicago. On February 21 he sailed from New York, 
following the Mediterranean route to Beirut, Syria, where he will 
spend a month or more with his son, Vernon, who is an instructor 
at the American University. From there he will go to England 
and later to the continent to make a study of the economic condi- 
tions in the principal European countries. 

Mr. and Mrs. H. C. Hobgood (Tobitha Alderson, ex- '17), and 
their three children, are spending the spring college term in Irv- 
ington. In September, 1925, they returned to America from their 
mission home at Lotumbe, Belgian Congo, where for several years 
they have been doing evangelistic, industrial and educational work, 
including the making of translations. Mr. Hobgood will receive 
the degree of Master of Arts at the College of Missions in June. 
In the early summer the family will go to Belgium for two or 
three months' study, from where they will return to the Congo. 

Colonel and Mrs. W. H. Tefft and daughter Julia Anne spent 
the months of February and ]\Iarch in Indianapolis on their way 
from a two years stay in the Philippines to their new station at 
Fort Thomas, Kentucky. Mrs. Tefft was formerly Miss Cordelia 
Butler and is the youngest child of Mr. and Mrs. Scot Butler. Dur- 
ing her stay in Indianapolis, Mrs. Ovid McQuat Butler, formerly 
Miss Adele McMaster, came from her home in Washington, D. C, 
and visited Mrs. Carlos Recker. Mrs. Tefft and Mrs. Ovid Butler 
were college friends and charter members of the Kappa Alpha 
Theta Chapter, installed at Butler in 1907. During their stay in 
Indianapolis there were many pleasant reunions of the group of 
girls in college at that time. 

66 Butler Alumnal Quarterly 


Kiser-Weight — On October 23, 1925, were married in Florida 
Mr. William H. Kiser, '24, and Miss Virginia May Wright, of 
St. Louis, Missouri. Mr. and Mrs. Kiser are at home in Indian- 

Gray-Doles — On January 16 were married Mr. Herman B. Gray 
and Miss Helen Doles, ex- '17, in Greensburg, Indiana. Mr. and 
Mrs. Gray are at home in Indianapolis. 

Newman-Pollak — On February 14 were married in Indianap- 
olis Mr. Irving Newman and Miss Anna Pollak, '25. Mr. and Mrs. 
Newman are at home in Indianapolis. 

Habbe-Lewis — On March 10 were married in Neponset, Massa- 
chusetts, Dr. John Edwin Habbe, and Miss Anna Mary Lewis. Dr. 
and Mrs. Habbe are at home in Norfolk, Virginia. 

Heemstra-Hussey — On March 28 were married in Carmel, In- 
diana, Mr. Simon Heemstra and Miss Garnet Kathryn Hussey, '23. 
Mr. and Mrs. Heemstra are at home in Dowagiac, Michigan. 

Cline-Heuss — On April 3 were married in Indianapolis Mr. 
Grady W. Cline and Miss Esther Heuss, '20. Mr. and Mrs. Cline 
are at home in Indianapolis. 


Baker— To Mr. C. M. Baker, '19, and Mrs. Baker (Louise Stew- 
art, '20), on March 16, in Indianapolis, a son — David Stewart. 

Harrison — To Mr. and Mrs. Thomas B. Harrison (Mary Edna 
Shelley, '19), on February 16, in Knoxville, Tennessee, a daughter 
— Edna Louise. 

Harrison — To Mr. William H. Harrison and Mrs. Harrison 
(Josephine Lewis, '22), on February 1, in Indianapolis, a daugh- 
ter — Martha Jo. 

Births 67 

HiLi.— To Mr. Thomas N. Hill, '17, and Mrs. HiU (Elma Alex- 
ander, '16), on March 10, in Fountain City, Indiana, a daughter — 
Marjorie Ann. 

Lentz — To Mr. Richard E. Lentz, '22, and Mrs. Lentz (Ruth Fill- 
more, ex- '21), on July 9, 1925, in Wadsworth, Ohio, a son — Rich- 
ard Edward, Jr. 

Mitchell — To Mr. and Mrs. Mitchell (Marguerite C. Sherwood, 
'25), on November 22, 1925, in Indianapolis, a son — Hugh 
Burton, Jr. 

Nethercutt — To Mr. William R. Nethercutt and Mrs. Nether- 
cutt (Ruth Habbe, '17), on October 23, 1925, a son— Richard 

Rose — To Mr. William Rose and Mrs. Rose (Mildred Kuhn, ex- 
'16), on Janury 25, in Irvington, a daughter — Margaret. 

Wright — To Mr. and Mrs. Wright (Luella Nelson, '19), in Jan- 
uary, in Indianapolis, a daughter — Dorothy Louise. 


The Quarterly extends its sympathy to Dean Frederick D. 
Kershner and Professor Bruce L. Kershner, of the College of Re- 
ligion, in the recent death in Irvington of their mother. 

CuLBERTSON — William D. Culbertson, student at the College 
from 1871- '74, died at his home in Indianapolis in January at the 
age of seventy-four years. He graduated from the Indiana Med- 
ical College and was for a time in the office of Dr. P. H. Jameson. 
Later he practiced medicine in Broad Ripple, but he did not con- 
tinue his practice for long. For a number of years he was salesman 
connected with the Fishback Company. 

Mr. Culbertson is survived by one daughter, Mrs. John S. Fish- 

KiRKPATRiCK — Judge Lcx J. Kirkpatrick, member of the Board 
of Directors of Butler University, died in Indianapolis on March 

68 Butler Alumnal Quarterly 

21 and was buried from his home in Kokomo, Indiana, on the 24th. 
Early in life Mr. Kirkpatrick decided to be a lawyer, and was 
admitted to practice in 1875. As a young man he brought to the 
profession a respect for the fundamentals that was lasting. There 
was a majesty about the law that both inspired and awed him, 
and he conceived it to be one of his greatest privileges to uphold 
not only the Constitution, but the laws that flowed from it. 

Not only as a lawyer, but as a judge as well, did he come in con- 
tact with legal problems. A Democrat in politics, he overcame a 
normally large Republican majority in the circuit then composed 
of Howard and Tipton counties, and was chosen judge. Follow- 
ing an interval during which he practiced law, he was appointed 
judge of the new Howard circuit court. Other lawyers recognized 
Judge Kirkpatrick 's ability and faithfulness. He was honored 
as president of the Howard County Bar Association, as president 
of the Indiana State Bar Association and as vice-president for 
Indiana of the American Bar Association. 

Judge Kirkpatrick took a deep interest in the Constitution con- 
test for which The Indianapolis News has been sponsor in Indiana, 
and believed that it would bring youth into closer contact with the 
basic laws of the nation and cause a greater respect for American 
institutions. He was active as a member of the Christian Church 
and as a leader in industrial affairs. One of Judge Kirkpatrick 's 
greatest interests was Butler University. He was a member of the 
Board of Directors and a generous supporter of the University's 
financial campaign for a new plant. He saw in the law, in his 
church and in the University, opportunities to stress the important 
and worth-while truths of life. His loss will be most keenly felt in 
Kokomo, and the whole State will mourn his passing. — Copied 
from The Indianapolis News. 

LuTZ — The Quarterly extends its sympathy to Miss Juna M. 
Lutz, '17, assistant professor in the department of mathematics, in 
the death of her mother on April 3 at the home in Indianapolis. 

Parker — James I. Parker, student at the College in the early 
seventies, died in New Orleans on February 25, and was buried on 

Deaths 69 

the 28th in Washington, D. C. Besides his widow, he is survived 
by two sons, P. C. Parker of New Orleans, and Claude I. Parker of 
Dallas, Texas. 

Judge Parker began his public career in 1883 in his native city, 
Tipton, Ind., as a city attorney upon admission to the bar follow- 
ing completion of his legal training at Northwestern Christian Uni- 
versity, now Butler University. In 1887 he was elected a member 
of the House of Representatives of the State of Indiana and after 
one term came to Washington. He was admitted to practice before 
the United States Supreme Court in 1889. The same year he was 
appointed principal examiner of land claims and contests in the 
General Land Office of the Department of the Interior and held 
the post for two years. 

In 1900 he was elected mayor of Tipton, returning to Washington 
in 1903 to become an assistant attorney in the Department of the 
Interior. Other positions he held were chief of the lands and rail- 
roads division of the Secretary of the Interior's office, private secre- 
tary to the Secretary of Interior and assistant attorney to the Secre- 
tary in 1908-1909. He then became law examiner for the Forest 
Service for several years, returning to become chief clerk of the 
Interior Department in 1913. He resigned in 1915 and was asso- 
ciated with the Transatlantic Steamship Conference. 

Sweeney — Reverend Z. T. Sweeney died at the Methodist Hos- 
pital in Indianapolis on February 4, and was buried from the 
Tabernacle Christian Church on the 8th in the Columbus city 

In the death of the Rev. Zachary Taylor Sweeney, Indiana lost 
one of its notable figures — a man whose reputation as a preacher, 
lecturer and religious worker extended to all parts of the country. 
Mr. Sweeney was a Kentuckian, the son and grandson of ministers 
of the Disciples Church. He attended an academy in Illinois and 
later was a student at the old Asbury — now Depauw — University 
at different times. Feeling the desire to become a clergyman, at 
an early age he began preaching in Paris, 111., and later was called 
to the pastorate of the Tabernacle Christian Church at Columbus, 

70 BuTLEE Alumnal Quarterly 

Ind., a pastorate he held for more than twenty years and one that 
he gave up over the protests of his parishioners. For short periods 
he was pastor of a church in Louisville and elsewhere, including a 
pulpit in Brooklyn during the absence of the regular pastor. 

The religious activity of Mr. Sweeney was not confined to his 
pulpit utterances, eloquent and moving as they were. He took an 
active part in all church work and stood four square for sound 
citizenship and religion. His most recent labors, despite his seven- 
ty-seven years, were regarded as his most effective. There was a 
tradition that no matter how large the debt on a new church might 
be, the Rev. Mr. Sweeney could wipe it out with the appeals he 
made following a dedicatory sermon. For many years he had been 
a trustee of Butler College and was chairman of the committee 
that conducts the department of religion. 

During the administration of President Harrison Mr. Sweeney 
was consul-general to Constantinople, a position that had been 
held by General Lew Wallace. He served there with distinction 
and became a close friend of the sultan of Turkey. He was the 
first fish and game commissioner appointed in Indiana and held 
the commissionership for twelve years. Under his direction the 
first game preserves were established and the first work done in 
the state leading to the fish and game department as it is now 
organized and administered. He loved nature and his fellowman 
and was a delightful companion, full of rare stories apt for any 

For the last few years Mr. Sweeney held no regular pastorate. 
He was known rather as a pastor of the Christian Church at large, 
ready to answer a call anywhere, eager to be of service to the faith 
for which he had labored during a long and successful career. 
He lectured widely on foreign, domestic and religious problems 
and was the author of books of travel. His acquaintance was not 
bounded by the borders of the nation and his friends and admirers 
were legion. A few years ago, while abroad, he was welcomed by 
Lloyd George, and at the latter 's request, preached in the church 
in "Wales of which the former British premier is a communicant. 

Deaths 71 

He visited Russia and studied the church situation there, establish- 
ing consultant relations with outstanding leaders. He belonged to 
that stalwart "elder race of men" of whom so many came from 
Kentucky and southern Indiana. Forced by circumstances to bat- 
tle their way through life, they became self-reliant and invincible. 
— Copied from The Indianapolis News. 


The life of the Quarterly depends upon prompt payment of the 
annual alumni fee. Two dollars are due on October 1 to the new 


Butler University 



1925 Drift Wins Cup 

Best Annual in Country 

Last year's annual of Butler College was award- 
ed the loving cup for the best college year book 
in the country by the National Arts Craft Guild. 

1^26 Drift Improved 

The editors of the 1926 Drift are doing every- 
thing possible to put out the best annual in 
the history of the school. Many features have 
been added to this year's book. 

Interest to Alumni 

The book will include complete accounts of the 
school activities for the past year, besides some 
special news and pictures of Butler alumni. 

Price Reduced 

The price of the book this year has been re- 
duced to $3.50. The 1925 Drift sold for $5.00. 
A much larger circulation has made this price 

Order a Drift Now 

Anyone desiring a book is requested to send 
check now to 

RALPH HITCH, Business Manager 
2yo Downey Avenue 

The books will be circulated about June i, 1926. 

1926 Butler Drift 




JULY, 1926 


Entered as second-class matter March 26, 1912, at the post 
office at Indianapolis, Ind., under the Act of March 3, 1879. 


Commencement Address Dr. Raphael H. Miller 

Class Poem — 1926 Rebecca E. Pitts 

Chemistry, Health'^ Torchbearer Janet Rioch 

College News — 

Beautiful Giving 
Commencement Week-end 
Class Reunions 

From the City Office .-^^'^'''^^^'nrnT**^^ 

Honor Day ^^^^^^^ ^^ 

May Day /^ ''•''"' 

Memorial Stone ff . % _ ^ V \ \n W i 

Resignation of D. C. Brown 


Scholarships \x 'I'^C^ 

Scholastic Averages ^*>i<5:~' j :::> rv -< 

Degrees for Butler Alumni 


The Butler DRIFT 

Purchase at Fairview 


Summer School 

Family Representation in Butler University 

The Students and Forestry Preservation 

Kindly Read 

Directory of Class Secretaries 

Personal Mention 




The Tie that Binds 



Loyalty undimmed by time or distance 

Gratitude unforgotten 

Service vigorous and unquenched 

To such spirit manifested toward the Alma Mater this issue of 
The Quarterly is dedicated. 

One port, methought, alike they sought, 
One purpose hold where 'er they fare, — 
bounding breeze ! rushing seas ! 
At last, at last, unite them there ! ' ' 


VoL XV JULY, 1926 No. 2 


By Dr. Raphael H. Miller 

Members of the graduating class, alumni and friends of Butler 
College: I will speak on the subject of "Specialism and Sym- 

One of the strange phenomena of our times is found in the 
fact that we live in a world of knowledge easily obtained and 
easily available accompanied by an intensity of narrowness and 
fragmentarianism and limitation for our individual thinking and 
our individual living., The total knowledge of the world, that 
which belongs to all our humanity, is very vast. But the amount 
that is compassed by any of us and by the best of us, is very small. 
The problem of the hour is the problem of the specialist. Philip 
Brooks said a long time ago that all the streams of knowledge are 
poured down the sleuth ways of our popularity. Our knowledge 
is the knowledge we desire, the knowledge we are prejudiced 
toward and the knowledge we can use. It is a strange fact that 
with all the world extending about us and the horizon of thinking 
and of living being pushed back with great rapidity into the vast 
distances, that the phenomena of our time should be the intensi- 
fying of partisanship, of nationalism, of race prejudices, of sec- 
tarianism and of specialism. Just at a time when you would expect 
the human efforts and the human life to be most highly balanced, 
we are faced with the unwarranted and the almost unfathomable 
social fact that life for the individual is becoming narrower and 
more prejudiced. It is the age of specialism and of fragmentari- 

84 Butler Alumnal Quarterly 

It is Willard Sperry who tells us that there is a rapid increase 
in all fields of experiment in the technical and social field, a vast 
increase of spreading knowledge in life and in the application to 
life and human needs. 

Young people, you have on the spectacles of life, you have 
looked out upon the world. Today you become the spectators 
who go forth to apply your thinking to living your lives in a 
world that is very vast, in the midst of which there is the un- 
fortunate temptation to live a life which runs in grooves or limited 
channels along the line of specialism. We are tempted to shut our 
eyes to every sort of endeavor except that which will tell for us, 
and this is our great test. It is easier to write a brief than to write 
a thesis and it is easier to live for a case than for a cause. 

As I got up to leave the train this morning and my baggage was 
being arranged to be taken off, the porter said, "Haven't you a 
brief case?" And I looked around and everybody in the car 
had a brief case. Everybody carries a brief case now, but how 
few have a great cause for which to live. How few lawyers when 
pleading a special case, or business men when carrying on their 
special business and promoting their special enterprises, have 
back of it and above it and around it the great causes to which a 
whole life can be committed. The need is for men and women who 
can live under a whole sky. 

In a book, the Rosary, it is portrayed that so many until com- 
ing to a great crisis in life delay in taking a big view of things. 
And that is the lesson I wish to give to you this morning. Try to 
take a big view. You will be tempted to take the narrow view. 
Your life will necessarily be partly ruled by your convictions, by 
the successfulness of your enterprise and by the limitation of your 
knowledge. It is so easy to put up in the nearest port, to be in- 
fluenced by others and by prejudices, by our own limited per- 
ceptions and resources, to see the good and the truth and the 
worth while things to be done all about us. 

Dr. John Hutton says that we are afflicted with the torment of 
limitation. The man who is making a humanized effort to readjust 
himself and get hold of the broad sense of life, cannot do so by 

Commencement Address 85 

being content to sit under the flame of his own candle and believe 
that in that light is all truth and all right. The door of life does 
not open that way. What man sitting in his office or study and 
viewing the world through his own activities, his own convictions, 
his own training, his own prosperity, his own attainments, is not 
continually tormented with the insistence of a vast world outside 
seeking for entrance? What man is not tormented by that great 
sun that seeks to burst through his satisfied exterior and sound 
the recesses of his soul ? 

Every day I am confronted by the need, the necessity of view- 
ing things in a big way, of the need of knowledge and truth and 
facts that lead up to the truth, and I say to you that I would do 
everything to resist the reorganizing of my life to a narrower 
plane. The highest kind of satisfaction comes from living up to 
the new and larger things, yet it is so much easier to be partisan 
and to be specialists. 

How many of our prejudices, our false judgments, are based on 
lack of information. J. Y. Simpson says, ' * Let not one man think 
that his limitations are those of another." And I say, let not the 
theologian assume that the limitations of faith are the limitations 
of facts. Let not the man in the laboratory assume that the limi- 
tations of his method are the limitations of experiments in the 
realm of religion and the social world. 

If only we could put fragmentarianism out of our lives, set 
aside our prejudices and get a big view of things, see something 
great and grab hold of the things that give new power we would 
accomplish something in this vast world in which you and I are 
called upon to live. 

There are some people who think with their brain or whatever 
the thinking organ is, and others think with their hearts, and their 
blood and muscle and marrow of the bone, with their very lives. 
Those who think only with their brain become indifferent and 
bloodless. In the realm of those who think with their hearts, the 
main problem is that of the facilities and ability to bring something 
worth while to the world. There are so many modernists, and they 

86 Butler Alumnal Quarterly 

are fragmentarianists. So many prejudices are based on partial 

There is no place more conducive to specialism and partial 
knowledge of facts than the university class room and the campus, 
and the young men and women who go out with their decorations 
and attainments into life. 

Some one said, and they are remarkable words, that the tragedy 
of Jesus was that he had to have disciples. Sinclair Lewis has 
been in Kansas City spreading his doctrines and trying to tell us 
how to live and think, and he said, "Why do you preachers think 
you are called upon to defend Jesus Christ ? The best thing would 
be for the churches and preachers to be silent for two hundred 
years and let Jesus speak for himself. ' ' But Jesus selected disci- 
ples, and every great teacher has selected disciples, and every great 
truth has been spread by true disciples and where it may have been 
the tragedy of Jesus, it is according to the New Testament. It is 
the tragedy of every cause, whether scientific, social, religious, edu- 
cational, or political that it has disciples and advocates and wit- 
nesses that are so bound up in selfish interests that they injure the 
cause to which they are committed. 

The need is for a clearer insight and a deeper insight into the 
world of knowledge and the relationships about us. 

What I ask is that the man in the department of science who 
day after day and night after night works in the laboratory and 
looks upon the miracles that lie under the lenses, and views the 
wonders and mysteries of a vast world that is as strange to me as 
an unknown continent — all I ask is that in my department in which 
I am as expert as he is in the world in which he lives — I ask that 
in my department that he will believe I am as honest, as faithful 
and as diligent in my search for the truth and in discovering the 
facts as he is in his department. He has a right to ask that I shall 
be as honest and as tolerant to him in his desire to find the truth 
as he shall be to me. 

It is Mr. Shaw who says that in all other departments he is 
content to receive instructions; that he is willing to take advice 

Commencement Address 87 

from a shoemaker or a tailor without requiring or desiring an 
explanation, satisfied to understand his own department and in all 
other departments to allow those who are capable of giving that 
understanding to interpret for him. 

It is hard to choose between symmetry and tolerance. It is dif- 
ficult to be tolerant without being prejudiced. It is hard to be the 
one and everyone understands that the man who cares for a cer- 
tain thing is more than a match for the man who does not care, 
and the man who cares the least in his search for the truth is so 
apt to become indifferent and will never find the truth. 

In every department in life we will find our common cause, and 
then we stay in that particular specialty or department. I find the 
great problem in my life is to be tolerant and at the same time not 
to be prejudiced, to look upon the whole world of truth with kind- 
ness and yet hold close to my heart a prejudice for the particular 
cause to which I am called to witness. 

America had a case when Belgium was invaded. America had 
a case when the Lusitania was sunk. But when President Wilson 
raised that call for men from the east and west to help make the 
world safe for democracy, then she had a cause and three million 
young men from the Atlantic to the Pacific began to march to that 
song, "We are going over, and we won't come back till its over 
over there. ' ' 

Every man has his test, but when life with its illusions and 
knowledge raises its mighty call, then we begin to march to the 
drum beat of the soul, to the trumpet call of the hosts of Heaven 
which call us to the onset. 

Young men and young women, there never was a great conquest 
won to which men rode mounted upon hobby horses. There is a 
vast difference between a hobby and a cause, between a prejudice 
and a conviction, between intolerance and prejudice. The need of 
the world today is that men shall take their hobbies and their spe- 
cialties and mould them into great causes. 

I do not think there is anything in the world today that is so 
driving men into fraud and graft and violation of the laws of life 

88 Butler Alumnal Quarterly 

and living, as the insincerity of the men pleading our cases before 
our courts, of men who plead cases rather than causes. 

We had a great murder trial in Kansas City not long ago. A 
young man, a lawyer of great promise, brought out what seemed 
to be the best of his manhood in holding up the witness to honor 
and respect and in justifying her act, until the reporter said he 
was sure the jury would bring in a verdict for her acquittal. But 
the facts were against her and the jury brought in a verdict for 
conviction and when it was all over, the young lawyer stepped up 
and congratulated them and in a report indicated that the case 
which he had been arguing was not a cause in his own heart, that 
he did not believe the things he said and that he was arguing 
against his conviction. He was trying to win a case but not trying 
to save a cause. I do not understand that in the legal or any 
other profession, a man has a right to argue for a case back of 
which he has no cause. And there are cases being argued in the 
pulpit, in the laboratory, in the class room, in the instructor's room 
and in the physician's office — cases that are not backed by a great 

It has gotten in the medical world that they mark the body off 
in certain areas. These areas are as distinct as the boundaries of 
the states in the continent. The modern physician studies only his 
certain area and has nothing to do with the other areas of the body. 
If you go to a doctor and have nothing wrong in his certain area 
it is not his case, and a great physician told me the other day that 
the greatest calamity in the medical profession today is that there 
are very few doctors coming out of the medical schools who are 
able to make a diagnosis. They have their area in which they op- 
erate. Beyond that they have no knowledge. You may have ap- 
pendicitis, gall stones, a brain affection or heart disease, but if 
you go to the doctor whose area is somewhere else he does not 
know anything about your trouble, with the result that people are 
falling back on sources of consultation where it is supposed and 
claimed they can receive a diagnosis with reference to their total 

Commencement Address 89 

That is true in all the other professions. We have our areas and 
specialties, and if you come to me with a certain trouble then I am 
at a loss in making any diagnosis of your disease. I am pleading 
not that any man know everything, because the area of knowledge 
has become too vast to do more than stand before the threshold, 
but I am pleading in view of the fact that the knowledge has be- 
come so limited, that our specialty is so limited — I do plead that 
in these vast areas that lie before us, we shall have patience 
and kindness, we shall leave to those who are making an honest 
and earnest investigation the right to proceed and to give to us 
the truth based upon their investigations verified by the experience 
of man. 

I never felt there was any conflict between the sciences and re- 
ligion. It is in our minds that we are not big enough, intelligent 
enough to accept all the conclusions of science and adjust them to 
all the accepted truths of our spiritual experience. I think if we 
were able to combine them we should see there is no conflict any- 
where as to the truth in one department with that in the other. 
The conflict is in us. The impossibility is in us. The difficulty is 
in us because we must be specialists, we must be limited, we must 
be fragmentarianists. 

Then I bring this last word. It is another word by Dr. Sperry. 
He said that a case can be made a cause. 

I talked not long ago with a man who had gone into Central Asia 
in the Andrews expedition. He came back a short time ago, and 
he said : ' ' Dr. Miller, I would like to have you come out and spend 
an evening with me. I have specimens and notes I would like to 
have you discuss with me." But I am afraid to go and I acknowl- 
edge it. I am afraid in my heart and mind to sit down with a 
man scientifically minded and discuss a specimen and notes and 
follow him and understand him and try to let my mind go out to 
his and I am afraid that I will not be able to bring his mind to 
mine so that he will see as I see and know what I know. This is 
the tragedy of modern life where we are shut up in our own special 
departments with our limited libraries. Why anybody going into 

90 Butler Alumnal Quarterly 

my library would know my profession because it is limited to my 
department, because I am a lonely man and he is a lonely man. You 
are going out into a world where you will be lonely. And just be- 
cause you are going into a world where you will be lonely, I ask you 
to remember that there are others who are lonely also. You may 
think that you can hold nothing in common with those of another 
department, and we may look with difference of opinion upon the 
truths with reference to Jesus Christ and the New Testament. But 
I want you to remember that you are lonely and I am lonely in 
tliis vast world, and what is the perspective that I want you to 
have? It is just this: That the highest cause and the divinest 
cause will at last justify itself. Keep yourself in the presence of 
the best in any area of life. Keep yourself in the presence that 
reveals the best in your area. Never be satisfied in any lower level 
of life in any area. I ask you when you come into the area of life 
in which I work, that you challenge me for the best I know and 
believe, and the best I can see through the divine Christ and that 
you look upon my truths with tolerance, for the highest cause will 
at last justify itself. And when you take me into your area do 
not take me into the lower realms but into the best that you know 
in the area you possess, for the highest and divinest cause will at 
last justify itself. There are thousands of places where I cannot 
think, but I must live in my area and accept the truths of those 
who live in theirs. 

So my word to you, my young friends of Butler, this morning 
is that you make the great causes your cases and that you will 
at last find symmetry. There are too many people who are lop- 
sided and corrupted. I am asking that you shall go out to a life 
of symmetry and that it will be lived on the level of the divinest 
experiences that life can give. 


By Rebecca E. Pitts 

Today will be remembered thru long years — 

For its fresh laughter and its sunny skies, 

Its gathering of the old grads and our class 

To honor Alma Mater in this wise. 

With glad hearts we pay homage as we pass, 

Yet not untouched by tears — 

For true friends we must part from ; for long hours 

Of care-free laughter; for sunny walks in May, 

Arched by green trees over each winding way, 

When Irvington is lovely with her flowers. 

The library, with its cool romantic rooms. 

Its trysting steps, will know our feet no more. 

And years to come will find us wandering 

Along new paths, by streams not loved before — 

Where mightier trees leaf out as each new spring 

Her magic green assumes ; 

And vaster halls will front each wooded hill. 

And greener lawns will slope where fountains play. 

Enough. We are met in these old halls today — 

And pausing, a dim sadness leaves us stilL 

It is good to pause, good to accord a sigh 

To the scene of well-remembered yesterdays ; 

But better, in going, to renew our faith. 

It is good to give the future school high praise; 

Better — to pledge our service until death 

Severs the loyal tie. 

In each heart, then, in going, let us fix 

Firmer devotion to her — truer zeal 

To serve the Alma Mater. May she feel 

Her loyalest sons are those of "twenty -six." 



By Janet Rioch, '26 

Fear not to go where fearless Science leads, 
Who holds the keys of God. 

The "dark ages" of Medicine are past. A glowing torch lights 
up the path of her progress and the bearer of the torch is the 
genius of Chemistry, Centuries ago in the land of Egypt the first, 
faint spark was kindled, when chemicals were for the first time 
used as medicine. That spark, cherished by the alchemists of old, 
smouldered through the years. At last it burst into a tiny flame 
and glowed ever brighter as the science of chemistry developed. 
Now, the torch of Chemistry illumines the way toward the eon- 
quest of disease. Truly enough, there are shadows ahead; and 
the way is often rough, but Medicine with dauntless steps follows 
the gleaming torch. 

One of those whose clear vision pierced the gloom during the 
latter half of the nineteenth century was Louis Pasteur. He was a 
trained chemist and his piercing analysis solved problems that 
advanced the cause of Medicine, and Science in general, by many 
years. He showed in his magnificent work the dependence of the 
medical sciences upon chemistry. Robert Boyle was in a prophetic 
mood when he said, two hundred years before, that the man who 
could determine the nature of the process of fermentation would 
be able to account, in a large measure, for the phenomena of dis- 
ease. Pasteur was that man., He overthrew the theory of spon- 
taneous generation and incontrovertibly proved that specific "mi- 
crobes" caused fermentation and putrefaction. One is aghast at 
the revolting description of the state of surgery at that time. Mor- 
tality following amputation was over sixty per cent ; no one thought 
of disinfectants. Pasteur's early training as a chemist had taught 
him above all things to be exact. He performed convincing ex- 
periments to demonstrate the proposition that infection could come 

•Prize-winning college essay on the Relationship of Chemistry to Health and 
Disease. 1925-26. 


Chemistry, Health's Torchbearer 93 

from the air or from the hands of the operator. It was the young 
Scotch doctor, Lister, who first undertook to test carefully Pasteur's 
proposition. He used carbolic acid (phenol) as a disinfectant and 
reduced the mortality after amputation to fifteen per cent! Pas- 
teur's signal work on vaccination and immunization borders on 
the realm of bacteriology, but it must be admitted that his chem- 
ist's training, his thirst for truth, lay at the bottom of his greatest 

Another genius that added fire to the flaming torch was Emil 
Fischer. He has been acclaimed as the greatest organic chemist 
of the latter generation. His monumental study of the chemical 
composition of carbohydrates and proteins has thrown light upon 
the entire problem of metabolism. ''With an imagination tem- 
pered only by a splendid scientific training, an originality of mind 
which made a lasting impress upon every piece of work with which 
he was associated. ... he gradually unfolded the mysteries that 
had enshrined the most complex chemical substances known to 
man."^ Fischer's most outstanding work was on the structure 
and synthesis of proteins, those complex substances which have 
been a constant riddle to chemists and physiologists. Fischer's 
sjrtithesis of certain proteins showed in a wonderful way how this 
may occur in the living organism. The specific nature of the en- 
zymes and their action was another study of great importance 
which Fischer undertook. Few men have accomplished so much 
which has been of real value as this deep-thinking chemist. 

Our gratitude should overflow to these great pioneers and to the 
host of others who have been unmentioned. It is fitting to pay 
tribute to their work, before turning our dazzled eyes to the bril- 
liancy of present-day achievements. 

Most startling to the general reader, although not necessarily 
most important, are the accounts of the amazing effects upon the 
human body of specific medicines. Years of experience taught 
mankind that certain remedies were good for certain diseases. 
It has remained for analytical chemistry to determine why this is 

1 Benjamin Harrow, "Eminent Chemists of Our Time," D. Van N'ostrand & Co., 
New York, 1920. 

94 Butler Alumnal Quarterly 

so and for synthetic chemistry to produce these remedies in their 
purest form. Analytic and synthetic chemistry have not only 
refined our drugs and greatly increased their potency, but they 
have actually produced new substances never before formed in 
nature. These new drugs contain the beneficial qualities of the 
natural substances without the harmful ones. 

It was known for years that cinchona bark was the specific rem- 
edy for malaria. Then chemistry showed that the bark contained 
twenty different alkaloids, only one of which was of value. This 
pure substance, quinine, was isolated and found to be an ex- 
tremely powerful protein poison. Its action, however, is only on 
the malarial parasite. SjTithetic chemistry is now trying to isolate 
its powerful destroying property in order to use it against any 
other micro-organism. 

Another wonderful improvement on nature is the refinement of 
the chaulmoogra oil treatment for leprosy. Leprosy up to the 
present day has been at once the most loathsome and the most 
hopeless of diseases. To linger on from year to year, an object of 
horror, dreaded by all, and yet suffering agonies that only death 
will relieve, such has been the terrible lot of the leper. To chem- 
istry has come the honor and the privilege of showing the way 
towards cleansing the lepers and thus obeying the command of the 
Man, who once stretched forth His hand to a victim of this dread 
disease, and said, ''I will, be thou clean." A careful chemical ex- 
amination of chaulmoogra oil showed that its therapeutic value lay 
in the presence of the fatty acids of the chaulmoogric series. The 
ethyl esters of these acids were extracted and it was found that 
hypodermic injections of the purified esters were of more benefit 
than the use of the oil itself. Treatment could also be carried on 
over a much longer time without the unfavorable reactions caused 
by the crude oil. 

It has been my pleasure to see the wonderful change that comes 
over lepers during this course of treatment. Their listlessness 
goes, they brighten up and become active and begin again to enjoy 
life. In advanced cases little can be done except to relieve and 

Chemistry, Health's Torchbearer 95 

lessen the suffering. In early cases, carried over a long course of 
treatment, hope of recovery is good. Up to the present time 
"cures" are not claimed, but the patients are released on parole 
and may never need to return to the hospital. It is not hard to 
imagine the joy springing, as a fountain, in the heart of the pa- 
tient pronounced ''free from every indication of the disease." 

From the days of Lister, antiseptics have been developed and 
improved. Here chemistry shows the way. Again, in the broad 
field of anesthetics, chemistry has an almost unlimited opportunity 
for service. Ether was formed by Valerius Cordus, a tutor in 
Materia Medica at Wittenberg in 1540 ; but it was not until 1846 
that the first operation was performed with its use. Had medicine 
in the old days been more ready to follow the lead of the labora- 
tory, instead of scorn it, much human agony might have been 
spared. Chloroform was used far more than ether at first, but it 
gave way to the less harmful anesthetic. Careful regulation of the 
amount given is absolutely necessary; but often, especially with 
chloroform, the shock to the heart causes sudden death. It is for 
this reason that anesthesia has been looked upon as such a terrible, 
mysterious sleep, from which one may never awaken. Chemistry 
has ushered in the era of the local anesthetic. Few discoveries 
have brought more immediate relief to mankind than that of the 
efficient harmless local anesthetic. Cocaine, the natural product 
which is found in the coca leaves, is effective but very poisonous. 
The chemist tore it apart and resynthesized it without the poison- 
ous portion and called it novocaine — the invaluable local anes- 
thetic. It was found that the blood washed away the injected sub- 
stance and so anesthesia did not last. Adrenalin was injected along 
with the novocaine to contract the blood vessels. This made it 
possible to perform even major operations and the patient was 
saved the danger and the bad after-effects of the general anes- 

The isolation of adrenalin itself is one of the thrilling chapters 
of chemical history. No adventurous voyage of discovery, no ex- 
citing detective story can compare with the search for the active 

96 Butler Alumnal Quarterly 

principle of secretion of the suprarenal glands. "The history of 
this drug bears proud testimony to the powers of chemical re- 
search in the present day. Though not much more than twenty- 
five years have passed since the search for this unknown substance 
began, not only has it been found, but its chemical constitution 
has been determined, and the final result is the synthetic produc- 
tion of a substance that is identical with the natural. ' '^ 

Let us pause a moment to think; of what is this marvelously 
constructed body of ours made, that it should react as it does to 
outside stimuli? What governs this intricate structure of cells 
that each one, in a normal state, carries out its functions with such 
precision ? 

The answer to these questions lies at the basis of the study of 
health and disease. Physicians are not longer overloading the 
system with the innumerable drugs of pharmacology. Rather they 
are turning to chemistry to find the explanation of the way in 
which the body reacts and how this reaction may be controlled. 
The chemist and biologist, working together in the great science of 
bio-chemistry, are steadily solving these problems. Chemistry leads 
the way. Biology can go no farther than the microscope, while 
chemistry dissects the very atoms themselves. 

The chemistry of the blood presents a subject of intense interest 
both to the physical and to the physiological chemist. From earli- 
est times the blood has been looked upon as the symbol of life. It 
forms the transportation system of the body and its constituents 
affect every cell. It is extremely important, then, that the blood 
be kept in a normal state. What is the normal state ? This again, 
the chemist is called upon to determine. We look upon water as 
being practically neutral in its reaction. If the change in the al- 
kalinity of the blood were as great as the difference between tap 
water and distilled water, the organism would instantly die. To 
counteract this possibility of change, the blood contains certain 

2 E. Poulsson, "Pharmacology and Therapeutics," Williams & Wilklns Co., 
Baltimore 1923. 

Chemistry, Health's Torchbearer 97 

compounds which react with the entering substances in sucli a way 
as to maintain the normal alkalinity. The blood is thus an excellent 
' ' buffer ' ' solution and is able to take care of all ordinary disturb- 
ances. In cases of disease, however, such as diabetes mellitus, se- 
vere nephritis, and food intoxication, these ''buffer'' substances 
are used up and acidosis results. This also occurs when the diet 
contains too much of the acid-forming foods, such as meat, fish, 
a,nd eggs.. A change in diet, with increased carbohydrates which 
give base-forming products, helps to correct the acidosis. The 
mystery of this life-giving stream becomes so clear, when chemistry 
explains, that we forget the years of accurate research which made 
this explanation possible. 

The processes of life are ultimately chemical. Oxidation and re- 
duction is one of the most fundamental physiological reactions. 
The process of respiration, we know, consists in taking in oxygen 
and giving off carbon dioxide. In pulmonary tuberculosis, the 
lung must have as much rest as possible. When both lungs are 
affected this is not possible. A regulation of diet in a large meas- 
ure helps to lessen the amount of work the lungs have to do. It 
has been found that a high carbohydrate diet increases the amount 
of carbon dioxide to be given off by the blood. This makes more 
work for the lungs. If a fairly high protein diet is given, the pa- 
tient does not require to breathe so deeply or so frequently to throw 
off the carbon dioxide. 

The body seems to be governed by a system of mysterious mes- 
sengers, who pass unseen through the blood stream and deliver 
their messages at the right door. These messengers are known as 
hormones. They are secreted into the blood stream by the ductless 
glands. Experiments on animals and observations of thyroid dis- 
eases in humans have shown that the thyroid influences the meta- 
bolism of the body. In cases where the thyroid has degenerated 
or is removed, a very marked and truly terrible change comes over 
the organism. The individual becomes listless and idiotic, the skin 
dries and thickens, the hair falls out, the general metabolism is 

98 Butler Alumnal Quarterly 

"slowed down." This condition is known as myxoedema, in 
adults. In children it is called cretinism. Chemistry has presented 
to medicine the synthetic hormone, thyroxin. When injected into 
the blood stream, in regulated amounts, it will cure victims of 

It Is a mistaken notion, however, to imagine that a person fed on 
quantitative amounts of pure fats, proteins, and carbohydrates 
will continue very long to live in health, or in fact to live at all. 
Experiments have clearly demonstrated that animals fed on pure 
substances fail to develop normally. Death regularly ensues. The 
remarkable results obtained in experiments have been proved by 
chemists to be due to a lack of certain "vital principles," the 
vitamins. The vast amount of research done on them is justified 
by the tremendous role they play in the metabolism of the body. 
When the vitamin A is missing from the diet, the animal loses 
weight, its resistance to disease is lowered. It develops a typical 
opthalmia ; and atrophy of the thymus, spleen, pancreas, and heart 
follow. Paralysis and at last atrophy of the heart and other or- 
gans follow the omission from the diet of the vitamin B. Rickets 
is a "deficiency disease" caused by a lack of vitamin X. Scurvy 
follows an omission of vitamin C. Remarkable recovery follows 
the administration of the vitamin even in extremely small doses. 
Mendel very truly makes the following statement: "Bearing in 
mind that the pathological phenomena described are among the 
more obvious and unmistakable signs of disturbance, one cannot 
avoid the suspicion that numerous less obvious, but equally detri- 
mental defects or deteriorations as yet undetected and undeter- 
mined may also occur in so-called avitaminosis. " "Recent ad- 
vances have failed entirely to disclose the nature of vitamins or 
the mode of their operation in the organism. "^ 

Of intense interest to every chemist is the work being carried on 
now at Johns Hopkins University. A Japanese investigator, who 

3 L. B. Mendel, "Nutrition, the Chemistry of Life," Yale University Press, New 
Haven, 1923. 

Chemistry, Health's Torchbearer 99 

recently died, claimed to have isolated one of the vitamins. His 
papers do not make it clear whether it was vitamin A or B. These 
papers on the investigation have been obtained by Dr. McCollum, 
who is now repeating the work with the hope of verifying the de- 
terminations and of actually isolating a vitamin. 

The sick or convalescent individual requires vitamins to ''stimu- 
late metabolic processes. ' ' The difficulty we now face is in supply- 
ing the sick with known amounts of vitamins. Concerning the 
feeding of vitamins to patients Emmett says, ''In short, recovery 
should then be more rapid and convalescence shortened by this 
procedure, all of which shows the relation of the vitamins — 'the 
infinitely little' — to health and disease."* 

Professor Louis Kahlenberg, in a recent address, pointed out in 
what a tantalizing way the plants carry on their functions. Their 
adjustments are so fine and they work so quietly. Yet we humans 
go at things in our "hammer and tongs" style and expect results. 
A close analogy may be drawn between the plant and the organism. 
If we knew how these "infinitely little" principles, the vitamins 
and hormones, acted we could control the body in a wonderful way. 
There would be no need to drug the patient. Nature would be 
quietly and gently helped by the means she herself uses. 

There has not been an attempt in this essay to cover the entire 
field of medicine, but in every branch chemistry is always the 
leader, the forerunner, the torchbearer. In an address entitled 
"First Get the Facts," Secretary Redfield said, "The mind of 
science is one of high ideals. It is a modest mind, for it recognizes 
that there are many things it does not know. ... It is a practical 
mind, for it aims to find the hidden things of nature and put them 
to use. . . . The scientific mind, if it be true to itself, knows no 
passion, nor prejudice nor predilection, unless it be the passion 
for the truth that is not yet known. ' ' 

This is the mind of Chemistry. 

4 A. D. Emmett, "The Vitamins and Their Relation to Health and Disease,' 
Detroit, 1922. 






Published by the Alumni Association of Butler College, Indianapolis. 
Subscription price, two dollars per year. 

Entered as second-class matter, March 26, 1912, at the post office at Indi- 
anapolis, Indiana, under the Act of March 3, 1879. 

Officers of the Alumni Association — President, John F. Mitchell, Jr., '06; 
First Vice-President, Shelley D. Watts, '00; Second Vice-President, Mrs. 
Mary Louise Ragsdale, '17; Treasurer and Business Manager, George A. 
Schumacher, '25; appointees, Howard C. Caldwell, '15 and George A. 
Schumacher, '25. 

Secretary and Editor of the Butler Alumaml Qiut/rterly — Katharine M. 
Graydon, '78. 


The beauty of giving like the beauty of 
is a worship of the Lord. 

The latest benefaction to the College, that of Mrs. A. M. Robert- 
son in her gift of real estate valued at $80,000, recalls gifts of 
other women — women who have long been residents of Indian- 
apolis and have done much to make the city safe and fair and 
good. Each has carried on the traditions of early days, when in 
the midst of meagre surroundings they lived and wrought — su- 
perior women of intelligence and cultivation and spirituality. Of 
similar character are those who have recently remembered in fine 
form our growing institution. 

The College is to be congratulated in such beneficence, and these 
friends are to be congratulated in possessing the ability to make 
real that which many a woman 's heart has visualized. 

To give to the College a chapel is a wonderful gift. It will 
breathe in stone of Mrs. Robertson's spirit of loyalty to high en- 
deavors, interest in education, in the arts, especially music, in the 
development of Indianapolis along lines of beauty. 


Beautiful Giving 101 

Some of us who are women are hoping the day is not far distant 
when there may appear upon the campus a much-needed WOM- 
AN'S BUILDING dedicated to the womanhood of the College, the 
memory of which womanhood is one of the enriching possessions 
of the Alma Mater. Or, as the College was pioneer in the world of 
education, would it be better to dedicate such a structure to the 
womanhood of earlj'^ Indiana? 

102 Butler Alumnal Quarterly 


The program of Commencement week-end was ushered in by 
the Phi Kappa Phi dinner given on the evening of June 11, at the 
University Club. About sixty members were present and the oc- 
casion was most enjoyable, especially the post-prandial feature. 
Professor Henry M. Gelston as toastmaster introduced the fol- 
lowing speakers: 

What Phi Kappa Phi Means to the Undergraduate, Mr. Lewis 
Wilson, 1926. 

Scholarship versus Campustry, Miss Emily M. Helming, 1899. 

Scholarship for Its Own Sake, Dean Frederick D. Kershner. 

Our Educational Business, Miss Bertha Thormeyer, 1892. 

A Fairview of Scholars, President Robert J. Aley. 


On Saturday, the 12th, youth and maturity met and mingled 
and joined hands in spirit and fellowship. It was a memorable 
day for two classes in particular. For the class of '26, it marked 
the close of undergraduate life; for the class of '90, it meant the 
renewal of college associations thirty-six years after graduation. 
One was departing, the other was returning. They passed on the 
way, and in their greeting there was both pleasure and pathos. 

Class Day exercises took place in the chapel in the afternoon. 
The program, which was under the general direction of Justine 
Halliday, carried out an unusual note of seriousness which was 
impressive not only for the members of the senior class but also for 
the many alumni who were present. Virginia Curtis presented a 
carefully prepared class history, recalling the many contributions 
of '26 to scholarship, athletics, oratory, dramatics, journalism, and 
other phases of school life. The class prophet, Lewis Wilson, 
looking at the future through the glass of the past, predicted that 
high ideals would be the animating motive behind the deeds and 
achievements of class members. The class will, read by J. Douglas 

Commencement 103 

Perry, among other bequests, left to the faculty the trust of build- 
ing and shaping the university of the future, and devised to the 
men of the college the old spirit of fighting on until the last whistle 
blows. The class poem, also serious in its appeal, was given by 
Rebecca Pitts. 

Sarah Frances Downs, giftorian, provided the comic relief and 
gave the program balance with her clever presentations to individ- 
uals in the class. The class stunt, a take-off on various phases of 
college life during the past year, was also uproariously funny. 
Thus it was that the seniors' mingled feeling of sorrow and pleas- 
ure at the prospect of graduation found fitting expression in the 
well-blended program of sentiment and mirth. 

David Konold, senior president, brought the afternoon to a 
close by announcing that the class would present as a gift to the 
school $180 to be applied to the fund being raised for the purchase 
of a new piano for the chapel.. 

In the meantime, tables were being arranged on the front lawn 
m the shadow of the administration building, and in the cool of 
the evening, the old grads and the young grads, laden with lunch 
boxes and baskets of food, came streaming back upon the campus 
for the alumni supper. Old acquaintances were renewed across 
the tables and reminiscences of college days were exchanged until 
well nigh dusk when the company adjourned to the chapel for the 
business session of the Alumni Association. 


June 12, 1926 

The leading activity for the year now ending of the Alumni 
Association as an association has been the raising of two scholar- 
ships of the value of tuition ($150 each) for worthy and appre- 
ciative students who find the struggle of earning their way almost 
heavier than can be met — a Sophomore girl and a Senior boy. 
The association has through its class secretaries voted to continue 
its work and will again give for next year two scholarships. 

104 Butler Alumnal Quarterly 

The prime purpose of this activity on the part of the Alumni 
Association is two-fold, not more to lighten the burden certain 
young people are bravely and silently carrying than it is to have 
the Association as an association unite in giving some worth-while 
expression to the College — something which in the aggregate is 
good, yet taxes heavily no one. There are two things the Asso- 
ciation asks of its members — a contribution of one dollar or more 
to the Alumni Scholarship Fund and a payment of the dues of 
two dollars, this covering the subscription of The Quarterly. 

The necrology of the year has been heavy, removing from our 
midst some on whom we thought to lean, whose loyalty and whose 
lives adorned our alumni record: William T. Sellers, 75, Miles 
L. Clifford, 79, Lora C. Hoss, '81, Miss Blanche A. Eyker, '10, 
Miss Lucile Sherritt, '16. 

This evening the Association is to admit the class of '26, one 
hundred ninety-two members. We congratulate them, we con- 
gratulate ourselves. We look to them for continued loyalty in 
furthering the large interests of their Alma Mater, and bespeak 
for them that same fine activity as alumni which has character- 
ized them as under-graduates throughout their four years. 

It is a great pleasure to have in our midst for this occasion 
so many of the out-of-town alumni. The Association values your 
return and welcomes you of the long-ago, and you of the more re- 
cent times. Thrice welcome are you ! Of the class of 1890 gathered 
from the four corners of the country, returned fourteen out of 
its eighteen members. Let mention be made for its splendid spirit 
of loyalty which years have not in any wise lessened. Its reunion 
of three days starting last evening with a dinner is memorable in 
the history of the College. A spirit of love and gratitude to the 
Old School is reaching high-water mark in our midst just now. 
May there be many such expressions to follow! 

There has never been an alumni reunion, so far as the secretary 
recalls, when Demarchus C. Brown, '79, if in the city, has not 
been present. Detained from attendance this evening on account 
of illness, we may feel' assured his thoughts are of and with us. 

Commencement 105 

To this beloved alumnus and former teacher of many gathered 
here may not our greetings be sent? 

And to another alumnus, also absent because of illness, may not 
an expression of our remembrance be sent to the dear teacher 
and loyal friend of the College, the gracious and true Corinne 
Welling of the class of 1912? 

Respectfully submitted, 



President, John F. Mitchell, Jr., '06; First Vice-President, 
Shelley D. Watts, '00; Second Vice-President, Mrs. Mary Louise 
Ragsdale, '17; Treasurer, George A. Schumacher, '25; Secretary, 
Katharine M. Graydon, '78. 

106 Butler Alumnal Quarterly 

June 12, 1926 

Balance on hand July 1, 1925 $ 1.73 

Received during the year: 

Membership dues and Quarterly subscriptions 632.00 

Advertising in Quarterly 200.00 832.00 

Expenditures : 

To postage and mailing Quarterly 11.36 

To printing Alumnal Quarterly 750.00 


Balance on hand $72.37 

Liabilities : 

Unpaid accoimt for printing Quarterly $302.39 

Less cash on hand 72.37 

Net deficit 230.02 

Outstanding accoimts to reduce deficit: 

225 unpaid subscriptions at $2.00 each $450.00 

Respectfully submitted, 

CHAS. W. WILSON, Treasurer. 

One of the features of the evening program was the awarding 
of blankets to the senior athletes, a custom of long standing at 
Butler. Hilton U. Brown, chairman of the board of directors, 
made the presentations, introducing each recipient of honor with 
remarks in a happy and characteristic vein. But the athletes of 
the present were not permitted to share the limelight alone. Out 
in the audience was Henry Mann of the class of '90, and captain of 
the champion football team of '89, and there, too, were his team- 
mates, Thomas Hall, Frank D. Muse, John Nichols, and Ray Meeker 
— all reminders of the time when football players wore sideburns 

Commencement 107 

and mustaches and when sheer brawn was much more important 
than science and skill. These men were presented to the audience, 
and thus it was that even in the realm of sport the class of '90 
vied for honors with the youth of '26. 

The climax of the evening came when the class of '26 was offi- 
cially voted into the alumni body. Appropriately enough, a mem- 
ber of '90, Miss India Martz, brought the greeting of the Associa- 
tion to its youngest group. David Konold, senior president, re- 
sponded. Honor having then been done to both the present and 
the past, alumni turned their attention to the future when John 
W. Atherton, financial secretary of the University, presented to 
them plans for immediate building operations at Fairview. At 
the conclusion of Mr. Atherton 's address, members of the Asso- 
ciation, with freshened memories of the past and clearer visions 
for the future, brought Alumni Day to a close as they sang to- 
gether Auld Lang Syne. 


On Sunday afternoon at 4 o'clock occurred in the Chapel the 
Baccalaureate service. The Reverend Pearl H. Welshimer of Can- 
ton, Ohio, preached the sermon. The invocation was pronounced 
by the Reverend J. N. Jessup, '90, of Lafayette, and the benediction 
by the Reverend Frank D. Muse, '90, of Spokane, Washington. 
Miss Ocie Higgins, '28, of Lebanon was soloist, singing "Love 
Never Faileth." The processional and recessional were played by 
a College trio consisting of Miss Marcia Clapp, violin; Miss Mar- 
cina Campbell, 'cello; Miss Dorothy Berger, piano. 


At 10 o'clock on Monday morning the long processional con- 
sisting of Senior Class, Honored Guests and Alumni, Faculty, 
Trustees, Speaker of the Day, wound its way to the music of the 
Butler University Band, to seats under the trees in front of the 

108 Butler Alumnal Quarterly 

Residence. The invocation was pronounced by Dr. W. A. Shullen- 
berger. Following orchestral music the address of the occasion 
was made by Reverend Raphael H. Miller of Kansas City and is 
given elsewhere in this issue. 

In the conferral of degrees, the President of the University said : 

Most college students are familiar with debts. Doubtless the 
usual percent of this, the largest class in Butler's history, have 
been or are now in debt. Nevertheless, trite as it may seem, I 
wish to speak to you briefly on the subject "Debtors." 

Many centuries ago, St. Paul, the organizer of Christianity, said, 
''I am debtor both to the Greeks, and to the Barbarians; both to 
the wise, and to the unwise. ' ' 

You are debtors to the community in which you live. That com- 
munity has given you protection, opportunity, and encouragement. 
Through its local government it was made possible for you to se- 
cure a common and high school education. 

You are debtors to your parents. Their love and prayerful so- 
licitation for your welfare together with their material contribu- 
tions to your support make a debt so large that you can hardly 
hope ever to pay it in full. 

You are debtors to your country. The labors and sacrifices of 
the patriots of the past made it possible for you to live in a republic 
with all the opportunities and advantages that free government 

You are debtors to science. The conveniences, comforts and 
luxuries that you enjoy, from a modern compact or shaving kit to 
an airplane or dirigible, are all the results of science. Wipe out 
science and the race would be back to primitive conditions in a 

You are debtors to literature and art. You are able to enjoy 
a story, a poem, a painting, a statue, a cathedral because the artist 
lived and worked and gave the product of his skill to the world. 
Destroy literature and art and barbarism comes rushing back. 

You are debtors to your friends. They have believed in you, 

Commencement 109 

condoned your faults, picked you up where you stumbled, and 
encouraged you to new efforts. Without friends your life would 
not only be lonely but it would also be absolutely fruitless. 

You are debtors to the church. From your earliest childhood the 
church has constantly pointed the way to higher and better things 
and urged you to enter the kingdom of heaven. Without the in- 
fluence of the church your life would indeed be sterile and un- 

Debt is often thought of as a liability, and therefore as some- 
thing to be avoided. It is a liability if it is incurred for trivial, 
temporary or unnecessary things. When incurred rationally and 
for valuable, permanent and necessary things, debt becomes a 
most valuable asset. 

Your indebtedness is for the most valuable and permanent things 
the world has to give., Your four years here have greatly increased 
your debt, and we trust have made you more sensitive to the value 
of the things for which you owe. 

The question which confronts you today and which will be pres- 
ent with you tomorrow is, ' ' How shall I pay the debt ? " or perhaps 
even more searching than that, ''How shall I keep my credit 
good?" We believe you are the men and women who will face 
these questions with courage and answer them with confidence. 

Possibly these suggestions may help you: — Try to vision the 
magnitude of what you owe and then acknowledge the debt with 
humble gratitude. Be sure to use properly and constantly the 
great gifts with which you are charged. Be the kind of citizen 
that your community and country need, and give a full measure 
of unselfish service to both. Help others to use science, enjoy 
literature and appreciate art. Make real in your lives the dreams 
of your parents and determine to be the men and women that in 
your moments of highest exaltation you wish to be. Anchor your- 
selves to the principles of righteousness taught by seers and 
prophets and exemplified by the Great Teacher. 


Butler Alumnal Quarterly 

The following students were presented as candidates for degrees 
by Dean James W. Putnam : 


Dora Oma Atkins 
Frank C. Atkins 
Joy Julian Bailey 
Mary Irwin Bainum 
Shailer Linwood Bass 

* Margaret Ann Bell 
Wilma Bennett 
Mary Elizabeth Biggerstaff 
Berenice Billman 
Julia Atherton Brown 
Joseph H. Bruns 
Robert Holton Bull 

*Katherine Lacey Burgan 
Madeliene Byrket 
Theta May Byrket 

*Dorothy Carey 
Evelyn Carpenter 
Charlotte Tyler Carter 
Neal Duncan Carter 
Merel Emmet Carver 
Helen Joan Chandler 
Dorotha Marjorie Chiles 
Mary Miles Coate 
Gladys Ruth Collins 
Ruth Valeria Combs 
Elizabeth Jane Cotton 

^Jocelyn Perry Courtright 

"Joseph R. Craw 
Virginia Delmont Curtis 
Kathleen Reeves Dabney 
Lillian Lott David 
Arnold Gerard Davis 
Mary Leonora Davis 
Alfred T. DeGroot 
Catharine Dodson 
Sarah Frances Downs 

*Kathleen Allison Dyer 

Major Subject 

































English and Latin 







La Porte 



























Biblical Literature 

Washington, D. C. 









*Burge O. Emmert 

Helen Marie Erber 

Katharine Jane Fillmore 

Ernest Paul Fink 

Iness Leighton Frey 

Florence E. Fritts 

Rlou Fern Gochenour 

Caroline Godley 

W. H. Brewer Graham 
*Vivian Raye Greatbatch 

Nell V. Green 
*William Edwin Grubbs 

Margaret Elizabeth Haldy 

Hildreth Hall 

Sarah INIarie Hall 

Justine Halliday 

* Albert L Harker 
Ada B. Harris 
Mildred L. Hasely 

*Wanda Marie Haverkamp 
*Frank F. Hiatt 

Myron Taggart Hopper 

Harry T. Ice 

* Alice Pauline Ingalls 
Hazel Mae Jackson 
jSIildred Lucyl Johns 

*Wanda Inez Johnson 

David Byron Kilgore 
*Leona Borum KJaight 

Grace Louise Koehne 

David William Konold 

LaDonna F. Lamb 
*Vesta Violet Leach 

John David Leslie 
*Irene Warren Lewis 
*Thomas Blair Lindley 
^Marguerite Lloyd 
*Ruth Blythe Marshall 

John Brown Mason 

Bruce King Matlock 

Eleanor Elizabeth McCollum 

Mary Anna McFarland 

M. Alice McGinnis 


Spanish and English 

English and French 

Latin and Greek 




English and Journalism 

History and Economics 




Romance Languages 






Home Economics 


Physics and Mathematics 

Sociology and Philosophy 




English and Greek 













History and German 


English and Histon' 

English and French 
































Winona Lake 









Denver, Colo. 





Butler Alumnal Quarterly 

Virginia Mae Mclntire 


Cambridge City 

Mary MclMeans 



Maida Melchior 

English and Public 


Bessie Vernal Minor 

English and History 


George K. Morlan 



George E. Mulholland 



Elizabeth Virginia Neal 



Robert L. Nipper 



Grace Noble 

Latin and English 


Beulah Hattie Nonweiler 

English, Botany 


Mary Reuss Nussbaum 

Romance Languages 


Marjorie Okes 



Dorothy Marie Patterson 

Spanish and English 


'Gordon E. Paul 


Selkirk, N. Y. 

Helen Claire Payne 



J. Douglas Perry 



Margaret Cogswell Pihl 

Latin and Mathematics 


Rebecca E. Pitts 

English and Classics 


Dorothy P. Poindexter 



Helen Miller Porter 



'Donald Meredith Ream 



Louis J. Reichel 

English and History 


Kathleen Marie Reidy 



Alice Lucille Reynolds 



Dorothy Louise Rinehart 



Georgiana G. Rockwell 



Sarah Phelps Rodecker 



Thomas Perrette Rogers 

Chemistry and Zoology 


'■John Thomas Rohm 



Paul Menzies Ross 



'William H. Rowlands 



Dorothy Laura Sandefur 



Emma Esther Schlender 



Edna B. Schulz 



Glen Juanita Schwenk 



^Allen M. Sells 



Elsie M. Shepherd 



Albert Shumaker 



'^Bernice Sinclair 



Frank T. Sisson 



^Lenora Eugenia Skaggs 



Mabelle Browning Slater 


T-aHarpe, 111. 



A. Ivin Smith 

Lillie Florence Smith 

Renee Baron Smith 

Thomas Franklin Smith 
*Rosalee Baker Spong 
*Loui3 Jacob Steinmetz 

Clarence Jerome Stembel 

Dorothy Alice Stephenson 

Helen Louise Stevens 

Lucile Stokes 

Horace Elbert Storer 
*Gerald W. Strole 
*Verna Lucile Sutton 

Marie Louise Tacoma 
*Thelma Hope Taylor 

Edna-Mae Thomas 

Charlotte Thomas 

Mary Juanita Thompson 

Juliana Thorman 

Avanelle Thorp 
*Edna Eachel Todd 
*John C. Troyer 

Wihia E. Tully 

Irma Elizabeth Ulrich 

Jackson White Wales 

Margaret Ruth Walters 
*W. Herman Wheat 
*Louise A. Wheeler 

Lorene Winifred Whitham 

Eva Yoimg Wiles 

Alice Amelia Wilmanns 
*Irene Elizabeth Wilson 

Lewis Wilson 

Mary Lester Winter 

Dorothea L. Wolfe 

Jabez Hall Wood 

Mary Lou Wright 

Earl J. Wynn 

Alice Templer Young 








French and Journalism 






French and Spanish 


History and Latin 


English and Spanish 



Romance Languages 





Spanish and English 




























Charlottesville, Va. 












Beech Grove 










Sarasota, Fla. 




Butler Alumnal Quarterly 


Dorothea A. Duncan 

Florence Everett Hooper 

Thomas O. Jaleski 
*E. R. Leach 
^Houston Harry Meyer 

Lowell A. Mullen 

Janet Rioch 

Edward A. Troy 


Major Subject 


Botany and Chemistry 


Zoology and Chemistry 


Botany and Chemistry 











Major Subject — Economics 

Harold Frederick Barnes 

Carl O. Cecil 

James R. Davis 

Rollin Murray Davis 

Russell J. Ferree 

Carter Benson Helton 

Hiram M. Hensel 

Ruth Pratt Johnson 

Damien J. Lyman 

Vallorous B. McLeay 
^Richard Lyc#n Mills 
*William Rowe Neukom 

Lester LeRoy Nicewander 

Virgil V. Rohy 

Harry W. Ruth 

Robert L. Wolfe 
^Homer E. Woodling 

Joe William York 


Adelaide G. Smith 




North Salem 
















Commencement 115 

Mildred Morey Casey Indianapolis 


Frank Webster Sumner Indianapolis 

William H. Rowlands Indianapolis 



'Oscar Christian Ries Indianapolis 

Robert Grover VanDuyn Greenfield 

*Mrs. Elizabeth Rippetoe Witt Indianapolis 

•These students have not completed all the requirements for graduation. They 
expect to complete their work during the Summer Session. The degree and diploma 
will be awarded when the requirements are met, provided this is done before the 
onenins' of the Fall Semester, and these students will be graduated as of the Class 
of June, 1926. 

116 Butler Alumnal Quarterly 


Henry Mills Gelston, graduate of Michigan University, student 
in the American School of Classical studies at Rome, Classical 
Fellow at Michigan University, teacher of Latin in Bay City High 
School, for the past sixteen years Professor of Latin in Butler 
University, student, scholar, teacher, sane and safe athletic guide, 
beloved friend of all — by the unanimous vote of the Board of Di- 
rectors I am authorized to confer upon you the honorary degree 
of Doctor of Laws, with all the honors, rights and privileges per- 
taining thereto. 

Elijah Newton Johnson, graduate of Drake and Kansas Univer- 
sities, graduate student in Kansas and Chicago Universities, since 
1904 Professor of Mathematics in Butler University, inspiring 
teacher, wise student adviser, safe faculty counselor, keen wit, 
genial friend, Christian gentleman — by unanimous vote of the 
Board of Directors I am authorized to confer upon you the hon- 
orary degree of Doctor of Science with all the honors, rights and 
privileges pertaining thereto. 

Pearl H. Welshimer, graduate of Millersville State Normal of 
Ohio Northern University and of Hiram College, ordained minister 
since 1897, pastor at Millersburg, Ohio, for the past twenty-four 
years in charge of the First Christian Church of Canton, Ohio, one 
of the greatest churches in America, lecturer, author, member of 
many boards, inspiring leader of men — ^by unanimous vote of the 
Board of Directors of Butler University I am authorized to confer 
upon you the honorary degree of Doctor of Divinity, with all the 
honors, rights and privileges pertaining thereto. 

Raphael Harwood Miller, graduate of Hiram College and of 
Auburn Theological Seminary, an ordained minister since 1902, 
pastor in Buffalo and in Kansas City, secretary of the Men and 
Millions Movement, member of the Board of Managers of United 
Christian Missionary Society, preacher of righteousness, active 
exemplar of Christian virtues — ^by unanimous vote of the Board of 

Honorary Degrees 117 

Directors of Butler University I am authorized to confer on you 
the honorary degree of Doctor of Laws, with all the honors, rights 
and privileges pertaining thereto. 

Demarchus Clariton Brown, A. B. and A. M. Butler University; 
student University of Tubingen, American School of Classical 
Studies, Athens; British, French, German Museums; for twenty- 
four years professor of Greek in Butler University; since 1906 
state librarian of Indiana; profound scholar, able administrator, 
genial friend, Christian gentleman — by a unanimous vote of the 
Board of Directors of Butler Unuiversity I am authorized to con- 
fer upon you the honorary degree of Doctor of Laws with all the 
rights, privileges and honors belonging thereto. 


Magna Cum Laude — Shailer Linwood Bass, in Chemistry 
Ernest Paul Fink, in Latin 
Florence Everett Hooper, in Botany 
Thomas C. Jaleski, in Chemistry & Zoology 
Margaret Cogswell Pihl, in Mathematics 
Rebecca E. Pitts, in English 
Paul Menzies Ross, in History 
Edna-Mae Thomas, in History 

Cum Laude — Virginia Delmont Curtis 

Florence E. Fritts 

J. Douglas Perry 

Janet Rioch 

Lucile Stokes 

Edna Rachel Todd 

Irma Elizabeth Ulrich 
Highest Standing for Seniors who have made as many as 
ninety semester hours in Butler University: Janet Rioch, Edna- 
Mae Thomas, Shailer Linwood Bass. 


Butler Alumnal Quarterly 


Joy Julian Bailey 
Shailer Linwood Bass 
Dorothy Carey 
Evelyn Lucerne Carpenter 
Helen Joan Chandler 
Dorotha Marjorie Chiles 
Virginia Delmont Curtis 
Ernest Paul Fink 
Florence Ernestine Fritts 
W. H. Brewer Graham 
Wanda Marie Haverkamp 
Florence Everett Hooper 
Thomas C. Jaleski 

J. Douglas Perry 
Margaret Cogswell Pihl 
Rebecca E. Pitts 
Paul Menzies Ross 
Lucile Stokes 
Marie L. Tacoma 
Edna-Mae Thomas 
Edna Rachel Todd 
Irma Elizabeth Ulrich 
Margaret Ruth Waters 
Lewis Wilson 
Mary Lester Winter 
Dorothea L. Wolfe 

Senior Scholarships — Full Tuition : Ferdinand Mehrlich 

Half Tuition: Lester Earl Budd, Helen 
Marjorie Pascoe 

Alumni Scholarships — Full Tuition : Pauline Faye Peirce 
Full Tuition: Anna Louise Hall 


The class of 1917 held its annual gathering on Sunday evening 
following the Baccalaureate service at the home of Mr. and Mrs. 
Myron ]\L Hughel on Central Avenue. Supper was enjoyed in 
tlieir garden pervaded by a cordial spirit of friendliness. The past 
was rehearsed and the future was discussed. Next year will occur 
the tenth anniversary of the graduation of this loyal class and al- 
ready plans are in formation for fireworks such as the alumni 
have never seen. There were present : Mr. and Mrs. William Book 
(Margaret Moore), Mr. and Mrs. Leland Carter (Charlotte Bach- 
mann), Mr. and Mrs. Austin V. Clifford, Mr. and Mrs. Earl T. 
Bonham, Mr. and Mrs. John L. H. Fuller, Mr. and Mrs. George E. 
Gill (Urith Dailey), Mr. and Mrs. Leroy C. Hanby, Mr. and Mrs. 
M. M. Hughel, Mr. and Mrs. John I. Kautz, Mr. and Mrs. John 
Paul Ragsdale (Mary Louise Rumpler), Miss Hazel Stanley, and 
Miss Graydon. 


The annual luncheon of the class of 1914 was held as usual at 
the Hotel Lincoln. The numbers were few, but the spirit of fellow- 
ship was fine. There were present Elvin E. Daniels, Ellen Graham 
George, Karl Means and Mrs. Means, Paul W. Ward, Pearl Wolf 
Whitlock and Miss Graydon. Professor Ward is connected with the 
department of philosophy of the University of Syracuse, New York. 
Dr. Means was en route to his new home, where he will be in charge 
of the department of chemistry in Milligan College, Tennessee. 


Perhaps the class of 1908 has uninterruptedly held an annual 
meeting longer than any other class. Their breakfast, usually en- 
joyed in Ellenberger Woods, was, because of rain held on Tuesday, 
June 15, at the home of Gretchen Scotten in Irvington. Ten were 
present, including children. The membership of this class is 
widely scattered over the face of the country, yet the local repre- 
sentation never fails in gathering at alumni time. 


120 Butler Alumnal Quarterly 


On June 12, 1890, there graduated from Butler twelve men and 
six women. This class has the unique distinction of having passed 
thirty-six years without the loss of a single member. 

On the evening of June 11, fourteen of this class, together 
with accumulated wives and husbands, met at the home of Julia 
Graydon Jameson to begin a three-day reunion. Twenty-four 
sat down to a beautiful and generous dinner and to renew old 
friendships. Those present were: Mr. and Mrs. J. N. Jessup of 
Lafayette ; Mr. and Mrs. John D. Nichols of Mooseheart, 111. ; Mr. 
and Mrs. Henry T. Mann of Mannville, Fla. ; Mr. and Mrs. J. F. 
Findley of Longmont, Col. ; Frank D. Muse of Spokane, Washing- 
ton. ; Mr. and Mrs. B. M. Davis of Oxford, Ohio ; Mrs. Tace Meeker 
Stearns of Chicago, 111. ; Miss India Martz of Kokomo, Ind. ; Otis 
Green of Kansas City, Mo.; Mr. and Mrs. Chas. M. Fillmore, Mr. 
and Mrs. H. S. Schell, Mr. and Mrs. George S. Cottman, and Mr. 
and Mrs. Alexander Jameson, of Indianapolis. Miss Katharine 
M. Graydon and Miss Mildred Jessup were also guests. Those not 
able to be present were : A. C. Smithers, Los Angeles, Calif. ; Frank 
Marshall, Enid, Okla. ; Augusta L. Stevenson, Indianapolis, and 
Laz Noble, Warrenton, Va. 

After the dinner, letters and telegrams from absent members 
were read and those present were asked to tell something of their 
lives and experiences through the years. There was much men- 
tion and perhaps a little boasting of children and grandchildren, 
their numbers, height and general superiority. John Nichols 
claimed the largest number of children and told of his life at 
Mooseheart where he is father to hundreds of orphans. Frank 
Muse and Frank Findley related some of their experiences in 
pioneer preaching and teaching. Henry Mann could not refrain 
from singing the praises of his adopted state, Florida. Otis Green, 
who is in the drug business, said that future years were bringing 
old age to all of us when we might need the wherewithal to repair 
the ravages of time and bring us comfort and solace, so he was 
presenting to each woman a box of powder and to each man a 

Class Reunions 121 

cigar. Then Charlie Fillmore told of his anti-tobacco crusade 
and nobody offered to light a cigar. Charlie needn't have worried, 
however, for Otis' cigars were like his powder, for looks only. 
They were made of rubber. 

There was much of reminiscence in the talks, all harking back 
to the happy days of college life, expressing appreciation of our 
Alma Mater and acknowledging our indebtedness to the teachers 
of our day.. One after another they were mentioned, and all with 
affection and feeling. Only four of these are still living — Scot 
Butler, D. C. Brown, 0. P. Hay and T. M. Iden. 

On Saturday morning the class motored to Fairview to inspect 
the new site for Butler. At noon they returned to the home of 
Stewart and Romaine Schell where a delightful luncheon was 
served. The program of our 1890 commencement was interesting 
to all, as were the graduating photographs. Later, in the yard, 
new group pictures were taken, in which one fears it will be hard 
to recognize the boys and girls of thirty-six years ago. 

After attending 1926 's class performance in the afternoon, the 
veterans of 1890 gathered round a long table on the college lawn 
for the alumni supper. India Martz represented the class in the 
talks that were made later in the college chapel. The football 
heroes, of which our class boasted several, were called on, and John 
Nichols and Henry Mann told of the days of real sport. 

Perhaps the climax of the reunion was reached on Sunday 
morning when 1890 had charge of the services at the Downey 
Avenue Christian Church. J. F., Findley read the scriptures, 
Frank Muse offered the prayer, J, N. Jessup preached the sermon 
and H. S. Schell and Charles M. Fillmore presided at the com- 
munion table. The class attended in a body, seats having been 
reserved for them. 

Sunday dinner was enjoyed together at the home of Mr. and Mrs. 
Jameson and during the afternoon a number of old college friends 
called. At four o'clock all adjourned to the college chapel for the 
Baccalaureate service, after which the class repaired to the home 
of Mr. and Mrs. George Cottman for supper. A number of old 

122 BuTLEE Alumnal Quarterly 

programs and college papers afforded much amusement and we 
were all transported back thirty-six years when India Martz read 
from the Collegian of June, 1890, a full account of our Com- 
mencement week, with all its "Spring Exliibitions " of literary 
societies, class day, receptions and comments on the graduates' 
essays and orations. The class will, which had been carefully pre- 
pared for the class day of 1890, was read by its author, H. S. 
Schell. This important document had been stolen by mischievous 
under classmen at that time, and it now had an audience for the 
first time. After much solicitation Charlie Fillmore gave the his- 
tory of and sang his famous song, ''Tell Mother I'll Be There." 
This led to a singing of old time songs by everyone with Mr. Fill- 
more at the piano. 

On Monday morning the class was honored by being included 
in the processional, following the caps and gowns of '26. Our 
last hour together was at the home of Julia Jameson where we 
lunched and said our farewells. It was decided to hold another 
reunion in 1930 and we all promised to be on hand for the fiftieth 
celebration in 1940. Charles M. Fillmore, in a few words of 
prayer, voiced the gratitude of all for the joys of our reunion, for 
the richness of our lives, for the hope of many happy years to 
come. "Auld Lang Syne," "Blest Be the Tie that Binds," and 
' ' God Be With You Till We Meet Again ' ' were sung heartily but 
tearfully as we realized that the days of our companionship were 
over and we must part to our widely separated homes. 

The class of 1890 has held three reunions, in 1915, 1920 and 1926. 
At the first there was surprise and delight. The old ties meant so 
much more than we had realized and it was so good to see the class- 
mates of twenty-five years ago. In 1920, because of various reasons, 
there were few present, but it was a meeting of deep feeling. The 
present reunion has been the best of all. The May time of life has 
gone but the fruition period has arrived.. There has been no death, 
there has been no failure in our number. All are reaping the 
joys of the harvest — "honor, obedience, troops of friends" and 
contentment in the durable satisfactions of life. 

ViDA TiBBOTT CoTTMAN, Class Secretary. 

From the City Office 123 


Present indications point to the completion of the boulevard 
around the new Fairview park site within a very short time. 

At the annual May Day ceremonies, which were held for the 
first time this year in Fairview park, ground was broken to in- 
dicate the lines that will be followed in erecting the first buildings. 
Hilton U. Brown, chairman of the board of directors of the uni- 
versity, spoke briefly of the significance of the occasion and held 
the plow handles when the first furrow was turned. The entire 
celebration at Fairview was replete with unusual features and 
marked another definite step in the direction of moving the uni- 
versity to the new location. 

Dr. Frederick D. Kershner, dean of the Butler College of Re- 
ligion, and John W. Atherton, executive secretary of the university, 
represented the school at the annual meeting of the Christian 
churches of Indiana, in Bloomington. Both were speakers on the 
program. Dean Kershner explained the plan and program for the 
College of Religion. Mr. Atherton also dwelt upon the plan to 
make the College of Religion the dominant graduate school of the 
brotherhood. During Mr. Atherton 's remarks he gave a detailed 
accounting of the work done thus far in raising funds for addi- 
tional endowment, new buildings and the school of religion. 

A recent gift of importance to the university was the donation of 
$80,000 made by Mrs. Carrie Frances Robertson, widow of Alex- 
ander M. Robertson, who died three years ago. This sum is to be 
applied toward the erection of a chapel building on the new Butler 
site. The gift was made by Mrs. Robertson in memory of her hus- 
band, who was much interested in the educational advancement of 
Indianapolis and who hoped to see established in Indianapolis a 
university that would be in keeping with the city's development 
along other lines. Before his death he and Mrs. Robertson mu- 
tually agreed that Butler University should be the chief recipient 
of their estate when they were through with it. 

''The gift made by Mrs. Robertson," said Arthur V. Brown, 
a member of the City Committee, "is additional evidence of the 

124 Butler Alumnal Quarterly 

appeal being made by the Butler expansion program. Not only 
was it generous and magnificent on the part of Mrs. Robertson, 
but it was assurance to us that our plea is not falling on deaf 
ears and that, eventually, whatever is needed to complete the 
new Butler program will be forthcoming." 

A gift of $50,000, to be applied to the building funds, has been 
made by an anonymous donor, Mr. Atherton has announced. The 
friend of the university, who gave this money, also made a sub- 
stantial contribution to the endowment fund in the early stages 
of the financial campaign. 

' ' Our only regret about the $50,000 gift ' ', said William G. Irwin, 
"is our inability to give proper credit to the donor. We are com- 
pelled, however, to respect the wishes of the person who made this 
bountiful donation. It is another indication of the interest being 
taken in our campaign for a great educational institution." 

The fiscal year ending July 1 was the most successful in the 
history of Butler University, according to the financial report of 
John W. Atherton, which was submitted to the board of directors 
at a meeting July 14. 

The report of Mr. Atherton showed that in the year just closed 
the university made large financial gain. New gifts were in ex- 
cess of $660,000. During the same period, the city office's cash 
collections were more than $700,000. Interest from the donations 
amounted to more than the entire promotional charges. 

Every dollar contributed to the university funds, in the cam- 
paign to obtain money to build a new institution at Fairview park, 
will be used for the purposes the donors intended. William G. 
Irwin, chairman of the general campaign committee, explained 
that in practically every campaign of this nature a part of the 
money raised must be taken to defray promotional expenses. 

"Our work has been extremely unusual in that respect," said 
Mr. Irwin. "The interest from our contributions has been such 
that we have a comfortable balance in the interest fund and at 
the same time this interest has paid all of the promotion expenses. 
In short, every contributor will be glad to know that every cent 

From the City Office 125 

he gave to the endowment or building funds will be used and that 
no part of these contributions has been needed to pay what com- 
monly is called overhead. We are confident that the same showing 
will be made in the future." 

C. W. Wilson, secretary of Butler, reported that all of the 
university expenses for the year had been met and there is a 
balance in the treasuiy. 

The three new directors chosen are R. A. Long, Kansas City, 
Mo. ; Crate Bowen, of Miami, Fla., and Arthur Jordan, Indian- 
apolis capitalist. They take the places of the Rev. Z. T. Sweeney, 
L. C. Hoss and Lex Kirkpatrick, who died in the last year. An- 
other vacancy on the board of directors will be filled later. 

Some necessary changes in the architectural plans for the first 
buildings to be erected at Fairview have delayed approval of the 
drawings and the letting of contracts. Mr. Atherton expresses 
disappointment over this delay but points out that corrections 
should be made now, while changes are possible. It is the hope of 
the university authorities to start actual construction some time 
this summer. 

126 Butler Alumnal Quarterly 


Honor Day was observed on May 7 as the occasion when in the 
mad rush of school activities time was taken to recognize those 
who have accomplished feats and upheld Butler's academic stand- 
ing. Honor Day is no longer an annual custom. It has become 
a tradition backed by the respect that students have for academic 

President Aley presented in chapel the awards to students who 
won money prizes in academic contests, those who received appoint- 
ments at other universities, and seniors who had been voted into 
membership of the Phi Kappa Phi national honor society. 

Winners of the contests and their money prizes are : Oratorical 
contest, first, Lewis "Wilson, $30 ; second, Parker Wheatley, $15 ; 
extemporaneous contest : First, J. Douglas Perry, $10 ; second, John 
Love, $5; peace oratorial contest: Local winner, John Love; third 
place in state meet, John Love ; debating contest : Affirmative team 
composed of Robert Hutchinson, Frank Furstenberg and Lester 
Budd and negative team composed of Rudolph Baker, Lewis Wil- 
son, Horace Storer, winners of seven decisions out of eight debates ; 
and literary contest : First, Ferdinand Mehrlich, $50 ; second, 
Louise Eleanor Rose, $25. Honor was given the women's debating 
squads composed of Alice Kepner, Elizabeth Moschenross, Louise 
Frisbie, affirmative, and Billie Mae Kreider, Mary Frances Ogle, 
Alice Reynolds, negative. 

The recognition given to students receiving appointments in 
other institutions went to John Mason, offered scholarships in his- 
tory at Wisconsin, Illinois, Chicago universities ; Florence Hooper, 
appointed an assistant in Plant Chemistry at Iowa State College; 
Lowell Mullen, a teaching fellowship in botany at Washington 
State college ; Thomas C. Jaleski, a graduate assistantship in chem- 
istry at Yale University ; Shailer Bass, a graduate assistantship in 
chemistry at Yale. 

The Scarlet Quill Scholarship was awarded to Jane Ogborn. 
The names of the ten junior girls taken into the Scarlet Quill, 
the national honorary society for senior women, were read : Eleanor 

Honor Day 127 

Dunn, Billie Mae Kreider, Martha Zoercher, Helen Pascoe, Dorothy 
Knisely, Kathryn Bowlby, Lucy Ashjian, Frances Woolery, lone 
Agnew, Jeanne Bouslog. 

The names of the senior class elected to membership in the Phi 
Kappa Phi society, the national scholastic honorary society, were 
read. Dr. Aley then presented to Janet Rioch a check for $1,000 
as the prize won by her for the essay in the American Chemical 
Society contest. 

The address of the Day was given by Dr. F. R. Moulton, head 
of department of astronomy in the University of Chicago, dealing 
with science and its effect upon living organisms. In part, the 
speaker said : ' ' No where in the world is there such a favored place 
for the youth of the world to live than in our country. The ad- 
vantages we inherit are due to the toil of our predecessors, and this 
fact imposes upon you young men and women a tremendous re- 
sponsibility. We owe it to those who have gone before to cultivate 
our higher faculties. In three ways may we and our successors 
follow: first, to obtain a more perfect control over the inanimate 
world; second, to work out human relations on a practical basis 
that will cast off the inequalities that hamper us, such as wrong 
economic and social relationships ; and, third, to look forward to 
the evolution of the human race. 

"The effect that science has had upon us as thinking creatures 
— as those with highly organized central nervous systems — is 
great. There are 600,000 young men and women who are now de- 
voting time to education in universities. Science has made this 
possible for with its combinations it has reduced the hours of labor 
and allowed more time in which men may educate their higher 
faculties. It is from science we have the opportunity to study 
great men." 

In conclusion the speaker remarked that he envied the students 
their youth and opportunities and congratulated them on having 
an institution in which they could look toward great minds. The 
plan of Honor Day, he said, was a novel one, and he hoped the 
students would not forget that for which it stood. 

128 BuTLEE Alumnal Quarterly 



Athletic events 9:00 

Breakfast 11 :00 

Band concert 1:00 

Pageant 2:30 

Ground Breaking 4:00 

College sing 4:15 

All-College Dance, Riley Room, 
Claypool 8:30 

To Butler's all-too-meager list of traditions a splendid addition 
has been made, a splendid precedent has been set for posterity. 

The College has had a May Day worthy of the name. The success 
of so large a venture as was planned was at first a little doubtful. 
People wondered whether it would be worth while — all this business 
of having a holiday for the whole school and making a public day 
of the affair — but now there is no doubt in anyone's mind that 
the project proved its own worth. 

The administration of the college declared a holiday for Friday, 
May 21, thus showing its belief and confidence in the ability of 
the student body to make the most of its opportunities. May Day 
started out, as all May Days had done before, under the direct 
supervision of the Woman's League. Through the excellent or- 
ganization of Virginia Curtis, the president of the League, the 
day's activities began to assume the mammoth proportions for 
which it had been conceived. 

And when the men of the school organized a group designed to 
function in the same manner as the League, the women realized the 
need for their help and called upon them accordingly. After 
some hesitancy, natural because of the newness of the idea to 
co-operate with the girls in anything, the men responded nobly 
to the call for their aid, and the result was : 

A May Day larger in scope, more inclusive in its proportions 

May Day 129 

than has ever been known before at Butler ; a series of celebrations 
on a larger and more stupendous scale than has ever been pre- 
sented at Butler; an audience of townspeople not connected with 
Butler larger than has ever attended any Butler function, and a 
recognition by the city papers to a greater extent than has ever 
before been accorded to the college. 

Butler is now recognized as an integral part of the city of In- 
dianapolis. It has been placed before the eyes of the Indianapolis 
public by the tireless activities of certain of its students. Can we 
not continue this tradition so excellently established? Can not 
May Day in the future be set down in the school calendar as a 
regular school holiday — as a tribute to the splendid efforts of 
those individuals, Virginia Curtis, Clarence Jaleski, Irma Ulrich, 
Dorothy Knisely and Elizabeth Anderson, who have made possible 
the establishment of a precedent such as has been set this year? 

— The Butler Collegian. 


The great gray boulder which students of many college genera- 
tions have known on the campus near the gymnasium now stands 
on the Brown Triangle, corner of Washington street and Emerson 
avenue, and is the base of a bronze tablet memorial to Hilton U. 
Brown, Jr. This familiar landmark came from the field upon 
which young Brown played as a college athlete and it goes to rest 
upon the plot of ground where he romped in sport as a child. As 
long as it stands there it will be a reminder of the close bond that 
existed between the honored young soldier and Butler College. 

The tablet is stamped at each of the upper corners with a Mal- 
tese cross on crossed swords. On each cross is a head with a 
wreath of victory on the brow. Below is inscribed, ' ' In memory of 
Hilton U. Brown, Jr., who played at mimic warfare on these 
grounds and who November 3, 1918 in the language of Petain, 
Marshal of France, 'Died gloriously in the Argonne while serving 
his battery under concentrated enemy fire' Seventh Division, F. 

130 Butler Alumnal Quarterly 

The dedicatory program was presented on the afternoon of May 
30 in presence of a large gathering of friends representing the city, 
the state, the army, the navy, the marines, the Legion, Butler 
College, Phi Delta Theta fraternity, and Downey Avenue Church. 

The program in charge of the Hilton U. Brown, Jr., Post and 
the Irvington Posts of the American Legion, consisted of speeches 
made by Thomas C. Howe, Emsley W. Johnson, Colonel Grosvenor 
W. Townsend, Lester Heath, Governor Ed. Jackson. The Reverend 
George W. Allison read the Legion Memorial Prayer and the 
Reverend Michael W., Lyons pronounced the benediction. Hilton 
Brown Atherton unveiled the tablet. The service was closed with 
taps sounded by army buglers. 


The resignation of Demarchus C. Brown, '79, effective September 
1, has been announced. The press of July 1 in commenting upon 
this action says : In his letter to the board Dr. Brown referred to 
his inability to carry the burden of direction, owing to recent im- 
pairment of his health and the advice of his physician to conserve 
his physical resources. It appears probable that as he regains his 
strength the library will again have the benefit of his counsel and 
help, and the state willl continue to benefit by the application of 
his scholarly talents to its cultural growth. 

Dr. Brown's record of twenty years of uninterrupted service to 
the state in a position which is subject to many vagaries is a notable 
page in the history of Indiana government. He brought to the 
position the best the state had to offer in the way of training, aug- 
mented by study abroad, and he shaped his habits of study to meet 
the expanding purpose of the library. Indiana has been fortunate 
in its libraries. Dr. Brown has expanded and developed the li- 
brary's best traditions. He will leave its direction next September 
with credit for having perfected it as a librarians' library and 
through the mail book — lending service, a state library in fact, serv- 
ing every community in the state on almost instant notice. He 

Resignation of D, C. Brown 131 

was especially successful in surrounding himself with a staff 
of varied talents and fine sense of loyalty. 

In his letter of resignation, Dr. Brown repeats his frequent allu- 
sions to the need for a state library building. The state might 
well take up this matter as a tribute to his service. The fact that 
the library work claimed twenty years of the life of a man of Dr. 
Brown's superior qualities as a scholar, librarian and citizen, and 
that his retention under several administrations was universally 
acclaimed, should exercise a stimulating influence upon the gen- 
erous impulses of the next legislature. The state will always feel 
grateful to Dr. Brown for his work, not only as a librarian, but as 
a member of its board of charities, as an indefatigable advocate of 
the preservation of sources of state history, and as a man whose 
linguistic sense elevated its cultural standards. It is gratifying 
to know that Dr. Brown will continue to serve the library in some 


The Alumni Association, through its organization of Class Sec- 
retaries, voted to continue through the year 1926- '27 two scholar- 
ships known as Alumni Scholarships, of the value of one year's 
tuition. These honors were bestowed upon Pauline Pierce, '27, 
and Anna Louise Hall, '30. 

The University Commerce club of Butler will annually award 
a scholarship to the man majoring in economics or business ad- 
ministration who maintains the highest scholastic average during 
the school year. The award, which is the full tuition for one se- 
mester, will be given the first semester of each school year. This 
scholarship is open only to members of the sophomore and junior 
classes. In addition, the name of the holder of each scholarship 
award will be inscribed on a commerce scholastic trophy which wiU 
remain the permanent property of the college. The Commerce 
club is offering these scholarships as a result of an increased in- 
terest in the college and for the purpose of "boosting" the insti- 
tution. The business men of the club wish to see a greater interest 


Butler Alumnal Quarterly 

taken in economics and business administration, by the men of the 
university. The first scholarship award will be made in the fall 
of 1927 and will be based upon the work done during the school 
year, 1926-1927. 

The Sphinx Club (honorary society) has voted to bestow an- 
nually a loving cup upon the graduating senior who makes the 
highest four-year average. The first cup will be presented upon 
Honor Day of 1927. 


Miss Sarah E. Cotton, registrar of the college, has made public 
the averages of various organizations and unorganized students on 
campus. The following is the official average as it is held in the 

Woman's Fraternities — 
Kappa Kappa Gamma_84.783 
Kappa Alpha Theta_— 83.867 

Alpha Chi Omega 83.585 

Delta Delta Delta 82.356 

Zeta Tau Alpha 82.337 

Delta Gamma 82.049 

Pi Beta Phi 81.951 

Delta Zeta 80.087 

Alpha Delta Pi 79.516 

Alpha Delta Theta 78.859 

Miscellaneous Averages — 

Woman's Fraternities_82.373 

Men's Fraternities 74.284 

Organized Groups 78.055 

Unorganized Students_75.593 

Men's Fraternities — 

Butler Association 85.001 

Delta Tau Delta 75.756 

Tau Kappa Tau 75.704 

Sigma Chi 74.933 

Chi Rho Zeta 73.603 

Delta Phi Sigma 71.936 

Lambda Chi Alpha 71.540 

Alha Rho Delta 71.443 

Phi Delta Theta 70.317 

Average of Men 74.801 

Average of Women 81.722 

Average of Student 

Body 76.959 

Degrees fob Butler Alumni 133 


Upon George A. Schumacher, '25, was conferred by the Uni- 
versity of Virginia the degree of Master of Arts for work in Eng- 
lish. Mr. Schumacher has been appointed instructor in the de- 
partment of English of Butler University for next year. 

The Indiana University Medical School has conferred the degree 
of Doctor of Medicine upon: 

Durbin Day, A. B. Butler, '23. Dr. Day has been appointed 
to the Naval Hospital, San Diego, California. 

James Himler, A. B. Butler, '23. Dr. Himler has been appointed 
to the Riley Hospital. 

Claire Ingalls, A. B. Butler, '23. Dr. Ingalls has been appointed 
to the Indianapolis City Hospital. 

J. T. C. McCallum, A. B. Butler, '16. Dr. McCallum has been 
appointed to the Indianapolis City Hospital. 

John Melvin Masters, A. B. Butler, '21. Dr. Masters has been 
appointed to the Indianapolis City Hospital. 


During the past spring season Butler athletic teams maintained 
the high standard which has been set during the past few years. 
The baseball team, under the able coaching of Athletic Director 
Paul Hinkle, made as good a record as any team in Indiana and, 
although the championship race was badly muddled, the Bulldog 
team had a valid claim for premier honors. The feature of the 
season was the double victory over the strong Wabash nine, in 
which the excellent pitching of Captain Ewing completely baffled 
the Cavemen. Captain Ewing, along with Mills, Strole, Nipper, 
Woodling and Reichel, graduated in June and Coach Hinkle will 
have to build a new infield next spring around Bob Woolgar, third 
baseman, who was elected captain for 1927. The Freshman team, 
under Coach Middlesworth, contained some valuable material from 
which the holes in the varsity line^|>v«^ja^^j^'e"^ii4^aptain Fro- 

line^i>v (pig ^^ Med^^^^aptaii 

•■^vt0^h>^' — 


134 Butler Alumnal Quarterly 

muth, of the yearling squad, looks like a ''find" in the pitcher's 

Captain Phillips of the track squad proved to be one of the 
greatest runners in the country. In the State meet he won both 
the quarter and half mile events, setting a new record in the 
quarter mile. A week later, he won the same two events at Mil- 
waukee in the Central Inter-Collegiate meet. On June 12, in the 
National Collegiate meet in Chicago, Phillips rose to national fame 
by setting a new record for the quarter mile, winning from a field 
of stars from all over the country. Prospects for a good all-around 
track squad next spring are fairly bright, as Phillips has another 
year of competition and the reserve and freshman squads contain 
some fine material which should develop rapidly next year. 

Captain Sagalowsky made another clean sweep of State tennnis 
honors and at the time of writing is making a fine showing in the 
National Meet at Philadelphia. Freshman tennis brought out some 
promising players and Butler should be able to maintain her high 
ranking in this sport, despite the fact that the graduation of Sag- 
alowsky will leave the squad without an experienced star. 


Football prospects for the coming fall are only fair. The loss 
of twelve men by graduation leaves Coach Hinkle with only a 
handful of experienced men from which to build a nucleus for the 
gridiron machine that will represent Butler next season. It is 
asking too much to expect Coach Hinkle adequately to fill, in one 
year, the places left vacant by such stars as Bob Nipper, Lew 
Reichel, Jerry Strole, Bob Keach, Lefty Woodling, Hi Hensel, 
Gordon Paul, Carter Helton, Carl Cecil, Dave Kilgore, George 
Mulholland, and Konold. The freshman squad from last fall con- 
tained some fine material, which should, with experience, give 
Coach Hinkle the necessary men to build a real machine. The 
schedule for the coming season is the hardest that any Butler team 
has ever tackled and only the stoutest kind of work on the part of 
both coaches and players will enable the Bulldogs to carry off a 

Athletics 135 

majority of victories. Coach Strohmeier held a six weeks' session 
of spring football practice during which the members of last fall's 
3^earling squad were given instruction in the system which Coach 
Hinkle will employ next fall and the results obtained were highly 
satisfactory. Practice is scheduled to commence on September 8, 
which will give the squad a little over two weeks of work before the 
opening game on September 25. The complete schedule follows : 

September 26 — Earlham College, "Indianapolis Day" 

October 2 — Hanover College. 

October 9 — At the University of Illinois. 

October 16 — Franklin College. 

October 23 — DePauw University. 

October 30 — Lombard College, "Dad's Day." 

November 6 — Wabash College. 

November 13 — At the University of Minnesota. 

November 20 — At Dayton University. 

It is with regret that the college announces the departure of 
Hugh W., Middlesworth, '24, assistant coach, who has accepted a 
position with the athletic department at Indiana University. Mr. 
Middlesworth attained much fame for his work on the athletic 
teams during his four years at Butler. 

The athletic department is fortunate indeed in securing as a 
successor to Mr. Middlesworth another ex-Butler athlete. Robert 
Nipper, '26, who has been one of the outstanding athletes of the 
college during the past four years, is the latest addition to the 
coaching staff. 

The Quarterly desires to extend best wishes for success to both 
Mr. Middlesworth and Mr. Nipper. 

136 Butler Alumnal Quarterly 


With the closing of the school year has come another issue of 
the Drift, the annual year book, issued by the Junior class. The 
volume for 1926 contains the usual sections devoted to the faculty, 
board of directors and all phases of campus life. The latter part 
of the book is given separately to the Law Department. 

The Drift also contains some pleasing and unusual features. The 
art work is of a very high quality. The cover of dull red and tan 
with the single letter B in the center makes the book unusually 
attractive from the exterior. With the exception of the embossed 
B, the cover is an exact replica of a book in the British Museum. 
Beautifully colored illustrations accompany the accounts of each 
of the departments of the college. The foreword and the dedication 
are unusually noteworthy. Throughout the book there are many 
pages which contribute to the artistic quality of the book. Four 
pages comprising the beauty section are devoted to women of 

The Drift was edited by Wilson Daily, the business management 
was handled by Ralph L. Hitch. Four hundred and fifty more 
copies have been sold this year than any previous issue. The 
Drift of 1926 is an able successor to the Drift of 1925, the national 
prize-winner, and has the hearty congratulations of The Quar- 


The Lambda Chi Alpha fraternity is reported to have made the 
first purchase of a lot at the Fairview site, 82 by 132 feet. 

The lot is situated fifty feet outside the new Butler campus, 
three squares from the canal. It is an ideal location between the 
two main thoroughfares of Sunset avenue and 44th street. To the 
north two blocks is Blue Ridge road, an east and west thorofare. 
To the west three blocks, is the north and south street — Boulevard 
Place. On the south is the east and west street — Berkeley road. 

Enrollment 137 


At the last chapel of the freshman class President Aley gave 
a brief report of this year. In the two semesters there was a total 
enrollment of 1,652 students; 443 towns other than Indianapolis 
were represented ; 46 of the original number of students came from 
17 different states, and 10 from nine foreign countries. 

Five years ago there was a graduating class of fifty-six. This 
year there is a class three and one-half times as large for one hun- 
dred and ninety-two will receive diplomas. 

Of the 1,642 students only 105 stated no church affiliations. 
Four hundred and twenty-nine were members of the Christian 

"I confidently expect that attendance at Butler will increase 
greatly next year. We will have in two years one of the best col- 
leges in the world, undoubtedly of the best in America. You mem- 
bers of the freshman class of today will spend your last two years 
at Fairview. I hope to see you start out next year with the largest 
sophomore class that Butler has ever known," said Dr. Aley. 


The Summer School is in session with 404 students, to date. 
The faculty consists of: 

Robert Judson Aley, Ph. D., LL, D., President. 

James William Putnam, Ph. D., Dean and Professor of Eco- 
nomics, Director. 

Sarah Hill Baumgartner, A. B., Instructor in German, 

A. Dale Beeler, A. M., Assistant Professor in History. 

Henry Lane Bruner, Ph. D., Professor of Biology. 

Evelyn Butler, '93, A. M., Professor of English. 

Marie Cousin, Instructor in French. 

Murray A. Dalman, A. M., Director of Research, Indianapolis 
Public Schools. 

138 Butler Alumnal Quarterly 

Seth Earl Elliott, M. S., Professor of Physics. 

Ray Clarence Friesner, Ph. D., Professor of Botany. 

Henry Mills Gelston, A. B., Professor of Latin. 

Pleasant R. Hightower, A. M., Assistant Professor of Education. 

Paul D. Hinkle, B. S., Director of Athletics. 

Elijah Newton Johnson, A. M., M. S., Professor of Mathematics. 

Frederick D. Kershner, LL. D., Professor of Christian Doctrine. 

Bruce L. Kershner, A. M., Professor of New Testament and 
Church History. 

Martha May Kincaid, '13, A. M., Instructor in French. 

Andrew Leitch, '11, Ph. D., Professor of Philosophy and Psy- 
chology. Bethany College, Professor of Educational Psychology. 

Albert Mock, A. M., Assistant Professor of Education. 

Charles Mervin Palmer, M. S., Assistant Professor of Botany. 

May K. Schaefer, '24, A. B., Instructor in Zoology. 

Guy Howard Shadinger, Ph. D., Professor of Chemistry. 

Irvin T. Shultz, A. M., Assistant Professor of Education. 

Claude Sifritt, A. M., Assistant Professor of Public Speaking. 

Allegra Stewart, '21, A. M., Instructor in English. 

Fay Shover, '00, A. M., Instructor in English. 


The following excerpt appearing in The Indianapolis News of 
June 15 has called forth several interesting expressions: 

Robert Holton Bull, who received his degree at Butler College 
represented the fourth generation of one family to be identified 
with Butler. He is the ninth of his family to attend the school 
and the tenth to be connected with it. 

It is the first instance on record of a connection with Butler car- 
ried through four generations. 

Family Representation 139 

Bull's grandfather, grandmother, father, mother, and four un- 
cles all attended Butler and his maternal great-grandfather, Dr. 
James Ford, was one of the incorporators of Northwestern Chris- 
tian University, established under the auspices of the Disciples of 
Christ in 1850. This institution became Butler College in 1870. 

In his ' ' History of the Ford Family, ' ' Dr. Ford places affiliation 
with Butler as the greatest heritage he can bequeath to his posterity 
in the following paragraph : 

''To my children: Butler University is destined to be a great 
institution of learning in the various departments of human knowl- 
edge. It is my desire that the interest on my stock shall be used 
for the benefit of my family and their descendants, male or fe- 

Although Dr. Ford did not attend Butler as a student, his 
daughter, Allena Ford, was a member of the class of 1866. She 
was married to Benjamin Franklin Williams, who was graduated 
at the head of the Butler law class in 1859. In the civil war he 
served as captain of the 8th regiment, Indiana volunteer infantry. 

Bull's father, Robert Alexander Bull, of Chicago, was the pres- 
ident of the class of 1897, and is a past president of the Butler 
Alumni Association. His mother, Mrs. Anna Holton Williams 
Bull, was a member of the class of 1898, and the daughter of Ben- 
jamin Franklin Williams. 

Bull's four uncles who attended the college were Jesse Benton 
Williams, 1895; Edwin Holton Ford, ex- '84; Frank Ford Wil- 
liams, 1893, and John Sherman Williams, ex- '02. 

Edward H. Clifford, '93, of Christopher, Illinois, sends this fine 
record: John Ellis Clifford; Miles L. Clifford, '79; Vincent G. 
Clifford, '79; Perry H. Clifford, '89; Edward H. Clifford, '93; 
Grace J. Clifford, '01 (Mrs. Raymond A. Smith) ; Jeannette O, 
Clifford, '12 (Mrs. Ray V. Wickens) ; Austin V. CUfford, '17; 
Catherine Clifford ; Scot Butler Clifford, '23. 

The Brown family adds up well: Demarchus C. Brown, '79; 
Hilton U. Brown, '80 ; Louise Brown (Mrs. J. W. Atherton) ; 

140 Butler Alumnal Quarterly 

Mark Brown; Mary Brown (Mrs. George Stewart) ; Archibald A. 
Brown ; Jean Brown, '19 ; Hilton U. Brown, Jr. ; Paul V. Brown, 
'24; Jessica M. Brown, '24; Ji^ia A. Brown, '26; Philip C. 
Brown, '23. 

Of the Jameson family the following representation may be 
given: Alexander C. Jameson; Sarah Jameson (Mrs. William 
Wallace) ; Ada Jameson ; Rebecca Jameson ; Emma Jameson ; Eliz- 
abeth M. Jameson; Lucy M. Jameson; Henry Jameson, '69; Ovid 
B. Jameson; George L. Jameson; Edward L. Jameson; Thomas J. 
Jameson; Anna Jameson; Cordelia C. Jameson (Mrs. A. S. Cald- 
well) ; Charles T. Jameson; Alexander Jameson; Katharine Merrill 
Jameson, '16 (Mrs. P. C. Lewis) ; Henry M. Jameson, '19 ; Lydia 
Douglass Jameson. 

The Blount family is thus represented in the College catalogues : 
Cyrus N. Blount, '58; Barzillai M. Blount, '95; EU V. Blount, 
'59; Jacob Blount, '66; Barbara P. Blount, '68 (Mrs. Frank C. 
Cassel) ; (Alcinda T. Blount, '68 (Mrs. J. A. Canady) ; Robert S. 
Blount, '76 ; May Blount, (Mrs. E. S. Conner) ; Dora Grace Blount, 
'87; Friend Blount; Marvin Blount; Homer Blount; Roland 
Blount ; Robley D, Blount ; Lena Blount Van Horn ; Claude Blount 
Van Horn ; Eunice Blount Wright ; Charles Blount Winfield ; Ray 
Blount Winfield; Willis Blount, '97; Effine P. Blount; Mabel 
Blount Pfafifman; Anna M. Blount, '07 (Mrs. J. W. Curry) ; Verna 
Sweetman (Mrs. William Mendenhall) ; Lola Blunt Conner, '17; 
Lois B. Blount, '20 (Mrs. Herman J. Sheedy) ; Katherine Crebs 
McClure; Barbara Smith Blickenstaff; Carroll Blount. 

The Blount family has, therefore, received twelve degrees; the 
Clifford family, eight; the Brown, seven; the Jameson, three. 

The Students ajstd Forestry Preservation 141 


Stanley Cain, '25, instructor in the department of botany, talked 
to the students in chapel upon Forestry Preservation and at the 
close presented the following resolution, which was accepted by a 
rising vote and ordered to be forwarded to Ovid M. Butler, '02, 
secretary of the The American Forestry Association with offices 
at Washington, D. C. : 

Whereas, after twenty years of strenuous effort the preserva- 
tion of our forests has seemed assured, with large tracts set aside 
in the West under national guardianship and a growing tendency to 
establish reserves in the East, and 

Whereas, "flourishing woodlands", as declared by President 
Coolidge in his proclamation for National Forestry Week, April 
18-24, 1926, ''mean more than timber crops, permanent industries, 
and an adequate supply of wood. They minister to our outdoor 
recreation, they preserve animal and bird life; protect and beau- 
tify our hillsides and feed our streams ; they preserve the inspiring 
national environment which has contributed so much to American 
character," and 

Whereas, these areas with their natural resources, which are 
the property of the people as a whole, and the policies of the 
United States Forest Service which have been widely approved 
by scientific and other societies and by the public generally, are 
now seriously endangered by proposed legislation, namely the Stan- 
field grazing bill, known officially as S. 2584, and 

Whereas, this legislation, if passed, or similar legislation, would 
divest the government of its rightful control and the people of 
property and rights which are theirs, and would virtually form a 
series of easements, politically favoring and subsidizing certain 
individuals, and, 

Whereas, such a condition would result in practical annulment 
of present conservation policies and advantages and would result 
in exploitation of our natural resources more flagrant than that of 

142 Butler Alumnal Quarterly 

the Tea-pot Dome, Alaskan Coal, Timber Rights, etc., which have 
been national scandals, therefore, 

Be It Resolved, That the student body of Butler University of 
Indianapolis earnestly request the people and the Congress of the 
United States to prevent such legislation. 

Upon receipt of the resolution Mr. Butler wrote to Mr. Cain: 
It is a pleasant moment in our work when a letter like yours 
arrives. It makes us feel that our work is very much worth while, 
and then, of course, the fact that my Alma Mater has taken such 
splendid action in support of forest conservation is particularly 

Of all the resolutions pertaining to the Stanfield legislation 
which have come across my desk I can not recall any that show a 
clearer understanding of the situation or one that is worded more 
to the point than the one which the students of Butler University 
adopted. I congratulate you and them. 


Many letters to the alumni are sent from the secretary's office — 
perhaps too many; but certain facts are necessary concerning the 
maintenance of this office evidently not yet understood. 

Of every graduate of the College an alumni fee of two dollars 
due yearly on October 1 is desired. This fee is spent entirely upon 
the publication of The Quarterly — and then does not cover ex- 

The secretary may be at fault in her communications in speaking 
of the dues under caption of "subscription for The Quarterly," 
because several alumni have replied that one copy of the mag- 
azine is enough for their family, though several others have grad- 
uated. We realize that a whole family may read one copy, but 
we feel that no member of a family may assume the alumnal re- 
sponsibility of another member, that every degree carries with it 
the obligation and privilege of the payment of personal alumni 

Kindly Read 143 

In addition to this alumni fee of two dollars is asked a contri- 
bution of whatever amount an alumnus cares to make, from one 
dollar up, for the Alumni Scholarship Fund, this amount 
to be sent to the Class Secretary. The request for this contribution 
will come each year, so why not make this as easy as possible for 
your secretary by promptly — even without notification — paying? 
Next year will continue the offering by alumni of two scholarships 
in the form of the payment of a year's tuition each. 

If you look into the management of alumni affairs of any aca- 
demic institution, you will find nowhere so little asked of graduates 
as by Butler. For instance: In the east is a college we all know 
with a registration of 500 students. Last year its voluntary alumni 
contributions were sufficient to pay the running expenses of the 
alumni office which consisted of the salary of the alumni secretary 
(equal to a head professor's) and his two assistants, the publication 
of the alumni magazine, and at the close of the year to hand over 
to the College treasury a surplus of $7,000. ''You must have rich 
alumni," remarked an aghast listener. "Not at all, replied the 
secretary, "but practically every alumnus pays something into the 
alumni fund." This is by no means an unusual situation. 

There has been a reorganization of The Quarterly staff. A busi- 
ness manager has been added for the assistance of the editor, who 
will at the same time be treasurer of the Association. Therefore, 
hereafter pay your dues to George A. Schumacher, Butler Uni- 
versity. All business communications go to Mr. Schumacher. All 
literary communications go to Miss Gray don. If for any reason 
your Quarterly fails to reach you, notify either of the above 

It is essential that a correct mailing file be kept by the secretary, 
so kindly notify her of changed address. The last mailing brought 
back over fifty letters stamped with "address unknown". You 
will readily see this is trying at the office. We like to know where 
you are, we are interested in you and all your ways, so please keep 
us informed. 

The Executive Committee of the Alumni Association is composed, 

144 Butler Alumnal Quarterly 

according to the constitution, of the the officers elected in June to 
whom are added another member appointed by the president of 
the university (for next year George A. Schumacher, '25) and one 
elected by the officers (for next year Howard C. Caldwell, '15). 
This committee met and organized on the evening of June 29 at 
the home of Miss Graydon. Plans were discussed and set on foot 
for next year. With Commencement fresh in mind, the activities 
suggested bore especially upon the subject of alumni representation 
at the various alumni occasions of the year — Home-coming in Oc- 
tober, Founders' Day in February, Alumni Day in June. 

The question of regional Alumni Clubs was discussed with ap- 
proval, and warmly encouraged. 

For any helpful suggestion from any interested alumnus the 
committee will be grateful. 


1881 — ;Mrs. Myron R. Williams, 345 N. Audubon, Indianapolis. 


1883 — Robert L. Dorsey, Tucker & Dorsey, Indianapolis. 

1884 — Mrs. Grace Julian Clarke, 115 S. Audubon Road, Indianapolis. 

1885 — Arthur V. Browoi, Union Trust Company, Indianapolis. 


1887 — Jane Graydon, 303 Downey Avenue, Indianapolis. 



1890— Mrs. Vida T. Cottman, 336 N. Ritter Ave., Indianapolis. 

1891 — Mrs. Mary Brouse Schmuck, 5808 E. Washington St., Indianapolis. 

1892— Mrs. John S. Wright, 3730 N. Pennsyvania St., Indianapolis. 

1893 — Dr. D. W. Layman, Medical Arts Building, Indianapolis. 

1894 — iMrs. Willis K. Miller, 312 Downey Avenue, Indianapolis. 

1895 — Mrs. Mansur Oakes, 2121 N. Alabama St., Indianapolis. 


1897— Mabel Tibbott, 336 N. Ritter Ave., Indianapolis. 


1899 — Emily Helming, 552 N. Central Court, Indianapolis. 

1900 — Esther Fay Shover, 2057 Broadway, Indianapolis. 

1901 — May Cunningham, 2327 N. Meridian St., Indianapolis. 



Directory of Class Secretaries 145 

1904 — Katherine Quinn, 722 Fairfield Ave., Indianapolis. 

1905— Mrs. Edith D. Hughes, 1728 Cross Drive, Woodruif PL, Indianapolis. 

1'906 — ilrs. Gem Craig Eeasoner, 920 Campbell St., Indianapolis. 

1907 — Miss Irma Brayton, 2125 Broadway, Indianapolis. 

1908 — Mrs. John Wallace, 246 Hampton Drive, Indianapolis. 

1909— Mrs. Elizabeth Bogert Schofield, 2625 E. Washington, Indianpolis. 

1910 — Herbert Hyman, 3445 Birchwood Ave., Indianapolis. 

1911 — Maud Russell, 60 N. Ritter Ave., Indianapolis. 

1912 — Corinne Welling, 5202 Washington Blvd., Indianapolis. 

1913— Mrs. Jessie Breadheft Chalifour, 2131 E. Tenth St., Indianapolis. 

1914 — Mrs. Ellen Graham George, 2802 Cornell Ave., Indianapolis. 

1915 — Howard C. Caldwell, 32 Bosart Ave., Indianapolis. 

1916 — Francis W. Payne, 5345 University Ave., Indianapolis. 

1917 — Mrs. Georgie E. Gill, 5841 Julian Ave., Indianapolis. 

1918 — Virginia Kingsbury, 317 Downey Ave., Indianapolis. 

1919 — Jean Brown, 5087 E. Washington St., Indianapolis. 

1920 — Gladys Banes, 1556 Brookside Ave., Indianapolis. 

1921 — Margaret Bruner, 324 S. Ritter Ave., Indianapolis. 

1922— Mrs. Dale Hodges, 5345 E. Washington St., Indianapolis. 

1923— Dale R. Hodges, 5345 E. Washington St., Indianapolis. 

1924 — Gwendolyn Dorey, 4602 N. Pennsylvania St., Indianapolis. 

1925 — Katharine M. Lennox, 2413 N". Delaware St., Indianapolis. 

1926 — Julia A. Brown, 5087 E. Washington St., Indianapolis. 


Earl T. Ludlow, '96, is now living in Longmont, Colorado. 

Miss Frieda P., Haseltine, '16, is spending the summer in Europe. 

Edward Ploenges, '15, was back for Commencement from Par- 
sons, Kansas. 

Miss Grace McGavran, '19 ; spent a few days in Irvington en 
route to Colorado for the summer. 

Arthur A. Johnson, '95, is located in Cuba in connection with 
The Cuba Railroad Company. 

Dr. Paul A. Draper, '21, recent resident physician in the Riley 
Hospital, has removed to Detroit. 

146 Butler Alumnal Quarterly 

Edward McGavran, '24, has received the Austin Teaching Fel- 
lowship in the Harvard Medical School. 

Mrs. W. L. Caldwell, formerly Miss Ida Snyder, ex- '97, of Dan- 
ville, Illinois, made a recent brief visit to the campus. 

Paul W. Ward, '14, stopped long enough in Indianapolis on June 
12 to say ''hello" and take a bite with his class mates. 

Earl T. Bonham, '17, is located in Indianapolis, associated with 
the Equitable Life Assurance Society of the United States. 

Mrs. Joseph Ostrander (Guinevere Ham, ex- '16) and little 
daughter, Nancy, are living in the Audubon Court, Irvington. 

Myron M. Hughel, '17, makes announcement of his office for in- 
vestment securities recently opened in 701 J. F. Wild building, 

Mrs. Pearl Wolf Whitlock, '14, has accepted a position in a 
school for girls among the mountain people of Kentucky, located 
at Olive Hill. 

Victor C. Twitty, '25, is spending the summer in the Biological 
Laboratory on Mount Desert, Maine, where he is making a survey 
of marine worms. 

Miss Maurine Watkins, '19, has written a play which will be pre- 
sented in the autumn at the opening of Professor George P. Baker 's 
theatre at Yale University. 

William L. Kiser, '24, is special agent of the International Life 
Insurance Company with offices at 805-6 Fletcher Savings and 
Trust Building, Indianapolis. 

Edward H. Clifford, '93, and Mrs. Clifford (Lora C. Hadley, 
'95) began on April 19 their work in the pastorate of the Chris- 
tian Church of Christopher, Illinois. 

Personal Mention 147 

Miss Agnes Tilson, '10, has spent the past year at Teachers' 
College and has also taken courses in the Nursery School Research 
at the Child Welfare Institute of New York City. 

Mrs. E. H. Fishback, wife of the principal of the Junior High 
School of Anderson, Indiana, has been a recent visitor to the 
campus. Mrs. Fishback was Miss Beulah Smith, ex- '11. 

Mr. and Mrs. Charles Sharpe, ex- '92, teacher in the religious 
department of the Young Men's Christian Association of Detroit 
recently visited Irvington as the guests of Mrs. Walter S. King, 

Dr. and Mrs. Kercheval (Elizabeth Stephenson, '15) have mo- 
tored to Connecticut to visit their brother, John Stephenson, ex- 
'14, and Mrs. Stephenson, who have a studio in the woods near 

On the evening of May 19 the faculty of the College entertained 
at the Propylaeum, Indianapolis, the faculties of the schools af- 
ffiliated with the University, Teachers' College, John Herron Art 
Institute and the Metropolitan School of Music. 

Miss Martha Oliver, A. B., Wheaton College, A. M., Columbia 
University, daughter of Dr. John H. Oliver, former student of the 
University and long-time friend, has been appointed instructor in 
English for next year in the absence of Miss Mary McBride, '14. 

Miss Eleanor A. Hester, secretary of President Aley, is again 
seen in her office, after a year's study in the University of Min- 
nesota. Miss Hester took vocational psychology, business psychol- 
ogy, public speaking, and, in addition, gave special attention to 
personal work in that institution. 

Thomas Carr Howe, Jr. graduated in June from Harvard, be- 
ing one of the three in his department taking degrees magna cum 
laude, and being one of fifty seniors elected from the number of 
those graduating magna cum laude to membership in the Phi Beta 
Kappa Society. He and his sister. Miss pharlotte B. Howe, have 
sailed for a summer in Europe. ^^^CvV '' <^^ 

148 Butler Alumnal Quarterly 

Announcement is made of the reorganization of the office of Lee 
Bums, ex- '93, whereby, after June 1, Edward James, ex- '22, will 
be associated with him in the practice of architecture. After leav- 
ing Butler College to enlist in the great war, Mr. James graduated 
from the College of Architecture of Cornell University and is a 
junior member of the American Institute of Architecture. 

Claris Adams, ex- '10, has been appointed Secretary and Coun- 
sellor-at-law for the American Life Convention, an organization of 
life insurance companies located at St. Louis. This necessitates 
the removal for residence of Mr. Adams and his family, a loss to 
Invington and Indianapolis. However, The Quarterly sends it very 
cordial congratulations to Mr. and Mrs. Adams and wishes for 
them all good things in their new home. 

It was pleasant to see on the campus on Alumni Day Robert 
Mathews and his children, Robert III and Nancy. Professor 
Mathews will next year be in charge of the department of mathe- 
matics in the University of West Virginia. Of his brothers, Mur- 
ray, '13, is located at the Del Monte hotel, California ; William in 
Tucson, Arizona; Philip practicing law in San Francisco. Mrs. 
Mathews is making her home with her son Philip. 

Phil C. Brown, '23, formerly football star and captain of the 
Butler eleven in 1922 and son of Mr. and Mrs. D. C. Brown, has 
been appointed football coach and instructor in physical training 
in Washington College, Chestertown, Maryland. This institution 
is one of the oldest schools of higher education in the east, having 
been established by George Washington and his associates in 1782. 
Washington's first subscription was fifty guineas and he was a 
member of the first board of directors. 

Of the faculty Dr. and Mrs. W. L. Richardson are summering in 
England and France ; Dr. and Mrs. Thor G. Wesenberg in Spain, 
France, Norway; Dr. Baumgartner in Germany; Dr. Jensen in 
Mexico ; Mr. and Mrs. Dabuey, in Prance. Studying in American 
Universities are: Miss WiUiite, Columbia University; Mr. Slifer, 
Mr. Graham, Miss McBride, University of Chicago; Miss Banes, 

Personal Mention 149 

Radcliffe College ; Mr. Bridenstine, University of Iowa ; Miss Dur- 
bin, Ohio State University. Professor Birdsong is teaching in the 
University of Wisconsin. 

It was very pleasant to greet on the campus so many old alumni, 
among whom were B. F. Kinnick, '71; H. U. Brown, '80; M. 0. 
Naramore, '83; Clarence L. Goodwin, '83; Mrs. May Dailey Mor- 
gan, '84; Mrs. A. M. Chamberlain, '84; William C. Smith, '84; 
Mrs. Grace Julian Clarke, '84; Mrs. Corinne Thrasher Carvin, 
'86; Alex. Jameson, '86; B. F. Dailey, '87; Jane Gray- 
don, '87; E. S. Conner, '87; Arthur Shoemaker, '87; R. 
F. Kautz, '87; A. M. Hall, '88; W. G. Irwin, '89; Mrs. 
Clara Shank Levy, '89; the class of '90; Robert Hall, '91; Mrs. 
Eva J. King, '91 ; Raymond D. Meeker, '91 ; Miss Grace Meeker, 
ex- '91; T. A. Hall, '92; Mrs. Lettie N. Wright, '92; Samuel Shank, 
'92 ; Bertha Thormyer, '92, and many others. 

Mrs. Anne Butler Thomas has sent the fine Celtic library of 
her husband, David Owen Thomas, to the National Library of 
Wales. This library is under the patronage of the Prince of Wales 
and contains some of the rarest works and manuscripts in exist- 
ence. The building itself is a beautiful marble structure and 
stands in a lovely vale near Aberystwith. 

Dr. Thomas's favorite research was in the history and signi- 
ficance of the Holy Sacrament and he had a remarkable collection 
of authorative works on that subject. His library contained every 
known work published in that field, together with a really great 
reference library on Textual Criticism containing all the latest 
works on the original text of the Sacred Scriptures. To scholars 
these are extremely valuable works and Mrs. Thomas is having 
them arranged in one library of two divisions with the expectation 
of presenting them to the College of Religion of Butler University. 

Mrs. Thomas has also previously given funds to the University 
for a Memorial Reading Room in memory of her brother. Mack 
Butler, and is planning to place some valuable paintings in this 
room when the new Butler is achieved. 

150 Butler Alumnal Quarterly 


Stuhldreher-Brosnan — On April 28 were married in Indian- 
apolis Mr. Walter Joseph Stuhldreher and Miss Mildred Genevieve 
Brosnan, '25. Mr. and Mrs. Stuhldreher are at home in Indian- 

Pohl-Pollitt — On May 14 were married in New York City Mr. 
Frederick Julius Pohl and Miss Josephine Mellwain PoUitt, '17. 
Mr. and Mrs. Pohl are at home in Brooklyn, New York. 

Godfrey-Strickland — On May 15 were married in Indianapolis 
Mr. Culver Godfrey, '25, and Miss Louise Strickland. Mr. and 
Mrs. Godfrey are at home in Indianapolis. 

Gray-Snyder — On May 26 were married in Indianapolis Mr. 
Glenn Gray, '25, and Miss Dolores Snyder. Mr. and Mrs. Gray 
are at home in Hollywood, Florida. 

Stout-Day — On June 16 were married in Indianapolis Mr. 
Richard H. Stout and Miss Dorothy Day, ex- '25. Mr. and Mrs. 
Stout are at home in Indianapolis. 

Morgan-Foxworthy — On June 16 were married in Indiaanpolis 
Mr. James Green Morgan, son of Mrs. Dorinda Green Morgan, '95, 
and Miss Mildred Foxworthy, '25. Mr. and Mrs. Morgan are at 
home at Frankfort, Kentucky. 

Trabue-Jaehne — On June 19 were married in Indianapolis Mr. 
Samuel Logan Trabue and Miss Helen Coulter Jaehne, '19. Mr. 
and Mrs. Trabue are at home in Rushville, Indiana. 

Mackey-Daugherty — On June 22 were married in Indianapolis 
Mr. Maurice C. Mackey and Miss Rebecca Daugherty, '25. Mr. 
and Mrs. Daugherty are at home in Indianapolis. 

Van Houten-Findley — On June 25 were married in Indian- 
apolis Mr. Walter C. Van Houten and Miss Katherine Findley, 
ex- '16. Mr. and Mrs. Van Houten are at home in Lenox, Iowa. 

Marriages 151 

Badger-Showalter — On June 26 were married in Danville, In- 
diana, Mr. Stephen Mills Badger, ex- '26, and Miss Mary Agnes 
Showalter, instructor in French. Mr. and Mrs. Badger are at 
home in Bradentown, Florida. 

Keach-Kessler — On June 30 were married in Seymour, In- 
diana, Mr. Glen Keach, '23, and Miss Lucile Kessler. 

Bryant-Fitzgerald — On July 3 were married in Indianapolis 
Mr. George Bryant and Miss Edith Mae Fitzgerald, '24. Mr. and 
Mrs. Bryant are at home in Chicago, Illinois. 

Ropkey-Chiles — On July 10 were married in Indianapolis Mr. 
Frederick Noble Ropkey and Miss Dorotha Marjorie Chiles, '26. 
Mr. and Mrs. Ropkey are at home in Indianapolis. 


Beeler — To Professor and Mrs. A. D. Beeler, on June 19, in 
Indianapolis, a son — James Albert. 

Ham— To Mr. Scott Ham, '25, and Mrs. Ham, '24, in Florida— 
a daughter. 

Kingsbury — To Mr. George H. Kingsbury, ex- '20, and Mrs. 
Kingsbury, on July 10 in Indianapolis, a son — Edward David. 

Negley — To Mr. and Mrs. Arthur Negley (Alma Hoover, '08) 
in Indianapolis on March 17, a daughter — Helen Louise. 

ScHMALZRiED — To Mr. and Mrs. Schmalzried (Muriel Bruner, 
'15) on May 31 at Lagro, Indiana, a daughter — Margaret Ann. 

Schumacher — To Mr. and Mrs. William Schumacher (Virginia 
Barney, '22) on April 7 in Indianapolis, a daughter — Joan. 

Wheeler — To Mr. and Mrs. Charles Edward Wheeler (Ruth 
Brayton, ex- '18) on May 30 in Swissvale, Pennsylvania, a daugh- 
ter — Mary Irma. 

152 Butler Alumnal Quarterly 


DuTTENHAVER — The QUARTERLY sends its Sympathy to Mr. Harry 
Duttenhaver, ex- '24, and Mrs. Duttenhaver in the loss by drowning 
of their son, Harry, Jr., at the age of two years at Bunnell, Florida. 

Felt — The Quarterly extends its sincere sympathy to Mrs. 
Mable Felt Browder, '15, Mrs. Elsie Felt Caldwell, '17, and Truman 
Felt, ex- '23, on occasion of the death of their father. The passing on 
June 5 of Judge Edward W. Felt was a loss not only to his fam- 
ily, but also to the community in which he lived, to the Methodist 
Episcopal Church of Irvington, to the Bar Association of Indiana. 
He was the friend of all good things, and his withdrawal from the 
world deeply in need of such valiant men is bereavement and im- 

GiLLMAN — John, son of Mr. and Mrs. Waide Gillman (Helen 
Findley, '18) died at his home in Irvington on April 12 at the age 
of three years, and was buried in Crown Hill cemetery on the 14th. 

TiBBOTT — Inez Watts, wife of E. F. Tibbott (both former stu- 
dents of the College), died in New Orleans on May 11 and was 
laid in the cemetery of the Irvington she loved on the 13th. 

When the word came that Inez Watts Tibbott had crossed the 
Great Divide, her many friends were conscious of a yawning gap 
in life. 

Language does not come easily in face of such a loss. Her name 
conjures visions of her loyalty, her strength of love that defied 
criticism or fault, that reached out in the dark and across spaces 
with understanding and sympathy. There comes the memory of 
her fine, well-trained mind filled with rich store of the literature 
of every age. She lived so close to Shakespeare, Dickens, Jane 
Austen, De Morgan, Marshall, Bennett, that she reflected them in 
the very atmosphere which radiated from her mind. 

There was nothing mediocre in her walk through life. She 
loathed the common-place. She loved greatness in people, in books, 
in pictures, in song. She gloried in the beauty of bird and flower 
and all of God's great out-of-doors. She knew and felt deeply the 



responsibility of fine birth, yet through her mood of high serious- 
ness was shot a keen sense of humor and the bubbling fun of life. 
She was tender, she was large, she was human — a staff to lean upon 
and a light to the path. 

J. G. J. 


Losing a friend is a fearful price to pay for 
having known him. Yet it is not too great a 
price for the glory of the friendship he brought 
us, the inspiration he was, and the pride we 
have in him. 

He is not gone. For just a little while he 
has passed beyond our ken. In memory and 
in truth he is deathless and eternal. 

We have not known before such courage as 
was his. We do not ask that we shall ever know 
a finer spirit. 

We saw him grow. We saw him, buoyant, 
unafraid, triumphant, rise over obstacles and 
accomplish more in a few short years than four 
score might have brought him were he less un- 
quenchable of courage. 

None need ever have asked what his ideals 
were. He lived them. The greatest of them 
was devotion to family and friends, of a depth 
that passes understanding. 

Beautiful in life, dauntless in death, as he 
loved us, we love him. 

A Friend. 

154 Butler Alumnal Quarterly 


Listen, you blessed and fortunate seniors, Butler has filled a 
I'ather large place in your lives during the last four years, hasn't 
it! You know it has. And now that everything is almost over — 
all except taking an examination or two and reaching out after 
your diploma — it is high time you were thinking of what your 
relationship to your college will be after graduation. 

Of course, you will be an alumnus. You can't help that. Grad- 
uation makes you that, but graduation does not and can not make 
you the kind of an alumnus that you should wish to be. That is 
an individual matter of heart and soul. As the years roll by you 
will develop either into an alumnus that will be one of the College 's 
rich treasures or into one that will be a nonentity, a dead letter 
on the alumnal roll. The situation rests with you. 

A number of the seniors have already made their decision. That 
is, they have subscribed to the Alumnal Quarterly, which is the 
first step toward becoming a true-blue alumnus. Two dollars is 
sometimes a considerable sum of money around Commencement 
time, but these seniors know that the campus associations which 
they have been building up through the years have a value that 
can not be computed in coin of the realm. When they leave this 
place to scatter across the land, they can not take their college 
with them. They can not take their college friends. But the 
Alumnal Quarterly will in a fashion bring what they can not 
take. It will reach out across the miles and across the years, and 
like a silken cord, will bind heart with heart and old with new in 
the name of "auld lang syne." — The Butler Collegian. 



Oaober, 1926 


Entered as second-class matter March 26, 1912, at the post 
office at Indianapolis, Ind., under the act of March 3, 1879. 


Demarchus C. Brown 

H. S. ScHELL, B. F. Dailey, Louis Rowland 

New Ideals in Industry and Education 

Dean Ralph E. Heilman 

Music and Poetry : Their Relation to the Medical Life 

Dr A. W. Brayton 

College News 

From the City Office 
Around the Campus 
College of Religion 
Alumnae Clubs 
Distribution of Butler Alumni 
Information Wanted 
Personal Mention 


Vol XV OCTOBER, 1926 No. 3 


Published by the Alumni Association of Butler College, Indianapolis. 

Subscription price, two dollars per year. 

Entered as second-class matter, March 26, 1912, at the post office at Indi- 
anapolis, Indiana, under the Act of March 3, 1879. 

Officers of the Alumni Association — President, John F. Mitchell, Jr., '06; 
First Vice-President, Shelley D. "Watts, '00; Second Vice-President, Mrs. 
Mary Louise Ragsdale, '17; Treasurer and Business Manager, George A. 
Schumacher, '25; appointees, Howard C. Caldwell, '15 and George A. 
Schumacher, '26. 

Secretary and Editor of the Butler Alumnal Quarterly — Katharine M. 
Graydon, '78. 



We have met to do honor to the memory of a man full-orbed and 
without guile; a teacher of rare power, ever enamoured of the 
beautiful, the true and the good ; a citizen interested in everything 
human, but especially devoted to the amelioration of the condition 
of the unfortunate. 

I entered Butler College in the 'eighties, some time after the 
beginning of the fall term. Arranging my program of studies I came 
last to the Greek room. There, seated on a platform, class-book and 
pencil in hand, sat the professor of Greek. One glance and I knew 
I had met the college professor of my boyish dreams. The stalwart 
frame, Olympian head, lofty brow, firm jaw, ruddy countenance, 
kindly voice bound me with ' ' hoops of steel. ' ' For five years I was 
his devoted pupil. 

A few characteristics of this wonderful teacher come to me 
through the mists of time. His dignity, often verging on austerity, 
but always bounded by courtesy, impressed every student. There 
were no pranks played in his classroom; no unseemly hilarity; no 
frivolous chatter. His remarkable patience was always in evidence. 


158 Butler Alumnal Quarterly 

The stupidity of some of us was enough to wreck the patience of a 
saint, but Brown was always imperturbable and undismayed. His 
marvelous restraint has always been my envy and alas ! my despair. 
He never scolded, never nagged, never gave vent to sarcasm, yet 
somehow got things done. His boundless enthusiasm for the clas- 
sics made the most difficult subject of the curriculum attractive 
and popular. He would beam gloriously over a choral passage of 
Aeschylus and chuckle merrily over a witty thrust of Aristoph- 
anes — ours not to reason why, but we likewise beaincd and 
chuckled. He possessed the unusual gift of inspiring in his 
students the will to work. Other lessons they might shirk, but no 
student of Brown ever ventured to come to recitation without at 
least an attempt at preparation. 

Nor did his interest in education lag after leaving Butler. His 
universal greeting to friends was, ' ' what do you know ? ' ' — not that 
he expected to hear some wonderful bit of knowledge gleaned or 
knotty problem solved, but he simply couldn't forget that he was 
a pedagog and wanted to know that his friends were alive and 
growing in knowledge. 

Last spring I was wrestling with the Logos of the first Chapter 
of John 's Gospel — ' ' In the beginning was the Word and the Word 
was with God, and the Word was God." Again late in the evening, 
I went to my old teacher. For a half hour we discussed the Greek 
involved, with the old time fervor. And so it always was. When 
one wanted to know something of the beautiful, the true and the 
good — the God-like — he went to Brown, and never came away 
empty handed: for Brown, like the Great Teacher, "Having loved 
His own, He loved them to the end. ' ' 

His life has been taken from us ; his body will soon be consigned 
to Mother Earth ; but his spirit is our everlasting possession, 

H. S. SCHELL, '90. 

In days gone by the classical course was a challenge to students 
of the first order. Its major study was the Greek language. Four 
years of Greek — the most highly inflected language ever spoken ; 
four years of thumbing Hadley's Greek grammer and Liddell and 
Scott's lexicon; four years of Greek, under the most exacting 
professor ever in Butler College, who marked his class book in red 

Demarchus C. Brown 159 

ink, and on a scale of ten, shaded the grades to fractions of one- 

Only students of high ambition elected this course. To their 
great delight they found the professor of Greek not only exacting 
but also much given to kindness and patience. He got from his 
students the greatest amount of work with the least amount of 
friction. He was enthusiastic, stimulating, inspiring. This ideal 
college professor was Demarchus C. Brown. 

He was the embodiment of the threefold manhood-physical, 
intellectual and spiritual. He had the body of an athlete ; it Avas 
good to see him crossing the campus with long strides and uplifted 
face. His mind was at home in many fields of knowledge. Among 
the ten most scholarly men in Indiana there was a place for De- 
marchus C. Brown. His religion was of the Spirit and left its 
benediction on all who came in touch with him. 

It was a joy to be present when he conducted chapel exercises. 
His scripture readings were selected with great care. They were 
often dramatic passages from the Old Testament and were read 
with fine effect. The prayer that followed had the simplicity of 
childhood for he prayed as one who talked with God. 

Professor Brown was ever in touch with the times. He carried 
his years gracefully. In dress, in manner, in alertness, he retained 
the spirit of youth. He was by instinct a teacher; with him a 
common form of salutation was "What do you know?" A student 
of the Bible, he gathered around him a class loyal to his leadership. 
He was a lover of books; to him a library was a sacred place. 
Versed in the literature of many languages, he was par excellence 
a man of letters. The soul of refinement, he gave freely of himself 
for the uplift of the deficient and delinquent. His interests were 
far-reaching ; he served the School, the State, the Church with 
unselfish devotion. His was a culture charming and changeless; 
he was always the Christian gentleman. 

He was a captain in the fight for truth and for the freedom of 
mind and spirit and his buoyant, heroic soul goes marching on in 
the hearts of aU his students who recall, with happy memories, the 
days spent at the feet of Professor Brown. 

B. F. DAILEY, '87. 

160 Butler Alumnal Quarterly 

Those who knew Demarchus C. Brown will, it is believed, agree 
that he was first of all a gentleman, in the fine sense of the word. 
Broad-minded, tolerant, charitable, courteous and kindly — such 
adjectives as these are suggested by the very mention of his name. 
Loving and cherishing knowledge, he yet recognized the limits 
beyond which it was impossible for him or any one else to go in 
acquiring it. So he was always a questioner rather than an asserter, 
and was accustomed to say "I wonder" rather than "I know." 
There was in this no pose, but rather the manifestation of the spirit 
of the true scholar — and a scholar this man was. 

It is a favorite theory with some that the classically-minded 
man, the man who loves the classics, is rather resentful of human 
contacts, and is indeed shut off from his kind. There could be no 
more striking refutation of this theory than the man who has just 
died. He was probably the most widely read scholar in this com- 
munity, and yet his life was largely devoted to social service, a 
field in which he was most efficient. Twenty-five years a member 
of the board of state charities, president of the Indiana Conference 
of Charities, and member of the board of Children 's Guardians — in 
all these capacities he showed an aptitude for public service that 
was remarkable. 

The truth, of course, is that the classics are feeders of the social 
instinct, and kindlers of interest, not only in humanity, but in 
individual men and women. It was a Roman writer who said that 
because he was ''a man, nothing that concerns a man do I deem a 
matter of indifference to me." That was exactly the feeling of 
Mr. Brown, the scholar, the lover of poetry, the adorer — one may 
almost say — of the Greek spirit and the Greek ideals of beauty and 
wisdom. His life was largely ruled by the admonition of one of 
the wisest of the Greeks : ' ' Nothing in excess. ' ' 

Of this man's public services little need be said, for they speak 
for themselves. The state library, over which he presided for 
twenty years with distinction, owes much to him. It is due to his 
intelligent interest and his energy that the library is far richer 
than it ever was before in historical data, particularly those con- 
nected with Indiana history. Many original documents are now 
the most cherished possessions of the library, which, but for the 
zeal of Mr. Brown, might have been lost. His social service, as 

Demarchus C. Brown 161 

related to charities, prisons and correctional institutions was of the 
highest importance and value. 

Mr. Brown was a student to the end of his life, and a lover of 
literature. Of late he had been much interested in New Testament 
Greek, agreeing with other scholars-^and indeed there is no room 
for difference of opinion — that it was not classic, but rather the 
Greek of the street and the market place. So his sympathy was 
wholly with those who would translate the New Testament in the 
light of that truth. The whole subject was interestingly and 
exhaustively discussed by Mr. Brown in a paper dealing with the 
writings of St. Paul before the Indianapolis Literary Club, of 
which he was a valued member, contributing much to its 

A well-rounded man he was, loving sports (and in his youth 
participating in them) as well as books — perhaps in this, as much 
as in anything else, he was a Greek. He was a man of the purest 
and finest character, transparently honest, loyal to duty, coveting 
only light and truth. It has been said that the highest praise ever 
carved on a gravestone was this tribute to a woman : ' ' She was so 
pleasant." This may with entire truth be said of Demarchus 

Editor of The Indianapolis News. 


By Ralph Emerson Heilman, Ph. D. 

Professor of Economics and Dean, School of Commerce 
Northwestern University 

The most important transformation Avhich in recent years has 
come about in the spirit and ideals of industry is the increasing 
emphasis which is coming to be placed upon achievement and ac- 
complishment in the realm of business, as distinguished from mere 
acquisition. The emphasis in business or industry is coming more 
and more to be placed upon the winning of economic independence 
and financial competency through creative achievement and con- 
structive accomplishment of results which are of themselves 
important and worth while. The opening up of new territory, the 
development of latent resources, the introduction of time and labor- 
saving devices, the bringing forth of improved methods of 
manufacture and production, the planning and instituting of more 
economical methods of finance, the initiation of more effective 
and less wasteful methods of marketing and merchandising, the 
elimination of waste, the reduction of cost, the stoppage of leaks, 
the more effective utilization of by-products, the more effective 
mobilization of our plant and human resources, these are the objec- 
tives which are coming increasingly to captivate the imagination 
and appeal to the enthusiasm of men avIio are engaged in business 
and industry. It is true the accomplishment of these purposes 
leads to private gain. But more and more, the emphasis is coming 
to be placed upon the winning of economic gain and financial 
competence through the accomplishment of purposes and results 
of this character. Such purposes, when accomplished, go far to 
promote social progress and human welfare. 

In one of the popular plays last year in New York there was an 
interesting scene in w^hich a student comes to an elderly scholar, a 
man of letters, who has devoted liis entire life to literature, and 
asks him "Who is today America's greatest living poet?" This 
venerable man of letters, instead of mentioning the name of any 


New Ideals in Industry and Education 163 

well-knoAvn poet, replies, "Charles M. Schwab." The young man 
says, "What do you mean by referring to him as a poet?" The 
old man makes this reply : ' ' Because he dreams great dreams and 
makes his dreams come true." 

Now I care not what your individual opinion may happen to 
be of Mr. Schwab — I mention this incident simply because it is 
indicative of the new spirit of the times. If you will run over in 
your mind the names of those individuals who are accounted out- 
standing leaders in America's commerce and industry, not simply 
those who have succeeded in amassing a fortune, but those who 
command large public respect, confidence and esteem — you will 
find that in every case you are mentioning the name of an indi- 
vidual M'ho has achieved his present position in industry through 
making some significant and notable contribution to business 
methods of his time, which has resulted in a larger and better life 
for his fellowmen. , 

So I say that the new ideal in business, first and foremost, is 
the increasing emphasis which is coming to be placed upon the 
productive life, the achieving, constructive, accomplishing life, as 
distinguishd from the merely acquisitive or the possessive life. 
Business and industry are coming to recognize the truth enunciated 
by the Great Teacher Himself who taught that a man's life con- 
sists not in the abundance of material things which he possesses, 
but in the higher values which are to be found in service. And 
business and industry as it is organized today, presents unusual 
opportunity for service to the one who seeks it. 

The second important change which has come about in the 
spirit and ideals of business is this: An increasing emphasis is 
coming to be placed upon cooperation in business. Concerted, 
joint, united action by men of business associated together is be- 
coming more important as distinguished from purely individual 
action on the part of any one business. Business men are coming 
to realize that while they may have certain interests which conflict, 
they nevertheless have certain interests in common, and within the 
limits of those common interests cooperative or common action may 
be better than individual or competitive action. Until recently 
the management of any successful business enterprise was accus- 
tomed to conduct its oaati business regardless of what was being 

164 Butler Alumnal Quarterly 

done by other businesses in the same or allied lives. But today the 
manager of any successful business enterprise recognizes that an 
obligation rests upon him to cooperate with the other business 
organizations in the community. If he fails to do so, not only may 
he miss his opportunity to make a notable contribution to the 
community welfare, but some day he may awaken to find himself 
lagging behind in the race for survival. 

This new ideal expresses itself in various ways — through the 
associations and chambers of commerce— local, state, national and 
international trade. organizations and many similar bodies, all of 
which exist for the purpose of promoting interests which are 
larger and broader than the interests of any single firm or any 
single member, but which are common to the welfare of the indus- 
try or the community as a whole. More and more business is 
coming to realize that "we are all members of one body." 

It is interesting to note that while these newer ideals have come 
to dominate in business and in industry, similar changes are also 
coming to dominate our thought in the realm of education. 

First, with regard to this newer ideal of achievement. The old 
ideal of a college, like the old concept of business, was to a consid- 
erable extent individualistic and acquisitive. The college was a 
place where young men went to acquire for themselves a sort of 
personal culture, an institution intended primarily for those who 
expected to enter a profession, and for the children of the well-to- 
do. But today we are coming to see that it is the function of the 
college and university not onlj^ to enable its students to acquire 
personal culture, but also to train and qualify them for achieve- 
ment, creative accomplishment, and definite leadership in every 
single important field of human activity and human endeavor. As 
a result the old curriculum has been greatly broadened, enriched 
and extended. Side by side with the older departments which still 
retain their important place, as they should, there have been estab- 
lished many new departments of instruction. For example, courses 
have been established in architecture, in engineering, civil, elec- 
trical and mechanical, in forestry, in social work, in commerce, 
finance and industry, and courses for teachers, courses in house- 
hold science, in agriculture, etc. We are coming to recognize that 
education is not the function of any single college, but that it is the 

New Ideals in Industry and Education 165 

function of our system of education as a whole to train young men 
and women for leadership, accomplishment, and service in every 
important field of human activity and endeavor which requires a 
highly trained intelligence, or which can be reduced to a teachable 
basis, or which is of importance to mankind. This refers not only 
to those fields which require a high degree of appreciation for the 
cultural values in life, but also to those which require a high degree 
of technical and professional training. 

True, we recognize the enormity of this problem and the fact 
that no single institution can cover this entire field. The demand 
for various types of education would be entirely beyond the 
resources of any single institution now existing or which can pos- 
sibly be conceived. The wisest thing which any single institution 
can do is to select that portion of this field which, by virtue of its 
location, resources and clientele, it is best qualified to serve. Those 
who are familiar with the record of achievement of Butler College 
agree that that portion of the field which Butler College has 
elected to serve, it has for many years served honorably, nobly 
and well. 

The second ideal above referred to, that of cooperative action, 
is likewise making itself felt in education. A generation ago the 
college, very much like the business house, was largely self- 
centered. It was concerned with itself and its own activities. A 
college was thought of as an institution apart from the world, a 
place where people went to live a life of thought and contempla- 
tion, but an institution having little concern or interest in the 
everyday workaday world. Today we are coming to see that a col- 
lege is not a place set apart from the world, that it is a part of the 
world, and that a very large amount of its thought and interest 
may properly be devoted to those matters which are of vital 
concern to this everyday, workaday world of ours. Therefore, 
today, among all of our colleges and higher institutions of learning, 
both in their institutional capacity and through the activities of 
the individual faculty members, there is the heartiest cooperation 
with the various public service agencies of the community. Our 
colleges and their faculty members today cooperate actively with 
the various government agencies, with the various professional, 
trade and industrial organizations of the community, with the 

166 Butler Alumnal, Quarterly 

chamber of commerce, the press, the women's clubs, the parent- 
teacher's associations, the churches, etc. In fact, the colleges are 
coming to realize that they are primarily" public service institu- 
tions, with an obligation resting upon them to cooperate effectively 
with every other public service agency in the community in order 
that all of them make the largest and best contribution to the 
public welfare. Today no young man or young woman can attend 
one of our colleges or universities for a period of four years, and 
catch the spirit that dominates the institutions, Avithout having 
become very much better qualified to take his or her place in the 
community to cooperate, to work with others and to "pull in har- 
ness" with others for the purpose of promoting the interests of 
their trade, industry, profession and community. 

Another thing which is to be marked is this : We are coming 
to recognize the fact that the interests of industry and the inter- 
ests of education are mutual and interdependent. We are recog- 
nizing that business and industrj^ must rely upon our higher 
institutions of education to perform certain important tasks; and 
that higher education must lean upon the men of business and 
affairs to perform certain other important functions. For example, 
business and industry must rely upon education to conduct the 
scientific investigation and researches Mdthout which modern 
industry could not be conducted and to train those who are to 
conduct such work. I call your attention to the results achieved in 
colleges and universities in the field of chemistry, physics, econom- 
ics and natural science. The results in these scientific investiga- 
tions and research are not confined to the ten per cent, or less of 
our population which attends our colleges and universities, but 
they ramify through the entire rank and file of our population, 
going far to promote the comforts, conveniences and safety of 
human life. 

- Business and industry must rely upon our colleges and liigher 
institutions of learning to provide, either directly or indirectly, 
practically all of the formal instruction which is offered not only 
to the small percentage of the population which attend our col- 
leges, but to that vast majority who leave school at an early age to 
assume their place as wage earners in industry. For these children 
are taught by teachers who in their turn have received their train- 

New Ideals in Industry and Education 167 

ing in our colleges, universities and normal schools. The whole 
character of the child's outlook on life, and the type of employee, 
business man or citizen he will make, depends in large part upon 
the way in which the job of training teachers is performed in our 
colleges and universities. 

Industry must rely on education to promote clarity and sanity 
of thought, in these days when all of our economic, political and 
industrial institutions are being subjected to scrutiny, analysis 
and attack. 

Industry "has a stake" in our system of higher education, and 
in its proper support. 

On the other hand, education must rely upon industry, upon 
men of business and affairs, for the performance of certain other 
liighly important functions. It must rely upon them to provide 
personal interests, counsel and advice in the conduct of our educa- 
tional institutions. Our educational institutions must depend upon 
men of business and affairs for the financial assistance and sup- 
port which makes possible their existence. In that connection, I 
want to call your attention to a few extremely interesting facts. 
In a recent year (the last year for which the Government figures 
are available) the total expenditure in this country for cosmetics, 
perfumes and cigarettes amounted to more than $750,000,000, 
This amount was fifty per cent, in excess of the total then-existing 
endowment of all the colleges and universities of the country. In 
the same year our expenditure for chewing gum alone was a little 
over $00,000,000, which was 100 per cent, in excess of the total 
average annual contributions to all of our educational institutions 
for the preceding ten years. The expenditure in that year for ice 
cream was $600,000,000; cigarettes, $800,000,000; tobacco, 
$850,000 000; jewelry, $625,000,000. In other words for all of 
these purposes more was expended in a year than the total accu- 
mulated endowment of all of our colleges and universities. 
Certainly a nation sufficiently wealthy and prosperous to afford 
such expenditures for purposes of this kind, is sufficiently 
wealthy and generous to see to it that its system of higher educa- 
tion is properly assisted, maintained and supported. 

One of the most hopeful indications today is the fact that 
successful business men are rallying to the support of our 

168 Butler Alumnal Quarterly 

educational institutions. A new philosophy is coming to prevail 
among them. It is this : That the man who has been successful in 
business has a special and peculiar obligation to perform some 
particular form of public service with at least a portion of the 
means with which Fortune has favored him, and that the wise 
business man is the one who does this during his lifetime when he 
can see his. own money at work. Successful men of business, if 
they are public spirited, have two kinds of investments — first, 
their private investments; and second, their investments in public 
service. The business men who make investments of a portion of 
their means in some agency for public service, are rightly insisting 
that these investments shall meet the same high standards which 
they impose with regard to their private investments. 

Business and industrial leaders are coming to realize that 
colleges and universities present an unparalleled opportunity for 
investment in public service. The well managed college presents 
every characteristic of a sound investment in public service. 

I congratulate you, and I congratulate Butler College, upon the 
splendid response which has already been accorded to your mag- 
nificent plans for the future, and more particularly upon the 
splendid gifts which have been announced. But while Butler 
College is entitled to congratulation, those who are really most 
entitled to congratulation are the citizens here in your own 
community, because this institution presents to them an opportu- 
nity to make an investment in public service. Without such 
opportunities, life would indeed be barren for those blessed with 
personal means. 

H. G. Wells has referred to the race between education and 
catastrophe which is always in progress. How strikingly true is 
that statement. Today, as always in the history of the human 
race, education is the most vital and the most important single 
factor in the promotion of human welfare and social progress. But 
if our system of education lags behind, if it fails to keep pace with 
the new times or respond to new needs and new conditions catas- 
trophe for civilization inevitably follows. Happily in this country 
our system of education has not lagged behind; it has not been 
weighed in the balance and found wanting. 

New Ideals in Industry and Education 169 

I have been particularly impressed in looking over the plans of 
Butler University to find that, in the future development and 
expansion contemplated, Butler will not lag behind, I am con- 
vinced that it will keep abreast of the new requirements, that it 
will serve as well this new day, as it has in years gone by. 

By Dr. A. W. Brayton, 79 

The great interest manifested by the physicians of Indianapolis 
in the musical events of the past few years shows that medicine is 
not regarded as entirely prosaic by the local profession, even if the 
practice of it is not at all times heroic or even idyllic. 

For medicine as a biological science includes psychology and 
stands in very close relation to poetry and music, the highest forms 
of human expression. All avenues of approach and sympathy 
should be open to the physician. We agree that he should be 
trained in the elements of the profession, should have four year 
courses in the great medical schools of city and state universities, 
with abundant clinical courses, as is the cry of our profession in 
Indiana today. 

And we agree, too, that it is better for his whole future and 
that of his patients that the physician should have so broad and 
liberal an education that he will have the best outcome of culture, 
and that is, in the long run of years, independence and placidity. 
For only by culture can the physician achieve intellectual power 
and independence and full justness of perception. Only by cul- 
ture, by being in company with the best men and the best books in 
youth and throughout life, can he achieve alliance with those choice 
spirits who have conceived an infinite hope for mankind ; only by 
culture can he enlarge the horizon of feeling and emotion. 

But a well-trained intellect and a sound, healthy body and a 
due and just temperance are not yet enough for the qualification 
of the physician. Nor can he achieve power and intelligence and 
justness of perception by following a single line of research in 

For even so eminent a scientist and specialist as Darwin did not 
bring full circle in the sphere of life. He spent ten years on the 
study of barnacles — a notable lesson in patience and persistence — 
and he finally rose to the highest concept in biology, that of organic 
evolution. And yet he had not culture in the sense that an edu- 


Music and Poetry 171 

cated man has it — the man of Arnold, who knows the best that has 
been said and thought in the world. Late in life he confessed to a 
friend that he no longer experienced the need of two things, for 
which most men have a dire necessity; and these two things were, 
strange as it may seem, religion and poetry. And yet Darwin was 
one of the most religious of men, for his love of nature and his 
reasoning upon it had come to be to him a religion and secured to 
him the ends of right conduct, of solace, of independence, of 
serenity and beauty. 

There are thousands of men — a constantly increasing host — 
who by their intensity of study and research, notable in nature 
subjects, as natural history, astronomy, geologj^ — there are many in 
our profession — who are going on with their work in patience and 
reverence and yet are enabled to lay aside the shackles of habit, of 
ancient dreams and traditions. The law of the world ceases for 
them to be a narrow fanaticism ; error is no longer the condition of 
human morality. But religion is to the physician of this type 
none the less a reality. 

The mind of man has ever stood in perplexity between the 
demands of intellect and sanctity, now tiring of the saints and 
again of the philosophers, and no reconciler has as yet appeared 
answering once and for all the problems of being, whence, why and 
whither. Literature does not solve this problem ; Shakespeare only 
presents it. Philosophy accounts as well as it can for the consti- 
tution of the world, of the mind of man, but still the old question 
of being comes to each anew and must be solved by his own life 
and thought, by no book or tradition. The physician, seeing life in 
all its aspects and motives, is brought early and often against the 
boundary of science and philosophy, and to a higher and more 
compelling region, the world of morals and of will. The sense of 
moral sentiment lays hold of every man at some time with fierce 
haste, taking precedence of all else, reducing all material and 
philosophical concepts to chaff and vacuity, and he finds that only 
along this way lies serenity and safety. He becomes religious with- 
out tradition and without system, creed or theology. Even the 
typical agnostics of our generation conduct themselves as though 
they believed that God and the soul of man exist and are 

172 Butler Alumnal Quarterly 

We may well keep in mind, then, that all the avenues of ap- 
proach and sympathy should be kept open by the physician. He 
should not be less cognizant of the spiritual and emotional relations 
in which he stands or may stand to his patient than of the physical 
and intellectual. 

Men primarily educated in medical science have drawn heavily 
upon the scientific and religious tolerance of the age. Darwin and 
Huxley are notable examples. Darwin discovered evolution and 
Huxley was its greatest English advocate, as was Asa Gray in our 
country. What a revolution in thought and doctrine ! The 
hypothesis that all the forms of life, the universe itself, the mind 
of man and all its qualities, emotion, intellect and will, and all the 
phenomena of their action were once the latent possibilities of a 
fiery cosmic cloud ! 

Our profession also knows, or should know, the limits beyond 
which science ceases to be strong in proof and statement, when it 
is time to stop affirming and begin wondering. None more than 
we should feel the humility born of insight and knowledge — that 
Ave are only transient actors in the cosmic drama. Like Prospero's 
fairy creation, we 

"Are melted into air, into thin air, 

And like the baseless fabric of a vision, 

The cloud-capped towers, the gorgeous palaces. 

The solemn temples, the great globe itself ; 

Yea, all which it inherit, shall dissolve. 

And like this insubstantial pageant faded, 

Leave not a rack behind. We are such stuff 

As dreams are made of, and our little life 

Is rounded with a sleep." 

So when times of storm and stress have passed and the pause 
of reflection and emotion comes to us, we are overshadowed by the 
great awe which was experienced by Emanuel Kant when he 
declared that two things filled him with wonder and emotion — the 
contemplation of the starry heavens and the sense of moral respon- 
sibility in man. This feeling is inherent, none have escaped it, 
even if like the Latin poet they have struggled and denied — 

Music and Poetry 173 

"Lucretius, better than his mood, 
Dropped his plummet down the broad, 
Deep universe and said, 
'There is no God.' 

"Finding no bottom, he denied 
Divinely the Divine, and died. 
Chief poet of the Tiber side, 
By grace of God." 

All serious study leads to this cloudland, which lies far beyond 
the hampering details of science and theology — a realm and a 
vision we can not analyze by the intellect or comprehend by the 
sense. It is illumined and made comforting to us by the mystics 
and idealists, by the poets and musicians. 

The writer was speaking to a thoughtful young man walking 
faithfully the ways of his daily vocation the day following a 
presentation of the "Walkyrie." He was explaining to his com- 
panions the story of the Niebelungen dramas, describing the 
Ride of the Walkyries as far, that is, as it is possible to describe 
music in words or play the ten commandments on a violin. He 
said, in his enthusiasm : "If the whole range of modern literature 
Avere lost and only the works of Shakespeare and Wagner remained 
to us, the world would have lost but little." 

This, I suppose, is the common feeling of those who are wor- 
shipers at the shrine of Wagner, master of the drama of thought 
and sound, the very "Shakespeare of music." 

The opera before Wagner bore little relation to the thought and 
life of the people, as it did not spring from their native thought 
and tradition. Wagner's aim was to make the opera to the Ger- 
mans what the Greek drama was to the Athenians. The tragedies 
of Sophocles and Aeschylus embodied human types and elemental 
emotions. They were the celebration of the great religious festivals 
and w^ere presented twice each year for three days in succession in 
open-air theaters to the whole adult male population. Their 
influence upon the life and thought of the people was tremendous, 
and those few preserved to us are, after two thousand years have 
passed away, among the most precious remains of the w^orld 's early 

174 Butler Alumnal Quarterly 

Wagner, then, followed the Greek, seizing upon the national 
myths, pagan and Christian, for myths are universal and free from 
the limitations of time and place. And so he wrote the dramas, the 

librettos, which in themselves are powerful dramatic poems. 


But what shall we say of the mighty genius which could do all 
that the old dramatists attempted on the scenic stage and to this 
added the vocal and instrumental music, making all contributory 
to his purpose? We leave this question to those who have studied 
the Wagnerian operas, and they have a voluminous literature in 
every modern language. 

Those of our profession who have heard " Tannhauser, " the 
story of love and redemption through suffering, and the ''Wal- 
Icyrie ' ' will know wherein lay their pleasure and what stirred their 
emotion; whether it was the art form of the Greek drama, the 
tracing of the pagan or Christian myths used as the groundwork 
of the drama, the dramatic action and declamation of the text, the 
simple scenery employed, or the independence and illustrative 
agency of the orchestra, which in Wagner's operas is one of the 

chief elements in the development of the plot. 


After all "the play's the thing," and not the study or the criti- 
cism of it. Wagner was an original genius in music. He could not 
express himself in existing forms and so produced an absolutely 
new operatic form. Classicism always resists new movements. 
Classicism in music means devotion to pure beauty of form and 
matter as we have it in ritual music, in the devotional contempla- 
tive spirit withdrawn from the world. It is intellectual; it is 
profound; it is simple, serene and cloistered — not the life among 
men. Classical music found its expressive field in religion just as 
did the Gothic architecture, with its heaven-seeking and earth- 
despising spires, the cathedrals w^hich were "frozen music." 

Wagner could not express himself in these forms, for they do 
not contain the note of earthly passion, the fierce dominance of 
love and hate, the cry for intellectual liberty, the destructive 
analysis of old theologies, the passage of feudalism. 

The passion for liberty, the demolition of pagan theology and 
the substitution of Christian traditions were the themes of Wag- 

Music and Poetry 175 

ner, and the old vessels would not serve his purpose, and so he 
devised a new operatic mold. And the music-loving world seems 
to have accepted it. Few were his friends; the insane King of 
Bavaria was the most helpful and appreciative. He was derided 
as an iconoclast. France, England and Italy, the latter the home 
of the opera, refused his works, but they were received in this 
country from the outset. It was sixty-seven years ago that 
' ' Tannhauser ' ' was written and it was sung in English in our city 
the first time the 11th of April, 1906. It is not to be wondered at 
that our physicians very generally seized the opportunity to hear it 
sung in English. 

Physicists and physicians have done much to develop the his- 
tory of the evolution of music, notably Helmholz and Bilroth. The 
latter was by nature and desire a musician, although greatest of 
the German surgeons and pathologists. The twenty-five years he 
spent in Vienna were divided between surgery and music. He 
wrote a great work on music, the substance of which has been made 
available to American physicians through an extensive and sympa- 
thetic essay by Dr. Hemmeter, of Baltimore, in the Johns Hopkins 
Hospital Bulletin several years ago. Bilroth shows how the earliest 
music was intonation, the rhythm simply that of the text, as in the 
Gregorian chants, which emphasized to the people the church 

Even now the most civilized nations can not escape the tyranny 
of rhythm, the law of periodicity which rules the stars in their 
courses and also exercises power over all living things. Rhythm is 
the "dance of sound" just as dancing is the rhythm of movement. 
Melody grew out of an intonation and rhythm appeared in music 
as soon as it did in the measured verses to which music was set. To 
children and savages rhythm is the most agreeable form of music 
and in primeval humanity must have been the only music known 
and was interwoven with language itself. Language expresses 
thoughts, moods and emotion in but a crude manner even now — 

"In words, like weeds, I'll wrap me o'er, 


For words, like Nature, half reveal 
And half conceal the soul within. ' ' 

176 Butler Alumnal Quarterly 

Much can be conveyed by music when language fails utterly. 
Music and poetry are the highest reaches of human expression and 
the closest allies of the heart and mind of man. They serve to spur 
up the emotions on which action depends and they nourish indi- 
rectly the intellect and the will, 

' ' What a piece of work is man ! How noble in reason ! How 
infinite in faculties ! The beauty of the world, the paragon of 
animals," and yet he can never know himself any more than he 
can know the flower in the crannied wall, nor can he ever reveal 
himself fully to others by his act or by his speech. 

His best life is the life of thought of introspection, and in the 
last analj'sis every one must find his solace and his consolation 
within himself. The contemplation of the universe of which he is 
the highest expression and in which he is supreme, may baffle his 
intellect, but it should elevate his heart. 

In 1833 Emerson "found the house of Carlyle amid the des- 
olate, heathery hills of Craigenputtock, where the lonely scholar 
nourished his mighty heart," no one to speak to within sixteen 
miles save the minister of Dunscore. Emerson and Carlyle walked 
over the long hills and looked down into Wordsworth's country 
and naturally reverted to the immortality of the soul. Emerson 
tells us that it was not by Carlyle 's wish that they talked upon this 
topic, for Carlyle "had the natural disinclination of every nimble 
spirit to bruise itself against walls and did not like to place himself 
where no step could be taken." "But he was cognizant of the 
subtle links which bind the ages together, and how every event 
affects the future. Christ died on the tree; that built Dunscore 
Kirk yonder and brought you and me together. Time has only a 
relative existence." The point of this conversation between 
Carlyle and Emerson on immortality is that Carlyle did not want 
to talk about it — and what talk of immortality is there that is 
positive and assuring? Not that of Socrates in the Phaedo of 
Plato ; not in Cicero ; not in the several annual essays by Fiske, by 
James, by Osier and others on the Ingersoll Foundation at Har- 
vard ; not in Weissman or Metchnikof f do we find proof, for there 
is no proof; there is only hope and desire, and we express these 
best by poetry and by music, by looking into the eyes of love. 

And then we turn to the poets and the musicians, who in the 

Music and Poetry 177 

past have been the great comforters of mankind, and have yet a 
greater part to play in the future of the world. Poetry and music 
have filled many shores which the recession of the theologic and 
scientific tides have left exposed and lifeless in the past century, 
and to poetry and music we may look for our greatest joy and 
happiness in the future. 


The BUTLER ALUMNAL QUARTERLY has passed its fif- 
teenth birthday. In these fifteen years of its existence it has 
sought to please and to serve the alumni of Butler University. 
That it has not entirely failed in this effort is evidenced by the 
slowly increasing subscription list and thr; occasional letter of ap- 
probation which is received by the editor. And yet, the QUAR- 
TERLY has not been able to awaken sufficient interest among the 
alumni to make the publication self-supporting. Each year, save 
one in John Kautz's treasurership, since the QUARTERLY was 
born in April, 1911, it has been obliged to carry over a deficit on 
its books. The cost of publishing the QUARTERLY above the 
income from it, for the fiscal year ending June 12, 1926, was 
$230.02. Added the cost of the July issue, $381.70, the deficit 
which stares us in the face is $611.72. There are for last year two 
hundred and twenty-five unpaid subscriptions. 

This is a state of affairs which can not be continued indefi- 
nitely. The alumni officers can not carry this burden much 
longer. The college administration can not — ought not — carry it, 
though much help has come from that source in the past. If the 
QUARTERLY is worth while, the alumni should shoulder the 
burden of keeping it going. 

Perhaps there has existed too high an ideal in the hope that a 
large percentage of the alumni might care to hear from the old 
college home at least four times a year, might care enough to 
assume the responsibility of a payment of annual alumni dues of 
two dollars. About twenty per cent, of living alumni are paid up 
recipients of the periodical. 

If the QUARTERLY can be placed upon a self-supporting 
basis, there is much to be accomplished. There should be at least 
several hundred new subscribers. It should also have business 
cards from many alumni who would find it decidedly advantageous 
to them to keep their friends and others of the large family of 
Butler men and women informed as to where they can be reached. 
The business cards are inexpensive, and are a perpetual reminder 
to former classmates and friends of one's address and business. 


Is THE Quarterly Worth While? 179 

There are now more than 1,500 living graduates of Butler Uni- 
versity. Less than 350 are paying readers of the QUARTERLY. 
Out of the 1,150 who are not paying their alumni dues and thus 
receiving the QUARTERLY, ought there not to be at least 900 who 
desire to keep in touch with affairs at the college and with their 
college friends now very much scattered? There is no better way 
to do this than through the QUARTERLY. 

IS THE QUARTERLY WORTH WHILE ? If you think it is, 
send in now your two dollars for the new year ; also use your influ- 
ence in increasing the subscription list. 


Actual work on the construction of the buildings that will form 
the first unit of the Butler University plant in Fairview Park has 
been started. Work on the basement of the Arthur Jordan Memo- 
rial Hall was begun September 27. Gravel was found at a depth 
of five feet, making it possible to utilize this in facilitating the 
construction of concrete basement walls. 

Contracts for the basements, foundations, the stadium, sewers, 
sidewalks, drives, etc., have been let to William C. Smith, pres- 
ident of the Marion County Construction Company. He was 
graduated from Butler with the class of 1884 and was a member of 
the Sigma Chi fraternity while in the university. 

"We have been particularly fortunate in having for the school 
such a friend as William C. Smith," said John W. Atherton, 
executive secretary of Butler. "When we were so badly in need 
of money to help along the endowment and building funds he gave 
us $25,000. He has taken the contracts for the new Butler units 
at Fairview without the hope or expectation of one cent of profit. 
All the institution is to pay is the actual cost of the labor and 
material, as he will make no charge for the use of his machinery. 
When we take into consideration what a fair profit for a contractor 
would be on as large a job as this, we may as well say that Mr. 
Smith has doubled his $25,000 contribution to his alma mater. He 
shows not only generosity but a willingness to do himself what will 
be necessary before the actual work ,f placing brick and stone for 
the new buildings can be undertaken. We have in Mr, Smith a 
Butler man who can be trusted to do his part of the work with a 
degree of pride that will be a guarantee of its worth. ' ' 

"We are happy to have a typical Butler man, such as Mr. 
Smith, responsible for the important preliminary work that has to 
be done on the first three buildings at Fairview," said Arthur V. 
Brown, a member of the building committee. "Mr. Smith prob- 
ably has built more roads and streets than any man in Marion 
county. I recall having heard it said that he paved the first street 
ever given a permanent surface in Irvington and it stood the test 
of time. That work was done when Irvington was still a town of 


From the City Office 181 

its own. Having Mr. Smith do this work is not like entrusting it 
to the ordinary contractor. We have here not only an experienced 
contractor but a graduate of Butler who has made a substantial 
donation in cash and who now will give perhaps an equal amount 
in time and labor. Now that construction of the basement of the 
Jordan Hall has been started we anticipate there will be no delays 
and that work on the new plant will progress continuously until it 
is in shape to be occupied." 


The Butler College of Religion opened for its second annual 
session on September 16, 1926. The enrollment on that date was 
74, as against 38 at the same time last year. The student body 
includes matriculates from Australia, Japan, Canada, and from the 
Atlantic to the Pacific slopes. Two additional classrooms have 
been secured in the College of Missions Building and the chapel 
exercises of the College of Religion are being held regularly in the 
College of Missions Chapel. 

Dr. Hugh McLellan, of Winchester, Ky., delivered the Convo- 
cation address at the first chapel service of the College of Religion 
on September 17. His subject was "The Wisdom of Jesus." The 
address was an eloquent and scholarly message. Dr. McLellan also 
preached the Convocation sermon at the Downey Avenue Christian 
Church Sunday morning, September 19. He took as his subject 
"Fishers of Men," and in dignified but straightforward fashion 
he laid upon his hearers the obligations and responsibilities of the 

Mr. H. H, Halley, of Chicago, is giving his Scripture Recitals 
at the Chapel exercises of the college, and will continue to do so 
until the close of October. Rev. John R. Golden is scheduled to 
give four addresses on problems of the Orient, October 26-29, and 
Mr. Frederick J, Libby, of Washington, D. C, will speak on 
November 2 and 3. September 21-24 was Faculty Week. Profes- 
sor F. D. Kershner spoke on "The Minister as Student," Professor 
Hoover on "The Minister as a Preacher," President C. T. Paul, of 
the College of Missions, on "The Minister and Missions," and 
Professor B. L. Kershner on "The Minister as a Man." These 
messages were practical in their character, and were intended to 
acquaint the student body at the beginning of the school year with 
certain specific information which it was believed would be helpful 
to them in their student life. 

Rabbi Morris Feuerlicht, of Indianapolis, is giving instruction 
in Historical Hebrew in the college this year. Rabbi Feuerlicht is 



College of Religion 183 

one of the best known students of Semities in the Middle West, and 
is a recognized authority in his field. Professor Wm. F. Bacon, a 
graduate of McCormiek Seminary and post-graduate student of 
the University of Chicago, is teaching Elementary Hebrew and 
certain classes in the Old Testament. 

Dean Kershner's speaking schedule for the last month included 
two addresses at the Carroll County meeting at Delphi, September 
12 ; two addresses at the Western Pennsylvania State Convention, 
Wilkinsburg, Pa., September 24, with dates at Burlington for 
October 3, and Marion, October 10. His schedule for October 17 
is at Hartford City. He was also on the program of the Indiana 
Federation of Women's Clubs, at the Claypool Hotel, Indianap- 
olis, October 6, for an address on "The Church as a Character 
Building Agency." 


The total registration of the semester to date is 1,556, the num- 
ber being about equally divided between men and women. 
The freshman class numbers 520. 
Sixty-six per cent, of the enrollment comes from Indianapolis. 

To contribute to the democratic spirit of the college many fra- 
ternity receptions, freshman mixers, and "open houses" are being 

President Aley, forehanded as usual, has established himself in 
the vicinity of the new campus, having purchased a residence at 
the corner of Capitol Avenue and Berkeley Koad. Those who think 
it absolutely necessary to have an automobile in order to reach 
eight o'clock classes might cast a glance at Dr. Aley. 

Alumni generosity continues, as evidenced by the latest gift of 
William C. Smith, '84. Mr. Smith is doing the general contracting 
work for the foundations, sewers and roadways at cost as his added' 
contribution to the greater Butler, 

The first meeting of the Faculty Club of Butler College was 
held on the evening of September 18 at The Residence. Greeting 
to the new members was extended by Dr. Aley. The new president 
of the Club, Professor Harrison, presided and gave a talk upon 
"Scholarship and Its Relation to the Club," following which a 
social hour was enjoyed. 

The program for the year is : 

October 2 

Contemporaneous France and Italy Professor Gino A. Ratti 

November 6 

Excavations in Greece and Crete Professor Anna F. Weaver 

December 4 
Some Impressions of My Trip in Germany 

Professor Milton D. Baumgartner 


Around the Campus 185 

January 8 

Church and State in Mexico Professor Howard E. Jensen 

February 12 

The Stars in Poetry Professor Elijah N. Johnson 

March 5 

The Modern Buddhist Revival President Charles T. Paul 

April 9 

Collegiate Schools of Business Dean James "W. Putnam 

May 14 

The 1926 Drift, under editorship of Wilson Daily, '27, follow- 
ing the custom set by its predecessor, took first place in the Na- 
tional Art Craft Guild contest. The award for winning first place 
is a large silver cup which made its advent on the campus last 

"While the winning of the cup is an important item in the 
pleasure derived from the place won by the Drift, the greatest 
honor is the recognition of Butler University's own work by 
eminent men. 

The general makeup and plan of the book pays credit to the 
staff as elected from the college, but credit for the execution of the 
staff's ideas goes to the John Herron School art students who did 
their work faithfully and well. 

This is the second consecutive year that the honor has been 
brought to Butler by its Drift and as winning the cup two years in 
succession makes it a school's permanent possession the silver cup 
is ours. 

The outstanding success of the last two annuals must be an 
incentive to the coming staff to put all they have into the book 
that is to bear their name. College annuals have come and gone. 
Some have been remembered and many have been forgotten but 
the Drift has been placed upon a plane below which no other Drift 
will dare fall, but which to go above will take decided industry. 

The scholastic standing of the last semester presents the un- 
usual picture of the men leading the women. 

The statistics as kept in the registrar 's office are as follows : 

186 Butler Alumnal Quarterly 

Butler Association 86.736 

Lambda Chi Alpha 78.474 

Sigma Chi 76.542 

Tau Kappa Tau 76.263 

Delta Tau Delta 76.141 

Phi Delta Theta 75.491 

Sigma Nu 74.188 

Chi Rho Zeta 72.612 

Alpha Rho Delta 69.187 


Kappa Alpha Theta 84.779 

Kappa Phi 84.436 

Delta Gamma 84.261 

Alpha Chi Omega 84.047 

Kappa Kappa Gamma 83.837 

Pi Beta Phi 83.222 

Delta Delta Delta 83.031 

Zeta Tau Alpha 82.438 

Alpha Delta Pi 81.455 

Delta Zeta 80.895 

Alpha Delta Theta 80.444 

The fraternity average is 76.575, and the sorority total 83,152. 
The organized average, this includes fraternities and sororities, is 
80.34. The unorganized are close with the figures 78.925. 

Unorganized women are ahead of the unorganized men with an 
average of 81.961 to the men's 75.476. The women of the school 
are credited with 82.566, the men with 75.872. 

The freshman women have an average all their own, and they 
run true to form in that, they too, lead the frosh men to the tune 
of 81.345, the other end of the score being 72.108. The freshman 
average was 77.213. 

Many changes are seen in the faculty. Miss Corinne Welling, 
'12, associate professor of English, will not return this semester on 
account of illness. Her presence is greatly missed, but it is hoped 
she will soon resume her accustomed place. 

Around the Campus 187 

Of those absent on leave last year there has returned Professor 
Gino A. Ratti, head of department of Romance Languages, who, 
with his family, spent the year in France, Italy and Switzerland. 

Professor Anna F, Weaver, of the Greek department, is back 
from European travel, having spent nine months in Greece. 

Miss Hazel Whisenand, instructor in Spanish, spent her year 
studying in Indiana University. 

Miss Eleanor Hester, secretary of the president, in the Univer- 
sity of Minnesota. 

For the current year there are off on leave Miss Emily Hel- 
ming, '99, who is working in English at Yale University; Miss 
Esther Renfrew, '21, in Romance Languages at University of Chi- 
cago ; Mr. Joseph Fucilla in Spanish at the University of Chicago ; 
Shultz, in Education, at the University of Pennsylvania ; Allen, in 
Economics at Columbia. 

Miss Mary McBride, '14, is teaching in the department of 
English at Hiram College. 

But there are "new faces at the door." In the Department of 
Education are seen A. B. Carlisle of the Kansas State Teachers' 
College, and Lee O. Garber, of Illinois Wesleyan University. 

In English are Miss Martha Oliver, of Columbia; Mr. George 
A. Schumacher, '25, of LTniversity of Virginia; Mr. Nathan G. 
Carder, of Ohio State; Miss Sarah T. Sisson, '24. 

In Zoology is Dr. Nathan E. Pearson, of Columbia. In History 
is Mr. R. W. Keahey, of Wisconsin. In Romance Languages are 
Mr. John E. Frazeur, of Indiana University, and Mr. Talbert 
Reavis, also of Indiana University. 

The faculty was well represented in foreign travel during 
vacation. Dr. and Mrs. Wesenberg visited Spain and France. 
Dr. Richardson toured Britain and France. Dr. Baumgartner was 
in Germany and France. Mr. Dabney in France. Dean Putnam 
and Dr. Jensen in Mexico. 


The beginning of the present football season marks a new era 
in the athletic history of Butler College. The graduation of 
twelve seniors last spring with the passing of Pat Page ended the 
old regime which had played such an important part in the phe- 
nomenal climb of Blue and White varsity teams. This dozen ath- 
letes who had played a major part in Butler successes for four 
years was a costly loss to Paul Hinkle who took the reins of a 
greatly weakened department. 

Nine varsity letter men greeted the new coach on September 8, 
six of this group being seniors. Twelve numeral men of last year's 
strong freshman varsity returned with a host of reserves of last 
year's varsity team, making a squad of about thirty-five men; 
this squad being smaller than any Butler football squad of recent 

With the hardest schedule in the history of the school facing 
the Bulldogs, athletic officials and supporters are not overly 
optimistic as to the future. Wabash, Franklin and DePauw are 
all represented by stronger teams than those of the past while 
Illinois, Minnesota, Lombard and Dayton will all have strong line- 
ups to send against the Blue and White warriors. 

Captain Black at end; Hitch and Fletcher, tackles; Puett, 
center; Northam, halfback, and Miller, fullback, are the senior 
lettermen who are making bids for places in the Blue and White 
team- Collyer, halfback; Thaung and Southern, guards, are the 
junior letter men on the Bulldog roster. Sophomore numeral men 
who are sure to see service in this year 's line-up are : Fromuth, 
Cochrane, Royce, Meeker and Leichty, backf ield men ; and Hedden, 
Bugg, Anderegg, Geisert, Maney, Malone, Fately and McGaughey. 

The opening clash of the season with Earlham indicated that 
the Bulldogs are well supplied with backfield men, while the line 
is more or less an uncertainty. The Bulldogs ran up a 38 to score 
against the Quakers in the first half, and then set back on their 
haunches and failed to score during the remainder of the contest. 
"Red" Fromuth, flash sophomore quarterback of Ft. Wayne, 
startled the side-lines by his brilliant return of punts. The 


Athletics 189 

sorrell-headed lad shows promise of being one of the cleverest ball 
carriers that ever donned a blue and white uniform. 

Royce, Miller, Northam and Collyer are backf ield men of a high 
caliber that will carry the brunt of the Blue and White offensive 
this season. Northam led the state in scoring last year, and bids 
to be among the topnotchers again this year. Miller, Leichty 
and Meeker are all good line buckers, w^hile Royce, Collier and 
Summers can skirt the ends and slip through the tackles in fine 

Captain Black, a born leader, a hard fighter and a clever ball 
player is an ideal man to govern the destinies of the Bulldogs on 
the gridiron. Art will hold down one of the end positions this 
season. Geisert, a sophomore of Marshall, 111., will probably be on 
the other wing, Bugg, Hitch, Fletcher and Anderegg are all mak- 
ing strong bids for the tackle jobs. Thaung and Hedden will 
probably have the call over Fately and Malone at the guard 
positions while Walter Floyd, former Malnual Training High 
School star, will hold down the center position with Puett ready 
for relief duty. 



September 25 — Earlham College, score 38 to 0. 

October 2 — Hanover College, score 70 to 0. 

October 9 — At the University of Illinois, score 38 to 7. 

October 16 — Franklin College, score 7 to 0. 

October 23 — DePauw University, score 10 to 21. 

October 30 — Lombard College. 

November 6 — Wabash College. 

November 6 — Freshmen at Culver. 

November 13 — At the University of Minnesota. 

November 13 — Kentucky State Freshmen. 

November 20 — At Dayton University. 

AU games on Irwin Field unless otherwise indicated. 


have appeared, each attractive in its way. The former discusses 
recent books of travel, fiction, drama. The latter makes study in 
eighteenth century life and literature, centering in the period of 
Samuel Johnson and his contemporaries. 

The openinng day of the Literary Club was held on September 
25 with Mrs. Edith Dockweiler Hughes, '05, as hostess. After 
luncheon Miss Gretchen Scotten, '08, discussed "Far Harbors 
Around the World"; Mrs. Edith Gwartney Butler, '19, "With a 
Ford in the Garden of Eden." 

The first meeting of the GRAYDON CLUB was held on Octo- 
ber 5 at the residence of Mrs, Marjorie Hall Montgomery, '15, the 
incoming president. Following luncheon the program consisted of : 

Introduction of New President Mrs. Nell Reed Offutt, '11 

The Program Mrs. Irma Weyerbacher Van Tassel, '16 

The Historical Setting (1714-1784) . .Miss Virginia Kingsbury, '18 
Literature At the Opening of the Eighteenth Century 

Mrs. Dorothy Kautz Hamp, '14 

That about twenty- five young women in each group intensely 
occupied in the home or in occupations of the world, graduates of 
the college, should care to meet once a month in pleasant fellow- 
ship to follow along a line of reading and discussion, a love for 
which was instilled by their Alma Mater, is one of the encouraging 
features of alumni expression. The Quarterly commends and 
congratulates these endeavors, knowing "Spirits are not finely 
touched but to fine issues." 



Not Including Former Students 


Alabama 2 

Arizona 3 

Arkansas 1 

California 43 

Colorado 12 

Connecticut 11 

Florida 15 

Illinois 60 

Indiana 1113 

Iowa 10 

Kansas 11 

Kentucky 7 

Louisiana 2 

Maryland 6 

Massachusetts 11 

Michigan 16 

Minnesota 8 

Mississippi 1 

Maine 1 

NebrasJsa 1 

New Hampshire 2 

New Jersey 8 

New Mexico 4 

New York 23 

Missouri 20 

North Carolina 3 

Ohio 33 

Oklahoma 10 

Oregon 4 

Pennsylvania 8 

Tennessee 4 


192 Butler Alumnal, Quarterly 

Texas 6 

Utah 1 

Vermont 1 

Virginia 4 

South Carolina 1 

Washington 9 

West Virginia 10 

Washington, D. C 9 

Wisconsin 8 


Argentina, South America 1 

Alaska 1 

Australia 2 

Africa 4 

Canada 2 

China 4 

India 8 

Germany 1 

Japan 4 

Mexico 5 

Porto Rico 1 


The Alumni Office is without knowledge of the following 
graduates of the college. Definite information regarding them, 
whether living or deceased, will be gratefully received by the 
alumni secretary, Butler University : 

John Kimmons, '56; T. C. Elliott, '57; W. G. Hastings, '57; 
Ora Knowlton, '58 ; Levi Hanson, '59 ; Charles F. Lockwood, '61 ; 
Wickliffe A. Cotton, '64; Alexander C. Easter, '64; Henry H. 
Black, '66; David Utter, '67; John W. Tucker, '69; Samuel E. 
Young, '71 ; Willard R. Lowe, '72 ; Ernest R. Copeland, '78 ; W. 
Henry Grove, '81; Mary Paddock, '88; Bertha Belle Ward, '93; 
Edwin W. Brickert, '94 ; George W. Hoke, '95 ; Willis J. Burner, 
'01; Mrs. Netta Campbell Brown, '02; Mary Baldwin, '03; Paul 
L. Vogt, '03; Guy E. Killie, '04; Bert Markham, '05; Mrs. Bertha 
Empey Hoagland, '06 ; Maud Taylor, '06 ; Roscoe C. Thomas, '06 ; 
Mrs. Ethel Woody Horton, '07; Anna H. Burt, '08; Elmo Scott 
Wood, '08; Joseph H. Jackson, '11; Estall A. Roberts, '11. 



Miss Hazel Warren, '17, has returned to Indianapolis for 

Shelley D. Watts, '00, is engaged in Red Cross work in 

Gordon Paul, '26, is teaching in the Shattuek Military School 
of Faribault, Minnesota. 

Harry F. Lett, '13, has charge of the Christian Church in 
Washington, Indiana. 

Miss Vera Morgan, '19, has recently returned from a trip 
around the world. 

Mrs. Jessie Christian Brown, '97, has returned from a brief 
trip to Central America. 

Ralph V. Austin, '20, has become pastor of the Christian 
Church in Richland Centre, Wisconsin. 

Miss Dorothy Perkins, '24, is teaching history in the Manual 
Training High School of Indianapolis. 

Mrs. Carl Harris (Lois Brown, '09) of Des Moines, Iowa, vis- 
ited friends in Indianapolis in the summer. 

Gilbert Horney Fern, '12, has been appointed president of the 
Missouri Christian College, at Camden, Missouri. 

Ferris J. Stephens, '15, Ph. D. Yale, is professor of Old Testa- 
ment in the Culver-Stockton College, Canton, Missouri. 

Herman J. Sheedy, '20, entered in September the brokerage 
firm of George W. Cook and Company of Cleveland. 

Mr, and Mrs. Robert L. Keiser (Helen M. Reed, '12) now of 
Washington, D. C, have recently visited Indianapolis. 

Jabez Hall Wood, '26, and Horace Storer, '26, have entered the 
School of Business Administration of Harvard University. 

Karl S. Means, '14, has assumed his new duties as head of the 
chemistry department of Millikan College, Knoxville, Tennessee. 

Mrs. Ralph E. Stephenson (Mildred Hill, '18), of Longview, 
Washington, is visiting, with her children, her parents in Irvington. 

Arnold G. Davis, '26, has taken a position in the real estate 
department of the Washington Bank and Trust Company, 


Personal Mention 195 

Lester C. Nagley, former student, is secretary-manager of the 
Advertising Club of Indianapolis, with offices in the Chamber of 
Commerce Building. 

Miss Irene Seuel, '25, has gone for the year to Baltimore, where 
in the School of Social Economics of Johns Hopkins University she 
will take courses. 

Mr. and Mrs. Stuart Bowman (Margaret Barr, '11) with two 
sons, have spent August at Chama, New Mexico, with Kenneth 
Barr, '16. 

Miss Frances Weaver, '21, and Miss Mary Fugate, '21, were 
attendants at the recent wedding of Mr. and Mrs, WiUiam O. Sines 
in Indianapolis. 

Captain Herbert W. Schmidt, '11, is located at Lexington, 
where he is connected with the Military Department of the Uni- 
versity of Kentucky. 

Mrs. Walter B. Hilton (Kathryn Karns, '19), now living in 
Elyria, Ohio, spent with her two sons the month of August in Irv- 
ington with her parents, 

Robert Keach, ex- '25, visited old friends on Homecoming Day. 
He was en route to Minneapolis where he is connected with the 
Firestone Rubber Company, 

Mrs. William Miller (Marie Hamilton, '20) formerly of Rensse- 
laer, Indiana, now living in Redlands, California, visited old 
friends in Indianapolis in the summer. 

Miss Leora Carver, of Salem, Oregon, spent the summer in 
Irvington, called by the death of her brother, Mr, James E, Carver, 
father of Miss Mary Patia Carver, '25. 

The Butler University Alumni Scholarships have been awarded 
for scholastic promise and attainment to Miss Pauline Pierce, a 
senior, and to Joy J. Bailey, '26, a graduate student. 

Maurice B. Judd, ex- '13, received the LL.B. degree from the 
National University of Washington, D. C, Mr. Judd will practice 
law in Washington and continue his work as correspondent of the 
New York Sun. 

Miss Helen Payne, '26, has entered the graduate department 
of the University of Iowa, where she is devoting herself to vocal 
music. Mrs. Payne will spend the winter in Iowa City with her 
two daughters. 

196 Butler Alumnal Quarterly 

Raymond D. Meeker, '91, of Sullivan, Illinois, was on the cam- 
pus at the opening of college for the purpose of registering in the 
freshman class his nephew, Robert Stearns, of Chicago, son of Mrs. 
Tace Meeker Stearns, '90. 

Dr. and Mrs. John E. Stevens (Margaret Davis, '14), with 
their little family sailed from San Francisco on July 17 for their 
home in Miraj, India. They are in charge of a great work which 
the Quarterly follows with sincere interest. 

Miss Pearl Forsythe, '08, has returned from a year's leave of 
absence spent chiefly in Japan, where she made study of conditions 
of the Young Woman's Christian Association. She is enthusiastic 
over her experiences in the Land of the Rising Sun. 

Six scholarships have been conferred by the Indianapolis Cham- 
ber of Commerce through its educational department, of which 
number two came to students of Butler University: Harold H. 
Bredell, a sophomore, and Harold E. Ross, a freshman. 

Announcement has been made by Professor and Mrs. Edward 
Martin Greene, of the University of South Dakota, formerly of 
Butler University, of the marriage of their sister, Miss Alice 
Carter, to the Reverend Augustus Inglesbe Nasmith, of Shaohsing, 

Ralph C. Minton, '22, has entered Drew Theological Seminary, 
where he is taking a three years' course preparatory to entering 
the ministry. Mr. and Mrs. Minton (Henrietta Cochrane, ex- '19) 
and five children are living on Long Island, fifty miles out of 
New York City. 

Miss Penelope V. Kern, '00, is studying in the Harvard Grad- 
uate School of Education, where she has elected as major The. 
Teaching of English, and as minor Social Ethics. Miss Kern's 
interest in the college and loyalty to alumni activities never fails 
wherever she may be. 

When a teacher of the public schools of Indianapolis and a 
principal, too, is able to earn the degree of Master of Arts from 
Butler University the feat is worthy of mention and of praise. 
This is due Mrs. Elizabeth R. Witt, who with the class of 1926, 
received her advanced degree. 

Personal Mention 197 

Miss Virginia Young, '21, is sending a generous cheek for the 
ALUMNI SCHOLARSHIP FUND, writes: "It is a pleasure to 
make return in this way for the help I received at Butler in my 
student days. I am looking forward eagerly to the coming of the 
next number of the Quarterly for the latest news of the Butler 
family. I read it from cover to cover as soon as it arrives. 

"My home is across the road from that of Mr. and Mrs. J. G. 
McGavran. We share with each other the news from America, 
especially that from Indianapolis." 

Hilton U- Brown, '80, president of the board of directors, has 
made an extended tour through Russia, where he observed social 
and political conditions. He studied, also, the educational institu- 
tions in that and other countries which he visited. Letters received 
from Berlin, Moscow and Leningrad conveyed impressions of the 
interest and enjoyment he found. He returned on the Leviathan 
October 18. 

Mrs. Mary Ohaver Owsley, '19, gladdened her friends with her 
week's visit in Irvington at the time of the Wagoner-Brown wed- 
ding. Among the out-of-town Butler friends who enjoyed the 
beautiful lawn wedding at four o 'clock of the afternoon of August 
7, were Mrs. Lora C. Hoss, Mrs. Donald Elliott (Pauline Hoss, 
'14), Mr. Clarence L. Goodwin, '80; Miss Mary Brown, '19, and 
David Konold, '26. 

After a year's furlough Mr. and Mrs. Thomas N. Hill (Elma 
Alexander, '16), and their two little daughters have sailed for 
their foreign field of service. Their address will be Jhansi, U. P., 
India, where they will have charge of a boy's school and a church. 
It is pleasant to know they are to have a Ford ear for their relief, 
assistance and pleasure. The best wishes of the Quarterly go out 
to them in their good work. 

Dr. Richard Bishop Moore, formerly head of department of 
chemistry in Butler University, recently general manager of the 
Dorr Company, industrial chemists and chemical engineers of New 
York, has been appointed dean of the school of science and head of 
the department of chemistry at Purdue University. The office of 
the dean of science was made vacant by the retirement of Dr. 
Stanley Coulter on July 1. 

198 Butler Alumnal Quarterly 

Dr. Moore comes to Purdue with experience in educational, 
commercial and research fields, and his appointment is a valuable 
addition t« the University. The Quarterly congratulates both 
the university and Dr. Moore. 


Deming-Schuler — On July 24 were married in Anderson, In- 
diana, Mr. Arthur Deming and Miss Ruth Lucille Schuler, '25. 
Mr. and Mrs. Deming are at home in Indianapolis. 

Douglas-Frazee — On August 1 were married in Rushville, In- 
diana, Reverend Charles Harold Douglas and Miss Dorothy Frazee, 
'20. Mr. and Mrs. Douglas are at home in Dayton, Ohio. 

Wagoner-Brown — On August 7 were married in Irvington 
Mr. Clifford E. Wagoner and Miss Jean Elizabeth Brown, '19. 
Mr. and Mrs. Wagoner are at home in Irvington. 

La Fuze-Wolfard — On August 11 were married in Irvington 
Mr. Donald F. La Fuze and Miss Margaret Alice Wolfard, '23. 
Mr. and Mrs. La Fuze are at home in Irvington. 

Hawkins-Tunis — On August 12 were married in Indianapolis 
Mr. Laurence F, Hawkins, '22, and Miss Mabel Tunis. Mr, and 
Mrs. Hawkins are at home in Fayetteville, Arkansas, the seat of 
the LTniversity of Arkansas. 

Woodling-Pinnell — On August 19 were married in Osborn, 
Ohio, Mr. Homer E. Woodling, '26, and Miss Frances R. Pinnell, 
'24. Mr. and Mrs. Woodling are at home in Bloomfield, Indiana. 

Moor-Wrentmore — On August 21 were married in Irvington 
Mr, H. C, Moor and Miss Marjorie Wrentmore, '22. Mr. and Mrs. 
Moor are at home in Aledo, Illinois. 

Kehm-Early — On September 2 were married in Irvington 
Lieutenant Harold David Kehm and Miss Mary Early, '24. Lieu- 
tenant and Mrs. Kehm are at home in Fort Sill, Oklahoma. 

Avels-Sandefur — On September 11 were married in Indianap- 
olis Mr. Robert Eugene Avels and Miss Dorothy Laura Sandefur, 
'26. Mr. and Mrs. Avels are at home in Indianapolis. 

Witherspoon-Fitzgerald — On September 11 were married 
in Irvington Mr. Frederick Randolph Witherspoon, ex- '18, and 


200 Butler Alumnal Quarterly 

Miss Marie Fitzgerald, ex- '19. Mr. and Mrs. Witherspoon are at 
home in Indianapolis. 

Ingalls-Whitham — On September 15 were married in Indian- 
apolis Mr. Allin Kibben Ingalls and Miss Lorene Winifred Whit- 
ham, '26. Mr. and Mrs. Ingalls are at home in Chicago, Illinois. 

Thomson-Gentry — On September 18 were married in Nobles- 
ville, Indiana, Mr. Malcolm E. Thomson and Miss Velma Gentry, 
'24. Mr. and Mrs. Thomson are at home in Vincennes, Indiana. 

Ehlert-Erber — On September 18 were married in Indianap- 
olis Mr. Kurt F. Ehlert and Miss Helen M. Erber, '26. Mr. and 
Mrs. Ehlert are at home in Indianapolis. 

Van Arsdale-Hodges — On October 6 were married in Indian- 
apolis Mr. Sanford Buoyer Van Arsdale and Miss Lucele Hodges, 
'24. Mr. and Mrs. Van Arsdale are at home in Danville, Illinois. 

Pattison-Wilson — On October 9 were married in Indianapolis 
Mr. Edgar Young Pattison and Miss lone Wilson, '19. Mr. and 
Mrs. Pattison are at home in Indianapolis. 

McRoberts-Lahr — On October 9 were married in Irvington 
Dr. Earl S. McRoberts, '17, and Miss Margaret C. Lahr, '19. Dr. 
and Mrs. McRoberts are at home in Chicago. 

Palmer-Mead — On October 12 were married in Indianapolis 
Mr. W. Irving Palmer and Miss Kathryn Marcia Mead, '21. 

Portteus-Sweet — On October 13 were married in Martins- 
ville, Indiana, Dr. Walter Leroy Portteus, ex- '21, and Miss Harriet 
Sweet- Dr. and Mrs. Portteus are at home in Indianapolis. 

Harrison-Hasely — On October 16 were married in Indianap- 
olis Dr. C. E. Harrison and Miss Mildred Hasely, '26. Dr. and 
Mrs. Harrison are at home in Greenwood, Indiana. 

Albershardt-Watkins — On October 20 were married in In- 
dianapolis Mr. Frederick Conrad Albershardt and Miss Dorothy 
Watkins, ex- '25. Mr. and Mrs. Albershardt are at home in 


Brinkmann — To Mr. and Mrs. Frank Brinkmann (Ruth 
Bates, '25) on August 19, in Indianapolis, a son — Frank, Jr. 

BuRKHARDT — To Mr. Carl Burkhardt, '11, and Mrs, Burkhardt 
(Haidee Forsythe, ex- '13) on July 15, in Kansas City, Missouri, a 
daughter — Reba Pearl. 

Farson — To Mr. and Mrs. Matthew Farson (Rachel Campbell, 
'24) on October 3, in Indianapolis, a daughter — Martha Jean. 

Griggs — To Mr. Haldane A. Griggs, '25, and Mrs. Griggs 
(Lydia Bates, ex- '27) on August 27, in Indianapolis, a daughter — 
Dorothy Anne. 

McGavran — To Mr. Donald A. McGavran, '20, and Mrs. 
McGavran (Mary Elizabeth Howard, '22) on June 9, in India, a 
daughter — Helen Frances. 

Pearson — To Dr. and Mrs. Pearson (Evelyn Utter, '17) on 
February 7, in Mondombe, Africa, a daughter — Barbara Viley. 

Perkins — To Mr. Harry B. Perkins, '20, and Mrs. Perkins on 
July 13, in Indianapolis, a daughter — Patricia Catherine. 

Snyder — To Mr. Ralph W. Snyder, '25, and Mrs. Snyder 
(Freda Parr, ex- '25) on April 12, in Indianapolis, a son — John 

Whitaker— To Mr. Edwin S. Whitaker, ex- '20, and Mrs. Whit- 
aker on September 5, in Indianapolis, a daughter — Carol Jane. 


Brayton — Dr. Alembert W. Brayton, '79, died in Indianapolis 
at the age of seventy-eight years, on September 22, and was buried 
from his home on the 24th in Memorial Park cemetery, Irvington. 

Dr. Brayton was a loyal friend of Butler University, showing 
his interest in many ways, not the least being that he chose to take 


202 Butler Alumnal Quarterly 

his bachelor's degree from Butler, but elected that eight of his 
children should attend the college, the names of five standing upon 
the Alumni Register — May, Nelson, James, Irma, Elizabeth. 

A friend has written with appreciation of his fine qualities 
thus : 

Dr. Brayton was a man of strong personality, noted perhaps 
for his intellectual independence as much as for any other quality 
that he possessed. A lover of truth, an uncompromising truth- 
teller and a fearless investigator in the intellectual as well as the 
physical realm, he shrank from no result to which his inquiries 
seemed to lead. Genial and kindly as he was, he yet could be, and 
sometimes was, relentless in debate. Dr. Brayton had read widely, 
and he had the good reader's love for literature — literature as 
such. Scientifically trained, he yet had a passion for the human- 
ities. Who were his favorite authors it would be hard to say, but 
it is certain that he had a great admiration for Arnold and Emer- 
son, with the writings of both of whom he was admiringly familiar. 
The poets, too, were his friends — as were the philosophers. 

Dr. Brayton was an exceedingly interesting man, as one with 
so well-stored a mind could hardly help being. His humor at its- 
best was delightful, none the less so for sometimes being tinged 
with sarcasm, a sarcasm which was directed only against sham and 
humbug, and which is likely to mark both the thought and speech 
of all who love reality and honesty, A curious combination Dr. 
Brayton was of outdoor man and student. Of the former there 
was no suggestion in his physical frame, which always gave the 
impression of delicacy. But he was both a lover and investigator 
of nature, and he certainly "had an eye" for her beauties. 

Of his professional ability it is not necessary to say more than 
that he stood high in the ranks of scientists and physicians, and 
was loyal to their best standards and traditions. The respect of 
his associates he enjoyed in fullest measure, and he richly merited 
it. Perhaps, outside his immediate circle, Dr. Brayton was best 
known to the members of the Indianapolis Literary Clubs. No one 
enjoyed more than he did the meetings of that club, and no one 
was more loyally devoted to it. For it he wrote many interesting 
papers and to its discussions he contributed much that was 

Deaths 203 

It was in that association that he revealed himself most fully 
and unreservedly, and perhaps in no other group did he feel more 
completely at home, and in none other will he be more keenly 
missed. Dr. Brayton was, finally — though this might be taken for 
granted, and so, left unsaid — a man of the strictest integrity, both 
morally and intellectually. 

Brown — Demarchus C. Brown died in Indianapolis August 22, 
and was buried in Crown Hill cemetery on the 24th. The final 
services were held in the Downey Avenue Christian Church where 
tribute was borne by Keverend J. B. Armistead, Henry S. Schell 
(his words are given above), Amos W. Butler and Rabbi M. M. 
Feuerlicht. The pallbearers were, representing the college fac- 
ulty : Dean J. W. Putnam and Professor E. N. Johnson ; Alumni : 
F. R. Kautz, '87, and Robert Hall, '91 ; the church : W. A. Sweet- 
man and A. B. Tharp. 

Demarchus C. Brown, '79, was born in Indianapolis June 24, 
1857. He attended the public schools and on completing the 
grammar grades went to preparatory school, then conducted by 
the Northwestern Christian University, and later took the college 
course proper at Irvington, when the Northwestern Christian Uni- 
versity moved to the suburb and was changed in name to Butler 

At Butler he fell under the influence of Professor John 0. 
Hopkins, a noted Greek scholar of the day, and took all the Greek 
that was offered in the courses, as well as the Latin under Pro- 
fessor Scot Butler, now the sole survivor of the faculty of that day. 
He was graduated in 1879 and immediately became a tutor in the 
Greek language. 

After taking his master 's degree he went abroad and studied at 
the University of Tubingen, in Germany, and followed with re- 
search work at the British Museum in London. While away he 
was elected secretary of the college and instructor in Greek. In 
1884 he was elected full professor of Greek, occupying the Jeremy 
Anderson chair of Greek. This chair he occupied for twenty 
years, serving for nearly two years as acting president of the col- 
lege as well. In the meantime also he added a course in Greek art 
and made several extensive trips to Europe for further study. He 

204 Butler Alumnal Quarterly 

particularly became interested in archaeology and the Schliemen 
excavations that were then attracting attention of classical stu- 
dents. In 1892-93 he was with the American School at Athens. 
He spent several months also in Paris. On a return trip he en- 
gaged in research work in Athens, Rome and Munich, and with his 
wife traveled extensively and studied in the museums. 

In the early part of the twentieth century there were great 
changes in the curricula of colleges. A revival set in afterward, 
but along in 1906 and 1907 comparatively few students were reg- 
istering for the classical languages. 

In 1906 Governor James A. Mount and the state board of ed- 
ucation invited Professor Brown to become state librarian. He 
accepted, and had occupied that office ever since becoming in 
1926, under a new law, the director of Indiana library work. Pre- 
viously to that appointment he had been named as a member of 
the board of state charities, and was for twenty-five years in active 
service on that board. He was president of the Indiana Confer- 
ence of Charities in 1904, and at the time of his death was a mem- 
ber of the board of Children's Guardians. 

In all these years he had been party to all the agencies that 
promoted the work in which he was interested and commissioned 
He was a member of the Archselogical Institute of America, the 
American Philological Association, the American Library Asso- 
ciation (whose meetings in many cities he annually attended), the 
Classical Association of the Middle West, the Indiana Historical 
Society, etc. He was long a member of the Indianapolis Library 
Society, in which he found much pleasure. 

His one excursion into business was in the organization of the 
Irvington State Bank. He had a local pride in the development of 
his community and went into the bank largely on that account, and 
for a period served as president. 

In 1896 Mr. Brown published, as translator, "Selections From 
Lucian. " The volume has been used in many colleges and libra- 
ries for reference purposes. This was followed by ''American 
Criminology," from the work of Freudenthal, He edited also the 
Indiana Legislature and State Manual for the years 1907 and 1909. 
From the time he entered the library he became zealous in the 
search for original manuscripts and historical Indiana data, and 

Deaths 205 

through his own efforts and the help of the agents of the library, 
to whom he always gave the credit, he was successful in adding 
extensively to the original documents now in the possession of the 
state. These particularly include many letters and state papers 
of the early period and rare documents that have been all but for- 
gotten in closets and trunks. Among the collections that came to 
the library that he particularly prized was a gift from John H. 
Holliday of Civil War books, letters and pamphlets forming prob- 
ably the most complete in the West, as Mr. Holliday saved every- 
thing of value during the period of the great rebellion. The 
priceless documents in this and other collections that have come to 
the state were regarded by Mr. Brown as of rarest consequence to 
future historians. 

In 1881 Mr. Brown married his college classmate. Miss Anna 
Rudy, of Paris, 111. She died in 1891. In 1897 Mr. Brown married 
Jessie Lanier Christian, who, with their son Philip, survives him. 

Mr. Brown was a great athlete. In his college days baseball 
was practically the only collegiate sport, and at this he was what 
would be called in these days a star of the first magnitude. On 
the Butler team at that time were Dr. Frank A. Morrison, Dr. 
John Oliver, Clarence Forsythe and Henry Kahn. They were all 
great players, and all have testified many times to Demarchus 
Brown's great "arm." It was said that in contest in that day he 
could throw a ball farther than any of his contemporaries. There 
is a giant wild cherry tree near the line of Emerson avenue in 
what was left-field, in the first playing ground that was laid out 
in Irving-ton after the college removed to that suburb. Old-timers 
remember a homerun hit that he made over that cherry tree. It 
would seem an almost impossible feat to this da3^ In later years 
Mr. Brown's recreation was in tennis. And the best players were 
hard put to it in defeating him. 

Three years ago he suffered a severe attack of influenza, from 
which in reality he never recovered. It affected his heart and kid- 
neys and he was obliged to suspend all athletic exercises. This 
grieved him sorely, for he loved sports both as a participant and 
as a spectator. When football came in as the premier college 
sport, Mr. Brown became a real student of that game, but he did 

206 Butler Alumnal, Quarterly 

not lose interest in baseball which he knew technically and his- 

It was fitting that Mr. Brown's last public utterance should 
have been in the college chapel, and readers of the Quarterly will 
not forget the tender loyalty of the man and delightful culture of 
the scholar in that Founders' Day talk. Upon Commencement 
Day the directors conferred upon him the degree of Doctor of 
Laws, but he was not present to accept the honor. 

Cale — David H. Cale, student of the late eighties and son of 
Howard Cale, '66, died on October 5 in Denver, Colorado, and was 
buried in Crown Hill cemetery. 

Mr. Cale was born, reared and educated in Indianapolis, but 
for many years had lived in the West, where he was a well-known 
lumberman. His mother, Mrs. E. S. CruU, lives in Indianapolis, 
and his brother, Harrison Cale, in Cleveland. 

HuESMANN — Louis C. Huesmann, director of Butler University 
and chairman of the City Endowment committee, died suddenly in 
Indianapolis on September 30, and was buried in Crown Hill 
cemetery on October 3. 

At a meeting of the executive committee of the board of direc- 
tors, Mr. William G. Irwin, '89, paid the following tribute : 

"In the death of Louis C, Huesmann, Butler University lost a 
friend, supporter and leader whose place cannot be filled. We 
may not expect to find another who will measure up to his stature, 
but we may at least say something of the qualities that so endeared 
him to us, his close associates, and that made him so invaluable in 
the particular work he had chosen to do. 

*'For many years Mr. Huesmann had been a member of the 
Butler University board of directors. He had made a substantial 
contribution to the endowment fund early in the financial cam- 
paign and he became actively identified with the new Butler 
movement, not in a perfunctory manner, but as an enthusiastic 
leader. He served as city chairman of the endowment and build- 
ing fund committee and subsequently became chairman of the 
special Fairview building committee. Also he was a member of 
the executive and athletic committees. On the morning of the day 

Deaths 207 

he died, Mr. Huesmann discussed Butler affairs with members of 
the board and had called a meeting of his building committee for 
the afternoon. The two things that were nearest his mind at the 
time he was so suddenly taken from us were the Indianapolis First 
movement and the new Butler program. These he linked together 
and often said that one of the city's greatest immediate needs was 
an institution for the higher education of boys and girls, so well 
endowed, so adequately equipped and so wisely planned that it 
would serve the community, not only for the present, but for years 
to come. 

"Not long ago Air. Huesmann made a statement relative to 
Butler in which he said 'This winning of financial support of aU 
Indianapolis is the work of the committee of which I am chairman. 
For a long time Butler has enjoyed the moral support of the entire 
city. It is now time that this support be translated into assistance 
as well." 

' ' Mr. Huesmann was familiar with every phase of the new But- 
ler work. He was broad minded, free from prejudice and greatly 
tolerant of the opinions of others, but he had his firm convictions 
as to policy and he was unwilling at any time to compromise his 
principles. He believed in the teaching of sound government and 
sound religion and he never forsook his position at any time during 
his long connection with the Butler program. 

"As a man of large business affairs, experienced in many lines 
and at heart a firm believer in every good effort for Indianapolis, 
Mr. Huesmann was of particular value to the Butler building pro- 
gram. He brought an enlarged vision to aid the architects in 
planning the buildings that will comprise the first unit to be 
erected and he had direct charge of the contracts whereby these 
buildings will become a reality. He believed that Butler deserved 
the best and he did his utmost to that end. There is no method by 
which we, his friends and associates, may gauge the value of the 
work that Mr. Huesmann did for Butler. It was and is beyond 
our power to estimate. We feel a deep sense of loss, not only to a 
cause with which he was so closely identified, but a personal be- 
reavement as well for he was to all of us a friend, a guide and an 
adviser. We may not fill his place but we can and will carry on 

208 Butler Alumnai^ Quarterly 

the work he so wisely started and to which he was giving his best 
personal efforts even at the time of his death." 

Stearns — To Mrs. Taee Meeker Stearns, '90, and her family 
the Quarterly extends its sincere sympathy in their sorrow. Mr. 
Stearns died in Chicago on October 17. 

Recently the College folk have been saddened by five deaths : 

Mrs. Jocelyn Perry Courtright, '26, died in Irvington on 
September 12. She had long tanght in the Indianapolis public 
schools, having been for the last eight years principal of Number 
62. Completing her college course while carrying very insistent 
teaching work proved too much for her aspiring spirit, and her 
weariness yielded to eternal sleep. 

Paul Knight, member of the junior class, was accidentally 
killed on the early morning of August 8, while motoring from 
Irvington to northern Indianapolis. The loss of a promising son 
at twenty-two years of age, with no other child, who can express 
the sorrow of those parents? To them the Quarterly sends very 
tender sympathy. 

Miss Pearle E. Marley, member of the class of '26, teacher in 
the Indianapolis public schools, died on June 30. Miss Marley 
was to have completed her course in the summer school and to have 
then received her degree. 

James G. Morgan, former student, only son and only child of 
Mrs. Dorinda Greene Morgan, '95, died in Indianapolis on August 
16, at the age of twentyrfive years. Mr. and Mrs. Morgan (Mil- 
dred Foxworthy, '25) had been married two months previously, 
and were at home on a visit prior to taking up residence in Wheel- 
ing, "West Virginia. 

Stout — On October 3 died at Fort Benjamin Harrison, from 
injuries received in an aeroplane accident, Lieutenant Richard H. 
Stout. Lieutenant and Mrs. Stout (Dorothy Day, ex- '25) had 
been married on June 16, 1926. 

Deaths 209 

Stewart — Dr. Jonas Stewart, former student of the old uni- 
versity, died on August 5 in Anderson, Indiana, at the age of 
eightj'-three years. 

Just one year ago the editor received a letter from Dr. Stewart 
in reply to inquiry concerning his studentship from which she 
makes the following excerpt : 

"Soon after the spring term, August 28, 1862, I left to enlist 
in the Civil War — Company E, 44th Ohio Infantry. In January, 
1864, this regiment reenlisted under the Veteran Act and was 
afterwards known as the 8th Ohio Veteran Volunteer Cavalry. I 
remained with it until the close of the war, I was discharged on 
May 30, 1865, by reason of the General order of War Department 
to discharge all who had less than a year to serve. I served two 
years, nine months and two days. 

After returning from the war, I came back to the same dear old 
college in September, 1865, and spent one more year, finishing all 
the natural sciences as then taught there under dear old Professor 
E. T. Brown, and mathematics through trigonometry under Pro- 
fessor G. W. Hoss. I still think "there were giants in those days." 

On November 26, 1865, I was baptized in the baptistry of the 
little old Central Christian Church at the corner of Delaware and 
Ohio streets, by the then pastor, Otis A. Burgess, another of God's 
great and good men. But at the end of this college year my money 
was all gone, and there was no one upon whom I could call, my 
father having died before I was three years of age. So I am not 
an alumnus, much to my regret. I look back upon the time spent 
in the old college up on College avenue (then far out of the city) 
as the happiest days of my life. ' ' 

Dr. Stewart was born near Daleville, Delaware county, and 
lived at Anderson since 1870. He retired from practice of med- 
icine fifteen years ago. He was vice-president of the Indiana 
Medical Society in 1897, when it was reorganized and its name 
changed to Indiana State Medical Association, and Dr. Stewart 
was the first president of the association. He has served in vari- 
ous offices in the Central Christian church and in Major Maj'- 
Post of the Grand Army of the Republic in Anderson. 

1927 1927 

The T>rift 

The last Drift to be published on the 
Historic Butler Campus 

You Alumni cannot afford to miss this Drift 

The Drifts of 1925 and 1926 have won na- 
tional honors. 

The 1927 Drift will be better. 

Every one reads the Drift. 

Be in style. Keep informed. 

Send your check to 


2330 College Avenue 

Bigger 1927 Better 



iJj, /r -yvQ, Ll 

January, 1927 


Entered as second-class matter March 26, 1912, at the post 
office at Indianapolis, Ind., under the act of March 3, 1879. 


— Just Bill B, Wallace Lewis, '15 

The City of Washington Merrill Moores, ex- 76 

A Queen's Visit H. U. Brown, '80 

Dr. Eliza A. Blaker President Aley 

A Radio Talk Dean Putnam 

Advantages of a Small College Harvey W. Wiley 

The Ryks Gallery Frieda P. Haseltine, '16 

Illusion Marie George, '24 

College News — 

A Challenge to Alumni 


From the City Office 

From the College of Religion 

Around the Campus 

College Publications 

Another Prize-Winning Essay 


Executive Committee Meeting 

Butler College Monogram Association 

Information Needed 

Personal Mention 





Ain't God good to Indiana t 

Folks, a feller never knows 
Just how close he is to Eden 

Till, some time, he ups an' goes 
Seekin' fairer, greener pastures 

Than he has right here at home. 
Where there's sunshine in th' clover 

An' there's honey in th' comb; 
"Where th' ripples on th' river 

Kind o' chuckle as they flow — 
Ain't God good to Indiana? 

Ain't He, fellows? Ain't He, though? 

— William Herschell. 

We speak of patience as a worthy trait, 
So few of us have calm to watch and wait. 
But I believe that, on the Other Shore, 
Our dogs will be there — waiting — at the door ! 

— William Herschell. 

By Permission. 



Vol. XV January, 192T ^^ ' ^^' No. 4 

By B. Wallace Lewis, '15 

A long white road in France, ankle deep with the chalky dust 
of Champagne — July, 1918. And a long olive-drab column, sweat- 
ing, toiling, pounding down the road, hands swollen from the 
constant swing, swing, swing in cadence with the step; shoulders 
aching cruelly from the dragging weight of heavy packs, eyes 
filmed with sweat and fatigue. Thirty kilometers since dawn! 
Company B, 168th United States Infantry, going up, up where the 
lion of England and the flower of France have failed before them. 
Pound, pound, pound. Sometimes a man drops out, dizzy with 
fatigue, reeling from exhaustion, body and will can stand no more. 

' ' Hey, sergeant, give us a song ! ' ' 

Throats are dry and burning with dust and voices quaver a little 
at the start, but they gather strength as they swing along. Com- 
pany B is roaring its challenge, faster, faster, shoulders squared, 
heads up, fatigue forgotten in the stirring, deep-throated, defiant 
chant of the song — 

"Good-bye, Ma! Good-bye, Pa! 
Good-bye, mule, with your ole hee-haw ! 

* * * * 

I '11 get you a Turk, an ' th ' Kaiser, too — 
An' that's about all one feller kin do!" 

Not once, but ten thousand times, in those brave, bitter months 
of blood and battle, "Long Boy" turned blank despair into fight- 
ing courage. Tommy Atkins had "Tipperary" and "Keep the 
Home Fires Burning" — the Blue Devils had "Madelon" — the 
Doughboy had "The Long, Long Trail" and "Long Boy." 

Who wrote "Long Boy"? Bill Herschell— just Bill. 

214 BuTLEB Alumnal Quarterly 

Strange, yet natural, too, that this man whose profound delight 
is in being a ' ' pal to all the kids of Indianapolis ' ' should have had 
no childhood of his own. For William Herschell's childhood ended 
forever on the day they buried his mother in Evansville, when he 
was nine ; brave in his first suit with long trousers and fiercely de- 
termined to be the man his father expected him to be, so he could 
care for his two sisters and brother, all younger, while father 
worked in the railroad shop. 

Maybe it is the phantom dreams of that lost childhood that have 
made him the man he is. For William Herschell — no, Bill 
Herschell — can look straight into the heart of a child, and under- 
stand. He is the kind of man that "kids" tell their troubles to. 
That invisible, yet granite barrier of restraint and inability to 
understand that separates us grownups from children, and them 
from us, does not exist for Bill Herschell. Children call him 
"Bill." They understand him and he them. 

John Herschell was born in Scotland. He worked with his 
hands and took honest pride in his work. He was a blacksmith. 
On the day he completed his apprenticeship and graduated to his 
full status as a master blacksmith, he set off for America. It was 
a terrible passage, for the old ship, the St. James, took fire at sea, 
and passengers and crew battled the flames heroically for eight 
days until port could be made in Nova Scotia. From the old 
Scotland to the new ! Soon afterward came his Scottish sweet- 
heart, Martha Leitch. They were married in Buffalo and moved 
into the West. 

John Herschell and his bride found a home in Spencer, Indiana, 
where they lived for seven years. There, on November 17, 1873, 
came William, a man-child, sturdy from his Scotch inheritance, 
yet heir, too, to the traditions of this new world where his father 
and mother had found their home. 

William Herschell's first recollections are of his father, sitting 
of an evening in the lamplight, his day's work done, reciting Rob- 
ert Burns to his family. "The Cotter's Saturday Night" was 

Just Bill 215 

their favorite, and his father read those matchless lines with the 
fervor of an expatriate Scotsman. William Herschell grew up 
with the lilting music of Robert Burns bred into his soul, and it is 
to the vivid impressions of these early days that he owes today the 
sincere music and facile rhythm of his lines. 

The Herschell family lived in Spencer, Rockport, Evansville, 
Huntingburg, Princeton and Vincennes — all in that romantic and 
historic "pocket" of southwestern Indiana. John Herschell, after 
a brief service as blacksmith for the Indianapolis & Vincennes 
railroad, became foreman of the tool-making shop of the State- 
house quarry, near Spencer, where McCormick's Canyon Park is 
now, during the seven years the family lived in Spencer. He was 
foreman blacksmith for the old Evansville, Rockport and Eastern 
railroad, now a unit of the Southern Railroad, in the shops that 
were successively located in Rockport, Evansville, Huntingburg 
and Princeton. In the late years of John Herschell's life the 
family lived in Vincennes. 

School was always a desultory affair for young William, with 
all his family responsibilities. He was not a good student. Sev- 
eral years after Martha Herschell's death and before the family 
left Evansville, his father married again. William had reached 
the seventh grade in common school, old for his years, a man in 
mind and almost in stature at a time he should have been playing 
at boyhood's wonderful make-believe. One day he played truant 
to take part in a political parade, a parade that angered his 
teacher, who was of the opposite political faith and took his 
polities seriously, and the teacher unceremoniously and with com- 
plete finality expelled the truant. 

There was nothing for William to do but go to work. With the 
assistance of his father he apprenticed himself as a machinist in 
the railroad shops. 

William was a lad of spirit. He was elected secretary of his local 
union, and in the great American Railway Union strike in 1894, 
his activities in behalf of justice for the downtrodden, capital-ridden 
workmen (as he believed) became so intensely unpleasant to the 
employing "capitalists" that when the strike broke up and the 

216 Butler Alumnal Quarterly 

beaten men went back to work, young Herschell was out of a job. 

Then followed an interim of wandering. No longer needed at 
home, independent, footloose, young William went in search of 
adventure. He went to Canada. He came back to work in electric 
light plants in western New York. He worked as a night ma- 
chinist in the Monon shops at Monon. He returned to Princeton 
to visit the family, and there he met James McCormick, editor of 
the Princeton Daily News. McCormick needed a reporter. 

Herschell was only an indifferent machinist, violating a tradition 
centuries old in the Herschell family, for the Herschell men could 
all work well with their hands. And this indifferent machinist went 
to work as a reporter on this small town newspaper ! He found his 
life work. 

After his first day, he went back to his room and threw his over- 
alls and tools out of the window into the creek! 

"I'll give you nine dollars a week, if you can get it," McCor- 
mick had said. That meant nine dollars a week as a reporter if 
Herschell could bring in enough advertising to pay his salary. 

Those were happy, hopeful days for Bill Herschell. His wan- 
dering machinist past slipped from him. He was doing work he 
loved. McCormick was more than a boss. He was a friend, coun- 
sellor, inspiration. He took deep interest and concern in this 
strapping youth, who was perhaps ill-equipped for his work, but 
who put his whole soul into the difficult task of learning the art 
of stringing words together to make hearts respond to them. 

In 1898 the call of a larger field of endeavor won William away 
from McCormick and the Princeton Daily News. He went to the 
Evansville Journal. There was a sorrowful parting between Mc- 
Cormick and Herschell, for each had discovered the other, and the 
watch Bill Herschell carries today was McCormick 's parting gift. 

In 1899 John H. Holliday and Major W. J. Richards founded 
the Indianapolis Press, which lived for sixteen months. During 
those sixteen months, Bill Herschell covered "police" and learned 
about life as only a police reporter on a city newspaper can learn 
it. When the Press gave up the ghost, Herschell moved over to 
the Terre Haute Tribune. In 1902 he came back to Indianapolis 

Just Bill 217 

to the old Journal. In April, 1902, he joined the staff of The 
Indianapolis News. And here at The News he is today. 

In 1904 Hersehell was graduated from reporter to feature 
writer. In 1911, his editor, observing his facility at versification, 
urged him to write a series of poems, one for each Saturday. He 
wrote the series, "Songs of the Streets." "Ballads of the By- 
ways," another series, followed. Poems selected from these made 
up his first book, "Songs of the Streets and Byways." Later 
books chosen from poems first appearing in The News are "The 
Kid Has Gone to the Colors," "The Smile-bringer, " "Howdy 
All" and "Meet the Folks." 

In 1908 William Hersehell and Josephine Pugh were married. 
They live in Tecumseh Place, a quiet little street near Woodruff 
Place in Indianapolis. 

This twenty-four year connection between William Hersehell 
and The Indianapolis News has been a happy one for both. The 
News has given his simple, sincere genius a chance to flower by 
assigning him work he likes to do, writing about these plain, honest 
Hoosier folk he knows so well. The News gave him the audience 
that has grappled him to its heart. And he has helped, as all men 
have done who have "hung their copy on The News hook," to build 
the institution that has held for so many years such profound in- 
fluence on our Indiana people and our times. 

Prepare for a mild shock when you first meet Bill Hersehell. He 
looks more like the manager of a successful retail store than a poet. 
He is big, with the kind of bigness that goes clear through. A 
round head, hair trimmed close, joins to a massive trunk with a 
powerful neck. The hands that once wielded a machinist's ham- 
mer are strong and grip yours as if they meant it. At fifty-two, 
his hair is only tinged with gray, for his is the spirit of everlasting 
youth. Pale blue eyes that twinkle kindly and with deep and gen- 
tle understanding will charm you in spite of yourself. You want to 
call him "Bill" at once. He isn't William Hersehell, poet and 
feature writer of The Indianapolis News, with his share of what 
the world calls fame. He's Bill Hersehell, human being. 

The War was an amazing interlude for Bill Hersehell. It 

218 Butler Alumnal Quarterly 

stirred him to the depths of his soul. Uncle Sam had little use for 
r.ear-sighted, middle-aged fat men. He couldn't go. But he did 
go to all the training camps where Indiana men trained. He met 
them, he talked with them, he ate out of a mess-kit with them, he 
lived with them, he loved them. And he wrote "Long Boy" — 
about that green Hoosier rookie, who confidently, if a little bombas- 
tically, promised to bring the Kaiser, and a Turk, too, back to his 
sweetheart. Barclay Walker, of Indianapolis, composed the 
swinging melody for Herschell's verses. It took a million copies 
of "Long Boy" to teach the words of its lilting defiance to the 
armies of the nation. There was a lot of bravado in this leaving 
home to go to War — bravado to cloak the pang and pain of it. 
There was a lot of bravado on the Other Side, in the mud, and 
grief and horror of it all, to keep at bay the deadening weakness 
of homesickness. Bill Herschell knew this. And he gave us "Long 
Boy. ' ' It was worth an extra division of fighting men, or an extra 
ship in that bridge of ships that carried men and food to the 

There was a proud, sad void at home, too, for the men who had 
gone away. Bill Herschell knew this, too. He gave the folks at 
home "The Service Flag" and "The Kid Has Gone to the Colors" 
— and they loved him for it. 

Wabash College conferred the honorary degree of Master of Arts 
en William — no. Bill — Herschell, for having written these war 

On Bill Herschell's office wall, up on the tenth floor of The 
News, there hangs a letter from Joaquin Miller, that strange, 
erratic and gifted "poet of the Sierras." "You can write — you 
can see and understand. You are a seer in the true old Biblical 
sense," it says. 

James Whitcomb Riley, uncrowned poet laureate, yet crowned 
with everlasting glory in the hearts of men, was a tried and 
staunch friend of Bill Herschell. There is something fine and 
touching in the friendship of these two men — Riley, who had 
painted signs, and Herschell, who had worked in a machine shop, 

Just Bill 219 

both of them climbing to the heights on the plain, simple, sincere 
verses they wrote of, by and for these Hoosiers they loved so well. 

Bill Herschell doesn't write books. He writes for The News. 
Yet five books have been made from his verses and a sixth is com- 
ing, because they are the kind of verses that people like to keep 
and read again and again. 

By highhroiv standards. Bill Herschell is not a great poet. He 
writes for those common people whom Lincoln knew the Lord must 
have loved. In these days of free and futuristic verse with neither 
rhyme nor reason, Bill Herschell is writing poetry that rhymes, 
poetry that has music in it, poetry that sings its way into your 
heart. He writes of ordinary people like you and me, with sym- 
pathy and in the light of the great understanding that we are 
all the same under this thin veneer we wear. He writes of the 
children he loves, and he makes us love the ragged little street 
urchin, too. He writes of simple and eternal things — home, neigh- 
bors, children and mothers — and he makes our heart strings sing. 

What a world of joy this world would be 
If the grownup eyes of you and me 
Saw only the things that children see — 
Just "woses!" 
— From "Woses" in "Meet the Folks. 


By Hon. Merrill Moores, ex- '76 

As long ago as 1779 the members of the Continental Congress 
were discussing the question of locating the Nation's capital at 
Princeton, New Jersey; and four years later Kingston, on the 
west bank of the Hudson, about 90 miles north of Manhattan 
Island, and fifty or so north of West Point, where the Revolutionary 
troops were holding back the British, memorialized the New York 
Legislature asking that it be set apart as a Federal district, a 
memorial which two months later was granted by the New York 
General Assembly. A little later Annapolis asked to be selected, 
with an offer from the state to turn over the state buildings and 
spend $150,000 in the erection of thirteen residences for the mem- 
bers of the Congress from the thirteen colonies. New Jersey offered 
a township ten miles square at the head of navigation in the Dela- 
ware River, and Virginia offered her old capital, Williamsburg. 
New Jersey offered $150,000 and Virginia $500,000. Finally Vir- 
ginia and Maryland combined in an offer of $200,000 in case the 
capital should be located on the Maryland side of the Potomac 

Following these offers came the mutiny of the Colonial troops 
which drove Congress out of Philadelphia, and it was forced to 
meet successively at Trenton, York, Lancaster and Baltimore. The 
new Constitution went into effect March 4, 1889, and contained the 
following provision: ''The Congress shall have power ... to 
exercise exclusive legislation in all cases whatsoever over such dis- 
trict (not exceeding ten miles square) as may, by cession of par- 
ticular states, and the acceptance of Congress, become the seat of 
government of the United States. ' ' 

The site on the Potomac was selected by means of a trade ar- 
ranged between Alexander Hamilton and Thomas Jefferson; but 
the location of the exact site was left to President Washington, who 


The City of Washington 221 

had to select the site on the north bank of the Potomac somewhere 
on a line running sixty-seven miles up the river from the mouth of 
the Anacosta River which empties into the Potomac near the War 
College, in the east part of Washington. The President went 
over the whole territory and finally selected the present site. 

Of this site. Lord Bryce, who knew Washington as well or better 
than he knew London, said : 

"The site has a great deal that is admirable and charming. 
There is rising ground inclosing on all sides a level space, and so 
making an admirable amphitheater, between hills that are rich 
with woods, which in many places, thanks to the hard ancient 
rocks of this region, show bold faces and give much more striking 
effects than we can have in the soft, chalky or sandy hills which 
surround London. Underneath these hills and running like a 
silver thread through the middle of the valley is your admirable 

"The Potomac has two kinds of beauty — the beauty of the up- 
per stream, murmuring over a rocky bed between bold heights 
crowned with wood, and the beauty of the wide expanse, spread 
out like a lake below the city into a vast sheet of silver. 

"Besides all this you have behind Washington a charming 
country. On the north, east and west sides of Washington, and to 
some extent on the south, or Virginia side, . . . the country is 
singularly charming, quite as beautiful as that which adjoins any 
of the great capital cities of Europe, except, of course, Constanti- 
nople, with its wonderful Bosphorus. ' ' 

Washington himself was responsible for the ten miles square of 
the district and he early wrote that Philadelphia occupied an area 
of six square miles and that the capital of a Nation should be 
large enough to accommodate future growth. He took the greatest 
interest in the building and development of the new city. He 
selected Pierre Charles L 'Enfant to draw the plans; but he par- 
ticipated in drafting them ; and we owe as much to Washington as 
to L 'Enfant for their general excellence. 

222 Butler Alumnal Quarterly 

L 'Enfant was the son of a French artist, and was educated as 
an army engineer. He left France at the age of twenty-two, a few 
months before LaFayette, and came as a volunteer to the American 
army. His first work after volunteering was the construction of 
Fort Mifflin, and Washington selected him as Chief of Engineers 
in the American army with the modest rank of major, and en- 
trusted him with almost all of the engineering and fortification of 
the Revolution. He was an artist as well as a great engineer, but 
was cursed with a most temperamental disposition, and was sadly 
opinionated and obstinate. 

The men in charge of laying out the new capital were Washing- 
ton, Jefferson and L 'Enfant. Only Washington and L 'Enfant 
could visualize the great city Washington was to become. All 
Jefferson was capable of imagining was a country village with 
straight and rather narrow streets, something like those in Phila- 
delphia. In this notion he was fortunately outvoted; and he be- 
came most useful in the carrying out of the project. Washington 
had never been outside the colonies except to accompany his sick 
brother Lawrence to Barbadoes. L 'Enfant was not widely trav- 
eled; but Jefferson had seen much of the world and at once gave 
L 'Enfant large maps and plans of Frankfort-on-the-Main, Carls- 
ruhe, Amsterdam, Strasburg, Paris, Orleans, Bordeaux, Lyons, 
Montpelier, Marseilles, Turin and Milan, which were of the great- 
est service to L 'Enfant and Washington in preparing their plan 
of the city; and when L 'Enfant 's plan was finally approved by 
Washington, Jefferson cordially acquiesced and was of great assist- 

Washington himself selected the site of the Capitol and of the 
White House. The plans have met bitter opposition in Congress; 
but, on the whole have been followed to this day, the changes made 
by Congress having all of them been detrimental but few in num- 
ber. During the administration of President Polk, Congress hav- 
ing taxed the portion of the District in Virginia, some three or 
more square miles, and having made no roads or other improve- 
ments there, and it appearing likely that an act might pass to 
abolish slavery in the District, Virginia demanded its retrocession 

The City of Washington 223 

and Congress weakly gave it back to Virginia and it ceased to be 
a portion of the District. The part given back includes Arlington, 
of course, and the city of Alexandria and everything across the 
Potomac, although the government owns Arlington, Fort Myer, and 
a great government farm used by the Department of Agriculture 
for experimental purposes. 

The economy or parsimony of Congress was so great that, when 
the District was taken over by the government, the land was not 
paid for outright; but the farms throughout that portion of the 
District included in L 'Enfant 's plan of the city were platted into 
avenues, streets, parks and lots, and something like alternate lots 
were returned to the farmer owners as part compensation for the 

At that time the greater part of the city between the White 
House and the Capitol along Pennsylvania avenue and south of 
the avenue, and practically all of the present beautiful Potomac 
Park in the rear of the White House was dismal swamp ; and for 
many years after the Capitol was occupied ague and other forms 
of malaria were almost universal. The Washington monument was 
started in the marsh without any adequate foundation and when 
Congress was compelled to finish it, nothing could be done until the 
stump standing in the water had been jacked up, a concrete foun- 
dation placed under it, and the surrounding land raised some thirty 
feet by filling in. The land where the beautiful Lincoln Memorial 
stands was a part of the bed of the Potomac ; and had to be filled 
in. Much of the earth used for filling was excavation in the con- 
struction of the tidal basin, the attractive artificial lake drained 
every day by tidal gates built with valves so that the water comes 
in from the Potomac to the west of the White House and escapes 
through tidal gates not far south of the Bureau of Printing and 

The Tiber, a muddy stream which flowed down Second street, 
N. W., a little west of the Capitol, and had a bridge where Penn- 
sylvania avenue crosses Second street, has been covered over and 
is now only a sewer passing under the Botanic Gardens. 

The Battle of Blandensburg would make a fine motive for comic 

224 Butler Alumnal Quarterly 

opera. Although a British fleet was known to be in the Chesa- 
peake, and the capital was threatened by the fleet, Washington 
was unprotected except by about 1,000 regulars, two or three thou- 
sand Maryland militia, and some 600 sailors under the command of 
Captain Joshua Barney, who had charge of a fleet of small gun- 
boats, wholly inadequate for the defense of the Chesapeake, and 
who turned his 600 men into soldiers by the simple expedient of 
burning his gun-boats. The sailors did all the fighting which was 
at all creditable to our arms. Blandensburg is on the District line, 
and when the first advance of the British drove the Marylanders 
back to the District line, they at once disbanded and returned to 
their homes. The regulars were already scattered through the 
incompetency of the general in command, and Barney's six hun- 
dred fought with the courage of the Light Brigade at Balaclava, 
and with much the same result. 

Dolly Madison managed to get away with the pictures in the 
White House and took them and her feeble husband over into 
Virginia. The one hundred regulars in charge of the White 
House drank up all the wine and disappeared; and the roof was 
burned off by the British. At the Capitol the British troops had 
the excellent taste to burn off the wooden dome, which had been 
badly designed by an amateur architect, and gave place to the 
superb dome which now surmounts the building. It seems to me 
that the best results of the War of 1812 were the victory of Gen- 
eral Jackson at New Orleans, the Battle of Lake Erie and the 
burning of the ramshackle old wooden dome. Since then the two 
great wings have been built and have added much to the beauty 
of the Capitol; and in more recent years the office buildings de- 
signed by Daniel H. Burnham, but constructed under the super- 
vision of an Indianapolis architect, Elliott Woods 

Washington is richer in its parks than any other city in the 
world. Pursuant to L 'Enfant 's design, it possesses no less than 
400 parks, nearly all of them scattered here and there through the 
populous parts of the city. Two of them are of really great size, 

The City of Washington 225 

Potomac Park, made largely on reclaimed river bottom, and Rock 
Creek Park, made from a natural ravine, which follows the creek 
and runs from almost Chevy Chase south-south-west through the 
best part of the city and divides Washington proper from the 
historic village of Georgetown. Everybody knows Potomac Park, 
which needs not be described; but comparatively few know of 
the extent and beauty of Rock Creek Park, which besides bridle 
and foot-paths has some fifty miles of improved roads within 
its limits, any of them as good as the best streets in Washington, 
Let me give you the description of it by Lord Bryce, 

"To Rock Creek there is nothing comparable in any capital 
city of Europe, What city in the world is there where a man liv- 
ing in a house like that in which we are meeting in Eighteenth 
street can within less than ten minutes by car and within a quarter 
of an hour on his own feet get in a beautiful rocky glen, such as 
you would find in the woods of Maine or Scotland — a winding 
rocky glen, with a broad stream foaming over its stony bed and 
wild leafy woods looking down on each side, where you not only 
have a carriage road at the bottom, but an inexhaustible variety 
of foot-paths, where you can force your way through thickets and 
test your physical ability in climbing up and down steep slopes, 
and in places scaling the faces of bold cliffs? 

"Along one part of the stream there are places where the creek 
is deep and stagnant, with sandy pools: at other places the water 
runs swiftly and there are ripples in the stream and many tiny 
cascades where water splashes over ridges of rock and twists round 
huge boulders. You will find an endless variety of beauty. . . . 

"All along the creek one may see a great many water-loving 
birds — king-fishers and ouzels and others too numerous to mention. 
All along the slopes and in the meadows by the stream one can 
find a great many beautiful wild flowers. I have found some 
quite uncommon and most lovely wild flowers growing there in 
the spring. 

"There are leafy glades where a man can go and lie down on a 
bed of leaves and listen for hours to the birds singing; and forget 

226 Butler Alumnal Quarterly 

there is such a place as Washington and such a thing as politics 
within eight miles of him." 

Expression is frequently made of the resemblance Indianapolis 
bears to the city of Washington, and I frankly admit that in some 
respects it does. Yet I must confess that in my opinion the pioneers 
who laid out the city of Indianapolis, among whom was my grand- 
father and the grandfathers of many of you, were men lacking in 
vision, who neglected opportunities and made many mistakes which 
through the century that has passed since the laying out of our city 
their descendants have been trying to correct, with a success com- 
mendable but by no means complete. 

The site for the State Capital was fixed June 7, 1820, by a most 
able commission of pioneers, ten in number, who were given the 
duty of laying out the city. Most of them knew of and admired 
the plans drawn by L 'Enfant and approved by Washington and 
Jefferson for the Nation 's Capital. Washington was dead : he had 
had to remove Major L 'Enfant from the execution of his admirable 
plan because he was so unconciliatory in disposition that it was 
impossible for the District Commissioners to co-operate with him, 
and in 1792 Washington made him Commandant at West Point, 
and appointed Andrew EUicott, a man wonderfully qualified for 
the development of L 'Enfant 's plans, and who, after Ellicott had 
completed his work of laying out Washington, was L 'Enfant 's 
succcessor at West Point Academy. He died in 1820. L 'Enfant 
was old and feeble and unpopular with the members of Congress, 
who had never compensated him decently for his great work in 
Washington and with whom he had quarreled bitterly. Jefferson 
was over eighty and in retirement at Monticello. The Indiana com- 
missioners wished to get the services of one who had been actively 
engaged in laying out Washington, and the best they could do was 
to employ an old Scotch surveyor, Alexander Ralston, who was 
not an engineer; but had run the lines for Washington's streets 
through the primeval forest. 

Ralson was ignorant of city planning and of many other things 
a simple surveyor ought to know. He was as stubborn as L 'Enfant, 
had a great admiration for Thomas Jefferson, was opinionated and 

The City of Washington 227 

probably dishonest, as the first case tried in this county was one 
in which a man he had swindled with wildcat money recovered 
judgment against Ralston for fraud. From Jefferson he had the 
idea that a state capital not located on a navigable stream could 
never grow. 

Imbued with Washington's idea that the site for a state capital 
should provide for the future growth of the capital, Congress in a 
burst of generosity had granted to Indiana four square miles of 
land to be laid out for the future city. Ralston convinced the 
commissioners that the city would never cover more than one 
square mile, and laid out the land between North, South, East and 
West streets as the site, and sold the other three square miles for 
small farms and suburban residences, if the pioneer residents knew 
of such things. He made no plans for expansion beyond the one 
square mile and modified Washington's ideas as to streets and 
avenues by Jefferson's checkerboard plan. With true Scotch 
thrift, he made no provision for parks, except the small circle in 
which the monument stands, and put four avenues running diag- 
onally, as we all know. He was compelled by the commissioners to 
leave University Square not as a park but for the site of a future 
university, and he provided for a drill-ground, which we now call 
Military Park. He made the streets narrower than Washington 
approved but wider than Jefferson would have made them. Know- 
ing that the congressional survey had been made several years be- 
fore and that its lines had been run on the true meridian, he laid 
out our streets with a pocket compass, although he knew the roads 
of the state were to be made according to the true meridian accord- 
ing to the congressional survey, with the result that when the 
streets within the original one-mile square are extended beyond it, 
they are compelled to change direction more or less or have jogs in 
them. He made other mistakes, which I have not time to enumer- 
ate; and his plan was simply execrable in that it made no pro- 
vision for the extension of the streets he had laid out. 

I wish to close with Lord Bryce's comparison of Washington 
with the other great capitals of the world : 

** Perhaps you would like to hear a few remarks on some of the 

228 Butler Alumnal Quarterly 

other great capitals of the world. Take Berlin. It stands in a 
sandy waste, perfectly flat, with here and there a swampy pond or 
lake, and a sluggish stream meanders through it. Part of the en- 
virons have, however, been well planted with trees, and this 
redeems the city to some extent. The streets are now stately, 
adorned by many a noble building. It has become, through the 
efforts of the government and its own citizens, an imposing city; 
but the environs can never be beautiful, because nature has been 
very ungracious. 

"Take St. Petersburg. St. Petersburg has a splendid water- 
front facing its grand river, the Neva, with its vast rush of cold 
green water, covered with ice in winter and chilling the air, and 
seeming to chill the landscape in summer. That, however, is the 
only beauty St. Petersburg has. The country is flat and in many 
places water-logged, owing to numerous pools and swamps. It has 
no natural attraction either in its immediate or more distant en- 
virons, except the stream of Neva. 

"Paris again has some agreeable landscapes within reach, but 
nothing at all striking, nothing nearly so fine in the lines of its 
scenery as the hills that enclose the valley in which Washington 
lies, and no such charm as a still wild forest as Washington affords. 
The Seine, too, is a stream not to be compared to your Potomac. 

"The same thing can be said of Madrid. It stands on a level, 
and the mountains are too distant to come effectively into the 
landscape, and its only water is a wretched little brooklet called the 
Manzanares. They tell a story there about a remark attributed to 
Alexandre Dumas when he visited Madrid. He was taken to the 
lofty bridge which spans the ravine, at the bottom of which the 
rivulet flows. The day was hot and being thirsty, he asked for a 
glass of water. They brought him the water, and he was about to 
drink, when looking down and catching sight of the streamlet, he 
said: 'No, take it away: give it to that poor river: it needs a 
drink more than I do.' 

"Then, there is our English London, which stands in a rather 
tame country. It is true that there are some charming bits of 
quiet and pretty rural scenery in Surrey and Essex, within a 

The City of Washington 229 

distance of from 20 to 30 miles, and there are pleasing beech woods 
covering the chalky hills of Bucks. Yet Nature has done nothing 
for London comparable to what she has done for Washington. The 
Thames, though it fills up pretty well at high tide, is nowise com- 
parable for volume and beauty of surroundings to your own Po- 
tomac. ' ' 

I have said little or nothing of the architecture of Washington 
and its great monuments. They are almost without exception fine ; 
and as to the future the prospects are along the line of even better 
buildings and monuments and statues. In 1911 Congress created 
a Fine Arts Commission in whose charge was placed all the art 
and architecture of the future. Its membership of seven includes 
the greatest artists, sculptors and architects in the country and no 
President can be expected to let the membership deteriorate. 


Indianapolis was stirred in November by a visit of a few hours 
of members of the reigning family of Roumania, Queen Marie — 
the womanly woman, the queenly queen — and her children, Princess 
Ileana and Prince Nicholas. For the stay, Hilton U. Brown, '80, 
was appointed official escort of the royal party. At the dinner 
given at the Columbia Club Mr. Brown spoke briefly in presenting 
the Queen a souvenir of her visit, a miniature golden replica of the 
"World "War Memorial, fashioned by Charles B. Dyer, a former 
student. Mr. Brown said: 

""We are not used to royalty, but we are not strangers to good 
company. Friendships do not depend on title or rank. General 
Grant once said to an acclaiming multitude that he well understood 
that the applause was not so much personal to him as to the office 
and the dignity of the government behind him. The combination 
is happy when the world can pay tribute both to the office and its 
occupant. Indianapolis recognizes that these are in conjunction on 
this occasion. 

"Our guests are a long way from that part of the earth that 
they call home, but the hand of American friendship extends across 
the seas. "We remember when Roumanian citizens sojourning in 
Indianapolis went forth to the aid of their mother country. Some 
of them are buried on Roumanian battlefields. "We remember the 
struggles of Roumania, and its emergence from wracking war to 
its present promising and ambitious state. "We remember its royal 
rulers not because they were royal, but because of the unselfish 
spirit that they displayed when their lands were desolated. 

"We know something of the queen of Roumania. In the gloom 
of disaster, in mid-winter, on foot and on horseback, she went from 
camp to camp, stirring the hearts of freezing and starving soldiers. 

"We know from correspondents that, like Florence Nightingale 
in the Crimean war, the Roumanian queen sacrificed herself in the 
hospitals and in the wreckage brought by war. And we know that 
those hospitals were not of the class that the world calls best. They 
were not immaculate in marble and tile. Nursing facilities were 

A Queen's Visit 231 

meager and the surgeons were themselves the victims of plagues 
and exhaustion. They were the ghastly field hospitals, under shell 
fire, without bandages and anaesthetics. 'Buzzing night flies,' and 
crawling creatures did not drive this queen from her work. 

In the perfumed chambers of the great, 
Under the canopies of costly state, 

she might have 'steeped her senses in f orgetf ulness, ' but she chose 
the 'uneasy pallets and the loathsome beds' and ministered to her 
torn and wasted countrymen. It is such a person that the city of 
Indianapolis welcomes, and not merely one of royal rank. Any 
community in any land in any time may well pay tribute to such 
a one. 

"Peace has come and in the security of victory we can not fail 
to honor those who stood in the bloody breach. Indiana, central in 
population of the great country that took up your quarrel with the 
foe, does not glory in war, but does not cower before the oppressor. 
It not only fills the ranks of the army but it is devoted to the arts 
of peace. Its men of letters are not unknown to you and to your 
libraries. You are neither stranger to them nor to the valorous 
deeds of our soldiers. The state is building here a monument to 
commemorate the lives of those who died in the great war in which 
you were so directly interested and in which your participation was 
so great a credit to womanhood. 

"That you may have some memento of your visit and some re- 
membrance of what Indiana is doing for her warrior dead, this 
replica of the Soldiers ' Memorial, now in process of construction, has 
been made for you. It is a testimonial of the peace and goodwill 
which the men in arms made possible, an assurance that the arts 
may continue to prosper. 

' ' This that I now present to you, in behalf of the city of Indian- 
apolis, home of the American Legion, is in appreciation of your 
devotion which has ennobled both patriotism and peace. As 
'friendship is golden' this offering has been wrought in precious 
metal, by one of our own citizens, befitting the occasion and the 
queenly attributes of its recipient. 

' ' May it be a monument of peace and good will. ' ' 

By President Aley 

In the passing of Mrs. Blaker the community and the state loses 
the presence and service of a remarkable woman. For forty-four 
years she lived and worked in Indianapolis. She came here in 
1882 upon the invitation of a committee made up of Hiram Had- 
ley, A. C. Shortridge and Junius Roberts. She was brought here 
to establish a kindergarten school. Her first work was done at 
the Hadley and Roberts Academy at Vermont and Meridian streets. 
Mrs. Blaker had a broad vision of the needs of the underprivileged 
children of the city. As a result of this vision she led in organ- 
izing the Indianapolis Free Kindergarten and Aid Society. This 
was the beginning of a system that now includes more than forty 
units. Of this organization Mrs. Blaker was superintendent to the 
end of her life. 

It was not long after her work began in Indianapolis until she 
realized the need of capable teachers well trained for the work. 
She organized the Indiana Kindergarten Training School to meet 
this need. The name of the school was changed in 1893 to Teachers 
College of Indianapolis. The scope of the school was enlarged and 
preparation given to both city and rural grade teachers. Some- 
thing of the influence of this school may be inferred from the fact 
that three thousand young women have graduated from it and 
that more than twenty-two thousand have enrolled in it. Students 
from Teachers College have gone to all parts of the world. They 
have, however, never gone so far as to lose their touch with the 
school or with Mrs. Blaker, the head. 

Within the last year an affiliation between Teachers College and 
Butler University was arranged. Mrs. Blaker was very anxious 
that her life work should be perpetuated. To that end she desired 
that some connection be made with Butler. Just what details may 
be worked out in the near future cannot at this time be determined. 
It is certain that Butler recognizes the worth of the work that has 
been done and will stand ready in every way to help continue it. 


Dr. Eliza A. Blaker 233 

Personally, ]\Irs. Blaker was very modest and retiring. She did 
not seek popular applause. Her fine personal qualities, her won- 
derful powers of leadership, and her winsome manner attracted 
to her all who came to know her. Her influence was very marked 
upon the students of the school. She gave herself freely to their 
service. She also gave herself generously to the needs of the com- 
munitJ^ She was known either personally or by reputation to all 
the people of our city and beloved by them. The example and 
lesson of her life remain with us to inspire and to bless. 

'These monuments of manhood strong and high 
Do more than forts or battle-ships to keep 

Our dear-bought liberty. They fortify 

The heart of youth with valour wise and deep ; 

They build eternal bulwarks, and command 
Immortal hosts to guard our native land. ' ' 

By Dean James W. Putnam 

On behalf of Butler University, it is a pleasure to me to greet 
the radio audience of WFBM, This is only a preface, so to speak, 
to a series of fifteen minute talks to be broadcasted from Butler 
University at 7 :15 on successive Friday evenings. These talks will 
be given in conjunction with the various scientific and scholarly 
clubs or societies connected with the several departments of the 
university, such as the Chemistry Club, the Biology Clu^, the Com- 
merce Club, the Classical Club, and the others. , 

The suggestion has been made that this opening talk of the 
series might well sketch the history, purpose, and plans of the 
institution. However, the brief time available will permit only 
an inadequate statement. Chartered by special act of the Indiana 
Legislature in 1849, as North Western Christian University, a name 
subsequently changed to Butler University, the institution opened 
its doors to students on November 1, 1855, and graduated its first 
class the following year. The college of liberal arts has had an 
uninterrupted existence from that time to the present hour. 

The purpose and scope of the institution are declared by the 
charter to be, ' ' To establish, found, and build up, maintain, sustain, 
and perpetuate at or in the vicinity of Indianapolis, in the state of 
Indiana, an institution of learning of the highest class, for the 
education of the youth of all parts of the United States, and espe- 
cially the states of the Northwest; to establish in said institution 
departments or colleges for the instruction of the students in every 
branch of liberal and professional education; to educate and pre- 
pare suitable teachers for the common schools of the country; to 
teach and inculcate the Christian faith and Christian morality as 
taught in the sacred scriptures, discarding as uninspired and 
without authority all writings, formulas, creeds, and articles of 
faith subsequent thereto; and for the promotion of the sciences 
and arts. ' ' The management of the institution has never lost sight 
of these purposes, and is moving toward their accomplishment as 
rapidly as conditions permit. 


Butler University Radio Talks 235 

The breadth and liberality of the charter provide an ample legal 
basis for the development of a great modern university in the years 
ahead. Free from hampering legal restraints, the future of the 
institution will depend upon the amplitude of its financial support 
and the wisdom of its management. 

At this time Butler University consists of two constituent col- 
leges, Butler College and the College of Religion. Butler College 
is the older and larger of the two. It is primarily a college of 
liberal arts. However, it not only furnishes a general college 
course, but provides for considerable specialization. The depart- 
rflents of Economics and Business Administration, Education, 
Journalism, and Home Economies are embryonic schools still 
organized administratively under the Dean of Butler College. The 
College of Religion has developed out of a former department of 
the older college and holds to its task of training ministers and 
other religious workers. It has its own Dean and Faculty. As is 
the case with Butler College, it is under the control of the Board 
of Directors and the President of Butler University. The Teachers 
College of Indianapolis, the Metropolitan School of Music, and the 
Art School of John Herron Art Institute are affiliated with the 
University in the training of teachers and supervisors, and the 
Indiana Law School and the College of Missions are associated 
with it. 

For twenty years the university has sustained a steady growth 
in numbers and curriculum. The enrollment for the current 
semester is 1,560; 1,094 of these students come from Indianapolis 
and its environs and 398 from other communities in Indiana, 65 
from other states, and 3 from foreign countries. They represent 
23 different religious bodies. They are as cosmopolitan as the com- 
munities from which they come. In addition to these, 410 attended 
the summer session and more than 500 city school teachers are now 
carrying part time evening courses with us while teaching. 

A faculty of 70 members, trained in 54 of the colleges and uni- 
versities in this country and abroad, offers instruction in twenty- 
five departments. These departments cover the lines of training 
found in the other standard colleges and universities in the Middle 

236 Butler Alumnal Quarterly 

West. The institution endeavors not only to observe the require- 
ments of sound educational tradition but also to keep a forward 
look and discerningly to accept every real advance in the field of 
higher education. In method and content the courses are 
"standard." The work given in the various departments is in- 
tended to prepare the student for the graduate or professional 
school or for business and in a few departments one year of grad- 
uate work is offered, usually leading to a Master's Degree. 

But not all education is received through formal instruction. 
Much comes through experience and student activities. Aside 
from the twenty fraternities on the campus and the Christian 
associations and literary, debating, oratorical and dramatic organ- 
izations, there are eighteen clubs and societies through which stu- 
dents and faculty members carry on special interests centering in 
their own special fields. These organizations promote and encour- 
age more or less independent study and investigation on the part 
of their members, in this way familiarizing them with the methods 
and materials of research in the fields of their special interests. 
Some of the upper-class students have, through these clubs, made 
really worth while contributions to the work of their departments 
and many have gained a grasp of their subjects which insured a 
greater success in the later graduate or professional career. It is 
through these clubs that these Friday evening programs are made 

The rapid and steady growth of Indianapolis and the constantly 
rising general level of economic well-being of its people resulting 
in an increasing host of high school graduates demanding admis- 
sion to college each year, has forced upon Butler University the 
necessity of making provisions for a larger student body than it 
can at present accommodate. Plans have therefore been made 
looking to the immediate future and preparing the way for the 
generations to come. The first step in the new program was the 
raising of $1,000,000.00 additional endowment to aid in carry- 
ing on the expanding educational program. That having been 
accomplished, a new plant in which to carry on this work became 
the next necessity. For the new grounds and buildings more than 

Butler University Radio Talks 237 

$1,400,000.00 has been secured. The 240-acre Fairview Park has 
already become the new campus and three large buildings are now 
in process of construction there. When completed these buildings 
will give more than double the space the institution now has at 
its disposal. To this beginning must soon be added a College of 
Religion building, a gymnasium and athletic field equipment. At 
no distant day the main administration building, a library and an 
ample assembly hall must be provided. And along with the physi- 
cal plan the endowment must keep pace with the growth of the 
student body. The fact is becoming increasingly apparent to those 
responsible for the management of the institution that the 
$2,500,000.00 raised thus far on the enlargement program will have 
to be more than duplicated in the near future if Butler University 
is to measure up to its responsibility in caring for the higher 
educational needs of this city and this state. Having demonstrated 
her worth through seventy-one years of service and by the char- 
acter of the product which she has given to two generations, there 
can be no doubt that funds will be forthcoming to enable her to 
meet her constantly enlarging obligations. With sufficient funds 
lier future will be assured and her services to an enlarged con- 
stituency, multiplied. From an honorable past and hopeful pres- 
ent she looks cheerfully to the future. 

By H. W. Wiley 

I have had a good deal of experience with small and large uni- 
versities. My first training was in Hanover College, a Presby- 
terian institution, now approaching its one hundredth year, and 
the first church college established in Indiana. 

The beginning of this institution was in the year 1827. At Han- 
over I not only knew every member of the faculty but also prac- 
tically every boy in the college. I feel that by this intimate 
association with my teachers I received a training which it is 
impossible to get in a great university. Among those who trained 
me at Hanover was Doctor John W. Scott, a Presbyterian minister, 
who taught the sciences, chemistry and physics of the physical 
sciences, and botany and zoology of the biological sciences. Doctor 
Scott was a wonderful teacher. He was the father-in-law of Pres- 
ident Benjamin Harrison, I had a training in the classics in this 
small college which I would not have been able to get in a big 
college or university. And the same is true of my training in 

I shall always remember with delight my associations with my 
professors, as well as my fellow students at Hanover in those 
troublesome days of our history, the days of the Civil "War. In 
fact, nearly the whole student body enlisted early in 1864 in the 
United States Army, I among them as a private, in Company I, 
of the 137th Volunteer Infantry of Indiana. 

In contrast to this, I may say that I went to Harvard Univer- 
sity, at that time the largest institution in the United States. There 
I had also the good fortune to make the intimate acquaintance of 
some of my professors, but others whose lectures I attended I never 
met socially or otherwise. In my career at Harvard I never met 
the president of the university. Doctor Charles W. Eliot. He was 

*As Hanover College celebrates its Centennial in June, 1927, it may not be 
inappropriate to call attention of readers of The Quarterly to the article 
which appeared in the issue of January, 1914. 


Advantages of a Small College 239 

then a young man and in the third year of his presidency. I sub- 
sequently had the great good fortune to be well acquainted with 
Doctor Eliot, but not as a student at the institution. 

Another great man whose lectures I attended, and whom I did 
not know personally, was Professor Agassiz. Of the students I 
knew only those with whom I worked in the laboratories, otherwise, 
Harvard was an unknown sea to me. 

After I graduated at Harvard, I attended the great University 
of Berlin, which was even a larger university than Harvard. 
There, the only professor that I knew personally was the professor 
of chemistry, Doctor Hoffmann. I took lectures, however, from a 
number of other eminent men, among them Professor Helmholtz 
whom I never met personally. I was again on an uncharted and un- 
known sea. 

In contrasting the advantages which I had in these two great 
universities with those that I enjoyed at Hanover, I have always 
felt that it was my original training at Hanover which was the 
foundation of all that I ever learned. Perhaps for technical edu- 
cation it is well to go to a great university, but for the foundations 
of a liberal education, in my opinion, the small colleges give the 
ideal opportunity. 

By Frieda P. Haseltine, '16 

To understand the art of the great Dutch masters one must see 
the country in which they lived and painted, for their one inspira- 
tion has been nature, either within the house or in the out-of-doors ; 
their art has been the glorification of the homely and the exaltation 
of the commonplace. 

It was Sunday afternoon when we came into Holland from Ger- 
many and it had been raining. The gloomy landscape and dark- 
cast sky immediately suggested Van Ruisdael to us and the 
windmills crooning their song of peace and contentment brought 
before us his "Mill" picture. Sleek black and white cattle grazing 
in the meadows reminded us of Cuyp, and the water-front with its 
boats, cloud effects and distant church spire, of Van Goyen. 

Through the canals to the picturesque Zuyderzee villages where 
we found the Hollanders as we had always pictured them with 
their wooden shoes, quaint caps, the multi-colored dresses of the 
women and the wide trousers of the men, we were invited to enter 
a Volendam home. 

The sunlight warming the immaculate room where an old woman 
was seated by the window suggested DeHoogh whose pictures are 
characterized by shafts of radiant light. 

The largest art gallery in Holland is the Ryks gallery in Amster- 
dam with its three thousand pictures. Immediately upon entering 
we were directed to Rembrandt's large canvas, "The Night 
Watch," his most famous picture. It occupies a room with a 
painting by Van der Heist, the latter having been painted on order 
of the persons whose portraits appear in the Rembrandt picture. 
Because Rembrandt gave some figures more prominent positions 
on the canvas than others, their jealousy was aroused. The Van 
der Heist figures appear in a practically straight line, each of 
equal importance, which satisfied his customers. 

Sir Joshua Reynolds is said to have given the title, "The Night 
Watch. ' ' The painting is peculiar and no one seems to understand 


The Ryks Gallery 241 

it. It is remarkable for its lights and shades and its rich costume 

"The Syndics" by Rembrandt is more understandable, present- 
ing a meeting of merchants. So life-like are the figures one feels 
an expression of wonderment on their faces at a stranger coming 
into the same room to interrupt their meeting, 

Vermeer of Delft left but few paintings. He was lost sight of 
for several years and only about twenty-five of his pictures have 
been found. Invariably they have a blue and yellow color note. 
"The Cook" is one of his best. 

One is always aware in Gerald Dou's paintings of the artist's 
close attention to detail. He was a pupil of Rembrandt and be- 
cause his work showed his painstaking care he was liked and 
prospered. "The Dutch Cook," "The Store-room," "The Den- 
tist," "The Herring Seller" and "The Poultry Shop" show his 

Franz Halz was Holland's first great portrait painter and he 
was at his best in "The Jester" and "The Jolly Toper." No one 
could depict so well tavern scenes; he painted what he saw and 
left nothing out. 

Low life in tavern and town — usually hilarious — was painted by 
Steen. His subjects were the simple people whom he knew best 
and "The Doctor's Visit" is one of the most striking. 

Although some of Paul Potter's paintings are in the Ryks gal- 
lery, his best known work, ' ' The Bull, " is in the Mauritz House at 
the Hague which we saw a few days later. 

To many Americans making their first trip abroad it comes as 
something of a surprise and disappointment that every Hollander 
does not go down the street with wooden shoes cluttering along 
the cobblestones; that every Dutch woman is not wearing a full 
pleated skirt, bodice and flaring white cap; that every house is 
not built on stilts and that tulips are not blooming in every yard 
and field in mid-summer. 

It is the small towns of Marken, Volendam and other Zeeland 
villages that delight the tourist and provide inspiration for the 
artist. The cities are cosmopolitan and only occasionally does one 

242 Butler Alumnal Quarterly 

see a villager in picturesque costume on the streets. The shops 
allure with their fascinating stocks and one can scarcely resist the 
flower stands with their roses and dahlias, lovelier than one ever 
saw and so surprisingly cheap. 

Impressions gained on my recent visit to Holland have prompted 
me to tell you briefly of this lesser country in the world of Art. 
Holland must be seen to be understood, then you will know why 
my decision is that any artist may find a haven there. 


By Marie George, '24. 

He thinks I'm dainty — flowerlike — 

Ah, he must never know 

How accurately I cast a fly, 

And climb a tree that towers high; 

That I can scale yon garden wall 

Is none of his affair at all. 

Dolls and dishes — small girls' joys — 

Were not for me; I played with boys! 

No, I must never let him guess 

That I know aught but soft caress — 

He thinks I'm dainty — flowerlike. 

— Courtesy of The Ladies' Home Journal, 
January, 1927. 



Published by the Alumni Association of Butler College, Indianapolis. 

Subscription price, two dollars per year. 

Entered as second-class matter, March 26, 1912, at the post office at Indi- 
anapolis, Indiana, under the Act of March 3, 1879. 

Officers of the Alumni Association — President, John F. Mitchell, Jr., '06; 
First Vice-President, Shelley D. Watts, '00; Second Vice-President, Mrs. 
Mary Louise Eagsdale, '17; Treasurer and Business Manager, George A. 
Schumacher, '25; appointees, Howard C. Caldwell, '15 and George A. 
Schumacher, '26. 

Secretary and Editor of the Butler Alumnal Quarterly — Katharine M. 
Graydon, '78. 


The editorial, "Is The Quarterly Worth While," 
which appeared in the October issue of The Butler 
Alumnal Quarterly is one which should challenge 
every son and daughter of Butler University. The 
Quarterly has come to be recognized as one of the most 
valuable assets of Butler. Why it has been so slightly 
supported, is hard to imagine. 

That something should be done is apparent ! Grad- 
uates and old students should get on the subscription 
list without delay. Present subscribers ought to urge 
their friends to support The Quarterly. The admin- 
istration of Butler should lend aid in some substantial 

In order to convince the readers of this letter (for a 
request accompanied this letter that it be published in 
the January Quarterly) that this be not considered idle 
talk or insignificant sentiment, the writer wishes to con- 
tribute twenty-five dollars to the treasurer of the Alumni 
Association of Butler University for The Quarterly. 

No donations ever seem to be made to The Quarterly 
and how it has continued as a publication these years 
with so little support seems very much of a mystery. 

It is urgent that the present efficient editor and busi- 
ness manager, both of whom are rendering a most un- 
selfish and apparently unthankful service to their Alma 
Mater, be encouraged and supported in their important 


244 Butler Alumnal Quarterly 

work. As a challenge to Butler alumni, the writer will 
give an additional twenty -five dollars to The Quarterly, 
if in the April issue, four additional gifts of twenty-five 
dollars or more are reported. 

What would a great University on the new campus at 
Fairview be without The Quarterly! Now is the time 
for our alumni to show whether or not they have any of 
the true blue of our sacred blue and white of our insti- 
tution. Are there not four alumni or ex-students of 
Butler loyal enough to accept this challenge? 




Alumni organizations in American colleges have been assuming 
a new role in recent years, the significance of which seems not 
fully appreciated. Following the developments through the last 
five years one is astonished at the rising tide of idealism manifested 
in the highly organized bodies known as alumni associations and 
the efficiency resulting therefrom. 

The Alumni Association for Accomplishment, is the present- 
day slogan! To this end, Yale, Columbia and the University 
of California have taken purposeful lead. These institutions 
and many others have conceived the idea of organizing into 
an Alumni Fund Association, thus allowing all contribu- 
tions to their University to go in through a pledge card system. 
Such system is business-like and convenient for the alumnus, allow- 
ing him to state his desired contribution, relieving him of different 
and numerous appeals from the alumni office, and at the same time 
permitting him to withdraw at the close of any year. 

This method we wish to see launched into Butler Alumni man- 
agement. The alumni of our University are asked for very little 
financial expression of loyalty to their Alma Mater — no college of 
the country asks of its sons and daughters for less — their annual 
alumni dues of two dollars and a voluntary contribution for the 
maintenance of the Alumni Scholarship Fund; the former 

A New Idea in Alumni Affairs 245 

for the support of The Quarterly, the latter for the bestowing of a 
scholarship upon one or more worthy and appreciative students. 

The financing of The Butler Alumnal Quarterly is the per- 
petual concern of those who have the management in charge. A 
system of advertisements should meet largely the expense of the 
publication, but right here lies the difficulty — our small mailing 
list. We are not a missionary body appealing to business men for 
a gift of their notices, but an independent, self-respecting ex- 
pression of our Alma Mater — a voice speaking of interests at home 
to children afar; a quarterly letter from the campus. Were it 
possible to arrive at the minimum of one thousand paid subscribers, 
The Quarterly would henceforth be self-supporting. Is it too 
much to ask each alumnus to lend his assistance in boosting the 
number of paid readers of the magazine ? 

The New Idea of the past year lies in the Intercollegiate 
Alumni Hotel Scheme. 

Eighty college and university alumni associations of America 
have cooperated in some forty outstanding centers of America. At 
these hotels will be found everything planned for the convenience 
and comfort of the college man. Here the alumnus of each of these 
colleges will find on file his own alumni magazine and a list of his 
own college alumni living in the immediate locality served by the 
hotel. He will find the alumni atmosphere carried throughout. 
This service will be unusually pleasing, and undoubtedly local 
alumni spirit will be greatly forwarded by this movement. 

In California, where the plan has been in operation for three 
years, it has been found to be eminently successful. The inter- 
collegiate alumni hotel idea came into being from a very definite 
need. The growth of travel by automobile combined with the 
gigantic growth in numbers of university and college men has 
brought to light the necessity for some place to which the visiting 
alumnus may go when in a strange city to find the names and 
addresses of his fellow alumni living in the community. It was 
formerly the policy of the University of California Alumni Associ- 
ation, for instance, to have the president or secretary of the local 
alumni club keep on file these names and addresses. Often, how- 

246 Butler Alumnal Quarterly 

ever, when the list was most desired the local president or sec- 
retary could not be found, so by keeping an accurate list on file at 
a prominent hotel this list became available at all hours of the 
day and night, and consequently it has resulted that a new means 
has been found whereby alumni spirit can be engendered and en- 
couraged in centers distant from the immediate influence of the 

In no way does the establishment of an alumni hotel headquar- 
ters in the local centers interfere with the local university club. 
The university club is exclusive in its membership; the Intercol- 
legiate Alumni Hotel is non-exclusive. It forms headquarters for 
the transient, the man who is in and out of town, and for the man 
who is in town for only a few hours. 

Full and complete data will be given concerning this nation- 
wide movement in a four-page announcement that will appear in 
each of the participating alumni magazines this month. 

In this four-page advertisement lies a financial advantage. The 
Alumni Secretary is desirous of announcing that the Claypool or 
some standard hotel of Indianapolis has been added to the list of the 
eighty Intercollegiate Alumni Hotels, that thereby the two- 
fold reward may be attained : drawing our alumni closer and 
receiving the enlarged revenue of the advertisement. But this latter 
consideration may not be until the paid subscription list has 
arrived at the minimum mark of one thousand. 


As the new year opens the City Office is able to report that the 
basements for the first three buildings to be erected at Fairview 
Park are finished ; the foundations are in for two and work on the 
third is nearing completion. The first unit includes the Arthur 
Jordan Memorial Hall, a science building and a general recitation 
building. These will cost a total of $1,100,000, all of which is in 
hand. Provision is being made to house 2,000 students. 

The annual report of John W. Atherton, financial secretary of 
Butler, shows that the assets of the University have been increased 

From the City Office 247 

during the last five years from $780,000 to $3,750,000. Collections 
during the year have amounted to $720,000. Interest on various 
funds have provided more than enough money to carry on the 
promotional work and every cent of the original gifts, to endow- 
ment or building funds, will be used for the purposes specified 
by the donors. The interest in excess of overhead costs during the 
last year has amounted to more than $20,000. 

Butler -^as represented at the annual international convention 
of the Disciples of Christ at Memphis. At the banquet given in 
connection with the convention, Doctor Frederick D. Kershner, 
dean of the Butler College of Religion, acted as toastmaster. Mr. 
Atherton was the chief speaker and displayed drawings made by 
the architects who are planning the new Butler buildings. Mr. 
Atherton paid a tribute to "William G. Irwin, of Columbus, one of 
the largest donors to the Butler funds and chairman of the general 
campaign committee. Mr. Irwin was present and the audience 
stood to cheer him during Mr. Atherton 's remarks. Dean Kersh- 
ner was a member of several of the more important committees 
that functioned during the convention. 

Representatives of Butler at the Memphis meeting were impressed 
by the manner in which delegates from all over the country recog- 
nized Butler as the outstanding school of the church in America. 

Mr. and Mrs. Mark H. Brown, ex- '06, and Mrs. Mary 'Haver 
Ousley, '19, of Memphis, gave dinners in honor of the Butler rep- 
resentatives at the convention. 

In the death of Walter E. Smith, of Indianapolis, Butler lost one 
of its strongest supporters. It was largely through his efforts that 
the Butler band was organized and provided with uniforms. Mr. 
Smith had given financial assistance to Butler students for many 

During the quarter the reorganized board of directors has been 
functioning. R. A. Long, of Kansas City, widely known as one 
of the most influential members of the church, promises to be a 
most valuable addition to the board. He attended the convention 
at Memphis, as did Mr. Irwin, Mr. Atherton and C. L. Goodwin, 
of Greensburg, Pa., aU members of the board. 

248 Butler Alumnal Quarterly 


A gift of $5,000 to the College of Religion made by W. L. Powell 
of Lebanon, Indiana, has been announced. 

* * * * 

The College of Religion was represented at the Memphis Con- 
vention by three members of the faculty and twelve students. The 
faculty representatives were Professor Hoover, Professor Bruce 
Kershner, and Professor F. D. Kershner. The student represen- 
tatives were Messrs. E. G. Aubrey, Thomas J. Bennett, O. T, Ander- 
son, Kenneth Parsons, Frank Hopper, Frank Messersmith, A. T. 
DeGroot, Carlos C. Boaz, Alfred E. Poe, Herschel Reed, Allan 
Knapp, and Cyrus Herod. Mr, DeGroot represented Butler at the 
Youth Convention, speaking on "The Indigneous Church," and 
also spoke before the International Convention at its Saturday 
evening session. Mr. Frank Hopper led the singing for the Youth 
Convention throughout. Dean Kerschner acted as a member of 
the Committee on Recommendations, and was appointed on the 
Committee of Fifteen to arrange for the observance of Pentecost 
in 1930. 

* * * # 

Mr. H. H. Halley completed his "Scripture Readings" the third 
week in November. He made a profound impression upon the 
student body and friends of the institution during the six weeks 
he was here. He is one of the most popular lecturers who have 
appeared on our platforms. The last week in October Mr. John R. 
Golden, of Decatur, 111., gave four addresses on "The Work of the 
Disciples in the Orient," "Christian Union in the Orient," "The 
Indigenous Church, ' ' and ' ' The Call of the Orient. ' ' The speaker 
was exceedingly frank in his statements, and was listened to with 
much attention by the audiences which heard him. On November 
23 and 24 Guy P, Leavitt, editor of "The Lookout," gave two 
informing and inspiring addresses on "The Church Paper" and 
"The Psychology of Advertising," He was followed the week 
after Thanksgiving by Harry Munro, of the Religious Education 
Department of the Christian Board of Publication, who gave four 

College of Religion 249 

excellent addresses upon the educational problems of the church. 
Professor Talbert F. Revis, of the Department of Romance Lan- 
guages of Butler College, spoke during the week of November 2-5 
on the general subject of problems of Latin America. He dis- 
cussed these problems in a thoroughly interesting and penetrating 

• * * « 

Beginning on Wednesday, December 8, Dr. W. A. Shullenberger, 
of the Central Christian Church of Indianapolis, instituted his 
series of lectures on the problems of the city church. This series 
will be given on Wednesdays of each week throughout the re- 
mainder of the school year. Beginning on Thursday, December 9, 
Dr. Thomas W. Grafton, of the Third Christian Church, Indi- 
anapolis, began a similar series on the practical problems of 
the ministry which will continue each Thursday throughout the 
present semester and the greater part of the semester which fol- 


Dr. Robert J. Aley represented Butler University at the inau- 
guration on December 3 of the new president of Wabash College, 
Dr. Louis Bertram Hopkins. 

Professor Ray C. Friesner, head of the Department of Botany, 
was reelected secretary of the Indiana Academy of Science at the 
annual meeting held in December at the Ball Teachers' College, 

In mentioning in our last issue the names of new members of the 
faculty that of Mr. Scott was inadvertently omitted. Mr. R. H. 
Scott from the University of Chicago is instructor in the Depart- 
ment of Economics. 

A. B. Carlisle, associate professor in the Department of Educa- 
tion, received his doctor of philosophy degree from the University 
of Wisconsin during his vacation. His thesis for his degree was 
"Compulsory Attendance Laws and Their Development in the 

250 Butler Alumnal Quarterly 

United States." Before coming to Butler last September he was an 
assistant in the University of Wisconsin. Mr. Carlisle did his 
undergraduate work at Emporia (Kans.) State Teachers College. 

A series of Butler Radio Talks under auspices of the Chemistry- 
Club has just been broadcast from the WFBM station on suc- 
cessive Friday evenings. The first by Dean Putnam has been given 
elsewhere in this issue. Others following were by Professor Jor- 
dan, Dr. Jensen, Dr. Shadinger, Miss Schulmeyer, and Mr. Stanley 

The portrait of Miss Catharine Merrill, which for three years 
has graced the College walls, creating an atmosphere in Room 11, 
was in the loan exhibit during the month of December at the John 
Herron Art Institute of the work of Theodore C. Steele. In no 
form of his portraiture did the artist surpass this lovely picture of 
Miss Merrill in drawing or in color or in spiritual expression. It 
is gratifying to hear student appreciation of 

"The countenance in which did meet 
Sweet records, promises as sweet." 

One of the older fraternities has decided to do all in its power 
to improve the scholarship of its men. It proposes to require its 
freshmen to make an average of "C" or better before being 
eligible for initiation. If at any time a pledge falls below an 
average of " C " he is deprived of his pin until he comes up to the 
required grade. The organization proposes to bring all the pressure 
possible upon its members mediocre in their work. If the present 
experiment is successful, other organizations will probably follow. 
This movement is heartily in accord with the faculty. 

There has appeared in the chapel a beautiful new Knabe Grand 
piano, for which the Women's League has been working since Sep- 
tember, 1925. 

While credit for originating and agitating plans for a new 
chapel piano belongs to the Woman's League and its committee in 
charge of the enterprise, nevertheless, the accomplishment could 
never have been attained in so short a time, had it not been for the 
enthusiasm and generosity of friends of the College. 

Around the Campus 251 

President Aley immediately encouraged the enterprise ; the class 
of 1926 contributed to the fund ; Mr. John Atherton became at once 
an ardent advocate of putting the plans through; Dr. Alexander 
Jameson took up the good work and arranged for the most liberal 
terms and prompt delivery; Mr. Arthur Jordan, a liberal bene- 
factor of the College and a member of the board of directors, be- 
came interested and generously offered to pay one-half the cost of 
the instrument. This made it possible to get the piano at once. 
Mr. Jordan has given much to Butler. His earliest gift was $25,000, 
and his later gift of $350,000 made it possible to start building at 
Fairview; but this kindly help in a student enterprise makes the 
name and interest and personality of our friend more real to us 
than his bigger gifts. 

A new organization has appeared on the campus in the form of 
the University Club. One might feel the College to be surfeited 
with clubs and sororities of one kind and another; yet there has 
long been a real need of the gathering of young women 
not affiliated with the Greek letter societies, and a strong 
influential activity awaits it. The fact that it has an open member- 
ship, a definitely outlined social character and a name, "The 
University Club," gives evidence of the high ideal of college life 
for which it stands. Miss Irene Bowers, '28, has been elected 
president, under whose leadership sixty animated enthusiastic 
charter members ought to accomplish genuine things. The 
Quarterly greets with enthusiasm the launching of this new enter- 
prise and wishes it well in all its ways. The Women 's Faculty Club 
entertained on December 1 the new club at dinner in the College 

The Directory and Handbook of the students for 1926-1927, 
published annually by the Y. W. C. A. and the Student Budget, 
was distributed before the Christmas recess. The Directory is one 
of the most complete j^et published. 

The contents contain a greeting from Dr. Aley, general infor- 
mation for students concerning the administration of the univer- 
sity, the alphabetical list of students and a brief report of every 

252 Butler Alumnal Quabterlt 

organization and activity on the campus. Space is provided for 
the insertion of names of second semester students. 

The Directory was edited by Irene Bowers and Louise Frisbie, 

The dean of women has appointed a faculty representative as 
friend or "ally" of each sorority. The appointments are as fol- 

Alpha Delta Pi Mrs, Wesenberg 

Alpha Delta Theta Miss Wilhite 

Delta Delta Delta Mrs. Bruner 

Delta Gamma Mrs. Ratti 

Delta Zeta .' . .Mrs. Beeler 

Kappa Alpha Theta Miss Cotton 

Kappa Kappa Gamma Mrs. Shadinger 

Kappa Phi Mrs. Putnam 

Pi Beta Phi Mrs. Richardson 

Zeta Tau Alpha Miss Weaver 

Alpha Chi Omega Miss Graydon 

Mrs. Thor. G. Wesenberg of the English Department has been 
appointed for the current year general chairman of the Indi- 
anapolis branch of the American Association of University Women. 
The scholarship of Mrs. Wesenberg, through her writings and 
talks, has been recognized. Last January she wrote an article in 
correspondence of the New Republic protesting the emphasis of a 
review of Gumming 's poetry. Among her other works are: ''Soli- 
taire, ' ' a poem which appeared in Voices, a New York publication ; 
' ' Amy Lowell 's Keats, ' ' a sonnet published in the American Poetry 
Magazine, "In Praise of Wakefulness," a sonnet published in the 
American Poetry Magazine; and with Professor Thor. G. Wesen- 
berg she wrote ' ' Times That Have Been, ' * translation from Spanish 
of Rosalia de Castro, published in the Gypsy, and "Anti-Crusade, 
A Twelfth Century Idyl, "' translation from the Provencal of Mar- 
cabrum, published in the Stratford Magazine. 

Included in the addresses recently delivered by Mrs. Wesenberg 
have been "Amy Lowell's Life of Keats," "Some Spanish 
Women," and "Emily Dickinson." 

Around the Campus 253 

During the past summer Professor and Mrs. Wesenberg were 
abroad. Besides visiting the places of interest in connection with 
the older Spanish literature, the Wesenbergs visited Galicia, the 
province of Rosalia de Castro, the nineteenth century woman poet 
of Spain, in whose works Professor and Mrs. Wesenberg are espe- 
cially interested. 

Last year, the Pan-Hellenic Association under auspices of the 
Women's League, arranged a Melting Pot Bazaar, the proceeds of 
which were to go toward the building fund for the new Woman's 
Building at Fairview. The idea was so successful that it was tried 
again this year with even greater remuneration. It is now the 
plan to make the event a traditionary one at Butler. 

This year the Bazaar was held at the Spink Arms Hotel on 
December 11. Each woman's organization was given a booth in 
the arrangement of which it had a central idea and color. The 
articles were donated, or money was collected and the articles were 
made by certain girls. The kitchen booth, arranged by Alpha Chi 
Omega, won the first prize. It was a large loving cup in the shape 
of a melting pot. Pi Beta Phi, in charge of the candy booth, won 
second place, and Kappa Alpha Theta, in charge of the boudoir 
booth, was awarded third place. The judges were the presidents 
of the Mothers' Clubs of the men's fraternities. 

A dance was held Saturday evening in the Palm Room of the 
Spink Arms Hotel. The proceeds of the dance and the bazaar 
amounted to about $550. 

Professor Friesner, Mr. Palmer and Mr. Cain, of the Botany 
Department, and Professor Bruner, Dr. Pearson and Mr. Weber, 
of the Zoology Department, attended a meeting of the Indi- 
ana Academy of Science at Ball Teachers' College, Muncie, Indiana, 
December 2, 3, and 4. Professor Friesner is Secretary of the 

Mr. Cain read a paper entitled "Air Photography and Ecologi- 
cal Mapping," in which he showed the value of the aeroplane as 
an aid to botanical study in regions not otherwise easily accessible. 
"The Cytology of Gynandromorphic Katydids" was the subject of 

254 Butler Alumnal Quarterly 

an important paper by Dr. Pearson, who has solved the riddle of 
the gynandromorph by means of the microscope. The paper will 
be read before the American Society of Zoologists which meets at 
Philadelphia during the latter part of December. 

For the benefit of the uninitiated it may be said that a gynan- 
dromorph is an abnormal animal which is male on one side of the 
body and female on the other. 

Blue Key, a national honorary upperclassmen 's fraternity, made 
its appearance on November 9, succeeding the Skulls Club founded 
in 1920 by H. 0. Page. The ideals of this national organization 
are for promoting on the campus a closer school spirit between the 
students and supporting any activity which will reflect to the good 
of the institution. Blue Key selects its member^ from outstanding 

The national organization was founded five years ago by B. C. 
Riley at the University of Florida and since that year has estab- 
lished twenty-three chapters throughout the country. Butler has 
the second chapter in the state, Wabash having the first. Blue Key 
is commonly known as "The College Man's Rotary Club." 

Since its appearance. Blue Key has conducted the annual grid- 
iron banquet in honor of the football team. It supervised the 
freshman-sophomore game and scrap, and also conducted the 
annual Butler-Wabash dance. Other activities for the year are 
on the fraternity's program. 

Ralph Hitch, instrumental in establishing the chapter here, has 
been elected president. President Aley, fifteen alumni mem- 
bers of the Skulls Club and twenty-five active members were pres- 
ent at the installation, which took place at the Sigma Chi House. 
A banquet followed at the Phi Delta Theta House. The ritualism 
of the program was conducted by members of the Wabash Chapter 
of Blue Key. 



LIGHT OF MODERN THOUGHT. By Frederick D. Kershner. 
210 pp. St. Louis: The Bethany Press. $1.50. 

From the pen of Professor Frederick D. Kershner, Dean of 
Religion, Butler University, comes a book bearing the title, 
"Horizons of Immortality." The author brings to his task not 
only scholarship and critical insight, but also a human interest that 
will commend the book to the average reader. 

No question has ever so interested and so puzzled the human 
race as the question of immortality. Religion, philosophy and 
science have spent their forces trying to unlock the mysteries of 
the hereafter. Doctor Kershner lays before the reader, in concise 
form, the attempts that have been made in these fields to solve the 
problems involved. In this he displays a range of information that 
leaves nothing to be desired. It seems no authority is left un- 
touched, from the most ancient to the most recent writers. Poets, 
prophets and philosophers share his attention and their contri- 
butions are analyzed and compared with remarkable clearness. 

The greater part of the book is given to the historical presen- 
tation of the subject. In this the author reaches the following 
conclusions : 1. The pre-Christian views once adhering to the 
early Christian concept of immortality must be cast aside and 
much of the Medieval eschatology is disappearing. 2. The Pla- 
tonic doctrine of the inherent immortality of the soul appears to 
be removed from the realm of probability. 3. The present attitude 
of philosophy is not unfavorable to the doctrine of personal immor- 
tality. 4. The testimony of science has neither strengthened nor 
diminished the argument for at least some form of personal sur- 
vival. 5. Efforts to revive Oriental philosophy, under western 
conditions have largely failed. 6. The evidence for spiritualism 
justifies the verdict of "not proven." 7. The belief in immor- 
tality growing out of faith in Jesus Christ, finds nothing in present 
day thought to discredit it. 


256 Butler Alumnal Quarterly 

In the part in which Doctor Kershner offers his own conclu- 
sions, he asserts that the scientific demonstration of immortality 
would be the greatest discovery in the history of the human race; 
as it is, the question remains in the realm of faith. Here the 
eternal hope centers around the following considerations: 

1. Both science and philosophy bear witness to the reality and 
value of personality. This view has also been strengthened by the 
new science known as the psychology of religion. "If personality 
is valuable and there is any meaning in the universe, personality 
must be preserved." 

2. Belief in God and immortality go hand in hand. "If there 
is a moral universe there must be a God and if there is a God 
there must be a hereafter for the human spirit." This God is a 
personal God and not a subjective creation. Such a divine per- 
sonality is nowhere so fully expressed as in the God of the New 
Testament. Faith in the revelation of God in Jesus Christ was 
and is the day-spring of the coming morn, for eternal life is the 
promise of the gospel. 

3. The poet is essentially a seer. The poets, with rare excep- 
tions, bear witness to the belief in immortality. Theirs is the 
authority of inspiration. The truth they offer is first-hand ma- 
terial, while that offered by the logicians is second-hand. "It is 
the difference between genius and talent." The poet speaks as one 
having authority and not as the Scribes who are the critics and the 
dry-as-dust authorities of every kind. 

4. The saints are believers in immortality. The author believes 
that the time will come when personal immortality will be scien- 
tifically demonstrated. Then no longer will aspersions be cast on 
the faithful souls who keep the fires of hope burning. "The great 
value of religion consists in the fact that it enables us to appro- 
priate realities which science can not reach. These realities are of 
supreme importance for the daily ordering of our lives. The con- 
viction of life beyond the grave belongs to this group." 

5. "The gospel conquered the world because it delivered men 
from the fear of death and the power of the grave." The resur- 
rection of Christ is the cornerstone of the gospel. The proofs of 

Publications 257 

the resurrection were not speculative but scientific and practical. 
The first gospel preachers were witnesses of the fact. The corol- 
lary of the resurrection of Christ, was the guarantee of the resur- 
rection of His saints. This gospel of the resurrection was and is 
the hope of the world. 

It must be remembered that for thousands of years the wisest 
men on earth have tried to solve the mysteries of the hereafter. 
Happy is the man who can add one single thought to the solution. 
This the author has more than done. If some of the arguments for 
the conclusions he reaches seem unconvincing, there will yet re- 
main ample rewards for those who read this book. It is another 
worthy attempt to anticipate the dawn "Until the day break and 
the shadows flee away." — B. F. DAILEY, '87. 

Social Theology and the New Theism as conflicting schools of pro- 
gressive Religious Thought. By Daniel S. Robinson. 233 pp. New 
York: D. Appleton & Co. $2. 

Of the above volume the New York Times says : 

"Being by training and occupation a professor of philosophy, 
Mr. Robinson, who is at present a member of the Faculty of Miami 
"University, has written a book about present-day religious beliefs, 
discussions and tendencies that is as keen and searching in its 
analysis and as little tinged with sentiment as an argument con- 
cerning the fourth dimension. His viewpoint is that of the Chris- 
tian believer, although his belief might vary widely from that of 
some other Christians more concerned with dogmas than with life. 

"The Christian consciousness [he says in his preface] is more 
real than any or all of the theological systems and interpretations 
which it fabricates. . . . The history of Christian doctrine proves 
that, just as the snake in growing a new skin sloughs off the old, so 
the Christian consciousness picks its way forward through every 
narrowing and imprisoning theological construction, breaking its 
adhesive power and sloughing it off into desuetude. 

"As he faces his subject Professor Robinson sees first the vary- 
ing types of contemporary theology and investigates the relation 
between them and science, and then passes on to the controversy 

258 Butler Alumnal Quarterly 

between the Modernists and the Fundamentalists. He goes rather 
deeply into this matter, suggesting a psychological explanation that 
seems to apply also to an even wider expanse of ideas and sources 
of controversy. He shows that there is a cleavage on the liberal 
side of this argument and makes a discriminating analysis of the 
points of difference between the meliorists, whose social phi- 
losophy aims at the betterment of mankind here on earth, and the 
believers in the new theism, who while adopting the evolutionary 
social philosophy of the meliorists interpret it in a way to avoid 
its atheistic implications, who do not surrender their belief "that 
man's spiritual life is but a fragment of the spiritual life of the 
universe." Other subjects with which Professor Robinson deals 
are the problem of evil, the attempts that have been made to solve 
it and the view of it taken by liberal religious thought, the doctrine 
of God and its modern interpretation, and the doctrine of a future 
life, its significance to Christianity and its root in inner experi- 

The book offers a comprehensive, philosophical survey of what 
is perhaps the most deeply rooted and the most widely debated 
controversy of modern life. The treatment is sympathetic but 
logical, and the volume ought to bring illumination of these ques- 
tions and tendencies to many who are perplexed by them." 

The Outlook of November 3 comments thus upon Dr. Randall's 
recent book: 

James G. Randall. D. Appleton & Co., New York. $4. 

It is a singular thing that the public has had to wait sixty years 
for an adequate treatment of the Constitutional issues involved in 
the conduct of the Civil War. This learned, judicial, and carefuUy 
executed performance answers every demand that can reasonably 
be made upon it. The matter of war powers. Presidential and Con- 
gressional, the defining and punishing of treason and sedition, the 
exercise of the draft, the relations of the Government and the 
States — all these and every other issue having to do with the 
fundamental law are treated. The book is no treatise on tech- 
nicalities; it is a narration, lively and colorful, of what happened 

Publications 259 

under these various categories, with a constant reference to their 
legalistic aspect and to the disputes that raged over each Govern- 
mental act. The Constitution was widely stretched under the 
pressure of a life-and-death struggle for the maintenance of the 
Union. There were those who would have stretched it further, and 
others — not a few of them sympathizers with the Confederacy — 
who would have stretched it not at all. Though Lincoln assumed 
powers greater than those assumed by any other President, and 
thereby came to be denounced as an "unlimited despot," a judicial 
review of his rulership shows that he never abused his powers, 
"except," as Colonel Ingersoll once said, "on the side of mercy." 
What the author finds as perhaps the two most significant facts of 
the Lincoln Administration is the wide extent of the war powers 
and "the manner in which the men in authority were controlled 
by the American people's sense of constitutional government." 

The latter two authors are Butler men, Mr. Robinson grad- 
uating with the class of 1910, and Mr. Randall with that of 1903. 
Mr. Robinson is Professor of Philosophy in Miami University, Ohio ; 
Mr. Randall is in the Department of History of the University of 
Illinois. Both are sons held in high esteem by their Alma Mater. 


Miss Elizabeth Dawson has received one of the first high school 
prizes oifered by the American Chemical Society for an essay 
upon the subject of "The Relation of Chemistry to the Enrich- 
ment of Life." This paper won for her a four-year scholarship 
to any school in the country she may wish to attend, in addition to 
$500 a year for four years. 

Miss Dawson is a member of the freshman class, having entered 
from the Indianapolis Technical High School. It will be recalled 
that one of the college prizes of $1,000 was received last year by 
Miss Janet Rioch of the senior class. 


With six letter men and a host of promising sophomore material 
available, prospects for a winning basketball team were exceed- 
ingly bright to Coach Paul D. Hinkle when he took charge of the 
net snipers following the close of the grid season. In the first 
encounter of the year, the Bulldogs turned back the Central Nor- 
mal five of Danville, conquerors of Franklin, by a 28 to 24 score. 
The showing of the Bulldogs in this game clearly convinced the 
most pessimistic Blue and White fan that a good year was in store 
for Captain Wakefield and his colleagues. 

Captain Wakefield, all-state center last year, should be the main- 
spring of the Bulldog offensive. Wakefield may work at forward 
this year with Holz, a letter man of last season, jumping at center. 
Clarence Christopher, a letter man of two years ago, returned to 
school this fall and will be a fixture in the Bulldog net machine. 
Archie Chadd is the same little Archie of a year ago, and will 
surely have the floor guard assignment for the year. Chadd is 
fast as a streak, a fine dribbler and a good shot. Summers is 
another star of last year's team and will see considerable service 
at the back guard position. "Dog" is a guard of no mean ability. 
Jackman is the remaining letterman of the club. He is a pinch 
hitter of the highest quality. He is the long shot artist of the 
team, and pulled several games out of the fire last year by his 
long range bombardment. 

Some of of the celebrities from Coach Hinkle 's freshman team 
of last year are White of Mooreland, Chandler of Technical, Bugg 
of Bainbridge, Fromuth of Ft. Wayne and Stahl of Broad Ripple. 
With such promising sophomores out for the team, competition for 
a steady berth is promised all season. Floyd, a varsity candidate 
from last year, is making a strong bid for the back guard position. 

White is another Chadd in speed, stature and basketball ability. 
He is due for a big year. Chandler is a fine forward and should 
give some of the other varsity candidates a real battle for a berth 
this year. Big Bill Bugg of Bainbridge is a stonewall on the 


Athletics 261 

defense. He has uncanny ability in getting the ball from the 
bank board and smothering opposing forwards under the basket. 
Red Fromuth is a good floor guard. He guards well and is a fine 
shot from the field. Red will be in the line-up a great deal this 
season. Stahl is a clever forward and one that bears watching. 

The following schedule in addition to the Central Normal and 
Chicago games have been scheduled by Coach Hinkle : 

January 7 — Evansville at Indianapolis. 
January 10 — Marquette at Indianapolis. 
January 14 — Michigan State at Indianapolis. 
January 19 — DePauw at Greencastle. 
January 29 — Iowa at Iowa City. 
January 31 — Michigan State at Lansing. 
February 1 — Kalamazoo at Kalamazoo. 
February 2 — Illinois at Urbana. 
February 4 — Franklin at Indianapolis. 
February 5 — Evansville at Evansville. 
February 10 — "Wabash at Indianapolis. 
February 17 — DePauw at Indianapolis. 
February 19 — Marquette at Milwaukee. 
February 24 — Franklin at Franklin. 
March 1 — Wabash at CrawfordsviUe. 


At the last meeting of the Executive Committee of the Alumni 
Association decision was made to hold a monthly luncheon meeting. 

These meetings will be open to all men, women and former 
students of Butler College to discuss matters relative to the 
association and to promote pleasant fellowship. It is hoped that 
large numbers of the alumni will be present. COME OUT ! You 
have to eat somewhere, why not once a month be a student again 
and enjoy your old mates and teachers. 

At the meeting the Commencement program so far as it relates 
to the alumni was discussed, and a report will be made later. As 

262 Butler Alumnal Quarterly 

next Commencement may be the last held on the old campus, it is 
urged that as many alumni as possible plan now to be present and 
make it such a reunion as the Old School has never seen. 

The committee holds the great desirability of establishing re- 
gional alumni clubs, and bespeaks the interest of the alumni in this 
enterprise. A gathering of old Butler students at least once a year 
in some central place as New York, Washington, Kokomo, Green- 
field, Columbus, Vincennes, Muncie, and others could easily be 
made delightful and beneficial. If other colleges in the country 
can promote such happy reunions, WHY NOT BUTLER? Chi- 
cago has taken the lead in this enterprise, and it is hoped before 
this academic year has closed many other regions will have fol- 
lowed in her train. 


On Saturday noon preceding the Butler-Wabash football clash 
(this year November 6) occurred the annual reunion and luncheon 
of the Butler College Monogram Association. This organization 
had its origin during the coachship of Cullen Thomas and ad- 
mitted to its membership all letter men of the College. During the 
World War nearly all of its members were in service, so the meet- 
ings were discontinued until 1920 when the boys had come back. 
The purpose of this organization is to keep alive old friendships 
and traditions, and to talk over again the never-forgotten battles 
of years ago, as well as to assist in any way possible the present 
teams and coaching staff. 

This year the meeting was held in the Lincoln Hotel and was 
well attended. "Cully" Thomas was present and again told the 
boys he hoped always to be present on these occasions. To him the 
boys presented as an expression of affectionate appreciation a gold 
football. Short talks were made, and with "nine rahs for the 
team," the members adjourned for Irwin Field. 

Among those present were : Cullen Thomas, Albert Tucker, 
Ralph Bruner, Emmett Staggs, Earl T. Bonham, Louis Kirkhoff, 

Alumni 263 

Leslie Fleck, Ashton Wood, M. J. Woods, Lewis Woods, Charles 
Karabell, Morty Frankfort, Joseph Mullane, Harry B. Perkins, 
Jake Seyfried, Clarence Burkhardt, Ralph Agnew, Henry Brown- 
ing, Harold Dailey, Ralph Tapscott, Bruce Baker, Ralph Batton, 
John W. Hutchings, Xerxes Silver, Ralph Strickland, Glenn Cruse. 


The alumni office is without knowledge of the address of the 
following graduates. Definite information will be gratefully re- 
ceived by the alumni secretary. William V. Nelson, '12; Modeste 
P. Capiel, '15 ; Remberto A. Hermandez, '15 ; Clarence Blackford, 
'18 ; Wyatt C. Strickler, '21 ; John Orus Malott, '21 ; Chalmers L. 
McGaughey, '21 ; Mrs. Libbie Abson Steadman, '21 ; Roy S. Julian, 
'23 ; Ralph Howard Beabout, '23 ; H. Harold Walter, '23 ; William 
A. Thomas, '24 ; Helen Elizabeth Palenius, '25 ; Elizabeth Waters, 
'07 : Howard H. Burkher, '24. 


Saturday, February the fifth 

Postmaster-General New, Butler Man, Speaker 
of the Day 

Make plans now to be present in the morning at the 
College. In the evening at the Claypool Hotel. 


Allen H. Lloyd, '12, and Mrs. Lloyd, '13, have taken up resi- 
dence in Seattle, Washington. 

John A. Young, '25, is teaching English in the New Mexico 
Military Institute at Roswell. 

Miss Irene Seuel, '25, returned from the Johns Hopkins Uni- 
versity for the Christmas holidays. 

The Butler Alumni Literary Club held its holiday meeting 
at the home of Mrs. Ruth Cunningham Kirkhoff, '15. 

Dean Evelyn M. Butler spent the Christmas holidays in St. 
Augustine, Florida, the guest of her aunt, Mrs. David 0. Thomas. 

Mr. and Mrs. Allin K. IngaUs (Lorene W. Whitham, '26) have 
returned to their home in Chicago from a four months' tour in 

Rev. T. W. Grafton, '80, has resigned from a fifteen years' pas- 
torate of the Third Christian Church, Indianapolis, to take effect 
March 1, 1927. 

Jabez Hall Wood, '26, came to his home in Irvington for the 
holidays from Harvard, where he is working in the School of 
Business Administration. 

On the evening of December 14 Hilton U. Brown, '80, addressed 
in the College the International Relations Club and their friends 
upon the topic, "Russia and Her Neighbors." 

John F. Mitchell, '06, president of the Alumni Association, and 
Mrs. Mitchell entertained at dinner at their home in Greenfield on 
November 29 the alumni executive committee. 

Mrs. John S. Wright (Letta Newcomb, '92) was hostess on De- 
cember 4 to the Friendship Circle. These occasional gatherings of 
friends who centered about Miss Noble are happy events to all the 

Lewis Levy, ex- '26, has received the honor scholarship from the 
School of Commerce and Administration of the University of 

Personal Mention 265 

Chicago. The award was one of six offered for excellent work in 
the field of business administration. 

Garrison Winders, ex- '18, formerly state supervisor for the Mis- 
souri State Life and who traveled over the state in the interest of 
his company while in that capacity, has been located in Indianapo- 
lis permanently, where he will do special work for the company's 
educational bureau. 

Miss Lola Carver, former student, represented Butler Univer- 
sity at the inauguration of Dr. Arnold Bennett Hall, as president 
of the University of Oregon. The event celebrated, also, the 
fiftieth anniversary of the founding of the university, for which 
a full rich program was carried out. Miss Carver is living in 
Salem, Oregon. 

Miss Maurine Watkins, '19, is author of the play, "Chicago," 
scheduled to make its appearance soon on Broadway. Miss Watkins 
formerly held a position on the staff of the Chicago Tribune, and 
while serving as a reporter she covered one angle of the Loeb- 
Leopold trial. While in Chicago she met Leo Ditrichstein and 
wrote a play for him which was never produced. She went to New 
York two years ago and while there she wrote the play ' ' Chicago, ' ' 
Much of the material used in writing the play was taken from 
observations of the Loeb-Leopold trial. 

There is quite a Butler colony in the Ball Teachers' College, 
Muncie. Mary C, Pavey, '12, is associate professor of English, in 
which department is also Laura Benedict, '05. Helen Jackson, '19, 
is professor of French. The husband of Katherine Gawne Edwards, 
'13, is assistant professor of mathematics, while Barcus Tichenor, 
'10, is head librarian. Miss Tichenor last spring laid the corner- 
stone of the beautiful new library, which is now nearing com- 
pletion and will probably be dedicated in January. 

At the November meeting of the Art League of Crawfordsville, 
held in the home of Mrs. A. L. Loop, Fred G. Domroese, '06, reg- 
istrar and professor of German at Wabash College, sketched the 
life and work of the Swedish artist, Anders Zorn, The speaker's 
introduction was a personal appreciation of the artist in which 

266 Butler Alumnal Quarterly 

he told how the artist had affected his own artistic development. 
This was followed by a sketch of the artist's boyhood, his appren- 
ticeship with its struggles, his successes, his visits to England, 
France, Mediterranean lands, and America, and his frequent re- 
turns to his home in the region of Lake Syljan, Sweden. Professor 
Domroese told of the genius of the artist as displayed in his water 
colors, oils and etchings, and illustrated the artist's work with 
reproductions. He called attention to the water effects, waves and 
reflections and the handling of light. Professor Domroese said that 
in order to keep a record of his oil paintings the artist would re- 
produce them in the form of etchings. He closed his talk with a 
number of anecdotes about Zorn when he was in Chicago at the 
time of the World's Fair. 

A recent letter from David Rioch, '98, in India, has been re- 
ceived : "It was in 1892 that I first entered Butler and I bless 
that day, for I received there more than I can ever tell. The 
most of the instruction has been forgotten, but the influence of 
Demarchus Brown, Scot Butler, Professor Thrasher and the 
others has always been with me, and these influences have come 
on down to our children, 

Mrs. Rioch and I have just gone through the hottest Hot Season 
and most trying we have ever endured. It is now the Rainy 
Season and India is in her glory with her wondrous variety of 
greens. This is the time to really see India but for no other 
reason. It is the time of every creeping, crawling, and flying 
creature from whom it is next to impossible to escape. Some of 
these gliding creatures give one anything but a pleasurable sen- 

"The other evening just after dark it being warm three of us 
were sitting just where the light from the lamp fell when right 
between us the glistening back of a huge cobra was seen gliding 
within six inches of our feet. In a minute its gliding, glistening 
days were past. Then next evening at our back door another was 
found just entering the house. It was dealt with in as speedy 
manner as possible. Then the second day after a commotion was 
heard in our yard, a flock of small birds flying low over something 

Marriages 267 

and chattering away as if they desired the world should know 
a cobra was gliding through the grass. He disappeared down a 
hole but our boys with pick and hoe were soon after him. Sud- 
denly a pick sank into a hole and out shot Mr. Cobra, but my 
shot-gun cut him in three pieces before he knew what had happened. 
So in the Rainy Season with snakes and scorpions it is well to be 
reasonably watchful and careful. However, not quite so much so 
as you poor folks in America have to be before you step off the 

"I fear when we come back to Irvington again it will seem very 
lonesome without Butler and her students making things lively. 
However, it will be wonderful to see her growth in that beautiful 


Glendening-Malott — On October 26 were married in Indi- 
anapolis Dr. John Lincoln Glendening, ex- '15, and Miss Macy Anna 
Malott. Dr. and Mrs. Glendening are at home in Indianapolis. 

Insley-Wishard — On January 1 were married in Irvington Mr. 
Francis H. Insley and Miss Lois E. Wishard, '25. Mr. and Mrs. 
Insley are at home in Irvington. 

Mannon-Moorhead — On November 11 were married in Indi- 
anapolis Mr. Warren K. Mannon and Miss Virginia Moorhead, '22. 
Mr. and Mrs. Mannon are at home in Indianapolis. 

Mercer-Stevens — On November 16 were married in Indianapo- 
lis Mr. Harold Leslie Mercer and Miss Helen Louise Stevens, '26. 
Mr. and Mrs. Mercer are at home in Indianapolis. 

Wirick-Pleece — On October 28 were married in Tampa, Flor- 
ida, Mr. Charles J. Wirick and Miss Pauline Fleece, ex- '24. Mr. 
and Mrs. Wirick are at home in Tampa. 

Wood-Brewer — On November 22 were married in Indianapolis 
Mr. Lewis Wood, ex- '22 and Miss Nellie Brewer, ex- '24. Mr. and 
Mrs. Wood are at home in Indianapolis. 

268 Butler Alumnal Quarterly 


Campbell — To Mr. and Mrs. Leland Campbell (Mary Southwick, 
ex- '17) on November 19, in Benton, Arkansas, twins — Francis and 

DuNKEL — To Mr. and Mrs. Wilbur Dunkel (Georgia Osborn, 
'25) in Rochester, New York, on November 13, a daughter. 

Hanson — To Mr. and Mrs. Samuel Carlton Hanson (Esther 
Murphy, '18) on November 8, a son — Samuel Carlton, Jr. 

Meyer — To Mr. and Mrs. Elmer Meyer (Gwyneth Harry, '14) 
on November 23, in Chicago, a son — John Edward. 


Mackey — Rebecca Daugherty, '25, wife of Maurice C. Mackey, 
died in Indianapolis on October 29 and was buried from her 
mother's home on November 1 in Crown Hill cemetery. 

Rebecca Daugherty, daughter of Major W. W. Daugherty, '61, 
and sister of Miss Maria M. Daugherty, '22, was married to Maurice 
Mackey on June 22, 1926. The radiant bride of that summer after- 
noon, accompanied by her sister and given away by her military 
brother, will not be forgotten by those who looked upon the scene. 
Of the three Butler College couples united in marriage in one week 
last June, severance by death has occurred in each instance. The 
Quarterly sends tender sympathy to Mr. Mackey and to Mrs. 
Daugherty and her family. 

Rebecca was a refined gentle girl, appreciative of fine things in 
literature and life, of high ideals and hopes. Her sudden going 
strikes her friends dumb with the sorrow of it. 

Morris — Since going to press, The Quarterly has received the 
sad news of the death of Mrs. John L. Morris, (Grace May Reeves, 
'95) at her home in Columbus, Indiana. 

Muse — The sad news of the death of Mrs. Frank D. Muse has 
recently reached the College. 

Anna A. Farr was born near Paragon, Indiana, June 29, 1867. 

Deaths 269 

Her parents were Dr. U. H. Farr and Sarah Blankenship. Miss 
Farr was married to F. D. Muse, '90, Butler University, at what 
is now Bellingham, September 22, 1892. Miss Farr was a teacher 
at that time in the New Whatcom public schools. She had taught 
altogether about five years. She received her education at the 
Martinsville, Indiana, High School, the Indiana State Normal 
School and the Smith Business College, Lexington, Kentucky. 

Mrs. Muse was the granddaughter of Perry M. Blankenship, a 
Civil War chaplain of the Seventieth Indiana and pioneer 
preacher of southern and central Indiana. She was baptized at 
Martinsville, Indiana, by W. B. F. Treat and became a member of 
that church September, 1886. She had taught in the Bible School 
for forty years and while at Lewiston, Idaho, was superintendent 
for two years, during which time the school attained its largest 
growth up to that time. Mrs. Muse was very active in all lines of 
church work, was very fond of young people and a leader in all 
activities in which they were interested. She especially cham- 
pioned the cause of young men and delighted in giving them 
"feeds" of all kinds. Her last service of this kind was the Greek 
banquet at Spokane University. Mrs. Muse was an able assistant 
of her husband and on occasions had filled the pulpit. Her papers 
on Bible themes were well written and always received with 

Mrs. Muse was also a member of the W. C. T. U. She cham- 
pioned the cause of temperance and also became a crusader against 
the cigarette. She had inherited her zeal for these reforms from 
her mother and had been more or less active in the work since 1884. 

She was very desirous of having both her children graduates of 
Spokane University and for this purpose the family moved to the 
campus in June, 1919, and built the home adjacent in the same 
year. Mrs. Muse was happy in disposition and in her home life, 
especially here, the home being largely planned by her and suited 
to her needs. In 1920 she nursed her husband through a long siege 
of sleeping sickness and by her heroic work largely was responsible 
for saving his life. Her father being a physician and her mother 

270 ^ BuTLEE Alumnal Quarterly 

a practical nurse, she also became skilled in this work and nursed 
the family through serious sieges of sickness. 

The cause of death was a surgical operation, from which she 
failed to rally. She died seemingly without knowing she was in 
danger of death, yet prepared to die at the Master's call, and yet 
knowing the danger into which she was going, she had made prep- 
aration for the end, making particular arrangements for the 
funeral services. She died in the faith of a Christian and had 
been an earnest contender for the Church of Christ and the simple 
New Testament gospel. 

She leaves her husband, F. D. Muse, a daughter, Mabel E, Crom- 
well, wife of Professor A. B. Cromwell, superintendent of schools 
at Craigmont, Idaho, both graduates of Spokane University, and a 
son, Howard M. Muse, and his wife. Birdie Titus Muse, also grad- 
uates of Spokane University and graduate students at the Uni- 
versity of Idaho; her aged father. Dr. U. H. Farr, 80 years old, 
of Paragon, Indiana ; a sister, Mrs, Monta Burkhart, and a brother, 
Daniel B. Farr, all of Paragon, Indiana. These and other 
relatives, scattered widely over the United States, together with a 
host of friends on every field where the labors of a ministry of 
more than thirty-six years has called the family, mourn her loss, 
but they have an abiding faith in the Christ, who is the resurrection 
and the life. 

Smith — Walter Edgar Smith, ex- '91, died suddenly at the age of 
fifty years at his home in Indianapolis on December 10, and was 
buried on the 13th in Crown Hill cemetery. 

"Walter Smith was a lifelong resident of Indianapolis, being one 
of the ten children of George M. Smith whose farm Was on the 
Brookville pike, and closely allied with the early life of Irvington 
and of Butler College. He is survived by five sisters and four 
brothers, three of whom graduated from the College, the others 
attending. Mr. Smith has been loyal to the School, giving gener- 
ously to its various activities and attending regularly its exercises. 
He will be sincerely missed.