Certain aspects of educational progress

Digitized by the Internet Archive

in 2007 with funding from

IVIicrosoft Corporation

http://www.archive.org/details/certainaspectsofOOunivrich

VOL. 1. NO. 3.

INVESTIGATIONS

OF THE

Department of Psychology and Education

OF THE

UNIVERSITY OF COLORADO

ARTHUR ALLIN, PH. D., EDITOR.
Professor of Psychology and Education.

CONTENTS:

Certain Aspects of Educational Progress.

Published by the

UNIVERSITY OF COLORADO,
Boulder, Colo., April, 1903.

PRICE, FIFTY CENTS

CONTENTS.

Page

fi Some Recent Sociological Views 3

President James h. baker.

Recent Essays Emphasizing the Social in Education ... 13
Harvey a. Carr, m. a.

The English Education Act 21

M. F. LIBBY, PH. D.

The Origin and Function of Habits 25

ARTHUR ALLIN.

The Law of Acceleration and Increase of Sensory

Stimulation 45

ARTHUR ALLIN.

Miscellanea 52

Reviews of Important Books ........... 73

SOME RECENT SOCIOLOGICAL VIEWS.

J AMES H. BAKER.

Sociology is the science which considers the fundamental laws of association
and the means of social progress. It is thus distinguished from the special prob-
lems of human association treated in Economics, Political Science, Ethics, etc.
Sociology as a distinct science is comparatively new, but it is increasingly
engaging the attention of thinkers and philanthropists and gives promise of large
results for human betterment. The theme proposed is a large and difficult one,
and calls for a summary of some accepted views with more or less reference to
leading writers. It must be understood, however, that the personal equation will
enter into the entire treatment of the subject.

PRINCIPLES.

Many theories regarding the basal principle of association have been
advanced. We may quote that of Professor Giddings, who finds the original sub-
jective social element to be "consciousness of kind." He thus defines his mean-
ing: "The consciousness of kind is that pleasurable state of mind which includes
organic sympathy, the perception of resemblance, conscious or reflective sympathy,
affection, and the desire for recognition." Together with the struggle for life
appears the social tendency as the struggle for the life of others — the germ of
altruism. Instinctive association later becomes conscious and purposeful, and
what is called the social mind is developed. Society advances by survival of the
fittest ideals and forms of organization.

That society is not a self-shaping organism is now generally admitted. Even
Herbert Spencer, after the extensive use which he makes of his device to set forth
the organization of society, explains that there are only certain limited analogies
between the human and the social organism; and Huxley repudiates the use of
such analogies on the ground that the units of society are independent existences.
Any exclusive biological doctrine of social evolution appears to be materialistic
and fatalistic. It refuses a unique character to the psychic elements of human
nature, denies free agency, and leads to the laissez-faire view which even today is
the worst feature of our civilization. If he who attempts to prove free will is
logically insane, he who in real problems denies free agency is practically a fool.

There is a difference between biological laws and human social laws, since
society has a moral aim. "Ethics and evolution are as far asimder as the poles."
Natural evolution at a certain point becomes "artificial and teleological" — con-
scious purpose appears as a factor in guiding events.

Professor Ward claims in substance, that psychology alone can explain
human society and that the social bond is found in the feelings. Professor Gid-
dings and Professor Baldwin advance similar views.

3

In substantial agreement with the doctrine of these writers, we ascribe chief
importance to the inventions, thoughts and sentiments of individuals who have the
power of initiative and leadership. "The matter of social organization is
thought; the method in social organization is imitation. Society grows by imi-
tative generalization of the thoughts of individuals." Carlyle's "Heroes and Hero
Worship," though presenting an exaggerated view, is a notable recognition of this
principle. History furnishes many examples of the power of genius to create
public sentiment. "Let who will make the laws of a people, if I write their songs"
was uttered with genuine insight.

The principle of struggle and survival in evolution is of course generally
accepted; Weismann's principle that acquired traits are not transmissible is
accepted by many. The followers of Weismann, like Benjamin Kidd, hold that
natural selection must obtain, or society will degenerate. If, they claim, we in-
herited the mental and moral culture of the past, there might be progress with-
out natural selection; but, if the survival of the best-adapted variations is the
only means of progress, then struggle must go on; the race deteriorates if the fit
and the unfit have an equal chance to survive; lack of competition would mean
biological deterioration and death. This question is of far-reaching importance
in all discussion of progress, and, until it is settled, the manner of solving many
practical problems must remain in doubt. Certainly the belief in accumulated
heredity is widespread, and nothing but scientific demonstration will overthrow
it. In the meantime, even if Weismannism be true, the accumulated culture of
the race is transmissible from generation to generation through education, and
this fact strengthens the faith of the optimist.

In passing we may refer to another important view, as held by Benjamin
Kidd. He teaches that reason is selfish, and that by itself it serves to intensify
the struggle. This view is of course disputed. Professor Ward says that civil-
ization has advanced through will and intellect; that the intellectual faculty,
superseding biological evolution, rapidly adapts the environment to man, and
does away with brutal selfishness; that the intuitive reason desires not the harm
of others. It is difficult to compare views because of the different meanings
attached to terms by different writers, but reason in its full sense must recognize
the principle of altruism, must know that rich individual growth includes social
desires and aims, and must perceive the rational and divine order of the world.

We grant there must be struggle in some form, but even Kidd recognizes
there must be another principle to make civilized society possible. He brings in
the power and sanction of religion, as the necessary altruistic intluence. The
rational selfishness of individuals is the disintegrating influence; religious belief
provides a sanction for social conduct; the first must constantly be subordinated
to the second. He believes evolution teaches that the race must continue to grow
more and more religious. He believes that in an improved religion we shall con-
quer; we may add that the victory will be easier and more complete because of
an improved science.

One conclusion is justified, namely, that social progress can not rely
upon natural selection alone, but must bring to its aid all the forces of material
and physical betterment, of public opinion, law, morality and religion.

MEANS OF PROGRESS.
CHARACTER OF THPJ PEOPLE.

A century ago "laiascz-faire" was the cry of economists and 'natural rights"
the means to cure social ills. Today ethical principles and co-operation enter
into the discussion of social and economic questions. John Stuart Mill moral-
ized Political Economy. He showed broad sympathy with the masses and exerted
a powerful influence upon all political thought. Men like Carlyle, Ruskin and
Tolstoy liave popularized and spread ideas making man more than an economic
member of the State. Christianity, just coming to full consciousness of its mis-
sion, inaugurates humane movements for the cure of social ills. Judging by
some recent tendencies even wealth is beginning to see the necessity of some kind
of ethical code.

According to a principle previously nowd, the individual furnishes the mate-
rial for progress, and individual responsibility is to be determined in the light of
that principle. Those who are natural leaders have the larger duty. There will
always be distinctions in society, and this is as desirable as it is inevitable. Since
the many will accept the guidance of the few, the good citizen will always be
ready to make some reasonable sacrifice for the public good. Avoidance of this
duty is the worst of our evils. The active interest of intelligent citizens is the
only efficient and final check on official neglect and abuse; the safety of democ-
racy depends on a healthy public sentiment. Progress cannot come through
struggle alone; its trend must be ideal, social and ethical.

Biology, psychology, history show that, if man is selfish, he is also pre-emi-
nently social. Spite of all the existing evils of government, the governments of
civilized nations are being made the instruments through which the will of the
people finds expression. Democratic government is the servant of the people; the
will of the people can control its character and its tendencies; it is the necessary
machinery for bringing about many reforms; and a people who have not the vir-
tue and active energy to eflfect reforms through government are incapable of
accomplishing them through any other organization of society or lack of organi-
zation. I have always held the view that the forces working in the world are the
forces of progress. Carroll D. Wright closes his volume on "Practical Sociology"
with a most hopeful view. He claims that as a result of the human struggle we
have a new man, a new political economy, a new state — the kingdom of Christ on
Earth, a new religion — that of progress, and a coming "revival of a religion which
shall hold in its power the church, industry, commerce, and the whole social
fabric."

Spencer of course believes in the natural evolution of institutions and he
makes a long list of the products of civilization that have developed by natural
process, without government interference, or indeed in spite of interference. He
thinks there must always be a higher and a lower in society. Whatever view
we may take of his decentralization doctrine, he is undoubtedly correct in claim-
ing that the form of political institutions is less important than the nature of the
citizens. The character of the units makes the character of the aggregate.
Political institutions may not be modified faster than the character of the citi-

6

zens is changed. France and America furnish illustration of this fact. The hope
of progress is not in legislation but in character. We hope, and I think may be-
lieve, that Spencer is right in his Utopian view. "The ultimate man will be one
whose private requirements coincide with public ones. He will be that manner
of man who, in spontaneously fulfilling his own nature, incidentally performs
the functions of a social unit; and yet is only enabled so to fulfill his own
nature by all others doing the like."

Individual responsibility in social reform can not be too strongly urged.
Laissez-faire is materialism, fatalism, selfishness, savagery, indifference, laziness,
mere subjective religious life and Pharisaism. It is the Priest and the Levite and
not the Samaritan.

EDUCATION.

Whether Weismann's view or Spencer's of heredity be true, we may be sure
that wide-spread education pays, because the accumulated traditions and stores
of knowledge are transmissible, if not by heredity, then at least by education and
the social atmosphere. Giddings says "States should assume cultural functions.
The members of the state see that social cohesion is a spiritual union rather than
an external compulsion, and that it depends upon the ideas of individuals. They
believe it to be as necessary to guide the minds of men as it is to suppress crime
and insurrection. Rightly or wrongly, they believe also that the guidance will be
inadequate or pernicious unless the state itself is the supreme guide." He notes
some twelve modes of equality, a sense of which he regards as necessary for the
safety and success of democracy, and he argues that a sense of these equalities can
be established only by an eflicient public school system.

RELIGION.

Another force for progress is religion. Even Herbert Spencer concedes there
is a great truth running through the whole history of religious thought and feel-
ing, namely, the belief in unseen causes. He believes that religion will still and
ever possess the minds of men, though modified in doctrine to harmonize with the
best universal instincts of human nature. The press from time to time heralds
the beginning of movements in Germany, England and America looking toward a
broad religious philosophy, and spiritual life abounding in good works. The
churches are adapting themselves to new interpretations in accord with the grow-
ing conception of truth and are meeting new demands for practical Christianity.
We may believe religion will still be the dominant influence toward ideal and
altruistic living, and that Kidd's theoretical need of religion as a socializing force
will be met in fact.

THE STATE.

There are two extreme tendencies of society, — individualistic and socialistic.
Each tendency, besides containing a selfish element, looks toward bettering human
conditions.

Individualists are opposed to state interference. Individualism developed
from the Fifteenth to the Nineteenth centuries as a movement toward religious
and political freedom. The later development of individualism is economic.

6

Adam Smith, the great political economist, was an individualist. Individualists
argue that individualistic countries are the most progressive; that regulative leg-
islation is always faulty; that dependence upon the state weakens the people and
lowers the social level ; and that socialism is the negation of freedom. Spencer is a
strong advocate of individualism. He claims that, while benefit according to
incapacity and need is the principle ruling in the family, the relation of the state
to the citizen must be governed by the principle of reward according to merit;
that by competition the quality of the species is preserved. He objects to the dis-
integration of the family and the too ready assumption by the state of responsi*
bility for children.

On the other hand Kidd uses evolution in favor of state interference, and
Huxley uses biology to the same end. Socialists use evolution to show the neces-
sity of organic social life without 'competition.

The aim of socialists is not at paternal or state control, but at the gradual
CO operative reorganization of society through government. Ihey are neither
revolutionary nor anarchistic. There are other types of socialists; but in Eng-
land, America and Germany, the term is commonly applied as above noted.

Socialists claim that the co-operative state would bring individual freedom
Instead of servitude of labor to capital; would tend to the survival of the best
instead of the strongest, and would make good character.

Spencer says that, while there must be sympathy enough to mitigate ills
without helping the worst to multiply, there must be no communistic distribution
equalizing good and bad, but must always be private ownership of things pro-
duced by labor. The German socialists under the militant idea want to establish
merely a new form of coercion and regulation. He cites the ancient Peruvian
Empire with its detailed military organization. He argues that, while sponta-
neous sympathy will bring an average of benefit, in the social state society would
perish; parental instinct would disappear. Human nature is not fitted to the
social state, is too selfish. The officers of such a state would be corrupt.

John Rae takes a similar view. Socialism intent on diffusion of progress
fails to see that it would cut the springs of progress. Incentives to production
and energy of effort would be relaxed. Human nature would take its ease. There
would be diminution of production, increase of population, industrial slavery.
Freedom would disappear under another form of absolute government. Military
despotism would be better.

Between these extreme views there is a golden mean. We may dismiss
anarchism and revolutionary socialism at the outset. Even if in a distant age
government control can be largely relaxed, abolition of government today, human
nature being as it is, would necessitate the gradual re-establishment of govern-
ment through a chaos and struggle which would be a repetition of Middle-Ages
history. Did we have the social state to-day, human nature being what it is, we
should have under another form of organization an exaggeration of all the politi-
cal corruption and selfishness and weakness which exist under present forms of
government. In all civilized countries political changes will be an evolution and
not a revolution. We may throw aside all supposed absolute rights and inflex-
ible principles. Let the state do what it can do better than individuals. Gid-

7

dings says that normal evolution is neither individualistic nor socialistic; that
the distribution of functions between public and private agencies is a varying
one; that we can gain and maintain liberty through government. John Rae be-
lieves in extending the sphere of the state. Kidd thinks that, while state man-
agement is not desirable, state regulation and control will be extended in the in-
terest of free competition. John Rae holds that laissez-faire is no longer a living
faith; that the state cannot divest itself of a distinct social mission; that state
functions do not interfere with individualism; that the state may be a social re-
former without being socialistic. Huxley believes in state functions. Ward ex-
presses his views somewhat in this fashion: Plutocrats cry laisses-faire and
create fear of government and advocate individualism. He thinks unequal dis-
tribution worse than all the evils government can commit. The individual has
ruled long enough; society must govern its own affairs. Sociocracy is the ideal
aim. Sociocracy recognizes all forms of government, but holds it to be the duty
of society to guard its own interests and work out its destiny. It is the art of
applying the active forces of society to society's problems. When the people
govern their own affairs instead of leaving them to party machines all issues ir-
relevant to the real question will be laid aside. What is called the natural does
not rule in the affairs of men. The artificial is infinitely superior to the natural.
Government is artificial and can be changed according to progressive ideas when-
ever intelligent and moral leadership desires.

The tendency today is toward more government control and, I believe, rightly.
Though many of society's ills must be treated by government instrumentality, yet,
when the cure is effected, there may properly be a reaction toward individualism.
The abuse of monopoly, the evils of poverty and degeneracy must be met in the
immediate future by extension of governmental functions. . Charles Booth uses the
phrase "socialism in the arms of individualism," and it is a very significant
phrase.

ECONOMICS.

POVERTY.

We must acknowledge that the sociological problem as related to poverty is
startling and difficult, and calls for an earnest attempt at solution.

The cry of some extremists is that the rich are growing richer and the poor
poorer. The former may be true, but not the latter. This is demonstrated by Car-
roll D. Wright in his "Practical Sociology." He shows that in 1891 the purchas-
ing power of a day's labor was in the proportion of 168 to 100 greater than the
purchasing power in 1860. He claims that the effect of machinery, saving the
incidental readjustment of labor, has been in every way beneficial.

The causes of poverty are hard to determine with accuracy because of the
varying conditions for every set of statistics, and the personal equation of statis-
ticians. Some say lack of work, insufficient work and poorly paid work added to-
gether are the supreme causes of poverty; that capitalists get too great a share;
that misfortune and not misconduct accounts for much the larger amount of
poverty. Individualists say, inefficiency of the poor, shiftlessness, lack of thrift,
prodigality, etc., are prominent causes. One important table makes an average,

8

taken from three large cities, of causes of poverty of applicants to certain charity
organization societies. Prominent causes in the order of their percentage are as
follows : ( 1 ) Sickness, accident or death ; ( 2 ) lack of employment, not due to the
employee; (3) intemperance; (4) lack of thrift, industry and judgment.

To meet the problems of the unemployed a Massachusetts commission sug-
gests, among other things, (1) removal to farms; (2) industrial education;
(3) state public works in winter; (4) state labor colonies. These remedies are
socialistic in character. Individualists recommend manual training, temperance,
thrift, etc. Wright suggests these remedies for social disorders, but they may
apply, in part, specifically to the problem of poverty: (1) trade, technical and
manual training; (2) justice to labor; (3) equitable distribution which must
come under some system without resorting to socialism which is revolution; (4)
prison instruction in trades; (5) moral law in business relations.

Certainly we must recognize many causes of poverty. It is harmful to make
a hobby of any one theory, or to try to find a panacea in any one remedy.
Unwillingness may be subject to state regulation; lack of thrift, prodigality, etc.,
may be modified by philanthropic endeavor; inability can be removed in a per-
centage of cases by education and by the influence of such work as that of the
"settlements;" lack of opportunity for work can be met in part in times of
distress by state or municipal provision for needed public improvements; various
kinds of misfortune should be met by state provision and organized philanthropy ;
hopeless pauperism should be the state's care; inequitable distribution will be
gradually modified by labor organizations and the development of altruistic prin-
ciples in society. There is much of poverty that no plan of state or society can
remove until the tone of the whole social organism is improved. I refer to the
lack of aims and motives in those who are otherwise physically and mentally
capable. The world is full of opportunities for establishing in thousands of cen-
ters productive industrial activities, if the unemployed had the power of initia-
tive. This whole subject is related to the problem of degeneracy.

MONOPOLY.

The problem of industrial combinations is a growing one and it enters into
the whole question of human relations, social and governmental. Some believe
that there are natural limits to combinations: limited fields for additional enter-
prises; regulative power of demand as related to price and quality; the selfishness
of the people who resent injury; the sense of justice of the people. Others hold
that monopolies are not necessarily evil, but the inevitable accompaniment of
our new civilization.

That monopolies, so far as harmful in fact and tendency, should be subject to
control is, I believe, the growing theory. The findings of the United States Indus-
trial Commission, which has recently finished its labors, are significant, especially
as the commission cannot be charged a priori with undue hostility to wealth.
Regarding railroads the commission recommend for discrimination and other
evils : ( 1 ) That government control be strengthened and that the authority of
the Interstate Commission be restored and its functions be enlarged ; ( 2 ) that for
eflTectiveness the Commission should be representative of various interests; (3)

9

that capitalization and financiering of railroads should be regulated by legisla-
tion; (4) that discrimination in favor of imports be prohibited. Regarding in-
dustrial combinations they recommend, amongst other things: Publicity; prosecu-
tion for violation of federal anti-trust laws; national and state laws against dis-
crimination between customers; laws concerning over-capitalization and to fur-
nish state supervision; federal taxation and supervision; tariff modifications as
related to the evils of monopolies; investigation of the whole question of import
duties.

These findings show the need of control through government, and the belief
in its possibility and feasibility. Moreover, the very fact of the report shows that
specialists, statesmen and even politicians and monopolists are awake to the fact
that reform must come.

TAXATION.

Taxation is another interest that is related to the problems of altruism. The
Industrial Commission advocate : ( 1 ) that states raise their revenue from corpo-
rations, inheritances and incomes, supplemented, when necessary, by indirect tax-
ation— the taxation for local purposes remaining on real estate and personalty;
(2) that corporations be taxed on the value of their franchises, based on actual
value of stocks and bonded debts, less value of real estate assessed locally; (3)
that states levy graduated taxes on inheritances; (4) that the state establish a
graduated tax on incomes; (5) that there be special taxes upon any business not
otherwise made to bear its just share.

Professor Seligman, who is one of the progressive writers on taxation, says
tax is to correspond as far as possible to revenue of citizens. Citizens should
support government according to their capacity to support themselves. Revenue
or income is now regarded as the ideal basis for taxation. He advocates as a
present policy the inheritance tax, and the corporation tax for state purposes.

DEGENERACY.

In spite of certain biological doctrines of social evolution, in spite of the
advocates of struggle, in spite of all laissez-faire theories, one important fact
must be recognized — namely, that human sympathy is growing and that human
sympathy must be preserved in all its strength and purity; it is the bond that
unites the units into a social aggregate. At the same time it is conceded by all
scientific philanthropists that, as struggle is modified by altruism, the unfit of
every description are preserved to the detriment of the race as a whole, and
that some humane solution of the difficulty must be sought. The burden of the
stkte is becoming such that the causes of degeneracy must be in large part re-
moved. The very fact that state and society are assuming the care of the unfor-
tunate shows the growth of altruism and a recognition of the solidarity of so-
ciety. The dependent, defective, and delinquent classes are beginning to receive
attention and study commensurate with the importance of their effect upon the
welfare of the whole social fabric. Since all degeneracy is due to heredity or
environment, state and society can reach, and to some extent regulate, the causes.
Sociology is becoming an important subject of study in institutions of learning;,

10

in institutions for the care of wards of the state experiments are conducted with
the desire to discover practical principles for care, education and reformation.
State and national conferences are comparing results of practical experience.
Every city counts its philanthropic organizations by the dozen, and organized
charities are doing with wisdom and efficiency what formerly was done by un-
wise and harmful spontaneous charity.

The economic organization of society as related to the class of dependents
has already been discussed. Dependents who are able but ignorant or unwilling
must be reached by education, and by all influences that will awaken the dor-
mant impulses to right activity. There are thousands of splendid men and
women who need sympathy, encouragement and guidance, and in some cities
the chief work of charity organizations is not alms-giving, but developing a self-
respecting, self-active personality. The class of dependents who are born pau-
pers, hopeless in ability and motive, should at once become the care of the
state, and the sexes should be permanently segregated.

The defectives, on humane and economic grounds, should be educated, each
according to his capacity, and the hopelessly incapable should remain under in-
stitutional care, the sexes being separated.

The class of delinquents furnish greater problems than other defectives.
Criminals as a whole are likely to possess physical anomalies, physical degeneracy,
and a humbly developed mental organization. Children with these traits often
become criminal because of social conditions ; they do not readily find employment
and easily turn to evil ways. Those born with criminal taint usually inherit it
from some form of degeneracy in parents. With good environment, however,
many of these may become good citizens. Poor homes, bad surroundings, lack
of education and occupation may make criminals of normal children. It is
shown that a large percentage of criminals have no trade. One table of statistics
shows that only six per cent of inmates in the Elmira Reformatory had good
homes. The home is the starting place for all . sorts of reforms. Practical
sociologists today deplore the tendency to disintegrate the family, and when-
ever possible endeavor to preserve its integrity and keep children within its
fostering influence. For care of dependent children, homes are preferred to insti-
tutions. Of course, industrial and other education for all neglected children is
nearly the panacea. Children with positive and exaggerated native criminal ten-
dencies, whose offspring could but be degenerates, should at an early age be
placed under custodial care.

In the treatment of criminals, belief in the indeterminate sentence is grow-
ing. The first work of prisons is reformation. When a criminal is reformed
and has been taught an honest trade he is ready to be released; if he is a hope-
less criminal by nature, he never should be restored to society. So far as possi-
ble prisoners should be made self-supporting. It is an anomaly that able-bodied
criminals should be supported in idleness by good citizens.

Since the struggle in human society is bound to be lessened, and race deteri-
oration will surely follow unless degenerate tendencies are eliminated, what is the
aspect of the problem? Society will no longer allow the unfortunate to perish.
The answer seems to me plain and simple. Dickens, in his marvelous study of

11

social problems, emphasized with terrible vividness the evils of society from
neglected children, when these should become grown and trained in vice and hence
powerful for harm. The work of improving the lower strata of society must
begin with children. Educate the normal children of the poor, teach them some
trade and start them right in life. Educate all who, under right influences and
training, can become useful citizens. Remove waifs from unwholesome surround-
ings, or rather improve the surroundings. But in the name of humanity place
all those who by nature must become hopeless paupers, imbeciles, all who by
nature will become hopeless criminals under permanent custodial care. Teach
them some simple occupation and make them in part self-supporting. Segre-
gate the sexes that such unfortunates and society may be spared the fatal gift
of degenerate offspring. This will do more to regenerate society than use-
inheritance and all remedies proposed, ex<!ept the great moral evolution of the
1 ace as a whole, which I believe is going on. To those not acquainted with recent
views and experiments, some of these propositions may seem chimerical. But in
some states already imbeciles, epileptics, etc., are colonized and the sexes are
segregated. The members of these institutions, or colonies, are given some light
occupation and are made comfortable — better off than they would be under greater
freedom. This method is humane, is practicable, and its use is a common-sense
duty. I predict that so far as scientific investigation shall determine — not in-
consistently with proper sympathy — this method of decreasing degenerate ele-
ments of society will be employed. The radical method proposed by some medical
men of putting all the unfit to painless death will never be employed — it would
destroy human sympathy; besides, too many of us would be in danger. The
plan in operation would produce a French-Revolution frenzy of destruction. All
reforms are possibly by conservative, wise and humane methods.

THE FUTURE.

Altruism is growing; philanthropy is becoming scientific and practical. Are
poverty, degeneracy and crime decreasing? Probably we are at too early a stage
of practical investigation to draw definite conclusions; but we feel certain that
science under the inspiration of altruism will discover the means for reducing
all the evils from which society suffers.

12

RECENT ESSAYS BEARING ON THE SOCIAL IN
EDUCATION.

HARVEY A. CARR.

In times past, education was largely a family or parental function. The
family, present and future, was the corporate survival unit in conscious educa-
tional activity. Formal education was individualistic in tendency; as to aims,
it centered around the child — its success, happiness and development. Many
definitions of the aims of education still embody this personal, parental attitude;
they entirely face the child with no glance over the shoulder at social ideals and
tendencies — as to where the journey tends; they emphasize individual acquire-
ments— power, character, culture, complete development, etc., etc.

Education is evolving from parental to social care, from a family to a state
function. On the one hand the family has gradually surrendered the function,
as society performs it better, and on the other society has tended to usurp the
office as corporate consciousness and the spirit of democracy have arisen. The
aim of education becomes objective or social. Society demands that certain ends
be attained. The young must be fitted as members of the social corporation.
The particular end changes with varying emphasis; at one time the political con-
sciousness is dominant and training for citizenship is demanded, the industrial
with its requirements, or the social with its demand for an ethical and social
character, but the aim is social or objective. The idea has been further accent-
uated by historical studies of educational systems, and by biological and socio-
logical theories with their emphasis upon adaptation to existing conditions as the
keynote of success.

With the industrial ideal has come science, technical, trade and manual-
training schools, specialization, electives, readjustments of the curriculum, de-
mands for shorter courses, etc. The tendency has been illiberal and utilitarian
to some extent, a somewhat mechanical adaptation to the social regime, a train-
ing to fit the individual as a mere wheel in a complex interacting system.

With the rise of democratic self-consciousness, the ideal becomes more liberal
in nature. The essence of democracy is to superadd to a mechanical arrangement
a psychic relationship — a conscious partnership in the social corporation. The
social aim of education arises wherein the aim is to educate the young as con-
scious partners, rather than as mere clerks or laborers. Social participation and
social self-consciousness is the ideal. The old industrial and political ideals are
not destroyed; a new one is added. The curriculum and the various branches
must be remodeled with a social reference, the child must be conscious of their
bearing and relation to present progress. All roads now lead to the "new
Rome." Social industries and institutions pervade the school, furnishing educa-
tional material to incite an interest in and understanding of the real active

13

world round about. An intimate connection between the school and society
must be established. The social spirit of conscious cooperation is fostered by the
organization of the school into a conscious corporate body that finds unity of
action in self-government, on the playground, through athletics, care and decora-
tion of grounds and buildings, and a multitude of other corporate activities. To
a training for life is added the celebrated dictum that "education is life." From
the old parental ideals, education has evolved until now it is a training by, for
and through social activities and relationships.

Various phases of these lines of thought have been strongly emphasized in
recent educational writings. G. Stanley Hall has a most excellent article on
"Some Social Aspects of Education" in the Pedagogical Seminary.

He summarizes the position of sociology in its adverse criticisms to present-
day educational practice: Man is a social being, and when isolated from society
tends to imbecility and one-sided development. Social interaction is thus
markedly educative and the social spirit, social activities and relationships should
enter into and pervade the school. In view of these principles the following criti-
cisms are urged: Education is too individualistic, the child is isolated from
the home and from nature; education being conservative, like all institutions,
the curriculum looks to the past rather than to the present; the curriculum is
rigid and non-adaptable to varying personalities; form is emphasized rather than
context; science is abstract and unrelated to living nature; present-day current
questions appealing to live social interests, such as religion, politics, etc., are
ejected from the school because of divergence of public opinion; instruction and
work is individual, allowing of no mutual help, cooperation or emulation on the
part of the pupils; there is but little correlation of branches; the parts of the
whole system are not articulated, with consequent gaps, overlappings and waste;
and the grades are isolated, making promotion difficult and interaction of grades
impossible.

President Hall admits these indictments to some extent, but considers them
too sweeping and somewhat exaggerated. There are certain tendencies in these
directions, but critics fail to see on the other side social tendencies already at
work, and which may be further utilized by judicious management for the im-
provement of present conditions. These social instruments and means he briefly
mentions: 1st. Language is a social instrument, and its very use necessitates
social interaction, communication, and experience; 2d. Imitation is primarily a
social activity whose force and extent are much greater than commonly supposed.
It necessitates interaction and communication; 3d. The school may be organized
as a social unit whose corporate activity may be expressed in various ways as
decoration and improvements of grounds and buildings, etc.; 4th. Self-govern-
ment may be initiated ; 5th. The socializing effect of group-games and of the play-
ground in general may be extended; 6th. A greaiter connection between the home
and the school may be made through home activities ; 7th. Nature study may
link the school with everyday surroundings ; 8th. Social, politica,l, ethical and
philanthropic agencies in their actual concrete workings may be studied; and
9th. The same may be done of the social industries of the iminediate environ-
ment. ^

14

With the advent of adolescence President Hall advocates a change of locus
from society to the individual. Training of the pupil in individuality and not
for social ends is to be emphasized. Society must fit personality and not vice
versa. Culture and a wide general knowledge must take precedence over special-
ized training. Educational methods must look toward, not the present, but the
future society through a full and wide development of the individual. (1)

An interesting and instructive attempt to unite more closely for mutual in-
teraction the school and society in the Greenleaf Public School of Washington,
D. C, is described by Sanford Bell. (2) The work was conceived and carried
out by Principal Riordon of one of the regular ward schools in the poorest sec-
tion of the city. A school garden five feet in width and skirting the inside of
the school yard fence gives expression to the conscious corporate activity of the
school. The entire work is done by the children, community activity and owner-
ship lasting till harvest time. Flowers and vegetables are raised which are
divided and used in the school. The children voluntarily keep off the garden in
their play.

Two courts of sixty feet square were improved and fitted up by the children
for playgrounds. They are shaded by awnings and are provided with swings, see-
saws, benches, sand piles, gymnastic apparatus, etc. All improvements were made
or purchased by the children and belong to them as a community. Disciplining
is left as much as possible to them. These grounds are used before and after
school hours and on Saturdays.

A monthly paper is edited and published by the pupils and a savings bank,
paying interest on deposits, is also officered and managed by them.

The manual training consists as much as possible of the necessary industrial
activities of the school community. The girls take care of the halls and recitation
rooms as to cleanliness and decoration; actual accounting and bookkeeping are
necessary; reports, programmes and announcements are typewritten and copied
on a mimeograph; telephones and electric bells are put in and kept in repair;
actual painting and carpentry are taught, the buildings being thus kept in con-
stant repair.

A vacation school was established; the morning hours being devoted to a
variety and combination of academic and industrial work, and the afternoon to
the playground, with an hour's programme of music, recitations, etc. Saturdays
were used for country excursions. The afternoons were open to the parents, and
members of the professions and trades gave simple talks on their respective indus-
trial activities.

Miss Jane Addams, in her book on "Democracy and Social Ethics" (3), has
a chapter on Educational Methods, in which she deals very sanely and sympa-
thetically with current educational practices in relation to the social needs of

<1) G. Stanley Hall, Some Social Aspects of Education, Pedagogical Seminary,

Vol. IX, No. 1, pp. 81-93.
<2) Sanford Bell. An Educational Object Lesson, Pedagogical Seminary, Vol.

IX, No. 2, pp. 237-248.
(3) Jane Addams, Democracy and Social Ethics, Chap. VI, pp. 178-220. Mac-

Millan & Co., 1902.

See also Prince Kropotkin, Mutual Aid, London, 1902.

15

urban industrialism. Her views are the result of long experience with the actual
conditions in the Hull House Settlement and are of inestimable value to either the
theoretical or the practical educator who is earnestly attempting to adapt the
educational institution to the rapidly evolving social conditions.

Miss Addanis shows well that the essence of democracy is to educate each
individual into the corporate consciousness of the evolving society; that democ-
racy includes all of the body politic and that social progress depends upon bring-
ing each member into, not mechanical, but conscious relationship to the whole;
each must be not a silent, mechanical, but a conscious dynamic integer; a con-
scious co-partner of the great corporation.

In view of this Miss Addams characterizes present learning and training as
too individualistic in that it fits too exclusively for individual or family success
and neglects that knowledge which gives social value and meaning to the daily
experience of the industrial laborer. As a case in point, she pictures an Italian
colony in their relation to the educational system. They were mostly peasants
in Italy and in the family industrial stage with its diversified activities for the
whole family. Here their whole industrial life is changed. The father works
in a factory, the mother's home work is very limited in comparison to her former
outdoor and domestic activities. The child has comparatively little to learn from
his parents that will put him in touch with surrounding industrial and social
conditions.

The school in no way utilizes the child's language, his habits of mind and
body or his social traditions; the school has no power or attraction for him what-
soever. It is but natural that he should leave school and enter a factory at 14,
or take to selling papers or the life of the street at an earlier age. The knowl-
edge gained in school in no way relates to his future occupation or daily expe-
rience; it is commercial or professional in tendency, in that it is clerical in
nature; it is associated with a rise in life and away from trade and industry; it
has no relation to productive industry and the industrial worker. Business col-
leges also emphasize the clerical part of commercialism and do not minister to
the factory employee. The same is true of university extension and settlement
work; it is bookish, academic and divorced from their actual life and experience;
it appeals to a few of the academic type, but leaves the mass untouched. Indus-
trial education has attempted the problem, but has failed, in that it has trained
experts — engineers, chemists, electricians, machine builders, etc. — rather than
educated machine tenders; it has raised but a few to a higher position, but has
done nothing to improve those who remain laborers.

The dehumanizing effects of the machine monotony that results from special-
ization and division of labor must be overcome. According to Miss Addams this
can be done by giving the workman some conception of the evolution of his in-
dustry in its relation to social and industrial progress. Machines and processes
have their evolution, their growth, their historic associations with human progress
as do ancient buildings or ruins. We inject the "doing of life" into education
and we should also surround the "doing of life" with education, give life and
meaning to the workman's activities. The interdependence of society must be
more than mechanical — a conscious, psychic affair. The historical evolution of

16

industry, of the machines, processes and the worker, in its relation to the unity
of purpose in an evolving society would serve to orientate the worker and to eval-
uate his position in reference to the whole.

President Hall (1) in an article in the Pedagogical Seminary characterize*
briefly three attitudes or aims that have or may obtain in an educational system:
Ist. The training of the old schools which looked largely to the past for its ideals.
This is the natural tendency of every system in that an evolving society continu-
ally outgrows a conservative institution. 2nd. The training that aims to fit for
present social conditions. Efficiency in present social, political and industrial
activity is the keynote. Standards are fixed and defined and hence the training
with this ideal tends to become illiberal. The child is subordinated to social de-
mands. 3rd. The training that looks forward to the world to be, for the next
stage of development. Society is changing rapidly and unless we aim ahead we
train children after the fashion of the man who was born an hour too late. It
aims for future projected efficiency and is both liberal and specialized in nature.

This last phase of the subject is well and thoroughly treated by Prof. Allin in
an article (2) in the Journal of Pedagogy. Prof. Allin shows convincingly that
the educative process is part and parcel of a general biological and social law
which he terms "The Law of Future Specific and Social Efficiency." This law is
that natural selection has reference more to the future welfare of the species than
to present survival.

The attempt is made to prove that in the organic life of the past only those
species have survived the actions of whose members were conducive to propagation
of and the best provision possible for the young. The young have been the goal
and heirs of all efforts, directly or indirectly.

"One of the most striking, and yet at the same time one of the least observed,
facts about specific action is the pre-eminence of the specific as such. The indi-
vidual is secondary to the species. Instincts, which are characteristically the
grand trunk line of transmission and continuity in the lower orders of the zoologi-
cal series, are peculiar and very important in this, that they are always in their
origin and bloom for the benefit of the species to which the animal
may belong which possesses the instinct. They are of benefit to the
individual only secondarily, in so far as that individual may be of
benefit to the species. The mother gives up her life for the child. She
dies, but the child, and through it the species, lives. The salmon strug-
gles up the Columbia river for a thousand miles, is torn and battered by the
rocks and waterfalls on the long and weary journey, lays its eggs, and dies;
but the race lives on, although at the loss and sacrifice of one of its best members.
The long history of the mammalia or mothers is a record of innumerable such ex-
amples. Of course, it is not necessarily true that the individual performs an
instinctive act in order that the species may be benefited, but the persistent fact

(1) G. S. Hall, The High School as the People's College versus the Fitting

School, Pedagogical Seminary, Vol. IX :1, pp. 63-74.

(2) Artliur Allin, The Law of Future Specific and Social Efliciency, Journal of

Pedagogy, Dec, 1902 (Syracuse, N. Y.), pp. 119-127.

See also an article by the same author on The Basis of Sociality in
the American Journal of Sociology, Vol. VIII, No. 1, July, 1902.

17

remains that in the long run only those species and individuals survive which act
in such a way that the species may be further propagated. Instincts are always
for species or race preservation. They are specific, altruistic, other-regarding,
profoundly social. They may not be all consciously such, but in their origin and
bloom they are in their final import intensely social. It is a question of survival.
It is a question of propagation and of the safety and welfare of the propagated.
The individuals of a species which do not propagate obviously nullify the proba-
bility of like descendants. That which militates against the species thereby mili-
tates against the survival of the members of that species. The species that sur-
rives is characterized by the fact that its members act in such a manner that
descendants are provided, and also provided for in some way or other. The goal
of their activities is the young and their welfare. The young are heirs of all
efforts, directly or indirectly {Erziehting, eine Fortsetzung der Erzeugung) . In
the highest mammalian species, man, art, religion and science are, in the long run,
directly or indirectly means for more certain perpetuation of the species and the
more certain welfare of the same. The rank of a species is determined by the
d^free of such care for the young. The survival of the fittest means the survival
of the parental, and all efforts are to be judged according to a parental standard.
The greatest good to the greatest number must also be interpreted in a similar
manner, not as the greatest happiness of the greatest number, but as such paren-
tal conduct, direct or indirect, as will be most conducive to the propagation and
welfare of the species."

That species or society persists in which there is progressive adaptation of
each successive generation. Natural selection implies progress or greater adap-
tation. Without provision for the future the species must die.

As instances, Prof. AUin cites the parental care of the mammalia where the
life of the mother is sacrificed for the future welfare of the species through her
progeny, and Weismann's argument that the duration of life itself is determined
by natural selection, being conditioned upon the time necessary for propagation
of and provision for the young; that the life and survival of the individual is of
value only as it secures the further evolution of the species by propagation and
education. Hence in the long run natural selection and evolution face the future
rather than the present. The law is inherent in the very concept of progressive
evolution, for selection must provide in one generation a basis for a better ad-
justment in the progeny. Increasing plasticity, parental care and education are
cases in point.

Of course this process is not necessarily conscious on the part of the individ-
ual or society. The result may be attained, no matter what the motive may be,
as is instanced by the worldly ambition and money getting of parents. The mo-
tive may be selfish or sordid, but the fact remains there is better provision for
their progeny. However the majority of parents desire to give their children bet-
ter opportunities than they themselves had. Dr. AUin instances the growth of
paternalism in the state, municipal improvements on a large scale, transisthmian
canals, national irrigation, transcontinental railroads, protection of industries,
and other large enterprises of society which minister more to the future than to
the present. It is but a continuance of the biological fact of increasing provision

18

for the young and represents the dominant tendency in social progress. "Society,**
he says, "is not composed (merely) of those now living; it represents the living
as the servants of posterity,'' a saying which embodies the very essence of the
■ocial institution of education in that it is an outgrowth of parental care.

The present ideal of education is the adaptation of the young into the present
social fabric, a training for existing needs and demands as though society repre-
sented static and fixed conditions. This emphasizes unduly narrow specialization.
Education must be this and more ; it must also have an eye to the future and em-
phasize those conditions which will allow of continual adaptation in a changing
evolving society; it must both survey the present, and chart the future.

How this has been done in the past or is to be accomplished in the future Dr.
Allin does not say. The law is merely stated in its bearing upon a proper edu-
cational ideal.

19

THE ENGLISH EDUCATION ACT.

M. F. LIBBY

The London Times of December, 1902, publishes the new education act in
full. The English Journal of Education of April, 1902, gives a clear abstract of
the act. This journal published the act in full, but before it had been debated,
and hence not in its final amended form. The debates are to be found in a suffi-
ciently complete form in The Times, The leading speeches, outside the house, by
Balfour, Rosebery, Sir John Gorst, Chamberlain, the Duke of Devonshire, and
others, are given in all the English papers. The letters between Dr. Cliti'ord and
Mr. Balfour can be had in the form of campaign literature. By a study of these
sources and of the English periodicals one can form some opinion of the nature of
this latest pitched battle between National Education and Established Church
Education in England.

Mr. Balfour protests that this bill is a great triumph for National Education,
in spite of the fact that it pleases the church party. But the non-conformists do
not shout for this alleged triumph of theirs. On the other hand they call the act
•The Bishop's Bill." Certainly the Conservatives are practically all Episco-
palians. The bill was carried in crucial divisions by a majority of 170. Seldom
has there been a great parliamentary struggle over an act which was eventually
passed by such a majority.

The object of this paper is to give a mere but clear sketch of the whole situ-
ation, i

From Elizabeth's reign until the 18th century free grammar schools provided
all education for the English proletariat. In 1698 these had decayed through
crowding of the population into towns. The "Society for Promoting Christian
Knowledge" then founded 1,000 schools. In the beginning of the 19th century we
find two rival societies carrying on this work — one favoring ecclesiastical manage-
ment, the other state control. From 1830, a memorable year, to 1870, we find in-
cessant struggles between the societies, concerning government grants, appoint-
ment of inspectors and other questions. Between 1833 and 1858 the expenditure
by government and municipalities had increased from twenty thousand to seven
hundred thousand pounds. From the days of the Duke of Newcastle and Mr.
Lowe to 1870 the system of paying teachers by results (examinations of individ-
ual pupils) gave some steadiness to the system, which, however, was unsatisfac-
tory, especially to the new liberal democracy.

The English regard the act of 1870 as a compromise between the church and
squire on the one hand, and the liberals and non-Conformists on the other. It did
a great deal for national secular education similar to the American system, but it
recognized the church schools and subsidized them out of the public purse; not
directly from the rates, but indirectly from the parliamentary exchequer. This

act established school boards and gave them the power to see that all children got
some education, but of course not to interfere with children educated by the
church schools. The cost of board schools was defrayed by parliament, fees, and
direct tax on every householder in the district; while church schools were sup-
ported by their own supporters and by the exchequer at London.

The board schools had been efficient and were gradually but surely gaining
on the church schools. The board schools have been denounced as "godless
schools.'* But as the Methodists and Baptists and Independents and other non-
Conformists were their chief supporters these denunciations have not alarmed
the English people outside the established and the Eoman Catholic churches.

Shortly after the brief successes of Lord Roberts in South Africa the Conserv-
atives went to the country and were returned with an overwhelming majority. It
is freely asserted that the church compelled the government to use this majority,
for which they claimed much credit, in passing a new act which would rescue the
church schools from impending ruin. Neither Mr. Balfour nor Mr. Chamberlain
is inclined to reaction. The act honestly does all it can to advance education, but
it cannot do much in the present juncture.

The salient features of the new act are these: The boards are abolished; new
"local authorities" are established and are entirely elective, being in reality the
county councils. These appoint managers for the schools, but these managers, in
the case of the church schools, must be nearly all church representatives. The
church schools are to draw on the rates. The managers hire and dismiss the
teachers.

This arrangement seems incredible to us in America, but the first part of this
paper explains it.

To the calm outsider the bill is a fairly just compromise, somewhat favorable
to the church party, as is shown by the simple fact that all the church people and
the House of Lords supported it strenuously, while the Liberals and non-Conform-
ists seem to find in opposing it a sincere ground of reunion. This argument is
tempered by the ever-present fact of party politics, by which the opposition
oppose the government.

Mr. Balfour says, with his air of philosophic aloofness, that the bill will
work well for National Education. The astute Chamberlain told his constituents
that if they turned out the Conservatives the Liberals could not bring in so good
a bill, nor any bill, because it would ruin them through dissensions. This fact
seems indisputable. Lord Rosebery declares that to give the church power to
collect "rates" is to subvert the principles of British freedom and that the pre-
tended unity of control is the flimsiest kind of sham, while Episcopalian man-
agers appoint only Episcopalian teachers. He more than hints that if he were a
Nonconformist he would refuse to obey the law and withstand "the little tyrant
of his field." Dr. Clifford, speaking for the Baptists and many others, declares
flatly that the law must be resisted.

It is far from improbable that the Liberals and Nonconformists are embit-
tered chiefly through disappointment that the act of 1870 was not allowed to do
its complete work, which, in their estimate, would have involved the complete ruin
of the church schools. The present panic concerning the need of education as a

22

weapon against commercial rivals favored the board schools, which, as they se-
lected teachers solely on grounds of educational efficiency, naturally afforded bet-
ter educational opportunities than the church schools, which selected teachers
partly on other and to them more important grounds.

Even in this rough sketch of the largest points of a comprehensive and com-
plicated measure, it must be added that the bill makes an honest, though not mas-
terly effort to coordinate elementary, secondary and technical departments of the
very disjointed English educational system or, rather, arrangement.

With more money the church schools must do better work. The secular part
of their programme will be scrutinized as never before. The power of the purse
has always been a great power and may prove greater in this case than the Lib-
erals now believe.

Conjecture as to results is perhaps idle. The long war is far from its end.
Will the American idea prevail? Can it prevail without disestablishment? Will
til is act help or hinder disestablishment? Will there be a large access of desire for
religious and sectarian education, such as hardly any American dreams of? Will
the Episcopalians gradually relinquish this desire themselves? To what extent
will the new system handicap the English in their commercial struggle? Will the
religious education of the denominational schools counterbalance the possibly su-
perior keenness and acumen of the American system? Between these questions
and their disturbing answers lie the experiences of a generation. We must hope
for our own peace of mind, that time is on the side of broad national views of the
moral and religious problems of nations in which citizenship must accommodate
itself as the honorable ideal of very various races, and in which no name of a sect
meets like apperception in comparatively many.

23

THE ORIGIN AND FUNCTION OF HABITS.

ARTHUR ALLIN.
I. THE ORGANIZATION OF HABITS.

Habits are the definite, regular rhythmic activities of an organism which have
been acquired during the lifetime of that individual. In contrast with instincts
they are reactions acquired de novo. Owing to the great increase of unorganized
material in tlie nervous system (increase of plastic endowment) as compared
with the lower animals, new combinations, associations and reactions are ren-
dered possible. While instincts are adaptations and useful to the organism, they
are fitted for a relatively simple, unchanging environment. With the increase of
the social heritage the environment has become exceedingly complex and at the
same time changeable. Hence the inflexibility and perdurability of instinctive life
tends to become a disadvantage and plasticity or the possibility of the organiza-
tion of new reactions, i. e., habits, increasingly usurps a larger and larger field.
The instincts of biology tend to give way to the habits of sociology, adaptability to
the environment being the ever-present criterion. Thus the habits acquired
through present-day education possess a relatively greater survival value for the
individual and for the species than the instincts which are the survivals of the
curriculum of the infinite past.

Habits may grow out of spontaneous, impulsive, reflex movements, may
develop from variations occurring in connection with instincts and instinct-im-
pulses or they may be acquired de novo in various ways, as for example, through
simultaneous stimulation of two sensory areas, etc. The organism reacts in vari-
ous ways to internal and external stimuli, many strange and new reactions aris-
ing in the process. Those which are useful for certain ends survive, while many
others tend to disappear. This is especially evident in childhood. (1) After the
completion of the first act the system, to quote Dr. Carpenter's words, "grows to
the way in which it was first exercised." This automatic acquiescence of the sys-
tem to its primary impressions and reactions makes possible the acquisitions of
the social heritage. Reactions, whether good or bad, when they have attained the
status of habits, are retained. Past habits which have been overcome are still re-
tained in a latent condition. They exist side by side with reigning, dominant
reactions, regaining ascendency at times in disease, weakness or crises when the
governing hand of the so-called higher ideals loses its strength. The past,
though latent, is always a possibility. Treacherous, lurking foes may be left

<1) Baldwin, Mental Development in the Child and in the Race, Chap. Vll.
Social and Ethical Interpretations, Part II, Chap. lil.

Perhaps it is advisable to follow the terminology suggested by Os-
born, according to which the term "modification" should be confined to
acquired, and "variation" to congenital changes.

25

in the rear of the advancing column, or on the other hand every ally gained may
but make more sure the success of the expedition.

1. With maximum of automatism there is minimum of consciousness. As a
habit becomes more automatic, consciousness gradually ceases to accompany the
individual parts of the action. Consciousness apparently accompanies those nerv-
ous processes in which there is a relatively large amount of resistance and hin-
drance to the transmission of nervous impulses. With growing ease comes uncon-
sciousness. Progressive habituation or automatization means often the short-
circuiting of nerve paths. In the construction or organization of a new habit the
nervous impulses coming in from the sensory apparatus traverse the spinal cord
or basal ganglia of the brain, attain certain cortical areas and then return by
motor channels via the ganglia and possibly the spinal cord. As the habit be-
comes automatic the nervous impulses travel simply to or from the spinal cord or
to and from the basal ganglia. At first the "central telephone office" is called up
to secure connections, but after connections are established there is no need to
trouble the central office.

Insufficiently organized habits tend continually to re-enter consciousness, pro-
ducing vagueness, indecision and uncertainty. "What you can't do blindfold you
can't do at all." "The high school boy who must halt in his mathematical work to
remember the multiplication table, is enjoying the fruits of a pseudo-freedom in
the grades. There is no freedom except through automatism. Automatism is not
genius, but it is the hands and feet of genius." (1)

"The great thing then," says James, "in all education is to make our nervous
system our ally instead of our enemy." Some writer has said that good habits are
better than good principles. With the growing automatization, mental and cere-
bral energy is set free for further acquisition and co-ordination. Each ideal or
practice becomes automatic and registered in the system with the result "That
men may rise on stepping-stones of their dead selves to higher things."

If anyone should ask an expert typewriter operator where certain keys were
on the keyboard of the instrument on which he daily writes, he could with diffi-
culty rely on the accuracy of his visual memory ; but on the other hand his lingers
will not make a mistake, even when they are writing at a very rapid rate. He
might not pass with credit an examination in visual memory, but in conduct he is
adept. The conduct or service rendered is the desideratum. This should be taken
into serious consideration, not only in school examinations, but also in all school
work, which is but a preliminary exercise for the life of adult service.

2. Hierarchy of habits for certain activities. "A man is organized in spots —
or rather in some spots far more than in others. This is true structurally and
functionally. It is strikingly true of the various sense organs and their functions.
No less is it true of the various parts of the central nervous system and their
functions. A man has some habits which are sporadic and isolated, some which
are bunched together in loose groups (such as the outlay of skills which make
one a carpenter ) , and then, some habits which are knit together into a hierarchy.

"A hierarchy of habits maybe described in this way: 1. There is a certain

(1) Bryan and Harter, Studies on the Telegraphic Language, The Acquisition of
a Hierarchy of Habits, Psych. Rev., July, 1899, pp. 369 and 375.

26

number of habits which are elementary constituents of all the other habits within
the hierarchy. 2. There are habits of a higher order which, embracing the lower
as elements, are themselves in turn, elements of higher habits, and so on. (3) A
habit of any order, when thoroughly acquired, has physiological, and, if conscious,
psychological unity. The habits of lower order which are its elements, tend to
lose themselves in it, and it tends to lose itself in habits of higher order when it
appears as an element therein. ( 1 )

This hierarchy of functions has been termed by Groos "the monarchistic con-
stitution of the mind." Many other scientific facts and theories could be cited in
substantiation of this view of the matter, such as, for example, Hughlings Jack-
son's three-level theory (2) confirmed by so many clinical experiences, the laws of
reflex action as enunciated by Pflueger, the progressive medullation of nerve fibres
(Flechsig) (3), the development of the individual from fundamental to accessory
activities (Ross), etc. (4)

The hierarchy of instincts and reflexes which represents to us the bequest of
the unconquerable past is still further extended and enlarged in the acquisition of
the social heritage. This also is transmitted to us in hierarchical fashion, and
owing to the plasticity of the nervous system in youth, is acquired educationally
by the young. Thus acquired habits tend to represent the ideals, laws and stand-
ards of a very highly developed society. The imperial tone of our ideals re-echoes
the sovereign behests of accumulated wisdom. The "Stern Daughter of the Voice
of God" gives utterance to few justifying reasons — they have been lost in a long-
forgotten past.

Thus conscience grows. As there is no one imagination but an imagination
for each sensory cortical area and for each system of ideas, so there may be said
to be not one conscience but many, a conscience for every dominant system of
ideas and reactions, a conscience for this subject of study, for that occupation,
for this person and for that. Furthermore, these consciences form groups and
systems which again are co-ordinated with or subordinated under other groups.
Each dominant habit thus forms an imperative, with possible exceptions and
conditions, but all are subject to the Categorical Imperative of Social Service.

Character is therefore a vast system of smaller systems of habits, the hier-
archical constitution (5) of our natures probably extending even to molecular
structure. It is as if the railroad systems of a country were all consolidated into
one system or organization with one board of managers at its head directing an
almost endless chain of subordinates. The systems of thoughts and habits form
groups of systems, as for instance, in those cases where home and club life are
used to serve business aims or where business enterprises and social life are sub-
servient to the dominant habits of home life. A man's specialty or skill may be

(1) Bryan and Harter, Studies on the Telegraphic Language, loc. cit., pp. 360-

361.

(2) Hughlings Jackson, Remarks on Evolution and Dissolution of the Nervous

System, Journal of Mental Science, April, 1887, pp. 25-48.

(3) Flechsig, Gehirn und Seele, Leipsig, 1806.

(4) Ross, Diseases of the Nervous System, 1885, p. 83, flF. Burk, From Funda-

mental to Accessory in the Development of the Nervous System, Peda-
gogical Seminary, Vol. VI (1898), pp. 5-64.

(5) Ribot. in his Diseases of Will (1894), p. 113, also discusses hierarchic co-

ordination.

27

a system quite different from that of his religion or artistic life, hia common sense
being usually a special system of uncommon sense or skill in some line of thought
or action. His success is tantamount to the organization of his groups of systems
of habits in such a way that they are a factor in the public service. "Prolligacy
consists not in spending, but in spending off the line of one's career." In der
Beschraenktheit eeigt sich der Meister. Without the monarchistic constitution
in the organization of habits one's actions are unstable as water, or remind us of
the eternal rolling of a Sisyphus stone.

"It is striking how easily dexterities are acquired, if sufficient limitation is
exercised. One-sidedness produces virtuosity. He who admires a spider for spin-
ning his web, should bear in mind how limited his other faculties are. Nor should
he forget that the spider did not learn his art himself, but that it was acquired
slowly by innumerable generations of spiders and that this art is almost all they
learned. Man takes to his bow and arrow if his nets fail to catch him food, but
the spider must starve." ( 1 )

Character may be said to be the sum total of our habits. As such only an in-
finitesimal part is present in consciousness at any time, different habits and dif-
ferent systems functioning at different times. Thus the major part of character
is latent or potential, the present thought and action being a function of that po-
tential character. As in the kaleidoscope, only one system is in view at a time.
At one time Dr. Jekyll and at another Mr. Hyde is in the ascendency. The elec-
tric light is turned on in this room of the mansion while the others are in the
dark; as the servant passes through the different rooms each room is lit in turn
but is left to darkness the moment she leaves one room for another. This explains
the many-sidedness of our natures, the different aspects of our characters which
we manifest to our friends at different times, many inconsistencies of conduct,
changing ideals in life, alternating personalities, conversion of opinion, and many
similar matters. (2)

This organization into systems extends also to the extra-organic. One who is
master of himself uses his sense and motor organs as tools and instruments for
the furtherance of some higher plan. In the same way tools and instruments, an-
imals and human beings are systematized in the carrying out of great commercial
plans. Nevertheless the master in any field of activity must transform his lieuten-
ant from a mere dependent and tool into a sympathetic participant in the fortune
and honor of his establishment, must open the path to individual promotion, must
give to industry and genius their legitimate share and must make his force of men
and mechanics a co-operative band of willing workers aiming at the accomplish-
ment of the ideals and purposes of the whole system. Good school government is
obviously based on the same idea. The hierarchical system of organization is but
the universal principle of the division of labor.

3. Habit and interest. The theory somewhat generally accepted by psycholo-
gists that pleasure is the psychical accompaniment of the discharge of surplus-
stored energy and that pain is the accompaniment of an abnormal discharge due

(1) Ewald Hering, Memory as a General Function of Organized Matter, Open

Court Co., 1895.

(2) Note the derivation of such words as morality, ethics, habit, character, etc.,

etc.

to excessive stimulation or drain on tho reserve ( 1 ) , is, if true, pedagogically very
interesting on account of the conclusions which may naturally be drawn from it.
It may be taken for granted that surplus-stored energy will tend to accumulate in
those nerve cells and muscles which function habitually. This increased function
will, up to a certain limit, be accompanied by increase in strength, assimilative
capacity and directive power; that is to say, the habit will be accompanied by
greater pleasure, and on the psychological side the interest becomes more and more
dominant and imperious. The interest is, hotoever, the sign and symbol of the un-
derlying controlling habit.

Progressive habituation often produces pleasure and interest. Kipling's Gal-
ley Slave is an instance of Rousseau's saying that slaves lose all in their chains,
even a desire to leave them, and that tranquillity of life can also be found in a
prison.

"But to-day I leave the galley and another takes my place;
There's my name upon the deck-beam — let it stand a little space.
I am free — to watch my messmates beating out to open main
Free of all that life can offer — save to handle sweep again.

By the brand upon my shoulder, by the gall of clinging steel,
By the welt the whips have left me, by the scars that never heal,
By eyes grown old with staring through the sun-wash on the brine,
I am paid in full for service — ^would that service still were mine!"

The prisoner of Chillon says,

"I learned to love despair.

♦ ♦ » * » * •

My very chains and I grew friends,
So much a long communion tends
To make us what Ave are: — even I
Regained my freedom with a sigh."

Interests are therefore indicative or symbolic of habits and of growing capaci-
ties. We do not things because they are interesting, but because they are habit-
ual. Imperious interests are imperious habits.

Habits may also be imperious without being interesting, for in addition to the
instincts, reflex acts and secondarily automatic activities which may be unaccom-
panied by consciousness, the somewhat general consensus of physiological psychol-
ogists may be cited in support of the view that there are perceptions and ideas
and accordingly habits, which are unaccompanied by either pleasure or pain. A
pedagogy or an ethics built on the basis of interest is, therefore, not only incom-
plete in so far as it omits those acts which are indifferent to pleasure and pain — a
large part of life — but also is deficient in causal explanation. Its analysis is not
ultimate. It deals with signs and symbols — pleasure and pain — and not with the
underlying controlling factors, viz., habits. A calculus of pleasure must give way

(1) It is a common saying that a man is as old as his arteries. Many an indi-
vidual in adult life lives on a lower level because of over-strain, never-
ending examinations and demands too urgent for the organism still in its
formative stages. The surplus energy and the consequent interest or
zest in life are lacking. On the other hand a too superficial training
in youth will produce similar results.

29

to a calculus of habit, and individual appreciation must give way to social service.
We follow our likings and inclinations because that is the way we are built.
Function acts in harmony with structure. "It is because of this invariable expe-
rience of its moral and vital results that the new education follows the 'liking*
of the boy; because 'liking' is in very deed 'the great ruler'; because it is here,
in the real needs of our nature — in our need for struggle, conflict; in our need
for expression, for creation ; in our need for being of use, for taking a hand in
the game; in our love of home, of country; because it is here, and not in the
visible pedagogue, that we find the real schoolmaster, the stern, the inexorable
one, the one who lays upon us the tasks that are really hard, who makes the
calls upon our powers which they must hear and obey, and leaves in his track a
more living power and a more far reaching and a firmer will." (1)

Every interest implanted means a habit implanted, and that means that
the pupil becomes automatically progressive along that line. His interests are
his teachers. He pursues ends of his own accord. This is the essence of the
democratic idea: every man self-acting, his own teacher, an autocracy of each
individual. The undemocratic forms of government treat the individual as an
infant or as a potential political criminal. According to Hegel the history of
mankind is a progress in the consciousness of freedom. Freedom, like Protest-
antism, may possibly be defined as doing what you please, following your inter-
ests, likings or habits. Whether those habits are determined in their nature,
members of an all-embracing causal chain, would still remain a matter of inves-
tigation; some writers, however, claiming that determinism and free will are
like the lion and the lamb lying down together — with the lamb inside the lion.

Spinoza, in the same spirit, endeavors to explain psychologically this feel-
ing of freedom by citing facts in support of his statement that we think we are
free because we are ignorant of the causes of our actions. There is certainly a
manifest difference between those acts which are performed because of external
compulsion and those performed because of individual initiative, interest or habit.
The scientific justification for freedom and democracy evidently lies in the fact
that men, allowed to follow their "bent," capacity or interest, will accomplish
more than if subjected to external compulsion. Some will fail, others will be-
come "cranks" and idiosyncratics, but in the long run the progress of the mass
will probably be greater.

Habit and interest also play an important role in the acquisition of knowl-
edge. One of the prime conditions necessary for the attainment of knowledge
is that new facts be associated with the facts already attained. Isolated facts
possess little foothold in memory. If, therefore, the interests or habits of the
pupil be aroused to such an extent that he thinks over the new facts ( psycholog-
ically speaking, associated ideas are aroused ) , then the new facts are attached
or linked to the older system and will henceforth belong to that system. In
the associational life of the individual, isolation means oblivion. Organization
or incorporation into systems means everything. Appealing to past habits is
simply linking or grafting on new facts to older systems. A prime pedagogical

(1) Joseph Lee, Miinsterberg on the New Education, Educational Review, Sept.,
1900, p. 137.

30

necessity, then, is to keep interests, i. e., older habit-H, aroused in every subject.
To live without interest is to live without initiative; the throttle is closed and
nothing but external compulsion will move the machine. One of the worst
curses that can befall a nation or individual is what a German writer has called
verdammtc licdiwrfnisslosigkeit. Instead, therefore, of barely assigning a new
lesson, let the interests and needs of the pupil be lirst aroused by stirring up
a problem, giving some interesting information, solving one of the new prob-
lems, asking pupils to hunt up all the information possible on the new topic,
asking the pupils to tell the teacher the facts about the next lesson without her
asking for them, etc., etc. Assimilation of new knowledge is not assimilation,
it is a concatenation, combination, linkage — or in short, association. Let the old
habit react on the new and the new becomes the old. "Any object not interesting
in itself may become interesting through becoming associated with an object in
which an interest already exists. The tw» associated objects grow, as it were,
together: the interesting portion sheds its quality over the whole; and thus
things not interesting in their own right borrow an interest which becomes as
real and as strong as that of any natively interesting thing. The odd circum-
stance is that the borrowing does not impoverish the source, the objects taken
together being more interesting, perhaps, than the originally interesting portion
was by itself." "From all these facts there emerges a very simple abstract
program for the teacher to follow in keeping the attention of the child: Be-
gin with the line of his native interests and offer him objects that have some
immediate connection with these." "Next, step by step, connect with these first
objects and experiences the latter objects and ideas which you wish to instill.
Associate the new with the old in some natural and telling way, so that the
interest, being shed along from point to point, finally suffuses the entire system
of objects of thought." (1)

4. The end of habit. The end of habit should be social utility, a character
devoted to social service. "Character means power of social agency, organized
capacity of social functioning. It means social insight or intelligence, social
executive power, and social interest or responsiveness." (2) That man is there-
fore educated who knows and feels the needs of society, has the ability to pro-
mote them, and has the willingness and disposition to do so. "As to methods,"
says Dr. Dewey, "this principle" — that man exists for society, and that the
school should be a social community which reflects and organizes the fundamen-
tal prwiciples of all community life — "when applied, means that emphasis must
be upon construction and giving out, rather than upon absorption and mere
learning. We fail to recognize how essentially individualistic the latter methods
are, and how unconsciously, yet how certainly and etf^ectively, they react into
the child's way of judging and of acting. Imagine forty children all engaged in
reading the same books, and in preparing and reciting the same lessons day after
day. Suppose that this constitutes by far the larger part of their work, and
that they are continually judged from the standpoint of what they are able to
take in in a study hour, and to reproduce in a recitation hour. There is next

(1) James' Talks to Teachers (New York), 1899, pp. 94-96.

(2) Dewey, Third Year Book of the National Herbart Society.

31

to no opportunity here for any social or moral division of labor. There is na
opportunity for each child to work out something specifically his own, which be
may contribute to the common stock, while he, in turn, participated in the pro-
ductions of others. All are said to do exactly the same work and turn out the
same results. The social spirit is not cultivated — in fact, in so far as this
method gets in its work, it gradually atrophies from lack of use." (1)

To be of social service, habits of expression must be cultivated in order to
utilize the habits of impression. As James puts it, "No reception without re-
action; no impression without correlative expression — this is the great maxim
which the teacher ought never to forget. An impression which simply flows ini
ftt pupils' eyes or ears, and in no way modifies his active life, is an impression
gone to waste. It is physiologically incomplete. It leaves no fruits behind it
in the way of capacity acquired. Even as mere impression, it fails to produce
its proper effect upon the memory; for, to remain fully among the acquisition*
of this latter faculty, it must be wrought into the whole cycle of our operations.
Its motor consequences are what clinch it. Some effects due to it in the way of
an activity must return to the mind in the form of the sensation of having'
acted, and connect itself with the impression. The most durable impressions are
those on account of which we speak or act, or else are inwardly convulsed." (2)

"When we turn to modern pedagogics, we see how enormously the field of
active conduct has been extended by the introduction of all these methods of con-
crete object teaching which are the glory of our contemporary schools. Verbal"
reactions, useful as they are, are insufficient. The pupil's words may be right,,
but the conceptions corresponding to them are often direfully wrong. In a mod-
ern school, therefore, they form only a small part of what the pupil is requiredl.
to do. He must keep notebooks, make drawing, plans and maps, take measure-
ments, enter the laboratory and perform experiments, consult authorities and*
write essays. He must do in his fashion what is often laughed at by outsiders-
when it appears in prospectuses under the title of "original work," but what is
really the only possible training for the doing of original work thereafter. The-
most colossal improvements which recent years have seen in secondary educa-
tion lie in the introduction of the manual training schools; not because they^
will give us a people more handy and practical for domestic life and better
skilled in trades, but because they will give us citizens with an entirely different
intellectual fibre. Laboratory work and shop work engender a habit of observa-
tion, a knowledge of the difference between accuracy and vagueness, and an in-
sight into nature's complexity and into the inadequacy of all abstract verbal
accounts of real phenomena, which, once wrought into the mind, remain there
as life-long possessions. They confer precision; because if you are doing a
thing, you must do it definitely right or definitely wrong. They give honesty;
for, when you express yourself by making things, and not by using words, it
becomes impossible to dissimulate your vagueness or ignorance by ambiguity.
They beget a habit of self-reliance; they keep the interest and attention always

(1) Dewey, Third Year Book of the National Herbart Society.

(2) James, loc. cit.

18

cheerfully engaged, and reduce the teacher's disciplinary functions to a mini-
mum." (1)

It is also true, on the other hand, that excessive kinesis prevents formation
of steady, persistent, consecutive habits of thought, just as excessive aesthesis
tends to form a "walled-up" mind without executive power and hence without
utility. A true character, like true ideas, is composed of habits (ideas, feelings
tknd actions), which are really successful habits, habits which prove themselves
socially fruitful. (2)

II. SOME RECENT EXPERIMENTAL CONCLUSIONS ON PRACTICE AND

HABIT. (3)

/. Expenditure of Nervous Energy — Nervous energy discharged in a part
of the brain by peripheral or central stimulation tends to cause a diffusion of
nervous impulses over other nervous areas. Thus the ticking of the feet may
start nervous impulses to every part of the nervous system. A telegram may
cause great visceral and emotional disturbances. A small amount of strychnine
introduced into the system will aid this process of nervous diffusion, causing
quicker reaction and often irritability. Nervous weakness, epilepsy, etc., are
conditions favorable to diffusion. This diffusion of nervous impulses, normal
and abnormal, is the physiological basis of association of ideas and actions, and
is thus a fundamental factor in our psychical life.

2. Specialization in Diffusion — Instead of a chaotic diffusion, nervous im-
pulses may gradually take definite channels, following lines of least resistance.
Inherited reflexes and instincts and formerly acquired habits may outline the
growth of such paths or habits. The establishment of such paths means a limi-
tation of the diffusion and an increase of the amount and force in the definite
specialized channels thus established. With progress in habituation this energy
expended may in time be limited or increased to meet the requirements of
the case.

"Practice makes perfect" means no waste by diffusion, and the least expen-
diture of energy needful. (4) Martin's description of the education of the
spinal cord is in point here. "Much of what is called educating our touch or
our muscles is really education of the spinal cord. A person who begins to play
the piano finds at first much difficulty in moving his fingers independently; the
nervous impulses from the brain to the cord radiate from the spinal centers of
the muscle which it is desired to move, to others. But with practice the inde-
pendent movements become easy. So, too, the localizing power of the skin can
be greatly increased by exercise, as one sees in blind persons who can often dis-
tinguish two stimuli on parts of the skin which are so near together as to give

(1) James' Talks to Teachers (New York), 1899, p. 36.

(2) Cf. Georg Simmel, Ueber eine Beziehung der Selectionslehre zur Erkennt-

nisstheorie, Archiv. f. sys. Philos. Bd. 1, Heft 1, p. 34.

(3) Reprinted by courtesy of the editor of the Journal of Pedagogy (Vol. XIV,

No. 3).

(4) Note the similarity of phenomena in physiological, economic and territorial

division of labor. ^ — ^"T, — ---.

33 / OF T,

( UNI

3 V ^

- - - \-YC^

OF T,,

IVERSITY )

to other people only one sensation. Such phenomena depend on the fact that the
more often a nervous impulse has traveled along a given road in the gray mat-
ter, the easier does its path become, and the less does it tend to wander from it
into others. We may compare the gray matter to a thicket; persons seeking
to beat a road through from one point to another would keep the same general
direction, determined by the larger obstacles in the way, but all would diverge
more or less from the straight path on account of the undergrowth, tree trunks,
etc., and would meet with considerable difficulty in their progress. After some
hundreds had passed, however, a tolerably beaten track would be marked out,
along which travel would be easy and all after-comers would take it. If in-
stead of one entry and «ne exit we imagine thousands of each, and that of the
paths between, certain have been often traveled, others less and some hardly at
all, we get a pretty good mental picture of what happens in the passage of
nervous impulses through the gray matter of the cord; the clearing of the more
trodden paths answering to the effects of use and practice. The human cord
and that of the frog must not, however, be looked upon as pathless thickets at
the commencement; each individual inherits certain paths of least resistance,
determined by the structure of the cord, which is the transmitted material result
of the life experience of a long line of ancestry." (1)

3. Law of Short Exercise — ^A short exercise often repeated is preferable
to long drawn-out practice for the rapid development of accurate adjustment of
the muscles. Long uninterrupted practice at writing, drawing, piano playing,
etc., wastes time and energy, cultivates inattentive habits and strengthens those
wrong variations and adjustments which tend to gain a place in the chain of
unconscious reactions. (2)

4. Law of Greatest Initial Gain — The greatest gain in rapidity and regu-
larity of muscular action is made during the first periods of exercise; the rate
of progress diminishes as practice continues at each experiment, as well as at
successive experiments. (3) As the muscles come more completely under con-
trol, the influence of practice becomes less during each experiment. The "curve
of practice," i. e., the curve of change for a continuous experimental session,
seems to be very similar to the "curve of habit," i. e., the curve of change for
successive sessions. In both alike the gain is most rapid in the tirst part of
the exercise. In the latter part of the exercises progress is less perceptible; it
is the stage of the expert. The experiments of Ebbinghaus and others in the
learning of nonsense-syllables all bear out the same law. (4) Consciousness as
an accompaniment of the habit tends to disappear the more automatic the habit
becomes, the reason probably being that the nervous resistance gradually be-

(1) Martin, Human Body, pp. 580, 581.

(2) W. Smythe Johnson, Researches in Practice and Habit, 1889. Yale Univer-

sity Thesis, pp. 25, 14-25, 51.

(3) Ibid. pp. 14, 17. This has a causal connection with one of the laws of mus-

cular work: "When a muscle begins to contract, it can lift the largest
load; as the contraction proceeds, it can lift only a less and less load,
and when it is at its maximum of shortening, only relatively very light
loads." (Landois-Stirling, p. 606, Vol. II., 4th Ed.)

(4) Ebbinghaus, Grundzlige der Psychologie, Bd. I, Theil II. Pp. 624 ff.

34

comes less during the growth of the habit. "Man wird taglieh dummer, aber
brauchbarer," as a Badischer Beamter puts it.

5. Jjaw of Minimum (Jain — A minimum gain in rapidity during any prac-
tice period seems to be the best condition for impressing a habit upon the ner-
vous system. The decrease of maladjustments, disadvantageous variations and
hence probable error, is noticeable in a process of steady habituation
as compared with a process in which spasmodic accelerations take place. ( 1 )
To attain the standard aimed at in the practice each error has to be rectified
and a new habit begun. Thus three units of time (1) the time lost in
the establishment of the error which might have been employed in acquiring the
correct habit, (2) the time occupied by the obstructiveness of the bad habit,
and (3) the founding of the new habit in the face of the old one, are taken where
only one unit was necessary. Add to this the uncertainty of future behavior
due to the persistence of the bad habit. It must be remembered that habits
remain with us, though latent, even if they are superseded by better ones. If
the subject puts forth the greatest etlort in the beginning of an experiment, the
error is correspondingly greater in the first part. But when the special effort
is relaxed, muscles revert to their more accustomed speed of adjustment, and
at the same time become more regular in their functioning. Ebbinghaus, in his
experiments with nonsense-syllables, (2) discovered a psychological law which
may have decided bearings on pedagogical practice. In the learning of a row
of twelve nonsense-syllables, sixty-eight repetitions, each repetition immediately
following its predecessor, were found to be less advantageous than thirty-eight
repetitions of another row, which repetitions were distributed over three suc-
cessive days. In other words, a distribution of the effort over several days with
a relatively small amount of effort expended each day involves less effort in the
sum total and a better result than the massing of effort at one period of time.
G. E. Mueller, Jost, and Pilzecker have also confirmed these results by other
experiments. (3) Jost also proved that the result was not due to fatigue in
the case of the massing of the effort at one time. He also found that the results
of the distribution of effort over a larger area of time was still more advan-
tageous, i. e., two repetitions on twelve successive days was better than eight re-
petitions on three successive days.

For pedagogical practice this is obviously important. The student reviews
in the morning that which he has learned over night; the teacher holds numerous
reviews and quizzes, and even the much abused examination receives some justi-
fication. The advertiser insists this week on what he insisted last week, and
you are now quite firmly convinced that what he says is true, although you have
never made a personal examination.

6. Practice and Attention — "The practice at each sitting should last only
so long as the movements are purposely directed." (3) "Purposeful attention
and persistent effort on the part of the subject are the two most essential ele-

(1) Yale Psychological Studies, loc. cit.. p. 9.

(2) Ebbinghaus, Crrundziige, etc., pp. 029 ff.

(3) Jost. Die Associationsfestigkoit in ihrer Abhangigkeit von der Verteilung der

Wiederholungen. Zeitschr. f. Psych. Bd. 14, S. 430. Mueller u. Pil-
zecker, Experimentelle Beitraege zur Lehre vom Gedachtnis, Zeitsch. f.
Psych., Erganzungsband. 1, 1900.

35

ments in practice for the establishment of any definite mode of muscular ac-
tion." (1) This seems to be true especially of the beginning of practice, but
towards the end, when the feelings and actions of an expert begin to manifest
themselves, I venture to suggest that attention and consciousness may be at
times harmful. In the first stages, however, attention means both an excellent
nutritional condition of the muscles and nerve cells and excellent powers of co-
ordination of movements to definite ends. Practice produces a more lasting and
accurate habit when the muscles and nervous system are in an excellent condi-
tion of metabolism. Fatigue and weariness render success almost impossi-
ble. (2)

7. Advantage of Muscular over Sensorial Reaction — In so-called reaction
time experiments, a technical term for those experiments in which the time
is measured which elapses, to take one example, between, say, the perception of
a sound and one's reaction to it by pressing a reaction-key — there is a decided
difference in time between the sensorial reaction tj'^pe and the muscular reaction
type. In the "extreme muscular" type, as Lange, its first observer, called it, the
attention of the person reacting is kept on the finger which is about to press the
key as soon as the sound is perceived; in the "extreme sensorial" type the atten-
tion is kept on the sound-signal. Herr Lange's own muscular time averaged
0'M23; his sensorial time, 0".230.

May not the fact of this difference in reaction be important pedagogically
in so far as attention to the motor reaction rather than to the suggestion or
copy produces greater rapidity, more correctness and less irregularity? Since
suggestion and imitation play such important roles the matter is worthy of more
extended experimental investigation and possible application.

8. Summation of Stimuli — By this is meant that a single weak stimu-
lus, which is of itself incapable of discharging a reflex act, may, if repeated
sufficiently often, produce this act. Ihe single impulses are conducted to the
central nervous system, in which the process of summation takes place. So far
as purely reflex acts are concerned, Rosenthal found that three feeble stimuli
per second are capable of producing the effect, although sixteen stimuli per sec-
ond are most effective. (3) W. Stirling, according to Landois-Stirling, has
shown it to be extremely probable that all reflex acts are due to the repetition
of impulses in the nerve centers. (4) The psychological experiment is well
known of stimulating the leg of a brainless frog a number of times if the first
stimulation does not succeed.

The sound of a doorbell may not call up much of a motor response, but
repeated often (Halloween night) may cause a very considerable response. A
slight tickling when one is asleep or awake may, if continued, produce convul-
sive responses. "To strike a horse repeatedly on the same spot is to invite
him to kick." Continued dropping of water from a faucet during the night, or
the intermittent sounds of a mouse gnawing, produce extreme irritability.

(1) Yale Psychological Studies, p. 25.

(2) lb. p. 16.

(3) See Landois-Stirling, Vol. II, 606-617, on the conditions of muscular ac-

tivity.

(4) Landois-Stirling, Vol. II, p. 785 (4th Ed.).

36

stories of ingenious systems of torture of a similar nature for prisoners will
readily occur to the reader. Repeated losses, as, e. g., Job's, continued insults,
mannerisms, especially of those one dislikes, continued criticism of one's per-
sonal appearance, continued disobedience of one's requests in classroom work,
old songs, old stories, etc., are instances in point. Continued acts of kindness
and love or of hate produce eventually a strong and steady disposition in the
recipient. Similarly with repeated dreams in the minds of the nervous or
superstitious.

Nagging is one continuous jerking at the reins of authority. Nerves are,
said to be "worn to a frazzle" by this unintermittent process. The sheer ex-
haustion of patience is a popular equivalent for the scientific phrase of sum-
mation of stimuli. The process is the same in the irritation produced by, say,
an ill-fitting garment, as it is in the rebellious thoughts Induced by the small
talk and small thoughts of a more or less constant companion. Nagging often
originates in an excessive narrowing or widening of interests. Too many duties
are assumed, or there are not enough on which the full tide of vital activities
can be expended. In the one case exhaustion supervenes, and in the other the
horizon is filled with petty trifles and wrong perspectives.

This law is of wide general application, as is evidenced by a multitude of
facts. In the schoolroom the teacher's loud voice, nagging, slovenly dress or
gait, mannerisms of speech and gesture, tone of voice, low ideals of thought
and behavior may finally cause a very decided revulsion. The steady persistence
of higher types of thought and feeling will as surely culminate in action.
Good examples should act as the drama acts, by suggestion rather than by
homily. A confiding young son once told his father that he didn't like his
-^.unt Jane. When asked the reason he said, "Oh, she's always talking about
G-a-w-d." In approaching a German theater one generally meets a number of
vendors of the programmes or of the words of the play. One approaches the
first of them with a confident shake of the head, but by the time the last one
is reached, confidence has collapsed and the summation of stimuli has accom-
plished its mission. The psychology of advertising shows many evidences of this
law. "Pears' soap is the best." Temptation in all its forms usually works by
the summation of stimuli. The young man of slight moral resistance, on his
way home in the evening, passes through one, it may be two, streets of saloons;
in the third street his inhibitory power is exhausted and he passes helplessly
through the doors.

9. Cross-Education — Training of one portion of the body trains at the
same time the symmetrical part and also neighboring parts. (1) Volkmann
lelates (2) experiments showing that practice of the finger tip of the left hand
increases the fineness of the touch of the finger-tip of the right hand, but does
not increase that of the left forearm. Practice on the third phalanx increases

(1) E. W. Scripture, Theodate Smith and Emily M. Brown, in Yale Psycholog-

ical Studies, Vol. 2, pp. 114-119, 1894.

(2) Volkmann, Ueber den Einfluss der Uebung auf das Erkennen rauemlicher

Distanzen, Ber. d. k. Saechs. Ges. d. Wiss., math.-phys. Kl. 1858, X38.

37

the fineness on the first phalanx. Fechner ( 1 ) relates an observation by Weber
on the ability to write with the left hand obtained by learning with the right
hand. Fechner states that practice in writing the figure nine backwards with
the left hand frequently caused him involuntarily to write the nine backward
when he used the right.

These observations, says Scripture, seemed of sutticient importance to justify
a further inquiry regarding the general law of education followed by our muscu-
lar abilities, and also regarding the possibility of what he briefly calls "cross-
education." His conclusions were that the increase of steadiness of movement
due to practice is not limited to the control of the muscles immediately trained,
but affects the control of the corresponding muscles on the opposite side of the
body. This training seems to be of a psychical rather than of a physical order
and to lie principally in steadiness of attention. (2)

Scripture's hypothesis (3) ipr explaining cross-education is, "physiologically
speaking, that the development of the center governing a particular member
causes at the same time the development of higher centers connected with groups
of members, psychologically speaking, development of the will power as a whole."
Diffusion of nervous energy into neighboring nerve cells following most accus-
tomed paths, i. e., lines of least resistance, seem to explain to a large extent these
phenomena of cross-education. (4)

10. The Law of the "Plateau" — Bryan and Harter, in their experiments on
habit (5), claim that the improvement in learning to receive telegraphic mes-
sages, while rapid for a time, ceases at a point just below the required pro-
ficiency, to be followed later by a stage of more rapid improvement. "For many
weeks there is an improvement which the student can feel sure of, and which is
proved by objective tests. Then follows a long period when the student can feel
no improvement and objective tests show little or none. At the last end of the
plateau the messages in the main line are, according to the unanimous testi-
mony of all who have experience in the matter, a senseless clatter to the
student, practically as unintelligible as the same messages were months before.
Suddenly, within a few days, the change comes, and the senseless clatter becomes
intelligent speech. W. S. Johnson affirms that the "plateaus" mentioned by
Bryan in the habit curve would seem rather to indicate resting periods in the
effort. If the subject can be induced to sustain the same effort day by day,
there will not be any "plateaus" in the habit curve. (6)

( 1 ) Fechner, Beobachtungen, welche zu beweisen seheinen, dass durch die Uebung

der Glieder der einen Seite die der anderen zugleich mitgeuebt werden,
Ber. d. k. Sachs. Ges. d. Wiss., math.-phys. Kl., 1858, X. 70.

(2) Scripture, Smith and Brown, op. cit., p. 118.

(.3) Scripture, Recent Investigations in the Yale Laboratory, Psych. Rev., 1899,
VI. 165.

(4) Note the similarity in Pflueger's Laws of Reflex Action. Note also the ex-

periments of Urbantschitsch and Patrick's observations on right-handed-
ness in the University of Iowa Studies in Psychology, Vol. I, 1897. For
further observations the reader is referred to Walter W. Uavis, Re-
searches in Cross-Education, Studies from the Yale Psychological Labo-
ratory, Vol. VI, 1898, and Vol. VIII.

(5) Bryan and Harter, Studies in the Physiology and Psychology of the Tele-

graphic Language, Psych. R., Vol. IV, No. 1, p. 52.

(6) Loc. cit., p. 33.

38

11. The Law of Sudden Attainment — After some study practice and experi-
mentation (period of trial and probation) the goal of the effort is suddenly at-
tained, the knack is acquired, the expert emerges from the novice stage. In the
experimental stage the nervous energy seems to be diffused at random for some
time, partial habits are formed, but the paths are not complete enough for easy
action. Other and older habits perhaps tend to drain off the energy diffused, thus
weakening the growing habits. This is instanced by the worry and confusion of
thought of a business man. Small details will appear as important as the main
items, but let him sleep over the matter and in the morning his affairs will ap-
pear in their true proportions. In the acquirement of a new language many per-
sons experience this feeling of sudden mastery. Religious conversions are often
but the culmination of long but concealed effort. Joy comes with the cessation of
the inhibitory processes and with the final establishment of the habit. No man
can serve with joy two masters. In matters of courtship the young man often
says, "It seems I have known her for years." His long cherished ideals have
suddenly met their realization. Habits of thought are freed from their inhibition
and joy is the result.

12. Gain in Rapidity and Accuracy through Rhythm — Energy is saved,
time gained, accuracy increased and amount of product enlarged by rhythmic
movements. If the output of energy is so regulated that it follows a certain pro-
portion and so regulated that the beginning and end of a movement always lie be-
tween the same spatial and temporal boundaries, we have the essence of habit and
practice. Habit and practice largely mean equal intervals occupied by movements
and equally strong movements of the same muscle or group of muscles. Propor-
tion is its main characteristic. When freed from interference by the higher cen-
tres and the will the proportion in expenditure of time and energy is likely to be
better maintained by the lower centres. When influenced by the higher centres
(intelligence), the movement is likely to be hindered or accelerated by other ideo-
motor associations. Fatigue, a subjective measure of work performed, is less
likely to arise the more practiced and habitual the movement maybe. Fatigue
more easily ensues when the amount of energy expended is at one time too great'
and at another time too small and when the intervals are irregular, demanding
extra adjustments, etc. (1)

In the progress of socialization of the race through technic we see the same in-
fluence of rhythm. It is well known that the machine is useful because it saves
time and labor but does this because of its rhythmic action. It can only enter
with profit where movements are repeated with due uniformity, with the greatest
lapidity, and where often the action of one part of the machine is but one in-
stance out of a thousand similar ones in the same machine {e. g., spinning in a
wool factory). (2) The machine must.be freed from causes of irregularity, such
as change of material, change of caprice in the mind of the operator, etc. The

( 1 ) Karl Buecher, Arbeit und Rhythmus, pp. 26-26.

(2) Schmoller, Grundriss der allgemeinen Volkswirtschaftslehre, Erster Theil,

S. 219: "Die Uniformierung, Mechanlsierung, hoechste Beschleunigung,
und vollendete Praecision, welche das Wesen des machinellen Arbeits-
prozesses characterisiert, wird wohl die ganze Volkswirtschaft indirekt
beeinflussen; tiefgreifend umbilden wird sie nur bestimmte, freilich sehr
erhebliche Telle."

39

machine presupposes many parts performing their individual tasks (division of
labor) and on the part of the object manufactured a division into many parts
which can be made separately. Under these conditions the machine has revolu-
tionized society. Inasmuch as the machine is an extension of the apparatus of
the body, that which has been said of the machine may be inferred to be also
largely true of the body.

13. Law of the Greatest Attainment through Freedom — ^A generation ago
it. was the accepted theory of educators generally that instruction, to be most
eflFective, should cross the grain of the youthful mind ; that if disinclination were
shown to any particular study, the teacher should catch at this as his welcome
clue; and that the scholar should thereafter be practiced and drilled, for his
mind's good, against his indifference, his dislike, and even his repugnance, until
he should learn to do well and freely that for which he had originally the strong-
est inaptitude. In a word, indisposition towards any kind of mental exercise
was to be dealt with like a sinful inclination; war was to be made upon it until
it should be conquered. Not only a better observation of life, but the study of
physiological psychology, has led the educators of today to a widely different view
of the office of instruction. It is now generally admitted that it is the first duty
of the teacher to ascertain the true bent of the youthful mind, and that, so far as
practicable, instruction should be made to conform thereto; that the successful
teacher is not the one who compels the scholar to do at the last reasonably well
that which he was at the first least disposed to do, but the one who brings the
scholar to do, in the fullest degree and in the most perfect manner, that for
which he has the greatest aptitude, leading him, with ever increasing freedom and
pleasure of work, in the way which nature has pointed out; that in any other
system of training there is enormous and irreparable loss of nervous force and
moral enthusiasm, with the result certain to be lower and less desirable than the
system which seeks to develop to their highest efficiency the native powers of the
mind. (1)

14. The Laio of Adequate Exercise — "I desire to challenge peremptorily,"
says General Walker, "the whole policy of giving out exercises of any appreciable
degree of logical difficulty to children of an early age, thoroughly convinced that
such a practice involves, to repeat the phrase already used, bad psychology, bad
physiology and bad pedagogics." (2) General Walker further says, "The notion
that exercises, either mental or physical, prescribed for young children, should be
often up to the full limit of their powers and should at times exceed those powers,
is distinctly false. The true gymnastic for the growing child is through exercises
easy and pleasant, which lead insensibly up to ever higher planes of attainment,
as the faculties are expanded and strengthened, according to their own law of
growth through gentle and agreeable exercise. Wherever fatigue, confusion and
the sense of strain begin, there the virtue of the exercise ceases, whether for the
promoting of the powers as they exist or for creating new powers. Loss and waste
— it may be much, it may be little — begin at this point, and go forward from this
point, at a constantly accelerating ratio.

(1) General Walker, Discussions in Education, p. 225.

(2) Ibid, p. 226.

40

In college, thirty years ago, those of us who were given to athletics were ac-
customed to use heavy dumb-bells, the heavier the better. Twenty-four and thirty-
two pounders; the famous "fifty-sixes" and even eighty- pound dumb-bells were
much in favor with young fellows who desired to become strong. Today a prize
fighter preparing to contest the championship of the world uses, habitually very
light dumb-bells, just heavy enough to give a purpose to his blow, and to be
distinctly felt at the end of the strokes. He makes with the light bell ten strokes
to one he would make with the heavy bell, and gets twice as much good from the
exercise. If this be the part of wisdom for the grown giant, overflowing with
the exuberance of his strength, much more is such a course desirable in the case
of the young, tender children, yet in the gristle, the frame and brain still plastic
and yielding, with the possibilities of manhood and womanhood but dimly inti-
mated.

Whether for the promotion of future growth, or for the training of the
powers as they are, or for the acquisition of the inestimable art of rapid and
accurate computation, school exercises in arithmetic should, in the opinion of the
Boston Board, be easy and simple, with the resulting advantage of becoming more
frequent than is possible, within any reasonable limits of time, in the case of the
highly complicated and difficult sums and problems with which the traditional
gymnastics deals."(l)

The experimental evidence derived from the labors of Eblfinghaus, G. E.
Mueller and others with the learning of nonsense-syllables proves unmistakably
the harm and danger arising from the imposition of excessively large burdens on
the student. The "sums" and problems which even the "master" of the country
school could hardly solve are mostly delightful memories of the "good old times"
and are fortunately disappearing along with the head-splitting "lessons" and un-
explained assignments of the next "ten pages." From the experiments of Ebbing-
haus and others it is surprising to note the confusion, disorder and perplexity
which arises when the number of syllables in each row is increased only a small
amount over the largest number which the mind can master after having them once
presented. In such a case the mind is not able to retain even as many syllables
as were attained when the rows possessed fewer syllables. A priori one might
imagine that at least as many syllables would be retained while the excessive syl-
lables would be omitted, but in reality the inability to master the excessive num-
ber injures also the ability for the lesser and the number of syllables reproduced
after one view of them decreases very rapidly. While, for example, a row of six
nonsense-syllables can be reproduced correctly almost without exception, after
having once been seen, a row of twelve such syllables can only be reproduced in its
first and last number? The subjective certainty also decreases with increase in
number of syllables, the whole row being gradually mastered in parts. Individual
parts once mastered are being continually brought into confusion by other parts
not yet mastered. (2) This confusion introduces inaccuracy of judgment as may
be seen from Bolton's experiments on memory in school children. He found that
there is an apparent tendency to over-estimate the number of ideas presented to

(1) General Walker, Discussions in Education, p. 251.

(2) Ebbinghaus, Grundzuege der Psychologic. Bd. I. Th. II, p. 624.

41

the mind, when the number of ideas is slightly greater than the memory span;
but the general rule is to under-estimate the number. ( 1 )

15. Attainment and Nutrition — In a poor state of health, weakness or
fatigue, more mistakes are possible, and consequently more time and energy are
wasted. Slovenly habits of thought and action are generated. "Perfect inhibi-
tion is the sign of perfect health." Associated ideas and movements fail to ap-
pear, and maladjustments of various kinds occur. Visitors to foreign countries
when fatigued tend to lose command of the language of the country they are vis-
iting. Aphasia is increased in fatigue. What is learned in a state of fatigue is
soon lost. Chronic fatigue produces introspection and consequent loss of objective
associations. Social service is thus impaired. Inability or dislike to bearing
responsibility is another way of saying the same thing. In weakness inattention
gradually merges into abulia.

Fatigue rapidly ensues when the work is distasteful. Maggiora has shown
that more can be accomplished without fatigue when the work is properly
adjusted. Again, damp, muggy days, certain seasons, the time of day, etc., influ-
ence the working capacity of the organism, its interests and its attainments.

Weariness comes to a muscle, not because so much capital has been spent, but
because it has been spent at too quick a rate. Its expenditure is greater than its
income. Whether a muscle wearies or not with action, and how soon it wearies,
will depend not so much on how much work it is called upon to do as on whether
or no the expenditure involved in the work outruns the income. You may take a
weak muscle, that is to say, a muscle with a scanty store of available living stutt',
and a strong muscle, that is to say, one with an ample store; and by timely calls
upon the weak one, and an imperious sudden demand on the strong one, you will
get much work from the former, leaving it still fresh, w^hile the latter is wearied
before it has done a little of the work of the first. (2)

16. Warming Up — Initial or preliminary practice may often induce
fatigue. After a short rest, however, better work, greater rapidity, and a greater
amount of work can be attained than in the beginning of practice. This does not
seem to be of universal application, but it is a quite general phenomenon. It may
be noticed for instance in animals. Dogs on the chase, animals pursued, and es-
pecially race horses, show the effect of warming up.

Athletes, for example, ball-players, realize the importance of practice just be-
fore the game. A pitcher will hardly enter the box until he has his arm in work-
ing order by a few minutes' practice. Orators are often dull at first, but warm up.
Experiments performed by E. G. Lancaster in lifting a weight with the index
finger show the effects of this warming process. In the initial practice the subject
did not lift more than 800 grams before the warming up occurred. In one instance
the subject's warmed-up curve with 600 grams was continued a long time and then
additions were made until he was lifting 1,075 grams, which he raised to a good
height until stopped by the operator. There was a feeling of muscular exaltation
that made it a pleasure to lift the weight after the warming up occurred. In

( 1 ) Th. F. Bolton, The Growth of Memory in School Children, Amer. J. of Psych.,

Vol. IV, No. 4, p. 380.

(2) Sir Michael Foster, "Weariness," Nineteenth Century, September, 1893,

p. 340.

42'

OF THE

UNIVE'^SITV

studying the same phenomenon of warming up was observabk. Keligioua services
and school work beginning with musical exercise exhibit the sHiii6|^proli table pre-
liminary practice.

According to Dr. Lancaster's experiments it is evident that persons "warmed
up" in, say, an intellectual exercise, will show a warmed-up curve in physical
exercise, although they may have rested physically up to the time of the physical
experiment. (1)

It. Influence of Age on Memory — In learning nonsense-syllables, i. e., syl-
lables consisting of a vowel between two consonants, an adult, according to Eb-
binghaus (2) is able to memorize much larger rows of syllables than can chil-
dren. To give a relative estimate, those at the age of 18-20 can reproduce ap-
proximately one and a half times as many syllables as those from 8 to 10 years
of age. After completed bodily development the figures remain practically con-
stant. Ebbinghaus relates that for 20 years the figures have remained the same
for him. Within certain limits we can say that, beginning with the age of 13-15,
the "curve of practice" and the "curve of habit" are repeated in what may be
called the "curve of life," that is to say, the rate of progress is greater in the
beginning, then gradually falling off to a level.

18. Inaccuracy of Subjective Judgments — The objective accuracy of a re-
peated or "reproduced" row of nonsense-syllables and the subjective conscious es-
timate of their correctness do not always, by any means, coincide. A row is re-
peated easily and smoothly as if one had nothing to do with it, and one is consid-
erably surprised to be informed afterwards by the person conducting the exper-
iment that it was wholly and completely correct. Quite frequently the opposite
occurs; the pleasant consciousness that the row has been correctly repeated is
later disturbed by the fact that one or more errors have been made. (3)

Similar phenomena were observed by Prof. Judd, in experiments with illu-
sions. The gradual disappearance of the illusion owing to continued practice was
not a matter of consciousness and hence it could be inferred that the effects of
practice were not always to be judged by subjective opinion, but rather by object-
ive results. (4)

In the general phenomena of weariness it is quite frequently noticeable that
the subjective estimate does not tally correctly with the real state of the bod^.
Neither does the subjective feeling of exaltation always indicate a favorable con-
dition of metabolism in the body.

One of the most marked characteristics of modern progress is the substitution
of extra-organic instruments and natural forces for the erring and uncertain
sense and motor instruments of the human organism. The stress of the times is
ever toward automatic precision and certainty. '

(1) E. G. Lancaster, Warming Up, Colorado College Studies, Vol. VII, 1898. For

other researches bearing on this point of weariness and recovery the
reader may be referred to Lombard's researches on The Effect of Volun-
tary Muscular Contractions, Amer. J. of Psychology, Vol. Ill, pp. 24-25.
Lombard's experiments seem to point to the central nervous system as
the seat of the successive rhythmic changes of weariness and recovery.

(2) Ebbinghaus, op. cit., p. 621.

(3) Ebbinghaus, op. cit, p. 623.

(4) C. H. Judd, Practice and Its Effects on the Perception of Illusions, Psych.

Rev., Jan., 1902, p. 32.

43

THE LAW OF ACCELERATION AND INCREASE OF
SENSORY STIMULATION.

ARTHUR ALLIN.

The fact that Pestalozzi's simple but wonderful intuitions have been followed
by such magnificent fruit is ample testimony to the genius of the man. The
school systems which have been founded upon his doctrine of sensory instruction
are living monuments to the memory of this poor but genial Swiss. From the
germs of his ideas and life have sprung the kindergarten, the laboratory method,
nature study, manual training, and many other integral factors of our modern
curriculum. His continual cry was one that has been echoed by nearly every
pedagogical reformer since his day: Das Fundament des Unterrichts ist die Ans-
chauung. "The foundation of education lies in sensory observation." "The first
development of thought in the child," he said, "is very much disturbed by a
"wordy system of teaching." His demand that "We must psychologize instruction"
(1) is but the fit and proper helpmate for the more recent demand, "we must so-
cialize the school." Only in the union of these two complementary truths or
processes can education be justified.

That which Pestalozzi discovered empirically and intuitively is based upon
scientific truths. When he insisted persistently on personal observation and the
acquisition of individual experience as a sine qua non of early education he was
but following out the plan laid down by nature. Recent contributions of eminent
histologists have given a scientific justification for this important pedagogic doc-
trine. It may be summed up as the law of Acceleration and Increase of Sensory
Stimulation. This law on the physiological and anatomical side is the justifica-
tion for laboratory methods, manual training, nature study and all object teach-
ing.

From the investigations of Ramon a Cajal (2) and others it is known that
between the sense-organs and the different regions of the cortex there exist closely
connected chains of conductors or neurons by means of which one single impres-
sion taken up by one single element of the chain at the periphery is carried on,
avalanche-like, by an ever increasing number of nerve cells until a very large
number of nerve cells are excited in the cortex.

This appears to be a general law applicable to all the senses. Take for ex-
ample the sense of sight. In the fovea centralis retinae, where visual acuteness

(1) "Ich will den menschlichen ITnterricht psychologisieren."

(2) Ramon a Cajal, Einige Hypothesen ueber den anatomischen Mechanismus

der Ideenbildunjj, der Association und der Aufmerksamkeit. Archiv ftir
Anatomic und Physiologic, 1895. Also: Sur la morphologic et les con-
nexions des elements de la retine des oiseaux. Anatomischer Anzeiger,
1889. Also: Les nouvelles id6es sur la structure du systSme nerveux
2nd Ed., Paris, 1895. Also: The Coronian Lecture in Proceedings of the
Royal Society, Vol. XV, London. Schwalbe, Anatomic der Sinnersor-
ganc;Edinger and others.

45

is the greatest, one rod or cone affected by a ray of light carries the excitation
over to a bipolar cell; this in turn conducts it further to a ganglion cell lying
beneath it (cell of the ganglionic layer) ; this by means of its nerve prolonga-
tions branches out richly in the fore part of the corpora quadrigemina carrying
the excitation over a considerable number of cell groups ; finally the axis cylinders
of these cell groups end in the occipital region of the cortex of the brain, where,
by means of their branches, they come into contact with the bush-like endings of
an innumerable number of pyramidal cells. Thus from a single impression re-
ceived by a single cone, hundreds or perhaps thousands of nerve cells of a cor-
tical area are discharged of their nervous energy.

The same process is observable in reference to the auditory apparatus. One
or two hair cells of the Organ of Corti transmit the excitation of an acoustical
nerve fibre (cell of the ganglion spirale of the cochlea), which on its side contin-
ues the excitation to the ventral acusticus nucleus of the medulla oblongata; here
each acoustical root fibre by means of a bifurcation (Koelliker, Held and others)
and numerous collaterals distributes the movement over numerous nerve cells.
Each of the conductors or axis cylinders of the cells of the ventral nucleus runs to
the corpus trapezoides of the medulla oblongata, where by means of their numer-
ous collaterals, new series of neurons, which lie in the trapezium nucleus, the su-
perior olivary body, the nucleus praeolivaris and the nucleus of the posterior
corpora quadrigemina, enter into the chain of conduction; finally the excitation
reaches the cortex, where it probably spreads over a considerable group of pyra-
midal cells.

This avalanche-like method of conduction is likewise observable, according to
Ramon a Cajal, in the sense apparatus for smell. In fact, it appears to be a gen-
eral arrangement for afferent nerves in general. Golgi, Cajal, von Lenhossek, van
Oehuchten, Koelliker, Retzius and other well known histologists may be cited as
authorities for these statements.

It is therefore evident that no matter how few the peripheral sensory cells
may be which are stimulated, the number of pyramidal cells of the cortex set in
motion by the excitation originating in the periphery is extraordinarily large.
The physical basis therefore of a perception or sense-presentation is not a single
cell, but rather a large number of cortical cells. Each cell in the cortex partici-
pating in a perception maybe a unit functioning often in other perception-com-
plexes. This is very important in the explanation of association, imagination,
memory, etc.

Ramon a Cajal, from whom the major part of these anatomical facts is
taken, suggests that the cortical sensory centers present, according to this view,
a genuine, enlarged and widened projection of the sensory surface of the sense or-
gans, and that, therefore, there exist, as some writers have supposed, a central
retina and a central Organ of Corti. Each peripheral sensory cell, however, is
represented in the cerebral cortex, not by one single pyramidal cell, as so many
popular writers loosely assert, but by a group of such cells.

The exact nature of the nervous excitation is still problematical. It proba-
bly involves the decomposition of highly complex and unstable chemical com-
pounds. It has been likened to a row of card houses or a row of bricks. A dis-

46

turbance, an explosion at one end of the row will set the whole row in commotion,
the movement gathering impetus and momentum as it proceeds. If this be so the
acceleration and increase of nervous excitation in the sensory apparatus Is again
noteworthy.

The following diagram taken from Cajal illustrates the first stages of this
acceleration movement in the sensory mechanism. ( 1 )

y

I

s

(Section of the retina of the chick impregnated by the Golgi method) :

A, giant spongioblast; B, pear-shaped or long-stemmed spongioblast; C,
small or neuroglia spongioblast; D, bipolar cell; E, club (massue) of Landolt;
F, small stick (batonnet) ; G, cone; H, subreticular cellule; /, bipolar ( ?) ; J,
iibre of Mueller.

(This figure contains elements taken from different preparations.)
Furthermore, the primary peripheral stimulus may be almost indefinitely
small but the resulting muscular reaction very large and altogether out of pro-
portion to the strength of the primary excitation, as for example, in convulsions
arising from tickling. It may be that the nerve cells lying in the path or chain
of conduction are of the nature of reservoirs and that the liberated energy of each
nerve cell releases a still greater store in the succeeding nerve cells. Moreover, a
larger number of nerve cells are brought into play and the accumulated nervous
energy of the final total will be out of all proportion to the number at first en-
gaged. The spreading of epileptical convulsions is apparently of this nature.

Important as this law of acceleration and increase may be, another aspect of
the question must, however, not be forgotten. At first sight one might suppose
that if this law is true and valid, then conduct will be shaped and governed by

(1) From the article of Cajal in the Anatomischer Anzieger, cited above.

47

the nature and strength of the impinging stimuli. This, however, would not be
taking into account the fact that the stimuli alTect an already organized structure
which is prepared to react to such and such stimuli and not to others. On the
physiological side some nerve cells are loaded, and on the psycholog-
ical side there are corresponding interests. Storm and besiege the organism
as they may, some stimuli will produce, relatively speaking, no reaction,
while on the other hand persistent, all-embracing or explosive reactions may be
induced by apparently insignificant stimuli. All sorts of delectable oratory may
not persuade the kitten to come nearer to you, but the trailing of a string across
the floor appeals mightily to certain predatory characteristics peculiar to its kind.
The Decalogue contains no commandment for parents to love their children, but
all the thunders of Mount Sinai accompanied the command that children were to
love and honor their parents. A mother sitting in a park surrounded by hun-
dreds of noisy children will hear one little voice of pain above all the rest. It is
evidently the waiting, attending attitude which brings the quick reaction.
Forces are mobilized, ready for action. Where our interests are, there will be
found the track we follow. Taking, therefore, two stimuli of apparently equal
potency, the one that appeals to loaded sense-organs or to central nerve cells
already filled with surplus-stored energy will succeed in eliciting a reaction much
stronger than the one appealing to sense-organs or nerve cells exhausted by work,
worry or disease.

Various phenomena of nervovis action subsidiary and complementary in nature
to this tendency to acceleration and increase of sensory stimulation might be cited
in this connection. For instance, the solidarity of the nervous system is conducive
to the propagation of nervous impulses from, one area or group of nerve cells to
another. This solidarity of function explains to some extent the reinforcement of
currents by other currents from other areas. Pain is reinforced by severe excita-
tion of the auditory or visual areas. Pleasure may be increased also by suitable
excitation of other areas. Thus that which influences one area or group of nerve
cells influences the rest of the system, this unity of function with relative difteren-
tiation of functions of different parts probably constituting the physical basis of
personality.

Motor movements may reinforce other motor movements. Certain occupa-
sensG areas. All the phenomena of encouragement and discouragement may be
cited here as witnesses. Instance a cake-walk, a wrestling match, a schoolboy
fight, hand-clapping and foot-stamping at a contest.

Motor movements may reinforce other motor movements. Certain occupa-
tions induce more lively mental action, and on the other hand lively cerebral or
mental action may induce more rapid corporeal activities. Clenching some ob-
ject in the hand assists some in thinking, assists others in trials of skill, running,
etc. (1) The German habit, sometimes observable, of striking the side of the
nose with the forefinger, and the habit of scratching the head during the solution
of some knotty problem, stimulate the trigeminus nerve endings, thus causing a
larger determination of blood to the brain and increased mental action. (2)

(1) Some of these phenomena can of course be explained as automatisms,

whereby troublesome movements are inhibited.

(2) Lauder Brunton, Action of Medicines, 1899, pp. 168 if.

48

Additional sensory stimulation may call up hy association or suggestion addi-
tional motor movements. 1 need only cite the very fine illustration of Baldwin:
"Suppose we hang up a piece of meat over Carlo's head and tell him to jump for
it. His first jump falls short of the meat. He jumps again and clears a greater
distance. Why does he jump farther the second time? Not because he argues
that a harder jump is necessary to secure the meat, bi\t because by the first jump
he got more smell, blood, color and appetite stimulus from the meat. Now
suppose it to be a red rag instead of meat, and Carlo refuse to jump a second time.
This is not because he coucludes the rag would choke him, but because he gets a
kind of sensation which takes away what appetite stimulus he already had. The
thing is a thing of sensational dynamogeny or suggestion, and the child's state of
mind up to his twenty-fourth month, more or less, is just about the same."

In the dull despair of the teacher, rank incompetence is often charged to the
discredit of the pupil when a wider range of power on the part of the teacher
would have brought into play additional stimuli and thus have secured reac-
tion and self-expression by the pupil.

The law of diffusion of nervous currents throws additional light upon the
matter under discussion. Intense pains, for example, often involve a much larger
area than that injured. It may result in convulsive movements of the whole
body. Musical tones reinforce color and visual discrimination. (1) This law of
diffusion is also exemplified in the association of ideas. From various well known
experiments, stimulation of one sensory area in the cortex is known to reinforce
the activity of neighboring areas. In the association of ideas the nervous process,
whatever it may be, diffuses itself over various areas, but especially in the direc-
tion of one particular area, thereby calling up an associated idea or movement.
The stimulation of the first sensory area necessarily involves by the law mentioned
above the stimulation of a large number of nerve cells in that area. On the
psychical side the accompanying perception will be full of details, vivid and per-
sistent. The idea called up by association will comprise fewer details and may be
less vivid and persistent owing to the probable circumstance that fewer nerve cells
are engaged and less nervous energy involved. Thus perception, the first-hand in-
formation of direct sensory stimulation, is, comparatively speaking, full, vivid,
complete and lasting. Second-hand information, i. e., knowledge of one sense de-
rived by association of ideas from the sense area of first stimulation, is on the
other hand, less complete, somewhat vague, misty and less permanent.

The exceeding importance of this distinction between primary sensory knowl-
edge and second-hand information can hardly be over-emphasized or over-illus-
trated. It is full of meaning and pregnant with consequences, not only in peda-
gogic matters, but in all affairs of life. An illustration from every-day life, sim-
ple and obvious though it may be, may serve to make the distinction clearer. Sup-
pose, for example, that A has been present at the arrest of a man caught in the
performance of a criminal act. Thanks to this process of increasing sensory stim-
ulation, A is possessed of visual perceptions of great vividness, detail and per-
sistency ; he sees, as in a great canvas picture, the actions of the combatants, the
faces of the surrounding crowd, the shrinking attitude of the prisoner, the police-

(1) Urbantschitsch, Amer. Jour, of Psychology, I: 530.

49

man handcufl&ng the accused and marching him off to jail. In A's description of
the affair to B, who was not present, the psychical results produced in B's mind
are of quite different nature from those acquired by A, who was present at th«
disturbance. B's auditory impressions as he listens to th^ descriptions while in
one way somewhat complete because of immediate sensory stimulation may be
classed as second-hand information with all the characteristics of such informa-
tion; but imperfect as it may be, it stands a chance of still greater deterioration,
because in the diffusion of nervous currents from the auditory area to various
parts of the nervous system, and especially to the visual area, only a portion ar-
rives at the visual area, and arouses associated ideas corresponding in some de-
gree with the perceptual visual presentations of A, who was present at the dis-
turbance. In B's visual picture of the occurrence the details are lacking, every-
thing is dim, misty and uncertain. He fails perhaps to see the expression on the
face of the criminal, the varying, changing attitudes of the crowd, etc. He lacks
particularity in almost every case. It was a policeman, a criminal, and a dim
and uncertain crowd. On the physiological side we may safely assert that in A's
visual perceptions thousands of nerve cells in the occipital cortex were aroused
to activity, whereas in B's visual image there were comparatively few visual
nerve cells stimulated from the auditory area. The consequence was paucity of
mental images, vagueness, instability and uncertainty.

Thus, to take another example, one present at the battle of Hastings would
have some very realistic pictures of the dying men, the posts of the stockade shot
with quivering arrows, Edith, the queen mother, searching for the body of her son
Harold, and a thousand other details. No second-hand information could possi-
bly produce the same result. In history teaching the nearest approach to percep-
tual reality can only be obtained by illustrations, paintings, and the use of the
stereopticon.

It is evident at a glance that the present overwhelming movement towards
illustrations in our school books, school rooms, monthly, weekly and daily publi-
cations, lectures, etc., is but a tardy recognition in a practical form of the vital
importance of the law here under discussion.

Many pedagogical applications of the foregoing principles could be cited such
as the following, selected at random: In the primary grades the making of boats,
houses, a wagon, a loom, bow and arrow, etc., in the workshop attached to the
school ; the making of physiological and physiographical models ; the introduction
of photography in the various departments of school work; sloyd work, cooking,
sewing, etc., the making of collections — not the keeping of them — of various arti-
cles and living things ; an aquarium, an aviary, a botanical collection, a mineral
collection, a collection of stamps for geographical work, etc., a collection of works
of art, books, etc.; (Nature-study is almost a farce without the presence of the
living things) ; the use of the stereopticon in the teaching of geography and his-
tory and all other subjects in which the natural objects are not available for pre-
sentation to the senses; use of the stereopticon in teaching art; geographical, geo-
logical, historical, commercial and political excursions wherever possible; visits
to manufactories, mines, electric light plants, sessions of legislative bodies, stock
exchanges, higher seats of learing, etc. ; the use of the typewriter in the schools;

50

use of museums, art schools, pictures, magazines, etc.; the use of objects in the
teaching of mathematics, especially in the earlier grades ; introduction of the usages
of the social world into the school; less traditional book lore and book methods
and more socialization of the school room; introduction of weights and measures,
banking facilities, etc.; introduction of social ends and aims and then the use of
arithmetical, algebraical and geometrical processes as means to those ends (by the
inevitable force of tradition, arithmetical processes, like all other processes, tend
to become ends in themselves rather than means for the adequate supply of the
demands of society) ; viva voce teaching of languages; employment of as many
senses as possible in the teaching of languages, i. e., by dictation, writing, speak-
ing, etc; legislative sessions, newspaper reports, telegraphic dispatches, etc.; dif-
ferent forms of dancing in the inculcation of courtesy, grace and the finer emo-
tions; introduction of dramatic presentations in the grades, as well as in the high
schools ; the introduction, to a certain extent, of the source method in the teaching
of history. An arithmetical process, such as long division, should not be taught
as such, but as a means for determining, say, the amount of the material needed
for the new house of some child in the room. Children should not learn to read,
but read for the sake of the subject-matter. So it should also be with the teach-
ing of spelling, writing, composition, etc. The time needed for the teaching of
these subjects in the schools will thus be materially shortened. The concrete social
life of the pupil should be the starting point for the teacher. Should we ever leave
it ? Fame and fortune are awaiting the person who will transform the teaching of
gymnastics from being more or less an end in itself, into the satisfaction of some
social and organic concrete end. Will it come through the drama, pantomime, an
extension of the Delsartean system, or through the organization of the already
Existing play activities based on the more accurate knowledge of the organic and
social nature and functioning of youth? Certainly the present form of gymnas-
tics teaching is crude and pedagogically insufficient.

As to manual training, the future school curriculum will undoubtedly de-
scribe it as an initiation into technic, as an introduction into the ways and means
of historical progress in culture. Training in technic will take its place side by
side with the other two great branches, the study of nature's forces and the study
of man's social activities.

51

MISCELLANEA.

SOME STATISTICS BEARING ON EDUCATION IN THE UNITED

STATES. (1)

/. Elementary Schools.

Expenditures on elementary education in Europe (1900-1901) ap-
proximately $246,000,000

Expenditures on elementary education in United States (1900-1901) .$226,043,236

Value of all school property in United States (common schools) $576,963,089

Enrollment in elementary schools of Europe, approximately 45,000,000

Enrollment in elementary schools of the United States 15,603,451

Total enrollment in public and private elementary schools in United

States 16,984,751

Estimated number of children 5-18 years of age in 1901 in United

States 21,897,678

Estimated population of United States in 1901 77,262,743

Number of teachers employed in United States ( 1900-1901 ) 430,004

Percentage of male teachers in United States:

1870-71

1879-80

1889-90

1899-1900

1900-1901

41.0

42.8

34.5

29.9

28.8

Average monthly salaries of teachers (1900-1901) ; males $ 47.55

Average monthly salaries of teachers (1900-1901) ; females 39.17

Paid for teachers' and superintendents' salaries ( 1900-1901) 142,776,168.00

Average expenditure per pupil (for the whole school year) 21.14

Average daily expenditure per pupil 14.7 cents

School expenditure per capita of population (1900-1901) $2.93

School expenditure per capita of population (1900-1901) $1.75

(1) Compiled from Advance Sheets of the Report of the U. S. Commissioner of
Education for 1900-1901. This report promises to be the best yet issued
in a long line of most excellent reports.

52

Ecopenditure by the twenty largest cities for maintenance and operation of public
schools and of police departments.

[Data from Bulletin of the Department of Labor, No. 42, September, 1902; calculations made
in the Bureau of Education.]

City.

Spent for
schools,
building
omitted.

Spent for po-
lice depart-
ment.

Ratio.

New York

$19,731,629

8,203,493

8.819,604

1,526,140

8,043,640

1,417,892

1,257,845

1,161,834

1,166,763

1,126,681

848,648

478,025

869,713

764,968

1,182,916

880,081

500,382

512,947

786,981

739,695

$10,199,206

8,685,982

8,086,264

1,602,182

1,754,151

967,828

417,932

798,294

789,251

555,185

490,287

231,374

542,049

342,508

687,922

428,495

421,616

273,615

216,698

871,875

$1.98 for schools to $1 for police.

Chicago .. .... .

$2.23 for schools to $1 for police.

Philadelphia

$1.09 for schools to $1 for police.

St. Louis __..

$0.95 for schools to $1 for police.

Boston .. .......

$1.73 for schools to $1 for police.

Baltimore ._... ..

Cleveland ,._

$3.01 for schools to $1 for police.

Buffalo

$1.46 for schools to $1 for police.

San Francisco

Cincinnati _..

$1.48 for schools to $1 for police.
$2.03 for schools to $1 for police.

Pittsburg

$1.72 for schools to $1 for police.

New Orleans .

$2.07 for schools to $1 for police.

Detroit

$1.60 for schools to $1 for police*

Milwaukee

$2.24 for schools to $1 for police.

Washington

$1.72 for schools to $1 for police.

Newark

$1 94 for schools to $1 for police.

Jersey City

$1.16 for schools to $1 for police.

Louisville _

$1.87 for schools to $1 for police.

Minneapolis ._

Providence

$1.99 for schools to $1 for police.

6S

wdoe/j

1

V

\

\.

\

V

^$-■^691

^^

"-^

/

\

\,

0€-68St

\

«v

\

\

\

\

)

79-^681

eoeot>i>t~o>MiCiniooooirtei

.2

o
o
(.1

8
2

o

5"

s

\,

^^^t'a'f.^^^^^^:i^'^^ii

/

•«■ *

llslslllilillls

y

\

t

^

1

^n^^>uu?iP.^^?,^^,?.?.'^

?

^rt^rt^^^„^^rt^„rt„^

09-6181

It

S6^

1870-71..
1871-72..
1872-73..
1873-74..
1874-75..
187^76..
1876-77..
1877-78..
1878-79..
1879-80. .
1880-81..
]g81-82..
1SS2-83..
1883-84..
18S4-a5..
1885-86..

J

^y^

i

/

*^

91-^191

\

J

.^

---'

. — ^

11-0191

5: :i

1

CO
5

^

^1-

1

^

fO

I

54

66

^3.00

*i50

^2.00

Hso

^100

^0.50

^

56

Diagram 4. — Number of secondary students in public and private secondary

schools.

550,000

/

/

/

/

/

i

/

500,000
450,000

/

/

/

/

/

/

/

/

/

400,000

I

/

/

/

/

/

350,000

J

/

/

/

9n/t /)/ic

/

1

vi

i

/

250,000
200,000

/

^
X

f

/

/

/

1

/50,000

(

y

/

/

/

/

/ 00,000

/

/

1

/^

p r}V<

xfe

/

s

_

y

^

— '

,y

V

/

r

S 0,0 00

y

^

y^

Pr

V«j

'^

y

\y

\

y

/

/

./^

/

J

P^

/A

'C.

y

57

Diagram 5. — Percentage of the population enrolled as secondary students in
public and private secondary schools.

^^

of

fp

?A<

-en

J

/

/

%

/

1

\

y

f

/

'//C

1

1

/

f—

/

/

1

V/C

/

/

/

f

^

t

si

V/c

1

7

/

y

1

Y,c

J

/

f

/

-

/

%

/

/

"**

/

/

y

4

''vc

te

■..^

^

-

::^

1

/

p,

ivi

^

/

\

'/'Q

A

/

0<?;

nf.

/

/

f—

\

x"

7

^*

^^

/

ut

Ik

'"^

/

—

V

_^

/

58

//. Secondary pupils in the United States.

Institutions.

Male.

Female.

Total.

Public high schools -

224,584

2,749

7,287

53,813

4,408

80,016

317,146
4,404
2,570

54,408
2,809

14,785
5,614
4;58»

541,730

Public normal schools ._ . . .. - .--

7,153

Public universities and collets .... ...... .............

9,857

Private high schools .......

108,221

Private normal schools ........................

7,217

44,801

5,614

6,818

11,407

Total

829,675

406,825

726,000

The 736,000 secondary students comprised 4.25 per cent of the entire school
enrollment of the country, which was 17,299,230. .Almost 1 per cent of the
whole population was receiving secondary instruction. In the last ten years the
rate of increase of secondary students has been more rapid than the rate of in-
crease in population. The number of secondary students in private institutions
has very nearly kept pace with the growth of population from year to year, while
the number of such students in public institutions has increased from about 3,500
to the million in 1891 to about 7,200 to the million in 1901. In 1891 the total
number of public and private secondary students was about 5,800 to the million,
while the number in 1901 was about 9,500 to the million.

Leaving out of consideration the secondary students in preparatory depart-
ments of colleges and in other institutions, the following table will illustrate the
growth of public and private high schools proper since 1890:

Public and private High Schools since 1889-90.

Public.

Private.

Total.

Year^

reported.

Schools.

Teach-

Stu-

Schools.

Teach-

Stu-

Schools.

Teach-

Stu-

ers.

dents.

ers.

dents.

ers.

dents.

188^90

2.526

9,120

202,963

1,632

7,209

94,931

4,158

16,329

297,894

1890-91

2,771

8,270

211,596

1,714

6,231

98,400

4,485

14,501

309,996

1891-92

8,085

9,564

239.556

1,550

7,093

100,739

4,585

16,657

340,295

1892-93

3,218

10,141

254,023

1,575

7,199

102,375

4,793

17,840

356,398

1893-94

3,964

12,120

289,274

1,982

8,009

118,645

5,946

20,129

407,919

1894-95

4,712

14,122

350,099

2,180

8,559

118,347

6,892

22,681

468,446

1895-96

4,974

15,700

380,493

2,106

8,762

106,654

7,080

24,452

487,147

1896-97

5,109

16,809

409,433

2,100

9,574

107,633

7.209

26,383

517,066

1897-98

5,315

17,941

449,600

1,990

9,357

105,225

7,305

'^7,298

554,825

1898-99

5,495

18,718

476,227

1,957

9,410

103,838

7,452

28,128

580,065

1899-1900...

6,005

20,372

519,251

1,978

10,117

110,797

7,983

30,489

630,048

1900-1901...

6,318

21,778

541,730

1,892

9,775

108.221

8,210

31,553

649,951

In the last dozen years there has been a steady increase in the proportion of
High School students in certain leading secondary studies. In 1890 less than 34
per cent of the students were studying Latin, while in 1901 the per cent was
about 50. The per cent studying algebra increased from nearly 43 in 1890 to
nearly 56 in 1901. The following synopsis exhibits these percentages for each
of the twelve years in certain studies:

59

Per cent, of the total number of secondary students in public and private high
schools and academies in certain courses and studies, etc.

Students and studies.

1889-
1890.

1890-
1891.

1891-
1892.

1892-
1893.

1893-
1894.

1894-
1895.

1895-
1896.

1896-
1897.

1897-
1898.

1898-
1899.

1899-
1900.

1900-
1901.

Males...

Females

45.03
54.97

43.67
56.33

44.01
55.99

43.62
56..38

43.39
56.61

43.00
.57.00

43.40
56.60

43.84
56.16

43.50
66.50

42.93

57.07

43.16
56.84

42.83
57.17

Preparing for college,
classical course

Preparing for college,
scientific courses...

10.61
8.05

8.45
6.38

9.18
7.59

9.90
8.22

10.34
7.33

10.00
7.11

10.05
7.16

8.94
6.57

7.99
6.03

7.87
6.18

8.32
6.21

8.30
6.54

Total preparing
for college

18.66

14.83

16.77

18.12

17.67

17.11

17.21

15.51

14.02

14.«5

14.53

14.84

Graduates

Graduates prepared

for college (a)

Studying—

Latin

Greek

10.05

83.62
4.32
9.41

11.48

42.77
20.07

10.51

35.'J4

39.80
4.65
9.06
15.68
49.89
23.04

10.87

39.15

38.80
4.68
8.59
11.61
47.65
22.52
2.96
22.04
10.08

11.46

36.62

41.94

4.92

9.94

13.00

49.92

24.36

3.61

22.25

9.9S

11.88

30.92

43.59
4.99
10.31
12.78
52.71
25.25
3.80
24.02
10.31

11.60

32.44

43.76

4.73

9.77

12.58

52.40

24.51

3.25

22.15

9.31

22.44

28.03

31.31

11.73

32.69

46.22

4.58

10.13

13.20

53.46

25.71

3.15

21.85

9.15

24.93

31.08

32.27

11.95

32.60

48.01

4.60

9.98

13.76

.54.22

26.24

3.08

20.89

9.18

24.64

29.98

33.78

11.75

30.60

49.44
4.50
10.48
14.24
55.29
26.59
2.8S
20.48
8.55
24.33
29.88
35.30
38.90

37.68

11.78

31.61

50.29

4.27

10.68

14.91

56.21

27.36

2.58

19.97

8.64

23.75

28.62

36.70

40.60

38.32

11.74

32.95

49.«7
3.95
10.43
15.06
55.08
26.75
2.42
18.88
8.00
22.88
26.96
37.70
41.19

37.80

11.95

33.48

49.93
3.58

French

German

Algebra

Geometry . _ _

10.75
16.09
55.66
27.26

Trigonometry

2.54

Physics

21.36
9.62

23.06
10.37

18.24

Chemistry

Physical geography

7.86
22.42

Physiology...

26.27

Rhetoric

39.69

English literature..

43.90

History (other than
U.S.)...

27.83

29.77

31.35

33.46

35.78

34.65

35.73

36.08

38.41

(a) Per cent, of total number of graduates.

THE "NATURE-STUDY" EXHIBITION IN LONDON.

Complete success seems to have attended this inauguration of a new
movement toward the introduction of a better system of instruction in ele-
mentary schools. Through the courtesy of the Royal Botanic Society of Lon-
don an exhibition was held last Fall of appliances and methods employed in
nature-study. In connection with the exhibition a series of conferences was
held, at which a number of valuable addresses were given. A few extracts are
here given:

Mr. Hanbury, President of the Board of Agriculture, presided at the first of
the meetings on July 24 and spoke of the general educational value of nature-
study and of the special dependence of agricultural industry upon habits of care-
ful observation.

Lord Avebury took as the subject of the first address "The Study of Nature."
He attributed a most curious ignorance of common things to the fact that great
public schools omit the subject altogether, or devote to it only an hour or two in
the week snatched from the insatiable demands of Latin and Greek. Oxford and
Cambridge have most excellent science schools, but prizes and fellowships are still
mainly given to classics and mathematics ; degrees are given there, and now, alas !
even at the University of London, without requiring any knowledge of the world
in which we live.

60

Mr. Henry Hobhouse, M. P., read a paper on "How County Councils may en-
courage Nature-Study."

As it was not to be expected, he said, that every village schoolmistress would
be able to teach nature-study, an arrangement would have to be made for peripa-
tetic teachers to visit groups of small schools ; school gardens and school museums
would also have to be organized.

Prof. Geddes was unable to be present, and his paper was taken as read; Its
vital points are ( 1 ) that nature is a moving unity or pageant of the seasons, not
an abstract syllabus of "object lessons" or even dissected "types;" (2) that the
essential strategic point for the nature teacher is to give the pupil the joy of
nature before the intellectual analysis of it; (3) among immediate practical pos-
sibilities, and taking excursions for granted, the essential desideratum to be se-
cured for country and suburban schools without delay and for town schools so far
as possible is the school garden, always provided this is designed to show to the
full, the living seasonal beauty of its chosen plants and be not a cats' graveyard
of labels, however orderly. The introduction of a flower border, however small,
into the present desert playground is pleaded for on all grounds, moral as well a»
intellectual and aesthetic.

Prof. J. Arthur Thomson began his most interesting and suggestive paper by
quoting the definition of nature-study given by his friend Prof. Geddes: it is "the
habit of observing and thinking for one's self and at one's best, without books or
helps, in the presence of the facts and in the open air." Prof. Thomson had next
a word to say on the danger of doing nature-study teaching badly and distorting
the child's outlook on the world. Given a man or woman with the mood of the
naturalist, the country schoolmaster who knows and loves the birds, or the coun-
try schoolmistress who knows and loves the flowers, then the course of nature-
study — now compulsory — is sure to be healthful. Given, however, a teacher who,
through overwork, or preoccupation with other disciplines, or lack of early train-
ing, is only coercively, not organically, interested in nature-lore, then Prof. Thom-
son feared that the result would be very bad, indeed. The title of the paper was
the "Seasonal Study of Natural History," and a sketch of a seasonal course was
given, arranged so that the scholars faced appropriate problems at appropriate
times. It was argued that the seasonal order and method of study, though not the
easiest, was the most natural. It was the most primitive method, yet the ex-
hibits seem to show that it was capable of being the most evolved. It followed up
the pre-school education of the child, and was justified by physiological and psy-
chological facts. Furthermore, the seasonal method worked exceedingly well in
practice, being always relevant to what the pupils are seeing and feeling out of
school, facilitating the desirable co-operation of the class in securing the specimens
for the actual work, and being readily correlated with other school studies.

Mr. H. Coates illustrated the subject of local museums as aids in the teach-
ing of nature with reference to Perth Museum, in connection with which chil-
dren's essay competitions are most successfully held.

Lord Strathcona, as chairman at the second conference on July 28, gave an
account of work in Canada carried out by the generosity of Sir William McDon-
ald, who has given three-quarters of a million of money. Model farms were touched

61

upon, and Lord Strathcona gave a particularly interesting account of his own
work in introducing vegetable culture into Labrador, which had previously been
unknown.

Prof. Lloyd Morgan had also a definition to give when dealing with nature-
study in elementary education. He said that it was "a means by which simple
natural objects and processes acquire meaning." Like Prof. Thomson's paper, the
whole question is so carefully considered that no brief notice could do it justice.
The movement which the meeting was to foster and develop, according to the
speaker, is part of that reform educational procedure which has been in prog-
ress for many years. One of the points to be regarded is the patchiness of a child's
mind, to whom even the beginnings of science are impossible. The teacher, say a
scientific botanist, must not, therefore, get tired of fostering the powers of obser-
vation and affording facilities for simple investigation, and instead endeavor to
inculcate general laws and principles beyond the comprehension of the child.
Technical terms where they are simple nouns and not descriptions are allowable,
but after reading a long description of the dandelion taken from a nature-study
book Prof. Morgan begged his hearers to stop before they got to "anthers syngene-
sious."

On Tuesday, July 29, the chair was taken by the Lord Balfour of Burleigh,
K. T., Secretary for Scotland. He gave an account of the excellent progress of the
"nature- study" movement started several years ago across the border. "Nature-
study," he said, "must be rather looked upon by the children as recreation;
their minds must not be filled with facts, but must be taught to make observa-
tions and to investigate. If this were done it would redound to the credit of
education in all countries." — Nature, July 31, 1902.

REPORT OF A BRITISH COMMITTEE OF TEACHERS ON THE TEACH-
ING OF MATHEMATICS.

Since Prof. Perry brought forward the subject of "The Teaching of Mathe-
matics" at the meeting of the British Association last September, several associa-
tions of teachers have discussed the reforms suggested or appointed committees to
report upon the matter. A committee of the Assistant Masters' Association has
had the subject under consideration, and a preliminary report has been drawn up,
from which it appears that masters in secondary schools are in favor of most of
the reforms advocated by speakers at the British Association meeting. The report
is as follows : I. Arithmetic. ( 1 ) The method of teaching in the early stages should
be inductive and concrete. Actual measuring and weighing should be introduced
as early as possible. (2) Decimals should be treated as an extension of the ordi-
nary notation, their nature being illustrated by actual metric weights and meas-
ures. Multiplication and division of a decimal by a decimal would, we think,
hare to follow vulgar fractions. (3) The decimalization of English money and
English weights and measures should be practiced frequently. (4) Approximate
methods should be gradually introduced after the treatment of finite decimals.
They should be taught with due regard to rigidity of proof. Appreciation of the
degree of approximation should be continually insisted upon. (5) If "commer-
cial arithmetic" is to be taught at all, the subject-matter should receive more ade-

62

quate and correct treatment, and the examples should be drawn from transactions
as they actually occur. II. Algebra. (1) The foundation of algebra should be
"literal arithmetic," i. e., algebra should at first be arithmetic generalized. (2)
The minus sign should receive its extended meaning from copious illustrations;
and illustrations, not rigid proof, should also be resorted to for the purpose of the
"rule of signs." (3) Algebra should often be applied to geometry. (4) Loga-
rithms should form an important section of the subject. We believe that the
graphic method could be very usefully employed in this connection. (5) We de-
sire to deprecate the waste of time so commonly practiced in mere manipulation
of symbols. III. Geometry. (1) We are strongly of opinion that the ordinary
deductive geometry should be preceded and continually supplemented by concrete
and inductive work. (2) Whilst "mensuration" might possibly be taught in con-
nection with physics and arithmetic, we believe that the value of geometry
would be enhanced by practical applications of the propositions as they occur.
(3) We feel very strongly that Phicl id's text is very unsuitable for teaching geom-
etry. But we are impressed with the difficulty of abolishing its use in the face
of external examinations. In the circumstances, we can only hope that exam-
ining bodies, even if they insist on Euclid's sequence, will allow greater latitude
in methods of proof, and give greater prominence to easy "riders" and applica-
tions of geometry. — Nature, July 31, 1902.

SOME CONCLUSIONS AND SUGGESTIONS FROM EXPERIMENTS ON
SPELLING IN THE CHICAGO SCHOOLS. (1)

1. In these tests of memory an attempt has been made to divest the matter
to be memorized of as many associations as possible, and so to measure the na-
tive strength of the memory. The power thus measured is passive ; it is blind ; it
attempts to take and give back without change, to return an echo of the sensa-
tions. It shows what the child can apprehend, not what he can comprehend.
Good teaching attempts to make the mind active and alert, causing it to compare,
associate and classify. It is the province of the school to discipline this native
power of memory; to bring forth skill where originally there is only strength.
The teacher should aim to develop from the native sense memory an organized
rational memory. It is said that English spelling is illogical, but this is true in
part only, and the teacher should use every available opportunity to see that the
child uses his rational memory instead of depending too largely on the native
force of his sense memory,

2. Those with superior memory power being in superior physical condi-
tion, as shown by the anthropometric tests, clearly indicates that the immediate
sense memory is dependent upon good brain formation and nutrition. The
skillful and rational use of this memory power is dependent upon habitual use,
hence on education and experience. All these factors are significant in learn-
ing to spell.

( 1 ) Report of Fred Warren Smedley, Director of the Department of Child-Study
and Pedagogic Investigation, Chicago Public Schools, Keport JNo. 3,
1900-1901.

63

3. Where the matter memorized has been divested of associations, repetition
is necessary for the securing of deep and lasting impressions. Wherever logical
association is possible, there can be a more efficacious method of study. In study-
ing, the child should be habituated to depend upon comparing and classifying,
rather than upon mere repetition. Children are so prone to depend upon blind
repetition that they sometimes put forth as much effort in studying the words
that they have long thoroughly known as they do upon unfamiliar words, and use
as much energy in studying the parts of a word that present no difficulty as they
do upon the unknown portions. A wise direction of the child's energies would
greatly shorten the time necessary for the mastery of English orthography.

4. While usually the better spellers are possessed of better memory power
than are the poor spellers, yet there are bad spellers with a high development of
memory. Superior memory may make the acquisition of spelling easy, yet it by
no means removes the necessity for some intelligent application on the part of the
pupil. While most good spellers tend toward the visual type, still there are both
good and bad spellers of each type.

5. The fact that children have the ear memory stronger during the early
years suggests at once that the teaching of spelling to the young will be effective
if the ear is appealed to; that there is probably a place for oral spelling; that
there should be some pronunciation of syllables with the spelling; that the words
presented to the child at first should be, as far as possible, phonetic in their spell-
ing, leaving the "more cruel and unusual" forms of English orthography to be
learned in later years when the eye memory has become stronger.

6. The investigation shows that there is no "memory period," no period in
early school life when the memory is stronger than it is at any later portion of
the child's life, a period especially adapted for learning to spell. While there are
no memory stages, there are undoubtedly periods of interest that are especially
favorable for the child's learning to spell; times when, through the influence of
companions or teachers, the child is aroused from indifference or from a feeling
that spelling is a small part of life to a recognition that is important.

7. It has been pointed out that during early school life the auditory memory
is the stronger, and later that the visual memory is stronger. During the whole
of school life the audio-visual memory is stronger than either the auditory or vis-
ual; that is, a simultaneous appeal to both sight and hearing produces a richer
and more usable image than is brought about by an appeal to either sense alone.
This fact is very far-reaching in its application to teaching. The audio-visual-
articulatory memory, in which the impression is produced by an appeal to the
hearing, sight and the muscle sense, is even stronger than the audio-visual. It
would seem from this that the more senses we can appeal to, the deeper will be the
impression. This fact should be made use of in spelling drills.

8. The aim in teaching spelling should be to render words of the most fre-
quent use automatic, to have them so well known that in writing they will flow
from the point of the pen, requiring but little thought as to their formation. ITien
there is a large class of words of less frequent occurrence which should be recalled
on slight reflection. For the more unusual words the individual should have the
dictionary habit so firmly fixed that he will conscientiously look up every word he

<^ 64

needs to write if in doubt about its correct sfiwlM»g,--^*iif?8pelling of words is ren-
dered automatic through practice in writing them. Though the lirst grasp of the
word may well be made through other combinations of sense memories, yet the
final retention of the spelling of most words should he through the audio-visual-
hand-motor memory.

9. The per cent, of pupils having sight and hearing defects is greater among
the poor spellers than among the good spellers ; yet there are pupils with decided
sensory defects among the very best spellers. While these sensory defects are
handicaps in learning to spell, still they may be overcome, through careful appli-
cation, by those pupils who have good memory power.

10. Much that has been said here concerning the teaching of spelling will
apply with but slightly diminished force to instruction in the other branches of
the curriculum.

SOME PEDAGOGIC CONCLUSIONS FROM THE REPORT OF 1899-1900. (1)

Many of the tests and measurements which this department has made are
preliminary to other investigations, which, it is suggested, should be carried on in
reference to diflTerent lines of mental development, methods of instruction, and
school adjustments. It is believed that the utility of much of the work so far
done will best appear as it forms a basis for these future investigations and com-
pilations; yet there are certain truths important for educational theory and
practice which have been so clearly foreshadowed as to warrant their being set
forth here.

From the investigations of last year Dr. Christopher formulated the following
deductions :

1. In general there is a distinct relationship in children between physical
condition and intellectual capacity, the latter varying directly as the former.

2. The endurance (ergographic work) of boys is greater than that of girls
at all ages, and the difTerence seems to increase after the age of nine.

3. There are certain anthropometric indications which warrant a careful and
thorough investigation into the subject of co-education in the upper grammar
grades.

4. Physical conditions should be made a factor in the grading of children
for school work, and especially for the entrance into the iirst grade.

5. The great extremes in physical condition of pupils in the upper grammar
grades, make it desirable to introduce great elasticity into the work of these
grades. >

6. The classes in Physical Culture should be graded on a physical instead of
an intellectual basis.

The work this year, so far as it relates to them, confirmed these deductions,
except as to the age, when great differentiation of the sexes in endurance begins.
To these, certain other conclusions are added, not as settled beyond any possibil-
ity of modification, but yet as being fairly indicated by these tests.

1. The pubescent period is characterized by great and rapid changes in
height, weight, strength of grip, vital capacity, and endurance. There seems

(1) Report No. 2 of Child-Study Department of the Chicago Public Schools.

65

to accompany this physical activity a corresponding intellectual and emotional
activity. It is therefore a period when broad educational influences are most
needed. From the pedagogic standpoint it is pre-eminently a time for character
building.

2. The pubescent period is characterized by extensive range of all physical
features of the individuals in it. Hence, although a period lit for great activity
of the mass of children, it is also one of numerous individual exceptions to this
general law. During this period a greater per cent, of individuals than usual pass
beyond the range or normal limits set by the mass. It is a time, therefore,
when the weak fail and the able forge to the front, and hence calls for a higher
degree than usual of individualization of educational work and influence.

3. Unidexterity is a normal condition. Rapid and marked accentuation of
unidexterity is. a pubescent change. On the whole, there is a direct relationship
between the degree of unidexterity and the intellectual progress of the pupil. At
any given age of school life, bright or advanced pupils tend toward accentuated
unidexterity, and dull or backward pupils tend toward ambidexterity. The
pupils of the John Worthy (Bridewell) School are more nearly ambidextrous
than even the backward pupils of the ordinary schools. Training in ambidex-
terity is training contrary to a law of child life.

4. Boys of school age at the Bridewell are inferior in all physical measure-
ments to boys in the ordinary schools, and this inferiority seems to increase with
age.

5. Defects of sight and hearing are more numerous among the dull and
backward pupils. These defects should be taken into consideration in the seating
of pupils. Only by removing the defects can the best advancement of the pupils
be secured.

6. The number of eye and ear defects increases during the first years of
school life. The causes of this increase should be investigated and as far as pos-
sible removed.

7. There are certain parts of the school day when pupils, on the average,
have a higher storage of energy than at other periods. These periods should be
utilized for the highest forms of educational work.

8. The stature of boys is greater than that of girls up to the age of eleven,
when the girls surpass the boys and remain greater in stature up to the age of
fourteen. After fourteen, girls increase in stature very slowly, and very slightly,
while boys continue to increase rapidly until eighteen.

9. The weight of the girl surpasses that of the boy about a year later than
her stature surpasses his and she maintains her superiority in weight to a later
period of time than she maintains her superiority in height.

10. In height, sitting, girls surpass boys at the same age as in stature, viz.,
eleven years, but they maintain their superiority in this measurement for one year
longer than they do in stature, which indicates that the more rapid growth of the
boy at this age is in the lower extremities rather than in the trunk.

11. Commencing at the age of thirteen, strength of grip in boys shows a
marked accentuation in its rate of increase, and this increase continues as far as
our observations extend, viz., to the age of twenty. In girls no such great accel-

66

eration in muscular strength at puberty occurs, and after sixteen there is little in-
crease in strength of grip. The well known muscular differentiation of the sexes
practically begins at thirteen.

12. As with strengtii of grip, so with endurance as measured by the ergo-
graph, boys surpass girls at all ages and this differentiation becomes very marked
after the age of fourteen, after which age girls increase in strength and endurance
but very slightly, while after fourteen boys acquire almost exactly half of the
total power in these two features which they acquire in the first twenty years of
life.

13. The development of vital capacity bears a striking resemblance to that
of endurance, the curves representing the two being almost identical.

MEASUREMENTS OF PUPILS AT THE AGE OF PUBERTY AND ADO-

LESCENCE.

Dr. W. S. Christopher, of the Child Study Department of the Chicago Pub-
lic Sc'liools. aided by several experts, measured some 0,259 children of the Chi-
cago schools, 2,788 boys and 3,471 girls. The charts and methods employed may
be seen in the Journal of the American Medical Association, September 14, 1901.
Some of the results were known before, but may be repeated here.

From the age of nine to eleven and twelve boys tend to show a period of
relative quiescence in growth ; from eleven to seventeen, however, there is a period
of accelerated growth. The cuVve for girls shows a less well-marked quiescent pe-
riod, a better marked and shorter growth. The sharp increase in growth of boys
at eleven and twelve has a corresponding parallel in the growth of girls a year
earlier.

There is an exaltation of life processes at the pubertal period which finds its
expression not only in an increased rate of growth, but also in the development of
physical power. This exaltation is preceded by a period of relative quiescence.

The range of the measurements show a normal variation of considerable ex-
tent in the growth of both boys and girls, but slightly more marked in the case
of girls. The growth is not quite regular, showing considerable individuality in
each case. The variation of range occurs a year earlier in the case of girls. While
puberty is a period of great exaltation of life processes it is also a period of great
individualization. It is a time when the weak fail and the able forge to the front.

Tlie well-known law of Axel Key, that mortality and disease are less at
puberty than at any other period of child life, is to be explained as the result of
these accelerated life processes. The neuroses, psychoses, neurasthenias, the pas-
sions and the vaulting ambitions characteristic of puberty are the principal mor-
bid manifestations of the rapid physical changes of the body. The lack of steady
balance has its counterpart an the physical side. Rapid increase in stature asso-
ciated with deficient nutritive supply is commonly productive of stoop, muscular
atrophy, depression, fatigue, irritability and inability to sustain control exercised
by others.

The article of Dr. Christopher is especially noteworthy for the emphasis it
places on the great individualization of puberty as indicated by the great normal
range of physical measurements at this period.

67

FATIGUE.

Dr. Giuseppe Bellei, of the Municipal Hygienic Department of Bologna, from
his investigations, has arrived at results which correspond with other results ob-
tained by similar researches in this country and abroad.

He examined carefully by the dictation method 460 pupils (average age eleven
years and six months ) belonging to the fifth elementary class in the public schools
of that city. There were six dictations for each child, given at the various hours
of the school day, taking from twenty to twenty-five minutes. The chief conclu-
sions arrived at are as follows :

1. No evidence as to the diverse fatigue-influence of the various subjects of
instruction is forthcoming.

2. The first lesson-hour is a useful mental exercise if the pupils during that
time succeed in arousing themselves from the disattention under the influence of
which they are when they enter school.

3. The morning school does not produce notable mental fatigue.

4. The noon rest is very useful to the pupil since it does not destroy the good
effects produced by the mental exercise of the morning, and renders him capable
of better work than he is able to give after a prolonged rest, as observed when en-
tering school.

5. In spite of the fact that immediately after the noon rest the pupils are in
the best conditions of mind, an hour or a little more of school in the afternoon is
sufficient to induce so much mental fatigue as to cause, at the end of the after-
noon's lessons the worst work of the whole day.

The general statement seems justifiable, therefore, that, if the morning school
does not fatigue, it exhausts the mental resistance of which the pupil is capable
to such an extent that he is unable to undergo even brief mental labor during the
afternoon without exhibiting the most evident signs of notable fatigue.

It may be added that music seems admirably adapted as the first preliminary
morning exercise to secure the mental attitude of attention for the morning's work
and that motor exercises, manual training, etc., are displacing the usual recitation
work. (1)

RURAL SCHOOLS.

(From Report of Professor Robertson, Commissioner of Agriculture for Ontario,
on his investigation of the consolidation or centralization of rural schools
in Ohio.)

Six years ago Gustavus township became the pioneer in that part of the
United States in the consolidation of rural schools. There were nine school dis-
tricts in the township and as many small schools. Then the districts were united
into one, and a central school was erected at a cost of $3,000. It is a frame
building, containing four large, well-lighted class rooms, a small recitation room
and cloak rooms. Instead of nine teachers in little isolated schools, there are now

(1) A. F. Chamberlain, in an article in the Pedagogical Seminary, June, 1901,
on Some Recent Anthropometric Studies.

68

a principal at a salary of $65 per month, and four assistant teachers at $32 or $30
per month in the united school. Nine nice-looking vans are used to convey the
children from and to their homes. These wagons or school vans have comfortable
seats, running lengthwise of the vehicle, waterproof canvas covers and spring gear-
ings. Before consolidation the average attendance at the schools in that township
was 125. On the day of the visit by the three Canadians it was 143 out of an en-
rollment of 162. The year before consolidation the cost of maintenance of the
nine schools of the township was $2,900. Four years afterwards the cost of the
centralized schools, including the conveying of the children, was $3,156, being an
increase in expenditure by the township on its school system of $256. However,
the average attendance at the central school was so much greater than at the sin-
gle district schools that the cost of education was decreased $1.59 per pupil on the
average attendance.

Moreover, three years of high-scliool work is carried on in the consolidated
school, and the total cost of that is included in the $3,156.

The contracts for conveying the children to and from the schools are given to
responsible persons. These are under bond to provide comfortable covered wagons
and to comply with the regulations of the school authorities. The vans hold from
fifteen up to over twenty-five. The longest route traversed was about six miles.
The vans arrive at the school at from ten to twenty minutes before 9 o'clock, the
hour at which the forenoon session begins. The afternoon session closes at half-
past 3 o'clock. At Johnston school, where the closing exercises were observed, the
children were in the vans starting for their homes in less than five minutes after-
wards. At Kinsman, the eight vans are engaged at an average cost of $2.07 per
school day; at Gustavus, the nine vans at an average of $1.25, and at Johnston the
ten vans at an average of $1.27. The price of the vans was from $100 to $135
each. All the vans observed were drawn by two horses each. The drivers who
were conversed with said they had not known of any injury to any child. They
said the regulations required them to wait for the children at any house for a
period not exceeding two minutes, that as a matter of fact it was rarely neces-
sary to wait one minute, and that a case where the children missed the van or
were left from being late was very uncommon. The average attendance at the
schools confirmed all that.

About 5 per cent, of the pupils preferred walking to the old school rather
than riding in a van to the new school. Almost without exception these were
pupils who now have four to six miles of a drive in place of a former walk of one
mile or less. At the same time these pupils expressed a decided preference for the
work of the consolidated school. The evidence of both pupils and teachers goes to
show that riding in the vans is alike comfortable and free from injury to even
the youngest children. The increased enrollment of pupils and the very high per-
centage of regularity in attendance struck the visitors as remarkable. For the
past three months the daily average attendance at the Kinsman school, which is
in that respect typical, was 91 per cent, of the number of pupils enrolled. More
striking in this connection is the fact that the percentage of regular attendance
among the youngest pupils — those of five, six and seven years — was as high as
that of any other class.

69

Although the weather was rainy and the roads as bad as three inches of snow
mixed with mud could make them, the children jumped out of the vans at Kins-
man school with dry clothing and dry feet. Little boys and girls of six years
came three and four miles in comfort. The teachers said they came regularly in
all weathers. Under the small district system in the township of Kinsman two
years before, the enrollment at the schools was 110; under the consolidated sys-
tem it has risen to 146, without any appreciable difference in the total enumera-
tion of children in the township. The high percentage of young children (six to
eight years) and the large proportion of older pupils (from fifteen to twenty
years) were eloquent of the gains in education during the first two and the later
years of school life in a rural district.

The large class and larger schools seemed to meet the social needs of the
children better than the small isolated schools. The older boys and girls grown
into young men and women had opportunities for going on with a high school ed-
ucation without going away from home. There was said to be, and there
appeared to be, a great development of a spirit of co-operation and of mutual good
will and friendship from the wider and closer acquaintance of the children of the
locality, and from the new interests created and recognized as being common to
all, and for the common good.

As far as could be learned, there was almost entire unanimity of opinion
among the ratepayers respecting the marked success and superior advantages of
consolidation. While the scheme was brought into effect under vigorous discus-
sion and considerable opposition, the adverse criticism has been disarmed by the
results of experience.

With few exceptions, the "kickers," as they are designated locally, were rate-
payers without children, or persons who feared some depreciation in the value of
their own property; or, worse still, some increase in the value of the property
nearest to the centralized school. Experience has proven the former of these two
fears to be groundless and childish.

Professor Robertson sums up some of the advantages afforded by the consoli-
dation of rural schools and the free transportation of pupils :

1. It results in the attendance of a larger number of children in the locality,
particularly of those under the age of eight years, and of those over fifteen years.

2. It brings about a more regular attendance of pupils of all grades of
advancement.

3. It ensures the engagement and retention of some teachers of higher qual-
ifications and longer experience in rural schools.

4. It creates conditions for a proper classification of pupils and for such a
grading of the schools as permits the pupils to be placed where they can work to
the best advantage for their own improvement.

5. It permits the time-table to be so arranged that teachers can give each
class and every pupil in the class more direct help and supervision.

6. It provides the beneficial influences of fairly large classes of pupils of
about equal advancement: (a) by more companionship; (b) by friendly rival-
ries to excel; (c) by children learning from each other; (d) co-operating under
careful discipline, and (e) by class enthusiasms.

70

7. It makes it convenient for boys and girls in rural districts to obtain a
high-school education without leaving home.

8. It leads to the erection of better school buildings and more satisfactory
equipment in all the requisites of a good school.

9. It makes it practicable for rural schools to enrich their course for ail
pupils by nature study, manual training and household science, as well as by bet-
ter music; and for advanced pupils by instruction in agriculture, horticulture and
allied subjects.

10. It stimulates public interest in the schools and brings to the people of a
township an institution in which all can have an equal interest and a worthy
pride.

11. It may lead to an improvement of the public roads in the country parts.

12. It would facilitate the rural free delivery of mail. — Montreal Witness,
Dec. 23, 1902. /

SOME NEW EDUCATIONAL THESES.

The address on the "American University" recently read by Professor J. Mc-
Keen Cattell, of Columbia University, before the Phi Beta Kappa of Johns
Hopkins, has a combination of sense, audacity and breeziness that amounts almost
to a gale. For example, he says: "Ten years of age is early enough to begin to
read, write and calculate; primary education should be chiefly for the formation
of motor habits; a child's head will not hold more miscellaneous facts than can be
injected in a year or two; he can learn nearly as much of his present scholastic
studies in two hours a day as in eight. If the required school attendance for each
child were reduced to one-half or one-third, then, without additional expense, the
fewer buildings and smaller equipment might be doubled or tripled in value, and
the salaries of teachers might be doubled or tripled. The best trained teachers,
more men than women, should be in charge of the younger children. If society
must develop a class similar to the neuter insects, it should not have charge of the
education of children. The boy should stay in the high school until he is
eighteen, and then go to the university, or he should enter the college at sixteen
and pass forward to the university in two years. The man should begin to take
part in the real work of the world at twenty-one, but he should never regard his
education as complete, and should for many years, if not always, continue to
spend some time in work at the university. « * »

"In my opinion the university is, or should be, a group of professional schools,
giving the best available preparation for each trade and profession. It is more
feasible to give such training than to teach culture and research. These, like the
building of character, are not the result of any particular kind of curriculum.
Culture comes from daily and immediate association with the best that the world
has; and this should be found at the university. * • *

"The chief diflBculty in securing the right men for university chairs is the
small field from which they must be draAvn. When we have a hundred thousand
men of university training teaching in the schools, there will be those deserving
promotion. When we have more students doing research work at the universities,
there will be more men of genius for the higher offices. ♦ • • We should,

71

without delay, introduce the privatdocent system of Germany." — E. C. H., Amer-
ican Journal of Sociology, July, 1902.

MILITARY EXPENSES IN TERMS OF EDUCATION.

The meaning of the promised reduction of the military force in the Philip-
pines to 18,000 men may be better appreciated, perhaps, when it is stated in terms
of education. To support an American army on a peace footing costs something
over a thousand dollars per man. Warlike operations, of course, cost more. Ev-
ery regiment of a thousand men, therefore, is equivalent in expense to a university
like Columbia. Nine thousand men on garrison duty in the Philippines, making
no allowance for campaigns, use up as much money as all the colleges and uni-
versities in New England and the Middle States combined, including Harvard,
Yale, Columbia, Cornell, Princeton, the University of Pennsylvania and Johns
Hopkins. When the promised reduction is made we shall have brought home
52,000 men from our Philippine army in a little over two years. That means a
saving two and a half times as great as the cost of maintaining all the universi-
ties and colleges in the United States, and one-third as great as the combined
salaries of all the public school teachers in the country. Even those who are most
convinced of the necessity of our presence in the Philippines will be glad to see
this shrinkage in the bill. We are not a military people, and we think that we are
particularly partial to education. It may surprise some of us to know that we
spent last year in round numbers six times as much for the army, four times as
much for the navy and seven times as much for pensions as for higher education,
and that the aggregate of our expenditure for these three military objects was
about twice our total outlay on education of every kind, from the kindergarten to
the university. — Harper's Weekly.

72

REVIEWS OF IMPORTANT BOOKS.

J. A. Hohson, The Social Problem, New York, 1902 (James Pott).

In this work by J. A. Hobson, certainly the most original of political econo-
mists in England today, many new and rich suggestions are ottered which have a
decided bearing on educational theory, as well as on the problems of political
economy. Only a few points can be emphasized here.

First, society is the maker of "values." The claims of Herbert Spencer and
other*'individualists" that property and other values are the results of the labor
of individuals and therefore their rightful possession, are denied on the ground
that such values are not the exclusive products of individuals, as such. They are
not attained through merely individual agency. They are the result of the social
labors of the past, of the aid rendered by social institutions, of the many co-labor-
ing social agencies of which one particular individual is but the agent or expres-
sion. They, therefore, represent co-products. The family assists, the neighbors
lend their aid, co-specialists are necessary in every unit of work. The "unearned
increment" is due to the labor of others. The rise and fall of prices and the law
of supply and demand are pre-eminently social factors. Inspiration, ambitions
and ideals are factors, and very important ones at that, in the economic life of in-
dividuals. Whence their origin unless from community life, past and present, the
life of social co-operation?

Secondly, property and rewards should, in the final analysis, be distributed
not according to work done, but according to needs. To the individualist of the
old school this is heresy indeed. If values are social products, if each man's prod-
uct is a communal result, if, and this is the main point, the needs of society are
paramount, then each laborer should be provided with just so much and no more,
as will make that laborer most productive and most useful to the society in which
he lives. How to elevate each producer to the highest degree of social efficiency,
that is the problem. Has he worked for it? Have the pupils of our schools
"earned" the educational facilities we airord them so generously? Have the poor
and the inhabitants of our slum districts "earned" the provisions we make for
their amelioration? That is not the question. Social utility, not only for the
present, but also for the future, is the standard according to which all eff'orts, ail
reward, all remuneration must be gauged. Society has done this it is true
heretofore, but unconsciously. We are now becoming deliberately conscious of our
efforts with a much greater chance for more successful adaptation in the future.
This same principle of distribution according to needs, not for charitable purposes,
but for reasons of social utility, holds as well for other fields of human effort as
for the field of economics. Criminal jurisprudence and school discipline must in-
evitably come under the sway of this great governing principle. The crime or
offense must be punished, so runs the traditional judgment expressed in most em-
phatic terms. We forget that if a mother's tears or Christ's love do reform the

73

offender, they are sufficient punishment. If physical castigation is necessary to re-
form the criminal, then let it be "distributed according to his needs." If good
food or industrial training is necessary, then let the "punishment" take that form.
We plead for this principle as an ultimate standard. At the same time we are not
forgetful that, as a secondary matter for consideration, the means employed in
judging of the proper distribution of rewards may well be, in many cases, the
actual services hitherto performed; but this is not always possible, as, for in-
stance, in the education of the young or of the criminal.

Karl Groos, The Play of Animals, Appletons, New York, 1898. The Play of Man,

New York, 1901.

These works were critically reviewed in the preceding number of the Investi-
gations, but on account of their exceeding importance they are recommended very
earnestly for perusal and study by all who have not yet had the pleasure of read-
ing them. They mark an epoch in the scientific study of this important subject.
Not content with bare speculative a priori statements. Prof. Groos has laid the
foundations in an inductive study of the phenomena of play of one of the most
important topics in the science of education, and also of a more solid superstruc-
ture in the realm of aesthetics. The mass of facts packed and arrayed in splendid
numbers are sufficient of themselves to have gained for the author an enviable repu-
tation, but in addition to this a most thorough discussion has arisen which prom-
ises to bear rich fruit in the future. None interested in the scientific study of
education can talk intelligently on the subject without having read these two
works.

Th. Rihot, Evolution of General Ideas. Open Court Pub. Co., Chicago, 111.

This work of Ribot's, the best yet published on the subject of Concepts or
general ideas, is psychological rather than logical. It is a worthy successor of
Locke, Berkeley and Hume, It demonstrates clearly that there is no one imagi-
nation but many; that a concept may be of many kinds, auditory, visual, motor,
olfactory, etc. ; that a concept is symbolic in that the mental presentation in ques-
tion is a sign or symbol of much potential knowledge, which may be aroused by
association at any time. Ribot discusses the evolution of the concepts of number,
time, space, cause, etc.

H. G. Wells, Anticipations of the Reaction of Mechanical and Scientific Progress
upon Human Life and Thought. Harper & Bros., 1902.

Many forecasts are made of social evolution based generally on safe scien-
tific grounds. Mr. Wells curbs his Harpun al Raschid imagination and deals with
probabilities instead. It is fertile, suggestive reading and optimistic withal.

Increased facilities for locomotion in the twentieth century will be respon-
sible for the probable diffusion of great cities. The general distribution of popu-
lation in a country must always be directly dependent on transport facilities.
Many incidental suggestions are made of a causal nature, such as the various
reasons for the present form of railway power and transport. Many of the antici-
pations would have more promising validity if they had been backed up and sup-
ported by statistical studies of the actual growth of certain tendencies within re-
cent times. Thus, e. g., the utilization of nature's forces — the bringing in of mill-

74

ions of unseen slaves for the service of man — is well illustrated by the last U. B.
census. |

Judging by the amount of power used, manufacturing in the United States
has almost doubled in ten years, and it is five times greater than it was thirty
years ago. Here are the figures from the census reports:

Year. Horse Power.

1900 1 1,300,000

1890 5,954,050

1880 3,410,837

1870 2,330,1452

These vast amounts do not include the power used for other purposes than
manufacturing, such as transportation and lighting. More than 1,000,000 horse
power was used in the power houses of the 1,200 electric railroads in operation in
1900, and more than 1,500,000 horse power was used in generating electricity for
the 3,300 lighting and power distributing stations. More than 350,000 horse
power is employed for this purpose in New York City alone.

Of the total power used in manufactures during the census year steam en-
gines furnished 8,742,410 horse power, or 77.4 per cent, of the aggregate; water
wheels supplied 1,727,258 horse power, or 15.33 per cent.; electric motors, 311,016
horse power, or 2.7 per cent.; gas and gasoline engines, 143,850 horse power, or
1.3 per cent, and other forms of mechanical power 54,490 horse power, or five-
tenths of 1 per cent. Rented power was used to the extent of 321,051 horse power,
or 2.8 per cent, of the total. Of this rented power 183,682 horse power was
electric and 137,369 horse power was from other sources of energy.

The modern office building, often housing a population equal to that of a
small town, is almost wholly a creation of the last ten years, and the power re-
quired in these great structures forms a large item when the number of these
buildings in the United States is taken into consideration, as about 1,000 horse
power is required to operate the lighting plant, elevators, pumps, compressors
and ventilators in a 16-story modern building containing 560 offices.

New York leads the list of states in the use of water power, having 368,456
horse power derived from this source in 1900, against 233,795 in 1890, an increase
of 134,661 horse power, or 57.6 per cent, directly traceable to the great expansion
of the wood pulp industry in the State.

The influence of mechanism on the serf, peasant and laboring classes, on
tranportation, political union, the organization and conduct of states, commerce,
the growth of joint-stock companies and their necessary consequence, the trusts
and municipal or social control, finance, growth of democracy, the growth of
specialized classes, etc., etc., is all ingeniously investigated. The charm of a fine
style adds its glamour to the natural fascination exercised over us by all antici-
pations.

American Engineering Competition, A Series of Articles Resulting from an Inves-
tigation by a Correspondent of the London "Times." Harper Bros.,N, Y.,1901.
This series of letters published in The Times by an English engineer aroused

very considerable comment on both sides of the water. The author describes the

75

size of the factories, the completeness of manufacturing plants, the way the men
work, the enterprise of employers and the natural resources of the company. He
points out those qualities in American business life which have practically won
for them commercial supremacy. The whole work is full of excellent things.
Few books are more conducive to the teaching of patriotism than this one. Fu-
ture patriotism will be taught and inculcated by such scientific books as these
rather than by the sentimental nonsense now so largely used.

Hodge, Nature Study and Life. Ginn & Co., 1902.

This is no common school-book. One seldom reads a book of greater genuine
power and inspiration. Not one page is a conventional following of uncriticized
inheritances; not a line but breathes of living original personal feeling; yet never
once does the book fail to impress the reader with the authority of profound
modern scholarship. "Nature- study," according to this book, "is learning those
things in nature that are best worth knowing, to the end of doing those things
that make life most worth the living." AH through there is a full-breathed hard-
ihood of optimism as unconscious as a child's health. The love of nature revealed
here is of the true breed, free from affectation or afterthought, like a bird's song
or a boy's whistle. There is a naive inward cleanliness about the book that re-
minds one of great poetic genius. One would say that the writer had in his own
way come to the view of Wordswprth and of Shakespeare's Cynibeline and Win-
ter's Tale that Nature can herself form hearts and winds more sweet, strong and
perfect than the best art. "To apprehend thus draws us a profit from all things
we see." " 'Tis wonder that an invisible instinct should frame them to royalty
unlearned, honour untaught, civility not seen from other, valour that wildly
grows in them, but yields a crop as if it had been sow'd." Strength and gentle-
ness for boys, gentleness and strength for girls, these rather than literary refine-
ments, or emotional excitements are the end aimed at by "Nature-Study and
Life." The author seems a magician making paradoxes easy. The word "prac-
tical" seems syfionjmaous with "poetical" in his diction. There is an almost re-
ligious love for plants and insects breathing through the most matter-of-fact
phrases, and one almost wonders whether the author knows the gift he brings to
poorer souls. \

One can imagine Wordsworth looking down upon this new movement with
pride. His exquisite verses describing a girl formed by nature seem to be becom-
ing accepted as a guide for school-teachers.

"She shall be sportive as the fawn.
That with wild glee across the lawn,

Or up the mountain springs;
And hers shall be the breathing balm.
And hers the silence and the calm

Of mute, insensate things.
The floating clouds their state shall lend
To her; for her the willow bend;

Nor shall she fail to see
Even in the motions of the storm,
Grace that shall mould the maiden's form

By silent sympathy.

76

The stars of midnight shall be dear
To her; and she sliall lean her ear

In many a seeret place,
Where rivulets dance their wayward round,
And beauty born of murmuring sound

Shall pass into her face.
And vital feelings of delight
Shall rear her form to stately height,

Her virgin bosom swell;
Such thoughts to Lucy I will give
While she and I together live

Here in this happy dell."

So spake Nature according to her deepest interpreter: and one may say
that Wordsworth's poetry and Hodge's idea of "life" coincide.

The book is different from any other on the subject. With the confidence of
a scientist of acknowledged position the author has been as bold in discarding
technical learning as Baldwin was in his Story of the Mind, in this book meant
for children. It is the richest and most interesting book of the kind, the best
adapted to the various periods of development in children, the most profoundly
right in pedagogy, and the most free from the ineffective will-lessness of hooka
straining after pretty literary effects, that one could desire. But to end where
we began, the quality that makes this book a service to the republic is an amaz-
ing unconscious magic distilled out of a splendid original personality which sees.
no distinction between practical and poetical, between the common earth and
sky and the divine being that it is, and that is it, and that therefore knows no
divorce between sentiment and volition, and tends to reproduce itself in a race of
gentle giants fit for all offices of an indeal land and race. A few more decades
of this fruitful pedagogy and we shall begin to see our way out of the wood*
and the shadows of medisevalism and to boast of the beginning of a true Renais-
sance.

Commercial Geographies. ( 1 )

Dr. H. R. Mill, President of the Geographical Section of the British Asso-
ciation for the Advancement of Science (1901), defines geography as "the science
which deals with the forms of relief of the earth's crust, and with the influence
which these forms exercise on the distribution of all other phenomena," and he
divides the subject into: (1) Mathematical geography, which regards the earth
as a spinning ball lighted and warmed according to a rigid succession of diurnal
changes. (2) This merges into physical geography which is concerned with the-
contemporary changes in the crust and in the surrounding fluid envelopes. (3)
Bio-geography or the geographical distribution of life, and finally (4) Anthropo-
geography or the relation of man to the earth's crust, a subject which must be
separated for the more general third division on account of the number of excep-
tions it presents to the laws governing the distribution of the lower forms of ani-
mal life and on account of the exceptional powers possessed by man for modifying
the conditions of the earth's surface.

(1) Adams, A Text-Book of Commercial Geography, Appleton's, N.Y.,1902. Olin,.
Commercial Geography, Crane & Co., Topeka, Kansas, 1902.

77

One of the most promising signs of the times is the newer and improved
type of text books now being published by our leading firms. Outside the natural
sciences the text books in geography probably have improved most rapidly. Phys-
ical geography has done good pioneering work and now comes commercial geogra-
phy. A great advance has been made when a comparison is made with the older
descriptive geographies. Causal conditions are now emphasized and a truer ap-
preciation of the control exercised by economic factors in human history is be-
coming general throughout the population. A splendid future awaits the teach-
ing of commercial geography in our schools.

At the same time improvements are certainly possible. For instance, in-
stead of treating each country seriatim after the fashion of the older descriptive
geographies, each industry might be considered more or less oy itself with its
various ramifications, dependent or superior industries, necessary conditions of
growth or decay, etc. The life history of an industry with its social causes and
effects and historical setting would be of inestimable value. Fewer industries
could be treated and these more thoroughly. The encyclopaedia-effect of certain
text books would then be avoided. The causal habit would then be engendered and
the memory left free for correlated facts. If such a method of treatment were
adopted there would be a much closer connection established between pedagogic
methods and the actual conditions of social life. The study of commercial geog-
raphy would be one of the most humanistic of all studies.

Another suggestion which might be made is that as soon as possible some
approach must be made to the laboratory method. Vast mountains of facts be-
wilder and confuse the students. Only that which is sought for and connected
together in one system of search and thought tends to remain as useful acquisi-
tions. Such a suggestion is, however, in the present state of geographical and
historical equipment, more easily made than carried out.

Adams' book — one of the Twentieth Century text books — is certainly one of
the best ever published. It is replete with the right kind of information and the
author shows a very complete mastery of his subject. It is a decided improve-
ment on its predecessors of a similar nature.

Olin's book is more elementary than that of Adams' but equally good. It is
also arranged with great pedagogic insight. The author and publisher are to be
congratulated on getting out such a suitable work.

Causal Geography. ( 1 )

The light which geography throws upon history is being recognized more and
more by our teachers, much to the benefit of pedagogics in general. The works
•of Ratzel, Ihering, Kirchoff, Hann, Dorn and a score of other writers are enriched
by another, Mr. H. B. George of Oxford. His present work is an attempt to pro-
vide still more data for the explanation of history, mainly political history, by
means of geographical influences. Man cuts canals and tunnels mountains,
drains marshes and constructs artificial harbors, but it must be admitted that
these things are trifles compared to the steady operation of geographical causes

•(1) H. B. George. The Relations of Geography and History, Oxford, Clarendon
Press, 1901.

78

throughout all history. The book is another evidence of the irresistible march of
causal geography, and as such it ought to be in the library of every High School
and in the hands of every teacher of history. The following is a fair sample of
the tenor of the whole book:

*'The vast region of tiie Pinsk marshes protected a great part of Russia in
1812; if a new Napoleon invaded Hussia now, he would not have his operations
limited to a portion of the western frontier. The clearing of forests seems to
have permanently allected climate in many regions. The construction of harbor
works, besides assisting commerce, has modified geographical conditions under
which maritime war is waged. The Kiel canal greatly increases the practical
naval strength of Germany, by rendering it possible to move ships securely be-
tween the Baltic and the North Sea, instead of their being compelled to make the
circuit of Jutland and pass through the Sound under the guns of a foreign, per-
haps hostile, power. The cutting of the isthmus of Suez has almost revolutionized
one-half of ocean commerce, and has modified profoundly many political condi-
tions which depend on geographical facts. But for the Suez canal, England
might, in view of the great improvement in speed of ocean voyages, have been
content with the Cape route to India for all purposes except passenger traffic.
As it is, she has been compelled to retain a hold on Egypt; and the whole bal-
ance of power in the Mediterranean, the geographical conditions afi'ecting possible
war in that sea, are deeply affected thereby."

J. Laurence Laughlin, The Elements of Political Economy, with Some Applica-
tions to Questions of the Day. American Book Co., 1902.

This is probably the best book for High Schools on Political Economy yet
published for American schools. It presents in a plain and simple form the ele-
mentary principles of political economy. It leads the pupil to think causally and
to investigate for himself. The treatment of the fundamental laws is clear and
adequate and well illustrated by excellent example.

Scientific Memoirs. Edited by Joseph S. Ames, Professor of Physics and Director
of the Physical Laboratory, Johns Hopkins University. Fifteen volumes,
bound in cloth, about 150 pages each, prices varying from 60 cents to $1.00
per volume. (New York: American Book Co., 1898 to 1902.)'

This is a physical classic series, consisting of translations or reprints of
memoirs of the discoverers in Physical Science from its rise to the present day.
Each subject is treated in one volume and has a separate editor. The editor has
selected memoirs and parts of memoirs bearing on the subject, adding notes from
his own hand for connection and elucidation. Each volume also contains a short
])refa(e, chiefly liistorical, and a short biographical sketch of each of the writers
from whose memoirs he has selected. References to allied papers are found in a
bibliography at the end of each volume.

It is refreshing to note this departure. Excessive reliance upon text-books
has been too much the order of the day instead of a liberal use of the scientific
classics themselves. Probably the pressure of examinations has had a good deal
to do with this unfortunate slavery to one text. Too much cannot be said in

79

praise of this series. It ought to be in the reference library of each High School
and the property of each teacher of physics and chemistry.

The series oflFers no mathematical difficulties to the average reader and pre-
sents, on the whole, delightful reading to any one at all interested in the subjects
treated. Following is a list of the memoirs:

The Free Expansion of Gases. Memoirs by Gay-Lussac, Joule, and Joule and
Thomson. Edited by Dr. J. S. Ames, Johns Hopkins University.

Prismatic and Diffraction Spectra. Memoirs by Joseph von Fraunhofer. Trans-
lated and edited by Dr. J. S. Ames, Johns Hopkins University.

Roentgen Rays. Memoirs by Roentgen, Stokes, and J. J. Thomson. Translated
and edited by Dr. George F. Barker, University of Pennsylvania.

The Modern Theory of Solution. Memoirs by Pfeffer, Van't Hoff, Arrhenius
and Raoult. Translated and edited by Dr. H. C. Jones, Johns Hopkins Uni-
versity. J

The Laws of Gases. Memoirs by Boyle and Amagat. Edited Dy Prof. Carl
Barus, Brown University.

The Second Law of Thermodynamics. Memoirs by Carnot, Clausius and Thom-
son. Translated and edited by Prof. W. F. Magie, Princeton University.

The Fundamental Laws of Electrolytic Conduction. Memoirs by Faraday, Hit-
torf, and Kohlrausch. Edited by Dr. H. M. Goodwin, Mass. Institute of
Technology.

The Effects of a Magnetic Field on Radiation. Memoirs by Faraday, Kerr and
Zeeman. Edited by Dr. E. P. Lewis, University of California.

The Laws of Gravitation. Memoirs by Newton, Bouguer, and Cavendish. Trans-
lated and edited by Prof. A. S. Mackenzie, Bryn Mawr College.

The Wave Theory of Light. Memoirs by Huygens, Young, and Fresnel. Trans-
lated and edited by Prof. Henry Crew, Northwestern University.

The Discovery of Induced Electric Currents. Vol. I. Memoir by Joseph Henrj.
Edited by Dr. J. S. Ames.

The Discovery of Induced Electric Currents. Vol. II. Memoir by Michael Fara-
day. Edited by Dr. J. S. Ames.

The Foundations of Stereo-Chemistry. Memoirs by Pasteur, Van't Hoff, Le Bel
and Wislicenus. Translated and edited by Prof. G. M. Richardson, Leland
Stanford, Jr., University.

The Expansion of Gases. Memoirs by Gaj'^-Lussac and Regnault. Translated
and edited by Dr. W. W. Randall, Mackenzie School.

The Laws of Radiation and Absorption. Memoirs by Prevost, Stewart, Kirchholf,
and Bunsen. Edited by Prof. D. B. Brace, University of Nebraska.

80

OF THF X

UNIVEPSITY ]

Bancroft, Jessie H., School Gymnastics. Free Hand. D. C. H3JfctIy|&,' Co., BQslOn,
1901; Ibid, School Gymnastics, with Light Apparatus. D. C. Heath & CJo.,
Boston, 1901.

The place of gymnastics in the school curriculum seems to be well assured.
In addition to the motor and mental training to be secured from manual train-
ing and from play activities there is certainly much to be acquired from a well-
developed system of gymnastics. The field of gymnastics may possibly in the
future be more limited when manual training is better developed and when play
activities are more scientifically studied and scientifically controlled, but until
that day gymnastic exercises can hardly be over-emphasized. As Miss Bancroft
claims in her excellent introduction, three objects are to be attained by phys-
ical exercise: stimulation of nutritive functions, correction of posture, and a gen-
eral, basic training of some of the psychological powers, particularly of the will.

This is largely defensive warfare, a combat with adverse influences and that
is one of the weak points about gymnastic training. It is excellent fronl a path-
ological standpoint. The right kind of motor training is obviously, however,
that kind of a training in which a social aim is to be achieved, in which there
are necessarily involved adaptations of means to ends, and, finally, in which the
instructive and developing characteristics of the child act as grooves along which
training will take its way to the ideal.

Miss Bancroft has done most excellent work in these volumes. Neither the
Swedish nor the German systems have been slavishly adopted, but the charac-
teristics of these systems suitable for our American schools have been utilized.

The publishers have issued the books in perfect form. \

Herbert Spencer, Facts and Comments. Appleton & Co., N. Y., 1902.

This, the last work to be issued by Herbert Spencer, has been called the swan-
song of the philosopher. A truly gigantic worker has said his last word. Regret is
merged into triumph, however, when one considers the great work accomplished
and the amount of influence exerted by this one man. True he was the expression
of his age, but still he was one of the few greatest men of that age.

Facts and Comments contains many valuable utterances and many sugges-
tions for further thought. Mingled with these are views which, to say the least,
are not in harmony with the age, but it may well be that in many cases the
aged seer may be wiser than we know. Stern advocate as he is of laissez-faire^
one is not surprised to see him deplore state education, vaccination, state-aided
enterprises, party government, etc. These essays are well worth reading, never-
theless. They are full of suggestions. There riins throughout education at large
the pestilent practice of starting with the abstract and ending with the concrete
— a practice utterly at variance with the course of mental development, which
starts with the concrete and ends with the abstract. The forcing grammar-les-
sons on children aff'ords perhaps the most glaring illustration. But those whose
mental culture is carried to a high stage may properly enter upon the study of
grammar as a preliminary to the study of logic. Both concern the co-ordination
of the ideas which constitute coherent thinking.

81

In matters of education we still consider his work on Education as one of the
best books yet published on that subject. In a number of the essays here col-
lected he returns to some of the subjects there discussed. In speaking of gram-
mar he details the manner in which he was educated without any training in for-
mal grammar, either in the mother tongue or in a foreign language, yet he claims
that his works are as clear of grammatical defects as one would normally ex-
pect of any author. He says: "One who is clear-headed and who throughout
early life has daily heard correct speech from those around, will speak correctly.
But non-fulfillment of either condition will entail incorrectness. If his thoughts
are so indistinct that he does not perceive clearly the relations among the ele-
ments of a statement he is making, or if throughout boyhood and youth he has
perpetually heard words misused by parents and others, the learning of gram-
matical rules will not prevent him from making blunders. Of course grammar
should have a place in a complete curriculum. That place, however, should be
not at the beginning, but at the end.

C. R. Henderson. Introduction to the Study of the Dependent, Defective and De-
linquent Classes. 2d Ed. 1901. D. C. Heath & Co., Boston.

The purpose and contents of this work, so useful for workers in social re-
form and so suitable as a text-book, is well stated by the author in the preface.
It is an elementary introduction to the systematic study of the nature, condition
and social relations of dependents, defectives and delinquents. The theoretical
discussion of the first part describes and explains the facts connected with these
forms of defective social life. The latter parts of the treatise are chiefly prac-
tical. They deal with social conduct, with institutions and organizations for
betterment, alleviation and correction. The ethical basis of charity, and the
social mechanism for attaining in larger measure what ought to be, are described.
Social institutions are described; their adaptation to ends is judged and valued;
better methods are proposed according to the teachings of scientific investigation
and experience.

This second edition is much enlarged by the addition of very valuable matter.
One point alone may be mentioned here, viz., a statement by Prof. Jacques Loeb
in reference to the causation of crime. He makes the statement to the effect that
the inherited physiological and psychical traits are of minor, even of insignifi-
cant, importance, as causes of crime, save in the rare and exceptional cases of
depleting disease or insanity; that defective social conditions, economic, indus-
trial, domestic and educational, are the supreme maleficent forces; that it is even
positively misleading and harmful to dwell much, if at all, on bodily and mental
traits, because we thus divert public attention away from social problems and
amelioration which are within human power to control, and which alone are
capable of preventing a criminal career.

Herbert N. Casson, Organized Self-Help. A History and Defence of the Amer-
ican Labor Movement, 5th Ed., 1902, paper 25c, cloth 75c Peter Eckler,
New York.

This book is one which ought to be found on every man's table. It is a book
which breathes on every page a spirit of fairness and justice and heart-felt inter-

82

•est in the millions of the working classes. The book is a veritable cyclopedia of
facts and data on the labor cause and a category of things accomplished by trade
unionism in the way of shortening workdays, raising wages, lifting unjust bur-
dens and forcing recognition for the wage-earners. It is an invaluable volume
for the unionists themselves and for all who desire to understand, appreciate and
aid them.

"At the time of writing (1901)," says Mr. Casson, "the American Federation
of Labor has on its rolls 1,100,000 members and is increasing at the rate of 350,-
000 a year. It not only contains more citizens than any church denomination or
society in the United States, but is the strongest non-military organization in the
world. Yet the actual beginnings of the movement, which has resulted in this
^reat formation, can be traced back to a period of little more than three-quarters
of a century ago." The topics discussed show clearly the aim of the author:

The Trade Union as a a legitimate business institution;

The Trade Union and prevention of lawlessness and revolution;

The Trade Union as the distributor of prosperity;

High-priced labor and commercial supremacy ;

Trade Unions as the pioneers of social reform;

The Trade Union as the inevitable development of the American spirit;

The Trade Union and the promotion of morality and education.

The style of the author is crisp and bright, but it is the clear-cut thought
and hard-headed way of driving home fact on fact which makes the book a notable
one.

President A. C. Millar, Twentieth Century Educational Problems. Hinds and

Noble, New York, 1901.

An excellent work full of common sense and scholarly judgment, bearing
chiefly on the relation of the small college to the university on the one hand and
the High Schools on the other. The excessive tendency of the young college pro-
fessor to lecture and carry on "research work" is properly excoriated. The
"teaching" function of the college is emphasized and the trend of certain colleges
to over-capitalization along university lines properly condemned. ^

Smith's Text-book of Anatomy, Physiology and Hygiene, 2nd Ed. Jenkins, N. Y.
An excellent text book for preparatory students. It is well arranged and
clear in expression. The author very properly urges the objective method of in-
struction through manikin, microscope, rough dissections, etc.

Bolton, H. C. Evolution of the Thermometer (1592-1743). The Chemical Pub-
lishing Co., Easton, Pa., $1.00.

An attractive history of the different stages of development of the modern
thermometer. Instruction in physics, especially in secondary schools, can in-
crease its social value considerably by the use of such histories. If in addition
the value to and effects on society of such instruments were emphasized the nat-
ural sciences might become more and more humanistic.

Bardeen, A Dictionary of Educational Biography. C. W. Bardeen, Syracuse, 1901.

Quite a handy work of reference for a teacher, full of interesting data and

portraits and well printed. Quite an amazing omission, however, is that of Pres-

83

ident G. S. Hall from the list of modern biographies. The information con-
tained is usually quite up to date.

Long, Wm. J. Ways of Wood Folk, Ginn & Co., Boston, 1902; Wilderness Ways,

Ginn & Co., Boston, 1901 ; Secrets of the Woods, Ginn & Co., Boston, 1902.

These delightful studies of wood-life cannot be too highly commended. Good
for children they are good also for the so-called grown-up. The Secrets of the
Woods must have had the fascination for the author which all boys have had at
some stage in their development. The sketches are taken almost at random, so
the author tells us, from old note-books and summer journals. About them
gather a host of associations, of living-over-agains, that must have made it a de-
light to write them out and a delight to read them, associations of the winter
woods, of apple blossoms and nest-building, of New England uplands and wilder-
ness, rivers, of camps and canoes, of snow-shoes and trout rods, of sunrise on the
hills, when one climbed from the eagle's nest, and twilight on the yellow, wind-
swept beaches, where the surf sobbed far away, and wings twaDged like reeds in
the wind swooping down to decoys — all thronging about one, eager to be remem-
bered.

Bretherton, Ralph H., The Child Mind. John Lane, New York, 1903.

A delightful presentation of the child mind in a manner half-autobiograph-
ical and wholly literary. It is charming from beginning to end and true to na-
ture. The dainty description of certain phases of pathos, passion and wide-eyed
wonder is excellent. The hard-headed and callousecf adult is rejuvenated by a
look behind the curtains at the real world of youth. It may incidentally do
him good.

84

14 DAY TTSF ttkTIARY

RETURN CIRCULATION DEPARTMENT

TO— i^ 202 Main Library

LOAN PERIOD 1
HOME USE

2

3

4

5

6

ALL BOOKS MAY BE RECALLED AFTER 7 DAYS

1 -month loans may be renewed by calling 642-3405

6-month loans may be recharged by bringing books to Circulation Desk

Renewals and recharges may be made 4 days prior to due dote

DUE AS STAMPED BELOW

"SEFTTTgHT

RECEIVCD IPf

JULl 0 i^B!

CIRCUUTION DIPT,

FORM NO. DD6, 60m.

UNIVERSITY OF CALIFORNIA, BERKELEY
n/78 BERKELEY, CA 94720

GENERAL LIBRARY U.C. BERKELEY

YC

... U^^ '

6000207851

IV

/

VCv^

Cy