Skip to main content

Full text of "Champions of change : the impact of the arts on learning : [summary]"

See other formats


CHAMPIONS 
OF  CHANGE 

-+- 


THE  IMPACT 

OF  THE  ARTS 
ON    LEARNING 


ARTS  EDUCATION  PARTNERSHIP 

The  Arts  Education  Partnership  (formerly  known  as  the  Goals  2000  Arts 
Education  Partnership)  is  a  private,  nonprofit  coalition  of  more  than 
100  national  education,  arts,  business,  philanthropic  and  government 
organizations  that  demonstrate  and  promote  the  essential  role  of  arts 
education  in  enabling  all  students  to  succeed  in  school,  life  and  work. 
The  Partnership  was  formed  in  1995  through  a  cooperative  agreement 
between  the  National  Endowment  for  the  Arts  (NEA),  the  U.S. 
Department  of  Education,  the  National  Assembly  of  State  Arts  Agencies 
(NASAA),  and  the  Council  of  Chief  State  School  Officers  (CCSSO). 

PRESIDENT'S  COMMITTEE  ON  THE  ARTS  AND  THE  HUMANITIES 

The  President's  Committee  was  created  by  Presidential  Executive 
Order  in  1982  to  encourage  private  sector  support  and  to  increase 
public  appreciation  of  the  value  of  the  arts  and  the  humanities, 
through  projects,  publications  and  meetings. 

Appointed  by  the  President,  the  Committee  comprises  leading 
citizens  from  the  private  sector  who  have  an  interest  in  and  commit- 
ment to  the  humanities  and  the  arts.  Its  members  also  include  the 
heads  of  federal  agencies  with  cultural  programs,  such  as  the  National 
Endowments  for  the  Arts  and  the  Humanities,  the  Institute  of 
Museum  and  Library  Services,  the  U.S.  Department  of  Education,  the 
Smithsonian  Institution,  the  Library  of  Congress,  the  National  Gallery 
of  Art  and  the  John  F.  Kennedy  Center  for  the  Performing  Arts. 


CHAMPIONS 
OF   CHANGE 

THE  IMPACT 

□  F  THE  ARTS 
ON  LEARNING 

EDITED    BY    EDWARD    B.     FISKE 


+ 


THE    ARTS    EDUCATION    PARTNERSHIP 

THE    PRESIDENT'S    CDMMITTEE 
ON   THE  ARTS   AND  THE    HUMANITIES 

Funded  by: 
THE    GE    FUND 

THE    JDHN    D.    AND    CATHERINE    T. 
MACARTHUR    FOUNDATION 


Arts 

Education 

Partnership 


*»»,#  .  s*5* 


GEFund 


THE   JOHN    D.     AND    CATHERINE    T. 

MacArthur  Foundation 


Edward  B.  "Ted"  Fiske,  the  former  Education  Editor 
of  the  New  York  Times,  is  an  internationally  known 
education  correspondent,  editor,  and  lecturer  who  is 
■widely  regarded  as  one  of  the  nation's  leading  education 
writers  and  observers  of  school  reform.  He  is  perhaps 
best  known  as  the  author  of  the  best-selling  Fiske  Guide 
to  Colleges  (Times  Books),  an  annual  publication  that 
is  a  standard  part  of  the  college  admissions  literature. 
In  1991,  he  published  Smart  Schools,  Smart  Kids  (Simon 
&  Schuster),  which  former  U.S.  Secretary  of  Education 
T.  H.  Bell  called  "the  most  important  work  on  educa- 
tion to  be  published  since  A  Nation  at  Risk!' 


C  HAM  pi  a 


DF   CHANGE 


PREFACE 

When  young  people  are  involved  with  the 
arts,  something  changes  in  their  lives. 
We've  often  witnessed  the  rapt  expres- 
sions on  the  faces  of  such  young  people.  Advocates  for 
the  arts  often  use  photographs  of  smiling  faces  to 
document  the  experience. 

But  in  a  society  that  values  measurements  and  uses 
data-driven  analysis  to  inform  decisions  about  alloca- 
tion of  scarce  resources,  photographs  of  smiling  faces 
are  not  enough  to  gain  or  even  retain  support.  Such 
images  alone  will  not  convince  skeptics  or  even  neutral 
decision-makers  that  something  exceptional  is  happen- 
ing when  and  where  the  arts  become  part  of  the  lives 
of  young  people. 

Until  now,  we've  known  little  about  the  nature  of 
this  change,  or  how  to  enable  the  change  to  occur.  To 
understand  these  issues  in  more  rigorous  terms,  we 
invited  leading  educational  researchers  to  examine  the 
impact  of  arts  experiences  on  young  people.  We 
developed  the  Champions  of  Change:  The  Impact  of  the 
Arts  on  Learning  initiative  in  cooperation  with  The 
Arts  Education  Partnership  and  The  President's 
Committee  on  the  Arts  and  the  Humanities  to  explore 
why  and  how  young  people  were  changed  through 
their  arts  experiences. 

We  believed  that  evidence  could  be  collected  that 
would  help  answer  the  questions  of  why  positive 
changes  occur  and  what  might  be  done  to  replicate 
them.  We  expected  the  work  to  build  on  previous 
research  concerning  the  arts  and  learning  so  that 
similar  programs  could  become  even  more  effective; 
we  also  hoped  to  increase  the  overall  understanding  of 
how  the  arts  can  impact  learning. 

We  invited  the  initial  Champions  of  Change 
researchers  to  examine  well-established  models  of  arts 
education.  We  then  added  research  efforts  that  looked 
beyond  specific  programs  to  larger  issues  of  the  arts  in 
American  education.  Finally,  we  expanded  our  concept 
beyond  classrooms  and  schools  to  include  out-of-school 
settings.  We  wanted  to  better  understand  the  impact  of 
the  arts  on  learning,  not  just  on  formal  education. 


The  Champions  of  Change  Researchers 

Over  the  last  few  years,  seven  teams  of  researchers 
examined  a  variety  of  arts  education  programs  using 
diverse  methodologies: 

■  James  S.  Catterall  of  the  Imagination  Project  at 
the  University  of  California  at  Los  Angeles 

analyzed  data  on  more  than  25,000  students  from 
the  National  Educational  Longitudinal  Survey  to 
determine  the  relationship  of  engagement  in  the 
arts  to  student  performance  and  attitudes.  He  also 
investigated  the  impact  of  intensive  involvement 
in  instrumental  music  and  drama/theatre  on 
student  achievement. 

■  Shirley  Brice  Heath  of  The  Carnegie  Foundation 
for  the  Advancement  of  Teaching  and  Stanford 
University,  with  Adelma  Roach,  examined  after- 
school  programs  for  youth  in  poor  communities. 
The  researchers  were  interested  in  the  qualities 
that  made  programs  in  the  arts,  sports,  and 
community  service  effective  sites  for  learning  and 
development,  and  they  identified  features  that 
made  involvement  with  the  arts  the  most  powerful 
factor  to  success  in  and  out  of  school. 

■  The  Center  for  Arts  Education  Research  at  Teachers 
College,  Columbia  University,  studied  arts  education 
programs  within  elementary  and  junior  high 
schools.  Researchers  Judy  Burton,  Rob  Horowitz, 
and  Hal  Abeles  created  a  taxonomy  of  learning  in 
the  arts,  and  investigated  the  ways  that  learning  in 
the  arts  affected  learning  across  the  curriculum  and 
the  conditions  that  made  this  possible. 

■  James  Catterall  and  The  North  Central  Regional 
Educational  Laboratory  (NCREL)  evaluated 
the  impact  of  the  Chicago  Arts  Partnership  in 
Education  (CAPE).  The  CAPE  network  of  nine 
neighborhood-based  partnerships  of  23  local 
schools,  33  arts  organizations,  and  1 1  commu- 
nity-based organizations  has  pioneered  new 
ways  to  integrate  the  arts  with  learning  across 
the  curriculum. 


■ 


— 


1^=**™= 


■  Researchers  at  the  National  Center  for  Gifted  and 
Talented  at  the  University  of  Connecticut  exam- 
ined the  Young  Talent  Program  and  other  offerings 
of  ArtsConnection,  the  largest  outside  provider  of 
arts  education  programming  to  the  New  York  City 
public  school  system.  They  also  created  a  model  of 
obstacles,  success  factors,  and  outcomes  for  talent 
development  in  the  arts. 

■  Steve  Seidel  and  researchers  from  Harvard 
University's  Project  Zero  examined  two  education 
programs  of  Shakespeare  &  Company,  a  profes- 
sional theatre  company  based  in  Lenox, 
Massachusetts.  Researchers  investigated  the 
National  Institute  on  Teaching  Shakespeare,  a  high 
school  teacher  training  program,  as  well  as  the  Fall 
Festival  of  Shakespeare,  an  annual  regional  experi- 
ence that  involves  teenagers  in  the  study  and 
performance  of  Shakespeare's  works. 

■  Dennie  Palmer  Wolf  and  researchers  from  the 
Performance  Assessment  Collaboratives  for 
Education  (PACE)  of  Harvard's  Graduate  School 
of  Education  examined  the  Creating  Original 
Opera  program  of  The  Metropolitan  Opera  Guild. 
This  professional  development  program  trains 
elementary  and  secondary  school  teachers  in  a 
process  that  enables  young  people  to  create, 
perform,  and  produce  an  original  opera. 

ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS 

This  research  initiative  had  many  champions.  We 
are  grateful  to  them  all,  and  would  like  to  recognize  the 
contributions  of  several  who  made  this  entire  collabo- 
ration possible. 

First  and  foremost,  we  thank  the  late  Ernie  Boyer, 
former  president  of  The  Carnegie  Foundation  for 
the  Advancement  of  Teaching  and  former  U.S. 
Commissioner  of  Education,  for  encouraging  us  to 
work  together.  This  partnership  has  been  a  highlight 


of  our  professional  lives,  and  we  will  always  remember 
Ernie  as  an  articulate  advocate  for  the  role  of  the  arts 
in  young  lives. 

Throughout  the  development  and  implementation 
of  Champions  of  Change,  several  individuals  provided 
critical  support  and  counsel.  They  included  Peter  Gerber, 
Vartan  Gregorian,  Rich  Gurin,  Ellen  Lovell,  Margaret 
Mahoney,  Harold  Williams,  and  Jim  Wolfensohn. 

During  the  research  process,  we  held  several 
sessions  to  review  work  in  progress  and  identify 
questions  for  the  research  to  be  funded.  In  addition  to 
the  artists,  educators,  and  researchers  named  in  this 
report,  we  benefited  from  the  involvement  of  arts  and 
education  leaders  from  across  the  country.  They 
included  Terry  Baker,  Jim  Berk,  Bob  Bucker,  Jessica 
Davis,  Elliott  Eisner,  Carol  Fineberg,  Rita  Foy,  Milton 
Goldberg,  Derek  Gordon,  Doug  Herbert,  Sarah  Howes, 
Peter  Martinez,  Ruth  Mitchell,  David  O'Fallon,  David 
Perkins,  Terry  Peterson,  Jane  Remer,  Dan  Scheinfeld, 
Josiah  Spaulding,  Robert  Stake,  and  Louise  Stevens. 

Under  the  leadership  of  executive  director  Dick 
Deasy,  The  Arts  Education  Partnership  has  been  a  critical 
partner  for  the  Champions  of  Change  research  initiative. 
We  are  also  grateful  to  The  President's  Committee  for  the 
Arts  and  the  Humanities,  honorary  chair  First  Lady 
Hillary  Rodham  Clinton,  and  executive  director  Harriet 
Mayor  Fulbright  for  their  involvement  and  support  since 
the  inception  of  this  ambitious  undertaking. 

Finally,  we  thank  the  advisory  committees  and  the 
boards  of  our  respective  institutions  whose  support 
made  this  extraordinary  endeavor  possible.  We  believe 
their  significant  commitment  of  resources  for 
Champions  of  Change  will  help  transform  countless 
young  lives  for  the  better  through  the  arts. 

Jane  L.  Polin 
The  GE  Fund 

Nick  Rabkin 

The  John  D.  and  Catherine  T.  MacArthur  Foundation 


C  HAM  PI  D  N  S 


D  F   CHAN  GE 

THE  SECRETARY  OF  EDUCATION 

Washington,  D.C.  20202 


The  ultimate  challenge  for  American  education  is  to  place  all  children  on  pathways  toward 
success  in  school  and  in  life.  Through  engagement  with  the  arts,  young  people  can  better  begin 
lifelong  journeys  of  developing  their  capabilities  and  contributing  to  the  world  around  them.  The 
arts  teach  young  people  how  to  learn  by  giving  them  the  first  step:  the  desire  to  learn.  Champions  of 
Change:  The  Impact  of  the  Arts  on  Learning  also  shows  that  the  arts  can  play  a  vital  role  in  learning 
how  to  learn,  an  essential  ability  for  fostering  achievement  and  growth  throughout  their  lives. 

American  education  is  changing,  and  changing  for  the  better.  Who  teaches,  what  is  taught, 
where  teaching  takes  place,  and  how  teaching  occurs  are  evolving  dramatically  in  communities 
across  America.  And  a  key  factor  in  changing  American  education  for  the  better  is  to  increase  high 
quality  arts  learning  in  the  lives  of  young  Americans. 

Why  is  American  education  in  such  flux?  In  simplest  terms,  the  reason  is  because  America  is 
in  transition.  We  are  a  more  diverse  society  facing  daunting  demands  from  global  social  and 
technological  innovation.  The  American  economy  is  shifting  from  a  manufacturing-driven  engine 
to  a  services-driven  enterprise.  If  young  Americans  are  to  succeed  and  to  contribute  to  what 
Federal  Reserve  Chairman  Alan  Greenspan  describes  as  our  "economy  of  ideas,"  they  will  need  an 
education  that  develops  imaginative,  flexible  and  tough-minded  thinking.  The  arts  powerfully 
nurture  the  ability  to  think  in  this  manner. 

Champions  of  Change:  The  Impact  of  the  Arts  on  Learning  provides  new  and  important 
findings  on  actual  learning  experiences  involving  the  arts.  The  report  which  follows  presents  these 
research  findings,  complete  with  ground-breaking  quantitative  and  qualitative  data  and  analysis,  as 
articulated  by  leading  American  educational  researchers.  These  researchers  investigated  the 
content,  process,  and  results  of  learning  in  and  through  the  arts.  Perhaps  what  makes  their 
findings  so  significant  is  that  they  all  address  ways  that  our  nation's  educational  goals  may  be 
realized  though  enhanced  arts  learning.  As  the  researchers  discovered,  learning  in  the  arts  can  not 
only  impact  how  young  people  learn  to  think,  but  also  how  they  feel  and  behave. 

The  American  public  is  demanding  more  than  ever  from  our  schools,  and  rightly  so.  Parents 
and  other  caregivers  want  to  equip  young  people  for  professionally  and  personally  rewarding 
careers,  and  they  recognize  that  to  do  so  we  must  give  them  greatly  enriched  experiences.  As  these 
researchers  have  confirmed,  young  people  can  be  better  prepared  for  the  21st  century  through 
quality  learning  experiences  in  and  through  the  arts. 


Richard  Riley  V 


Secretary,  Department  of  Education 


Our  mission  is  to  ensure  equal  access  to  education  and  to  promote  educational  excellence  throughout  the  Nation. 


^__ i SllMgl=1 


DF   CHANGE 


WHAT  THE  ARTS  CHANGE  ABOUT  THE 
LEARNING  EXPERIENCE 

As  a  result  of  their  varied  inquiries,  the 
Champions  of  Change  researchers  found  that 
learners  can  attain  higher  levels  of  achievement 
through  their  engagement  with  the  arts.  Moreover,  one 
of  the  critical  research  findings  is  that  the  learning  in 
and  through  the  arts  can  help  "level  the  playing  field" 
for  youngsters  from  disadvantaged  circumstances. 

James  Catterall's  analysis  of  the  Department  of 
Education's  NELS:88  database  of  25,000  students 
demonstrates  that  students  with  high  levels  of  arts 
participation  outperform  "arts-poor"  students  by 
virtually  every  measure.  Since  arts  participation  is  highly 
correlated  with  socioeconomic  status,  which  is  the  most 
significant  predictor  of  academic  performance,  this 
comes  as  little  surprise.  The  size  and  diversity  of  the 
NELS  database,  however,  permitted  Catterall  to  find 
statistical  significance  in  comparisons  of  high  and  low 
arts  participants  in  the  lowest  socioeconomic  segments. 
This  closer  look  showed  that  high  arts  participation 
makes  a  more  significant  difference  to  students  from 
low-income  backgrounds  than  for  high-income  students. 
Catterall  also  found  clear  evidence  that  sustained 
involvement  in  particular  art  forms — music  and 
theater — are  highly  correlated  with  success  in  mathe- 
matics and  reading. 

These  findings  are  enriched  by  comparisons  of 
student  achievement  in  14  high-poverty  schools  in 
which  the  Chicago  Arts  Partnerships  in  Education 
(CAPE)  has  developed  innovative  arts-integrated 
curricula.  The  inspiring  turnaround  of  this  large  and 
deeply  troubled  school  district  is  one  of  the  important 
education  stories  of  this  decade.  Schools  across  Chicago, 
including  all  those  in  this  study,  have  been  improving 
student  performance.  But,  when  compared  to  arts-poor 
schools  in  the  same  neighborhoods,  the  CAPE  schools 
advanced  even  more  quickly  and  now  boast  a  significant 
gap  in  achievement  along  many  dimensions. 

Schools  are  not  the  only  venue  in  which  young 
people  grow,  learn,  and  achieve.  Shirley  Brice  Heath 


spent  a  decade  studying  dozens  of  after-school  programs 
for  disadvantaged  youth.  These  programs  were  broadly 
clustered  into  three  categories — sports/academic, 
community  involvement,  and  the  arts.  This  research 
shows  that  the  youth  in  all  these  programs  were  doing 
better  in  school  and  in  their  personal  lives  than  were 
young  people  from  the  same  socioeconomic  categories, 
as  tracked  by  NELS:88. 

To  the  researchers'  surprise,  however,  the  youth  in 
the  arts  programs  were  doing  the  best.  Skeptical  about 
this  finding,  Heath  and  her  colleagues  looked  more 
closely  at  the  arts  programs  and  the  youth  participat- 
ing in  them.  Although  the  youth  in  the  arts  programs 
were  actually  at  greater  "risk"  than  those  in  the  other 
programs,  the  researchers  found  that  characteristics 
particular  to  the  arts  made  those  programs  more 
effective.  They  now  believe  that  a  combination  of 
"roles,  risks,  and  rules"  offered  in  the  arts  programs 
had  a  greater  impact  on  these  young  lives. 

Another  broad  theme  emerges  from  the  individual 
Champions  of  Change  research  findings:  the  arts  no 
longer  need  to  be  characterized  solely  by  either  their 
ability  to  promote  learning  in  specific  arts  disciplines  or 
by  their  ability  to  promote  learning  in  other  disciplines. 
These  studies  suggest  a  more  dynamic,  less  either-or 
model  for  the  arts  and  overall  learning  that  has  more  of 
the  appearance  of  a  rotary  with  entrances  and  exits 
than  of  a  linear  one-way  street. 

This  rotary  of  learning  provides  the  greater  access 
to  higher  levels  of  achievement.  "Learning  in  and 
Through  the  Arts"  (LITA)  and  other  Champions  of 
Change  studies  found  much  evidence  that  learning  in 
the  arts  has  significant  effects  on  learning  in  other 
domains.  LITA  suggests  a  dynamic  model  in  which 
learning  in  one  domain  supports  and  stimulates 
learning  in  others,  which  in  turn  supports  and 
stimulates  learning  in  a  complex  web  of  influence 
described  as  a  "constellation."  LITA  and  the  other 
researchers  provide  compelling  evidence  that  student 
achievement  is  heightened  in  an  environment  with 
high  quality  arts  education  offerings  and  a  school 
climate  supportive  of  active  and  productive  learning. 


EXECUTIVE  SUMMARY 


Why  the  Arts  Change  the  Learning  Experience 

When  well  taught,  the  arts  provide  young  people 
with  authentic  learning  experiences  that  engage  their 
minds,  hearts,  and  bodies.  The  learning  experiences  are 
real  and  meaningful  for  them. 

While  learning  in  other  disciplines  may  often 
focus  on  development  of  a  single  skill  or  talent,  the 
arts  regularly  engage  multiple  skills  and  abilities. 
Engagement  in  the  arts — whether  the  visual  arts, 
dance,  music,  theatre  or  other  disciplines — nurtures 
the  development  of  cognitive,  social,  and  personal 
competencies.  Although  the  Champions  of  Change 
researchers  conducted  their  investigations  and 
presented  their  findings  independently,  a  remarkable 
consensus  exists  among  their  findings: 

■  The  arts  reach  students  who  are  not  otherwise 
being  reached. 

Young  people  who  are  disengaged  from  schools 
and  other  community  institutions  are  at  the  greatest 
risk  of  failure  or  harm.  The  researchers  found  that  the 
arts  provided  a  reason,  and  sometimes  the  only 
reason,  for  being  engaged  with  school  or  other 
organizations.  These  young  people  would  otherwise 
be  left  without  access  to  any  community  of  learners. 
The  studies  concerning  ArtsConnection,  CAPE,  and 
learning  during  non-school  hours  are  of  particular 
significance  here. 

■  The  arts  reach  students  in  ways  that  they  are  not 
otherwise  being  reached. 

Other  recent  educational  research  has  produced 
insights  into  different  styles  of  learning.  This  research 
also  addresses  examples  of  young  people  who  were 
considered  classroom  failures,  perhaps  "acting  out" 
because  conventional  classroom  practices  were  not 
engaging  them.  These  "problem"  students  often 
became  the  high-achievers  in  arts  learning  settings. 
Success  in  the  arts  became  a  bridge  to  learning  and 
eventual  success  in  other  areas  of  learning.  The 
ArtsConnection  study  provides  case  studies  of  such 
students;  the  "Learning  In  and  Through  the  Arts" 


research  examines  the  issue  of  learner  self-perception 
in  great  depth. 

■  The  arts  connect  students  to  themselves  and 
each  other. 

Creating  an  artwork  is  a  personal  experience. 
The  student  draws  upon  his  or  her  personal  resources 
to  generate  the  result.  By  engaging  his  or  her  whole 
person,  the  student  feels  invested  in  ways  that  are 
deeper  than  "knowing  the  answer."  Beyond  the 
individual,  Steve  Seidel  and  Dennie  Palmer  Wolf  show 
how  effective  arts  learning  communities  are  formed 
and  operated.  James  Catterall  also  describes  how  the 
attitudes  of  young  people  toward  one  another  are 
altered  through  their  arts  learning  experiences. 

■  The  arts  transform  the  environment  for  learning. 

When  the  arts  become  central  to  the  learning 
environment,  schools  and  other  settings  become 
places  of  discovery.  According  to  the  Teachers  College 
research  team  and  those  examining  the  CAPE  schools, 
the  very  school  culture  is  changed,  and  the  conditions 
for  learning  are  improved.  Figurative  walls  between 
classrooms  and  disciplines  are  broken  down.  Teachers 
are  renewed.  Even  the  physical  appearance  of  a  school 
building  is  transformed  through  the  representations  of 
learning.  The  Heath  research  team  also  found  "visible" 
changes  in  nonschool  settings. 

■  The  arts  provide  learning  opportunities  for  the 
adults  in  the  lives  of  young  people. 

Those  held  responsible  for  the  development  of 
children  and  youth — teachers,  parents,  and  other 
adults — are  rarely  given  sufficient  or  significant 
opportunities  for  their  own  continuing  education. 
With  adults  participating  in  lifelong  learning,  young 
people  gain  an  understanding  that  learning  in  any 
field  is  a  never-ending  process.  The  roles  of  the  adults 
are  also  changed — in  effective  programs,  the  adults 
become  coaches — active  facilitators  of  learning.  Heath 
and  other  researchers  here  describe  the  altered 
dynamics  between  young  and  less  young  learners. 


CHAMPIDNS 


DF   CHANGE 


■  The  arts  provide  new  challenges  for  those  students 
already  considered  successful. 

Boredom  and  complacency  are  barriers  to 
success.  For  those  young  people  who  outgrow  their 
established  learning  environments,  the  arts  can  offer 
a  chance  for  unlimited  challenge.  In  some  situations 
described  in  the  research,  older  students  may  also 
teach  and  mentor  younger  students.  In  others,  young 
people  gain  from  the  experience  of  working  with 
professional  artists.  The  ArtsConnection  researchers 
in  general,  and  James  Catterall  in  particular,  explored 
the  impact  of  intensive  involvement  in  specific  art 
disciplines. 

■  The  arts  connect  learning  experiences  to  the  world 
of  real  work. 

The  world  of  adult  work  has  changed,  and  the  arts 
learning  experiences  described  in  the  research  show 
remarkable  consistency  with  the  evolving  workplace. 
Ideas  are  what  matter,  and  the  ability  to  generate 
ideas,  to  bring  ideas  to  life  and  to  communicate  them 
is  what  matters  to  workplace  success.  Working  in  a 
classroom  or  a  studio  as  an  artist,  the  young  person  is 
learning  and  practicing  future  workplace  behaviors. 
A  company  is  a  company,  whether  producing  an  opera 
or  a  breakthrough  technological  service. 

How  the  Arts  Change  the  Learning  Experience 

The  programs  and  schools  examined  by  the 
Champions  of  Change  researchers  were  selected 
because  they  appeared  to  be  models  of  excellence  that 
were  making  a  real  difference  to  young  people.  Their 
research  helps  us  identify  the  principles  and  require- 
ments that  make  these  arts  learning  models  work.  By 
helping  to  better  define  the  characteristics  of  effective 
arts  learning  programs,  the  Champions  of  Change 
researchers  have  also  done  a  great  service. 

Education  reformers  and  researchers  have  learned 
a  great  deal  about  "what  works"  in  recent  years.  In 
examining  the  work  of  Shakespeare  &  Company,  Steve 
Seidel  cites  the  general  characteristics  of  "project- 
based  learning"  as  factors  that  also  support  effective 


arts  learning.  In  Real  Learning,  Real  Work,  author 
Adria  Steinberg  identifies  six  elements  that  are  critical 
to  the  design  of  project-based  learning:  authenticity, 
academic  rigor,  applied  learning,  active  exploration, 
adult  relationships,  and  assessment  practices.  Seidel 
also  emphasizes  that  the  best  assessment  of  a  person's 
understanding  is  a  product  that  "puts  that  under- 
standing to  work."  Learning  is  deepest  when  learners 
have  the  capacity  to  represent  what  they  have  learned, 
and  the  multiple  disciplines  of  the  arts  all  provide 
modes  of  representation. 

The  quality  arts  learning  experiences  described  by 
the  Champions  of  Change  researchers  regularly  contain 
these  project-based  learning  elements.  The  best 
programs  display  them  in  great  breadth  and  depth.  To 
be  effective,  the  arts  learning  experience  will  also 

■  Enable  young  people  to  have  direct  involvement 
with  the  arts  and  artists. 

Young  people  become  and  see  themselves  as  artists. 
Whether  creating  art  works,  as  in  the  Creating  Original 
Opera  program,  or  performing,  as  in  the  Fall  Festival 
of  Shakespeare  program,  or  perhaps  even  teaching 
younger  student  artists,  as  in  the  ArtsConnection 
program,  the  students  learn  various  disciplines  through 
hands-on  arts  experiences.  They  actively  engage  with 
artistic  content,  materials,  and  methods. 

■  Require  significant  staff  development. 

The  best  teachers  are  life-long  students.  The 
teachers  involved  in  the  staff  development  programs 
examined  by  the  Champions  of  Change  researchers 
describe  life-changing  experiences  that  transform 
their  professional  lives.  High-impact  programs 
demand  both  adequate  staff  preparation  and  strong 
administrative  support.  Well-trained  staff  and 
teachers  also  become  leaders  for  institutional  and 
systemic  change. 

■  Support  extended  engagement  in  the 
artistic  process. 

Opportunities  to  achieve  artistic  and  learning 
excellence  cannot  be  confined  to  forty-five  minute 


^~ 


' 


EXECUTIVE  SUMMARY 


time  periods.  Sustained  engagement  during  individual 
sessions  as  well  as  expanded  program  length  support 
enhanced  learning  opportunities.  These  learning 
experiences  are  also  not  limited  to  place;  school  is  just 
one  of  many  settings  where  this  learning  occurs. 
Superior  results  are  also  associated  with  the  concept  of 
"practice"  and  the  development  of  a  sense  of  "craft." 

■  Encourage  self-directed  learning. 

Students  learning  in  and  through  the  arts  become 
their  own  toughest  critics.  The  students  are  motivated 
to  learn  not  just  for  test  results  or  other  performance 
outcomes,  but  for  the  learning  experience  itself. 
According  the  to  the  ArtsConnection  study,  these 
learners  develop  the  capacity  to  experience  "flow,"  self- 
regulation,  identity,  and  resilience — qualities  regularly 
associated  with  personal  success. 

■  Promote  complexity  in  the  learning  experience. 

Students  who  might  otherwise  complain  of 
boredom  become  fully  challenged.  Unlike  other  learning 
experiences  that  seek  right  or  wrong  answers,  engage- 
ment in  the  arts  allows  for  multiple  outcomes.  Seidel 
found  that  when  "refusing  to  simplify"  Shakespeare's 
challenging  texts,  students  became  passionately  engaged 
in  learning  classic  works  which  high  schoolers  so  often 
consider  boring.  Effective  learning  in  the  arts  is  both 
complex  and  multi-dimensional. 

■  Allow  management  of  risk  by  the  learners. 

Rather  than  see  themselves  as  "at-risk,"  students 
become  managers  of  risk  who  can  make  decisions 
concerning  artistic  outcomes  and  even  their  lives.  The 
students  learn  to  manage  risk  through  "permission  to 
fail,"  according  to  the  Shakespeare  &  Company  study, 
and  then  take  risks  "to  intensify  the  quality  of  their 
interactions,  products,  and  performances,"  according 
to  Heath  and  her  colleagues. 

■  Engage  community  leaders  and  resources. 

Another  recent  study,  Gaining  the  Arts 
Advantage:  Lessons  from  School  Districts  That  Value 
Arts  Education,  found  that  "the  single  most  critical 


factor  in  sustaining  arts  education  in  (their)  schools 
is  the  active  involvement  of  influential  segments  of 
the  community  in  shaping  and  implementing  the 
policies  and  programs  of  the  district."  Similarly, 
effective  arts  learning  out  of  school  also  requires  the 
active  engagement  of  the  community.  The  CAPE  and 
Heath  studies  show  a  process  that  attracts  and  builds 
on  this  engagement  from  parents  and  other  commu- 
nity members. 

Policy  Implications  of  the  Champions  of 
Change  Research 

The  Champions  of  Change  studies  examined  the 
messy,  often  hard-to-define  real  world  of  learning, 
both  in  and  out  of  schools.  As  a  result,  these  research 
findings  have  immediate  relevance  for  both  policy  and 
practice  in  American  education  today. 

For  example,  if  we  now  know  that  arts  experi- 
ences help  level  the  educational  playing  field  for 
disadvantaged  students,  as  revealed  by  James  Catterall, 
then  we  need  to  bring  more  proven  arts  learning 
resources  to  these  students.  If  arts  learning  can  help 
energize  or  re-energize  the  teaching  workforce,  as 
described  by  Steve  Seidel,  then  we  must  look  to  the 
arts  both  as  a  vehicle  for  preparing  entrants  to  the 
teaching  profession  and  as  a  means  of  supporting  its 
more-experienced  members.  Looking  beyond  class- 
rooms, Shirley  Brice  Heath  found  the  profound 
impact  the  arts  can  have  on  learning  for  youth  outside 
school  settings.  If  this  is  so,  we  must  expand  quality 
arts  learning  programs  outside  of  schools  as  well. 

In  the  CAPE  model,  the  researchers  find  that  arts 
learning  can  have  a  defined  impact  on  the  academic 
performance  of  students  in  an  urban  setting.  If  well- 
constructed  partnerships  between  school  and  arts 
organizations  can  increase  student  achievement,  then 
such  partnerships  must  be  nurtured  and  replicated.  In 
another  urban  program,  ArtsConnection  researchers 
define  the  role  of  the  arts  in  enabling  students  to 
overcome  obstacles  to  success;  again,  such  experiences 
should  be  made  more  widely  available.  Researcher 
Dennie  Palmer  Wolf  describes  the  impact  of  group 


CHAMPIONS 


DF  CHANGE 


versus  individual  learning  generated  through  a 
collaborative  arts  experience.  For  this  approach  to 
grow,  a  more  serious  commitment  to  developing 
communities  of  arts  learners,  rather  than  just  oppor- 
tunities for  "stars,"  is  required.  If  sustained,  integrated, 
and  complex  projects,  like  producing  an  opera,  a 
Shakespeare  production,  or  a  visual  arts  exhibition, 
significantly  deepen  the  learning  process,  as  these 
studies  suggest,  then  school  schedules  must  also  be 
modified  to  make  such  experiences  possible. 

The  findings  of  the  individual  research  studies  are 
worthy  of  the  reader's  careful  review. 

We  owe  a  great  debt  to  these  researchers  for  their 
diligence  and  insights;  we  can  only  repay  this  debt  by 
heeding  their  words  and  seeking  systemic  ways  to 
make  the  arts  a  meaningful  part  of  every  American 
child's  life.  Together,  we  can  make  the  everyday 
learning  experiences  of  young  Americans  less  ordinary 
and  more  extraordinary. 


CONCLUSION 

These  Champions  of  Change  studies  demonstrate 
how  involvement  with  the  arts  provides  unparalleled 
opportunities  for  learning,  enabling  young  people  to 
reach  for  and  attain  higher  levels  of  achievement.  The 
research  provides  both  examples  and  evidence  of  why 
the  arts  should  be  more  widely  recognized  for  its 
current  and  potential  contributions  to  the  improve- 
ment of  American  education. 

Similarly,  the  experiences  we  offer  too  many  young 
people  outside  of  school  are  often  limited  in  their 
purpose  and  resulting  impact.  They  provide  recreation, 
but  no  sense  of  creation.  They  provide  recess,  but  no 
sense  of  success.  Arts  learning  outside  of  schools  can 
also  enhance  the  sense  of  accomplishment  and  well- 
being  among  our  young  people. 

This  research  provides  compelling  evidence  that  the 
arts  can  and  do  serve  as  champions  of  change  in  learning. 
Yet  realizing  the  full  potential  of  learning  in  and  through 
the  arts  for  all  American  children  will  require  heroic  acts 
from  all  segments  of  our  society.  With  the  21st  century 
now  upon  us,  we,  too,  must  be  champions  of  change;  we 
must  meet  and  exceed  the  challenge  of  giving  our  young 
people  the  best  possible  preparation  we  can  offer  them. 
To  do  so,  we  must  make  involvement  with  the  arts  a  basic 
part  of  their  learning  experiences.  In  doing  so,  we  will 
become  champions  for  our  children  and  their  children. 


To  obtain  additional  copies 

of  this  summary  or 

a  copy  of  the  full 

Champions  of  Change  report, 

contact  the  President's  Committee 

on  the  Arts  and  the  Humanities 
by  sending  an  email  to  pcah@neh.gov 

or  writing  to 

1100  Pennsylvania  Avenue,  NW,  Suite  526, 

Washington,  DC  20506. 

You  can  also  access  the  report  online  at 

http://artsedge.kennedy-center.org/champions 

SPONSORS 

GE  Fund's  award-winning  arts-in-education  program  supports 
model  partnerships  between  schools  and  cultural  organizations. 
Through  advancing  the  role  of  the  arts  in  education,  the  GE 
Fund  promotes  both  skill  development  and  community  involve- 
ment in  schools  and  arts  settings  nationwide. 

Known  as  an  innovator  in  corporate  philanthropy,  the  GE  Fund 
is  a  catalyst  for  improving  the  education  and  well-being  of  men, 
women  and  children  around  the  world.  As  the  principal  vehicle 
for  the  GE  Company's  philanthropy,  the  GE  Fund  supports  a 
wide  range  of  education,  social  service,  arts,  environmental,  and 
other  charitable  organizations  in  the  United  States  and  abroad. 

The  John  D.  and  Catherine  T.  MacArthur  Foundation  is  a 

private,  independent  grant-making  institution  dedicated  to 
helping  groups  and  individuals  foster  lasting  improvement  in  the 
human  condition.  The  Foundation  seeks  the  development  of 
healthy  individuals  and  effective  communities;  peace  within  and 
among  nations;  responsible  choices  about  human  reproduction; 
and  a  global  ecosystem  capable  of  supporting  healthy  human 
societies.  The  Foundation  pursues  this  mission  by  supporting 
research,  policy  development,  dissemination,  education  and 
training,  and  practice. 


^^IMHHI 


ARTS    EDUCATION    PARTNERSHIP 

One  Massachusetts  Avenue,  NW,  Washington,  DC  20001 
http://aep-arts.org 


PRESIDENT'S   COMMITTEE 
ON  THE  ARTS  AND   THE  HUMANITIES 

1100  Pennsylvania  Avenue,  NW,  Suite  526, 
Washington,  DC  20506 
http://www.pcah.gov 


Funded  by: 
THE   GE    FUND 

THE   JDHN    D.    AND    CATHERINE 
MACARTHUR    FDUNDATIDN 


(Arts 
Education 
I  Partnership 


GEFund 


THE   JOHN     D.     AND    CATHERINE    T. 

MacArthur  Foundation