Skip to main content

Full text of "Myelopteris topekensis, n. sp. [microform]"

See other formats


mm 


IMAGE  EVALUATION 
TEST  TARGET  (MT-3) 


4 


/ 


o 


^  -y^ 


/ 


«/. 


%'' 


A  ^" 


1.0 


I.I 


1.25 


■■  m  |||||22 

,     ."    112  0 


u 


1.6 


Photographic 

Sciences 
Corporation 


^^ 


#' 
<;^ 


^i: 


\ 


-^ 


^% 


\ 


\ 


23  WEST  N\r       STREET 

WEBSTER.  Nt     14580 

(716)  8/i-4503 


^ 


*» 
*> 

*. 


a^ 


<^\<^ 

^ 


6^ 


M 


"> 

^  . 


& 


fe 


CIHM/ICMH 

Microfiche 

Series. 


CIHM/ICMH 
Collection  de 
microfiches. 


Canadian  Institute  for  Historical  Microreproductions  /  Institut  canadien  de  microreproductions  historiques 


Technical  and  Bibliographic  Notes/Notes  techniques  et  bibliographiques 


The  Institute  has  attempted  to  obtain  the  best 
original  copy  available  for  filming   Features  of  this 
copy  which  may  be  bibliographically  unique, 
which  may  alter  any  of  the  images  in  the 
reproduction,  or  which  may  significantly  change 
the  usual  method  of  filming,  are  checked  below. 


L'Institut  a  microfilm^  le  meilleur  exemplaire 
qu'il  lui  a  ete  possible  de  se  procurer    Les  details 
de  cet  exemplaire  qui  sont  peut  etre  uniques  du 
point  de  vue  bibliographique    qui  peuvent  modifier 
une  image  reproduite,  ou  qui  peuvent  exiger  une 
modification  dans  la  m6thode  normale  de  filmage 
sont  indiques  ci  dessous 


K 


7f   Coloured  covers/ 

Couverture  de  couieur 


U 

n 


Covers  damaged/ 
Couverture  endommagee 

Covers  restored  and/or  laminated/ 
Couverture  restaur6e  et/ou  pellicul6e 


Coloured  pages/ 
Pages  de  coulour 


Pages  damaged/ 
Pages  endo.nmagees 


G    Pages  restored  and/or  laminated/ 
Pages  restaurees  et/ou  pelliculees 


n 


Cover  title  missing/ 

Le  titre  de  couverture  manque 

Coloured  maps/ 

Cartes  geographiques  en  couieur 

Coloured  ink  lie    other  than  blue  or  black)/ 
Encre  de  couieur  (i.e.  autre  que  bleue  ou  noire) 


I       I    Pages  discoloured,  stained  or  foxed/ 
i !    Pages  decolorees,  tachetees  ou  piquees 

□    Pages  detached/ 
Pages  detachees 

I       'i    Showthrough/ 
I I    Transparence 


D 


Coloured  plates  and/or  illustrations/ 
Planches  et/ou  illustrations  en  couieur 


D 


Quality  of  print  varies/ 
Qualite  in^gale  de  I'impression 


0 


Bouni  with  other  material/ 
Relie  avec  d'autres  documents 


D 


includes  supplementary  material/ 
Comprend  du  materiel  supplementaire 


n 


D 


Tight  binding  may  cause  shadows  or  distortion 
along  interior  margin/ 

Lareliure  serree  peut  causer  de  I'ombre  ou  de  la 
distortion  le  long  de  la  marge  int6rieure 

Blank  leaves  added  during  restoration  may 
appear  within  the  text.  Whenever  possible,  these 
have  been  omitted  from  filming/ 
II  se  peut  que  certaines  pages  blanches  ajout6es 
lors  dune  restauration  apparaissetit  dans  le  texte, 
mais,  lorsque  cela  etait  possible,  ces  pages  n'ont 
pas  ete  filmdes. 


D 
D 


Only  edition  available/ 
Seule  edition  disponible 

Pages  wholly  or  partially  obscured  by  errata 
slips,  tissues,  etc..  have  been  refilmed  to 
ensure  the  best  possible  image/ 
Les  pages  totalement  ou  partiellement 
obscurcies  par  un  feuillet  d'errata.  une  pelure. 
etc  .  ont  ete  filmees  ^  nouveau  de  facon  a 
obtenir  la  meilleure  image  possible 


D 


Additional  comments:/ 
Commentaires  supplementaires 


This  item  is  filmed  at  the  reduction  ratio  checked  below/ 

Ce  document  est  filme  au  taux  de  reduction  indique  ci-dessous. 

10X  14X  18X  22X 


26X 


30X 


V 


12X 


16X 


20X 


/ 


24X 


28X 


32  X 


The  copy  filmed  hero  has  been  reproduced  thanks 
to  the  generosity  of; 

Libriiry  of  Cotu|r»!SS 
Photoduplication  Service 

The  images  appearing  here  are  the  best  quality 
possible  considering  the  condition  and  legibility 
of  the  original  copy  and  in  keeping  with  the 
filming  contract  specifications. 


LoKL'tnoiairo  film«^  fuf  roproduit  grSce  A  la 
g6ri«^rosit«'(  de. 

Library  of  CoiKjrnss 
PhotudupliCiitioti  Service 

Les  images  suivantes  ont  6t6  reproduites  avec  le 
plus  grand  soin,  compte  teriu  de  l.i  condition  et 
de  la  nettHt^  de  I'exemplaire  film6,  et  en 
conformity  avec  les  conditions  du  contrat  de 
filmage 


Original  copies  in  printed  paper  covers  a'e  filmed 
beginning  with  the  front  cover  and  ending  on 
the  last  page  with  a  printed  or  illustrated  impres 
sion,  or  the  back  cover  when  appropriate    All 
other  original  copies  are  filmed  beginning  on  the 
first  page  with  a  printed  or  illustrated  impres 
sion,  and  ending  on  the  last  page  with  a  printed 
or  illustrated  impression. 


The  last  recorded  frame  on  each  microfiche 
shall  contain  the  symbol  — ••  (meaning     CON 
TINUED"),  or  the  symbol  V  (meaning  '  END   ), 
whichever  applies. 


Les  exemplaires  originaux  dont  la  couverture  en 
papier  est  imprim^e  sont  film6s  en  commencant 
par  le  premier  plat  et  en  terminant  soit  par  la 
derni^re  page  qui  comporte  une  empreinte 
d'impression  ou  d'illustration,  soit  par  le  second 
plat,  selon  le  cas    Tous  les  autres  exemplaire.s 
originaux  sont  filrn6s  en  commencant  par  la 
premiere  page  qui  comporta  une  empreinte 
d'impression  ou  d'illustration  et  en  terminant  par 
la  dernidre  page  qui  comporte  une  telle 
empreinte. 

Un  des  symboles  suivants  apparaitra  sur  la 
dernidre  image  de  chaque  microfiche,  selon  le 
cas:  le  symbole  — ■*-  signifie  'A  SUIVRE    ,  le 
symbole  V  signifie     FIN  " 


Maps,  plates,  charts,  etc.,  may  be  filmed  at 
different  reduction  ratios   Those  too  large  to  be 
entirely  included  in  one  exposure  are  filmed 
beginning  in  the  upper  left  hand  corner,  left  to 
right  and  top  to  bottom,  as  many  frames  as 
required.  The  following  diagrams  illustrate  the 
method; 


Les  cartes,  planches,  tableaux,  etc  ,  peuvent  etre 
film^s  i  des  taux  de  reduction  diff6rents. 
lorsque  le  document  est  trop  grand  pour  etre 
reproduit  en  un  seul  cliche,  il  est  film6  ^  partir 
de  Tangle  sup6rieur  gauche,  de  gauche  ci  droite, 
et  de  haut  en  bas,  en  prenant  le  nombre 
d'images  necessaire.  Les  diagrammes  suivants 
illustrent  la  m^thode. 


1 

2 

3 

32X 


i 

2 

3 

4 

5 

6 

11 


..( 


QKll 


McGILL  UNIVERSITY 


PAPERS  FROM  THE  DEPARTMENT 
or 

Botany. 


iDon 


N 


mnn    < 


\'-'i 


l.'^'nr.ff.- 


No.  5. — Myelopteris  Topekensis,  n.sp. 

>-   >   BY 
D.Pr^'PENHALLOVV. 


With  Plates  II.  and  III. 


[Reprinted  from  the  Botanical  Gazette,  January,  1897,  pp.  15-31] 


Montreal,  1897. 


MVKI.OITKKIS  TOI'KKKNSIS,  N.  SI'. 

A  M'W    CAKIIOSII'ICKOUS    I'r.ANT. 

I>.  I'.  I'K  N  II  A  I.I.OW, 

(wrni   I'l.ATKS  II   AM)  III) 

I)uKiN<i  the  past  sixty  years  a  luinibcr  of  plants,  variously 
described  uiuler  the  names  of  Mediillosa'  (  1.S32) .  I'aliiiacitcs' 
(1845),  Myeloxyloii^  ( iS4(j) ,  Sten/.tliaM  1S64  ),aiul  Myelopteris' 
(1874),  have  been  obtained  from  the  Carboniferous  of  France, 
Germany  and  Great  Britain,  but,  so  far  as  I  am  .uvare,  110 
representative  of  this  group  has  been  obtaineil  heretofore  from 
any  locality  in  America. 

Recently  Professor  C.  S.  I'rosser  has  sent  to  me  three  small 
specimens  of  flattened  stems  from  the  upper  Carboniferous  of 
Topeka,  Kansas.  These  fragments  are  about  6""  long  and  lie 
in  a  matrix  of  calcite.^  One  specimen  represents  the  full 
width  of  the  original  structure  and  is  33"""  broad.  A  second 
has  the  edges  broken  off,  but  a  natural  extension  of  the  curva- 
tures of  the  sides  shows  the  probable  breailth  to  have  been  about 
6'^'".  Both  of  these  specimens  have  been  compressed  into  a 
flattened  mass  having  a  lenticular  transverse  section  with  a 
maximum  thickness  of  5"""  and  8'""'  respectively.  A  third 
specimen,  flattened  to  an  irregularly  lenticular  mass,  represents 
thin  layers  of  plant  residue  adherent  to  the  sides  of  the  matrix, 
and  obviously  but  a  small  part  of  the  original  structure.  The 
dimensions  of  breadth  here    given    represent    very    nearly    the 

'Cotto  :  Die  Deiulmlitlienin  liivit'luiiig  auf  ilircii  inneren  Uaii.  Dresden,  1832. 

'Corda  :  Heitr.  zur  Flora  der  \'or\velt.   1 845. 

'Hrongniart  :'rab.  des  >,'en.  de  vdg.  foss.  Diet.  Univ.  d'  Hist.  nal. 

*  Goeppert  :  Die  foss.  Fil.  der  perm.  Form. 

5  Renault  :  Ktude  du  gen.  de^.Myelopteris.  Acad,  dc  Paris  aa  :  — 1875.  |  no.  10.  | 

*  1  am  much  indel)ted  to  Dr.  H.  J.  Harrington  for  detenninations  of  tlie  mineral 
constituents  of  these  fossils. 

1897]  IS 


t 


I 


:CTg?iS-S3%i't'-^<'''^»HMtWJiswtfiW«i^,.u'HW!','' 


If 


Hot.lMi.U   u.i/l  III. 


I  I^MAKV 


<n.im«tfr  tif  Itu-  Hiriii  tiirr  iir  in  original  fnrni.  Thr  ^n  MHr.il  .  ..|..i 
!•>  iImI  <>|  Iikiwii  I  u.iI.  Tlir  siirl.M  r  sliows  ik  (  iisiuii.il  iir<  ,i«i  u| 
lliiii  (  n,il\'  ni;i»l«r  iniK  li  hrnkiii  u|»  iiiti»  Miiall  angular  Iragiiitiils, 
Itiit  It  IS  iliiillv  «  li.iiailfri/»'il  by  »  HnnH-whal  fiiuly  sliialti! 
a|i|ifaraiUf  iliu'  Ik  ri'imtval  hI  iIk  ...iliral  lavi-r,  with  n»iis(t|ii(  nt 
ixpnsiiif  III  iln-  iiiKlfilyiiij^  >liafi'l-i  u|  M'lfrt'iichvriia. 

I'lu'  tLiiisvi-rsi-  scttinii  III  thi'  iiiiir«'  |»rrfcrllv  |irfs(rv»il 
H|H'cmKii  sliii\v>  an  iiiilir  /niic  i  ,5"""  tliii  k.  uliii  li  is  (iiminiiniis 
(111  ,ill  sidfs.  Ci'nlial  tn  this  ami  thus  Imiiiiii^'  tin- axis  of  tin- 
original  siriutiiii'.  is  .1  ili^tiii«  tly  ilaiktr  ami  smmwli.it  im,ir 
l>c>ii»iis  mass,  r«»iilaiiiiii^.  luii-  aiiii  tlinc.  small  irr(rj,Milarlv 
roiimlfd  massis  nl  |iyrilf.  l)'|i<iii  Mil)Mi|iiirit  mi(ros«ii|ii(  al 
c'xamiiiatidii,  llicsi.'  zonal  a|i|i('aiaii<t>  wnr  luiiml  tn  lir  din'  tu 
wi'll  lirfiiH'tl  (lirffri'iicrs  ol  striu  tiiri-. 

I  111'  mil  riisn)|iiial  lUtails  pifsctit  iii.iiu  li  .ituics  of  iiiti  rest 
ami,  allliiuij;li  the  m-iifral  i-ffi-cts  of  die  av  ami  ( oinprissioii  liavc 
iiiiii  to  complctfly  (U-slioy  tlu'^tiirral  nlalioiis  of  |iiiits,  ami  in 
many  I'ascs,  also,  to  (U-stroy  stnutiiral  ditails,  tlusr  last  imvc  hccn 
preserved,  in  some  instaiui's,  in  a  n-markahly  ptrfii  t  manm-r. 

Tin;  ii;NrKAi  axis.  1  In-  intiif  ci-iitral  portion  of  the  stiiii 
presents  a  romplete  absence  of  strmtiiial  ditail.  'llie  whole 
central  area  is  occupied  i)y  a  mass  of  dark  colored  male-ial  so 
disposeil  as  to  indicate  its  prol)al)le  derivation  from  thin  walled 
tissue,  but  much  altered  by  tiecay  and  tlii'  sul)se(|uent  effects 
of  extreme  compression.  Here  and  there,  dark  colored  masses 
appear,  possibly  the  residue  of  the  mucilajfe  ori^Miiallv  present. 
Thiouirhout  this  rej,non  lari^^e  rounded  o|)eninjfs  a|)pear.  and 
while  some  of  these  undoubtedly  represent  the  displacement  of 
pyrite,  many,  and  probably  all,  represent  the  former  locations  of 
vascular  bundles,  in  the  dark  color  and  structural  character  of 
this  area,  we  find  amjile  reason  for  its  evident  separation  from 
the  cortical  /.one,  as  ascertained  upon  microsco])ical  examination. 
Outwardly,  this  area  is  limited  by  a  somewhat  well  defined  but 
narrow  and  irregular  darker  line,  which  is  obviously  composed 
of  much  compressed  thin  walled  cells,  but  which,  nevertheless, 
seems  to   sug)j[est  a  somewhat  definite  boundarv  line  between  a 


(lAM'MiV 


•  »»'»7  I 


.Ul/./iU-//  fi/.\  /(>/•/  A/. X,\/S 


n 


tii'ral  tutor 
il  an, IS  of 
Irii^'itit'iils, 
ly    sliialiil 

I  MIlM   l|lll    lit 

|iri'sfrv<'i| 

(  lilltilllMMIS 

ixin  (»f  the 
Mliat  iimrr 
irrt;>j[iilarly 
"roscopical 

he    due    t(i 

of  iiiti  rest 
Nsion  have 
rts,  ami  in 
liavi'  Iji'i'ii 
ii;iiiiii-r. 

I      till'    Slllll 

riif  wliolf 
iiatr "ial  so 
hill  walli'il 
•nt  rlfccts 
t(I  masses 
y  idcsciit. 
pear,  ami 
iccmeiU  of 
icitioiis  of 
laracttr  of 
ition  from 
;uiiinatioti. 

ll'fllK'tl    l)llt 

composed 
I'crthclfss, 
between  a 


central  tiicilnlla  in  wliiih  thin  vvalli-il  (iitiilatiKtilal  tis<tiir  |>rt'> 
<lomiii,it('s,  ,tnil  .1  soini'what  ri^icl,  or  at  least  firiiur,  out)  r /om-. 

I  111.  M»KirA,  No  proper  tortical  struiiiir«'  is  rrprrsnitt  d 
II!  ihiHf  spt'titmiis  I  he  outer  liiuitH  of  the  ttiatioitn  ar«;  fhTiiK  il 
\>\  more  or  Ichh  liroki  ii  iIovvii  slramlH  of  HcU'rciuliyina  lelK,  with 
surroiiiiilin)^'  parcm  liynia  tissue,  making;  it  i  tear  that  a  certain 
,iiiioiiiit  of  struiture  has  tieeii  ri  iiio^ed  ;  ami  thisairords  witti 
wImI  has  .ilreadv  lieiii  noted  in  spii  itiieiis  of  Myelopteris,  that 
"tin-  tissue  layers  outside  the  sclcreni  hyma  strands  are  very 
rait  l\  prcservftl."'  In  tins  ease  the  thin  surface  layers  of  coal 
.ilitMfiv  ilest  rilu'il  are  in  .dl  proliahilits  to  lie  re^'anled  as 
rt  presenliiiL,'  theitirtiial  struiture,  wlinh  must  li.ive  lit  in  <  hit  fly 
or  vvholK  parent  In  iii.'itous  in  eharat-ter,  ami  of  small  radi.d 
vtilmne. 

I'm    si  1.  I  o|<  I  |(  \|    I  \\  I  K.      The  outer,  lontllMloUs  /one.  i.n""" 

thick  as  alreailv  iltsi  riheil,  li.is  iis  maertist uph  ilitlen  nti,ition 
from  the  meilull.i  explaim  «l  l»y  the  Iar|,(e  ;ini<iUiil  <if  lihioiiH 
elements  whitli  it  <  ont,iins  nuiuLf  to  tlu-  pre-i  n«  t  of  these 
t  lenients,  ami  tht  pet  uliar  way  in  uhiih  thi:y  are  tlistrihiitetl, 
thev  have  ser\ed  not  onlv  to  prolei:t  one  .iiiotlu  r,  Imt  they  have 
,ilso  ser\eil  to  prevent  the  tl'fti  t  ol  i  ttmprission  trom  f,illiiij,' 
with  full  force  upon  the  interveiiinu  fuinlanientai  strut  lure  whit  h 
in  conse(|ue!ice,  h,is  often  retained  its  strut  tur;il  ft-aiures  in  an 
exceptitin.illv  perfect  m.inner  (  /ii^'.s.  /  .iml  -»i. 

1'ak1'".N(  iiVM A. — The  i^rouml  tissue,  tor  the  irreattr  ;  .irt,  is 
much  .ilteretl  hv  tiecav  ami  ctunpression,  so  that  all  structural 
features,  especi.itlv  in  the  central  area,  have  been  pretty  com- 
pletely elimin.itetl.  ( )ccasioiially.  however,  when  prtitected  hy 
earlier  inl"iltralit)n  and  petrif.ictioii,  tir  by  the  resistiiiLT  char.icter  of 
the  acct.!n|)anyin,i(  ;^tramls  of  hard  sclerenchym.i,  this  part  of  the 
structure  has  been  preserved  in  a  very  be.iutiful  manner  iji\^s. 
I  and  .?).  I''roin  these  areas  it  is  possible  to  tlelermiiit;  the  fact 
that  this  tissue  consists  of  very  vari.ible.  but  chiefly  liir-^e  ami 
thin  walled  elements  of  such  a  character  as  to  reminti  me  very 
forciblv  of  the  fundamental  structure  in  many  t)f  the  lar^^cr  ferns. 

'Si)lm>l.:iul)acli:  r(i>>.  H'.t.  lOJ. 


i 


li 


HOiMXn.il   I,  </A/7A 


hi«M  411* 


l'li>  iiiU'ri'i'lliil.ii  sjMCCH  onliiLirity  mu*I  \«illi  in  Hiich  tiNNtit*  tiru 
|ircNi'iil,  Intt  llit-u'  It  ID)  t-viilciiti'  III  lilt- I'siHti-nt'f  of  l.u  iiii.i- 
St  i  i  him  iuma.  It  l);iH  Ih-cii  hIiomii  .ilitMilv  that  tln'  siilf 
curtu.tl  /t)iu'  \%  !.«;"""  tlurk.  Willuu  Ihi-^  region  tlu-n-  arc 
iniiiii-roiiHuval  or  liiii^t'iiti.illy  I'loii^atctl  iHinilk'M  i>f  NtU'rciii'liyiiia, 
wliii'l)  U»\\\  lon^:  ttriiiitlH  travi*r>tiii^;  tlic  stem  luii^itiiilinallv  lor 
^'n-at  ilKtaiui's  <.//c>'  /.  •/.  inul  ./).  I'Iuhi'  straiuK,  wlmli  \ii\i' 
till*  |ii-(  (iliarly  slriati-d  a|i|ii-arai)('f  to  tlu'  Mirlaci-  ol  tin-  >t|ic(  iiiuii 
wlti-rt'vrr  cx|to>*rtl,  .ir»'  alwav*  si'|»ar.itccl  Iroiii  oiU'  aiiulhi  i  hv 
Hcvcral  lai^f  ,iiitl  tiiiii  \vallc«l  |»iirciitliyma  «i'lls  {fi}^.  i)  uliirli 
iiri'  Hccn  to  In-  vory  |tfrlicctly  pnv^crvwil  in  ctrtain  ari-as.  ||ju 
Mi'lcrfniliviiiatoiis  clciiu'iits  arc  always  vfr\  tliick  wallril  in  those 
strands  uhiih  lii'  mxl  the  mrtix  ( //^,^  >' ).  t'»it  luruini'  nimh 
tliiiiiit'i  w.illi'd  toward  tlu- (inter  ol  llu-siini  wlure  thes  ollcn 
appear  to  III-  in  a  forniative  eoiidition.  The  strands  an*  Hcparatcd 
radially  by  rather  wide  areas  ol  (iindaniental  tissue  (//</'.  j),  Itul 
in  conseipienee  of  the  ^^i-neral  and  ^reat  alteration  in  relative 
positions  el'fi-eti  d  liv  lompressiun,  it  is  inipossililc  to  ditertnine 
their  ori^Miial  distrilmtioii.  The  radial  dislnlitition  ol  these 
strands  thron^h  a  rather  wide  /one  woidd  seem  to  indii  .ite  that 
they  ntay  ha\e  luen  developed  in  more  or  less  well  deliiietl  con- 
eentric  layers,  a  relation  whieh  is  certainly  implied  liy  their 
distriliiilitin   within   eertain   areas    (//(,^.').      HeNdnd    a   limit   of 

1.3 Iroiii  the   siirlace  the   development  ol    the  strands  a|ipears 

to  lie  wholly  arrested. 

\'\^i  riAU  inMH  IS.  riu-  vaseular  bundles  are  not  Ireipieiitly 
represented,  siuie  in  uiust  cases  they  have  been  removed  by 
decay,  or  other  causes,  and  their  former  positions  are  then 
markeil  by  the  presence  of  rather  broail,  irre^nilarly  rounded 
openinj^s  of  variable  dimensions,  which  appear  throuj^hout  the 
transverse  section  ( y/X""-*.  /.  -'.  -md  ,,').  and  particularly  internal  to 
the  sclerenchyma  /one.  Occasionally  the  bundles  are  preserved 
in  a  very  perfect  manner,  and  exhibit  all  their  essential  structural 
features  with  tfreat  clearness  {y/^,^  /).  The  outermost  uf  the 
two  bundles  seen  in  //{,'".  /,  when  much  enlaru;eil  (//i,'-.  y).  is  found 
to  consist  of  several    broad   scalariform   ducts   enclosed   011    two 


I  MM    tut 

llHHtif  tire 

,1111.1' 

till'      Hllll- 

tlUTf      AtK.' 

renchyina, 

iiially  lor 
liH  li  ^ivc 
>»|H'i  iiiifii 
Itillirr  l)V 
/I     uliitli 

CJIH,         I  III 

li  ill  tlioNC 
illir  lllticll 
lu'\  ullcn 
Ht'paiati'il 

(C-  ■'I .  'it'l 
II  relative 
(K-tiTinitu* 

m|  tlu'Hi' 
liratc  that 
fllU'il  ruii- 

l>y  I  heir 
I  limit  III 
Is  appears 

■re(|iicntly 
uoveil  l)y 
are  then 
V  riiundcd 
,^hniit  the 
nternal  to 
|)reservtHl 
stnictiiral 
St  ul  the 
),  is  I'oiiiul 

li    1)11     two 


•  ■•»7 1 


.U  r  A  A  r»/7/  A7.S  / 1  »/'A  A  A  \.S/M 


»'» 


Hlili'H  l>y  tttws  )ii  lliick  walleii  I'lhruiiH  elritHMIts,  The  phlucrii, 
rtither  Hiiiall  tii  vuliinie,  in  hen.*  iiituh  hrnki  ii  ilowii.  hut  it  it 
•titiiiiteii  riiiiiiilly  outwanl,  while  in  the  other  hiittille  { Jijf.  th 
where  it  in  rather  mure  perleetly  prcHervcil,  it  •«  situated  radially 
iiuv.iri!.  The  prntuxvli  Ml  in  luri'  sicn  as  n  iiTnu\>  of  siiialU  r 
elt  iiienis  iiiiuli  altered  l»y  n»iiipre""<i«in  ( /f),'.  /).  or  i»i  otlnr 
iiisiiiiices  mure  perfectly  preservi  il  (///;.  /),  sometimes  un  the 
uuter  fuce  uf  the  veNsels,  {irid  sumetiiiicH  un  the  inner  face,  hut 
Hlways  hetween  them  and  the  phloem.  While  the  hundles  vary 
con><ideral)lv  in  si/e,  tin  v  all  < unlnrm  to  the  en"  iteral  type  and 
it  IS  ol  interest  to  note  ili.it  in  .ill  their  structur.il  features,  they 
H^:ree  very  cli»scly  with  the  iKindlcii  of  n  Hpeclen  of  Myclox\loi) 
tltserilied  l»y  Solnis  |,.uil).ich,"  and  xhtt  hy  Seward.^ 

l*'rom   the   present   material    I    have   heeii  wholly   un.ihie  to 
oliiiiin    ^atisf.utorv  det.iiN   of    th«'    structure   (»l    the   bundle    m 
loii^'itiuliii.il    section,  he;,  Olid   the    latt    that    the  vessels   are   dis 
tiiu  tlv  scalarifornt,  and  in  this  respect  they  conform  to  the  type 
j^eiierally  ohservi  d  in  (mis. 

The  peculiar  situation  td  these  bundles  is  not  altoj^ether  easy 
to  .lecount  for.  Tlu  \  icrtainlv  appe.ir  to  lie  between,  ;ind  are 
therefore  iiiitifrliil  Willi,  the  strands  of  si  K  reiichynia,  from  which 
eircumstiinee  I  was  at  first  led  to  siippos*-  them  to  he  collateral, 
as  in  the  case  of  I'hoeiii\  .iiid  titlier  p.iliiis,  but  .t  very  careful 
examination  fails  to  disclose  any  satisfactory  eviilence  of  such 
relationship,  while  in  some  cases  at  least  the  vascul.ir  bundle  is 
separ.ited  from  the  nearest  sclerenchyma  stranil  by  a  broad  zciie 
ni  fundamental  tissue.  Indeed,  the  evidence,  so  far  as  obtain- 
able from  the  present  material,  seems  icj  indicite  that  these 
bundles  and  the  sclerenchyma  are  altot,'ether  independent  of  or\c 
another;  but  in  the  present  unsatisfactory  comlition  of  the 
niateri.^I  now  available,  :io  fin.il  conclusion  can  be  drawn.  Kroiii 
the  eviilence  at  hand,  however,  it  would  seem  that  the  vascular 
bundles  have  their  extreme  outwanl  distribution  in  the  central 
portion  of  the  .sclerenchyma   zone.      I-'mm    this   position    they 

•^■o^!^.  It'll.  ii>i.  //f.  / /  /i, 

•.\nn.  lint.  7:   />.'.  /  .111.1  //,  /ii't.  /.  V.  /y. 


/.'(»//  \/l.l/    ( :.!//■  Ill: 


( I A  M   \  K  V 


ilUllMSi-   ill    IIIIHlhlT   illUMld     tin-    1  I'lltlT  .111(1     1)C(  lilllr   llll>->t    iiuiiu'r- 

oiis  uilliin  tlu'  ci'iitiii'  rii^JDii. 

Si  cKi.TiiKv  oK.iAN.-..  A  ii()t,il)U-  fi-at'irr  ^li  llu"  prcsfiil  fossil 
is  tlir  orciirronci-  of  mmuTous  largi.  iiiiicila^f  passa^fs.  As  a 
nik'  tln'SL-  stniiluifs  ait'  imuli  altiTiM  hv  ili-iay  ami  c-nmpiis- 
sioii,  hilt  ill  two  instances  tlu'V  wire  foiiiul  in  a  vi^y  piTfi'Ct 
state  ol  preservation  (  //;,'-.  J\.  So  far  as  it  is  at  pii'scii  possible  to 
deteriniiK',  these  organs  occur  tlirounliuut  the  siih-cortical  region 
where  thev  are  in  nion-  or  less  intimate  association  with  the 
sclerencliyni.\  stran('s.  i-Jsewhere  it  is  not  possible  1o  determine 
the  (listrihiition  satisfactorily,  l)nt,  fiom  our  kii  iwledi^c  ol  their 
occurrence  in  recent  |<laiils,  it  is  a  fair  inference  tliat  they  must 
also  be  distributeil  throui'li  Die  entire  l)ody  of  the  fniidaiiuntal 
structure. 

Measurements  of  such  of  these  passages  as  were  in  a 
sufficient  state  of  prcservati.m  for  such  a  pu'pose  showed  them 
to  ha\e  the  lollowinn'  dimensions:  i.;;xi00jw,;  JC);xi3;/x; 
2 1 1;  ■  143^.  From  these  results  it  is  possible  to  deduce  an 
averaj^e  dimension  of  127  I(j2/x.  I-'-om  this  ayain  it  appears 
that  these  passa<.jes  mavbe  described  as  of  elliptical  form,  in  which 
the  minor  and  major  axes  have  a  ratio  ol  i  :  1.5.  The  very 
great  size  of  these  structures,  unusual  except  in  a  few  irroui)s  of 
plants,  seems  to  su'^^'nest  a  comparison  with  both  Lyciclaceie  and 
Marattiace;e.  In  structure  they  are  siniijle.  LoiiL,n'tudinally 
thev  form  liMig  tubular  passaf^es  which  traverse  the  stem  for 
great  distances.  l:i  transverse  section  they  consist  of  large  ellip- 
tical openings  bounded  by  a  very  regular  w.iU  composed  of  par- 
en:hyma  cells  often  iliffering  but  little  from  those  of  the  sur- 
rounding tissue.  Thev  are  mc>re  commonly  somewhat  elongated 
tangential Iv  to  the  central  canal,  and  by  analogy  with  similar 
structures  in  recent  plar.ts  we  may  infer  that  they  contained 
active  proto])lasm.  Thev  thus  forn:  the  secretory  cells,  or  an 
epithelium  which  is  not  .-.pecially  differentiated  ^fig.  _^).  A 
comparison  of  the  two  canals  {fig.  2)  will  serve  to  show,  how- 
ever, that  the  secretory  cells  often  show  little  or  ikj  dexiation 
from     llie    general     character    of    tlie    fundamental     structure. 


(  I  \  M    \  H  V 
st    IIUIIUT- 

HMit  fossil 

t"-.      As  ;i 

cumprcs- 

\-     [HTli'Ct 

iussil)|i'  to 
cal  rr'^ioii 
I  witli  tlu' 
(Iftfiiniru' 
(•  ol  tlicir 
tlicv  must 
idaiiu'iilal 

icrc  in  a 
wed  tlitin 
D5X  i3;/x; 
IcdiKc  an 
it  a|)|)(.-ais 
1,  in  whicli 

The  \rrv 
groups  ol 
l.iCLM'  and 
;itudinallv 

stem  for 
art^c  el  lip  • 
ed  of  par- 
)f  the  sur- 
eloiigatcd 
itli  similar 
contain. -d 
A\s,  or  an 

:^-  /)■  A 

how,  how- 
dexiation 
structure. 


iK>7| 


MVi.i.ori hRis  hiI'I-.k i:\sis 


31 


Another  important  feat'ire  of  tliese  laiials  is  t«.  Ix-  found  in  the 
fact  that  tliev  are  always  devoid  of  contents.  llii-.  ap|)ears  to 
justily  tlie  view  tliat  wliatever  they  may  liave  contained  origi- 
nallv  was  of  a  soiul)ie  nature  and  thus  |)assed  out  ol  the  ixuly 
of  tin-  plant  during  the  process  of   petrilactioii. 

In  all  tlieir  principal  structural  aspects  these  canals  hear  a 
stronj,'  reseml)lance  to  those  of  Ani^iof^fcris  ivcctii  (they  are  of 
the  same  tyi)e),  and  it  mav  al^o  l)e  |)ointed  out  that  they  are 
similar  to  tliose  fourd  in  Riuliiophris  / 1 '////</w,sw/// vvhi(  h  .Seward 
has  recently  separated  honi  M velowlon,"  as  also  to  tiiose  of 
Myeloxylon  itself." 

'rhroutfhoul  the  transverse  section  of  the  Topeka  specinuii 
there  are  numerous  resinous  or  coaly  masses  of  very  variable 
si/.e,  l)Ut  cvidentlv  originalls  contained  in  special  channels  or 
cells,  which  have  heconu'  much  disorifani/ed,  aiul  the  details  ol 
which  cannot  now  he  made  out.  In  huinituilinal  section  these 
masses  are  (;f  indefinite  lenjfth.  but  ratiier  freiiuently  septate. 
From  these  features  it  is  |)ossil>le  to  refer  them  to  the  residue  ol 
resin  masses  which  the  plant  oriifinally  contained,  and  they  are, 
therefr)re,  directlv  c(jmparaljle  with  the  similar  resin  bodiis 
fouiul  in  recent  plants,  particularly  those  of  Ani^iopkns  tVCiUi. 

It  is  tiui^-  fairlv  certain  tiiat  in  the  Topeka  plant  there  were 
orii(inally  at  least  two.  and  possibly  niore,  kinds  of  secretory 
origans,  tiie  one  holding  mucilage,  the  other  resinous  matter, 
and  in  these  resjiects  our  plant  is  once  more  comparable  with 
certain  recent  forms. 

The  general  view  of  tiie  internal  structure  thus  obtained 
permits  us  to  gain  some  conception  of  the  real  composition  of 
this  stem  or  stipe,  from  which  we  may  infer  that  a  restoration 
would  show  a  cortical  layer  of  parenchyma  at  least  several  layers 
of  cells  thick,  containing  numerous  mucilage  passages.  P'ollow- 
ing  this  is  a  sub-cortical  zone  distinguished  by  the  presence  of 
nuiiicrous  rather  widclv  separatetl  strands  of  sclcrenchyma,  the 
elements  of  which  are  very  thick  walled  toward  the  cortex,  but 

■'.\nn.  Hot.  8:  />/.  .V///./(V.f.  'i' //  t.'"- 
"  .\nn.  Uui.  7;  //.  I,  figs.  1,1). 


-r*jSJ^^^^|J(^||flffff^^BnW^?J^''"' 


HO/AXJCl/.  UA/./.J  //: 


I.IANIARY 


Cdiuimially  tliiiitu"'  walled  toward  the  mciliilla.  Tlicsc  strands 
iisuall)'  liavf  an  accompunvin^  iiuicilajfc  passaj^c  on  the  oiiter 
lace,  inul  are  inconstant  {':)  process  of  formation  tow.ird  tlie 
center.  Within  this  zone,  vascular  bundles,  distinf^uislied  by 
tiieir  broad  scalariform  vessels,  appear,  anil  increase  in  number 
toward  the  central  re^non.  The  central  axis  consists  of  a  rather 
broad  tract  of  parenchyma  tissue,  throuj^h  which  tlie  vascular 
bu.ndles  are  distributed  in  larj,    numbers. 

l*rom  this  point  of  view,  and  with  ilue  allowance  for  the 
effects  of  compression,  it  is  possible  to  trace  a  strikinj^  similarity 
in  several  respects  to  a  species  of  Myeloxvlon  describeil  by 
Solms-Laubach,"  and  i  lore  |)articularly  in  certain  respects  to 
specimens  of  Myelopte  is  described  bv  Williamson.'^  The  evi- 
dence is  both  clear  and  direct  that  this  plant  must  be  considered 
as  belontrinn'  to  that  peculiar  trroup  for  which  the  name 
Myelo|)teris,  pro])osed  by  Renault,  has  been  most  jrcnerally 
emploved. 

In  1S32,  Cotta  ilescribed  certain  fossils  from  the  Carbonifer- 
ous of  Kuro|)e  under  the  name  of  Medullosa,  which  has  more 
recently  become  mer^red  in  that  of  Myelopteris.  Williamson, 
however,  informs  us  that  Cotta's  figures  of  M.  clegans  are  wholly 
misleading,  the  structure  being  represented  in  a  much  exagger- 
ated form,  while  his  two  .>^pecies,  J/,  stiilata  and  .]/.  porosa, 
remain  too  obscure  to  be  depended  upon  without  further  evi- 
dence than  has  come  down  to  us.'^  The  genus  Medullosa, 
nevertheless,  constitutes  the  basis  of  that  group  of  i)lants 
which,  ])assing  under  several  names,  ha;;  finallv  come  to  be  known 
under  that  of  Mvelopteris. 

In  1845,  Corda  assigned  to  his  genus  Falmacites  two  plants 
from  the  Coal  Measures  of  Bohemia,  under  the  names  of  P. 
ntrboiiigciiiis  ami  P.  Icptoxylon.^^  An  examination  of  Corda's 
figures  shows  that  there  is  no  very  great  resemblance,  although 

"Fos.s.  Hdt.  l6i,  fiji.  14A. 

■'Fossi,  plants  of  tlic  Coal  Measures.     I'hil.  Trans.  166:  fin!.  /,.?,  4. 
'■•Koss.  plants  of  the  Coal  Measures.     I'hil.   Trans.  166'. 
'SFIora  tier  Vcjrweit  4c,  41.  //.  /9,  .?().      1845, 


I.IAMARY 

c  Strands 
the  outer 
•ward  the 
lislicd  bv 
II  iuinil)cr 
if  a  rather 

■  vascular 

L'  for  the 
simihirity 
:ribecl  l)y 
rspects  to 
The  evi- 
onsitlcred 
he  name 
j^cne  rally 

irbonifer- 
lias  more 
illiamson, 
re  wholly 
exagger- 
'/.  poros(7, 
rther  cvi- 
IcduUosa, 
)f  plants 
be  known 

\\o  ])lants 
lies  of  P. 

■  Corda's 
although 


lSi>7 


M)  /  lor/  /  h/S    /<)/7A/:XS/S 


M 


there  is  a  suggestion  of  similarity  to  our  plant  in  the  general 
eiiaracter  of  the  fundamental  tissue,  and  tiie  presence  of  numer- 
ous mucilage  passages.  These  latter,  however,  are  small  and 
a|)|iarentlv  altogether  separated  from  the  vascular  bundle.s. 

Subsecpient  observers  have  not  been  unmimlful  of  certain 
structural  aspects  in  these  plants,  which  ha\e  seemed  to  suggest 
their  possii)le  relationship  to  the  palms,  and  more  particularly  to 
that  tvpe  of  structure  represented  in  the  genus  IJrac;ena,  but  much 
doubt  has  always  been  entertaineil  as  to  the  possibility  of  mono- 
cotyledons occurring  so  far  back  as  the  Carboniferous.  These 
doubts  w-ere  first  ijromiuently  expressed  by  lirongniart  as  the 
result  of  comparing  with  the  plants  figuied  by  Cotta  and  Corda, 
new  material  obtained  from  Autun,  France."'  He  says  "il  y  ait 
des  differences  fort  essentielles  et  (|ue  rendent  tres  difficile 
d'etablir  des  rapports  entre  ces  fossiles  et  les  vegetaux  vivants." 
He  therefore  preferred  to  regard  Cotta's  Midullo.ui  i/t\!^'-a//s  as 
the  representative  of  a  new  genus,  for  which  he  proposed  the 
name  Mveloxylon.  which  thus  seemed  to  indicate  the  leading 
structural  features  indicated  by  the  former  name,  the  signifi- 
cance of  which  was  thereby  jjcrpetuated. 

Fifteen  years  later,  Goeppert,  in  reviewing  Cotta's  species, 
regartled  Midiil/osa  cligtiiis  as  possessing  characters  which  were 
variously  represented  in  the  gymnosperms,  in  i)alms,  and  in  the 
ferns.  As  a  generalized  type,  he  applied  to  it  the  name  of 
.Stenzelia. 

In  1873,  Williamson  first  drew  attention  to  the  belief  that 
the  relations  of  these  fossils  had  not  been  correctly  interjireted, 
and  expressed  the  view  that  tiiey  were  really  ferns  allied  to  the 
Marattiace;e.'' 

In  1874.  Renault  reviewed  the  fossils  obtained  from  the 
Carboniferous  beds  at  Autun,  as  a  result  of  which  he  supports 
the  conclusions  reached  by  Williamson,  and  while  he  regards  the 
name  proposed  by  Corda  to  be  wholly  untenable,  and  those  of 
Cotta  and  Goeppert  to  be  insufificiently  indicative,  he  views  that 

"'Tab.  des  gen.  ile  Veg.  l-'oss.  Oo.   1849.     (Quoted  from  Williamxm.) 
"Hril.  A.-is.  .\<X\.  Sci.  1873. 


I 


34 


/U)/.l\/l'.t/.   (,.l/./:/r/: 


I  ia.\i;akv 


of  Hroii^Mjiart  \vit!i  lavor,  l»iil  ictfards  a  tlinVrcnt  form  as  more- 
expressive  of  tlie  rclati()nslii|)  wliicli  lie  (litirniliud.'**  He 
tluit  lore  says:  "  I'oiir  coiiserver  le  iioiii,  |ireiiiier  eii  tiale,  doiiiie 
|iar  M.  Hron^niiart  a  ces  [jortioiis  de  plaiUes,  et  eii  iiieine  temps 
|toiir  rappeler  leiir  nature,  je  les  desi^iierai  sous  !e  iiom  tie 
M  yeloptcris." 

riie  yet  more  recent  studies  of  tliese  plants  h\  Williamson 
led  him  to  admit  the  force  of  the  ari^uments  employed  Uy 
Renault  and  the  appropriateness  of  his  nanie.'^  Referenct-  to 
Willianisou's  figures  discloses  several  points  of  resemblance 
between  his  specimens  and  my  own.  This  is  to  be  noted  (irsl 
in  a  i,n-eat  similarity  with  res|)ect  to  the  Lfeneral  distribution  of 
tissues,  particuhiily  as  exhibited  in  his  Jii^s.  j  and  ./,  as  likewise 
in  the  very  general  removal  of  the  vascular  inmdles.  The  vas- 
cular bundle  i,nven  by  him  (  Williamson, y/^'-.  7*)  is  closely  similar 
to  that  derived  from  the  Topeka  s|)ecinien  [  Jii^.  7),  but  differs 
materially  from  his  other  representation  (Williamson,  y/i,''-  7) 
taki'U  from  the  uj)|)er  end  of  a  rachis,  which  is  closelv  simil.ir  to 
bundles  observed  by  me  in  Dioon  cdulc,  whereby  it  offers  some 
basis  of  C(jmparison  with  the  Cvcadacea;. 

In  longitudinal  section  the  resemblance  is  rather  close,  but 
in  this  aspect  the  To|)eka  specimen  offers  little  evidence  of  a 
satisfactory  nature  beyond  the  general  relations  of  jiarts,  anil 
the  structural  markings  of  the  vessels  winch  are  seen  to  be 
scalariform,  as  in  the  ferns. 

Finally,  the  relation  of  the  mucilage  passages  to  the  vas- 
cular bundles  (Williamson,  y?^.  14)  and  of  the  very  large,  elli])- 
tical  mucilage  passages  to  the  sclerenchvma  strands  (William- 
son, Aa''-  A))>  ^^  '^'^"  i''*-'  ^■'-"'■y  thin  walled  elements  of  the  funda- 
mental structure,  all  |)resent  features  almost  identical  with  those 
observed  in  the  Topeka  specimens  {Jigs.  /,  ^, .?). 

Williamson's  specimens  appear  to  differ  from  mv  own  chiefly 
with  respect  to  the  particular  distribution  of  the  sclerenchvma 
strands  in  the   cortical   region,  a  difference  which,   however,  is 

■'  Reclierclies  .sur  les  veKctaiix  silicitics  d'.Viitun.     ( l-'rom  Willjumxtn.) 
"  Fos.sil  plants  of  the  Coal  .Measures.     I'liil.  Trans.  i66'. 


I  i\\i;akv 

II  as  more 
ncl/"  ifc 
late,  (Idiiiu'" 
einc  temps 
L'    iKim    <lc 

A'illiamsnn 
ployed  by 
■tereiice  to 
;scnil)Iaiice 
noted  first 
iil)iiti(iii  of 
as  likewise 
The  vas- 
^ely  similar 
but    dil'lers 

t^'i.A'--  7) 
•  similar  to 

Ifers  some 

■  close,  but 

deuce  of  a 

parts,  and 

ieeti   to   be 

o  the  vas- 
arife,  ellip- 
(Williani- 
the  funda- 
with  those 

)vvn  chiefly 
ereiichvma 
lowever,  is 

n.) 


IM.,7 


.M\ I  i.oi'i r.ias  i{<i'i  Kissis 


35 


more  speeilk:  than  y;eneric,  l)iit  my  material  has  been  so  altered 
bv  compression  tliat  I  slimdd  liesitate  t<t  place  much  reliance 
upon  tliese  aspects  oi  >triuture,  preferring-  ratiur  to  establish 
the  aflinity  i)y  nicans  of  the  more  perfectly  prestrved  slriutmal 
elements. 

The  distribution  of  the  vascular  l)imdles  in  concentric  zones, 
as  described  by  Williamson,  may  also  be  a  feature  of  the  Topeka 
specimen,  but  for  reasons  alreaily  stated  this  cannot  lie  asserted 
with  anv  def^ree  of  confidence. 

More  recently  Solms-I.aubach*  has  reviewed  the  entire 
relations  of  this  tfrouj)  of  i)lants,  and  while  lie  rejects  Renault's 
name  because  he  rei^ards  the  evidence  as  not  altogether  satis- 
factory, he  prefers  to  retain  HronLjni.irt's  name  (jf  Myeloxylon 
••rather  than  .Sten/elia,  because  it  is  better  known."  He  \(\\c^ 
two  il^nires,  one  of  a  i,a-neral  transverse  section,  the  other  of  a 
separate  vascular  bundle,  and  it  is  r)f  considerable  interest  to 
note  that  this  latter  is  almost  the  e.\act  counterpart  of  a  vascular 
bundle  obtained  from  the  Topeka  fossil  (y/!,^  /i.  His  ^a-neral 
vii-w  of  tlie  structure  is  not  so  satisfactory,  but  it  nevertheless 
exhibits  a  close  similarity  to  my  own  material  in  all  its  principal 
features. 

Solnis-Laul)ach  dissents  from  the  conclusions  of  both  Renault 
and  Williamson,  holdini(  that  there  are  stront^  reasons,  on  ana- 
tomical trrounds.  for  considerin^r  the  alliance  to  be  with  the 
CN-cadace;e,  and  cites  Mcdnllosa  Lciulun-ti  as  pnjbably  affording 
important  evidence  in  support  of  this  view. 

The  most  recent  contribution  to  our  knowledL^e  of  these 
|)lants  is  that  offered  i)y  Mr.  A.  C.  Seward,  who  has  not  only 
reviewed  tlie  material  originally  described  by  Williamson,  but 
has  made  a  detaileil  study  of  specimens  contained  in  the  Hinncy 
collection  of  the  Woodwardian  Museum.  Cambrid;^^'.  as  well  as 
of  new  naterial  derived  from  the  Millstone  grit  of  Lancaster." 
The  o.'r,  ^.')ses  show  that  his  material  is  generically  the  same  as 
tiiat   represented  by  the  Topeka  specimens  as  described.       In  a 

^'Koss.  lii)t.  161.     I^'OI. 
="  Ann.  liot.  7:1. 


It 


a6 


MO TAX/C.t I.  GA/.E TTE 


[jANi-A«V 


scCDiid  |);i|)cr,  tlic  same  authority  tuakcs  a  stiulv  of  certain  spec- 
imens containetl  in  the  Williamson  collection  and  originally 
incliulcd  by  Williamson  in  the  ^rcniis  Myelopteris,  hut  which  he 
fiiuls  to  be  in  reality  ([uite  distinct.  lie  therefore  He|)arateH 
them  under  the  name  of  Riuhhptcris  WiUinnisoni."  This  species 
is  quite  tlistinct  from  our  Topeka  specimen  with  res|)ect  to  the 
character  of  '.he  vascular  bundles,  which  are  concentric,  and  thus 
show  a  tlistinct  approach  to  the  type  represented  iit  Aui:;iof>tins 
evccta.  On  the  other  hand,  the  mucilage  passages,  which  are 
also  of  the  type  found  in  Angiopteris,  are  essentially  the  same 
as  those  of  the  Topeka  specimen,  differing  only  in  distri- 
bution.'3 

l'>om  the  review  thus  presented,  it  is  tpiitc  clear  that  our 
specimen  must  be  regarded  as  a  s|)ecies  of  myelopteris,  accord- 
ing to  the  name  adopted  by  Renault  anil  Williamson,  and 
retained  by  me  as  expressing  its  probable  relations,  but  that  it 
differs  s|)ecifically  from  any  of  the  specimens  heretofore 
described.  It  may  be  concluded  further  that  the  present  mate- 
rial represents  the  stipe  of  a  frond,  rather  than  the  stem 
proper. 

Heretofore  the  representatives  of  this  genus  have  been 
derived  wholly  from  the  Carboniferous  of  Kuropc.  The  material 
now  at  hand  from  the  Upper  Carboniferous  of  Kansas  thus 
afforils  important  evidence  as  to  the  wider  geographical  range 
of  these  plants,  while  the  well  ])reserved  condition  of  portions 
t)f  its  structure  permits  a  further  discussion  of  its  possible  affin- 
ities. I  have,  therefore,  carefully  passed  in  review  such  species 
of  living  plants  as  are  available  in  the  botanic  (iardens  of 
McGill  University,  as  affording  a  possible  solution  of  this  ques- 
tion. In  jjrosecuting  these  studie;N  I  have  had  in  view  the  sug- 
gestions of  earlier  investigators,  as  well  as  those  which  natu- 
rally arose  in  my  own  mind  upon  making  a  preliminary 
examination  of  these  fossils.  I  have,  therefore,  carefully  exam- 
ined   Cordylinc    tcrminalis.  Phoenix  dactylifcra ,  Kcntin  Fosteruvia, 

=-■  Anil.  Hot.  8  :  207. 
-■'.■\nn.  Bot.  8://. /.^A^  *. 


f  lAMAKV 

•rtain  spoc- 

orijfinally 

t  which   he 

;   SL-paratcs 

his  spt'cit's 

)ect  to  the 

c.and  thus 

/hii^io/ifin's 

wliiclj  are 

the  same 

in    tlistri- 

r  that  our 
is,  accord- 
uson,  and 
)iit  tliat  it 
heretofore 
scnt  niate- 
tlie    stem 

have  been 
ic  material 
msas  thus 
ical  ranjj^e 
if  portions 
sible  aflfin- 
ch  species 
ardens  of 
this  ques- 
w  the  sug- 
hich  natu- 
reliminary 
Lilly  exani- 
Fosteriano, 


I8.J7I 


MM.  I  A  tpTKKts  ror/:Ki:\s/s 


>1 


LiitiNiiii  borbonha,  Cyciis  irroliitii,   IHoon  cdulc,  /.lonio  intn^ri/oliti, 
Cibotiiiin  tr^iih,  and  .■hij;^io/'/iii.\  ivcitii. 

A  close  comparison  of  the  Uracicna  type,  as  represented  by 
Cordvline,  shows  that  any  suj,fgeslion  of  resemblance  which 
might  at  first  appear,  has  no  real  basis  in  structural  characters, 
while  in  manv  essential  respects  there  is  a  \ery  wide  difference. 
Noteworthy  points  of  reseniblance  being  absent,  it  is  wholly 
uiujecessarv  to  enter  into  a  more  iletailed  consideration  of  the 
structural  aspects  of  this  type.  \'ery  nearly  the  same  observa- 
tions arc  applicable  to  the  palms.  In  this  grou|>  of  |)lants,  how- 
ever, there  is  a  somewhat  closer  point  of  contact  to  be  found  in 
the  mucilage  passages.  Here  these  structures  appear  as  tubular 
channels  of  great  length,  and  in  this  respect,  as  well  as  in  their 
distribution  and  great  number,  there  is  a  general  resemblance  to 
the  Topeka  fossil.  Their  detailed  structure  is,  on  the  other  hand, 
(|uite  different,  anil  it  jxiints  to  a  want  of  aflinity  which  is  sup- 
ported bv  the  structure  and  distribution  of  the  vascular  bundles, 
as  also  the  character  of  the  funilamental  structure,  and  no  very 
searching  comparison  is  required  to  establish  the  fact  that  the 
affinities  of  our  fossil  must  be  sought  elsewhere. 

Hv  several  authorities  the  Cycadace;e  ha\e  been  suggested 
as  affording  a  satisfactorv  basis  of  comparison,  a  view  which,  in 
more  recent  times,  appears  to  have  been  particularly  urged  by 
Solms-Laubach,^*  although  he  elsewhere  agrees  with  other 
observers  that  certain  exceptions  which  have  been  taken  to  the 
cycadaceous  character  of  the  Medullos;e  are  well  fouiuled." 

Mr.  Seward,  vet  more  recentlv.  has  given  expression  to  the 
same  view,  basing  his  opinion  upon  a  very  critical  examination 
of  a  large  amount  of  material.-''^  While  admitting  the  many 
points  of  resemblance  to  ferns,  he  holds  that  in  the  position  of 
the  protoxvlem  and  in  the  structure  of  the  fnucilage  passages, 
as  also  in  the  distribution  of  the  sub-cortical  sclerenchyma, 
there  arc  strong  reasons  for  considering  the  affinity  to  be  with 

^*l-'<)ss.  Hot.   Ibl. 
'ilMii.  100. 
"'^Aiin.  Hot.  7:  iS. 


! 


«l 


*. 

fi 


in 


I 

i 

.1 

I! 


.'S 


/mr.iMc.if.  i;.\/.i- 1 II: 


(lAMAHV 


tin-  cyi.uls  ratlur  than  with  thi-  firns.  Without  liopiii^-  to 
settle  this  i|iicsti<tn  at  ihf  prcsiiit  tiim-,  it  may  l)r  prufitalilr  to 
coiisiilcr  .some  of  the  arguments  ailvancctl  by  Mr.  Seward  in 
the  light  of  tvideiice  obtained  froii)  an  examination  of  material 
ilerivcd  from  existing  species,  as  also  from  the  Topeka  specimen 
itself. 

Vasili.ak  iiiM)i.i;s. — An  examination  of  both  tyeadaceoiis 
jilants  and  ////i,w/'/<m  cvccto  afforiis  but  littU-  evidence  contrary 
I')  the  view  urgeil  bv  Mr.  .Seward.  The  evidence  obtained  shows, 
as  he  contemls,  that  the  position  of  the  |)rotoxylem  in  these 
plants  is  certainlv  an  argimieiit  in  favor  of  the  cycadaceous 
character  of  .Mveloxylon.  On  the  other  hand,  the  collateral 
character  of  the  vascular  bundles  in  the  latter  cannot  be  taken 
as  final  evidence  of  afViiiity  either  with  the  ferns  or  with  the 
cvcads,  as  Mr.  Seward  himself  points  out.  Althougli  the  longi- 
tudinal sections  of  the  Topeka  specimens  havi'  given  far  from 
satisfactorv  results,  the  evidence  to  be  derived  from  them  indi- 
cates a  much  closer  resemblance  to  Angiopteris  than  to  any  t)f 
the  cvcads  1  li.ive  been  able  to  study. 

.Si;(  KKiuKV  ()i<(;.\Ns. — lu  the  Cycadacea',  ;is  represented  by 
Cyciis  nvoliitii,  /.oniui  iiili'i^rifolid,  and  Dioon  ciiiile,  the  secretory 
organs  ap|)ear  to  be  all  of  j>ne  kind  as  represented  by  mucilage 
canals.  These  structures  are  distributicl  throughout  the  funda- 
mental tissue  and  are  represented  by  broad  canals  v/hich  are 
chiefly  limited  by  tangentially  elongatetl  parenchyma  cells. 
These  latter,  therefore,  differ  somewhat  conspicuously  from  the 
cells  of  the  surrounding  tissue,  as  already  shown  by  Mr.  .Sew- 
ard.'' .So  far  as  apj)ears  from  the  species  above  irulicated,  how- 
e^'cr,  these  canals  are  alway.s  lined  with  a  layer  of  very  thin- 
walled  epithelium  cells,  which  become  ru|)tured  with  age  and, 
shrinking  back  upon  the  main  wall  of  the  canal,  give  it  a  thick- 
ened and  very  ragged  ajjpearance. 

In  Angiopteris  cvecta  there  are  three  distinct  kinds  of  secre- 
tory organs:  {a)  tannin  sacs,  \,b)  resin  canals,  and  U)  mucilage 
canals. 

=?Ann.  l{<it.  8:  214. 


1   i 


I  I  A  M    \  K  V 

liopiim  to 
(ifitalili'  III 
Seward  in 
il   iD.'itfrinl 

I  sprciilun 

■ciulfiiruiis 
;c  contrary 
ncd  allows, 

II  in  these 
,'ca(laccoiis 

coilatLial 
)t  be  taken 
ir  \vitl\   the 

tliu  longi- 
•II  far  from 
tliein  inili- 
II  to  any  of 

cscnttil  l)v 
;  secrctorv 
y  nuicilaife 
the  funda- 

which  are 
yma  cells. 
V  from  tlic 
y  IMr.  Sew- 
atcd,  how- 
very  thiii- 
1  age  and, 

it  a  thick- 

s  of  sccrc- 
)  mucilage 


|H.)7| 


.1/ )  A l.Ont-./i/S  Ton. A7. .\.s7.s 


29 


Toniiin  stus.  Ill  U-iiisverM-  section  the  tamiin  sarn  .ire  ultrii 
harely  ilistiiigiii^hahle  frtnii  the  resin  canals,  In  reason  of  their 
structural  similarity.  They  occur  al>un<lantly  in  the  cortex  and 
^l^roll^dlout  the  fundamental  tissue,  and  especially  in  ilose  |»r«).\- 
imity  to  or  within  the  limits  of  the  vascular  hundles.  To  me 
these  appear  to  he  the  structures  rcfcrieil  to  by  Mr.  Seward  in 
his  description  of  Kmhiopkns  W'illiiiinsoni,  when  he  says,  "there 
are  smaller  canals  in  the  peripheral  part  of  the  phloem  of  each 
bundle."'**  In  longitudinal  section  tliesc  sacs  are  seen  to  be  of 
about  the  same  diamet<'r  as  in  the  transverse  section.  e.Ncept  in 
the  cortex,  where  thev  assume  the  loMii  of  cylindrical  cells  about 
three  or  four  limes  longer  than  broad.  The  contents  are  much 
lighter  colored  than  those  of  tlu-  resin  canals,  and  often  present 
a  well  defined  granular  appearance.  They  readily  yield  the 
characteristic  reactions  for  tannin, 

Rfsin  <v///^//.v.  — Throughout  the  sub-corticd  zone,  scattered 
among  the  sclereiichyma  cells  ami  also  central  t«)  each  of  the 
isolated  strands,  are  rather  broad  canals  of  indefinite  length. 
Throughout  the  fundamental  tissue,  particularly  in  the  neighbor- 
hood of  the  vascular  bundles,  there  are  also  numerous  c  ;iii.ils 
which  differ  but  slightly  in  their  structural  aspects  from  the 
surrounding  cells.  In  all  cases,  however,  they  are  at  once 
recognizable  by  the  r.ither  ilark  reil  resinous  mass  which  each 
contains.  In  longitudinal  section  the  canals  ;ire  of  indefinite 
length.  The  contents  are  often  septate.  These  structures 
appear  tt)  mc  to  be  comparable  with  the  black,  resinwus  m.isses 
of  variable  size  to  be  met  with  not  only  in  the  Topeka  specimen, 
but  in  most  of  the  Kuro|)ean  specimens  of  Myeloxylon. 

Miiciltigv  Kimtls. — Throughout  the  ground  tissue  of  Angio- 
pteris  there  may  be  seen  broad  openings  bounded  by  more  or 
less  taiigeiitially  elongated  cells.  These  are  the  canals  from 
which  issue  the  very  large  volume  of  mucilage  freely  liberated 
when  the  stipe  is  sectioned.  These  canals  are  always  limited  by 
cells  which  differ  but  little  from  those  of  the  surrounding  tissue, 
except  that  they  are  more  or  less  elongated  taiigentially.      Here 

•-•'Ann.  Hot.  8:  214. 


fl 


i 

! 


I 


fli 

r  I 

I* 


M 


m>t'i\n  u  I,  i/h  lit 


\\SHV\*H 


llun*  in  no  «<|»»cl;illv  iliff«niiliattil  t|iithiliiim,  ;int!  in  tlii««  rtN|ntt 
w.'  unit  will)  a  Icitiiii'  wliitli  sirv«s  tn  sIi.m|iIv  M|iai.ili-  tlus«' 
.stiiiitmi's  Iroin  Uiuhi-  hI  tin-  l.yiatlai  «',r.  <  >ii  llir^f  uniiimh  I 
mIiouIiI  ti'il  m»  hositalioii  iii  ^l^•t•i(lill^;  as  tn  wlnllitr  a  ^;iviii  plant 
wi'rc  cvi"iulai"iM)iiH  m  filimiil  iti  its  alVinitits.  l-'inm  llii',  |miiiiI  ul 
vifW,  tlu-n,  It  \\i>ultl  sitin  that  tlir  lt>|i«'ka  s|iii  iimii  in  inun- 
lu-arlv  alli«'<l  to  Iitiih.  and  tin*  same  wniild  Imlil  (riu-  ul  Myrlu.s- 
vliin.  il  \vr  an-  tn  haso  an  i>|iinii>n  ii|Min  tlir  i'.\«illrnl  li,niin->  u\ 
Mr.  Si'waitl. 

Sin-i  iiKin  \i  SI  iiiKi'MiiVMA, — Tlu'  ilistrilKilioii  <>t  tin-  sclri- 
i'lu-hyma  lan  liaidly  l>o  taki-ii  as  an  arj,Minu-nt  uiu-  way  m  tin- 
..till  r.  siiui-  lii  luilli  liTiis  and  cyfails  tln-ir  is  siuli  widf  variation. 
I  .should  cons'clcr  this  a  sprcilii  latluT  than  a  i-fniiu'  i  liar  ictrr. 
In  all  of  tiu'  njycloxylons  so  lar  studiid.  tlu'  m  lirfiu  hyiii.i  is 
dislributi'd  in  st-paratc  strands.  In  the  i)iads  studinl  l>\  inc 
this  tissue  forms  a  continuous  i)and  in  all  lasi-s  wht-rr  slrnn^ly 
di'\clo|n"d.  In  .\n>jio|itiTis  it  forms  a  rontiniions  /oiu'  of  ron- 
sidcrahli.'  lliickiu'ss,  with  si'|>aralc  stramls  lyin^^  aloii^f  tin.-  iiiiur 

face. 

A  rcsunu'  i>f  the  results  above-  dctailo<i  shows  that  in  tin- 
To|>i.'l<a  s|ii'cinicn  tluMV  arc  characters  which  directly  connect  it 
with  Kitiliioptcrii  Willi, nnsoni,  and  aUo  with  other  l-airopean  spe- 
cies of  Mvelo.\ylon,  and  tlu-  ividence  would  seem  to  indiiate 
that  few  of  these  can  be  separateil  ifeiierically.  yUlmittinu  the 
force  of  sonii-  of  the  objections  raised  by  Mr.  Sewaid  respecting' 
the  tilicoid  character  of  Myeloxylon,  there  are,  nevertheless, 
Strom,'  arguments  in  favor  of  this  \iew.  which  seem  to  me  to  jire- 
poiulerate  and  thus  to  justify  the  retention  of  the  name  Myelop- 
teris  as  a  name  expressive  of  this  possible  relationship;  while 
the  fact  that  these  plants  do  not  conform  closely  It)  any  modern 
tvpe  would  seem  to  raise  a  ipiestion  as  to  the  possible  correctness 
of  the  view  oriifinally  expressed  by  (ioeppert  that  these  plants 
in  realitv  represent  a  ^Generalized  type  occupyini;-  a  position 
between  the  cyads  and  the  ferns. 

llolASK  Al.    I.AIIORAIOKV, 

Ml  Gil  I.    1'MVl.R-iirV,    M'lMKKAI.. 


1 1 >sr  \H\ 

{ivcii  |il.iiit 
MH  |)niiit  iif 
11  i>  mure 
il    Myil.ix- 

I  rinuifjt  of 

I  till-  «.i;lfr- 
vv.iy  or  \]u' 
I-  variation. 
rhaiatt«T. 
luliyiii.i  is 
liid  l)\  MM- 
rr  sliniij^^ly 

ilJf    ol    11)11- 

f  tin.'  iiiiur 

that  in  the 
•  coiiru'ct  it 
■o|)t'an  s|)c- 
to  indiratc 
[iiittin,^:  the 

respecting 
jvcrthelfss, 

nio  to  |)rc- 
iie  Mvelo|)- 
sliip  ;  while 
my  inotleni 
correctness 
hese  plants 

a    |>usition 


•>"•■;  I 


l/l  /  /('/■//  A/s    .'0/7  A  /  \Sl% 
I   Ml    \S  \  I  InS   Ml     ri.A  II        n     Wh    III 


.M 


cf  yn    It 

(•'(»»,   ».     I  i,iii>^»l'>t     "U  Hull  'Imwilik.'  Uli    •»•  lilt  111  In  111,1     li.iiiil',  itit    liii.il.i 
iiiriitiii  liootif,  iiimI  Imm  ttiM  hIiii  liiiitilliti.    /  l^i 

III,     •      I  i,iii«vrt-«i'  •»<•' Mull  -iMm  III.'    Ill'    «i  iiit  II' liv  iii.i    -li.iiiil-,    Willi    l»»" 
l;(ii.'f  mm  il4iK<'  |'iii«MK»»      •    (X 

I  I    \  I  I      Ml 

III,,    (      ri,iii»vt|i(r  Ml  linn  "I    .1    HI  IciriM  li\  MM    -ll.ili'l    'tiumh"    <li  liiiN  <if 
tliih  til II'  III  II  tiiil'  iliiu'i'  iia-**:!!.'!'  I'll  il-"  iiilli  I  liii  I'.     ■    t-'i 

III,.     1        I  t.lll'^M'tHC     vcill.Ml     III       .1      V.f.ll|l,(»       llllll'llc       'll'lWItlL'       'UirtiN      •>! 

>i  I  III  iiiri'.     '    iHcj. 


r" 


k 


t» 


i 


mnix/t'ff  umrtA,  <  w// 


Htth  M 


MVI.I.OITKklS    Tol'KKKNSlS   IViili;illu\v. 


JfWW 


>"*  •  :¥'^."^*'.-*^^_"-^'";'*VV"'  i™*!*lU'5'l^£('r'*' 


/!(>/    l.\/l  .1/    (..I//   III-,     Will. 


I  I.I  1 1     III. 


MVKLOi'lKKlS    I'ori'.KKNSIS   I'enliallow. 


Ji 


fel 


I 


I 


I 


.) 


s  I 


t*  • 


!V 


i 


I5 


^IMlMi^-IF 


mk