Early music in Philadelphia with special reference to German music

-TT-

FROM THE LIBRARY OF

REV. LOUIS FITZGERALD BENSON, D. D.

BEQUEATHED BY HIM TO

THE LIBRARY OF

PRINCETON THEOLOGICAL SEMINARY

\ /»•

(Sermcm Ctmertccm Ctnnals

CONTINUATION OF THE QUARTERLY

AMERICANA GERMANICA

A BI-MONTHLY DEVOTED TO THE COMPARATIVE STUDY OF THE

Historical, Literary, Linguistic, Educational and Commercial Relations

OF

Germany and America

ORGAN OF

The German American Historical Society
The National German American Alliance
The Union of Old German Students in America

CONTENTS:
The Life of Francis Daniel Pastorius, the Founder of Germantown - 121
Sarly Music in Philadelphia, with Special Reference to German Music 157
The German American Historical Society and the German American

Annals 180

New Series, Vol. 6, No. 3. Old Series, Vol. io, No. 3.

May and June, 1908.

Subscription Price, $3.00.

Single Copies, 50 Cents.

Copyright, 1908.

(Entered March 2, 1903, at Philadelphia, Pa., as Second Class matter, under Act of

Congress, of March 3, 1879)

PUBLISHED BY

THE GERMAN AMERICAN HISTORICAL SOCIETY •
Chas. H. Breitbarth, Business Manager,
5821 Chester Avenue,

pbtlaDelpbta.

Berlin : View L'orfc : XeiP3ig :

MAYER & MOLLER CARL A. STERN F. A. BROCKHAUS

XonJton : Paris:

KEGAN, PAUL TRENCH, TRUBNER & CO., Ltd. H. LeSOUDIER

ANNOUNCEMENT.

The Bi-Monthly, German American Annals, is a continuation of the
Quarterly, Americana Germanica, and will make accessible to a wider public
current matter bearing upon the Relations of Germany and America. Each
number will contain a series of original contributions, reviews, book notices and
lists of new publications, relating to the history of the Germans in America and
also to American studies in the general field of Germanics.

The original title Americana Germanica will be retained for the series of
larger monographs which do not fall within the limits of a periodical, and for
reprints. These monographs will be published at such times as they are presented,
and will be sold separately, the price varying according to the character of the
monograph.

In the Monthly regular attention will be given to reviews and book notices.
New publications will be promptly listed and so far as possible reviewed.
Contributions, books for review and exchanges are solicited, especially such as
come within the scope of the Monthly, and should be sent to the editor, M. D.
Learned, Sox jo, College Hall, University of Pennsylvania, Philadelphia, Pa.

Subscriptions and other business communications should be directed to the
business manager, Charles H. Breitbarth, 5821 Chester Avenue, Philadelphia, Pa.

The annual subscription price is three dollars ($3.00) in advance. Members of
the German American Historical Society are entitled to the periodical publications
issued by the Society. To members of other affiliated societies the Monthly will
be sent for two dollars ($2.00), provided not less than a hundred members of such
a society subscribe for the journal.

complete $15.00

SPECIAL TO LIBRARIES.
German American Annals.
As full sets are nearly exhausted, Vol. I-IV will not be sold separately. Back
sets can be had as follows :
Volume I,
Volume II,
Volume III,
Volume IV.

Volume V, Nos. 1-12 3.00

Volume VI, Nos. 1-12 3.00

Volume VII, Nos. 1-12 3.00

Volume VIII, Nos. 1-12 3.00

Volume IX, Double Nos. 1-6 3.00

Americana Germanica (Monographs Bound in Cloth).

1. Translations of German Poetry in American Magazines.

By E. Z. Davis, Ph. D . f 1.50

2. The Harmony Society. By J. A. Bole, Ph. D 1.50

3. Friedrich Schiller in America. By E. C. Parry, Ph. D. . 1.25

4. The Influence of Salomon Gessner Upon English Literature.

By Bertha Reed 1.25

5. The German Settlement Society of Philadelphia and its Colony,

Hermann, Missouri. By Wm. G. Bek 1.50

6. IValdeck's Diary of the American Revolution. With Photographic

Reproduction of List of Officers. By M. D. Learned. 1.50

Printed by the International Printing Co.,
Philadelphia, Pa.

EARLY MUSIC IN PHILADELPHIA WITH SPECIAL
FERENCE TO GERMAN MUSIC.

Introduction.

The ( migration of Germans to Philadelphia increased

to suclTan extent, that before the middle of the eighteenth century

the English colonists became alarmed for fear that Pennsylvania

be alienated from the English crown, and be dominated by

srman immigrants. Indeed, throughout the eighteenth cen-

| greater part of the German immigrants landed at Phila-

and from there were distributed into other States. We

aturally expect with so great a population of Germans

lelp'nia and the surrounding country, that these people

continually extend their influence, and constantly spread

their ideas of art, religion, music and literature.

: us consider for a moment the condition of the Germans

md in this country. In 1683, moved by William Perm's

1 10 clamations of the glorious new world, as well as by

'he it freedom of conscience was granted in Pennsyl-

II, a band of German immigrants arrived in Philadel-

f( xinded Germantown. With the exception of the

fifiarjeis Daniel Pastorious, there were no highly cultured

femven among them. These people were of the middle

l Wt ?re more interested in weaving and agriculture and

Iv ation, than in the cultivation of the fine arts. The

• in ; Germany were not conducive to culture.

ioui ptry was just recovering from the Thirty Years'
V jpi ie strength of the people was being expended in

h the homes, and improving the land made desolate

durii !i 'erce struggle. At this time, too, the German people

dS7)

i5«

Early Music in Philadelphia with

had little liberty, but rather were under the thumb ->f absolutism,
which was at that time the great force in Europear countries. It
was not an epoch favorable to the cultivation of the fine arts.
There was no great literature, no great art, no great music. There
was, however, a strong religious spirit, which is often the result
of hardship and suffering. It is in the field of religion, too, that
we find the best music during the seventeenth century, although
it was not original in style, but simply a continuation of Luther's
music.1 The hymn writers of that time, both Catholic and Protes-
tant, are not to be despised, and we need mention but a few
whose songs have lived even to the present day : as Paul Fleming
(1609- 1 640) and Paul Gerhardt (1606- 1676) Protestant; Fried-
rich Spe% (1591-1635) and Johann Scheffer (1624-] 677), Catho-
lics. It can be said, then, with some degree of surety, that the
performance of music by the early German settlers in Philadel-
phia was confined, in the province of music, to hymns.

In this department the Germans hold an important position;
not only was their church music an essential part of their serv-
ices, but the number of hymn-writers and the mar'ry editions of
German hymn books published in Philadelphia testi fy to the love
which these new settlers had for church music.

It is only necessary to mention a few of these < hymn-writers
to recall to mind the extreme productiveness of this style of litera-
ture and music. Among the most important hynr n-writers were
F. D. Pastorius, of Germantown ; Johann Kelpuis, of the Wissa-
hickon; Conrad Beissel, of Ephrata, and Count vcbn Zinzendorf,
the Moravian.2

'Louis Elson, National Music in America, p. 18.

2Cf. for further information on this subject: J. H. T Jubbs, Early German
Hymnology of Pennsylvania; Hausmann, German Amer'u :an Hymytology 16S3-
1800, in Americana Germanica 1898, Vol. II, No. 3, p. 1 1.

Special Reference to German Music 159

CHAPTER I.
Church Music and the Manner of its Performance.

It has already been mentioned that there were many
German hymn-writers in Philadelphia in the early eighteenth
century, and it is now in place to consider what was the quality of
the music in the German churches at that period, and whether
musical instruments of any kind were used in the Philadelphia
churches.

For the first record it is necessary to go a little beyond Phila-
delphia to the Hermits of the Wissahickon. To this people un-
doubtedly belongs the honor of first using instrumental music
in religious services. Of their voyage across the Atlantic, Kelpuis
says:

"We had also prayer meetings and sang hymns of praise and
joy, several of us accompanying on instruments that we had brought
from London." 3

Evidently the instruments which they brought with them
were not satisfactory or were regarded as inadequate for the
worship of God, as Kelpuis in a letter to friends in London asked
that two clarichords with additional strings might be sent.4

Again the Hermits at the consecration of the new Swedish
church — Gloria Dei — July 2, 1700, act as choristers and furnish
instrumental music.5

The first German minister ordained in this country was
Justus Falckner, who was consecrated by the Swedish Lutherans.
In a letter to Rev. Heinrich Muhlen, of Holstein (1701), Falck-
ner shows that, even at that early day, music was considered an
important adjunct of the church service. He says:

' Sachse, German Pietists, p. 22 ; Seidensticker, Geschichtsblactter, p. 100.

4 Seidensticker, Geschichtsblactter, p. 100.

5 Sachse, German Pietists, p. 144 (hereafter quoted as G. P.).

160 Early Music in Philadelphia with

"In short there are Germans here, and perhaps the majority, who
despise God's Word and all outward good order ; who blaspheme the
sacraments and frightfully and publicly give scandal

"I will here take occasion to mention that many others besides
myself, who know the ways of the land, maintain that music would
contribute much towards a good Christian service. It would not
only attract and civilize the wild Indians, but it would do much good
in spreading the Gospel truths among the sects and others by attract-
ing them. Instrumental music is especially serviceable here. Thus
a well-sounding organ would perhaps prove of great profit, to say
nothing of the fact that the Indians would come running from far
and near to listen to such unknown melody, and upon that account
might become willing to accept our language and teaching, and re-
main with people who had such agreeable things ; for they are said
to come ever so far to listen to one who plays even a reed-pipe (rohr-
pfeiffe) : such an extraordinary love have they for any , melodious
and ringing sound. Now as the melancholy, saturine stingy
Quaker spirit has abolished (relegiert) all such music, it would
indeed be a novelty here, and tend to attract many of the young
people away from the Quakers and sects to attend services where
such music was found, even against the wishes of their parents. This
would afford a good opportunity to show them the truth and their
error.

"If such an organ-instrument (Orgel-werck) were placed in the
Swedish church .... it would prove of great service to this
church.

"If there were music in the church, the young people would
consider church-going a recreation.

"The Lord of Hosts .... would be praised and honored
with cymbal and organ.

"And it may be assumed that even a small organ-instrument
and music in this place would be acceptable to God, and prove far
more useful than many hundreds in Europe, where there is already
a superfluity of such things.

"There are in Europe masters enough who would build such
instruments, and a fine one can be secured for 300 or 400 thalers.
Then if an experienced organist and musician could be found, and
a curious one, who would undertake so far a journey, he would be
very welcome here. In case this could not be, if we only had an
organ, some one or other might be found who had knowledge there-
of." 6

'Cf. The Missive of Justus Falckner of Germantown, Concerning the
Religious Condition of Pa. in the Year 1701. Translated by J. F. Sachse.
Found also in Pa. Mag. of Hist., 1897.

Special Reference to German Music 161

The writer of this missive was somewhat of a poet himself,
and composed several fine hymns, some of which are in use at
the present day.7

Whether the appeal for musical instruments was of avail,
we know not, but in the Journal of Rev. Andreas Sandel for
July 20, 1702, is mentioned one Jonas, organist of Gloria Dei
church. Again, on November 24, 1703, when Falckner was
ordained in this church, Sachse says :

"The service was opened with a voluntary on the little organ in
the gallery by Jonas the organist, supplemented with instrumental
music by the Mystics on the viol, hautboy, trumpets (Posannen) and
kettledrums (Pauken)" 8

The first church organ in Philadelphia, then, was placed in
a Swedish Lutheran church largely by means of a German. Al-
though the merit for this achievement must be divided between
the Germans and Swedes, in one department of music — the sing-
ing of hymns — the Swedes probably were pre-eminent. In 1696
Charles, King of Sweden, sent to the church at Wicacoa, one
hundred hymn books,9 while in 1712 another lot, consisting of
"360 hymn books of three sorts" were shipped.10 The Swedes
were strict, too, in their regulations of the church services, espe-
cially of singing. In 1702, Rev. Andreas Sandel imposes a fine
"for untimely singing, six schillings." n Especially interesting
is the account concerning the attempt of Pastor Andreas Hes-
selius, of Christina, Delaware, to reform church singing in 1713.
Acrelius says :

' Sasche, Justus Falckner, pp. 20-21.

8 Justus Falckner, p. 64 ; also G. P., pp. 354-5. Sachse believes this organ
was one brought over by Kelpius.

' Israel Acrelius, A History of New Sweden, trans, by Wm. Reynolds,
in Memoirs of Pa. Hist. Soc, Vol. XI, pp.- 197, 366 (hereafter quoted as
Acrelius).

"Acrelius, p. 367; also Andreas Sandel's Diary, in Pa. Mag. Hist. 1906,
p. 446.

11 Acrelius, p. 217.

1 62 Early Music in Philadelphia with

"He had special regard to propriety in church-singing, in which
there was often such discord, as though they intended to call their
cows to the church. In opposition to which it was represented that
as all those who possessed the gift of praising God with a pleasing
voice in psalms and hymns should not stand mute, so, on the other
hand, those who were unfitted for this should not with their harsh
voices, hinder others and make confusion, but, by softly singing after
the others, train themselves to correct singing. During the singing,
he went around the church and aided where they failed." 12

It is very probable that in Philadelphia, this same instruc-
tion in church singing prevailed, since Hesselius was for some
time Provost, and had a right to command, and also, because
Samuel Hesselius, his brother, occupied the pulpit at Wicacoa
and could more easily be coerced — if necessary — to establish this
method of instruction.

In the other churches of Philadelphia, organs seem to have
been introduced at a relatively late date. On September 2, 1728,
a committee having been appointed at Christ Church "to treat
with Mr. Lod. C. Sprogel,13 about an organ lately arrived here,
report that they had done the same, and that he insisted on £200
for said organ ; and that they had procured men of the best skill
this place could afford to erect the said organ in a convenient
house in town, to make trial thereof ; which, being done, it is said
the organ proves good in its kind, and large enough for our
church." 14 Upon this recommendation the organ was purchased.
In the Moravian church, corner of Race and Broad streets, there
were two organs in 1743,15 one of which was sold in 1796, and
a new one built by David Tannenberger.16 In this same year

"Acrelius, p. 276.

" Ludovic Christian Sproegel was one of the "Hermits of the Wissa-
hickon."

"Quoted from the Minutes of the Vestry of Christ Church, by Benj.
Borr, History of Christ Church, p. 61.

15 Madeira, Annals of Music in Philadelphia, p. 24.

" Madeira, Annals of Music in Philadelphia, p. 24 (hereafter quoted as
Madeira).

Special Reference to German Music 163

( 1 743 ) the Moravians in Germantown had an organ costing £60,
but in 1744 both church and organ reverted to the German Re-
formed Church.17 The Catholic church had an organ in 1750.18
These are the earliest known organs in use in Philadelphia
churches. From this time on, the other churches in the city
gradually established them as an aid to their services.

One writer, who came to this country from Germany, evi-
dently had no knowledge of these organs when he said :

"I came to this country with the first organ [1750] which now
stands in a High German Lutheran church in the city of Philadel-
phia, and which was built in Heilbronn." 19

In the face of the evidence already produced, it is needless
to say that this statement is a little off color, to say the least.

There were then in Philadelphia several organs before 1755,
and it is reasonable to assume that in the Moravian church, that
"wind" and "string" instruments were used, since we find this
true at the colony in Bethlehem.20 The testimony of travellers
of that time or of members of other churches is of some interest
and importance. The first witness is William Black, secretary
of the commission appointed by the Governor of Virginia to
unite with commissions from Maryland and Pennsylvania for
the purpose of treating with the Indians. In the year 1744, he
resided in Philadelphia, during which time he kept a journal
of interest and importance. June 8 he writes :

" Minutes and Letters of the Coetus of the German Reformed Church,
p. 29.

18 Madeira, p. 24.

"Gottlieb Mittelberger's Journey to Penn. in the Year 1750; translated
by Carl T. Eben, p. 114.

"Wm. Reichel, Something about Trombones, p. 4 ff. See also the state-
ment concerning Justus Falckner's ordination as quoted above, where musical
instruments of this character were used.

164 Early Music in Philadelphia with

"We went to the Moravian Meeting, where I had the pleasure
to hear an Excellent Comment on that Passage in Scripture Relating
to the Prodigal Son, and after some very Agreeable Church Mustek,
half an hour after 9 they broke up." 21

This testimony is not without its value, as this gentleman
was evidently somewhat of a musician himself, since under the
same date in his diary we find :

"I Rose from my Bed and pass'd two hours in writting, the
rest of the time till Breakfast, I spent with my Fiddle and Flute." 22

Concerning the music in the Moravian church we have other
evidence, at a later date. John Adams remarks in his diary for
October 23, 1774:

"The singing here [Methodist meeting] is very sweet and soft
indeed ; the first music I have heard in any society except the
Moravians, and once at church with the organ." 23

He also remarks September 4, 1774, upon "the organ and
a new choir of singers at Christ Church, which were very musi-
cal." 24

Franklin, in 1755, speaks of hearing Moravian music at
Bethlehem, and praises it generously.25 A year earlier Acrelius,
who visited the same place, gives a more detailed account in the
following words :

"It was finally agreed that we should sit below [in the audi-
torium of the church], as the music sounded better there. The
organ had the accompaniment of violins and flutes. The musicians
were back in the gallery, so that none of them were seen." One of
the ministers "read some verses of a German hymn book, after which
they were sung with excellent music." 28

21 Perm. Mag. of History, Vol. II, p. 43.

^Penn. Mag. of Hist. Vol. II, p. 40.

m John Adams Works, Vol. II, pp. 401 and 364.

"John Adams Works, Vol. II, pp. 401 and 364.

"'Franklin, Autobriography, p. 325 [Lippincott, Phila., 1868].

26 Acrelius, p. 413.

Special Reference to German Music 165

Their style of music and manner of performing it must
have been exceptionally good, as compared with the music of
other churches, to have impressel so favorably such men, who,
we may be sure, were quite different. There is the sturdy pastor
Acrelius, understanding church music and the manner of its
performance ; the cordial, genial Ben Franklin, who knew some-
thing about music from living in London ; the somewhat cold
but highly cultured, John Adams, with his Puritan traditions ;
then the gentleman from Virginia, William Black, who most
probably partook of the nature of the warm, sunny-tempered
Southerners, himself somewhat of a musician. Could we ask
for witnesses more unlike?

To the Moravian church undoubtedly belongs the palm for
music during the eighteenth century ; but there was music, and
good music, in some other churches as well. We have already
mentioned the music in Christ Church and the Methodist
Church. Concerning the music in the German Lutheran Church,
we have the testimony of Daniel Fisher, who writes in his Diary
for May 25, 1755:

"Went to the Lutheran Church, a neat Brick Building where
there is a good organ27 to which I heard them sing Psalms, agree
ably enough." 2S

Again he says :

"The Lutheran Church has an organ, and a good one." 29

There were organs then in the churches, to a great extent,
before 1750. The question now arises were there men who
could repair these instruments if they got out of order? By the
end of the fourth decade, there were several men who could
not only repair an organ, but also build one. Of these men Gus-
tavus Hesselius is the most important, as he was the first spinet

21 The organ Mittelberger brought from Heilbronn ; see above.
Tenn. Mag. of Hist, Vol. XVII, p. 267.
" Penn. Mag. of Hist., Vol. XVII, p. 272.

1 66 Early Music in Philadelphia with

builder in America, having produced specimens as early as 1743,30
and probably the first organ builder in Pennsylvania. It is claimed
that he was the first organ builder in America, and in support of
that claim an organ is mentioned as built by him for the Moravian
Church at Bethlehem, Pa., in 1746.31 The fact is lost sight of
that a Boston man, Edward Bromfield, generally regarded as
the first organ builder, constructed an instrument in 1745,32
although Hesselius was undoubtedly the first man who built
many church organs.

Still another claimant appears for this title — no less a man
than £he Englishman, Doctor Christopher Witt (1675- 1765).
another hermit of the Wissahickon. Doctor Witt possessed a
large pipe-organ presumably made by him alone, but possibly
aided by other Hermits. It was built at least while he was living
with the Settlement on the Wissahickon, and as he left that society
shortly after the death of Kelpuis,33 which took place about
1708,34 the evidence is in his favor. This organ at his death was
valued at £40.33

Hesselius was not only a musician, but a painter as well. He
died in 1755. 36 Connected with Hesselius in 1746 was John G.
Klemm, a native of Dresden, Germany. Three years later David
Tannenberger arrived in Philadelphia, a man whom many of his
contempararies conceded to be the greatest organ builder in
America, but, as is usually the case, there is another claimant for
this high honor, as will be seen later.

David Tanneberger was born March 21, 1728, in Berthesdorf,
Saxony. He was evidently an all-round musician, and could
play, sing — he possessed a good voice — build, or repair an organ

>Penn. Mag. of Hist, XVI, p. 473 (note).

lPenn. Mag. of Hist., Vol. XXIX, p. 131 ff; also Reichel, p. 4.

! L. Elson, History of American Music, p. 43.

1 German Pietists, pp. 403. 412.

* German Pietists, p. 192.

5 German Pietists, p. 418 (note).

"Penn. Mag. of Hist., Vol. XII, p. 503 (note).

Special Reference to German Music 167

as occasion presented itself. It is known that he built at least
fourteen organs during his stay in Pennsylvania, while no record
of the number of spinets, which he made and sold for £22. 10s,
has been discovered. He died May 19, 1804, stricken by paraly-
sis while tuning an organ at York, Pa.37

As to Tannenberger's reputation as an organ builder, we
have the testimony of a man who probably knew Tannenberger :

"Tannenberg belongs to history as the organ builder of his day
and one of renown. He too, was of the German school. Fancy
stops were not generally in vogue, except the trumpet in the great
organ, and the vox humana in the swell, of which latter there was
but one in the city, and that was in Christ Church, and to my young
ear, a good imitation of the human voice.

"There are several of Tannenberg's organs yet in breathing
existence [1857]. Lancaster, Litiz, and Nazareth still hold his
memory in audible and respectful tones ; and much of his work is
worthy of imitation. His diapsons were particularly dignified,
whilst his upper work, 12th, 15th, and sesquialtera, gave brilliancy to
the whole." 38

This testimony of Abraham Ritter, an organist of good
standing in the Moravian Church, gives some idea of the excel-
lence of the work and of the reputation which Tannenberger still
had in the nineteenth centruy.

We have already spoken of Gottlieb Mittelberger and his
organ, and, although we cannot depend upon his statements, there
may be some truth in his somewhat exaggerated account of the
dedication of his organ. It is at least interesting, and shows that
the people as a whole were certainly not prejudiced against
music. He says :

"After this work had been set up and tuned it was conse-
crated with great rejoicing and delivered to the Christian St.
Michael's Church for the praise and service of God.

"The crowd of hearers was indescribably large ; many people

37 Penn. Mag. of Hist., Vol. XXII, p. 231 ff.

38 Abraham Ritter, Hist, of the Moravian Church in Phila. (1857), p. 59 ff-
note.

168 Early Music in Philadelphia with

came from a great distance, 10, 20, 30, 40 and even 50 hours' journey,
to see and hear this organ. The number of hearers, who stood
inside and outside the church, both German and English, were
estimated at several thousands. I was appointed school-master and
organist. As I became more and more known in Pennsylvania, and
the people learned that I had brought fine and good instruments
with me, many English and German families came 10, 20 and 30
hours' journey to hear them and the organ, and they were greatly
surprised because they had never in all their lives seen or heard an
organ or any of those instruments.39

"At the present time [1754] there are 6 organs in Pennsylvania
— the first is in Philadelphia, the 2nd in Germantown, the 3rd in
Providence, the 4th in New Hanover, the 5th in Dulpehocken, all
of them came to this country during the four years of my sojourn
there." *°

This statement concerning the number of organs in Phila-
delphia cannot be true, as we have shown above that there were
several. In his list of the organs in Pennsylvania, he neglects
to mention the one made for the Moravian Church at Bethlehem
in 1746.41 The number of people which he claims was present
at the dedication is probably exaggerated, and, as Mittelberger
was the chief performer, we can pardon him this slip of the
pen. It is probable, however, that there was a large number of
people present, as there would be at any new event entering into
their narrow lives — especially as there was no charge for admis-
sion.

In 1762 a new organ was built in Philadelphia by Philip
Feyring for St. Paul's Church. He is the other claimant to the
honor of being the greatest organ builder of his day.42 One of
the newspapers was evidently partial to him, since it gives this
notice :

M This statement is utterly false, as it will be shown later that there
were musical instruments in Philadelphia long before this time, and even
concerts in 1740.

w Mittelberger's Journey to Penn., p. 114.

41 Cf. above, p. .

u Cf. above, p. .

Special Reference to German Music 169

"The New Organ, which is putting up in St. Paul's Church in
this City, will be in such Forwardness as to be used in Divine Service
on Christmas Day. It is of a new Construction, and made by Mr.
Philip Fyring,43 Musical Instrument-Maker, in this City, who may,
with Justice, be said to be the best Hand at that ingenious Business
on the Continent." 44

The organ was evidently in use on Christmas Day and must
have proven satisfactory, as it called forth a poem lauding both
Feyring and his organ.

We have this biographical reference to him in a contem-
porary newspaper :

"Mr. Feyring is a German by Birth, but has for some years
past, practic'd the making of Musical Instruments (particularly
Spinets and Harpsichords) in this City, with great Repute." 45

How many instruments were sold by these organmakers it
would be difficult to say, although undoubtedly parlor organs were
found in many houses. There are advertisements of two organs
for sale among a list of household goods before the end of 1750:
A "small" organ belonging to Benj. Morgan, 1748,46 and a
"large" one, the property of the late Peter Kook, in 175c.47

Religious music in this half century was flourishing, and
was considered a valuable adjunct of the church service, not only
in German churches, but also in the Swedish and English
churches. The composition of hymns up to this time seems to
have been confined to the Germans.

Spelled also Feyring.
Pa. Gazette, Dec. 23, 1762.
Pa. Gas., Dec. 30, 1762.
Pa. Journal, July 7, 1748.
Pa. Journal, Jan. 2, 1750.

170 Early Music in Philadelphia with

CHAPTER II.

Secular Music.

From the preceding chapter it has been clearly seen, that
the Germans in Philadelphia, and indeed in the whole State, were
strongly religious, and were celebrated for their church music
and instrument makers, especially for their organ builders.

Were all the people in Philadelphia as religious as the Ger-
mans and Quakers seem to have been, and were there no public
amusements? This is an important question, and one not easily
answered, especially during the first half of the eighteenth cen-
tury. It may be thought that this question is not related to Ger-
man music, but indirectly it is, so that it may be shown whether
or not the people of Philadelphia were ready to welcome music,
whether they were in a state of mind favorable for the introduc-
tion of any amusements. It is necessary to establish these
facts before we can clearly understand the reasons and cause
for the introduction of German concert music into America.

We know, that in Philadelphia during the eighteenth cen-
tury, there were men of every creed and religion, of every walk
of life, of many different nationalities, and we may be sure that
in such a conglomeration of men and ideas there would be some
to whom amusements would be necessary — even amusements
which strait-laced people would condemn. The information there
is upon this subject supports the opinion, that there were amuse-
ments even in the early part of the eighteenth century. Foremost
among the pleasures in which the inhabitants of Philadelphia
indulged, was dancing, and we have reference to this art at an
early period. In a book written in 17 10 is the following state-
ment :

"Among the rest of my Friends, I must not forget the facetious

Special Reference to German Music iji

Mr. Staples, Dancing-Master, who was the first Stranger of Phila-
delphia that did me the Honour of a Visit." *8

As early as 1 716 we find this record :

"At the Yearly Meeting of the Friends, members were ad-
vised against 'going to or being in any way concerned in plays,
games, lotteries, music and dancing.' " *9

Throughout the first half of the eighteenth century dancing
was evidently held in due respect by a certain element of the popu-
lation. In 1728 it forms a part of the curriculum of a boarding
school.50 In 1730 dancing is taught by Thomas Ball's sister.51
The first really fashionable ball was probably that given by Gov-
ernor Gordon, in 1726, in honor of the Prince of Wales' birth-
day.52 To some extent, too, music and dancing were surely a
part of the marriage festivities, as the following item shows :

"We hear that Tuesday night last, a young Dutchman was
married to an old Dutchwoman, who was known to have money.
They had a fiddle at the Wedding. . . . She danc'd till it
was late." 53

We find ministers of different denominations complaining of
the irreligion of some of the inhabitants. As one writer remarks :

"We live in an age, when 'tis counted almost a scandal to be
a Christian. Religion is stil'd Preciseness and Hyprocrisy, and a
strict Conformity to Truth and Virtue is imputed to be the Effect
of Melancholly, a Distemper'd Imagination. We daily hear the

"Hart, American History told by Contemporaries II, p. 77, quoted from
"The Voyage, Shiprack and Miraculous Escape of Richard Castleman, Gent.,"
appended to "The Voyages and Adventures of Capt. Robert Boyle," London,
1726, 4th Ed. 1786, p. 331.

" Scharf & Wescott, History of Phila., Vol. II, p. 863.

60 American Weekly Mercury, March 5-14, 172%.

"Pa. Gazette, March 5-13, 1729-30.

" Scharf & Wescott, Hist, of Phila., Vol. I, p. 203.

"Pa. Gaz., March 15 to 22, 1738-9.

172 Early Music in Philadelphia with

greatest Mysteries of our Faith Ridicul'd and Banter'd, the Clergy
Despis'd, Expos'd and Degraded ; and that even by Men, who have
not yet Publickly Renounc'd Christianity; but such as would be
thought to have clearer Heads, and more refin'd Conceptions of
Things than their Brethren, those Men to their Shame stand Pelting
Religion at a distance, with little Scoffs and Jests, when there is
a more Fair and Honourable way of deciding the Matter, by rational
and indeniable Arguments." 54

In opposition to this we have the testimony of Benjamin
Franklin, who writes :

"Giir people, having no publick amusements to divert their
attention from study, became better acquainted with books." 55

So, too, a correspondent in the Weekly Mercury writes :

"Here are no Masquerades, Plays, Balls, Midnight Revellings,
or Assemblies to Debauch the Mind or promote Intrigue." 56

When, however, we read an advertisement in the same paper
about a month later like the following, we may be permitted to
doubt somewhat the statements of the last two men.

"The Art of Dancing Carefully Taught (as it is now Practic'd
at Court) by Samuel Perpoint, at his School. . . . where
for the Recreation of all Gentlemen and Ladies : There will be
Country Dances every Thursday Evening; likewise he teaches small
Sword." 57

From this time on, we notice the advertisements of various
dancing masters, who, often were school masters at the same time.
Not only did these Philadelphians enjoy dancing, but they were
partial to late suppers and card playing as well, — playing cards
was a staple article of importation after 1736.58 Another favor-

M American Weekly Mercury, June 19-26, 1729 [a correspondent].

05 Autobiography, p. 207.

M American Weekly Mercury, June 19-26, 1729.

"American Weekly Mercury, July 31 to August 7, 1729.

"American Weekly Mercury, February 8, 1736 [first advertised].

Special Reference to German Music 173

ite amusement, we may be sure, was playing on the Jew's harp,
for after 1733, this instrument frequently is advertised.59 The
Jew's harp must have been considered a harmless instrument by
all sects, for as early as 1675 in one State of Puritan New Eng-
land it is stated that a law was enacted, "that no one should play
on any kind of music except the drum, the trumpet and the jew-
sharp."60

Besides the amusements already mentioned, the Philadel-
phians had an opportunity to see a rope-dancer in 1724,61 "Punch
and Joan his Wife," 62 "Magick Lanthorn" exhibition,63 "Camera
Obscura and Microscope," 64 a musical clock with a man and
woman appearing as mountebanks.65

Music was evidently popular at society meetings, banquets,
etc. Perhaps there was nothing more than singing, but possibly
a violin and spinet helped to while away the time. For instance,
in 1 73 1 at the celebration of "St. David's Day," by the "Society
of Ancient Britons," the evening ended with "Musick, Mirth and
Friendship." 66

In the two items which will be given now, may be detected,
perhaps, the incipient germs of musical criticism, or at least the
idea, which most people probably had of what a professor of
music should know and be able to do :

"Elocution is not unlike Musick ; there is scarce a Soul so rustick
as not to admire both in their Excellency, altho' the Masters of
those Sciences may lose their proper Share of the Praise. He that

''"American Weekly Mercury, March 2, 1733 [first advertised].

60 Perkins & Dwight, History of Hacndel & Haydn Society, p. 17 (note).

61 Scharf & Wescott, Vol. II, p. 863.
"Pa. Gas., Dec. 30, 1742.

63 Pa. Gas., Jan. 27, 1743.

"Pa. Gas., July 2, 1744.

60 Pa. Gas., May 31, 1744.

m Pa. Gas., Feb. 23 to March 4, 1730-31.

"American Weekly Mercury., Aug. 7-14, 1729.

174 Early Music in Philadelphia with

having laid before him the several Parts of a Musical Instrument,
can Unite them in their Places, and tune them to Harmony, merits
the appelation of a Master in Musick and should be distinguished as
such, as he that disposes Words into grammatical sentences, and
eloquent Periods, is a Master of Language." 67

This quotation may argue for the popularity and respect in
which music was held at that time by at least some of the people.
We find in this crude statement, that music was thought worthy
of a position by the side of elocution, which has always held a
high place in the minds of every people, and so we may be safe
in believing that music had a place, and an important place, in
Philadelphia, in the early history of that city.

Another correspondent states that:

"Women, like Instruments of Musick, require to be long used
before their Sweetness or Discord are certainly discovered." 68

Unless the writer of the above knew something about music,
and unless music was an object of interest or pleasure, so that
this comparison would be appreciated, he would not likely have
ventured to use such a simile.

In 1733 there is a record of a "ball" 60 while, in the next
year under the heading "London news," there is a notice con-
cerning the marriage of the Princess Royal to the Prince of
Orange, which gives the following information :

"A fine anthem compos'd by Mr. Handell was perform'd by a
great Number of Voices and Instruments." 70

This latter item proves nothing except that the name of
Handel was introduced into the colonies at an early date, and may
have remained in the memories of some of the people, since he
was connected with such an important event. This may possibly

! American Weekly Mercury, Sept. 10-17, 1730.
' American Weekly Mercury, Nov. II, 1733.
'American Weekly Mercury, May 23, 1734.

Special Reference to German Music 175

have helped to increase the popularity which his works, later in
the century, attained in America.

It has been seen that there was music and dancing at this
time, and it is now interesting to learn what kind of musical
instruments were used. It has been shown already, that there
were Jew's harps,71 that Kelpuis had clavichords,72 and assuredly
there were some virginals, although probably few. In the fourth
decade the various instrument makers mentioned above,73 prob-
ably had quite a number of customers.

In 1729 Andrew Bradford, proprietor of the American
Weekly Mercury, advertises :

"A well-strung Virginal to be sold; being in good Order. En-
quire of Printer hereof." 74

Dr. Christopher Witt, referred to before,75 was a capable
player on the virginal,70 which at his death was estimated at
£1, 15s. ; 77 while a virginal belonging to the "Hermits" reverted
to the widow of Magister Zimmerman.78

The people who owned instruments of this kind had an
opportunity to learn to play, since in 1730 a woman — the first
music teacher in Philadelphia — makes an announcement in the
newspaper as follows :

[Thomas Ball's] "Wife teaches Writing and French. Like-
wise Singing, Playing on the Spinet, Dancing and all sorts of
Needle- Work are taught by his Sister lately arrived from London." 79

"Vide above, p.

" Vide above, p.

" Vide above, p.

"American Weekly Mercury, March 4-13, 1728-9.

75 See above.

" German Pietists, p. 412.

"German Pietists, p. 418 (note).

"Justus Falckner, p. 64 (note).

"Pa. Gaz., July 2-9, 1730.

176 Early Music in Philadelphia with

What class of music she and her pupils played, it would be
hard to say, but it did not cause anyone to start a music store,
and it is not until 1739 that any great musical works are adver-
tised at the office of the man of many parts, Benjamin Franklin.
The following pieces were to be obtained there: "Corelli's
Sonatas, Geminiani's Concertos, Ditto's Solos."80

Besides spinets and virginals there were probably violins,
German flutes, trumpets, drums, a few viols, etc. For instance,
in 1749 Anthony Lamb, of New York, advertises among other
things: "German Flutes," 81 while other men advertise, in 1750,
"Hunting pipes," 82 and "fiddle strings," S3 From 1744 on num-
erous advertisements of drums appear.

Before 1740 there is no record of any kind of musical organi-
zation, but in this year there was such a society. During this
year the evangelist, Whitefield, visited Philadelphia and made
a strong impression upon people of all beliefs. One of his
disciples caused this to be printed :

"Since Mr. Whitefields' Preaching here, the Dancing school,
Assembly, and Concert Room have been shut up, as inconsistent
with the Doctrine of the Gospel : And though the Gentlemen con-
cern'd, caus'd the Door to be broke open again, we are inform'd that
no Company came the last Assembly night." 84

One of the members, however, denied the charge that dances
were inconsistent with the doctrine of the gospel, and affirmed
that the hall was closed up by William Seward, an "Attendant
and intimate Companion" of Whitefield's. This same writer
speaks of "Members of the Concert" and the rooms belonging to
them. He also says that the members "met the Night after
according to Custom ; and the Thursday following the Company

80 Pa. Gaz., June 15-22, 1738-9.

81 Pa. Gas., Jan. 31, 1749.

" Pa. Journal, Jan. 9, 1750.

"Pa. Jour, and also Pa. Gas., May 24, 1750.

81 Pa. Gazette, May 1, 1740.

Special Reference to German Music 177

met to Dance as they used to do ; but the Assembly being only for
the Winter Season is now discontinued of Course and the Concert
being for the whole Year still goes on as usual." 85

This is interesting, as it is the first record of concerts, and
also, because these concerts, continued the whole year, not merely
during the winter months as nowadays. There were "Members
of the Concert," too, who rented or owned rooms. There must
then have been some kind of a club or society, which gave these
performances.

These concerts must either have been kept up for years, or
new series instituted year by year, since our friend William
Black (already quoted) says in his diary of 1744, June 5:

"At 8 O'Clock went to hear a Concert of Musick ; the Per-
formers was some Town's Gentlemen, and did Us the Honour of an
Invitation, we staid till past 11, and I left the Company to go home
to my lodgings." 88

It is important to observe, that William Black says he had
the "Honour" to be invited to a concert. One might say that this
word was simply a common expression. It probably was, and still
is; but we believe a man would hardly write such an expression
in his diary, unless he really thought he was honored. It seems
probable that this concert and those of 1740 must have been very
exclusive and were not public entertainments, which anyone
might attend.

There was exhibited this same year (1744) a curiosity,
which would attract a large crowd of people. This was no less
than :

"The Unparallelled Musical Clock, made by that great Master
of Machinery, David Lockwood. It excels all others in the Beauty
of its Structure and plays the choicest Airs from the most cele-
brated Operas- with the greatest Nicety and Exactness. It per-
forms with beautiful graces, ingeniously and variously intermixed,

85 Pa. Gaz., May 8, 1740.

MPenn. Mag. of Hist., Vol. I, p. 416.

178 Early Music in Philadelphia with

the French Horn Pieces, perform'd upon the Organ, German and
Common Flute, Flageolet, etc., Sonata's, Concerto's, Marches, Minu-
etts, Jiggs and Scots Airs, composed by Corelli, Alberoni, Mr. Handel
and other great and eminent Masters of Musick." 87

This is the first public record we have, that works of such
famous composers were played, and they must have become
familiar, in a short time to a great number of the inhabitants.

It will be remembered that Miss Ball's capabilities in the
province of music were confined to but two branches, voice and
spinet. In 1749, however, appears a truly musical genius, if we
may judge by the number of instruments which he played. This
man was, as we learn from the following :

"John Beals, Musick Master from London [who] at his House
in Fourth Street, near Chestnut Street, joining to Mr. Linton's, collar
maker, teaches the Violin, Hautboy, German Flute, Common Flute
and Dulcimer by Note.

"Said Beals will likewise attend young ladies, or others, that
may desire it, at their houses. He likewise provides musick for balls
or other entertainments." 88

Here was an opportunity for the inhabitants of the Quaker
City to improve their time by learning music, and as the variety
of instruments from which they might choose, was large, no
doubt some of them became proficient musicians.

This same year saw the beginnings of drama and opera in
Philadelphia, given by the English actors, Murray and Kean.89
These dramatic performances were soon discontinued on account
of the opposition of the public. From now until the latter part
of the fifth decade of the eighteenth century there were desultory
attempts to give dramas, but not until 1759 did the theatre prove
successful and become permanent.

There was then in this decade an incipient appreciation of

87 Pa. Gaz., July 12, 1744.

"Pa. Gaz., March 21, 1749.

81 Madeira, Annals of Music, p. 29.

Special Reference to German Music 179

drama to which some music was oftentimes joined. What other
music was there at this time? In 1750-4 Mittelberger says :

"The cultivation of music is rather rare as yet. . . . Some
Englishmen give occasional concerts in private houses with a spinet
or harpsichord." 90

Mittleberger's statement concerning the cultivation of
music is not quite true. Music undoubtedly was studied a great
deal more than Mittelberger seems to think. If his statement
that occasional private concerts were given by Englishmen is
true, this was probably the kind of concert William Black at-
tended in 1749,91 and may have been similar to the concerts of
1740.92

During the first half of the eighteenth century Philadelphia
was not so utterly devoid of musical culture as some of our his-
torians of music would have us believe. The music was not
entirely church music, and although musical culture was not so
important a factor in the life of the people as at the present day,
still music was beginning to make itself felt among intelligent
people, and interest in it and appreciation of it were gradually
growing.

R. R. DRUMMOND,
University of Pennsylvania.

90 Mittelbergers Journey, p. 114 fif.

91 Cf . above, p.
M Cf . above, p.

THE GERMAN AMERICAN HISTORICAL SOCIETY
AND THE GERMAN AMERICAN ANNALS.

At the Whitsuntide Festival at Washington Park, Philadel-
phia, on June 8, 1908, Mr. Theodore Sutro, of New York, in his
most excellent address, divided mankind into three classes : Pessi-
mists, Conservatives and Optimists. He declared the Conserva-
tives fthe most tiresome class, as they always wish to leave
everything as it was and is ; the Pessimists are the worst class,
because they always find everything wrong; whatever is done, is
not enough — they only talk and criticise, but never do anything
themselves. They always say what ought to have been done and
what ought to be done ; they put up visionary ideals, but never
do anything to bring about those things desired. Much better
is the third class, the Optimists, who do things and act, and bring
forth things as the conditions demand and wait till they bring
about other things when new times and conditions demand. Mr.
Sutro spoke of these three classes in reference to the German
endeavors in America.

I can readily endorse Mr. Sutro's words in reference to the
German American Historical Society and the German American
Annals.

Of course, things could be better; this German American

Historical Society which tries in its Annals to bring before the

whole of the American world all those matters in which Germans

and German influence have worked upon the political and social

status of America, ought to have ten thousand members, instead,

of less than one thousand; and if the Pessimists wish to have

matters made better, let them become members of the German

American Historical Society — of which our great President,

Theodore Roosevelt, is an honorary member, who in a letter

addressed to the president of the German American Historical
(180)

FOREIGN CONTRIBUTORS.

Prof. Dr. Otto Bindewald, University of Giessen.

Prof. Dr. Karl Borinski, University of Munich.

Prof. Dr. Aloys Brandl, University of Berlin.

Prof. Dr. Otto Bremer, University of Halle.

Prof. Dr. Karl Breul, King's College, Cambridge, England.

Prof. Dr. Konrad Burdach, University of Berlin.

Prof. Dr. Creizenach, University of Krakau.

Prof. Dr. Ernst Elster, University of Marburg.

Dr. K. Endemann, Weilberg a. L.

Prof. Dr. Ludwig Geiger, University of Berlin.

Dr. Grayell, Brussels.

Prof. Dr. F. Holthausen, University of Kiel.

Prof. Dr. M. H. Jellinek, University of Vienna.

Prof. Dr. O. Jiriczek, University of Breslau.

Prof. Dr. Max Koch, University of Breslau.

Prof. Dr. K. Landmann, Darmstadt.

Prof. Dr. Paul Langhans, Gotha.

Prof. Dr. H. Lambel, University of Prague.

Prof. Dr. John Meier, University of Basel.

Prof. Dr. Rudolph Meissner, University of Gottingen.

Prof. Dr. Richard M. Meyer, University of Berlin.

Prof. Dr. J. Minor, University of Vienna.

Prof. Dr. E. Mogk, University of Leipzig.

Prof. Dr. Lorenz Morsbach, University of Gottingen.

Prof. Dr. F. Muncker, University of Munich.

Prof. Dr. Anton Schoenbach, University of Graz.

Prof. Dr. Bernhard Seuffert, University of Graz.

Prof. Dr. Alexander Tille, University of Glasgow.

Prof. Dr. H. Varnhagen, University of Erlangen.

Prof. Dr. Oskar Walzel, University of Bern.

Prof. Dr. G. Witkowski, University of Leipzig.

Prof. Dr. Wychgram, University of Leipzig.

(List may be extended.)

form von IDermacbtnissen.

I give and bequeath to the "German American Historical
Society", Central Office located at Philadelphia, Pa.,

(Here describe the amount, if money or premises, if real estate)

to aid in carrying out the designs of the Society.

THE NATIONAL GERMAN AMERICAN ALLIANCE.

President, DR. C. J. HEXAMER, Philadelphia, Pa.
ist Vice-Pres., Joseph Keller, Indianapolis, Ind.
2d Vice-Pres., Noah Guter, Newark, N. J.
Ireas., H. Weniger, Phila., Pa. Fin. Sec, John Yenny, East Pittsburg, Pa.
Sec, AdolphTimm, 522 W. Lehigh Ave., Phila., Pa.

National Executive Committee:

John Tjarks, Balto., Md., C. W. Bente, Wheeling, W. Va.;

Kurt Voelckner, Washington, D. C; F. Oskar Martin, Idaho;
H. I. Nienstedt, St. Paul, Minn. ; Gustav C. Martens, Cleveland, O. ;

C. C. Lienau, Newark, N. J.; Dr. Carl Bark, St. Louis, Mo.;

Dr. H. A. C. Anderson, N. Y. City; Albert Curlin, Oakland, Cal.;
H. C. Bloedel, Allegheny, Pa.; Carl Eberhard, Boston, Mass.

*' I

THE GERMAN AMERICAN HISTORICAL SOCIETY.

(Incorporated 1901)

Honorary President, J. G. Rosengarten, Philadelphia, Pa.
President, Dr. Albert Bernheim, Philadelphia, Pa.
Vice-Presidents: L. P. Hennighausen. Baltimore, Md. H. H. von Starkloff,

St. Louis, Mo. C. F. Huch, Philadelphia, Pa.
Editor: Marion D. Learned, Box 10, College Hall, University of Pennsyl-
vania, Philadelphia, Pa.
Treasurer: Hans Weniger, Philadelphia, Pa.
Business Manger \ Charles H. Breitbarth, 5821 Chester Avenue,
and Secretary: / Philadelphia, Pa.

Annual Dues, $5.00.

THE UNION OF OLD GERMAN STUDENTS IN AMERICA.

Headquarter!, ARION HALL, 59th St. and Park Ave., New York

President, Dr. Carl Beck, 37 E. 31st St, New York.
Vice-Presidents:
Dr. M. D. Learned, Dr. Henry G. Kraus,

Hon. Chas. F. McLean, Dr. Carl Barck,

Dr. W. Freudenthal.

Rec Secretary, Dr. J. Heckmann. Cor. Secretary, Dr. Carl Pfister.
Treasurer, Dr. Albert J. W. Kern, Jamaica, N. Y.

Dr. Em. Baruch,
Dr. Chas. F. Chandler,
TL Drobegg,
Dr. C. W. Eliot,

D. C. GlLMAN,

William R. Harper,
Friedrich Hirth,
Oswald Joerg,
Henry G. Krause,
L. Herzog.

Directors:

W. Hallock,

Dr. R. Johnstone Mooney,
Dr. H. Muensterberg,
W. Schauffler,
Dr. H. Schoenfeld,
H. Schueter,
Dr. J. G. Schurman,
Dr. L. L. Seaman,
Andrew H. Smith,
Andrew von Grimm,
H. A. Weber.

Annual Dues, $3.00.