NT
CD
9
O
UNIVERSITY OF CALIFORNIA.
GIF^T OK
Received
Accession No.
• '8(>?'
• Clots No.
N
This is one of an edition of one
thousand copies printed from type
on Van Gelder hand-made paper for
the Battle Monument Association
in the month of December, 1898.
fiistory
of
Che Battle JMonumcnt
at
Cdest point
Ristory
of
Cbe Battle JMonument
Slest point
together with a list of the names of those inscribed
upon and commemorated by it and of the
original subscribers thereto
prepared by
Charles CCL Lamed
professor, d. 8. JVIilitary Hcademy
Secretary of the Building Committee
^ n ^ ^ ^'
Co which is added a description of the quarrying, working
transportation and erection of the shaft, by
Gdward f% JMiner
Cdest point, New \ork
1898
CONTENTS
PAGE
i
History of the Battle Monument . . ,
Dedication of Site on Trophy Point . . . % 19
Prayers . . . . . . • . 23
Oration by General George B. McClellan . . 29
Dedication Ceremonies at West Point ; . . . 83
Prayers . . . . . . \ > . . . 87
Address of General Wilson . . * . .89
Address of General Schofield . . . . 495
Address of Secretary of War . . . .99
•
Address of Justice Brewer ;. . . . . 103
Epilogue . . . * . . .113
List of Officers and Men Borne upon the Monument . 117
Description of the Quarrying, Working, Transportation
and Erection of the Battle Monument . . . 221
Report of the Treasurer . . . . . 239
LIST OF ILLUSTRATIONS
i Monument. View from West . . Frontispiece
ii Monument. Front view . . . Facing page i
in Competitive Design of Babb, Cook &Willard " " 67
iv Competitive Design of Carrere & Hastings . " " 71
v Alternative Design of Carrere & Hastings . " " 73
vi Competitive Design of R. W. Emerson . " " 75
vn Grand Stand from the West . . . " " 83
vm Rostrum . . . . . . " " 89
ix Grand Stand from the South . . . " "103
x Fame. View from West . ' . . " "113
xi Fame. View from East . . . . " " 117
xii Cylindrical Base, bearing Names of Officers " " 119
xin Sphere and Plinth, bearing names of Enlisted
Men " " 131
xiv Shaft in the Quarry .- . . . " " 221
xv Preparing the Shaft for Working . Facing page 225
xvi Mounted on Journals for Cutting . . " " 227
xvn Mechanical Appliances for Polishing / . " " 228
xviii On the Cars for Transportation . . " " 231
xix From Station to Site . . . . " " 232
xx On the Way . . . . . " " 233
xxi Arrival at Site . ^ _,..., , ^ . . " t( 234
xxii Erection . . . . . . " " 237
or THK
UNIVERSITY }
THE BATTLE MONUMENT
AT WEST POINT
THE BATTLE MONUMENT
AT WEST POINT
CHE polished monolith of granite that faces
on the terre-plein of West Point the gate-
way of the Hudson Highlands, guarding
like a giant sentinel the memory of two thousand
heroes of the mighty struggle for principle which
freed a race and welded a nation, was dedicated
to its sacred function on a day of mingled cloud
mists and sunbursts — fit type of the dark years
of battle and of the glory of the victory which it
commemorates.
The band of men whose roll is to be read upon
its tablets, and high above whose names winged
Fame stands poised with trumpet and outstretched
wreath, are the battle victims of that little army
which stood at the beginning of the fight of 1861
for all the military art our country knew. Its
2 THE BATTLE MONUMENT
monument rests to-day within the borders of the
great Academy which for half a century had kept
alive the tradition of military integrity, discipline,
simplicity, and science which inspired these men,
and through them the mighty hosts of heroic vol-
unteers who offered their lives for principle and
country.
This is a monument to the regular army of the
United States, erected by brothers to brothers, not
in an invidious or vaunting spirit, but with a just
pride in the great work wrought by the soul that
went forth from this army into the leaderless
masses of noble men who left the walks of peace
for the hard field of fight. The regular army is
justified in this ppde,and rightly glories in this rock-
hewn witness to a work well and faithfully done,
not only in this War of the Rebellion, but by these
same men in exile, hardships and peril on remote
frontiers amidst savage foes — the advance-guard
of our civilization, the protectors of a land which
they did not possess, and the promoters of a great
industrial development whose fruit was not theirs.
This memorial was not built by a grateful coun-
try, but by voluntary offerings from the hard-won
pay of comrades in the field within hearing of
the roar of battle, and in sight of the dead whose
memory it preserves. Was ever shaft so reared
before, or with a sentiment more modest, tender,
and unselfish ?
AT WEST POINT 3
Those who have guarded the sacred trust con-
fided to them, and whose honor and pleasure it
has been to bring it to fruition, have labored to
express in the finished work the dignity of the
sentiment that gave it birth. The granite block,
hewn from the mountain — single, upright, shin-
ing like the deeds to which it bears witness ; the
polished sphere, rounded like their lives and belted
with enduring bronze ; the simple inscription :
IN MEMORY
OF THE
OFFICERS AND MEN
OF THE
REGULAR ARMY OF THE UNITED STATES
WHO FELL IN BATTLE DURING THE
WAR OF THE REBELLION
THIS MONUMENT IS ERECTED BY THEIR
SURVIVING COMRADES
— these are all conceived in reverence, and in-
tended to speak simply and directly the purpose
of the givers and the merits of the dead. It is but
right to add that the designer, Stanford White,
and the sculptor, Frederick MacMonnies, have
given a generous and enthusiastic labor to the
work far beyond the value of any money recom-
4 THE BATTLE MONUMENT
pense received, and in the true spirit of the artist
and patriotic citizen.
In response to a request from the Secretary of
the Building Committee of the Battle Monument
Association that he should narrate the circum-
stances which surrounded the initiative of the un-
dertaking, Col. Hasbrouck wrote as follows :
Fort Monroe, Va., Nov. 6, 1897.
My dear Lamed:
I returned to Fort Monroe last week from detached ser-
vice on a board which has kept me busily occupied for about
two months. I have been trying to recall the facts and inci-
dents connected with the Battle Monument, and the action
taken just after the conception of the project, which might
avail you for your article. I find that my memory is unreliable
about many things that have happened so long ago and I am
sorry and afraid that my letter will not be of much use to you.
The idea of the monument originated at West Point and the
successful efforts to arouse interest and to raise the necessary
funds were made by the officers permanently and temporarily
on duty at the Academy. I was ordered to West Point for
duty in September, 1863, while north on sick leave. At that
time all the officers temporarily on duty had seen service in the
field and many of them had been disabled by either wounds or
sickness. All knew and appreciated the services of the regulars ;
and the merits and deeds of officers and men who had fallen
were constantly recalled. These services were well known at
the front, but received little recognition in the press, which,
from local and State pride, made special effort to exploit the
AT WEST POINT 5
achievements of their own volunteers. We all thought the reg-
ulars were not receiving their just dues, and that their services
should be better known and permanently commemorated. Soon
after my arrival I suggested one night after dinner at the Mess
a Monument at West Point which should have inscribed upon it
a list of the battles and the names of all the officers and men of
the Regular Army who had been killed or died of wounds re-
ceived in action. The idea was well received and a notice for
a meeting the next Saturday, a day when most of the officers
could attend, was sent out. The meeting was attended by many
officers. Lieut, (afterwards Captain) Charles C. Parsons, 4th
Artillery, was especially interested and enthusiastic. He was a
very able and earnest man, and I think the success of the effort
in its initial stages was more due to him than to any other sin-
gle individual. It is my recollection that he was made chair-
man of this meeting. He thought it important to secure as
soon as possible the co-operation of all in the Regular Service,
and urged that letters be promptly written to officers in the
field and at other stations, asking for their views and aid. He
sent for the necessary stationery, and many letters were writ-
ten before the meeting broke up. A number of officers were
there, but I cannot recall with certainty any except Parsons
and Captain A. T. Smith, 8th Infantry, now Colonel of the
1 3th Infantry. In a short time so many favorable responses
were received that a regular organization was formed, a treas-
urer appointed, and subscriptions asked for.
Sincerely yours,
H. C. HASBROUCK.
The minutes of the Association formed under
the impulse of this suggestion of Lieutenant Has-
brouck give a clear account of the early stages of
IA
6 THE BATTLE MONUMENT
the undertaking which has recently culminated in
the dedication of a Monument bearing the names
of every officer and soldier in the Regular Army
of the United States who fell in battle or died of
wounds received in the War of the Rebellion.
The following extracts are selected as giving the
most important acts of the committees having it in
charge as well as the names of their individual
members :
West Point, N. Y., Oct. 6, 1863.
At a meeting of officers convened at West Point,
N. Y., Oct. 6, 1863, for the purpose hereafter
designated, First Lieutenant W. A. Elderkin, ist
Artillery, U. S. Army, was called to the chair, af-
ter which the following resolution was unani-
mously adopted :
For the purpose of perpetuating the memory of
those officers of the Regular Army who shall have
fallen in action or died from wounds received in
the field during the present war, it is
Resolved — That an organization be hereby ef-
fected, to consist of a President, a Treasurer, a
Secretary, and an Executive Committee of eleven,
including the above-named, who shall be em-
powered to solicit and receive subscriptions, as
shall hereafter be determined, for the erection of a
Monument at this post, upon which shall be in-
AT WEST POINT 7
scribed the names, etc., of those who are embraced
within the purpose of this resolution.
Whereupon the following officers were desig-
nated to constitute this organization :
President : Col. A. H. Bowman, U. S. Engineers,
and Superintendent
Treasurer: Prof. A. E. Church, Military Academy
Secretary : First Lieut. C. C. Parsons, 4th Artillery,
U. S. Army
Lieut-Col. H. B. Clitz, Maj. 12th Infantry, U. S.
A., and Comdt.
Capt. W. P. Chambliss, 5th Cavalry, U. S. Army
Capt. S. V. Benet, Ordnance
Capt. M. D. McAlister, Engineers
Capt. L. Lorain, 3d Artillery
First Lieut. A. T. Smith, 8th Infantry
First Lieut. W. A. Elderkin, ist Artillery
First Lieut. H. B. Noble, 8th Infantry
Executive Committee.
And the chairman of the meeting, in conjunc-
tion with Lieut. Hasbrouck, 4th Artillery, and
Captain Bradford, Ordnance Corps, was directed
to notify these officers of their selection, and re-
quest their acceptance. On further motion, the
8 THE BATTLE MONUMENT
Executive Committee was directed to establish a
pro rata standard of subscription, to fill vacancies
among themselves, and to inquire into the expe-
diency of obtaining permission from the Secretary
of War to forward circulars, etc., through the Ad-
jutant-General's Office.
On motion, the meeting adjourned to meet at
Lieut. Hasbrouck's quarters on Friday evening
following.
W. A. ELDERKIN,
First Lieut. 1st Artillery, U. S. Army,
President.
C. C. PARSONS,
First Lieut. 4th Artillery, U. S. Army,
Secretary.
West Point, N. Y., Oct. 9, 1863.
The meeting assembled, pursuant to adjourn-
ment, and resolved itself into the Executive Com-
mittee previously designated. Present — all the
members except Col. Bowman, Prof. Church, and
Capt. Chambliss. Lieut. Elderkin in the chair.
The minutes of the last meeting were read, and
on motion accepted, with the following amend-
ment:
That the Superintendent of the Military Acad-
emy and Commandant of the Corps of Cadets
should become ex-officio members of the Execu-
tive Committee, the former being also President.
AT WEST POINT 9
On motion, the Committee adjourned to meet at
the call of the Secretary.
Lieut. Elderkin, from Committee on Notifica-
tion, reported that the officers selected to constitute
the organization had been severally waited upon,
with the exception of Captain Chambliss, absent
from the post, and that each, with the above ex-
ception, had signified his acceptance.
Report adopted and Committee discharged.
On motion, the following Sub-committees were
appointed:
Design and Execution.
Col. Bowman, Lieut.-Col. Clitz,
Lieut. Elderkin.
Finance.
Prof. Church, Capt. Benet,
Capt. McAlister.
Site.
Col. Bowman, Capt. Chambliss,
Capt. Lorain.
Ceremonies.
Lieut.-Col. Clitz, Lieut. Smith,
Lieut. Noble.
The following is the circular prepared by the
Executive Committee :
io THE BATTLE MONUMENT
West Point, N. Y.,
Sir:
In response to what is believed to be the wish
of all who have an interest in the subject, the Offi-
cers now stationed at West Point have effected an
organization for the purpose of erecting at that
post a Monument, to be called THE BATTLE MON-
UMENT, upon which shall be inscribed the names
of all Officers of the Regular Army who, during
the present war, shall have been killed or died of
wounds received in the field.
It is not deemed necessary that any elaborate
argument should set forth the propriety of earnest
action in behalf of this object. It is an admitted
fact, that while in other countries and other ages
places are assigned in the historic mausoleum of
the nation's illustrious dead, for those who have
fallen for the public good, the soldiers of the
American army are often permitted to rest among
the unknown dead, while their names find no place
in the annals of the stormy scenes in which, per-
haps, they were the most exalted actors.
Is it not fit, therefore, that at West Point, the
great central post around which cluster some of
the richest associations of the Regular Army, to
which would cheerfully resort all who wish to pay
a tribute to the gallant dead, — under the shadow
of the Academy which at last receives her sons
and all who fight or fall beside them, — should be
AT WEST POINT n
erected a Monument which shall supply the want
that now exists ?
To the dead it would offer the grateful homage
of fraternal hearts, — to the living, still another
inspiration to heroic virtues and sublime self-
devotion.
The plan of action that is proposed has been
carefully sought out, and it is trusted that, with a
favorable response, a sufficient sum may be raised
to make the Battle Monument, in design and dura-
bility, entirely worthy of its purpose.
It seems unnecessary that those who have un-
dertaken to initiate this project should disavow any
undue assumption in regard to it, since they ear-
nestly ask from their brother officers, in the field or
elsewhere, such instructions or suggestions as may
tend to forward the purpose that is held in view.
For the purpose of indicating a standard of sub-
scription, the following rates are proposed. Every
one, however, will feel at liberty to offer a greater
or less sum, as circumstances permit :
Maj.-Gen-eral, $27.00 Major, . $10.00
Brig.-General, . 18.00 Captain, . 8.00
Colonel, . 13.00 Lieutenant, . 7.00
Lieut.-Colonel, . 11.00
(Approximating to six per cent, of monthly
pay, for one month.)
Beside your personal subscription, your co-oper-
12 THE BATTLE MONUMENT
f
ation with your associates in the field is also so-
licited, since this circular may not otherwise reach
them on account of the difficulty of obtaining
correct address.
Should subscriptions be forwarded in aggregate,
the officer so forwarding will please enclose the
names of the several subscribers. Subscriptions
may be remitted to the Treasurer,
Prof. A. E. CHURCH, West Point, N. Y.
Signed, etc., by Executive Committee.
On motion, it was declared the purpose of the
Committee to include the cases of such officers as
may die after the war from wounds received as be-
fore mentioned, and that in addition to the name, etc.,
and rank in the Regular Army, should be recorded
also the rank, in Volunteers, of officers named.
On motion, the Finance Committee were in-
structed to inquire the amount which might prob-
ably be raised by proposed plan of subscription ;
and the same Committee was authorized to direct
such incidental expenditures as are from time to
time required.
W. A. ELDERKIN,
First Lieut, ist Artillery, U. S. Army,
President.
First Lieut. C. C. PARSONS, 4th Artillery,!!. S. Army,
Secretary.
AT WEST POINT 13
West Point, N. Y., Nov. 24, 1863.
The Executive Committee met upon call of the
Secretary, pursuant to terms of last adjournment.
Prof. Church in the chair. Present — all the mem-
bers except Col. Bowman and Capt. Benet.
The minutes of the last meeting were read and
accepted. The Secretary stated that he had called
the meeting in order to answer inquiries in regard
to action taken since the last adjournment. The
minutes of the meeting and the Circular after-
wards adopted had been placed by the Presi-
dent of the Committee in the hands of Brig.-
General Totten, Chief Engineer and Inspector of
the Academy. No response had been returned
thereto.
Whereupon, after full discussion, the following
resolutions were adopted :
The purpose and plan of action of this Organi-
zation having been laid before the Chief Engineer
and Inspector of the Academy and no objection
having been returned, it is
Resolved, ist. That the Secretary, under super-
vision of the Finance Committee, be directed to
procure the printing of (blank to be filled by the
Secretary) copies of the Circular, to be distributed
as contemplated, and also the publication of the
same in the most suitable journals.
2d. That application in the name of the Execu-
H THE BATTLE MONUMENT
tive Committee be made to the Secretary of War for
permission to erect the Battle Monument at this post.
3d. That the subscriptions necessary to defray the
expenses to be incurred by the First Resolution be
at once solicited, such subscriptions to be regarded
as part of the permanent fund.
4th. That the Secretary be permitted to sign the
name of each member of the Executive Commit-
tee to the above Circular, and all corresponding
papers properly authorized.
5th. That the Finance Committee be directed to
procure a book in which shall be permanently re-
corded the names of all subscribers to the funds of
the Association.
6th. That copies of the proceedings, resolutions,
etc., most prominently setting forth the plans and
purposes of the organization be forwarded by the
Secretary to officers of the Regular Army high in
command, with the request that they furnish re-
sponses which shall be appended to the Circular
for general distribution.
The Secretary was directed to add to the Circu-
lar so much as is necessary to carry out the inten-
tion of the 6th Resolution.
West Point, N. Y., Dec. 15, 1863.
The Secretary reported that, conformably with
a Resolution of the last meeting, he had ordered
AT WEST POINT 15
*•
the printing of fifty copies each of Submitted Cir-
culars and Extracts from Minutes, and asked fur-
ther instructions.
A list of names including sixteen was deter-
mined upon by the Committee, to whom these
papers should be forwarded and their responses
appended to the Circular.
The Committee on Finance, through the Chair-
man, reported that from calculation upon the present
basis of subscription, the amount to be realized would
approximate to $20,000. The Committee on Site
were directed to report as early as convenient.
West Point, N. Y., Jan. 28, 1864.
The Secretary presented as subject for action
printed Circulars, of which 2600 copies had been
ordered, embodying, in addition to the first Circu-
lar of the Committee, extracts from all the responses
thus far received — namely, from Maj.-Genls.
McClellan, Wool, Grant, Thomas, Buell, Hooker
and Meade, and Brig.-Gen. Meigs, Q.-M.-General
of the Army ; also a plan for the Monument from
Genl. Meigs. The Chairman stated that he had
received a letter from Gen. Gibbon containing
certain suggestions laid before the Committee.
On motion and after discussion upon the ways and
means of issuing these, the Circular was adopted.
16 THE BATTLE MONUMENT
West Point, N. Y., Feby. y, 1864.
The Secretary submitted a letter from Major R.
Williams, A. A. G., suggesting the printing of
about 3000 Circulars, to be forwarded to him, upon
which he would forward them to every officer of
the Regular Army.
Upon motion, it was directed that the Circulars
of the first edition be so changed as to include in
the object of the Monument a Memorial to the
Enlisted Men who shall fall, etc., and that in the pro
rata subscription $1.00 be added for Enlisted Men.
******
West Point, N. Y., Feby. 24, 1864.
The Secretary announced as business before the
Committee that a vacancy had been created by
reason of Capt. Benet having been ordered from
the post.
On motion, Capt. T. J. Treadwell, Ordnance
Corps, was elected to fill the vacancy.
The letter of Maj. F. M. Etting, Additional Pay-
master, enquiring in regard to those included within
the appeal and objects of the Executive Commit-
tee, being submitted, the Secretary was directed to
reply that the term " Regular Officer " was sup-
posed to include those enumerated on page 110
(marked A), Army Register, dated Washington.
April i, 1863.
AT WEST POINT 17
West Point, N. Y., April 19, 1864.
The following resolutions, providing for the in-
augurating of the Monument, were unanimously
passed :
1st. Resolved: That the ceremony of inaugu-
ration of the BATTLE MONUMENT take place the
15th of June, next.
2d. That the Committees on Site and Design
be directed to so determine that a position for the
Monument shall be selected and reported to the
Executive Committee at its next meeting.
3d. That the Committee on Ceremonies be
directed to prepare and report at the next meeting
a programme of exercises for the day of inaugu-
ration.
4th. That Maj.-General McClellan be invited
in the name of the Executive Committee to de-
liver the Inaugural Address.
Upon further motion, it was directed that the
Chairman appoint three other members of the
Executive Committee to confer with the Com-
mittee on Ceremonies upon the drawing up of the
Programme in accordance with the 3d Resolution ;
whereupon the chairman appointed Maj. Cham-
bliss, Captains McAlister and Treadwell as such
additional members. Upon further motion, the
Secretary was directed to tender the thanks of the
Executive Committee, and thus of the Army, to
1 8 THE BATTLE MONUMENT
Major R. Williams, Asst. Adjt.-General, for the
especial service he has rendered to this project by
procuring the directing, franking and forwarding
of 2500 copies of the Committee's last circular to
all officers of the army.
On May 3, 1864, as a result of the foregoing,
the Secretary laid before the Committee a letter
from Maj.-General McClellan, accepting the Com-
mittee's invitation to deliver the Inaugural Address
upon the 15th of June, next, whereupon it was
directed that the correspondence upon this invita-
tion be entered in the minutes of the evening.
This correspondence was not so entered, and no
trace of it can be found.
The dedication of Trophy Point as the site of
the Monument took place in accordance with the
foregoing resolutions.
Its interest was heightened by the presence of
the shattered but still steady remnants of the 3d,
6th, yth, and 12th Regiments, U. S. Infantry, the
bands of these and of the 5th Artillery, and the
permanent party of Fort Columbus, N. Y. Har-
bor, preceded in procession by the U. S. Corps of
Cadets and the Military Academy Band.
It was also distinguished throughout by that
deep solemnity of feeling which was eminently
due to the occasion.
Brig.-General Anderson officiated as chief mar-
shal, and Rev. Drs. French and Sprole as chaplains.
DEDICATION OF SITE
ON
TROPHY POINT
DEDICATION OF SITE ON TROPHY
POINT, ON JUNE 15, 1864
*
•
West Point, June 15, 1864.
PROGRAMME OF CEREMONIES.
PROCESSION.
Assistant Marshal, Capt. Wilkins, 3d Infantry.
I. Military Academy Band.
II. Battalion of Cadets.
Assistant Marshal, Capt. Smith, 8th Infantry.
III. Detachments of troops stationed at and visit-
ing the post.
IV. Carriage containing the President of the
Executive Committee, the Chief Marshal,
and State Executives.
2A
22 THE BATTLE MONUMENT
Assistant Marshal, Lieut. Hamilton, 2d Artillery.
V. Senior member of the Committee, Orator,
and Chaplains.
VI. The Executive Committee.
VII. Military and Academic Staff, Board of Vis-
itors, and Invited Guests.
Assistant Marshals,^?*- Dayies' l6th Infantry-
( Capt. Barlow, Engineers.
PROCEEDINGS.
I. Prayer ..... . . Rev. Dr. French
II. ^lusic .... Military Academy Band
" Hail Columbia."
III. Oration . '." .' / . Maj.-General McClellan
IV. Music .... Military Academy Band
" Star Spangled Banner " and " Yankee Doodle."
V. Benediction . .''*•*.' . Rev. Dr. Sprole
VI. Dirge .... Military Academy Band
PRAYERS.
I.
For the Country.
Almighty God, fountain of order, source of all law in heaven
and in earth, who hast ordained that men shall exist in organ-
ized communities, who, in the days of our fathers, didst bring
forth, in the hour of darkness, the starry order of American insti-
tutions, for which we praise and bless Thee, we commend our
country, now and ever, with all its interests, to Thy protecting
care. May Thy fatherly hand ever be extended for perpetual
benedictions over this land, kept by Thee through ages for us ;
over its people, trained by Thee so long for a sublime heaven ;
its Constitution, fruit of Thy teachings in history ; its Union,
blending human diversities into one chorus acceptable to Thee,
the lover of concord ; and its laws, uniting, after the model of
Thine, mercy with justice, and liberty with order. From
Thine own deeps of purity and love, breathe into the whole
American people, by Thy spirit, and through all-subduing char-
ity, that sacred affection, love to our country. Remove for
ever from them, the spirit of sedition, conspiracy, rebellion,
and give them steadfast loyalty, and unswerving allegiance.
Specially do we implore Thee thus to turn the hearts of those
who are now in arms against authority. In the contest to
which we have been summoned for defending the precious trusts
handed on from our fathers, wilt Thou send us now prosperity,
and grant us victory. O, let not the impassioned yearnings of
23
24 THE BATTLE MONUMENT
a great people for unity, for nationality, for beneficent order,
for a lasting tranquillity, be in vain. May their lavish sacri-
fices, their patriotic efforts, their patient endurances, their silent
tears falling in so many saddened homesteads, not be fruitless,
but be regarded by Thee, through Thy Son, for benedictions,
and by distant posterities, blessed through them, for abundant
honor. So may we be through coming time, one people, fear-
ing Thee and working righteousness, glorifying Thy name, and
elevating Thy whole human family. All of which we ask through
Jesus Christ our Saviour. Amen.
II.
For the President of the United States, and
all others in Authority.
O everlasting God, by whose eternal providence all things
and all men have their stations and their works, wherein they
may serve Thee, and do good to Thy creatures, we ask for
Thy blessing on the President of the United States, and all
others in authority. Called by Thee to great duties, may they
find in Thee strength and wisdom for all. Bestow upon them
all good gifts for government ; inspire them with wisest counsels
and heroic resolutions. Console them in their difficult tasks
with the consciousness of duty done, of intentions sincerely
placed on the public welfare, justice, and honor ; of the sym-
pathy of upright men ; of the appreciation of other ages ; and
of Thine own merciful and forgiving approval. In this life may
Thy providence guard them. In mortal senses may Thy spirit
so guide them, that they may hereafter serve and glorify Thee
in a better country that is an heavenly ; through Him who
taught the rules and procured the spirit for all human duties,
our teacher, our model, our restorer, Jesus Christ our Lord.
Amen.
AT WEST POINT 25
III.
For the Army and Navy and their Schools.
Lord God of Hosts, who hast determined the union of power
with law throughout all Thy works, and for all communities of
men, be pleased to receive into Thy almighty and most gracious
protection the Army and Navy of the United States. Fill the
whole public force with the spirit of patriotism and self-sacri-
fice, with an inspiring conviction of the glory of the cause for
which it is now called to dare and to endure. May its persons
be defended by Thee in danger and encouraged to all deeds of
heroism by the affection and honor of a grateful country. And
may both its schools be the nurseries of pure, accomplished,
and brave men, and be continually sending forth on land and
sea those who may render, in peace and war, good and faithful
service to the public. So may the people of our land, under
the shelter of good laws, in peace and quietness, serve Thee
our God, and lead lives of all godliness and honesty, to the
glory of Thy name, and the promotion of human welfare,
through Him who gave the example of self-sacrifice, dying for
us that we might live with Thee, Thy Son, our Saviour.
Amen.
For a Blessing on the Occasion.
O God of the spirits of all flesh, calling the generations from
the beginning, and, since the first transgression, bidding dust
return to dust again, may this spot, consecrated now to the
memory of heroes, be hallowed also to the benefit of the liv-
ing. May those brought here for their last repose be the
temples of Thy Holy Spirit, and leave spotless records of lives
made glorious by duty conscientiously done, so that the way-
farer, lingering and musing here, may find his soul enkindled
26 THE BATTLE MONUMENT
to ennobling emulations. And may this whole assembly look
this day from the grave to the life immortal. Here, in a tem-
ple not made with hands, where the mountains rise, the river
flows, the valley slumbers, all telling of Thee and of Thy un-
speakable perfection, may thoughts arise within us answering
to the majesty of Thy glorious works. Here may we conse-
crate ourselves anew to the love of Thee, the love of man, the
love of Thy will ; to the doing of justice, to the loving of
mercy, and to walking humbly with Thee our God : that so,
when we too shall lie down in the dust, we may be Thy chil-
dren, justified, sanctified, and prepared to be glorified, all
through Him who has opened the way to Thee, and who, to
inbreathe these great affections, has taught us when we pray to
say:
Our Father, who art in heaven, Hallowed be Thy name.
Thy Kingdom come. Thy will be done on earth, as it is in
heaven. Give us this day our daily bread. And forgive us
our trespasses, as we forgive those who trespass against us. And
lead us not into temptation : But deliver us from evil. For
Thine is the kingdom and the power and the glory, for ever
and ever. Amen.
AT WEST POINT 27
After the prayer, Prof. French said :
I am requested, on behalf of the officers of the army, and
of the local authorities and residents, to express their senti-
ments and wishes, and most earnestly to ask that these may be
respected. To all of us, the day is a solemn one ; to military
feelings, ever confronted with death, the occasion is the same as
though cherished comrades were now to be laid in the grave.
They ask, therefore, that this hour and this day may be invested
with the decorum attached to funeral solemnities, that no
demonstration of any kind be made on the ground or afterward,
but that all may enter into the spirit and motive of the solemn
occasion which calls us here in reverence, before Almighty
God, to set apart a portion of his foot-stool for the remains of
those who shall fall in this war in the defense of the Constitu-
tion, the Union, the welfare, and the national honor of the
United States.
General Anderson's introduction of the orator :
Fellow-citizens, members of the corps of cadets, and brother
soldiers, I have the pleasure of going through the form of in-
troducing to you one who is better known to you than I who
introduce him, — the orator of the day, Major-General George
E. McClellan.
ORATION BY
GENERAL GEORGE B. McCLELLAN
HLL nations have days sacred to the remembrance of joy
and of grief. They have thanksgivings for success,
fasting and prayers in the hour of humiliation and
defeat, triumphs and paeans to greet the living and
laurel-crowned victor. They have obsequies and eulogies for
the warrior slain on the field of battle. Such is the duty we
are to perform to-day. The poetry, the histories, the ora-
tions of antiquity, all resound with the clang of arms ; they
dwell rather upon rough deeds of war, than the gentle arts of
peace. They have preserved to us the names of heroes, and
the memory of their deeds, even to this distant day. Our
own Old Testament teems with the narrations of the brave
actions and heroic deaths of Jewish patriots, while the New
Testament of our meek and suffering Saviour often selects the
soldier and his weapons to typify and illustrate religious hero-
ism and duty. These stories of the actions of the dead have
frequently survived, in the lapse of ages, the names of those
whose fall was thus commemorated centuries ago. But, al-
though we know not now the names of all the brave men who
fought and fell upon the plain of Marathon, in the pass of
29
30 THE BATTLE MONUMENT
Thermopylae, and on the hills of Palestine, we have not lost
the memory of their examples. As long as the warm blood
courses the veins of man, as long as the human heart beats
high and quick at the recital of brave deeds and patriotic sacri-
fices, so long will the lesson still incite generous men to emu-
late the heroism of the past.
Among the Greeks, it was the custom that the fathers of the
most valiant of the slain should pronounce the eulogies of the
dead. Sometimes it devolved upon their great statesmen and
orators to perform this mournful duty. Would that a new
Demosthenes, or a second Pericles, could arise and take my
place to-day, for he would find a theme worthy of his most
brilliant powers, of his most touching eloquence. I stand here
now, not as an orator, but as a whilom commander, and in the
place of the fathers of the most valiant dead ; as their com-
rade, too, on many a hard-fought field, against domestic and
foreign foe — in early youth and mature manhood — moved by
all the love that David felt when he poured forth his lamenta-
tions for the mighty father and son who fell on Mount Gilboa.
God knows that David's love for Jonathan was no more deep
than mine for the tried friends of many long and eventful
years, whose names are to be recorded upon the structure that
is to rise upon this spot. Would that his more than mortal
eloquence could grace my lips and do justice to the theme !
We have met to-day, my comrades, to do honor to our own
dead ; brothers united to us by the closest and dearest ties, who
have freely given their lives for their country in this war — so
just and righteous so long as its purpose is to crush rebellion,
and to save our nation from the infinite evils of dismemberment.
Such an occasion as this should call forth the deepest and no-
blest emotions of our nature — pride, sorrow, and prayer :
pride that our country has possessed such sons ; sorrow that
she has lost them ; prayer that she may have others like them ;
that we and our successors may adorn her annals as they have
AT WEST POINT 31
done, and that when our parting hour arrives, whenever and
however it may be, our souls may be prepared for the great
change.
We have assembled to consecrate a cenotaph which shall
remind our children's children, in the distant future, of their
fathers' struggles in the days of the great rebellion. This
monument is to perpetuate the memory of a portion only of
those who have fallen for the nation in this unhappy war —
it is dedicated to the officers and soldiers of the regular army.
Yet this is done in no class or exclusive spirit, and in the act
we remember, with reverence and love, our comrades of the
volunteers who have so gloriously fought and fallen by our
side. Each State will, no doubt, commemorate in some fit-
ting way the services of its sons who abandoned the avoca-
tions of peace and shed their blood in the ranks of the volun-
teers. How richly they have earned a nation's love, a nation's
gratitude, with what heroism they have confronted death, have
wrested victory from a stubborn foe, and have illustrated de-
feat, it well becomes me to say, for it has been my lot to
command them on many a sanguinary field. I know that I
but echo the feeling of the regulars when I award the high
credit they deserve to their brave brethren of the volunteers.
But we of the regular army have no States to look to for the
honors due our dead. We belong to the whole country, and
can neither expect nor desire the general government to make
a perhaps invidious distinction in our favor. We are few in
number, a small band of comrades, united by peculiar and very
binding ties ; for with many of us our friendships were com-
menced in boyhood, when we rested here in the shadow of
the granite hills which look down upon us where we stand ;
with others the ties of brotherhood were formed in more ma-
ture years, while fighting among the rugged mountains and the
fertile valleys of Mexico — within hearing of the eternal waves
of the Pacific, or in the lonely grandeur of the great plains of
32 THE BATTLE MONUMENT
the far West. With all, our love and confidence have been
cemented by common dangers and sufferings, on the toilsome
march, in the dreary bivouac, and amid the clash of arms, and
in the presence of death on scores of battle-fields. West Point,
with her large heart, adopts us all — graduates and those appointed
from civil life, officers and privates. In her eyes we are all
her children, jealous of her fame, and eager to sustain her
world-wide reputation. Generals and private soldiers, men
who have cheerfully offered our all for our dear country, we
stand here before this shrine, ever hereafter sacred to our dead,
equals and brothers in the presence of the common death
which awaits us all, perhaps on the same field and at the same
hour. Such are the ties which unite us, the most endearing
which exist among men ; such the relations which bind us to-
gether, the closest of the sacred brotherhood of arms.
It has therefore seemed, and it is fitting, that we should
erect upon this spot, so sacred to us all, an enduring monu-
ment to our dear brothers who have preceded us upon the path
of peril and of honor, which it is the destiny of many of us
to tread.
What is this regular army to which we belong ?
Who were the men whose death merits such honors from the
living ?
What is the cause for which they have laid down their lives ?
Our regular or permanent army is the nucleus which, in time
of peace, preserves the military traditions of the nation, as well
as the organization, science and instruction indispensable to
modern armies. It may be regarded as co-eval with the na-
tion. It derives its origin from the old Continental and State
lines of the Revolution, whence, with some interruptions and
many changes, it has attained its present condition. In fact,
we may with propriety go even beyond the Revolution to seek
the roots of our genealogical tree in the old French wars, for
the Cis-Atlantic campaigns of the Seven Years' War were not
AT WEST POINT 33
confined to the "red men scalping each other by the great lakes
of North America/' and it was in them that ou-r ancestors first
participated as Americans in the large operations of civilized
armies. American regiments then fought on the banks of the
St. Lawrence and the Ohio, on the shores of Ontario and
Lake George, on the islands of the Caribbean and in South
America. Louisburg, Quebec, Duquesne, the Moro, and
Porto Bello, attest the value of the provincial troops, and in
that school were educated such soldiers as Washington, Put-
nam, Lee, Montgomery and Gates. These, and men like
Greene, Knox, Wayne and Steuben, were the fathers of our
permanent army, and under them our troops acquired that dis-
cipline and steadiness which enabled them to meet upon equal
terms, and often to defeat, the tried veterans of England. The
study of the history of the Revolution, and a perusal of the
despatches of Washington, will convince the most skeptical of
the value of the permanent army in achieving our independence
and establishing the civil edifice which we are now fighting to
preserve.
The War of 1812 found the army on a footing far from ad-
equate to the emergency, but it was rapidly increased, and of
the new generation of soldiers many proved equal to the
requirements of the occasion. Lundy's Lane, Chippewa,
Queenstown, Plattsburg, New Orleans — all bear witness to
the gallantry of the regulars.
Then came an interval of more than thirty years of external
peace, marked by so many changes in the organization and
strength of the regular army, and broken at times by tedious and
bloody Indian wars. Of these the most remarkable were the
Black Hawk War, in which our troops met unflinchingly a foe
as relentless, and far more destructive than the Indians — that
terrible scourge, the cholera ; and the tedious Florida War,
where, for many years, the Seminoles eluded in the pestilential
swamps our utmost efforts, and in which were displayed such
3 f
34 THE BATTLE MONUMENT
traits of heroism as that commemorated by yonder monument
to Dade and his command, " when all fell, save three, without
an attempt to retreat. " At last came the Mexican War, to
replace Indian combats and the monotony of the frontier ser-
vice, and for the first time in many years the mass of the regu-
lar army was concentrated, and took the principal part in the
battles of that remarkable and romantic war. Palo Alto, Re-
saca, and Fort Brown, were the achievements of the regulars
unaided; and as to the battles of Monterey, Buena Vista, Vera
Cruz, Cerro Gordo, and the final triumphs in the valley, none
can truly say that they could have been won without the regu-
lars. When peace crowned our victories in the capital of the
Montezumas, the army was at once dispersed over the long fron-
tier, and engaged in harassing and dangerous wars with the Indians
of the plains. Thus thirteen long years were spent, until the
present war broke out, and the mass of the army was drawn in
to be employed against a domestic foe.
I cannot proceed to the events of the recent past and the
present without adverting to the gallant men who were so long
of our number, but who have now gone to their last home; for no
small portion of the glory of which we boast was reflected from
such men as Taylor, Worth, Brady, Brooks, Totten, and
Duncan.
There is a sad story of Venetian history that has moved
many a heart, and often employed the poet's pen and the
painter's pencil. It is of an old man whose long life was glo-
riously spent in the service of the state as a warrior and a states-
man, and who, when his hair was white and his feeble limbs
could scarce carry his bent form toward the grave, attained the
highest honors that a Venetian citizen could reach. He was
Doge of Venice. Convicted of treason against the state, he
not only lost his life, but suffered beside a penalty which will
endure as long as the name of Venice is remembered. The
spot where his portrait should have hung in the great hall of
AT WEST POINT 35
the doge's palace was veiled with black, and there still remains
the frame, with its black mass of canvas — and this vacant frame
is the most conspicuous in the long line of effigies of illustrious
doges !
Oh ! that such a pall as that which replaces the portrait of
Marino Faliero could conceal from history the names of those,
once our comrades, who are now in arms against the flag under
which we fought side by side in years gone by. But no veil
can cover the anguish that fills our hearts when we look back
upon the sad memory of the past, and recall the affection
and respect we entertained toward men against whom it is our
duty to act in mortal combat. Would that the courage, ability
and steadfastness they displayed had been employed in the de-
fense of the "Stars and Stripes" against a foreign foe, rather
than in this gratuitous and unjustifiable rebellion, which could
not be so long maintained but for the skill and energy of those,
our former comrades! • *
But we have reason to rejoice that upon this day, so sacred
and so eventful for us, one grand old mortal monument of the
past still lifts high his head amongst us, and graces by his pres-
ence the consecration of this tomb of his children. We may
well be proud that we have been commanded by the hero who
purchased victory with his blood near the great waters of Ni-
agara, who repeated and eclipsed the achievements of Cortez ;
who, although a consummate and confident commander, ever
preferred, when duty and honor would permit, the olive branch
of peace to the blood-stained laurels of war, and who stands,
at the close of a long, glorious and eventful life, a living column
of granite against which have beaten in vain alike the blandish-
ments and the storms of treason. His name will ever be one of our
proudest boasts and most moving inspirations. In long-distant
ages, when this incipient monument has become venerable, moss-
clad, and perhaps ruinous, when the names inscribed upon it shall
seem, to those who pause to read them, indistinct mementos of
36 THE BATTLE MONUMENT
an almost mythical past, the name of Winfield Scott will still
be clear cut upon the memory of them all, like the still fresh
carving upon the monuments of long-forgotten Pharaohs.
But it is time to approach the present.
In the war which now shakes the land to its foundation, the
regular army has borne a most honorable part. Too few in
numbers to act by themselves, regular regiments have partici-
pated in every great battle in the East, and in most of those
west of the Alleghanies. Their terrible losses and diminished
numbers prove that they have been in the thickest of the fights,
and the testimony of their comrades and commanders shows
with what undaunted heroism they have upheld their ancient
renown. Their vigorous charges have often won the day, and
in defeat they have more than once saved the army from de-
struction or terrible losses by the obstinacy with which they
resisted overpowering numbers. They can refer with pride to
the part they played upon the glorious fields of Mexico, and
exult at the recollection of what they did at Manassas, Gaines's
Mill, Malvern, Antietam, Shiloh, Stone River, Gettysburg,
and the great battles just fought from the Rapidan to the Chick-
ahominy. They can also point to the officers who have risen
among them and achieved great deeds for their country in this
war ; — to the living warriors whose names are on the nation's
tongue and heart, too numerous to be repeated here, yet not
one of whom I could willingly omit.
But perhaps the proudest episode in the history of the regu-
lar army is that touching instance of fidelity on the part of the
non-commissioned officers and privates who, treacherously
made prisoners in Texas, resisted every temptation to violate
their oath and desert their flag. Offered commissions in the
rebel service, money and land freely tendered them, they all
scorned the inducements held out to them, submitted to every
hardship, and when at last exchanged, avenged themselves on
the field of battle for the unavailing insult offered their integ-
AT WEST POINT 37
rity. History affords no brighter example of honor than that
of these brave men, tempted, as I blush to say they were, by
some of their former officers, who, having themselves proved
false to their flag, endeavored to seduce the men who had often
followed them in combat, and who had naturally regarded them
with respect and love.
Such is the regular army — such its history and antecedents
— such its officers and men. It needs no herald to trumpet
forth its praises ; it can proudly appeal to the numerous fields,
from the tropics to the frozen banks of the St. Lawrence, from
the Atlantic to the Pacific, fertilized by the blood and whit-
ened by the bones of its members. But I will not pause to
eulogize it. Let its deeds speak for it ; they are more elo-
quent than tongue of mine.
Why are we here to-day ?
This is not the funeral of one brave warrior, nor even of
the harvest of death on a single battle-field, but these are the
obsequies of the best and bravest of the children of the land,
who have fallen in actions almost numberless, many of them
among the most sanguinary and desperate of which history
bears record. The men whose names and deeds we now
seek to perpetuate, rendering them the highest honor in our
power, have fallen wherever armed rebellion showed its front —
in far-distant New Mexico, in the broad valley of the Mis-
sissippi, on the bloody hunting-grounds of Kentucky, in the
mountains of Tennessee, amid the swamps of Carolina, on the
fertile fields of Maryland, and in the blood-stained thickets of
Virginia. They were of all the grades — from the general
officer to the private ; of all ages — from the gray-haired vet-
eran, of fifty years' service, to the beardless youth ; of all de-
grees of cultivation — from the man of science to the unedu-
cated boy. It is not necessary, nor is it possible, to repeat
the mournful yet illustrious roll of dead heroes whom we have
met to honor. Nor shall I attempt to name all of those who
3A
38 THE BATTLE MONUMENT
most merit praise — simply a few who will exemplify the
classes to which they belong.
Among the last slain, but among the first in honor and repu-
tation, was that hero of twenty battles — John Sedgwick.
Gentle and kind as a woman, brave as a brave man can be,
honest, sincere, and able — he was a model that all may strive
to imitate, but whom few can equal. In the terrible battles
which just preceded his death, he had occasion to display the
highest qualities of a commander and a soldier ; yet after es-
caping the stroke of death when men fell around him by thou-
sands, he at last met his fate at a moment of comparative quiet,
by the ball of a single rifleman. He died as a soldier would
choose to die — with truth in his heart, and a sweet, tranquil
smile upon his face. Alas ! our great nation possesses few sons
like true John Sedgwick.
Like him fell, too, at the very head of their corps, the white-
haired Mansfield, after a long career of usefulness, illustrated
by his skill and cool courage at Fort Brown, Monterey, and
Buena Vista; John F. Reynolds and Reno, both in the full
vigor of manhood and intellect — men who had proved their
ability and chivalry on many a field in Mexico and in this
civil war, gallant gentlemen of whom their country had much
to hope, had it pleased God to spare their lives. Lyon fell in
the prime of life, leading his little army against superior num-
bers, his brief career affording a brilliant example of patriotism
and ability. The impetuous Kearny, and such brave generals
as Richardson, Williams, Terrill, Stevens, Weed, Strong,
Saunders and Hayes, lost their lives while in the midst of
a career of usefulness. Young Bayard, so like the most re-
nowned of his name, that " knight above fear and above re-
proach," was cut off too early for his country, and that excel-
lent staff-officer, Colonel Garesche, fell while gallantly doing
his duty.
No regiments can spare such gallant, devoted and able com-
AT WEST POINT 39
manders as Rossell, Davis, Gore, Simmons, Bailey, Putnam
and Kingsbury — all of whom fell in the thickest of the com-
bat — some of them veterans, and others young in service, all
good men and well-beloved.
Our batteries have partially paid their terrible debt to fate in
the loss of such commanders as Greble, the first to fall in this
war, Benson, Hazzard, Smead, De Hart, Hazlitt, and those gal-
lant boys, Kirby, Woodruff, Dimmick and Gushing ; while the
engineers lament the promising and gallant Wagner and Cross.
Beneath remote battle-fields rest the corpses of the heroic
McRea, Reed, Bascom, Stone, Sweet, and many other com-
pany officers.
Besides these were hosts of veteran sergeants, corporals and
privates who had fought under Scott in Mexico, or contended
in many combats with the savages of the far West and Florida;
and, mingled with them, young soldiers who, courageous,
steady and true, met death unflinchingly, without the hope of
personal glory. These men, in their more humble sphere,
served their country with as much faith and honor as the most il-
lustrious generals, and all of them with perfect singleness of heart.
Although their names may not live in history, their actions,
loyalty, and courage will live. Their memories will long be
preserved in their regiments, for there were many of them who
merited as proud a distinction as that accorded to the "first
grenadier of France, " or to that other Russian soldier who gave
his life for his comrades.
But there is another class of men who have gone from us since
this war commenced, whose fate it was not to die in battle,
but who are none the less entitled to be mentioned here.
There was Sumner, a brave, honest, chivalrous veteran, of
more than half a century's service, who had confronted death
unflinchingly on scores of battlefields, had shown his gray head
serene and cheerful where death most revelled, who more than
once told me that he believed and hoped that his long career
40 THE BATTLE MONUMENT
would end amid the din of battle — he died at home from the
effects of the hardships of his campaigns.
The most excellent soldier, the elegant C. F. Smith, whom
many of us remember to have seen so often on this plain, with
his superb bearing, escaped the bullet to fall a victim to the
disease which has deprived the army of so many of its best
soldiers.
John Buford, cool and intrepid ; Mitchell, eminent in sci-
ence; Plummer, Palmer, and many other officers and men,
lost their lives by sickness contracted in the field.
But I cannot close this long list of glorious martyrs without
paying a sacred debt of official duty and personal friendship.
There was one dead soldier who possessed peculiar claims
upon my love and gratitude. He was an ardent patriot, an
unselfish man, a true soldier, the beau ideal of a staff-officer —
he was my aide-de-camp, Colonel Colburn.
There is a lesson to be drawn from the death and services of
these glorious men which we should read for the present and
future benefit of the nation. War in these modern days is a
science, and it should now be clear to the most prejudiced that
for the organization and command of armies, and the high com-
binations of strategy, perfect familiarity with the theoretical
science of war is requisite. To count upon success when the
plans or execution of campaigns are intrusted to men who have
no knowledge of war, is as idle as to expect the legal wisdom
of a Story or a Kent from a skilful physician.
But what is the honorable and holy cause for which these
men laid down their lives, and for which the nation still de-
mands the sacrifice of the precious blood of so many of her
children?
Soon after the close of the Revolutionary War, it was found
that the Confederacy, which had grown up during that memor-
able contest, was fast falling to pieces from its own weight.
The central power was too weak ; it could only recommend
AT WEST POINT 41
to the different States such measures as seemed best ; and it
possessed no real power to legislate, because it lacked the ex-
ecutive force to compel obedience to its laws. The national
credit and self-respect had disappeared, and it was feared by
the friends of human liberty throughout the world that ours was
but another added to the long list of fruitless attempts at self-
government. The nation was evidently upon the brink of ruin
and dissolution, when, some eighty years ago, many of the
wisest and most patriotic of the land met to seek a remedy for
the great evils which threatened to destroy the great work of
the Revolution. Their sessions were long, and often stormy;
for a time the most sanguine doubted tlie possibility of a
successful termination to their labors. But, from amidst
the conflict of sectional interests, of party prejudices, and of
personal selfishness, the spirit of wisdom and conciliation at
length evoked the Constitution, under which we have lived so
long.
It was not formed in a day, but was the result of patient
labor, of lofty wisdom, and of the purest patriotism. It was
at last adopted by the people of all the States — although by
some reluctantly — not as being exactly what all desired, but
as being the best possible under the circumstances. It was
accepted as giving us a form of government under which the
nation might live happily and prosper, so long as the people
should continue to be influenced by the same sentiments which
actuated those who formed it, and which would not be liable
to destruction from internal causes, so long as the people pre-
served the recollection of the miseries and calamities which led
to its adoption.
Under this beneficent Constitution the progress of the na-
tion was unexampled in history. The rights and liberties of
its citizens were secure at home and abroad ; vast territories
were rescued from the control of the savage and the wild
beast, and added to the domain of civilization and the Union.
42 THE BATTLE MONUMENT
The arts, the sciences, and commerce, grew apace ; our flag
floated upon every sea, and we took our place among the great
nations of the earth.
But under the smooth surface of prosperity upon which we
glided swiftly, with all sails set before the summer breeze,
dangerous reefs were hidden which now and then caused rip-
ples upon the surface, and made anxious the more cautious
pilots. Elated by success, the ship swept on, the crew not
heeding the warnings they received, forgetful of the dangers
they escaped in the beginning of the voyage, and blind to the
hideous maelstrom which gaped to receive and destroy them.
The same elements of discordant sectional prejudices, interests,
and institutions, which had rendered the formation of the Con-
stitution so difficult, threatened more than once to destroy it.
But for a long time the nation was so fortunate as to possess a
series of political leaders who, to the highest abilities, united
the same spirit of conciliation which animated the founders of
the Republic, and thus for many years the threatened evils
were averted. Time and long-continued good fortune obliter-
ated the recollection of the calamities and wretchedness of the
years preceding the adoption of the Constitution. Men for-
got that conciliation, common interest, and mutual charity,
had been the foundation and must be the support of our govern-
ment — as is indeed the case with all governments and all the
relations of life. At length men appeared with whom sec-
tional and personal prejudices and interests outweighed all con-
siderations for the general good. Extremists of one section
furnished the occasion, eagerly seized as a pretext by equally
extreme men in the other, for abandoning the pacific remedies
and protection afforded by the Constitution, and seeking re-
dress for possible future evils in war and the destruction of the
Union.
Stripped of all sophistry and side issues, the direct cause of
the war as it presented itself to the honest and patriotic citi-
AT WEST POINT
43
zens of the North, was simply this : Certain States, or rather,
a portion of the inhabitants of certain States, feared, or pro-
fessed to fear, that injury would result to their rights and prop-
erty from the elevation of a particular party to power. Al-
though the Constitution and the actual condition of the govern-
ment provided them with a peaceable and sure protection
against the apprehended evil, they preferred to seek security in
the destruction of the government, which could protect them,
and in the use of force against the national troops holding a
national fortress.
To efface the insult offered our flag ; to save ourselves from
the fate of the divided republics of Italy and South America,
to preserve our government from destruction, to enforce its
just power and laws, to maintain our very existence as a
nation — these were the causes that compelled us to draw the
sword.
Rebellion against a government like ours, which contains the
means of self-adjustment, and a pacific remedy for evils, should
never be confounded with a revolution against despotic power,
which refuses redress of wrongs. Such a rebellion cannot be
justified upon ethical grounds, and the only alternative for our
choice is its suppression, or the destruction of our nationality.
At such a time as this, and in such a struggle, political partisan-
ship should be merged in a true and brave patriotism, which
thinks only of the good of the whole country.
It was in this cause, and with these motives, that so many of
our comrades gave their lives, and to this we are all person-
ally pledged in all honor and fidelity. Shall such a devotion as
that of our dead comrades be of no avail ? Shall it be said in
after ages that we lacked the vigor to complete the work
thus begun ? that, after all these noble lives freely given, we
hesitated, and failed to keep straight on until our land was saved ?
Forbid it, Heaven, and give us firmer, truer hearts than that !
Oh, spirits of the valiant dead, souls of our slain heroes, lend
44 THE BATTLE MONUMENT
us your own indomitable will, and if it be permitted you to
commune with those still chained by the trammels of mortality,
hover around us in the midst of danger and tribulation, cheer
the firm, strengthen the weak, that none may doubt the salvation
of the republic and the triumph of our grand old flag !
In the midst of the storms which toss our ship of state, there
is one great beacon light, to which we can ever turn with con-
fidence and hope. It cannot be that this great nation has played
its part in history ; it cannot be that our sun, which arose with
such bright promises for the future, has already set for ever. It
must be the intention of the overruling Deity that this land, so
long the asylum of the oppressed, the refuge of civil and re-
ligious liberty, shall again stand forth in bright relief, united,
purified, and chastened by our trials, as an example and en-
couragement for those who desire the progress of the human
race. It is not given to our weak intellects to understand the
steps of Providence as they occur ; we comprehend them only
as we look upon them in the far distant past.
So is it now.
We cannot unravel the seemingly tangled skein ot the pur-
poses of the Creator — they are too high and far-reaching for
our limited minds. But all history and his own revealed word
teach us that his ways, although inscrutable, are ever righteous.
Let us then honestly and manfully play our part, seek to un-
derstand and perform our whole duty, and trust unwaveringly
in the beneficence of the God who led our ancestors across the
sea, and sustained them afterward, amid dangers more appalling
even than those encountered by his own chosen people in their
great exodus. He did not bring us here in vain, nor has he
supported us thus far for naught. If we do our duty and trust
in him, he will not desert us in our need.
Firm in our faith that God will save our country, we now
dedicate this site to the memory of brave men, to loyalty, pa-
triotism, and honor.
AT WEST POINT 45
BENEDICTION.
May the God of our fathers and our God, succeed with his
divine benediction the solemn and interesting services of this
occasion. May he conduct, by his gracious providence, the
work commenced to-day to successful completion. May the
monument here to be raised in honor of the illustrious dead,
inspire with all the ardor of a sound Christian patriotism, the
soldiers of our common country here trained for its defence ;
may it prove to them a constant remembrancer of their mortality,
and keep alive upon the altar of their hearts the flame of devo-
tion to God, to country, to the Union, the Constitution, and
the immutable principles of truth and justice ; and may the
blessing of the triune God, the Father, Son, and Holy Spirit,
be with you all. Amen.
46 THE BATTLE MONUMENT
West Point, N. Y., October 20, 1864.
On the call of the Secretary of the Association,
First Lieutenant C. C. Parsons, 4th Artillery, a
meeting of the officers of the Army, present at the
Post, was held, for the transaction of such busi-
ness in regard to the " Battle Monument " as might
be brought before them. Prof. H. L. Kendrick
in the chair.
The Secretary having been ordered from the
Post, his resignation was tendered and accepted,
and upon motion Captain F. L. Guenther, 5th
Artillery, was elected to fill the vacancy thus oc-
curring.
Upon motion, it was Resolved. That all officers
of the Army, present at the Post, on duty or other-
wise, be constituted a "Monument Committee."
A motion that the Executive Committee of the
Association should consist of the President, Trea-
surer and Secretary, and eight other members, was
adopted.
Upon motion, the following officers were elected
to constitute the Executive Committee, viz. :
Brig.-Gen. Geo. W. Cullum, President
Professor A. E. Church, treasurer
Captain F. L. Guenther, 5th Artillery, Secretary
Colonel H. M. Black
Captain George H. Mendall, U. S. Engineers
Captain Lorenzo Lorain, 3d Artillery
AT WEST POINT 47
Captain A. K. Arnold, ^th Cavalry
Captain A. T. Smith, 8th Infantry
Captain R. M. Hill, Ordnance Department
Lieut. H. B. Noble, 8th Infantry
Assistant Surgeon E. S. Dunster, Medical Dept.
Upon motion, it was
Resolved. That the thanks of the Association
be tendered to the retiring Secretary, First Lieut.
C. C. Parsons, 4th Artillery, for the zealous and
able manner in which he has performed the duties
of his office.
There being no further business before it, the
meeting, upon motion, adjourned to meet again
on the call of the Secretary.
F. L, Guenther, Captain _fth Artillery,
Secretary.
At some time not shown by the record an invi-
tation to submit designs for the monument was
issued by the Committee on Design. To what
extent responses were obtained and what their
character does not appear.
The invitation was as follows :
The BATTLE MONUMENT EXECUTIVE COMMITTEE will receive
DESIGNS for the MONUMENT TO BE ERECTED AT WEST POINT,
N. Y., to the Memory of the OFFICERS and ENLISTED MEN of
the REGULAR ARMY who shall have fallen during the present
war, as follows :
Sufficient expanse of surface is required to receive inscrip-
tions of the name, rank, place of decease, etc., etc., of all
48 THE BATTLE MONUMENT
Officers of the Regular Army who shall have fallen during the
war, and a general tablet for the enlisted men.
In connection with the monument, should be embraced a plan
for a mausoleum, or place of interment, for the remains of such
officers as may be brought to West Point for burial.
Full drawings, with the usual details, must be made, accom-
panied by an estimate of the cost — this not to exceed $25,000.
A premium of $250 will be paid for the design which is
finally accepted.
It is desirable that designs be sent in as early as possible,
in order that they may be carefully considered before a selec-
tion is made.
Further particulars may be obtained by addressing the Secre-
tary at West Point, N. Y.
A. H. Bowman, Col. of Engrs., Chairman ,
H. B. Clitz, Lieut. -Col. and Comdt.,
W. A. Elderkin, First Lieut, ist Art.,
Committee on Design.
C. C. Parsons, First Lieut. 4th Art., Secretary.
During the period from October, 1864, until the
call of General Schofield of Sept. 9, 1878, the funds
of the Association had been gradually accumulat-
ing under the admirable management of the Trea-
surer, Professor Church. Upon his death a meeting
was called pursuant to the following circular :
U. S. Military Academy, West Point, N. Y.,
September 9, 1878.
All officers of the army on duty at West Point
are requested to attend a meeting at the Officers'
AT WEST POINT 49
Mess at 7.30 this evening to transact important
business appertaining to the Battle Monument Asso-
ciation.
A full attendance is respectfully desired.
J. M. Schofield,
Major-General and Superintendent.
This meeting of the officers of the Army on
duty at West Point was held in the Officers' Mess
at 7.30 P. M. Monday, the gth of September, 1878,
Major-General J. M. Schofield, Superintendent and
ex-officio President of the Battle Monument As-
sociation, in the chair.
The President stated the object of the meeting
to be to elect officers and fill vacancies upon the
Executive Committee occasioned by death and by
removal from the Post.
On motion the following officers were unani-
mously elected an Executive Committee in addi-
tion to
ist. Major-General J. M. Schofield, Superinten-
dent, President.
2d. Lieut.-Colonel Thos. H. Neill, 6th Cav-
alry, Commandant of Cadets \_Ex-qfficw
members], viz: —
3d. Professor Peter S. Michie.
4th. Professor George L. Andrews (^treasurer).
5th. Professor Junius B. Wheeler.
6th. Professor Charles W. Larned.
50 THE BATTLE MONUMENT
yth. Professor Edgar W. Bass.
8th. Professor Guido N. Lieber.
gth. Surgeon Charles T. Alexander,
loth. First Lieut. Eric Burgland, Corps of En-
gineers.
nth. Captain William M. Wherry, 6th Infan-
try, Secretary.
On motion Professor George L. Andrews was
unanimously elected Treasurer, and Colonel Wil-
liam M. Wherry, Secretary. On motion it was
Resolved^ That the Treasurer be directed to invest
the funds of the association in U. S. registered
bonds.
The Secretary was directed to furnish the "Army
and Navy Journal " with a transcript of the record
of these proceedings for publication.
On motion the meeting was adjourned.
J. M. Schofield, Major-General,
President.
Wm. M. Wherry, Bvt.-Colonel, U. S. A.,
Secretary.
******
The first attempt to open the question of erec-
tion was made in the meeting of Oct. 22, 1885,
called by General Merritt.
West Point, N. Y., Thursday, Oct. 22, 1885.
Proceedings of a meeting of the officers of the
army stationed at West Point, N. Y., pursuant to
AT WEST POINT 51
a call of the Superintendent, Col. W. Merritt, 5th
Regiment of Cavalry.
The meeting was called to order by Professor
Michie.
On motion of Prof. Michie, Gen. Merritt was
elected Chairman ; Lieut. G. B. Davis was appointed
Secretary by the Chair. At the request of the
Chairman, Professor Geo. L. Andrews, the Treas-
urer of the Battle Monument Association, made an
informal statement of the amount of the Monu-
ment fund. Lieut. W. C. Brown, Adjutant of the
Military Academy, announced that he had in his
possession the " Record of Proceedings of the Bat-
tle Monument Association." At the request of
the Chairman, the record was produced by Lieut.
Brown, and its contents were read by the Secretary.
The Chairman stated the purpose of the meet-
ing to be to take some steps looking to the increase
of the fund, and the erection of the Monument.
A motion that a committee of seven members
be selected by the Chairman to investigate and
report upon the question of erecting a monument
was withdrawn.
A motion that the Executive Committee be di-
rected to fill its vacancies, and report, was also
withdrawn.
The Superintendent announced that he would
call a meeting of the Executive Committee, at an
early day, for the purpose of filling its vacancies
52 THE BATTLE MONUMENT
and acting upon questions connected with the erec-
tion of the Monument.
On motion, the meeting then adjourned.
W. Merritt, Colonel 5th Cavalry,
Brevet Major-General, U. S. A.,
^ -o TA • President.
Geo. B. Davis,
Secretary.
Nothing, however, was done towards actual re-
alization of the project until the administration of
Col. John M. Wilson as superintendent of the
Academy. Deeming the time ripe for a move-
ment in the matter, he addressed the following to
the Treasurer of the Association :
Headquarters U. S. Military Academy,
West Point, N. Y., October 21, 1889.
General Geo. L. Andrews,
Treasurer Battle Monument Association.
Dear Sir :
Yours of the 2ist instant, expressing a desire to resign the
Treasurership of the Battle Monument Association is just
received.
Will you please send me the list of subscribers to the Monu-
ment, if in your possession ? If you have not the list, please
inform me where it can be found.
I will at once enter into correspondence with such of the
original subscribers as may be living and obtain their views as
to what they would prefer in the shape of a Monument.
For myself, I think it might be well to use the fund either
for the enlargement of the present Chapel, or the construction
AT WEST POINT 53
of a memorial hall in which would appear mural tablets giving
the names of the officers who lost their lives in the defense of
the Union.
As soon as I can get the views of those subscribers still living
I will call a meeting of the officers here.
In the meantime may I ask you, for the present, to continue
to hold the position of Treasurer which you have so acceptably
filled for the past ten years ?
Yours very truly,
JOHN M. WILSON, Colonel of Engineers,
Superintendent.
The following is the letter of General Andrews
referred to :
U. S. Military Academy, West Point, N. Y.,
Oct. 21, 1889.
Colonel John M. Wilson,
Superintendent U. S. Military Academy,
President of the Battle Monument Association.
Dear Sir :
Some time near the close of our Civil War, an association
was formed at West Point for the purpose of having a monu-
ment erected here to the Officers of the Regular Army who fell
in that war. The late Professor Church was elected Treasurer,
and subscriptions were invited and received. The formation
of the Association seems to have been somewhat loosely made ;
but on the decease of Professor Church in 1878, General Scho-
field, then Superintendent, as ex-officio President of the Asso-
ciation, called a meeting of the officers here stationed, who, it
seems, constitute the Association. At that meeting I was
elected Treasurer, and directed by vote of the members present
to invest the funds and income of the Association in U. S.
4A
54 THE BATTLE MONUMENT
Registered Bonds. Another meeting was called by General
Merritt when Superintendent to consider what should be done
in regard to the Monument, but no decisive action was taken.
The funds now in my hands as Treasurer are :
U. S. Currency 6 per cent. Bonds, par,
U. S. 4 per cent. Registered Bonds, par,
Total, .... $50,300
At the present market rate these Bonds would sell for about
$63,500.
t There were also donated by Act of Congress to Professor
Church, Treasurer of the " Battle Monument Committee," fifty
bronze cannon. These cannon were left stored at the New
York Arsenal, Governor's Island, having been, as I understood,
virtually delivered to Professor Church. However, more than
a year ago, I was informed that unless the cannon were removed
there was danger that they would be delivered to other parties.
I wrote to General Benet, and learned from him that a new
application for the cannon must be made, accompanied by evi-
dence of authority for the new Treasurer to receive the same.
I stated the case orally to General Parke, then Superintendent,
but he was disinclined to do anything about the matter, and
nothing further was done.
The foregoing statement is made agreeably to your oral re-
quest, and I would add that I wish to resign as soon as may be
the position of Treasurer of the Association which I now hold.
It is desirable that the new Treasurer be elected so that the trans-
fer of bonds may be made before the books are closed for this
quarter.
Respectfully yours,
GEO. L. ANDREWS,
Treasurer Battle Monument Association.
AT WEST POINT 55
The following are the guns above described by
Professor Andrews :
50 Cannon, Bronze, reserved at N. Y. Arsenal for Battle
Monument.
15 12-pounder Field Guns, heavy, . . . U. S. 26,607
1 12 " **•-«• u . Rebel trophy, i,375
1 6 24 " «• Howitzers . * .. . U. S. 20,891
2 24 " " " . Rebel trophies, 2,567
6 32 " " , " . . . . U. S. 11,457
5 24 " Boat Howitzers, .... " 6,502
212 " Rifled Guns, James, 3,180
212 " Field Guns, Light, Rebel trophies, 2,400
i 1 8 " Gun, Austrian, . " trophy, 2,514
Total, 77,493
The next step of Colonel Wilson was the issue
of this
CIRCULAR.
Headquarters U. S. Military Academy,
West Point, N. Y., October 29, 1889.
About a quarter of a century ago a number of officers and
enlisted men, together with a few citizens, subscribed for a
Battle Monument to be erected at West Point, in memory of
the officers and enlisted men of the Regular Army who fell in
the defense of the Union during the late war.
Of the seven or eight hundred officers who subscribed only
about one hundred and sixty still remain in the Army.
The fund now amounts to $50,300.00 in United States
Bonds, the value of which, if sold to-day, would be about
#63,000.00.
56 THE BATTLE MONUMENT
The Superintendent of the Military Academy finds himself,
ex officio, President of the Battle Monument Association.
It certainly seems as if action in this matter should no longer
be delayed, and that some use should be made of the fund before
all of the subscribers shall have passed away.
The Military Academy Chapel is too small, and its present
condition — for lack of means to improve it — is not creditable to
the Academy. A larger place of worship is needed, and also a hall
where important ceremonies can take place, similar to those in-
cident to the recent presentation of portraits.
The Superintendent suggests either the enlargement of the
present Chapel, and placing therein mural tablets in memory of
our fallen heroes, or the erection of a memorial hall with simi-
lar tablets on Trophy Point.
The views of all surviving subscribers upon the subject are
invited.
JOHN M. WILSON, Colonel of Engineers,
President Battle Monument Association.
Out of 60 responses to this Circular now on file
the expression of opinion regarding the character
of the memorial is as follows :
In favor of a Memorial Hall 25
" " " a Monument 16
" " " an Addition to Chapel . * . . 9
" a New Chapel 5
No choice 5
West Point, N. Y., January 16, 1890.
At this time the Executive Committee of the
Battle Monument consisted of the following
named officers:
AT WEST POINT 57
Col. John M. Wilson, Supt. M. A., ex officio,
President.
Lieut.-Col. H. S. Hawkins, Commandant of
Cadets, ex officio.
Prof. Geo. L. Andrews,
treasurer.
Prof. P. S. Michie, Prof. Chas. W. Lamed,
Prof. E. W. Bass, Prof. Wm. Winthrop,
Prof. James Mercur, Surg. H. R. Tilton,
Capt. Geo. McC. Derby, Lieut. Charles Braden.
And their sentiment being favorable, a meeting
was called to decide upon the question of imme-
diate action.
West Point, N. Y., January 22, 1890.
Colonel Wilson briefly stated the object of the
meeting and gave a short history of the Battle
Monument Association from its organization in
1863 to the present time.
Professor Geo. L. Andrews tendered his resigna-
tion as Treasurer of the Association and submitted
a statement of the condition of the fund.
Professor Andrews' resignation was accepted and
it was unanimously voted to extend the thanks of
the Association to Professor Andrews for his ser-
vices as Treasurer during the past twelve years.
58 THE BATTLE MONUMENT
Professor Edgar W. Bass was unanimously
elected Treasurer of the Association.
A letter from Major George B. Davis, the
former Secretary, was read, giving a brief account
of the object of the Association and facts relating
to the subscribers to the fund.
After remarks by several of the officers present,
the following resolution offered by Major Spurgin
was adopted :
Resolved, That the Executive Committee be
instructed to carry out the original intention of
the subscribers to the fund, or take such action
as they may deem expedient.
The following resolution was adopted :
Resolved^ That the Treasurer be requested to
correspond with the Chief of Ordnance and secure
as soon as possible the fifty bronze cannon men-
tioned in Professor Andrews' report, and which
are now stored at the Arsenal on Governor's
Island, N. Y.
The Chairman announced that he would call a
meeting of the Executive Committee at an early
day to act upon the business of erecting a suitable
monument.
AT WEST POINT 59
MEETING OF FEBRUARY 18, 1890.
The meeting called by Colonel Wilson for February 1 8th
marks the first Executive Act of the Association in
pursuance of its purpose. The Committee ap-
pointed at this meeting formulated a line
of action which was subsequently
adopted and resulted in the erec-
tion of the Battle Monument.
West Point, N. Y., February 18, 1890.
Pursuant to a call by Colonel J. M. Wilson,
President, issued February 17, 1890, the Execu-
tive Committee of the Battle Monument Asso-
ciation met at the Superintendent's quarters at
7.15P.M.
Present.
ColonelJohnM. Wilson, Prof. Jas. Mercur,
Lt.-Col. H. S. Hawkins, Prof. P. S. Michie,
Prof. G. L. Andrews, Prof. C. W. Larned,
Prof. E. W. Bass, Prof. Wm. Winthrop,
Surg. H. R. Tilton.
The Chair stated that the object of the meeting
was to take preliminary steps towards inviting
designs for the Battle Monument to be erected
at West Point, N. Y.
After informal discussion, on motion of Pro-
fessor Bass, a committee was appointed by the
Chair to consider and prepare a circular, or to
60 THE BATTLE MONUMENT
determine what other action might be preferable,
in order to invite designs for the monument; it
was understood that the members of this Com-
mittee would personally consult, upon their next
visit to New York, with distinguished sculptors,
etc., as to the best method of procedure in the
matter.
The Chair appointed as the Committee :
Prof. P. S. Michie, Prof. C. W. Larned,
Prof. E. W. Bass.
There being no further business before the
Committee, the meeting adjourned at 8.15 P. M.
John M. Wilson, Colonel of Engineers,
President of Association.
Charles Braden,
Secretary.
Subsequent to the foregoing meeting the fol-
lowing authorization was received from the Adju-
tant-General :
War Department,
Adjutant-General's Office,
Washington, February 2ist, 1890.
Sir:
Your communication of the zoth instant, concerning the
erection at West Point, by the Battle Monument Association,
of a Monument to the memory of the officers and enlisted
men of the Regular Army of the U. S. who were killed or
died of wounds received in action during the war of the rebel-
lion, has been laid before the Secretary of War, who instructs
AT WEST POINT 61
me to inform you that the Association is granted permission
to proceed with the work of erecting a monument on Trophy
Point.
Very respectfully,
J. C. KELTON,
Adjutant-General.
The Superintendent,
U. S. Military Academy,
West Point, N. Y.
The minutes of the next meeting give the re-
port of the sub-committee outlining a method of
procedure which governed future action.
West Point, N. Y., March 8, 1890.
Pursuant to the call of the President, the Exec-
utive Committee met at 7.30 P. M. to-day, in the
Superintendent's quarters.
Present all the members of the Committee, ex-
cept Surgeon Tilton and Captain Derby.
The minutes of the last meeting were read and
approved.
Surgeon Henry McElderry was elected a mem-
ber of the Executive Committee in place of Sur-
geon Tilton, relieved from* duty at West Point.
The Committee appointed at the meeting held
February 18 being called upon for a report, the
following was read by Professor Lamed :
Report of the Committee of the Battle Monu-
ment Association appointed to prepare a plan of
procedure.
6z THE BATTLE MONUMENT
Your Committee, after some consideration of
the matter intrusted to them, concluded to visit
New York and seek the advice of sculptors and
architects of established reputation. A consulta-
tion with Mr. Augustus St. Gaudens, the leading
sculptor of America, confirmed the Committee in
its opinion that the conditions governing the erec-
tion of this Monument, i. e., the number of indi-
viduals commemorated by it, the conspicuous na-
ture of the site, and the limited funds available, re-
quire that it should be mainly architectural in its
character, and that the sculptural features should be
subordinate or accessory. A single figure or group
of figures of life size would be, in such a place
and for such a purpose, inadequate, unless placed
upon a pediment or substructure of considerable
dimensions, which would also be necessitated by
the commemorative inscriptions. So placed, the
statuary would appear insignificant unless of heroic
size, in which case the cost would be largely
beyond the limit of our resources. An architec-
tural structure, however, of such dimensions as to
be dignified, and accord with the surroundings,
with sculptural accessories in the round or in re-
lief, and decorative tablets, can be erected within
the specified amount.
An examination of the results of many public
and general competitions shows that they rarely if
ever give satisfaction either to the competitors or
AT WEST POINT 63
their clients, and that the feeling is so strong
against them among architects of high reputation
that they generally decline to enter them. This
is due largely to the fact that they are forced to
bring their labor and reputations into competition
with those of inferior men, and to submit to the
judgment of incompetent critics. In a private
and selected competition properly conducted, these
objections can be avoided, to the great saving of
time and friction and with a great gain in the
standard of result. Your Committee, therefore,
conclude it wise to recommend the adoption of
the method of private and selected competition,
and to choose for such competition, with proper
advice, three or four of the architectural firms of
the country having the highest artistic reputation.
With these convictions your Committee visited
the office of Messrs. Babb, Cook and Willard, the
leading member of the firm having been most
highly indorsed by Mr. St. Gaudens as perhaps
the most talented of our architects, and laid be-
fore these gentlemen the commission intrusted to
it, with the request that they would advise as to
the course most likely to give the most satisfactory
results to all concerned. These gentlemen con-
sented to draw up, after sufficient time for consul-
tation, a memorandum embodying the more im-
portant features of such a competition, and to for-
ward it to your Committee. This they have done,
64 THE BATTLE MONUMENT
and upon this outline as a basis your Committee
has prepared the accompanying scheme for your
approval.
It, therefore, recommends for adoption the fol-
lowing resolution :
Resolved. 1st. That the Monument shall be
mainly architectural in character, with such sculp-
tural accessories as shall be deemed fitting and
appropriate by the designer.
2d. That it shall afford proper space for the
necessary inscriptions commemorative of its pur-
pose.
3d. That it shall be of sufficient height to
give dignity to its proportions, and to harmonize
with its surroundings ; but that its height shall not
be a feature of the design, as in the case of a large
column or shaft.
4th. That it be located \ipon Trophy Point,
upon a site to be selected by the Building Com-
mittee of this Association, of which the Superin-
tendent of the Military Academy and the success-
ful competitor shall be, for this purpose, members
ex officio.
5th. That the designer shall be chosen by pri-
vate selected competition.
6th. That for this purpose four of the architec-
tural firms of this country having high professional
reputation shall be invited to compete.
AT WEST POINT 65
yth. That a Building Committee be appointed
consisting of four members of the Executive Com-
mittee, which Building Committee shall be author-
ized to make all necessary arrangements for such
competition, to decide upon the merits of the de-
sign, and to supervise, with the Superintendent
of the Military Academy, its erection, the Super-
intendent becoming for this purpose, ex officio, a
member of the Committee, and its Chairman.
8th. That the Building Committee be author-
ized to draw upon the Treasurer of this Associ-
ation for all necessary funds, and to audit all
the accounts arising from the disbursements con-
nected with the work, and to take any and all
steps necessary to its completion.
gth. That, upon the completion of the Monu-
ment, the Building Committee — the Superinten-
dent being, ex officio, a member thereof — shall
arrange for proper dedication exercises and cere-
monies.
loth. That, upon the selection of the accepted
design, a meeting of the Association shall be called
and the drawings exhibited.
nth. That, upon dedication, the Monument
shall be presented to the Military Academy of the
United States, and shall upon acceptance be turned
over to the proper military authorities.
1 2th. That, upon the completion of these duties,
the Building Committee shall turn over to the
5
66 THE BATTLE MONUMENT
authorities of the Military Academy all vouchers
and papers relating to its functions and the action
of the Battle Monument Association for file with
the records of the Military Academy, and shall be
discharged from these functions.
13th. That the Superintendent be requested to
obtain from the authorities at Washington the
necessary names and data for inscription upon the
monument.
Peter S. Michie, Prof., U. S. M. A.
Chas. W. Larned, "
Edg. W. Bass,
Professor Larned, at the request of the Chairman
of the Committee, described the action of the Com-
mittee in its visit to New York, and after some
explanatory remarks and an informal discussion
submitted the following form for an invitation to
compete for the erection of the monument :
•
INVITATION TO COMPETE FOR A
MONUMENT TO BE ERECTED
AT WEST POINT, N. Y.
I.
This Monument is to commemorate the Officers and Soldiers
of the Regular Army killed in the War of the Rebellion. It is
to be erected upon the land of the Government reservation at
West Point, N. Y., the site being that portion of the plain in
OF THK
UNIVERSITY
AT WEST POINT 67
front of Cadet Barracks commonly known as Trophy Point ;
the exact spot to be hereafter designated.
II.
The general character of the design is to be architectural with
such sculptural accessories as the taste of the designer may
deem fitting and appropriate. It is to be of such proportions
as to provide for the display of bronze tablets sufficient in num-
ber and dimensions for the inscription of the names of
officers and the designation by number and regiment of
non-commissioned officers and privates.
The material is to be stone and bronze, the nature of the
stone being optional with the designer.
III.
The funds available for this construction, proper, are $50,-
ooo in cash. There are, also, at the disposal of the Asso-
ciation fifty (50) bronze cannon which may be employed in
any way deemed proper, presented for the purpose by the fol-
lowing Joint Resolution of Congress :
Joint Resolution (No. 37), approved April 28, 1870.
Resolved, &c., &c., &c., That the Secretary of War
is hereby authorized and directed to deliver to Pro-
fessor A. E. CHURCH, Treasurer of the Battle Monu-
ment Committee, fifty bronze guns captured from the
rebels, to be used in the construction of a monument
at West Point, New York, in memory of the officers
and soldiers of the regular army who fell in the late
war, and in the ornamentation of the grounds around
said monument. — 16 Stats, at Large, 373.
IV.
You are invited to submit to this Committee of the Battle
Monument Association at West Point a design for the above
68 THE BATTLE MONUMENT
described monument in competition with those of the following
named firms of architects :
on or before September I5th, 1890, under the following con-
ditions :
V.
CONDITIONS.
1st. The design to be shown in the following drawings :
1. A Perspective view in color or mono-tint, at your option,
on a sheet not smaller than 34x48 inches, in proper relative
proportion.
2. A Plan.
3. Elevation of the principal front to scale of \" to 4' in
line.
Should any of the other fronts possess special features of im-
portance, separate elevations in pencil to same scale showing
these features should be submitted with principal drawings.
Each drawing is to be marked with a motto or device, and
the whole sent in a sealed package, accompanied by a sealed
envelope containing name, and marked with device on out-
side, to the chairman of this Committee, Professor PETER S.
MICHIE, U. S. Military Academy, West Point, N. Y. A com-
plete description of the design with explanation of its material
and construction should accompany the drawings.
zd. For the purpose of selection only, the Committee will
associate with itself three gentlemen — sculptors or architects
— to be chosen from a list of names submitted by the com-
petitors themselves, each competitor submitting three, not more
than one to be taken from the list of any one firm. These as-
sociates for the purpose named shall each have a full vote, and
the result of the vote shall be decisive as to the selection or re-
jection of the designs submitted.
AT WEST POINT 69
3d. No designs other than those submitted by the firms
named in the list above given shall be admitted in this com-
petition, nor shall any designs from any source be considered by
the Committee until after the decision in this instance. After
the decision the rejected designs will be returned to their re-
spective owners, and no use in any way will be made of them
or any of their features unless by arrangement with and consent
of the owner.
The accepted design is to become the property of the Asso-
ciation, and the construction of the monument is to be in the
hands and under the direction of the successful competitor, who
shall be responsible for its proper and satisfactory completion
according to the terms of the detailed specifications and draw-
ings accepted.
It shall be the right of the Superintendent of the Military
Academy to appoint a competent officer who shall inspect the
work during its progress, and who shall have the power, by di-
rection of the Superintendent, to require a conformity in all
particulars with the requirements of the specifications. He
shall have the right, as above, to stop work at any stage of pro-
gress should he discover any failure on the part of contractors to
fulfil such requirements, until the architect can enforce them.
His function shall not be construed to interfere in any way with
the freedom of action of the architect, or of any person deputed
by him to represent him as supervisor or clerk of the work.
The sum of two hundred and fifty dollars ($250.00) will
be paid to each competitor as a compensation for time and labor
in the preparation of the designs submitted in competition, except
that the successful competitor shall receive the usual compensa-
tion of 5 per cent, upon the total cost of the monument, which
sum shall include cost of all drawings prepared by him.
Should the nature of the design involve special sculptural
features requiring separate and original designing by the archi-
tects, special arrangements for compensation will be made.
70 THE BATTLE MONUMENT
Sculptural designs not furnished by architect must be contracted
for by him, and paid out of the fund for general cost of monu-
ment as part of the regular expenses.
4th. The design must be carefully calculated to come within
the limits of the amount available for construction, as the cost
of the monument can in no case exceed fifty thousand dollars, ex-
clusive of the value of the bronze guns. To this end an esti-
mate of cost should accompany each design, and upon acceptance
a detailed estimate of cost must be submitted to this Committee.
Should any excess result in this detailed estimate, or in the bids
for construction, the design must be so modified as to come
within the required limits.
5th. The Committee reserve the right to reject all designs
under the conditions of payment and return, as specified above.
6th. For the purpose of definitely locating the site only, the
Superintendent of the Military Academy and the successful
competitor shall become ex-officio members of the Building
Committee, and for the purpose of superintending the con-
struction after selection, and the final arrangements for dedica-
tion, the Superintendent of the Military Academy becomes a
member of the Committee ex ofEcio, and its Chairman.
VI.
The Committee herein referred to consists of the following
named officers of the Military Academy :
Professor Peter S. Michie, Chairman.
Professor Charles W. Lamed.
Professor Edgar W. Bass, Treas. Battle Mon. Ass.
Professor James Mercur.
They are appointed by authority of the Executive Com-
mittee of the Battle Monument Association.
This Association has invested the Executive Committee
with full powers for the expenditure of the funds herein de-
AT WEST POINT 71
scribed, and for the determination of all matters pertaining to
the erection of this monument. It has delegated to this Com-
mittee authority for action in the premises as above described,
and all communications relative to the matter in hand will be
addressed to it through its Chairman, Professor Peter S. Michie.
An informal discussion took place, after which
the report of the Committee was accepted, and
the Committee discharged from further action.
The sections were discussed and considered in
detail. All were adopted as submitted, except
No. 3, which was amended to mean that the prin-
cipal view should be " as seen from the plain."
The following resolution was adopted :
Resolved. That the Superintendent be requested
to name a committee of four to take charge of
the building of the Monument, and that after the
Committee is appointed and vacancies occur, the
other members of the Committee be authorized
to fill said vacancies.
In pursuance of this resolution, the following
were appointed members of the Committee :
Professor Michie, Professor Larned, Professor Bass
and Professor Mercur.
It was moved and carried that the Committee
prepare and send a circular letter to competitors.
The following resolution was adopted :
72 THE BATTLE MONUMENT
That the Building Committee can change the
specifications as it thinks proper, keeping the gen-
eral idea of the Monument in view at all times.
After careful investigation and consultation the
following named firms of architects were selected
for the competition and a circular letter inclosing
a printed copy of the terms of competition was
addressed to them by the Secretary of the Build-
ing Committee : Babb, Cook & Willard, New
York City ; Carrere & Hastings, New York City ;
McKim, Mead & White, New York City ; and
R. W. Emerson, Boston, Mass. The circular letter
contained the following paragraphs:
The history of the action of which this proposed competi-
tion is the outcome is briefly as follows :
During the War of the Rebellion certain officers of the regu-
lar army stationed at West Point conceived the idea of com-
memorating their brother officers of the regular army killed
in that struggle by a monument erected there, and to that
end formed an association known as the Battle Monument
Association, with headquarters at the Military Academy.
Letters were sent out to all officers of the regular army in-
viting contributions in proportion to the rate of pay received.
The fund resulting was placed in the custody of the Treasurer
of the Association, invested in government bonds, and has in-
creased through accrued interest to its present size. Congress
was petitioned to further the project by appropriating a certain
number of bronze cannon, and acceded by placing at the dis-
posal of the Association fifty bronze guns captured from the
AT WEST POINT 73
rebels. It was proposed to make the monument commemora-
tive as well of the non-commissioned officers and privates,
which proposition was adopted with the proviso that the de-
scription should be by number and regiment only. The Ex-
ecutive Committee of the above described Association, in which
was invested plenary power both to act and to expend the
funds accrued, in turn has transferred its authority to a Building
Committee from which this circular emanates, and which pur-
poses to push the project to completion. This monument,
therefore, is distinctly commemorative of the officers, non-
commissioned officers and privates of the regular army of the
United States killed, or who died of wounds received in action,
during the War of the Rebellion.
In regard to the bronze guns available for use in the work,
the committee desires it to be understood that they are at the
disposition of the architect en masse, to be used to defray the
cost in a finished state of all bronze decorations used upon the
monument. In other words, the committee conceives it to be
a legitimate use of this material to employ it not only as mate-
rial, but to defray the cost of its own working and designing.
Should, however, the cost of working exceed the value of the
guns, the excess will be paid from the general fund. It will
follow therefore that the bronze decorations should be a con-
siderable feature of the design in order that all of the guns
shall be available for use. As these guns are in themselves
commemorative and historic, the committee suggests that a cer-
tain number of them — say ten or more — be retained intact
for direct decoration in the monument, or as accessories on the
plinth and stylobate, or in the grounds in the immediate neigh-
borhood.
The invitation to compete was identical with
the form adopted as given above, and, after formal
acceptance on the part of the firms addressed, their
74 THE BATTLE MONUMENT
members were invited to visit West Point as the
guests of the Building Committee to inspect the
site, and an exact location was determined on by
a general vote of the Committee and the competi-
tors. As the date of competition matured, a se-
lection of associates was made by the Building
Committee from the list of candidates nominated
by the competitors. These associates became, for
the purpose of choice, members of the Committee
with a full vote, and the action of this jury was
final. The names of these gentlemen, who at
once most courteously consented to serve, are R.
M. Hunt, President American Institute of Archi-
tects ; Augustus St. Gaudens ; Arthur Rotch.
On the date of competition they were invited, as
guests of the Building Committee, to visit West
Point, where the jury proceeded to examine the
drawings. After a long and careful study, a final
vote resulted in the selection of the design marked
" Monolith " — the motto of the firm of McKim,
Mead & White. The results of the competition
were very gratifying, and the merits of all the de-
signs so conspicuous as to render final decision a
matter of nice discrimination based upon many
considerations.
Messrs. McKim, Mead & White made the fol-
lowing statement regarding their design :
In preparing the design, we have most carefully considered
the object of the monument and the site which it is to occupy.
AT WEST POINT 75
We believe the monument should be first and foremost a
martial one, distinctive in its character and impressive in its de-
sign. The beauty of its site and the surroundings seems to us
to preclude any bulky or massive treatment, and to suggest rather
a treatment where the impression should be produced by height
supported by a base which should not interfere with graceful
and artistic treatment. For this reason we have adopted as the
feature of our design a single monolithic shaft treated in the
shape of a memorial column, or column of victory. This form
seems to us to be more distinctively martial than any other, and
in this form we believe it is possible to obtain impressiveness
and dignity without a sacrifice of grace, at the same time pre-
serving a distinctively architectural and monumental character.
We lay great stress upon these two points, viz. : the necessity
of giving the monument a martial character, and the relation of
the monument to its site. In our design we have had these two
points continually in mind, with results which you must judge.
The shaft is a monolith of polished granite forty-six feet high
and five feet six inches in diameter. To the best of our belief,
it would be the largest polished shaft in the world. It is proposed
to surmount it with a figure of Victory, and surround it by eagles
— a distinct mark of its national character. The shaft rests
upon a circular base, surrounded by flights of steps, giving the
greatest breadth and dignity possible to the base. The materials
are the most enduring — granite and bronze.
We have received an estimate from the most reliable firm
known to us upon this monument which comes within the
amount available. We submit with this statement a memo-
randum specification and copy of this bid.
Very respectfully,
" MONOLITH."
76 THE BATTLE MONUMENT
MEMORANDUM OF ESTIMATED COST OF
PROPOSED BATTLE MONUMENT.
Messrs. Norcross Bros.' estimate for granite work, $41,000.00
Our estimate for figure, 5,000.00
Our estimate for eagles, 4,000.00
$50,000.00
Value of bronze cannon to cover architects' fees
and contingencies 5,000.00
The designs of the other competing firms are shown in the
half-tone prints in this report.
The contract for the erection of the monument
was let to Messrs. Norcross Bros., of New York
City, and the sculptor for the figure of Fame sur-
mounting the shaft, selected by Messrs. McKim,
Mead & White and approved by the Building
Committee, was Mr. Frederick MacMonnies. The
architects desired to make some modifications in
the design, and were permitted to do so, the most
notable change from the accepted design being the
omission of the eagles surrounding the shaft.
Owing to various delays incident to changes and
modifications of details, the procuring and correc-
tion of the lists of names of officers and men, and
their casting in bronze tablets, the work progressed
somewhat slowly. Instead of the site dedicated by
General McClellan in 1864, a new site contiguous
to it was selected by the architect and Building
AT WEST POINT 77
Committee to the east of Trophy Point, and about
midway between it and the hotel.
This site is a very conspicuous one from the
river, and this consideration largely determined its
selection.
The quarrying, transportation and erection of so
large a mass as the monolithic shaft — probably the
largest polished monolith in the world — are mat-
ters of considerable difficulty, requiring very great
caution and considerable engineering skill; and
the details of the operations involved are fully de-
scribed in a separate section.
By the spring of 1894, the shaft was ready to
receive the figure of Fame, and accordingly it was
placed in position facing toward the Library Build-
ing. It was hoped that the monument would be
completed and in readiness for dedication by Octo-
ber of this year, and partial preparations for the
dedication ceremonies were made. In the mean-
while formal criticism of the figure of Fame, in-
volving its replacement, having been made by a
member of the Committee and acquiesced in by
the architect, it was decided that the figure must
be replaced. Ultimately the architect offered to
assume the entire expense of this change, and a
new figure was undertaken at once by Mr. Mac-
Monnies. As a necessary consequence, the dedi-
cation was postponed and May 31, 1895, selected
for the event. Before that time it became evident
78 THE BATTLE MONUMENT
that completion could not be hoped for until later,
and the matter was left for future decision. Great
difficulty was experienced in securing correctness
in the casting of the bronze tablets, and many
alterations were demanded before their completion
and location on the monument. The lists of
names had been carefully prepared in the office of
the Adjutant-General of the Army, and afterwards
were examined critically by both the Chairman of
the Committee and the Treasurer. The lists and
tablets were repeatedly checked after casting, and
everything done to insure accuracy in the record.
Early in May, 1896, the new figure was put in
place, but various modifications in the details of
the monument and the location of the bronzes
rendered it impossible to dedicate in June, as the
Committee had hoped to do. It was not until
March, 1897, that definite steps were taken to ar-
range for the final ceremonies and the date fixed
for May 3ist. It was decided to make the event
memorable, and, after careful consultation, a list of
those to whom invitations were to be extended
was prepared. This list is as follows :
The President of the United States ;
The Vice-President of the United States ;
Members of the Cabinet of the President of the United States ;
The Chief Justice of the Supreme Court ;
The Speaker of the House of Representatives ;
The General of the Army and all officers of the Regular Army;
Graduates of the United States Military Academy ;
Architects, Sculptor and Competing Architects ;
AT WEST POINT 79
Members of the Selection Committee;
Veterans of the Regular Army who served in the War of the
Rebellion ;
Families of Soldiers commemorated by Monument ;
The Commander of the Loyal Legion ;
The Commander of the Grand Army ;
The Superintendent and Officers of the Naval Academy ;
Heads of Bureaus of the Naval Department.
The invitation was the subject of much careful
consideration, and was printed from special type
originally cast in Philadelphia in the i8th century.
It consisted of four leaves on heavy rough paper
with uncut edges, tinted pale buff. On the first
or cover page was an artotype of the figure of
Fame; on the 3d page the invitation in black
and red ink ; on the 5th an artotype of the monu-
ment; on the yth the names of the Building Com-
mittee and Architects; on the 8th or rear cover
was printed the order of the exercises. A special
card entitling the holder to a seat was sent with
each invitation, the assignment being made upon
presentation of this card at the Auditorium.
The wording of the invitation was as follows,
the letters in italics being in red ink :
ist page.
The Dedication Ceremonies of the
Battle Monument at West Point,
[Figure of Fame.]
The thirty-first day of May,
MD CCC XC VII.
8o THE BATTLE MONUMENT
THE honor of your presence is
requested at West Point, New
York, on Monday, May the thirty-
first, eighteen hundred and ninety-
seven, at half after eleven o'clock,
at the dedication of the BATTLE
MONUMENT erected in memory
of the Officers and Men of the
Regular Army of the United States
who fell in battle during the War
of the Rebellion by their surviving
comrades.
In behalf of the Building Committee^
Charles W. Lamed, Professor
United States Military Academy ',
Secretary.
THE favor of an early reply is
earnestly requested.
•jtb page.
tfhe Building Committee.
Colonel Oswald H. Ernst, Corps
of Engineers, United States Army,
Superintendent of the United States
Military Academy, Chairman, ex
officio.
Professor Peter S. Michie, United
AT WEST POINT 81
States Military Academy, Brevet
Lieutenant-Colonel United States
Army.
Professor Charles W. Larned, United
States Military Academy ; Secretary.
Professor Edgar W. Bass, United
States Military Academy, Treasurer.
Colonel John M. Wilson, Corps of
Engineers, United States Army,
Superintendent of the Military Acad-
emy, Chairman Ex-officio from 1890
to 1893.
Professor James Mercur, United
States Military Academy, from
1890 to 1896, deceased.
Professor Albert E. Church, United
States Military Academy, Treasurer
from 1864 to 1878, deceased. *
Professor George L. Andrews, United
States Military Academy, from 1878
to 1890, resigned.
McKim, Mead and White, Architects,
Frederick W. MacMonnies, Sculptor.
8tt> page.
^fhe Order of the Exercises.
Music by the Band of the Military
Academy.
82 THE BATTLE MONUMENT
A Prayer by Reverend Herbert
Shipman,
Chaplain of the Military Academy.
Presentation to the United States
Army by Brigadier-General John
M. Wilson, Chief of Engineers,
United States Army.
Acceptance by Lieutenant-General
John M. Schofield, Retired, and
Presentation to the General Gov-
ernment.
Acceptance by the President of the
United States.
The National Salute.
The Star Spangled Banner by the
Band of the Military Academy.
Oration by the Honorable David J.
Brewer, Associate Justice of the
Supreme Court of the United States.
Handel's Largo by the Band of the
Military Academy.
Benediction by Reverend Herbert
Shipman, Chaplain of the Military
Academy.
DEDICATION CEREMONIES
AT
WEST POINT
DEDICATION CEREMONIES AT
WEST POINT.
CHE morning of the dedication opened wet
and threatening, with heavy cloud mists
and showers. By ten o'clock, however,
the sun broke through the clouds with a su-
perb effect of light and shade, and the ceremonies
took place without interruption, although the
threatening weather kept away a large number
of those who would otherwise have attended.
The President of the United States had delegated
his function in the ceremony to the Secretary of
War, who, together with Lieutenant-General J.
M. Schofield, formerly Commanding the Army;
Brigadier-General J. M. Wilson, Chief of Engi-
neers ; and Justice D. J. Brewer, of the Supreme
Court of the United States, had arrived on the
previous day. The Corps of Cadets were marched
under arms to the Auditorium and occupied seats
6A
86 THE BATTLE MONUMENT
in rear. The members of the distinguished party
who were to take part in the ceremonies were
escorted in carriages by the Superintendent and
members of the Academic Board to the rostrum,
which was occupied also by others of conspicuous
rank or service.
The circular grand stand, designed by the ar-
chitect to accommodate over a thousand specta-
tors, faced a raised rostrum, both covered by awn-
ings of red and white striped canvas decorated
with flags and trophies, the whole forming a very
brilliant and beautiful mass of color. The cere-
monies opened with prayer by the Chaplain of
the Military Academy and the regular order of
the programme was followed without change other
than that of the substitution by the President of
the United States, who was unable to be present,
of the Secretary of War as his representative.
OPENING PRAYERS.
I. The Lord's Prayer.
II. God of heaven and earth, who leddest our fathers forth,
making them go from one kingdom to another people ; we
yield Thee hearty thanks for all that Thou didst for them and
art doing for the land to which they came. We remember that
their communion was to eat their bread in exile, their sacrament
to shed their blood for others. And we give Thee thanks for
them. In particular, we remember here and now those of a
later day who spared not their lives that our land might be one ;
patriots of the newer time ; prophets and martyrs of our coun-
try's unity and peace. And for them we give Thee thanks.
And we pray that we may follow their good examples and be-
queath to those that come after a nation worthy of its founders,
and preservers, a nation fitted and glad to do Thy will, a na-
tion subject alone to Thee and to Thy Christ. May the mem-
ory of those who offered up their lives for principle, for unity
in which alone peace could be, lift and draw the coming gen-
erations upward and forward to see and seek that true and perfect
peace which Thou wiliest for all the sons of men. May we feel
and heed the silent yet solemn protest, rising from the graves of
those who died for their country's honor and integrity, against
all that is untrue, unworthy of the high and holy destiny we
believe Thou hast set before this nation.
May we, like them, placing before the love of self, the love f
of others ; before the love of earthly gain and life itself, the love
of truth and righteousness ; bring nearer that day, for which Thy
Son's last earthly prayer went up, when all Thy children shall
be one in love. We ask this in Thy Name, O Heavenly
Father; in Thine, O blessed Son, who art the Prince of Peace; in
Thine, O Holy Spirit, who guidest the hearts and minds of men
in the way of light and truth; in thine, O One Eternal God, to
whom be dominion, power and glory, now and forever. Amen.
87
ADDRESS OF
GENERAL WILSON.
^L TH^R- Chairman, Ladies and Gentlemen :
I^XI That hero, statesman, and martyr, Abraham
T ^L Lincoln, in his grand inaugural, expressed the ex-
j quisite sentiment that, "The mystic chords of
memory, stretching from every battle-field and patriot's grave
to every living heart and hearthstone all over this broad land,
will yet swell the chorus of the Union, when touched, as they
surely will be, by the better angels of our nature."
May I not borrow this glowing language to-day and say
that the mystic chords of memory, stretching from the Maine
mosaic block of the Union to the coral reefs of Florida, from
the orange groves of Louisiana to the ice palaces of Minnesota,
from the vine-clad hills of Southern California to the majestic
forests of Puget Sound, are joined in one grand electric circuit
within which, at every hearthstone from which a soldier de-
parted to fill a patriot's grave, hearts are throbbing and pulses
tingling at the thought that to-day, upon this historic spot, will
be dedicated a monument erected in memory of the heroes of
the regular army who gave up their lives in the defense of the
honor of the nation and the perpetuity of the Union.
89
90 THE BATTLE MONUMENT
More than a third of a century ago, a few noble and gallant
officers, who had been sent to duty at this post, some of whom
were slowly recovering from wounds received in action, and
others who were convalescing from the fearful fevers contracted
in the Chickahominy swamps, conceived the idea of erecting,
at West Point, a monument to the memory of the officers and
enlisted men of the regular army who had fallen in the terri-
ble conflict then in progress, and to others who might give up
their lives in the cause of the nation.
At the suggestion of that splendid soldier, that courteous
and accomplished gentleman, that much loved comrade, Col.
Henry C. Hasbrouck, of the 4th Artillery, then a young
lieutenant of artillery, a meeting of the officers was called, an
Executive Committee constituted, and circulars sent to the
commanding generals of the army and to others, outlining
the object in view and soliciting cooperation.
The replies surpassed the most ardent anticipations, and the
committee, realizing that it could act in the name of the army,
prepared and distributed to their comrades in the field and else-
where circulars inviting subscriptions.
The beloved and lamented Professor A. E. Church was ap-
pointed treasurer, and during the year 1864 over $14,000
was received, the grand total eventually reaching, by 1871, the
sum of $14,856.54, after which no further subscriptions were
received.
This amount was subscribed by 670 officers, 790 enlisted
men and civilian employees representing all branches of the
regular service and the 'civil employees of the Quartermaster's
Department at New Orleans.
Among the subscribers were Generals Grant, Sheridan,
Meade, Thomas, Buell, Foster, Franklin, French, Gillmore,
Heintzelman, Hitchcock, Hooker, Howard, Keyes, McCook,
McDowell, Parke, Pope, Reynolds, Rosecrans, Sedgwick,
Slocum, Steele, Sykes, Warren, Webb, and Wright.
AT WEST POINT 91
A site was selected and dedicated for the monument on June
15,1 8t>4, the oration having been delivered by that distin-
guished soldier, the late Major-Gen. Geo. B. McClellan.
For some reason not fully understood by us, the matter lan-
guished, the actual construction of the monument was post-
poned, and the meetings of the Executive Committee became
exceedingly rare, only four or five having been recorded be-
tween October, 1 864, and January, 1 890.
In the meantime the grand old treasurer had not buried the
talent committed to his charge, but by skilful management the
fund had been so invested that upon his death in 1878 it had
been increased to about $32,000.
Professor Church was succeeded by Professor Geo. L. An-
drews, of the U. S. Military Academy, a distinguished officer
of the army during the war, who was equally successful in his
stewardship ; and when he resigned his treasurership early in
1890, he transferred to his successor, our beloved friend Col.
E. W. Bass, the eminent professor of mathematics, bonds
whose market value at the time was over $60,000.
Early in the year 1 890 the subject was again brought for-
ward, and the officers then at the Military Academy, some of
whom had not yet seen the light of day when the great conflict
was initiated, took up the matter with such enthusiasm that it
was finally consummated, and the result is before you.
In addition to the available funds, fifty bronze cannon cap-
tured during the war were presented by the War Department,
some of which have been placed around the monument, and
others used to -provide for bronze tablets and ornaments.
A new Executive Committee, consisting of several of the
eminent professors of the Academy, was constituted, and this
committee, after consultation with distinguished artists, sculptors,
and architects in New York, in order to obtain the highest or-
der of art, decided to invite designs from four firms of exalted
reputation.
92 THE BATTLE MONUMENT
The parties invited, and who promptly and courteously ac-
cepted the invitation, were :
Messrs. McKim, Mead and White,
Messrs. Babb, Cook and Willard,
Messrs. Carrere and Hastings, and
Mr. W. R. Emerson.
The results exceeded the highest anticipations of the com-
mittee, and the superb designs presented reflected the greatest
credit upon the distinguished gentlemen who had competed for
the prize.
The Executive Committee, still anxious to make no mistake
and to do no injustice, called to its aid, in selecting the design
to be accepted, Messrs. Richard M. Hunt, Augustus St.
Gaudens, and Arthur Roache, men whose reputations in their
profession were second to none others in our broad land.
After most critical examination, and upon the advice of these
eminent experts, the design of Messrs. McKim, Mead and
White was adopted, the modeling of the figure of Fame which
crowns the shaft being intrusted to Mr. Frederick MacMonnies,
and the construction of the monument to the Messrs. Norcross
Brothers, of Worcester, Mass.
The marvelous creation of these artists, with its exquisite
lines, its symmetry and beauty, is before you, and no words
that I can utter can do it justice.
It bears upon it the names of 188 officers and 2042 enlisted
men ; and, through the courtesy of the War Department at
Washington, it is believed that the name of evtry officer and
of every enlisted man of the regular army who was killed in
action or died of wounds received in action during the great
war of 1861-65 ls P^ced in enduring bronze, so that the
youths of our land, who are here serving their squirehood in
their country's services, may have before them, as an everlast-
ing example, a list of heroes who laid down their lives in the
cause of the nation.
AT WEST POINT 93
Every arm of the service, and every regiment in the service,
save one which was not in the field but kept on other impor-
tant duty during the war, is represented by the names of some
of its heroes upon the monument.
Lieutenant- General Schofield, it is meet and right that
to-day, through you, one of its most distinguished heroes, this
monument should be transferred to the Army of the United
States.
To you, our former and beloved commander — to you, the
ideal soldier, the heroic commander of many a well-fought
and victorious field, the soldier sans peur et sans reprocbe, alike
at home in the din of battle or the councils of the nation,
whose brilliant stars were won in a baptism of fire, — it is my
duty, my pleasure, and my pride, in the name of the Building
Committee, to transfer this wonderful work of the genius of
man.
The polished granite sphere which surmounts the beautiful
shaft is symbolic of the well-rounded lives of the heroes who
have been called before the Great White Throne, and I be-
lieve that he who lays down his life in the defense of his coun-
try's honor is received by the King of kings with those joyous
words : "Well done, thou good and faithful servant : thou hast
been faithful over a few things, I will make thee ruler over
many things : enter thou into the joy of thy Lord."
Capping the whole of this grand work is MacMonnies' ideal
creation of Fame ; and while we admire its wondrous beauty, as
it holds forth the chaplet of victory for these heroes, there
come to our mind those glowing words of O'Hara :
" On Fame's eternal camping-ground
Their silent tents are spread,
And Glory guards with solemn round
The bivouac of the dead."
ADDRESS OF
GENERAL SCHOFIELD.
CHE purest patriotism is that which inspires the simple
soldier, who, of his own choice, offers his services
and his life to execute the orders of the Commander-
in-Chief. He looks to the head of the nation alone
for the national will. The President's policy is his policy,
the President's orders his only rule of action. He eliminates
self absolutely from his motives, and learns to be content with
hunger, privation, hardship, wounds, and death in the effort to
execute the orders of the Commander-in- Chief. He is not
only willing to die for his country, but he accepts without
question or doubt the choice made by his countrymen of the
leader whose orders he is to obey and whose policy he is to
accept as the will of the nation. This is the purest example
of patriotic devotion of which man is capable, and that which
the true soldier most highly honors.
It is the just and proud boast of the armies of the United
States that this has always been their standard of patriotic
duty, and in this the difference between the regular and volun-
teer exists only in name. The one, no less than the other,
is a volunteer soldier, and the other, hardly less than the first,
95
96 THE BATTLE MONUMENT
soon becomes, under the discipline of war, a regular soldier.
The sublimest fact in American history is the perfect disci-
pline, patient endurance, undoubting confidence of final tri-
umph even in the midst of temporary defeat, and heroic
valor shown by our soldiers during four years of war. They
knew little and cared less about the dissensions among poli-
ticians over questions of public policy, or the troubles of finan-
ciers over the state of the treasury. They fought bravely on
as they were led, with no thought but the triumph of the
Union cause as the end of their soldierly duty.
In all this soldierly devotion there was little room for dif-
ference of rank. Only a very few of the highest commanders
were at liberty to indulge in other thoughts. With such few
exceptions, soldiers of all grades, from the private in the ranks
to the general in command of a division or army corps, were
governed by the same devotion, obedience, faith, and courage.
These are the patriotic qualities which soldiers honor in
their comrades, and especially in those who have given their
lives in the country's service. As the States of the Union,
and the regiments which they sent to the field, and the vari-
ous corps of the great Union army have erected fitting monu-
ments in honor of their heroic dead, so the little body of
regulars contributed during the war a generous fund for the
purpose of erecting here, on this historic spot, a monument to
their fallen comrades. That work was delayed, if my memory
is not at fault, in order that the increase due to judicious in-
vestment might in no very long time enable the trustees to
erect a monument much more appropriate to the purpose and
the place than could at first have been done.
The wisdom and fidelity with which this sacred trust has
been discharged is fully attested by the beautiful and noble
work of art now presented to us. In the name of the army, I
thank all who have taken part in this noble work for the fidel-
ity with which they have discharged the trust reposed in them.
AT WEST POINT 97
And in behalf of the army I accept from the Building Com-
mittee this Battle Monument, as a worthy token of our re-
spect and reverence for the memories of our comrades who
gave their lives to preserve the national Union.
Let every young soldier who shall here follow in the foot-
steps of these heroes be inspired, as he looks upon this monu-
ment, by a noble ambition to so master the art of war that he
shall neither live nor die in vain, and so fit himself for his
patriotic duty that in his life, as in his death, he shall be an
honor to his country.
To you, Mr. Secretary, comrade in battle of the brave men
whose names are engraved hereon, I now present this monu-
ment, in memory of our fallen heroes, and place it, through
you, in the custody of the National Government. Let it and
the ground on which it stands be held sacred forever.
ADDRESS OF
THE SECRETARY OF WAR.
GENERAL SCHOFIELD: By command of the Pres-
ident, in whose name I appear to-day, I accept for
the Government of the United States this beautiful
monument erected to her honored dead. It will stand a
lasting memento to those men who gave their lives to save this na-
tion from destruction when the question of its existence was given
over to the arbitrament of arms. This is the fittest spot in the
land for its abiding-place. Here is the soldier school of the repub-
lic, famed for the classic beauty of its surroundings, and sanctified
by its association with the names of men whose genius and valor
in defense of the government which educated them to the profes-
sion of arms, and whose loyalty to the flag which here in their
early manhood they were taught to love, have brought imper-
ishable renown to the country of their devotion. This, too,
is the fittest day of all the year for its unveiling and dedication,
for it is the day set apart by the people and by the law for
popular tribute to those who on land and sea offered their lives a
willing sacrifice upon the altar of loyalty and liberty. It is
pleasant to remember, as we gaze for the first time upon this
graceful shaft, that every Union soldier* s grave within reach of
99
ioo THE BATTLE MONUMENT
our people has been strewn by loving hands with beautiful
flowers, and it is sweet to fancy that the graves unmarked and
unknown, scattered throughout the land wherever soldiers fought
and died, are not left unadorned by the kindly hand of nature.
It will be ever gladly borne in mind that this monument
does not simply commemorate the names and fame of those who
wore the insignia of rank. It rescues and brings out into the
light, to share in that way the fame of their commanders, names
little known nor much remembered, save in the small circle of
home and loved ones. It was quite characteristic of the chiv-
alrous men who planned this memorial to take thought of the hum-
ble, but equally devoted and daring, men who followed where
they led, and who equally with them, without the spur of ambi-
tion or the hope of fame, gave their lives in the line of duty. Had
they forgotten, which they" could not, the rank and file, without
whose discipline, fidelity and bravery there is no fame for a
commander, they would have been less the ideal soldiers that
they were and less worthy of remembrance, for the true soldier
and officer never forgets what he owes to the men he commands.
It is altogether well and worthy that these names of en-
listed men are borne upon this monument in one grand muster
roll with those of their commanders. Could this shaft, now
towering above us, have been builded as high as the deeds of
the men in whose memory it is erected deserve, its capstone,
indeed, would be lost beyond the skies.
In the history of all nations that which has made them
great in prosperity and in strength has been achieved in war,
and the brightest of its pages are illumined by the deeds of
knightly men in the field. It can truthfully be said that greater
disaster can come to a nation than war, for life without honor
is not worth the living, and the short span that is given to man,
even at its greatest length, is nothing as compared to the sus-
taining of the dignity and strength of the nation and the keeping
alive that patriotism which is so essential to its existence.
AT WEST POINT 101
Many men have seen war in its terrible aspect, but to none
is it given to describe it. War should be but for defense, else
Providence were seemingly but the plaything for men's passions.
Even to-day the greatest nations of the earth must see its hor-
rors in both hemispheres, regretful that such struggles must come,
hopeful that from the conflict may spring a lasting peace. From
all people has come the reverence of the most heroic deed that
can be performed by mortal man — death in the defense of
country, home and faith. Greater far than the glory which
crowns the victor, more sublime than tongue can picture him,
lies in the dust at the feet of armies, the soldier who served
without hope of reward or glory, and fell to be buried and
named "Unknown."
Now a word to you young men gathered here to-day, whose
profession is war. The spotless integrity of the men who
have graduated at this great academy in their official and daily
lives is a guide for you, and wherever you may be called,
whether in time of peace or armed conflict, remember that you
are marked men — the successors of those whose names must
live immortal when succeeding generations shall have passed
away. Should I name these men the pulse would quicken, and
the glory of the old flag they defended would brighten in your
thoughts, but you have their example for your beacon light.
Go forward then, in life, young men, knowing that you have
the prayers and hopes of seventy millions of people with you,
and remember that over you floats the proudest flag in the world,
that which symbolizes freedom, civilization, Christianity. That
flag, glorious in its purity, has never been unfurled in front of
any foe but to prevail, nor will it in the time that is to come.
That flag shall guard the life of every American in every land
and at whatever cost.
Guard well then your heritage, and keep ever before you
the thought that patriotism is the highest impulse in the world,
that the good that men do always lives, and he who is never
7A
102 THE BATTLE MONUMENT
swerved by temptation, but stands for the right, wears the
crown of American manhood.
It is the fond hope of the best minds of every land that
the time may come — and that in the near future — when
armed force in the field shall no longer be required, when all
differences between nations shall be settled by the benign in-
fluences of man's best judgment, and that arbitration shall be
substituted for artillery, musketry and the saber. But while
man is mortal perhaps the hope that this consummation so de-
voutly wished may become the rule of the world, cannot be
realized, and it is therefore incumbent upon every prudent
people to at all times be prepared for any emergency, so that if
war should come they would be in readiness.
May we then hope, the soldier equally with the civilian,
that the day will come when with one accord the great nations
of the earth shall say : " Let the bugler sound the truce of God
to the world forever." God speed the coming of that day !
In no human heart will that prayer be stronger than in the
heart of the true soldier. Remember that "peace hath her vic-
tories no less renowned than war," and that the country has
use for chivalrous soldiers in peace as well as war.
ADDRESS OF
JUSTICE BREWER.
IT is one of the paradoxes of life that that which to
eye and touch seems solid and enduring will assuredly
crumble and disappear, while that which the eye and
touch cannot reach is alone immortal. There is no
work of man wrought on canvas, in marble or bronze, lifted
in column or cathedral, but soon or late yields up its form and
beauty as time's unceasing pendulum is swung by Him with
whom a thousand years are as one day, and one day as a thou-
sand years. While on the other hand those viewless, intan-
gible things, born of the brain and soul, lofty thoughts and
heroic purposes, live on and on with all the dewy freshness
of unfading youth. " The beings of the mind are not of clay ;
essentially immortal."
Phidias and Praxiteles chiseled their dreams of beauty into
the solid marble, singing as they wrought,
"For art can grant what love denies,
And fix the fugitive ; "
only broken statues and wretched fragments remain to tell of
their forgotten dreams. But the marvelous philosophy of
103
io4 THE BATTLE MONUMENT
Plato, the lofty thought of Socrates, the logic of Aristotle, and
the epic grandeur of Homer, are as young and inspiring to-
day as when first syllabled beneath the groves of the Academy,
or chanted through the hamlets of Greece. Nineteen centuries
ago the temple of Jerusalem, forty and six years in building,
crowned the summit of Mount Moriah as the great achieve-
ment of Jewish art, the pride and wonder of the nation. Its
ruins are scarcely discoverable, while the loving words of
the humble Galilean, spoken beneath the shadow of its glory,
are the ever-living comfort and solace of unnumbered millions.
The massive Pyramids still stand, and the huge Sphinx still
tosses in the face the unsolved riddle of its being, but the
broken angles and loosened stones of the former and the bat-
tered face of the latter attest their subjection to the crumbling
touch of time. Indeed, this whole earth is one mighty sepul-
cher within which are entombed in hopeless confusion all the
beauty and splendor that past generations were able to put into
forms of matter, while the only things that preserve the fresh-
ness of youth and pass on from age to age with all the vigor
and bloom of immortality, are those intangible and viewless
things, ideas, feelings — the children of the human soul.
Is the work of the painter, the sculptor and the architect
then in vain ? Is it idle to paint forms of beauty on the can-
vas, to chisel them in marble or bronze ? Is it a waste of
time and labor to lift the columned glory or to put the symme-
try and grace of architecture into capitol and cathedral ? Is it
wrong or foolish to challenge the inexorable law of material
decay, to place before the eye the visible beauty which we
know must one day disappear ? Not so ; certainly not, if that
thing of matter both carries with it the sweet influences of
beauty, and also is eloquent of ideas and purposes which are
an inspiration to humanity and will continue so to be long
after that which represents them has passed away. While it
endures, it incarnates the thought. It is the visible expression
AT WEST POINT 105
of the idea which is itself immortal. And so, as long as it en-
dures,vit carries a message to every human soul, and as a carrier of
such message deserves the time and labor and money put into it.
We stand to-day in the presence of a stately column, erected
by the soldiers and officers of the regular army of the United
States, to commemorate the heroism and sacrifice of those of
their number who during the civil war gave their lives for
their country and in order that " liberty and union might re-
main now and forever one and inseparable." We are here
not simply to speak our praises of its beauty, but more to bow
in reverence before the ideas and the ideals which have found
material expression in that beauty, and which we believe will
be the inspiration not only of this great land but of humanity
the world over, long after the column shall have fallen and
crumbled into dust. We come, not so much to eulogize it as
a work of art, but rather to attest the great fact that brought
it into being, and to take a solemn oath in the presence of high
heaven that that fact shall never pass from the remembrance
of man.
And now what are the ideas and ideals which this column
expresses ? What are the lessons which, as it stands in solitary
grandeur beside the flowing waters of this majestic stream, it
teaches to us, and will teach to those who come after us ?
What is it that this witness, eloquent though mute, says to us,
and will say to the generations yet to come ? Of the many
voices which it bears I have only time to notice two. I know
it speaks of heroic achievements. I know it voices the glori-
ous and immortal thought, dulce et decorum est pro patria mori.
I know it is eloquent with the suffering and self-denial and
sacrifice which the great war developed and ennobled. But
beyond all that, it bears two voices, which I fain would catch
in the words of my talk, and speak to every citizen of the
United States.
And first it voices the immeasurable value of law and peace.
io6 THE BATTLE MONUMENT
It says to us that they whose names are written on its face gave
up their lives not merely for military glory, but also that war
should cease, and peace with all its blessings prevail ; that every
citizen might find the doors of the court-house open for the
punishment of wrong and the enforcement of right ; that the
humblest might stand side by side with the highest, placing in
the ballot-box his equal vote in the settlement of all questions
of public policy. They died that a government created by all
should not be destroyed by a part, and that, as all once volun-
tarily consented to its establishment, only in like manner should
any change be made in its provisions or any territory released
from its dominion. They read in the Constitution the solemn
declaration that it and the laws of the United States made in
pursuance thereof " shall be the supreme law of the land,"
and they gave their lives to make that declaration good. It is
fitting that in the dedication of this monument there should be
heard the voice of a member of the Supreme Court of the
United States, the court which the Constitution provided as
the ultimate judicial tribunal for the settlement of questions of
private right and public law ; for, through the sacrifice and he-
roism of these illustrious dead it continues still the supreme
court for South Carolina and Texas as for New York and
Kansas. These men died that law might live, that the will of
the people incarnated in constitution and statutes should be
obeyed by every one, and that all questions of policy, all dis-
putes as to rights of property, or obligations of contracts,
should be settled peaceably in the courts or at the ballot-box.
They marched beneath the Stars and Stripes not merely that
no star should be dimmed, not merely that its folds might
float on the shores of the Gulf of Mexico as well as by the
great lakes, but also that so floating triumphantly it should
speak to every child of America the comforting words of as-
sured peace and law. On its folds may there ever be seen the
words of General Grant, " Let us have peace."
AT WEST POINT 107
t
Is this voice worth listening to ? In the shadow of the sa-
cred memories which gather around the names of these heroic
dead, in the presence of these veterans who yet live to tell the
stories of the great war, and in the presence of these eager and
enthusiastic youth who are here studying that they may learn
all the possibilities of military science, and, whenever duty
shall call, win on the battle-field the victor's laurels, — in all this
presence I affirm that the greatest meed of praise which can be
bestowed upon the army of the United States is, that it makes
certain to every citizen the blessings of peace and order and
law. Doubtless, young gentlemen, as you look over the bright
fields of the future, you see dazzling before you visions of
military glory ; " the pride, pomp and circumstance of glori-
ous war " are there, and the eagle and the stars wait tt> rest on
your shoulders ; but when the evening of life shall come you
will realize that the highest praise which can be awarded to
you is that in your military lives you have been the defenders
of law and the guardians of peace ; that you have stood behind
the multitudinous business activities of this mighty people, and
thundered in the ears of all the irresistible declaration that
those activities should go on undisturbed by rebel or mob ;
that you have been beside the marvelous postal machine which,
like a thing of life, reaches its myriad fingers into every city
and village and neighborhood, gathering and distributing the
sweet messages of love and the rich words 'of trade; beside the
swift-rolling wheels which bear into and through every State
the mighty volume of our internal commerce, and bade no
man dare to stay the free movement of fingers or wheels ; that
while the representatives of the people have gathered in the
halls of Congress to legislate, the judges have sat on the bench
to adjust private rights and public wrongs, and the President
has taken his place in the White House to execute the laws
and enforce the judgments, you have stood back of legislator
and judge and President, and been the unfailing guarantor that
io8 THE BATTLE MONUMENT
in peace they shall act, and that by every citizen their acts
shall be respected and obeyed.
There is no true American who does not look with honest
pride on the army of the United States, who does not feel his
heart thrill with exultation as he repeats the names of its illus-
trious leaders ; there is no true American who would withhold
aught that will help to make that army in the future as in the
past, though small in numbers, most efficient and potent ; there
is no true American who depreciates its achievements, or sneers
at its usefulness ; and yet, while all this is true, every one sees
in the organized and disciplined and educated force that which
means not war, but peace ; that which means not alone military
glory, but also the securing to every city and village and home
in the la*nd the priceless blessings of law and order. And to-
day this column lifts its stately height in the presence of the
American people, proclaiming to all, in a voice which fills the
land and will fill the centuries, that these men died that law
might live and peace prevail.
The other voice which comes from this silently eloquent
witness is that these men died in order that there might be pre-
served in our borders equal opportunities for all. Ours is the
land of the free. Here is government of and by and for the
people. We know no rank. Birth brings no title. Before
each individual is opened every door, and to him who wills and
strives there is no place of influence or power which does not
hold out the equal invitation. The doors of this institution
are not opened to only the children of a privileged class. From
the poorest cabin and the richest home, from the lonesome
prairie and the crowded city, from the ranks of the humblest
toilers and the counting-houses of the richest merchants, from
farm and factory and shop and office you come, and come on
equal terms, with equal opportunities before you, and to take
in after life not the glory which your fathers give you, but that
which you yourselves are able to win. From a humble farm-
AT WEST POINT 109
house in Ohio, through the gateways of this school, passed a
modest, resolute young man, to become the great commander ;
the present General of the Army commenced life as a mere
clerk ; and a private soldier is now the President of the United
States.
And the end is not yet. That which was so yesterday is so
to-day, and will be so to-morrow. The barefoot boy may thank
God and take courage, for beneath the Stars and Stripes the
future is his. "Whosoever will" not only expresses the as-
surances of the Gospel, but is also the law of American life and
success. It must be remembered, however, that there is a
world-wide difference between " whosoever will " and "who-
soever simply wishes." The one implies a resolute and un-
failing purpose controlling all activities, while the other carries
with it nothing but lazy desire. The one is the assurance of
success, the other deserves the failure which it receives. Of
the thousand men in our land who succeed, luck may be the ac-
cident of one, but the other nine hundred and ninety-nine toil
for and win it. No one can sit on a dry-goods box and whit-
tle himself into wealth, or stand on the street corner and talk
himself into learning, position or power. Before every one is
the open door of opportunity ; "whosoever will " may enter.
And this fact of equal opportunity and equal right has been
strengthened and made more far-reaching through the devotion
of those whose names are written on this column. They died
not in defense of a princely class, not to perpetuate an aristoc-
racy of wealth or birth, but rather to lift a race into the large
domain of equal rights and equal opportunities. They heard
the sad, pathetic voice of him who walked from the lonesome
home of poverty and ignorance through the untiring strength
of his own earnestness and ability to the chief magistracy of the
nation and a place among the immortals of earth ; and, heeding
that voice, they died in order that this government of and by
and for the people should not perish from the face of the earth,
i io THE BATTLE MONUMENT
but should continue with a more complete and glorious affirm-
ance of equal rights and equal opportunities for all.
And I want here to say that this doctrine of equal rights and
equal opportunities which has always been the theory of our
political and social institutions is, notwithstanding some idle
talk, still, as ever, the significant fact of our life. The great
accumulations of money are not in the hands of those who in-
herited, but of those who themselves accumulated it ; and when
I read, as I often do, the denunciations in certain quarters of
inordinate wealth, I find almost without an exception that the
names connected with that wealth are the names of men who
started in life without a dollar. Who are the leaders of our
thought to-day ? Who are the great men in intellectual life ? Who
are the inventors and authors, the orators and poets ? Who are
they that give direction and guidance to the thought and busi-
ness and high ambition of the nation ? Did they come from any
class ? Were they born into station ? Did they come from some
privileged rank ? On the contrary, as you run over the list of
names, you will find that no rank, or class, or place monopo-
lized their beginnings. Their power and influence is some-
thing which they themselves have won, and not something
which they inherited. The humblest child may look upon
the White House with expectation. The poorest and most
friendless student may begin with faith and hope his struggle
for a seat on the highest bench of the nation. A place in the
halls of Congress is not a thing of purchase or inheritance,
and the few exceptions which occur only attest the fact as well
as the strength and vigor of the rule. This is to-day, and God
grant that it may ever remain, a land of equal rights and equal
opportunities, not an equality of life and living which is com-
pelled, for wherever there is such compulsion there is slavery,
whether the master be a single despot or a mob, but the equal-
ity of the Declaration of Independence, the equal possession of
" certain unalienable rights . . . life, liberty, and the pur-
AT WEST POINT in
suit of happiness" ; the right of each individual to choose for
himself his life and work and to pursue that life and work sub-
ject to no dominion, and realizing all the success that the in-
tensity of his life and work deserve.
It is fitting that this memorial to the officers and soldiers of
the regular army who died in the recent war should be here,
for this is the military center of the nation, the great school of
those who are to be the officers and commanders ; and it is
well that the lessons of those patriotic and heroic lives should
ever be present before the young who shall come to prepare
themselves to take the places they filled and glorified. It was
fitting also that this work should have been undertaken and car-
ried through by the surviving officers and soldiers of the army,
for it is your comrades' memory that is thus preserved.
Here let this column rise in stately beauty, proclaiming to
the coming generations the great occasion and the great truths
which have caused it to be. And may every ripple of yonder
stream, as it passes and floats onward toward the commercial
metropolis of the nation, bear from its lips to the tomb where
sleeps the coffined dust of the great commander, the assurances
of the unvarying loyalty of the army of the United States now
and hereafter to the heroic ideas and ideals of his life, to peace
with equal rights and privileges to all.
EPILOGUE.
CHIS granite shaft stands not as a memorial
alone, but for a principle. It bears wit-
ness to the supremacy of discipline and
education in the vocation of arms. It vindicates
the professional soldier. It glorifies obedience,
self-restraint, intelligence. It stands for duty, pro-
fessional honor, responsibility, order, precision.
In the polished integrity of its unbroken mass the
primeval granite, upright and unswerving, points
heavenward the path of patriotism and of honor.
This is the only monument on the continent to
the officers and soldiers of the Regular Army who
fought in the War of the Rebellion, and in pre-
senting it to the government of the great republic
it has served so well, that army asks its fellow-
citizens to bear in remembrance, together with the
names of the leaders inscribed upon it — McPher-
son, Sedgwick, Reynolds, Mansfield, Lyon —
those survivors who belong with them to history,
8 113
114
THE BATTLE MONUMENT
officers of the Regular Army and sons also of that
Military Academy where their memory is pre-
served and venerated.
Army Commanders.
Grant Hooker Pope
Sherman Rosecrans Slocum
Sheridan McClellan Canby
Meade Halleck Wright, G.
Thomas . Buell McDowell
Schofield Ord Curtis, S. R.
Howard
Corps Commanders.
Reynolds, J. F. j
ist.
Newton
Hancock "I
Couch I 2d.
Humphreys J
Heintzelman 1 .
French / 3
Keyes j
Gordon Granger > 4th.
Stanley J
Sykes 1
Warren j- 5th.
Griffin j
Smith, W. F.
Wrigh
Steele
Reynolds,
ith, W. F. I
•ight, H. G. /
6th.
Parke, 9th.
Gillmore, loth.
Williams, izth.
Davis, J. C., 1 4th.
Smith, A. J., 1 6th.
Foster, J. G., i8th.
Franklin '
Emory I9th.
Grover
McCook, zoth.
Augur, zzd.
Hartsuff, 23d.
Gibbon, 24th.
Weitzel, 25th.
Stoneman
Pleasonton
Merritt
Wilson, J. H.
Cavalry.
Fit/. J^>hn Porter, jtJa.
AT WEST POINT
Division Commanders.
Doubleday
McCall
Carlin
Stevens
Robinson, J. C.
Morgan, J. D.
Ricketts
Barnes
Hazen
Rufus King
Getty
Ransom
Richardson
Russell, D.
Martindale
Webb
Neill
Palmer
Hays, W.
Seymour
Wessels
Sully
Davidson
Sherman, T.
Hays, A.
Carr
Abercrombie
Berry
Wilcox
Ruger
Prince
Brannan
Kautz
Hamilton
Saxton
Jackson, R. H
Whipple,A.W.
Ames
Buford
Elliott, W. L.
Turner
Gregg
Wood
Gordon, G. H.
Custer
Casey
Greene, G. H.
Kilpatrick
Ayers
Smith, C. F.
Upton
Morell
Baird
Mackenzie
And their non-graduate brothers-in-arms of the
Regular Army.
Corps Commanders.
Sumner Butterfield
Sickles Terry
Kearny
Miles
Mower
Division Commanders.
Harney
De Trobriand
n6 THE BATTLE MONUMENT
This is the verdict of the greatest war of modern
times, given also with equal emphasis in the case
of our antagonists — tried in a hundred battles and
justified by the results of a score of campaigns.
No lesson in war was ever more inevitable, clear-
cut and decisive. After a desperate struggle of
four years, involving over three millions of com-
batants, the officers of a little body of ten thousand
regulars, almost wholly graduates of the Military
Academy at West Point, command as Lieutenant-
or Major-Generals every army in the field, nearly
all of the Army Corps, and a large proportion of
the Divisions.
They head every Supply Corps of the General
Staff, and hold every important command in these
Corps. They have organized and directed that
immense mobilizing and supplying mechanism
without which victory would have been impos-
sible, and whose efficiency in the face of enormous
difficulties was the wonder and admiration of the
military world. They gave to the century two
of its greatest commanders, and from their body
came the President of the Confederacy and the
successor of the immortal Lincoln, all sons of
West Point and of the Regular Army.
This sweeping result achieved itself as the
gradual but inevitable logic of experience in
the face of a political favoritism and demoraliza-
tion without limit or precedent.
UNIVERSITY
NAMES OF
OFFICERS AND ENLISTED MEN BORNE
UPON
THE BATTLE MONUMENT
8A
OFFICERS.
*
General Officers.
Brigadier- Generals.
Joseph K. F. Mansfield, Maj.-Gen. Vols., Antietam, Md.
James B. McPherson, Maj.-Gen. Vols., Atlanta, Ga.
General Staff.
Lieut. -Col. Julius P. Garesche, Adjt.-Gen. Dept., Murfrees-
boro, Tenn.
Surgeon William J. H. White, Medical Dept., Antietam, Md.
Capt. Guilford D. Bailey, Subsistence Dept., Fair Oaks, Va.
Capt.OtisH.Tillinghast, Quartermaster Dept., ist Bull Run,Va.
Corps of Engineers.
Majors.
Amiel W. Whipple, Maj.-Gen. Vols., Chancellorsville, Va.
James St. C. Morton, Petersburg, Va,
Captains.
Holdimand S. Putnam, Fort Wagner, S. C.
Charles E. Cross, Rappahannock River, Va.
Arthur H. Dutton, Bermuda Hundred, Va.
izo THE BATTLE MONUMENT
First Lieutenants.
Patrick H. O'Rorke, Col. Vols., Gettysburg, Pa.
John R. Meigs, Harrisonburg, Va.
Corps of Topographical Engineers.
First Lieutenants.
]. L. Kirby Smith, Corinth, Miss.
Orlando G. Wagner, Yorktown, Va.
Ordnance Department.
Captains.
Jesse L. Reno, Maj.-Gen. Vols., South Mountain, Md.
George C. Strong, Brig. -Gen. Vols., Fort Wagner, S. C.
ist Cavalry.
Captains.
Benjamin F. Davis, Beverly Ford, Va.
Samuel McKee, Cold Harbor, Va.
First Lieutenants.
Robert Allen, Jr., Gaines's Mill, Va.
Caesar R. Fisher, Ashby's Gap, Va.
Frederick C. Ogden, Trevillian Station, Va.
Joseph S. Hoyer, Smithfield, Va.
John H. Nichols, Trevillian Station, Va.
John S. Walker, Harper's Ferry, Va.
2d Cavalry.
Captains.
Charles W. Canfield, Beverly Ford, Va.
James F. McQuesten, Opequan, Va.
AT WEST POINT 121
First Lieutenants.
Michael Lawless, Trevillian Station, Va.
Charles McMaster, Front Royal, Va.
Second Lieutenant.
George DeV. Selden, Gettysburg, Pa.
3d Cavalry.
Captain.
Alexander McRae, Valverde, N. M.
Second Lieutenant.
George Harrington, Memphis, Tenn.
4th Cavalry.
Colonel.
John Sedgwick, Maj.-Gen. Vols., Spottsylvania C. H., Va.
Captain.
George D. Bayard, Brig. -Gen. Vols., Fredericksburg, Va.
First Lieutenant.
Elbridge G. Roys, Selina, Ala.
Second Lieutenants.
Thomas Healy, Franklin, Tenn.
Francis C. Wood, Middleton, Tenn.
5th Cavalry.
Captains.
Thomas Drummond, Five Forks, Va.
Joseph P. Ash, Todd's Tavern, Va.
James Cahill, Todd's Tavern, Va.
122 THE BATTLE MONUMENT
First Lieutenants.
John J. Sweet, Gaines's Mill, Va.
Richard Byrnes, Lieut.-Col. Vols., Cold Harbor, Va.
Joseph P. Henley, Trevillian Station, Va.
Richard Fitzgerald, Winchester, Va.
John Trevor, Winchester, Va.
6th Cavalry.
Captains.
William P. Sanders, Brig. -Gen. Vols., Knoxville, Tenn.
Charles R. Lowell, Brig. -Gen. Vols., Middletown, Va.
First Lieutenants.
Peter McGrath, Apache Canon, N. M.
Isaac M. Ward, Beverly Ford, Va.
Christian Balder, Gettysburg, Pa.
Thomas W. Simson, wounds received in battle.
Andrew Stoll, Beverly Ford, Va.
Second Lieutenant.
Hugh Mcguade, Bull Run, Va.
1st Artillery.
Captain.
Lewis O. Morris, Col. Vols., Cold Harbor, Va.
First Lieutenants.
Douglas Ramsay, ist Bull Run, Va.
Edward B. Hill, White Oak Swamp, Va.
Justin E. Dimick, Chancellorsville, Va.
Edmund Kirby, Brig. -Gen. Vols., Chancellorsville, Va.
George A. Woodruff, Gettysburg, Pa.
Philip D. Mason, Trevillian Station, Va.
AT WEST POINT 123
Second Lieutenant.
James A. Sanderson, Pleasant Hill, La.
2d Artillery.
Captain.
Henry Benson, Malvern Hill, Va.
First Lieutenant.
John T. Greble, Big Bethel, Va.
Second Lieutenants.
Presley O. Craig, ist Bull Run, Va.
Thomas Burnes, Hatcher's Run, Va.
Samuel D. Southworth, Cedar Creek, Va.
3d Artillery.
Second Lieutenants.
William D'Wolf, Williamsburg, Va.'
Manning Livingston, Gettysburg, Pa.
Robert Floyd, Chickamauga, Ga.
4th Artillery.
Captain.
George W. Hazzard, White Oak Swamp, Va.
First Lieutenants.
William L. Baker, Antietam, Md.
George Dickinson, Fredericksburg, Va.
Franklin B. Crosby, Chancellorsville, Va.
Bayard Wilkeson, Gettysburg, Pa.
Alonzo H. Cushing, Gettysburg, Pa.
124 THE BATTLE MONUMENT
5th Artillery.
Major.
Thomas Williams, Brig. -Gen. Vols., Baton Rouge, La.
Captains.
William R. Terrill, Brig. -Gen. Vols., Perry ville, Ky.
John R. Smead, zd Bull Run, Va.
Henry V. De Hart, Gaines's Mill, Va.
Stephen H. Weed, .Brig. -Gen. Vols., Gettysburg, Pa.
First Lieutenants.
Henry W. Kingsbury, Antietam, Md.
Charles E. Hazlett, Gettysburg, Pa.
Howard M. Burnham, Chickamauga, Ga.
Second Lieutenants.
William W. Williams, Boonsboro, Md.
Henry M. Baldwin, Cedar Creek, Va.
1st Infantry.
Capt. James E. Powell, Shiloh, Tenn.
Second Lieut. Charles Wilkins, Vicksburg, Miss.
2d Infantry.
Colonel.
Dixon S. Miles, Harper's Ferry, Va.
Captains.
Nathaniel Lyon, Brig. -Gen. Vols., Wilson's Creek, Mo.
Salem S. Marsh, Chancellorsville, Va.
Richard Brindley, Gaines's Mill, Va.
Samuel A. McKee, Greenwich, Va.
AT WEST POINT 125
First Lieutenants.
Frank C. Goodrich, Gettysburg, Pa.
Ralph E. Ellinwood, 2d Bull Run, Va.
Second Lieutenants.
Thomas D. Parker, Gaines's Mill, Va.
William Kidd, zd Bull Run, Va.
3d Infantry.
Major.
Nathan B. Russell, Gaines's Mill, Va.
First Lieutenant.
Woods McGuire, Malvern Hill, Va.
4th Infantry.
Major.
Seneca G. Simmons, Glendale, Va.
Captains.
Julius W. Adams, Gaines's Mill, Va.
Charles H. Brightly, Wilderness, Va.
First Lieutenant.
Ira F. Gensel, Fredericksburg, Va.
5th Infantry.
Colonel.
John F. Reynolds, Maj.-Gen. Vols., Gettysburg, Pa.
Captain.
Benjamin Wingate, Valverde, N. M.
126 THE BATTLE MONUMENT
First Lieutenant.
Lyman Mishler, Valverde, N. M.
6th Infantry.
Colonel.
Edward A. King, Chickamauga, Ga.
Captain.
Rennselaer W. Foote, Games' s Mill, Va.
7th Infantry.
Captain.
George Ryan, Laurel Hill, Va.
First Lieutenants.
Wesley F. Miller, Gettysburg, Pa.
Richard R. Crawford, Gettysburg, Pa.
Frederick E. Grossman, Weldon Railroad, Va.
8th Infantry.
Majors.
Joseph B. Plummer, Brig. -Gen. Vols., Wilson's Creek, Mo.
David A. Russell, Brig. -Gen. Vols., Opequan, Va.
First Lieutenant.
Otis Fisher, Poplar Spring Church, Va.
loth Infantry.
Captains.
Jesse A. Gove, Col. Vols., Chickahominy, Va.
William G. Jones, Col. Vols., Chickamauga, Ga.
AT WEST POINT 127
First Lieutenants.
William J. Fisher, Gettysburg, Pa.
Richard Skinner, Petersburg, Va.
Second Lieutenants.
Michael C. Boyce, Gettysburg, Pa.
James Henry, Wilderness, Va.
nth Infantry.
Captain.
Thomas O. Barri, Gettysburg, Pa.
First Lieutenants.
Herbert Kenaston, Gettysburg, Pa.
Matthew Elder, Gettysburg, Pa.
Wright Staples, Wilderness, Va.
Charles I. Pleasants, Wilderness, Va.
James P. Pratt, Bethesda Church, Va.
Second Lieutenants.
Henry Rochford, Gettysburg, Pa.
Amaziah J. Barber, Gettysburg, Pa.
12th Infantry.
Major.
Luther B. Bruen, Laurel Hill, Va.
Captains.
John G. Read, zd Bull Run, Va.
Thomas M. Hulings, Spottsylvania Court House, Va.
Samuel S. Newbury, Weldon Railroad, Va.
Frederick Winthrop, Bvt. Brig.-Gen. Vols., Five Forks, Va.
William Sergeant, Gravelly Run, Va.
iz8 THE BATTLE MONUMENT
First Lieutenants.
Jean P. Wagner, Wilderness, Va.
August Eggemeyer, Bethesda Church, Va.
Thomas D. Urmston, Chapel House, Va.
Second Lieutenants.
Charles F. Van Duzer, Gaines's Mill, Va.
Silas A. Miller, Gettysburg, Pa.
13th Infantry.
Captains.
Edward C. Washington, Vicksburg, Miss.
Archibald H. Engle, Resaca, Ga.
Cornelius W. Tolles, Newton, Va.
First Lieutenant.
Justus A. Boies, Vicksburg, Miss.
14th Infantry.
Captains.
Patrick E. Burke, Col. Vols., Rome Cross Roads, Ga.
Roderic Stone, Valverde, N. M.
Sullivan W. Burbank, Wilderness, Va.
Hamlin W. Keyes, Spottsylvania Court House, Va.
James F. McElhone, Bvt. Lieut.-CoL, Gaines's Mill, Va.
First Lieutenants.
Warren W. Chamberlain, zd Bull Run, Va.
Daniel M. Broadhead, Wilderness, Va.
Second Lieutenants.
George W. Hoover, Gaines's Mill, Va.
John K. Clay, Spottsylvania Court House, Va.
Thomas E. Collins, Wilderness, Va.
AT WEST POINT 129
15th Infantry.
Captains.
William W. Wise, Stone River, Tenn.
Jacob B. Bell, Stone River, Tenn.
Charles G. Marker, Kenesaw Mountain, Ga.
Second Lieutenant.
Joseph C. Forbes, New Hope Church, Ga.
i6th Infantry.
Major.
Sidney Coolidge, Chickamauga, Ga.
Captains.
William H. Acker, Shiloh, Tenn.
George N. Bascom, Valverde, N. M.
Patrick T. Keyes, Shiloh, Tenn.
Alexander Hays, Brig. -Gen. Vols., Wilderness, Va.
Patrick Kelly, Col. Vols., Petersburg, Va.
First • Lieutenants.
Edward L. Mitchell, Shiloh, Tenn.
Homer H. Clark, Chickamauga, Ga.
Second Lieutenant.
Peter J. Coenzler, Mission Ridge, Tenn.
iyth Infantry.
Captains.
Albert Dodd, Gaines's Mill, Va.
Henry J. McLandburgh, Fredericksburg, Va.
William J. Temple, Chancellorsville, Va.
Alexander Wilkin, Col. Vols., Tupelo, Miss.
9
1 30 THE BATTLE MONUMENT
First Lieutenants.
Charles T. Weld, Chancellorsville, Va.
William H. Chamberlin, Gettysburg, Pa.
Edward S. Abbot, Gettysburg, Pa.
Frank E. Stimpson, Laurel Hill, Va.
John T. Dowling, Laurel Hill, Va.
i8th Infantry.
Captains.
Charles E. Denison, Murfreesboro, Tenn.
Charles L. Kneass, Murfreesboro, Tenn.
John A. Thompson, Hoover's Gap, Tenn.
First Lieutenants.
James Simons, Murfreesboro, Tenn.
Joseph McConnell, Murfreesboro, Tenn.
Charles L. Truman, Chickamauga, Ga.
Lucius F. Brown, Chickamauga, Ga.
Second Lieutenants.
John F. Hitchcock, Murfreesboro, Tenn.
John Lane, Chickamauga, Ga.
igth Infantry.
Majors.
Stephen D. Carpenter, Murfreesboro, Tenn.
George L. Willard, Col. Vols., Gettysburg, Pa.
First Lieutenant.
Michael B. Fogarty, Chickamauga, Ga.
Second Lieutenant.
Charles F. Miller, Chickamauga, Ga.
OF THB
UNIVERSITY
ENLISTED MEN.
Battalion of Engineers.
Private Thomas Berry
Martin C. Kehoe
Ordnance Corps.
Carriage-maker Henry Thesang
Signal Corps.
Sergeant John Corrigan
Private Philip W. Ashton
Amos P. Barnes
Abraham E. Borden
Andrew P. Cobb
Alexander McCollim
General Service.
Private Thomas Ronon
1st U. S. Cavalry.
First Sergeant Henry Montraville
Frederick Papp
Sergeant Jasper R, Boyles
132 THE BATTLE MONUMENT
Thomas J. Clark
Edwin Chutland
James Kelly
Adolph Meyer
Thomas Montgomery
William Mulcahy
Charles Oertel
James Rathburn
James A. Samo
Corporal Henry C. Albert
William T. Bennett
Samuel A. Carr
William H. Cole
George A. Cullison
John Hall
James T. Holt
Peter Latti
Thomas Leary
John Mallen
Michael Mulcahy
Jacob McAtee
James O'Connor
Charles A. Tankersly
Charles Pfil
Lucius F. Walden
Adam Ziegler
Blacksmith Timothy Muldowny
Farrier Andrew Van Camp
Bugler William H. Burritt
Musician Frank Dawson
Private Hubbard Babcock
John Beacon
Samuel Bell
William Blumhardt
AT WEST POINT 133
John B. Brown
Elijah Comstock
Jacob Deeds
Mark Dolby
August Echolett
Henry S. Fetrow
William Gallop
John A. Gibbons
Joseph Hagin
George Hannon
Warren F. Hedges
Frederick Hensinger
Charles Hoffman
Nelson Johnson
James Kearney
William Kellier
Lewis Ladue
John J. Livingston
Daniel Lynch
Martin V. Mathewson
John McCafferty
James McHugh
Hugh Meegan
Henry Miller
William J. Mincen
William Monroe
John Normoyle
John A. O' Carroll
George Ott •
William Peter
John Radeford
Charles Reinstein
James Rodgers
William Scott
9A
i34 THE BATTLE MONUMENT
John Smith
John M. Smith
Samuel Stinebarger
Jacob Steinhauser
John R. Sulivan
Thomas Thews
Peter Welgong
John F. Zeitler
2d U. S. Cavalry.
First Sergeant Ephriam Adams
Henry Kinzler
Sergeant Martin Bailey
James Carr
John D. Dunbar
Christian Fisher
James Hanna
Andrew Moore
Charles Vanmeter
Corporal John C. Annis
John Buckhardt
Stephen Hogan
William H. Keiger
Truman King
Patrick Morglu
Luke Ollis
Albert Roe
Edward Shuhey
Peter B. Worden
Martin Zimmer
Saddler David C. Dinim
Wilhelm Oleker
Bugler John Robinson
Private Richard F. Ambrose
AT WEST POINT 135
Joseph Anderson
John Barrington
John Blael
Emil Briede
Ariel C. Chapin
Thomas Clark
John Conover
Samuel A. Cook
William Cooper
Thomas Corbeth
Andrew B. Couch
James Courtney
Daniel Crimmins
James Dean
Daniel Denison
John Driscoll
Joseph Eckels
Rudolph Engel
James Ferris
Philip Fitzsimons
Charles Frick
Michael Gahe
Edward Gorman
Harvey D. Haynes
Leo Henze
Frederic Hood
George Hozzell
Frederick Kauffman
William Kline
Patrick McArdle
John McCullough
Thomas McTague
Rodney A. Manning
Andrew L. Metts
136 THE BATTLE MONUMENT
Michael Mooney
Patrick Murray
Michael O'Brien
John Philips
Thomas N. Prentice
James Levens
Patrick Rhatigan
James Ruseher
Charles Smith
Samuel E. Smith
John T. Thompson
James Tryon
Charles W. Uber
Charles Williams
30* U. S. Cavalry.
Sergeant Thomas M. Brierley
John J. Knox
Francis O'Cain
Corporal James E. Brophey
Thomas Hughes
Bugler Albert Shott
Musician Henry Ebert
Private Peter Beatty
Theodore Braun
Edward Carey
William J. Dake
Edward Doyle
John Finn
Bartley Folan
James Hughes
John Lane
John Ludwig
James McDougal
AT WEST POINT 137
Patrick Scanlon
Thomas Sharda
Eli W. Smith
Samuel Smith
Erley P. Turman
William E. Wade
John Weckesser
John H. Westervelt
4tb U. S. Cavalry.
Sergeant John Carmichael
Martin Murphy
John Rankin
Joseph B. Richmond
James Walsh
Corporal Martin Birmingham
Patrick Cuddehy
Phelix Cullan
Frederick Hall
Frederick W. Klein
George Phillips
Stephen Wetzberger
Farrier Alexander Millright
zd Class Musician Frederick Shafer
Alfred S. Toy
Private Frank Bars
John Baum
Bartholomew Burke
George Cassell
Commodore P. Cole
Charles Cowarden
Patrick Craven
David Daugherty
Robert P. Doyle
138 THE BATTLE MONUMENT
John Entwhistle
Napoleon M. King
Andrew J. Mahoney
Daniel McDonell
James Orange
Archibald B. Orr
John Parsons
Levi L. Pettitt
Friend Pratt
Henry J. Preas
Fretrick Rhyman
Philip H. Sailer
William Sawyer
Adolph Stettler
Rodger Stokes
Patrick Tracy
Nathan Writhe
Colored Cook Jackson Kelley
Jib U. S. Cavalry.
Sergeant Thomas Barrett
John Doherty
Franklin S. Ginginer
Henry Hedrick
Corporal Charles E. Asher
David Courtney
George T. Crawford
Aquilla Hart
Michael Howard
James H. Oliver
Lewis J. Robage
Musician Christopher Buermann
Bugler Edward Feldhiene
Private Ira K. Bailey
AT WEST POINT 139
Benni D. Bailey
John Bigmone
Clarence O. Bingen
John C. Burk
George Burrhus
Michael Canton
Walter R. Covington
Francis Croal
John Curran
Edward Dolan
Domian Erne
Patrick Galliger
Peter Gillasper
Samuel Gindrat
Francis Hogan
William Johns
Patrick Kenny
William H. King
William Larison
James Lason
William H. Lazier
Gustaf Lindell
Thomas Miller
Preston O. Morse
Charles Olens
Alexander Rayner
David F. Roberts
Barney Ryan
Charles W. Sanders
Jacob Schneider
John Schlotterer
George Segerer
John Siepe
Vinton T. Swallow
THE BATTLE MONUMENT
William Talday
Edmond Whelan
William W. Wright
Recruit Jacob Schlichter
6tb U. S. Cavalry.
Sergeant William Ellsworth
Miles L. Ten Eyck
James McCallister
John Pattinson
Frank Schweigus
Corporal William Alexander
Alonzo Ellsworth
John H. Erb
John Manice
David C. Oby
Saddler Robert McElroy
Bugler Edson S. Cooke
Private George D. Bartlett
George Beckert
Henry Borden
William A. Boyntion
Charles Croissant
Patrick Doyle
Henry Eisle
James Evans
Edward Falkner
John Fisher
James W. Gillispie
Lyman W. Hale
Joshua Heakin
Christian F. Hildenbrand
Abel A. Irish
James King
AT WEST POINT 141
Conrad Klein
Thomas Lee
William D. Masters
William L. Mattern
Lue Merkle
Francis M. Miller
Lewis Negler
Charles O'Harra
Nathaniel B. Owen
Thomas J. Peterman
Jacob Poet
Nelson Remmington
William R. Reynolds
David A. Thaburn
William H. Thomas
William Vandevender
Joseph F. Vanzant
Spencer Viall
* Samuel Wilson
1st U. S. Artillery.
Sergeant Alfred J. Carber
Thomas Kirnan
Edward F. McNamara
Henry Rukert
Corporal William Ferguson
John W. Mahany
Musician John S. Blaney
Private James Allen
James Allum
Christian A. Andler
Charles Baker
Michael Barrey
William Bates
142 THE BATTLE MONUMENT
Edward Beavin
Henry Bergmann
John Buckley
Patrick Broderick
James Campbell
Rowland Card
John Casey
Daniel B. Chase
Philip Clarke
Daniel B. Cofrin
John Connellan
Charles Cooley
Daniel Curly
Michael Dillon
John Donoghue
Richard Forsyth
Edward Gallwey
Jacob Gilb
James Gilmore
John Gray
Arsenal H. Griffin
Edward Grove
Martin Halloran
Rollin E. Hartwell
Andrew Hauss
Horace Holmes
John Hopkins
Daniel Hough
Frank E. Houghton
John Irvin
Patrick Kerrigan
James Killion
John King
Abraham LaFayette
AT WEST POINT 143
James Little
Samuel J. Lewis
John J. Mackey
John Marklein
Henry Miles
Patrick McGuinity
James R. Mooney
Andrew McLeer
George A. Nutter 9
Shako O'Brien
Thomas Padgett
Joseph H. Parslow
Henry Platt
Frederick Renard
Charles Rivers
John Roache
George Royce
Robert Rummler
John Shafer
John Shea
William H. Smith
August Stein
John Stoltz
Peter Struthers
James B. Terney
James F. Wheeler
William H. Whitehouse
John C. Wood
William S. Worcester
2d U. S. Artillery.
First Sergeant William Scott
Sergeant Samuel Bellinger
Herman O. Gotz
or THK
UNIVERSITY
i44 THE BATTLE MONUMENT
Corporal George D. Cook
Josiah Steele
Private Franklin F. Allen
Charles Ammerman
William Baird
Garrett Barry
Henry Beck
John Bergamin
Adolphus Bhoy
John Campbell
William Cope
Martin Corbet
Hugh Donaghue
William Finley
Henry Foster
Vandy Franklin
Martin Gilroy
William H. Grover
William Guth
Randolph Hand
George Hang
Arthur Hardes
John Hitz
Henry Horstman
Jacob Huber
William Lacumber
Patrick Loughery
Joseph Margery
Charles Mathers
Emmore Moore
Michael S. Moriarty
John E. Mowrer
Timothy McSweeny
John B. Norris
AT WEST POINT 145
Silvester Parker
Richard Powers
John Prisen
Philip Reehil
Charles Ritchie
George W. Ritchmond
John W. Semline
Daniel Spane
John W. Them
Augustus Van Dwingle
Oliver Wren
3d U. S. Artillery.
Sergeant Robert Ames
Bugler John W. Sarguson
Private Jacob Altheer
Ackerman Anderson
Mathew Ashton
Alfred Barnard
Benjamin Bayliss
George C. Bentley
Henry Boothbey
William Brown
Charles W. Carlton
Denis Carroll
John Clifford
Michael Conroy
Andrew Cooley
James George
Amos Y. Harry
Arthur Hughes
William H. Hurlbut
Francis M. Hutchings
Charles A. Kratka
146 THE BATTLE MONUMENT
James King
Bernard Laughran
John Malone
Dennis Murphy
John Mclntyre
Sylvester Nordike
Charles H. Pinkham
Henry Reinschoss
Rudolph Richner
James Rice
James H. Riddel
Henry Schaffer
Jeremiah Shehan
Charles H. Taylor
Augustus Tainter
Perry S. White
Michael Woods
William Wright
4tb U. S. Artillery.
Sergeant Samuel L. Buell
Charles Ellis
Andrew Fay
Joseph Herzog
Corporal Frederick Bright
Theodore L. Williamson
Artificer Dennis Maloney
Bugler David R. Patrick
Private Benjamin Anderson
William Anderson
Christian Aungst
Richard Bannin
John Brown
John Burns
AT WEST POINT 147
Jeremiah Butler
Joseph A. Campbell
Reuben A. Gary
Cosmas M. Cecil
Jacob Defren
Bartholomew Dempsey
Edward E. Doran
Andrew Dougherty
Edward Dunne
Bryan Charles Eagar
John Edgecombe
Henry Elmer
William E. Emory
Francis Enright
Ansel Fassett
Adolph Freitag
Franz A. Fugmann
Henry Geary
Shelby Gray
John Grennin
Dwight F. Griswold
George Haffner
George W. Hall
John Hickey
Charles F. Hoefer
Patrick Hogan
Samuel C. Hooker
William M. Howard
William Kavanagh
Bartly Kelly
Peter Kelly
Ellis A. Kingsbury
Timothy Larry
Andrew J. Lowe
1 48 THE BATTLE MONUMENT
Henry P. Lyons
John Marley
John Mayberry
William McNeal
David A. Meneilly
Andrew F. Missimer
James Murphy
Lewis Murphy
Patrick O'Connor
Willis H. Patrick
William Patton
Ervin L. Pepper
Samuel Powell
Luke Roach
Reuben Rowley
Gustavus Sachse •
Patrick Savage
Martin Scanlon
Paul Schur
Frank Scudder
Peter Schutzle
John Sheahan
Franz Smith
Henry Strait
James Thompson
William Travillion
Norbare B. Walcott
Thomas Wallace
Edward H. Ward
Edward D. West
William H. Williams
George W. Yapp
AT WEST POINT 149
5tb U. S. Artillery.
Sergeant David Cain Bickel
Frederick O'Donnell
James Scanlon
Corporal John Philip Edwin Brader
John Coushmaghnan
Thomas Davison
Martin Dooley
Michael Graham
George W. Houk
William Kirkwood
Michael McGrath
Charles V. Osborn •
Artificer Jonathan Robeson
Private Alexander Allen
John Allen
John Andrews
Eugene Brower
Charles Burger
James Carrell
Robert Chamberlin
Thomas Cleary
John B. Cochran
John Collins
Joseph Cooper
John Costello
James Cullen
Frederick Deasonbach
Bernard Des Gouttes
Michael Driscoll
John Duffy
Christian Enzlan
Charles Geiger
Jacob Gobriel
IOA
150 THE BATTLE MONUMENT
Thomas Green
Lewis C. Griswold
Henry Harris
Francis Harrison
George Helshaw
Jesaias M. Heydt
Martin Higgins
James Hoobler
David T. Howard
Henry Jersey
Adonija Jewell.
Dennis Kennedy
Samuel W. Laffefty
Thomas Maloney
James Mathews
Robert Morrison
Francis Mourey
James F. McAulis
Martin McFadden
James McGlindon
John McMahon
John Munhall
William Naylor
Peter Nugent
James O'Brien
Michael O'Donnell
Henry Owens
Frank Packard
Ash ford Painter
Benjamin Putt
Frederick A. Reig
Henry Ripley
Samuel Rodenberger
Louis Row
AT WEST POINT 151
Thomas C. Stone
Peter Sharrow
George Shafer
John Searfoss
Daniel E. Sickles
Jacob J. Snyder
Edwin H. Taylor
Leander Taylor
James Turner
Joseph W. Tuttle
Andrew Wagner
Denis Walks
John Walsh
Thomas Worts
ist U. S. Infantry.
Sergeant Joseph T. Nichols
Willis B. Worth
Corporal George I. Doller
Henry Harbold
Private Jacob Baehr
Adam Brangle
Edward Brawn
Patrick Daniel
James Doig
Samuel Furter
Sylvester Johnson
John Johnston
John Kerns
Ferdinand Knaut
August Kruger
William Lazarus
George W. Lee
John Long
152 THE BATTLE MONUMENT
John Lynch
Daniel Murray
William McGann
Joseph A. Mciyiullan
Timothy Neligan
Edward O'Donnell
William Peacock
James Pinkerton
John Res
William F. Rock
Napoleon Sherzinger
Jacob Stahlman
Adam Sturm fels
2d U. S. Infantry.
>- First Sergeant Rudolph Thieme
Sergeant Thomas S. Camp
Werner Jahres
Thomas Madigan
Rudolph Zimmerman
Corporal George Butler
William H. Butler
William Carney
Ezra C. French
John Fullbright
James Kelly
Frederick Kousenmiller
Patrick Rourke
Musician Theodore A. Miller
Private William Bankhouse
William L. Barnes
Lawrence Belfour
Michael Bogan
William J. Bond
AT WEST POINT 153
John Bradly
Robert Brown
George W. Bush
Terence Carroll
Francis R. Chesbro
Charles C. Cleaver
John Cooly
John Cooper
Thomas Cosgrove
Thomas E. Donnellan
Michael Donnelly
James Eugene
George D. Fenner
William Fitch
Michael Gonzel
Adam Groh
John Hare
Useb Harper
Louis Hartman
Michael Heath
Charles A. Hedges
William Heuratty
Peter Hickey
Walter Hill
William Hunter
William Johnson
Peter Kelly
James Kenny
John Kenney
Leslie Laporte
William Loyd
James Mackle
John Magarry
William Malony
154 THE BATTLE MONUMENT
David Martin
James Meehan
August Meyer
Nicholas McDonough
Stephen McGinnity
Peter McNulty
Augustus Mier
James McGinn
William H. Nixon
Christian Orb
Maurice Pepper
George Reynolds
Lucus Rittler
James E. Rugers
Austin Sadler
John Selinon
James Sheehan
Joseph Shupfer
Godfrey Smith
Henry Smith
Augustus Stahl
Joseph Theiring
James Trainer
Frank Uhrman
N. D. Van Ormun
Francis Vanston
Michael Walsh
Patrick Welch
John Wells
John Weston
Richard White
John Willis
Patrick Woods
Homer Young
AT WEST POINT 155
^d U. S. Infantry.
First Sergeant Francis P. Litzinger
Corporal Charles H. Canwell
Harry Loraine
Malcolm J. Montford
John Toner
Private Nicholas Applebury
James Beaty
Gilbert H. Beverly
Peter Bingel
John Brennan
James County
Thomas Dalton
David Dreakes
Robert Furlong
John A. Gale
Michael Groustine
Robert Haley
William S. Holmes
Frederick Jansen
Benjamin F. Kellog
Thomas Kennedy
Maurice Knopfmacher
Caspard Kupferk
Mathew Lodin
Charles F. Long
John Murrey
Patrick McDonald
John McManamin
John Pyne
Philip Rodel
Luke Shaughnessy
Michael J. Smith
Patrick Sullivan
156 THE BATTLE MONUMENT
Peter Sullivan
Patrick Tighe
Mark White
Edward M. Williams
4th U. S. Infantry.
Sergeant Timb Doherty
John Flynn
Louis Planmann
John Riely
John J. Strain
Corporal Michael McGarvey
William O'Brien
German Restell
James Rogerson
Private Christian Albert
Ernest A. C. Aschemoor
William Bonner
Bernard Brady
Randall H. Brunning
Charles Caldwell
James M. Carroll
Michael Carroll
Frederick Case
Richard Casey
John Christensen
Uriah W. Clark
Thomas Conlin
Bernhard Douch
Christian Engers
Charles T. Fox
Henry Grazier
William Hamilton
William Harnett
TIN
AT WEST POINT 157
William G. Harper
John Kahear
George Lemaine
Patrick Masterson
Bernard McCue
James McDonald
Roger McDonald
Daniel L. McGinn
Peter McManaman
-David Meredith
David Miller
Michael McCue
Michael McGuire
James O'Dowd
Gottlieb Ott
John Patterson
Thomas Peters
Isaac Rice
John Rourke
Bennet Robinson
Edward Simpson
Warner R. Thompson
Andreas Waker
U. S. Infantry.
First Sergeant Luther Sheppard
Sergeant John Stewart
Corporal Simon Rothschild
Henry Schlutter
Private John Ford
Nicholas Hayes
Joseph Hudson
Patrick Hughes
Andres Kinnberger
158 THE BATTLE MONUMENT
Thomas Leary
Jacob Levy
John Murphy
John Pollock
Francis Richard
John Sands
George A. Smith
6tb U. S. Infantry.
First Sergeant Julius Thetard
Sergeant Patrick Weare
Corporal Owen Leonard
James L. Lovett
Herman Westhus
Private Thomas Ainsworth
William Brown
James Campbell
Cornelius Collins
James Contoit
John Cook
Charles Costello
John Donoghue
James Dunlap
William Fenton
Frederick H. Hicks
Thomas Jackson
Patrick Kiernan
Barney Lafferty
Cornelius Leo
John Mahony
Patrick Mullen
Charles F. Niemetz
Patrick O'Keeffe
Joseph L. Pinkham
AT WEST POINT 159
William L. Rutherford
Ransom B. Russell
Christian F. Schmidtzer
Henry Schultz
John Sullivan
John Wilson
Jtb U. S. Infantry.
Sergeant William James
James M. Rockwell
Timothy Sullivan
Corporal Gustavus Percy
John P. Rumbel
Private Thomas Arnold
John C. Ashton
John A. Bishop
Thomas Carey
John C. Connolly
William H. Curtis
John Douglas
John Ellard
John Fitzgerald
Joseph Folgen
Charles Forrest
Julius Furgeson
Eugene F. Gibbins
Michael Gill
Thomas Gilling
Alexander Gillon
John H. Jack
Cyrus Junkins
Emile M. Kahn
John Keenan
Peter Keim
160 THE BATTLE MONUMENT
Thomas Lawlare
Harvey Lary
John Liebrich
Joseph C. Labadie
William A. Mason
John Mee
William Muller
Bernard McBride
Peter McCue
James McDonald
James Nolan
Edward Nugent
James O'Briene
James Reilly
Pixlee Sherwood
George Smith
Patrick Smith
Philip Shoemaker
John Teahan
William Wilson
Frederick Winscher
8tb U. S. Infantry.
Private James Adams
William Bailey
James Cunningham
Robert Boyle
George O. Curtis
William Dougharty
William Gurl
John Hanley
Michael Hoag
John Latimer
Martin Molarcky
AT WEST POINT 161
Christian W. Shafer
William Waldov
Qtb U. S. Infantry.
(None)
loth U. S. Infantry.
First Sergeant James Carroll
William K. Davis
John Kelly
Sergeant Daniel C. Ballard
Herman Buiter
Thomas Corcoran
Michael Finnaughty
Able Johnston
Corporal James Craig
John A. Crotty
Thomas H. Crotty
Charles Fischer
George W. Green
Robert Hayes
Charles Smith
Low D. Webb
Private Rudolph Arndt
John Battersbee
Francis Blake
Thomas Brady
John C. Brown
Patrick Burke
Darby Burns
Hazimier Canomski
Carl Christiansen
Francis M. Cleary
Peter Collins
i6z THE BATTLE MONUMENT
Michael Crogan
Albert J. Cross
Wesley Dailey
James Daley
John E. Davis
Frank Depoire
Edwin Eeney
Michael Feeney
Thomas Fitzpatrick
Richard Gregg
George Harris
Matthew Harrison
Henry Heine
John Henderson
George W. Hicks
John Hoggan
John Igo
Hugh Jeffery
Stephen Jennings
Israel L. Jones
Mathew Kelly
Thomas Kelly
Michael Kennedy
Joseph Kremer
Owen Mahoney
Andrew Marshal
James Marx
George Meins
Frederick Miller
Samuel Miller
John B. Montgomery
Owen McGorman
Patrick McDonell
Peter McKenny
AT WEST POINT 163
Frank Nelson
Michael Neville
John Noonan
Joseph Odgers
Michael O'Keefe
John C. Orwig
John Parker
Eail Payne
John Reichling
Jacob Rife
Emil Rotwitt
Henry Ruhr
William Schweer
Henry Schwep
John Wesley Smith
John D. Steel
Oliver P. Stewart
Edward Walsh
Charles W. Washburn
Recruit William H. Potter
nth U. S. Infantry.
First Sergeant Thomas O'Connor
John Remsen
Sergeant John P. Birmingham
Edward Britt, Jr. .
Frank W. Clock
Alfred E. Cook
William C. Fitzgerald
Patrick Fitzmorris
Henry Clay Ford
Francis Fuchs
James Henry
William H. Keys
164 THE BATTLE MONUMENT
Samuel Murphy
H. M. Reed
William H. Thomas
Corporal James B. F. Adams
Josiah S. Estabrook
James M. Fleming
Pulaski Jerome
Ephraim Sands
William P. Woodworth
William Wylie
Private Albert Anderson
Albert Ankerson
George A. Annis
Robert R. Armstrong
John L. Arnold
Joseph Bissonnette
Michael H. Bock
Charles W. Bodman
George J. Brown
Henry Brown
Michael Carew
James D. Cavenagh
John Clahane
John Conway
Philip Corrigan
John Creardon
Michael Curley
Mark Dempsey
Napoleon Dubue
Elias A. Dunkelberg
Albert P. Eagle
Alfred Esset
George W. Fales
Patrick Fallon
AT WEST POINT 165
James Farrell
Michael Fitzgibbon
John Flangherty
Jeremiah Ford
Louis Fuchs
Benjamin F. Garland
Gedeon Germain
John Goff
John Hanna
Solomon Hannant
Charles Horton
George Jacobs
Otho Jenkins
Darwin Johnson
James Kelley
John Keenan
Jonas Keim
Thomas Kennedy
Thomas W. Laurence
George LaMountain
Henry Lasinger
Henry L. Leighton
Timothy Lowry
Thomas Mallon
Albert Mattice
William Mears
Gottlieb Metsger
John Miller
James F. Mitchell
Patrick Molloy
James Moonay
Casimire Morain
John T. Myers
John McCluskey
HA
1 66 THE BATTLE MONUMENT
Alcott D. McKeen
Charles McElroy
Private John O'Keefe
Richard Parsons
Andrew W. Perkins
John H. Ransom
Henry Reals
William Rising
John Roach
Stapylton Robinson
George Ryan
Thomas F. Ryan
George Scott
Andreas Selyelie
Frank Sheldon
James L. Sholes
George J. Simpson
William I. Sloan
Oliver J. Stork
Levi Strickland
Hubert Stone
William Sullivan
William H. Sullivan
James Sweeney
Henry Thron
Charles H. Tinker
Willard Twichell
George Vanbuskirk
William Walace
Charles Watkins
Virgil I. Wheeler
Luke White
David Wright
Amos B. Wilcox
Charles Wilson
AT WEST POINT 167
I2tb U. S. Infantry.
First Sergeant Richard Blakely
Kasper Dusmann
Thomas Earley
Sergeant Peter Black
William A. Eichelberger
Charles Meeks
Joseph Morrison
Valentine B. Oaks
Hugh Rogers
Michael Shannahan
Corporal Ithamer Barbur
William H. Brundage
Charles E. Dunn
Morgan Flanders
John B. McLaughlin
James M. Nelson
William Over
Francis Tracey
Samuel J. Walton
George M. Wark
Joel White
Ludwig Wittstock
Private George Abender
James Aiken
Charles Andrus
William Armstrong
Joseph Ashborne
Patrick Ayres
William D. Baldwin
Anthony Barrett
Solomon Bell
John Biggs
Benjamin F. Black
Justin S. Booth
i68 THE BATTLE MONUMENT
Anthony Bush
Ezra Carter
James Cassidy
Joseph Champlain
John Chard
Aurora S. Chatfield
John Clark
Patrick Crawford .
George Comstock
John Currie
Jacob P. Cutright
James T. Davis
Michael Donavan
Hiram Dunning
William Dushon
Levi Eells
Solomon Eldridge
Patrick Gartland
Eugene Gerard
Philip Glessner
John Gray
Samuel Green
Edward M. Hammond
William Hannegan
George M. Harrington
John Higgins
Charles Hinniker
William H. Hoffman
Samuel Hyland
Martin James
Jacob Johnson
Reuben Kelley
Daniel Kenney
Christopher Kimbley
AT WEST POINT 169
George W. Kinney
Edward Kirwin
Edward Kiser
Benjamin F. Lee
Adrian Lucas
Thomas Lyons
Edward Maloney
Stephen Markham
Hugh McGowen
Alexander McMillen
Patrick Meagher
Isaac Mellin
Henry C. Mereness
John Moles
Thomas Morgan
Levi Morway
David D. Moser
Edward McCann
John McManus
George Neeger
James O' Conner
William O'Grady
Jonathan Oliver
Andrew O'Neil
Albert Parker
George H. Patterson .
Alonson Pearce
Martin Pringle
Patrick Quigley
Thomas Richards
William Riley
Joseph Robbe
Frank Schiffmacher
John L. Shackelford
;
THK
1 70 THE BATTLE MONUMENT
Charles Shaile
Charles Shellhert
James M. Sivine
LaFayette G. Smith
David Stancleft
Edward N. Stewart
Edgar I. Town
Lewis Ward
Frank Watier
George Werner
George Whiting
Noah Wickersham
John Wilkie
Zule Witsel
Charles Wright
John Wyne
ijtb U. S. Infantry.
Sergeant-Major George W. Steever
First Sergeant Frank Dilworth
Sergeant James E. Browne
Charles H. Ludlow
John C. Matthews
Milo J. Somers
Jesse B. Webster
Corporal Edward Maher
Daniel T. Payne
Asahel Skinner
Robert H. Slate
Henry Yank
Musician George Haney
Private Richard Bailey
John Beringer
Jacob H. Bumgardner
AT WEST POINT 171
Clark Burris
Thomas Cassidy
William H. Clair
Joseph C. Cramer
John Danaha
Thatcher O. Danforth
Alonzo S. Eaton
Dennis Flynn
John Gillespie
John Glancy
Edward Hamilton
John Hampson
William H. H. Harrison
Alfred Hastings
Asaph K. Hildreth
Christopher Hite
Anton Jeager
George H. Johnson
John C. Kimble
Augustus G. Laban
John Lamer
Daniel Lienhardt
Henry Lurink
John Maggert
William Miller
Charles H. Mooers
James Nash
Richard H. Palmer
Frank Roberts
Gottfred Rocht
Charles Schroeder
William P. Sims
Thomas Warner
Charles Wheaton
THE BATTLE MONUMENT
Michael Winn
Edward D. Wood
I4tb U. S. Infantry.
First Sergeant Joseph Stengele
Sergeant John F. Barnes
John Doyle
John Collins
Albert Funke
Jesse A. Ingersoll
Francis L. Theremin
Albert M. Welles
James Williams
Thomas F. Wise
Corporal William H. H. Barnhart
Joel Edmund Benton
Francis Burchard
John Burke
Daniel Cavanagh
Lewis F. Colton
William A. Fay
Gustav Fomm
James Green
Milles Jamerson
John Laffin
George Meyers
William H. Reed
Augustus S. Vogintz
James Worrell
Private William U. Aid
John W. Allen
James A. Alexander
Abram Baker
Marion Bartholf
AT WEST POINT 1?3
Lewis Berkfelt
John Bonaparte
William J. Boyle
Warner Brown
Edward Burns
Harrison Carkin
Samuel Carnes
Patrick Cassidy
Hiram Cole
Parker C. Colladay
George Compton
Patrick Cooney
Nathaniel B. Copp •
Arthur Cosgrove
Paul S. Crosby
John Gushing
Gurdin B. Dart
John Davidson
Patrick Degnan
Thomas Diamon
Michael Donohue
William Driesbach
Dennis Driscoll
John M. Easby
James Eagin
Hector Fan ton
John Farrell
Charles Fees
John Fitzgerald
John Foley
Henry Francis
Robert Franey
Dudley Gordon
James Gordon
174 THE BATTLE MONUMENT
Samuel W. Goodall
Frederick Grasper
John Green
Allen Hadley
William D. Hammonds
Thomas Hannah
William Harris
James Hart
Hiram Haynes
John C. Heath
Jackson Henion
Barney Horan
John L. Horton
Edmund W. Howard
Horace P. Howd
Andrew J. Hughes
John Jefferies
• William Jenner
Moses Jones
Henry Keast
Tracy A. Kellogg
Albert Kendall
Christopher Klenk
Duncan Langmuir
Patrick Larkin
Michael Ledwitch
Byron Loomis
Andrew Love
David Loyall
Charles Lucua
Martin Luhtz
Dennis Martin
Nicholas W. Millis
John McAlpine
AT WEST POINT 175
Arthur McCune
John McDonald
Thomas McDonald
James McManus
John McSorley
Peter Millmore
James Minogue
Walter Moll
James Morrison
Thomas Murray
John Mooney
Thomas Mulligan
Hiram Newman
Thomas Noonen
Charles O' Conner
Patrick O'Neill
Edwin G. Osgood
Joshua Peck
Sidney R. Peterson
Charles N. Phillips
Patrick Power
William Prescott
Ezra Prindle
David Regan
Oliver Robbins
Hiram B. Robinson
Martin Roney
Charles Schirmer
Ozias Shank
Thomas E. Sheets
Richard Simpkins
Simon Singerling
George Slade
George Smith
176 THE BATTLE MONUMENT
Samuel S. Smith
John Smith
Henry Snider
George Stadler
Edson Stevens
Frederick Stevens
William H. Swartz
Robert Swindells
James Trusdell
George F. Turner
Ezra Vallean
Edward Vining
. Mark Ward
George Watson
Sidney Way
John Weik
Erastus D. Woodman
Playford Woods
U. S. Infantry.
First Sergeant Edward Cummings
Charles Kelling
Sergeant William H. Benson
Peter Byrnes
Peter Hartz
John G. Hughes
John Kanable
Edward Quinn
Corporal Augustus Brown
Daniel Butler
John Carr
Charles Wesley Chessroun
* Samuel T. Davis
J. Henry Ferris
AT WEST POINT
Thomas M. Irwin
William McDonald
Thomas Price
Musician Patrick Burns
Private Robert Adams
Mathias Akerman
Jacob Aumiller
John Bawer
Jonathan Blaker
Franklin Blanz
David Bowman
Chester Brown
Isaac Bubb
Archelaus Card
Joseph A. Cellar
Andrew J. Collins
William E. Coyn
John Cradle
Henry Darwood
Isaac Debore
Isaac Detwiler
Enoch Dunham
Andrew Duttry
Thomas Findly
Samuel Finley
Elias Fissel
Patrick Fits
John Frank
Ithiner Gatton
Benjamin Geph
Gustave Gericke
Peter Gilooly
Jesse B. Goodsell
Elias K. Gruver
178 THE BATTLE MONUMENT
David Hartz
William M. Hatch
Henry M. Hayden
Lawrence Hayes
Thomas Hegan
William Hennicy
Jacob Hexamer
Edward Higley
William H. Hoover
Robert M. Horner
Robert Howell
Vincent Jester
David Jones
William Kappel
William Ambrose King
Harrison Kinney
Emanuel Kritzer
Joseph T. R. Lamb
William Leiby
James H. Lemon
Francis M. LeRoy
Isaiah Lomison
John Marrs
John Marshall
John W. Marshgrove
Christian F. Matznick
John Mauk
Samuel Mehaffey
Franklin Meson
John Murphy
William McCall
Florence McCarty
James H. McDowell
Daniel McGowan
AT WEST POINT 179
James McKinley
Robert Miller
Edward Moran
Michael McCabe
Patrick McDonald
Daniel Neely
Samuel Newcomb
Cyrus Newman
Jeremiah Nichols
Samuel G. Nunveller
Joshua W. Patten
David Perry
Joshua M. Prevost
Farrel Queenan
Suton B. Quin
Robert Raison
Alex. C. Ramsey
Daniel Reichart
Josephus Reis
Benjamin Riddle
Edward Rogers
Hamilton W. C. Roney
Newton Root
John Rourke
Robert Ruttman
Joseph Sandbach
Benjamin Scott
Thomas J. Scutt
Philip Sep
Harrison C. Smith
Jesse Sponsler
Joseph Styer
Thomas Suthers
Martin V. Suttle
i8o THE BATTLE MONUMENT
John Sweaney
Henry Symington
Charles W. Thompson
George Townsend
Charles H. Umbaugh
Lewis Vasion
Gustavus Vincent
John Walsh
William E. Walter
Harrison Wannamacher
John Waugh
Thomas E. Whiteside
David Wise
l6tb U. S. Infantry.
Commissary Sergeant James M. Howe
Sergeant Brice Veirs Baker
William D. Reynolds
Corporal Thomas Donahue
David C. Jennings
Alexander Kinkaid
Thomas O'Neill
Robert Robinson
Cortland Wells
Private Samuel C. Adams
Walter F. Amos
Hallett W. Barber
Alexander Boyle
Edward Brady
Amos Brainard
James Brooks
James Buck
Thomas Caldwell
Patrick Canon
AT WEST POINT 181
Erastus Cheedle
Frank Clark
Jacob Clement
Christian Corai
John Crabtree
Solomon H. Curtis
James Darcy
Gregory Drouillard
John Dubi
Fernando Ferguson
Carl Fjetterstrom
Nathan Frost
George E. Galligher
James Gillick
Francis A. Gilson
Nicholas Ginsburg
Nicholas Growney
John Harrison
Joseph Harper
Nicholas Hendelong
William J. Hendrickson
Martin Herrix
William Howard
John Hurley
George P. Hutchinson
Frederick Kalenbach
Patrick Keho
Michael Kilmartin
William J. Leslie •
Benjamin Lewis
James B. Lewis
Hugh Livingston
Charles Lyons
George Mahon
I2A
1 82 THE BATTLE MONUMENT
Charles A. Mann
Amos Mellott
Elias Minnich
Patrick Murphy
Felix McCarthy
Patrick McCaughy
John McLeod
Martin O'Connor
John Olson
Louis Orth
Dennis O' Sullivan
Thomas Owens
Charles Page
Lemuel K. Palmer
Ami Curtis Perry
Robert Pitts
George L. Pooler
Samuel Robinson
Robert W. Russell
James Saunders
Warren E. Sawyer
Coleman Shuff
Benjamin F. Silsby
Aaron Simons
Richard Stanley
Charles B. Stiteler
Hanson Stocdal
John Stokes
Samuel Swainbank
Wilford Trueblood
Valentine Vigar
Charles West
Zacariah G. White
John Williams
AT WEST POINT 183
iftb U. S. Infantry.
First Sergeant William H. T. Hogan
Sergeant Silas P. Blanchard
James M. Downs
Charles P. Giles
Henry P. Hyde
Henry J. Madison
Ransom L. Smith
Corporal Stephen G. Armstrong
Elias H. Baker
John Elliott
Dennis Fitzpatrick
Francis D. Gould
James Mitchell
John S. Pomeroy
John W. M. Small
John C. Wadsworth
Lester F. Wells
Private Albion T. E. Avery
Albert I. Allard
William F. Banks
Patrick Baron
Enos S. Bishop
Thomas Brozzen
David Burke
Charles P. Butler
William A. Byrne
William Cahill
Washington Cole
Daniel J. Conant
Solon L. Cornell
William J. Cottell
David Crider
William Duffy
1 84 THE BATTLE MONUMENT
Alphonso Estes
John Finton
Patrick Flood
Frederick W. Cans
Albert M. Gould
Michael Hallinan
George G. Hammond
Joseph Henny
Ephraim Holmes
Edwin A. Howard
Rufus B. Jameson
Thomas Kearney
George M. Kennerson
Louis Kilborn
Marcus Killam
John King
Michael King
Michael Landers
Nathaniel Lombard
Thomas Lynn
James Mangan
Michael Marshal
Patrick Mehan
James Merrill
Charles H. Miller
Jacob Mitchell
Michael Murphy
Samuel Murray
James McHough
John McMahon
Barney McNamee
Erskine E. McMillan
Amos Newland
Stover W. Nichols
AT WEST POINT 185
Patrick OJ Brian
Bartholomew O'Donnell
Michael O'Kane
George W. Paul
William Pender
Robert Perkins
Orlando H. Powers
Joseph Prince
George C. Prouty
William Schmidt
Fairy Selem
Sebastian Shaffer
George Sites
Carl Joseph Standar
Benjamin Stone
Edward Sullivan
Charles H. Temple
Henry Thompson
Isaac Travis
Josiah Victory
Charles H. Whitney
Constantine Yeker
i8tb U. S. Infantry.
Sergeant- Major Christopher Peterson
First Sergeant Zenas Dunham
Ruggels Elrick
George F. White
Sergeant James Barrett
John G. Boyce
Cheyney H. Dawson
Samuel Dobbins
Amos Flegal
Solomon Greenley
1 86 THE BATTLE MONUMENT
Henry Headley
Thomas W. Jesse
William P. Leibole
William D. Madeira
Thomas Shonessy
William Tombon
Tunis H. Swick
Joseph F. Wether
Corporal Jesse H. Brooks
Bernard C. Connelly
Joseph H. Dodds
John C. Donnelly
Warren D. Estabrook
John Falter
Alexander Goodwell
Joseph L. Harcourt
William H. Himes
Samuel Hobill
Jacob Leibole
John Linebaugh
Isaac Linn
Thomas J. Long
James Lowden
Engelbert A. Miller
Uriah H. McDowell
Patrick O'Connors
Francis M. Philippi
William Walter
Musician James Marsh
Private James Adair
John Alberty
Peter Altmeyer
James Anderson
James A. Anderson
AT WEST POINT 187
Charles Argus
S. T. Armstrong
John W. Arthur
William Baglin, Jr.
Gordon Beard
Ezra Beckwith
William H. Bellfield
Isaac Bemesdarfer
Edwin Benjamin
Andrew Bowers
Jacob Bike
Jacob Blessing
Joseph Bray
Bernard Brinck
George Brooks
Preston Brown
Henry Burns
Martin Burr
George W, Burton
Adolphus Caio
Arthur D. Cantrell
John J. Carmean
John Cashiell
John W. Cass
Bishop Church
Miller Clark
Abraham Combs
Andrew J. Connor
William Cornwall
William H. Crandall
Edward Cunningham
Samuel Daihl
Thomas B. Daniels
Alexander Dean
1 88 THE BATTLE MONUMENT
Thompson J. W. Devor
William H. Diehl
James Dixon
William Durller
George Eckert
Joseph F. Elcbeck
William Ennis
Joseph A. Ensign
Valentine Farrenkoff
James S. Fisher
James Fitzgerald
Willis B. Fitzgerald
Franklin S. Frick
John Fussalmann
Michael Gallivin
Philip Gorsuck
William Gray
Mahlon F. Hancock
James Handley
Elisha Harper
James Harrisson
John T. Havice
Jarret Claiborn Headington
Alexander Helmold
Moses C. Helvirson
Ambrose Higgins
Ferdinand Hill
Samuel Hill
Nicholas Holsbach
Joseph Hook
Jeremiah Howald
George W. Hoyt
Thomas Porter Hunley
W. W. Hutchison
AT WEST POINT 189
Joseph A. Hynus
John Jacobee
Joel Jacobs
John Jewel
Isaac B. Jones
Richard J. Jones
Frank Kelley
Fredric H. Kiest
George W. Kleckner
Daniel Kring
Edward P. Lacey
Charles W. Laff
Michael Larkin
William H. Larrowe
Anthony Livingston
Joseph Luken
James B. Massey
Francis Masterson
John Merten
Thomas Mooney
George H. Morrison
Samuel Mowrer
Patrick McDonnell
Peter Murphy
James W. McAdow
Alfred M. McGinnis
Robert McGuire
Thomas Nary
Robert F. Nightingale
Dennis O'Brien
James O'Neill
John O'Hara
James Ostrander
Samuel Palmer
1 9o THE BATTLE MONUMENT
John W. Parsons
Thornton Perry
Harvey Peters, Jr.
John W. Peters
William L. Pinney
Emery Plumley
George H. Poorman
Timothy Quinn
Martin Rapstock
Nathan Ray
Stephen Ray
David Redmon
Charles Reifenberg
Samuel C. Rhoads
Henry Rider
Charles Roberson
William H. Robey
Amos Robins
Patrick Savage
Joseph W. Sawyer
James M. Saxton
Theodore Schmitz
Charles Schreck
Hugh Scolan
Gideon W. B. Searight
Jacob Shaffer
Amos Sherman
Isaac S. Shoffner
Christian Shrack
George Shuler
William Sieg
Joseph Harrison Silk
George B. Smith
Harrison D. Smith
AT WEST POINT 191
Henry D. Smith
James Smith
John M. Smith
David Sours
George W. Stierhof
David D. Stine
George W. Stone
Francis Stoufer
George W. Stover
Martin V. Swank
William H. Swisher
Abraham Tabler
Jonas Tallhamer
Newton Tharp
William H. Thomas
James Thompson
John Henry Tieman
Jonathan Trueblood
George Waterfield
Alexander White
William E. Wilison
Isaac Wilson
John Wilson
Joseph Wosmer
Franklin Zimmerman
i$tb U. S. Infantry.
Sergeant James F. Day
Patrick Leonard
John H. Topky
Corporal Lewis Bols
Nicholas Clemenz
Benjamin Davis
Thomas Doyle
i92 THE BATTLE MONUMENT
Joseph Purer
Frederick Kunzel
John Reed
Alexander Van Dolkum
John R. Waller
Private John W. Barnes
John Boyer
Thomas Brennen
Charles Brown
David M. Chubb
John Dignan
Townsend E. Fall
Alexander Filson
Michael P. Fishell
David Gifford
George Goettinger
Edward Gorman
Bernard Haggerty
Joseph Hendricks
Samuel C. Higgins
• Alexander Hood
Peter Laughlin
Aaron Luther
Patrick Lynch
William Manning
George W. McGuinn
John O'Brien
James Pierson
Henry Porter
John Quinn
Willhun Randall
William Resor
Jacob Romig
John Schilbe
AT WEST POINT 193
Philip Schrom
Henry Shul
Adam Smith
James Smith
Claiborne Taliafero
Charles Tanner
Paul Tatem
Henry Thompson
Henry T. Tibbits
John Wilger
RECAPITULATION
Total number of officers killed . ;> . . . 188
Total' number of enlisted men killed .«;.;. . ." 2042
OFFICERS.
General Officers . . .... . . 2
General Staff Officers . . ' . 4
Staff Corps.
Corps of Engineers .... 7
Corps of Topographical Engineers ... 2
Ordnance Department • . ... 2
Total Staff Corps 1 1
Cavalry.
ist Cavalry . 8 4th Cavalry . . 5
2d Cavalry . . 5 5th Cavalry » * 8
3d Cavalry . . 2 6th Cavalry . . 8
Total Cavalry 36
194
AT WEST POINT 195
Artillery.
ist Artillery . . 8 4th Artillery . .. • 6
zd Artillery . 5 5th Artillery . . 10
3d Artillery . . 3
Total Artillery 3z
Infantry.
\ st Infantry
. ' Z
nth Infantry
8
zd
9
izth "
n
3d «
z
1 3th "
4
4th "
4
I4th "
10
5th ««
3
1 5th "
4
6th «
z
1 6th "
9
7th
4
1 7th
9
8th "
3
1 8th
9
9th "
o
1 9th "
4
loth "
6
_____
Total Infantry 103
ENLISTED MEN.
Staff Corps.
Battalion of Engineers z Signal Corps . 6
Ordnance Corps . i General Service . i
Total Staff Corps 10
Cavalry.
ist Cavalry . 79 4th Cavalry . 4z
zd " . 7z 5th " . 5z
3d " z6 .6th " 47
Total Cavalry 318
196
THE BATTLE MONUMENT
ist Artillery
2d "
3d
Artillery.
76 4th Artillery
48 5th '«
39
Total Artillery
80
81
Infantry.
ist Infantry . .
3i
1 1 th Infantry
115
2d " . ,.;
87
1 2th
118
3d « .
37
ijth " .
52
4th
51
1 4th " - .
150
5th
16
i5th » .
. 129
6th "
31
1 6th " .
87
7th "
47
1 7th
89
8th "
13
1 8th
. 205
9th "
0
1 9th
51
loth
81
Total Infantry I 390
LIST OF ORIGINAL SUBSCRIBERS FOR
THE BATTLE MONUMENT.
Name and Rank. Amount.
Abbot, H. L., Captain of Engineers . . . $13.00
Abert, J. W., Major of Engineers . . . 10.00
Alderdice & Co., Sutlers, 1 2th Infantry . . 10.00
Aldrich, B., Lieutenant 8th Infantry . . . 7.00
Alexander, C. T., Surgeon . , . . 10.00
Alexander, E. B., Colonel loth Infantry . . 13.00
Ames, A., Brigadier-General; Lieutenant 5th Artillery 18.00
Ames, E. R., Lieutenant 7th Infantry . . . 10.00
Amory, T. J. C., Col. Mass. Vols.; Capt. 7th Infy. 13.00
Anderson, T. M., Captain loth Infantry . . 10.00
Andrews, C. C., Colonel 3d Minn. Volunteers . 13.00
Arnold, A. K. , Captain 5th Cavalry . . . 10.00
Arnold, Isaac .-»...,. . . . 7.00
Arnold, W. F., Lieutenant 8th Infantry . . 7.00
Ash, J. P., Captain 5th Cavalry . * , > .-. . 10.00
Atchison, C. B., Capt. A. D. C. Vols.; Lt. 3d Inf. 8.00
Austin, R. H., Capt. 24th Wisconsin Volunteers • 10.00
Ayres, R., Lieutenant I9th Infantry . . . 10.00
Babbitt, L. S., 1st Lieutenant Ord. Department . 10.00
Bache, H., Colonel of Engineers ... • : .:: . . 13.00
ISA '97
198 THE BATTLE MONUMENT
Name and Rank. Amount.
Bacon, C., Jr., Assistant Surgeon . . . $7.00
Baden, J. T., Lieutenant 5th Cavalry . . . 10.00
Bailey, T. C. J., Captain ijth Infantry . . 10.00
Bainbridge, E. C., Captain 5th Artillery . . 8.00
Bainbridge, A. H., Lieutenant I4th Infantry . 7.00
Baird, A., Brigadier-General .... 50.00
Baldwin, H. M., 2d Lieutenant 5th Artillery . 10.00
Bales, F. H., Captain, retired .... 8.00
Ball, E., Lieutenant 1st Cavalry . . . . 7.00
Bankhead, H. C., Captain 5th Infantry . . 11.00
Barclay, C. B. (Citizen) . . . I'* 100.00
Barry, R. P., Captain 1 6th Infantry .. . .. 8.00
Barry, W. F., Brig. -Gen., Major 5th Artillery . 18.00
Bartholomew, W. H., Captain i6th Infantry . 7.00
Bartlett, C. G., Captain 1 2th Infantry . . 10.00
Bartlett, W. H. C., Prof. U. S. M. A. • w' . . 15.00
Beaumont, E. B., Captain 4th Cavalry . . 8.00
Beckwith, A., Major Subsistence Department . 15.00
Beecher, H. B., Lieutenant 4th Artillery . . 10.00
Beecher, Rev. H. W. ..... 50.00
Benet, S. V., Captain Ordnance Department . . 10.00
Benham, H. W., Brigadier-General Volunteers . 18.00
Benjamin, S. N., Lieutenant 3d Artillery -** . 10.00
Benton, J. G., Captain Ordnance Department . 10.00
Best, C. L., Captain 4th Artillery . . . n.oo
Bisbee, W. H., Lieutenant i8th Infantry . . 7.00
Bliss, A., Captain and A. Q. M. . • V . 20.00
Blunt, C. E., Major Engineers . . -. . 10.00
Blunt, M. M., Captain I2th Infantry . » . 8.00
Board, C. A. F., retired . . .• W. ,. . 8.00
Bomford, J. V., lieutenant-Colonel i6th Infantry . n.oo
Bonneville, B. L. E., Colonel, retired . . . 13.00
Bowman, A. H., Colonel of Engineers . . 40.00
AT WEST POINT
199
Name and Rank. Amount.
Boyce, P., Lieutenant 8th Infantry . . . v $10.00
Brackett, A. G., Colonel Vols.; Major 1st Cavalry 13.00
Brady, G. K., Lieutenant I4th Infantry '. . 7.00
Brainerd, T. C., Assistant Surgeon . . -,-.. 10.00
Brewerton, H., Lieutenant-Colonel of Engineers . 25.00
Brigham, E. D., Capt. Com. Sub. . . '•. '». .._- 8.00
Britton, T., Lieutenant 6th Infantry . , . .. - 7.00
Brooks, W. T. H., Major-General . i ^ , ^,v. 30.00
Brown, F. H., Lieutenant i8th Infantry » :.. . ,.,, '.. 7.00
Brown, H., Lieutenant i8th Infantry . • ... . • 7.00
Buchanan, R. C., Lieut. -Colonel 1 4th Infantry . n.oo
Buell, D. C., Major-General Volunteers . . . 30.00
Buffington, A. R., Captain Ordnance Department . 10.00
Burbank, S. W., Captain I4th Infantry . . 10.00
Burke, D. W., Lieutenant ad Infantry . . . 10.00
Burke, P. E., Captain 1 4th Infantry „ ..; .-. • :; . 8.00
Burnett, R. L., Lieutenant izth Infantry .-.. . 7 Too
Burnham, H. M., First Lieutenant 4th Artillery . 25.00
Burns, T., Lieutenant ist Cavalry ..«* . .-' • ./i. ; 10.00
Burns, W. W., Brigadier-General . , . ' . 18.00
Burroughs, Geo., Lieutenant Engineers . . 10.00
Bush, E. G., Captain loth Infantry . ;t . 8.00
Butler, J., Lieutenant 2d Infantry , , . . 7.00
Butterfield, D., Major-General . v . . 27.00
Byrne, T., Lieutenant 2d Infantry . , . . . 7.00
Callender, F. D., Major Ordnance Department . 10.00
Canby, S., Lieutenant 4th Artillery . . . 7.00
Card, B. C., Captain and A. Q. M. , .;> ,*•»»,, 8.00
Carlin, W. P., Brigadier-General . . . 20.00
Carney, J. D., Captain I7th Infantry . « . 8.00
Carpenter, A. B., Lieutenant I9th Infantry . .. 10.00
Carpenter, T. H., Captain I7th Infantry v . ' . C 8.00
Carr, C. C. C., Lieutenant ist Cavalry ,.- . * ;.; 10.00
OF THJT
UNIVERSITY
f o7 ~ ,,
200 THE BATTLE MONUMENT
Name and Rank. Amount.
Carr, E. A., Brigadier-General .... $18.00
Carter, J. W., Lieutenant lyth Infantry . . 7.00
Casey, Silas, Major-General .... 30.00
Casey, T. L., Major Corps of Engineers . . 10.00
Chaffee, C. C., Lieutenant Ordnance Department . 15.00
Chambers, A., Brigadier-General; Capt. i8th Infantry 20.00
Chambliss, W. P., Major 4th Cavalry . . . 10.00
Chapman, W., Lieutenant-Colonel, retired . . 11.00
Chevers, M. L., Chaplain* U. S. A. . . . 8.00
Choisey, G. L., Lieutenant i/fth Infantry . . 7.00
Clarke, F. M., Captain 5th Artillery . .„•-• . 10.00
Clay, H. DeB., Captain I4th Infantry . . 8.00
Clay, J. K., Lieutenant I4th Infantry . ;' . 7.00
Clements, B. A., Surgeon . . . « * ' . 10.00
Clinton, Wm., Captain loth Infantry . . . 10.00
Coates, E. M., Lieutenant I2th Infantry . . 10.00
Cdggswell, M., Captain 8th Infantry . . . 10.00
Cole, A. A., Lieutenant 7th Infantry . . . 7.00
Coleman, R. W., Civilian ....*. 15.00
Collins, G. H., Civilian . . . *-., . 10.00
Comly, C., Lieutenant Ordnance Department . 20.00
Comstock, C. B., Captain Corps of Engineers , n.oo
Conrad, J. S., Captain 2d Infantry ;.'. .-. •',. 8.00
Coolidge, R. H,, Medical Inspector . -A . 15.00
Cooper, S. W., Lieutenant 8th Infantry . . 7.00
Coppinger, J. J., Captain 141)1 Infantry .-" . 10.00
Cornick, W. F., Assistant Surgeon . . , '- 7.00
Counselman, J. H., Lieutenant 1st Artillery . .'.-.' 10.00
Crilly, F. J., Captain and A. Q^ M. . ; - , 10.00
Crofton, R. E. A., Captain i6th Infantry • j . / , 8.00
Crosman, C. H., Colonel and Quartermaster . 13.00
Cross, O., Lieutenant-Colonel and Quartermaster . 15.00
Culbertson, S. S., Lieutenant I9th Infantry . . 10.00
AT WEST POINT 201
Name and Rank. Amount.
Curtis, A., Lieutenant I9th Infantry . . . $10.00
Curtis, S. R., Major-General . . . •< '.,''' 27.00
Gushing, H. C., Lieutenant 4th Artillery . U . 10.00
Cuyler, J. M., Surgeon U. S. A. . . ,\ 15.00
Dallis, A. ]., Captain . „'• 10.00
Darling, J. A., Major Vols. ; Lieut, zd Artillery . 10.00
Davidson, J. W., Brigadier-General . . . 18.00
Davis, O. E., First Lieutenant of Engineers . . 7.00
Davis, R., Lieutenant zd Infantry . . -» 7.00
Davis, T., Lieutenant 1 9th Infantry . . ''.,,- 10.00
Dean, W., Lieutenant ist Cavalry . - .-• -'. 10.00
DeCourcy, F. E., Lieutenant I3th Infantry . . . 10.00
DeKay, D., Lieutenant I4th Infantry i. .; 7.00
Delafield, R., Colonel of Engineers . . . 50.00
Denton, A. B., i8th Infantry . . • . . 10.00
DeRussy, R. E., Colonel of Engineers . . 25.00
Dimmick, J., Colonel U. S. A. . . . 13.00
Dodge, R. I., Captain 8th Infantry . V . 10.00
Dolan, M., Lieutenant zd Infantry •- * . . 10.00
Donaldson, J. L., Major Q^ M. Department . 15.00
Dorman, O. M., Paymaster Volunteers . . 10.00
Doubleday, A., Major I7th Infantry ; Major-General Z7.oo
Downey, G. M., Lieutenant I4th Infantry . . 8.00
Dowling, J. T., Lieutenant I7th Infantry . . 7.00
Drouillard, J. P., Captain 6th Infantry . . 8.00
Drum, W. F., Captain zd Infantry , . . 8.00
Drummond, Thos., Captain 5th Cavalry . » 10.00
Drury, T., Lieutenant zd Infantry v . • fc 7.00
Dryer, H., Captain 4th Infantry . . .- !, 8.00
DuBarry, B., Major and Com. Sub. . «. , », 10.00
DuBois, J. V., Captain 3d Cavalry ; Col. of Vols. . 13.00
Dudley, J. S., Lieutenant zd Artillery . * . 7.00
Duer, E. A., Lieutenant ist Artillery . . »• • 10.00
202 THE BATTLE MONUMENT
Name and Rank. Amount.
Duncan, T., Major 3d Cavalry . . . $10.00
Dunn, T. S., Lieutenant loth Infantry . . 10.00
DuPont, H. A., Lieutenant 5th Artillery . . 7.00
Dutton, A. H., Lieutenant of Engineers . . 15.00
Earle, M., Lieutenant loth Infantry . . . 10.00
Eckert, G. B., Lieutenant 3d Infantry . . . 7.00
Eddy, A. R., Captain and A. Q^ M. . . . 8.00
Edgerton, W. G., Captain nth Infantry . . 8.00
Edie, J. R., Lieutenant Ordnance Department . 10.00
Edson, T., Captain Ordnance Department . . 8.00
Edwards, D., Lieutenant I9th Infantry . . 10.00
Egbert, H. C., Lieutenant izth Infantry * . 10.00
Eggemeyer, A., Lieutenant loth Infantry .. ,' . 10.00
Elder, S. S., Captain 1st Artillery -,,«-., ;. , ' - . , 8.00
Elliot, G. H., Captain of Engineers . Y . 20.00
Elliott, W. L., Brigadier-General ; Major ist Cav. 20.00
Ellis, H. A., Captain I7th Infantry . . . 10.00
Emerson, J. J., Lieutenant 1 7th Infantry . . . ' 7.00
Estes, C. A. M., Lieutenant i6th Infantry . . 10.00
Evans, A. W., Captain 6th Cavalry . ,«<' . 10.00
Ewers, E. P., Lieutenant I9th Infantry ;. . .>-. . 7.00
Falk, W., Lieutenant 2d Infantry . , . 7.00
Falvey, J., Lieutenant 3d Cavalry - •» . • 7.00
Farley,}. P., Lieutenant of Ordnance . . * /f 7.00
Farquhar, F. U., Captain of Engineers . ... 8.00
Feiler, N. J., Captain ist Cavalry . . , v 10.00
Fessenden, F., Col. Vols. ; Capt. I2th Infantry . 13.00
Fetterman, W. J., Captain i8th Infantry , •-* ,. i 8.00
Field, J. H. V., Lieutenant Ordnance Department 7.00
Fitzgerald, J., Lieutenant 2d Artillery . . v. 7.00
Fitzhugh, C. L., Lieutenant 4th Artillery '>.,-.., 10.00
Flagler, D. W., Captain Ordnance Department . 10.00
Fletcher, C. H., Captain ist Infantry . ,-. j, ;= 8.00
AT WEST POINT 203
Name and Rank. Amount.
Flint, F. F., Lieutenant-Colonel . : .• . $15.00
Foot, A., Lieutenant I4th Infantry . ; .. 7.00
Forsyth, J. W., Captain i8th Infantry ' * •• •••,{.'- . 10.00
Foster,}. G., Major-General . . .,. r v>. 30.00
Frank, R. T., Captain 8th Infantry . I , . 10.0.0
Franklin, W. B., Major-General ; Col. I 2th Infantry 30.00
Franklin, W. S., Captain I2th Infantry . . 8.00
French, W. H., Major-General . ,-, ' •«•••< . . 30.00
Fry, J. B., Major, A. A. G., Prov. Mar. General 13.00
Gansevoort, H. S., Lt. 5th Art. ; Col. N. Y. Vol. Cav. 1 3.00
Gapen, H. C., Lieutenant I5th Infantry . . 7.00
Gardiner, J. W. T., Major, retired * . . 10.00
Garrard, K., Brigadier-General ; Captain 5th Cavalry 20.00
Gentry, W. T., Captain I7th Infantry . . 10.00
Getty, T. M., Surgeon . ;• • ^"v . .. 10.00
Gibbon, J., Brigadier-General . . . 20.00
Gibbs, J. S., Lieutenant ist Artillery . ,,?••' . 7.00
Gibbs, T. K., Lieutenant ist Artillery . . 7.00
Gibson, A. A., Major 2d Artillery . . . 10.00
Gibson, H. G., Col. of Vols. ; Major 3d Cavalry . 13.00
Giddings, G. R., Major I4th Infantry . . . 10.00
Gilbert, C. C., Major I9th Infantry . . . 10.00
Gillespie, G. L., Lieutenant of Engineers . . 10.00
Gillmore, Q^ A., Major-General . . . 27.00
Gilman, J. H., Captain and Com. Sub. . . 8.00
Goddard, C. C., Captain I7th Infantry . . 10.00
Goddard, C. E., Assistant Surgeon . ... 7.00
Goodhue, J. M., Captain nth Infantry . . 8.00
Gooding,O. P.,Capt. loth Inf. ; Col. 6th Mass. Cav. 1 3.00
Gordan, G. H., Brig. -Gen. (late Capt. M. Rifles) . 25.00
Graham,}. D., Colonel of Engineers . " . . - 20.00
Granger, G., Major-General . -. . ;.^ 27.00
Granger, R. S., Brigadier-General ; ; . * ; 20.00
204 THE BATTLE MONUMENT
Name and Rank. Amount.
Grant, U. S., Lieutenant-General . . . $50.00
Greene, J. D., Colonel 8th Infantry . . . 20.00
Greene, O. D., Major, A. A. G. . . . 10.00
Green, M. C., Lieutenant I3th Infantry . . 10.00
Grier, W. N., Lieutenant-Colonel ist Cavalry . n.oo
Grossman, F. E., Lieutenant 7th Infantry . . 8.00
Haight, E., Captain Vols. ; Lieutenant i6th Infantry 10.00
Haines, T. J., Colonel, Com. Sub. . . . 13.00
Hall, J. A., Lieutenant ist Cavalry . . . 10.00
Hall, R. H., Captain loth Infantry . . . 20.00
Hall, R. M., Lieutenant ist Artillery . . . 7.00
Hamilton, J., Captain 3d Artillery . . . 8.00
Hamilton, S. M., Lieutenant 3d Infantry . . 7.00
Hammond, J. F., Surgeon . - . - • ,. . . 10.00
Harbach, A. A., Lieutenant nth Infantry . . 10.00
Hardin, M. D., Lieut. -Col. Vols.; Lieut. 3d Art'y 30.00
Hargrave, R. W., Lieutenant I7th Infantry . . 7.00
Harker, C. G., Captain 1 5th Infantry . • . 13.00
Harrington, G., Lieutenant 3d Cavalry . • *.' 7.00
Harris, W. H., Captain Ordnance . ,';•. , . 10.00
Haskin, J. A., Major 3d Artillery . , . 12.00
Hastings, J., Lieutenant 5th Cavalry . . . 10.00
Hawkins, H. S., Captain 6th Infantry . . . 10.00
Hawkins, J. P., Brig.-Gen., Capt., and A. C. S. . 50.00
Hawley, W., Lieutenant 3d Cavalry . . . 7.00
Hay, C. E., Lieutenant 3d Artillery . -. > 12.00
Haymond, H., Captain i8th Infantry . .„• . 10.00
Hazen, H. E., Lieutenant 8th Infantry .,.:,-. ;..t 7.00
Head, J. F., Surgeon . . . .; . . 10.00
Hearn, J. H., Lieutenant i6th Infantry . .. 10.00
Hecksher, J. G., Captain I2th Infantry . . 10.00
Heilman, W. H., First Lieutenant I5th Infantry . 7.00
Heintzelman, S. P., Major-General . . . 30.00
AT WEST POINT 205
Name and Rank. Amount.
Hendrickson, T., Major U. S. A. . . . $10.00
Henley, J. P., Lieutenant 5th Artillery -^ •'•'• .^ 8.00
Henry, G. V., Lieut, ist Artillery ; Col. of Vols. 13.00
Hickox, C. R., Lieutenant 5th Artillery * .< ' •*. * 10.00
Higbee, G. H., Lieutenant nth Infantry « ^ J * 10.00
Hildeburn, S., Lieutenant 3d Cavalry . ' %• • • .' 20.00
Hitchcock, E. A., Major-General . ^ » • . 50.00
Hodges, H. C., Captain and A. Q. M. . -.'" 10.00
Hoffman, Wm., Colonel 3d Infantry . . . .' 15.00
Holden, L. H., Surgeon -«•«; • • • '.••^•* 10.00
Holman, Chas., Lieutenant 5th Artillery v , J *f> 7.00
Honey, S. A., Lieutenant I5th Infantry .; • 7.00
Hooker, J., Major-General '- «' - * . . . • -•'..• I 27.00
Hope, L. F. * • *< . •*' -. . . 5.00
Hopkins, J. A., Lieutenant I7th Infantry . . *> 7.00
Hotsenpiller, C. W., Lieutenant i6th Infantry •>. ,: 7.00
Howard, C. O., Captain i8th Infantry •' . 10.00
Howard, O. O., Major-General . . . •% • 27.00
Howard, R. V. W., Lieut.-Col.Vols.; Capt. 4th Art. i i.oo
Howland, G. W., Captain 3d Cavalry . » . 8.00
Hubbard, V. B., Assistant Surgeon . . . 10.00
Hubbs, W. H., Lieutenant I3th Infantry -i . 10.00
Hudson, E. McK., Captain I4th Infantry . . 10.00
Hunt, J. C., Lieutenant ist Cavalry . . . . 10.00
Hunt, J. S., Lieutenant 4th Artillery * . . 10.00
Huntington, H. A., Lieutenant 4th Artillery . 10.00
Ilges, G., Captain I4th Infantry .- . .« 8.00
Ingalls, R., Brigadier-General . ;. ' . . 18.00
Ingham, G. T., Lieutenant nth Infantry . ( .-', 20.00
Ireland, D., Captain I5th Infantry ~±_: . -v' 13.00
Irish, D. C., Captain I3th Infantry . * •« - -.^ 8.00
Irvine, J. B., Lieutenant I3th Infantry -.*T -. ^ 10.00
Irwin, B. J. D., Surgeon . . . " * i 10.00
206 THE BATTLE MONUMENT
Name and Rank. Amount.
Jackson, J., Lieutenant loth Infantry . . . $10.00
Jackson, R. H., Captain i st Artillery . . . n.oo
James, F. J., Lieutenant 3d Cavalry . . . 20.00
Jane way, J. H., Assistant Surgeon . . . 7.00
Johnson, J. B. . . . . . . . 10.00
Johnson, G. W., Lieutenant igth Infantry . . 7.00
Johnson, R. W., Brigadier-General . . . 18.00
Jones, DeL. Floyd, Lieutenant-Colonel I9th Infantry 11.00
Kane, J. H., First Lieutenant 5th Artillery . . 10.00
Kurtz, J. D., Major of Engineers .... 10.00
Kellogg, E. R., Lieutenant i6th Infantry . . 7.00
Kellogg, J., Captain and A. C. S. . . . 10.00
Kelton, J. C., Major and A. A. G. . . . 20.00
Kendrick, H. L., Professor U. S. M. A. .. . 20.00
Kennington, J., Lieutenant 1 1 th Infantry . . 7.00
Kensel, G. A., Capt. 5th Art.; Lt.-Col. of Vols. n.oo
Kent, J. Ford, Capt. 3d Inf.; Lt.-Col. A. I. G. . n.oo
Keteltas, H., Captain I5th Infantry . . .{. 8.00
Keyes, E. D., Major-General ; Colonel nth Infantry 27.00
Keyes, H. W., Captain I4th Infantry . . «, ' 10.00
Kilburn, C. L., Lieutenant- Colonel and Com. Sub. n.oo
King, C. L., Captain loth Infantry . . .10.00
King, W. R., Lieutenant of Engineers . ; -. . 7.00
Kingsbury, C. P., Major Ordnance Department . 10.00
Kinzie, D. H., Lieutenant 5th Artillery ,.,^ .,•> 7.00
Kirtland, F. S., Lieutenant i8th Infantry ^ j *,,., 7.00
Knowlton, M., Captain, retired ., . :r,v. . 8.00
Kress, J. A., Lieutenant Ordnance Department . 7.00
Lacy, F. E., Lieutenant 2d Infantry . ; . l..; . 7.00
Lay, R. G., Captain 3d Infantry f». . . 8.00
Laidley, T. T. S., Major Ordnance Department . 10.00
Lancaster, G., Lieutenant I7th Infantry . . 7.00
Lane, W. B., Captain 3d Cavalry . ;-. < . 10.00
AT WEST POINT 207
Name and Rank. Amount.
Langdon, L. L., Captain 1st Artillery . . . $8.00
Lauman, G. S., Captain loth Infantry - ..-} . 10.00
Larned, C. T., Paymaster . . . J . ' •'• v'V. ^:- 10.00
Latimer, A. E., Captain nth Infantry . ^:/.,. .2J~/: 20.00
Leahy, M., Lieutenant ist Artillery . . ' .,.' 7.00
LeConte, J. L., Surgeon .... : j 25.00
Leib, E. H., Captain 5th Cavalry . r :. . . V 10.00
Leonard, H., Lieutenant-Colonel Pay Department . n.oo
Lind, J. S., Lieutenant i8th Infantry . . ..;* . 7.00
Lindsly, W., Assistant Surgeon . . . •• <& «; 7.00
Livingston, L. L., Captain 3d Artillery Nl^v' > <v . 8.00
Long, E., Col. 4th Ohio Cavalry ; Capt. 4th Cavalry 15.00
Long, J. W., Captain zd Infantry . , .-. .' *;>: 8.00
Lorentz, Antoine, Sword-Master U. S. M. A. ,»-J 10.00
Lowell, C. R., Col. zd Mass. Cav.; Capt. 6th Cav. 13.00
Lattimore, W. O., Lieutenant igth Infantry . [ ^f"', 10.00
Lyman, G. H., Lieutenant-Colonel Medical Dept. n.oo
Lynn, D. D., Captain 6th Infantry '* - „ . 8.00
Lyster, W. J., Lieutenant ipth Infantry ' * -. 10.00
Mack, O. A., Captain I3th Infantry ; • ,*1 .« • i/ ' 10.25
Macomb, J. N., Lieutenant-Colonel of Engineers . 20.00
Maley, T. E., Lieutenant 5th Cavalry *' . 10.00
Marcy, R. B., Colonel, Inspector General - ,; . 13.00
Marshall, L. H., Major i6th Infantry, Col. of Vols. 13.00
Marye, W. A., Lieutenant Ordnance Department . 10.00
Mason, E. C., Captain I7th Infantry . . ' . < 13.00
Mason, J. W., Captain 5th Cavalry •. . .«_ . 10.00
May, J. H., Lieutenant loth Infantry . ' > • ^-' i • 10.00
Maynadier, H. E., Captain I5th Infantry v ,..*: . 10.00
Maynadier, W., Colonel Ordnance Department . 15.00
McCall, C. A., Assistant Surgeon . >.* - * . .i* . 7.00
McClellan, E., Assistant Surgeon . :>:»J' ! *\^ 7.00
McClintock, J., Captain I4th Infantry ; * .; . 8.00
208 THE BATTLE MONUMENT
Name and Rank. Amount.
McCook, A. McD., Major-General . . . $50.00
McCormick, C., Surgeon U. S. A. . . . 10.00
McCrea, Tully, Lieutenant ist Artillery . . 7.00
McDowell, I., Major-General .... 27.00
McFeely, R., Lieutenant-Colonel Com. Dept. . n.oo
McGee, Lieutenant 1 3th Infantry . < ,. _•:.. 8.00
McGilvray, J., Lieutenant 4th Artillery . >; ., 7.00
McGinniss, J. R., Lieutenant Ordnance Department 10.00
McKee, S., Captain ist Cavalry . . <?,* • ... . 10.00
McKee, S. A., Captain zd Infantry * •-» . * 8.00
McKeever, C., Major, A. A. G. . . .'» . 10.00
McKibbin, C., Lieutenant 1 4th Infantry .... ,.; 7.00
McKibbin, D. B., Lieutenant I4th Infantry . «, 10.00
McKibbin, R. P., Captain 4th Infantry -,* •• . 7.00
McKibbin, Sutler 1 2th Infantry (citizen) ' -. ,. . 10.00
McKnight, J., Captain 5th Artillery . . ? . 25.00
McLaren, A. N., Surgeon U. S. A. . , ! •. . .. 10.00
McLaughlin, N. B., Captain 4th Cavalry . .,' 10.00
McLoughlin, G. H., Lieutenant 2d Infantry » 7.00
McMullin, G. O., Lieutenant 3d Cavalry . . '> 7.00
McNally, C. H., Captain 3d Cavalry . ... 8.00
McNutt, J., Captain Ordnance Department . . 10.00
Meade, G. G., Major-General .... 30.00
Meigs, J. R., Lieutenant of Engineers . . .. 10.00
Meigs, M. C., Brigadier-General, Q. M. General 20.00
Meinhold, C., Lieutenant 3d Cavalry . . / -, = 7.00
Meline, J. F., Colonel of Volunteers, A. D. C. . 10.00
Mendenhall, J., Captain 4th Artillery . ••.. . r .. 10.00
Merrill, L., Colonel of Volunteers, Captain 2d Cav. 13.00
Merrill, W. E., Captain of Engineers . , .' .* 10.00
Michie, P. S., Lieutenant of Engineers . ; .' . 7.00
Miles, Evan, Lieutenant 1 2th Infantry . „ . 10.00
Milhau, J. J., Surgeon U. S. A. . V . . .; >•.-. 15.00
AT WEST POINT 209
Name and Rank. Amount.
Miller,]. F., Captain 1 4th Infantry . . . $8.00
Miller, M. S., Major and Quartermaster . . . 10.00
Mills, M., Surgeon £ % ,. - 10.00
Mills, W., Lieutenant i6th Infantry . •'•. . „'• ..* 7.00
Mills, W. H., First Lieutenant I4th Infantry . 10.00
Monahan, D., Lieutenant 3d Cavalry . \ .. . 10.00
Montgomery, D. L., Captain iyth Infantry . . 10.00
Moody, G. C., Captain I9th Infantry . ,,*-: , . 10.00
Mooney, J., Captain 1 9th Infantry . . &..\. 10.00
Mordecai, A., Captain Ordnance Department . ->. f 10.00
Morehead, W. J., Captain iyth Infantry -. y ; 10.00
Morgan, C. A., Colonel of Vols., 4th Artillery . 13.00
Morgan, H. C., Lieutenant loth Infantry . .-,.. >: 10.00
Morgan, M. R., Lieutenant-Colonel, Com. Sub. . n.oo
Morris, L. O., Captain 1st Artillery . . . 10.00
Morris, R. L., Captain i8th Infantry . . ., . 10.00
Morris, L. T., Lieutenant I9th Infantry . . 10.00
Morrison, P., Colonel, retired . » * . 13.00
Mulhenberg, F. P., Captain I3th Infantry . . 10.00
Mulligan, J. B., Captain I9th Infantry ...%. . 10.00
Myers, E., Lieutenant ist Cavalry ,J. .. . 10.00
Myers, F., Lieutenant-Colonel and Quartermaster . 13.00
Myers,}., Lieutenant Ordnance Department . 8.00
Myers, Wm., Quartermaster > . . . . 13.00
Myrick, J. R., Lieutenant 3d Artillery . . 10.00
Nash, B. F., Lieutenant 5th Artillery . . . 7.00
Nealy, O. H., Lieutenant nth Infantry . ..,, . 7.00
Neill, T. H., Brigadier-General . >r*\ .• H. ' 18.00
Noble, H. B., Lieutenant 8th Infantry . •.-. . , 10.00
Noggle, C. L., Lieutenant 2d Infantry . «. . • 7.00
Norris, B., Surgeon . . . •*; : . ^,. 10.00
Norton, A. S., Major and A. D. C. Volunteers . 18.00
Norton, G. D., Captain I4th Infantry ^ :. . 8.00
zio THE BATTLE MONUMENT
Name and Rank. Amount.
Noyes, H. E., First Lieutenant zd Cavalry . . $10.00
Oakes, J., Lieutenant-Colonel 4th Cavalry . . 20.00
O'Beirne, R. F., Captain I4th Infantry . . 10.00
Ogden, F. C., Lieutenant 1st Cavalry . . . 10.00
Ogden, R. L., Captain and A. Q. M. . . 8.00
Ostrander, J. S., Lieutenant i8th Infantry . . 7.00
Otis, E., Captain 4th Cavalry . . . . 8.00
Palmer, Innis N., Brigadier-General . . . 18.00
Parke, J. B., Lieutenant loth Infantry . . . 7.00
Parke, J. G., Major-General .... 50.00
Parker, D., Captain 3d Infantry . .• . . 10.00
Parker, R. C., Lieutenant I2th Infantry . . 10.00
Parry, E. R., Lieutenant nth Infantry . . . 10.00
Patterson, H. W., Lieutenant 4th Infantry . . 7.00
Patterson,]. H., Lieutenant nth Infantry . . 7.00
Patterson, W. W., Lieutenant loth Infantry . . 10.00
Paul, G. R., Lieutenant-Colonel 8th Infantry . 11.00
Pease, W. B., Captain I7th Infantry . . . 8.00
Pease, W. R., Captain 7th Infantry . . . 8.00
Pennington, A. C. M., Lieutenant 2d Artillery . 7.00
Penrose, W. H., Colonel of Vols. ; Capt. 3d Inf. . 15.00
Perkins, D. D., Captain 4th Artillery . ; . 10.00
Perry, D., Lieutenant ist Cavalry . V . 10.00
Pettee, L., Lieutenant nth Infantry . . . 10.00
Phelps, E., Lieutenant 191)1 Infantry . . . . 7.00
Phelps, J. E., Lieutenant 3d Cavalry . v . 15.00
Phipps, F. H., Lieutenant Ordnance Department . 7.00
Phisterer, F., Lieutanant i8th Infantry . . 7.00
Pike, H. L., Lieutenant ist Artillery . . . 7.00
Pineo, P., Lieutenant-Colonel Medical Department. n.oo
Pleasonton, A., Major-General * •• • :„ i . . 27.00
Pomeroy, C. C., Captain nth Infantry . . 8.00
Pope, J., Major-General . ». . . . 50.00
AT WEST POINT 211
Name and Rank. Amount.
Porter, A. P., Lieut. -Colonel.; Capt. Sub. Dept. . $50.00
Porter, G. L., Assistant Surgeon . . v * - 10.00
Porter, H., Captain Ordnance Department . . 16.00
Porter, R. H., Lieutenent I4th Infantry . . 7.00
Potter, J. A., Captain and A. Q. M. . . . 8.00
Potter,]. H., Major yth Infantry . « . . 13.00
Pratt, H. C., Major and Paymaster U. S. A. . 10.00
Prescott, W. H., Captain i6th Infantry . . 20.00
Prime, N., Captain lyth Infantry •* - , ; . 10.00
Prince, F. E., Captain loth Infantry . .. . 10.00
Procter, J. L., Captain i8th Infantry . . . 8.00
Purcell, J. H., Lieutenant ist Infantry . . . 7.00
Putnam, H. R., Captain I2th Infantry . . . 10.00
Putnam,]. E., Lieutenant izth Infantry . . 10.00
Pyne, C. M., Lieutenant 6th Infantry . . . 12.00
Ramsey, W. R., Assistant Surgeon . . . 7.00
Randall, B., Surgeon U. S. A. / . . . 10.00
Randol, A. M., Captain ist Artillery . . . 10.00
Randolph, J. T., Surgeon ..... 10.00
Rankin, W. G., Captain I3th Infantry . . 10.00
Ransom, H. C., Lieutenant-Colonel, Q. M. . 13.00
Rathbone, H. R., Captain I2th Infantry . . 10.00
Raynolds, W. F., Major Engineers . . . 13.00
Reid, J. R., Lieutenant loth Infantry . . . 7.00
Reese, C. B., Captain Engineers . . . 8.00
Reese, H. B., Paymaster . . . . 10.00
Reeve, I. V. D., Lieutenant-Colonel I3th Infantry n.oo
Remington, P. H., Lieutenant 8th Infantry . . 7.00
Reno, M. A., Captain ist Cavalry . . . 10.00
Reynolds, C. A., Captainand A. Q. M. . . n.oo
Reynolds, J. ]., Major-General . , . ,'.. 30.00
Ricketts, ]. B., Brigadier-General M .- . v" .- 25.00
Rittenhouse, B. F., First Lieutenant 5th Artillery . 10.00
212 THE BATTLE MONUMENT
Name and Rank. Amount.
Ritter, J. F., Col. 1st Miss. Cav.; Capt. 1 5th Inf. $13.00
Robbins, K., Lieutenant 5th Cavalry , . . 10.00
Robert, H. M., Captain of Engineers . . . 8.00
Roberts, B. S., Brigadier-General . . . 18.00
Roberts, J., Lieutenant-Colonel 4th Artillery . 13.00
Robertson, C. S., Lieutenant loth Infantry . . 10.00
Robins, R., Lieutenant nth Infantry . . . 10.00
Robinson, D., Lieutenant yth Infantry . . 7.00
Robinson, S. S., Captain loth Infantry . . 8.00
Rockwell, C. F., Lieutenant Ordnance Department 10.00
Rodney, G. B., Lieutenant 4th Artillery . . 10.00
Rollins, J. H., Lieutenant Ordnance Department . 10.00
Rosecrans, W. S., Major-General . ... . 27.00
Rossell, W. H., Captain loth Infantry . . 8.00
Rowley, G. A., Lieutenant 2d Infantry . . 7.00
Roy, J. P., Captain 2d Infantry . . . . 10.00
Royall, W. B., Captain 5th Cavalry . . . 10.00
Rucker, D. H., Brigadier-General, Q. M. D. . 20.00
Ruggles, G. D., Major and A. A. G. . . . 13.00
Russell, C. S., Captain nth Infantry . ... . 10.00
Russell, D. A., Brig. -Gen., Major 8th Infantry . 18.00
Russell, G., Lieutenant 3d Artillery . ... 20.00
Sachs, W., Lieutenant 3d Cavalry * . • . 10.00
Sacket, D. B., Colonel and Inspector-General . 13.00
Sanders, W. W., Captain 6th Infantry . . 8.00
Sanger, J. P., Lieutenant 1st Artillery . . . 7.00
Sutorius, Alex., Lieutenant 3d Cavalry . £»,J 7.00
Saxton, R., Brigadier-General . ... . 18.00
Scammon, C. T., 9th 111. Vol. Cav., A. D. C. . 10.00
Schenck, P. V., Assistant Surgeon . • , . 7.00
Schiffler, J. K., Lieutenant i6th Infantry .. . 7.00
Schuyler, P., Captain I4th Infantry , , . . 10.00
Schwan, T., Lieutenant nth Infantry . . 10.00
O'JtfT
AT WEST POINT
Name and Rank. Amount.
Sedgwick, J., Major-General .... $27.00
Sellers, E. E., Lieutenant loth Infantry . . 10.00
Seymour, T., Brig. -Gen. ; Capt. 5th Artillery „ 18.00
Sheridan, P. H., Major-General . . , W . • 27.00
Shipley, A. N., Captain and A. Q. M. . •* . 20.00
Sidell, W. H., Lieutenant-Colonel I5th Infantry . 12.00
Silliman, H. R., Assistant Surgeon . • ,.;%j . 10.00
Silvey, W., Captain 1st Artillery . y ; , .,',. 8.00
Simonson, J. S., Colonel . . . .„ . ,., 13.00
Simpson, J. H., Lieutenant-Colonel of Engineers . n.oo
Sinclair, J. B., Lieutenant I4th Infantry .;g. \ j ^; 7.00
Sinclair, Wm., Lieut. -Col. of Vols. ; Lt. 3d Art. n.oo
Sitgreaves, L., Lieutenant-Colonel of Engineers . 15.00
Slidell, W. J., Captain i6th Infantry . ; . ^ ^ 8.00
Slocum, H. W., Major-General . . >u;. . 27.00
Slonge, J. L., Lieutenant loth Infantry f\ . , ,10.00
Small, M. P., Lieutenant-Colonel Sub. Dept. , .:,** 11.00
Smalley, H. A., Captain 2d Artillery . .. "] «,( 8.00
Smedberg, W. R., Captain I4th Infantry . Vs 10.00
Smith, A. K., Assistant Surgeon . f . .j ... 10.00
Smith, A. T., Captain 8th Infantry ^) . . 10.00
Smith, E. W., Captain I5th Infantry . . .11.00
Smith, F. G., Lieutenant 4th Artillery . . 10.00
Smith, G. A., Bvt. Lieutenant-Colonel . . 10.00
Smith, G. W., Lieutenant I7th Infantry . , 7.00
Smith, H. E., Captain I2th Infantry . , . 10.00
Smith, J. H., Lieutenant 2d Artillery . -v, . 7.00
Smith, L., Lieutenant 5th Artillery ...... i -. . .* 7.00
Snyder, C., Lieutenant 8th Infantry . ^ ti. ;; . 10.00
Snyder, J. A., Lieutenant 3d Infantry . . . . 10.00
Sokalski, G. O., Lieutenant zd Cavalry . . 7.00
Sommer, H., Lieutenant zd Infantry . . . 7.00
Stacey, M. H., Lieutenant loth Infantry . . 10.00
I4A
2i4 THE BATTLE MONUMENT
Name and Rank. Amount.
Stanley, Wm., Lieutenant loth Infantry . . $10.00
Steele, F., Major-General .... 27.00
Stephenson, J. M., Lieutenant 4th Artillery . . 10.00
Sternberg, G. W., Assistant Surgeon . . . 7.00
Stevens, H., Medical Department . . . 8.00
Stewart, C. S., Major of Engineers . . . 12.00
Stonge, S. E., Lieutenant i6th Infantry . . 7.00
Strickland, L. S., Lieutenant i6th Infantry . . 7.00
Stimpson, F. E., Lieutenant I7th Infantry . . 7.00
Strode, E. C., Assistant Surgeon . . . . 7.00
Strong, G. O., Brig-Gen, (by Gen. B. F. Butler) . 27.00
Sully, A., Brigadier-General . . . . 18.00
Summers, J. E., Surgeon ..... n.oo
Sumner, E. V., Captain 1st Cavalry . •» t • . 10.00
Sumner, S. S., Lieutenant 5th Cavalry . >/*' -\' • 10.00
Suydam, C. C., Assistant Adjutant-General . . 10.00
Swan, W. W., Lieutenant I7th Infantry . . 10.00
Swartwout, H. A., Lieutenant I7th Infantry . . . 10.00
Sweet, W., Captain I7th Infantry ". -H ' »-*' 8.00
Sweitzer, N. B., Captain ist Cavalry . . •* . 30.00
Swift, E., Surgeon U. S. Army . . . . 10.00
Swords, T., Colonel Q. M. D. . . "... .- *'..,•< ,3.Oo
Sykes, G., Major-General ...... 40.00
Symington, J., Colonel Ordnance Department . 13.00
Taggart, D., Major and Paymaster . Wtv . 10.00
Taliaferro, L., Military Store Keeper . . . 8.00
Tardy, J. A., Captain of Engineers . . . 10.00
Tayler, A. B., Lieutenant 5th Cavalry . . ' .- 10.00
Taylor, J. McL., Lieutenant-Colonel, Com. Sub. . n.oo
Theaker, H. A., Lieutenant i6th Infantry . . - .. -. 7.00
Thieman, A., Lieutenant loth Infantry * . 10.00
Thorn, G., Lieutenant-Colonel of Engineers . . 13.00
AT WEST POINT 215
Name and Rank. Amount.
Thomas, E., Lieutenant 4th Artillery . . . $10.00
Thomas, G. H., Major-General .... 30.00
Thomas, L., Jr., Captain ist Artillery . • V 20.00
Thomas, P. K., Lieutenant 3d Cavalry . I . : 7.00
Thompson, J. A., Captain 4th Cavalry . '; « 8.00
Thorpe, W. C., Captain I3th Infantry . . 10.00
Tidball, J. C., Captain 2d Artillery . . . 10.00
Tidball, J. L., Captain U. S. A. . . •• ; ' 8.00
Tilfbrd, J. G., Captain 3d Cavalry . \ .>< ; . 8.00
Tillson, J., Captain I9th Infantry . * •* ''* *Vl ,'•• 10.00
Tilton, H. R., Assistant Surgeon . . : -J . 7.00
Tompkins, C. H., Captain and A. Q^ M. "'; :' *>-. 8.00
Tompkins, D. D., Colonel and Q. M. . ->:/..- 13.00
Tonne, W. R., Lieutenant I9th Infantry ' • . 10.00
Torbert, A. T. A., Brig.-Gen. Vols. U. S. A. . 20.00
Totten, J. G., Brigadier-General Engineers . . 20.00
Totten, J., Brigadier-General; Major). G. Dept. . 18.00
Townsend, F., Major i8th Infantry . V'.;i : . 10.00
Trowbridge, C. F., Captain i6th Infantry • . - . 8.00
Turner, J. W., Brigadier-General; Captain, Com. Sub. 20.00
Upham, J. J., Captain 6th Infantry ",:- •'•. . • 20.00
Upton, E., Colonel . * . -. 1.^1 . 13.00
Urban, G., Lieutenant 5th Cavalry . . • 10.00
Urmston, J. D., Lieutenant I 2th Infantry / ,. • . 8.00
Vance, D. M., Lieutenant nth Infantry . ..' » 10.00
Van der Slice, J. H., Lieutenant I4th Infantry i, 7.00
Van Home, J. J., Captain 8th Infantry -. . . 20.00
Van Renselaer, C., Captain I3th Infantry .,v * 8.00
Vernon, G. R., Lieutenant I4th Infantry . - • 7.00
Vogdes, I., Brigadier-General . . .; .^. ' 18.00
Wagoner, J. J., Lieutenant 1 9th Infantry * -:• 10.00
Wagner, H., Lieutenant iith Infantry . . 7.00
2i6 THE BATTLE MONUMENT
Name and Rank. Amount.
Wagner, J. P., Lieutenant loth Infantry . . $10.00
Walker, J. H., Lieutenant I4th Infantry . . 7.00
Walker, T. W., Captain U. S. A. . . . 10.00
Wall, R., Lieutenant 3d Cavalry . . . 10.00
Ward, R. B., Captain nth Pa. Vol. Cav. . . 10.00
Ward, R. J., Lieutenant ist Cavalry . . . 10.00
Warner, C. N., First Lieutenant 4th Artillery . 7.00
Warner, L. H., Lieutenant 7th Infantry . . 10.00
Warner, J. M., Lieutenant 8th Infantry . . 7.00
Warren, G. K., Major-General .... 30.00
Weaver, H. E., Lieutenant 8th Infantry . . 10.00
Webb, A. S., Brigadier-General .... 20.00
Webster, W., Surgeon ..... 7.00
Weeks, G. H., Captain and Quartermaster . . 12.00
Wessells, H. W., Brigadier-General . fc «V . 20.00
West, W., Lieutenant 2d Infantry . • \ . 7.00
Wharton, H. C., Lieutenant of Engineers . . 10.00
Wheaton, F., Brigadier-General ; Capt. 4th Cavalry 20.00
Wheeler, J. B., Captain of Engineers . ! *'.> . 8.00
Whipple, W. D., Brigadier-General ?'*••• ,!"!. - . 18.00
White, C. B., Assistant Surgeon } i - ; . . 7.00
Whitely, R. H. K., Lieutenant-Col. Ord. Dept. . 11.00
Whitney, S., Lieutenant 4th Artillery . . . 10.00
Whittemore, J. M., Captain Ordnance Department 8.00
Wikoff, C. A., Lieutenant I 5th Infantry • . 7.00
Wilkin, A., Captain 1 7th Infantry ; Col. Vols. . 13.00
Wilcox, J. A., Lieutenant 4th Cavalry . , . . 7.00
Williamson, R. S., Major of Engineers . ' v,-f . 10.00
Williams, G., Lieutenant 4th Infantry . " •' .,> . 7.00
Williams, G. A., Captain ist Infantry . . >. 10.00
Williams, J., Lieutenant i 5th Infantry . . . 7.00
Williams, S., Brigadier-General . . . . 18.00
AT WEST POINT 217
Name and Rank. Amount.
Williams, T. C., Captain I9th Infantry • * ^ $8.00
Wilson,}. E., Lieutenant ist Artillery . . 7.00
Wilson, R., Lieutenant 5th Cavalry . . :' . 10.00
Wilson, R. P., Lieutenant lyth Infantry . . 7.00
Winthrop, F., Captain . . . . «' 10.00
Wister, F., Captain i 2 th Infantry • ' , . • 10.00
Wolverton, W. D., Assistant Surgeon . . . 7.00
Wood, T. J., Brigadier-General ; Colonel zd Cavalry 20.00
Wood, W. H., Major i7th Infantry > \ ' . 10.00
Woodhull, A. A., Assistant Surgeon . . . 7.00
Woodruff, C. A., Lieutenant zd Artillery . . 7.00
Woodruff, D., Major I2th Infantry . . . 10.00
Woodruff, I. C., Major of Engineers . . . 10.00
Woodward, S. E., Lieutenant I5th Infantry . . 7.00
Wright, H. G., Brigadier-General . . . 18.00
Wright, J. P., Assistant Surgeon . . . 7.00
Yates, T., Captain I3th Infantry . . . 10.00
Yorke, L. E., Captain I3th Infantry . . . 10.00
ENLISTED MEN.
Cavalry.
Organization. Amount.
5 enlisted men Capt. Drummond's recruiting party,
$1.00 each . . . . . . $5.00
80 enlisted men Cavalry Detachment, West Point. 113.00
2i 8 THE BATTLE MONUMENT
Artillery.
Organization. Amount.
7 N. C. O. and Enlisted men Batty. L, 4th Arty. $7.00
Enlisted men 5th Artillery ; by Lt. Hickox . . 6.00
" " Battery B, ist Artillery . . . 67.00
48 enlisted men Co. K, zd Artillery . . . 48.00
33 Enlisted men Battery D, ist Artillery . . 33.00
40 " " " M, zd " . 52.00
Band, 1st Artillery . . . . . . 21.00
Infantry.
7 Enlisted men Washington rec. rndvz., $1.00 each 7.00
2 Corporals Lt. Grossman's rec. party, $1.00 each 2.00
Lt. Wuniston's rec. party (two men), £1.00 each . 2.00
Enlisted men Co. D, ist Batt. nth Infantry . 80.00
" " Co. G, " " ... 34.00
" " Co. B, " " . . 21.00
" " Co. C, " " . . 15.00
" " Co. E, " « 18.50
" " Co. F, " " 17.00
ii Enlisted men loth Infantry ; by Capt. Sellers . 25.00
56 " " 1 4th Infantry . 57 .00
52 " " 1 7th Infantry . . . . 52.00
2d Infantry Band . . . . . .13 .00
Enlisted men 2d Infantry ..... 24.50
Enlisted men 1 2th Infantry Band . . . 1 1 .00
1 1 2 Enlisted men 1 2th Infantry . . . . 130.25
Sergt. Minneman, Sergt. Kennedy, Pvt. McNamara,
8th Infantry ... . . » ^ 8.00
2 Enlisted men I2th Infantry; by Captain Wiston 3.00
15 " " 7th Infantry, Co. F . . . 18.00
AT WEST POINT 219
Volunteers.
Organization. Amount.
Pvt. L. S. Phillips, ist Ohio V, A., for his friend
Lt. Frank Work, 4th U. S. Cavalry . . $7.00
Enlisted men Hd. Qrs. ist Brig, zd Div. 5th Army
Corps ....... 21.00
Staff.
Regulars, Watertown, Mass. . ..... 13.00
Bradford, G., Ord. Sergt 5.00
A DESCRIPTION
OF THE
QUARRYING, WORKING, TRANSPOR-
TATION AND ERECTION
OF THE
SHAFT OF THE
BATTLE MONUMENT
AT WEST POINT
EDITED BY
EDWARD F. MINER
QUARRYING AND WORKING.
CHE quarry from which the shaft of the monument was
taken is located at Stony Creek, in the town of Bran-
ford, Connecticut. The quarry has been opened up
and extensively operated for only about ten or twelve
years, so that there is little of historical interest gathered about
it, although several buildings of a monumental character in
the central and eastern sections of the country have been built
of granite taken from it.
The chief characteristic of the quarry is the ability to pro-
duce large stones ; the out-croppings on the hill above the por-
tion opened up show ledges of very great length, without seams.
For a building in Boston there was furnished a platform twenty-
two feet ten inches long, seven feet wide and one foot seven
inches thick. Another instance of the ability to produce large
stones was given when at a single blast a block twenty feet
square and fifty feet long, without crack or seam, was dislodged
from the ledge. This block, if properly cut up, would have
furnished stone for nine shafts like the one in the Battle
Monument.
In quarrying the block for the monument, a bench was
cleared in the quarry, having the top, one side and one end en-
223
224 THE BATTLE MONUMENT
tirely free, and with the other end freed from the ledge by a
natural seam. A line was marked off on the top surface for a
second side, and a set of holes for a blast drilled along this line
with a steam-drill. To insure breakage from the blast to be
in the exact line required, lewis-holes were drilled — /. e.y one
hole is drilled vertically and one obliquely on either side, all
drilled from the same position of the tripod of the steam-drill.
The powder put into these holes for the blast was fired simul-
taneously with a battery, and cleared the block from the ledge,
opening up a seam from the top surface to the natural seam be-
low. The result was a block more than twice the size re-
quired for the shaft. A large slab was removed from the top
of the block with wedges, and then, by the same process of
wedging, a rectangular block of the necessary size to make the
shaft was split off. After the block of stone was entirely free it
was tipped from the ledge, carefully inspected and rolled from
the quarry to a suitable place where it could be cut and polished.
This whole process of quarrying, and the magnitude of the
undertaking, are very clearly illustrated in the accompanying cut
(I), which is a copy of a photograph taken at the quarry while
the men were at work on the block.
The working of the shaft involved no new problems in stone-
cutting and polishing except such as pertained to its excep-
tional size. The usual method of cutting the shaft of a column
involves the splitting off of the corners of the block with
wedges, then using the point and the pene hammer and finish-
ing the surface with the bush or patent hammer. The first
process in polishing is the grinding of the surface of the granite
with chilled shot, then with different grades of emery and fin-
ishing or glossing with putty powder. Chilled shot is the
trade name for small globular particles of chilled cast-iron ; it
being made by blowing out a molten stream of cast-iron with
a steam jet. The first of these processes is accomplished by
rubbing the surface of the granite to be polished with a block
AT WEST POINT 225
of cast-iron under which is placed the chilled shot. Because
of their size and globular form, each individual shot presents
an almost infinitesimal point of contact with the stone, the re-
sult being that a slight pressure on an infinitely small area
breaks down the surface of the stone. The process of grind-
ing with emery is exactly similar, except that different grades
of emery are used and the process requires a greater length of
time. The grinding with emery leaves the stone with a very
smooth, even surface, but no polish. The polish or gloss is
put on by rubbing with a piece of felting covered with putty
powder.
With the above description of cutting and polishing granite,
the problems in working the monument shaft come clearly to
view. Without question, for all the processes of working, it
was best to mount the shaft so that it could be revolved, and
no effort was spared in devising a scheme for doing so, since it
was fairly expected that better results could be obtained in a
much shorter time than in any other way.
Where it was proposed to work the shaft a platform of heavy
timbers was laid down, and the stone rolled on to the platform
and blocked up. The ends were then squared up, and the
corners roughly knocked off, thus bringing the stone to a con-
dition where it was necessary to have it revolve.
The process up to this point is shown in the accompanying
cut (II).
As soon as the ends of the stone were squared up, journals
were bolted to it at the ends, and half-boxes in which the jour-
nals were to revolve were placed upon a crib-work of timber.
These journals were 13" in diameter, 18" long, and were cast
of refined iron on a face-plate two and one quarter inches thick
and three feet eight inches in diameter. On the inner or stone
side of the face-plate was cast a hub of the same size as the
journal, projecting into the stone six inches. Each face-plate
was fastened to the stone by fourteen i^" stud bolts, which
226 THE BATTLE MONUMENT
were set on a circle three feet in diameter. The bolts were
set six inches into the stone, and for this six inches they were
cut with a very coarse lag screw-thread ; the part of the shank
passing through the face-plate being plain, and the nut end
having the standard V thread.
After a careful series of experiments on the testing-machine
in the laboratory of the Worcester Polytechnic Institute to de-
termine the best method of fastening the stud bolts to the stone,
it was decided to set them in sulphur. This material was
selected because it developed the greatest strength of any ma-
terial experimented with, was easily worked, and the fastenings
could be used immediately.
The method adopted for setting the journals in position on
the ends of the stone was as follows : A zinc template the size
of the face-plate was cut out, and the position of the bolts ac-
curately spaced off on the proper pitch-line. This template
was applied to the end of the stone, and the position of the
bolt-holes marked on the stone. With a steam-drill, holes six
and one quarter inches deep and two and one quarter inches in
diameter were drilled in the end of the stone. From the zinc
template a wooden template was made thick enough, so that
when a bolt was placed in one of the holes it was held firmly
at right angles to the face of the template. The wood template
was then placed in the proper position on the end of the stone,
and the bolts one by one put in position, so that they projected
into the holes drilled into the stone. Through a specially pre-
pared channel in the wood template,* melted sulphur was run
into the holes in the stone, surrounding the bolts, and thus
fastening them firmly and accurately in place. The wood
template was removed, and the iron face-plate with the journal
slipped on in its place, the nuts put on the bolts, and the face-
plate tightly screwed to position against wooden wedges placed
between it and the stone.
At this point the most difficult part of setting the face-plates
OP THK
UNIVERSITY
AT WEST POINT 227
was encountered. The axis of each of the journals must coin-
cide exactly with that of the stone shaft, or when the shaft was
revolved the journals would bear at the outer end for part of
the revolution, and at the inner end for the remainder, and
would not lie truly in their bearings. The face-plates were
set in exact position by means of measurements from a system
of horizontal wires stretched the whole length of the shaft and
from plumb-lines of wire. After the plate was brought to an
exact position it was firmly bolted in place, being held by the
wood wedges about one quarter of an inch away from the face
of the stone. The space between the stone and the face-plate
and around the projecting hub was filled with melted sulphur,
which, when cold, gave a true surface against which the face-
plate could be bolted without unduly straining either bolts or
face-plate.
As soon as the face-plates were bolted in position the shaft
was lowered so that the journals rested in the half-boxes pre-
pared for them on the timber crib-work. For the purpose of
cutting, before the machinery was set up, the shaft was revolved
by means of a tackle block hitched to the end of a rope wound
several times around the shaft.
To get the correct profile for the use of the stone-cutters, a
reverse template was made of wood, and hung on hinges just
above the shaft in the vertical plane of its axis. When in use,
the template was dropped down, and measurements taken be-
tween it and the surface of the stone ; at other times it was
swung up to one side.
The cut (III) shows the stone mounted on the journals and
the cutting partially completed.
As a precaution against breakage, it was thought desirable, in
designing the machinery for revolving the shaft, to arrange it in
such a manner as to furnish some support for the shaft. To
accomplish this, two wooden pulleys (cut IV) eight feet in
diameter and one foot ten inches on centers were placed at the
228 THE BATTLE MONUMENT
center of the length of the shaft, and one third of the weight
carried by means of wire-ropes R running from them to the
driving-gear above. This driving-gear and the part of the
weight of the shaft borne by the ropes were carried by three
trusses E, made of ten by twelve inch timber, which in turn
were footed upon a trussed stringer H to distribute the load
over a large area.
The main trusses E were braced by plank G, and connected on
the top by twelve-inch caps. On these caps were placed eight
draw-bar car springs C, two over each of the outer trusses, and
four over the center. On these springs were placed two six by
twelve inch timbers, which in turn carried three ten by twelve
timbers placed at right angles, these latter acting as seats for
four pairs of long wedges K by which the wire ropes between
the pulleys I and the sheaves B were kept at the proper ten-
sion. Upon the wedges rested a strong timber frame carrying
three boxes in which ran a six-inch steel shaft. To this shaft
were keyed two sets of three sheaves B, from which approxi-
mately one third of the weight of the shaft was hung by means
of six seven-eighths inch wire ropes. The shaft also carried a
twelve-foot wood pulley A, which was belted through a coun-
ter-shaft to a fifty horse-power engine. At its outer end the
shaft was supported by a movable bearing balanced by a counter-
weight D of nine hundred pounds.
It will be noticed that the device of supporting the six-inch
steel shaft on springs gave the required flexibility which was
necessary to allow for the unevenness of motion in such tem-
porary work. By experiment the modulus of the springs was
ascertained, so that with a simple device, indicating the com-
pression, it was possible to know very closely how much of the
weight of the stone shaft was carried by the ropes at any time.
The ropes first used were made with the ordinary long splice,
and great difficulty was experienced in the splice pulling out and
the wires breaking where the strands were crossed in the splic-
AT WEST POINT 229
ing. This difficulty was overcome by using grommets — /. e.,
rings of rope made from single strands of wire. They were
made in the following manner : A piece of wire rope the re-
quired length and size was cut off and formed into a ring with
the ends simply butted together. A single strand from this rope
was removed and another strand of the same size from a long
coil wound in its place, a second strand was then removed, and
the same strand as before wound in its place. This process
was continued until the six strands of the original ring of rope
had been removed and the new single continuous strand wound
in their place. The result was a ring of rope made from a
single continuous strand, with, of course, only two ends to tuck
in. These ropes were forty-two feet long, and in wearing ouf
stretched ten inches, the stretch being taken up with the wedges.
The first process in polishing, that of grinding with chilled
shot, was accomplished by placing on the top of the shaft flat
pieces of cast-iron, called planes, having the under side curved
to fit the shaft. They were held in place, when the stone re-
volved, by an attached piece of board which rested against a
stringer plank placed at the back of the shaft. While the shaft
was revolving the chilled shot mixed with lime and water was
thrown upon the surface, and, passing under the planes, ground
the stone to an even surface. After the surface was reduced
as much as possible with the chilled shot, the same process was
used with emery, the finest of the emery leaving the surface
very smooth and even. After the emery was washed off, the
planes were covered with a thick felt, and putty powder mixed
with water was put on. This finished the surface with a pol-
ish or gloss, and completed the process.
One shift of the machinery had to be made in order to polish
the surface under the first position of the wood pulleys. This
was accomplished by tying together and bracing all of the parts
to be moved, and then sliding them bodily four feet six inches
to a new position.
16
230 THE BATTLE MONUMENT
From careful measurements of the water used in the boilers,
the cylinder pressure of the engine and the pull of the planes
on the surface of the stone, it was ascertained that the maxi-
mum horse-power used was slightly under twenty. By testing
with a spring balance it was found that the friction of the planes
varied with the material used in grinding, and also with the
amount of water on the surface of the stone at the time. The
friction when grinding with shot averaged eleven per cent,
of the weight of the plane, twenty-five per cent, with the emery,
and thirty-five per cent, when glossing. The shaft was run at
an average of six and one third revolutions per minute. The
time taken for the different operations was : for chilled shot,
thirty-eight hours; emery, fifty-six hours; and glossing, eight
hours, for each different length of surface worked at any one
time.
OF THB
UNIVERSITY
TRANSPORTATION.
CHE casing or boxing of the shaft for transportation was
planned with especial view toward facilitating the erec-
tion at the site of the monument. It consisted of four
fourteen-inch square timbers for stringers, fitted to the
profile of the shaft and placed at four points equidistant about its
circumference. These timbers were connected and held firmly in
place by a series of heavy bolts. In order to reduce the danger of
breakage to the shaft during transportation to a minimum, the
vertical sides of the square formed by these heavy timbers were
trussed. The bolts of the trussing passed through the stringers
and also through a cross timber placed under the shaft and fitted
to it. This gave support to the shaft at five points intermediate
between the bearing points on the car. The stringer timbers
projected some four feet beyond the small end or top of the shaft,
and between these were fitted four cross timbers. One set of
two cross timbers were twelve inches square and were fitted
carefully to the necking and top 'of the shaft, and bolted se-
curely to the stringers. Diagonally through these cross timbers
were passed ten two-inch eye-bolts, five on each timber, the
eyes of all bolts meeting in a line through the center of the
other set of cross timbers, which were placed at right angles to
the first set. Between the eye-bolts were placed the straps
231
232 THE BATTLE MONUMENT
for the tackle block, and then a two and one half inch steel rod
was passed through the timber, eye-bolts and straps, thus form-
ing the connection by which the column was lifted when
erected.
At the large, or bottom, end the stringer timbers projected
only one foot and eight inches. Here two cross timbers were
fitted at the end of the shaft and bolted firmly to the stringers.
The ends of the bottom stringers were notched to receive a
twelve-inch timber twelve feet long, whose section was three
quarters round and one quarter square. This timber was used
as a hinge on which the shaft was brought to an upright posi-
tion when erected at the site.
The cars used for transportation were the usual design of flat
cars, but were quite low and built extra heavy in all their de-
tail, the axle being five by eight inches. They were thirty-
eight feet six inches long, and were built and used by a loco-
motive builder for carrying two elevated railroad locomotives.
The cars were prepared for the shaft by laying ten by ten
timbers on the car body, which were two feet longer than the
distance between the centers of the trucks. They were blocked
up from the car body two inches at the ends and held from side
deflection by separator blocks fastened to the car, and by long
bolts passing through the outer timbers down through the bol-
ster blocks of the truss rods. The object of these timbers was
to transmit directly to the trucks a part of the weight of the
shaft, thus relieving the car body and truss rods beneath of an
excessive load. The timbers carried a load sufficient to deflect
them the two inches of the blocking plus the deflection of the
car body.
Across these ten by ten stringer timbers were placed flatwise
two eight by twelve inch timbers bolted firmly to them. Simi-
lar timbers were fastened to the stringers of the casing to the
shaft, and fitted so that the shaft rested in them. These two
sets of timbers were placed at each end of the shaft, and on
AT WEST POINT 233
each car, and formed the bearing on which the shaft rested in
transportation. All of the timbers were shod with iron and
the set under the large end of the shaft was arranged with a two-
inch king-bolt. At the other end the bolster timbers on the
car were longer, and heavy blocks, having their inner surface
worked to a curve, were bolted to them. At this end there
was no fastening between the bolster blocks, and the casing of
the shaft was allowed to slide back and forth as the motion of
the cars required on the different curves of the railroads.
Loaded as described, the shaft was transported by railroad
without any accident whatever. The only annoyance during
the trip was caused by the heating of the journals of the axles.
There was little difficulty when the speed of the train was kept
below ten miles an hour; above that, the journals would run
for only a short time without heating badly. The heaviest
loaded set of trucks was under the large end of the shaft, and
with the weight of the car it carried approximately seventy-five
thousand pounds.
The cut (V) shows the cars as they appeared ready for
shipment, with the shaft protected from the weather by a can-
vas cover.
The journey from Stony Creek to West Point was made over
the New York, New Haven and Hartford Railroad from Stony
Creek to Hartford via Say brook Junction; from Hartford to
Fishkill on the Hudson by the New York and New England
Railroad; across the Hudson to Newburg by boat; and from
Newburg to West Point over the West Shore Road — a total
distance of one hundred and ninety-one miles. The trip was
made in thirteen days, with an actual running time of thirty-
eight hours.
The transportation from the switch at the West Point sta-
tion up the steep hill to the site of the monument on the parade
ground was accomplished by laying a temporary track in short
sections, — no particular difficulty being experienced except
234 THE BATTLE MONUMENT
near the riding school, where a reverse curve of seventy-five and
eighty-five feet radii on a twelve per cent, grade was encoun-
tered. Here the curve was so short that the car timbers
had to be deeply cut to allow the wheels of the trucks enough
swing to pass the sharp curve. The shaft was not removed
from the cars until it was blocked up at the site of the mpnu-
ment ready for erection. The cars were made up to a con-
venient height on a crib-work of timbers.
The cuts (VI, VII) illustrate very clearly the method of
transportation from the railroad switch to the site.
ERECTION.
CHE erection of the shaft was the subject of quite as
much thought and planning as any part of its hand-
ling, the difficulty being not only the handling of so
great a load, but that it must be put in an upright
position without any weight being allowed to come upon the
lower edge, since that would very likely break out a piece from
the shaft. A method of erection similar to that used in erect-
ing the Egyptian obelisk in Central Park, New York, by bolting
trunnions to the sides near the center of gravity, was considered,
but abandoned. The method adopted was to arrange a sort of
wooden hinge about which the shaft and casing were revolved
while being raised to an upright position.
A twelve-inch timber three quarters round and one quarter
square was fitted to the bottom stringer timbers at the end next
the base of the monument. This was allowed to rest on other
timbers which had been hollowed out half round. In erection,
the whole of the shaft and casing rested on the round timber,
which in turn rested on and turned in the timbers hollowed out
to receive it.
When the shaft was raised to an upright position it was
landed upon an upright stone post, two feet square, set in the
center of the base several inches above the permanent position
235
236 THE BATTLE MONUMENT
of the bottom of the shaft. This stone post was supported
upon a bed of sand in a pocket formed in the base of the mon-
ument, and so arranged that by opening a gate valve the sand
would flow out and so lower the post and the shaft above,
forming what may be termed a sand-jack.
The shaft was raised to an upright position by a tackle of
twenty ropes, ten sheaves eighteen inches in diameter being
fastened to the top of the casing of the shaft as previously de-
scribed. The fixed block was made up of eleven sheaves of the
same size, and was fastened with six two-and-one-half-inch eye-
bolts to a sixteen by eighteen inch hard pine timber reinforced
on the top by an iron plate one inch thick and eighteen inches
wide. This cross-head timber was suitably fastened to the top
of a stage built of heavy timbers from the ground to a height
convenient for handling the shaft and the surmounting stone
work. On the front the stage was braced on either side by two
twelve by twelve inch timbers, and in the opposite direction it
was guyed from the top to two posts two hundred feet apart
and two hundred and fifty feet back of the monument. It was
at first planned to use a breast derrick instead of a stage for the
erection of the shaft, and a derrick one hundred and three feet
high was built and erected. During the winter previous to the
erection of the monument it was- wrecked in a high gale, and a
stage substituted instead of building another derrick.
The rope used in the tackle for hoisting was a three-quarter
inch crucible steel wire rope, and rated by the manufacturers at a
breaking strain of thirty-six thousand pounds. The greatest strain
on the single rope during the erection to a vertical position was,
neglecting friction, four thousand pounds; and afterward, when
the whole weight of the stone and casing was held for a short
time while the position of the shaft was being adjusted, the
strain was slightly over nine thousand pounds.
Previous to the erection the shaft and casing were blocked
up to as high an angle as was practicable and a trial lift made.
AT WEST POINT 237
This trial developed a weakness in the front brace timbers,
which was remedied by adding more guys to the back. When
the final lift was made, everything worked smoothly, and in ten
minutes the shaft was erect and resting on the stone post.
The cut (VIII) is a copy of a photograph taken while the
shaft was being raised to an upright position.
It was intended to land the shaft on the stone post in the
correct position for lowering on to the base; but, owing to a
slight movement of the shaft in the casing, this was not ac-
complished. The correct adjustment was made by taking a strain
on the lifting tackle, then locking the drums of the hoisting en-
gine and allowing sufficient sand to flow out from under the stone
to clear it from the whole weight of the shaft and casing. The
shaft was then lashed in correct position and lowered back on
the stone post. It will be noted that by this operation, while
the whole weight was held for a given time, a direct lift was
avoided.
When everything was ready for lowering the shaft to its final
position the bottom part of the casing was sawed off and re-
moved. The valve controlling the sand was then opened, and
the running' out of the sand allowed the shaft to settle gradually
and smoothly to its permanent bed, which had previously re-
ceived a thin layer of cement mortar. The bottom of the
pocket for the sand was made conical in shape, it being found
necessary by experiment in order to make the sand flow out
uniformly. After the shaft was landed upon the stone post it
was found to have compressed the sand three eighths of an
inch, or two hundred and sixteen cubic inches in a total vol-
ume of sixteen cubic feet, under a direct compression of about
three hundred and twelve pounds per square inch.
REPORT OF THE TREASURER
^ so" 2 !T £ (5TS ON <£
*s
MI so -<j- N <""> )-1 °0 N O
£
h
,* s^o c*"i >•* ro t^^ *-^ *^ ' *^ ^
2
^j(^«u-\i-iONr^ VO OO
1
00
ON
00
£
h
^'sO^t^t^.^i "^ ^ ^
T*- VO
Wh
^
w
. ^
C5
uA
S *«
^ "s
**
^
'C o
^3
V
O
H
§ s
O
** 1
O
§
, "O • ~Q . • • g5
^ 1
£
g
< % « 'gs
W v
^ TS
>^ ti
h
Z,
0
<
h
| <* * 1 ' § S 1 ^
<-? d
PH
£
•
« H ^ S Q 'S
^ i
H
S
) vU QJ • ^^ ^^ ^^ Ol
** s
1
1
an
U-i g rt jp w r< ^ ^j
|||lf|i|!
*
I
PQ
^5
"
illlllii
w ^
i
1
N O ^ ^x-
so O N 0°
s
0 ^
8
•4- ro w O
fc ^o
o
o
ON N O N
00 N t^ 00
° . -c
U
rt
O ON vO vo
T3 <1
*2 ^
§ ^ c
O ^ w
•S
*> O O N ,-T
GO 1
I
2 o o vo *
1 £ m ~ o
.i O vo rn H
I tfj
§
< ? "
1 11
C*H
U~i
*
HJ **•«••• J
i K ^
GO
*^ G
• W ^ w
PQ
2 • g • • £
S £ S
CL| (x] C/}
£
»-. •• . co °
^ o ^ £ "8 .S
U Oi
rf
ON c S d 13
6 00 o »- 0 00
o - pq H W p.
"S 6:'
PS *•*
S
2s CO* CO* r^ o -
1
^ 1 -s ^ p' ^ 1 1
1 1
S o
rt 5 p^
o
" OF THK
UNIVERSITY
/O