LIBRARY OF THE
UNIVERSITY OF ILLINOIS
AT URBANA-CHAMPAIGN
335 . 973
Sh2i
I • H • S •
ICARIA
Chapter in the History of Communism
BY
ALBERT SHAW, Ph. D.
NEW YORK & LONDON
G. P. PUTNAM'S SONS
1884
COPYRIGHT BY
G. P. PUTNAM'S SONS
1884
Press 0/
G. P. Putnam's Sons
New York
:;
335-. <H3
CONTENTS.
PAGE
Preface v
I. — £tienne Cabet, the Founder of Icaria .... 3
II. — Colonization in Texas 29
III. — Community Life at Nauvoo 47
IV.— The Cheltenham Episode 67
V. — Pioneer Life in Iowa 75
VI. — The Sons versus the Fathers 91
VII. — Reorganization — " The New Icarian Community " . 113
VIII.— " La Jeune Icarie " 127
IX. — In California — " Icaria-Speranza " .... 139
X. — Personal Sketches 155
XI. — Some Kindred Social Experiments . . . .173
XII.— Appendix 189
Index 217
111
PREFACE.
A GREAT number of books and articles have been
written in recent years discussing socialism and
communism in the abstract. Some of these have
been thoughtful and profound ; most of them have
a partisan tone, and are either in sympathy with
the doctrines and projects discussed, or else are
given up to condemnation and warning. The sub-
ject has been treated from almost every conceivable
standpoint, and there would be no reason for the
present monograph if it also undertook to enter the
field of general discussion. Such is not its purpose
or plan. Certainly the most common defect in the
current literature of social and political questions
consists in the tendency to generalize too hastily.
Too little diligence is given to searching for the
facts of history and to studying with minute atten-
tion the actual experiences of men. In the follow-
ing pages the attempt is made to present the his-
tory of a single communistic enterprise. I have
endeavored to explain its origin, to follow the ex-
ternal facts of its checkered and generally unfortu-
nate career, to picture its inner life as a miniature
social and political organism, to show what are, in
VI PREFACE.
actual experience, the difficulties which a com-
munistic society encounters, and to show, by a
series of pen-portraits, what manner of men the
enterprise has enlisted.
Whether or not such a study of a community
now small and obscure is trivial and useless, must
depend upon the manner in which the study is
made. If made with the requisite intelligence and
thoroughness, it may give a better knowledge of
what communism really is and what it wants than
can be obtained from reading abstract disquisitions
about communism. Minuteness, far from being a
fault, will be the chief merit of such a study. To
be of any value it must be conducted in the true
historical spirit. Truth must not be distorted in
the interest of picturesque narrative. A didactic
spirit and a conviction that communism and social-
ism in every form are dangerous heresies must not
be allowed to make the investigator over-anxious to
condemn or disparage ; nor, on the other hand,
should sympathy with good intentions and brave
efforts lead him to a blind praise of projects in
themselves useless or unpraiseworthy. I have tried
scrupulously to avoid all preaching for or against
communism, and it is hoped that no reader of the
following pages will interpret expressions of respect
for well-meant attempts to alleviate the condition
of our fellow-men as signifying approval of particu-
lar projects about which I write without any dis-
PREFACE. VI 1
tinct word of disapprobation. To speak well of
certain men who participated in the Paris Commune
of 1 871 is not to justify that terrible episode.
There are two reasons in particular why this frag-
ment of communistic history should be written.
In the first place it is a story which, except in the
most meagre and inaccurate way, has never before
been told, and therefore it furnishes students of
social science with a new bit of illustrative material ;
moreover, when compared with the annals of other
communistic enterprises, the Icarian story is a pecul-
iarly romantic and interesting one, and my oppor-
tunities for collecting the necessary materials have
been exceptionally favorable.
In the second place, as an example of communism
in the concrete, Icaria has illustrative value beyond
all proportion to its membership, wealth, and suc-
cess. Most of the communistic societies of the
United States might better be studied as religious
than as socialistic phenomena. Their socialism is
incidental to their religious creeds. They believe
themselves honored with special and direct divine
revelations, and those revelations furnish them with
governments of a theocratic character. They do
not justify their socialism by any kind of philosophy
of society, but simply refer the inquirer to a man-
date received through their prophet or prophetess.
I would not be understood as speaking con-
temptuously of these religious societies or their pe-
Vlll PREFACE.
culiar creeds ; but I must insist that the experiences
of such societies can afford little material to aid in
the discussion of rational, democratic communism
or socialism. For example, the Amana Inspiration-
ists, a German communistic body, are to be found
in the same State with the Icarians ; and while
Icaria, with its handful of members, has been strug-
gling, in poverty and dissension, for very existence,
Amana has numbered its many hundreds of people,
has accumulated great wealth, and has lived in
peace and harmony. And yet, for all that, the
history of Icaria is as superior to that of Amana for
the student of social science as the history of Greece
is superior to that of China for the student of politi-
cal science. Icaria is an attempt to realize the
rational, democratic communism of the Utopian
philosophers, hence its value as an experiment.
The movement most akin to Icarianism was Owen-
ism ; but Robert Owen's colonies were all dissipated
before their communistic life was fairly begun.
Fourierism gained much prestige and made a con-
siderable history in this country; but Fourierism
was not communism by many degrees ; and even
those two or three phalansteries which developed
most strength and lived longest, died very young.
If then it is proper to distinguish what I call the
rational, democratic community from the religious
community (Shaker, Amanist, Rappist, etc.), which
seems only incidentally concerned with the solution
PREFACE. IX
of the social problems which confront the civilized
world, I must conclude that Icaria is the most typi-
cal representative of the former sort. Feeble and
disappointing as its career has been, Icaria has per-
severed for more than a generation ; and its ex-
periences should not be left unrecorded.
To both Icarian communes acknowledgments
should be made for courtesies and hospitality.
Especially from Messrs. A. A. Marchand, J. B.
Gerard, A. Sauva, and E. Peron, valuable assistance
has been received. Many others have rendered
material aid in the gathering of facts which were
scattered almost beyond recovery. It may not be
inappropriate to add that this study, which was
first undertaken at the instance of Professor Rich-
ard T. Ely, of the Johns Hopkins University, has
been accepted by the University as a thesis for the
degree of Ph.D., upon the completion of a course in
the department of history and political science.
Johns Hopkins University, June, 1884.
I.
ETIENNE CABET, THE FOUNDER OF ICARIA.
ICARIA.
i.
^TIENNE CABET, THE FOUNDER OF ICARIA.
In the year 1848, the readers of the London Quar-
terly Review, and also those of Taifs Edinburgh
Magazine, were entertained with accounts of a con-
temporary social movement in France which had
attained remarkable proportions and influence, — a
movement which even then had reached its zenith,
and was destined to be obscured and almost forgotten
in the intensity of the political events crowding that
memorable year of revolutions, and the years imme-
diately following. The foreign tourist of to-day, as
he passes through southwestern Iowa on his wonted
pilgrimage from Chicago to the Pacific, may see
from his car-window a forlorn-looking little hamlet
of a dozen cottages grouped about a larger wooden
building, the whole irregularly flanked with the un-
picturesque sheds, stacks, and cattle-yards of a
prairie stock-farm. Such is the Icaria of to-day, the
humble survival of a movement which, a generation
ago, numbered its zealous adherents by hundreds of
thousands, and which assumed the mission of re-
organizing human society with as pure an enthusiasm
and as sublime a confidence as has ever attended
3
4 ICARIA.
the birth of any reform movement. The story of
Icaria is a record of hardships, dissensions, and dis-
appointments almost innumerable; but it is also a
record of endurance, and of unswerving devotion
that commands respect and honor. And, especially
as heard from the lips of the few surviving pioneers
of 1848, it is a story that awakens unusual interest
and sympathy. Certainly no sincere and generous
attempt to improve the condition of mankind, how-
ever disappointing in its outcome, is entirely un-
worthy the notice of the student of sociology or of
the practical reformer.
The first French Revolution was essentially a
political upheaval. Nevertheless, Voltaire, Rous-
seau, and the Encyclopedists, in their glittering
doctrines of the equal rights of man, had pro-
pounded a philosophy which did not reach its logi-
cal ultimatum with the undermining of the Church
and State of the ancien regime and the establish-
ment of a political democracy. The emancipation
of humanity, as preached by the doctrinaires, meant
more than the subversion of kingcraft and priest-
craft ; it meant also a revolution in the industrial
organization of society. The communistic con-
spiracy of Babceuf against the Directory shows the
strength that communism had thus early gained as
a practical creed. Marat, Robespierre, all the
great revolutionary leaders were, in theory, advo-
cates of the levelling philosophy. But it was not
ETIENNE CABET. 5
until the later revolutions of 1830 and 1848 that the
socialists and communists took the leading part, and
that the u tyranny of property ' became a more
pervasive cause of discontent than the rule of the
restored Bourbon, or the republican " king of the
barricades." At the period of the first revolution,
the new philosophy had scarcely reached the French
people. The masses knew that they were op-
pressed, but they had not yet imbibed the doctrines
of the " social compact " and the " rights of man,"
nor had they yet learned that " property is rob-
bery." But the revolution wonderfully aroused the
intellect of the proletaire ; and the nineteenth cen-
tury dawned on a French nation of thinkers, readers,
philosophers. It is not strange that ignorant arti-
sans and peasants, severed from all the moorings of
the past by a revolutionary cataclysm which effaced
every traditional landmark, and stimulated by novel
circumstances to an unparalleled mental acuteness,
should have adopted the new social philosophy
with the ardor of intoxication. If the revolution
of 1789 was the work of lawyers, journalists, and men
of education, those a generation later were genuine
movements of the people, — though diverted from
accomplishing the popular objects. The ouvrier
had become a doctrinaire.
It is only by recurrence to these peculiar condi-
tions and transformations of French society that we
can thoroughly understand the career of a man
0 I CARTA.
whose own life strikingly illustrates them, foienne
Cabet the founder of Icaria. Cabet was born Jan.
I, 1788, at Dijon, in the department of the Cote
d'Or, his father being a cooper by trade. He had
the advantage of a general education under the
tutelage of his celebrated fellow-townsman Jacotot,
whose attainments as one of the leading educators
of the age, and whose career as a revolutionary pa-
triot must have had weighty influence in forming
the character and opinions of young Cabet. Our
subject next appears as a student of medicine,
which profession was soon abandoned for the more
congenial study of the law. He acquired a speedy
reputation as an eloquent advocate at the Dijon
bar, and probably made himself well known as a
republican ; for, in 1825, two years after Charles X.
had succeeded his brother Louis XVIII. to the
throne, we find that Cabet has transferred his resi-
dence to Paris, where he becomes at once a leading
man in the new democratic movement which cul-
minated five years later. Associated intimately
with Manuel, Dupont de l'Eure, and other patriot
leaders in Paris, he became a director in the secret
revolutionary society of the Carbonari, which had
lately been introduced into France from Naples ;
and he threw himself fearlessly into the dangerous
work of extending this society and its principles
throughout the realms of his majesty the last French
Bourbon. He was an active participant in the July
ETIENNE CABET. 7
revolution of 1830, heading the popular movement
as member of an insurrectionary committee. The
abdication of Charles X. was a triumph won by the
democrats, but they reaped small advantage from
their success. By superior adroitness, Lafitte,
Thiers, Guizot, and their coterie succeeded in out-
witting the democrats and in placing Louis Philippe
on "a throne surrounded by republican institu-
tions." However, the men who had precipitated
the revolution must needs be recognized and con-
ciliated : and we now find our subject representing
the government of Louis Philippe as Procurer-Gen-
eral in Corsica. But Cabet continued to be a thorn
in the crown of royalty, and soon identified himself
so notoriously with the radical anti-administration
party that he was removed from orifice. Already,
however, his old neighbors of the Cote d'Or had
elected him as their deputy in the lower chamber,
and he took his seat with the extreme radicals.
This was in 1834. During his absence in Corsica
there had been incessant democratic intrigues, the
most formidable being the outbreak in Paris at the
funeral of General Lamarque, in the summer of
1832. The ministry had entered upon a course of
severely repressive measures, undoubtedly exceed-
ing their constitutional powers. Cabet's opposition
in the chamber was intense. His denunciations
and predictions were too revolutionary to be tolera-
ted, and the government allowed him to choose be-
8 ICARIA.
tween two years of imprisonment and five years of
exile. He preferred the latter, and found asylum in
England.
Hitherto, Cabet had been a man of action rather
than of speculation. He had worked for the reali-
zation of a political democracy. In his own life-
time, which had not yet spanned half a century, he
had witnessed a mighty growth of the people.
Under the reign of Louis Philippe, he and his dem-
ocratic associates had secured an extension of the
elective franchise, and had seen the downfall of an
hereditary peerage and an upper chamber of aristo-
crats. These political reforms had engrossed him,
but he had lived to see the popular movement shift
its grounds. What had been at first a movement of
the middle class against an absolute monarch and an
intolerable aristocracy, had almost imperceptibly
come to be a movement of the lowest class against
the middle class. The first and second estates were
no longer formidable ; Louis Philippe was the king
of the bourgeoisie. Money was the new tyrant. Capi-
tal controlled the electorate. The government was
in league with bankers, manufacturers, and the mer-
cantile classes. Democracy now meant the move-
ment of the proletariat against the bourgeoisie. Society
was breaking into two more and more clearly de-
fined classes : the rich and prosperous, the capital-
ized class, numbered by thousands ; and the laboring
class, numbered by millions. Oppression was no
longer conceived of as political, but as industrial.
ETIENNE CABET. 9
During the five years of his residence in England,
Cabet gave himself to study and reflection. His
mental processes at this period are well described in
a little French tract 1 by one of his disciples, from
which I translate a few sentences : " Studying,
pondering the history of all ages and of all countries,
he at length arrived at the conclusion that mere
political reforms are powerless to give to society the
repose, the welfare which it obstinately seeks ; that
the slavery of antiquity, the serfdom of the Middle
Ages, and the proletariat of modern times are, under
different names, one and the same thing ; that, in
short, if the malady has changed its name it has not
changed its nature. He found at all epochs the
same phenomena : society sundered in twain ; on
one side a minority, cruel, idle, arrogant, usurping
exclusive enjoyment of the products of a majority,
passive, toiling, ignorant, who remained wholly des-
titute. Excessive wealth and excessive poverty,
such was the spectacle which every page of history
presented to his eyes. To change all this, to find
the means of preventing one portion of humanity
from being eternally the prey of the other, — such
was his desire, the goal of all his efforts. But how
was it to be accomplished ? * * * Gradually
this idea gained possession of Cabet's mind; he
comprehended, he admitted that only equality of
property could change the aspect of the world and
i <<
Icarie," by A. Sauva.
IO ICARIA.
set humanity in the veritable path of its destiny.
The transformation was wrought ; Cabet was a
Communist."
Cabet was an honest man, with the courage of
his convictions. If his thinking had brought him
to an unexpected result, he did not shrink from his
conclusions. He had always ranked with "practical "
men, and he had no taste for being called a chimeri-
cal dreamer, a Utopian theorist, a visionnaire ; but
nevertheless he resolved to become a propagandist
of communism as he had been a propagandist of
democracy. He was by nature an organizer ; his
temperament was hopeful ; his mind was construc-
tive. When, in 1839, ne was again admitted to
France, he had worked out his system of social re-
organization ; and in 1840 the workingmen of Paris
were reading with enchantment the " Voyage en
Icarie." Cabet had wisely chosen to write his new
doctrines in a clear, popular style, and to give his
book the form of a romance. Little as the work is
now known or read, it is certainly one of the most
clever and captivating volumes of social philosophy
ever written.1
2The form of the "Voyage en Icarie" was, confessedly, suggested
by Sir Thomas More's " Utopia," and it contains many general
ideas common to nearly all of the numerous books describing ideal
commonwealths, from Plato's "Republic" down through the list.
But the " Voyage " 'is neither a plagiarism nor a mere imitation, as
several hostile French critics have pronounced it. Thus, Francis
Lacombe, in his " Etudes surles Socialistes " (Paris, 1850), refers to
the "^Voyage" as " copiee presque textuellement dans le Manifeste
des Egaux, dans 1' Utopie de Thomas Morus, et dans la Vie de
ETIENNE CABET, II
The book purports to be the journal of an in-
genuous and adventurous young English nobleman,
Lord Carisdall, who has learned by chance that in a
remote part of the world there exists an isolated
commonwealth known as Icaria, in which the
government, the arts and sciences, the popular wel-
fare and all the accessories of life have attained a
most astonishing perfection. My lord determines
to see the country ; and his voyage of inspection
gives title to the book. Part I., containing 300
pages, is an exhaustive and realistic description of
the social arrangements prevailing in this happy
country, as they appeared to a man familiar with
the civilization of England and France. Occasional
allusions to current European events lend an added
air of reality. Part II. tells the history of Icaria,
recounting the mode of its transformation and mak-
ing an exposition of its doctrines and theories. These
Lycurgus." And Louis Reybaud in the " Etudes sur les Reforma-
teurs ou Socialistes Modernes " in a similar spirit remarks : " Ce Lord
Carisdall est en outre le heros d'un recit dans lequel Buonarrotti et
Morus, Fenelon et Campanella se donnent la main a travers les siecles.
L'Icarie est une terre promise ; elle doit ce bonheur au pontife Icar,
qui a un faux air de famille avec l'Utopus du chancelier d'Angle-
terre et le grand metaphysicien de la Cite du Soleil." It is true that
there are striking points of external resemblance ; but it should be
borne in mind that More's " Utopia," for instance, is a mere sketch
as compared with Cabet's volume of six hundred pages. In its
essential character the book owes much more to Robert Owen than
to Sir Thomas. It should not be forgotten that Cabet's chief object
was not the production of an original and unique piece of literary
work, but rather the promulgation of his new opinions in a manner
likely to gain the widest attention. For his opinions he doubtless
owed something to each one of the principal contributors to the
literature of communism.
12 ICARIA.
new and superior arrangements are effectively con-
trasted with the vicious character of the former
social and political organization. Part III. is a
brief re'sume' of the principles of communism. Lord
Carisdall, who is supposed to make his voyage in the
year 1836, finds the history of Icaria to be some-
what as follows :
The country had been under the irksome rule of
a long line of monarchs. In 1782 a hero, patriot,
and philosopher named Icar led a successful revo-
lution. Long reflection had made Icar a democrat
and a communist. He readily convinced his grate-
ful countrymen of the superiority of his proposed
method of reconstruction, and his plans were
adopted with enthusiasm. Ultimately, the country
would become radically and exclusively socialistic ;
but the transition was to be a gradual one, occupy-
ing fully fifty years. The government was to be-
come at once a democratic republic. The country
was accordingly divided into a hundred provinces,
and each province into ten communes. Each com-
mune was a small self-governing democracy. Each
province had its assembly composed of representa-
tives of the communes, and the nation had its larger
assembly composed of representatives of the prov-
inces. At the head of administration there was an
elective executive council, of which the good Icar
reluctantly consented to be President. During the
transitory regime existing proprietors and vested
ETIENNE CABET. 1 3
rights were to remain undisturbed, but the state
was to begin at once a system of national work-
shops, tenements for workingmen, and various other
ameliorations. Taxation was to be removed from
all articles of necessity, and a graduated income
tax was to be an important means of arriving at
equality. So speedily as possible the public lands
were to be colonized by the poor, and devoted to
the application of thorough-going communistic prin-
ciples, being transformed into farms and villages
organized on the industrial model of the ultimate
Icarian constitution. Meanwhile, great attention
was to be given to education. This was to be com-
pulsory, thorough, and practical, and was to fit the
growing generation for the dawning era of perfect
equality and fraternity. By the absorption of in-
heritances under an extended law of escheat, by
the mode of imposing taxes, by the legal regulation
of wages, and by the development of large national
industries, the state would absorb all private prop-
erty and all industrial and social functions, so that,
at the end of half a century, the people would find
themselves transformed into a vast partnership — a
great national hive, where each labored according
to his abilities and consumed according to his neces-
sities ; where crime had vanished with poverty, and
idleness with luxurious wealth ; where peace and
plenty, liberty and equality, virtue and intelligence,
reigned supreme. Thus the former political unit of
14 ICARIA.
the commune would have developed by a gradual
and simple process into the unit of social and indus-
trial cooperation. The waste of competition would
have been replaced by the economy of general
organization. Buying and selling and all monetary
operations would obviously have become obsolete.
Such is a slight outline of Cabet's elaborate " transi-
tory constitution." The author was particularly
proud of this portion of his work, which he believed
contained many original suggestions and consti-
tuted his most valuable contribution to commu-
nistic thought. He makes one of the characters in
the romance express regret that France had not
adopted such a constitution after the July revolu-
tion of 1830.
The English voyager arrived in Icaria several
years after the transitory period had been com-
pleted, and he found the system in full operation.
Space will not permit us to describe the interesting
and beneficent manner in which the Icarians man-
aged to provide all their people with healthful and
abundant food, pleasant raiment and comfortable
homes — suffice it to say that Icaria was a veritable
housekeeper's paradise. The educational system
was admirable, and is elaborately described by Lord
Carisdall. The organization of industry was ingeni-
ously planned and effectively carried out. Hygi-
enic arrangements of all kinds were beyond praise.
Writers, savants, men of high and varied attain-
ETIENNE CABET. 1 5
ments had honored places in the system. The
standard of morality was pure and lofty. Marriage
and the family were deemed sacred. The position of
woman was fully on the par with that of man. The
treatment of women and children is a cardinal sub-
ject in the Icarian philosophy, and one will search
in vain to find more sensible, enlightened views.
The religious beliefs of Icaria were peculiar. All
religions were freely tolerated, but the current
belief was a species of rationalistic theism. (Cabet
himself had a strong leaning toward Comte's posi-
tive philosophy.)
The second part of the book has a discussion of
the faults of the old social and political organiza-
tion, much in the vein of recent writers like Henry
George. A valuable summary showing the progress
of democracy in all ages and all countries crowds
sixty pages with historical facts. Next follows a
brief historical sketch of industrial progress. And,
above all, comes finally a sort of chronological cyclo-
pedia of communistic philosophers, bristling with
names like those of Pythagoras, Lycurgus, Socrates,
Plato, the Gracchi, Plutarch, the Fathers of the
Church, Sir Thomas More, F6nelon, Grotius,
Hobbes, Harrington, John Locke, Campanella,
Rousseau, Morelly, Babceuf, Buonarotti, Robert
Owen, Saint-Simon, Fourier, and scores of others,
all of whom are most ingeniously quoted as advo-
cates of the doctrines of human equality. This
1 6 ICARIA.
plan of associating a purely imaginary picture of an
ideal society, with so learned and comprehensive an
array of historical facts and distinguished philoso-
phers, was well contrived to give the whole work an
appearance of verity and sober weight. As Cabet
says in his preface, the " Voyage en Icarie M is indeed
"a veritable treatise on morals, philosophy, social
and political economy, the fruit of long labors, im-
mense researches, and constant meditations." And
he adds : " To understand it well, it will not suffice
to read the book ; it must be re-read, read often,
and studied."
The title-page, in an elaborate and symmetrical
arrangement of mottoes, contains a summation of
all Cabet's philosophy. It is so curious that I think
it worth while to reproduce it in full upon the
adjoining page. It is transcribed from a copy of
the fifth edition, published in 1848.
Such was the book which Cabet presented to the
French public in 1840, and it met with a reception
more immediate, and more serious, probably, than
has ever been accorded to any similar work. It
suited the popular mind because it furnished a pro-
gramme. It was easy to read and to understand.
Its generalizations were clear, and yet seemed pro-
foundly wise. Its morality appealed to the best
motives, and satisfied the ideals of the conscientious.
Though rejecting Christianity as divine, it accorded
Christ the highest place of honor as a teacher
VOYAGE
EN
ICARIE
PAR
M. CABET.
FRATERNITE
TOUS POUR CHACUN — CHACUN POUR TOUS
SOLIDARITE AMOUR EDUCATION
EGALITE — LIBERTE JUSTICE INTELLIGENCE — RAISON
ELIGIBILITY SECOURS MUTUEL MORALITE
UNITE ASSURANCE UNIVERSELLE O R D R E
PAIX ORGANIZATION DU TRAVAIL UNION
— MACHINES AU PROFIT DE TOUS —
AUGMENTATION DE LA PRODUCTION
REPARTITION EQUITABLE DES PRODUITS
SUPPRESSION DE LA MISERE
AMELIORATIONS CROISSANTES
premier broit mariage et famille premier beboir
tfibre progres continuel (TrubiuIUr
— ABONDANCE —
A CHACUN ARTS DE CHACUN
SUIVANT SES BESOINS Q SUIVANT SES FORCES
BONHEUR COMMUN
PARIS
AU BUREAU DU POPULAIRE RUE JEAN-JACQUES-ROUSSEAU, 14
Dans les Departments et k l'Etran^er chez les Correspondants du Populaire.
1848
17
1 8 ICARIA.
of human brotherhood, of unselfishness, of equality,
and of community.
The air was already full of social discontent.
Babouvism had never wholly died out. Only the
year before our book appeared the insurrection of
Blanqui and Barbes had been recognized as a
socialistic revolt. Fourierism and Saint-Simonism
had each its large body of disciples. But nothing
as yet had crystallized the vague longings of the
masses. Icarianism met the situation. It was
hailed as a new gospel to the poor. The " Voyage "
was read not only in Paris but throughout France ;
and it circulated widely in foreign countries, running
through a number of editions.1
In the following year, 1841, Cabet founded a
journal, the Popidaire, in which he defended and ex-
pounded his ideas as set forth in the "Voyage."
From 1843 to J847 he printed an Icarian almanac,
and a perfect flood of controversial pamphlets.
During the same year he published his work on
Christianity, and a " Popular History of the French
Revolutions from 1789 to 1830," in five volumes,
and he had now added the reputation of a man
of letters to that of a radical politician. His
" Christianity " (" Le Vrai Christianisme suivant
Jesus-Christ") is a curious little volume of over six
1 An English reviewer remarked in 1848 : " It has already gone
through five editions — there is not a shop or stall in Paris where copies
are not in readiness for a constant influx of purchasers — hardly a
drawing-room table on which it is not to be seen."
ETIENNE CABET. 1 9
hundred very small pages. It undertakes to set
primitive Christianity in contrast with modern ec-
clesiasticism, and displays much ingenuity in mak-
ing it to appear that the mission of Christ was
to establish social equality among men, and that
Christ was the chief teacher of communism that the
world has ever seen. The newspaper, the almanac,
the pamphlets, and the books were eagerly read and
circulated, and no propaganda ever won a more im-
mediate success. It is said on good authority that
in 1847 the adherents of the Icarian doctrine — the
members of the so-called " Icarian school " — num-
bered four hundred thousand, besides many more
who sympathized with the movement. These were
almost exclusively working people, especially the
better class of artisans in the towns. So extensive
a movement could not but attract wide attention and
could not hope to escape prosecution. The press,
the government, through all its organs of magistra-
ture and police, the priests, and the powerful influ-
ence of the bourgeoisie — the mercantile class — were
combined to crush out so dangerous a social
heresy.
It is altogether improbable that Cabet had at the
outset any design of putting his theories into im-
mediate practice, or of demonstrating their feasi-
bility by means of an experimental colony. But as
persecution and controversy increased, his sanguine
friends on the one hand and his taunting enemies on
20 ICARIA.
the other constrained him into a project for the
realization and vindication of his Icaria. He had
at first been content to hope that at some political
crisis the French people would be persuaded to or-
ganize a democratic republic, with a constitution
providing for a gradual transition to communism.
But now he was urged to found a colony whose suc-
cess would be the best Icarian argument, and would
react inevitably upon the structure of European so-
ciety. Cabet had won the perfect, unlimited confi-
dence of his adherents, and he had but to propose
the project of a colony to meet with prompt re-
sponses from large numbers who were willing to go.
Cabet was to them what the good Icar in the ro-
mance was to the grateful people who took his
name.
It was in May, 1847, that there appeared in the
Populaire a long oratorical proclamation headed,
" Allons en Icarie ! " (Let us go to Icaria!) and
signed " Cabet." The article is now before me as I
write. It sets forth in the most lofty and glowing
terms the desirability of an Icarian emigration. It
promises a " new terrestrial paradise." Moreover,
it expatiates on the unparalleled opportunity for
achieving undying fame and for winning happiness,
which should extend its blessings to the universe.
For a glowing prospectus this certainly surpasses
the best recent efforts of the Dakota land-agents.
It promised a heavenly climate, a soil that would
ETIENNE CABET. 21
produce, with scarcely any labor, an unparalleled
fruitage, and, in short, every thing was to be mag-
nificent— perfect. But this first appeal did not
name the location of the new land of promise. In
the next number of the Populaire he completes his
appeal, under the title: " Travailleurs, allons en
Icarie!" This address to laboring men sets forth
in strong contrast their unhappy lot in France and
the delightful life that awaits them in Icaria. It
ends with these words : " Let us found Icaria in
America!" The next week an address to women
appears in the Populaire, inviting them to an eman-
cipated life in happy Icaria. Only a few weeks had
elapsed when Cabet was able to announce : ' " To-day,
after the reports and letters we have received, the
accession to our proposal is so prodigious that we
have no doubt of being able to unite more than a mil-
lion of co-operators I "
Cabet had announced that a year would be re-
quired for preparations, but the people were be-
coming impatient to go. The Populaire from time
to time drew flattering pictures of the success of
various communistic ventures in America. It was
at this time that the Rappists in Pennsylvania were
at their zenith ; the Zoarite community in Ohio was
flourishing ; Robert Owen had failed at New Har-
mony, but he was still indefatigably engaged in
socialistic enterprises. This was the era of the
1 For the use of valuable documents and materials, from which this
portion of my sketch is prepared, I am indebted to J. B. Gerard.
22 I C ARIA.
Brook Farm experiment, which enlisted such names
as those of Ripley, Margaret Fuller, Hawthorne,
Channing, Dana, and others as well known. I find
in a copy of the Populaire, in the summer of 1847,
a quaint little notice of " Brouck-Tarm, sous la
direction du predicateur unitaire Ripley." The
Populaire was also kept crowded with letters en-
thusiastically endorsing the plan of emigration.
Preparations were making, but the destination of
the colony was not yet announced. In September
Cabet went to London and spent some days in con-
ference with Robert Owen. . As the result of that
conference, the Populaire announced that the choice
lay between three localities in the United States
(none of which were specified), and that the final
decision must be deferred until the most thorough
investigation had been made of all such matters as
soil, climate, products, streams, etc. This sounded
very business-like. There seems little doubt that
Robert Owen advised him to go to Texas, and
that Cabet was pretty fully determined upon that
State. Nearly twenty years previous, while Texas
was Mexican territory, Owen had been in negotia-
tion with the Mexican government and had visited
the country with the object of planting colonies, so
that he was familiar with its general character.1
1 Robert Owen's negotiations with the Mexican Government, after
the failure of his Indiana project, and his visit to Mexico in the fall
of 1828, form one of the most interesting episodes in Owen's remark-
able career. His negotiations were at first very successful, and his
ETIENNE CABET. 2$
Texas had now been admitted to the Union and
was entering upon an era of prosperity. She was
in every way inviting immigration to her vast em-
pire of unoccupied land. Large grants were made
to private companies on condition of securing im-
migrants. One of these was the Peters Company,
of Cincinnati ; and it was with this company that
Cabet arranged for his land. He went through the
form of sending a commissioner to examine the
the property, but he was already satisfied and
sanguine as to his chosen location. In the Populaire,
Jan. 17, 1848, was the following announcement:
<{
C EST AU TEXAS.
" After having examined all the countries suitable
for a grand emigration, we have chosen Texas — the
northeastern part — as that which presents the most
advantages in respect to health, the temperature of
the climate, the fertility of the soil, extent of coun-
try, etc. We have already obtained more than a
million acres of land along the Red River, a beau-
schemes of social reform attracted the Mexican President and par-
ticularly fascinated Mr. Poinsett, the American Minister, who used
his official influence for the success of the negotiation. Mr. Owen
secured the promise of an enormous tract, thousands of square miles
in extent, in Texas. Later the Mexican Congress refused to confirm
the grant, and the affair came to nought. But Owen never forgot
the daring project of a communistic commonwealth in Texas, and,
naturally enough, twenty years later he put the idea into Cabet's
head. Though I have no direct evidence, I cannot doubt that Cabet
in choosing Texas was simply acting as heir to Owen's large plan of
1828. For an account of Owen's visit to Mexico, see San;ant's
" Robert Owen and His Social Philosophy," London, i860 (pp. 262-
276).
24 ICARIA.
tiful stream, navigable up to our very settlement,
and we will be ^able to extend our territory indefi-
nitely.
" Cabet."
It had not been intended to begin emigration
until the summer of 1848; but persecutions multi-
plied. Cabet himself was continually charged by
the press with being a swindler who had no real
intention of founding a colony, and who was ob-
taining money under false pretences. These irri-
tating circumstances made haste seem desirable, and
on the morning of the 3d of February there were
assembled on the wharves at Havre sixty-nine
picked men, constituting the " first advance guard."
These, Cabet said, were to be followed soon by one
thousand or fifteen hundred men, composing the
11 second advance guard," and some weeks later would
begin the general emigration. The scene of emi-
gration was a most impressive one. Cabet and his
friends, many relatives of the pioneers, and hun-
dreds of curious spectators, thronged the piers.
Before sailing, the sixty-nine entered into a solemn
engagement with Cabet, in the form of a series of
questions to which they assented one by one. For
example, they were asked if they gave their adher-
ence without any mental reservation to the " Social
Contract," published in the Populaire some four
months previous. This social contract was sim-
ply a provisional constitution, providing for the
ETIENNE CABET. 2$
organization of a communistic society, arranging for
its management while in the early formative stages,
and making Cabet the Director-in-chief for the first
ten years. Other questions put to the advance
guard had reference to their sincere devotion to the
communistic cause and their willingness to endure
privations for its realization. The whole formed a
ceremony well adapted to make an indelible impres-
sion on the minds of men leaving their native land
under circumstances so romantic and peculiar.
Cabet himself was touched with a sense of the hero-
ism of the spectacle. He wrote in the Populaire,
that in view of men like the advance guard, he
" could not doubt the regeneration of the human
race." He believed that the 3d of February, 1848,
would be forever known as an epoch-making date.
" At length," he writes, " on Thursday, February
3d, at nine o'clock in the morning, there was accom-
plished one of the grandest acts, we believe, in the
history of the human race ; — the advance guard,
departing on the ship ■ Rome/ has left Havre to
enter the ocean and voyage toward Icaria. * * *
These courageous Icarians, placed on the stern-
deck of the ship, entoned in unison the farewell
chant, ' Partons pour Icarie,' to which the specta-
tors responded in a thousand cries of ' au revoir ! '
* * * May the winds and waves be propitious
to you, soldiers of humanity ! And we, Icarians,
who remain, let us prepare without loss of time to
rejoin our friends and brothers ! "
II.
COLONIZATION IN TEXAS.
II.
COLONIZATION IN TEXAS.
As the ship " Rome," bearing the sixty-nine pi-
oneers, approached New Orleans on the 27th of
March, its passengers heard the booming of artillery.
But the salute was not in honor of their arrival. A
faster ship had brought word from Paris of the
Revolution of February 24th, and the French people
of New Orleans were celebrating the downfall of
Louis Philippe and the establishment of the Second
Republic. If the advance guard had tarried three
weeks longer in France, the subsequent history of
Icaria would doubtless have been something very
different from that which is recounted in the follow-
ing pages. But it is for us to record what was, not
what might have been.
The Revolution of 1848 was the rock on which
the great Icarian school split. Part of the society ad-
vocated the recall of the advance guard, the aban-
donment of the emigration scheme, and the concen-
tration of every effort for the success of the new
Republic. This party hoped for the gradual trans-
formation of France into an Icaria. But on the
other hand, the party led by Cabet maintained that
29
30 ICARIA.
Icarians had nothing to hope from a government
controlled by Lamartine, Ledru-Rollin, and others
hostile to the Communistic cause. In reality, Louis
Blanc, Blanqui, Cabet, and the extremists were now,
as in 1830, the men who had precipitated the revolu-
tion ; but, as before, they were unable to control its
results. Louis Blanc was the only one of their
number who obtained a leading place in the new
government, and in accordance with his views a
series of reforms were at once instituted, almost
precisely in the line of those contained in Cabet's
" transitional constitution," described in the " Voy-
age." The " right to labor " was proclaimed by law,
and in a few weeks, more than a hundred thousand
men were employed in national workshops. Taxes
on salt, and other indirect taxes on the necessaries of
life were removed, and direct taxes were almost
doubled. The interests of the laboring man were
solicitously, ostentatiously regarded in the legislation
of the Republic. The length of a day's labor was fixed
bylaw. Wages were made matter of legislation. But
the triumph of socialism was brief, the workshops
proved a dismal failure, and the reform legislation
survived only a few weeks.1 The whole situation,
1 It is now established beyond controversy that Louis Blanc and his
socialistic friends were not responsible either for the founding, the
bad management, or the failure of the national workshops. They
were doomed to failure from the beginning, because they were de-
liberately planned by anti-socialists in order to throw discredit on the
doctrines and the men represented by Blanc. The usual attribution
of these measures to Blanc is therefore erroneous. For a proper state-
COLONIZATION IN TEXAS. 31
however, placed Cabet in a painful dilemma. He
decided that he could not wisely abandon the col-
onization, and the hitherto devoted and harmonious
body of Icarians was fatally severed.
On the 3d of June the second advance guard left
France, but it was not the corps of 1,000 or 1,500
men that had been promised. It was a resolute band
of only nineteen !
Here let us turn to follow the fortunes of the
sixty-nine pioneers. On learning in New Orleans
that the Republic had been proclaimed in France,
the question of immediate return was agitated. This
view did not prevail, although three or four men left
the party determined to go back.1 It was ascer-
tained that in order to reach the lands of the Peters
Company they must go to Shreveport, Louisiana, on
the Red River, by steamboat, and advance thence
to their destination by teams. The Populaire had
stated that the land acquired from Peters was washed
by the Red River and would be readily accessible by
boat ; but on arriving' at Shreveport the advance
guard discovered a very momentous geographical
discrepancy. Icaria was more than two hundred and
fifty miles distant (some thirty miles distant from
ment of the case, see Ely's " French and German Socialism " (New
York, 1883), pp. 111-113.
1One of these seceders was a young fellow, A. Piquenard by name,
lie afterward rejoined the society. In later years he became the
most distinguished architect of the West. Among other public build-
ings he designed the magnificent State Capitols at Springfield, Illinois,
and Des Moines, Iowa. He died several years ago at St. Louis.
12 ICARIA.
the spot where the city of Dallas now flourishes),
and must be reached by a march across a wellnigh
trackless wilderness of plains and hills, prairies and
forests, undrained swamps and unbridged streams,
swollen by the spring rains. Like most emigrants,
these pilgrims were encumbered with much unneces-
sary luggage, and provided with too little ready
money. They spent several days in Shreveport try-
ing in vain to procure wagons and teams for the
conveyance of their goods to Sulphur Prairie. (Sul-
phur Prairie, be it said, was a farm about a hundred
miles from Shreveport, which Sully, Cabet's com-
missioner, had bought as an Icarian rendezvous and
base of operations ; and at this time Sully himself
was lying sick at Sulphur Prairie.) Finally a portion
of the guard started, with two or three ox-teams and
one wagon. The others remained behind until they
had completed a large temporary shed on the edge
of the village, in which shed they stored their trouble-
some and bulky belongings. A most graphic account
of the weary trudge on foot from Shreveport to
Sulphur Prairie and thence to Icaria was written by
Levi de Rheims on the 2d of June, a very few days
after his arrival on the scene of the " new terrestrial
paradise." This letter, written to relatives and
friends in France, found its way into print, and a
copy of it is among my materials for this sketch.
From the arrival at New Orleans to the arrival at
Icaria, almost two months had elapsed. Strangers
COLONIZATION IN TEXAS. 33
in a strange land, unable to speak English, ignorant
of almost everything which a pioneer should know,
their hardships were only exceeded by their forti-
tude and good cheer. Sickness by the way, the
breaking down of their one wagon, the wading of
dangerous streams, the insufficient supply of food,
sleeping on the damp ground, — the whole situation
can hardly be realized by one who has not ex-
perienced something of life in a wilderness.
At Sulphur Prairie they found a new cause of
anxiety and haste. They had been assured by Cabet
and by the Populaire that a million acres of land had
already been acquired. Here also, as in the case of
the geographical situation, they found a painful dis-
crepacny. The acquisition was discovered to be not
absolute, but on condition of actual colonization.
Each man could secure and hold a half-section (320
acres) by building a house upon it and living therein.
This would give free possession. But this offer held
good only until July 1st. After that date, land
would have to be purchased at one dollar an acre.
When July 1st arrived, it was found that their utmost
efforts had availed to build thirty-two very small
log-cabins. They were, therefore, in possession, not
of 1,000,000 acres, but of 10,240. As it was a jour-
ney of more than three months from Paris to Icaria,
emigrants leaving France later than the month of
March could not possibly have arrived in time to
secure land under the contract with Peters.
34
ICAR1A.
But it remains to relate another sad discrepancy.
The thirty-two half-sections were not contiguous !
The State of Texas had granted to the Peters Com-
pany each alternate section (square mile, 640 acres)
of a certain tract of land, on condition that the
company should secure immigration. The company
had in turn granted the Icarians the privilege of
acquiring by actual residence the half of each of its
sections, to the extent of a million acres. Cabet's
million acres would therefore have been checkered
over a territory of four millions, and the 10,240
acres were scattered through two townships. The
accompanying diagram represents a single township
(thirty-six sections), the blank sections representing
the land reserved by Texas, the blank half-sections
that reserved by the Peters Company, and the
COLONIZATION IN TEXAS. 35
shaded half-sections showing the disjointed char-
acter of the Icarian domain.
It needs no argument to show that a colony in-
tending to live grouped in a village, with a unitary
cuisine and dining-hall and a cooperative system of
agriculture and industry, must have its land in a
compact body. The possibility of buying the alter-
nate half-sections from Mr. Peters and the alternate
sections from the State of Texas was entirely too
remote and uncertain to have been relied upon. In
spite of all this disheartening outlook, the pioneers
kept pretty good spirits, and set resolutely to work
to establish a central headquarters, in anticipation of
the large arrivals expected. A log-house fifteen feet
wide by twenty-five long was achieved, and three or
four long covered sheds. The summer was far ad-
vanced, but it was obviously necessary to put in a
crop. A plow had been purchased, and they set about
" breaking" prairie. But, alas! they knew not how.
In turning the matted virgin sod of the prairie for
the first time, the Western farmer never sinks his
plow-share deeper than two or three inches ; but
these young French tailors and shoemakers knew
nothing about Western farming, and they drove the
plow in clear to the beam. It was what is known
in Western parlance as a large " breaking plow/'
and they fastened twenty oxen to it. They broke
their plow very promptly, but they never " broke '
any Texas prairie. For by this time the middle of
36 ICARIA.
July was past, and man after man succumbed to an
intermittent malarial fever, till there was not a well
person in the camp. The unaccustomed heat, their ar-
duous and imprudent labors, and their unacclimated
condition had subjected them to a terrible scourge.
Their physician became sick, then hopelessly insane.
Four men soon died of the fever. Another was
killed by lightning. Those least sick prepared food
and cared for their more helpless comrades.
August was passing away. It was now too late
to think of putting in a crop, even if they had been
able to do the work. It took letters several months
to reach France, and they knew that before word
could be received from Texas their own wives and
families, as well as many additional Icarians, would
have embarked for America. To prepare either
the settlement on the Peters lands or the camp at
Sulphur Prairie for the winter-quarters of a large
body of immigrants was now seen to be practically
impossible. In June, the pioneers had been cheer-
ful, and had written home glowing, enthusiastic
accounts of the beauty and evident richness of the
vast prairies, with their fine streams bordered with
heavy timber fringes. But a wild southwestern
prairie in the flowery months of May and June
seems a much more inviting and hospitable place
than under the withering sun and scorching winds
of August. The fever had dispirited the Icarians,
and the country had become loathsome to them.
COLONIZATION IN TEXAS. 37
They resolved to abandon it. Indeed, to have done
otherwise would have been mistaken heroism.
About the middle of September, after a residence
of scarcely four months in Texas, the enfeebled
Icarians began a straggling retreat to Shreveport.
They had produced nothing and had bought many
of their supplies from the agent of the Peters Com-
pany, whom they now reimbursed by turning over
to him their oxen and other articles of equipment.
They were far too numerous to march in a body, for
the few scattered farm-houses along the three
hundred miles between them and Shreveport could
not be expected to furnish food for a company
numbering several scores of famishing men. The
last money in the treasury was divided, and each
man, with gun and haversack and six or seven dol-
lars, began the journey. By different routes and in
small squads of two, three, or four men, travelling
faster or slower as their strength would permit, most
of them had reached Shreveport at the end of a
month. Four or five had died by the way. Nothing
in Icarian annals is more doleful than this retreat
of the Texas invalids.
The little squad composing the second advance
guard participated in this retreat. They had landed
at New Orleans, July22d, and ten or twelve of them
had reached Icaria on August 29th, others remain-
ing sick at Sulphur Prairie. Two or three days after
his arrival, Favard, the leader of the second ad-
33 ICARIA.
vance guard, had written home to Cabet the follow-
ing letter :
" Icarian Colony, Sept. 2, 1848.
" Poor Father : —
" How can I depict to you the situation in which I
have found our brothers ? Almost all those who survive
are sick. Four are dead ; the first was Guillot, the
second, Collet, who was killed by lightning, the third
was Guerin, and the fourth Tange.
" Those least sick attend to the cuisine and the fatigue
makes them fall sick again.
" The sun is so hot that if one is exposed to its rays he
is almost certain to have the fever. I have not hesitated
an instant in favoring the abandonment of the camp —
which also seems best to all ; for many have only awaited
our arrival in order to have the assistance which would
enable them to get away.
" We should not be able to bring the women here by
these abominable roads. Wagons could not make more
than two or three leagues a day. One finds no villages,
but only farm-houses at long intervals, and in none of
them have they beds for four persons. One does not even
find bread ; for the people of the country do not make
bread except in small quantities at the very moment of
eating.
" When we started from Shreveport we left there our
trunks and mattresses. We loaded our wagons with pro-
visions for our brothers and ourselves. We placed in
our haversacks such clothing as was indispensable and a
blanket, and thus departed. We slept out of doors dur-
COLONIZATION IN TEXAS. 39
ing the entire route. We had beautiful weather all the
time ; but that did not prevent eight [8 out of 19] of our
men from falling sick, and it was necessary to leave them
en route. Edouard remained with them as nurse.
" I continued on the road with the others, and we ar-
rived here in good health. All our attention is given to
those who are most ill, and to preparations for departure.
But what is most annoying is that we have incurred a
debt of seven or eight thousand francs, and we are em-
barrassed for the means to liquidate it under the circum-
stances. If we can arrange with our creditors we will
occupy ourselves exclusively with our retreat to Shreve-
port. We will join in writing you a letter making you
acquainted with all our affairs, * * *
" Ever your devoted
" Favard."
Cabet received this discouraging letter early in
November, but did not think it best to publish
it until about the first of December. It does not
seem to have occurred to him that he was in any
wise responsible for the sad fiasco. We read in
the Populaire in his bright, glowing style a most
sympathetic epitome of their hardships, — the story,
as he says, " of an ardor, a zeal, a devotion, a courage
almost superhuman. " " But," he reprovingly sug-
gests, "this was not prudent under a new climate."
He proceeds to recount the praises which all their
letters have bestowed upon the general features
of the country, and he asserts that if they had
40 ICARIA.
labored more moderately, had cared for themselves
more prudently during the heated term, and had
had their baggage and medicines and proper food,
"all our hopes would have been realized." He
further endeavors to show how the February revo-
lution had greatly contributed to the disaster. It
had overthrown Icarian plans in France, destroyed
financial resources, prevented the sending of men
and money to the aid of the pioneers, and had been
in every way paralyzing and distracting. Thus
Cabet laid all the blame on the imprudence of the
pioneers and the events of the Revolution, and it
seems never to have crossed his mind that his own
sanguine and immature sort of planning had really
been the chief cause of disaster. He concludes this
rather unsatisfactory article by saying that if the
first and second guards would decide to return from
Shreveport to Sulphur Prairie, which, he adds, they
were morally certain to do, " all would yd be saved."
" All would yet be saved." Just what Cabet
meant by this it is difficult to say. Perhaps it was
not quite clear in his own mind. As a practical
financier and manager, Cabet's limitations were
already becoming conspicuous. By this time the
general emigration had begun. In several different
vessels as many as four hundred Icarians arrived at
New Orleans toward the close of 1848. Last of
all Cabet came himself. He embarked from France
the 15th of December and arrived in January.
COLONIZATION IN TEXAS. 41
Affairs had gone unfortunately with our politician,
litterateur, and philosopher. He had fully believed
that his colony would be carried on a tremendous
wave of popularity, and had made no provision for
possible reverses. The finances of the society were
at low ebb. In fact the society had never had any
firm financial basis. Before the first advance
guard had sailed, the Populaire had published a
"Plan Financier" which is rather a remarkable
document. It begins by frankly confessing that
Icaria lacks the funds for the proposed emigration,
and that their cause would seem hopeless but for
the fact that it was based upon grand truths, such
as could be relied upon to win universal confidence
and sympathy, and open universal purse-strings.
The "Plan" proceeds to give five sources whence
the necessary capital would be forthcoming. First,
the property of the members. At least 600 francs
for preliminary expenses vrould be required of all
who joined the emigration. Second, gifts and sub-
scriptions for Icaria. An appeal was made to all
classes to aid so beneficent and glorious a move-
ment. Third, loans, which might be contracted
with companies, large capitalists, and even with
common people in sums as small as 500 francs.
These loans would be secured by mortgage on the
real estate of the prospective Icaria, which real
estate Cabet declared would " augment in value ten-
fold, fifty-fold and even a hundred-fold." Fourth,
42 ICARIA.
it was expected that credit could be obtained for
the larger purchases and negotiations. Fifth, " we
will establish a bank and issue circulating notes, as
is the usage in America for grand enterprises which
inspire sympathy and confidence ! "
So ethereal and precarious a scheme may well
make us smile ; but we must remember that more
experienced men have often embarked in less prom-
ising enterprises. The " Plan " read smoothly, had
a plausible appearance, and was not subjected to
very critical scrutiny by the enthusiastic young
ouvriersy whose sublime faith in Cabet made them
ready to brave any thing at his bidding.
Besides the colonization scheme and its reverses,
Cabet must have been at this time greatly occupied
with French politics. It was not possible for him
to be in France without being a participant in the
incessant agitations of the entire year 1848. Those
were times when it was literally impossible to tell
what a day would bring forth. If Cabet had some
political aspiration, some dream of being a Minister
or even a President, it was pardonable under the
circumstances. We actually find him mentioned
during the fall as one of the seven or eight more
prominent presidential candidates, Louis Napoleon,
Cavaignac, and Lamartine leading in the list. But
there was no prospect of his election, and five days
before the overwhelming vote in favor of Louis Na-
poleon was thrown, Cabet left France with declining
COLONIZATION IN TEXAS. 43
fortunes behind him and prospects none too bril-
liant before him.
Early in 1849, then, we find the Icarian pilgrims
of seven or eight successive embarkations, and num-
bering in all about four hundred and eighty souls, re-
united with their founder and leader at New Orleans.
Their treasury contained somewhere near 86,000
francs — $35 per capita. It is hardly too conserva-
tive an estimate to say that people founding a home
in an entirely undeveloped country should have suf-
ficient capital to provide for fully two years' suste-
nance besides all other expenses. If it had been de-
cided to return to Sulphur Prairie, the 86,000 francs,
after deducting transportation and other unavoid-
able expenses, would have furnished support for
only a few months. Returning to Texas was there-
fore out of the question. In the presence of hard
realities, the beautiful dream of a million acres on
the Red River, with the fine roads and the rapidly
rising towns had faded away. For three months
the Icarian community controlled no wider premises
than those pertaining to two large brick houses on
Saint Ferdinand Street, New Orleans. Exploring
parties were sent in different directions in search of
a new location. Those were weeks of suspense,
dampened enthusiasm, and incessant — not always
harmonious — discussion. Many wished to return
to France. Others desired to secure a more suitable
location than Texas, and persevere with the colony.
44 ICARIA.
At length a minority of two hundred withdrew,
Cabet allowing them to take $5,000 — nearly one
third of the precious 86,000 francs. Some of this
minority remained in New Orleans, but the larger
number returned to France, no more to embark in
Utopian enterprises. Some two hundred and
eighty souls remained with their leader, heard the
reports of the returned explorers, agreed upon a lo-
cation, and early in March took passage on a Mis-
sissippi steamer for their new home.
III.
COMMUNITY LIFE AT NAUVOO.
III.
COMMUNITY LIFE AT NAUVOO.
If these people had been of a religious mind,
they might well have believed that their new home
was providentially prepared for them. In 1840
Joseph Smith had brought his Mormon followers
from Missouri to Hancock County, Illinois, and had
built the town of Nauvoo in a beautiful bend of the
Mississippi, and on a magnificent tract of agricul-
tural land. In four or five years the Latter-Day
Saints at Nauvoo numbered 15,000, and their pros-
perity was remarkable. At this time Chicago had
only 8,000 people, and Nauvoo was the largest and
most flourishing town in the State. But, as in
Ohio, and afterward in Missouri, so now in Illinois
the active hostility of " Gentile " neighbors was too
intense to be withstood. Smith was killed, and the
new prophet, Brigham Young, organized the migra-
tion to Salt Lake — a migration as absolutely unique
and remarkable as any ever recorded. This two
years' migration was now practically completed,
and Nauvoo was an almost empty town. The Mor-
mons still had large properties there in land and
houses, and had left an agent in charge.
47
43 I C ARIA.
Here, then, was the opportunity for the Icarians.
Their resources forbade the immediate occupation
of the virgin soil on the frontier; but at Nauvoo
they could find good houses ready built, and good
land that had been brought under cultivation. Best
of all, they were not obliged to exhaust their scanty
treasury by the purchase of land, for under the cir-
cumstances it could be rented at a merely nominal
figure. It was indeed well for them that they had
thus found a ready-made home, for they were
dispirited and homesick. On the boat up the river
they had been attacked by the cholera, and had
lost twenty of their number. The division at New
Orleans had parted many friends. The deaths in
Texas and on the Mississippi had left many
mourners.
On the 15th of March they landed at Nauvoo.
They purchased some houses in the village, rented
perhaps 800 acres o*f land, bought a.mill.and a distil-
lery, and set their social life in the best order that
circumstances would permit. We will not concern
ourselves with their doings for the first year or two,
while they were fitting themselves to their sur-
roundings, and were at work on the problem of
adjusting their actual life to their Icarian theories.
We must simply remember that they were average
Frenchmen, abundantly endowed with the ordinary
traits of human nature, trying sincerely to adopt a
more equal, unselfish, altruistic life ; that they were
COMMUNITY LIFE AT NAUVOO. 49
embarking in a difficult enterprise without the ad-
vantage either of experience or capital ; that they
were artisans from French cities founding a com-
munity based on agriculture ; that they were igno-
rant of the language, laws, customs, and business
methods of the country ; and that their leader was
rather a patriot, agitator, and theorist than a practi-
cal business manager.
In 1854 or 1855, the visitor would have found the
colony well established and measurably prosperous.
Suppose we imagine ourselves shown through the
establishment by the bland and affable Cabet, presi-
dent of the community. On a tract of some fifteen
acres were the principal Icarian buildings, clustered
on and about the old " Temple Square " of the
Mormons. The Mormons had left unfinished a
huge "temple" of dressed white limestone, one
hundred and twenty-eight feet long, eighty feet
wide, and with walls sixty feet high. A fire in
1848 had destroyed the interior, but the bare walls
stood massive and uninjured. Cabet bought the
property with the intention of completing the tem-
ple and transforming it into a grand Icarian assem-
bly and dining hall, school-rooms, etc. But shortly
after the work of restoration had begun, a tornado
blew down the north wall, and the building was
henceforth utilized only as a stone-quarry whence
materials were taken for other structures. The
main Icarian building was one hundred and fifty feet
50 ICARIA.
by thirty, two stones high, and the first floor was
used as the common dining-hall, an assembly room,
theatre, etc., while the upper rooms were used as
dwellings. A large two-story stone building was
erected for educational purposes. Another large
stone building, the old Mormon arsenal, was bought
and transformed into workshops. For dwelling
purposes a forty-room brick house had been pur-
chased of the Mormons and a number of smaller
houses were bought, built, or rented. Thus the
question of habitations had been fortunately dis-
posed of.
Membership, meanwhile, had doubled, and we find
a community numbering upward of five hundred,1
while as many more had come, tarried awhile, and
departed. We find a thousand acres or more of
rented land under cultivation. The chief industries
are a flouring mill, saw mill and whiskey distillery.
Various small workshops, tailoring, shoemaking,
blacksmithing, carpentering, and the like supply the
needs of the community and are a source of income
by taking outside work. Good schools are main-
tained in which boys and girls are taught separately
and taken very young. English, French, mathe-
1 Mr. Nordhoff is in error when he says that Cabet "had at
Nauvoo at one time not less than fifteen hundred people." {Vide
"Communistic Societies of the United States," p. 334.) Member-
ship never reached six hundred at any one time. But members were
coming and going continually, and it is not unlikely that as many as
fifteen hundred different individuals were at one time or another
connected with Icaria between 1849 anc* I856.
COMMUNITY LIFE AT NAUVOO. 51
matics, drawing, history, and geography are taught,
but mere cramming is not the object of the school.
Careful training in manners and morals, and in
Icarian principles and precepts, is work with which
the schools are especially charged. The printing-
office is a place of great activity. Newspapers are
printed in English, French, and German. Icarian
school-books are published, treating of the history
and doctrine of the community as well as of the
common branches of knowledge. Pamphlets, news-
papers, and books designed to aid the propaganda
in France are industriously produced, and dis-
tributed through the agency of the Icarian Bureau
at Paris. It is pleasant to find that the community
is a model of industry, intelligence, peace and good
order, that family life is sacredly regarded, and that
the Nauvoo neighbors, whose experience with the
Mormons had naturally made them at first suspicious
of the new French colonists, have now learned to es-
teem them highly. A library of five or six thousand
volumes, chiefly standard French works, seems to be
much patronized. Though obliged, as they explain,
by circumstances to operate a distillery as a leading
means of support, we see the Icarians discounte-
nancing the use among themselves of alcoholic
drinks and also of tobacco. They have not lost
their love for public amusement, and a well-trained
band discourses good music at the numerous fetes
of the community. Frequent theatrical entertain-
UNIVERS1TY OF
ILLINOIS LIBRARV
52 ICARIA.
merits, social dances, and lectures are common means
of diversion, and attract many outside visitors. The
style of living is economical, hard labor is a neces-
sity; but it must be admitted by the intelligent
visitor that the Icarian system is enabling these
families to live a less sordid life, one more social,
humane, intellectual, and less grinding, toilsome,
and degrading than that of the average workingman
under the system of individualism and competition.
They are far from the condition of the happy Ica-
rians in the " Voyage," but considering the difficul-
ties they have encountered they must be accredited
with having done reasonably well.
It was from the outset the intention to make Nau-
voo only a temporary home ; and as early as 1852
a number of men were sent into southwestern Iowa
1 to acquire government land, and begin its improve-
ment with the purpose of ultimately removing the
community thither. At the end of the year 1855,
we find that the official inventory of the community's
property, exclusive of that in Iowa, sums up $76,
439.76, from which should be deducted a debt of
$11,633.23, leaving a net valuation of $64,806.53.
In addition to this, the community owned in Iowa
over three thousand (3,115) acres of land with some
crude improvements on the tract. Unless some
serious reverses should overtake them, the Icarians
had now reached the point from which they might
expect rapid material prosperity. Unhappily, the
COMMUNITY LIFE AT NAUVOO. 53
reverses were already impending. The difficulties
were in connection with the government of the
society.
In an earlier chapter I have spoken of the im-
pressive scene at Havre when the first advance
guard assented to the " Icarian Engagement" and the
" Social Contract," promising among other things to
accept Cabet as dictator for ten years. These en-
gagements were also taken by the several parties
embarking successively during the year 1848, and
were renewed at New Orleans and again renewed on
arriving in Nauvoo. However, before the com-
munity had lived in Nauvoo a year, Cabet resolved
to relinquish his absolute authority, and to give his
people a constitution. The document was submitted
and unanimously adopted in February, 1850. It is
so long that a synopsis of its chief provisions must
suffice here. It provided for six directors, called a
" Committee of Gerance," elected for a year, three
being chosen every six months. One of these
was to be elected separately as President of the
Icarian Community. These six divided among them-
selves the work of administration as follows: 1st.,
Presidency and General Superintendence ; 2d.,
General Direction of Finances and Provisions ; 3d.,
Clothing and Lodging; 4th., Education, Health, and
Amusements ; 5th., Industry and Agriculture ; 6th.,
Secretaryship and Management of the Printing-
office. Legislative authority was vested in the
54 ICARIA.
General Assembly, which met every Saturday, and
was composed of every male member of the com-
munity twenty years old. The Committee of Gerance
were responsible to the Assembly. The constitution
was subject to revision every second year. Admis-
sions to the community were first provisional; then
definitive, by vote of the Assembly, after six months'
probation. In case of withdrawal, half of the
property brought into the community by the in-
dividual was returned to him.
One of Cabet's objects in granting this constitu-
tion was the procuring of a charter of incorporation
from the Illinois Legislature. The Mormon charter
had been revoked by the Legislature during the
trouble at Nauvoo, and there had remained a very
strong prejudice against chartering peculiar so-
cieties. Cabet's constitution contained a great
amount of preliminary and general matter explain-
ing the moral and social virtues of the Icarian sys-
tem, and appealing to the approbation of the
average legislator by expressing many of the glitter-
ing political maxims of the American Declaration
of Independence. Notwithstanding this unexcep-
tionable constitution, the community had some
difficulty in getting its charter, the act finally pass-
ing by a small majority. Under the new organic
law, Cabet was elected President, and was unani-
mously reelected from year to year. But on more
than one important subject differences of opinion
COMMUNITY LIFE AT NAUVOO. 55
began to appear. Cabet was not always wise, and
a number of younger and more practical men found
themselves frequently at variance with him. He
was now nearly seventy years old, and was perhaps
growing more arbitrary and determined in the ex-
ercise of power while becoming less capable of
exercising it wisely.
The breach was widening imperceptibly, and its
extent was not realized by either party until in
December, 1855, when Cabet made a proposition
for a radical change in the constitution. He pro-
posed the abolition of the governing board of di-
rectors, the so-called " Committee of Gerance," and
the substitution of a President, to hold office four
years, who should have authority to name and to
remove at will all the subordinate officers of the
community. The constitution distinctly provided
for revision every two years, namely, in March,
1853, March, 1855, March, 1857, etc. Cabet's propo-
sition therefore came at an illegal time. It should
have been made nearly a year earlier, or more than
a year later. Moreover, it violated express provis-
ions of the Illinois charter. Nevertheless, he in-
sisted, and every Icarian took sides, — the majority
being against Cabet. The contest grew serious,
bitter, and disturbing. A few weeks later, on Feb.
3d (anniversary of the first departure from Havre),
came the annual Presidential election. In the
meeting of the Assembly on that day Cabet stoutly
56 ICARIA.
refused to withdraw his proposition, and hinted
darkly at abandoning the society. Thereupon the
majority proceeded to choose as President a vigor-
ous young leader of their party, J. B. Gerard by
name. Cabet was thoroughly surprised. He con-
sented to withdraw his proposition for a year, and
the whole Icarian community met the next day
and showed their undiminished personal affection
for their old chief by unanimously electing him
President, Gerard gladly resigning for that purpose.
Peace seemed to be secured, but hostilities soon
opened again. Cabet had most of the Committee
of Gerance on his side, and therefore controlled the
executive, while his opponents held a steady major-
ity in the Assembly, to which the executive was
theoretically subject. Cabet controlled the printing-
office and newspaper, and used the press for par-
tisan purposes. Dissension now so threatened the
permanence and prosperity of the society that many
withdrew from membership. The Assembly ap-
pointed an investigating committee who condemned
the management of the printing-office. Another
committee investigated the affairs of the Icarian
Bureau in Paris. This was in the charge of Madame
Cabet and other members of the family. It had
been a centre of propaganda and information, had
secured recruits, and had been the European fiscal
agency of the community, negotiating loans and
receiving donations. Cabet had made use of it for
COMMUNITY LIFE AT NAUVOO. $7
the distribution among the thousands of Icarians in
France of bulletins and circulars which were secret-
ly printed at Nauvoo and were full of denunciations
against the actions of the majority. The committee
reported that the Bureau was expensive, ill-managed,
and hostile to the majority of the community, and
recommended its immediate suppression. The rec-
ommendation was adopted by the Assembly. Ca-
bet now brought in proposals of separation, his
plan being that one party should remain at Nauvoo
and the other occupy the Iowa domain. But a
party which was in the majority and legally in the
right could hardly be expected under the circum-
stances to cede half the common estate to a disaf-
fected, turbulent, and law-breaking minority. So
all hope of amicable separation fell to the ground.
Both parties rushed into print voluminously
enough, with memorials, resolutions, pamphlets,
polemics, and appeals to the world ; but though I
have collected a quantity of such materials relating
to this bitter little civil war, I must hasten the re-
cital lest the story become tedious. I have al-
ready stated that half the Committee of Gerance
were elected in February, and half six months later
— viz., August 3d. The majority of the Gerance
were still Cabetists. The date of the August elec-
tion arrived, and the anti-Cabet party elected their
own candidates, thus at length obtaining preponder-
ant executive influence. Cabet and the minority
58 ICARIA.
refused to submit to the election, and the old mem-
bers of the Gerance would not yield up their offices
to the newly elect. Excitement and enmity now
reached their climax, and the civil authorities of
Nauvoo intervened to prevent probable bloodshed.
The new directors were installed by force. The
whole Cabet party thereupon ceased to work at
their places in shops, fields, and mills. For months
the party lines had been drawn everywhere. In the
Assembly the opposing factions had occupied oppo-
site sides of the hall ; at meals they had taken sep-
arate tables ; the little children at school had be-
come partisans. Now the majority decided that
those who would not work should not eat. The
new Gerance assigned every individual his work,
and gave notice that those who absented themselves
from labor would be cut off from rations after
August 13th.
Cabet rented a large building in the village of
Nauvoo, and the minority made it their temporary
home. Their object now seemed to be to secure
the dissolution of the society. By secret letters and
messengers Cabet had secured the loyalty of the
larger part of those absent on the land in Iowa, and
he undertook to effect the abandonment of that
estate, which would have entailed severe damage
upon the community, since the titles were in Cabet's
name, and if the estate had been deserted, the
Nauvoo Community would not have the prestige of
COMMUNITY LIFE AT NAUVOO. 59
" possession," which " is nine points of the law."
The alertness of the majority foiled Cabet's scheme
in this direction. He also endeavored to bring
financial confusion on the community by making
damaging statements to its creditors, and represent-
ing it as in an unsound condition. He had carried
away the records and account books, and as he had
always represented the community in its external
relations, he was in a situation to injure its credit
materially. He further attempted to secure the
dissolution of the community by bringing suit in
the State courts. This plan was found ineffective,
and in a long partisan statement the Cabetists pe-
titioned the Legislature of Illinois to repeal the Act
of Incorporation. The Legislature refused to do so
by a vote of 55 to 9. In October a committee ap-
pointed for that purpose brought into the Assembly
a series of formal charges against Cabet which were
sustained by unanimous vote, and he was expelled
from membership.
The minority had already resolved to spend the
winter in St. Louis, where their men, largely tailors
and mechanics, could find work pending the adop-
tion of some permanent arrangement. About the
1st of November the minority, comprising one hun-
dred and eighty persons, left Nauvoo. A week
later, Nov. 8, 1856, Cabet died suddenly of apoplexy,
in St. Louis. He was in his sixty-ninth year. In
his threescore years of life in France as a democrat,
60 ICARIA.
revolutionist, and doctrinaire, Cabet had suffered im-
prisonment, exile, ridicule, slander, persecution by
the officers of church and state ; but nothing had
ever so pained and shocked him as his rejection at
Nauvoo. He had grown old ; he had long since
abandoned all idea of preferment and power in
French public life ; nothing was left to him but the
colony he had founded. And he had so identified
himself with its fortunes that he unconsciously mag-
nified his own importance to the community. It
seemed to him his very own. Any dissent from his
opinion was treason. The democratic government
which he had himself granted became an evil thing
in his eyes, because it sometimes obstructed his own
necessary, beneficent, and pre-eminently wise gov-
ernment. Cabet must not be too severely blamed
for the plots, subterfuges, and machinations he em-
ployed in the quarrel. He was hardly responsible
for his conduct. He had lost the power to view
Icaria as a thing separate from his own personality ;
he was not a part of the community — the com-
munity was a part of him.
Cabet was so industriously calumniated and un-
dervalued in France by contemporary writers hostile
to socialism, that the lies have, in part at least,
stuck ; and neither his character nor his ability have
been appreciated at their true worth. He had
faults, more than one of which I have been obliged
already to show. But he was a better and truer man
COMMUNITY LIFE AT NAUVOO. 6 1
than his Parisian detractors. He was ambitious ;
but more than once he sacrificed office, fortune, and
prospects rather than be false to his convictions and
his sense of public duty. Disaffected persons who
had left the community at New Orleans and re-
turned to France charged him with embezzlement
before the French courts and in his absence secured
against him a verdict of guilty. Hearing of the
matter he journeyed from Nauvoo to Paris to
vindicate himself. In the spring of 1852 he
triumphantly refuted all charges preferred against
him and was formally acquitted by the court.1
Cabet's literary work, done chiefly in the intervals
of a life busy with other pursuits, was considerable
in amount and not devoid of merit. A list of his
1 Professor Richard Owen of New Harmony, Ind., a son of the dis-
tinguished English reformer, Robert Owen, furnishes me with two or
three pleasant incidents connected with this visit of Cabet's to
Europe. It would seem that on his return from France he stopped
in England to see his old friend and counsellor, Owen. For, says my
informant : " In Part XXI. of Robert Owen's Journal, June 5, 1S52,
an account is given of the toasts and responses, on May 14th, when
celebrating my father's birthday at Anderton's Hotel, Fleet St. My
father responded to the first and second toasts, ' The Queen,' ' Robert
Owen ' ; the third, ' The distinguished social reformers from abroad,'
etc., etc., was responded to by MM. Cabet, Pierre Leroux, Walter
Cooper, and Lloyd Jones." As to honors paid Cabet on his arrival
in New York, Mr. Owen also says : " I find in my father's periodical
(' Robert Owen's Journal,') Part XXV., Sept. 25, 1852, a paragraph
copied from the ATew York Tribune of July 9th giving an account of
a banquet at the Shakespeare Hotel, N. Y., on July 8th, in honor of
M. Cabet, at which M. E. Chevalier [the French economist] pro-
posed his health, and M. Cabet ' responded in an interesting and
eloquent speech,' etc. On the next page [of Owen's Journal] is an
extract from The Popular Tribune, organ of the Icarian community.
It is headed: 'Arrival of M. Cabet at Nauvoo.' All this shows
the strong interest my father took in the movements of M. Cabet."
62 ICARIA.
writings has never been placed on record. Those
which I shall name in this paragraph have all come
under my notice, and I have heard of no others of
importance. The five-volume " Histoire Populaire
de la Revolution Frangaise de 1789 a. 1830," is his
most extensive work. The "Voyage en Icarie '
and the " Vrai Christianisme ' have already been
sufficiently described and are without question the
author's best productions. " Douze Lettres d'un
Communiste a. un Reformiste sur la Communaute '
(1841-2, pp. 166) was published a year after the
appearance of the "Voyage," in explanation and
defence of its doctrines. The " Refutation du
Dictionnaire Politique (articles Babouvisme, Com-
munaute, Association, Propriete) et de la Revue des
Deux Mondes (sur le Communisme)," the character
of which is sufficiently obvious from the title, ap-
peared in the fall of 1842. In the previous year
also he had published an important pamphlet de-
fending marriage and the institution of the family,
and entitled " Refutation de X l Humanitaire ' (de-
mandant l'abolition du manage et de la famille)."
Deploring the hostility between French communis-
tic sects and journals, he wrote in 1845 a little book
of fifty-six pages, " Le Salut est dans TUnion ; la Con-
currence est la Ruine." " Les Masques Arraches '
(1845, PP« *44) is a controversial defence of com-
munism. Cabet took advantage of his visit to
France to publish in 1852 a " Lettre du Citoyen
COMMUNITY LIFE AT NAUVOO. 63
Cabet a l'Archeveque de Paris en Reponse a son
Mandement du 8 Juin, 185 1." The Archbishop had
issued a mandate severely condemning communism,
and Cabet in a pamphlet of forty-seven pages refers
him to the communistic practices of the Apostles
and the early Church, cites the opinions of the
Church fathers, etc. " Proces et Acquittement du
Citoyen Cabet Accuse d'Escroquerie pour 1' Emigra-
tion Icarienne " is a volume of two hundred and forty
pages, in which are compiled the evidence, corre-
spondence, addresses, etc., relating to Cabet's trial
for embezzlement. I have seen no copies of the
" Icarian Almanac," published from 1843 to j^47j
— a work which seems to have played an important
part in the propaganda. The " Realization du
Communisme" (1847) is a volume filled with ex-
tracts from the Populaire respecting the proposed
emigration. To this list of writings might be added
a very large number of pamphlets, some published
in France and some at Nauvoo.
IV.
THE CHELTENHAM EPISODE.
IV.
THE CHELTENHAM EPISODE.
The Icarians, one hundred and eighty in num-
ber, who had accompanied Cabet in his retreat from
Nauvoo to St. Louis, had relied in every thing upon
their leader ; and his death was a terrible blow to
them. A romantic young German, Fritz Bauer,
committed suicide in his grief, and the whole group
were hardly less disconsolate. But, the first mo-
ment of stupor past, they took courage. They had,
on October 13, 1856, before leaving Nauvoo, taken
an engagement to remain faithful to Icaria and its
founder ; and they now resolved unanimously that
the best mode of honoring the memory of their de-
parted leader and of testifying to their faith in his
principles consisted in remaining united and con-
tinuing his work.
They installed themselves as well as they could in
St. Louis, intending as soon as possible to acquire a
tract of land somewhere further west for a perma-
nent home. Meanwhile the men, who were nearly
all tailors, shoemakers, or mechanics of some de-
scription, found work in the city. Explorers were
sent in various directions to discover the promised
67
68 ICARIA.
land, but nothing was found which met all the con-
ditions requisite. In May, 1858, the search was
given up and an estate called Cheltenham, lying six
miles west of St. Louis, was purchased.
This place afforded some advantages as a domicile
for the community. It was near the city, and the
men could continue to work at their trades. It pos-
sessed a large stone house capacious enough to
lodge the greater portion of the colony, besides six
log-houses. Unfortunately there were only twenty-
eight acres of land, and the price paid was very
large — $25,000. Further, the location was unhealthy,
and the intermittent fever was as regular in its semi-
annual visits as the appearance of spring-time and
fall. It was much better, however, than remaining
in St. Louis, crowded into several scattered houses ;
and it was with elation that the new home was en-
tered on May 8, 1858.
During the sojourn in the city a few families had
withdrawn, and at the time of removal the member-
ship was not above one hundred and fifty. This is
as large a number as was ever reached at Chelten-
ham ; for though accessions from France were made
almost continually, the withdrawals were quite as
numerous and constant. At once upon their re-
moval the Icarians set about perfecting their social
and industrial organization. They established work-
shops of tailors, joiners, wheel-wrights, blacksmiths,
painters, shoemakers, etc. All these shops, of
THE CHELTENHAM EPISODE. 69
course, did work for outsiders, in addition to sup-
plying the Icarians themselves, and were sufficiently
prosperous to furnish a comfortable support for the
establishment as well as to meet the first payments
on the property as they became due.
The Cheltenham community was exceedingly
active in propaganda. It had many correspondents,
it published a journal and a number of books, and
it maintained at Paris the Bureau which the Nauvoo
majority had so bitterly condemned for its partisan-
ship. The Bureau printed and circulated many
brochures throughout France. Cabet's name and
the efforts of the bureau gave the Cheltenham
branch a prestige which the Nauvoo brethren lacked,
and the formerwas recognized in France as the only
original and genuine Icarian community. Thus the
men and money sent to reinforce the Icarian cause
were all diverted to St. Louis, and the Nauvoo
people strove in vain to get a hearing in France.
Many recruits were forwarded through the activity
of the Bureau, and a loan opened in Paris, in 1857,
produced the considerable sum of 50,000 francs
among Icarian disciples.
All now went prosperously; hope and enthusiasm
reigned in Cheltenham. Schools were opened for
the boys and girls, and a " salle d'asile " — a sort of
kindergarten — for the smallest children. The band
of music and the theatre, so dear to the French
heart, were not wanting. In 1858 the so-called
70 ICARIA.
11 Cours Icarien ' was inaugurated. This was a
Sunday-afternoon assembly which contributed much
to the intellectual and moral well-being of the com-
munity. The programme usually consisted of select
readings from the works of Cabet and other authors,
recitations by the school-children, and discourses on
various subjects by the more accomplished members
of the community. It was a school for mutual im-
provement in things moral and mental. Progress
was also making in the payment of the debt on the
property ; and thus the material as well as the moral
situation was satisfactory. Still a few years of cour-
age, union, and perseverance, and the community
of Cheltenham would be in condition to undertake,
with good guaranties of success, its removal to some
ampler and more suitable domain.
But this was never to be realized. In May, 1859,
the community entered upon a discussion of the
social and political constitution. Two radically dis-
tinct parties were developed. The majority adhered
faithfully to the later ideas entertained by Cabet,
and believed in investing very large if not absolutely
dictatorial authority in some chosen leader, — some
" gcrant unique" directing the moral and material
affairs of the community. The minority, however,
were unalterably opposed to so undemocratic a sys-
tem of government. Difference of opinion degener-
ated into party strife; and the vanquished minority,
numbering forty-two persons, left the community.
THE CHELTENHAM EPISODE. 7 1
This proved the death-blow to Cheltenham. From
the date of this withdrawal the community declined
in every way. Many of the most intelligent mem-
bers, many of the most skilful craftsmen, were
among those who withdrew, and the loss was irre-
parable. The depleted society struggled heroically
for five years longer in spite of a series of untoward
events which seemed to be in conspiracy to crush it
down ; and in 1864 there remained only eight
" citoyens," seven " citoyennes," and some chil-
dren. Thus had the number been reduced to a
residue of the bravest and most persistent spirits.
The mortgagee was pressing for payment and
threatening to take the property. Funds were ex-
hausted, and there were no available sources of
revenue. The propaganda had ceased, and no more
aid came from France. A last effort was still made.
Two members were sent to Nebraska to find an
eligible location on the public lands. But on their
return the morale was so weakened, and the funds
requisite to accomplish the removal were so com-
pletely lacking, that the undertaking had to be
abandoned.
It was a moment of profound sorrow for these
eight families when they met for the last time in
the capacity of an Icarian Assembly, to hear the
President, A. Sauva,1 formally announce the disso-
1 For the materials from which this chapter is prepared, I am en-
tirely indebted to Mr. Sauva, who at my request wrote me out, in
72 ICARIA.
lution of the community. There were few words
and many tears. In March, 1864, Sauva bestowed
the keys upon the mortgagee, and the last Icarian
left Cheltenham.
French, a little sketch of Cheltenham upon which the chapter is
based. In several places I have rendered into English Mr. Sauva's
own expressions.
V.
PIONEER LIFE IN IOWA.
PIONEER LIFE IN IOWA.
It need scarcely be said that the community at
Nauvoo had been greatly weakened by the split.
Much of the movable property, all of the account
books, a large portion of the library, had been car-
ried off by the seceders. The titles to the real
estate, both in Nauvoo and in Iowa, were in Cabet's
name, and long, tedious suits were required in order
to give the community perfect legal title to its own
premises. The whole system of industry had been
deranged. Crops had failed. Debts had greatly
increased. The St. Louis party, claiming as we
have already shown, to be the real Icarians and
maintaining the old Bureau in Paris, had so indus-
triously circulated their version of the story in
France, that the Nauvoo majority were there re-
garded by their still numerous Icarian fellow-dis-
ciples as base ingrates who had overturned the
society for selfish ends, driven away their noble
benefactor Cabet, broken his heart, and caused his
death by their brutal treatment. Letters of explana-
tion sent from Nauvoo to France were returned
unanswered. No more funds or recruits came to
75
76 ICARIA.
Nauvoo. However, the community pursued an
active, resolute course. Gerard was made Presi-
dent, and Marchand, a young man especially quali-
fied for the position, was made Secretary and placed
in charge of the printing-office. The Revue Icarienne
was reestablished and it most ably defended the
conduct of the majority in the recent strife.
On the first of January, 1857, the community
found itself with two hundred and thirty-nine
members, eighteen of whom were absent doing
pioneer work on the estate in Iowa. By the official
inventory of the same date, the assets of the com-
munity (exclusive of the Iowa property) had shrunk
to a little less than $60,000, while the debt had
grown to nearly $19,000. In Iowa they owned
3,115 acres of land, of which 273 were under culti-
vation and about 1,000 were woodland. Several log-
houses had been built, and live stock and farming
utensils to the value of several thousand dollars had
been accumulated.
Four or five years later, in the flush times, such a
financial showing would not have been discouraging.
But it must be remembered that this was at the
beginning of the year 1857. The great panic and
business depression of that year could not be
weathered by the community. Their industries
were no longer a source of profit ; creditors pressed
their claims ; Nauvoo property was dead, and could
not be made to realize any thing like the inventoried
PIONEER LIFE IN IOWA. 77
valuation. As to the land in Iowa, the soil of
almost the entire State lay wild and uninhabited,
and there was no demand for so remote a track as
that owned by Icaria. To crown the difficulty
Cabet's heirs held the title-deeds and would not
yield them up.
In this predicament it was decided that the com-
munity should remove to Iowa, and that its prop-
erty should be placed in the hands of assignees for
the benefit of the creditors. Mr. Gerard, the Presi-
dent,' and another member withdrew from the
society temporarily in order to be qualified to act as
assignees. These, with enough members to consti-
tute a board of directors, in order to do business
legally under their charter, remained at Nauvoo till
the courts had satisfactorily adjusted the titles in
Illinois and Iowa, the Nauvoo property had all been
sold, and the creditors had all been honorably
arranged with. This required more than two years,
and it was not until the fall of i860 that Nauvoo
was finally abandoned as the legal headquarters of
Icaria. In September of the same year a new char-
ter was procured under the laws of Iowa.1
1 Section 3 of the Illinois charter of 1851 read: "The busi-
ness of said company shall be manufacturing, milling, all kinds of
mechanical business, and agriculture." But in Iowa it was illegal
for the Legislature to grant special charters to corporations. General
laws of the State provided for the formation of banking and other
business corporations. These general laws, however, evidently did
not contemplate the incorporation of a community ; and their pro-
visions were in several respects unsuitable. For the benefit of the
Icarians the Legislature was prevailed upon in the spring of i860 to
78 ICARIA.
In these years of removal and non-production the
society reached a most unenviable financial condi-
tion. It retained the Iowa land, but subject to a
mortgage for a large amount. This debt drew ten
per cent, interest, and as the community was unable
to meet the interest payments, the debt was com-
pounding at a fearful rate. Moreover, membership
had become rapidly reduced by withdrawals after
the assignment in 1857.
The Icarian land lay in Adams County, in the
southwestern part of Iowa, about thirty miles north
of the Missouri State line, and about sixty miles
east of the Missouri River. It is upon a great
highway of travel, the main line of the Chicago,
Burlington, and Quincy Railroad passing across the
tract. Four miles to the west lies the prosperous
town of Corning, and twenty miles eastward is the
city of Creston. But, twenty-five years ago, the
railroad was not built, nor was there a house where
enact an additional section to the general law of corporations. This
section read as follows: "Corporations for agricultural and horti-
cultural purposes, and cemetery associations may be formed to endure
any length of time that, may be provided by the articles of incorpora-
tion thereof: Provided, such corporation shall not own to exceed
nine sections [5,760 acres] of land, and the improvements and neces-
sary personal property for the management thereof : and provided
further that the articles of incorporation shall provide a mode by
which any member thereof may, at any time withdraw from such
incorporation, and also the mode of determining the amount to be
received by such member upon withdrawal ; and also for the
payment thereof to such members subject only to the rights
of the creditors of such incorporation." Under this Iowa law,
therefore, which came into effect July 4, 1S60, the Icarians in Sep-
tember following took out a charter as an agricultural society.
Many years later this became a matter of vital consequence.
PIONEER LIFE I AT IOWA. 79
the towns stand. Where the traveller now finds
rich farms and clustering villages, there then
stretched the virgin prairie. In 1857 there was
not a squatter along the trail for forty miles east of
Icaria. It was indeed a new country. Cabet seems
to have believed that it was necessary for his colony
to begin its life in the greatest possible seclusion.
He wished its members to be free from the influ-
ences and attractions of the outside world, and to
be thrown in on themselves as entirely as possible
during the early years of the experiment. It was
with some such thought as this that he chose first
Texas and then southwestern Iowa for a location.
Perhaps, if his community could have grown, as he
had anticipated, into a very populous and diversified
society, it might have found itself able to maintain
a prosperous existence independent of the outside
world, as the Mormons proved themselves able to
do in Utah. And in that case Cabet's choice of a
remote location would doubtless have been well
advised. But a small community, a mere handful
of people, especially people like our French Icarians,
accustomed to a highly complex life in an old and
populous country, can not cut themselves loose from
the great world without peculiar hardships. They
would have done better to remain at Nauvoo, if
possible, or at least to have sought a less remote
locality.
Land under such circumstances has no value, ex-
So ICARIA.
cept a speculative or anticipatory one. It is, in the
economic phrase, a " free natural agent." It pro-
duces sustenance for the tiller, but it has not begun
to yield rent, and therefore it gives no surplus
to apply toward the purchase price. The present
homestead law, which makes wild lands free to
actual settlers, is simply just and reasonable on
economic principles, and the old law, under which
settlers like our Icarian friends were obliged to pay
$1.25 per acre, was a hardship. But, if the actual
settler on remote lands can not afford to pay any
purchase money, much less can he bear an addi-
tional weight of mortgages on his land. It is
simply a foregone conclusion that he will forfeit his
land to the speculative holder, who can afford to
await the time when the growth of population and
new facilities for transportation will give the land
market value. What if the Icarians had lived so
frugally that two thirds of their crop would have
been net surplus. There was no accessible market
for surplus farm products.1 Such was their situa-
1 The annals of the Western States are full of curious instances of
this kind. Within ten years quantities of corn have been burned as
fuel in parts of Missouri and Nebraska ; less because of a fuel famine
than from want of a market for grain. Being " land poor" is a fre-
quent expression in the West. Thousands of men have committed
the mistake of buying lands on credit at what seemed merely nominal
prices, but have ruined themselves and forfeited the lands because
they had not sufficient capital to hold valueless land until circum-
stances gave it value. In 1876, in Dakota, the writer found a solitary
farmer who had established himself on the shore of a beautiful little
lake. The rich shocks of harvested wheat dotted broad acres, and
the maize was maturing in his fields. In his granaries were thousands
PIONEER LIFE IN IOWA. 8 1
tion when they settled in Iowa on land which had
no actual market value, and yet was mortgaged for
three or four dollars an acre, on which ten per cent,
'annual interest was to be paid. Of course, they paid
no interest. The small amount of products which
they were able to transport eastward to a market
scarcely sufficed to procure clothing, salt, and the
most absolute necessaries. The story of their priva-
tions and hardships in those days can not be written.
It is a story which testifies to their high faith in the
principle of communism, and to their personal cour-
age and devotion. The group of small log-huts in
which they spent those days remains as a suggestive
reminder of pioneer privations.
In 1863 the debt had grown to $15,500. The war
of the rebellion, which was the destruction of Chel-
tenham, was the salvation of the Iowa Icaria. Agri-
cultural products rose to fabulous prices. The Icarians
had acquired a flock of sheep ; and wool had the
double advantage of being readily transportable and
of selling at an enormous figure. They improved this
favorable juncture and made a settlement with their
creditor by allowing him to take two thousand acres
of bushels of fine wheat, stored up from the crops of two or three
preceding years. It was a beautiful sight, this flourishing farm in a
wide uninhabited region ; but the clear grain was almost as valueless
as the chaff. It could not be drawn 150 miles to the nearest railroad
market over almost impassable wagon roads with any profit. To-day,
however, a prosperous "city" has grown up close by, two or three
railroads are accessible, any possible amount of farm surplus com-
mands high prices, and the formerly valueless land now has real and
high value.
82 ICARIA.
of their land at five dollars an acre. For the remain-
ing $5>500 of the debt they succeeded in procuring
the money. It was a fortunate deliverance.
They were left with only a little more than eleven
hundred acres of land ; but it was all they needed,
for their number was now reduced (1863) to only
thirty-five, including men, women, and children. The
withdrawal of members in those years of hardship
can not in all cases be attributed to selfish motives
or an unwillingness to share privation. Members
had to be fed, clothed, and sheltered ; and to a com-
munity unable even to pay interest on its debt,
membership may be a cause of added expense rather
than a source of advantage and profit.
For the ensuing twelve or thirteen years, life was
any thing but ideal and poetic in Icaria, and we need
not dwell at length upon its external features.
There were few events to break the monotony of
secluded farm life. These were years of patient,
self-sacrificing struggle, devoted to the one object of
securing a solid material basis for the happy Icaria
of the future. With this end in view these " soldiers
of humanity " shrank from no privation. Little by
little they bought back portions of their land.
Through their domain ran a stream known as the
Nodaway River, overlooking which, on the bluffy
upland half a mile away, was their cluster of a score
or more of diminutive log dwellings grouped about
a larger log structure which was used as common
PIONEER LIFE IN IOWA. 83
dining-hall and assembly room. On the river they
built a grist- and saw-mill, which was patronized by
the neighbors, and was the source of a small net in-
come. Their industry, intelligence, and upright con-
duct gained the favor of all the surrounding country.
Now and then an old Icarian family would return ;
and by the end of the year 1868, they were able to
report a membership of sixty, a domain of over
seventeen hundred acres, fairly well stocked with
horses, cattle, and sheep, their mills paid for, and
their entire indebtedness lifted. Three years later
we find the domain increased by two hundred more
acres, steam introduced in the mills, a personnel of
seventy members, a new framed central hall, sixty
feet long and two stories high, carpenter, black-
smith, wagon and shoe shops in operation, and rail-
road connections with Eastern markets furnished by
the completion of the Burlington and Missouri River
(now the Chicago, Burlington, and Quincy) Railroad.
Such are the meagre annals, for a dozen years, of
these disillusioned pioneers, who had hoped that by
this time their brilliant demonstration and realiza-
tion of a beautiful idea would have converted all
civilized nations and transformed the face of the
earth. Verily, the world had even forgotten their
existence.
Doubtless their care and toil for the means made
them sometimes forget the end. It would have been
strange had it been otherwise. When men and
84 ICARIA.
women have spent the best quarter-century of their
lives drudging for the bare means of subsistence and
haunted by the spectre of debt, even if they do not
grow sordid and hard, they tend to become cautious
and conservative ; the generous enthusiasms and
glowing ideals of youth are toned down and tem-
pered by stern experience. The amenities of life
had a poor chance in those miserably built, cramped
log-huts, which were not half as large as the average
one-room log-house of the American backwoodsman.
But even in this condition the Icarians favorably
impressed visitors, as the following extracts from
letters will show. An intelligent gentleman who
visited Icaria in 1869 wrote that he found in the
"log-shanties" "a degree of cultivation, courtesy,
and kindness not often so generally found among
the same number of persons." The same writer con-
tinues: "The Icarian community is a success. The
best of feeling appears to prevail among them, and
we could but feel elated that here at least was a
demonstration of successful communism. We wish
them that good success in the future to which their
self-denial and perseverance so richly entitle them." '
In 1871, another visitor wrote as follows: "The
most surprising thing there was the presence of so
many intelligent persons content to live in such a
squalid way. The kind, hospitable, and tolerant
spirit of the association was perfectly fascinating,
'Letter from Dr. Briggs, in The Communist, 1S69.
PIONEER LIFE IN IOWA. 85
and almost gilded the quasi hog-pasture in which
they live. I thought I perceived in the young people
a goodness and intelligence which will in another
dozen years revolutionize their mode of living and
doing business, and make their society a power in
the land. Indeed, I think there is more vitality and
virtue and hope for humanity at Icaria than in any
other association." 1
About this time the finances of the community
began to justify the building of better habitations,
and as these were gradually erected (arranged in the
form of a quadrangle enclosing the larger hall), the
old log-huts were one by one abandoned. As Dr.
Gaskin had predicted, the new generation began to
exert a strong influence in the direction of improve-
ments and "progress." Flowers and shade trees
began to be cultivated, and the village took on a
better appearance. Mr. William Alfred Hinds visited
Icaria in the summer of 1876, and the following ex-
tracts from a letter which he sent to the American
Socialist give a true and graphic picture of life in
the community at that time :
"A dozen small white cottages arranged on the sides
of a parallelogram ; a large central building containing a
unitary kitchen and a common dining-hall, which is also
used as an assembly room and for community amuse-
ments, including an occasional dance or theatrical presen-
1 Private letter of J. W. Gaskin, of Chicago, printed in The Com-
munist, 1871. Mr. Gaskin some years later proved the sincerity of
this opinion by joining the community.
S6 1CARIA.
tation ; a unitary bake-room and laundry near at hand ;
numerous log-cabins, also within easy reach of the central
building — forcible reminders of the early poverty and
hardships of this people ; a small dairy-house near the
thatched stable to the south ; barns for the horses and
sheep to the north : all these buildings on the bluff rising
from the valley of the Nodaway River, and surrounded
by the community domain of over two thousand acres of
fertile land, of which seven hundred have been culti-
vated, and including, with some timber land, extensive
meadows and pastures, over which range 600 sheep
and 140 head of cattle — the cultivated part having the
present season 5 acres of potatoes, 5 acres of sorghum,
100 of wheat, 250 of corn, one and a half of straw-
berries, besides vineyards, orchards, etc.: behold the
present external aspects of Icaria.
" At the sound of the bell all direct their footsteps to
the central building ; and should you enter at meal-time
you would see the entire community, now numbering
seventy-five, seated at the oblong and circular tables, as
lively and sociable as French people know how to be.
Over the entrance door you would notice in large letters
the word 'Equality,' and directly opposite the word
1 Liberty,' and at one end of the room the suggestive
1 1 776-1876.' You would notice also that upon the table
there is an abundance of substantial food, but that every
thing is plain.
"Should you enter the same building at evening you
might find most of the family assembled, some to con-
verse, some to sing their songs of equality and fraternity.
Or should you call on a Sunday afternoon, as was my
PIONEER LIFE IN IOWA. 87
good fortune, you might hear selections from the writings
of their great apostle, Etienne Cabet, or recitals by the
young, or songs, perchance, which would stir your social-
istic enthusiasm. One of these I heard had this refrain :
' Travailleurs de la grande cause,
Soyons fiers de notre destin ;
L'egoiste seul se repose,
Travaillons pour le genre humain.'
" A recital by a maiden of fifteen was very effective.
She put great expression into the words :
' Mes freres, il est temps que les haines s'oublient ;
Que sous un seul drapeau les peuples se rallient ;
Le chemin du salut va pour nous s'aplanir.
La grande liberte que l'Humanite reve,
Comme un nouveau soleil, radieuse, se leve
Sur l'horizon de l'avenir.'
" It is indeed time that hatreds were forgotten and that
all people rallied under a single flag. Shall that flag be
Communism ? The Icarians will enthusiastically answer
* yes ' ; and yet should one inquire whether all hatreds
are forgotten in Icaria itself, would the reply be also
' yes ' ?
>> 1
This last question of Mr. Hinds' was a peculiarly
significant one as we shall proceed to show.
1 This letter is quoted by Mr. Hinds in his " American Communi-
ties," pp. 67-69.
VI.
THE SONS VERSUS THE FATHERS.
VI.
THE SONS VERSUS THE FATHERS.
Outwardly Icaria was in a promising state. Its
assets were now equal to about $60,000 dollars, its
membership was increasing, some of the convenien-
ces and a few of the luxuries of life were finding
admittance ; the lads had grown up to be good
farmers; the library was freely used, and French
and American periodicals were eagerly perused by
bright minds. A generation had now passed since
the great socialistic movement which had stirred
generous souls in every country, which had given
birth to so many enterprises besides Icaria, and
which reached its climax in the eventful year of '48.
And now a new tidal wave of socialism was sweep-
ing Europe and America. It did not fail to reach
Icaria; and the community was quickened with a
new sense of its moral mission. The young people
felt a thrill of that grand enthusiasm for humanity
which in '48 had transformed peasants and artizans
into heroes and philosophers. And so, with a solid,
though moderate, material prosperity, with a hard-
earned knowledge of the practical things of life, and
yet with a high consciousness of a moral mission
91
92 ICARIA.
which lifted them above that sordidness and men-
tal sloth to which otherwise their mode of life
must have degraded them, — with these conditions
existing, what stood in the way of a proud and
brilliant future for Icaria ?
Alas, the Icarians were again to demonstrate the
exceeding difficulty of maintaining harmony in a
community based upon the principle of acquiescence
in the will of the majority. Party spirit had broken
up the great Icarian school in France ; it had di-
vided the colony at New Orleans ; it had violently
rent the society at Nauvoo ; it had precipitated the
fall of Cheltenham. For some years the elements
of a new tragedy had been silently brewing. A
writer on American communities has well observed:
" It is obvious that the process of transferring the
interests of a community from one generation to
another, which always has to be done sooner or
later, will be at least a painful one. The highest
wisdom is needed to make this transfer, and not
mar the harmony of the society." The process may
be a very gradual one, yet it necessarily involves a
more or less serious crisis. The thoughts and man-
ners and maxims of the fathers are not as those of
the sons.
In the Icarian contest, which we must now briefly
describe, neither party was wholly right nor wholly
wrong. As for motives of conduct, it must be as-
sumed that each party felt itself justified. The
THE SONS VERSUS THE FATHERS. 93
party of the old people, who were in the voting
majority, and whom we may call the Constitutional
party, were undoubtedly more nearly right accord-
ing to the tenets and written law of Icarianism ; but
perhaps they may have been too rigid and too little
conciliatory. The party of the young people, whom
we may term the Revolutionary party, were chafing
for change, expansion, progress, and to them the
party of the majority seemed retrogressive and
dead to the cause of humanity. It is not worth
while to trace in detail the growth of these parties,
nor the points at issue between them. Such
breaches tend to widen constantly. The younger
party desired changes in the business management,
and improvements in the method of agriculture.
They wished the franchise given to women, — only
males above twenty years being voters. Perhaps
they were the more anxious for the emancipation of
the sex because it would have changed the voting
majority in assembly to their side. They were for
admission of many new members and for the intro-
duction of a varied industry which would provide
work and maintenance for a much larger number
than could be supported or employed by ordinary
agriculture. The older party were unwilling to try
any rash or doubtful experiments, and their long
experience had made them cautious and circumspect
in admitting strangers.
The younger party were eager for " propaganda."
94 ICARIA.
They had been fired by the events of '71 in Paris,
and felt strongly with the new Communism of
France, the Social Democracy of Germany, and the
Nihilism of Russia. The new ideas were taking
sudden and rank growth in America. Socialistic
labor parties and socialistic newspapers were spring-
ing up in every city, and the movement was rapidly
taking shape which was soon to culminate in the
rash and unfortunate riots of 1877. ^n tne West
the Greenback party, honest and earnest in its rank
and file, though misguided by fallacious doctrines
and in some cases by false leaders, was proclaiming
a form of socialism. The business depression that
had followed the panic of 1873, and which kept
thousands of workingmen idle, contributed above
all else to the menacing form assumed by social
agitation. With these new views, and with the
anarchical spirit of the new agitation, whether in
Europe or in America, the older party of Icarians
had little sympathy. In its very essence the Icarian
doctrine was one of peace and good-will. Its mis-
sion was constructive or nothing. Its work was to
teach the world the philosophy of a better social
system, and to demonstrate the practicability of
that philosophy. It proposed a peaceful and grad-
ual evolution of existing society into the society of
the future ; and violent subversions would only
hinder progress. Such were the opinions of the
older party. ,
THE SONS VERSUS THE FATHERS, 95
I would not affirm that this difference of sym-
pathy was sufficiently defined to form a very dis-
tinct issue between the two parties in Icaria, but it
certainly contributed, consciously or unconsciously,
to widen the breach. The young party wished to
fall in line with the large movements outside, to
wage a more vigorous propaganda, to make Icaria
an asylum for communists. Distrust grew rapidly
between the parties. The old people regarded
every proposition to admit a new member as a wily
move of the minority to gain a vote in the assem-
bly. The following resume of the situation is from
the pen of a versatile young Parisian communist
who came at this stormy moment to join Icaria, and
who afterward became prominently identified with
the party of the young people. The reader should
bear in mind that this account, written several years
after the events it describes, is entirely from the
standpoint of the young party:
" Icaria was also to furnish proof that all things are
born of suffering, and that progress is but the prize of
brave effort, and of the discussion, the struggle, and dis-
tress which accompany it.
" For a long time isolation, privations, an absorbing
labor, perhaps also the effects of age, had totally effaced
in the eyes of the Icarians the moral mission of Icaria.
Very little cared they for its socialistic character, or de-
sired to yield to the consequences of its legitimate des-
tiny. The age of generous illusions was past, the desire
96 ICARIA.
for improvements extinguished ; internal progress no
longer possessed charms for them. It is not always ego-
tism which makes one a conservative ! The recollection
of an unfortunate past, while inspiring exaggerated fears
for the future, also forces people into inaction or immo-
bility.
" Meanwhile a new generation came upon the stage.
Some old Icarians, in whom the fire of the cause of
humanity still smouldered under the ashes of years,
aided by communistic visitors who were attracted to
Icaria by its ancient renown, communicated to the youth
of the community the heat of their convictions and the
light of their counsels. Nevertheless, as it is with the
earth on which seed vainly falls, some of the young
people remained insensible to this kind of magnetism.
But, in general, the sons grew rapidly in the love of
progress, and were not slow to manifest the impatience
and discontent which were produced in them by the
resistance, unconsciously systematic, opposed by their
predecessors to every innovation.
" This divergence of views soon created in the heart of
the Assembly a distinction of groups. The law of affinity
is irresistible ! The members yielded to its power, and
formed parties, one to defend the progressive movement,
the other to oppose it and favor inertia.
" The struggle was at first pacific and quite fraternal.
But soon came the bad habit of mingling personalities in
the controversy. The friction of irascible characters and
an old leaven of antipathy, brought from Nauvoo and
revived in the heat of the combat, very quickly substi-
tuted absolute incompatibility for the comparative homo-
geneity which had previously existed.
THE SONS VERSUS THE FATHERS 97
" Two opposing parties encamped face to face. One
was that of the young Icarians, including some aged
people ; the other that of the old Icarians, including
some young people. There were the Progressives and
the Non-Progressives.
" As with all parties, those of Icaria sought recruits —
with this difference, however, between them, that while
the old party endeavored to increase their numbers from
within, the young party, faithful to the principle of ad-
mission, especially sought to increase their strength by
new members. Nevertheless, by the law of admission,
the first party possessed the ' open sesame ! ' of the doors
of Icaria, and it was only with all the fears, all the
anxieties of conservatism that they consented to pro-
nounce the magic words.
" The necessity of gaining the ascendancy became for
each party more and more urgent. Menaces of ostracism
had been lanced by the majority of the old party against
the minority of the young people, and the latter, while
conscious of the advantage it would probably gain by the
admission of new members, was anxious, in its turn,
about the future attitude of the candidates. It was
necessary that these should offer to both parties the
hope of a future support in order to overcome all resist-
ance to their admission.
" The logic of parties is to continually widen the gulf
which separates them. Sentiment may deny this ; reason
does not. Compromises may intervene ; they will never
unite the incompatible. The skepticism which new ideas
profess toward old ways and old notions is at first an
obstacle to this.
98 ICARIA.
" Subject to this rule, the Icarians were so separated
at this point that each party foresaw the imminent rup-
ture of the material bond which still held the two groups
together.
" This was in the spring of 1876.
"On the 17th of April of the same year, the minority
read in the Assembly a document in which it protested
against the retrogressive acts of the majority, reproached
them for the lack of regard for the rights and opinions
of women, their hostility to propagandism, their perse-
cution of the progressives, etc. It affirmed its devotion
to the cause, and its purpose to pursue its ideal at all
cost, and to this end signified its wish to be separated
from the majority, amicably if possible, by legal means if
necessary. The majority refused to consider such an
unusual demand.
" Meanwhile, four Internationalists had made applica-
tion for admission to Icaria. Animated by the fears we
have mentioned, each party considered it to be its duty to
plead its cause in advance before these prospective mem-
bers. The majority wrote to them : ' Our enemies desire
a separation, that they may then divide the property
among themselves.' The minority sent its reasons for
demanding a separation.
" Thus forewarned, the candidates left New York, in
spite of a dispatch from the majority which told them to
postpone their coming. On their arrival each party de-
scribed to them the situation in its own manner. But it
is in supreme moments that one trusts to chance.
Either from confidence in the result, or because they
were willing to risk every thing, the two parties united
THE SONS VERSUS THE FATHERS. 99
in admitting the new-comers after only fifteen days of
novitiation."
One of these new-comers was Emile Peron him-
self, the author of the paragraphs quoted above, a
young man who had come to New York after the
downfall of the Paris Commune. Another was A.
Sauva, who years before had come from France to
join the Cheltenham Icarians at St. Louis, and had
supported that unfortunate enterprise to the very
last. He had then served in the Union army, and
afterward had returned to France. He was a promi-
nent member of the great organization of the In-
ternational, and helped to make French history at
Paris in 187 1. Both were men of marked ability.
The new-comers bent their energy to a restoration
of harmony, and apparently with gratifying success.
It was during this lull that Mr. Hinds made his
visit to Icaria and wrote the letter to the American
Socialist quoted in the preceding chapter.
The annual election, which came on the 3d of
February, 1877, resulted most encouragingly. The
directors of the two departments of Industry and
Agriculture, those most susceptible of improve-
ments such as had been clamored for, were chosen
from the young party. With excellent taste the
Presidency for the year was confided to Sauva, who
had not identified himself with either faction, but
had been a peace-maker. This election seemed to
indicate a genuine spirit of concession on all sides,
100 ICARIA.
and a disposition to sink party differences for the
good of the whole which promised well for the com-
munity.
But Sauva did not find his administration a bed
of roses. It soon became evident that the leaders
of the young party were wholly disaffected, and
were only waiting for an occasion to insist again
upon separation. Although three or four more
"men of '71 " — and certainly men of "progressive"
views — were soon admitted, the young party were
not satisfied ; and the refusal of the majority to
admit a young candidate whom the minority espe-
cially favored, brought to the surface again all
the old animosity. Another point of controversy
must be mentioned ; not so much because of its in-
trinsic importance, as because it illustrates a phase
of community life.
This was no less a matter than that of " les petits
jar dins" — the little gardens. Prior to 1870, while
the families of the community still lived in the log-
huts, the privilege had been granted each family of
using a narrow strip of ground surrounding the
house for a flower-garden, or for cultivation in any
way that seemed good to the occupants of the
house, in their hours of leisure. These poor pio-
neers, with their Gallic love of flowers and of gar-
dening, found genuine satisfaction in their bits of
ground ; and here a vine, there an apple-tree, a
tobacco-plant, or a fragrant bunch of garlic, were
THE SONS VERSUS THE FATHERS. 101
added to the original flower-bed feature. Every-
where else in the community the Icarian motto,
" All for each, each for all," was the invariable rule.
If in the one matter of these tiny plots environing
their humble domiciles, the Icarians allowe67"the
idea of "meum et tuum " insidiously to enter, and
if they found a keener enjoyment in the flowers or
the grapes because of the forbidden but delicious
sense of personal ownership, we must not condemn
them too harshly, nor impeach their communism.
There was something noble and pathetic in the
manner with which these " citoyens " and " citoy-
ennes " put away the accursed thing when they
awoke to a realization of the fact that the gardens
were introducing a dangerous element of individual-
ism and inequality. This consciousness was arrived
at about the time when the first half dozen of the
new and more commodious houses were built ; and
it was arranged that whenever a family should leave
the hut for a frame-house, the wicked garden should
be given up and no new ones should be made.1
" Years rolled on," as the novelists say, and we
come again to our point of departure, the inauspi-
cious days of 1 877. Three citizens still abode in
1 It is somewhat interesting to note that this Icarian village com-
munity, in its tendency to evolve individual proprietorship, began
precisely at the same point as the primitive village communities,
which maintained common ownership and use of arable lands and
pastures and woodlands long after the homesteads and their imme-
diate environment had become individual property. Evidently the
" petits jardins " are a modern reproduction of the ancient " toft and
croft."
102 ICARIA.
their primitive log-huts, and maintained, therefore,
their " petits jardins." To the young party this
was a scandal and an abomination ; nor did the old
party really approve of the conduct of the three
selfish citizens in clinging to their truck-patches and
vines. In the fall of 1877 there was to be a sale of
grapes ; and a member of the young party proposed
that, instead of gathering the fruit in the commu-
nity's vineyard, there should be a confiscation of
the grapes in the three little gardens. The proposi-
tion was certainly in keeping with Icarian princi-
ples. But the person who made it, and his manner
of making it, were so offensive to the old party that
they voted solidly against it.
All compromises were now at an end, and the
factions were openly at war again. Sauva had by
this time identified himself with the conservative
party, and Peron had become the fluent spokesman
of the " progressives," as they termed themselves.
On the 26th of September the young party an-
nounced their fixed purpose to withdraw and found
an autonomous branch on a portion of the domain,
and a few days later they submitted a detailed plan
by which the division might be accomplished. The
land was to remain the common property of the
two branches, but was to be assigned for use and
control to the respective communes in a manner
which they set forth in the following paragraph of
their proposition :
THE SONS VERSUS THE FATHERS. 103
" That a division of land and stock be made pro
rata, each stockholder, man, woman, and child, to
be given ten acres of land ; that henceforth we
carry on our affairs, agricultural, industrial, and
financial, as two distinct branches of one com-
munity; that the land be held on both sides in
usufruct only, each branch having the privilege of
mortgaging its land to one fifth of its appraised
valuation ; that each branch admit to its ranks such
new members as it may deem proper (births being
reckoned as new admissions) ; and that the surplus
of land remaining after the division shall be made
according to the above proposition, shall be held in
common at the disposal of both sides for the use of
its new members. In case of death on either side,
if the portion held in the name of the deceased is
not taken up by a new admission within a specified
time, the opposite party shall have the right to
claim it."
The nineteen voters of the old party were em-
phatically opposed to the proposition, while, of
course, the thirteen voters of the young party were
agreed in urging it. The plan certainly was a very
awkward one, and must have led, if adopted, to
continual friction and misunderstanding between
the two communes. Having thus failed to accom-
plish a separation in lawful manner by vote of the
assembly, the " progressives " assumed a revolu-
tionary attitude. They might very easily have re-
104 ICARIA.
signed and withdrawn, as at one time and another
in the history of Icaria many hundreds had done;
but they could have taken with them only a small
portion of the property. At this juncture the
Icarian constitution showed a singular weakness,
which was taken advantage of by the revolutionary
party. This faction had now resorted to the civil
courts, and was doing every thing in its power to
harass and destroy the community ; and yet the
majority had no adequate defence, for the reason
that expulsion required a two-thirds vote, whereas
the rebellious minority cast one vote more than
three-eighths of the whole number. Though plot-
ting its destruction, the community was powerless
to expel them. The legal proceedings, which were
pending for some months, resulted in the forfeiture
by the Circuit Court of the Icarian charter, and the
appointment by Court of trustees to "wind up " the
business of the community.
Meanwhile many fruitless efforts at amicable
adjustment had been made. A new colony in some
remote region where personal frictions would be
avoided was a plan promptly rejected by the revo-
lutionists. Both parties devised plans of arbitration,
but in neither case could the preliminaries be agreed
upon.1 The old party grew so generous as to offer
1 The old people proposed that arbitrators should be selected from
among former Icarians, many of whom were scattered throughout the
West. They maintained that a dispute between Icarian factions
could best be understood and adjusted by those who had knowledge
THE SONS VERSUS THE FATHERS. 105
their disaffected young compatriots a cash bonus
of several thousand dollars if they would withdraw-
in peace and set up a community somewhere else.
But the young people had other plans.
It is, perhaps, not to be expected that, in a coun-
try where the property rights of the individual are
held more sacred by the laws than aught else,
scarcely excepting life and personal liberty, the
Courts should take into consideration the peculiar
nature of a property accumulated, and held through
an entire generation, on the principles of commu-
nism. Many an old member whose toil had helped
to build up the establishment, and whose donation
of his private possessions on joining the community
had added to the wealth of the society, had long
since died ; or perchance he had for personal reasons
withdrawn from membership, taking next to nothing
with him, but consoled by the thought that what he
had left behind would perpetually promote the
good cause of communism. The purpose and prin-
of and sympathy with Icarian principles. They thought the vital
issue should be settled on the basis of communistic and Icarian doc-
trines. On the other hand the young people proposed an arbitration
by "old settlers" of the county, i. e., by their American farmer
neighbors. Now the only point of view possible for such arbitrators
must have been that of individual rights. With them separation
would have been a foregone conclusion. Their only care would have
been to secure an equitable distribution of the property among the
members. Certainly the young party were right in regarding this
plan as the most favorable to the end they had in view, that of sepa-
ration ; while the plan proposed by the old folks was of course much
more in accord with the peculiar principles professed by both parties,
and much more likely to favor the object of the old party, that of
preserving intact the domain of the community.
106 ICARIA.
ciple of Icaria was radically different from that of
an ordinary business corporation or joint-stock com-
pany. Except as recognized in a very limited way
in cases of withdrawal, there were really no individ-
ual rights in the property of the community.
Occupiers held only in trust, as it were, in a line of
perpetual succession. Unfortunately, under the
laws of Iowa they had been obliged to organize in
the form of a joint-stock company under the desig-
nation of an " agricultural society," and each mem-
ber was nominally the holder of a share of stock.
The Court saw fit to hold the community strictly
and technically as a chartered business corporation.
The plan pursued by the minority was to secure the
abrogation of the charter by proving that the com-
munity had performed functions in excess or in vio-
lation of those granted. Of course the plaintiffs felt
themselves justified in using every influence and
every technicality to gain their end. Nevertheless,
it did seem a little surprising when they gravely
charged their elder brethren with being communists
forsooth, and with making the establishment of
communism the chief motive and purpose of their
organization, rather than the tilling of the soil and
the raising of live stock, as specified in their articles
of incorporation! When it is remembered that the
young party possessed several members fresh from
the Paris barricades of 1871, and that the complaint
against the old party all along had been its luke-
THE SONS VERSUS THE FATHERS. 107
warm zeal for communism, and when one further
considers the wholesome horror that an Iowa jury-
would be likely to experience when the word " com-
munist " was mentioned in court, — these things
taken into account, one is in condition to appreciate
the fine humor of such- an accusation. The forfeiture
of the charter seems finally to have been pronounced
by the Court on the ground that a society which was
incorporated for agricultural purposes had exceeded
its powers in constructing and operating a mill on
its estate, and in doing certain other things of a
mechanical and manufacturing character. The man-
ufacture of lumber and flour had really been a very
subordinate part of the industry of the community,
and the spirit of the charter had suffered no viola-
tion ; for Icaria, even against the will of the
accusing party, had remained an agricultural com-
munity instead of becoming a manufacturing com-
munity. But the Court doubtless believed a recon-
ciliation to be hopeless, and being convinced that
substantial justice to all parties required the disso-
lution of the society, the technical ground already
named was made to justify a forfeiture of the char-
ter. In 1856 the Cabet party at Nauvoo had tried
in vain to compass the abrogation of the Illinois
charter; and after Cabet's death, his heirs, probably
in behalf of the Cheltenham community, had fruit-
lessly attempted to secure the real estate, the titles
to which were in Cabet's name. Certainly the com-
108 ICARIA.
munity had better cause to expect protection from
the law in 1878 than in those former suits. The
decision disregarded the nature of the Icarian estate
as a perpetual foundation, with its own definite
provision for the withdrawal of discontented mem-
bers,— a foundation in which were involved the rights
of hundreds of predecessors and the rights of an
indeterminate number of prospective successors, as
well as the rights of those immediately on the
ground and which alone were regarded. Possibly
the current feeling against communism, vague but
strong, made the Court the more willing to reduce
Icaria to its constituent atoms.
On the 17th of August, 1878, the Circuit Court
declared the charter forfeited, and appointed three
trustees, who were charged with the task of an
equitable distribution of the property. By mutual
agreement between the factions, these trustees were
superseded by a board of arbitrators chosen among
the American neighbors ; and during the months of
January and February, 1879, this board held ses-
sions attended by the delegates from the two par-
ties. In their apportionment the arbitrators took
account of the amount individuals had originally
deposited with the community, and the period of
their service as members. Somewhat more than
half of the property fell to the party of the old
people. Meanwhile, it was understood that each
wing would reorganize as a separate community,
THE SONS VERSUS THE FATHERS. 109
and it was arranged that the domain should be
divided into eastern and western portions, the old
party remaining in the original village, and the
young people building a new hamlet a mile to the
eastward, where they had asked leave to colonize
themselves two years before.
VII.
REORGANIZATION— " THE NEW ICARIAN
COMMUNITY."
VII.
REORGANIZATION — " THE NEW ICARIAN COMMUNITY."
It was expected that the old party would retain
the old name and keep the old domicile ; but it hap-
pened otherwise. The young people were some-
what more prompt in their reorganization, and on
the 16th of April they were the possessors of a new
charter under the ancient title of " The Icarian Com-
munity." The conservative ex-majority took the
name of " The New Icarian Community" ; and upon
receipt of a bonus of fifteen hundred dollars from
their successful adversaries, they consented to be-
come the emigrants, and accepted the eastern por-
tion of the domain for their new home. There,
with a patience and courage which enemies could
but respect, they took up the broken threads of com-
munity life, and quietly restored the order of their
social economy.
For President they chose Marchand, who had suf-
fered with the first advance guard in Texas in 1848,
and had ever since been a leading Icarian. They built
a new dining and assembly hall similar to the one in
the old village, and grouped about it eight of the
frame cottages which had been assigned to them in
113
114
ICARIA.
the division of goods, and which they removed
bodily from the other hamlet.
The subjoined diagram will show the plan of
New Icaria :
■BH
(Trees and Park.)
(Hall.)
mm
f
Hi
mi
The group of houses stands upon a level plateau
many acres in extent, and commanding a view un-
usually varied and charming for a prairie State.
From the plateau the land slopes gradually to the
meadows flanking the Nodaway, a mile to the north-
ward. The stream is fringed with trees, and its
winding course across the prairie is revealed for
many miles by the waving timber line, now a mere
fringe of underbrush, and now widening into a con-
siderable grove. On the bank directly north of the
hamlet is to be seen the mill, which in the partition
fell to the portion of the old party. Half-way
between the village and the mill passes the railroad.
East and south of the village recede long stretches
of rolling prairie, broken now into farms. To the
west, among the trees, lies the old village ; and
still further west, on the horizon, are the more
ambitious uplands beyond the Nodaway, on the
slopes of which a glimpse may be had of the town
of Corning. Here, in the summer of 1879, some
REORGANIZA TIOJV. 1 1 5
thirty Icarians resumed the seemingly discouraging
experiment of communistic life.
In the spring and again in the fall of 1883 it was
my privilege to spend several days among them
there. Their numbers had remained almost station-
ary, and amounted now to thirty-four, including ■
twelve men, ten women, and twelve children all
under thirteen years of age. In spite of its hardships,
Icarian life has proved remarkably conducive to
health and longevity ; and eight of the thirty-four
people were past the age of sixty. While in one
sense the whole community constituted one family,
there was not wanting something of a private home-
life in each of the humble cottages, in which one was
sure to find books and papers, with perhaps a bird-
cage hanging in the window, or a quaint picture or
two on the plain walls. With no carpets, the scantiest
furniture, and a sad lack of the small household ac-
cessories, these neat and tidy Frenchwomen had man-
aged to give an air of decency and even of comfort
to their little homes. Quite regardless of the old
scruple against the " petits jardins," a number of
bright flower-beds environed the houses. The park
upon which the cottages fronted had been laid out
with some care and taste, and promised to be a
charming place when the trees were grown. Young
vineyards and orchards were flourishing. A large
kitchen-garden supplied abundance of all ordinary
greens and vegetables, together with a great variety
1 1 6 ICARIA.
of extraordinary kinds known only to Frenchmen.
The fare in the common dining-hall was wholesome,
though not served in an elaborate manner. The
visitor could not fail to be impressed by the intelli-
gence of every one, the pleasant and polite manners
of the women, and the bright and pretty appearance
of the children.
In dress the Icarians are necessarily very plain,
though entirely free from the affectation of peculi-
arities. At Nauvoo, when the colony numbered
some hundreds, there was more reason for adopting
uniformity of garb than in the small community of
to-day where there is no temptation to extrava-
gance or to rivalry in dress. A dark blue calico is
the fabric most commonly worn by the women on
week-days. The men wear the plain, substantial
clothes of western farmers. Most of the members
can converse in English, but French is used exclu-
sively in the community, and it is spoken with great
accuracy and purity. The government is, of course,
purely democratic. The functionaries are a Presi-
dent, a Secretary and Treasurer, and three Direc-
tors, all of whom are chosen annually, on the third
of February, the anniversary of the first departure
from Havre. The President represents the society
in its external affairs, and the Directors have charge
respectively of agriculture, industry, clothing and
lodging. The Director of Industry is superintend-
ent of buildings, fences, the mill, etc. A woman is
REORGANIZA TION. 1 1 7
generally chosen Director of Clothing and Lodging.
The acts of all these officers are subject to discus-
sion and revision in the general assembly, which
holds frequent sessions ; and in more important
matters, the officers simply carry into effect the
decisions of the assembly. The women are entitled
to vote on several questions, such as the admission
of new members, amendments to the constitution,
choice of a Director of Clothing and Lodging, and
some other matters either of more than ordinary
importance or of more than usual concern to the
women themselves. On most current questions
they do not vote.
The community has its own tailor and shoemaker,
but otherwise little is attempted besides agriculture.
The land of the New Icarian Community amounts
to about eleven hundred acres, of which two hun-
dred are woodland. Since an abundance of good
coal has been found in the county, timber land has
not the relative value it once had, especially as
very few of the trees are suitable for sawing into
lumber. Fuel and fencing material comprise the
total product of the timber land. The sawmill has
ceased therefore to yield much income, and stands
idle most of the time. The same is also true of the
flouring mill which is under the same roof. The
agriculture is of the usual western character, corn
and hay being the principal crops, and cattle and
hogs the chief marketable products.
Il8 JCARIA.
The amusements of the community are not of a
very gay and hilarious character, and are not so
prominent a feature of the social life as they would
be, were the young members more numerous. (Al-
though we have generally referred to this branch
as the " old party," it was not exclusively composed
of old people ; on the other hand the party of the
young people contained several aged persons.) The
younger members have some musical taste, and
there is a cabinet organ in the hall. The library,
now containing about a thousand volumes — an
equal number having been kept at the other village,
— consists chiefly of standard French works of
literature, philosophy, history, science, and miscel-
lany, most of them saved from the wreck of the
Nauvoo library. A number of French and Ameri-
can periodicals are taken, and their perusal is the
favorite recreation. Sunday is kept as a holiday,
and sometimes the little community gathers in the
assembly hall for music, select reading, a dance, or
an amateur play; while on other Sundays a quiet
picnic is enjoyed under the trees on the Nodaway.
The standard of morality is high, and the ethical
sense of the community, trained by their unselfish
mode of life, is superior; but, though permitting
any form of belief among their members, they are
not religious. Being materialists and positivists,
philosophically, they exalt their communistic doc-
trines into a so-called religion of humanity. Cabet's
REORGANIZA TION. 1 1 9
views of the life and character of Jesus Christ, as
presented in his " Vrai Christianisme," are those
held by the Icarians to-day.
Their relations with the outside world show ad-
mirable discretion and good sense. If a marriage
is to take place, the nearest justice of the peace is
resorted to, and the knot is tied in a simple and legal
manner. The school-house, which stands midway
between the two villages and is patronized by both,
belongs in the regular district school system of the
county, and school-director and teacher are chosen
in the usual manner. As there are only two or
three families besides Icarians resident in the school-
district, an Icarian is always elected director, and
the teacher is appointed with particular reference to
the character of the school. For several years an
intelligent French lady, well educated in Cincinnati,
and formerly an Icarian, has presided in the school-
room. Until quite recently Icaria maintained its
own schools, wherein Icarian doctrines, manners,
and morals received much attention ; but the de-
pleted membership of the communities has of late
years made the present arrangement expedient.
From the first the Icarians have been good
American citizens, taking a quiet but intelligent
part in public affairs, and showing high respect for
our institutions and forms of government. Cabet
and all his comrades took out naturalization
papers in 1848, and showed ardent sympathy with
120 ICARIA.
abolitionist and free-soil doctrines. They voted the
Fremont presidential ticket in 1856, and Marchand
is rather proud of having voted for every Republi-
can President. All his fellow-members in the New
Icarian Community remain Republicans. The other
community has for several years thrown its political
influence with the "Greenback" party on the
ground that it represents dissatisfaction with the
present state of society. If the colony had remained
in Texas, its thorough-going ideas of liberty must
have involved it in trouble with its neighbors,1 and
the war would have endangered its existence. A
number of its members saw military service in the
Union Army. They wisely keep aloof from the
strife of politics, and enter its domain only as simple
voters. An Icarian occasionally fills a township
administrative office, but never is a candidate for
any position the duties of which would interfere
with his community life and work.
As money-getters, the people of New Icaria are
only moderately successful. However, by frugal
living and faithful labor, they are reducing and will
1 Mr. Marchand informs me that the pioneer party in Texas in
1848, were everywhere asked if they were Democrats. Their igno-
rance of the English language was only surpassed by their profound
ignorance of American party distinctions. Of course they replied un-
hesitatingly that they were " democrats," as they certainly had been
in France ; and for some reason not then understood by them they
found that this profession of political faith made the Louisianians
and Texans uncommonly kind. Mr. Marchand thinks the Demo-
cratic party wins the adherence of a great many foreigners simply on
account of the prepossession they bring in favor of the word
"democrat."
REORGANIZA TION. 1 2 1
soon extinguish the debt in which their expensive
quarrel and their re-establishment involved them.
On the ist of January, 1883, the property of New
Icaria was worth at a very low estimate $25,000;
and their indebtedness approached $4,000. Their
land is steadily appreciating in value, and one or
two good crops will pay the debt and leave them in
a financial condition which will amply justify the
admission of new members and will permit the in-
troduction of many comforts and luxuries now pain-
fully lacking. Of their business policy and manner
of labor, one who knew the Icarians before the sep-
aration, made the following remarks, which are
quite applicable to New Icaria to-day : " Having
learned from bitter experience that debt is the bane
of societies, as well as of individuals, the Icarians
have adopted it as a fixed principle, to contract no
liabilities, and to avoid all speculative and hazard-
ous enterprises. They are content with small
gains, and in an old-fashioned way study rather to
moderate their outlays than to increase their profits.
Naturally, as they own in common, they are not in
haste to be rich. With them the acquisition of
wealth is not a leading object of life. They have
greater regard to independence, and give more
thought to personal ease. They labor industriously,
but not exhaustingly, and in such ways as to make
their toil as comfortable and pleasant as possible." '
1 S. W. Moorhead in The Western Magazine, Omaha, July, 1877.
122 ICARIA.
To keep the world apprised of its doings the com-
munity issues a small monthly paper the Revue
Icarienne, which is printed on a curious and anti-
quated little press — originally a lithograph press —
brought from France by the early colonists. An
edition of about three hundred copies is printed.
These circulate among French people of Icarian
antecedents in the United States, and in France
among the friends of the colonists.
Such, in brief, is an outline of the modus vivendi
prevailing in New Icaria, as it has come under my
observation. It is a plain, monotonous life ; yet I
cannot hesitate to affirm that it seems in some re-
spects a more rational and intelligent life than that
which is to be found in the average American
farmhouse of the West. Certainly a more serene
life one will not often discover any where, in this
age of turmoil, haste, and discontent.
In their reorganization both parties undertook to
provide against the recurrence of deadlocks and
constitutional crises, but resorted to different expe-
dients. The New Icarian Community (the old
people), instead of filing articles of incorporation
under the State law, decided to organize in the
form of a general partnership. They drew up a
comprehensive Contract of Partnership which they
all duly signed and which was placed on record in
the office of the County Recorder. This organization
was found to give the community all the practical
REORGANIZA TION. 1 2 3
advantages of an incorporated body, while avoiding
some of the dangers and disadvantages. The con-
tract is itself so satisfactory a statement of Icarian
principles and of their ordinary modes of govern-
ment, as well also as of their constitutional pro-
visions for the protection of the society in case of
future dissensions, that I have made a translation of
it and added it as an appendix.1
So far as the form of organization can protect a
society and provide safeguards against its dissolu-
tion, New Icaria seems to be well fortified by the
main provisions of this contract. Each member
agrees to relinquish all individual claims and to re-
frain from any attempt at any time to recover a
portion of the property. Permission is given to a
majority to expel a minority when in an overt
state of rebellion or insubordination. Under arti-
cles of incorporation the society might at any time
be dissolved for some technical violation of its
charter on the information of an outsider ; but under
this contract of partnership no outside interference
is possible. But safeguards like these, while they
may assure the existence of New Icaria for a long
time to come, cannot give it life and success. The
evils of stagnation are now more to be feared in New
Icaria than those of dissension. If the jealousy of
personal leadership could be laid aside, and if some
strong man gifted with executive ability and full of
1 See Appendix I.
124 ICARIA.
enthusiasm could be entrusted with the direction of
affairs, an auspicious future might yet await the so-
ciety. As it is, predictions would be worthless and
superfluous.
VIII.
"LA JEUNE ICARIE.1
VIII.
"LA JEUNE ICAR1E."
The new Articles of Incorporation under which
the young party reorganized on the 16th of April,
1879, took care to provide against the fate of the
old charter by stating the nature and purpose of the
organization in terms so inclusive as to render it
practically impossible for the community to exceed
its lawful powers. Article II. reads as follows:
'* This corporation, having for its object the mutual
support of each other, and the creating of a fund
with which to provide for the comfort of the young,
the old, the sick, and decrepit, and the carrying out
of the principles set forth in the preamble hereof
[welfare and happiness of humanity and demonstra-
tion of the feasibility of community life] ; for that
purpose the general nature of business to be trans-
acted shall be all kinds of agriculture, horticulture,
stock-raising, mechanical arts of every kind and
nature, milling, manufacturing in all its depart-
ments, and the establishment and building of
towns, villages, colonies, schools, and colleges, also
the development of the fine arts and also all kinds
of commerce." The articles provide that upon
127
128 ICARIA.
withdrawal members shall receive the amount of
property actually paid in by them, less a proportion
of the indebtedness of the society, and shall further
receive such sums for years of service as the by-laws
of the corporation may specify. To show, however,
that this liberal provision for a return to the selfish
life of the world was not for their own benefit but
rather for the reassurance and comfort of new-
comers, the incorporators at once proceeded to
draw up what they entitled an " Act of Donation to
the Icarian Community," by which they relin-
quished all personal claim upon the property. The
essential paragraphs in this act of donation are as
follows :
" Know all men by these presents that we : Antoi-
nette Cubels, Therese James, Louise Bettannier, Marie
Mourot, Madeleine Vallet, Valentine Vallet, Louise
Peron, Leonie Dereure, Francoise Leroux, Adele Gau-
vain, Emilie Fugier, Maria Laforgue, Henriette Vallet,
Caroline Gauvain, Jean Haegen, Michael Brumme, An-
toine Gauvain, Emile Fugier, Alexis Marchand, Simon
Dereure, Jerome Laforgue, Paul Leroux, Emile Peron,
Eugene Mourot, Pierre James, Justin Vallet, Auguste
Gauvain, Alexandre Vallet, being members of the Icarian
Community of Adams County, Iowa, and being desirous
of promoting its interests, and of establishing a perpetual
fund for the promotion of the business and principles of
said Corporation, do hereby donate, assign, and set over,
unto the said Corporation, each for ourselves, the several
sums, property, rights, and credits as follows, to wit :
LA JEUNE ICARIE. 1 29
"All our right, title, and interest unto the several sums,
subscribed by us, on the books of said Corporation, being
the property and interest received by us as our share of
the old Corporation of Icarian Community, and which
we were found to be entitled to by a board of arbitration
that was selected to settle up between the members of
the old Icarian Community ; the same to be held by
said Corporation to them and their successors forever,
never to be divided between the individual members of
said Corporation under any circumstances whatever ; but
to be used by the Corporation for the general purposes of
its organization, and in case said Corporation shall for
any reason dissolve, and fails to keep its organization
renewed from time to time, upon such dissolution the
above amount as donated, after the payment of debts of
the Corporation, shall be accounted for and paid over to
any number of Icarians, who shall become incorporated
on the same principles and for the same purposes as are
set forth in the Articles and By-Laws of this Corpora-
tion."
In the following October Icaria adopted a new
constitution which, in the picturesque phraseology
of a member, " extends the right of suffrage to
women, abolishes the presidency, overthrows the
demi-gods and their Jacobin notions of political in-
fallibility, associates the efforts of the community
with those of outside socialistic agitation, formu-
lates the Icarian creed according to rationalism
founded on observation, and places it outside of and
against all anti-scientific revelations." This consti-
130 ICARIA.
tution, which abounds in felicitous and epigrammatic
expressions pointing to Mr. Peron as its author, is
a rather remarkable document. It has a long
preface discussing the history of society and main-
taining the philosophical and scientific basis of
socialism. The second chapter sets forth in twenty-
six articles the general principles of the community
on the subjects of Society, Equality, Liberty, Fra-
ternity, Unity, and Law. The third chapter is con-
cerned with Social Organization, and states the views
of the society as to community of property; the
education of the young ; the institution of marriage,
which is approved ; voluntary celibacy, which is dis-
approved. The fourth chapter deals with the
Political Organization. The government is as purely
democratic as possible, and the office of President
is given up. The only officers are four Trustees,
two of whom are elected semi-annually. One of
these is Secretary-Treasurer, and the others have
charge respectively of Industry, Agriculture, and
Commerce. These Trustees execute the mandates
of the general assembly. Various matters of detail
are entrusted from time to time by the general as-
sembly to special commissions appointed and em-
powered as the occasion requires. The general
assembly is itself the government. It is not to be
presided over by one of the Trustees, but by a chair-
man selected anew at each meeting. The constitu-
tion states that " it is the duty of the Community
LA JEUNE ICARIE. 131
to set apart such sums of money as it may deem
necessary to the propagation of principles which
tend to the political, philosophical, and economic
emancipation of mankind," and to this end a stand-
ing committee of propagandism is provided for.
For the information of the public and the con-
venience of applicants and inquirers, a pamphlet
was published containing this constitution and other
laws and regulations of the Icarian Community.
The " Law upon Admission " and the " Law upon
Withdrawal and Expulsion ' are particularly full
and minute, and they contain so much of frank con-
fession and sage reflection, under the head of
" preliminary considerations/' upon the difficulties
of a community life, the differences between Uto-
pian visions and existing realities, and the inevitable
embarrassments of a sudden transition from the
individualistic to the socialistic life, that it is thought
worth while to publish them as an appendix.1
Young Icaria, freed from the apron-strings of the
conservative party, set in order its household
economy with some flourish and a great deal of real
energy. During the period of discord and interreg-
num between the decision of the court and the reor-
ganization^ number of people withdrew altogether.
Of the eighty persons in the society before its disso-
lution, forty-seven belonged to the young party and
thirty-three to the old, although as has been ex-
1 See Appendix II.
132 ICARIA.
plained, the latter party had a voting majority.
Having paid their elders an indemnity to withdraw,
the young party, with a total personnel of about
thirty-five, largely women and children, found them-
selves in undisputed control of the old village. Their
enthusiasm proved contagious, and applications for
admission came by the score. Before the end of
1880 there were upward of seventy names on the
roll of membership, including those admitted pro-
visionally. Good crops blessed their labor. The
orchards and vineyards planted by the fathers were
now yielding bountifully for the sons. Advanced
methods in agriculture and stock-raising were
eagerly adopted. The industrial branch of produc-
tion was begun with a shoe-shop and a blacksmith-
shop in the neighboring town of Corning, and a
broom factory was started. All labored with a fine
energy for a reduction of the debt of seven or eight
thousand dollars with which the community
property was encumbered.
Peron made La Jeune Icarie, the organ of the
community, a bright and able paper. He found
some time for scientific experiments. In the winter
he taught the inter-communal school ; and the
electric telephone by which he connected the school-
house and his own cottage was the first one used in
the State. Among the new members were men of
intellect and experience. The communistic world
has its own channels of communication ; and the
LA JEUNE ICARIE. 1 33
new vigor and promise of Icaria became known in
the communistic world. Ten applicants knocked at
the gate where one could be admitted. The com-
munity had only eight hundred acres of land, and
so long as its industry was chiefly agricultural, mem-
bership could only be increased gradually, and
could not safely pass a certain limit. Consequently
it was the design of the society to develop a variety
of industrial enterprises as speedily as circumstances
would allow. The "Act of Donation," as an evi-
dence of sincere devotion to the cause, had been
highly approved by the communistic world, and
young Icaria was enjoying an enviable reputation.
And certainly its society was not to be despised.
It had men who had seen military service on two
continents ; men who knew languages, history,
philosophy, and modern science ; men who could
discuss current thought and were familiar with cur-
rent literature ; men who had seen experience in
other communistic societies ; old Icarians who had
come back after years of absence ; agreeable women,
and plenty of vigorous infants.
So constituted, Icaria seemed to give promise of
speedy and interesting achievements; but the
promise, unfortunately, was not to be realized, — at
least not without some adversity and delay. Under
the first flush of excitement and novelty, the com-
munity had seemed to be of one heart and one
mind ; but when the group had become fairly ac-
134 ICARIA.
customed to their surroundings and to one another,
little inharmonies and incompatibilities began to
appear. Decided differences of opinion as to the
general policy of the community were found to be
entertained. There were too many clever men, and
no one with a gift of leadership sufficient to assimi-
late and unify the group. To use a favorite Icarian
word, there was no real "solidarity." There were
no bitter party quarrels, there was no "crisis," nor
even much unfriendliness ; but the most of the
new-comers soon deemed it expedient to withdraw,
and the community was, in a year or two, reduced
to a membership of about thirty, most of whom
were of the original " young party ' who had
formed the incorporation and made the " Act of Do-
nation." Of those who departed, some went into
private life ; a family or two went to Florida with
the purpose of founding there a colony on Icarian
principles; and in the spring of 1881 a group of
families went to California to inaugurate a com-
munity enterprise which will again have mention
in these annals.
So many members having departed, it became
for the present unprofitable to give attention to its
new industrial enterprises, and the shops in Corning
were given up, the community merely providing for
its own needs in small shops on its own estate.
The cultivation of corn and the cereals on a large
scale was also given up, and the land was seeded to
LA JEUNE ICARIE. 1 35
grass for the maintenance of flocks and herds, stock-
farming having been found more profitable and less
toilsome than plowing and sowing and reaping.
But our friends were already becoming convinced
that the business of general farming and stock-
feeding in a Northern State is not the one best
adapted to the welfare of a community like theirs.
A certain amount of leisure for mental improvement
must be regarded as an indispensable condition of
success in a society based on Icarian or similar prin-
ciples. Community life must provide something
besides bread and butter, or it falls short of its main
object. The young Icarians came to have a painful
feeling that for them the arduous business of gen-
eral farming was an impediment in the way of moral
and intellectual progress, and they began to look
forward to a removal at some time to a warmer
climate, where horticulture, a business so congenial
to the Frenchman, might take the place of heavy
farming, which seldom suits the Gallic tempera-
ment.
Florida was talked of, and those who had gone
thither sent glowing accounts of orange and lemon
groves and cheap lands. A committee which was
sent out to " prospect " for a location visited Ken-
tucky, Tennessee, Louisiana, and the neighborhood
of the original Icarian station in Texas, now a flour-
ishing region. The group of families who went to
California had purchased a tract of fruit-land in
136 ICAR1A.
Sonoma County, eighteen miles from San Francisco,
and were sending enthusiastic reports from the Oc-
cident, and were inviting their former associates in
Iowa to join them. At length it came to be gen-
erally understood that the community would leave
Iowa whenever a favorable opportunity to sell the
property should be found, and would resort to the
pleasant fruit-lands of California. Under these cir-
cumstances plans of enlargement and improvement
were for the time postponed, and attempts at propa-
ganda were held in abeyance. The future triumphs
or failures of the community were not to be in
Iowa,
IX.
IN CALIFORNIA—" ICARIA-SPERANZA."
IX.
IN CALIFORNIA. " ICARIA-SPERANZA."
At length, in the winter of 1883-4, the negotia-
tions which had been for some time pending, resulted
in the adoption of a definite basis and contract of
union between the little Icarian group at Cloverdale,
California, and the Icarian community (young
branch) in Iowa. It was agreed that as soon as
Icaria could dispose of the Iowa estate, its members
would remove in a body to California and unite for-
tunes with their friends on the " Bluxome rancho."
Of the interesting personal history of the little
group already in California something more will be
said in a subsequent chapter devoted to the por-
traiture of various Icarians. Suffice it to say here
that the leader of the colony was a Mr. Dehay, the
son-in-law of an aged exile of '48, Jules Leroux, and
that the sons of the latter, Pierre Leroux and Jules
Leroux fits, with their families, with two or three
additional families not of the Leroux connection,
made up the entire membership. These families had
left Icaria in the spring of 1 881, and had wisely spent
several months in California before deciding upon a
purchase. In September they found for sale the
139
HO ICARIA.
Bluxome ranch on the Russian river, in Sonoma
County, two or three miles from the town of Clover-
dale, and eighteen miles from San Francisco. It
contained 885 acres, and suited them precisely. The
price demanded was $15,000. Mr. Dehay was pos-
sessed of upward of $4,000, and the others were able
to contribute enough to make up the first payment of
$5 ,000. The remaining payments were considerably
deferred, and the little colony set vigorously to work
to pay the debt. At the -end of two years they had
a farm worth $30,000 and their debt was reduced to
$6,000. Though living in an associative way, they
had not yet framed a formal and legal organization,
that being deferred in anticipation of some such
event as the fusion with the young Icarian commune.
For a description of the character and capabilities
of the farm, and its charms of situation, I may quote
from an article which an editor in the neighboring
town of Cloverdale inserted in his paper in Decem-
ber, 1882.1
" Two miles and one half below town, skirting the
banks of our beautiful stream, Russian River, lies the
extensive farm owned by the French colonists. * * *
The commodious dwellings and barns are located on the
Healdsburg road, where they were erected several years
ago, and present a rare picture of rural comfort. Sweep-
ing around over low, rolling hills and smiling valleys, is
seen the body of the farm, which is destined in the near
1 The Pacific Sentinel, Cloverdale, Dec. 21, 1882.
IN CALIFORNIA. I4I
future to become one of the finest vineyards in California.
The entire tract comprises 885 acres, of which about 400
is first-class vineyard land that is being rapidly cleared
and made ready for the plow. Nine white men and six
Chinamen are at work grubbing out trees and brush, pre-
paring the land for cultivation, and acre after acre is rap-
idly being added to the improved area. At present,
forty-five acres are planted in rooted vines, principally of
the Zin-fandel variety, and enough will be added in the
spring to swell the area to fifty acres. * * * Besides
the vineyard, one hundred acres of fair-grade wheat land
is under cultivation, and at this writing it is all sown and
some of the young grain is already above ground. A
thrifty orchard of five acres stretches to the west from
the Healdsburg road, and includes many choice varieties
of trees. Some of the finest peaches we have ever tasted
were produced here. * * * It is the intention of the
proprietors to increase the area of the orchard as soon as
possible, and they will engage extensively in the culture
of French and German prunes. They intend planting
nothing but the very best varieties, and hence will make
a success of the business. They also propose establish-
ing a first-class winery and distillery as soon as their pro-
duction will admit of the outlay. As soon as practicable
a French colony will be formed, duly incorporated, to
include some twenty-five families, and with this force the
large farm will soon be developed. * * * The site on
which the dwellings intended for the colonists will be built,
is located near the road in a beautiful meadow, sloping
on a gentle incline to the banks of the Russian River, and
is one of the most beautiful spots in this locality.
142 I C ARIA.
" Standing on a vine-planted mound near the road, and
gazing upon the beautiful valley, which will one day be
the centre for so much life and prosperity, we must admit
that it is naturally an earthly Eden. Geyser Peak stands
boldly forth at no great distance from the lovely vale, and
even Mt. St. Helena is plainly visible, towering toward
heaven in the distance. The low hills on every side, the
road winding along and almost parallel here with the
curving river, the picturesque woods and the smiling vine-
yards, all unite in forming a panorama transcendant in
its quiet, peaceful beauty. Exclusive of vineyard and
grain land, there yet remains about three hundred acres
of rolling hill-land, suitable for pasture, and the colonists
will utilize this by entering the cattle-raising business.
They thoroughly understand this class of ranching, and
prefer it to wool-growing."
As thus described, the topography and the capa-
bilities of the new Icarian station are most inviting.
Certainly, if the writer were seeking the realization
of a Utopia, his ideal would not be met in a com-
munity of factory operatives, nor of toiling agricul-
turists engaged in the rough labor of general farm-
ing in a Northern State; but of all places and all
occupations on earth he would choose as most con-
sonant with the theories and purposes of com-
munism— California and horticulture. In begin-
ning life anew on the Pacific slope, an Icarian com-
mune for the first time finds itself in an environ-
ment thoroughly favorable to its development.
Few persons outside of California have yet come to
IN CALIFORNIA. 1 43
realize the marvels of its orchard products and the
''terrestrial Paradises" in which its opulent horti-
culturists embower themselves. An acre there pro-
duces more fruit, and of vastly superior quality,
than ten or twenty acres elsewhere in the United
States. The soberest recital of facts concerning
the transformation, during the past decade, of wide
tracts of California wheat-lands into orchards and
gardens containing all the fruits and spices of the
tropics in addition to all the fruits of the temperate
regions, seems too extravagant for belief. Yet it is
true that lands which a few years ago, as wheat-
fields, gave employment to four men, now require
at least four hundred fruit-gatherers during the
picking season ; and the tract which, in wheat, fur-
nished a comfortable income to a single proprietor,
now enables fifty proprietors to live in comfort and
refinement as fruit-growers.
Taking, therefore, the roseate view of the future
of the " Icaria-Speranza Community," as the fusion
of the two groups is to be called, it is not hard to
imagine that in a few years they will have trans-
formed the Bluxome ranch into a veritable Paradise ;
that in place of the primitive sheds of the Texas
pioneers, the tenements of the sojourners at Nau-
voo, the log-huts or the box-like frame structures in
Iowa, the Icarians will dwell in commodious and
beautiful houses with complete appointments some-
what after the manner of those pictured by Cabet
144 ICARIA.
in the "Voyage en Icarie"; that the educational
and recreational, the scientific and literary, pursuits
so highly esteemed by the Icarians will have found
their long-deferred opportunity to flourish ; that the
climate and the nature of the work will have proved
remarkably adapted to the French temperament,
and that membership will have increased rapidly,
both from within and from without. Indeed, the
very necessity of many active hands to gather in
the fruit will compel the increase of membership as
the area of orchard and vineyard increases ; and in
work of this kind the women and children are as
useful as men. On the other hand, the enforced
leisure of six or eight months in the year will prove
advantageous to the mental and moral interests of
the community. But even while picturing this
attractive prospect, one can hardly help remember-
ing the unpleasant occurrences which were disas-
trous to the first Paradise of which we read; and
judging their future by their past, what guaranty
can we have that our French friends will love one
another and behave themselves discreetly in their
Paradise ? Alas, there is the rub !
The new name, " Icaria-Speranza," was adopted
as a compromise. The Messrs. Leroux were at-
tached to the name " Speranza" because their uncle,
the famous philosopher, Pierre Leroux, had given
that title to a Utopian romance he had published,
in which he pictured a social organization somewhat
IN CALIFORNIA. 1 45
like that advocated by Cabet. The name " Icaria-
Speranza " perpetuates, therefore, the memories
and unites the similar social systems of two distin-
guished contemporaneous writers and radical politi-
cians, Etienne Cabet and Pierre Leroux.
The new constitution of " Icaria-Speranza " is in
the form of a " Contract and Articles of Agree-
ment." Like the " New Icarian Community," they
have concluded that the form of a general partner-
ship is preferable to that of a corporation. This
new constitution contains many important innova-
tions ; and as it is the fruit of the combined reflec-
tion and experience of men who know well the
problems of community life, it is worth careful
study.1 Among the cardinal principles of the old
Icarian constitution were these three: i, the abso-
lute authority of the majority except in a few speci-
fied cases ; 2, the absolute community of property ;
3, the absolute control of the individual by the so-
ciety— i. e., the abnegation of personal liberty. The
new constitution considerably modifies these three
principles, as we shall proceed to show, after having
explained the framework of the government. The
General Assembly is composed of all full members
of both sexes, above the age of twenty-one. In
January of each year, five standing committees are
elected, having charge of the following subjects : I,
Works ; 2, Home Consumption ; 3, Education ; 4,
1 This constitution will be found in full as Appendix III.
146 ICARIA.
Commerce ; 5, Accounts. These committees in a
collective capacity constitute the Board of Adminis-
tration. The Board has vested in it the titles to
the property of the community. Ordinary matters
of administration are attended to by the individual
committees, or if more important, by the entire
Board. Regular meetings of the General Assembly
are held only twice a year ; though special meetings
may be called at any time by the Board, or by a
certain number of members concurring in a written
request. No action whatever can be taken by a com-
mittee, or by the Board of Administration, unless with
the unanimous consent of every member of such Commit-
tee or Board ; and no decision of the General Assembly
is valid unless stistaincd by a three-fourtJis vote. In
many matters,such as admissions, expulsions, etc., a
nine-tenths vote of the whole voting membership is
required. To amend or change certain of the Articles
of Agreement, a unanimous vote is requisite, for other
articles a nine-tenths vote, and for the rest a three-
fourths vote. The evident object is to have as
little government as possible, and to leave routine
administration to the committees instead of dis-
cussing every detail in frequent meetings of the as-
sembly. This will have a marked tendency to miti-
gate that bane of communities, — too much politics.
While majority tyranny will evidently be impossible,
minority conservatism may at times block the
wheels of progress. But this power of the minority
IN CALIFORNIA. 1 47
can be exercised only negatively — i. e., as a veto
power ; and the intention that changes shall not be
made without a very general concurrence of view,
would seem favorable to the stability of the society.
Party action under this system will have much less
scope than under the old majority rule. A useful
device to facilitate elections of officers is introduced.
For election on the first ballot a three-fourths ma-
jority of all the voting membership is requisite; on
second ballot a simple majority elects ; and on third
ballot the person receiving the highest number of
votes — that is, a plurality — is elected.
But the greatest innovation in this new constitu-
tion lies in the admission, to a limited extent, of the
principle of private property. Each family is to
have exclusive and absolute ownership in articles of
apparel, furniture, and in general in the equipments
and utensils of the household. This will give
greater freedom and independence to personal and
family life. Up to an annual value of fifty dollars,
individuals may receive, and keep as their own,
presents from friends outside the organization. The
book-keeping of the community is to provide in the
following way for the contingency of withdrawal :
Upon entering the community, individuals place
all their property in the common fund, and the
amount is credited upon the books. An inventory
is taken at the end of every year, and the surplus,
or net profits, is calculated. This sum is divided
I48 ICARIA.
into two equal parts, one of which goes to augment
the common indivisible fund, and the other is
divided into as many equal shares as there are
voting members, such shares being credited on the
individual accounts in the community's books.
This, however, is not so great a departure from
communism as it might at first seem ; for no one
has any right or claim to the sums placed to his
credit until he has relinquished all his membership
rights, and has actually returned to the world and
its ways ; in which case this method of book-keeping
readily determines the amount that shall be paid
him. Of course under this constitution the famous
" Icarian Donation " is still respected, and the most
of the charter members would not be entitled to
withdraw their original deposit in case they should
retire, although they would be entitled to the an-
nual sums placed to their credit, and also to a bonus
of two hundred dollars provided for, to meet their
case, in an article of the new contract.
The feature of this constitution most open to
criticism is that of the so-called " labor-premiums."
To each person above the age of sixteen who en-
gages in the common work of the community, there
is to be J paid a monthly " labor-premium " of one
dollar and a half, provided he has lost no working-
time. If he has lost not more than half a day in
the month, he will receive one dollar; and if not
more than a day, fifty cents. No excuses whatso-
IN CALIFORNIA. 1 49
ever will be accepted in lieu of lost time. The
Icarians are neither hermits nor fanatics ; and from
the nature of their surroundings they must come so
much in contact with the outside world, as to make
a little private spending-money a convenient thing.
Furthermore, in the theory of communism there
can be no serious objection to having such spending-
money, provided the distribution of it is not upon
objectionable principles. This plan of labor-premi-
ums would seem designed to reward good health
and a mere show of " putting in the time." The
man who is sick a day, or who is kept from work
by reason of sickness in his family, may have served
the community during the other days of the month
in such a way as to be ten times as valuable as another
who has lost no time ; yet the former sacrifices his pit-
tance of spending-money. " From each according to
his abilities, to each according to his needs," is the
original Icarian motto ; and this labor-premium ar-
rangement is not at all consistent with it. One
might infer that the chief practical difficulty in a
communistic society arose from the disposition of
members to shirk steady labor ; and yet as a matter
of fact that is not the case. With the possible ex-
ception of Robert Owen's motley congregation at
New Harmony, no community has ever been
troubled in that way. With all their other adverse
experiences, the Icarians have never been annoyed
by the presence of lazy members. An atmosphere
I50 ICARIA.
of industry pervades community life which is prac-
tically irresistible in its influence. There seems no
good reason whatever why the distribution of a
little pocket-money once a month should be made
upon so arbitrary and unreasonable a plan. In our
opinion the labor-premiums will be found impracti-
cable, and will in time be superseded by a simple
and even-handed method of distributing from time
to time among all faithful members such sums as
may seem desirable.
The matter of clothing illustrates the greater per-
sonal freedom permitted by the new constitution.
Instead of furnishing necessary articles of raiment
without regard to individual choice, the Board of
Administration will open accounts in the name of
each individual member with merchants in the
neighboring town ; and each may buy such clothing
as pleases him, within the limits of the sum placed
to his credit for that purpose. Parents provide for
their children on the same plan. The credit is to
be renewed twice a year, the " budget" being pre-
pared by the Committee of Home Consumption,
and subjected to the approval of the Assembly. For
other interesting features of this constitution, the
reader is referred to the document itself.1
The following extract from a letter written me by
Mr. Peron is a good general comment upon the new
instrument :
1 See appendix III.
IN CALIFORNIA. 151
11 We have abandoned the legal form of a corporation,
and have adopted that of a general partnership, living
under the clauses of a covenant containing a good many
more provisos for liberty than our former constitution
does. * * * We consider the adoption of our new
modus vivendi as a pacific revolution in Icaria. We have
all lost the greater part of our faith in the principles of
majority rule, and adhere more every day to the higher
doctrine of assent by all to any act affecting common in-
terest. Therefore we reject all the more the primitive
notions of leadership, temporal or spiritual, have no use
for Presidents, high-titled officials, etc., and rely mostly
upon everybody's sense of duty and responsibility to keep
our machine a-going morally and materially. In fine, it
is our first leap in the brilliant avenue which leads to
social anarchy — understood in its good sense — or to the
very attractive doctrine of ' Do as you please,' so cleverly
and humanely expounded by our immortal French phil-
osopher, Rabelais. Of course narrow minds, the common-
place tribe of grocers, will call it a mad leap ; but we
except, stating that we know our high business as well as
they understand theirs, which is limited to the very small
circumference of a hysteric dollaromania."
The material prospects of Icaria-Speranza are de-
cidedly good. The community begins with an
aggregate capital of about $60,000. Besides its
fruit-culture and wine business, it will engage in the
breeding of blooded live stock, and will have good
expectations of a bountiful income after a season or
two of preparation. The combined membership at
152 ICARIA.
present is fifty-two. Such is the Icarian movement
in its latest phase. There is no middle ground for
" Icaria-Speranza " ; it must be either a bright success
or a dismal failure. Which it shall be will depend,
not upon external conditions, but upon the devotion,
forbearance, harmony, and what in general we may
term the associative capacity of its members.
X.
PERSONAL SKETCHES.
X.
PERSONAL SKETCHES.
A BOOK might be filled with sketches of the re-
markable men who have at one time or another been
connected with Icaria. Thus, of the colony in its
palmy days at Nauvoo some one has written : " A
physician who had received diplomas from two Ger-
man universities, and an ex-military officer who had
won distinction in Algiers and had been decorated
with the cross of the Legion of Honor, were enrolled
in the corps of wood-choppers. A civil engineer
who had superintended the construction of a great
French railroad was put in charge of the wheezy old
engine of the flouring mill. An accomplished young
architect and builder from Normandy was retained by
the President as a private secretary, and spent most of
his time rendering Cabet's good French into bad Eng-
lish for publication in The Popular Tribune, a dingy
little five-column journal devoted to the glorification
of the ' new philosophy of life.' And so on through
the list." Another speaks of a " talented fresco-
painter who was set to digging coal, at which em-
ployment he was able to make the magnificent sum
of fifteen cents a day." But these remarks may be
155
1 56 ICARIA.
somewhat misleading as to the general personnel of
the colony. Only a few had been men of mark in
France. Saint-Simonismhad appealed to the highly
intellectual classes, and so, to a less exclusive degree,
had Fourierism ; Icarianism had gone home to the
ouvrier class, — the sturdy young tailors and shoe-
makers and mechanics of the provincial towns all
over France. But, none the less, they were a re-
markable body of men. The very nature of their
experiment had been a sifting process, had developed
their intellects, and had made them men of thought
and character.
The young architect referred to in the passage
quoted above, was scarcely more than a lad when he
joined the advance guard of Icarians who left Havre
for Texas on Feb. 3, 1848. On reaching New
Orleans and learning of the outbreak of the Revolu-
tion in Paris, this young man, A. Picquenard by
name, was in favor of returning to France ; and
abandoned the pioneer party. But with a young
man's curiosity he determined to see Indians before
returning home, and spent a year or two among the
tribes in the Indian Territory. Meanwhile Icaria
had become located at Nauvoo, and Picquenard there
rejoined the society. His first large achievement as
an American architect was to have been made in the
completion of the great Mormon temple and its
transformation into Icarian assembly-halls and
school-rooms. Picquenard was absent on business
PERSONAL SKETCHES. I $7
connected with this building project when a great
storm demolished the temple walls. He never re-
turned, but took up his abode at St. Louis, wherein
later years he made a reputation as an architect
second to none in the country. The two finest
buildings in the West, the new State-houses of
Illinois and Iowa, will for centuries be monuments
to his genius. He died in 1876.1
There are several surviving members of the first
band of Texas pioneers. One was too sick to
follow his comrades away from Texas, and he re-
mains to-day a flourishing citizen of Dallas. A few
others are scattered through the west, at Nauvoo, at
St. Louis, or in different Iowa towns. But while
nearly all the old Icarians keep their faith in the
principles of their youth and retain sympathy with
the struggling little community, only one of the
first advance guard remains an active Icarian.
Alexis A. Marchand has been a prominent man from
the first. He was the Secretary and Treasurer of
the Texas party, a young man of such courage and
devotion as only the spirit of '48 could have pro-
duced. He had been a student at Paris and a clerk
in an attorney's office, and was regarded as having
more literary ability than the young mechanics who
surrounded him. At Nauvoo he was made useful
in the work of education and especially in the busy
1 More than one young and rising architect owes his success to asso-
ciation with Picquenard, among the number being Mr. M, E. Bell, the
Supervising Architect of the United States Treasury Department.
158 ICARIA.
printing-office. He was one of the leaders of the
party which withstood Cabet, and he edited some
very strong numbers of the Revue Icarienne, in justi-
fication of the action of the Nauvoo majority, for
circulation in France after Cabet's withdrawal and
death. In 1857 ^e was made president of the com-
munity, and was also the first president after the
reorganization in Iowa two or three years later.
Since that time he has repeatedly filled the presi-
dential chair. He is now a man of benign and ven-
erable aspect, but in full vigor of body and mind.
No one can know him without being impressed with
the purity, dignity, and unselfishness of his char-
acter. Serene and kindly in manner, lofty in his
standards of right and duty, almost a mystic in his
devotion to communism and the welfare of mankind,
Marchand is a true type of the altruist. To have
produced a few such characters as Marchand is itself
enough to redeem Icarianism from the charge of
utter failure. He was a prominent member of the
party of the old people in the unhappy division of
1877, which not only cleft the community in twain,
but also divided families, — his son, Alexis Marchand,
going with the young party.
On a farm of five or six hundred acres adjoining
the land of the New Icarian Community lives a
a man who has made himself a part of Icarian his-
tory,— Jean Baptiste Gerard. In France he was a
young cabinet-maker, of bright mind and remarka-
PERSONAL SKETCHES, 159
bly strong characteristics. Though only twenty-five
years old, he was the leader of the third advance
guard, which left France in the fall of 1848 and met
the retreating Texas pioneers at New Orleans. He
became at Nauvoo a member of Cabet's administra-
tion, filling the office of Director-General of Finan-
ces. In the quarrel with Cabet he became the most
prominent figure, and was made Cabet's successor
in the presidential office in 1856. In 1857 ^e
found it necessary to resign and retire temporarily
from the society in order to act as assignee for the
community. This duty occupied him a number of
years, and to his honorable discharge of the trust
were due the payment of the creditors on the one
hand and the preservation of the society on the
other. Many a long and weary journey on horse-
back or on foot did he make over the several hun-
dred miles of almost uninhabited prairies between
Nauvoo and western Iowa, in the prosecution of his
unpaid task. In 1863 he had fully completed the
duties of the trust and was about to re-enter the
society (his withdrawal of course had only been
technical); the community was not very rich nor
prosperous, but it was on a safe footing and had
fair prospects ; Gerard had no other home, and his
family had always remained in the community;
what it retained of fortune he had a right to feel
was due to him more than to any other man. But
there was a prominent member with whom he was
l6o I C ARIA.
not in accord, and he feared that his return might
endanger the harmony of the society. He was forty
years of age, and had given the community fifteen
years of talented and self-sacrificing service. With
the pittance of twenty dollars apiece which the
Icarian constitution at that time allowed to with-
drawing members, he took his family and departed
to find a new home. It is not apprehension of their
own failure in the competitive struggle which im-
pels such men as Gerard to seek community life.
As we have said, he owns to-day a magnificent farm
of several hundred acres; and he is surrounded by
a phalanx of sturdy, manly sons who do him honor.
Gerard has never lost his faith in communism, nor
has his success made him a mere sordid money-get-
ter. He has always remained a friend and adviser
of the neighboring community, and has kept abreast
of the social movements and thought of the day.
In the Icarian quarrel of 1877 he espoused the cause
of the old party, and published in their defence a
tract entitled " Quelques Veritas sur la derniere
Crise Icarienne." The Icarian split had attracted
wide attention among French socialists both in this
country and in Europe. Communistic bodies in
New York, Chicago, St. Louis, Keokuk, and else-
where, had endeavored to prevent the separation,
and various French papers had published accounts
favoring one party or the other. Under these cir-
cumstances Gerard constituted himself the cham-
PERSONAL SKETCHES. l6l
pion of the old party, and in 1880 and 1881 pub-
lished several numbers of a paper which he called
LObservateur. This engaged in lively controversy
with La Jeune Icarie, the organ of the young branch,
and also contained valuable reminiscences of early
Icarian days. In this plain and simple-hearted old
French farmer on the Iowa prairies is the stuff from
which statesmen and generals are made. Force,
patience, sagacity, and a certain largeness of mind
and character mark him as one of nature's noble-
men.
The leader of the second advance guard was
P. J. Favard, whose letter from Texas to Cabet has
been quoted in a former chapter. In the Nauvoo
controversy Favard sided against Cabet, although
his brother-in-law. He soon after withdrew from
the society, and is to-day a merchant in Keokuk,
Iowa. Of the Cheltenham leaders, the young
lawyer Mercadier whom Cabet designed to be his
successor, and who was president at Cheltenham
for the first year, is now a gentleman of wealth and
influence in St. Louis. Charles Raynaud, who was
equally prominent in the Cheltenham movement, is,
with other ex-Icarians, resident in New York Citv.
There are some vigorous specimens of manhood
among the second generation, who have spent their
lives in Icaria; — for it must be remembered that
Icaria is more than a third of a century old. Eugene
F. Bettannier preferred to remain with the old
1 62 ICARIA.
party. He is a man whose good sense and shrewd
intelligence would be recognized in any sphere of
life. His father, long since dead, was a leading man
at Nauvoo. Eugene Mourot and Emile Fugier
were, from the first, chief agitators in the young
people's movement. Mourot was born in Paris, the
son of E. Mourot, a revolutionist of '48, who was a
victim of the bloody contest of the " bourgeois re-
action " of June. His young children were sent to
America and brought up as Icarians. Fugier is a
native of Lyons, that cradle of revolution, and in
early childhood accompanied his father to Nauvoo*
Both Fugier and Mourot are men of energy and
practical ability, and Icaria-Speranza will doubtless
owe much to them.
Antoine von Gauvain, who died at Corning,
Iowa, in January, 1883, was an Icarian of blessed
memory. Born in Berlin of a French Huguenot
family, the son of an army ofricer, he became an
army ofricer himself. At twenty-five he came to
America, edited a French paper in New York for a
time, was a teacher in several different States, and
at length joined Icaria at Nauvoo. He served three
years in the Union army and then reentered the
community. He sided with the young party in the
division ; but two years before his death he with-
drew and made his home in Corning. Gauvain was
one of the most scholarly men ever in the com-
munity. He was acquainted with languages, litera-
PERSONAL SKETCHES. 1 63
ture, philosophy, and history. His was a spirit so
gentle and so guileless, though so brave and soldierly,
that every one loved him. He was of noble blood
and of still nobler nature.
The admission of six Internationalists to member-
ship in Icaria in 1876 has been mentioned. Their
careers and characters are of sufficient interest to
have more particular attention. The six were : A.
Sauva, Emile Peron, J. Laforgue, A. Tanguy, S.
Dereure, and Charles Levy. Arsen Sauva is by
trade a tailor. Of his early history I have learned
nothing. In about i860 he came from France to
join the Cheltenham Icarians at St. Louis. He re-
mained in that community until its dissolution, and
then entered the Union army serving until the end
of the war. He returned to France and fought
through the Franco-Prussian war. He played an
active and prominent part in the commune rising of
1871, being an officer and acquainted with all the
leaders. After the collapse of the commune gov-
ernment he took refuge in this country. He was a
member of the notable Congress of the International
Society at the Hague in 1872, and aided in the ex-
pulsion of Bakounine and the Anarchist faction.
Returning to this country and working at his trade
in Chicago, St. Louis, and New York, he joined the
Iowa Icarians in 1876, where he was soon elected to
the presidency, and threw his influence with the
Conservative party. Sauva is not a man of many
164 ICAR1A.
words, but he has seen the world, and does his own
thinking. Two pamphlets in my possession, "La
Crise Icarienne " and "Icarie," prove that he is
master of a brilliant and cogent French style, while
the books in his humble home show him to be a
student of the French social philosophers. The sin-
cerity and thorough integrity of Sauva's character
are manifest to all who know him. Since the bitter
quarrel in which he and Peron were so active upon
opposite sides, the two men have not been on terms
of friendship. Yet even Peron bears the following
high testimony as to Sauva's character : *
" I have so bitterly fought Sauva's course of action
during Icarian troubles that one might expect me to write
about him with a pen dipped in gall and aloes. Well, it
would not be right ; for Sauva with all his shortcomings
is certainly a high type of man. His errors, blunders, and
mistakes, his straying judgment and reason on men and
events, do not impair his faith and commendable devo-
tion to principles that we claimed to be wrong but that
he believed to be right. * * * If all social work-
ers had his perseverance, endurance, devotedness, and
moral courage, the world would soon adopt better modes
of social relations. Sauva is a fine example of the faculty
of altruism as discovered by A. Comte, for he can suffer,
work, and live for others. Is not that very much in a
man, especially in a country where the dollaromaniacal
disease is so prevailing ? "
Emile Peron himself is a younger man, and has
1 I take the liberty to quote from a private letter.
PERSONAL SKETCHES. l6$
not so long a history. He too was engaged in the
Paris Commune of 1871, and came to New York im-
mediately after. He was a machinist by trade, but
a philosopher, critic, and scholar, by natural in-
stinct. In the workingmen's clubs of Paris, at night
lectures, and in one way or another, he managed to
find food for his voracious intelligence, and when he
arrived at New York, though only a young prole-
tarian of twenty-three or thereabouts, his scientific
baggage was very considerable. It is not often,
even among those trained from early boyhood in
the best schools, that one finds a young man who
is so conversant with philosophy, history, belles-
lettres, political and social economy, and the natural
sciences, as this Parisian mechanic. Quotations al-
ready given show that he has learned to write a very
picturesque English. In philosophy he is an un-
qualified Positivist. If he does not fully sympathize
with Anarchists and Nihilists, he can at least make
a very apologetic statement of their doctrines.
His keen critical faculty makes his conversation
sparkling and epigrammatic. It is to be hoped that
Icaria-Speranza may afford Peron time for system-
atic study and for literary work;
La Forgue and Levy follow their trades in Iowa
towns, and seem to have lost somewhat of their
pristine fervor for social reform, according to the
report of their former brethren in Icaria. This is
not the case with Tanguy and Dereure, both of
1 66 ICARIA.
whom have returned to Paris. Tanguy is an ac-
complished fresco-painter. He was an active Com-
munist in 1871, and was obliged to flee for his life,
first to England and then to America. After the
amnesty he left Icaria and resumed his old calling,
among the palaces and salons of the gay French
capital. But he plays his part in the work of social
agitation, and is known among the " militantes."
As for Simon Dereure, he is no ordinary man. He
was a member of the Commune Government of Paris
in 1871, and also with Sauva a member of the Inter-
national Congress at the Hague in 1872. Dereure
is a shoemaker of superior skill ; and while he shoes
the Paris plutocracy for a living, his real calling is
that of a social agitator. He is a man of force,
energy, and convictions, — one of the sort whom
revolutions bring to the front.
As has been said, the Leroux family constitute
the nucleus of the California colony. The name
Leroux is entitled to occupy a prominent place in
the history of modern French socialism. The two
brothers, Pierre and Jules Leroux, were among the
group of brilliant disciples of Saint-Simon. Pierre,
the elder of the two, had already made his reputa-
tion as a distinguished Parisian journalist, and in
1829 his paper, the Globe, was transformed into an
organ of Saint-Simonism.1 After the breaking up
of Saint-Simonism into rival sects, Pierre Leroux
1 For the part played by Pierre Leroux in the St.-Simonian move-
ment, See Booth's "St.-Simon and St.-Simonism."
PERSONAL SKETCHES. 1 67
withdrew and became a socialistic philosopher on
his own account. He founded the so-called Hu-
manitarian School, the doctrines of which were of a
rather mystical and transcendental character. He
wrote many books, which at the time made a
marked impression on the intellectual people of
France. For years he was intimately associated
with George Sand, and exerted upon her philo-
sophical opinions an influence as strong as was that
which afterward Mr. Lewes exercised upon those of
George Eliot. Like most other dreamy philoso-
phers, Pierre Leroux also indulged in the construc-
tion of an ideal society, which he named " Speranza."
Jules Leroux, born in 1805, was seven years younger
than his brother, and though also a man of ideas
and of literary talents, he was not so prominent as
Pierre, with whom he was intimately associated, and
whose views in general he shared. Both brothers
became Representatives in the Legislative Assembly
after the Revolution of 1848, and both were exiled,
victims of Louis Napoleon's coup d'etat of December
2, 185 1. They found homes in the island of Jersey,
where for many years they maintained their families
by agriculture. It was not a small mitigation of
their hardships that in their exile they enjoyed the
company of Victor Hugo. In 1869 Pierre Leroux
returned to Paris, where he died in 1871. Jules
Leroux resolved to make a home in America ; and
in 1867, with his family of now full-grown children,
1 68 ICARIA.
he settled on government land in Kansas, where he
and his sons acquired homestead claims. Here, in
1872, they were joined by Adam Dehay, who after-
ward married the youngest daughter of Jules Leroux.
Dehay was a young Frenchman who had seen life
in various parts of his native country, had spent
some years in London, and had come to America in
1866. He bought the homestead of his father-in-
law, and undertook the formation of a community
thereon, but without success. In 1877 Paul Leroux,
one of the sons, went to Iowa and joined the
Icarians, whither he was followed by his father and
mother, and afterward by his brothers and by Dehay.
The old hero of '48 lived for several years in the
Icarian community, but did not become a member.
He had begun in Kansas the publication of a little
French paper expository of his views on social and
religious philosophy, and continued its publication
in Iowa, and afterward in California up to his death
in October, 1883. The last number of his paper,
" L' Etoile des Pauvres et des SourTrants," was com-
pleted a few days after his death by his son, Pierre
Leroux, and contained a touching account of the old
philosopher's life, doctrines, and personal traits.
Jules Leroux was undoubtedly a man of pure and
noble character and of a strong religious nature.
His sons revere his memory and his opinions ; and it
is their desire to honor and perpetuate the associated
labors of their uncle and their father which has led
PERSONAL SKETCHES. 1 69
them to insist upon the retention of the name
"Speranza" in the title of the community. Dehay
must be regarded as the prime mover in the Cali-
fornia enterprise. His purpose in joining Icaria
had been to found a colony in a warmer climate
after having gained some practical experience of
community life. " Icaria-Speranza " may trace its
lineage on the one side to Cabet, and on the other
through the Leroux family to Saint-Simon.
The story of Emile B£e furnishes a rather charac-
teristic Icarian biography. Bee was a tailor's son
in northern France, and became a tailor himself. At
the age of sixteen he went to Paris, where he found
the tailors very active in the secret revolutionary
society of Barbes and Blanqui, under which influen-
ces he became indoctrinated in Communism. He
identified himself with the numerous disciples of
Cabet, and subscribed of his humble means to aid
the grand Icarian colonization. He was one of
many thousands who were arrested on occasion of
the coup d' 'Mat of Dec. 2, 1851, and he soon man-
aged to leave France for the gold mines of Califor-
nia, where he spent some years. In 1862 he re-
turned to France. As a member of the 69th
Battalion of the National Guard, he was actively
engaged in the defence of Paris in 1870, and in 1 871
served the Commune. He found it expedient to
return to California the same year, and became ac-
tive in the San Francisco section of the International
17° ICARIA.
Society. A few years later he joined Dehay and
his friends in the purchase of the Cloverdale estate,
and is now a peaceful citizen of Icaria-Speranza.
Such are a few hasty pen pictures of some of the men
whose lives have been identified with Icaria. Many
more, perhaps equally interesting and adventurous,
might be given ; but these will suffice to show that
French Communists are not necessarily the tremen-
dous villains or the blood-thirsty wretches which we
Americans are generally taught to believe that they
are. Some of their doctrines may be dangerous to
the existing order of society ; probably they are.
History may render her final verdict in condemna-
tion of many of their actions ; probably she will.
But good men may mistake in their opinions and
may honestly err in their actions ; and we can never
understand the history and meaning of social move-
ments in France, or in any other country, unless we
render due credit to the sincerity, devotion, cour-
ageous self-denial, and grand enthusiasm for hu-
manity, of many of the participants in those move-
ments.
XI.
SOME KINDRED SOCIAL EXPERIMENTS.
XI.
SOME KINDRED SOCIAL EXPERIMENTS.
ONE cannot long explore the history of a social
experiment like that of Icaria until he has discov-
ered that the seeming isolation of the experiment is
more apparent than real. He encounters threads
of connection and lines of influence extending in
most unexpected directions ; and if he follows those
threads they will lead him into the labyrinths of
a world of whose very existence, probably, he had
been unaware. The past ten years have been full
of earnest inquiry and discussion, in the larger circles
of American society, touching all matters of social
reform ; but the persons engaged in those discus-
sions have been almost absolutely ignorant of the
equally earnest efforts embodied in the obscure
literatures and obscure social experiments which
this same decade has produced in out-of-the-way
nooks and crannies of nearly every State in the
Union. There is no formal organization among
these obscure experimenters and theorists ; their
ideas are infinitely varied ; they are unlike in every
thing except in their despair of the present struc-
ture of society, and also in this, that they have made
173
174 ICARIA.
themselves peculiar by their views or their prac-
tices ; and these two things supply a bond of loose
federation.
These people constitute a little world within a
world. The large world is not even aware of their
existence ; while they have the advantage of know-
ing their own world and also of knowing the great
world perfectly well. This network, interwoven
with all manner of curious, intersecting influences
and lines of intercommunication, constitutes what
we may term the Communistic World, for lack of a
better designation. Viewed in the aggregate, it
contains those persons whose convictions or whose
traditions make them the foes of modern individual-
istic, competitive society. Its unity is of a negative
rather than of a positive character. Each element
of its membership is working in its own chosen way
to compass the transformation of society.
It comes to the surface most prominently in such
manifestations as those of the International Society
and the Socialistic Labor Party ; yet, in such active
measures the Communistic World is never in agree-
ment and union, and perhaps the organizations
named might better be regarded as forming a con-
necting link, or a transitional stage, between the ob-
scure Communistic World and the substratum of the
larger society. Newspapers, travel, personal corre-
spondence, are the means of communication in this
unseen world. Yet, though their papers are num-
KINDRED SOCIAL EXPERIMENTS. 1 75
bered by the score, and are not printed on secret
presses, nor designedly kept from the perusal of the
larger society, few people have read any of them, or
even know of their existence. If this seems a little
strange at first, it is really not so strange after all.
Ordinarily people are much more interested in what
goes on in their own world than in the things which
pertain to worlds beyond their own. It does not,
therefore, necessarily brand a man as an ignoramus
if he has never heard of The Sociologist, published at
Adair Creek, in the mountains of East Tennessee ;
or of The Communist, published near Glen-Allen,
Bollinger County, Missouri ; or of the Matrimonial
Review, which issues from Farmersville, Pennsyl-
vania ; or of The Agnostic, whose home is Dallas,
Texas, or of fifty more reform sheets which now
exist or have existed within half a dozen years.
Nevertheless, to read these papers and to learn the
personal history of those who publish them, is to
enter a new and a very curious field of sociological
inquiry.
In the last sixty years there have been hundreds
of attempts at associative or communistic organiza-
tions in this country, all but a few of which failed
in their very inception. Thousands of people have
been engaged in these short-lived enterprises. What
becomes of these people ? Has their futile attempt
freed them from illusive hopes and unattainable
ideals? Have they been, as we should suppose,
I?6 ICARIA.
completely cured ? Generally not. It was the tes-
timony of the community at Brook Farm that :
" The life which we now lead, though to a superficial
observer surrounded with so many imperfections and em-
barrassments, is far superior to what we were ever able to
attain in common society. There is a freedom from the
frivolities of fashion, from arbitrary restrictions, and from
the frenzy of competition. * * * There is a greater
variety of employments, a more constant demand for the
exertion of all the faculties, and a more exquisite pleasure
in effort, from the consciousness that we are laboring,
not for personal ends, but for a holy principle ; and even
the external sacrifices which the pioneers in every enter-
prise are obliged to make, are not without a certain ro-
mantic charm, which effectually prevents us from envying
the luxuries of Egypt, though we should be blessed with
neither the manna nor the quails which once cheered a
table in the desert."
Some such feeling as that seems to be perma-
nently retained by almost all who have ever engaged
in community life. It is a notable fact that many
of these people who have enlisted in what they
deem the work of human amelioration have their
wits wonderfully quickened thereby, while the one-
sidedness of their development tends to deepen and
confirm opinions once received. The ill-fated colo-
nies of Robert Owen had passed into the history of
" extinct socialisms " a generation ago ; and yet the
writer hereof might designate one and another and
XINDRED SOCIAL EXPERIMENTS. 1 77
another of the now venerable associates of Owen,
still fresh with enthusiasm and warm with sympathy
for every proposed social reform. The last of the
Fourierist Phalansteries disappeared before the war;
but many of the men who were engaged in them
may still be found wrestling with the problems of
cooperation, or pounding away at something more
radical. Icaria once numbered its hundreds of dis-
ciples. Most of them have disappeared, seemingly
swallowed up in the mass of American society;
but if the truth could be ascertained they would,
in all probability, still be found to be communists
at heart.
One would not unnaturally suppose that the at-
tempts to form new communities would be made by
new men who had not experienced the almost
insuperable difficulties of such an enterprise. The
fact is that the new propositions almost always
come from men who have had abundance of dis-
heartening experience, but who have a limitless
stock of hope and faith. Widely different as are the
American communities in point of origin, objects,
and policy, there is still a strong sympathy among
them all. Thus I found that a leading member of
the Oneida Perfectionists was regarded as a friend
and counsellor by the Icarians, widely divergent as
were their religious views. I made the acquaintance
at Icaria of an Ohio Shaker, who is in the habit of
paying long and welcome visits to the French
178 ICARIA.
materialists of Iowa. I found the Icarian women
clad in calicoes manufactured by the prosperous
German community known as the " Amana Inspira-
tionists " ; and I found that friendly correspondence
and acts of courtesy brought Icaria into relations
with various other communistic enterprises.
One of these, with which Icaria has a peculiarly
intimate relation, is the new colony known as the
" Mutual Aid Community," located at Glen-Allen, in
Bollinger County, Missouri, a hundred miles or more
below St. Louis, on the Iron Mountain Railroad.
Its actual working existence began only in the sum-
mer of 1883, and it has as yet only twenty or thirty
members, with a small capital. Its principles and
organization are essentially Icarian, though its mem-
bers are Americans. Its founder is Mr. Alcander
Longley, who in 1867 was a member of Icaria. The
story of Mr. Longley's career is one so typical
of a certain class of American social reformers that
I shall give its outlines. Mr. Longley comes very
honestly by his advanced views. His father, who
was a Universalist minister at Cincinnati, took
a leading part in about 1843 m forming the Cler
mont (Ohio) Phalanx, which however lived only
three years. The Fourier movement was at its
height in those days and young Longley heard of
little else in his boyhood. At eighteen he proposed
to found a Phalanx himself, but without success;
at twenty-one, in the year 1853, he found himself a
KINDRED SOCIAL EXPERIMENTS. 1 79
member of the famous North American Phalanx,
which was '■' the test-experiment on which Fourier-
ism practically staked its all in this country."1
Horace Greeley was its Vice-President, Charles
Sears was its practical chief, and Albert Brisbane
was its sponsor. Longley did not remain here many
years, for in 1857 we find him undertaking to
establish a Phalanx at Moore's Hill, Indiana. In
1864 he appears at Black Lake, Michigan, as the
founder of a Cooperative Association. No failure
could suppress Longley. In 1865 he is founding
another Association at Foster's Crossing, Ohio.
The year 1867 finds him and his family converted
from the complicated system of Fourierism to a be-
lief in Communism pure and simple, and admitted
to membership in Icaria. But it did not suit
Longley's temperament to be a quiet Icarian
farmer ; he was born to be an apostle. So in 1868
he withdrew, went to St. Louis, founded his paper
The Communist (which he has published ever since),
and advertised his purpose to establish a community
on Icarian principles. So came into being the " Re-
union Community" in southwestern Missouri, in
the county of Jasper. In the spring of 1870 " Re-
union" had twenty-seven members, among them
being several remarkably intelligent men, and the
prospects of the establishment were counted good.
1 The story of the North American Phalanx is best told by
J. H. Noyes in his " History of American Socialisms," pp. 449
to 512.
l8o I C ARIA.
But suddenly the enterprise collapsed. Longley
had good old-fashioned views about marriage, while
some of his companions were inclined to the doc-
trines of free-love ; and on this rock " Reunion "
split. Mr. Longley returned to St. Louis in the
best of spirits, and The Communist began to publish
an extended prospectus of the " Friendship Com-
munity" which Mr. Longley proposed to establish
in Dallas County, Missouri, near the town of Buffalo.
In 1872 "Friendship Community" was an actuality.
Its ups and downs, hopes and possibilities, were
food for the issues of The Communist for a period of
five years. " Friendship " never attained a large
membership or a strong financial footing. It did
not win the favor of the stalwart Missourians of
Dallas County, who regarded it as something essen-
tially equivalent to Mormonism, and a disgrace to
good Missouri society. Accordingly they organized
a " Committee," and Mr. Longley was warned that
his institution must go. Means were taken to give
emphasis to the warning. So the " Friendship
Community" closed business in 1877.
Again Mr. Longley returned to St. Louis. This
was the year of strikes, riots, labor unions, and
socialistic political organizations. Mr. Longley's
paper became, temporarily, an organ of the socialis-
tic labor party. Meanwhile he published the
prospectus of a " Liberal Community," to be or-
ganized in St. Louis. This community never ex-
KINDRED SOCIAL EXRERIMENTS. l8l
isted except in prospectus. In 1879 we find The
Communist published at Cincinnati, energetically
proposing to revive the "Friendship Community,"
and meanwhile giving much attention to politics
and the state of the country. Two years pass and
The Communist in 188 1 is issued from the " Principia
Community," Polk County, Missouri, in which
community Mr. Longley has now become a social
pillar. His sojourn in " Principia " is brief ; for in
January, 1882, we find him once more domiciled at
St. Louis and advertising to the world the doctrines
and prospects of the " Mutual Aid Community,"
which he desired to found at Glen-Allen, Bollinger
County, Missouri. " Mutual Aid," though a humble
and small outfit, became a resident fact in Bollinger
County in July, 1883. To predict that it will live
long and prosper would be the very climax of reck-
lessness after the history we have just narrated ;
though it is right to say that the " Mutual Aid "
has some reasons for regarding itself as on a more
solid basis than its predecessors. As for Mr.
Longley himself, he is doubtless a gentleman of
good conscience, of complete faith in communism,
and of such buoyant spirit and fine pluck that he
never acknowledges himself beaten. His paper has
been an organ for other enterprises besides his own,
and its files are a storehouse of information con-
cerning the crude and obscure communistic enter-
prises of the West during fifteen years past. A
1 82 ICARIA.
hobby with Mr. Longley is inter-communal or
ganization. He advocates a loose union, or at least
an occasional delegate convention of all the com-
munities in the United States for the furtherance
of such views and ends as they have in common.
From such a beginning he pictures the gradual
transformation of the whole country into a congeries
of united communities.
One of the most remarkable men associated with
Mr. Longley in the " Reunion Community " was
William Frey. Though never an Icarian, he has
visited Icaria, and through association with Mr.
Longley he may be regarded as having gained some
of his afflatus from our little French centre of in-
fluence. Frey is a Russian, and was an astronomer
in the service of his government, with a brilliant
career before him. But his communistic views sub-
jected him to political persecution, and he came to
America in 1868. In the spring of 1870 he went
west, and entered Mr. Longley 's " Reunion Com-
munity " with his family. After the collapse of that
enterprise we find him, with another of its recent
members, on government land in Howard County,
Kansas, proposing to found there the " Progressive
Community." There he remained for several years,
publishing a paper called The Progressive Communist,
and endeavoring to found a colony on hygienic and
high moral principles. It had neither length of days
nor temporary success. For several years following
KINDRED SOCIAL EXPERIMENTS. 1 83
that effort, I do not know his history, though from
the recent appearance in Boston of a little book en-
titled "The Religion of Humanity," I infer that he
must have spent much time in thought and study.
With a profoundly philosophical mind, and at the
same time a deeply religious nature, Mr. Frey adopts
and expounds the religion of Positivism with the
moral earnestness of an apostle. He is at present
engaged in a most interesting work. In Douglas
County, Oregon, a company of thirty young Russians
founded the " New Odessa Community " in the fall
of 1882. They had great confidence in Mr. Frey,
and asked him to live with them and be their teacher
and guide in the theory and practice of Communism.
They have seven hundred acres of land, and their
material prospects are not bad. But Mr. Frey is not
chiefly concerned to win a material success. As he
says in a letter to the writer : " I am convinced that
a proper communal life must be a school for moral
improvement, a cooperation for mutual assistance
and support in realization of the common ideal of a
better life; that, in short, moral aims must pre-
dominate over material." Mr. Frey is fully con-
vinced that no bond except religion can permanently
unite men in communistic societies, and he is under-
taking the ethical culture of these young country-
men of his as the only means of saving their enter-
prise. How he is succeeding may be seen from the
following sentences which I extract from a private
letter written by an intelligent observer :
1 84 ICARIA.
" I find the thirty Russians full of good feeling ; they
embrace each other each day like devoted brothers and
sisters. Every act of their social life is dominated by the
ideas of conduct imposed upon them by the teaching and
personal magnetism of Frey. Frey's idea of happiness is
to eat two meals a day of crackers and raw fruit, to touch
no kind of stimulant, to do all the labor between meals so
as to be free after to study, — the evenings in his com-
munity to be devoted to study and moral and social ex-
hortations in which all should join. This includes per-
sonal criticism with the purpose of perfecting character.
In the morning there is music and singing, which exercise
is supposed to make those who join in it feel more friendly
to each other, so that if you meet one of them before the
music he hurries by with a cold " good morning " ; but if
you meet him afterward he warmly shakes your hand and
kisses you. As a friend of Frey's I am both surprised and
delighted at the success he has made. The disciples are
all young and full of devotion ; it is charming to see such
persons, resolved to love each other, and determined to
do what is right. It is unquestionable that these persons
have given up bad habits for a social purpose, led to do
so not by superstition, but by a rational conception of
personal and public duty. For instance, they were nearly
all smokers, and without exception have given up the
habit as unwholesome and unsocial. * * * It is a
charming spot amongst the mountains which these
Russians have secured. I like the people very much in-
deed, and believe they will be successful in establishing
such a society as they aim at."
Mr. Longleyin Missouri, and Mr. Frey in Oregon,
KINDRED SOCIAL EXPERIMENTS. 1 85
are instances of what one may discover by following
the threads he finds radiating from such a centre as
" Icaria " ; just as he would have discovered
"Icaria' if his point of departure had been the
" Mutual Aid," or just as he would have found the
" Mutual Aid " and " Icaria " if his investigation
had begun at "New Odessa." Almost equally
striking is the story of N. T. Roumain, an associate
of Longley at one time, and an applicant for admis-
sion to Icaria at another time, who, in 1877,
founded the " Esperanza Community" in Kansas,
— an enterprise which had its bright day, but ended
in sadness and disaster. Or one might make a long
tale of the adventures of Earl Joslin, who was
Longley's associate in his earliest attempts at Pha-
lansteries, who has since been in various enterprises,
and who, at last accounts, was endeavoring to or-
ganize a "Cooperative Association" in Rice
County, Kansas. Though these sketches might be
multiplied, it is not my object to give a catalogue
of abortive attempts at association, but rather
merely to suggest the curious ramification into
which an apparently isolated social experiment is
likely to widen before the investigator, and to call
attention to a kind of sociological study deserving
of more consideration than it has received.
Beginning with a single community and with no
object of studying American communities in general,
I have incidentally discovered and could enumerate
1 86 ICARIA.
probably not fewer than fifty distinct attempts to
found communistic or semi-communistic associa-
tions in the United States since 1870. Most of
them were obscure, fruitless, and ephemeral. They
attracted almost no public attention, and some of
them were perhaps worthy of very little. If
they had been in Europe, they would doubtless
have thriven on the persecution of government and
the calumnies of the press, and such opposition
would have cemented and preserved them ; while in
this country their very liberty to be or not to be, to
become incorporated, to buy and sell and get gain,
to wear peculiar garments, to preach peculiar doc-
trines, and to worship strange gods, has been a
centrifugal force that community bonds have seldom
been able to stand against.
XII.
APPENDIX.
APPENDIX I.
CONTRACT OF THE NEW ICARIAN COMMUNITY
of Adams County, Iowa.
In order to form an association whose object is the realization of
Community on Icarian principles, and the formation and establish-
ment of a common fund for the assurance to each of us and of our
children of our wants, intellectual and material, in all conditions of
life — infancy, old age, health, sickness, and infirmity, — and being re-
solved to give to our association a solid basis and to place its exis-
tence beyond the risk of all misunderstanding and of all controversy
which might arise among us, —
We, the undersigned, members of the ex-Community Icarian of
Adams County, Iowa, do freely and voluntarily make, admit, sign,
and accept this contract for the formation of an association which
shall be known under the name of the New Icarian Community of
Adams County, Iowa.
Consequently we give and transfer freely to our said association all
property of every nature and of every kind immovable, movable,
and mixed — which we have and possess now, and also all property of
every kind which we may acquire in the future — by inheritance, gift,
or otherwise, to be during our lives and after our death and for ever
the exclusive property of the New Icarian Community.
We promise and agree freely and formally that, at no time and in
no case will we, or any of us, make any reclamation or demand, nor
will we claim any pecuniary compensation for any property which we
give now or which we may give in the future to our association,
either for interest or for capital, for work, labor, or any other service
which we may have performed for it.
We formally enjoin upon our heirs and upon their guardians, in
perpetual succession, not to make any reclamation against our said
189
I90 I C ARIA.
association for any thing which we have freely and voluntarily given
to it.
We consent to submit our children during their minority to the
care and the absolute control of our association, giving it the same
rights and the same powers over them, and charging it with the same
duties toward them, as if they were under its guardianship conform-
ably with the laws of Iowa.
We, who sign this contract, engage ourselves and enjoin upon our
heirs, and upon their executors, administrators, and guardians, never
to bring any suit in law or in equity against our said association,
neither to recover any property which we have freely and voluntarily
given to it, nor to obtain any salary or pecuniary compensation for
labor or service done or rendered by us or them for the said society.
We engage ourselves to give all our time, all our strength, and all
our capacities for the service of the association, during all the time
while we are members of it, and at every time and under all circum-
stances without opposition or murmur to obey the laws and regula-
tions which shall be adopted conformably to this contract, and to the
following articles :
Article i. — The place of business of the New Icarian Commu-
nity for the present, and until it may be changed, shall be Icaria,
Adams County, Iowa ; the nature of the business, which shall com-
mence on the first of May, 1879, shall be : agriculture, horticulture,
industry, art, commerce, mills, and manufactures.
Art. 2. — This association shall last for ninety-nine years, and shall
not be dissolved before that time for any reason whatsoever, without
the unanimous consent of all the adult members.
Art. 3. — The capital or the property of the New Icarian Commu-
nity shall consist of all which the founders may have recovered, in im-
movable or movable property in the liquidation of the former Icarian
Community, dissolved by a judgment of the Court of Adams County,
Iowa, rendered the 17th of August, 1878 ; and of all the increase re-
sulting from the operations of the agriculture, horticulture, mills,
manufactures, commerce, and arts of the said society, of all gifts
made by strangers, and of all money paid, or property given by new
members when they have been admitted to final membership.
APPENDIX. 191
Art. 4. — The social capital shall be common and indivisible. It
shall be recorded in the name of the New Icarian Community.
Art. 5. — The affairs of this society shall be conducted and ad-
ministered by five directors, chosen among the members, as follows
a President, a Secretary-Treasurer, a Director of Industry, a Director
of Agriculture, a Director of Clothing. Each director shall hold
office for a year, and shall be elected separately in a general assembly,
which shall meet on the 3d of February of every year after the year
1879 for this especial purpose.
Art. 6. — No member of the association who has not reached the
age of twenty-five years at least shall be eligible to the office of di-
rector, and no one shall be eligible to the presidency who is not at
least thirty years old and has not been a member of the society for
at least five years. The founders of the society are excepted from
this rule. No member shall be chosen director more than twice con-
secutively, and after a member shall have been elected director twice
consecutively, he shall not be re-elected director until after having
been a year out of office.
Art. 7. — The title of all the fixed property which the society now
possesses, or which may hereafter be acquired, is and shall be vested
in the name of the five directors hereinafter named, or of their suc-
cessors in office, for the use and benefit of the said association ; and
may be sold, conveyed, or mortgaged by a vote of the association as
hereinafter described, and the five directors shall sign and acknowl-
edge all the conveyances, and set upon them the seal of the associa-
tion.
Art. 8. — In all transactions relating to movable property, the
President of the community alone may buy, sell, and contract in the
name of the community, after authorization of the general assembly.
Every contract, sale, or purchase which has not been made by the
President, or upon an order written and signed by him, shall not in
any manner bind the association. If by any reason not provided for
in this contract, it is impossible for the President to attend to the
affairs of the society, the other directors shall appoint one of their
members to act temporarily in his place.
Art. 9. — The directors of this association are responsible before
192 ICARIA.
the general assembly, and can be suspended or removed from their
office by a vote of the majority of the male members. In case of the
death, suspension, dismissal, withdrawal, or expulsion of a member of
the administration, the assembly shall fill the vacancy eight days after
either the death, suspension, dismissal/withdrawal, or expulsion of a
member.
Art. 10. — Every business transaction exceeding in amount $100,
must be signed by the President and the Secretary, and must bear the
seal of the society in order to be binding.
Art. 11. — All male adult members who have been definitely ad-
mitted, are eligible to all the offices of the society subject to Article
7 of this contract, and will participate by their vote in all decisions.
The adult members of the ' ' sexe f eminin "have the right to vote
upon all admissions and exclusions ; they are both electors and eli-
gible for all committees and for the office of the Director of Clothing.
They have the right to vote upon the revision of this contract, upon
the dissolution of the society, and in general upon all matters of
moral and intellectual interest, such as education, propaganda, and
amusements. Minors and members admitted on probation have no
right to vote in any case.
Art. 12. — The suffrage shall be exercised in the general assembly
and in person ; no vote by proxy or substitute will be permitted. The
vote in general assembly may be taken in any manner whatsoever,
except in the following cases : admissions, exclusions, and the elec-
tion of the Board of Directors, which votes shall be by written bal-
lot, signed or unsigned at the will of the voter.
Art. 13. — Provisional admissions and definitive admissions shall
take place in general assembly by a vote of at least nine tenths of the
members having the right to vote. Adult candidates, when they are
admitted definitively, shall pay $100 ; minors, $20. They shall con-
form to all the special law on the subject of admission. Provisional
admission must take place, at the latest, fourteen days after the ar-
rival of the candidate at Icaria ; six months after arrival, a second
vote likewise is necessary for permission to continue the novitiate.
Definitive or full admission shall take place one year after the pro-
visional admission. Any admission not made conformably to the
APPENDIX. 193
terms of this contract is null and void, and does not confer any
right.
Art. 14. — When a candidate has not the means to pay a part or
all of the sum required by Article 13, the society may exempt him by
a vote of nine tenths of the voting members.
Art. 15. — No stranger may reside more than fourteen days in the
association without the consent of nine tenths of the members having
right to vote.
Art. 16. — The adults and minors admitted provisionally are held
to obey the directors and to perform the labor assigned to them by
decision of the assembly general. They shall labor at all times ac-
cording to their strength and their capacity, and shall receive in com-
pensation for their labor, proportionally to their needs and to the
means of the society, their lodging, food, clothing, care in sickness,
attention and care for the children and the aged ; but no other com-
pensation of any sort.
Art. 17. — Minors who have lost father and mother in the associa-
tion, shall be supported and shall remain under the surveillance of the
society, which shall take the same care of them and give them the
same support as the children whose parents are living. When the
minors, having arrived at their majority, desire to remain in the as-
sociation, they shall state the same in writing to the general assem-
bly, and shall sign this contract. They shall then have all the rights
of members admitted definitively by this contract.
Art. 18. — The principal object of this association in conducting
the affairs described and considered in these articles, being that of
creating and establishing a fund which shall provide for the needs and
comforts of the young, the old, the sick, and the infirm, no dividend
shall be paid to any member ; but every accumulation of wealth shall
be added to the common fund.
Art. 19. — Every member who has decided to retire from the so-
ciety shall give to the general assembly fifteen days' notice in writ-
ing. Every member retiring in this manner shall receive from the
society the pledge of a gift of $100 if he be an adult, and $20 if he be
a minor. This amount may be increased by a vote of three fourths
of the general assembly, in the meeting which is held on the 3d of
194 ICARIA.
February, for trie election of the Board of Directors, upon the propo-
sition of five members of the society. 1
Art. 20. — The sale of annual products may be made when it is
authorized by a vote of the majority of the adult men present in the
general assembly, and the majority may decide upon the use and the
disposition of such products and of the proceeds of their sale. Be-
sides these annual revenues of the society, the majority may — but
not more than once in a month — decide upon the use or the disposi-
tion of a portion of the social capital not to exceed $100. Every dis-
position of the social capital beyond the amount of $100, must be
made by a vote of nine tenths of the voting members, and the dis-
position of the fifth part of the social capital may not be made except
by the unanimous consent of the members voting.
Art. 21. — This association does not approve the borrowing of
money as a general rule ; but as it may sometimes be necessary, the
President may, by a vote of the general assembly, borrow money to
the amount of $100, when the loan does not require mortgage ; but
this may be done only once a month.
Art. 22. — No loan under any other conditions shall bind the so-
ciety, unless by the consent of nine tenths of the voting members.
Art. 23. — All the ordinary affairs of the society shall be con-
ducted and decided by a majority vote of the adult men who are
present In the general assembly at the moment of the vote, ex-
cept in cases specified and provided for in the other articles of this
contract.
Art. 24. — The general assembly of this association shall be com-
posed of the members having the right to vote ; and its decisions shall
bind the association when the half plus one of the men having the
right to vote are present at the meeting. In case of urgency recog-
nized by the majority of the men having the right to vote, that ma-
jority shall suffice to authorize the assembly to make decisions which
shall bind the society when the postponement of a decision might be
prejudicial to the interests of the society.
1 Note to Art. 19. — This article was revised at the meeting of Feb. 3, 1883.
Under the new rule, a man when admitted simply gives the society whatever
he possesses. If he retires, he receives two thirds the amount of his initial de-
posit, and $25 additional for each year he has served the society. This rule
applies to charter members and later admissions equally.
APPENDIX. 195
Art. 25. — Any member of this association maybe expelled by a
vote of nine tenths of the members having the right to vote, when
that member has been guilty of voluntary disobedience, without any
good reason, and of refusing repeatedly to perform the orders of the
directors, or when he refuses to conform to the decisions of the gen-
eral assembly, if, by his conduct, the said delinquent member has
seriously prejudiced the moral and material interests of the society.
The expulsion will take place in a special assembly called for that
purpose, of which assembly and of the charges preferred against him
the said member shall have fifteen days' notice. The member ac-
cused shall have every guaranty for the proof of his innocence and
for the explanation of the acts of which he is accused. In case
of withdrawal or expulsion from the society of a member who is the
head of a family, that withdrawal or expulsion shall imply the with-
drawal of his children under the age of fifteen years.
Art. 26. — If one or more members of this association shall rebel
against its authority, or form a party detached from the common
group, in the matter of nourriture (eating), of labor, of purchase and
of sale, of loans and of gifts, or in any other manner ; or shall under-
take to turn the society from its true end as specified above ; or shall
leave the society for more than three consecutive days without the
consent of a majority of three fourths of the members ; or shall labor
repeatedly outside the community, or within its limits, for strangers,
without the knowledge and consent of the assembly, that member
or those members may be expelled by a majority of the members
having the right to vote, but the member or members expelled shall
have the right to receive the gift of $100 upon their expulsion, like
members withdrawing. The member or members accused of
offences against this contract shall not have the right to vote upon the
penalty which shall be inflicted upon them by the assembly.
Art. 27. — All the laws and regulations necessary to execute and
to carry into proper effect the objects of this association, provided
they are not inconsistent with or opposed to this contract, may be
made by a majority of the men.
Art. 28. — Five members of the association may, at every annual
assembly for the election of the directors, propose the revision of any
196 ICARIA.
part of this contract whatsoever, and if a majority of nine tenths of
the members having the right to vote, vote in favor of the proposed
revision, it shall be placed upon the order of the day of the general
assembly, discussed and voted upon three months after its presenta-
tion, and if at this last vote the nine tenths of the members having
the right to vote decide in favor of such revision, it shall have full
force and effect as part of this contract.
Art. 29. — In case of the dissolution of this association by the
unanimous consent of all its members, or by any other unforeseen
cause, the social capital and the property shall be divided as follows :
First, all the debts' or claims due or belonging to persons outside the
society shall be determined and paid. Second, the members who
were founders or who signed this contract at the date of its adoption,
viz., May 1, 1879, shall receive, and shall be paid in money or in
equivalent property the amount placed in the common fund by
them at the date of the signature of this contract, or at any other
later date, as the books of the association shall make evident. Third,
the members who were not founders shall also receive in money or in
equivalent property that which they have placed in the common fund
of the association at the time of their definitive admission, or at any
other time thereafter, as the books of the association may show.
Fourth, the remainder of the property of the association, if there be
any, shall be divided among the members according to the years of
service of each adult member, reckoning from the time of his signa-
ture of this contract. Every adult member shall receive a part pro-
portioned to his time of service under this contract. The period of
service of the founders shall be counted, in reckoning their years of
service, from the date of this contract ; the period of the other mem-
bers shall be counted from their definitive admission ; the time of
children bom in the community, and of those who enter as minors,
shall be counted from the day when they have attained their
majority ; minor orphans shall have the right to ten years of service
in making this division of the property in case of dissolution.
We, the undersigned, in full possession of our faculties intellectual
and moral, knowing well and comprehending perfectly the above con-
tract and all its articles, do adopt and accept them freely and volun-
APPENDIX. 197
tarily, and do engage ourselves not to make any reclamation of any
sort or nature whatsoever against our said association which would
not be in accordance with the terms of this contract.
The directors chosen conformably to this contract, in 1879. for
the year 1879, to remain in office until Feb. 3, 1880, are as follows :
E. F. Bettannier, President ; A. A. Marchand, Secretary-Treasurer ;
V. E. Caille, Director of Agriculture ; Armel Marchand, Director of
Industry ; and Marie V. Marchand, Director of Clothing.
[Here follow signatures, acknowledged before a notary public, and
the minute of the county recorder.]
APPENDIX II.
LAW UPON WITHDRAWAL AND EXPULSION FROM
THE ICARIAN COMMUNITY.1'
Section I. — Preamble.
When a person has resolved to live in communism, and has made
his demand for admission into Icaria, the greatest prudence, the
most serious reflection, should be exercised in the accomplishment of
the act, which, by its good or bad results may be classed among the
most important acts of his life.
No inconsiderate enthusiasm for the beauty of the Icarian system
should influence his mind, nor have weight in his decision. It is im-
portant that he separate from the causes of his determination all
sentimentalism, all enthusiasm of a nature to conceal the truth from
his eyes and make him conceive of the community as much more
beautiful, more developed, more perfect than it really is, and its
members better than they really are.
In the distance defects are unperceived, forms harmonize, all is
embellished ; men are exalted in their merit, and things appear more
beautiful than they are.
But if it is necessary that one should always be on his guard
against mirages and illusions, it is especially important that he
should do so in reference to an act which may result, in the future,
in regrets to all concerned.
Icaria does not escape the rule of illusions ! The experience of
many years demonstrates, on the contrary, that the hope of amelio-
rating his situation, the idea which he generally forms of Icaria and
Icarians, the joy that he experiences in the thought of being able to
live according to his principles, exercises over every distant candidate
an irresistible enchantment, which in many cases suffices to conceal
1 See page 131
198
APPENDIX, 199
from him the inconveniences of our society of equality, and leave on
his mind only a conception of its advantages.
To these natural inclinations toward the transports of enthusiasm
are added the great influence of the writings of Cabet, picturing the
splendors that communism shall one day realize, and also the favor-
able impression that the regular publication of La Jeune Icarie
cannot fail to exercise over the mind, by its exposition of the organi-
zation, the principles, and the grandeur of the end which the com-
munity proposes to itself.
But in all things — it is necessary to repeat — it is a long distance
from the desire to the realization, from the principle to the fact,
from the theory to the practical embodiment ; and what is true else-
where is true also in Icaria. Those who desire to join it ought to be
thoroughly impressed with this fact, and act only after having thor-
oughly considered the gravity of the situation.
For, let us not forget, enthusiasm is ephemeral ! When its inspi-
ration has passed, deceptions, discouragement, succeed to the en-
chantment, and a prompt return to individualism is often the sad
consequence of it.
Theoretically, quitting old society to embrace the communistic
life should be an irrevocable act. Those who join themselves to the
community should do it for all time ; and whatever property they
possess should be deposited in the social fund without power of
recall. For if it is reasonable that one should withdraw himself
from the iniquities of individualism, to adopt a better form of associa-
tion, there can be no reason for quitting the latter in order to live
again under the yoke of laws which one has once rejected with all
his convictions.
Change for the better is logical ; returning upon one's steps, in the
path of progress, is an absurdity.
Moreover, withdrawal often involves a multitude of inconveniences
for the society and the seceders.
In what concerns the definite deposit of property there is, in fact^,
a certain inequality in this respect, that one family can retain some
rights over a deposit while others have nothing which belongs to
themselves.
200 ICARIA.
It is true that the inequality reappears only on the morrow of
their departure. While persons live in Icaria equality is perfect as
regards possession. But for the communists this difference with
the seceders is not less an evil, which the financial weakness of Icaria
can alone justify.
Later, when the community shall have grown, when its produc-
tion shall be better assured and its general situation prosperous, it
will be able, while giving increased comforts to its members, to
exact guarantees of stability, and to establish equality even in the
case of withdrawing members.
Meanwhile many inconveniences would result from holding too
rigorously to principles deduced from pure reason, and upon this
point, as upon others, it is necessary to conform to the exigencies of
practical life.
Nevertheless, the sincere and firm intention to remain perma-
nently in Icaria should be the basis of the application of every can-
didate.
But since the weakness and variableness of men compel us to an-
ticipate withdrawals, and since, on the other hand, a member may so
disregard his duties that the Society will feel itself under obligation
to exclude him, it is important to regulate in advance, in the interest
of seceders and of the Society, the condition which shall govern vol-
untary or constrained withdrawals.
Section II. — Withdrawal.
Article i. — Every member, provisional or absolute, can at any
time, by giving notice to the delegates one month in advance, with-
draw from the Community.
Art. 2. — The withdrawing member shall give notice of his pur-
pose in a written paper or letter of withdrawal.
Art. 3. — The withdrawing member shall not be relieved of his
duties until the Assembly shall have passed a vote accepting his
resignation of membership.
Section III. — Withdrawal in the Novitiate.
Art. 4. — When a provisional member shall decide to withdraw,
the money, deeds, jewelry, credits, tools, and other things that he
APPENDIX. 20 1
may have deposited on entering, -with the knowledge of the trustees,
shall be returned to him.
Art. 5. — The provisional member, being considered in every thing
save voting a full member, no interest, rent, or revenue whatsoever,
be it :n money or in commodities which shall have been obtained by
mone/. the credits or the property that he shall have deposited upon
entrance, shall be returned to him. The revenue in all its forms be-
longs to the community.
Section IV. — Withdrawal of Full Members.
Art. 6. — After having accepted the resignation of a full member,
the General Assembly shall take into consideration the time that said
member has passed in the community, the services that he has ren-
dered to it, the value of his deposit, the condition of his family, his
personal resources, and allow to him, under the title of gift, such
sum of money or such property as the financial condition and interest
of the community, being well considered, shall at the time permit it
to give.
Art. 7. — The withdrawal of the husband involves the withdrawal
of the wife, and vice versd ; also the withdrawal of their children
under twenty years of age. By a two-thirds vote the latter may be
re-admitted upon their application.
Section V. — Cash Deposits.
Art. 8. — When a member who has deposited in the common
treasury more than a hundred dollars shall have offered his resignation
of membership, the general assembly shall designate the times and
the successive payments in the refunding of such deposit.
Art. 9. — Deposits not exceeding one hundred dollars shall be re-
funded within one year after the withdrawal of the depositor.
Art. 10. — The same amount shall be refunded that was deposited ;
that is, it shall be refunded without interest.
Art. 11. — Likewise, after the dismissal of a member, the sums
which the community shall refund to him in partial payments, by
the direction of the general assembly, shall not bear interest. The
exact amount contributed shall be refunded.
202 ICARIA.
Art. 12. — Articles 8, 9, 11 shall be in force until the present debt
of the community is paid.
Art. 13. — After that the General Assembly shall have the power
to determine in advance the sums which shall be refunded yearly in
case of withdrawal.
Section VI. — Deposits other than in Cash.
Art. 14. — When a member shall contribute to the community a
deposit other than cash, such as houses, lands, credits, mortgages,
horses, cattle, etc., the said deposit, with a statement of its character,
shall be recorded to the credit of the member on the books of the
community.
Art. 15. — In case of withdrawal this deposit shall in the course of
six months be returned to him in the condition in which it shall be at
the time.
Art. 16. — When the community shall have sold a part or the
whole of the lands, houses, or property of any kind, deposited by a
member, the net product of this sale shall be placed to the account of
said depositor, and he shall be reimbursed just as though his deposit
had been made in ready money.
Art. 17. — The tools, arms, instruments, machines, books, furni-
ture, etc., shall be returned immediately and in the condition in
which they are at the time of withdrawal.
Art. 18. — No damage or indemnity shall be accorded for tools,
instruments, or property of any kind, which shall have been mislaid,
used, damaged, or destroyed.
Section VII. — Special Contracts.
Art. 19. — When a candidate shall possess considerable money, and
the conditions of the present law shall prevent his admission, the
community may make a special contract with him respecting the
manner in which his capital shall be refunded in case of his with-
drawal.
Art. 20. — Nevertheless this special contract shall not be in opposi-
tion to Article 10, concerning the non-payment of interest for time
anterior to withdrawal.
APPENDIX. 203
Art. 21. — Special contracts shall be recorded upon the books of
the community at the pages devoted to the contracting persons, and
signed by the latter and two trustees.
Section VIII. — Expulsion.
Art. 22. — When a member shall not wish to conform to the laws ;
when he shall refuse to fulfil his duties ; when he shall conduct
himself improperly toward his associates ; when his general attitude
shall constitute a real danger to the society, he can be expelled by
a vote of two thirds of the members.
Art. 23. — This expulsion can only take place when the accused
has been notified of the misdemeanors charged against him ten days
in advance of the day for their investigation, and he shall' have been
given full liberty to defend himself before the assembly.
Art. 24. — As in admission so in dismission, the expulsion of the
husband implies the withdrawal of his wife, and reciprocally ; also
the withdrawal of their children under twenty years of age.
Art. 25. — Expelled members shall be settled with in accordance
with the law upon withdrawals, as in the case of dismissed members.
Section IX. — Revision.
Art. 26. — The present law is subject to annual revision beginning
from the 1st of May, 1879, by a majority of two thirds of the mem-
bers of the General Assembly.
This law was unanimously approved by the General Assembly
Dec. 8, 1879.
APPENDIX III.
CONTRACT AND ARTICLES OF AGREEMENT OF THE
ICARIA-SPERANZA COMMUNE.1
Section I. — Society.
Article i. — Know all men by these presents that we : Armand
Dehay, Marie Dehay, Paul Leroux, Francoise Leroux, Pierre Le-
roux, Josephine Leroux, Gustave Provost, Irma Provost, Emile
Bee, Caroline Bee, Eugene Mourot, Marie Mourot, Emile Fugier,
Emilie Fugier, Therese James, Michel Brumme, Alexis Marchand,
Louise Mourot, Louise Peron, Emile Peron,
and all others who shall be admitted and allowed to sign this Contract
and Articles of Agreement ; being of age and in full knowledge of
our action and deed, do hereby associate and form a society, under
such name and conditions, and for such business and object as is
hereinafter described.
Art. 2. — The name of this society is
ICARIA-SPERANZA COMMUNE ;
and its location and principal place of business is on Bluxome
Rancho, near Cloverdale, Sonoma County, State of California.
Section II. — General Object.
Art. 3. — The general purpose of the Icaria-Speranza commune
is as follows, to wit :
A. To establish for humanity as an example and in devotion to
its welfare, a system of society capable of rendering it happy.
B. To prove to our fellow-men that community, based on soli-
darity, is realizable and possible.
1 See page 145
204
APPENDIX. 205
C. To perform such labor, and use such sums of money, from
time to time, as the commune may deem sufficient in publishing, ad-
vertising, and circulating the business and principles of the Icaria-
Speranza Commune ; but the aggregate of sums of money and
reasonable value of labor applied to such advertising shall at no time
be less than fifty dollars per annum.
D. To create a common fund, composed of money, real estate,
personal property, and all kinds of other property, said common fund
to be used for the mutual support and in the interest of all members
composing this society ; for the supplying of their legitimate wants,
their comfort, care, and education, in all stages of life, as well in in-
fancy, sickness, infirmity, and old age ; and to be used also to carry
out the principles, business, and various objects of the community, in
accordance with the purport of an instrument styled, " Act of Dona-
tion to the Icarian Community" dated April 22d, A. D., 1879, and
recorded in Book II., miscellaneous, at page 378, in the office of
Recorder of Deeds, Adams County, State of Iowa.
Section III. — Dtiration and Dissolution.
Art. 4. — The duration of the Icaria-Esperanza commune shall be
ninety-nine years, counting from the date of the adoption of this con-
tract, and its organization shall be renewed whenever it becomes
necessary.
Art. 5. — If for any reason whatever this contract should become
annulled, or if for any cause whatever the Icaria-Speranza commune
should be dissolved, its entire property shall be disposed of in the
following manner.
A. First, all outside creditors shall be paid up and settled with.
B. Next, all credits to which the members of the commune shall
be individually entitled to, and which sums shall have been entered
on the books of the commune, below their individual name, as their
exclusive property, shall be paid to them.
C. The remainder shall be accounted for, paid over, assigned or
transferred in accordance with the several donations that shall have
been made to the Icarian Community, a true copy of which donations
is hereto attached.
206 1CARIA.
Section IV. — Capital Stock.
ART. 6. — The capital stock of the Icaria-Speranza commune com-
prises all kinds of property, and constitutes a common fund owned
by the commune and applicable to all its wants through its proper
agents.
But said common fund shall not be mortgaged, alienated or in-
debted to a greater extent than is hereinafter prescribed, unless nine
tenths of the members having voting privilege agree, in general as-
sembly, to such greater alienation.
Art. 7. — The common fund of the Icaria-Speranza commune is
composed of all sums of money or property of any description that
shall have been either donated, transferred, assigned, or set over in
any lawful manner to the commune, by friends, well-wishers, charter-
members or later admitted members, by societies or any other com-
munes ; and such money or property, as well as all accumulations
thereof, shall be held in trust and used only in accordance with the
purport of said donations, transfers, assignments, and the stipulation
of this contract.
Art. 8. — The common fund of the Icaria-Speranza commune is
further composed of all sums of money or property whatever, owned
or possessed by its individual members before entering this associa-
tion.
But such money or property as shall have been conditionally con-
tributed to the common fund by individual members, is to be re-
funded to them, in case of their withdrawal from the commune, un-
der such conditions as are hereinafter agreed to.
Art. 9. — However, each and every individual member has the ex-
clusive use and ownership of the following property :
A. Each and every article of his wardrobe.
B. Each and every article of his furniture, bedding, and house-
hold implements.
C. Each and every article that shall have been given him as a
present by persons who are not members of the commune, and who
shall be still living at the time when the individual member takes pos-
session of such present ; provided, however, that, in the aggregate,
the fair value of the present, or presents, so received in the course of
APPENDIX. 207
any one year, shall not exceed fifty dollars, and that all surplus shall
be remitted to the common fund, and entered on the member's
credit.
D. Each and every article which shall have been given him as a
present by any one member or members of the commune, who shall
still be living at the time when the donee-member takes possession of
such present ; provided, however, that, in the aggregate, the fair
value of the present or presents so received by him in the course of
any one year shall not exceed twenty-five dollars, and that all surplus
shall be remitted to the fund.
Section V. — Prodtiction and Business.
Art. 10. — The general nature of production and business of the
Icaria-Speranza commune is as follows, to wit : agriculture, horti-
culture, viticulture, mechanical arts, milling, manufacturing, and
commerce in all various branches ; also the building and establishing
of schools, colleges, villages, colonies, and the developing of sciences
and fine arts.
Section VI. — Administration.
ART. II. — The business affairs and common interests generally
shall be conducted by a Board of Administration, composed of five
committees, denominated as follows :
A. Committee on Works.
B. Committee on Home-Consumption.
C. Committee on Education.
D. Committee on Commerce.
E. Committee on Accounts.
Art. 12. — Each one of these five committees shall be composed of
at least two members having voting privilege ; and when acting
separately, shall transact only such business as comes within the lim-
its of their conferred powers.
Art. 13. — The duties, power, and scope of action of each com-
mittee shall be defined in special by-laws to be adopted in general
assembly.
Art. 14. — When any unusual or contingent matter shall
come before any one committee, the latter shall convene the
208 ICARIA.
board of administration and lay such matter before them, either for
final decision, or for reference to a special or to an ordinary meeting
of the general assembly.
Art. 15. — The board of administration may convene the general
assembly in extraordinary session, whenever they deem it necessary ;
and said board shall convene said assembly when any five members
having voting privilege shall have made a written application for that
purpose.
Art. 16. — No decision or vote, taken either by a committee or by
the board of administration, shall be valid unless it obtains the
unanimous assent of its members.
Art. 17. — The title to all common property, either real, personal,
or mixed, is vested in the persons composing the board of adminis-
tration, and in their successors in office, who shall, in this relation,
be considered as trustees of the Icaria-Speranza commune.
Art. 18. — Each and every member of the board of administration
shall be elected by the general assembly in the month of January,
for one year, and shall be, at any time, accountable to, and remov-
able by, said assembly.
Art. 19. — The names of the persons composing the board of ad-
ministration until next January are as follows, to wit :
Section VII. — Liabilities.
Art. 20. — The highest amount of debts for which the property of
the Icaria-Speranza commune shall become liable is thirty-
three per cent, of the whole assets, as shall be yearly shown by a cor-
rect inventory. For exceptions, see Art. 6.
Art. 21. — The aggregate of debts, or the liabilities of any kind,
shall include all credits which may, at any time, become due to the
members, as shall appear from the books of the commune.
Section VIII. — General Assembly.
Art. 22. — The general assembly is composed of all members, of
both sexes, who are at least twenty-one years old, and who shall have
been admitted to sign this contract.
Art. 23. — Minor members above fourteen years of age, and pro-
APPENDIX. 209
visional members may be admitted to its sessions, but with consulta-
tive voice only.
Art. 24. — Its regular sessions are held semi-annually, but special
sessions may be convoked according to the foregoing provisions.
Art. 25. — The general assembly may adopt, at any time, such
by-laws and regulations as shall be deemed necessary to the proper
fulfilment of this agreement.
Art. 26. — No decision or vote taken in general assembly shall
be valid unless carried by fully three fourths of the voting members
who shall be present at the session when such vote is taken.
Art. 27. — A majority of fully three fourths of the members having
voting privilege constitutes a " quorum," without which " quorum "
the general assembly shall not open its sessions, except to adjourn
twice, if necessary ; and, after such adjournments, a majority of half
plus one of the members having voting privilege shall be deemed a
M quorum " to transact any business.
Art. 28. — All admissions of new members, all expulsions of mem-
bers, and all elections to any office shall be by ballot upon unsigned
tickets.
Art. 29. Elections to any office shall not be valid, unless carried
as follows, to wit : —
A. Candidates must obtain a majority of fully three fourths of
the members having voting privilege, to be elected on first ballot.
B. Elections on second ballot shall be determined by a majority
of half-plus-one of the members having voting privilege.
C. A relative majority, viz. : the highest number of votes cast,
shall carry an election on third ballot.
Section IX. — Withdrawal Fund.
Art. 30. — In the month of January of every year, the board of
administration, through the committee on accounts, shall make a
correct inventory in which every article of common property of the
Icaria-Speranza commune shall be listed and appraised at its fair
cash value.
Art. 31. — In appraising some classes of property, especially real
estate, the possible fluctuation of the market shall be taken into con-
210 ICARIA.
sideration, and the average fair cash value, of such property, in two
or more past years, shall be deemed the correct value.
Art. 32. — One of the objects of the taking of said inventory is to
fairly ascertain the surplus or net profit earned, year after year, by the
Icaria-Speranza commune, said profit to be expressed in dollars.
Art. 33. — When the amount of said surplus shall have been ascer-
tained, and approved by the general assembly, said amount shall be
divided into two halves ; one half shall belong to the commune and
accumulate to the common fund ; and the other half shall be divided
by the number of members having the voting privilege for the purpose
of ascertaining each member's equal share.
Art. 34. — The amount thus yearly found due to each member shall
be entered on the books of the commune, below his individual name,
together with any other credits that he may have ; but shall only be-
come his exclusive property, and be paid him, in case of his with-
drawal from the commune.
Section X. — Consideration.
Art. 35. — Besides all other benefits that each member may derive
from this contract, the Icaria-Speranza commune, as a further con-
sideration, shall enter on its books, and pass to the credit side of -each
individual member having voting privilege, the sum of two hundred
dollars, to come out of its property, and to be paid to said member
in case of his withdrawal ; provided, however, that each such mem-
ber shall have made a donation, transfer, or assignment forever of his
property to the Icaria-Speranza commune, located at near Clover-
dale, Sonoma County, State of California, within one year from the
date of the recording of this contract, or, previously to such record-
ing, to the Icarian Community situated near Corning, Adams County,
State of Iowa.
Section XI. — Labor Premiums.
Art. 36. — Monthly labor premiums shall be given to each member,
being above sixteen years of age, provided said member partakes in
the common work of the commune ; said premium shall be paid in
money, and shall not be less than fifty cents, nor more than one dol-
lar and a half per month.
APPENDIX. 211
Art. 37. — The member of the board of administration, acting as
treasurer, shall not pay any money as labor premiums, unless in
accordance with the following conditions :
A. Every month he shall pay a premium of fifty cents to each
member who shall not have lost more than one working-day during
said month.
B. Every month he shall pay a premium of one dollar to each
member who shall not have lost more than half a working-day during
said month.
C. No excuse whatever shall be admitted as a substitute for
working-time lost by a member, in relation to the payment of pre-
miums.
Art. 38. — The general assembly shall adopt a special by-law in
which all labor of any kind that is to be considered common work,
shall be defined.
Section XII. — Inheritance.
Art. 39. — Each and every signer of this contract formally agrees
and stipulates that if he deceases while being a member, each and
every article of his individual property, as well as all credits entered
on the books of the commune, shall return forthwith to the common
fund ; with such minimum exception, however, as the law may
require.
Section. XIII. — Clothing.
Art. 40. — The board of administration, through the committee on
home consumption, shall make a semi-annual budget of expenses
necessary to properly clothe each and every member of the Icaria-
Speranza commune, and to that effect they shall carry out the fol-
lowing rule :
A. They shall ascertain and express in dollars what sum is neces-
sary to purchase the clothing, in the six ensuing months, of each full-
grown female member.
B. They shall find what sum is necessary for each full-grown male
member.
C. They shall classify all the children in as many series as shall
be found necessary, and ascertain what sum is wanted to clothe each
member of each series.
212 ICARIA.
D. When the aggregate of all such sums shall be found, they
shall submit the " Semi-Annual Budget of Expenses for Clothing"
to the general assembly for correction or approval.
E. After such proceedings, the member of the board of adminis-
tration, acting as delegate to commercial business, shall open, in one
or more stores of the nearest town to be designated by said delegate,
a credit to each individual member, said credit not to exceed the sum
found as his individual budget ; and the said delegate shall see, when
necessary, that no credits opened in any store are diverted from their
legitimate destination.
F. All credits so opened shall be equal for each member of each
series of persons ; but in cases of special wants of clothing for spe-
cial common works, or common purposes, the committee on home
consumption may cause such articles to be bought and delivered
whenever deemed necessary, and every such article shall be common
property to be used temporarily.
Art. 41. — Within the limits of his individual budget, each mem-
ber shall be at liberty to select whatever object of clothing that suits
him.
Section XIV. — Rights and Duties.
Art. 42. — All who shall be admitted to sign this contract, together
with their children, shall be members of the Icaria-Speranza com-
mune, and shall have equally all the same rights and privileges,
either express or implied, pertaining to such membership ; provided,
however, that no privilege, so exercised by any one member, shall
conflict with the expressed or implied provisions of this contract.
Art. 43. — The committee on home consumption shall see that
all food prepared and cooked in the common kitchen be wholesome,
and that the menu, or bill of fare, be so varied and so complete as is
reasonably compatible with the means of the commune.
Art. 44. — As far as practicable and not objectionable, all meals
shall be taken in common, in the common dining-room of the com-
mune ; but each member shall have the privilege to obtain, from the
menu prepared in the common kitchen, his reasonable proportion of
food, and to take his meals wherever he pleases.
Art. 45. — In cases of sickness each member shall be entitled to a
APPENDIX. 213
private bill of fare, privately prepared, provided said bill shall not ex-
ceed the ordinary and reasonable staples of food, and call only for
such articles of food as shall be within the easy purchasing powers of
the commune.
Art. 46. — Except in special cases designated by the general as-
sembly, each member shall reside on the place where the commune
is located, in houses furnished for that purpose ; and said residences
shall only be used for their legitimate destination, viz. : exclusively as
dwellings for said members.
Art. 47. — Each and every signer hereof formally agrees and stipu-
lates that he shall never claim, nor attempt to recover, either directly
or indirectly, at law or in equity, any other sums of money, or pro-
perty whatever, than is herein specified and provided for as part of the
compensation given by the commune for his time, services and labor.
Art. 48. — He further agrees and stipulates that he relinquishes all
rights of recovery from work, time, or services whatever given to the
commune, by any one member of his family ; relinquishing also all
rights of recovery either for services, damages, expectancy of life or
estate, in cases of death or of any accident whatever that may have
happened, by any reason or cause, to any one or every member of his
family ; agreeing hereby that the benefits that he, and each member
of his family, derived daily from the operations of this contract,
are ample and sufficient compensation for the relinquishment of all
such rights.
Art. 49. — Each and every member of this association shall give
his entire working time and abilities to the common use and works of
the commune, as shall be amicably distributed among them by the
committee on works, after a workers' consultation.
Art. 50. — The Icaria-Speranza commune shall give to each minor
member, at least until he shall have attained the age of sixteen years,
as thorough and as complete an education, in both English and
French languages, as shall be found reasonably compatible, at any
time, with the various works, the financial means, and the professorial
opportunities of the association.
Section XV. — Admission.
Art. 51. — New members may be admitted in the Icaria-Speranza
214 ICARIA.
commune, and allowed to sign this contract, under the following con-
ditions :
A. Each and every applicant for admission should sufficiently
know the French language to speak it and read it fluently.
B. All admissions shall be, at first, provisional, and shall not be
valid, unless fully nine tenths of the members having voting privilege,
assent, by a vote in general assembly, to such provisional admission.
C. After such provisional admission, each applicant shall stay in
novitiate for a term of strictly twelve consecutive months, after which
term he may be absolutely admitted in general assembly, by a vote of
fully nine tenths of the members having voting privilege.
Art. 52. — Upon the written request of five voting members, the
board of administration may cause any provisional member, as well
as any other person having sojourned for more than three consecutive
days, to withdraw from the commune at any time within forty-eight
hours from such request.
Section XVI. — Withdrawals.
Art. 53. — After having given ten days' notice of his intention to
the committee on accounts, each member may, at any time, resign
his membership and withdraw from the commune, but such formal,
resignation shall be made on a written and signed instrument stating
that the resigning member relinquishes all his membership rights for
the purpose of obtaining a settlement of his accounts with the com-
mune.
Art. 54. — After such proceedings, the committee on accounts
shall convene the board of administration, and lay before them such,
letter of resignation for final acceptation and mode of settlement of
the resigner's account, or for reference to the general assembly.
Art. 55. — Within sixty days after he shall have tendered his resig-
nation, each member shall receive, and be paid, all his credits that
shall have been entered on the books of the commune ; provided,
however, that within the twelve months preceding such resignation,
the Icaria-Speranza commune shall not have paid out, as fund for
withdrawing members, more than fifteen hundred dollars in the
aggregate.
Art. 56. — When within any one year the Icaria-Speranza com-
APPENDIX. 2 1 5
mune shall have paid to withdrawing members a sum of money ex-
ceeding fifteen hundred dollars, the board of administration, when
requested to settle with any other resigning member, shall strike a
balance of the account of said member, deliver him a due-bill or note
for such balance, and shall be allowed one year's time to pay said
bill.
Art. 57. — In cases of married members, the resignation of the
husband shall imply the resignation of his wife, and vice versd ; as
well as of all their children under sixteen years of age.
Section XVII. — Expulsions.
Art. 58. — When the conduct, or general behavior, of any member
above sixteen years of age shall be so obnoxious as to seriously en-
danger either the material, financial, or moral interests of the Icaria-
Speranza commune, he may be ousted from his membership and ex-
pelled from the commune.
Art. 59. — Each accused member shall have ten days' notice of the
charges preferred against him, and shall have fair opportunities to de-
fend himself in general assembly ; but no expulsion shall be valid
unless carried by a vote of fully nine tenths of the members having
voting privilege, the vote to be expressed in two different sessions,
to be held at least thirty days from the first.
Art. 60. — No member, or his wife, and vice versd, shall vote
upon his own expulsion ballot, and in case he does vote, his ticket
shall be refused.
Art. 61. — The expulsion of a member husband shall imply the
resignation of his wife, and vice versd ; as well as the resignation of
all their children under sixteen years of age.
Section XVIII. — Revisions.
Art. 62. — Each and every article of this contract may be revised
in General Assembly ; but the revision of any article shall not be
valid unless the following rules shall have been strictly adhered to :
A. The unanimous consent by vote is requisite to revise the fol-
lowing enumerated Articles : I, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, — 30, 31, 32, 33, 34,
35,-42, 43, 44, 45, 46, 47, 43, 49, and 50.
2l6 1CARIA.
B. The consent by vote of fully nine tenths of the members hav-
ing voting privilege is requisite to revise the following enumerated
Articles : 8, 9,-20, 21, 22, 23,-39,-53, 54, 55, 56, 57, 58, 59, 60,
61, 62.
C. The consent by vote of three fourths of the members having
voting privilege is requisite to revise the following enumerated
Articles : 10, 11, 12, 13, 14, 15, 16, 17, 18, 19, — 24, 25, 26, 27, 28,
29,-36, 37, 38,-40, 41.
D. The consent by vote of nine tenths of the members is requisite
to revise Articles 51 and 52 ; but after a period of three years, from
the day of recording of this contract, Articles 51 and 52 shall be re-
visable by a majority of three fourths of the members having voting
privilege.
INDEX.
Almanac (Icarian), 18.
Amana Community, 178.
American Socialist, 99.
Amusements, 51, 52, 118.
Arbitration, 104, 108.
Baboeuf, 4, 15.
Babouvism, 18.
Barbes, 18.
Bauer,^ Fritz, 67.
Bee, Emile, 169.
Bettannier, E. F., 161.
Blanc, Louis, 30.
Blanqui, 18.
Booth's " St. -Simon and St.-Si-
monism," 166.
Briggs, Dr., 84.
Brisbane, Albert, 179.
Brook Farm, 22, 176.
Buonarotti, II, 15.
Bureau, Icarian, at Paris, 56, 69,
75-
Cabet, Etienne, early career, 6 ;
in political life, 7 ; in exile, 8 ;
a communist, 10 ; his " Voyage
en Icarie," 10-17 J colonization
scheme, 19-25 ; reaches Amer-
ica, 43 ; quarrel with majority,
at Nauvoo, 53-58 ; death, 59 ;
character, and writings, 60-63.
Cabet, Madame, 56.
California, 134, 136, 137 et seq.
Campanella, 11, 15.
Carbonari, 6.
Cavaignac, 42.
Channing, 22.
Charters in Illinois, 54, 59, 77,
107.
Charters in Iowa, 77, 104, 107,
127.
Cheltenham, 67-72.
Chevalier, M. E., 61.
Chicago, 47.
Christianity, 16, 18, 19.
Clothing, 116, 150.
Cloverdale, 139.
Communist, The, 84, 179.
Constitution at Nauvoo, 53-55.
Constitution of " New Icaria,"
122, 189.
Constitution of "Young Icaria,"
129.
Constitution of " Icaria-Speranza,"
145-150.
Corning (Iowa), 78, 114.
Creston (Iowa), 78.
Dana, 22.
Dehay, Adam, 139, 168.
De 1' Eure, Dupont, 6.
Democratic Party, 120.
Dereure, S., 166.
"Donation, Act of," 128, 133, 148.
Ely, Professor R. T., "French
and German Socialism," 30.
Encyclopedists, French, 4.
Esperanza Community, 185.
Fathers of the Church, 15.
Favard, P. J., 37, 161.
217
218
INDEX.
Fenelon, II, 15.
Florida, 134, 135.
Fourier, 15.
Fourierism, 18, 156, 177, 178.
French Revolution, 4, 5.
Frey, William, 182.
Friendship Community, 180, 181.
Fugier, Emile, 162.
Fuller, Margaret, 22.
Gardens ("les petits jardins "),
100-2.
Gaskin, J. W., 85.
Gauvain, Antoine von, 162.
George, Henry, 15.
Gerard, Jean Baptiste, 56, 76,
158-61.
Gracchi, 15.
Greeley, Horace, 179.
Greenback Party, 94, 120.
Grotius, 15.
Guizot, 7.
Harrington, .15.
Hawthorne, 22.
Hinds' " American Communities,"
87.
Hinds, William Alfred, 85.
Hobbes, 15.
Homestead Law, 80.
Humanitarian School, 167.
" Icaria-Speranza Commune," 137
-152.
Intercommunal Organization, 182.
Internationalists, 98, 163, 174.
Iowa, 52, 58, 77. '
Jacotot, 6.
44 Jeune Icarie," 132.
Jones, Lloyd, 61.
Joslin, Earl, 185.
Kansas, 182, 185.
Labor Party, 174.
Labor-premiums, 148.
Lacombe, " Etudes sur les Social-
istes," 10.
Lafitte, 7.
LaForgue, J., 165.
Lamarque, Funeral of, 7.
Lamartine, 30, 42.
Ledru-Rollin, 30.
Leroux, Jules, 139, 166-7.
Leroux, Jules (fils), 139.
Leroux, Pierre, 61, 144, 166.
Leroux, Pierre, (fils), 139.
" L Etoile des Pauvres et des
Souffrants" 168.
Levy, Charles, 165.
Liberal Community, 180.
Libraries, 51, 118.
L' Observateur, 161.
Locke, John, 15.
Longevity, 115.
Longley, Alexander, 178.
Louis Philippe, 7, 8.
Lycurgus, 15.
Manuel, 6.
Marat, 4.
Marchand, Alexis A., 76, 113, 120.
Marchand, Alexis (fils) 158.
Marriage, 15, 119, 157, 180.
Mercadier, 161.
Mexico, 22.
Moorhead, S. W., 121.
More, Sir Thomas, 10, 11, 15.
Morelly, 15.
Mormons, 47.
Mormon Temple at Nauvoo, 49.
Mourot, Eugene, 162.
Mutual Aid Community, 178, 181.
Napoleon, Louis, 42.
National Workshops in France, 30.
Nauvoo, 47 et seq, 77.
Nebraska, 71.
New Harmony, 21.
INDEX.
219
New Icarian Community, 113-24.
New Odessa Community, 183.
New Orleans, 29, 31, 37, 40, 43.
Nordhoff's "Communistic Socie-
ties," 50.
North American Phalanx, 179.
Noyes' "American Socialisms,"
179.
Oneida Perfectionists, 177.
Owenism, 176.
Owen, Richard, 61.
Owen, Robert, 11, 15, 21, 22.
Pacific Sentinel, 140.
Panic of 1857, 76.
Panic of 1873, 94.
Paris Commune, 94.
Party Spirit, 58, 92.
Peron, Emile, 99, 102, 130, 150,
164.
Peters Company, 23, 34, 37.
Piquenard, A., 31, 156,
" Plan Financier," 41.
Plato, 15.
Plato's Republic, 10.
Plutarch, 15.
Populaire (newspaper), 18-25, 39»
41.
" Popular History of the French
Revolutions," by Cabet, 18.
Popular Tribune, 155.
Principia Community, 181.
Progressive Community, 182.
Propaganda, 69, 93, 131.
Pythagoras. 15.
"Quelques Verite's," 160.
Rappists, 21.
Raynaud, Charles, 161.
Red River, 23.
Religion, 118.
Republican Party, 120.
Reunion Community, 179.
Revolution, of 1789,4, 5.
Revolution of 1830, 5, jt 14.
Revolution of 1848, 5, 29.
" Revue Icarienne," 76, 122, 158.
Reybaud, " Socialistes Modernes,"
11.
Rheims, Levi de, 32.
Riots of 1877, 94.
Ripley, George, 22.
Robespierre, 4.
Roumain, N. T., 185.
Rousseau, 4, 15.
Saint-Louis, 59, 67.
Saint-Simon, 15.
Saint-Simonism, 18, 156, 166.
Sand, George, 167.
Sargant's, " Robert Owen," 23
Sauva, A., 9, 71, 72, 99, 102. 163.
Schools, 50, 51, 69, 119.
Sears, Charles, 179.
Second French Republic, 30.
Shakers, 177.
Shreveport, 31, 32, 37.
Smith, Joseph, 47.
" Social Contract," 24, 53.
Socrates, 15.
"Speranza," 144, 167.
Sulphur Prairie. 32.
Tanguy, A., 165.
Texas, 22, 23, 29 et seq.
Thiers, 7.
Voltaire, 4.
" Voyage en Icarie," 10-17.
War of the Rebellion, 81.
Western Magazine, 121.
Withdrawal, 54, 128, 131, 198.
Young, Brigham, 47.
Zoarite Community, 21.
IMPORTANT
FORTHCOMING PUBLICATIONS.
AMERICAN ORATIONS. From the colonial period to the present
time, selected as specimens of Eloquence, and with special reference to
their value in throwing light upon the more important epochs and
issues of American History. Edited, with introductions and notes, by
Alexander Johnston, Professor of Jurisprudence and Political
Economy, College of New Jersey. Three volumes, i6mo, uniform
with " Prose Masterpieces."
BRITISH ORATIONS. A selection of the more important and repre-
sentative Political Addresses of the past century. Edited, with intro-
ductions and notes, by Henry K. Adams, Professor of History in the
University of Michigan. Three volumes, i6mo, uniform with " Amer-
ican Orations."
These sets are expected to prove of special service to students, while full of
interest to the general reader.
THE COMPLETE WORKS OF ALEXANDER HAMILTON.
Including his Contributions to the " Federalist." Edited, with intro-
duction and notes, by Henry Cabot Lodge. Seven volumes, large
octavo, handsomely printed from type, with two portraits engraved on
steel, $35. Edition limited to 500 copies.
THE NUTSHELL SERIES. A Gathering of the Best Thoughts of
the Best Writers. Edited by Helen Kendrick Johnson, and
arranged under the following heads : Wisdom, Philosophy, Sentiment,
Epigrams and Epitaphs, Wit and Humor. Six volumes, oblong 32mo.
Uniquely printed.
" I could be bounded in a nutshell.'*— Hamlet.
G. P. PUTNAM'S SONS, NEW YORK.
RECENT ISSUES.
PROSE MASTERPIECES FROM MODERN ESSA'! 3TS.
Comprising single specimen essays from Irving, Leigh Hunt, Lamb,
De Quincey, Landor, Sydney Smith, Thackeray, Emerson, Arnold,
Morley, Helps, Kingsley, Ruskin, Lowell, Carlyle, Macaulay, Froude,
Freeman, Gladstone, Newman, Leslie Stephen. These essays have
been selected with reference to presenting specimens of the method of
thought and the literary style of their several writers, and also for the
purpose of putting into convenient shape for direct comparison the
treatment given by such writers to similar subjects.
Such of the essays as are copyright have been included in the collec-
tion through the courtesy of their several authors and publishers.
The Mutability of Literature, by Irving ; The World of Books, by Hunt ; Imper-
fect Sympathies, by Lamb ; Conversation, by De Quincey ; Petition of the Thugs, by
Landor : Benefits of Parliament, by Landor ; Fallacies, by Smith ; On a Certain Con-
descension in Foreigners, by Lowell ; On History, by Carlyle ; History, by Macaulay;
The Science of History, by Froude ; Nil Nisi Bonum, by Thackeray ; Compensation,
by Emerson ; Sweetness and Light, by Arnold ; Popular Culture, by Morley ; Art of
Living with Others, by Helps ; My Winter Garden, by Kingsley ; Work, by Ruskin ;
Race and Language, by Freeman ; Kin Beyond Sea, by Gladstone ; Private Judg-
ment, by Newman ; An Apology for Plain Speaking, by Stephen.
3 vols., 1 6mo, bevelled boards, in box, each .... $1.25
The same in extra cloth, gilt top, with cloth box . . . 4.50
The same in Russia-leather binding and case, round corners, red
edges $10.00
The same, large-paper edition, with portraits, cloth extra, gilt top, rough
edges $7-5°
" Three charming little volumes, showing admirable judgment on the part of the
editor." — Chicago Tribune.
" A most admirable collection, which presents not only specimens of the best Eng-
lish style, but the methods of thought and characteristic modes of expression of the
several writers." — Magazine of A merican History.
HALF A CENTURY OF ENGLISH HISTORY. Pictorially
presented in a series of 147 cartoons selected from the gallery of Mr.
Punch, and describing the careers and achievements of Peel, Palmerston,
Russell, Cobden, Bright, Derby, Salisbury, Disraeli, and Gladstone.
i2mo $1.25
This work of Doyle, Leech, and Tenniel has value as a robust and characteristic
expression of English humor, as reflecting the changing phases of the political thought
of middle-class England, and as a faithful, though humorous* record of the essential
characteristics and achievements of the men who for the past fifty years have ruled the
British Empire.
G. P. PUTNAM'S SONS, NEW YORK.
K