Skip to main content

Full text of "November Meeting. Letter from Charles J. Hoadly; Account of Portrait of Sir William Phipps; Letter from Hon. Hugh Blair Grigsby"

See other formats


Early Journal Content on JSTOR, Free to Anyone in the World 

This article is one of nearly 500,000 scholarly works digitized and made freely available to everyone in 
the world by JSTOR. 

Known as the Early Journal Content, this set of works include research articles, news, letters, and other 
writings published in more than 200 of the oldest leading academic journals. The works date from the 
mid-seventeenth to the early twentieth centuries. 

We encourage people to read and share the Early Journal Content openly and to tell others that this 
resource exists. People may post this content online or redistribute in any way for non-commercial 

Read more about Early Journal Content at 
journal-content . 

JSTOR is a digital library of academic journals, books, and primary source objects. JSTOR helps people 
discover, use, and build upon a wide range of content through a powerful research and teaching 
platform, and preserves this content for future generations. JSTOR is part of ITHAKA, a not-for-profit 
organization that also includes Ithaka S+R and Portico. For more information about JSTOR, please 



A stated meeting was held on Thursday, November 10th, at 
11 o'clock, a.m., the President in the chair. 

The record of the preceding meeting was read. 

The Librarian read his list of donors for the past month. 

The Corresponding Seoretary read a letter of acceptance 
from Mr. C. J. Hoadly, of Hartford. 

The President read the following letter from Mr. Hoadly : — 

Hartford, Nov. 2, 1870. 
Hon. Kobebt C. Winthrop, Boston. 

Dear Sir, — I have directed Mr. S. S. Crosby, of 240 Washington 
Street, to present to the Massachusetts Historical Society a view of the 
once famous Newgate of Connecticut, taken from an old copper-plate, 
now in the possession of Mr. Samuel Hubbard, of this city. When 
the plate was engraved, or by whom, I am unable to say ; but it must 
have been done before 1802, because in that year the picket fence was 
replaced by a stone wall. 

I visited Newgate last summer. The building in the centre still 
exists, but enlarged, and is occupied as a dwelling. There is a range of 
buildings on the south and west sides of the enclosure, which are not 
represented in the plan. Perhaps they were not built when the plate 
was cut. 

The plate seems to be little known. I have conversed with several 
aged persons brought up in Simsbury and Granby, near the prison, 
who had never seen nor heard of it. Neither Noah A. Phelps nor 
R. H. Phelps, — both of whom have published histories of Newgate, — 
seem to have been aware of the existence of this view, for it is not 
mentioned in their books. . . . 

Very respectfully yours, &c, 

Charles J. Hoadly. 

He also communicated, from Count A. de Circourt, a copy 
of his interesting review of Dean Stanley's Memorials of Can- 
terbury, as originally printed in the " Revue Brittanique." 


Our associate, Dr. Dexter, presented a copy of a book, of 
which he is the author, entitled " The Church Polity of the 
Pilgrims, the Polity of the New Testament." 

The President read a letter from our associate, John Foster 
Kirk, the author of " Charles the Bold," saying that he had 
changed his place of residence to Philadelphia, and therefore 
had ceased to be a member of the Society. 

The President announced a new number of Proceedings 
(No. VII.), embracing the transactions of the Society for the 
months of June, July, August, and September, of this year. 

He also called attention to a Parliamentary Blue Book, 
presented to him by Mr. Richard Almack, of Long Melford, 
County Suffolk, being the " First Report of the Royal Com- 
mission on Historical Manuscripts," appointed to search for 
documents in possession of private persons. 

Mr. George T. Davis gave an account, of the recent dis- 
covery of an original portrait of Sir William Phipps, in pos- 
session of a family in Boston : — 

The discovery was the result of inquiries instituted by a 
native of Maine, Mr. Samuel J. Bridge, who was desirous of 
obtaining such a portrait, or a copy of it, for the State House 
at Augusta. Inquiries made through our Minister, of the 
Mulgrave family in England, in the mistaken idea that Sir 
William was connected with that family, were of course unsuc- 
cessful. A communication, published in a Portland paper, 
brought out the fact that a portrait, said to be of Sir William, 
was in the possession of a family of the name of Blackstone, 
formerly resident in Portland, and now in Boston, tracing its 
descent to Danfortk Phipps, who was born in 1711, and of 
whom the tradition is that he was a relation of Sir William. 

The owners of the portrait have a family Bible, printed in 
1710, containing the usual family records, and showing the 
following facts: — 


1. Their mother, Mrs. Lois Blackstone, born 1790, died 
in 1866. 

2. Her mother, Mrs. Elizabeth Berry, was a Blackstone, 
born in 1764, died in 1846. 

3. Her mother, Elinor Phipps, daughter of Danforth Phipps, 
born in 1733, died in 1807. 

Their grandmother, Mrs. Berry, always kept this picture 
carefully as a portrait of Sir William, and as a picture coming 
by family descent. 

It would seem then that the tradition is fairly enough traced 
to information received from Elinor Phipps, and so to a point 
of time within forty or fifty years of the date of Sir William's 
death in 1695. 

An examination of the portrait itself tends to confirm the 
accuracy of the tradition. It represents a man about forty 
years of age, with periwig, bright armor on the arms and 
shoulders, and embroidered vest ; giving the idea of a combi- 
nation of military and civic position. It is very well executed, 
having on the back the name of Plaisted, which is probably 
the name of the artist. 

The portrait is to be disposed of; and it is to be hoped that 
Mr. Bridge will succeed in his patriotic plan of obtaining a 
copy for the State House at Augusta, and that the picture itself 
will fall into the hands of some public body. 

The President read the following letter from our Corres- 
ponding Member, the Hon. Hugh B. Grigsby, containing more 
especially an account of persons of his acquaintance who had 
attained the age of one hundred years and more : — 

Edgehill, neak Chaklotte C. H., Virginia, 
October 17, 1870. 

My dear Mb. Winthrop: 

The tributes of your Society to the memory of the late John 
Pendleton Kennedy came duly to hand, and were welcome to me on 
many accounts. I followed your outline of his life very attentively, as 


I am almost old enough to remember his entire career ; and as I went 
along with you, I was struck with the reflection, which has doubtless 
often occurred to you, how contemporaneously all the events of a man's 
life, however separated they may be by the lapse of years when he is 
living, appear when he is dead, and constitute a symmetry of character, 
which our passions or interests or heedlessness prevent us from seeing 
while he is living and moving in our midst. I did not know him per- 
sonally, but was aware of his connection with our Pendletons of Vir- 
ginia. His mother's brother, the late Philip C. Pendleton, who died 
in 1863 or 1864, at the age of eighty odd, was a political associate of 
mine more than forty years ago ; and in his latter days, of his own 
accord, invited a correspondence with me, which was continued until our 
recent troubles put an end to it. If your friend Kennedy took after 
the Pendletons, he must have been a tall and well-proportioned man. 
The Kennedys are of a stouter stature and more bulky. The man who 
first impressed immortality on the name of Pendleton, was Edmund, 
who was one of our members of the first Congress, was the chairman 
of the Committee of Safety while Virginia was passing from the Colony 
to the Commonwealth, was the president of the Virginia Federal Con- 
vention of 1788, and was president of our High Court of Appeals, — 
a great and venerable name indeed, in whose shadow repose some of 
the most endearing recollections of our honored past. I read with 
interest the remarks of Professor Lowell and of Mr. Hillard, and the 
letter of Dr. Holmes, and found much food for thought in what they 
said. I thank you again for your kindness in sending to me these 
memorials of your friend. 

In the " Proceedings " of April of the present year, you refer to a 
discussion in the Society, held a year or two ago, respecting persons 
who are said to have reached one hundred years and more ; and you 
mention the case of Captain Lahrbush, who has entered his 105 th year. 
I have the honor of knowing the old gentleman, whom I met at the 
residence of Admiral Farragut in June, 1867, and with whom I held a 
pleasant conversation. As I had never before seen any one above a 
hundred years old, I determined to be very observant of every thing 
that occurred. He is a very remarkable man, possessing the faculties 
of his mind and body in apparent vigor, and engaging with zest in cur- 
rent talk. I shaped my conversation in his presence purposely to draw 
him out, and to watch the operations of his mind ; and I indulged in 
some playful sallies ; and I saw that he was as fully abreast of the scene, 
and had as clear and as ready an appreciation of the point or play of 


the moment, as any of the young and brilliant persons who were pres- 
ent. It is, I believe, no secret with him or with his friends, that even 
in his latter years he used opium in very large quantities, and that 
from conscientious scruples he resolved to discontinue its use; but, 
finding that his health gave way, and that he would certainly die if he 
abstained from it altogether, he gradually resumed the use of it, and 
ascertained the exact amount which was necessary to sustain him ; and 
he has continued to use daily this amount, which is very considerable, 
but which I cannot recall, without increase or diminution to the present 
day. He is a gentleman of the old school in more senses than one ; 
dresses with neatness and taste, and has a well -formed, intellectual, and 
much younger face than his years would lead you to expect. He is 
stout, and rather below than above the middle size, and has a very 
broad chest, — characteristics which, in my experience, usually attach 
to persons who possess great vigor and an erect posture in extreme old 
age. I have said that he was of the old school in his breeding. One 
instance will somewhat illustrate this remark : when I rose to take 
leave of him, knowing that the effort to rise from the chair was difficult 
and often painful to very old people, I approached him so nearly as 
almost to touch his knees with mine, in order to prevent his rising ; but 
the old gentleman was not so easily satisfied ; for he grasped my hand, 
and rose by its aid to his feet, and then, and not till then, would he bid 
me farewell, which he did, I must add, not only with a cordial squeeze, 
but in some very kind and courteous words. His name is not spelt 
quite correctly in the " Proceedings." It is " F. Lahrbush," which I 
copy from a letter of his now before me. This letter is addressed to a 
lady whose friendship he valued highly, was written in October, 1867, 
and concludes with these words: "Now, my dear lady, my faithful 
friend, I pray God to have you in His holy keeping, and trusting on 
the continuance of your kind good-will and valued friendship, I am, 
dear lady, my kind Christian friend, yours till death." 

You are aware that as people grow old, they are apt to write smaller 
and smaller. Such was the case with Mr. Jefferson and Mr. Madison 
and Governor Tazewell ; and, though not old myself, I find such is my 
case, without an effort to the contrary. But the handwriting of 
Captain Lahrbush is large, most distinct, and entirely free from 

I now proceed to give you an account of a centenarian, a neighbor 
of mine, Mr. George Foster, who resides about ten miles from my 
house, but whom, though I have frequently sent kind messages to him, 


I had never seen until the 28th of May last, when I made him a special 
visit. But, as it occurred to me to report his case to you, I determined 
to make him another visit, to look into his case minutely, and to con- 
sult all available authorities ; and on Friday last I performed my pur- 
pose. I rode to Keysville, and despatched my servant to the house of Mr. 
James A. Foster, the oldest son of the centenarian, who resides four or 
five miles from his father, with a request that he would accompany me 
on a visit to the old gentleman. He soon arrived, and we set out on 
foot for his father's house. As Mr. Foster, Jr., was sixty-five years 
old, I offered him my horse ; but he said that, as the way was on the 
railway bed, it was safer to go on foot, and we accordingly made our 
jaunt of three miles in a little while, in full conversation about his 
father. When we approached the house, we saw the old gentleman 
looking into his corn-crib, which was sixty or seventy yards distant 
from his dwelling, at a load of very fine corn which had just been 
deposited in it. He received us cordially, and invited us into the 
house ; and by the aid of my arm and his staff, he made his way with- 
out difficulty or fatigue. When we reached the narrow steps of his 
porch, he withdrew his arm from mine, and, dropping his cane, he 
caught hold of the rail on either side of the steps ; and though he was 
somewhat slow in his movement, he reached the platform unaided, 
without any serious exertion of his strength. His daughters, Mrs. 
Hudson, who was seventy-six on the 6th instant, and Miss Eliza H. 
Foster, who was fifty-four in July last, received us kindly, and we were 
all soon seated, including the old man and his son, around the capacious 
fireplace. I introduced the topic of the Revolution of 1776, and men- 
tioned, among other things, that the British had never set foot in the 
County of Charlotte. Mr. Foster, who was born on the 22d of May, 
1768, and was eight years old at the Declaration of Independence, 
observed that he remembered very well when the Delaware Blues 
came up and encamped on the hill in Mr. Crawford's present plantation, 
on which his father then lived. I told him that, although I had con- 
versed with several citizens of the county who had served in the war, 
and who were older than himself at the date of that event, I had never 
heard that fact before ; but that I knew a detachment of French sol- 
diers bad encamped at the Court House. He said that he remembered 
the arrival of the French very well, — that they remained some weeks 
in the country, — but that the Delaware Blues encamped for a day or 
two only. Let me add that these forces were sent from the coast to aid 
General Greene, when pressed by Cornwallis, who was stopped south 


of the Dan, by a fresh in that stream, and were afterwards recalled. 
Thus the recollection of Mr. Foster has saved a waif from the past, 
which otherwise would have been lost for ever. As Mr. Foster was 
born in 1768, he was thirteen in 1781 ; and in answer to my inquiries, 
he observed that he remembered distinctly — to use his own words — 
" when Washington whipped Cornwallis at York." I also tested his 
recollection of several prominent characters, such as John Blair Smith, 
who was second president of Hampden Sidney College, and a leading 
clergyman in all this region of country, from 1779 to 1790, when he 
removed to Philadelphia, and whose influence is still felt among us, 
and learned from Mr. Foster that he could recall him distinctly, and 
had heard him preach. Having thus satisfied myself of his knowledge 
of men and things from 1778 to 1790, 1 asked his son to let me look 
at the family Bible. One of the ladies instantly went into the next 
room, and brought out the venerable book, which was a quarto, and 
was printed in Edinburgh in 1785. I turned to the births, and found 
the following record, which I copy entire : — 

" George Foster, son of Josiah and Elizabeth Foster, was born May 22, 1768 ; 
and Sally, his wife, was born the 16th of October, 1773 (and died July 12, 1858, 
aged 85). 

1. Rebecca G. Foster was born 23d of September, 1792. 

2. Amy J. Foster was born October 6, 1794 (Mrs. Hudson, who was present). 

3. Susan D. Foster was born April 2, 1801. 

4. Mary I. Foster was born Nor. 5, 1803. 

5. James A. Foster was born April 30, 1806 (was present at my interview). 

6. Martha A. Foster was born Sept. 30, 1808. 

7. Adrian W. Foster was born March 2, 1811. 

8. George I. Foster was born Aug. 8, 1813. 

9. Eliza H. Foster was born July 15, 1816 (was present at my interview). 
10. Sarah Foster was born March 24, 1819." 

This Bible was presented to Mr. Foster by his wife's father on his 
marriage in 1791, and has been in constant use ever since. The first 
four or five entries were made in pale ink, and are indistinct, but may 
be read ; and many years ago Mr. Foster copied the whole in darker 
ink on the reverse side of the leaf. You perceive that I had this inter- 
view in the presence of three of the children of Mr. Foster, whose ages 
were seventy-six, sixty-five, and fifty-four, and who have been for many 
years consistent members of the church, and of great worth in their 
neighborhood. I will also state that Mr. Foster has lived an active, 
temperate, and industrious life, on the land given him by his father on 
his marriage ; that he has been ever esteemed a man of integrity and 



piety, having been a member of the Baptist Church for seventy years ; 
and that his daughters and son, who were present, have been members 
of the same communion from their earliest life. 

The physique of Mr. Foster differs very much from that of Captain 
Lahrbush. He is five feet ten, tall and thin, and stoops considerably, 
walking and sitting, while the Captain is short, and as straight as an 
arrow. Mr. F. has lost his teeth within a few years past ; his eyes are 
gray, and the lids are drawn closely when he looks about him. He has 
a benignant smile, and relishes any amusing thing uttered in his pres- 
ence. He has had slight bilious complaints occasionally ; but he says 
that he never has been dangerously ill since he had "the fever" in 
1794. He has no present organic disease, and no bad habits, and 
may live for years to come. He sleeps well, enjoys his food, and moves 
freely about the house and yard without assistance. "While I was chat- 
ting with the ladies, he arose quite briskly from his chair, walked into 
another room, filled his pipe, and, resuming his seat, lighted his tobacco, 
and enjoyed a pleasing smoke ; and when he had done, he knocked 
away the ashes very carefully, and put his pipe in his pocket. Neither 
Ralph nor Ebenezer Erskine, who wrote those fine stanzas on tobacco, 
and loved a pipe, could have done the thing more graciously. 

In addition to what I have already written, I will give what in the 
Scotch law are called adminicula testimonii, — adminicles of testimony, 
— or some odds and ends that tend to establish Mr. Foster's age, apart 
from his family records. On the wall of his front room is a large 
sampler, worked by the needle, and containing moral sentences and 
striking dates ; and among the latter is this : " George Foster, born 
May 22, 1768." Now this sampler was worked by a grandchild of 
the patriarch more than twenty years ago, when he was not over 80, 
which is not deemed remarkable in this county, as I may presently 

George C. Smith, Esq., is aged about fifty-five, has for thirty years 
been a member of the Baptist Church, has attended the same church 
with Mr. Foster since 1843, a space of twenty-seven years, and watched 
his progress to ninety, and to his present age of one hundred and two. 

"William Cardwell, Esq., will be seventy-one on the 7th of November 
next ; was born, and has always lived, within nine miles of Mr. Foster ; 
has known Mr. F. from his own childhood ; recollects Mr. F. as a 
middle-aged man, when he could first recall him; remembers his 
arrival at the age of ninety, and has chronicled his years to the present 


But the strongest testimony, apart from records, is that of Mrs. Lucy 
Bailey, who resides within one mile of Mr. Foster ; is his relative, has 
been a member of the church for over sixty years, and is now eighty- 
seven years old, retaining her faculties in as great a degree as has, per- 
haps, been seen in our time. She states that she has known Mr. Foster 
all her life, that she has always known his age, and that from her own 
observation alone she knows that he cannot be less than one hundred 
and two years old. 

I can also state that I have resided within ten miles of Mr. Foster 
for thirty years, that I have always known him as an extremely aged 
man, that I remember his arrival at ninety, and at one hundred, and 
that I have often sent kind messages to him. 

Mr. Foster, Jr., mentioned a fact concerning his father, which may 
be sustained by the public records. He says that his father was 
draughted into the militia, and sent to Norfolk in March, 1813 ; and 
that he became forty-five, or muster-free, on the 22d of May following, 
and returned home. Add the interval from 1813 to 1870, and we 
have the one hundred and two years. 

When I speak of distance, as, for instance, of nine miles, I refer to 
the state of facts with us, and not with you. Nine miles with us may 
often be measured by four or five estates, that is, by the intervention 
of not more than four or five farmers. I live within a mile and a 
quarter of my nearest neighbor, because the sites of our dwellings are 
within that distance ; but if my neighbor had built on the western 
extremity of his land, and I on the eastern extremity of the land on 
which I live, there would have been an interval of six miles be- 
tween us. 

Excuse this long epistle, and believe me, 

Ever truly yours, 

Htigh Blair Grigsbt. 
To the Hon. Kobekt C. Winthrop, Boston.