Skip to main content

Full text of "The larva and pupa of the caddisfly genus Setodes in North America (Trichoptera: Leptoceridae)"

See other formats


%u 


fc/ty, 


^ 


^ 


Digitized  by  the  Internet  Archive 

in  2012  with  funding  from 

Royal  Ontario  Museum 


http://archive.org/details/larvapupaofcaddiOOmerr 


ROM 


Life  Sciences 
Occasional  Papers 


Royal  Ontario  Museum 
November  26,  1971 


No.  19 


The  Larva  and  Pupa  of  the 

Caddisfly  Genus  Setodes  in  North  America 

(Trichoptera:  Leptoceridae) 


by  Dorothy  Merrill1  and  Glenn  B.  Wiggins2 

Among  the  leptocerid  caddisflies  of  North 
America  there  are  many  species  which  are 
not  known  in  the  larval  stage.  All  but  one 
of  the  genera,  however,  contain  a  sufficient 
number  of  species  for  which  larva-pupa- 
adult  associations  have  been  established  to 
permit  the  construction  of  fairly  reliable 
generic  keys  to  the  immature  stages,  such  as 
those  by  Ross  (1944,  1959).  The  genus 
Setodes  is  the  exception.  For  none  of  the 
Nearctic  species  have  immature  and  mature 
forms  been  associated.  In  Ross'  keys  to  the 
genera  of  leptocerid  larvae,  specimens  char- 
acterized chiefly  by  strongly  developed  sclero- 
tized  plates  on  the  caudal  face  of  the  anal 
prolegs  were  tentatively  assigned  to  Setodes, 
because  these  unusual  larvae  clearly  do  not 
fit  readily  into  any  of  the  other  North  Ameri- 
can genera. 

Descriptions  of  Setodes  larvae  in  Europe 
in  recent  years  have  left  little  doubt  that 
Ross'  tentative  assignment  was  correct:  Se- 
todes hungarica  Ulmer  (Botosaneanu,  1959); 
Setodes  punctata  Fabricius  (Botosaneanu 
and  Sykora,  1963).  Larvae  of  both  species 
were  associated  with  mature  pupae,  and 
both  have  the  sclerotized  plates  on  the  caudal 
face  of  the  anal  prolegs  as  illustrated  by 
Ross  {op.  cit.).  The  larva  of  a  third  Euro- 
pean species  was  described  by  Murgoci 
(1959);  the  identity  is  not  clear,  but  Boto- 


CO 

111-^^— i 

1> 

cr — 

tr 

CM 

m             - 

h- 

CO 

CM 

in           — 

(O 

5= 

m 

u            - 

o 

2                   - 

(£> 

h- 

-J                ~ 

U 

co 

saneanu  and  Sykora  (1963)  suggested  that 
this  is  the  larva  of  S.  argentipunctella  Mc- 
lachlan.  Hickin  (1967)  provided  a  descrip- 
tion of  the  larva  of  S.  argentipunctella,  but 
details  of  the  plates  of  the  anal  prolegs  were 
not  given.  Illustrations  of  the  larva  of  a 
Japanese  species  assigned  to  Setodes  by 
Akagi  (1957)  show  that  similar  larval 
characteristics  occur  in  the  Asian  fauna. 

Knowledge  concerning  the  comparative 
morphology  of  larval  and  pupal  stages  of 
Setodes  from  various  parts  of  the  world  has, 
then,  been  steadily  accumulating,  although 
few  observations  have  been  offered  on  the 
biology  of  the  group.  For  the  North  Ameri- 
can fauna  nothing  has  been  added  since  the 
original  tentative  allocation  of  these  larvae 
to  Setodes  by  Ross  in  1944.  In  North 
America,  six  species  are  known,  and  only 
from  the  adult  stage.  These  are  confined  to 
the  eastern  half  of  the  continent,  extending 
as  far  west  as  Oklahoma:  Setodes  incerta 
(Walker),  S.  stehri  (Ross),  S.  oxapia 
(Ross),  5.  guttata  (Banks),  S.  oligia  (Ross), 
and  S.  epicampes  Edwards. 

In  the  summer  of  1969,  larvae  possessing 
the  sclerotized  anal  plates  were  collected  in 
Michigan  (by  D.M.).  Rearing  them  to  the 
adult  stage  established  that  the  species  was 
Setodes  incerta  (Walker).  Additional  obser- 
vations were  made  in  the  summer  of  1970. 


1.  The  University  of  Michigan  Biological  Station,  Pellston,  Michigan. 
Present  address:  Western  College,  Oxford,  Ohio,  45056. 

2.  Department  of  Entomology  and  Invertebrate  Zoology,  Royal  Ontario  Museum. 


Based  upon  that  association,  this  paper 
offers  the  first  detailed  information  on  the 
morphology  of  the  larva  and  pupa  of  this 
genus  in  North  America  (by  G.B.W.),  and 
on  the  behaviour  of  the  larva  as  well  (by 
D.M.).  Diagnostic  genitalic  characters  for 
the  female  of  S.  incerta  were  not  previously 
known  and  are  illustrated.  The  larva  of 
another  species  of  Setodes  from  South  Caro- 
lina is  briefly  characterized,  although  no 
specific  association  has  yet  been  established 
for  it. 

The  larvae  of  S.  incerta  were  collected  in 
the  Ocqueoc  River,  near  the  northern  tip  of 
Michigan's  lower  peninsula,  in  a  region  of 
strong  current,  upstream  from  Ocqueoc 
Falls.  The  initial  collection  was  made  by 
examining  rocks  taken  from  a  depth  of  less 
than  2  feet.  Laboratory  observations  indi- 
cated that  the  larvae  were  burrowers,  and 
in  subsequent  collecting,  screening  of  sand 
from  the  lee  of  rocks  provided  a  larger 
number  of  larvae  in  a  given  time. 

After  transportation  to  a  laboratory  at  the 
University  of  Michigan  Biological  Station, 
the  animals  were  maintained  in  individual 
stender  dishes,  mostly  without  aeration,  at 
room  temperature  ( 20-25  °C).  Plant  mate- 
rial was  present  in  all  containers  and  the 
water  was  changed  every  2  or  3  days. 

Enchytraeid  worms  were  provided  daily 
as  food  until  the  animals  closed  their  cases 
for  pupation.  At  that  time  the  cases  were 
transferred  to  clean  stender  dishes  until  the 
larval  sclerites  were  extruded  by  the  pupa. 
The  sclerites  were  then  placed  in  labelled 
vials  and  the  pupal  cases  transferred  to  rear- 
ing cages  for  capture  of  adults  upon  emer- 
gence. Some  of  the  insects  were  preserved 
in  the  larval  and  pupal  stages  to  provide 
adequate  material  for  morphological  study. 

Larval  behaviour  was  observed  daily,  and 
some  aspects  were  recorded  on  motion  pic- 
ture film,  using  Kodak  Double-X  negative 
film  in  a  Bolex  H-16  Rex  3  camera.  With 
the  aid  of  extension  tubes  on  a  Switar  25  mm 
lens,  magnifications  of  1  to  2.4  were  ob- 
tained. The  illustrations  of  larval  behaviour 
(Fig.   15)  were  printed  from  this  film. 

Specimens  are  deposited  in  the  collections 
of  the  Department  of  Entomology  and  In- 
vertebrate Zoology,  Royal  Ontario  Museum. 


Setodes  incerta  (Walker) 

Leptocerus  incertus  Walker  1852,  p.  71. 

Setodes  incerta  McLachlan    1863,  p.    158, 

163. 

Setodes  vernalis  Betten  1934,  p.  277,  pi.  36, 

figs.  7-9. 

Setodes  incerta  Betten   and   Mosely    1940, 

p.  69,  fig.  33. 

Setodes  incerta  Ross  1944,  p.  302,  figs.  737 

(S.  vernalis),  872. 

larva — (Figs.  1,  2,  8-11).  Full-grown 
larva  5-6  mm  in  length,  uniformly  whitish 
in  overall  colour,  sclerotized  portions  pale 
yellow,  affording  little  contrast  in  colour 
with  the  unsclerotized  portions.  Head  with- 
out contrasting  colour  pattern,  and  with 
several  structures  typical  for  the  Mystacidini: 
gular  sclerite  rectangular,  extending  posterad 
to  occipital  foramen;  antennae  long  and 
stout;  labrum  with  only  primary  setae;  man- 
dibles with  teeth  arranged  around  edge  of 
a  central  cavity,  but  with  a  patch  of  stout 
spines  in  this  central  area  on  left  mandible; 
maxillary  palpi  not  projecting  conspicuously 
beyond  anterior  edge  of  labrum.  Thorax  as 
illustrated;  trochantin  of  fore  legs  rather 
truncate  anteriorly,  as  in  Mystacides;  hind 
legs  without  dense  row  of  swimming  hairs, 
tibia  of  hind  legs  with  constriction  and 
secondary  suture,  apparently  dividing  it  into 
two  equal  parts  as  in  Mystacides  and 
Triaenodes;  metasternum  with  transverse 
row  of  about  17  dark  setae,  terminating  on 
each  side  in  a  patch  of  about  a  dozen  setae. 
Abdomen  with  pair  of  single  posteroventral 
gills  on  segments  n  to  vn  inclusive;  first  ab- 
dominal segment  with  lateral  humps  rough- 
ened with  tiny  spines,  and  bearing  a  short 
sclerotized  bar,  line  of  6-8  dark  setae  be- 
tween lateral  and  dorsal  humps,  sternum  with 
curved  line  of  about  a  dozen  dark  setae;  seg- 
ment vni  with  row  of  about  30  small  sclero- 
tized points  along  each  side;  lateral  line  of 
very  short  setae  on  segments  in  to  vn  inclu- 
sive; segment  ix  with  sclerotized,  but  lightly 
pigmented,  plate  bearing  4-5  pairs  of  moder- 
ate to  stout  setae  along  posterior  margin;  cau- 
dal face  of  anal  prolegs  with  sclerotized  con- 
cave plate  on  each  side  of  anal  opening,  each  I 
plate  extending  into  a  median  ventral  lobe 
and  an  ovoid  lobe  arising  near  base  of  anal 
claw,  all  plates  armed  around  margins  with 


Figures  1-3,  Setodes  incerta,  larva 
1.  Head  and  thorax,  dorsal  view.  2a.  Larva,  lateral  view.  2b.  Right  metathoracic  leg,  lateral  view.  2c. 
Trochantin  and  base  of  prothoracic  leg,  lateral  view.  2d.  Lateral  hump  of  first  abdominal  segment,  lateral 
view.  2e.  Sclerotized  plates  on  base  of  anal  prolegs,  caudal  view.  2f.  Claw  of  anal  proleg.  3a.  Larval  case. 
3b.  Posterior  opening  of  larval  case. 


short  spines;  anal  claws  each  with  two  small 
dorsal  accessory  hooks. 

Case  (Fig.  3)  of  rock  fragments,  slightly 
curved,  but  with  little  taper;  posterior  end 
open,  diameter  of  opening  not  reduced  with 
silk  or  rocks;  length,  for  full-grown  larvae, 
6-7  mm,  scarcely  longer  than  larva  itself. 

pupa — (Figs.  4,  5,  6).  Length  6  mm.  Head 
unlike  that  in  Mystacides  and  Triaenodes  in 
having  prominent  tubercle  arising  between 
bases  of  antennae,  and  with  two  additional 
tubercles  on  each  side  between  base  of  an- 
tenna and  mandible;  labrum  with  patches  of 
stout  setae  and  pair  of  thorny  protuber- 
ances; mandibles  well  sclerotized,  much  as 
in  Mystacides  (Yamamoto  and  Wiggins, 
1964,  fig.  10),  blade  fairly  straight,  with 
single  row  of  minute  teeth  extending  full 
length,  blade  not  curved  as  in  Triaenodes. 
Abdominal  sclerites  different  from  Mysta- 
cides and  Triaenodes  in  that  one  additional 
segment,  vn,  bears  a  pair  of  hooked  plates, 
and  plate  5P  is  narrower  and  bears  only 
three  hooks,  in  contrast  to  6-10  in  the  other 
genera;  anal  appendages  with  prominent 
dorsal  and  ventral  spiny  lobes,  roughly  mid- 
way between  origin  and  apex,  seen  to  best 
advantage  in  lateral  view;  proximal  portion 
before  these  lobes  longer  in  male  than  in 
female. 

Case  closed  at  both  ends  with  rock  frag- 
ments and  silk,  leaving  a  round  central  hole, 
lip  of  the  hole  somewhat  raised  (Fig.  7); 
length  5-7  mm. 

adults — The  diagnostic  features  of  the  fe- 
male genitalia  of  5.  incerta  are  illustrated 
here  for  the  first  time  (Fig.  14).  They  show 
a  clear  generic  affinity  in  structure  to  those 
of  the  other  three  North  American  species 
for  which  the  female  is  known:  S.  stehri 
(Ross)  (Ross,  1941,  fig.  80);  5.  oligia 
(Ross)  (Ross,  1944,  fig.  871);  S.  epicampes 
Edwards  (Edwards,  1956,  figs.  4,  5).  Com- 
parison of  the  diagnostic  details  in  these 
figures  indicates  that  the  female  of  S.  incerta 
is  distinguished  by  having  segment  x  trun- 
cate posteriorly  in  lateral  view.  Segment  x 
of  S.  incerta  also  bears  a  deep  median  notch, 
and  is  subtended  at  the  base  on  segment  ix 
by  a  pair  of  raised  ridges.  These  characters 
are  not,  however,  illustrated  for  the  other 
species.  A  noteworthy  structural  detail  of 


S.  incerta  is  the  pair  of  sclerotized,  invagi- 
nated  pockets  in  the  sternum  of  segment 
vin,  presumably  to  receive  the  ends  of  the 
long  claspers  of  the  male  during  copulation. 
Similar  sclerotized  pockets  are  shown  for 
S.  stehri  (Ross,  1941,  fig.  80)  but  it  is  not 
clear  whether  or  not  these  structures  occur 
in  the  other  two  species. 

The  diagnostic  characteristics  of  the  male 
genitalia  in  5.  incerta  were  described  and 
illustrated  previously  (Betten  and  Mosely, 
1940,  p.  69,  fig.  33;  Ross,  1944,  fig.  872), 
but  are  included  here  (Fig.  13)  to  make 
the  present  paper  a  more  useful  reference 
for  identification  of  S.  incerta  in  its  larval, 
pupal,  and  adult  stages. 

MATERIAL    EXAMINED MICHIGAN,    OcqueOC 

River,  Presque  Isle  Co.,  20  June  1969,  12 
larvae;  1  July  1969,  many  larvae,  reared 
and  preserved  as  pupae  and  adults;  all  col- 
lected by  D.  Merrill. 

Setodes  sp. 

larva — Larvae  of  this  genus  were  also  col- 
lected from  the  Chattooga  River  in  South 
Carolina.  These  larvae  were  burrowing  in 
accumulations  of  sand  lying  in  the  lee  of 
large  rocks  in  the  riffle  areas  of  the  river. 
Depth  of  water  was  about  1  foot.  The  col- 
lection comprises  two  types  of  larvae:  one 
having  a  light  yellowish  head  with  no  dis- 
tinguishing colour  pattern,  as  in  S.  incerta; 
the  other  having  a  dark  brown  head,  with 
some  indistinct  lighter  patches  and  some 
darker  patches  on  the  pronotum  (Fig.  12). 
No  other  distinctions  among  these  two  larval 
types  and  the  larva  of  S.  incerta  from  Michi- 
gan were  found.  All  have  similar  sclerotized 
plates  on  the  anal  prolegs,  and  a  subdivided 
hind  tibia.  The  light-coloured  larvae  may  be 
conspecific  with  those  of  5.  incerta,  but  the 
dark-headed  larvae  very  likely  belong  to  a 
different  species. 

The  larval  cases  of  both  types  of  South 
Carolina  specimens  are  also  of  sand  grains, 
but  many  of  these  are  black  and  have  a 
flattened  flaky  texture.  The  posterior  opening 
is  the  full  diameter  of  the  case  as  in  5. 
incerta. 


MATERIAL       EXAMINED — SOUTH       CAROLINA 

Chattooga  River  at  Burrell's  Ford  Camp- 
ground, near  Route  107,  Oconee  Co.,  18-19 


Figures  4-11,  Setodes  incerta 

4a.  Head  of  pupa,  dorsal  view.  4b.  Head  of  pupa,  lateral  view.  5a.  Mandibles  of  pupa,  dorsal  view.  5b. 
Labrum  of  pupa,  dorsal  view.  6a.  Abdomen  of  pupa  with  sclerites  enlarged,  dorsal  view.  6b.  Anal  appen- 
dage of  pupa,  dorsal  view.  6c.  Anal  appendage  of  pupa,  mesal  view.  7.  Pupal  case,  anterior  opening. 
8.  Labrum  of  larva,  dorsal  view.  9.  Head  of  larva,  ventral  view.  10.  Labium  and  maxillae  of  larva,  ven- 
tral view.  11.  Mandibles  of  larva,  dorsal  view. 


Figure  12,  Setodes  sp. 

Head  and  thorax  of  larva,  dorsal  view. 


May  1970,  many  larvae,  G.  B.  Wiggins  and 
T.  Yamamoto. 

Cases  and  Case-building — The  slightly 
curved  cylindrical  cases  of  the  larvae  were 
constructed  of  fine,  flattened  sand  grains 
closely  fitted  together.  The  size  of  the  grains 
was  variable,  but  rarely  exceeded  0.5  mm 
in  their  largest  dimension.  The  majority  of 
the  grains  measured  0.3  mm  or  less.  The 
outside  diameters  of  the  larval  cases  aver- 
aged 1  mm,  and  the  lengths,  at  the  time  of 
collection,  ranged  from  3  to  7  mm.  Pupal 
cases  ranged  in  length  from  5  to  7  mm,  and 
were  just  sufficient  to  enclose  the  insect. 

Five  larvae  were  evicted  from  their  cases 
and  were  placed  in  stender  dishes  with  sand, 
filamentous  algae,  and  Utricularia.  As  the 
naked  larvae  crawled  on  the  sand,  they 
applied  silk  to  the  grains,  and  thus  formed 
masses   of  sand  grains  loosely  bound   to- 


gether. Within  a  short  time,  each  larva  bur- 
rowed into  the  sand,  making  further  obser- 
vations impossible.  By  the  following  day 
each  larva  had  a  new  case,  the  definitive 
portion  of  which  was  3  to  5  mm  in  length. 
Two  of  the  cases  had  a  few  millimeters  of 
loosely  organized  sand  at  the  posterior  end. 

One  can  infer  that  as  the  larvae  burrowed 
they  continued  to  apply  silk  to  the  grains 
around  them,  forming  a  rough  provisional 
case  in  this  manner.  As  this  tube  was 
lengthened  to  encompass  more  of  the  body, 
the  building  pattern  progressed  to  greater 
selectivity  of  grains  and  more  careful  attach- 
ment, ultimately  giving  rise  to  the  definitive 
case,  which  was  essentially  identical  to  the 
larva's  original  case.  The  progression  from 
provisional  to  definitive  building  has  been 
described  elsewhere  for  several  species  of 
caddis  larvae  (Bierens  de  Haan,  1922; 
Gorter,  1929;  Fankhauser  and  Reik,  1935; 
Copeland  and  Crowell,  1937;  Neilsen,  1942, 
1948). 

On  only  one  occasion  was  a  larva  ob- 
served in  the  process  of  adding  a  sand  grain 
to  the  rim  of  its  case.  A  high  degree  of  selec- 
tivity on  the  part  of  the  larva  was  indicated 
by  the  large  number  of  sand  grains  that  were 
picked  up,  tested  in  several  positions  against 
the  rim,  and  finally  rejected  before  a  suitable 
grain  was  found. 

Burrowing — The  five  larvae  that  had  built 
new  cases  continued  to  burrow  in  the  sand 
even  after  their  case-building  activity  had 
apparently  ceased.  When  five  additional  lar- 
vae were  provided  with  sand  in  their  con- 
tainers, they  too  proceeded  to  burrow  with 
their  cases.  Daily  observations  on  the  10 
larvae  indicated  a  strong  tendency  to  posi- 
tion themselves  with  one  end  of  the  case 
buried  in  the  sand  and  the  other  end  nearly 
flush  with  the  surface  (Fig.  15a).  This  posi- 
tion was  seen  in  88  out  of  112  observations. 
In  a  majority  of  the  observations,  the  case 
position  differed  from  one  day  to  the  next, 
indicating  some  degree  of  mobility  even 
under  these  unnatural  conditions. 

Occasionally  at  the  time  of  an  observa- 
tion, a  larva  had  apparently  reversed  its 
position  in  the  case  and  was  beginning  tc 
burrow,    its    posterior    end    clearly    visible 


through  the  opening  of  the  case  at  the  sur- 
face of  the  sand  substrate.  During  some  of 
these  observations  it  was  possible  to  insert  a 
worm  or  another  small  object  through  the 
opening.  Invariably  the  larva  moved  back- 
ward rapidly  and  ejected  the  intruding  ob- 
ject. 

It  is  possible  that  the  open  posterior  end 
of  the  case  is  associated  with  the  animal's 
burrowing  habits,  permitting  reversal  of 
larval  direction  without  the  necessity  of  re- 
versing the  case.  The  unusual  sclerotization 
at  the  larva's  posterior  end  appears  to  com- 
pensate for  the  vulnerability  resulting  from 
the  open-ended  case. 


Adaptations  to  Current — Because  of  its  ob- 
vious protective  advantage,  burrowing  may 
also  be  an  adaptation  for  survival  in  rapid 
currents.  Another  behaviour  pattern  ob- 
served in  larvae  of  S.  incerta  that  may  be  an 
adaptation  to  the  habitat  was  a  tendency  to 
fasten  both  ends  of  the  case  to  the  substrate 
when  they  were  not  actively  moving  about. 
This  was  particularly  noted  among  larvae  in 
containers  without  sand.  Larvae  of  many 
species  fasten  the  anterior  ends  of  their 
cases  to  the  substrate  when  at  rest  (Lestage, 
1921),  but  attachment  of  both  ends  gener- 
ally indicates  the  approach  of  pupation.  In 
5.  incerta,  attachment  at  both  ends  appears 


14c 


Figures  13-14,  Setodes  incerta 

13a.  Male  genitalia,  lateral  view.  13b.  Male  genitalia,  dorsal  view.  13c.  Male  genitalia,  ventral  view.  14a. 
Female  genitalia  (abdominal  segments  in  Roman  numerals)  lateral  view.  14b.  Female  genitalia,  dorsal 
view.  14c.  Female  genitalia,  ventral  view. 


to  provide  additional  protection  against 
being  swept  away  by  the  current.  This  be- 
haviour by  the  larvae  of  Setodes  probably  is 
unusual  because  most  other  caddis  larvae 
inhabiting  streams  and  building  portable 
cases  cannot  extend  the  head  from  either  end 
of  the  case. 

Camouflage  Behaviour — Frequently  a  larva 
was  observed  holding  a  large  grain  of  sand 
(hereafter  called  a  rock)  over  the  mouth  of 
the  case.  Sometimes  the  rock  was  loosely 
attached  to  the  rim  of  the  case  and  was 
seized  by  the  larva  when  there  was  a  change 
in  the  light  pattern  or  a  disturbance  in  the 
water.  This  practice  appeared  to  provide  ex- 
cellent camouflage  as  long  as  the  animal  re- 
mained motionless.  If  a  worm  was  placed 
near  the  larva  under  these  circumstances,  the 
larva  continued  to  hold  the  rock,  sometimes 
manipulating  it,  until  the  worm  was  within 
reach.  Then  it  released  the  rock  and  seized 
the  worm  (Fig.  15  c,  d,  e). 

This  behaviour  was  seen  in  10  out  of  12 
larvae  observed  daily  during  July  1970.  In 
80  observations,  42  were  made  under  condi- 
tions where  camouflage  behaviour  might 
occur,  i.e.  one  end  of  the  case  flush  with  the 
surface  and  the  animal  facing  upward. 
Camouflage  behaviour  actually  occurred 
during  24  of  these  observations.  In  eight 
others,  the  larva  was  manipulating  a  rock 
but  did  not  hold  it  still. 

It  is  possible  that  this  behaviour  is  derived 
from  the  manipulation  of  sand  grains  for 
purposes  of  case-building,  but  the  large  size 
of  the  grain  and  its  loose  attachment  to  the 
rim  of  the  case  suggest  that  it  is  a  special 
adaptation  of  the  more  primitive  behaviour 
pattern. 

Feeding — Filamentous  algae  (Spirogyra) 
from  the  collecting  site  were  provided  initi- 
ally until  the  supply  was  depleted.  The  prin- 
cipal food  provided  for  the  larvae  was  en- 
chytraeid  worms.  The  larvae  seized  and  ate 
the  worms  without  hesitation,  even  when 
the  worm  was  nearly  as  large  as  the  larva 
and  writhed  violently  in  the  larva's  grasp. 

Usually  while  the  animal  was  feeding,  its 
respiratory  current  was  reversed,  propelled 
anteriorly  instead  of  posteriorly.  This  phe- 
nomenon has  been  observed  in  several  spe- 


cies of  caddis  larvae,  and  is  currently  under 
investigation  by  one  of  us  (D.M.). 

No  attempt  was  made  to  examine  stomach 
contents  of  freshly  caught  larvae,  although 
fecal  pellets  in  the  containers  were  collected 
and  examined  the  first  morning  after  the 
capture  of  the  larvae.  Most  of  the  contents 
were  filamentous  algae  and  other  plant 
material,  but  several  minute  head  capsules  of 
insects  were  also  found.  Thus,  it  seems  that 
these  larvae  are  omnivorous.  The  avidity 
with  which  they  seized  and  ate  the  worms 
leaves  little  doubt  that  animal  food  is  an  im- 
portant component  of  their  diet. 

Cannibalism  sometimes  occurred  when 
larvae  were  kept  in  the  same  container.  Ex- 
periments on  a  small  number  of  larvae  indi- 
cated that  this  tendency  can  be  suppressed 
by  provision  of  an  adequate  food  supply. 

General  Conclusions — 1.  There  seems  to  be 
general  agreement  in  the  morphological  de- 
tails of  larvae  and  pupae  among  the  North 
American,  European,  and  Asian  species  of 
Setodes  for  which  these  stages  are  known.  In 
the  larvae  differences  exist  at  the  specific 
level  in  the  colour  pattern  of  the  head  and 
thorax,  the  shape  of  the  sclerotized  plates  of 
the  anal  prolegs,  and  the  presence  or  absence 
of  abdominal  gills. 

2.  Ulmer  (1955),  in  discussing  the  inter- 
relationships of  the  genera  comprising  the 
Mystacidini,  assigned  Setodes  to  a  group  in 
which  the  posterior  tibia  of  the  larva  is  not 
secondarily  divided,  and  in  which  the  dark, 
sclerotized  ridge  on  the  lateral  hump  of  the 
first  abdominal  segment  is  absent.  No  infor- 
mation on  North  American  larvae  of  Setodes 
was  available  to  Ulmer.  It  is  noteworthy, 
then,  that  with  this  information  now  avail- 
able, Setodes  emerges  as  a  genus  comprising 
species  with  a  clearly  divided  hind  tibia  (Fig. 
2b),  and  a  lateral  sclerite  on  the  first  ab- 
dominal segment  (Fig.  2d),  along  with  spe- 
cies evidently  lacking  these  features.  There 
appears  to  be  no  mention  in  the  recent  litera- 
ture of  a  subdivided  hind  tibia  in  the  Euro- 
pean larvae  of  Setodes,  although  a  clear  con- 
striction in  the  tibia  is  shown  in  an  illustra- 
tion of  Setodes  sp.  by  Murgoci  (1959,  fig. 
5c).  Whatever  may  be  the  functional  signifi- 
cance of  this  character,  it  seems  that  the  sub- 
divided hind  tibia  of  the  larva  can  no  longer 


be  regarded  as  a  consistent  generic  charac- 
ter in  the  way  that  Ulmer  did.  Another  pos- 
sibility is  that  further  study  of  all  stages  of 
the  species  now  assigned  to  Setodes  will 
show  consistent  groupings,  and  may  ulti- 
mately require  recognition  of  an  additional 
:nus.  This  discordance  may,  however,  be 
another  example  of  the  residue  of  characters 
in  the  Leptoceridae  which  apparently  cannot 
be  completely  aligned  with  a  generic  classifi- 
cation. The  diverse  shapes  taken  by  the  gu- 
lar  sclerite  in  species  of  Athripsodes  appears 
to  be  one  such  set  of  characters. 

3.  Most  of  the  information  now  available 
indicates  that  Setodes  larvae  inhabit  cool 
running  waters,  although  S.  argentipunctella 


is  reported  to  inhabit  lakes  as  well  (Hickin, 
1967).  Our  observations  indicate  that  these 
larvae  are  strongly  inclined  to  burrow  in  the 
sand  of  river  bottoms,  but  thus  far  there  is 
little  to  support  this  view  from  the  European 
observations.  Murgoci  (1959)  assigned  lar- 
vae of  Setodes  sp.  collected  in  rivers  in  Ro- 
mania to  "la  biocenose  petricole  du  biotype 
lotique,"  where  they  were  evidently  taken  in 
company  with  larvae  of  Psychomyia,  Hy- 
dropsyche,  Lepidostoma,  Brachycentrus, 
and  Sericostoma.  This  same  author  regarded 
the  concave  sclerotized  plates  of  the  anal 
prolegs  as  an  adhesive  organ  by  which  the 
larva  maintains  its  case  on  rocks  in  the  cur- 
rent, aided  by  secretion  from  a  pair  of  glands 


j^.   ,      §w.  m  £OK«  wmmmmmJKKM 

Figure  15,  Setodes  incerta  larva  and  case;  case  diameter  is  1  mm.  15a.  Partially  buried  in  sand,  anterior 
end  uppermost.  15b.  Posterior  end  of  case  showing  wide  opening  and  plates  on  bases  of  anal  prolegs. 
15c,  d,  e.  Camouflage  behaviour  of  larva  in  case;  c  =  case;  r  =  rock;  arrow  indicates  head  of  larva 
protruding  from  case.  15c.  Rock  held  over  mouth  of  case.  15d.  Rock  manipulated  to  a  different  position. 
15e.  Rock  cast  aside,  larva  feeding  on  worm. 


situated  near  the  ventral  edge  of  the  sclero- 
tized  plates.  Evidence  supporting  this  inter- 
pretation is,  however,  lacking. 

Our  observations  prompt  us  to  offer  a 
different  interpretation  of  the  function  of 
these  sclerotized  plates  of  the  anal  prolegs, 
which  are  so  remarkable  among  case-build- 
ing caddis  larvae.  Larvae  of  Setodes  have 
a  second  unusual  feature — a  behavioural 
pattern  of  case-making  that  produces  a  case 
with  little  taper  from  end  to  end,  with  the 
openings  at  both  ends  unrestricted  with  silk 
or  sand  grains,  and  equal  to  the  full  inside 
diameter  of  the  case  (Figs.  3,  15b;  Murgoci, 
1959,  fig.  3c).  Although  there  appears  to  be 
some  diversity  in  the  extent  to  which  the 
cases  of  different  species  of  Setodes  taper 
posteriorly,  the  larval  case  in  species  such 
as  5.  incerta  contrasts  strikingly  with  the 
larval  cases  of  most  Trichoptera  that  build 
portable  cases.  In  other  genera  the  case  has 
a  definite  taper  from  front  to  rear,  and  the 
posterior  opening  is  usually  further  reduced 
with  silken  secretion  and  other  materials. 

The  intepretation  offered  here  is  that  the 
sclerotized  plates  and  the  case  with  two 
open  ends  are  components  of  an  integrated 
morphological-behavioural-character  com- 
plex enabling  the  larva  to  extend  its  head, 
thorax  and  legs  from  either  end.  The  sclero- 
tized plates  on  the  caudal  face  of  the  anal 
prolegs  protect  the  larva  against  intrusions 
through  whichever  opening  harbours  its  pos- 
terior end.  Our  observations  demonstrate 
that  the  larva  does  actively  repel,  with  these 
plates,  intrusions  through  the  distal  end  of 
its  case.  Evidence  indicates  that  Setodes  lar- 
vae do  not  always  burrow  in  the  beds  of  the 
rivers  they  inhabit,  but  that  they  also  do 
occur  on  the  rocks  of  the  river  bed.  This 
character  complex  seems  to  serve  the  larvae 
well  in  both  habitats  by  permitting  them:  to 


burrow  in  the  bottom,  advancing  from  either 
end;  to  burrow  to  the  depth  of  the  case,  and 
take  up  a  feeding  position  with  the  head 
level  with  the  river  bed;  or  to  fasten  both 
ends  of  the  case  to  a  rock  for  added  stability 
while  feeding  in  strong  currents.  This  inter- 
pretation is  consistent  with  the  evidence  now 
available,  and  is  offered  as  a  conceptual  basis 
for  further  observations  on  the  biology  of 
these  remarkable  insects. 

Acknowledgments — We  are  indebted  to  Dr. 
L.  Botosaneanu  of  Bucharest  for  comments 
on  the  manuscript.  All  line  drawings  are  the 
work  of  Mr.  Anker  Odum,  scientific  illustra- 
tor in  the  Department  of  Entomology  and 
Invertebrate  Zoology,  Royal  Ontario 
Museum. 

Summary — This  paper  provides  morpholog- 
ical details  for  the  larva  and  pupa  of  Setodes 
incerta  (Walker)  from  Michigan,  the  first 
North  American  species  in  this  genus  for 
which  this  information  is  available.  The  male 
and  female  genitalia  of  this  species  are  also 
illustrated,  the  latter  for  the  first  time.  The 
larva  of  another  species  of  Setodes  from 
South  Carolina,  unidentifiable  to  species,  is 
also  briefly  described  and  illustrated.  Larvae 
of  these  two  North  American  species  are 
shown  to  be  discordant  with  European  lar- 
vae of  Setodes  in  having  a  secondary  division 
in  the  hind  tibia,  a  character  previously  con- 
sidered to  be  generic. 

Observations  on  aspects  of  the  behaviour 
of  the  larva  of  S.  incerta  are  presented:  case- 
building,  burrowing,  adaptations  to  current, 
camouflage  behaviour,  and  feeding.  Arising 
from  these  is  an  overall  interpretation  of  the 
function  of  the  unusual  morphological  and 
behavioural  characteristics  of  larvae  of  the 
genus  Setodes. 


10 


Literature  Cited 

A.kagi,  I. 

1957  On  the  larvae  of  three  Leptoceridae  and  two  Sericostomatidae  species  (Trichop- 
tera).  Ann.  Kansai  Nat.  Sci.  Ass.,  no.  10,  pp.  24-28. 

Betten,  C. 

1934  The  caddis  flies  or  Trichoptera  of  New  York  state.  Bull.  N.Y.  St.  Mus.,  no.  292,  pp. 
1-576. 

Betten,  C.  and  M.  E.  Mosely 

1940  The  Francis  Walker  types  of  Trichoptera  in  the  British  Museum.  London,  Br.  Mus. 
(Nat.  Hist.),  248  p. 

Bierens  de  Haan,  J. A. 

1922  Uber  den  Bauinstinkt  einer  Kocherfliegenlarve  (Limnophilus  marmoratus  Curt.). 
Bijdr.  Dierk.,  vol.  22,  pp.  321-327. 

Botosaneanu,  L. 

1959  Cercetari  asupra  trichopterelor  din  masivul  Retezat  si  muntii  Banatului.  [Bucuresti] 
Editura  Academiei  Republicii  Populare  Romine  (Biblioteca  de  biologie  anamala  1) 
165  p. 

Botosaneanu,  L.  and  J.  Sykora 

1963  Nouvelle  contribution  a  la  connaissance  des  Trichopteres  de  Bulgarie.  Acta  Faun. 
Ent.  Mus.  Nat.  Pragae,  vol.  9,  no.  77,  pp.  121-142. 

Copeland,  M.  and  S.  Crowell 

1937  Observations  and  experiments  on  the  case-building  instinct  of  two  species  of  Tri- 
choptera. Psyche,  vol.  44,  no.  4,  pp.  125-131. 

Edwards,  S.  W. 
1956  Two  new  species  of  Trichoptera  from  Tennessee.  J.  Tenn.  Acad.  Sci.,  vol.  31,  no.  1, 
pp.  3-7. 

Fankhauser,  G.  and  L.  E.  Reik 

1935  Experiments  on  the  case-building  of  the  caddis-fly  larva,  Neuronia  postica  Walker. 
Physiol.  Zool.  vol.  8,  no.  3,  pp.  337-359. 

Gorter,  F.  J. 

1929  Experiments  on  the  case-building  of  a  caddis- worm  (Limnophilus  flavicornis 
Fabr.).  Tijdschr.  ned.  dierk.  vereen.,  vol.  1,  no.  3,  pp.  90-93. 

tfickin,  N.  E. 
1967  Caddis  larvae.  London,  Hutchinson,  476  p. 

Lestage,  J.  A. 

1921  In  Rousseau,  Les  larves  et  nymphes  aquatiques  des  insectes  d'Europe  (morphologie, 
biologie,  systematique).  Vol.  I.  Bruxelles,  Office  de  Publicite,  Anc.  etabliss.  J.  Le- 
beque  et  Cie.  967  p. 

McLachlan,  R. 

1863  Notes  on  North  American  Phryganeidae,  with  special  reference  to  those  contained 
in  the  collection  of  the  British  Museum.  Entomologist's  Ann.  1863,  pp.  155-163. 

Murgoci,  A. 

1959  Donnees  sur  les  imagos  et  les  larves  des  Leptocerinae  (Trichoptera)  de  la  Repu- 
blique  Populaire  Roumaine.  Lucrarile  Sesiunii  Stiintifice  a  Statiunii  Zoologice  Ma- 
rine Agigea,  1956,  Iasi,  Universitatea  "Al  I.  Cuza",  pp.  445-452. 

Nielsen,  A. 

1942     Uber  die  Entwicklung  und  Biologie  der  Trichopteren  mit  besonderer  Berucksich- 


11 


tigung  der  Quelltrichopteren  Himmerlands.  Arch.  Hydrobiol.,  Stuttgart,  Suppl.,  vol 
17,  pp.  255-631. 
1948  Postembryonic  development  and  biology  of  the  Hydroptilidae.  K.  danske  vidensk 
Selsk.  Biol.  Skrift.,  vol.  5,  no.  1,  159  p. 

Ross,  H.  H. 

1941   Descriptions  and  records  of  North  American  Trichoptera.  Trans.   Am.  Ent.  Soc. 

vol.  67,  pp.  35-126. 
1944  The  caddis  flies,  or  Trichoptera,  of  Illinois.  Bull.  111.  Nat.  Hist.  Surv.,  vol.  23,  artic. 

l,pp.  1-326. 
1959  Trichoptera.  In  Edmondson,  W.  T.,  ed.  Freshwater  biology.  2nd  ed.  New  York 

Wiley,  pp.  1024-1049. 

Ulmer,  G. 

1955  Kocherfliegen  (Trichtopteren)  von  den  Sunda-Inseln  (Teil  n).  Larven  und  Puppei 
der  Integripalpia  unter  Beriicksich  tigung  verwandter  Formen  und  deren  Literatur  au 
anderen  Faunengebieten.  Arch.  Hydrobiol.,  Stuttgart,  Suppl.,  vol.  21,  pp.  408-608 

Walker,  F. 

1852  Catalogue  of  the  specimens  of  neuropterous  insects  in  the  collection  of  the  Britisl 
Museum.  Pt.  1.  London. 

Yamamoto,  T.  and  G.  B.  Wiggins 

1964  A  comparative  study  of  the  North  American  species  in  the  caddisfly  genus  Mysta 
cides  (Trichoptera:  Leptoceridae).  Can.  J.  Zool.,  vol.  42,  pp.  1 105-1126. 


Suggested  citation:  Life  Sci.  Occ.  Pap.,  R.  Ont.  Mus. 

All  manuscripts  considered  for  publication  are  subject  to  the  scrutiny  and  editorial  policies  of  the  L: 
Sciences  Editorial  Board  and  to  review  by  persons  outside  the  Museum  staff  who  are  authorities  in  t 


particular  field  involved. 

price:  50tf 

©  The  Royal  Ontario  Museum,  1 97 1 

100  Queen's  Park,  Toronto  181,  Canada 

PRINTED  AT  THE  UNIVERSITY  OF  TORONTO  PRESS 


12 


^3Sl 


niAi 


^^9/7°  7**tf 


1\P 


jC>