Skip to main content

Full text of "The Life and Speeches of the Very Reverend J. H. Cotton, B.C.L., Dean of Bangor, and Rector of ..."

See other formats


Google 



This is a digital copy of a book lhal w;ls preserved for general ions on library shelves before il was carefully scanned by Google as pari of a project 

to make the world's books discoverable online. 

Il has survived long enough for the copyright to expire and the book to enter the public domain. A public domain book is one thai was never subject 

to copy right or whose legal copyright term has expired. Whether a book is in the public domain may vary country to country. Public domain books 

are our gateways to the past, representing a wealth of history, culture and knowledge that's often dillicull lo discover. 

Marks, notations and other marginalia present in the original volume will appear in this file - a reminder of this book's long journey from the 

publisher lo a library and linally lo you. 

Usage guidelines 

Google is proud lo partner with libraries lo digili/e public domain materials and make them widely accessible. Public domain books belong to the 
public and we are merely their custodians. Nevertheless, this work is expensive, so in order lo keep providing this resource, we have taken steps to 
prevent abuse by commercial panics, including placing Icchnical restrictions on automated querying. 
We also ask that you: 

+ Make n on -commercial use of the files We designed Google Book Search for use by individuals, and we request thai you use these files for 
personal, non -commercial purposes. 

+ Refrain from automated querying Do not send automated queries of any sort lo Google's system: If you are conducting research on machine 
translation, optical character recognition or other areas where access to a large amount of text is helpful, please contact us. We encourage the 
use of public domain materials for these purposes and may be able to help. 

+ Maintain attribution The Google "watermark" you see on each lile is essential for informing people about this project and helping them find 
additional materials through Google Book Search. Please do not remove it. 

+ Keep it legal Whatever your use. remember that you are responsible for ensuring that what you are doing is legal. Do not assume that just 
because we believe a book is in the public domain for users in the United States, that the work is also in the public domain for users in other 

countries. Whether a book is slill in copyright varies from country lo country, and we can'l offer guidance on whether any specific use of 
any specific book is allowed. Please do not assume that a book's appearance in Google Book Search means it can be used in any manner 
anywhere in the world. Copyright infringement liability can be quite severe. 

About Google Book Search 

Google's mission is to organize the world's information and to make it universally accessible and useful. Google Book Search helps readers 
discover the world's books while helping authors and publishers reach new audiences. You can search through I lie lull lexl of 1 1 us book on I lie web 
al |_-.:. :.-.-:: / / books . qooqle . com/| 



, T151. It 



ItUtauA tfollrgc lilivarii 



m 



V *,y 



JOHN HARVEY TREAT 

'11' I.AWHKM'K, MASH. 
[OUtl of iUt) 



:// * 

■' / ' 

* 7 



\ 









fc 



if* 




J[^u 



. A /?.&*** 



THE 



gIMPKIN MARSHALL & Co., STATIONERS* HALL COURT. 

1874. 
(all rights reserved.) 



7 /' : / - 



I 



¥> 




.. 



< 



V 



ft 




J(^u 




TO 

THE REVEREND JJHN PRYCE, M.A., 

VICAR OF BANGOR, RURAL DEAN, 

AND 
HONORARY SECRETARY TO THE DIOCESAN BOARD OF EDUCATION, 

WITH 

PROFOUND RESPECT FOR HIS LEARNING, 

AND 
PRAISE- WORTHY EXERTIONS IS BEHALF OF EDUCATION, 

AND 

IN AFFECTIONATE GRATITUDE, 

FOR UNSOUGHT AND UNEXPECTED KINDNESS, 

THIS VOLUME 
IS MOST RESPECTFULLY DEDICATED BY HIS FAITHFUL 

AND OBLIGED SERVANT 

WILLIAM HUGHES. 



PKEFACE. 



It would appear unnecessary to offer any apology for the 
publication of the Life and Speeches of one so well known, 
admired, and revered as the late ' Good Dean Cotton,' but, 
in introducing the following pages to the notice of the 
public, I feel that some apology is due on my part for 
undertaking this work. 

The late Dean had been dead twelve years, and there 
appeared no probability of any one else undertaking to 
publish his " Life," " although," to use the words of a 
writer in a local paper soon after his death, " there are 
few whose characters could so well afford to wait to have 
justice done them, inasmuch as his many excellencies will 
be embalmed in the memories of those who have been for 
so many years witnesses of his daily acts — his neverceasing 
labour of love." In one of the characters of Shakspeare 
it is said, 

" The evil that men do lives after them, 
The good is oft interred with their bones," 

but in the case of the late beloved Dean, we trust that 
these words are not applicable, nay, rather, let us hope 
that his untiring zeal, courage, and self devotion may be 
long remembered by those who now reap the benefit of his 
labours. 

I should have been heartily glad if any writer, better 
qualified than myself, had undertaken to write a more 
complete life than this can pretend to be, I readily 



/) .ft. W*#L4sl 



THE 



LIFE AND SPEECHES 



OF THE 



VERY REV. J. H. COTTON, B.C.L.: 



DEAN OF BANGOR, AND RECTOR OF LLANLLECHYD. 



WITH A BRIEF SKETCH OF THE PERIOD IN WHICH HE LIVED, TO 

WHICH IS ADDED AN APPENDIX, CONTAINING A CHRONOLOGICAL 

LIST WITH BIOGRAPHICAL SKETCHES OF THE DEANS OF 

BANGOR, FROM 1162 TO THE PRESENT TIME. 



EDITED BY THE 

REV. WILLIAM HUGHES, 

CURATE OF GLASYNFRYN, BANGOR. 



BANGOR: 
NIXON AND JARVIS, PUBLISHERS, BANK PLACE. 

LONDON: 

SIMPKIN MARSHALL & Co., STATIONERS* HALL COURT. 

1874. 
(ALL RIGHTS RESERVED.) 



TJ>V|-|.S\3. fc 



(*0CTI8 19IJ'*) 




BANGOR CATHEDRAL 



TO 

THE REVEREND JOHN PRYCE, M.A., 

VICAR OF BANGOR, RURAL DEAN, 

AND 
HONORARY SECRETARY TO THE DIOCESAN BOARD OF EDUCATION, 

WITH 

PROFOUND RESPECT FOR HIS LEARNING, 

AND 
PRAISE-WORTHY EXERTIONS IN BEHALF OF EDUCATION, 

AND 

IN AFFECTIONATE GRATITUDE, 

FOR UNSOUGHT AND UNEXPECTED KINDNESS, 

THIS VOLUME 
IS MOST RESPECTFULLY DEDICATED BY HIS FAITHFUL 

AND OBLIGED SERVANT 

WILLIAM HUGHES. 



* 



PEEFACE. 



It would appear unnecessary to offer any apology for the 
publication of the Life and Speeches of one so well known, 
admired, and revered as the late ' Good Dean Cotton,' but, 
in introducing the following pages to the notice of the 
public, I feel that some apology is due on my part for 
undertaking this work. 

The late Dean had been dead twelve years, and there 
appeared no probability of any one else undertaking to 
publish his " Life," " although," to use the words of a 
writer in a local paper soon after his death, " there are 
few whose characters could so well afford to wait to have 
justice done them, inasmuch as his many excellencies will 
be embalmedin the memories of those who have been for 
so many years witnesses of his daily acts — his neverceasing 
labour of love." In one of the characters of Shakspeare 
it is said, 

" The evil that men do lives after them, 
The good is oft interred with their bones," 

but in the case of the late beloved Dean, we trust that 
these words are not applicable, nay, rather, let us hope 
that his untiring zeal, courage, and self devotion may be 
long remembered by those who now reap the benefit of his 
labours. 

I should have been heartily glad if any writer, better 
qualified than myself, had undertaken to write a more 
complete life than this can pretend to be. I readily 



acknowledge my inability to do justice to the worthy subject 
of this imperfect memoir, and I have felt this very keenly 
during the compilation of the following pages. Should 
any future writer, possessed of the necessary qualifications — 
and there are many still living, who have enjoyed both the 
confidence and society of the Demi for many years — 
undertake to draw a fuller portrait, no one will rejoice 
more than myself. In the meantime. 1 humbly trust that 
my efforts may servo, in some measure, to preserve the 
memory of the Dean, and to rescue from oblivion as many 
of his papers, speeches aud sayings, as could with propriety 
be published, and such as might prove to be of general 
interest to future generations. 

I am anxious to express my obligations to the Rev. 
Canon Thomas, the Rev. 11. Williams, Llanfaclog, the 
Bev. B. J. Binns, and II. Barber, Esquire, for their 
interesting contributions to the first Appendix of this 
volume. My thauks are also due to the Rev. H. J. Cotton, 
the Rev. R. Williams, Trefdraeth, Mr. R. Foulkes, and 
Mr. John Parry, Bangor ; they have most kindly furnished 
me with much valuable information in the compilation of 
this work. 

WILLIAM HUGHES. 
Glasynfryn, 28th May, 1814. 



CONTENTS. 



CHAPTER I. 

Birth of Mr. Cotton — Parentage — Education — Early desire to 
enter the Ministry — Ordination — First Curacy — The late 
Bishop Heber and Mr. Cotton as Volunteers — Extract from 
Lecture — Leaves Stoke for Thornton — Promoted to Derwen 
— Becomes Vicar of Bangor and Precentor of the Cathedral — 
First Marriage and issue — Labours as Parish Priest and 
Educationist — Extract from Bishop Majendie's Visitation 
Questions — Establishment of first Church Sunday School at 
Bangor — Extract from Lecture —Death of Captain Cotton — 
Death of Bishop Cotton — Extract from the "Free Church 
of Scotland Missionary Record " — Dr. Pring and others, 
versus Dean and Chapter — Building of Pentir and Vaynol 
Schools —Resigns Llandyfrydog and becomes Rector of 
Llanllechyd ... ... ... ... 1 

CHAPTER II. 

Opening of the first National School at Bangor — Mr. Cotton's 
speech on the occasion — Death of Mrs. Cotton — Monumental 
inscription —Restoration of Bangor Cathedral — Mr. Cotton's 
application to Dean and Chapter for the use of the nave of 
the Cathedral — Extract from . Browne Willis' History of 
Bangor Cathedral — Mr. Cotton's second marriage, and 
issue — Death of Mrs. Cotton — Monumental inscription — 
Savings Bank defalcation — Death of Bishop Majendie , and 
translation of Bishop Bethell — Speech at Beaumaris Royal 
Eisteddfod — Building of Bangor Infant School — Speech at 
at a Banquet, in celebration of the birthday of Princess 
Victoria ... ... ... ... ... ... 18 

CHAPTER III. 

The Welsh Church — Labours of the Reverend Griffith Jones, 
Llanddowror — The Welsh circulating Charity Schools — 
State of Education in Wales in 1760 — Madam Bevan's 
Charity — Rowlands Llangeithio — Charles of Bala ... 31 



TO. 

CHAPTER IV. 

The Separation of 1811— " The 117/*// Lookhnj r,'W— John 
Elias — His advise to Cadwalader Jones - Testimonies con- 
cerning the Church— The Ministry of the < 'huivh < 'h-rical 
Education Societies — Extract from, Bishop Campbell's 
Charge — Causes of the early growth of Methodism- -Early 
Methodist preachers— The JFiri/f -Extract from Mr. Jones, 
Llanddowror's " Practical Piety " — Extempore preaching — 
Manuscript Sermons — Mr. Cotton as a preacher— The 
Clergy and Education ... ... ... ... 48 

CHAPTER V. 
Mr. Cotton's letter on education in Wales ... ... 64 

CHAPTER VT. 

Mr. Precentor Oottm becomes Pern of Bin^or — Presentation 
of a Testimonial— The East Win-low of Bangor < Sthedral — 
Extract from Browne Willis's ///.</■»/■// nf !ht injur ('nth* ifral — 
Lines composed by the Oean on the East Window — 
Anagram on the proposed union of the Sees of Rancor and 
Saint Asaph - Establish ing of Church Building Society — 
Speech at lay : n^ foundation stone of Carnarvonshire and 
Anglesey Infirmary- -Restoration of Llanllechyd School, 
Speech at laying foundation stone of Llanf ihangcl ( 'hurch— 
Dean Cotton and Archdeacon Allen's School Inspection 
Tour ... ... ... ... ... ... 84 

CHAPTER VII. 

Dean Cotton's Speech at Stephenson's Banquet— His love and 
knowledge of Music— Address to Welsh Singera of Bangor 
Cathedral — Speech at laying Foundation Stone of Glan- 
ogwen Church — Correspondence on the state of the Church 
at Bangor — Presentation of an Address and Family Bible 97 

CHAPTER V11L 

Remarks on the State of Church Schools in connection with the 

Committee of Council on Education ... ... ... 113 



Vlll. 

CHAPTER IX. 

Marriage of Miss Ann Cotton — Her Death — Extract from 
Merthyr Telegraph— Death of Bishop Bethell and appoint- 
ment of Bishop Campbell — The dispute about the Minor 
Canonry — A description of England and Wales in verse — 
Extract from Lecture delivered at the Bangor Sailor's 
Christian Institute ... ... ... ... ... 125 

CHAPTER X. 

The Dean's Blindness — Activity — "A Modest -wish" — Illness 
and Death — The Funeral — Extract from 'North Wales 
Chronicle ' — Extract from ' Chester Courant ' — Extract 
from Funeral Sermon — Inscription on tombstone and tablet 136 

CHAPTER XI. 

Dean Cotton's Personal Appearance — Character and Church- 
manship — Bangor Eisteddfod — Two Welsh Elegies — 
Memorial Church — Restoration of Bangor Cathedral— 
Removal of Testimonial Window — Letters of Sir George 
Gilbert Scott ... ... ... ... ... 145 

APPENDIX I. 

Letters written by personal Friends of Dean Cotton ... . . 157 

« 

APPENDIX II. 

Chronological List with Biographical Sketches of the Deans of 

Bangor, from 1162 to the present time ... ... ... 178 



5 

I 

i 



LIFE AND SPEECHES 



OF THE 



VERY REV. J. H. COTTON, B.C.L. 

LATB DEAN OF BANGOR, AN'D RECTOR OF LLAN'LLECHYD. 



CHAPTER I. 

Birth of Mr. Cotton — Parentage — Education — Early desire to enter 
the Ministry — Ordination — First Curacy — The late Bishop Hcbcr 
and Mr. Cotton as Volunteers — Extract from Lecture — Leaves 
Stoke for Thornton — Promoted to Derwen — Becomes Vicar of 
Bangor and Precentor of the Cathedral — First Marriage and issue 
— Labours as Parish Priest and Educationist — Extract from 
Bishop Majendie's Visitation Questions — Establishment of rirst 
Church Sunday School at Bangor — Extract from Lecture — Death 
of Captain Cotton — Death of Bishop Cotton — Extract from the 
"Free Church of Scotland Missionary Record" — Dr. Pring and 
others, versus Dean and Chapter — Building of Pentir and Vaynol 
Schools — Bcsigns Llandyfrydog and becomes Rector of Llan- 
llechyd. 

JAMES HENRY COTTON, the second son of the Very 
Reverend George Cotton, D.D., Dean of Chester, and of 
Catherine, his wife, was born February ioth, 1780, at Dorfold 
Hall, near Nantwich, Cheshire, the seat of James Tomkinson, 
Esquire, his maternal Grandfather. 

He received his early education at Rugby School, under 
Dr. Wool, from thence he proceeded to Trinity College, 
Cambridge, where, in due course, he took the Ordinary 
Degree of B. A. 



6 

From a boy he had always a great desire to enter the 
Christian Ministry; and in the year I803, he was ordained 
at Eccleshall, by Dr. Cornwallis, Bishop of Lichfield, and 
licensed to the Curacy of Stoke, Salop. 

While Mr. Cotton was Curate of Stoke, Reginald Heber, 
afterwards the celebrated Bishop of Calcutta, held the family 
living of Hodnet, an adjoining Parish, and during the 
Peninsular war, they were <both volunteers in the same corps. 
In a Lecture on "The Progress of Education, and the gradual 
knowledge of the Holy Scriptures" delivered by Mr. Cotton, 
at the " Sailors' Christian Institute/' Bangor, he said, 

In the year 1803, I was myself a Volunteer commanding a com- 
pany of 100 men. These consisted of the peasants, the servants of 
farmers, &c. And a most rough and uncultivated set they were. 
I remember being on parade on one occasion, the drill serjeant, in 
the terse and quick manner in which they are accustomed to speak, 
in directing the feet of his corps, repeated the words ri</ht, left — 
right, left, when one of these boors in an abrupt manner, with 
rounded shoulders and slouched gait, turned out of the ranks and 
with a loud voice said, ' I'll be hanged if I'll stay here any longer to 
be barked at in this manner.' Now, it gives me great pleasure to 
afford a different report of the persons who now compose the body 
of our volunteers in this immediate neighbourhood, and to show the 
improvement which has risen from education as it respects them. 
The discipline which these persons have undergone in school lias 
taught them, in a great measure, to control themselves, and the 
religious and moral impressions they have received, strengthen this 
habit of self control. Nay, indeed, I have heard that the serjeant 
who formed the volunteer corps in this immediate neighbourhood, 
declared that they were so self disciplined and amenable that he had 
no trouble with them. 

In the year 1806, Mr. Cotton removed from Stoke to the 
curacy of Thornton, near Chester, where his ministrations 
were eminently successful. 

In the year 1809, on the death of the Reverend Peter 
Jones, Mr. Cotton was promoted by Bishop Majendie to the 
living of Derwen, Denbighshire, which living was then in the 
diocese of Bangor. 



In 1810, Mr. Cotton exchanged the living of Derwen with 
the Reverend John Kyffin, for the Junior Vicarage of Bangor, 
and in the same year, on the death of the Reverend Hugh 
Owen, D.D., he became Precentor of Bangor Cathedral. 

In the year 18 10, Mr. Cotton married Mary Anne, daughter 
of Dr. Majendie, (sometime Bishop of Chester, but translated 
to Bangor in 1809) by whom he had two sons, the eldest of 
whom, the Reverend Henry James Cotton, is now Rector of 
Dalbury, near Derby, and the other died in his infancy. 

In strictness as Vicar, he was officially connected with 
the city and parish of Bangor only, to the inhabitants 
of which he was a constant friend and benefactor, both in 
the example of his daily life and conversation, as well as in 
his munificent charities to the poor, and his encouragement 
of the trade and institutions of the town. The sympathy 
which he exhibited towards the poor in their trials and 
sufferings, and the willingness with which he relieved their wants, 
his unaffected simplicity, and his labours " in season and out 
of season," at the sick-bed, and over the dying couch, 
won for him a title than which none can be more honourable 
and dignified, that of being " the poor man's parson." 

He did not, however, confine his energies to his own 
parish, but he took an active, often the foremost, part in 
every good work throughout the Diocese. In whatever 
capacity he was placed, whether it be that of Secretary to 
the Christian Knowledge Society, or Chairman of the 
Bangor Auxiliary Branch of the Bible Society, a Justice of 
the Peace, or any other post of trust or honor ; whatever 
scheme he undertook, whether the building and restoring of 
churches and schools, the establishing of clothing clubs, or 
any other good work, he threw himself into the undertaking 
with untiring exertions, ardent zeal and unflinching courage, 
for he considered himself as promoted to power, not for his 
own sake, but for the public good, and to this end he 
applied the power which he possessed. 



8 

Although Mr. Cotton was a constant friend to every 
Christian and philanthrophic enterprise, yet what seemed to 
engage his time and attention in an especial manner, was 
the promotion of the cause of popular and religious education. 
When he first came to Bangor he was struck with the 
paucity of parochial schools in the diocese ; indeed, Wales 
had been more neglected than any part of the kingdom, for 
there were scarcely any means of education provided for the 
lower classes in rural districts, except Sunday schools, and a few 
charity schools founded by Madam Be van, and Dean Jones. 
Mr. Cotton promptly devoted his active energies, in spite, at 
first, of public prejudice and opposition, to remove this defect, 
and labouring incessantly, succeeded eventually, in establishing 
schools in a very considerable number of parishes throughout 
the diocese. He travelled over the whole diocese every 
year to hold meetings, and to encourage teachers. He made 
annual visits to examine the schools, and drew up and 
circulated reports entirely at his own expense. He often 
taught at the schools all day, and then lectured to the 
people at large in the evening, and we may add that he was 
the first who ever inspected schools in Carnarvonshire. 
Indeed, it would be no exaggeration to say that he was the 
great apostle of education in his time, and that both as 
parish priest and educationist, he was, in his day, a " burning 
and a shining light." 

The following remarks on Mr. Cotton appeared in a local 
paper, soon after his death : 

" Men's minds too, at that time were so fired with partisan 
zeal on various subjects that great jealousy existed lest the 
interest of some other cause should be subserved under the 
guise of a regard for education. He found the greatest diffi- 
culty in obtaining the assistance of his brother clergymen, 
nor could vulgar and bigoted persons comprehend why he 
devoted his time and income to the cause, unless actuated 
by some vulgar and bigoted motive like their own. Sub- 



9 

sequent events proved the wisdom of his course, and during 
many " years of labour and devotedness, no opponent of the 
cause, or of his views in conducting it, was ever able to 
specify a single instance in which he had prostituted or 
perverted his influence for any personal partisan or collat- 
eral end whatever. 

It is obvious, on a moment's reflection, that few works 
ever undertaken by man had relations so numerous, or 
touched society at so many points, and those so sensitive, 
as those in which he was now engaged. The various 
religious denominations were all turned into eyes, each to 
watch against encroachments upon itself, or favouritism to 
others. Sordid men anticipated the expenditures incident 
to improvement. Many teachers of private schools foresaw 
that any change for the better in the parochial schools would 
withdraw patronage from their own, though to their honor it 
must be said that the cause of public education had no 
better friends than many private teachers proved themselves 
to be. But hundreds of wretchedly poor and incompetent 
teachers knew full well that the daylight of educational intel- 
ligence would be to them what the morning dawn is to night 
birds, — and he lived to see schools built and established in 
almost every parish in the diocese, towards which he gave 
hundreds of pounds, and many persons now holding respect- 
able positions in society, in the church, the learned profes- 
sions and commerce, bestow their blessings on this kind and 
generous benefactor." 

Mr. Cotton's mode of examining children was peculiarly 
winning : he would address them in kind and affectionate 
terms, which, with his genial smile and innocent wit, would 
easily win the attention of the young pupils gathered round 
him. Mr. Cotton, in a letter on the state of education in 
Wales, says : 

There are few persons indeed who understand the office of an 
examiner. The duty of an examiner is not to teach, but to learn. 



10 

His business is not to teach his pupils what he knows, but to karn 
from them what they know. Many persons forget this distinction. 
The examiner has both to hear them, and to ask them questions, 
that he may know their understanding and answers. He is the key 
to unlock their minds. He lifts them up, and gently leads them by 
the hand, that they may walk confidently. He so puts his questions, 
as that he may lead the child by gentle steps to think for himself, 
and to draw religious and moral inferences. While he is asking the 
children questions, he is enabling them to ask themselves questions. 
His mode of examination leads the child to understand that he must 
thoroughly sift or dissect every sentence, and leave no part unex- 
amined or unexplored as respects its general meaning, its inferential 
meaning, its punctuation, grammar, <Cr. When an examination is 
thus carried on, the mind opened, and the understanding informed, 
education is a source of the highest gratification to young children. 
'My boys and girls,' said a clergyman (after examining the children 
of the upper class) ' how long have we been at work ? ' ' About two 
hours, sir,' was the answer. ' Longer my children,' said the clergy- 
man, ' we have been engaged nearly three hours ; are you tired ? ' 
' No sir. ' ' Well, then, you have been so attentive, I will tell you a 
story, and you shall make some intelligent remarks upon it, drawing 
such inferences as will naturally arise from the subject. The story 
is this : — In our infant school, as you know, children, the same 
lessons of religion and morality are instilled daily. The mistress 
frequently asks this question, and receives the following answer : — 
' If you find anything in the street, when nobody sees you, what are 
you to do ? ' ' Try to find the right owner. ' A little girl, acting 
upon this principle, having found a purse in the street in this town, 
containing fifteen sovereigns, picked it up, carried it to her mother, 
and said, 'Mother, we must try to find the right owner.' Her 
mother, moved, as we hope, by an honest principle, set off with her 
child, and thinking, possibly, that the purse might belong to some 
stranger travelling through the place, called at the several inns. 

She came at length to the L Arms. The woman asked if 

there was any stranger there ? The landlady answered that there 
was a lady there, who lived in the neighbourhood. The question 
next asked was, had the lady complained that she had lost anything? 
The landlady said, yes ; and told her the amount of the loss, giving 
her also a description of the purse. The purse and its contents 
exactly answered to the description given. The mother and child 
were then admitted to see the lady ; and upon the restoration 
of the property, the lady gave the child two sovereigns, and sent a 
third to the treasurer of the infant school. That is my story children. 



11 

Now, how can you be sure that the purse really belonged to the 
lady who claimed it ? A little girl answered, ' Because the descrip- 
tion of the purse and the money in it had been made by the lady 
herself to the landlady, before the woman brought it ; and the purse 
an.d the money agreed with what she had said.' 'But,' said the 
clergyman, ' though that is a very good answer, I must have another 
from some of you greater children. You must give me what I call 
internal evidence of the fact ; you must do it by drawing an 
inference. ' Well,' said one of the upper boys, * I think if the lady 
had coveted, and had taken what was not her own, she would not 
have been willing to give anything back ; at least, she would not 
have been so generous as to give so much. ' Thus the clergyman I 
allude to addressed his pupils ; and this was the result. Now, I 
relate this little story, merely to show how the minds of children 
may be drawn out by a kind and pleasing manner, and by a judicious 
mode of examination." 

The above extract will suffice to shew the course pursued 
by Mr. Cotton in examining schools. 

■ TJie following extract from Bishop Majendie's Primary 
Visitation questions, addressed to the Rev. J. H. Cotton, 
and the Reverend John Jones, Vicars of Bangor, in the 
year 1811, will shew the state of school accommodation in 
the parish at that date. 

" Question 7. — What schools are there in your parish, 
and of what description, viz. Free, Voluntary, or Sunday 
Schools ? What number of children are taught in each ? 
What provision for the former, and how are those of another 
description supported ? Have the Dissenters or Methodists 
any School or Schools in your parish, and if any, how con- 
ducted or frequented ? 

Answer — There is a respectable Grammar School under 
the Dean and Chapter, and several voluntary schools. There 
is also a school for a limited number of children, supported 
by the interest of ;£ioo left by Dean Jones, and under the 
patronage and management of the Dean for the time being. 
The Calvinistic Methodists have a Sunday School, at which 
the number of children varies continually, but the number 
of regular attendants is probably not considerable. " 



12 

We find from answers to the questions above referred to, 
that the number of families in the parish of Bangor, in the 
year 1811 was 491, and the number of souls 2,383, not 
including such persons as were then serving in the Local, the 
Old established Militia, the regular Army, or the Navy. 

In the year 18 10, Mr. Cotton opened a Sunday School in 
the nave of the Cathedral, where it continued until the year 
1822, when it was removed to the National School. 

The following is an extract from Mr. Cotton's Diary — 

July, 1822. The Welsh Sunday School which had been restored 
last year, was now removed from the Church to the New 
Schoolroom. — Instruction commencing at 1 o'clock in the afternoon, 
and ending at 3 o'clock, when a Prayer and Psalm concluded the 
whole, and the scholars went to Church. The average number atten- 
ding, about 98. 

This was the first Church Sunday School held in the parish* 
and to the last Mr. Cotton took the liveliest interest in its 
working ; he was most punctual in his attendance, and had a 
class of his own. Many now remember his well known figure, 
as in later years, escorted by some friend, and robed in his 
academical gown, he wended his way towards the Sunday 
School. 

In the lecture at the Sailor's Institute, above mentioned, 
Mr Cotton, among other remarks on the Sunday School, said : 

I remember well being attacked by a gentleman on account of my 
propensity in instructing children to read. I was then a young man. 
I ventured to argue with him, but he answered my arguments by 
knitting his brow and shaking his head, those outward and visible 
signs of an assured inward discernment, at the same time saying, 
' You are a very young man. ' I bless God, however, that the * very 
young man ' was born in the year 1780, the very year in which Sunday 
Schools were originated, that he has been preserved so as to promote 
such Schools beyond his 80th year, and who, could it be possible 
that he should survive until the year 1880, would desire nothing 
more than he should depart, sitting amidst the children under his 
care, with the Book of God in his hand, and the words of God in his 
mouth. 



In the times succeeding, some persons still held objections to the 
instruction of the poor in reading, which were grounded on passion 
and prejudice than on principle. In arguing with one of these 
persona who objected to National Schools, I said, there is now a 
flood upon the earth which will either produce inundation or irri- 
gation. If you direct it aright it will irrigate the soil, if you let it 
hare its own course it will inundate the earth. Another objected 
to Infant Schools, saying they encouraged early marriages, I answered, 
that I gave him credit for having uttered the severest satire against 

In November 1813, Captain Thomas Cotton, brother of 
Mr. Cotton, and father of the lamented *Dr. Cotton, Bishop 
of Calcutta, and Metropolitan of all India, was mortally 
wounded at the battle of Nivelle, only a fortnight after the 
birth of his illustrious son. 

In the year 1813, Dr. Pring, the then organist of Bangor 
Cathedral, in conjunction with certain members of the Choir, 

* PBrhups it will not be uraiss to Insert hero the following account of the melu- 
■holj and untimely end o( this estimable prelate, end nephew 01 Mr. Cotton, which 



Utaiewrj Record, and is tarn 
hi wemuiea the gnat Ganges 


mVE£!'JS? e 'h^Ttanf 


»','«■ 


□dredand 


*ft/ milti to the ,. M 








be nacbed on the 




Saturday, stb October (1BB6) int. 






WOttaitl. hy the 








dybenl, 


bed to be anohoroi 




MttiiaO iifiiii':ifi*tely opposite the 












' <•*,'« goode.ee* 










Ob nulling the 






delay his 


»™j to Calcutta 










J-ftaj. Always 










TWe Mteral o( hii 




riginally intended, proceeded by t 














5J» I M residents 




. about doak, accompanied by two gentleme 




■SaoSrinViSt 


ne*™!™ 


the yacht laj, fnll of rfyanity and cheerfolneee, and 


*»■' in length, end 




leBeoi to which the yacht waa mo 








by two springy planks of betwee 








eet In breadth. — without a rope or 








good-niaM to the friends who had 






JU^"""™ 




nw, two-planted bridge which led to 






with a lantern ; while he himself followed ale 


wly, steadily, ..nd 



■ w-iHinu-atick. When ho re 



onaeoreted soil, and denied the right* or Christian 



ai the garb of immortality. 



14 

instituted a Chancery Suit against the Dean and Chapter, of 
which body Mr. Cotton was, as Precentor, a member. 

The object of the suit was to obtain an advance in the 
salaries of the petitioners, in consequence of the great in- 
crease in the tithes of Llandinam, which form the endow- 
ment of the Choir, and were appropriated under an Act of 
the i st year of King James II, entituled, " An Act for the 
Repair of the Cathedral Church of Bangor, and for the main- 
tenance of the Choir there, and for the Augmentation of 
the Revenue of the Bishoprick of Bangor, and also for an 
Augmentation of several Vicarages, within the Comportions 
of Llandinam, in the Diocese of Bangor aforesaid." 

A question was also raised as to the right of the Precentor, 
and two Vicars-Choral being considered as members of the 
Choir. The suit, which lasted five years, was heard before 
Lord Eldon, the then Lord Chancellor, who decided in 
favour of the Dean and Chapter, and his lordship made the 
following order, dated August, 18th, 1818 : — 

" Let the Master appoint a third person to estimate what 
sum will be sufficient to put the Cathedral in good and sub- 
stantial repair, and refer it back to the Master to review his 
Report in this respect. Declare that the Precentor and 
Vicars-Choral are members of the Choir, within the reach 
and meaning of the Act of King James II., and confirm the 
Master's Report as to the distributions and proportions ; and 
let the proportions given to the Vicars-Choral be paid to 
them so long as they shall do their duties in those characters, 
and in case of their neglecting so to do, let any person in- 
terested, be at liberty to apply to the Court." 

Dr. Pring, in a book containing a full account of the 
above suit, and published by himself, says : — " The Rev. 
Mr. Cotton, son in law to the present Bishop of Bangor, 
will be the greatest gainer by the new distribution of the 
funds, for his six shares and a half, in his two-fold capacity 
of Precentor and Junior Vicar, (if the two appointments can 



15 

3e held compatibly by the same person) will produce him 
ibout j£iSo a year, with the hitherto unheard of advantage 
>f being his own Trustee. On the other hand, Dr. Pring, 
who has officiated as Organist 26 years) will be the greatest 
ufferer by the late decision ; for after having expended, in 
he vain pursuit of impartial justice, several hundred pounds 
o the irreparable loss of a numerous family, his salary, as 
Drganist, is by the late decision, a little more than doubled, 
vhile the salaries of his colleagues have been quadrupled, 
ind the salaries of the singing Boys increased to eight times 
heir former amount. And even other persons, who before, 
nrere satisfied with an ample maintenance arising from 
mother source, have been allowed most liberal salaries, now 
or the first time, from the tithes of Llandinam, in open 
lefiance to the preamble of the Act, which states : that 
the said tithes were intended exclusively for the main- 
:enance of those persons forming the choir of Bangor, who, 
prior to the passing of the said Act of King James II., had 
5 no Income or Allowance ; ' whereas the Vicars of Bangor, 
enjoyed, at that time, a full and sufficient ' Income and 
Allowance,' arising from the tithes of the parish of Bangor." 
In the year 18 14, a School was built at Pentir, and another 
at Vaynol in 181 6, both in the parish of Bangor, entirely 
through the exertions of Mr. Cotton. 

The following is from Mr. Cotton's Diary : — 

1816. — *A School established near Vaynol, on the Tyddyn bach 

land, built upon a lease for 60 years, supported by sums raised from 

the funds of the National Society and voluntary subscriptions. 

Thirty children educated on charity, £10 annually granted from the 

Bangor school fund, the rest by annual subscriptions — J. Jones, 

Muter, — Reading, Writing, and Arithmetic taught as at Bangor, — 

Girls were sent from this school and that of Pentir, to Bangor, to 

be taught sewing. The school first began by the assistance of 
monitors from Bangor. 

•This building continued in use until the year 1859, when a new and apacioui 
HiJhnninwwn was built upon other land presented by the Reverend H. D. Owen, D.D., 
2alfcMthBectory. 



16 

The Bishop promises annually £5 for an apprenticing fee to the 
best and oldest boy in Bangor School. 

We add a further extract from Bishop Majendie's Primary 

Visitation Questions (1811), shewing the number of Divine 

Services held in the Parish at that time. 

" Question 5. How often is Divine Service performed at your 
Church or Chapels in English or Welsh ? " 

"Answer. At Bangor, Divine Service is performed four times 
every Sunday — twice in English, and twice in Welsh. The evening 
Service in Welsh, and the Welsh Lecture were lately instituted. The 
evening Service being partly English and partly Welsh, with no 
Sermon. At Pentir Service is performed every other Sunday, with a 
Sermon and evening prayers during the Summer. ,, 

In the year 1821, on the death of the Reverend John 
Roberts, Mr. Cotton became Rector of Llanllechyd, a popu- 
lous and important parish in the Penrhyn quarries district, 
which he held up to the day of his death. Mr. Cotton had 
held the living of Llandyfrydog some time previously, which 
he resigned on being promoted to Llanllechyd. 

The following is from Mr. Cotton's Diary : — 

1821. A Chapel in Pendref, formerly belonging to the Wesleyan 
Methodists, sold to a private individual, and let by him for the use : 
of a boys School. One Hundred and thirty boys in the School. 

In the Spring of this year, an Adult Sunday School, established for ' 
teaching the Welsh language, conducted by the Vicars, Church- , 
wardens, and principal Shop-keepers in Bangor. Attendance in 
numbers from 3 ) to 40. Hours, from 1 to half -past 3. 

The numbers attending the Communion at Easter (including ' 
Good Friday, Low Sunday, and Pentir Chapel), and a few infirm j 
persons living at a distance from the Church, amounted to 410. 

Great increase in the size of Bangor, several new houses built* ! 
but of a poor description. The Census was taken in May, and ; 
amounted in the whole Parish to 3,579. In the town to 1, 138 males ; \ 
females, 1,175; total, 2,313. 

1822. The Service of Pentir Chapel, formerly performed every \ 
alternate Sunday in the morning, was first performed in the year 1817 
on every Sunday in the evening ; the Vicars agreeing for the benefit 
of that portion of the Parish to pay a Curate for that purpose. The 
Salary given was £30, which was accepted by the Curate of Lias- 



17 

liolen. Ou thi Great Festivals, however, the Service is 

irmed in the lings, with a Communion. The effect* of this 
igeroent have beeu rery beneficial The attendance is doubled, 
some persons at the outskirts of the Parish attend the morning 
ice at the lea most contiguous to them. — Good Singing 

a Sunday School— the children joining in the responses and 

he Diary contains also an entry to the effect, that the 
irchwardens and Overseers of the Parish of Bangor.made 
actice of going round to inspect Public-houses on Sunday, 
t-hich inspection Mr. Cotton, in his capacity of County 
pstrate, frequently joined. This was, of course, long 
re the formation of the Police Force. 



CHAPTER II. 

l822 TO 1837. 



Opening of the first National School at Bangor— Mr. Cotton's speech 
on the occasion— Death of Mrs. Cotton— Monumental inscription 
—Restoration of Bangor Cathedral— Mr. Cotton's application to 
Dean and Chapter for the use of the- nave of the Cathedral- 
Extract from Browne Willis' History of Bangor, •Cathedral- 
Mr. Cotton's second marriage, and issue — Death of Mrs. Cotton- 
Monumental inscription — Savings Bank defalcation — Death of 
Bishop Majendie, and translation of Bishop Bethell — Speech at 
Beaumaris Royal Eisteddfod — Building of Bangor Infant School- 
Speech at a Banquet, in celebration of the birthday of Princess 
Victoria. 

When Mr. Cotton came to Bangor in the year 18 10, there 
was no School accommodation in the Parish for the educar 
tion of the poorer classes ; but a house was rented for the 
purpose, under *Dr. Bell's system, at Berllan Bach, Bangor, 
which continued to be used for Educational purposes until 
the 1 st. of January, 1-822, when the first National School 
Buildings for Bangor were opened. 

On that occasion, the children, in number exceeding 400, 
assembled in the Schoolroom, from whence, after prayer and 
preliminary arrangement, they walked in order to the Cathe- 
dral, preceded by a band of music, with flags bearing 
appropriate devices. After Divine Service, the procession, 
on returning to the School, assumed a more imposing:] 
appearance, as had been previously arranged, in the following] 
order — Boys, Girls, Band, Tradesmen, Gentlemen, Ladies,! 
Churchwardens and Clergy, the two vergers in their gownsj 
closing the whole. 

* " Who teacheth others will be brought 

To learn much more than those he taught" 

Which Mr. Cotton translated into Welsh, thus : — 

" Tr bwn a ddysg y rhai heb ddysg, 
A dysg efe ei nun a mag." 



19 

Bishop Majendie having previously entered the School- 
room, then received the procession. After the whole were 
seated, the Reverend J. H. Cotton addressed the meeting in 
the following terms : — 

My Lord Bishop, Ladie3 and Gentlemen, I congratulate yon all 
upon the opening of a new year : and I bless God, that I have the 
happiness of witnessing together with you the completion of this 
excellent work, the first stone of which was laid upon so auspicious a 
day — the day of the coronation of our present gracious Majesty. I 
shall not detain you long from your family circles, though 1 must 
entreat your pardon, if I occupy your time and attention a short time, 
while I enter into some particulars as to the circumstances of the 
place in which we are now collected. If I trespass in length of 
detail, I doubt not (estimating as I do the feelings of all here present), 
that the gladdening scene before us will ensure the pardon which I 



I shall begin by stating the necessity of this Building. No one 
will doubt that in a place of this growing respectability, and increas- 
ing population, it was absolutely necessary to erect a suitable room 
for the religious and moral education of its children. Every town in 
this Diocese (this only excepted), is provided with such a room, 
while we were compelled to take up with any place which could be 
hired, however ill suited to the purpose. Xext as to the situation of 
the School, it will be readily allowed that the situation of any 
Institution which is least calculated to annoy that portion of the 
community, which are to contribute to its support, and best cal- 
culated to accommodate those who are to receive benefit from it, is 
the best possible situation which could be fixed upon. Both these 
qualifications meet in this situation — it is removed from the best 
portion of the town — it is removed from the public road, while it is 
open to public view. It stands nearly in the centre of the town, at 
equal distances from both extremes, and is placed where all the poorer 
orders liva The dimensions of the room are these : The building is 
in itself, within the walls, 85 feet in length, and in breadth 32 feet ; 
in height 16 feet to the bottom of the roof, and 11 more to the centre. 
The building is, we hope, well calculated for our purpose, being well 
supplied with ventilators, both in the windows and roof, having no 
windows to the exposed aspect, and having back doors to each of the 
courts, covered with porches and double doors, a screen in the 
centre to divide the sexes, which may be drawn or undrawn in an 
instant ; an entrance is also provided at one angle, by which the 
ladies, who visit the female School, may enter in without passing 



20 

either through the boys or the back courts. Large drains also pass 
through the building ; a foot pavement around it, and an excellent 
road made on the best principles, leads to the main Street. The 
ground on which it stands is procured from the Dean of Bangor, upon 
a lease of 60 years, having a clause by which the Committee are 
empowered to purchase the premises within the first 20 years, for the 
sum of £130. The ground rent is £7 per annum. The building by the 
original contract was to have amounted only to £500 ; but it was 
found necessary in the progress of the work, to make some alterations. 
These, together with the several additions I have just named to you, 
will make the whole amount to £600, as near as can be calculated. 
To meet this expense, the following sums have been collected, which 
I shall name in detail : — ' Donations from Land-owners and inhabi- 
tants, £254 17s. ; Savings out of our current income, £86 0s. Od. ; 
Interest upon this sum in the Savings' Bank, £10 0s. lid. ; Grant 
from the National Society in London, £90 ; a Loan from the 
Bishop of £150, making a total of £600 17s. lid., so that a 
larger sum has been obtained than has been expended, and we 
should have had some excess on the building account, had we not 
been obliged to borrow £7 from our stock towards a temporary 
arrangement in a former Schoolroom. This sum together with the 
expenses of this day, may, perhaps, amount to about £10. It 
must be remembered, however, that the Schoolroom, and the ground 
on which it stands, is loaded with a debt of £280 ; being the amount 
of the Bishop's loan of £150, and £130 the purchase of the land 
belonging to the Dean. It is proposed by a Sinking Fund to meet 
this debt ; and as the Committee have been enabled to save nearly 
£100 in the last three years, they hope they are not too sanguine in 
assuming that the £280 will be liquidated long before the expiration 
of the 20 years, already alluded to. And now, having gone through 
all the necessary detail, it becomes me, in the name of our Committee, 
to return thanks to all who have so liberally and steadily given their 
assistance. 

Our best thanks then in the first place, are due to the Lord Bishop, 
for his kind loan of £150, without interest, in addition to his Lord- 
ship's liberal benefaction of £100. Our thanks are next due to The 
Very Rev. The Dean, for his ready attention to the wishes of the 
Committee in accommodating them with the site of this building. To 
the National Society in London, for thei* liberal grant of £90. Next 
must we thank Mr. Hall, of this city, for having supplied us with a 
plan of this building, and for superintending the work with so much 
ability and zeal. Our particular thanks are also due to that respect- 
able body I see now before me, I mean the tradesmen of this city, 



21 

who have come forward upon this day, as they did on the celebration 
of the Coronation, in the support of piety, loyalty, and good order, 
acts these which mark at once their good sense and good conduct. 
We should also be wanting in gratitude, did we not thank the four 
following persons, Mr. Thomas, the Mason, for his attention to the 
work : Mr. Towers, the Iron-founder ; Mr. Heywood, the Watch- 
maker ; and Mr. D. Griffith, the Contractor, for their respective gifts 
to the School ; and while the name of the last person is on my lips, 
I beg leave to say, that he deserves all praise, not in having com- 
pleted the work according to contract, but in having gone beyond the 
letter of his agreement, both in quality of work and materials. 
And now, having so fully laid before you the liberal spirit of so many 
zealous friends, and fully expressed, as I hope, our sense of gratitude 
to them, it will be unnecessary to say much to encourage a feeling, 
which has been already so fully excited. I see here so many firm 
friends of the good cause, that I have every pledge afforded of the 
same support we have hitherto experienced. A building founded on 
religion and loyalty shall never totter, much less shall it fall. Indeed, 
what institution so well deserves your support, as that which 
embraces every thing which is valuable to man, religion, morality, 
loyalty, whose object it is to form obedient children, faithful servants, 
honest men, and pious Christians. In promoting these objects, a 
man best secures his own interest and happiness ; and though the 
good effects resulting from the education of these particular children, 
may not return to him here, he may rest assured, that in promoting 
their welfare and happiness, he is eventually ensuring his own, and 
in the same proportion as he blesses others will be blessed himself ; if 
in promoting this, and every other pious work, he intends not the 
establishment of his own credit, but the increase of his heavenly 
Master's honour. 

These remarks I beg to urge more particularly upon the Tradesmen 
of this city, the advantages arising from this Institution are doubly 
applicable to them : to this place must they look for all those prin- 
ciples of piety and morality, and for all such instructions as are best 
calculated to make their children useful mechanics, respectable 
members of society, and pious members of the Christian Church. 
And since without the help of God, the best directed efforts of men 
are vain, let us entreat his blessing through the mouths of these 
children." 

A prayer was then repeated fromrnemory, first in the Welsh 

language, and afterwards in English, by two of the Scholars. 

The pronouncing of the Benediction by the Bishop brought 



22 

the meeting to a close. His Lordship had previously intended 
to address the meeting, but declared that he felt so much 
affected by the scene before him, that he dared not trust his 
feelings. 

At the close of the meeting a collection was made, amount- 
m g t0 jQ 11 5 s - 6d. As this was proceeding, a message was 
sent from the Society of Calvinistic Methodists, declaring it 
to be their intention to make a collection for the National 
School, in consequence of the convenience of the new road, 
now called Dean Street,* which, as it led to the National 
School, passed by their Chapel-door. A collection was 
accordingly made, amounting to ^5, which was handed 
over to the School Committee. 

At the latter end of the year 1823, Mrs. Cotton died. A 
marble tablet raised to her memory in Bangor Cathedral bears 
the following inscription : — 

|rr Hfemorg 

OP 

MARY ANNE, 

WIFE OP 

The Rev. James Henry Cotton, 
Precentor and Vicar 

OF THIS CHUBOH, 

AND DAUGHTER OF 

HENRY WILLIAM MAJENDIE, 
Lord Bishop of this Diocese, 

WHO DIED OCTOBER 8TH., 1823, 

AGED 35. 

Her body lies in the adjoining 

Burial Ground. 
•' Blessed are the poor in Spirit, 

For theirs is the kingdom of heaven. 
Blessed are the meek : 
For they shall inherit the earth. 
Blessed are the pure in heart, 
For they shall see God." 

St. Matthew v. 3, 5, 8. 

* Some years after the erection of this School, the greater number of the houses 
now forming Dean Street were built. The Welsh name of the Street is OaeV Deon, or 
Dean's Field, because it was the property of Dean Warren. 



23 

In the year 1824, Mr. Cotton undertook the Restoration 
of Bangor Cathedral, which was in a deplorable state of 
delapidation ; some portion of the floor in the nave being 
without flagstones, and the rain dropping in through the roof. 
The work occupied three years and a half, during which time 
Divine Services were held in the National Schoolroom, there 
being no Parish church at Bangor.* 

" The Diary has the following entry : — 

1824. In the Spring of this year, the repairs of the Cathedral 
having been commenced, the Bishop granted his license to the 
National School Room for the purposes of Divine worship : it was 
accordingly fitted up at the expense of £40. The arrangements were 
so made as to suit the purposes of a Church on the Sabbath, and School 
on week days, holding commodiously about 500 persons attending 
worship. 

The cost of this Restoration was ,£5,300, out of which 
^2,000 came from the tithes of Llandinam, Montgomery- 
shire, appropriated by an act of James II., 1685, for the 
repairs of Bangor Cathedral,! and the remainder, ,£3,300 
were collected in different parts of the kingdom through the 
praiseworthy and indefatigable exertions of Mr. Cotton, the 
whole of which sum was expended under his superintendance. 
It is true that the internal fittings of the Cathedral were of 
inferior quality — the Bishop's throne, pulpit, stalls, and pews 
being of stained deal ; and it must be admitted, and Mr. 

* " Besides the Cathedral Church, which is dedicated to St. Daniel, there was formerly 
a Pariah Church of St. Mary, which stood at the back of the Bishop's Palace, about 400 
yard 8 distant from the Cathedral : the ground on which it stood, together with the 
Church-yard belongs to the Vicars Choral, who let it out, and rec ive the rent of it, 
which is 6s. 8d. per annum, as they do the rent of three small Quillets or Parcels of 
ground, let for 5s. 6d., on which, 'tis suppos'd there stood formerly houses belonging 
to some of the Church-members. When St. Mary's Church was demolish'd, there is 
no tradition, and the very foundations of it, and the old Castle, said to have been 
heretofore in or near this town, are so perish'd, that they can't be traced out with any 
certainty, tho' there is a hill on the side of the town, which bears the name of Bryn 
y Castle, or Castle-hill ; but whether it be from the Castle's having stood there is not 
well known by the inhabitants. There have been often human bones dug up on the 
Bite of St. Mary's Church and Church-yard. 

•' Here was hard by the Cathedral Church-yard Gate, not long since, an Hein-house, 
or Bishop's Gaol, but the same is fallen down, and become part of the delapidations of 
the Bishopriok."— Browne Willi*' History of Bangor Cathedral, p. 46. 

t " The Endowment of the Choir, and Reparation of the Church, arises from the 
lents of the sinecure of Llandinam, Co , Montgomery, now set at £172 per annum, 
which were appropriated by Act of Parliament, Anno 1685, to that purpose. Before 
which time the Cathedral Service and Fabric were supported solely by contributions of 



24 

Cotton acknowledged it himself, that the restoration com- 
pleted in the year 1827, partook more of the nature of a 
restoration of a Parish Church than of a Cathedral. Indeed, 
the principal object in view was to provide sufficient 
accommodation in the Cathedral Building to cope with the 
rapid increase in the population of the town, and the great 
influx of visitors during the Summer months. Still, for the 
money, and under the circumstances, it was, perhaps, the best 
that could be done. Moreover, when we bear in mind that 
ecclesiastical taste was not then what it is now, the lethargy 
and apathy which had, at that time, possessed both Clergy and 
Laity, and the difficulty of obtaining pecuniary aid, owing to 
so many local claims for the building and supporting of 
Schools, we must give Mr. Cotton full credit for completing 
a great and much needed work, almost single handed. 

At the completion of this Restoration, the nave of the 
Cathedral was set apart as a Welsh Parish Church, being 
divided from the Choir and transepts by a partition, above 
which was the organ-loft ; but during the late extensive and 
elaborate restoration begun in 1868, this partition was taken 
down, and the Cathedral-building thrown open from east to 
west. 

We insert here Mr. Precentor Cotton's application to the 
Dean and Chapter for the use of the nave of the Cathedral 
to hold special Services. 

"The Precentor is desirous of giving some additional spiritual 
advantages to the English population of the town of Bangor. 

" His present duties consist in an attendance at the choral services 
of the Church, in a general superintendance of the Choir, &c, &c, 
and in preaching five English Sermons during each year. 

"He proposes (in consideration of the income now granted him 
from the Choral Funds) to read the prayers of the Church, and to 
to preach a Sermon every Sunday evening ; he proposes to light the 

the Bishop and Chapter, and what they could get by begging from other persons in the 
Diocese, was apply 'd to the same use. It was usual before this settled Endowment, 
for most persons in this Diocese to leave somewhat by Will to the Church of Bangor. 
Some did it voluntarily ; others as they were moved to it. However, there was some- 
thing left by most of them, according to their several abilities."-— .Browne Witli*' 
History of Bangor Cathedral (1721), pages 30. 31. 



25 

nave of the Church, in which part he proposes to perform the Service, 
and to pay any expenses attendant npon such service, &c. He intends 
by this offer to give to the middle and lower ranks of the English 
population, as well as to the larger children of the National School, 
an opportunity of attending upon, and joining in a Service better 
calculated for their benefit than the Choral Services of the Church. 
He proposes that this Service, &c. , should commence at a quarter 
past six o'clock, immediately after the evening Choral Service. This 
time will be found most convenient for tradesmen, mechanics, and 
the servants of Gentlemen, &c. 

Services at this hour now take place in every town in the king- 
dom, and are found to be well attended by the description of persons 
alluded to. 

The Precentor proposes to engage for one year, to try the effect 
of this plan, intending not to press its continuance, unless such a 
congregation shall assemble as shall justify its continuance. He 
solicits the Bishop to allow him to make the experiment ; and he asks 
the Dean and Chapter to grant him the use of the Nave of the 
Cathedral, and of the lamps, books, organ, &c, he paying all charges 
attendant upon the use of them, and making an acknowledgment in 
money for any damage occasioned to them by wear, practice, or re- 
moval. 

J. H. COTTON. 
Bangor, Oct. 16th, 1827. 

The Precentor does not ask the assistance of any other person, nor 
will he consider any assistance offered by a brother Clergyman as any 
relief to him ; but he presumes that the Bishop, Dean, the members 
of the Chapter, when resident, and any Clergy living in the town 
will not be unwilling occasionally to confer a benefit upon the people by 
preaching, as is usual at Chester, Liverpool, Ruthin, Pwllheli, and 
most places in the kingdom. 

In the year 1826, Mr. Cotton married Mary Laurens, 
daughter of Samuel Fisher, Esquire, M.D., of Bath, and niece 
of the then Lord Bishop of Salisbury, by whom he had two 
daughters, Mary and Ann. 

Extract from Diary. 1826. — December. The Penny Club for 
the School children, instituted last year, continues to prosper — 90 
admitted — amount of collection about £35. Number in Sunday 
School 300. 

This excellent Penny Clothing Club, established by Mr, 



26 

Cotton in 1825, is still carried on, and has proved to be a 
great help to the poor and working classes with large families. 
The children pay a penny every Sunday at the Sunday School, 
which amounts at the end of the year to 4s. 4d., to which a 
bonus of equal amount is added, making the total sum of 
8s. 8d. to be received by each child at the close of the year. 

Early in the year 1828, Mrs. Cotton died. A marble 
tablet raised to her memory in Bangor Cathedral, bears the 
following inscription : — 

|rr P*m0rg 

OF 

MARY, 

THE SECOND WIFE OF 

The Rev. James Henry Cotton, 
Precentor and Vicar 

OF THIS CHURCH, 
AND DAUGHTER OF 

SAMUEL FISHER, M.D., 

OF THE CITY OF BATH. 

she died january 27th., 1828, 
Aged 28. 

Her body lies in the 

Adjoining Burial Ground. 

"The fruit of the Spirit is 

Love, Joy, Peace, 

Longsuffering, Gentleness, 

Goodness, Faith, Meekness, 

Temperance." 

Gal. v. 22, 23. 

In the year 1818, a Saving's Bank was established at 

Bangor, chiefly through the exertions of Mr. Cotton. The 
following is from Mr. Cotton's Diary : — 

1818. October 2nd. The Savings Bank opened at Berllan Bach- 
School Room, after several previous meetings having been held* The 



27 

deposits, including Subscriptions, amounted to £493. The Charity 
School Fund deposited £50. 

Some years after the establishing of this Savings Bank, 
the Trustees sustained a heavy loss through misplaced con- 
fidence in the Manager. In the face of this, Mr. Cotton 
wrote thousands of begging letters for subscriptions to 
diminish their loss ; and during a visit to Birmingham, he 
made a house to house collection for the same purpose, 
during which he narrowly escaped apprehension as a begging 
imposter ! Notwithstanding all his exertions, he had to pay 
^1,200, and his Co- Vicar, and Co-Trustees, the Reverend 
Hugh Price, and Mr. Dawkins Pennant, a thousand pounds 
each. 

On the 9th, July, I830, Bishop Majendie, Mr. Cotton's 
father-in-law, died, having presided over the Diocese of 
Bangor for 2 1 years, and was succeeded by Bishop Bethell, 
who had been successively Dean of Chichester, Bishop of 
Gloucester, and Exeter. 

The following is the inscription on Bishop Majendie's 
monument within Bangor Cathedral. 

Sbmtb ta ijj* UUmurg ai 

HENRY WILLIAM MAJENDIE, D.D., 
Who died at the house of his son, the Vicar of Longdon, near 

Lichfield, 
July 9th 1830, Aged 75 Yeaes and 9 Months, 
And was buried in a Vault within the Church of Longdon. 
In early life he was honored by the personal regard of that 
Truly virtuous monarch, King George the III., by whom he was 

appointed 

Preceptor to Prince William Henry, our present sovereign, 

After holding successively a canonry of Windsor and St. Pauls, 

He was consecrated to the Bishopric of Chester in the year 1800, 

and in the year 1809, was translated to that of Bangor. 
He married April 11th 1785, Anne, the eldest daughter of Henry 

Routlegde, of Stapleton, in the County of Cumberland, 

Esquire, 



28 

By whom he had thirteen children. 
During an Episcopacy of thirty years, he was distinguished 
By a faithful and zealous discharge of his Sacred duties, and by 
a constant endeavour to increase the usefulness and pro- 
mote the welfare of his Clergy. 
As a preacher, he employed the eminent powers of oratory, which 
he possessed, in forwarding the will of his heavenly Master, 

And bringing men into the true fold of Jesus Christ. 
His private character was marked by that spirit of Christian Benevo- 
lence, which is ever ready to give, and glad to distribute. 
By that Charity which thinketh no evil, and by an unaffected sim- 
plicity and suavity of demeanour to all around him. 
What he was as a husband and a father, those only can know 
Who most deeply feel his loss, and cherish the hope of re-union with 

him, 
In a more perfect state of existence hereafter, 
Through the merits of Jesus Christ. 

We should not omit to mention that Mr. Cotton attended 
the Beaumaris Royal Eisteddfod in the month of August, 
1832, at which her late Royal Highness the Duchess of Kent, 
and the Princess (now Queen) Victoria were present, and 
took an active part in the proceedings. During the stay of 
the Royal party at Plas Newydd, the seat of the Marquis of 
Anglesey, Mr Cotton had the honour of being invited there 
by the Duchess of Kent. 

At the above Eisteddfod a prize of ^15, and a medal of 
the value of £$ were offered for the best Essay in English 
on the History of the Island of Anglesey, with Biographical 
sketches of the eminent men it had produced ; and a premium 
of £y 1 os. for the second best Essay in English on the same 
subject. Mr. Cotton, with others, was appointed adjudica- 
tor. In delivering his adjudication, 

Mr. Cotton said, that he had been, among others, selected to 
pronounce a decision as to the comparative claims of the several 
Essays on the History of the Island of Anglesey. He felt himself in 
many views incompetent to the task. In particular, he was not a 



29 

native of Cambria, and even if he had possessed all the requisite 
qualifications, he must lament that the time* he could bestow upon 
the subject had been much too limited. He had, however, no hesita- 
tion in declaring it to be his opinion that the Essay, which assumed 
the fictitious name of " Bronwen," had by far the greatest merit. The 
writer seems to posse3S stores of information which had never 
previously been opened, and which perhaps, would never have 
come to light, had it not been for the industry of the author. Indeed, 
the Essay was like the Island of Anglesey itself — it contained ore of 
inestimable price — ore which it was difficult to find, but which when 
discovered, proved not only to be valuable, but most abundant. 
There was, as he already intimated, a distinctive character about the 
Essay— it was peculiarly national. A tone pervaded it, which consti- 
tuted its high recommendation to the meeting. The author, he felt 
persuaded, must be a Cymro — a Cymro not by name only, but vitus 
# in cute To none could the words of the immortal bard be more 
justly, or more appropriately applied : — 

En Ner a folant, 
En hiaith a gadwant, 
Eu tir a gollant, 
Ond Gwyllt Walia. 

These lines he would take the liberty of translating, for the benefit 
of some of the " country gentlemen." The translation would not pre- 
w&t the characteristic alteration of the original, but this he trusted, 
would be forgiven. 

Their Lord, they land, 
Their language love, 
Their land they lose, 
Except wild Wales. 

1 He was about to hazard a remark, which might appear in a Saxon 
*° be a sketch of the imagination, but he hoped that under such 
<ar cnmstances, even a Saxon might be allowed to catch a small portion 
°* poetic fire. Who that examined the Essay which had called forth 
these observations, and saw its correct and beautiful representation 
°i the Island of Anglesey, but must be excused, if he indulged in a 
%ht of fancy, and imagined the author to have soared to the heights 
°* Snowdon itself, to have plucked a quill from one of its own eagles, 
•^ to have described with it, in language of incomparable accuracy 
** taste, all the varying characteristics of the Island. The Essay 
t° which he adverted was, beyond question, the most valuable that 
tod been offered on that occasion. There was however, another, the 
Production of a writer who signed himself " Investigator," which 
stained a fund of good sense, and which was drawn up with much 
r^wpicuity, and in excellent taste. It was calculated to offer both 

D 



30 

information and delight to the general reader. It entered very cir- 
cumstantially into the history of Beaumaris, its antiquities, and its 
later improvements. It told the world of that which it was impossible 
for those before whom he had the honour of speaking, ever to forget. 
It expatiated on the signal munificence which distinguished the former 
illustrious and benevolent possessor of Baron Hill. But in offering 
this deserved tribute on the altar of departed excellence, the writer 
had not exhausted his subject. He had recorded many delightful 
instances of liberality on the part of the present justly respected pro- 
prietor, while he left much, indeed, for the future historian to hand 
down to posterity of the patriotism and liberality of that truly 
exalted and noble house." 

The Reverend gentleman concluded amidst the loudest 
acclamations of the meeting by applying the following stanza 
to the President, — Sir Richard Bulkeley Williams Bulkeley — 

Llwyddiant i'w deulu, 
Llwyddiant i'w dy, 
Llwyddiant i'w gariad, 
A dedwydd bo hi. 

Although Mr. Cotton was an Englishman, yet, by his long 
residence in Wales, the lively interest which he took in 
Eisteddfodau, Literary meetings, and all other national 
institutions conducive to the prosperity of the principality — 
and the fact that — to extend the sphere of his usefulness — he 
had striven hard to learn the Welsh language, and had care- 
fully studied the history, antiquity, and literature of his 
adopted country, he was a great favourite with the masses, 
and was considered and claimed as a Welshman. 

In the year 1835, the Infant Schools, situated in Drum 
Street, were begun through the exertions of Mr. Cotton. In 
his Diary Mr. Cotton says : — 

"1835. The new Infant School Rooms, situated at the back of 
the National School were begun. Application made to the public 
for means, and a memorial addressed to the Lords of the Treasury 
was filled up ; signed by all Denominations." 

At a public dinner, in celebration of the birthday of our 
present Queen, the Vice-President, John Williams, Esquire, 
now of Treffos, Anglesey, in proposing the toast, drew the 



81 

attention of the company to the very interesting sight they 
had that day witnessed ; a sight which was truly pleasing, 
and at the same time affecting, to see the behaviour of the 
700 children, who had this day through the city testified, by 
their hymns of praise and shouts of joy, their warm and 
genuine attachment for the person and happiness of Her 
Royal Highness, the Princess Victoria. This however, 
as regards these children could not have occurred from 
common accident. It shows some kind hand, and sympa- 
thizing mind, must have been engaged to mould and form the 
tender dispositions of the rising generations of Bangor and 
its vicinity to that unerring precept, " Train up a child in the 
way he should go." I perceive, gentlemen, we allow by 
common consent, to whom, under providence, that debt is 
personally due, and may our worthy Vicar, Mr. Cotton, long 
enjoy the precious fruits of arduous ministerial duties, and 
may his heart enjoy the gratification of seeing that his labours 
amongst us are not in vain. The announcement of Mr. 
Cotton's health was most warmly received by the company. 

Mr. Cotton in acknowledging the toast, said ; 

He would not conceal his feelings, but admit at once he was 
pleased with the remark, which the force of a moral and religious 
education had drawn out from the beliaviour and conduct of the 
children, to whom Mr. Williams alluded. Parochial education is a 
mbject to which I have (as you seem to allow), paid much attention, 
and I have considered it a duty incumbent on me as a clergyman, to 
put it into practical effect in this city, and pariah of Bangor. My 
calls upon yon for support in aid of education have been, I acknow- 
ledge, frequent ; nor have I confined them to you alone, and here it 
iflj in this respect, nothing less than just and proper to state the 
munificent donations T received for public puqwscs from H.R.H., 
the Duchess of Kent, when resident a few years since at Plas New- 
ydd, and I thought this day was a very proper occasion for 
the children of the various Schools in and about Bangor to tes- 
tify their national loyalty, and hereby showing that we have not 
forgotten the past munificent acts of our Royal benefactress, but 
wish to cherish a grateful recollection of their residence amongst us, 
by giving vent to our best feelings upon the majority of H.R.H., the 



82 

•Princess Victoria. It is a great national blessing that her education 
has been completed under the ablest and best of teachers, persons 
who rank high for their religious and moral attainments, and what is 
still more, all this improvement of the mind acquired under the mater- 
nal eye of her Royal mother, and thus adapting her daughter by 
habit and education, to become one who can, when the period may 
arrive, rule wisely and well over her people, and become a nursing 
mother to the Church and her people. 



CHAPTER III. 

The Welsh Church — Labours of the Reverend Griffith Jones, 
Iilanddowror — The Welsh circulating Charity Schools — State 
of Education in Wales in 1760— Madam Sevan's Charity — 
Rowlands Llangeitho — Charles of Bala. 

The period immsdiately preceding the birth of Mr. Cotton, 
and that in which he lived, are very important epochs in the 
history of the Welsh Church, as marking, on the one hand, the 
state of Education in Wales, the separation of the Methodists* 
from the Church, the subsequent growth of Methodism, and, 
on the other hand, the great revival of work in the Church ; 
the regaining of her lost position, and her consequent rapid 
growing strength. It is not foreign to our purpose, and, we 
trust, no digression from the subject, nor uninteresting to the 
general reader to take a glimpse at these periods. 

To characterize the Church in Wales at any period as 
entirely void of life would be gross injustice. We need no 
further proof of that, than the fact, that reformation began 
within her own pale, and the great ' revivals/ which marked 
the close of the last and the beginning of the present 
century emanated, in a great degree, from the Clergy. The 
Welsh Church has from time to time possessed some Clergy 
of great piety, usefulness, and learning ; Rces Prichacd, the 
pious and able Vicar of Llanymddyfri, and author of 
" Canwyll y Cymry ;" Dr. William Morgan, Bishop of St. 
Asaph, the translator of the Welsh Bible ; Dr. Richard 
Parry, his successor, who published a revised edition of the 
Welsh Bible after his predecessor's death ; Archdeacon Prys ; 
Ellis Wynn, the author of" Bardd Cwsg ;" Theophilus Evans, 

* We may state here by way of explanation, that whereever tho word Mothodista 
herein, it 



mast be understood of the Calvinistic Mothodistn. No attempt was 
by any Wesleyan to preach in the Welsh language until the year 1800, and in 
thai year the Methodists assumed tho name Calvinidtic, to distingniah thorn from 
Axxoinian brethren* 



34 

the author of " Drych y Prif Oesoedd," are names familiar 
and dear to every Welshman ; their contributions to Welsh 
literature, and their self-sacrificing activity and service to 
their Church and generation, are such as can claim the 
lasting gratitude of posterity. 

The Reverends Griffith Jones, Llandd*>wror, Daniel 
Rowlands, Llangeitho, William Williams, of Pantycelyn, the 
" Sweet Psalmist of Wales ;" Peter Williams, the " Biblical 
Expositor ;" D. Jones, Llangan ; D. Griffiths, of Nefern, and 
Thomas Charles, of Bala, were all ordained Clergy of the 
Established Church, and, with the exception of Griffith 
Jones, who died in 1761, were all contemporaries of Mr. 
Cotton. These men are connected, more or less, with the 
establishing of Welsh Methodism, but our space will not 
permit us to notice more than the most prominent of them. 

The Reverend Griffith Jones, Llanddowror, was ordained 
in the year 1709, by the celebrated Bishop Bull. He was 
eminent as an author, preacher, and educationist, and is 
looked upon as the " morning Star " of Welsh Church-revival, 
and he continued a zealous pastor in the Church up to the 
time of his death. Besides contributions to English literature, 
he wrote, in Welsh, an elaborate exposition of the Church 
Catechism, in one large octavo volume ; ' A Call to the throne 
of Grace f sl book on the ' Necessity of instructing the 
ignorant ;' ' Forms of Prayer ;' ' A Guide to the throne of 
Grace,' and a ' Collection of the Poems of the Rev. Rees 
Prichard. Mr. Jones was the most popular and prominent 
preacher of his time, both as regards matter, eloquence, and 
feeling, and it is said that he seldom preached a sermon 
without producing a deep impression upon his hearers. As 
a parish priest he was most exemplary. On every Saturday 
preceding Communion Sunday, he read the service in Church, 
and after the second lesson, in accordance with the rubric, 
he would catechize his congregation on the two lessons 
which had been read. As an inducement to the poor and 



85 

older persons to attend these Semi-Catechetical services, Mr. 
Jones established a custom of distributing white bread, the 
cost of which he defrayed from the Offertory of Llanddowror 
Church, imposing upon each aged recipient the task of learning 
out by heart a verse from Scripture, for recitation in Church 
at every such service. This plan of catechizing the congre- 
gation proved to be exceedingly beneficial for the instruc- 
tion of the ignorant, as well as a means of making Mr. Jones 
acquainted with the ignorance which prevailed among the 
poorer classes, and resulted in the establishing of * Welsh 
Circulating Schools ' throughout the principality, the first of 
which he established in his own parish, and supported it by 
the Communion Offertory. 

" The plan on which Griffith Jones proceeded was simply 
this : — He first engaged a body of schoolmasters, and then 
distributed them in different directions over the country. 
The duty of these men was to teach the people to read the 
Scriptures in the Welsh language, to catechize them, to 
instruct them in psalmody, and to promote their advance- 
ment by every means in their power. They were sent, in the 
first instance, to the nearest town or village where their 
assistance had been requested, and then having taught all 
who were desirous of instruction, they were to pass on to the 
next district where a similar feeling had been manifested. 
In the course of time, they were to revisit the localities 
whence they had at first started, and resume the work of 
education anew on the youth who had sprung up during their 
absence, and thus making a continual circuit of the whole 
country, to present to every generation, as it arose, the means 
of knowledge, and the incentives to virtuous principle."* 

Mr. Jones also established a Training School for teachers 
at Llanddowror. Among his pupils may be mentioned 
Howel Harris ; Howel Davies ; Williams, Pantycelyn, and 
Peter Williams ; but they were under his tuition not as school 

* Johnes' Causes of Dissent in Wales, p. 18. 



86 



teachers, but as candidates preparing for college, preparatory 
to taking Holy Orders. 

These Circulating Schools were open to every age, and it 
is said that in the space of 24 years, no less than 150,212 
persons of every age from six to seventy years old were 
taught to read their Welsh Bibles. The success of Mr. 
Jones' plan was so great, that the number of schools through- 
out the principality in the year 1760 was 215, having 8687 
scholars, as follows : — 



NORTH WALES. 



SOUTH WALES. 



COUNTY. 



Anglesey 

Carnarvon 

Merioneth 

Denbigh 

Montgomery 



No. of 


No. of 


Schools. 


Scholars? 


25 


1023 


27 


981 


15 


508 


8 


307 


12 


339 
3158 


87 



COUNTY. 



Brecon 

Cardigan 

Carmarthen 

Glamorgan 

Monmouth 

Pembroke 



No. of 


No. of 


Schools. 


Scholars 


4 


196 


20 


1153 


54 


2410 


25 


872 


2 


Gl 


23 


837 


128 


5529 



Total, throughout North and South Wales, 
Scholars— 8G87. 



Schools— 215; 



Mr. Jones was very materially assisted in supporting and 
establishing these Circulating Schools, by liberal grants of 
thousands of Bibles and othe r valuable books by the Society 
for Promoting Christian Knowledge, established in the year 
1698. Mrs. Bevan, an intimate friend of Mr. Jones, and a 
regular attendant at his church, was also a very liberal sup- 
porter ot these schools during his life-time, and after his 
death. 

In the year 1777, sixteen years after the death of Mr. Jones, 
and two years before the demise of Mrs. Bevan, the schools 
numbered 6,465, and the scholars 314,051. "Few men 
have conferred greater benefits on their country, than Wales 
derived from the labours of the good rector of Llanddowror, 
and to him it was in great part owing that the Bible has 



87 

been so generally found and read in the Welsh cottage. Not 
only was he enabled by his own self-denial, and the cliarity 
of others, to achieve this large amount of good in his life- 
time, but at his death he left in the hands of his friend, 
Madam Bevan, upwards of ^7000! to be applied by her for 
the same objects, and that lady, who died in 1779, B avc ^ ie 
books and the estate of the late Griffith Jones, and also the 
residue of her own estate, for the use of the Welsh Circulat- 
ing Charity Schools, so long as the same should continue, 
and for the increase and improvement of Christian knowledge. 
One of the Trustees of the will of Madam Be van possessed 
herself of the property thus bequeathed, and having refused 
to apply it for the charitable purposes directed by the will, 
the schools were closed for many years, pending an Informa- 
tion by the Attorney General, and the Charity only came 
again into operation in 1809, since which time it has been 
managed under a scheme embodied in an order of the Lord 
Chancellor, made the nth. July, 1807, of which the following 
are the principal regulations." 

That the Trustees of the charity appoint schoolmasters of com- 
petent abilities and good character, (members of the Established 
Church), who, being approved of by the bishop of the diocese, or by 
some two or more Clergymen named by him, shall receive salaries not 
exceeding £7 10s. a quarter ; but no person shall be appointed a 
Schoolmaster without conforming himself pursuant to the Act of 
Uniformity. 

That the Trustees appoint schools at such towns, villages, and 
places, within the principality of Wales, as with the concurrence 
of the bishop or such clergymen, they shall deem convenient. 

That each of such schools be continued in the same place for such 
term as shall be expressed by the bishop of the diocese or such 
clergymen. 

That the duty of the schoolmaster shall consist in teaching the 
children, both male and female, of poor indigent persons to read, in 
making them learn by heart the Creed, the Lord's Prayer, the 
Commandments, and the Church Catechism ; and in going with and 
attending such children in the parish church on the Lord's Day, and 
as often on other days, when Divine Service shall be performed, as 
may be convenient. 



88 

That tho Trustees appoint two fit and discreet members of the 
Church to be approved of by the bishop of the diocese, at a salary 
not oxcoeding £30 a year for each, to be visitors of the schools, who 
shall visit and inspect every school in their district once in six 
months, and report on the state of the schools to tho Trustees and 
the bishop. 

That the Trustees meet yearly in tho town of Cardigan, on the 
last day of the Autumn great Sessions for that County, to take into 
consideration tho general state and concerns of the charity. * 

The amount actually bequeathed by Madam Bevan was 
;£io,ooo, and from the year 1779 t0 1809, ^ na d accumu- 
lated to ,£30,000, 3 per cent consols, yielding an annual 
income of £"944 12 s. During the thirty years that this 
Chancery suit was pending the country suffered very much, 
and gradually reverted into the deplorable condition in which 
Mr. Jones found it when he first established the Circulating 
Schools. But during this long interval, the Reverend 
Thomas Charles, of Bala, by his unceasing labours in behalf 
of education, did much to stem the tide of ignorance which 
then threatened to inundate the principality. 

Fortunately, Madam Bevan's Charity came into operation 
just about the time that Mr. Cotton became Vicar of Bangor, 
by which he was, no doubt, materially assisted in establish- 
ing schools. He was the great consolidator of the work 
which Griffith Jones had so nobly inaugurated in the year 
1730, and as regards the work of education generally, we 
know of no one upon whom the good Rector of Lknddow- 
ror's " mantle fell " in the last generation, except it be Mr, 
Cotton. 

We now pass on to the most prominent character in the 
history of Welsh Methodism. 

The Reverend Daniel Rowlands^ Llangeitho. He is said 
to have led a dissipated life in the early part of his 
ministry. About the year 1735, ms mind was deeply im- 
pressed while listening to a sermon by the Reverend 

* WalcB, by Sir Thomas Phillips, p.p. 286, 380. 



39 

Griffith Jones, Llanddowror, at Llanddewibrefi Church, where 
Rowlands had resorted to hear him. It is said that 
Rowlands 1 demeanour during the sen-ice was so offensive to 
this eminent preacher, that he made special reference to him 
in his prayer, and with a blessed result. A biographer says, 
"his church, until now but thinly attended, began to be 
crowded with hearers. Known at first in his own neighbour- 
hood as ' the mad parson,' it was not long before he was 
reputed to be the mightiest preacher of his time. Llangeitho 
became the Jerusalem of Wales." 

Rowland's ministry was peculiarly productive of great 
revivals. The pathos and feeling with which he read and 
preached were overpowering. It was during the reading of 
that beautiful obsecration of our Litany, " By thine agony 
and Bloody Sweat,'' that one of the most powerful revivals 
broke forth ; the words fell like heavenly thunderbolts, as it 
were, upon the worshippers, and they were bathed in tears : a 
striking proof of the adaptability of our Liturgy to the Welsh 
mind, when feelingly read. 

The obscure little village of Llangeitho became the scene 
of monthly pilgrimages from all parts of the principality, to 
partake of the Holy Eucharist, the celebration of which was the 
most prominent feature in Rowlands' ministry. It is said 
that from two to three thousand partook of Holy Communion 
monthly, and Rowlands was assisted in the administration by 
other clergy. His zeal and earnestness prompted him 
to preach in the "highways and hedges," and in conse- 
quence of his persisting in a practice from which his diocesan, 
Bishop Samuel Squire, who presided over the see of St. 
David's from 1761 to 1766, had several times endeavoured 
to disuade him, Rowlands was eventually inhibited from 
officiating in that diocese, the notice of which was publicly 
served upon him just after he had finished reading the 
service, and was about to ascend the pulpit at Llanddewi- 
brefi Church. Having read the Inhibition himself, he 



40 

announced its contents to his hearers, and leaving the church 
his congregation followed him, weeping. This proceeding 
happened about the year 1763, in the thirtieth year of his 
ministry, (for he took Orders while a minor,) and resulted in 
the erection of a spacious chapel at Llangeitho, where 
Rowlands officiated up to the time of his death, in 1790, 
with the same marvellous success as had attended his 
ministrations at Llangeitho parish Church. Bishop Squire 
was translated to Oxford in 1766, from thence to London in 
1777, where he died in 1787. It is said that his proceedings 
against Rowlands gave him much pain, and that he expressed 
profound sorrow for his conduct on his death-bed. It was 
the opinion of Dr. Burgess, late Bishop of St. David's, that 
had his predecessor rightly considered the deplorable moral 
condition of the people, he would not have dealt so 
arbitrarily in the matter. 

Although Rowlands was thus separated from the Church, 
. he was still a churchman, and nothing could be further from 
his mind than the creation of schism, as the following 
incident, which we translate from Rowlands' Welsh 
Biography, page 125, by the Rev. John Owen, Rector of 
Thrussington, testifies. " The last time that Rowlands saw 
Nathaniel, his son, a short time before his death, in 
conversing, Rowlands told him, in substance, as follows : — 'I, 
have been persecuted till I am tired ; but you shall be per- 
secuted more ; but stand by the Church in spite of everything. 
You will, perhaps, receive no remuneration for that, but 
stand by her, yea, unto death. There will be a great 
reformation in the Church of England. This is an exhort- 
ation for you to stand by her." 'Are you a prophet ?* asked 
the son ; * No/ replied the father, € nor the son of a prophet ; 
but God has revealed this to me on my knees. I shall not 
live to see it.' * Shall I P'said the son. Rowlands then 
put his hands for a short time over his eyes, and after that 
he said, ' I think you will be.' " " This," the Biographer 



41 

adds, " I heard from the late Reverend Nathaniel Rowlands 
himself about the year I826 ; and in closing the narrative, he 
said that he often thought of his father's words, after Ur. 
Burgess had come to the Diocese of St. Davids, and seeing 
so many Evangelical Clergy rising in the Established Church. 
By the above persecution is meant, doubtless, the opposition 
he had received for standing by the system of the Church, 
in respect of the ministry. There was a desire by many at 
that time to bring a system of separation, and to place some 
of the preachers to administer the Sacraments, as had then 
been done by the Wesleyan Methodists in England. 
Rowlands was very adverse to this. He was a thorough 
Churchman, on principle f although he could not, on 
account of unavoidable circumstances, conform with some of 
her rules. It was, probably, his expectation and hope, that 
there would be, in a short time, such a change, in respect of 
godliness, in the Church, that he could unite his own 
people more completely with her. The above conversation, 
according to my opinion, distinctly shews this. And this 
would have been no vain hope had the dignitaries of the 
Church acted wisely in such cases." 

The Reverend Nathaniel Rowlands kept faithfully to the 
above last request of his father. Up to the year 181 1, he 
was a Methodist, but he still considered himself a member 
of the Church, for when the Methodists formally separated 
themselves from the Church in the year 181 1, of which event 
we shall speak presently, he severed all connection with 
them. From the year 1807, to the time of his death in 1831, 
he did not, on account of some irregularity in his conduct, 

* The Reverend William Williams, Pant-y-cclyn, in his Elegy on Rowlands, 
aeknowlodgee this fact in the following lines :— 

' Mae ei holl ddaliadan gloow 

Mewn tair credo i'w gwel'd yn glir, 
Athanasins a Nicca, 

'Nghyd a'r apostolaidd wir; 
Hen Articlau Eylwys Loegr, "J 

Catecis' Westminster Fawr ; 
Ond yn bena'r Bibl Sanctaidd, 

D'wynodd araynt oleu wawr.' 



42 

officiate within the consecrated fabrics of the Church. 
During the remainder of his life, he ministered in a chapel at 
Haverforwest, to a congregation of Methodists, who still 
adhered to the Church of England. 

We translate the following extract from the History of 
Welsh Methodism, by the late Reverend John Hughes, 
Calvinistic minister, Vol. I. p. 447. " We are surprized to 
see so much of the spirit of a churchman in the Reverend 
N. Rowlands, when we remember what his father was, and the 
treatment which he had, and what also his father-in-law was — 
the Reverend Howel Da vies. In tracing the history of the 
Rev. D. Rowlands minutely, we continually become more 
and more convinced that his views were less ecclesiastical, 
than we are led to think they were in investigating the 
histories of his life. We do not by this insinuate that his 
biographers, to whom we have much respect, have willingly 
misrepresented him ; but we are of opinion that they were 
misled, and that they were furnished with one-sided testi- 
monies, while others, on the other hand were kept from 
them ; and they could not but judge and write according to 
the testimony brought before them. We have had other 
writings to hand, the authenticity of which cannot be doubted, 
which tend to weaken the effect of those former testimonies 
on the mind of the keen and searching man/' 

When we read the solemn charge of Daniel Rowlands, 
already referred to, we are, by no means " surprized to see 
so much of the spirit of a churchman in the Reverend 
Nathaniel Rowlands," who was a clergyman of the Church of 
England, and Chaplain to the Duke of Ormond, and Lady 
Huntingdon. 

If we accept the interpretation of the Reverend J. Owen, 
on the persecution which Rowlands refers to as having been 
borne by him " till he was tired," it will be seen that he was 
persecuted by the Methodists, for his determined opposition 
to organize anything like a permanent schism, in authorizing 



43 

laymen to administer the Sacraments. On the other hand, 
if we construe this persecution to mean the opposition which 
he received within the Church before, and at his expulsion, 
it is a very strong proof, indeed, of his profound attachment 
to the Church in spite of all the hard treatment which he had 
received from his ecclesiastical superior, that had Rowlands 
been permitted to officiate in the Church, no amount of 
internal opposition would have induced him to quit her pale. 
His separation was compulsory, bnt his attachment to the 
Church continued unchangeable. That his views were c * less 
ecclesiastical" towards the close of this life, the above 
conversation distinctly disproves. 

The assertion by the Rev. John Hughes in the translated 
extract, that Rowlands biographers were furnished with one- 
sided testimonies, and that others were with-held from them, 
led us to examine the authenticity of the above narrative, but 
we have failed to find a contradiction in anv book within 
our reach. The writer of the above extract, who has written 
very elaborately on the Reverend Daniel Rowlands, and has 
made very extensive use of his biography by the Reverend 
J. Owen, has also passed over Daniel Rowlands' charge in 
significant silence. When we bear in mind that this death- 
bed request of Rowlands to his son, was communicated to 
his Biographer by Nathaniel Rowlands himself, and that he 
Tendered implicit obedience to it in refusing to acquiesce in 
the decision of 1S11, and afterwards severing all connection 
with the Methodists, we cannot consider it as a " one-sided 
statement/' and in the absence of a direct negative, we must 
accept it as authentic and true. 

The Reverend Thomas Charles, of Bala, is another very 
prominent character in the history of Welsh Methodism. He 
was born in the year 1755, and was for about three or four 
years a pupil of the Reverend Griffith Jones, at Llanddow- 
rar. In the year 1775, he matriculated at Jesus College, 
Oxford, where he graduated in the year 1779. He was 



44 

ordained on June 14, (Trinity Sunday) 1778, at Oxford, and 
licensed to a curacy in Somersetshire, where he continued 
until the year 1783, when he removed to Bala, which he made 
his permanent residence for the remainder of his life. He 
continued unemployed here for some time. The following 
extract from one of Mr. Charles' Letters of 1783 shows the 
strong desire he had to remain in the Church. 

Sep. 29. I am now waiting to see what the Lord has to do with 
me, making use of every means in my power to procure some place 
in the Established Church to officiate, not for the sake of any 
emoluments I might have, but from a principle of conscience. I can 
live independent of the Church, but I am a churchman on principle, 
and therefore shall not on any account leave it, unless I am forced to 
do so. But you can well conceive how disagreable and uncomfort- 
able it is to be doing nothing. I never felt before in the same degree 
the force of these expressions, " Woe is unto me if I preach not the 
gospel." I feel that a necessity is laid upon me, and that my life 
would be perfect misery, without engaging in the work with all my 
powers.* 

Early in the year 1784, Mr. Charles obtained the curacy 
of Llan y Mawddwy, about fourteen miles from Bala, where 
he journeyed every week, often on foot, through every 
weather, for the space of about a year : so anxious he was to 
remain in the Church, and to work for her. His ministra- 
tions during his short stay at this curacy were eminently 
successful. His Biographer says, " He revived there the 
ancient and excellent custom of catechising the young people 
in the afternoon on Sunday. This gave offence to some, 
though it was approved by others. His faithfulness and 
diligence in the parish were blessed to many. But some 
' gainsayed/ opposed, and reviled. His continuance at Llan 
y Mawddwy was not long. A complaint was sent by those 
in the parish who disliked his preaching to the Rector, who, 
either without examining the truth of the allegations made 
against Jim, or not approving of his diligent and faithful 
labours, sent him notice to quit the curacy. A petition was 

* Memoir, by Bey. E. Morgan, p. 192. 



45 

then drawn up by those who liked his ministry, with an 
intention of sending it to the incumbent. It was given to a 
person in the parish to forward to him. But it never 
reached its destination. * " * Through the influence of 
some individuals of the parish who were inimical to Mr. C, 
the person to whom the petition was" entrusted, was prevailed 
upon to destroy it on the road to the rectors residence, as 
he himself afterwards confessed. No revocation of the 
notice given having taken place, it was concluded the petition 
had no effect. Mr. C. was obliged to discontinue his services 
at this Church about the end of April •#•*••••*" 
" Being once more deprived of the opportunity of exer- 
cising his ministry, Mr. C. felt no small perplexity of mind. 
If he was predisposed to leave the Church he would have done 
so before now ; but the truth appears to be, that he contem- 
plated such an event with pain and sorrow. The many 
passages which occur in his letters written at this time 
respecting self-denial, and resignation to the will of God, 
were evidently occasioned by what he was foreseeing, would 
in all probability be the final issue of his repeated dis-appoint- 
ments. And we may easily conceive that to quit a Church, 
whose doctrines he cordially approved, and which commanded 
general respect, and to be connected with a despised people, 
was a step which required no small degree of self-denial. 
In doing this he had also to go against the current of habits 
and prepossessions. An application to the bishop of the 

diocese was made about this time, of what nature it was we 
are not able to learn. His letters only allude to such a thing 
as having been made. Every influence which his wife's 
family and his own friends could command, was exerted in 
his favour." 

Mr. Charles in a letter to his wife from Shropshire, where 
he had gone soon after he was deprived of Llan-y-Mawddwy, 
to consult his friends there as to the course he should adopt, 
says:— 

E 



46 

" There are no tidings of a church, but all friends here seem to 
give me up for the chapels in Wales, whilst at the same time they 
are much satisfied with my conduct in waiting so long. All I can 
say is, that I desire, I hope sincerely, to be where the Lord would 
have me to be. I cannot carry a guilty conscience any longer about 
me, which I must do if my days are consumed in vanity." 

In another letter to a friend, he says, " I am in a strait between 
two things — between leaving the Church and continuing in it. 
Being turned out of three churches in this country without the 
prospect of another. What shall I do ? In the last church I served, 
I continued three months. There the gospel was much blessed as to 
the present appearance of things. The people there are calling on 
me with tears to feed them with the bread of life. What shall I do ? 
Christ's words continually sound in my ears, " Feed my lambs." I 
think I feel my heart willing to engage in the work, be the conse- 
quences what they may. But then I ought to be certain in my own 
mind that God calls me to preach at large. This stimulates me to 
try all means to continue in the Church, and to wait a little longer to 
see what the Lord will do. I thank the Lord, I want nothing but to 
know His will, and strength to do the same. The gospel spreads here, 
and thousands flock to hear it ; and I believe thousands in all parts 
have received it in its power. I tremble, lest the Lord should find me 
unfaithful, when I see so much work to do. I often think that I 
hear my dear Master saying to me, " Why standest thou here all the 
day long idle ?"*•*»#* I endeavour to 
give myself up entirely to God, willing that he should dispose of me 
just as he pleases. Were he to give me to turn the scales, I should 
be afraid to throw in a straw, lest I should throw it into the wrong 
one." 

Mr. Charles having failed to obtain a curacy, his ardent 
zeal for the work of the Ministry forced him to join the 
Methodists, which he did in the year 1784; he had then 
been six years in Holy Orders, and was twenty nine years of 
age, and he continued with them up to the time of his death 
in 1 8 14, a space of thirty years. His whole life is one 
chapter of unceasing labour. His Scriptural Dictionary, in 
writing which he was engaged eight years, is the only 
one of any merit in the Welsh language. Mr. Morgan 
in commenting upon the treatment which Mr. Charles 
received in the Church says : — " But the manner in 



47 

which Mr. C. was treated was not only unjust, but impolitic 
also. The Church of Rome would never have been so un- 
wise and regardless of common prudence as to shut its door 
against such a man as Mr. C. How many different orders 
or denominations of friars, though on some points opposite 
to each other and objectionable too to the regular Clergy, 
did the head of that Church patronize ? It was doubtless a 
wise policy, promotive of the general interest of the Church, 
though not pleasing to some of its members. It was to 
accommodate itself to that variety of predilections and taste 
always prevalent among mankind, and to engage in its favour 
and in its service the talents, the zeal, and the exertions of 
all who seemed anxious to advance its interest. This was 
done by the Church of Rome, though it had to combat 
with no dissent, because it allowed none. * * * • To 
what are we to attribute the vastness of dissent in the present 
day? to what else, as to its main cause, but to the scowling 
and oppressive treatment of Mr. C. and others met with 
from the bishops and clergy? They blindly thought to 
silence them by preventing them from being employed in the 
Church. * * * Happily for our times, a different 

course is generally pursued. Zeal and diligence are not only 
encouraged, but even practized by many of those who rule 
over us. May their labours be abundantly blessed." 



48 

CHAPTER IV. 

The Separation of 1811 — " The Wehh Looking Glass"— John Elias— 
His advise to Cadwalader Jones — Testimonies concerning the 
Church — The Ministry of the Church — Clerical Education 
Societies — Extract from Bishop Campbell's Charge — Causes of 
the early growth of Methodism — Early Methodist preachers — 
The Hwyl — Extract from Mr. Jones, Llanddowror's "Practical 
Piety " — Extempore preaching — Manuscript Sermons — Mr. 
Cotton as a preacher — The Clergy and Education. 

One of the most important events in the history of the Welsh 
Church during the present century, is the formal separation 
of the Methodists from the Established Church, which occur- 
ed in the year i8it, the year following Mr. Cotton's 
appointment as Vicar of Bangor. The question of ordaining 
preachers from among themselves, had, as we have already 
seen, been mooted in the time of Rowlands, a project which 
he strenuously opposed, for during his life and ministry, and 
that of his coadjutprs and immediate successors, Welsh 
Methodism was considered as a part and parcel of the 
Established Church, and the great success of that movement 
must be attributed, chiefly, to those Clergy who superintended 
its affairs and aided its progress, but still kept within the 
pale of the Church ; but as these clergymen confined their 
labours for the most part to their respective parishes, and the 
bishops increased the difficulty by insisting upon more 
conformity on the part of these Clergy, great inconvenience 
was felt and expressed at the non-frequency of the celebration 
of Holy Communion to the rapidly increasing congregations. 
Moreover, many of the preachers, entertaining the idea that 
Methodism had now become a distinct body from the Church, 
were naturally apprehensive as to its future success if deprived 
of the services of episcopally ordained ministers ; this 
combination of circumstances forced the question of ordain- 
ing ministers prominently forward, and was eventually acted 
upon* The subject was introduced at the Llangeithio 



49 

Association in the year 1810, at which the Rev. D. Jones, 
Rector of Langan, presided — the most influential member of 
the connexion, Mr. Charles not excepted. It is said that 
this venerable clergyman was so indignant at the proposal, 
that he ordered the person who introduced it to be turned out, 
which resulted in a great uproar. The Clergy, headed by the 
eloquent D. Griffiths, of Nefern, protested against the move- 
ment and stigmatized the promoters as schismatics, and a 
very considerable number of the old Methodists were also 
decidedly opposed to the project, and very justly argued that 
as the ministrations of the Clergy had been so signally blessed 
there was no reason for a change. The opposition to the 
proposal was so determined at this Association, that it fell to 
the ground ; but it was proposed that a day of prayer should 
be set apart for guidance in the matter, to which Mr. Jones 
replied, " For goodness sake, my dear brethren, do not pray 
me out of this world ; I shall be out of the way very soon." 
His words were almost prophetic, for he died a few days 
after he had uttered them. The proposal, which he and his 
brother Clergy had up to that time successfully suppressed, 
was, however, carried into effect in the following year. In 
the month of June, 181 1, the Reverend Thomas Charles, 
assisted by others, ordained eight persons at Bala Association, 
among whom was the celebrated John Elias ; and in the 
month of August of the same year, the Reverend John 
Williams, of Pant-y-celyn, and the Reverend William Wil- 
liams, Lledrod, ordained thirteen preachers at Llandilo 
Association, of whom the notorious John Evans, New Inn, 
was one. This proceeding gave rise to a very able and 
spirited pamphlet entitled " The Welsh Looking Glass," by 
the Reverend Thomas Jones, of Creaton, a Clergyman of 
great usefulness and renown, and who was much attached 
to the Methodists as long as they continued in union with 
the Church. In this pamphlet the author shews that this 
separation was most unjustifiable, contrary to the intention of 



50 

the early Methodists, and he solemnly charges the separatists 
with the sin of schism, and rushing irregularly into the sacred 
functions of the Ministry. 

On the demise of Mr. Jones, Langan, there were only 
twelve Clergymen among the Methodists, but in consequence 
of the proceedings of 181 1, six of them quitted the connexion,* 
taking with them a very considerable number of the most 
respectable and better educated class of their congregations, 
and in more instances than one many of those who remained 
positively refused to receive Holy Communion from the 
hands of the newly ordained preachers — a convincing proof 
that the belief in an apostolically descended commission 
of Ministry was not foreign to the teaching of the early 
Methodists. 

In fairness to Mr. Charles we must add, that from the 
very first he had protested strongly against the separation, 
and only a short time before it actually took place he spoke 
most decidedly against it at an Association at Bala, 
viewing its inevitable consequences with much pain, and, 
probably, as a churchman, naturally entertaining doubts as 
to the validity of any Orders other than episcopal. Had 
it not been that undue pressure was put upon him, and 
the fact that one layman went so far as to administer the 
Sacraments of Baptism and Holy Communion at Denbigh, 
and that this proceeding appeared to indicate the course 
which all the lay-preachers would universally adopt, Mr. 
Charles would, probably, never have consented to become 
a party to this ordination of preachers. He chose the lesser 
evil of the two, and reluctantly gave away. 

Of all the lay-preachers set apart in the year i8n f John 

* The following are the names of tlie clergy • The following remained among the 
wlio quitted the connexion. 

Rev. D. Griffiths, Nefern. 



„ W. Jouea, Llandudooh. 

,, W. Davieti, Llaufyrnach. 

„ W. Davies, Cynfll. 

,, W. Hughes, Sychbant. 

„ H. Jones. 



Methodists. 

Rev. T. Charles, Bala. 
„ S. Lloyd, Bala, 
i, W. Lloyd, Carnarvon. 
„ John Williams, Pant-y-oelyn. 
„ John Williams, Lledrod. 
„ Howel Howells, TrehilL 



51 

Elias was, undoubtedly, the most prominent. In the early 
part of his life he had followed the occupation of a weaver, 
and although deprived of the advantages of early training, he 
was, nevertheless, a man of very refined tastes, possessed of 
much intellectual power, and eminently endowed with 
ministerial qualifications. He was a perfect master of 
eloquence, and some of his sermons remained so indelible 
upon the minds of his hearers, that, in after years, they were 
taken as landmarks of contemporaneous events. 

Notwithstanding the fact that John Elias was an advocate 
of the separation — and he advocated it, probably, because as 
a layman, he would naturally consider some kind of ordin- 
ation better than none at all ; add to this, that there was no 
reasonable hope of the bishops ordaining these men, — he 
considered Methodism a part ot the Church as the following 
conversation testifies. It took place only a short time before 
John £lias ? death, between him and Cadwalader Jones, 
Ty*n y Pistyll, Trawsfynydd.* This person is still living, and 
is now in the 79th year of his age. The following is a transla- 
tion of his communication : — 

- "I was in union with the Established Church, and with the 
Calvinietic Methodist body, and the Methodist Deacons were grum- 
bling rather, and wanted ine to stand by either of the two, and sever my 
connection with the other. I had some hestitation about this. Subse- 
quently, Mr. Elias was to preach here on a .Sunday, and on Saturday, 
the 7th of May, 1S40, 1 started to meet him for the purpose of having his 
opinion and advice on my case. And this is what he said. ( Never 
separate from the Communion of the Established Church, nevertheless 
you can be in connection with us, because we are a branch of the 
Church. ' These are his words, word for word." 

* Tr* Y Pisttll, TRAwsFYNvnD, Tach. I.'i. 1873. 

Ajtwyi. Syb. — " Yr yuiddiddau a fn rhyusrwyf a Mr. Elias o F*in, yn nghyda'r 
aebrjrarsydd fely canlyn:— Yr oeddwn mown nndeb fi'r Eijlwys Sirfydkdifr, ac hofyil 
a cboiphy Methodistiaid Caltinaidd. ec yr nail blaonoriaid y Methodist iaid braidd yn 
grwgnaeh o eisien i mi sefyll ac nn or a Liu. a tumi'in cysylltiad a'r Hall, ohorwydd hyny 
yr oeddwn mewn petrnsder meddwl. Yn minlyuM. yr oedd Mr. Elias i fod yma yn pre- 
getha y Sabboth. ac ar A-lyiM Sadwrn. y 7fi-d dydd J Mai. y tl. 1S40. fe cychwynais i'w 
jgrflarfod. er cael ei faru a'i jjyiiu'hor ar fy acho*. A ilyma f>. 1 y dy wedudd. * Pi idiweh 
bjth a{£ ymadael a Chymmundeb yr Eirlwys ^t-fydlcdiu, c-r nyny c'jwi a ellwchfo.1 mewn 
CTBjllbad a ni, oherwydd cangen or El'1w> > ydym ni.' Dyma ei eiriau, air yn air. 

Yr eiddoeh, yn rhwymaa cariad, 

CADWALADEB JONES. 



52 

The following extracts from Mr. Elias' Diary express his 
sentiments towards the Church and her Liturgy. 

"Never was there an accusation so groundless, for there is no 
Methodist in the country opposed to paying tithes or any such 
impost. And no true sincere Methodist can he opposed to the 
Established Church, or to tribute and tithes to support it. Its 
ministers were the most celebrated instruments in the commencement 
and the advancement of Methodism in Wales ; and from the hands of 
those ministers the Methodists received the ordinances of Baptism and 
the Lord's Supper for upwards of sixty years. When circumstances 
arose which obliged the Methodists to set apart some of the elder 
preachers to administer the ordinances, it was not intended to make 
an essential alteration with regard to the form and order of the body. 
It was merely a setting apart of some to assist ministers of the 
Established Church, whilst they were among us ; and every one who 
was ordained, was called on to confess and declare that he most truly 
from his very soul, approved and accepted the present order and 
constitution of the connexion ; and also to promise and engage before 
God and his people, to endeavour to preserve the union of the body in 
which the Lord has blessed and prospered it so much. So it is evident 
that no faithful sincere Methodist, can intend the destruction of the 
Church of England, nor desire to with-hold tithes or contributions 
towards its support." 

" The last time Elias was in this place, he preached an admirable 
sermon on Heb. xiii. 20, 21. When he came from chapel to my house, 
he found upon the table that interesting book, published by the Society 
for Promoting Christian Knowledge. ' The Liturgy compared with the 
Bible.' He read a portion of it with great pleasure, took it with him 
to his bedroom when he retired ; and when he came down next 
morning, I begged his acceptance of the book ; he appeared highly 
pleased and said that he would rather have that book than that I 
should have given him £20. He also said that he had always 
entertained the highest veneration for the I iturgy of the Church — 
that he had many discussions respecting it with Dissenters, and was 
delighted to find his opinion of it confirmed by that book. A few 
months before his death he sent me a kind message by a mutual friend, 
expressing his fears he should never see me again, but he had not 
ceased to value the book I gave him." # 

In his earlier days John Elias attended Church with his 
grandfather, who, he says, was " a true churchman." When 

* Life by Morgan, p.p. 198, 199. 



58 

comparatively young he had a strong desire to enter the 
Ministry, and had the necessary assistance been offered him, 
there is no doubt that his services could have been secured 
for the Church. His strong testimonies, given above, in 
favour of the Church and her Liturgy distinctly show the 
bent of his mind. But, unfortunately, for the Church at 
that time, Holy Orders were almost inaccessible to those in 
the lower ranks of life, as the bishops insisted upon so much 
classical knowledge, as an indispensible qualification, and as 
there was then no provision made to assist poor students 
to attain the standard set up by the bishops, many who 
were otherwise well qualified, were precluded from serving 
" in the sacred Ministry of the Church," which they loved 
and revered so much. Jja augurs well for the Church in ^ 
Wales that her rulers* now-a-days would never allow a man 

* Wo make the following extract from tho very excellent Charge of Dr. Campbell, 
Bishop of Bangor, delivered to his Clergy, in 1872. In speaking of the Bangor 
Clerical Education Society, his Lordships says: — 

11 Hitherto, tho action of tho Society has been chiefly to assist promising yotmg 
men in our grammar schools, on tho ground of literary merit, tested by examination, 
and supported by good character, as witnessed by the Master and other competent 
persons. This is, doubtless, money well expended, and I should be sorry to see this 
part of oar work given up. Yet, if wo confine ourselves to this, oar funds mast be 
vastly increased, before wo can act, with any sensible increase of power, on the coentry 
generally. Besides which, tho persons, so assisted, are those chiefly provided for on 
« w, ** lw g foundations. They are in a position to competo hopefully for exhibitions, and 
scholarships, in the Universities, and would probably, though with a greater struggle, 
have made their way withoat our help. It was not for them alone % that J, at least, 
nzgsd Use formation of the Society. It was also that tho Church might be edifiod, by 
the ministry of men, endowed indeed with natural gifts — endowed also, as far as man 
ean judge, with the higher gifts of the Holy Spirit— but shut out from tho prospect of 
reesMng Holy Orders, by tho want of educational advantages, and consequently of 
l i t e r a ry Qualifications. Keeping before mo the good, not of individual members only, 
bniof the whole body, I look for tho persons to bo assisted, not simply to the grammar 
liiooln, bat also to those parishes where the 6igns of spiritual lifo are most apparent, 
where the pastoral work is been carried on with the greatest zeal, and where the living 
Ghnreh. is being evidently built up with lively stones ; and to those young men therein, 
fhat are most helpful to tho Clergyman. Unless wo procood thus, we may, indeed, 
assist one and another, who, like Samuel, have been early devoted by their parents to 
the service of the Altar; we shall, nevertheless, lose many a one, of whom it may bo 
^ w xhe word of the Lord was in his heart as a burning fire, shut up in his bones, 
and lie was weary of forbearing and could not stay." Thoughtful men, with minds 
jHidpHwiftrl by education, and accustomed to look forward to remote consequences, may 
■— *- their seal within tho limits of authority, that they avoid the evil of division ; 



54 

of John Ellas' qualifications to escape their grasp, and 
every lover of the Church must hail with unmixed pleasure 
the establishing of Clerical Education Societies, to assist 
poor, but able students, to enter the Ministry of the 
Church, and the very existence of these, and other Church 
Extension Societies, is one of the many outward and 
visible signs of the inward and spiritual vitality, which now 
throbs through the whole body of the Welsh Church, and 
is also an undeniable proof that the system of the Church is 
sufficiently elastic to cope with the wants of the times. And 
as regards the supply and education of candidates for the 
Ministry, no one will deny that the great benefactors both of 

but the very love of God, combined with the consciousness of power to sway the hearts 
of their fellow-men, almost drives men of impulsive minds, not accustomed to look 
beyond the present or to consider remote consequences, to dissent from oar communi- 
on, if no adequate field for the exercise of their peculiar gifts is open to them within 
it. Examples within our own Diocese will readily occur to your minds, showing how 
grievous is the loss sustained, when such men as I have described are refused a place 
in the Ministry of the Church. Yet, they cannot bo expected to compete with the 
well-trained student of our grammar schools in a literary examination. It would be 
overlooking their special qualifications to test them by such a touchstone. If the 
Society is to do the greatest amount of good, of which its organization is capable, these 
men must not be passed over. A way must be devised to discover them — to improve, 
by suitable training, their gifts ; in one word, to prepare them, by competent 
instruction, for their proper work. Nor is it any sufficient objection, that their choice 
is open to tho danger of favouritism. An active Clergyman, it may be said, will bring 
forward some member of his congregation, who has been useful to him, or whose 
family is influential in the parish, and will, by canvassing, secure his acceptance by 
the Council. Certainly, thero is too much in tho general feeling of the country to 
warrant such a suspicion. Yet to be swayed by it would be almost equivalent to 
despairing of the Church. Are there absolutely none amongst us, whose discretion 
and integrity are to be trusted ? or must we take for granted that the subscribers 
generally are so indifferent to the usefulness of the Society as to place in the Council 
men less honest and trustworthy if better may bo had ? You will observe, that I am 
not arguing in favour of dispensing with all examination, but only of so modifying the 
examination to suit the circumstances of the case, as to make it a test of the mental 
power and diligence of the candidate, and thus, also, as far as may be, a criterion of his 
future usefulness in the Church. Cases may occur, though they will be rare and 
exceptional inthqjr character, in which it would be important to give a Literate a year's 
training at tho expense of the Society, and I should be sorry that this power wore 
taken away by an unbending rule. 

I have, however, good confidence that every year's experience will teach us how best 
to adapt our operations to the wants of the country, until the administration approves 
itself to all, who desire the efficiency of the Ministry, and the welfare of our National 
Church." 



55 

Church and State, have, often times, been raised from 
comparatively low stations in society ; but to say that the 
Welsh Church has not, and will not, profit by the services of 
Cleigy drawn, from the higher class of society would be as 
unjust as it would be inconsistent with ourselves, in pointing 
out the many ministerial excellencies of the worthy subject 
of this memoir, who could, certainly, boast of a noble 
pedigree ; still, the state of the Church in Wales during the 
earlier period of Mr. Cotton's life, corroborates the fact that 
the Welsh Church has suffered very considerably in not 
possessing clergy of comparatively lower social standing, 
living and moving among the common people, and having 
a clearer insight into their manners and customs, and if we 
venture to say that it is to the advantage of the Church that 
her Ministry should comprise men representative of all classes 
of the community, we only assert a principle which is now 
very generally recognized and universally acted upon by 
bishops. 

The early and rapid growth of Methodism cannot be 
attributed to any hostility entertained by that body towards 
the doctrines, rites and ceremonies of the Church ; such 
hostility did not exist ; she was always spoken of with the 
utmost veneration, and regarded and designated as " Old 
Mother Church." Had the early Methodists assumed a hostile 
attitude towards the Church, it would have proved a strong 
barrier to check their progress, and we doubt not that their 
profession of unity with the Church, as instanced in the case 
of Cadwalader Jones, obtained for them many adherents. 
Indeed, the Church had not, even within her own pale, better 
and more powerful defenders of Church and State than the 
early Methodists were, especially John Elias. In a document 
now before us, we find that the subject of Disestablishment 
was mooted at Bala Association, in the year 1834, when 
Mr. Elias stood up and proposed that the Methodist body 
should have nothing to do with the question, or with any- 



66 

thing else which had a tendancy to harm the Church ; the 
proposal was seconded by William Morris, Cilgerran, and 
500 preachers and deacons supported and passed the 
resolution. We have it upon the same authority, that Mr. 
Elias said, on another occasion, that if the Methodists would 
continue to evince so hostile a feeling towards the Church, as 
some of them seemed then to do, they would not be worthy of 
the name of Methodists ; indeed, Mr. Elias was so partial to 
the Church and her Liturgy, that at the opening of the 
present Calvinistic Chapel at Trawsfynydd, he publicly stated 
that if time had permitted, he would have read the Service 
of the Established Church,* and he followed up this state- 
ment with an eloquent address upon the Church, and, inter 
alia, said that the Methodists ought to regard the Church as 
their Mother, and revere her accordingly. 

We shall not be far wrong in attributing the success of early 
Methodism to (1) its popular style of preaching, which was 
so well adapted to the Welsh people ; (2) the itinerant nature 
of its ministry, by means of which the great preachers were 
heard in almost every part of the principality ; and (3) its 
lay agency. 

Regarding the published sermons of John Elias, from a 
literary point of view they disappoint us, when we contrast 
them with the wonderful effect they produced, but this is 
explainable if we only bear in mind that his sermons, like 
all other printed oratory, suffer for the obvious reason that 
the eloquence and feeling with which they are delivered can 
never be transferred to paper. The great interest evinced in 
Mr. Elias' preaching was not so much in the matter of his 
sermons, although they were creditable productions — as in 
his admirable and pathetic style of delivery. But John Elias 
was an exception to the generality of the Methodist preachers 
of his time, who were mostly ignorant and illiterate men with 

* It may bo interesting to/ add that at the opening of the first Chapels at Traw*- 
fynydd, Tremadoo, Llangwm, and Bala, Mr. Charles of Bala read the Serrioe of the 
Church. 



67 

eccentric ways, which they carried with them, and exhibited 
in the pulpit ; however, they were earnest, and amusingly 
original ; they knew next to nothing about the arrangement of 
a sermon; and living and moving among the common people ; 
they retained much of their ideas, manners and customs. 
Being men of strict moral life, they were rigid disciplinarians, 
and deprived of the advantages of education they stood 
almost on the same level as the people to whom they had to 
preach; still, these preachers were much respected and 
exceedingly popular, and they accomplished much of the 
work for which sermons and pulpits are intended, for the 
simple reason that their discourses were perfectly adapted to 
the necessities of the population ; in a word, they were the men 
of the period. Their discourses, exceedingly simple in matter, 
chiefly figurative and metaphorical in style, were delivered 
in the most homely way ; their sermons were far from being 
distinguished for any grammatical precision or philosophical 
acuteness, indeed the pulpit was as conspicuous for the 
absence of any literary and classical element as the labourer's 
cottage or the farmers kitchen. On the other hand, the Clergy- 
man of the parish was highly connected and well educated, and 
was generally a Justice of the Peace, and in country parishes 
he was the only legal and medical adviser of his parish ; he was 
much respected, and was looked upon more as a country squire 
than a country parson. The generality of the Clergy of this 
period werenot endowed with popular preaching powers, whilst 
the secret of the power and influence of the Welsh Dissenting 
preacher, lay in his popular style of delivery and in his wonderful 
power of appealing to the feelings of his hearers. This appeal 
came on at the close of the sermon, and is called the faay/ 9 
which is the Welsh word for a sail, why it should be so called 
we know not, except it be a metaphor that as the ship in 
full sail rides swiftly over the sea, so also the preacher having 
arrived at this part of his discourse had reached the zenith of 
his power in preaching. The hwyl neither explained nor 



58 

argued, it actually sang, and the preacher having finished 
addressing the understanding of his hearers would address 
himself to their imagination in a chanting strain, by means of 
which he played so much upon their feelings as to excite 
them to tears and loud sobbings. These outward manifestions 
of feeling with the amens and other responses reacted upon 
the preacher with equal effect, and there was thus a mutual 
sympathy between preacher and people. If a preacher was 
endowed with a melodious voice and could modulate it to 
advantage, no matter how deficient his discourse might be 
in intellectual power, he was more acceptable in the pulpit 
than any divine who might undertake to expound any 
intricate point of theology. If the Jnvyl was well done the 
sermon was considered good, for the popular Welsh sermon 
must, like an Epic-poem, have a beginning, a middle and an 
end. 

The hwyl has nothing akin to it in the preaching of any 
other nation, in fact it is peculiarly national, and to deny its 
power and effect as exemplified in those to whom it was 
natural and genuine would be utter folly. We are correct in 
asserting that this style of preaching originated in the Church, 
and not among the Methodists, as some would have it, for 
we find it practised by Mr. Jones, Llanddowror, before the 
rise of Methodism, and this was the great secret of his power 
as a preacher. Rowlands, Llangeithio, was a perfect master 
of Welsh pulpit eloquence, and he also practised this style 
of preaching, long before his expulsion from the Church, and 
it was said by those who heard him that Wales never 
possessed a better preacher, Mr. Jones, Llandowror, only 
excepted. Mr. Jones, Langan, and Mr. Griffiths, of Nefem, 
were of the same class of preachers, and their ministry was 
wonderfully powerful and effective. But, granting that this 
peculiarly Welsh style of preaching originated with the 
Methodists, we may be pardoned for suggesting its more 
general adoption within the consecrated fabrics of th^ 



59 

Church, in a refined and modified form, when we have a 
precedent in the early Church, in the adoption of litanies, 
which were first originated by the Arians.* 

The Reverend Griffith [ones. Llandowror, in his 4i Practical 
Piety," for the year 1741, pages 12, 13, says that the people 
" generally dissent for no other reason than for want of plain, 
practical, pressing, and zealous preaching, in a language and 
dialect they are able to understand ; and freedom of friendly, 
access to advise about their spiritual state. When they come 
(some way or other) to be pricked in their hearts for their 
sins, and find, perhaps, no seriousness in those about them, 
none to unbosom their griefs to, none that will patiently 
hear their complaints, and deal tenderly by their souls, and 
dress their wounds ; they flee to other people for relief, as 
dispossessed demoniacs will no longer frequent the tombs of 
the dead. For though the Church of England is allowed to 
be as sound and healthful a part of the Catholic Church as 
any in the world, when people are awakened from their 
lethargy, and begin to perceive their danger, they will not 
believe that their is anything in reason, law, or gospel, that 
should oblige them to starve their souls to death for the 
sake of conforming, if their pastor (whose voice, perhaps, 
they do not know, or who resides a great way from them,) 
will not vouchsafe to deal out unto them the Bread of Life." 

Although we maintain that the hwyl originated in the 
Church ; we must admit that it never was a distinguishing 
feature in the preaching of the Welsh Clergy, but after the 
rise of Methodism it became the characteristic of the preaching 
of that body, and what remained of it in the Church gave 
way, in a great measure, to manuscript sermons, in the 

* M The Arians, not being allowed to use the Churches within tho city, assembled 
about the porticoes, and sung heretical hymns through great part of the night, and at 
dawn of Saturday and Sunday wont through the city and out of tho gates to their place 
Of worship, singing axitiphonally all the way. Chrysostome, fearing that his people 
might be induced by these processions to join tho Arians, established them on a more 
tpHf»»fl<fl scale ; and by the help of tho Empress Endoxia, silver crosses wero provided 
1fBBT i,1 g wax-lights, which were carried in tho processions of tho orthodox. Soor. Hist. 
Jfed. ii. 8; Bosom, viii. ti." See Procter on the Book of Common Prayer, page 247. 



majority of FrwraiwTS y coldry and stiffly defircicd. El 
preaching is, unquestionably, preferred by the Wdsh 
bat the use of manuscripts by die Clergy may be ae 
for by the fact of the statioiiary and parochial nature 
Ministry of the Church. Preaching twice, and in ma 
three times a week all the year round to the same pe 
well as attending to the pastoral duties of visitis 
fatherless and widows in their affliction/ 7 and £ 
discharging his responsibilities as the chief gnardia 
education of his parish, keeps a Clergyman fully occup 
leaves him barely time for preparing three extempore ! 
weekly. On the other hand, the itinerant and non-pc 
nature of the ministry of the Methodist preacher, a 
for his extempore effusions, for he seldom or ever ac 
the same congregation more than once a month thn 
the year; is a perfect stranger to parochial work, 
occupied with nothing else save the composition < 
pilation of his sermon. In a letter, now before us, wr 
a Methodist Minister to a Dissenting contemporary, tt 
asserts that the great Methodist preachers are not ob 
compose more than twelve sermons a year, one i 
monthly meeting.* But extempore sermons are no 
more general in the Church than they were twenty y< 
and her preaching is consequently more power 
attractive. 

To those English Clergy who held Welsh 
manuscripts were indispensible auxiliaries to pn 
And this leads us to speak of Mr. Cotton as a preacl 
must be admitted that even as an English preacl 
Cotton has left no lasting claims upon the hor 
posterity, but he was considered one of the best English 
in the diocese of Bangor; his earnestness, devotic 
well-weighed emphasis, in reading the Scripture and 



*"Ni raid i*n Gweinidogk 
flwyddyn— on gogyfer a phob < 
byn yw y gwlrfonedd. See"< 



_^_^liL ra i < * ^ Gweinidogion goreu ni wneyd mwy na dwsin o fareget 

Cyfarfod Misol. Dyweded 4 'bugeiliaid w acerei 
Qoleuad." ftovember 29, 1878. 



61 

were absolutely an exposition of their mesr.inj : and those 
beautiful prayers, often reduced :y eare*e*> reading into 
mere forms, when read by b.'.in. r.w.cl :"r.r attcr.tijn and 
enlisted the hearty respor.se> of the v. ;>:.!: :--.r>. 

As a Welsh reader 2nd preacher, hv l :«..! J not. of course. 
excel. Born and educated in rlr.j'.aiid. :.r.d L-norant of the 
Welsh language until he e.-.ine to rrs!d-j in Wales, after 
taking Holy Orders, it was .. 4 uitv inv.-ossii-le f. r him to master 
the Welsh language to that penl-.-ti-ia as :.' i»e al«;e to read 
and preach with the power and t rriVrt >;• T-eculiar to native 
talent, which work so much upon the feelings of Welsh 
congregations, and is almost a //vr »/.v-i /;. /: k»r the pulpit 
success of even a Welshman. ?»::: " there are diversities of 
gifts," and if Mr. Cotton wa< ;■._■: a distinguished preacher, 
his pre-eminent efficiency and succers as a parish priest amply 
counter-balanced this seeming defect, for the cood effects 
of his ministerial life — especially in behalf of the education 
of the poor — remain unto this day, and have made his name 
quite a 'household word" among Dissenters as well as 
Churchmen, who have indiscriminately reaped the benefits 
of his labours ; and we hesitate not to say that the majority of 
the present native inhabitants of Bangor, as well as a large 
number of others, now scattered throughout the world, are 
indebted to him, in a great measure, for their early education. 
Nay, we can point to more than one Dissenting minister in 
the principality, who have now risen to great eminence in 
their respective sects, as well as to several Welsh Clergy of 
great usefulness, who can look back to their school-days at 
Bangor as the dawn of their religious, moral, and secular 
education, and thankfully acknowledge their obligation to 
this kind and generous benefactor. To provide cheap 
education was not then so easy a matter as now-a-days, as 
there were then no Government Grants or School Board rates 
to fell upon, but the clergyman was solely responsible for the 
education of his parish, and had to work hard to obtain the 



62 

necessary funds for the support of his schools ; and whilst 
acknowledging many and grievous clerical negligences in the 
past, let it be added to the credit of the Clergy that they are, 
and have been, the mainstay and support of the education 
of the country, and the schools so liberally supported by 
churchmen, have in many instances proved to be seminaries for 
Dissenting pulpits, and the Church can honestly claim the 
honour and dignity of being the great educator of the country. 
And this was not denied her by the early Methodists; we have 
already seen what were the testimonies and feelings of John 
Elias concerning the Church in his time, when the activity 
and zeal of her members were not so great and generally felt 
as they are now. The Welsh Church has undergone a great 
change since his time ; her Clergy are diligent and true to 
their holy calling ; her laymen are actively engaged in her 
work ; dilapidated churches are replaced by handsomely 
built edifices ; churches and mission chapels are built in 
new districts — towards the building of which her rich and 
poor* members have liberally contributed according to their 
several abilities — her Liturgy has become a great object of 
admiration, and the miserable duet between parson and 
clerk is now rapidly giving way to hearty congregational 

* The Rev. J. Pryce, M.A., Vicar of Bangor, in a very able letter on the Church in 
Wales, in speaking of the popular, bnt erroneous, idea that the Welsh landlord! 
belong to the Established Church -whilst the rest of the population are ahtKSt 
exclusively Dissenters, says :—" Sometimes this theory, that the Welsh Charon is i 
close corporation consisting only of landowners and employers of labour, is made sn 
of to account for the material activity now manifested in the erection and restoratlei 

of churches, mission chapels, Rchool-rooms, &c Against this view, put forward to 

lessen tho importance of those outward manifestations as indicating the strength sal 
extent of the Church feeling which is now awakened in Wales, I would most eamestif 
protest. Such a view is not only at variance with actual facts, but it is also emfy 
unjust to thousands (< who of their penury cast in unto the offerings of God all tM 
living that they have ." It would neither be grateful nor right to undervalue the gnat 
liberality of our wealthy laymen, but in the way of proof that the people are a powerfsl 
factor in the zeal and devotion which now throb through the whole body of the Welsh 
Church, it would be difficult to conceive more convincing evidence than is supplied by 
the annual report of the Bangor Church Extension Society for 1871. This society vsi 
founded by Bishop Campbell in 1869 ; it has existed barely for three years, ana yet. 
without interfering with the working of other older diocesan societies, it has already 
aided in tho building of five churches and eighteen chapels, while it supports in put 
or wholly twenty curates and six lay-readers. The society's income for the past year 
was £1579 2s. 6d. contributed by about 1726 members. Of these 1796 members I 
find, after a most careful analysis, that only thirty-five can be deseribed as either 
" landed proprietors or employers of labour." 




68 

responses and singing; churches, once deserted, are now 
becoming full ; Advent and Lenten Services, Harvest Home 
Festivals, and other annual gatherings have become general, 
at which Clergy exchange pulpits, and a system of voluntary 
itineracy has been mutually established by the Clergy them- 
selves; the evil of pluralities is abolished; none but Welsh- 
speaking Clergy hold Welsh livings, and all the bishops ofWelsh 
sees understand the language and feelings of ihe Welsh people. 
Had John Elias been spared to witness this great ' revival ' 
of work in the Church, no one would have rejoiced more 
than himself; nay, he would have realized his prediction in a 
celebrated sermon at Pentir, in which he asserted that " the 
revival must begin within the pale of the Established Church, 
for without her no revival would ever be effectual." And this 
great revival of work in the Church, predicted by Rowlands 
of Llangeitho, and John Elias has had its beneficial effects 
upon every dissenting community in the numerous secessions 
from their ranks to the Church, and especially of promising 
young members, which is a sure sign of growing strength and 
augurs well for the future of the Welsh Church ; add to this 
that the Methodist " deacons " — knowing full well with what 
harshness the preachers are treated, and the miserable 
pittance they receive from the " voluntary " system — train up 
their own sons for the Ministry of the Church, where, by the 
liberal endowments of her members, such a provision is made 
as will " encourage them to speak with all boldness, crouching 
to no man for their morsel of bread, nor tempted to lick the 
hand that feeds them." 



64 

CHAPTER V. 
Mr. Cotton's letter on education in Wales. 



THE following letter, signed " An unpaid Inspector," was 
written by Mr. Cotton to the North Wales Chronicle for the 
purpose of refuting certain statements which had appeared 
in that paper derogatory to Welsh schools. The letter is very 
amusing and characteristic of Mr. Cotton, and is interspersed 
with many of his favourite anecdotes which he repeated so 
often and so well. It is interesting also foijthe account it 
gives of the way in which he examined schools in his 
capacity of — as he chose to call himself — Unpaid Inspector. 

EDUCATION IN WALES. 

Sir, 

In your paper some time since, I found a letter addressed to 
you, in which the writer exposes the mis-statements made in several 
instances by the School Inspectors, which appeared in their Report 
for North Wales. I have no doubt that the statements to which the 
writer alludes arc as incorrect as he has said. I can safely infer that 
such they are, from the many mis-statements which I find in other 
cases with which I am well acquainted ; and also from the slovenly 
manner and flippant tone which pervades the whole Report. But, 
there are three instances of a flagrant nature : I must particularize 
them : the first is that of the National School at Carnarvon. The 
Reporters speak of this School in almost unqualified terms of dis- 
approbation. Now, Sir, this school was examined with great ability 
and impartiality, but a few weeks subsequently, in the presence of many 
gentlemen, lay and clerical, by the Lord Bishop of St. Asaph, and was 
declared by his Lordship to be in a very excellent state, both in respect 
of system, discipline, and acquirements. The Bishop of St. Asaph ex- 
amined also the Training School, conducted in the same room by the 
master, and passed this judgmentupontheinstitution and its conductor: 
" That he thought the one might form the basis of a Training School 
for North Wales ; and the other well qualified to act in the capacity 
of one of its principal officers." The stations which his Lordship has 
filled render him peculiarly competent to form a just opinion as to 



65 

the merits of persons submitted to examination.* ThiB school had 
also been previously examine! by a Clergyman, who has made the 
education of the poor his study, not being connected with the 
immediate neighbourhood of Carnarvon, who gave it as his opinion, 
that the school exceeded any other he had ever examined in respect 
to spelling : "I am not an inhabitant of Carnarvon, neither am I a 
parishioner, nor yet a subscriber, but a person quite unbiased, and 
desirous only of justifying the just, and speaking the truth." 

I now pass to the case of Jiulgcllvy. By reference to the Report 
of the School Inspectors, I tind it stated that none of the children of 
the Dolgelley National School could repeat the Church Catechism. 
It is equally a matter of fact that the Inspector did not ask any ono 
boy or girl in .the school, a single question in the Church Catechism. 
At the close of the examination of the children, the master reminded 
the Inspector, that ho had not questioned the children in the 
Catechism, and offered him a book, requesting him to do so ; upon 
which the Inspector inquired, whether they could repeat it ? The 
master replied that they could ; and that the lirst class could not 
only repeat it perfectly, but also answer any plain questions which 
the Inspector might put to them on it. The Inspector briefly 
answered, that as it was getting dark, he would take his word for 
it ; and immediatlcly left the school, and never returned to it again. 
The master was much disappointed, because he had taken great 
pains with the children in the Catechism. 

This statement I received from a person of high respectability, 
one of the Committee, and a constant visitor of the school. I can 
myself, also, add my testimony as to the full eiliciency of this school 
in every department. I examined the school in the autumn of last 
year, in the presence of persons both lay and clerical ; one of these, 
who was a stranger, declared his surprise at the general knowledge 
which the children possessed, their ready answers, and their repeti- 
tion of the Catechism. 

The last case is that of Bottwnog. I have ever been in the habit 
of examining this school, and in consequence of the attention paid to 
it by the Clergyman, have found it above the average of ordinary 
National Schools, cither in England or in Wales. 

"A lie has no legs," say the Chinese ; but 1 may add, it has 
wings wherewith it flies far and fast. 

" Faina volat, vires rue aciuirit euudo,'' 

+ They who know tho character of tho Bishop of St. Asaph, well know that ho is 
quick in detecting any error, most candid in stating his actual opinion, unwilling to 
compromise tho truth, or to compliment any person who docs not fully doserve it. 



66 

I may here observe, that the office of an examiner, however 
honestly he may be disposed, is not so easy an office as some persons 
imagine ; especially if called upon to examine children in a foreign 
tongue, " not linderstanded of the people," of which people the 
children form a part. Both the examiner and the examined?are 
placed in a difficult position. Imagine a case : Suppose yourself 
transferred to some very obscure village school in the heart of 
England ; you are told that the children are instructed in the 
French or the German tongue, (as it may be,) and you are told 
also that their instructor in this tongue is an Englishman, who never 
had quitted his own country. You are called upon to examine the 
children in this foreign tongue ; you being, as we will persume, a 
perfect master of that tongue ; what, I ask, what expectations would 
you form ? How would you approach them ? Now, this is just 
the position in which the Welsh children stand with respect to their 
teachers — their teachers with respect to them — and the inspectors 
or examiners with respect to both. The children in' Wales 'speak 
the British language ; think in the British language ; converse with 
their parents and with each other in the British language ;"attend 
divine service, and for the most part respond in the British language. 
The greater part of them never hear or utter a word of English, but 
during the hours of instruction, and within the walls of the school ! 
Go to the schools of Eton, Westminster, Winchester, &c, and ask 
the masters of those schools, whether they will impose upon them- 
selves and their pupils this task ; viz. The conducting the whole 
instruction of their respective schools through the medium of those 
languages alone in which they are instructing their pupils ? # Are 
they prepared to ask every child, commencing his studies in the 
Latin or Greek Grammar, questions in those languages ? and are they 
prepared to receive correct answers in those languages ? Nay, to 
state the case with more licence, are the masters of our first Gram- 
mar Schools in the habit of conversing with the pupils of the highest 
grade in Greek and Latin only ? Is nothing but Greek and Latin 
spoken within the walls of our colleges ? But the Welsh child in 
learning English is under great disadvantages. No two languages 
differ more entirely than do the British and English languages. 
They differ greatly in the power of their respective letters ; in 



* The idea which formerly prevailed of instructing persons in a language through 
the medium of the language itself is now quite obsolete. That this system formerly 
prevailed is wall known ; some copies, perhaps, of Dr. Busby's Latin Grammar : 
yet be extant. 



67 

respect of idiom, f accentuation,^ and general construction. There 
is an instance on record which strongly proves the truth of this 
position, and that well known to myself. The instance is this : An 
English lady, who speaks the French language, has stationed herself 
in a village in Wales. She had engaged a female servant who could 
only speak the Welsh tongue. The communication between them 
was attended with such difficulty (the girl not having been an 
attendant, unfortunately, in any of our National Schools) that the 
lady determined to instruct her in speaking the French language. 
In this attempt she fully succeeded ; and now the parties com- 
municate with ease. Upon the same principle a gentleman near 
Conway has acted, and the result lias been the same. 

Every person who possesses the Welsh language, and has any 
knowledge of the French, will, while he compares the characters of 
the two, see clearly how comparatively easy the task was, which the 
teachers and pupils had to perform. 

Having thus stated the case of the Welsh females, I proceed. See 
then the position in which the examiner stands with respect to his 
pupil, and his pupil in respect of him. The examiner has never 
the child before, nor the child the examiner. The child has 



I Idiom. — The following anecdotes will shew tho difficulties the Wulsh have in 
respect of idiom :— A labourer, meaning to say that he had Hprcad dang upon tho land 
of his employer, finding himself in food, made the following charge : " For spreading 
dung upon my own meet." A bntcher. writing to a lady to inform her that ho could 
not himself kill beef the present week, but would kill the following week, thus expressed 
himself, " Bladdam, I am sorry that I did not kill'd beef this week, but I will kill myself 
next week in hopes to place you." 

X Accentuation. — In the Welsh language, the accent is placed in words as late as 
possible ; there is no such thing as a dactyle in the Welsh language.— tho language 
mores in anapaests. In words derived from th»* same ptock, they movo tho accent to 
the penultimate, as in the following instances: Cyffulyb. cyffcly'biaeth, cyffelyb- 
ise'thsu; ath x raw, athrawiaeth, athraw'iaethau. It will be easily conceived, therefore, 
how difficult it ia for the Welsh children to place the accent on the early part of the 
words which they pronounce. As for instance, they would call the word com'muned, 
oommu'hed ; no'minativc, nominative ; superlative, superlative ; glo^rify. glorify* ; 
ssne'tify, sanctify', &c. Are not the three following words ditticult of pronunciation, 
even to those who are accustomed from their childhood to their proper accentuation : 
GongZAtulatory, confa'bulatory. laboratory. There aro several other simple words in 
the English language even monosyllables, in which tho Welsh meet no difficulty on 
the score of accent, but where the difficulty consists in tho power of the letters thom- 
selres, as in the following words : War, was, want, warm, water. In pronouncing theso 
words, the Welsh use tho open a, consistently witb their own language, and as adopted 
by the English language in the following instances : Father, rather, glass, pass, cant, 
pent, fancy, card, hard. &e. They lind. therefore, great difficulty in pronouncing tho 
broad a. as in the words, All. call, wall, fall, ball, and in the words quoted above ; these 
they would pronounce in the same manner as they are accustomed to do with the 
following words : Abad, achar. adar, afal. aha, allan, anudl. araf, athraw, bagad. bala, 
bara, cadarn, carchar, galar, gras. gwastad, gwas, paladr, tar an. traha, In reference 
to the difficulties arising from idiom, as alluded to above, the following is given as an 
illustration : A boy excused his absence from school, saying he could not walk, as ho 
had hurt his thumb, meaning his great toe. Tho Welsh language expresses the woid 
toes, by the fingers of the foot, (bysedd y^troed) ; and tho great toe, by the thumb of 
the foot* (bawd y troed). 



68 

never heard the tone of the examiner's voice ; his tone is foreign, 
and his accent is foreign. They who have not studied acoustics 
know not how much there is in the music of a voice. Again : his 
manner is foreign ; the disposition of his words is foreign. There is 
much in all this. Again : the examiner will .have to adapt his 
manner to, and make choice of words familiar to the people of the 
country to which his commission extends. The Cheshire man, 
though " chief of men," must not be sent to Cornwall, nor must the 
Cornish man be sent to Cumberland, nor he of Cumberland to 
Cornwallia. Now, if tha man of Cheshire or Cumberland should 
not have his commission in Cornwallia, how much less so in Wallia 
Magna !* If the examiner undertakes the work of inspector, he 
should possess good sense, good ear, and such tact as may enable 
him to adapt himself to the way of thinking and speaking of the 
people to whom he is sent ; as also their habits, their familiar 
sayings, their customs, &c. There is much also in this, for thuB he 
may lead on his pupils, by simple illustrations borrowed from 
objects with which they are familiar. Now, if this is true as it 
respects England, how true is it as it respects Wales ! Here, far 
more than in England, the examiner may (because he has less 
previous knowledge of the country) use terms which are very 
familiar to him, but not known to the children whom he is exa- 
mining. Again : there is much in the manner of putting the question. 
The child may be led on step by step till he shall find himself 
confident enough to answer difficult questions, to which at^first he 
could have given no answer ; or at least, an uncertain one, or one 
presented to his mind by association. The examiner will not begin 
his work abruptly, and with a stern countenance, and a commanding 
voice, ask the child some question totally unconnected with the 
subject on which he is reading ; but will take off ihejiery edge qf 
his fear, by asking him some questions, the answer to which the 
child must know, if he knows anything, giving the child credit for 
the answer ; and thus he will proceed, until he becomes possessed of 
all the actual knowledge of which the child is possessed Imagine a 

* In reference to the remarks hero made, I will presume to add, that, probably, no 
persons are loss qualified as effective school examiners in our rural districts, than they 
who have been born and bred in London. The Londoner brings with him either the 
refined pronunciation of the Capital, or its less rofinod peculiarities. A man speaking 
in a broader dialect, and with a more northern accent, would be for better understood 
by thoso who are conversant with the same accent, and dialect. The dialect which 
does not give to tho vowel e its duo sound, but converts it into ant; post fixes the 
letter r to words terminating in a ; substitutes w for r, and makes the v and w to 
change places ; this, I say,- confounds our rustic s in tho northern counties of England, 
and in the interior of Wales. Tho peculiarities alluded to may be thus embodied: 
Jemes, biing the cold weal, and the winegar, and the rest of wituals. I hope yon 
will find the pudden wery good. I shall be atome this aternoon, I have no idear of 
going out. Elizar, tell Miss Mariar to como to tea, and git the kittle ready. 



69 

in some obscure country school, amidst the mountains of 
Wales ; a school situated in a parish, in length twelve miles, in 
breadth two ; or another embracing within its boundaries 30,000 
acres, more extensive but more compact ! (for such parishes there 
are) ; in such cases, " the children of the mist " are often mist when 
they should be present. Can you wonder, Sir, that the Atlantic, 
borne upon the wings of the winds, and bearing down upon the huts 
of David Davies and Jane Jones, for six, sometimes twelve, and even 
eighteen hours together, should deter these persons from sending 
their children, two, three, or four miles, to meet the pelting of this 
pitiless storm, this "drwg hin," or "dryc hin," (which you may 
translate ducking,) with no omnibus in the eye, no umbrella in 
hand, no house by the way, with no living object, either animal or 
vegetable, to console them, save a bush not big enough to hide a 
bird, or a patient cow, with her tail turned to the tempest, or the 
lowly sheep sheltering under the projection of a shelving stone ; or 
■ome bad bent birch brooms, few and far between, " the counter- 
feit presentment " of a would-be wood, to stand or sit all day in his 
▼et clothes, with his bread and butter in his pocket, reduced to 
padding, or to puddle, or to pulp ! Or again : suppose the weather 
tt Bright ; has the poor cottager, or the little farmer, who is, indeed, 
Httie more than a cottager, nothing to do which renders the assis- 
tance of his children necessary ? Where is Owen Owens to-day v 
8*yB the master. She is gone to Carnedd Dafydd, or Trawsfynydd, 
(•a it may be,) if you please, says William Williams, to look after 
. the seeps ; a tog has tored wan of a seeplegs very pad ; her is 
k&e, and she is bringing him home. The master again inquires, 
"We is Grace Griffith ? He is gone to brought some ool (wool) 
from little way up Bryneryri, (Snowdon, about 3,000 feet,) and she 
*y he will sure come in morning.* The Inspector enters at this 

* H*, ghe, &c. — The Welsh feel great difficulty in applying the pronouns aright ; 
jj**Mch, very substantial reasons might be given. The following anecdotes will 
1 *Wtrate my meaning :— A kind English lady sympathised with a poor bed-ridden 
y°°»Mupon a preceding stormy night, saying, " I fear you got but very little sleep 
j^Jight." She answered, " No, inteet, you (meaning it) plow (blow) very pad all 
^W»t (night) ; you plow all these slate upon my pod." Another poor woman made 
Sr >D8,rer *° an inquiry respecting the health of .;er husband, " You dio 
*** %ht, you be bury next week." A man bought a horse, and declared that " he 
**• good horse, though he thought that she was little lame, and he thought he 
*oold sell it." A traveller called at a small country inn, and asked a little girl, who 
Jwted upon him, for a boot-jack; she accordingly brought him one, saying, "Here 
*«ii." The traveller remonstrated, and said, "You should not call the boot-jack. 
!**•* M No inteet," was the answer, " I should not call him she, for Iter name is 
***•" When the Welsh Militia were in Chester, the persons passing by, when tho 
J**** were called upon parade, were amused by tbe answers given : " Robert 
Tg^l—Here 8 ;^ i 8 . Owen Owens?— Here it is " 

"•B.— It must be remarked that tho Welsh language has no neuter gender. 



70 

moment ; the children are not quite collected in their classes : some 
are standing, leaning with their backs to the wall, for they have not 
had the advantage of being drilled in St. James's Park, under the 
eye of the Secretary of the Council of Education, nor have they 
been under a regularly trained master from Westminster, f Again : 
these children have walked two or three miles over rocks and 
morasses, through bogs and briers, woods and water-courses ; and 
may, possibly, be somewhat fatigued ; thus circumstanced then they 
are found not quite in an upright posture, with all their appoint- 
ments in order, when the Inspector enters. The master, however, 
(who by the way is passing rich with Thirty Pounds a year, to- 
gether with a cottage, for which boon his wife instructs the children 
in Needlework,) as the Inspector enters, calls his children to order, 
exhorting them, perhaps, in the following manner : For the sake of 
goodness, why do you not all stand upon your own heads ! Mean- 
ing, in the Welsh idiom, standing upright, or supporting themselves 
by their own means. The Inspector wonders at the order ; but 
would cease to wonder, if he was told, what he ought to have 
known, that the British think in their own language, and in trans- 
lating their ideas into English, convey the idiom of their own 
language into that into which their ideas are transfused. This is 
the case in all languages, of which many instances might be given. 
But the Inspector has entered ; and having entered, with his atten- 
dants, armed with books, pencils, &c, and all the artillery of 
scholastic warfare ; when the scholars are told that this gentleman 
has come from London, and has been sent by the Queen to examine 
them ; when these urchins, who hardly ever saw a gentleman, 
except a tourist, who has given them a penny for shewing him the 
way, or twopence for a piece of Snowdon crystal, or sixpence for a 
woollen Welsh wig, by which he has won their confidence ; — when 
this London gentleman, commissioned by Queen Victoria, steps up 
to the first class of these country urchins, and peremptorily demands 
of them, as one having authority, answers to some questions in 
theology, chronology, geography, grammar, &c. , couched in no very 
easy language, is it not enough to make the stoutest heart among 
them quail, and lead them, astounded and stunned as they are, to 
say something rather than nothing? and from mere sound and 
association to declare Paul (meaning Saul) to be the king of Israel ! 
and Judas (meaning Judah) to be one of the sons of Jacob ! Or 
again : not fully understanding the familiar word made in all its 
acceptations, can we wonder that, if the Inspector should ask a child 
t The Inspectors of schools emanate from the Council of Education ; the oflleeef 
which is situated in Parliament Street, which lies on the borders of St, James's 



71 

of what occupation Jacob was, the child should answer, A tailor, 
because he made his son Joseph a coat of many colours ! Or 
would you wonder if a little girl, hurried and fright end, should 
transpose some letters, and for the passage, "sitting on twelve 
ftrtmeff," should read, twelve thurn*? Or, never having seen the word 
stytafery, should read the passage which contains it, thus : Therefore 
astf a man lace his father ami his mother, and mil clacr to his wife, 
and they twain sail be one/?* ; this is a great wi# nj ! Or again : 
can you wonder if a Welsh child, though long under instruction, 
should not always be able to give an English word for some familiar 
object of daily occurence. I remember an instance of this : A boy 
had answered every question put to him ; reading the history of 
Lof 8 wife, the master asked him how she was punished for her 
disobedience? The boy answered, She was turned into a pillar 

of . Here he hesitated, saying, I cannot say what in English, 

but the Welsh word is hal-n. — Salt, said another boy. The fact 
was. that the boy could answer the most difficult questions, but that 
f«nfli*r word salt was not familiar with him. Such an anecdote as 
this will put foreigners in possession of the difficulties which the 
Welsh have to overcome in learning a foreign language. They who 
understand the genius of the Welsh language, well know how 
difficult it is to discard its peculiarities, when called upon to speak 
their sentiments in English ; nay, even the difficulties which they 
encounter in the use of the mutable consonants, p t A, t, d. They 
who are aware of these difficulties will not be suprised when the 
Welsh child asks Lazarus to tip the dip of his finger, instead of dip 
the tip ; or if he causes the forgiving father of the prodigal son to 
direct his servants, instead of a rah?, to put the best rope upon him ! 
Again : nor, if in the spirit of his native tongue, after the manner of 
the French, the child should dovetail one word into another, or, in 
other terms, thrust the termination of one word into the commence- 
ment of another ; as, for example, in repeating the Tenth Command- 
ment, "Thou nalt not covet the ntiyhboursoune, thou Halt not covet the 
meighbour8wift y nor hisojc, nor him**, nor any thing that i*hbt"* I 

* This mode of combining words is well known to be common in other languages 
of the same family; we are not aware, perhaps, how prrfe -tly unintelligible our mode 
of •peaking would be to those classical authors, whose work's we are in the hai.it of 
wearing in our schools and Universities. It is well lor us that "bonus dorm i tat 
Hemeros," or how would he be enraged to hear the moderns murder his lines. 
Would not TTOCaQ utKvg 'AxiAXei'C take to his heels when he heard himself so 
grossly nicknamed? 

M O there be " some " that I have seen, and heard others praise, and that highly, 
not to speak it profanely, that neither having the accent or Christians, nor the gait of 
Christian, Pagan, Norman ; have so bellow'd, that I have thought some of nature's 
Journeymen had made them, and not made them well. — they imitated humanity so 
sAoarinaUy."— Shake spe a es. 



72 

have stated a supposed case above ; permit me to state an actual 
case : On the great London Road, near Cernioge, there lives a poor 
blind woman, who exists, in a great measure, by selling woollen 
Welsh wigs. She occasionally employs her little girl in performing 
this office. The price of these articles is one shilling. The whole 
stock of English, which this poor child has acquired, is the single 
word shilling, which she pronounces sillin. When she exposes 
these wigs for sale to the coach passengers, they amuse themselves 
by asking her several questions, to which she invariably gives the 
same answer, viz. sillin. As thus : What do you ask for the wig ? 
Sillin ! What is your name ? Sillin ! Where do you come 
from? Sillin! &c. Now, you will suppose this child's time, 
during the summer months, (while travellers and tourists are on the 
move,) to be engaged for the most part in this sillin traffic ; while in 
the winter months she may be spared to attend the school at Oapel 
Voylas, lying about three miles distant, and in a country pre- 
eminently bleak. Suppose, then, the Inspector should come in 
collision with this silly lass, and open out upon her his stores of 
theology, philosophy, etymology, chronology, geography, geometry, 
or any other thing which he has in his budget ; could she be 
severely blamed should she not give satisfactory answers; but 
evince ignorance, arising from such disadvantageous circumstances, 
as well as her self-interest, and the effect also of habit, by occasion' 
ally responding sillin ? 

We are aware that in those words in the English language, begin- 
ning with the letters kn, the English have suppressed the. letter h, 
and read those words as if that letter had no power, nor possessed 
any part of those words. Thus have they confounded (as it 
respects the ear) several words, giving them the same sound as 
other words which have a totally different sense. As, for instance, 
nave for knave ; nap, for knap ; no, for know ; nose for knows; night, 
for knight ; need, for knead ; not, for knot, &c. 

Thus they have broken the back of these words, and drawn out 
their spinal marrow. They stand indeed, but not erect ; they have 
frail bodies without souls, as shadows without substance ; putting 
us much in mind of the play of Hamlet, in which the part of Hamlet 
was omitted "by particular desire." 

Thus also they have sacrificed the onomatopeia, and thus the sound 
is lost which should echo the sense, as in the words, knap, knife, knit, 
knob, knock, knoll, &c. Now in the Welsh language the hard f, 
which is equivalent in sound to the English k, is retained in all its 
power. Can we wonder then if the Welsh child, accustomed to 



78 

renounce this letter in the following Welsh words, cneifio, cnap, 
tan, cnawd, cnoi, cnu, &c, should convey the sound into English 
raids in which the same sound was originally acknowledged ? The 
inglish indeed have relinquished the proper sound of these words, 
vhile the Welsh have retained it. 

I have given a reason and have made an excuse for the Welsh 
shild in using the letter h, when preceding the letter n, I wish I could 
make as good an excuse for certain orders of the English, in the 
perpetual misapplication of the letter h. From this fault (the 
English shibboleth) the Welsh are entirely free. The Welsh child 
never perverts the meaning of words, nor alters the sense of passages, 
by omitting or supplying this letter. In the description of the awards 
made by Pharaoh to his servants, we are satisfied that the following 
version is correct, as applying to the chief baker, " and him he 
Hanged." I have however heard the following reading in England, 
Han im e anged. No Welsh child was ever guilty of such a per- 
version of the account of the baker's fate as would make him worthy 
of the same. "Ere is the hare come, let us kill im." Accustomed 
as I am to hear the reading of the Welsh children, I confess that I 
have a prejudice in favour of the received version. The Welsh chil- 
dren do not crush heaven into eaven ; nor exalt earth into hearth. 
They do not mistake the letter I, for hell ; nor make an n lay heggs. 
They permit the owl to be an owl, since a hoot, not a howl, is its 
natural cry. Every horseman is not a Norseman in the esteem of the 
Welsh child. The substantive ear is not the verb hear in his parts 
of speech ; nor again, the substantive eye, the adjective high. Nor 
B * high hM necessarily a nigh ill, especially jin Wales.* 

" Now tell me whero's this fancy bred, 
Not in the art nor in the ead; 
No, 'tis hengender'd in the high." 

The Welsh child never yet mistook the letter a for dried grass, com- 
^M&ly called hay ; though I have been told that such a mistake has 
heenmadein the neighbourhood of St. James's Park.f The meekest 
maiden of our Welsh Infant Schools could not be taught to sympathize 
*fth the London hairdresser, who lamented that the prevailing 
epidemic was in the hair ; correcting, however, the mistake to which 
to had led his companion, by saying, Not the air of the ead, but 
we hair of the hat-mosphere. It must be allowed, however, that 

_* For further particulars, inquire at Snowdon, Cider Idris, Aran Mowddwy, 
fltmtimon, and Bannau Bry cheiniog. 

t in allusion is here made to a work put out by an officer of the Council of 
gyWitt on, in Which it was proposed to express the sound of the letters by signs. In 
warning up the principle, the letter a was represented by a cart-load of hay. 



74 

there is a close connection between the hair and the hat. In short, 
the Welsh children dare to say, and do, what the English children 
can neither say nor do. They can repeat the following well known 
line : — 

" How high his highness holds his haughty head." 

The boys can leave their houses, and mount their horses, and hunt 
the hare over the high hedges, holding their reins in their hands, as 
they hurry over hill and hollow, hallooing and hooping as they haste 
the harriers to their home. Nor, when they arrive there, are they so 
hungry, as of necessity to eat their own pokers, ovens, and teakettles. 
Nor is their larder so lean or so ill stocked with fish, flesh, and fowl, 
as to constrain them to eat their heels at the fire, or to heat their eels 
upon the table. Their language is not, as it is in England, at one 
time a baseless f abrick of a vision which leaves no h behind, and at 
another a baseless fabrick which leaves each h behind. Borrowing 
my ideas from the same dramatic author, whose words I have 
dared to paraphrase, borrowing also from the reading of a great 
tragedian of his school, these children nothing exhaspirate, nothing 
extenuate, nor fill our sides with ach — es. * 

I have stated above the reason why the Welsh retain the sound 
of the letter h before n; the English having dropped that letter 
in like circumstances. There are other consonants whose apparently 
arbitrary use presents difficulties to the Welsh. I allude to the 
letter c and g, the hard or soft sound of which is regulated, with 
few exceptions, by their succeeding vowels ; the c retaining the soft 
sound of 8 before the vowels e and i ; and the hard sound, like k, 
before the vowels a, o, and u. The g having sometimes the soft sound 
before e and i, and the hard sound before a, o, and u. The following 
words may serve as examples : — Card, cell, cill, cord, cord ; car- 
case, concert, circuit, circumcise ; gale, gem, gird, goose, guide ; 
Ganges, ginger, gigantic, gudgeon. The Welsh child is ill prepared 
for meeting with this difficulty, since the Welsh language assumes a 
definite sound in each letter, and retains it. The consonant dd 
(double d) is, I believe, peculiar to the Welsh language ; its Bound, 
however, is acknowledged in the letters th in the English language ; 
as in the words, that, the, thee, them, then, thou, there, though, this, 

* Ach— es : Mr. John Kemble, the Tragedian, in that passage of Shakespeare^ Hay, 
" The Tempest," in which Prospero threatens to punish Caliban, by fltttng hia riM 
with aches, desirous of making the line, as he supposed, metrically correct, read the 
word aches as a word of two syllables, softening the hard sound of the letter e. The 
following will exactly give the sound : Aitch — es. 

In further reference to the misapplication of the letter h t I subjoin the following 
anecdotes :— A gentleman thus addressed his lady at dinner, " My dear, your soap v 
haeid and your heels are greasy." A churchwarden put the following item in Mi 
accounts: "For eating the church." A lady, touring in Wales, took a ear to 



75 

thy ; father, mother, brother, smother, other, rather, leather, lather. 
In the following words ; through, thick, thin, thrust, throttle, thrash, 
thatch, throw, &c, the th retains its harsher sound. The first 
sound of the th, viz. as a (bl, is produced by bringing the Hat part 
of the tongue on the roof of the mouth, and extending it latterly to 
the teeth in both sides. The harsher sound of the th is produced by 
bringing the tip of the tongue under the front teeth. Any letter, I 
conceive, may be pronounced by attending to the position of the 
tongue. Even the 11, which has a sound peculiar to the Welsh, may 
be pronounced by fixing, the tip of the tongue to the roof the mouth, 
and breathing forcibly through the jaw-fat h on both sides, but more 
on the right; as if written in English lift." I, myself, have been 
enabled to teach a master of the French language to distinguish 
between and clearly to articulate the words tru? and through. 
How, this different sound given to th, to which we alluded above, 
is a source of difficulty to the Welsh child ; he being required to 
give two sounds of such different characters to the same letters, 
A gain, the seven vowels of the Welsh language, a, e, i, o, u, w, y, 
are not sounded as in English, but much more after the manner of 
the French and the Italians. The vowel w has a peculiar sound, 
and is never used as in the following English words : — what, where, 
which, whom, when, &c, but has a sound resembling that of two 
cte ; the Welsh child, therefore, would naturally pronounce the 
word wool as "ool," wood as i% ood" world as " orW," woman as 
"omany" for which reason Shakespeare makes Parson Evans, in 
his Merry Wives of Windsor, speak in the following manner ; — " By 



1 from Llanrwst to Bettws-y-Coed. One side of tho road is bounded by a hedge ; on 
the other is a steep precipice overhanging the river Conway. The lady, being alarmed 
when she found herself so cIobc to the odue of tho precipice, directed the drivor to keep 
dose to the edge, meaning the hedge. Tho Welsh driver, conceiving that the English 
lady most understand her own language took her direction literally, and persisted in 
drawing close to the edge, at ,the same time declaring that ho kept as close to the 
edge as he could, for he was thon within a foot of the precipice. The lady, by signs, 
at ^gfefr, made him understand that by edge, she meant Judge. At one of the 
Oratorio* performed at Worcester, one of the gentlemen of tho Commit te, who was 
notorious for misusing the letter 7t, was present, fulfilling the duties of his office. 
Wfi^y"* Garradori Allen, one of the performers, was taken ill, and retired to another 
room for the benefit of cooler air. The gentleman attended her, and directed that one 
of ibe doors should be opened, at the time affirming that Madame C. Allen had no hair. 
The lady, having a little recovered, and finding herself somewhat chilled, the gentleman 
eaDed out, saying, " Shut the dour there, Madame C. Allen has too much hair." A 
lady from Lancashire was asked by the gentleman of tho house where she dined, what 
aha would eat? She answered, "I will take a littlo are," meaning liare. The 
gentleman taking her at her word, ordered the servant to open the window, and give 
the lady a little air. A gentleman in Berkshire asked his friend why a certain match 
had gone off ? He answered, *' Its all owing to tho itch" moaning hitch. The gentle- 
man mistaking him, asked on which side ? The answer was, " The lady's ! 1" A man 
of Walsall wrote to his friend at Wolverhampton : and in so doing he omitted the h 
In that word. The man of Wolverhampton asked is friend why ho had omitted the h ? 
He answered, " that he meant to make a present of it, to enable the people of 
Wolverhampton to spell hiron I /" 



76 

yea, and no, I think the 'oman is a witch, indeed. I like not when 
a 'omans has a great peard ; I spy a great peard under his muf- 
fler. " The Welsh language has no open sound resembling the 
sound of aw and au, as caw, daw, flaw, maw, paw, saw ; or, again, 
daub, gaud, laud, maude. They would, therefore, express flaw as 
flo, maw as mow, draw as dro, saw as so, &c. ; daube as dobe, laud 
as lode, &c. The construction of the Welsh language also is some 
cause of difficulty. In the Welsh language the substantive precedes 
the adjective : the thing is first affirmed, and then denned. Thus, 
while the English, if I may so speak, place the cart before the 
horse, the Welsh place the horse first, who draws the cart after 
him. For the sake of example : — Where the English language 
uses the expression, a good man ; the Welsh would say, the man 
good. Can we wonder, then, that under these circumstances, the 
Welsh child should express himself thus': — " Pudding rice, John 
little, the cow fat, the tree apple, the post gate, the handkerchief 
pocket." 

In the Welsh language, the noun substantive is termed, enw 
cadarn, i. e. the strong noun ; the noun adjective, enw gwan, i. e. 
the weak noun ; as the epithet defines the noun, and as the ad- 
jective, or enw gwan, leans upon the substantive, or enw cadarn ; it 
is fit, therefore, that it should follow. When this principle has long 
been acted upon, it is difficult to dismiss it from the mind. The 
scholar well knows how far other languages agree with, ot differ 
from, the English and Welsh languages in this respect. 

The usual formation of plural nouns in the English language by 
the addition of a letter, or a syllable, contains some degree of 
difficulty in the mind of a Welsh child, since his own language in a 
few instances, instead of adding, drops a syllable ; as llygoden, a 
rat ; llygod, rats ; mochyn, a pig ; moch, pigs ; plentyn, a child ; 
plantt children. The peculiarly Saxon, and irregular plurals, though 
they add a syllable, yet contain a difficulty ; as brother, brethren ; 
child, children ; hose, hosen ; man, men ; woman, women ; ox, 
oxen ; foot, feet ; tooth, teeth. 

The Welsh tongue is defective in the present tense of the 
regular verbs ; and therefore, it uses a circumlocution by a verb 
substantive and the infinitive mood of the verb, which it adopts 
instead of a participle of the present tense . Thus, instead of I love, 
or do love ; it says, I am loving. Sometimes it makes use of the 
future of the indicative mood. This accounts for expressions such 
as the following: — "My master is in telling me; my brother is in 
asking " The preterite of do (did) is often used, as we know, with 



77 

the present tense of any verb, and expresses the preterite of that 
verb ; as did say, for said ; did bring, for brought ; did tight, for 
fought. The Welsh children find this substitution a greater diffi- 
culty than might have been conceived, and are disposed to join it to 
the past tense of the verb, for which it is a substitute. For this 
reason, they are often heard to say, I did brouyht, he did said, they 
did fought, when did ho cam* 1 where did he went i Tt is easy, 
therefore, to perceive the difficulty a child has to overcome in 
ft/v^mi-mg the English verbs. In learning the Numeration Table, 
another difficulty presents itself to the child. In reading, tho 
KngKwh begin with the greater number, and close with the lesser •' 
whereas the Welsh reverse the order, beginning with the lesser, 
and ending with the greater. For example: "The hundred and 
thirty-seventh Psalm " is expressed in Welsh thus : " Yr rilfnl Sahi 
ar bymtheg ar hwjain ar of y yanfvd :" i. c. literally, The second 
Psalm upon fifteen upon twenty after the hundredth ; "Thirty- 
nine " is pedwar ar bymthey ar huyahi : i. e. Four upon fifteen upon 
twenty. The Welsh count by scores and not by tens. 

The Welsh language being, defective in the present tense of the 
regular verbs, sometimes uses the future tense sf the indicative 
mood, as in the Apostles' Creed, " Credaf yn Nuw Dad;" literally, 
according to the English, " / mill belieiy." This is so peculiar, and 
so foreign to the character of the English language, that it adds 
another to the host of difficulties in the way of the Welsh child in 
acquiring the English language. 

There are some words in the Welsh language which have two 
lenses nearly allied ; rhoddt, to give or put ; torn, to break or cut. 
This naturally occasions mistakes, which may be illustrated by the 
following anecdotes : — An old woman kept a favourite cat, and 
was detailing its merits to a stranger, saying, " He good cat, she 
kill rat, and give him to a step." That is, put him on the step. 
A Welsh labourer in Chester was heard to complain, and say, " I 
was brake my coat ;" meaning, I have torn my coat. 

" Ah bootless," plaint, " for which ho paid most dear," 
For all the English lads, both far and near, 
Throughout tho streets, '* did sing most loud and clear," 
Ah, " I was brake my coat," — in every ear." 

Welsh children are often heard to say, " My mother did brake my 
hair/' meaning cut it. 

There was one practice of the Inspectors I must name, which 
was universally censured, and deservedly so. It is the following : 
They were in the habit of putting leading questions, so as to 

G 



78 

delude and entrap the unsuspecting children : who, by the assumed 
confident manner of the examiner, were led to suppose that he 
thought as he spoke, and desired to obtain the answer which he 
seemed to anticipate. Thus he taught the child a lesson of deceit, 
(which needs not to be taught,) and left the children to be de- 
ceived by those whose duty it was to inform them aright. I will 
endeavour to illustrate what I mean. The examiner, we will 
suppose, thus asks an ensnaring question : It was Joshua then who 
led the children of Israel through the Red Sea, and Moses who led 
them through the river Jordan, was it not? " Yes Sir," answers 
the unsuspecting child ; assuming that the examiner must be right, or 
would not willingly lead him wrong. Does not the word ascend mean 
to go down ? Was not John the Baptist the same person as John the 
Evangelist ? Was Bethlehem in Galilee or in Samaria ? If Judas 
received thirty pieces of silver for betraying his Master, what did 
Peter get for denying him ? In the 12th chapter of the Acts of the 
Apostles, 17th verse, we read that Peter on his deliverance from 
prison came to the house of Mary the mother of John, and declared 
unto the persons assembled there, how the Lord had brought him out 
of the prison saying, " Go shew these things unto James and to the 
brethren." How does this agree with the account given in the 1st 
and 2nd verses, that " Herod the king killed James ?" Was not the 
province of Judea in the north of Palestine, and Nazareth one of its 
principal cities ? The plural number of sheep is sheeps, and of foot, 
foots, is it not ? 

I do not mean to say that these questions were asked ; but I mean 
such questions were asked : these are given merely as illustrations, 
to hold up to censure the principle herein admitted, and the practice 
grounded upon it. Neither the principle nor the practice can be too 
much condemned. The practice is forbidden in the legal pro- 
ceedings of our courts of justice. The examiner is not permitted to 
put such leading questions to the witness as may occasion him to 
ensnare himself, nor to the prisoner to condemn himself. " Chwart 
teg i bawb" says the Welsh proverb; which is equivalent to the 
English proverb, " Fair play is a jewel."* 

* Tho following soductive questions wero actually asked by one of the Inipeotart:— 
Christ was crucified, in Bethlehem, was he not ? 
Noah built the Templo, did he not ? 
Peter was one of the Prophets, was he not ? 
St. Revelation wrote the Acts of tho Apostles, did he not? 
Does not tho River Jordan run by Mold ? 

What was the name of tho angel who spake to Balaam on the way ? 
Where was Moses laid when a babe ?— on tho banks of what river,— w»i ft tbf 
river Dee ? 



79 

Now, under all the circumstances I have detailed, will any one 
censure heavily the defects found in Welsh schools, especially when, 
under all these disadvantages, the children in these schools are 
superior to their ordinary English neighbours in Biblical knowledge, 
and in expressing themselves in language which, however defective 
in accent, is, in the absence of provincialism, far purer than the 
language which is spoken in many of our English rural districts ?f 
But, laying all these considerations aside, we well know that children, 
when examined by a stranger, are always placed in disadvantageous 
circumstances, "for they know not the voice of strangers." On 
such, occasions they always disappoint their patrons and teachers. 
In making these remarks respecting the incompetency of strangers 
to conduct an examination, so as to atiord the children the means of 
doing themselves credit, I must admit that in many instances, (as I 
believe,) the Inspectors did permit the masters to examine their 
respective schools. But, with respect to examinations generally, 
do not timid boys at our Grammar Schools, and young men of 
modest merit at our Universities, often do themselves injustice, when 
submitted to a viva voce examination **•••* And is it not for this 
reason that the examiners in our Universities, desirous of affording 
equal advantages to all, resort to the use of a written mode of 
examination ? I conclude by accommodating a piece of advice for the 
use of all Inspectors, given by the Son of Sirach, "If thou love to 
hear, thou shalt receive understanding. First understand, and then 
rebuke. If thou hast understanding, answer thy neighbour ; if not, 
pat thy hand upon thy mouth. " 

Yours, &c. 

AN UNPAID INSPECTOR. 

The Commissioner and his Assistants do not appear to have attended to the 
following directions which they hod received, and which I have extracted from the 
Beport :— " Whenever yon have the means to form a just estimate of the qualifications 
ana attainments of the Masters, it should be so stated us not to operate as a dis- 
couragement to humble but deserving men, who may have hod few opportunities of 
education." 

The Clergy and the Schoolmasters doprccatcd the nso of the following harsh 
epithets, when generally applied to the stato of the schools :— " abominable," 
"atrocious," " disgusting," and " demoralizing ;" as also the following language, when 
applied to the children of the schools : — " Is tho boy deaf, or imbecile ?" &c. 

The Master of the School at Carnarvon, says ho feels astonished at the Report made 
by the Commissioner as to the state of his School : as from documents in the Master's 
possession, he is able to show that tho Commissioner took littlo pains to inquire into 
the real state of the School. 

t Every one well knows how various are the dialocts and provincialisms which 
prevail in tho different counties of England. Tho language spoken in our rural 
districts, it must be granted, is exceedingly impure. I am acquainted with the dialect 
of some of the northern and southern counties. I allude in this place to Cheshire, 
Shropshire, and Dorsetshire ; in the first of these the following conversation was heard 
to take place between a gentleman and his tenant : the gentleman in allusion to a 



80 

It is obvious that none but the Welsh scholar can enter fully into 

the spirit of the philological remarks contained in this pamphlet, or 

be enabled entirely to judge of their correctness. Every reader, 

however, will be enabled in a great measure to see the difficulties 

the Welsh child has to overcome in acquiring the English language . 

He will feel also the injustice which has been done to him by the 

Report of those persons who, from their ignorance of the language 

could not have done him justice, even if they had been disposed to 

do so. As the subject itself is somewhat dry to the English reader, 

the illustrations and examples have been given in such a manner as 

may induce those persons to read the letter, who might not have 

been interested in the subject itself. 

promise mado by a young man to marry the tenant's daughter, asked the tenant, 
whether ho had fulflllod his engagements ? to which he answered, " Noe, noe, heiwunit 
com up toth snob ;" which in the English of the Principality signifies, *' No, no, he is 
not willing to come forward." Upon this, the gentleman said, "I will speak 
to him." And then, the farmer answerod, " Dunna yew now, for if yew don, yonle 
besh him and smey him ;" which signifies in the English of the Principality, "Pont 
yon now, for if you do, you will abash him and dismay him." 

I now speak of Shropshire. We will suppose a farmer thus to address his servant. 
I premise that the address is entirely imaginary, intended only to embrace peculiar- 
ities,— a peg upon which to hang provincialisms. I do not mean, indeed, to assert 
that all the terms used aro provincialisms; for many of them are obsolete words, 
which may bo found in some of the works of our best ancient authors. The address, 
we will suppose to run thus : " Ast seed tho fcyther mon ? Come tothmaister ; eome 
orth dych ; donna bo afeard ; its power eemer ; and pike up that bowk. Where hast 
bin so lung? It jows o raan ; theill be the dickens to pey at whoam if yeget wetehet. 
The usen to bey a farancle feller, bat yo seem meetily flusker'd mon : yore yeads awe 
of a maanch, yore welly glopen, yore mithered. Be ye market fresh like ? yen looks 
welly borson we drink. Forrat, forrat, cum along; dunna ye mammock the sack o 
thatons, a schronchin it aw of a rock, if yea wagle o that faahuns, oill wallop 
yea ; oill gie thee ragging ; yea were welly down anent tha geat. Howd the 
jaw; dang it, oill be at thee it y'sen another synable." Now, all this, if translated 
into the purer English language of the Prinicpality, would be to the following effect: 
"Have you seen your father, man? Come to your master; come over the ditch ; 
don't be afraid ; it is much nearer ; and pick up that little bucket. Where hate job 
been so long ? It dows with rain ; there will be sad work at home if yon get wet. Yott 
used to be a tidy lad, but you seem greatly confused now ; our head is all in confusion, 
liko one well nigh burst with drink. Forward, forward, come along ; dont crush Ike 
sack in that way, and make it all of a heap. If you stagger in that way, I will gbe 
you a good beating : there, you are well nigh down over against the gate. Hold JOV 
tongue, or I will be at you, if you say another syllable." 

N.B.— Tho word "farancle" is a contraction of fair and clean ; "glopen" is from 
the German " glypen ," oculos voltomqoe dimittere. " Market fresh," neither drunken 
nor sober, bat neighbour to both. ' ' Do yon now forene this year ?" i. e. early. * ' Hoo 
a'not a down reet sken, bot a koind of a gloid of the oye loike."— She has not a down 
right squint, bot a kind of a glide of the eyo like. 

I now speak of Dorsetshire. A boy keeping some young geese upon a common, 
thus addressed another boy who was throwing stones at them, " Why vor yon threw 
stanes at those guzzle chicks ?" and received the following answer, " What does vatfcer 
hiss I vor ?" which conversation may be thus interpreted, " Why do yon throw atones 
at those goslings ?" " Why does tho father hiss me?" A farmer complained to Us 
Clergyman of the change made in his pew from a square to an oblong shape, as is now 
usual ; and gave this as a reason of his disapproving of tho narrower shape : " Ton sat 
when I goos to Church, I voulds my arms, and thraw$ out my legs, and thinks o' 
nothen." Certainly a better shape could not have been devised than the great sauan 
pow, for those who go to Church only to fold their arms, throw out their lags, and 
think of nothing. 



81 

P.S-— I propose that a number of children shall be drafted from 
a school situated in one of the rural districts of England ; and 
that such children shall be placed under a Welsh master, for 
instruction in the Welsh language, in one of the rural districts of 
Wales. I propose also, that an equal number of children of the 
amine age, and under like circumstances, shall be selected from a 
school situated in one of the rural districts of Wales, and that for a 
like period, and shall be transferred to a school in England, and 
placed under the tuition of an Englishman, for instruction in that 
language. An Inspector shall then be appointed, of sound judgment, 
and of an unbiased mind ; possessing the art of examining, and 
having had experience in the same ; having also a perfect know- 
ledge of both languages. The children having been respectively 
instructed in a foreign tongue, and thus placed on equal terms, the 
examiner will be able to form an opinion as to their respective 
proficiency. 

In justice to the children of our Welsh schools, I am induced to add in this place 
soma questions pat and answers tfiven, iu one of the schools in which I am in the 
habit of attending, which shew the mental effects flowing from th«.sc institutions : — 

Q. What did the High Priest mean by saying, I adjure thoo by the living 
God,*©.? 

A. I pot thee on thy oath before God. 

Q. "Why did he say living God V 

A. In opposition to idols. 

The master in questioning the first class* upon the following words, taken from the 
lat of Acts, viz. " The former treatise have I mode, O Theophilus, of all that Josus 
Began both to do and teach," a boy inquired how thut portion of Scripture would agree 
^lth another in the 21st of John, viz. " And there are also many other things which 
Jans did, the which, if they bhould be written every one, I suppose that even tho 
vorld itself could not contain the books that should be written.*' Had the boy under- 
stood the figure contained in the last quotation, he could easily have reconciled the 
tact, A girl of tho first class was asked, whether the following words, as applying to 
the "Virgin Mary, *' Yea, a sword shall pierce through thine own soul/' were meant 
figuratively or literally ? answered, Figuratively . And whi-n asked what did the words 
imply, said, The sufferings and death of her Son would deeply afflict her soul. 
£i*tMun> child, when asked, whether Pontius Pilate made bimself innocent of the blood 
of Christ by washing his hands, answered, No ; he ought to have had his heart washed 
In the blood of Christ. Another, when speaking of the omnipresence of God, asked, 
Is God every where ? Do you think he would dwell in the heart of a wicked man ? 
The master put tho following question : When it is Baid, Judas went out and repented 
himself, was it trno repentance? A boy said, "That had it been real and true 
repentance, he would not have hanged himself, and thus have broken the Sixth Com- 
mandment.'' Another said, " That Peter's repentance was real, since he went out 
, wept bitterly, and shewed his real sorrow by his future life." 



Thus having shewn, as stated above, the mental effects arising from theso institutions, 
I subjoin an anecdote which marks their moral effects. A boy of the first class had 
broken his thigh, and was consequently confined to his bed for several weeks. The 
master -was in the habit of visiting him after school hours, where he met with two of 
hta sehool-fellows, sitting by his bed side, engaged in reading aloud some interesting 
narratives from a book belonging to tho school library. The master told the boys so 
engaged, how very much pleased he was at seeing them so employed, when the 
mother of the sick child said, that most of the children of the first class visited him 
daily. 



82 
APPENDIX. 



The writer has been in the habit of examining Schools in Eng- 
land, and in doing this, often found it necessary to lower the character 
and style of his questions, to suit the parties examined. This 
remark does not apply to country schools only. He examined the 
first class of a school in a Rural District, in one of the western 
counties, of which county he is himself a native. He had exercised 
his ministry there until he was thirty years of age. He had ever 
been conversant with schools ; he knew well the character of the 
people, their habits, modes of speaking, tones of voice, &c. He 
was not therefore, a barbarian to them. In examining the children 
as stated above, he assumed the manner and language most familiar 
to them ? he encouraged them in the most suasive manner to answer 
his questions : still he could draw nothing from them. At length, 
he requested them to read the 1st and 2nd verses of the 1st chapter 
of the Acts of the Apostles — " The former treatise have I made, 
O Theophilus, of all that Jesus began both to do and teach, until 
the day in which he was taken up," &c. He then asked the 
children the following questions : — Who wrote the Acts of the 
Apostles ? What was the treatise here named ? What matter did 
that treatise contain, or what was it all about ? To whom was that 
treatise addressed, or to whom was it written ? To whom had the 
word he a reference, or who is meant by he? What part of speech 
is he ? Who was taken up to heaven ? He could not obtain an 
answer to any of these plain questions. Now he can 'say with 
perf 3ct truth, that there are many schools in North Wales, in which 
he has obtained answers to these very questions, and many others in 
which he would not have asked them, in consequence of their 
extreme simplicity. 

The following may be given as a specimen of the English Dame 
Schools in England, as they existed a few years since. In a village 
in one of the western counties, a Dame thus addressed one of her 
pupils, called Nanny Norbury : — " Nanny Norbury, yow be a big 
buzzard, yow never knows nothink, and aw the Norburys they bin 
aw big buzzards, they never knowd nothink." Nanny Norbury 
soon confirmed the truth of the Dame's remark as respected herself, 
by stumbling over a long word. The instructress, being as unable to 
utter it, or comprehend it, as was her pupil, cut the matter short, by 
saying, " Skip o'er it wench, skip o'er it ; 'tis a big word that yow 
and Oi (you and I) shall niver want " (want sounded with the open a). 



It Menu extraordinary that the Commissioner should have gires 
bo unfavourable a Report of the Schools in X:>n*. Wiles, since he 
was often heard to declare that the state ><f the Schrols in North 
Wales was above the average of those in Engianl 7V- tcitlrr 
itatemati is perfectly jurf. 

The following schools, viz. Banjor. Carnarvon, and eight coun- 
try schools in their immediate neighbours o -id, were examine, a during 
Passion Week, in the presence <-•:" several persons of respectability. 
Our English neighbours, coul 1 they have l»een present, wr-ulu have 
been highly gratified by the clearness of the children s enunciation, 
their correct and ready answers, the pointed and feeling manner in 
which they read the passages of .Scripture relative to tbe sufferings 
of our Saviour, their reference t j the pr^pheiies and ft texts bear- 
ing upon the subject, their proficiency in sacred music, their state of 
discipline, their cleanliness of person and neatness of dress. Some 
of the persons present declared that they should not have been able 
to have answered many of the questions, nor to have adduced the 
s c rip tu re proofs ; and doubted whether an onl'mary examiner would 
have chosen to have subjected himself to such an examination. 

The following anecdote will afford an additional proof of the 
purity of the English language, as spoken in some of the Rural 
Districts of England, and also a specimen of the scriptural know- 
ledge of some of the lower classes. A poor woman had the charge 
of an orphan child : the child ran away from her. One of her 
neighbours thus consoled her : — " There, it don't zignify, 'tis the 
sem as Scriptir do zay var, Train up a child, and away ul goo.'' 
Translation : — There, it does not signify, it is the same as the Scrip- 
tore says, "Train up a child and away he'll go," (in the way he 
should go). 



84 

CHAPTER VI. 

1838— 1850. 

Mr. Precentor Cotton becomes Dean of Bangor — Presentation of a 
Testimonial — The East Window of Bangor Cathedral — Extract 
from Browne Willis's History of Bangor Catlwdral — Lines com- 
posed by the Dean on the East Window — Anagram on the pro- 
posed union of the Sees of Bangor and Saint Asaph — Establish- 
ing of Church Building Society — Speech at laying foundation stone 
of Carnarvonshire and Anglesey Infirmary — Restoration of 
Llanllechyd Church, and Building of Llanllechyd School — Speech 
at laying foundation stone of Llanfihangel Church — Dean Cotton 
and Archdeacon Allen's School Inspection Tour. 

IN the year 1838, on the death of the Very Rev. John 
Warren, M.A., Mr. Precentor Cotton, was, at the request of 
Her late Royal Highness the Duchess of Kent, elevated to 
the office of Dean, by the appointment of the then Archbishop 
of Canterbury, in whom the patronage was vested at that 
particular time ; and in the following year he removed from 
Tan-y-Bryn,* where he had resided during his vicarship, to 
the Deanery house upon which he expended £800 in 
improvements. 

Soon after Mr. Cotton's preferment, the citizens of 
Bangor originated a subscription in acknowledgment of the 
many good services which he had rendered to the city and 
neighbourhood, and as a testimony of their approval of his 
elevation to the Deanery. The subscriptions amounted to 
upwards of .£300, which sum the Dean, with his characteris- 
tic disinterestedness and praiseworthy regard for the fabrics 

* When the Lodge, at the approach to Tan-y-Bryn was being built, and the 
trees and shrubs surrounding the house were planted, some evil disposed persons made 
continual incursions into the grounds, damaging, and carrying away the trees, Mr. 
Cotton caused the following inscription to be carved in Latin and Welsh on the bay- 
window sill of the Lodge— 

" Latrat canis, caveat latro :"— " LU bo ci, lleidr affy" 

Under the window is also a figure of the three-headed monster ' Cerberus,' the fabled 
keeper of Pluto's palace. 



85 



of the Church, devoted to ornamenting the Cathedral with a 
painted East Window.* 

This Testimonial Window consists of the following 
subjects. At the top, in the centre, is placed a circular light 
with a ' glory/ within which is inscribed the I.H.S. Beneath 
are two rows of small lights, in number eighteen, 
containing shields, twelve of which bear the emblems 
of the twelve tribes of Israel. All these shields are sur- 
mounted by flowing drapery in the form of military tents. 
Under these 18 rows of small lights, are two rows of 
large lights, five in each row, they occupy the main part of 
the window, and are filled up with niches and canopies. 
When the window was first put up, the four outer 
niches were not supplied with figures, owing to the 
inadequacy of the Testimonial Fund ; some time afterwards 
the late Bishop Bethell supplied this defect at his own 
expense. 

The Figures are : — 



AARON 

holds the rod 
in his right 
hand, and a 
center in his 
left. 



8. MATTHEW 



DAVID 



8. MARK. 



bears a scroll in learn upon his bears a book, as 
one hand, con-liarp awl has a if about to con- 
taining the Oos- crown upon his mit to writing 
pel, and a halberd head. something which 



in the other. 



is dictated by an- 
other. 



M08E8 

holds the 
two tables o 
stone in h 

right arm, 
and the rod 

in his left. 



i 



8. PETER 

holds the key 8 
in his right 



8. LUKE 



I 



SOLOMON 



8. JOHN 



8. PAUL 



as if in tJie act of holds a sceptre in bears a cup in his is in the act o 

right hand, and uplifting h" 

in his left the\ right hand, 
Hook of Re vela- and leans with 



writing either the 
Gospel or tlve Acts 
of the Apostles. 



hisrighthand.and 
the ground plan 
of the temple in 
his left, and has 
also a crown up- 
on his head. 



I 



Hon closed 
clasped. 



and 



his left] on a 
sword. 



Inscription, — "The cost of this painted window was at his own 
request defrayed from a fund contributed for the purpose of present- 
ing to the Very Reverend James Henry Cotton, B.O.L., Dean of this 
Cathedral, a public testimony of respect for his character and 
meritorious services as Vicar for a period of 28 years." 

* It will, perhaps, interest our readers to read the description of the old East 
Window of Bangor Cathedral, as giren by Browne Willis, in his History, p. 16. 
" At the East End of the Choir is an handsome Window, which reaches from the top 



86 

The Dean composed on the East Window the following 
lines, which he characterized as "recalled to the mind in 
the vision of the night, descriptive of the Church militant 
here on earth." 

" Now a thing was secretly brought to me in thougJtis from 

the vision of the night, when deep sleep falleth on men." 

Jobiv. 12, 13. 

The sacred day had pass'd, its duties done, 

I laid me down to sleep ; for now the sun 

His fiery course had run with measur'd tread, 

And o'er the moon his mantle's skirt had spread ; 

When, lo ! in the night visions, as I slept, 

The past day's image o'er my spirits crept. 

The organ peal'd, "the window richly dight," 

Again cast forth "its dim religious light." 

I saw the standards of the sacred band 

Uplifted, as they march'd to Canaan's land ; 

I heard ("'twas Jacob's voice") their names declared 

By whom that distant region should be shared, 

" Reuben, my first-born, thou shalt not excel ; 

" Unstable thou as water." Thou didst not well, 

Simeon, who "slew a man in fiercest rage," 

(Cruel thine "instruments") ; thine ''heritage 

" I will divide in Jacob." But thou, my son, 

" Who over foes and friends hast vict'ry won," 

Thou, " Judah, shall thy brethren praise ;" ''thine hand 

" Shall hold the sceptre o'er the land 

" Till Shiloh come " — to him ('tis heaven's decree) 

" Shall then the gath'ring of the people be." * 

of the wainscot to the ceiling of the roof, about 27 foot high, and about 18 foot and a 
half broad ; in the small arches at the top of the Window, are some painted figures 
representing Saints and Bishops in] their robes and mitres ; one of these is (as may 
be distinguished by the name) 8t. Ambrose, another St. Augustin, Knottier figure of 
St. George ; Here is also a crucifix with these letters on it I. N. B I. The test cannot 
well be made out the glass is broken and patched up. At the bottom seems to be 
these words, Orate pro Bono. Which was to pray for the good estate of the Benefactor 
or Benefactors who glass'd it on rebuilding the Church, Temp., Hen. VII and Henry 
VIII, by Bishop Dean and Bishop Skefington; the first of which is reported to hate 
built the Choir, and the other all the rest of the Church, except that most part of the 
great Cross-Ike was standing before. There is a Tradition, that a younger brother of 
the family of Llwydiart, Co. Anglesey was at the charge of this Window. The 
of the present family there is Lloyd, but whether so anciently I cannot tell." 



87 



" Judah's a lion's v/help ; he stooped down 
" And couched like a lion, " tore the crown, 



it 



And bow'd the neck of those his power withstood. 
Thy teeth are white with milk, thine eyes with blood 
Of grapes are red ;" Judah the pow*r is thine 
" To bind thy foal unto the choicest vine." 
" A haven of ships thou Zebulon shalt be," 
" By Zidon bord'ring near the utmost sea." 
" O ! Issachar, between two burdens prest 
" Thou as a strong ass couching, seeing rest 
" Is good, shalt seek a pleasant land, and there 
" Shalt bow thy shoulder low, and tribute bear." 
" His people Dan shall judge,'* and be their stay ; 
" An adder Dan — a serpent by the way." 
"A troop shall overcome thee, Gad ;" but past 
That terror, thou " shalt overcome at last." t 
" Asher shall bread, shall royal dainties yield. 
"Napthali a hind let loose," shalt range the field. 
" Ephraim, a heifer taught," shall lift the horn ; 
" Ephraim shall ride, he loves to tread the corn." 
Manasseh, too, from Joseph's fruitful roots 
Branching, shall spread abroad his vigorous shoots. 
" The angel who redeem'd me from all ill, 
" Shall bless the lads " — shall be their Saviour still. 
" Thou, Benjamin, shalt raven in the day 
" Like as a wolf — at night devour the prey." 
As Jacob spake : the vision on my bed 
Shew'd me on " Moab's plains " the people spread. 
From * ' Pisgah's heights " I heard the Prophets's voice, 
The Prophet Balaam, he, proclaiming thrice 
That people's greatness ere by sin they fell : 
"How goodly are thy tents, O Israel." 
" Higher than Agag," greater far than he, 
O happy Israel, shall thy ruler be. 
" In many waters shall thy seed be cast :" 
The " Almighty hand of God shall hold thee fast." 
" From out of Israel shall a sceptre rise," 
" Shall Seir and Moab smite, (his enemies) ;" 
"And Sheth, thy children " shall be smitten through, 
"And over Edom shall he cast his shoe." 
" Him shall I see " (resumes th' enraptured Seer) ; 
" Him shall I see ; but yet not now, — not near." 



88 



My mind still dwelling in the sacred fane, 

My thoughts uplifted to the storied pane ; 

I saw a " goodly company " — a band 

Of holy men of old before me stand. 

All heaVn before mine eyes the vision brings — 

Apostles, martyrs, prophets, priests, and kings. 

Moses, the leader of the Jewish race, 

And law -giver, maintains the foremost place : 

Having " the sacred tables and the rod," 

As one commission'd by the hand of God. 

Moses, whose books the earliest times record ; 

Moses, "raised up a prophet like the Lord." 

His brother Aaron, the High Priest of God, 

Bearing the smoking censer, ** and the rod 

"That budded," and in holy garb array' d, 

As when within the Holiest he pray'd. 

David, the Psalmist, but by God's command 

Call'd to be Israel's King ? yet " whose right hand 

" Did ne'er forget her cunning." Thus he bears 

A stringed harp ; and thus a crown he wears.' 

Beneath him stands his son, who built on high 

A gorgeous Temple to God's majesty ; 

'Tis Solomon, in regal robes array'd, 

The temple, crown, and sceptre, all pourtray*d 

But where his writings ? for I see them not : 

His Proverbs, Song of Songs — are these forgot ? 

No : it were needless these should form a part ; 

Inscrib'd already these on every heart. 

But who and what are they who stand around, 

Of holier mien, with rays of glory crown'd ? 

Servants of God, commission'd from above, 

To bring to men the messuages of love. 

The four Evangelists, whose books record 

The life and doctrines of our blessed Lord. 

"The overseers of Christ's own flock, who fed 

" The Church, which by his blood he purchased." 

" Matthew's right hand a written scroll contains, 

A halberd 'tis the other hand sustains. 

The one reveals his hope of life to come ; 

The other shews the path through martyrdom. 

Mark holds a book, as just prepared to write 

The words he waits for other to indite. 



89 

•'Whose praise is in the Gospel." Luke stands next, 

And with his pen inscribes the sacred text. 

John in his hand the cup of suff ring holds, 

(Emblem of suffering) : in his arm he folds 

A pond'rous book fast clos'd, whose ev'ry page 

Displays the Church of Christ from age to age : 

What has been, is, and is to come, reveals, 

And thus the sacred volume signs and seals. 

But who are these I see on either hand ? 

Apostles too ? who seem apart to stand. 

Peter is one, who bears the book and key ; 

These emblems with his office well agree. 

The other, Paul ; his right hand raised on high, 

As when he spoke. His ready will to die, 

The manner of his death, the sword implies . 

In emblem here th' Apostle lives and dies. 

For both these saints, let all with one accord, 

Both Jew and Gentile, bless their common Lord. 

May we repent, believe, and be forgiven, 

And meet him with these holy saints in heaven." 

Here darkly, through a glass I see ; and know 

My lord, in part alone, while here below. 

O Lord, my God, then shall I blessed be 

When face to face I may Thy glory see. 

Jlere in Thine house I'll dwell — But as I spoke, 

The vision vanish'd, — and I straight awoke. 

Apart from the Deanery, Dean Cotton was also rector 
of Llanfihangel-Ysceifiog, cum Llanffinan, in the County of 
Anglesey, Gyffin* and Llanllechyd, in the County of Car- 
narvon, — three livings : distant at least twelve miles from each 
other, and yielding a gross annual income of upwards of 
^1,300. Owing to the deplorable system of pluralities so 
prevalent in his time, the Dean was necessarily non-resident, 
and his curates had sole charge, but he was by no means 
a stranger to the souls entrusted to his care in either of these 
parishes. He was very fortunate in the choice of his curates, 

* The Tithes of Llanfihangel-Ysceifiog, Llanffinan, and Gyffln formed the income of 
the Deanery, but after Dean Cotton's death the Ecclesiastical Commissioners appro- 
priated these tithes and settled the income of the Deanery at £700 per annum. 



90 

having men of marked ability, good Welshmen, and entirely 
devoted to the service of the Church ; some are now occupying 
prominent positions in the Diocese ot Bangor — but one 
has just passed into his rest — the Rev. Morris Williams, M.A., 
(Nicander), Rector of Llanrhyddlad, sometime curate of 
Llanllechyd — an accomplished scholar, a preacher, critic and 
poet, and one who has shed a lustre upon the poetry and 
literature of his native Wales. 

The subjoined Anagram was written by Dean Cotton 
at the passing of the Act, in 1838, for uniting pro- 
spectively the sees of St. Asaph and Bangor, which Act 
was never, happily, carried into effect, It was felt that 
the enactment would be detrimental to the efficiency of 
the North Wales Episcopate, and the late Earl of Powis, the 
present Lord Penrhyn, Sir Robert Inglis, and other influential 
churchmen sought the repeal of the measure. The struggle 
began in 1843, and after two unsuccessful attempts in the 
House of Lords to rescind the Act, a third effort was made 
which was crowned with success, the Government gave way, 
and the integrity of the North Wales Dioceses was preserved. 

READ-BANGOR AND SAINT ASAPH. 



When I considered the union of Bangor and St. Asaph, I said to 
myself, "this union contains everything which implies craft, violence, 
wrong, and robbery, everything which is expressive of sorrow 
and disgrace. There was nab, sap, trap, trip, train, gin ; then came 
rap, strap, bang, hang, toss, rasp. Then, there is grasp and rob, 
which imply seizure ; and hasp and bag, which imply retention and 
possession. 

But this is not all, for even these losses are attended with aggravated 
circumstances of pain. A gnat which bites, a rat which gnaws, and 
an asp which stings and poisons. Worse still, when I looked closer 
I could see the very principle of the reunion and its effects ; for I find 
that it contains not only a stain and a taint, and a base, but sin ; yen, 
and the author of sin — Satan. I hear too the Ah I the sigh, and the 



91 

fo6 of the snfferen, who hang down their feeble hands, and with their 
tad countenances look like a wearied nay or an over burdened a** 

I tee but one comforting word, and that is pastor, but even that 
haa a sting ; I meet with saint also ; but that only serves to remind 
me of that saint who was robbed to pay PauL 

In the year 1838, the Diocesan Church Building Society 
was established, chiefly through the exertions of Dean 
Cotton. The churches in the diocese of Bangor were then 
in a very dilapidated state, and greatly deficient in suitable 
accommodation. To remedy this great defect this society was 
founded and called the "• Society for Building, Enlarging, and 
Improving Churches, and Parochial Chapels within theDiocese 
of Bangor,*' This society, which has now existed 36 years, 
continues to flourish; and has done great and good work. 
Since its establishment down to the present time, it has 
aided the rebuilding and restoring of 222 churches in the 
diocese of Bangor. 

The Dean delivered the following speech at the laying of 
the foundation stone of the Carnarvon shire and Anglesey 
Infirmary, on the 14th day of May, IS44. This institution, 
in the establishing of which the Dean took an active and 
prominent apart, is supported by voluntary contributions 
and has proved to be an inestimable benefit to the sick poor 
of the counties of Carnarvon and Anglesey. A Dispensary* 
had been in operation since the year 1809, at Tan-y-coed, 
Bangor, which ceased to exist at the completion of the above 
building. On the above occasion, the Dean said : — 

I am happy to meet you all on this occasion. We are met to do 
a work which I doubt not will bring satisfaction to our own minds, 
and fill the hearts of many with gratitude and gladness. There is a 
great difference of opinion upon many subjects. Some cannot see the 

* Over the Dispensary door were the following words, " Carnarvonshire and 
Anglesey Loyal Dispensary." A friend happening to meet the Dean near the 
Dispensary remark?! chat the inscription was very significant, and that it appeared 
that no radical euros were effected there ; " no," replied the Dean, " bat we give 
&ov*reiffn remedies." 



92 

the propriety or expediency of some institutions, but all will agree in 
the expediency and propriety of forming this institution — the first 
stone of which we are now about to lay. We all feel the duty of 
relieving the sick, healing the wounded, and of bringing health to 
the dwellings of the poor. 

" Hero then, shall charity repair, 
And break tho bonds of griof : 
Bootho tho harrowed oonch of care, 
Man to man must bring relief." 

And this we will do, we will not see our neighbour sick or wounded, 
and turn away on the other side, but we will take care of him ; we 
will pour oil and wine ; we will bring him to this very inn | and 
say to the master of the house, take care of him, and I will repay 
thee. We are all partakers of one common nature. We may all be 
visited with sickness ; we may all meet with accidents. The relief, 
then, we should desire in such cases, we should extend to those who 
are afflicted and have no helper. We have all read the history of the 
good Samaritan. We have read the history of one greater and better, 
of Him who went about doing good and healing all manner of sickness 
and disease amongst the people, and has commanded us as far as we 
are able ' to go and do likewise. ' If we cannot obey this command 
according to our present mode of living, then let us learn to deny 
ourselves — let us dress with less decoration — let us dine less delicately. 

No man is liberal in the degree which he ought to be until he makes 
his luxuries yield to another's wants, his wants to another*! 
comforts, his comforts to another's extreme necessities. 

Let all, then, contribute to this excellent work — let no man think 
that he has a right to all he has ; when he has supported himself and 
family, and provided suitably for those whom he shall leave behind 
him, the rest belongs to God and to the poor. 

Let all give, then, as God has prospered them. He that has little, 
let him gladly give of that little, for so will he treasure to himself s 
good reward against the day of necessity. He that has much, 1st 
him give plenteously. We are told to charge them who are rich is 
this world to be willing to give and glad to distribute, for so will tlwy 
gather to themselves a good reward in the time to come. 

From the year 1846 to 1850, Dean Cotton was much 
involved with building contracts. In the year 1846, he under- 
took the rebuilding of Llanllechyd* church at a cost of 

* In Engravings of the Dean taken about this time— which are * mn g up ah&oit it 
every Clergy house throughout tho Diocese— it will be seen that he has by fatal* 
drawing of the ground plan and elevation of Llanllechyd church. 



93 

; two years afterwards he built a school-room in 
ge of Rachub in the same parish. In the year 1850, 
I was built at Gaerwen, in the parish of Llanfihangel- 
y; and a new church in the same parish was 
ed about the same time at a cost of nearly ^2000. 
oin a speech delivered by the Dean on the occasion 
tg the foundation stone of Llanfihangel-Ysceifiog 
in the year 1848. 

u*ly beloved brethren, — I heartily congratulate you upon the 
: this day's meeting. We are met together to do a work — a 
the greatest importance and to honour ourselves in the 
wssible degree. We are assembled to lay the first stone of 
t of God, to build a house to that great Being who dwelleth 
tmples built with hands, but as the prophet saith, " whose 
\ heaven, and whose footstool is the earth. " The greatest, 
t, the holiest men of all ages, Pagans, Jewish and Christian, 
aught to honour the Gods whom they worshipped by erecting 
for their worship. Some have seen, and all have heard of 
adid temple of the land of Egypt. We have read of the 

of the temple of the great goddess Diana, whom all the 
►rshipped ; we all remember what is said in the scriptures of 
iy stones of the temple of the living God at Jerusalem, termed 
bus, " the wonder of magnificence." We cannot forget the 
; of humility which ruled the minds of those men who under 
ish dispensation sought to honour God. When Moses 
. tabernacle to God in the wilderness, he invited the people 
bute to the work ; when all they that were "cunning work- 
d* were wise hearted — were zealous to shew their respect to 
the place where his honour dwelleth — insomuch that the 
rought too much and were restrained from offering. David 
s had collected material for the building of the temple, 
d " I will not suffer mine eyes to sleep, nor mine eyelids to 
neither the temples of my head to take any rest, until I find 
j for the Lord, or habitation for the mighty God of Jacob, 
lland what are my people, that we are able to offer in this sort, 
have cometh from thee, and of thine own have we offered unto 

know, my God, that thou knowest the heart, and hast 

in the uprightness — in the uprightness of my heart have I 

f offered all these things : and now havel seen with these people, 

H 



94 

whoare herepresent, toofferwillinglyuntothee." When his son Solomon 
erected the temple, he used the same language, " Behold (says he) the 
heaven of heavens cannot contain thee, how much less this place 
which I have builded." It is said of King Hezekiah that " all which 
he did for the service of God, he did it with all is heart." Ezra and 
Nehemiah and the other worthies under the Old Testament are spoken 
of in the same termi. We have, under the christian ages, noble 
memorials, raised to the honour of our God and Saviour : witness the 
beautiful churches of this nation, the lofty spires which reach to the 
clouds, and point as it were to brighter worlds, and lead the mind to 
that temple not made with hands, eternal in the heavens. Witness 
the lofty shaft, the high embowered roof, the windows richly dight, 
her long drawn aisle, and fretted vault in which the pealing anthem 
swells the note of praise. Even in this our land, our ancestors 
endeavoured to honour God with their substance, and raised temples 
to his honour somewhat proportionate to their means. They did 
what they could ; the house of God was then the best in every parish. 
It has of late years been the worst. When I went round this country 
by the direction of the Bishop in the year 1812, the churches were in 
the most deplorable state. Much was then done ; but much more 
has been done in later days ; and I am happy to say that since the 
year 1838, no less than 75 churches have been either re-built or 
restored in this diocese, and that no less than nine are now re-building, 
restoring, or refitting. A new additional church is actually building, 
at which I was present, and the first stone of which was laid by the 
Hon. Master Wynne. We shall proceed to lay the first stone of this 
sacred edifice ; Mr. Trygarn Griffith, attended by the clergy, is kindly 
disposed to do this good work. This stone, as you will observe has 
been prepared with a little chamber in which we are about to place 
these two books which I hold in my hand. They are the Bible and 
the Common Prayer Book. These will be side by side,! they will 
remain with one accord in one house, and whom God hath joined 
together let no man put asunder, for indeed they are as one ; as 
brethren they speak one language ; they contradict not one another, 
but are of one heart and of one soul ; the one cannot say to the other 
" I have no need of thee ; no, this (the Bible) tells us to pray ; this 
the (Prayer Book) expounds it, and places before us prayers couched 
in the very language of the Bible, and breathing all its sentiments. 
This, (the Bible) bids us to sing praise to God— this, the Prayer Book 
spreads before us the sweet songs of Sion. puts a new song in oar 
mouths, and teach us to praise him as we ought. Let these teach >• 



95 

m — let them teach as to be of one mind in our house as they 
m there is but one Lord, one faith, one baptism, one God and 
r of us all, so let us be of one heart and one soul, shining 
er for the truth of the Gospel ; building up ourselves in our 
holy faith ; praying in the Holy Ghost ; let us keep ourselves 

> love of God, looking for the mercy of our Lord Jesus Christ, 
hall we become a glorious church, built upon the foundation of 
postles, Jesus Christ Himself being the chief corner stone. 
Sfod bless this work and labour of love ; may its foundations 
till day of doom ; may peace be within its walls. For my 
en and companions sake I will wish thee prosperity ; yea, 
te of the house of the Lord our God, I will seek to do it good." 

e following account given by the Dean will show the 

hospitality he received in his tour of School Inspection. 

lie year 1845, Archdeacon Allen, afterwards Vicar of Preea, 
-opshire, was sent down to the Diocese of Bangor as Inspector 
tools. He requested me to accompany him in his visitation, 
j been in the habit of inspecting the Schools for many successive 
Having laid out a plan of proceeding and prepared the clergy 
: coming, we set out and completed a journey of about 500 miles, 
ring the space of six weeks. The Laity and Clergy received us 
ously, and supplied us for the most part with bed and board. 
4 nothing to complain of but sometimes the excess of hospitality, 
[though all were willing to admit the justness of the following 
lage in part, yet few were willing to allow the justness of the 
"Welcome the coming, speed the going guest." The 
ing circumstances will afford an instance. 
mr progress we left the kind hostess of Plas Tanybwlch, 
liately after a good breakfast, with a plentiful provision by the 

> sustain us until dinner time, we visited a School about six 
distance, after which wc were entreated by the old Rector to 
ith him. We at first declined, saying we were invited to dine 
)use six miles beyond Barmouth, and were engaged to examine 
jhools in our way. The old Rector still urged his request while 
th equal earnestness urged him to permit us to depart that we 

keep our engagements. Moved however by his importunity, 
nowing that he had made great preparations for the Dean and 
eacon ! ! and that he would suffer in consequence great dis- 
itment ; to our own infinite inconvenience and disarrangement 
• plans we consented with the best grace that we could. Our 



96 

plates were then laden and we were so pressed to eat more, that had 
it not been for a friendly dog under the table, who was more 
accommodating than the guests, the two officials might have suffered 
suffocation in this severe service. The consequence of this was, that 
full justice was not done to the Schools before named, and in seeking 
to oblige an old gentleman, we greatly dis-obliged an old lady. "We 
were invited to dine at six o'clock, and great preparations had been 
made as before, to make the table as complete as possible. Think 
then of her dismay, who saw meat roasting to rags, and all her fond 
hopes disappointed ! Think of her state and that of her cook, with 
all her blasted hopes for three lung hours, for we did not arrive till 
nine o'clock at night ! The old lady had then drunk her tea, and 
was preparing to go to bed. We trembled as we crossed the threshold 
felt ourselves still less at ease as we approached to make oar 
apologies. The old lady bore thunder in her brow, and was not 
propitious in her manner. What could we say? We could only 
intreat that we might be pardoned, have a cup of tea and go to bed. 
We had dined, (the greater our sin,) we were tired, etc., etc. This, 
the old lady would by no means permit, we were destined to suffer a 
second direful dinner persecution, and no famished and faithful dog 
to come to our relief. We eat without appetite, and talked while 
our minds and bodies were half asleep, we bit our tongues, trod upon 
our own feet, secretly plucked our ears and hair, and at about eleven 
o'clock were delivered from this culinary calamity. The. next 
morning we rose early, walked about the garden, admired the views 
from the house, the arrangements within and without the house, the 
old lady's brow relaxed, and we departed in peace. 



97 

CHAPTER VII. 

1851 TO 1858. 

ean Cotton's Speech at Stephenson's Banquet — His love and 
knowledge of Music — Address to Welsh Singers of Bangor 
Cathedral — Speech at laying Foundation Stone of Glanogwen 
Church — Correspondence on the state of the Church at Bangor — 
Presentation of an Address and Family Bible. 

7HE Dean delivered the subjoined speech on the 27th 
.ugust, 1851, at a Banquet given to Robert Stephenson, 
Isquire, on the occasion of opening the Britannia Tubular 
ridge over the Menai Straits. In replying to the toast, " the 
ishops and Clergy," proposed by the President — the present 
ord Penrhyn — the Dean said : — 

I, for my part, have all my life been seeking ubiquity, and nothing 
is so much contributed to my ubiquitous advancement as the great 
an band which unites together these two counties. I am now 
tabled to officiate in three churches on the same day in two counties, 
id two languages. If then my brethren of the Clergy are grateful, 
un more so, they will at least understand me when I say, 

" 08 mawl py'n perthyn iddynt hwy, 
Mae mawl i mi mil miloedd mwy." 

clerical friend not less an admirer of the work or the author, but 
assessing less nerve, seeing me about to pass through the tube on 
e first experimental trip, said, " And will you venture !" My 
iswer was, " My motive is both disinterested and selfish, for if I 
ould not pass, I shall leave the Deanery open to you, and I shall 
t into the see by descent." (Cheers and laughter.) How shall we 
1 our benefactor honour ? Shall we celebrate his merits in a Poem. 
Tio shall undertake to do him justice in poetry when none can do 
m justice in prose ? 

We have not got 

The mind of Scott; 

We have no Byron 

Who shall environ— in verge. 

This bridge of Iron ! 

Wo have no man upon 

This very earth, 

lluth worth of sense 

To make a Wordsworth. 



98 

What shall we do then ? Now we know that the direct passage to 
the heart of an Englishman is through the tube of the mouth ; the 
viaduct of the tongue ; the railroad of the teeth ; the tunnel of the 
throat ; the station of the stomach ; this is the refreshment room of 
the first class, where the parties need no engineer but the appetite, 
and no gas to light the liver but the gastric juice. We have adopted 
to-day the characteristic mode of paying honour ; we have ate and 
drank in honour of Mr. Stephenson. To-morrow, like Englishmen, 
we shall blend benevolence with amusement, and dance down our 
dinners. The whole will dance that the lame may walk ; the sound 
and strong will sup, that they may support the sick and weak. But 
they who cannot dance will not forgot that they may be represented 
by their tickets. This is no crime, for as Shakespeare says, " We 
must speak by the card, or equivocation will undo us." Not that 
Shakespeare possibly intended such a sense to be affixed to his words, 
but I have presumed so to accommodate them. In no greater a degree 
indeed than Virgil did anticipate the drinking tea, morning and 
evening, when he wrote this lino, " Te vencente die, te decedente 
lanebam. " But how shall we raise a memorial to a man who has 
built a greater memorial to his own memory than other men can 
raise ? Snail we refer ourselves to St. Paul's Cathedral ? And there 
we shall find a plain tablet in the midst of that splendid edifice 
inscribed to the memory of its great author and containing a few 
words in the Latin tongue. Shall we adopt the idea, and fix up a plain 
tablet near the Bridge, and inscribe upon it these compendious but 
untranslatable words : — ' Si monumentum requiras, circumspioe.' 
(Cheers. ) 

The subjoined earnest and affectionate address was 
published by the Dean and addressed to the singers of the 
Welsh congregation within Bangor Cathedral, reflecting 
upon their conduct in the organ loft, which, as it was only 
accessible through the English portion of the Cathedral had 
become the resort of many drones, not connected with the 
singing or the Cathedral, dropping in at every hour of Divine 
Service, much to the annoyance and disturbance of the 
worshippers. The Dean used every means to remedy this 
evil, and was present almost invariably at every Welsh 
Sunday morning service, among the singers in the organ 



09 

loft, and although he was blind and could not see the offenders, 
his presence secured proper behaviour. 

My Dear Friends and Fellow Churchmen, 

I have lived in this place and acted as Vicar and Dean of the 
Cathedral above the period of for by three year3, during which time 
we have " walked together in the house of God as friends." 

The connection which has existed between us, the long continuance 
of that connection, my age, my affectionate regard for you as once 
my spiritual children, now my Christian brethren and fellow com- 
municants ; will justify me in the liberty I take in addressing you 
upon a subject very near my heart, and deeply affecting your souls. 
I use these words — " The liberty I take," both as they refer to your- 
selves, and to your legitimate Pastors. It is not I, but they that are 
authorised to address you, and I presume to do it upon the hope that 
though I have not the permission of either, I shall receive the pardon 
of both. 

You are specially appointed to assist in the celebration of Divine 
8ervice, you have the high honour and great privilege of leading those 
devotional exercises, the performance of which properly belongs to 
the whole united congregation. The one part of your duty you 
falfil with great skill and propriety, and also with much efficiency ; 
I mean that part in which you sing the praises of God. The other 
part however you entirely neglect ; I mean the reading the responses 
after the Minister, as enjoined by the Rubric of the Church. Thus, 
you observe that part of your duty which is not accurately defined, 
*ud neglect that part which is positively and explicitly enjoined, — In 
short, you praise God with your mouth, but neither in heart nor with 
mouth pray to Him. You " come together, not for the better, but 
,for the worse." You hear the confession read, but heed it not, for 
you do not confess. You will not make this acknowledgment in the 
words of the Church, — " We have erred and strayed from thy ways 
"** lost sheep. We have left undone those things which we ought 
to have done, and done those things which we ought not to have 
done; an d there is no health in us. But thou, Lord, have 
mercy upon us, miserable offenders. Spare thou them, God, 
which confess their faults. Restore thou them that are penitent." 
*°u are not entitled to receive absolution until you have made confes- 
•Oft. You have not expressed your penitence and do you expect 
pwdon? Penitence consists of these four parts, — Conviction, Contrition, 



100 

Confession, Conversion. But you have not given any proof that you 
have truly penitent hearts, that " you repent you truly of your former 
sins, that you stedfastly purpose to lead a new life, and that you have 
a thankful remembrance of Christ's death." 

Christ died for penitent sinners ; not to save men in their sins, but 
from their sins. You cannot apply to yourselves the following words 
of the Form of Absolution, — " He pardoneth and absolveth all them 
that truly repent." Neither have you yet shewn any inclination to 
apply them, for you will not even comply with the earnest entreaty 
of the Minister embodied in the following words : — " Wherefore I 
pray and beseech you , as many as are here present, to accompany me 
me with a pure heart and humble voice unto the throne of the 
heavenly grace, saying after me." Why will you not obey this 
injunction (so earnest, so affectionate,) both in heart and voice, and 
11 say after him ?" When the " Creed ' ' is read, you will not acknow- 
ledge that "you believe in God the Father, who made you, — in God the 
Son, who redeemed you, — and in God the Holy Ghost, who sanctifieth 
you. When the " Litany " is read, you will not pray to that same 
" Holy, Blessed and Glorious Trinity," Three Persons and One God ;" 
nor will you ask mercy, and say, " Have mercy upon us, miserable 
sinners ?" When the Minister thus addresses his and your common 
Redeemer, — "By the mystery of thy holy Incarnation ; by thy holy 
Nativity and Circumcision ; by thy Baptism, Fasting, and Tempta- 
tion ; by thine Agony and bloody Sweat ; by thy Cross and Passion ; 
by thy precious Death and Burial ; by thy glorious Resurrection and 
Ascension ; and by the coming of the Holy Ghost," will you not 
endeavour to make this short response? " Good Lord deliver us.'' 
When again the Minister lifts up his voice, and cries, " O Lamb of 
God that takest away the sins of the world." Will you not in 
answer to those deeply devotional words, both of the Scripture and 
of your own Church, utter these four simple monosyllables, " Grant 
us thy peace." In the Communion Service you are instructed in the 

Collect thus to pray : — " Almighty God, Cleanse the thoughts of 

our hearts by the inspiration of thy Holy Spirit." After the delivery 
of each of the commandments with the exception of the last, you are 
taught to repeat the following words : — " Lord, have mercy upon us, 
and incline our hearts to keep this law." After the delivery of the 
last, you are told to repeat the following words : — " Lord, have 
mercy upon us, and write all these thy laws in our hearts, we beseech 
thee." Have you observed the beautiful gradation implied in these 
words, The cleansing of the heart, by the inspiration of God's 



.._«.- 



« • - • 



i _ - » — 



. - i -« 



1*1 

Holy Spirit : the mcPir-g rrzz l-tLr:* - 7 *l* ^^-7 " "- »i z: if 
his laws : the writing cc :— r-rr-^-Lj ■:. ■•.- 1-.:— .: :: r-. _. t? ; : 
tame attribute of mer^y*. Ail :..- : - -. --.:._ ;•_:-.: 
grant you that insp.ir:*:: 1 : : _---.;■: "----* -" ■--* " 
that impression. If y.- hiv; l : ' 1- - : :.:.- -. j: -._-.; 
your duty to Go-i an I : ■. y -7 -■- - -.. 

But I understand :":_v: •» :_.- ■ _ ..■■_: :-.-". : 
language. Be it so. A:^ y - :. : : ■. -_ ;- - * -■--_ 
your "own tongue, whir-..:, "y . . — :-. ■ ~_ I -■_ 1 
you are fully capab:-.- : : : .- ■.-....." -; . .: ■ 

have proved it, in ii^vilj :.. .1;. ..:.-■:.. .— ■. 

tongue "wherein [y •■."/ -a-.:. "-. :. " rr.- ' ..: : ;: .. 
you possess the powers :_ ■:..!-.:__ .■_":■_■ „■ -: ■:._■.-_:;-. i:_ '. y:~ 
oan at least repeat th- L ■:'.■?;.-.■. : -. . . '.. .:. . :.. V .?-:.".■. s 7 

Short Answers, the- 1 Jl-.-r:- :'.»::. . .-_ . ... -..;-. ■■ A:..^: . " :.: :"-«:- 

Giving of Thanks Th^-.- '_' -'-■ r .:y y :-."'■= ":.::'_^r:: 

neglected.'* "Now, shall 1 : r..!--. y ■_ :. :"._.« : — I -?;.:»■. y -.: l:.'* 
Nay as you rea«l the** w-.-rd 5 -. I :-.-.'. -!.::-. :.. ^: y .:r :....:> : ■:. Ic:::r. 
you. I am sure they «i". -j ::*.':»•■ v.--; ^r. :::.:*y ::. \:r.-T--ir. : ■ :;.eso 
things. I beg you t'i rva-1 ::.? K. :'•.■.-:. ^ ■: :"..-.■ !'• • k ■■: i"--.mmon 
Prayer, and to obey tu.-ir « 1 : r-_- _-ii- .■::«. Th-.-y -v-i^k thus : — ** T<- ; .« 
«atd 6y //i<? M*/io/r rrtivjr'-j'i*'-jff "'■ r •■"•■ .V ■■"-"■ *. ■•" ■-:■;-• "■"■;.». or. 7m •: 
people also kneeling awl /•'//■■v'-V/ ''.•■"■''• ; "'.". 7"» r - 7.'- *:. ;." t ™ .*;■:•• r 
Aer« and at the end of aH of I" r > # /■» w- r*. Am ... Th • .•» */.ff" '#•■ ai ; • / i#r 
ntn^f, <C*c., <£■<:." Is it not sad, i? it n- >t strange, that many of those, 
who profess themselves Members of thu church, never obey any of 
these injunctions, — never km- /.—never /»y,. at. — never .»«/;/ or ■*'«;/, — 
never answer, Arum t It must be remarked that there is no Rubric 
in our Liturgy telling the people to *if. I fear that you do not 
understand what the nature of Prayer really is,—" Th* VftUnj up 
the heart to heaven, — The pouring uiif tin- tout In fore 6V/." I fear that 
you do not feel that deep devotion of spirit, that entire abasement of 
soul which is felt by the siueere worshipper ; that prostration of 
mind which marks the truly penitent offender. I fear there are some 
amongst you who will not know what 1 mean, for there are sonic who 
come after the Service has begun ; somo depart before the Service 
is concluded ; some whisper and talk during the L'raycrfl. " What, 
have you not houses [to talk in,] or despise you the Church of ( Sod 1 — 
The House of God is called a House of Prayer." It is not a plaeo 
of preaching only, nor a place for musical display at all. Some, I 
fear, consider it as a Music Hall, in which to amuse othcrn, 



10S 

and display themselves ; they esteem the House of God as a 
Concert Room, with this difference in favour of the last above 
the fir3t, that a respect for decorum, secures that for the one, 
which a regard for devotion will not command in the other. To 
speak still more plainly, I mean to say that in so doing you pay more 
re3p3ct to thing3 secular than to things sacred, and pay more honour 
to man than to God. 

Oh ! my dear brethren, these things ought not so to be. I entreat 
you from the bottom of my heart, do not do so, — do not dis- 
honour God, —do not desecrate the place where his honour dwelleth. — 
do not bring discredit upon your own Church. — do not destroy 
your own souls, — but by God's grace, come at once to the 
resolution made by David the sweet Psalmist of Israel, f What is it 
then, " I will pray with the spirit, and I will pray with the under- 
standing also ; I will sing with the spirit, and I will sing with the 
understanding also." I close my address in the words of our own 
dear Church, no less applicable here, than in their proper place in 
the book of Common Prayer. * These things, if ye earnestly consider, 
ye will, by God's grace return unto a better mind ; for the obtaining 
whereof we shall not cease to make our humble petitions unto 
Almighty God our Heavenly Father. 

Your late spiritual Pastor, 

But now and ever your 

Sincerely affectionate Friend, 

J. H. COTTON. 

Deanery-House, Bangor. 
January, 1854. 

It remains to notice that the Dean was passionately fond 
of music, an excellent musician and singer, and gifted with 
a powerful and melodious voice ; the heartiness an animation 
with which he joined in the anthems, — particularly Handel's 
Hallelujah Chorus — choral services and cathedral music 
generally, will be long remembered by those who heard him. 

t And the Apostle. See Psalm xlvii. 7 ; also, 1 dor. xlv. 15. 
* Seoond exhortation in the Communion Serriot. 



108 

He also effected considerable reforms in the ridiculous* 
mode of singing very much in vogue at Bangor, to accomplish 
which he encouraged Glee and Choral Societies, and every 
other movement for the cultivation of taste in both sa' red and 
secular music, .and was regular and punctual at every 
singing practice. 

The Dean delivered the following speech at the laying of 
the foundation stone of Christ Church, Glanogwen, a populous 
village in the parish of Llajillechyd, and in the immediate 
neighbourhood of the Penrhyn Qu.irries, now mide into an 
ecclessiastical district, which church was built and endowed 
entirely through the munificence of the present Lord 
Penrhyn. 

My Deab Friends and Fellow Churchmen, 

You are hero met together t> confer upon yourselves Urn 
highest dignity and honour, it is) possible to ho con furred u|iou man 
by man ; or even upon man by God himself. A man who builds a 
noose, builds it for his own comfort and satisfaction. A man who 
builds an institution which he intends for a scion tide purpose, built In 
it to his own credit, and collaterally for the benefit of others ; and 
indirectly to the glory of God, inasmuch as he promotes the welfare 
of that creature who is formed after the imago of God, and upon 
whom God is most desirous to extend his benevolence, but are now 
met together to build a house to the living God ; to him, who is thu 
builder of all things? and whom nothing can contain, the incom- 
prehensible God, incomprehensible, not in the sense of being beyond 
reach of our capacity, but incomprehensible in the sense of not being 
able to be contained in space, as expressed by our Nicono Greed. A 
Being who upholds time and space, whose centre is everywhere, but 
whose circumference is no-where. How then can He be compressed 

* The Dean was very fond of repeating tho following example of the rldiouloun way 
In which words were divided in music when he came to Bangor. 

Hell take the pil— 
He'll take tho pil— 
Hell take the pilgrim home. 

Hell catch the flee— 
He'll catch the flee— 
He'll eatoh the fleeting hoars. 



104 

into a building ? But we do not endeavour so to do. We raise this 
building, not to receive God, but to receive the Church — the Church 
that is the outward and visible sign of the inward and spiritual grace, 
signified in the Body of Christ. It is called " Christ Church." It 
contains the body of the people of Christ. This church, though it is a 
material church, yet we may learn a lesson from everything in it. 
Here are a corner stone, foundation stone, walls, and a roof. It is a 
building in unity with itself. It is united in every joint. It is built 
on a firm foundation, on a corner stone, and a roof holds it together 
in one. In drawing this parallel between the material and the real 
Church, I do not go beyond the record of scripture, for I am justified 
by St. Paul himself, and having shewn the parallel, I will proceed to 
draw the application from it. We have a Church here built, whose 
foundations, I should say, are built upon the foundation of the 
Apostles and Prophets, Christ himself being the head corner stone. 
As the Prophet Isaiah says, "her walls are walls of love and her 
gates, praise and He is the head. But one is the head, and He is 
Christ." St. Paul allows me to draw a parallel, for he 'puts a parallel 
between the body and members of a man, and the body and members 
of Christ. "For there is but one body, and of that body many 
members ; and those members but one body ; so also is Christ." " For 
we have all been baptized by the spirit into one body, and have all 
been made to partake of the same spirit ; the eye cannot say to the 
hand, I have no need of thee ; nor the head to the feet, I have no 
need of you. " So there is no schism in the body, for all the members 
have the care of one another. If one member suffer, all suffer ; if one 
be honoured, all rejoice. Now we are the body of Christ and members 
in particular. Taking up this idea an excellent man thus diversifies 
it, " Look at a thorn in the foot, how the eye fastens on it, how the 
head bows down, how the back bends to it, how the hand stretches 
out, and the fingers grasp it, thus each contributing its aid to the 
suffering member. " There is evidence of unity, look where you will ; 
it always leads to perfection, and the nearer it rises to perfection the 
nearer it comes to unity. There is but one God, Jehovah ; but one word, 
one salvation, but one son in the world. There is also but one faith, 
one essence, and one over all — the Lord Jesus Christ. But although 
his Divine humanity may seem to convey some semblance of com- 
position, yet it is made up a threefold thing, for as in the Deity there 
is one essence, and three persons ; so in Christ there is one person 
and three essences, never to be divided. And if Christ be one with 
the Father, and the Father in Christ, let us be so one with another. 



106 

And you, my dear children, if any of yon are within my hearing, — 
you, children who are to be educated in the school.-* of this parish, 
look around you, and behold the preparation.-: m:i le :-»r y.iu in this 
place. Here, there is meat for babes, and str-iiij ine.it i >r men. Here 
are schools to instruct you in all the rudiment- «•:" the Christian 
religion. You have here all the advantage* which the I'mphct 
Samuel had under the Old Testament dispensation, and which 
Timothy had under the New. Hiiuiah prayed f-.r her child .saving, 
11 Oh Lord, for this child have I prayed, and the L«>rd hath in-anted 
my petition, therefore he shall he lent to the L >rd a? lung as he 
liveth." And prayers in this church will he odered fur you children, 
that you may be "lent to the LjpL" You have been lent to the 
Lord, and as long as you live you alia 11 be lent to the Lord. 
Timothy through the piety and industry of hi* grandmother Eunice, 
knew the scripture from his ynuth. This church will prove a 
Eunice to you all. Now children, having drank the milk of the 
Church, as babes, will you refuse to feed on her strung meat, when 
men ? Will you desert hrr in her old age, who has nourished you in 
youth ! God forbid ! And may God, our Heavenly Father, put 
down all our unsanc titled schisms, and our unfortunate discords, and 
may the Prince of Peace, the only God and Father of our Lord Jesus 
Christ, give us grace to feel the danger we are in from our unnatural 
divisions ; and as there is but one hope, one faith, one baptism, one 
Lord, and one God and Father of all. so may we be one, with one 
head, and one mind, united in the holy bonds of faith, love and 
charity And may we with one mouth and one mind glori.y the 
God and Father of our Lord Jesus Christ ; and may we, young and 
old, rich and poor, one with another, be able to join in heart, as well 
as in voice, in that Psalm which has been sung, " I was glad when 
they said unto me, we will go into the house of the Lord ; our feet 
shall stand in thy gates, Jerusalem ; Jerusalem is built as &c, &c," 
I will seek to do thee good ! Farewell ! May God bless and prosper 
the work. Amen. 

The following correspondence appeared in the North 
Wales Chronicle, in the year 1858. It is interesting for the 
account it gives of the number of Church Services in the 
parish of Bangor at that time, and it also shows how inde- 
fatigable the Dean was notwithstanding his great age. 



106 
BANGOR CATHEDRAL. 

To the Editor of the North Wales Chronicle. 



Sir, 

I send you a copy of two letters, the former of which appeared 
a few weeks since in the * Union Newspaper.' — The latter is my 
answer to the same, which I forwarded to the Editor, and this also 
appeared in his columns. I will thank you to insert both letters in 
the "North Wales Chronicle." 

Yours obediently, 

J. H. COTTON, 

Deanery, Bangor, September 2\8t. 



To the Editor of tlue " Union. 



a 



Sir, 

It may interest the readers of the " Union " to hear of the state 
of the Church in Bangor. There is a full staff of clergy, the Bishop, 
who is 84 — the Dean who is an old man and totally blind, Vicar, 
Canons, and Choir. With all those it will hardly be believed that the 
doors of the Cathedral are opened only on Sundays ! that the daily 
Services are hebdomadally ! that though on the first day of the week 
the holy walls echo the words " day by day we magnify thee," the 
other six are mutes ! not one of the " saintly days of saintly men 
observed," and this too, in a Cathedral, the model for all churches 
in the Diocese ! The Services on Sunday are, matins at half-past 
eleven ; evening at half -past four ; celebration monthly. The 
Cathedral is the only Anglican Church in this widely scattered town. 
It need not be added that false doctrine, heresy and schism, are ram- 
pant, that the spiritual care of the people is left to the Revd. Evan 
Jones's " who have had a calL" It would be taking up too much of ■ 
valuable space to describe the ritual arrangements of this miserable 
edifice, and the Service, the anthem before the Sermon, &c I must 



107 

therefore conclude with hearty thanks for the able and energetic way 
in which you defend our spiritual mother from the attacks of liur 
enemies, both within and without 

And I remain, Sir, 

Yours respectfully, 

AX ANGLICAN TOUHIST. 

Bangor, Transfiguration of our Lord, 1858. 



To the Editor of the " Union: 1 

Sir, 

In your paper of the 13th of last month. I found a letter (that 
of an Anglican Tourist.) It is stated in the letter, that there in a full 
staff of clergy attached to the Cathedral of Uuigor. Now, Sir, Mm 
Tourist is not correct that there is a full staff of Clergy, or Mich a HtafF 
as is usually attached to Cathedrals. Canons Residentiary liavi; not 
yet been appointed to fill the stalls. 

The staff at present (resident; consists of the Bishop, the (Jean, and 
two Vicars Choral and Parochial. The last two Mipply the pant oral 
duties of the parish, as the second title implies, in addition to the 
office which they fill as members of the Cathedral Church. Tin: 
Bishop re3ide3 during eight month? of the y-.-ar, when he can absent 
himself from his Parliamentary duties, lie is coini«lerabIe above 
80 years of age. His Lordship, however, preichen *:v*-.ry Sunday with 
considerable power. The Dean is described in the letter as an 
•' old man and totally blind." He is old, it is true, being three score 
and eighteen years of age : he is not however totally Mind ; and 
though not able to discern the letters of a hook, he h htill able to 
officiate as before, both in the English and Welsh languages, by the 
aid of mind and memory. The two Vicar.* are in mid-age, and in 
fall possession of their powers, both mental and physical. 'I he choir 
consists of an Org mist, six singinz men. and eight singing boys. In 
addition to the3e there are also a .Sacrist and two Verger?;, who conduct 
the members to the church, and endeivcur to find accommodation 
for the numerous '• Anglican Tourists," who viut ft in^or in the 
Summer season, and who desire to attend the Services of the 
Cathedral 



108 



The Church Services which are performed in the parish and city 
of Bangor are as follows : — 

On Sundays, two Welsh Services, with two Sermons... 104 

Two English Services, with two Sermons 104 

Parochial English Service on each Wednesday and 
Friday in the year, with four additional Services 
during Passion week, and on the Martyrdom of 

Charles the First 109 

Welsh Parochial Services during Lent 17 

Ditto on Festivals 6 

The English Weekly Choral Services 52 

Ditto Saints days and Vigils of ditto 74 

State Holidays 3 

A Welsh Service with Sermons on Sunday in a Chapel 
of Ease, four miles from the City of Bangor ... 52 

Communions throughout the year 32 

Total Services annually, exclusive of baptisms, 
marriages, burials, pastoral engagements, visitation of 
the sick, attendance on day and Sunday Schools, etc. 553 
If your "Anglican Tourist," does not place any confidence in the 
correctness of this account, I beg he will refer himself to any respect- 
able person in the city and parish of Bangor, whether of the number 
of the clergy or of the laity, be he Papist, Protestant, or Puritan, 
friend or foe, or (to use his own words) "any of the Rev. Evan 
Jones's who have had a call." If he is really desirous of obtaining 
and giving any circulation to the truth, he will take every possible 
means he can to investigate it, lest he should be found guilty of a 
breach of the commandment, "Thou shalt not bear false witness 
against thy neighbour." Indeed should the ' 'Anglican Tourist," (to use 
the sentiments of the immortal " Hudibrastic Butler,") feel that truth 
has got the advowson of his conscience, he will return to Bangor 
and place himself under the conduct of the " Old blind Dean," who 
will be glad to receive him, and to assist him in making a personal 
inquiry. Thus, he will be able to satisfy himself and the public by 
contradicting the assertions he has made, and counteracting any evil 
which may have arisen, and any injury which the cause of religion 
may have suffered in consequence of their circulation. Thus also his 
statements will at once afford a contradiction and involve a confession. 
He will be happy to do this out of regard to the interests of our 
common faith, if not from a feeling of affection towards the Church. 
I have said above, "He will place himself under the conduct of 



109 

the " Old blind Dean." Yes ; I odd, that I am sorry that he had not 
remained in Bangor until the 24th of last month, as thus he might 
have accompanied the " Old blind Dean " to the service on that day, 
the Eve of St. Bartholomew ; to the two services of the following day ; 
to the prayers on the Wednesday, devoting Thursday to make 
inquiries from house to house in distant parts of the parish, as he 
would have done in the city on the previous days. He would also 
have followed his conductor to the service on Friday morning ; would 
have attended with him at the choral practise on Saturday morning ; 
the service on the same evening, and the second practise which follows 
on Sunday morning ; the " Old Mind Dean " would have invited him 
to have breakfasted with him at eight o'clock : he should then have 
accompanied him to the Welsh service and sermon a little after nine ; 
after which he .should have placed him in a stall in the choir after the 
first and second sen-ices (leaving the anthem and the sermon) ; he 
should have hurried him from the Cathedral and conveyed him 4 miles 
of a very hilly road to the chapel of ease named above. After the 
service and sermon there, he would have returned with him to Bangor 
in time for the evening choral service, sermon, etc., when, after the 
interval of £ hour, he would find himself sitting in one of the seats of 
the nave during the performance of Welsh evening service, sermon, 
etc., closing before 8 o'clock, when the " Old blind Dean " trusts that 
the "Anglican Tourist " would have done him the favour of taking a 
comfortable tea with him at the Deanery, closing the day by joining 
with bim in the family devotions." 

I have made answer to your correspondents^ letter without using 
any terms of reproach. I have adopted only the advice of our great 
poet, viz., " You must speak by the card or equivocation will undo 
you." I have not shot out my arrows, even " bitter words," even 
though, " as the fire kindled," I might have been disposed " thus to 
■peak unadvisedly with my lips." "A soft answer thrneth away 
wrath. ' ' My words then have been dictated by that spirit with which 
our Church, through Christ its Head, ever imbues the minds of its 
sincere and faithful members. Assuming that I am possessed of this 
spirit, I cannot but be consistent with myself in assuming that the 
M Anglican Tourist "possesses a kindred spirit. He will therefore 
heartily join with me in expressing his approbation of the following 
words of the son of Sirach, with which I close my letter ; " Blame 
not before thou hast examined the truth ; understand first, and then 
rebuke. Answer not before thou hast heard the cause. Strive not 
in a matter that concerneth thee not. My son, meddle not with many 
matters ; for, if thou meddle much, thou shalt not be innocent. If 

I 



110 

thou hast understanding, answer thy neighbour ; if not f lay thy 
hand upon thy mouth." 

I am, Sir, your humble Servant, 

THE OLD BLIND DEAN. 

N.B. — I hope your readers -will exercise the same patience in perusing the answer 
as in reading the attack, notwithstanding the opinion conveyed in the well known 
axiom that " men like short accusations better" than long answers." 

About the end of the year 1858, the children of the 
Bangor National Schools presented the Dean with a handsome 
Family Bible, together with the following address, as a 
testimony of their great love and esteem. The address was 
read by one of the pupils on behalf of himself and the other 
scholars, and was couched in the following terms : 

" Dear Mr. Dean, — We, the boys and girls of this school, are glad 
of the opportunity, before breaking up for the holidays, of wishing 
you a merry Christmas and a happy New Year. 

We also beg leave to thank you for the kind interest you have at 
all times taken in our spiritual and temporal welfare, and it is our 
sincere prayer that your valuable lif e may be spared for many years, 
that others may receive the kindness which you have shown to us, 
and when your earthly career is over, you may be received into the 
heavenly garner, and hear those blessed words of our Lord, " well 
done thou good and faithful servant, enter thou into the joy of thy 
Lord." 

The following stanzas composed by the late Mr. Martin, 
Editor of the North Wales Chronicle, expressive of the 
children's gratitude to the Dean, was then sung by them, 
assisted by the Cathedral Choir. 

Dear Mr. Dean, 

Our good kind Dean, 

We long have loved yon well, 

Tour noble parts 

Have won our hearts, 

Much more than we can tell. 

Von kind have been 

Good Mr. Dean, 

To bring as here to School, 

Where we may be 

In harmony — 

And learn to live by rule. 



Ill 

And when this lifo 

And all its strife, 

8hall ended be in he&Ycn, 

Wo hope to sinj? 

Before oar kin&, 

The joys which you have given. 

The Dean replied, — " My dear children, I was quite unprepared 
for the very kind salutations which have just given me, and what I 
shall have to say, will be more from the heart than the head ; but 
what comes from the heart goes through my head also. You have 
been pleased to esteem mc as your benefactor. I have now been here 
60 yeara — being 70 years of age next birthday — if it shall please God 
to extend my life to that time. The establishment of this Institution 
owes its existence more t > circumstances than to any merit which I 
possess. It came under the auspices of the Bishop in that day, who 
was my father in law, and what I then did, I did subject to his 
approval. When this room was built, the town consisted of a few 
houses, and very few persons understood the English language ; and 
I well remember what the Bishop said to me when this room was 
first opened." Well this room said he, '• can never be filled ;" and 
having a tendency to being a little jocular, I said it was like John 
Gilpins wig, sure to fit if made large enough. It has since proved 
too small, if it was then thought to be too large. I lately said at a 
meeting of a demonstration that was to take place here, that the 
School had been used for nearly every purpose except as a slaughter 
house, and so it had. It had been a Church, and meetings of the 
Society for the Propagation of the Gospel — for Promoting Christian 
Knowledge — National Society, and of the Bible Society, have been 
held in it ; Clubs have met in it ; and it has been made a Barrack 
for the Queen, and you see it has been a very useful room ; but it 
was originally built for bringing up children in the nurture and 
admonition of the Lord. 

I have had many masters, I should have said, we have had many 
masters, but there never was a master who conducted himself with so 
much credit to himself and so indefatigably discharged the duties of 
the School, as the present one. The number of those who have been 
elevated to lawyers officios — to pulpits — the post office — and many 
offices of trust, will long testify upon what principles these school 
children are taught. In fact the master and mistress have both done 
their duty with equal credit to themselves and deserve well of you 
alL You wish me prosperity in this life, and eternal happiness in 
another. As long as I continue to receive the wages of the Church, I 
shall continue to do the work of the Church, and hope I may be 



112 

enabled to say with the Apostle, " I have fought a good fight, I have 
finished my course, I have kept the faith ; henceforth there is laid up 
for me a crown of righteousness, which the Lord, the righteous judge, 
shall give me at that day : and not to me only, but unto all them also 
that love his appearing. ' ' The ven. gentleman concluded his affecting 
address in the words of Hooker : "Lord, wherein I have failed, 
pardon me, for I plead not my own merits but the forgiveness of my 
demerits for his sake, who died to purchase pardon for penitent 
sinners ;" after which he invoked the blessing of God upon that day's 
proceedings. 



118 

CHAPTER VIII. 

Remarks on the State of Church Schools in connection with the 

Committee of Council on Education. 

THE subjoined 'Remarks' were made by Dean Cotton 
and published in a pamphlet. The subjects treated of are : 
(i) Religious Education. (2) Qualifications of National 
School-masters. (3) The main objects of National Schools — 
Dissenters and the Church. (4) The most effective means 
of educating the lower orders in the principality. The 
' Remarks ' will repay perusal as emanating from one of such 
great experience and who was certainly before his age on the 
question of education. They are also doubly interesting at 
the present time when modern Dissenters evince so much 
hostility to religious education in day schools. 

" Yet stay a while, consider well ; are they not senseless fools 
Who, for the Science and the Silver of these modern Schools 
Neglect the Word of God, no less the Church's Golden Rules ?" 

And here we must not omit to mention the great services 

rendered to the cause of religious education and dissemination 

of Church principles by the * Bangor Diocesan Board of 

Education/ established in the year 1848, through the 

exertions of Dean Cotton and other clerical and lay friends 

of education. Its liberal grants to young persons to perfect 

themselves as National School-masters or mistresses, and its 

grants in aid of the salaries of masters and mistresses in 

parishes or districts where their support was one of peculiar 

difficulty, added much to the efficiency of the religious 

knowledge of the schools under the control of the Board, and 

the inspection of its honorary Inspectors. 

It is the opinion of those who are anxious to bring up the Children 
of the poor in religious, moral, and Church principles, that the 
present System of Education is not calculated to meet their wishes, 
or the wants of the poorer orders, It is evident that some Masters 
are more anxious to have a number of children on the list for the 
sake of the Capitation Grant, than to advance them in the knowledge 
of the Scriptures, and the instilling into them good Church principles. 



114 

They are particularly regardless of their attendance at the Sunday 
School and at Divine Service. The Masters appear not to consider their 
Sunday engagements as a matter of primary importance. ' Indeed it is 
not probable that the young persons bred in our Training Schools 
should attach themselves to the duties of a Sunday School ; if it is 
true, as is stated, that they are not in the habit of attending regularly 
as Teachers in the Sunday Schools in those towns in which the 
Training Schools are placed. If this is so, the mdet important part of 
their own education is neglected. The Sunday School is the very 
best School in which they themselves can imbibe religious' principles, 
and in which they will best learn how to give a religious tone, and 
to impart religious knowledge to the children who may afterwards 
receive instruction from them. The Master of a National School, if 
he is to be entirely efficient, should be such as I now describe : — 

The Master or Teacher (for he should be both), should possess a 
religious mind, should be a man of strict moral conduct, and be 
strongly imbued with Church principles. He should love children and 
delight in the office of teaching them. He should be able to induce 
the children to love him, and to delight in being taught by him. He 
should prefer the advancement of the children, whether spiritual, 
mental, or moral, before his own interest. He should neither regard 
the favours of their parents nor dread their frowns. 

The conductor of a School should also use his uttermost effort to 
maintain a placid state of mind. His pupils should never be able to 
entertain a suspicion that in his correction of faults he can be actuated 
by passion or act without due deliberation. And that he may confirm 
this favourable opinion in their minds, he will let a considerable 
time elapse between the commission of the fault and the infliction of 
the punishment. If moved by anger, he will lose his influence over the 
minds of his pupils, and discourage them from the desire of pleasing 
him by striving to correct themselves. He must preserve also a 
perfect consistency of conduct ; and thus assure his pupils that they 
may so fully depend upon him that he will not pass over an offence 
on one day, which he has visited on the preceding day, or deny the 
approbation to one which, under similar circumstances, he has 
awarded to another. 

Conciliation without compromise should be the motto of every 
Master and Teacher of a school. He should be most scrupulously 
careful to avoid anything which may create an opinion that he is in 
any degree actuated by partiality. I say this, because I know there 
are cases in which Masters permit some of their scholars to absent 
themselves from Divine Service in the Church, while others are 



115 

excused from attending with the children, and are privileged to 
attend there as private scholars under the charge of their own friends. 
Now the effect of this last indulgence, to say nothing of the former, 
is productive of evil, both as it respects the Master himself and the 
minds of his scholars. This apparent partiality creates an opinion 
unfavourable to the character of the Master. The public are led to 
infer that he is actuated by a worldly or other unworthy motive, 
receiving in return some recompense for granting this privilege to 
the favoured few. As it regards the minds of the children them- 
selves, it leads those who are thus favoured to assume a little self- 
importance, and leaves the remainder of the children under a feeling 
of disgust towards their Master, and jealousy with respect to their 
fellows. The main object of Church school*, is to ground the children 
well in the knowledge of the Holy Scriptures, and to imbue them 
with Church principles. An education so conducted, and that 
consistently, and without compromise, will certainly be productive 
of the best effects. This is not merely a matter of opinion, or an 
assumption, for the proof may be seen in the action of a school for 
nearly 30 years, where this system of training !has been strictly 
observed. The young persons who have been brought up in this 
Institution arc now filling situations of responsibility and respect- 
ability, with credit to themselves and satisfaction to their employers. 
The Bible and the Book of Common Prayer should form the two 
corner stones upon which should be founded the education of the 
sons of the Church of England. These should be especially, though not 
exclusively, studied. It is feared that the children of our schools are 
not sufficiently instructed in the character of the Prayer Book, and are 
not made to understand that it is an epitome of the Book of God. 
They are not imbued sufficiently with an entirely devotional spirit , 
nor is there instilled into them such a sober piety as may guard them 
against the wild enthusiasm which is now going abroad, which tends 
to make young persons both presumptuous and profane, and 
extinguish all rational religion. Indeed the very form of godliness is 
not enforced in some places, as I once evidenced in a school while 
singing a hymn preparatory to their proceeding to the Church 
Service. In this case the cliildren, instead of being directed to stand 
up and preserve a reverent posture, were permitted to lean or loll 
indifferently on the desks before them, while remaining in a sitting 
posture. I am sorry to add, that the masters generally are not 
disposed to imbue their scholars with religious, moral, and above all 
with Church principles, and I feel assured that this most important 
part of their education will be entirely neglected, unless the Clergy 



116 

take this part upon themselves. I have submitted the above remarks 
to many of my brethren amongst the Clergy, and to some of the laity 
who take an interest in the schools : some of these admitted them to 
be just. I also submitted them to one of the Inspectors in connection 
with the Committee of Council of Education, who entirely concurred 
with me adding that it was impossible to speak in terms too strong 
with respect to the neglect shown to the religious, moral, and 
Church principles of the children. He afforded me the following 
idea, which I convey in these lines : 

" Away with graphy> logy y metry ; science for tho head, 
And give me solid food, to feed the mind and heart instead." 

The rebuke which is intended to be given by the following extract 
from a humorous publication, to a system of education now too 
general, may be as appropriately given to the system pursued by 
some masters, conducting schools in connection with the Council of 
Education. 

" Father," said a lady of the new school to her indulgent spouse, 
as he resumed his pipe after supper, one evening, " you must buy 
your dear Georgiana an English grammar and spelling book ; she 
has gone through her French, Latin, and Greek, Music, Drawing, 
and Dancing, and now she must commence her English studies !" 

Some there are, who, while they give their pupils a small 
smattering of science, neglect the weightier matters of the law ; the 
reading, the understanding, and the applying the Word of God. 
Let me recommend to these the following text from the Book of 
Nehemiah, as a rule by which they ought to act, both as it respects 
their pupils and themselves : "So they read in the book of the law 
of God distinctly, and gave the sense, and caused them to under- 
stand the reading." 

To proceed with my remarks : The Dissenters wish to induce 
the Clergy to permit the master to compromise their principles, 
in neglecting to imbue their children with Church principles, and 
not to require their attendance upon the Service of the Church 
on every Sunday. But surely the Clergy will not give place 
to these men, "no not for an hour;" thus betraying the interests 
of the Church to which they have sworn allegiance, and bringing 
up the children of the poor in schism, making the Church a society 
for the propagation of religious and political fanaticism. There are 
few men among schoolmasters who understand the art of teaching. 
Many there are who would rather preach than teach. By this I 
mean that they would rather show what they themselves know than 
draw out from the minds of the children what they know, they teach 



117 

their children rather to answer mechanically than mentally. The 
great art is to teach children to think, to depend upon themselves, 
and to draw upon their own resources. It is very interesting to 
watch the struggles of a child while in the act of endeavouring to 
express his mind. The child will often describe what he means very 
significantly, though defectively for want of language. 

I subjoin the following extract from a work entitled '* Trench 
Upon Words," which will be read with interest and establish 
the opinion I have given of the importance of bringing moral and 
spiritual forces to bear upon the mind and affections of the child. 

"There is no such fruitful source of confusion and mischief as 
this : — Two words are tacitly assumed as equivalent, and therefore 
exchangeable, and then that which may be assumed, and with truth, 
of one, is assumed also of the other, of which it is not true. Thus, 
for instance, it often is with * instruction ' and ' education.' Cannot 
we ' instruct ' a child, it is asked, cannot we teach it Geography, or 
Arithmetic, or Grammar, quite independently of the Catechism, or 
even of the Scriptures ? No doubt you may, but can you * educate ' 
without bringing moral and spiritual forces to bear upon the mind 
and affections of th3 child ? And you must not be permitted to 
transfer the admissions which we freely make in regard of ' instruct- 
ion, ' as though they also held good in respect of ' education.' For 
what is ' education ? ' Is it a furnishing of a man from without with 
knowledge, and facts, and information ? Or is it a drawing forth 
from within, and a training of the spirit of the tmc humanity which 
is latent within him V Is the process of education the filling of the 
child's mind as a cistern is filled with waters brought in buckets from 
some other source, or the opening up of its own fountains ? Now if 
we give any heed to the word ' education,' and to the voice which 
speaks in the word, we shall not long be in doubt. Education must 
educe, being from * educare ' which is but another form of * educere ;' . 
and that is ' to draw out ' and not to ' put in. ' To draw out what is 
in the child, the immortal spirit which is there, this is the end of 
education ; and so much the word declares. The putting in is indeed 
most needful, that is, the child must be instructed as well as educated, 
and the word ' instruction ' just means furnishing ; but not instructed 
instead of educated. He must first have powers awakened in him, 
measures of spiritual value given to him, and then he will know how 
to deal with the facts of this outward world ; then instruction in 
these will prolit him ; but not without the higher training, still less 
as a substitute for it. " 

I will now make a remark as to the most effective method of 



118 

educating the children of the lower orders in the Principality. 
The § Welsh children, thinking as they do in their native language 
and speaking in the same, find it difficult to attain to a perfect 
pronunciation of the English tongue and yet more so to a fall 
understanding of it3 terms. I submit therefore the following plan 
to the consideration of the conductors of our National Schools, 
under a hope that it may enable the children to attain at once to the 
knowledge of the two languages, the knowledge of which will prove 
most advantageous to them in their intercourse both with the higher 
and lower ranks. 

The Clergyman, or master, will take copies of the Duoglott 
Testament, or Prayer Book, and putting one of these in the hand of 
every child of the first class, he will direct one of them to read a 
short portion of the same in the English language. He will tell the 
other children, to fix both their eyes and their attention upon the 
corresponding Welsh portion, and follow him who reads. He will 
next direct another to read the same in Welsh, while the others fix 
their minds upon the English portion, which has been before read. 
Thus, the whole class will be instructed in two languages at once, 
and these will expound each other, and mutually meet in the mind 
of the learner. A Cambrian child, perhaps, will find himself quite 
abroad in " sundry places," but he will find himself at home 
"mewn amrywiol fannau." When he repeats the 19th Psalm, 
he will wonder when it is said that "there is neither speech nor 
language, but their voices are heard among them ;" bu5 if he turn to 
the Welsh version of the same passage, he will find this apparent 
contradiction removed, for he will understand, "Nid oes iaithnac 
ymadrodd, lie ni chlybuwyd eu lleferydd hwynt." This passage 
indeed has been mistaken by English persons, who had not given 
credit for the equivocal character of the English language, nor made 
an allowance for obsolete terms. Even Addison appears to have 
done so in his paraphrase of this Psalm. His words are as 
follows : — 

" What though no real voice nor sound 
Amid their radient orbs be found." 

The child, in reading the 4th verse of the 95th Psalm, will be 
placed in "corners of the earth," from whence he may have a 
distant and indistinct view of "the strength of the hills," but when 
he has read the Welsh version, his capacity is wonderfully enlarged, 
for he encompasses at once in his embrace both " gorddyfnderaa " 
ddaear," and also " uchelder y mynyddoedd." H he seeks to pray 
in the words of our Collects, he will perhaps, suppose that in two of 



110 

he asks God to "hinder " him, " in all his doings," for so he 
alsely interpret the word " prevent,*' but when he turns to 
Collects in his own language, and tinds the corresponding 
"rhagflaena," he takes comfort, and finds that " ni allwn ni 
hnr gweithredoedd da, hoff a chymmera'lwy gan Dduw heb 
nw trwy Grist yn ein rhagtiaenu." (See 39 articles.) Again, 
t Litany, he sees that he is to pray for the " Prince Consort," 
e does not understand what the term " Consort " means, 
tea the word perhaps for the name of some foreign Prince ; 
r hen he looks to the opposite side of the page and reads 
rysog, Priod y Frenhines," then his piety and loyalty are 
ned. In the 1st Book of Samuel are the following words of 
: "The Lord who delivered me out of the paw of the lion 
be paw of the bear, will deliver me out of the hands of this 
tine." The following is the Welsh version of the same words. 
Arglwydd, yr hwn am hachubodd i o grafangc y Hew, ac o balf 
ih, efe a'm hachub i o law y Philistiad hwn.'' Here the 
ot teacher will not fail to lead his pupil to compare the two 
as and to observe the superiority of the latter. Here he will 
hat an appropriate instrument is given to each, the lion, the 
ind the man ; the claw or crafangc to the first, the paw or balf 
second, and the hand or Haw to the third. 

the Litany the following words occur: "O Lord deal not 
na after our sins, neither reward us after our iniquities." 
ed an adult what was here meant by the word " after." 
iswered it meant to ask God not to punish us after we 
wnmitted "sin" and "iniquity." I directed him to look at 
elah Prayer Book where he found the following words ; "yn 
pechodau.'' These words in Welsh entirely explained the 
in English, and answering to the English words, "according 
'. sins." If an Adult might mistake the meaning of the word 
r," how much more likely would it be for a child to err in this 
;t. 

the 17th Chapter of the Acts of the Apostles, and the 19th 
we are told that the people brought St. Paul unto Areopagus ; 
the 22nd verse we are told that St. Paul " stood in the midst 
j*s Hill." Xow, if the Welsh child should be asked whether 
ars Hill and Areopagus were different places he would naturally 
r "Yes;'' but if he was directed to look in the Welsh 
a, he would answer, that the same place was meant. If he 
sked why he thought so, he would answer, "Because they 
have the same name." This would give the Teacher an 



120 

opportunity of shewing tho learner that the latter was only ft 
translation of tho former. 

In the Litany wo have tho following sentence : " In all time of oar 
tribulation, in all time of our wealth," &c. The word " wealth " 
hero docs not convey tho sonso of riches, but weal, prosperity, or 
happiness ; as opposed to "woo." " As we love the weal of oar 
souls and Bodies." — flac-on. " Tho weal or woo in thee is placed."— 
Milton. This word " wealth " is not understood in its proper sense 
oven by some among our English congregations, much less by a Welsh 
child. Let us then refer such a child to the corresponding version 
in tho Welsh language, and ho will read thus " Yn holl amser ein 
trallod, yu holl aniser ein gwynfyd," &c. 

Let the English -Welsh, or (if you please), the Anglo-Cymro 
scholar, read the following passage in the Communion Service, 
"if any man sin we have an Advocate with the Father, Jems 
Christ tho righteous, and he is the propitiation for our sins*" 
Tho words "advocate" and "propitiation" are of Latin origin. 
What does he know of these ? What sense can he affix to them? 
Let him turn to the parallel passage in the Welsh version and be 
will road thus : " 0& poeha neb, y inae i ni Eiriolwr gyd aVr Twl 
Iohu Crist y oyfiawn ; ac efo yw'r iawn dros ein i>cchodau ni." 
Let him also compare the words "righteous" and "propitiation" 
with tho words "cyfiawn" and " iawn" in tho Welsh version. 
Such a comparison will not only tend to explain but to add strength 
and givo increased signiiicancy to tho latter. 

When young persons arc thus taught to compare two languages 
together, it will give them a groat enlargement of mind. They 
will comparo together tho grammatical construction of each, ftnd 
understand the etymology and full signiiicancy of words.- This will 
give to tho Welsh children an immense advantage over the children 
of a like grade and of similar circumstances who possess the English 
language only. This portion of their instruction I would commit 
principally to the Clergyman of each parish, who will also give effect 
to this mode of instruction by oasy expositions in familiar terms, 
and that in both languages, I should hope that every Clergymen 
would devote at least one day in every week to this work, in addition 
to his attendance at the Sunday School. Surely no Pastor can be 
better employed, or ho eflicieutly as in attending to the younger 
members of his (lock. J Low shall the elder members digest strong 
meat if tho younger aro not fed with the sincere milk of the word. 
If the aged aro to " grow in grace and in the knowledge of our Lord 
and Saviour Jesus Christ," their children must be brought np in 



121 

the " nurture and admonition of the Lord. " These must read, mark, 
and learn, before they can inwardly digest the Holy Scriptures 
which were written for our learning. Let the Ministers then give 
their whole heart and strength to this work, and we shall bring up 
the next generation as a people " prepared for the Lord," and 
qualified to value and prefer the ministration.') of the Church al>ovo 
the services which are now relished by those who frequent the 
congregations of our Dissenting brethren. I desire not to impose 
heavier duties upon others than those which I practise myself, and 
I should be unhappy if I should be ever impelled to say — 

Younger and abler pass'd these by ; 
How strong are they, how weak am I ! 

As I have said before — It is very interesting to watch the 
straggles of children to express what they mean, when a question is 
pat to them. If they are permitted to think, and encouraged to do 
so, it affords them satisfaction, and they take a pleasure in learning. 
The following are the answers of children, both in the Town and in 
Rural Districts, which show that they will reason if they are both 
permitted and prompted to do so. 

I asked a child in a rural district, who never heard the English 
language but during his school hours, what was meant by a vision. 
He answered, "mind awake, body asleep." I asked another, to 
bo give me an instance of the humility shown by our Lord, He 
answered, " he told a man that wanted to go with him that he had 
bo place to lie down," meaning, " nowhere to lay his head." 

When some of the little boys in our National Schools are 
questioned as to the meaning of certain words or passages they 
Sometimes answer, "I can tell you in Welsh, but not in 
English." The fact is, they understood the meaning, but could 
oot express it fully, so as to satisfy themselves. A girl in a country 
sehool was asked why Christ was said to be of the house of David. 
She answered, " Because ho was of the lineage of David." Certainly 
ihe children of peasantry in Wales have made an advance upon some 
rf the children of the gentry in England during the period of the last 
lizty or seventy years. This will be believed by those who read the 
following story. A gentleman of great respectability was speaking 
rf the slovenly manner in which the Catechism was allowed to be 
repeated when he was a child, and also the utter neglect of 
XHttveying to the child the meaning of that which he repeated. 
Se said : "I went with my mother to a place bordering on the sea. 
When I saw the sea for the first time in my life, I oried out 



122 

* Mamma, why, I now see the sea, but where is all the tindem ia! 
meaning, the sea and all that in them is ?" We have indeed made ai 
improvement upon the manner of repeating the Catechism, when th< 
children were permitted to forsake faith as well as sin. I allude tc 
the following question and answer : " What is required of persons tc 
be baptised?" "Repentance whereby they forsake sin and faith, * 
&c. ; omitting the comma after the word sin and thus causing 
the child to declare that the forsaking of faith is required oi 
persons to be baptized. 

A Clergyman exercising one day the upper class of a country 
school in the Prayer Book on the plan which I have stated 
above, selected the Gospel for the Seventeenth Sunday after 
Trinity. In this Gospel the word "rooms" occurs more than 
once, he did not ask the children what was the original meaning 
of the word " rooms," knowing, as he did, many amongst English 
readers did not know its meaning. He referred them therefore 
to the Welsh version, when they understood the word "eistedd- 
leoedd," signifying "sitting places," or " seats." The word •• rooms" 
signified the same, and not "chambers" or "rooms," in the 
present acceptation. In the life of " Cardinal Wolsey, by Cavendish, 
his gentleman usher, is the following passage : " When the Cardinal 
came in to see the guests, he bade them ' keep their rooms.' " 

I subjoin the following extract from the life of Dr. Bichard 
Hooker, by Isaac Walton, and quote it as a pattern upon 
which' all parents and schoolmasters should imbue the minds and 
form the manners of the children whom God or good men have 
committed to their care. 

Speaking of Dr. Hooker's instructors, the historian thus ex- 
presses himself : " His parents and masters laid a foundation 
' for his future happiness, by instilling into his soul the seeds of 
piety, those conscientious principles of loving and fearing God, 
of an early belief that he knows the very secrets of our souls, 
that he punisheth our vices, and rewards our innocence; that 
we should be free from hypocrisy, and appear to men what we an 
to God, because first or last the crafty man is catched in his own 
snare. These seeds of piety were so seasonably planted, and to 
continually watered with the daily dew of God's blessed spirit, that 
his infant virtues grew into such holy habits, as did make him grow 
daily into more and more favour both with God and man ; which, 
with the great learning that he did after attain to, hath made Bichard 
Hooker honoured in this, and will continue him to be so to laooeedjf 
generations." 



123 

Tn closing these remarks I am happy in being able to add that, at 
meeting of the " Board of Education " resolutions to the following 
ffect were adopted, viz : — 

That rewards should be given to those children who were 
lost proficient in Scripture History, Catechism, Liturgy, and 
Jhurch History, after the annual examination by the Diocesan 
nspector. 

I cannot deny the friends of education in general, the satisfaction, 
lor schoolmasters'in particular, the advantage, which they will both 
•eceive by the perusal of the following extract from one of the 
Reports of the National Society for promoting the education of the 
x»r in the principles of the Established Church. 

" The history of the National Society is not only a history of the 
more mechanical parts of education — of the building and improve- 
ment of schools, and of the establishment and management of 
training colleges — it is also in a great measure, a history of 
principles, and of the growth and progress of .public sentiment with 
regard to the real meaning and import of education and the legitimate 
means of promoting it. The fundamental principle of this society — 
a principle which now seems happily to be very generally recognised 
and approved — has ever been, that all education deserving the name 
must be based upon religion ; and that education in its full and 
proper sense, cannot rightly be said to be carried on where definite 
wHgious belief and religious principle do not pervade the whole 
teaching of a school. Your committee believe that much fewer 
persons than formerly are now to be found, who would contend that 
it is not necessary to education that special religious instruction (as 
it was called) should be given in a school, and who think that the 
children of persons of all religious tenets may safely be placed in the 
■Mne school, under the same teacher, and be taught those general 
troths of religion only on which all their parents are agreed. 
•Against such a notion, the National Society has always entered its 
•wnest protest, contending, that to profess to be educating a child, 
•&d yet to make nought, or to make light, of definite religious belief 
•fid principle, is to engender in youth the most fatal habit of mind 
and thought, and to sap the foundation of all religion in the breast. 
The children brought up in such a school would breathe an atmosphere 
of hesitancy and doubt on almost all matters of Revelation ; and the 
Necessary tendency of such a scheme would seem to be, to produce 
JU their young minds a coldness towards religion, if not to stamp 
them with a positive scepticism. Again, others have said that, while 
they agreed with the National Society in rejecting the notion of placing 



124 

children in a school where the master should so contrive to generalize 
religion, as to inculcate nothing except what men of all forms and 
shades of religious opinion might be brought to agree upon, yet that 
another scheme was feasible, for educating together all children, 
irrespective of religious tenets — namely, that the schoolmaster should 
professedly and distinctly impart secular and literary instruction 
only, and that certain fixed hours should be set apart, at which the 
ministers of religion might attend, in separate rooms, to teach 
religious belief and religious principle. To this plan, the Society has 
ever opposed its leading principle — that education is not education, 
unless religion is throughout its pervading essence ; for education 
means much more than instruction. To educate a child, " the master 
must do more than impart certain lessons. The master should be 
more than a clever, expert teacher. You want to bring mind in 
contact with mind — the mature mind of a religious master 
in contact with the impressible mind of the scholar. Yon want 
the innermost spirit of the man to hold converse with the innermost 
spirit of the child. You want the heart of the child to catch some of 
the holy fire of religion, which should burn in the breast of the 
master, and breathe through all his actions. Religion is not only 
imparted in set lessons, but in the whole course of school discipline- 
by example, by gesture, by look, by the turn of a phrase, by a kind 
of mental oontagion, which may be understood, though it can hardly 
be described. Do what you will the child will look up to the school- 
master as his educator, and the schoolmaster will mainly contribute 
to form, not only the future mechanic, but the future man. And 
shall the schoolmaster be one who is forbidden to name the name of 
Christ ? Nay, if you will give the child a chance of growing up a 
religious being, the master must be a person who is religious ; he 
must be one whose spirit will prompt and urge him, upon every 
occasion, to seize the moment when the heart of an erring child is 
warm and malleable, for impressing it indelibly with some of the 
touching words, or with the still more touching example, of our 
Saviour. No one has such opportunities as the schoolmaster for 
doing this ; but if the master is not permitted — nay, bound — thus to 
bring forward the doctrines and precepts of Christianity, and to 
found all his rules and his discipline upon them, — if these *hi*wg» are 
not interwoven naturally with the daily school routine, but are merely 
taught in a cold set formal way, at stated intervals, then, at the very 
best, the child insensibly learns to look upon religion as a medid 1 *! 
drug, to be occasionally resorted to, instead of regarding it as the 
very bread of life. 



125 



CHAPTER IX. 

Carriage of Miss Ann Cotton — Her Death — Extract from Merthyr 
Telegraph — Death of Bishop Bethell and appointment of Bishop 
Campbell — The dispute about the Minor Canonry — A description 
of England and Wales in verse — Extract from Lecture delivered 
at the Bangor Sailor's Christian Institute. 

IN the month of October, 1859, Miss Ann Cotton, Dean 
Cotton's youngest daughter was married to the Rev. Evan 
Lewis, then Vicar of Aberdare, now Rector of Dolgelley, and 
Chancellor of Bangor Cathedral. She died in December of 
the following year. The " Merthyr Telegraph," commenting 
upon the death of this estimable lady, says : — 

" In the street and market-place, in the poorest of poor homes, by 
the most wretched of wretched beings, a lady was once very often 
met doing deeds of charity in a pure, kindly -hearted manner. On 
the lips of a hundred her name hung as that of a benefactress, and 
wherever we went, her praises were the theme of pleasant conver- 
sation. Sad to write that one so good is now no more, and that a 
hfe, which in all human likelihood would have been so useful, has 
been so abruptly closed. Let us while penning our humble tribute to 
the dead, direct attention to the noble example she gave us — and 
hope that other women following in her steps may in good deeds and 
pure womanly sympathies, awaken-ever during memorials of the 
P*8t." The flame paper, in commenting upon the severity of the 
▼rather, and the necsssity of adopting measures for the relief of the 
distressed poor, says, "The poor of Aberdare never lost a better 
friend, nor the world a better woman than she who was so cruelly 
torn from the field of her Christian labours, fcut a week or two ago— 
the lamented wife of the Vicar of the parish. And it is much to be 
hoped that the kindly disposed ladies of the town will see that the 
pfcrt which Mrs. Lewis so nobly sustained during her life time, be 
▼ell played out. Had this good lady lived, it is more than probable 
that she would have found means ere this to establish some 
hind of temporary institution to help out the efforts of private 
°harity during the present trying crisis, and we heartily trust that 
■Hon a desideratum will not long be " conspicuous for its absence." 

On the 19th April, 1859, Bishop Bethell died, at the 
advanced age of 86 years, having presided over the Diocese, 

K 



126 

for 29 years, and was succeeded by the Venerable Archdeacon 
Campbell, who, as Rector of Merthyr, had, by his good 
judgment, earnest piety, unwearied labours, and his con- 
ciliatory, but at the same time, firm and consistent 
character, won the respectand admiration of both rich and 
poor. 

In the year 1850, on the death of the Reverend Hugh 
Price, Bishop Bethell appointed the Reverend Evan Pughe 
to succeed him as Vicar Parochial and Vicar Choral of 
Bangor, both of which appointments had from time im- 
memorial been held by his predecessors, the right of collation 
being always vested in the Bishops of Bangor. 

In the year i860, the Dean and Chapter disputed Mr. 
Pughe's right to hold the office of Vicar Choral or Minor 
Canon, alleging that the late Bishop had inadvertently 
collated him to both offices, and that his lordship had over- 
looked the fact, that by sec. 44 of 6 and 7 Vic. c. 77, he 
had been divested of the patronage of Vicarage Choral, which 
section enacts, " That henceforth the right of appointing 
Minor Canons shall be in all cases vested in the respective 
Chapters, and shall not be exercised by any other person or 
body whatsoever ; and that so soon as conveniently may be, 
and by the authority hereinafter provided, regulations shall 
be made for fixing the number and emoluments of such 
Minor Canons in each collegiate or Cathedral Church, 
provided that in any case there shall not be more nor less 
than two, and that the stipend of each such Minor Canon 
shall not be less than one hundred and fifty pounds a year," 
This dispute caused much unpleasantness at the time, but 
it was finally settled by the Ecclesiastical Commissioners 
confirming Mr. Pughe's appointment. 

The following lines descriptive of England and Wales 
were composed by Dean Cotton ; intended for the use of 
young children, and particularly for the children of Infant 
Schools. 



127 

THE TOUR OF ENGLAND. 



Little England has forty Counties in all. 

Some great and some middling, and one very small ; 

Six Northern, four Western, eight Eastern ; and mind, 

Three South East, twelve Midland, seven Southern you'll find. 

CHORUS. 

If you'll hear all my song, 

And it shall not be long, 

We'll visit them all in their turn. 

2 

Northumberland stands at the top of the tree, 
And Cumberland next with his hills you will see ; 
Then Westmorland for its lakes and slates so fam'd, 
And Durham oft times with its Bishoprick nam'd. 

If you'll hear all my song, &c. 



Then York with its Ridings the next on the roll, 
And Lancashire, known for its weavers, and coal ; 
Then Lincoln, so rich in its coast and its soil, 
And Nottingham, where they spin all the while. 

If you'll hear all my song, &c. 

4 

In Derbyshire the Peak we'll see if you please ; 
In Cheshire we'll oat a good slice of their cheese ; 
In Shropshire, of ale, we will take a small sup ; 
In Stafford, the pott'ries shall find us a cup, 

If you'll hear all my song, &c. 



By the Leicestershire spires, so taper and tall, 
Thro' Rutland of Counties the smallest of all, 
We'll pass to Northampton, nor stay to alight, 
Since we purpose to sleep at Bedford that night. 

If you'll hear all my song, &c. 



128 



6 

And now, my good children, where next shall we rest ; 
We'll travel thro' Bucks, and so on to the West ; 
We'll see Warwick Castle tho' out of our way : 
At Worcester the china we'll see the next day. 

If you'll hear all my song, &c. 

7 

For Herford and Ross we'll set out the next morn, 
And see Monmouth, where Henry the 5th was born ; 
The orchards of Oloster we'll pass on our way, 
And tarry at Oxford the whole of the day. 

If you'll hear all my song, &c, 

8 

But stop, let us see, as we are going all round, 
We must here turn about, and double our ground ; 
And to Huntingdon go, and take a full view 
Of Cambridge's fam'd University too. 

If you'll hear all my song, &c. 



The Turkeys in Norfolk are famous we know, 
We will have a slice ere to Suffolk we go ; 
Next over the fens of Essex we'll travel, 
Then roll away o'er the Hertfordshire gravel, 
If you'll hear all my Song, &c. 

10 

We're now got to London, so great in renown, 
Of England itself, the great Capital Town ; 
In Middlesex standing with Westminster too, 
Embracing each other as Children should do. 
If you'll hear all my song, &c. 

11 

Thro* the County of Surrey we'll now take our ride, 
Thro* Kent down to Dover, and there we'll abide ; 
Tho* out of our country we may not advance, 
We mill have a peep at the country of France. 
If you'll hear all my song, &c. 



129 



12 

To the shores of Sussex we next will repair, 
The Forests of Hants, and Berks 1 pastures so fair ; 
The broad downs of Wiltshire we'll gallop along, 
Nor Stonehenge, nor Sarum omit in our song. 

If you'll hear all my song, &c. 

13 

In Dorset and Somerset we'll tarry awhile, 
Their beautiful coasts all the time will beguile ; 
And Devonshire too, so mild and so bold, 
So fam'd for its vallies and worthies of old. 

If you'll hear all my song, &c. 

14 

To conclude, and to make an end of [the Land, 
We'll make at the Land's-end of Cornwall a stand ; 
And since that in every place you have been, 
You'll remember, I hope, the things you have seen. 

CHORUS. 

As you've heard all my song, 

And you thought it not long, 

You shall travel to Wales in its turn. 



THE TOUR OF WALES. 



The Country of Wales has twelve Counties to name, 
Six Northern, six Southern, in number the same ; 
On three sides you will find it wash'd by the main, 
And the fourth bounded close by England's fair plain. 



CHORUS. 



If you'll hear all my song, 

And it shall not be long, 

We'll visit them all in their turn. 



130 



The County of Flint, stands the first in onr tale, 
With its castle ; and next the beautiful vale 
Of Denbighshire ; known to each man of good taste, 
Who tours not (as some) thro' the country in haste. 

. If you'll hear all my song, &c. 

3 

We'll ask for a Guide, and to Snowdon we'll go, 
And look on the Map, which is spread out below ; 
The birth place of Edward the Second we'll seek, 
We'll see every thing, tho' we tarry a week. 

If you'll hear all my song, &c. 



We can't leave Carnarvonshire yet, but we'll wait, 
The Quarries to see, ere we pass Menai Strait, 
Through the grand Iron Tube to Anglesey Isle, 
Whose Mines, Bays, and Beauties shall keep us awhile. 

If you'll hear all my song, &c. 



But as we return ; we will surely repair 
To that beaut' ous Bridge, which hangs in the air ; 
View the Tubular Bridge, for thus we shall see 
They differ in make, but in merit agree. 

If you'll hear all my song, &c*. 

6 

And next Merioneth, its hills crown'd with wood, 
Where the water-falls pour along as a flood : 
With Ffestiniog* 8 vale, when seen you will say, 
You may live there a year, and think it a day. 

If you'll hear all my song, &c. 

7 

Then Montgomery stands next ; now five we have past, 
Of North Wales, the County the sixth, and the last ; 
The mountains are neither much wooded, nor steep, 
Yet its hills are adorn' d with herbage and sheep. 

If you'll hear all my song, &c. 



181 

• 8 

The County of Radnor shall keep us a day, 
We'll Cardigan see, and go down to its Bay ; 
Next Pembroke we'll visit, which justly may boast, 
St. David's Cathedral, and Milford's fair Coast. 
If you'll hear all my song, &c. 

9 

Carmarthen we'll visit, we must without fail, 
So fam'd for its rich and beautiful vale ; 
Glamorgan we'll visit, which ever was fam'd, 
As the Garden of Wales, as once it was nam'cL 

If you'll hear all my song, &c. 

10 

Last to Brecon we'll go, for who would pass by, 
Nor linger a time on the Banks of the Wye ? 
Then here we will stay ; we've no more to rehearse, 
Then farewell to you, and farewell to my Verse. 

CHORUS. 

So you've heard all my song, 

And although 't was not long, 

You have seen every place in its turn. 



We make the following extract from a lecture delivered 
by Dean Cotton, at the Bangor Sailors Christian Institute, 
established in the year i860, in which the Dean took a great 
interest. 

I proceed now in tracing out the progress of education. Encourage- 
ment was given more and more in every succeeding age to instruction 
in reading and the circulation of the word of God. It must be 
remarked however that at the early period of 1698, when the S.P. C. K. 
was established a great stimulus was given to education. This 
Society now circulates annually upwards of six millions of books of a 
religious and moral character, and the Diocesan committee founded 
at Bangor circulates no less in every year than 1400 copies of Bibles, 
Testaments, Prayer Books, Books of Devotion, SchoolBooks, Tracts, &c. 



182 

In the year 1804, the Bible Society was formed which circulates 
nearly forty thousand copies of the scriptures annually. The 
National Society formed in the year 1811, established to promote the 
religious and moral education of the children of the poor in the principles 
of the established church. This society effected this by making grants 
towards erection of the Schools in every part of the kingdom, "That the 
national religion should be made the foundation of national education," 
was the basis on which the society was formed, and to a steady attach- 
ment to this principle are mainly due those results which may now 
be thankfully recorded. Boards of Education have been formed in 
almost every Diocese ; nearly 12,000 schools, containing 1,100,000 
scholars are in union with the society ; assistance has been given 
towards the building of 9122 school-rooms and 2138 teachers 
residences, the erection of 23 training schools has been secured, a large 
body of trained teachers has been sent forth, (no less than 8761 
having been supplied from the Society's own Institutions,) numerous 
schools have been organized ; the work of Diocesan Inspection has 
been encouraged. For these various purposes the society has 
distributed three quarter of a million of money, and the result secured 
by that distribution is itself a matter of deep thankfulness. Of this 
sum, the Diocese of Bangor alone has received £4337. But it is a 
yet higher cause for rejoicing that the labours of the society have 
been abundantly blessed in awakening the public mind to the claims 
of the great cause for which it was instituted, and that there now 
exists an overwhelming preponderance of opinion in favour both of 
its principles and its objects. Parliament has expressed its sense of 
the duty of promoting national education, and has uniformly 
declined to sanction any plan of general education in this country, 
which does not embody religious teaching. Attempts have been 
vainly made to introduce some scheme which shall merge into one 
common indefinite system all instruction in spiritual truth. The 
committee believe it to be a most important part of the work of the 
society, to watch such attempts, and to arouse the members of the 
Church of England, to resist any encroachment on that teaching which 
is provided in Holy Scripture and the Book of Common Prayer. 
Grants have been made since last audit amounting to £3867 by the 
aid of which 176 school -rooms affording accommodation to 20,278 
scholars, and of 80 Teacher's residences have been secured. The 
City of Bangor is infinitely indebted to this society for the liberal 
grant of £155 made towards the erection of our National School built 
in the year 1821. This room has been of inestimable advantage to 
this place, considered as it respects its primary purpose, no lflwtha* 



183 

I children have been admitted into it during the period of 40 
8. The young perso:is so educated of both sexes have given great 
faction to the promoters of this establishment by the manner in 
h they have conducted themselves in life. The greater part are 
keeping establishments on their own account, or tilling stations 
aponsibility in which they have gained great credit to themselves 
given satisfaction to their employers, of these many are enjoining 
lies varying from £.~>0 to £150 per annum. This room so aided 
he National Society has so far been beneficial to this place and 
bbourhood, but it has been available for abnost every other 
>ose beside that of education. It has been employed as a church, 
place for the use of religious, benevolent and scientific societies, 
l their annual meetings ; of these no less in number than 20 have 
accommodated ; coiuerLs and lectures have been held in it. It 
been employed as a refreshment room, a room for Friendly 
sties, children and auult clubs ; Horticultural, Agricultural and 
laeological Societies have held their meetings in it. It lias been 
loyed at the Elections as the hustings, and during the stay of the 
an in this neighbour] lood it was used as a barracks for her 
iers. It has now probably served its generation, and will be 
rseded in respect to the secular purposes to which it has been 
•opriated by a superior room, with which the place will be 
mmodated through the munificence of Colonel Pennant.* Since 
astablishment of the National Society, British Schools have been 
ied, and Government through the medium of the Council of 
cation has afforded encouragement by Grants of money to Schools 
ranection with the Council. It appears from well authenticated 
iments that the year 1818, when the population amounted to 11 £ 
ons, the children educated in this nation in public charity 
ols of day scholars amounted to 074,883, and on Sunday 477,255. 
333, the population was 18 millions, day scholars were 2,144,378, 
snnday scholars 2,407,642. As we have no information of the 
ber of scholars at the last census in 1861, I can give no state- 
ts as to the number of scholars or the proportion between Day 
Sunday attendance, but it is highly satisfactory that I am able to 

Tp to the year 18G9, seven years after the death of Dean Cotton, this room 
med to he used for educational purposes, bat owing to its being in a dilapidated 
tion, and surrounded by unhealthy premises, Government threatened the with- 
d of their annual grant, unless now buildings on a new site wore erected; the 
ihool was consequently sold, and is now replaced by a terrace of houses. In the 
i year, through the exertions of the Reverend John Prycc, M.A., Vicar of Bangor, 
ind spacious National School-rooms were opened in Garth Road, at a cost of 
i 418000, the foundation stone of which was laid by Lady Penrhyn on the 18th 
iary, 1868, and the land given by Lord Penrhyn, supplemented by a, donation ol 
towards the building fund. 



184 

remark that the increase of the number of scholars has borne vastly 
more than a proportion to the increase of propulation. It 
will be seen also, and will contribute to our satisfaction that 
Sunday Scholars have increased in a greater proportion to the 
number of Day Scholars. It will appear that in the year 1857, not 
less than 2k millions of adults and children in our Sunday Schools 
were enabled in different degrees to read the Holy Scriptures. This 
circumstance as it refers to Sunday Schools forms a subject of great 
satisfaction, inasmuch as the instruction on Sundays must be one 
of an entirely religious and moral character unmixed with secular 
matter. It affords also additional satisfaction that this instruction is 
carried on by persons who are in heart and soul entirely devoted to 
the work. They who are appointed masters of our week day School 
may consist of some men who are conscientiously disposed to bring 
their children up in the nurture and admonition of the Lord, butthil 
may not be the case with respect to them all. These men undertake 
the work for a remuneration, and they may undertake it loving their 
dues better than their duties Some may be hirelings who care not 
for the flock. But it is not so with respect to Sunday School teacher*, 
they undertake the work hoping for nothing again but the spiritual 
welfare of the children. They are not hirelings they care for the flock, 
and if not ready to lay down, are ready to give their lives for the flock, 
and thus it has ever been found that the best Biblical teachersof onrD*/ 
Schools are those who have been voluntary teachers of Sunday School** 
It is fully allowed that the Sunday School is the very best School for 
the formation of masters of Day Schools. The reason of this » 
evident. These persons undertake the work of teaching for the love 
which they have for the work, and the regard which they feel for the 
best interest of their children. This regard for the children natuiw 
begets a love of the children for them. Thus a mutual attachinen* 
is formed which produces the happiest results, neither the work <* 
teaching nor learning is burdensome to either party, and as the wiahe* 
of both are combined with the work — the work is well dono by both. 
One word more concerning the National Society. The system of thi* 
Society combines both daily and Sunday instruction. It has afforded 
to the lower orders all that is necessary to fit them for their station* 
in this life, and to prepare them for a better, according to Nehemi** 
this system has taught them to " read in the book of the law of GfcH* 
distinctly, to give the sense, and has caused them to understand *D* 
reading ;" and also to be conversant in Scriptural Geography, ^ 
writing, and arithmetic. Systems of more modern date and science «* 
less value as it respects these young persons, somewhat to the excloi* 011 



185 

e weightier matters of the law, have lately been introduced into 
Schools. An inspector of the Council of Education gave me the 
wing idea which I have thus versified. 

Away with graphy, logy, metry, science for the head, 

And give me wholesome food to feed the mind and heart instead. 

id now to close my remarks before I give some anecdotes of the 

of teaching in the olden times by the worn out, shrunk, and 
ered pedagogues and daft old dames of which I gave a hint 
e ; let me conclude by congratulating every seaman, whether 
ait or absent, upon the ability which they now possess of reading 

books as afford them necessary information for their state of 
and the duty which it involves ; but above all that they possess 
can read, mark, learn and inwardly digest the contents of the 

of life, which can steer thro' the waves of this troublesome 
1, no man forbidding them. The ability I say to study this 

whether in sickness or in health, by land or by sea, especially 
1 engaged on the sea, or in distant lands when separated from 

friends and their home. When they take up their Bible and 
: of Prayer, and refer themselves to their God and Saviour who 
lis power can raise the storm or make a great calm, so that the 
ffl thereof are still, tho', carried up to heaven and down again to 
deep, and their soul melteth away because of the trouble, they 
feel that there best and surest friend is ever with them, and will 
g them to the haven where they would be. 



186 



CHAPTER X. 

The Dean's Blindness — Activity — "A Modest-wish " — Illness and 
Death— The Funeral— Extract from ' North Wales Chronicle '— 
Extract from * Chester Courant ' — Extract from Funeral Sermon- 
Inscription on tombstone and tablet, 

IN the Dean's younger days his sight had never been good, 
and as he grew older, it gradually failed him, until about the 
age of seventy, he became almost blind. 

Notwithstanding this most trying affliction, and his 
advanced age, his intellect and activity continued quite 
unimpared. To the very last he took the liveliest and most 
active interest in all religious and social matters, and was 
punctual to fulfil all his engagements. He always devoted 
Saturday to prepare for Sunday duties, in committing to 
memory either the Epistle, Gospel, Lessons, or Sermon, or 
whatever part he chose to take in Divine Service. He was 
present, almost invariably, at Llanllechyd Church on the first 
Sunday of every month to administer the Holy Communion 
to the parishioners ; and at Bangor, he would willingly and 
cheerfully, co-operate with and assist the Vicars in their 
parochial work. 

Within a few weeks of his death he was as active as ever 
in examining schools, and he might be seen almost every 
day, led by some friend, walking the streets of Bangor 
visiting the sick and dying, " the fatherless and widows in 
their affliction," and administering to the spiritual and 
temporal wants of the poor and needy among whom he 
resided, " as it is written, he hath dispersed abroad, he 
hath given to the poor ; his righteousness remaineth for ever. 
No one seeking relief at the D&anery House door was 
ever sent away empty, and if sometimes, owing to this 
indiscriminate giving, his charities were bestowed amiss and 
abused, he might with propriety say, like the immortal Bishop 
Wilson, " I had rather give to ten unworthy than that one 



187 

irving person should go away without relief." The Dean 
*r thought of saving money, for he would not make 
chandize of his heritage, and from first to last his activity, 
rality and almsgiving were most exemplary, for he fully 
fled almost with his dying breath, his grand motto through 
" as long as I continue to receive the wages of the 
irch, I shall continue to do the work of the Church. " 
'he following lines were composed by the Dean, which he 
racterized a9 " A modest wish," and may be taken as 
ository of his own feelings. 

" ! that I had ten thousand iron tongues 

A throat of brass and adamantine lungs ; 

My bones of marble made, in steel encased, 

Wire drawn my muscles, and whale-bone my waist ! 

My veins of gutta percha thick and tough, 

My skin of flint, and thin but thick enough ; 

Ubiquitous my body, and my mind 

Always infallible in every kind ; 

My moments, months ; my pennies turned to pounds ; 

I'd give, go, hear, pray, preach, read, run, say, sing, 

Talk, write, walk, work, beyond all bounds. 

Give me the man who will not blow away, 

Melts not in dews of night nor heat of day ; . 

Not salt, nor sugar, not a bit the thinner, 

Loving his duty better than his dinner," 

Of him (whatever his age) the proverb's just, 

" Better it is to rub out than to rust." 

Tie immediate cause of the Dean's illness, which lasted 
a short time, was a cold, caught in going on a very wet 
damp day to examine a neighbouring school, which 
lted in a very severe attack of his old complaint — 
ichitis, and on Wednesday evening, May the 28th, 
2, at half-past nine o'clock, the revered and "good Dean 
ton," breathed his last, in the 83rd year of his age, at 
Deanery House ; and on Wednesday, June 4th, his 
tal remains were deposited in the grave of his first wife 
he old churchyard, under the shadow of the Cathedral^ 



188 

over which he had presided for so many years, amidst deep 
sighs, the shedding of many tears, and every manifestation of 
the profoundest grief and respect for one of the greatest 
philanthropists that Wales has ever seen. 



THE FUNERAL, 

From the "North Wales Chronicle," 

On Wednesday last, at noon, the remains of the truly estimable 
Dean of Bangor were consigned, amidst universal manif estions of 
grief and sorrow, to their last resting place in the old churchyard, 
Bangor. 

Early on the morning of that day, the old Cathedral bell tolled 
forth in mournful peals the approaching hour of interment. AH the 
shops were closed, and business suspended, until this last solemn act 
of human kindness had been performed. Emblems of deep and 
sincere mourning were visible on all hands and in every direction; 
and although the funeral, strictly speaking, was known to be • 
private one, few seemed willing to allow the opportunity topee^ 
without doing honour to the obsequies of so good a man — one, who, in 
his personal and public character, did everything to command th0 
respect of all classes of the community. 

About 11 o'clock the members of the Bangor Sailors' Chriath* 
Institute (60 of whom were master mariners), met together, and 
formed themselves into a procession, previous to which they wert 
addressed in a feeling manner by the Rev. Samuel Roberto. He 
briefly dwelt upon the principal traits in the character of the lefe 
Dean — the vast good he had affected by his unceasing effort! on 
behalf of popular education, and the loss which all charitahll 
institutions in the neighbourhood had sustained by his death. He 
also referred to a speech of his on the occasion of the Powis Memorial, 
his long connection with the Bible Society as its chairman, his eft** 
in forming a Branch of the Shipwrecked Mariners' Society, and the 
debt of gratitude which they in particular, as members c/tf** 
Institute, owed to his revered memory. An appropriate hymn having 
been sung, they then moved slowly along High-street, headed hythi 
Rev. S. Roberts, and wended their way towards the chnrchyaA 
which they afterwards entered in the rear of the funeral cortej4 
through the lower entrance gate to the Palace and Deanery. Inthi 



-i CA 



189 

inds of the latter place, were the children of the Infant School, 
the first and second classes of the National School, whose fathers 

1 even grandfathers of some of them) were taught the first elements 

ducation, at the Schools the late Dean of Bangor had established. 

l 12 o'clock, the funeral procession was formed, and moved in 
following order from the Deanery, through the Welsh Church 

) the Cathedral : — 

the choir : 
Cantoris. Decani. 

Boys. Boys. 

Mr. Fletcher, Lay Clerk. 

Men. Men. 

Rev. Canon Vincent and Rev. James Williams, Rev. 
Purvis, Rev. D. Evans, Rev. E. Pughe, Archdeacon Jones, 
Archdeacon White, The Lord Bishop. 

PALL BEARERS. 

Rev. E. Parry. W Hev. Parry Jones. 

O 

Rev. T. E. Ellis. y Rev. W. C. Totton. 

H. Kennedy, Esq. . Dr. Richards. 

MOURNERS : 

Rev. E. Lewis, Rev. H. J. Cotton. 

F. Lear, Esq,, Rev. H. Majendie. 

J. V. H. Williams, Esq., H. B. Roberts, Esq. 

Mr. M'Intyre, Mr . Ferns. 

Mr. Foulkes, Mr. John Parry. 

he nave and aisles of the Cathedral were soon filled by a great 
iber of the inhabitants, without distinction of creed or sect, and 
mgst tjiose present, we noticed several clergymen and others, from 
»nt parts of the Diocese. As the procession entered the sacred 
ice, the well-known " Dead March in Saul," was performed with 
uisite pathos, and the Burial Service was most impressively read 
the Right Rev. the Lord Bishop, assisted by Ven. Archdeacon 
es. A portion of the Psalms appointed to be read on the occasion 
chanted by the choir, and an appropriate Anthem sung during 
offering. 

'he procession being re-formed, moved, through an immense 
30urse of spectators in the churchyard, towards the grave, in 



140 

which reposed the remains of the venerable Dean's first wife. The 
last portion of the beautiful Burial Service of the Church was also 
said by the Lord Bishop, and Archdeacon Jones, during which the 
coffin slowly, and at first almost imperceptibly, sank into its resting 
place — "that bourne from whence no traveller returneth." The 
choir then sang that solemn Anthem by Ca]cott, " I Heard a Voice 
from Heaven," after which, the friends of the deceased retired, and 
the multitude dispersed. 

Thus was the Dean of Bangor, whose life was consecrated to 
promote the good of others, and whose death was to him a sure gain, 
buried in the most profound and deserved grief. 



From tlie " Chester Courant." 

" In Chester, where the late Dean was well-known, his visits were 
always looked forward to with great delight, and there are many who 
will grieve at the thought of seeing his benevolent face no more. It 
was only recently that he had promised to deliver a lecture before 
the Chester Archaeological Society upon an antiquarian subject which 
had lately been occupying his attention. When last amongst us his 
interest in everything that was going on was as keen as ever, and 
notwithstanding his great age, there still seemed to be many yean 
of activity and usefulness in store for him. The deceased was the 
uncle of P. S. Humbertson, Esq. , the popular 'and respected member 
for this city, 

" For many years past he had suffered from an affection of the eyes, 
which finally deprived him almost entirely of sight. But when this 
grievous affliction overshadowed him, the Dean set about with 
redoubled energy, to accomplish the work that was appointed him to 
do. With an elasticity of step altogether foreign to one of hia ad- 
vanced .years, he might be seen any day and every day for the last 
quarter of a century moving about the streets of Bangor on some 
favourite mission of charity or goodwill, administering the consolation! 
appertaining to his sacred office, or dispensing with no niggard hand 
the overplus of those earthly means, with which God had been pleased 
to bless him. 

" And now, in the full fruition of his days, having diligently aid 
faithfully served his Divine Master for more than half a century, the 
hoary head has reverently bowed at that Master's call, and the soil 
of the devoted pastor has returned to the God that gave it, and to At 
enjoymentof that everlastingpeace reserved for just men made perfect" . 



141 

id an extract from a funeral sermon preached on the 
f the Dean, at Bangor Cathedral, on Sunday, June 
2, by his friend and colleague, who has since passed 
rest, the Reverend J. W. Trevor, Chancellor of the 
and Canon Residentiary of Bangor. 

reverend Canon chose for his text St. John xi. 1 1. 

friend sleepeth /' and after a few preliminary 

, he said : — 

tore, in the sanctuary of God's House, when we are contem- 
te death of a neighbour and brother, we must remember that 
Hiding on holy ground ; we must think of our own mortality 
T the event to our own spiritual improvement ; and though 
be painful, as it would be unseemly, to speak of his failings 
alas ! is without his failings) we should be reminded of our 
. thus make our tribute of regret and affection to him 
> to our own preparation to die. 

Wend sleepeth." Within the last few days it has been 
U to close the long life of our aged and venerable brother, 
of this Cathedral Church. You will see no more that well- 
rm, so familiar to all, so dear to many, of the inhabitants of 
and parish. No more will his cheerful voice, his kindly 
his innocent wit, be heard at your hearths or in our streets. 
ain will he cross the threshold to comfort the sick and 
le cottage of the poor will know him no more : his welcome 
re ceased for ever : charity and consolation must now be 
red by other hands and other lips. 

irho now hear me know better than I can tell, how, for 
1 half a century, he laboured in his vocation, as Vicar of 
h, and of late years as Dean of this Cathedral, to promote 
emporal and spiritual welfare of this town. You know how 
rare his exertions, how ardent his zeal, how unflinching his 
o undertake and pursue every scheme, however difficult, or 
romising, which had real or seeming good to recommend it. 
persevering, and, happily, who so successful, as he, in 
5 the charitable feelings, and obtaining the aid of the rich 
rful for his benevolent undertakings ? Witness your 
schools, your hospital, your clothing clubs, the restoration 
athedral : to say nothing of the private objects of his 
e to the sick and needy. 

L 



142 

But his claim to our grateful memory is not confined to the benefits 
which he conferred on this immediate neighbourhood. He took an 
active, often the foremost, part in every good work within this 
Diocese. To him we were, in great measure, indebted for the 
institution of that Society, by whose aid so many of our Parochial 
Churches have been restored, or re-built, and enlarged : and I 
believe it would be found, that to few, if any, of these, he was not a 
kind and liberal contributor for their cost. 

Of his zealous exertions in the cause of popular and religious 
education throughout the Diocese, it is well-known, and thankfully 
will be long remembered, that he took the lead and maintained his 
energy to the last, in spite at first of public prejudice and opposition, 
content with the good man's reward of an approving conscience, and 
the happiness in the end of seeing the success of his labours, and the 
establishment of a school in almost every parish and district of the 
country. 

Such are some of his claims, on public grounds, to our respect and 
gratitude, Of the excellencies of his private character it scarcely 
becomes me to speak in this place, much as might be justly said in 
his praise for your imitation. But there is one trait which I cannot 
forbear mentioning. I allude to the remarkable placability of hv 
temper. 

The undertakings in which he was engaged, (such I mean as those 
which I have mentioned, ) necessarily brought him into contact with 
men of various dispositions and opinions, and often led to discussion! 
not always carried on without undue excitement, and objections, and 
difficulties were often raised. I have myself been present on such 
occasions, nor will I presume to say that I did not sometimes commit 
the fault to which I am alluding ; but this I can confidently affirm, 
that I never heard an angry retort, or an unkind expression escape 
the lips of our venerable friend. I have been constrained by my sense 
of what was best to be done on the subject under discussion, to oppose 
his measures, or suggest amendments which he disapproved, but I 
never saw his temper ruffled for more than a moment, and the passing 
cloud was immediately dispersed by a genial smile, with one of those 
good humoured and quaint phrases which his friends knew and 
heard so often and so well. 

But, " our friend now sleepeth ;" he is gone to his rest. In a few 
days, the cold grave will be closed over his mortal remains, bat mi 
spirit is now with God who gave it, to live for ever in the mansions of 
his Father's house, with the blissful foretaste of greater glories at the 



143 

resurrection of just men made perfect. His good works on earth 
survive him, and they will long be the memorials of the virtues which 
distinguished him, and the affectionate regard which he had justly 
earned and had so long enjoyed. He sleepeth in the bosom of his 
Saviour and his (rod. Emphatically I have called him your friend. 
If to feed the hungry, to clothe the naked, to instruct the ignorant. 
to visit the fatherless and the widow in their affliction, be the duties 
and the proofs of friendship, who lias earned that name if our departed 
brother has not? If these be the memories " which blossom in the 
dust," will he be soon or be ever forgotten by the people of this town 
and neighbourhood? Will not his name ever be mentioned with 
kindness, and his human infirmities, few as they were, be buried in 
silence and oblivion. Others there have been and will be again 
endowed with greater talents ami distinguished by greater attain- 
ment in human learning, but it will be long before we sec amongst us 
again a better man ; one whose qualities of the hart will claim a 
larger share in our respect, or whose life will have been more useful 
and irreproachable. 

But though I am sure that T have not said a word of commendation 
more than our departed friend's character justly deserves, and my 
own knowledge of him during more than forty years amply justifies, I 
am reminded by the place where I stand, that enough has been said 
for human panegyric and praise ; and that there remains to be im- 
pressed upon you the great lesson which all such events as we are 
now contemplating ought to teach us with permanent influence and 
effect. 

That lesson is, in few and simple words, that we may learn so to 
number our days that we may apply our hearts unto wisdom — that 

wisdom which surely we may believe our departed friend to have 

well acquired, and is now gone to reap its "great recompense of 

reward "* — the wisdom of being prepared to die. 

Many who heard the above sermon will remember with 
what eloquence, pathos and feeling, it was delivered, and its 
thrilling effect upon the large and sorrowing congregation 
assembled in the cathedral on that occasion 

The following is the inscription on the Dean's tomb 
stone : — 



♦Hob. z. 86. 



U4 

OF 

JAMES HENRY COTTON, B.C.L., 

HE WAS 28 YEARS VICAR OF THIS PARISH, AND AFTERWARDS 

24 YEARS DEAN OF BANGOR, 

He died on the 28th day of May, 1862, 

Aged 82 Years. 



" By thine Agony and Bloody sweat, 

By thy Cross and Passion, 

By thy precious Death and Burial, 

By thy glorious Resurrection and Ascension ; 

And by the coming of the Holy Ghost, 

Good Lord deliver us," 

Some time before his death, the Dean had requested Mr. 
Foulkes, the present Sacrist of Bangor Cathedral, to see that 
these beautiful woids of the Litany of our Church, should be 
inscribed upon his tomb stone ; Mr. Foulkes was accordingly 
entrusted to draw up the above inscription. 

A brass tablet raised to the Dean's memory at Bangor 
Cathedral, bears the following inscription. 

|tt Pjemorg 

OF THE 

Very Rev. James Henry Cotton, B.C.L., 

28 YEARS VICAR OF THE PARISH OF BANGOR, AND 24. 

DEAN OF THIS CATHEDRAL, 

Having zealously and faithfully laboured in his 
Heavenly Master's Service, 

HE ENTERED INTO HIS REST 28TH MAY, 1862, 

Aged 82 Years. 



" Lord now lettest thpu thy servant depart in peaos." 



145 

CHAPTER XI. 

Dean Cotton's Personal Appearance — Character and Churchmanship — 
Bangor Eisteddfod — Two Welsh Elegies — Memorial Church — 
Restoration of Bangor Cathedral — Removal of Testimonial 
Window — Letters of Sir George Gilbert Scott in explanation. 

IN stature Dean Cotton was somewhat tall, graceful and 
well built, and was possessed of much physical energy and 
activity. His face was pale and care worn ; his forehead, 
shaded over by his long silvery- white hair, high and receding ; 
his eyelids were partially closed ; his nose Roman in form \ 
the cheeks sunken, and the lips thick ; and his face bore a 
very reverend and genial countenance, and bespoke much 
kindness. 

The distinguishing feature in the Dean's character was his 
great desire to "do good to all men," hence he was 
significantly called " Good Dean Cotton." It is true 
that he has left no valuable or lasting contributions to 
literature to perpetuate his memoiy, and his speeches — 
some of which were, probably, delivered at the impulse of 
the moment, and never intended for publication — are in- 
teresting, not so much for their intrinsic merit, as their 
connection with important epochs in the history of the city, 
parish, and diocese of Bangor, and although it may be that 
the late Dean was not distinguished for intellectual brilliancy ; 
nevertheless, his noble disposition, vivid imagination, quaint 
sayings, and his ardent aspirations after " whatsoever things 
are true, honest, just, pure, lovely, and of good report " — 
rendered him one of the most conspicuous and useful 
clergyman in the principality. 

An intimate friend of the late Dean, writes : — 

" The Dean's life had but one aspect — his heart was wrapped up in 
his master's service — lie was always thinking of it — always engaged 
in his master's work — his whole deportment as well as his conversation 
showed whose servant he was — he could not disguise himself. He 
i, on one occasion my guest from the Saturday to the Monday, and 



146 

had on the Sunday an attack, to which he was latterly subject, of 
lymphatic pressure on the brain. After the Dean's visit one of my 
servants remarked, (and servants are keen observers of character,) 
"It does not matter, Sir, to that old gentlemen when he dies — he's 
ready for heaven." Emphasizing the words "when" and he's." 

He had been invited to spend a few days at Abbey, 

including a Sunday. He wrote to me to request that I would invite 
him to my house, so that he might spend the Sunday there. Accord- 
ingly I did so, and went for him on the Saturday. Some visitors 
called, and it was late in the day before we could leave the Abbey. 
Lady said, *'You must remain here now," and pressed the 

Dean very much to stay ; till, at length he said, " No, I do not like 
Sunday* in great houses. So I brought him home with me." 

Dean Cotton was deeply attached to the Church of 
England, and her liturgy, rites and ceremonies were all most 
dear to him ; and although he was tolerant towards Dissenters, 
and would willingly work with them hand in hand to accom- 
plish any object which had the public good for its aim, and 
which did not involve the sacrifice of principle on his part. 
His principals in his own words were, "civility without servility; 
conciliation without compromise." Yet his tastes and prin- 
ciples made him recoil from dissent as a system, and he 
never failed to express those sentiments, whenever an 
opportunity afforded itself, either in the pulpit, on the plat- 
form, or in private conversation ; notwithstanding this, there 
were but few men who had won the affection and attachment 
of so many loving admirers among those who differed from 
him in religious points, among whom may be mentioned the late 
Reverend Arthur Jones, D.D., of Bangor, afterwards of 
Chester, to whom the Dean showed much personal kindnessi 
and the late Reverend John Phillips, Principal of the Bangor 
Normal College, with whom the Dean came in contact 
frequently as chairman of the Bangor Auxiliary Branch of the 
British and Foreign Bible Society, and other public gatherings. 
The Reverend John Evans, Vicar of Whixall, Whitchurch,- 
an intimate friend of the Dean, writes : — 

" A little before his death he was anxious to print some valuable 
remarks as a guide to young clergymen in reading the services of tbt 



147 

Ghnrch — interspersed with anecdotes illustrating the effects of careless 
reading. Owing to his defective sight, these remarks were dictated 
to an amanuensis, generally one of the National School boys, 
consequently the whole was a sadly confused map. At his request I 
reduced all into a readable form and sent it to him. We were to 
meet and revise my "digest, only a few weeks before his death. 
I have still the rough material by me." 

In another letter Mr. Evans says : — 

•' If I might advise, you will not delay your publication for the 
sake of adding, in an appendix, the good old Dean's remarks on 
reading the Liturgy, &c. I have just looked over the M.S. in my pos- 
session and find that there are some 204 pages folio, foolscap size, 
besides some loose sheets. I do not think that justice could be done 
seeing the compression necessary to fit the remarks for an appendix, 
As I said, the remarks are illustrated by anecdotes — my difficulty in 
the " digest," of the essay was to arrange these anecdotes in 
their proper places in the text, was not to give too many. The 
good Dean was so enamoured of his anecdotes that he was 
unwilling to omit one ! Nevertheless, I ventured, in drawing up 
the paper to give a selection, and purposed to insert the others in an 
appendix, and this would have been the grand point to be debated 
had we been permitted to meet. The Dean wished me to publish the 
work as mine, which suggestion I could not of course listen to. The 
rough M.S. I accepted, but only to use as faithfully as I could in the 

Dean's behalf and mine I will examine the M.S. and 

see what can be made of it, and should recommend a separate 
publication. The anecdotes alone would produce a sale." 

At a local Eisteddfod held at Bangor, on the 21st day of 
July, 1863, a prize of three guineas and a silver medal was 
offered for the best elegy on the Dean. Twenty one com- 
positions were received. The first prize was awarded to Robyn 
Wyn, and the second best was the composition of the late 
Reverend John Hughes, Vicar of Pontlottyn, Glamorgan. 
The two elegies difler in their ideas, and we insert them here 
for the benefit of our Welsh readers. 

Mae'n Deon hybarchus yn awr wedi marw, 
Fe roddwyd ein Deon dan briddell y bedd 

Mae'r galon yn gwaedu yn adsain ei enw, 
O'r hawddgar bendefig ! urddasol ei wedd 



148 

Tyr'd Awen alarus, tywallt dy ddagrau, 

Ni raid iti wrido am wylo yn awr, 
Ni roddwyd dan leni yr oerion briddellau 

Un gerid'n fwy anwyl, un berchid mor fawr. 

Ob ydoedd yn estron o ran ei waedoliaeth, 

Ein bryniau a garodd yn raoreu ei oed ; 
Ei enaid a hudwyd gan swynion ein talaeth, 

'Rwy'n caru'r llanerchau a sathrodd ei droed ; 
Hen ddinas Oaerlleon ddyrchafa ei chwynion, 

Mae dagrau y Cymro yn gymysg a'r Sate 
Wrth gofio rhinweddau dysgleirwych y Dbon ; 

Bu'n gyfaill i ryddid, bu'n elyn i drais. 

Mae talu ymweliad ag argel ei wely 

Yn agor cuddf eddau y fynwes yn awr ; 
Wei dyma orweddfan y g#r y mae Cymru 

Mewn hiraeth o'i golli, ei galar sydd fawr : 
Ar ddydd ei gynhebrwng, olwynion masnachaeth 

Gydsaf odd yn llonydd, yn deyrnged o barch, 
Yn offrwm gwladgarol i'w bur goffadwriaeth 

'Roedd gwreng a boneddig yn dylyn ei arch. 

Y newydd o'i farw darawodd ein dinas 

A iasau llesmeiriol o ofid a braw ; 
Trwm alar a lanwodd y bwthyn a'r palas, 

A'r gweithiwr a safai a'i bwys ar ei raw ; 
Pob sect ac aethyddiaeth gyd-deimlant ei golli, 

Galaru amdano wna'r ieuanc a'r hen ; 
Trom ergyd anaele i gymoedd Eryri 

Fu dydd claddedigaeth fythgofus y Dean. 

Bu'n anrheg fendithiol o ddwylaw Rhagluniaeth 

I'n dinas Esgobol, pwy ddy wed ei gwerth ? 
A'i fywyd llafurus fu'n ddirfawr wasanaeth 

I buro ei moesau, i grefydd bu'n nerth ; 
Bu'n fflangell ar bechod ar hyd ei faith yrfa, 

Bu'n gyfaill moesoldeb, pob rhinwedd a bri, 
Bu'n darian i rinwedd, bu'n elyn pob traha, 

Ei glust oedd ago red i'r tlawd dan ei gri. 

I'r achos na wyddai f e chwiliai ein harwr, 
Oedd Job mewn haelioni, i'n dinas bu'n dad ; 



149 



Oedd frawd i'r pendefig, oedd gyfaill y gwanwr, 
Bu'n fendith annhraethol i gylchoedd ein gwlad : 

" CymdeitJias y Beiblau " sy'n wylo o'i golli, 
Fe gwympodd ei Lly wydd, pwy'leinw ei le ? 

Ar ddydd ei gwyl mwyach, pwy, pwy geir i'n Uoni 
Mor llawn ei arabedd, mor selog ag e' ? 

Ein " Heglwys Gadeiriol" yn'awr amddifadwyd 

O'r aelod ffyddlonaf, a'r swyddog o fri, 
O'r Deon hybarchaf yn Mangor a welwyd, 

Pa ryfedd ei gweled yn wylo yn lli* ? 
Tyr'd A wen alarus, cusana'i droedolion, 

Mor ddystaw, llafurus, y llanwai ei swydd ! 
Rhag ofn ei olygon y ciliai gw^r trawsion, 

Yr annuw ni safai, gan farw yn ei wydd. 

O heol i heol bu'n ymlid pechodau, 

Oedd halen santeiddiol, yn puro pob lie, 
Bu'n angeu a dinystr i lu o hen gampau 

Fu'n warthrudd a staen ar gymeriad ein tre' ; 
Halogwyr y Sabboth, gloddestwyr, a meddwon, 

Geryddai yn llym, adferodd i'w fri 
Y dydd a gysegrwyd gan Arglwydd Dduw Seion, 

O'i lafur mwynhau y tawelwch gawn ni. 

Oedd gyfaill i addysg, pwy, pwy "all amgyffred 

Fath fendith ardderchog fu ef yn ei ddydd ? 
A phwy a geir ini all adrodd y golled 

I lu o dylodion am dano ef sydd ? 
Na wrided y gw^r a fu'n derbyn o'i gedion, 

Hyfrydwch ei enaid oedd cwmni y plant ; 
Gwnaed llu yn foneddwyr drwy haeledd ein Deon, 

u Yn gwneuthur daioni " y byddai y sant. 

Rhown dro i'r ysgoldy am unwaith i'w wrando 

Yn holi ac ateb f el plentyn ei hun ; 
Pwy gaid yn gymhwysach na'r Deon mwyn jmo ? 

Ymryson i'w ateb y byddai pob un ; 
Fe wyddai e'r llwybr i f eddwl y plentyn, 

Astudiodd athroniaeth ieuenctid ein gwlad, 
Ac arnynt chwareuai fel cerddor a'r delyn, 

Ein Deon gyf rifidjyn athraw a thad. 



150 

Ysgolion y wlad alarant o'i golli, 

Yn iach iddynt mwyach ei wel'd yn eu mysg ; 
Yn iach am ymweliad ar ddydd mawr yr holi, 

Yn iach iddynt dderbyn o'i gynghor a'i ddysg ; 
Yn iach i Eryri am noddwr y tlodion, 

Hoff gyfaill y weddw alarus a'r plant ; 
Wei, wylwch am dano, fu'n derbyn o'i gedion, 

Yr Eglwys a wyla am golli y sant. 

Ei enaid wefreidddiwyd yn adsain cerddoriaeth, 

Mor f elus y pynciai ef glodydd yr I6r, 
Ei lais cryf a chwyddai ar danau tdnyddiaeth, 

Oedd organ ei hunan yn nghanol y cdr : 
Ar dabyrddau fy nghlyw mae'i lais eto'n arcs, 

Mor gryf yn ei henaint, mor dyner a mwyn ! 
Ei gan ydoedd lawn o hudoliaeth yr eos, 

Yn orllawn o geinion cerddoriaeth a'i swyn. 

Ond gwag yw'r areithfa — bu farw'r pregethwr, 
Ein Heglwys a gollodd y ffyddlon gynghorwr ; 
Mor ddiwyd y daliodd hyd ddyddiau penllwydni, 
Yn nghanol ei wendid, ei lesgedd, a't ddellni ! 
Ei gof oedd yn fywiog, a'i sel oedd yn danbaid, 
Ac " achos yr Arglwydd " wresogai ei enaid ; 
Yn y gwaith y byddai ei fyfyrdod ef beunydd, 
Nis gallai yn unman ddim aros yn llonydd. 

Mae mainc yr Ynadon yn wag am ei golli, 
Symudwyd cynghorwr addfwynaf o honi ; 
Mae'r dagrau yn gwlychu aelwydydd y tlodion 
Am golli eu noddwr a'u cyfaill mwyn, fiyddlon ; 
Yn gwisgo'i galarwisg mae'r Eglwys Gadeiriol, 
Am Fugail, a Deon, ac Aelod rhinweddoL 

Tra ni yn galaru, mae ef yn molianu 
Tuhwnt i'r wahanlen, yn nghwmni yr Iesu ; 
Fe groesodd yr anial, cyraeddodd fro Seion, 
Mae'n chwareu y delyn, mae'n gwisgo y goron ? 
Sych ymaith dy ddagrau, nac wyla, O Eglwys, 
Cyraeddodd ein Deon hardd " ddinm paradwys." 

O Dduw, bydd drugarog o'i anwyl wehelyth, 
Arosed ei enw yn Nghymru'n dragyfyth ! 

Plorator. 



161 

Hen Gaerlleon ! er nad oedd 

Cotton o freninol Sch, 
Uchel arddas roddodd arnat, 

E' fu'n chwareu'n blentyn bach 
Rhwng dy furiau adfeiliedig, 

Ychwanegodd at dy fri, 
Llawer garant sain dy enw 

Am it' fagu'n Deon ni. 

Gyda chleddyf mawr yr Ysbryd 

Traethodd it' am Iesu mad, 
Gyda chleddyf dynol dysgodd 

Lu i ymladd tros eu gwlad : 
Ond pan oedd blodeuyn bywyd 

Ar ymagor, collais ef ; 
Mwy yw'n colled ni yr awrhon, 

Er bod Cotton yn y nef. 

Colli un a garai'n henwlad 

Ddarfu in' pan hunodd ef, 
Noddwr iaith a meibion Gwalia 

Sydd yr awrhon yn y nef ; 
Wyla'r cerddor am ei fyned, 

Er ei fyned idd yr wyl, 
Lie mae'n canu'n fwy ardderchog, 

Yn ngwresawgrwydd nefawl hwyl. 

Yn mhlith rhengau gwir wladgarwyr 

A dyngarwyr nid yw'n awr ; 
Ysgolaig rhagorol gwympodd 

Pan y torwyd ef i lawr : 
Un oedd ef a berfaith lanwodd 

Yn ei oes yr enw dyn, 
A grynhodd ei holl rinweddau 

Idd ei enaid mawr ei hun. 

Hael wasgarai'i w&nau tirion 

Nes y ffoai ofn y gwan, 
Ac ymdrechai'n wastad guddio 

Ei uchanaeth yn mhob man : 
Nid oddiar esgynlawr swyddawl 

Yr edrychai ef ar ddyn, 
Na, ystyriai ei gyd-ddynion 

Fel yn frodyr iddo'i hun. 



14« 

Angel pur gwarcheidwol addysg 

Sydd a thristwch ar ei rudd, 
Ac ar feddrod Cotton dduwiol 

Hir yr wyla ef yn brudd, 
A dysgyblion addysg wylant 

Foliant iddo am ei waith, 
Teimlad llawer un nis gellir 

Ei arwisgo'n iawn mewn iaith. 

Morwyr, ar wyllt donau'r eigion, 

Ar serenog noswaith oer, 
A ddarllenant eu hofif Feiblau 

Yn ngoleuni can y lloer, 
Geirwon ddwylaw sych'r dagrau 

Am eu ffrynd, nad ydyw mwy, 
Ond dych'mygant fry ei weled 

Yn hoff wenu arnynt hwy ! 

Ac yn anedd clyd y gweithiwr, 

Llawer anwyl fam a thad 
Ddysgant wersi Cotton dduwiol 

Idd eu hastud blantos mad : 
Pan fo'n pydru y rhieni, 

Plant eu plant a'u dysg un wedd T 
Cyn eu collir, llawer blwyddyn 

Lithra'n ddystaw idd ei bedd 

O ddyngarol Gristionogion, 

Ni chewch weled mwy ei bryd 
Yn dysgleiriaw pan yn dadleu 

Am " Feibl i bawb o bobl y byd :" 
Pwy deilynga'r gadair lanwyd 

Am flynyddau ganddo ef 
Sydd yn awr ar gadair euraidd, 

Yn telynu yn y nef ? 

Cynllun o weinidog ffyddlawn 

Ydoedd, tra bu yma'n byw 
Anwyl Briod, Iesu'i Brynwr, 

Garai'n nesaf at ei Dduw : 
Llamai'i galon pan y Uwyddai, 

Ar ei rhan dyrchafai'i lef, 
Yn ei bryder tros yr Eglwys 

Rhyw ail Eli ydoedd ef. 



158 

Serch ei galon lynai wrfchi, 

Ac ystyriai'n werthfawr fraint 
Cael hyrwyddo cynydd Eglwys, 

" Had yr hon yw gwaed y saint, 
Eglwys gredai a oroesai 

Chwyldroadau'r llawr i gyd, 
Ac a safai'n gadarn golofn 

Uwch dinystr erch holl bethau'r byd. 

Hen Eglwysi fu yn dyoddef 

Oesol wyntoedd blin y nen, 
A thrwy nenau'r rhai y ffrydiai 

Gwlaw a gwres yr haul uwchben, 
A adf erwyd ganddo'n llawen 

Oddiwrth eu ffaeleddau gynt, 
Fel yn awr y gallant herio 

Holl ruthriadau gwlaw a gwynt. 

! nid ffugiol ydyw'r dagrau 

Wylir amy" Deon Da," 
Er yn pydru yn y beddrod, 

Clod diragrith lluoedd ga : 
Ar ei feddfaen llawer deigryn 

Ddisgyn, er nas gwybydd ef , 
Oddiwrth lygaid fu yn syllu 

Arno'n traebhu am y nef ! 

Ger yr Eglwys a adseiniodd 

Eiriau'r galon am y groes, 
Y gorphwysa ef yn dawel 

Oddiwrth laf ur mawp ei oes : 
Yn mhriddellau'r glyn yr huna, 

A bendithion ar ei ben, 
Ar y llanerch engyl wenant, 

Wrth ymwibio trwy y nen ! 

Pan na byddo 61 adf eilion 

Byd na lleuad, haul na ser, 
Aur orielau nef y nef oedd 

A ddadseinia'i nodau per, — 
Nodau synant archangylion, 

A cnillant w§n yr Oen 
Fu yn wrthddrych serch ei galon 

Tra yn teithio byd y poen.— Diaddurn, 



154 

For many years before the Dean's death, it had been his 
most earnest wish to build a church at Upper Bangor, for 
the benefit of the increasing population, and the accom- 
modation of visitors in summer ; but it was not his Heavenly 
Master's will that he should see this great work completed. 
Prior to his death, he had succeeded in collecting about 
;£i,4oo for the building fund, towards which he was himself 
a very liberal contributor. During a visit to Liverpool, 
the late Dean made a house to house collection towards this 
projected church, and in looking over the subscription list, 
now before us, we find that in Canning Street and neighbour- 
hood he collected ^102 1 6s. od. This church, which the 
late Dean had desired so much to see completed, was 
consecrated on the seventh day of September, 1867, as a 
memorial church, under the name of " Saint James." The 
entire cost of the church, as now completed, amounted 
to nearly ^6000. The late Mrs. Price of Bryn-y-mor, 
gave ;£iooo towards the endowment, in addition to £4$° 
towards the building ; and the Bangor Diocesan Church 
Building Society ^280. 

A brass tablet placed in the porch of the above church, 
bears the following inscription : — 

A.D. 1866. 

"this church was built to 
the glory of god and to 

PERPETUATE THE REMEMBRANCE 

OF THE ENTIRINO ZEAL AND 
PIETY OF HIS FAITHFUL SERVANT 

JAMES HENRY COTTON, 

WHO DIED MAY 28TH, 1862, 
AGED 82 YEARS, 

HAVING WORKED IN HIS LORD'S VINEYARD 
FOR 28 YEARS AS VICAR OF THE PARISH OF BANGOR, 

AND AFTERWARDS FOR 24 YEARS AS 
DEAN OF THE CATHEDRAL." 



155 

In the year 1868, the Dean and Chapter undertook the 
restoration of Bangor Cathedral on a very extensive and 
elaborate scale. About ^22,000 have been already spent, 
out of which sum Lord Penrhyn contributed ,£6,135, but it 
will require some £"10,000 more before the restoration is 
complete, as the nave is untouched, and the steeple has yet 
to be built. 

During the above restoration. Dean Cotton's Testimonial 
Window, of which we have given a full account at page 85, 
was removed and replaced by another very handsome stained 
window, representing scenes from our Lord's Life — the 
gift of Lord Penrhyn. The following letters of Sir George 
Gilbert Scott, the Architect, will explain why the Dean's 
window was removed. 



31, late 20, Spring Gardens, London, S. W., 

December 7th, 1871. 

Dear Sir, — I owe you many apologies for not having answered 
your letter earlier. 

I am rejoiced to hear Lord Penrhyn's munificent offer, and I feel 
favourable to that alternative which embraces the decoration of the 
roof, &c, but in saying this I do so in the full hope and confidence 
that by some other means the present east window may be removed 
and glass of a more suitable character substituted for it. This window 
was put in during the very early days of the revival of the then 
almost lost art of painting on glass ; and, though executed with the 
best intentions, is really quite unworthy of its position, and as long 
as it remains where it is will be a very serious blemish upon the 
restored choir. Messrs. Clayton and Bell have of late been specially 
successful in producing excellent works in the style suited to this 
window Possibly some position in the nave might be formed for the 
lights of the present east window. — I remain, dear sir, your very 
faithful servant, 

Geo. Gilbert Scott. 

The Rev. Charles W. F. Jones, hon. sec. to the Restoration 
Committee. 



166 

Spring Gardens, London, S. W., 

August 3rd, 1872. 

My Lord, — In reply to your enquiry, I beg to say that I think 
that the glass from the old east window of Bangor Cathedral, will, if 
placed in the south or any window of the choir be wholly out of 
keeping both with the new glass of the window and with the general 
colouring of the choir. I would therefore strongly advise that it 
should not bo introduced there. Possibly some position may be 
found for it in the nave. At the same time there can be no doubt 
that so large a window on the sunny side will, if allowed to remain 
untempered and clear, throw such a body of light upon the inner face 
of the east window as materially to damage its effect. It would of 
course be much best that this window also should be filled with 
stained glass, though its colouring should be such as not to clash with 

but to aid that of the east window I have the honour to be, 

my Lord, your lordship's most obedient humble servant. 

Geo. Gilbert Scott. 
The Eight Hon. Lord Penrhyn. 

We should not omit to mention that a portion of the 
Dean's Testimonial Window has been placed in the nave of 
the Cathedral over the west door, prior to the re-opening of 
the Cathedral. 

Had the worthy Dean been destined to see this great 
restoration of the Cathedral, with which his whole career 
was so closely identified, during his long connection of more 
than half a century, no one would have rejoiced more at 
its completion, and no member of the Church militant 
would have re-echoed in heartier strains, those prayerful 
words of old, " Peace be within thy walls, and prosperity 
within thy palaces. For my brethren and companion's 
sakes, I will now say, Peace be within thee. Because of the 
house of the Lord our God I will seek thy good." 



167 

APPENDIX I. 

The able and interesting letters which form this Appendix 
were kindly contributed by personal friends of the late Dean, 
and will be read with double interest as emanating from those 
who knew him so well and had frequent opportunity of 
observing and judging his character. 



LETTEE A. 

The late Veey Beverend Dean Cotton, 

I had the privilege of the intimate friendship of the late 
good old Dean for a quarter of a century, and was closely 
connected with him in the cause of the education of 
the poorer classes in National Schools. He was the 
originator of these Institutions in the Diocese of Bangor. 

At the time when he commenced his work in earnest, 
there existed in the minds of many of the higher classes in 
the Diocese a strong prejudice against the education of the 
children of the poor. The Dean was the very man to 
combat and overcome this feeling. Highly connected and 
well bred as he was, with most genial manners and a fund 
of wit and good humour, he seldom failed to convince his 
opponents and very frequently won their countenance and 
support. He was possessed of unflagging zeal in the 
cause of religious education in Church schools and took 
much pains and exertion in promoting them. 

Wherever a school was to be built, opened or examined, 
he neither regarded trouble, distance or expence. He 
proffered his willing aid and ready co-operation even in the 
most out-lying parts of the Diocese. It was a favourite 
saying of his, " that prayer patience and perseverance did 
wonders, and verily, he acted according to this maxim. 
His labours were incessant, his patience most exemplary, 
and his prayers constant and unceasing. 

M 



158 

The Diocese of Bangor is as deeply indebted to him for 
his exertions in the work of education as the Diocese of 
St. Asaph is to the late Bishop Dr. T. Vovvler Short. They 
were men of different gifts but of the same spirit, they both 
proved great benefactors to Church Education in North 
Wales, and many generations yet to come will rise and call 
them blessed. I esteem it as one of the happiest circum- 
stances of my life that I enjoyed the friendship and the 
confidence of these twe excellent men. 

T. THOMAS, 
Vicar of Llanrhaiadr and Canon of Banger. 



LETTEB B. 

Llanfaelog Bectory, Anglesey, 

August 12th, 1873. 

Bev. and Deab Sir, 

Since the death of the late venerable and venerated 
Dean Cotton in 1862, it has often occurred to me that it 
was a matter of regret that no one had taken in hand to 
prepare a memoir of so worthy a clergyman, distinguished 
by so many private and public excellences, and who during 
his long career was the honoured instrument of such great 
and extensive good in the Diocese. I was therefore very 
pleased to learn that this great desideratum was at' last to 
be supplied, and that it was proposed to publish a record of 
his "Life and Speeches," &c. Though the memory of the 
good old Dean is doubtless enshrined in the esteem and 
affection of those to whom he was best known, and that no 
monument is needed to preserve in their minds a recollect- 
ion of his bright Christian character, with his many 
admirable qualities, yet some " Beminiscences " of him in 
a permanent form cannot fail to be acceptable to his 
numerous admirers as well as prove useful to those who 



159 

come after us. You accordingly deserve much credit for 
undertaking such a work, and I trust that through the aid 
of materials furnished by some of the late Dean's friends, 
together with other sources of information, you may be 
enabled to compile a volume replete with interest and 
instruction, as well as in some measure worthy of so good 
a man. 

As a native of Bangor, whose earliest and most sacred 
associations are entwined around the old Cathedral, with 
which he was so long and officially connected, first as 
Vicar, and afterwards as Dean, it was my privilege to be 
well acquainted with him. I sat long at his feet, as one 
of the guides of my youth, from whose teaching both in 
private and public, I derived many a useful lesson, and 
to whose example 1 looked up as a model for imitation in 
his pastoral and ministerial work. I can thankfully say 
that many early impressions for good, which I received 
from intercourse with him, are indelibly engraved on my 
mind, and I never knew one, whose life appeared to me 
more pure, more benevolent, and more thoroughly imbued 
with love to God and to his fellow-men. 

In his private and social relations, Dean Cotton was 
uniformly kind and genial — the life and soul of whatever 
circle he was in — and never more in his element than 
when " condescending to men of low estate," and minister- 
ing to the wants and comforts of the poor, whether young 
or old. He was a man of a truly devout spirit and of deep 
piety, but his piety was of a cheerful type, realizing the 
description given by Cowper that " true piety is cheerful 
as the day," and like the village pastor, " He allured to 
brighter worlds and led the way." I do not remember 
hearing an unkind word from him of any one, and a 
common suggestion of his, especially to young persons, 
was to accustom themselves in company to speak oi things, 
rather than persons, as a safe-guard against giving way to 



160 

censorious remarks. He possessed an almost inexhaustible 
fund of facetiousness, which found expression in a flow of 
witticisms, puns and repartees, Earely did he address 
any meeting connected with any object of charity, but that 
he interspersed his speeches with happy plays on words, 
suitable to the occasion, which put the audience in good 
humour and often in fits of laughter. I would possibly 
only travel over ground already pre-occupied by some other 
of your correspondents, if I were to cite generally such of 
his sallies. Let one out of many suffice. When once 
speaking at Carnarvon at a concert got up in connexion 
with the Bagged School, just then established there, the 
Dean observed " that having unexpectedly been called to 
address the meeting, he was so unprepared that he was 
sure he would make only a ragged speech, but hemmed in 
as he was by so many ladies, they would, he hoped, help 
him to darn it, and between them all he might expect to 
turn up some tolerable patch work." And a right good 
piece of handy- work ho did turn up too. Equally happy 
did I often find him, in private company and at public 
meetings, turn off the keen edge of bitter raillery or blunt 
the pointed shaft of controversy by some seasonable pun or 
jocular observation, e.g., that of all the many Isms of the 
day, by which Christian Unity was so unhappily marred, 
save me, said he, from the rheumatism, as the worst of 
them all." On one occasion I well remember an Oxford 
graduate of distinguished scholarship, and who had 
a strong leaning to Bomanism, staying with his pupils at 
Bangor. When spending an evening at the Deanery, he 
was strongly recommending to the Dean the perusal of a 
book marked by decided Bomanistic tendencies. The 
Dean, when pressed hard on the subject at last said, " The 
author has a squint towards Rome, has he not V % To which 
Mr. 0. replied, I would rather squint towards Home any 
day, than towards Geneva.'* The Dean instantly rejoined, 



161 

with characteristic good humour, I would rather not squint 
either way, but prefer looking straight ahead." This, besides 
happily terminating a not very pleasant subject, was, too, 
a striking illustration of the good Dean's via media views 
on the Church controversies of the day. 

As a Parochial Clergyman and Pastor, during the 25 
years he was one of the Vicars of Bangor, he was in every 
department of his clerical duties always most exemplary, 
indefatigable and devoted. Residing as he then did a short 
distance from the town, he never as he observed to me took 
a walk, as such, except on pastoral duty. He was untiring 
in visiting the sick and the poor of his charge ; and as the 
then excellent national schoolmaster — still surviving — can 
testify, he almost daily visited the parish schools, and 
invariably attended the Sunday school, stimulating the 
teachers and children by his example and precept. His 
devotional feelings seemed to be moulded in the ritual of 
the church, and whether few or many came together to the 
week day services, his whole soul seemed to be wrapped up 
in these holy exercises. Some expository lectures delivered 
by him on the Prayer Book are amongst my earliest re- 
collections, and doubtless many like myself were estab- 
lished in our attachment to the Church by his many excell- 
ent observations, ably meeting the objections of separatists 
from her communion and enforcing the arguments from 
Holy Scripture and the history in favour of her forms of 
prayer and her apostolic order and discipline. His fre- 
quent advice to young clergymen and those in course of 
preparation for the ministry — (and of this he was himself 
a model,) was to strive to pray the prayers — toraa/the 
lessons % and to deliver the commandments. 

As an instance how observant he was of the force and 
significancy of the language of the Prayer Book, I shall 
never forget how he on one occasion impressed on his 
hearers the beautifully striking gradations in the Com- 



162 

munion Service, where, as he observed, the Church teaches 
us first to pray, cleanse the thoughts of our hearts; 
when cleansed to incline them to keep the law, and when so 
inclined, that the Holy Spirit would writs all God's Laws 
in our hearts — stereotypying them there, so as to form 
part of our inner life. 

Good Vicar Cotton — verifying in his own person the 
observation that " those who have most to do find time to 
do still more," was uniformly zealous and active on behalf 
of the great religious societies of the Church, and the 
several charitable institutions of his parish. To him 
the Diocese is mainly indebted for the first formation 
of the Branch of the S. P. C. K., in 1812, established 
as it wasy&r the purpose of reducing the publishing price of the 
Parent Society, so as to bring its Bibles -, Prayer Books, and other 
publications within easier reach of the Day and Sunday 
Schools then springing up in the Diocese. He was himself 
a regular house to house collector for this and other 
societies and as a proof that charity, especially that branch 
of it grows by exercise, he was wont to say that when he 
entered on his parochial charge, he had only one annual 
collection. This he then found it . difficult to accomplish, 
but by the gradual growth of new objects, the charity of 
his parishioners grew in the same proportions, so that he 
lived to see thirteen collections in the yeaf, every one of 
which exceeded in amount the one solitary collection with 
which he first started. It was often amusing to hear him 
recount the difficulties with which he had to contend in his 
begging campaigns for a time, and how he overcame them 
by his three p.p.ps., patience, perseverance and prayer. 
Sometimes when appealing on behalf of Church Missions 
he was met by the objection that "charity begins at home," 
when these very people gave least for home objects. To 
them his ready answer was that when charity really begins 
at home, it loved, too, to roam abroad" Others sought refuge 



168 

in grumbling that there were too many collections in the 
year, but by bringing them to book and showing them the 
actual amount of their aggregate contributions, as well as 
how little their religion cost their pockets in the year, they 
became ashamed of themselves and the appeal as a rule 
eventually proved successful. 

Dean Cotton, too, was in advanc3 of his age'onmany public 
questions, and none more so than the education of the poor 
and working classes, in which department he pre-eminently 
proved himself the " poor man's friend " in this Diocese. 
Long before this important subject had taken hold of the 
public mind and come to the front, as is now happily the 
case, he more than half a century back was actively 
engaged in establishing and superintending Schools for 
Elementary Education. It was a common saying with 
him that education without religion was like placing in a 
man's hand a dangerous instrument, without giving him 
the knowledge how to use it to his own advantage. Nor 
did he confine his exertions in this direction to parishes 
with which he had official connexion, but for many years 
he travelled over the length and breath of the Diocese as 
"Unpaid Inspector;" laudably exerting himself in the 
establishment of Schools, where none existed — in the im- 
provement of the quality of the instructions and in the 
encouragement of the teachers, when there were few to 
cheer them in their uphill and often thankless work. 
Again and again did I hear him review the difficulties with 
which he had to contend, owing to the scanty support from 
the owners of property generally, arising chiefly from the 
then prevailing prejudices against the spread of education. 
The great want, too, of duly qualified and trained teachers was 
long felt by him as a grievous obstacle in his philanthropic 
efforts, many being as he used to say " like teapots, which 
could make good tea, but could not pour it :" possessing 
natural ability, but without the faculty and aptness to 



164 

impart knowledge, and still more of them* without any 
education to fit them for teaching others. Through good 
report and evil report, the good Dean, however persevered 
in the good work with such materials as were available. 
In the face of all disadvantages, he worked nobly and 
untiringly, and his mission as a pioneer in the great cause of 
popular education was beyond all praise. He was permitted, 
too, to live, to witness the removal on the one hand of 
many old fashioned prejudices against the spread of edu- 
cation, as well as a great improvement in the quality of the 
teachers on the other. Many gratifying fruits of his 
beneficent labours were realized by the multiplication of 
schools, and a growing appreciation of the advantages of 
education. Many young men under his fostering care were 
raised from the humbler walk to respectable and useful 
positions in life, some as clergymen, and others as trades- 
men, several of whom still survive a credit to themselves, 
and a blessing to society. Other educationists have in these 
more auspicious times entered into his labours, and through 
the liberal aid now extended for some years to the edu- 
cation of the working classes by the state and by the landed 
proprietors of the country generally, this great work is being 
promoted in some proportion to its vast importance, but 
the Diocese of Bangor should never forget what it owes to 
the late revered Dean Cotton, who long before the tide of 
popular education had set in, stood alone and foremost in 
the onward march. 

My almost filial admiration of good Dean Cotton will, I 
fear have carried me to too great length, and perhaps 
beyond the space you may be able to spare for my remarks, 
but I must ask your indulgence for one or two further 
observations in reference to his connexion with Church 
Building and Restoration. Here again, he rendered most 
valuable services to the Church in the Diocese. In the 
course of his travels as " Unpaid Inspector " of Schools, he 



m 

made a point of visiting periodically most of the parish 
churches throughout the Diocese, which were then, with 
rare exceptions, extremely dilapidated and comfortless. 
His spirit was stirred within him to see the houses of God 
in the land thus lying waste, for he loved their stones and 
it pitied him to see them in the dust." This led to the 
establishment of the "Diocesan Church Building Society " for 
which the Diocese is mainly indebted to him. Its formation 
was proposed by him at the visitation of Bishop Bethell, 
in 1837, and in the following year its organization was 
completed. Its good effects throughout the Diocese have 
been very considerable in the promotion of the erection of 
new churches, as well as rebuilding and repairing old ones, 
there being now comparatively few churches, which have 
not been benefited by it. During his incumbency, the 
parish church of Llanllechid and District church of Pentir 
were re-built. As far back, too, as 1826, the Cathedral of 
Bangor at that time used also as a Parish Church, being 
in a deplorable state of dilapidation and utterly unfit for 
public worship, underwent extensive reparation and re- 
fitting at a cost exceeding £5000, mainly raised through 
his exertions. We at this distance of time can hardly 
estimate the difficulties in this way of carrying out such 
an undertaking and great allowance should be made for 
any defect in architectural taste, as well as general arrange- 
ment, but all must agree that his memory is entitled to all 
honour for his painstaking efforts in providing such greatly 
improved accommodation. We have fallen upon happier 
times, when a revival of Church architecture and orna- 
mentation has become so general. Under the auspices and 
through the praise worthy exertions of Dean Vincent, we 
have been privileged to witness a far nobler restoration of 
our venerable old Cathedral, in a manner more worthy of 
its sacred purpose, as well as its historic interest, and 
carried out so far with admirable taste and beauty. 

N 



166 

Let us hope and pray that this deeply interesting event 
may prove a new and bright era in the history of our 
Cathedral, that new life from above may be infused into all 
its services, that its scriptural ritual may be carried out 
with earnestness and spirituality, and that henceforth the 
mother church may be a model to the other churches of 
the Diocese in the ever-living fire on her altar, in the fervour 
of her worship and her faithful testimony for "the truth as 
it is in Jesus." 

Yours very faithfully, 

KOBEET WILLIAMS. 



LETTEE 0. 

2, Cleveland Terrace, Swansea, 

June 25th, 1878. 

Eev. and Dear Sir, 

I am glad to find from Messrs. Nixon & Jams' circular 
that you are about to publish a memoir of the late Dean 
Cotton. Having enjoyed the privilege of his friendship for 
many years, I had frequent opportunities of hearing from 
his own mouth some of those choice examples of innocent 
wit, as well as some pithy sayings of a graver kind, which 
so eminently characterized him, and which may perhaps be 
new to most of his acquaintance. I was first brought into 
contact with him on the occasion of my ordination in 1844, 
and subsequently met him at a meeting held in the National 
School-room, Carnarvon, in 1846, for the purpose of 
establishing a Training Institution, in connection with 
the established Church for the education of young men to 
serve as teachers of National and Elementary Schools. 
At this meeting, the Dean was asked to move one of the 



167 

resolutions. On rising for the purpose, he said, " I do not 
know why the secretaries have given me this resolution to 
propose, I suppose it must he owing to the position I hold 
in the Church. But here again, I am frequently at a loss ; 
for I would have you know, gentlemen, that I am Kural 
Dean, as well as City Dean. But one thing I trust will 
never take place, and that is, for my rusticity to overcome, 
or drive away my urbanity!" Of this institution, the 
Dean was ever a warm and liberal supporter, feeling as he 
did how important a step it was towards raising the tone 
of education to train and educate fit and proper persons as 
teachers. When I subsequently become principal of this 
Institution, the worthy Dean continued to take an active 
I>art in its management, and on several occasions attended 
the harvest gatherings of schoolmasters which were held 
each summer, from 1849 to 1854, as well as the various 
committee meetings, &c. At some of these harvest 
gatherings he addressed the assembled masters, and gave 
"them the results of his own experience as a Promoter and 
** Unpaid Inspector" of Schools. His words, both from 
the cheerful tone in which they were spoken, and from the 
liappy illustrations which they afforded, particularly when 
recalling his experiences of schools and teachers during the 
earlier period of his life." When the Dean first came to 
^Bangor, he entered upon what was at that time regarded 
s,s an unusual course of procedure, namely, a crusade 
against ignorance. He made a tour of inspection through- 
out the diocese in order to ascertain the number and 
condition of its Elementary Schools. On one occasion he 
^as met by the rector of the parish, whose greeting was, 
"Well, Mr. Dean, at it again; riding your old hobby, ,, to 
^hich the ready reply was " yes, I will ride it to the death." 
•These tours of inspection were annual,- and during a long 
c °Urse of years he came into contact as might be supposed, 
^ith a great variety of teachers of all conditions and grades. 



108 

In reviewing their qualifications, he used to say that the 
male portion were invariably drawn from three classes, 
viz : " bankrupt tradesmen, fraudulent excisemen, and 
sailors or cattle drovers who had learnt a little English in 
foreign parts." While thus contrasting the former state 
of things with the present, he at the same time never 
failed to acknowledge how great an improvement had taken 
place, and how much higher a sense of duty animated and 
influenced the trained and duly educated teachers of the 
age in which we live. No one in those days made greater 
exertions to extend the blessings of education, or devoted 
a larger share of his time and means in order to improve 
its tone and enhance its efficiency, and these efforts were 
continued throughout the period of half a century, during 
which he resided in Bangor. In his preaching he aimed 
at being original, sententious, and practical. A thorough 
master of the English tongue, his choice of terms was 
always judicious and appropriate. He new the science of 
rhetoric well, and had a perfect acquaintance with the 
various figures of speech, which he delighted to illustrate 
by examples from Scripture or the Prayer Book. No one 
could fail to be impressed by the feeling and solemnity with 
which he read or repeated the collects, or passages from 
the communion service, thereby unfolding the beauty of 
their structure, or devoloping some hidden meaning, which 
had hitherto been unnoticed. He was particularly fond of 
alliterations ; one of these was the following : — " prayer, 
patience, and perseverance will inevitably prevail." Two 
things he seemed especially to dislike were want of reverence 
in the house of God, and want of courtesy in the behaviour 
of the lower orders towards each other. At one time it "WM 
the custom for the servant men, who attended the Bangor 
Cathedral, to leave before the conclusion of the sermon. 
This annoyed the Dean, and was at length put a stop to by 
the following denunciation, " It is usual for male domestics 



169 

to slip out of this Cathedral hefore the sermon is finished, 
or the blessing has been pronounced. Pampered menials, 
better fed than taught, who, under pretence of getting 
ready their master's horses and carriages, in reality slip 
into the public house, there to regale themselves until the 
angry voice of their impatient superiors recalls them to a 
sense of their forgotten duties." The effect of such a pointed 
attack may easily be imagined; in an instant every head was 
hidden under the pews, every conscience felt the reproof, 
and from that time forward no repetition of the offence 
occurred. Speaking in the want of politeness observable 
among the lower orders in the City of Bangor, he said, " a 
stalwart group of young fellows will crowd around the 
doors of the public house, and block up the entire pavement, 
while they allow their betters to walk through the gutter." 
It is well known that the Dean took great pains to acquire 
a knowledge of the Welsh language, and although his 
success, was but partial, still he greatly admired its beauties, 
and acknowledged how much more forcible and expressive 
the translation of the Scripture, was in the one language 
rather than in the other. An instance of this he found in 
2 Cor. iv. 17, where three words at the end of the verse in 
the Welsh translation seem to answer to the corresponding 
three at the beginning. It has not been my good fortune 
to hear the Dean preach in Welsh, but an instance of a 
pointed repartee is well known. When preaching at the 
re-opening of Llanllechyd Church, he took occasion to 
address a word to those who had abandoned the fold of the 
the Church for that of dissent, and after exhorting them to 
return, and assuring them that in no other community 
would they find more wholesome pasture, he said, " Y 
maent yn dyweyd bod yr eglwys yn hen. Y mae hi yn 
hen yn wir. Ond nid ydyw peth da ddim gwaeth o ran fod 
yn hen," and then with a pointed allusion to the modern 
systems which have recently sprung up amongst us, he added, 



170 

'• Ac nidydyw peth drwg ddim gwell o ran fod yn newydd." 
His memory was to the last extremely retentive ; notwith- 
standing his loss of sight in his later years, he could repeat 
the entire Church Service, Psalms included, without making 
a mistake, He was passionately fond of music, and took the 
greatest interest and pride in his choir, " all of whom," he 
used to say, " I have brought up myself." He always kept 
a score or copy of the anthems in his decanal stall, and 
would follow every note as it was sung with the closest 
attention, joining with heart and voice in each part, no 
matter whether alto, tenor, or bass, and checking with the 
utmost promptitude the slightest inaccuracy either in time 
or tune, whenever it occurred. In all his intercourse in 
society, he was invariably affable, courtious, and conciliatory. 
A rude expression, or an unkind remark never issued 
from his lips. He was in fact the embodiment of what a 
christian gentleman ought to be. His sallies of wit, and 
his innocent jokes, were lively and frequent. Among the 
many which he gave utterance to, the following are worthy 
of record. When the Bishopric of Manchester was about 
to be founded, a friend asked him if he knew who the first 
Bishop of the new see was likely to be, " Can you keep a 
secret ?" asked the Dean, " because if so, I will tell you. 
I think the Government are likely to offer it to me. Whom 
should they send but Dean Cotton to Manchester ?•' At 
the Aberffraw Eisteddfod, marquees were erected inside of 
which luncheon was spread for the bards and other visitors- 
A heavy shower of rain happened to fall, while they were 
seated at their meal ; the canvas was insufficient to keep 
out the moisture, and every one felt more or less damp and 
uncomfortable. The Dean, who was present, got up, and 
addressing the assemblage said " Ladies and Gentlemen, 
although I perceive you are all intent, still I fear some of 
you are not very content." On another occasion, when 
taking leave of some clerical friends at Ruthin! he said, 



171 

" And now as I look around upon yon charming Vale of 
Clwyd, and as I fear it may probably be for the last time, 
I feel I must, in bidding you adieu, say " Vale, Vale." At 
Llandudno on the re-opening of the Church he is reported to 
have made the following pun on the name of the worthy 
saint from whom the place is designated. " Ah ! St. 
Tudno was a wise saint ; he did know what a fine place 
this was likely hereafter to become." In fact to record all 
the witty sayings of the late Dean would fill a volume. 
Suffice that of him it may be remarked, as it was of 
Hudibras, 

" For Rhetoric, he could not ope, 

His mouth, but out there flew a trope." 

The scene at his funeral will be long remembered. The 
Cathedral and Churchyard were crowded with sympathising 
friends and mourners, Dissenters as well as Churchmen 
acknowledged if any one deserved a future and heavenly 
reward, it was he, inasmuch as there was hardly a single 
person then present, whom he had not in some way or 
other benefited. This was an unexampled tribute to his 
goodness, and of few, if any, has a similar one ever been 
uttered. May the example of his labours, and the recollect- 
ion of his memory, influence others to follow the same 
career of self-denying effort and disinterested benevolence 
that he so conspicuosly and so long adorned. 

I remain, Eev. and Dear Sir, 

Yours very faithfully, 

B. J. BINNS. 



172 

LETTER D. 

Penballt, 

20th July, 1878. 

Dear Mb. Hughes, 

You are very welcome to a few of my impressions 
of the late Dean to whom I owed much kindness, and who 
was intimately known to me from the year 1852 to the 
time of his death. Your memoir of him is sure to be read 
with interest, for his memory retains a strong hold upon 
the respect and affection of all classes in the Diocese, and 
it is seldom that a man so prominent leaves so unclouded 
a reputation, 

" The virtues of a temperate prime, 
"Bless with an age exempt from scorn or crime ; 
"An age that melts with unperceived decay, 
" And glides in modest innocence away ; 
" Whose peaceful day Benevolence endears, 
"Whose night congratulating conscience cheers ; 
" The general fav'rite as the general friend ; 
" Such age there is and who shall wish its end." 

Others beside me will remember Johnson's lines being 
quoted at a party, which the Dean had just left, and 
with what warmth they were applied to him, by those to 
whom he was best known. 

But you will forgive me if I say that the time has not 
yet arrived at which the Dean's life can be properly written. 
Much of what would be said in any attempt to relate Mb 
full history would now be a betrayal of confidence, and 
an intrusion on the privacy of others. Your book will do 
good service in preserving memories which might otherwise 
perish, but the Dean's whole life and character cannot be 
faithfully written until the present generation has passed 
away, and faded letters now treasured in privacy can be 
given to the public. 



in 

Those to whom Dean Cotton was but slightly known 
remember him chiefly by his wit and his quaint eccentri- 
cities of manner and speech. But his truest characteristic 
was his untiring energy for good. Once in pursuit of a 
benevolent object he took no rest until he had attained it. 
Private advantage and personal ease were alike sacrificed. 
He started on the instant and never flagged in the chace. 
He was a great benefactor to this Diocese, and not soon will 
his labours and journeyings be forgotten. Nor did he 
selfishly prosecute his own plans only. Wholly free from 
•personal jealously he advanced the designs of others with 
as much ardour as his own. But you asked for recollections 
and I am writing a eulogy. 

The Cotton arms contain jesses. These old implements 
of falconry, (Othello's "dear heart strings,") the Dean called 
hanks of cotton. No longer used in sport, he regarded 
them as the hanks or skeins that bound him to his benefi- 
cent undertakings. 

Born of an ancient family, highly connected, and 
accustomed to society, his frank simplicity of manners 
made him a favourite with the highest, as well as with the 
humbler classes. He is well known to have owed his 
deanery to the impression he involuntarily made on the 
Queen (then Princess) and the Duchess of Kent during their 
stay in Anglesey. Many will remember a drawing sur- 
mounted by a royal crown which was preserved in the Dean's 
study. He had been examining the Princesses' folio on 
board a yacht in the Menai Straits. " I will make a 
drawing for you," said the Princess, " what shall it be ?" 
That was left to her Highnesses* choice. '• Then I will 
draw," said she, " an old Welsh woman going to market," 
and a spirited sketch in pencil of a woman on horse 
back in long cloak, and Welsh hat, with a market basket 
was the result ; and commendably proud was the Dean of 
his prize. 



174 

His gifts to charities, and his constant hospitality not 
only prevented any saving from his income, but exhausted 
his private fortune, and he told me that on the failure of a 
savings bank of which he was a trustee, he sold out the 
last money he had in the funds to assist in making up the 
losses to the depositors. He was not alone in that calamity. 
The late Kev. Hugh Price of Friars was a large sufferer 
also, and Mrs. Price (who will always be remembered with 
affection and regret) used to relate at her table a pleasant 
story of the practical sympathy she and her husband met 
with on the occasion, from the father of the late Mr. R. M. 
Griffith. 

So completely were the Dean's private resources exhausted 
by his uncalculating liberality, that but for the munificence of 
the present Lord Penrhyn, he would at one time have been in 
some peril. The Cymro, a Welsh paper, was for many years 
printed by Messrs. Waterlow,the present Lord Mayor's firm, 
under the auspices of a committee of which Lord Penrhyn and 
the Dean were members. With a negligence not uncom- 
mon in such cases the financial interests of the paper (with 
which his Lordship had nothing to do) were allowed to 
drift into hopeless ruin. The printers selected the Dean 
as a prominent member of the committee, and sued him 
personally for a considerable sum, the cost of some years 
printing. Judgment was speedily obtained, and but for 
the prompt munificence of Lord Penrhyn, the Dean would 
have been in personal jeopardy, with the poor chance only 
of assistance from an indifferent, or an impecunious com- 
mittee. 

The Dean was an elocutionist. He read and preached 
in a bold tone, and with great emphasis. I remember to 
have heard him say that he had studied under, or profit- 
ted, by the Kembles. He drew from all quarters for his 
sermon illustrations. Herbert and Quarles were favourite 
authors, but he did not neglect Shakspere or even Butler. 



176 

He surprised his audience at the Cathedral one Sunday 
afternoon with the long and quaint colloquy from Quarles 
between Justice and the Sinner, and on another occasion 
startled some of his hearers by quoting the couplet from 
Hudibras. 

" Compound for sins they are inclined to, 
" By damning those they have no mind to. ,, 

He could not resist the vigorous wit of the satirist, and 
repeated the lines twice with great energy but out of com- 
passion for weaker brethren exchanged the two first words 
of the second line for " condemning.* ' 

He was fond of dramatic literature, and promoted every 
rational amusement. In the year 1854, a private 
society for dramatic reading aloud, was suggested to him 
on the ground that if a single intelligent reader can render 
the exercise agreeable to others, the varied voice and 
treatment of a different reader for each part, give more 
individuality and expression, and avoid the awkwardness 
of perpetually naming the characters. The Dean fell 
in with the idea at once, and a party which encountered 
much harmless and good humoured banter at the time was 
the result. We read Shakspere mostly, because every one 
has copies and the works of other dramatists cannot easily 
be got in sufficient numbers. 

The programmes of this little coterie which lasted for 
three years lie before me. Some of the members have left 
Bangor, some are in distant climes, and some have made 
that still more serious journey from which no " traveller 
returns." The Dean's name occurs as Hamlet, Catesby 
the Duke, (As you like it,) Cardinal Campeius, (Henry VIH,) 
and the Archbishop of York, (Henry IV.) Some members 
of that circle may read this page. They will say whether 
its meetings were not improving, or at least pleasant ; and 
whether the wit and geniality of the Dean did not shed over 
them a light which it would be well should more often gild 



176 

our pleasures. When he began to lose his sight, his parts 
were copied for him in large characters by one who has 
since taken that " still more serious journey," and who has 
left behind her a humbler, but a no less fragrant, memory 
perhaps than the Deans'. 

While this Society lasted it was determined to invite 
Mr. Macready, then an occasional visitor to Colwyn, 
in the hope that he would give us an evening. A 
member was deputed to invite the great tragedian and 
offer him the hospitality of the Deanery. Two letters in 
answer lie before me, dated from Sherborne House, in 1855. 
With the modesty of a truly eminent man Mr. Macready, 
writes " Whatever can tend to diffuse more widely a taste 
for the beautiful is a public benefit. It would be a great 
satisfaction to me, therefore, if I could see any likelihood 
of being able to offer you my humble co-operation in the 
efforts of your society, but I am rarely so circumstanced as 
to have the power of leaving here for long distances, and 
the chances do not appear to offer me an opportunity of 
accepting your very flattering invitation, of the courtesy of 
which I am truly sensible.'* And again, " It seems to me 
scarcely within the verge of possibility that I should be led 
within the reach of Bangor, but if an accident so unlikely 
should occur, I should be happy to make acquaintance with 
your association." No one felt the disappointment more 
than the Dean. 

His sight eventually left him entirely. But he retained 
to the last his devotion to his duty, his affection for his 
friends, and his cheerful serenity. He never omitted 
attendance and such assistance as he could give at public 
services, and long after sight had left him, he learned by 
heart the baptismal office to perform the rite for a child 
of a Mend, and his ready reply and pleasant joke never 
failed him. 



177 

He might, without presumption, have said with Milton, 

" yet, I argue not 
Against Heavens' hand or will, nor bate a jot 
Of heart or hope ; but still bear up and steer 
Right onward." 

His nights were passed in his latter years on a convertible 
bed (" a bed by night, a chest- of-drawers by day,") in his 
study, part of the present drawing room of the Deanery. 
He counted his long waking hours by feeling when no 
artificial light could aid him, the hands of his watch. There 
are few recollections more touching perhaps than that of 
the blind old Dean, as he is affectionately called, so counting 
his hours. There is another resemblance between his case 
and Milton's. Each had two daughters. Doubts have 
been entertained as to the comfort the great poet derived 
from his. There is no such doubt in the Dean's case. 
The filial devotion of his daughters (one of these again has 
taken that " serious journey,") helped to cheer and sustain 
him under his heavy affection and solaced the close of that 
long and active life to which both churchmen and dissenters 
owe so much. 

Yours very faithfully, 

H. BAEBEE. 



178 

APPENDIX II. 

During the compilation of the foregoing pages it occurred to 
the Editor, that it would not be uninteresting to add hereto 
the names of the Deans of Bangor, from the year 1162 to 
the present time. We subjoin the following \ chronological 
list, from Browne Willis' History of Bangor Cathedral down 
to the year 1720, which is the last recorded in that book, and 
for the succession of Deans from that date onwards, we are 
indebted to Mr. Breese of Portmadoc. 

A.D. 1162. Arthur de Bardset. 

A.D. 1235. Guido. 

A.D. 1286. Kyndelw. 

A.D. 1291. William. 

A.D. 1309. Anian Sais, was Dean of Bangor, in 1309, 
but the date of his appointment is unknown. He had 
previously held in succession, the Canonry of Bangor and 
Archdeaconry of Anglesey. He was consecrated Bishop of 
Bangor, on the 9th November, 1309. He died January 26th, 
1327, and was buried on the 28th of the same month in 
Bangor Cathedral, between the choir and the altar. 
He is the only Bishop of pre-reformation times who is 
mentioned as being buried in Bangor Cathedral. 

A.D. 1327-8. Adam. 

A.D. 1353-9. Elias ap Kenrio. 

A.D. 1359. Howel ap Gronow or Grono, was made 
Bishop of Bangor, in 1370. He went to Borne the following 
year, and died there, before he had been twelve months 
Bishop 

A.D. 1371. John. 

A.D. 1299. David Daron. Son of Evan ap David ap 
Griffith, a descendant of Carradoc ap Jestyn, a Prince of 

(1) Pat. 20. Hen. III. m. 6. 

(2) Keg. Cantaur. (3) Ibid. 



179 

• 

Wales. He is supposed to have assumed the name Daron 
from his native place Aberdaron. He was outlawed in the 
year 1406, for aiding the conspiracy of Owen Glyndwr 
against King Henry the IV. This conspiracy is said to 
have been contrived at Dean Daron's house at Bangor, 
this supposition is probably founded upon Shakspeare's 
Henry the IV. 

A.D. 1406. William Pollard, an Englishman, appears 
to have been thrust upon the Canons for their acceptance 
as Dean, but appears never to have been installed. He 
exchanged the Deanery of Bangor for the Vicarage of New 
Church with Henry Honore, who was instituted May 5th, 
1410, and died in 1413. 

A.D. 1413. Boger Woodhele, was instituted 9th June, 
1413. He exchanged for St. Mary's Church, Colchester, 
with John Vainfort or Vantot, who was instituted Sept. 
21st, 1416. 

A.D. 1436. Nigellus Bondeby, held the Deanery 
this year. 

A.D. 1445. John Martin, was Dean at this date. In 

A.D. 1450. Hugh Alcock. 

A.D. 1468. Hugh Morgan. Son of David ap Eees, of 
the family of Presaddfed, Anglesey. 

A.D. 1474. Nicholas Bewys. 

Bichard Kyffin. L.L.B. became Dean of Bangor in the 
year 1480. He was also Bector of Llanddwyn, in the 
County of Anglesey, where the ruins of his house, and of 
the east gable of the church still remain. The greater 
part of this parish has now been washed away by the 
encroachment of the sea, and the only inhabitants are the 
inmates of Llanddwyn lighthouse. What remains of the 
parish is incorporated with the adjoining parish of New- 
borough. Dean Kyffyn is said to have been of great 
assistance to Henry VII in sending dispatches and assisting 

(4) Reg. Chiche. 



180 

in securing his accession to the Grown, for which services 
Browne Willis supposes he obtained a grant of several lands, 
and also liberty to found and endow a certain chantry in 
the South Cross Aisle of Bangor Cathedral. This chantry 
was dedicated to S. Catherine, and endowed with the tithes 
of the parishes of Llangoed, Llaniestyn, and Llanfihangel- 
Tinsilin. Dean Kyffyn died in the year 1502, and was buried 
at the entrance to this chantry, and up to the restoration of 
1827, his grave was known as Beddy Deandu, i.e. the grave 
of the Black Dean. Over the body was a grave stone, which 
had the following mutilated inscription in the year 1720, 
when Browne Willis wrote his History of the Cathedral : 






dicta ecclesia fundavit Sacerdotem 

ad celebrandum pro anima Obiit xiii. die mensis Augusti. 

This is supposed to have been the oldest inscription 
within the Church except one. What has become of this 
tomb stone is not known, probably it was carried away as 
debris at the restoration of 1827. Browne Willis supposes 
the inscription on Dean Kyffin's tomb stone, when entire, 
to have ran thus, 

u Orate pro anima Eichardi Kyffin, hnjus ecclesia 
Cathedralis Decani qui in dicta ecclesia fundavit Cantariam 
et Sacerdotem ordniairt ad celebrandum pro anima, Obiit 
xiii. die mensis Augusti, Mcccccii. 

ElCHARD COLLEND, ALIAS COLLAND OR COWLAND, 6. T. P., 

instituted 18th September, 1508. He died in 1506. 

John Glynn was born at Heneglwys, in the County of 
Anglesey, of which parish he was afterwards Hector. He 
was elder brother to Dr. William Glynn, sometime after- 
wards Bishop of Bangor. Dean Glynn died in the month 
of August, 1534, and was buried at his own request in the 
Chancel of his Cathedral- He was succeeded by 

Bobert Evans, L.L.B., who was Bector of Llantrisaint, 
in the County of Anglesey, since the year 1526. He was 



181 

instituted as Dean of Bangor, on the 12th December, 1584. 
He afterwards held the livings of Llanengan and Aber, in 
the County of Carnarvon, of which livings, together with 
the Deanery, he was deprived in the year 1554 for being 
married. He however succeeded, through the influence of 
his great friends, in obtaining the living of Llanllechyd. 

Ehesb Powell succeeded Eobert Evans as Dean on 
the deprivation, and died in the year 1557, whereupon 

Eobert Evans became Dean a second time in the year 
1557, which he held to the time of his death in 1570. He 
was buried in Bangor Cathedral, and was succeeded by 

Eoland Thomas, L.L.D. born in Anglesey, and was 
fellow of Magdalen College, Cambridge. He became Eector 
of Llanganhafal, Dyffryn Clwyd, in 1562; Llandyfrydog, 
Anglesey, in 1569, and was instituted Dean of Bangor, on 
September 26th, 1570, upon which he resigned the above 
two livings. Dean Thomas was also Chancellor of the 
Diocese. He was a generous benefactor to Bangor, and 
he improved and settled the revenues of the Grammar 
School at Bangor. In his Will, dated January 8, 1586-7, 
he bequeaths, says Browne Willis, his body to be buried in 
Bangor Cathedral, near his predecessor Eobert Evans.* 

* By Will of 3rd January, 1586, Rowland Thomas, D.C.L., gave 
(among other bequests) as follows : — " Item I do geve andbequeth to 
the Cathedrall Churche of Bangor xx tie nobles. — (a) Item I do geve 
my house called the Dean's house to my successor, and to his successors 
forever, together with the garden and orchard lyenge at the barne. 
(b) — And I do give to the poore of the parish xls. besides breade and 
drinke. (c) — And I do geve to my God sonne Humffrey Robinson a 
couple of my best goulde rings. Item I do geve all my books of 
statutes (d) to my nephew Roland Thomas . My wyll is that three 
mourninge cloakes be made of broade cloth, one for my Curate of 
Eskyveog, one other for Sir John Leeke (or Luke,) and another for 
Sir John Martin the Usher, (e) — And also my wyll is that six mandel- 
ians (f ) of white and blacke cotten to be made and given to the size 
poorest men in the prishe." 

(a) £6 13s. 4d. 

o 



182 

Hugh Bellott, Bishop of Bangor, assumed the Deanery, 
June 22nd, 1588, and held it in commcndum until August 
26th, 1593, and on his releasing it, was conferred upon 

Hknry Rowlands, S. P. B. He was born at Mellteyrn, 
in the County of Carnarvon, of which parish he became 
Rector, in the year 1572, he was afterwards Eector of 
Launton, in Oxfordshire. In 1584, he became Prebendary 
of Penmynydd, and in 1588, Rector of Aberdaron. On the 
29th August, 1593, he was instituted to the Deanery of 
Bangor. He became Bishop of Bangor, in the year 1598. 
He purchased four bells for the Cathedral instead of those 
sold by Bishop Bulkeley. He also roofed the body of the 

(b) Was "the house called the Bean's house," on the site of 
the present Deanery, or was it "Plas Alcock," at the corner of 
Lon-y-popty ? A bam belonging to the Vicars stood formerly where 
the Vicar's garden is now, and the adjoining property is still described 
as Berllan Bach, (the little orchard,) bub the garden and orchard 
mentioned in the will would seem to have been appurtenant to '* the 
Dean's house," wherever that was. In the possession of the Revd. 
Daniel Evans is a Nuremberg counter dug from the site of the ancient 
barn in 1873, and which had doubtless been used in keeping tale of 
the tithes in kind. 

(c) To be distributed at the funeral. 

(d) Kastalls' statutes 1568, black letter (possibly one of Dean 
Thomas' volumes) are in the Chapter Library. Even at the date of 
the Will, there were no fewer than 40 printed collections of statutes, 
the earliest from the famous presses of Lettou and Machlinia, Oaxton, 
Wynkyn de Worde, Pynson and others. What typographical 
treasures may have boon comprised in "all my books of statutes !" 

(e) The Usher or second master of Friar's School. 

(f ) Mandil (fr) a cloak or mantle, Mandilion, a soldier's coat 
Here doubtless mourning suits. 

How do the "three mourning cloakes, to be made of broade 
cloth," remind us of Hamlets', "incky cloake," and "customary 
suites of solembe blacke," I quote from the Devonshire copy printed 
less than 20 years after the Dean's Will was written. 

Sir, was a title formerly bestowed on the clergy, the beneficed 
clergy as least, as now upon knights.— H.B. 



188 

Church. " There is one beam in each ceiling of the Cross- 
lies under which is writ Henry Rowlands' Episcopus, 
Bangor, 1611. This same date is under the ceiling 
of the nave, which plainly shews that a great part of the 
Church hath been repaired in Bishop Rowlands' time." 
Bishop Rowlands also founded two fellowships, at Jesus 
College, Oxford ; and in his Will gave money towards 
founding a School at Mellteyrn, the place of his birth. 
He also founded an Hospital at Bangor. We make the 
following Extract from his Will so far as it relates to this 
Hospital or Alms House as it is now called. 



Extract of Bishop Rowlands 's Will, 6r*c. 

And for settling the perpetuity and Inheritance after the 
death of my wife, of all those my Messuages, Lands, Tene- 
ments, and Hereditaments, with the Appurtenances which 
I purchased of Thomas Bold, Gentleman, situate, lying, 
and being within the township of Castellor, Perth Kyrn, 
Bryn Erryr, and Rhos Owen, in the comote of Tyndaethwy, 
and county of Anglesey, I leave power to myself to dispose 
of yet hereafter, by a codicil in my will, or also by a deed 
of free and absolute gift to good uses ; but least I be pre- 
vented by death (in majorem cautelam) then I may alter 
my mind. I do appoint, constitute, and make my well- 
beloved friends Edmund Griffith, now Dean of Bangor; 
Richard Gwynn, Archdeacon of Bangor ; Griffith Hughes, 
Chancellor of Bangor ; Arthur Williams, one of the Pre- 
bendaries of Bangor ; Hugh Lewis, one other of the said 
Prebendaries ; John Martin, Clerk, one of the Vicars of 
Bangor ; David Owen, Gent.Wm. Griffith, of Pen y Bryn, 
Gent, and John Koythy, of Bangor, Gent, my feoffees and 
devisees of trust ; and to them, out of a religious mind, I 
do hereby give, devise, and bequeath all my said Lauds, 



184 

Tenements, and Hereditaments, lying and being in Castettor, 
Perth Kym, Bryn Erryr, and Rhos Owen,vrhich I purchased 
of the said Thomas Bold as aforesaid, to have and to hold 
to them and their heirs for ever, to the intent and purpose, 
that they shall employ and bestow the profits of the same, 
to maintain and find six poor Almsmen, old and impotent, of 
honest name and fame, to attend divine service in the 
church of Bangor for ever, Wednesdays, Fridays, and 
Sundays, allowing to their maintenance 2s. a week a piece, 
to be paid by the hands of my said feoffees, by order 
amongst themselves for ever. One of the Vicars of Bangor, 
if he be found a staid trusty man, to be employed always 
therein, and further and above the said stipend of 2s. a 
piece, 6 yards of good white frieze a piece, to make them 
gowns towards winter every year. And that the said 
Lands shall remain in perpetual feoffment to that use ; 
and that the aforesaid feoffment to whom my devise 
is made as aforesaid, and their heirs, shall be feoffees and 
devisees according to the trust above rehearsed, provided 
always that after the death of some of my said feoffees or 
devisees, the rest remaining shall from time to time take 
order that there be always four at the least alive in the 
feoffment ; and that the Bishop and Dean of Bangor when- 
soever the feoffment is renewed, shall be two of the said 
feoffees to the intents and purposes aforesaid. And 
concerning these Almsmen, my will and meaning is, that 
they shall be under the government of the Bishop, Dean and 
Chapter chiefly, and by them and others of my feoffees to 
be placed and displaced when they are found culpable in 
any notorious crime, and namely, drunkenness and ~ whore- 
dom, or also found remiss and negligent in repairing to the 
Church at the time appointed. And my care is, they shall 
all be single men ! without wives, and one of them to be 
elected out of the parish of Penmynydd, if any there he 
found fit for the place and do make motion for it. And 



185 

two out of the parish of Aberdaron and Meylltyrn ; and the 
rest out of the town of Bangor, and the parish of Bangor, 
Llangristiolys and Amlwch Mon, known for their capacity 
to be religious, devout, and fearing God. Over whom, for 
God's Glory sake, I beseech and desire the Lean for the 
time being, because of his place in the church, to carry a 
hand, and to oversee that they frequent the church duly ; 
and the nomination and election of them to be in the 
greater part of my feoffees, together with the Bishop and 
Dean for the time being forever : but if the voices be equal, 
the side which the Bishop shall be of, or in his absence the 
Dean, shall nominate and appoint to any void place as 
they fall. And for a convenient house for them, I will 
take order hereafter in this my will ; but all these bequests 
to take no effect until two full years after my wife's death, 
to whom it is appointed for her 3d. And that two years' 
fruit I give to raise a rent, if needs be to discharge my 
will, or if no need be, I give one year's fruit of the same 
to my Godson, Bowland Owen, Mr. David Owen's son and 
heir, and then immediately to be employed to the use here 
set down to God's honour and glory. And further, I 
desire and pray, that the said David Owen, and his said 
son after him, may be tenants of that moiety of the said 
Lands of Perth Kyrn, Bryn Erryr, and Bhos Owen ; that 
is next to the said David Owen's house, in Humphrey 
Reynold's hands, which I suppose will be enough for him. 
And do desire, that my kinsman, John Jones, may have 
the other moiety that is next him, paying both what it is 
worth, for I would not have my Hospital shortened, by 
pleasuring of friend or kinsman whatsoever, which moiety 
is valued at 251. a-year; and so much hath been offered. 
But if the Hospital may stand, and any of the rent spared 
for the service, I am well pleased for a time, so good friends 
as they be, otherwise not. And my said feoffees, always 
with the overplus of the rent that shall be to spare, to find 



186 

the Almsmen Gowns, and to keep the house in a reparation. 
Item, I appoint that house wherein George Steel, Register, 
now dwelleth, with the Garden thereunto adjoining, for 
my poor Almsmen to be sorted at the discretion of my 
feoffees ; to whom, and to their heirs, to the use aforesaid, 
I give and bequeath the same for ever, praying them to 
prevent it from ruin, and to make it fit and strong for the 
Almsmen, with the overplus of the rent from time to time ; 
and so to set the Lands as the rents may reach to pay the 
Almsmen 2s. weekly, which is but some 30/. 12s. yearly ; 
but I have been offered for the Lands 50/. a-year, (viz. :) 
25/. for each payment, being two in all ; and therefore I 
hope there will be a good overplus for the reparation, and 
to buy them gowns yearly, and bedsteads, and flockbeds, 
and two pair of coarse sheets for each, and which I desire 
that my Executors do provide with the money they shall 
have to spare. 

Bishop Rowlands died July 6, 1616, and was buried in 
Bangor Cathedral. His monument in the Cathedral bears 
the following inscription, 

D. 0. M. 

Pie memories viri vere Reverendie Henrici Rowland, nuper 
Episcopi Bangor : qui obiit 6 Julii, A.D. 1616, Elatis 
Suce 65. 

Richabd Parry, S. T. P., succeeded Dean Rowlands, 
August 29th, 1599, and in the year 1604, he became 
Bishop of bt. Asaph. The arms of Bishop Parry were 
gules, on a bend argent a lion passant sable. He was 
appointed one of the Council of the Marches of Wales, in 
1608, and these arms with those of the see of St. Asaph 
with them, were formerly in the Council Chamber of the 
Castle at Ludlow. Bishop Parry was succeeded in the 
Deanery of Bangor, by 



187 

John Williams, S. T. P., who was instituted May 8th, 
1605. He was fellow of All Souls College, Oxford, 1597, 
and was afterwards Margaret Professor, and Principal of 
Jesus College, Oxford. He was also Hector of Llandrinio, V 
in the County of Montgomery, which Kectory has been by 
several bishops successively held in commendam with the 
see of St. Asaph, the tithes being considered as part of the 
income of the Bishoprick. Dean Williams, died September 
4th, 1613, and was buried in North St. Michael's Church, 
Oxford. 

Edkund Griffith, S. T. B. t succeeded to the Deanery. 
He was born in the year 1570, at Cefn Amlwch, in the 
County of Carnarvon. Educated at Brazenoze and Je'sus 
Colleges, Oxford. In 1599, he became Kector of Llandwrog, 
and in the following year Canon of Bangor Cathedral ; and 
in 1604, Kector of Llanbedrog, he was instituted to the 
Deanery, September 9th, 1613. He became Bishop of 
Bangor, in the year 1633. He died May 26th, 1637, and 
was buried in his own Cathedral, near Bishop Bowlands' 
grave. 

Griffith Williams, S. T. P., born atLlanrug. He was 
Kector of Llanllechyd ; Prebendary of Westminster, and 
Rector of Bennet Sherebog, London. Dean Williams was 
installed Dean of Bangor by proxy, March 28th, 1634. In 
1647, he became bishop of Ossory, in Ireland, with leave 
to hold the Deanery in commendam, which he did to the 
time of his death in the year 1672, at his house in 
Kilkenny, at the age of 84. He was buried in the tomb of 
one Nicholas Motynge, in South side of the Chancel of 
Kilkenny Cathedral, the episcopal city of the Dipcese of 
Ossory. The tomb has no inscription. 

William Lloyd, S. T. P., became Dean of Bangor, May # 
3rd, 1673. He had also been Vicar of St. Mary's, Beading ; 
Archdeacon of Merioneth, and Chaplain in ordinary to the 
Queen. He became Bishop of St. Asaph in the year 1680, 



m 

and was consecrated at Lambeth, in the October of that 
year. Dr. Lloyd was remarkably clever; he was a scholar 
of Jesus College, Oxford, at the early age of 12 years, and 
became Bachelor of Arts, when he had only just entered 
his fourteenth year. Bishop Lloyd is remarkable as being 
one of the seven Bishops of the tower. Although very 
clever, Bishop Lloyd was equally unscrupulous and very 
time serving. 

Humphrey Humphreys, S. T. P., became Dean, December 
16th, 1680, and in 1689, he became Bishop of Bangor. 

John Jones, S. T. P., became Dean in the year 1689; he 
was also Treasurer of the Cathedral, and Prebendary of 
St. Asaph. He was a native of Pentraeth, Anglesey. He 
was Rector of Llanllechyd. Dean Jones left the interest of 
£100 towards the education of poor persons in the 
parish of Bangor, and the interest of the like sum to go 
towards the maintenance of a free school in the parish of 
Llanllechyd. He also presented to the Church a large 
silver flagon inscribed "The gift of John Jones, D.D. to the 
Church of Llanllechyd, A.D. 1719,- a silver paten with the 
same inscription dated 1712, and a silver cup with the 
latter inscription and date. Dean Jones, died in the 
month of November 1727, aged 78 years. A tablet raised 
to his memory within Bangor Cathedral, is now placed 
above the south door. 

Peter Maurice was instituted as Dean of Bangor, on 
the 24th November, 1727, and was succeeded by 

Hugh Hughes, who was instituted 26th April, 1760, 
and succeeded by 

Thomas Lloyd, instituted 19th September, 1758. 

John Warren was instituted 11th November, 1798. He 
died on the 16th February, 1888. A tablet raised to his 
memory within Bangor Cathedral, in the North Aisle, 
beiars the following inscription : — 



189 



IN MEMORY OF 
THE VERY REVD. JOHN WARREN, M.A., DEAN OF BANGOR, 

AND PREBENDARY OF LONGDON IN THE CATHEDRAL 

CHURCH OF LICHFIELD, FOURTH SON OF RICHARD WARREN, 

PHYSICIAN TO HIS MAJESTY GEORGE THE IIIRD, 

HAVING RESIDED FOR MORE THAN XL. YEARS IN HIS 

DEANERY, RESPECTED AND ESTEEMED FOR THE BENEVOLENCE 

OF HIS HEARH, AND THE UPRIGHTNESS OF HIS CONDUCT, 

HE DIED ON THE XVITH OF FEBRUARY, MDCCCXXXVIII, 

AGED LXXI YEARS, AND WAS BURIED IN THIS CHURCHYARD. 



" Mark the perfect man, and behold the upright : for the end of 
that man is peace. " Psalm xxxvii. verse 37. 



James Henry Cotton, instituted 81st March, 1888. 
Died May 28th, 1862. 

James Vincent Vincent the present Dean was instituted 
in the year 1862. He was fellow of Jesus College, Oxford, 
and Proctor in Convocation ; and Hector of Llanfairfechan, 
28 years. The restoration of the Cathedral in 1868-78 
was begun under his auspices. 



LIST OF SUBSCRIBERS. 

:0: 

No. of 

Copies. 

Allen, Archdeacon John, Prees Vicarage, Salop 

Atkinson, John, Esq., Maesygroes, Bangor 

Babington, Miss, Owestry 

Bangor, The Lord Bishop of, the Palace, Bangor ... 
Bangor, Very Revd. the Dean of, the Deanery 
Banks, R., Esq., Dover Street, Higher Crumpsall Manchester 
Barber, Henry, Esq., Penrallt, Bangor 
Barker, Rev. T. J., Rectory, Thorton-le-Moor, Chester 
Barlow, Benjamin, Esq., Leek, Staffordshire 
Barlow, Miss, at Messrs. Nixon & Jarvis', Upper Bangor 
Binns, Rev. B. J., Inspector of Schools, 2 Cleveland Terrace, 

Swansea 
Brown, Mr., Diocesan Registry, Bangor 
Bowlger, Rev. J., Pennant, Llanrwst, Conway 
Bowen, Miss, Cotton Hall, Whitchurch, Shropshire ... 2 

Breese, Ed., Esq., Morfa Lodge, Portmadoc 
Catherall, Thomas, Esq., Chester 
Combermere, Lady, 43, Belgrave Square, London ... 
Combermere, Viscount, Combermere Abbey, Whitchurch, Salop 
Corbet, Mrs. V. R., River sdale, Leamington 
Corbet, Robert, St. John, Junior Conservative Club, St, 

James's, London, S. W. ... 

Cotton, Admiral, Alport House, Whitchurch, Salop 

Cotton, Revd. H. J., Dalbury, Derby ... 

Cotton, Revd. R. Lynch, D.D., Worcester College, Oxford ... 

Cotton, Lt. General, Sir Sidney. G. C. B. 

Cotton, Miss, 20 Bryanston Square, London ... ... 10 

Cotton, Mrs,, Reaseheath Hall, Nantwich, Cheshire 

Crooks, Mrs, High Street, Bangor 

Crowther, Mrs., Menai Bridge 

Curtes, Revd. George J., Coddington Rectory, Ledbury, 

Herefordshire 
Davies, Mr. David, Frondeg Terrace, Bangor 
Davies, John, Esq., 3, Friars Terrace, Bangor 



191 

No. of 
Oopie$. 

js, Miss, Bronwylfa Square, St. Asaph ... ... 2 

js, Revd. W , D D., Wesleyan Minister, Bangor 

js, Henry, Mr., Post Office, Upper Bangor 

ts, Mr. Jno., Bodfeirig Schools, Bangor 

er, F. W., Esq., Menai View Terrace 

, J. J., Esq., Bangor 

:>n, A. J., Esq., Dhoor, near Cuddapah 

shire, Dowager Marchioness of, Wakehurst Place, 

laywards Heath, London ... - 

,rds, Mr. Wm., Magistrates Clerk's Office, Bangor 

,rds, Rev. W. Christopher, Rectory, Llanfairpwll 

rds, Revd. J. R., Curate of Llanfechell, Anglesey 

Revd. J. Williams, Glasfryn, Pwllheli 

R«vd. P. C, The Rectory, Llanfairfechan ... 
s, Mrs., The Vicarage, Bangor 
3, Venerable Archdeacon, Llanllechid, Bangor 
s, Revd. J . 0., Margam Vicarage, Taibach, S. Wales 
8, Mr. Wm., Butcher, 325, High Street, Bangor 
s, Revd. Daniel, M. A., Vicarage, Bangor 
is, Revd. John, M.A., The Vicarage, Whixall, Whitchurch 
s. Revd. D. D., St. Ann's, Bangor 
s, Evan, Esq.. Gwynfryn, Bangor 
s, Mr., Bangor 
s, Mr. Hugh, at Mr. Charles Jones', Carnarvon 

Mr. Charles, Ermme Hotel 
ces, Richards, Esq., Sacrist, Bangor 
tes, Mr., Garth, Bangor 
er, Miss, Trosycanol, Bangor 
in, Mrs., 33, Crune Street, Chester 
>ry, Mrs. , 6, Glandwr Terrace, Bangor 
th, Revd. R. Wms., The Rectory, Llangadwaladr 
th, Mr. David, Schoolmaster, Capel Curig, near Llanrwst 
th, Revd. John, M A., Vicar of Llanynys, Denbighshire . . 
th, Revd. G. W., Curate, Llanfairisgaer, Bangor 
th, Miss Conway, Carreglwyd, Holyhead ... . . 

th, Mr. Wm., Henfaes, Bangor 
th, Mr. J. E., Chemist, Bangor .. 
ths, Mr. G., (Rhychwyn) Capel Curig 

J. H. L. , Esq. , Old Bangor 
lton, Mrs , Hoole House, Chester . 
son, Mrs., Plasllwyd Terrace 



192 

No. of 
Copies 

Harris, T. E., Esq., 260, High Street, Bangor 

Hartley, Mr. Lewis, Frondirion Terrace, Bangor 

Hathawaye, Thomas, Esq., C.E., The Mount, Bangor 

Heaton, Revd. Hugh Edward, Bettws Vicarage, Abergele 

Hewitt, Revd. T. Swinton, Vicarage, Leystairs, near Tenbury 

Hicks, Edmund, Esq., Supervisor, Llangefni 

Hill, Revd. Dr.. Magdalene College School, Oxford 

Hill, M.A., Re vd. John Wilbraham, Waverton Rectory, nr. Chester 

Hordern, Revd. J . , Burton Agnes Rectory, Hull 

Howell, Revd. W., Lower Chapel Vicarage, Brecon 

Hughes, Mr. Samuel, New London House, Bangor 

Hughes, Mr. John James, Herald Cymreig Office, Carnarvon . . 

Hughes, E. 0., Revd, Rectory, Llanddeiniolen 

Hughes, Revd. J., Tydweiliog, Pwllheli 

Hughes, Thomas, Esq., F.S A., The Groves, Chester 

Hughes, Revd. Thomas, Clocaenog Rectory, Ruthin 

Hughes, Revd. T. J. , Llanbedr Rectory, Ruthin 

Hughes, Revd. J., Vicar of Pontlottyn, Glanmorgan 

Hughes, Mr. Alex., 5, Dane Street, Northwich, Cheshire 

Hughes, Henry, Mr., Organist & Schoolmaster, Shrewsbury ... 

Humberston, Miss, Newton Hall, Chester 

Humberston, Philip Stapleton, Esq., Glanywern ... 

Humphreys, Revd. H. J., The Old Grange, Hinckley 

Humphreys, Mr., Seedsman, Bangor ... 

Hussey, Honble. Mrs., Llanidan, Llanfairpwll 

Ince, Mrs., Townsend Christleton, Chester 

James, Revd., J., B.D., Incumbent of St. Davids, Liverpool . . 

Jarvis, Mr. Wm., Bookseller, Bangor ... 

Jenkins, Revd. John, Glanogwen 

Jennings, Venble. Archdeacon, 18, Dean's Yard, Westminster 

J ones, Revd. S. , Llangwyf an , Anglesey 

Jones, Revd. Evan , Bryngoleu, Llanddeusant 

Jones, Mr. \V. C, Glasynfryn National School ... •• 

Jones, Mr. R. (Eidiol), National School 

Jones, Mr, Jno., Westminster Bys., Chester 

Jones, Revd. Lewis, Rectory, Dowlais, Glanmorgan 

Jones, Revd. G., Curate, Pentir, near Bangor 

Jones, Revd. D., Gelli, Llandegai, near Bangor 

Jones, Revd. D., Curate, Llanllechid, near Bangor.. 

Jones, Mr., Carnarvon Tea Company, Bangor . . . . 

Jones, Robt. Wynne, Esq. , Beaumaris , . . ... . • 



198 



Jones, Rd., Mr., Llandefalog School, Kidwelly- 
Jones, Mr. Wm. , 110, High Street, Bangor 
Jones, Revd. Henry Wynne, Vron, Llanrwst 
Jones, Mr. John, Lay Clerk, Bangor 
Jones, Mr. Thomas, Cottage, Port Penrhyn, Bangor 
Jones, Venble. Archdeacon Wynne, Triorwerth, Holyhead 
Jones, Revd. Thos., The Rectory, Llanengan 
Jones, Miss Parry, Gaerwen, Anglesey 
Jones, J., Esq., Court House, Nutley, Uckfield, Sussex 
Jones, Mr. Superintendent, Bangor 
Kenyon, Mrs. C. Orlando, Great Ness, Shrewsbury 
Lambert, Mrs., Tanygraig, Pentraeth ... 
Laurie, Andrew, Esq., Baron Hill, Beaumaris 
Lear, Canon. Bishopstone, Salisbury 
Lee, Miss, Belle Vue Cottage, Upper Bangor 
Littler, Mrs., 17. Eaton Road, Chester ... 
Lloyd, Revd. D. Lewis, Friars, Bangor... 
Lloyd, John, Esq., Old Bank, Bangor .. 
Lloyd, Revd. William, Yspytty Rectory, Llanrwst 
Lowe, G. , Esq. , North Lodge, Bunbury, Cheshire . . . 
Luck, R., Esq , Plas Llanfair, Llanfairfechan 
Lynch, Father, Bangor 

Mainwaring, Sir Harry, Peover Hall, Knutsf ord . . . 
Majendie, Miss, Speen, Newbury 
Majendie, Lewis A., Esq.. Hedingham Castle, Halstead 
Manley, H. P., Esq., Brynteg, Carnarvon 
Martin, Studlay, Esq., 177, Bedford Street, Liverpool 
Mawdesley, Miss, 27, Crane Street, Chester 
Meredith, Revd. J. L., The Vicarage, Towyn, Abergele 
Michael, Revd. H , Calvinistic Minister, Glasynfryn 
Morgan, Revd . Wm. , Llandegai 
Morgan, Mr. John, Cadnant, Menai Bridge 
Morgan, Revd. John, Rectory House, Llandudno ... 
Morgan, Revd. John, Glanogwen 
Morgan, Revd. David, Rector, Penegees 
Nixon, Benjamin Barlow, Esq., Leek, Staffordshire 
Olive, Miss, Upper Bangor ... 

Owen, Revd. H. D., D.D., Trefdraeth Rectory, Anglesey 
Owen, Mrs., Trefdraeth Rectory, Anglesey 
Owen, Miss, Trefdraeth Rectory, Anglesey 
Owen, R., Esq., B. &. B. Union, Bangor 



No. of 
Copies 



104 

No. of 
Copies. 

Owen, Revd. Henry, The Rectory, Llangefni 

Owen, Revd. W. Hicks, M A.R.D., Rhyllon, St. Asaph 

Owen, Revd. T. Cassar, Llanbedrog, Pwllheli 

Owen. John, Esq., National Provincial Bank, Holywell 

Owens, Mrs. Elizabeth, 266, Bank Place, Bangor 

Owen, R, Esq., City View, Bangor 

Parry, Mr. John. Mercer, &c, Bangor .. 

Parry, Revd. Henry, Vicarage, Llanfairisgaer, Carnarvon 

Parry, Mr. Richard, Contractor, Menai Bridge 

Payne, Lt. Colonel C.W.M., Abbey Court, CJhester 

Pearson, Miss, Little Abington, Cambridge 

Pennant, P. P., Esq., Rhual, Mold 

Pierce. Mr. David, Junr., Glasynfryn 

Pope, Mrs., Bronmenai, Garth, Bangor 

Powell, Ed. Griffith A., Esq. , Coedmawr, Carnarvon 

Price, Revd. D. Bankes, Llangelynin Rectory, Conway 

Price, Revd. H. H., Alva House, Clifton Down, Bristol 

Price, Mrs., 14, Off Green, Chester 

Price, John, Esq., Normal College, Bangor 

Prichard, Mary E., Parkfield, Birkenhead 

Priestley, C. J., Esq., Hirdrefaig, Llangefni 

Pry ce, Revd. John, Vicar of Bangor ... . . 

Pryse, Revd. James, Vicarage, Clynnog, Carnarvonshire 

Pulford, Mrs. Massie, Wrexham 

Pugh, Revd. David, A.B., Abererch 

Richardson. Mrs, The Star Hotel. Bangor 

Richards, Mr. Morgan, High Bailiff 

Richards, Mr , Post Office, Bangor 

Roberts, Revd. John, Rhiwlas 

Roberts, It. , Esq. , Postmaster, Bangor 

Roberts, Revd. Mr., Vicarage, Amlwch 

Roberts, Mr. Wm., 10, Lavan Street, Liverpool 

Roberts, Revd. David, Mostyn Vicarage, Holywell 

Roberts, Revd. David, Independant Minister 

Roberts, Revd. Samuel, Plasllwyd, Bangor 

Roberts, Mrs. , Castle Hill, Bangor 

Roberts, Miss Ellin, Anglesey House, Bangor 

Roberts, Mrs. Owen, Port Penrhyn House 

Roberts, Revd. Ellis, (Elis Wyn o Wyrfai,) Llangwm Rectory, 

Denbighshire 
Roberts, M. H. , Esq., Garnedd wen, Bangor 



■ 



i 



196 

No. of 
Copies, 

Roberts, E., Esq., H.M., Inspector of School, Bangor 
Rowlands, Mr. Wm., Wine Merchant, Bangor 
Rowlands, Revd. Daniel, M. A. , Normal College, Bangor 
Schwabe, Mrs., Glyn Garth, Bangor 
Scrivener, Mrs., 20. Bryanston Square, London 
Sidebotham, Miss, Chester ... 
Simon, John, Esq., High Street, Bangor 

Simpson, Geo. J. It., Esq., 22, Corn Exchange Chambers, Chester 
Sparrow, Captain, Glanymore, Beaumaris 
Storin, C. F., Revd., 59, Warwick Square. Pimlico, London .. 
Thomas, Canon, The Vicarage, Llanrhaiadr 
Thomas, Revd. D. W., St. Ann's, Bangor 
Thomas, Revd. David, Capel Curig. Carnarvonshire 
Thomas, Evan, Mr., 113, Carneddi Road, Bethesda 
Thomas, Revd. Owen Poole, Llaneilian Rectory, Amlwch, Anglesey 
Thomas, E. W., Esq., Professor of Music, Bangor . 
Thomas, Mrs., Menai View Terrace, Bangor 
Thomas, Revd. D. R., Cefn, St. Asaph . 
Thomas, Revd. Owen,. 16 1 Islington 
Tolomache, Wilbraham, Esq., Dorfold Hall, Nantwich 
Tomkinson, Mrs., 24, Lower Seymour Street, Portman Square 
London ... . . . . ... . • 

Turner, Sir Llewelyn, Parkia, Carnarvon 

Twendlow, Mrs., Penlewood, Market Drayton, Salop 

Twigge, George, Esq., Atlow Moat, Ashbourne 

Walker, Mrs., Hendregadredd, near Tremadoc 

Wallace, Thomas, Esq., Cefn Poeth, Llangefni 

Walwyn, Mr. J., Sheep Market, Leek, Staffordshire 

Watts, Mrs. , Henfaes, Dolgelley 

Williams, Revd. Robert, The Rectory, Llanfaelog 

Williams, Lady Sarah Hay, Rhianva, Bangor 

Wilson, Mr. Geo., Llandegai, near Bangor 

Williams, Revd. Thomas, Vicarage, Llechcynfarwy, Anglesey 

Williams, Revd. Robert, Trefdraeth 

Williams, Mr. Richard, at Mr. Birketts, Bangor 

Williams, Revd. St. George Armstrong, Rector, Uangybi 

Williams, Mr. E. P., 11, Victoria Place, Bethesda 

Williams, Mrs. Ignatius, Hendregadredd, near Tremadoc 

Williams. 0. T. , Esq., Surgeon, Bangor. . 

Williams, Miss Harriet, Wasperton House, near Warwick 

Williams, T. Peers, Esq., Craig-y-don, Bangor 



Williams, Mrs., (latu Tyd.lyu.) 33, Viuturiu, T.-rrnoo, Bangor • 
Willinioa, Mr., Thomas, Cae Derwen, Upper ItongMr 
Williama, Mr. John, National S.-l ' 

(VflliHiM, Mr, David, Tyddowi, Uinurv ' "' 

Williama, The Revd. H. G , Pwllheli 

WillJuraa, Herd. John, Brynteg Terrace, Morthyr Tydfil 

Williams. Mr. Peter, Shipwright, Mnuutaj.ii Si.ri.turu, I'aiiyur 

Williams. Mrs. Viuoant, Friars, Bangor 

Williama, Mr. D. Wynne, Garth, Bangor 

iania, K. Herbert, Esq , [I'urfauyilJ.} Meoai Bridge 
iHmB, Mr. Owen. Ttiuygi'tiig. Ptiitracth, Anglesey 
iams, (level, fi.olw.srt, l.l.'ini'.vlliii [ii-.'-'m-y. Montgomery 



!■■ mi Mr. a., ::v:,. n.. -:,--.:, ,■■■!. u. ,,,,■., .1 
J i, Mi-. . ' "'. ' 'tu Hi |i|..-. Hangar . , 

I ■ I . !.■■' I 1 11(11', 1'i.l-elliy ,, 

B ■■-. [lev ■■am.ii YVytui, Meutiiln.u 






. ffiUlUSUB, UAUft" tui:i 



/*3 



This book should bo returned to 
ibo Librarj on or bolero the last date 
stamped below. 

A fine of five vents a day is ilium-rod 
by retaining it beyond the h pee tiled 
time. 

Please return promptly.