Skip to main content

Full text of "The Four Suites For Orchestra"

See other formats


BadiMhe  Four  Suites 


wilh  I  lainc  SIkiIIlm’  (lliilc) 


SIB-6085 


SERAPHIM 


"Angets  of  the  highest  order' 


Expert  performances  In  which  one, 
finds  the  best  of  ali  possible  worldf 
:  ...  with  scholarship  scrupulous 

enough  to  satisfy  the  most  exacting 
modern  standards.  And  they 
are  rattling  good  entertainment,  too, 
T::.  just  as  they  were  intended  to  be. 

:  C,J,Luten 

in  The  American  Record  Guide 


TWO  DISCS 


Bach 

The  Four  Suites  for  Orchestra 

Yehudi 

Menuhin 

conducting  the 

Bath  Festival  Chamber 

Orchestra 


Yehudi  Menuhin’s 
Original  Recipe 
for  Recording  Bach 

I  have  been  asked  to  write  a  few 
words  on  the  four  orchestral  Suites 
of  Bach. 

For  my  own  part,  I  would  rather 
the  proof  remained  in  the  eating,  as 
in  any  case  cooks  are  expected  to 
produce  food,  and  not  words,  and 
then  the  only  words  acceptable  in  a 
cook’s  mouth  are  the  words  of  the 
recipe.  In  my  experience  these  are 
the  very  words  a  cook  will  never 
pronounce,  which  reduces  me  again 
to  preferring  the  diner’s  comment  to 
my  own.  As  for  my  recipe,  the  near¬ 
est  analogy  in  cooking  runs  thus: 

“Take  a  large  turkey,  stuff  it  with 
a  goose.  Stuff  the  goose  with  a  duck, 
stuff  the  duck  with  a  guinea-hen, 
stuff  the  guinea-hen  with  a  par¬ 
tridge,  the  partridge  with  a  pigeon, 
the  pigeon  with  a  woodcock,  the 
woodcock  with  a  sparrow;  fill  the 
sparrow  with  an  olive.  Cook  the 
whole  for  X  number  hours;  then 
throw  away  the  turkey,  and  the  goose 
and  the  duck  and  the  guinea-hen, 
and  the  partridge  and  the  pigeon 
and  the  woodcock  and  the  sparrow. 
Serve  the  olivel’ 

And  so  it  really  is. 

I  hope  the  public  will  realize  how 
very  precious  is  the  olive.  This  olive 
which,  like  the  fish  of  the  parable, 
must  feed  a  countless  multitude. 

Lest  you  have  any  worries  about  the 
many  excellent  birds,  they  were 


devoured  in  the  kitchen.  We  gorged 
ourselves  to  our  heart’s  content. 

Those  recording  sessions,  again 
speaking  for  myself,  were  feasts. 
Generations  of  cooks  have  left  such 
a  vast  choice  of  recipes. 

Sometimes  we  tried  plain,  boiled 
Bach  with  Aioli  sauce— but  there  was 
too  great  a  discrepancy  between  the 
bare  meat  and  the  rich  sauce.  Then 
there  was  Bach  a  I’orange,  served  in 
flaming  Cointreau— somehow  it 
seemed  overdramatic.  (It  is  left  to 
the  reader  to  guess  whose  recipes 
those  are.) 

So  we  settled  for  good  old  English 
roast  Bach,  with  two  veg.  and  three 
oboes,  and  finally  for  pungency 
added  some  ninth  overtone— unfor¬ 
tunately  we  only  had  old  spice;  fresh 
herbs  were  out  of  season. 

The  real  test  of  the  party  was 
ultimately  whether  or  not  we  felt 
like  dancing.  Sometimes  we  were 
transported  (E.M.I.  will  spare  no 
expense  to  achieve  authenticity)  to 
masked  balls  in  Venice,  where  of 
course  Nannie  Jamieson  and  Muriel 
Taylor  came  into  their  own  in  the 
Forlane*— that  was^  I  am  sorry  to 
say,  as  far  east  as  we  managed  to  get. 
Sometimes,  as  at  Versailles,  where 
we  did  a  good  deal  of  dancing- 
minuets,  gavottes,  etc.— we  invited 
a  group  of  peasants  to  do  an  old- 
fashioned  bourree.  On  the  whole  we 
spent  little  time  in  Germany— and 
the  majestic  pomp  and  circumstance 
of  the  introductory  movements  were 
all  recorded  in  the  studios  of  Ye  Olde 
Abbey  Road,  St.  John’s  Wood. 

I  would  like  to  single  out  each  one 
of  our  players  for  particular  praise, 
as  I  would  each  one  of  the  excellent 
critics  and  technicians  behind 
the  glass  panel. 

Suffice  it,  however,  to  express  my 
grateful  thanks  for  suggestions  and 
inspiration,  to  Robert  Masters,  as  to 
Sidney  Wilson,  Patrick  Ireland, 
Derek  Simpson,  Archie  Camden, 
Eugene  Cruft,  and  to  those  ever- 
helpful  and  patient  E.M.I.  collabo¬ 
rators,  Peter  Andry,  Ronald  Kinloch 
Anderson  (both  sides  of  the  glass 
panel),  and  Neville  Boyling,  etc. 

—Yehudi  Menuhin 


*Viola  player  and  ’cellist,  respectively,  in  the 
Forlane  from  Suite  No.  1. 


MANUFACTURED  BY  CAPITOL  RECORDS,  INC.,  A  SUBSIDIARY  OF  CAPITOL  INDUSTRIES,  INC.,  HOLLYWOOD  AND  VINE  STREEtS,  HOLLYWOOD,  CALIFORNIA.  FACTORIES:  LOS  ANGELES.  CALIFORNIA,  JACKSONVILLE,  ILLINOIS.  WINCHESTER.  VIRGINIA 


THIS  RECORD  IS  ENGINEERED  A  MANUFACTURED 


IN  ACCORDANCE 


STANDARDS  DEVELOPED  BY  THE  RECORDING  INDUSTRY  ASSOCIATION  OF  AMERICA.  INC 


SlB-6085 


Yehudi  Menuhin  made  his  first 
appearance  as  conductor  in  1945  in 
Dallas.  There,  at  the  insistence  of 
his  friend  Antal  Dorati,  he  con¬ 
ducted  Wagner’s  “Meistersinger” 
Overture,  the  Schubert  Eighth  Sym¬ 
phony,  and  the  Slavonic  Dances  of 
Dvorak.  The  evening  was  a  success, 
but  Menuhin’s  career  as  violin  vir¬ 
tuoso  and  his  many  other  interests 
precluded  any  further  conducting 
until  1959.  In  that  year,  he  became 
artistic  director  of  the  Bath  Test ival 
and  began  to  conduct  performances 
of  Mozart  and  Bach. 

In  1 96 1 ,  Menuhin  made  a  guest 
appearance  at  London’s  Roygil 
Festival  Hall,  leading  the  Ltodon 
Symphony  Orchestra  in  works  of 
Bartok  and  Schubert.  To  his  Bath 
schedule,  he  added  summer  festival 
performances  in  Gstaad,  Switzer¬ 
land.  When  his  association  with 
Bath  concluded,  he  formed  the 
Menuhin  Festival  Orchestra  to  com¬ 
mence  the  distinguished  series  of 
concerts,  tours  and  recordings  which 
soon  won  Menuhin  the  conductor 
worldwide  renown  to  equal  that  of 
Menuhin  the  violinist. 

Menuhin’s  conducted  works  of 
Bach,  Mozart,  Schubert,  Handel, 
Vivaldi,  Beethoven,  Boyce  and  other 
composers  have  been  acclaimed  on 
both  sides  of  the  Atlantic.  T he 
Gramophone  stated  that  Menuhin’s 
performances  of  the  Bach  Branden¬ 
burg  Concertos  would  represent  for 
other  conductors  “a  challenge  for 
years  to  come!’  His  complete  record¬ 
ing  of  Handel’s  Concert!  gross!  Op.  6 
was  named  by  T he  New  York  T imes 
as  the  best  of  all  available  versions. 

This  album  makes  newly  available 
on  Seraphim  recordings  Menuhin’s 
superb  performances  with  the  Bath 
Festival  Chamber  Orchestra  of 
Bach’s  Suites  for  Orchestra, 

BWV  1 066 /  9.  Of  them,  Denis 
Stevens  wrote  in  The  Gramophone: 
“This  interpretation  so  easily  sur¬ 
passes  its  competitors  that  a  compar¬ 
ative  review  in  the  usual  sense  is 
superfluous.  The  spiritual  insight 
and  musical  mastery  that  Menuhin 
and  his  colleagues  brought  to  the 
Brandenburgs  last  year  is  now 
applied  to  the  four  orchestral  suites, 
and  the  result  is  equally  impressive, 
in  some  ways  even  more  so  . .  .This 
pair  of  records  should  be  in  every 
library,  whether  large  or  small!’ 


..  A  NON  PROFIT  ORGANIZATION  DEOtCATED  TO  THE  BETTERMENT  OF  RECORDED  MUSIC  &  LITERATURE. 

PRINTED  IN  U  S  A 


Bach 


The  Four  Suites  for  Orchestra 

In  1 6 1 8  the  King  o£  Spain  joined 
the  Catholic  Emperor  of  Germany 
against  the  Protestants.  A  local  strug¬ 
gle  for  power  in  Bohemia  became 
widespread  and  the  Thirty  Years 
War  had  begun.  By  its  end,  with  the 
Treaty  of  Westphalia,  Germany  was 
utterly  exhausted  —  all  central 
government  ceased  and  more  than 
three  hundred  independent  princes 
held  absolute  sway  within  their 
tiny  domains. 

From  all  this  unimaginable 
turmoil  arose  some  remarkable 
developments  in  the  field  of  the  fine 
arts  generally,  and  in  music  in 
particular.  Germany  became  the 
melting-pot  for  all  that  was  great  in 
the  surrounding  countries.  Italy 
contributed  charm  and  power  of 
melody;  France  gave  music  for  the 
harpsichord  as  well  as  its  own  special 
kind  of  “Overture”  developed  by 
Lully  (1632-87). 

Long  before  Bach’s  time  it  had 
been  the  custom  to  group  together 
two  or  more  dance  movements. 

The  English  virginalists  did  it  with 


the  Pavane  and  Galliard,  and  as 
seen  in  “Parthenia”  (1611).  They 
occasionally  added  a  Prelude:  so  too 
the  Italian  lutenists  as  shown  by 
the  four  books  published  in  Venice 
in  1507-8.  Froberger  (1616-67) 
established  a  nucleus  of  four  dances 
(Allemande,  Courante,  Sarabande 
and  Gigue)  to  which  others  could  be 
added.  The  early  Sonatas  of  Corelli 
(1653-1713)  are  almost  entirely 
dance  movements  with  a  Prelude. 
Couperin  (1668-1733)  seems  to 
imply  that  his  sets  of  dances  were  not 
necessarily  to  be  performed  as  a 
whole  in  the  written  order— instru¬ 
mentalists  choosing  whichever  most 
fitted  their  mood  or  circumstances. 

In  Germany  these  instrumental 
suites  were  composed  primarily  by 
or  for  the  town  musicians  ( Stadt- 
pfeifer J.  To  the  dances  they  added 
the  French  “Overture”  of  Lully 
with  its  slow  introduction,  its  faster 
fugal  middle  section  and  its  slow 
conclusion.  The  dances  increased  in 
number  and  began  to  move  away 
from  a  fixed  order  and  pattern. 

J.  S.  Bach’s  father  (Johann 
Ambrosius),  his  uncle  (Johann 
Christoph)  and  grandfather  (Chris¬ 
toph)  were  all  town  musicians,  and 
therefore  it  is  perhaps  not  surprising 
that  Bach  himself  should  contribute 
something  great  to  this  class  of 
composition.  The  result  is  remark¬ 
able  in  every  way.  He  so  enriched 
the  established  scheme  of  things 
that,  beside  Bach’s  work,  the  primi¬ 
tive  model  of  Lully  becomes  almost 
unrecognizable.  Bach  transports  us 
by  his  superb  handling  of  instru¬ 
mental  form  and  texture,  his  use  of 
highly  cogent  differentiation  and 
organization  of  his  material  and  by 
grandeur  and  sweep  of  his  melody. 
The  fugal  sections  of  the  Overtures 
are  well  developed,  with  striking 
and  sharply  contrasted  episodes. 

In  the  dances  themselves  variety  is 
achieved  by  differing  moods;  one 
strong,  the  other  tender. 

As  Schweitzer  wrote:  “A  fragment 
of  a  vanished  world  of  grace  and 
elegance  has  been  preserved  for  us 
. . .  Their  charm  resides  in  the 
perfection  of  their  blending  of 
strength  and  grace!’ 


Side  One: 

24:55 

Suite  No.  1  In  C  Major, 
BWV.1066 

Overture 

7:31 

Courante 

2:14 

Gavotte  1 8c  II 
3:08 

Forlane 

1:39 

Minuet  1 8c  II 

3:33 

Bourree  1 8c  II 
2:56 

Passepied  1 8c  II 
3:54 

Probably  written  about  the  same 
time  as  the  Brandenburg  Concertos, 
this  work  is  for  two  oboes,  bassoon, 
strings  and  harpsichord. 

The  Overture  begins  with  a 
stately  slow  introduction  for  the  full 
orchestra.  The  vivace  is  built  on  a 
brisk  theme  given  to  the  oboes  and 
first  violins,  the  remaining  groups  of 
instruments  entering  one  by  one 
in  accordance  with  fugal  treatment. 
During  its  course  the  three  wind 
instruments  are  occasionally  heard 
in  solo  passages  which  are  quickly 
supplanted  by  the  vigorous  recapitu¬ 
lation  of  the  theme.  A  slow  section 
ends  the  movement. 

An  energetic  Courante  is  followed 
by  two  delightful  Gavottes,  the 
second  of  which  is  for  the  oboes  with 
a  simple  accompaniment  of  strings. 
This  accompaniment  would  seem 
to  be  some  sort  of  fanfare  and  is 
very  similar  to  the  horn  part  at  the 
beginning  of  the  first  Brandenburg 
Concerto. 

The  Forlane  was  an  old  Venetian 
dance,  popular  with  the  gondoliers. 
The  oboes  and  first  violins  are  in 
unison,  with  a  charming  running 
figure  in  the  lower  strings. 

The  two  Minuets  are  sharply 
contrasted— one  for  full  orchestra, 
the  second  played  softly  by  the 
strings  alone. 

A  similar  contrast  appears  in 
the  two  Bourrees— the  first  for  full 
orchestra,  the  second  for  wood¬ 
wind  only. 

Finally  two  Passepieds— a  dance 
of  sixteenth  century  Brittany 
fishermen. 


Side  Two: 

21:26 

Suite  No.  2  In  B  Minor, 

BWV.  1067 

Overture 

8:17 

Rondeau 

1:46 

Sarabande 

3:00 

Bourree  1 8cII 
2:04 

Polonaise  and  Double 
3:37 

Minuet 

1:22 

Badinerie 

1:20 

The  second  Suite  is  written  for 
strings  and  harpsichord  with  a  solo 
flute.  Its  Overture  is  on  the  same 
pattern  as  in  the  first  Suite,  with 
episodes  for  flute. 

The  second  movement,  a  Ron¬ 
deau,  is  a  very  rare  form  in  Bach’s 
music.  In  the  course  of  the  second 
part  of  the  flute  breaks  away  from  its 
unison  with  the  first  violins.  A  strik¬ 
ing  effect  is  produced  in  bars  36-38 
when  the  interval  from  the  opening 
bars  is  inverted. 

In  the  Sarabande  (a  Spanish  dance) 
the  flute  and  cellos  are  in  canon. 

The  first  Bourree  has  an  interest¬ 
ing  ground  bass;  the  second  gives 
the  flute  a  solo  part. 

The  two  sections  of  the  Polonaise 
are  closely  linked.  In  the  second 
(Double)  the  cellos  play  two  octaves 
lower  the  flute  part  from  the  Polo¬ 
naise  proper,  the  flute  playing  a 
highly  decorated  theme. 

After  the  Minuet  (originally  a  gay 
dance  from  Poitou)  comes  a  lively, 
playful  Badinerie,  fragments  of  the 
flute  part  appearing  in  the  continuo. 


<‘S3yf5'2 

AV 


SIB-6085 


\ 


Side  Three: 

19:25 

Suite  No.  3  In  D  Major, 
BWV.  1068 

Overture 

7:38 

Air 

4:06 

Gavotte  1 8c  II 
3:32 

Bourree 

1:21 

Gigue 

2:48 

This,  like  No.  4,  is  for  larger 
orchestra  than  is  the  case  with  Nos. 

1  and  2,  and  was  probably  written 
soon  after  Bach’s  appointment  to 
Leipzig  in  1723.  (Unfortunately 
all  the  original  autograph  scores  of 
these  compositions  have  disap¬ 
peared;  thus  there  is  no  opportunity 
of  dating  them  by  paper,  watermark, 
or  styles  of  writing.)  The  work  is  for 
strings  and  harpsichord,  with  two 
oboes,  three  trumpets  and  timpani. 

The  Overture  is  in  the  usual 
Lully  form.  In  the  fugal  section  are 
several  episodes,  in  this  instance 
derived  from  the  original  counter 
subject  (compare  bars  42  and  28). 

The  second  movement  is  the 
famous  and  most  beautiful  Air, 
for  strings  only. 

The  two  Gavottes  are  for  full 
orchestra,  with  the  timpani  silent 
in  the  second. 

The  Bourree  and  Gigue  round  off 
one  of  Bach’s  most  appealing  works. 

Mendelssohn  gave  a  performance 
of  this  Suite  at  the  Leipzig  Gewand- 
hauson  February  15, 1838.  He 
simplified  the  trumpet  parts  and 
added  two  clarinets  in  the  Gigue. 

Side  Four: 

21:33 

Suite  No.  4  In  D  Major, 
BWV.  1069 

Overture 

9:55 

Bourree  1 8cII 
3:12 

Gavotte 

1:39 

Minuet  8c  Trio 
4:04 

Reiouissance 

2:43 

The  orchestra  is  similar  in  size  to 
that  employed  in  No.  3,  with 


the  addition  of  a  solo  bassoon  and 
a  third  oboe. 

The  Overture  is  of  the  usual  form, 
with  two  episodes  in  the  fugal 
section— one  for  woodwind,  the 
other  for  strings. 

Immediately  after  the  beginning 
of  the  first  Bourree  (a  dance  prob¬ 
ably  from  the  Auvergne),  the  trum¬ 
pets  and  timpani  remain  silent  until 
the  end.  In  the  second  Bourree  the 
woodwind  (including  a  solo  bassoon) 
are  accompanied  by  a  strange  off¬ 
beat  figure  on  unison  strings. 

The  full  orchestra  returns  in  the 
Gavotte  with  a  boisterousness  very 
unlike  the  original  dance  from  Dau- 
phine,  in  which  kissing  seems  to  have 
been  one  of  the  main  preoccupations. 

A  stately  Minuet  is  followed  by 
a  Trio  for  strings. 

The  last  movement,  Rejouissance, 
is  a  lively  dance;  many  eighteenth 
century  composers  used  this  title, 
as  for  example  Telemann  in  his 
Suite  in  A  minor  for  flute  and  strings. 

An  adaptation  of  the  Overture 
appears  at  the  beginning  of  Cantata 
110,  for  Christmas  Day  (“Unser 
Mund  sei  voll  Lachens”),  a  work  first 
written  in  1725  and  revised 

about  1731.  -CHARLES  ENDERBY 

The  Bath  Festival 
Chamber  Orchestra 

1st  Violins: 

Robert  Masters 
Eli  Goren 
Jack  Rothstein 
Marjorie  Lavers 
Kelly  Isaacs 
Kenneth  Havelock 

2nd  Violins: 

Sydney  Humphreys 
Trevor  Williams 
James  Barton 
Wolfgang  Kellerman 
Edward  Bor 
Anthony  Howard 

Violas: 

Patrick  Ireland 
Nannie  Jamieson 
Eileen  Grainger 
Brian  Clarke 

Cellos: 

Derek  Simpson  (continuo) 

Muriel  Taylor 
Bernard  Richards 

Double  Bass: 

Eugene  Cruft 


Flute: 

Elaine  Shaffer  (in  No.  2) 

Oboes: 

Michael  Dobson 
James  Brown 
Maurice  Checker 

Bassoon: 

Archie  Camden 

Trumpets: 

Dennis  Clift 
Sidney  Ellison 
Horace  Barker 

Timpani: 

James  Blades 

Harpsichord: 

R.  Kinloch  Anderson 

Menuhin  Conducts  Bach 
on  Angel  Records: 

THE  COMPLETE  BRANDENBURG 
CONCERTOS.  Soloists  include  Elaine 
Shaffer,  flute;  George  Malcolm,  harpsi¬ 
chord;  Denis  Clift,  trumpet;  Derek  Simp¬ 
son,  cello;  Janet  Craxton,  oboe;  Archie 
Cramden,  bassoon;  Christopher  Taylor, 
recorder;  Yehudi  Menuhin,  violin,  viola 
8c  violino  piccolo;  and  others. 

2LP's.  SB-3787. 

THE  MUSICAL  OFFERING.  Festival 
Orchestra  members  include  Menuhin  and 
Robert  Masters,  violins;  Patrick  Ireland, 
Nannie  Jamieson,  violas;  Derek  Simpson, 
Muriel  Taylor,  cellos;  Elaine  Shaffer, 


flute;  Archie  Camden,  bassoon;  Kinloch 
Anderson,  harpsichord.  S-35731. 

CONCERTO  IN  D  MINOR  FOR 
VIOLIN,  OBOE  AND  STRINGS.  With 
Handel  Concertos  for  Oboe  Nos.  1,  2  &:  3; 
Vivaldi  Concerto  for  Strings  in  B  minor. 
Soloists:  Menuhin,  violin;  Leon  Goossens, 
oboe;  others.  S-36103. 

TRIPLE  CONCERTO  IN  A  MINOR. 
With  C.PE.  Bach  Harpsichord  Concerto 
in  D  minor.  Soloists:  Menuhin,  violin; 
Malcolm,  harpsichord;  William  Bennett, 
flute.  S-36336. 

TWO  SOLO  CANTATAS:  “Ich  habe 
genug,”  BWV  82;  “Gott  soil  allein  mein 
Herze  haben”  BWV  169.  Janet  Baker, 
mezzo-soprano;  the  Ambrosian  Singers. 
S-36419. 

TWO  CONCERTOS  FOR  TWO 
HARPSICHORDS  AND  ORCHESTRA: 
the  C  major,  S  1061;  the  C  minor,  S.  1060. 
TWO  CONCERTOS  FOR  HARPSI¬ 
CHORD  AND  ORCHESTRA:  the 
F  minor,  S.  1056;  the  G  minor,  S.  1058. 
Soloists:  George  Malcolm,  Simon  Preston. 
S-36762. 

HARPSICHORD  CONCERTOS, 

VOL.  2:  the  D  major,  S.  1054;  the 
A  major,  S.  1055;  the  F  major,  S.  1057. 
George  Malcolm,  harpsichord.  S-36790. 

BACH:  SIX  SONATAS  FOR  VIOLIN 
AND  HARPSICHORD,  BWV  1014/19. 
Menuhin,  violin;  George  Malcolm, 
harpsichord;  Ambrose  Gauntlett,  viola 
da  gamba.  SB-3629.