The ocean of story, being C.H. Tawney's translation of Somadeva's Katha sarit sagara (or Ocean of streams of story)

rj.'ijfil

VOL. IX

THE
OCEAN OF STORY

t OC\VlT>V\

THE

OCEAN OF STORY

BEING

G. H. TAWNEY'S TRANSLATION

OP

SOMADEVA'S KATHA SARIT SAGARA

\«*

(OR OCEAN OP STREAMS OF STORY)

NOW EDITED WITH INTRODUCTION, FRESH

EXPLANATORY NOTES AND TERMINAL ESSAY

BY

N. M. PENZER, M.A., F.R.G.S., F.G.S.

MEMBER OF THE FOLK-LORE SOCIETY ; FELLOW OF THE

ROYAL ANTHROPOLOGICAL INSTITUTE; MEMBER

OF THE ROYAL ASIATIC SOCIETY, ETC.

AUTHOR OF

"AN ANNOTATED BIBLIOGRAPHY OF SIR RICHARD FRANCIS

BURTON," ETC.

IN TEN VOLUMES

VOL. IX

WITH A FOREWORD BY

Sir ATUL CHATTERJEE

HIGH COMMISSIONER FOR INDIA

S*t

LONDON: PRIVATELY PRINTED FOR SUBSCRIBERS ONLY
BY CHAS. J. SAWYER LTD., GRAFTON HOUSE, W.l. MCMXXVlll

Made and Printed in Great Britain

FOREWORD

WHEN Mr Penzer honoured me with an invitation
to write a Foreword to the ninth volume of this
admirable work, I felt that it would be foolish pre-
sumption on my part to attempt to add to the learned and
fascinating studies on different aspects of the Ocean of Story
that have been contributed to the previous volumes by
scholars of eminence and authority. But it may not perhaps
be unwelcome to the Western or Eastern reader of the Ocean
to consider for a while the influence which must have been
exercised by this unique and marvellous collection of stories
on the culture and ideas of the people for whom they were
primarily strung together. It may also be worth while to
examine the evidence afforded by it of life and society in
India at a most interesting and elusive period of its history,
a century before the establishment of a Muslim Kingdom at
Delhi.

It is a well-known, but none the less remarkable, fact that
for the Hindu there is no code or compendium either for
religious dogma or for moral conduct. There is nothing of
final authority to guide him like the Ten Commandments,
the Gospels or the Qur'dn. The Vedas contain little in the
way of definite and concrete rules of belief and conduct, and,
at the best, the teaching of the Vedas could have been familiar
only to a microscopic minority of the population of India.
The term " Sastras " is a generic expression which may be
said to embrace the entire non-secular literature of Sanskrit ;
individual works included in the term Sastras have possessed
authority only at different times, in different parts of India
and among different sections of the population. We must
also remember that until recently only an insignificant pro-
portion of the people were able to read or write even the
spoken vernaculars, and that in the climate of the country

vi THE OCEAN OF STORY

the preservation of manuscripts is an arduous task. In these
peculiar circumstances, the ethical and spiritual culture of
the masses could be maintained only by the spoken word, and
what better vehicle was there for the necessary teaching than
tales embodying in a concrete form both religious principles
and rules of conduct ? The adoption of the story as a medium
of religious and moral instruction had the further advantage
that the characters and incidents could be varied according
to the rank or culture of the audience which represented
people in all stages of civilisation, from the aboriginal tribes
to the courtly and warlike Kshatriya and the priestly Brah-
man of pure descent. These " stories with a moral " were
woven into the history of mythical and epic gods and heroes,
and thus obtained wide currency. They could not in any
sense be described as the composition or the property of
any one author or writer. They were altered or adapted to
suit the reciter or the listeners and the particular occasion.
Infinite variations of a story would therefore be current simul-
taneously, but the framework and the moral would remain
much the same in all versions. Even thirty years ago the
Kaihak (literally " story-teller ") was a familiar figure in the
villages of northern and eastern India. His services would
be requisitioned for one evening, or for a fortnight, or even
for a whole season, either through the piety and generosity
of a wealthy patron (often a lady), or by subscriptions raised
among the residents of a village or circle of hamlets. A
popular Kaihak? s clientele extended to all districts where the
same language was spoken. He was commissioned to relate
sometimes the whole of the Rdmdyana or the Mahdbhdrata
or a Purdna, or sometimes only a striking episode appropriate
to the season or the occasion. In reciting the history of the
hero, the Kaihak never hesitated to bring in extraneous or
subsidiary stories by way of illustration or for purposes of
diversion. For, though his main object was to instruct, he could
not hope to do so without amusing or interesting his audience.
The speaker sat on a slightly raised platform, while the audi-
ence, composed of men, women and children, of all castes
and conditions, circled round him, in an open thatched hall,
or under an awning, or in the dry season under a spreading

FOREWORD vii

banyan-tree. This mixed audience was no doubt responsible
for the fact that, although the stories were treated in the
frank natural manner of the East, there was seldom any
indecency or obscenity in them.

The printing-press and the spread of primary education
are affecting the demand for the services of the Kathak, but
we can well imagine how extensive his influence was in
mediaeval India. It will also be recognised that the art of
the Kathak must have been largely responsible for the main-
tenance of a literary standard in the vernacular, and for the
gradual development of a vigorous literature in languages
such as Hindi, Bengali and Guzerati. In the earlier centuries
of the Christian era the epics and the stories were mostly
enshrined in Sanskrit, but the Kathak had to relate them to
his audience in the spoken language. It is not difficult
therefore to realise that powerful influences were at work for
the preservation, in a written form of the vernacular, of works
which were previously accessible in a language understood
only by a very small minority of the people. Perhaps some
explanation may be found in these circumstances of the
tradition embodied in Somadeva's recension of the Kathd-
sarit-sagara that Gunadhya had originally written out his
collection of the stories in the PaisachI dialect.

It is safe to assume that during the centuries after
Somadeva, the stories embodied in the Ocean, including the
Panchatantra and Vetala tales, became familiar to practically
all sections of the Hindu population of India, and exerted a
potent influence on their ideas and culture. Mr Penzer has
shown in his Terminal Essay — pp. 118 and 119 — how in the
earlier collections of the stories the characters belonged to a
non-aristocratic sphere of society, such as merchants, artisans
and cultivators, and the presiding deity was Kuvera, the God
of Wealth. Somadeva and his coadjutors thought it desirable
to replace Kuvera by Siva (the chief deity worshipped in
Kashmir in their time), and they also attempted to invest
the chief characters with a social eminence which did not
belong to them in the original recensions. But the new
editors did not succeed in altering the general tone and
atmosphere of the tales, and we have therefore available

(

viii THE OCEAN OF STORY

in Somadeva's Ocean, so skilfully and faithfully translated by
Tawney, a living picture of life of the common people in India
in the tenth and eleventh centuries of the Christian era.

It is not my purpose to dwell at length on the moral and
religious beliefs of the people as illustrated in these tales, for
this work has already been accomplished in the excellent notes
and appendices with which Mr Penzer has enriched these
volumes. It is evident, as might have been anticipated by
students of this period of Indian history, that the prevailing
beliefs were a curious medley of the purer forms of Hindu
mythology, of the later and sometimes debased Buddhistic
doctrines and of tantric practices of comparatively recent
development. The conflict between the Hindu and the
Buddhist ideals of life is very clearly brought out in the tale
of the Buddhist merchant Vitastadatta of Taxila and his
Hindu son Ratnadatta (III, 2-5). We see incidentally how
Buddhism had been the more popular religion with " low-
caste men," and it is pleasant to note the spirit of toleration
underlying the declaration of the philosophic Buddhist —
" Religion is not confined to one form." While in the course
of the work we are treated to learned and highly technical
discussions on the doctrine of " Maya," we have also many
allusions to the more common practice of the worship of
Durga. The very frequent references to the famous temple
of Durga in the town of Bindhachal (Vindhyachala, or
literally Vindhya mountain), close to Mirzapur, are probably
accounted for by the proximity of the regions peopled by
forest tribes such as Bhillas, Savaras, or Pulindas, who are
described in many parts of the Ocean. These references also
indicate that one of the main routes between the Gangetic
Valley and the Deccan must have been in those days, as it
is now, from Mirzapur by a ford over the Narmada above
Jabalpur, and through the forest districts, to Pratishthana on
the Godavari. It is interesting to find that the temple of the
Mahakala Siva at Ujjayini described in Kalidasa's MeghadiUa
was equally famous in the days of Somadeva, and, like the
Durga temple at Bindhachal, still attracts votaries from all
parts of the country. Belief in magic ceremonial is illustrated
in many of the stories ; in the tale of Kamalakara and

FOREWORD ix

Hamsavali we have gruesome details of the rites connected
with human sacrifice (VI, 52). The synthesis of the philo-
sophic tenets of Hinduism and Buddhism and the animistic
rites and practices of the forest tribes, had produced a mixture
which was not calculated to impart either social or political
stability to Hindu India in the coming struggle with Islam.
A careful reader of the Ocean of Story cannot fail to be struck
by the spirit of gentle satire which underlies most of the
stories, but unfortunately the criticism was not sufficiently
trenchant for the purposes of reform and purification. ^

Similar observations apply to the picture of the political
organisation of India in the tenth and eleventh centuries that
is presented by these tales. Somadeva and his associates
delineate for us a country divided into a large number of
small states each ruled by a personal monarch, with dynastic
ambitions and a desire for territorial aggrandisement. The
King is usually guided by an intelligent and devoted minister,
often a Brahman. We have also a reference to a system
where the Crown Prince had a court composed of young men
in training for the posts of ministers. But there is little
evidence of any complex political or administrative organisa-
tion at the centres of government. We are led to presume
that the system of regional administration by means of a
trained bureaucracy, which had been inaugurated by rulers
such as Asoka, continued to survive and function, and was
a familiar feature which the editors of the stories did not
consider it worthy to stress. It is difficult on any other
hypothesis to account for the easy revival of the ancient
bureaucracy by early Muslim rulers like Alauddin. There is
no trace in the stories of the Ocean of any " state " or civic
patriotism among the masses of the population. On the other
hand there is much dynastic intrigue in the ruling families ;
territorial expansion was frequently sought by means of
matrimonial alliances, which naturally led to counter -alliances.
The picture thus sketched furnishes abundant explanation
for the jealousies and weaknesses which characterised the
defence of these kingdoms when the Muslim invaders arrived
in the twelfth and succeeding centuries. A point to be noted
in passing is that although we have many references to

\

x THE OCEAN OF STORY

kingdoms so far apart as Ujjayini, Pataliputra and Kashmir,
and although there is mention of Takshasila in the north,
Lata (Guzerat) on the west, Chola and Kalinga in the south,
and Kamarupa in the east, there is no allusion to any
state in modern Rajputana. Not the least interesting pas-
sages in the stories are concerned with the " non -Aryan "
kingdoms in the Vindhya country, peopled by the older tribes
such as Bhillas, Savaras and Pulindas, and the efforts made
by the Aryan chiefs to secure their friendship and support.
In these fragmentary references to the political organisation
of the country the frequent demoralisation of the rulers is
also vividly described. (Compare the story of King Bhima-
bhata in VI, 162.) No doubt there were popular risings in
consequence and the replacement of one ruler by another.
But we cannot expect many stories describing such incidents
in a collection specifically dedicated to a royal personage.

The social fabric of India in the tenth and eleventh cen-
turies was composed of the four chief castes, but it is remark-
able that even at that comparatively late epoch, although
we have mention of many different vocations and professions,
there is no allusion to any subcastes within the limits of
which intermarriage was restricted. Indeed, leaving out the
rather doubtful cases of gdndharva marriage in the stories of
the Ocean, we find frequent instances, without provoking any
comment or criticism from the authors, of marriages with
women of an inferior caste. In the story of the Golden City
(II, 171), the king, who is presumably a Kshatriya, is willing
to marry the Princess Kanakarekha, to a Brahman or a
Kshatriya, and the first aspirant to her hand is a Brahman.
In a later story, Asokadatta, the son of " a great Brahman,"
marries the daughter of a Kshatriya king (II, 204). Other
instances will be found in III, 134, IV, 140, and VI, 73.
In the story of Anangarati (IV, 144), four suitors belonging
respectively to the four castes seek the hand of the princess,
and, in spite of a decided preference for the Kshatriya
and the Brahman on account of their caste, the Vaisya and
the Siidra were not summarily ruled out. On the other
hand, there is no instance in the Ocean of a man actually
marrying a woman of a superior caste. In modern times

FOREWORD x

efforts are being made to break down provincial or regional
caste-barriers, and until recently instances were very rare of
intermarriage between people of different provinces. In the
Ocean, however, there is no indication of any such barriers,
and no surprise is caused when we hear of a Pataliputra man
bringing a wife from Paundravardhana.

It is also noteworthy that caste did not determine the
occupation or profession of a man. We come across Brah-
mans employed in the secular departments of the State ; a
Brahman youth becomes a professional wrestler (II, 200),
and another becomes a bandit (VI, 166), apparently without
losing caste. In the story of Viravara, we have a Brahman
becoming a soldier of fortune (VI, 173). In the story of
Phalabhuti, the Brahman Somadatta adopts the occupation
of a husbandman (II, 95).

A subject of speculation among students of Indian social
history is the extent to which the custom of the seclusion of
women existed in the pre-Muslim period. There can be little
question that at all periods of Indian history the women of
the richer classes led a more sheltered life than is the case
with the modern Western woman. In the Purdnas, as well
as in the secular literature, there are frequent references to
the " antahpura," or the inner apartments of a palace, or a
rich man's dwelling-house, which are usually occupied by
the womenfolk of the family. The stories in the Ocean, how-
ever, prove that in no part of the country in the eleventh
century was there anything corresponding to the " parda "
system of northern India in recent days. We have in the
story of Arthalobha (III, 286) an indication of the fact that
it was not unusual for a woman to participate in mercantile
business of some importance. At the same time it would
appear that a polygamous chief or ruler occasionally en-
deavoured to introduce stricter seclusion for his wives. We
have a reference to such attempts in the incident described
at III, 169. Ratnaprabha, after successfully insisting that
her apartments " must not be closed against the entrance of
her husband's friends," made the following remarks, which
are as true to-day as they were in the eleventh century : " I
consider that the strict seclusion of women is a mere social

xii THE OCEAN OF STORY

custom, or rather folly produced by jealousy. It is of no
use whatever. Women of good family are guarded by their
own virtue as their only chamberlain. But even God Himself
can scarcely guard the unchaste. Who can restrain a furious
river and a passionate woman ? "

Polygamy was legally permissible to all Hindus in Soma-
deva's time as it is now, but in spite of the fact that the hero
of the Ocean frequently indulges in the pastime of taking to
himself a new wife, the practice of polygamy appears to have
been confined in the main to chiefs and ruling princes. In
the tale of Gunasarman (IV, 99), we have the very pertinent
economic explanation of monogamy among the common
people in spite of the legal sanction for polygamy. The wise
Brahman Agnidatta says : " Wives generally have many rivals
when the husband is fortunate ; a poor man would find it
difficult to support one, much more to support many." In
the story of Akshakshapanaka we have an instance of a man
belonging to the middle classes who was persuaded by his
relations to take a second wife after his first wife had deserted
him (VI, 152). We do not come across any other tale in the
Ocean illustrating a polygamous marriage by a person who
did not belong to a semi-divine or princely category. It is
hard to believe that if polygamy had been a common practice,
the authors of the tales would not have utilised the theme
for the obviously amusing situations that were bound to
arise.

Mr Penzer has dealt with the custom of sail in an illumin-
ating appendix, and it is not necessary for me to refer to it
here. But it is worthy of note that the remarriage of widows
does not receive disapproval or condemnation in any tale in
the Ocean ; in the story of the Eleven Slayer (V, 184),
although the exceptional and extraordinary circumstances
bring ridicule on the woman, she incurs no religious penalty
or social ostracism for her repeated marriages. Another
question frequently asked in modern India is whether the
custom of child -marriage was prevalent in older days. We
have an echo of the oft-quoted text enjoining the marriage of
immature girls in the statement of the harassed King Paro-
pakarin to his " grown-up " daughter : " If a daughter

FOREWORD xiii

reaches puberty unmarried, her relations go to hell and she is
an outcast and her bridegroom is called the husband of an
outcast " (VI, 173). But this very story, where the princess
has already been reared to womanhood and there are many
suitors for her hand, proves that the pious text was not un-
often honoured in the breach. The general tenor of most of
the tales in the Ocean indicates that, though child-marriage
may not have been unknown and some social theorists were
advocating it, young men and young women seldom married
before they were " grown up." The custom of child-marriage,
like that of the strict seclusion of women, seems to have
been a later development.

The profession of courtesans that existed in all the court-
cities of the country has been described by Mr Penzer in an
elaborate and exhaustive manner in the Appendix on Sacred
Prostitution (Vol. I). Another unpleasant feature of the social
organisation of the pre-Muslim epoch appears to have been
the wide prevalence of wine-drinking. In the Parrot's Story
(VI, 186), we find a young merchant " drowsy with wine,"
while all the people of the house also sink into a drunken sleep.
To those who are familiar with the abstemious habits of the
Hindu merchant castes of the present time this story would
cause natural surprise. What is still more shocking is the
laxness that prevailed in this respect even among women.
Somadeva relates several stories, without any hint of dis-
approval, of princesses of noble birth indulging in drinking
bouts. (See III, 107, III, 174, and VII, 10.) In his Terminal
Essay Mr Penzer has put forward the hypothesis that the
Kashmirian editors of the Ocean gave a much higher social
rank to the original characters of the stories. But this does
not improve matters from our point of view. There can be
little doubt that, so far as wine-drinking is concerned, the
position has been very much better in recent times among
the middle classes in India : among the women of all classes
, the habit is almost unknown. It is a matter of speculation
whether this change was effected through the influence of the
Hindu reformers of the fourteenth and fifteenth centuries,
or as the result of Muslim rule.

There are in the Ocean references to the datura as a

xiv THE OCEAN OF STORY

stupefying intoxicant (I, 160, and V, 145), but it is difficult
to say whether it was in common use except for criminal
purposes. It is worthy of note that there is no allusion in any
of the tales to the consumption of opium either as a medicine or
as an intoxicant. Nor do we find any mention of ganja, char as
or bhang (different forms of hemp drugs). The proximity of
Kashmir to the natural habitat of some of these drugs ought
to have familiarised the editors with them had they been in
vogue in the tenth or eleventh centuries. Gambling appears
to have been a widespread vice in the time of Somadeva. It
is true that sometimes it may have been indulged in as a mere
amusement or recreation (see the story at V, 86). But we
have a graphic description of a gambling den in the story of
Chandrasvamin (VII, 72), and there are tales in the Ocean
devoted to the same theme. Certain classes in India do not
seem to have changed their habits in this respect since the
date of the Vedas and the Mahdbharata (II, 231n).

A more pleasant diversion, the subsequent disappearance
of which one notes with regret, was dancing among respectable
ladies. It is difficult to trace how in later days dancing in
public became confined to women of the " dancing-girl " class.
Was it merely an accompaniment of the introduction of the
custom of strict seclusion of women, or was it the result of
contact with the puritanic ideals of Islam ? In the Ocean we
find many instances of ladies of position giving fine exhibitions
of the dancing art. We have the spectacle of the Princess
Hamsavali dancing before her father (and apparently many
others present at the Court) " to the music of a great tabor,
looking like a creeper of the tree of love agitated by the wind of
youth, shaking her ornaments like flowers, curving her hand
like a shoot " (VI, 41). The " dancing teacher " for the ladies of
the Court was apparently a regular institution (IV, 156). In
the story of King Kanakavarsha (IV, 208), his ambassador
sent to the Court of King Devasakti to secure the hand of
Princess Madanasundari has the good fortune of witnessing
" the elegance in the dance " of the princess. There is no
reason to presume that the art was known only in the Courts
and was not practised by respectable women in a humbler
sphere of life.

FOREWORD xv

Music was an equally popular art, both among men and
women. There were professors of singing as of dancing
(VI, 41). It is unnecessary for me here to quote further
instances, for they will be found throughout the tales.

Painting was also one of the fine arts held in high esteem.
Picture galleries were a regular feature in royal palaces
(IV, 205), and portrait painters moved from one Court to
another, being often entrusted with delicate missions. The
art of fresco-painting, of which such excellent examples
survive at Ajanta and Bagh, was also in request. The father
of the Princess Hamsavali employs an artist to paint his
daughter's bower, and the artist thereupon paints the Prince
Kamalakara and his servants on the wall of the bower (VI, 41).
The kindred arts of sculpture and architecture must have
flourished at the same time, for they were needeot not only for
the palaces of which we have such glowing descriptions in
various stories, but also for the temples and the figures in
them, to which there is constant reference. There are also
indications in various passages in the Ocean that gardening
was a highly patronised art.

Among professions of a different type to which allusion is
made in the Ocean are those of the astrologer and the fortune-
teller. It was recognised that there were many pretenders in
these professions, and much fun is made of the dupes of false
astrologers in the story of the Brahman Harisarman (III, 70).
A story of similar purport in regard to fortune-tellers will be
found at II, 90.

References to the economic condition of the people are
unfortunately meagre in the Ocean. We find Brahmans and
others subsisting on royal grants of land, but no details are
available of the conditions of tenure of such grants or of other
land. Slavery was a recognised institution. We have in
the story of Dharmadatta (III, 7) a case of a female slave
in the house of a Brahman married to " an excellent hired
servant in the house of a certain merchant." In this instance
at any rate the bonds of slavery were not rigorous, for
the woman and her (free) husband were permitted to set
up a separate house of their own. It would have been
interesting to know whether she was only a life slave, or
VOL. ix. b

xiv THE OCEAN OF STORY

stupefying intoxicant (I, 160, and V, 145), but it is difficult
to say whether it was in common use except for criminal
purposes. It is worthy of note that there is no allusion in any
of the tales to the consumption of opium either as a medicine or
as an intoxicant. Nor do we find any mention of ganja, char as
or bhang (different forms of hemp drugs). The proximity of
Kashmir to the natural habitat of some of these drugs ought
to have familiarised the editors with them had they been in
vogue in the tenth or eleventh centuries. Gambling appears
to have been a widespread vice in the time of Somadeva. It
is true that sometimes it may have been indulged in as a mere
amusement or recreation (see the story at V, 86). But we
have a graphic description of a gambling den in the story of
Chandrasvamin (VII, 72), and there are tales in the Ocean
devoted to the same theme. Certain classes in India do not
seem to have changed their habits in this respect since the
date of the Vedas and the Mahdbharata (II, 231 n).

A more pleasant diversion, the subsequent disappearance
of which one notes with regret, was dancing among respectable
ladies. It is difficult to trace how in later days dancing in
public became confined to women of the " dancing-girl " class.
Was it merely an accompaniment of the introduction of the
custom of strict seclusion of women, or was it the result of
contact with the puritanic ideals of Islam ? In the Ocean we
find many instances of ladies of position giving fine exhibitions
of the dancing art. We have the spectacle of the Princess
Hamsavali dancing before her father (and apparently many
others present at the Court) " to the music of a great tabor,
looking like a creeper of the tree of love agitated by the wind of
youth, shaking her ornaments like flowers, curving her hand
like a shoot " (VI, 41). The " dancing teacher " for the ladies of
the Court was apparently a regular institution (IV, 156). In
the story of King Kanakavarsha (IV, 208), his ambassador
sent to the Court of King Devasakti to secure the hand of
Princess Madanasundari has the good fortune of witnessing
" the elegance in the dance " of the princess. There is no
reason to presume that the art was known only in the Courts
and was not practised by respectable women in a humbler
sphere of life.

FOREWORD xv

Music was an equally popular art, both among men and
women. There were professors of singing as of dancing
(VI, 41). It is unnecessary for me here to quote further
instances, for they will be found throughout the tales.

Painting was also one of the fine arts held in high esteem.
Picture galleries were a regular feature in royal palaces
(IV, 205), and portrait painters moved from one Court to
another, being often entrusted with delicate missions. The
art of fresco-painting, of which such excellent examples
survive at Ajanta and Bagh, was also in request. The father
of the Princess Hamsavali employs an artist to paint his
daughter's bower, and the artist thereupon paints the Prince
Kamalakara and his servants on the wall of the bower (VI, 41).
The kindred arts of sculpture and architecture must have
nourished at the same time, for they were neede4 not only for
the palaces of which we have such glowing descriptions in
various stories, but also for the temples and the figures in
them, to which there is constant reference. There are also
indications in various passages in the Ocean that gardening
was a highly patronised art.

Among professions of a different type to which allusion is
made in the Ocean are those of the astrologer and the fortune-
teller. It was recognised that there were many pretenders in
these professions, and much fun is made of the dupes of false
astrologers in the story of the Brahman Harisarman (III, 70).
A story of similar purport in regard to fortune-tellers will be
found at II, 90.

References to the economic condition of the people are
unfortunately meagre in the Ocean. We find Brahmans and
others subsisting on royal grants of land, but no details are
available of the conditions of tenure of such grants or of other
land. Slavery was a recognised institution. We have in
the story of Dharmadatta (III, 7) a case of a female slave
in the house of a Brahman married to "an excellent hired
servant in the house of a certain merchant." In this instance
at any rate the bonds of slavery were not rigorous, for
the woman and her (free) husband were permitted to set
up a separate house of their own. It would have been
interesting to know whether she was only a life slave, or

VOL. IX. 6

xvi THE OCEAN OF STORY

whether the offspring of the union would have become
slaves.

The same story furnishes a description of " a grievous
famine." Owing to it the allowance of food which the couple
received every day " began to come to them in small quanti-
ties. Then their bodies became attenuated by hunger, and
they began to despond in mind, when once on a time at meal-
time there arrived a weary Brahman guest. To him they
gave all their own food (cooked rice brought from the houses
of their respective masters), as much as they had, though they
were in danger of their lives." The famine must have been
grievous indeed to compel a Brahman to eat cooked rice from
the hands of low-caste slaves. After the Brahman has eaten
and departed, the husband dies of starvation, and the wife
" lays down the load of her own calamity " by burning her-
self with her husband's corpse. The miseries and privations
suffered during famines, together with the familiar phenom-
enon of migration of whole families with their cattle from
famine-stricken tracts, are vividly portrayed in several other
passages in the Ocean (II, 196, and VI, 27). In the story of
Chandrasvamin (IV, 220) even " the King began to play the
bandit, leaving the right path and taking wealth from his
subjects unlawfully." There is unfortunately no description
in any story of special measures of protection or prevention
such as watercourses, embankments, or grain stores which
must have been familiar to the people.

The amusing story of Devadasa (II, 86) is based on the
habit of hoarding gold — a propensity which has not yet died
out in the country. There are no stories about money-lenders
— a theme which might have easily provided some humorous
situations.

Trade and commerce were honourable professions, and
the stories abound in references to merchants who not only
traded between different parts of the country, but ventured
across the seas. In the story of the Golden City, we find
Saktideva accompanying seafaring merchants from the sea-
port of Vitankapura to the islands in the midst of the ocean
(II, 191). The merchant Hiranyagupta (IV, 160), after getting
together wares, goes off to an island named Suvarnabhumi

FOREWORD xvii

to trade, and afterwards travels " some days over the sea " in
a ship (see also IV, 190-191, V, 198, and VII, 15). Realistic
descriptions of countries beyond the seas are not likely to be
found in the work of editors living in land-locked Kashmir,
but it is clear that in the epoch of Somadeva there was no
social or religious ban on sea-voyages, even of considerable
duration. The circumstances that led to the subsequent
prejudice against sea- voyages would be an appropriate subject
for research by the student of Indian social history.

Curiously enough, one is disappointed at the absence in
a work edited in Kashmir of clear references to the regions
north and west of India. In the legendary account in II,
93, 94, of Udayana's conquests there are vague allusions to
the defeat of Mlechchhas, Turushkas, Parasikas and Hiinas,
but this appears to be a mere echo of the account of the con-
quests of Raghu in Kalidasa. In another story (III, 185)
four young merchants travel " to the northern region,
abounding in barbarians," where they are sold to a Tajika
(Persian ?), who sends them as a present to a Turushka
(Turk). After a miraculous escape, three of the travellers
prefer to leave a quarter of the world infested with bar-
barians and return to the Deccan, while the fourth finally
reaches the banks of the Vitasta (the Jhelum). It must be
confessed that even this passage is not very illuminating.

We also look in vain in the stories for any enlightening
evidence about the favourite crops and vegetables. Among
edible fruits, mango, citron, dmalaka and jambu are men-
tioned, as also triphald, which Tawney interprets to mean
three varieties of myrobolan. Fish appears to have been
popular, at least with certain classes, for we have many
references to fishermen and fishing. The flesh of deer and
other wild animals was consumed, but there is no evidence
of any animals reared for food. In the allegorical tale of
Arthavarman and Bhogavarman (IV, 196), even the abstemi-
ous and dyspeptic Arthavarman has a meal consisting of
" barley-meal, with half a pala of ghee, and a little rice and
a small quantity of meat-curry" while Bhogavarman, who
believes in good living, soon after a meal at a friend's house
where he has " excellent food " with wine returns home and

xviii THE OCEAN OF STORY

M again enjoys all kinds of viands and wines at his own house
in the evening."

It is hoped that the examples given above will illustrate
how the stories in the Ocean give us very interesting glimpses
into the social and economic life of the later centuries in the
" Hindu period " of the history of India. In this respect they
ought to prove valuable to the historical student who has at
present only very limited material at his disposal.

As a pupil of Charles Tawney at Calcutta, it is gratifying
to me to be associated in a humble manner with a work which
will remain for ever a testimony to his erudition, industry
and scholarly method. Precision of thought and expression,
thoroughness and breadth of mind were the striking attributes
of Tawney's character. Kindliness of temper and a genial
sense of humour endeared him to his pupils.

It may be permitted to me to congratulate Mr Penzer
on the completion of his work as editor. Alike in conception
and in execution, it has been a great task. The magnificent
results must be a source of pride both to Mr Penzer and his
publisher.

Atul C. Chatter jee.

I

CONTENTS

BOOK XVIII: VISHAMASILA
CHAPTER CXX

PAG1

Author's Preface ..... xxiii

Invocation . . . . . .1

M(ain story) . . . . . .1

171. Story of King Vikramaditya . . .2

CHAPTER CXXI

171. Story of King Vikramaditya . . .12

171a. Madanamanjari and the Kapalika . 12

171aa. The Cunning Gambler

Dagineya and the Vetala
Agnisikha . . .14

171aaa. The Bold Gambler

Thinthakarala . 17

171aa. The Cunning Gambler

Dagineya and the Vetala
Agnisikha . . 26

171a. Madanamanjari and the Kapalika . 27

171. Story of King Vikramaditya . . .28

171b. Ghanta and Nighanta and the Two

Maidens . . . .29

PAGE

xx THE OCEAN OF STORY

CHAPTER CXXI— continued

171. Story of King Vikramaditya . . .29

171c. Jayanta and the Golden Deer . 29

171. Story of King Vikramaditya . . .30

CHAPTER CXXII
171. Story of King Vikramaditya . . .34

CHAPTER CXXIII
171. Story of King Vikramaditya . . .43

171d. Kalingasena's Marriage to King Vikra-
maditya . . . .43

171d (1). The Grateful Monkey . 47

171d. Kalingasena's Marriage to King Vikra-
maditya . . . .48

171d (2). The Two Princesses . 50

171d. Kalingasena's Marriage to King Vikra-
maditya . . . .52

171d (3). The Merchant Dhanadatta

who lost his Wife . 53

171d (4). The Two Brahmans Kesata

and Kandarpa . . 54

171d (5). Kusumayudha and Kamala-

lochana . ... 61

CONTENTS xxi

CHAPTER CXXIII— continued

PAOB

171d (4). The Two Brahmans Kesata

and Kandarpa . . 62

171d (3). The Merchant Dhanadatta

who lost his Wife • 66

171d. Kalingasena's Marriage to King Vikra-
maditya . . . .67

CHAPTER CXXIV

171d. Kalingasena's Marriage to King Vikra-
maditya . . . .68

171d (6). The Brahman who re-
covered his Wife alive
after her Death . . 68

171d. Kalingasena's Marriage to King Vikra-
maditya . . . .70

171. Story of King Vikramaditya . . .71

171e. The Permanently Horripilant Brahman 74

171. Story of King Vikramaditya • • ,75

171f. The Brahman AgniSarman and his

Wicked Wife . . .75

i

171. Story of King Vikramaditya . . ,77

171g. Muladeva and the Brahman's Daughter 77
171. Story of King Vikramaditya . . .85

M. Concluded . . . . .85

XX11

THE OCEAN OF STORY

Author's Epilogue ....

PAGE

. 87

Terminal Essay ....

. 91

Retrospect .....

. 122

Index I — Sanskrit Words and Proper Names .

. 127

Index II — General ....

. 133

Addenda and Corrigenda

. 139

Bibliography .....

. 169

PREFACE

THE present volume sees the conclusion of the Ocean,
and we leave Siva, with his beloved Parvati, on the
summit of Mount Kailasa.

Somadeva's Epilogue is now given for the first time — the
translation and notes being the work of Dr Barnett.

My Terminal Essay follows.

In a work of this size, the publication of which stretches
over a number of years, it is only natural that much additional
matter, as well as slips and errors, both in the text and in
the notes, are bound to accrue. I have considered it best to
put all this fresh material in the present volume under the
general title of " Addenda and Corrigenda."

The rest of the volume is taken up with the Bibliography.
Volume X will contain various Appendixes and a single general
index to the complete work.

N. M. P.

St John's Wood, N.W.8,
November 1927.

i

xxin

THE
OCEAN OF STORY

(

BOOK XVIII : VISHAMASlLA

CHAPTER CXX
INVOCATION

GLORY be to that god, half of whose body is the
moon-faced Parvati, who is smeared with ashes white
as the rays of the moon, whose eyes gleam with a fire
like that of the sun and moon, who wears a half-moon on
his head !

May that elephant-faced god protect you, who, with
his trunk bent at the end, uplifted in sport, appears to be
bestowing successes !

[M] Then Naravahanadatta, in the hermitage of the
hermit Kasyapa, on that Black Mountain, said to the
assembled hermits : " Moreover, when, during my separa-
tion from the queen, Vegavati, who was in love with me,
took me and made me over to the protection of a science,
I longed to abandon the body, being separated from my
beloved and in a foreign land; but while, in this state of
mind, I was roaming about in a remote part of the forest,
I beheld the great hermit Kanva.

" That compassionate hermit, seeing me bowing at his
feet, and knowing by the insight of profound meditation
.. that I was miserable, took me to his hermitage, and said
* to me : 4 Why are you distracted, though you are a hero
sprung from the race of the Moon ? As the ordinance of
the god standeth sure, why should you despair of reunion
with your wife ?

" ' The most unexpected meetings do take place for men
in this world. I will tell you, to illustrate this, the story of
Vikramaditya. Listen.

VOL. IX. 1 A

2 THE OCEAN OF STORY

171. Story of King Vikramdditya1

There is in Avanti a famous city, named UjjayinI, the
dwelling-place of Siva, built by Visvakarman in the com-
mencement of the Yuga ; which, like a virtuous woman, is
invincible by strangers ; like a lotus plant, is the resort of
the Goddess of Prosperity ; like the heart of the good, is rich
in virtue ; like the earth, is full of many wonderful sights.

There dwelt in that city a world-conquering king, named
Mahendraditya, the slayer of his enemies' armies, like Indra
in Amaravati. In regard of prowess he was a wielder of
many weapons ; in regard of beauty he was the flower-
weaponed god himself; his hand was ever open in bounty,
but was firmly clenched on the hilt of his sword. That king
had a wife named Saumyadarsana, who was to him as Sachi
to Indra, as Gauri to Siva, as Sri to Vishnu. And that king
had a great minister named Sumati, and a warder named
Vajrayudha, in whose family the office was hereditary. With
these the king remained ruling his realm, propitiating Siva,
and ever bearing various vows in order to obtain a son.

In the meanwhile, as Siva was with Parvati on the mighty
mountain Kailasa, the glens of which are visited by troops
of gods, which is beautiful with the smile that the northern
quarter smiles, joyous at vanquishing all the others, all the
gods, with Indra at their head, came to visit him, being
afflicted by the oppression of the Mlechchhas 2 ; and the
immortals bowed, and then sat down and praised Siva. And
when he asked them the reason of their coming, they addressed
to him this prayer : " O God, those Asuras, who were slain
by thee and Vishnu, have been now again born on the earth
in the form of Mlechchhas. They slay Brahmans, they
interfere with the sacrifices and other ceremonies, and they
carry off the daughters of hermits : indeed, what crime do
not the villains commit ? Now, thou knowest, lord, that

1 This story, with its numerous sub-stories, stretches to p. 85, and forms
the last tale in the whole work. — n.m.p.

2 I.e. "outer barbarian" — anyone who disregards Hindu dharma. The
name occurs continually in the Mahabharata. See Sorensen's Index, p. 480
el seq. — n.m.p.

THE GANA MALYAVAT 3

the world of gods is ever nourished by the earth, for the
oblation offered in the fire by Brahmans nourishes the
dwellers in heaven. But, as the Mlechchhas have overrun
the earth, the auspicious words are nowhere pronounced over
the burnt-offering, and the world of gods is being exhausted
by the cutting off of their share of the sacrifice and other
supplies.1 So devise an expedient in this matter; cause
some hero to become incarnate on the earth, mighty enough
to destroy those Mlechchhas."

When Siva had been thus entreated by the gods, he
said to them : " Depart ! You need not be anxious about
this matter ; be at your ease. Rest assured that I will soon
devise an expedient which will meet the difficulty." When
Siva had said this, he dismissed the gods to their abodes.2

And when they had gone, the holy one, with Parvati at
his side, summoned a Gana, named Malyavat, and gave him
this order : " My son, descend into the condition of a man,
and be born in the city of Ujjayini as the brave son of King
Mahendraditya. That king is a portion of me, and his wife
is sprung from a portion of Ambika ; be born in their family,
and do the heaven-dwellers the service they require. Slay
all those Mlechchhas that obstruct the fulfilment of the law
contained in the three Vedas. And by my favour thou shalt
be a king ruling over the seven divisions of the world.
Moreover, the Rakshasas, the Yakshas and the Vetalas shall
own thy supremacy 3 ; and after thou hast enjoyed human
pleasures, thou shalt again return to me."

When the Gana Malyavat received this command from
Siva, he said : " The command of you two divine beings can-
not be disobeyed by me ; but what enjoyments are there in
the life of a man which involve separations from relations,
i, friends and servants very hard to bear, and the pain aris-
ing from loss of wealth, old age, disease and the other ills
of humanity ? " When the Gana said this to Siva, the god

1 The central idea of the Birds of Aristophanes.

2 Here Bohtlingk and Roth would read svadhishnyany. Two of the three
India Office MSS. seem to read this, judging from the way in which they form
the comhination shn. No. 1882 is not quite clear.

3 He is a kind of Hindu Solomon.

4 THE OCEAN OF STORY

thus replied : " Go, blameless one ! These woes shall not
fall to thy lot. By my favour thou shalt be happy throughout
the whole of thy sojourn on earth." When Siva said this
to Malyavat, that virtuous Gana immediately disappeared.
And he went and was conceived in Ujjayini, in the proper
season, in the womb of the queen of King Mahendraditya.

And at that time the god, whose diadem is fashioned of
a digit of the moon, said to that king in a dream : "I am
pleased with thee, King : so a son shall be born to thee, who
by his might shall conquer the earth with all its divisions ;
and that hero shall reduce under his sway the Yakshas,
Rakshasas, Pisachas and others — even those that move in
the air and dwell in Patala — and shall slay the hosts of the
Mlechchhas : for this reason he shall be named Vikrama-
ditya, and also Vishamasila, on account of his stern hostility
to his enemies." 1

When the god had said this, he disappeared ; and next
morning the king woke up, and joyfully related his dream to
his ministers. And they also told the king, one after another,
with great delight, that Siva had made a revelation to each
of them in a dream that he was to have a son. And at that
moment a handmaid of the harem came and showed the king
a fruit,2 saying : " Siva gave this to the queen in a dream."
Then the king rejoiced, saying again and again : " Truly, Siva
has given me a son " ; and his ministers congratulated him.

Then his illustrious queen became pregnant, like the
eastern quarter in the morning, when the orb of the sun is
about to rise ; and she was conspicuous for the black tint of
the nipples of her breasts, which appeared like a seal to secure
the milk for the king with whom she was pregnant. In her
dreams at that time she crossed seven seas, being worshipped
by all the Yakshas, Vetalas and Rakshasas. And when the
due time was come, she brought forth a glorious son, who lit
up the chamber, as the rising sun does the heaven. And when
he was born, the sky became indeed glorious, laughing with
the falling rain of flowers, and ringing with the noise of the

1 I adopt the correction of the Petersburg lexicographers, vaishamyato for
vaisasyato. I find it in No. 1882 and in the Sanskrit College MS.

2 See Vol. II, p. 136'n1; and Vol. Ill, p. 263n2.— n.m.p.

I

THE BIRTH OF VIKRAMADITYA 5

gods' drums. And on that occasion the city was altogether
distracted with festive joy, and appeared as if intoxicated,
as if possessed by a demon, as if generally wind-struck.
And at that time the king rained wealth there so unceasingly
that, except the Buddhists, no one was without a god.1 And
King Mahendraditya gave him the name of Vikramaditya,
which Siva had mentioned, and also that of Vishamasila.

When some more days had passed, there was born to
that king's minister named Sumati a son, of the name of
Mahamati, and the warder Vajrayudha had a son born to him,
named Bhadrayudha, and the chaplain Mahidhara had a son
of the name of Sridhara. And that prince Vikramaditya
grew up with those three ministers' sons as with spirit,
courage and might. When he was invested with the sacred
thread, and put under teachers, they were merely the occa-
sions of his learning the sciences, which revealed themselves
to him without effort. And whatever science or accomplish-
ment he was seen to employ, was known by those, who
understood it, to be possessed by him to the highest degree
of excellence. And when people saw that prince fighting
with heavenly weapons, they even began to pay less atten-
tion to the stories about the great archer Rama and other
heroes of the kind. And his father brought for him beautiful
maidens, given by kings who had submitted after defeat, like
so many goddesses of fortune.

Then his father, King Mahendraditya, seeing that his son
was in the bloom of early manhood, of great valour, and
beloved by his subjects, duly anointed him heir to his realm,
and, being himself old, retired with his wife and ministers to
Varanasi,2 and made the god Siva his refuge.

And King Vikramaditya, having obtained that kingdom
of his father, began in due course to blaze forth, as the sun,
when it has occupied the sky. Even haughty kings, when
they saw the string fitted into the notch of his bending bow,3

1 The word anlsvara, when applied to the Buddhists, refers to their not
believing in a Disposer, but its other meaning is "wanting in health."

2 I.e. Benares.

3 As Dr Kern points out, there is a misprint here : namatya should be
namaty.

6 THE OCEAN OF STORY

learned a lesson from that weapon, and bent likewise on every
side. Of godlike dignity, having subdued to his sway even
Vetalas, Rakshasas and other demons, he chastised righteously
those that followed evil courses. The armies of that Vikra-
maditya roamed over the earth like the rays of the sun,
shedding into every quarter the light of order. Though that
king was a mighty hero, he dreaded the other world ; though
a brave warrior, he was not hard-handed x ; though not
uxorious, he was beloved by his wives. He was the father
of all the fatherless, the friend of all the friendless, and the
protector of all the unprotected among his subjects. Surely
his glory furnished the Disposer with the material out of
which he built up the White Island, the Sea of Milk, Mount
Kailasa and the Himalayas.2

And one day, as the King Vikramaditya was in the hall
of assembly, the warder Bhadrayudha came in and said to
him : " Your Majesty dispatched Vikramasakti with an
army to conquer the southern region and other territories, and
then sent to him a messenger named Anangadeva ; that
messenger has now returned, and is at the gate with another,
and his delighted face announces good tidings, my lord."
The king said, " Let him enter," and then the warder
respectfully introduced Anangadeva, with his companion.
The messenger entered and bowed, and shouted, " Victory ! " 3
and sat down in front of the king ; and then the king said
to him : " Is it well with King Vikramasakti, the general
of my forces, and with Vyaghrabala and the other kings ?
And does good fortune attend on the other chief Rajputs
in his army, and on the elephants, horses, chariots and
footmen ? "

When Anangadeva had been thus questioned by the
king, he answered : "It is well with Vikramasakti and
the whole of the army. And your Majesty has conquered
the Deccan and the western border, and Madhyadesa and
Saurashtra and all the eastern region of the Ganges ; and

1 Or "not cruel in exacting tribute."

2 Glory is white according to the canons of Hindu rhetoric.

3 It might merely mean, cried " All Hail," but here I think there is more
in the expression than in the usual salutation.

ANANGADEVA THE MESSENGER 7

the northern region and Kasmira have been made tribu-
tary; and various forts and islands have been conquered;
and the hosts of the Mlechchhas have been slain, and the
rest have been reduced to submission ; and various kings
have entered the camp of Vikramas'akti, and he himself is
coming here with those kings, and is now, my lord, two or
three marches off."

When the messenger had thus told his tale, King Vikra-
maditya was pleased, and loaded ' him with garments,
ornaments and villages. Then the king went on to say to
that noble messenger : " Anangadeva, when you went there,
what regions did you see, and what object of interest did you
meet with anywhere ? Tell me, my good fellow ! " When
Anangadeva had been thus questioned by the king, he began
to recount his adventures, as follows :

" Having set out hence by your Majesty's orders, I reached
in course of time that army of yours assembled under Vikra-
masakti, which was like a broad sea resorted to by allied
The Adventures kings, adorned by many princes of the Nagas that
of Ayiangadeva^d come together with horses and royal magni-
ficence.2 And when I arrived there, that Vikramasakti bowed
before me, and treated me with great respect, because I had
been sent by his sovereign ; and while I was there considering
the nature of the triumphs he had gained, a messenger from
the King of Simhala 3 came there.

" And that messenger, who had come from Simhala, told
to Vikramasakti, in my presence, his master's message, as
follows : ' I have been told by messengers, who have been
sent by me to your sovereign and have returned, that your
sovereign's very heart, Anangadeva, is with you, so send him
to me quickly ; I will reveal to him a certain auspicious affair
that concerns your king.' Then Vikramasakti said to me :

1 Dr Kern would read abhyapujayat = honoured. The three India Office
MSS. and the Sanskrit College MS. confirm Brockhaus' text.

2 A most elaborate pun ! There is an allusion to the sea having proved
the refuge of the mountains that wished to preserve their wings, to the serpent
Vasuki's having served as a rope with which to whirl round Mount Mandara
when the sea was churned and produced Sri or Lakshmi. In this exploit Hari
or Vishnu bore a distinguished part.

3 I.e. Ceylon.

8 THE OCEAN OF STORY

4 Go quickly to the King of Simhala, and see what he wishes
to say to you when he has you before him.'

"Then I went through the sea in a ship to the island
of Simhala with that King of Simhala's ambassador. And in
that island I saw a palace all made of gold, with terraces of
various jewels, like the city of the gods. And in it I saw that
King of Simhala, Virasena, surrounded by obedient ministers,
as Indra is by the gods. When I approached him he received
me politely, and asked me about your Majesty's health, and
then he refreshed me with most sumptuous hospitality.

"The next day the king summoned me, when he was
in his hall of audience, and showing his devotion to you,
said to me, in the presence of his ministers : ' I have a
maiden daughter, the peerless beauty of the world of mortals,
Madanalekha by name, and I offer her to your king. She
is a fitting wife for him, and he a suitable husband for
her. For this reason I have invited you ; so accept her
in the name of your king.1 And go on in front with my
ambassador to tell your master ; I will send my daughter
here close after you.'

" When the king had said this, he summoned into that
hall his daughter, whose load of ornaments was adorned by
her graceful shape, loveliness and youth. And he made
her sit on his lap, and showing her, said to me : 4 1 offer
this girl to your master : receive her.' And when I saw that
princess I was astonished at her beauty, and I said joyfully,
' I accept this maiden on behalf of my sovereign,' and I
thought to myself : ' Well, the Creator is never tired of pro-
ducing marvels, since even after creating Tilottama he has
produced this far superior beauty.'

"Then, having been honoured by that king, I set forth
from that island, with this ambassador of his, Dhavalasena.
So we embarked on a ship, and as we were sailing along in
it, through the sea, we suddenly saw a great sandbank in the
middle of the ocean. And on it we saw two maidens of
singular beauty : one had a body as dark as priyangu,2 the

1 Bohtlingk and Roth explain pratlpsa in this passage as werben um.

2 This is a well-known small millet, " Panic " (JPanicum ltalicum). It is
familiar to Kashmiris, who now call it pingi. — n.m.p.

THE TWO SEA-MAIDENS 9

other gleamed white like the moon, and they both looked
more splendid from having put on dresses and ornaments
suited to their respective hues. They made a sound like the
clashing of cymbals with their bracelets adorned with splendid
gems, and they were making a young toy-deer, which, though
of gold and studded with jewels to represent spots, possessed
life, dance in front of them.1 When we saw this we were
astonished, and we said to one another : ' What can this
wonder mean ? Is it a dream, magic or delusion ? Who
would ever expect to see a sandbank suddenly start up in
the middle of the ocean, or such maidens upon it ? And
who would ever have thought of seeing such a thing as this
living golden deer studded with jewels, which they possess ?
Such things are not usually found together.'

4 While we were saying this to one another, King, in
the greatest astonishment, a wind suddenly began to blow,
tossing up the sea. That wind broke up our ship, which
was resting on the surging waves, and the people in it were
whelmed in the sea, and the sea-monsters began to devour
them. But those two maidens came and supported both of
us in their arms, and lifted us up and carried us to the sand-
bank, so that we escaped the jaws of the sea-monsters. And
then that bank began to be covered with waves, at which we
were terrified; but those two ladies cheered us, and made
us enter what seemed like the interior of a cave. There we
began to look at a heavenly wood of various trees, and while
we were looking at it the sea disappeared, and the bank and
the young deer and the maidens.

" We wandered about there for a time, saying to ourselves :
4 What is this strange thing ? It is assuredly some magic.'
And then we saw there a great lake, transparent, deep and
broad, like the heart of great men, looking like a material
representation of Nirvana that allays the fire of desire.2

1 I read pranartayantyau with Dr Kern for the obvious misprint in the text.
The y is found in the three India Office MSS. and in the Sanskrit College MS.

Tawney refers us to Iliad, xviii, 417-420, but the gold and silver dogs

of Odyssey, vii, 91, are surely more apposite. See my note on "Automata"
in Vol. Ill, pp. 56-59, and Crooke, "Some Notes on Homeric Folk-Lore,"
Folk-Lore, vol. xix, p. 71. — n.m.p.

2 In the original, trishna.

10 THE OCEAN OF STORY

41 And we saw a certain beautiful woman coming to bathe
in it, accompanied by her train, looking like an incarnation
of the beauty of the wood. And that lady alighted from
her covered chariot1 and gathered lotuses in that lake, and
bathed in it, and meditated on Siva. And thereupon, to our
astonishment, Siva arose from the lake, a present god, in the
form of a linga, composed of splendid jewels, and came near
her ; and that fair one worshipped him with various luxuries
suited to her Majesty, and then took her lyre. And then she
played upon it, singing skilfully to it with rapt devotion,
following the southern style in respect of notes, time and
words. So splendid was her performance that even the
Siddhas and other beings appeared there in the air, having
their hearts attracted by hearing it, and remained motion-
less, as if painted. And after she had finished her music 2
she dismissed the god, and he immediately sank in the lake.
Then the gazelle-eyed lady rose up and mounted her chariot,
and proceeded to go away slowly with her train.

" We followed her, and eagerly asked her train over and
over again who she was, but none of them gave us any answer.
Then, wishing to show that ambassador of the King of
Simhala your might, I said to her aloud : * Auspicious one,
I adjure thee, by the touch of King Vikramaditya's feet, that
thou depart not hence without revealing to me who thou
art.' When the lady heard this she made her train retire,
and alighted from her chariot, and coming up to me, she said
with a gentle voice : ' Is my lord the noble King Vikrama-
ditya well ? But why do I ask, Anangadeva, since I know
all about him ? For I exerted magic power, and brought
you here for the sake of that king, for I must honour hiny as
he delivered me from a great danger. So come to my palace ;
there I will tell you all — who I am, and why I ought to honour
that king, and what service he needs to have done him.'

44 When she had said this, having left her chariot out of
courtesy, that fair one went along the path on foot and respect-

1 All the India Office MSS. give karnirathavatirna.

2 The word Gandharva should be Gandharva ; see Bohtlingk and Roth,
s.v. har with upa and sain. No. 2166 has Gdndharas; the other two MSS.
agree with Brockhaus' text.

MADANAMANJARI'S CASTLE 11

fully conducted me to her castle, which looked like heaven.
It was built of various jewels and different kinds of gold ;
its gates were guarded on every side by brave warriors wear-
ing various forms and bearing various weapons; and it was
full of noble ladies of remarkable beauty, looking as if they
were charms that drew down endless heavenly enjoyments.
There she honoured us with baths, unguents, splendid dresses
and ornaments, and made us rest for a time."

P

CHAPTER CXXI

171. Story of King Vikramdditya

WHEN Anangadeva had told this to King Vikrama-
ditya in his hall of audience, he continued as follows :
" Then, after I had taken food, that lady, sit-
ting in the midst of her attendants, said to me : ' Listen,
Anangadeva, I will now tell you all.

171a. Madanamanjari and the Kdpdlika1

I am Madanamanjari, the daughter of Dundubhi, the
King of the Yakshas, and the wife of Manibhadra, the brother
of Kuvera. I used always to roam about happily with my
husband on the banks of rivers, on hills, and in charming
groves.

And one day I went with my beloved to a garden in
Ujjayini called Makaranda to amuse myself. There it
happened that in the dawn a low hypocritical scoundrel of
a kdpdlika l saw me, when I had just woke up from a sleep
brought on by the fatigue of roaming about. That rascal,
being overcome with love, went into a cemetery, and pro-
ceeded to try to procure me for his wife by means of a spell
and a burnt-offering. But I, by my power, found out what
he was about, and informed my husband ; and he told his
elder brother, Kuvera. And Kuvera went and complained
to Brahma, and the holy Brahma, after meditating, said to
him : " It is true that kdpdlika intends to rob your brother
of his wife, for such is the power of those spells for master-
ing Yakshas, which he possesses. But when she feels herself

1 Bohtlingk and Roth explain the word khandakdpdlika as " ein Stuck von
einem Kapalika, ein Quasi-kapalika." A kdpdlika is, according to Monier
Williams, s.v., a worshipper of Siva of the left-hand order, characterised by
carrying skulls of men as ornaments, and by eating and drinking from them.

These are the same as the Aghori, for which see Vol. II, p. 90w3. — n.m.p.

12

THE MAGIC CIRCLE 13

being drawn along by the spell, she must invoke the pro-
tection of King Vikramaditya ; he will save her from him."
Then Kuvera came and told this answer of Brahma's to my
husband, and my husband told it to me, whose mind was
troubled by that wicked spell.

And in the meanwhile that hypocritical kdpdlika, offering
a burnt-offering in the cemetery, began to draw me to him
by means of a spell, duly muttered in a circle. And I, being
drawn by that spell, reached in an agony of terror that awful
cemetery, full of bones and skulls, haunted by demons. And
then I saw there that wicked kdpdlika : he had made an
offering to the fire, and he had in a circle 1 a corpse lying on
its back, which he had been worshipping. And that kdpdlika,
when he saw that I had arrived, was beside himself with
pride, and with difficulty tore himself away to rinse his
mouth in a river, which happened to be near.

At that moment I called to mind what Brahma had said,
and I thought : " Why should I not call to the king for aid ?
He may be roaming about in the darkness somewhere near."
When I had said this to myself, I called aloud for his help in
the following words : " Deliver me, noble King Vikrama-
ditya ! See, protecting talisman of the world, this kdpdlika
is bent on outraging by force, in your realm, me, a chaste
woman, the Yakshi Madanamanjarl by name, the daughter of
Dundubhi, and the wife of Manibhadra, the younger brother
of Kuvera."

No sooner had I finished this plaintive appeal than I saw
that king coming toward me, sword in hand ; he seemed to
be all resplendent with brightness of valour, and he said to
me : " My good lady, do not fear ; be at ease. I will deliver
you from that kdpdlika, fair one. For who is able to work
such unrighteousness in my realm ? " When he had said
this, he summoned a Vetala, named Agnislkha. And he, when
summoned, came — tall, with flaming eyes, with upstanding
hair — and said to the king: "Tell me what I am to do."
Then the king said : " Kill and eat this wicked kdpdlika,
who is trying to carry off his neighbour's wife." Then that

1 For the magic circle see Vol. II, p. 98m4, and Vol. Ill, p. 201 et seq. —

N.M.P.

14 THE OCEAN OF STORY

Vetala, Agnisikha, entered the corpse that was in the circle
of adoration, and rose up and rushed forward, stretching out
his arms and mouth. And when the kdpdlika, who had come
back from rinsing his mouth, was preparing to fly, he seized
him from behind by the legs ; and he whirled him round in
the air, and then dashed him down with great force on the
earth, and so at one blow crushed his body and his aspirations.
When the demons saw the kdpdlika slain they were all
eager for flesh, and a fierce Vetala, named Yamaslkha, came
there. As soon as he came he seized the body of the kdpd-
lika ; then the first Vetala, Agnisikha, said to him : " Hear,
villain ! I have killed this kdpdlika by the order of King
Vikramaditya ; pray what have you to do with him ? "
When Yamasikha heard that, he said to him : " Then tell
me, what kind of power has that king ? " Then Agnisikha
said : "If you do not know the nature of his power, listen,
I will tell you.

171aa. The Cunning Gambler Ddgineya and the Vetala
Agnisikha who submitted himself to King Vikramaditya

There once lived in this city a very resolute gambler of
the name of Dagineya. Once on a time some gamblers, by
fraudulent play, won from him all he possessed, and then
bound him in order to obtain from him the borrowed money
which he had lost in addition. And as he had nothing, they
beat him with sticks and other instruments of torture,1 but
he made himself like a stone, and seemed as rigid as a corpse.
Then all those wicked gamblers took him and threw him into
a large dark well, fearing that, if he lived, he might take
vengeance on them.

But that gambler Dagineya, when flung down into that
very deep well, saw in front of him two great and terrible
men. But they, when they saw him fall down terrified, said
to him kindly : " Who are you, and how have you managed
to fall into this deep well ? Tell us ! " Then the gambler

1 For aruntudais, MS. No. 1882 has adadanstachcha, No. 2 1 66 has adadattascha
and 3003 adadattuscha. These point, I suppose, to a reading adadattachcha ;
which means, "not paying what he owed."

THE DEMONS' TALE 15

recovered his spirits, and told them his story, and said to
them : " Do you also tell me who you are, and whence you
come." When those men who were in the pit heard that,
they said : " Good sir, we were Brahman demons ' dwelling
in the cemetery belonging to this city, and we possessed two
maidens in this very city ; one was the daughter of the
principal minister, the other of the chief merchant. And
no conjurer on the earth, however powerful his spells, was
able to deliver those maidens from us.

" Then King Vikramaditya, who had an affection for their
fathers, heard of it, and came to the place where those
maidens were with a friend of their fathers'. The moment
we saw the king, we left the maidens and tried to escape,
but we were not able to do so, though we tried our utmost.
We saw the whole horizon on fire with his splendour. Then
that king, seeing us, bound us by his power. And seeing us
unhappy, as we were afraid of being put to death, he gave
us this order : * Ye wicked ones, dwell for a year in a dark
pit, and then ye shall be set at liberty. But when freed,
ye must never again commit such a crime ; if ye do, I will
punish you with destruction.' After King Vishamasila had
given us this order, he had us flung into this dark pit ; but
out of mercy he did not destroy us.

" And in eight more days the year will be completed, and
with it the period during which we were to dwell in this cave,
and we shall then be released from it. Now, friend, if you
engage to supply us with some food during those days, we
will lift you out of this pit, and set you down outside it ; but
if you do not, when lifted out, supply us with food according
to your engagement, we will certainly, when we come out,
devour you."

When the Brahman demons made this proposal to the
gambler, he consented to it, and they put him out of the pit.
When he got out of it, he went to the cemetery at night to
deal in human flesh, as he saw no other chance of getting
what he wanted. And I, happening to be there at that time,
saw that gambler, who was crying out : "I have human flesh
for sale ; buy it, somebody ! " Then I said : "I will take it

1 Sanskrit, Brahma-Rakshasa.

16 THE OCEAN OF STORY

off your hands : what price do you want for it ? " And
he answered : " Give me your shape and power." Then I
said again to him : " My fine fellow, what will you do with
them ? " The gambler then told me his whole story, and
said to me : " By means of your shape and power I will get
hold of those enemies of mine, the gamblers, together with
the keeper of the gambling-house, and will give them to the
Brahman demons to eat." When I heard that, I was pleased
with the resolute spirit of that gambler, and gave him my
shape and my power for a specified period of seven days.
And by means of them he drew those men that had injured
him into his power, one after another, and flung them into
the pit, and fed the Brahman demons on them during seven
days.

Then I took back from him my shape and power, and that
gambler Dagineya, beside himself with fear, said to me : "I
have not given those Brahman demons any food this day,
which is the eighth, so they will now come out and devour
me. Tell me what I must do in this case, for you are my
friend." When he said this, I, having got to like him, from
being thrown with him, said to him : "If this is the case,
since you have made those two demons devour the gamblers,
I for your sake will in turn eat the demons. So show them
to me, my friend." When I made the gambler this offer, he
at once jumped at it, and took me to the pit where the demons
were.

I, suspecting nothing, bent my head down to look into
the pit, and, while I was thus engaged, the gambler put his
hand on the back of my neck and pushed me into it. When
I fell into it, the demons took me for someone sent for them
to eat, and laid hold of me, and I had a wrestling-match with
them. When they foimd that they could not overcome the
might of my arms, they desisted from the struggle, and asked
me who I was.

Then I told them my own story from the point where my
fortunes became involved with those of Dagineya,1 and they
made friends with me, and said to me : " Alas ! What a
trick that evil-minded gambler has played you, and us two,

1 They had heard Dagineya' s story up to this point from his own lips.

THE GAMBLER'S CHALLENGE 17

and those other gamblers ! But what confidence can be
placed in gamblers who profess exclusively the science of
cheating ; whose minds are proof against friendship, pity and
gratitude for a benefit received ? Recklessness and disregard
of all ties are ingrained in the nature of gamblers : hear in
illustration of this the story of Thinthakarala.

171aaa. The Bold Gambler Thinthakarala

Long ago there lived in this very city of Uj jayini a ruffianly
gambler, who was rightly named Thinthakarala.1 He lost
perpetually, and the others, who won in the game, used to
give him every day a hundred cowries.* With those he
bought wheat-flour from the market, and in the evening
made cakes by kneading them somewhere or other in a pot
with water, and then he went and cooked theni in the flame
of a funeral pyre in the cemetery, and ate them in front of
Mahakala, smearing them with the grease from the lamp
burning before him : and he always slept at night on the
ground in the court of the same god's temple, pillowing his
head on his arm.

Now, one night he saw the images of all the Mothers,3
and of the Yakshas and other divine beings in the temple of
Mahakala trembling from the proximity of spells, and this
thought arose in his bosom : " Why should I not employ
an artful device here to obtain wealth ? If it succeedsj well
and good ; if it does not succeed, wherein am I the worse ? "
When he had gone through these reflections, he challenged
those deities to play, saying to them : " Come now, I will
have a game with you, and I will act as keeper of the

1 This may be loosely translated : " Terror of the gambling saloon."

2 I.e. Cyprcea moneta, found chiefly off the Maldive Islands, Ceylon, the
i Malabar coast, Borneo, etc. It was used as a currency both in India and

Africa. For a short bibliography on shell-money see Ency. Brit., 11th edit.,
vol. xxiv, p. 833. In Kashmir the cowrie appears to have been the unit of the
monetary system. The number of cowries that went to the rupee was 4096.
See further, M. A. Stein, Kalhanas RajataraAginl, vol. ii, pp. 323, 324 ; Yule's
Hobson-Jobson, under "Cowry," and especially Briffault, The Mothers, 1927,
vol. iii, pp. 275-278. — n.m.h.

3 See Ocean, Vol. IV, pp. 69m1, 225ft1 ; and Briffault, op. cit., vol. iii, ch. xxiv.

— N.M.P.

vol. IX. B

18 THE OCEAN OF STORY

gaming-table, and will fling the dice ; and mind, you must
always pay up what you lose." When he said this to the
deities, they remained silent ; so Thinthakarala staked some
spotted cowries, and flung the dice. For this is the universally
accepted rule among gamblers, that, if a gambler does not
object to the dice being thrown, he agrees to play.1

Then, having won much gold, he said to the deities :
" Pay me the money I have won, as you agreed to do." But
though the gambler said this to the deities over and over
again, they made no answer. Then he flew into a passion
and said to them : "If you remain silent, I will adopt with
you the same course as is usually adopted with a gambler
who will not pay the money he has lost, but makes himself
as stiff as a stone. I will simply saw through your limbs
with a saw as sharp as the points of Yama's teeth, for I have
no respect for anything." When he had said this, he ran
towards them, saw in hand ; and the deities immediately
paid him the gold he had won. Next morning he lost it all
at play, and in the evening he came back again, and extorted
more money from the Mothers in the same way by making
them play with him.

He went on doing this every day, and those deities, the
Mothers, were in very low spirits about it ; then the goddess
Chamunda said to them : " Whoever, when invited to gamble,
says, 'I sit out of this game,' cannot be forced to play; this
is the universal convention among gamblers, ye Mother deities.
So when he invites you, say this to him, and so baffle him."
When Chamunda had said this to the Mothers, they laid her
advice up in their minds. And when the gambler came at
night and invited them to play with him, all the goddesses
said with one accord : " We sit out of this game."

When Thinthakarala had been thus repulsed by those
goddesses, he invited their sovereign Mahakala himself to
play. But that god, thinking that the fellow had taken this
opportunity of trying to force him to gamble, said : " I sit
out of this game." Even gods, you see, like feeble persons,
are afraid of a thoroughly self-indulgent, ruffianly scoundrel,
flushed with impunity.

1 See Vol. VII, p. 72.

THE MANIFESTATION 19

Then that Thinthakarala, being depressed at finding his
gambler's artifice baffled by a knowledge of the etiquette
of play, was disgusted, and said to himself : " Alas ! I am
baffled by these deities through their learning the conven-
tions of gamblers ; so I must now flee for refuge to this
very sovereign of gods." Having formed this resolution in
his heart, Thinthakarala embraced the feet of Mahakala, and
praising him, addressed to him the following petition : "I
adore thee that sittest naked ■ with thy head resting on
thy knee ; thy moon, thy bull, and thy elephant-skin having
been won at play by Devi. When the gods give all powers
at thy mere desire, and when thou art free from longings,
having for thy only possessions the matted lock, the ashes and
the skull, how canst thou suddenly have become avaricious
with regard to hapless me, in that thou desirest to dis-
appoint me for so small a gain ? Of a truth the wishingr
tree no longer gratifies the hope of the poor, as thou dost
not support me, lord Bhairava, though thou supportest the
world. So, as I have fled to thee as a suppliant, holy Sthanu,
with my mind pierced with grievous woe, thou oughtest even
to pardon presumption in me. Thou hast three eyes, I have
three dice,2 so I am like thee in one respect ; thou hast ashes
on thy body, so have I ; thou eatest from a skull, so do I :
show me mercy. When I have conversed with you gods,
how can I afterwards bear to converse with gamblers ? So
deliver me from my calamity."

With this and similar utterances the gambler praised that
Bhairava, until at last the god was pleased, and manifesting
himself, said to him : " Thinthakarala, I am pleased with
thee ; do not be despondent. Remain here with me : I will
provide thee with enjoyments." In accordance with this
; command of the god's that gambler remained there, enjoying
all kinds of luxuries provided by the favour of the deity.

1 Two of the India Office MSS. and the Sanskrit College MS. have indu
* for Indra; the other has inmu. I have adopted indu. In sloka 100 for dadute

; No. 1882, and the Sanskrit College MS., read dadhate, which means that the
god's possession of wealth and power depends on the will of Siva. In //. 89
the Sanskrit College MS. reads ekada for the unmetrical devatah.

2 Tryaksha can probably mean " having three dice," as well as " having
three eyes."

20 THE OCEAN OF STORY

Now, one night the god saw certain Apsarases, that had
come to bathe in that holy pool of Mahakala, and he gave
this command to Thinthakarala : " While all these nymphs
of heaven are engaged in bathing, quickly snatch up the
clothes, which they have laid on the bank, and bring them
here ; and do not give them back their garments until they
surrender to you this young nymph, named Kalavati." x

When Thinthakarala had received this command from
Bhairava, he went and carried off the garments of those
heavenly beauties, while they were bathing ; and they said
to him : " Give us back our garments, please ; do not leave
us naked." But he answered them, confident in the power
which Siva gave : "If you will give me the young nymph
Kalavati, I will give you back these garments, but not
otherwise." When they heard that, seeing that he was a
stubborn fellow to deal with, and remembering that Indra
had pronounced a curse of this kind upon Kalavati, they
agreed to his demand. And on his giving back the garments,
they bestowed on him, in due form, Kalavati, the daughter
of Alambusha.

Then the Apsarases departed, and Thinthakarala re-
mained there with that Kalavati in a house built by the wish
of Siva. And Kalavati went in the day to heaven to attend
upon the king of the gods, but at night she always returned 2
to her husband. And one day she said to him in the ardour
of her affection : " My dear, the curse of Siva, which enabled
me to obtain you for a husband, has really proved a blessing."
Thereupon her husband, Thinthakarala, asked her the cause
of the curse, and the nymph Kalavati thus answered him :

" One day, when I had seen the gods in a garden, I praised
the enjoyments of mortals, depreciating the pleasures of the
dwellers in heaven, as giving joys that consist only in seeing.3
When the king of the gods heard that, he cursed me, saying :
* Thou shalt go and be married by a mortal, and enjoy those
human pleasures.' In this way has come about our union

1 Cf. Vol. VIII, p. 58, and see also Appendix I, on "Swan-maidens," in
that volume. — n.m.p.

2 Upayau is a misprint for upayayau, as is evident from the MSS.

3 The three India Office MSS. and the Sanskrit College MS. give drishti.

THE DIVINE COAT 21

that is mutually agreeable. And to-morrow I shall return
to heaven after a long absence : do not be unhappy about
it, for Rambha is going to dance a new piece before Vishnu,
and I must remain there, my beloved, until the exhibition
is at an end."

Then Thinthakarala, whom love had made like a spoiled
child, said to her : "I will go there and look at that dance
unperceived, take me there." When Kalavati heard that,
she said : " How is it fitting for me to do this ? The king
of the gods might be angry, if he found it out." Though
she said this to him, he continued to press her ; then, out of
love, she agreed to take him there.

So the next morning Kalavati, by her power, concealed
Thinthakarala in a lotus, which she placed as an ornament
in her ear, and took him to the palace of Indra.' When Thin-
thakarala saw that palace, the doors of which were adorned
by the elephant of the gods, which was set off by the garden
of Nandana, he thought himself a god, and was highly
delighted. And in the Court of Indra, frequented by gods,
he beheld the strange and delightful spectacle of Rambha's
dance, accompanied by the singing of all the nymphs of
heaven. And he heard all the musical instruments played by
Narada and the other minstrels ; for what is hard to obtain
in this world, if the supreme god l is favourable to one ?

Then, at the end of the exhibition, a mime, in the shape
of a divine goat, rose up, and began to dance with heavenly 2
movements. And Thinthakarala, when he saw him, recog-
nized him, and said to himself : " Why, I see this goat in
Ujjayini, figuring as a mere animal, and here he is dancing
as a mime before Indra. Of a truth this must be some
strange incomprehensible heavenly delusion." While Thin-
thakarala was going through these reflections in his mind,
the dance of the goat-mime came to an end, and then
Indra returned to his own place. And then Kalavati, in
high spirits, also took back Thinthakarala to his own home,
concealed in the lotus ornament of her ear.

1 I.e. Siva in this instance.

2 For the second divya in si. 132 b, MSS. Nos. 1882 and 2166 give navya,
"new."

22 THE OCEAN OF STORY

And the next day Thinthakarala beheld in Ujjayini that
goat-formed mime of the gods, who had returned there, and
he insolently said to him : " Come, dance before me, as you
dance before Indra. If you do not, I shall be angry with
you ; show off your dancing powers, you mime." When the
goat heard this he was astonished, and remained silent,
saying to himself: " How can this mere mortal know so much
about me ? " But when, in spite of persistent entreaties,
the goat refused to dance, Thinthakarala beat him on the
head with sticks. Then the goat went with bleeding head to
Indra, and told him all that had taken place. And Indra,
by his supernatural powers of contemplation, discovered the
whole secret, how Kalavati had brought Thinthakarala to
heaven when Rambha was dancing, and how that profane
fellow had there seen the goat dancing. Then Indra sum-
moned Kalavati, and pronounced on her the following curse :
" Since, out of love, thou didst secretly bring here the man
who has reduced the goat to this state to make him dance,
depart and become an image on a pillar 1 in the temple built
by King Narasimha in the city of Nagapura."

When Indra had said this, Alambusha, the mother of
Kalavati, tried to appease him, and at last he was with
difficulty appeased, and he thus fixed an end to the curse :
" When that temple, which it has taken many years to
complete, shall perish and be levelled with the ground, then
shall her curse come to an end." So Kalavati came weeping
and told to Thinthakarala the curse Indra had pronounced,
together with the end he had appointed to it, and how he
himself was to blame, and then, after giving him her orna-
ments, she entered into an image on the front of a pillar in
the temple in Nagapura.

Thinthakarala for his part, smitten with the poison of
separation from her, could neither hear nor see, but rolled
swooning on the ground. And when that gambler came to
his senses he uttered this lament : " Alas ! fool that I was.
I revealed the secret, though I knew better all the time — for
how can people like myself, who are by nature thoughtless,

1 For a large number of references to metamorphoses into stone, see
Chauvin, op. cit., vi, p. 58. — n.m.p.

THE BURIED PITCHERS 23

show self-restraint ? So now this intolerable separation has
fallen to my lot." However, in a moment he said to him-
self : " This is no time for me to despond ; why should I not
recover firmness and strive to put an end to her curse ? "

After going through these reflections, the cunning fellow
thought carefully over the matter, and assuming the dress
of a mendicant devotee, went with rosary, antelope-skin,
and matted hair, to Nagapura. There he secretly buried, in
a forest outside the city, four pitchers containing his wife's
ornaments — one towards each of the cardinal points ; and
one full of sets of the five precious things * he deliberately
buried within the city, in the earth of the market-place, in
front of the god himself.

When he had done this, he built a hut on the bank of the
river, and remained there, affecting a hypocritical asceticism,2
pretending to be meditating and muttering. And by bathing
three times in the day, and eating only the food given him as
alms, after washing it with water on a stone, he acquired the
character of a very holy man.

In course of time his fame reached the ears of the king,
and the king often invited him, but he never went near him ;
so the king came to see him, and remained a long time in
conversation with him. And in the evening, when the king
was preparing to depart, a female jackal suddenly uttered
a yell at a distance. When the cunning gambler, who was
passing himself off as an ascetic, heard that, he laughed.
And when the king asked him the meaning of the laugh,3
he said : " Oh ! never mind." But when the king went on
persistently questioning him, the deceitful fellow said : "In
the forest to the east of this city, under a ratan, there is a
pitcher full of jewelled ornaments ; so take it." This, King,
is what that female jackal told me, for I understand the
language of animals."

Then the king was full of curiosity : so the ascetic took

1 Gold, diamond, sapphire, ruby, and pearl. The Buddhists usually

enumerate seven: see Burnouf, Lotus de la Bonne Lot, p. 319. The list is

nearly the same as that of the five jewels. See Vol. VII, p. 247n2. — n.m.p.

2 See section iv, p. 228, of Bloomfield's " False Ascetics and Nuns in
Hindu Fiction," Journ. Amer. Orient. Soc., vol. xliv, pp. 202-242. — n.m.p.

3 See Vol. VII, pp. 253-256.— n.m.p.

24 THE OCEAN OF STORY

him to the spot, and dug up the earth, and took out that
pitcher, and gave it to him. Then the king, having obtained
the ornaments, began to have faith in the ascetic, and con-
sidered that he not only possessed supernatural knowledge,
but was a truthful and unselfish devotee. So he conducted
him to his cell, and prostrated himself at his feet again and
again, and returned to his palace at night with his ministers,
praising his virtues.

In the same way, when the king again came to him, the
ascetic pretended to understand the cry of an animal, and in
this way made over to the king the other three pitchers,
buried towards the other three cardinal points. Then the
king and the citizens and the king's wives became exclusively
devoted to the ascetic, and were, so to speak, quite absorbed
in him.

Now, one day, the king took that wicked ascetic to the
temple for a moment ; so he contrived to hear in the market-
place the cry of a crow. Then he said to the king : " Did
you hear what the crow said ? ' In this very market-place
there is a pitcher full of valuable jewels buried in front of the
god : why do you not take it up also ? ' This was the mean-
ing of his cry ; so come and take possession of it." When
the deceitful ascetic had said this, he conducted him there,
and took up out of the earth the pitcher full of valuable
jewels, and gave it to the king. Then the king, in his exces-
sive satisfaction, entered the temple holding that pretended
seer by the hand.

There the mendicant brushed against that image on the
pillar which his beloved Kalavati had entered, and saw her.
And Kalavati, wearing the form of the image on the pillar,
was afflicted when she saw her husband, and began to weep
then and there. When the king and his attendants saw this,
they were amazed and cast down, and said to that pretended
seer : " Reverend sir, what is the meaning of this ? " Then
the cunning rascal, pretending to be despondent and be-
wildered, said to the king : " Come to your palace ; there I
will tell you this secret, though it is almost too terrible to be
revealed."

When he had said this, he led the king to the palace, and

THE TRICKERY OF GAMBLERS 25

said to him : " Since you built this temple on an unlucky
spot and in an inauspicious moment, on the third day from
now a misfortune will befall you. It was for this reason
that the image on the pillar wept when she saw you. So, if
you care for your body's weal, my sovereign, take this into
consideration, and this very day quickly level this temple
with the earth ; and build another temple somewhere else,
on a lucky spot, and in an auspicious moment. Let the evil
omen be averted, and ensure the prosperity of yourself and
your kingdom." When he had said this to the king, he, in
his terror, gave command to his subjects, and in one day
levelled that temple with the earth, and he began to build
another temple in another place. So true is it that rogues
with their tricks gain the confidence of princes, and impose
upon them.

Accordingly, the gambler Thinthakarala, having gained
his object, abandoned the disguise of a mendicant, and fled,
and went to Ujjayini. And Kalavati, finding it out, went to
meet him on the road, freed from her curse and happy, and
she comforted him, and then went to heaven to visit Indra.
And Indra was astonished, but when he heard from her
mouth the artifice of her husband the gambler, he laughed
and was highly delighted.

Then Brihaspati, who was at his side, said to Indra:
" Gamblers are always like this, abounding in every kind of
trickery. For instance, in a previous kalpa there was in a
The Gambler certain city a gambler, of the name of Kuttani-
who cheated kapata, accomplished in dishonest play. When
he went to the other world, Indra said to him :
4 Gambler, you will have to live a kalpa in hell on account
of your crimes, but, owing to your charity, you are to be
Indra for one day, for once on a time you gave a gold coin
to a knower of the Supreme Soul. So say whether you will
take out first your period in hell or your period as Indra.'
When the gambler heard that, he said : ' I will take out first
\ my period as Indra.'

" Then Yama sent the gambler to heaven, and the gods

1 Cf. Vol. VI, p. 92 et seq., and see p. 99 el seq. of Brown's article, as
mentioned in the note on p. 92. — n.m.p.

26 THE OCEAN OF STORY

deposed Indra for a day, and crowned him sovereign in his
stead. He, having obtained sovereign sway, summoned to
heaven the gamblers, his friends, and his female favourites,
and in virtue of his regal authority gave this order to the
gods : ' Carry us all in a moment to all the holy bathing-
places,1 those in heaven, and those on earth, and those in
the seven dvipas ; and enter this very day into all the kings
on the earth and bestow without ceasing great gifts for our
benefit.'

" When he gave this order to the gods, they did every-
thing as he had desired, and by means of those holy observ-
ances his sins were washed 2 away, and he obtained the rank
of Indra permanently. And by his favour his friends and
his female favourites, that he had summoned to heaven, had
their sins destroyed, and obtained immortality. The next
day Chitragupta informed Yama that the gambler had, by
his discretion, obtained the rank of Indra permanently. Then
Yama, hearing of his meritorious actions, was astonished, and
said : ' Oho ! this gambler has cheated us.' "

When Brihaspati had told this story, he said, " Such,
O wielder of the thunderbolt, are gamblers," and then held
his peace. And then Indra sent Kalavati to summon Thin-
thakarala to heaven. There the king of the gods, pleased
with his cleverness and resolution, honoured him, and gave
him Kalavati to wife, and made him an attendant on him-
self. Then the brave Thinthakarala lived happily, like a god,
in heaven, with Kalavati, by the favour of Siva.

171aa. The Cunning Gambler Ddgineya and the Vetala
Agnisikha who submitted himself to King Vikramdditya

" So you see, such is the style in which gamblers exhibit
their treachery and audacity; accordingly, Agnisikha the

1 No. 1882 reads snapayata tatkshandt at the end of si. 194 a. It seems to
remove a tautology, but is unmetrical. " Take us and cause us to bathe." The
Sanskrit College MS. has snapayata tatshanam.

2 I read dhxda for dyida; No. 1882 (the Taylor MS.) and the Sanskrit
College MS. have dhfda ; No. 3003 has dhfda ; the other MS. does not contain
the passage.

BLACK MAGIC 27

Vampire, what is there to be surprised at in your having
been treacherously thrown into this well by Dagineya the
gambler ? So come out of this pit, friend, and we will come
out also."

When the Brahman demon said this to me, I came up
out of that pit, and being hungry, I came across a Brahman
traveller that night in the city. So I rushed forward and
seized that Brahman to eat him, but he invoked the pro-
tection of King Vikramaditya. And the moment the king
heard his cry, he rushed out like flame, and while still at a
distance, checked me by exclaiming : " Ah, villain ! do not
kill the Brahman " : and then he proceeded to cut off the
head of a figure of a man he had drawn — that did not sever
my neck, but made it stream with blood.1

Then I left the Brahman and clung to the king's feet, and
he spared my life.

171a. Madanamanjarl and the Kdpdlika

" Such is the power of that god, King Vikramaditya.
And it is by his orders that I have slain this hypocritical
kdpdlika. So he is my proper prey, to be devoured by me
as being a Vetala ; let him go, Yamasikha ! "

Though Agnisikha made this appeal to Yamasikha, the
latter proceeded contumaciously to drag with his hand the
corpse of that hypocritical kdpdlika. Then King Vikrama-
ditya appeared there, and drew the figure of a man on the
earth, and then cut off its hand with his sword. That made
the hand of Yamasikha fall severed ; so he left the corpse,
and fled in fear. And Agnisikha immediately devoured the
corpse of that kdpdlika. And I witnessed all this, securely
protected by the might of the king.2

1 An interesting use of sympathetic black magic, occurring again a little
lower, but in this case with the hand.

2 I read dlikhya purusham bhumau. This is the reading of the Taylor MS.,
the other has atikhya. The Sanskrit College MS. has alikhya purushain.

28 THE OCEAN OF STORY

171. Story of King Vikramaditya

In these words did that wife of the Yaksha, Madana-
manjari by name, describe your power, O King, and then she
went on to say to me :

" Then, Anangadeva, the king said to me in a gentle
voice : * Yakshi, being delivered from the kdpdlika, go to
the house of your husband.' Then I bowed before him, and
returned to this my own home, thinking how I might repay
to that king the benefit he had conferred on me. In this
way your master gave me life, family and husband ; and
when you tell him this story of mine, it will agree with his
own recollections.

" Moreover, I have to-day found out that the King of
Simhala has sent to that king his daughter, the greatest
beauty in the three worlds, who has of her own accord elected
to marry him. And all the kings, being jealous, have gathered
themselves together and formed the intention of killing
Yikramasakti and the dependent kings,1 and of carrying off
that maiden. So, do you go, and make their intention known
to Yikramasakti, in order that he may be on his guard and
ready to repel their attack. And I will exert myself to enable
King Vikramaditya to conquer those enemies and gain the
victory.

" For this reason I brought vou here bv mv own deluding
power, in order that you might tell all this to King Vikrama-
sakti and the dependent monarchs ; and I will send to your
sovereign such a present as shall to a certain small extent be
a requital for the benefit that he conferred on me."

While she was saying this, the two maidens that we had
seen in the sea came there with the deer ; one had a body
white as the moon, the other was dark as a priyangu ; so
Continuation „/ they seemed like Ganga and Yamuna returned
A nan gad era * from worshipping the ocean, the monarch of
Adventures rivers< yVTieii they had sat down, I put this
question to the Yakshi : " Goddess, who are these maidens,
and what is the meaning of this golden deer ? " When the

1 Both the India Office MSS. in which this passage is found give tatsa-
mantam. So Vikramasakti would himself be a " dependent king."

THE TWO DANAVAS 29

Yakshini heard this, King, she said to me : " Anangadeva, if
you feel any curiosity about the matter, listen, I will tell you.

171b. Ghanta and Nighanta and the Two Maidens

Long ago there came to impede Prajapati, in his creation
of creatures, two terrible Danavas, named Ghanta and
Nighanta, invincible even by gods. And the Creator, being
desirous of destroying them, created these two maidens, the
splendour of whose measureless beauty seemed capable of
maddening the world. And those two mighty Asuras, when
they saw these two exceedingly wonderful maidens, tried to
carry them off ; and fighting with one another, they both of
them met their death.1

Then Brahma bestowed these maidens on Kuvera, saying,
" You must give these girls to some suitable husband " ;
and Kuvera made them over to my husband, who is his
younger brother ; and in the same way my husband passed
these fair ones 2 on to me ; and I have thought of King
Vikramaditya as a husband for them, for, as he is an
incarnation of a god, he is a fit person for them to marry.

171. Story of King Vikramaditya

M Such are the facts with regard to these maidens ; now
hear the history of the deer.

171c. Jayanta and the Golden Deer

Indra had a beloved son named Jayanta. Once on a
time, when he, still an infant, was being carried about in the
air by the celestial nymphs, he saw some princes in a wood
on earth playing with some young deer. Then Jayanta 3 went

1 Cf. the story of Sunda and Upasunda, Vol. II, pp. 13-14; and Preller,
> Griechische Mythologie, vol. i, p. 81m1.

2 For ete manorame No. 3003 and the Sanskrit College MS. have vara-
karanam: "in order that I might find a husband for them." No. 1882 has
varanam for karanam.

3 For Jayanto MSS. Nos. 1882 and 3003 and the Sanskrit College MS. give
hevdkl — i.e. " full of longing."

30 THE OCEAN OF STORY

to heaven, and cried in the presence of his father because he
had not got a deer to play with, as a child would naturally
do. Accordingly Indra had a deer made for him by Visva-
karman, of gold and jewels, and life was given to the animal
by sprinkling it with nectar. Then Jayanta played with it,
and was delighted with it, and the young deer was continually
roaming about in heaven.

In course of time that son of Ravana, who was rightly
named Indra jit,1 carried off the young deer from heaven and
took it to his own city Lanka. And after a further period
had elapsed — Ravana and Indra jit having been slain by the
heroes Rama and Lakshmana, to avenge the carrying off of Sita,
and Vibhishana having been set upon the throne of Lanka,
as King of the Rakshasas — that wonderful deer of gold
and jewels remained in his palace. And once on a time,
when I was taken by my husband's relations to Vibhishana's
palace on the occasion of a festival, he gave me the deer as
a complimentary present. And that young heaven-born deer
is now in my house, and I must bestow it on your master.

171. Story of King Vikramdditya

And while the Yakshini was telling me this string of tales,
the sun, the friend of the kamalini, went to rest. Then I and
the ambassador of the King of Simhala went to sleep, both
of us, after the evening ceremonies, in a palace which the
Yakshini assigned to us.

In the morning we woke up and saw, my sovereign, that
the army of Vikramasakti, your vassal, had arrived. We
reflected that that must be a display of the Yakshini's power,
and quickly went wondering into the presence of Vikrama-
sakti. And he, as soon as he saw, showed us great honour,
and asked after your welfare ; and was on the point of asking
us what message the King of Simhala had sent, when the two
heavenly maidens — whose history the Yakshini has related
to us — and the young deer arrived there, escorted by the
army of the Yakshas. When King Vikramasakti saw this, he
suspected some glamour of malignant demons, and he said

1 I.e. conqueror of Indra.

THE GREAT BATTLE 31

to me apprehensively : " What is the meaning of this ? "
Then I told him in due course the commission of the King of
Simhala, and the circumstances connected with the Yakshini,
the two maidens, and the deer. Moreover, I informed him
of the hostile scheme of your Majesty's enemies, which was to
be carried out by all the kings in combination, and which I
had heard of from the Yakshi. Then Vikrama^akti honoured
us two ambassadors, and those two heavenly maidens ; and
being delighted, made his army ready for battle with the
assistance of the other vassal kings.

And immediately, King, there was heard in the army
the loud beating of drums, and at the same instant there
was seen the mighty host of hostile kings, accompanied by
Anmxradeva *ne Mlechchhas. Then our army and the hostile
tells of the army, furious at beholding one another, closed
Great Battle ^j^ a rush, and the battle began. Thereupon
some of the Yakshas sent by the Yakshi entered our soldiers,
and so smote the army of the enemies, and others smote them
in open fight.1 And there arose a terrible tempest of battle,
overspread with a cloud formed of the dust raised by the
army, in which sword-blades fell thick as rain, and the shouts
of heroes thundered. And the heads of our enemies flying up,
as they were cut off, and falling again, made it seem as if the
Fortune of our victory were playing at ball. And in a moment
those kings that had escaped the slaughter, their troops
having been routed, submitted and repaired for protection
to the camp of your vassal.

Then, lord of earth, as you had conquered the four
cardinal points and the dvipas, and had destroyed all the
Mlechchhas, that Yakshini appeared, accompanied by her
husband, and said to King Vikramasakti and to me : " You
must tell your master that what I have done has been done
merely by way of service to him, and you must also request
him, as from me, to marry these two god-framed maidens,
and to look upon them with favour, and to cherish this deer
also, for it is a present from me." When the Yakshi had said
this, she bestowed a heap of jewels, and disappeared with her
husband and her attendants. The next day, Madanalekha,

1 It is just possible that sankhyad ought to be sakshad.

32 THE OCEAN OF STORY

the daughter of the King of Simhala, came with a great
retinue and much magnificence. And then Vikramasakti went
to meet her and, bending low, joyfully conducted her into
his eamjx And on the second day Vikramasakti, having
accomplished his object, set out with the other kings from
that place, in order to come here and behold your Majesty's
feet, bringing with him that princess and the two heavenly
maidens, and that deer composed of gold and jewels — a
marvel for the eyes of the three worlds. And now, sovereign,
that vassal prince has arrived near this city, and has sent us
two on in front to inform vour Highness. So let the kino; out
of regard for the lord of Simhala and the Yakshi, go forth to
meet those maidens and the deer, and also the subject kings.

When Anangadeva had said this to King Vikramaditya,
though the king recollected accomplishing that difficult
rescue of the Yakshini, he did not consider it worth a straw
when he heard of the return she had made for it ; great -
souled men, even when they have done much, think it worth
very little. And, being much pleased, he loaded 1 Anangadeva,
for the second time, with elephants, horses, villages and
jewels, and bestowed similar gifts on the ambassador of the
King of Simhala.

And after he had spent that day, the king set out from
Ujjayini, with his warriors mounted on elephants and horses,
to meet that daughter of the King of Simhala, and those two
maidens created by Brahma. And the following speeches
of the military officers, assigning elephants and horses, were
heard in the neighbourhood of the city when the kings
started, and within the city itself when the sovereign started :
" Jayavardhana must take the good elephant Anangagiri,
and Ranabhata the furious elephant Kalamegha, and Simha-
parakrama Sangramasiddhi, and the hero Vikramanidhi
Ripurakshasa, and Jayaketu Pavanajava, and Vallabhasakti
Samudrakallola, and Bahu and Subahu the two horses Sara-
vega and Garudavega, and Kirtivarman the black Konkan
mare Kuvalayamala, and Samarasimha the white mare
Gangalaharl of pure Sindh breed."

1 This expression is very similar to that in Taranga 120, x/. 80 b, to which
Dr Kern objects.

THE TRIUMPHANT MARCH 33

When that king, the supreme sovereign of all the dvipas,
had started on his journey, the earth was covered with
soldiers, the quarters were full of nothing but the shouts that
they raised, even the heaven was obscured with the dust that
was diffused by the trampling of his advancing army, and all
men's voices were telling of the wonderful greatness of his
might.

■

VOL. IX.

CHAPTER CXXII

171. Story of King Vikramdditya

THEN King Vikramaditya reached that victorious
army commanded by that Vikramasakti, his general,
and he entered it at the head of his forces, accom-
panied by that general, who came to meet him, eager and
with loyal mind, together with the vassal kings.

The kings were thus announced by the warders in the tent
of assembly : " Your Majesty, here is Saktikumara, the King
of Gauda, come to pay you his respects, here is Jayadhvaja,
the King of Karnata, here is Vijayavarman of Lata, here is
Sunandana of Kasmira, here is Gopala, King of Sindh, here
is Vindhyabala, the Bhilla, and here is Nirmuka, the King
of the Persians." And when they had been thus announced,
the king honoured them, and the feudal chiefs, and also
the soldiers. And he welcomed in appropriate fashion the
daughter of the King of Simhala, and the heavenly maidens,
and the golden deer, and Vikramasakti. And the next day
the successful monarch Vikramaditya set out with them and
his forces, and reached the city of Ujjayini.

Then, the kings having been dismissed with marks of
honour x to their own territories, and the world-gladdening
festival of the spring season having arrived, when the creepers
began, so to speak, to adorn themselves with flowers for
jewels, and the female bees to keep up a concert with their
humming, and the ranges of the wood to dance embraced
by the wind, and the cuckoos with melodious notes to utter
auspicious prayers, King Vikramaditya married on a for-
tunate day that daughter of the King of Simhala, and
those two heavenly maidens. And Simhavarman, the eldest
brother of the Princess of Simhala, who had come with her,
bestowed at the marriage-altar a great heap of jewels.

1 Dr Kern would read sammmiitavisrishteshu ; and this is the reading of the
Taylor MS. and of the Sanskrit College MS. ; No. 3003 has sammanitair.

34

NAGARASVAMIN THE PAINTER 35

And at that moment the YakshinI Madanamanjari
appeared, and gave those two heavenly maidens countless
heaps of jewels. The Yakshi said : " How can I ever, King,
recompense you for your benefits ? But I have done this un-
important service to testify my devotion to you. So you must
show favour to these maidens, and to the deer." When the
YakshinI had said this, she departed honoured by the king.

Then the successful King Vikramaditya, having obtained
those wives and the earth with all its dvipas, ruled a realm
void of opponents : and he enjoyed himself roaming in all
the garden grounds — during the hot season living in the
water of tanks and in artificial fountain-chambers ; during
the rains in inner apartments, charming on account of the
noise of cymbals that arose in them; during tl^e autumn on
the tops of palaces, joyous with banquets under the rising
moon; during the winter in chambers where comfortable
couches were spread, and which were fragrant with black
aloes — being ever surrounded by his wives.

Now, this king, being such as I have described, had a
painter named Nagarasvamin, who enjoyed the revenues
of a hundred villages, and surpassed Visvakarman. That
painter used every two or three days to paint a picture of
a girl, and give it as a present to the king, taking care to
exemplify different types of beauty.

Now, once on a time, it happened that that painter

had, because a feast was going on, forgotten to paint the

required girl for the king. And when the day for giving the

The Wonder- present arrived, the painter remembered and was

Jul Picture bewildered, saying to himself : " Alas ! what can

I give to the king ? " And at that moment a traveller, come

from afar, suddenly approached him and placed a book in his

i hand, and went off somewhere quickly. The painter, out of

r curiosity, opened the book, and saw within a picture of a girl

on canvas. Inasmuch as the girl was of wonderful beauty, no

^sooner did he see her picture than he took it and gave

v, it to the king, rejoicing that, so far from having no picture

to present that day, he had obtained such an exceedingly

beautiful one. But the king, as soon as he saw it, was

astonished, and said to him : " My good fellow, this is not

36 THE OCEAN OF STORY

your painting, this is the painting of Visvakarman : for how
could a mere mortal be skilful enough to paint such beauty ? "
When the painter heard this, he told the king exactly what
had taken place.

Then the king kept ever looking at the picture of the girl,
and never took his eyes off it; and one night he saw in a
dream a girl exactly like her, but in another dvipa. But as
he eagerly rushed to embrace her, who was eager to meet
him, the night came to an end, and he was woke up by
the watchman.1 When the king awoke, he was so angry
at the interruption of his delightful interview with that
maiden, that he banished that watchman from the city.
And he said to himself : "To think that a traveller should
bring a book, and that in it there should be the painted
figure of a girl, and that I should in a dream behold this
same girl apparently alive ! All this elaborate dispensation
of destiny makes me think that she must be a real maiden,
but I do not know in what dvipa she lives ; how am I to
obtain her?"

Full of such reflections, the king took pleasure in nothing,2
and burned with the fever of love so that his attendants
were full of anxiety. And the warder Bhadrayudha asked
the afflicted king in private the cause of his grief, whereupon
he spake as follows :

" Listen, I will tell you, my friend. So much at any rate
you know — that that painter gave me the picture of a girl.
And I fell asleep thinking on her ; and I remember that in
my dream I crossed the sea, and reached and entered a very
beautiful city. There I saw many armed maidens in front of
me, and they, as soon as they saw me, raised a tumultuous
cry of ' Kill, kill.' 3 Then a certain female ascetic came and,
with great precipitation, made me enter her house, and briefly
said to me this : ' My son, here is the man-hating princess
Malay avati come this way, diverting herself as she pleases.

1 For falling in love with a lady seen in a dream see Vol. Ill, p. 82, 82w2,
and Rohde, Der Griechische Roman, pp. 45, 46 and 49. For falling in love with
a lady seen in a picture, see Vol. IV, p. 132, 132W1.

2 I read aratiman for ratiman in the Sanskrit College MS. The Taylor MS.
has sarvatranratiman ; the other agrees with Brockhaus.

8 I read pravesyaiva.

THE ARROWS OF LOVE 37

And the moment she sees a man, she makes these maidens
of hers kill him : so I brought you in here to save your
life.' s

" When the female ascetic had said this, she immediately
made me put on female attire ; and I submitted to that,
knowing that it was not lawful to slay those maidens. But
when the princess entered into the house with her maidens,
I looked at her, and lo ! she was the very lady that had been
shown me in the picture. And I said to myself : ' Fortunate
am I in that, after first seeing this lady in a picture, I now
behold her again in flesh and blood, dear as my life.'

" In the meanwhile the princess, at the head of her maidens,
said to that female ascetic : ' We saw some male enter here.'
The ascetic showed me, and answered : ' I know of no male ;
here is my sister's daughter, who is with me as a guest.'
Then the princess, seeing me — although I was disguised as a
woman — forgot her dislike of men, and was at once overcome
by love. She remained for a moment, with every hair on her
body erect, motionless, as if in thought, being, so to speak,
nailed to the spot at once with arrows by Love, who had spied
his opportunity. And in a moment the princess said to the
ascetic : ' Then, noble lady, why should not your sister's
daughter be my guest also ? Let her come to my palace ;
I will send her back duly honoured.' Saying this, she took
me by the hand, and led me away to her palace. And I
remember, I discerned her intention, and consented, and
went there, and that sly old female ascetic gave me leave to
depart.

"Then I remained there with that princess, who was
diverting herself with the amusement of marrying her maidens
to one another, and so forth. Her eyes were fixed on me,
and she would not let me out of her sight for an instant, and
no occupation pleased her in which I did not take part. Then

1 Cf. Ralston's Russian Folk-Tales, p. 97 ; in Waldau's Bbhmische M'drchen,
p. 444, there is a beautiful Amazon who fights with the prince on condition
that if he is victorious she is to be his prisoner, but if she is victorious, he is
to be put to death. Rohde, in Der Griechische Roman, p. 148, gives a long
list of M coy huntress maids." Spenser's Radigund, Faerie Queene, Book V,

cantos 4-7, bears a close resemblance to Malayavatl. Cf. the fair Amazon in

the "Tale of King Omar bin al-Nu'uman," Nights, Burton, vol. ii, p. 96. — n.m.p.

38 THE OCEAN OF STORY

those maidens, I remember, made the princess a bride, and
me her husband, and married us in sport. And when we
had been married, we entered at night the bridal chamber, and
the princess fearlessly threw her arms round my neck. And
then I told her who I was, and embraced her ; and, delighted
at having attained her object, she looked at me and then
remained a long time with her eyes bashfully fixed on the
ground. And at that moment that villain of a watchman
woke me up. So, Bhadrayudha, the upshot of the whole
matter is that I can no longer live without that Malayavati,
whom I have seen in a picture and in a dream."

When the king said this, the warder, Bhadrayudha, per-
ceived that it was a true dream, and he consoled the monarch,
and said to him : "If the king remembers it all exactly, let
him draw that city on a piece of canvas in order that some
expedient may be devised in this matter." The moment the
king heard this suggestion of Bhadrayudha's, he proceeded
to draw that splendid city on a piece of canvas, and all the
scene that took place there. Then the warder at once took
the drawing, and had a new monastery * made, and hung it
up there on the wall. And he directed that in relief-houses
attached to the monastery, a quantity of food, with pairs of
garments and gold, should be given to bards coming from
distant countries. And he gave this order to the dwellers
in the monastery : " If anyone comes here who knows the city
represented here in a picture, let me be informed of it." 2

In the meanwhile the fierce elephant of the rainy season,
with irresistible loud deep thunder-roar and long ketaka tusks,
came down upon the forest of the heats — a forest, the breezes
of which were scented with the perfume of the jasmine, in
which travellers sat down on the ground in the shade, and
trumpet-flowers bloomed. At that time the forest-fire of
separation of that King Vikramaditya began to burn more
fiercely, fanned by the eastern breeze.3 Then the following

1 Sanskrit, matha.

2 For a note on methods of finding people, see Chauvin, op. cit., v, p. 90.

— N.M.P.

3 The Petersburg lexicographers would read paurattya ; and I find this in
the Taylor MS. and the Sanskrit College MS. The same MSS. read ambudasyamo
for atha durdarsa. The latter word should be spelt durdharsha.

THE PAINTING ON THE WALL 39

cries were heard among the ladies of his court : " Haralata,
bring ice ! Chitrangi, sprinkle him with sandalwood juice !
Patralekha, make a bed cool with lotus leaves ! Kandar-
pasena, fan him with plantain leaves ! " And in course of
time the cloudy season, terrible with lightning, passed away
for that king, but the fever of love, burning ' with the
sorrow of separation, did not pass away.

Then the autumn, with her open-lotus face and smile of
unclosed flowers, came, vocal with the cries of swans,2 seeming
to utter this command : " Let travellers advance on their
journey ; let pleasant tidings be brought about absent dear
ones ; happy may their merry meetings be ! " On a certain
day in that season a bard — who had come from a distance —
of the name of Sambarasiddhi, having heard the fame of that
monastery, built by the warder, entered it to get food. After
he had been fed, and presented with a pair of garments, he
saw that painting on the wall of the monastery. When the
bard had carefully scanned the city delineated there, he was
astonished, and said : "I wonder who can have drawn this
city ? For I alone have seen it, I am certain, and no other ;
and here it is drawn by some second person." When the
inhabitants of the monastery heard that, they told Bhadra-
yudha ; then he came in person, and took that bard to the
king. The king said to Sambarasiddhi : " Have you really
seen that city ? " Then Sambarasiddhi gave him the following
answer :

" When I was wandering about the world, I crossed the
sea that separates the dvipas, and beheld that great city
Malayapura. In that city there dwells a king of the name
of Malayasimha, and he has a matchless daughter, named
Malayavati, who used to abhor males. But one night she
somehow or other saw in a dream a great hero in a convent.8

1 I read savirahajvalo and sakasa in //. 72.

2 The two India Office MSS. that contain this passage, and the Sanskrit
College MS., make the compound end in ravaik, so the command will be given
by the cries of the swans. In //. 71, for grathyantam, No. 1882 and the Sanskrit
College MS. give budhyantam. In //. 73, for akhyatim, three MSS. give khydtim.

3 Sanskrit, vihara. The tapasi of //. 39 was therefore a Buddhist. No. 3003
reads viharanirgata, which agrees with //. 40. No. 1882 has viharanirgatam.
The Sanskrit College MS. has viharanirgataip.

40 THE OCEAN OF STORY

The moment she saw him, that evil spirit of detestation of
the male sex fled from her mind, as if terrified. Then she
took him to her palace, and in her dream married him, and
entered with him the bridal chamber. And at that moment
the night came to an end, and an attendant in her room woke
her up. Then she banished that servant in her anger, think-
ing upon that dear one whom she had seen in her dream;
seeing no way of escape owing to the blazing fire of separation,
utterly overpowered by love, she never rose from her couch
except to fall back upon it again with relaxed limbs. She
was dumb — as if possessed by a demon; as if stunned by a
blow ' — for when her attendants questioned her, she gave them
no answer.

" Then her father and mother came to hear of it, and
questioned her ; and at last she was, with exceeding diffi-
culty, persuaded to tell them what happened to her in the
dream, by the mouth of a confidential female friend. Then
her father comforted her, but she made a solemn vow that,
if she did not obtain her beloved in six months, she would
enter the fire. And already five months are past ; who
knows what will become of her ? This is the story that I
heard about her in that city."

When Sambarasiddhi had told this story, which tallied so
well with the king's own dream, the king was pleased at know-
ing the certainty of the matter, and Bhadrayudha said to
him : " The business is as good as effected, for that king and
his country own your paramount supremacy. So let us go
there before the sixth month has passed away." When the
warder had said this, King Vikramaditya made him inform
Sambarasiddhi of all the circumstances connected with the
matter, and honoured him with a present of much wealth,
and bade him show him the way, and then he seemed to
bequeath his own burning heat to the rays of the sun, his
paleness to the clouds, and his thinness to the waters of
the rivers,2 and having become free from sorrow, set out at
once, escorted by a small force, for the dwelling-place of his
beloved.

1 For ghdta, No. 1882 has tamak and No. 3003 vata.

2 This probably means that he started in the autumn.

THE REALITY OF THE DREAM 41

In course of time, as he advanced, he crossed the sea, and
reached that city, and there he saw the people in front of it
engaged in loud lamentation, and when he questioned them,
he received this answer : " The Princess Malayavati here,
as the period of six months is at an end, and she has not
obtained her beloved, is preparing to enter the fire." Then
the king went to the place where the pyre had been made
ready.

When the people saw him, they made way for him, and
then the princess beheld that unexpected nectar-rain to her
eyes. And she said to her ladies-in-waiting : " Here is that
beloved come who married me in a dream, so tell my father
quickly." They went and told this to her father, and then
that king, delivered from his grief, and filled with joy,
submissively approached the sovereign.

At that moment the bard Sambarasiddhi, who knew his
time, lifted up his arm, and chanted aloud this strain : " Hail,
thou that with the flame of thy valour hast consumed the
forest of the army of demons and Mlechchhas ! Hail, King,
lord of the seven-sea-girt earth-bride ! Hail, thou that hast
imposed thy exceedingly heavy yoke on the bowed heads
of all kings, conquered by thee ! Hail, Vishamasila ! Hail,
Vikramaditya, ocean of valour ! "

When the bard said this, King Malayasimha knew that it
was Vikramaditya himself that had come, and embraced his
feet.1 And after he had welcomed him, he entered his palace
with him, and his daughter Malayavati, thus delivered from
death. And that king gave that daughter of his to King
Vikramaditya, thinking himself fortunate in having obtained
such a son-in-law. And King Vikramaditya, when he saw
in his arms, in flesh and blood, that Malayavati, whom he
had previously seen in a picture and in a dream, considered
it a wonderful fruit of the wishing-tree of Siva's favour.
Then Vikramaditya took with him his wife Malayavati, like
an incarnation of bliss, and crossed the sea resembling his
long regretful2 separation, and being submissively waited

1 No. 3003, yatha chitre tathd svapne yatha svapne tathaivalam vilokya sakshad ;
so too No. 1882. The Sanskrit College MS. agrees, but omits yatha svapne.

2 The word that means "regret " may also mean " wave."

42 THE OCEAN OF STORY

upon at every step by kings, with various presents in their
hands, returned to his own city Ujjayinl. And on beholding
there that might of his, that satisfied x freely every kind of
curiosity, what people were not astonished, what people did
not rejoice, what people did not make high festival ?

1 I follow Bohtlingk and Roth. Dr Kern would read sojjlkrita in the
sense of " prepared " ; he takes kautukam in the sense of nuptial ceremonies.
No. 1882 (the Taylor MS.) has mantu and No. 3003 has satyl. The Sanskrit
College MS. supports Brockhaus' text.

CHAPTER CXXIII

171. Story of King Vikramdditya

THEN, once on a time, in the course of conversation,
one of Vikramaditya's queens, called Kalingasena,
said to her rival queens : " What the king did for the
sake of Malayavati was not wonderful, for this King Visha-
masila has ever been famous on the earth for such like acts.
Was not I swooped down on by him and married by force,
after he had seen a carved likeness of me and Jbeen overcome
by love ? On this account the kdrpatika l Devasena told me
a story : that story I will proceed to tell you. Listen.

" I was very much vexed, and exclaimed : ' How can the
king be said to have married me lawfully ? ' Then the kdr-
patika said to me : 4 Do not be angry, Queen, for the king
married you in eager haste out of a violent passion for you.
Hear the whole story from the beginning.

171d. Kalingasena 's Marriage to King Vikramdditya

Once on a time, when I was serving your husband as a
kdrpatika, I saw a great boar far away in the wood. Its
mouth was formidable with tusks, its colour was black as a
tamdla tree, it looked like an incarnation of the black fortnight
devouring the digits of the moon. And I came, Queen, and
informed the king of it, describing to him as I have done to
you. And the king went out to hunt, attracted by his love
for the sport. And when he reached the wood, and was deal-
ing death among the tigers and deer, he saw in the distance
that boar of which I had informed him. And when he saw
that wonderful boar, he came to the conclusion that some
being had assumed that form with an object, and he ascended
his horse called Ratnakara, the progeny of Uchchhaihs'ravas.

1 See Vol. II, p. 178, I78nl; Vol. IV, p. 168, 168^, and Vol. VI, p. 209,
209n2. — n.m.p.
43

44 THE OCEAN OF STORY

For every day at noon, the sun waits a brief space in the
sky, and then his charioteer, the dawn, lets the horses loose,
that they may bathe and feed : and one day Uchchhaih-
sravas, having been unyoked from the chariot of the sun,
approached a mare of the king's, that he saw in the forest,
and begot that horse.1

So the king mounted that swift horse, and quickly pursued
that boar, that fled to a very remote 2 part of the forest.
Then that boar escaped somewhere from his view, being
swifter even than that horse that had Uchchhaihsravas for a
sire. Then the king, not having caught him, and seeing that
I alone had followed him, while he had left the rest of his suite
far behind, asked me this question : " Do you know how
much ground we have traversed to get to this place ? "
When I heard that, Queen, I made the king this answer :
" My lord, we have come three hundred yojanas." Then the
king, being astonished, said : " Then how have you managed
to come so far on foot ? " When he asked me this question
I answered : " King, I have an ointment for the feet ; hear
the way in which I acquired it.

" Long ago, on account of the loss of my wife, I went forth
to make a pilgrimage to all the holy bathing-places, and in
the course of my journey I came one evening to a temple with
H D a garden. And I went in there to pass the night,

sena obtained and I saw inside a woman, and I remained there
the Magic hospitably welcomed by her. And during the
course of the night she elevated one lip to heaven,
resting the other on the earth, and with expanded jaws said
to me : 4 Have you seen before anywhere such a mouth as
this ? ' Then I fearlessly drew my dagger with a frown, and
said to her : * Have you seen such a man as this ? ' Then
she assumed a gentle appearance without any horrible dis-
tortion of shape, and said to me : ' I am a YakshI, Vandhya
by name, and I am pleased with your courage ; so now tell
me what I can do to gratify you.'

" When the Yakshini said this, I answered her : ' If you
are really pleased with me, then enable me to go round to all

1 Cf. Iliad, v, 265 et seq. ; and (still better) Mneid, vii, 280 et seq.
* Deviyasim is a misprint for daviyasim, as Dr Kern points out.

THE MAGIC OINTMENT 45

the holy waters without any suffering.' When the Yakshi
heard this, she gave me an ointment for my feet * ; by means
of it I travelled to all the holy bathing-places, and I have been
able to run behind you now so far as this place. And by its
aid I come to this wood here every day, and eat fruits, and
then return to Ujjayini and attend upon you."

When I had told that tale to the king, I saw by his pleased
face that he thought in his heart that I was a follower well
suited to him. I again said to him : " King, I will bring
you here some very sweet fruits, if you will be pleased to
eat them." The king said to me : " I will not eat ; I do
not require anything ; but do you eat something, as you are
exhausted." Then I got hold of a gourd and ate it, and no
sooner had I eaten it than it turned me into a/python.

But King Vishamasila, when he saw me suddenly turn
into a python, was astonished and despondent. So, being
there alone, he called to mind the Vetala Bhiitaketu, whom
he had long ago made his servant, by delivering him with a
look from a disease of the eyes. That Vetala came, as soon
as the king called him to mind, and bowing before him said :
" Why did you call me to mind, great king ? Give me your
orders." Then the king said : " Good sir, this my kdrpatika
has been suddenly turned into a python by eating a gourd ;
restore him to his former condition." But the Vetala said :
" King, I have not the power to do this. Powers are strictly
limited. Can water quench the flame of lightning ? " Then
the king said : " Then let us go to this village, my friend.
We may eventually hear of some remedy from the Bhillas
there."

When the king had come to this conclusion, he went to
that village with the Vetala. There the bandits surrounded

1 In European superstition we find the notion that witches can fly through
the air by anointing themselves with the fat of a toad, Veckenstedt, Wendische
Mdrchen, p. 288. In Bartsch, Sagen und Gebrauche aus Meklenburg, we read
(vol. ii, p. 19) that Margretha Detloses confesses that she smeared her feet
with some black stuff that Satan brought, and then said, Auf und darvan und
nergens an. Anneke Mettinges (ibid., p. 23) smeared herself with yellow fat ;

Anneke Swarten (ibid. p. 27) with black stuff from an unused pot. Cf. the

magic ointment in the Nights, " The Adventures of Bulukiya," vol. v, p. 308
et seq. — n.m.p.

46 THE OCEAN OF STORY

him, seeing that he wore ornaments. But when they began
to rain arrows upon him, the Vetala, by the order of the king,
devoured five hundred of them. The rest fled and told their
chief what had occurred, and he, whose name was Ekakike-
s*arin, came there in wrath, with his host. But one of his
servants recognized the monarch, and the chief, hearing from
him who it was, came and clung to Vikramaditya's feet, and
announced himself. Then the king welcomed kindly the sub-
missive chief, and asked after his health, and said to him :
" My kdrpatika has become a python by eating the fruit of a
gourd in the forest ; so devise some plan for releasing him
from his transformation."

When that chief heard that speech of the king's, he said to
him : " King, let this follower of yours show him to my son
here." Then that son of his came with the Vetala, and made
me a man as before by means of a sternutatory made of the
extract of a plant. And then we went joyfully into the
presence of the king ; and when I bent at the feet of the king,
the king informed the delighted chief who I was.

Then the Bhilla chief, Ekakikesarin, after obtaining the
king's consent, conducted him and us to his palace. And we
beheld that dwelling of his, crowded with Savaras, having its
high walls covered with the tusks of elephants, adorned with
tiger-skins ; in which the women had for garments the tails
of peacocks, for necklaces strings of gunjd fruit, and for
perfume the ichor that flows from the forehead of elephants.
There the wife of the chief, having her garments perfumed
with musk, adorned with pearls and such like ornaments,
herself waited on the king.

Then the king, having bathed and taken a meal, observed
that the chief's sons were old, while he was a young man, and
put this question to him : " Chief, explain, I pray you, this
that puzzles me. How comes it that you are a young man,
whereas these children of yours are old ? "

When the king had said this to the Savara chief, he
answered him : " This, King, is a strange story. Listen, if
you feel any curiosity about it.

THE HEAVENLY FRUIT 47

171d (1). The Grateful Monkey l

I was long ago a Brahman named Chandrasvamin, and I
lived in the city of Mayapuri. One day I went by order of
my father to the forest to fetch wood. There a monkey stood
barring my way, but without hurting me, looking at me with
an eye of grief, pointing out to me another path. I said to
myself : " This monkey does not bite me, so I had better go
along the path which he points out, and see what his object
is." Thereupon I set out with him along that path, and the
monkey kept going along in front of me, and turning round to
look at me. And after he had gone some distance, he climbed
up a jambu tree, and I looked at the upper part of the tree
— which was covered with a dense network of creepers — and I
saw a female monkey there with her body fettered by a mass
of creepers twisted round her, and I understood that it was
on this account that the monkey had brought me there. Then
I climbed up the tree, and cut with my axe the creepers 2 that
had twisted round and entangled her, and set that female
monkey at liberty.

And when I got down from the tree, the male and female
monkey came down also and embraced my feet. And the
male monkey left that female clinging to my feet for a moment
and went and fetched a heavenly fruit, and gave it to me. I
took it and returned home after I had got my fuel, and there
I and my wife ate that splendid fruit together, and as soon as
we had eaten it, we ceased to be liable to old age and disease.3

1 See Vol. V, pp. 157, 157ft1, 158n. The present story bears perhaps a
closer resemblance to that of Androclus, Aulus Gellius, Nodes Atticce, v, 14, the
Indian form of which may be found in Miss Stokes' tale of " The Man who

went to seek his Fate," Indian Fairy Tales, p. 63 et seq. Owing to the large

number of sub-tales introduced, a slightly different form of enumeration has
to be adopted. — n.m.p.

2 Vati should, of course, be valti.

3 Cf. Oesterley's Baital Pachlsl, p. 14 ; and the note on p. 176. In
Elian's Varia Historia, iii, 19, there is a tree, the fruit of which makes an old
man become gradually younger and younger until he reaches the antenatal
state of non-existence. The passage is referred to by Rohde, Der Griechische
Roman, p. 207. Baring-Gould, in Appendix A to his Curious Myths of the Middle
Ages, gives a very curious passage from the Bragda Magus Saga, an Icelandic
version of the romance of Maugis. Here we have a man named Vidforull who

48 THE OCEAN OF STORY

Then there arose in that eountry of ours the scourge of
famine. And afflicted by that calamity the people of that
land fled in all directions. And I happened in course of time
to reach this country with my wife. And at that time there
was a kino of the Savaras named Kanchanadamshtra. I
entered his service with my sword. And as Kanchanadam-
shtra saw that I came to the front in several engagements, he
appointed me general. And as I had won the affections of
that master of mine by my exclusive devotion to him, when
he died, having no son, he bestowed on me his kingdom. And
twenty-seven hundred years have passed over my head, since
I have been in this place, and yet, owing to eating that fruit,
I do not suffer from old age.

171d. Kalingasend's Marriage to King Vikramaditya

When Ekakikesarin, the King of the Bhillas, had told in
these words his own history, he went on to ask a favour of
the astonished monarch, saying : " By the fruit given by the
monkey I gained a long life, and by that long life I have again
obtained a perfect fruit — namely, the sight of your august self.
So I entreat, King, that the condescension towards me which
you have shown by coming to my house, may be developed
into gracious approval. I have, King, a daughter of match-
less beauty, born to me by a Kshatriya wife, and her name is
Madanasundari. That pearl of maidens ought not to fall to
the lot of anyone but your Highness. Therefore I bestow her
on you ; marry her with due ceremonies. And I, sovereign,
will follow you as your slave with twenty thousand archers."

When the Bhilla chief addressed this petition to the king,
he granted it. And in an auspicious hour he married the
daughter of that chief, who gave him a hundred camels laden
with pearls and musk. And after the king had remained
there seven days, he set out thence with Madanasundari and
the army of the Bhillas.

was in the habit of changing his skin and becoming young again. He changed
his skin once when he was 330 years old, a second time at the age of 215 and
a third time in the presence of Charlemagne. It is quite possible that the story
in the text is a form of the fable of the Wandering Jew.

u

a:

THE BOAR IS SLAIN 49

In the meanwhile, after the king had been carried away
by his horse, our army remained despondent in the forest,
where the hunting took place ; but the warder Bhadrayudha
said to them : " Away with despondency ! Even though our
king has been away for a long time, he is of divine power,
and no serious misfortune will happen to him. Do you not
remember how he went to Patala and married there the
daughter of a Naga, whose name was Surtipa, and came back
here alone ; and how the hero went to the world of the Gan-
dharvas, and returned here with Taravali, the daughter of the
king of the Gandharvas ? " With these words Bhadrayudha
consoled them all ; and they remained at the entrance of the
forest waiting for the king.

And while that Madanasundari was advancing leisurely
by an open path, accompanied by the Savara hosts, the king
entered that forest on horseback, with myself and the Vetala,
in order to get a sight of the boar he had before seen ; and
when he entered it, the boar rushed out in front of him, and
the moment the king saw it, he killed it with five arrows.
When it was slain, the Vetala rushed to it and tore its belly
open, and suddenly there issued from it a man of pleasing
appearance.

The king, astonished, asked him who he was, and then
there came there a wild elephant, resembling a moving moun-
tain. When the king saw that wild elephant charging down
on him, he smote it in a vital place and slew it with a single
arrow. The Vetala tore open its belly also, and there issued
from it a man of heavenly appearance, and a woman beautiful
in all her limbs. And when the king was about to question
the man who issued from the boar, he said to him : " Listen,
King, I am going to tell you my history.

" We two, King, are two sons of gods * ; this one's name
is Bhadra, and I am Subha. As we were roaming about we
observed the hermit Kanva engaged in meditation. We
assumed in sport the forms of an elephant and a boar, and
aving done so, we terrified the great sage in our reckless folly,
and he pronounced on us this curse : ' Become in this forest
an elephant and boar such as you are now ; but when you

1 I read devakumarau.
VOL. IX. D

50 THE OCEAN OF STORY

shall be killed by King Vikramaditya, you shall be released
from the curse.' So we became an elephant and a boar by
the curse of the hermit, and we have to-day been set free
by you. As for this woman, let her tell her own story.
But touch this boar on the neck and this elephant on
the back, and they will become for you celestial sword and
shield."

When he had said this he disappeared with his companion,
and the boar and elephant, touched by the hand of the king,
became for him a sword and a shield. Then the woman, being
questioned about her history, spoke as follows :

" I am the wife of a great merchant in Ujjayini named
Dhanadatta. One night, as I was sleeping on the top of a
palace, this elephant came and swallowed me and brought me
here ; however, this man was not inside the elephant, but when
its belly was torn open he came out of it with me."

When the woman said this in grief, the king said to her :
"Be of good courage ! I will take you to your husband's
house. Go and journey along in security with my harem."
When he had said this, he made the Vetala take her and hand
her over to the Queen Madanasundari, who was travelling by
a different path.

Then, the Vetala having returned, we suddenly saw there
in the wood two princesses, with a numerous and splendid
retinue. And the king sent me and summoned their chamber-
lains, and they, when asked whence the two maidens came,
told the following story :

171d (2). The Two Princesses

There is a dvipa named Kataha, the home of all felicities.
In it there is a king rightly named Gunasagara.1 He had
born to him by his principal queen a daughter named
Gunavati, who by her beauty produced astonishment even
in the Creator who made her. And holy seers announced that
she should have for a husband the lord of the seven dvipas.
Whereupon her father, the king, deliberated with his coun-
sellors, and came to this conclusion : " King Vikramaditya

1 I.e. "sea of virtues."

THE GREAT FISH 51

is a suitable husband for my daughter ; so I will send her to
marry him."

Accordingly, the king made his daughter embark in a
ship on the sea, with her retinue and wealth, and sent her
off. But it so happened that when the ship came near
Suvarnadvipa it was swallowed, with the princess and the
people on board, by a large fish. But that monstrous fish was
carried by the current of the sea, as if by the course of Destiny,
and thrown up on a coast near that dvipa, and there stranded.
And the people of the neighbourhood, the moment they saw
it, ran with many weapons in their hands, and killed that
marvellous fish, and cut open its belly.1 And then there
came out of it that great ship full of people. And when the
king of that dvlpa heard of it, he came there greatly wonder-
ing. And that king, whose name was Chandrasekhara, and
who was the brother-in-law of King Gunasagara, heard the
whole story from the people in the ship. Then the king,
finding that Gunavati was the daughter of his sister, took
her into his palace, and out of joy celebrated a feast. And
the next day that king put on board a ship in a lucky
moment his daughter ChandravatI, whom he had long in-
tended to give to King Vikramaditya, with that Gunavati,
and sent her off with much magnificence as a gift to that
sovereign.

These two princesses, having crossed the sea, by advancing
gradually, have at length arrived here ; and we are their
attendants. And when we reached this place, a very large
boar and a very large elephant rushed upon us. Then, King,
we uttered this cry : " These maidens have come to offer
themselves for wives to King Vikramaditya : so preserve
them for him, ye Guardians of the World, as is meet." When
the boar and the elephant heard this, they said to us with
articulate speech : " Be of good courage ! The mere mention
of that king's name ensures your safety. And you shall
see him arrive here in a moment." When the boar and the

1 See Vol. II, pp. 193, 193nl, 194n, and Vol. VI, p. 154, 154n3, and Rohde's
note on page 196 of Der Griechische Roman. This is probably the incident
depicted on the Bharhut Stupa. See General Cunningham's work, Plate
XXXIV, Medallion 2.

52 THE OCEAN OF STORY

elephant, who were, no doubt, some heavenly beings or others,
had said this, they went away.

171d. KalingasenoVs Marriage to King Vikramaditya

" This is our story," said the chamberlain, and then,
Queen, I said to them : " And this is the king you seek."
Then they fell at the king's feet, rejoicing, and made over
to him those two princesses Gunavati and Chandravati.
And the king gave orders to the Vetala and had those two
fair ones also taken to his queen, saying : " Let all three
travel with Madanasundarl."

The Vetala returned immediately, and then, Queen, the
king went with him and myself by an out-of-the-way path.
And as we were going along in the forest, the sun set ;
and just at that time we heard there the sound of a drum.
The king asked : " Whence comes this sound of a drum ? "
The Vetala answered him : " King, there is a temple here.
It is a marvel of heavenly skill, having been built by
Visvakarman; and this beating of the drum is to announce
the commencement of the evening spectacle."

When the Vetala had said this, he and the king and I went
there out of curiosity, and after we had tied up the horse we
entered. And we saw worshipped there a great linga of
tdrkshyaratna,1 and in front of it a spectacle with blazing
lights. And there danced there for a long time three nymphs
of celestial beauty, in four kinds of measures, accompanied
with music and singing. And at the end of the spectacle
we beheld a wonder, for the dancing nymphs disappeared in
the figures carved on the pillars of the temple ; and in the
same way the singers and players went into the figures of
men painted on the walls. When the king saw this he was
astonished ; but the Vetala said to him : " Such is this
heavenly enchantment produced by Visvakarman, lasting for
ever, for this will always take place at both twilights."

1 A certain dark-coloured precious stone. Bohtlingk and Roth s.v.

Sir George Grierson tells me he thinks it must be the same as the Garuda-
manikya, which means " emerald." Both words have the same literal meaning
anyway. — n.m.p.

THE STORY OF DHANADATTA 53

When he had said this, we wandered about in the temple,
and saw in one place a female figure, on a pillar, of extra-
ordinary beauty. When the king saw her, he was bewildered
by her beauty, and remained for a moment absent-minded and
motionless, so that he himself was like a figure cut on a pillar.
And he exclaimed : " If I do not see a living woman like this
figure, of what profit to me is my kingdom or my life ? "
When the Vetala heard this, he said : " Your wish is not hard
to gratify, for the King of Kalinga has a daughter named
Kalingasena, and a sculptor of Vardhamana seeing her, and
being desirous of representing her beauty, carved this figure in
imitation of her.1 So return to Ujjayini, King, and ask that
King of Kalinga for his daughter, or carry her off by force."
This speech of the Vetala's the king laid up in his heart.

Then we spent that night there. And the next morning we
set out, and we saw two handsome men under an asoka tree,
and then they rose up and bowed before the king. Then the
king said to them : " Who are you, and why are you in the
forest ? " One of them answered : " Listen, King, I will tell
you the whole story.

171d (3). The Merchant Dhanadatta who lost his Wife

I am the son of a merchant in Ujjayini, and my name is
Dhanadatta. Once on a time I went to sleep on the top of
my palace. In the morning I woke up and looked about me,
and lo ! my wife was not in the palace, nor in the garden
attached to it, nor anywhere about it. I said to myself :
44 She has not lost her heart to another man ; of that I am
convinced by the fact that the garland which she gave me,
telling me that as long as she remained chaste it would cer-
tainly not fade, is still as fresh as ever.2 So I cannot think
where she has gone — whether she has been carried off by a
demon or some other evil being, or what has happened to

1 The Petersburg lexicographers explain it as a statue of sala wood. They
explain stambhotlarna too as wie aus einem Pf'osten geschnitten, wie eine Statue von
Holz. But could not the figures be cut in stone, as the Bharhut sculptures are ?

2 See Vol. I, pp. 156, l6'5-l68. The parallel to the story of the " Wright's
Chaste Wife " is strikingly close.

54 THE OCEAN OF STORY

her." With these thoughts in my mind I remained looking
for her, crying out, lamenting and weeping ; consumed by
the fire of separation from her ; taking no food. Then my
relations succeeded at last in consoling me to a certain extent,
and I took food, and I made my abode in a temple, and
remained there plunged in grief, feasting Brahmans.

Once when I was quite broken down, this Brahman came
to me there, and I refreshed him with a bath and food, and
after he had eaten, I asked him whence he came, and he
said : "I am from a village near Varanasi." My servants
told him my cause of woe, and he said : " Why have you,
like an unenterprising man, allowed your spirits to sink ?
The energetic man obtains even that which it is hard to
attain ; so rise up, my friend, and let us look for your wife.
I will help you."

I said : " How are we to look for her, when we do not even
know in what direction she has gone ? " When I said this,
he answered me kindly : " Do not say this. Did not Kesata
long ago recover his wife, when it seemed hopeless he should
ever be reunited with her ? Hear his story in proof of it.

171d (4). The Two Brahmans Kesata and Kandarpa

There lived in the city of Pataliputra a wealthy young
Brahman, the son of a Brahman ; his name was Kesata, and
he was in beauty like a second God of Love. He wished to
obtain a wife like himself, and so he went forth secretly *
from his parents' house, and wandered through various lands
on the pretext of visiting holy bathing-places. And in the
course of his wanderings he came once on a time to a bank of
the Narmada, and he saw a numerous procession of bride-
groom's friends coming that way. And a distinguished old
Brahman, belonging to that company, when he saw Kesata
in the distance, left his companions, and coming up to him
accosted him, and respectfully said to him in private : "I
have a certain favour to ask of you, and it is one which you
can easily do for me, but the benefit conferred on me will be

1 Dr Kern would read avidito. This is confirmed by the Sanskrit College
MS. and by MS. No. 1882 ; No. 3003 has avadito.

THE BARGAIN 55

a very great one ; so, if you will do it, I will proceed to say
what it is." When Kesata heard this, he said : " Noble sir,
if what you say is possible, I must certainly do it : let the
benefit be conferred on you."

When the Brahman heard that, he said : " Listen, my
good young man. I have a son, who is the prince of ugly, as
you are of good-looking, men. He has projecting teeth, a flat
nose, a black colour, squinting eyes, a big belly, crooked feet,
and ears like winnowing-baskets. Though he is such, I, out
of my love for him, described him as handsome, and asked
a Brahman, named Ratnadatta, to give him his daughter,
named Riipavati, and he has agreed to do it. The girl is as
beautiful as her name expresses, and to-day they are to be
married. For this reason we have come. But I know that,
when that purposed connection of mine sees my son, he will
refuse to give him his daughter, and this attempt will be fruit-
less. And while thinking how I could find some way out of
the difficulty, I have met you here, courteous sir ; so quickly
perform for me my desire, as you have pledged your word to
do. Come with us and marry that maiden, and hand her over
to my son to-day, for you are as good-looking as the bride."

When Kesata heard this, he said : " Agreed ! " And so
the old Brahman took Kesata with him, and they crossed the
Narmada in boats and landed on the opposite bank. And
so he reached the city, and rested outside it with his followers,
and at that time the sun also, the traveller of the sky, went to
his rest on the mountain of setting. Then the darkness began
to diffuse itself abroad, and Kesata, having gone to rinse his
mouth, saw a terrible Rakshasa rise up near the water. And
the Rakshasa said : " Where will you go from me,1 Kesata ?
I am about to devour you." Thereupon Kesata said to the
Rakshasa : " Do not devour me now ; I will certainly come
back to you presently, when I have done the Brahman the
service I promised." When the Rakshasa heard this, he
made Kesata take an oath to this effect,2 and then let him

1 Both the India Office MSS. and the Sanskrit College MS. have yasyasi for
pasyasi. The latter would mean : " Where will you drink ? "

2 This is another example of the " Promise to Return " motif. See Ocean,
Vol. VII, p. 203, 203n1.— n.m.p.

56 THE OCEAN OF STORY

go ; and he returned to the company of the bridegroom's
friends.

Then the old Brahman brought Kesata adorned with the
ornaments of a bridegroom, and entered that city with all
the bridegroom's party. And then he made him enter the
house of Ratnadatta, in which an altar-platform was ready
prepared, and which was made to resound with the music of
various instruments. And Kesata married there with all due
ceremonies that fair-faced RupavatI, to whom her father gave
great wealth. And the women there rejoiced, seeing that the
bride and bridegroom were well matched. And not only
RupavatI, when she saw that such a bridegroom had arrived,
but her friends also, fell in love with him. But Kesata at that
time was overpowered with despondency and astonishment.

And at night RupavatI, seeing that her husband, as he lay
on the bed, was plunged in thought, and kept his head turned
away, pretended to be asleep. And in the dead of night
Kesata, thinking that she was asleep, went out to that Rak-
shasa to keep his promise. And that faithful wife RupavatI
also gently rose up unobserved and followed her husband, full
of curiosity. And when Kesata arrived where the Rakshasa
was, the latter said to him : " Bravo ! You have kept your
promise faithfully, Kesata : you are a man of noble character.
You sanctify your city of Pataliputra and your father Desata
by your virtue, so approach, that I may devour you." When
RupavatI heard that, she came up quickly and said : " Eat
me, for if my husband is eaten, what will become of me ? "
The Rakshasa said : " You can live on alms." She replied :
" Who, noble sir, will give alms to me who am a woman ? "
The Rakshasa said : "If anyone refuses to give you alms
when asked to do so, his head shall split in a hundred pieces." *
Then she said : " This being so, give me my husband by way
of alms." And as the Rakshasa would not give him, his head
at once split asunder, and he died. Then RupavatI returned
to her bridal chamber with her husband, who was exceedingly
astonished at her virtue, and at that moment the night came
to an end.

And the next morning the bridegroom's friends took food
1 Cf. Vol. V, pp. 95, 96.— n.m.p.

KESATA IS SAVED 57

and set out from that city, and reached the bank of the Nar-
mada with the newly married pair. Then the old Brahman,
who was their leader, put the wife Rupavati, with her attend-
ants, on board one boat, and went on board a second himself,
and cunningly made Kesata embark on a third, having pre-
viously made an agreement with the boatmen ; but before he
went on board he took from him all the ornaments he had
lent him. Then the Brahman was ferried across with the wife
and the bridegroom's party, but Kesata was kept out in the
middle of the stream by the boatmen, and carried to a great
distance. Then those boatmen pushed the boat and Kesata
into a place where the current ran full and strong, and swam
ashore themselves, having been bribed by the old Brahman.

But Kesata was carried with the boat, by the river which
was lashed into waves by the wind, into the sea, and at last a
wave flung him up on the coast. There he recovered strength
and spirits, as he was not doomed to die just yet ; and he said
to himself : " Well, that Brahman has made me a fine recom-
pense ! But was not the fact that he married his son by
means of a substitute in itself sufficient proof that he was a
fool and a scoundrel ? "

While he remained there, buried in such thoughts, the
night came on him, when the companies of air-flying witches
begin to roam about. He remained sleepless through it, and
in the fourth watch he heard a noise in the sky, and saw a
handsome ' man fall from heaven in front of him. Kesata
was terrified at first, but after some time he saw that he had
nothing uncanny about him, so he said to him : " Who are
you, sir ? " Then the man said : " First tell me who you
are, and then I will tell you who I am." Hearing that,
Kesata told him his history. Then the man said : " My
friend, you are exactly in the same predicament as myself,
so I will now tell you my history. Listen.

"There is on the bank of the River Vena a city named
Ratnapura; I am a Brahman householder in that city, the
son of a rich man, and my name is Kandarpa. One evening
I went down to the River Vena to draw water, and I slipped
and fell into it, and was carried away by the current. The

1 I insert subhayam before khdd, from the Sanskrit College MS.

58 THE OCEAN OF STORY

current carried me a long way during that night, and when
the morning came, as I was not doomed to die yet, it brought
me to the foot of a tree that grew on the bank. I climbed

Kandarpa UP ^ne ^an^ by the nelp °f the tree, and when I
relates his had recovered breath I saw in front of me a
Adventures great empty temple dedicated to the Mothers. I
entered it, and when I saw before me the Mothers flashing,
as it were, with brightness and power, my fear was allayed,
and I bowed before them, and praised them, and addressed
this prayer to them : ' Venerable ones, deliver me, a miserable
man ; for I have to-day come here as a suppliant for your
protection.' When I had uttered this prayer, being exhausted
with my struggles in the current of the river, I rested, my
friend, till my fatigue gradually disappeared, and the day dis-
appeared also. And then there appeared the horrible female
ascetic called Night, furnished with many stars by way of a
bone necklace, white with moonlight instead of ashes, and
carrying the moon for a gleaming skull.

" And then, I remember, a band of witches came out from
the company of the Mothers, and they said to one another :
4 To-night we must go to the general assembly of the witches
in Chakrapura,1 and how can this Brahman be kept safe in
this place which is full of wild beasts ? So let us take him
to some place where he will be happy ; and afterwards we
will bring him back again : he has fled to us for protection.'
When they had said this, they adorned me, and, carrying me
through the air, placed me in the house of a rich Brahman
in a certain city, and went away.

" And when I looked about me there, lo ! the altar was
prepared for a marriage, and the auspicious hour had
arrived, but the procession of bridegroom's friends was
nowhere to be seen. And all the people, seeing me in front
of the door arrayed in bridegroom's garments of heavenly
splendour, said : * Here is the bridegroom at any rate arrived.'
Then the Brahman of the house took me to the altar, and
led his daughter there adorned, and gave her to me with the
usual ceremonies. And the women said to one another :

1 Both the India Office MSS. read Vakrapura. The Sanskrit College MS.
supports Brockhaus' text.

THE CITY OF BHlMAPURA 59

1 Fortunate is it that the beauty of Sumanas has borne fruit
by winning her a bridegroom like herself ! ' Then, having
married Sumanas, I slept with her in the palace, gratified by
having every want supplied in the most magnificent style.

" Then those witches came back from their assembly in
this last watch of the night, and by their supernatural power
carried me off, and flew up into the air with me. And while
they were flying through the air they had a fight with another
set of witches, who came wishing to carry me off, and they
let me go, and I fell down here. And I do not know the city
where I married that Sumanas ; and I cannot tell what will
become of her now. This succession of misfortunes, which
Destiny has brought upon me, has now ended in happiness by
my meeting with you."

When Kandarpa had given this account of his adventures,
Kesata said to him : " Do not be afraid, my friend : the
witches will have no power over you henceforth, since I
possess a certain irresistible charm, which will keep them at
a distance. Now let us roam about together ; Destiny will
bestow on us good fortune." And while they were engaged
in this conversation the night came to an end.

In the morning Kesata and Kandarpa set out from that
place together, and, crossing the sea, reached in due course
a city named Bhimapura, near the river called Ratnanadi.
There they heard a great noise on the bank of that river, and
when they went to the place whence it came, they saw a fish
that filled the channel of the stream from bank to bank.
It had been thrown up by the tide of the sea, and had got
fast in the river owing to the vastness of its bulk, and men
with various weapons in their hands were cutting it up to
procure flesh. And while they were cutting it open there
came out of its belly a woman, and being beheld by the
people with astonishment, she came terrified to the bank.

Then Kandarpa looked at her, and said exultingly to
Kesata : " My friend, here is that very Sumanas, whom I
married ! But I do not know how she came to be living in
the belly of a fish. So let us remain here in silence, until
the whole matter is cleared up." Kesata consented, and
they remained there. And the people said to Sumanas :

60 THE OCEAN OF STORY

" Who are you, and what is the meaning of this ? " Then
she said very reluctantly :

" I am the daughter of a crest- jewel of Brahmans, named
Jayadatta, who lived in the city of Ratnakara. My name is
Sumanas, and one night I was married to a certain handsome
young Brahman, who was a suitable match for me. That
very night my husband went away somewhere, while I was
asleep ; and though my father made diligent search for him,
he could not find him anywhere. Then I threw myself into
the river to cool the fire of grief at separation from him, and
I was swallowed by this fish ; and now Destiny has brought
me here."

While she was saying this a Brahman named Yajnasvamin
rushed out of the crowd and embraced her, and said this to
her : " Come, come with me, niece ! You are the daughter of
my sister ; for I am Yajnasvamin, your mother's own brother.
When Sumanas heard that, she uncovered her face and looked
at him, and recognising her uncle, she embraced his feet,
weeping. But after a moment she ceased weeping, and said
to him : " Do you give me fuel, for, as I am separated from
my husband, I have no other refuge but the fire."

Her uncle did all he could to dissuade her, but she would
not abandon her intention ; and then Kandarpa, having thus
seen her real feelings tested, came up to her. When the
wise Sumanas saw him near her she recognised him, and fell
weeping at his feet. And when the discreet woman was
questioned by the people, and by that uncle of hers, she
answered : " He is my husband." Then all were delighted.
And Yajnasvamin took her husband Kandarpa to his house,
together with Kesata. There they told their adventures, and
Yajnasvamin and his family lovingly waited on them with
many hospitable attentions.

After some days had passed, Kesata said to Kandarpa :
" You have gained all you want by recovering your longed-
for wife ; so now go with her to Ratnapura, your own city.
But as I have not attained the object of my desire, I will not
return to my own country. I, my friend, will make a pilgrim-
age to all the holy bathing-places and so destroy my body."
When Yajnasvamin, in Bhimapura, heard this, he said to

THE TRICK 61

Kesata : " Why do you utter this despondent speech ? As long
as people are alive there is nothing they cannot get. In
proof of this hear the story of Kusumayudha, which I am
about to tell you.

171d (5). Kusumayudha and Kamalalochana

There was in a town named Chandrapura a Brahman
named Devasvamin : he had a very beautiful daughter
named Kamalalochana ; and he had a young Brahman
pupil named Kusumayudha, and that pupil and his daughter
loved one another well.

One day her father made up his mind to give her to
another suitor, and at once that maiden sent by her confidante
the following message to Kusumayudha : " Though I have
long ago fixed my heart on you for a husband, my father has
promised to give me to another, so devise a scheme for carry-
ing me off hence." So Kusumayudha made an arrangement
to carry her off, and he placed outside her house at night a
servant with a mule for that purpose. So she quietly went
out and mounted the mule, but that servant did not take her
to his master ; he took her somewhere else, to make her his
own.

And during the night he took Kamalalochana a long dis-
tance, and they reached a certain city by the morning, when
that chaste woman said to the servant : " Where is my
husband, your master ? Why do you not take me to him ? "
When the cunning rogue heard this, he said to her who was
alone in a foreign country : "I am going to marry you my-
self : never mind about him ; how can you get to him now ? "
When the discreet woman heard this, she said : " Indeed I
love you very much." * Then the rascal left her in the garden
of the city, and went to the market to buy the things required
for a wedding. In the meanwhile that maiden fled, with
the mule, and entered the house of a certain old man who
made garlands. She told him her history, and he made her

1 No. 1882 and the Sanskrit College MS. give tarhi for tvayt hi and priyatp.
for prtyah. No. 3003 agrees with the above MSS. in the first point and in the
second with Brockhaus.

62 THE OCEAN OF STORY

welcome ; so she remained there. And the wicked servant, not
finding her in the garden, went away from it disappointed,
and returned to his master Kusumayudha. And when his
master questioned him, he said : " The fact is, you are an
upright man yourself, and you do not understand the ways of
deceitful women. No sooner did she come out and was seen,
than I was seized there by those other men, and the mule was
taken away from me. By good luck I managed to escape,
and have come here." When Kusumayudha heard this, he
remained silent and plunged in thought.

One day his father sent him to be married, and as he
was going along he reached the city where Kamalalochana
was. There he made the bridegroom's followers encamp in a
neighbouring garden, and while he was roaming about alone,
Kamalalochana saw him, and told the garland-maker in
whose house she was living. He went and told her intended
husband what had taken place, and brought him to her. Then
the garland-maker collected the necessary things, and the
long-desired marriage between the youth and the maiden was
immediately celebrated. Then Kusumayudha punished that
wicked servant, and married in addition that second maiden,
who was the cause of his finding Kamalalochana, and in
order to marry whom he had started from home. And he
returned rejoicing to his own country with those two wives.

171d (4). The Two Brdhmans Kesata and Kandarpa

" Thus the fortunate are reunited in the most unexpected
manner ; and so you may be certain, Kesata, of regaining your
beloved soon in the same way." When Yajnasvamin had
said this, Kandarpa, Sumanas and Kesata remained for some
days in his house, and then set out for their own country.
But on the way they reached a great forest, and they were
separated from one another in the confusion produced by a
charge of wild elephants. Of the party Kesata went on alone,
and grieved, and in course of time reached the city of Kasi
and found his friend Kandarpa there. And he went with him
to his own city Pataliputra, and he remained there some time
welcomed by his father. And there he told his parents all his

SUMANAS IS LOST 63

adventures, beginning with his marrying Rupavati, and
ending with the story of Kandarpa.

In the meanwhile Sumanas fled, terrified at the elephants,
and entered a thicket, and while she was there the sun set for
her. And when night came on she cried out in her woe :
" Alas, my husband ! Alas, my father ! Alas, my mother ! "
and resolved to fling herself into a forest fire. And in the
meanwhile that company of witches, that were so full of pity
for Kandarpa, having conquered the other witches, reached
their own temple. There they remembered Kandarpa, and
finding out by their supernatural knowledge that his wife
had lost her way in a wood, they deliberated as follows :
" Kandarpa, being a resolute man, will unaided obtain his
desire ; but his wife, being a young girl, and having lost her
way in the forest, will assuredly die. So let us take her
and put her down in Ratnapura, in order that she may live
there in the house of Kandarpa's father with his other wife."
When the witches had come to this conclusion, they went to
that forest and comforted Sumanas there, and took her and
left her in Ratnapura.

When the night had passed, Sumanas, wandering about
in that city, heard the following cry in the mouths of the
people, who were running hither and thither : " Lo ! the
virtuous Anangavati, wife of the Brahman Kandarpa, who,
after her husband had gone somewhere or other, lived a long
time in hope of reunion with him, not having recovered him,
has now gone out in despair to enter the fire, followed by her
weeping father-in-law and mother-in-law." When Sumanas
heard that, she went quickly to the place where the pyre had
been made, and going to Anangavati, said to her, in order to
dissuade her : " Noble lady, do not act rashly, for that
husband of yours is alive." Having said this, she told the
whole story from the beginning. And she showed the
, jewelled ring that Kandarpa gave her. Then all welcomed
her, perceiving that her account was true. Then Kandarpa's
father honoured that bride Sumanas, and gladly lodged her
in his house with the delighted Anangavati.

Then Kandarpa left Pataliputra x without telling Kesata,

1 I read Pataliputrakat.

64 THE OCEAN OF STORY

as he knew he would not like it, in order to roam about in
search of Sumanas. And after he had gone, Kesata, feeling
unhappy without Riipavatl, left his house without his parents'
knowledge, and went to roam about hither and thither. And
Kandarpa, in the course of his wanderings, happened to visit
that very city where Kesata married Riipavatl. And hear-
ing a great noise of people, he asked what it meant, and a
certain man said to him : " Here is Riipavatl preparing to
die, as she cannot find her husband Kesata; the tumult is
on that account. Listen to the story connected with her."
Then that man related the strange story of Rupavati's mar-
riage with Kesata and of her adventure with the Rakshasa,
and then continued as follows :

" Then that old Brahman, having tricked Kesata, went
on his way, taking with him Riipavatl for his son ; but no-
body knew where Kesata had gone after marrying her. And
Riipavatl, not seeing Kesata on the journey, said : ' Why do
I not see my husband here, though all the rest of the party are
travelling along with me ? ' When the old Brahman heard
that, he showed her that son of his, and said to her : ' My
daughter, this son of mine is your husband : behold him ! '
Then Riipavatl said in a rage to the old man there : 4 1 will
not have this ugly fellow for a husband ! I will certainly die
if I cannot get that husband who married me yesterday.'

" Saying this, she at once stopped eating and drinking ;
and the old man, through fear of the king, had her taken back
to her father's house. There she told the trick that the old
Brahman had played her, and her father, in great grief, said
to her : ■ How are we to discover, my daughter, who the man
that married you is ? ' Then Riipavatl said : 4 My husband's
name is Kesata, and he is the son of a Brahman named
Desata in Pataliputra ; for so much I heard from the mouth
of a Rakshasa.' When she had said this, she told her father
the whole story of her husband and the Rakshasa. Then her
father went and saw the Rakshasa lying dead, and so he
believed his daughter's story, and was pleased with the virtue
of that couple.

" He consoled his daughter with hopes of reunion with her
husband, and sent his son to Kesata's father in Pataliputra

THE TIMELY ARRIVAL 65

to search for him. And after some time he came back and
said : 4 We saw the householder Desata in Pataliputra. But
when we asked him where his son Kesata was, he answered
us with tears : " My son Kesata is not here. He did return
here, and a friend of his named Kandarpa came with him ;
but he went away from here without telling me, pining for
Rupavati." When we heard this speech of his, we came back
here in due course.'

" When those sent to search had brought back this report,
Rupavati said to her father : ' I shall never recover my
husband, so I will enter the fire ; how long, father, can I live
here without my husband ? ' She went on saying this, and
as her father has not been able to dissuade her, she has come
out to-day to perish in the fire. And two maidens, friends
of hers, have come out to die in the same way ; one is called
Sringaravati, and the other Anuragavati. For long ago, at
the marriage of Rupavati, they saw Kesata and made up their
minds that they would have him for a husband, as their hearts
were captivated by his beauty. This is the meaning of the
noise which the people here are making."

When Kandarpa heard this from that man, he went to the
pyre which had been heaped up by those ladies. He made a
sign to the people from a distance to cease their tumult, and,
going up quickly, he said to Rupavati, who was worshipping
the fire : " Noble lady, desist from this rashness. That
husband of yours, Kesata, is alive ; he is my friend : know
that I am Kandarpa." When he had said this, he told her
all Kesata's adventures, beginning with the circumstance of
the old Brahman's treacherously making him embark on the
boat. Then Rupavati believed him, as his story tallied so
completely with what she knew, and she joyfully entered her
father's house with those two friends. And her father kindly
welcomed Kandarpa and took good care of him. And so he
remained there, to please him.

In the meanwhile it happened that, as Kesata was
roaming about, he reached Ratnapura, and found there the
house of Kandarpa, in which the two wives were. And as
he was wandering about near the house, Sumanas, the wife
of Kandarpa, saw him from the top of her house, and said,

VOL. IX. E

66 THE OCEAN OF STORY

delighted, to her father-in-law and mother-in-law, and the
other people in the house : " Here, now, is Kesata, my
husband's friend, arrived ; we may hear news of my husband
from him. Quickly invite him in." Then they went and,
on some pretext or other, brought in Kesata as she advised,
and when he saw Sumanas come towards him, he was de-
lighted. And after he had rested she questioned him, and
he immediately told her his own and Kandarpa's adventures,
after the scare produced by the wild elephants.

He remained there some days, hospitably entertained,
and then a messenger came from Kandarpa with a letter.
The messenger said : " Kandarpa and Riipavati are in the
town where Kandarpa's friend Kesata married Riipavati " ;
and the contents of the letter were to the same effect. And
Kesata, with tears, communicated the tidings to the father of
Kandarpa.

And the next day Kandarpa's father sent, in high glee,
a messenger to bring his son, and dismissed Kesata, that
he might join his beloved. And Kesata went with that
messenger, who brought the letter, to that country where
Riipavati was living in her father's house. There, after a
long absence, he greeted and refreshed the delighted Riipa-
vati, as the cloud does the chdtaki. He met Kandarpa once
more, and he married, at the instance of Riipavati, her two
before-mentioned friends, Anuragavati and Sringaravati.
And then Kesata went with Riipavati and them to his
own land, after taking leave of Kandarpa. And Kandarpa
returned to Ratnapura with the messenger, and was once
more united to Sumanas and Anangavati and his relations.
So Kandarpa regained his beloved Sumanas, and Kesata his
beloved Riipavati, and they lived enjoying the good things
of this life, each in his own country.

171 d (3). The Merchant Dhanadatta who lost his Wife

" Thus men of firm resolution, though separated by
adverse destiny, are reunited with their dear ones, despising
even terrible sufferings, and taking no account of their
interminable duration. So rise up quickly, my friend ; let

THE REWARD OF MERIT 67

us go. You also will find your wife, if you search for her.
Who knows the way of Destiny ? I myself regained my
wife alive after she had died."

171d. Kalingasena's Marriage to King Vikramdditya

" Telling me this tale, my friend encouraged me ; and
himself accompanied me. And so roaming about with him,
I reached this land, and here I saw a mighty elephant and
a wild boar. And (wonderful to say !) I saw that elephant
bring my helpless wife out of his mouth and swallow her
again. And I followed that elephant, which appeared for a
moment and then disappeared for a long time; and in my
search for it I have now, thanks to my merits, beheld your
Majesty here."

When the young merchant had said this, Vikramaditya
sent for his wife, whom he had rescued by killing the elephant,
and handed her over to him. And then the couple, delighted
at their marvellous reunion, recounted their adventures to
one another, and their mouths were loud in praise of the
glorious King Vishamasila.

CHAPTER CXXIV

171d. Kalingasena' s Marriage to King Vikramdditya

THEN King Vikramaditya put this question to the
friend of the young merchant, who came with him :
" You said that you recovered your wife alive after
she was dead : how could that be ? Tell us, good sir, the
whole story at length." When the king said this to the friend
of the young merchant, the latter answered : " Listen, King,
if you have any curiosity about it, I proceed to tell the story.

171d (6). The Brahman who recovered his Wife alive
after her Death

I am a young Brahman of the name of Chandrasvamin,
living on that magnificent grant to Brahmans called Brahma-
sthala, and I have a beautiful wife in my house. One day
I had gone to the village for some object, by my father's
orders, and a kdpdlika, who had come to beg, cast eyes on
that wife of mine. She caught a fever from the moment he
looked at her, and in the evening she died. Then my relations
took her and put her on the pyre during the night. And
when the pyre was in full blaze I returned there from the
village ; and I heard what had happened from my family,
who wept before me.

Then I went near the pyre, and the kdpdlika came there,
with the magic staff dancing x on his shoulder and the boom-
ing drum in his hand. He quenched the flame of the pyre,
King, by throwing ashes on it,2 and then my wife rose up

1 The khatvanga, a club shaped like the foot of a bedstead — i.e. a staff with
a skull at the top — considered as the weapon of Siva, and carried by ascetics
and Yogis. For karah the MSS. give ravah. This would mean that the ascetic
was beating his drum. The word in No. 1882 might be khah, but is no doubt
meant for ravah.

2 Cf. Vol. VI, p. 1 80, and Canney, " Ashes," Hastings' Ency. Rel. Eth., vol. ii,
p. 112 el seq. — n.m.p.

68

THE MAGIC STAFF 69

from the midst of it uninjured. The kdpdlika took with
him my wife, who followed him, drawn by his magic power,
and ran off quickly ; and I followed him with my bow and
arrows.

And when he reached a cave on the bank of the Ganges he
put the magic staff down on the ground, and said exultingly
to two maidens who were in it : " She, without whom I
could not marry you, though I had obtained you, has come
into my possession ; and so my vow has been successfully
accomplished." * Saying this, he showed them my wife, and
at that moment I flung his magic staff into the Ganges. And
when he had lost his magic power by the loss of the staff, I
reproached him, exclaiming : " Kdpdlika, as you wish to rob
me of my wife, you shall live no longer." Then the scoundrel,
not seeing his magic staff, tried to run away ; but I drew my
bow and killed him with a poisoned arrow. Thus do heretics,
who feign the vows of Siva only for the pleasure of accom-
plishing nefarious ends, fall, though their sin has already
sunk them deep enough.

Then I took my wife, and those other two maidens, and
I returned home, exciting the astonishment of my relations.
Then I asked those two maidens to tell me their history, and
they gave me this answer : " We are the daughters respec-
tively of a king and a chief merchant in Benares, and the
kdpdlika carried us off by the same magic process by which
he carried off your wife ; and thanks to you we have been
delivered from the villain without suffering insult." This
was their tale. And the next day I took them to Benares and
handed them over to their relations, after telling what had
befallen them.2

And as I was returning thence I saw this young merchant,
who had lost his wife, and I came here with him. Moreover,
I anointed my body with an ointment that I found in the cave

1 I separate pratijna from siddhim.

2 It is possible that this may be the original of the fourth story in the

tenth day of the Decameron. Personally I can see no resemblance whatsoever.

Boccaccio's tale of Carisendi and Catalina is merely intended as an example of
great liberality on the part of a lover whose passion was not returned. The
lady in question was buried as dead, but her lover, on giving her a last kiss in
her tomb, finds her heart feebly beating, and rescues her. — n.m.p.

70 THE OCEAN OF STORY

of the kdpdlika ; and, observe, perfume still exhales from it,
even though it has been washed.

171d. Kalingasena' s Marriage to King Vikramaditya

"In this sense did I recover my wife arisen from the
dead."

When the Brahman had told this story, the king honoured
him and the young merchant, and sent them on their way.
And then that King Vikramaditya, taking with him Guna-
vati, Chandravati and Madanasundari, and having met his
own forces, returned to the city of Ujjayini, and there he
married Gunavati and Chandravati.

Then the king called to mind the figure carved on a pillar
that he had seen in the temple built by Visvakarman, and he
gave this order to the warder : " Let an ambassador be sent
to Kalingasena to demand from him that maiden whose
likeness I saw carved on the pillar." When the warder re-
ceived this command from the king, he brought before him
an ambassador named Suvigraha, and sent him off with a
message.

So the ambassador went to the country of Kalinga, and
when he had seen the King Kalingasena, he delivered to him
the message with which he had been entrusted, which was as
follows : " King, the glorious sovereign Vikramaditya sends
you this command : 4 You know that every jewel on the
earth comes to me as my due ; and you have a pearl of a
daughter, so hand her over to me, and then by my favour
you shall enjoy in your own realm an unopposed sway.' "
When the King of Kalinga heard this, he was very angry,
and he said : " Who is this King Vikramaditya ? Does he
presume to give me orders and ask for my daughter as a
tribute ? Blinded with pride he shall be cast down." When
the ambassador heard this from Kalingasena, he said to him :
" How can you, being a servant, dare to set yourself up
against your master ? You do not know your place. What,
madman ! do you wish to be shrivelled like a moth in the
fire of his wrath ? "

When the ambassador had said this, he returned and com-

THE EMPLOYMENT OF STRATAGEM 71

municated to King Vikramaditya that speech of Kalingasena's.
Then King Vishamasila, being angry, marched out with
his forces to attack the King of Kalinga, and the Vetala
Bhutaketu went with him. As he marched along, the
quarters, re-echoing the roar of his army, seemed to say to
the King of Kalinga, " Surrender the maiden quickly " ; and
so he reached that country. When King Vikramaditya saw
the King of Kalinga ready for battle, he surrounded him with
his forces. But then he thought in his mind : "I shall never
be happy without this king's daughter ; and yet how can I
kill my own father-in-law ? Suppose I have recourse to some
stratagem."

When the king had gone through these reflections, he
went with the Vetala, and by his supernatural' power entered
the bedchamber of the King of Kalinga at night, when he
was asleep, without being seen. Then the Vetala woke up
the king, and, when he was terrified, said to him, laughing :
' What ! Do you dare to sleep when you are at war with
King Vikramaditya ? " Then the King of Kalinga rose up,
and seeing the monarch, who had thus shown his daring,
standing with a terrible Vetala at his side, and recognising
him, bowed trembling at his feet, and said : " King, I now
acknowledge your supremacy ; tell me what I am to do."
And the king answered him : "If you wish to have me as
your overlord, give me your daughter Kalingasena." Then
the King of Kalinga agreed, and promised to give him his
daughter. And so the monarch returned successful to his camp.

And the next day, Queen, your father, the King of Kalinga,
bestowed you on King Vishamasila with appropriate cere-
monies, and a splendid marriage gift. Thus, Queen, you were
lawfully married by the king out of his deep love for you, and
at the risk of his own life, and not out of any desire to triumph
over an enemy.

171. Story of King Vikramaditya

" When I heard this story, my friends, from the mouth of
the kdrpatika Devasena, I dismissed my anger, which was
caused by the contempt with which I supposed myself to

72 THE OCEAN OF STORY

have been treated. So, you see, this king was induced to
marry me by seeing a likeness of me carved on a pillar, and
to marry Malaya vati by seeing a painted portrait of her."
In these words Kalingasena, the beloved wife of King Vikra-
maditya, described her husband's might, and delighted his
other wives. Then Vikramaditya, accompanied by all of them,
and by Malayavati, remained delighting in his empire.

Then one day a Rajput named Krishnasakti, who had
been oppressed by the members of his clan, came there from
the Deccan. He went to the palace gate surrounded by five
hundred Rajputs, and took on himself the vow of kdrpatika
to the king. And though the king tried to dissuade him, he
made this declaration : "I will serve King Vikramaditya for
twelve years." And he remained at the gate of the palace,
with his followers, determined to carry out his vow ; and while
he was thus engaged, eleven years passed over his head.

And when the twelfth year came, his wife, who was in
another land, grieved at her long separation from him, sent
him a letter ; and he happened to be reading this Arya verse,
which she had written in the letter, at night, by the light of a
lamp, when the king, who had gone out in search of adven-
tures, was listening, concealed: "Hot, long and tremulous,
do these sighs issue forth from me, during thy absence,
my lord, but not the breath of life, hard-hearted woman
that I am."

When the king had heard this read over and over again
by the kdrpatika, he went to his palace and said to himself :
" This kdrpatika, whose wife is in such despondency, has long
endured affliction, and if his objects are not gained he will,
when this twelfth year is at an end, yield his breath. So I
must not let him wait any longer." After going through
these reflections, the king at once sent a female slave, and
summoned that kdrpatika. And after he had caused a grant
to be written, he gave him this order : " My good fellow, go
towards the northern quarter, through Omkarapitha ; there
live on the proceeds of a village of the name of Khandavataka,
which I give you by this grant ; you will find it by asking
your way as you go along."

When the kino- had said this, he gave the grant into his

THE DESERTED CITY 73

hands, and the kdrpatika went off by night without telling
his followers. He was dissatisfied, saying to himself : " How
shall I be helped to conquer my enemies by a single village
that will rather disgrace me ? Nevertheless, my sovereign's
orders must be obeyed." So he slowly went on, and having
passed Omkarapitha, he saw in a distant forest many maidens
playing, and then he asked them this question : " Do you
know where Khandavataka is ? " When they heard that,
they answered : " We do not know ; go on farther. Our
father lives only ten yojanas from here; ask him. He may
perhaps know of that village."

When the maidens had said this to him, the kdrpatika
went on, and beheld their father, a Rakshasa of terrible
appearance. He said to him : " Whereabouts here is Khan-
davataka ? Tell me, my good fellow." And the Rakshasa,
quite taken aback by his courage, said to him : " What have
you got to do there ? The city has been long deserted ; but
if you must go, listen. This road in front of you divides
into two : take the one on the left hand, and go on until you
reach the main entrance of Khandavataka, the lofty rampart
on each side of which make it attract the eye."

When the Rakshasa had told him this, he went on, and
reached that main street, and entered that city, which, though
of heavenly beauty, was deserted and awe-inspiring. And in
it he entered the palace, which was surrounded with seven
zones, and ascended the upper storey of it, which was made
of jewels and gold. There he saw a gem-bestudded throne,
and he sat down on it. Thereupon a Rakshasa came with a
wand in his hand and said to him : " Mortal, why have you
sat down here on the king's throne ? " When the resolute
kdrpatika Krishnasakti heard this, he said : "I am lord
here; and you are tribute-paying householders whom King
Vikramaditya has made over to me by his grant."

When the Rakshasa heard that, he looked at the grant,
and, bowing before him, said : " You are king here, and I
am your warder ; for the decrees of King Vikramaditya are
binding everywhere." When the Rakshasa had said this, he
summoned all the subjects, and the ministers and the king's
retinue presented themselves there ; and that city was filled

74 THE OCEAN OF STORY

with an army of four kinds of troops. And everyone paid
his respects to the kdrpatika ; and he was delighted, and
performed his bathing and his other ceremonies with royal
luxury.

Then, having become a king, he said to himself in amaze-
ment : " Astonishing, truly, is the power of King Vikrama-
ditya ; and strangely unexampled is the depth of his dignified
reserve, in that he bestows a kingdom like this and calls it a
village ! " Full of amazement at this, he remained there,
ruling as a king ; and Vikramaditya supported his followers
in Ujjayini.

And after some days this kdrpatika, become a king, went
eagerly to pay his respects to King Vikramaditya, shaking
the earth with his army. And when he arrived, and threw
himself at the feet of Vikramaditya, that king said to him :
" Go and put a stop to the sighs of your wife who sent you
the letter." When the king dispatched him with these words,
Krishnasakti, full of wonder, went with his friends to his
own land. There he drove out his kinsmen, and delighted
his wife, who had been long pining for him ; and having
gained more even than he had ever wished for, enjoyed the
most glorious royal fortune.

So wonderful were the deeds of King Vikramaditya.

Now one day he saw a Brahman with every hair on
his head and body standing on end ; and he said to him :
" What has reduced you, Brahman, to this state ? " Then
the Brahman told him his story in the following words :

171 e. The Permanently Horripilant Brahman

There lived in Pataliputra a Brahman of the name of
Agnisvamin, a great maintainer of the sacrificial fire ; and
I am his son, Devasvamin by name. And I married the
daughter of a Brahman who lived in a distant land, and be-
cause she was a child I left her in her father's house. One
day I mounted a mare and went with one servant to my
father-in-law's house to fetch her. There my father-in-law
welcomed me ; and I set out from his house with my wife,
who was mounted on the mare, and had one maid with her.

THE CANNIBAL WIFE! 75

And when we had got half way, my wife got off the mare
and went to the bank of the river, pretending that she wanted
to drink water. And as she remained a long time without
coming back, I sent the servant, who was with me, to the
bank of the river to look for her. And as he also remained a
long time without coming back, I went there myself, leaving
the maid to take care of the mare. And when I went and
looked, I found that my wife's mouth was stained with blood,
and that she had devoured my servant, and left nothing of
him but the bones.1 In my terror I left her and went back
to find the mare, and lo ! her maid had in the same way
eaten that. Then I fled from the place, and the fright I got
on that occasion still remains in me, so that even now I cannot
prevent the hair on my head and body from standing on end.2

171. Story of King Vikramdditya

" So you, King, are my only hope." When the Brahman
said this, Vikramaditya by his sovereign fiat relieved him
of all fear. Then the king said : " Out on it ! One cannot
repose any confidence in women, for they are full of daring
wickedness." When the king said this, a minister remarked :
4 Yes, King, women are fully as wicked as you say. By the
by, have you not heard what happened to the Brahman
Agnisarman here ?

171f. The Brahman Agnisarman and his Wicked Wife*

There lives in this very city a Brahman named Agni-
sarman, the son of Somasarman, whom his parents loved as
their life, but who was a fool and ignorant of every branch
of knowledge. He married the daughter of a Brahman in
the city of Vardhamana ; but her father, who was rich, would

1 See Vol. II, p. 202, 202n1. To the references given there I would add
Macculloch's excellent article, " Cannibalism/' in Hastings' Ency. Bel. Eth.,
vol. iii, pp. 194-209 (see especially p. 208), and Coxwell, Siberian Folk-Tales,
pp. 104, 110. — N.M.P.

2 No. 3003 and the Sanskrit College MS. give antahsthena for sambhramayya.
No. 1882 has tva-tahsthena ; an insect has devoured the intermediate letter.

3 This is substantially the same story as the second in Chapter LXXVII.

76 THE OCEAN OF STORY

not let her leave his house, on the ground that she was a mere
child.

And when she grew up, Agnisarman's parents said to him :
" Son, why do you not now go and fetch your wife ? " When
Agnisarman heard that, the stupid fellow went off alone to
fetch her, without taking leave of his parents. When he left
his house a partridge appeared on his right hand and a jackal
howled on his left hand — a sure prophet of evil.1 And the
fool welcomed the omen, saying : " Hail ! Hail ! " And
when the deity presiding over the omen heard it, she laughed
at him unseen. And when he reached his father-in-law's
place, and was about to enter it, a partridge appeared on his
right and a jackal on his left, boding evil. And again he
welcomed the omen, exclaiming : " Hail ! Hail ! " And again
the goddess of the omen, hearing it, laughed at him unseen.
And that goddess presiding over the omen said to herself :
" Why, this fool welcomes bad luck as if it were good ! So I
must give him the luck which he welcomes. I must contrive
to save his life." While the goddess was going through these
reflections, Agnisarman entered his father-in-law's house, and
was joyfully welcomed. And his father-in-law and his family
asked him why he had come alone, and he answered them :
" I came without telling anyone at home."

Then he bathed and dined in the appropriate manner, and,
when night came on, his wife came to his sleeping apartment,
adorned. But he fell asleep, fatigued with the journey. And
then she went out to visit a paramour of hers, a thief, who
had been impaled. But while she was embracing his body
the demon that had entered it bit off her nose, and she fled
thence in fear. And she went and placed an unsheathed 2
dagger at her sleeping husband's side, and cried out loud
enough for all her relations to hear : " Alas ! Alas ! I am
murdered. This wicked husband of mine has got up and,
without any cause, actually cut off my nose." When her
relations heard that, they came, and seeing that her nose was

1 See Vol. IV, pp. 93, 93n2, 9*n.— n.m.p.

2 Vikrosam is a misprint for vikosam. The latter is found in MS. No. 1882
and the Sanskrit College MS. and, I think, in No. 3003 ; but the letter is not
very well formed.

THE NOSE BETWEEN THE TEETH 77

cut off, they beat Agnisarman with sticks and other weapons.
And the next day they reported the matter to the king, and
by his orders they made him over to the executioners, to be
put to death, as having injured his innocent wife.

But when he was being taken to the place of execution
the goddess presiding over that omen, who had seen the pro-
ceedings of his wife during the night, said to herself : " This
man has reaped the fruit of the evil omens, but as he said,
4 Hail ! Hail ! ' I must save him from execution." Having
thus reflected, the goddess exclaimed unseen from the air :
" Executioners, this young Brahman is innocent ; you must
not put him to death. Go and see the nose between the teeth
of the impaled thief." When she had said this, she related
the proceedings of his wife during the night. Then the
executioners, believing the story, represented it to the king
by the mouth of the warder ; and the king, seeing the nose
between the teeth of the thief, remitted the capital sentence
passed on Agnisarman and sent him home, and punished
that wicked wife, and imposed a penalty on her relations *
also.

171. Story of King Vikrdmaditya

" Such, King, is the character of women." When that
minister had said this, King Vikramaditya approved his
saying, exclaiming : "So it is ! " Then the cunning Mula-
deva, who was near the king, said : " King, are there no
good women, though some are bad ? Are there no mango-
creepers as well as poisonous creepers ? In proof that
there are good women, hear what happened to me.

171g. Miiladeva and the Brahman's Daughter2

I went once to Pataliputra with Sasin, thinking that it
was the home of polished wits, and longing to make trial of

1 The word bad hum is evidently a misprint for bandhuns: as appears from
the MSS.

2 This story is known in Europe, and may perhaps be the original source
of Shakespeare's AlFs Well that Ends Well. At any rate there is a slight
resemblance in the leading idea of the two stories. It bears a close resemblance

78 THE OCEAN OF STORY

their cleverness. In a tank outside that city I saw a woman
washing clothes, and I put this question to her : " Where do
travellers stay here ? " The old woman gave me an evasive
answer, saying : " Here the Brahmany ducks stay on the
banks, the fish in the water, the bees in the lotuses, but I
have never seen any part where travellers stay." When I got
this answer I was quite nonplussed, and I entered the city
with Sasin.

There Sasin saw a boy crying at the door of a house, with
a warm x rice-pudding on a plate in front of him, and he said :
" Dear me ! this is a foolish child not to eat the pudding in
front of him, but to vex himself with useless weeping." When
the child heard this, he wiped his eyes, and said, laughing :
" You fools do not know the advantages I get by crying. The
pudding gradually cools and so becomes nice. And another
oood comes out of it ; my phlegm is diminished thereby.
These are the advantages I derive from crying. I do not cry
out of folly. But you country bumpkins are fools because
you do not see what I do it for."

When the boy said this, Sasin and I were quite abashed at
our stupidity, and we went away, astonished, to another part
of the town. There we saw a beautiful young lady on the
trunk of a mango-tree, gathering mangoes, while her attend-
ants stood at its foot. We said to the young lady : " Give us
also some mangoes, fair one." And she answered : " Would
you like to eat your mangoes cold or hot ? " When I heard
that, I said to her, wishing to penetrate the mystery : " We
should like, lovely one, to eat some warm ones first, and to
have the others afterwards." When she heard this, she flung

to the story of Sorf'arina, No. 36 in Gonzenbach's Sicilianische Marchen, and to
that of Sapia in the Pcjitamerune of Basile. In the Sicilian and in the Neapolitan
tale a prince is angry with a young lady who, when teaching him, gave him a
box on the ear, and married her in order to avenge himself by ill-treating her ;
but finding that he has, without suspecting it, had three children by her, he is
obliged to seek reconciliation. l)r Kohler, in his note on the Sicilian tale,
gives no other parallel than Basile's tale, which is the sixth of the fifth day.

See Burton's translation, vol. ii, p. 526 et seq. See, further, Bloomfield, Amer.

Journ. Phil., vol. xliv, 1923, p. 202 et seq.— KM.?.

1 I think we should read ushne. I believe that Nos. 1882 and 3003 have
this, judging from the way in which shn is usually formed in those MSS.

A BRAHMAN'S PROMISE 79

down some mango-fruits into the dust on the ground. We
blew the dust off them and then ate them. Then the young
lady and her attendants laughed, and she said to us : "I first
gave you these warm mangoes, and you cooled them by blow-
ing on them and then ate them : catch these cool ones, which
will not require blowing on, in your clothes." When she had
said this, she threw some more fruits into the flaps of our
garments.

We took them, and left that place thoroughly ashamed of
ourselves. Then I said to Sasin and my other companions :
" Upon my word I must marry this clever girl and pay her
out for the way in which she has made a fool of me ! Other-
wise what becomes of my reputation for sharpness ? " When
I said this to them, they found out her father's house, and on
a subsequent day we went there disguised, so that we could
not be recognised.

And while we were reading the Veda there, her father, the
Brahman Yajnasvamin, came up to us and said : " Where
do you come from?" We said to that rich and noble
Brahman : " We have come here from the city of Mayapuri
to study." Thereupon he said to us : " Then stay the next
four months in my house ; show me this favour, as you have
come from a distant country." When we heard this, we said :
" We will do what you say, Brahman, if you will give us, at
the end of the four months, whatever we may ask for." When
we said this to Yajnasvamin, he answered : M If you ask for
anything that it is in my power to give, I will certainly give
it." When he made this promise, we remained in his house.
And when the four months were at an end we said to that
Brahman : " We are going away, so give us what we ask
for, as you long ago promised to do." He said : " What is
that ? " Then Sas'in pointed to me and said : " Give your
daughter to this man, who is our chief." Then the Brahman
Yajnasvamin, being bound by his promise, thought : " These
fellows have tricked me. Never mind ; there can be no harm
in it ; he is a deserving youth." So he gave me his daughter
with the usual ceremonies.

And when night came I said, laughing, to the bride in the
bridal chamber : " Do you remember those warm and those

80 THE OCEAN OF STORY

cool mangoes ? " When she heard this she recognised me,
and said, with a smile : " Yes, country bumpkins are tricked
in this way by city wits." Then I said to her : " Rest you,
fair city wit. I vow that I, the country bumpkin, will desert
you and go far away." When she heard this, she also made
a vow, saying : "I too am resolved, for my part, that a son
of mine by you shall bring you back again." When we had
made one another these promises she went to sleep, with her
face turned away, and I put my ring on her finger while she
was asleep. Then I went out, and, joining my companions,
started for my native city of Ujjayini, wishing to make trial
of her cleverness.

The Brahman's daughter, not seeing me next morning
when she woke up, but seeing a ring on her finger marked
with my name, said to herself : " So he has deserted me and
gone off ! Well, he has been as good as his word ; and I must
keep mine too, dismissing all regrets. And I see by this ring
that his name is Miiladeva ; so no doubt he is that very
Muladeva who is so renowned for cunning. And people say
that his permanent home is Ujjayini ; so I must go there, and
accomplish my object by an artifice." When she had made
up her mind to this, she went and made this false statement
to her father : " My father, my husband has deserted me
immediately after marriage ; and how can I live here happily
without him. So I will go on a pilgrimage to holy waters,
and will so mortify this accursed body."

Having said this, and having wrung a permission from
her unwilling father, she started off from her house with her
wealth and her attendants. She procured a splendid dress
suitable to a courtesan, and travelling along she reached
Ujjayini, and entered it as the chief beauty of the world.
And having arranged with her attendants every detail of
her scheme, that young Brahman lady assumed the name
of Sumangala. And her servants proclaimed everywhere :
" A courtesan named Sumangala has come from Kamariipa,
and her goodwill is only to be procured by the most lavish
expenditure."

Then a distinguished courtesan of Ujjayini, named Deva-
datta, came to her, and gave her her own palace, worthy of a

THE UNAPPROACHABLE LADY 81

king, to dwell in by herself. And when she was established
there, my friend Sasin first sent a message to her, by a servant,
saying : " Accept a present from me which is won by your
great reputation." But Sumangala sent back this message by
the servant : " The lover who obeys my commands may enter
here. I do not care for a present, nor for other beastlike
men." Sasin accepted the terms, and repaired at nightfall
to her palace.

And when he came to the first door of the palace, and had
himself announced, the doorkeeper said to him : " Obey our
lady's commands. Even though you may have bathed, you
must bathe again here, otherwise you cannot be admitted."
When Sasin heard this, he agreed to bathe again as he was
bid. Then he was bathed and anointed all oyer by her female
slaves, in private ; and while this was going on, the first watch
of the night passed away. When he arrived, having bathed,
at the second door, the doorkeeper said : " You have bathed :
now adorn yourself appropriately." He consented ; and
thereupon the lady's female slaves adorned him, and mean-
while the second watch of the night came to an end. Then
he reached the door of the third zone, and there the guards
said to him : " Take a meal, and then enter." He said,
" Very well " ; and then the female slaves managed to delay
him with various dishes until the third watch passed away.
Then he reached at last the fourth door, that of the lady's
private apartments ; but there the doorkeeper reproached
him in the following words : " Away, boorish suitor, lest
you draw upon yourself misfortune. Is the last watch of the
night a proper time for paying the first visit to a lady ? "
When Sasin had been turned away in this contemptuous
style by the warder, who seemed like an incarnation of un-
timeliness, he went away home with countenance sadly fallen.

In the same way that Brahman's daughter, who had
assumed the name of Sumangala, disappointed many other
visitors. When I heard of it I was moved of curiosity, and,
after sending a messenger to and fro, I went at night splendidly
adorned to her house. There I propitiated the warders at
every door with magnificent presents, and I reached without
delay the private apartments of that lady. And as I had

VOL. IX. F

82 THE OCEAN OF STORY

arrived in time I was allowed by the doorkeepers to pass the
door, and I entered and saw my wife, whom I did not recog-
nise, owing to her being disguised as a courtesan. But she
knew me again, and she advanced towards me and paid me
all the usual civilities — made me sit down on a couch, and
treated me with the attentions of a cunning courtesan. Then
I passed the night with that wife of mine, who was the most
beautiful woman of the world, and I became so attached to
her that I could not leave the house in which she was staying.

She, too, was devoted to me, and never left my side until,
after some days, the blackness of the tips of her breasts
showed that she was pregnant. Then the clever woman
forged a letter, and showed it to me, saying : " The king, my
sovereign, has sent me a letter : read it." Then I opened the
the letter, and read as follows : " The august sovereign of the
fortunate Kamarupa, Manasimha, sends thence this order to
Sumangala : ' Why do you remain so long absent ? Return
quickly, dismissing your desire of seeing foreign countries.' "

When I had read this letter, she said to me, with affected
grief : "I must depart. Do not be angry with me ; I am
subject to the will of others." Having made this false
excuse, she returned to her own city Pataliputra. But I did
not follow her, though deeply in love with her, as I supposed
that she was not her own mistress.

And when she was in Pataliputra she gave birth in due
time to a son. And that boy grew up and learned all the
accomplishments. And when he was twelve years old, that
boy, in a childish freak, happened to strike with a creeper
a fisherman's son of the same age. When the fisherman's
son was beaten he flew in a passion, and said : " You beat
me, though nobody knows who your father is ; for your
mother roamed about in foreign lands, and you were born
to her by some husband or other." '

1 Cf. Ralston's Tibetan Tales, p. 89. The accusation of bastardy, as also

of marriage or intercourse with a person of low birth, is a motif well developed
in Sanskrit literature. See Professor Bloomfield's Foreword to Vol. VII, p. xxvi,
and the numerous examples given on p. 195 of his Life and Stories of the Jaina
Savior Parcvanatha. See also Chauvin, op. cit., v, pp. 72nl, 294, where the
"Accusation of Bastardy" motif occurs in the tale of "Ali and Zaher," as
given in Weil's translation of the Nights, vol. iv, p. 194. — n.m.p.

THE CREST-JEWELS OF CUNNING ONES 83

When this was said to the boy, he was put to shame. So
he went and said to his mother : " Mother, who and where is
my father ? Tell me ! " Then his mother, the daughter of
the Brahman, reflected a moment, and said to him : " Your
father's name is Miiladeva : he deserted me and went to
Ujjayinl." After she had said this, she told him her whole
story from the beginning. Then the boy said to her :
" Mother, then I will go and bring my father back a captive.
I will make your promise good."

Having said this to his mother, and having been told by
her how to recognise me, the boy set out thence, and reached
this city of Ujjayinl. And he came and saw me playing dice
in the gambling-hall, making certain of my identity from the
description his mother had given him, and he conquered in
play all who were there. And he astonished everyone there
by showing such remarkable cunning, though he was a mere
child. Then he gave away to the needy all the money he had
won at play. And at night he artfully came and stole my
bedstead from under me, letting me gently down on a heap
of cotton while I was sleeping. So when I woke up, and
saw myself on a heap of cotton, without a bedstead, I was
at once filled with mixed feelings of shame, amusement and
astonishment.

Then, King, I went at my leisure to the market-place, and
roaming about, I saw that boy there, selling the bedstead.
So I went up to him and said : " For what price will you give
me this bedstead ? " Then the boy said to me : " You can-
not get the bedstead for money, crest- jewel of cunning ones ;
but you may get it by telling some strange and wonderful
story." When I heard that, I said to him : " Then I will
tell you a marvellous tale. And if you understand it, and
admit that it is really true, you may keep the bedstead;
but if you say that it is not true, and that you do not
believe it,1 you will be illegitimate, and I shall get back the
bedstead. On this condition I agree to tell you a marvel.

1 I read pratyayo na me, which I find in the Taylor MS., and which makes
sense. I take the words as part of the boy's speech : " It is untrue ; I do not
believe it." But vakshyasyapratyayena me would also make sense. The Sanskrit
College MS. supports Brockhaus' text.

84 THE OCEAN OF STORY

And now listen. Formerly there was a famine in the kingdom
of a certain king. That king himself cultivated the back of
the beloved of the boar with great loads of spray from the
chariots of the snakes. Enriched with the grain thus pro-
duced the king put a stop to the famine among his subjects,
and gained the esteem of men."

When I said this, the boy laughed and said : " The
chariots of the snakes are clouds ; the beloved of the boar
is the earth, for she is said to have been most dear to Vishnu
in his boar incarnation ; and what is there to be astonished at in
the fact that rain from the clouds made grain to spring on the
earth?"

When the cunning boy had said this, he went on to say to
me, who was astonished at his cleverness : " Now I will tell
you a strange tale. If you understand it, and admit that it
is really true, I will give you back this bedstead ; otherwise
you shall be my slave."

I answered " Agreed," and then the cunning boy said this :
" Prince of knowing ones, there was born long ago on this
earth a wonderful boy, who, as soon as he was born, made
the earth tremble with the weight of his feet, and when he
grew bigger, stepped into another world."

When the boy said this, I, not knowing what he meant,
answered him : "It is false ; there is not a word of truth in
it." Then the boy said to me : " Did not Vishnu, as soon as
he was born, stride across the earth, in the form of a dwarf,
and make it tremble ? And did he not, on that same occa-
sion, grow bigger, and step into heaven ? So you have been
conquered by me, and reduced to slavery. And these people
present in the market are witnesses to our agreement. So,
wherever I go, you must come along with me." When the
resolute boy had said this, he laid hold of my arm with his
hand ; and all the people there testified to the justice of his
claim.

Then, having made me a prisoner, bound by my agree-
ment, he, accompanied by his attendants, took me to his
mother in the city of Pataliputra. And then his mother
looked at him and said to me : " My husband, my promise
has to-day been made good. I have had you brought here

EXCEPTION PROVES THE RULE 85

by a son of mine begotten by you." When she had said this,
she related the whole story in the presence of all.

Then all her relations respectfully congratulated her on
having accomplished her object by her wisdom, and on hav-
ing her disgrace wiped out by her son. And I, having been
fortunate, lived there for a long time with that wife and that
son, and then returned to this city of Ujjayini.

171. Story of King Vikramdditya

44 So you see, King, honourable matrons are devoted to
their husbands, and it is not the case that all women are
always bad." x When King Vikramaditya had heard this
speech from the mouth of Miiladeva, he rejoiced with his
ministers. Thus hearing, and seeing, and doing wonders,
that King Vikramaditya 2 conquered and enjoyed all the
divisions of the earth.

[M] 44 When the hermit Kanva had told, during the
night, this story of Vishamasila, dealing with separations and
reunions, he went on to say to me who was cut off from the
society of Madanamanchuka : 4 Thus do unexpected separa-
tions and reunions of beings take place, and so you, Narava-
hanadatta, shall soon be reunited to your beloved. Have
recourse to patience, and you shall enjoy for a long time, son
of the King of Vatsa, surrounded by your wives and ministers,
the position of a beloved emperor of the Vidyadharas.' This
admonition of the hermit Kanva enabled me to recover
patience. And so I got through my time of separation ; and I
gradually obtained wives, magic science, and the sovereignty
over the Vidyadharas. And I told you before, great hermits,
how I obtained all these by the favour of Siva, the giver of
.' boons."

By telling this his tale, in the hermitage of Kasyapa,

1 Cf. the tale of the "Badawi and his Wife," Nights, Burton, vol. vii,
p. 124 et seq. — n.m.p.

2 In the original there is the following note : " Here ends the tale of King
Vikramaditya."

86 THE OCEAN OF STORY

Naravahanadatta delighted his mother's brother Gopalaka
and all the hermits. And after he had passed there the days
of the rainy season, he took leave of his uncle and the hermits
in the grove of asceticism, and mounting his chariot departed
with his wives and ministers, filling the air with the hosts of
his Vidyadharas. And in course of time he reached the
mountain of Rishabha, his dwelling-place. And he remained
there, delighting in the enjoyments of empire, in the midst of
the kings of the Vidyadharas, with Queen Madanamanchuka,
and Ratnaprabha and his other wives ; and his life lasted for
a kalpa.

This is the story called Brihatkatha, told long ago, on the
summit of Mount Kailasa, by the undaunted x Siva, at the
request of the daughter of the Himalaya, and then widely
diffused in the world by Pushpadanta and his fellows, who
were born on the earth wearing the forms of Katyayana and
others, in consequence of a curse. And on that occasion that
god, her husband, attached the following blessing to this tale :
" Whoever reads this tale that issued from my mouth, and
whoever listens to it with attention, and whoever possesses
it, shall soon be released from his sins, and triumphantly
attain the condition of a splendid Vidyadhara, and enter my
everlasting world."

1 Having reached the end of my translation, I am entitled to presume that
this epithet refers to the extraordinary length of the Katha Sarit Sagara.

T!

AUTHOR'S EPILOGUE1

(1) ^1 1 "\HERE was a lord of earth, King Sangrama,
a pdrijdta tree [issued] from the ocean of the
blest Satavahana race,2 who, being attended by

diverse vibudhas 3 descending [to him], rendered the realm

of Kashmir a Nandana.4

(2) To him was born a son, an emperor whose footstool
was made a touchstone for masses of rubies on the crests of
all lords of earth as they bowed [before him],xthe kalpa tree 6
of his stock, a peculiar store of valour, the blest Ananta.

(3) The head of a king which was rolled in the ground at
the front of his (Ananta's) doorway, severed at the neck, with
the belly cast away, was like Rahu come to do service because
he was delighted on hearing the pleasant fame of (Ananta's)
chakra (dominion) which surpassed the chdkra (discus) of great
Hari.6

1 These verses, translated by Dr L. D. Barnett, appear here in English
for the first time. They are not found in Brockhaus' text, and consequently are
not in Tawney's translation either. They appear, however, in the first edition
of Durgaprasad's text. Subsequently, they were printed separately, and in some
copies of the third edition of the Durgaprasad text they have inadvertently
been omitted.

As previously stated, these verses contain all we know of our author.
Although Sir Aurel Stein has kindly endeavoured to obtain information in
Kashmir, no evidence whatever has been forthcoming.

The notes to these final verses, as well as the translation, are the work of
Dr Burnett.

2 This metaphor is based on the myth of the Churning of the Milk-ocean
by the gods and Asuras. Among the precious objects that issued from the ocean
on this occasion was the celestial pdrijdta, or coral-tree (see Ocean, Vol. II,
p. 13, ISn2).

3 Meaning both sages and gods.

4 The paradise or park of the god Indra.

6 The wishing-tree of paradise : see Vol. I, p. 8, 8nl.

• This apparently refers to an episode narrated in the Rdjataranginl, vii,

1 67 et seq. : The Darad king, Achalamangala, was defeated and slain by Ananta's

general, Rudrapala, who cut off his head and brought it to Ananta. Here this

head, thrown down before the doorway of the palace, is compared by Somadeva

87

88 THE OCEAN OF STORY

(4) Now this moon of kings wedded as his queen a daughter
of the monarch of Trigarta, Suryavati, who, like the juncture of
dawn, dispelled darkness from her subjects and was universally
adored.1

(5)-(6) The Kasmiras were adorned with excellent monas-
teries built by his queen, which were like holy traditions, in
being kept by hundreds of Brahmans born in various lands ;
like gem-filled oceans, in being hospitable even to terrified
bhubhrits 2 ; like noble kalpa trees, in dispelling daily the distress
of the needy.

(7) The dwellings of the gods, white with palatial plaster,
which were built by her on the spacious bank of the Vitasta,
assuredly possess the semblance of peaks of Himalaya, the
ends whereof are encompassed by the Heavenly River.3

(8) Because of the countless gems, gold, great estates, black
antelope-skins, mountains of wealth and thousands of kine
which were bestowed [by her], that lady indeed bears even
. . . Earth.4

(9) Her son was the blest monarch King Kalasa, who,
though a unique tilaka on the circle of the earth, was

to the demon Rahu, a bead without any body, who is said to have been thus
mutilated by Vishnu (Hari) with his chakra or discus (see Ocean, Vol. VIII,
p. 72w) ; and Rahu is conceived as coming thus to do homage to Ananta because
he is glad to hear that Ananta's chakra (dominion) has surpassed Vishnu's
chakra (discus) by which he was decapitated — in short, it is suggested that
Ananta is superior to the god Vishnu.

One is tempted to understand dvara, which I have translated as M doorway,"
in the common Kashmiri sense of " mountain pass" or "hill-fort" ; but to do
so would spoil the point of the simile, in which Ra.hu is represented as " come
to do service " to Ananta, which implies that he came to the latter's palace door.

1 A play on the name Suryavati, which means M she to whom the sun
belongs." The dawn dispels darkness for beings (praja) and is greeted with
prayers (sandhya-vandana) ; Suryavati saved her subjects {jpraja) from moral
darkness and was adored by all (yiha-vandya).

2 A pun : bhubhrit, " bearer of earth," means both a king and a mountain.
Taken in the latter sense, it refers to the legend that when Indra cut off the
wings of the mountains, the mountain Mainaka took refuge in the ocean (see
Vol. VI, p. Sn1).

3 The celestial Ganges.

4 The text is here defective. The sense seems to be that Suryavati may
be compared to the earth (vihambhara, "all-supporter") because of her gifts to
mankind.

AUTHOR'S EPILOGUE 89

nevertheless an-alika-lagna,1 and, though a friend to the
guni, was full of rich ambrosia.2

(10) Her excellent grandson was the blest King Harsha,
who was like a modern Child of the Jar created by the gods,
a puissant one who was able to make all lofty urvlbhrits bow
[before him] and to drink up the seven oceans.8

(11) In order to interest somewhat for a moment the
mind of that queen, who was ever intent upon the rules for
the diverse offerings of oblation-rites for the worship of him
who couches on the mountains,4 and constantly devoted her
efforts to learning from books of instruction,

(12) This summary of the Brihat-kathd's essence, consisting
of the ambrosia of diverse tales, [a summary which is] a full-
moon [attracting] the ocean of good men's minds, was verily
composed by Soma, the son of Rama, a worthy Brahman,
agreeable because of his abounding virtues.

(13) May this Ocean of Streams of Story, composed by
the stainless-minded Soma, which has the semblance of very
widespread waves, be for the delight of good men's hearts.

1 A pun. Tilaka means the mark (ornamental or sectarian) made on the
forehead with paint, etc., and generally an ornament; alika signifies either
" forehead " or " inauspicious," and lagna is both " attached " and "astrological
moment." The poet thus says that the king, though he is metaphorically a
frontal decoration on the brow of the goddess Earth — i.e. an ornament of the
circle of earth — was in one sense not bound upon any brow (an-atika-lagna),
because (in the other sense) he was subject to no inauspicious moments
(an-alika-lagna).

2 A pun based on the king's name, KalaSa, which means "jar." He is
said to be ghanamrita-maya, literally "(as ajar) full of rich ambrosia" (amrita);
but amrita also signifies the state of salvation, the condition of the redeemed
soul (moksha or nirvana), so ghanamrita-maya may also signify "consisting of
compact (perfect) spirituality," and in this sense it is opposed to one of the
meanings of guni-bandhava, "friend to the guni." For guni denotes both
" virtuous," " bow," and " physical nature " as characterised by the three
gunas or phases of materiality ; and while Kalasa is " a friend to the virtuous "
and "a friend of the bow" (i.e. a brave warrior), he is not "a friend to
materiality," because he is perfectly spiritual."

3 A pun : kalasodbhava means both " son of Kalasa " and " child of the jar "
— i.e. the mythical saint Agastya, who made the Vindhya mountains (urvibhrit,
meaning both "mountain " and "king") bow down to let him pass, and drank
the ocean (see Vol. VI, pp. 4/Sn1, 44n).

4 The god Siva.

TERMINAL ESSAY

TERMINAL ESSAY

WHEN, in the summer of 1919, I first approached
Mr Tawney with the suggestion of reissuing his
Magnum opus, little was decided about the form
the Terminal Essay was to take. At that time there were
so many immediate points connected with the work to be
considered that any questions relating to the final volumes
were to be deferred to a later date.

My own idea was to discuss briefly the manners and
customs of the Hindus as illustrated in the work, together with
some account of the different religious systems introduced.
I then intended to speak of the debt Western literature
owes to the East, and conclude with a few paragraphs on
the classification of the world's folk-tales. If room could be
found, I was also going to give extracts from Speyer's work
on the Kathd-sarit-sdgara.

At that time, however, the idea of a Foreword to each
volume by some eminent scholar had not been formulated, nor
had the number or length of my own notes been determined.

As the scheme of the work began to take definite shape,
matters became more established, and a precedent was gradu-
ally formed in accordance with what seemed to be the best
way of dealing wijth subjects as they arose. Thus, whenever
some custom, ceremony, name or incident was thought to
require a note, it seemed most practicable to give it on the
same page, or, if too long, at the end of the chapter.

Following this plan, all the notes which would have been
used for the Terminal Essay were given in their respective
places. It also proved much better to give Speyer's trans-
lations and suggestions in situ, and not relegate them to the
present volume.

My idea of inviting a different scholar to write a Foreword
to each volume has proved a great success, and my work is
now enriched by nine excellent Essays, each dealing with the
great collection from a different angle.
93

94 THE OCEAN OF STORY

With the appearance of the present volume, and its most
interesting Foreword by Sir Atul Chatterjee, which approaches
the K.S.S. from the economic standpoint, I find practically
every subject which I might have treated in this present
Essay already dealt with in a manner which I could never
have equalled.

All general questions have been dealt with by Sir Richard
Temple, Sir George Grierson and Dr Thomas ; the study and
classification of folk-tales has received expert attention from
Dr Gaster, Mr Wright, Professor Bloomfield and Professor
Halliday ; while Sir Denison Ross has contributed original
research work on the Persian recension of the Panchatantra.
I think it will thus be agreed that, on the face of it, there
seems little left to write about.

There is, however, one subject which, as yet, we have
not discussed in sufficient detail — the " frame-story " of
the Kathd-sarit-sdgara, the arrangement and order of its con-
tents, the sequence of events in the history of Udayana and
Naravahanadatta, the introduction of the numerous sub-
stories, and the resemblance the whole bears to the original
Brihat-kathd of Gunadhya.

I shall, therefore, devote this Terminal Essay to a brief
discussion of this subject.

The " Frame-Story " of the Kathd-sarit-sdgara

In order to determine, as far as possible, the changes
any recension of a lost original text may have undergone,
two distinct methods at once suggest themselves : a critical
examination of the version in question ; and a reconstruction
of the original with the help of other versions known to be
derived from that same original.

In some cases it may happen that both these methods can-
not be applied, and until quite recently this has been so with
Somadeva's work. Thanks, however, to the researches of
Professor Lacote, the Nepalese recension of the Brihat-kathd,
known as the Brihat-kathd -sloka-samgr aha, supplies us with
evidence which can be compared with the results obtained
from a close examination of the text of the Kathd-sarit-sdgara.

TERMINAL ESSAY 95

If the evidence from the one source corroborates that
from the other, some definite conclusions will result. It is, of
course, unnecessary to discuss all the points raised by Lacote
in his Essai sur Gunadhya, but I shall endeavour to lay before
my readers the main arguments for his conclusions, as far as
they concern the present work.

The method I have adopted throughout of affixing a num-
ber to each story has not only enabled the thread of a tale
long since suspended to be picked up again with ease, but
facilitates the separation of the Main Story from the mass of
sub-stories introduced on every possible occasion.

Readers will have noticed to what a great extent the latter
are in excess of the former. This fact alone should make us
suspicious, particularly when we remember * how, after the
adventures of Naravahanadatta had been brought to a suc-
cessful close by his coronation, the long series of Vikrama
tales are introduced for no apparent reason. The final return
to the Main Story * is purely conventional, and clearly betrays
the hand of a later editor.

Although many of the shorter sub-stories justify their
position and introduction sufficiently well, there is a large
number that fit uneasily into the places where we find them,
and display no reason whatever for being there rather than
anywhere else. This, of course, specially applies to whole
collections, such as the Panchatantra. Since studying Lacote's
Essai, I am now convinced that it could never have been
included in Gunadhya's original poem. A closer examina-
tion of Somadeva's text of the Main Story will reveal many
inconsistencies and inaccuracies which are largely hidden and
unnoticed with the inclusion of so many sub-stories.

Book I : Kathdpitha (Vol. I, pp. 1-91).

Let us first, then, consider the Introduction to Somadeva.

It will be remembered that it consists of a strange legend in

which Gunadhya himself plays a part. This fact did not

• diminish the belief of Brockhaus, Wilson and Lassen that such

a person as Gunadhya never existed in reality. Since their

i See Vol. VIII, p. 93. 2 Pp. 85, 86 of this volume.

96 THE OCEAN OF STORY

day, however, the advance in Sanskrit literary research has
proved his existence beyond a doubt.

The evidence contained in the Brihat-katha-sloka-samgraha
only strengthens this opinion. We are introduced to Siva
and Parvati on Mount Kailasa. In reply to a request from
his wife for a story, Siva relates his own history in one of his
former lives. This is received with scorn as an age-worn tale,
and Siva is called a fraud. As compensation he promises to
tell an entirely new tale that Parvati could never have heard
before — the history of the Vidyadharas. Thus the hackneyed
tales of gods, on the one hand, with their usual accompanying
laudatory eulogies, and of men, on the other hand, with their
sad and commonplace happenings, would both be avoided.

Parvati is placated, and, we are led to conjecture, listens
in silence and interest to the long tale which Siva unfolds.

This fact is significant as showing that the author puts
forward strong claims to originality. The well-known Vedic
and Puranic legends are not to be given — there is something
that even a goddess would get a thrill over !

Yet this high standard is hardly borne out when we see
later what old tales have crept in.

Kshemendra is more cautious, and allows Parvati to raise
no objections to Siva's first tale about himself, thus at once
disarming criticism if well-known tales are introduced.

But let us proceed with the story.

Pushpadanta, one of Siva's Ganas, overhears the tale by a
trick and repeats it to his wife, who in turn tells it to Parvati.
Thus Pushpadanta is discovered, and Parvatl's wrath is piti-
less. Both the eavesdropper and his friend Malyavan, who
pleaded on his behalf, are cursed to fall into mortal wombs.

Pushpadanta, now to be born in Kausambi under the
names of Vararuchi and Katyayana, will obtain release from
the curse only when he meets a Yaksha named Supratlka
residing in the Vindhya forest under the name of Kanabhiiti,
and tells him the Great Tale. Malyavan is to be born in
Supratishthita under the name of Gunadhya, and will be
freed from the curse only when he has heard the tale from
Kanabhiiti.

In course of time Pushpadanta- Vararuchi-Katyayana

TERMINAL ESSAY 97

meets Supratika-Kanabhuti and tells him the Great Tale ;
then, after also relating his life-story in detail, reaches his
heavenly home once again.

It is, however, with the history of Malyavan-Gunadhya
that we are mainly concerned, for the legend may contain
some clue to the real Gunadhya. According to the story he
is of semi-divine birth, his mother being a Brahman girl and
his father a Naga prince. Thus he takes rank with the two
other semi-divine authors — Valmlki of the Rdmdyana and
Vyasa of the Mahdbhdrata — and he is actually mentioned in
Sanskrit literature as forming the third of the Epic trio.

Kshemendra wrote manjaris (abridged versions) of them
all. The Nepdlamdhdtmya draws a comparison between the
(Nepalese) versions of the legends of Valmlki and Gunadhya,
showing how both men had to visit Nepal by divine command,
the former to find a sacred spot worthy to be the cradle of the
Rdmdyana, and the latter to fulfil certain conditions necessary
for his return to his previous semi- divine state. Both men
erect lingas before leaving Nepal.

To return to Somadeva's version, we find that Gunadhya
becomes a minister of King Satavahana in a city named
Supratishthita, capital of the Pratishthana (Vol. I, p. 60). On
one occasion the king shows his ignorance of grammar (p. 69),
and Gunadhya offers to teach him Sanskrit grammar in six
years. Thereupon another minister, Sarvavarman, promises
to do it in six months, or carry his shoes on his head for twelve
years. Gunadhya considers this impossible, and says that if
he succeeds, he, in his turn, will renounce for ever Sanskrit,
Prakrit, and his own vernacular dialect.

By the favour of the god Karttikeya a grammar known
as Katantra and Kalapaka (on account of its conciseness) is
revealed to Sarvavarman, who, with its help, wins the bet.
In accordance with his vow, Gunadhya, now reduced to
silence, retires to the Vindhya forest. Here he learns the
language of the Pisachas, and, on meeting Vararuchi, writes
down the Great Tale, as it is told him, in his own blood
(p. 89). This done, he sends it to King Satavahana, who,
however, rejects it as being written in a barbarous language.
On hearing this, Gunadhya is in despair, and reads out the

VOL. IX. O

98 THE OCEAN OF STORY

whole work to the animals of the forest, who crowd round,
lost in admiration at its beauty. As he reads, so he burns
the tale page by page.

Meanwhile the king, owing to a sudden and unexplained
lack of nutritive qualities in his food, has fallen sick. He is
informed that the explanation of this curious state of affairs
is to be found in a Brahman who is reciting a wonderful story
in the forest, to which all the animals are listening motionless.
Out of curiosity he goes to see for himself, and recognises
Gunadhya. He is, however, too late to save the Great Tale.
All has been burnt, with the exception of the Adventures
of Naravahanadatta. This Satavahana takes back to his
palace, and, in order that these strange happenings shall not
be lost to the world, himself composes " the book named
Kathapitha, in order to show how the tale came to be first
made known in the Paisacha language " (p. 91).

Thus the first book of the Kaiha-sarit-sdgara ends. But
what does it all mean ? Who is this Satavahana, at whose
Court Gunadhya became a minister ? And what is the point
of introducing a kind of grammatical controversy on the
respective qualities of Sanskrit and Prakrit ?

These are some of the queries that present themselves.

Satavahana is the family name, in inscriptions, of the
Andhra dynasty, whose home lay in the Deccan, between
the rivers Godavarl and Kistna. Their capital was Prati-
shthana, the modern Paithan on the north bank of the
Godavari. Thus Gunadhya's connection of king and capital
is historically correct, although (as far as we can judge from
Somadeva) he omits to mention which Satavahana is meant.

The third of the line, Satakarni, is perhaps the most im-
portant of these kings. For he it was who wrested Ujjayini
from the Suiiga king, Pushyamitra. The evidence for this is
numismatic, but the horse-sacrifice performed by him would
find justification only in some such important feat of arms.
Satakarni gave his name to many subsequent Andhra kings,
so that altogether his pre-eminence is undoubted.

But it seems most unlikely that our author would have
omitted to mention, and even to enlarge on, such great
victories, or to allude to the Asvamedha. It looks, therefore,

TERMINAL ESSAY 99

as if we must search among other Satavahanas. A most
important point to notice is that the Andhra kings were
patrons of Prakrit, and that it was only late in the history of
the dynasty that Sanskrit was finally accepted as the Court
language, and Prakrit was ousted from its former place of
honour. Among the Satavahanas there was one king who
became specially famous for being the centre of a literary
Court and for being himself a poet of no mean order * — and
that was Hala. His date, though still uncertain, is considered
to have been about the second or third century a>d.2 Whether
he finally became a convert to the use of Sanskrit we do not
know, but grammatical controversies could not have been
unknown. If it was not Hala himself whom the legend of
Gunadhya makes ignorant of Sanskrit grammar, it is one of
the succeeding Satavahanas ; but in connecting any tale
about the introduction of Sanskrit in the place of Prakrit
with a Satavahana, it is Hala that at once would be
thought of.

A change so important and far-reaching as the use of a
different language at the Court, and in literature generally,
would, of course, take a considerable time to effect.

As patrons of Prakrit the Satavahanas would be the most
vigorous opposers of such an innovation, and it is only in the
time of Dandin (sixth century) that we find the use of Prakrit
becoming rare. The fact that in subsequent centuries native
opinion looks upon Hala as the central figure of Prakrit litera-
ture is surely a sufficient explanation of why Gunadhya himself
is represented in the legend as a native of Pratishthana. Such
evidence as exists points to Ujjayini, or rather Kausambi,

1 In the article on " Prakrit," by Sir George Grierson, in the Ency. Brit.,
vol. xxii, p. 253, he says : " Hala's work is important, not only on its own
account, but also as showing the existence of a large Prakrit literature at the
time when it was compiled. Most of this is now lost. There are some scholars
(including the present writer) who believe that Sanskrit literature owes more
than is generally admitted to works in the vernacular, and that even the
Mahabharata first took its form as a folk-epic in an early Prakrit, and was
subsequently translated into Sanskrit, in which language it was further

i manipulated, added to, and received its final shape."

2 See further Winternitz, Gesckichte der Indischen Litteratur, vol. iii,
pp. 102, 103.

100 THE OCEAN OF STORY

as the birthplace of the real Gunadhya; but once he is
connected with Hala, the champion of Prakrit, no further
excuse for the work being in Pai^achi would be needed.

It is only after the Katantra grammar has converted the
king to Sanskrit that he regards Paisachi as a barbarous
language. Whether the real Gunadhya and Hala, or Hala
and Sarvavarman, were contemporaries or not in no way
affects the argument, but it seems highly probable that
Gunadhya antedates Hala, and that the growing legend
used as an introduction to his work came into being later.
It was well known by the sixth century, as Dandin not only
refers to the Brihat-kathd, but to the legend of Gunadhya
as well.

It now remains to mention Vararuchi and his strange story,
which, for some reason or other, has become connected with the
legend of Gunadhya. The stories of the two men are quite
distinct. They never meet in the tale, and Vararuchi could
disappear, with his complete history, without upsetting the
story in the least.

But the name of Vararuchi is famous in connection with
both Sanskrit and Prakrit grammar, and its introduction
would merely assist in bringing the most famous gram-
marians on the stage at once. It then needed some clever
invention to link the two entirely separate tales together as a
single legend. On earth Kanabhiiti is the common point of
contact. But in the realms of heaven the person of Gunadhya
has been divided into two. It will be remembered that it
is Pushpadanta- Vararuchi who originally overhears the tale
and is cursed by Parvatl. Surely, then, it is he who should
have been made to repeat it on earth. Yet not only is it not
so, but he receives less punishment than his friend Malyavan-
Gunadhya, whose only crime was to plead for him.

Finally, Vararuchi is born at Ujjayini, the very place
where internal evidence places the birthplace of Gunadhya.
From all these considerations Lacote has come to the con-
clusion that the form of the legend as reproduced by the
Kashmirian poets is purely a Kashmirian work. "... dans
la forme originale," says Lacote (Essai sur Gunadhya, p. 33),
" Vararuci n'y paraissait pas et un seul gana etait maudit,

TERMINAL ESSAY 101

le futur Gunadhya. C'est ce dernier £tat de la tegende qui
devait etre courant dans l'lnde."

All the evidence certainly seems to point to this conclusion
— the compiler or editor has been at work, and has produced
a composite legend which, by its inclusion of grammatical
disputes on the one hand, and lively sub-stories on the
other hand, would appeal to both savant and bourgeois.
The legend of Gunadhya, as told in the Nepalese version by
Budhasvamin, confirms the belief in a much simpler original
form than we find in Somadeva. There is only one Gana,
and he is known as Gunadhya in his mortal life. Such altera-
tions as there are can easily be explained by remembering that
one of the chief objects the Nepalese had in view was to con-
nect the names of heroes with their holy places of pilgrimage,
and allow their actions to further sanctify those places.

The important point of this evidence is that Budhasvamin
dates from the eighth or ninth century, and thus antedates the
Kashmirian poets. The work had not received the attention of
editors who padded out the text with other collections, and thus
the form of tales in the Brihat-kathd-sloka-samgraha is much
more likely to be closer to the original of Gunadhya.

The title of this first Book of Somadeva is Kathapitha,
which means " Introduction " or " Preface."

The second Book has a very similar name : in fact the
two words kathapitha and kathamukha differ in meaning little
more than our " Introduction " and " Foreword." But why
should a work contain two introductions ? Lacote suggests
that if, as is probable, the legend was added to the work later,
a Kathamukha was already there. The next best thing would
be to use another word with almost exactly the same meaning.

Book II : Kathamukha (Vol. I, pp. 94-189).

In accordance with the title of this Book, we should have
expected it to contain merely introductory matter, such as
the name of the narrator, the scope and object of his work,
with possibly some laudatory reference to King Udayana and
his son Naravahanadatta. In fact we should have expected
it to have resembled other " Kathamukhas," such as that

102 THE OCEAN OF STORY

which introduces the Panchatantra. We have already seen
that Somadeva omitted the Kathamukha of the Panchatantra,
probably because the tales could quite easily be put into the
mouths of characters in the Main Story. In this case, how-
ever, he has retained the title which he doubtless found in the
texts he followed, although in the original Brihat-katha the
subject-matter may have been different and more in accord-
ance with the usually accepted contents of a Kathamukha.
More than half the Book contains sub-stories which have
but little connection with the Main Story, which, in order
to make room for them, has had to be very considerably
condensed. Otherwise the Book would have swelled to an
undue size.

Thus we find the Main Story in this second Book crowded
with incidents. We are hurried through the hero's birth and
childhood, and are introduced to Chandamahasena, King of
Ujjayini, who is anxious to marry his daughter Vasavadatta
to our hero. The schemes and counter-schemes to obtain
this end follow, and finally the wedding takes place at
Kausambi. Udayana proves a fickle husband, but we are
clearly given only a very condensed form of his amours.
The Book ends, then, on a dramatic note, and we naturally
turn to the next one to discover how things turn out.

Book III : Ldvdnaka (Vol. II, pp. 1-116).

We are not disappointed. The Book opens with the
lamentations of Udayana's ministers at his desultory life —
spent either with women or in the hunting-field. They fear
he will never enlarge his realm, and are anxious for him to
begin a series of conquests. Their eyes are first fixed upon
Magadha, and their knowledge of political statecraft tells
them that a marriage with Padmavati, daughter of Pradyota,
King of Magadha, would be the easiest method to employ
in the winning of their object. Vasavadatta is naturally
rather in the way for such an alliance, but a plot is cleverly
engineered, and finally Udayana marries his second wife.

After all is smoothed over, and everyone is conciliated, the
king, now roused from his idleness, determines on conquest.

TERMINAL ESSAY 103

Accordingly he marches east to the sea, and circles India in a
clockwise rotation, finally returning to Kau^ambi.

The Book being almost entirely devoted to the Padmavati
incident is much more easily condensed than was the case in
the former Book. Hence ample opportunity occurs for the
inclusion of a large number of sub-stories. The chief feature
of interest in this Book, from an historic point of view, is
Udayana's conquest. We hear very little about it really,
and, with the one exception of Brahmadatta, no particulars
of the conquered kings, their countries, or deeds of prowess
of the conquerors are forthcoming. The first point to be
considered is the names of the people he conquers. He
sets out eastwards to Benares, turns south, sweeps west-
wards and occupies Sindh. Among the tribes defeated are
the Mlechchhas, Turushkas, Parasikas and Htinas (Vol. II,
pp. 93, 94).

Now Udayana was an ancient king of legendary times,
yet here we find him fighting with peoples of comparatively
recent times — Mohammedans, Turks, Persians and Huns. In
fact the Hunas did not appear till the second half of the fifth
century. Surely he should have fought with such peoples as
the Yavanas and Sakas. The explanation seems simple.
The peoples mentioned by Somadeva are those of the western
and north-western frontiers, whose names would be known
and appreciated in Somadevd's time, and which, moreover, a
Kashmirian would be most likely to employ.

Lacote points out that the places supposed to have been
conquered by Udayana constitute a pradakshina : the cam-
paign is arranged like a pilgrimage. Central India is always
kept on the right ; and finally he visits Alaka, the city of the
god Kuvera. Not a word is said as to how he gets there.
No aerial chariot, magic shoes or any similar contrivance
appears. Now several of the sub-stories in this Book are
concerned with spells to enable one to fly through the air, yet
we are given no clue as to why especially they are found in this
Book. Might it not be that ancient tradition associated to-
gether Udayana's campaign and some story of aerial transit ?
This would certainly explain the journey to Alaka. So
perhaps in the original Brihat-kathd Udayana made a kind of

104 THE OCEAN OF STORY

aerial pilgrimage. In support of such a theory we have the
fact that nothing more is said of all these vast conquests.

In fact, when finally Udayana leaves the world of mortals
and gives all his possessions to Gopalaka, we find (Vol. VII,
p. 102) that these consist only of Kau£ambl. Surely we
should be justified in expecting a long list of conquests to
be enumerated !

The Kashmirian editors seem to have been very busy with
this Book.

Book IV : N aravdhanadattajanana (Vol. II, pp. 125-165).

The story continues in due chronological sequence. Vasa-
vadatta longs for a son, and, after her pregnant whim for
aerial chariots has been satisfied, Naravahanadatta is born.

As in previous Books, the sub-stories occupy a very large
part of the text.

Book V : Chaturdarikd (Vol. II, pp. 170-239).

As we have already seen, Books II, III and IV form an
uninterrupted series of events in the history of Udayana, but
now comes a very distinct break.

Naravahanadatta has been proclaimed a future king of
the Vidyadharas, and this fact is an excuse for Saktivega, a
Vidyadhara prince, to relate in full how he reached his present
high position. The tale, with its sub-stories, occupies the
whole Book, and is a unity in itself. Whether it was in
Gunadhya's original work in the same form as it appears
here, or whether it has been compiled out of some of the
adventures which formed part of Naravahanadatta's own
adventures, are questions it seems impossible to answer.

The only point to stress is that the contents of this Book
are entirely unconnected with previous or subsequent matter,
and could be removed and inserted anywhere else without
upsetting the text at all.

TERMINAL ESSAY 105

Book VI : Madanamanchukd (Vol. Ill, pp. 1-149).

The curious thing about this Book lies in the opening lines.
Here we are informed that it is N.1 himself who from this
point onwards is the true narrator, and that he tells his own
history on a certain occasion after his coronation. The actual
words are :

" Now hear the heavenly adventures which N., speak-
ing of himself in the third person, told from the very
beginning, after he had obtained the sovereignty of the
Vidyadharas and had been questioned about the story of
his life on some occasion or other by the seven Rishis and
their wives."

What does it all mean ? It looks like the beginning of
a new tale altogether, yet it is in reality a direct continuation
of the story of N. when last he was mentioned. So far it
has been told in the third person, yet here is a note which
specially tells us that henceforward N. will narrate the tale
in the third person. Now if it had said, in the first person,
a distinct difference would naturally have been noticed at
once. The value of this curious sentence, then, is quite in-
explicable. If it had not appeared at all, we should have
noticed nothing, for the tale would have gone straight on
— still in the third person.

Why this sudden wish to introduce N. as the teller of his
own story ? Perhaps the author of the Kashmirian recension
thought that this was in accordance with tradition, and he
was anxious at least to give some indication of this well-
known fact. Even if this were so, we are still in the dark
as to why it is inserted at this particular place, making it
look like the very beginning of the whole work.

We are told nothing as to the occasion on which N. was
asked questions by the Rishis. In fact the whole matter
would remain a mystery if we were not to look ahead and
find that full details of the visit to the Rishis are given in
Book XVI, chapters cxi, cxii.

Here we learn (Vol. VIII, p. 103) that after Udayana's
death, N. spent the rainy season at Kasyapa's hermitage with

1 In future I shall thus refer to the hero Naravahanadatta.

106 THE OCEAN OF STORY

his uncle, Gopalaka. Here it is that the Rishis are assembled,
and, in answer to their questions, he begins to relate his
adventures.

Yet, if we are to believe the opening lines of Book VI, it
was N. who had been speaking all the time !

It is obvious, then, that Book XVI must have originally
stood before Book VI, and, in fact, have led up to the state-
ment that has caused all the trouble. It is not Somadeva
who is to blame. He has merely followed his texts. It is
the Kashmirian compilers who have purposely changed the
order of the Books. Perhaps they worked from composite
and incomplete texts, or perhaps they considered that the
new order was better fitted to embrace all the new matter
to be incorporated. Whatever may have been the true
explanation, there can be no doubt that the order of the
Books in the Kashmirian recension does not agree with that
originally laid down by Gunadhya.

The early part of the Book is taken up with the story of
the Buddhist king, Kalingadatta, and his daughter, Kalinga-
sena. Many sub-stories are introduced, several of obvious
Buddhist origin. The tale now centres on Kalingasena. With
the help of her Apsaras friend Somaprabha she sees Udayana,
who immediately falls in love with her.

His faithful minister, Yaugandharayana, however, con-
siders such a marriage undesirable for reasons of state, and
finally manages to make it impossible by proving Kalinga-
sena to be unchaste. A daughter is born to her by her lover,
the Vidyadhara Madanavega. This child was in reality a
son, but by Siva's orders was replaced at birth by a girl who
was an incarnation of Rati. Her name is to be Madanaman-
chuka, and she is the destined wife of N. All this is told in
detail, but the rest of the Book is greatly condensed, and the
events of the next ten or twelve years — the time to allow
Madanamanchuka to grow up — are all crammed into Chapter
XXXIV. In the next chapter we are in Book VII, and our
hero is a full-grown man !

Although by far the greater portion of the Book deals
with Kalingasena, yet it takes its title from Madanaman-
chuka. It seems obvious that the original work must have

TERMINAL ESSAY 107

been much longer, and that the second half of the Book as it
appears in Somadeva is a mere summary.

In fact there are places where we can clearly see the ruth-
less hand of the Kashmirian compiler, reducing what must
have been incidents of considerable length to a single sentence.

For instance, we read in Chapter XXXIV (Vol. Ill, p. 140)
that one day N. goes to a garden called Nagavana. What
for ? Nothing happens at all, except that he worships the
snakes. It surely must have been the beginning of some
adventure now entirely suppressed.

Even in the first part of the Book there are signs of mis-
chievous alterations in the work. Why is Kalingadatta such
a nonentity, and why does he make no effort at all to pro-
tect his daughter after her trouble with Madanavega and the
childish scruples of Yaugandharayana ? Numerous other
examples of improbabilities in the text could be given, but
I think sufficient has been said to show that Gunadhya's
original must have been very different to what we find in the
Kaiha-sarit-sagara.

Book VII : Ratnaprabhd (Vol. Ill, pp. 155-300).

The first part of this Book is taken up with N.'s marriage
to a Vidyadhari whose name gives the Book its title. He is
taken in a magic chariot to heaven for the wedding. This is
the first time we hear of N. leaving the earth. There is no
connection between ±his adventure and the end of the previous
Book.

With Chapter XLII (Vol. Ill, p. 259) begins the adven-
tures of N. in search of Princess Karptirika. They are far
more important than the affair with Ratnaprabha, and would
much more fitly have given their name to the Book. It seems
likely that the two parts formed separate Books in the original
Brihat-kathd.

< Book VIII : SuryapraJbha (Vol. IV, pp. 1-121).

Like Book V, this stands alone, and could be inserted
anywhere as a separate story. It exhibits the highest flights

108 THE OCEAN OF STORY

of an unbridled imagination, and can be regarded as a great
hotchpotch of ancient Buddhist myths and popular Hindu
beliefs.

Book IX : Alankdravati (Vol. IV, pp. 122-251).

The first part of this Book is taken up with another Vidya-
dharl marriage — this time to Alankaravati, who gives her
name to the Book. It is in no way connected with Book VIII,
and could go in anywhere. The second part of the Book,
beginning with Chapter LIV (Vol. IV, p. 184), stands as a
complete entity, and is of considerable interest. It deals with
N.'s visit to Vishnu, and resembles the journey of the brothers
Ekata, Dvita and Trita and of Narada to the same " white
island," as related in the Mahdbhdrata (xii, 138, 139). The
allusion in these passages to the worship of Christian com-
munities in the East has already been pointed out.1 Lacote
considers that the accounts of the visit to the " White Island,"
as found in the Mahdbhdrata and the K.S.S., agree sufficiently
well to suspect a common origin. Either the latter has
borrowed from the former, or the Mahdbhdrata has taken the
episode from the Brihat-kathd, or possibly both versions have
been independently developed from a narrative derived from
some traveller who had visited the Christian communities in
Bactria.

Book X : Saktiyasas (Vol. V, pp. 1-192).

There is no connection between this Book and the previous
one. After a series of tales dealing with the favourite subject
of " fickleness of women," introduced on the slightest pretext,
we once again find N. marrying a Vidyadhari. The wedding
cannot be arranged for a month, and so an exceptionally large
number of stories, including the whole of the Panchatantra,
can be successfully introduced.

1 Sir George Grierson, "Modern Hinduism and its Debt to the Nestorians/'
Journ. Roy. As. Soc, 1907, p. 7 et seq.

TERMINAL ESSAY 109

Book XI : Veld (Vol. V, pp. 196-204).

This deals with N.'s visit to Vai^akha and his subsequent
marriage to Jayendrasena. The story of the merchant and
his wife, Vela, gives its name to the Book. But why it is
so very short and devoid of any continuity is impossible
to say.

It looks as if it had been purposely compressed out of all
recognition, in order, perhaps, to make up for the very long
Books that precede and follow it.

Book XII : Sasdnkavati (Vol. VI, pp. 1-221, and Vol. VII,
pp. 1-193).

This Book has been discussed already in Vol. VII, pp. 194-
196. We saw there that it is obviously in its wrong position,
because we are continually told that N. has lost his beloved
Madanamanchuka ; yet not only do we know nothing about
this, but we are definitely told at the beginning of the Book
(Vol. VI, p. 9) that it is Lalitalochana who is lost.

Our attention, however, is taken off such trifles (!) by the
appearance of the hermit Pisangajata, who proceeds to relate
the huge tale of Mrigankadatta (Vol. VI, p. 10 et seq.), which
stretches to p. 192 of Vol. VII.

The Book finishes without solving the mystery in the least.

Book XIII : Madirdvati (Vol. VIII, pp. 1-17).

This short Book is a continuation of the last, for we find
N. still disconsolate at the loss of his beloved, who is now
definitely stated to be Madanamanchuka, and not Lalitalo-
chana. The latter unhappy lady also is lost, but N. seems
to care little about her.

He meets two Brahmans who tell tales of how they have
successfully overcome difficulties, and so encourage N. in his
search. The heroine of the first Brahman's story gives her
name to the Book. When the stories are finished, lo ! N.'s
ministers turn up, and so does Lalitalochana (nobody knows
how or whence, and nobody seems to care !), and all proceed

110 THE OCEAN OF STORY

to Kausambl. We have no clue whatsoever as to the loss of
Madanamanchuka.

Book XIV : Pancha (Vol. VIII, pp. 21-69).

The long-awaited explanation of the loss of N.'s chief wife,
Madanamanchuka, is found at the very beginning of this
Book. She suddenly disappears without a trace, leaving N.
distracted with grief. He searches for her in vain. Vegavati,
a certain unmarried Vidyadhari, is anxious to obtain N. for
a husband, and, taking the form of his lost wife, manages
to trick N. into going through the marriage ceremony again.
The fraud is soon discovered, but she is soon forgiven on
promising N. to help to find the real Madanamanchuka, who,
it appears, has been carried off by her brother, a Vidyadhara
named Manasavega.

Accordingly Vegavati carries him through the air to the
mountain Ashadhapura, whither Manasavega has hastened to
kill them both. A magical combat ensues, in which Vegavati
is victorious. For safety she places N. in a dry well in the
city of the Gandharvas, and there leaves him (Vol. VIII,
p. 27). He is soon rescued and, by his skill of playing the
lyre, wins the king's daughter Gandharvadatta for his wife.
He seems to have entirely forgotten all about Madanaman-
chuka, and settles down to a married life of heavenly bliss.
Suddenly a Vidyadhari appears, and takes N. through the
air to the city of Sravasti, with the intention of marrying
him later to her daughter Ajinavati.

While waiting in a garden, King Prasenajit comes along
and marries him to his daughter Bhaglrathayasas. One
night N. hears a low voice outside his sleeping-room. It is
that of a beautiful Vidyadhari named Prabhavati, who moans
the unhappy fate of Madanamanchuka in having so fickle a
husband. At last N. is roused by the mention of her name,
and begs to be led to her presence. Accordingly Prabhavati
flies with him through the air, and, by cleverly flying round
a fire, becomes the wife of N. Although N. is anxious to
consummate the marriage, Prabhavati says he must wait,
and takes him to Madanamanchuka (Vol. VIII, p. 36).

TERMINAL ESSAY 111

General rejoicings follow ; but N., who is now wearing the
shape of Prabhavati, is soon threatened by Manasavega, who
discovers his presence as N. assumes his own shape. The
supreme court of the Vidyadharas judge the case, and N.
wins. Manasavega is far from satisfied, and a quarrel ensues.
N. escapes with Prabhavati, but Madanamanchuka remains
a prisoner with Manasavega. While N. and Prabhavati are
living together, Ajinavati turns up with her mother and
marries N. He returns to KausambI with the two wives,
where he is soon joined by VegavatI and Gandharvadatta and
all the relations of his various wives. A great campaign is
decided upon, before which N. has to obtain certain magical
sciences from Siva. While so engaged five (pancha) Vidya-
dharls vow to marry him all together. This incident gives
the name to the whole Book. After another marriage a
great battle is fought. More marriages follow, including
that to the five Vidyadharis. N. is now informed that before
overcoming his final vow it is necessary for him to become
possessed of the seven jewels of the Chakravartin. He wins
the magic sandalwood-tree, but his obtaining of the other
" jewels " is reserved for Book XV.

It has been considered necessary to give a somewhat
detailed resume of this Book, because, with the exceptions of
the brief sub-stories 164, 165 and 166, it is entirely devoted to
the Main Story.

There are several important points to notice. In the first
place, the Book is crowded with detail. Marriages and ad-
ventures follow one upon the other at an enormous rate.
In the second place, we must remember that they are all
centred round the disappearance of Madanamanchuka. The
Book, then, is really a cycle of marriages, with intermediate
adventures. In this cycle the incident of N.'s marriage to
the five Vidyadharis is comparatively unimportant, yet it
gives its name to the whole Book. This fact, added to the
obvious condensing of so many incidents in order to cram
them into a single Book, makes it practically certain that
{ originally each marriage must have formed the subject and
title of a separate Book.

We have had several examples of this already — e.g. Books

112 THE OCEAN OF STORY

VII, IX and X. Any doubt as to the probability of this
is surely removed by finding that this is exactly what has
happened in the case of the Brihat-kathd-sloka-samgraha.
Each marriage has a Book to itself, and is recorded with far
greater detail than in the K.S.S. On the evidence given
by the K.S.S. itself we can definitely state that the present
Book (and also Book XV, q.v.) originally must have come
before Book XII, and consequently also Book XIII, which is
a continuation of Book XII.

If this were not so, the events in Books XII and XIII
could never have happened, for Madanamanchuka would
not have been lost, and consequently the search, leading to
all the other marriages and adventures, would never have
taken place.

Book XV: Mahdbhisheka (Vol. VIII, pp. 70-93).

This is a direct continuation of the previous Book.
N. obtains the seven jewels, and starts on the last of his
expeditions. After sundry adventures and vicissitudes he
conquers his sole remaining enemy, Mandaradeva. N. proceeds
to consolidate his empire. He marries five Vidyadharis (a
repetition of a similar incident in the last Book), and prepares
for his coronation on the Rishabha mountain.

The coronation takes place, and of his two dozen odd
wives, Madanamanchuka alone is crowned with N. Udayana,
Vasavadatta and Padmavati are invited, and with a blare of
trumpets and general rejoicing the Book ends. Not only the
Book, we would imagine, but the entire work.1 Yet we find
three more Books still unopened.

Book XVI : Suratamanjari (Vol. VIII, pp. 94-131).

Years have passed. One night N. has an evil dream,
and, on awakening, calls upon the science named Prajnapti
for an explanation. He is told all the news of his family in
KauSambi. Udayana, his wives and ministers are dead,
Gopalaka has given his kingdom to Palaka, and has retired

1 See WoY. VIII, p. 93n».

TERMINAL ESSAY 113

to the Black Mountain in company with the hermits of
Kasyapa. N. hastens there to see his uncle, and remains
during the rainy season.

With Chapter CXII begins the incident of Ityaka's
attempted ravishing of Suratamanjari, who gives her name to
the Book. An inquiry is started. It turns out to be a family
matter, and the evidence of Palaka, his son, and his minister
are needed. They accordingly are sent for, and the court sits.
Evidence is found against Ityaka, but, by the request of the
hermits, his life is spared.

The next chapter, the last of this Book, deals with the
history of Taravaloka, and has nothing whatsoever to do
with what precedes or follows. At the end of it N. is still
on the Black Mountain among the Rishis. Here, then, is the
occasion on which he is among the Rishis already referred
to in Book VI, and on which he is requested to relate " from
the beginning " all his adventures.

If, then, Chapters CXI and CXII preceded Book VI, all
would be clear.

Book XVII : Padmdvati (Vol. VIII, pp. 132-209).

The Rishis now ask N. how he could bear his separation
from Madanamanchuka. This is merely an excuse to intro-
duce the story of Muktaphalaketu and PadmavatI, which
takes up the rest of the Book. It is supposed to have been
told during the period covered by Book XIV. Thus it is not
in its proper chronological order.

Book XVIII : Vishamasila (Vol. IX, pp. 1-86).

This last Book also is out of place, as it is merely another
tale told to N. while he was separated from Madanaman-
chuka. But it is even more extraneous, as it deals with
Vikramaditya, who was much later than the period to
which Udayana and N. must be assigned.
» Somadeva (and perhaps even the Kashmirian compilers)
places this Book at the very end as a kind of Appendix, for it
would at once be apparent that heroes who were supposed to

VOL. IX. h

114

THE OCEAN OF STORY

date from the time of Buddha could not listen to tales about
a king as recent as Vikramaditya.

As already mentioned, the final return to the Main
Story is purely conventional. So tame and unconvincing
is the conclusion of this work, especially after the " grand
finale " at the end of Book XV, that the most casual reader
must at once suspect textual commutation on a fairly large
scale.

Before we compare the order of the Books as found in the
Brihat-kathd-manjari and Brihat-kathd-sloka-samgraha , with
a view to reconstructing as far as possible the original work
of Gunadhya, it will perhaps be best to arrange in tabular
form the points we have noticed in the foregoing pages :

Name of Book

1. Kathapitha

2. Kathamukha -\

3. Lavanaka

4. Naravahanadatta-

janana

5. Chaturdarika

6. Madanamanchuka

7. Ratnaprabha

8. Siiryaprabha

9. Alankaravati
10. Saktiyasas

Comments

Legend of Gunadhya. Complete
in itself.

Uninterrupted series of events
describing period from birth of
Udayana to that of his son N.

Vidyadhara tale. Quite separate.

Could go in anywhere.
Unconnected. Apparently a fresh

beginning. Must originally

have stood after the first part

of Book XVI, because of

Rishis incident.
Two love adventures. Probably

once formed two separate

Books.
Like Book V. Vidyadhara tale.

Quite separate. Could go in

anywhere.
Two distinct divisions. Both

separate and unconnected.
Unconnected. Another marriage.

Excuse for numerous sub-tales.

TERMINAL ESSAY

115

Name of Book

11. Vela

12. Sasankavati

13. Madiravati

14. Pancha

15. Mahabhisheka

16. Suratamanjarl

Comments

Another marriage. Very, and

suspiciously, short.
^Text shows Book must be in its

wrong place. N.'s chief wife is

lost.
Direct continuation. Wife is still

lost.
Mystery of loss explained. N.

marries several other women.
Direct continuation. Leads to

coronation. Finale.
Another unconnected Book. First

part helps to explain Book VI

and should precede it. Second

part quite separate. Could go

in anywhere.
Out of place. Told during period

of Book XIV.
Out of place. Told during period

of Book XIV, but is also an

obvious addition, and could

not have been in the original.

We can now see the situation at a glance. Books II, III
and IV form a group ; V and VIII are unconnected and both
Vidyadhara narratives; VI looks like a new beginning, but
lacks any explanatory introduction ; VII, IX, X and XI are
marriages, more or less unconnected ; XII and XIII are closely
connected, but must come after XIV and XV (also connected),
and consequently also after XVII and XVIII, because the
events they relate happened during the period covered by
XIV. The remaining Book, XVI, must be regarded as of two
distinct divisions, the first supplying the necessary introductory
matter to VI, and the second being quite unconnected.

It will thus be seen that the critical inspection of the
work as presented by Somadeva shows without doubt that
the work has undergone much reshuffling as far as the order
of Books is concerned.

17. Padmavati

18. Vishamaslla

116 THE OCEAN OF STORY

We can now turn to the Brihat-kaiha-mahjari and see if
the order followed by Kshemendra in any way confirms our
theories.

The first five Books correspond to those of Somadeva.
Then the differences begin. We notice Books V and VIII are
put together. This is followed by Vela, the very short Book,
but the chief interest here lies in the fact that it finishes with
the loss of Madanamanchuka. In the K.S.S. this incident is
found at the beginning of Book XIV, Pancha. Thus, so far,
we find Kshemendra's order much better than that adopted
by Somadeva. After Vela he has placed Books XII, XVIII,
XIII, XVII, thus obtaining a correct sequence of events,
which is lacking in Somadeva. Book XIV follows, but with
its opening incident transferred to the end of Book XI (Vela),
as has been already mentioned.

Thus we see that our complaints about the order of the
Books in the K.S.S. are fully justified by what we find in
Kshemendra. The question which at once presents itself is,
Why did not Somadeva copy the order in Kshemendra instead
of changing it and so introducing muddling anachronisms?
The answer would appear to be that he took what he con-
sidered to be the lesser of two evils ; for although Kshemendra
has followed a better order of Books dependent upon the loss
of Madanamanchuka, he has had to pay dearly for it in the
rest of his work. For here we find chaos, and no attempt
made to remove it. Such inconsistency makes us chary of
giving Kshemendra credit for the arrangement of the first
part of the work. He probably left it as he found it. Soma-
deva, on the other hand, saw how unconnected his material
was, but preferred to put together only such chapters as
were undoubtedly connected. We have seen how Book XV
follows directly on to XIV ; but Kshemendra, by his placing
of Pancha, has been forced to separate them by other
three Books, thus introducing all kinds of improbabilities
and chronological impossibilities.

The incident of N. relating his adventures to the Rishis
in the third person must have seemed entirely upsetting to
Kshemendra, and he gets over the difficulty by omitting it

TERMINAL ESSAY 117

altogether. As Lacote has remarked, the above clearly shows
that the Kashmirian Brihat-kathd was a compilation and not
an original work.

I think we must attribute the unsatisfactory state of the
text of the Kashmirian work very largely to the simple fact
that the compilers (there may have been several at different
dates) were not trying to reconstruct in their entirety the
adventures of N. They had a very different object in view —
namely, to use the story as a frame for all the tales they could
collect together. The better-known incidents would have to
appear in some detail, while many of N.'s love- adventures
could be ignored or highly compressed. The result has its
pros and cons. On the one hand we are given a jumbled and
very defective version of the story of N., but on the other
hand we have that huge mass of tales which sheds so much
light on the manners and customs, the folklore and beliefs of
a country so poor in historical documentary evidence.

True, the Panchatantra and Vetdlapanchavimsati are found
in separate collections, but scholars are not yet agreed as to
the respective values of the different versions.

That Somadeva was very conscious of the difficulties in
the text or texts he was using is clear from his introductory
remarks (Ocean, Vol. I, p. 2), where he says : "... the
observance of propriety and natural connection, and the
joining together of the portions of the poem so as not to inter-
fere with the spirit of the stories, are as far as possible kept
in view. . . ." The meaning of this is not perfectly clear,
and great importance should be laid on the correct translation
of the passage.

Many suggestions have been made, but Lacote alone has
treated it in the light of his extensive critical examination of
the whole subject, taking into consideration all debatable
grammatical queries and all possible modes of construction.

His translation of the full passage is as follows : —

« " Tel l'original, telle cette copie ; pas d'une ligne meme
elle ne s'en ecarte. Je comprime le volume du recueil et je
traduis, voila toute la difference. Attentif a observer, autant
que je le puis, les convenances (litteraires) et l'ordre logique,

118 THE OCEAN OF STORY

en ayant soin de n'interrompre ni le recit ni le ton des senti-
ments, je ne le suis pas moins a disposer une portion de poeme
regulier. Mes efforts ne vont pas a gagner une reputation
d'artiste consomme ; je veux simplement qu'on puisse retenir
sans peine ce vaste ensemble de contes de toute espece."

This clearly means that he has been accurate as far as the
subject-matter is concerned, but has found it necessary to
alter the order of some of the Books. Here he surely must
refer to Books VI-XVIII, while the " portion de poeme
regulier " which he has been so careful to arrange in proper
order can be none other than Books XIV-XV.

When we turn to the Brihat-kathd-sloka-samgraha x we at
once find ample support for our theories. The order of the
Books is reasonable and clear, and what in the Kashmirian
versions was passed over with little more than a mere refer-
ence is now detailed in full. In fact, we not only meet with
entirely new adventures, but find certain of the characters
presented in quite a different light.

For the first time the improbabilities found in the Kash-
mirian accounts of Madanamanchuka's marriage and the
romance of Kalingasena entirely disappear. Their social
standing is certainly much lower, but this only adds to the
strength of the plot.

Vegavati, being of much higher birth, has been accepted
by the Kashmirians practically unaltered. Their desire to
raise the social standing of the principal characters to the
detriment of the tale is manifest. In some cases where they
have raised merchants to the rank of princes, or mortals
to the degree of Gandharvas, we are able to detect the fraud,
for the same names have been retained with suffixes which
violate the accepted rules of Sanskrit etymology.

So great appears to be the wish of the Kashmirian com-
pilers to raise the social tone of the work, that tales which
cannot escape their low-type settings are altogether omitted,
but appear in detail in the Nepalese version.

Without giving other evidence of the accuracy of

1 Discussed in detail by Lacote, Essai, pp. 146-198, and edited by him,
with a French translation, the same year (1908).

TERMINAL ESSAY 119

Budhasvamin's work as detailed by Lacote, I would mention
one point which seems to me of great importance. We have,
of course, noticed that throughout the whole of the Ocean
the chief deity is Siva. Now, in the Sloka-samgraha it is not
Siva, but Kuvera. The name of the hero alone tells us which
is correct. Naravahanadatta means " given by Naravahana."
Naravahana is one of Kuvera's, and not Siva's, titles. So,
when Udayana was praying for a son, it must have been
Kuvera whom he worshipped, otherwise our hero's name
would have been Sivadatta or some other name compounded
from one of Siva's many titles.

It is obvious that the Kashmirian compilers have altered
the name of the deity in accordance with local contemporary
beliefs.

Numerous other examples of the reliability of Budha-
svamin's work could be quoted, but full details will be found
in Lacote's Essai. With the help, then, of the Sloka-samgraha,
we are able to get a fairly shrewd idea of what Gunadhya's
original work must have been like. The first Book corre-
sponded to Book XVI of the K.S.S. It contained the history
and abdication of Gopala and Palaka, which led up to the
incident of Ityaka and Suratamanjarl. The subsequent trial
brought N. on the scene, who later was asked to relate his
history. After some hesitation (only in the B.K.S.S.) he com-
menced (K.S.S., Bk. VI, ch. xxvii) by relating his family
history (K.S.S., Bks. II, III — with possibly another, now lost,
giving further details of Udayana's amours 1).

The story of his own birth (K.S.S., Bk. IV) follows. Ignor-
ing the two Vidyadhara Books (K.S.S., Bks. V and VIII),
which, as we have already seen, could go in anywhere, we
come to the heroine of the whole story, Madanamanchuka.

N. sees her as a child and falls in love with her (K.S.S.,
Bk. VI, ch. xxxiv). Various adventures follow (only in
the B.K.S.S.), leading up to the marriage (K.S.S., Bk. VI,

1 It seems probable that Gunadhya used only a portion of the widely
1 known Udayana cycle of legends current at the time.

Reference should be made to Burlingame's Buddhist Legends, Harvard
Oriental Series, vol. xxviii, pp. 247-293 ; Synopsis, pp. 79-84 ; parallels,
pp. 62-63.

120 THE OCEAN OF STORY

ch. xxxiv-end). Then comes the sudden disappearance of
Madanamanchuka (K.S.S., Bk. XIV, ch. cv), resulting in
numerous adventures, usually terminating in a fresh marriage.
The order and number of Books thus formed cannot be deter-
mined for certain, but in the K.S.S. they certainly included
Books XIV (chaps, cvi, cvii), VII, IX-XIII, XIV (ch. cviii)
and XV.

We can also add Books XVII and XVIII, if, as Lacote
thinks is the case, they are not apocryphal.

The plan of the Brihat-kathd resembles that of the Rdmd-
yana to a certain extent — the setting out of the hero to recover
his lost love, acquiring others on the way, the constant help
of a trusty friend, the purity of the captive wife, and the final
triumph on her safe recovery.

We must not press the comparison further; but to dis-
regard it would be a mistake, because then we would miss the
due appreciation of the genius of Gunadhya. Not that it is
evident from the fact that he has copied the plan of the great
Epic, but because, having copied it, he proceeds to treat his
subject-matter in a way unheard of and absolutely original.

His heroes are not borrowed from the great national epics,
the deity is not the omnipotent Siva or Vishnu, and the
incidents in the tale are not confined to kings, princes and
gods.

In place of this usually accepted precedent we find the
heroes are but petty princes who rub shoulders with mer-
chants, artisans, sailors, adventurers and beggars. The
heroine is the daughter of a prostitute, but her desire to raise
the level of her caste and be worthy of her husband gives great
strength to the character that Gunadhya has created. The
chief deity is Kuvera, the god of merchants and treasures.

All this must have struck contemporary audiences as most
original and novel. But there is another point that we must
not miss. The nature of the work would reach a much wider
public — the kind of public, in fact, which would flock together
at the annual festivals held at Kausambi and Ujjayini. Per-
haps long extracts from the Brihat-kathd were recited at these
events ; anyway I notice Lacote thinks it likely.

We can now more readily understand that the Kashmirian

TERMINAL ESSAY 121

compilers would find much to alter and suppress. The
necessity for an Introduction also becomes more apparent.

Thus at the end of our short inquiry we find that the
K.S.S., as we have it to-day, is but a poor and badly arranged
version of the original work. This Somadeva must have
known ; and though we see he has done his best to rearrange
certain portions of it, he was well aware that any attempt to
reconstruct it entirely would mean little less than composing
a new work.

There was, I think, another factor which prevented Soma-
deva from making too drastic alterations — namely, his wish
to retain all that mass of sub-stories added by the Kash-
mirians. The frame -story had been altered in order to take
them in as naturally as possible. Although in many cases
they are introduced in the most clumsy fashion, it is clear
that considerable alterations would have to be made in
Gunadhya's text before it was ready to receive so many new
stories.

But we must not complain — far from it — for the result has
been that in about a.d. 1070 Somadeva has presented us with
one of the greatest collections of tales the world has ever seen
— tales which not only mirrored contemporary customs and
beliefs, and exhibited the versatile genius of the story-teller,
but tales which were destined to inspire the genius of unborn
giants of European literature — Boccaccio, Goethe, La Fontaine,
Chaucer and Shakespeare.

As to Kshemendra, we should have lost little if he had
not lived, or at any rate had not produced a version of the
Brihat-kathd.

But with Somadeva matters are very different. We must
hail him as the Father of Fiction, and his work as one of the
masterpieces of the world.

RETROSPECT

THERE remains but the pleasant task of acknow-
ledging the help received during my long work
of editing the Ocean. So varied have been the
subjects of my notes and appendixes, that my inquiries and
correspondence have been very great. It is most gratifying
to know that, with hardly a single exception, I have found
scholars and fellow-students only too pleased to help in any
way they could.

First and foremost, I would mention the superintendents
of the Reading Room of the British Museum. The numerous
bibliographical queries, which they have helped to clear up,
have, I fear, taken up much of their valuable time, but the
kindness and patience they have always shown is remarkable.
In this connection I would especially mention Mr F. D. Sladen,
Mr A. I. Ellis and Mr L. C. Wharton. In the Department of
Oriental Books and MSS. I owe gratitude to Mr E. Edwards,
while the continuous assistance afforded by the head of the
department, Dr L. D. Barnett, has been a sine qua non of the
whole work.

I have already mentioned names of eminent members
of the Royal Asiatic Society, the Royal Anthropological
Institute, the Folk-Lore Society, the School of Oriental
Studies, and other similar scientific bodies who have allowed
me to take advantage of their learning and erudition.

I would also like to mention the friendly way in which
American scholars have so readily replied to my queries,
forwarded me copies of their articles and works, and done
everything they could to assist in my research.

As I am sure my subscribers will be only too ready to
admit, the engineering of any ten-volume work is no light
undertaking, particularly if it includes numerous indexes
and appendixes, which continually have to be overhauled,
rearranged and improved. Questions of " setting up," sizes

122

RETROSPECT 123

of type, and a hundred other important points in the general
" make-up " of the work have had to be taken one by one and
discussed in the most minute detail, before a working precedent
could be set up.

I think, then, the feeling of satisfaction of an editor will
be duly appreciated when he sees the completion of a work
that has occupied what is usually considered the best ten
years of his life. Before speaking of the incident that gave
rise to the whole idea of the work, and the man who made
the carrying out of that idea possible, I would offer un-
stinted thanks to my two secretaries, whose patience and
pertinacity have so largely contributed to the success of the
work, Miss Betty Krause (who had to return to America
during the publication of Vol. V) and Miss Maud Lundblad,
who continued her work to the end.

To the Riverside Press, who have devoted special care and
attention to the printing of the volumes, and have always been
ready with valuable suggestions, I am also very grateful.

Then there are my reviewers to be considered. They
have, one and all, received the work in the kindest and most
sympathetic way imaginable, and it is of course largely due
to this that we have been able to get such a complete list of
subscribers, and produce the work volume by volume with as
little delay as possible.

The incidents which gave rise to the idea of re-editing
Tawney's great translation form quite a little romance, and
should, I think, find a place here.

In 1917 and 1918 I was working on my Bibliography of
Sir Richard Burton, and my whole mind became saturated in
what I may term " Burtoniana." My researches took me
for many months to the Central Library, Kensington, where
the remains of Burton's library are housed. My work was an
arduous one, as I had to go through, not only every book
Burton wrote, but every pamphlet, article and letter, either
written by him, or in which he was interested. Many of these
pamphlets were bound up into volumes, but the majority
were packed away in thirty-four large book-boxes, containing
close on five hundred pamphlets. I had examined nearly all

124 THE OCEAN OF STORY

of them, when one especially arrested my attention. It
proved to be an odd part of Tawney's original edition of the
Kathd-sarit-sdgara. The work was entirely unknown to me,
and, although I knew the Nights intimately from cover to
cover, my knowledge of Sanskrit fiction was practically
confined to the Hitopadesa and " Pilpay's Fables." A hasty
inspection of the odd part in question at once convinced me
that it must belong to a work of the highest importance,
although I knew nothing of its age, author or translator.

I cannot say what it was, but I felt instinctively that this
odd part of an unknown Indian work was to be of the utmost
importance to me personally. For a time my work on the
Burton bibliography stopped, and I at once began to make
inquiries about the Kathd-sarit-sdgara. It seemed almost as
if Burton, with whom I had now become so intimate, was
offering me the chance of giving to the public the Indian
counterpart of his own great Arabian Nights. This feeling
grew on me more and more, and I was determined somehow
to see it through. And here, for the encouragement of
students hesitating to undertake a work of similar difficulty
and importance, I would add the following.

After having found out all I could about the work, and
having met Mr Tawney, I went straight to Dr Barnett at the
British Museum and asked his advice. I told him that, apart
from having a deep interest in Oriental folklore and kindred
subjects, I could lay no claim whatever to Oriental scholar-
ship ; but that in spite of this fact I was particularly anxious
to re-edit Tawney's work. Did he think the idea was pre-
sumptuous and ridiculous, and could I dare, with my strictly
limited knowledge, to attempt so large an undertaking ? So
kind and encouraging was his reply that I at once started on
a task that, alas ! many authors and editors have attempted
in vain — to find a publisher. After I had explained the nature
of the work and the number of volumes I had estimated it
would take, my hoped-for publisher smiled sympathetically
and asked the sum I was prepared to put down for the work.
My answer merely provoked the wishes for a " Good morning."
In fact, as time went on, this termination of my interviews
began to grow monotonous. However, I never despaired, and

RETROSPECT 125

finally discovered that the most enterprising and trenchant
figure in the literary world was not a publisher at all, but
a bookseller — Mr Sawyer of Grafton Street. Accordingly I
hastened to Grafton House and once more explained my
business, which by this time sounded to me more like a recita-
tion than anything else. I waited for the usual " Good
morning," but it did not come. " This work," he said,
" must be of the highest importance, and should be published
in a form worthy of that importance. From what you tell
me, it is one of the world's greatest collections of stories, and
in all my long experience of bookselling I have never once
been asked for it, or even seen a copy. I conclude that it is
known only to Oriental scholars. I regard it as an unknown
masterpiece, and am willing to publish it myself at my own
expense."

My chief difficulty was thus overcome,- and we at once
got to work on all those preliminary details necessary in
the engineering of such a large undertaking.

Mr Sawyer is truly a wonderful man, and the initiative
he displayed in sponsoring the work is deserving of the
very highest praise. It is needless to say that without his
support the work would never have seen fight ; and although
the enormous expense involved would have deterred most
men, however rich, once Mr Sawyer is determined on a pro-
ject, nothing can stop him. If he is satisfied — and I think he
is — and if in the Elysian Fields Mr Tawney is not disappointed
with the new edition of his Magnum opus, my work will have
received its reward.

INDEX I

SANSKRIT WORDS AND PROPER NAMES

The n stands for " note " and the index number refers to the number of the note. If there
is no index number to the n it refers to a note carried over from a previous page.

Achalamangala and the

serpent-king Ananta, King,

87n<*
.(Elian, Varia Historia, 47n3
Agastya, the mythical saint,

89w3
Aghori, order of Siva wor-
shippers, 12/11
Agnisarman and his Wicked

Wife, The Brahman, 75,

75n3, 76-77
Agnislkha, Vetala named, 13,

14, 26, 27
Agnisvamin, Brahman named,

74
Alaka, the city of Kuvera,

visited by Udayana, 103
Alambusha, mother of Kala-

vati, 20, 22
Alankaravati, Book IX, 108
AmaravatI, city of Indra, 2
Ambika (Durga, Parvati,

Gauri, etc.), 3
Amrita, pun on word, 89na
Anangadeva, messenger

named, 6, 7, 10-12, 28,

29
Anangavati, wife of Kandarpa,

63, 66
Ananta, a thousand-headed

serpent, 87, 87w6, 88n
Andhra dynasty, the, 98,

99
Androcles, the story of, 47m1
Anneke Mettinges and An-

neke Swarten and the

magic fat, 45nx
AnuragavatI, friend of Rupa-

vati, 65, 66
Apsarases, attendants of the

gods, 20, 106
Aristophanes, Birds, 3nx
Asoka tree, 53
Asuras, enemies of the gods,

2, 29, 87w2
Aulus Gellius, Nodes Attica;,

47/11
Avanti, the land of, 2

127

Baring-Gould, S., Curious
Myths of the Middle Ages,
47n3

Barnett, Dr L. D., Author's
Epilogue translated by,
87W1

Bartsch, K., Sagen, M'drchen
und Gebrauche a us Meklen-
burg, 45wl

Basile, G. B., // Penlamerone,
78n

Benares, Varanasi — i.e., 5n2 ;
King of, 69 '

Bhadra, prince named, 49

Bhadrayudha, son of Vajra-
yudha, 5, 6, 36, 38-40,
49

Bhairava — i.e. Siva, 19, 20

Bharhut Stupa, sculptures on
the, 51ft1, 53W1

Bhillas or Bheels, 34, 45, 46,
48

Bhimapura, city called, 59,
60

Bhubhrits, the, kings or
mountains, 88, 88w2

Bhutaketu, Vetala named,
45,71

Bloomfield, Professor M.,
Foreword to Vol. VII, 82wl

Bloomfield, M., "The Art of
Stealing in Hindu Fiction,"
Amer. Journ. Phil., vol. xliv,
78n ; " On False Ascetics
and Nuns in Hindu Fic-
tion," Journ. Amer. Orient.
Soc., vol. xliv, 23w2 ; The
Life and Stories of the Jaina
Savior Parcvanalha, 82nx

Boccaccio, Decameron, 69w2

Bohtlingk, O., and Roth, R.
(Sanskrit Wbrterbuch), 3w2,
8n\ 10n2, 12711, 42n\ 52nl

Borneo, cowries found in, 17n2

Bragda Magus Saga, the, 47n3

Brahma, 12, 13, 32

Brahmasthala, a grant to
Brahmans, 68

Briffault, R., The Mothers,

3 vols., Ldn., 1927, 17n3
Brihaspati, minister of Indra,

"25,26
Brihat-katha, the, Gunadhya,

86, 89, 94, 100, 102, 103,

108, 117, 120, 121
Brihat - katha - mdnjari, the,

Kshemendra, 114, 116
Brihat - katha - sloka- samgraha,

the Nepalese version of the

Brihat-katha, 94, 96, 101,

112, 114, 118, 119
Brockhaus' text of the K.S.S.,

7wl, 10n2, 36n2, 42»\ 52nS

58ft1, $1*1, 83W1, 87/11
Brown, W. N., " Escaping

One's Fate," Studies in

Honor of Maurice

Bloomfield, 1920, 25nl
Budhasvamin, compiler of

the Nepalese version of the

K.S.S., 101, 119
Burlingame, E. W., Buddhist

Legends, 119711
Burnett, A. C, Yule, H.,

and, Hobson-Jobson, 17n2
Burton, R. F., // Pentamerone,

78n; Nights . . . , 37n\

45W1, 85ni

Canney, M. A., "Ashes,"

Hastings' Ency. Rel. Eth.,

vol. ii, 68n2
Catalina, tale of Carisendi

and (Decameron), 69»2
Ceylon, occurrence of cowries

(Cyprxa moneta) in, 17n2
Ceylon, Simhala — i.e., 7n3
Chakra, discus or dominion,

87, 88n
Chakrapura, place called, 58,

58/ii
Chamunda, the goddess, 18
Chandrapura, city called, 61
Chandraiekhara, king named,

51

128

Chandrasvamin, Brahman

named, 47, 68
Chandravati, daughter of

Chandrasekhara, 51, 52, 70
Charlemagne, Vidforull

changes his skin in the

presence of, 45n
Chataki and the rain-cloud,

67
Chatterjee, Sir Atul C, Fore-
word to Vol. IX, 94
Chaturdarika, Book V, 104
Chauvin, V., Bibliographie des

Outrages Arabes, 22n\ 38w2,

82/11
Chitragupta, recorder of good

and evil deeds, 26
Cowries (Cyprcea moneta),

shell-money, 17, 17w2, 18
Coxwell, C. F., Siberian and

Other Folk-Tales, 75wl
Crooke, W., "Some Notes on

Homeric Folk-Lore,"

Folk-Lore, vol. xix, 9m1
Cunningham, A., Stupa of

Bharhut, 51m1

THE OCEAN OF STORY

Dagineya and the Vetala
Agnisikha who submitted
himself to King Vikrama-
ditya, The Cunning
Gambler, 14-17, 26-27
Danavas, enemies of the

gods, 29
Dandin (sixth century), 99,

100
Deccan, the, 72; conquered
by King Vikramaditya, 6 ;
the home of the Andhra
dynasty, 98
Desata, father of Kesata, 56,

64," 65
Detloses, the magic foot-
ointment of Margretha,
45»l
Devadatta, courtesan named,

80
Devasena, karpatika named,

43-45, 71
Devasvamin, Brahman named,

61
Devasvamin, son of Agnis-

vamin, 74
Devi (Parvatl, Gaurl, etc.),

19
Dhanadatta who lost his
Wife, The Merchant, 53-
54, 66-67
Dharma, Mlechchha, one who
disregards Hindu, 2n2

Dhavalasena, ambassador

named, 8
Dundubhi, King of the

Yakshas, 12, 13
Durgaprasad text of the

K.S.S., 87n*
Dmpas, the seven, 26, 31, 33,

35, 36, 39, 50, 51

Ekakikesarin, chief of the
Bhillas, 46, 48

Ganas, attendants of Siva, 3,

4, 96
Gandharvas, attendants of

the gods, 49, 110, 118
Ganga, the river, 28
Ganges, the, 6, 69, 88n3
Gauda, the King of, 34
Gaurl (Durga, Parvatl, consort

of Siva), 2
Gellius, Aulus, Nodes Attica:,

47m1
Ghanta and Nighanta and the

Two Maidens, 29
Godavari, the river, 98
Gonzenbach, L., Sicilianische

Marchen, 78w

Gopala, king named, 34, 119

Gopalaka, uncle of Narava-

hanadatta, 86, 104, 106, 112

Grierson, George A., on the

tarkshyaratna jewel, 52m1
Grierson, G. A., "Modern
Hinduism and its Debt to
the Nestorians," Journ.
Roy. As. Soc, 1907, 108nl ;
" Prakrit," Ency. Brit, vol.
xxii, 99n*
Gunadhya or Malyavan, 98-

100 ; semi-divinity of, 97
Gunadhya, the Brihat-katha,
94, '95, 101, 104, 107, 114,
119n\ 120, 121
Gunas, the three, or phases of

materiality, 89w2
Gunasagara, king named, 50,

QOn1, 51
Gunavati, daughter of Guna-
sagara, 50-52, 70
Gunja fruits, 46

Hala, king of the Andhra
dynasty, 99, 99nl, 100

Hari or Vishnu, 7n2, 87, 88n

Harsha, King, 89

Hastings' Encyclopaedia of
Religion and Ethics, 68m1,
75wl. For details see under
Ency. Rel. Eth.

Himalayas, the, 6, 86, 88

Indra, the king of the gods,
2, 8, 20-22, 25, 26, 29, 30,
30w\ 87n4, 88n2

Indrajit, son of Ravana, 30,
30nl

Jambu tree, 47

Jayadatta, Brahman named,

60
Jayadhvaja, king named, 34
Jayanta and the Golden Deer,

29-30

Kailasa, Mount, 2, 6, 86, 96
Kalapaka, grammar called,

97
Kalasa, King, 88, 89w2- 3
KalavatI, a heavenly nymph

named, 20-22, 24-26
Kalinga, the country of, 53,

70,71
Kalingasena's marriage to
King Vikramaditya, 43-46,
48-50, 52-53, 67, 68, 70-71
Kalpa — i.e. 1000 Mahayugas,
or 4320 million years, 25,
26
Kalpa tree, the wishing-tree

of paradise, 87, 87n5, 88
Kamalalochana, Kusuma-

yudha and, 61-62
Kamalini, the friend of the —

i.e. the sun, 30
Kamarupa, place called, 80,

82
Kanabhuti or Supratika, 96,

97
Kanchanadamshtra, king

named, 48
Kandarpa,The TwoBrahmans

Kesata and, 54-61, 62-66
Kanva, hermit named, 1, 49,

85
Kdpdlika — i.e. a worshipper of
Siva of the left-hand order,
12, Un\ 13, 14, 27, 28, 68-
70
Karnata, the King of, 34
Karpatika — i.e. dependent of

a king, 43, 43n*, 71-74
Karttikeya, the god, 97
Kashmir, the realm of, 87 ;

use of cowries in, 17n2
Kasmlra conquered by King

Vikramaditya, 7
Kasmlra, Sunandana, King of,

34
Kasyapa, hermit named, 1,

85, 105, 113
Kataha, dvlpa named, 50

INDEX I— SANSKRIT WORDS, ETC.

Katantra, grammar called,

97, 100
Kathamukha, Book II, 101-

102
Kathapltha, Book I, 95-101
Katha-sarit-sagara, the, Soma-

deva, 94, 98, 107, 108, 112,

116, 119-121
Katyayana or Pushpadanta,

86, 96
KausambI, city called, 96, 99,

104, 110, 112, 120
Kern, Dr, conjectures by, 5n3,

7w>, 9n\ 32n\ 3in\ 42n\

44n2, 54nl
Kesata and Kandarpa, The

Two Brahmans, 54-61, 62-

66
Ketaka tusks of an elephant,

38

Khandavataka, city called,

72, 73
Khatvanga, staff with a skull

at the top, a weapon of

Siva, 68nx
Kistna, the river, 98
Kohler, Dr Reinhold, notes

to Gonzenbach's Sicilian-

ische Mdrchen, 78n
Krishnasakti, Rajput named,

72, 74
Kshatriyas, warrior caste, 48
Kshemendra, Bfihat - hatha -

manjari, 116
Kusumayudha and Kamalalo-

chana, 61-62
Kuttanikapata, gambler

named, 25
Kuvera, the God of Wealth,

12, 13, 29, 103, 119, 120

Lacote, F., Essai sur Gunadhya *

et la Brhatkatha, 94, ' 95,

100, 101, 117, 118nS H9
Lakshmana, brother of Rama.

30
Lanka (i.e. Ceylon), city of,

30
Lata, the King of, 34
Lavanaka, Book III, 102-104
Lihga of jewels, Siva appears

in the form of a, 10
Linga of tarkshyaratna, 52,

52ni
LiAgas erected by Gunadhya

and Valmlki in Nepal, 97

Macculloch, J. A.,
" Cannibalism," Hastings'
Ency. Rel. Eth., vol. iii,
75ni

VOL. IX.

Madanalekha, daughter of

King Virasena, 8, 31
Madanamanchuka, head
queen of Naravahanadatta,
85, 86, 106, 109-113, 116,
118, 119, 120
Madanamanchuka, Book VI,

105-107
Madanamanjari and the
Kapalika, 12, 12ft1, 13-14,
27
Madanasundari, daughter of
the Bhilla king, 48-50, 52,
70
Madhyadesa conquered by

King Vikramaditya, 6
Madiravati, Book XIII, 109-

110
Magarasvamin, painter

named, 35
Mahabharata, the, Vyasa, 2n2,

97, 99m1, 108
Mahabhishekha, Book XV,

112
Mahakala, an epithet and a
famous UAga of Siva, 17-19
Mahamati, son of Sumati, 5
Mahendraditya, king named,

2-5
Mahldhara, chaplain of King

Mahendraditya, 5
Mainaka, the mountain, 88n2
Makaranda, garden called, 12
Malabar coast, cowries found

on the, 17n2
Malayapura, city called, 39
Malayasimha, king named,

39, 41 '
MalayavatI, princess named,

36, 37ni, 38-41, 43, 72
Maldive Islands, cowries found

on the, 17w2
M a 1 y a v a n, Gana named

(Gunadhya), 96, 97, 100
Malyavat, Gana named, 3, 4
Mandara, Mount, 7n2
Manibhadra, the brother of

Kuvera, 12, 13
Manjaris, abridged versions,

97

Margretha Detloses receives

magic ointmentfrom Satan,

45ni

Maugis, the romance of, 47n8

Mayapur(i), city called, 47,

79
Mettinges and the magic

yellow fat, Anneke, 45nx
Mlechchhas, the — i.e. "outer
barbarians," 2, 2n2, 3, 4, 7,
31,41

129

Moksha or nirvana, the con-
dition of the redeemed
soul, 89n2

Monier Williams, Professor,
explanation of the word
kapalika, 12nl

Muladeva and the Brahman's
Daughter, 77, 77n2, 78-85

Nagapura, city called, 22, 23
Nagas, snake-demons, 7, 49,

97
Nandana, the garden of the

gods, 21, 87, 87n4
Narada, musical instrument

played by, 21
Narasimha, king named, 22
Naravahana, a title of Kuvera,

119
Naravahanadatta, son of the
King of Vatsa, 1, 85, 86,
95, 98, 101, 104, 105, 108-
113, 116, 117, 119
Naravahanadattajanana, Book

IV, 104
Narmada, the river, 54, 55, 57
Nepal, visits of Gunadhya

and Valmlki to, 97
Nepalamahatmya, the, 97
Nighanta and the Two

Maidens, Ghanta and, 29
Nirmuka, King of the

Persians, 34
Nirvana, lake resembling, 9
Nirvana or moksha, the con-
dition of the redeemed
soul, 89n2

Oesterley, H., Baital Pachist,

47n3
Omkarapitha, place called,

72,73

Padmavati, Book XVII, 113
Paisacha language, the, 98,

100
Paithan, the old Pratishthana,

98
Pancha, Book XIV, 110-112
Patichatantra, the, 95, 102,

108, 117
" P a ni c," priyangu— i.e. a

small millet, 8, 8n2
Parijala or coral tree, 87,

87n2
Parvati (Durga, Gauri, etc.,

wife of Siva), 1, 2, 3, 96,

100
Patala, the underworld, 4, 49
Pataliputra, city called, 56,

62-65, 74, 77, 82, 84

130

THE OCEAN OF STORY

Pingl, prii/angu (Panicum

Italicum) — i.e. the Kash-

mirian, 8n2
Pis.uhas, demons hostile to

mankind, 4, 97
Prajapati, the Creator, 29
Pratishthana, the modern

Paithan, 97-99
Pre Her, L., Griechische

Mythologie, 29nx
Priyangu (a small millet),

body like a, 8, 8n2, 28
Pushpadanta or Katyayana,

86, 96

Radigund to Malaya vatl,

resemblance of, 37/11
Rahu, the demon, a head

without body, 87, 88n
Rajatarahginl, the, Kalhana,

87n6
Rakshasas, demons hostile to

mankind, 3, 4, 6, 30, 55,

56, 64, 73
Ralston, W. R. S., Russian

Folk- Tales, Ldn., 1873, 37wx
Ralston, W. R. S., and

Schiefner, F. A. von,

Tibetan Tales, 82m1
Rama, 5, 30
Ramdyana, the, Valmikl, 97,

120
Rambha, a heavenly nymph,

21,22
Rat an, pitcher concealed

under a, 23
Rati, wife of the God of

Love, 106
Ratnadatta, Brahman named,

55,56
Ratnakara, city called, 60
Ratnakara, the horse of

Vikramfiditya, 43
Ratnanadi, the river, 59
Ratnaprabha, Book VII, 107
Ratnaprabha, wife of Narava-

hanadatta, 86
Ratnapura, city called, 57,

60, 63, 65, 66
Havana, chief of the Rak-
shasas, 30
Rishabha mountain, the, 86,
' 112

Rishis, the seven, 105, 106,
" 113
Rohde, E., Der Griechische

Roman, 3Gn\ 37n\ 47n3,

5 In1
Roth, R., Bohtlingk, O., and

(Sanskrit Worterbuch), 3n2,

8n\ 10n2, 12n\ 42nS 52n*

Rudrapala, general of Ananta,
87n6

Riipavatl, daughter of Ratna-
datta, 55-57, 63-66

Sachl, wife of Indra, 2
Saktikumara, king named,

. 34

Saktiyasas, Book X, 108
Sangrama, king named, 87
Sanvarasiddhi, bard named,

39-41
S a p i a, story of, Basile's

Pentamerone, 78w
Sarmishta, 6
Sarvavarman, minister of

King Satavahana, 97, 100
Sasankavati, Book XII, 109
Safin, magician named, 77-

79, 81
S a t a k a r n i, king of the

Andhi-a dynasty, 98
Satavahana, King, 87, 97-99
Saumyadar^ana, wife of King

Mahendraditya, 2
Saurasthra conquered by

King Vikramaditya, 6
Savaras (Bhillas, etc.), 46, 48,

49
Schiefner, F. A. von, Ralston,

W. R. S., and, Tibetan

Tales, 82W1
Shakespeare, All's Well that

Ends Well, 77n2
Siddhas, independent super-
humans, 10
Simhala (i.e. Ceylon), the

King of, 7, 7w3, 8, 10, 28,

30-32, 34
Simhavarman, son of the

King of Simhala, 34
Sindh, the King of, 34
Slta, wife of Rama, 30
Siva, 2-5, 10, 12W1, 19W1, 20,

21W1, 26, 41, 68n!, 69, 85,

86, 89n4, 96, 106, 111, 119,

120
Soma, the son of Rama — i.e.

Somadeva, 89
Somadeva (Katha- sarit-

sagara), 87w6, 94, 95, 97,

101-103, 107, 113, 115-117,

121
Somasarman, father of

Agnisarman, 75
Sorensen, S., An Index to the

Names in the Mahabharata,

2«2
Sorfarina, story of, Gonzen-

bach's Sicilianische Marchen,

78n

Spenser, E., The Faerie

Queene, 37nx
Sri or Lakshml, wife of

Vishnu, 2, 7w2
Srldhara, son of Mahldhara,
, 5
Sringaravati, friend of

Anurfigavati, 65, 66
Stein, M. A., Kalhana' s

Rdjatarangint, 17n2
Sthanu — i.e. Siva, 19
Stokes, M., Indian Fairy

Tales, 47wx
Subha, prince named, 49
Sumanas, daughter of

Jayadatta, 59, 60, 62-66
Sumangala, the assumed

name of the Brahman's

daughter, 80, 81
Sumati, minister named, 2,

5
Sunandana, king named, 34
Sunda and Upasunda, story

of, 29«i
Supratlka, Yaksha named

(Kanabhuti), 96, 97
Supratishthita, city called,

96, 97
Suratamanjan, Book XVI,

112, 113
Surupa, daughter of a Naga,

49
Survaprabha, Book VIII,

107-108
Suryavati, daughter of the

King of Trigarta, 88, 88W1- *
Suvarnadvlpa (the Island of

Gold), 51
Suvigraha, ambassador

named, 70
Swarten and the magic black

fat, Anneke, 45ft1

Tamala tree, 43
Tarkshyaratna, a dark precious

stone, 52, 52wx
Taravali,aGandharva maiden,

49
Tawney, C. H., 9n\ 87n\

93
Taylor MS. of the K.S.S.,

the, 26n2, 27w2, 34n2, 36w2,

38n3, 42W1, 83nx
Thinthakarala, The Bold

Gambler, 17-26
Tilaka, ornamental mark on

the forehead, 88, 89W1
Tilottama, a heavenly nymph,

8
Trigarta, the monarch of,

INDEX I— SANSKRIT WORDS, ETC.

Uchchhaihsravas, 43, 44

Udayana, the King of Vatsa,
94, 101-106, 112, 113, 119

UjjayinI, city called, 2-4, 12,
17, 21, 22, 25, 32, 34, 42,
45, 50, 53, 70, 74, 80, 83,
85, 98, 99, 100, 102, 120

Upasunda, story of Sunda
and, 29n*

Urvibkrits, mountains and
kings, 89, 89n3

Vajrayudha, warder named,

2,5
Valmlki, the Bamayatia, 97
Vandhya, Yakshi named, 44
Varanasi — i.e. Benares, 5, 5n2,

54
Vararuchi or Katyayana, 96,

97, 100
Vardhamana, city called, 53,

75
Vasavadatta, queen of the

King of Vatsa, 102, 104
Va^uki, the serpent - king,

7n2
Vatsa, the King of, 85
Veckenstedt, E., Wendische

Sagen, 45nx
Vedas, the (three), 3, 79
Vegavatl, Vidyadhari named,

Vela, Book XI, 109
Vena, the river, 57
Vetala entering a corpse, 14
Vetalapailchavtjhsati, the, 117

Vetalas, demons hostile to
mankind, 3, 4, 6, 13, 14,
45,46,49,50,52,53,71
Vibhlshana, king of the

Rakshasas, 30
Vibudhas — i.e. sages and gods,

87,87n3 H *

Vidforull who became re-
juvenated by changing his
skin, 47n3, 48n
Vidyadharas, independent
superhumans, 85, 86, 96,
104, 105, 106
Vidyadhari, female form of
Vidyadhara, 107, 108, 110-
112
Vijayavarman, king named,

34
Vikramaditya, Kalingasena's
Marriage to King, 43-46,
48-50, 52-53, 67, 68, 70-71
Vikramaditya, King, 13-15,

27, 50, 51, 113, 114
Vikramaditya, Story of King,
2, 2ni, 3-11, 12, 28-29, 30-
33, 34-42, 43, 85
Vikramasakti, king named, 6,

7, 28, 28^, 30-32, 34
Vindhya forest, the, 96, 97;

mountains, the, 89n3
Vindhyabala, Bhilla named,

34
Vlrasena, King of Simhala,

8
Vishama^Ila or Vikramaditya
King, 4, 5, 15, 41, 43, 45,
67, 71, 85

131

Vishamaslla, Book XVIII,

1-86, 113-114
Vishnu, 2, 7n2, 21, 84, 88n,
^ 108, 120
VisVakarman, the architect

of the gods, 2, 30, 35, 36,

52,70
Vitasta, the river, 88
Vyaghrabala, king named, 6
Vyasa, the Mahabharata, 97

Waldau, A., Bdhmischet

Marchenbuch, 37nx
Weil, G., Tausend und Eine

Nacht, 82nx
Winternitz, M., Gesckichte der

Indischen Litteratur, 99n2

Yajna^vamin, Brahman

named, 60, 62, 79
Yakshas, subjects to Kuvera,

the God of Wealth, 3, 4,

12, 17, 28, 30, 31, 96
Yakshi or YakshinI, female

form of Yaksha, 13, 28,

29, 30, 31, 32, 35, 44,

45
Yama, the God of Death, 18,

25,26
Yama&kha, Vetala named,

14,27
Yamuna, the river, 28
Yojanas, measure of distance,

44,73
Yule, H., and Burnett, A. C,

Hobson-Jobson, 17n2

INDEX II

Accusation of bastardy, 82,

82w*
Adulterous wife bitten off,

nose of, 76
Adventures of Anangadeva,

the, 7-12, 28, 30-32
" Adventures of Bulukiya,

The," The Nights, R. F.

Burton, 45n*
JEneid, Virgil, 44nx
Age and disease, fruit that

prevents old, 47, 47w3
Air-flying witches, 57-59
" AH and Zahir," tale of The

Nights, Weil's trans., 82w*
All's Well that Ends Well,

Shakespeare, 77n2
Alms to a woman, con-
sequence of refusing, 56,

56ni
American Journal of Philology,

"The Art of Stealing in

Hindu Fiction," M.

Bloomfield, vol. xliv, 78n
Animal transformation, 45
Animal, woman eats an, 75
Animals, pretended know-
ledge of the language of,

23,24
Arabian Nights. See under

Nights . . .
"Art of Stealing in Hindu

Fiction, The," M.

Bloomfield, Amer. Journ.

Phil., 78w
Artifice of the gambler, 23, 24
Ascetic, disguising as an,

23-25
Ashes on a funeral pyre,

magical rite of throwing,

68, 68n2, 69
"Ashes," M. A. Canney,

Hastings' Ency. Rel. Eth.,

68n2
Author's Epilogue to the

K.S.S., 87, 87/11, 88, 89
Authors, semi-divine

(Gunadhya, Valmiki and

Vyasa), 97
Automata, 9nx
133

GENERAL

« Badawi and his Wife," The
Nights, R. F. Burton, Sbn1

Bait a I Pachtsi, H. Oesterley,
47n3

Bastardy, the accusation of,
82, 82n*

Bathing nymphs, stealing the
clothes of, 20, 20nl

Battle, description of a, 51

Bed made of lotus leaves, 39

Belly, of a boar, man issuing
fromthe,49; ofanelephant,
man and woman issue from
the, 49 ; of a fish, woman
issuing from the, 59 ; of
large fish, a whole ship
issues from the, 51, 51nx

Bibliographic des Ouvrages
Arabes, V. Chauvin, 22wx,
38n2, 82m1

Birds (Aves), Aristophanes,
3»i

Black magic, sympathetic,
27, 27wx; ointments, magic,
45n*

Black Mountain, the, 1, 113

Blood produced through cut-
ting off the head in picture,
27,27ft1

Boar, man issuing from the

. belly of a, 49

Bodies of girls like the moon
and the priyangu, 8, 9, 28

Body, Rahu a demon with a
headless, 88w

Bbhmisches Marchenbuch, A.
Waldau, 37ft1

Bold Gambler Thinthakarala,
The, 17-26

Book XVIII: Vishamasila,
1-86

Books I-XVIII of the K.S.S.,
discussion of, 95-116

Books in the K.S.S., tabular
list of, 114-115

Brahman Agni£arman and his
Wicked Wife, The, 75,
75w3, 76-77

Brahman demons, the punish-
ment of the, 15, 16

Brahman named Agnisvamin,

74; named Chandrasvamin,

47, 68; named Devasvamin,

61 ; named Jayadatta, 60 ;

named Ratnadatta, 55, 56 ;

named YajnasVamin, 60,

62, 79
Brahman, The Permanently

Horripilant, 74-75
Brahman who recovered his

Wife alive after her Death,

The, 68-70
Brahman's Daughter, Mula-

deva and the, 77, 77w2, 78-
_ 85
BrA.hm.ans KeSata and

Kandarpa, The Two, 54-61,

62-66
Bridegroom, the substituted,

55-57
Buddhist Legends, E. W.

Burlingame, 119na
Buddhists, seven precious

things of the, 23nx

"Cannibalism," J. A.
Macculloch, Hastings'
Ency. Rel. Eth., 75/i1

Challenge to the Mothers,
Thinthakarala's, 17, 18

Changing skin as means of
rejuvenation, 48n

" Chaste Wife, Wright's,"
story of the, 53n2

Chastity, the garland of, 53,
53n2

Child of the Jar — i.e. the
saint Agastya, 89, 89n3

Churningofthe(Milk-)Ocean,
the, 7n2, 87n2

Circle, the magic, 13, 13nx,
14

City called Bhimapura, 59,
60 ; called Chandrapura,
61 ; called KausambI, 96,
99, 104, 110, 112, 120;
called Khandavataka, 72,
73; called Malay apura,
39; called Mayapur(i), 47,
79; called Nagapura, 22,23

134

THE OCEAN OF STORY

City called Pataliputra, 56,
62-65,74,77,82,84; called
Ratnakara, 60; called
Ratnapura, 57, 60, 63, 65,
66; called Supratishthita,
96, 97; called UjjayinI,
2-4, 12, 17, 21, 22, 25, ,'52,
34, 42, 45, 50, 53, 70, 74,
SO, 83, 85, 98, 99, 100, 102,
120; called Vardhamana,
53, 75 ; of La h k a (i.e.
Ceylon), 30

Clever boy, the, 83-85

Clothes of heavenly nymphs,
wliile bathing, stealing the,
20, 20/1*

Comparison between the
Rdmayana and the Brihat-
katha, 120

Conquest of various peoples,
Udayana's, 103

Contemplation, supernatural
powers of, 22

Contents of Books in the
K.S.S. unconnected, 104,
107, 108, 115

Cool and warm mangoes, the,
78, 79

Coral or pdrijdta tree, 87,
87n-

Corpse of a thief, demon
inhabiting the, 76, 77;
Vetala entering a, 14

Courtesan named Devadatta,
80 ; the sham, 80

"Cowry," Hobson-Job.scm, H.
Yule and A. C. Burnett,
17n-

Creator of the Vindhya
mountains, Agastya, 89w:i

Crow, interpretation of the
cry of a, 24

Cunning Gambler Dagineya
and the Vetala Agnisikha,
who submitted himself to
King Vikramaditya, The,
14-17, 26-27

Cunning Sumangala, the, 81

Curious Myths of the Middle
Ages, S. Baring-Gould,
47n:!

Curse on the heavenly nymph,
Indra's, 22

Cyproea moneta, cowries, 17w2

Dancers disappear in carved
figures of temple pillars,
52

Daughter, Muladeva and the
Brahman's, 77, 77n2, 78-85

Death, The Brahman who

recovered his Wife alive

after her, 68-70
Death caused by the look of

a kapalika, 68
Decameron, Boccaccio, 69n-
Deer of gold and jewels

possessing life, 9, 9ft1, 28-

32, 34
Demon inhabiting the corpse

of a thief, 76, 77
Demons, the punishment of

tin- Brahman, 15, 16
Description of a battle, 31
Diamond, one of the five

precious things, 23wL
Dice with the Mothers,

Thinthakarala plays, 17, 18
Disconnection of contents of

Books of the K.S.S. , 104,

107, 108, 115
Discussion on Books I-XVIII

of the K.S.S., 95-116
Disease, fruit that prevents

old age and, 47, 47ft3
Disguising as an ascetic, 23-

25
Dislike for men, princess's,

36, 37, 37m1, 39
Dogs of gold and silver, 9ft1
Dream, falling in love with a

person in a, 36, 36m1, 38,

40 ; fruit given by Siva in

a, 44ft2
Dwarf incarnation of Vishnu,

the, 84

Ear ornament, Thinthakarala

concealed in a lotus used

as, 21
Eating a gourd turns a man

into a python, 45 ; human

flesh, 75, 75ft1
Elephant, man and woman

issue from the belly of an,

49
Elephant-faced god — i.e.

Ganesa, 1
Encyclopaedia Britannica, 11th

e'd., 17n2, 99ft1
Encyclopaedia of Religion and

Ethics, Hastings', " Ashes,"

M. A. Canney, vol. ii,

68n2 ; "Cannibalism," J. A.

Macculloch, vol. iii, 75ft1
Entering a corpse, Vetala,

14
Epilogue to the K.S.S.,

Author's, 87, 87ft1, 88-89
Erect, hair standing, 37, 74,

75

"Escaping One's Fate," W.N.
Brown, Studies in Honor of

Ma mice Bloomjleld, 25ft1
Essai stir Gunadhya et la

Brhatkathd, F. Lacote, 94,

95, 100, 101, 117, ll&n1,

119
Essay, Terminal, 93-121
Evil omens, 76, 76w'
Evil of gambling, the, 16,

17
Existence of Gunadhya,

doubt about the, 95, 96

Faerie Queene, The, E. Spenser,

37ft1
Falling in love with a person

in a dream, 36, 36ft1, 38,

40 ; with a picture, 36,

36ft1, 38
" False Ascetics and Nuns in

Hindu Fiction, On," M.

Bloomfield, Journ. Amer.

Orient. Sac, 23ft2
Fat of a toad enabling witches

to fly through the air, 45ftl
Father of Fiction, the,

Somadeva, 121
Feet, magic ointment for the,

45, 45ft1
Fever of love, the, 36, 38,

39
Figures on temple pillars,

dancers and singers be-
come, 52
Fire sacrifices of Brahmans,

the gods nourished by the,

3, 3ft1
Fish swallows a whole ship,

large, 51, 51ft1 ; woman

issuing from the belly of

a, 59
Five precious things, the, 23,

23ft1
Flesh, selling human, 15, 16;

woman - eaters of human

and animal, 75, 75ft1
Flying power of witches

produced by fat of a toad,

45ft1
Folk-Lore, "Some Notes on

Homeric Folk-Lore," W.

Crooke, vol. xix, 9ft1
Folk-Tales, Russian, W. R. S.

Ralston, 37ft1
Folk- Tales, Siberian and Other,

C. F. Coxwell, 75ft1
Forewords to the Ocean of I

Story, the different, 93, 94
Four pitchers buried in the

ground, the, 23, 2 4

INDEX II— GENERAL

135

" Frame-story " of the K.S.S.,

the, 94-95
Friend of the kamalini — i.e.

the sun, 30
Fruit, given by Siva to the

queen in a dream, 4, 4n2 ;

that prevents old age and

disease, 47, 47n3

Gambler who cheated Yama,

the, 25, 25m1, 26; Dagineya

and the Vetala Agni&kha

who submitted himself to

King Vikramaditya, The

Cunning, 14-17, 26-27;

Thinthakarala, The Bold,

17-26
Garland of chastity, the, 53,

53n2
Garments of bathing nymphs,

stealing the, 20, 20nl
Geschichte der Indischen

Litleratur, M. Winternitz,

99n2
Girl in a dream, falling in

love with a, 36, 36nx, 38
Glory white in Hindu rhe-
toric, 6n2
God of Love, the Kama, 54
Goddess of the evil omen,

the, 76, 77
Goddess of Prosperity, 2
Gods nourished by the

oblation in fire-offerings,

3, 3ni
Gold and jewels possessing

life, deer of, 9, 9nl, 28-32,

34; one of the five precious

things, 23W ; and silver,

dogs of, 9nx
Golden Deer, Jayanta and

the, 29-30
Gourd, man turned into a

python through eating a, 45
Grammar called Katantra and

Kalapaka, 97, 100
Grateful Monkey, The, 47,

47nS 48
Great tale, the — i.e. the

Brihat-lcatha (q.v.), 96-98
Griechiscke Mythologie, L.

Preller, 29nl
Griechiscke Roman, Der, E.

Rohde, 36n\ 37n\ 47n3,

Sin1

Hair standing erect, 37, 74,

75
Hand of Vetala severed by

cutting off hand of a drawn

figure, 27, 27n*

Head of a drawn figure, blood
produced through cutting
off the, 27, 27?*1

Headless body, Rahu a demon
with, 88n

Heavenly fruit preventing
old age and disease, 47,
47n3; maidens, the two, 8,
9, 28-32, 34, 35; nymphs
while bathing, stealing the
clothes of, 20, 20n» ; River,
the, the Ganges, 88, 88n3

Hermit named Kanva, 1, 49,
85 ; named Kasyapa, 1, 85,
105, 113

High social tone of the
Kashmirian version of the
K.S.S., 118

Hindu pun, Sn1, 6, 6n\ 7, 7n2,
19n2, 41n2, 87, 87n3, 88n,
88w12, 89n'-2-3; rhetoric,
glory white in, 6n2

Hindu Solomon, Vikra-
maditya a, 3n3

Hobson-Jobson, H. Yule and
A. C. Burnell, 17n2

Horripilant Brahman, The
Permanently, 74-75

Horripilation, 37, 74, 75

Howling jackal on left-hand
side an evil omen, 76, 76nx

Human flesh, eating, 75,
75nx ; selling, 15, 16

Ichor from elephant's fore-
head used as perfume, 46

Iliad, Homer, 9ft1, 44nx

Illuminating power of newly
born prince, 4

// Pentamerone. See under
Pentamerone, II

Image on a pillar through
curse, transformation into
an, 22, 22*!1

Incarnation of Vishnu, the
dwarf, 84

Index, the chastity, 53, 53n2

Index to the Names in the
Ma habhar at a, An, S.
Sorensen, 2, 2n2

India Office MSS. of the
K.S.S., 3n2, 4/11, 7n\ $nl,
lOn1-2, Un\ 19n\ 20n23,
2 In2, 26n12, 2&V, 29n2-3,
Mn\ 55nx, 58^, 6 In1, 75n2,
76n2, 78n1

Indian Fairy Tales, M. Stokes,
47ni

Interpretation of the lan-
guage of animals, 23, 24 ;
of the two strange tales, 84

Introduction of Narava-

hanadatta as teller of his

own story, 105
Investiture with the sacred

thread, 5
Island of Simhala (i.e. Ceylon),

8
Island, the White, 6 ; of gold

(Suvarnadvipa), 51

Jackal, interpretation of the

yell of a, 23
Jackal on left-hand side,

howling, an evil omen, 76,

76ni
Jar, Child of the — i.e. the

saint Agastya, 89, 89n3
Jewels, the five, 23nx;

possessing life, deer of gold

and, 9, 9nx, 28-32, 34
Journ. Amer. Orient. Soc., "On

False Ascetics and Nuns

in Hindu Fiction," M.

Bloomfield, vol. xliv, 23n-
Journal of Philology , American ,

78n. For details see under

Amer. Journ. Phil.
Journ. Roy. As. Soc, " Modern

Hinduism and its Debt to

the Nestorians," G. A.

Grierson, 1907, lCSn1

Kalkana's Rdjatarangini, M. A.
Stein, 17n2

King of Kalinga, the, 53 ;
named Chandra^ekhara,
51 ; named Dundubhi, 12,
13 ; named Gunasagara, 50,
51 ; named Kanchanadam-
shtra, 48 ; named Mahen-
draditya, 2-5; named
Malayasimha, 39, 41;
named Narasimha, 22;
named Vikrama^akti, 6, 7,
28, 28n1, 30-32, 34; named
Vyaghrabala, 6 ; Satakarni
of the Andhra dynasty, 98 ;
of Simhala — i.e. Ceylon, 7,
7n3, 5, 10, 28, 30-32, 34;
of Vatsa, the, 85 ; Vikra-
maditya, Kalingasena's
Marriage to, 43-46, 48-50,
52-53, 67, 68, 70-71

King Vikramaditya, Story of,
2, 2n\ 3-11, 12, 28-29, 30-
33, 34-42, 43, 85

Knowledge of the speech of
animals, pretended, 23, 24

Lady in a dream, falling in
love with a, 36, SGn1, 38

iao

THE OCEAN OF STORY

Lake resembling Nirvana,

magic, 9, 10
Language of animals,

pretended knowledge of,

23,24
Laugh of the hypocritical

gambler, 23, 23n3
Leaves, bed made of lotus, 39
Left-hand order of Siva

worshippers, kapalikas, 12n*
Life, deer of gold and jewels

possessing, 9, 9n1, 28-32 ;

through ashes thrown on

her pyre, woman returns

to, 68, 68n2, 69
Life and Stories of the Jaina

Savior Parcvanatha, The,

M. Bloomfield, 82wx
List of Books in the K.S.S.,

tabular, 114-115
Look of a kapalika, death

caused by the, 68
Lotus leaves, bed made of, 39
Lotus, used as ear ornament,

Thinthakarala concealed in

a, 21'
Love, the fever of, 36, 38,

39 ; Kama, the God of, 54 ;

with a person in a dream,

falling in, 36, 36n\ 38, 40 ;

with a picture, falling in,

36, 36n\ 38
Low social tone of the Brihat-

katha and its Nepalese

version, 118, 120
Lyre, Madanamanjari's skill

of playing the, 10

Magic circle, the, 13, 13W1,
14 ; ointment for the feet,
45, 45»x ; rite of throwing
ashes on a funeral pyre, 68,
68n2, 69; staff, 68, 68W1,
69 ; sympathetic black, 27,
27/11 ; Thinthakarala con-
cealed in a lotus by, 21

Mahabharata, the Vyasa, 2w2,
97, 99n\ 108

Maidens, the two heavenly,
8, 9, 28-32, 34, 35
ale sex, girl's dislike for
the, 36, 37, 37W1, 39

Man, becomes rejuvenated by
changing his skin, 48n ;
issuing from the belly of a
boar, 49 ; and woman issue
from the belly of an
elephant, 49

"Man who went to seek his
Fate, The," Indian Fairy
Tales, M. Stokes, 47nx

Man-hater, princess who is a,

36, 37, 37n\ 39
Mangoes, the warm and the

cool, 78, 79
Mare devoured by a woman, 75
Marriage to King Vikrama-

ditya, Kalingasena's, 43-46,

48-50, 52-53, 67, 68, 70-71
Materiality, the three gunas

or phases of, 89n2
Men, ornaments of skulls of,

12W1
Merchant Dhanadatta who

lost his Wife, The, 53-54
Metamorphoses, stone, 22nx
Metaphor of the sun, 30
Methods of finding people,

38, 38»2
Milk, the Sea of, 6
Milk-ocean, the Churning of

the, 87n2
" Modern Hinduism and its

Debt to the Nestorians,"

G. A. Grierson, Journ. Roy.

As. Soc, 108ft1
Monkey, The Grateful, 47,

47W1, 48
Monstrous fish swallows a

whole ship, 51, 51wx
Moon, body white like the,

9,28
Mothers, the, personified

energies of the principal

deities, 17, 17w3, 18, 58
Mothers, The, R. Briffault,

17w3
Motif, "Accusation of

Bastardy," 82nx; " Promise

to Return," 55, 55w2
Mount Kailasa, 2, 6, 86, 96 ;

Mandara, 7/i2
Mountain, the Black, 1, 113;

Mainaka, the, 88w2 ; of

Rishabha, 86, 112
Mountains, Indra cutting the

wings of the, 88w2 ; to the

sea, refuge of the winged,

7»2 ; the Vindhya, 89w*

Names of Books I and II of

the K.S.S., similarity in,

101
Nepalese version of the

Brihat- hatha — i.e. the

Brihat-katha-sloka-samgraha,

84, 101
Nights and a Night, The

Thousand, R. F. Burton,

Zln\ 45n*, 85w*
Nodes Attica;, Aulus Gellius,

47W1

Nose of adulterous wife bitten

off, 76
Nymphs, stealing the clothes

of bathing, 20, 20nx

Ocean, the Churning of the

(Milk-), 7n2, 87n2; Mount

Mainaka takes refuge in

the, 88w2
Oceans swallowed by Agastya,

the seven, 89, 89n3
Odyssey, Homer, 9/11
Offerings of Brahmans, the

gods nourished by the fire-,

3, Sn1
Ointment for the feet, magic,

45, 45W1
Old age and disease, fruit

that prevents, 47, 47n3
" Omar bin al-Nu'uman, Tale

of King," The Nights, R. F.

Burton, 37m1
Omens, evil, 76, 76»x
Order of Books VI, XII,

XVII and XVIII of the

K.S.S., wrong, 106, 109,

113, 115
Order of Siva worshippers,

kapalikas a left-hand, 12nx
Ornament, Thinthakarala

concealed in a lotus used

as an ear, 21
Ornaments of men's skulls,

12wv

Painting, falling in love with

a, 36, 36/11, 38
Panicum Italicum, " Panic," a

small millet, 8n2
Paradise, kalpa tree or

wishing-tree of, 87, 87n5
Partridge appearing on the

right, an evil omen," 76,

76/11
Pearl, one of the five precious

things, 23m1
Pentamerone, II, G. B. Basile,

78w
People conquered by the

King of Vatsa, 103
Perfume, ichorfrom elephants'

foreheads used as, 46
Permanently Horripilant

Brahman, The, 74-75
Phases of materiality, the

three gunas or, 89w2
Picture, falling in love with

a, 36, 36n\ 38
Pillar through curse, trans-
formation into an image

on a, 22, 22n*

INDEX II— GENERAL

137

Pitchers full of precious

things buriedin the ground,

23,24
Players and singers disappear

in the carved figures on

temple wall, 52
Position of Books VI, XII,

XVII and XVIII of the

K.S.S., wrong, 106, 109,

113, 115
Power of newly born prince,

illuminating, 4; Vetala

giving away his shape and,

16 ; of witches produced

by the fat of a toad, flying,

45ni
Powers of contemplation,

supernatural, 22
Prakrit, the Court language

of the Andhra dynasty, 99
"Prakrit," G. A. Grierson,

Encyclopaedia Britannica,

99m'1
Precious stone ( Tarkshya-

ratna), 52, 52nx; things,

the five, 23, 23nx
Pretended knowledge of the

language of animals, 23, 24
Princesses, The Two, 50-52
" Promise to Return " motif,

55, 55n2
Promises of Muladeva and

the Brahman's daughter,

the, 80
Prosperity, the Goddess of,

2
Pun, Hindu, 5nx, 6, 6m1, 7,

7n2, 19n2, 41n2, 87, 87nJ,

88n, 88W1- 2, 89^- 2- 3
Pyre, magical rite of throw-
ing ashes on a funeral, 68,

68n2, 69
Python through eating a

gourd, man turned into a,

45

Queen Kalingasena, 43, 52,
106 ; Madanamanchuka,
85, 86 ; Madanasundari,
48-50, 52, 70

Bajatarangini, the Kalhana,

87n6
Raiatarangini, Kalhana's,M.A.

Stein, 17n2
Rdmayana, the, Valmiki, 97,

120
Refuge in the ocean, Mount

Mainaka takes, 88n2 ; in

the sea of the winged

mountains, 7n2

Refusing alms to a woman,

the consequence of, 56,

56nJ
Resuscitation through ashes

thrown on funeral pyre,

68, mn\ 69
Retrospect, 122-125
M Return, Promise to," motif,

55, 55w2
Revenge of the cunning

gambler, the, 16
Rhetoric, glory white in

Hindu, 6n2
Rite of throwing ashes on a

funeral pyre, magical, 68,

eSn1, 69
River, the Heavenly — i.e. the

Ganges, 88, 88n3
Romance of Maugis, the, 47n3
Ruby, one of the five precious

things, 23nx
Rupee, 4096 cowries— i.e. one,

17n2
Russian Folk-Tales, W. R. S.

Ralston, 37ft1

Sacred thread, investiture

with the, 5
Sacrifices of Brahmans, the

gods nourished by, 3, 3nx
Sagen, Marchen und Gebrauche

aus Meklenburg, K. Bartsch,

45m1
Sale of human flesh, 15, 16
Sandalwood juice applied as

relief for fever, 39
Sandbank in the sea, the two

maidens on a, 8, 9
Sanskrit College MS. of the

K.S.S., 4nS W, $n\ 19m1,

20n3, 26nx- 2, 27n2, 29n2, 3,

Un\ 36n2, 38n3, 39n2,3,

4 In1, 42W1, 54nx, 55nx, 57m1,

58n\ 6 In1, 75n2, 76n2, 83m1
Sapphire, one of the five

precious things, 23nx
Satan, magic ointment for

feet brought by, 45nx
Sea of Milk, the, 6
Sea, the two maidens on a

sandbank in the, 8, 9 ; the

winged mountains taking

refuge in the, 7n2
Semi-divine authors

(Gunadhya, Valmiki and

Vyasa), 97
Servant, the deceitful, 61, 62
Seven oceans swallowed by

Agastya, 89, 89n3; precious

things of the Buddhists,

23m1

Sex, girl's dislike for the

male, 36, 37, 37m1, 39
Shape and power, Vetala

giving away his, 16
Shell-money, use of, 17n2
Ship swallowed by a large

fish, a whole, 51, Sin1
Siberian and Other Folk-Tales,

C. F. Coxwell, 75nx
Sicilianische Marchen, L.

Gonzenbach, 75n
Silver, dogs of gold and,

9m1
Similarity in names of Books

I and II of the K.S.S., 101
Singers disappear in the

carved figures of temple

walls, 52
Skill of playing the lyre,

Madanamanjari's, 10
Skin, youth regained by

changing one's, 48n
Skulls of men, ornaments

made of, V2nl
Social tone of the Brihat-

katha and its Nepalese

version, low, 118, 120
" Some Notes on Homeric

Folk- Lore," W. Crooke,

Folk-Lore, 9nx
Speech of animals, pretended

knowledge of the, 23, 24
Spell of the kdpdlika, the, 13
Staff, magic, 68, 68m1, 69
Standing of the Brihat-katha

and its Nepalese version,

low social, 118, 120
Stealing the clothes of bath-
ing nymphs, 20, 20nx
Stone metamorphoses, 22m1
Story of King Vikramaditya,

2, 2nl, 3-11, 12, 28-29, 30-

33, 34-42, 43, 85 ; of Sapia,

Basile's Pentamerone, 78n ;

of Sorfarina, Gonzenbach 's

Siciliariische Marchen, 78n
Strange tales, the two, 84
Strides of Vishnu, the (three),

84
Stupa of Bharhut, A.

Cunningham, 51m1
Sub-stories to the Main Story

of the K.S.S., proportion

of, 95
Substituted bridegroom, the,

55-57
Sun, metaphor of the, 30
Swan-maidens (Appendix I

of Vol. VIII), 20m1
Sympathetic black magic, 27,

27m1

138

THE OCEAN OF STORY

Tabular list of Books in the

K.S.S., 114, 115
Tale of " Ali and Zaher,"

The Nights, Weil's trans.,

82nx; of Carisendi and

Catalina (Decamero?i), 69n2
Tale, The Great — i.e. the

Brihat-katha, 96, 97, 98
"Tale of King Omar bin al-

Nu'uman," The Nights,

R. F. Burton, 37W1
Tales, the two strange, 84
Tales, Indian Fairy, M. Stokes,

47n*
Tansend und Eine Nacht, G.

Weil, 82n*
Terminal Essay, 93-121
Thief, demon inhabiting the

corpse of a, 76, 77
Things, the five precious, 23,

23nx
Thousand Nights and a Night,

The. See under Nights . . .
Thread, investiture with the

sacred, 5
Three gunas or phases of

materiality, the, 89w2
Three-eyed god, Siva, the, 19
Throwing ashes on a funeral

pyre, magical rite of, 68,

68n2, 69
Tibetan Tales, W. R. S.

Ralston and F. A. von

Schiefner, 82wx
Toad enables witches to fly

through the air, fat of a,

45W1

Transformation, animal, 45 ;
into an image on a temple-
pillar, 22, 22n*

Tree, asoka, 54 ; jambu, 47 ;
kalpa, or wishing-tree of
paradise, 87, 87 w5, 88;
parijata or coral, 87, 87w2 ;
tamala, 43

Two beautiful maidens in the
sea, the 8, 9, 28, 29;
Brahmans Ke£ata and
Kandarpa, The, 54-61, 62-
66 ; Princesses, The, 50-
52

Unfading garland, the, 53,
53n2

Varia Historia, ^Elian, 47w3
Visits of Valmlki and
Gunadhya to Nepal, 97

Wandering Jew fable, the

romance of Maugis possibly

a form of the, 48m
Warm and cool mangoes, the,

78, 79
Weapon of Siva, the magic

staff a, 68W1
Weeping image on the temple

pillar, the, 24
Wendische Sagen, E. Vecken-

stedt, 45wx
White in Hindu rhetoric,

glory, 6n2 ; Island, the, 6

Wicked Wife, The Brahman
AgniSarman and his, 75,
75w3, 76-77

Wife alive after her Death,
The Brahman who re-
covered his, 68-70

Wife bitten off, nose of adul-
terous, 76

Wife, The Merchant Dhana-
datta who lost his, 53-54

Winged mountains to the
sea, refuge of the, 7w2

Wings of the mountains,
Indra cutting the, 88n2

Wishing-tree of paradise, the
kalpa tree or, 87, 87n5

Witches, air- flying, 57-59;
produced by fat of a toad,
flying power of, 45nx

Woman, eats human flesh, 75,
75nx ; issue from the belly
of an elephant, man and,
49 ; issuing from the belly
of a fish, 59 ; returns to life
through ashes being thrown
on her pyre, 68, 68w2, 69

"Wright's Chaste Wife,"
story of the, 53w2

Wrong position of Books VI,
XII, XVII and XVIII of
the K.S.S., 106, 109, 113,
115

Yellow fat, smearing with

magic, 45wx
Youth regained by changing

one's skin, 48n

ADDENDA AND CORRIGENDA

139

ADDENDA AND CORRIGENDA

The following pages (fully indexed in Vol. X) contain not merely corrected
printer's errors, but additional references and information, which I have either
come across personally since the publication of the particular volume in question,
which have appeared in reviews, or which have been forwarded me by some of
my subscribers. In this connection I would especially mention Sir George
Grierson, Professor W. R. Halliday, Dr A. H. Krappe and Professor Paul Pelliot.

VOLUME I

Page xxxiii, line 21 from top. For " chapters " read " books."

P. 2, lines 12-20. Cf. Lacote's translation in Ocean, Vol. IX,
pp. 117, 118.

P. 10n3. The World Egg. See tether R. Eisler, Weltenmantel
u. Himmelszelt, 2 vols., Munchen, 1910 (esp. vol. ii). The
material is mainly Iranian.

P. 12w\ The reference from Melusine should read " vol. i,
1878, col. 107." The extract given has been translated
by Tawney from the French.

P. 14, lines 15 and 16 of note. " Gharib " and " Ajib " are
more correctly written " Gharib " and " Ajib."

P. 15, line 11 of note. For " Hola " read " Holoa."

P. 16w\ The bodiless voice. For a good example of Kledo-
nomancy (the acceptance of the spoken word as an omen)
cf. Halliday, Greek Divination, London, 1913, p. 229 ;
cf. also Voyage d'Ibn Batoutah, Paris, 1853, vol. i, p. 34 ;
Anibal, " Voces del cielo," Romanic Review, vol. xvi,
p. 57 et seq. '

P. 19na. Gold under pillow. After the Grimm reference add :
" See Bolte and Polivka, Anmerkungen zu den Kinder -
und Hausmdrchen der Briider Grimm, Leipzig, 1913, vol. i,
p. 542. The Marchen type of 4 Gold pieces under pillow ■
stories has been examined with the help of all known
variants by A. Aarne, in his Vergleichende Marchenfor-
schungtn, Helsingfors, 1908, p. 143 et seq. Cf. also the
review of K. Krohn in Anzeiger der Finnisch-U grischen
Forschungen, pp. 1-10. See further Kretschmer, Neu-
griechische Marchen, 1921, p. 23 et seq. ; Tille, Verzeichnis
der Bbhmischen Marchen, FF Com. 34, p. 285 ; Hertel,
Pantschdkhydna-Wdrttika, Leipzig, 1923, p. 119 ; and
also Halliday 's note on p. 165 of this volume."
141

142 THE OCEAN OF STORY

Page 24W1. Virgil, the sorcerer. Add to note : " See Chauvin,
Bibliographic des Ouvrages Arabes, viii, pp. 188-190."

Pp. 25-29. Notes on " Magical Articles." See Bolte and
Polivka, op. cit.9 vol. ii, p. 331 ; Coxwell, Siberian Folk-
Tales, p. 238 ; and Halliday, Journ. Gypsy Lore Soc,
3rd series, vol. ii, 1924, pp. 151-156.

P. 25, line 28. For " Scandinavian Tales " read " Yule-Tide
Stories."

P. 25, line 37. For " Ashbjornsen " read " Asbjornsen."

P. 26, line 1. For " Hamelin " read " Hameln."
line 21. For " Von " read " von."
line 41. For " J. C. Croker " read " T. C. Croker."

P. 27, line 4. For " Kinder " read " Kinder-."
line 23. For " Freer " read " Frere."

P. 28, last line. Read " j . . . Wonderful ape Ala,' which
occurs in Chapter LVII of the Ocean, Vol. V, pp. 5-13."

Pp. 42-44. " Entrapped Suitors." See Halliday, Journ. Gypsy
Lore Soc, 3rd series, vol. i, 1922, pp. 55-58; Bedier,
Les Fabliaux, Paris, 1925, pp. 454-457 ; R. Kohler,
Kleinere Schriften, vol. ii, pp. 445-456 ; J. Bolte, Zeitsch.
d. Vereins f. Volkskunde, vol. xxvi, p. 19 ; Fornmanna
Sogur, vol. iii, p. 67 et seq. ; Kretschmer, op. cit., p. 175 ;
Mazon, Conies populaires de la Macedoine sud-occidentale,
Paris, 1923, pp. 123, 213. Professor Jolly sends me a
German variant — J. Ayrer, "Die ehrlich Beckin mit iren
drey vermeinten Bulern," Dramen herausg. von Keller,
vol. iv, p. 2763 et seq.

P. 42. For line 8 from bottom read : " See Ind. Ant., vol.
ii, 1873, pp. 357-360, and ditto, vol. ix, 1880, pp. 2, 3,
where G. H. Damant relates, in . . ."

P. 44, line 22. Insert " Early " before " English."

line 5 from bottom : " For variants of the i Mastermaid '
type see Bolte and Polivka, op. cit., vol. ii, p. 517et seq."

P. 46, line 5 from bottom. For " Jacobi's " read "Jacobs'."

P. 46n2. For the laughing fish cf. Mazon, op. cit, p. 137 ;
Halfs Saga, chapter vii ; Naumann, Isldndische Volks-
mdrchen, Jena, 1923, p. 287 ; P. Paris, Les Romans de la
Table Ronde, vol. i, pp. 82, 85 ; vol. ii, pp. 42-43.

P. 48, line 12. For " todeath " read " to death."

P. 48w2. On " Svend's Exploits " cf. the Eddie Fjolsvinnsmdl,
Gering, Die Edda, p. 130 et seq.

P. 50W1. Riddles. Cf. The Story of Ahikar, ed. F. C. Cony-
beare, J. Rendel Harris, A. S. Lewis, 1898, pp. 74-79.

ADDENDA AND CORRIGENDA 143

Page 51ft1. For the"Riddle of the Sphinx " seeKohler, Kleinere
Schriften, vol. i, p. 115 ; Schmidt, Griechische Mdrchen,
p. 144 ; and Apollodorus, ed. Frazer, vol. i, p. 347.

P. 52, last 3 lines. Drought. Cf. 1 Kings xvii, 1.

P. 77ft1. For the cock's crow see Wilhehn, Chinesische Volks-
mdrchen, Jena, 1921, pp. 201, 212.

P. 81, line 11 from bottom. For "sabbarah" read "sabbarah."

P. 82. Language of signs. For its use among the North
American Indians see G. Mallery, Introduction to the Study
of Sign Language, Washington, 1880. Cf. Kautilya,
Artha&dstra, I, xi, 21 ; I, xii, 13 ; and II, xxvii, 43.

P. 84ft2. The Ovid quotation is from Metamorphoses, viii, 684.
See further Ocean, Vols. VI, p. 122ft2, and VII, p. 126ft2.

P. 93, line 9. For " and " read " on."

P. 95ft2. For " Freer " read " Frere."

P. 98w. Magical properties of blood. Three cases of the
murder of children for obtaining offspring occurred in
the Panjab as recently as 1921, in one of which a barren
woman bathed in the blood of a child.

P. 98ft1. For an interesting note on the Constantine legend
see Halliday, Folk-Lore, vol. xxxv, 1924, p. 404.

P. 101ft1, line 6 from bottom. For "Holin's "read "Hahn's."
Grateful snakes. Add to note : " See also Aarne, op. cit.,
p. 1 et seq."

P. 109ft1, lines 1, 2. In his review, Mr S. M. Edwards says :
" The explanation of mrigdnka, an epithet of the Moon,
as * hare-marked,' i because Hindus see a " hare " in the
moon,' appears scarcely correct. The words Sasdnka
and Sasidhard are applied to the Moon in that sense ;
whereas mrigdnka signifies ' the deer-marked,' in allusion
to the alternative theory that there is an 4 antelope ' in
the Moon." For the moon-hare see Briffault, op. cit.,
vol. ii, pp. 615-619.

P. 11 On1, line 8. A better reference to St Hildegard's work
would be Physica, vi, 7, 5. (See Migne, Patrologia Latina,
cxcvii, p. 1291.)

Poison detectors. See further the Arthasdstra, I, xx.
Certain plants such as jivanti will keep off snakes. The
parrot, the maina, and the Malabar bird shriek in the
presence of snake poison. The heron swoons in the pres-
ence of poison, the pheasant becomes uncomfortable, the
amorous cuckoo dies, and the eyes of a partridge lose
their natural colour.

144 THE OCEAN OF STORY

Pages 129-132. External Soul. See further Vol. VIII,
p. 106ft8.

P. 181, line 1. For " Freer " read " Frere."

P. 142ft2. For " Freer " read "Frere."

P. 144ft1. Tree of life. See also Wiinsche, "Die Sagen vom
Lebensbaum und Lebenswasser," Ex Oriente Lux, vol. i,
p. 50 et seq.

P. I6O711. Datura poisoning. The late Mr S. M. Edwards
said that in 1921 there were twenty-one cases of datura
poisoning in the United and sixty-eight in the Central
Provinces, and that this form of crime is particularly
prevalent in Ghazipur, Bahraich and Gorakhpur. The
victims in almost every case have been drugged and
robbed at railway stations.

P. 170, line 11. For the "libertine husband" cf. G. Para-
bosco, I Diporti, No. 7.

P. 188ft2. Ceding part of life. See further Vol. VIII, p.
117ft2.

P. 190. Circumambulation. See further Hillebrandt, Mitt,
d. schles. Gesell. f. Volkskunde, xiii-xiv, p. 1 et seq.

P. 211. For a note on the Kashmiri word sdr, collyrium, see
Journ. Roy. As. Soc, April 1926, pp. 507, 508.

P. 212, line 24. For " asand " read " asana."

P. 213, last two lines. Read " . . . De simpl. Medic., ix,
25. ..."

P. 221. The Dohada motif occurs in Grimm's tale of Rapunzel.
See Bolte and Polivka, op. cit., vol. i, p. 97. See also Pro-
fessor Bloomfield's remarks in his Foreword to Vol. VII,
pp. vii, viii. The source of the superstition appears to lie
in the belief in transmigration. The embryo remembers
its sensations in a former life. See J. Jolly, Medicin,
§40.

P. 224. Monkey and crocodile. See Dahnhardt, Natursagen,
iv (1912), p. 1 et seq.

P. 226. Persons pierced without knowing it. See A. Rass-
mann, Die deutsche Heldensage und ihre Heimat, ii (1858),
p. 235 ; B. Kuttner, Jiidische Sagen und Legenden, iii,
1920, p. 14.

P. 231 et seq. Sacred Prostitution. See Briffault, The
Mothers, vol. iii, pp. 210-217.

P. 241, lines 10, 11. Sacred prostitution in Cambodia, a-nan
is not exactly a transcription of the Sanskrit dnanda. In
his review of Hirth and Rockhill's work in T'oung Pao,

ADDENDA AND CORRIGENDA 145

vol. xiii, 1912, p. 467, Pelliot says : " Ananda est en effet
souvent transcrit en chinois, parce que c'est le nom d'un
des plus celebres disciples du Buddha ; mais ce nom est
tou jours ecrit A-nan. On peut presque se hasarder a
predire qu'on ne le trouvera jamais ecrit avec l'ortho-
graphie des a-nan de Tchao Jou-koua, car le nan de
Tchao Jou-koua, au xiiie siecle encore, se prononcait
*nam, au lieu que le nan employe pour transcrire le nom
d' Ananda se terminait tou jours, comme il convenait, par
une nasale dentale et etait alors nan comme aujourd'hui."
In his review of the Ocean he adds : " C'est peut-etre le
Khmer ram ; cf. Bull, de VEcole Frangais d 'extreme
Orient, vol. xviii, 1918, pt. ix, p. 9."

Page 242w3. The mystical number 108. See further Vol. VI,
p. 14m1. It is also used in documents before the name
of the " Maharajas " or high priests of the Bhattia caste.
In any letter or statement containing a reference to one
of these Gosains, the name of the individual invariably
appears as " 108 Devadlnandan Maharaj " or " 108
Gokulnathji Maharaj."

M. Pelliot refers me to Bunyiu Nanjio's Catalogue of
the Chinese Translation of the Buddhist Tripitaka, 1883,
No. 755 (on the 108 beads of the Buddhist rosary) ; and
to W. F. Mayers, " The Buddhist Rosary and its Place in
Chinese Official Costume," Notes and Queries of China
and Japan, vol. iii, pp. 26-28. M. Pelliot is inclined to
see in the number 108 a multiplication of the 12 months
by the 9 planets. I notice another suggestion pencilled
in the copy of .Vol. I of the Ocean in the Roy. As. Soc.
Library — namely, that it is obtained by the following
arrangement of the lucky 3 : {(3+3) (3+3)} 3.

P. 245. Castes of sacred prostitutes. The Sudra caste of
Naikins. One of their chief strongholds is a district in
Goa, which fact may account partly for the suggestion,
current in Bombay some years ago, that these women
are descended from the illicit unions of Portuguese priests
and Hindu women. Mr Edwards states that there is
little evidence to support this view, and that it is more
likely that the women were originally descended from
the courtesans of Vijayanagar, who must have taken
refuge in the villages of the Carnatic and the South
Konkan, when the city was finally destroyed by the
Mohammedans .

VOL. EX. K

146 THE OCEAN OF STORY

Reference should also be made to the Mur(a)li and
Vaghe (or Waghya) orders of mendicants, of whom the
former are girls and the latter are male children dedi-
cated to the god Khandoba, of Jejuri (an incarnation of
Siva), in the Poona district. For further information
see Balfour, Cyclopcedia of India, under " Murli,"
vol. ii, p. 1012 ; and Russell, Tribes and Castes of the
Central Provinces, " Waghya," vol. iv, pp. 603-606.
Page 248, line 5 of text from bottom. For south of Tunga-
bhadra, " read " south of the Turigabhadra."

VOLUME II

P. 2ft1. The title of Webster's play should be spelt
" Dutchess of Malfey."

P. 28, line 21. For " send " read " sent."

P. 32, line 27. For " Youth " read " Truth."

P. 37, line 19. For " as " read " was."

P 46, line 14. For " has " read " hast."

P. 57ft1. Horse. See M. Oldfield Howey, The Horse in
Magic and Myth, 1923.

P. 76ft1. For a large number of " lost wife " and " declaring
presence " variants see Bolte and Polivka, op. cit., vol. ii,
p. 329. Cf. also Coxwell, op. cit., p. 471.

P. 81. Rahu and eclipses. Cf. the monograph of R. Lasch,
" Die Finsternisse in der Mythologie und im religiosen
Brauch der Volker," Arch. f. Rel. Wiss., iii, p. 97.

Lines 13 and 14 from bottom. For "Tsun Tsiu"
read " Ch'un ch'iu." M. Pelliot says that the word che
is always used for "eclipse" in the sense of "to eat."
Since the beginning of the Christian era, however, the
character has been added to " par 1 'addition de la clef
de 1" insecte ' (laquelle clef s'applique aussi aux plus
grands reptiles ; son emploi ici parait avoir pour point de
depart l'idee du monstre-dragon qui cause les eclipses."

P. 103, line 10 from bottom. Eating of human flesh. See
Coxwell, op. cit., p. 246 et seq.

P. 104ft2. For the most recent work on Walpurgis night,
Hallowe'en, etc., see chapter iv, " The Sabbat," of Mon-
tague Summers' History of Witchcraft and Demonology,
London, 1926, pp. 110-172.

Page 107ft1. Overhearing. Sir George Grierson refers me to
R. B. Shaw, "On the Ghalchah Languages (Sarikoli),"

ADDENDA AND CORRIGENDA 147

Journ. As. Soc. Bengal, vol. xlv, pt. i, 1876, which
contains a good example of the motif.

P. 113ft1. Eating human flesh unknowingly. Cf. Cento
Novelle Antiche (Gualteruzzi's edition, No. lxii).

Pp. 117-120. Nudity in magic ritual. See further J. Hecken-
bach, De Nuditate sacra, 1911 ; S. C. Mitra, " On a recent
instance of the use of the nudity-spell for Rain-making
in Northern Bengal," Journ. Anih. Soc. Bombay, vol. -xii,
1924, pp. 919-926 ; R. O. Winstedt, " Notes on Malay
Magic," Journ. Malay Br. Roy. As. Soc, vol. iii, pt. iii,
December 1925, p. 6 ; Briffault, The Mothers, 1927, vol. iii,
pp. 209, 304.

P. 136ft1. Conception through eating fruit, etc. See Brif-
fault, op. cit., vol. ii, pp. 457, 458.

P. 152ft4. Snakes. See further Vol. VII, pp. 233-240.

P. 169. Jewel-lamps. In Kalhana's Rdjatarangini (iv, 15)
we read of "lamps formed of jewels (manidipika)."
Stein (vol. i, p. 121ft15) says a lamp is meant in which
a shining jewel takes the place of a burning wick.

P. 190m1, line 8. The Melusine reference should read "vol. i,
col. 447."

P. 196m1. The Two Brothers. See Bolte and Polivka, op.
cit., vol. i, p. 542.

P. 223ft1. Forbidden chamber. See Bolte and Polivka, op.
cit., vol. i, pp. 20, 409 ; and Coxwell, op. cit., p. 555.

P. 224ft. Gil de Rais and Bluebeard. See Vincent and
Binns, Gilles de Rais, London, 1926, especially the
Bibliography in Appendix VI.

P. 263. Umbrellas — other forms of the Greek equivalent
are o-kiuSiov and o-KiaSio-Kr). See Smith's Dictionary of
Greek and Roman Antiquities, under "umbraculum,
umbrella," which includes the earliest Greek references
from Anacreon, Aristophanes, etc. A woodcut is given
from Millin's Peintures de Vases Antiques, showing the
Greek umbrella in use. The original plate (No. lxx,
vol. ii, p. 113) is well worth looking up. The whole
work is a masterpiece of the engraver's art. See further
Daremberg and Saglio, Diet, des antiquites grecques
et romaines under umbrella " and " umbraculum."
The article in question seems to have been brought to
Greece from the Middle East, like pheasants, peacocks
and peaches, not later than the early part of the fifth
century B.C.

148 THE OCEAN OF STORY

Page 264, line 13. For " eleventh century B.C." read " second

century a.d."
P. 280ft6. For " Bowick " read " Bonwick."
P. 281, line 5. For M Exercito " read " Esercito."
P. 289ft3. Insert " Hebrceischen " before " Uebersetzungen."
P. 289ft4. For " Biblioth." read " Bibliographic"
P. 294ft2. For "Atti, Series IV, . . ." read " Atti delV

Accademia dei Lincei, Serie IV, ..."
P. 800ft1. For "veneris" read "venenis" Omit "2" after

" fol."
P. 302ft1. Cf. Vol. VIII, p. 245. Clusius wrote a resume, not

a translation, of Orta. Markham's work is not a trans-
lation of Clusius, but of the original Coloquios dos simples

of da Orta.
P. 306ft1. Proxies at marriages. See further Briffault, op.

city vol. iii, pp. 223-226. For mechanical defloration of

girls see ditto, p. 319.
P. 307?i2. Snake = phallus. See Eisler, Weltenmantel u.

Himmelszelt, 1910, p. 123 ; and Briffault, op. cit., vol. ii,

pp. 664-669.
P. 308ft2. Syphilis. Add to note : A. F. Chamberlain,

" Disease and Medicine (American)," Hastings' Ency.

Bel. Eth., vol. iv, p. 732.
P. 310ft3. Cf. the story of how the enemies of Francis I of

France encompassed that monarch's death in 1547.

They poisoned his concubine with syphilis germs.

VOLUME III

P. 2ft2. Cf. Hiranandra Shastri, " The Origin and Cult of

Tara," Mem. Arch. Surv. India, No. 20, Calcutta, 1925.
P. 20ft1. Self-mutilation. See Bolte's edition of Pauli's

Schimpf und Ernst, vol. ii, pp. 258, 259.
P. 21, line 13 from bottom. Delete " Orestes."
P. 21. line 5 from bottom. Circumcision, infibulation, ex-
cision. See Briffault, op. cit., vol. iii, pp. 320-333.
P. 28ft1. Faithful John. For references to Grimm, No. 6,

see Bolte and Polivka, op. cit., vol. i, pp. 42-57.
P. 29, line 12. For " Ahichchhatra " read " Ahichchhatra."
P. 40ft1. Mechanical doll. See Coxwell, op. cit., p. 858
Page 52ft. Worms in teeth. Add to note : " See also Codrington,
The Melanesians, Oxford, 1891, p. 193 ; J. Batchelor,
The Ainu and their Folklore, London, 1901, p. 293 ; C. S.

ADDENDA AND CORRIGENDA 149

Myers, "Disease and Medicine (Introductory)," Hastings'
Ency. Rel. Eth., vol. iv, p. 724.

Pp. 56-59. Automata. M. Pelliot refers me to Ganapati
Sastri's edition of Samardnganastitradhdra, thought to
date back to the eleventh century. In the Preface to
vol. i (Gaekwad's Oriental Series, No. xxv, Baroda, 1924)
we are told that chapter xxxi " contains descriptions
of various kinds of machines that are not found in other
Silpa works, such as the elephant-machine, wooden bird-
machine travelling in the sky, wooden vimana machine
flying in the air, doorkeeper-machine, soldier-machine,
etc. See also the Preface to vol. ii (G. O. S., No. xxxii).
See S. Levi, Journ. As., vol. ccviii, 1926, pt. ii, p. 379.
Automatons figure also in the several tales in the Chinese
Tripitaka (see Chavannes, Cinq Cents Conies et Apologues,
vol. ii", p. 12, No. 163 ; vol. iii, pp. 167, 170, 171, No. 427).
Cf. the tale of the Mechanician and 4he Painter in
Schiefner and Ralston's Tibetan Tales, p. 361.

P. 57, line 1. Vitrivius did not write till after Caesar's death,
so is more properly a contemporary of Augustus.

P. 63. Overhearing. Add Coxwell, op. cit., p. 163, and
Bolte and Polivka, op. cit., vol. i, p. 5Snx.

P. 75. " Doctor Knowall " motif. See also Coxwell, op. cit.,
pp. 193 et seq. and 244, 245 ; cf. Wesselski, Mdrchen des
Mittelalters, pp. 242, 243.

P. 76. line 4 from bottom. For " Irubriani " read
"Imbriani."

P. 105w, line 15. For " Cabnoy " read " Carnoy."

P. 118ft1. The Cento Novelle Antiche. The reference to
No. 74 of this collection (occurring again in Vol. V,
p. 13ft1) is to the edition of Borghini, and not to that
of Gualteruzzi. The same applies to No. 68, quoted
in Vol. II, p. 113w. Owing to the importance of this pre-
Boccaccio work, and to the fact that its early history
is uncertain, no excuse will be made for the following
bibliographical notes.

The work in question is thought to have been compiled
by one or more authors at the end of the thirteenth or
first quarter of the fourteenth century. It was edited
by Carlo Gualteruzzi in 1525 (2nd ed., Milano, 1825),
and his hundred tales agree with seven out of the eight
known manuscripts. There is also another edition, with-
out date or place, considered by some to be earlier. A

150 THE OCEAN OF STORY

copy of this is in the British Museum. I have compared
the two copies very carefully and have come to the con-
clusion that the undated one is later than 1525. In the
first place, the " errata " of the dated edition are almost
entirely found corrected in the undated edition, and both
the length of page and^ lack of abbreviated forms would
seem to support this view. (Cf. Brunet, Manuel du
libraire, vol. i, cols. 1736-1738.) Panzer (Annales Typo-
graphic^ vol. i, p. 410) speaks of a 1482 edition, but
nothing is known of it, and it may even have been an
unrecorded version of the Decameron I See Biagi, Le
Novelle Antiche dei Codici Panciatichiano-Palatino, pp.
lx-lxii. With regard to the title of the work, Gualteruzzi
calls it Ciento Novelle Antike, but it was later known as II
Novellino, and thus has occasionally been confused with
Masuccio's work of fifty tales bearing the same name.1

The second editor of the Cento Novelle was Vincenzo
Borghini, who issued his Libro di Novelle et di bel Parlar
Gentile, Florence, in 1572. It contains several fresh tales,
and the order of most of the others is altered. Of the
eight codexes, that known as the Panciatichianus is the
most interesting, as it contains about thirty tales and
proverbs not found either in Gualteruzzi or Borghini.
It was published in 1880 by Biagi, who has included a
most useful bibliography, with notes on the different
MSS. (see p. lx et seq.).

An English translation by Storer has recently (1925)
appeared. Except for tales 57, 58, 80 and 86 it follows
Gualteruzzi's original text.

Page 127, lines 12-15. Amphitryon and Alcmene. See Pau-
sanias' Book V, xviii, 3, and Frazer's note, vol. iii, p. 613.

P. 152, line 6. Momiai, or Momiyai. This word means liter-
ally " extract of mummie " (momiya), and originally
meant this. In India it is properly a kind of bitumen
said to be brought from Persia and elsewhere (momiya
is a Persian word). In Bihar the word is corrupted to
mimiyal. Cf. Grierson, Bihar Peasant Life, § 1158.
"It is said to be extracted from the heads of coolies
who emigrate to the colonies, by hanging them head
downwards and roasting them over a slow fire. The
threat of extracting it from the head of a child is there-
fore an active deterrent."

1 Another collection with a similar title is Sansovino's Cento Novelle.

ADDENDA AND CORRIGENDA 151

Page 161/11, line 7 from bottom. For " Ahmadabad " read
"Ahmadabad."

P. 201 et seq. Magic circle. Cf. the story of Antiochus in
Livy, xlv, 12, for an interesting use of the circle. The
most complete treatment of the circle in classical
religious and magical use is Eitrem, Opferritus und
Voropfer der Griechen und Romer, chapter i, " Der
Rundgang," pp. 6-75. Delete lines 6 and 7 from bottom
on p. 201 (i.e. the references to Bouchet and Major).

P. 205, line 1. For "A. and W. Schott " read ." A. and A.
Schott."

P. 222ft1. See also Coxwell, op. cit, p. 241.

P. 225w2. This is a variant of the " Declaring Presence "
motif. See further Coxwell, op. cit., p. 859.

P. 230ft3. For " viii, 355 " read " viii, 855."

Pp. 236-239. "Magic Obstacles" motif . Sir George Grierson
sends me the following translation of a " magic obstacles "
tale told by the Pashais, a Dard tribe of Laghman in
East Afghanistan. It occurs in its original form in the
Linguistic Survey of India, vol. viii, pt. ii, p. 109 et seq.

" There was a king who had one son and one daughter.
The girl was a cannibal. The brother fled from her, and
settled in another country, where he lived with a woman.
He spent a long time there, and always kept two dogs.
He returned to his father's city and found it desolate [his
sister having eaten up everyone]. Only his sister was
there. She made preparations for eating him, and he
became afraid. She said to him : ' I am going to eat
you.' The brother replied : 4 Good ! Take a sieve and
bring water in it from the river, and come back when you
have sharpened your teeth.' The sister went to the
river, but before she started she put a drum before him
and told him to keep beating it. He caught a rat and
put it on the drum. The rat jumped about [on the
drum] and made it sound, and [while it did so] the boy
ran away. The sister returned, and found her brother
missing. She pursued him. When she began to over-
take him, he dropped a needle which became a mountain.
She climbed this with great difficulty. Again, he threw
down salt. It also became a mountain. She climbed
this with great difficulty. Again, he threw down soap.
It also became a mountain, and she ascended to the top.
The brother then ascended a tree, and she came below

152 THE OCEAN OF STORY

it. Just as she was about to eat her brother, his dogs
arrived. He called to them : ' Eat her in such a way
that not a drop of her blood falls to the ground.'
The dogs immediately tore her to pieces."
Page 247w\ line 1. For "thirteenth" read "twelfth."
Pp. 250-251. " Impossibilities " motif. For the tale of
Pharaoh Nectanebo and Lycerus, King of Babylon, as
related in a Syriac MS. (Cambridge Univ. Col. Add.
2020 = S2) see Conybeare, Harris and Lewis, Story of
Ahikar, pp. 77, 78.

There is an amusing story told in Nasr al-Din (see
Arratoon, Gems of Oriental Wit and Humour, p. 32)
in which Hajja was entertaining guests. He borrowed
a large copper pot from his neighbour. When return-
ing it, he gave one of their own small pots with it. The
neighbour asked what this meant. He replied that their
big copper had given birth while in his house. The
little one was therefore its baby. The neighbour took
both in. On another occasion Hajja called again and
took the large copper pot, but this time he did not
return it. On being asked for it he very much regretted
to have to inform the owner that his pot was dead.
"Dead!" said the owner; "how can you make such a
felonious assertion ! " " Oh," said Hajja, " so you are
incredulous ! How easily you admitted the possibility
of its being able to give birth to a child on the day
when I gave you a smaller copper pot with it ; and now
I tell you she is dead, poor thing ! "

In commenting on my note, M. Pelliot gives some
interesting information on " Impossibility " expressions.
" La ' corne de lievre ' est un terme usuel dans l'lnde,"
he says, " pour designer quelque chose d'impossible, et
l'expression se retrouve dans la litterature chinoise.
Comme en chinois la 'corne de lievre' (Vou-kiao) est
souvent associee au ' poil de tortue,' il parait bien que
ce soit une expression bouddhique venue de l'lnde, car
la * corne de lieVre ' et le ' poil de tortue ' se trouvent, je
crois, pour la premiere fois en chinois dans la traduction
du Parinirvdnasutra. L'expression a dii devenir assez
populaire quisque les Japonais l'ont adoptee, en valeur
purement phonetique, pour ecrire le terme japonais
tokaku, 4 en tout cas,' ' apres tout.' "

Numerous English expressions, such as "making a silk

ADDENDA AND CORRIGENDA 153

purse out of a sow's ear," " squaring the circle," " gather-
ing grapes from thistles," etc., will occur to readers.

Page 268W1. Cutting off heads. See also Hartland, Legend of
Perseus, vol. iii, p. 23 ; various references in Dawkins,
Modern Greek in Asia Minor, pp. 226, 226ft2, 373 ; and
Coxwell, op. cit.y p. 88.

P. 272ft1, line 1. Amys and Amylion. See Chauvin, op.
cit.y viii, p. 195.

P. 280. Letter of Death. Add to note : See Chauvin, op.
cit.y viii, pp. 145-147.

P. 287ft1. For an amusing " loaning wife " tale see Nights,
Burton, vol. vi, p. 150 ; and Chauvin, op. cit.y viii, p. 44.

P. 303 et seq. Sneezing. As a bad omen it is frequent in
Indian folklore. See Waterfield's Lay of Alha, pp. 115,
193, 197-198. The omen generally turns out to be true,
but in one or two cases Rajputs refuse to be frightened
by it and win through. See " The Lay of Brahma's
Marriage," Bull. School Orient. Studies, vol. ii, pt. iv,
p. 587.

P. 321, line 18. Eunuchs. Hijra. The word hijra means both
"eunuch" and "hermaphrodite." In the nineties of
the last century Sir George Grierson was informed on
good authority that there was a colony of hermaphrodites
at Pandua in the Hooghly District of Bengal. People
who have seen and examined them say that the herma-
phroditism seems to have been congenital.

P. 327, line 6. For " Tungabhadra " read " Tungabhadra."

P. 329. Add to Eunuch bibliography : H. R. M. Chamber-
lain, The Eunuch in Society , London, 1927 (privately
printed). See also Briffault, op. cit.y vol. iii, p. 213.

VOLUME IV
P. 10. The Greek quotation should, of course, read : xa^K^a

kucXtjctkovctl 6eoi avope? oe ko/ulu'oiv . . .

P. 14. " Le cheval," says M. Pelliot, " parait en realite avoir
joue un role assez faible dans les anciens sacrifices chinois ;
cf. Granet, Danses et legendes de la Chine ancienne, Paris,
1926, pp. 153-154."

Page 16, lines 27, 28. Woman fertilised by horse. See A. M.
Hocart, " Phallic Offerings to Hathor," Mant October
1926, No. 128, p. 192 (also printed, by some curious

154 THE OCEAN OF STORY

mistake, in Man, July 1927, No. 92, p. 140) ; Briffault,
op. cit., vol. iii, p. 188.

P. 51, line 9 from bottom. For " myiard " read " myriad."

P. 69W1, line 4. For " Engyion " read " Engyon." The
mothers. See C. Hiilsen, in Pauly-Wissowa, Real-
encyclopddie, v, 2568; and Briffault, op. cit., vol. iii,
p. 46 et seq.

P. 8O711, last line. For " 227 " read " 226."

P. 126, line 9. Dasaratha. See N. B. Utgikar, " The Story
of the Dasaratha Jataka and of the Ramayana," Journ.
Roy. As. Soc, Centenary Supplement, October 1924,
pp. 203-211.

P. 129n, line 5. For " Tunghwan " read " Tung-hun-hou."
For trees and flowers of precious materials cf. Artibus
Asioe, 1927, p. 71. [Pelliot.]

P. lUn1, line 5. For " ther ain-cloud " read " the rain-cloud."

P. 185. For the most recent article on Svetadvipa, see
W. E. Clark, " Sakadvipa and Svetadvipa," Journ.
Amtr. Orient. Soc., vol. xxxix, pt. 4, October 1919, pp.
209-242.

P. 229n2, last line. After " 1881 " add " p. 161." The
article was reprinted in the Indian Antiquary, vol. x,
1881, pp. 292, 293.

P. 257, line 20. Opium. " Le suicide par l'opium en Chine
est moderne." [Pelliot.]

P. 272, line 13. Widow-burning. For "p. 153" read "pp.
44, 45." Add to bibliography : Tylor, Primitive Culture,
vol. i, p. 459 et seq. ; F. E. Maning, Old New Zealand,
London, 1863, p. 172 et seq. ; H. Ling Roth, Great
Benin, Halifax, England, 1903, p. 43 ; J. Erskine,
Journal of a Cruise among the Is. of the Western Pacific,
1853, p. 228; Winternitz, "Die Witwenverbrennung,"
Die Frau in den indischen Religionen, S. A. aus dem
Archiv fur Frauenkunde und Eugenik, vol. iii, pp. 55-85,
Leipzig, 1920 ; Winternitz, " Die Witwe im Veda," Wiener
Zeitschrift f. Kunde des Morgenlandes, vol. xxix, p. 172
et seq. ; Zachariae, Kleine Schriften, Bonn and Leipzig,
1920, p. 33 et seq.

The satl stones in the Bombay Presidency have been
recently described by G. V. Acharya, Proc. Third Oriental
Conference, Madras, 1925, p. 237 et seq. The latest
article on satl I have seen is E. Thompson, " The Sup-
pression of Suttee in Native States," Edinburgh Review,

ADDENDA AND CORRIGENDA 155

April 1927, pp. 274-286. He is shortly issuing a work
on the whole subject.
Page 292. To the Nala bibliography add : Liebich, Sanskrit-
Lesebuch, Leipzig, 1905 (containing the Nalopdkhydna
with Riickert's translation) ; Fritze, Nal und Damajanti,
metrische Uebersetzung, Berlin, 1910; Caland, Savitri und
Nala, Utrecht, 1917 ; Winternitz, Geschichte der indischen
Litteratur, vol. i, p. 327 ; S. Levi, La Legende de Nala et
Damayanti, " Les Classiques de l'Orient," Paris, 1920 ;
A. F. Herold, Nala et Damayanti, Paris, 1923; Dumont,
P. E., Histoire de Nala, Bruxelles, 1923 ; and N. M.
Penzer, Nala and Damayanti, London, 1926.

VOLUME V

P. llw1. Gold-spitting. Add to note : For a similar trick
played by the courtesan see Bolte and Polivka, op. cit.,
vol. iii, p. 3 et seq. ; Aarne, Vergleichende Mdrchenfor-
schung, p. 83 et seq. ; and cf. Krohn, Anzeiger der Finnisch-
Ugrischen Forschungen, p. 4 et seq. See further the note
on " gold-spitting " by Professor Halliday on pp. 164, 165
of this volume.

P. 66, line 9 from bottom. " Where mice nibble iron."
For classical references see Knox — Headlam, The
Mimes of Herodas, iii, 76, p. 153 ; and Weinrich's note
on Seneca, Apocolocyntosis.

Professor Halliday informs me that in Greek and
Roman usage the proverb usually means a country so
poor that mice have to gnaw iron in desperation [cf. our
"poor as a church mouse"]. It means the "land of
nowhere " only secondarily and less usually.

P. SOn2. Faithless wife. Add to note : Chauvin, op. cit.t
viii, p. 120.

P. 117. The servant who looked after the door. I find
this in the Persian (?) collection of " fool " stories,
Mutdyabdt i Mulld Nasr al-Din (a.h. 1305). See
N. Arratoon, Gems of Oriental Wit and Humour . . . of
Molla Nasraddin, Calcutta, 1894, p. 15.

P. 122ft.1 The woman with a hundred lovers. Add] to
note: See further Wesselski, Mdrchen des Mittelaliers,
pp. 185-187. #*

P. 132n.2 Imaginary debt and payment. Very similar to
the Japanese story about the smell of fried eels is an

156 THE OCEAN OF STORY

amusing tale in the Cento Novelle Antiche (Gualteruzzi,
No. ix). Here a poor Saracen holds a loaf over the pot
of a cook, thus letting the savoury steam soak into it.
The cook demands payment, and finally the case is sub-
mitted to the " wise men " of the country. It is decided
that as the cook takes money for the food he sells, he
must in this case, where he has sold only steam, be
content with the sound of money as payment.

Page 15Sn. Grateful animals. Add to note : See also Coxwell,
op. cit., pp. 259, 260.

P. 166. Pretending to be dead. In the Persian collection of
Nasr Al-Din are two stories not merely of pretending,
but actually of believing that death had occurred. In
the first (Arratoon's translation, p. 35), Hajja's death is
foretold when his donkey should neigh three times.
When this happened he concluded he must be dead, and
insisted on being conveyed to the cemetery. The
" mourners," however, lost their way, whereupon Hajja
raised himself from the bier and, pointing in a certain
direction, exclaimed : " That was the way I always went
to the cemetery when I was alive."

The second tale (Arratoon, p. 47) relates how Hajja
once asked his wife what were the signs of death. She
replied that when a man's body and hands were cold he
was dead. One very cold day, while ascending a hill with
his donkey, he chanced to feel his hands and then his
body. Both were cold, so he concluded that he must
be dead. Accordingly he lay down on the hill. Mean-
while a number of wolves approached his donkey and
tore it into pieces. Hajja cried out : " Oh, ye wolves,
eat the donkey, for the owner is dead ; if I was alive
be sure I would have made it hot for you ! "

P. 168. " Story of the Fools and the Bull of Siva." Cf. the
story in the Linguistic Survey of India, vol. v, pt. ii, p. 161
et seq. The animal here is not a bull, but an elephant.

P. 186. " Story of the Rogue who managed to acquire Wealth
by speaking to the King." A comical repetition of the
above was actually witnessed by Sir George Grierson
in India. He describes the incident as follows :

"In a certain district there was a planter — a most
popular man, but so hard up that he had exhausted all
his credit, and the Indian bankers refused to advance
him money necessary for his outlay. It chanced that at

ADDENDA AND CORRIGENDA 157

this time the Lieutenant-Governor of Bengal was making
an official visit to the headquarters of the district, and
was arriving by special train. The planter, whom we
may call 4 X,' met the train at a watering-station some
twenty miles from the terminus, and asked the aide-de-
camp for permission to travel by it, as he was in a hurry.
The aide-de-camp welcomed him, and gave him the lift.
At the terminus * X ' issued from the train in the
midst of the Lieutenant-Governor's staff, the observed
of all observers — there being, of course, an assembly of
notables (including the chief bankers) to welcome the
Lieutenant-Governor .

" It was said that, after this, 4X ' enjoyed a temporary
almost unlimited credit in the local money market. I
saw the arrival of 4 X ' with my own eyes, and heard the
amused and admiring talk of his fellow -planters."

Page 193. Note on Nail-marks and Tooth-bites. For a refer-
ence to amorous scratches see the description of the
svayamvara in Kalidasa's Raghuvamsa, vi, 17.

P. 194, line 33. For " Dasanchachhedya " read " Dasanach-
hedya."

P. 218 et seq. The Burzoe legend. Sir Denison Ross has
now added to his authoritative Foreword to Vol. V by
a note in Journ. Roy. As. Soc., July 1926, pp. 503-505,
and an article in Bull. School Oriental Studies, vol. iv,
pt. 3, 1927, pp. 441-472, entitled " An Arabic and a
Persian Metrical Version of Burzoe 's Autobiography
from ' Kalila and Dimna.' " The Persian version is
by Qani'i, of which a unique MS. is preserved in the
British Museum, and the other MS. is by Naqqash, of
which only two copies are known to exist. Owing,
therefore, to their great scarcity, their reproduction
with notes forms an important addition to Panchatantra
research. See Pelliot's remarks in T'oung Pao, vol. xxv,
1927, p. 136.

P. 255 et seq. The classical versions of the story of Rhampsi-
nitus. Professor Halliday tells me that it is almost
certain that the tale dates back to the Telegonia of
Eugammon of Cyrene, the last of the cyclic poets. He
mentions the gift of a bowl ornamented with scenes
from the history of Agamedes and Augeas. No other
story is known which would correspond to the drawings.
If this is accepted, the tale must have been known to

158 THE OCEAN OF STORY

the Greeks before the time of Herodotus. This does not
affect my contention that it is of Egyptian origin. On
the contrary, if anything, it supports the view, for even
Eugammon is " Eugammon of Cyrene."

See further Pauly-Wissowa, Realencyclopadie, under
"Agamedes."

As regards analogues of the story, I have received two
versions. As the first is unpublished, I give the resume of
it as sent me by Colonel Lorimer (via Sir George Grierson).
It is from Gilgit, an outlying province in the extreme
north-west of India, and is in the Shina language.

A father and a son, expert thieves, made a hole in the
wall of the King's Treasury, by quite ordinary means,
and carried off all the King's treasures. They returned
again to search for more loot. The father entered the
Treasury, while the son remained outside. The father
knocked down some pots, and so woke up the guards, who
seized him. He tried to escape by the hole, and a tug-of-
war followed, the guards pulling him inwards by the legs,
and the son pulling him outwards by the head. Finding
he could not get him out, the son cut off the father's head
and went off with it. In due course the King had the de-
capitated body hung up to act as a trap for its mourning
relatives.

After that the detail is different. The mother succeeds
in relieving her feelings with impunity in the presence of
the corpse by dropping and breaking a gourd of milk
as she passes it, and ostensibly weeping over the lost
contents.

Then follow several episodes in which the thief soon
gets the better of his would-be captors. There is a lot
about the flesh of a camel he killed and an old woman.
This also appears in a Bakhtiari story, in which also
there is a dead hand (possibly arm), corresponding to
Herodotus' dead arm.

In the Shina story the thief further wins the respect
and enthusiastic approval of the king by dealing very
adequately with another king who had insulted him,
the thief's king, by refusing him his daughter as wife for
his son, on the grounds of his inability to deal with the
thieves in his kingdom. The thief not only secures the
foreign king's daughter for his king's son, but also her
sister for himself. In recognition of his ability in deal-

ADDENDA AND CORRIGENDA 159

ing with foreign affairs his king makes him "King for
External Affairs," retaining to himself only the control
of " Internal Affairs."

" And so they continued to live happily, eating and
drinking."

The other variant has been sent me by Professor T. F.
Crane. It is to be found on p. 73 of C. C. Jones' Negro
Myths from the Georgia Coast, Boston and New York, 1888.
It is entitled " Brother Lion, Brother Rabbit, Brother
Fox, and Brother Raccoon." It contains practically all
the incidents of the Rhampsinitus story. The first few
sentences, as transliterated from the negro vernacular
by Professor Crane, will be sufficient to show its amusing
style:

44 Brother Lion, he keeps a bank. In that bank he has
chickens, and hogs and sheep. Brother Fox is married
to Brother Coon's daughter. Brother Fox's father-in-
law is a rogue. Brother Coon and Brother Rabbit make
a plan to rob Brother Lion's bank, and they used to take
things out of it every now and then, and nobody can find
out who does the stealing. Brother Fox, Brother Rabbit
and Brother Coon, they were fast friends and kept con-
stant company. Brother Rabbit tells Brother Lion that
he knows the man who robs his bank, but he don't want
to tell his name, and he advises Brother Lion to set a steel
trap to catch the thief. Brother Lion does as he says,
and the next night, when Brother Coon, Brother Fox
and Brother Rabbit went to rob the bank again, Brother
Coon walked on the trap and it caught him by the foot.
The thing broke Brother Coon's leg, and it hurt him very
badly, but he was afraid to holler, because if he did holler,
he knew that Brother Lion was going to run there and
kill him. So he lay down and moaned, and begged his
friends to help him. Brother Fox and Brother Rabbit,
they study over the thing, and they make up their minds
if Brother Lion finds Brother Coon in the trap, he is
going to kill not only Brother Coon, but will send and
kill all the family. Then they conclude that the best
thing to do is that Brother Fox, who is his son-in-law,
must take a sword and chop Brother Coon's head off
and bury it, and that he skin Brother Coon and bury
his hide and his clothes, and leave Brother Coon naked
in the trap, so nobody can tell who was caught. ..."

160 THE OCEAN OF STORY

Page 284. M. Pelliot says that a large portion of the Ka-gyur
had been translated by the beginning of the eleventh
century. He refers me to a Chinese version which was
translated at the end of the third century (J;he exact
date is uncertain). For this see E. Huber "Etudes de
Litterature Bouddhique," Bull, de Vllcole Frangaise
d' extreme-orient, vol. iv, 1904, pp. 698-726 (701-707), and
Chavannes, Cinq cents contes et apologues, vol. ii, pp. 380-388,
and vol. iii, p. 146.

VOLUME VI

P. xxiii. Preface, line 9. For " sixteen (really fifteen) " read
" seventeen (really sixteen)."

P. 61, lines 2 and 3. The word talisman. In Folk-Lore, vol.
xxxv, 1924, p. 230, Professor Dawkins points out that
certain magical figures found in Thrace practically corre-
spond to what we mean by talisman, and that the words
used for them is reXea/ma from reAw, which, in the sense
employed, means " to enchant." He considers it prob-
able that both the English talisman and the Arabic tilsam
are independent borrowings from the Greek. This would
explain the final n, as the mediaeval Greeks pronounced
reXecr/uLa as TeXear/mav. There appears to be no Semitic
derivation for the Arabic word — a fact that supports the
Greek origin.

P. 118, line 9 from bottom. Feet turned wrong way. This
is quite a common feature in Indian folklore. See
Grierson, Bihar Peasant Life (1st ed.), p. 408, where
the kichin (a kind of lamia) has feet back to front.
In this way the wise can recognise her. Some years
ago Whitley Stokes told Sir George Grierson of an Irish
legend, that when the devil wanted to say his prayers,
he was unable to do so, because his knees bent the
wrong way (backwards instead of forwards).

P. 147, last line. For " ofnight " read " of night."

P. 150n, line 7. The reference to Henderson's Folk-Lore of
the Northern Counties is to the 1879 edition. The
corresponding page to the first edition is 19.

P. 150n\ line 2. For " Aapaai " read " Aa/wof."

P. 166 (also p. 240). Fruit containing jewels or money. Cf.
Cento Novelle Antiche (Gualteruzzi), No. lxxix.

P. 191, line 12. Sudraka. See Keith, Sanskrit Drama, pp.
128, 129.

ADDENDA AND CORRIGENDA 161

Page 231. Frame-story. Reference should be made to J.
Przyluski, "Le Prologue- Cadre des Mille et une Nuits,"
Journal Asiatique, 1924, pp. 101-137.
P. 241, line 16. The Chauvin reference should read " . . . v,

pp. 144, 145."
P. 242nx. For " vol. lxxiv, Leipzig, 1920 " read " vol.
lxxv, Leipzig, 1921." Francke has now published a
further article on the Tibetan version of the Vetala tales :
" Zur tibetischen Vetalapancavims'atika (Siddhikur),"
Zeitschr. d. d. morgen. GeselL, Neue Folge, Band II,
Leipzig, 1923, pp. 239-254.

P. 264, line 2. For " No. 2 of Jiilg " read " No. 1 of Julg."

P. 264, line 3. For " No. 4 of Coxwell " read "No. 3 of
Coxwell."

P. 269, line 13. For " there s little in comimon " read " there
is little in common."

P. 273, last line. The sabda-bhedi arrow, which strikes what
is heard, is a familiar feature in Hindu legend. In the
Alha cycle of folk-epics, Prithiraj of Delhi has such an
arrow, and with it hits the sword-wound of a severely
wounded ally, so as to sew up the wound, and enable
the ally to go on fighting.

P. 282w6. Sirens. Add to note : V. Berard, Les Pheniciens
et VOdyssee, vol. ii, p. 333 et seq. ; and Daremberg and
Saglio, Dictionnaire des Antiquites grecques et romains,
vol. iv, pt. 2, pp. 1353-1355.

P. 283w4. For " Brumond " read " Brumund."

P. 286. The tale from the Nights is found also in the Cento
Novelle Antiche (No. iii of Gualteruzzi's edition), where
the boring-worm, horse and baker incidents are all
repeated.

P. 287. For another variant of the " lost-camel " story see
Linguistic Survey of India, vol. viii, pt. i, p. 278.

P. 287n2, line 3. For " translations " read " translation."

P. 290w3. For " Sunblad " read " Sundblad."

P. 291w4. For " 1915 " read " 1885."

P. 293. Add to the Andersen bibliography : L. M. Shortt,
" H. C. Andersen and Fairyland," Fortnightly Review,
July-December 1925, pp. 190-201 ; Clausen and Marr,
" King, Queen and Knave," Argosy, vol. i, December
1926, pp. 145, 146.

VOL. IX.

162 THE OCEAN OF STORY

VOLUME VII

Page xxix. Change of sex. To the list by Dr W. N. Brown
must now be added, ''Change of Sex as a Hindu Story
Motif" Jonrn. Amer. Orient. Soc, vol. xlvii, 1927, No. 1,
{>]). 3-24. See further below.

P. 92??1, line 4. Delete the " s " in " Egypts."

P. 103, line 17. "And kissed her." I believe I am correct
in saying that this is the only time kissing is mentioned
in the whole of the Ocean of Story. This seems extra-
ordinary, especially when we remember the large number
of love scenes introduced into the work, and the existence
(from about a. p. 250) of Vatsyayana's Kama Sutra, in
which a complete chapter (iii) is devoted to the subject.
The explanation must lie in the fact that kissing, as we
understand it, was unknown in the Vedas and only rarely
indulged in during the period assigned to the Maha-
bhdrata (cf. Book III, chapter cxii, 12). Moreover, the
" sniff-kiss " of the Vedas still exists in parts of India,
as it also does among many Mongol and semi-civilised
peoples. The kiss can be described as very rare among
all the lower races, the typical primitive kiss consisting
of the contact of the nose and cheek followed by inhala-
tion. The mouth kiss would certainly be unknown in
the time of Udayana and Naravahanadatta. See further
Hopkins, ' The Sniff-Kiss in Ancient India," Journ.
Amer. Orient. Soc., vol. xxviii, 1907, pp. 120-134 ; and
Crawley, " Kissing," Hastings' Ency. Rel. Eth., vol. vii,
pp. 739-744.

P. 107. Sandalwood. Among the earliest mediaeval refer-
ences may be mentioned that by the Chinese writer,
Chau Ju-Kua. See Ilirth and RockhiU's edition of his
Chu-fan-chi, pp. 208, 209.

P. 126n2, lines 3 and 4. The Mclusine reference should read
" vol. i, col. 447."

P. 191//1. The name of and reference to Professor Bloomfield's
article should be corrected as follows : " On Recurring
Psychic Motifs in Hindu Fiction . . .," Journ. Amer.
Orient. Soc., vol. xxxvi, pp. 57, 58.

P. 222 et seq. Change of Sex. As mentioned above, Dr
W. N. Brown has recently issued an article on change
of sex in Hindu fiction. Although the author was kind
enough to send me proofs in advance for use in the Oceant

ADDENDA AND CORRIGENDA 163

my volume was already in print. The article in question
is of great importance and, among many other things,
clearly shows that stories of sex-changing water are quite
common in folk-tales (at any rate in Hindu fiction).
Thus my remark at the bottom of p. 225 requires
qualification.

Dr Brown deals first with bathing in enchanted water,
dividing the first section into (a) Change of man into
woman — unexpected, unwelcome ; (b) Change of woman
into man — unexpected, welcome. The next sections
deal respectively with change of sex as a curse or blessing ;
exchanging sex with a Yaksha ; change brought about
by magic objects and charms ; resulting from righteous-
ness or wickedness ; and finally the origin of the notion
of sex change.

Page 231. Pretended change of sex. See W. Crooke, "Simu-
lated Change of Sex to Baffle the Evil Eye," Folk-Lore,
vol. xxiv, p. 385 ; also Stein and Grierson, Hatirri's Tales,
pp. 29, 30. Sir George Grierson tells me that in the
Radhavallabhi sect the men pretend to be Radha, and
dress in women's clothes, even pretending to be disabled
once a month like women.

P. 237, last line. This work will not be issued until early in
1928.

P. 250 et seq. Self-sacrifice. Dr W. N. Brown sends me the
following additional references : Hitopadesa (Narayana's
version), iii, 7; Benfey, Pantschatantra, i, 414; Dracott,
Simla Village Tales, p. 194 ; Pantalu, Folklore of the
Telugus (3rd ed.), p. 51.

He would differentiate the versions : (1) The hero
kills his son, and others of his family also die (Vetdla-
pahchavirhsati, Hitopadesa) ; (2) No blood is shed
(Tuti-ndmah, Dracott, Pantalu). The stories are related
genetically within the two groups — that is, the modern
Indian oral tales are derived from the Persian, not the
Sanskrit.

P. 252, line 11. The boy's laugh. The Forty Vazirs. The
same story, with minor variations, will be found in the
Linguistic Survey of India, vol. viii, pt. 1, p. 367.

P. 270. Bibliography of the Vetdlapanchavimsati. After
44 Gothenburg, 1901 " add Deromps, M., Les vingt-cinq
reciis du mauvais genie traduits de Vhindi. Paris, 1912.

164 THE OCEAN OF STORY

VOLUME VIII

Page 19, line 21. "Festival . . . called Pongol." See the
excellent description of this festival in Dubois, Hindu
Manners, Customs and Ceremonies, 3rd ed., Oxford, 1906,
p. 571 et seq.
P. 58w\ " Bathing - dress dripping with moisture." Sir
George Grierson sends me a possible explanation of
hrita-vastrd ' ardra-vasand. He suggests that vastra
means the outer garment, and vasana the under garment,
the vetement oVintimite. In Bengal women bathe with
their under (and only) garment on them. This is very
thin, and they walk home unconcernedly, almost nude,
owing to the transparent wet clothes clinging to their
limbs. Up-country Hindus are horrified at this, and
there is a proverb about the Bengali woman " saying
' hethd hethd ' when she means * hither.' Modestly cover-
ing her face, and yet displaying her vulva ; deserting
her husband, and hastening to a lover — so shines in her
glory the fair one of the noble Bangali."

The swan-maiden puts her outer garment (her vastra)
of feathers on the bank, but bathes in her vasana, which
is, of course, wet when she comes out of the water. She
is thus ardra-vasand. As her outer garment of feathers
has been taken away, she is also hrita-vastrd.
P. 59n3. Gold-spitting. I am indebted to Professor Halliday
for the following note : —

The magical property of dropping or spitting gold,
jewels (vel sim), habitually occurs in three groups of
stories :

(/) In stories related to Frau Holle (Grimm, No. 24), in
which two sisters meet with their respective deserts ; it
is frequently part of the good girl's reward that whenever
she opens her mouth to speak, gold and jewels drop out
of it, and part of the bad girl's punishment that toads or
other vermin drop similarly from her lips. Gold-spitting
of this type is irrelevant here.

(Ha) A donkey or other animal, which vomits or
excretes gold, is frequently one of the Magical Articles
acquired by the hero and stolen by the villain in variants
of Grimm, No. 54 (see Bolte and Polivka, op. cit., vol. i,
p. 470 et seq.).

(lib) A fictitious gold-dropping donkey figures in what

ADDENDA AND CORRIGENDA 165

is really a burlesque form of Ila, the Sham Magical
Articles, with which the clever hero dupes his adversaries
(see Bolte and Polivka, op. cit., vol. ii, pp. 1-18). Con-
nected with this group, though it is more exactly to be
classed as belonging to one of the hybrid forms men-
tioned below, is the fraudulent gold-spitting monkey
of Vol. V, p. 11. For other examples where the gold-
producing animal is * salted ' by being given gold pieces
to eat, see Clouston, Popular Tales and Fictions, vol. ii,
p. 274 ; Campbell, Popular Tales of the West Highlands,
vol. ii, p. 247 ; Cosquin, Contes Populaires de Lorraine,
vol. i, p. 108 ; Journal of the Gypsy Lore Society, 3rd
series, vol. iv, p. 99 ; cf. also Dozon, Contes AWanais,
No. 23, p. 177.

(///) In variants of Grimm, Nos. 60 and 85 (see Bolte
and Polivka, op. cit., vol. i, p. 542 ; vol. iii, p. 3), the hero
acquires the gift of spitting gold, or, a somewhat more
comfortable peculiarity, of finding gold beneath his
pillow every morning, through having eaten part of a
magical bird.

There is an obvious similarity between II and III, for it
is usual in III for the hero to be deceived by a courtesan,
who tricks him into betraying his secret, causes him to
vomit the bird's heart (vel sim), and eats it herself. The
hero ultimately is revenged by the discovery of a magic
plant, by means of which he turns her into a donkey,
or makes her nose grow indefinitely. In practice there
are a good many hybrid versions intermediate between
II and III. For example, the donkeyfying cabbage
is often attached to form the denouement of stories of
type Ila in place of the magic club, in versions in which
the villain is not an innkeeper but a courtesan. It is
to this group, represented by Ila and 77/ and their
intermediate hybrids, that our gold-spitting hero belongs.
Page lllw3. The modesty of elephants. Professor Halliday
refers me to a passage in JElian, De Natura Animalium,
i, 28:

" ■yiTcuK&s wpaias toSc rh £wov rj-rraTcu, kcu
Trapakverai S< tou dvfwv tKKax^tofois KaXAo?,"

In viii, 17, the chastity of the elephant is lauded,
and mention is made of its great modesty in sexual
matters. The mediaeval collection known as Physiologus,

166 THE OCEAN OF STORY

or the Bestiary, relied on ^lian for much of its in-
formation. Being Christian allegories, the moral side
of animals would be especially emphasised. Thus, in the
Gesta Romanorum we should not be surprised to find
an allusion to its modesty rather than its partiality
to beauty.
Pages 227, 228. Swan-maiclens. In tracing the swan-maiden
story from India, I made no mention of Assam. Sir
George Grierson refers me to a version current among
the Angami Nagas of the Assam Hills. It appears in
the Linguistic Survey of India, vol. iii, pt. ii (Bodo, Naga
and Kachin Groups), p. 219 et seq., under the title of
" How Jesu got a Goddess for his Wife." Here the
article stolen is not a garment, but a head-band or rope
used for carrying loads.

I have just noticed a much more developed and ex-
tremely interesting variant in Stack's The Mikirs, pp. 55-
70. It is entitled " Story of Haratar Kunwa." After
successfully evading death at the hands of his jealous
brothers, Harata goes to live with his poor old grand-
mother. He discovers the bathing-pool of six beautiful
maidens, who doff their clothes, bathe, and then fly
away. After various stratagems Harata substitutes
another petticoat (apini) for that discarded by the
youngest, and only unmarried one, of the sisters. On
donning it, she discovers her inability to fly. Thus the
marriage takes place, but Harata is warned not to
make her cook, and never to touch her hand or foot.
This taboo incident is curious, as nothing comes of it
in the story at all. The sequel to it must have been
forgotten in transit. A son is born, and the family
return to Harata 's father and brothers. The beautiful
bride is admired by everyone, but points out that if
she had her own petticoat she would be much more
lovely still.1 In the absence of Harata, his father
procures it — with the usual result. By holding on to
the tail of a celestial elephant,2 he arrives at the land of
his beloved. He employs the " Declaring Presence "
motif 3 by means of his ring and enters into the presence

1 Cf. the Gypsy story, Vol. VIII, p. 219.

2 Cf. the way Saktideva reaches the City of Gold (Vol. II, p. 219), and
the bull of Siva in Vol. V, p. 168.

3 See Vol. II, p. 76nl.

ADDENDA AND CORRIGENDA 167

of the whole Court, accompanied by his little son. The
child runs to its mother, and in disgust the King of the
Winds, who was about to marry the Princess, leaves
the happy couple together. This is only a very brief
resume of the story, but it is an important variant and
should not be overlooked.
Page 254>n3. For " Aupapdtckd " read " Aupapdtikd."
P. 270, line 9 from foot. For " Sheering " read " Sherring."
P. 272 et seq. Betel used as a challenge. Sir George Grierson
tells me that a bird (used in the sense of a single betel-
roll) flung down on the ground is used as a kind of chal-
lenge. When a king wants some difficult or dangerous
feat performed, he throws down in open court a bird of
pan. Whereupon the bravest of his knights picks it up
and at once sets out on his adventures.

Readers will at once think of the well-known custom of
flinging down a glove as a challenge. Here the use was
symbolical. A " gage " originally signified only a pledge,
and an article of value was actually deposited. In time
the folded glove became the most handy symbol of such
a bond, and its tendering was the accepted method of
waging one's law. In the " wagers of battle " the glove
was thrown on the ground as a challenge, which action
was required by the " appellee " in answer to the charge
of the appellant."

At English coronations, up to the time of George IV,
the " king's champion " challenged anyone to dispute his
master's right to the throne by picking up the gauntlet
flung down three times in succession.

It would seem that the betel chew also is symbolical,

and denotes friendship, duty, trust and devotion.

The throwing of it would be a challenge by which the

champion's self-assertion would be put to the test.

P. 318W1, line 13. Read " Balfour's Cyclopcedia of India,

3rd ed., 1885. . . ."
P. 314 et seq. Betel-chewing (Solomon Islands). See also
W. G. Ivens, Melanesians of the South-east Solomon
Islands, Ldn., 1927. Pp. 285-289.

BIBLIOGRAPHY

BIBLIOGRAPHY

THE following Bibliography, or, more correctly, Biblio-
graphical Index, is arranged alphabetically under
authors, whether the work in question be a series of
volumes, a work in a single volume, an article in a periodical,
or a short note of a few lines in some scientific journal.

Although it lays no claim to perfection, it is not a mere
" list of books quoted," but is intended to be of individual use
to the student of folk-lore and " storiology."

With this view in mind, I have added brief notes where
I have considered them necessary. Wherever possible, I
have personally examined every title-page, and have not
copied the (often incorrect) references of other people. Thus
I have discovered numerous mistakes in references quoted in
the notes and Appendixes of the Ocean, all of which have now
been corrected, and, in many cases, annotated. In considera-
tion of the enormous amount of work this has entailed, I may
perhaps be permitted to say that I consider this Bibliography
by far the most difficult and laborious part of my whole
work.

Some references have taken weeks to track down, owing
to incorrect data, or to the fact that what was taken to be a
" work " turned out to be an article in, say, some Slavonic
periodical unrecorded at the British Museum or University
libraries.

I have departed from the usually accepted method of
merely giving details of each work itself by stating in addition
exactly where the work in question is quoted in the Ocean.
Surely the student wants to know in what connection an
author has been cited, even if an actual quotation is not
given. I consider that a Bibliography thus arranged serves
a double purpose.

That such a method is not superfluous I know from per-
sonal experience, and am merely at pains to spare my readers
171

172 THE OCEAN OF STORY

and fellow-students a similar experience.1 A glance at the
Bibliography will show that the name of a work appears in
italics, while that of an article is placed between inverted
commas. References to the Ocean are in brackets thus :
[I, 263711 ; II, 41n ; VIII, 81].

Any explanatory notes follow in smaller type. In con-
clusion I would mention that the Bibliography can be used
in conjunction with the Index (see Vol. X of the Ocean).
The names of authors quoted appear in the Bibliography
only, but their works and subjects referred to in them will
be found indexed and cross-indexed in Vol. X.

[Anonymous.] " Betel-nut Chewing." The Leisure Hour.

Part 209. No. 907. Ldn. 15th May 1869. Pp. 311, 312.

[VIII, Sl8nK]
[Anonymous.] " The Betel Tree." Notes and Queries on

China and Japan. Edited by N. B. Dennys. Vol. ii. Jan.

to Dec. 1868. Sept. 1868. Pp. 136-139. [VIII, 289n2.]

This periodical seems to have been discontinued after the third volume,
which ended in Dec. 1869-

[Anonymous.] " Imports and Exports of Canton." Chinese
Repository. Vol. ii. Canton. 1834. Pp. 447-472. [VIII,
SOSn3.]

The above periodical was completed in 20 vols. Canton. 1832-1851.

[Anonymous.] Ophiolatreia. An Account of the Rites and
Mysteries connected with the Origin, Rise and Development
of Serpent Worship. . . . Ldn. 1889. [Ill, 142w\]

[Anonymous.] " Sandal- wood." The Practical Magazine :
An Illustrated Cyclopaedia of Industrial Information, Inven-
tions and Improvements, collected from Foreign and British
Sources. Vol. vii. No. 36. New Series. Ldn. Dec. 1877.
Pp. 373, 374. [VII, 107.]

1 Thus I naturally was anxious to know in what connection Frazer had quoted
Tawney. No cross-references were given, but I found the work mentioned under
" Katha Sarit Sagara." I then had to go through each volume of the Golden
Bough to discover where it was mentioned, and in what connection it was quoted.
I have strictly avoided what appear to me useless references such as Frazer uses
in his Bibliography — e.g. Times, The — weekly edition ; Daily Graphic, The ;
Athenaeum, The, etc., without any intimation whatsoever as to date, name of
article or author !

BIBLIOGRAPHY 173

[Anonymous.] "Shell-Money." Ency. Brit. 11th edit. 1911.

Vol. xxiv. P. 833. [IX, 17w2.]
[Anonymous.] " The True Sandalwood of India." Scientific

American. The Weekly Journal of Practical Information.

Vol. cviii. No. 25. New York. 21st June 1913. P. 558.

[VII, 107.]
Aarne, A. Vergleichende Mdrchenforschungen. Suomalais-

Ugrilaisen Seuran Toimituksia, xxv. (Memoirs de la Societe

Finno-Ougrienne, xxv.) Helsingfors. 1908. [IX, 141, 143,

155.]
Aarne, A. Verzeichnis der Marchentypen. Helsingfors. 1910.

FF Communications 3. [V, 281.]
Aarne, A. Finnische Marchenvarianten, Verzeichnis der his

1908 gesammelten Aufzeichnungen. Hamina. 1911. FF

Communications 5. [V, 281.]
Abano, Pietro d' (Petrus de Apono, Aponensis). Libellus

(or Tractatus) de venenis. [II, 300, 300m1.]

This work was published alone, and also with his Concitiator, at various dates
in fifteenth and sixteenth centuries. For full details of all Peter of Abano 's
works, see Lynn Thorndike, History of Magic, vol. ii, 1923, pp. 917-926.

Abbott, G. F. Macedonian Folklore. Cambridge. 1903.

[II, 70w2 ; III, 310, 310n4.]
'Abd Allah ibn Ahmad. See under Sontheimer, J. von.
1Abdu-r Razzaq ('Abd ul-Razzaq, or Abd-er Razzak).

See under Elliot, H. M., and Major, R. H.
Aberg, G. A. Nyldndska Folksagor. Helsingfors. 1887.

[V, 281.]
Abu'l-Fadl 'Allami (Abul Fazl Allami). See under

Blochmann, H.
Acarya, Merutunga. See under Tawney, C. H., Prabandha-

cintamani.
Acharya, G. V. " Memorial Stones in the Bombay Presi-
dency." Proceedings and Transactions of the Third Oriental

Conference. (22nd-24th Dec. 1924.) Madras. 1925. Pp.

237-241. [IX, 154.]
Acharya, Madhava. See under Cowell, E. B., and Gough,

A. E.
Achilles, Tatius. The Loves of Clitopho and Leucippe.

[V, 200w2 ; VIII, 156w\]
Adam of Cobs am. See under Furnivall, F. J.
Ad-Damiri. See under Jayakar, A. S. G.
^lian (i.e. Claudius ^lianus). Varia Historia. [VI, 294W1 ;

IX, 47n3.] De Natura Animalium. [Ill, 116w ; VI, 282n5 ;

IX, 165.]

174 THE OCEAN OF STORY

Aeschines. De male ob. legatione (or more usually De male
gesta legatione, or De falsa legatione). [II, 278.]

The above is the Latin title of irepl rrjs HapaTrpeo-ftetas, the speech delivered
by Demosthenes, which was answered by Aeschines in a speech of the same
title.

uEsop. Fables. [I, 20ft, 169 ; V, 43ft2.] See further under

Jacobs, Joseph.
Afanasjev, A. N. Narodnya russkija skazki. 8 vols. Moscow.

1855-1863. [II, 202ft1.]
Afanasjev, A. N. Narodnya russkija skazki. 3rd edit, by

A. E. Gruzinskij. 2 vols. Moscow. 1897. [VIII, 227ft5.]
A. F. F. and B. F. R. See under [Burton, R. F., and Arbuth-

not, F. F.].
Ahmad, 'Abd Allah ibn. See under Sontheimer, J. von.
Aiyar, V. Nates a. " Maredapalli Grant of Sri-Rangaraya II ;

Saka 1497." Epigraphia Indica and Record of the Archaeo-
logical Survey of India. Vol. xi. Calcutta. 1911-1912. Pp.

326-336. [VIII, 254ft4.]
Alberg, A. See under Stephens, G. and Cavallius, H.,
Albertus Magnus. Alberti Magni, de secretis mulierum
• Libellus, scholiis auctus et a mendis repurgatus. Ejusdem

de virtutibus herbarum, lapidum et animalium quorumdam

Libellus. Item de mirabilibus mundi. . . . Adjecimus et
| ob materice similitudinem Michaelis Scoti philosophi de

secretis opusculum. . . . Amstelodami. 1669. [II, 299,

299ft3.]
Alemany (i.e. Jose Alemany Bolufer). La Antiqua Version

Castellana del Calila Y Dimna Arabe de la Misma. Madrid.

1915. [V, 237.1
Ali 'Aziz Efendi. See under Gibb, E. J. W., Story of Jewad.
Al-Jazari. See under Coomaraswamy, A. K.
Al-Kazwini, or Qazwini. See under Ethe, Hermann.
Allen, C. G. Vancienne version espagnole de Kalila et Digna.

Texte . . . precede d'un avant-propos et suivi tfun glossaire.

These presentee . . . par . . . Macon. 1906. [V, 237.]
Allen, J. " Maya." Hastings' Encyclopaedia of Religion and

Ethics. Vol. viii. 1915. Pp. 503-505. [VI, 35.]
Al-Mufaddal ibn Salama. See under Mufaddal ibn

Salama, al-.
Alphonsus, Petrus. Disciplina Clericalis. (Catalogued in

the Brit. Mus. under " Alfunsi (Petrus) formerly Rabbi

Moses Sephardi.") [I, 169; III, 118ft1 ; V. 13ft1.] See

further under Hulme, W. H.
Al-Tha'alibi. See under Zotenberg, H.

BIBLIOGRAPHY 175

Alviella, G. D\ See under D'Alviella, G.

Amherst of Hackney, Lord, and Basil Thomson. The

Discovery of the Solomon Islands by Alvaro de Mendana in

1568. Translated from the Original Spanish Manuscripts.

Edited, with Introduction and Notes, by . . . Hakluyt

Society. Ldn. 1901. [VIII, 314, 314w2.]
The above volumes form Nos. vii and viii of the Second Series.

Anaryan. See under [Arbuthnot, F. F.].

[Ancillon, C] Traite des Euneuques, dans lequel on explique

toutes les differentes sortes d'euneuques. . . . Paris. 1707.

[Ill, 328.]
Ancona, A. D'. See under D'Ancona, A.
Andersen, H. C. Eventyr fortalte for Born. Copenhagen.

1835. [VI, 288, 290.]
Andersen, H. C. " King, Queen and Knave." Introduction

by Prof. Julius Clausen, Royal Librarian at Copenhagen.

Translated by Hamilton Marr. The Argosy7 Vol. i. No. 7.

Dec. 1926. Pp. 145, 146. [IX, 161.]

This tale was recently discovered in MS. in the Collins' collection.

Andersen, H. C. See also under Br^ekstad, H. L. ; Brix,

Hans ; Craigie, W. A. and J. K. ; Larsen, K. ; Rubow,

P. V. ; Schmitz, V. A. ; Schwanenflugel, H. ; Shortt,

L. M. ; Vedel, Valdemar.
Andersen, Dines. See under Fausboll, V. ; Sorensen, S.
Anderson, W. " Die Meleagrossage bei den Tschuwaschen."

Philologus. Zeitschrift fur das klassische Altertum und sein

Nachleben hrsq. von Otto Crusius. Vol. lxxiii. Leipzig.

1914-1916. Pp. 159, 160. [VIII, 107n.]
Andersson, H. Likspokets Tjugufem Berattelser, Goteborgs

Kungl. Vetenskaps- och Vilterhetssamhdlles Handlingar.

4 foljden, iii. Gothenburg. 1901. [VI, 226, 226n2.]
Andree, R. Ethnographische Paralleln und Vergleiche.

Stuttgart. 1878-1879. [VI, 140.]
Andrews, J. P. History of Great Britain, from the Death of

Henry VIII to the Accession of James VI of Scotland to the

Crown of England. Being a Continuation of Dr Henry's

[q.v.] History of Great Britain. ... 2 vols. Ldn. 1796.

[VI, 24w.]
Anibal, C. E. "Voces del cielo — A note on Mira de Amescua."

The Romanic Review. Vol. xvi. Jan.-March. Pp. 56-70. New

York. 1925. [IX, 141.]
Anspach, A. E. De Alexandri Magni Expeditione Indica.

Ldn. 1903. [II, 2S2nK]

176 THE OCEAN OF STORY

Anstey, L. M. See also under Blochmann, H.
Apollodorus. The Library (BIBAI09HKH). [IV, 256;

VI, 282, 282ft2 ; VII, 228ft1.] For other references see

under Frazer, J. G., Apollodorus.
Apollonius. Historia Mirabilium (AIIOAAQNIOY . . .

KCLTe^reva/jLevr} tarTopia >/ laroplai 6avfx.d(riai). See Vol. i, pp. 193-

201 of I. L. Ideler's Physici et Medici Grceci Minores.

Berolini. 1841. [I, 39ft2.]
Apollonius Rhodius. Argonautica. [VI, 282, 282ft1 ; VII,

228ft1.]
Apollonius of Tyana. Indian Travels. [II, 108ft.] See

also under Conybeare, F. C.
Apuleius. Metamorphoses — The Golden Ass. [II, 60ft2 ; III,

226ft2, 285ft1, 311ft1 ; VI, 56ft2 ; VIII, 56ft1.]
Arber, E. See under Gosson, S.
Arbman, E. Rudra. Untersuchungen zum altindischen

Glauben und Kultus. Uppsala. 1922. [I, 206.]
[Arbuthnot, F. F.] Early Ideas. A Group of Hindoo Stories.

Collected and collated by Anaryan. Ldn. 1881. [I, 236,

236ft1 ; IV, 48.]

This work consists of extracts from the Panchatantra, Hitopadesa, Katha-

sarit-sagara, Vetalapafichavimsati, etc.

[Arbuthnot, F. F.] See also fonder [Burton, R. F., and

Arbuthnot, F. F.].
Arfert, P. Das Motiv von der unterschobenen Braut in

der internationalen Erzdhlungs-Litteratur. . . . Schwerin.

1897. [VI, 48ft.]
Ariosto. Orlando Furioso. [Ill, 167ft2.]
Aristophanes. Aves. [II, 152ft1 ; V, 37ft2, 61ft3 ; IX, 3ft1.]

Acharnians. [IV, 138ft1.] Nubes. [V, 29ft2, 256, 257.]
Aristotle. Historia de animalibus. [II, 296.] History of

the Constitution of Sybaris. [VII, 207.] Problemata. [Ill,

310ft1.] Secretum Secretorum (Pseudo- Aristotle). [II, 286

et seq.]
Armeno, Christoforo. See under Bolte, J., and Fischer, H.
Armstrong, O. C. See under Penzer, N. M., Mineral

Resources of Burma.
Arnason, J6n. Icelandic Legends (collected by . . .). Trans-
lated by G. E. J. Powell and E. Magnusson. 2nd Series.

Ldn. 1866. [I, 27, 44.]

The English translation of the 1st Series (containing sixty-six stories)
appeared in 1864. The 2nd Series contains seventy-four stories and an
Appendix.

Arnobius, Afer. Adversus Gentes. [Ill, 21ft.]

BIBLIOGRAPHY 177

Arnold, Edwin. The Book of Good Counsels : From the

Sanskrit of the " Hitopadesa." . . . Ldn. 1861. (Subsequent

editions : 1893, 1896.) [V, 210.]
Arratoon, Nicolas. Gems of Oriental Wit & Humour or

the Sayings <& Doings of Molla Nasraddin the Celebrated

Humourist of the East. Compiled db Translated from the

Persian by . . . Calcutta. 1894. [Date at end of Preface.]

[IX, 152, 155, 156.]
Arrian. Indica. [II, 263 ; V, 83711, I6O711.] See also under

McCrindle, J. W.
Arya S6ra. See under Speyer, J. S., The Gdtakamdld.
Asbjornsen, P. C. See under Dasent, G. W.
Asher, A. See under Benjamin, Rabbi, of Tudela.
Athen^eus. The Deipnosophists. [VII, 206, 206n3, 207.]

See also under Yonge, C. D.
Atiya Begum Fyzee-Rahamin. See under Fyzee-Rahamin,

A. B.
Atkinson, E. T. The Himalayan Districts of the North-Western

Provinces of India. 3 vols. Allahabad. 1882, 1884, 1886.

Forming vols, x-xii of Statistical, Descriptive and Historical

Account of the North-Western Provinces of India. [IV,

159W1 ; VIII, 19.]
Atkinson, T. D. " Points of the Compass." Hastings' Ency.

Rel. Eth. Vol. x. 1918. Pp. 73-88. [II, 54nK]
Attai, M. O. Kitdb Kalilah wa-Dimnah. Fables of Bidpdi

[in Russian]. Introduction by M. B. Ryabinin. Moscow.

1889. [V, 235, 238, 240.]
Aubrey, John. See under Britten, James.
Aufrecht, Theodor. " Beitrage zur Kenntniss indischer

Dichter." Zeitschrift der Deutschen Morgenldndischen

Gesellschaft. Vol. xxxvi. Leipzig. 1882. Pp. 361-383, 509-

559. [V, 136w3.]
Augustine. See under St Augustine.
Aulus Gellius. See under Gellius, Aulus.
Aurivillius, P. F. Prolegomena ad librum: ^retyavhw kcu

'IxvrjXdrm e Cod. Mscr. Biblioth. Acad. Upsal. Edita et

Latine versa. Upsala. [1780.] [V, 238.]
Avalon, A. [i.e. Sir John Woodroffe]. T antra of the Great

Liberation (Mahdnirvdna T antra). . . . A translation . . . with

Introduction and Commentary by . . . Ldn. 1913. [VI, 52n.]
Avalon, A. Principles of T antra (Tantratattva). 2 vols. Ldn.

1914-1916. [VI, 52w.]
Avalon, A. Shakti and Shdkta. 2nd edit. London and

Madras. 1922. [VI, 52w.]

VOL. IX. M

178 THE OCEAN OF STORY

Avalon, Arthur and Ellen. Hymns to the Goddess. Trans-
lated from the Sanskrit. Ldn. 1913. [VI, 52ft.]

Axon, W. E. A. Lancashire Gleanings (relating to the History
and Archaeology of Lancashire). Manchester. 1883. [II,
76ft1, 77n.]

Axon, W. E. A. " The Myth of the Sirens," The Academy.
13th Aug. 1881. No. 484. Pp. 120, 121. [VI, 282ft6.]

Ayrer, J. " Fassnachtspil, die ehrlich beckin mit iren drey
vermeinten bulern . . ." (46.) Ayrers Dramen heraus-
gegeben von Adelbert von Keller. Vol. iv. Stuttgart. 1865.
Pp. 2763-2789. [IX, 142.]

The above volume forms Pub. lxxix of Litterarischen Vereins in Stuttgart.

Ayyangar, S. K. Sources of Vijayanagar History. Selected
and edited for the University. Madras University Series.
1919. [I, 250ft1.]
Catalogued in the Brit. Mus. under Srlnlvasa-Raghava Ayyaiigar.

Ayyar, R. See under Ramanatha Ayyar, A. S.

'Aziz Efendi, 'All. See under Gibb, E. J. W., Story of Jewdd.

Babington, B. G. The Veddla Cadai, being the Tamul Version

of a Collection of Ancient Tales in the Sanscrit Language;

popularly known throughout India, and entitled The Vetdla

Panchavinsati.

The above translation forms the fourth, of a series of five, of vol. i of :

Miscellaneous Translations from Oriental Languages. Printed
for the Oriental Translation Fund. 2 vols. Ldn. 1831-1834.
[VI, 226, 226ft3, 232ft1, 268ft1, 269ft3, 274ft1, 276ft2, 278ft2,
285ft2; VII, 199, 200ft1, 204ft2, 211ft2, 212ft2, 216ft1,2, 222ft2,
234ft1, 241ft2, 245ft1, 250ft1, 251ft1, 256ft2, 257ft1'2, 259ft1,
260ft2, 262ft2, 264ft2.]

For details of all papers in both volumes see Catalogue of the Library of the
Royal Asiatic Society, 1893, pp. 256, 257.

Babrius. Fabulae. [V, 79ft2, 110ft1.] See also under Lewis, G. C.

Bacon, J. R. The Voyage of the Argonauts. Ldn. 1925.
[VIII, 109ft1.]

Badger, G. P. The Travels of Ludovico Di Varthema in
Egypt, Syria, Arabia Deserta, and Arabia Felix, in Persia,
India, and Ethiopia, ad. 1503 to 1508. Translated ... by
John Winter Jones, Esq., F.S.A., and edited, with Notes and
an Introduction, by . . . Hakluyt Society. Ldn. 1863 [1864
on back of cover]. It forms No. xxxii of the First Series.
[II, 300, 300ft4, 301 ; III, 201, 202; VIII, 96ft2, 258ft1.]

Baker, E. C. Stuart. The Indian Ducks and their Allies.
Natural History Society. Bombay. 1908. [VI, 71ft3.]

BIBLIOGRAPHY 179

Baker, F. Grenfell. See under Penzer, N. M.

Baldo [Alter Aesopus]. See under Meril, Edelestand Du.

Balfour, Edward. The Cyclopaedia of India and of Eastern

and Southern Asia, Commercial, Industrial, and Scientific.

3rd edition. 3 vols. Ldn. 1885. [VIII, 318W1 ; IX, 167.]

The first edition was published in Madras in 1857-1858. It was issued in
parts. The second edition also was issued in Madras. 5 vols. 1873.

Balfour, Henry. See under Hutton, J. H., Sema Nagas ;
and Mills, J. P., Ao Nagas.

Ball, V. Travels in India by Jean Baptiste Tavernier, Baron
of Aubonne. Translated from the Original French Edition
of 1676, with a Biographical Sketch of the Author, Notes,
Appendices, etc. 2 vols. Ldn. 1889. [I, 241n3; VIII, 295n\]

A second edition, edited by William Crooke, appeared in 1925.

Bana. See under Ridding, C. M.

Bandello. Novelle. [I, 44, 162ns 166 ; II, 10n.]

Bandow, C. J. The Precedents of Princess Thoodamma Tsari

. . . with Numerous Explanatory Notes and a Vocabulary of

the Pali and difficult Burmese words in the text. Rangoon.

1881. [VI, 60, 266W1 ; VII, 203w2.]

Simultaneously with the above appeared the Burmese text. The English

portion of the title-page reads : The Decisions of the Princess Thoodamasari.

Sixth edition. Rangoon. 1881.

Both works are catalogued in the Brit. Mus. under " Sudhammachari."

The book was translated into French as vol. xxiv of Collection de Contes et

Chansons Populaires under the title : Contes Birmans D'apres le Thoudamma

Sari Dammazat. By Louis Vossion. Paris. 1901.

Banerji-Sastri. " The Plays of Bhasa." Journ. Roy. As.

Soc. July 1921. Pp. 267-282. [II, 21n\]
Bapst von Rochlitz, Michael. Artzney Kunst- und Wunder-

Buch. Eissleben. 1604. [II, 294W1.] "
Barbazan-Meon. Fabliaux et Contes des Pokes Francois des

XIe-XVe sUcles. 4 vols. Paris. 1808. [1,44.]
Barbier de Meynard. See under Meynard, C. Barbier de.
Barbosa, Duarte. See under Dames, M. Longworth.
Barham, R. H. Ingoldsby Legends. [Ill, 40w2.]
Baring-Gould, S. Curious Myths of the Middle Ages. New

Edition. Ldn., Oxford and Cambridge. 1869. [II, 39n3 ;

III, 152, 167ra2, 187w3, 268W1 ; IV, 185w2, 245w4 ; V, 138wx ;

VI, 18n2, 56n2, 109n2 ; VII, 52n* ; IX, 47w3.]

The " New Edition," first issued in 1869, was the amalgamation of the
M First Series " and " Second Series," both of which appeared in 1868. It
was continually reprinted — 1872, 1881, 1884, 1897, etc. With the exception
of the section on " S. Patrick's Purgatory," the " First Series " was a reprint
of the 1st edition of 1866.

180 THE OCEAN OF STORY

Baring-Gould, S. Strange Survivals, Some Chapters in the
History of Man. Ldn. 1892. [11,272.]

Baring-Gould, S. See also under Henderson, William.

Barker, W. Burckhardt. The Baitdl Pachisi ; or, Twenty-
five Tales of a Demon : A new edition of the Hindi Text
. . . and with a perfectly Literal English Interlinear
Translation . . . by . . . Edited by E. B. Eastwick,
F.R.S. . . . Hertford. 1855. [VI, 226, 232, 232ft2, 267,
267ft2, 273ft6, 276ft1, 278m1, 285ft1 ; VII, 199ft1-2, 204ft1,
211ft1, 212ft1, 215ft1, 222ft1, 233ft3, 241ft1, 244ft2, 249ft3, 250ft2,
256ft1, 258ft1, 260ft1, 262ft1.]

Barnes, T. " Trees and Plants." Hastings' Ency. Rel. Eth. Vol.
xii. 1921. Pp. 448-457. [1,144ft1.] "Alchemy "(European).
Hastings' Ency. Rel. Eth. Vol. i. Pp. 292-298. [Ill, 162ft.]

Barnett, L. D. A Supplementary Catalogue of Sanskrit, Pali,
and Prakrit Books in the Library of the British Museum
(1892-1906). Ldn. 1908. [VI, 6ft1.] Continuation of above
to be issued in 1928. [VII, 237ft2.]

Barnett, L. D. The Golden Town and Other Tales from
Somadeva's " Ocean of Romance-Rivers." Ldn. 1909. [II,
200ft2, 201ft1 ; VI, 26ft2, 28ft1, 32ft1 ; VII, 137ft1.]

This volume forms one of the " Romance of the East " Series, edited by
L. Cranmer-Byng.

Barnett, L. D. Antiquities of India. An Account of the
History and Culture of Ancient Hindustan. Ldn. 1913.
[IV, 16, 258ft1 ; VII, 26, 187ft1 ; VIII, 78ft1.]
This volume forms one of the " Handbooks to Ancient Civilizations."

Barnett, L. D. Hindu Gods and Heroes. Studies in the
History of the Religion of India. Ldn. 1922. [11,21ft1.]

This volume forms one of the " Wisdom of the East " Series, edited by
L. Cranmer-Byng and Dr S. A. Kapadia.

Barnett, L. D. " Inscriptions of Sudi." No. 6. Epigraphia

Indica. Vol. xv. Pt. ii, iii. April, July. Calcutta. 1919.

Pp. 73-112. [Ill, 207ft2.]
Barnett, L. D. " Bhasa." Journ. Roy. As. Soc. Oct. 1921.

Pp. 587-589. [II, 21ft1.]
Barrow, H. W. " Aghoris and Aghorapanthis." Journ. Anth.

Soc. Bombay. Vol. iii. No. 4. 1893. Pp. 197-251. [II, 90ft3.]
Bart, A. " Un Ancien Manuel de Sorcellerie Hindoue."

Melusine. Vol. i. Paris. 1878. Cols. 105-109. [I, 12ft1.]
Barth, A. The Religions of India. Trans. J. Wood. 2nd edit.

Ldn. 1889. [VII, 85ft.]
Barto, P. S. Tannhduser and the Mountain of Venus. Oxford

Univ. Press, New York Branch. 1916. [VI, 109ft2.]

BIBLIOGRAPHY 181

Barton, G. A. " Hierodouloi (Semitic and Egyptian)."
Hastings' Ency. Rel. Eth. Vol. vi. 1913. Pp. 672-676.
[I, 271ft1, 277.]

Bartsch, K. Deutsche Liederdichter des zwolften bis vierzehnten
Jahrhunderts. Eine Auswahl. Leipzig. 1864. [II, 292ft3.]

Bartsch, K. Herzog Ernst. Heraus von . . . Vienna. 1869.
[VII, 189ft.2]

Bartsch, K. Sagen, Mdrchen und Gebrauche aus Meklenburg.
2 vols. Vienna. 1879. [I, 129 ; II, 98ft4, 107m1, 153ft ; III,
4ft1, 104ft2, 131ft3, 133ft1, 150, 187ft3, 231ft1, 272ft1 ; IV, 93ft3,
145ft2, 227ft1 ; V, 4ft1, 92ft2, 157ft1, 170ft1, 201ft ; VI, 24ft,
149ft1 ; VIII, 56n2 ; IX, 45ft1.]

Basile, Giovanni Battista. II Pentamerone. [I, 20ft, 44,
46ft2, 168 ; IX, 78ft.] See further under Burton, R. F.,
II Pentamerone.

Basset, Rene. " Deux Manuscrits d'une Version Arabe
inedite du Recueil des Sept Vizirs." Journal Asiatique,
10 Ser. Tom. ii. Paris. 1903. Pp. 43-83. [VI, 260ft1.]

Basset, Rene. " Contes et Legendes de la Grece Ancienne."
Revue des Traditions Populaires. Recueil Mensuel de Myth-
ologie. . . . Paris. Vol. xxv. Aug.-Sept. 1910. Pp. 289-293
(being one section of a serial article). [VIII, 107ft.]

Bastian, A. Die V biker des ostlichen Asien : Studien und
Reisen. 6 vols. Leipzig. 1866-1871. [V, 128ft.]

Bastian, A. Geographische und ethnologische Bilder. Jena.
1873. Naumburg a. S. [Printed.] [VII, 208ft1.]

Bastian, A. Indonesien oder die Inseln der Malayischen
Archipel. 5 vols. Berlin. 1884-1894. [VIII, 232ft1.]

The volumes deal with the following islands : 1. Die Molukken. 1884.
2. Timor und umliegende Inseln. 1885. 3. Sumatra und Nachbarschaft.
1886. 4. Borneo und Celebes. 1889- 5. Java und Schluss. 1894.

Bastian, A. Allerlei aus Volks- und Menschenkunde. 2 vols.
Berlin. 1888. [VIII, 232ft3.]

Batchelor, J. The Ainu and their Folklore. . . . Religious
Tract Society. Ldn. 1901. [IX, 149.]

Batten, J. H. Official Reports on the Province of Kumaon,
with a Medical Report on the Mahamurree in Gurhwal, in
1849-50. Edited under the Orders of the Horfble The
Lieut. -Governor, "North-Western Provinces. Agra. 1851.
[IV, 160ft.]

The reference in the Ocean is under the name Traill. The above work con-

t sists of collected reports by various officials. The first of these is entitled :

Statistical Sketch of Kumaon, by George William Traill, Esq., Commissioner

for the Affairs of Kumaon. It was originally issued in Asiatick Researches,

vol. xvi, Calcutta, 1828, pp. 137-234.

182 THE OCEAN OF STORY

Batuta, Ibn. See under Yule, H., Cathay and the Way
Thither.

Ibn Batuta 's Travels are to be shortly issued in 3 vols., translated and edited
by H. A. R. Gibb, for the Hakluyt Society.

Baumeister, A. Denkmdler des klassischen Altertums zur
Erlduterung des Lebens der Griechen und Romer in Religion,
Kunst und Sitte. Lexikalisch bearbeitet von B. Arnold . . .
unddem. . . . Miinchen und Leipzig. 1884-1888. [VI, 282n\]

Beal, Samuel. Si-Yu-Ki. Buddhist Records of the Western
World. Translated from the Chinese of Hiuen Tsiang (a.d.
629). Triibner's Oriental Series. Popular edition. Two vols,
in one. Ldn. n.d. [VI, 69nS 284w2 ; VII, 237n2, 238711.]

The pagination is the same as the 2- vol. edition of 1884.

Beal, Samuel. The Life of Hiuen-Tsiang. By the Shaman
Hwui Li. With an Introduction containing an Account of
the Works of I-Tsing. . . . With a Preface by L. Cranmer-
Byng. Trubner's Oriental Series. Popular edition. Ldn.
1914. [VII, 106.]

Beal, Samuel. " The Swastika." Indian Antiquary. Vol. ix.
March 1880. Pp. 67, 68. [I, 190.]

Beal, Samuel. " Story of the Merchant who struck his
Mother." Indian Antiquary. Vol. ix. Sept. 1880. Pp. 224-
226. [IV, 229n2.]

Beauchamp, H. K. See under Dubois, M. l'Abbe J.-A.

Beaver, W. N. Unexplored New Guinea. A Record of the
Travels, Adventures, and Experiences of a Resident Magis-
trate amongst the Head-hunting Savages and Cannibals of the
Unexplored Interior of New Guinea. With an Introduction
by A. C. Haddon. Ldn. 1920. [VIII, 313rc2.]

Bebelius, Henricus. Facetiarum Heinrici Bebelii Poetae,
A.D. Maximiliano laureati, librites, a mendis repurgati, &
in lucem rursus redditi. His Accesserunt selectee qiuedam
Poggii Facetice. . . . Tubingen. 1561. [Ill, 75.]

This is the earliest edition in the Brit. Mus. library. Zapf, Heinrich Bebel
nach seinem Leben und Schriften, 1802, gives the title-page of the 1506 edition
as follows : Commentaria epistolarum conficiendarum Henrici Bebelii. . . .
Argentina.

Beccari, O. " The Palms of the Philippine Islands." The
Philippine Journal of Science. Vol. xiv. No. 3. 1919. Pp.
295-363. With three plates, facing p. 362. [VIII, 249W1.]

Bedier, Joseph. Les Fabliaux Etudes de Litterature Popu-
laire et D'Histoire Litteraire du Moyen Age. Quatrieme
edition revue et corrigee. Paris. 1925. [VI, 271, 271 n2 ;
IX, 142.]

BIBLIOGRAPHY 183

Beet, W. E. 8 See under Crawley, A. E. ; Beet, W. E., and

Canney, M. A.
Beglar, J. D. Report of a Tour in Bundelkhand and Malwa,

1871-72 ; and in the Central Provinces, 1873-74. Calcutta.

1878. [VII, 229ft1.]

This report forms vol. vii of the Archaeological Survey of India, under the
superintendence of A. Cunningham.

Behrnauer, W. F. A. Die Vierzig Veziere oder Weisen
Meister, ein altmorgenldndischer Sittenroman aus dem
Turkischen ubertragen. Leipzig. 1851. [Ill, 20ft1 ; V,
153ft1 ; VII, 252, 252ft1.]

Bell, H. C. P. See under Gray, Albert.

Bellows, H. A. The Poetic Edda. Translated from the
Icelandic with an Introduction and Notes by . . . Two vols,
in one. Continuous pagination throughout. Scandinavian
Classics. Vols, xxi and xxii. Published by the American-
Scandinavian Foundation. New York. 1923. [VIII, 221ft1.]

Benfey, T. Pantschatantra : FiXnf Biicher indischer Fabeln,
Marchen und Erzdhlungen. Aus dem Sanskrit ubersetzt mit
Einleitung und Anmerkungen. 2 vols. Leipzig. 1859. [I,
37ft2, 39ft2, 51ft1, 54ft1, 84ft2, 145ft1, 157ft2, 188ft2, 189ft ; II,
52ft1, 108ft, 113ft1, 297ft2 ; III, 28ft1, 62, 69ft1, 76, 115ft1, 126 ;
IV, 192ft1, 196ft1, 230ft1, 245ft1 ; V, 42ft, 42ft1, 43ft1, 43ft2,
46ft1, 48ft1, 49ft1, 52ft2, 53ft1, 55ft1, 55ft2, 55ft3, 58ft1, 59ft2,
61ft3, 64, 73ft1, 75ft1, 76ft1, 76ft3, 77ft1, 79ft3, 93ft1, 98ft1, 99ft3,
100ft1, 101ft1, 102ft2, 104ft1, 105ft1, 106ft1, 107ft1, 108ft2, 109ft2,
111ft2, 112ft1, 127ft1, 130ft1, 134ft2, 135ft, 138ft1, 153ft1, 157ft1,
164ft1, 217 ; VI, 155ft2, 246 ; VII, 213, 252ft2, 260 ; IX, 163.]

Benfey, T. " Ueber die alte deutsche auf Befehl Des Graf en
Eberhardt von Wiirtenberg abgefasste Uebersetzung des
Kalilah und Dimnah, insbesondre deren altesten Druck
und dessen Verhaltniss zu der spanischen Uebersetzung."
Orient und Occident. Vol. i. 1862. Pp. 138-187. [V, 238.]

Benfey, T. " Somadeva's Marchenschatz." Orient und
Occident. Vol. i. 1862. Pp. 371-383. [Ill, 2ft2, 28ft1, 70ft2,
76, 115ft1, 150.]

Benfey, T. " Gothe's Gedicht : Legende (Werke 1840, 1,
200) und dessen Indisches Vorbild." Orient und Occident.
Vol. i. Pp. 719-732. [VI, 276, 276ft5.]

Benfey, T. " Beitrage zur Geschichte der Verbreitung der
indischen Sammlungen von Fabeln und Erzahlungen ;
urspriingliche Grundlage der Sieben weisen Meister." Orient
und Occident. Vol. iii. 1866. Pp. 171-180. [II, 120 ; V,
259ft1.]

184 THE OCEAN OF STORY

Benfey, T. See also under Bickell, G.
Benjamin, Rabbi, of Tudela. Itinerary. Translated and
Edited by A. Asher. 2 vols. 1840. [I, 141ft2.]

This work was translated into Latin from the Hebrew in 1575, while a
French version appeared in 1734.

Bennett, A. L. " Ethnographical Notes on the Fang."
Journ. Anth. Inst. Vol. xxix. 1899. (New Series. Vol. ii.)
Pp. 66-97, with discussion to p. 98. [VI, 265ft3.]

Berard, Victor. Les Pheniciens et VOdyssee. 2 vols. Paris.
1902, 1903. [VIII, 56ft2 ; IX, 161.]

Bergson, H. he Rire. Essai sur la Signification du Comique.
Vingt-Troisieme edition, Augmentee. Bibliotheque de
Philosophic Contemporaine. Paris. 1924. [VII, 253ft1.]

See the bibliography on pp. vii, viii. An English translation, from the
1900 edition, appeared by Cloudesley Brereton and F. Rothwell : Laughter.
An Essay on the Meaning of the Comic. Ldn. 1911.

Bernier, Francois. See under Constable, A.

Bertrand, L'Abbe. " Histoire des Rois de l'Hindoustan

apres les Pandavas, traduite du texte hindoustani de Mir

Cher-i-Ali Afsos." Journal Asiatique. Ser. iv. Tom. iii.

1844. Pp. 104-123, 229-257, 354-377. [VI, 240ft2.]
Bettei, V. [Italian translations of the Vetdlapanchavimsati.]

For Bibliographical details see Vol. VII, p. 266.
Bevan, E. R. India in Early Greek and Latin Literature."

The Cambridge History of India. Vol. i — Ancient India.

Chapter xvi, pp. 391-426. Edited by E. J. Rapson. [IV,

261.]
Bezemer, T. J. Volksdichtung aus Indonesien. Sagen, Tier-

fabeln und Mdrchen. tJbersetzt von . . . mit Vorwort von

Prof. Br H. Kern. Haag. 1904. [VIII, 2Sln8.]
Bhandarkar, R. G. " The Aryans in the Land of the Assurs."

Journ. Bombay Br. Asiatic Soc. Vol. xxv. 1918. Pp. 76-81.

[1, 198.]
Bhartrihari. See under Tawney, C. H.
Bhasa. Svapna-vdsavadatta. [II, 21m1.]
Bhavabhuti. Maha-vira-charita. [II, 214.] Mdtali-mddhava.

[II, 205ft3, 214.] Uttara-rdma-charita. [II, 214.] See also

under Tawney, C. H.
Bhishagratna, Kaviraj Kunja Lal. An English Transla-
tion of The Sushruta Samhita Based on Original Sanskrit

Text. Edited and published by ... 3 vols. Calcutta.

1907, 1911 and 1916. [I, 211, 212 ; II, 276, 276ft1 ; III,

51ft ; VIII, 96ft1, 255ft1.]
Bhojadeva, King. See under SastrI, T. Granapati.

BIBLIOGRAPHY 185

Bhola Nath. See under Nath, Bhola.

Bholanauth Chunder. See under Chunder, Bholanauth.

Biagi, Guido. he Novelle Antiche del Codici Panciatichiano-

Palatino 138 e Laurenziano-Gaddiano 193, con una Intro-

duzione sulla Storia Esterna del Testo del Novellino. Firenze.

1880. [IX, 150.] See also under Borghini, V. ;

Gualteruzzi, C. ; and Storer, E.
Bickell, G. Kalilag und Damnag Alte syrische Vbersetzung

des Indischen Furstenspiegels. With an Introduction by

T. Benfey. Leipzig. 1876. [V, 219.]
Billington, M. F. Woman in India. . . . With Introduc-
tion by the Marchioness of Dufferin and Ava. Ldn. 1895.

[II, 163n.]
Binns, C. See under Vincent, A. L., and Binns, C.
Birch, Samuel. See under Wilkinson, J. G.
Birlinger, A. Aus Schwdben Sagen, Legenden, Aberglauben,

Sitten, Rechtsbrduche, Ortsneckereien, Lieder, Kinderreine,

neue Sammlung, von ... 2 vols. Wiesbaden. "1874. [1, 103;

III, 150, 218W1 ; IV, 93rc2, 145n2, 227m1 ; VI, 10rc4, 24n ;

VII, 21w3.]

For the French editions, chiefly published at Amsterdam and Rouen, see

Catalogue General des livres imprimes de la Bibliotheque Nationale. Tome xxxv.

1908. Cols. 467, 468. There is no French edition in the Brit. Mus. library.

Blade, J. F. Quatorze Superstitions populaires de la Gascogne.
Agen. 1883. [VI, 150n.]

Blade, J. F. Contes populaires de la Gascogne. 3 vols. Paris.
1886. Forming vols, xix, xx and xxi of " Les Litter, pop. de
toutes les nations." [Ill, 105w.l

Blagden, C. O. See under Skeat, W. W., and Blagden, C. O.

Blair, E. H., and Robertson, J. A. The Philippine Islands,
1493-1898. Explorations by Early Navigators, Descriptions
of the Islands and their Peoples . . . showing the Political,
Economic, Commercial and Religious Conditions of those
Islands from their earliest Relations with European Nations
to the close of the Nineteenth Century. Translated from the
Originals. Edited and annotated by . . ., and with Intro-
duction and additional notes by Edward Gaylord Browne.
With Maps, Portraits and other Illustrations. 55 vols.
Cleveland, Ohio. 1903-1909. [VIII, 302, 302n2.]

Blakeborough, R. The Hand of Glory and Further Grand-
fathers Tales and Legends of Highwaymen and Others.
Collected by the late . . . Edited by J. Fairfax-Blakeborough,
M.C. . . . Ldn. 1924. [Ill, 152.]

186 THE OCEAN OF STORY

Bloch, Iwan. Der Ursprung der Syphilis. Eine medizinische
und kulturgeschichtliche Untersuchung. Jena. 1910-1911.
[II, 310n3.]

Blochmann, H. The Ain I Akbari by Abul Fazl 'Allami.
Translated from the Original Persian, by . . . Published
in the Bibliotheca Indica Series of the Asiatic Society of
Bengal. Vol. i. Calcutta. 1873.

Vols, ii and iii were translated by H. S. Jarrett, the details of which are as
follows : —

The Ain I Akbari by Abul Fazl Alldmi. Translated . . .
Vol. ii. Calcutta. 1891. The Ain I Akbari by Abul Fazl-I-
Alldmi. Translated . . . Vol. iii. Calcutta. 1894.

In 1910 there appeared :

A Supplementary Index of the Place-Names on pages 89 to
414 of the 'Ain-I- Akbari, vol. ii (translated by Colonel H. S.
Jarrett). Compiled by William Irvine . . . and Lavinia
Mary Anstey. [I, 237nx ; III, 162n ; VIII, 264n5.]

This completed the entire work, which commenced issue by parts (fascicles)
in 1868. In the Catalogue of Works ... of the Bibliotheca Indica Series,
issued by the Asiatic Society of Bengal in 1926, the translation is Work No. 61,
while the text edited by Blochmann (1867-1877) forms Work No. 58.

Bloomfield, M. A Vedic Concordance, being an Alphabetic
Index to Every Line of Every Stanza of the Published Vedic
Literature and to the Liturgical Formulas thereof, that is, an
Index to the Vedic Mantras, together with an Account of their
Variations in the Different Vedic Books. Cambridge, Mass.
1906. [II, 45n4.]

The above volume forms vol. x of the Harvard Oriental Series.

Bloomfield, M. The Life and Stories of the Jaina Savior

Pdrgvandtha. Baltimore. The Johns Hopkins Press. 1919.

[I, U8n2 ; II, 14n, 108w, 122, 285W1, 286n3 ; III, 63, 280 ;

IV, 47 ; V, 176 ; VII, 203, 203ft1, 213 ; IX, 82ft1.] 0
Bloomfield, M. " The Character and Adventures of Mula-

deva." Proc. Amer. Phil. Soc. Vol. Iii. 1913. Pp. 616-650.

[Ill, 2.07n2 ; VII, 220nx.]
Bloomfield, M. "On the Art of Entering Another's Body ;

a Hindu Fiction Motif." Proc. Amer. Phil. Soc. Vol. lvi.

1917. Pp. 1-43. [I, 38n ; II, 45w4, 212W1 ; III, 83W1 ; IV,

47 ; VI, 74rc ; VII, 260rc3.]
Bloomfield, M. "On Recurring Psychic Motifs in Hindu

Fiction, and the Laugh and Cry Motif." Journ. Amer.

Orient. Soc. Vol. xxxvi. 1917. Pp. 54-89. [I, 46W1, 47w,

121w2 ; V, 37W1 ; VII, 191W1, 251n\ 254, 254/11, 255, 256,

260w3 ; IX, 162.]

BIBLIOGRAPHY 187

Bloomfield, M. " The Dohada, or Craving of Pregnant
Women ; a Motif of Hindu Fiction." Journ. Amer.
Orient. Soc. Vol. xl. 1920. Pp. 1-24. [I, 221, 222, 223,
228.]

Bloomfield, M. " The Art of Stealing in Hindu Fiction."
Amer. Journ. Phil. Vol. xliv. 1923. Pp. 97-133, 193-229.
[I, 118n2 ; II, 183ft1 ; III, 153 ; V, Gin1, 64, 142w2, 143w,
158n; VI, 37ft1 ; VII, 164ft1, 201, 201ft1, 203ft1, 218ft2,
220 ; IX, 78w.]

Bloomfield, M. " Joseph and Potiphar in Hindu Fiction."
Trans. Amer. Phil. Assoc. Vol. liv. 1923. Pp. 141-176.
[IV, 104, 107 ; V, 176.]

Bloomfield, M. "On False Ascetics and Nuns in Hindu
Fiction." Journ. Amer. Orient. Soc. Vol. xliv. 1924. Pp.
202-242, [III, 211ft1 ; V, 102ft2 ; VI, 12m1 ; IX, 23ft2.]

Blundell, C. A. " Specimen of the Burmese Drama, trans-
lated by J. Smith, Esq., communicated by . . ." Journ.
As. Soc. Bengal. Vol. viii. No. 90. July 1839. Pp. 535-551.
[VIII, 231ft1.]

Blyth, A. Wynter. Old and Modern Poison Lore. Inter-
national Health Exhibition, 1884. Lectures. Ldn. 1884.
[II, 281.]

Blyth, A. W. and M. W. Poisons : their Effects and Detec-
tion. Fifth Edition . . ., revised, enlarged and rewritten.
Ldn. 1920. [II, 281.]

Earlier editions (1884, etc.) were by A. W. Blyth alone.

Boas, Franz. " The Central Eskimo." Sixth Annual Report
of the Bureau of Ethnology to the Secretary of the Smithsonian
Institution, 1884-85, by J. W. Powell, Director. Washing-
ton. 1888. Pp. 399-669. [VIII, 228ft8.]

The above volume has another title-page which describes it as vol. xiv
of The Miscellaneous Documents of the House of Representatives for the
First Session of the Fiftieth Congress, 1887-88. In Twenty-five Volumes.
Washington. 1889.

Boccaccio, G. The Decameron. [I, 26, 44, 69ft2, 120ft1, 145m1,
147ft2, 148ft, 165, 171; II, 10ft, 76ft1, 114ft; III, 44ft1, 60ft1,
118ft1, 126 ; IV, 165ft1, 183 ; V, 13ft1 ; VI, 271 ; VII, 203,
203ft8 ; IX, 69ft2.]

Boccaccio, G. See also under Moutier, I.

Bock, Carl. Temples and Elephants : the Narrative of a
Journey of Exploration through Upper Siam and Lao. Ldn.

t 1884. [VIII, 288w2, 289W1.]

Bodding, O. See under Bompas, C. H.

Boerckel, A. Frauenlob. Mainz. 1881. (2nd edit.) [II, 292n8.]

188 THE OCEAN OF STORY

Bohtlingk, O., and Roth, R. Sanskrit-Worterbuch Her aus-
gegeben von der Kaiserlichen Akademie der Wissenschaften.
7 vols. St Petersburg. 1853-1875. [I, 70ft1 ; II, 53ft2, 67m1,
161 ft1 ; III, 45ft1, 158ft1, 195ft2, 245ft1 ; IV, 33ft1, 41ft1, 91ft2,
122ft2, 168ft1 ; VI, 4ft2, 76ft2, 93ft1, 160ft2 ; VII, 31ft2, 33ft1,
Hon1, 112ft2, 146ft2, 177ft3; VIII, 42ft1, 62ft1, 112ft1, 119ft1,
125ft1, 135ft2, 143ft1, 160ft2, 167ft2, 170ft1, 186ft1; IX, 3ft2,
4ft1, 8ft1, 10ft2, 12ft1, 38ft:i, 42ft1, 52ft1, 53ft1.]

Boiardo, M. M. Orlando Innamorato. [VI, 280ft2.]

Often published with its continuation, the famous Orlando Furioso of Oriosto.
See Panizzi's 9- vol. edit., 1830-1 831.

Bolling, G. M. " Disease and Medicine (Vedic)." Hastings'
Encij. Rel. Eth. Vol. iv. 1911. Pp. 762-772. [Ill, 52ft.]

Bolte, J. " Deutsche Marchen aus dem Nachlasse der Brtider
Grimm." 3 Die getreue Frau. Zeitschrift des Vereins fur
Volkskunde. Vol. xxvi. Berlin. 1916. Pp. 19-42. [IX, 142.]

Bolte, J., and Fischer, H. Die Reise der Sohne Giaffers aus
dem Italienischen des Christoforo Armeno ubersetzt durch
Johann Wetzel 1583 herausgegeben von. . . . Bibliothek des
Litterarisehen Vereins in Stuttgart. Ccviii. Tubingen.
1896. [VI, 287, 287ft2 ; VII, 210?i4.]

This appeared in English as :

The Travels and Adventures of Three Princes of Sarendip.
Intermixed with Eight Delightful and, Entertaining Novels.
Translated from the Persian into French, and from thence
done into English. To which is added Amazonta, or, The
Politick \\ rij x ; a Novel. Ldn. 1722. [VI, 287ft2.]

And in French as :

Voyages et Aventures des Trois Princes de Sarendip. Tra-
duits du Persan ; par le Chevalier de Mailli. Being pp. 223-
480 of : Voyages Imaginaires, Songes, Visions, et Romans
Cabalistiques. Vol. xxv. Amsterdam. 1788.

Bolte, J., and PolIvka, G. Anmerkungen zu den Kinder-
u. Hausmdrchen der Brilder Grimm. 3 vols. Leipzig. 1913,
1915, 1918. Vol. i deals with Grimm, Nos. 1-60 ; vol. ii,
Nos. 61-120 ; and vol. iii, Nos. 121-225. [Ill, 76, 105ft,
188ft, 204, 227ft, 238, 272ft1, 280 ; IV, 117ft1, 129ft, 132ft1,
145ft1 ; V, 3ft1, 66, 79ft3, 100ft1, 117ft1, 153ft1, 157ft1, 267,
275 ; VI, 18ft1, 48ft, 56n2, 61, 98ft1, 122ft2, 263, 273ft3, 274,
274ft2, 275ft2, 291ft1, 291ft3 ; VII, 209ft1, 263ft1 ; VIII, 83ft1,
107ft, 109ft2, 117ft2, 182ft1, 216ft1, 217ft1; IX, 141, 142, 144,
146-149, 155, 164, 165.]

BIBLIOGRAPHY 189

Bolte, J. See also under Kohler, R. ; Paris, G. ; Pauli, J.
Bolton, H. C. Catalogue of Works on Alchemy and Chemistry

exhibited at the Grolier Club. New York. 1891. [Ill, 162w.]
Bompas, C. H. Folklore of the Santal Parganas. Translated

by . . . Ldn. 1909. [I, 46w2, 131 ; III, 76, 182 ; V, 65.]
The tales were collected by Rev. O. Bodding of the Scandinavian Mission.

Bonaparte, Louis Lucien. " Antimony." Being a letter to
the Academy. 23rd Feb. 1884. No. 616. P. 135. [VIII,
65711.]

His chief philological works were in connection with the Basque language.

Bonwick, J. The Last of the Tasmanians, or the Black War of
Van Diemarfs Land. Ldn. 1870. [II, 280w5.]

Bopp, F. Nalus, Carmen Sanscritum. E. Mahdbhdrato :
Edidit, Latine vertit, et Adnotationibus illustravit. Londini,
Parisiis et Argentorati. 1819. [IV, 292.]

Bopp, F. Nalas und Damajanti, eine indische Dichtung aus
dem Sanskrit ubersetzt. Berlin. 1838. [IV, 292.]

Borghini, V. Libro di Novelle, et di bel parlar gentile. Nel
qual si contengono Cento Novelle altravolte mandate fuori da
Messer Carlo Gualteruzzi da Fano. Di Nuovo Ricorrette, con
aggiunta di quattro altre nel fine. Et con una dichiaratione
d'alcune delle voci piu antiche [by Vincenzo Borghini].
Fiorenza. 1572. [IX, 149, 150.] See also under Biagi, G. ;
Gualteruzzi, C. ; and Storer, E.

Born, Dr. " Einige Bemerkungen uber Musik Dichtkunst
und Tanz der Yapleute." Zeitschrift fur Ethnologic Organ
der Berliner Gesellschaft fur Anthropologic, Ethnologie und
Urgeschichte. Vol. xxv. 1903. Berlin. Pp. 134-142. [VIII,
2S2n3.]

Bose, S. C. The Hindoos as they are, with a Preface by Rev. W.
Hastie. London and Calcutta. 1881. [II, 163w.]

Bostock, John. See under Pliny.

Bourke, J. G. Scatologic Rites of all Nations. Washington.
1891. [II, 199n.]

Bowrey, Thomas. See under Temple, R. C, Countries round
the Bay of Bengal.

Br^ekstad, H. L. Fairy Tales by Hans Christian Andersen.
Newly Translated by . . . With an Introduction by Edmund
Gosse. Illustrated by Hans Tegner. 2 vols. (1st and 2nd
Series.) Ldn. 1900. [VI, 292.]

Brand, John. Observations on the Popular Antiquities of
Great Britain : chiefly illustrating the Origin of our Vulgar
and Provincial Customs, Ceremonies, and Superstitions. By

190 THE OCEAN OF STORY

. . . arranged, revised, and greatly enlarged by Sir Henry

Ellis, K.H. ... A New Edition, with Further Additions.

Bonn's Antiquarian Library. 3 vols. Ldn. 1849. [I, 191 ;

II, 99w, 105w ; III, 131n3, 152; IV, 99w2, 199m1; V,

lOOw1, 201n ; VI, 24>n, 136, 149W1.]
Brasseur de Bourbourg. Popol Vuh. Le livre sacre et les

mythes de V antiquite Americaine avec les livres heroiques et

historique des Quiches. Paris. 1861. [II, 309w\]
Brauns, D. Japanische Marchen und Sagen Gesammelt und

herausgegeben von . . . Leipzig. 1885. [VIII, 231 w4.]
Brereton, C. See under Bergson, H.
Brewer, E. C. Dictionary of Phrase and Fable, giving the

Derivation, Source, or Origin of Common Phrases, Allusions,

and Words that have a Tale to Tell. New Edition, Revised,

Corrected, and Enlarged. . . . Ldn. 1895. [I, 109W1 ;

II, 271 ; III, Win1 ; VIII, 154w2.]

The first edition (undated) appeared in 1870, while the most recent one was

issued in 1928.

Bricteux, A. Contes persans. Traduits pour la premiere fois
sur un manuscrit inedit de la Bibliotheque de Berlin par . . .
Avec preface de Victor Chauvin. Bibliotheque de la
Faculte de Philosophic et Lettres de FUniversite de Liege.
Fasc. 19. (Academia Leodiensis.) Paris and Liege. 1910.
[VIII, 227n2.]

Bridges, J. H. The ''''Opus Majus" of Roger Bacon. Edited
with Introduction and Analytical Table by ... 2 vols.
Oxford. 1897. (Supplemental vol. Ldn. 1900.) [II, 100n.]

Briffault, R. The Mothers, a Study of the Origins of Senti-
ments and Institutions. 3 vols. Ldn. 1927. [IX, 17ns, 143,
144, 147, 148, 153, 154.]

Briganti, A. Due libri delV Historia de i Semplici, Aromati,
et altre cose, che vengono portate dalV Indie Orientalis, per-
tinenti alia medicina, di Don Garzia dalV Horto, Medico
Portughese ; con alcune breui annotationi di Carlo Clusio.
Et due altri libri parimente di quelle che si portano dalV Indie
Occidentali, di Nicolo Monardes. . . . Hora tutti tradotti
dalle loro lingue nella nostra Italiana da. . . . Venice.
1576. [VIII, 245.]

Brisard, C. V Eternuement. Lyon. [1896.] [Ill, 315.]

Briscoe, J. P. Nottinghamshire Facts and Fictions : a
Miscellany of Curious Manners and Customs, Legends,
Traditions and Anecdotes. . . . Collected and Edited by . . .
Two Series. Nottingham. 1876, 1877. [IV, 99w2.]

BIBLIOGRAPHY 191

Brisson, B. Barnabce Brissonii Senatus Parisiensis Prcesidis

De Regio Persarum Principatu Libri Tres, post CL.

Sylbvrgii editionem. . . . Argentorati. [Strassburg.] 1710.

Edited by J. H. Lederlini. [Ill, 329.]
Britten, James. Remaines of Gentilisme and Judaisme. By

John Aubrey, R.S.S. 1686-1687. Edited and Annotated

by . . . Folk-Lore Society. Ldn. 1881. [VIII, I00n.]
Brix, Hans. H. C. Andersen og hans Eventyr. Copenhagen.

1907. [VI, 290ft1, 293.]
Brock, Irving. See under Constable, A.
Brockelmann, C. " Kalila Wa-Dimna." Ency. of Islam.

No. 28. 1924. Pp. 694-698. [V, 234, 236, 239, 240.]
Bromyard, Joannes de. Summa prcedicantium . . . expli-

cans prcecipuos Catholicce disciplines sensus . . . recognita

et . . . ducta . . . [by A. Ritius]. 2 parts. Venetia. 1586.

(The colophon of each part bears the date 1585.) [II, 114w.]

The 1st edit, of Nurnberg, 1485, had a different title-page.

Brouwer, P. van Limburg. Akbar, an Eastern Romance.

Ldn. 1879. [I, 159ft1.]
Brown, George. Melanesians and Polynesians. Their Life-
Histories Described and Compared. Ldn. 1910. [Ill, 314,

314ft1 ; VIII, 317ft1.]
Brown, R. Annual Report on the Munnipore Political Agency

for 1868-69. Selections from the Records of the Government

of India, Foreign Department. No. lxxviii. Statistical

Account of Manipur. 1874. [VIII, 286n3.]
Brown, R. Grant. " The Pre-Buddhist Religion of the

Burmese." Folk-Lore. June 1921. Vol.xxxii. Pp. 77-100.

[II, 265ft1.]
Brown, W. N. " The Paficatantra in Modern Indian

Folk-Lore." Journ. Amer. Orient. Soc. Vol. xxxix. 1919.

[V, 48ft1, 49ft1, 63ft1, 64.]
Brown, W. N. " Escaping One's Fate : A Hindu Paradox

and its Use as a Psychic Motif in Hindu Fiction." Studies

in Honor of Maurice Bloomfield. New Haven, London,

Oxford. 1920. Pp. 89-104. [V, 186m1; VI, 92n2 ; IX,

25n\]
Brown, W. N. " Change in Sex as a Hindu Story Motif."

Journ. Amer. Orient. Soc. Vol. xlvii. 1927. Pp. 3-24.

[IX, 162, 163.]
Browne, Edward Gaylord. See under Blair, E. H., and

Robertson, J. A.

192 THE OCEAN OF STORY

Browne, Thomas. Pseudodoxia Epidemica: or, Enquiries
into very many received Tenets, and commonly presumed
Truths. Ldn. 1646. [Ill, 30n\ 167w2 ; V, 135n ; VIII,
75n\ 156nS 195n\]

The above work is commonly referred to as Browne's Vulgar Errors. Refer-
ence should be made to G. Keynes, A Bibliography of Sir Thomas Browne,
Cambridge, 1924, pp. 48-65. Forerunners and imitators of" Vulgar Errors "
are given on pp. 210-220.

Bruce, C. Die Geschichte von Nala. Versuch einer Herstellung
des Textes. St Petersburg. 1862. [IV, 292.]

Brueyre, Loys. " Traditions Populaires du Bannu (Pend-
jab)." Melusine. Vol. i. Paris. 1878. Cols. 177-180. [V,
127ft1.]

Brugmann, K. Kurze vergleichende Grammatik der indo-
germanischen Sprachen. Auf Grund des funfbdndigen
" Grundrisses der vergleichenden Grammatik der indoger-
manischen Sprachen von K. Brugmann und B. Delbruck "
verfasst. 3 Lfgn. Strassburg. 1902-1904. [I, 198.]

Brumund, J. F. G. See under Leemans, C.

Brunet, J. C. Manuel du libraire et de Vamateur des livres.
3 vols. Paris. 1810. [IX, 150.]

The 5th edition (1860-1865) was in 6 vols., with a Supplement by
P. Deschamps and G. Brunet. 1878-1880. A German zinco reprint has
recently appeared.

Brunet, J. C, and Montaiglon, A. de. Li Romans de Dolo-
pathos publie pour la premiere fois en entier aVapres Les Deux
manuscrits de la Bibliotheque Imperial par . . . [Herbert's
or Herbers' version.] Paris. 1856. [V, 260, 262, 263, 274.]

Brunet, P. G. Le Violier des Histories Romaines, Ancienne
traduction francaise des Gesta Romanorum, nouvelle edition,
revue et annotee par . . . Paris. 1858. [II, 289w2.]

Brunet, P. G. L'Elite des Contes du Sieur d'Ouville, re-
imprimee sur Vedition de Rouen, 1860. Avec une Preface
et des Notes par ... 2 vols. Paris. 1883. [VII, 209rc2.]

Brunetto, Latini. See under Chabaille, P.; and
D'Ancona, A.

Buddhaghosa. The Visuddhimagga. [VIII, 254n2.]

See edition by C. A. F. Rhys Davids, 2 vols., Ldn., Pah Text Society,
1901-1921.

Budge, E. A. Wallis. Osiris and the Egyptian Resurrection.

2 vols. Ldn. 1911. Medici Society. [IV, 257 ; V, 254 ;

VIII, 75nK]
Buerger, G. A. Leonora. [VI, 138.]

Numerous editions. I have used one in German and English, translated
by W. R. Spencer, Ldn., 1796.

BIBLIOGRAPHY 193

Buhler, J. G. Vikramdnkadevacharita. Edited, with an
Introduction, by . . . Bengal Sanskrit Series. No. xiv.
Bombay. 1875. [II, 174W1.]

Buhler, J. G. The Laws of Manu, with Extracts from Seven
Commentaries. Translated by . . . The Sacred Books of the
East. Vol. xxv. Oxford. 1886. [1,87,205; 11,275,275^.]

Buhler, J. G. " On the Vrihatkatha of Kshemendra."
Indian Antiquary. 4th Oct.' 1872. Vol. i. Pp. 302-309.
[V, 212.]

Buhler, J. G., and Kielhorn, F. Panchatantra. [Textus
Simplicior.] Edited, with Notes, by . . . Bombay Sanskrit
Series. 1868 and 1869. [V, 216.]

Buhler, J. G., and Peterson, P. The Dasakumdracharita
of Dandin. Edited, with Critical and Explanatory Notes,
... 2 pts. Bombay Sanskrit Series. Nos. x and xlii.
Dept. Pub. Inst., Bombay. 1873 and 1891. [I, 234w4.]

Buhler, J. G. See under Jolly, J. ; and Macdonell, A. A.

Buret, F. La Syphilis Aujourd'hui et chez les Anciens. Paris.
1890. [II, 308n2.]

Burgess, J. See under Fergusson, J.

Burlingame, E. W. Buddhist Legends translated from the
original Pali text of the Dhammapada Commentary. 3 vols.
1921. Cambridge, Massachusetts. Harvard Oriental Series.
Vols, xxviii, xxix, xxx. [VII, 221; VIII, 254w2; IX,
119ft1.]

Burlingame, E. W. " The Act of Truth (Saccakiriya) ; a
Hindu Spell and its Employment as a Psychic Motif in
Hindu Fiction." Journ. Roy. As. Soc. July 1917. Pp. 429-
467. [I, 166 ; II, 31, 33 ; III, 179, 182.]

Burnell, A. C. The Sdmavidhdnabrdhmana. . . . Edited,
. . . with the Commentary of Sdyana, an English Transla-
tion, Introduction and Index of Words, by . . . Ldn. 1873.
[I, 12H1.]

Burnell, A. C. On the Aindra School of Sanskrit Gram-
marians, their Place in the Sanskrit and Subordinate
Literatures. Mangalore. 1875. [I, 32/11.]

Burnell, A. C. The Voyage of John Huyghen Van Linschoten
to the East Indies. From the Old English Translation of 1598.
The First Book, containing his Description of the East. In
two volumes. Edited, the First Volume, by the late Arthur
Coke Burnell, Ph.D., CLE. . . ., the Second Volume, by

t Mr P. A. Tiele of Utrecht. 2 vols. Hakluyt Society. Ldn.
1885. They form Nos. lxx and lxxi of the First Series.
[VIII, 259, 259n\]

VOL. IX. N

194 THE OCEAN OF STORY

Burnell, A. C. Letter on the Brihat-kathd-manjari to the

editor. The Academy. Vol. ii. 15th Sept. 1871. P. 447.

[V, 211, 212.]
Burnell, A. C. See also under Yule, H., and Burnell,

A. C, Hobson-J obson.
Burnouf, E. Bhdgavata Pur ana, on Histoire Poetique de

Krishna, traduit et publie par ... 4 vols, (folio). Paris.

1840-1884. [I, 5n\]
Burnouf, E. Introduction a VHistoire du Buddhisme Indien.

Vol. i. Paris. 1844. [VIII, 71n2.]

See note to Burnouf 's Le Lotus de la Bonne hoi. The second edition of the
above work formed vol. iii of the " Bibliotheque Orientale."

Burnouf, E. [Saddharma-pundarika.] Le Lotus de la Bonne
Lot, traduit du Sanskrit, accompagne d'un commentaire et
de vingt et un memoires relatifs au Buddhisme. Paris.
1852. [IV, 23n2 ; IX, 23nK]

The above work is a continuation of Introduction a VHistoire du Buddhisme
Indien, and contains an Index to both works. It was reprinted in 1925.

Burnouf, E. " Nala, episode du Mahabharata," Extrait de

Mem. de VAcademie de Stanislas. 1855. Nancy. 1856.

(Pp. 189-278.) [IV, 292.]
Burton, J. H. Narratives from Criminal Trials in Scotland.

2 vols. Ldn. 1852. [I, 191.]
Burton, R. F. Goa, and the Blue Mountains; or, Six

Months of Sick Leave. Ldn. 1851. [11,19.]
Burton, R. F. Personal Narrative of a Pilgrimage to El-

Medinah and Meccah. 3 vols. Ldn. 1855-1856. Vol. i —

El-Misr; vol. ii — El-Medinah; vol. iii — Meccah. [I, 192;

II, 271.]
Burton, R. F. First Footsteps in East Africa; or, An

Exploration of Harar. Ldn. 1856. [II, 271n2.]
Burton, R. F. The City of the Saints and Across the Rocky

Mountains to California. Ldn. 1861. [II, 280, 280w3.]
Burton, R. F. A Mission to Gelele, King of Dahome. With

Notices of the So-called "Amazons," the Grand Customs, the

Yearly Customs, the Human Sacrifices, the Present State of

the Slave Trade, and the Negro's Place in Nature. 2 vols.

Ldn. 1864. [I, 278, 278m1.]
Burton, R. F. Wit and Wisdom from West Africa ; or, A

Book of Proverbial Philosophy, Idioms, Enigmas, and

Laconisms. Ldn. 1865. [Ill, 313, 313n3.]
Burton, R. F. Vikram and the Vampire ; or Tales of Hindu

Devilry. Adapted by . . . with thirty-three Illustrations

BIBLIOGRAPHY 195

by Ernest Griset. Ldn. 1870. [I, 87, 136w2; VI, 226, 227,

227n\]

The above work first appeared in serial form in Fraser's Magazine for Town
and Country, vols, lxxvii and lxxviii, 1868. It was reprinted in the " Memorial
Edition " of Burton's Works in 1893.

Burton, R. F. Camoens. The Lyricks. Part I. [Part II.]
(Sonnets , Canzons, Odes, and Sextines.) Englished by . . .
2 vols. Ldn. 1884. [VIII, 240nx.]

The above volumes form vols, v and vi of what was to have been a complete
translation of all the writings of Camoens. Six volumes only appeared, the first
four of which were as follows : Os Lusiadas {The Lusiads). ... 2 vols. Ldn.
1880. Camoens: His Life and his Lusiads. A Commentary. 2 vols. Ldn. 1881.

Burton, R. F. The Book of the Sword. By . . . Maitre
D'Armes (Brevete). With numerous illustrations. Ldn.
1884. [I, 109W1.]

This was the only published volume of the three that were originally in-
tended. For details of the material left for the other two vols, see my Burton
Bibliography, pp. 108-112.

Burton, R. F. A Plain and Literal Translation of the Arabian
Nights' Entertainments, Now Entituled The Book of the
Thousand Nights and a Night. With Introduction, Explana-
tory Notes on the Manners and Customs of Moslem Men and
a Terminal Essay upon the History of the Nights. 10 vols.
Benares. 1885. Printed by the Kamashastra Society for
Private Subscribers only. This was followed by : Supple-
mental Nights to the Book of The Thousand Nights and a
Night. With Notes Anthropological and Explanatory. 6 vols.
Benares. 1886-1888.

The latter six volumes are easily distinguished at sight from the previously
issued ten volumes, by having a silver diagonal band across the volume, while
the others had a gold band. " Benares " is a synonym for Stoke Newington.
The following references in the Ocean are to the Nights as a whole — 16 vols.

[I, In1, 14n, 25, 27, 28, 30n2, 43, 4>7n, SOn1, 82n, lOlra1, 103,
105, 120m1, 124W1, 131, 133m1, 141w2, 144m1, 163n, 167, 170,
183W1, 186nS 204, 217 ; II, lOn, 58n\ 104n, 104nJ, 123, 124,
131ns 147m1, 153n, 169, 190m1, 193nx, 201n3, 202W1, 218w3,
219w3, 220n, 223W1, 224n ; III, 56, 60, 68W1, 76, 95n\ lOln,
105w, 115W1, 118nx, 203, 227n, 260n\ 260n2, 268nx, 279, 308,
308w4, 328; IV, 2ln, 90n\ 108n2, 132W1, 192nS 249w; V,
13n\ 43n\ 65, 66, 97m1, 122/i1, 177, 181w2 ; VI, 8, 23ft1, 37W1,
61, 62, 63, 74w, lOOw1, 240, 255, 256, 258, 260, 260W1, 274,
275n\ 286, 286m1 ; VII, 24W1, 56w, 88w2, 203, 217, 224, 224n3,
245, 249, 258 ; VIII, 93w2, 158n2, 161w2, 219, 227w8, 302711 ;
IX, S7n\ 4>5n\ S5nK]

In view of a criticism on my quoting from the rare original edition of the
Nights instead of the " more accessible " 12-vol. Burton-Smithers edition, I

196 THE OCEAN OF STORY

would here state that, owing to the thousands of cheap American " facsimile "
reprints, there are very many more copies with the original pagination in
circulation than of the 12- vol. edition. It should, however, be remembered
that the original bulky Supplemental vol. hi was published in all reprints (except
the Denver edition) as two distinct volumes with continuous pagination.
Thus these reprints appeared in 17 volumes. Consequently Supp. vols, iv, v
and vi of the original edition correspond to vols, v, vi and vii of the reprints.
For full details of every edition and issue of the Nights see my Bibliography of
SirR. F. Burton, pp. 113-149..

Burton, R. F. II Pentamerone : or, The Tale of Tales. Being
a Translation by the late Sir Richard Burton, K.C.M.G., of
II Pentamerone ; Overo Lo Cunto De Li Cunte, Trattene-
miento De Li Peccerille, of Giovanni Battista Basile, Count
of Torone (Gian Alessio Abbattutis). 2 vols. Ldn. 1893. [I,
26, 77ft1, 97ft2 ; II, 5ft1, 190ft1, 253 ; III, 20m1, 21ft, 28ft1,
48ft1, 105n, 226ft2, 238, 239, 272ft1, 285ft1, 292ft1 ; V, lift1,
158ft, 172ft ; VI, 16ft, 47ft1, 48ft, 200ft3, 263 ; VII, 42ft1,
162ft1 ; VIII, 69ft1 ; IX, 78ft.] See also under Basile,
Giovanni Battista.

The pagination runs straight through both volumes.

Burton, R. F. " Notes on an Hermaphrodite." Memoirs
read before the Anthropological Society of London. Vol. ii.
1865-1866. Pp. 262, 263. [VII, 233ft1.]

Burton, R. F. See also under Nefzaoui ; and Penzer, N. M.

[Burton, R. F., and Arbuthnot, F. F.] The Kama Sutra of
Vatsyayana. Translated from the Sanscrit. In Seven Parts,
with Preface, Introduction, and Concluding Remarks. Re-
print : Cosmopoli : 1833 : for the Kama Shastra Society
of London and Benares, and for private circulation only.
[I, 234ft2.]

The above is from the title-page of the first issue of the second edition, the
first being issued in seven parts, and of extreme rarity. For details see my
Annotated Bibliography of Sir Richard F. Burton, 1923, pp. 161-171.

[Burton, R. F., and Arbuthnot, F. F.] Ananga-Ranga ;
(Stage of the Bodiless One), or, The Hindu Art of Love. (Ars
Amoris Indica.) Translated from the Sanskrit, and Anno-
tated by A. F. F. and B. R. F. Reprint Cosmopoli : 1885 :
for the Kama Shastra Society of London and Benares, and
for private circulation only. [I, 236ft3 ; V, 193.]

The author of the work was Kalyana Malla.

[Burton, R. F., and Smithers, L. C] Priapeia or the Sportive

Epigrams of divers Poets on Priapus : the Latin Text now

for the first time Englished in Verse and Prose (the Metrical

Version by " Outidanos "), with Introduction, Notes Ex-

BIBLIOGRAPHY 197

planatory and Illustrative, and Excursus by " Neaniskos."
Cosmopoli. 1890. [Ill, 328.]

" Cosmopoli " is, of course, a name that can apply to anywhere. In this case
it was London. I have given full details of the history and different issues of
the work in my Annotated Bibliography of Sir Richard F. Burton, pp. 150-158.

Bushby, H. J. Widow-Burning. A Narrative. Ldn. 1855.

[IV, 272.]
Bushell, S. W. Chinese Art. Board of Education, South

Kensington, Victoria and Albert Museum. 2 vols. Ldn.

1904, 1906. (Revised editions : 1909 and 1921.) [II, 264.]
[Busk, R. H.] Sagas from the Far East ; or, Kalmouk and

Mongolian Traditionary Tales. With Historical Preface and

Explanatory Notes. By the author of " Patrailas," " House-
hold Stories from the Land of Hofer," etc. Ldn. 1873.

[I, 25, 27, 39w2, 162W1 ; II, 5n\ 52n12 ; III, 4>Sn\ 75, 142m1,

182, 195W1, 204, 218nx ; V, 63nx, 77n\ 153n\ 157wx ; VI, lS2n\

lS6n\ 242, 248, 264, 269rc2 ; VII, 2S5n2 ; VIII, 59n3.] See

also under Julg, B.
Busk, R. H. The Folk-Lore of Rome, collected by word of mouth

from the people. Ldn. 1874. [I, 20n, 26, 132.]
Butler, Samuel. Hudibras. [II, 302 ; VI, 24n.]
Butterworth, H. Zigzag Journeys in India ; or, The

Antipodes of the Far East. A Collection of Zenana Tales.

Boston. 1887. [IV, 48 ; V, 49ft1.]
Buxton, L. H. Dudley. " Some Navajo Folktales and

Customs." Folk-Lore. Vol. xxiv. No. 4. December 1923.

Pp. 293-313. [Ill, 268n1.]
C. B. "What I saw of the Sandalwood Trade." The Leisure

Hour. Part 213. No. 925. Ldn. 18th Sept. 1869. Pp. 598-

600. [VII, 107.]
Cabanes, A. " Dieu vous benisse ! (Origine d'un dicton)."

Mosurs intimes du Passe. Series I. Pp. 125-149. Paris.

[1908.] [Ill, 315.]

Series 2 came out in 1909» Series 3 in 1910, and so on. The 8th Series was
published in 1923.

Cahier, C. Caracteristiques des Saints dans Vart populaire,

enumerees et expliquees. 2 vols. Paris. 1867. [Ill, 20m1.]
Caland, W. Altindisches Zauberritual ; Probe einer tJberset-

zung der wichtigste Theile des Kauscka Sutra. Amsterdam.

1900. [VI, 149W1.]
Caland, W. " Zur Exegese und Kritik der rituellen Sutras."

Zeitsch. d. d. morg. Gesell. Vol. lxii. Leipzig. 1908. Pp. 123-

131. [II, 232n.]

198 THE OCEAN OF STORY

Caland, W. Savitri und Nala. Utrecht. 1917. [Not seen by

me.] [IX, 155.]
Callaway, C. H. Nursery Tales, Traditions, and Histories

of the Zulus, in their own words, with a Translation, into

English, and Notes, by . . . Natal and London. 1868.

[VIII, 227rc10.]
Callaway, C. H. The Religious System of the Amazulu.

Natal, Springvale, etc. 1868-1870. (Incomplete.) [111,313,

313n4.]
Calmet, A. Traite sur les apparitions des esprits et sur les

vampires. 2 vols. Paris. 1751. [VI, 140.]

For an English trans, see The Phantom World, with notes by H. Christmas.
2 vols. Ldn. 1850.

Calmette, R. Les Venins, les animaux venimeux et la sero-

therapie antivenimeuse. Paris. 1907. [II, 281.]
Camoens. See under Burton, R. F.
Campbell, D. M. Java : Past and Present. A Description of

the Most Beautiful Country in the World, its Ancient History,

People, Antiquities, and Products. 2 vols. Ldn. 1915. [VIII,

295w3.]
Campbell, J. F. Popular Tales of the West Highlands. 4 vols.

Edinburgh. 2nd edit. 1890-1893. [I, 26, 84rc2, 129, 132,

141n2, 157m2, 163m1 ; III, 195W1, 205, 231W1, 237, 272m1 ;

IV, 67W1 ; V, 46W1, 157W1 ; VI, 5n* ; IX, 165.]
Campbell, J. G. D. Superstitions of the Highlands and Islands

of Scotland. Glasgow. 1900. [VI, 135.]
Campbell, J. G. D. Siam in the Twentieth Century. Being

the Experiences and Impressions of a British Official. Ldn.

1902. [VIII, 289w2.]
Campbell, J. M. Gazetteer of the Bombay Presidency. 26 vols.

Bombay. 1877-1901. [VII, 26, 230.]

Several volumes are in two parts. The General Index forms vol. xxvii, and
is the work of R. E. Enthoven. 1904.

Campbell, J. M. Notes on the Spirit Basis of Belief and

Custom. Bombay. 1885. [II, 167, 229rc2 ; III, 37.]
Campbell, Killis. A Study of the Romance of the Seven Sages

of Rome, with Special Reference to the Middle English

Versions. Baltimore. 1898. [V, 263711.]
Campbell, Killis. The Seven Sages of Rome. Edited from

the Manuscripts, with Introduction, Notes, and Glossary by

. . . The Albion Series. Boston, New York, Chicago. Ldn.

1907. [V, 128n, 138m1, 260n\ 263, 264, 266n\ 267 ; VI,

272w4, 294n2.]
Campbell Thompson. See under Thompson, R. Campbell.

BIBLIOGRAPHY 199

Canney, M. A. " Ashes." Hastings' Ency, Rel. Eth. Vol. ii.
1909. Pp. 112-114. [IX, 68w2.]

Canney, M. A. See also under Crawley, A. E. ; Beet,
W. E. ; and Canney, M. A.

Capua, John of. See under John of Capua.

Cardonne. See under Galland and Cardonne.

Carey, W., and Marshman, J. The Ramayuna of Valmeeki
in Sungskrit, with Translation and Notes by ... 3 vols.
Serampore. 1806-1810. [I, In2.]

Carlill, James. Physiologus. Translated, with an Introduc-
tion, by . . . Being pp. 153-250 of: The Epic of the Beast, in
"Broadway Translations." Ldn. [1924.] [1,104; IX, 165.]

The above is the most recent translation of Physiologus. Reference should
be made also to E. Legrand's edition of the original, Paris, 1873 ; and A. S.
Cook, The Old English Elene, Phcenix, and Physiologus, New Haven, 1919-

Carne, J. Letters from the East. 3rd edit. 2 vols. Ldn. 1830.

[VI, lOOw1.]
Carnoy, E. H. Litter ature or ale de la Picardie. Paris. 1883.

Forming vol. xiii of " Les Litteratures pop. de toutes les

nations." [Ill, 105w, 311w5.]
Carnoy, E. H. Contes Francais recueillis par . . . Paris.

1885. Forming vol. viii of " Collection de Contes et de

Chansons pop." [I, 26.]
Carnoy, E. H. "La Montagne Noire ou Les Filles du Diable.

Conte Picard." Conte en aout 1877 par Ladent Alphonse.

Melusine. Vol. i. Paris. 1878. Cols. 446-451. [II, 190W1 ;

III, 238 ; VII, 126n2.]
Carnoy, E. See under Certeuse, A., and Carnoy, E. H.
Carpenter, G. H. " Ichneumon." Ency. Brit. 11th edit.

Vol. xiv. Pp. 242, 243. [Ill, 115m1.]
Carra de Vaux, Bon B. VAbrege des Merveilles traduit de

VArabe d'apres les Manuscrits de la Bibliotheque Nationale

de Paris. Paris. 1898. [VIII, 227w3.]
Carra de Vaux, Bov B. " Alchemy (Muhammadan)."

Hastings' Ency. Bel. Eth. Vol. i. 1908. Pp. 289-292.

[Ill, 162w.]
Carter, A. C. The Kingdom ofSiam. Ministry of Agriculture,

Louisiana. Purchase Exposition St Louis, U.S.A. Siamese

Section. Edited by . . . New York, Ldn. 1904. [VIII,

289n2.]
Cartwright, T. See under Tawney, C. H., Richard the Third.
Cary, H. Herodotus. A New and Literal Version from the Text

of Baehr. . . . Bohn's Classical Library. Ldn. 1877. [V,

245711.]

200 THE OCEAN OF STORY

Casas, F. B. de las. Historiadores de Indias. Tomo I — Apolo-
getica Historia de las Indias. . . . Madrid. 1909. [II,
309ft1.]

The above forms vol. xiii of Nueva Biblioteca de Autores Espanoles.

Cassel, P. An Explanatory Commentary on Esther. Edin-
burgh. 1888. [VI, 74m.]

Castren, M. A. Ethnologischen Vorlesungen uber die alta-
ischen Volker nebst samojedischen Mdrchen und tatarischen
Heldensagen. St Petersburg. 1857. [VIII, 228ft1.]

The above work forms vol. iv of Nordische Reisen und Forschungen, 12 vols.,
1852-1858. A Swedish edition was issued in Helsingfors, 6 vols., 1852-1870.

Catullus. Carmina. [Ill, 311, 311ft2.]

Cavallius, G. O. See under Hylten-Cavallius, G. O.

Cayley- Webster, H. Through New Guinea and the Cannibal

Countries. Ldn. 1898. [VIII, 317ft1.]
Cazotte, Jacques. See under Chavis, Dom, and Cazotte,

Jacques.
Cecioni, G. "II Secretum Secretorum attribuito ad

Aristotile e le sue Redazioni Volgari." 17 Propugnatore.

Periodico Bimestrale. Vol. ii. Pt. ii. Pp. 72-102. Bologna.

1889. [II, 289ft2.]
Cento Novelle Antiche. See under Biagi, Guido ;

Borghini, V. ; Gualteruzzi, Carlo ; and Storer, E.
Cerquand, J. F. " Les Sirenes." Revue Archeologique. New

Series. Vol. x. 1846. Pp. 282-303. [VI, 282ft6.]
Certeux, A., and Carnoy, E. H. Contributions au Folk-Lore

des Arabes. UAlgerie Traditionnelle Legendes, Contes,

Chansons, Musique, Moeurs, Coutumes, Fetes, Croyances,

Superstitions, etc. Vol. i. Paris, Alger. 1884. [Apparently

all published.] [VIII, 227ft7.]
Cervera, Guillem de. See under Thomas, A.
Chabaille, P. Li Livres dou Tresor par Brunetto Latini.

Publie pour la premiere fois oVapres les manuscrits de la

Bibliotheque Imperiale de la Bibliotheque de V Arsenal. . . .

Collection de Documents Inedits sur l'Histoire de France.

2nd Series [printed wrongly as "Premiere Serie." Paris.

1863. [II, 299ft1.]

The reference to basilisks is in Bk. i, pt. 5, ch. cxli, pp. 192, 193.

Chakladar, H. " Vatsyayana — the Author of the Kama-
sutra : Date and Place of Origin." Journ. Dept. Letters
University of Calcutta. Vol. iv. 1921. Pp. 85-122. [V, 193.]

Chakravarti, S. C. Mvdrarakshasam [of Visdkhadatta].
With Sanskrit Text, Notes and Translation. Calcutta.
1908. [II, 283ft3, 284.]

BIBLIOGRAPHY 201

Chalmers, R. See under Cowell, E. B.

Chamberlain, A. F. " Disease and Medicine (American)."

Hastings' Ency. Rel. Eth. Vol. iv. 1911. Pp. 731-741.

[IX, 148.]
Chamberlain, B. H. " Ko-Ji-Ki ... or Records of Ancient

Matters." Trans. As. Soc. Japan. Vol. x. Supplement.

Yokohama. 1882. Index by N. Walter and A. Lloyd.

Tokyo. 1906. [VII, 238, 238n2.]

The work was reprinted, complete with index, in 1920.

Chamberlain, H. R. M. The Eunuch in Society. Ldn. 1927.
[IX, 153.]

Champault, Philippe. Pheniciens et Grecs en Italie, d'apris
VOdyssee. Etude geographique, historique et sociale, par une
methode nouvelle. Paris. 1906. [VIII, 56n2.]

Chanakya. See under Kautilya.

Chandra Mitra, S. See under Mitra, Sarat Chandra.

Chatterji, K. K. Syphilis in General Practice, with special
reference to the Tropics. Calcutta. 1920. [II, 30Sn2.]

Chau, Ju-Kua. See under Hirth, F., and Rogkhill, W. W.

Chaucer, Geoffrey. The Canterbury Tales. " Tale (or Rime)
of Sir Thopas." [Ill, 82n2.] " Clerk's Tale." [Ill, 221^.]
" Squire's Tale." [1, 145nx; III, 40m1 ; IV, 145nx ; V, 27n2.]
"Franklin's Tale." [VII, 203, 204.] The Hous of Fame. [II,
219w3.]

Chaucer, Geoffrey. See also under Schofield, W. H. ; and
Skeat, W, W.

Chauvin, Victor. Bibliographic des Ouvrages Arabes ou
Relatifs aux Arabes publies dans V Europe Chretienne de 1810
a 1885. 11 Parts. Liege and Leipzig. 1892-1909. The
sub-titles of the various parts are as follows : I. Preface
— Table de Schnurrer — Les Proverbes. II. Kalilah. III.
Louqmane et les fabulistes — Barlaam — 'Antar et les
romans de chevalerie. IV. Les Mille et une nuits. (Pre-
miere partie.) V. Les Mille et une nuits. (Deuxieme partie.)
VI. Les Mille et une nuits. (Troisieme partie.) VII. Les
Mille et une nuits. (Quatrieme partie.) VIII. Syntipas.
IX. Pierre Alphonse — Secundus — Recueils orientaux —
Tables de Henning et de Mardrus — Contes occidentaux —
Les maqames. X. Le Cor an et la Tradition. XI. Ma-
homet. [I, 27, 28, lOln1, 105, 128m1, 168, 171, 186ns ^S9n ;
II, 46w3, 58W1, 108w, 122, 131m1, lS6n\ 147W1, 151w2, 190W1,

, 193m1, 202nx, 224n ; III, 4n», 21w, 68n, 76, 82w2, 105w, 127,
167w2, 191nS 204, 227w, 260W1, 272nJ ; IV, 48, 132W1, 235w2,
249w; V, 3n\ 16n\ 66, 87n\ 94w2, lOln1, 122na, 133n,

202 THE OCEAN OF STORY

147711, 153W1, 177, 181w2, ISSn1, 210, 219, 220nx, 232, 234-
242, 266 ; VI, 16n, 18n\ 56w2, 62, 74n, 84W1, 188nl, 241,
249, 256, 260, 260nx, 273n2, 275rcx, 287, 287wx ; VII, 52n2,
82n, 160nS 203n6, 213, 224w2, 252ft1; VIII, 107w, 219,
227w3 ; IX, 22ft1, 38ft2, 82m1, 142, 153, 155, 161.]

Chauvin, V. " Les Obstacles Magiques." Revue des Tradi-
tions Populaires. Tome xvi. No. 11. Nov. 1901. Pp. 537,
538. [Ill, 238.]

Chauvin, V. See also under Bricteux, A.

Chavannes, E. Cinq cent contes et apologues extraits du Tripi-
taka chinois et traduits en frangais. 3 vols. Paris. 1910-
1911. [V, 63ft1 ; IX, 149, 160.]

Chavis, Dom, and Cazotte, Jacques. La Suite des Mille
et une nuits. Forming vols, xxxviii-xli of Le Cabinet
des Fees, ou Collection choisie des contes des fees, et autres
contes merveilleux. 41 vols. Geneve. 1785-1789. [VII,
245, 245ft4.]

Cheikho, L. Kalilah wa-Dimnah. . . . Beyrouth. 1905.
(2nd edit. 1923.) [V, 236.]

Chenery, T. The Assemblies of Al-Hariri, translated from the
Arabic, with an Introduction and Notes, Historical and
Grammatical, by . . . Vol. i. Containing the First Twenty-
six Assemblies. Ldn. 1867. Bound up later as part of the
Oriental Translation Fund. New Series. Roy. Asiatic
Society. 1898. Reprinted 1926. [Ill, 278.]

The second half of the work appeared as : The Assemblies of Al Hariri.
Translated from the Arabic, with Notes, Historical and Grammatical. By
Dr F. Steingass. . . . Prefaced and Indexed by F. F. Arbuthnot. . . . Vol. ii.
Containing the Last Twenty-four Assemblies. Orient. Trans. Fund. New
Series. Roy. As. Soc. 1898.

Chevalier de Mailli. See under Bolte, J., and Fischer H.

(French version.)
Cheyne, T. K. " Jonah." Ency. Brit. 11th edit. Vol. xv.

Pp. 496, 497. [II, 194n.]
Ch(h)atre Sadas(h)iv. See Sadasiv Chhatre.
Chignell, A. K. An Outpost in Papua. With a Preface

by the Archbishop of Brisbane. . . . Ldn. 1911. [VIII,

317n\]
Child, F. J. The English and Scotch Popular Ballads. 10 parts.

Boston. 1882-[1898]. [II, 76W1.]
Chilli, Shaik. Folk-Tales of Hindustan. Allahabad. 1908.

[I, 131 ; III, 272m1 ; VII, 256.]

A second edition appeared in 1913. The collection consists of eleven tales,
ten of which had previously appeared in the Modern Review.

BIBLIOGRAPHY 203

Chinnery, E. W. Pearson. " Piper Methysticum in Betel-
Chewing." Man. Vol. xxii. No. 2. Feb. 1922. Pp. 24-27.
[VIII, 311, 311W1, 312, 313.]

Christensen, G. " H. C. Andersen og de Danske Folke-
eventyr." Danske Studier. Copenhagen. 1906. Y.lQSetseq.
[VI, 290, 290w2, 292, 293.]

Christian, F. W. The Caroline Islands. Travel in the Sea of
the Little Lands. Ldn. 1899. [VIII, 308ft1.]

Chudjakov, J. A. Velikorusskija skazki. 3 vols. Moscow.
1860-1862. [VIII, 227n6.]

Chunder, Bholanauth. The Travels of a Hindoo to various
Parts of Bengal and Upper India. With an Introduction
by Talboys Wheeler. 2 vols. Ldn. 1869. [I, 238W1.]

Cicero. De Officiis. [II, 277.] Tusculanoe Disputationes.
[V, 257.]

Clark, K. M. Maori Tales and Legends. Ldn. 1896. [VI,
135.]

Clark, W. E. " Sakadvipa and Svetadvipa." Journ. Amer.
Orient. Soc. Vol. xxxix. Pt. 4. Oct. 1919. Pp. 209-242.
[IX, 154.]

Claudian. De Bello Gildonica. [II, 277.]

The most recent English translation is that by M. Platnauer in the Loeb
Classics. 2 vols. 1922. " The War against Gildonica " appears in vol. i,
pp. 98-137.

Clausen, Julius. See under Andersen, H. C, " King, Queen
and Knave."

Clodd, E. " The Philosophy of Punchkin." The Folklore
Journal. Vol. ii. Ldn. 1884. Pp. 289-303. [I, 130.]

Clouston, W. A. Popular Tales and Fictions, their Migra-
tions and Transformations. 2 vols. Edinburgh. 1887. [I,
29, 42-44, 85n, 101ft1, 130 ; II, 108n, 114w, 122, 169, 190ft1,
192ft1, 224ft ; III, 56, 76, 133m1, 204, 227ft, 238 ; IV, 192ft1 ;
V, 66, 267, 275, 285 ; VI, 275ft1 ; VII, 214ft2, 214ft3, 224,
224ft2 ; VIII, 227ft2 ; IX, 165.]

Clouston, W. A. The Book of Sindibdd ; or, The Story of the
King, his Son, the Damsel, and the Seven Vazirs. From the
Persian and Arabic. With Introduction, Notes and Appendix,
by . . . Privately printed [Glasgow]. 1884. [I, 27, 43, 170,
171, 186ft1 ; II, 114ft, 120-122, 224ft ; IV, 132ft1 ; V, 122ft1,
127W1, 267 ; VI, 255, 259n\ 260nK]

Clouston, W. A. Originals and Analogues of some of Chaucer' 's
Canterbury Tales. Pts. iv and v. Chaucer Society. 2nd
Series. Nos. 20, 1886, and 22, 1887. [VII, 203, 203w3, 204.]
The other parts form Nos. 7, 10 and 15 of the 2nd Series.

204

THE OCEAN OF STORY

Clouston, W. A. The Book of Noodles : Stories of Simpletons,
or, Fools and their Follies. Ldn. 1888. Forming part of the
" Book-Lover's Library." [Ill, 231W1 ; V, 68n, 168W1.]

Clouston, W. A. A Group of Eastern Romances and Stories
from the Persian, Tamil, and Urdu. With Introduction,
Notes, and Appendix, by . . . Privately printed [Glasgow].
1889. [I, 43, lOlw1, 131, 160n3 ; II, 108w ; III, 118/11 ;
IV, 139n2, 182 ; VI, 60, 287, 287w3 ; VII, 224ft1.]
Only three hundred copies were printed, and fifty-two on large paper.

Clouston, W. A. Flowers from a Persian Garden and other
Papers. . . . Ldn. 1890. (Second and Cheaper Edition,
1894.) [Ill, 167n2 ; V, lOln1 ; VI, 74ra.]

Clouston, W. A. " The Treasury of King Rhampsinitus."
The Academy. A Record of Literature, Learning, Science,
and Art. Vol. xxxviii. 29th Nov. 1890. No. 969. Pp.506,
507. [V. 275.]

The article refers to a note printed in The Academy of 15th November 1890,
p. 449, in which reference is made to a pamphlet by Mr Levi H. Elwell giving
three variants of the Rhampsinitus story. One of them is " Buh Lion, Buh
Rabbit, and Buh Roccoon," from Col. Jones's Negro Myths from the Georgia
Coast. Clouston refers to his chapter on the study of Herodotus' story, and
adds a gypsy variant from Groom's (then unpublished) notes, being No. vi of
Constantinescu's collection.

Clusius. See under L'E(s)cluse, Charles de.

Cochrane, W. W. See under Mills, L.

Codrington, R. H. The Melanesians : Studies in their

Anthropology and Folk-Lore. Oxford. 1891. [VI, 135 ;

VIII, 232n4 ; IX, 149.]
Codrington, R. H. " Religious Beliefs and Practices in

Melanesia." Journ. Anth. Inst. Vol. x. Ldn. 1881. Pp. 261-

315. Discussion, p. 316. [II, 198ft1.]
Ccedes, G. " Le Royaume de £rivajaya." Bull, de VEcole

Francaise d' Extreme-Orient. Tome xviii. Hanoi. 1918.

No. 6. P. 36. [I, 155ft1.]
Coelho, A. Contos popular es portuguezes. Lisbon. 1879.

[I, 26, 44, 145ft1 ; II, 76ft1 ; III, 30ft1, 48ft1, 191ft1, 238,

272ft1 ; IV, 132ft1 ; V, 55ft3, 67ft3, 105ft, 109n2, 183^ ; VI,

277 ; VIII, 57n2, 59n\]
Cole, H. " Notes on the Wagogo of German East Africa."

Journ. Anth. Inst. Vol. xxxii. 1902. Pp. 305-388. [111,38.]
Colebrooke, H. T. Essays on the Religion and Philosophy

of the Hindus. New Edition. Ldn. 1858. [111,37.]
Colin, Antoine. Histoire des Drogues, espiceries, et de

certains medicamens simples, qui naissent es Indes 6c en

V Amerique, divise en deux parties. La premiere comprise

BIBLIOGRAPHY 205

en quatre livres ; les deux premiers de Me Garcie du Jardin,
le troisiesme de Me Christophle de la Coste, & le quatriesme
de VHistoire du Baulme adioustee de nouveau en ceste
seconde edition : oil il est prouve, que nous avons le vray
Baulme d'Arabie, contre V opinion des anciens & modernes.
La seconde composee de deux livres de maistre Nicolas
Monard traictant de ce qui nous est apporte de VAmerique.
Le tout fidellement translate en Frangois, par . . . Lyon.
1619. [VIII, 245.]

Collet, O. J. A. Terres et Peuples de Sumatra. . . . Ouvrage
ayant obtenu le Prix Triennal " Maurice Rahir " decerne
pour la premiere fois en 1924 par la Societe Royale Beige
de Geographic Soci6te D'Edition " Elsevier." Amsterdam.
1925. [VIII, 294.]

Collin de Plancy, J. A. S. Dictionnaire Infernal, ou
Recherches et Anecdotes sur les Demons, les Esprits, les
Fantomes . . . en un mot, sur tout ce qui tient aux
apparitions, a la magie. . . . 2nd edition, revised. 4 vols.
Paris. 1825-1826. [Ill, 150.]

Comparetti, D. Richerche intorno at Libro di Sindibdd.
Estratto dalla Memorie del R. Instituto Lombardo di
Scienze e Lettere, 11, 2 ; della serie, 3. Milano. 1869.
[II, 122.]

Comparetti, D. Virgilio net Medio Evo. 2 vols. Livorno.
1872. [I, 148w.]

A revised edition appeared in Florence. 2 vols. 1896.

Comparetti, D. Novelline popolari italiane. Torino. 1875.
[V, 275.]

A collection of seventy tales.

Comparetti, D. Researches respecting the Book of Sindibdd.
[Translated by H. C Coote.] Folk-Lore Society. Publica-
tion No. ix. Ldn. 1882. [I, 170, 186W1.]

Constable, A. Travels in the Mogul Empire, a.d. 1656-1668,
by Frangois Bernier. . . . Translated on the Basis of
Irving Brock's version, and Annotated by . . . (1891).
2nd edition revised by Vincent A. Smith, M.A. . . .
Oxford. 1914. [VIII, 267w3.]

Constantinescu, B. Probe de Limba §i Literatura ^iganilor
din Romania. Bucharest. 1878. [V, 275.]

Conti, Nicol6. See under Major, R. H.

Conway, M. D. Demonology and Devil Lore. 2 vols. Ldn.
1879. [II, 117.]

206 THE OCEAN OF STORY

Conway, M. D. " Mystic Trees and Flowers." Frazer's

Magazine. New Series. Vol. ii. Ldn. Nov. 1870, pp.

590-608. Dec. 1870, pp. 705-723. [Ill, 154.]
Conybeare, F. C. Philostratus. The Life of Apollonius

of Tyana. Translated by . . . Loeb Classical Library.

2 vols. Ldn. 1912. [VI, 280n6.]
Conybeare, F. C. " A Brittany Marriage Custom." Folk-Lore.

Vol. xviii. 1907. P. 448. [II, 2Sn.]
Conybeare, F. C. " Asceticism." Ency. Brit. 11th edit.

Vol. ii. Pp. 717-720. [I, 79nK]
Conybeare, F. C. ; Harris, J. Rendel; Lewis, A. S.

The Story of Ahikar from the Syriac, Arabic, Armenian,

Ethiopic, Greek and Slavonic Versions. Ldn. 1898. [IX, 142,

152.]
Cook, S. A. " Serpent- Worship." Ency. Brit. 11th edit.

Vol. xxiv. Pp. 676-682. [I, 203.]
Cook, S. A. " Tree- Worship." Ency. Brit. 11th edit. Vol.

xxvii. Pp. 235-238. [I, 144W1.]
Coomaraswamy, Ananda K. Mediceval Sinhalese Art. . . .

Being a Monograph on Mediceval Sinhalese Arts and

Crafts, mainly as surviving in the Eighteenth Century,

with an Account of the Structure of Society and the Status

of the Craftsmen. Broad Campden. 1908. [VIII, 251,

252w6.]
Coomaraswamy, Ananda K. Sati : A Vindication of the

Hindu Woman. A paper read before the Sociological

Society. Ldn. 12th Nov. 1912. [IV, 272.]
Coomaraswamy, Ananda K. The Treatise of Al-Jazari on

Automata. Museum of Fine Arts. Boston. No. 6. 1924.

[Ill, 58.]
Coomaraswamy, Ananda K. See also under La Touche,

T. H. D.
Coombe, F. Islands of Enchantment. Many-sided Melanesia

seen through many Eyes, and Recorded by . . . Ldn. 1911.

[VIII, 317n2.]
Coote, H. C. "Some Italian Folk-Lore." The Folk-Lore

Record. Vol. i. Ldn. 1878. Pp. 187-215. [I, 26.]
Coote, H. C. See also under Comparetti, D., Researches

respecting . . .
Cordier, Henri. Set Marco Polo. Notes and Addenda to Sir

Henry Yule's Edition, containing the Results of Recent

Research and Discovery. Ldn. 1920. [I, 104, 241n2.]
Cordier, H. See also under Maspero G., Popular Stories . . . ;

Muller, F. W. K. ; Yule, H.

BIBLIOGRAPHY 207

Cory ate, Thomas. Cory ate' s Crudities hastily) gobbled up
in Five Months' Travels in France, Italy, etc. Ldn. 1611.
(Reprinted in 2 vols. Glasgow, 1905.) [II, 270.]

Cosmas Indicopleustes (of Alexandria). Topographia
Christiana. [Ill, 84m1, 85n ; VII, 106, 107.]

For a translation of the above work see that by J. W. M'Crindle, published
in 1897 for the Hakluyt Society.

Cosmas, the Monk. See under M'Crindle, J. W.

Cosquin, Emmanuel. Conies Populaires de Lorraine
Compares avec les Contes des Autres Provinces de France et
des Pays Etrangers et Precedes D'un Essai sur UOrigine et
la Propagation des Contes Populaires Europeens. 2 vols.
Paris. [1886.] [Ill, 76, 227n, 238 ; V, S7nl ; VI, 18m1,
122n2 ; VIII, 107w, 109n2 ; IX, 165.]

Cosquin, Emmanuel. Les Contes Indiens et UOccident.
Petits Monographies Folkloriques A Propos De Contes
Maures Recueillis A Blida Par M. Desparmet. Ouvrage
posthume. Paris. 1922. [V. 177 ; VI, 16rc, 48n.]

Cosquin, Emmanuel. Etudes Folkloriques. Recherches sur
les Migrations des Contes Populaires et leur point de depart.
Paris. 1922. [Ill, 204, 2l2n\ 238, 280 ; IV, 48 ; VI, 246,
246ft1 ; VII, 82n, 263.]

Costanzo, Angelo di. Istoria del regno di Napoli. 3 vols.
Milano. 1805. [II, 310, 310n2.]

Cotton, C. W. E. Handbook of Commercial Information for
India. 2nd edit. Calcutta. 1924. [VIII, 318nx.]

Courteille, Pavet de. See under Meynard, C. Barbier de.

Co well, E. B. The Jataka or Stories of the Buddha's Former
Births. Translated from the Pali by Various Hands. Under
the Editorship of ... 6 vols. Cambridge. 1895-1907.
Index vol. 1913. [I, 62n\ lOln1, 122n2, 146ft1, 223, 224,
225, 226, 227, 232ft2 ; II, 122, 298ft1 ; III, 60, 179, 304m1 ;
V, 3ft1, 63ft1, 64, 79ft3, 98ft1, 99ft3, 100ft1, 101ft1, 101ft2,
153ft1, 155ra2, 157W1, 163n\ 176; VI, 72n\ 262, 279n2,
284711 ; VII, 162m1, 220, 221n5, 241w3 ; VIII, 69w\ 112w4,
254rc1.]

The several translations were as follows : Vol. i, R. Chalmers ; vols, ii and
iv, W. H. D. Rouse ; vol. hi, H. T. Francis and R. A. Neil ; vol. v, H. T.
Francis ; vol. vi, E. B. Cowell and W. H. D. Rouse.

Cowell, E. B. " The Legend of the Oldest Animals." Y
I Cymmrodor, embodying the Transactions of the Honorable
Society of Cymmrodorion of London, etc. Vol. v. Oct. 1882.
Pp. 169-172. [II, 190/11.]

208 THE OCEAN OF STORY

Cowell, E. B., and Gough, A. E. The Sarva-Dars'ana-
Samgraha or Review of the Different Systems of Hindu
Philosophy. By Madhava Acharya. Translated by . . .
Triibner's Oriental Series. Ldn. 1882. [V, 151n2.]

Cox, G. W. The Mythology of the Aryan Nations. 2 vols.
Ldn. 1882. (Original edition, 1870.) [I, 130, 148n ; III,
2Sn\ 272nx ; VI, 72W1.]

Cox well, C. F. Siberian and Other Folk-Tales. Primitive
Literature of the Empire of the Tsars, Collected and Trans-
lated, with an Introduction and Notes . . . Ldn. 1925.
(Date on verso of sub-title.) VI, 123w, 242, 248, 264, 269n2,
2"/0, 273rc2, 280; VII, 204, 235w2 ; VIII, 59n3, 227n5,
228n5,6'7; IX, 75n\ 142, 146-149, 151, 153, 156, 161.]
See also under Julg, B.

For some details of the scope of the work see my review in The Asiatic
Review, July 1926, pp. 518-520.

Craigie, W. A. and J. K. Fairy Tales and Other Stories

by Hans Christian Andersen. Oxford Univ. Press. 1914.

[VI, 292.]
Crane, T. F. Italian Popular Tales. Boston and Ldn. 1885.

[I, 26 ; III, 76 ; V, 66.]
Cranmer-Byng, L. See under Barnett, L. D., Golden Town,

and Hindu Gods and Heroes.
Crawfurd, John. History of the Indian Archipelago ; contain-
ing an Account of the Manners, Arts, Languages, Religions,

etc., of its Inhabitants. 3 vols. Edinburgh. 1820. [IV, 258.]
Crawley, A. E. " Chastity (Introductory)." Hastings'

Ency. Rel. Eth. Vol. iii. 1910. Pp. 474-490. [Ill, 72n2.]
Crawlejy, A. E. "Doubles." Hastings' Ency. Rel. Eth. Vol.iv.

1911. Pp. 853-860. [I, 37n2.]
Crawley, A. E. " Dress." Hasting's Ency. Rel. Eth.

Vol. v. 1912. Pp. 40-72. [II, 118 ; VII, 231w.4]
Crawley, A. E. " Drums and Cymbals." Hastings' Ency.

Rel. Eth. Vol. v. 1912. Pp. 89-94. [I, 118n2.]
Crawley, A. E. " Foeticide." Hastings' Ency. Rel. Eth.

Vol. vi. 1913. Pp. 54-57. [II, 229n2.]
Crawley, A. E. " Kissing." Hastings' Ency. Rel. Eth. Vol.

vii. 1914. Pp. 739-744. [IX, 162.]
Crawley, A. E. " Magical Circle." Hastings' Ency. Rel.

Eth. Vol. viii. 1915. Pp. 321-324. [II, 99n ; III, 203.]
Crawley, A. E. ; Beet, W. E., and Canney, M. A. " Oath

— Introductory and Primitive, NT and Christian, Semitic."

Hastings' Ency. Rel. Eth. Vol. ix. 1917. Pp. 430-438.

[I, 57n1.]

BIBLIOGRAPHY 209

Creighton, C. " Medicine." Ency. Biblica. Vol. iii. Ldn.
1902. Cols. 3005-3009. [Ill, 38.]

Croix, F. Petis de la. Histoire de la Sultane de Perse, et des
Visirs. Contes Turcs. Composez en langue Turque par Chec
Zade,ettraduits en Francois. Paris. 1707. [VII, 245, 245 n3.]
See also under Dervish Makhlis of Ispahan.

Croker, T. C. Fairy Legends and Traditions of the South of
Ireland. Ldn. 1825. 2nd edit., first part, 1826 ; second
and third parts, 1828. [I, 26 ; VII, 120ft2.]

The last part of the second edition contains some Scottish and Welsh, besides
Irish, stories. The first part was translated into German by the Brothers Grimm.
See further under Grimm, J. L. C. and W., Irische Elfenmarchen. A second
edition of the whole appeared in 1834. Croker died in 1854, and in 1870
Thomas Wright (who with Croker and other antiquarians had founded the
Camden and Percy Societies) issued a third edition of the work.

Crooke, W. An Introduction to the Popular Religion and
Folklore of Northern India. Allahabad. 1894.

This edition is not referred to in the Ocean.
It then appeared as :

The Popular Religion and Folk-Lore of Northern India. A
New Edition, Revised and Illustrated. 2 vols. West-
minster. 1896. [I, 37ft2, 67ft1, 98ft, 134ft1, 203, 205, 206,
228 ; II, 57ft1, 82, 83, 96ft1, 99n, 127ft2, 138ft3, 142ft1, 155ft3,
193ft1, 197ft2, 202ft1, 240, 256, 256ft3 ; III, 37, 40ft2, 121ft1,
142ft1, 151, 152, 161ft1, 185ft1, 218ft1, 247m1, 263ft2, 272m1,
306ft2 ; IV, 55ft1, 177ft1, 225ft1, 235ft2, 245ft1, 271 ; V. 27ft2,
30ft2, 59ft1, 101ft1, 126ft1, 160ft1, 176 ; VI, 59, 109ft1, 149ft1.
A new and posthumous edition appeared as follows :

Crooke, W. Religion & Folklore of Northern India. Pre-
pared for the Press by R. E. Enthoven, C.I.E., Late of the
Indian Civil Service. Oxford. 1926. [VI, 265w3 ; VII,
In2, 5w3, 146ft1, 230ft1 ; VIII, 19, 271ft2.]

Crooke, W. The Tribes and Castes of the North-Western
Provinces and Oudh. 4 vols. Calcutta. 1896. [I, 239ft1,
240ft2; II, 119, 166, 168, 257, 257ft2, 305ft1; III, 101ft,
325 ; IV, 160ft ; V, 176 ; VIII, 270ft1.]

Crooke, W. The Talking Thrush and Other Tales from India.
Collected by W. Crooke and Retold by W. H. D. Rouse.
Illustrated by W. H. Robinson. Ldn. 1899. [V, 49ft1, 65.]

These stories (forty-three in number) first appeared in North Indian Notes
and Queries. A second edition appeared in 1902.

Crooke, W. " Aghori, Aghorapanthi, Augar, Aughar."
'Hastings' Ency. Rel. Eth. Vol. i. 1908. Pp. 210-213.
[II, 90ft3, 198ft1.]

VOL. IX. O

210 THE OCEAN OF STORY

Crooke, W. " Ancestor- Worship and Cult of the Dead

(Indian)." Hastings' Ency. Rel. Eth. Vol. i. 1908. Pp. 450-

454. [I, 56n\]
Crooke, W. " Bad(a)rlnath." Hastings' Ency. Rel. Eth.

Vol. ii. 1909. P. 325. [IV, 159n\]
Crooke, W. " Charms and Amulets (Indian)." Hastings'

Ency. Rel. Eth. Vol. iii. 1910. Pp. 441-448. [II, 167 ;

III, 37 ; VI. 59.]
Crooke, W. " Demons and Spirits (Indian)." Hastings'

Ency. Rel. Eth. Vol. iv. 1911. Pp. 601-608. [II, ein1.]
Crooke, W. " Dravidians (North India)." Hastings' Ency.

Rel. Eth. Vol. v. 1912. Pp. 1-21. [IV, 177n\]
Crooke, W. " Kedarnath." Hastings' Ency. Rel. Eth.

Vol. vii. 1914. P. 680. [VII, 2ra1.]
Crooke, W. " Prostitution (Indian)." Hastings' Ency. Rel.

Eth. Vol. x. 1918. Pp. 406-408. [I, 233, 239n2.]
Crooke, W. " Serpent Worship (Indian)." Hastings'

Ency. Rel. Eth. Vol. xi. 1920. Pp. 411-419. [I, 203-204 ;

II, 307n2.]
Crooke, W. " Water, Water-Gods (Indian)." Hastings'

Ency. Rel. Eth. Vol. xii. 1921. Pp. 716-719. [VII, 146wx.]
Crooke, W. " The Legends of Krishna." Folk-Lore. Vol. xi.

March 1900. No. 1. Pp. 1-38. [II, 39n2.]
Crooke, W. " Some Notes on Homeric Folk-Lore." Folk-Lore.

Vol. xix. March 1908. No. 1. Pp. 52-77. June 1908.

No. 2. Pp. 153-189. [II, 57nx ; III, 204, 208nx, 227w, 258 ;

VI, 282w6 ; IX, 9W1.]
Crooke, W. " King Midas and His Ass's Ears." Folk-Lore.

Vol. xxii. June 1911. No. 2. Pp. 183-202. [V, lln1 ;

VI, 26nK]
Crooke, W. " The Veneration of the Cow in India." Folk-
Lore. Vol.xxiii. Sept. 1912. No. 3. Pp. 275-306. [11,242.]
Crooke, W. " Simulated Change of Sex to baffle the Evil

Eye." Folk-Lore. Vol. xxiv. Sept. 1913. No. 3. P. 385.

[IX, 163.]
Crooke, W. " The Holi : A Vernal Festival of the Hindus."

Folk-Lore. Vol. xxv. March 1914. No. 1. Pp. 55-83. [II,

59m1.]
Crooke, W. " The Divali, the Lamp Festival of the Hindus."

Folk-Lore. Vol. xxxiv. Dec. 1923. No. 4. Pp. 267-292.

[II, 118, 2S2n.]
Crooke, W. " The Hill Tribes of the Central Indian Hills."

Journ. Anth. Inst. Vol. xxviii. (New Series, vol. i.) Feb.

and May 1899. Pp. 220-248. [II, 24rc.]

BIBLIOGRAPHY 211

Crooke, W. "Nudity in India in Custom and Ritual."
Journ. Roy. Anth. Inst. Vol. xlix. 1919. Pp. 237-251.
[II, 119.]

Crooke, W. "Brahmani." Indian Antiquary. Vol. x. 1881.
P. 293. [VII, 5n\]

The above note was an answer to a query as to the meaning of the word
" Brahmani " by Sir R. C. Temple, in Ind. Ant., vol. ix, 1880, p. 280.

Crooke, W. " Secret Messages and Symbols used in India."
Journ. Bihar and Orissa Research Soc. Vol. v. Patna,
1919. Pp. 451-462. [I, 82n.]

Crooke, W. See also under Ball, V. ; Fryer, John ;
Herklots, G. A. ; Stein, A., and Grierson, G. A. ; and
Tod, J.

Crusius, O. See under Anderson, W.

Cumming, F. G. Gordon. " Pagodas, Aurioles and Umbrellas."
The English Illustrated Magazine. 1887-1888. Pp. 601-612 ;
654-667. [II, 272.]

Cunningham, A. The Ancient Geography of India. I. The
Buddhist Period, including the Campaigns of Alexander,
and the Travels of Hwen-Thsang. Ldn. 1871. [Only one
vol. published.] [II, 3W1 ; III, 172n\ 184nx ; IV, 2n2, 144/11 ;
V, 165W1 ; VI, 69nx.]

Cunningham, A. Archaeological Survey of India. 23 vols.
Simla (vols, i and ii) and Calcutta. 1871-1887. Index
volume by V. A. Smith. Calcutta. 1887. [I, 238wx ; II,
110n2 ; VII, 229ft1.] See also under Beglar, J. D.

Cunningham, A. The Stupa of Bharhut; with Photographic
Plates. Ldn. 1879. [1,42; V, 79n3; IX, 5ln\]

Curtze, L. Volksuberlieferungen aus dem Furstenthum
Waldeck. Mdrchen, Sagen, Volksreime, Rathsel, Sprich-
worter, Aberglauben, Sitten und Gebrauche, nebst einen
Idiotikon. Arolsen. 1860. [I, 26.]

The above work contains 37 Mdrchen and 140 Sagas.

Dahnhart, O. Natursagen. Eine Sammlung naturdeutender

Sagen, Mdrchen, Fabeln und Legenden. . . . Leipzig und

Berlin. 1907, etc. [IX, 144.]
Dalton, E. T. Descriptive Ethnology of Bengal. Calcutta.

1872. [VIII, 285w2.]
D'Alviella, G. The Migration of Symbols. Introduction by

Sir G. Birdwood. Ldn. 1894. [I, 192.]
D'Alviella, G. " Circumambulation." Hastings' Ency.

Rel. Eth. Vol. iii. 1910. Pp. 657-659. [I, 193.]
1)amadaragapta. See under Langle, Louis de.
Damant, G. H. " Bengali Folklore-Legends from Dinajpur."

212 THE OCEAN OF STORY

(" Legends from Dinagepore.") Indian Antiquary. Vol. i,

1872, pp. 115, 170, 218, 285, 344; ii, 1873, pp. 271, 357;

iii, 1874, pp. 9, 320, 342 ; iv, 1875, pp. 54 ; ix, 1880, p. 1 et seq.

Twenty-two tales in all. [I, 42, 131 ; IX, 142.]
Damant, G. H. " Bengali Folklore Legends from Dinagepore.' •

Indian Antiquary. Vol. ix. 1880. Pp. 1-8. [IX, 142.]
Dames, M. Longworth. The Book of Duarte Barbosa. An

Account of the Countries Bordering on the Indian Ocean

and their Inhabitants, written by Duarte Barbosa and

completed about the Year a.d. 1518. Translated from the

Portuguese Text . . . and Edited and Annotated by . . .

2 vols. Hakluyt Society. Ldn. Vol. i. Second Series.

No. xliv. 1918. Vol. ii. Second Series. No. xlix. 1921.

[II, 18, 269nx, 300, 300rc5, 301, 303; III, 329; IV, 269,

270 ; VIII, 96n2, 258w2.]
Dames, M. Longworth. "Balochi Tales." Folk-Lore. Vols, iii,

1892, p. 517 ; iv, 1893, pp. 195, 285, 518 ; viii, 1897, p. 77.

Twenty stories in all. [II, 302 ; III, 182 ; V. 49ft1.]
Dames, M. Longworth, and Joyce, T. A. " Note on a

Gandhara Relief representing the Story of King Sivi."

Man. Vol. xiii. No. 2. Feb. 1913. Pp. 17-19. [I, 85n.]
Damiri, Ad-. See under Jayakar, A. S. G.
Dampier, William. A New Voyage round the World. . . .

Ldn. 1697. [VIII, 293, 301, 301W1.]

This work was reprinted six times (1697-1729) and has now appeared (under
my editorship) with an Introduction by Sir Albert Gray. Argonaut Press.
Ldn. 1927.

Dampier, William. Voyages and Discoveries. . . . Ldn.
1699. [VIII, 302.]

Three further editions of the above volume were issued — 1700, 1705, 1729.

D'Ancona, A. " II Tresoro di Brunetto Latini versificato."
Atti delta R. Accademia dei Lincei. Serie Quarta Classe
di Scienze Morali, Storiche e Filologiche. Vol. iv.
Pt. i. Memorie. Roma. 1888. Pp. 111-274. See also the
" Relatione " by Carlo Merkel, pp. 275, 276. [II, 294, 294rc2.]

Dandin. Dasa-kumara-charita. (Story of the Ten Princes.)
[i,*25, 234, 234w4, 235 ; II, 183m1, 184n; VI, 247, 251, 259.]
See also under Hertel, J., Die zehn Printzen . . .; and
Meyer, J. J.

Dandin. Mrichchhakatika. See under Ryder, A. W.

Danicic*, G. " Indijske price prozvane Stefanit i Ihnilat."
Starine, na sviet izdaje Jugoslavenska Akademija Znanosti
I Umjetnosti. Vol. ii. Zagrebu (Agram). 1870. Pp. 261-310.
[V, 235, 238.]

BIBLIOGRAPHY 213

Daniels, C. L., and Stevans, C. M. The Encyclopaedia of
Superstitions, Folk-Lore and the Occult Sciences of the
World. ... 3 vols. Chicago and Milwaukee. [1903.]
[II, 145n.]

Dante Alighieri. Inferno. [I, 40n3 ; .VIII, 99n2.] Purgatorio.
[IV, 239rc2 ; VIII, 100n.] See also under Lombardi, P. B.

Da Orta, Garcia. See under Orta, Garcia da.

Daremberg, C. V., and Saglio, E. Dictionnaire des Anti-
quites grecque et romaines, d'apres les textes et les monuments
. . . Ouvrage redige par une societe d'ecrivains speciaux
. . . sous la direction de . . . 5 vols. Paris, Corbeil
[printed]. 1873-1919. [IX, 147, 161.]

Dasent, G. W. Popular Tales from the Norse. With an
Introductory Essay on the Origin and Diffusion of Popular
Tales. 2nd edition, enlarged. Edinburgh. 1859. [I, 26,
27, 44, 77/11 ; II, 190W1 ; III, 104nx, 205 ; V, Sn\ Un1.]

Dasent, G. W. Tales from the Fj eld. Ldn. 1874. [111,76.]

Both the above work and Popular Tales from the Norse are from the
collections of Asbjornsen andMoe.

Dasent, G. W. " De Deif van Brugghe." Zeitschrift fur
deutsches Alterthum. Vol. v. Leipzig. 1845. Pp. 385-406.
[V, 284.]

Davids, C. F. Rhys. " Notes on Early Economic Conditions
in Northern India." Journ. Roy. As. Soc. Oct. 1901.
Pp. 859-888. [II, 240.]

Davids, T. W. Rhys. Buddhist Birth Stories; or Jdtaka
Tales . . . being the Jdtakatthavannand, Edited by
V. Fausboll, and Translated by . . . Trubner's Oriental
Series. 2 vols. Ldn. 1880. [II, 52nx ; V, 3n\ 55w3, 79n\
9Sn\ lOOw1 ; VIII, 135n2.]

Davids, T. W. Rhys. Buddhist Suttas Translated from Pali
by ... 1. The Maha-Parinibbana Suttanta. 2. The
Dhamma-2£akka-PPavattana Sutta. 3. The Tevigga
Suttanta. 4. The Akankheyya Sutta. 5. The i£etokhila
Sutta. 6. The Maha-Sudassana Suttanta. 7. The
Sabbasava Sutta. Oxford. 1881. [VIII, 71n2.]

The above work forms vol. xi of the " Sacred Books of the East " Series,
edited by F. Max Miiller. The reference in the Ocean is to No. 6 of the
work — the Maha-sudassanasuttanta.

Davids, T. W. Rhys. Buddhism. A Sketch of the Life and
Teachings of Gautama, the Buddha. Ldn. 1890. (1st
edit. 1878.) [VIII, 127/11.]

214 THE OCEAN OF STORY

Davids, T. W. Rhys. Buddhist India. Ldn. 1903. [II, Sn1.]

Part of " The Story of the Nations " Series.

Davids, T. W. Rhys. "Adam's Peak." Hastings' Ency. Rel.

Eth. Vol. i. 1908. Pp. 87, 88. [II, 85n.]
Davids, T. W. Rhys. "Chastity (Buddhist)." Hastings'

Ency. Rel. Eth. Vol. iii. 1910. P. 490. [Ill, 172n2.]
Davids, T. W. Rhys. See also under Fausboll, V.
Davies, John. The Voyages and Travels of J. Albert de

Mandelslo . . . into the East Indies. Begun in the year

1638 and finished in 1640. . . . 2nd edition, corrected.

Ldn. 1669. [IV, 270.]
Dawkins, R. M. Modern Greek in Asia Minor. With a

chapter on the Subject-matter of the Folk-tales by W. R.

Halliday. Cambridge. 1916. [VI, 122n2, 123rc, 138, 273w2 ;

VIII, 109n2 ; IX, 153.]
Dawkins, R. M. " Ancient Statues in Mediaeval Con-
stantinople." Folk-Lore. Vol. xxxv. 1924. Pp. 209-248.

[IX, 160.]
Day, Lal Behari. Folk-Tales of Bengal. Ldn. 1883. [I, 28,

95n\ 131 ; II, 108n ; III, 29n, 62, 280 ; VII, 261.]

The 2nd edition of the above was issued in 1912. The collection, formed at
the suggestion of Sir Richard Temple, contains twenty-two excellent tales.

Defremery, C. See under Ibn Batuta.

De Groot, J. J. M. The Religious System of China, its
Ancient Forms, Evolution, History and Present Aspect.
Manners, Customs and Social Institutions connected there-
with. Published with a subvention from the Dutch
Colonial Government. 6 vols. Leyden. 1892-1901. [IV,
257n2 ; VIII, 304, 304ft1.]

This important work is divided into two parts, consisting of two Books,
three volumes constituting a Book. The title of Book i is " Disposal of the
Dead," and that of Book ii," The Soul and Ancestral Worship." The sub-titles
of the volumes are as follows : Vol. i, pt. i, Funeral Rites ; pt. ii, Ideas of
Resurrection. Vol. ii, pt. iii, The Grave (first half). Vol. iii, pt. iii, The Grave
(second half). Vol. iv, pt. i, The Soul in Philosophy and Folk-Conception.
Vol. v, pt. ii, Demonology; pt. iii, Sorcery. Vol. vi, pt. iv, War against
Spectres ; pt. v, Priesthood of Animism.

De Gubernatis. See under Gubernatis, A. de.

Dekker, T. The Honest Whore. (1604.) [II, 14>5n.]

Della Valle, Pietro. Travels. [II, 162n ; III, 85n.] See

further under Grey, Edward.
Dellon, C. A Voyage to the East Indies [2 pts.]. . . . Also,

a Treatise of the Distempers peculiar to Eastern Countries.

. . . Ldn. 1698. [IV, 271.]

BIBLIOGRAPHY 215

Del Rio (or Delrio), M. A. S. J. Disquisitonum Magicarum
Libri Sex. Louvain. 1599. [II, 300, 300n2.]

The 1606 edition is not accessible to me.

Dennys, N. B. The Folk-Lore of China, and its Affinities with
that of the Aryan and Semitic Races. London and Hong-
Kong. 1876. [VIII, 231 ft3.] See also under [Anonymous.]
44 The Betel Tree," and Mayers, W. F.

Denton, W. Serbian Folk-Lore : Popular Tales selected and
translated by Madam Cs. Mijatovics. Edited with an
Introduction by . . . Ldn. 1874. [I, 132 ; III, 204.]

Derenbourg, J. Deux versions hebraiques du livre de Kalildh
et Dimndh la premiere accompagnee d'une traduction
francaise, . . . Paris. 1881. [V, 220.]

Derenbourg, J. Johannis de Capua Directorium vitce
humance alias parabola antiquorum sapientum. . . . Paris.
1889. [V, 237.]

Deromps, M. Les vingt-cinq recits du mauvais genie traduits
de Vhindi. Paris. 1912. [IX, 163.]

Dervish Makhlis of Ispahan. The Thousand and One
Days. [I, 43, 145ft1 ; II, 6ft2.] Les Mille et un jour, Contes
Persans, Traduits en Francois par Mr. Petis de la Croix. . . .
5 vols. Lille. 1783-1784. [II, 190ft1 ; IV, 48.]

Deslongchamps, A. L. Essai sur les Fables Indiennes et sur
leur introduction en Europe. . . . Paris. 1838. [1,25,169.]

Dewar, D. See under Wright, R. G., and Dewar, D.

Dey, Kanny Lall. Indigenous Drugs of India. 2nd edit.
Calcutta. 1896. [VI, 110ft1.]

Dey, Nundolal. " Geographical Dictionary of Ancient and
Mediaeval India." The Indian Antiquary (Supplement).
Vol. xlviii, 1919, pp. 1-6; vol. xlix, 1920, p. 7-54; vol. 1,
1921, pp. 55-78 ; vol. li, 1922, pp. 79-118 ; vol. lii, 1923,
pp. 119-150 ; vol. liii, 1924, pp. 151-190 ; vol. liv, 1925,
pp. 191-214; vol. lv, 1926, pp. 215-262. [VI, 69ft1, 150ft1.]

D'Gruyther, W. J. " Panjab — Rajputana — Patandi —
Jesalmer — Burning with Dead by men and women — Sati-
Satu." Indian Notes and Queries (late Panjab Notes and
Queries). Vol. iv. Allahabad. Dec. 1886. Pp. 44, 45.
[IV, 272.]

DlONYSIUS HaLICARNASENSIS. 'Poyxaib; apxaioXoyla. [VIII,
114ft1.]

, Dithmar of Merseburg (or Thietmar) . See under Pertz, G. H.

D'Ohsson, M * * * (i.e. Mouradja). Tableau General de

VEmpire Othoman, divise en deux parties, dont Vune

216 THE OCEAN OF STORY

comprend le legislation Mahometans; V autre, VHistoire de

VEmpire Othoman. 3 vols. Paris. 1787, 1790 and 1820.

[Ill, 329.]
Doni. See under Jacobs, J.
Dorsey, J. O. " Abstracts of Omaha and Ponka Myths."

The Journal of American Folklore. Boston and New York.

Vol. i. April to June 1888. No. 1. Pp. 74-78. [VIII,

228n8.]
Dorys, G. La Femme Turque. Paris. 1902. [II, 163w.]
Douce, Francis. Illustrations of Shakspeare, and of Ancient

Manners : with Dissertations on the . . . Gesta Romanorum.

... 2 vols. Ldn. 1807. [V, 87W1.]
Douce, F. See also under Ellis, George.
Doughty, C. M. Travels in Arabia Deserta. 2 vols. Cambridge.

1888. [I, 217.]

Reprinted twice in 1921.

Doutte, Edmond. La Societe Musulmane du Maghrib.

Magie & Religion dans VAfrique du Nord. Algiers.

1909. [Ill, 202 ; VIII, 100n.]
Dowson, John. A Classical Dictionary of Hindu Mythology,

and Religion, Geography, History and Literature. Triibner's

Oriental Series. Vol. vi. Ldn. 1879. [IV, 233nx.]
Dowson, John. See also under Elliot, H. M.
Dozon, A. Contes Albanais, recueillis ettraduits. Paris. 1881.

Collection de Contes et de Chansons populaires. Vol. iii.

[I, 20n, lOln1, 132 ; II, 190nx ; III, 204 ; VII, 224, 226rc2 ;

IX, 165.]
D'Penha, G. F. "Folklore in Salsette." The Indian

Antiquary. Vol. xxii. Bombay. 1893. Pp. 243-250 (cont.

on pp. 276-284). [I, 131.]
D'Penha, G. F. " Folklore in Salsette." Indian Antiquary.

Vol. xxiii. 1894. Pp. 134-139. [V, 65.]
D'Penha, G. F. " Superstitions and Customs in Salsette."

The Indian Antiquary. Vol. xxviii. 1899. Pp. 113-119.

[II, 167.]
Dracott, A. E. Simla Village Tales, or Folk Tales from the

Himalayas. Ldn. 1906. [IX, 163.]
Drew, F. The Jummoo and Kashmir Territories : a Geo-
graphical Account. Ldn. 1875. [II, 232n.]
Drury, H. The Useful Plants of India ; with notices of their

Chief Value in Commerce, Medicine, and the Arts. 2nd

edit. With Additions and Corrections. Ldn. 1873.

[VII, 105.]
The first complete edition appeared in Madras, 1858.

BIBLIOGRAPHY 217

Dubois, M. l'Abbe J.-A. Le Pantcha-T antra, ou Les Cinq
Ruses, Fables du Brahme Vichnou-Sarma ; Aventures de
Paramarta, et Autres Contes. . . Paris. 1826. [V, 48W1,
55w3 ; VII, 224.]

The edition of 1872 had the same title-page and contents, but, in addition,
thirteen eaux-fortes by M. Leonce Petit.

Dubois, M. l'Abbe J.-A. Hindu Manners, Customs and
Ceremonies. . . . Translated from the Author's Later French
MS. and edited with Notes, Corrections, and Biography by
Henry K. Beauchamp, C.I.E. . . . with a prefatory note
by the Right Hon. F. Max Muller and a Portrait. 3rd edit.
Oxford. 1906. [I, 250, 250w3, 251-253 ; II, 168, 242 ;
III, 306, 306w4 ; IX, 164.]

This justly famous work has an interesting history. The original French
MS. was purchased for 8000 rupees by the East India Company. It was then
sent to England, translated and published in 1816 (reprinted with omissions
in 1864). Meanwhile a copy of the MS. lying among the records of Fort St
George had been forwarded to the Abbe for revision and addition. So great
and important did this fresh work prove, when returned in 1815, that it was
decided to send it to the Court of Directors in England. If arrived too late,
and the 1816 edition had already been published. The translation and edit-
ing of the revised MS., undertaken by H. K. Beauchamp, first appeared in
two vols. Oxford. 1897. By 1906 it had reached the third edition. Other
editions can be ignored. Several stories occur in the work, chiefly from the
Pahchatantra, and appear in Dubois' translation of that collection — see above.

Du Fail, Noel, Seigneur de la Herissaye. Les Contes

et Discours d'Eutrapel. Rennes. 1585. (Other editions :

Rennes, 1598 ; 2 vols. [Paris] 1732 ; 2 vols., Paris, 1875.)

[II, 2n\ Sn.]
Duff, J. C. G. A History of the Mahrattas. 3 vols. Ldn.

1826. (3rd edit. Bombay, 1873. Printed in Ldn.) [VII,

216w2.]
Dulaure, J. A. Des Divinites Generatrices, ou du Culte du

Phallus chez les anciens et les modernes. Paris. 1805.

[I, 14w, 15n.]

The subsequent editions of this work require some elucidation. The first
edition (1805) was in one volume of 428 pages. In 1825 appeared a two- volume
work, of which vol. i was : Histoire abregee de differens Cultes, des Cukes qui
ont precede et amene Vidolairie ou V adoration des figures kumains.1 Vol. ii was
an enlarged reprint of Des Divinites Generatrices . . . (464 pages). It was at
once suppressed, but was reprinted separately in 1885. The most recent
edition I have seen was dated 1905. All editions were published in Paris.

Du Meril. See under Meril, Edelestand du.
Dumont, P. E. Histoire de Nala. Traduction Nouvelle par
. . . Bruxelles. 1923. [See IX, 155.]

1 This had also been issued in 1805 as a separate work.

218 THE OCEAN OF STORY

Dunlop, John. History of Fiction. Ldn. 1814. 2nd edit.
1816, 3rd 1845, with notes by H. Wilson (Bohn's Standard
Library), 1888.

In the Ocean practically all references are to the valuable notes of Liebrecht
in his German translation :

Dunlop, John. Geschichte der Prosadichtungen oder Ge-
schichte der Romane, Novellen, Mdrchen . . . Aus dem
Englischen ubertragen . . . und mit einleitender Vorrede,
ausfuhrlichen Anmerkungen . . . verschen von . . . Berlin.
1851. [I, 24W1, 44, mn\ 97ra2, 103, 137m1, 145wx, 166; II,
6n2, 39n2, 127n2; III, 82w2, 2S5nx ; IV, 129n, 132W1,
145?i1,2 ; V, life?, S7n\ llln2, 162W1, 186n2 ; VI, 280n2-3,4.]

Dutt, Manmatha Nath. The Ramayana. Translated into
English Prose from the original Sanskrit of Valmiki. 7 vols.
Calcutta. 1892-1894. [VII, 174 ; VIII, 44W1.]

The title-page of vol. iv is dated 1891. This is due to the fact that the first
four books, and xli sections of the fifth book, had been previously issued in
1889-1891 in fourteen parts. All title-pages were reset and the date altered
accordingly. In the case of the title-page to vol. iv, however, the printers
forgot to change it — hence the error. There is nothing to tell us why this
first edition suddenly stopped issue in 1891? for in the next year, instead of
continuing the issue, it started from the beginning again, but this time the
complete work was printed.

Dutt, Manmatha Nath. A Prose English Translation of
Srimadbhagabatam [i.e. Bhagavata Purana]. Edited and
Published by . . . Calcutta. 1895. [VIII, 214n2.]

The above work forms part of the " Wealth of India " Series, described as
" A Monthly Magazine Solely devoted to the English Translation of the Best
Sanskrit Works."

Dutt, Udoy Chand. The Materia Medica of the Hindus.
Compiled from Sanskrit Medical Works. . . . With a
Glossary of Indian Plants, by George King, M.B., F.L.S.,
Superintendent, Royal Botanical Garden, Calcutta, and the
Author. Calcutta. 1877. [VII, 105.]

In the Brit. Mus. Catalogue the work is entered under Udayachandra Datta.
It was reprinted as follows : —

The Materia Medica of the Hindus . . . with a Glossary
of Indian Plants by George King, K.C.I.E., F.R.S.
. . . Revised Edition. With Additions and Alterations by
Kaviraj Binod Lall Sen and Kaviraj Athutosh Sen.
Calcutta. 1900.
Dyce, A. Glossary to the Works of William Shakespeare.
Ldn. 1894. [Ill, 154.]
A revised edition, with new notes by H. Littledale, appeared in 1902.

BIBLIOGRAPHY 219

Dyer, T. F. Thiselton. English Folk-Lore. Ldn. 1878.
Bogue's " Half-hour Volumes." (2nd edit.) [I, 191 ;
IV, 93n2, 99w2, 116n2.]

Dyer, T. F. Thiselton. The Folk-Lore of Plants. Ldn. 1889.
[Ill, 154.]

Dymock, W. " Flowers of the Hindu Poets." Journ. Anth.
Soc. Bombay. Vol. ii. 1892. Pp. 80-91. [VIII, 7nK]

Dymock, W. " On the Use of Turmeric in Hindoo Cere-
monial." Journ. Anth. Soc. Bombay. Vol. ii. 1892.
Pp. 441-448. [I, 255W1, 255n3 ; VIII, 18.] See also under

KlRTIKAR, K. R.

Eastwick, E. B. See under Barker, W. Burckhardt.
Ebden, H. "A Few Notes with Reference to ' The Eunuchs '

to be found in the large Households of the State of

Rajpootana." The Indian Annals of Medical Science.

Vol. iii. April 1856. No. vi. Pp. 520-525. [Ill, 325.]
Eberhard, A. Philogelos Hieroclis et Philagrii Facetice.

Berolini. 1869. [V, 93w, 133m1.]

The <f>i\6ye\ws is a collection of derma (witticisms).

Edelestand du Meril. See under Meril.

Edgerton, Franklin. The Panchatantra Reconstructed. An
attempt to establish the lost original Sanskrit text of the most
famous of Indian story-collections on the basis of the principal
extant versions. Text, critical apparatus, introduction,
translation by ... 2 vols. New Haven, Vienna [printed].
1924. American Oriental Series. Vols, ii, iii. [V, 56wx,
77n3, lOlw1, 102711, 105n12, 109W1, 207ft1, 208, 209, 213,
214, 217, 221.]

Edgerton, Franklin. Vikrama's Adventures, or The Thirty-
two Tales of the Throne. A Collection of Stories about
King Vikrama, as told by the Thirty-two Statuettes that sup-
ported his Throne. Edited in four different Recensions of
the Sanskrit original (Vikrama-Charita or Sinhasana-
Dvatrincaka) and translated into English with an Intro-
duction by . . . Part 1 : Translation, in Four Parallel
Recensions. Part 2 : Text, in Four Parallel Recensions.
These two Parts form vols, xxvi and xxvii respectively
of Harvard Oriental Series, edited . . . by C. R. Lanman.
Cambridge, Massachusetts. 1926. [VI, 227, 228, 228nx,
228n2, 229, 229ft1, 229n2, 231m1, 231ft2, 240ft1 ; VII, 212,
234ft2, 252w2.]

Edgerton, F. " Pancadivyadhivasa, or Choosing a King
by Divine Will." Journ. Amer. Orient. Soc. Vol. xxxiii.
1913. Pp. 158-166. [V, 175.]

220 THE OCEAN OF STORY

Edgerton, F. "Evil- Wit, No- Wit and Honest- Wit."

Journ. Amer. Orient. Soc. Vol. xl. 1920. Pp. 271-275.

[V, 59w2.]
Egede, P. E. Efterretninger om Grbnland uddragne of en

Journal helden fra 1721 til 1788. Copenhagen. [1788.]

[VIII, 228n9.]
Eggeling, J. The Satapatha-Brdhmana according to the

Text of the Mddhyandina School. Translated by . . .

Sacred Books of the East, vols, xii, xxvi, xli, xliii and xliv.

Oxford. 1882, 1885, 1894, 1897 and 1900. [II, 245nx ;

IV, 16.]
Egilsson, S. [and others]. Fornmanna Sogur, eptir gomlum

handritum utgefnar ath tilhlutum hins Norraena Fornfrcetha

Felags. 12 Bind. Kaupmannahofn. 1825-1837. [IX, 142.]

Each Bind has a second title-page, except vol. xii. The first three vols,
deal with Saga Olafs Koniings Tryggvas-onar, the third of which is quoted
in the Ocean.

The key to the division of the volumes among the various editors is to be
found in the " Formali " at the beginning of most of the volumes. Details of
the editorship of the complete work is as follows : Edited, tomes 1-3 and 12, in
part, by S. Egilsson ; 1-6 and 11, in part, by T. GuSmundsson ; 4, 5 and 11,
in part, by T. Helgason ; 8, 1 1 and 12, in part, 9 and 10 wholly, by F. Magniis-
son ; 12, in part, by N. M. Petersen ; 1-5, 8 and 11, in part, by C. C. Rafn ;
1-3, 6 and 11, in part, 7 wholly, by R. C. Rask.

Einaiut Oollah ['Inayatu-'llah]. See under Scott,

Jonathan, Bahar-Danush.
Eisler, R. Weltenmantel und Himmelszelt. 2 vols. Miinchen.

1910. [IX, 141, 148.]
Eitrem, S. Opferritus und Voropfer der Griechen und Romer.

Kristiana. 1915. [IX, 151.]
Eliot, Charles. Hinduism and Buddhism : An Historical

Sketch. 3 vols. 1921. [I, 56n\]
Elliot, H. M. The History of India, as told by its own

Historians. Edited from the Posthumous Papers of the

late Sir H. M. Elliot, K.C.B., ... by Professor John

Dowson, M.R.A.S. . . . 8 vols. Ldn. 1867-1877. [I, 238n3,

248n1.]

The works mentioned in the Ocean are as follows : —

Vol. iv. 1872. Pp. 89-126. No. xxii. Matla'u-s Sa'dain
of 'Abdu-r Razzak. Vol. vii. 1877. Pp. 207-533. Munta-
khabu-l Lubdb of Muhammad Hashim, Khafi Khan. No.
lxxix.

Elliot Smith, G. See under Hose, C.

Ellis, A. B. The Tshi-speaking Peoples of the Gold Coast of
West Africa. Ldn. 1887. [I, 278n2 ; VIII, 227w9.]

BIBLIOGRAPHY 221

Ellis, A. B. The Ewe-speaking Peoples of the Slave Coast of
West Africa. Ldn. 1890. [I, 278n2.]

Ellis, George. Specimens of Early English Metrical
Romances, to which is prefixed An Historical Introduction,
on the Rise and Progress of Romantic Composition in France
and England. New Edition, revised by J. O. Halliwell.
Bohn's Antiquarian Library. Ldn. 1848. [I, 97w2 ; II,
113W1 ; III, 272W1 ; VI, 294w3.]

The first edition had a slightly different title :

Specimens of Early English Metrical Romances, Chiefly
Written during the Early Part of the Fourteenth Century ;
To which is prefixed ... 3 vols. 1805. [I, 169.]

The above reference in the Ocean is to Mr Douce 's Analysis of Petrus
Alphonsus' Disciplina Clericalis. In the first edition it appeared in vol. i,
pp. 127-136, and in Bohn's edition, pp. 39-44.

Ellis, H. Havelock. Studies in the Psychology of Sex.

6 vols. Philadelphia. 1906-1912. [II, 229n2, 308, 308nJ ;

III, 328 ; V, 189W1.]
Elster, E. Tannhduser in Geschichte Sage und Dichtung.

Bromberg. 1908. [VI, 109n2.]
Elton, O. The First Nine Books of the Danish History of

Saxo Grammaticus. With an Introduction by Prof. F.

York Powell. Folk-Lore Society. 1894. [VI, 288n\]
Elworthy, F. T. The Evil Eye. An Account of this ancient

and widespread superstition. . . . Ldn. 1895. [I, 216 ;

II, 298.]
Elworthy, F. T. Horns of Honour, and other studies in the

by-ways of archaeology. . . . Ldn. 1900. [Ill, 188n.]
Elworthy, F. T. " Evil Eye." Hastings' Ency. Rel. Eth.

Vol. v. 1912. Pp. 608-615. [II, 298.]
Enthoven, R. E. The Tribes and Castes of Bombay. 3 vols.

Bombay. 1920-1922. [I, 246/i1 ; III, 322 ; VIII, 274.]
Enthoven, R. E. The Folklore of Bombay. Oxford. 1924. [Ill,

315 ; IV, 70n, 94n, 122n\ Win1, 177W1 ; VII, 229, 230W1.]

Part of this work had already appeared in the pages of The Indian Antiquary
(Supplement), and later as a separate work in two volumes. For both of these
see below.

Enthoven, R. E. " Introduction to Folklore Notes from

Gujarat and the Konkan." Indian Antiquary. Vols, xl,

1911 (Supplement), pp. 1-36; xli, 1912, pp. 37-72; xliv,

1915, pp. 73-105 ; xlv, 1916, pp. 106-124 ; xlvi, 1917,

, pp. 125-160. [VII, 230W1.]

Part of the above was issued in two vols., Bombay, 1914, 1915, as Folk-lore
Notes. Gujarat, Konkan. The material was collected by A. M. T. Jackson.

222 THE OCEAN OF STORY

Enthoven, R. E. See also Crooke, W., Religion & Folklore
of Northern India. (1926.)

Erlenvejn, A. A. Narodnyja russkija skazki i zagadki
sobrannyja seljskimi u-Hteljami Tuljskoj gubernii v 1862
1863 godach. 2nd edit. Moscow. 1882. [VIII, 227n5.]

The collection contains thirty-six tales.

Erp, T. von. See under Krom, N. J.

Ersch, J. S., and Gruber, J. G. Allgemeine Encyklopddie
der Wissenschaften u. Kunste. Leipzig. 1818. etc. [II,
163rc.]

Erskine, J. E. Journal of a Cruise among the Islands of the
Western Pacific, including the Feejees and others inhabited
by the Polynesian Negro Races. Ldn. 1853. [IX, 154.]

Ethe, Hermann. Zakarija Ben Muhammed Ben Mahmud
El-Kazwini's Kosmographie. Nach der Wustenfeldschen
Textausgabe . . . Aus dem Arabischen zum erste Male
vollstdndig ubersetzt von . . . Leipzig. 1868. [II, 298,
312.]

Etienne de Bourbon (Stephanus de Borbone). Liber de
Donis. [II, 114w.]

The above is the best-known title of Tractatus de diversis materiis prce-
dicabilibus ordinatis et distinctis in septem partes, secundum septem dona Spiritus
sancti et eorum affectus. . . . Extracts appear in Lecoy de la Marche, Anecdotes
historiques, Legendes et Apologues. , . . Paris. 1877.

Ettmuller, L. Heinrichs von Meissen des Frauenlobes
Leiche, Spruche, Streitgedichte und Lieder. Erldutert und
herausgegeben von . . . Quedinburg and Leipzig. 1843.
Bibl. d. gesammt. deut. Nat.-Lit. Vol. xvi. [II, 292n3.]

Eugammon of Cyrene. Telegonia. [IX, 157.]

Euripides. Suppliants. [IV, 256.]

Eustathius (or Eumathius, surnamed Macrembolites).
The Story of Hysmine and Hysminus. [V, 200w3.]

Evans, G. H. A Treatise on Elephants : Their Treatment in
Health and Disease. Rangoon. 1901. [VI, 6Sn.]

Evans, G. H. Elephants and their Diseases. Rangoon. 1910.
[VI, 68n.]

Eyre, E. J. Journals of Expeditions of Discovery into Central
Australia, and Overland from Adelaide to King George's
Sound, in 1840-41 ; including an Account of the Manners
and Customs of the Aborigines, and the State of their Rela-
tions with Europeans. 2 vols. Ldn. 1845. [II, 280, 280n4.]

Eysinga, P. P. Rooda van. " Kalilah en Daminah."
Tijdschrift voor NeSrlands Indie. Zesde Jaargang (6th Year).
Pt. 1. Batavia. 1844. Pp. 435-450. [V, 239.]

BIBLIOGRAPHY 223

Falconer, I. G. N. Keith-. See under Keith-Falconer.
Fan Yeh [or Y£]. Hou Han Shu [or How Han shoo]. " The

History of the Later Han Dynasty." With notes by

Prince Chang-hwae and Lew Chaou. 1643. [I, 104.]
Farnell, L. R. The Cults of the Greek States. 5 vols. Oxford.

1896-1909. [I, 15n ; III, 328.]
Farnell, L. R. " Nature (Greek)." Hastings' Ency. Rel.

Eth. Vol. ix. 1917. Pp. 221-227. [VIII, 218n2.]
Farrer, J. A. Primitive Manners and Customs. Ldn. 1879.

[VIII, 228n8.]
Fassel, Rabbi H. B. Neun Derusch Vortrdge. Gross Kanizsa.

1867. [Ill, 59.]
Fausboll, V. The Jdtaka together with its Commentary, being

Tales of the Anterior Births of Gotama Buddha. Translated

by T. W. Rhys Davids and edited in the Original Pali by . . .

6 vols. London, Strassburg and Kopenhagen. 1877-1896.

Index vol. by Dines Andersen. 1897. [I, 66nx ; II, 52m1 ;

III, 4w3, 292wx ; V, 127nx.] See also under Davids,

T. W. Rhys.
Fausboll, V. Indian Mythology according to the Mahd-

bhdrata, in outline. Ldn. 1903. Luzac's Oriental Series.

Vol. i. [II, 45rc4.]
Favre, G. Melanges aVHistoire Litteraire par . . . Recueillis

par sa famille et publies par J. Adert. 2 vols. Geneve.

1856. (Only 300 copies printed.) [II, 289n2.]
Fawcett, F. " Basivis : Women who through Dedication to

a Deity assume Masculine Privileges." Journ. Anth. Soc.

Bombay. Vol. ii. 1892. Pp. 322-345. See also pp. 345-353.

[I, 255, 255W1 ; III, 327.]
Fawcett, F. " Notes on Some of the People of Malabar."

Bulletin of the Madras Museum. Vol. iii, Anthropology.

Madras. 1900. Pp. 1-85. [II, 199rc.]
Fayrer, Joseph. " On Serpent- Worship and on the Veno-
mous Snakes of India and the Mortality caused by them."

Journal of the Transactions of the Victoria Institute, or,

Philosophic Society of Great Britain. Vol. xxvi. 1893.

No. 102. Pp. 85-113. Discussion continues to p. 122.

[II, 311nx.]
Fenwick, C. G. See Vattel, E. de.
Ferguson, Donald. See under Sinclair, W. F.
Ferguson, John. Bibliotheca Chemica : a Catalogue of the

Al-Chemical, Chemical and Pharmaceutical Books in the

Collection of the late James Young of Kelly and Durris.

2 vols. Glasgow. 1906. [Ill, 162w.]

224 THE OCEAN OF STORY

Fergusson, James. Tree and Serpent Worship : or Illus-
trations of Mythology and Art in India in the First and

Fourth Centuries. . . . Ldn. 1873 (revised edition). The

1st edition appeared in 1868. [I, 144m.1]
Fergusson, J. History of Indian and Eastern Architecture.

Revised and Edited, with Additions. Indian Architecture

by James Burgess . . . and Eastern Architecture by

R. Phene Spiers. ... 2 vols. Ldn. 1910. [II, 265ft4.]
Fergusson, Samuel. " On the Ceremonial Turn, called

4 Deisul.' " Proceedings of the Royal Irish Academy. Vol. i.

2nd Series. Dublin. 1879. Pp. 355-364. [I, 190.]
Ferrand, G. Relations de Voyages et Textes Geographique

Arabes, Per sans et Turks relatifs a VExtrSme-Orient du

VHP au XV IIP siicles. Traduits revues et annot^s par

. . . Documents Historiques et Geographiques relatifs a

rindochine. ... 2 vols. Paris. 1913-1914. [Ill, 260ft1.]
Ferrand, G. Contes populaires malgaches. Paris. 1893.

[V, 127ft1 ; VIII, 227ft10.]
Ferrand, G. " L'Empire Sumatranais de £rivijaya."

Journ. Asiatic. 11th Series. Tom. xx. Paris. 1922.

Pp. 1-104 ; 161-244. [IV, 224ft1.]
Ficalho, Conde de. Garcia da Orta e o seu tempo. Lisbon.

1886. [VIII, 240.]
Ficalho, Conde de. Coloquios dos simples, e drogas da

India. ... 2 vols. Lisbon. 1891, 1895. [VIII, 245.]

See also under Markham, Clements.
Ficalho, the Conde de. See also under Markham,

Clements.
Firenzuola, Agnolo. Discorsi degli Animali Nuoumente

ristampati dfc reuisti. Venetia. 1562. (Other editions :

1602, 1841.) [V, 220, 238.]
Fischer, H. See under Bolte, J., and Fischer, H.
Fitzgerald, David. "The Myth of the Sirens." The

Academy. 3rd Sept. 1881. No. 487. P. 182. [VI, 281,

281ft1, 282ft6.]
Fleeson, K. N. Laos Folklore of Farther India. New York.

1899. [V, 59ft2 ; VII, 261.]
Fleet, J. F. " Imaginative Yojanas " — Miscellaneous

Communications. Journ. Roy. As. Soc. Jan. 1912. Pp. 229-

239. [I, 3ft1 ; VI, 70ft1.]
Fletcher, John. Rule a Wife and Have a Wife. [V, 13ft1.]

Woman Pleased. [VI, 271.] See also under Shakespeare,

W., and Fletcher, John.
Forbes, A. K. See under Rawlinson, H. G.

BIBLIOGRAPHY 225

Forbes, C. J. F. Smith. British Burma and its People. . . .

Ldn. 1878. [II, 266n1.]
Forbes, Duncan. The Adventures of Hatim Tax, A Romance.

Translated from the Persian by . . . Oriental Translation

Fund. Ldn. 1830. [II, 6n2 ; VI, 280W1.]
Forbiger, A. P. Virgilii Maronis Opera ad optimorum

librorum fidem edidit perpetua et aliorum et sua adnotatione

illustravit dissertationem de virgilii vita et carminibus atque

indicem rerum locupletissimum. 3 pts. (vols.). Lipsiae.

1845-1846. (3rd edit. 1852.) [VIII, 49n1.]
Forcellini, Egidio. " Salisatores " [in his Totius Latinitatis

Lexicon. 4 vols. Padua. 1771]. [V, 201n.]
Fornmanna Sogur. See under Egilsson, S. [and others].
Forster, Edward. The Arabian Nights1 Entertainments ;

translated by . . . Ldn. 1839. [II, 147ft1.]
Forster, P. R. De Aristotelis quae feruntur secretis secretorum

commentatio. Kilise. 1888. [II, 287ft1, 288ft1.]
Forteguerri, Ser Giovanni. Novelle edite ed inedite.

(Limited to 202 copies.) Introduction by V. Lami. Bologna.

1882. [I, 44.]
Foster, William. The Embassy of Sir Thomas Roe to the

Court of the Great Mogul, 1615-1619, as narrated in his

Journal and Correspondence. Edited from Contemporary

Records by ... 2 vols. Hakluyt Society. Ldn. 1899.

[VIII, 266ft2.]

These are the first two volumes of the 2nd Series.

Foster, William. Early Travels in India, 1583-1619. Oxford.
1921. [VIII, 266ft3.]'

The travellers dealt with in the above work are as follows : Ralph Fitch,
1583-1591 ; John Mildenhall, 1599-1606 ; William Hawkins, 1608-1613 ;
William Finch, 1608-1611; Nicholas Withington, 1612-1616; Thomas
Coryat, 1612-1617 ; and Edward Terry, 1616-1619-

Foulet, L. Le Roman de Renard. Bibliotheque de l'Ecole

des Hautes Etudes. Sciences Historiques et Philologiques.

(Fascicule No. 211.) Paris. 1914. [Ill, 34ft.]
Fouque, F. H. K. de la Motte. Undine. (First appeared

in 1811. See the English translation by Edmund Gosse,

New Edition, 1912.) [VI, 280.]
Fowler, H. W. and F. G. The Works of Lucian of Samosata.

Complete with exceptions specified in the Preface. 4 vols.
. Oxford. 1905. [I, 77ft1, 140ft1.] See further under Lucian.
Fox, C. E. The Threshold of the Pacific. An Account of the

Social Organization, Magic and Religion of the People of

VOL. IX. p

226 THE OCEAN OF STORY

San Cristoval in the Solomon Islands. With a Preface by
G. Elliot Smith, F.R.S. Ldn. 1924. [VIII, 316ft1.]

This volume forms part of the " History of Civilisation " Series.

France, Anatole. Les Sept Femmes de la Barbe-Bleu, et autres
Contes Merveilleux. Paris. 1909. [II, 224ft.]

Francis, H. T., and Thomas, E. J. Jataka Tales. Selected
and Edited with Introduction and Notes. Cambridge. 1916.
[VI, 284ft1.]

Francis, H. T. See under Cowell, E. B.

Francke, A. H. " Die Geschichten des toten $o-rub-can.
Eine tibetische Form der Vetalapaficavirhsatika aus
Purig." Zeitschrift der Deutschen Morgenldndischen
Gesellschaft. Vol. lxxv. Leipzig. 1921. Pp. 72-96. [VI,
242ft1 ; VIII, 59ft3.]

Francke, A. H. " Zur tibetischen Vetalapancaviihgatika
(Siddhikur)." Zeitschrift der Deutschen Morgenldndischen
Gesell. Neue Folge, Band ii (Band lxxvii). Leipzig. 1923.
Pp. 239-254. [IX, 161.]

Frauenlob (Heinrich von Meissen). See under Bartsch, K.
D2idschc Liederdichter . . . ; Boerckel, A. ; Ettmuller, L. ;
Hagen, F. H. von der ; Kroeger, A. E.

Frazer, J. G. Totemism and Exogamy. A Treatise on Certain
Early Forms of Superstition and Society. 4 vols. Ldn.
1910. [VIII, 233ft2.]

Frazer, J. G. The Golden Bough. A Study in Magic and
Religion. 3rd edit. 12 vols. Ldn. 1911-1915. [I, 37ft2,
130, 144ft1, 222, 228, 268, 273ft3, 278, 278ft3 ; II, 72ft1, 83,
105ft, 108ft, 117, 118, 166, 189ft1, 253, 253ft1, 256, 256ft2,
257n2, 268, 268ft1 ; III, 38, 142ft1, 151, 153, 203, 314, 314ft6,
328 ; IV, 16 ; V, 189ft1 ; VI, In1, 24ft, 59, 100ft1, 133, 137,
265ft3, 283ft3 ; VII, 231n2, 231ft3, 240, 240ft3 ; VIII, 233ft2.]

The 3rd edition of The Golden Bough, in 12 vols., presents grave difficulties
from a reference point of view, owing to the fact that the volumes are not
numbered consecutively on the back. If in a public library vol. xii (the " key "
vol.) happens to be " out," there is no cue whatever to tell you, e.g., that
vol. viii of the series is Spirits of the Corn, vol. ii. Readers (and the
publishers) would be well advised to stamp consecutive numbers on each
corresponding volume. The titles in the correct order are as follows : I. The
Magic Art and the Evolution of Kings, vol. i. II. The Magic Art and the
Evolution of Kings, vol. ii. III. Taboo and the Perils of the Soul ; IV. The
Dying God ; V. Adonis Attis Osiris Studies in the History of Oriental Religion,
vol. i. VI. Adonis Attis Osiris . . . vol. ii. VII. Spirits of the Corn and of
the Wild, vol. i. VIII. Spirits of the Corn and of the Wild, vol. ii. IX.
The Scapegoat ; X. Balder the Beautiful. The Fire-Festivals of Europe . . .
vol. i. XI. Balder the Beautiful . . . vol. ii. XII. Bibliography and General
Index.

BIBLIOGRAPHY 227

Frazer, J. G. Pausanias's Description of Greece. Translated,
with a Commentary, by ... 6 vols. 2nd edit. Ldn.
1913. [II, 70w2 ; IV, 14, 65n, 249rc, 258 ; V, 256, 257, 266 ;
VI, 133, 282n6 ; VII, 240, 240w2.]

Vol. i contains the translation, vols, ii-v form the Commentary, and vol. vi
consists of the Indices and Maps.

Frazer, J. G. The Belief in Immortality and the Worship
of the Dead. 3 vols. Ldn. 1913,1922,1924. Vol. i— The
Belief among the Aborigines of Australia, the Torres Straits
Islands, New Guinea and Melanesia. Vol. ii — The Belief
among the Polynesians. Vol. iii — The Belief among the
Micronesians. [Ill, 314, 314w2 ; VI, 137; VIII, 225w4,
308W1.]

A fourth volume is promised dealing with the Belief among the Indonesians.

Frazer, J. G. Folk-Lore in the Old Testament. Studies in
Comparative Religion, Legend and Law. 3 vols. 1918.
[II, 194w ; III, 153 ; VIII, 107n.]

Frazer, J. G. Apollodorus, The Library, with an English
Translation by ... 2 vols. Ldn. 1921. Loeb Classical
Librarv. [Ill, 258 ; VI, 18nx, 133, 134, 282w6 ; VII, 3n2,
227, 227w2, 230, 230n* ; VIII, 107n, 117n2 ; IX, 143.]

Frazer, J. G. " Indonesians." Hastings' Ency. Bel. Eth.
Vol. vii. 1914. Pp. 232-252. [Ill, 313, 313n5.]

Frederick, Caesar. See under Hakluyt, Richard.

Frere, M. Old Deccan Days or Hindoo Fairy Legends Current
in Southern India. Collected from oral tradition by . . .
Ldn. 1868. [I, 28, 95n2, lOln1, 131, 142m1 ; II, 3n, W8n,
136/11, 202nx ; III, 2Sn\ 52n, 62, 238 ; IV, 48 ; V, 49W1.]

This was the pioneer work in modern Indian folk- tales. In 1868 an edition
appeared in Philadelphia, and also a Danish translation by L. Moltke. The
second English edition was in 1870, and the third edition, with notes by
Sir Bartle Frere and illustrations by C. F. Frere, was issued in 1881. It is from
this latter edition that I have made any quotations which appear in the Ocean.
A further American edition came out in 1897, and a German one, by Passow,
was published in Jena. No date.

Fresnoy, N. Lenglet du. Histoire de la Philosophic Her-
metique. Accompagnee oVun catalogue raisonne des ecrivains
de cette science. Avec le veritable Philalethe revu sur les
originaux. 3 vols. Paris. 1742. [Ill, 162n.]
Freytag, G. Arabum Proverbia vocalibus instruxit, Latine
vertit, commentario illustravit et sumptibus suis edidit. . . .
* 3 vols. Bonnse ad Rhenum. 1838-1843. [Ill, 279.1

Arabic and Latin. Vol. iii is in two parts, each with a distinct title-page and
pagination.

228 THE OCEAN OF STORY

Friederich, R. " Voorloopig Verslag van het Eiland Bali."

Verhandelingen van het Bataviaasch Genootschap van Kunsten

en Wetenschappen. (Extract from.) Vol. xxiii. 1849.

[IV, 258.]
Friedlander, L. Darstellungen aus der Sittengeschichte

Roms in der Zeit von August bis zum Ausgang der Antonine.

Sechste rieu bearbeitete und vermehrte Ausflage. 3 vols.

Leipzig. 1888-1890. [VIII, 117n2.]
Fritsche, A. T. A. Theocritus' Idyllia. Iterum edidit . . .

Leipzig. 1868-1869. [V, 201w.]
Fritze, L. Nala und Damayanti. Zwei altindische Erzdh-

lungen. Aus dem Sanskrit metrisch ubersetzt von . . .

Berlin. 1913. [IX, 155.]
Frobel, J. Seven Years' Travel in Central America, Northern

Mexico, and the Far West of the United States. Ldn. 1859.

(From Aus Amerika. 2 vols. Leipzig. 1857, 1858.) [II,

280ti7.]
Fryer, A. C. Book of English Fairy Tales from the North

Country. Ldn. 1884. [I, 26.]

Part of the " Fairy Library of All Nations." A reissue appeared in London,
1896, with a different title-page.

Fryer, John. A New Account of East India and Persia.
Being Nine Years' Travels, 1672-1681. Edited with Notes
and an Introduction by William Crooke, B.A. 3 vols.
Hakluyt Society. Ldn. 1909, 1912 and 1915. [VIII, 269,
270.]

The volumes form Nos. xix, xx and xxxix of the 2nd Series.

Fuhrer, A. The Monumental Antiquities and Inscriptions
in the North- Western Provinces and Oudh. Described and
arranged by . . . Allahabad. 1891. Archaeological Survey
of India. (New Series.) Vol. ii. [IV, 166n* ; VI, 69nx.]

Fulton, A. S. See under Steele, Robert.

Furnivall, F. J. The Wright's Chaste Wife, or ... A Merry
Tale, by Adam of Cobsam, From a MS. in the Library of the
Archbishop of Canterbury, at Lambeth, about a.d. 1462.
Early English Text Society. Reprints, 1865, No. 12.
[2nd edit., 1869.] Ldn. 1865. [I, 44, 165.]

Fyzee-Rahamin, A. B. The Music of India. Ldn. 1925.
[VIII, 95W1.]

The above work first appeared (somewhat shorter) in 1914 under the title of
Indian Music, by Shahinda (Begum Fyzee-Rahamin), with a Preface by
F. Gilbert Webb. The British Museum catalogue under " Faiz I Rahamln,
'Atlyah Begam."

BIBLIOGRAPHY 229

Gaal, G. v. Mdhrchen der Magyaren. Wien. 1822. [I, 20w,
26 ; II, 135w2, 207w2 ; III, 48W1, 167n2, 226rc2, 238 ; IV,
213711 ; V, 157nl ; VI, 26w3, 280 ; VII, 72n3.]
The collection consists of seventeen stories.

Gagniere. " Missions de l'Oceanie Centrale Extrait d'une
lettre du R. P. Gagniere, de la Societe de Marie, au R. P.
Poupinel." [On customs, etc., in New Caledonia.] Annates
de la Propagation de la Foi, Recueil Periodique des Lettres
des evSques et des Missionnaires. . . . Vol. xxxii. Lyons.
1860. Pp. 438-446. [VI, 134, 135.]

Gait, E. A. " Khasi," from the Assam Census Report, 1891.
Census of India, 1901. Vol. i, India. Ethnographic
Appendices, being the Data upon which the Caste Chapter
of the Report is based, by H. H. Risley. . . . Calcutta.
1903. Pp. 198-200. [VIII, 285711.]

Gait, E. A. " Human Sacrifice (Indian)." Hastings' Ency.
Rel. Eth. Vol. vi. 1913. Pp. 849-853. [I, 116m1.]

Galen, Claudius. De Simplicivm Medicamentorvm Facvl-
tatibvs Libri Vndecim. Paris. 1530. [I, 213.]-

I cannot find the 1576 Venice edition mentioned in the Ocean.

Galland, A. Les Contes et Fables indiennes de Bidpai et de
Lokman, traduites oVAli Tchelebi-Ben-Saleh, auteur turc.
(Posthumous work.) 2 vols. Paris. 1724. [V, 241.]

The above work gives only the first four chapters and makes no mention
of Lokman. It was followed later by :

Galland and Cardonne. Contes et fables indiennes,

de Bidpai et de Lokman. . . . Ouvrage commence par

M. Galland, continue et fini par M. Cardonne. 4 vols.

Paris. 1778. [V, 241.]
Ganapati Sastri. See under SastrI, T. Ganapati.
Garbe, R. Indien und das Christentum. Eine Untersuchung

der religionsgeschichtlichen Zusammenhange. Tubingen.

1914. [IV, 185w2.]
Garbe, R. " Vedanta." Hastings' Ency. Rel. Eth. Vol. xii.

1913. Pp. 597-598. [VI, 35.] " Yoya." Hastings' Ency.

Rel. Eth. Vol. xii. 1913. Pp. 831-833. [IV, 39/i1.]
Garcia da Orta. See under Orta, Garcia da.
Garcin de Tassy, J. H. Histoire de la Litter ature hindouie et

hindoustanie. [V, 240 ; VI, 240n2.]

The 2-vol. edition was issued by the Oriental Translation Fund, Paris,
1839-1847. The 2nd edition was in 3 vols., 1870-1871.

Garcin de Tassy, J. H. Allegories Recits Poetiques et Chants
Populaires traduits de VArabe, du Persan, de VHindoustani
and du Turc. 2nd edit. Paris. 1876. [VII, 224/11.]

230 THE OCEAN OF STORY

Garcin de Tassy, J. H. " L'inexorable Courtisane et les
Talismans." Revue Orientale et Americaine. Vol. x. 1865.
Pp. 149-157. [I, 28.]

Gardner, C. "Folk-Lore in Mongolia." The Folk-Lore
Journal. Vol. iv. 1886. Pp. 18-45. [I, 27.]

Garnett, L. M. J. The Women of Turkey and their Folk-
Lore. Vol. i, The Christian Women. Vol. ii, The Jewish
and Moslem Women. 2 vols. Ldn. 1890, 1891. [II,
163w.]

Garrett, John. A Classical Dictionary of India, illustrative
of the Mythology, Philosophy, Literature, . . . Manners,
Customs . . . of the Hindus. 2 pts. Madras. 1871-1873.
[II, 252W1.]

Garstang, J. See under Strong, H. A.

Gaspar de los Reyes Franco. Elysius jucundarum quces-
tionum Campus; . . . Bruxellae. 1661. [II, 300, 300w3.]

Gaster, M. Beitrdge zur vergleichenden Sagen- und Mdrchen-
Kunde. Bucharest, 1883. [V, 128n.]

This work was limited to fifty copies for private distribution. It is to be
reprinted in Dr Gaster 's Studies and Texts.

Gaster, M. The Exempla of the Rabbis ; being a Collection of
Exempla, Apologues and Tales culled from Hebrew Manu-
scripts and rare Hebrew Books. Ldn. Leipzig. The Asia
Publishing Co. 1924. [Ill, 63, 118W1, 172??, 251 ; IV, 192nx ;
VI, 287, 287n4, 288 ; VII, 203n4.]

Gaster, M. Studies and Texts. 3 vols. [Probably Ldn.
1928.] [V, 128n.]

Gaster, M. " The Hebrew Version of the * Secretum
Secretorum.' " Journ. Roy. As. Soc. Oct. 1907, pp. 879-
912 ; Jan. 1908, pp. 111-162 ; and Oct. 1908, pp. 1065-
1084. [II, 290, 290711, 291, 298, 298n2.]

Gaulmin, M. See under Sahid, David.

Gay, John. Trivia, or the Art of Walking the Streets of
London. (First appeared in 1716.) [II, 270, 271.]

Gayangos, P. de. Calila e Dymna, de Abdallah ben al-
Mocaffa. Vol. Ii. of Bibl. de autores espafioles. Madrid.
1860. [V, 237.]

Geden, A. S. " Asceticism (Hindu)." Hastings' Ency. Rel.
Eth. Vol. ii. 1909. Pp. 87-96. [I, 79n\]

Geil, W. E. The Sacred 5 of China is the 5th Book on China
by . . . Ldn. 1926. [VIII, 248n.]

Geldner, K. F. " Asvamedha." Hastings' Ency. Rel. Eth.
Vol. ii. 1909. Pp. 160, 161. [IV, 16.] See also under
Pischel, R., and Geldner, K. F.

BIBLIOGRAPHY 231

Gellius, Aulus. Nodes Atticae. [II, 277 ; III, 56 ; V, 162W1 ;

IX, 4>7nK]
Geoffrey of Monmouth. Historia Britonum. [VIII, 154n2.]
Georges, L. I/Arme bacteriologique future concurrents des

armes chimique et balistique ; tentatives allemandes repetees

de son emploi de 1914 a 1918. . . . Paris. 1922. [11,281.]
Gerard, John. The Herball, or Generall Historie of Plantes.

Ldn. 1597. (Enlarged edit. 1633.) [Ill, 154.]
Gering, Hugo. Die Edda. Die Lieder der sogenannten

dlteren Edda, nebst einem Anhang Die muthischen und

heroischen Erzdhlungen der Snorra Edda. Ubersetzt und

erlautert von . . . Leipzig and Vienna. 1892. [VIII,

223, 223W1 ; IX, 142.]
Gerould, G. H. The Grateful Dead. The History of a Folk

Story. Folk-Lore Society. Ldn. 1908. [II, 80nK]
Gibb, E. J. W. The Story of Jewdd. A Romance by ''All

Aziz Efendi the Cretan. Translated from the Turkish

by . . . Glasgow. 1884. [II, 190ft1 ; VII, 248.]
Gibb, E. J. W. The History of the Forty Vezirs or The Story

of the Forty Morns and Eves. Written in Turkish. By

Sheykh-Zdda. Done into English by . . . Ldn. 1886.

[I, 38n, 43 ; II, 123 ; III, 20n\ 204 ; IV, 48 ; V, 153711 ;

VI, 249 ; VII, 203w6, 245, 252W1.]
Gibbon, Edward. Decline and Fall of the Roman Empire.

[Ill, 329.]
Gilbert, H. " Culture du Betel (Piper Betle de Linne).

Cay D'au-khong des Annamites (Annam)." Bulletin

Economique. Gouvcrnement General de VIndochinc. New

Series. Vol. xiv. Hanoi-Haiphong. 1911. Pp. 382-391.

[VIII, 318nx.]
Gildemeister, J. Scriptorum Arabum de Rebus Indicis loci,

et Opuscida inedita . . . Fasciculum primus [no more

published]. Bonn. 1838. [II, 312rc2.]
Giles, Herbert A. Strange Stories from a Chinese Studio.

Translated and Annotated by ... 2 vols. Ldn. 1880.

[I, 77W1; III, 191711; IV, 25n3 ; V, 162nx; VI, 15n3, 95n\

136, 277.]

A 2nd edition, revised, appeared in one volume, Ldn., 1909» and a

3rd edition in 1916.

Giles, H. A. Some Truths about Opium. Cambridge. 1923.
[II, 304W1.]
A pamphlet of forty pages.

Giles, Lionel. An Alphabetical Index to the Chinese Encyclo-
paedia. . . . ChHn Ting Ku Chin T'u Shu Chi Ch'eng.

232

THE OCEAN OF STORY

Compiled by . . . British Museum. Ldn. 1911. [IV,
257w3 ; VIII, 304.]

Prepared in the reign of the Emperor K'ang Hsi, under the editorship of
Ch'enMSng-lei ; the encyclopaedia was not published until 1726 — for political
reasons. The work consists of 10,000 chiian, or books, the copy at the British
Museum being bound in 745 thick volumes. In English printing this would,
roughly, correspond to a work about four times the size of the Ency. Brit. It
is considered to be the greatest typographical feat that the world has seen.
A reprint of the work, limited to 250 copies, appeared some time subsequent
to 1862. A second reprint was undertaken in 1885-1888.

Gill, W. W. Myths and Songs from the South Pacific. With a
Preface by F. M. Muller. Ldn., Beccles [printed]. 1876.
[Ill, 314, 314w3.]

The text of the songs is in Polynesian and English.

Gillen, F. J. See under Spencer, W. B., and Gillen, F. J.
Gimlette, J. D. Malay Poisons and Charm Cures. 2nd edit.
Ldn. 1923. [II, 303V.]

The 1st edition appeared in 1915 and was only about half the size of the
2nd edition.

Giovanni, Ser. See under Waters, W. G.

Giraud, J. Testament d'un Haschischeen. Paris. 1913.

[VII, 249w2.]
Gladwin, Francis. The Persian Moonshee. Persian and

English. Calcutta. 1795. [Ill, HSn1.]

A 2- vol. (3rd) edition appeared in Calcutta, 1800 ; another in London, 1801,
and an abridged version by Smyth in 1882. A translation into Bengali by
Galloway, with the English, was issued in Calcutta, 1840.

Godabole, N. B. " Folklore — The Story of Chandrahasya."

Indian Antiquary. Vol. xi. 1882. Pp. 84-86. [Ill, 280.]
Godeke, K. " Zu Kalilah und Dimnah." Orient und

Occident. Vol. i. 1862. Pp. 681-688. [V, 238.]
Godeke, K. " Liber de septem sapienibus." Orient und

Occident. Vol. iii. 1866. Pp. 385-423. [V, 261n3.]
Godley, A. D. Herodotus, with an English Translation by

. . . Loeb Classical Library. 4 vols. Ldn. 1920-1921.

[V, 245nS 254.]
Goes, Benedict. See under Yule, H., Cathay and the Way

Thither.
Goethe, J. W. von. Faust. [II, 105n, 297.] Faust (trans.

Bayard Taylor. 2 vols. Ldn. 1871). [IV, 227m1.] Legende

(in Sdmmtliche Werke. Vol. i of the Stuttgart and

Tubingen 40-vol. edit. 1840.) [VI, 276.] See also under

Taylor, Bayard.
Goldsmid, F. See under Morier, James.

BIBLIOGRAPHY 233

Golther, Wolfgang. " Studien zur germanischen sagen-
geschichte I der valkyrjenmythus. II iiber das verhaltniss
der nordischen und deutschen form der Nibelungensage."
Abhandlungen der Philosophisch-Philogischen Classe Der
Koniglich Bayerischen Akademie der Wissenschaften.
Vol. xviii. Pt. 2. Munchen. 1890. Pp. 399-504. [VIII,
224ft1.]

Gomes, E. H. Seventeen Years among the Sea Dyaks of Borneo.
A record of intimate association with the natives of the
Bornean Jungles. . . . And an Introduction by the Rev.
John Perham. With 40 illustrations and a map. Ldn.
1911. [VIII, 231ft9.]

,Gomme, G. L. The History of the Seven Wise Masters of
Rome, printed from the edition of Wynkyn de Worde, 1520,
and edited, with an Introduction, by . . . Ldn. 1885.
Chap-Books and Folk-Lore Tracts, First Series, II. [V,
266ft2.]

Gomme, Lawrence. " Mutilations." Hastings' Ency. Rel.
Eth. Vol. ix. 1917. Pp. 62-63. [Ill, 21ft.]

Gongrijp, J. R. P. E. Hhikajat Kalila dan Damina tersalin
dari pada nosehat malajoe. . . . Leiden. 1876. (2nd edit.
1892.) [V, 239.]

Gonzenbach, L. Sicilianische Mdrchen. Aus dem Volks-
mund gesammelt . . . Mit Anmerkungen R. Kohler's und
einer Einleitung herausgegeben von O. Hartwig. 2 vols.
Leipzig. 1870. [I, 20ft, 25, 26, 44, 66ft1, 97ft2, 129, 141ft2,
165, 169 ; II, 6n2, 80ft1, 113ft1, 135ft2, 155n4, 190nS 196W1,
202ft1, 209ft1 ; III, 104ft2, 124ft1, 187ft3, 211ft1, 218ft1, 222ft1,
225ft2, 226ft2, 230ft2, 236, 259ft2, 272ft1 ; IV, 248ft1 ; V, 3ft1,
lift1, 117ft1, 164ft1, 171ft2 ; VI, 47ft1 ; VII, 81ft1, 126ft2 ;
VIII, 59ft3 ; IX, 78ft.]

Goonetilleke, W. " Comparative Folklore." The Orient-
alist. . . . Vol. i. 1884. Pp. 249-260. [I, 101ft1 ; V, 64.]

The RasavahinI story appears on pp. 252-255 and forms the second part
of the article ; the story of the goddess PattinI forms the third part (pp.
255-256).

Goonetilleke, W. and S. J. " Sinhalese Folklore." The
Orientalist, a Monthly Journal of Oriental Literature. Vol. i.
Kandy, Ceylon. 1884. Pp. 35-40. [Ill, 76.]

Gosse, E. See under Br^ekstad, H. L.

Gosson, S. Schoole of Abuse, containing a pleasant invective
against Poets, Pipers, Plaiers, Jesters, and such like Cater-
pillars of the Commonwealth (1579). Edited by E. Arber
in his English Reprints. Ldn. 1868. [V, 55ft3, 133ft.]

234 THE OCEAN OF STORY

Goswami, B. The Mudrd-Rdkshasa. Calcutta. [1909.] [II,

283ft3.]
Gother, W. Zur deutschen Sage und Dichtung. Gesammelte

Aufsdtze. Leipzig. 1911. [VI, 109ft2.]
Gottfried von Strassburg. Tristan und Isolde. [VI,

109n2.]
Gough, A. E. See under Cowell, E. B., and Gough, A. E.
Gould, Baring-. See under Baring-Gould, S.
Gower, John. Confessio amantis. [V, 157ft1.]

The 1st edition is dated 1390. It was published by Caxton in 1483. See
G. C. Macaulay's edition of Gower 's Works, 4 vols., 1899-1902.

Graafland, N. De Minahassa. Haar Verleden en Haar
Tegenwoordige Toe stand. (Eene bijdrage tot de Land-
en Volkenkunde.) 2 vols. Rotterdam. 1867, 1869. [VIII,

297ft2.]

A new and enlarged edition appeared in 1898, published at Haarlem in two
vols. The title was the same, except that the words in parentheses are omitted.

Grafton, R. A Chronicle at large, and meere History of

the affayres of England. . . . Ldn. 1569 (and numerous

subsequent editions). [VI, 24ft.]
Graham, A. W. Siam: A Handbook of Practical, Com-
mercial, and Political Information. Ldn. 1912. [VIII,

288ft1.]
Graham, W. A. Siam. With one hundred and fifty-three

illustrations and a map. 2 vols. Ldn. 1924. [VIII, 289ft2.]
Grand, Le. See under Le Grand d'Aussy, P. J. P.
Grandgent, C. H. See under Schofield, W. H.
Granet, Marcel. Dorises et Legendes de la Chine Ancienne.

Travaux de l'annee sociologique ... 2 vols. Paris.

1926. [IX, 153.]
Grasberger, L. Nodes Indicce sive quo3stiones in Nalum

Mahdbhdrateum. Wirceburgi. 1862. [IV, 292.]
Grasse, J. G. T. Beitrdge zur Literatur u. Sage des Mittel-

alters. 3 vols. Dresden. 1850. [I, 25, 169.]
Grasse, J. G. T. Die beiden dllesten lateinischen Fabelbucher

des Mittelalters. Des Bischofs Cyrillus Speculum und des

Nicolaus Pergamenus Dialogus Creaturam herausgegeben

von . . . Bibliothek des Litterarischen Vereins in Stuttgart,

cxlviii. Tubingen. 1880. [II, 114ft.]
Graves, A. P. The Irish Fairy Book. Ldn. 1909 (date at

end of Preface). [VIII, 107ft'.]
Gray, Albert. The Voyage of Francois Pyrard of Laval to

the East Indies, the Maldives, the Moluccas and Brazil.

Translated into English from the third French edition of

BIBLIOGRAPHY 235

1619, and edited, with Notes, by ... , assisted by H. C. P.

Bell, Ceylon Civil Service. 2 vols. (Vol. ii is in two parts,

each of which forms a separate volume.) Hakluyt Society.

The numbers and dates of the volumes are as follows :

Vol. i— First Series. No. 76. 1887. Vol. ii, pt. i— First

Series. No. 77. 1887. Vol. ii, pt. ii— First Series. No. 80.

1889. [VIII, 266W1.]
Gray, Albert. See also under Dampier, William.
Gray, Louis H. " Eunuch." Hastings' Ency. Rel. Eth.

Vol. v. 1912. Pp. 579-584. [Ill, 319, 320, 328.]
Green, A. O. Modern Arabic Stories, Ballads, Proverbs and

Idioms. Collected and Translated bij . . . Arabic and

English. 2 pts. Oxford. 1909. [Ill, 76.]
Gregor, Walter. Notes on the Folk-Lore of the North-east of

Scotland. Folk-Lore Society. Ldn. 1881. [VI, 150rc.]
Gregorovius, F. Geschichte der Stadt Rom im Mittelalter.

Vom funften Jahrhundert bis zum sechzchnten Jahrhunderi.

8 vols. Stuttgart. 1859-1872. [II, 310n2.]

The above is the 1st edition. The Brit. Mus. have no copy of the 2nd
edition quoted in the Ocean. The story of Ladislao is to be found in vol. vi,
p. 622 of 1st edition. The English translation, by G. W. Hamilton (Mrs),
appeared in 8 vols., London, 1894-1902 (2nd edition, 1900-1909), entitled
History of the City of Rome in the Middle Ages, by Ferdinand Gregorovius,
translated from the Fourth German Edition. [1886-1896.]

Gregory, J. C. The Nature of Laughter. Ldn. 1924. Inter-
national Library of Psychology, Philosophy and Scientific
Method. [VII, 253W1.]

Grey, Edward. The Travels of Pietro Delia Valle in India,
from the Old English Translation of 1664 by G. Havers.
Edited, with a Life of the Author, and Introduction and
Notes, by ... 2 vols. Hakluvt Society. Ldn. 1892.
[VIII, 266w\]

The above vols, form Nos. 84 and 85 of the First Series.

Grierson, G. A. The Modern Vernacular Literature of
Hindustan. Calcutta. 1889. [VI, 226.]

Grierson, G. A. Bihar Peasant Life, being A Discursive
Catalogue of the Surroundings of the people of that province,
with many illustrations from photographs taken by the
Author. Prepared (in 1885), under Orders of the Govern-
ment of Bengal. Second and Revised Edition. Patna.
1926. [VIII, 275 ; IX, 150, 160.]

Grierson, G. A. " Maithila Folk-Lore — Vararuchi as a
Guesser of Acrostics." Indian Antiquary. Vol. x. 1881.
Pp. 366-370. [I, 50711.]

236 THE OCEAN OF STORY

Grierson, G. A. "The Water of Life." Folk-Lore. Vol. xi.

1900. Pp. 433-434. [Ill, 253nx.]
Grierson, G. A. " Pisaca = Q/nocpdyog. " Journ. Roy. As.

Soc. April 1905. Pp. 285-288. [I, 92.]
Grierson, G. A. "Modern Hinduism and its Debt to the

Nestorians." Journ. Roy. As. Soc. April 1907. Pp. 311-

335. Discussion, pp. 477-503. [IX, 108nx.]
Grierson, G. A. " Gleanings from the Bhakta-Mala."

Journ. Roy. As. Soc. July 1909, pp. 607-644 ; Jan. 1910,

pp. 87-109 ; April 1910, pp. 269-306. [Ill, 280.]
Grierson, G. A. " Rajasekhara and the Home of Paisaci."

Journ. Roy. As. Soc. July 1921. Pp. 424-428. [I, 93.]
Grierson, G. A. " Mongoose." Journ. Roy. As. Soc. Oct.

1923. Pp. 619, 620. [V, 189ft1.]
Grierson, G. A. " Prakrit." Ency. Brit. 11th edit. Vol.

xxii. Pp. 251-254. [IX, 99n\]
Grierson, G. A. " Paisaci, Pisacas, and ' Modern Pisaca.' "

Zeitschrift der Deutschen Morg. Gesell. Vol. lxvi. 1912.

Pp. 49-86. [I, 93.]
Grierson, G. A. " Pisacas in the Mahabharata." Fest-
schrift Vilhelm Thomsen zur Vollendung des Siebzigsten

Lebensjahres am 25. Januar 1912 darg. von Freunden und

Schulern. Leipzig. 1912. Pp. 138-141. [I, 93.]
Grierson, G. A. " Gaya." Hastings' Ency. Ret. Eth. Vol. vi.

1913. Pp. 181-187. [VII, 85n.]
Grierson, G. A. " Pisachas." Hastings' Ency. Rel. Eth.

Vol. x. 1918. Pp. 43-45. [I, 92.]
Grierson, G. A. " Western Hindi — A Folk-Tale." Linguistic

Survey of India. Vol. ix. Pt. i : Specimens of Western

Hindi and Panjdbi. Calcutta. 1916. Pp. 228-230. [V, 65.]
Grierson, G. A. Linguistic Survey of India. Vol. viii. Pt. ii :

Specimens of the Dardic or Pisacha Languages {including

Kashmiri). Calcutta. 1919. [1,93; IX, 151.]
Grierson, G. A. "The Lay of Brahma's Marriage: An

Episode of the Alh-Khand." Bull. School Orient. Studies.

Vol. ii. Pt. iv. 1921-23. Pp. 573-608. [IX, 153.]
Grierson, G. A. See also under Stein, A., and Grierson,

G. A. ; Waterfield, W.
Griffis, W. E. The Japanese Fairy World. Ldn. 1887.

[V, 128n.]
Griffith, R. T. H. The Birth of the War-God. Translated

into English Verse by . . . Oriental Translation Fund.

Ldn. 1853. [VI, an1.]

BIBLIOGRAPHY 237

Griffith, R. T. H. The Rdmdyan of Vdlmiki. Translated
into English Verse. 5 vols. London and Benares. 1870-
1874. [I, 5/i1 ; II, 45n4 ; VII, 174 ; VIII, 44n*.]

Book vii, Uttarakanda, is only summarised in an Appendix, pp. 315-329 of
vol. v. For another English translation (in prose) of the Ramayana see under
Dutt, Manmatha Nath.

Griffith, R. T. H. The Hymns of the Rigveda translated

with a Popular Commentary. 4 vols. Benares. 1889-1892.

[II, 250, 250W1, 255711.]
Grimm, J. L. C. Deutsche Rechtsalterthumer. Gdttingen.

1828. (2nd edit. 1854.) [IV, 255.]
Grimm, J. L. C. Reinhart Fuchs. Berlin. 1834. [V, 79n3,

238.]
Grimm, J. L. C. Deutsche Mythologie. Gdttingen. 1835.

The Anhang has a separate pagination. [II, 105n.]

Other editions followed in 1844. and 1854 (2 vols.), but the best is the
4th edition, by E. H. Meyer, 3 vols., Berlin, 1875-1878. For the English
translation see below.

Grimm, J. L. C. Kleiner e Schriften. 8 vols. ^Berlin. 1864-
1890. [VIII, 117w2.]

Grimm, J. L. C. Teutonic Mythology by Jacob Grimm. Trans-
lated from the Fourth Edition, with Notes and Appendix,
by James Steven Stally brass. 4 vols. Ldn. 1880-1888.
[II, 43W1, 57m1, 96W1 ; III, 311rc4 ; IV, 23n2, 64rcx ; V,
179W1 ; VI, In1, 277.]

Vols, i-iii (1880, 1883, 1883) are numbered consecutively right through, and
have an index in vol. iii. Vol. iv is a Supplement and Appendix, and has a
separate index.

Grimm, J. L. C. and W. Irische Elfenmarchen, aus dem
Englischen. Leipzig. 1826. [I, 77nx ; II, 104n ; III, 30ft1,
188n; V, Sn1; VI, 36m1, 194W1, 281 ; VII, 120w2.]

The above work is a translation of the first part of Croker's Fairy Legends
and Traditions of the South of Ireland (q.v.). Wilhelm Grimm added a treatise
on elves and further literary information. A second edition was published in
Munchen, 1906.

Grimm, J. L. C. and W. Kinder- und Hausmdrchen. 3 vols.
Gottingen. 1856. [I, 19rc2, 26, 27 ; II, 60w2, 196m1, 223n* ;
III, 28711, 75, 104n2, 187w3, 188n, 189n\ 226w2, 227w, 231W1,
237, 272W1 ; IV, 129n, 145wx ; V, 62w2, 66, 79n3, lOOn1,
l5Sn\ 275, 281 ; VI, 18711, 47/11, 56n\ 61, 98nS 122w2 ;
VIII, 83W1, 107rc, 109n2, 216.]

The above is the standard edition of Grimm. Its first two volumes are the
7th edition, while the third is the 3rd edition. The 1st edition was in two vols.,
Berlin, 1812, 1815, while a third volume followed in 1822.

238 THE OCEAN OF STORY

Grohmann, J. V. Sagen aus Bohmen. Prag. 1863. [I, 97ft2 ;

II, 13ft4, 43ft1, 99ft, 104ft ; III, 133ft1 ; IV, 245ft1 ; V,
114ft1 ; VI, 26ft3, 36ft1 ; VII, 137ft3.]

Groome, F. H. Gypsy Folk-Tales. Ldn. 1899. [V, 275.]
Groome, F. H. " Two Gypsy Versions of the Master Thief."

Journal of the Gypsy Lore Society. Vol. iii. July 1891.

Pp. 142-151. [V, 275.]
Groot, J. J. M. De. See under De Groot, J. J. M.
Grose, F. Provincial Glossary, with a Collection of Local

Proverbs and Popular Superstitions. Ldn. 1811. [Ill,

150.]
Grossler, H. Sagen der Grafschaft Mansfeld und ihrer

nachsten Umgebung. Eisleben. 1880. [I, 77nl ; II, 99ft;

III, 227ft ; IV, 245ft1.]

He also published " Nachlese von Sagen und Gebrimchen der Grafschaft
Mansfeld und ihrer nachsten Umgebung," Mansfelder Blatter, i (1887) — xxi
(1908).

Grotius, Hugo (Huig van Groot). De jure belli ac pacis.
Translated by W. Whewell. 3 vols. Cambridge. 1853.
[II, 277-279.] See also under Whewell, W.

The 1st edition of the above appeared in Paris, 1625. For full details of his
works see Lehmann, Hugonis Grotii manes vindicati, Delft, 1727.

Growse, F. S. Mathurd: A District Memoir. 2nd edit.

Allahabad. 1880. [I, 231ft1 ; III, 142ft1 .]
Grubauer, A. Unter Kopfjdgern in Central Celebes Ethno-

logische Streifzilge in Siidost- und Central- Celebes. Leipzig.

1913. [VIII, 299ft1, 300.]
Grundtvig, S. H. Ddnische Volksmarchen. Nach bisher

ungedruckten Quellen erzdhlt von . . . Translated by

W. Leo. Leipzig. 1878. (From the 2-vol. Danish edition

of Copenhagen, 1876-1878.) [Ill, 205 ; VI, 291.]
Gualteruzzi, Carlo. Le ciento Novelle antike. Bologna.

1525. [IX, 149, 150.]
Gualteruzzi, Carlo. Le Cento Novelle Antiche secondo

Vedizione del mdxxv. Corrette ed Illustrate con Note.

Milano. 1825. [IX, 149, 150.] See also under Biagi, G.;

Borghini, V. ; Storer, E.

Only six copies of this edition appear to have been printed — all on azure-
coloured paper.

Gubernatis, A. de. Zoological Mythology, or the Legends
of Animals. 2 vols. Ldn. 1872. [I, 26, 76ft2, 84ft2, 129,
130, 144ft2 ; II, 57ft1, 127ft2 ; III, 92ft, 104ft2, 187ft3, 272ft1 ;

IV, 249ft; V, 43ft1, 100ft1, 101ft1, 102ft2, 109ft2, 130ft1, 157ft1 ;
VI, 277 ; VII, 21ft3.]

BIBLIOGRAPHY 239

Gubernatis, A. de. Drammi Indiana. II Re Nala. Trilogia

Drammatica. Florence. 1883. Pp. 1-160. [IV, 292.]
Guest, Lady Charlotte. The Mabinogion, from the Llyfr

Coch o Hergest and other Ancient Welsh Manuscripts ;

with an English Translation and Notes by ... S vols.

Ldn. 1838, 1840. [Ill, 205.]

Each volume has two title-pages. The first one gives 1849 as the date in
each volume. The second gives 1838 and 1840 as the dates of vols, i and ii
respectively, while there is no date given in the second title-page of vol. iii.

Guillem (Guylem) de Cervera. See under Thomas, A.
Gunasekara, A. Mendis, Mudaliyar. " Betel." Notes &

Queries. The Ceylon Antiquary and Literary Register.

Vol. i, pt. ii, Oct. 1915. Colombo. 1915-1916. Pp. 124,

125. [VIII, 318W1.]
Guppy, H. B. The Solomon Islands and their Natives. Ldn.

1887. [VIII, 315n1,2-3.]
Gurdon, P. R. T. The Khasis. With an Introduction by

Sir Charles Lyall, K. C.S.I. Published_ under orders of

the Assam Administration. 2nd edition illustrated. Ldn.

1914. [VIII, 285w3.]

The 1st edition had appeared in 1907.

Habicht, Max. Tausend und eine Nacht. Arabische Erzdh-
lungen, zum ersten Male aus einer Tunesischen Handschrift
ergdnzt und vollstdndig ubersetzt von . . ., F. H. Von Der
Hagen und Karl Schall. 15 vols. Breslau. 1825. [VII,
203n5.]

Haddon, A. C. Head-Hunters Black, White, and Brown.
Ldn. 1901. [VIII, 298nx.]

Haddon, A. C. " Magic and Religion." Reports of the Cam-
bridge Anthropological Expedition to Torres Straits. Vol. v,
Sociology, Magic, and Religion of the Western Islanders.
1904. Pp. 320-378. 6 vols. Cambridge. 1901-1908. [II,
198wx.]

Haddon, A. C. See also under Beaver, W. N. ; Hose, C, and
McDougall, W.

Hagen, F. H. v. d. Minnesinger. Deutsche Liederdichter des
zwblften, dreizehnten und vierzehnten Jahrhunderts, aus
alten bekannten Handschriften und fruheren Drucken ge-
sammelt und berichtigt, ... 4 Thle. Leipzig. 1838.
[II, 292n3.]

Hagen, F. H. v. d. Gesammtabenteuer altdeutsche Erzah-
lungen ... 3 vols. Stuttgart. 1850. [I, 169, 170, 171.]

The tale " Alten Weibes List von Konrad von Wiirzburg " occurs in vol. i,
pp. 189-205.

Duties of a Faithful HiiH
Soc. New Series. Vol. ii
lenient, pp. 193-198. [IV,
dward. See also under W
V. R. Greek Divination. 2
iples. Ldn. 1913. [Ill,
ider Dawkins, R. M.
N. R. "The Force of
Folk-Lore. Vol. xxi. 191

V. R. " Snake Stories." \
Pp. 262-271. [V, 245W1.]
7. R. See under Dawkins,
J.

J. 0. The Voiage and
e, Kt., . . . with an In

Glossary. Ldn. 1839. [I

BIBLIOGRAPHY 241

Hamilton, Francis [formerly Buchanan]. A Journey from
Madras, through the Countries of Mysore, Canara, and
Malabar. . . . 3 vols. Ldn. 1807. [1,252,252m1; 111,201.]

Hamilton, Francis [formerly Buchanan]. An Account of
the Kingdom of Nepal, and of the Territories annexed to
this Dominion by the house of Gorkha. Edinburgh. 1819.
[II, 280n2.]

Hammer [-Purgstall], J. von. " Sur le Langage des Fleurs."
Fundgruben des Orients bearbeitet durch eine Gesellschaft
von Liebhabern. A second title-page reads : Mines de
VOrient, exploitees par une Societe aVamateurs. Vol. i.
Vienna. 1809. Pp. 32-42. [I, 81w.]

The publication consisted of 6 vols., Vienna, 1809-1818.

[Hammer-Purgstall, J. von.] Rosenol Erstes [-Zwentes]
Flaschchen oder Sagen und Kunden des Morgenlandes aus
arabischen, persischen und tiirkischen Quellen gesammelt.
2 vols. Stuttgart und Tubingen. . . . 1813. [VII, 203w6 ;
VIII, 227rc3.]

The above work was issued anonymously and seems to have escaped the
attention of most scholars. Not a single German bibliography gives the correct
details of issue. The reference in Vol. VII, p. 203ra6, is to " Dschami-960." This
is not Jam!, the famous Persian mystic and poet, but refers to a work by
Muhammad 'Aufi, entitled Jami ul-Hikayat. Neither Rieu nor Ethe mentions
Hammer's work in cataloguing Aufi's MSS.

Hammer-Purgstall, J. von. Liter atur-Geschichte der Araber.

7 vols. Wien. 1850-1856. [Ill, 278.]
Hanson, Ola. The Kachins ; their Customs and Traditions.

Rangoon. 1913. [VIII, 285n5.]
Hardy, R. Spence. Eastern Monachism : An Account of

the Order of Mendicants founded by Gotama Budha. Ldn.

1850. [V, 153^.]
Hardy, R. Spence. A Manual of Buddhism in its Modern

Development; translated from Singhalese MSS. Ldn. 1853.

(2nd edit. 1880.) [I, 121n2.]
Hariri, Abu Muhammad al Kasim al-. See under

Chenery, T.
Harley, T. Moon Lore. Ldn. 1885. [V, 101n2 ; VI, lOOw1.]
Harris, Joseph. The Fables of Pilpay, A Famous Indian

Phylosopker : . . . Ldn. 1699. [V, 240.]

[The name of Harris is not on the title-page, but appears at the end of the
Dedication.]

Harris, J. Rendel. " The Origin of the Cult of Aphrodite."
Bulletin of the John Rylands Library. Vol. iii. Manchester.
1916-1917. Pp. 354-381. [Ill, 153.]

VOL. IX. Q

242 THE OCEAN OF STORY

Harris, J. Rendel. The Ascent of Olympus. [Four lectures

on Greek Mythology.] Manchester. 1917. [Ill, 153.]
Harris, J. Rendel. See also under Conybeare, F. C.
Harrison, J. E. Myths of the Odyssey in Art and Literature.

Ldn. 1882. [VI, 282w6.]
Harrison, J. E. Mythology and Monuments of Ancient

Athens . . . with . . . commentary by . . . Ldn. 1890.

[VI, 282n6, 283, 283m1.]
Harrison, J. E. Prolegomena to the Study of Greek Religion.

2nd edit. Cambridge. 1908. (1st edit. 1903 ; 3rd edit.

1922.) [I, 15w; VI, 282n6.]
Harrison, J. E. " Odysseus and the Sirens — Dionysiac

Boat-races — A Cylix by Nikostenes." Journal of Hellenic

Studies. Vol. vi. Ldn. 1885. Pp. 19-29. [VI, 282n6.]
Harsdorffer, G. P. Der grosse Schauplatz Lust- und

Lehrreicher Geschichte. Frankfurt. 1660. [II, 296.]

The earliest edition at the Brit. Mus. is 1653. I have not seen the Frankfurt
1660 edition, but Heyse, Biich. d. d. Nat-Lit., quotes a 1664 Frankfurt edition
as the fifth reprint.

Hartland, E. S. The Science of Fairy Tales. An Inquiry

into Fairy Mythology. Ldn. 1891. [I, 168 ; V, Sn1 ; VI,

135 ; VIII, 107n, 233n2, 233n3.]

This forms No. xi of the Contemporary Science Series, edited by Havelock
Ellis, while a 2nd edition, nothing to do with the above series, was issued
in 1925, with an Introduction by A. A. Milne.

Hartland, E. S. The Legend of Perseus. A Study of Tradi-
tion in Story Custom and Belief. 3 vols. Ldn. 1894, 1895,
1896. The volumes form Nos. 2, 3 and 5 of the Grimm
Library. Their separate sub-titles are : Vol. i, The
Supernatural Birth. Vol. ii, The Life-Token. Vol. iii,
Andromeda. Medusa. [I, 130 ; II, 70n\ 96nx, 136W1,
153ri; III, 204, 227n, 263n2 ; VI, 138; VII, 227n\ 240,
240nx ; IX, 153.]

Hartland, E. S. Ritual and Belief. Studies in the History of
Religion. Ldn. 1914. [V, 177.]

Hartland, E. S. " The Forbidden Chamber." Folk-Lore
Journal. Vol. iii. 1885. Pp. 193-242. [II, 223ft1.]

Hartland, E. S. " The Voice of the Stone of Destiny :
An Enquiry into the Choice of Kings by Augury." Folk-
Lore. Vol. xiv. 1903. Pp. 28-60. [V, 177.]

Hartland, E. S. " Life-Token." Hastings' Ency. Rel. Eth.
Vol. viii. 1915. Pp. 44-47. [I, 130.]

Hartland, E. S. " Phallism." Hastings' Ency. Rel. Eth.
Vol. ix. 1917. Pp. 815-831. [I, 15n ; II, 119, 307n2.]

BIBLIOGRAPHY 243

Harvey, A. J. Turkish Harems and Circassian Homes.

Ldn. 1871. [II, 163w.]
Hassan, Syed Siraj Ul. The Castes and Tribes of H.E.H.

The Nizam's Dominions. Vol. i [all published as yet].

Bombay. 1920. [I, 244, 244nS 245w2 ; VIII, 274, 275.]
Hastie, W. See under Bose, S. C.
Hastings, James. A Dictionary of the Bible dealing with its

Language, Literature and Contents. ... 4 vols, with a fifth

of indexes, maps, etc. Edinburgh. 1900-1904. [VII, 106.]
Hastings, James. Encyclopaedia of Religion and Ethics.

12 vols. Edinburgh. 1908-1921. Index vol. 1926.
All articles are to be found under the author's name.

Haughton, H. L. Sport & Folk-Lore in the Himalaya. . . .

Ldn. 1913. [Ill, 182 ; V, 65.]
Havers, G. See under Grey, Edward.
Hawthorne, Nathaniel. Mosses from an Old Manse.

Paterson's Shilling Library. New England Novels.

Edinburgh. 1883. [II, 297, 297W1.]
Headlam, W. Herodas. The Mimes and Fragments. With

Notes by . . . Edited by A. D. Knox. Cambridge. 1922.

[IX, 155.]
Heckenbach, J. De nuditate sacra sacrisque vinculis.

Gieszen. 1911. Forming vol. ix, pt. iii, of Religions-

geschichtliche Versuche und Vorarbeiten. [IX, 147.]
Heliodorus. Mthiopica. [II, 62wx, 106/14 ; III, 112/11 ;

IV, 239n2 ; VI, 51n\ 204n3 ; VII, I89n2.] See also under

Underdowne, T.
Hemachandra. See under Hertel, J., and Jacobi, H.
Henderson, William. Notes on the Folk-Lore of the Northern

Counties of England and the Borders. . . . With an

Appendix on Household Stories by S. Baring-Gould^

M.A. . . . Ldn. 1866. [I, 190; II, 2n\ 98n\ 104w ;

III, 150, 195W1 ; IV, 93n2 ; IX, 160.] A revised edition

was issued by the Folk-Lore Society in 1879, " with

many additional notes by the Author." [VI, 150w.]
Henry, Robert. The History of Great Britain. ... 6

vols. Ldn. 1771-1793. [VI, 24n.] See further under

Andrews, J. P.
Henry, R. M. " On Plants of the Odyssey." The Classical

Review. Vol. xx. 1906. Pp. 434-436. [VIII, 56n2.]

The article is divided into two parts, the first dealing with (uokv, and the
1 second with Aom-os.

Herbers or Herbert. See under Brunet, J. C, and

MONTAIGLON, A. DE.

244 THE OCEAN OF STORY

Herklots, G. A. Jaffur Shurreef [Ja'far Sharif]. Qanoon-e-
Islam : Customs of the Mussulmans of India. Compiled
under the direction of, and translated by . . . Madras.
1895. [I, 213; VI, 150//; VII, 249, 249ft1.]

A new edition, quoted in the two latter references, appeared in 1921, edited
by W. Crooke.

Hermas, Shepherd of. Similitudes. [I, 144ft1.]

The chief modern edition is that of Gebhardt and Harnack, in fasc. in of
their Patrum Apostolicorum Opera, Leipzig, 1877. For an English translation
see that by C. Taylor. !2 vols.. 1903-1906.

Hero of Alexandria. Catoptrica, Pneumatica, Automato-
poietica. [Ill, 57.]

Herodotus. History. [V, 245ft1, 252.] See also under
Godley, A. D., and Rawlinson, G.

Herold, A. F. Nala et Damayanti. " Ex Oriente Lux "
Series. Vol. viii. Paris. 1923.' [IX, 155.]

Herolt, John. Sermones discipuli de tempore d'sdetis unaciL
promptuario exemplar. . . . Argentine. 1490. (Without
pagination — a perfect copy should have 428 leaves.) [I,
169.]

Herrara, Antonio de. The General History of the vast
Continent and Islands of America commonly calVd the
West Indies from the first Discovery thereof. . . . Trans-
lated by John Stevens. 6 vols. Ldn. 1725-1726. [II,
SSn1.]

Herrtage, S. J. H. The Early English Versions of the Gesta
Romanorum. Formerly edited by Sir Frederic Madden for
the Roxburghe Club, and now re-edited . . . by . . . The
Early English Text Society. Extra Series. No. xxxiii.
Ldn* 1879. [I, 44 ; V, 87ft1* 104ft1, 138ft1 ; VI, 98ft1, 154ft3,
262ft1 ; VII, 3ft2, 81ft1.]

Hertel, J. TJber das Tantrdkhydyika, die kasmirische
Rezension des Pahcatantra. Leipzig and Berlin. 1904.
[V, 209ft1.]

Hertel, J. Das siiddliche Pahcatantra. Sanskrittext der
Rezension ft mit den Lesarten der besten IIss. der Rezension
a. Herausgegeben von . . . Leipzig. 1906. Forming Bd.
xxiv, No. 5, of Abhandlungen d. philol.-historischen Klasse
d. kgl.-siichsischen Gesell. d. Wissenschaften. [V, 209ft2,
209W3.]

Hertel, J. Ausgeivdhlte Erzdhlungen aus Hemacandras
Parisistaparvan. Deutsch mit Einleitung und Anmerkungen
von . . . Leipzig. 1908. Bibliothek morgenlandischer
Erzahler. Vol. i. [II, 285ft1 ; III, 180, 207ft2.]

BIBLIOGRAPHY 245

Hertel, J. The Panchatantra. A collection of ancient Hindu
tales in the Recension, called Panchakhyanaka, and dated
a.d. 1199, of the Jaina monk, Purnabhadra. Critically
edited in the original Sanskrit by ... 3 vols. Cambridge,
Mass. 1908, 1912. The title-page of vol. ii is as follows :
The Panchatantra-Text of Purnabhadra. Critical Intro-
duction and List of Variants by . . . That of vol. iii is :
The Panchatantra-Text of Purnabhadra and its Relation
to Texts of Allied Recensions as shown in Parallel Specimens
by . . . [V, 216ft1 , 217ft1.]

The above volumes form vols, xi-xiii of the Harvard Oriental Series.

Hertel, J. Tantrdkhydyika. Die dlteste Fassung des
Pancatantra. Aus dem Sanskrit ubersetzt mit Einleitung
und Anmerkungen von ... 2 vols. Berlin, Leipzig
[printed]. 1909. [V. 42ft1, 43ft2, 46ft1, 48ft1, 49m1, 52ft2, 53m1,
55ft2, 55n\ 56ft1, 59ft2, 61ft3, 64, 65, 73ft1, 75ft1, 76ft3, 77ft1,
98ft1, 99n3, lOOw1, 101n\ 102ft2, 104m1, 106ft1, 107ft1-2, 108ft2,
109ft2, 112ft1, 127ns 130ft1, 138ft1, 209m1' 3, 211.]

Hertel, J. Das Pancatantra, seine Geschichte und seine
Verbreitung. . . . Leipzig and Berlin. 1914. [V, 55 n2, 64,
175, 207nx, 208, 210, 216, 219, 232-241.]

Hertel, J. Kathdratndkara. Das Mdrchenmeer. Eine
Sammlung indischer Erzdhlungen von Hemavijaya. Deutsch
von . . . Meisterwerke Orientalischer Literaturen. Bd.
iv, v. Miinchen. 1920. [VII, 200n2.]

Hertel, J. Indische Mdrchen. Die Marchen der Welt-
literatur. Jena. 1921. [VI, 254n4.]

Hertel, J. Die zehn Printzen. Ein indischer Roman von
Dandin. Vollstdndig verdeutscht von ... 3 vols. Leipzig.
1922. [V, 142n2 ; VI, 251.]

Hertel, J. Kaufmann Tschampaka von Dschinakirti Pdia
und Gopdla von Dschinakirti Ratnatschuda von Dschndna-
, sdgara. Indische Marchenromane I. Indische Erzahler.
Bd. vii. Leipzig. 1922. [II, 121.]

Hertel, J. Pantschdkhydna-Wdrtlika. Eine Sammlung
volkstumlicher Marchen und Schwdnke. Vollstdndig
verdeutsche von . . . Leipzig. 1923. Forming Bd. vi of
the " Indische Erzahler " Series. [IX, 141.]

Hertel, J. " Die Erzahlung von Kaufmann Campaka."
Zeitschrift der Deutschen Morgenlandischen Gesellschaft.
Vol. lxv. Leipzig. 1911. Pp. 425-470. [Ill, 280; V,
186^.]

Hertel, J. " Ein altindisches Narrenbuch." Berichte uber
die Verhandlungen d. kgl. sdchsischen Gesell. d. Wissen-

246 THE OCEAN OF STORY

schaften, philol.-hist. Klasse. Vol. lxiv. Leipzig. 1912.

Pp. 1-67. [V, 213, 213W1.]
Hertel, J. " t)ber die Suvabahuttarikatha." Festschrift

Ernst Windisch zum siebzigsten Geburtstag am 4. Sept.

1914 dargebracht von Freunden und Schulern. Leipzig.

1914. Pp. 138-152. [II, 286, 286nx ; III, 62, 180.]
Hertz, W. Deutsche Sage im Elsass. Stuttgart. 1872.

[VIII, 107n.]
Hertz, W. Spielmanns-Buch. Novellen in Versen aus dem

zwolften und dreizehnten Jahrhundert. Zweite verbesserte

und vermehrte Auflage. Stuttgart. 1900. (The 1st edit.

was issued in 1886.) [VIII, 117w2.]
Hertz, W. " Die Sage vom Giftmadchen." Aus den Abhand-

lungen der k. bayer. Akademie der Wiss., I, CI. ocx. Bd. i,

Abth. Munich. 1893. Pp. 91-166. (The separate off-
prints are also numbered pp. 1-78.) [II, 286, 286n2, 292,

292ft1, 296, 298, 300.]
Hertz, W. See also under Leyen, F. von der.
Hervieux, L. Les Fabulistes Latins Depuis le siecle oV Auguste

jusqu'a a la fin de Moyen age. 5 vols. Paris. 1884-1899.

The sub-title of vol. v (referred to in the Ocean) is :

Jean de Capone et ses derives. [V, 237.]
Hesiod. Thegony. [IV, 212ft1.]
Hewat, M. L. Bantu Folk-Lore. Cape Town. 1905. [Ill,

313, 313ft2.]

The reference in the Ocean is to the review of the work by B. C. A. Windle
in Folk-Lore, vol. xvii, 1906, pp. 248-251.

Hickson, S. J. A Naturalist in North Celebes. A Narrative of
Travels in Minahassa, the Sangir and Talaut Islands, with
notices of the Fauna, Flora and Ethnology of the Districts
visited. Ldn. 1889. [VIII, 231ft10, 296n2, 298n2.]

Hierocles. See under Eberhard, A.

Hildebrand, Wolfgang. Magia Naturalis, das ist, Kunst
und Wunderbuch, darinnen begriffen Wunderbare Secreta,
Geheimnusse und kunststucke, wie man nemlich mit dem
gantzen Menschlichen Corper, fast unerhorte wunderbarliche
Sachen, verrichten . . . kan . . . zusammen getragen . . .
durch . . . Leipzig. 1610. (2nd edit., 4 pts., Erfurt,
1611-1612 ; another similar edit., Jena, 1625.) [II, 296,
300.]

Hildegard, St. See under St Hildegard of Bingen, and

MlGNE, J. P.

Hilka, A. Historia Septem Sapientum. Eine bisher unbe-
kannte lateinische tJbersetzung einer orientalischen Fas sung

BIBLIOGRAPHY 247

der Sieben weisen Meister (Mischle Sendabar), heraus-
gegeben und erklart von . . . [Sammlung mittellateinischer
Texte. No. 4.] Heidelberg. 1912. [V, 261, 261w2.]

Hillebrandt, A. Rituallitteratur \ Vedische Opfer und
Zauber. Grundriss der Indo-Arischen Philologie und
Altertumskunde. Vol. iii. Pt. ii. Pp. 149-152. Strassburg.
1897. [IV, 16.]

Hillebrandt, A. " Circumambulatio." Mitteilungen der
schlesischen Gesell. f. Volkskunde. Vols, xiii-xiv. Breslau.
1911. Pp. 3-8. [IX, 144.]

Hirananda Shastri. See under Shastri, Hirananda.

Hirt, H. Die Indogermanen. Ihre Verbreitung, ihre Urheimai
und ihre Kultur. 2 vols, (continuous pagination). Strass-
burg. 1905, 1907. [Ill, 319.]

Hirth, F. China and the Roman Orient : Researches into
their Ancient and Mediaeval Relations as represented in Old
Chinese Records. Leipzig and Munich. [Shanghai printed.]
1885. [I, 104.]

Hirth, F., and Rockiiill, W. W. Chau Ju-Kua : His work
on the Chinese and Arab Trade in the twelfth and thirteenth
Centuries, entitled Chu-fan-chi. Translated from the
Chinese and Annotated by . . . and W. W. Rockhill.
Imperial Academv of Sciences. St Petersburg. 1911.
[I, 241nx ; VIII, 256m1, 303n2 ; IX, 162.]

HlUEN TSIANG (HSUAN TsANG, HlOUEN THSANG, YtJAN-

Tsang, or Yuan-Chwang). See under Beal, Samuel.
Hobb[e]s, Thomas. Humane Nature : Or, The fundamental
Elements of Policie. Being a Discoverie of the Faculties,
Acts, and Passions of the Soul of Man, from their original
causes; . . . By Tho. Hobbs [sic] of Malm[e]bsury. Ldn.

1650. [VII, 253W1.]

Hobbes, Thomas. Leviathan, or, The Matter, Form, and
Power of a Common-Wealth Ecclesiastical and Civil. Ldn.

1651. [VII, 253n\]

The above edition was reprinted with an Essay by W. G. Pogson Smith,
Oxford, 1909.

Hocart, A. M. " Flying through the Air." The Indian

Antiquary. Bombay. Vol. Iii. 1923. Pp. 80-82. [II, 64nx.]
Hocart, A. M. " Phallic Offerings to Hathor." Letter in

Man, No. 128. Vol. xxvi. No. 10. Oct. 1926. P. 192.

(Also in Man, No. 92, p. 140.) [IX, 154.]
Hock, Stefan. Die Vampyrsagen und ihre Verwertung in der

deutschen Litteratur. Forschungen zur neuren Litteratur-

geschichte, xvii. Berlin. 1900. [VI, 140.]

248 THE OCEAN OF STORY

Hodson, T. C. The Meiiheis. With an Introduction by Sir
Charles Lyall, K. C.S.I. . . . Published under orders of
the Governments of Eastern Bengal and Assam. Ldn.

1908. [II, 118 ; VIII, 286ft2.]

Hodson, T. C. The Primitive Culture of India. Lectures

delivered in 1922 at the School of Oriental Studies (Univ.

of London). James G. Forlong Fund. Vol. i. Roy. As. Soc.

Ldn. 1922. [II, 97ft.]
Hoey, W. See under Oldenberg, H.
Hoffmann, A. G. " Harem." Allgemeine Encyklopadie der

Wissenschaften und KiXnste. Pt. 2. Leipzig. 1828. Pp. 396-

408. [II, 163ft.]
Hogarth, D. G. " Carchemish and its Neighbourhood."

Annals of Archaeology and Anthropology. . . . Vol. ii.

1909. Pp. 165-184. University of Liverpool. [I, 272ra4.]
Holland, W. L. Das Buch der Beispiele der alten Weisen

nach Handschriften und Drucken herausgegeben von . . .
Stuttgart. 1860. [V, 238.]

Holmes, E. M. " Opium." Ency. Brit. 11th edit. Vol. xx.
Pp. 130-137. [II, 304ft1.]

Holmes, J. H. In Primitive New Guinea. . . . With many
illustrations and a map. Ldn. 1924. [VIII, 314ft1.]

Holmstrom, H. Studier over svanjungfrumotivet i Volundark-
vida och annorstades. Malmo. 1919. [VIII, 217ft2, 218,
218ns 223ft3, 226, 227ft1.]

The above work, limited to 440 copies, was a treatise written for the degree
of Doctor of Philosophy at Lund University. It contains a second (loose) title-
page to this effect, with the printer's name . . . Lund, 1919-

Homer. Iliad. [II, 218ft4 ; III, 229ft1, 277 ; IV, 112m1 ;
IX, 9ft1, 44ft1.] Odyssey. [II, 106ft4, 217ft2, 21Sns ; III,
138ft1, 208ft1, 225ft2, 310, 310ft2 ; IV, 58ft2, 120ft1, 151ft2 ;
VIII, 56ft2, 92ft1 ; IX, 9ft1.]

Homes, Nathaniel. Dcemonologie, or the Character of the
Crying Evils of the Present Times. . . . The second title-
page reads : Daemonologie and Theologie. The First,
The Malady, . . . The Second, The Remedy. . . . Ldn.
1650. [V, 201ft.]

Both J. Brand and his editors wrongly refer to the above as the work of
" N. Home."

Hooker, J. D. The Flora of British India. . . . Assisted by
Various Botanists. 7 vols. Ldn. 1875-1897. [VIII, 7ft2, 8ft1.]

Hooper, D. " Caliature Wood." Nature, A Weekly Illus-
trated Journal of Science. Vol. lxxxvi. 4th May 1911.
Pp. 311, 312. [VII, 107.]

BIBLIOGRAPHY 249

Hopkins, E. Washburn. " The Sniff-kiss in Ancient India."

Journ. Amer. Orient. Soc. Vol. xxviii. 1st Half. New

Haven, Conn. 1907. Pp. 120-134. [IX, 162.]
Hopkins, E. Washburn. " Bhairava." Hastings' Ency.

Rel. Eth. Vol. ii. 1909. Pp. 538, 539. [IV, 225n2.]
Hopkins, E. W. " Festivals and Fasts (Hindu)." Hastings'

Ency. Rel. Eth. Vol. v. 1912. Pp. 867-871. [VIII, 19.]
Hopkins, E. W. " Family Life and Social Customs as they

appear in the Sutras." The Cambridge History of India.

Vol. i. 1922. Ch. x. Pp. 227-250. [II, 241.]
Horace. Odes. [II, 120 ; IV, 93w2 ; VIII, 40nx.] Satires.

[VIII, 99w2.] See further under Wickham, E. C.
Hose, C. Natural Man. A Record from Borneo. With a

Preface by Prof. G. Elliot Smith. Ldn. 1926. [VIII,

296nx.]
Hose, C, and McDougall, W. The Pagan Tribes of Borneo.

A Description of their Physical, Moral and Intellectual

Condition, with some Discussion of their Ethnic Relations.

With an Appendix on the Physical Characters of the

Races of Borneo by A. C. Haddon. ... 2 vols. Ldn.

1912. [VIII, 296n1.]
Houtum-Schindler, A. "Notes on Marco Polo's Itinerary

in Southern Persia." Journ. Roy. As. Soc. New Series.

Vol. xiii. 1881. Pp. 490-497. [I, 214.]
Hovorka, O. von, and Kronfeld, A. Vergleichende Volks-

medizin. Eine Darstellung volksmedizin. Sitten und

Gebrauche ... 2 vols. Stuttgart. 1908, 1909. [VI, 140.]
Howey, M. O. The Horse in Magic and Myth. Ldn. 1923.

[IX, 146.]
Howitt, A. W. The Native Tribes of South-East Australia.

Ldn. 1904. [Ill, 151.]
Huber, E. " Etudes de Litterature Bouddhique." Bull.

de VEcole Frangaise d' extreme Orient. Vol. iv. 1904.

Pp. 698-726. [IX, 160.]
Hughes, T. P. ^arim or Hareem." A Dictionary of Islam,

being a Cyclopaedia of the Doctrines, Rites, . . . Ldn.

1885. Pp. 163-167. [II, 163w.]
Hulme, W. H. Peter Alphonse's Disciplina Clericalis (English

Translation) from the Fifteenth Century Manuscript

F. 172. Western Reserve University Bulletin. Vol. xxii.
1 May 1919. Cleveland, Ohio. [V, 87nx ; VI, 272n3.]
HfJLSEN, C. "Engyon." 'Pa.uly-Wissow&'s Real-Encyclopddie.

Vol. v. Pt. ii. Col. 2568. [IX, 154.]

250 THE OCEAN OF STORY

Hultzsch, E. South-Indian Inscriptions, Tamil and Sans-
krit. . . . Edited and Translated by . . . 3 vols. Madras.
1890-1916. Archaeological Survey of India. [I, 155nx,
247-w1.]

Vol. i is New Scries, vol. iii. Subsequently the New Imperial Series took
its place and vol. ii became N. Imp. Ser., vol. x, and vol. iii, N. Imp. Ser.,
vol. xxix. The different parts have dates up to 191G.

Hultzsch, E. " Tirumalai Rock Inscriptions of Rajendra-
Chola I." Epigraphia Indica and Record of the Arch.
Sure. Jnd. Vol. ix. Calcutta. 1907-1908. Pp. 229-233.
[I,155w\]

Hunt, Margaret. Grimm's Household Tales. With the
Author's Notes. Translated from the German and Edited
by . . . With an Introduction bij Andrew Lang, M.A.
Bonn's Standard Library. 2 vols. Ldn. 1884. [I, 98n ;

III, 76, 104rc2, 105/i; V, 66.]

See also under Grimm, J. L. C. and W., Kinder- unci Hausmdrchen.

Hunt, Robert. Popular Romances of the West of England ;
or the Drolls, Traditions, and Superstitions of old Cornwall.
Ldn. 1865. (Other editions 1871 and 1881.) [I, 191 ;

IV, 93n2.]

Hunter, W. W. Orissa ; or, the Vicissitudes of an Indian
Province under Native and British Rule. 2 vols. Ldn.
1872. [I, 242W1.]

Hunter, W. W. A Statistical Account of Assam. 2 vols.
Ldn. 1879. [VIII, 284n5.]

The districts dealt with in the vols, are as follows : 1. Kamrup, Darrang,
Nowgong, Sibsagar and Lakhimpur ; 2. Goalpara (inc. Eastern Dwars), the
Garo Hills, the Naga Hills, the Khasi and Jaintia Hills, Sylhet and Cachar.

Hurgronje, C. Snouck. Mekka. I. Die Stadt und ihre

Herren ; II. Aus dem heutigen Leben. [With Atlas.]

Haag. 1888-1889. [Ill, 329.]
Hurgronje, C. Snouck. The Achehnesc. Translated by the

late A. W. S. O'Sullivan, . . . with an Index by R. J.

Wilkinson. . . . Leyden and London. 1906. [VIII, 293w2,

294nx, 294nV]
Hutt, A. G. "Chinese Zoological Myths," note in section

headed, " Notes and Queries." The Folk-Lore Journal.

Vol. vii. Jan.-Dec. Ldn. 1889. Pp. 318, 319. [VIII,

231n3.]
Hutton, J. H. The Angami Nagas, with some Notes on

Neighbouring Tribes. With Maps and Illustrations.

Published bv direction of the Assam Government. Ldn.

1921. [VIII* 284/2-.]

BIBLIOGRAPHY 251

Hutton, J. H. The Sema Nagas. With Maps, and

Illustrations and a Foreword by Henry Balfour, M.A

Published bv direction of the Assam Government. Ldn.
1921. [VIII, 284w].]

Hutton, J. H. " Folk-Tales of the Angami Nagas of
Assam, II." Folk-Lore. Vol. xxvi. No. 1. 1915. Pp. 82-88.
(Continued from vol. xxv, p. 498.) [Ill, 105n.]

Hutton, J. H. See also under Mills, J. P., Ao Nagas and
Lhota Nagas; and Smith, W.C.

Hyginus. Fabulce. See Schmidt's edition, 1872. [I, 190;
VI, 282, 282w4; VII, 227n2.]

Hylten-Cavallius, G. O., and Stephens, G. Svenska Folk-
Sagor och Afventyr. Efter muntlig ofverlemning Samlade
och Utgifna af . . . 2 vols. Stockholm. 1844-1849 (date
on verso of title-page and end of Preface). [VI, 291, 291n2.]
See also under Stephens, G., and Cavallius, H.

A selection of the above work appeared as follows : —

Svenska Folksagor . . . med handtecknkigar af Egron
Lundgren. Stockholm. 1875.

It contains only thirteen stories and has no notes.

Ibbetson, D. See under Rose, H. A.

Ibn al-Baytar (Ebn Baithar). See under Sontheimer,

J. VON.

Ibn Batuta (Muhammad ibn 'Abd Allah). Voyages d'Ibn
Batoutah, Texte Arabe, accompagne d*une Traduction par
C. Defremery et le Dr B. R. Sanguinetti. Collection
d'ouvrages Orientaux publiee par la Societe Asiatique.
4 vols. Paris. 1853-1858. Index vol. 1859. [IX, 141.]

Ibn Qutaiba. Mukhtalif al-hadith. Ed. Cairo. 1326. [VI,
63, 66.]

Iken, C. J. L. Touti Nameh. Fine Sammlung persischer
Mdhrchen von Nechschebi. Deutsche Uebersetzung von . . .
Mit einem Anhange von demselben, und von J. G. L.
Kosegarten. Stuttgardt. 1822. [VI, 272nx, 275n3, 275n5,
276n3 ; VII, 222w4, 241w3.]

Catalogued in the Brit. Mus. under Muhammed Khudavand Kadirl.

Ilg, B. Maltesische Marchen und Schwdnke. Aus dem
Volksmunde gesammelt von ... 2 vols. Leipzig. 1906.
[VIII, 107w.]

The work appears also under the title : Beitrage zur Folks ku fide. Im Auftrag
( d. Vereins f Sachsische Volkskunde hrsg. von Prof. Dr E. Mogk, Heft 2 and 3.

Imbriani, V. La Novellaia Milanese: esempi e panzane
lombarde raccolte nel Milanese. Bologna. 1872. [Ill, 76.]

252 THE OCEAN OF STORY

Im Thurn, E. "Piper methysticum in Betel-Chewing."

Man. Vol. xxii. No. 4. April 1922. P. 57. [VIII, 311,

311n2.]
'Inayatu-'llah. Bahdr-i-Ddnish. [I, 25, 43, 162nx.] See

further under Scott, Jonathan.
Irvine, William. Storia Do Mogor or Mogul India, 1653-

1708. By Niccolao Manned, Venetian. Translated with

Introduction and Notes by ... ^ vols. Ldn. 1907, 1908.

Indian Texts Series. [I, 238w2 ; VIII, 268n2.]
Irvine, William. See also under Blochmann, H.
Isidore of Seville (Isidorus Hispalensis). Originum sive

Etymologiarum libri xx. [V, 201n.]

The above was the last of Isidore's works, and was written between 622 and
633. It was corrected by his friend Braulion.

Issaverdens, J. Uncanonicdl Writings of the Old Testament

found in the Armenian MSS. of the Library of St Lazarus.

Venice. 1901. [VI, 74w.]
I-Tsing. See under Beal, Samuel.
Ivens, W. G. Melanesians of the South-east Solomon Islands.

Ldn. 1927. [IX, 167.]
Iyengar, K. Rangaswami. The Kama-Sutra (or the Science

of Love) of Sri Vdtsyayana. Punjab Sanskrit Book Depot.

Lahore. 1921. [I, 234n2 ; V, 193.]
'Izzat Ullah, Shaykh. Gul-i-Bakdwall or Rose of Bakdwall.

[I, 43; VI, 60 ; VII, 224, 224nx.]

The above work is included in Clouston's A Group of Eastern Romances . . .
(q.v.)

Jacobi, H. Hemachandra 's Sthavirdvalic(h)arita or Parisista-
parvan, being an Appendix of the Trishasti-sdldka-
purushac(h)arita. Edited by . . . Bibliotheca Indica Series
of the Asiatic Society of Bengal. Calcutta. 1883. [I, 39/11,
121n2 ; II, 283n2.]

Jacobi, H. Ausgewahlte Erzahlungen in Mdharashtri.
Leipzig. 1886. [I, 224, 226 ; VII, 217, 219.]

Jacobi, H. " Das Kalakacarya-Kathanakam." Zeitschrift
der Deutschen Morgenlandischen Gesellschaft. Vol. xxxiv.
Leipzig. 1880. Pp. 247-318. [VI, 230^.]

Jacobi, H. " On Sulasa." Indian Antiquary. Vol. ix. 1880.
P. 28. [IV, 69^*.]

Jacobi, H. " Agastya (or Agasti)." Hastings' Ency. Bel. Eth.
Vol. i. 1908. Pp. 180, 181. [VI, 44n.]

Jacobi, H. " Ages of the World (Indian)." Hastings' Ency.
Bel. Eth. Vol. i. 1908. Pp. 200-202. [IV, 240W1.]

BIBLIOGRAPHY 253

Jacobi, H. " Chakravartin." Hastings' Ency. Rel. Eth.

Vol. iii. 1910. Pp. 336, 337. [VIII, 72n.]
Jacobi, H. " Cosmogony and Cosmology (Indian)."

Hastings' Ency. Rel. Eth. Vol. iv. 1911. Pp. 155-161.

[I, 10n3 ; IV, 21 n1.]
Jacobi, H. " Cow (Hindu)." Hastings' Ency. Rel. Eth.

Vol. iv. 1911. Pp. 224-226. [II, 240, 241.]
Jacobi, H. " Daitya." Hastings' Ency. Rel. Eth. Vol. iv.

1911. Pp. 390-392. [I, 200.]
Jacobi, H. See also under Meyer, J. J.
Jacobs, J. The Earliest English Version of the Fables of

Bidpa/, " The M or all Philosophic of Doni " by Sir Thomas

North, . . . Now again edited and induced by . . . Ldn.

1888. [V, 220, 235, 241.]
Jacobs, J. The Fables of Aesop as first printed by William

Caxton in 1484 with those of Avian, Alfonso and Poggio

now again edited and induced by ... 2 vols. Ldn. 1889.

[I, 101 n1, 171.]

The sub-title to vol. i is " History of the yEsopic Fable," and that to vol. ii,
" Text and Glossary." They form vols, iv and v of the Bibliotheque de Carabas
Series.

Jacobs, J. Painter's Palace of Pleasure. Edited ... 3 vols.

Ldn. 1890. [V, 267.]
Jacobs, Joseph. Indian Fairy Tales Selected and Edited

by . . . Illustrated by John D. Batten. Ldn. 1892.

[I, 46n2, lOln1, 132.]
The above work consists of stories from the Jatakas, the Kathd-sarit-sagara,

the Panchatantra, and from the collections of Frere, Steel, Temple, Stokes,

Day, Knowles, etc. Jacobs should be pitied, rather than blamed, for his idiotic

remarks about Somadeva on p. 230.

Jade, Heinrich. Aus dem Morgenlande, Their-N ovellen

nach Bidpai. Leipzig. 1859. [V, 241.]
Ja'far Sharif. See under Herklots, G. A.
Jaganatha, Pandita. The Story of Nala and Damayanti.

An Indian Legend, Preserved in the Archives of Hindoostan ;

Translated from the Sanskrit into English Prose, to which

is added Explanatory Notes by ... St Louis, Mo. [1881.]

[IV, 292.]
Jagor, F. " Berichte iiber verschiedene Volkerstamme in

Vorderindien." Zeitschrift fur Ethnologic Vol. xxvi.

Berlin. 1894. Pp. 61-93. [II, 166.]
Jahn, A. Die Mehri-Sprache in Sudarabien. (Siid-arabische

Expedition 3.) Vienna. 1902. [VIII, 227w8.]

254 THE OCEAN OF STORY

[James I, King of Great Britain and Ireland.] Dcemon-
ologie, in forme of a Dialogue, Divided into three Bookes.
Edinburgh. 1597. [VI, 24n.]

Two reprints were issued in London, 1603. Both have the name of the
author on the title-page : " Written by the high and mightie Prince, lames
by the grace of God King of England, Scotland, France, and Ireland, Defender
of the faith, etc."

The work was reprinted as the first part of No. ix of the " Bodley Head
Quartos," 1924, under the title King James the First Dcemonologie (1597). . . .

Jarrett, H. S. See under Blochmann, H.

Jarrett, Thomas. Nalopdkhydnam, or, The Tale of Nala ;
containing the Sanskrit Text in Roman Characters, followed
by A Vocabulary . . . and a Sketch of Sanskrit Grammar.
New Edition Revised. Cambridge. 1882. [IV, 292.]

Jastrow, Morris. The Religion of Babylonia and Assyria.
Vol. ii. of " Handbooks on the History of Religions "
Series. Boston. 1898. [II, 61m1 ; VI, 133, 134.]

Jayakar, A. S. G. Ad-DamirVs Hay at Al-Hayawdn (A
Zoological Lexicon). Translated from the Arabic by . . .
2 vols. London and Bombav. 1906, 1908. [I, 103.]

Jebb, R. C. 0EO$PACTOY XAPAKTHPEC. The Char-
acters of Theophrastus. An English Translation from a
Revised Text with Introduction and Notes. New Edition,
edited by J. E. Sandys, Litt.D. Ldn. 1909. (1st edit.
1870.) [II, 984 ; IV, 94n.]

Jensen, P. Assyrisch-Babylonische Mythen und Epen von
. . . Keilinschriftliche Bibliothek. Sammlung von
assyrischen und babylonischen Texten in Umschrift und
Ubersetzung. (In Verbindung mit . . . Dr P. Jensen . . .
herausgegeben von E. Schrader.) 6 vols. Berlin. 1889-
1900. (See vol. vi., pp. 125, 127.) [I, 274m1.]

Jerdon, T. C. The Birds of India; being a natural history

of all the birds known to inhabit Continental India . . .

2 vols. Calcutta. 1862-1864. [VI, 71n3.]

Vol. ii is in two parts, the second of which is sometimes found bound up as
vol. iii. The pagination is continuous throughout the whole of vol. ii.

Jethabhai, G. Indian Folk-Lore (Being a collection of tales
illustrating the customs and manners of the Indian people).
Limbdi. 1903. [V, 64.]

Jevons, F. B. See under Schrader, O.

John of Bromyard. See under Bromyard, Joannes de.

John of Capua. Directorium vitce humanos . . . [V, 220,
238.] See further under Derenbourg, J.

BIBLIOGRAPHY 255

Johns, C. H. W. " Notes on the Code of ^ammurabi."

American Journ. Semitic Languages. Vol. xix. Chicago.

1902-1903. Pp. 96-107. [I, 271W1.]
Johns, C. H. W. " Babylonian Law." Ency. Brit. 11th edit.

Vol. iii. Pp. 115-121. [I, 270m1.] "Law (Babylonian)."

Hastings' Ency. Rel. Eth. Vol. vii. 1914. Pp. 817-823.

[I, 270nx.]
Johnson, F. Hitopadesa, or Salutary Counsels of Vtshnu-

sarman. London, Hertford. 1847. [IV, 173m1; V, 210;

VI, 279nx.]
Johnson, W. Folk-Memory, or the Continuity of British

Archaeology. . . . Oxford. 1908. [II, 167.]
Johnston, H. H. The Uganda Protectorate. 2 vols. Ldn.

1902. [II, 199w.]
Johnstone, P. de Lacy. The Raghuvanga. The Story of

Raghu's Line. By Kdliddsa. Ldn. 1902. [VI, Sw1.]
Jolly, J. Recht und Sitte (Einschliesslich Der Einheimischen

Litter atur. Grundriss der Indo-Arischen Philologie und

Altertumskunde (Ency. Indo-Aryan Research). Bd. ii.

Heft 8. Herausgegeben von G. Buhler. Strassburg. 1896.

[II, 163n ; VII, 26 ; VIII, 196n.]
Jolly, J. Medicin. Grundriss der Indo-Arischen Philologie

und Altertumskunde (Ency. Indo-Aryan Research).

Bd. iii. Heft 10. Herausgegeben von G. Buhler. Strass-
burg. 1901. [II, 310w3 ; IX, 144.]
Jolly, J. " Disease and Medicine (Hindu)." Hastings'

Ency. Rel. Eth. Vol. iv. 1911. Pp. 753-755. [Ill, 59n.]
Jolly, J. " Fate (Hindu)." Hastings' Ency. Rel. Eth. Vol. v.

1912. Pp. 790-792. [IV, 182.]
Jolly, J., and Schmidt, R. Arthasdstra of Kautilya. A New

Edition by . . . The Punjab Sanskrit Series. No. 4. Lahore :

The Punjab Sanskrit Book Depot. 1923. [II, 277^.] See

also under Kautilya and Shama Sastri, R.
Jones, C. C. ( Jun.) Negro Myths from the Georgia Coast, told in

the Vernacular by . . . Boston & New York. 1888. [IX, 159.]
Jones, John Winter. See under Badger, G. P.
Jones, William. Hitopadesa of Vishnu Sarman. Calcutta.

1870. [V, 210.]
Jones, W. H., and Kropf, L. Folk-Tales of the Magyars,

collected by Kriza, Erdelyi, Pap, and others. Translated

and Edited with Comparative Notes by . . . Folk-Lore

Society. Ldn. 1889. [VI, 292W1.]
Josephus, Flavius. Antiquitates Judaicae (lovSaiKt)

'ApxatoXoyla). [I, 145W1.]

256 THE OCEAN OF STORY

JOSEPHUS, FLAVIUS. Bellum JudaiCUm (llep\ rod 'louScukov
TroXe/uiOu). [Ill, 154.]

Joyce, T. A. Mexican Archaeology. An Introduction to the
Archceology of the Mexican and Mayan Civilizations of
Pre-Spanish America. Ldn. 1914. [II, 309W1.]

" Handbooks to Ancient Civilizations " Series.

Joyce, T. A. See also under Dames, M. Longworth, and
Joyce, T. A.

Julg. B. Kalmukische Mdrchen. Die Marchen des Siddhi-
Kur, aus dem Kalmukischen ubersetzt. Leipzig. 1866.
[I, 20n, 25, 227 ; III, 56, 62, 63, 75, 182, 204 ; VI, 242n2,
264, 269n2 ; VII, 235ri2 ; VIII, 59n3.]

The above work contains the first thirteen stories of Siddi-Kiir only. They
have all (twenty-three — see below) been freely translated into English by
Miss Busk, Sagas from the Far East, 1873, while the first thirteen (the above
work) appear in Coxwell's Siberian and Other Folk-Tales, p. 175 et seq.

Julg, B. Mongolische Marchen- Sammlung. Die Neun
Marchen des Siddhi-Kur nach der ausfiXhrlicheren redaction
und die geschichte des Ardschi-Bordschi Chan. Mongolisch
mit deutscher uebersetzung und Kritischen anmerkungen.
Innsbruck. 1868. [Ill, 182 ; V, 63W1, 15Snx ; VI, 242rc2,
248 ; VIII, 228w4.]

This volume contains stories Nos. xiv-xxiii of Siddhi-Kur and one story from
Arji-Borji Khan.

Julien, Stanislas. Memoir es sur les Contrees Occidentales,
traduit du Chinois, en Van 648, par Hiouen-Thsang, et du
Chinois en Frangais. 2 vols. Paris. 1857-1858. [I, 84w2.]

Julien, Stanislas. Les Avaddnas, Contes et Apologues
Indiens . . . suivis de Fables, de Poesies et de Nouvelles
Chinoises. 3 vols. Paris. 1859. [I, 26 ; V, 67n2, 67n3,
Q8n\ 69n2, 70n\ 70n2, 71n\ 71n3, 72n\ 84nS 92n\ 92rc2,
93nS 94nx, 94n2, 102n2, 105n\ llln2, 114W1, 115W1, 116n\
116w2.]

Jungbauer, G. Marchen aus Turkestan und Tibet. Jena.
1923. [VIII, 107n.]

Juvenal. Satires. [I, 218.]

Kaden, W. Unter den Olivenbaumen Suditalische Volks-
marchen nacherzahlt. Leipzig. 1880. [I, 26, 101 n1 ; II,
5n\ 190W1 ; III, 48wJ, 187n3, 218nl, 238 ; V, 62w2 ; VI,
16n.] •

Kaindl, R. F. " Zauberglaube bei den Rutenen in der
Bukowina und Galizien." Globus, Illustrierte Zeitschrift
fur Lander- und Volkerkunde. Vol. lxi. Braunschweig.
1892. Pp. 279-282. [Ill, 151.]

BIBLIOGRAPHY 257

Kalhana. Rdjatarangini. [VII, 244.] See further under

Stein, M. A.
Kalidasa. Sakuntala. [II, 144W1.] VikramorvaM. [II, 245,

257-259; III, 25n8, 84W1.] Raghuvamsa. [VI, Sn1; IX, 157.]

Kumar a Sambhava. [I, 5w3 ; VI, 3n*.] Mdlavikdgnimitra.

[VII, 2nK]
Kalidasa. See also under Griffith, R. T. H. (Birth of War

God) ; Johnstone, P. de Lacy (Raghuvanca) ; Tawney,

C. H. (Mdlavikdgnimitra).
Kallas, O. " Achtzig Marchen der Ljutziner Esten."

Verhandlungen d. gelehrten Estnischen Gesellschaft. Vol. xx.

Pt. ii. Pp. 87-400. Jurjew (Dorpat). 1900. [Ill, 84ft.]
Kalyana Malla. The Ananga-Ranga. [I, 236; II, lOw;

V, 193-195.] See also under [Burton, R. F., and

Arbuthnot, F. F.].
Kanny Lall Dey. See under Dey, Kanny Lall.
Kapadia, S. A. See under Barnett, L. D., Hindu Gods and

Heroes.
Kaul, Pandit Govind. See under Stein, A., and Grierson,

G. A.
Kautilya (Chanakya, or Vishnugupta). Arthasdstra.

[II, 283wx ; VII, 15n3, 218, 218nx ;' IX, 143.] See also under

Jolly, J., and Schmidt, R. ; and Shama Sastri, R.
Kaviraj Kunja Lal Bhishagratna. See under Bhisha-

GRATNA.

Kaviratna, K. U. C. G. See under Sen, K. N. N.

Keate, George. An Account of the Pelew Islands situated
in the Western Part of the Pacific Ocean. Composed from
the Journals and Communications of Captain Henry Wilson,
and some of his Officers, who, in August 1783, were there
shipwrecked in " The Antepole" a packet belonging to the
Honourable East India Company. 2nd edit. Ldn. 1788.
[VIII, 306711.]

Keightley, Thomas. Tales of Popular Fictions ; their
Resemblance, and Transmission from Country to Country.
Ldn. 1834. [Ill, 204.]

Keightley, Thomas. The Fairy Mythology, illustrative of
the Romance and Superstition of various Countries ; by
. . . New Edition, revised and greatly enlarged. Bohn's
Antiquarian Library. Ldn. 1850. (1st edit. 1828.) [VI,

i 136.]

Keith, A. B. Classical Sanskrit Literature. " Heritage of
India " Series. Calcutta and London. 1923. [I, 93.]

VOL. IX. R

258 THE OCEAN OF STORY

Keith, A. B. The Sanskrit Drama in its Origin, Development,
Theory & Practice. Oxford. 1924. [VII, 237w2 ; VIII,
17W1 ; IX, 160.]
Keith, A. B. " The Game of Dice." Journ. Roy. As. Soc.

July 1908. Pp. 823-828. [II, 232rc.]
Keith, A. B. " OM." Hastings' Ency. Rel. Eth. Vol. ix.

1917. Pp. 490-492. [IV, 176W1.]
Keith, A. B. " Ordeal (Hindu)." Hastings' Ency. Rel. Eth.

Vol. ix. 1917. Pp. 522-524. [VIII, 196n.]
Keith, A. B. See also under Macdonell, A. A.
Keith-Falconer, I. G. N. Kalilah and Dimnah on the Fables

of Bidpai . . . with an English Translation of the Later

Syriac Version. Cambridge. 1885. [V, 219, 242.]
Keller, A. v. See under Ayrer, J.
Keller, H. A. Li Romans de Sept Sages. . . . Heraus-

gegeben von . . . Tubingen. 1836. [I, 171 ; III, 82n2 ;

V, 79ra3.]
Keller, H. A. Dyocletianus Leben von Hans von Bilhel,

Herausgegeben von . . . Quedlinburg and Leipzig. 1841.

Bibliothek der gesammten deutschen Nat.-Lit. Vol. xxii.

[V, 79w3.]
Kellgren, H. Nala och Damayanti. En indisk dikt ur

Mahdbhdrata fr&n originalet ofversatt och med forklarande

noter forsedd of . . . Helsingfors. 1852. [IV, 292.]
Kemp, J. See under Schopenhauer, A.
Kennedy, J. " The Prehistoric Aryans and the Kings of

Mitani." Journ. Roy. As. Soc. Oct. 1909. Pp. 1107-1119.

[I, 198.]
Kennedy, Michael. Notes on Criminal Classes in the

Bombay Presidency, with Appendices regarding some

Foreign Criminals, who occasionally visit the Presidency,

including Hints on the Detection of Counterfeit Coin.

Bombay. 1908. [I, 246nx ; II, 185n.]
Kennedy, P. The Fireside Stories of Ireland. Dublin. 1875.

[Ill, 76.]

There is no copy of this work in the Brit. Mus. Library.

Kerbaker, M. Storia di Nolo : episodio del Mahabharata
tradotto in 8a rima da . . . Torino. 1878. [IV, 292.]

Kha.fi Khan. See under Elliot, H. M.

Kiixis Campbell. See under Campbell, Killis.

Kincaid, C. A. Tales of King Vikrama. Oxford Univ. Press.
1921. [VI, 226, 226w\]

King, George. See under Dutt, Udoy Chand.

BIBLIOGRAPHY 259

Kirby, W. F. " The Forbidden Doors of the Thousand and

One Nights." Folk-Lore Journal. Vol. v. 1887. Pp. 112-

124. [II, 224n.]
Kirtikar, K. R. " The Use of Saffron and Turmeric in

Hindu Marriage Ceremonies." Journ. Anth. Soc. Bombay.

Vol. ix. 1913. Pp. 439-454. [VIII, 18.]

The above paper is supplementary to that on the same subject by

W. Dymock, q.v.

Klauber, E. Assyrisches Beamtentum nach Briefen aus der

Sargonidenzeit. Leipziger Semitische Studien. Bd. v.

Heft 3. Leipzig. 1910. [Ill, 329.]
Klinkert, H. C. Pandja-Tandaren of de geschiedenis van

Galilah en Daminah. Een keur van Oostersche fabelen, uit

het Maleisch vertaald door. . . . Bommel. 1870. [V, 237.]
Knatchbull, W. Kalila and Dimna, or the Fables of Bidpai,

translated from the Arabic. Ldn. 1819. [1,62m1.]
Knebel, J. " Amulettes javanaises." Tijdschrift voor

Indische Taal-, Land- en Volkenkunde. Vol. xL Batavia.

1898. Pp. 497-507. [111,151.]
Knight, R. Payne. An Account of the Remains of the

Worship of Priapus, lately existing at Isernia. . . . Ldn.

1786. [I, 14m.]
Knott, J. " The Origin of Syphilis." New York Medical

Journal. 31st Oct. 1908. [II, 308m2.]
Knott, J. " Origin of the Custom of Salutation after

Sneezing." St Louis Medical Review. Vol. liv. 1906.

Pp. 382-387. [Ill, 315.]
Knowles, J. H. A Dictionary of Kashmiri Proverbs and

Sayings. Bombay, Calcutta, London, 1885. [IV, 48; V,

64, 65.]
A collection of ninety-one fables, legends, etc., illustrating proverbs.

Knowles, J. H. Folk-Tales of Kashmir. Ldn. 1888. (2nd
edit. 1893.) Trubner's Oriental Series. [I, 46m2, 95m2, 131 ;
II, 124, 193m1 ; V, 65, 281 ; VI, 60.]

Nine of the above sixty-four stories, which comprise the collection, appeared
in the Ind. Ant, vols, xiv, xv and xvi.

Knox, A. D. See under Head lam, W.

Koeppen, C. F. Die Religion des Buddha und Ihre Entstehung.

2 vols. Berlin. 1857. [V, 153m1.]
Kohl, J. G. Kitchi-Gami : Wanderings round Lake Superior.

,Ldn. 1860. [VIII, 228m8.]
Kohler, J., Peiser, F. E., and Ungnad, A. Hammurabi's

Gesetz. 5 vols. Leipzig. 1904-1911. [I, 270m1.]

This work is an almost complete text-book for the study of Babylonian law.

260 THE OCEAN OF STORY

Kohler, R. Kleinere Schriften hsg. von J. Bolte. 3 vols.
Weimar. 1898-1900. [IX, 142, 143.]

1 . Zur Marchenforschung. 2. Zur erzahlenden Dichtung des Mittelalters.
S. Zur neueren Literaturgeschichte, Volkskunde und Wortforschung.

Kohler, R. " Ueber J. F. Campbell's Sammlung galischer

Marchen." Orient und Occident. Vol. ii. 1864. Pp. 98-126,

294-331, 486-506, 677-690. [I, 129, 157n2 ; III, 124nx,

237, 272W1.]
Kohler, R. See also under Gonzenbach, L.
Konow, Sten. The Aryan Gods of the Mitani People. Royal

Frederik University, Christiania. Pubs. Indian Institute.

No. 1. 1921. [VI, 8n*.]
Konow, Sten. " The Home of Paisaci." Zeitschrift d.

Deutschen Morgenlandischen Gesellschaft. Vol. lxiv.

Leipzig. 1910. Pp. 95-118. [I, 92.]
Konow, Sten. " Rajasekhara on the Home of Paisaci."

Journ. Roy. As. Soc. April 1921. Pp. 244-246. [I, 93.]
Konrad of Wurzburg. See under Hagen, F. H. v. d.,

Gesammtabenteuer .
Kopp, Hermann. Die Alchemie in dlterer und neuerer Zeit.

Beitrag zur Culturgeschichte. 2 vols. Heidelberg. 1886.

[Ill, 162w.]
Kosegarten, J. G. L. Pantschatantrum sive quinque-

partitum de moribus exponens. Ex codicibus manuscriptis

edidit, commentariis criticis auxit. . . . Bonnae ad Rhenum.

1848-1849. [V, 216.]
Kosegarten, J. G. L. See under Iken, C. J. L.
Krappe, A. H. " The Myth of Balder. A Study in Com-
parative Mythology." Folk-Lore. Vol. xxxiv. 1923.

Pp. 184-215. [VI, In1.]
Krappe, A. H. " The Valkyries." The Modern Language

Review. Vol. xxi. No. 1. Jan. 1926. Pp. 55-73. [VIII,

224n2, 225ra3, 226^.]
Kremer, A. von. Mgypten. Forschungen uber hand und

Volk wdhrend eines zehnjdhrigen Aufenthalts. ... 2 vols.

Leipzig. 1863. [Ill, 329.]
Kremnitz, M. Rumdnische Marchen. Leipzig. 1883. [VI,

292nK]
Kretschmer, P. W. Neugriechische Marchen. Herausgegeben

von . . . Jena. 1917. [IX, 141, 142.]

Forming part of the " Die Marchen der Weltliteratur " Series.

Kriza, J. Vadrozsdk. Kolozsvartt. 1863. [VI, 292nK]

BIBLIOGRAPHY 261

Kroeger, A. E. The Lay of Our Lady. Translated from the

German of Frauenlob, with explanatory notes. (I.e. Heinrich

von Meissen's Cantica Canticorum.) St Louis, U.S.A.

[1877.] [II, 292n3.] See also under Ettmuller, L.
Krom, N. J., and Erp, T. von. Beschrijving van Barabudur

samengesteld door. ... 3 vols. (vol. iii in two parts).

's-Gravenhage. 1920. [VI, 283, 283n5.]
Kronfeld, A. See under Hovorka, O. von, and Kron-

feld, A.
Kroningssvard, C. G. Nordiskt Sago-Bibliothek, eller

Mythiska och Romantiska Forntids-Sagor, utgifna af . . .

5 pts. Fahlun. 1834. [IX, 142.]

The Halfs Saga appears in vol. i, pt. 2, No. 4, pp. 5-47. The incident of the

laughing " mamiannill," or " sea-man," occurs on p. 13.

Kropf, L. See under Jones, W. H., and Kropf, L.
Kshemendra. Brihat-kathd-manjari. [I, 236, 237 ; V,

211-213 ; VI, 2n\ 26w2, l7Sn\ 225, 225w2, 225w4 ; VII,

64 ; IX, 116.]
Kshemendra. Samayamdtrikd. [I, 236.] See further under

Langle, Louis de, and Meyer, J. J.
Kshemendra. See also under Langle, Louis de ; Meyer, J. J.
Kubary, J. S. Ethnographische Beitrdge zur Kenntnis des

Karolinen Archipels. Leyden. 1895. [VIII, 306m1.]
Kuhn, A. Die Herabkunft des Feuers und des Gottertranks.

Berlin. 1859. [I,76w2; II,252w1; IV,145w2; V, 29W1, lllw2.]
A New Edition was issued at Giitersloh in 1886, edited by E. Kuhn. It

forms vol. i of Mythologische Studien.

Kuhn, A. Sagen, Gebrauche und Marchen aus Westfalen.

2 vols. Leipzig. 1859. [I, 26, 77nx ; III, 132w, 152, 187w3,

227n ; VI, 23w2, 36w\ 9Sn\ 136, 149nx ; VII, 120n2 ; VIII,

56n2, 69nx.]
Kunos, Ignaz. Tilrkische Volksmdrchen aus Stambul.

Leiden. 1905. [VIII, 227n4.]

This collection contains fifty-one tales.

Kunos, Ignaz. " Osmanische Volksmarchen " (Schluss.).
Ungarische Revue mit Unterstutzung der Ungarischen
Akademie der Wissenschaften herausgegeben von Paul
Hunfalvy und Gustav Heinrich. Vol. viii. Leipzig, Berlin
and Vienna. 1888. Pp. 435-441. [VIII, 227w4.]

Before 1880 the above periodical was known as Liierarische Berichte aus
Ungarn. . . .

Kuttner, B. Judische Sagen und Legenden fur jung und alt,
gesammelt und wiederzahlt von ... 3 Bdchn. Frankfurt
am Main, 1902-1904. [IX, 144.]

262 THE OCEAN OF STORY

Labuan, the Lord Bishop of. " On the Wild Tribes of
the North- West Coast of Borneo." Transactions of the
Ethnological Society of London. Vol. ii. New Series. Ldn.
1863. Pp. 24-34. [VIII, 231ft9.]

Lacote, F. Essai sur Gunddhya et la Brhaikathd suivi du
Texte Inedit des chapitres xxvii a xxx du Nepdla-Mdhdtmya.
Paris. 1908. [V, 211 ; IX, 94, 95, 100, 101, 117, 118,

118ft1.]

La Fontaine, Jean de. Fables. [I, 26, 27 ; III, 250 ; V, 64,
73ft1, 91ft1, 102ft2, 106ft1, 132ft2, 135ft.] La Vie d'Esope le
Phrygien (usually prefixed to the Fables). [Ill, 250.]
Contes et Nouvelles. [I, 20ft, 165 ; III, 33ft3 ; V, lift1.]

Laistner, L. Rdtsel der Sphinx. Grundzirge einer Mythen-
geschichte. 2 vols. Berlin. 1889. [II, 299ft1.]

Lal, R. B. H. " Human Sacrifice in Central India." Man
in India. Ranchi. Vol. i. No. 1. March 1921. Pp. 57-66.
[I, 116ft1.]

Lal, Rai Bahadur Hira. See under Russell, R. V.

Lambert, L. " Contes Populaires du Languedoc." Revue
des Langues Romanes. 3rd Series. Vol. xiii (i.e. vol. xxvii
of the whole collection). Paris. 1885. Pp. 184-193.
[Ill, 34w.]

Lami, Giovanni. Novelle Letterarie Pvbblicate in Firenze.
1750. Vol. xv, cols. 209-224, 225-240, 257-272 and 273-288.
[IV, 166ft.]

Lami, V. See under Forteguerri, Ser Giovanni.

Lancereau, E. " Extraits du Betal-patchisi." Journal
Asiatique. Serie iv. Vol. xviii, pp. 15-36, 366-410 ; vol. xix,
pp. 333-365. Paris. 1851-1852. [VI, 226 ; VII, 268.]

Landes, A. Contes et Legendes Annamites. Saigon. 1886.
[VIII, 231ft2.]

The collection consists of one hundred and twenty-seven tales and twenty-
two " Contes pour rire."

Lane, E. W. The Thousand and One Nights, commonly called
in England The Arabian Nights'1 Entertainments, a new
Translation from the Arabic with copious notes by . . .
3 vols. Ldn. 1839-1841. [I, 81ft.]

Lane, E. W. An Account of the Manners and Customs of
the Modern Egyptians. . . . Fifth Edition . . . edited
by Edward Stanley Poole. Ldn. 1860. [I, 217 ; II, 163ft ;
III, 308, 308ft2 ; VII, 224ft3 ; VIII, 196ft.]

Lane, E. W. Arabian Society in the Middle Ages; studies
from the Thousand and One Nights. Edited by his grand-
nephew, Stanley Lane-Poole. . . . Ldn. 1883. [I, 81ft.]

BIBLIOGRAPHY 263

Lang, Andrew. Custom and Myth. 2nd edit. Revised.

Ldn. 1885. (1st edit. 1884; New impression, 1910.)

[VI, 135.]
Lang, Andrew. See also under Romilly, H. H. ; Roth,

Henry Ling.
Lang, A., Leaf, W., and Myers, E. The Iliad of Homer,

done into English Prose by . . . Globe Edition. Ldn.

1912. (1st edit. 1882. Most recent revised edition, 1925.)

[Ill, 277.]
Langle, Louis de. he Breviaire de la Courtisane par

Ksemendra (XP siecle). Les Legons de V Entremetteuse par

Damadaragapta (VHP siecle). Traduits en francais pour

la premiere fois. . . . Les Maitres de 1' Amour. Le Livre

d'Amour de l'Orient, Quatrieme Partie. Bibliotheque des

Curieux. Paris. 1900. [I, 236n2, 236n5.]
Langmantel, V. Hans Schiltberger^s Reisebuch nach der

Niirnberger handschrift herausgegeben von . . . Bibliothek

des Litterarischen Vereins in Stuttgart. Vol. clxxii.

Tubingen. 1885. [II, 279W1.]

An English translation was published by the Hakluyt Society in 1879 under
the title : The Bondage and Travels of Johann Schiltberger, a Native of Bavaria,
in Europe, Asia and Africa, 1396-1427. Trans, by J. B. Telfer ; with Notes by
Prof. P. Bruun. The reference to poison grass and water will be found on
p. 23.

Lanman, C. R. Atharva-Veda Samhitd. Translated, with a
Critical and Exegetical Commentary, by William D. Whitney.
Revised and brought nearer to completion and edited by . . .
2 vols. Harvard Oriental Series. Vols, vii and viii.
Cambridge, Mass. 1905. [IV, 263.]

Lanman, C. R. See under Edgerton, Franklin, Vikramd's
Adventures, and Whitney, W. D.

Larminie, W. West Irish Folk-Tales and Romances. Collected
and Translated by . . . With Introduction and notes, and
Appendix containing specimens of the Gaelic originals
phonetically spelt. Ldn. 1898. [VIII, 107w.]

A previous edition has been issued in " The Camden Library " in 1893. The
pagination is the same in both editions.

Larsen, K. H. C. Andersen i Tekst og Billeder. Copenhagen.

1925. [VI, 293.]
Las Casas. See under Casas, F. B. de las.
Lasch, R. " Die Finsternisse in der Mythologie und im

religiosen Brauch der Volker." Archiv fur Religions-

wissenschaft. Vol. iii. Tubingen and Leipzig. 1900.

Pp. 97-152. [IX, 146.]

264 THE OCEAN OF STORY

Lassen, Christian. Anthologia Sanskritica. Bonnse ad
Rhenum. 1838. [VI, 261, 261n2, 273.]

Lassen, C. Indische Alterihumskunde. 4 vols. Bonn, Leipzig
and London. 1847-1862. [VII, 106.]

Latini, Brunetto. See under Chabaille, P., and
D'Ancona, A.

La Touche, T. H. D. A Bibliography of Indian Geology and
Physical Geography, with An Annotated Index of Minerals
of Economic Value. Published by order of the Government
of India. Geological Survey of India. 2 vols. Calcutta.
1917, 1918. [VIII, 65n\ 96n6.]

Vol. i (or pt. i, as it is called) is a Bibliography of the utmost importance.
Vol. ii (pp. 490) is the accompanying account of all the minerals, modestly
called by La Touche " an annotated index." References to articles on moon-
stone by A. K. Coomaraswamy occur in pt. i, p. 102 et seq.

Lawrence, R. Means. The Magic of the Horse-Shoe, with
Other Folk-Lore Notes. Ldn. Cambridge, Mass. [Printed].
[1898.] [Ill, 3WnK]

Lawrence, W. R. The Valley of Kashmir. Ldn. 1895. [II, 232ra.]

Lawson, J. C. Modern Greek Folklore and Ancient Greek
Religion. A Study in Survivals. Cambridge. 1910. [VIII,
218n2.]

Leaf, W. See under Lang, A. ; Leaf, W., and Myers, E.

Leber, C. ; Salgues, J. B. ; et Cohen, J. Collection des
Meilleurs Dissertations, Notices et Traites Particuliers relatifs
a VHistoire de France . . . par ... 20 vols. 1826-1838.

Vol. viii, 1826, contains :

" De FOrigine de l'Usage des Souhaits en Faveur de ceux
qui eternuent. Par Morin." Pp. 371-389. [Ill, 309n2.]

Lecluse. See under L'E(s)cluse, Charles de.

Lederbogen, W. " Duala-Marchen." Afrikanische Studien.
Redigirt von Dr C. Velten und Prof. Dr J. Lippert.
Mittheilungen des Seminars fur Orientalische Sprachen an
der Koniglichen Friedrick Wilhelms-Universitat zu Berlin.
Vol.v. Pt.iii. Berlin. 1902. Pp. 118-148. [VIII, 227w9.]

Lederlini, J. H. See under Brisson, B.

Lee, A. C. The Decameron, Its Sources and Analogues. Ldn.
1909. [1, 44, 148rc, 171 ; II, lOn, 76n\ 114rc; III, 44W1, 118^,
127; IV, 166w, 183 ; V, 275; VI, 271, 271nz ; VII, 204.]

Leemans, C. Boro-Boedoer op het Eiland Java, afgebeeld
door en onder toezigt van F. C. Wilsen, met toelichtenden en
venklarenden tekst naar de geschreven en gedrukte ver-
handelingen van F. C. Wilsen, J. F. G. Brumund en
andere Bescheiden bewerkt, en uitgegeven op last ban Zijne

BIBLIOGRAPHY 265

Excellentie den Minister van Kolonien. 3 vols. (8vo and

atlas folio). Leyden. 1837. [VI, 283ft4.]
Leger, L. Recueil de Contes populaires Slaves. Paris. 1882.

[I, 26, lOlw1.]
Leger, L. " Le Voleur Avis6 (variante Russe)." Melusine.

Vol. i. Paris. 1878. Cols. 136, 137. [I, 27.]
Le Grand d'Aussy, P. J. P. Fabliaux ou Contes, du XIP

et du XIIIe Siecle, Fables et Roman du terns. . . . Nouvelle

Edition, augmentee d'une Dissertation sur les Troubadours.

5 vols. Paris. 1781. [I, 165, 169 ; II, 113ft1 ; III, S2n2.]
The second reference in the Ocean is to the tale " Le Chevalier a la Trappe,"

to be found in vol. iii, pp. 157-166, with analogues on pp. 166, 167.

Leguat, Francois. See under Oliver, Pasfield.

Leland, C. G. The Algonquin Legends of New England, or
Myths and Folk Lore of the Micmac, Passamaquoddy, and
Penobscot Tribes. Boston. 1884 [printed Cambridge, Mass.].
A simultaneous edition also appeared in London. [VIII,
228ft8.]

Lenormant, F. Chaldean Magic : its Origin and Develop-
ment. Translated from the French. With Considerable
Additions by the Author and Notes by the Editor. Ldn.
[1877.] [II, 61ft1, 69ft3, 189m1.]

Lenormant, F. La Grande-Grece, Paysages et Histoire :
Littoral de la Mer Ionienne. (Vol. iii, La Calabre.) 3 vols.
Paris. 1881-1884. [VII, 206, 206ft2, 208.]

L'E(s)cluse, Charles de. Aromatum, et simplicium aliquot
medicamentorum apud indos nascentium historia : ante
biennium quidem Lusitanica lingua per Dialogos conscripta,
D. Garcia ab Horto, Proregis Indie Medico, auctore : Nunc
verb primiim Latina facta, & in Epitomen contracta a
Carolo Clusio Atrebate. Antverpiae, Ex officina Christophori
Plantini, 1567. [II, 302ft1 ; VIII, 245.] See also under
Briganti, A.

Leumann, E. Das Aupdpatika Sutra erstes Updnga der
Jaina. Einleitung, Text und Glossar. Abhandlungen fiir
die Kunde des Morgenlandes herausgegeben von der Deutschen
Morgenlandischer Gesellschaft. Bd. viii. No. 2. Leipzig.
1883. [VIII, 254ft3.]

Leumann, Ernst. See under Tawney, C. H., Kathdkoca.

Leveque, Eugene. Les Mythes et Les Legendes de Ulnde et
la Perse dans Aristophane, Plalon, Aristote, Virgile, Ovide,
Tite Live, Dante, Boccace, Arioste, Rabelais, Perrault, La
Fontaine. Paris. 1880. [I, 26, 84ft2, 189ft ; II, 152ft1 ;
III, 9ft1 ; IV, 150ft1 ; V, lift1, 91ft1, 132ft2, 133ft, 135ft.]

266 THE OCEAN OF STORY

Levi, Israel. " Une Fable de la Fontaine & Les Contes
Orientaux." Melusine. Vol. ii. Paris. 1886-1887. Cols.
541-545. [VII, 203ft4.]

Levi, Sylvain. La Legende de Nala et Damayanti. Traduite,
avec Introduction, Notes et Vocabulaire par . . . Bois
dessines et graves par Andree Karpeles. Les Classiques
de l'Orient. Vol. i. Paris. 1920. [IX, 155.]

Levi, Sylvain. " La Brihatkathamafijari de Kshemendra."
Journal Asiatique. Huitieme Serie. Tom. vi. Paris,
1885, pp. 397-479; ditto Tom. vii. 1886, pp. 178-222.
[V, 212 ; VI, 225ft2.]

Lewin, L. Ueber Areca Catechu, Chavica Betle und das
Betelkauen. Mit zwei lithographirten Tafeln. Stuttgart.
1889. [VIII, 237ft1, 315m1.]

This is a monograph of 100 pages, containing important references to the
custom of betel-chewing. It appears to be very scarce. In the Brit. Mus.
Library it is bound up in a volume, " Tracts on Botany," 1888-1910. The
number is 07028, i, 15.

Lewin, L. " Die Pfeilgifte. Historische und experimentelle

Untersuchungen." Archiv fur pathologische Anatomie und

Physiologie und fur klinische Medizen. Bd. cxxxvi,

Berlin, 1894, pp. 83-126, 403-443 ; and Bd. cxxxviii,

Berlin, 1896, pp. 283-346. [II, 279.]
Lewin, T. H. The Wild Races of South-Eastern India. Ldn.

1870. [I, 82ft.]
Lewis, A. S. See also under Conybeare, F. C.
Lewis, G. Cornewall. Babrii Fabulw Msopeoe. E Codice

Manuscripto Partem Secundam. Ldn. 1859. [V, 135ft1.]
Lewis, J. P. " Note on the Story of Rhampsinitus." The

Orientalist. Vol. iii. Pts. vii and viii. Kandv, Ceylon.

1888. Pp. 148, 149. [V, 255ft1.]
Leyen, F. von der. Indische Marchen. Ubertragen von . . .

Halle. 1898. Bibliothek der Gesammtlitteratur des In-

und Auslandes. [VI, 225ft1.]
Leyen, F. von der. Gesammelte Abhandlungen von Wilhelm

Hertz herausgegeben von . . . Stuttgart and Berlin. 1905.

[VI, 74ft.]
Leyen, F. von der, and Zaunert, P. Die Marchen der

Weltliteratur. Neugriechische Marchen. Jena. 1917.

[VIII, 107ft.]
Li, The Shaman Hwui. See under Beal, Samuel.
Libansky, J. Nal a Damajanti. Bdje Indickd desky vypravuje.

v. Olomonci. 1875. [IV, 292.]

BIBLIOGRAPHY 267

Lidzbarskt, M. Geschichten und Lieder aus den neu-
aramdischen Handschriften der Koniglichen BibliotJiek zu
Berlin. Beitrage zur Volks- und Volkerkunde. Vol. iv.
Weimar. 1896. [Ill, 76, 280.]

Liebich, B. Sanskrit-Lesebuch. Zur Einfiihrung in die
altindische Spr ache und Liter atur. Leipzig. 1905. [IX, 155.]

Liebrecht, F. John Dunlop's Geschichte der Prosadichtungen
oder Geschichte der Romane, Novellen, Mdrchen u.s.w.
Aus dem Englischen ubertragen und vielfach vermehrt und
berichtigt. Berlin. 1851. [I, 24W1, 44, 66wx, 97rc2, 103, 137/i1,
145n\ 166 ; II, 6n2, 39w2, 127ra2 ; III, 82w2, 285nx ; IV,
129rc, 132711, 145n\ 145w2 ; V, 13n\ S7n\ llln2, 162/t1,
186w2 ; VI, 204w3, 280w2'3-4.]

Liebrecht, F. Des Gervasii von Tilbury Otia Imperalia.
In einer Auswahl neu herausgegeben und mit Anmerkungen
begleitetvon . . . Hanover. 1856. [VI, 281.]

Liebrecht, F. Zur Volkskunde. Alte und neue Aufsdtze.
Heilbronn. 1879. [I, 13w3, 14w, 26, 39w2, 191 ; II, 39w2,
106w4, 131W1 ; III, 20W1, Un\ 131n3, 187n3, 210w3, 225w2,
2Slnl ; IV, 93w2 ; V, 80w2, 93nS W0n\ 102n2, lllw2, 121n2,
I27n\ 132n2, 135w, 201n; VI, 15w3, 122nx ; VIII, 233nx.]

Liebrecht, F. " Beitrage zum Zusammenhang indischer
und europaischer Marchen und Sagen." Orient und
Occident. Gottingen. 1860. Vol.i. Pp. 116-136. [V, 92w2.]

Liebrecht, F. " Merlin." Orient und Occident. Vol. i.
Pp. 341-344. [I, 46n2.]

Liebrecht, Felix. " Amor und Psyche — Zeus und Semele
— Pururavas und Urva9i." Zeitschrift fur Vergleichende
Sprachforschung auf dem gebiete des Deutschen, Griechischen
und Lateinischen. Heraus. von Dr Adalbert Kuhn. Vol.
xviii. Berlin. 1869. Pp. 56-66. [VIII, 232rc7.]

Limburg - Brouwer, P. A. S. Van. See under Van
Limburg-Brouwer, P. A. S.

Ling Roth. See under Roth, H. Ling.

Linschoten, J. H. van. See under Burnell, A. C.

Lith, P. A. van der ; Spaan, A. J. ; and Fokkens, F.
Encyclopcedie van Nederlandsch — Indie met medewerking
van Verschillende Ambtenoren, Geleerden en officieren
samengesteld door. ... 4 vols. *s Gravenhage - Leiden.
[1895-1905.] [VIII, 318W1.]

Livingstone, David. The Last Journals ... 2 vols. 1874.
< [I, 217.]

Livy [Titus Livius]. Ab urbe condita libri (also called
Historicc and Annates). [II, 277 ; IV, 23n2 ; VI, 24w.]

268 THE OCEAN OF STORY

Lloyd, A. See under Chamberlain, B. H.

Loeb, E. M. " The Blood Sacrifice Complex." Memoirs of

the Anthropological Association. No. 30. Menasha, Wis.

1923. (Pp. 40.) [IV, 65n.]
Lombardi, P. B. La Divina Commedia di Dante Alighieri

correta, spiegata, edifesa dal ... 3 vols. Roma. 1820-

1822. [VIII, 100n.]
Longfellow, H. W. Flowers. [VI, On1.]
Longhurst, A. H. Hampi Ruins Described and Illustrated.

Madras. 1917. [IV, 261, 268.]
Longworth Dames. See under Dames, M. Longworth.
Lott, E. The English Governess in Egypt. Harem Life

in Egypt and Constantinople. 4th edit. Ldn. 1867. [II,

163n.]
Low, C. E. Central Provinces. District Gazetteers. Balaghat

District. Vols. A and B. (Descriptive and Statistics.)

Allahabad. 1917. [Ill, 101n.]

The reference to barbers occurs on pp. 197, 198.

Low, Hugh. Sarawak : Its Inhabitants and Productions ;
being Notes During a Residence in that Country with H.H.
The Rajah Brooke. Ldn. 1848. [VIII, 298nx.]

Luber, A. Der Vetdlapandavingati oder Funfundzwanzig
Erzahlungen eines Dcemon. Erster Teil. Nach (?ividasa?s
Redaction aus dem Sanskrit iibersetzt, mit Einleitung,
Anmerkungen und Nachweisen von . . . Gorz. 1875.
[V, 265.]

Lucan [Marcus Ann^eus Lucanus]. Pharsalia. [II, 62nx.]

Lucian [Aowciavos], The Ass (Lucius sive Asinus). [VI, 56n2.]
De Dea Syria. [I, 275, 276 ; II, 169 ; III, 167n2, 327, 328.]
Demonax. [V, 136n3.] Dialogues of the Courtesans ('EracpiKol
StdXoyoi). [I, 140nx.] Hermoiimus. [Ill, 82n2 ; VI, 133n.]
Philopseudes (The Liar). [1, 77n] ; III, 40n2.] Vera Historia.
[II, 193nx, 219n3.] See also under Fowler, H. W. and F. G.

Luckenbill, D. D. " The Temple Women of the Code of
Hammurabi." Amer. Journ. Semitic Lang. Vol. xxxiv.
Chicago. Oct. 1917-July 1918. Pp. 1-12. [I, 271n*.]

Lucretius. De Rerum Natura. [I, 190.]

Lucretius. See under Munro, H. A. J.

Luders, H. Das Wiirfelspiel im alien Indien. Abhandlungen
der Koniglichen Gesellschaft der Wissenschaften zu
Gottingen. Phil.-hist. Klasse. New Series. Vol. ix.
Berlin. 1907. [II, 232rc.]

BIBLIOGRAPHY 269

Lumholtz, Carl. Through Central Borneo. An Account of

Two Years' Travel in the Land of the Head-Hunters between

the years 1913 and 1917. 2 vols. New York. 1920. [VIII,

298W1.]
Lyall, Charles. See under Gurdon, P. R. T., Hodson, H. C,

and Stack, Edward.
Lyall, C. J. Translations of Ancient Arabian Poetry, chiefly

Prat-Islamic, with an Introduction and Notes by . . . Ldn.

1885. [Ill, 278.]
Lyon, A. P. " Notes on the Gogodara Tribe of Western

Papua." Journ. Roy. Anth. Inst. Vol. lvi. 1926. Pp. 329-

359. [VIII, 313w2.] |jg

Lyon, D. G. " The Consecrated Women of the Hammurabi

Code." Studies in the History of Religions presented to

Crawford Howell Toy by pupils, colleagues and friends.

New York. 1912. Pp. 341-360. [I, 271nx.]
Macculloch, J. A. The Childhood of Fiction : A Study of

Folk Tales and Primitive Thought. Ldn. _ 1905. [I, 109n\

130; II, 108n, 194n, 202ft1 . 224w, 253; III, 204, 227w,

238, 253ft1 ; V, 128w ; VIII, 233ft3.]
Macculloch, J. A. " Austerities." Hastings' Ency. Rel.

Eth. Vol. ii. 1909. Pp. 225-235. [Ill, 21ft.]
Macculloch, J. A. " Cakes and Loaves." Hastings' Ency.

Rel. Eth. Vol. iii. 1910. Pp. 57-61. [I, 15ft.]
Macculloch, J. A. " Cannibalism." Hastings' Ency. Rel.

Eth. Vol. iii. 1910. Pp. 194-209. [IX, 75ft1.]
Macculloch, J. A. " Covenant." Hastings' Ency. Rel. Eth.

Vol. iv. 1911. Pp. 206-209. [VI, 133.]
Macculloch, J. A. " Hand." Hastings' Ency. Rel. Eth.

Vol. vi. 1913. Pp. 492-499. [Ill, 152ft.]
Macculloch, J. A. " Horns." Hastings' Ency. Rel. Eth.

Vol. vi. 1913. Pp. 791-796. [Ill, 188ft.]
Macculloch, J. A. " Nose." Hastings' Ency. Rel. Eth.

Vol. ix. 1917. Pp. 396-399. [Ill, 314, 314w\]
Macculloch, J. A. " Serpent Worship (Introductorv and

Primitive)." Hastings' Ency. Rel. Eth. Vol. xi. *1920.

Pp. 399-411. [I, 203, 204 ; II, 307ft2.]
Macculloch, J. A. " Vampire." Hastings' Ency. Rel. Eth.

Vol. xii. 1921. Pp. 589-591. [VI, 137.]
Macdonald, D. B. " Wahm in Arabic and its Cognates."

Journ. Roy. As. Soc. Oct. 1922. Pp. 505-521. [VI, 66.]
Macdonald, D. B. " The Earlier History of the Arabian

Nights." Journ. Roy. As. Soc. Julv 1924. Pp. 353-

397. [VI, 62 ; VII, 225nK]

270 THE OCEAN OF STORY

Macdonald, James. " East Central African Customs."
Journ. Anth. Inst. Vol. xxii. Ldn. 1893. Pp. 99-122.
[II, 198n>.]

Macdonell, A. A. Vedic Mythology. Grundriss der Indo-
Arischen Philologie und Altertumskunde (Ency. Indo-
Aryan Research). Bd. iii. Heft 1. A. Herausgegeben
vonG.Biihler. Strassburg. 1897. [II, 240, 252^ ; VI, SnK]

Macdonell, A. A. A History of Sanskrit Literature. Ldn.
1909. [II, 45ra4, 242 ; VI, 227.]

This forms vol. ix of " Short Histories of the Literature of the World "
Series, edited by Edmund Gosse, LL.D.

Macdonell, A. A., and Keith, A. B. Vedic Index of Names

and Subjects. Indian Text Series. 2 vols. Ldn. 1912.

[I, Sn1, 56n, 93, 205, 232m1 ; VII, 10w2.]
Maclagan, E. See under Rose, H. A.
Maclean, A. J. " Chastitv (Christian)." Hastings' Ency.

Rel. Eth. Vol. iii. 1910. Pp. 491-494. [Ill, 172rc2.]
Macler, F. La Version Armenienne de VHistoire des Sept

Sages de Rome, mise en Frangais par . . . Paris. 1919.

[V, 266ra4.]
Macnaghten, W. H. Principles of Hindu and Mohammedan

Law republished from the Principles and Precedents of the

Same, by the late Sir . . . and edited by H. H. Wilson.

Leipzig. 1860. [I, 87.]
Macoudi or Mas'audi. See under Meynard, C, Barbier

DE, ET COURTEILLE, PaVET DE.

Madden, F. See under Herrtage, S. J. H.

Madhava Acharya. See under Cowell, E. B., and Gough,

A. E.
Magnus, Albertus. " Ejusdem Alberti Magni de Mir-

abilibus Mundi feliciter incipit." Be Secretis Mvliervm.

Item De Virtutibus Herbarum Lapidum et Animalium.

Amstelodami. 1669. [II, 299, 299n3.]

The Brit. Mus. has not this edition, those of 1643 and 1655 being the
nearest.

Magnusson, E. See under Arnason, J6n.

Mailli, Chevalier de. See under Bolte, J., and Fischer,
H. (French version.)

Main, John [i.e. Mrs E. W. Parsons]. Religious Chastity:
an Ethnological Study. New York. 1913. [I, 279.]

Major, R. H. India in the Fifteenth Century. Being a Collec-
tion of Narratives of Voyages to India, in the Century
Preceding the Portuguese Discovery of the Cape of Good
Hope, from Latin, Persian, Russian, and Italian Sources.

BIBLIOGRAPHY 271

. . . Hakluyt Society. Ldn. 1857. [Issued for 1858.]

[I, 248ft1 ; VIII, 257.]

The volume forms No. xxii of the First Series and contains the following :
1. Voyage of Abd-er-Razzak. 2. Travels of Nicolo Conti. 3. Travels of
Athanasius Nikitin. 4. Journey of Hieronimo di Santo Stefano. Each section
has a separate enumeration.

Makhlls of Ispahan. See under Dervish Makhlis of

Ispahan.
[Malcolm, J.] Sketches of Persia from the Journals of a

Traveller in the East. 2 vols. Ldn. 1828. [Ill, 76 ; VII,

203w3.]
Malik Muhammad Din. The Bahdivalpur State. Lahore.

1908. [II, 167.]
Malla, Kalyana. See under [Burton, R. F., and Arbuth-

not, F. F.]> Ananga-Ranga.
Mallery, G. Introduction to the Study of Sign Language

among the North American Indians, as illustrating the

Gesture of Speech of Mankind. Smithsonian Institute,

Bureau of Ethnology. Washington. 1880. |IX, 143.]
Mandelslo, J. Albert de. See under Davies, John.
Mandeville, Jehan de. (" Sir John . . . ") See under

Halliwell, J. O.
Maning, F. E. (p.s. Pakeha Maori). Old New Zealand.

Ldn. 1863. [IX, 154.]
Ma^kowski, Leo von. Der Auszug aus dem Pancatantra in

Kshemendras Brihatkathdmanjari. Leipzig. 1892. [V, 212.]
Manning, C. Ancient and Mediceval India. 2 vols. Ldn.

1869. [II, 155n3.]
Manu. See under Buhler, J. G.
Manucci, Niccolao. See under Irvine, William.
Manuel, T. P. The Khirud-Ofroz : Translated from the

Oordoo into English. . . . Calcutta. 1861. (Reprinted

Lucknow, 1892.) [V, 240.]
Manwaring, A. Marathi Proverbs, collected and translated

by . . . Oxford. 1899. [V, 55n2.]
Mapes, Gualterus (i.e. Walter Map). De Nugis Curialium.

See the edition by T. Wright for the Camden Society.

1841. [Ill, 210n3 ; V, 80n2 ; VI, 122m1.]
Marcel, J. J. Contes du Cheykh El-Mohdy, traduits de

VArabe, aVapres le Manuscrit Original. 3 vols. Paris.
■ 1832, 1833. [I, Sin.]
Marco Polo. See under Marsden, W., and Yule, H.
Marett, R. R. See under White, W. G.

272 THE OCEAN OF STORY

Margaret of Navarre. The Heptameron. [II, 2nx, lOn ;

III, 126 ; V, 153W1.]

This work first appeared in Paris, 1558, under the title of Histories des
Amans Fortunez. The best English translation is that in 5 vols., 1894, issued
by the Society of English Bibliophilists, with an Introduction by George
Saintsbury.

Marie de France. Les Lais. [II, 113m1.]

Of the twelve Lais definitely attributed to Marie, only Equitan is referred
to in the Ocean. Numerous English, French and German editions have been
published.

Marignolli. See under Yule, H., Cathay and the Way Thither.
Markham, Clements. Colloquies on the Simples & Drugs

of India. By Garcia Da Orta. New Edition (Lisbon, 1895).

Edited and Annotated by the Conde de Ficalho. Translated,

with an Introduction and Index, by . . . Ldn. 1913.

[II, 302nx ; VIII, 240, 240ft1, 245.]
Markham, Clements. See also under Van Limburg-

Brouwer, P. A. S.
Marr, Hamilton. See under Andersen, H. C.
Marsden, W. Travels of Marco Polo in the Thirteenth

Century : being a Description, by that early Traveller, of

Remarkable Places and Things in the Eastern Parts of the

World. Translated from the Italian, with Notes, by . . .

Ldn. 1818. [VIII, 246.]
Marshall, H. I. The Karen People of Burma. Columbus.

1922. [VIII, 285n6.]
Marshall, J. H. " The Date of Kanishka." Journ. Boy. As.

Soc. Oct. 1914, pp. 973-986. April 1915, pp. 191-196.

[VI, 229, 229n3.]
See also corrections, etc., by F. W. Thomas, on pp. 987-992.

Martin, M. A Description of the Western Islands of Scotland,
. . . the Antient and Modern Government, Religion, and
Customs of the Inhabitants; a particular Account of the
Second Sight, etc. Ldn. 1716. [Ill, 13ln\]

Maspero, G. Etudes egyptiennes. Romans et poesies du
papyrus Harris No. 500 conserve au British Museum, avec
facsimile, texte, traduction et Commentaire. (Extraits du
Journal Asiatique.) 2 vols. Paris. 1879-1891. [VI, 134.]

Maspero, G. Histoire Ancienne des Peuples de V Orient
Classique. 3 vols. Paris. 1895-1899. [VI, 134.]

Maspero, G. Guide du Visiteur au Musee du Caire. Le
Caire. 1902. [V, 254.]

Maspero, G. Popular Stories of Ancient Egypt. . . .
Translated by Mrs C. H. W. Johns (A. S. Griffith) From

BIBLIOGRAPHY 273

the Fourth French Edition. Revised by Sir G. Maspero.
Ldn. 1915. [I, 37n2, 77n\ 129, ISSn1 ; II, ll2n\ 120-121 ;
III, 203, 238, 250, 268nx ; V, 252, 255 ; VII, 92/11.]

For details of the French editions see H. Cordier, Bibliographie des CEuvres
de Gaston Maspero, Paris, 1922, pp. 22, 79, 89 and 101.

Massinger, Philip. The Guardian. [VI, 271.] The Picture

[I, 44, 167.]
Masuccio. See under Waters, W. G.
Mather, F. J. " King Ponthus and the Fair Sidone."

Publications of the Modern Language Association of

America. Vol. xii. (New Series, vol. v.) Baltimore. 1897.

Pp. lxvii + 150. [II, 76711.]
Matignon, J. J. Superstition, Crime et Misere en Chine.

4th edit. Lyon. 1902. [Ill, 329.]

In the above edition the chapter on eunuchs occupies pp. 247-268.

Matth^sus Paris. See under Paris, Matth^us.

Matthews, A. N. Mishcdt-ul-Masdbih or A Collection of
the Most Authentic Traditions, Regarding the Actions and
Sayings of Muhammed ; exhibiting the Origin of the
Manners and Customs; the Civil, Religious and Military
Policy of the Muslemdns. Translated from the original
Arabic. 2 vols. Calcutta. 1809, 1810. [VIII, 100n.]

Maxfield, B. L., and Millington, W. H. " Visayan Folk-
Tales. II." The Journal of American Folk-Lore. Boston
and New York. Vol. xx. April- June, 1907. No. lxxvii.
Pp. 89-103. [VIII, 231w5.]

Mayers, W. F. " The Buddhist Rosary and its Place in
Chinese Official Costume." Notes and Queries on China and
Japan. Edited by N. B. Dennys. Vol. iii. Hong-Kong.
1869. Pp. 26-29. [IX, 145.]

The above article was a reply to an inquiry as to the explanation of the
Buddhist rosary containing 108 beads, etc., in ditto, vol. ii, 1868, p. 72.

Mayne, John D. A Treatise on Hindu Law and Usage.
Madras, Ldn. [printed]. 1878. [I, 88.]

Mazon, Andre. Contes slaves de la Macedoine sud-occidentale.
Textes et traductions, avec notes de Folklore. Travaux pub-
lies par l'lnstitut des etudes slaves. Paris. 1923. [IX, 142.]

McCrindle, J. W. Ancient India as described by Megasthenes
and Arrian. . . . Calcutta, Bombay, London. 1877. [V,
S3n\ 160m1.]

This work was reprinted (with additions) from The Indian Antiquary, 1876-
( 1877. It became very scarce and was reprinted in Calcutta, 1926.

McCrindle, J. W. KOZMA AirYIITIOY MONAXOY
XPIZTIANIKH TOnorPA^>IA The Christian Topography

VOL. IX. S

274 THE OCEAN OF STORY

of Cosmas, An Egyptian Monk. Translated from the Greek,
and Edited, with Notes and Introduction, by . . . Hakluyt
Society. Ldn. 1897. This volume forms No. xcviii of
the First Series. [VII, 107.]

McDougall, W. See under Hose, C, and McDougall, W.

Meier, E. Nal und Damajanti. Fine indische Dichtung.
Aus dem Sanskrit iibersetzt und erldutert. Stuttgart. 1847.
This forms vol. i of Die Klassischcn Dichtungen der Inder.
3 vols. Stuttgart. 1847, 1852 and 1854. [IV, 292.]

Meier, E. Deutsche Volksmdrchen aus Schwaben. Stuttgart.
1852. [V, 157W1.]

Meissen, Heinrich von. See under Frauenlob.

Melton, John. Astrologaster, or the Figure-Caster. Rather
the arraignment of Artlesse Astrologers, and fortune tellers,
that cheat many ignorant people . . . once againe brought
to the barre. Ldn. 1620. [II, 145w ; IV, 199nK]

Mendana, Alvaro de. See under Amherst of Hackney,
Lord, and Basil Thomson.

Menzel, Theodor von. Beitrdge zur Mdrchenkunde des
Morgenlandes. Herausgegeben von Georg Jacob und
T. Menzel. Vols, ii and iii have separate titles as follows :
Band ii, Tilrkische Mdrchen I. Billur Kiischk. (Der
Kristallkiosk) 14 tilrkische Marchen, zum erstenMale nach
den beiden Stambuler Drucken der Marchensammlung
ins Deutsche iibersetzt. . . . Halbleinen, 1923. Band iii,
Tilrkische Marchen II. Der Zauberspiegel. Turkische
Marchen, zum ersten Male aufgezeichnet und ins Deutsche
iibersetzt. . . . Halbleinen, 1924. [VIII, 107n.]

The reference in the Ocean is to vol. ii, Billur Kiischk.

Mercier, G. Le Chaouia de VAures dialecte de VAhmar-
Khaddou. Etude grammatical. Texte en dialecte chaouia.
Ecole superieure des Lettrcs d'Alger. No. 17 of Publica-
tions. Algiers. 1896. [VIII, 227n7.]

Meredith, George. " On the Idea of Comedy, and of the
Uses of the Comic Spirit." New Quarterly Magazine.
No. 15. April 1877. Pp. 1-40. [VII, 253?*1.] °

The above article was first delivered as a lecture at the London Institution,
1st Feb. 1877. It was published later as a separate work : An Essay on Comedy
and the Uses of the Comic Spirit, Westminster, 1897.

Merit, Edelestand du. Poesies Inedites du Moyen age,
Precedees D' une Histoire de la Fable Esopique. Paris. 1854.
[V, 73711.]

Baldo's Alter JEsopus occupies pp. 213-259-

BIBLIOGRAPHY 275

Merutunga . See under Tawney, C. H., Prabandhacintdmani.
Meyer, E. H. 1. Germanische Myihologie. Lehrbucher der

germanischen Philologie. Berlin. 1891. [VIII, 232n8.]
Meyer, J. J. Dandins Dagakumdracaritam, die Abenteuer

der zehn Prinzen. Ein altindischer Schelmenroman. Zum

ersten Male aus dem Sanskrit ins Deutsche ubersetzt von . . .

Nebst einer Einleitung und Anmerkungen. Lotus- Verlag.

Leipzig. [1902.] [II, 183wx, 184w ; V, 176 ; VII, 223nx.]
Meyer, J. J. Kdvyasamgraha : erotische und esoterische

Lieder. Metrische Ubersetzungen aus indischen und anderen

Sprachen. Leipzig. [1903.] [I, 234nx.]
Meyer, J. J. Hindu Tales. An English Translation of

Jacobi's Ausgewahlte Erzdhlungen in Mdhdrdshtn. Ldn.

1909. [V, 175, 176 ; VII, 218, 218n2, 223W1.]
This work " should be called Jain Tales," says Tawney on the title-page of

his copy.

Meyer, J. J. Das Weib im altindischen Epos. Ein Beitrag

zur indischen u. vergleichenden Kulturgeschichte. Leipzig.

1915. [I, 234nx.]
Meyer, J. J. Ksemendrd's Samayamdtrikd. Das Zauberbuch

der Hetdren. Ins Deutsche iibertragen von . . . Leipzig.

N.D. [I, 236, 236n4.]
Meyer, Kuno. Cain Adamndin, An Old Irish Treatise on

the Law of Adamnan. Edited and Translated by . . .

Anecdota Oxoniensia. Oxford. 1905. [Ill, 21n.]
Meynard, C. Barbier de, and Courteille, Pavet de.

Magoudi : Les Prairies d'Or. Texte et Traduction par . . .

9 vols. Societe Asiatique. Paris. 1861-1877. [VI, 293n2.]

The above is a French translation of the Muruj udh-Dhahab wa Ma'adin
ul-Jawahir ("Meadows of Gold and Mines of Precious Stones "), compiled in
947. An English translation had been commenced by A. Sprenger, Orient.
Trans. Fund, London, 1841, but only one volume appeared. The above work
apparently stopped any further volumes being issued.

Meynard, C. Barbier de. Les Colliers d'Or, allocutions
morales de Zamakhschari. Paris. 1876. [II, 298.]

The above is a French translation of the Atwaq udh-Dhahab. It had been
previously edited by Hammer-Purgstall (Vienna, 1835), Fleischer (Leipzig,
1835) and Weil (Stuttgart, 1863). Cf. M. de Goeje in Zeit. d. deut. morg.
Gesell., vol. xxx, p. 313 et seq.

Migne, J. P. Patrologice Cursus Completus. Patrologia
latina. 221 vols. Paris. 1844-1864. [IX, 143.]

The volume referred to in the Ocean is Tomus cxcvii, Saeculum xii. S. Hilde-
igardis Abbatissx Opera Omnia, ad Optimorum Librorum Fidem Edita, 1853.

Mijatovics, E. L. (Mijatovicka or Mijatovic). See under
Denton, W.

276 THE OCEAN OF STORY

Milburn, W. Oriental Commerce ; containing a geographical
description of the principal places in the East Indies, China
and Japan. ... 2 vols. Ldn. 1813. [I, 214.]

Miller, F. J. Ovid Metamorphoses, with an English Transla-
tion by ... 2 vols. Loeb Classical Library. Ldn. 1916.
Reprinted 1922. [VII, 228n2.] See further under Ovid.

Milligen, F. " The Circassian Slaves and the Sultan's
Harem." Journ. Anth. Soc. Ldn. Pp. cix-cxx. [II, 163w.]

The above Journal is contained in parts 1, 2 and 3 of the Journal of
Anthropology, 1 vol., Ldn., 1871.

Millin de Grandmaison,A. L. Peintures de Vases Antiques
Vulgairement appeles Etrusques tirees de differentes collec-
tions et gravees par A. Clener. Accompagnees d' explications
par . . . 2 vols, (large folio). Paris. 1808,1809. [IX, 147.]
The plate showing the Grecian umbrella is No. lxx, vol. ii, facing p. 113.
See the note (3) on this page.

Mills, J. P. The Lhota Nagas. With an Introduction and
Supplementary Notes by J. H. Hutton, CLE. Published
by direction of the Government of Assam. Ldn. 1922.
[VIII, 285n7.]

Mills, J. P. The Ao Nagas. With a Foreword by Henry
Balfour, M.A., F.R.S., and Supplementary Notes and Biblio-
graphy by Dr J. H. Hutton, CLE. Published by direction
of the Government of Assam. Ldn. 1926. [VIII, 284w3.]

Mills, L. Shans at Home. . . . With two chapters on Shan
History and Literature by the Rev. Wilbur Willis Cochrane.
With illustrations. Ldn. 1910. [VIII, 286n4.]

Milman, H. H. N alopdkhydnam. Story of Nala, an Episode
of the Mahd-Bhdrata : The Sanskrit Text, with a Copious
Vocabulary, Grammatical Analysis, and Introduction, by
Monier Williams. . . . The Metrical Translation by . . .
Oxford. 1860. [IV, 278.]

Milne, A. A. See under Hartland, Science of Fairy Tales.

Milton, John. Comus. [IV, 243n2 ; VI, 147nx ; VIII, 56n\]
Paradise Lost. [II, 42n2 ; III, 131n3 ; IV, 80ft1, 129n ; V,
29w2 ; VI, 2l5n\]

Mitchell, J. M. " Harem." Ency. Brit. Vol. xii. Pp. 950-
952. [II, 163n.]

Mitford, A. B. (Baron Redesdale). Tales of Old Japan.
Ldn. 1903. (The 7th reprint of the 2nd edit, of 1874.)
[I, 27 ; VIII, 231n4.]

Mitra, Rajendralala. " On the Gypsies of Bengal."
Memoirs read before the Anth. Soc. Ldn., 1867, 1868, 1869.
Vol. iii. Ldn. 1870. Pp. 120-133. [I, 240W1 ; III, 51n.]

BIBLIOGRAPHY 277

Mitra, Rajendralala. lndo- Aryans : Contributions towards

the Elucidation of their Ancient and Mediaeval History.

2 vols. Ldn. Calcutta [printed]. 1881. [II, 167.]
Mitra, Rajendralala. The Sanskrit Buddhist Literature of

Nepal. Calcutta. 1882. [I, 20n2 ; III, 20n\ 2tenl ; IV,

229n2 ; V, 127W.1]
Mitra, Rajendralala. " On Human Sacrifices in Ancient

India." Journ. As. Soc. Bengal. Vol. xlv. Calcutta. 1876.

Pp. 76-118. [IV, 64W1.]
Mitra, Sarat Chandra. " Bihari Folktales of the ' Mann

und Fuchs ' Tvpe." Journ. Anth. Soc. Bombay. Vol. vi.

Bombay. 1902. Pp. 132-141. [Ill, 250.]
Mitra, Sarat Chandra. " On a Recent Instance of the Use

of the Nudity-spell for Rain-making in Northern Bengal."

Journ. Anth. Soc. Bombay. Vol. xii. No. 7. Bombay.

1924. Pp. 919-926. (Extract from The Englishman,

Calcutta, Thursday, 19th July 1923.) [IX, 147.]
Mitra, Sarat Chandra. " Studies in Bird-Myths. No. vii. —

On an aetiological myth about the Brahminy duck."

The Quarterly Journal of the Mythic Society. 2nd Series.

Vol. xvi. Oct. 1925. Bangalore. [VI, 71n3'.]
Mobius, P. J. Ueber die Wirkungen der Kastration. Halle.

1906. [Ill, 328.]

This forms Heft 3 and 4 of Beitr'dge zur Lehre den Geschlechts-Unterschieden,
Halle, 1903-1906.

Modi, J. J. " A few Ancient Beliefs about the Eclipse and

a Few Superstitions based on those Beliefs." Journ.

Anth. Soc. Bombay. Vol. iii. No. 6. 1894. Pp. 346-360.

[II, 82, 83.]
Modigliani, E. Un viaggio a Nias. . . . Illustrato da . . ,

incisioni . . . e . . . carte geografiche . . . Milano. 1890.

[Ill, 314, 314w5.]
Moliere. Amphitryon. [Ill, 127.] (Euvres de Moliere.

Nouvelle edition . . . par MM. Eugene Despois (et Paul

Mesnard). 13 vols, and album. Paris. 1873-1900. [V, 89W1.]
Mollison, J. A Text-Book on Indian Agriculture. Vol. iii,

Field and Garden Crops of the Bombay Presidency. Bombay.

1910. [VIII, 318W1.]
Moltke, H. See under Rasmussen, K.
Monardes, Nicolo. See under Briganti, A. ; and also under

Colin, Antoine, where the name is spelt " Monard."
Moncelon, L. " Metis de Francais et de Neo-Cal6donien."

Bulletins de la Societe d? Anthropologic de Paris. 3rd

278 THE OCEAN OF STORY

Series. Vol. ix. Paris. 1886. Pp. 10-16. The Discussion
extends to p. 19. See also pp. 345-380. [IT, 306n\]
Monier-Williams, Monier. See under both Williams,
Monier, and Williams, Monier Monier-.

He adopted his Christian name of Monier as an additional surname after
he had been made a K.C.I.E. in 1889.

Montaiglon, A. de. Recueil general et complet des Fabliaux
des XIIIe et XIVe siecles imprimis on inedits publics d'aprks
les Manuscrits par ... 6 vols. Paris. 1872-1890. [I, 44 ;
III, 76.]

Vols, ii-vi were edited by Montaiglon and G. Raynaud.

Montaiglon, A. de. See under Brunet, C.

Montaigne, Michel de. Essays. [VII, 232w2.]

Monteiro, H. See under Pedroso, Consiglieri.

Mookerji, Radhakumud. Harsha. (Calcutta University-
Readership Lectures, 1925.) "Rulers of India" Series.
Ldn. 1926. [VII, 237W1.]

Moore, Thomas. The Epicurean. Ldn. 1827. [II, Qn2.]

Moreno, N. La versione or aba de Kalilah e Dimnah. San
Remo. 1910. [V, 237.]

Morga, Antonio de. See under Stanley, H. E. J.

Morgan, C. Lloyd. " Laughter." Hastings' Ency. Rel. Eth.
Vol. vii. 1914. Pp. 803-805. [VII, 253W1.]

Morier, James. The Adventures of Haji Baba of Ispahan.
Edited by C. J. Wills, M.D., with an Introduction by
Major-General Sir Frederic Goldsmid, C.B., K. C.S.I. Ldn.
1897. [I, 214.]

Morin, H. See under Leber, C. . . .

Morley, Henry. See under Ramaswami Raju, P. V., and
Wilkins, C, Fables . . .

Morlini. Novella? fabulo3 et comedian. [Ill, 76 ; V, 186w2.]

First printed in 1520. See the Bibliotheque Elzevirienne edited by Jannet,
1855.

Morris, Max. Die Me?itawai-Sprache. Berlin. 1900. [VIII,

231n7.]
Morris, R. " Jataka Stories — The Myth of the Sirens."

The Academy. 27th August 1881. No. 486. P. 161. [IV,

229n2 ; VI, 282n\]
Morse, J. A Report to the Secretary of War of the United

States, on Indian Affairs, comprising a Narrative of a

Tour . . . in 1820 . . . for the Purpose of ascertaining

. . . the Actual State of the Indian Tribes in our Country.

New Haven. 1822. [IV, 258.]

BIBLIOGRAPHY 279

Moschus. Idylls. [VIII, 99n2.]

Moseley, H. N. " On the Inhabitants of the Admiralty-
Islands, etc." Journ. Anthrop. Inst. Vol. vi. 1877.
Pp. 379-420. The Discussion and an additional note
stretches to p. 426. [VIII, 253w3.]

Moutier, Ignazio. Opere Volgari di Giovanni Boccaccio
Correite su i Testi a Pcnna. Edited by ... 17 vols.
Florence. 1827-1834. [VII, 203n7.]

Mufaddal ibn Salama, al-. The Fdkhir. [VI, 62, 63 ;

VII, 225.]

A celebrated collection of proverbs.

Muhassin ibn 4Ali at-Tanukhi. Al Faraj ba'da'sh-shiddah
(Joy after Hardship). Cairo. 1903-1904. (Text.) J. Uri
(q.v.) calls the book Post nubila Phoebus. [VI, 265w2.]

Muir, John. Original Sanskrit Texts on the Origin and
History of the People of India, collected, translated . . .
5 vols. Ldn. 1858-1872. [I, 56nl ; VII, 72ti2, 174 ;

VIII, 152W1.]

1. Caste. 2. Trans-Himalayan origin of the Hindus. ... 3. The Vedas ;
their origin, inspiration, authority. 4. Comparison of Vedic with later
representations of the principal deities. 5. Cosmogony, mythology, religious
ides ... in the Vedic Age.

Mukerji, T. N. See under Watt, George.

Mullenhoff, K. Sagen, Marchen und Lieder der Herzog-

thilmer (Schleswig) Holstein und Lauenburg. Kiel. 1845.

[I, 132.]
Muller, F. Max. The First Book [Second, Third and Fourth

Books] of the Hitopadesa: containing the Sanskrit Text

with Interlinear Transliteration, Grammatical Analysis,

and English Translation. 2 vols. Ldn. 1864, 1865. [V, 210.]
Muller, F. Max. Chips from a German Workshop. 4 vols.

Ldn. 1867-1875. [II, 251n\]
Muller, F. Max. " Comparative Mythology." Essay 1 of

Oxford Effays, contributed by Members of the University.

Oxford. 1856. Pp. 1-87. [II, 251n\]
Muller, F. Max. See also under Dubois, M. l'Abbe J.-A. ;

Gill, W. W. ; Rogers, T. ; Speyer, J. S., Gdtakamdld . . .
Muller, F. W. K. " Melanges — Aus dem Wakan Sansai

Dzuye." T'oung Pao. Archives pour servir a Vetude de

Vhistoire, des langues de la Geographic et de V ethnographic

de VAsie Orientate. . . . Edited by G. Schlegel and H.

Cordier. Vol. vi. Leyden. 1895. Pp. 65-73. [VIII, 231n8,

231n4.]
The present editor is P. Pelliot.

280 THE OCEAN OF STORY

Muixer, K. O. Geschichten hellenischer Stdmme und Stadte:

Orchomenos und der Minyer. Breslau. 1820-1824. [V, 257.]
Mullick, B. Essays on the Hindu Family in Bengal. Calcutta.

1882. [II, 163n.]
Mundy, Peter. See under Temple, R. C.
Munro, H. A. J. Lucretius. On the Nature of Things. With

an Introduction by J. D. Duff. Ldn. 1908. Bohn's

Classical Library. [I, 191.]
Murray, J. A. H. A New English Dictionary on Historical

Principles. Oxford. 1888 . [II, 269n4, 270 ; VIII, 34W1.]

Mus^eus. Hero and Leander. [VI, 204n3.]

Myers, C. S. " Disease and Medicine (Introductory and

Primitive)." Hastings' Ency. Eel. Eth. Vol. iv. 1911.

Pp. 723-731. [IX, 149.]
Myers, E. See under Lang, A. ; Leaf, W. ; Myers, E.
Naidu, M. P. The History of Professional Poisoners and

Coiners of India. Madras. 1912. [11,281.]
Nanjio, Bunyiu. A Catalogue of the Chinese Translation of

the Buddhist Tripitaka. Oxford. 1883. [IX, 145.]
Nanjundayya, H. V. The Ethnographical Survey of Mysore.

Nos. 1, 3, 11, 13, 17, 20 and 22. [Being pamphlets on

separate tribes or castes which practise the dedication of

basivis.] Bangalore. 1906-1911. [I, 258, 258nK]
Nares, Robert. A Glossary of Words, Phrases, Names and

Allusions in the Works of English Authors, particularly of

Shakespeare and his Contemporaries. New Edition, with

considerable additions by J. O. Halliwell and T. Wright.

Ldn. 1905. (1st edit. Ldn. 1822.) [Ill, 154.]
Nasr A1-Din. See under Arratoon.
Nassau, R. H. Fetichism in West Africa. Forty Years1

Observations of Native Customs and Superstitions. Ldn.

1904. [VIII, 227n9.]
Natesa Sastri. See under SastrI, Pandit S. M. Nate£a.
Nath, Bhola. Vikramavildsa. A metrical version of the

Baital-pachisi, or Tiventy-five Stories of King Vikramaditya.

By Bholanatha Chaube. Mainpuri. 1867. [VI, 226;

VII, 269.]
Naumann, Hans. Primitive Gemeinschaftskultur. Beitrdge

z. Volkskunde u. Mythologie. Jena. 1921. [VIII, 107n.]
Naumann, Hans ; and Ida. Isldndische Volksmarchen.

Jena. 1923. [IX, 142.]

Forming part of the " Die Marchen der Weltliteratur " Series.

Neale, F. A. Narrative of a Residence at the Capital of the
Kingdom of Siam ; zvith a description of the Manners,

BIBLIOGRAPHY 281

Customs, and Laws of the Modern Siamese. Ldn. 1852.

[VIII, 289ft2.]
" Neaniskos." See under [Burton, R. F., and Smithers, L.C.].
Nefzaoui. The Perfumed Garden. [I, 170.]

For details of the Kama Shastra Society editions see my Bibliography of
Sir Richard F. Burton, p. 173 et seq.

Negelein, Julius von. Der Traumschlussel des Jagaddeva.
Ein Beitrag zur indischen Mantik von ...

This forms the 4th part of vol. xi of :

Religionsgeschichtliche Versuche und Vorarbeiten begriindet
von A. Dieterich und R. Wunsch herausgegeben von
R. Wunsch und L. Deubner. . . . Giessen. 1911-1912.
[VIII, 100ft.]

Neil, R. A. See under Cowell, E. B.

Nesfield, J. C. Brief View of the Caste System of the North-
West Provinces and Oudh. Allahabad. 1885. [Ill, 100ft1.]

Newton, A. Dictionary of Birds. Ldn. 1893-1896. [I, 105 ;
VI, 183n2.]

Nicasi, G. " Le credenze religiose delle popolazioni rurali
dell' alta valle del Tevere." Lares. Bullettino delta Societd
di Etnografia Italiana. Vol. i. Roma. 1912. Pp. 137-176.
[II, lOSn.]

This periodical ceased issue in 1915 ; three vols, and fasc. i of vol. iv having
appeared.

Nicholson, R. A. A Literary History of the Arabs. The

Library of Literary History. Ldn. 1907. [Ill, 278 ; VI, 66.]
Nicolaides, J. Contes Licencieux de Constantinople et de

VAsie Mineure. Kleinbronn-Paris. [1906.] [Ill, 34n.]
Nicoll, W. R. See under Smith, G. A.
Nikitin, Athanasius. See under Major, R. H.
Nisbet, J. Burma under British Rule and Before. Ldn. 1901.

[II, 266ft1.]
Nonnus (of Panopolis). Dionysiaca. [VI, 18ft1.]
North, T. The M or all Philosophic of Doni : drawne out of

the auncient writers . . . and nozv lastly Englished out of

Italian by . . . Ldn. 1570. [V, 220.]
North, T. See under Jacobs, J.
Norton, Ruth. " The Life-Index : a Hindu Fiction Motif."

Studies in Honor of Maurice Bloomfield. New Haven,

Yale University Press. 1920. Pp. 211-224. [I, 130, 131,

167 ; III, 272ft1.]
Notthafft, A. von. " Die Legend e von der Altertums-

syphilis." Festschrift fur Georg Eduard von Rindfleisch.

. . . Leipzig. 1907. Pp. 377-592. [II, 308ft2.]

282 THE OCEAN OF STORY

O'Connor, W. F. T. Folk-Tales from Tibet. Ldn. 1907.

[I, 131 ; V, 49ft\ 64.]
Odoric of Pordenone. See under Yule, H., Cathay and

the Way Thither (vol. ii).
Oesterley, H. Gesta Eomanorum. Berlin. 1872. [I, 171 ;

VI, 262ft1.]
Oesterley, H. Baitdl Pachisi oder die funfundzwanzig

Erzdhlungen eines Damon. In deutscher Bearbeitang mit

Einleitung, Anmerkungen und Nachweisen von . . .

Bibliothek Oriental ischer Marchen und Erzahlungen . . .

Leipzig. 1873. [Ill, 204 ; VI, 226, 227, 227ft2, 240, 269,

272, 273ft6 ; VII, 213, 241ft4, 250 ; IX, 47ft3.]
Oesterley, H. lohannis de Alta Silva Dolopathos sive de

Rege et Septem Sapientibus. Strassburg. Ldn. 1873.

[V,'261, 261 ft1.]
Okamura, T. " Zur Geschicbte der Syphilis in China und

Japan." Monatshefte fur Praktische Dermatologie. Vol.

xxviii. No. 6. Hamburg. 1899. Pp. 295-304. [II, 308ft2.]
Olbers, E. G. F. Nionde och tionde sangerna af Nala och

Damayantl, fran Sanskrit bfversatte och kommenterade.

Akademisk afhandlung. Lund. 1862. [IV, 292.]
Oldenberg, H. Buddha: His Life, Doctrine and Order.

Translated bv W. Hoev (from the 1881 edit.). Ldn. 1882.

[VIII, 125ft1."]
Oldenberg, H. The Grihya-Siitras. Rules of Vedic Domestic

Ceremonies. Translated by . . . Sacred Books of the

East. Vols, xxix, xxx. Oxford. 1886, 1892. [II, 267,

267ft1.]
Oldenberg, H. Die Religion des Veda. Berlin. 1894. [II,

252ft1.]
Oldenberg, H. Die Literatur des alten Indien. Berlin.

1903. [II, 252W1.]
Oldham, C. F. " The Nagas. A Contribution to the History

of Serpent Worship." Journ. Roy. As. Soc. July 1901.

Pp. 461-473. With seven illustrations. [II, 307ft2 ; VII,

236ft1.]
Olesen, Elof. See under Sorensen, S.
Oliver, Pasfield. The Voyage of Francois Leguat of Br esse

Rodriguez, Mauritius, Java, and the Cape of Good Hope.

Transcribed from the First English Edition. Edited and

Annotated by ... 2 vols. Hakluyt Society. Ldn. 1891

(continuous pagination). [VIII, 295ft1.]

These volumes form Nos. lxXxii and lxxxiii of the First Series.

BIBLIOGRAPHY 283

O'Malley, L. S. S. Bengal District Gazetteers — Puri. Calcutta.
1908. [I, 24>2n\]

Oman, J. C. The Mystics, Ascetics, and Saints of India. A
Study of Sadhuism, with an Account of the Yogis, Sanyasis,
Bairagis, and other strange Hindu Sectarians. . . . Ldn.
1903. [I, 79n*.]

Oman, J. C. The Brahmans, Theists and Muslims of India.
Studies of Goddess-worship in Bengal, Caste, Brahmanism
and Social Reform, with descriptive Sketches of curious
Festivals, Ceremonies, and Faquirs. Ldn. 1907. [IV, 272.]

Oppert, G. On the Weapons, Army Organisation and Political
Maxims of the Ancient Hindus, with special reference to
Gunpowder and Firearms. Madras. 1880. [I, 109nx.]

Orbigny, A. d'. U Homme Americain (de VAmerique Meri-
dionale), consider e sous ses Rapports Physiologiques et
Moraux. 2 vols. Paris. 1839. [Ill, 314, 314n5.]

Orta, Garcia da. Coloquios dos simples, e drogas he cousas
mediginais da India, e assi dalguas frutas- achadas nella
onde se tratam alguas cousas tocantes amedigina, pratica, e
outras cousas boas, pera saber copostos pello Doutor gargia
dorta: fisico del Rey nosso senhor, vistos pello muyto
Reverendo senhor, ho ligengiado Alexos diaz : falcam
desenbargador da casa da supricaga inquisidor nestas partes.
Impresso em Goa, por Ioannes de endem as x dias Abril
de 1563 annos. [VIII, 240rc1.]

Orta, Garcia da. See also under Colin, Antoine ; Ficalho,
Conde de ; L'E(s)cluse, Charles de ; Markham,
Clements ; Varnhagen, F. A. de.

O'Sullivan, A. W. S. See under Hurgronje, C. Snouck.

Ouseley, J. W. J. Anvar-i Suheli ; or, Lights of Canopus. . . .
Hertford. 1851. [V, 239.]

" Outidanos." See under [Burton, R. F., and Smithers,
L. C.].

Overbeck, H. " Malay Customs and Beliefs as recorded
in Malay Literature and Folklore." Journal Malayan
Branch Roy. As. Soc. Singapore. (1) Vol. ii, pt. iii,
1924, pp. 280-288. (2) Vol. iii, pt. i, 1925, pp. 53-57.
(3) Vol. iii, pt. iii, 1925, pp. 22-30. [VIII, 253.]

Previous to 1923 the above periodical was known as Journal Straits Branch
Roy. As. Soc.

Ovid. Ars Amatoria. [II, 263.] Fasti. [II, 263 ; V, 68n ;
VIII, 114nx.] Heroides. [VI, 24n ; VIII, 99n2.] Meta-
morphoses. [I, 84w2 ; III, 188w, lOln1, 230w3 ; V, 29n2 ;

284 THE OCEAN OF STORY

VI, 26ft3, 282n3 ; VII, 227ft2, 228m1, 228ft2 ; VIII, 69ft1,

149ft2 ; IX, 143.] See also under Miller, F. J.
Padfield, J. E. The Hindu at Homey Being Sketches of

Hindu Daily Life. Madras. 1896. [VI, 59.]
Painter, William. See under Jacobs, J.
Palmer, A. S. Folk Etymology. Ldn. 1882. [Ill, 154.]
Pantulu, G. R. Subramiah. " Some Notes on the Folklore

of the Telugus." Indian Antiquary. Vols, xxvi, 1897,

pp. 25, 55, 109, 137, 167, 223, 252 and 304 ; xxviii, 1899,

p. 155 ; xxxii, 1903, p. 275.

The above collection totalled forty-three fables. They appeared in book

form as :

Folklore of the Telugus. Madras. 1905. (3rd edit.)

[V, 48ft1, 49ft1, 56ft1, 59n2 ; IX, 163.]
Panzer, Friedrich. Studien zur Germanischen Sagen-

geschichte. I— Beowulf. Munchen. 1911. [VII, 126ft2.]

ll—Sigfrid. Munchen. 1912. [VIII, 107ft.]
Panzer, G. W. Annates Typographici ab Artis Inventce Origine

ad Annum MD. 5 vols. Nuremberg. 1793. [IX, 150.]
The work was extended to cover the period to 1536 by an additional 6 vols.

issued in 1803.

Parabosco, G. J diporti. Venetia. 1552. [IX, 144.]
Paris, Gaston. Deux Redactions du Roman des Sept Sages

de Rome. Societe des Anciens Textes Francaise. Paris.

1876. [V, 263, 266ft1.]
Paris, G. " Die undankbare Gattin." Zeitschrift des Vereins

fiir Volkskunde. Begriindet von Karl Weinhold. Im

Auftrage des Vereins herausgegeben von Johannes Bolte.

Vol. xiii. Berlin. 1903. Pp. 1-24. [VIII, 117ft2.]
Paris, G. " Le Conte du Tresor du Roi Rhampsinite."

Revue de VHistoire des Religions. Vol. lv. 1907. Pp. 151-

187, 267-316. Annales du Musee Guimet. [V, 255.]
Paris, Matteueus. Monachi Albanensis, Angli, Historia

Maior, a Guilielmo Conquo3store, ad vltimum annum

Henrici tertii. Ldn. 1571. [V, 157ft1.]
Paris, Paulin. Les romans de la Table Ronde mis en nouveau

langage. 5 vols. Paris. 1868-1877. [IX, 142.]
Parker, E. H. " Some New Facts about Marco Polo's

Book." The Imperial and Asiatic Quarterly Review. . . .

3rd Series. Vol. xvii. Woking. Jan.-April 1904. Pp. 125-

149. [I, 214.]
Parker, H. Village Folk-Tales of Ceylon. 3 vols. Ldn.

1910-1914. [I, 157ft2, 223, 226, 227; III, 76, 272ft1;

V, 48ft1, 49ft1, 52ft2, 55ft3, 63ft1, 65.]

BIBLIOGRAPHY 285

Parker, K. L. Australian Legendary Tales. Folk-Lore of the

Noongahburrahs as told to the piccaninnies. Collected

by ... , with Introduction by Andrew Lang, illustrations

by a Native Artist, and a Specimen of the Native Text.

Ldn. 1896. [VIII, 232n6.]
Pascha, Rieder. See under Souby-Bey.
Patil, P. C. " The Crops of the Bombay Presidency, their

Geography and Statistics." Bombay Dept. Agriculture

Bulletin. No. 109 of 1921. Bombay. 1922. [VIII, 318711.]
Paton, J. L. " Gambling." Hastings' Ency. Bel. Eth.

Vol. vi. 1913. Pp. 163-167. [II, 232n.]
Paton, L. B. " Ashtart (Ashtoreth), Astarte." Hastings'

Ency. Bel. Eth. Vol. ii. 1909. Pp. 115-118. [VII, 231w5.]
Paton, L. B. " Atargatis." Hastings' Ency. Bel. Eth.

Vol. ii. 1909. Pp. 164-167. [I, 275, 275n2.]
Paton, L. B. " Ishtar." Hastings' Ency. Bel. Eth. Vol. vii.

1914. Pp. 428-434. [I, 273n3 ; VII, 231w5.]
Pauli, J. Schimpf und Ernst, hrsg. v. Johannes Bolte. 2 vols.

Berlin. 1924. [IX, 148.]
Paull, H. H. B. Grimm's Fairy Tales. A new translation.

By . . ., with . . . illustrations by W. J. Weigand. Ldn.

Guildford [printed, 1872]. [I, 25.]
Peacock, Edward. " Sunwise Processions." Folk-Lore.

Vol. xi. 1900. P. 220. [Ill, 295w2.]
Pedroso, Consiglieri. Portuguese Folk-Tales collected

by . . . and Translated from the Original MS. by Miss

Henriqueta Monteiro. With an Introduction by W. B. S.

Balston, M.A. Folk-Lore Society. Pub. No. ix. Ldn.

1882. [I, 27.]
The above work consists of thirty stories out of a total of five hundred

collected by Prof. Pedroso.

Pegolotti. See under Yule, H., Cathay and the Way

Thither.
Pelle, J. Notes on the Nalopdkhydnam, or Tale of Nala.

University Press, Cambridge. 1881. [IV, 292.]
Petser, F. E. See under Kohler, J. ; Peiser, F. E. ; and

Ungnad, A.
Pelliot, P. See under Muller, F. W. K.
Penzer, N. M. The Mineral Besources of Burma. With an

Introduction by Col. O. C. Armstrong, D.S.O., Federation

of British Industries, Intelligence Department. Ldn.

1922. [VIII, 65W1.]
Penzer, N. M. An Annotated Bibliography of Sir Bichard

Francis Burton, K.C.M.G. Preface by F. Grenfell Baker,

286 THE OCEAN OF STORY

M.R.C.S., L.R.C.P., etc. . . . Ldn. 1923. [I, 234n2, 236n3 ;

II, lOn; V, 193; VI, 227m1.]
Penzer, N. M. Selected Papers on Anthropology, Travel &

Exploration by Sir Richard Burton, K.C.M.G. Now Edited

with an Introduction and Occasional Notes by . . . Ldn.

1924. [I, 109W1, 217.]
Penzer, N. M. Nala & Damayanti. Illustrated with ten

miniatures by P. Zenker. Ldn. 1926. [IX, 155.]

This work was printed on Japanese vellum and limited to 1000 copies for
England and America.

Perceforest. La Treselegante, Delicieuse, Mellijlue et
tresplaisante Hystoire du tresnoble, victorieux et excellent-
issime roy Perceforest, Roy de la grande Bretaigne, fundateur
du Franc palais et du temple du souverain dieu. . . . [1,165.]

The Brit. Mus. library possesses two imperfect copies of the 6-vol. Paris,
1528, edition, and three imperfect copies of the 6-vol. Paris, 1531, edition.

Percy, Thomas. Reliques of Ancient English Poetry : con-
sisting of Old Heroic Ballads, Songs, and other Pieces of our
Earlier Poets . . . together with some few of a Later Date.
[Edited by ... ] Ldn. 1765. [I, 165 ; II, lOn.]

Pergamenus, Nicolaus. See under Grasse, J. G. T.

Perham, John. See under Gomes, E. H.

Perrault, Charles. La Barbe Bleue. [II, 223ft1.] Le Petit
Poucet. [Ill, 105w.] See further under Saintyves, P.

Pertz, G. H. Monumenta Germanice Historica inde ab Anno
Christi Qvingentesimo vsqve ad Annvm Millesimvm et
Qvingentesimvm . . . edidit . . . Vol. v. Hannover. 1839.
(I.e. Scriptorum, Tomus iii.) Thietmari Chronicon. V. CI.
Joh. M. Lappenberg, I.U.D. Pp. 723-871. [IV, 255r*2.]

The reference to widow-burning occurs in Lib. viii, 2, p. 861.

Peterson, P. The Hitopadesa of Ndrdyana. Edited by . . .

Bombay Sanskrit Series. No. 33. Bombay. 1887. [V, 210.]
Peterson, P. See under Buhler, J. G., and Peterson, P.
Petis de la Croix, F. See under Croix, F. Petis de la.
Petit6t, E. Traditions Indiennes du Canada Nord-Ouest.

Textes Originaux et Traduction Litter ale. Alencon. 1887.

[Ill, 205.]
Petrie, W. M. Flinders. " Assyrian and Hittite Society."

Ancient Egypt. Pt. i. March 1924. Pp. 18-28. [II, 88ft1.]
Petrus Alfonsus. Disciplina Clericalis. [I, 169.] See

further under Hulme, W. H.
Pez, Hieronymus. Scriptores Rerum Austriacarum veteres ac

genuini . . . Edidit et . . . Notis Observationibus et Anim-

BIBLIOGRAPHY 287

adversionibus illustravit ... 3 vols. Vienna. Ratisbonae.

1743-1745. [II, 310, 310W1.]
Pfor or Pforr, Anthonius von. Buck der Beispiele der

alten Weisen. Circa 1480. [V, 220.]
Phledrus. Fables. [V, 61n3, 102w2.]
Phillips, J. C. A Natural History of the Ducks. Ldn. 1923.

[VI, 71n3.]
Philostratus. See under Apollonius of Tyana, and

CONYBEARE, F. C.

Phlegon of Tralles. Mirabilia. [VII, 227n2.]

Phylarchus. Historia. [VII, 207.]

Physiologus. See under Carlill, James.

Pieris, H. A. " Sinhalese Folklore : The Fox and the

Tortoise." The Orientalist. Vol. i. Kandy, Ceylon. 1884.

Pp. 134-135. [V, 55w3.]
Pierret, P. Dictionnaire oV Archeologie egyptienne. Paris.

1875. [I, 215.]
P[ierrugues], P[ierre]. Glossarium Eroticum Linguce

Latinos, sive Theogonice, Legum et Morum Nuptialium

apud Romanos Explanatio Nova. . . . Parisiis. 1826.

[Ill, 328.]
Pietro della Valle. Travels. [II, 162w ; III, 85 n.] See

further under Grey, Edward.
Pinches, T. G. " Tammuz." Hastings' Ency. Bel. Eth.

Vol. xii. 1921. Pp. 187-191. [I, 273n3.]
Pincott, F. The Prema-Sdgara or Ocean of Love. Being a

Literal Translation of the Hindi text of Lallii Lai Kavi as

edited by the late Professor Eastwick, fully Annotated and

explained grammatically, idiomatically and exegetically by

. . . Westminster. 1897. [VIII, 214ft1.]
Pio, J. Contes populaires grecs. Copenhagen. 1879. [VI,

292ft1.]
" Pioneer." " Garhwal — Himalayas — Badrinath — Kidar-

nath — Object of Pilgrimage." Indian Notes and Queries.

Vol. iv. Allahabad. August 1887. P. 196. [IV, 160ft.]

The title of the first three volumes of this periodical was Panjab Notes and
Queries.

Pischel, R., and Geldner, K. F. Vedische Studien. 3 vols.

(usually bound in 2). Stuttgart. 1889-1901. [I, 232ft1 ;

II, 252W1 ; VI, 3W1.]
Pisharoti, A. K. and K. R. " Bhasa's Works, Are they

Genuine ? " Bull. Sch. Orient. Stud. Vol. iii. 1923.

Pp. 107-117. [II, 21nx.]

288 THE OCEAN OF STORY

Pisharoti, K. Rama. " Bhasa's Svapna Vasavadatta." The
Quarterly Journal of the Mythic Society. Bangalore. Vol. x,
1920, pp. 164-174, 209-220, 372-387; and vol. xi, 1921,
pp. 122-137. [II, 21n\]

Plancy, J. A. S. C. de. See under Collin de Plancy, J. A. S.

Plato. Minos. [IV, 65 n.]

Plautus. Amphitruo. [Ill, 127.] Curculio. [I, 190.]
Pseudolus. [V, 201n.] Stichus. [IV, 138ft1.]

Pleyte, C. M. Bataksche Vertellingen. Utrecht. 1894.
[VIII, 23ln«.]

The collection contains twenty-eight tales, the first five of which are the
most important.

Pliny. The Natural History of . . . Translated with Copious

Notes and Illustrations by the late John Bostock, M.D.,

F.R.S., and H. T. Riley, Esq., B.A. . . . Bohn's Classical

Library. 6 vols. Ldn. 1855-1856. [I, 103, 222 ; II, 108rc,

296, 300 ; III, 112ft1, 116ft, Slln1 ; VII, 232 ; VIII, 114m1.]
Ploss, H. Das Kind in Brauch und Sitte der Volker. Anthro-

pologische Studien. 2nd edit. 2 vols. Leipzig. 1884.

[Ill, 328.]
Ploss, H. Das Weib in der Natur- und Volkerkunde. Anthro-

pologische Studien. 3rd revised and enlarged edition.

(Edited, after the author's death, by M. Bartels.) Leipzig.

1891. [II, 306ft1.]
Plutarch. Consolatio ad Apollonium. [V, 257.] Isis et

Osiris. [V, 252.] Life of Agis. [V, 135ft.] Life of Camillus.

[I, 190.] Life of Marcellus. JV, 64.]
Polivka, G. Le Chat Botte : Etude comparee. Sophia. 1900.

[VI, 291ft1.]
Polivka, G. See under Bolte, J., and Polivka, G.
Polo, Marco. See under Marsden, W., and Yule, H.
Poole, E. S. See under Lane, E. W.
Poole, W. F. Index to Periodical Literature. New York and

Boston. 1853, etc. [II, 272.]

From 1882 W. I. Fletcher and others assisted in the editing.

Post, G. E. " Algum Trees, Almug Trees." Hastings'

Dictionary of the Bible. Vol. i. 1900. P. 63. [VII, 106.]
Postgate, J. P. " A Philological Examination of the Myth of

the Sirens." Journ. Phil. Vol. ix. London and Cambridge.

1880. Pp. 109-113. [VI, 282ft6.]
Poucher, W. A. Perfumes and Cosmetics, with especial

reference to synthetics. Ldn. 1923. (2nd edit. 1925.) [I,

218.]

BIBLIOGRAPHY 289

Poussin, L. de la Vallee. " Bodhisattva ( in Sanskrit

literature)." Hastings' Ency. Rel. Eth. Vol. ii. 1909.

Pp. 739-753. [Ill, 253ft.]
Poussin, L. de la Vallee. " Karma." Hastings' Ency.

Rel. Eth. Vol. vii. 1914. Pp. 673-676. [IV, 182.]
Poussin, L. de la Vallee. " Tantrism (Buddhist)."

Hastings' Ency. Rel. Eth. Vol. xii. 1921. Pp. 193-197.

[VI, 52n.]
Powell, F. York. See under Elton, O.
Powell, G. E. J. See under Arnason, J6n.
Powell, J. W. See under Boas, Franz.
Powlett, P. W. " Satti Worship in Rajputana." North

Indian Notes and Queries. Vol. ii. Allahabad. March 1893.

P. 199. [IV, 272.]
Preller, L. Griechische Mythologie. 2 vols. Leipzig. 1854.

(3rd edit. 1872-1875; 4th edit. 1887-1894.) [II, 13ft4;

IV, 65 ft, 230ft2, 245ft1; V, 67ft2; VI, 18ft1; VII, 3ft2 ;

VIII, 154ft2 ; IX, 29n1.]
Preller, L. Romische Mythologie. Berlin. 1858. (2nd edit.

1865.) [Ill, 133ft1 ; IV, 65ft ; VIII, 69m1, 156ft1.]
Preller, L. See also under Ritter, A. H., and Preller, L.
Prescott, W. History of the Conquest of Mexico, with a

Preliminary View of the Ancient Mexican Civilization and

the Life of Hernando Cortes. 3 vols. Ldn. 1843. [1,116ft1.]
Prescott, W. H. History of the Conquest of Peru, with a

Preliminary View of the Civilization of the Incas. 2 vols.

Ldn. 1847. [II, 88ft1.]
Prior, Matthew. The Ladle. [I, 27.] Les Quatre Souhaits

de Saint Martin. [I, 27.]
Procopius. Bellum Gothicum. [IV, 255.]
Prohle, H. Kinder- und Volksmarchen gesammelt von . . .

Leipzig. 1853. [I, 25.]
Propertius. Elegies. [Ill, 311ft3.]
Prym, E., and Socin, A. Der neuaramaeische Dialekt des

Tur 'Abdin. 2 vols. Gottingen. 1881.

Vol. ii contains a second title-page :

Syrische Sagen und Maerchen aus dem Volksmunde . . .
[I, 26, 97ft2, 125ft3 ; II, 76ft1, 155ft4, 219ft3 ; III, 191ft1,
231ft1 ; IV, 128ft1, 132ft1, 213ft1 ; V, 3ft1, 91ft1, 102ft2, 130ft1 ;
VI, 28ft2, 73ft2, 118ft1, 154ft3, 280; VII, 81ft1; VIII, 57ft2.]

It is important to quote both title-pages as given above. Tawney gave only
the second one. The British Museum, on the other hand, catalogues only the
first one (at least that was the case when I pointed out the omission in 1926)-

VOL. IX. T

290 THE OCEAN OF STORY

Przyluski, J. "La L£gende de l'Empereur A^ka (Acoka-

Avadana) dans les Textes Indiens et Chinois." Annates

du Musee Guimet. Bibliotheque d? Etudes. Tom. xxxii.

Paris. 1923. Pp. 1-222. [II, 120.]
Przyluski, J. " Emprunts Anaryens en Indo- Aryan."

Bulletin de la Societe de Linguistique de Paris. Vol. xxiv.

3rd Fasc. (No. 75.) 1924. Pp. 255-258. [VIII, 239, 239n2.]
Przyluski, J. " Le Prologue — Cadre des Mille et Une Nuits

et le Theme du Svayamvara." Journal Asiatique. Juillet-

Sept. 1924. Pp. 101-137. [IX, 161.]
Puntoni, V. Directorium humanoz vita?, alias parabola?

antiquorum sapientum . . . Pisa. 1884. [V, 237.]
Puntoni, V. Hre^avlr^ Kai 'I-^vrjXdr^ : quattro recensioni

delta versione greca. . . . Roma — Firenze — Torino. 1889.

[V, 238.]
Pyrard, Francois. See under Gray, Albert.
Quatremere, E. M. Histoire des Sultans Mamlouks de

VEgypte, ecrite en arabe par Taki-Eddin- Ahmed- Makrizi,

traduite en Frangais . . . par ... 2 vols. Paris. 1837,

1842. Oriental Translation Fund of Great Britain and

Ireland. [Ill, 329.]
Qutaiba, Ibn. See under Ibn Qutaiba.
Rabelais. Gargantua. [Ill, 34w.] Pantagruel. [132n2, 133w.]
Radiguet, M. Les Derniers Sauvages ; le Vie et les Mceurs

aux lies Marquises. New Edition. Paris. 1881. (1st edit.

1861.) [Ill, 314, 314w6.]
Radloff, W. Die Sprachen der Tiirkischen Stamme Sud-

Sibiriens und der Dsungarischen Steppe. [With a Preface

by A. Schiefner.] 6 vols. St Petersburg. 1866-1886.

[VII, 204 ; VIII, 107rc, 228n2.]

The title-page of Abth. i reads : Proben der Volkslitteratur der Tiirkischen
Stamme. . . . That of Abth. v changes to : Die Sprachen Nordlichen Tiirk-
ischen Stamme. The Brit. Mus. catalogues the author's name as Radio v,
Vasily Vasil'evich.

Rai Bahadur Hira Lal. See under Lal, R. B. H.

Raju, Ramaswami. See under Ramaswami Raju, P. V.

Ralston, W. R. S. The Songs of the Russian People, as
illustrative of Slavonic Mythology and Russian Social Life.
Ldn. 1872. [I, 191 ; II, 138n4, 189W1 ; IV, 255w2.]

Ralston, W. R. S. Russian Folk-Tales. Ldn. 1873.
[I, 26, S2nl, 104, 108711, 129, 132, 136n2 ; II, 60n2, 61m1,
7ln\ 98n4, 122, 152n\ 155rc4, 190W1, 202n\ 223W1 ; III, 4nJ,
30n\ S2n\ 187n3, 204, 222n\ 225n2, 231n\ 238, 253n\
268n*; IV, 145n2, 230w2 ; V, 82w2, 166nS 170m1, 183ft1 ;

BIBLIOGRAPHY 291

VI, 15n3, 28w2, 56ns 72W1, 73n2, 73w3, 136, 170w2, 280;
VIII, 56W1, 227n5 ; IX, 37W1.]
Ralston, W. R. S. Tibetan Tales derived from Indian
Sources. Translated from the Tibetan of the Kah-Gyur by
F. Anton von Schiefner. Done into English from the German,
with an Introduction, by . . . Ldn. 1882. [I, 97n2, 223,
226 ; II, 14w, 76W1, 122 ; III, 50W1, 51w, 115711, 180, 181,
188w ; V, 63W1, 64, 153W1, 157m1, 285 ; VI, 16rc ; VII,
162W1 ; VIII, 69n\ 83m1, 125nx, 228nx ; IX, 82nx.]
The volume forms part of " Triibner's Oriental Series."

Ralston, W. R. S. See also under Pedroso, Consiglieri ;
Stokes, Maive.

Raman atha Ayyar, A. S. " The Authorship of the Nalo-
daya." Journ. Roy. As. Soc. April 1925. Pp. 263-275.
[IV, 277.]

Ramaswami Raju, P. V. The Tales of the Sixty Mandarins
. . . with an Introduction by Prof. H. Morley. London
and New York. [1886.] [I, 131.]

Ramaswami Raju, P. V. Indian Fables. Ldn. 1887. (2nd
edit. 1901.) [V, 48nx, 49W1, 65.]

Rambaud, A. N. La Russie epique. Etude sur les chansons
hero'iques de la Russie, traduites ou analysees -pour la
premiere fois, par . . . Paris. 1876. [VII, 189w2.]

Ramstedt, G. J. Kalmuckische Sprachproben gesammelt
und herausgegeben von . . . Erster Teil. Kalmuckische
Marchen I. Suomalais-Ugrilaisen Seuran Toimituksia,
xxvii, 1 . ( Memoir es de la Societe Finno-Ougrienne, xxvii, 1 . )
Helsingfors. 1909. [VIII, 228n3.]

Ranft, M. Tractat von dem Kauen und Schmatzen der
Todten in Grabern, worin die wahre Beschaffenheit derer
Hungarischen Vampyrs . . . gezeigt . . . Leipzig. 1734.
[VI, 140.]

Rangachari, K. See under Thurston, Edgar.

Rang as w ami Iyengar. See under Iyengar, K. Rangaswami.

Rannie, Douglas. My Adventures among South Sea Canni-
bals. An Account of the Experiences and Adventures of a
Government Official among the Natives of Oceania. Ldn.
1912. [VIII, 310, 310n2.]

Rapson, E. J. Catalogue of the Indian Coins in the British
Museum. Ldn. 1908. [I, 64n2.]

Rapson, E. J. " Indian Native States after the Period of
the Maury a Empire." The Cambridge History of India.
Vol. i. Cambridge. 1922. Pp. 514-539. [VI, 230.]

292 THE OCEAN OF STORY

RashIduddin. See under Yule, H., Cathay and the Way

Thither.
Rasmussen, K. Nye Memesker Med Tegninger of H. Moltke.

Copenhagen and Christiania. 1905. [VIII, 228w9.]
Rasmussen, K. Gronlandska Myter och Sagor med Kultur-

historisk Inledning. Stockholm. 1926. [VIII, 228w10.]
The above work forms one of the " Myter och Sagor " Series.

Rassmann, A. Die deutsche Heldensage und ihre Heimat.
2 vols. Hannover. 1857, 1858. [IX, 144.]

Rauscher, Hieronymus. Das ander Hundert der ausser-
weltengrossen unverschemptenfeisten wolgemesten ersiuncknen
Papistischen Liigen . . . Laugingen. 1564. [II, 296.]

Rawlinson, G. History of Herodotus . . . assisted by Major-
General Sir Henry Rawlinson, K.C.B., and Sir J. G.
Wilkinson, F.R.S. 4th edit. 4 vols. Ldn. 1880. [V, 245m1,
253.]

Rawlinson, G. History of Ancient Egypt. 2 vols. Ldn.
1881. [Ill, 329.]

Rawlinson, H. G. Rds Mala . . . Hindoo Annals of the
Province of Goozerat in Western India. By A lexander Kinloch
Forbes. . . . Edited, with Historical Notes and Appendices,
by . . . with the original illustrations. 2 vols. Oxford Univ.
Press, Ldn. 1924. [II, 266, 266/13, 305^ ; III, 86n\ 322.]

Razi. The 'Mafatih al-ghaib (Qur'an commentary). [VI,
64, 66.]

Rehatsek, E. Amusing Stories, from the Persian. Bombay.
1871. [Ill, 118W1.]

Remondino, P. C. History of Circumcision from the Earliest
Times to the Present. Philadelphia and London. 1891.
[Ill, 328.]

Rhys, John. Lectures on the Origin and Growth of Religion
as illustrated by Celtic Heathendom. The Hibbert Lectures,
1886. London and Edinburgh. 1888. [VIII, 107n.]

Richet, Charles. " Les Poisons de L'Intelligence — ii."
(Hashish, Opium and Coffee.) Revue des Deux Mondes,
xlvii0 Annee, Troisieme Periode, 1st Mars. Vol. xx. 1877.
Pp. 178-197. [VII, 248.]

The first article was on alcohol and chloroform, and appeared on 15th Feb.
1877, pp. 816-840.

Ridding, C. M. The Kadambari of Bdna. Translated, with
Occasional Omissions, and accompanied by a Full Abstract
of the Continuation of the Romance by the Author's son
Bhushanabhatta, by . . . Royal Asiatic Society, Oriental
Translation Fund. New Series, II. Ldn. 1896. [V, 39.]

BIBLIOGRAPHY 293

Ridley, H. N. Spices. Ldn. 1912. [VIII, 18, 96ft2, 247.]

The spices dealt with are Vanilla, Nutmegs and Mace, Cloves, Pimento or
Allspice, Cinnamon, Cassia and Massoi Bark, Peppers, Cardamoms, Capsicums
or Chillies, Coriander, Dill, Cumin, Ginger, Turmeric, Zedoary, Galangal and
Calamus Root.

Ridley, H. N. The Flora of the Malay Peninsula. With

Illustrations by J. Hutchinson, F.L.S. 5 vols. Ldn. 1922-

1925. [VIII, 290, 290ft1.]
Rieger, C. Kastration in rechtlicher socialer und vitaler

Hinsicht. Jena. 1911. [Not seen personally.] [Ill, 328.]
Riess, E. " Alchemy (Greek and Roman)." Hastings' Ency.

Rel. Eth. Vol. i. 1908. Pp. 287-289. [Ill, 162w.]
Rieu, Charles. Catalogue of the Persian Manuscripts in

the British Museum. 3 vols. Ldn. 1879, 1881 and 1883.

[V, 239.]
This was followed by :

Supplement to the Catalogue of the Persian Manuscripts in
the British Museum. Ldn. 1895.
Riggs, J. M. The Decameron of Giovanni Boccaccio. Faith-
fully Translated by . . . With Illustrations by Louis
Chalon. 2 vols. Ldn. 1906. [I, 148ft.]

For other references to the Decameron see under Boccaccio, G.

Riley, H. T. See under Pliny.

Rink, H. Tales and Traditions of the Eskimo ; with a Sketch

of their Habits, Religion, Language, and other Peculiarities.

Translated from the Danish by the Author ; edited by Dr

Robert Brown. Edinburgh, London. 1875. [VIII, 228ft9.]
Risley, H. H. The Tribes and Castes of Bengal. 4 vols.

Calcutta. 1891. [I, 243ft2; II, 24ft, 167, 229ft2; VIII,

271ft1.]

The above volumes are divided up into two divisions each of two volumes.

The first is the " Anthropometric Data," and the second the " Ethnographic

Glossary."

Risley, H. H. See also under Gait, E. A.

Ritter, A. H., and Preller, L. Historia Philosophice Grcecce

et Latino? ex fontium locis contexta. Editio Quint a. Gothse.

1875. [IV, 150ft1.]
Rivers, W. H. R. The Todas. Ldn. 1906. [II, 82.]
Rivers, W. H. R. The History of Melanesian Society. (Percy

Sladen Trust Expedition to Melanesia.) 2 vols. Cambridge.

1914. [VIII, 310, 316ft, 316ft2, 317.]
Rivers, W. H. R. " Primitive Orientation." Folk-Lore.

Vol. xii. 1901. Pp. 210-212. [Ill, 295ft2.]

294 THE OCEAN OF STORY

Rivett-Carnac, J. H. " The Snake Symbol in India,
especially in connection with the Worship of Siva."
Journ. As. Soc. Bengal. Vol. xlviii. Calcutta. 1879.
Pp. 17-30. P. .31 contains an Appendix by Babu P. C.
Ghosha on the articles exhibited. [II, 307, S07n1.]

The reprints of the above were entitled " Rough Notes on the Snake
Symbol ..." and did not include Ghosha's notes.

Roberts, A. A. The Poison War. Ldn. 1915. [II, 281.]
Robertson, J. A. See under Blair, E. H., and Robertson,

J. A.
Robinson, E. J. Tales and Poems of South India. From the

Tamil. Ldn. 1885. [V, 64.]

The above is an enlarged edition of Tamil Wisdom . . . Ldn., 1873 (see
pp. 117, 118), by the same author.

Robinson, H. Wheeler. " Blood." Hastings' Ency. Rel.
Eth. Vol. ii. 1909. Pp. 714-719. [I, 98n.]

Robinson, W. H. See under Crooke, W., Talking Thrush.

Rockhill, W. W. See under Hirth, F., and Rockhill, W. W.

Roe, Thomas. See under Foster, William.

Roebuck, T. The Kirud JJfroz ; originally translated into the
Ilindoostanee language by Muoluvee Hufeez-ood-Deen Uhmud
from the Ayar Danish, . . . Calcutta. 1815. [V, 240.]

Rogers, T. Buddhaghosha's Parables : Translated from
Burmese. With an Introduction containing Buddha's
Dhammapada, Or ''''Path of Virtue" Translated from Pali,
By F. Max Muller, M.A., . . . Ldn. 1870. [I, 104, 226.]

Rohde, E. Der Griechische Roman und Seine Vorldufer.
Leipzig. 1876. [Ill, 188n ; IV, 132m1, 185m1; V, 133rc ;
VI, 16n, 18W1, 170?z2, 205n ; VII, 139n2, 147m1, 189w2 ;
IX, 36W1, 37nS 47w3, 5ln\]

This work was reprinted in 1900 with an Introduction by F. Scholl, and
again in 1914 with an Introduction by W. Schmid. Both were published at
Leipzig.

Rohue, P. See under Suchier, H.

R[olland], E. " L'Ogre." Melusine. Vol. ii. Paris. 1886-

1887. Cols. 308-310. [Ill, 105n.]
Holland in Dalkeith, ihon. Heir beginnis The Sevin

Seages Translatit out of Proisin Scottis Meiter, be . . .

Edinburgh. 1592. [V, 266n\]

The edition quoted in the Ocean is that of 1578, but apparently has a similar

title-page and contents.

Romilly, H. H. From my Verandah in New Guinea :
Sketches and Traditions ; with an Introduction by Andrew
Lang. Ldn. 1889. [VIII, 232w2.]

BIBLIOGRAPHY 295

Ronaldshay, Earl of. India. A Bird's-Eye View. Ldn.

1924. [II, 88W1.]

Rosario, A. de. " Tamil Folklore." The Orientalist.

Vol. ii. Bombay. 1885-1886. Pp. 183-184. [II, 184w.]
Roscher, W. H. Ausfuhrliches Lexikon der Griechischen

und Romischen Mythologie. 5 vols. Leipzig. 1884 .

[V, 258m1 ; VI, 282w6.]
Roscoe, John. The Baganda. An Account of their Native

Customs and Beliefs. Ldn. 1911. [Ill, 38.]
Rose, H. A. A Glossary of the Tribes and Castes of the Punjab

and North- West Frontier Province. Based mi the Census

Report for the Punjab, 1883, by the late Sir Denzil Ibbetson,

K.C.S.I., and the Census Report for the Punjab, 1892, by

Sir Edward Maclagan, K.C.I.E., C.S.I., and compiled

by . . . 3 vols. Lahore. Vol. i, 1919; vol. ii, 1911; vol. iii,

1914. [IV, 272.]
Rose, H. A. " Hindu Pregnancy Observances in the Punjab."

Journ. Anth. Inst. Vol. xxxv. 1905. Pp. 271-278. [II, 166.]
Rose, H. A. " Muhammedan Pregnancy Observances in the

Punjab." Journ. Anth. Inst. Vol. xxxv. 1905. Pp. 279-282.

[II, 166.]
Rose, H. J. Primitive Culture in Italy. Ldn. 1926. [VIII,

114711.]

Rosen, G. Tuti-N ameh. Das Papagaienbuch. Eine Samm-
lung orientalischer Erzdhlungen nach der tiirkischen. Bear-
beitung zum ersten Male uebersetzt. 2 vols. Leipzig. 1858.
[VI, 265W1, 269nJ, 271nx, 272n2, 275n4, 275n6, 276n4 ; VII,
203w6, 222n3, 241n4.]

Rosenbaum, J. Geschichte der Lustseuche im Alterthume.
Nebst ausfuhrlichen Untersuchungen iiber den Venus- und
Phalluscultus, Bordelle . . . und andere geschlechtlichen
Ausschweifungen der Alten. . . . 5th edit. Halle. 1892.
[II, 308w2.]

Ross, E. Denison. " Ibn MuqaftV and the Burzoe Legend."
Journ. Roy. As. Soc. July 1926. Pp. 503-505. [IX, 157.]

Ross, E. Denison. " An Arabic and a Persian Metrical
Version of Burzoe 's Autobiography from ' Kalila and
Dimna.'" Bull. School of Oriental Studies. Vol. iv. Pt. iii.
1927. Pp. 441-472. [IX, 157.]

Ross, H. M. " Alchemy." Ency. Brit. 11th edit. vol. i.
Pp. 519-522. [Ill, 162r*.]

Rost, Reinhold. See under Wilson, H. H.

Rostock, F. Mittelhochdeutsche Dichterheldensage. Halle.

1925. [VI, 109n2.]

296 THE OCEAN OF STORY

Roth, Henry Ling. The Natives of Sarawak and British
North Borneo. Based chiefly on the MSS. of the late Hugh
Brooke Low, Sarawak Government Service. With a Preface
by Andrew Lang. 2 vols. 1896. [VIII, 253ft2, 298ft1.]

Roth, H. Ling. Great Benin. Halifax, England. 1903.
[IX, 154.]

Roth, H. Ling. Oriental Silverwork, Malay and Chinese, with
over 250 Original Illustrations. A Handbook for Con-
noisseurs, Collectors, Students and Silversmiths. Ldn. 1910.
[VIII, 253ft1.]

Roth, R. See under Bohtlingk, O., and Roth, R.

Rothfeld, Otto. Women of India. Ldn. 1920. [II, 163ft.]

Rothwell, F. See under Bergson, H.

Rouse, W. H. D. See under Cowell, E. B., and Crooke, W.,
Talking Thrush.

Roux, M. de. Recueil de Voyages et de Memoires publie par
la Societe de Geographic Tome Premier. Paris. 1824.

The sub-title, following the Introduction, is :

" Voyage de Marc Pol." [VIII, 256.]

The above text was that on which Yule based his translation. The MS. is
Fr. 1116 in the Bib. Nat.

Roy, P. C. The Mahabharata of Krishna- Dwaipayana-

Vyasa. Translated into English Prose from the Original

Sanskrit Text. Calcutta. 1919 . (About 40 parts.)

[I, In2, 88 ; VII, 38ft2, 223ft2.]
Roy, Sripati. Customs and Customary Law in British India.

Tagore Law Lectures, 1908. Calcutta. 1911. [I, 88.]
Rubow, P. V. " Ide og Forn i H. C. Andersen's Eventyr."

Den Nye Litteratur. 1925. [VI, 293.]
Ruckert, F. Nat und Damajanti. Eine indische Geschichte,

Zweite verbesserte Auflage. Frankfurt a/M. 1838. [IV,

292.]
Russell, R. V. The Tribes and Castes of the Central Provinces

of India, by . . . , assisted by Rai Bahadur Hlra Lai. 4 vols.

Ldn. 1916. [I, 242, 242ft2, 243, 245 ; II, 22ft3, 23ft, 83, 88ft1,

118, 164ft4, 185ft, 242, 266, 266ft2, 304, 304ft2, 305ft1;

III, 14ft1, 51ft, 86ft1, 100ft1, 101ft, 306ft6, 325 ; IV, 202ft1,

272 ; V, 176 ; VII, 230ft2 ; VIII, 19, 273ft1 ; IX, 146.]
Rutherford, W. G. Babrius, edited with Introductory

Dissertations, Critical Notes, Commentary, and Lexicon,

by . . . Ldn. 1883. [V, 130ft1.]
Ryabinin, M. B. (or Riabini). See under Attai, M. O.
Ryder, A. W. The Little Clay Cart. A Hindu Drama

attributed to King Shudraka. Translated from the original

BIBLIOGRAPHY 297

Sanskrit and Prakrits into English Prose and Verse by . . .
Harvard Oriental Series. Vol. ix. Cambridge, Mass.
1905. [I, 235, 235W1.]

Rystenko, A. " On the History of the Story of Stephanites
and Ikhnelates in Byzantine and Slavo-Russian Litera-
ture " [in Russian]. Annals of the Historical-philological
Society of the Imperial New Russian University. Odessa.
1902. Vol. x. Byzantino-Slavonic, section vii, pp. 237-
280. [V, 235, 239.]

Sacchetti, F. Novelle. [Ill, lldn1.]

Sacy, Silvestre de. Calila et Dimna, ou Fables de Bidpai,
enarabe; . . . Paris. 1816. [V, 236.]

Sacy, Silvestre de. Chrestomathie Arabe, ou Eoctraits de
Divers 1 crivains Arabes, tant en prose qu'en vers, avec une
Traduction Francaise et des Notes, . . . Seconde Edition,
corrigee et augmentee. 3 vols. Paris. 1826-1827. [II, 312w2.]

Sadasiv Chhatre. Baital pachisi ; or, Twenty-five Tales of a
Demon. Translated from the Hindi by . . . Bombay. 1862.
[VI, 226 ; VII, 269.]

Safford, W. E. The Useful Plants of the Island of Guam,
with an Introductory Account of the Physical Features and
Natural History of the Island, of the Character and History
of its People, and of their Agriculture. Contributions from
the United States National Herbarium. Vol. ix. Smith-
sonian Institution U.S. National Museum. Washington.
1905. [VIII, 308n2, 309ft1, 309w2.]

Sage, Le. Le Diable Boiteux. [I, 148n.]

Saglio, E. See under Daremberg, C. V., and Saglio, E.

Sahid, D., and Gaulmin, M. Livre des lumiere ou la Con-
duite des roys, compose par le sage Pilpay. Paris. 1644.
(Reprinted 1698, etc.) [V, 240.]

§Ainenu, L. Basmele Romdne. Bucuresti. 1895. [VI, 138.]

St Augustine. Confessions. [Ill, 6n2.] De Civitate Dei.
[1,276; VI, 61.]

St Gatti. Nala e Damaianti, tradotto per . . . Naples.
1858. [IV, 292.]

St Hildegard of Bingen. Physica (Subtleties). [I, 110ft1.]
See also under Migne, J. P.

St John, R. F. St Andrew. " Indo-Burmese Folklore."
The Fblk-Lore Journal. Vol. vii. 1889. Pp. 306-313.
[VI, 266.]

This article includes a translation of three of the tales in The Precedents of
Princess Thoodamma. See further under Bandow, C. J.

298 THE OCEAN OF STORY

St John, Spencer. Life in the Forests of the Far East. 2 vols.

Ldn. 1862. (2nd edit. 1863.) [VIII, 296, 296w2.]
Saintsbury, George. See under Margaret, Queen of

Navarre.
Saintyves, P. Les Contes de Perrault et les Recits Par alleles

Leurs Origines (Coutumes Primitives et Liturgies Populaires).

Paris. 1923. [I, 29 ; II, 224w, 253U1 ; III, 105w, 238 ;

VI, 48n, 56n2, 291nl ; VII, 263.]
Saintyves, P. U Eternuement et le Battlement dans la Magie,

V Ethnographie et le Folklore Medical. Collection Science

et Magie. Paris. 1921. [Ill, 309^.]
Salama, al-Mufaddal ibn Salama. See under Mufaddal

ibn Salama, al-.
Sampson, J. " Welsh Gypsy Folk-Tales." Collected and

Edited by ... No. 12 (duvari) O trin Rasaia. With a

Note by Prof. W. R. Halliday. Journ. Gypsy Lore Society.

Third Series. Vol. i. Edinburgh. 1922. No. 2. Pp. 49-58.

[IX, 142.]
Sampson, J. "Welsh Gypsy Folk-Tales." Collected and

Edited by . . . No. 19. I Benesko Parami&us. With a

Rumanian Gypsy parallel recorded by Miss D. E. Yates,

and a Note by Prof. W. R. Halliday. Journ. Gypsy Lore

Society. Third Series. Vol. ii. Edinburgh. 1923. No. 4.

Pp. 145-156. [IX, 142.]
Sandys, J. E. See under Jebb, R. C.
Sangster, William. Umbrellas and their History. Ldn. 1855.

[II, 272.]
Sanguinetti, B. R. See under Ibn Batuta.
Sansovino, F. Cento novelle scelte da piv nobili scrittori della

Lingua volgare, di Francesco Sansovino nelle quali piacevoli

and notabili auuenimenti si contengono. Venice. 1603.

[I, 44.]
Sarat Chandra Mitra. See under Mitra, Sarat Chandra.
Sarawak, The Ranee of. The Cauldron. Ldn. 1925. [VI, 61.]
Sastri, Pandit S. M. Natesa. Folklore in Southern India.

In Four Parts. Bombay, 1884, 1886, 1888 and 1893.

[II, 136nx ; VII, 219.]

This collection contains thirty-seven tales, twenty-four of which appeared
in Kingscote and Sastrl's Tales of the Sun, Ldn., 1890. They had previously
been issued in The Indian Antiquary, vols, xiii-xx and xxiii-xxvii. A further
selection appeared also in the following : —

Indian Folk-Tales. Madras. 1908. [VI, 92nK]
Sastri, Pandit S. M. Natesa. The Dravidian Nights1
Entertainments : being a translation of Madanakamarajan-

BIBLIOGRAPHY 299

kadai. [An anonymous Tamil tale.] Excelsior Press,

Madras. 1886. [II, 190711 ; III, 29w, 204.]
Sastri, T. Ganapati. Samardnganasutradhdra by King

Bhojadeva. Edited by Mahamahopadhyaya T. Ganapati

Sastri. ... 2 vols. Baroda. 1924, 1925. Gaekwad's

Oriental Series, No. xxv, 1924 ; No. xxxii, 1925. [IX, 149.]
Sastry, R. Shama. " Vishnu's Three Strides : the Measure

of Vedic Chronology." Journ. Bombay Br. Roy. As. Soc.

Vol. xxvi. 1923. Pp. 40-56. [VI, 107rc2.] See also under

Shama Sastri, R.
Saville, W. J. V. In Unknown New Guinea. . . . With 58

Illustrations and Maps. Ldn. 1926. [VIII, 314W1.]
Sayce, A. H. Babylonians and Assyrians. Life and Customs.

No. vi of the Semitic Series. Ldn. 1900. [VII, 231n6.]
Schall, Karl. See under Habicht, Max.
Schechter, S. " The Riddles of Solomon in Rabbinic

Literature." Folk-Lore. Vol.i. 1890. Pp. 349-358. [VI,74w.]
Schiefner, A. Die Heldensagen d. minussinschen Tataren

Rhythmisch bearbeitet von ... St Petersburg. 1859.

[VIII, 228ti2.]
Schiefner, A. Tdrandihd's Geschichte des Buddhismus in

Indien. Aus dem Tibetischen ubersetzt von ... St Peters-
burg. 1869. [I, 69w4 ; II, 69n2.]
Schiefner, F. A. von. See under Ralston, W. R. S.
Schiller, J. C. Friedrich v. " Der Gang nach dem Eisen-

hammer." [II, 113W1.] "Der Graf von Hapsburg."

[II, 49w2.]

From his Gedichte. The Poems and Ballads were translated into English in

1844 by Sir E. B. Lytton.

Schiltberger, Johann (or Hans). See under Langmantel, V.
Schlegel, A. W., et Lassen, C. Hitopadesas id est Institutio

Salutaris. Pt. 1, Sanskrit Text. Pt. 2, Commentary.

Bonnae ad Rhenum. 1829-1831. [V, 210.]
Schlegel, G. See under Muller, F. W. K.
Schleicher, A. Litauische Marchen, Sprichworte, Ratsel und

Lieder. Gesammelt u. ubers. . . . Weimar. 1857. [Ill, 75.]
Schmidt, A. Shakespeare-Lexicon. 2 vols. Berlin. 1874-1875.

[Ill, 112n1.]
The 3rd edition, by G. Sarrazin, Berlin, 1902, was much enlarged.

Schmidt, Bernhard. Griechische Mar chert, Sagen und
Volkslieder. Leipzig. 1877. [I, 77wx, 188w2 ; II, 57W1,
127w2 ; III, 28n\ 133n\ 187w3, 218W1, 238, 253W1 ; IV, 65w,
145w2 ; V, 128w2, 157W1 ; VI, 16w, 47nx, 136, 277 ; VII,
61nx ; VIII, 57n2 ; IX, 143.]

300 THE OCEAN OF STORY

Schmidt, Hans. Jona. Eine Untersuchung zur vergleichenden

Religionsgeschichte. Forschungen zur Religion und Litera-

tur des Alte und Neuen Testaments. Heft ix. Gottingen.

1907. [II, 194ft.]
Schmidt, R. Die Qukasaptati. (Textus Simplicior.) Kiel.

1894. [V, 64 ; VII, 210ft1, 210ft2.]
Schmidt, R. Beitrdge zur Indischen Erotik ; das Liebesleben

des Sanskritvolkes nach den Quellen dargestellt. Leipzig.

1902. 2nd edit. Berlin. 1911. [I, 234ft1 ; III, 320 ; V,

195.] See also under Jolly, J., and Schmidt, R.
Schmidtmuller, Dr. " Bantik'sche Sage." Zeitschrift der

Deut. Morg. Gesell. Vol. vi. Leipzig. 1852. Pp. 536-538.

[VIII, 231ft10.]
Schmitz, V. A. H. C. Andersens Marchendichtung. Ein

Beitrag zur Geschichte der ddnischen Spatromantik (Mit

Ausblicken auf das deutsche romantische Kunstmarchen).

Nordische Studien. No. vii. Greifswald. 1925. [VI, 293.]
Schoff, W. H. The Periplus of the Erythraean Sea. Travel

and Trade in the Indian Ocean by a Merchant of the First

Century. Translated from the Greek and Annotated by . . .

Commercial Museum, Philadelphia. New York. 1912.

[VII, 106.]
Schoff, W. H. The Ship " Tyre" A Symbol of the Fate of

Conquerors as Prophesied by Isaiah, Ezekiel and John, and

Fulfilled at Nineveh, Babylon and Rome. A Study in the

Commerce of the Bible. Ldn. 1920. [VII, 106.]
Schoff, W. H. " Camphor." Journ. Amer. Orient. Soc.

Vol. xlii. Pts. 3 and 4. 1922. Pp. 355-370. [Ill, 260ft1 ;

VIII, 246ft3.]
Schofield, W. H. " Chaucer's Franklin's Tale." Modern

Language Ass. Amer. Vol. xvi. (New Series, vol. ix.)

Pp. 405-449. [VII, 203.]
Schofield, W. H. " The Story of Horn and Rimenhild."

Publications of the Modern Language Association of America.

Edited by C. H. Grandgent. . . . Vol. xviii. New Series,

vol. xi. Baltimore. 1903. Pp. 1-83. [II, 76ft1.]
Schopenhauer, A. The World as Will and Idea. Translated

from the German by R. B. Haldane, M.A., and J. Kemp,

M.A. 3 vols. Ldn/ 1883, 1886. Forming vols, xxii-xxiv

of the English and Foreign Philosophical Library. [VII,

253ft1.]
Schoppner, A. Sagenbuch der Bayerischen Lande ; Aus dem
Munde des Volkes, der Chronik und der Dichter heraus-

gegeben von ... 3 vols. Munchen. 1852-1853. [II, 113ft1.]

BIBLIOGRAPHY 301

Schott, Arthur und Albert. Walachische Mdrchen.

Stuttgart and Tubingen. 1845. [Ill, 205.]
Schrader, E. See under Jensen, P.
Schrader, H. Die Sirenen. Berlin. 1868. [VI, 282w6.]
Schrader, O. Prehistoric Antiquities of the Aryan Peoples.

Trans, by F. B. Jevons. Ldn. 1890. [IV, 255n\]
Schrader, O. Reallexikon der indogerman. Altertumskunde.

Strassburg. 1901. [Ill, 319.]
Schram, Robert. See under Sewell, R., and Sankara

Balkrishna DIkshit.
Schroder, Carl. Sanct Brandan. Ein Lateinischer und

Drei Deutsche Texte. Herausgegeben von . . . Erlangen.

1871. [VII, 189w2.]
Schultess, F. Kalila und Dimna, Syrisch und Deutsch.

Berlin. 1911. [V, 219.]
Schwalbe, E. Die Morphologie der Missbildungen des

Menschen und der Tiere. 3 vols. Jena. 1906-1913. [VII,

233nx.]
Schwanenflugel, H. Hans Christian Andersen. Et

Digterliv. Copenhagen. 1905. [VI, 293.]
Scidmore, E. R. Java the Garden of the East. New York.

1898. [VIII, 295n\]
[Scott, J. G.] The Burman, his Life and Notions. By Shway

Yoe, subject of the Great Queen. Ldn. 1896. [II, 167,

265w3 ; VIII, 286, 286n5.]

The first edition (of 1882) was in two volumes.

Scott, J. G. " Burma and Assam (Buddhism in)." Hastings'

Ency. Rel. Eth. Vol. iii. 1910. Pp. 37-44. [II, 265n4.]
Scott, Jonathan. Bahar-Danush ; or, Garden of Knowledge.

An Oriental Romance translated from the Persic of Einaiut

Oollah. 3 vols. Shrewsbury. 1799. [VII, 203n3, 214rc4, 259;

VIII, 227n2.]
Scott, Jonathan. Tales, Anecdotes and Letters, translated

from the Arabic and Persian. Shrewsbury. 1800. [II, 113m1;

VI, 255, 256, 257, 258, 260, 260m1.]
Scott, Jonathan. The Arabian Nights' Entertainments,

Carefully revised, and occasionally Corrected from the

Arabic. ... 6 vols. Ldn. 1811. [VIII, 227w3.]
Scott, J. G., and Hardiman, J. P. Gazetteer of Upper Burma

and the Shan States. 5 vols. Rangoon. 1900-1901. Vols.

i and ii form Pt. i, and vols, iii-v Pt. ii of the work.

[II, 232w.]
Scott, Walter. The Antiquary. [Ill, 150.] The Lady of

the Lake. [VIII, lUn1.]

302 THE OCEAN OF STORY

Seaton, M. E. " Swan-Maidens." Hastings' Ency. Rel. Eth.

Vol. xii. 1921. Pp. 125, 126. [VIII, 219nK]
Sebillot, P. Folk-lore de France. 4 vols. Paris. 1904-1907.

[Ill, 76.]
Seeley, H. G. Dragons of the Air: Account of Extinct

Flying Reptiles. Ldn. 1901. [I, 105.]
Seemann, B . 4 ' Sandal- wood and its Commercial Importance. ' J

The Intellectual Observer : Review of Natural History,

Microscopic Research, and Recreative Science. Vol. iv.

No. 20. Ldn. Sept. 1863. Pp. 73-83. [VII, 105, 106, 107.]

This periodical first appeared in 1860 under the title of Recreative Science . . .

Seler, E. Gesammelte Abhandlungen zur Amerikanischen

Sprach- und Altertumskunde. Berlin. 1902. [II, 309,

309m1.]
Seligmann, C. G. The Melanesians of British New Guinea.

Cambridge. 1910. [Ill, 310.]
Sellon, E. " The Phallic Worship of India." Memoirs read

before the Anth. Soc. Ldn. Vol. i. 1865. Pp. 327-334.

[II,. 242.]
Sen, K. B. L. See under Dutt, Udoy Chand.
Sen, K. A. See under Dutt, Udoy Chand.
Sen, K. N. N. Vaidyak-sabdasindhuh. (The Ocean of Medical

Words. A Vocabulary of Ayurvedic terms, drugs, etc., with

Illustrative Quotations from Works on Hindu Medicine.)

Compiled by Kavirdj Umes Candra Gupta Kaviratna. . . .

Revised and Enlarged by . . . Calcutta. 1913-1914.

[VIII, 246.]
Senart, E. Le Mahdvastu Texte Sanscrit publie pour la

premiere fois et Accompagne d' Introductions et d'un

Commentaire. Societe Asiatique. Collection d'Ouvrages

Orientaux. Seconde Serie. 3 vols. Paris. 1882-1897.

[VIII, 71w2.]
Senart, E. Les Inscriptions de Piyadasi. 2 vols. Paris.

1881-1886. [VII, 33^.]
Seneca. De Ira. [VI, 294nx.] De Matrimonio. [Ill, 328.]

Hercules Furens. [IV, 65W1.] See also under Weinreich, O.
Seth, Simeon (or Symeon). See under Stark.
Seville, Isidore of. See under Isidore of Seville.
Sewell, R. A Forgotten Empire (Vijayanagar). Ldn. 1900.

[I, 248W1 ; IV, 267.]
The work has been reprinted, Ldn., 1924 (printed in Saxony).

Sewell, R., and S Ankara Balkrishna Dikshit. The Indian
Calendar, with Tables for the Conversion of Hindu and
Muhammadan into a.d. Dates, and Vice Versa. . . . With

BIBLIOGRAPHY 303

Tables of Eclipses Visible in India by Dr Robert Schram
of Vienna. Ldn. 1896. [VIII, 19.]

The above work was followed by :

Continuation of the "Indian Calendar" Eclipses of the
Moon in India. By R. Sewell. Ldn. 1898.

This produced two further works on the subject — both by R. Sewell :

Indian Chronography. . . . Ldn. 1912. The Siddhantas
and the Indian Calendar. Calcutta. 1924.

Seymour, St John D. Tales of King Solomon. Oxford Univ.
Press, Ldn. 1924. [VI, 74w.]

Shaik Chilli. See under Chilli, Shaik.

Shakespeare, William. Measure for Measure. [I, 50n2.]
A Midsummer Night's Dream. [Ill, 29/i1.] The Merchant of
Venice. [IV, 183.] As You Like It. [IV, 24>5n\] AIVs
Well That Ends Well. [VI, 147m1 ; IX, 77n2.] The Winter's
Tale. [V, 7nK] The Life and Death of King John. [VI, 24n.]
The Tragedy of King Richard II. [IV, 222m1 ; VIII, S8n\
127n3.] The Life of King Henry the Fifth. [II, 98w4.] The
Second Pari of King Henry VI. [II, 98w4 ; VI, 24n.] The
Tragedy of King Richard the Third. [I, 31 n2 ; VI, 24n.]
(See also under Tawney, C. H.) Coriolanus. [VIII, 112n2.]
Romeo and Juliet. [Ill, 112ft1.] Julius Ccesar. [VIII, 99m1,
156n\] Macbeth. [II, 145n ; VII, 164711.] Hamlet. [I, 76n2,
77na; VIII, 99nK] Othello. [II, 145rc.] Cymbeline. [1,49m1.]

Naturally all readers have their own favourite editions of Shakespeare, but,
speaking purely from the point of view of the student of research, I find the
one- volume Globe Edition (Macmillan & Co., 4s. 6d.) excellent in every way.
On it was based Bartlett's Complete Concordance (also published by Macmillan),
that amazing work which no Shakespearian student can afford to be without.
For an annotated edition I prefer the Arden, 39 vols., 1899-1924 (Methuen).

Shakespeare, William, and Fletcher, John. The Two

Noble Kinsmen. [V, 69nx.]
Shama Sastri, R. The Arthasastra of Kautilya. Edited

by . . . Government Oriental Library Series. Bibliotheca

Sanskrita. No. 37. Mysore. 1909. [I, 233, 233ft1, 265;

III, 142w2.]

The above text was revised in 1919> and again in 1924, and published at
Mysore, Oriental Library Publications. Sanskrit Series. Nos. 37/54, 37/64.
University of Mysore. The translation of the above first appeared in the
Mysore Review, 1906-1909 (books i-iv), and Indian Antiquary, 1909-1910
(books v-xv). The whole was issued, with an Introductory Note, by Dr J. F.
Fleet, at Bangalore, 1915. Second edition. Mysore. 1923.

Shastri, Hirananda. The Origin and Cult of Tdrd. Mem.
Arch. Surv. India. No. 20. Calcutta. 1925. [IX, 148.]

304 THE OCEAN OF STORY

Shaw, R. B. " On the Ghalchah Languages Wakhi and
Sarikoli." Journ. As. Soc. Bengal. New Series, vol. xlv,
Pt. i', No. 2. 187G. Pp. 139-278. [IX, 147.]

Shaw, R. B. " On the Shighni (Ghalchah) Dialect." Journ.
As. Soc. Bengal. New Scries, vol. xlvi, Pt. i, No. 2. 1877.
Pp. 97-126. [Ill, 269w.]

Shea, D., and Troyer, A. The Dabistan, or School of Manners,
Translated from the Persian by ... 3 vols. Oriental
Translation Fund. Paris. 1843. [I, 192 ; II, 169.]

Sherring, M. A. Hindu Tribes and Castes. 3 vols. Calcutta.
1872, 1879, 1881. [VIII, 270w2.]

The above work is usually referred to under the title Hindu Tribes and
Castes, but this gives no idea as to the seope of the work. Each volume had
a different self-explanatory title, as follows : —

Sherring, M. A. Hindu Tribes and Castes, as represented in
Benares. Vol. i. Calcutta. 1872. Hindu Tribes and Castes ;
together with an Account of the Mahomedan Tribes of the
North- West Frontier and of the Aboriginal Tribes of the
Central Provinces. Vol. ii. Calcutta. 1879. Hindu Tribes
and Castes. Together with Three Dissertations : on the
National History of Hindu Caste ; the Unity of the Hindu
Race ; and the Prospects of Indian Caste ; and including a
General Index of the Three Volumes. Vol. iii. Calcutta.
1881.

This last volume was issued posthumously.

Shorey, P. " Sirens." Hastings' Ency. Rel. Eth. Vol. xi.

1920. Pp. 577-579. [VI, 282?i6.]
Shortland, E. Traditions and Superstitions of the New

Zealanders. 2nd edit. Ldn. 1856. [VI, 135.]
Shortt, J. " Kojahs of Southern India." Journ. Anth. Inst.

Vol. ii. 1873. Pp. 402-407. [Ill, 325.]
Shortt, J. " The Bayadere : or, Dancing Girls of Southern

India." Memoirs read before the Anth. Soc. Ldn., 1867-1869.

Vol. iii. 1870. Pp. 182-194. [I, 252, 253, 253n\ 254.]
Shortt, L. M. " Hans Christian Andersen and Fairyland."

Fortnightly Review. Vol. cxviii. New Series. July-Dec.

Ldn. 1925. Pp. 190-201. [IX, 161.]
Shway Yoe. See under [Scott, George].
Sibree, James. " The Oratory, Songs, Legends, and Folk-
Tales of the Malagasv." The Folk- Lore Journal. Vol. i.

Jan.-Dec. Ldn. 1883. Pp. 201-211. [VIII, 227n10.]

The artiele appears in instalments throughout the volume.

Siees, T. " Neues zur germanischen Mythologie." Mit-
teilungen der Schlesischen Gesellschaft fur Volkskunde

BIBLIOGRAPHY 305

herausgegeben von Theodor Siebs. Vol. xxv. Breslau. 1924.
Pp. 1-17. [VIII, 225n2.]

Sikes, W. Wirt. British Goblins: Welsh Folklore, Fairy
Mythology, Legends and Traditions. Ldn. 1880. [I, 76n2 ;
II, 75w2, 98w4, 223W1 ; III, 32n\ 187rc3, 225w2 ; IV, 213W1 ;
VI, 10n4, 277.]

Silius Italicus. Punica. [VIII, 154w2.]

Silva, Joannes de Alta. See under Hilka, A., and
Oesterley, H.

Silvestre de Sacy. See under Sacy, Silvestre de.

Simpson, W. The Jonah Legend. A Suggestion of Interpreta-
tion. Ldn. 1899. [II, 194n.]

Simrock, K. Die deutschen Volksbucher. 13 vols. Frankfurt
a/M. 1845-1865. [I, 24nS 97n2, 129, 137m1, 141n2 ; II,
57n\ 64n2, 76/11 ; III, 167w2, 187w3, 287nx ; IV, 128ft1 ;
V, 43w2, 102ra2, 104W1, 127n\ 138nS 146ft1, 204ft1 ; VI,
25ft2, 73ft3 ; VII, 21 ft3, 81ft1.]

Sinclair, J. Statistical Account of Scotland; from Com-
munications of Ministers of the Different Parishes.
21 vols. Edinburgh. 1791-1799. [I, 191.]

Sinclair, W. F. The Travels of Pedro Teixeira ; with his
"Kings of Harmuz," and extracts from his "Kings of
Persia." Translated and Annotated by . . . With further
Notes and an Introduction by Donald Ferguson. Hakluyt
Society. Ldn. 1902. [VIII, 259ft2.] See further under
Teixeira, Pedro.

The above volume forms No. ix of the Second Series.

Sivadasa. Vetdlapanchavims'ati. [VI, 225, 225ft3'*, 261, 267,

271-273.]
Skeat, W. W. Chaucer. The Prioresses Tale, Sire Thopas,

The Monk's Tale, The Clerkes Tale, The Squieres Tale,

from the Canterbury Tales. Clarendon Press Series. Oxford.

1874. [V, 27ft2.]
Skeat, W. W. (Jun.). Malay Magic. Ldn. 1900. [VI, 62;

VIII, 290ft4.]
Skeat, W. W. (Jun.). Fables and Folk-Tales from an Eastern

Forest. Cambridge. 1901. [V, 48ft1, 49ft1. 63ft1.]
Skeat, W. W. (Jun.). The Past at our Doors. Ldn. 1911.

[II, 270, 270ft1.]
Skeat, W. W. (Jun.). "Snake-stones." Folk-Lore. Vol. xxiii.

1912. Pp. 45-80. [IV, 245n1.]
Skeat, W. W. (Jun.), and Blagden, C. O. Pagan Races of

the Malay Peninsula. 2 vols. Ldn. 1906. [VI, 62; VIII,

289ft3, 290ft2,3.]

VOL. IX. U

306 THE OCEAN OF STORY

Sleeman, W. H. Rambles and Recollections of an Indian
Official. 2 vols. 1844. [I, 238/11 ; IV, 271.]
A new edition appeared in 1893, edited by V. A. Smith.

Smith, F. Porter. See under Stuart, G. A.
Smith, G. A. The Book of The Twelve Prophets, commonly
called the Minor. 2 vols. Ldn. 1896. [II, 194w.]

The above volumes form part of the Eighth Series of The Expositor's Bible,
edited by the Rev. W. R. NicolLM.A., LL.D.

Smith, G. Elliot. See under Hose, C.

Smith, M. Hamblin. See under Vincent, A. L., and Binns, C.

Smith, M. Staniforth. " Kikori Expedition." Papua.

Report for the Year ended 30th June 1911. No. 67.

Pp. 165-171. The Parliament of the Commonwealth of

Australia. [VIII, 312.]
Smith, V. A. The Early History of India. From 600 B.C.

to the Muhammadan Conquest, including the Invasion of

Alexander the Great. Oxford. 1904. [II, 282ft1 ; VII, 237ft1.]
Smith, V. A. The Oxford History of India. From the Earliest

Times to the end of 1911. Oxford. 1919. [I, 250ft1 ; IV,

264 ; VII, 237ft1.]

A 2nd edition " Revised and continued to 1921, by S. M. Edwardes . . . ,"

appeared in 1923.

Smith, V. A. See also under Constable, A. ; Cunningham,

A. ; Sleeman, W. H.
Smith, W. Dictionary of Greek and Roman Antiquities.

3rd edit. Ldn. 1890-1891. [V, 256 ; VIII, 156ft1 ; IX, 147.]
Smith, W. C. Ao Naga Tribe of Assam. A Study in Ethnology

and Sociology. With an Introduction by J. H. Hutton, CLE.,

D.Sc., M.A. Published by direction of the Government

of Assam. Ldn. 1925. [VIII, 284ft*, 286ft1.]
Smith, W. G. Pogson. See under Hobbes, Thomas.
Smith, W. Robertson. Lectures on the Religion of the

Semites. First Series. The Fundamental Institutions.

Burnett Lectures, 1888-1889. New Edition, revised

throughout by the Author. Ldn. 1894. [II, 119, 194ft ;

VI, 133 ; VII) 231ft5.]
[Smithers, L. C] See under [Burton, R. F., and Smithers,

L. C.].
Socin, A. See under Prym, E., and Socin, A.
Solalinde, A. G. Calila y Dimna — Fdbulas. Antigua version

castellana. Prologo y vocabulario de . . . Madrid. 1918.

[V, 237.]
Sontheimer, J. von. Grosse Zusammenstellung ilber die

Krafte der bekannten einfachen Heil- und Nahrungsmittel

BIBLIOGRAPHY 307

von Abu Mohammed Abdallah Ben Ahmed aus Malaga
bekannt unter den Namen Ebn Baithar. 2 vols. Stuttgart.
1840-1842. [VIII, 255n2.]

Sophocles. Antigone. [Ill, 292m1.] Electra. [II, 127n2.]
Trachiniae. [V, 29n2.] See also under Storr, F.

Sorensen, S. An Index to the Names in the Mahabharata,
with Short Explanations and A Concordance to the Bombay
and Calcutta Editions and P. C. Roy's Translation. Issued
in thirteen parts. Ldn. 1904-1925. [VII, 223w2, 235rc1 ;
IX, 2w2.]

This magnificent work, begun by Sorensen (who died in 1902), was completed
by Elof Olesen and Dines Andersen.

Souby-Bey. Fabeln und Parabeln des Orients. Der tiirk-
ischen Sammlung humajun name entnommenen und ins
Deutsche ubertr. . . . Foreword by Dr Rieder Pascha.
Berlin. 1903. [V, 241.]

Southey, Robert. Roprecht the Robber. [VI, 136.] Thalaba
the Destroyer. [Ill, 150; IV, 129n ; VI, 118n», 136.]
Old Woman of Berkeley. [VIII, 56n\]

Sowa, R. von. Die Mundart der Slovakischen Zigeuner.
Gottingen. 1887. [V, 275.]

Soy Yo. " The Antiquity of the Castanet." Once A Week.
A Miscellany of Literature, Art, Science, and Popular
Information. Vol. viii. Pt. xlviii. June 1863. Pp. 609,
610. [VIII, 95n\]

Spence Hardy. See under Hardy, R. Spence.

Spence, Lewis. Encyclopaedia of Occultism : a Compendium
of Information on the Occult Sciences, Occult Personalities,
Psychic Sciences, Magic, Demonology, Spiritism, and
Mysticism. Ldn. 1920. [Ill, 162n.]

Spencer, B., and Gillen, F. J. The Northern Tribes of
Central Australia. Ldn. 1904. [VII, 230n4.]

Spencer, Herbert. Essays : Scientific, Political, and Specu-
lative. Stereotyped Edition. 3 vols. Ldn. 1868-1874.
[VII, 253W1.]

Spencer, Herbert. Ceremonial Institutions [pt. iv of
Principles of Sociology]. Ldn. 1879. [Ill, 21n.]

Spencer, Herbert. " The Physiology of Laughter."
Macmillan's Magazine. March 1860. Pp. 395-402. [VII,
253W1.]

.Spencer, W. R. Poems. Ldn. 1835. [V, 138nx.]

The poem quoted in the Ocean is " Beth Gelert, or The Grave of the
Greyhound."

308 THE OCEAN OF STORY

Spenser, Edmund. The Faerie Queene. [Ill, 138nx ; V,
29n2 ; VI, 215W1 ; IX, 37W1.] Prosopopoia : or Mother
UubberaVs Tale. [V, 53w2.]

The latter poem first appeared in " Complaints, containing sundrie small
Poemes of the Worlds Vani tie. . . ." 1591.

Speyer, J. S. The Gdtakamdld or Garland of Birth-Stories.
By Arya Stir a. Translated from the Sanskrit by . . .
Ldn. 1895. [VII, 243m1:]

The above work forms vol. i of Sacred Books of the Buddhists . . . edited
by F. Max Midler. Published under the patronage of His Majesty Chulalan-
karana, King of Siam.

Speyer, J. S. Studies about the Kathdsaritsdgara. Verhan-
delingen der Koninklijke Akademie van Wetenschappen
te Amsterdam. Afdeeling Letterkunde. Niewe Reeks.
Deel viii. No. 5. Amsterdam. 1908. [I, 122w4 ; II, 28n2,
36n\ 53n3, 60n\ 60n3, 70n\ 92n6, 140ft1, 160ft1, 177ft1, 201ft2,
227ft2, 2S5711 ; III, 12ft1, 16ft1, 25ft1, 50ft1, Sin1, 83ft3, 83ft4,
94ft1, 159ft3, 208ft1, 241ft3, 244ft3, 246ft1, 298ft1; IV, 8ft2,
Wn, 13ft2, 30ft, 52ft1, 73ft1, 92ft1, 100ft1, 101ft1, 200ft1, 201ft1,
203ft1, 207ft1, 218ft3 ; V, 22ft1, 79ft1, 99ft2, 129ft1, 134ft1,.
159ft1, 200ft1, 212, 213; VI, 26ft2, Sin1, 46ft2, 54ft1, 90ft2,
167?!1, 193ft2, 205ft1, 220ft2, 225n2 ; VII, 16ft1, 78ft3, 93n2,
98ft2, 125n2, 126ft1, 126ft1, 132n2, 153ft1, 158ft2, 170ft4, 182ft2 ;
VIII, 16ft, 31ft1, 33n2, 37ft1, 60ft2, 63ft1, 63ft2, 87n2, 91n2.]

Spiegel, F. Anecdota Pdlica. Nach den Handschriften der
Konigl. Bibliothek in Copenhagen im Grundtexte heraus-
gegeben, iibersetzt und erkldrt von ... 1, Rasavahini . . .
Uragasutta aus dem Suttanipata . . . Leipzig. 1845.
[V, 157ft1.]

Spiers, R. Phene. See under Fergusson, J.

Spitta-Bey, G. Conies arabes modernes. Leiden. 1883. [III>
204.]

The collection consists of twelve tales.

Spooner, D. B. " The Zoroastrian Period of Indian History."
Journ. Roy. As. Soc. 1915. Pp. 63-89, 405-455. [II, 39ft1.]

Sprengling, M. " Kalila Studies." Amer. Journ. Semitic
Lang', and Lif. Vol. xl. No. 2. Jan. 1924. Pp. 81-97.
[V, 219, 235.]

Sriharsha. Naishadhlya (or N aishadha-charita). [IV, 277.]

Sripati Roy. See under Roy, Sripati.

Stack, Edward. The Mikirs, from the Papers of the late . . .
Edited, Arranged, and Supplemented by Sir Charles Lyall.
Published under the orders of the Government of Eastern
Bengal and Assam. Ldn. 1908. [VIII, 285ft4; IX, 166.]

BIBLIOGRAPHY 309

Stallybrass, J. S. See under Grimm, J. L. C.

Stanislas Julien. See under Julien, Stanislas.

Stanley, H. E. J. The Philippine Islands, Moluccas, Siam,
Cambodia, Japan, and China, at the close of the Sixteenth
Century. By Antonio de Morga. Translated from the
Spanish, with Notes and a Preface, and a Letter from Luis
Vaez de Torres, describing his Voyage through the Torres
Straits. By . . . Hakluyt Society. Ldn. 1868. [VIII,
300, 300W1.]

The above work forms No. xxxix of the 1st Series.

Stark, S. G. Specimen Sapiential Indorum Veterum id est
Liber Ethico-Politicus . . . Grace 2TE<MNITH2 Ka\
IXNHAATH2, Nunc primum Grace ex MSS. Cod.
Holsteiniano, prodit, cum versione nova Latina, opera . . .
Berolini. 1697. (2nd edit. Athens, 1851.) [V, 219, 238.]
The Greek translation of the Arabic version of Bidpal is by Simeon Seth.

Starkie, W. J. M. The Clouds of Aristophanes, with Intro-
duction, English Prose Translation, Critical Notes and
Commentary, Including a new Transcript of the Scholia in
the Codex Marcianus 474. Ldn. 1911. [V, 257.]

Steel, F. A. " Folklore in the Panjab." Collected by Mrs
F. A. Steel, with Notes by Lieut. R. C. Temple. . . .
Indian Antiquary. Vol. ix, 1880, pp. 205-210, 280-282 and
302-304; vol. x, 1881, pp. 40-43, 80-82, 147-152, 228-233,
331-333 and 347-352 ; vol. xi, 1882, pp. 32-43, 73-76, 163-
172 and 226-230 ; vol. xii, 1883, pp. 103-104 and 175-177.
[V, 49W1.]

Steel, F. A., and Temple, R. C. Wide- Awake Stories. A
Collection of Tales told by Little Children, between Sunset
and Sunrise, in the Panjab and Kashmir. Bombay : Educa-
tion Society's Press. London : Trubner & Co. 1884.
[I, 28, 130, 131 ; II, 108w, 122, 199n ; III, 182, 247nx,
272nJ, 280.]

This important collection of forty-three tales had, for the most part,
previously appeared in The Indian Antiquary, vols, ix-xii (see above) ; The
Calcutta Review, Oct. 1882, and Temple's Legends of the Panjab, vol. i, pp. 1-66.
The chief value of the collection lies in the Notes," " Analysis," and " Survey
of Incidents," embracing all the chief Indian collections previously published.
The work was reissued in 189* under a new title (see below), and without
any approbation or participation on the part of Sir Richard Temple.

The title-page was as follows : Tales of the Punjab, told by the People. By
Flora Annie Steel. With Illustrations by J. Lockwood Kipling, CLE., and
Notes by R. C. Temple. London. 1894.

Steele, Robert. Opera hactenus inedita Rogeri Baconi.
Fasc. V. Secretum Secretorum cum Glossis et Notulis

310

THE OCEAN OF STORY

Tractatus brevis et utilis ad declarandum quedam obscure
dicta Fratris Rogeri nunc primum edidit. . . . Accedunt
versio anglicana ex Arabico edita per A. S. Fulton. Versio
Vetusta Anglo-normanica nunc primum edita. Oxonii.
1920. [II, 291, 291m1.]
Steele, T. Kusa Jdtakaya, a Buddhistic Legend. Ldn. 1871.
[V, 48m1, 61n3, 64.]

The Appendix contains fourteen Sinhalese folk-tales. Several are to be
found also in Parker's Village Folk-Tales of Ceylon.

Steere, E. Swahili Tales, as told by Natives of Zanzibar.
With an English Translation. Ldn. 1870 (reprinted 1889).
[V, 127W1 ; VIII, 227n10.]

Stefano, Hieronimo di Santo. See under Major, R. M.

Stein, M. A. Kalhanrfs Rdjatarangini, A Chronicle of the
Kings of Kasmir. Translated, with an Introduction,
Commentary, and Appendices, by ... 2 vols. West-
minster. 1900. [I, 63nx; IV, 264, 266; VII, 244nx ;
IX, 17n2, 147.]

Stein, A., and Grierson, G. A. Hatim's Tales, Kashmiri
Stories and Songs recorded with the assistance of Pandit
Govind Kaul . . . with a note on the Folklore of the
Tales by W. Crooke, C.I.E. Indian Text Series. Ldn. 1923.
[I, S8n, 8ln, 163n ; II, 124; III, 280; IV, 48, 104;
V, 176, 177 ; IX, 163.]

Stein, O. " 'ZCpiy^ und surungd." Zeit. f. Indologie und
Iranistik. Vol. iii. Pt. ii. 1925. Pp. 280-318. [V, 142n2.]

Steinschneider, M. Hebro3ische Bibliographic Blatter fur
neuere und altere Literatur des Judenthums. Redigirt von
. . . Zugleich eine Erganzung zu alien Organen des
Buchhandels. 21 vols. Berlin. 1858-1882. [II, 289n4.]

J. Benzian assisted in editing vols, ix-xxi. During 1866-1868 the publication
was suspended.

Steinschneider, M. Die Hebraeischen Uebersetzungen des
Mittelalters und die Juden als Dolmetscher. Ein Beitrag
zur Liter aturgeschichte des Mittelalters, meist nach hand-
schriftlichen Quellen, von . . . Berlin. 1893. [II, 289n3 ;
V, 220nx, 237-239.]

Steinschneider, M. " Die toxicologischen Schriften der
Araber bis Ende XII. Jahrhunderts. Ein bibliographischer
Versuch, grossentheils aus handschriftlichen Quellen."

This forms No. xxiv of :

Archiv fur pathologische Anatomie und Physiologie und filr
Klinische Medicin. Herausgegeben von Rudolf Virchow.
Vol. Iii. Berlin. 1871. Pp. 340-375. [II, 28Sn1.]

BIBLIOGRAPHY 311

Stent, G. Carter. " Chinese Eunuchs " — Article V. (Read
before the Society on 26th March 1877.) Journal of the
North China Branch of the Royal Asiatic Society. New
Series. No. xi. Shanghai. 1877. Pp. 143-184. [Ill, 329.]

Stephani, L. " Erklarung Einiger im Jahre 1865 im
Sudlichen Russland Gefundenen Gegenstande." Compte-
Rendu de la Commission Imperiale Archeologique pour
Vannee 1866. St Petersburg. 1867. Supplement. Pp.
3-136. [VI, 282ft6.]

Stephani, L. "Erklarung Einiger im Sudlichen Gefundener
Kunstwerke." Compte-Rendu de la Commission Imperiale
Archeologique pour les Annees 1870 et 1871. St Petersburg.
1874. Supplement. Pp. 5-290. [VI, 282ft6.]

Stephens, G. A. " The Eating or Chewing Pan." The
Westminster Review. Vol. clxviii. Ldn. August 1907.
Pp. 163-167. [VIII, 318ft1.]

Stephens, G., and Cavallius, H. Old Norse Fairy Tales,
Gathered from the Swedish Folk. With Numerous Illustra-
tions by E. Lundgren. . . . Ldn. [1882.] [I, 25.]

Part of Series ii of " The Illustrated Library of the Fairy Tales of All
Nations." The translation is by A. Alberg.

Stevens, John. See under Herrera, Antonio de.
Stevenson, Sinclair (Mrs). The Rites of the Twice-Born.

With Foreword by A. A. Macdonell, . . . Oxford. 1920.

[I, 56m1; II, 54ft1, 83, 166, 242, 257ft1 ; III, 37, 38;

IV, 259, 259ft1, 260 ; V, 145ft1 ; VI, 59 ; VII, 26, 28, 188ft1 ;

VIII, 18, 277.]

The above volume forms one of " The Religious Quest of India " Series,
edited by J. N. Farquhar and H. D. Griswold.

Stober, August. " Elsassische Sagen und Marchen." [By
several authors. Tale 16 is by A. Stober and is entitled :
" Die Here von Kaisersberg."] Alsatia Beitrage zur
elsdssischen Geschichte, Sage, Sitte und Sprache heraus. von
August Stober. 1858-1861. Mulhausen and Basel. [1862.]
Pp. 263, 264. [VIII, 107ft.]

The journal Alsatia was previously (1850) known as Neujahrs-Stollen.
Alsatia was discontinued in 1876.

Stokes, Maive. Indian Fairy Tales Collected and Translated
by . . . With Notes by Mary Stokes and an Introduction
by W. R. S. Ralston, M.A. Ldn. 1880. [I, 26, 43, 129, 131
II, 42ft1, 43ft2, 57ft1, 136ft1, 193ft1 ; III, 218, 226ft2, 280

V, 157ft1 ; VI, 16ft, 47ft1, 61, 154ft3, 250, 260 ; VII, 255

IX, 47ft1.]

The above important collection of thirty stories first appeared, privately
printed, in 1879.

312 THE OCEAN OF STORY

Stokes, Whitley. Togail Troy. The Destruction of Troy,
Transcribed from the facsimile of the Book of Leinster and
translated with a Glossarial Index of the Rarer Words.
Calcutta. 1881 [1882 on outside cover]. [II, 72n2.]

Only seventy copies printed.

Stokes, Whitley. Three Middle-Irish Homilies on the Lives
of Saints Patrick, Brigit and Columba. . . . Calcutta.
1877. [Ill, 20k1.]

Of this work there are only one hundred copies privately printed.

Storer, E. // Novellino : The Hundred Old Tales Translated

from the Italian by . . . With an Introduction. Ldn.

[1925.] See also under Biagi, G. ; Borghini, V.; and

Gualteruzzi, C. [IX, 150.]
Storey, C. A. The Fdkhir of Al-Mufaddal Ibn Salama.

Edited from Manuscripts at Constantinople and Cambridge.

Printed for the Trustees of the " De Goeje Fund." Leyden,

1915. [VI, 63.]

A part of the above treatise was printed at Constantinople in a.h. 1301,
under the title Ghayat al-arab.

Storr, F. Sophocles, with an English Translation by . . .

2 vols. 1912, 1913. Loeb Classical Librarv. [II, 127n2 ;

III, 292k1 ; V, 29/i2.]
Strack, H. L. Das Blut im Glauben u. Aberglauben der

Menschheit. Munich. 1900. [I, 98n.]
Straparola, G. F. Piacevoli Notti. [I, 44 ; II, 10n.] See

further under Waters, W. G.
Strong, H. A. The Syrian Goddess. Being a Translation of

Lucian's " De Dea Syria," with a Life of Lucian by . . .

Edited with Notes and an Introduction by John Garstang,

M.A., D.Sc. . . . Ldn. 1913. [Ill, 328.]
Stuart Baker, E. See under Baker, E. C. Stuart.
Stuart, G. A. Chinese Materia Medica. Vegetable Kingdom.

Extensively revised from Dr F. Porter Smith's work by . . .

Shanghai. 1911. [VIII, 305.]
Stumme, H. Tunisische Mdrchen und Gedichte. Eine Samm-

lung prosaischer und poelischer Stiicke im arabischen

Dialecte der Stadt Tunis nebst Einleitung und Ubersetzung

von ... 2 vols. Leipzig. 1893. (Vol. i, text ; vol. ii,

Trans.). [VIII, 227n6.]
Stumme, H. Mdrchen der Schluh von Tdzerwalt. Leipzig.

1895. [Ill, 188n; VIII, 227n8.]
Subramiah Pantulu. See under Pantulu, G. R. Subramiah.

BIBLIOGRAPHY 313

Suchier, H. Denkmaler Provenzalischer Literaiur und
Sprache, zum ersten Male herausgegeben von . . . Erster
Band. Mit einer untersuchung von Paul Rohde : Ueber
die Quellen der Romanischen Weltchronik. Halle. 1883.
[II, 289m1.]

Sukthankar, V. S. Vdsavadatta. Being a translation of an
anonymous Sanskrit drama Svapanvdsavadatta attributed to
Bhdsa. Oxford University Press. 1923. [II, 21m1.]

Sukthankar, V. S. " Studies in Bhasa." Journ. Bomb. Br.
Roy. As. Soc. Vol. xxvi. No. 2. 1923. Pp. 230-249.
[II, 21n1.]

Sully, James. An Essay on Laughter, Its Forms, Its Causes,
Its Development, and Its Value. Ldn. 1902. [VII, 253W1.]

Summers, Montague. The History of Witchcraft and
Demonology. Ldn. 1926. [IX, 146.]

This volume forms part of the " History of Civilization " Series.

Sundblad, J. Gammaldags Seder och Bruk. New, revised,
and enlarged edition. 6 parts. Stockholm. 1888. [VI,
290n\]

Sura, Arya. See under Speyer, J. S., The Gdtakamdld.

Susruta. See under Bhishagratna.

Swan, Charles. See under Wright, Thomas.

Swift, Jonathan. A City Shower. [II, 270.] Tale of a Tub.
[II, 270.] Polite Conversation. [V, 121rc2.]

Swynnerton, C. Indian Nights' Entertainment ; or, Folk-
Tales from the Upper Indus. Ldn. 1892. [I, 81n, 168 ;
III, 204.]

The above work is usually misquoted as Indian Nights' Entertainments.

Swynnerton, C. Romantic Tales from the Panjdb with
Illustrations by Native Hands collected and edited from
original sources by . . . Westminster. 1903. [VII, 261.]

The above two works were amalgamated in a single volume, as follows : —

Romantic Tales from the Panjdb with Indian Nights'
Entertainment. New Edition in One Volume. Ldn. 1908.
[V, 49711, 65.]

This work contains no illustrations or index. The total collection, consists
of ninety-seven tales, the value of which is greatly reduced by the absence of
annotations and index.

A few of the stories were issued in the Journ. As. Soc. Bengal, vol. lii, p. 81 ;
while four of the Rasalu legends were printed in the Folk-lore Journal, vol. i,
p. 129.

Syed Siraj Ul Hassan. See under Hassan, Syed Siraj IJl.
Sykes, Ella C. " Persian Folklore." Folk-Lore. Vol. xii.
1901. Pp. 261-280. [Ill, 307, 307?i2.]

814 THE OCEAN OF STORY

Sykes, P. M. A History of Persia. 2nd edit. 2 vols. Ldn.
1921. [I, 103; VI, 293w3.]
The 1st edition appeared in 1915.

Sylvain Levi. See under Levi, Sylvain.

Tachard, Gui. Voyage de Siam des Peres Jesuites envoyez
par le Roy aux Indes et a la Chine. Avec leurs observations
astronomiques, et leurs remarques de physique, de geographic,
d'hydrographie, et oVhistoire. Paris. 1686. [Ill, 308, SOSw1.]

(There were also Amsterdam editions of 1687, 1689-)

Tacitus. Annals. [I, 103 ; II, 277.]

Taine, H. A. Les Origines de la France Contemporaine. Pt. ii,

La Revolution. 3 vols. Paris. 1878-1885. [II, 185n\]
Tassy, Garcin de. See under Garcin de Tassy, J. H.
Tatius, Achilles. The Loves of Clitopho and Leucippe.

[V, 200n\]
Tavernier, J. B. See under Ball, V.
Tawney, C. H. Uttara Rama Charita, A Sanskrit Drama by

Bhavabhuti, Translated into English Prose. Calcutta. 1871.

[I, viii.]

A 2nd edition, adapted to Pundit I. C. Vidyasagara's edition of the text,
appeared in 1874, also at Calcutta.

Tawney, C. H. The Mdlavikdgnimitra. A Sanskrit Play by
Kdliddsa. Literally translated into English Prose. Calcutta.
1875. [IV, 15 ; VII, 2nK]
A 2nd edition appeared in 1891.

Tawney, C. H. Two Centuries of Bhartrihari. Translated
into English Verse. Calcutta. 1877. [I, viii, x.]

Tawney, C. H. The Tragedy of King Richard the Third.
By William Shakespeare. With an Introduction and Notes
by . . . With an Appendix by T. Cartwright, B.A., B.Sc.
(Lond.). Ldn. 1888. (Last reprint 1922.) [I, viii.] See
also under Shakespeare, William.

Tawney, C. H. The Kathdkoga; or, Treasury of Stories. Trans-
lated from Sanskrit Manuscripts. . . . With Appendix,
containing Notes, by Professor Ernst Leumann. . . .
Royal Asiatic Society. Oriental Translation Fund. New
Series, II. Ldn. 1895. [I, 40/i, 48rc2, lOln1, 121w2, 223,
224, 226 ; II, 5ft1, 108n, 113nS 219n3, 2S2n ; III, 60, 61, 62,
207n2, 279; IV, 47, 174nx; V, 17m1, 125n\ 155n\ 176;
VI, In1, 25rc3, 205n; VII, 220, 223, 254 ; VIII, 29m1.]

Tawney, C. H. The Prabandhacintdmani or Wishing-stone
of Narratives. Composed by Merutunga Acdrya. Translated

BIBLIOGRAPHY 315

from the Original Sanskrit by . . . Calcutta. 1901.

[I, 37ft2, 39ft1, 47ft; II, 108ft ; IV, 47; V, 17ft1, 125ft1,

155ft2, 176 ; VI, 229ft1 ; VII, 202.]
T[awney], C. H. " Ancient Superstitions regarding i Meeting

Eyebrows.' " The Indian Antiquary. Vol. vii. Bombay.

1878. P. 87. [II, 104ft.]
Tawney, C. H. " Some Indian Methods of Electing Kincrs."

Proc. As. Soc. Bengal. Nov. 1891. Pp. 135-138. Calcutta.

1892. [V, 176.]
Tawney, C. H., and Thomas, F. W. Catalogue of Two

Collections of Sanskrit Manuscripts preserved in the India

Office Library. Ldn. 1903. [I, ix.]
Taylor, Bayard. Faust. A Tragedy by John Wolfgang von

Goethe. Translated, in the original metres, by ... 2 vols.

Ldn. 1871. [IV, 227ft1.]
Taylor, R. Te Ika a Maui; or, New Zealand and its

Inhabitants, illustrating the Origin, Manners, Customs, . . .

and Language of the Natives. . . . 2nd edit. Ldn. 1870.

[VI, 135 ; VIII, 232ft7.]
(The 1st edition appeared in 1855.)

Tegner, Hans. See under Br^ekstad, H. L.

Teixeira, Pedro. Relaciones de Pedro Teixeira <T el Origen
Descendencia y Svccession de los Reyes de Persia, y de
Harmuz, y de vn Viage hecho por el mismo Avtor dende la
India Oriental hasta Italia por tierra. . . . Antwerp. 1610.
[I, 214.] See further under Sinclair, W. F.

For an English translation of Teixeira, readers are referred to The Travels
of Pedro Teixeira ; with his " Kings of Harmuz," and extracts from his " Kings
of Persia," W. F. Sinclair and D. Ferguson, Hakluyt Society, 2nd Series,
No. ix, Ldn., 1902. The reference to tutia will be found on p. 218.

Temple, R. C. The Legends of the Panjdb. 3 vols. Bombay.
1884, 1885, 1901. [Ill, 321.]

This important collection was to have been issued in monthly parts in the
years 1884, 1885 and 1886. Owing, however, to official duties, seven years
elapsed between the appearance of No. xxxiii and No. xxxiv (the Index) ;
and another seven years passed until No. xxxv (the Preface) was issued.
This was followed in November 1901 by the final part, No. xxxvi, which
contained an Index to the Preface. These facts account for the great scarcity
of complete sets. (There is one at the India Office and another at the Royal
Asiatic Society. The British Museum lacks the last four parts.) The whole
collection as published consists of fifty-nine legends, which, however, re-
presents only half the number collected by Sir Richard Temple. The titles
of Nos. lx-cxviii are to be found in vol. iii, pp. vi-viii, of the above work.
Several of these have since been published : see Indian Antiquary, vols, xxv,
p. 300; xxxvii, p. 149; xxxviii, pp. 81, 311, and xxxix, p. 1, where the

316 THE OCEAN OF STORY

legends were edited by H. A. Rose. He also issued six more in his Glossary
of the Tribes and Castes of the Punjab, vol. i, pp. 646-675 and 720-730.

The only other published legend from the collection is to be found in
F. W. Skemp, Multani Stories, Lahore, 1917, pp. 78-81.

Reference should also be made to Temple's article, " The Folklore in the
Legends of the Panjab," Folk-Lore, vol. x, 1899? pp- 384-443.

Temple, R. C. A Geographical Account of Countries Round
the Bay of Bengal, 1669 to 1679. By Thomas Bowrey.
Edited by . . . Hakluyt Society. Cambridge. 1905. [IV,
270; VIII, 292n3, 293nx.]

This volume forms No. xii of the 2nd Series.

Temple, R. C. The Travels of Peter Mundy in Europe and
Asia, 1608-1667. 4 vols. Hakluyt Society. Ldn. [IV, 270;
VIII, 266n6, 267n2.]

The numbers and dates of the volumes are as follows : —

Vol. i. 2nd Series. No. xvii. 1905. Vol. ii. 2nd Series.

No. xxxv. 1914. Vol. iii. 2nd Series. Pt. i, No. xlv. ; Pt. ii,

No. xlvi. 1919. Vol. iv. 2nd Series. No. lv. 1924.
Temple, R. C. " Notes on a Collection of Regalia of the

Kings of Burma of the Alompra Dynasty." Indian

Antiquary. Vol. xxxi. Nov. 1902. Pp. 442-444. [II, 264n].]
Temple, R. C. " Family Godlings as Indicators of Tribal

Migration." The Indian Antiquary. Bombay. Vol. xxxiii.

March 1904. Pp. 98-100. [II, 269n4.]
Temple, R. C. " Ritual Murder as a Means of Producing

Children." Indian Antiquary. Vol. Hi. May 1923. Pp. 113-

115. [I, 154n*.]
Temple, R. C. See also under Steel, F. A., and Temple,

R. C.
Tendlau, A. M. Das Buch der Sagen und Legenden judischer

Vorzeit. Nach den Quellen bearbeitet nebst Anmerkungen

und Erlduierungen. 2nd edit., enlarged. Stuttgart. 1845.

[Ill, 59.]
Tennyson, A. Vivien. [VI, in1.]
Terence (Terentius Afer). Eunuchus. [Ill, 6n2.] Phormio.

[IV, 138n1.]
Tertullian. Ad Nationes. [Ill, 131n3.]
Tha'labi. Qisas al-anbiya\ Cairo, a.h. 1314. [VI, 63.]
Theocritus. Idyllia (the Idylls). [V, 201n ; VI, 24n.] See

also under Fritsche, A. T. A.
Theophrastus (6EO$PACTOY). See under Jebb, R. C.
Thietmar (Dietmar or Dithmar) of Merseburg. See under

Pertz, G. H.

BIBLIOGRAPHY 317

Thiselton-Dyer, T. F. Folk-Lore of Plants. Ldn. 1889.
[Ill, 154.]

Thomas, A. " Les Proverbs de Guylem de Cerveras (Poeme
Catalan du XII0 Siecle)." Romania. Recueil Trimestriel
consacre a V Etude des Langues et des hitter atures, Romanes.
Tom. xv. Paris. 1886. Pp. 25-110. [II, 292, 292na.]

Thomas, E. J. See under Francis, H. T., and Thomas, E. J.

Thomas, E. J. " Sun, Moon and Stars (Buddhist)." Hastings'
Ency.Rel.Eth. Vol. xii. 1921. Pp. 71-73. [11,81.]

Thomas, F. W. " The Plays of Bhasa." Journ. Roy. As. Soc.
Jan. 1922. Pp. 79-83. [II, 2lnK]

Thomas, F. W. " Chandragupta, the Founder of the Maurya
Empire." The Cambridge History of India. Vol. i. Cam-
bridge. 1922. Chap, xviii. Pp. 467-473. [II, 282W1.]

Thomas, F. W. See also under Tawney, C. H., and Thomas,
F. W.

Thomas, N. W. " Animals." Hastings' Ency. Rel. Eth.
Vol. i. 1908. Pp. 483-535. [I, 134n* ; II, 240 ; III, 170^.]

Thompson, C. J. S. Poison Mysteries in History, Romance
and Crime. Scientific Press, Ldn. 1923. [II, 281.]

Thompson, E. " The Suppression of Suttee in Native States."
The Edinburgh Review. No. 500. Vol. ccxlv. April 1927.
Pp. 274-286. [IX, 155.]

Thompson, R. Campbell. The Devils and Evil Spirits of
Babylonia, being Babylonian and Assyrian Incantations
against the Demons, Ghouls, Vampires, Hobgoblins, Ghosts
and kindred evil spirits, which attack mankind. ... 2 vols.
Ldn. 1903, 1904. [II, 61m1 ; VI, 138.]

Forming vols, xiv and xv of Luzac's Semitic Text and Translation Series.

Thompson, R. Campbell. Semitic Magic: Its Origins and
Development. Forming vol. iii of Luzac's Oriental Religious
Series. Ldn. 1908. [II, 99n, 19Sn\ 295 ; III, 38.]

Thompson, R. Campbell. " The Golden Age of Hammurabi,"
being; chap, xiv of The Cambridge Ancient History. Cam-
bridge. 1923. Pp. 494-551. [I, 271n\]

Thomson, B. See under Amherst of Hackney, Lord, and
Basil Thomson.

Thorburn, S. S. Bannu ; or Our Afghan Frontier. Ldn.
1876. [I, 43; V, 127m1.]

About fifty tales are included in the above work.

Thorndike, Lynn. A History of Magic and Experimental
Science during the First Thirteen Centuries of Our Era.
2 vols. Ldn. 1923. [I, 77nx ; II, 99w, 108n, 288n3, 295W1,
299n2, 299n4 ; III, 57, 162n; V, 201w.]

318 THE OCEAN OF STORY

Thorpe, Benjamin. Yule-Tide Stories. A Collection of
Scandinavian and North German Popular Tales and
Traditions, from the Swedish, Danish, and German. Ldn.
1853. Bonn's Antiquarian Library. [I, 25, 48n2, 147ft2,
166; II, 76>*1. SO/?1. 190ft1 ; III, 48ft1, 205, 225ft2, 226ft2,
236. 237 ; VI, 21)1 ft-.]

Thumb, A. " Zur neuorieehiselien Volkskunde." Zeitschrift
dfs Vereins fur Volkskunde. Im Auftrage des Vereins
herausgegeben von Karl Weinhold. Vol. ii. Berlin. 1892.
Pp. 123-134. [VIII, 117ft2.]

Thurn, E. Im. Sec under Im Thurn, E.

Thurston, Edgar. Ethnographic Notes in Southern India.
With 40 Plates. Madras. 1906. [I, 258ft2; II, 7ft1, 166,
256, 256»4; III, 46>r, 306ft3 ; IV, 122ft1, 171ft1, 245ft1.]

Thurston, Edgar. Castes and Tribes of Southern India. . . .
Assisted by K. Rangaehari, M.A. ... 9 vols. Govern-
ment Press, Madras! 1909. [I, 234ft3, 253, 258, 258ft2,
259, 265: II, 166, 256, 256ft4; III, 101ft, 325; VIII,
109ft3, 112ft1, 275ft1, 275ft2, 275-283.]

Thurston, Edgar. Omens and Superstitions in Southern
India. Ldn. 1912. [Ill, 306ft3.]

Thurston, E. See also under Watt, George.

Tiele, P. A. See under Burnell, A. C.

Title, Vaclav. Verzeichuis der Bohmischen Marchen. Vol. vi.
Helsinki. 1921. FF Communications No. 34. [VIII, 107ft ;
IX, 141.]

This series is edited for the Folklore Fellows by Johannes Bolte, Oskar
Hackman. Kaarle Krohn and C. W. von Sydow.

Tobler, O. Die Epiphanie der Seele in deutscher Volkssage.
Kiel. 1911. [VIII, 107ft.]

The above " Dissertation " is not in the British Museum, and I have not
personally seen it.

Tod, James. Annals and Antiquities of Rajasfhan, or the
Central and Western Rajpoot States of India. 2 vols. Ldn.
1829-1832. (2nd edit., Madras, 1873. Popular edition,
Ldn., 1914. New edition, 1920, by W. Crooke.) [11,305ft1;
VI, 22 On1.]

Torquemada, F. Juan de. La Monarquia Indiana. Madrid.
1723. [Ill, 150, 151.]

Touche, La. See under La Touche, T. H. D.

Traill, G. W. See under Batten, J. H.

Trebovsky, F. (i.e. F. M. KlAcel). Bdjky [Bidpajovy],
temdr do viech jazyku ji: preloiene, po desku vzdelane od

BIBLIOGRAPHY 319

. . . Pt. i, Olomouc (Olmutz), 1846 ; Pt. ii, Brn£ (Briinn),
1850. [V, 237.]

For further details see F. Doucha, Knihopisny Slovnik cesko-slovenskp,
Praze, 1865, p. IS.

Tremearne, A. J. N. Hausa Superstitions and Customs.
An Introduction to the Folk-Lore and the Folk. Ldn. 1913.
[Ill, 312, 312m1.]

Tremearne, A. J. N. The Ban of the Bori. Demons and
Demon-Darning in West and North Africa. Ldn. 1914 (date
at end of Foreword). [Ill, 38, 312, 312m1 ; VII, 231n\]

Trenckner, V. Pali Miscellany. Pt. I, containing a Speci-
men of the Milindapahho-Teort, Translation and Notes. Ldn.
1879. [I, 12n*.]

Trilles, Pere H. Proverbes, Legendes et Contes Fangs.
Neuchatel. 1905. [Ill, 105w.]

Troyer, A. See under Shea, D., and Troyer, A.

Trumbull, H. C. The Blood Covenant. Ldn. 1887. [I, 98n.]

Tschudi, J. J. von. Reisen dilrch Sudamerika. 5 vols.
Leipzig. 1866-1869. [II, 280n6.]

Turner, G. Samoa a Hundred Years ago, and long before ;
together with Notes on the Cults and Customs of Twenty-
three other Islands in the Pacific ; with a Preface by E. B.
Tylor. Ldn. 1884. [VIII, 232w5.]

Tylor, E. B. Primitive Culture : Researches into the Develop-
ment of Mythology, Philosophy, Religion, Language, Art and
Custom. 2 vols. Ldn. 1871. (2nd edit. 1873 ; 3rd edit.
1891.) [II, 83, 96nx, 103™1 ; III, 30m1, 185m1; IV, 64nx,
145ft1 ; V, 121W1, 179ft1 ; IX, 154.]

For full details of other editions, translations, etc., see Anthropological
Essays Presented to E. B. Tylor, Oxford, 1907, p. 379-

Tylor, E. B. "Eunuch." Ency. Brit. 11th edit. 1910-1911.

Vol. ix. Pp. 890, 891. [Ill, 328.]
Tylor, E. B. See also under Turner, G.
Uhle, H. Programm des Gymnasiums zum heiligen Kreuz

in Dresden. . . . Erste Abtheilung. Die funfzehnte Erzah-

lung der Vetdlapantchavin^ati . . . mit Uebersetzung und

Anmerkungen von . . . Dresden. 1877. [V, 267.]
Uhle, H. Die Vetdlapancavingatikd in den Recensionen des

Civaddsa und eines Ungenannten mit hritischen Commentar.

Leipzig. 1881. [VI, 225n4, 261, 261W1, 261n3, 267, 273w4,

273n5.]

This forms the first part of vol. viii of :

320 THE OCEAN OF STORY

Abhandlungen fiir die Kunde des Morgenlandes heraus-
gegeben von der Deutschen Morgenldndischen Gesellschqft
unter der verantwortlichen Redaction des Prof. Dr E.
Windisch. Leipzig. 1884.
Uhle, H. Die Vetdlapancavims'atikd des Sivadasa nach einer
Handschrift von 1487 (Samv. 1544). Text mit kritischen
Apparat nebst einer Inhaltsangabe der Erzahlungen von . . .
Leipzig. 1914. [V. 26&]

This forms vol. lxvi, pp. 3-87, of:

Berichte iiber die Verhandlungen der Kbniglich sdchsischen
Gesellschaft der Wissenschaften zu Leipzig. Phil.-IIist.
Klasse.
Ullah, 'Izzat. Gul-i Bakdwdli (Rose of Bakawali). [VI, 60 ;
VII, 224, 224ft1.]

The English translation is contained in W. A. Clouston's Eastern Romances
(q.V.).

Underdowne, Thomas. An ^Ethiopian History written in
Greek by Heliodorus. Englished by . . . anno 1587. With an
Introduction by Charles Whibley. Ldn. 1895. [VI, 51ft1.]

Forming vol. v of the Tudor Translations.

Unger, R. " Zur Sirenensage." Philologrs. Zeitschrift fur

das klassische Alterthum. Vol. xlvi. Gottingen. 1888.

Pp. 770-775. [VI, 282ft6.]
Ungnad, A. See under Kohler, J. ; Peiser, F. E. ; and

Ungnad, A.
Upham, E. The Mahdvansi, Rdjd-Ratnacari, and Raja-vali,

forming the Sacred and Historical Books of Ceylon ; also a

Collection of Tracts on Buddhism. Translated from the

Singhalese. 3 vols. Ldn. 1833. [V, 73ft1.]
Upreti, G. D. Proverbs and Folklore of Kumaun and

Garhwal. Lodiana. 1894. [V, 64, 65.]

The collection consists of one hundred and twenty-five stories, chiefly
fables.

Uri, J. Epistolo3 Turcicce ac Narrationes Persica; editoe et
Latine converses. Oxonii. 1771. [VI, 265, 265n2.] See
further under Muhasstn ibn 'Ali at-Tanukhi.

Utgikar, N. B. " The Story of the Dataratha Jataka and
of the Ramayana." Journ. Roy. As. Soc. Centenary
Supplement. Oct'. 1924. Pp. 203-211. [IX, 154.]

Utgikar, N. B. See also under Winternitz, M., " Serpent
Sacrifice ..."

Uzanne, O. VOmbrelle. Le Gant — Le Manchon. Paris.
1883. [II, 272.]

BIBLIOGRAPHY 321

Uzanne, O. The Sunshade : the Glove — the Muff. Translated

from the French. Ldn. 1883. [II, 272.]
Uzanne, O. Petites Monographies cTArt. Les Ornaments de

la Femme. Paris. 1892. [II, 272.]
Valecka, E. Bdjky Bidpajovy. Praha (Prague). [1894.]

[V, 237.]

In view of Prof. Edgerton's remarks in vol. v, p. 237, 1 put Valecka as the
author. He was, however, the publisher — but in this case was apparently
the author as well. The work was issued in nine sections and totals 354 pages.
These are all the details I can discover.

Valerius Flaccus. Argonautica. [I, 190.]

Valle, Pietro della. Travels. [II, 162n ; III, 85n.] See
further under Grey, Edward.

Vallee Poussin. See under Poussin, L. de la Vallee.

Valmiki. See under Carey, W. ; Dutt, Manmatha Nath ;
and Griffith, R. T. II.

Van Limburg-Brouwer, P. A. S. Akbar, an Eastern
Romance. Translated from the Dutch by M. M. With
Notes and an Introductory Life of the Emperor Akbar by
C.R.Markkam. Ldn. 1879. [IV, 159n\]

Varnhagen, F. A. de. Colloquios dos Simples e drogas e
cousas medicinaes da India e assi de algumas fructas achadas
nella (v arias cultivadas hoje no Brazil) compost os pelo
Doutor Garcia de Orta. . . . Feita, proximamente pagina
por pagina, pela primeira, impressa em Goa por Joito de
Endem no anno de 1563. Lisbon. 1872. [VIII, 243, 243w3,
245.]

The editor's name appears at the end of the Preface.

See also under Colin,A. ; L'E(s)cluse, Charles de ; Markham, Clements ;
and Orta, Garcia da.

Varnhagen, H. Ein indisches Marchen auf seiner Wanderung

durch die asiatischen und europdischen Litteraturen. Berlin.

1882. [I, 40w.]
Varthema, Ludovico di. See under Badger, G. P.
Vassal, G. M. On & Off Duty in Annam. With numerous

Illustrations from Photographs taken by the Author.

Ldn. 1910. [VIII, 287n3.]
Vats yay ana. See under [Burton, R. F., and Arbuthnot,

F. F.], Kama Sutra.
Vattel, E. de. Le Droit des Gens, ou Principes de la hoi

Naturelle appliques a la Conduite et aux Affaires des Nations

et des Souverains. The Classics of International Law.

Washington. 1916. [II, 278, 278W1, 279.]

Vols, i and ii are photographic reproductions of the 1st edition of 1758

and vol. iii is a translation of the same by C. G. Fenwick.

VOL. IX. x

322 THE OCEAN OF STORY

Vaux, Carra de. See under Carra de Vaux, Bon B.
Veckenstedt, E. Wendische Sagen, Mdrchen und aber-

gldubische Gebrduche. Graz. 1880. [I, 26, 51nx, 108n3, 129,

141n2; II, 4>2n\ 98n4, I07n\ 152n4, 155n\ 202nJ, 223n* ;

III, 131n3, 133ns 187n3, 191ns 225n2, 238, 253nx ; IV,

245nx ; V, lOOn1 ; VI, 28n2, 36nx, 280; IX, 45n\]
Vedel, Valdemar. " Den Andersenske Eventyrdigtning.

H. Brix : H. C. Andersen og hans Eventyr." Tilskueren.

Copenhagen. June 1907. Pp. 494-502. [VI, 293.]
Vedel, Valdemar. " H. C. Andersen's Eventyr i europaeisk

Belysning." Tilskueren. Copenhagen. Jan. 1926. Pp.

43-56. [VI, 293.]
Velten, C. Mdrchen und Erzdhlungen der Suaheli. Stuttgart

and Berlin. 1898. [Ill, 280.]
Verard,Antoine. LeCuerdePhilosophie. Circal507. [11,293.]
Vernaleken, T. Osterreichische Kinder- und Hausmdrchen.

Treu nach mundlicher Uberlieferung. Vienna. 1864.

[Ill, 272ns]
Vernieux, C. The Hermit of Motee Jhurna, or Pearl Spring ;

also Indian Tales and Anecdotes, Moral and Instructive.

2nd edit, recast and enlarged. Calcutta. 1873. [II, 114n.]
Vidyasagara, I. C. See under Tawney, C. H., Uttara Rama

Charita.
Vidyasagara, Jibananda. Kathasaritsagara, or Ocean of

the Streams of Story rendered into Sanskrit Prose from the

Poem of SomadevaBhattaby . . . Calcutta. 1883. [V, 236.]
Vignau, M. Du. Le Secretaire Turc, Contenant VArt

aVexprimer ses pensees sans se voir, sans se parler & sans

s'ecrire, avec les circonstances aVune Avanture Turque, & une

Relation tres-curieuse de plusieurs p articular itez du Serrail

qui n'avoient point encore este sceues. Paris. 1688. [I, 81n.]
Vigne, G. T. Travels in Kashmir, Ladak, Iskardo, the

Countries adjoining the Mountain-Course of the Indus,

and the Himalaya, North of the Punjab. 2 vols. Ldn.

1842. [IV, 272.]
Vincent de Beauvais. Incipit Specvlvm Historiale. . . .

2 vols. 1473. [VI, 272, 272n5.]
Vincent, A. L., and Binns, C. Gilles de Rais : The Original

Bluebeard. Introduction by M. Hamblin Smith. Ldn. 1926.

[IX, 147.]
Virchow, R. Verhandlungen der Berliner Gesellschaft fur

Anthropologic, Ethnologie und Urgeschichte. Redigirt von . . .

Berlin. 1899. [II, 308n2.]

The above was a Supplement contained in Vols, iii-xxxiv (1871-1902) of
the Zeit.fur Ethnologie. . . .

BIBLIOGRAPHY 323

Virchow, R. See also under Steinschneider, M.

Virc.il, JEneid. [II, 186W1 ; VII, 228nx ; VIII, 49wx (see also
under Forbiger, A.), 141n2 ; IX, 44W1.] Eclogues. [VI,
24n.] Georgics. [VIII, 49m1.]

Visakhadatta. See under Chakravarti, S. C.

Visentini, I. Fiabe Mantovane raccolte da . . . Canti e
Racconti del Popoli Italiano. Vol. vii. Torino, Roma.
1879. [Ill, 76.]

Vishnugupta. See under Kau'tilya.

Vitruvius. De Architectura Decern. [Ill, 56, 57.]

Vizetelly, E. A. Bluebeard: An Account of Comorre the
Cursed and Gilles de Rats. With Summaries of various
Tales and Traditions. . . . Ldn. 1902. [II, 224w.]

Vladimirtsov, B. J. Eine Mongolische Sammlung Erzah-
lungen aus dem Pancatantra. Vol. v, Pt. ii of Publications
du Musee oV Anthropologic et d'Ethnographie pres VAcademie
des Sciences de Russie. Petrograd. 1921. [V, 242.]

The original name and title was as follows : —

Vladimircov, B. J. Mongol* skii sbornik ~ razskazov iz
Pancatantra. Sbornik Muzeya Antropologii i Ethnografi
pri Rossiisko'i Akademii Nauk. Vol. v. Petrograd. 1921.

Vullers, J. A. Tarafce Moallaca cum Zuzenii Scholiis.
Teoctum . . . emendatum Latine vertit . . . indicem
Arabicum addidit . . . Paris. 1829. [Ill, 279.]

Waddell, L. A. Discovery of the Exact Site of Asokd's
Classic Capital of Pdtaliputra, the Palibothra of the Greeks
and Description of the superficial Remains. Calcutta.
1892. [II, 39W1.]

Waddell, L. A. The Buddhism of Tibet, of Lamaism . . .,
Ldn. 1895. [II, 142m1 ; VI, 14W*.]

Waddell, L. A. " Burmese Buddhist Rosaries." Pro-
ceedings of the Asiatic Society of Bengal. Dec. 1892
(publ. 1893). Pp. 189-191. [VI, 14W1.]

Waddell, L. A. "Bhutan, Buddhism in." Hastings' Ency.
Rel. Eth. Vol. ii. 1909. Pp. 561-562. [VII, 33nx.]

Wtadia, P. D. H. " Folklore in Western India." Indian
Antiquary. Bombay. Vols, xiv, 1885, pp. 311-313
xv, 1886, pp. 2-6, 46-47, 171-172, 221-222, 365-368
xvi, 1887, pp. 28-31, 188-194, 210-214, 322-327; xvii
1888, pp. 75-81, 128-132 ; xviii, 1889, pp. 21-26, 146-151
xix, 1890, pp. 152-155; xx, 1891, pp. 107-110; xxi
1892, pp. 160-166; xxii, 1893, pp. 213-219, 315-321
xxiii, 1894, pp. 160-164. [I, 131 ; IV, 182.]
The collection contains twenty stories in all.

324 THE OCEAN OF STORY

Waite, A. E. The Hermetic and Alchemical Writings of
Aureolus Philippics Theophrastus Bombast, of Hohenheim,
called Paracelsus the Great. Now for the first time translated
into English. ... 2 vols. Ldn. 1894. [Ill, 162ft.]

Waite, A. E. The Book of Black Magic and of Pacts, including
Rites and Mysteries of Goetic Theurgy, Sorcery, and Infernal
Necromancy. Ldn. 1898. (Privately printed.) [Ill, 203.]

Wake, C. Staniland. Serpent-Worship, and Other Essays ;
with a Chapter on Totemism. Ldn. 1888. [Ill, 142ft1.]

Waldait, A. Bohmisches Marchenbuch. Prag. 1860. [I, 20ft,
26 ; II, 76ft1, 190ft1 ; III, 48ft1, 152, 191ft1, 227ft ; IV, 230ft2 ;
V, 53ft2, 130ft1 ; VI, 36ft1, 73ft3, 94ft1, 136, 277, 279 ; VII,
3ft2, 61ft1 ; IX, 37ft1.]

Walhouse, M. J. " On the Belief in Bhutas — Devil and
Ghost Worship in Western India." Journal of the Anthro-
pological Institute. Vol. v. Ldn. 1876. Pp. 408-422.
[VI, 139.]

Walhouse, M. J. " Archaeological Notes." Indian Antiquary.
Vol. ix. Bombay. 1880. Pp. 71-73, 150-153, 296-299.
[V, 179ft1.]

Wallace, A. R. A Narrative of Travels on the Amazon and
Rio Negro, with an Account of the Native Tribes, and
Observations on the Climate, Geology, and Natural History
of the Amazon Valley. Ldn. 1853. [II, 280ft7.]

Wallis, W. D. " Prodigies and Portents." Hastings' Ency.
Rel. Eth. Vol. x. 1918. Pp. 362-376. [II, 83.]

Walshe, W. G. " Chastity (Chinese)." Hastings' Ency. Rel.
Eth. Vol. iii. 1910. Pp. 490-491. [Ill, 172ft2.]

Walter, N. See under Chamberlain, B. H.

Ward, W. A View of the History, Literature and Religion of
the Hindoos. 2nd edit. 4 vols. Serampore. 1815-1818.
[I, 241, 241ft4, 242.]

Ward, W. H. The Seal Cylinders of Western Asia. Carnegie
Institution of Washington. Publication No. 100. 1910.
[I, 272ft3.]

Wardrop, M. Georgian Folk-Tales. Ldn. 1894. The Grimm
Library, No. 1. [Ill, 204 ; VI, 123ft.]

Warneck, J. " Studien iiber die Litteratur der Toba-Batak."
Mittheilungen des Seminars fur Orientalische Sprachen . . .
zu Berlin. Vol. ii, Pt. i, Ostasiatische Studien. . . . Berlin
and Stuttgart. 1899. Pp. 101-139. [VIII, 231ft6.]

Warren, S. Nirayavaliyasuttam, een updnga der Jamais.
Met inleiding, aanteckeningen en glossaar, van . . .

BIBLIOGRAPHY 325

Koninklijke Akademie van Wetenschappen. Amsterdam.

1879. [I, 223.]
Waterfield, W. The Lay of Alha. A Saga of Rajput

Chivalry as sung by Minstrels of Northern India. Partly

Translated in English Ballad Metre by the late . . ., with

an Introduction and abstracts of the untranslated portions by

Sir George Grierson. . . . Oxford, University Press. 1923.

[IX, 153.]
Waters, W. G. The Nights of Straparola. Now First

Translated into English by . . . Illustrated by E. R.

Hughes, ... 2 vols. Ldn. 1894. [I, 46n2 ; III, 76, 205 ;

V, 158rc.]
Waters, W. G. The Novellino of Masuccio. Now First

Translated into English by ... 2 vols. Ldn. 1895. [Ill,

287711.]
Waters, W. G. The Precorone of Ser Giovanni. Now first

translated into English by . . . Illustrated by E. R.

Hughes, . . . Ldn. 1897. [V, 267.]
Watt, George. A Dictionary of the Economic Products of

India. . . . Assisted by Numerous Contributors. 6 vols.

Calcutta. 1889-1896. [II, 280n\ 304ft1 ; VII, 105, 106,

107, 249?i2 ; VIII, 7n\ 7n\ Sn1, 18, 65ft1, 96m1, 96ft2, 96ft3,

96ft5, 243ft2, 247, 249, 318ft1.]

In reality the work is in ten volumes, as vol. vi is in four parts, each of

which forms a distinct volume.

The tenth volume is the Index, published in 1896, three years after the

last Part of vol. vi. It was prefaced by E. Thurston, with the assistance of

T. N. Mukerji of the Indian Museum, Calcutta.

Watt, George. The Commercial Products of India; being
an Abridgement of " The Dictionary of the Economic Pro-
ducts of India." Ldn. 1908. [II, 280ft1, 304ft1.]

Weber, A. Verzeichniss der Sanskrit-Handschriften. Berlin.
1853. [II, 286, 286ft4.]

This catalogue forms vol. i of Die Handschriften-Verzeichnisse der Kiiniglichen
Bibliothek.

Weber, A. Indische Streifen. 3 vols. Berlin, 1868, 1869.

Leipzig, 1879. [II, 252W1.]
Weber, A. " Ueber den Zusammenhang indischer Fabeln

mit griechischen." Indische Studien. Vol. iii. Berlin.

1855. Pp. 327-373. [V, ISOn1.]
Weber, A. Ueber das (Jatrunjaya Mdhdtmyam. Ein Beitrag

zur Geschichte der Jaina. Abhandlungen fur die Kunde

des Morgenlandes. Vol. i. (No. 4.) Leipzig. 1858. [VII,

214711.]

826 THE OCEAN OF STORY

Weber, A. " Ueber die heiligen Schriften der Jaina."
Indische Studien. Beitrdge fiir die Kunde des indischen
Alterthums. Vol. xvi. Leipzig. 1883. Pp. 211-479. [VI,
69^.]

This periodical consists of seventeen volumes, 1850-1885, of which the
first eight volumes were published at Berlin and the rest at Leipzig.

Weber, H. W. Tales of the East, comprising the most popular

Romances of Oriental Origin. 3 vols. Edinburgh. 1812.

[I, 25.]
Webster, H. C. See under Cayley- Webster, H.
Webster, John. The Dutchess of Malfey. [II, 2n* ; VIII,

54m1, 156W1.]
Weeks, J. H. Among the Primitive Bakongo : A Record of

Thirty Years' close Intercourse with the Bakongo and other

Tribes of Equatorial Africa. . . . Ldn. 1914. [Ill, 313,

313W1.]
Weeks, J. H. " Notes on some Customs of the Lower

Congo People." Folk-Lore. Vols, xix, 1908, pp. 409-437 ;

and xx, 1909, pp. 32-63, 181-201, 304-311, 457-480. [Ill,

313, 313^.]
Weicker, G. De Serenibus qiuestiones selector. Leipzig. 1895.

[VI, 282ti6.]
Weicker, G. Der Seelenvogel in der alten Literatur und

Kunst. Leipzig. 1902. [VI, 283n2.]
Weicker, G. " Die Sirenen." Roscher's Ausfuhrliches

Lexikon der Griechischen und Romischen Mythologie. Vol. iv.

Leipzig. 1909-1915. Cols. 601-639. [VI, 282n6.]
Weil, G. Tausend und Eine Nacht. ... 4 vols. Stuttgart.

1837-1841. [IX, 82n*.]
Weinhold, Karl. See under Paris, G., and Thumb, A.

Weinreich, Otto. Senecas Apocolocyntosis. Die Satire

auf Tod, Himmel- und Hollenfahrt des Kaisers Claudius.

Berlin. 1923. [IX, 155.]
Welsford, E. " Serpent- Worship (Teutonic and Balto-

Slavic)." Hastings' Ency. Rel. Eth. Vol. xi. 1920. Pp. 419-

423. [I, 203, 204.]
Werner, E. T. C. China of the Chinese. Ldn. 1919. [IV,

257711.]
Wesselski, A. Marchen des Mittelalters. Berlin. 1925.

[VIII, 117n2 ; IX, 149, 155.]

The collection consists of sixty-six tales, with full and useful notes at the
end of the volume.

BIBLIOGRAPHY 327

West, E. W. Pahlavi Texts translated by . . . Sacred Books

of the East. Vols, v, xviii, xxiv, xxxvii and xlvii. Oxford.

1880-1897. [Ill, 307n\]
Westermarck, E. Marriage Ceremonies in Morocco. Ldn.

1914. [I, 217.]
Westermarck, E. The History of Human Marriage. In

Three Volumes. Fifth Edition Rewritten. Ldn. 1921.

[II, 18, 19, 23n, 24w, 306rax ; IV, 255w2, 258 ; VI, 265w3 ;

VII, 231711.]

The 1st edition was in one volume, and appeared in 189L

Westermarck, E. The Origin and Development of the Moral
Ideas. 2nd edit. Ldn. 1924 (vol. i), 1917 (vol. ii). (1st edit.
1906, 1908. The 2nd edit, of vol. i first appeared in 1912.)
[II, 96W1, 97n, 227n2 ; III, 38, 328 ; IV, 202W1.]

Westermarck, Edward. Ritual and Belief in Morocco.
2 vols. Ldn. 1926. [VIII, 100n.]

Wheeler, Talboys. See under Chunder, Bholanauth.

Wheeler, W. A. A Dictionary of the Noted Names of Fiction ;
including also Familiar Pseudonyms, Surnames bestowed
on eminent men, and Analogous Popidar Appellations often
referred to in literature and conversation. Bohn's Philo-
logical Library. Ldn. 1866. [IV, 145n2.]

Whewell, W. Hugonis Grotii De Jure Belli et Pacis Libri
Tres. Accompanied by an Abridged Translation. 3 vols.
Cambridge. 1853. [II, 277w2.]

White, John. The Ancient History of the Maori, his Myth-
ology and Traditions. Horo-Uta or Taki-Tumu migration.
6 vols. Wellington. 1887-1890. [VIII, 232w7.]

Each volume contains the English translation followed by the original
Maori text, with a separate title-page. That of vol. i is dated 1886, while that
of vol. vi is 1889. Four out of the six volumes were also published in London
in 1889. The original title-pages of the Maori portion of each volume, however,
remained unaltered.

White, W. G. The Sea Gypsies of Malaya. An Account of the
Nomadic Mawken People of the Mergui Archipelago, with
a Description of their Ways of Living, Customs, Habits,
Boats, Occupations, &c, &c, &c, by . . . With a Foreword
by R. R. Marrett, M.A., D.Sc, F.R.A.I. . . . Ldn. 1922.
[VIII, 287n2.]

Whitney, W. D. Atharva-Veda Samhita. Translated with a
Critical and Exegetical Commentary by . . . Revised . .
and edited by C. R. Lanman. 2 vols. Harvard Oriental
Series. Vols, vii and viii. Cambridge, Mass. 1905. [IV,
263.]

328 THE OCEAN OF STORY

Wickerhauser, M. Die Papageimarchen. Leipzig. 1858.
[VI, 265W1, 269nx, 271ft1, 272n2 ; VII, 222n3, 241n3.]

Wickham, E. C. Clarendon Press Series : Quinti Horatii
Flacci Opera Omnia. The Works of Horace, with a Com-
mentary by . . . 2 vols. Oxford. 1874,1891. [VIII, 99n2.]

Widter, G. See under Wolf, A.

Wilhelm, R. Chinesische Volksmarchen. tJbersetzt und
eingeleitet von . . . Jena. 1921. Forming part of the
" Die Marchen der Weltliteratur " Series. [IX, 143.]

Wilken, G. A. " Jets over Schedelvereering bij de volken
van den Indischen Archipel." Bijdragen tot de Taal- Land-
en Volkenkunde van Nederlandsch- Indie. Vol. iv. 1889.
Pp. 89-121. [VIII, 297ft1.]

Wilkins, C. The Heetopddes of Veeshnoo Sarmd, in a Series
of connected Fables, interspersed with Moral, Prudential,
and Political Maxims ; translated from an Ancient Manu-
script in the Sanskreet Language. With explanatory Notes
by . . . Bath. 1787. [V, 210.]

Wilkins, C. Fables and Proverbs from the Sanskrit : being
the Hitopadesa. Translated by . . ., With an Introduction
by Henry Morley. Ldn. 1885. [V, 210.]

Wilkins, W. J. Hindu Mythology, Vedic and Purdnic.
Calcutta. 1882. [VIII, 77ft2.]

Wilkinson, J. G. The Manners and Customs of the Ancient
Egyptians. A new Edition, Revised and Corrected by
Samuel Birch, LL.D., D.C.L. ... 3 vols. Ldn. 1878.
[I, 215 ; II, 264 ; III, 116ft.]

Wilkinson, R. J. Papers on Malay Subjects. 5 vols, and one
Supplementary. Kuala Lumpur. 1907-1911. [II, 167.]

The papers in question comprise : Malay Literature, Industries, History,
Life & Customs, Law, and Aboriginal Tribes (Suppl.).

Wilkinson, R. J. See also under Hurgronje, C. Snouck.

Williams, Monier. Nalopdkhydnam. Story of Nala, An
Episode of the Mahd-Bhdrata : The Sanskrit Text, with a
copious Vocabulary, Grammatical Analysis, and Introduc-
tion by . . . The Metrical Translation by the Very Rev.
H. H. Milman. Oxford. 1860. [IV, 278.]

Williams, Monier. Indian Wisdom or Examples of the
Religious, Philosophical, and Ethical Doctrines of the
Hindus. . . . Ldn. 1875. [I, 12ft2 ; IV, 256 ; VI, 92ft1.]
See also under Milman, H. H.

Williams, Monier Monier-. Buddhism, in its Connexion
with Brahmanism and Hinduism, and in its Contrast with
Christianity. 2nd edit. Ldn. 1890. [VIII, lft4.]

BIBLIOGRAPHY 329

Williamson, R. W. The Mafulu Mountain People of British
New Guinea. With an Introduction by A. C. Haddon.
Ldn. 1912. [VIII, 313nx.]

Williamson, R. W. The Social and Political Systems of
Central Polynesia. 3 vols. Cambridge. 1924. [VIII, 310W1.]

Wills, C. J. See under Morier, James.

Wilmot, S. E. The Life of an Elephant. Ldn. 1912. [VI,
68n.]

Wilsen, F. C. See under Leemans, C.

Wilson, Henry. See under Keate, George.

Wilson, H. H. Mackenzie Collection. A Descriptive Cata-
logue of the Oriental Manuscripts, and other articles
Illustrative of the Literature, History, Statistics and
Antiquities of the South of India ; Collected by the Late
Lieut.-Col. Colin Mackenzie, Surveyor -General of India.
2 vols. Calcutta. 1828. Reprinted in 1 vol. Calcutta.
1882. [I, 131 ; II, 121, 123.]

Wilson, H. H. The Dasa Kumdra Charita, or Adventures of
Ten Princes. A Series of Tales, in the Original Sanskrit.
By Sri Dariai. Edited by . . . Ldn. Oriental Translation
Fund. 1846. [I, 234, 234rc4 ; V, 153W1.]

Wilson, H. H. Works by the Late Horace Hayman Wilson,

M.A., FM.S. ... 12 vols. Ldn. 1863-1877. [I, In2,

7n\ 17n3, 25, 57n3, 75n\ 118n2, 162nx, 200; II, 92w4,

189nS 192W1, 214, 241, 248, 258, 259, 283n3 ; III, 84m1.]

In order to facilitate reference, the following details show the contents of
each volume :

i, ii. Essays and Lectures chiefly on the Religion of the
Hindus. Collected and edited by Dr Reinhold Rost.
2 vols. Ldn. 1862.

There is a separate index to each volume. The volumes are made up chiefly
of reprints from Asiatick Researches, Journ. Roy. As. Soc., and Quart. Orient.
Mag.

iii, iv, v. Essays Analytical, Critical and Philological on
subjects connected with Sanskrit Literature. Collected and
Edited by Dr Reinhold Rost. 3 vols. Ldn. 1864-1865.

The Index to these three volumes is in the third volume — i.e. vol. v of the
Works. They include papers on Hindu Fiction, the Mahabharata, Pancha-
tahtra, Dasa-Kumara-charita, etc., reprinted from the Journ. Roy. As. Soc. of
London, and of Bengal ; British and Foreign Review ; Trans. Philol. Soc. ;
Edinburgh Review, etc.

vi-x. The Vishnu Purdria : A System of Hindu Mythology
and Tradition. Translated from the Original Sanskrit, and
Illustrated by Notes derived chiefly from other Pur arias, . . .

330 THE OCEAN OF STORY

Edited by Fitzedward Hall, M.A., D.C.L.Oxon. 5 vols.
1864-1877 (1st edit. O. T. F. 1840.)

Vol. x was published in two parts, the second of which (1877) was an
index to the whole translation.

xi-xii. Select Specimens of the Theatre of the Hindus.
Translated from the Original Sanskrit. 3rd edit. 2 vols.
Ldn. 1871.

The 1st edition was issued at Calcutta, 3 vols., 1827. (Plays have separate
enumeration.) The 2nd edition was in 2 vols., Ldn., 1835. The plays included
are the Mriehchhakatika or Clay Cart, Vikrama and Urvasi, Malati and
Madhava, Uttara Rama Charitra, Mudra Rakshasa, and Ratnavall.

Wilson, H. H. " Extracts from the Dasakumara MSS. :
The Story of Nitambavati." The Quarterly Oriental
Magazine. Vol.vii. (No. xiv.) Calcutta. 1827. Pp. 291-293.
[VI, 251.]

Wilson, H. H. See also under Macnaghten, W. H.

Wilson, J. C. C. " The Breeding of Elephants in Captivity."
Miscellaneous Notes, No. ix to Journal of the Bombay
Natural History Society. Vol. xxviii. No. 4. Bombay.
1922. Pp. 1128, 1129. [VI, 68n.]

Windisch, E. Mara und Buddha. Leipzig. 1895. [VI, 1877&1.]

Windisch, E. See under Uhle, H.

Windsor, F.N. Indian Toxicology. Calcutta. 1906. [11,281.]

Winstedt, R. O. Papers on Malay Subjects. Life and
Customs. Part II, The Circumstances of Malay Life : The
Kampong ; the House ; Furniture ; Dress ; Food. General
Editor : R. J. Wilkinson. Kuala Lumpur. 1909. [VIII,
291 n1.]

Sixteen " Papers on Malay Life " were issued from time to time. The " Life
and Customs " section consists of three distinct parts. Pt. i is by R. J.
Wilkinson, The Incidents of Malay Life, Kuala Lumpur, 1908. Pt. ii has
been quoted above. Pt. iii, also, is by Wilkinson, Malay Amusements, Kuala
Lumpur, 1910.

A complete list of the other papers appears on the back wrappers of Pt. i
and iii of the above.

Winstedt, R. O. " Notes on Malay Magic." Journ.

Malayan Br. Roy. As. Soc. Singapore. Vol. iii. Pt. iii.

1925. Pp. 6-21. [VIII, 292, 292n* ; IX, 147.]
Winternitz, M. Geschichte der indischen Litteratur. 3 vols.

Leipzig. 1908, 1913, 1922. (Vol. i was issued in parts,

beginning in 1904. The 1908 issue is a second edition.)

[VI, 225n3-4'5; IX, 99r?2, 155.]

This work, the most important of its kind in print, is divided up as follows :
Vol. i, Einleitung — Der Veda — Die volkstiimlichen Epen und die Puranas.
Vol. ii, Die buddhistische Litteratur und die heiligen Texte der Jainas.

BIBLIOGRAPHY 331

Vol. iii, Die Kunstdichtung — Die wissenschaftliche Litteratur — Neuindische
Litteratur — Nachtnige zu alien drei Biinden.

The volumes form Bd. ix, 1, 2 and 3 of " Die Litteraturen des Ostens in
Einzeldarstellungen."

Winternitz, M. " Die Wit we im Veda." Werner Zeitschrift

f. d. Kunde des Morgenlandes. Vol. xxix. Vienna. 1915.

Pp. 172-203. [IX, 154.]
Winternitz, M. " Die Witwenverbrennung," in one of a

series of articles : " Die Frau in den indischen Religionen."

Archivfur FrauenkundeundEugenetik. Vol. iii. Wiirzburg.

1917. Pp. 69-99. [IX, 154.]
Winternitz, M. " Sururiga and the Kautilya Arthasastra."

Indian Historical Quarterly. Vol. i. No. 3. Sept. 1925.

Calcutta. Pp. 429-432. [V, 142n2.]
Winternitz, M. " The Serpent Sacrifice mentioned in the

Mahabharata." Journ. Bombay Br. Roy. As. Soc.

August 1926. Vol. ii. New Series. No. 1. Pp. 74-91.

[VII, 233n2.]

The above article was translated from the German- by N. B. Utgikar,
from " Kulturgeschichtliches aus der Tierwelt," Verein fiir Volkskunde und
Linguistik, Prag, 1905.

Wise, T. A. Commentary on the Hindu System of Medicine.
New Edition. Ldn. 1860. [II, 298.]

The 1st edition appeared in Calcutta in 1845.

Wlislocki, H. von. Volksdichtungen der siebenburgischen
und sudungarischen Zigeuner. Vienna. 1890. [VII, 2267&1.]

Wolf, A. Volkslieder aus Venetien. Gesammelt von G.
Widter. Herausgegeben von . . . Abdruck aus den Sitzungs-
berichten der Koniglichen Akademie der Wissenschaften.
Vienna. 1864. [Ill, 272m1.]

Wolgemuth, E. Der Traumende Musen-Freund, vorstellend
in 100 Absdtzen unterschiedliche, so wol in dem Geistlichen
Lehr als auch Weltlichem Wehr- und Hauslichem Nahr-
stande, den Jungen und Alten, vorgehende Laster und
Fehler, in kurzweiligen Historien : vor- und abgebildet
durch. . . . Warhausen im Warnethal. 1668. [Ill, 34n.]

I have not seen the 1670 edition.

Wollaston, A. N. The Anwar-i-Suhaili, or Lights of Canopus,

commonly known as Kalilah and Damnah. . . . Ldn. 1877.

(New Edition, 1894.) [V, 220.]
Wollaston, A. N. Tales within Tales. Adapted from the

Fables of Pilpai. "Romances of the East " Series. Ldn.

1909. [V, 240, 241.]
Wood, J. See under Barth, A.

332

THE OCEAN OF STORY

Worth am, B. Hale. The Buddhist Legend of Jimtitavdhana
from the Kathd-Sarit-Sdgara [The Ocean-River of Story]
Dramatized in the Ndgdnanda [The Joy of the World of
Serpents] A Buddhist Drama by Sri Harsha Deva. Trans-
lated from the Sanskrit. London and New York. [1911.]
[VII, 237w2.]

Wortham, B. Hale. " Metrical Version of the Story of
Devasmita. Journ. Roy. As. Soc. Vol. xvi. New Series.
1884. Pp. 1-12. [I, 172-181.]

Wortham, B. Hale. " The Stories of Jimutavahana, and of
Harisarman." Journ. Roy. As. Soc. Vol. xviii. New Series.
1886. Pp. 157-176. [Ill, 77-80 ; VII, 237w2.]

Wratislaw, A. H. Sixty Folk-Tales from exclusively Slavonic
Sources. Translated, with brief Introductions and Notes,
by . . . Ldn. 1889. [I, 132.]

Wright, Daniel. History of Nepal, Translated from the
Parbatiyd by Munshi Shew Shunker Singh and Pandit
Shri Gundnand : with an Introductory Sketch of the Country
and People of Nepal by the Editor. . . . Cambridge. 1877.
[II, 232?i.]

Wright, Dudley. Vampires and Vampirism. Ldn. 1924.
[VI, 137.]
This is the 2nd edition ; the 1st appeared in 1914.

Wright, R. G., and Dewar, D. The Ducks of India. Ldn.
1925. [VI, 71n3.]

Wright, Thomas. A Selection of Latin Stories, from Manu-
scripts of the Thirteenth and Fourteenth Centuries: A
contribution to the History of Fiction during the Middle
Ages. Printed for the Percy Society. Ldn. 1842.

The above work forms No. xxviii of the series, and, together with Gifford's
Dialogue of Witches and Witchcraft, constitutes vol. viii of :

Percy Society. Early English Poetry, Ballads, and Popular
Literature of the Middle Ages. Edited from Original Manu-
scripts and Scarce Publications. Ldn. 1843. [I, 169.]

Wright, Thomas. Gualteri Mapes De Nugis Curialium
Distinctiones Quinque. Edited, from the unique Manuscript
in the Bodleian Library at Oxford, by . . . Camden Society.
No. 1. 1850. [II, 114n.]

Wright, Thomas. Gesta Romanorum or, Entertaining Stories
Invented by the Monks as a Fire-side Recreation ; and
commonly applied in their Discourses from the Pulpit. New
Edition, with an Introduction bv . . . 2 vols. Ldn. 1871
(date at end of Preface). [I, loin1, 116w2 ; II, 296.]

The translation is the work of Rev. Charles Swan (see Preface, p. xxii).

BIBLIOGRAPHY 333

Wright, W. The Book of Kalflah and Dimnah. Translated
from Arabic into Syriac. Oxford. 1884. [V, 219.]

Wunsche, August. Die Sagen vom Lebensbaum und Lebens-
wasser Altorientalische Mythen. Leipzig. 1905. [IX, 144.]

The above work, of 108 pages, forms the 2nd and 3rd Parts of vol. i
of Ex Oriente Lux, a periodical devoted chiefly to Biblical research. The
continuous pagination is pp. 51-158.

Wunsche, August. Schopfung und. Sundenfall des ersten
Menschenpaares im jiidisohen und moslemischen Sagen-
kreise mit Rucksicht auf die Ueberlieferungen in der
Keilschrift-Literatur. Leipzig. 1906. [VIII, 117w2.]

The above work, of 84< pages, forms the 4th Part of vol. ii of Ex Oriente
Lux, and occupies pp. 169-252.

The periodical was discontinued after 1906 until 1924, when Band iii, Heft i,
was issued.

Wustenfeld, F. Die Uebersetzungen Arabischer Werke in

das Lateinische seit dem XI. Jahrhundert. Abhandl. d.

Koniglichen Gesell. d. Wissenschaften. Hist.-phil. Classe.

Vol. xxii. Gottingen. 1877. [II, 289W1.] -
Wuttke, A. Der deutsche Volksaberglaube der Gegenwart.

Edited by E. H. Meyer. 3rd edit. Berlin. 1900. [111,153.]

The 1st edition appeared in Hamburg, 1860, the 2nd in Berlin, 1869-

Xenophon. Anabasis. [Ill, 310n4.] Cyrop&dia. [Ill, 328.]

Yates, D. E. See under Sampson, J.

Yo, Soy. See under Soy Yo.

Yoe, Shway. See under [Scott, George].

Yonge, CD. The Deipnosophists or Banquet of the Learned
of Athenceus. 3 vols. Ldn. 1854. Bohn's Classical Library.
[VII, 206w3.]

Yuan-Tsang (Yuan-Chwang, Hiuen Tsiang, Hiouen
Thsang). See under Beal, Samuel.

Yule, H. Narrative of the Mission sent by the Governor-General
of India to the Court of Ava in 1855 ; with Notices of the
Country, Government, and People. Ldn. 1858. [II, 168.]

Yule, H. The Book of Ser Marco Polo the Venetian concern-
ing the Kingdoms and Marvels of the East. Translated and
Edited, with Notes, by . . . 3rd edit. Revised throughout
in the Light of Recent Discoveries bv Henri Cordier (of
Paris). ... 2 vols. Ldn. 1903. [I, 63n\ 105, 141n2, 213,
242w3, 247w3 ; II, S5n, 266, 268, 268n2, 302, 302n2, 303 ;
III, 85n, 201, 202, 307, 307W1, 329 ; VI, 150W1 ; VIII, 245,
246, 246w3, 247, 256, 257.]

The 1st edition appeared in 1871, and the 2nd in 1875. For " Notes and
Addenda " to the above work see under Cordier, Henri.

334 THE OCEAN OF STORY

Yule, H. Cathay and the Way Thither, being a Collection of
Medieval Notices of China. New Edition. Revised through-
out in the Light of Recent Discoveries by Henri Cordier,
D.Litt. ... 4 vols. Hakluyt Society. Ldn.

The volumes were not published in chronological order. The numbers,
dates, and sub-titles are as follows : —

Vol. i, Preliminary Essay on the Intercourse between
China and the Western Nations previous to the Discovery
of the Cape Route. 2nd Series. No. xxxviii. 1915. Vol. ii,
Odoric of Pordenone. 2nd Series. No. xxxiii. 1913.
Vol. iii, Missionary Friars — Rashiduddin — Pegolotti —
Marignolli. 2nd Series. No. xxxvii. 1914. Vol. iv, Ibn
Batuta — Benedict Goes. 2nd Series. No. xli. 1916.
The 1st edition of Cathay was in 2 vols., and forms
Nos. 36, 37 of the First Series of the Hakluyt Society,
1866. [I, 16, 63ft1, 104; II, 85ft, 268ft4; III, 57, 85ft,
329 ; VIII, 96ft2.]
Yule, H., and Burnell, A. C. Hobson-Jobson : Being A
Glossary of Anglo-Indian Colloquial Words and Phrases,
and of Kindred Terms ; Etymological, Historical, Geo-
graphical, and Discursive. Ldn. 1886. [I, 242ft1, 250ft2 ;
II, 162ft, 269, 269ft1 ; III, 14ft1, 85ft, 116ft ; IV, 272 ;
VII, 107 ; IX, 17ft2.]

The work was reprinted in 1903 as follows : Hobson-Jobson. A Glossary
of Colloquial Anglo-Indian Words and Phrases, and of Kindred Terms,
Etymological, Historical, Geographical and Discursive. New Edition. Edited
by William Crooke. Ldn. 1903. See also C. Partridge's Complete Verbal
Cross-Index to Yule's Hobson-Jobson. Bombay. 1906. The Index goes only
as far as the word " Izarees."

Zachariae, T. Kleine Schriften zur Indischen Philologie

zur Vergleichenden Liter aturgeschichte zur Vergleichenden

Volkskunde. Bonn and Leipzig. 1920. [VI, 59; IX,

154.]
Zachariae, T. " Zum altindischen Hochzeitsritual." Wiener

Zeitschrift f. d. Kunde d. Morgenlandes. Vol. xvii. Vienna.

1905. Pp. 135-155, 211-231. [VI, 59.]
Zachariae, T. " Verwandlung durch Umbinden eines

Fadens." Wiener Zeitschrift f. d. Kunde d. Morgenlandes.

Vol. xix. Vienna. 1905. Pp. 240-243. [VI, 59.]
Zada, Sheykh. See under Gibb, E. J. W.
Zamakhshari [Abu-l Qasim Muhmud ibn 'Umar uz-

Zamakhshari]. See under Meynard, C. Barbier de.
Zenobius. Centuria. See Adagia sive Proverbia Grcecorvm

ex Zenobii seu Zenodoto. . . . Partim edita nunc jprimiim,

BIBLIOGRAPHY 335

partim Latine reddita, . . . ab Andrea Schotto. Antwerp.
1612. [IV, 256.]

" Proverbia Zenobii ex Tarrhaeo Didymo." The reference in the Ocean is
on p. 9> Cent., i, 30.

Zimmer, H. Altindisches Leben. Die Cultur der Vedischen

Arier nach den Samhitd dargesellt. Berlin. 1879. [Ill, SOn1 ;

IV, 255w2 ; VII, 72w2 ; VIII, 156W1.]
Zimmern, H. " Babylonians and Assyrians." Hastings'

Ency. Rel. Eth. Vol. ii. 1909. Pp. 309-319. [I, 273w3.]
Zingerle, I. and J. Kinder- und Hausmdrchen aus Tirol.

Innsbruck. 1852. (2nd edit. Gera, 1870; 3rd edit.

Innsbruck, 1911.) [I, 26 ; II, 70n2.]
Zoroaster. Avesta. [I, 199.]
Zotenberg, H. Chronique de . . . Tabari, traduite sur

la version Persane d'Abou-'Ali Mo'hammed Bel1 Ami. . . .

4 vols. Paris. 1869. [VI, 293nx.]
Zotenberg, H. Histoire JDes Rois Des Perses par Abok

Mansour \4bd Al- Malik ibn Mohammad ibn Ismail Ah

Tha' alibi. Texte Arabe Publie et traduit par . . . Paris.

1900. [V, vn\]
Zugaro, F. " Les bacteries comme armes de guerre."

Bulletin Beige de Science Militaire. Revue Bibliographique

Militaire. Paris. June 1924. Pp. 33-34. [II, 281.]

The original article appears in Esercito e Marina, 4th March 1924.

Printed in Great Britain

by The Riverside Press Limited

Edinburgh

uF

■'*'-'.,

iff

AT

&■'■■■

m ,M*

.w

15 Pfc

«k

3«

feh

I Jf"l

tt(W

;%.

*****

**§to

''^r

5*Bfetttai

%au

^

or

mrF ■

>M

J&ff*

dm-'

I

I . V

10
o
o

•P
-P

is

•a

o

CO

o o
•p >

CO

•

N

<D C
O <D
O (L,

E-t

: 3
► SB

University of Toronto
Library

DO NOT

REMOVE

THE

CARD

FROM

THIS

POCKET

Acme Library Card Pocket
LOWE-MARTIN CO. LIMITED

jiff1

^^Sf^fe^^S

;% ••-ii'W^^S^Wji'^

1 1 iv'iV:'',»-y!'hbiT2r!'

^'S^S?^^^^

':'■'.''-'■ -\'.