^be ©pen Gourt
A MONTHLY MAGAZINE
S)c\>otc& to tbc Science of "Religf on, tbe IRellgton of Science, an& tbe
Bitension ot tbe IReliQious parliament f &ea
EcHtor: Dr. Paul Caids. j,.^^^t,..S E- C. Hboblu.
Atnttant Editor: T. J. McCoemack. Astoaaus. -j j^^^^^ Cards.
VOL. XIV. (no. 7) July, 1900. NO. 530
CONTENTS:
Frontispiece. Copernicus.
Copernicus, Tycho Brake, and Kepler. With Five Portraits, Diagrams of
Astronomical Systems, and Facsimile Reproductions of Early Astro-
nomical Instruments. Carus Sterne, of Berlin 385
The Notion of a Continuum. An Essay in the Theory of Science. Prof.
Ernst Mach, of the University of Vienna 409
The So-called Mystery Plays. Illustrated. E. F. L. Gauss 415
The Old and the New Magic. With Numerous Illustrations of Magical Ap-
paratus. (Concluded.) Editor 422
Kant and Spencer. A Criticism. Sir Robert Stout, Wellington, N. Z. 437
The Open Court and ^'Leaves of Grass.'" W. H. Trimble, New Zealand . 439
New Works on Political Economy, and Political Science 440
Book Eeviews and Notes 445
CHICAGO
®be ©pen Court IpubUsbing Companie
LONDON : Kegan Paul, Trench, Triibner & Co., Ltd.
Per copy, 10 cents (sixpence). Yearly, $1.00 (In the U. P. U., 5s. 6(L).
Copyright, 1900, by Tbe Open Court PvbliahiaK Co. Entered at the Chic«Ko Post Oflk;e as Second>Clasa MatUr.
^be ©pen Court
A MONTHLY MAGAZINE
2)cvote& to tbe Science of IReligion, tbe IReUaton of Science, arH> tbe
Extension ot tbe IReligious parliament irt)ea
EcHtfr: Dr. Paul Ca«us. >#,,<,««/^, . j E. C. Hboblxk.
Atnsiant Editor: T. J. McCoemack. Af*otMi€M. ^ j^^^^^ Cabus.
VOL. XIV. (no. 7) July, 1900. NO. 530
CONTENTS:
Frontispiece. Copernicus.
Copernicus, Tycho Brake, and Kepler. With Five Portraits, Diagrams of
Astronomical Systems, and Facsimile Reproductions of Early Astro-
nomical Instruments. Carus Sterne, of Berlin 385
The Notion of a Continuum. An Essay in the Theory of Science. Prof.
Ernst Mach, of the University of Vienna 409
The So-called Mystery Plays. Illustrated. E. F. L. Gauss 415
The Old and the New Magic. With Numerous Illustrations of Magical Ap-
paratus. (Concluded.) Editor 422
Kant and Spencer. A Criticism. Sir Robert Stout, Wellington, N. Z. 437
The Open Court and '^Leaves of Grass." W. H. Trimble, New Zealand . 439
f^ew Works on Political Economy, and Political Science 440
Book Reviews and Notes 445
CHICAGO
®be <S)pen (Toutt IPublisbtttd (TompaniS
LONDON : Kegan Paul, Trench, Trubner & Co., Ltd.
Per copy, 10 cents (sixpence). Yearly, $1.00 (la the U. P. U., %%. 6<L).
Copyright, igoo, by The Open Court Pnblithi&g Co. Entered at the Chicago Post Ofltee as Second-Class Matter.
JUST PUBLISHED
A BRIEF
HISTORY OF MATHEMATICS
AN AUTHORISED TRANSLATION OF
DR. KARL FINK'S GESCHICHTB DHR
BLBMENTAR-MATHEMATIK
BY
WOOSTER WOODRUFF BEMAN
Professor of Mathematics in the University of Michigan
DAVID EUGENE SMITH
Principal of the State Normal School at Brockport, N. Y. ».
With biographical notes and full index. Pages, 3334-xii. Price, cloth,
;^i.5o (5s. 6d.) net.
Of all the recent compendia of the history of mathematics, this work
by Professor Fink is the most systematic. It is not a book of anecdotes,
nor one of biography; it is a clear and brief statement of the facts of math-
ematical history.
The author systematically traces the development of the science of
mathematics from the earliest period to the present ; he considers the de-
velopment of algebra from the //a«-reckoning of the Egyptians to the the-
ory of functions of the nineteenth century ; he reviews geometry from the
primitive ideas of the Babylonians to the projective and differential geom-
etry and the science of ^-dimensional space ; and finally he traces the his-
tory of trigonometry from the rude ideas of Ahmes to the projective formulae
of recent times.
An invaluable work for teachers of mathematics.
THE OPEN COURT PUBLISHING CO., ,.^l'^^^^,,
London : Kegan Paul, Trench, Triibner & Co., Ltd.
NICOLAUS COPERNICUS.
■473-1543)
Kroiii a picture in the possession of the Royal Society, presented by Dr. Wolf of Dantzic,
June 6, i;;6. Engraved by E. Scriven.
Frontispiece to Tin- C/''" Court.
The Open Court
A MONTHLY MAGAZINE
Devoted to the Science of Religion, the Religion of Science, and
the Extension of the Religious Parliament Idea.
VOL. XIV. (NO. 7.) JULY, 1900. NO. 530
Copyright by The Open Court Publishing Co., 1900.
COPERNICUS, TYCHO BRAHE, AND KEPLER.'
BY CARUS STERNE.
IF we review the long line of fighters who freed the human mind
from the oppressive bonds of its early subjection, two investi-
gators, Copernicus and Kepler, always stand out prominently as
leaders. These men, however, did not stand in the fore-front of
battle; they worked in comparative obscurity; but they rank as
real leaders through the weight of their investigations, and through
the irresistible force of the proofs obtained by their patient obser-
vation of nature.
Although originally destined for the priestly office, each rose
above the narrow principles of Church doctrine as received in theo-
logical lecture-rooms. Nor must it be forgotten that the Protestant
camp from which Kepler came was at that time quite as intolerant
as the Catholic, as witness the case of Michael Servetus, discoverer
of the circulation of the blood. Indeed at the time of the rise of
Copernicus, the Church of Rome felt itself still so firm and un-
shaken in its sense of power, that it believed it might grant con-
siderable liberty in the observation and explanation of nature.
It must not be forgotten that a long time before Copernicus
the old belief in the geocentric system was shaken, but the Church
then acted as though this was a matter of no concern to her.
Nicholas Krebs of Cusa (1401-1464) had made no secret of his
conviction that the earth moves, and yet several popes had ad-
vanced him to the highest offices in the Church. Leonardo da
Vinci speaks repeatedly, in his written notes, of the movement of
J Translated from the German by Dr. David Eugene Smith, of the State Normal School
Brockport, N. Y. The publishers are also indebted to Dr. Smith for having courteously placed
at their disposal the originals of the portraits which adorn the present article. For the remaining
illustrations they are under obligations to W. Engelmann, of Leipsic.
386
THE OPtN COURT.
the earth as a matter of course. But all these views, differing from
the prevailing teaching, had been only philosophical speculations
P'rom an Old Print. A Scientific Interpretation.
which in part were awakened by the study of classical authors, in
part were clarified by independent reflexion, yet did not rest upon
COPERNICUS, TYCHO BRAHE, AND KEPLER. 387
the foundation of thorough observations. To have made such sup-
porting and confirming observations, with the simplest instruments
and with untiring patience, remains the undying merit of Coperni-
cus (1473-1543).
Through his uncle Lucas von Watzelrode, Bishop of Ermland,
Copernicus was led to the priestly office, although in Cracow, be-
sides his theological work, he was interested in mathematical and
astronomical studies, in which Albert Bruzewsky was his teacher.
The youth of twenty-three continued these many-sided occupations
in Bologna, then the indispensable source of scientific knowledge.
Insatiable in his thirst for learning, he then went to Padua where
he added medical studies to the theological, mathematical, and
astronomical which he had already pursued. From Rome, where
he received a professorship at the university in 1500, our scholar,
who apparently cared little for splendor and fame, returned to his
bleak northern home. Here he obtained, through the mediation
of his uncle, a position as canon in Frauenburg (1510), which al-
lowed him to prosecute his astronomical researches in all tran-
quillity.
Since the year 1507 the thought had come to him and had be-
come more and more fixed, that the old geocentric idea was false.
Finally, through unremitting observations, he became convinced
of the movement of the earth and the planets round the sun, not
publishing his views, however, save to friendly astronomers or to
amateurs, many of whom flocked to him for instruction and for the
removal of their doubts. Copernicus possessed a universal mind
similar to that of Leonardo da Vinci, a mind which seemed to suc-
ceed in all it undertook. He therefore was able to carry on the
government of the Chapter after the death of his uncle, to appear
as its representative at the Prussian diet, to undertake the regula-
tion of the Prussian system of minting and coinage, to carry on the
work of a popular physician in his district, and to advance to suc-
cessful conclusion a difficult construction of some flood-gates. Just
as thoroughly and systematically did he proceed in his observa-
tions of the heavens, so that his undying services to astronomy are
in nowise prejudiced by such predecessors as Nicholas von Cusa.
The views of the latter were still so confused that he seems never
to have drawn even the most important of the consequences of the
movement of the earth, namely, the immobilising of the sphere of
the fixed stars.
In the year 1530 the great work of Copernicus, On the Revolu-
tion of the Heavenly Bodies {De revolutionibus orbimn coelestium, libri
388
THE OPEN COURT.
VI.), was finished in outline, — a work which prepared the way for
a great revolution in thought. Of this work the Archbishop of
Capua, Nicholas von Schonberg, who was of German extraction,
and one of the sincerest admirers of Copernicus, is said to liave re-
ceived a manuscript copy in 1536. This good patron also encour-
aged Copernicus to publish the work, its contents being already so
much talked of in learned circles. He is also said to have borne
Diagram of the Copernican System.
From Copernicus's work, Dc ycz'olutionibus (1530).'
Copernicus says ; " The first and highest of all the spheres is that of the fixed stars, enclosing
itself and the others and therefore immovable, being the place of the universe to which the mo
tion and position of all the other stars are referred. Then follows the outermost planet, Saturn
which completes its revolution round the sun in thirty years [the planets, Uranus and Neptune
had not yet been discovered] ; then Jupiter, which has a period of twelve years ; then Mars, with
a period of two years. The fourth sphere in order is that of the yearly revolution, and in it is
contained the earth, having the orbit of the moon as an epicycle ; in the fifth place, Venus re-
volves in nine months; the sixth place is occupied by Mercury, which performs its revolution in
a period of eighty days. In the middle of all stands the sun : for who could think of another or
better place in this most beautiful temple for so brilliant a luminary? The sun, thus, seated on
its kingly throne, guides the movements of the stars that circle round it."
the cost of printing, and to have recommended the dedication of
the work to Pope Paul III., one of the most ardent admirers of
1 Reproduced from a cut in Friedrich Dannemann's Grundriss einer Geschichte der Natur-
wissenschaften, 2, vols. Leipsic : W. Engelmann.
COPERNICUS, TYCHO BRAHE, AND KEPLER. 389
astronomy. It was therefore probably scientific caution, rather
than apprehension as to its reception by the Church authorities,
that led Copernicus to defer so long the publication of this work.
This is the more probable because, only a short time before (1533),
the German astronomer Widmansstedt, who held similar views,
had met with a kind reception from Pope Clement VII.
That he would find manifold and lively opposition among
Diagram of the Ptolemaic System of the Universe (160 A. D.).
From Guericke's De vacuo spatio. (After Dannemann).
Reproduced for comparison with the system of Copernicus. The first sphere contains the
moon, which has a period of revolution of one twelfth of a year; the second contains Mercury
having a period of one fourth of a year; the third Venus, having a period of two thirds of a year
the fourth the sun, having a period of one year; the fifth Mars, having a period of two years;
the sixth Jupiter, having a period of twelve years; and the seventh Saturn, having a period of
thirty years.
Catholic and Protestant scholars and laymen, Copernicus must
have understood from the very beginning. It is, however, remark-
able that the first attacks of the Protestant spokesmen were almost
more violent than those of the Catholic, and this may have been
brought about by the well-received dedication to the Pope. It is
known that Luther was one of the most determined opponents of
the theory, and in the Table- Talk he says of the Canon of Frauen-
burg with little consideration :
390
THE OPEN COURT.
" Mention was made of a contemporary astrologer who tried to prove that the
Earth moved and turned round, but not the Heavens, nor the Firmament, nor the
TiOUNVS N'[COL/A'.S' COPERXICV'^.S't SaCKP.DOSt CAxVONICV:?
From an Original Claimed to be Authentic.
Interpretation.
An Ecclesiastical
Sun, nor the Moon ; just as when a person is seated in a wagon or on a boat and is
in motion, and fancies he is sitting still and at rest while the earth and the trees
are moving. But this is the way of the world now ; when a person is bent on being
COPERNICUS, TYCHO BRAKE, AND KEPLER. 39I
thought clever, he must perforce make up something of his own, which has to be
the best that is, just as he makes it. This fool will upset the whole Science of
Astronomy. But the Holy Scriptures tell us, Joshua bade the Sii?i stand still and
not the Earth."
One may well think from this that Luther followed the views
of his friend Melanchthon, who was an ardent adherent of astrology,
a science which remained, as we shall presently see, closely bound
up with the geocentric theory. Luther, however, believed less
firmly in astrology, and several times even declaimed vehemently
against it, so that the accusations brought against him, that he
made use of the astrological superstition of the time for his own
ends, is probably not tenable.
Naturally there was no lack of satirical inuendoes against the
new theory of Copernicus, which had become known long before
the appearance of his work. To such attacks on the part of med-
dling critics Copernicus addresses himself in the dedicatory letter
to Pope Paul IIL, published before the work appeared. Here he
speaks, in a tone of perfect confidence, of those vain babblers who,
without possessing mathematical knowledge of their own, would
condemn his work because it was at variance with a few purposely
distorted passages in the Bible. Thus did the holy Lactantius,
in his ignorance, once childishly scoff at the spherical form of the
earth ; but the learned must overlook with contempt such objec-
tions of non-mathematicians. Just as boldly did he oppose pre-
vailing prejudices by his eulogy of the new system, delivered with
noble pride and self-confidence: "Through no other arrange-
ment," he says, "have I been able to find such wonderful symme-
try of the universe and such harmonious connexion of the orbits,
as when I place the sun, the light of the world, as ruler of the
whole family of circling stars in the midst of the high temple of
nature, as though upon a kingly throne. Who indeed could find
in all glorious nature a better place for the sun than that from
which it can give light to the whole?"
It will be seen that in his works, which were finally given to
the press, appearing however only after his death (which occurred
on the following May 24), Copernicus spoke out with manly firm-
ness for the truth of the results of his investigations. It is evident,
too, that the supposition that he was spared by the ecclesiastical
censor only because one of the editors (Andreas Osiander) had sent
out in advance an anonymous preface, could be true only on the
hypothesis that the censors had read neither the dedication to the
pope nor the work itself. This preface of Osiander designated
392
THE OPEN COURT.
IB
Kinuji s^r(.Ho^\J-^hR^HFOT^<.)^]l)l^DAM Dni
l)>K\\l)srK\i n AJ<^l>VK'\NILNb\KC, IN INsVLA.
HI 1 1 IsPOMl DANK lH\T NNA^YNDATOiOii INiTRV
OKIS A^TAIIS
W##|f/flfiiiiflf#l!ii^^
I Ml N H)K\ 4<^V1 As I KU^lOMlCuRVMrN F'
I SiJUKVM INM^ MTORIi !< I STRVtlOW
» .S\ff. ANVO 4.0 ANJsO DM ir;£f^"c O
Tycho Brahe,
!i546-i6oi.)
(From a very rare print.)
COPERNICUS, XyCHO BRAKE, AND KEPLER.
393
the new doctrine as a mere hypothesis which ''need be neither
true nor probable," as it was to serve only to calculate more easily
the phenomena of the heavens, and it is not probable that it was
Altazimuth of Tycho Brake, the Archetype of the Modern Theodolite
(From Tycho Brahe's De mundi aether ei, Prague, 1603. After Dannemann.)
This beautiful instrument was constructed of brass and served for determining both azimuths
and altitudes. The azimuth-circle, NP, rested on four pillars ; the altitude-circle had a radius of
almost two yards, and was provided with a scale of minutes, BC, and an alidade, DE.
added with the consent of Copernicus. He could not, however,
protest against what had been done, as he received the first copy
only on his death-bed.
394
TH£ OPEN COURT.
The great successor of Copernicus in the field of observation
was the Danish nobleman Tycho Brahe. In the estimation of the
world he generally passes for the outspoken opponent of Coperni-
cus, and as the inventor of a new cosmology which left the earth
in the center of the universe, and made the sun and moon revolve
around it, but the planets around the sun, — a system which has
been explained as a conces-
sion to the prevailing belief.
But the traditional estimate
of this admirable investiga-
tor, who pursued his studies
in Leipsic, Wittenberg, and
Augsburg, is a very unjust
one. In point of fact, he was
the most ardent admirer of
Copernicus that could be
imagined. In the Sternen-
burg (Uranienburg) which
his royal patron Frederick
II. of Denmark had con-
structed for Tycho Brahe on
the island Hveen, the pict-
ure of the Canon of Frauen-
burg, adorned with palms
and laurels, occupied the
place of honor in the room
of state. When the heirs
and successors of Coperni-
cus heard of this worship,
they sent as a gift the sim-
ple wooden instrument with
which the latter had made
Armillary Sphere of Tycho Brahe.
This instrument, like all the others of the great
Danish astronomer, was manufactured in Tycho
Brahe's own workshop. The elegance and exactitude his observations. Tycho Ccl-
with which they were executed in every detail, are j i i j r •
beautifully shown by this illustration. ebratcd the happy day of its
reception (July 13, 1584) by
a Latin poem, in which it is said of Copernicus:
" He succeeded in snatching the sun from the heavens,
And placing it iirmly. Around it then he guided the earth.
As around the earth the moon."
And of the instrument, which had no lenses :
IFromGerland and Trauniiil
W. Engelmann.
Geschichte der f>kysiki.ilisclien Experhiientirkunst, Leips
COPERNICUS, TVCHO BRAKE, AND KEPLER.
395
" . . . O monument of the great
And immortal man! You are perishable wood,
But shining gold will look on you with envy."
But Tycho had so improved this instrument, although he like-
wise had to do without lenses, and he was besides so sharp an ob-
server, that he could not but perceive the defects still adhering to
the Copernican system as well as the discrepancies between the
facts and the calculations based upon it. Untiring observations
of the orbit of Mars showed clearly that the circles assumed as the
Tycho Brake's System of the Universe. (1587.)
This system occupies an intermediary place between the geocentric system of Ptolemy and
the heliocentric system of Copernicus. In Tycho's system the earth is at the center ; the sun
Mars, Jupiter, and Saturn revolve about the earth, while Mercury and Venus perform secondary
epicyclical revolutions about the sun. (From Guericke's De vacuo spaiio. After Dannemann.)
planetary orbits by Copernicus did not exist. Furthermore, Tycho
found good reason to deny the third movement of the earth (around
the pole of the ecliptic) presupposed by Copernicus. Hence he is
not to be blamed if he held provisionally to his own system, which
had in common with the ecclesiastical conception the geocentric
idea only; for naturally he had never doubted the revolution of the
earth on its axis.
396 THE OPEN COURT.
Neither did Tycho Brahe ever publicly set up his system in
opposition to that of Copernicus. His theory was not published
until three years after his death, in a book appearing in Frankfort
in 1604 ; and the essay contained in it "On the System of the Uni-
verse" is, probably with good reason, attributed to his pupil B.
Ursus. The fruits of Tycho's labors did not ripen until later, after
Kepler was able to build further on the foundation of these obser-
vations, the most exact that any astronomer had made before the
discovery of the telescope.
Johannes Kepler (born December 27, 1571) was on account of
his weak frame, like Copernicus, originally destined for the minis-
try; or rather we may say he had grown up into it, for his parents,
having ended after various vicissitudes in life in keeping a tavern,
had placed the boy in the school attached to the monastery of Hir-
sau. From there he went to the school of the former Cistercian
monastery Maulbronn, where in 1516 Dr. Faust is said to have
taught Abbot Entenfuss alchemy and to have passed the last years
of his life. We might believe that something of the Faust-spirit
there descended upon the young man, who later removed to the
seminary of Tubingen (1589) in order to study Protestant theology.
Kepler fortunately found at Maulbronn a fatherly friend and
adviser in Michael Miistlin, a theologian versed in astronomy and
an adherent of Copernicus. It is he whom Galileo also honored
as a teacher, and who inspired Kepler with all the more interest for
astronomy as his warm attachment to theology was repulsed by
the extreme views of most of the other teachers there. In particu-
lar Kepler would not profess Luther's dogma of the omnipresence
of the body of Christ, and as he was already suspected on account
of his fondness for the stars, he seems to have been in a difficult
position. Probably also he did not understand keeping his convic-
tion of the truth of the Copernican system as secret as was neces-
sary, as his cautious and timid teacher had done for years and also
recommended to him. Accordingly serious conflicts soon arose,
and Mastlin as well as several other teachers advised Kepler to
give up his theological studies entirely and accept a position as
teacher of mathematics at the Gymnasium at Graz, which was to
be filled in the spring of 1594. Kepler, who was a zealous Protes-
tant, even though not according to the strict Lutheran fashion,
went unwillingly to the Catholic country, but he accommodated
himself to circumstances and supplied the Styrian provincial al-
manac with all the astrological lumber which was at that time
deemed to be the main requisite of a calendar.
COPERNICUS, TYCHO BRAHE, AND KEPLER. 397
It is remarkable and at the same time instructive to observe
how Kepler, with his strong inclination to fantastic dreaming and
EycimiMm^ fa'neir ruiuj itv are, nncit~.
■nt tn.A
±
JoHANN Kepler. (1571-1630).
Probably from contemporary sources.
to poetical ideas of things in general and their relations, wrested
himself almost entirely free from the seductive allurements of the
astrological craze of that time. It was apparently, next to his
398 THE OPEN COURT.
mathematical vein, his religious conviction of the perfection of the
structure of the universe that kept him from this aberration. The
words of the Bible, that the universe is duly disposed according
to number, measure, and weight,^ which more than two hundred
years later led the chemist of the Berlin porcelain factory, J. B.
Richter, to the discovery of the stoicheiometric relationships be-
tween the chemical elements, impelled him also to seek the mathe-
matical la7u of the structure of the tiniversc.
Led astray on this quest by his classical education, he first
took up with the speculations of the Pythagoreans, who had alter-
nately compared the five regular solids to the five worlds and to
Kepler's Construction of the Planetary Spheres.
Exhibiting the dimensions and distances of the planetary orbits by means of the
five Platonic solids. (From Kepler's Mystcrium Cosniographiciim, Tubingen
1596. After Dannemann.)
Kepler says; "The orbit of the earth gives the circle which constitutes the measure of all
the others. About this circle (r; in the figure) describe a dodecahedron; in the sphere which
encloses this solid lies the orbit of Mars (e in the present figure). About the Martian sphere de-
scribe a tetrahedron ; the spherical surface described about this solid would contain the orbit of
Jupiter (see 7 in Fig. 2). Describe about the latter a cube ; the sphere enclosing the cube (a, Fig 2.
contains the orbit of Saturn. Further, construct within the terrestrial sphere an icosahedron ;
the spherical surface inscribed within the same contains the orbit of Venus U in the present fig
ure). Describe within this last sphere au octahedron, and this body will enclose the sphere
Mercury."
the five senses of man, and conjectured that by them possibly the
five spaces between the six planetary orbits might be typified. He
accordingly imagined the octahedron, icosahedron, dodecahedron,
tetrahedron, and cube, placed successively one within another,
with the sun at the center; and describing spheres between each
1 Wisdom, II, 22.
COPERNICUS, TYCHO BRAHE, AND KEPLER.
399
two successive solids to touch the outer angles of the smaller and
the inner surfaces of the larger, he conceived the great circles of
these spheres to represent the orbits of the planets, and the spaces
between them the distances of the orbits.
The unit for the orbit-distances was given by the orbit of the
earth, which was assumed to be on the sphere between the icosa-
hedron and the dodecahedron.
This device, when closely examined, will be found not un-
worthy of a poetising mathematician. As the mean distances of
the orbits of the planets, not then known with the strictest accu-
Kepler's Construction of the Planetary Spheres.
(For description see Fig. i.)
a=the sphere of Salurn ; |8 = thecube; Y = the sphere of Jove ; S = tetrahedron ; e = sphere
Mars; ^=dohecahedron ; r) = the sphere of the earth; 8— the icosahedron ; i = sphere of Venus
K^octahedron ; A = the sphere of Mercury; /x=:the sun.
racy, corresponded fairly well with those reckoned in this way, he
was convinced that he had discerned the skilful plan of the archi-
tect of the universe, and accordingly he made known this cosmical
secret in his maiden work, the Mysterium cosmographicuni (1596).
Genuine enthusiasm for the perfection of creation as revealed
by Copernicus had furnished the original incentive for all Kepler's
400 THE OPEN COURT.
calculations and investigations, and so he begins his work with the
following words :
"Inspired, full of holy joy, David cries aloud, calling upon the world itself :
'Praise ye him, sun and moon : praise him all ye stars of light.' But what voice
has been bestowed upon the heavens, and what upon the stars, fit to praise God
like that of man ? Because they give reasons for praising God, we may say, they
praise God himself. Since then we are endeavoring to make this voice of the heav-
ens and of all nature more perceptible and clear, let no one say we are pursuing
vain studies or exerting ourselves for naught."
After interpreting, as far as in him lies, this marvellous con-
struction, and emphasising the lack of a planet between the orbits
of Mars and Jupiter, his enthusiasm breaks forth once more in a
lofty hymn, a few lines of which may here be quoted :
" Great Artist of the universe, with admiration I look upon the works
Of thy hands, which constructed them according to an ingenious plan.
In their midst the sun, dispenser of light and life,
Which curbs the earth according to sacred law and guides her
In her changing course. I see the toil of the moon,
And stars scattered on the infinite meadow. . . .
Sovereign of the world ! Thou eternal power ! Thine infinite glory
Soars on the wings of light through all the worlds ! "
The impression of this work, which to-day possesses value
only as a poem and picture of the fancy, was a very mixed one.
Kepler's Tubingen teachers were not in accord with it. "God for-
bid," Professor Hafenraffer wrote (1597) with discernment but with
kindness, "that you should ever try publicly to bring your hypoth-
esis into agreement with Holy Scriptures ; act, I beg of you, en-
tirely as a mathematician and do not disturb the repose of the
Church."
But Galileo wrote an enthusiastic letter dated the fourth of
August, 1597 :
" I consider myself happy to know of so great an ally in the search for truth
and consequently such a friend of truth itself. It is really pitiful that there are so
few who strive for tha truth, and care to depart from perverted methods of philos-
ophising. But this is not the place to lament the wretchedness of our time ; rather
should I wish you good luck in those splendid investigations, by which you strengthen
the truth. ... I should risk publishing my own speculations, if there were more
like you. But since this is not the case, I postpone it, for fear of sharing the fate
of our master Copernicus, who although he has won undying fame with a few, has
nevertheless with very many — so great is the number of fools ! — become an object
of ridicule and contempt." •
The work was of great advantage to Kepler in that it brought
the young astronomer to the notice of Tycho Brahe of Prague, and
IK. von Gebler, Galileo Galelei und die romische Kurie, Stuttgart, 1876.
COPERNICUS, TYCHO BRAHE, AND KEPLER. 4OI
caused him to invite Kepler to come to that place as his assistant.
This was so much the more important for Kepler, as his position in
Graz had in the meantime become untenable. In the year 1598
Archduke Ferdinand had, by an edict, banished all Protestant
JoHANN Kepler.
From a picture in the collection of Godefroy Kraenner, merchant at Ratisbon.
Engraved by F. Mackenzie.
teachers and priests from Styria, and Kepler alone was allowed to
remain, it was said through the intercession of the Jesuits, who
needed his astronomical calculations for their missions in China.
But in the year 1600 there was a repetition of the storm, and Kepler
402 THE OPEN COURT.
might count himself happy in having found employment in the
well-appointed observatory of the Hradschin at Prague.
But his position there with the haughty Danish astronomer,
busy with the improvement of the Copernican system, seems not
to have been the most agreeable. Indeed it would probably have
become unendurable, owing to the great difference of temperament
of the two men, had not Tycho Brahe's unexpected and early death
(on the 23d of October 1601) put an end to this unsatisfactory
alliance. The result was that Kepler was raised to the position of
the imperial astronomer and mathematician. Not without mani-
fold difficulties, however, did he come into possession of the price-
less results of his predecessor's observations, which were to serve
in the calculation of the Rudolphine Tables (of the movements of
the planets). This material was so much the more indispensable
for Kepler's labors, because on account of the weakness of his eyes
he would never have been able to acquire it for himself. And even
now it would have gone badly with his mission, had not industry
been aided by imagination, that freest daughter of the mind, which
raised him above the preconceived but respectable errors of his
master, driving him incessantly into new combinations and conjec-
tures. Thus we see that not the gift of observation and the art of
calculating alone suffice for the making of great discoveries, but
that science often has still more to gain from the consistent work-
ing out of hypotheses. On the other hand, Kepler was always irre-
sistibly impelled to check the creations of his imagination by cal-
culation. But he was successful in doing this only in three discov-
eries, namely those relating to the movements of the planets, which
were alone sufficient to have made his name immortal. He dreamed,
however, of many another, which it remained for Newton, and
even for Laplace, to furnish a firm support.
It was above all the irregularities which Tycho Brahe had
established in the revolution of Mars that attracted the attention
of Kepler, and he gave voice to the conviction that "through the
planet Mars we must reach the secrets of astronomy, or remain
forever ignorant in this science."
In the preface to the New Astronomy or the Commentary on the
Planet Mars (1609) he gives an account to the Emperor Rudolph
of the result of the "struggle with the heathen god of war, in which
General Tycho Brahe won the highest fame, inasmuch as he dis-
covered in the night-watches of twenty years all the habits, posi-
tions, and stratagems of his enemy. O that he [Kepler] might
now bring this most noble lord a prisoner before the Emperor! "
COPERNICUS, TYCHO BRAHE, AND KEPLER. 4O3
Copernicus had, as was before mentioned, believed that the
planets move in circles round the sun, and from this assumption
had arisen the appearance of irregularities in these orbits. Kepler
now perceived that Mars and the other planets moved not in cir-
cular but in elliptic orbits round the sun, which therefore is not in
the center of the orbit, but in one of the foci (^Kepler's first lazv).
At the same time he perceived that the planet hurries forward
faster in its orbit in perihelion than in aphelion, but that the radius
of rotation describes equal areas in the same time in all portions of
the orbit. {Kepler's second law.')
He did not hesitate, in spite of the opposition made hitherto
by the Church, to announce openly these great discoveries, which,
as he rightly assumed, removed the last difficulties from the Co-
pernican system of the universe. Accept-
ing the Joshua miracle, he says that Joshua
merely expressed wrongly his prayer com-
manding the sun to stand still, just as we
still every day express ourselves wrongly
when we say we wish the sun would soon
rise above the horizon. He adds :
" In theology the weight of authority may de-
cide, in philosophy we must have reasons. Holy
is Lactantius, who doubted the spherical form of
the earth ; holy is Augustine, who conceded this but Diagram Illustrating
denied the existence of antipodes ; . . . but holier Kepler's Second Law.
to me is truth, when I, with all respect for the if the distances tt' and TT' are
Church, prove by science that the earth is round, is traversed in equal times, then the
inhabited by antipodes, is a little dot in the uni- segments tt'S and TT'S are equal
verse, and wanders among the stars ! "
Having now discovered in the law of areas a new confirmation
of the structure of the universe according to number, he bent all his
energies to find why the planets did not hasten round the sun with
uniform swiftness in the more perfect circular orbit, but revolved,
as he had found, with changing swiftness in elliptic orbits. Again
it was a dream of the ancients that captivated his poet-soul, the
Pythagorean dream of the harmony of the spheres, of the music of
the universe, audible only to spirits specially blessed. By this
means he hoped to reduce apparent anomalies to a mutual balance,
to harmonise the courses of the planets, so that every dissonance
which a single planet might produce when regarded outside of its
connexion with the system, would be by such law removed from
the celestial concert.
404 THE OPEN COURT.
"Straying in this labyrinth of delusion," as a stern critic of
these ideas would say, "at last, at last," he discovered on the 15th
of May, 1618, at Linz, where he meanwhile had found a position as
gymnasium professor, his third law. This is the law according to
which the squares of the times of revolution of the planets are pro-
portional to the cubes of the mean distances. This discovery fol-
lowed upon a failure that calls to mind the discovery of universal
gravity by Newton ; for suddenly, as Kepler expresses himself, the
perception of the truth triumphed "over the darkness of my mind
with such conformity to my seventeen years' work on the observa-
tions of Tycho, that I at first thought I was dreaming and that I
had taken for granted that which I was seeking."
Certain of his critics have utterly failed to comprehend this
combination of dreaming and mathematical genius, and in regard
to the discovery of the third law, have cried out: "Whence sud-
denly so much light after such deep obscurity?" (Bertrand.) They
have also spoken of his gambler's luck ; but Whewell has pointed
out, in his History of the Inductive Sciences, that this combination of
imagination and penetration is the peculiar characteristic of most
great discoverers. He further notes that Kepler is distinguished
from most of the others only in that he describes at length his mis-
takes and aberrations in his search for the truth, and admits that
truth would now hide herself from his gaze, and again incite him
to pursuit, like Virgil's Galatea :
" Galatea throws apples after me, the roguish maiden,
Then back she flies to the pastures, yet wishes first to be seen."
"We may be surprised," says Reuschle,^ at Kepler's wonder
ful luck in disentangling truth from the wildest, most preposterous
fancies; yet we kno^v that with our hero the one is productive of
the other, that both are strangely interwoven into a very singular
whole." We must also agree with what Reuschle has said about
his poetical bent and the enthusiasm that always reanimated his
courage when extended calculations threatened to wear out his
spirit, or his dire poverty seemed about to prostrate him. All his
life long he was obliged to beg of Tycho Brahe, as well as of the
emperor and the empire, for the salary rightfully belonging to him
and for the money to print his books. Indeed, he met his death
while on a begging expedition, made on foot, in early winter, to
the imperial diet at Regensburg, November 15, 1630. He had to
struggle not only with the opponents of Copernicus and Tycho,
IC. G. Reuschle, Kepler und die Astronomie, Frankfort, iS"?!.
COPERNICUS, TYCHO BRAKE, AND KEPI.ER.
405
men like Chiaromonte, Riccioli, etc., but also with the most absurd
prejudices of the people and with a fanatic priesthood. To add to
all his misery, through the efforts of his own degenerate brother
Christopher, his old mother was accused of witchcraft, so that she
was saved from the stake only by the greatest exertions and after
six years of legal contest.
Kepler was also forced incidentally to pay court to that "co-
quettish daughter of astronomy," astrology, both in Gratz and in
Prague, in order to keep his court position
and earn his living. This was done, how-
ever, with very little regard for her, and
with bitter complaint that he must so play
the charlatan. It all had its humorous side,
however; he writes in one place: "This
astrology is indeed a foolish little daugh-
ter, but — lieber Gott! — where would her
mother, the highly rational astronomy, be,
if she did not have this foolish offspring?
The world is even more foolish, so foolish
in fact, that this sensible old mother must
for her own benefit cajole and deceive it,
through her daughter's foolish, idle talk."
And although on the whole he was very
fortunate in his prophecies, yet he says
frankly: "Since the guessing is after all
only a matter of Yes or No, we are sure to
hit the mark half the time, and miss it only
the other half. The successful guesses are
remembered after the manner of women,
but the failures are forgotten, because they
are nothing peculiar, and so the astrologer
is still held in honor." Even Wallenstein
thought once of making Kepler his astrol-
oger, and met him in Sagan, after he had
lost his professorship in Linz through the
expulsion of the protestants under Ferdinand II. But Wallenstein
saw very well that Kepler did not believe in his own prophecies
Kepler Observes a Sun-
Spot which He Errone-
ously Takes for Mer-
cury.'
\Opera Omnia, II , 793. After Dannemann. This observation was made in 160;, before the
invention of the telescope. Tradition, dating from the days of Charlemagne, asserted Mercury
to be visible, when in conjunction, as a minute dark spot on the surface of the sun. Allowing
the rays of the sun to pass through a narrow orifice in a dark chamber, Kepler saw in the image
of the sun, caught on a paper screen, a minute flocculent speck, which he took for Mercury. It
was a sun-spot.
406 THE OPEN COURT.
himself, and so he gave him a professorship in Rostock instead, a
position where he ran against the same old difficulty of work with-
out salary.
In spite of all these distressing circumstances, Kepler was at
least a fortunate man through his discoveries, and but few investi-
gators can have tasted such hours of rapture as he. It was after
the discovery of his third law, that he could write :
"But now nothing more holds me back ; a year and a half ago the first dawn,
a few months ago the full day, a few days ago the pure sun of the most wonderful
contemplation, have come upon me. Now I will revel in holy ecstacy ; now will I
scoff at the children of men, with the simple avowal that I am stealing the golden
vessels of the Egyptians, in order to build a tabernacle for my God, far distant from
the land of Egypt. If they forgive, I shall be glad ; if they are angry, I shall bear
it; here I cast the die, and write a book to be read by my contemporaries or by pos-
terity, it matters not; it may wait for its reader thousands of years, since God him-
self waited six thousand years for him who should behold his work."
After this preface he unrolls in his favorite work, the HannoTiice
mundi (1619), a picture of the universe which would not cast discredit
upon the greatest of poets. In the eyes of many the scheme, how-
ever, is discrediting to an astronomer, for it contains, besides many
glorious thoughts and discoveries, fanciful speculations in regard to
the earth-beast, its sleeping, waking, breathing, etc., as well as in
regard to the spiritual relations of the heavenly bodies to one an-
other. We may be allowed to quote a few more words from the
epilogue, in order to show the beauty of the language.
"From the music of heaven to its hearers," he cries, "from the muses to
Apollo, the great chorister, from the six circling planets, that discourse the music
to the sun which in the midst of their orbits revolves about itself alone, without
change of place ! "
From the complete harmony obtaining between the smallest
and greatest movements of the planets, from their strong tendency
toward the center, Kepler inferred not only that the sun influenced
the planets, but that the latter also reacted upon the sun, which he
mystically designates as the contemplation and interchange of their
homage.
"What the nature of that seeing or that perception, in short, the nature of that
soul in the sun, may be, it is difficult to guess ; it is, however, true that the assump-
tion of the six principal orbits around the sun, which do homage to the latter with
constant revolutions, and above all the further existence of harmony, the trace of
the highest wisdom doing homage in the solar system, compels me to the assertion,
that not only from the sun does light go out into all parts of the world, life and
warmth as from the heart, motion as from the seat of power and might, but that
also, vice i<ersa, these tributes of the most delightful harmony gather from all
COPERNICUS, lYCHO BRAHB:, ANU KEPLER.
407
provinces of the universe. In short, in the sun are found counsel and favor for the
whole kingdom of nature."
This continual outbreaking of poetical language gives to Kepler's
works (of which we have received in modern times a model complete
edition by Frisch^) a living charm, and often lends to them a trans-
porting power. He took occasion to speak in verse only in inspired
moments, as in the lines given above from the Myste-
rium cosmographicum, and he then reaches such heights
that he must be counted among the great "German
classical authors," discovered by Daniel Strauss,
"who wrote in Latin." Not seldom he was impelled
to set forth his astronomical discoveries in the form
of popular tales, of which we find several examples,
among his works, as for instance his story of Jupiter's
satellites, of the star which had recently appeared in
the Swan, and his "Dream of the World." Exceed-
ingly vivid episodes are also frequently found in his
other writings, as for instance in his work on the new
star, which had appeared with great radiance in the
foot of Serpentarius, in 1604, It was this appearance
which raised again the question, whether the heavens
could really be called unchangeable, according to
Aristotle, when new stars actually appeared in it. Did
this star originate recently from the light-exhalations
of the universe, and if so, were perhaps all stars of
the universe such incidental productions of fate?
Against such assumptions, Kepler's deeply religious
nature struggled, and the idea of Cicero came into
his mind, that just as well might Homer's Iliad hdixe
been thrown together (as one would throw dice) from
the twenty-four letters of the alphabet, as the har-
mony of the universe from a lot of whirling atoms.
Keplek's
"Yesterday, in the midst of my meditations," he writes, "I Astronomical
was called to the table, as my young wife was serving a salad. ' Do Telescope -
you think,' I asked, 'that if pewter dishes, lettuce-leaves, grains of
salt, drops of oil and vinegar, with hard-boiled eggs, had been flying about in this
room higgledy-piggledy since creation, chance would ever have been able to gather
them together to-day into a salad ? ' ' Certainly not into so well and skilfully mixed
a one as this,' answered my beautiful wife."
1 In eight volumes, Frankfort, 1858— 1S72.
SGonstruction given in the Dioptrics (\(,\a]. After Danneniann. For the convex and concave
lenses of the Dutch and Galilean telescopes Kepler substituted two suitably disposed convex
lenses, giving an inverted but clearer image.
408 IHK ()Ht;N COUKl.
When to the newly discovered telescope, which in the begin-
ning was very imperfect and v/as constructed on the principle of the
opera glass, he had given the arrangement of the astronomical tel-
escope still in use, he addressed the new instrument in the preface
to his Dioptrics as follows: "O knowledge-fraught perspicil, more
precious than any sceptre ! Does not he who holds thee in his right
hand, stand like a king and a master of the works of God?"
As often as I try to search out in the history of German inves-
tigation the prototype of the practical ideal of German philosophy,
the ideal of Faust, who, wandering, but not confused, struggles
forward to the solution of the great world-problems, I always come
back again to Kepler, who, by his profound meditation, embodied
as has none other, the specifically German bent of mind.
How proudly he asserts in his Harmony of the World, that he
wrote this book as a German, according to the German manner and
habit of philosophising, freely and without constraint. All his works
and all his actions are in the most beautiful accord with this same
reflective German spirit, which descends to the profoundest depths
of speculation, yet ever remains self-conscious. He declined the
call to Bologna because he was a German, and did not wish to re-
nounce German liberty of speech and investigation ; and although
in constant distress in Prague, because of failure to receive his
salary, he answered the invitation of the king of England, that only
ingratitude could make him think of leaving Austria, his second
fatherland. Without envy he recognised foreign merit, rejoiced
over Galileo's discoveries, and admired in Copernicus still more
than his learning, his "free spirit." Yet, if all who pass judgment
on this German would do him like justice, they would have to say
with Galileo: "While I hold Kepler in exceedingly high esteem
on account of his fine unprejudiced mind, yet his manner of philos-
ophising is radically different from my own."
THE NOTION OF A CONTINUUM,
BY PROF. ERNST MACH.
BY a continuum is understood a system or manifoldness of parts
possessed in varying degree of a property A, such that be-
tween any two parts distant a finite length from each other, an in-
finite number of other parts may be interpolated, of which those
that are immediately adjacent exhibit only infinitely small differ-
ences with respect to the property A.
There can be no objection to such a system, considered as a
fiction merely, or as a purely arbitrary ideal construct. But the
natural inquirer, who is not exclusively concerned with the purely
mathematical point of view, is compelled to inquire whether there
is anything in nature that corresponds to such a fiction. Space
viewed in its simplest form as a succession of points in a straight
line, time viewed as the succession of the elements of a uniformly
sounding musical note, the succession of colors shown by the spec-
trum with the Fraunhofer lines obscured, are typical instances of
the kind of continua presented in nature. If we consider such a
"continuum" solely in the light of facts, it will be seen that there
is nothing perceptible by the senses corresponding to an infinite
number of parts or to infinitely minute differences. All we may say
is, that in traversing such a succession, the differences between the
parts increase as the parts move away from each other, until
ultimately these differences admit of not the slightest doubt ; and
again, that as the parts approach each other the differences decrease,
that afterwards it is alternately possible and impossible to distin-
guish them, according to chance and circumstances, and that fi-
nally it is altogether impossible to do so. Points of space and time
do not exist for sense-perception ; there exist for such, only spaces
and times so small as not to admit of more minute division percep-
1 f'anslated from the VVdrvielehre by T. J. McCormack.
4IO THE OPEN COURT.
tible to the senses, or so small that we consciously neglect their
size, although on increased attention they might admit of resolu-
tion into component elements. The possibility of passing imper-
ceptibly and uninterruptedly from a property ^ to a property A' ,
sharply distinguishable from A, is the important point. The fact
is, that any two terms on given trial are either distinguishable or
undistinguishable.
It is possible to remove a large number of parts from a given
sensory continuum without causing the system to cease giving the
impression of a continuum. If we imagine a large number of nar-
row equidistant bands of color cut out of a spectrum, and the re-
mainder pushed together until the parts touch, the spectrum will
still give the impression of a color-continuum, in spite of the inter-
ruption of continuity in the wave-lengths of the lines. In like man-
ner, an ascending musical note, if the intervals between the rates of
vibration be sufficiently small, may be regarded as a continuum, and
the jolting movement produced by a sufficiently large number of
successive but detached stroboscopic pictures may also be made to
appear as a continuous movement.
If the parts of a sensory continuum stood forth as individual
entities and were distinguishable with absolute accuracy, the em-
ployment of artificial expedients, as the use of measures for com-
paring continua of the same kind and the use of dividing lines for
rendering imperceptible differences of space distinct by means of
conspicuous differences in color, etc., would be superfluous. But
the moment we introduce such artifices as being superior physically
for the indication of the differences, we abandon the domain of im-
mediate sense-perception, and pursue a course in every respect
similar to that of substituting the thermometer for the sensation of
heat. A distance in which the measure is contained twice or three
times, is then twice or three times that in which it is contained
once ; and the hundredth part of the measure corresponds to a hun-
dredth part of the difference, although it may not be said that this
difference holds good for direct perception. With the introduction
of the measure, a new definition of distance or difference has been
introduced. Judgments of difference are now no longer formed
from simple sense-perception, but are reached by the more com-
plex reaction involved in the application of the measure; and the
result depends upon the issue of the experimental test. The con-
sideration last adduced may be profitably called to the attention
of that still large body of thinkers who refuse to admit that the
THE NOTION OF A CONTINUUM. 4II
axioms of geometry are the results of experience, — results 7wt given
by direct perception when metrical concepts are introduced.
The employment of measures suggests the employment of num-
bers, but the use of the latter is not necessarily entailed until it is
resolved to employ only one measure, which is multiplied or subdi-
vided according as the necessity arises for a larger or smaller con-
tinuum of comparison. In using a measure divided into absolutely
equal parts, we are immediately enabled to employ all the numeral
experiences which we have gained from our study of discrete objects.
This is not the place for a detailed discussion of the manner in which
operations of counting themselves gave rise to the necessity of new
numeral concepts far transcending the bounds of the original system
of integer positive numbers and of the gradual manner in which
negative and fractional numbers, and finally the entire system of
rational numbers, came into being.
If a unit is to be divided, it must either exhibit natural parts
for such a division, as for example do many fruits, or it must at least
permit of being conceived as made up of perfectly homogeneous
equivalent parts. The early appearance of unit-fractions is a prob-
able indication that division was learned by experiences of the first-
mentioned kind, and that the skill acquired in that field was car-
ried over to cases of the second class, namely, to the division of
continua. It is here apparent from the simplest instances that
the number-system which originated from the consideration of dis-
crete objects is inadequate for the representation of fluent or con-
tinuous states. For instance, the common fraction 1=0. 333333 . . .
A point of trisection, in other words, can never be found exactly by
decimal subdivision, however minute. The ratios of certain line-
segments, as that of the diagonal to the side of the square, are ab-
solutely unrepresentable by rational numbers, as Pythagoras long
ago discovered,^ and lead immediately to the concept of the irra-
tional.^
The cases of this are innumerable. It may be expressed by
saying that "the straight line is infinitely richer in point-individ-
uals than the domain of rational members is in number-individuals."^
But the remark is applicable, as the illustration given above of the
1 Euclid's ingenious proof of this proposition is found in his Elements, X, 117. Compare Can
tor's views in his Geschichte der Mathematik, pp. 154, at seq.
2 The irrational number \'p is the limit between all rational numbers (i) the squares of which
are less and (2) the squares of which are greater than/. In tl;e first class no greatest, and in the
second no least, number can be assigned. If \ p is rational, the number in question is the greatest
of the first and the least of the second class. Compare Tannery, Thcoric des Fotutions, Paris, 18S6
3Dedekind, Stetigkeii itnd irrationale Zahlen, Brunswick, 1892.
412 THE OPEN COURT.
point of trisection shows, quite irrespective of the irrational feature,
to every .y/^<:/a/ number-system. We might say i is a relative ir-
rational number, as compared with the decimal system.
Numbers, which were originally created for the intellectual
mastery of discrete objects, accordingly prove themselves to be ab-
solutely inadequate for the mastery of continua which are conceived
as inexhaustible, be these real or fictitious. Zeno's assertion of
the impossibility of motion on account of the infinite number of
the points that had to be traversed between the initial and terminal
stations, was admirably refuted in this sense by Aristotle, who re-
marked that "a moving object does not move by numbers."^ The
idea that we are obliged to exhaust all things by counting is due to
the inappropriate employment of a method which, for a great many
cases, is quite appropriate. A pathological phenomenon of what
might be called the counting-mania actually makes its appearance
here. No one will be inclined to discover a problem in the fact that
the series of natural numbers can be continued upwards as far as
we please, and consequently can never be completed ; and it is not
a whit more necessary to discover a problem in the fact that the di-
vision of a number into smaller and smaller parts can be continued
ad libitum and consequently never completed.
At the time of the founding of the infinitesimal calculus, and
even in the subsequent period, people were much occupied with
paradoxes of this character. A difficulty was found in the fact that
the expression for a differential was never exact, save when the dif-
ferential had become infinitely small, ^ — a limit which could never
be reached. The sum of non-infinitely small elements, it was thus
thought, could give only an approximately correct result. It was
sought to resolve this difficulty in all sorts of ways. But the actual
practical uses to which the infinitesimal calculus is put are totally
different from what is here assumed, as the simplest example will
show, and are affected in no wise whatever by the imaginary diffi-
culty in question.
If j('=„v"', I find for an increment dx of x the increment
dy =^ 7/1 x" ^ ax -] ^- — - — - x ' ~ ' dx-
1-2-3
Having this result, it will be seen that the function x'" reacts in a
definite manner in response to a definite operation, namely, that of
1 Hankel, Geschichte der Mathematik, Leipsic, 1874, p. 149.
THE NOTION OF A CONTINUUM. 413
differentiation. This reaction is a characteristic mark of x'", and
stands on precisely the same footing as the bluish-green coloring
which arises from dissolving copper in sulphuric acid. The num-
ber of terms that remain standing in the series is in itself indiffer-
ent. But the reaction is simplified by taking dx so small that the
subsequent terms vanish with respect to the first. It is on account
of this simplification only that dx is considered very small.
In a curve with the ordinate s=wa:'"~^ it is seen that on in-
creasing X by dx, the quadrature of the curve is increased by a small
amount of surface, the expression for which when dx is very small
is simplified by reduction to the form ?;/.v"'~^^/a-. In response to
the same operation as before, and under the same simplifying cir-
cumstances, the quadrature reacts as the familiar function x'" re-
acts. We recognise the function, thus, by its reaction.
If the mode in which the quadrature reacted did not accord with
the mode of reaction of any function known to us, the entire method
would leave us in the lurch. We should then have to resort to
mechanical quadratures; we should actually be compelled to put
up with finite elements; we should have to sum up finite numbers
of these elements; and in such an event the result would be really
inexact.
The twofold salto mortale from the finite to the infinitely small,
and back again from this to the finite, is accordingly nowhere ac-
tually performed ; on the contrary, the situation here is quite simi-
ar to that in every other domain of research. Acquaintance with
mathematical and geometrical facts is acquired by actual employ-
ment with those facts. These, on making their appearance again,
are recognised, and when they appear in part only, they are com-
pleted in thought, in so far as they are uniquely determined. ^
The manner in which the conception of a continuum has arisen
1 It is well known that differentials may be avoided by operating with differential coefficients
which are the limiting values of the difference-quotients. Timid minds which find solace in this
mode of conception will be content to put up with the cumbrousness sometimes involved.
414 THE OPEN COURT.
will now be clear. In a sensory system the parts of which exhibit
fluxional characteristics not readily admitting of distinction, we
cannot retain the single parts either in the senses or in the imagina-
tion with any certainty. To be able to recognise definitely, there-
fore, the relations obtaining between the parts of such systems, we
have to employ artificial devices such as measures. The mode of
action of the measures is then substituted for the mode of action of
the senses. Immediate contact with the system is lost by this pro-
cedure ; and, furthermore, since the technology of measurement is
founded on the technology of counting, numbers are substituted for
the measures precisely as the measures were substituted for direct
sense-perception. After we have once performed the operation of
dividing a unit into component parts, and after we have once no-
ticed that the parts exhibit the same properties as the original unit,
then no obstacle presents itself to our continuing in thought to in-
finity the subdivision of the number which stands for the measure.
But in doing so we imagine that we have also divided both the
measure and system that is measured, into infinity. And this leads
us to the notion of a continuum having the properties which we
specified at the beginning of this article.
But it is not permissible to assume that everything that can be
done with a sign or a number can also be done with the thing desig-
nated by that sign or number. Admitting that the number which is
employed to specify a distance can be divided into infinity without
any possibility whatever of meeting with obstacles, still the possi-
bility of such division by no means necessarily applies to the dis-
tance itself. There is nothing that presents the appearance oi a con-
tinuum but may still be composed of discrete elements, provided
only those elements be sufficiently small as compared with our
smallest practically applicable measures, or provided only they be
sufficiently numerous.
Wherever we imagine we discover a continuum, all we can say
is, that we can institute the same observations with respect to the
smallest observable parts of the system in question as we can in
the case of larger systems, and that we observe that the behavior
of those parts is quite similar to that of the parts of larger systems.
The length to which these observations may be carried can be
decided by experience only. Where experience raises no protest,
we may hold fast to the notion of a continuum, which is in no wise
injurious and represents a convenient fiction only.
THE SO-CALLED MYSTERY PLAYS.
BY E. F. L. GAUSS.
'T'^HE return during the coming summer of the Passion-Play at
J. Oberammergau in Bavaria has revived and increased the in-
terest in this most famous of all mystery-plays, perhaps more so in
this country than elsewhere. It may be timely, therefore, to inquire
into the history and nature of these plays, with special reference to
the one above named, which dates in its present form from the
year 1633, and has since then been repeated every ten years, save
when adverse circumstances prevented its performance.
While religious plays of a similar nature existed before the
Christian era, and some are known of more modern people other
than Christians, it may be said that the Christian mystery-plays are
as old as the story of Christ. From the beginning of the Christian
services, there was more or less of a dramatic element in them,
which has developed with the Church. This is due to the instinct
in man to express his religious sentiments and feelings by act as
well as by word, and is more or less shared by all religious services.
Indeed, every art of man has grown out of this human impulse and
need. Architecture, as an art, began with the erection of temples
to the gods, giving painting and sculpture the necessary foundation
and the opportunity for development. If it were not innate in these
arts to give expression to the spiritually highest conception, there
would not be the revolt against the realistic tendencies of our
present time.
The pure dramatic art especially, representing the highest ideal
types, not in colors and dead materials as sculpture and painting, but
by imitation through living figures, has sprung from the unavoidable
acting in religious services. We need only point to the worship of
Dionysos by the Greeks, which consisted chiefly in mimic represen-
tations of the exploits of the god.
4i6
THE OPEN COURT.
But as the religious conceptions grew from the crude to higher
ideals, culminating in the dynamic God-idea of the Christian faith,
so grew the ideals of dramatic representation upon the religious
field. Whoever is familiar with the services and ceremonies of the
Roman and Greek Catholic Church, must have been struck by the
dramatic force in them. But especially on certain holidays of the
Church, such as Christmas, the Feast of the Wise Men from the
East, Palm Sunday, Good Friday, the day of Christ's burial, ami
SATAN, ATTIRED AS A BISHOP, SLAYS Tf
PREACHER ZACHARIJAH WITH THE
ASSISTANCE OF THE COOK.
A.
%"
aA
^cL
%:/ ^-> - ??ft.
m
3. THE SON IS SLA1>
^
■ ^.^^k
t^^
^^^^3
'J
m
^m
"^^^
^^Mk
^*^'S,e
^^i^^s
2. SATAN APPEARS IN DISGUISE AT THE
VINTAGE.
4. SATAN ANNOUNCES THE DEATH OF THE
SON AT THE MOUTH OF HELL.
Scenes from M. Jacob Ruff's Religious Dramatisation of the Story of
Job and the Parable of the Vineyard.
Satan is introduced as sowing the seeds of sedition in the minds of the servants of
the vineyard and induces them to slay the son of their master. •
Easter Sunday, the services have unfolded from an early date into
actual dramatic plays. Particularly striking among these in some
1 Performed at Zurich, 1539 A. D., on May 26. From Konnecke, after contemporaneous illus-
trations.
THE SO-CALLED MYSTERY-PLAYS.
417
countries are the representations of Christ's entrance into Jerusa-
lem on Palm Sunday and of his resurrection on Easter Day. In
the latter, priests dressed as women approach the tomb, and upon
hearing the assurance of the angel seated there, "He is not here,
he is risen ! " return to the altar, announcing to the assembled con-
gregation : "Christ is risen ! " The great processions of the Cath-
olic Church are to this day dramatic representations of features in
the life of Christ or in the history of the Church.
The mystery-plays in all countries were largely of the same
character, since they have the same foundation and the same origin,
the coloring only varying in small measure with the characteristics
and peculiar religious conceptions of the people. They reached
their climax in the latter half of the middle ages, when the perform-
GOD THE FATHER SATAN GOD THE SON
The Main Actors in the Medieval Mystery-Plays.
ance of the larger plays lasted several days. Their texts, taken from
the Gospels and the legends of the Church, were mostly crude and,
while generally written in the language of the country, profusedly
interspersed with Latin words and phrases. As a rule their authors
were clerics, in most cases monks or nuns. But while the poetic
value of the mystery-plays was but small, we may assume that they
were all most excellently presented as to acting and scenic effect.
It is a remarkable fact, that the great solemnity of these plays
did not protect them against the intrusion of jokes and comic inter-
mezzos, for which an opportunity was offered in the part played
by the devil, the deeds of Judas, and the bitterness of the Jews.
The latter especially fared ill in these plays, and it may be supposed
1 From Bilderatlas zur Geschichte der deutschen Nationallitteratur, by Dr. Gus^av Konnecke,
Marburg, 1895, p. 93.
4l8 THE OPEN COURT.
that their portraiture in them had not a little to do with the con-
tempt in which the Jews were held in the middle ages.
The oldest of the passion plays known is that of St. Gall,
Switzerland, which came down to us from the fourteenth century.
In England the mystery-plays were generally only performed in
connexion with the processions on Corpus Christi day. In Austria,
the Tyrol, and Germany, they were prevalent up to the eighteenth
century, while in France a special community, the "Confr^rie de
la Passion," was founded for the purpose of producing and enact-
ing passion-plays. From the north of France we have only mys-
tery-plays of the fifteenth century, but these in large numbers. It
is worthy of notice that while Italy is the centre of the Catholic
Church, where its ceremonies are matters of daily observance and
therefore most familiar to the people, we know of only one Italian
passion-play, and that was published as late as 1888 at Turin.
The performance of the mystery-plays was, as indicated before,
originally part of the church-services and very simple. The per-
formers were, as a rule, either priests or members of sacred orders,
monks or nuns. The latter were at one time very prominent in
them, because the Virgin and Mary Magdalene were necessarily
represented.
One of the simplest among the early plays consisted in "The
Lamentations of Mary" at the death of her son, forming the lyric in-
troduction to the celebration of Easter. Soon, however, the mystery-
plays became in a measure worldly, inasmuch as they were played
by worldly companies in public places, generally at fairs and marts.
In fact, the name of these latter in some modern languages, partic-
ularly in German, is derived from "missa" or "mass," because
they ordinarily took place in connexion with the observance of the
more important church feasts.
On such occasions the mystery-plays were performed upon
special stages, roughly erected in the market-places, or even more
commonly in the street between the houses, extending from one
side to the other. These stages ordinarily consisted of three di-
visions, heaven, earth and hell, which could be opened to rear and
front, or on large places to all four sides, so that the performance
could be witnessed by all the people gathered around the stage.
One of the most characteristic mystery-plays of the middle
ages was that of the "Wise and Foolish Virgins," which was very
popular for several centuries, especially in Germany. At the be-
ginning of this play Christ (the ^'dominica persona,^' as he was called
in most of the mystery-plays) appears in the uppermost part of the
THE SO-CALLED MYSTERY-PLAYS.
419
Stage (heaven), surrounded by Mary and the angels. Then the
virgins come upon the scene in the middle part of the stage (earth).
The story is played as it is related in Matthew with some additions,
showing Mary interceding for the foolish virgins. Thereupon the
lower part of the stage (the jaws of hell) hitherto closed, opens.
Lucifer and a host of devils and of the damned are seen. They
remind Christ that he had promised to be a just judge and claim
Old English Mystery Play.
As performed on a portable stage erected in a public market-place,
usually on the occasion of some church festival.
the foolish virgins, who, after repeated vain intercessions from Mary,
are delivered up to the Prince of Darkness, and are bound by the
devils with chains, and dragged below. They disappear with the
cry of despair, "We deserve the wrath of God, we are eternally
lost ! " while above, Christ, Mary, the angels, and the wise virgins
are seen in blissful union. Thus ends the most dramatic of all
mystery-plays of old. How powerful the effect of these plays was
420 THE OPEN COURT.
upon the spectators, is shown by the case of Frederic, Landgrave
of Thuringia, who, upon witnessing one of the performances of this
play just described, fell into an hysterical state, which deprived
him of his reason and caused his death three years after.
Aside from some minor performances connected with the ser-
vices of the Catholic Church, nothing is left in our days of the old
mystery-plays, except the great Passion-Play at Oberammergau,
and in minor form in some other German and Swiss villages, refined
and purified in conception as well as in its dramatic production.
The town of Oberammergau itself is of historic interest. The Ro-
mans used the place as a trading-post and called it Coveliaca. It
has always been a thrifty village latterly, especially in certain in-
dustries connected with the religious life of the Catholic people. It
is not known whether mystery-piays were performed in the town in
the middle ages or previously, but there are strong indications that
such was the case.
However this may be, the fact is authenticated that in 1633 the
present Passion-Play was first produced there. It came about in
this wise : In the year named the plague visited that neighborhood
and claimed a great many victims in the village. The inhabitants
in their simple faith trusted that God would send them succor, and
they made a vow to perform "the great atoning-sacrifice upon Cal-
vary to the glory of God." The vow was enthusiastically partici-
pated in by all the people of the town and piously carried out.
Miraculously — as the people looked upon it — the plague ceased,
and in their gratitude to their deliverer and in their desire to per-
petuate their thanks through their children, the godly peasants
resolved to repeat the performance every ten years, the present year
closing the twenty-sixth decade.
Originally the performances took place in the most primitive
way at the cemetery of the village, but the play gradually attracted
large numbers of people, who now flock to witness it from all parts
of the globe, so that it soon became necessary to erect a play-house
in the village and to repeat the play a number of times during the
season. But not until 1890 was there anything but a board-fence
surrounding the seats of the auditorium, beside the spacious stage,
all uncovered. This year there is a large and commodious build-
ing, costing 62,000 dollars, with a seating capacity of from 4-5000,
still partly without a roof, as is also the greater portion of the stage.
The auditorium, fitted out with folding-chairs, is so well arranged
that every foot of the stage is clearly in view from even the cheap-
est seat, and the acoustic properties of the hall are most perfect.
THE SO-CALLED MYSTERY-PLAYS. 421
The stage is immense, representing chiefly the streets and build-
ings of Jerusalem at the time of Christ. Decorative paintings show
the original "play-ground" upon the cemetery, the old commercial
roads of the Germans ar.d biblical scenes. Everything is most
artistic.
The text of the Passion-Play was originally of the same crude-
ness that marked the early mystery-plays, and is claimed to have
been written by one of the monks of the neighboring monastery of
Ettal. In the course of time, however, the words were repeatedly
improved, until the drama reached a high perfection in its present
form, which was given it in 1850 by the priest of the village, Dai-
senberger. This pious man was for many years the spiritual guide
of the villagers, and to his wise and energetic efforts and zeal is due
the great interest of the entire world in the Passion-Play, which
never fails to make a deep impression upon every spectator of what-
ever creed and views he may be. The performers are all people of
the village, and those impersonating the more important characters
generally play them a number of seasons, achieving thereby inter-
national reputation.
The present year will bring an almost complete change in the
cast, and much is expected, especially of the two persons who bear
the roles of Christ and Mary. There is much music in the play, and
the choruses are pronounced by experts exceptionally fine.
Oberammergau is very picturesquely situated between high
mountains about 2550 feet above sea-level, and the highest of the
mountains overlooking the village, the Kofel, is fittingly crowned
by an immense stone-group of the Crucifixion, towering above the
summit more than forty feet. This fine piece of sculpture was erect-
ed in 1875 by the admiring friend of the villagers, King Louis II.
of Bavaria.
THE OLD AND THE NEW MAGIC.
HE EDIl'OK
[concluded.]
AFTER the old magic had retreated to the dingy haunts of for-
- tune-tellers and to the equivocal atmosphere of spiritualistic
stances, leading the lingering life of a consumptive, modern magic
developed rapidl}' and is now becoming more and more fascinating.
In speaking of modern magic, we refer to the art of the pres-
tidigitator, and exclude from its domain the experiments of hypno-
tism as well as the vulgar lies of fraud. There is no magic in the
psychosis of an hysterical subject who at the hypnotiser's suggestion
becomes the prey of hallucinations ; nor is there any art in the de-
ceptions of the fortune-teller, whose business will vanish when the
public ceases to be credulous and superstitious. The former is a
disease, the latter mere fraud. Magic proper (i. e., the artifices of
prestidigitation) is produced by a combination of three factors :
(]) legerdemain proper, or sleight of hand; (2) psychological illu-
sions, and (3) surprising feats of natural science with clever con-
cealment of their true causes. The success of almost ever}' trick
depends upon the introduction of these three factors.
The throwing of cards is mere dexterity ; Zollner's famous fig-
ures of parallel lines having an apparent inclination toward one
another is a pure sense-illusion (see the cut on page 426); so is the
magical swing ; while fire-eating (or better, fire-breathing) is a
purely ph3'sical experiment. But it goes without saying that there
is scarcely any performance of genuine prestidigitation which is
not a combination of all these elements.
The production of a bowl of water with living fishes in it is a
combination of dexterity with psychology. The bowl, covered with
an India rubber membrane, hangs in a running sling fastened to a
cord, at the back of the performer, who exhibits to the audience
a napkin, and while showing them that it contains nothing by
THE OLD AND THE NEW MAGIC. 423
spreading it out before their eyes, he bows slightly and slips the
bowl into the napkin. Seizing the bowl and taking off the India
rubber membrane together with the napkin is the work of a mo-
ment; and yet it is nothing but dexterity, so tempered with decep-
tion that the audience (unless initiated into the trick) cannot dis-
cover the cause of the bowl's appearance.
When a performer makes a dollar disappear by holding it up
in his left hand and catching it with his right, we have a psychical
illusion. The movement of the right hand merely diverts the at-
tention, for the dollar remains in the left hand and is hidden, while
the right hand in which every spectator expects it to be, is slowly
opened and shown to be empty.
The trick with the glass dial (which is now exhibited by both
Mr. Kellar and Mr. Hermann, the nephew of the late Alexander
Hermann) is purely physical. The machinery used by them is
apparently different, though Mr. Kellar's apparatus is the more
perfect; for in neither case is any sleight of hand needed nor any
psychological diversion, except in letting the accomplice behind
the stage know the number to which he should point.
As an instance of a wonderful trick which is a mere sense-illu-
sion we mention the magic swing, which is explained by Albert A.
Hopkins in his comprehensive book on magic ^ as follows:
"Those who are to participate in the apparent gyrations of the swing — and
there may be quite a number who enjoy it simultaneously — are ushered into a small
room. From a bar crossing the room, near the ceiling, hangs a large swing, which
is provided with seats for a number of people. After the people have taken their
places, the attendant pushes the car and it starts into oscillation like any other
swing. The room door is closed. Gradually those in it feel after three or four
movements that their swing is going rather high, but this is not all. The appai'ent
amplitude of the oscillations increases more and more, until presently the whole
swing seems to whirl completely over, describing a full circle about the bar on
which it hangs. To make the thing more utterly mysterious, the bar is bent crank
fashion, the swing continues apparently to go round and round this way, imparting
a most weird sensation to the occupants, until its movements begin gradually to
cease and the complete rotation is succeeded by the usual back and forth swinging.
The door of the room is opened, and the swinging party leave. Those who have
tried it say the sensation is most peculiar. -
"The illusion is based on the movements of the room proper. During the
^Magic, Stage Illusions, and Scientific Diversions, Including Trick Photography. Compiled
and edited by Albeit A. Hopkins. With 400 illustrations. New York : Munn & Co. 1898. Price,
$2.50. We noticed this book in the January number of The Ope'n Court, but are glad to call
our readers' attention to it again, as it will be a welcome addition to the library of those who
enjoy the seances of our prestidigitators and would like to possess a work of ready reference on
the subject.
2 See the illustrations on pages 424 and 425. The illustration on page 424 shows the true
position of the swing, that on page 425 shows the illusion produced by a ride in the swing.
424
THE OPEN COURT.
entire exhibition the swing is practically stationery, while the room rotates about
the suspending bar. At the beginning of operations the swing may be given a slight
True Position of the Swing.
push ; the operators outside the room then begin to swing the room itself, which is
really a large box journaled on the swing bar, starting it off to correspond with the
THE OLD AND THE NEW MAGIC.
425
movements of the swing. They swing it back and forth, increasing the arc through
which it moves until it goes so far as to make a complete rotation. The operatives
Illusion Produced by a Ride in the Swing.
do this without special machinery, taking hold of the sides and corners of the box
or ' ' room. " At this time the people in the swing imagine that the room is stationary
426
THE OPEN COURT.
while they are whirling through space. After keeping this up for some time, the
movement is brought gradually to a stop, a sufficient number of back and forth
swings being given at the //;/«/(■ to carry out the illusion to the end.
" The room is as completely furnished as possible, everything being, of course,
fastened in place. What is apparently a kerosene lamp stands on a table, near at
hand. It is securely fastened to the table, which in its turn is fastened to the floor,
and the light is supplied by a small incandescent lamp within the chimney, but
concealed by the shade. The visitor never imagines that it is an electric lamp, and
naturally thinks that it would be impossible for a kerosene lamp to be inverted
without disaster, so that this adds to the deception materially. The same is to be
said of the pictures hanging on the wall, of the cupboard full of chinaware, of the
chair with a hat on it, and of the baby carriage. All contribute to the mystifica-
tion. Even though one is informed of the secret before entering the swing, the
deception is said to be so complete that passengers involuntarily seize the arms of
the seats to avoid being precipitated below."
The illusion is purely an instance of
misguided judgment,, which is commonly
but erroneously called illusion of the
senses^ and belongs to the same category
as the well-known Zollner figures men-
tioned above and consisting of heavy lines
crossed slantingly by lighter lines. The
heavy lines are parallel but appear to
diverge in the direction of the slant. (See
cut. )
To conjure ghosts has alwa3's been
the highest ambition of performers of ma-
gical tricks and we know that the magic
lantern has been used for this purpose
since mediaeval days. Benvenuto Cellini
chronicles a strange story in his fascinating
biography, which we recapitulate in Mr.
Hopkins's words :
"Cellini, as guileless as a child in matters of science, desiring to study sor-
cery, applied to a Sicilian priest who was a professed dabbler in the occult art.
One dark night they repaired to the ruins of the Coliseum at Rome ; the monk
described a circle on the ground and placed himself and the great goldsmith within
its mystic outlines ; a fire was built, intoxicating perfumes cast on it, and soon an
impenetrable smoke arose. The man of the cowl then waved his wand in the air,
pronounced sundry cabalistic words, and legions of demons were seen dancing in
the air, to the great terror of Cellini. The story of this spirit seance reads like an
Arabian tale, but it is easily explainable. The priest had a brother confederate
concealed among the ruins, who manipulated a concave mirror, by means of which
painted images were thrown on the smoke."
Zollner's Illu.sion.
For an explanation of similar cases of misguided judgment see 7'/ie Monist, Vol. III., p. 152.
THE OLD AND THE NEW MAGIC. 427
The same author describes the further perfection of the art of
conjuring ghosts by Robertson and then by Mr. Pepper, as follows :
"In the height of the French Revolution, when the guillotine reeked with
blood and the ghastly knitting-women sat round it counting the heads as they fell
into the basket, a Belgian optician, named Etienne Gaspard Robertson, arrived in
Paris, and opened a wonderful exhibition in an abandoned chapel belonging to the
Capuchin convent. The curiosity-seekers who attended these seances were con-
ducted by ushers down dark flights of stairs to the vaults of the chapel and seated
in a gloomy crypt shrouded with black draperies and pictured with the emblems of
mortality. An antique lamp, suspended from the ceiling, emitted a flame of spectral
blue. When all was ready a rain and wind storm, with thunder accompanying,
began. Robertson extinguished the lamp and threw various essences on a brazier
of burning coals in the center of the room, whereupon clouds of odoriferous incense
filled the apartment. Suddenly, with the solemn sound of a far-off organ, phan-
toms of the great arose at the incantations of the magician. Shades of Voltaire,
Rousseau, Marat, and Lavoisier appeared in rapid succession. Robertson, at the
end of the entertainment, generally concluded by saying : ' I have shown you, cit-
izens, every species of phantom, and there is but one more truly terrible specter —
the fate which is reserved for us all.' In a moment a grinning skeleton stood in
the center of the hall waving a scythe. All these wonders were perpetrated
through the medium of a phantasmagoric lantern, which threw images upon
smoke."
The art of conjuring ghosts was perfected when the introduc-
tion of large show windows called Professor Pepper's attention to
the usefulness of glass as affording a transparent mirror. Mr. Hop-
kins says :
" Clever as was Robertson's ghost illusion, performed by the aid of the phan-
tasmagoric lantern, it had one great defect: the images were painted on glass and
lacked the necessary vitality. It was reserved for the nineteenth century to pro-
duce the greatest of spectral exhibitions, that of Professor Pepper, manager of the
London Polytechnic Institution. In the year 1863, he invented a clever device for
projecting the images of living persons in the air. The illusion is based on a simple
optical effect. In the evening carry a lighted candle to the window and you will
see reflected in the pane, not only the image of the candle but that of your hand
and face as well. The same illusion may be seen while travelling in a lighted rail-
way carriage at night ; you gaze through the clear sheet of glass of the coach win-
dow and behold your " double" travelling along with you. The apparatus for pro-
ducing the Pepper ghost has been used in dramatisations of Bulwer's "Strange
Story," Dickens' " Haunted Man " and " Christmas Carol," and Dumas' "Corsican
Brothers." In France the conjurers Robin and Lassaigne presented the illusion
with many novel and startling effects."
The illustration on page 428, reproduced from Carl Willmann's
work, sufficiently explains all details.
The Indian basket trick is a shocking performance, still prac-
tised in Hindustan in the open streets. A child is placed in an
oblong osier basket strapped so tight that it cannot escape, then
a sword is thrust into the basket, which on being withdrawn drips
"^ THE OPEN COURT.
■"'In':;-, T'" 7''^"" '^ te„or-s,nc.e„, but when the basket
IS opened it is found empt}'.
an. J!" "f """" " ""'P'" ■^'" P"'°""er has several assist-
ants of s,™.Iar appearance around hin,, all of then, dressed orarly
THE OLD AND THE NEW MAGIC.
429
alike. The child crawls out through an unnoticeable slit where
two ends overlap ; and while the conjurer puts his knee against
the basket, apparently to fasten the strap as tightl}^ as possible, the
prisoner hides under his flowing robe and then joins the other as-
sistants.
Herr Willmann describes practically the same trick under the
title "Spirit box," designed to prove the permeability of matter. A
medium is placed in the box, and after some hocus-pocus the man-
ager reopenes it and declares it to be empty; for the purpose of
proving his assertion he turns it over toward the public, and when
The " Spirit-Box," or Mysterious Trunk.
the lid is opened, the medium, who remains all the while in his
place, has become invisible, because he is hidden by the interior
part of the double wall, which now seems to be the bottom of the
box. The box stands upon a podium, in order to show that the
medium could not have escaped through the floor. The adjoined
illustration reveals the secret of the trick, the explanation of which
is as simple as the effect is surprising.
On stages which allow the prestidigitator to use traps, a trunk
is placed so as to allow the prisoner to escape through the floor.
The movable wall of the trunk in such a case swings round an axis
430
THE OPEN COURT.
which lies parallel with the rope that is afterwards fastened round
the trunk. The movable wall in the trunk connects with a trap in
the floor, and while visitors from the audience closel)' watch the
fastening, the enclosed person makes his escape with the greatest
ease.
Kellar has still another method of making a person disappear,
THE OLD AND THE NEW MAGIC.
431
which being done in full view of the audience is extremely perplex-
ing. The trick was invented by Mr. W. E. Robinson, the assistant
k^.
of the late Hermann and is based upon the same device as Pro-
fessor Pepper's ghosts. Mr. Hopkins describes it as follows (see
the above illustration):
432
THE OPEN COURT.
"When the curtain is raised the square frame is seen; this frame is braced
laterally by side pieces. At the lower part of the frame, within easy reach of the
prestidigitator, is a windlass. Ropes pass from this windlass, over pulleys, to a
crossbar in the upper part of the frame. A lady is now brought upon the stage and
seated in a chair, which she grasps tightly. She is then tied tightly to the chair
with ropes, and her hands are chained together. The prestidigitator now secures
the chair, with its fair occupant, to the ropes which are connected with the wind-
lass, by means of hooks which fasten to the top frame of the chair. The professor
of magic now winds away at the windlass and raises the chair until the head of the
victim is on a level with the crossbar. He then discharges a pistol, and at the same
instant the lady disappears and the chair drops to the floor. Such is, in brief, the
mode of operation of the trick called ' Gone.' "
The explanation is simple. The frame is covered between the
cross bars with plateglass which is invisible and leaves the lady on
the chair in full sight so long as the light falls upon her. A screen
of the same color as the background is concealed above the curtain
and placed at such an angle as to allow its reflexion to pass out to
the audience. The prestidigitator fires several shots from a pistol,
which is a signal for his assistant to turn a switch. The lady is
now veiled in relative darkness while the screen is illuminated and
its reflexion on the plate-glass conceals her from sight. She drops
the chair, which, like the shots, helps to divert the attention of the
audience, and the curtain drops before further investigation can be
made. The illusion is perfect, and the more watchful the public
are, the more will they wonder how a person can disappear so
completely and suddenly before their eyes.
Tricks performed by mediums are in one respect quite different
from the feats of prestidigitators; if they come up to the standard,
they are, or ought to be, based upon the psychic dispositions of
people, setting, as it were, traps for them and allowing them to be
caught in their own superstitions. Believers will do it willingly and
be grateful for the deception, while determined unbelievers are
either altogether hopeless or will be so puzzled as to be likely to
become believers. But sleight of hand is always a valuable aid to
the medium ; and, as tricks pure and simple, mediumistic stances
are not different from the performances of prestidigitators ; they
differ only in this, that they claim to be done with the assistance of
spirits. Mediums must be on the lookout and use different meth-
ods as the occasion may require. They produce rappings with their
hands, or their feet,^ or with a mechanism hidden in their shoes;
1 One of the Fox Sisters could produce rappings through a peculiar construction of the bones
of her foot, and Cumberland's big toe was blessed with a tendon of its own, enabling him to rap
the floor quite vigorously without being detected.
THE OLD AND THE NEW MAGIC.
433
neither do they scorn the use of rapping tables with concealed bat-
teries and electric wires.
A most convenient spirit-table is described by Hopkins in his
book on Magic, p. loi, as follows :
"The battery is carried in the lower part of the table, where the three legs
join. The top of the table is in two parts, the lower of which is hollow and the
upper very thin. In the center of the hollow part is placed an electro-magnet,
one of the wires of which connects with one of the poles of the battery, while the
other is connected with a flat metallic circle glued to the cover of the table. Beneath
''■2Y?F77}-'9Pm77//777/,
■mu
Rapping and Talking Table.
this circle and at a slight distance from it there is a toothed circle connected with
the whole pole of the battery. When the table is lightly pressed upon, the cover
bends and the flat circle touches the toothed one. This closes the circuit, and the
electro- magnet attracting the armature produces a sharp blow. When the hand is
raised the circuit is broken, producing another sharp blow. By running the hand
lightly over the table the cover is caused to blend successively over a certain por-
tion of its circumference. Thus contact is made at a number of places, and th§
sharp blow is replaced by a quick succession of sounds. This table is very useful
for spirit rappings; as the table contains all of the mechanism in itself, it can be
moved to any part of the room. The table may be also operated from a distance
by employing conductors passing through the legs of the table and under the car-
434
THE OPEN COURT.
pet. By substitutfng a small telephone receiver for the electromagnet, the rapping
spirits may be talking ones."^
Slate-writing may be done in various ways, and good mediums
will alwa3's change their methods. One of them is described by
Mr. Hopkins as follows :
"Two ordinary wooden-framed slates are presented to the spectators, and ex-
amined in succession by them. A small piece of chalk is introduced between the
two slates, which are then united by a rubber band and held aloft in the prestidigi-
tator's right hand.
ir^
^-^^ J^^
k. 1
Ib^^^^h
?i>^^^^^^^^^^a
■1^^
— '"~' '^~— -~-^^^
^^fc.;.., ■>. -
^^>^s^.^^^^
\ '^I^^^^Vi-szf^--'-: ■-■-
Spirit-Slates.
"Then, in the general silence, is heard the scratching of the chalk, which is
writing between the two slates the answer to a question asked by one of the specta-
tors— the name of a card thought of or the number of spots obtained by throwing
two dice. The rubber band having been removed and the slates separated, one of
them is seen to be covered with writing. This prodigy, which at first sight seems
to be so mysterious, is very easily performed.
"The writing was done in advance; but upon the written side of the slate, A,
there had been placed a thin sheet of black cardboard which hid the characters
written with chalk. The two sides of this slate thus appeared absolutely clean.
1 A similar table is described by Willniann in Moiii
U'litidcr, pp. 58-59.
THE OLD AND THE NEW MAGIC.
435
" The slate B is first given out for examination, and after it has been returned
to him, the operator says: "Do you want to examine the other one also ? " And
then, without any haste, he makes a pass analogous to that employed in shuffling
cards. The slate A being held by the thumb and forefinger of the left hand and the
slate B between the fore and middle finger of the right hand (Fig. i), the two hands
are brought together. But at the moment at which the slates are superposed, the
thumb and forefinger of the right hand grasp the slate A, while at the same time
the fore and middle finger of the left hand take the slate B. Then the two hands
separate anew, and the slate that has already been examined, instead of the second
one, is put into the hands of the spectator. This shifting, done with deliberation,
is entirely invisible.
" During the second examination the slate A is laid flat upon a table, the writ-
ten face turned upward and covered with black cardboard. The slate having been
The Sword-Trick.
sufficiently examined, and been returned to the operator, the latter lays it upon the
first, and both are then surrounded by the rubber band.
"It is then that the operator holds up the slates with the left hand, of which
one sees but the thumb, while upon the posterior face of the second slate the nail
of his middle finger makes a sound resembling that produced by chalk when writ-
ten with. When the operator judges that this little comedy has lasted quite long
enough, he lays the two slates horizontally upon his table, taking care this time
that the non-prepared slate shall be beneath (Fig. 2). It is upon it that the black
cardboard rests; and the other slate, on being raised, shows the characters that it
bears, and that are stated to have been written by an invisible spirit that slipped in
between the two slates."
Another very ingenious trick consists in apparently stabbing
a man to death, the bloody end of the sword appearing at the back,
436 THE OPEN COURT.
yet leaving- the man uninjured. Since the audience naturally will
suspect that the point emerging from the back is not the true end
of the sword, the trick has been altered to the effect of replacing
the sword with a big needle (A), having tape threaded through its
eye. -When the assassin's needle has passed through the victim,
it can be pulled out at the other side, together with the tape, where
it appears reddened with blood. The stabbing, when performed
quickly, before the spectator begins to notice that the blade is
somewhat reduced in size, is most startling, and makes a deep im-
pression on the audience; but the artifice through which the manip-
ulation is rendered possible is very simple. The sword, or needle,
used for the purpose is made of a very thin and flexible plate of
steel, sufficiently blunt to prevent it from doing any harm. The
victim, as if trying to ward off the dangerous weapon, takes hold
of it and causes it to slip into the opening of a concealed sheath
(B), which he carries strapped round his body, whereupon the as-
sassin makes his thrust. The interior of the sheatli contains a red
fluid, which dyes the blade and helps to make the deception com-
plete. The accompanying illustration sufficiently explains the per-
formance.
A magazine article cannot be exhaustive. But the instances
adduced are sufficient to prove that even the apparently most com-
plete deception admits of an explanation which in many instances
is much simpler than the spectators think. Neither the marvellous
feats of prestidigitators nor the surprising revelations of mediums
should make us believers in m3^sticism. The success of modern
magic, which accomplishes more than the old magic or sorcery
ever did, is a sufficient guarantee of the reliability of science, and
even where "now we see through a glass darkly," we must remain
confident that when we grow in wisdom and comprehension we
shall learn to see "face to face."
MISCELLANEOUS.
KANT AND SPENCER.
To the Editor of The Opeti Coia-t :
This is Herbert Spencer's eightieth birthday, and a few of his admirers in this
antipodean city are sending him a congratulatory message, by cable, for we feel
that he, of all English philosophers, has influenced us most.
I have spent part of the morning in reperusing Dr. Carus's pamphlet Kant
and Sfiencer, and I would like to say that it seems to me that Dr. Cams has mis-
apprehended Spencer's criticism of Kant.
Much controversy is raised by the use of the word "intuition". I do not think
Spencer meant by that word anything different from that which Dr. Carus means
He uses "forms of intuition" to mean just what Dr. Carus calls "pure intuition.'
The word "intuition" may not be the best translation of " Anschauung", but it is
the English word used by various translators and commentators. See Meiklejohn's
Translation p. 24, Max Miiller's p. 23, Vol. H. Watson Kant and his E)ig-lish
Critics, G. Croom Robertson's Elements of General Philosophy, and others.
I think that perhaps Alfred Fouillee in his Histoirc de la Philosophie puts
the question plainer. He says, pp. 397 and 398, " D'apres cela, qu'est ce que I'es-
pace et le temps ? Des conditions de notre sensibilite, sans lesquelles nous ne pour-
rions rien percevoir, des raoyens par lesquelles nous emissons nos sensations en
series regulieres, . . . Ce sont, dit Kant, des moules on cadres dans lesquels les
choses viennent prendre la forme qui nous permet de nous les representer; ce sont,
en un mot, les 'formes de la sensibilite'." Indeed, Meiklejohn's and Max Miiller's
translations, which almost agree in this respect, word for word, put it thus, so far
as Space is concerned : "It (Space) is nothing else than the form of all phenomena
of the external sense, that is, the objective condition of the sensibility, under which
alone external intuition is possible."
According to Kant, as Croom Robertson has well said, " The human mind
brings to the result of pure sense-experience certain subjective factors, viz., (i)
pure intuitions {reine Anschauung-), in order to perception; (2) pure categories of
concepts, in order to understanding; (3) pure ideas, in order to reason." These are
transcendental and a priori. Now the criticism of Mill, Bain, and Spencer, not to
mention others, on this position of Kant is, that these are not transcendental nor a
priori.
According to Spencer, to take " Space and Time", they have been derived by
"accumulated and consolidated experiences", not in the individual alone but
43^ THE OPEN COURT.
through heredity. To quote the words of Spencer in his Essay " On Space-Consci-
ousness", published in Mind:
" It must also be pointed out that since on the evolution-hypothesis, that con-
sciousness of Space which we have lies latent in the inherited nervous system and
since, along with those first excitations of the nervous system which yield rudimen-
tary perceptions of external objects, there are produced those first excitations of it,
which yield the rudimentary consciousness of the Space in which the objects exist
— it must necessarily happen that Space will appear to be given along with these
rudimentary perceptions in their form. There will necessarily very soon result
something like that inseparability which the Kantists allege. Hence we cannot ex-
pect completely to decompose into its elements the Space-consciousness as it exists
in ourselves."
It will be seen from this extract wherein the difference between Kant and Spen-
cer in this question lies. According to Kant the forms of Space and Time have not
been derived from experience. According to Spencer they have been so derived.
Both recognise that the " forms", so to speak, exist. To use Dr. Carus's happy ex-
pression they are "at-sights", but their " whence and how" is the question. How
have these moulds, if I may use another expression, come to us ? There they are,
like the mould of the linotype-machine into which the molten lead of experience dis-
appears, but how were these moulds formed ? As a thorough-going Evolutionist
Spencer says they are the product of ages of experiences. {Z&e.\\\s PsycJiology , 2. ed.)
The only quarrel that one might have with Spencer is that at first sight it might
appear that Space and Time, as forms of sensibility, are confounded with the ab-
stract idea of Space and Time ; a careful perusal of his Psychology will show, how-
ever, that he did not so confound them (p. 360, Vol. II, Psyc]iology). It is plain, I
submit, from his Essay I have quoted, that he rightly appreciated Kant's position.
I do not think Dr. Carus has quite apprehended Spencer's position when he says
that Spencer believes that Kant said " that Space and Time have no application in
the world of objects (i. e., the non-ego)." Spencer puts his position thus: "To
affirm that Time and Space belong to the ego, is simultaneously to affirm that they
do not belong to the non-ego." Again : "The Kantian doctrine not only compels
us to dissociate from the non-ego these forms as we know them, but practically for-
bids us to recognise or suppose any forms for the non-ago ". I do not know if a
Kantian would object to this statement, save in the words I have italicised. The only
"forms of intuition" Kant mentions as existing in order to perception are Space
and Time. The qualities of things, etc., are not "forms".
I may add, one point in which a Kantian may complain of Spencer is that he
has not recognised that, considering the time in which he lived and his environment,
Kant was an advanced Evolutionist. There are passages in his Antliropology, which
though put cautiously and suggestively, show that he believed that even man was a
product of Evolution. Spencer seems to me, however, to be right in saying that a
thorough-going Evolutionist must seek for the origin of the "forms of intuition" —
Space and Time — in experience; Kant did not do so. Whether Spencer's view is
accepted or not, it is ( n Evolutionist lines and seems to me the only rational expla-
nation given at present of how these forms arose. John Stuart Mill and Bain suf-
fer from the defects of the old English school — of having developed their psychol-
ogy before the far-reaching results of Evolution — of heredity — were appreciated
This is seen if one refers to James Mill's Analysis of the Human Mind, and is
also apparent if the first edition of Bain's works be perused.
Wellington. N. Z. Robert Stout.
MISCELLANEOUS. 439
THE OPEN COURT AND '' LEAVES OF GRASS '
7'o the Editor of the OJ<en Court :
In the January number of the 0;pen Court there appeared (amongst other good
things) a portrait of the Hon. C. C. Bonney, a representative individual ; an article
written by that gentleman on the principles of the Ope)i Court, a representative in-
dividualistic magazine, an extract of great beauty from the last prose-poem of that
(perhaps extreme) incarnation of Individualism — Robert Ingersoll ; and finally an
editorial note — not by any means appreciative — respecting the writings of Walt
Whitman, whom I have long held to be, par excellence, the poet of individualism.
In an article in the March number, The Jesuits afid the Mohainmedans , the
writer (Dr. Pfungst) states that the battle between Jesuitism and Republicanism "is
at present at its height"; by that, of course, is to be understood the struggle between
Authority on the one hand and Individual Freedom on the other. If that statement
be true, it represents a very serious state of affairs, and all your readers and all sym-
pathisers'with the Open Court idea should do everything in their power to cultivate
Individuality in themselves and all those with whom they may be associated, and
to encourage the circulation of literature bearing on the subject of Freedom.
Of literature of the kind, I know of none more powerful than Leaves of Grass,
and I confess to a feeling of some disappointment on reading the admission of the
Editor that "there must be something in Walt Whitman" not as the result of his
own study, but merely on the authority of Professor W. K. Clifford.
Then the Editor proceeds to remark upon Whitman's " breaches of etiquette"
and "immoral penchants," evidently not recognising that — read in their meaning —
the Children of Adam series is not immoral, that it is not written for the sake of
mere obscenity ; for mark these words from Starting froni Paumanok :
" And sexual organs and acts do you concentrate in me ; for I am determined
to tell you with courageous clear voice, to prove you illustrious."
He does not say "to prove you obscene and impure, ' but "illustrious." True,
he may not have taken the most judicious means for robbing Sex of its obscene as-
pect and rendering it "illustrious '; but so long as Sex is a tabooed subject for any
but physiological literature, so long will the majority of people continue to regard
it as impure.
The Editor continues, "his lack of poetic strength" and " genuine sentiment";
perhaps I am mistaken, but I do wish the Editor would read the Song of the Open
Road and litis Compost, and a few of the Druin Taps, particularly Over the Car-
nage rose prophetic a Voice ; I cannot help thinking that here he will find both
"genuine sentiment" and "poetic strength." Then the "gardner will not wind"
blades of grass "into garlands for a bride"; perhaps not, yet it is as well not to be
too sure about that, either ; if the Editor will examine for himself some of the com-
monest varieties of grasses, he will see what marvelous beauty they possess ; when
he has done this and read Leaves of Grass in a friendly (and not hypercritical)
spirit, I hope he will acknowledge that the beautiful grasses of the fields (and there
are no ugly ones) are typical of dear old Walt and his book, and might, in default
of Orange Blossoms, adorn even a marriage-feast.
Respecting the lines "Stranger, if you, passing, meet me," etc., the Editor
says, "surely there is no objection to a conversation between strangers," and the
"thought is trivial and not worth incorporating in a poem." No, from the author
of the Primer of Philosophy there can be no objection whatever ; but how many
440 THE OPEN COURT.
people are there who live up to /i/s philosophy ? I take those lines to be an asser-
tion of Equality, which is so closely allied to Freedom and Brotherhood, that the
two latter imply the former. Think for a moment how many strangers will volun-
tarily speak to one another, and then say whether Whitman's lines are justified or
not. His own antithesis to the lines in question is this ;
" It shall be customary in the houses and streets to see manly aftection ;
"The most dauntless and rude shall touch face to face lightly;
" The dependence of Liberty shall be Lovers ;
" The continuance of Equality shall be Comrades."
The Editor's concluding remark, that Witman's popularity is closely connected
with the stir which will always be unfailingly produced by any free discussion of
the "questionable passages" is, I think, incorrect; for several years after I had rec-
ognised the beauty of Lcar'cs of G?-ass, I did not encounter the book in its com-
plete form — having to content myself with Stead's Penny Post edition, the selection
edited by Mr. W. M. Rossetti and published by Chatto &. Windus, and the little
Canterbury Poet edition, edited by Mr. Ernest Rhys and published by Walter
Scott ; and I am fully aware that most of the admirers of Leaves of Grass whom I
met are quite unacquainted with the Children of Adam series, and that some are
not even aware of its existence. If in America that is not the case, then all I can
say is that the sooner an "expurgated" edition is published there, and the "harm-
less" poems circulated far and wide amongst the people whom Whitman loved so
well, the better.
The Editor complains that "long strings of enumerations are not poetry";
perhaps not ; like the Editor, I have never ' ' had the patience to read them through, "
but it has occurred to me that the author may have had a definite purpose in insert-
ing them, and that perhaps the Song of the Broad Axe, which otherwise contains
some noble sentiments, would be incomplete without such enumerations. I have no
wish to represent Whitman as faultless, and admit that much of his work is "mere
talk " and that it is " sometimes shallow. "
"Most of the admirers of Walt Whitman belong to the class of eccentrics
whose indorsement of a cause is not always a recommendation"; perhaps the pres-
ent writer is one of these; but, if in this respect he is a sinner, he at least sins in
good company ; for he has always understood that the lucid Open Court contribu-
tor, Dr. Moncure D. Conway, was one of Whitman's warmest admirers and friends ;
in Liberty in Literature the late Robert G. Ingersoll extolled and eulogised Leaves
of Grass and its author ; Wm. M. Rossetti (of a poet and artist-family) calls Whit-
man one of the " great " poets ; and Leaves of Grass has drawn admiration from
such literary men as R. L. Stevenson, Sir Edwin Arnold, Havelock Ellis, Robert
Buchanan, J. A. Symonds, John Burroughs, Professor Clifford, and others. These
may belong to a "class of eccentrics," but whether or no, I should feel disposed to
take their "indorsement of a cause" as " a recommendation."
W. H. Trimble.
DuNEDiN, New Zfaland, April 24th, 1900.
NEW WORKS ON POLITICAL ECONOMY AND POLITICAL
SCIENCE.
One of the latest enterprises in the publishing world is the Citizens' Library
of /coNOfnics, /'otitic's, and Sociology, conducted under the general editorship of
Richard T. Ely, Professor of Political Economy and Director of the School of
MISCELLANEOUS. 44I
Economics, Political Science, and History, in the University of Wisconsin. It is
published by the Macmillans. The design of the library is to "afford such com-
plete information concerning the theory and facts of the three sciences mentioned,
that the volumes will have some of the advantages of an encyclopedic work com-
bined with those of separate and distinct treatises." Its new and valuable feature
is the giving to the public of information of importance to every citizen, which must
now be sought in a great multiplicity of sources, and often sought in vain. We
have the explicit statement of the editor to the effect that the "utmost pains will be
taken to secure the greatest possible accuracy in all statistic tables and statements
of fact and theory, and that no partisan bias will disturb the conclusions." Fur-
thermore, while every attempt will be made to obtain in these volumes clearness of
statement and finish of literary style, the interests of science will in no case be sac-
rificed to popularity, the expressed aim being to bring every volume of the library
up to the present standard of science in every respect.
Two of the published volumes of the Libi-ary are by the editor, Prof. Ely,
himself. The first is apparently a reprint of an older work. Outlines of Economics
(New York and London: the Macmillan Co. Pages, xii, 432. Price, $1.25), which
was begun as a revision of his well-known Introduction to Political Econotny, but
became in the re-elaboration a perfectly new work. The aim of the Introduction
was to furnish historical and descriptive material chiefly, while the aim of the Oul-
lines is to give a systematic sketch of theory. It begins with the traditional "His-
torical Introduction," and afterwards takes up its subject proper under the follow-
ing headings : Production, Transfers of Goods, Distribution, Consumption, Public
Industry, and the Relation of the State to Private Enterprise, Public Expenditures,
and Public Revenues, ending with a sketch of the origin and development of eco-
nomical theories. The book is a text-book in every sense of the word, and is supplied
with summaries of chapters, set questions on the chapters, a list of subjects for
essays, discussions, and debates, courses of reading, and a general bibliography.
The book is simply and clearly written, and excellently adapted for private study.
The second work by Prof. Ely is entitled Monopolies and Trusts, and forms part
of a very large and comprehensive treatise on which he is engaged, to be called The
Distribution of Wealth. The book is a timely one. The author believes that he
has made an original, though not a definitive, contribution to economic theory, and
has presented in a clear manner the main known facts and the main points of view
necessary to the study of trusts and trust-legislation. (New York and London:
The MacMillan Co. 1900. Pages, xi, 278. Price, $1.25.)
The Econotnics of Distribution, by John A Hobson, is the third published
volume of the Citizetis'' Library. It "endeavors to construct an intelligible, self-
consistent theory of Distribution by means of an analysis of those processes of bar-
gaining through which economic distribution is actually conducted, the results of
industrial co-operation being apportioned to the owners of the factors of production
in the several stages of production In particular, it claims to prove that all
processes of bargaining and competition, by which prices are attained and the dis-
tribution of wealth achieved, are affected by certain elements of force which assign
'forced gains' and other elements of 'economic rent' to the buyers or the sellers.
There is thus established the existence of a large fund, partaking of the nature of
those monopoly and differential rents, long ago recognised in the case of land, which
furnish no stimulus to voluntary industrial energy, and which can be taken for
public service by taxation without injury to industry." Surplus value emerges
from all forms of bargaining, but is greater in the case of capitalistic bargainings.
442 THE OPEN COURT.
Inequality is ineradicable ; it should be redressed by taxation ; but if that is im-
possible, public monopolies will have to be substituted for private monopolies.
(New York and London: The Macmillan Co. igoo. Pages, vii, 361. Price, $1.25.)
A second revised and enlarged edition of Dr. Carl C. Plehn's Introduction to
Public Finance has just appeared. It is intended as an elementary text-book con-
taining a brief and simple outline of the knowledge necessary to prepare students
for independent research, brief discussions of the leading principles that are gener-
ally accepted, a statement of unsettled principles with the grounds for controversy,
and sufficient references to easily accessible works and sources to enable the student
to form his opinions for himself. The renewed interest which is now being taken
in our system of taxation has given a present import to the financial questions con-
nected with the conduct of the government, and Dr. Plehn's book is one that will
help us to inform ourselves concerning the difficulties of the present situation and
the most likely paths leading to its reform. (New York and London : The Mac-
millan Co. 1900. Pages, xii, 384.)
We have at last a text-book on political economy designed especially for farm-
ers. It is by Dr. George T. Fairchild, LL. D., of Berea College, Kentucky, and
bears the title, Rural Wealth and Welfare. The author believes he need offer no
apology for his restatement of the fundamental principles of economics. "Eco-
nomic literature," he says, "has usually dealt too exclusively with the phenomena
of manufactures and commerce to gain the sympathy of rural people." And if the
rural population of the country is ever to obtain a sound comprehension of the facts
and theories of the science of public wealth and welfare, it can be done only by bring-
ing the subject home to farmers' families in an elementary way, and in connexion
with subjects with which they are by experience acquainted. (New York and Lon^
don ; The Macmillan Co. 1900. Pages, xiii, 381. Price, $1.25.)
Mr. Alfred J. Ferris has presented some very readable considerations in his
book, Pauperizing the Rich : An Inquiry into the Value and Significance of Un-
earned Wealth to Its Owners and to Society. They may be regarded by some
thinkers as Eutopian ; they may be illogical ; but they at least have the merit of
being presented with conviction and naturalness. The central idea of the book is
that of a redistribution of incomes on a basis of the people's property in ideas.
"We do not wish," the author says, "to repudiate the well-founded claims of the
Self-Made Man; we have no thought of denying to industry its just rewards. But
let us render to industry the fruits of its labors : to the whole human race let us
render the fruits of its glorious inheritance, — its property of ideas." The author is
opposed to the indiscriminate administration of charities, which results in pauperi-
sation, but includes in the " charitable list" of the world all persons who have in-
herited fortunes and shown themselves unequal to the task of making them produc-
tive both for themselves and the human race. He terms this class " millionaires-
by-charity," and hence the title of his book, Pauperizing the Rich. (Philadelphia ;
T. S. Leach & Co. 1899. Pages, xiii, 432. Price, $1.25.)
Every one has experienced the difficulty of obtaining trustworthy information
concerning the "Welfare-Institutions" and the profit-sharingsystems which numer-
ous employers of labor maintain for their employees ; but the difficulty has been
MISCELLANEOUS. 443
removed by a recent work by Nicholas Paine Gilman, having the title, A Dividend
to Labor. " Welfare-Institutions " is the name given in economic parlance to the
libraries, hospitals, baths, improved dwellings, theaters, gymnasiums, schools, sav-
ings banks, etc., etc. conducted in connexion with the great industrial organisations
of the world. They all of them are of the nature of an " indirect dividend to labor, "
as Mr. Gilman phrases it, and form an intermediate stage between the old wages
system pure and simple and the more modern profit-sharing system. Mr. Gilman
prefaces his work with an exposition and discussion of existing industrial conditions ;
narrates the life of Robert Owen, the great English manufacturer, who was a
pioneer in this direction ; describes the welfare-institutions of Germany, the patronal
institutions of France, Holland, and Belgium, the British employers' institutions,
and lastly, the numerous but less systematic instances of American liberality to
workmen. The most famous cases of profit-sharing institutions are carefully dis-
cussed, such as the Maison Baille-Lemaire, the Bourne Mills, the Proctor and Gam-
ble Company, the South Metropolitan Gas Company, and the N. O. Nelson Com-
pany. Mr. Gilman is fair to both sides in his expositions, and his work may be
consulted with confidence in all cases. (Boston and New York : Houghton, Mifflin
& Co. 1899, Pages, viii, 400. Price, $1.50.)
We have not the space to enter into either a criticism or a discussion of Mr.
Charles H. Chase's Elementary Principles of Economics. It is a very pretentious
book, having been presented to the public in the firm conviction that it will prove
to be "the beginning of a i^c/t-w^t' of political economy." With all his admiration
for the great writers of the past, Mr. Chase is forced to confess that they "have
failed to lay a solid foundation for the science in an adequate nomenclature with
exact definitions, in the clear and definite statement of the object of economics, or
political economy, and in the formulation and statement of the fundamental propo-
sitions,"— all of which he believes he has supplied We shall mention as a specimen
of his reflexions the discussion of the standard of value : neither gold, nor silver,
nor copper, nor iron, nor any commodity whatever is, in Mr. Chase's opinion, a true
standard of value, neither is labor; the irwe sidinAd^rd^'is Ifie ai'erag-e of cornmodities
— the average price of commodities uniform under all conditions. The practical
difficulty, however, is to get hold of this average commodity, and we are consequently
obliged to assume a fictitious commodity moving along the lines representing the
average change in the labor cost of commodities. The government by its bureau
statistics would determine the total amount of new wealth reserved each year for
the satisfaction of desires pure and simple. The amount of this wealth would then
be divided by the total number of individuals producing it, and the comparison of
the resulting quotients for the successive years would give an unvarying unit or
standard of value for these several years. (Chicago: Charles H. Kerr & Co. 1900.
Pages, xvi, 405.)
Prof. Franklin Henry Giddings, of Columbia University, has attempted in his
work. Democracy and Empire (New York and London : The Macmillan Co.
igoo. Pages, x, 363. Price, $2.50), the rather difficult task of supplying the psy-
chological, economic and moral foundations of the two popular impulses which are
now uppermost in determining the political conduct of modern nations, and for
America especially his lucubrations are in the highest sense opportune. His studies
in theoretical sociology long ago led him to the belief that the combining "of small
states into larger political aggregates must continue until all the semi civilised, bar-
444 THE OPEN COURT.
barian, and savage communities of the world are brought under the protection of
the larger civilised nations." And further studies convinced him that the future of
civilisation depended largely upon the predominant influence of either the English-
speaking people of the world or of the Russian Empire. He saw here a steady trend
toward imperialism. On the other hand, he remained convinced "that the demo-
cratic tendencies of the nineteenth century are not likely to be checked or thwarted
in our own or in future generations." There existed here plainly two antithetical
tendencies which demanded reconciliation. There is no mistaking of the real issue.
' ' Democracy and empire, paradoxical as such a relationship seems, are really cor-
relative aspects only of the evolution of mankind." This is the problem of the
present crisis, and one which calls for explanation by means of a thorough study of
the psychology of society and of the fundamental economical and ethical motives of
human effort. The titles of the chapters, which will indicate the general trend and
scope of the discussions of this bulky volume, are as follows : The Democratic
Empire ; The Ethical Motive ; The Psychology of Society ; The Mind of the Many ;
The Costs of Progress ; Industrial Democracy ; The Trusts and the Public ; The
Railroads and the State ; Public Revenue and Civic Virtue : Some Results of the
Freedom of Women ; The Nature' and Conduct of Political Majorities ; The Des-
tinies of Democracy ; The Relation of Social Democracy to the Higher Education ;
The Popular Instruction Most Necessary in a Democracy ; The Shadow and the
Substance of Republican Government ; The Consent of the Governed; Imperialism;
The Survival of Civil Liberty ; The Ideals of Nations ; The Gospel of Non-Resist-
Prof, Frank J. Goodnow has aimed in his Politics and Admiiistratiou to show,
"from a consideration of political conditions as they now exist in the United States,
that the formal governmental system as set forth in the law is not always the same
as the actual system " ; and he has coupled with this aim the endeavor " to indicate
what changes in the formal system of the United States must be made, in order to
make the actual system conform, more closely than it does at present, to the politi-
cal ideas upon which the formal system is based." All this has involved a study
of the operations of our government, of the nature and mechanism of our political
parties, and of its distinctive type of leader, the "boss." The concrete remedies
which he proposes for the amelioration of the present state of affairs is a greater
centralisation of our state administrative system on the model of the national ad-
ministrative system, and the subjection of the political party to effective public
control, with the view of making the parties and its leaders more responsive to the
public will. (New York and London: The Macmillan Co. 1900. Pages, xiii,
270. Price, $1.50.)
Our own nation having entered upon a colonial career in the Philippines, Porto
Rico, and in a measure also in Cuba, all thinking Americans will be in favor of es-
tablishing a colonial system of civil service which shall be efficient and absolutely
free from political pressure. It will be instructive, therefore, to learn what light
can be derived from the experience of other nations in this field. Since the excel-
lent work of the late Dorman B. Eaton on English civil service was published, there
has been a radical change in the British system, and on the other hand there is no
book in any language containing the latest information on the methods of recruiting
officials for the colonies of Holland and France. A new book by A. Lawrence
Lowell, entitled Colonial Civil Service and treating of "the selection and training
MISCELLANEOUS. 445
of colonial officials in England, Holland, and France," will accordingly be welcomed
by students of political affairs. Appended to the volume is an historical account
of the British East Indian College at Haileybury, by Prof. H. Morse Stephens.
(New York and London : The Macmillan Co. igoo. Pages, xiv, 346. Price, $1.50.)
T. J. McC.
BOOK REVIEWS AND NOTES.
Der Schmuck des Menschen. By Emil Selenka. Berlin ; Vita, Deutsches Ver-
lagshaus. igoo. Pages, 72.
This is an extremely attractive book, elegantly got up, with ninety reproduc-
tions from photographs taken by Prof. Dr. Hans Meyer, Prof. Dr. M. Buchner,
and others on their travels round the world.
The author's problem is the nature of ornament, and the treatment betrays
the assthetician, as does also the style of publication. Seeing that ornament tends
to become a part of ourselves. Professor Selenka endeavors to discover the law of
ornament as well as its social significance.
Professor Selenka emphasises the fact that ornament is a kind of pictorial lan-
guage ; its purpose is to tell our neighbors of our preferences, be they imaginary
or real (p. 13). He compares it to the language of physiognomical expression as
treated by Darwin, and regarded among natural scientists as common to all the
races of the earth. Further our author insists that he has discovered a law of orna-
ment, and that its development is not a matter of subjective imagination, but of
objective facts which, according to him, are determined by the bodily form of man.
He distinguishes six kinds of ornament : (i) There are two which are intended to
show to advantage man's upright gait, finding expression in hanging ornaments;
(2) direction ornaments, which latter are indications of the direction of his move-
ments, as for instance the feathers in the hair of the Indians; further, there are (3)
ring ornaments, such as bracelets, collars, etc.; (4) ornaments of aggrandisation,
that is to say, things that increase the size of certain limbs, — epaulets and various
kinds of headgear; (5) ornaments of color, such as flowers stuck in the hair; and
(6) dress to set the color of the body in relief.
These subjects are treated in several chapters, and illustrated by fine figures.
The author sums up his opinions with some aesthetic remarks on true and false or-
nament, and concludes his book on initial and final forms of ornament.
While we appreciate the fact that the book is tastily gotten up and the subject
interestingly treated, we cannot help saying that Professor Selenka's discrimination
of the various kinds of ornaments dwells on externalities and scarcely touches the
main problem he has set out to solve. Our author might have enhanced the treat-
ment of the subject by explaining the historical origin of ornament, which (as an-
thropology is likely to prove) did not rise from the aesthetics, but vice versa is giv-
ing rise to conditions which slowly produce an aesthetical instinct. It is a significant
fact that all ornament originally served a religious or better talismanic purpose be-
fore it became ornament. The first ear-rings, nose-rings, and lip-rings were not
worn to satisfy man's aesthetical judgment but served the purpose of protecting
these entrances against the influence of evil spirits ; so did the amulets which are
now worn as ornaments on necklaces. They became ornaments only when their
significance as amulets was no longer understood.
An anthropologist might thus be disappointed in the author's treatment of the
446 THE OPEN COURT.
subject, but the beautiful pictures alone are worth the price of the book, which we
can therefore heartily recommend. P. c.
Confucius. The Secret of his Mighty Influence. His views upon the great prob-
lem of human life and destiny. By Thomas IVJiittiey. Chicago : Seibert,
Wermich & Quetsch. Price, 10 cents.
The pamphlet on Confucius by Mr. Thomas Whitney is an excellent, short elu-
cidation of the moral principles laid down by the great sage of the Celestial king-
dom, Confucianism is the sole religious system in the world, which is established
on the ground of positivism, free from all supernatural conceptions and which
nevertheless has given comfort to, and has gained the admiration of, millions of
souls. As the writer rightly says, " Confucius' doctrine converges at the perfecting
of humanity and the making up of the superior man." " To him there was nothing
miraculous or supernatural about this. The law of the unfolding of man's spiritual
nature was to him as natural as the unfolding of the oak from the acorn, a provision
of our nature, innate, the same as is the full fruit in the germ of the seed." The
one point, however, on which I cannot agree is the writer's emphasising too much
the "Will of Heaven" in expounding the doctrine of Confucius, as if he conceived
it as a Christian does. The truth is, to the Chinese mind nothing was so foreign
as the idea of a personal God or a willing being above man and nature. The heaven
or lien was a very vague idea for Confucius, being almost tantamount to the sense
of natural law for scientists. T. Suzuki.
Mr. F. J. Gould is favorably known as a writer on agnosticism and a popular-
iser of religious history and literature, and we are glad to call attention to two
books of his which may suit with the ideas of some of our readers. The first book
is entitled Tales from the Bible (pages, 103, price, is. 6d.), and aims to give a ra-
tional view of the Old Testament in a manner suitable to the capacity of chil-
dren. The author would introduce the child to Bible literature through a simple
manual in which the picturesque old legends are related, but accompanies the
stories with suggestions and warnings which will prevent children "from believing
that all the narratives of the Bible are historical and its teachings pure." In the
second book (pages, 176, price, 2s.), he has done the same work for the New Testa-
ment, first seeking to make his young readers understand the Gospel, and then if
possible " to open to them the natural charm of the early Christian legends." In
doing this he " has not scrupled to take away or to add or to modify details." The
legend is separated as far as possible from the fact, on the basis of an examination
of recent criticism. Some will object to the books that they represent a purely
personal, and in many respects a biassed, view of the Bible ; but this must be true
in a large measure of every attempt to make Bible history and literature compre-
hensible. Mr. Gould has at any rate well brought out the connexion of the whole,
and a coherent and systematic impression cannot fail to be produced in the young
mind by his stories. With modification of details and in some cases of interpreta-
tion, the books might be found of assistance by persons of widely varying opinion.
(London : Watts & Co., 17 Johnson's Court, Fleet St.)
The same company has just issued for the Rationalist Press Association a col-
lection of able essays by Mr. J. M. Robertson, entitled Studies in Religious Fal-
lacy. Mr. Robertson takes as his text such subjects as Drummond's Natural Laiv
in the Spiritual World, Lang's Views on the Origin of Religion and on Miracles,
MISCELLANEOUS. 447
Mr. Gladstone on the Atonement and on Butler, Freeman on Christianity, Tolstoy
on the Ethics of Jesus, etc. (Pages, 227.)
The Rationalist Press Association have also fathered the views of a little book
by Joseph McCabe, called The Religion of the Tzuentieth Century, wherein are
expounded the tenets of the agnostic faith by a convert from Roman Catholicism.
(London: Watts & Co., 17 Johnson's Court, Fleet St. 1898. Pages, 102. Price, is.)
The Evolution of Man : /lis Religious Sysfefns and Social Customs is the title
of a work by Dr. W. W. Hardwicke, issued by the same publishers, and being a
compilation of modern views of the development of religion from the point of view
of a free thinker. (Pages, xiv, 300. Price, 5s.)
A collection of essays by the leaders of the ethical societies, entitled Ethics and
Religion, is published to repel the imputation that these societies do not rest upon
any philosophical basis. The public, it is said, " is liable to mistake the absence
of philosophical theory for a lack of philosophical insight" among the members of
the union ; but it is contended that this absence may be a proof "of their philo-
sophic discipline and habit, and of their familiarity with the growth of metaphysical
systems"; in other words, " that they possibly expect to end, but certainly entertain
no hope of beginning, with a system of universal truth." The essays are by J. R.
Seeley, Felix Adler, W. M. Salter, Henry Sidgwick, G. Von Gizycki, Bernard Bo-
sanquet, Leslie Stephen, Stanton Coit, and J. H. Muirhead. The majority of them
were written ten years ago ; they then gave character and direction to the ethical
movement, and, being the thoughts of the founders, it is considered important that
they should be preserved. ( London : Swan Sonnenschein & Co. New York : The
Macmillan Co. 1900. Pages, ix, 324. Price, $1.50.)
We are in receipt of a brochure of 139 pages bearing the title Hinduism An-
cient and Modern as Taught in Origittal Sources and Illustrated in Practical
Life, by Rai Bahadur Lala Baij Nath, B. A., Fellow of the University of Allaha-
bad. "The object of the publication is to present the teachings of Hinduism, as
gathered from its most authentic and recognised sources, on all important phases
of the social, religious, and philosophic life of the Hindus, in a simple manner,
free from unnecessary details, technicality, and all controversial matter." It is an
enlarged and amended edition of some papers contributed by the author to the
National Oriental Congresses of Paris in 1797 and of Rome in 1899.
The Annual Literary Index for 1899, by the Publishers' Weekly of New
York, gives the titles and names of the authors of all the articles which have ap-
peared in the leading American and English periodicals for 1899, an index to the
general literature of the year, a list of the American and English bibliographies
published in 1899, an index to the dates of the principal events, a necrology of the
writers who have died, etc. The index of dates practically serves as an index to
the files of any newspaper for 1899. For libraries, newspaper offices, and students
who have to consult the literature of the year, this Index is indispensable.
One of the latest issues of the Temfle Primers, noticed at length in the June
Often Court, is The Civilization of India by Romesh C. Dutt. The little book
portrays in brief outlines the development of the literature, art, philosophy, science,
and industries of India, for some four thousand years, and contains illustrations of
several of the most prominent monuments and temples, together with three maps.
(London : J. M. Dent. New York : The Macmillan Co. Pages, vi, 146.)
448 THE OPEN COURT.
i
The latest issue of the Zeitfragoi des christUchen Volkslehens is by M.
Reichmann, and treats of the attractive subject of Catholicism and Protestantism
in France. The author concludes with the reflexion that whereas the Catholic
nations, as political and commercial powers, have succumbed to the Protestant
nations, nevertheless there has been built up within Germany an immensely pow-
erful and threatening imperium in the shape of the consolidated Roman Catholic
interests.
M. Georges Blondel has written an historical and critical study of the Passion
Play of Oberammergau in his Drame de la Passion, giving also practical hints to
travellers purposing to visit Oberammergau this year, descriptions of excursions
into the romantic vicinity, the plans of the theater, and two maps. The little
brochure costs i fr. 25, and is published by Victor LeCoffre, Paris, Rue Bona-
parte 90.
Carl Reissner, of Dresden and Leipsic, is the publisher of a series of German
b ographies entitled Men of llw Day. Krupp, Nansen, Nietzsche, Liszt, and
Windthorst were among the first numbers. The latest is a vivid portrayal of the
life and activity of the great German scientist, Ernst Haeckel, by Wilhelm Bolsche.
The little book is adorned with a good portrait of Haeckel.
We are in receipt of the first few numbers of a new weekly called The Indian
Kc-.'iezc, published by G A. Natesan & Co., Madras, India. The scope of the re-
view is a broad one, and not only are the political and literary affairs of India thor-
oughly discussed, but considerable attention is given to events of importance out-
side of India. The subscription price is 5 Rs. annually.
The first number of the first volume of the new series of I.e Museon, a philo-
logical, historical and religious review established in 1881 by the distinguished
Orientalist, M. Ch. de Harlez, has been issued, and contains an article on the
" Mysteries of the Greek Letters" by A. Hebbelynck, and one on "The Preposi-
tional Verb" by Raoul de la Grasserie, besides reviews.
Emanuel F. Goerwitz's translation of Kant's Dreams of a Spirit-Seer has
been edited by Mr. Frank Sewall. The little work is a humorous critique by Kant
of the philosophers of his day, using Swedenborg as a mark for his blows. Mr.
Sewall seeks to show that in his later inquiries Kant was indebted to Swedenborg
for some of his most famous philosophical theories
The editor of The Open Court, Dr. Paul Cams, will sail for Europe on July
18, with the steamer I^eittschland, to participate, as an official delegate from the
United States, in the Religious and Philosophical Congresses of the Paris Exposi-
tion.
L'Annce de I'ef^lise for 1899 has appeared. It is the year-book of the Catholic
church, and contains the statistics of its condition and operations. The editor is
Ch. Egremont. (Paris: Librairie Victor LeCoffre. 1899. Pages, 664.)
Students of Jewish history and literature will find much good advice for pur-
suing their work and selecting their materials in the syllabus issued by The Chau-
tauqua System of Jewish Education (Philadelphia, P. O. Box 825).
-T^TJ-r^ TT IT TT7NT "^^^ SWELLEST bicycle in AMERICA
1 aI H!^ J LJx_-/lXlLiN Prices: $35.00, $45.00 and $50.00
Riders who want The Best Money Will Buy ride the JULIEN. Wheels sent on ap-
proval on payment of charges one way.
JULIEN CYCLE WORKS, 447 W. Sixty=Third St., Chicago.
A First Book in Organic Evolution
An Introduction to the Study of the
DEVELOPMENT THEORV
By D. KERFOOT SHUTE, M. D.
Professor of Anatomy in the Medical Department of the Columbian University, Member of the Association
of American Anatomists, Member of the Washington Microscopical Society, etc.
Pages, xvi + 285, 39 illustrations — 9 in natural colors. Price, cloth,
$2.00 (7s. 6d.).
"It is a presentation of the subject for the general reader which is mas-
terly, clear, and entertaining. A profound subject is thoroughly grasped ;
a technical subject is made plain ; and a complex subject is made simple.
I am especially delighted with it as a book for auxiliary reading in the High
Schools and Colleges of the country.— J/a/<?r/. W. Powell, Smithsonian
Institution, Washington, D. C.
THE OPEN COURT PUBLISHING CO., ,.,^^'^^ri s..
London : Kegan Paul, Trench, Trubner & Co.
The Soul of Man
An Investigation of the
Facts of Physiological
and Kxperimental Psy-
chology. By Dr. Paul
Carus
Second Edition. Just Published.
With an Appendix on
the latest researches in
Physiology. 182 Dia-
grams. Pp., 482. Price,
Cloth, $1.50 (6s.) net.
The Open Court Pub. Co., Chicago
A Psychology for Beginners
AN OUTLINE SKETCH.
By HIRAM M. STANLEY,
Member of the American Psychological Association, author of the "Evolu-
tionary Psychology of Feeling" and "Essays on Literary Art." Pages, 44.
Boards. Price, 40 cents (2s.)
A Terse Statement of Psychological Facts
Designed to give to beginners a direct insight into the subject and
familiarity with its methods. The student is told as little as possible, but is
allowed to learn for himself by simple observation and experiment.
"A capital little primer .... printed in bold type .... with twenty-six
blank pages of stout paper for the scholar's notes and exercises .... Treats
the most elementary principles of psychology .... in the semi-conversa-
tional style that suggests the practised teacher." Literary World, London.
"Invaluable to teachers.' — Canadian Teacher.
THE OPEN COURT PUBLISHING CO.,
London : Kegan Paul, Trench, Triibner & Co., Ltd.
CHICAGO,
324 Dearborn St.
L'HUMANITE NOUVELLE
REVUE INTERNATIONALE ILLUSTREE
SCIENCES, LETTRES ET ARTS
Parait inensuellement en iin volume in-8° d'au moins 128 pages.
La Revue ne publie que de I'inedit.
DIRECTEUR SCIENTIFIQUE : DIRECTEUR LITTERAIRE:
A. HAMON. V. EMILE=MICHELET
L'HUMANITE NOUVELLE
est la moins couteuse, la mieux faite, la plus complete et la plus
independante de toutes les revues.
L'HUMANITE NOUVELLE
traite de : Sciences mathematiques, physiques, geographiques,
biologiques ; Lettres, Arts, Sociologie, Economique, Politique,
Philosophie, Religion.
L'HUMANITE NOUVELLE
public des articles dus aux meilleurs auteurs de tons les pays.
Dans cliaque numero il y a des chroniques litteraire, artis-
tique, theatrale, politique, une revue des livres et revues de
toutes les langues et de tons sujets.
Aucune Revue ne pent rivaliser avec L^ HiDuanit^ Notivelle.
Envoi d'un numero specimen gratis sur demande.
ABONNEMENTS;
Union postale : un an i8 fr. ; 6 mois 9 fr. 50; le N°: 1.75.
France et Belgique : un an 15 fr. ; 6 mois 8 fr. ; le N" : 1.50.
LiBRAiRiE C. REINWALD.
SCHLEICHER FRERES, Editeurs.
VI. PARIS, 15 RUE DES SAINTS-PERES. VI
Three Recent Publications
A WORK ON PSYCHOLOGY.
THE EVOLUTION OF GENERAL IDEAS. By Th. Ribot, Professor in
the College de France. Authorised translation from the French by
Frances A. Welby. Pp., xi, 231. Price, cloth, ^1.25 (6s. 6d.).
"All that he writes is lucid and suggestive, and the course of lectures here trans-
lated is a characteristic contribution to psychology." — Nature.
"An interesting and instructive essay, and well within the capacity of the general
reader." — The Dial.
A CONTRIBUTION TO SOCIOLOGY.
SCIENCE AND FAITH, or Man as an Animal and Man as a Member
OF Society. With a Discussion of Animal Societies. By Dr. Paul
Topinard, Late General Secretary of the Anthropological Society of
Paris, and Sometime Professor in the School of Anthropology. Pp.,
361. Price, cloth, gilt top, $1.50 (7s. 6d.).
"A most interesting volume." — Glasgow Herald
"Stimulating and suggestive."— 77i^ Scotsman.
" The book is worth reading, whether we are or are not satisfied with its conclu-
sions."— Nature.
"An unusually interesting volume .... suggestive in the highest degree ....
worth the time of any man to read from beginning to end."— Times- Herald.
A BOOK ON COMPARATIVE FOLK-LORE.
SOLOMON AND 50L0M0NIC LITERATURE. By Moncure D. Conway.
Pp., viii, 243. Bound in red cloth. Price, $1.50 (6s.). Portrays the
entire evolution of the Solomonic legend in the history of Judaism,
Christianity, Hinduism, Buddhism, and Parseeism, and also in ancient
and modern folk-lore, taking up, for example, the legend of Solomon's
ring, Solomon's seal, etc., etc.
"A thoughtful, interesting, and scholarly study." — PittsburgJi Times.
" Full of curious lore." — Afanc/iester Guardian.
" Mr. Conway's book on Solomonic literature is precisely such a work as we should
expect from the author of Sacred Anthology. The logic is everywhere blazed with
the poetry of Mr. Conway's nature. There are frequent passages of great eloquence."
— UTiity.
THE OPEN COURT PUBLISHING CO., a./oJa'^rt^r^n st.
London : Kegan Paul, Trench, Triibner & Co.
THE
BIBLIOTHECA SACRA
FOR JULY, igoo
AN OBBRLIN NUMBER
Two halMone Pictures of President Finney
These represent him at the ages of forty and seventy. The first is from a rare photo-
graph of an oil portrait painted for the well-known philanthropist Anson G. Phelps, of New
York City, at the time Dr. Finney was pastor of the Chatham Street church, and is now in
the possession of his son, F. Norton Finney, Esq., of Milwaukee, Wisconsin.
Nine Articles by Oberlin Professors
INAUGURAL ADDRESS.
By President JoJui Hejiry Barrozvs, D.D.
A STUDY IN THE LIFE OF JESUS.
By the Rev. Ediuard Increase Boszcorth, Professor of the New Testament Lan-
guage and Literature.
THE PRESENT STATUS OF OLD TESTAMENT BIBLICAL THEOLOGY.
By the Rev. George Stockton Burroughs, Ph. D., D.D., LL.D., Professor of the
Old Testament Language and Literature.
THE ECONOMIC INTERPRETATION OF THE FALL OF MAN.
By Thotnas Nixon Carver, Ph. D., Professor of Economics and Sociology.
BOSSUET; OR, THE MAKING OF A PREACHER.
By the Rev. Albert Henry Currier, D.D., Professor of Sacred Rhetoric and Prac-
tical Theology.
THE SIGNIFICANCE OF THE PERSONAL IN THEOLOGY.
By the Rev. Henry CliurcJiill King, D.D., Professor of Theology.
THE CATHOLIC ANTI-REFORMATION IN BOHEMIA.
By the Rev. Louis Francis Miskoi'sky, Principal of the Slavic Department.
PRESIDENT FINNEY AND AN OBERLIN THEOLOGY.
By the Rev. Albert Teinple Szving, Professor of Church History.
THE LESSON OF THE NEW HYMNALS.
By Edzuard Dickinson , Professor of the History of Music and the Pianoforte.
Two Articles by Oberlin Alumni
OBERLIN'S CONTRIBUTION TO ETHICS.
By Professor W. E. C Wright, Olivet, Mich.
LIMITING SALOON TERRITORY. THE MINNEAPOLIS PLAN.
By Captain Judson N. Cross, Minneapolis, Minn.
Single number, 75 cents. Yearly subscription, $3.00
Write for Sample Pages and Offers to New Subscribers :
THE BIBLIOTHECA SACRA CO.,
OBERLIN, OHIO, U. S. A.
Philosophical and Psychological Portrait Series,
(Now Complete.)
Suitable for framing: and hang^ing in public and private libraries, laboratories, seminaries,
recitation and lecture rooms.
The portraits, which are ii x 14 in., have been iaken from the best sources, and are
high-grade photogravures. The series is now complete.
HUME. (Ori^h.
^^■^^■■■^■H
Philosophical :
^^^^^^^^^^^^^1
PYTHAGORAS
SPINOZA
HEGEL
^^^^^^^^^^H
SOCRATES
LOCKE
SCHLEIERMACHER
I^^^B^^^^^H
PLATO
BERKELEY
SCHOPENHAUER
^^^^^^^^^^^^^H
ARISTOTLE
HUME
HERBART
^^^^^^^^^^H
EPICTETUS
MONTESQUIEU
FEUERBACH
^^^^^^^^^^H
THOMAS AQUINAS
VOLTAIRE
LOTZE
^H^^^^^^^^l
ST. AUGUSTINE
D'ALEMBERT
REID
^^^^^^^^^^^^^1
AVERRHOES
CONDILLAC
DUGALD STEWART
^^^^^^^^^^H
DUNS SCOTUS
DIDEROT
SIR W.HAMILTON
H^^^^^^^^^l
GIORDANO BRUNO
ROUSSEAU
COUSIN
l^^^^^^^^^^l
BACON
LEIBNITZ
COMTE
i
m^^^hE^^^^^^h
HOBBES
WOLFF
ROSMINI
ls
^^^HE^^^^^H
DESCARTES
KANT
J. STUART MILL
^^^^HH^^^H
MALEBRANCHE
FICHTE
HERBERT SPENCER
S^^l^l
SCHELLING
Psychological
s^^^^^s^bI^^i
CABANIS
MACH
ROMANES
^^^^BBB^^B
MAINE DE BIRAN
STUMPF
PAUL JANET
^-^m
BENEKE
EXNER
RIBOT
E.H.WEBER
STEINTHAL
TAINE
' i iL-'-:'MMt^M
FECHNER
BAIN
FOUILLEE
iJ^Bgl^gHBj^H
HELMHOLTZ
SULLY
BINET
^^^^^^^^^^H
WUNDT
WARD
G. STANLEY HALL
mum^i
HERING
AUBERT
C. L. MORGAN
G. T. LADD
ll
iiy,i4in.)
To Subscribers :
TERMS : For the luholc series {^Z portraits)
on regular paper, S7.J0 (SJs.); on heavy Im-
perial Japanese paper, $11.00 (jos.).
The Philosophical Series, 43 portraits, Impe-
rial Japanese paper, $8.75 (40s.); the same on the
best plate paper, $6.25 (30s). The Psychological
Series, 25 portraits, on Imperial Japanese paper,
$5.00 (24s.), the same on the best plate paper,
$3.75 (i8s.). (The higher prices in parentheses
refer to foreign countries. Carriage prepaid.) Sin-
gle portraits on regular paper, 25 cents.
For subscribers wLo may prefer not to frame
the portraits, a neat port/olio will be provided at
a cost of $1.00 additional.
On Inspection : A specimen portrait will be sent tp
any reader of The Open Court giving his or her full busi-
ness and home address on condition that it be returned
within two days after its receipt, if not satisfactory.
"I have received the first instalment of the
series of portraits of philosophers, and am very
much pleased with them." — Professor David G.
Kilchie, St. Andrews, Scotland.
SPINOZA. [Original I iy,i 4 in.)
"I congratulate you on the magnificent character of the portraits, and I feel proud to
have such adornments for my lecture room." — J. J. AfcNulty, Professor of Philosophy in
the College of the City of New York.
THE OPEN COURT PUBLISHING CO.,
London : Kegan Paul, Trench, Triibner & Co.
CHICAQO,
324 Dearborn St.
CONFIDENCE
A Perfect Pen at a Pop-
ular Price, and the
Best Pen at any Price.
i^ Your Choice of these
$3.00
Laughlln Fountain Pens
FOR™
ONLY
$1
llB TRYITAWEEK
If not salted, wa buy It
baok and offer you $1.10
for It. A Profltabis Propo-
sition any way you flgui'e
It. Don't miss this Oppor-
tunity of a Lifotim* to se-
cure the best Pen made.
Hard Rubber Reservoir
Holder in four simple parts.
Finest quality Diamond
Point 14.k Gold Pan and the
only Positively Parfaot ink
feeding device known to
the science of fountain pen
making.
jja-Any desired flexibility
In fine, medium or stub.
One Pen only to one
address on this offer.
LOSS— on the pen you buy— our
SEED-TIME expense.
BUSINESS— your pen procures—
our HARVEST.
By mall, postpaid, upon receipt
of $1, If you desire pen sent by
registered mall, send 10 cents ad-
ditional.
REFERENCE! Any Bank or Ex-
press Company In Detroit.
Address—
LAUQHLlNMFQ.Co.
97 Walker Block,
DETROIT, MICh.
Please mention The Open Court.
^13
00 ESCANABA
AND RETURN
FROM CHICAGO— Mealsand Berth Included. 4 days
trip on the water stopping en route and giving the
passengers an opportunity to see tiie following cities-
Milwaukee, Kufliie, Sheboygan, Manitowoc, Kewau-
nee, Algoiua, Sturgeon Bay, Marinette. Menominee,
Green Bay t^ity «fc other points oflntorest to tourists.
Leave Chicago 8:00 P. M. Wednesday & Saturday via
State
Room
and
Dining
Service
Finest
on
the
Great
Lakes.
For complete
information
address
The Psychology of Reasoning
Based on Experimental Researches in
Hypnotism. By ALFRED BINET, Doc-
tor of Science, Laureate of the Institute
(Academie des Sciences and Academie des
Sciences Morales), Director of the Labo-
ratory of Physiological Psychology in the
Sorbonne (Hautes Etudes).
' Clear and solid, and deserves careful reading two
or three times over."— Francis Gallon.
"llie Psychology of Reasoning is a
good specimen of those eminently lucid
and clear scientific treatises that French-
men know so well how to turn out."
Translated from the recent second
edition by Adam Gozuans IVJiyte, B. Sc.
Pages, 193. Index. Cloth, with gilt top,
75 cents (3s. 6d.).
The Open Court Pub. Co., Chicago.
324 Dearborn Street.
LONDON :
Kegan Paul, Trench, Triibner & Co., Ltd.
The Religion of Science Library.
Issued bi-monthly. Yearly, $1.50 ; single numbers according to the prices quoted. The
books are printed on good paper, from large type.
No. I. The Religion of Science. By Paul Carus. 25 cents (is. 6d.).
2. Three Introductory Lectures on the Science of Thought. By F. Max Muller.
25 cents (is. 6d ).
3. Three Lectures on the Science of Language. By F. Max MtjLLER. 25c (is. 6d.)
4. The Diseases of Personality. By Th. Ribot. 25 cents (is. 6d.).
5. The Psychology of Attention. By Th. Ribot. 25 cents (is. 6d.).
6. The Psychic Life of Micro-Organisms. By Alfred Binet. 25 cents (is. 6d.)
7. The Nature of the State. By Paul Carus. 15 cents (gd).
8. On Double Consciousness. By Alfred Binet. 15 cents (gd.).
9. Fundamental Problems. By Paul Carus. Pages, 373. 50 cents (2s. 6d.).
ro. The Diseases of the Will. By Th. Ribot. 25 cents (is. 6d.).
11. The Origin of Language, and The Logos Theory. By Ludwig Noir6. 15c (gd.)
12. The Free Trade Struggle in England. By Gen. M. M. Trumbull. 250(13 6d.).
13. Wheelbarrow on the Labor Question. 35 cents (2s.).
14. The Gospel of Buddha. By Paul Carus. 35 cents (2s.).
15. Primer of Philosophy. By Paul Carus. 25 cents (is. 6d.).
16. On Memory, and The Specific Energies of the Nervous System. By Pri f
Ewald Hering. 15 cents (gd.).
17. The Redemption of the Brahman. A Novel. By R. Garbe. 25 cents (is. 6d )
18. An Examination of Weismannism. By G. J. Romanes. 35 cents.
19. On Germinal Selection. By August Weismann. 25 cents (is. 6d.).
20. Lovers Three Thousand Years Ago. By T. A. Goodwin. (Out of Print.)
21. Popular Scientific Lectures. By Ernst Mach. 50 cents (2s 6d.).
22. Ancient India: Its Language and Religions. By H. Oldenberg. 25c (is. 6d ).
23. The Prophets of Israel. By C. H. Cornill. 25 cents (is. 6d.).
24. Homilies of Science. By Paul Carus. 35 cents (2s ).
25. Thoughts on Religion. By G J. Romanes. 50 cents (2s. 6d ).
26. Philosophy of Ancient India. By Richard Garbe. 25 cents (is. 6d.).
27. Martin Luther. By Gustav Frevtag. 25 cents (is. 6d.).
28. English Secularism. By George Jacob Holyoake. 25 cents (is. 6d.).
29. On Orthogenesis. By Th. Eimer. 25 cents (is. 6d.).
30. Chinese Philosophy. By Paul Carus. 25 cents (is. 6d.).
31. The Lost Manuscript. By Gustav Freytag. 60 cents (3s.).
32. A Mechanico=Physiological Theory of Organic Evolution. By Carl von
Nageli. 15 cents (gd.).
33. Chinese Fiction. By the Rev. George T. Candlin. 15 cents (gd.).
34. Mathematical Essays and Recreations. By H. Schubert. 25 cents (is. 6d.).
35. The Ethical Problem. By Paul Carus. 50 cents (2s. 6d.).
36. Buddhism and Its Christian Critics. By Paul Carus. 50 cents (2s. 6d.).
37. Psychology for Beginners. H.M.Stanley. 20 cents (is.).
38. Discourse on Method. By Ren^ Descartes. 25 cents (is. 6d.).
3g. The Dawn of a New Era. By Paul Carus. 15 cents (gd.).
40. Kant and Spencer. By Paul Carus. 20 cents (is.).
41. The Soul of Man. By Paul Carus. 75 cents (3s. 6d.).
42. World's Congress Addresses. By C. C. Bonney. 15 cents (gd.).
THE OPEN COURT PUBLISHINQ COMPANY.
324 DEARBORN ST., CHICAGO, ILL.
LONDON: Kegan Paul, Trench, Trubner & Co.
"/ am so much pleased with Post Pen {medium) sent me, that I would like another one
{stub) tor doing tree-hand writing."— PROP. R. M. WEISLEY, Ann Arbor, Mich.
Six Cardinal
Points
Peculiar
to the
POST
FOUNTAIN PEN
Se!f=FiIling
Self=Cleaning
Simplicity
Durability
Reliability
No Leaking
A, Barrel; B, Nozzle; C, Pen; D, Feed; E, Plunger; F. Rod.
PRICE3 $3.00
There are many pens on the market. Some have been sold for years and are very popular, but
we venture to say that no pen manufactured has received such testimonials in all the years they
have been before the public as the Post can show for a few months. The reason for this is not far
to seek. The Post is ahead of any other pen manufactured because of its self-filling and self-cleaning
features. But in praise of the pen we want to "let others speak." We submit here testimonials from
some of the most prominent men in the country.
READ CAREFULLY THESE TESTinONIALS
GENERAL LEW WALLACE, the author of the greatest book of the age, Ben Hur, also The
Prince of India, says: "I have tried every pen of its kind on the market and now unhesitatingly
give the preference to the Post. It not only feeds itself with less care, but has the immeasurable ad-
vantage of re-3upply without inking the fingers. I do all my work with it."
IRA D. SANKEY sends the following characteristic letter: "I have used the Post pen for
some time and have had great satisfaction with its use. It never fails or gets cranky. One can at
least have clean hands by using the Post, whatever the heart may be."
A testimonial from the late HON. ROSWELL P. FLOWER was worth a great deal and we
value very highly the accompanying testimonial, which he sent us in his own handwriting a short
time before his death. "This is written with the Post, a new fountain pen, the simplest and best
I have ever seen."
DR. LYMAN ABBOTT, the editor of the "Outlook," and former pastor of the Plymouth
Church, needs no introduction. We know the full value of the beautiful testimonial which he has
just forwarded and which is as follows:
"A number of years ago I had a Prinee fountain pen, which went out of existence, and I v/as
sorry for I preferred it to all others for the reasonthat it had no filler. Your "Post" self-filling foun-
tain pen has the advantage of the Prince, and one which it did not possess, namely, greater simplic-
ity. To me it is a greater advantage to have a fountain pen which requires no filler and can be filled
at any time, and at any inkstand, without the possibility of inky fingers or blotted paper or desk.
"Enclosed please find my check for $3.00 for the pen received, which I cordially recommend. It
will be found especially convenient for travelers."
COLONEL HERRICK, of Cleveland, O., says: "Recently I became possessed of a Post foun-
tain pen, which I am pleased to commend as in every way a perfect pen, simple in its mechanism,
durable, perfectly tight and responding readily. It has fully answered my expectations and is a
source of much comfort to me."
HON. LUTHER LAFLIN MILLS, the celebrated criminal lawyer and eminent orator of Chi-
cago, writes as follows: "Your Post fountain pen is the best I have ever used, simple, reliable,
durable, and I thank you for having brought it to my notice."
THE POST FOUNTAIN PEN
R. CAYGILU Manager,
120=124 W. 14th street, NEW YORK CITY.
THE
HISTORY OF THE DEVIL
AND
THE IDEA OF EVIL
FROM THE EARLIEST TIME TO THE PRESENT DAY
BY
DR. PAUL CARUS
With illustrations from ancient and modern demonology, as recorded on monuments
and in literature.
Offering a complete comparative history and analysis of the idea of evil, with philosoph-
ical, ethical, and religious comments.
The author reviews the broad field of the conceptions of evil among the various nations
of the earth. Beginning with prehistoric Devil-worship and the adoration of demon gods
and monster divinities, he surveys the beliefs of the Summero-Accadians, the Persians, the
Jews, the Brahmans, the Buddhists, the early Christians, and the Teutonic nations. He
then passes to the demonology of the Middle Ages, the Reformation, and modern times, dis-
cussing the Inquisition, witchcraft, and the history of the Devil in verse and fable. The
philosophical treatment of the subject is comparatively brief, but the salient points are
clearly indicated in every connexion. The pictures are numerous, and will aid considerably
the reader's comprehension.
No expense has been spared to make the book exemplary in every respect.
Printed In two colors from large type on fine paper.
Bound in cloth, Illuminated witb cover stamp from Dore. Five hundred 8vo pages, with 311
illustrations in black and tint. Price, when published. $6.00. READY IN AUGUST.
SPECIAL ADVANCE OFFER
All orders received from readers hi the United States, Canada, and Mexico, before
the date of going to press (August /Jth), will be filled at the special price of $4.00 per
copy, C. 0. D. , or cash zuith order.
Foreign orders accompanied by remittance and mailed before date of going to press,
though arriving after, will be accepted at the special rate.
CHICAGO
THE OPEN COURT PUBLISHING COMPANY
324 Dearborn Street
LONDON
Kegan Paul, Trench, Trubner & Co. (Ltd.), Paternoster House, Charing Cross Road