Skip to main content

Full text of "The poetry of Emily Dickinson : teacher's guide"

See other formats


TEACHER'S  GUIDE 


THE  POETRY  OF 


'•4F   --INSTITUTED      ,  ,. 

".*.».  Museum^ Library 

•  .•?*  services' 


Emily  Dickinson 


NATIONAL 
ENDOWMENT 
FOR  THE  ARTS 


y 


m 


READ 


THE  POETRY  OF 


Emily  Dickinson 


TEACHER'S  GUIDE 


NATIONAL 
ENDOWMENT 
FOR  THE  ARTS 

A  great  nation 
deserves  great  art. 


vi.  MuseumandLibrary 


AS 


MIDWEST 


The  National  Endowment  for  the  Arts  is  a  public  agency  dedicated  to  supporting 
excellence  in  the  arts — both  new  and  established — bringing  the  arts  to  all  Americans, 
and  providing  leadership  in  arts  education.  Established  by  Congress  in  1965  as  an 
independent  agency  of  the  federal  government,  the  Endowment  is  the  nation's  largest 
annual  funder  of  the  arts,  bringing  great  art  to  all  50  states,  including  rural  areas,  inner 
cities,  and  military  bases. 

The  Institute  of  Museum  and  Library  Services  is  the  primary  source  of  federal  support 
for  the  nation's  122,000  libraries  and  17,500  museums.  The  Institute's  mission  is  to  create 
strong  libraries  and  museums  that  connect  people  to  information  and  ideas.  The  Institute 
works  at  the  national  level  and  in  coordination  with  state  and  local  organizations  to 
sustain  heritage,  culture,  and  knowledge;  enhance  learning  and  innovation;  and  support 
professional  development. 

Arts  Midwest  connects  people  throughout  the  Midwest  and  the  world  to  meaningful  arts 
opportunities,  sharing  creativity,  knowledge,  and  understanding  across  boundaries.  Based 
in  Minneapolis,  Arts  Midwest  connects  the  arts  to  audiences  throughout  the  nine-state 
region  of  Illinois,  Indiana,  Iowa,  Michigan,  Minnesota,  North  Dakota,  Ohio,  South 
Dakota,  and  Wisconsin.  One  of  six  non-profit  regional  arts  organizations  in  the  United 
States,  Arts  Midwest's  history  spans  more  than  25  years. 

Additional  support  for  The  Big  Read  has  also  been  provided  by  the  W.K.  Kellogg 
Foundation. 

The  creation  of  Emily  Dickinson  educational  materials  has  been  made  possible,  in  part, 
with  support  from  the  Poetry  Foundation. 

Published  by 

National  Endowment  for  the  Arts 
1 100  Pennsylvania  Avenue,  N.W. 
Washington,  DC  20506-0001 
(202)  682-5400 
www.nea.gov 

Works  Cited 

Poems  in  this  guide  are  reprinted  by  permission  of  the  publishers  and  the  Trustees  of  Amherst  College  from  THE 
POEMS  OF  EMILY  DICKINSON:  READING  EDITION,  Ralph  W.  Franklin,  ed.,  Cambridge,  MA  The 
Belknap  Press  of  Harvard  University  Press,  Copyright  (c)  1998,  1999  by  the  President  and  Fellows  of  Harvard 
College:  Copyright  (c)  1951,  1955,  1979,  1983  by  the  President  and  Fellows  of  Harvard  College. 

Farr,  Judith.  The  Passion  of  Emily  Dickinson.  Cambridge,  MA:  Harvard  University  Press,  1992. 

Johnson,  Thomas  H.,  ed.  Emily  Dickinson:  Selected  Letters.  1958.  Cambridge,  MA  The  Belknap  Press  of  Harvard 
University  Press,  1986. 

Sewall,  Richard  B.  The  Life  of  Emily  Dickinson.  Cambridge,  MA:  Harvard  University  Press,  1998. 

Acknowledgments 

David  Kipen,  NEA  Director  of  Literature,  National  Reading  Initiatives 

Writer:  Erika  Koss  for  the  National  Endowment  for  the  Arts;  Handout  Two,  "Wild  Legacies," 
by  Diane  Thiel 

Series  Editor:  Molly  Thomas-Hicks  for  the  National  Endowment  for  the  Arts 

Image  Editor:  Dan  Brady  for  the  National  Endowment  for  the  Arts 

Graphic  Design:  Fletcher  Design/Washington,  DC 

Special  thanks  to  Jane  Wald,  Executive  Director  of  the  Emily  Dickinson  Museum 

Image  Credits 

Cover  Portrait:  John  SherfTius  for  The  Big  Read.  Page  iv:  Courtesy  of  Paul  Shabajee.  Page  1 :  Artwork  by 
John  Sherffius.  Inside  back  coven  Courtesy  of  Amherst  College  Archives  and  Special  Collections. 


April  2 


Table  of  Contents 


Introduction 1 

Suggested  Teaching  Schedule 2 

Lesson  One:  Word  Choice  and  the  Value  of  a  Dictionary 4 

Lesson  Two:  Biographical  Criticism 5 

Lesson  Three:  The  Speaker  of  a  Poem 6 

Lesson  Four:  Imagery  and  Personification 7 

Lesson  Five:  Figurative  Language 8 

Lesson  Six:  Rhythm  and  Meter l) 

Lesson  Seven:  Allusion 10 

Lesson  Eight:  Analyzing  a  Poems  Context 1 1 

I  wesson  Nine:  Poetry  and  Ideas 12 

Ixsson  Ten:  What  Makes  a  Poet  Great? 13 

Essay  Topics 14 

Glossary IS 

Handout  One  Emily  Dickinson  and 

the  Victorian  "Woman  Question" lo 

t  [andout  I  wo:  Wild  1  cg.icies  1" 

1  [andout  Three:  Dickinson  s  Final  Sorrows 1 8 

I  caching  Resources ll) 

NC 1 1  Standards  


*w 


■M 


The  Poets  light  but  Lamps 
Themselves  -  go  out  - 
The  Wicks  they  stimulate 
If  vital  Light 

Inhere  as  do  the  Suns  - 
Each  Age  a  Lens 
Disseminating  their 
Circumference  - 

—EMILY  DICKINSON 


Introduction 


Welcome  to  The  Big  Read,  an  initiative  from  the  National  Endowment  for  the 
Arts.  Designed  to  revitalize  the  role  of  literary  reading  in  American  culture, 
The  Big  Read  hopes  to  unite  communities  through  great  literature,  as  well  as 
inspire  students  to  become  lifelong  readers. 

The  National  Endowment  for  the  Arts  joins  the  Poetry  Foundation  to  create 
a  new  program  to  celebrate  great  American  poets  and  the  historic  sites 
associated  with  their  lives  and  works.  By  honoring  these  writers  and  literary 
landmarks,  we  hope  both  to  bring  poetry  to  a  broader  audience  and  to  help 
preserve  and  promote  local  cultural  heritage  and  history. 

This  Teacher's  Guide  contains  ten  lessons  to  introduce  students  to  the 
poetry  of  Emily  Dickinson.  Dickinson  is  not  only  one  of  the  supreme  lyric 
poets  of  American  literature,  she  has  also  come  to  symbolize  the  purest 
kind  of  artistic  vocation.  Not  merely  unrecognized  but  virtually  unpublished 
in  her  own  lifetime,  she  developed  her  genius  in  the  utmost  privacy,  invisible 
to  all  except  a  small  circle  of  family  and  friends.  Driven  only  by  her  own 
imagination,  she  created  a  body  of  work  unsurpassed  in  its  expressive 
originality,  penetrating  insight,  and  dark  beauty. 

Each  lesson  has  five  components:  a  focus  topic,  discussion  activities,  writing 
exercises,  vocabulary  words,  and  homework  assignments.  In  addition,  we  have 
suggested  essay  topics,  as  well  as  provided  handouts  with  more  background 
information  about  the  poems,  the  historical  period,  and  the  author.  All 
lessons  dovetail  with  the  state  language  arts  standards  required  for  poetry. 

Finally,  The  Big  Read  Reader's  Guide  deepens  your  exploration  with 
biography,  timelines,  and  historical  information.  We  hope  these  educational 
materials  allow  you  to  have  fun  with  your  students  while  introducing  them  to 
the  work  of  a  great  American  poet. 

From  the  NEA  and  the  Poetry  Foundation,  we  wish  you  an  exciting  and 
productive  school  year. 


National  Endowmeni  for  tin 


THE  BIG  READ  ■    | 


chedul 


Day  One 


FOCUS:  Word  Choice  and  the  Value  of  a  Dictionary 

Activities:  Discuss  Emily  Dickinson's  poem  "A  Route 
of  Evanescence."  Have  students  create  their  own 
four-line  poetic  riddles. 

Homework:  Read  "Emily  Dickinson,  1830-1886" 
(pp.  4-6)  and  "The  Publication  of  Dickinson's  Poetry" 
(p.  10)  in  the  Reader's  Guide.  Read  three  poems 
by  Dickinson:  "Fame  is  the  one  that  does  not 
stay  -,"  "Fame  is  a  fickle  food,"  and  "Success  is 
counted  sweetest."* 


2 


Day  Two 

FOCUS:  Biographical  Criticism 

Activities:  Examine  Dickinson's  life.  Discuss  her 
poems  on  fame  and  success. 

Homework:  Read  Handout  One:  Emily  Dickinson 
and  the  Victorian  "Woman  Question."  Read  three 
poems:  "They  shut  me  up  in  Prose  -  ,"  "I  dwell  in 
Possibility  -,"  and  "Crumbling  is  not  an  instant's  Act." 


*  Most  poems  cited  in  this  guide  are  on  the  Poetry 
Foundation's  Poetry  Tool:  www.poetryfoundation.org. 
A  biography  and  bibliography  are  also  available  there. 


3 


Day  Three 

FOCUS:  The  Speaker  of  a  Poem 

Activities:  Discuss  Dickinson's  use  of  persona  in 
contrast  to  her  autobiographical  poems. 

Homework:  Read  "Dickinson's  Poetry"  (pp.  8-9)  in 
the  Reader's  Guide,  and  her  poems  "The  Moon  is 
distant  from  the  Sea  -"  and  "After  great  pain  a  formal 
feeling  comes." 


4 


Day  Four 

FOCUS:  Imagery  and  Personification 

Activities:  Discuss  Dickinson's  use  of  nature  imagery 
and  personification  to  help  readers  visualize  sensory 
experiences. 

Homework:  Read  "'Hope'  is  the  thing  with  feathers-," 
"There  is  no  Frigate  like  a  Book,"  and  "Tell  all  the  truth 
but  tell  it  slant  -." 


5 


Day  Five 

FOCUS:  Figurative  Language 

Activities:  Discuss  Dickinson's  use  of  seemingly 
unrelated  objects  and  feelings,  and  the  contrast 
between  light  and  darkness  in  "Tell  all  the  truth  but 
tell  it  slant-." 

Homework:  Read  "Before  I  got  my  eye  put  out  -" 
and  "Because  I  could  not  stop  for  Death  -." 


2  *  THE  BIG  READ 


National  Endowment  for  the  Arts 


6 


Day  Six 

FOCUS:  Rhythm  and  Meter 

Activities:  Discuss  the  way  some  of  Dickinson's 
poems  employ  the  patterns  of  nineteenth-century 
hymns.  Listen  to  a  CD  of  hymns  and  "sing"  two  of 
her  poems.  Consider  contemporary  songs  that  follow 
fixed  forms. 

Homework:  Read  "A  little  East  of  Jordan,"  "Come 
slowly  -  Eden!,"  and  "All  overgrown  by  cunning 
moss."  Look  up  at  least  three  words  from  the 
poems.  Read  "From  The  Gardens  of  Emily  Dickinson" 
(pp.  12-13)  in  the  Reader's  Guide. 


7 


Day  Seven 

FOCUS:  Allusion 

Activities:  Discuss  Dickinson's  biblical  references  in 
"A  little  East  of  Jordan." 

Homework:  Read  "Now  I  knew  I  lost  her  -,"  "Wild 
nights  -  Wild  nights!."  and  "You  left  me  -  Sire  -  two 
Legacies."  Then  read  Handout  Two:  Wild  Legacies, 
and  the  short  essay  "The  Homestead  and  The 
Evergreens"  (p.  7)  in  the  Reader's  Guide. 


8 


Day  Eight 

FOCUS:  Analyzing  a  Poem's  Context 

Activities:  Discuss  two  of  Dickinson's  poem  cycles: 
the  "Sue  cycle"  and  the  "Master  cycle,"  both  of  which 
passionately  articulate — in  both  obvious  and  subtle 
ways — her  experience  with  love  and  loss. 

Homework:  Read  "This  World  is  not  conclusion,"  "I 
know  that  He  exists,"  and  "Forever  -  is  composed 
of  Nows  -  ."  Then  read  Handout  Three:  Dickinson's 
Final  Sorrows. 


9 


Day  Nine 

FOCUS:  Poetry  and  Ideas 

Activities:  Discuss  Dickinson's  "flood  subject." 
immortality,  and  the  way  in  which  her  faith  sustained 
her  through  suffering  and  sorrow. 

Homework:  Students  will  begin  working  on  their 
essays.  Drafts  are  due  next  class  period. 


10 


Day  Ten 

FOCUS:  What  Makes  a  Poet  Great' 

Activities:  Explore  the  qualities  of  a  great  poet  Wnte 
a  short  essay  that  explains  how  Dickinson  directs 
our  attention  to  the  beauty  of  nature,  the  depth  of 
emotions,  and  the  possibility  of  immortality 

Homework:  Students  should  complete  their  essays 


National  I  ndowmcnt  for  thv 


THE  BIG  READ  ■  3 


FOCUS: 

Word 
and  the 
Value  of  a 
Dictionary 


VOCABULARY  WORDS 

From  "A  Route 
of  Evanescence  " 

Evanescence,  n. 

The  event  of  fading  and  gradually 
vanishing  from  sight 

Resonance,  n. 

1.  Intensification  and 
prolongation  of  sound, 
especially  of  a  musical  tone, 
produced  by  vibration 

2.  Richness  or  significance, 
especially  in  evoking  an 
association  or  strong  emotion 

Cochineal,  n. 

A  vivid  red;  a  scarlet  dye 

Tunis,  n. 

The  capital  of  Tunisia,  on  the 
northern  coast  of  Africa 


Words  are  to  a  poet  what  clay  is  to  a  sculptor:  the  basic  material  of  his  or 
her  art.  Poets  see  the  shape  of  words,  listen  closely  to  their  sound,  feel  their 
weight.  Before  a  poem  can  be  appreciated  for  its  deeper  meanings,  it  must 
first  be  read  literally.  We  often  overlook  words  we  can  already  define.  Ralph 
Waldo  Emerson  wrote  in  Nature,  "Every  word  ...  if  traced  to  its  root,  is 
found  to  be  borrowed  from  some  material  appearance.  Right  means  straight; 
wrong  means  twisted.  Spirit  primarily  means  wind;  transgression,  the  crossing 
of  a  line;  supercilious,  the  raising  of  the  eyebrow''  Students  should  even 
look  up  words  that  are  commonly  used  to  understand  better  the  careful, 
conscious  choices  poets  make.  Several  words  from  assigned  poems  are 
already  defined  in  the  margins  of  this  Teacher's  Guide. 

Discussion  Activities 

Dickinson  found  great  joy  in  exploring  the  mysteries  of  nature,  and  some  of 
her  poems  read  like  riddles.  A  concise  and  complex  poem  like  the  one  below 
forces  the  reader  to  slow  down  and  consider  each  word  and  image.  Read  this 
poem  aloud  to  your  students  twice,  and  see  if  they  can  figure  out  that  the  poem 
describes  a  hummingbird. 

A  Route  of  Evanescence, 
With  a  revolving  Wheel  - 
A  Resonance  of  Emerald 
A  Rush  of  Cochineal  - 
And  every  Blossom  on  the  Bush 
Adjusts  it's  tumbled  Head  -  * 
The  Mail  from  Tunis  -  probably, 
An  easy  Morning's  Ride  - 

To  understand  this  poem,  students  must  know  the  definition  of  nouns  such  as 
"evanescence,"  "cochineal,"  and  "Tunis."  Also  important  is  an  understanding  of 
a  hummingbird's  flight  patterns,  wing  speed,  and  eating  habits — things  Dickinson 
would  have  noticed  from  her  meticulous  observations  of  her  gardens  and  the 
forests.  Taking  the  poem  line  by  line,  discuss  the  ways  Dickinson's  words  evoke 
the  particular  qualities  of  this  beautiful  creature. 

Writing  Exercise 

Have  students  create  four-line  poetic  riddles.  Students  should  choose  an  element 
from  nature  or  an  object.  Ask  them  to  use  the  dictionary  to  incorporate  at  least 
one  surprising  word  into  their  riddles. 


EJ  Homework 


Have  students  read  the  Reader's  Guide  essays  "Emily  Dickinson,  1830-1886" 
(pp.  4-6)  and  "The  Publication  of  Dickinson's  Poetry"  (p.  10).  Read  Dickinson's 
poems  "Fame  is  the  one  that  does  not  stay  -,"  "Fame  is  a  fickle  food,"  and 
"Success  is  counted  sweetest." 

*  The  incorrect  apostrophe  in  line  six  of  "A  Route  of  Evanescence,"  is  in  Dickinson's  manuscript 


4  *  THE  BIG  READ 


National  Endowment  for  the  Arts 


FOCUS: 

Biographical 
Criticism 


Biographical  criticism  is  the  practice  of  analyzing  a  literary  work  through 
the  lens  of  an  authors  experience.  It  considers  the  ways  age,  race,  gender, 
family,  education,  and  economic  status  inform  a  writer's  work.  A  critic 
might  also  examine  how  poems  reflect  personality  characteristics,  life 
experiences,  and  psychological  dynamics.  To  understand  some  poems, 
readers  need  knowledge  of  the  poet's  biographical  facts  or  experiences. 

As  explained  in  the  Reader's  Guide  essays  "Emily  Dickinson,  1830-1886 
(pp.  4-6)  and  "The  Publication  of  Dickinson's  Poetry    (p.  10),  Dickinson 
did  not  experience  fame  during  her  lifetime.  However,  fame  is  a  subject  that 
several  of  her  poems  explore.  Although  she  sent  about  one  hundred  of  her 
finest  poems  to  Thomas  Wentworth  Higginson,  in  some  ways  he  failed  to 
be  the  mentor  she  needed,  altering  her  poetry  and  publishing  only  a  handful 
of  her  poems  before  her  death.  Still,  though  Dickinson  was  writing  during 
a  period  that  discouraged  women  writers,  Higginson  was  one  of  few  men 
who  actively  championed  the  reading  and  publication  of  work  by  women. 


VOCABULARY  WORDS 

From  "Fame  is  the  one  that 
does  not  stay —  " 

Incessantly,  adv. 
Constantly;  without  ceasing 

Insolvent,  adj. 

Unable  to  pay  one's  debts; 

bankrupt 


From  "Success  is  counted 
sweetest " 

Strains,  n. 

A  passage  of  melody,  music,  or 
song 


Discussion  Activities 

Ask  some  students  to  share  their  riddles  in  class,  seeing  if  their  classmates  can 
figure  out  what  is  described. 

Emily  Dickinson  treated  the  subject  of  success  with  remarkable  insight  for 
someone  who  never  experienced  it.  Compare  the  two  poems  "Fame  is  the  one 
that  does  not  stay  -"  and  "Fame  is  a  fickle  food."  How  does  she  convey  her 
attitude  toward  fame?  What  is  the  relationship  between  the  crows  and  the  men 
in  the  latter  poem,  and  what  might  this  suggest  about  success? 


Q  Writing  Exercise 


Dickinson's  poetry  often  describes  inner  states  of  mind.  However,  several  of  her 
poems  composed  during  the  Civil  War  employ  images  of  battle,  including  her 
popular  poem  "Success  is  counted  sweetest."  Ask  students  to  explain,  in  writing. 
the  following  two  paradoxes:  Why  can't  "Victory"  be  defined  by  those  who  "took 
the  Flag"?  How  and  why  can  the  "defeated"  and  "dying"  hear  a  song  of  triumph? 


H  Homework 


Have  students  read  Handout  One:  Emily  Dickinson  and  the  Victorian  "Woman 
Question."  Ask  them  to  consider  the  relationship  between  her  poems  on  success 
or  fame  and  the  changing  opportunities  for  women  during  the  nineteenth  century 
Read  Dickinson's  poems  "They  shut  me  up  in  Prose  -."  "I  dwell  in  Possibility  -." 
and  "Crumbling  is  not  an  instant's  Act." 


National  Endowment  tor  rite  \rt««  the  big  read  •  5 


FOCUS: 

The  Speaker 
of  a  Poem 


Examining  an  author's  life  can  inform  and  expand  a  literary  text.  Readers 
should  be  careful  not  to  assume  that  the  speaker  of  a  poem  is  necessarily 
the  poet.  When  we  read  a  poem,  one  of  our  first  questions  should  be: 
Whose  "voice"  is  speaking  to  us?  Sometimes  a  poet  will  create  a  persona, 
a  fictitious  speaker,  and  this  speaker  may  not  always  be  human.  A  speaker 
may  be  an  animal  or  object,  and  good  poems  have  been  written  from 
perspectives  as  various  as  a  hawk,  a  clock,  or  a  cloud. 

Because  the  opening  lines  of  more  than  two  hundred  of  Dickinson  s  poems 
are  expressly  written  in  the  first  person  (either  the  singular  "I"  or  the  plural 
"we"),  it  is  difficult  to  resist  reading  most  of  her  poetry  as  autobiographical. 
Yet  many  of  her  poems  do  not  concern  the  experiences  of  an  "I"  but 
describe  natural  phenomena  (like  Lesson  One's  "A  Route  of  Evanescence"), 
characterize  states  of  mind,  or  define  abstractions  through  metaphor  (like 
Lesson  Two's  "Fame  is  a  fickle  food"). 


VOCABULARY  WORDS 

From  "I  dwell  in  Possibility  — 

Impregnable,  adj. 

Difficult  or  impossible  to  attack, 

challenge,  or  refute 

Gambrel,  n. 

A  roof  having  a  shallower  slope 
above  a  steeper  one  on  each  side 


From  "Crumbling  is  not  an 
instant's  Act" 

Dilapidation,  n. 

A  state  of  decay  due  to  old  age  or 
long  use 

Cuticle,  n. 

Botany.  A  protective  layer  covering 
the  epidermis  of  a  plant 

Borer,  n. 

A  tool  used  to  pierce  or  form  a 
hole;  an  auger 


Discussion  Activities 

In  many  of  her  poems,  Dickinson  attempts  to  describe  psychological  states 
objectively,  as  in  "Crumbling  is  not  an  instant's  Act."  In  these  kinds  of  poems,  she 
does  not  use  the  first  person,  or  any  overt  reference  to  her  life.  Examine  each 
stanza  of  this  poem  with  your  students,  noticing  the  imagery  Dickinson  uses  in 
her  declarative  statements  about  the  slow  process  of  decay. 

Discuss  Handout  One:  Emily  Dickinson  and  the  Victorian  "Woman  Question." 
Have  the  class  analyze  the  poems  "I  dwell  in  Possibility  -"  and  "They  shut  me  up 
in  Prose  -."  Although  the  speaker  of  these  two  1862  poems  may  be  Dickinson, 
who  else  could  it  be? 


Writing  Exercise 


Have  students  write  a  two-page  essay  on  Dickinson's  treatment  of  houses 
and  nature  in  all  three  poems.  How  does  she  use  imagery  to  portray  both 
confinement  and  liberation?  What  might  this  suggest  about  her  own  struggles 
and  triumphs  as  a  poet? 


EJ  Homework 


Ask  students  to  read  "Dickinson's  Poetry"  (pp.  8-9)  in  the  Reader's  Guide.  Also 
have  them  read  "The  Moon  is  distant  from  the  Sea  -"  and  "After  great  pain,  a 
formal  feeling  comes  -." 


THE  BIG  READ 


National  Endowment  for  the  Arts 


Lesson  Four 


FOCUS: 

Imagery  and 
Personification 


Poets  use  figurative  language  to  help  a  reader  imagine  the  events  and 
emotions  described  in  a  poem.  Imagery,  a  word  or  series  of  words  that  refers 
to  any  sensory  experience  (sight,  sound,  smell,  touch,  or  taste),  helps  create 
a  visceral  experience  for  the  reader.  Personification  is  a  figure  of  speech  in 
which  a  thing,  animal,  or  abstract  term  (truth,  death,  the  past)  takes  on 
human  qualities. 

To  comprehend  Emily  Dickinson's  poetry,  the  reader  must  understand 
the  importance  of  figurative  language  as  a  way  to  suggest  what  cannot 
be  literally  stated.  To  appreciate  her  work,  one  must  forgo  readings 
that  view  truth  as  black  or  white.  Dickinsons  poetry  is  consciously 
mysterious  and  elliptical.  The  reader  must  attempt  to  use  Dickinson  s 
own  logic,  remembering  that  "Much  Madness  is  divinest  Sense  -  / 
To  a  discerning  Eye  -  ." 


VOCABULARY  WORDS 

From  "The  Moon  is  distant 
from  the  Sea  -  " 

Docile,  adj. 

Easily  managed  or  led,  teachable 

Impose,  v. 

1.  To  force  to  be  accepted,  done, 
or  complied  with 

2.  To  take  advantage  of  someone 


From  "After  great  pain,  a 
formal  feeling  comes  -  " 

Quartz,  n. 

A  hard, transparent  mineral 

Stupor,  n. 

A  state  of  helpless  amazement 


Discussion  Activities 

Have  students  research  the  relationship  between  the  moon  and  the  sea.  the 
tides,  and  the  monthly  lunar  cycle.  Then  ask  them  to  read  "The  Moon  is  distant 
from  the  Sea  -,"  noticing  that  Dickinson  personifies  the  connection  by  invoking 
the  human  body,  saying  that  the  moon's  "Amber  Hands"  lead  the  sea  "Along 
appointed  Sands."  In  the  second  stanza,  she  deepens  this  personification  by 
noting  the  sea's  obedience  to  the  moon's  "eye,"  suggesting  a  scientific  reality:  that 
the  moon  controls  the  length  and  timing  of  the  sea's  tides.  The  poem  turns  to 
address  a  person  ("Signor")  in  stanza  three.  How  does  the  relationship  between 
the  moon  and  the  sea  parallel  that  between  the  mysterious  "Signor"  and  the 
speaker's  heart? 


P  Writing  Exercise 


List  each  example  of  personification  in  the  poem  "After  great  pain,  a  formal 
feeling  comes  -  ."  Ask  students  to  answer  the  following  questions:  Which  image 
resonates  best  with  your  experience  of  "great  pain";  How  do  the  images  in 
stanzas  one  and  two  build  to  the  final  image  of  "First  -  Chill  -  then  Stupor  -  then 
the  letting  go  -  "? 


d  Homework 


Read  "'Hope'  is  the  thing  with  feathers  -."  "There  is  no  Frigate  like  a  Book."  and 
"Tell  all  the  truth  but  tell  it  slant  -." 


National  Endowment  for  the  \rt« 


THE  BIG  READ  *  7 


Lesson  Five 


FOCUS: 

Figurative 
Language 


VOCABULARY  WORDS 

From  "'Hope'  is  the  thing  with 
feathers-" 

Gale,  n. 

A  very  strong  wind 

Abash,  v. 

Cause  to  feel  embarrassed, 
disconcerted,  ashamed 


From  "There  is  no  Frigate 
like  a  Book" 

Frigate,  n. 

A  warship  with  a  mixed  armament, 
generally  lighter  than  a  destroyer 


Courser,  n. 

A  swift  horse 

Traverse,  n. 

A  route  or  path  across  or  over 

Frugal,  adj. 
Economical;  thrifty 


Figurative  language  asks  us  to  stretch  our  imaginations,  finding  the  likeness 
in  seemingly  unrelated  things.  A  simile  is  a  comparison  of  two  things 
that  initially  seem  quite  different,  but  are  shown  to  have  a  significant 
resemblance.  Similes  employ  a  connective,  usually  "like,"  "as,"  or  "than,"  or  a 
verb  such  as  "resembles."  A  metaphor  also  compares  two  seemingly  different 
things,  but  it  states  that  one  thing  is  something  else  that,  in  a  literal  sense,  it 
is  not.  By  asserting  that  a  thing  is  something  else,  a  metaphor  creates  a  close 
association  that  underscores  an  important  similarity  between  them. 

Discussion  Activities 

As  a  class,  identify  the  opening  comparison  in  Dickinson's  poems  "'Hope' 
is  the  thing  with  feathers  -"  and  "There  is  no  Frigate  like  a  Book."  What 
correspondence  exists  between  hope  and  something  with  feathers  in  the 
first  poem,  and  between  a  ship  and  a  book  in  the  second?  Take  the  time 
to  go  through  each  line  of  the  poem  as  a  class.  Discuss  the  way  Dickinson 
develops  these  particular  metaphors  throughout  each  poem  to  make  a  more 
comprehensive  point  about  "the  Human  Soul."  What  other  metaphors  can 
students  find  in  these  two  poems? 

If  time  permits,  discuss  Dickinson's  use  of  metaphor  in  other  poems  referenced 
in  this  Teacher's  Guide. 


Ed  Writing  Exercise 


In  the  1872  poem  "Tell  all  the  truth  but  tell  it  slant  -,"  Dickinson  compares 
"Truth's  superb  surprise"  to  lightning.  Have  students  write  a  one-page  analysis  of 
what  Dickinson's  comparison  between  light  and  darkness  might  suggest  about 
how  we  discern  truth. 

To  expand  this  question,  consider  the  development  of  our  scientific 
understanding  of  light  and  lightning  since  the  nineteenth  century,  as  well  as 
Dickinson's  own  problems  with  her  eyes  and  sight. 


F3  Homework 


Read  "Before  I  got  my  eye  put  out  -"  and  "Because  I  could  not  stop  for 
Death  -." 


8  •  THE  BIG  READ 


National  Endowment  for  the  Arts 


FOCUS: 

Rhythm 
Meter 


and 


A  poem's  meaning  can  be  found  in  its  structural,  stylistic,  and  verbal 
components.  Two  such  components  are  rhythm  and  meter,  long  regarded 
as  distinguishing  features  of  verse.  Poems  may  be  written  in  fixed  forms — 
traditional  verse  forms  that  require  certain  predetermined  structural 
elements  of  meter,  rhythm,  and  rhyme,  such  as  a  sonnet  or  a  ballad — or  open 
form.  Not  all  poets  write  in  fixed  forms  or  meter,  but  all  poets  employ 
rhythm.  Rhythm  is  created  by  the  pattern  of  stressed  and  unstressed 
syllables  in  a  poetic  line.  Scansion  is  the  art  of  listening  carefully  to  the 
sounds  of  a  poem  and  trying  to  make  sense  of  it.  This  includes  paying 
attention  to  each  poetic  foot,  each  stressed  ox  unstressed  syllable,  and — if 
applicable — to  the  poems  rhyme  scheme. 

Most  nineteenth-century  poets,  including  Emily  Dickinson,  wrote 
primarily  in  fixed  forms  with  identifiable  meters.  Dickinson  drew  her  meter 
from  Protestant  hymns  sung  in  the  churches  in  Amherst,  Massachusetts. 


VOCABULARY  WORDS 

From  "Because  I  could  not  stop 
for  Death-  " 

Gossamer,  n. 

1.  An  extremely  delicate  variety  of 
gauze,  used  especially  for  veils 

2.  A  cobweb 

Tippet,  n. 

A  woman's  fur  cape  or  woolen 
shawl 

Tulle,  n. 

Fine  (often  starched)  net  used  for 
veils,  tutus,  or  gowns 

Cornice,  n. 

An  ornamental  molding  around  the 
wall  of  a  room  just  below  the  ceiling 


Discussion  Activities 

When  scanning  a  poem,  use  an  accent  (')  over  each  stressed  syllable  and  a  breve 
or  "little  round  cup"  (~)  over  each  unstressed  syllable.  Here  are  examples  of  how 
to  scan  one  of  Dickinson's  poems: 

Because  I  could  not  stop  for  Death  - 
He  kindly  stopped  for  me  - 
The  Carriage  held  but  just  Ourselves  - 
And  Immortality. 

Have  students  scan  "Because  I  could  not  stop  for  Death  -  ."  Ask  your  students 
how  scanning  a  poem  helps  them  understand  its  meaning. 

Find  a  recording  of  the  hymns  "A  Mighty  Fortress  Is  Our  God"  and  "Oh  God 
Our  Help  In  Ages  Past".  Notice  that  one  can  "sing"  the  poem  above  to  the  tune 
of  both  hymns. 


E(  Writing  Exercise 


Ask  students  to  consider  a  favorite  song  and  write  a  short  comparison  to 
Dickinson's  poetry.  Does  it  employ  meter,  rhythm,  or  rhyme'  How  do  fixed 
forms  help  the  listener  memorize  the  song? 


Q  Homework 


Read  "A  little  East  of  Jordan,"  "Come  slowly  -  Eden!."  and  "All  overgrown  with 
cunning  moss."  Read  "From  The  Gardens  of  Emily  Dtckmson"  (pp.  12-13)  in  the 
Reader's  Guide. 


National  Endowment  Rm  the  \m  the  big  read  •  9 


Lesson  Seven 


FOCUS: 

Allusion 


Most  poets  have  an  audience  in  mind  when  they  write — a  reader  who  will 
understand  and  appreciate  their  work.  In  trying  to  communicate  with  that 
audience,  poets  sometimes  use  overt  or  subtle  references — allusions — to  tap 
shared  cultural  memories,  or  enlarge  the  scope  of  their  work.  Allusions  may 
appear  in  a  poem  as  an  initial  quotation,  a  passing  mention  of  a  name,  or 
a  phrase  borrowed  from  another  writer — often  carrying  the  meanings  and 
implications  of  the  original.  When,  for  instance,  poets  allude  to  a  person, 
image,  or  event  in  Homer  s  Iliad  or  the  Bible,  they  presume  readers  will  be 
familiar  with  those  texts.  In  the  same  way,  poets  amplify  the  scope  of  their 
work  by  connecting  images  and  ideas  to  outside  sources. 

Emily  Dickinson  drew  from  Greek  and  Roman  myths,  the  Bible,  and 
British  writers  for  inspiration.  Her  poetry  is  rife  with  references  to  religion, 
botany,  biology,  history,  art,  music,  and  literature  (especially  Shakespeare). 
For  example,  her  poem  "All  overgrown  by  cunning  moss"  refers  to  the 
grave  ("little  cage")  of  Currer  Bell  (the  pseudonym  of  Charlotte  Bronte) 
in  Haworth,  Yorkshire  County,  England — a  detail  that  would  have  been 
familiar  to  readers  due  to  the  popularity  of  Brontes  1847  novel,  Jane  Eyre. 


VOCABULARY  WORDS 

From  "A  little  East  of  Jordan" 

Waxing,  v. 

Becoming  larger  or  stronger 

Worsted,  v.  tr. 

Gained  the  advantage  over;  defeated 

From  "Come slowly  —  Eden!" 

Jessamines,  n. 

A  variant  of  jasmine;  a  shrub  or 
climbing  plant  with  fragrant  white, 
pink,  or  yellow  flowers 

Balm,  n. 

1.  A  fragrant  ointment;  something 
soothing 

2.  A  tree  which  yields  a  fragrant, 
resinous  substance 


Discussion  Activities 

Hundreds  of  Dickinson's  poems  either  directly  or  indirectly  refer  to  God,  Jesus 
Christ,  the  crucifixion,  resurrection,  heaven,  or  hell.  In  "A  little  East  of  Jordan," 
Dickinson  responds  to  a  long-cherished  story  of  Jacob  as  recorded  in  Genesis 
32:24-32.  One  night  when  Jacob  is  alone,  a  man — thought  to  be  an  angel — 
wrestles  with  him  until  dawn.  The  unknown  man  injures  Jacob's  hip  in  the  fight, 
but  Jacob  refuses  to  let  him  go  and  demands  a  blessing.  To  his  surprise,  Jacob 
then  realizes  he  has  wrestled  with  God. 

Break  up  your  class  into  four  groups,  asking  each  to  read  the  original  Old 
Testament  story.  Then  read  "A  little  East  of  Jordan"  out  loud.  Ask  each  group 
to  go  through  the  entire  poem,  noticing  each  allusion.  Then  ask  each  group  to 
report  its  discoveries  to  the  class.  In  light  of  these  literary  allusions,  what  is  the 
significance  of  the  poem's  final  stanza?  Might  Emily  Dickinson  have  felt  that  she,  at 
times,  was  wrestling  with  God?  What  might  she  mean  when  she  says  Jacob  "had 
worsted  God"?  Explain. 


Writing  Exercise 


Ask  students  to  write  a  two-paragraph  interpretation  of  "Come  slowly  -  Eden!' 
How  does  Dickinson  portray  Eden?  How  does  the  poem's  treatment  of  Eden 
differ  from  the  Old  Testament  view  of  paradise? 


Ul  Homework 


Read  "Now  I  knew  I  lost  her  -  ,"  "Wild  nights  -  Wild  nights!,"  and  "You  left  me 
-  Sire  -  two  Legacies."  Then  read  Handout  Two:  Wild  Legacies,  and  the  Reader's 
Guide  essay  "The  Homestead  and  The  Evergreens"  (p.  7). 


10  *  THE  BIG  READ  National  Endowment  for  the  Arts 


FOCUS: 

Analyzing 
a  Poem's 
Context 


VOCABULARY  WORDS 

From  "Now  I  kneiv  I  lost  her  —  " 

Transmigration,  n. 

The  passage  of  a  soul  into  another 
body  after  death 

Penury,  n. 

Destitution,  poverty 

Restitution,  n. 

Restoration  to  a  former  or 
original  state 


From  "Wild  nights 
Wild  nights!  " 


Moor,  v.  it. 

To  attach  (a  boat  or  buoy)  by  cable 

or  rope  to  a  fixed  object 


Hundreds  of  Emily  Dickinsons  poems  deal  with  love  and  loss,  denial  and 
desire.  Scholar  Judith  Farr  identifies  two  thematic  "cycles"  in  the  poems  as 
the  "Sue  cycle"  and  the  "Master  cycle." 

Emily  Dickinson  had  several  long  and  passionate  loves.  As  a  teenager,  she 
deeply  loved  her  friend  Susan  (Sue)  Huntington  Gilbert,  who  later  became 
her  sister-in-law  when  Gilbert  married  Austin  Dickinson.  After  their 
July  1,  1856,  wedding,  Austin  and  Sue  moved  into  The  Evergreens,  the 
house  next  door  to  the  Homestead,  the  Dickinson  family  home.  Their 
lifelong  friendship  was  emotional  and  volatile;  to  Emily  it  was  an  "endless 
fire"  that  complicated  both  their  lives  due  to  their  proximity.  Sue  is  the 
"beloved  woman"  mentioned  in  many  poems  who  taught  Dickinson  joy 
and  renunciation. 

In  the  1860s,  another  prominent  name — "Master" — often  appears  in 
Dickinsons  poetry.  "His"  exact  Identity  remains  debated;  some  believe 
"Master"  is  God,  or  even  Sue.  (Three  enigmatic  letters  were  found  after 
Dickinsons  death.  However,  no  one  knows  to  whom  they  were  addressed,  or 
whether  they  were  ever  sent.)  Sue  once  wrote  a  letter  wherein  she  revealed  that 
she  had  seen  Dickinson  "reclining  in  the  arms  of  a  man"  in  her  drawing  room. 
It  is  often  assumed  this  man  was  Judge  Otis  Phillips  lord,  who  proposed 
marriage  to  Dickinson  when  she  was  in  her  fifties.  Although  she  loved  him, 
Dickinson  refused.  Before  Judge  Lord  was  her  suitor,  Dickinson  loved  Samuel 
Bowles,  a  married  man  and  close  friend  of  Austin  a\k\  Sue.  Some  scholars 
believe  that  "Master"  was  Bowles,  evidenced  by  the  poetry  that  she  seni  do 
him  such  as  "Title  divine  -  is  mine!  /  The  Wife     without  the  Sign! 


Discussion  Activities 

Read  "Now  I  knew  I  lost  her  -,"  a  poem  that  laments  lost  love  despite  physical 
proximity.  List  all  the  words  in  the  poem  connected  to  time  or  travel.  How  does 
the  speaker's  love  defy  time  and  distance?  How  does  the  beloved  seem  to  respond 
to  this  love?  First  discuss  the  literal  references  in  this  poem,  and  then  move  to  the 
symbolic.  Does  understanding  the  poem  require  knowledge  of  its  context' 


^  Writing  Exercise 


Have  students  write  about  the  figurative  language  used  in  two  of  Dickinson's  love 
poems:  "Wild  nights  -  Wild  nights!"  and  "You  left  me  -  Sire  -  two  Legacies" 
Does  the  imagery  of  these  poems  suggest  that  Dickinson  wrote  them  to  Susan 
Gilbert  Dickinson.  Samuel  Bowles,  or  someone  else'  Does  it  matter  if  the  ob|ect 
of  the  poem  is  identified? 


r]  Homework 


Read  "This  World  is  not  conclusion,"  "I  know  that  He  exists."  and  "Forever  -  is 
composed  of  Nows  -."  Then  read  Handout  Three:  Dickinson's  Final  Sorrows. 


National  Endowment  tor  tin-  \n-> 


THE  BIG  READ  ■    I  I 


Lesson  Nine 


FOCUS: 

Poetry 
and  Ideas 


VOCABULARY  WORDS 

From  "This  World  is  not 
conclusion" 

Sagacity,  n. 

The  quality  of  being  discerning; 
sound  in  judgment 

Contempt,  n. 

The  feeling  that  someone  or 
something  is  worthless  or  beneath 
consideration 


"No  man  was  ever  yet  a  great  poet,"  said  Samuel  Taylor  Coleridge,  "without 
being  at  the  same  time  a  profound  philosopher.  For  poetry  is  the  blossom 
and  fragrancy  of  all  human  knowledge,  human  thoughts,  human  passions, 
emotions,  language."  Exceptional  poets  can  pursue  their  craft  without 
aspiring  to  greatness,  as  Coleridge  defines  it  here,  but  the  greatest  poets 
through  the  ages  are  distinguished  by  their  willingness  to  confront  life's 
biggest  questions:  Does  God  (or  do  the  gods)  exist?  What  is  the  purpose  of 
life?  What  happens  when  we  die? 

Discussion  Activities 

Dickinson's  belief  in  the  promise  of  eternal  life  sustained  her  through  many 
sorrows,  illnesses,  and  losses.  The  Christian  doctrine  of  the  resurrection  and  the 
belief  that  the  body  and  soul  will  be  united  after  death  were  especially  precious 
to  her.  What  evidence  of  this  do  you  see  in  such  poems  as  "This  World  is  not 
conclusion"  or  "I  know  that  He  exists"?  Use  Handout  Three:  Dickinson's  Final 
Sorrows  to  guide  students'  interpretations  of  Dickinson's  "flood  subject" — 
immortality. 

How  might  these  two  poems  shed  light  on  the  following  sentence,  which 
Dickinson  wrote  to  Higginson  on  April  25,  1862:  "[My  family]  are  religious 
-  except  me  -  and  address  an  Eclipse,  every  morning  -  whom  they  call  their 
'Father.'" 

How  does  her  poem  "Forever  -  is  composed  of  Nows  -"  reflect  on  both  life's 
trials  and  joys?  Remember  that  despite  all  her  pain,  she  told  Higginson:  "I  find 
ecstasy  in  living  -  the  mere  sense  of  living  is  joy  enough." 


Wa  Writing  Exercise 


Vane,  n. 

A  blade,  plate,  sail,  etc.,  as  in  the 
wheel  of  a  windmill,  to  be  moved 
by  the  air 


The  poem  "This  World  is  not  conclusion"  asserts  that  "Faith  slips  -  and  laughs, 
and  rallies  -,"  suggesting  that  faith  may  have  more  in  common  with  the  rising 
and  falling  tide  than  with  a  rock  or  fortress.  Ask  students  to  write  a  one-page 
response  that  considers  how  understanding  faith,  doubt,  or  religious  conviction 
furthers  an  understanding  of  Dickinson's  poetry.  Ask  students  to  return  to  at 
least  one  poem  from  a  previous  lesson  that  includes  this  theme. 


EJ  Homework 


Have  students  choose  from  the  essay  topics  suggested  on  page  14.  Ask  them  to 
come  to  the  next  class  with  a  draft  of  the  essay. 


I  2  *  THE  BIG  READ  National  Endowment  for  the  Arts 


Lesson  Ten 


FOCUS: 

What  Makes 
a  Poet  Great? 


Poets  articulate  and  explore  the  mysteries  of  our  daily  lives  in  the  larger 
context  of  the  human  struggle.  The  writer  s  voice,  style,  and  use  of 
figurative  language  inform  the  themes  and  characters  of  the  work.  A  great 
poem  is  a  work  of  art  that  affects  many  generations  of  readers,  changes 
lives,  challenges  assumptions,  and  breaks  new  ground. 

If  one  mark  of  a  great  writer's  work  is  that  it  moves  us  to  return  to  it  again 
and  again — whether  for  enchantment,  wisdom,  or  consolation — then 
Emily  Dickinson  is  surely  one  of  our  greatest  writers.  In  her  verse,  we 
experience  the  "Transport"  or  pleasurable  excitement  that  she  herself  looked 
for  in  poetry:  "If  I  read  a  book  and  it  makes  my  whole  body  so  cold  no  fire 
can  warm  me  I  know  that  is  poetry.  If  I  feel  physically  as  if  the  top  of  mv 
head  were  taken  off,  I  know  that  is  poetry.  These  are  the  onlv  ways  I  know 
it.  Is  there  any  other  way[?]' 


VOCABULARY  WORDS 

From  "The  Poets  light  but 
Lamps  —  " 

Vital,  adj. 
Indispensable;  essential 

Inhere,  v. 

To  be  fixed  or  permanently 
incorporated  within  something 

Disseminate,  v. 

To  spread  widely 

Circumference,  n. 

The  outer  boundary,  especially  of  a 
circular  area 


Discussion  Activities 

Guide  your  students  in  a  close  reading  of  "The  Poets  light  but  Lamps  -." 
This  short  poem  contains  a  metaphor  so  complex  that  it  may  inspire  several 
interpretations.  Have  your  class  consider  the  various  symbolic  meanings  of 
objects  such  as  the  lamp,  the  wick,  the  light,  and  the  sun.  Does  everyone  have 
the  same  interpretation  of  the  symbols  and  the  poetic  metaphor? 

How  does  Dickinson  use  the  word  "Circumference"  to  represent  both  a  literal 
circle  of  light  that  surrounds  the  lamp  stand  and  the  power  of  great  poetry  that 
shines  out  to  others  over  centuries?  What  is  she  saying  about  the  eternal  nature 
of  great  poetry? 

Ask  students  to  list  the  characteristics  of  a  great  poet.  Put  these  on  the  board. 
What  elevates  their  poems  to  greatness?  Have  students  discuss,  within  groups, 
other  poems  or  songs  they  know  that  include  some  of  the  same  characteristics. 
Do  any  of  these  works  remind  them  of  Dickinson's  poems? 


y  Writing  Exercise 

Ask  students  to  write  a  one-page  essay  on  their  favorite  Dickinson  poem. 


23  Homework 


Students  should  continue  working  on  their  essays.  Final  drafts  are  due  during  the 
next  class. 


National  Endowment  tor  the  \m  the  big  read  •  I  3 


The  writing  exercises  in  this  guide  provide  you  with  possible  essay  topics,  as  do  the  discussion 
questions  in  the  Reader's  Guide.  Advanced  students  can  come  up  with  their  own  essay  topics,  as 
long  as  they  are  interesting  and  specific.  Other  ideas  for  essays  are  provided  below. 

For  essays,  students  should  organize  their  ideas  around  a  thesis — that  is,  an  argument  or 
interpretation — about  the  poem  or  poems  in  question.  This  statement  or  thesis  should  be  focused, 
with  clear  reasons  to  support  its  conclusion.  The  thesis  and  evidence  should  be  supported  by 
references  to  the  text. 


1 .  Choose  two  poems  in  which  Emily  Dickinson 
looks  closely  at  the  natural  world.  Research 
her  references  to  botany  and  biology,  providing 
your  own  interpretation  as  a  result  of  this 
knowledge. 

2.  The  popularity  of  poems  such  as  "I  felt  a 
Funeral  in  my  Brain"  or  "After  great  pain,  a 
formal  feeling  comes  -"  have  led  some  readers 
to  characterize  Dickinson  as  a  morbid  poet 
Does  she  deserve  this  reputation?  Why,  or 
why  not?  How  might  the  many  deaths  and 
losses  she  endured  have  affected  her  poetry? 

3.  Give  a  historical  reading  of  Dickinson's  poem 
"Some  keep  the  Sabbath  going  to  Church" 
by  finding  out  about  the  importance  of  the 
Sabbath  day  to  nineteenth-century  Christians. 
Research  the  Second  Great  Awakening  to 
provide  context  for  this  semi-autobiographical 
poem. 


Read  the  poetry  of  some  of  Dickinson's 
contemporaries,  such  as  American  poets  Edgar 
Allan  Poe,  Henry  Wadsworth  Longfellow,  and 
Walt  Whitman  or  English  poets  Alfred,  Lord 
Tennyson,  Christina  Rossetti,  or  Elizabeth 
Barrett  Browning.  Choose  one  poet  and 
examine  his  or  her  style  and  themes.  How  is 
Dickinson  like  this  poet?  How  is  she  different? 

Listen  to  Aaron  Copland's  musical  treatment 
of  several  Dickinson  poems  including  "Because 
I  could  not  stop  for  Death  -."  Dickinson  loved 
music  and  was  a  reasonably  accomplished 
pianist  In  what  ways  can  Dickinson  be 
considered  a  musical  poet?  What  poetic 
devices  does  she  use  to  bring  musicality  to  her 
poetry? 


I  4  •  THE  BIG  READ  National  Endowment  for  the  Arts 


A  glossary  of  some  of  the  poetic  terms  used  in  the  lessons  is  listed  below.' 


Allusion:  A  brief,  sometimes  indirect  reference  in  a 
text  to  a  person,  place,  or  thing. 

Biographical  criticism:  The  practice  of  analyzing  a 
literary  work  by  using  knowledge  of  the  author's 
life  to  gain  insight. 

Diction:  Word  choice  or  vocabulary  in  a  particular 
work. 

Fixed  form:  Traditional  verse  forms  that  require 
certain  predetermined  structural  elements  of 
meter,  rhythm,  and  rhyme,  such  as  sonnets  or 
ballads. 

Foot:  The  basic  unit  of  measurement  in  poetry. 
Different  meters  are  identified  by  the  pattern 
and  order  of  stressed  and  unstressed  syllables  in 
its  metrical  feet.  A  foot  is  usually  two  or  three 
syllables,  depending  on  the  meter. 

Free  verse:  From  the  French  vers  libre,  free  verse 
describes  poetry  that  organizes  its  lines  without 
meter.  It  is  not  usually  rhymed. 

Historical  criticism:  The  practice  of  analyzing  a 
literary  work  by  investigating  the  social,  cultural, 
and  intellectual  context  around  it. 

Meter.  A  systematic,  rhythmic  pattern  of  stresses 
in  verse. 

Paradox:  A  statement  that  at  first  seems 
contradictory,  but  on  reflection  reveals  some 
deeper  sense. 

Persona:  The  Latin  word  for  "mask."  A  fictitious 
speaker  created  by  the  poet. 


Rhyme  scheme:  The  pattern  of  rhyme  in  an 
individual  poem  or  a  fixed  form.  A  rhyme 
scheme  is  transcribed  with  lower-case  letters 
representing  each  end  rhyme — a  for  the  first 
rhyme,  b  for  the  second,  and  so  on. 

Rhythm:  The  pattern  of  stresses  and  pauses  in  a 
poem. 

Scansion:  A  method  of  notation  that  measures 
rhythms  in  a  poem.  Scansion  separates  the 
metrical  feet,  counts  the  syllables,  marks  the 
accented  ones,  and  indicates  the  pauses.  Scansion 
helps  the  reader  understand  a  poet's  choice  of 
rhythm,  verse  length,  and  sound. 

Stanza:  A  unit  of  two  or  more  lines  of  verse 
with  space  breaks  before  and  after.  The  stanza  is 
poetry's  equivalent  to  a  paragraph  in  prose. 

Stress  (or  accent):  A  greater  amount  of  force 
given  to  one  syllable  in  speaking  than  is  given  to 
another. 

Theme:  The  central  thought  or  idea  of  the  poem. 
Short  poems  might  have  only  a  single  theme 
while  longer,  complex  works  can  contain  multiple 
themes. 


All  literary  definitions,  both  here  and  in  the  lessons,  are  taken  from  An  Introduction  to  Poetry  1 1  Ith  edition t.  edited  by  X  J   Kennedy  and 
Dana  Gioia.  or  Handbook  of  Literary  Terms,  edited  by  X  J   Kennedy.  Dana  doia.  and  Mark  BaueHem  (2005) 


National  Endowment  ror  tin 


THE  BIG  READ  *    I  5 


HANDOUT  ONE 


Emily  Dickinson  and  the  Victorian 
"Woman  Question" 


When  Mary  Wollstonecraft  published  A 
Vindication  of  the  Rights  of  Women  in  1792, 
women  were  still  confined  by  law  and  custom 
to  the  domestic,  "private"  sphere,  in  contrast  to 
the  professional,  "public"  sphere  of  men.  By  the 
time  Queen  Victoria  took  the  throne  of  England 
in  1837,  this  so-called  "woman  question" — what 
is  a  woman's  proper  place  in  society? — was 
hotly  debated  by  many  politicians,  theologians, 
educators,  and  writers. 

A  king  in  Alfred,  Lord  Tennyson's  poem  "The 
Princess"  (1847)  succinctly  summarizes  the 
viewpoint  of  many  Victorians:  "Man  for  the  field 
and  woman  for  the  hearth:  /  Man  for  the  sword 
and  for  the  needle  she;  /  Man  with  the  head  and 
woman  with  the  heart,  /  Man  to  command  and 
woman  to  obey."  Yet  women  were  denied  basic 
liberties  even  in  the  domestic  sphere.  For  example, 
women  had  no  legal  rights  to  their  own  children 
until  1839  when  Parliament  passed  the  Custody 
of  Infants  Act,  allowing  a  divorced  mother  to 
obtain  custody.  It  took  until  1882  for  the  Married 
Women's  Property  Act  to  pass,  giving  women  the 
right  to  keep  pre-existing  land  and  money  in  their 
own  names. 

Throughout  the  nineteenth  century,  the  proper 
education  for  women  in  England  and  America 
comprised  music,  languages,  art,  and  needlework. 
An  important  milestone  came  in  1837  when 
Mount  Holyoke  College  was  founded  in  South 
Hadley,  Massachusetts,  and  the  school's  principal, 
Mary  Lyon,  decided  to  teach  her  female  students 
traditionally  "masculine"  subjects  such  as 
mathematics,  botany,  theology,  rhetoric,  logic, 
chemistry,  and  astronomy.  This  pioneering 


opportunity  in  women's  education  enabled 
Emily  Dickinson  to  receive  a  uniquely  privileged 
education.  This  successful  "experiment"  also  led 
several  universities  to  open  their  doors  to  women 
or  create  colleges  especially  for  them,  although 
women  sometimes  could  not  earn  formal  degrees. 

The  "woman  question"  was  especially  pointed  in 
literary  circles,  where  women  remained  subordinate 
in  the  mid-nineteenth  century.  In  England, 
writers  Charlotte  Bronte  and  Mary  Ann  Evans 
used  pen  names — Currer  Bell  and  George  Eliot, 
respectively — to  avoid  public  censure  for  the 
radical  ideas  and  passionate  heroines  described  in 
their  novels,  especially  Jane  Eyre  (1847)  and  The 
Mill  on  the  Floss  (1860).  Greater  barriers  existed  for 
female  poets,  since  the  genre  of  poetry  traditionally 
belonged  to  men.  A  notable  exception  to  Victorian 
prejudice  against  women  writers  was  Elizabeth 
Barrett  Browning,  whose  life  and  poetry  deeply 
influenced  Dickinson.  In  Barrett  Browning's 
radical  verse-novel,  Aurora  Leigh  (1857),  the  poet- 
heroine  refuses  to  renounce  her  artistic  ambition, 
when  the  man  she  loves  expects  her  to  give  up  her 
writing  to  become  his  helpmeet. 

In  America,  it  was  even  harder  for  women  writers 
to  publish  and  succeed.  The  young  United 
States  was  slower  to  address  women's  rights  than 
England.  In  an  age  that  looked  down  upon  women 
"scribblers,"  and  as  the  daughter  of  parents  who 
did  not  fully  understand  her  intellectual  pursuits, 
Dickinson  may  have  composed  such  poems  as  "I 
dwell  in  Possibility  -"  and  "They  shut  me  up  in 
Prose" — both  written  in  1862 — to  express  her  own 
frustration. 


I  6  *  THE  BIG  READ  National  Endowment  for  the  Arts 


HANDOUT  TWO 


Wild  Legacies 

by  Diane  Thiel 

Dickinson's  love  poems  are  not  the  ones  most  often 
chosen  to  represent  her,  but  they  reveal  complex 
aspects  to  her  work.  Much  speculation  exists  about 
whether  an  actual  relationship  inspired  these 
poems.  While  biographical  matters  are  always 
interesting,  it  is  even  more  important  to  recognize 
a  writer's  life  of  the  mind,  for  the  work  of  a  writer 
often  addresses  aspects  of  a  life  that  has  been 
imagined  or  a  life  re-invented.  The  poems  "Wild 
nights  -  Wild  nights!"  and  "You  left  me  -  Sire  - 
two  Legacies  -"  are  both  seemingly  simple  poems, 
emblematic  of  Dickinson's  compressed  style,  each 
offering  a  compelling  example  of  Dickinsons  love 
poetry  with  their  expressions  of  deep")  longing  and 
the  "Boundaries  of  Pain"  that  accompany  loss  or 
un  fulfillment. 

"Wild  nights  -  Wild  nights!"  is  a  love  poem  of 
intense  longing.  Perhaps  the  most  evocative  aspect 
of  the  poem  is  the  way  the  speaker  yearns  for  the 
wild  experience  of  love  and  passion.  The  poem 
might  be  read  as  the  expression  of  longing  for  a  low- 
that  can  bring  the  speaker's  "Heart  in  port."  Yet, 
the  words  also  reveal  the  craving  for  wild  abandon 
or    luxury. 

The  poem's  final  lines  encourage  one  to  read  and 
re-read  the  poem.  The  final  word  "thee"  invites 
multiple  interpretations.  Is  "thee"  the  apparent 
beloved  ill  the  poem,  or  is  she  addressing  the  sea? 
K  the  speaker  asking  to  be  moored  in  the  sc.i?  It 
seems  .is  it  the  speaker,  drawn  to  the  wild  nature 
of  the  Sea  and  the  beloved,  wants  to  be  "mooted 
in  this  wildness.   The  poem  has  .in  overtly  erotic 
quality,  from  the  desire  tor  "wild  nights"  in  the  fust 
line  to  the  wish  to  "moor      tonight  /  In  thee!    in 
the  List. 


These  layered  possibilities  occur  in  much  of 
Dickinson's  poetry,  and  take  the  reader  of  even  a 
short  poem  through  often  unexpected  turns.  "You 
left  me  -  Sire  -  two  Legacies  -    portrays,  in  a  few 
lines,  the  legacies  of  loving  someone,  describing 
the  intensity  of  feeling  that  can  barely  be  captured 
in  words.  But  when  intense  love  ends,  whether  by 
death  or  separation,  another  legacy  remains. 

I  he  language  in  "You  left  me  -  Sire  -  two 
Legacies  -"  is  simple  but  abstract,  but  the  intensity 
is  both  deeply  personal  and  universal.  While  the 
poem  seems  to  speak  about  a  romantic  affair. 
it  could  also  be  interpreted  as  referring  to  any 
relationship  that  has  left  the  legacies  of  love  and 
loss.   The  intensity  of  such  a  love  is  summed  up 
emphatically  in  the  first  stanza,  a  devotion  that 
would  "suffice"  even  .1  "1  leavenry  lather.    I  he- 
second  stan/a  speaks  to  the  nearly  inevitable  loss 
that  follows.  As  in  "Wild  nights     Wild  nights!, 
Dickinson  also  evokes  the  sea  in  this  poem.  While 
"Wild  nights  -  Wild  nights!    seems  to  cast  the 
sea  as  wild  and  erotic.  "Vbu  left  me  -  Sire  -  two 
I  egacies       emphasizes  the  vast  nature  of  the  sea 
and  connects  it  to  the  incalculable  pain  that  such 
,1  loss  of  love  leaves  behind.  I  he  final  lines  ol  this 
poem  also  otter  multiple  meanings,  .is  one  might 
understand  the  sc.i  to  lx-  the  divide  thai  now  cv 
between  the  two. 

Dickinsons  ability  to  capture  such  mtensitx 

emotion  is  emblematic  ol  her  spare,  oompi 
highly  charged  style  I  hese  short  poems  highlight 
Dickinson  .is  .1  poet  who  wnu  itiveh  about 

love.  In  |ust  .1  tew  words  and  lines,  she  traverses  the 
scope  ot  longing,  realization  of  love,  and  the  lay* 
leg.u  ies  it  lean  1 


National  Endowment  for  th.  the  big  read  •  17 


HANDOUT  THREE 


Dickinson's  Final  Sorrows 


In  a  letter  of  1883,  Emily  Dickinson  declared  that 
"The  Crisis  of  the  sorrow  of  so  many  years  is  all 
that  tires  me."  Later  she  cited  a  line  from  one  of  her 
favorite  poems:  "As  Emily  Bronte  to  her  Maker,  I 
write  to  my  Lost  'Every  Existence  would  exist  in 
thee  -  V'1 

The  darkest  season  of  Dickinson's  life  began 
after  her  mother's  death  in  1882,  followed  by  the 
death  of  her  eight-year-old  nephew  Gilbert  from 
typhoid  fever  in  1883.  After  this,  she  wrote  to  his 
mother:  "I  see  him  in  the  Star,  and  meet  his  sweet 
velocity  in  everything  that  flies  —  His  Life  was 
like  the  Bugle,  which  winds  itself  away,  his  Elegy 
an  echo  -  his  Requiem  ecstasy  -."  Dickinson's 
posthumous  editor,  Thomas  H.  Johnson,  claimed 
that  "no  death  during  Emily  Dickinson's  lifetime 
more  deeply  shocked  and  grieved  her"  for  "with 
his  departure  went  a  certain  inner  light."  Her  final 
"poems"  more  closely  resemble  fragments,  although 
she  continued  faithfully  writing  letters  to  many 
family  members  and  close  friends. 

One  such  friend  who  sustained  her  toward  the 
end  of  her  life  was  Judge  Otis  Phillips  Lord,  who 
had  been  one  of  her  father's  closest  associates. 
He  pursued  a  romance  with  Dickinson  after  the 
death  of  his  wife.  Although  Dickinson  loved  him, 
she  refused  his  marriage  proposal.  Lord's  death 
from  a  stroke,  only  six  months  after  Gilbert's,  led 
Dickinson  to  write  the  following  short  fragment: 

Each  that  we  lose  takes  part  of  us; 

A  crescent  still  abides, 

Which  like  the  moon,  some  turbid  night, 

Is  summoned  by  the  tides. 

1   "Every  Existence  would  exist  in  thee"  is  a  line  from  Emily  Bronte's  poem  "No  coward  soul  is  mine." 

This  Dickinson  line  clearly  refers  to  a  line  in  the  New  Testament  epistle  of  First  Timothy:  "For  I  know  whom  I  have  believed,  and  am 
persuaded  that  he  is  able  to  keep  that  which  I  have  committed  unto  him  against  that  day"  (1:12). 


In  June  1884,  Dickinson  suffered  a  second 
"nervous  prostration"  and  never  fully  recovered. 
Intimations  of  immortality  haunted  Dickinson 
until  the  end,  and  from  her  earliest  poetry  to 
her  final  letters,  a  central  theme  emerges — what 
she  identified  as  her  "flood  subject":  immortality. 
In  a  letter  dated  November  19,  1884,  she  confessed 
that  "to  'know  in  whom'  we  'have  believed,' 
is  Immortality."2 

That  final  day  came  for  her  on  May  15,  1886. 
Despite  her  inability  to  "declare  for  Christ"  during 
her  year  at  Mount  Holyoke  Female  Seminary, 
despite  her  failure  to  "keep  the  Sabbath  going  to 
Church,"  Dickinson  wrestled  with  God  to  the 
end.  One  of  her  last  letters  to  Thomas  Wentworth 
Higginson  ended  with  a  citation  from  the  Genesis 
32  story  of  Jacob's  fight  with  the  Angel:  "  'I  will 
not  let  thee  go  except  I  bless  thee'  —  Pugilist  and 
Poet,  Jacob  was  correct  -."  This  was  a  story  she 
had  dramatized  earlier  in  the  poem  "A  little  East 
of  Jordan."  Dickinson's  faith  conformed  neither 
to  Calvinist  orthodoxies  nor  to  the  fashions  of 
Amherst,  which  makes  Bronte's  poem — which 
Higginson  read  at  Dickinson's  funeral — even 
more  poignant: 

No  coward  soul  is  mine 

No  trembler  in  the  world's  storm-troubled  sphere 

I  see  Heaven's  glories  shine 

And  Faith  shines  equal  arming  me  from  Fear  . . . 


I  8  '  THE  BIG  READ  National  Endowment  for  the  Arts 


The  Poetry  of  Emily  Dickinson 


Biographies  and  Literary  Criticism 


Collected  Poetry 

The  three-volume  Variorum  Edition  of  The  Poems  of  Emily 
Dickinson,  edited  by  R.  W.  Franklin  (Cambridge,  MA: 
The  Belknap  Press  of  Harvard  University,  1998),  is  the 
most  reliable  edition  of  Dickinson's  collected  poems.  The 
paperback  "Reading  Edition"  of  this  collection  is  suggested 
for  teachers,  librarians,  and  the  general  reader  (Cambridge, 
MA:  Harvard  University  Press,  2005). 

Selected  Poetry 

Recommended  editions  include  Final  Harvest,  edited  by 
Thomas  H.  Johnson  (New  York:  Back  Bay  Books,  1964); 
The  Selected  Poems  of  Emily  Dickinson  (New  York:  Modern 
Library,  2004),  which  includes  an  introduction  by  Billy 
Collins;  and  Essential  Dickinson  (New  York:  Ecco,  1 996), 
which  includes  an  introduction  by  Joyce  Carol  Oates. 

Most  poems  used  in  this  guide  are  on  the  Poetry 
Foundation's  Poetry  Tool:  www.poetryfoundation.org. 
A  biography  and  bibliography  are  also  available  there. 


Farr,  Judith,  with  Louise  Carter.  The  Gardens  of  Emily 
Dickinson.  Cambridge,  MA:  Harvard  University  Press.  2004. 

Farr,  Judith.  The  Passion  of  Emily  Dickinson.  Cambridge.  MA 
Harvard  University  Press,  1 992. 

Habegger,  Alfred.  My  Wars  Are  Laid  Away  in  Books:  The  Life 
of  Emily  Dickinson.  New  York:  Modern  Library,  2001. 

Longsworth,  Polly.  The  World  of  Emily  Dickinson:  A  Visual 
Biography.  New  York:  Norton,  1 990. 

Lundin,  Roger.  Emily  Dickinson  and  the  Art  of  Belief  Grand 
Rapids,  Ml:  Eerdmans,  1998. 

Martin,  Wendy,  ed.  The  Cambndge  Companion  to  Emily 
Dickinson.  Cambridge:  Cambridge  University  Press,  2002. 

Pollak,  Vivian  R.  A  Histoncal  Guide  to  Emily  D<kmson.  Oxford: 
Oxford  University  Press.  2004. 

Sewall,  Richard  B.  The  Ufe  of  Emily  Dickinson  Cambndge. 
MA:  Harvard  University  Press.  1998  (Originally  published 
by  Farrar,  Straus  &  Giroux  in  1974) 


Emily  Dickinson's  Letters 

Johnson,  Thomas  H.,  ed.  Emily  Dickinson:  Selected  Letters. 
1 958.  Cambridge,  MA:  The  Belknap  Press  of  Harvard 
University  Press,  1986. 


Music 

Copland.  Aaron.  Ejgin  Poems  of  Emily  Dickinson  for  Voce  and 
Oiamber  Orchestra.  New  York:  Boosey  and  Hawkes.  1 970 


Play 

Luce.  William  The  BeOe  of  Amherst  A  Play  based  on  the  Ufe  of 
Emily  Dickinson  Boston  Houghton  Mifflin.  1976 


National  1  ndowmeni  t<u  the-  \us 


THE  BIG  READ  •    I  9 


National  Council  of  Teachers  of  English  (NCTE)  Standards' 


1 .  Students  read  a  wide  range  of  print  and 
non-print  texts  to  build  an  understanding  of 
texts,  of  themselves,  and  of  the  cultures  of 
the  United  States  and  the  world;  to  acquire 
new  information;  to  respond  to  the  needs 
and  demands  of  society  and  the  workplace; 
and  for  personal  fulfillment.  Among  these 
texts  are  fiction  and  nonfiction,  classic  and 
contemporary  works. 

2.  Students  read  a  wide  range  of  literature  from 
many  periods  in  many  genres  to  build  an 
understanding  of  the  many  dimensions  (e.g., 
philosophical,  ethical,  aesthetic)  of  human 
experience. 

3.  Students  apply  a  wide  range  of  strategies 
to  comprehend,  interpret,  evaluate,  and 
appreciate  texts.  They  draw  on  their  prior 
experience,  their  interactions  with  other 
readers  and  writers,  their  knowledge  of 
word  meaning  and  of  other  texts,  their 
word  identification  strategies,  and  their 
understanding  of  textual  features  (e.g.,  sound- 
letter  correspondence,  sentence  structure, 
context,  graphics). 

4.  Students  adjust  their  use  of  spoken,  written, 
and  visual  language  (e.g.,  conventions,  style, 
vocabulary)  to  communicate  effectively  with  a 
variety  of  audiences  and  for  different  purposes. 

5.  Students  employ  a  wide  range  of  strategies  as 
they  write  and  use  different  writing  process 
elements  appropriately  to  communicate  with 
different  audiences  for  a  variety  of  purposes. 


6.  Students  apply  knowledge  of  language 
structure,  language  conventions  (e.g.,  spelling 
and  punctuation),  media  techniques,  figurative 
language,  and  genre  to  create,  critique,  and 
discuss  print  and  non-print  texts. 

7.  Students  conduct  research  on  issues  and 
interests  by  generating  ideas  and  questions,  and 
by  posing  problems.  They  gather,  evaluate,  and 
synthesize  data  from  a  variety  of  sources  (e.g., 
print  and  non-print  texts,  artifacts,  people)  to 
communicate  their  discoveries  in  ways  that  suit 
their  purpose  and  audience. 

8.  Students  use  a  variety  of  technological  and 
information  resources  (e.g.,  libraries,  databases, 
computer  networks,  video)  to  gather  and 
synthesize  information  and  to  create  and 
communicate  knowledge. 

9.  Students  develop  an  understanding  of  and 
respect  for  diversity  in  language  use,  patterns, 
and  dialects  across  cultures,  ethnic  groups, 
geographic  regions,  and  social  roles. 

10.  Students  whose  first  language  is  not  English 
make  use  of  their  first  language  to  develop 
competency  in  the  English  language  arts  and  to 
develop  understanding  of  content  across  the 
curriculum. 

1 1 .  Students  participate  as  knowledgeable, 
reflective,  creative,  and  critical  members  of  a 
variety  of  literacy  communities. 

12.  Students  use  spoken,  written,  and  visual 
language  to  accomplish  their  own  purposes 
(e.g.,  for  learning,  enjoyment,  persuasion,  and 
the  exchange  of  information). 


*  This  guide  was  developed  with  NCTE  Standards  and  State  Language  Arts  Standards  in  mind.  Use  these  standards  to  guide  and  develop 
your  application  of  the  curriculum. 


20  *  THE  BIG  READ 


National  Endowment  for  the  Arts 


c 


I  find  ecstasy  in  living  —  the  mere 
sense  of  living  is  joy  enough." 

— EMILY  DICKINSON 

in  conversation  with,  and  recounted  by, 

Thomas  Wentworth  Higginson.  1870 


NATIONAL 
ENDOWMENT 
FOR  THE  ARTS 


There  is  no  Frigate  like  a  Book 

To  take  us  Lands  away 

Nor  any  Coursers  like  a  Page 

Of  prancing  Poetry  - 

This  Traverse  may  the  poorest  take 

Without  oppress  of  Toll  - 

How  frugal  is  the  Chariot 

That  bears  the  Human  Soul  -" 


-EMILY  DICKINSON 


The  Big  Read  is  an  initiative  of  the  National 
Endowment  for  the  Arts  designed  to  restore  reading 
to  the  center  of  American  culture.  The  NEA  presents 
The  Big  Read  in  partnership  with  the  Institute  of 
Museum  and  Library  Services  and  in  cooperation 
with  Arts  Midwest. 


A  great  nation  deserves  great  art. 


'•«•    .  -INSTITUTE  of  ., 

•;.'..  MuseurrUndLbrary 

JH  SERVICES