Skip to main content

Full text of "Publication"

See other formats


a«'i'  KJiMJj-: )  vi^  ■.-':;■;  i-' :  •'  !■ 


liiiiiiiiift 


f1  T  S  U    LIBRART 


00527   702^ 


Digitized  by  the  Internet  Archive 

in  2010  with  funding  from 

Lyrasis  IVIembers  and  Sloan  Foundation 


http://www.archive.org/details/publication09ruth 


S3.50    The  Copy 


Rutherford  County 
Historical  Society 


PUBLICATION   N0.9 


976.857 

R93lp 

V.9 


Dr.  James  M.  Dill 


S 


ummer 


1977 


MURFREESBORO,  TENNESSEE  37130 


Rutherford  County  Historical  Society 
Publication  No.  9 

THE  COVER 

Dr.  James  Madison  Dill  (1831-1916)  a  native  of  Rutherford  County, 
for  whom  the  community  of  Dilton  was  named,  is  featured  on  the  cover 
of  this  publication.   His  parents  were  Isaac  and  Gilley  Cooper  Dill 
who  were  natives  of  South  Carolina.   The  old  country  doctor,  a  highly 
respected  member  of  the  community,  was  buried  in  the  Harrell  Cemetery 
at  Dilton. 

Rebecca  L.  Smith  is  the  author  of  this  very  fine  history  of  Dilton. 
The  Rutherford  County  Historical  Society  is  proud  to  publish  this 
history  which  Miss  Smith  has  prepared. 

Thanks  to  Rutherford  County  Judge  Ben  Hall  McFarlin  and  Mrs.  Susan  R. 
Jones  for  their  assistance  in  publishing  this  book. 

Murfreesboro,  Tennessee 
1977 


RUTHERFORD  COUNTY  HISTORICAL  SOCIETY 
PUBLICATION  NO,   9 
Published  by  the 
RUTHERFORD    COUNTY  HISTORICAL  SOCIETY 


OFFICERS 


President ...» ...,<.,,,,,..,.,,...»... .  Dr.  Robert  B,  Jones  m 

Vice-President. Dr.  Homer  Pittard 

Recording  Secretary Miss  Louise  Cawthon 

Corresponding    Secretary  and  Treasurer. Mrs.  Dorothy  Ma  heny 

Publication  Secretary Mr.  Walter  K.  Hoover 

Directors ..,,.......,..,....  Mr.  Ernest  K.  Johns 

Miss  Mary  Hall 
Mr,  Robert  Ragland 

Publication  No.  9  (Limited  Edition-350copies)   is  distributed  to  mem- 
bers of  the  Society.    The  annual  membership  dues  is  $5.  00  (Family-$7„  00) 
which  includes  the  regular  publications  and  the  monthly  NEWSLETTER  to 
all  members.    Additional  copies  of  Publication  No.  9  may  be  obtained  at 
$3.  50  per  copy. 

All  correspondence  concerning  additional  copies,  contributions  to 
future  issues,  and  membership  should  be  addressed  to. 

Rutherford  County  Historical  Society 

Box  906 

Murfreesboro,  TN     37130 


FOR  SALE 

THE  FOLLOWING  PUBLICATIONS  ARE  FOR  SALE  BY  THE  RUTHERFORD  COUNTY  HISTORICAL 
SOCIETY,  Box  906,  Murfreesboro,  Tennessee,  37130; 

Publication  #  1,  2,  4:  Out  of  Print. 

Publication  #  3:   Rutherford  Marriage  Records,  1857-59;  Pre-history  of 

Rutherford  Co.;  Gen.  Griffith  Rutherford;  1803  Petition  for  Formation 
of  County;  Militia  Commissions  1821-1830;  and  Rock  Springs  Church 
"istory.  $3.00  +  $.50  postage 

Publication  #  5:   Nashville  and  Chattanooga  Railroad;  Rutherford  Co.  Post 
Offices  and  Postmasters;  The  Rutherford  Rifles;  and  Hardemans  Mill. 

$3.00  +  postage 

Publication  #  6:   Link  Community;  History  of  LaVergne;  Fellowship  Community; 
and  the  Sanders  Family.  $3.00  +  $.50  postage 

Publication  #  7:   Hopewell  Church,  1816-1883;   Stones  River  Presbyterian  Church; 
Cripple  Creek  Presbyterian  Church;  Early  Militia  Order,  Petition  by 
Cornelius  Sanders  for  Rev.  War  Pension.   $3.00  +  $.50  postage 

Publication  #  8:   Bethel-Leanna  Community;  Crowders  of  Readyville;  View  of 
Stones  River  Battlefield  from  N.  Y.  Times,  Sept.  2,  1865;  Record  of 
Jordan  Williford,  Rev.  Soldier;  Company  Roll  of  Hardy  Murfree,  Sept.  9, 
1?78.  $3.50  +  $.50  postage 

1840  Rutherford  Census;  With  index.      $5.00  +  $.50  postage 

Deed  Abstracts  of  Rutherford  County.  1803-1810.  Names  of  land  owners  and 

other  genealogical  information  from  early  deeds.   $10.00  +  $.50  postage 

Griffith:   A  beautifully  Illustrated  bi-centennial  publication.   60  pages. 

$2.00  +  $.50  postage 

AVAILABLE  FROM  WILLIAM  WALKUP,  202  RIDLEY  ST.,  SMYRNA,  TENNESSEE,  37167; 

Map  of  Rutherford  County  showing  roads,  streams,  and  land  owners,  dated  1878. 

$3.50  +  $.50  postage 

Cemetery  Records  published  jointly  with  the  Sons  of  the  American  Revolution: 
Vol.  1:  Northwest  portion  of  county  including  Percy  Priest  Lake  area 

and  parts  of  Wilson  and  Davidson  Counties,  256  cemeteries  with 

index  and  maps.  $10.00  +  $.50  postage 

Vol.  2:  Eastern  portion  of  Rutherford  Co.  and  the  western  part  of  Cannon 

Co.,  241  cemeteries  with  index  and  maps.  $10.00  +  $.50  postage 
Vol.  3:  Southwestern  portion  of  Rutherford  County,  193  cemeteries,  index 

and  maps.  $10.00  +  $.50  postage 


78-01915 


QUERIES 

Prepared  by  Mrs.  D.  C.  Daniel,  Jr. 

IMPORTANT:   Publication  of  queries  in  this  column  is  free  to  all  members 
as  space  permits.   Each  query  must  appear  on  a  full  sheet  of  paper  which 
must  be  dated  and  include  member's  name  and  address.   Please  type  if 
possible.   Queries  should  give  as  much  pertinent  data  as  possible,  i.e. 
approximate/actual  dates  of  birth,  marriage,  death,  etc.  Queries  must 
refer  to  RUTHERFORD  COUNTY,  TENNESSEE  FAMILIES  and  immediate  connections. 
Address  all  correspondence  relating  to  queries  to  the  Society,  P.  0. 
Box  906,  Murfreesboro,  Tenn.   37130. 

Deadline  Dates:   March  31  for  Summer  Publication  and  August  31  for 
Winter  Publication. 

No.  1  MORGAN -WINSTON:   Carey  Morgan  b.  VA.  CA  1776-80  (parents:  Elizabeth 
Clay  and  Joshua  Morgan,  m,  1817,  Ruth.  Co.,  Nancy  Winston  b.  1791). 
Is  1860  tombstone  in  old  Murfreesboro  Cemetery  for  Nancy  Morgan, 
wife  of  Gary,  hers?  Nancy  is  daughter  of  Nathaniel  Winston  per 
Ruth,  Co,  deeds  CA  1824.   Children:  John  m,  in  Denmark:  Robert  d. 
without  issue;   Samuel  m.  Ruth.  Co.  1860's,  Tabltha  Avent:   James  m. 
Rachel  Posey  (great-granddaughter  of  Gen,  John  Coffee's  sister): 
Elizabeth  m,  J.  C.  Wortham:   Mary  m.  Sam  Moore.   Compiling  Morgan 
family  tree,  especially  need  to  know  where  they  came  from  in  Virginia 
and  whether  they  settled  temporarily  somewhere  else  before  coming 
to  Ruth.  Co.  Mrs.  James  E.  Sraotherraan,  Route  1,  College  Grove, 
Tenn.,  37046. 

No.  2  WARREN-SOAPE/SWOPE/SOPE/SOAP/SWOAP:   Need  parents,  family  of 

Elizabeth  Warren  b.  8  April  1821  Cannon  Co.,  Tenn,,  d.  18  April 
1851,  Panala  Co.,  Tex.,  m.  7  Sept,  1840  Cannon  Co.,  Tenn., 
Absolom  Fowler  Soape,  son  of  James  Soape  &  Elizabeth  Fov^ler. 
Wants  to  correspond  with  any  person  interested  in  Soape  (&  various 
spellings)  family.   Eleda  Soape  Decherd,  5603  Green  Craig,  Houston, 
Tex.,  77035. 


A  member  of  our  society  is  a  genealogist:  Mrs,  Lalia  Lester 

1307  Wo  Korthfield  Blvd. 
Murfreesboro,  Tenn.   37130 
Tel.  (615)  896-9089 


INTRODUCTION 

This  history  represents  a  blend  of  anecdotal  information  with  infor- 
mation obtained  from  deeds,  wills,  tax  and  census  records,  newspapers, 
and  books.    Raymond  B.  Harrell  and  Jack  R.  Mankin  made  their  manu- 
scripts available  as  source  material.    Oral  information  was  provided  by 
several  men  and  women  who  either  live  now  or  have  lived  in  the  Dilton 
community.    Two  of  these,  who  were  especially  helpful,  are  Mrs.  Clemmie 
Harrell  Ring  and  Mr.  Joe  J.  Jemigan,  both  of  whom  are  ninety-three  years 
old  and  blessed  with  excellent  memories.    I  am  grateful  to  my  parents, 
William  Hoyt  and  Pearl  Marlin  Smith,   and  to  my  grandparents,  Ernest 
L.   Smith  (1871-1968)  and  Mary  Ann  Harrell  Smith  (1881-1960),  for  their 
memories  of  life  in  the  community.     Stories  passed  on  by  them  were  drawn 
not  only  from  their  own  personal  experiences  but  also  from  those  of  their 
parents  and  grandparents  and  from  friends  and  neighbors  who  lived  before 
them  in  Dilton.     I  am  also  indebted  to  Roy  E.  Tarwater,  who  suggested 
that  this  history  be  written;  to  all  those  who  contributed  written  or  oral 
information  to  be  used  as  source  material;  and  especially  to  Mrs.  Jean 
Overall  Thompson  for  reading  the  manuscript  and  making  suggestions  for 

its  improvement. 

Rebecca  L.  Smith 


HISTORY  OF  DILTON 

by 

Rebecca  L.  Smith 

I.        Location  pg.  1 
II.         Circumstances  Surrounding  Early  Settlement     pg.   2 
m.        Early  Settlers 

A.  William  smd  Elizabeth  Kelton  pg.  10 

B.  The  Philips  and  Childress  Families  pg.  14 

C.  Other  Early  Settlers  pg.   36 
rv.        Outstanding  Post  Civil  War  Families  pg.  38 

V.        Folklore  and  Folk  Medicine  pg.  47 

VI.         Unusual  Event  pg.  49 

VII.         Churches  pg.  51 

VIII.         Schools  pg.   67 

IX.         Social  Activities  pg.  77 

X,         Roads,  Trade,  Agriculture,  and  Industry  pg.  84: 


ILLUSTRATIONS 

Map  of  Cherokee  Country,   compiled  by  J.  P.  Brown 

(Shows  Black  Fox's  Camp  on  the  Trail  of  Tears).  pg.   9 

Plat  of  Kelton  Property,  1816  (See  Black  Fox  Spring 

and  Branch)  .  pg.  13 

Matthew  Rhea  Map,  1832  (Portion  of  map  showing 

the  old  road  from  Murfreesboro  to  Wartrace 

which  followed  Ljrtle  Creek  through  the  area 

now  known  as  Dilton).  pg.  I6 

Beers  Map  of  Rutherford  County,  1878:  District 

Eighteen.  pg.  22 

Sketch  of  Philips  House,  by  Gari  Webb.  pg.  34 

Childress /Philips  Genealogy  (Two  generations)  .  pg.   35 

1915  Map  of  Rutherford  County  showing  Dilton.  pg.  46 

Oaklands  Academy,  1896.  pg.  71 

Dilton  Stores,  circa  1900.  .    pg.  85,  86 


LOCATION 

The  Dilton  Store,  situated  on  the  southeast  comer  of  the  Bradyville 
Pike  and  the  Dilton-Mankin  Lane,  marks  the  center  of  the  Dilton  com  - 
munity.    History  records  that  early  settlers  moved  iu  long  before  it 
acquired  the  name  of  "Dillton"  in  1887, 1  the  year  the  community  acquired 
a  post  office  named  for  Dr.  James  Madison  Dill,  who  was  physician,  post- 
master, and  storekeeper.  ^   The  center  of  the  community  is  five  and  one- 
half  miles  southeast  of  the  Rutherford  County  Court  House  and  two  and 
three  -tenths  miles  by  way  of  Bradyville  Pike  from  the  present  city  limits 
of  Murfreesboro.  (See  map  on  page  45 .) 

The  original  settlement  had  its  center  at  Black  Fox  Camp,  located 
around  an  unusually  large  spring  about  one  and  one-fourth  miles  from  the 
Dilton  Store  toward  Murfreesboro.  ^  For  many  years  this  spring  supplied 
the  town  of  Murfreesboro  with  water.  Because  of  the  extraordinary  sup- 
ply of  water  at  Black  Fox  Spring  and  the  influence  of  men  such  as  William 
Kelton  and  Joel  Childress,  who  were  among  the  first  settlers,  it  was  con- 
sidered in  1811  as  a  possible  site  for  Rutherford  County's  seat  of  govern- 
ment. ^ 


lAccording  to  Mrs.  Jo  Anne  Kelton,  Dilton  was  spelled  with  two  I's  during 
the  late  1800 »s.    Mrs.  Kelton  is  a  great  granddaughter  of  Dr.  and  Mrs. 
Dill,  and  her  husband,  Sammie  Kelton,  is  a  descendant  of  William  and 
Elizabeth  Kelton. 

2Raymond  Harrell,  "Genealogy  of  the  Dill  Family"  (Workbook,  n.  d. , 
n.  pag.). 

3 Carlton  Sims,  History  of  Rutherford  County  (  Murfreesboro:  Sims, 
1974),  p.l9.  4jQterview  with  Roy  E.  Tarwater,  December,  1976. 

^The  Goodspeed  Histories  of  Maury.  Williamson.  Rutherford,  Bedford, 
and  Marshall  Counties  of  Tennessee,  reprinted  from  Goodspeed's    History 
of  Tennessee,  1886  (Columbia,  TN:    Woodward  and  Stinson,  1971),  p.  814. 


CIRCUMSTANCES  PRECEDING  AND  SURROUNDING  THE  EARLY  SETTLERS 
Approaching  the  Dilton  commimity  from  Murfreesboro,  one  sees  a 
countryside;  quite  different  ia  appearance  from  the  virgin  forest  land  which 
was  used  as  a  campground  by  the  Cherokee,  Chickasaw,  and  Choctaw  Indians 
when  they  came  here  to  hunt  each  year  prior  to  1790.  ■•■    However,   if  these 
Indians  could  return  today,  they  would  recognize  the  spring  beside  which 
they  camped,  the  creek  where  they  fished,  and  the  hills  which  form  a  blue 
backdrop  ia  the  southeast  for  the  Dilton  area  scenery.    Three  of  the  hills 

are  known  to  Dilton  residents  today  as  the  Gowan,  the  Dave,  and  the  Long 

2 
Ridge.      It  would  be  interesting  to  know  the  names  by  which  they  were  known 

to  Enolee.       Enolee  was  the  Indian  name  for  Black  Fox,  the  Cherokee  chief 

for  whom  the  spring  was  named.       Indian  trails  through  the  woodlands 

were  known  as  traces;  several  traces  led  to  Black  Fox  Spring.   (See  map  on 

page  9  . )    The  Indians  used  the  spring  and  the  area  around  it  as  a  base  for 

hunting  expeditions,  as  well  as  for  surprise  attacks  on  the  early  settlers. 

Prior  to  the  Indian  uprisings  it  served  as  a  trading  post  where  the  Indians 

exchanged  wares  with  the  early  settlers. 

It  is  tempting  for  some  to  thiak  that  life  for  the  Indians  who  camped 

around  the  spring  was  idyllic  and  peaceful  before  the  first  settlers  from 

•^Sims,  p.  4. 

^Interview  with  Charles  B.  Smith,  December,  1975. 

3 John  P.  Brown,  Old  Frontiers  (Kingsport,  Tenn. :  Southern,  1938), 
pp.   311,  331.    Other  spellings  used  were  Enola  and  Inali. 

4a.  W.  Putnam,  History  of  Middle  Tennessee  (KnoxvUle:  University 
of  Tennessee  Press,  1971,  first  published,  1859),  p.  479. 

Ssims,  pp.   64,  65. 

^Ibid. 


North  Carolina  and  Virginia  arrived.     The  woodlands  and  streams  provided 
a  plentiful  amount  of  food  and  furs  while  the  Indians  hunted  in  this  area  for 
bear,   elk,   deer,  and  a  large  variety  of  smaller  wild  creatures.      Although 
their  life- style  has  appeal  for  some  people  in  our  complex  time,  we  know 
that  life  for  the  Indians  was  not  always  simple  and  peaceful.     The  Cherokees, 

Chickasaws,  Chocktaws,  and  Shawnees  ia  Tennessee  had  often  fought  among 

2 
themselves,     but  they  were  to  become  a  united  people  in  the  early  1790 's  , 

when  they  had  in  common  a  desire  to  push  back  the  streams  of  white  set- 
tlers from  Virginia  and  North  Carolina. 

Black  Fox's  name  and  mark  appear  on  the  Treaty  of  Holston,  ^  signed 
in  1791,  along  with  the  names  and  marks  of  other  Cherokee  chiefs.    Forty 
chiefs,  twelve  hundred  warriors,   squaws  and  children  assembled  at  White's 
Fort  (Knoxville)  early  in  July  of  that  year  and  agreed  upon  a  treaty  which 
ceded  a  large  portion  of  that  area  of  Tennessee  to  the  United  States.       In 
return,  the  Cherokee  nation  received  certain  presents  and  an  annual  pay- 
ment of  $1,  000  a  year;  feeling  themselves  intimidated  and  tricked,  the 

5 
Cherokees  were  dissatisfied  with  the  Treaty  of  Holston. 

According  to  John  Brown,   evidence  that  the  Indian  troubles  were 

becoming  serious  by  1792  is  found  in  the  American  State  Papers,   Indian 

Affairs,  Vol.  1,  p.   264.    The  Shawnees  invited  the  Southern  Indians  to  join 

^C.C.  Henderson,  The  Story  of  Murfreesboro  (Murfreesboro;  News 
Banner,  1929),  p.    6. , 

2w.R.L.  Smith,  The  Story  of  the  Cherokees  (Cleveland.  Tenn. :  Church 
of  God  Publishing  House,  1928),  p. 17. 

^Brown,  p.   311.  ^Ibid.  Ibid.  ,  p.  312. 


them  ia  war  against  the  United  States  and  hoped  to  drive  back  its  entire 
western  frontiers.      Dragging  Canoe,  an    imcle  of  Black  Fox,  was  sent 

as  a  messenger  from  the  Cherokee  nation  to  the  Chickasaws  with  a  plea  for 

2 
confederation,  but  he  died  soon  after  he  returned.       At  a  Cherokee  Council 

3 
at  Estanaula,     June  26-30,  1792,  Black  Fox  had  these  words  to  say  in  eulogy: 

The  Dragging  Canoe  has  left  the  world.     He  was  a  man  of 
consequence  in  his  country.     He  was  a  friend  both  to  his  own  and 
the  white  people.     But  his  brother  is  still  ia  place,  and  I  mention 
now  in  public,  that  I  intend  presenting  him  with  his  deceased 
brother's  medal;  for  he  promises  fair  to  posess  sentiments  simi- 
lar to  those  of  his  brother,  both  with  regard  to  the  red  and  white. 
It  is  mentioned  here  publicly,   that  both  whites  and  reds  may  know 
it,   and  pay  attention  to  him.  ^ 

Because  of  the  surprise  attacks  on  the  Tennessee  settlers,  scouting 
parties  were  sent  out  in  1792.       Abraham  Castleman,  the  favorite  spy  of 
the  settlements,  who  withdrew  from  his  men  and  scouted  alone  is  described 
as  "fearless,  with  a  quick  sight,  and  a  sure  shot.    He  made  no  noise  or 
tramp  as  he  walked  and  ,  with  his  body  a  little  bent,  he  seemed  ever  look- 
ing for  Indians  or  marks  on  the  trees.'       When  he  returned  from  this  mis- 
sion, he  reported  that  he  had  been  as  far  as  Black  Fox's  Camp,  where  he 
had  seen  signs  indicating  that  a  numerous  party  of  Indians  had  been  there 
shortly  before  him.  "^    Castleman  had  spied  upon  the  Indians  there  before 

llbid.  ,  p.  328.  ^Jhid.  ,  p.   329. 

^Spellings  used  by  some  other  sources  are  Ustanaula  and  Oostanaula.     It 
is  locatea  m  Georgia  on  the  Coosawatie  River  a  few  miles  above  its  junction 
with  the  Canasauga. 
"^Brown,   p.   331. 

Sjohn  Haywood,   Civil  and  Political  History  of  the  State  of  Tennessee 
(Knoxville:  Tenase,  1969,   c.  1823),   pp.368,   369. 
6putnam,  p.   392.  Ilkid. 


and  knew  the  hunting  season  was  not  over;  therefore  he  was  concerned  about 
their  absence.-^    He  felt  it  was  an  ominous  sign  and  reported  this  to  his 
superiors,  who  regarded  his  assessment  with  skepticism.     In  a  letter  to 
Governor  Blount  on  August  22,  1793,  General  James  Robertson  wrote  that 
Abraham  Castleman  was  not  only  a  soldier  but  also  a  disorderly  person  who 
had  several  of  his  relations  killed  by  Indians.  ^    Soon  after  Castleman  made 
his  report,  a  party  of  two  hundred  and  eighty  Indians'^  attacked  Buchanan's 
Station  about  five  miles  south  of  Nashville^  on  September  30,  1792.^    The 
Indians  being  Creeks  (83)  and  Cherokees  (197),     Black  Fox  and  his  people 
could  have  been  among  them,   as  Castleman  feared.    General  Robertson 
apologized  to  Castleman  and,   summoning  a  force  of  150  men,   marched  in 
pursuit  and  followed  the  retreating  Indians  as  far  as  Stewart's  Creek,   report- 
ing that  at  least  seven  hundred  Indians  were  in  the  war  party.  ' 

In  the  spring  of  1793,   soldiers  were  sent  again  into  the  area  by  Gen- 
eral Robertson  with  hope  of  checking  the  forays  and  plunderings  of  the 
Indians  by  a  display  of  military  power,  but  they  turned  back  at  Black  Fox 

o 

Spring.       Since  this  mission  failed  to  accomplish  its  purpose,   Major  James 
Ore's  expedition  of  550  men  was  sent  out  by  General  James  Robertson. 

■^Putnam,  p.   393. 

^Thomas  E.   Matthews,  General  James  Robertson  (Nashville:  Parthenon, 
1934),  p.  344. 

3john  Trotwood  Moore,  Tennessee,  The  Volunteer  State  (Chicago: 
S.J.   Clarke,  1923),  vol.  1,  p.  214. 

^Haywood,   p.  314. 

5james  G.  Ramsey,  The  Annals  of  Tennessee  (Charleston,   S.  C. : 
Walker  and  Jones,  1853),  p.  600. 

^Moore,  loc.  £it.  "^Putnam,  p.  394.  ^Henderson,  p.  10. 

%aywood,  p.  407. 


They  followed  the  Indian  trace  by  way  of  Murfreesboro  and  camped  at  Black 
Fox  Spring  on  September  7,  1794.     On  the  next  day  they  proceeded  toward 
Nickajack  and  arrived  there  on  the  following  Thursday.-^     At  Nickajack 
and  Running  Water,   they  defeated  the  Indians,  finding  many  scalps  and  a 
quantity  of  ammunition  powder  and  lead  lately  arrived  from  Spain.       In  a 
letter  to  Robertson,   Major  Ore  says  "From  the  best  judgment  that  could 
be  formed,   the  number  of  Indians  killed  in  the  two  towns  must  have  been 
upwards  of  fifty  and  the  loss  sustained  by  the  troops  under  my  command 
was  one  lieutenant  and  two  privates  wounded.' 

A  legend  grew  that  en  route  to  Nickajack  when  General  Ore's  men 
overcame  a  group  of  Indians  at  Black  Fox  Spring,  the  Black  Fox  jumped 
into  the  spring  and  disappeared  to  avoid  capture.     Some  said  he  drowned, 

but  the  story  that  he  came  out  alive  where  the  waters  emerge  from  the  earth 

4 
again  at  Murphy  Spring     is  the  most  delightful  facet  of  the  legend  for  those 

who  have  listened  to  the  story  tellers  over  the  years.     When  bones  were 

found  in  Murphy  Spring  Cave,   the  legend  took  another  twist.     The  bones 

were  said  to  be  the  bones  of  Black  Fox.  ^    The  legend  which  allowed  him  to 

escape  alive  is  the  more  reasonable  one  as  his  name  and  mark  appear  in 

the  Treaty  with  the  Cherokee  of  1805,       It  appears  again  in  the  Treaty  with 


^Ibid.  ^Matthews,   p.  368. 

3lhid.  ,   p.  367. 

"^Sims,   p.  65.    Murphy  Spring  is  located  at  the  edge  of  the  Bellwood  Estates 
on  the  hillside  across  Broad  Street  from  Mercury  Blvd.     The  water  which 
submicrges  at  Black  Fox  Spring  comes  up  again  at  Todd  Lake  and  again  at 
Murphy  Spring. 

^Plenderson,   p.  11. 

^C.  J.  Kappler  (comp.),   Indian  Treaties,  i778-_1883  (New  York: 
Interland,    1973),   p.  84. 


the  Cherokee,   1806,   which  states  that  the  old  Cherokee  Chief,   Black  Fox, 
should  be  paid  annually  $100 by  the  United  States  during  his  life.      A  secret 
agreement  or  bribe  was  arranged  in  1807  by  Agent  R.J.   Meigs  with  Black 
Fox  allowing  him  $1,  000,   a  rifle,   and  an  annual  allowance  of  $100  in  return 
for  his  promise  to  keep  the  Indians  content.  ^    "From  1801  to  1811  Black 
Fox  was    Principal  Chief,   save  for  a  two  year  period  (1808-10)   during  which 
he  was  "broke"  from  power  because  of  his  leading  roll  in  an  unpopular 
scheme  to  effect  westward  movement  of  the  tribe.  "      If  Black  Fox  did,   in 
fact,  jump  into  the  Spring  in  1794,   he  must  have  found  a  way  to  keep  his  nose 
out  of  water  until  dark  or  until  the  soldiers  had  gone  away.     The  pool  around 
the  spring  is  large,   perhaps  covering  almost  a  half  acre  and  containing 
many  reeds,    cattails,   and  a  great  amount  of  water  cress.     Black  Fox  could 
have  hidden  himself  beneath  the  water  cress  or  among  the  cattails  and 
breathed  through  a  reed. 

The  area  around  Black  Fox  Spring  was  probably  used  for  the  last  time 
as  an  Indian  campground  in  1839.     From  October  1,   1838,   until  March  of 
1839,   thirteen  thousand  members  of  the  Cherokee  Nation,   divided  into 
contingents  of  one  thousand  each,   traveled  westward  from  the  mountains  of 
East  Tennessee  on  their  forced  and  tragic  migration  to  lands  west  of  the 
Mississippi  River.       After  crossing  the  Tennessee  River  at  Hiwassi  Island, 

%appler,  p.  90.  S^j^-own,  p.  453. 

^HenryT.   Malone,   Cherokees  of  the  Old  South_  (Athens:  University 
of  Georgia  Press,  1956),  pp.  75,  76. 
Brown,   p.  512.  . 


they  foJlowed  the  old  Black  Fox  Trail,    south  of  Pikevillc,   through 
McMinnville  and  across  the  Cumberland  to  Nashville.      The  "Trail  of 
Tears"  passed  through  the  Dilton  area  as  shown  on  the  map  on  the  following 
page.     The  Indians  traveled  an  average  of  ten  miles  per  day,  and  at  the 
end  of  each  day,   each  contingent  buried  its  dead.  ^    There  is  a  legend  in 
the  community  that  Indians  were  buried  in  the  vicinity  of  the  present  day 
Dilton  Cemetery.     It  may  be  that  some  of  the  Cherokees  v/ho  began  the 
journey  but  could  not  finish  it  were  buried  in  this  area.     It  is  known  that 
four  thousand  Cherokees  were  left  in  unmarked  graves  along  the  "nunna- 
da-ul-tsun-yi"    or  "trail  where  they  cried. " 


^Brown,   p.  513.  ^Ibid.  ,   p.  515. 

3 Ibid. ,   p. 519. 


10 


WILLIAM  AND  ELIZABETH  KELTON 

Many  families  from  North  Carolina  and  Virginia  began  to  move  into 
Tennessee  in  the  late  1790's,  when  the  danger  of  Indian  attacks  had  diminished. 
They  were  an  agressive,   hardy,  liberty -loving  people  who  were  mostly 
Scottish  Presbyterians.     Outstanding  examples  of  such  men  and  women 
were  the  Keltons  and  Childresses,   who  were  among  the  early  settlers  in 
the  Black  Fox  Spring  area. 

William  and  Elizabeth  Kelton  came  to  Tennessee  from  North  Carolina, 
where,   according  to  the  1780  census  record,   they  lived  with  a  large  family 
and  numerous  slaves.  ^    They  lived  in  Smith  County,  Tennessee,  for  a 
short  time  before  purchasing  land  in  Rutherford  County.  ^    William  Kelton 
purchased  619  acres  from  Thomas  Harris's  2,057  acre  grant.       The  tract 
began  in  the  middle  of  a  "blue  hole  in  the  Black  Fox  Spring,   to  the  corner 
past  Hawkins  and  Cummings  property,  thence.  .  .to  a  stake  in  the  original 
corner  to  Joseph  McDowell,  "  etc.  ^    The  indenture  was  made  on  July  16, 
1801,   for  $600.  ^    The  deed  was  registered  on  October  23,   1804,   and  was 

acknowledged  before  Andrew  Jackson,   at  that  time  one  of  the  judges  of 

7 
the  Tennessee  Supreme  Court  of  Law  and  Equity. 

The  first  house  in  Rutherford  County  is  believed  by  some  to  have 

Goodspeed,   p.  811. 

^Zella  Armstrong  (comp.).  Notable  Southern  Families  (Chattanooga: 
Lookout,   1922),   p.  215.  Sjbid. 

^Register's  Office,   Rutherford  County,   Tenn. :  Deed  Book  A.   p.  30. 

Sjbid.  ^Ibid- 

■^iienry  G.   Wray  (comp. ),   Rutherford  County,   Tennessee,  ^eed. 
Abstracts   (Smyrna:  Henry  G.  Wray,  n.d.),   Vol.   1,   1804-1810,   p.  7. 


11 


been  built  at  Black  Fox  Spring,   but  it  is  not  known  v/hen  or  by  whom.  ^ 
It  is  known  that  on  a  plantation  around  the  spring,   William  and  Elizabeth 
Kelton  established  their  family.  ^    Elizabeth  Kelton  was  a  charter  member 
of  the  First  Presbyterian  Church  near  Murphy  Spring.       It  is  said  that  her 

four  sons  went  into  the  woods  around  the  Kelton  plantation  to  hew  logs  for 

4 
the  building  of  the  church. 

On  October  25,  1803,  Rutherford  County  was  organized  by  an  act  of 
the  General  Assembly  at  Knoxville;  the  first  court  met  at  the  home  of 
Thomas  Rucker  on  January  3,   1804,   in  which  William-  Kelton  was  one  of  the 
grand  jurymen.  ^    Murfreesboro  was  founded  in  1811,  but  it  was  not  until 
November  5,   1813,   that  elections  were  ordered  to  be  held  at  Murfreesboro 
instead  of  Black  Fox  Spring,   indicating  that  much  of  the  county  business 
had  been  transacted  there. 

According  to  Deed  Book  K,   p.   457,   the  holdings  of  William  Kelton 
(1753-1813)  were  divided  among  his  widow  and  eight  living  children.     A 
plat  of  the  property  made  at  the  time  of  this  division  (October  10,   1816)  has 
been  reproduced  on  page  13.     The  boiondary  drawn  at  the  top  of  the  page 
is  the  eastern  boundary,   and  the  one  on  the  right  is  the  southern  boundary. 
Although  most  of  the  water  goes  underground  at  Black  Fox  Spring,  a  branch 
shown  in  the  plat  flows  toward  the  northwest  from  the  spring.    Although 

ISims,  p.  19.  2Apn^sti.ong,  p.   217.  ^gij^g^  p.  195. 

4  Armstrong,  p.   217.  ^  Ibid.  ^Goodspeed.,  p.   815. 


12 


not  shown,  the  Kelton  cemetery  may  be  seen  today  on  the  farm  owned  by 
James  Gilley  across  the  Bradyville  Road  east  of  the  spring.    Many  of  the 
stones  have  disappeared  or  are  illegible.     As  shown  in  the  plat,  lots  one 
through  nine  were  bequeathed  to  the  followiag  heirs:  Lot  1,  Archibald 
and  Agnes  Sloan;  Lot  2,   John  and  Mary  Sloan;  Lot  3,   Robert  Kelton;  Lot  4, 
Samuel  Kelton;  Lot  5,   Elizabeth  Kelton,   Sr.  ;  Lot  6,   James  Kelton;  Lot  7, 
Elizabeth  Kelton,   Jr.  ;  Lot  8,  William  Kelton;  and  Lot  9,  Alexander  and 
Margaret  Lackey. 


1  Register's  Office,  Rutherford  County,  Tennessee,  Deed  Book  K. 
p.   457. 


i'^r/  ;./ 


p  -/ 


N 


'^///?^. 


^^/-/i)   - 


<'-  "T. 


^ 


/- 


o//  jf 


^ 


«^<.>    Cc 


Lr  \/  i^ 


9  iy  ^/ 


'^c///. 


-#'      •    V 


]4 
Joel  Childress  and  Joseph  Philips  Families 
Closeness  of  the  Two  Families 

Some  of  the  members  of  both  the  Childress   and  the  Philips  families 
were  outstanding  citizens  and  very  closely  associated.     The  Joel  Childresses 
were  among  the  first  settlers  at  Black  Fox  Spring,  ^  and  Joseph  Philips 
must  have  lived  in  the  area  before  going  off  to  war  in  1812  since  the  two 
men  are  said  to  have  been  friends.  ^    By  the  time  Joseph  Philips  returned 
to  Tennessee  in  1822,  ^  Joel  Childress  had  died.  '^    In  later  years,   there 
were  marital  connections  between  the  two  families.     Joel  Childress'  soa. 
named  John  Whitsett  was  married  first  to  Judge  Joseph  Philips'  niece  named 
Sarah  Williams  in  1831  and  later  to  his  daughter,  Mary  Elizabeth  in  1851. 
Judge  Philips'  son,   James  W.  ,   married  in  1850  Sarah  Paicker,   a  niece  of 
John  W.   Childress.     The  Philips  family  home,   first  mentioned  in  a  deed 
of  1837,  5  may  have  been  built  in  the  early  1830's.     It  still  stands  in  the 
Dilton  community  today  and  has  been  occupied  by  members  of  and  descendants 
of  both  the  Philips  and  Childress  families. 
Location  of  Childress  Family's  First  Settlement 

Joel  and  Elizabeth  Childress  moved  from  North  Carolina  to 

%ashville.  Daily  American,   Oct.   9,   1884,   p.  5. 

2Hcrbert  Weaver  (ed. ),  Correspondence  of  James  K.  Folk    (Nashville, 
Vanderbilt  University  Press,  1969),  vol.  1,  p. 497. 

SRobertP.   Howard,   Tllmojs!  A  History  of  the  Prai.rie_Slate 
(Grand  Rapids:  Eerdmans,  1972),   p. 117. 

4county  Court  Clerk's  Office,  Rutherford  County,  Tennessee,  V/ills 
and  Inventories,   Book  4,   p.  196. 

^Register's  Office,  Rutherford  County,  Tennessee,  Deed  Book  W, 

p. 297. 


15 

Tennessee  in  the  1790's.-'-    Deed  records  reveal  that  they  lived  for  a  few 
years  in  Sumner  County  before  purchasing  one  thousand  acres  of  land  for 
$1,  000  from  Benjamin  Roberts  on  August  13,  1803.  ^    This  property  was 
iQ  Davidson  County  until  October  25,  1803,  when  Rutherford  County  was 
organized.     The  deed  states  that  the  land  was  bordered  on  the  west  by  Sarah 
Rutledge's  grant.    A  plat  of  her  2,  5  60  acre  grant  may  be  seen  in  Rutherford 
County's  Deed  Record  Book  K,   p.  306.     Upon  comparing  this  plat  with  Joel 
Childress'  indenture  with  Benjamin  Roberts,  and  after  reading  deeds  of 
what  were  probably  portions  of  this  one  thousand  acre  tract  v/hich  were 
sold  by  Joel  Childress  to  John  Jetton  and  John  Lawrence  about  a  month 
afterward,  ^    one  might  conclude  that  the  Childress  property  was  near  Black 
Fox  Spring.     When  Joel  and  Elizabeth  Childress  moved  to  Rutherford  County, 
they  are  said  to  have  settled  at  a  place  near  the  spring  and  on  the  old  road 
which  led  in  the  direction  of  Manchester  and  to  have  kept  a  store  there.  ^ 
Major  John  Wood  told  of  a  tin  cup  his  mother  bought  for  him  at  Joel 
Childress'  store  near  Black  Fox  Spring  when  he  was  four  or  five  years 
old.  ^    The  "old  road"  referred  to  by  Major  John  Wood  may  be  seen 
on  Matthew  Rhea's  1832  map  of  Tennessee{page  16).      A  plat  of  5  67  acres 

■'•Nashville,  Daily  American,   10c.   cit. 

Register's  Office,  Davidson  County,  Tennessee,  Deed  Book  F 
(Microfilmed  by  Tennessee  State  Library  and  Archives),  p.  75. 

SRegister's  Office,  Rutherford  County,  Tennessee,  Deed  Book  A, 
pp.36,    36;  R,   p.  302. 

%ashville.  Daily  American,   loc.   cit.  I^- 

6The  old  road  came  by  Black  Fox  Spring,  then  followed  Lytle  Creek 
for  several  miles  before  leading  off  toward  Wartrace.     It  had  a  foundation 
of  logs  in  low  places  along  the  trail.     Evidence  of  these  logs  were  found 
by  Carl  Marlin  (1906-19  62)  around  195  6  as  he  was  bulldozing  the  land  about 
one  half  mile  northeast  of  Mt.   Carmel  Baptist  Church. 


Photocopied  from  Rhea's  1832  map  of  Tennessee  to  show  the  "old  road" 
which  followed  Lytle  Creek  for  several  miles  before  leading  off  toward 
Wartrace.  According  to  the  map's  legend,  the  dot  under  the  words  "Lytle 
Creek"  marks  the  location  of  a  fort.   It  is  also  the  approximate  location 
of  the  foundation  of  a  log  structure  which  Ernest  Smith  pointed  out  to  his 
grandson,  Charles  B.  Smith.   The  house  had  burned  by  the  time  the  1878  map 
was  prepared.   Ernest  Smith  said  it  was  a  two-story  log  structure  which 
had  been  the  home  of  some  of  the  Childresses.   It  is  possible  that  this 
was  the  first  home  of  Joel  Childress  in  Rutherford  County. 


17 

in  this  area  which  belonged  to  Joel  Childress'  son,   John  W.  ,   a.nd  possibly 
to  Joel  Childress  himself,    may  be  seen  in  Deed  Book  27  on  page  438. 
There  are  no  deed  records  to  show  how  John  W.  Childress  acquired  this 
property.     Several  deed  record  books  are  missing  so  that  one  cannot  be 
sure,   but  it  seems  probable  that  he  acquired  the  land  from  his  father  or 
from  his  older  brother,   Anderson.     A  copy  of  a  portion  of  the  Rhea  map 
showing  the  "old  road"  is  reproduced  on  the  preceding  page. 

Children  of  Joel  and  Elizabeth  Childress 

The  children  of  Joel  and  Elizabeth  Childress  are  believed  to  have 
lived  a  few  years  of  their  childhood  in  the  Black  Fox  Camp  area.    In  the 
1810  census,  we  find  that  the  couple  had  two  girls  and  two  hoys  under  ten 
years  of  age  and  owned  sixteen  slaves.  ■'•    Their  children  were  Anderson, 
Susan,   Sarah,   and  John  Whitsett.     Two  other  children,   Benjamin,  and 
Elizabeth,   died  in  infancy.  ^    Their  daughter  Sarah,   later  the  v/ife  of  James 
K.   Polk,   became  the  most  well  known  individual  to  have  lived  in  the  com- 
munity about  which  this  history  is  written.     In  speaking  of  her  parents, 
Sarah  said,   "At  that  early  day,  they  had  limited  advantages  for  education, 
but  were  enterprising  and  industrious,   acquired  means  and  property, 
and  educated  their  children.  "^    Their  appreciation  for  books  is  made 
evident  by  the  inventory  of  Joel  Childress'  property  after  his  death.     There 


■•^U.  S.  Department  of  Commerce,  Bureau  of  Census,  Census  of 
Population,  Rutherford  County,  Tennessee,  1810  (Washington,  D.  C. : 
National  Archives,   Microfilm  Publications)  n.  pag. 

2jimmie  Lou  Claxton,   Eighty- eight  Years  V/ith  S^.rah^Pcllr^  (New 
York:  Vantage,   1972),  p.  11. 

3Anson  and  Fanny  Nelson,   Memorials  of  Sarah  ChiVrenP^olk. 
(New  York:    Randolph,   1892),   p.  2. 


18 


were  listed  the  following: 


1    set  of  Scott's  Family  Bibles,   5  vols. 

1    History  of  the  Late  War 

1    Medical  Guide 

1   Ovid 

1    Paley's  Philosophy 

1    Simpson's  Euclid 

1    Horace 

1    Xenophen 

1    Cicero 

1  Atlas 

40  voluines  of  large  and  small  books  assorted 
6    of  Arrowsmith's  large  maps 

2  sets  of  Bigland's  View  of  the  World,   5  vols,   each-^ 

Sarah  and  her  sister  Susan  were  taught  in  the  mornings  and  early 
afternoons  by  Daniel  Elam  at  a  little  log  school  house  in  the  neighborhood, 
and  in  the  afternoons,  when  the  exercises  of  the  academy  for  boys  were 
over  for  the  day,   they  were  given  additional  lessons  by  the  principal, 
Mr.   Samuel  P.   Black.  ^    When  she  was  twelve  or  thirteen,   Sarah  was 
sent  to  Abercrombie  Boarding  School  on  the  outskirts  of  Nashville.  ^    A 
few  years  after  their  arrival  in  Rutherford  County,  the  Joel  Childress 
family  may  have  moved  from  the  Black  Fox  Camp  area  to  the  town  of 
Murfreesboro. '^    Prosperous  men,   active  in  public  affairs,  who  owned 
plantations  frequently  maintained  town  houses  in  addition  to  their  planta- 
tion houses  and  lived  a  part  of  the  year  in  each.     Letters  from  John  W. 
Childress  to  James  K.  Polk  in  later  years  reveal  that  his  mother,   Mrs. 
Joel  Childress,   could  never  make  up  her  mind  whether  to  live  in  town 
or  in  the  country,   and  she  frequently  moved  from  one  place  to  the 

•^County  Court  Clerk's  Office,   Rutherford  County,   Tennessee,   Wills 
and  Inventories,   Book  5,   p.  244. 

2Nelson,   p.  4,  3  ibid. 

4  Register's  Office,   Rutherford  County,   Tenn.  ,  Deed  Book  L,   p.  291. 


10 


other.  •  It  seems  probable  that,   in  1815,  Joel  Childress  and  his  family   . 
left  their  first  Rutherford  County  home  on  the  "old  road"  near  the  Black 
Fox  Spring  for  good  except  for  Anderson,  who  may  have  lived  there  v/ith 
his  wife  and  daughter,  Mary,   at  times  prior  to  his  death  in  1827;  however, 

the  descendants  of  Joel  Childress  continued  to  own  property  in  the  Black 

2 
Fox  Camp  district  and  to  live  on  that  property  from  time  to  time  until  1895. 

The  Shelbyville  Road  Plantation 

In  1815  Joel  Childress  bought  for  $1,  860  from  Thomas  Smith  186  acres 

3 
on  the  West  Fork  of  Stones  River  bordering  the  meanderings  of  the  river. 

Mr.  Childress  purchased  thirty  additional  acres  bordering  this  property 

4 
in  1817  from  Bennett  Smith.        He  mentions    the  Stones  River  plantation 

in  his  will,      signed  nine  days  before  his  death,   as  being  land  on  v/hich  he 

lived.    After  his  death,  the  plantation  was  sold  but  was  purchased  again 

by  Joel  Childress'  son,  John  W. ,  in  1833.       In  a  letter  of  December  8,  1833, 

to  James  K.  Polk,  John  W.  ChUdress  writes,  "Mah  and  myself  have 

purchased  the  old  plantation  and  are  now  moving  to  it  ..."      John  W. 

Childress'  name  appears  on  the  site  of  the  plantation  on  the  Beers  map 

of  1878,   and  a  plat  of  the  property  may  be  seen  in  Deed  Book  27  on  page  437. 

^Weaver,  vol.  1,   pp.    205,594;  vol.   2,  pp.  14,  159;  vol.    3,   p.  444. 

^Interview  with  Mrs.   Margaret  Dismukes,  a  great  granddaughter 
of  Joel  Childress  and  of  Joseph  Philips,  December,  1975. 

3 Register's  Office,  Rutherford  County,  Tenn.  ,  Deed  Book  K,  p.  165. 

4  Ibid.  ,   Book  L,  p.   122. 

^County  Court  Clerk's  Office,  Rutherford  County,  Tennessee,  Wnis 
and  Inventories,  Book  4,  p.  195. 

^Register's  Office,   Rutherford  County,   Tenn.  ,  Deed  Book  W,   p.   554. 

■^  Weaver,   vol.   2,   p.  159.     "Mah"  is  Mrs.  Joel  Childress. 


20 

Joel  Childress'  Public  Life 

Joel  Childress  was  active  in  public  affairs  during  his    lifetime. 
An  Act  of  October  15,   1813,    made  Joel  Childress  and  six  other  men  com- 
missioners of  Murfreesboro.      He  served  as  commissioner  until  1815, 
and  postmaster  of  Murfreesboro  from  1812  until  1817,   and  as  a  director 
of  the  Murfreesboro,   Tennessee  Bank,   which  was  chartered  in  1817,  2 
He  was  a  merchant,   a  tavern  keeper,   planter,  and  a  large  scale  land 
speculator  in  Alabama  during  the  boom  years.  ^    Samuel  McLaughlin, 
who  knew  Joel  Childress,  wrote  that  he  owned  and  lived  in  the  framed 
portion  of  the  tavern  house  on  the  v/est  side  of  the  square.       In  December 
of  1818,   less  than  a  year  before  his  death,   Mr.   Childress  sold  a  lot  on 
the  public  square  with  a  dwelling  "in  which  he  had  lived"  to  Alpha  Kingsley 
for  $11,  000.  ^    It  is  quite  probable  that  he  returned  to  his  Shelbyville  Road 
home  in  December  of  1818  to  live  there  on  a  continuous  basis  until  his 
death  on  August  18,  1819  at  42  years  of  age.  ^    He  was  buried  in  a  garden 
tomb  near  his  house.  "^    In  later  years  his  tombstone  was  installed  face 
down  as  a  hearth  in  a  farm  house  built  on  this  property.     When  the  house 
was  torn  down,   the  stone  was  broken  into  several  pieces.  8    The  parts 
that  remain  are  presently  being  put  together  and  are  to  become  a  part  of 

1  Goodspeed,  p.  815.  ^  Ibid.  ,  pp.819,   830. 

3  Charles  G.   Sellers,  James  K.  Polk,  Jacksonian,  1795-1843 
(Princeton,  New  Jersey:    Princeton  University  Press,  1957),  pp.  74,  75, 

4  Henry  Wray,   "Sojourn  in  Murfreesboro,  "  Rutherford  County 
Historical  Society,   Publication  No.   1,   Summer,   1973,   p.  17. 

5  Register's  Office,   Rutherford  County,  Tenn.  ,   Deed  Book  W,   p.  246. 

6  Tombstone  of  Joel  Childress. 

'7  A.L.   Childress,    "The  ChHdress  FamHy  in  Tennessee,"  Tennessee 
State  Library  and  Archives,   Ms.   no.    69-316,   n.   pag. 

^  Interview  with  William  T.   Stephenson,  April,   1976, 


the  museum  village  to  be  known  as  "Cannonsbiirr^h".  1 

Anderson  Childress 

Ernest  Smith  (1871-1968)  remembered,   as  a  boy,   hearing  the  "old- 
timers"  in  the  community  tell  of  Anderson's  death,   and  he  understood 
this  tragic  event  to  have  occurred  on  the  Childress  farm  which  Avas 
adjacent  to  his  own  farm  on  the  west  and  southwest.     lie  once  pointed  out 
to  his  grandson,   Charles  B.   Smith,   the  foundation  of  an  old,   tv.'o- story 
log  house  on  this  farm  through  which  Lytle  Creel:  ran.  2    The  houre 
"where  one  of  the  Childress  boys  lived"  had  burned  down.     The  farm,  is 
known  to  have  belonged  to  Anderson's  younger  brother  Jo^ix).  YI ,  in  1878.  ^ 
A  plat  of  the  land  (5  67  acres)  may  be  seen  in  Deed  Record  Eco)-  27  on 
page  438  and  is  possibly  a  part  of  the  1,  000  acre  tract  purchased  hy  Joel 
Childress  in  1803  on  which  he  first  settled  when  he  came  to  Rutherford 
County.     In  1827,  just  seven  years  after  Anderson's  marriage  to  D.lary 
Sansom,   Anderson  was  thrown  from  his  horse,   his  neck  was  broken,   and 
the  injury  was  fatal.       This  story  of  a  young  man,   reputed  to  be  an  excel- 
lent horseman,    made  so  sharp  an  impression  upon  Ernest  Smith  v/Mle 
he  was  a  child  that  he  would  never  fasten  the  girth  on  the  saddle  V'hen 
he  rode  for  fear  he  would  hang  his  toe  in  the  stirrup  if  the  horse  threw 


1  From  October  17,   1811  to  November  15,   1811,   Mi\rfreesboro  was 
named  Cannonsburgh  in  honor  ofl^ewton  Cannon,   who  served  as  a  repre- 
sentative in  the  state  legislature  and  eventually  as  governor  o".   Tennessee. 

2  Interview  with  Charles  B.   Smith,   January,   1976.     The  approximate 
location  of  the  old  foundation  has  been  marked  with  a  star  on  the  1878  map 
on  page  22.     All  evidence  of  the  old  foundation  has  been  swep ■-.  avray  by 
farm  machinery. 

3  Register's  Office,   Rutherford  County,   Tenn.  ,   Peed  F-^ck  2".-  p.  ST: 

4  Claxton,   p.  32.  ^  ^  r  a_,  -P    m^   -t- 


,1  ;,  '•>    ..  A'»" 


0 


so' 


ML_ii"l  lU^ici-     ,<•'',..•'••    ^'^''.sV 

-^  !;v3i    *ni.is  ii„r,„i.x  fiiin 

—  \'  /  / « ^/^> 

L..I/  //,„y,„„//  <%        %*  ./  /'  >'//'//■/,/-/•  •  /.  A.  Unrhm- 

V.';"'c./.,.U4-  X  „.  ^,^.  >♦  AP.  AR.ST 

'■^V    ,// .  f'rns.v 

X 
♦J/.  /■ . 


-.•  •!.  "•  •      .  ** 


♦l''^^?^ 


22 


/    A>/.v/  wtniil     " 


7////'/lf-  Cnlliin  din 


h'liiirUi  II        \,_--^ r\  |l     V     ,- 

If'  I'rnti-:' 


\\   ilrx    Wiiixlnil 
I'l'-       JllrxMJIi/U'i 


I  J  il  l.rnl/tfmt^ 


%n.  T.  Welpt 


K  J/ii/iT 


Jl.^  J/  J.  A'liriHUjAV 
I  n.  Umyy^iif 


Z^\ui:s'rmriti    V   I'SmiTh  \ *;.    .      *      A     1  '  ^'' 

r  'Hzx  '■■'•  %  \\  ''■■■  /f 


This  map  of  the  Dilton  area  was  photocopied  from  the  Beers  Map  of 
Rutherford  County  of  1878.  On  it,  the  name  W.  S.  Childress  appears 
on  the  home  site  of  his  grandfather,  Judge  Joseph  Philips.  The  house 
and  9U6  acres  of  land,  called  the  "Philips  tract"  in  Deed  Book  27  on 
page  U38,  belonged  in  1878  to  his  father  and  mother,  John  W.  and  Mary- 
Elizabeth  Philips  Childress.  The  star  drawn  in  near  the  center  of 
the  map  has  been  placed  there  by  the  author  of  this  history  to  mark 
the  approximate  location  of  the  two-story  log  house  iirtiich  burned 
prior  to  1878.  It  stood  on  Childress  property  called  the  "quarter 
tract"  in  Deed  Book  27,  page  li38. 


23 

him. 

Joseph  Philips'  Background 

Judge  Joseph  Philips  was  a  son  of  Philip  Philips,   who  was  in  part- 
nership with  Michael  Campbell,   a  surveyor  and  land  speculator.     Tax 
records  indicate  there  were  7,  000  acres  of  Philips  and  Campbell  land 
in  Rutherford  County  in  1811.  ^    That  Philip  Philips  was  a  man  of  con- 
siderable wealth  is  attested  to  by  the  length  of  his  will,  ^  which  v/as 
probated  in  October  of  1797.     The  farm  on  which  he  lived  was  purchased 
from  William  and  Ephraim  McLean.  ^    A  deed  of  1791  tells  us  that  William     " 
McLean  owned  land  on  Knobb  Creek  north  of  Duck  River.       This  would 
seem  to  indicate  that  Philip  Philips  lived  in  Bedford  County  rather  than 
in  the  Dilton  area  where  his  son,   Joseph,   built  his  home.     In  his  will 
Philip  Philips  bequeathed  his  farm  to  his  wife,   Susannah,   and  his  stills 
to  his  eldest  son,  John.     According  to  the  1820  census,  John  and  his  family 
were  living  in  Bedford  County  at  that  time.  ^    Joseph  was  sixteen  at  the  time 

of  his  father's  death  in  1797.     According  to  court  minutes  of  1809,   Joseph 

7 
Philips  was  licensed  to  practice  law  in  Tennessee  during  that  year. 

Although  his  first  acquisition  of  property  was  in  1812,   when  his  father's 

1  Interview  with  Charles  B.  Smith,  January,  1976. 

2  Rutherford  Co.  ,   Tenn.  ,   Tax  Book,  1811  (Microfilmed  by  the 
Tennessee  State  Library  and  Archives),  n.  pag. 

3  County  Court  Clerk's  Office,  Davidson  Co.  ,  Tenn.  ,  WHls  and 
Inventories,  Book  2  (Microfilmed  by  the  Tennessee  State  Library  and 
Archives),  p.  89.  ^  Ibid. 

5  Register's  Office,   Rutherford  Co.  ,   Tenn.  ,  Deed  Book  C,   p.  306. 

6  U.S.  Census  of  Population,   Bedford  Co.  ,  Tenn.,  1820  (Washington, 
D.C.:    National  Archives,   Microfilm  Publications),  n.  pag. 

^  County  Court  Clerk's  Office,  Rutherford  Co.  ,   Tenn.  ,   Court 
Minutes,   Book  C,   1808-1810,   p.  142.     His  name  appears  once  as  Joseph 
R.  Philips  in  Book  E,  1811-1812  on  page  60. 


partner  and  executor  deeded  408  acres  to  him  and  to  his  brother,   John, 
on  Lytle  Creek, -"^  he  left  Tennessee  in  1812.       In  1817,   he  gave  his  brother- 
in-law,   Robert  Purdy,   power  of  attorney  to  act  for  him  in  settling  his 
father's  estate  and  identified  himself  as  Secretary  of  the  Illinois  Territory.  ^ 

When  Joseph  Philips  left  Tennessee  to  fight  in  the  V/ar  of  1812,   he 
became  a  captain  of  artillery.       After  the  war  he  settled  in  Randolph 
County,   Illinois,   and  remained  in  that  state  for  ten  years.     He  followed 
Nathaniel  Pope  as  Territorial  Secretary  of  Illinois,  ^  serving  from  1816 
to  1818,  ^  and,   because  of  his  excellent  reputation,   was  appointed  Supreme 
Court  Justice  of  Illinois  in  1818.  "^    In  1822,   he  resigned  as  Supreme  Court 
Justice  to  became  a  candidate  for  governor  of  Illinois,  but  he  lost  the 
election  because  of  his  pro- slavery  stand.  °    His  first  wife,   Elouise 
Morrison,  ^  died  about  this  time,   and  he  returned  to  Tennessee  in  1822 
at  38  years  of  age.^O    On  September  6,  1825,   he' married  his  second  wife, 
Dorothy  Drake  Sumner,   in  Davidson  County,  ^^    They  made  their  home  in 
Nashville  at  least  until  1830:  during  these  years.  Judge  Philips  served 

1  Register's  Office,  Rutherford  Co.  ,   Tenn.  ,  Deed  Book  K,  p.  75. 

2  Sims,   p.  75. 

3  Register's  Office,  Rutherford  Co.  ,   Tenn.  ,   Deed  Book  M,   p.  348. 
'^  Sims,   p.  75. 

5  Robert  P.   Howard,   Illinois:  A  History  of  the  Prairie  State    (Grand 
Rapids:  Eerdmans,   1972),  p.  117, 

6  John  Clayton,  The  Illinois  Fact  Book  and  Historical  Almanac, 
1673-1968  (Carbondale:  Southern  Illinois  University  Press,   1970),   p.  97. 

'''  Howard,   p.  117. 

8  Theodore  C.  Pease,  The  Story  of  Illinois  (Chicago:  University 
of  Chicago  Press,   1965),   p.  77. 

9  Letter  to  Mrs.   Selene  Woodson  from  Miss  Philippa  Gilchrist, 
Jan.    8,   1963. 

10  Clayton,   p.  97,    see  also  U.  S.   Census  of  Population,   Rvitherford 
Co.  ,   Tenn.  ,   1850,   which  gives  his  age  in  that  year  as  66. 

11  Davidson  County  Marriage  Record  Book  I,   1789-1837  (Nashville, 
French  Lick  Chapter,  D.A.R.,   1952),   p.  90. 


as  president  of  the  People's  Bank 


25 
1 


Joseph  Philip's  Return  to  Rutherford  County 

Prior  to  1830  Joseph  Philips  acquired  many  acres  of  land  in 
Rutherford  County  as  an  inheritance  from  his  father.  ^    No  mention  is 
made  in  deed  records  of  a  house  on  any  of  the  land  which  he  acquired, 
but  this  does  not  preclude  the  possibility  that  there  was  one.     The  1830 
census^  shows  the  Philipses  to  be  in  Davidson  County  during  that  year, 
but  sometime  between  1830  and  1837,  they  moved  to  Rutherford  County, 
and  it  could  have  been  during  this  time  that  the  Philips  house  was  built 
near  the  "old  road.  "    The  two  story  house  was  constructed  in  the  archi- 
tectural style  of  country  houses  built  in  the  early  years  of  the  nineteenth 
century.     A  deed  of  1837  transfers  from  Robert  Bates  to  Joseph  Philips 
and  his  stepson,  John  H.   Sumner,   "fifty  acres  of  land  beginning  at  a 
hickory  on  the  south  boundary  of  the  tract  on  which  Joseph  Philips  now 
resides,   it  being  the  northwest  corner  of  land  on  which  Robert  Bates 
resides  which  he  purchased  from  John  Fulks.  " 

After  John  Sumner's  death,  his  half-brother,  James  W.  Philips, 
deeded  his  one  third  interest  in  the  Sumner  estate  to  his  father,  Joseph 
Philips,   who  deeded  it  to  his  daughters,   Mary  Elizabeth  (Mrs.   John  W. 
Childress)  and  Ellen  Philips  Gilchrist.    Judge  Philips  then  deeded  his 

1  "Genealogical  Data.     Battle,   Childress,   Maney,  Robertson,  Rucker 
and  Williams  Families.  "    Tennessee  State  Library  and  Archives,  Ms=1102. 

2  Register's  Office,   Rutherford  Co.  ,   Tenn.  ,  Deed  Book  O,  pp.  263,  267, 

3  U.  S.  Department  of  Commerce,   Bureau  of  Census,   Census  of  Popu- 
lation, Davidson  Co.  ,   Tenn.  ,   1820  (Washington,  D.C:  National  Archives, 
Microfilm  Publications)  n.   pag. 

^  Register's  Office,  Rutherford  Co.  ,  Tenn.  ,  Deed  Book  W,  p.  291. 


own  farm  and  twenty -three  of  his  slaves  to  his  son,  James,   subject  to  this 
reservation:  "Joseph  Philips  reserves  to  himself  and  his  v/ifo,  Dorothy,  the 
exclusive  right  of  possession,   use  and  enjoyment  of  the  dwelling  house,  out- 
houses,  fixtures  and  garden  and  of  so  much  of  such  part  or  parts  of  the  land 
as  they  or  either  of  them  or  the  survivor  may  choose  to  occupy  .  .  .  for  and 
during  the  time  of  their  natural  lives. "      Judge  Philips  must  have  planned 
to  retire  from  farming  in  1850  when  this  land  and  these  slaves  were  deeded 
to  his  son,  James,  who  married  in  that  year  a  neice  of  Sorah  Childress  Polk, 

Sarah  Rucker.     Sarah  Rucker  Philips  and  her  child  died  two  years  later  when 

2  3 

the  child  was  born    and  James  W.  Philips  died  in  1854    at  age  tv/enty- eight. 

The  1850  Census  reveals  that  Judge  Philips  was  one  of  the  wealthiest 

4 
farmers  in  the  county,   with  property  valued  at  $33,  000  and  fifty-five  slaves. 

Ernest  Smith  remembered  hearing  people  in  Dilton  say  that  Judge  Philips 

"used  te  go  down  the  road  every  day,   rain  or  shine,   in  his  fancy,  four  wheel 

surrey,  "  and  he  recalled  seeing  the  old  surrey  in  a  dilapidated  condition  as 

it  sat  in  the  yard  of  the  Philips'  homeplace  in  later  years.     Judge  Philips 

died  in  1857  at  seventy- three  years  of  age.       A  plat  of  the  "Joseph  Philips 

^  Register's  Office,   Rutherford  Co.  ,   Tenn.  ,  Deed  Book  5,   p.    627. 

2  Claxton,   p.  141,   143. 

3  Register's  Office,  Rutherford  Co.,   Tenn.  ,  Deed  Book  23,  p.  583. 

4  Census  of  Rutherford  County,  Tennessee,  1850  (Nashville:  Deane 
Porch.   1967),  pp.   355,   356. 

5  County  Court  Clerk's  Office,  Rutherford  Co.  ,    Tenn.,  no.  19, 
pp.   78,  186. 


27 

tract"  may  be  seen  iii  Deed  Book  27,   page  438,   and  an  inventory  of  his 
estate  may  be  found  in  Book  19,   page  186,   in  the  County  Court  Clerk's 
office. 

John  W.  Childress,   Son  of  Joel  Childress  and  Son-In-Law  of  Joseph 
Philips 

Letters  from  John  W.  Childress  to  James  K.  Polk  reveal  that  he 

had  a  difficult  time  financially  during  the  1830's,-'-  but  by  1850,    census 

records  indicate  that  his  real  estate  was  valued  at  $28,000  and  that  he 

2 
owned  49  slaves.       When  he  brought  his  family  from  from  Griffin, 

3 
Georgia  after  the  Civil  War,  his  own  home  had  been  destroyed.       After 

serving  for  a  few  years  as  Circuit  Judge  in  Nashville,   Mr.   Childress 

probably  returned  to  Murfreesboro  to  live  in  the  early  1870 's,   when  he 

began  serving  as  president  of  the  branch  of  the  Planter's  Bank  of 

Tennessee  at  Murfreesboro;  from  1872  to  1880,  'he  served  as  president 

of  the  First  National  Bank  established  here."*    He  and  his  wife,  Mary 

Elizabeth,  are  believed  to  have  lived  with  his  widowed  mother-in-law, 

Dorothy  Sumner  Philips,   at  the  Philips  home  some  time  between  1870 

and  1875,   and  Mr.   Childress  continued  to  use  the  land  for  agricultural 

purposes  until  his  death.     Ernest  Smith,   born  in  1871,   remembered  that 

when  he  was  a  child,   John  W.   Childress  and  his  family  lived  at  the 

Philips  house.     He  recalled  seeing  John  W.  Childress,  who  was  known 


1  Weaver,   v.    2,   p.  14. 

2  Census  of  Rutherford  Cotmty,   Tennessee,  1850   (Nashville: 
Deane  Porch,   1967)  ,  p.    361. 

^  Claxton,   p.  157. 

4  Nashville,  Daily  American,   loc.   cit. 


28 
as  Major  Childress,    ride  to  and  from  Murfreesboro  everj^  day  on  his 
horse,   and  he  told  of  visiting  him  at  the  Philips  home  with  his  father, 
Alexander  T.   Smith.     He  also  told  his  grandchildren  that  he  watched  with 
his  father  and  Major  Childress  as  a  hired  man  attempted  and  failed  to  ride 
a  horse  which  had  not  been  broken  in.     When  John  and  Mary  Elizabeth 
moved  to  their  home  on  the  corner  of  Lytle  and  Academy  Streets  around 
1875,   their  son,   W.   S.   Childress  and  his  family  moved  into  the  Philips 
house.  ■'■ 

A  deed  of  1878  states  that  the  homeplace  "is  now  and  has  been  for 
years  in  the  use  and  possession  of  Mrs.  Dorothy  Philips,  "^   Peed  rec- 
ords and  tax  records  reveal  that  she  also  owned  a  house  and  lot  in 
Murfreesboro  from  1873  until  her  death.  ^    It  is  probable  that  she  lived 
alternately  in  her  country  house  and  town  house  during  these  latter  years 
of  her  life.     Rutherford  County  tax  records  indicate  that  she  was  still 
alive  in  1881,  "*  at  which  time  she  would  have  been  ninety- tv/o  years  old. " 

During  1878  John  W.   Childress  paid  $4,  000  to  Joseph  Philips 
Gilchrist  of  Alabama  for  his  interest  in  the  Philips  property.       The 
property  was  bordered  on  the  north  by  land  already  owned  by  John,   and 
by  properties  owned  by  Dr.   Robert  N.   Knox  and  by  Jasper  Knox.     The 


1  Beers  Map  of  Rutherford  County,   1878. 

^  Register's  Office,   Rutherford  Co.  ,   Tenn.  ,  Deed  Book  23,  p.  583. 
3 Ibid.  ,   Book  21,   p.  369. 

"^  Rutherford  Co.  ,   Tenn.  ,   Tax  Records  (Microfilmed  by  Tennessee 
State  Library  and  Archives,   1965),   n.   pag. 

5  Census  of  Rutherford  County,   Tennessee,  1850   (Nashville:  Deane 
Porch,   1967)  ,   p.  355. 

6  Register's  Office,   Rutherford  Co.  ,   Tenn.  ,  Deed  Dook  23,  p.  583. 


29 

Knox  properties  lay    to  the  east  of  the  property  already  ov/ned  by  John 
W.   Childress  as  did  property  of  H.  W.   Bivins  and  A.T.   Smith.     The 
Childress  tract  of  5  67  acres  and  the  Philips  tract  of  946  acres  may  be 
seen  in  plats  in  Deed  Book  27,  page  438.     Joseph  Philips  Gilchrist  was 
a  grandson  of  Judge  Joseph  Philips  and  the  child  of  Ellen  Philips  Gilchrist. 
When  Mrs.   Gilchrist  died,   the  remaining  heirs  of  the  Philips  property 
were  the  Judge's  widow,  Dorothy,   one  daughter  ( Mary  Elizabeth  Childrcso) 
and  her  family,   and  Mrs.   Gilchrist's  son. 

The  Philips  House  and  Homeplace 

The  following  description  of  the  Philips  house  and  outhouses  was 
given  to  the  writer  orally  by  Charles  B.   Smith,   a  grandson  of  Ernest  L. 
Smith.     Charles  and  Ann  Smith  and  their  daughter,   Virginia  Ljmn,  lived 
in  the  home  from  1962  to  1970  and,   with  the  financial  backing  of  the 
owners,   Mr.   and  Mrs.   Cannon  Overall,   they  restored  the  interior  of 
the  old  house  to  some  degree  of  its  former  beauty,   as  Robert  N.  Justice 
had  done  in  190  6.-^   The  house  was  badly  in  need  of  repair  in  1962.     It  had 
been  used  for  grain  storage  and  by  coon  hunters  on  v/eekends.     There 
were  times  when  it  had  been  occupied  by  only  snakes,   lizards,   and  rats. 
The  upstairs  bedroom  on  the  north  side  has  a  large  blood  stain  on  the 
floor  which  the  sanding  machine  was  unable  to  remove.     The  blood  may 


■•■  Interview  with  Charles  B.   Smith,   January,   1976. 


?0 


have  been  that  of  a  soldiers   since  the  home  vas  user^  os  a.  b.ocpxt^T  by         '^ 
the  Union  soldiers  during  the  Civil  War.      Its  use  as  a  hospital  may  have 
accoimted  for  its  survival  of  the  war. 

The  house  was  built  of  virgin  cedar  logs,  eighteen  feet  long.    The  butt 
ends,  twenty- four  inches  in  diameter,  were  hewed  down  to  six  inches  wide« 
Split  hickory  laths  hold  the  plaster  on  the  interior  walls.    The  plaster  was 
made  of  lime,  oyster  shell,  and  hog  hair.    The  hog  hair  v/as  for  bondinfj. 
The  exterior  is  covered  with  hand  hewn  cedar  vyeatherboarding  and  the 
floor  joists  are  of  round  cedar  logs  up  to  twelve  inches  in  diajneter.    The 
floor  is  one  and  a  half  inch  thick  yellow  ash,  tongue  and  groove  boards, 
six  inches  wide.     All  the  ceilings  are  yellow  poplar,  hand-^-planed  boards. 
The  rooms  are  seventeen  feet  by  seventeen  feet  and  the  ceilings  are  about 
eight  and  a  half  feet  high  except  for  the  back  part  of  the  house  v/here  they 
are  nine  and  a  half  feet  high.    The  floor  of  the  upstairs  bedroom  on  the 
south  side  is  cf  yellow  poplar  and  the  room  contains  no  fireplace.    Since 
evidence  of  a  brick  kiln  was  found  by  Ernest  Smith  near  the  house,  it  is 
probable  that  the  bricks  for  the  chimney  and  the  front  v/alk  were  made  on 
the  premises. 

The  doors  to  the  house  are  sturdy  with  extremely  large  iron 


■^Interview  with  Mrs,  Cannon  J,  Overall,  March,  1976. 
^Interview  with  Charles  B,  Smith,  January,  1976, 


31 

keyholes  and  keys,   and  the  front  doors  are  double  panel  doors  made  of 
yellow  poplar.     The  house,   facing  the  west,   has  a  one  story  front  porch, 
which  leads  into  a  lower  entrance  hallway  with  a  stairv/ay  leading  to  the 
upper  hall.     There  is  a  large  room  on  each  side  of  each  hall  on  both 
floors.     The  east  porch  originally  went  across  the  entire  house  on  the 
east  side;  however,   today,   behind  the  southwest  dov.Tistairs  room,   the 
porch  is  enclosed  as  another  hall  opening  onto  the  south  porch,     A  steep 
indoor  stairway,  which  has  now  been  torn  away,  led  to  the  upstairs  attic 
over  the  two  back  rooms.     Four  of  the  sons  of  the  John  Nelson  family, 
who  rented  the  farm  during  the  1880 's,   slept  in  this  attic,  but  there  was 
room  enough  for  twenty  people  to  have  bvoiked  in  the  large  a.tt^c^ 

The  privy  was  unusually  nice  with  a  copper  latrine.     The  old  log 
kitchen,   just  south  of  the  south  porch,   was  torn  down  in  1963.     Above 
the  kitchen  and  pantry  were  servants'  quarters  paneled  v/ith  yellow  poplar 
paneling.     The  log  carriage  house  and  the  log  barn  may  still  be  seen  on 
the  property.     Not  far  from  the  barn  is  a  dug  well.     At  one  time,   there 
were  nine  slave  cabins  on  the  property.     The  Beers  map  shov/s  that  the 

road  which  ran  past  the  house  was  near  the  front  of  the  house  in  IP'^H. 

o 

A  sunken  brick  walk  led  from  the  front  steps  of  the  house  to  the  old  road.  " 

During  the  early  1960's,  two  artifacts  were  found  near  the  house. 


Interview  with  Charles  B.  Smith,  January,  1976c 
2  Ibid. 


33 

moved  to  Murfreesboro.  ■'•    The  homeplace,   including  75  1/2  acres  and 
the  house,  became  the  property  of  Mrs.  Edgar  Smith  in  1900  when  the 
property  (947  acres)  was  divided  among  the  heirs  of  Mary  Elizabeth 
Philips  Childress.    A  plat  may  be  seen  with  the  deed.  ^    in  1906,   it  was 
sold  to  Mr.   and  Mrs.  Robert  N.   Justice.  ^    In  her  widowhood,  Mrs. 
Justice  (formerly  Lizzie  Overall)  married  Mr.   Sam  Paschal.     In  1945, 
the  property  was  sold  by  Mrs.   Paschal's  heirs  to  his  deceased    wife's 
nephew  Cannon  J.  Overall  and  his  wife,  Mary  Virginia  Bock  Overall.  ^ 
Mrs.   Overall  is  the  owner  at  the  present  time  (197  6).  ^ 

The  house  is  now  occupied  by  Gari  Webb,   a  local  artist,   whose  sketch 
of  it  appears  with  this  article.     A  window  in  the  end  of  the  house  to  the 
right  side  of  the  south  chimney  is  not  shown  in  the  sketch,  but  possibly 
was  not  there  originally.     A  window,   which  is  not  actually  there,   is  shown 
in  the  sketch  by  the  door  to  the  enclosed  south  hall,  but  the    hall  was  not 
enclosed  originally.     The  house  had  window  shutters  on  the  outside,  which 
were  removed  due  to  their  deteriorated  condition.     With  this  information, 
the  sketch,   and  some  imagination,  the  reader  may  "see"  the  house  as 
it  may  have  appeared  during  the  1830's  and  1840's  when  it  is  believed  to 
have  been  visited  by  the  president  and  first  lady  of  the  land.  President 
and  Mrs.  James  K.  Polk.  6 

1  Interview  with  Mrs.  Margaret  Dismukes,  December,  1976. 

2  Register's  Office,  Rutherford  Co.  ,  Tenn.  ,  Deed  Book  41,  p.  5. 

3  Interview  with  Mrs.  Margaret  Dismukes,  December,  1976. 

4  Interview  with  Mrs.  Jean  Overall  Thompson,  July,  1976. 

5  Register's  Office,  Rutherford  Co.  ,  Tenn.  ,  Deed  Book  95,  p.  135. 

6  Interview  with  Mrs.  Pearl  Marlin  Smith,  July,   1976.     Mrs.   Smith 
was  told  this  around  1910  by  older  residents  of  the  Dilton  community. 


""^^^^^^ 


1 


•I  -y 


>  i 


^  a  c-( 

50 

a  .    » 

c 

rt        g 

O 

•    1-  » 

!>r 

00    CO 

n 

O    lyi 

n 

K)  o  s: 

I-' 

CO 

C    W   Tl 

CB   n>   3* 

DJ    H    H- 

3      »      !-• 

D"    H. 

n      -o 

3-  po  <a 

t*  c 

K-    O    --^ 

a  x*  1-' 

►1    (t>    c» 

»   I   ro 

w  •     o\ 

en          1 

^^ 

a 

3 

9 

O 

01 

►* 

P 

c 

"< 

I-* 

00 

0. 

o 

yjy 

w 

n 

H> 

>-' 

(-• 

a 

t# 

H- 

CO 

«-• 

N 

w 

o 

t- 

<— ' 

n 

o 

t-' 

3* 

•T3 

3 

3* 

» 

H- 

0 

S 

I-' 

a 

w 

o 

03 

I-' 

3- 

H- 

H- 

^^ 

N 

I-- 

I-' 

0> 

O. 

00 

u- 

n 

to 

n 

n 

VO 

S 

> 

9 

O. 

•-* 

n 

00 

M 

N> 

n 

O 

o 

*• 

9 

g=9 

►1 

H- 

vj 

l-J 

(X 

« 

1 

t* 

n 

1-" 

CB 

t-" 

a 

(B 

^N 

CO 

!-■ 

e> 

-J 

9 
0) 

35 


i^i^ 


a  m 


00  9 

►-  > 


s 

CO 

c 

01 

f 

to 

00 

9 

ro 

o 

9 

H- 

o 

I— 

1 

a 

• 

1 

S   S   Ch 
•    •    o 


5 


o 

w 

H» 

o 

I-* 

(-• 

1 

o 

H- 

o 

c 

•o 

rt 

e- 

« 

3* 

» 

<-< 

n 

O 

3 

"Vl 

1 

o 
•1 

^ 

7^ 

►t 

1 

n 

1* 

I-- 

09 

eo 

m 

O 

ui 

g 

9 

^ 

<:  n 


to 

C  f 
n  00 
?r  00 

A    00 


S  w 


^  o 

00  » 

VO  • 

1  I-' 
^  00 

00  to 

00  to 


f 

P) 

CO  s* 

ro 

N>  o 

V 

3- 

H- 

►fl 

f-" 

n 

& 

(0 

n 

n 

a 

• 

CO 

n 

Ci 

» 

j-v 

« 

i-^ 

• 

00 

o 

?« 

w 

f 

»« 

00 

o 

\o 

•    o 

A 


M  O. 
I-*  1 
H-  » 

N  a 

»    0) 

ft  (-• 

3*  >>l 


ft  00 
09  C 
A    \0 


<-< 

cr  0) 

o 

o 

•^   o 

3- 

3* 

9 

9 

9 

3- 

A    O 

se 

Ui 

•1    H> 

>-h  o 

CO 

9 

H-   O 

pf 

A 

»1    1 

g 

H 

CO    O 

9 

>.^ 

ft  rr 

A 

3* 

n 

3-VJ 

C 

x-\ 

w   ^0 

O-   3- 

0>    H- 

3    1-- 

a  H- 

1 

»    "o 

^-d 

09 

00 

a  a  •    9 

o    0>  H> 

n  c  f  A 

o  00  00  n 

ft  3*  tn  A 

3*  ft  C 

v<    A  -  O 

M  Hi 

?    O      ff     tH 

H-  Ml  ft  O 
f  »<  09 
H-  C_  A 

"O    O    W  -o 
09    09    ►-   3" 
■^  A    H- 
•O    N    ffl 
3*  •      3* 


3* 
^-  9 
°°  _- 


»    I-- 
3*  1 

z:  (B 


36 
OTHER  EARLY  SETTLERS 

In  addition  to  Philip  Philips  and  Michael  Campbell,  there  were  others 
who  received  land  grants  in  the  area  to  become  known  as  Dilton.    Some  of 
these  men  were  Archibald  Lytle,     Thomas  Yeardley  (E,  421),   Henry  Winburn 
(D,  333),  Howell  Tatum  and  Henry  Wiggin  (C,  296),  Thomas  Love  as  assignee 
of  Giles  Brooks  (B,118),   and  Thomas  Harris  (A,  30).     Lytle  Creek,   a 
branch  of  the  West  Fork  of  Stones  River,    is  believed  to  have  been  named 
for  Archibald  Lytle  who,   in  1786,   received  7,  200  acres  through  which  the 
creek  ran. 

Some  of  the  men  who  purchased  land  in  the  Black  Fox  Spring  area 
between  1803  and  1810  were  William  Kelton  (A,  30),  Joel  Childress,  ^ 
Zebulon  Jetton  (H,  305),  James  Wilson  {F,493).  Isaac  Jetton  {S,185;  H,  305), 
John  Jetton  (A,  36),  John  Lawrence  (A,  35),  David  Fleming  (F,  494),  James 
Montgomery  (B,96),  John  Cummings  (A,  30),  James  Hawkins  (A,  29),  James 

Conway  (B,70),   Hugh  Montgomery  (B,139),  John  Kirk  (B,117),  Andrew 

3 

Miller  (E,  434),  Thomas  Yeardley  (E,  421),  and  Joseph  Marlin  (L,525). 

Census  records  for  1850  and  deed  records  disclose  other  land  owners 
in  the  community  during  the  years  prior  to  the  Civil  War.     Some  of  these 
were  John  Lawrence,   James  Wilson,   Bennett  Smith,   James  Neely,   Robert 
Bates,  John  Fulks,  Joseph  Philips,  John  W.   Childress,  William  D.  Nelson, 
John  Fleming,  William  Kelton,  James  Kelton,  Daniel  Maberry,  John  Kirk, 

^  Betty  G.   Cartwright  (comp.).  North  Carolina  Land  Grants  in 
Tennessee,  1778-1791  (Memphis:  Nortex,  1958),  p.  81,   see  also  Rutherford 
County,  Deed  Book  D,   p.  33. 

2  Register's  Office,  Davidson  Co.  ,   Tenn.  ,  Deed  Book  F,  p.  75. 

3  Register's  Office,   Rutherford  Co.  ,   Tenn.  ,   Deed  Books  with  page 
numbers  have  been  placed  in  parentheses  by  the  names  of  the  grantees. 


'  '  37 

Hugh  Kirk,   Samuel  H.   Hodge,   William  M.    Moore,   and  Samuel,   John  and 

William  Bellah.l    The  Bellah  Cemetery,  one  half  mile  southwest  of  Black 

Fox  Spring,   is  one  of  the  oldest  cemeteries  in  Rutherford  County.  ^ 

Hugh  Kirk,   Sr.  ,  owned  the  farm  on  the  west  side  of  Isaac  Jetton's 

farm  and  north  of  Roy  E.   Tarwater's  farm.  ^    Several  years  ago,   Hugh 

Kirk,   Jr.   recalled  for  Mr.   Tarwater  that  his  father  had  an  apple  orchard 

extending  from  one  end  of  his  farm  to  the  other  along  the  edge  of  the  Bradyville 

Pike.     Each  year  Mr.   Kirk  took  a  wagon  load  of  apples  to  a  still  in  Bradyville 

to  have  them  processed  into  a  barrel  of  apple  brandy.  "^   A  plat  in  Deed 

Book  S,  page  185,   reveals  the  location  of  land  owned  by  John  Lawrence 

and  Isaac  Jetton  in  relation  to  that  known  to  have  been  owned  by  Hugh  Kirk. 

Isaac  Jetton's  home  seems  to  have  been  located  across  the  road  from 

the  Dilton  Store  and  about  one  fourth  to  one  half  mile  to  the  northwest. 

The  house  burned  in  1863  during  the  Civil  War  and  Isaac  Jetton  died  in 

the  following  year.  ^    Among  his  many  descendants  is  Mrs.  Clarence  Rogers 

(nee  "Totsie"  Overall)  who  still  owns  some  of  the  property  which  once  belonged 

to  the  Jettons  and  Overalls.     Mrs.  Rogers'  grandmother  was  Mary  Louise 

Jetton  Overall,  a  granddaughter  of  Isaac  Jetton. 

^Census  of  Rutherford  County,  1850  (Nashville:  Deane  Porch,  1967). 

'^    Rutherford  County,  Tennessee  Cemeteries  (Murfreesboro: 
Rutherford  County  Historical  Society,  1975)    vol.   2,  pp.  4,  5. 

^  Register's  Office,  Ruth.  Co.,  T  enn.  ,  Deed  Book  S,  p.  185. 

4  Interview  with  Roy  E.  Tarwater,  December,  1975. 

^  Register's  Office,  Ruth.   Co.,  T  enn.  ,  Deed  Book  14,  p.  563. 
(That  the  Dilton  area  had  a  significant  role  during  the  Civil  War  is  also 
attested  to  by  Mrs.   Clemmie  Ring  who  recalls  that  the  property  presently 
owned  by  Mrs.   B.  F.   Todd  was  known  as  "The  Quarter"  during  the  late 
1800 's.     A  quarter  master  depot  where  Confederate  soldiers  picked  up  sup- 
plies was  located  at  this  place  just  six-tenths  of  a  mile  to  the  north  of 
B  lack  F  ox  Spring. ) 

6  Interview  with  Mrs.   Clarence  Rogers,  January,  1976. 


38 

According  to  Mrs.   Robert  M.   Sanders,  William  McAllister  Moore 
came  to  Dilton  from    Virginia  in  1859  and  settled  on  a  hill  about  a  mile 
to  the  east  of  the  Dilton  Store  of  today.    A  daughter  named  Mary  was  born 
to  William  and  Margaret  Nesbett  Moore  as  they  made  their  journey  to 
Tennessee  by  covered  wagon.    When  Mary  grew  up,   she  married  William 
Knox.      Their  daughter,   Margaret  Lee,  and  her  husband,  Robert  M. 
Sanders,   live  near  the  Leanna  community  today.     The  hill  on  which  Mrs. 
Sanders'  grandfather  settled  was  named  for  him.     Those  who  have  walked 
to  the  top  of  Moore  Hill  have  been  rewarded  with  a  splendid,  pastoral 
view  of  the  Dilton  countryside. 

OUTSTANDING  POST  CIVIL  WAR  FAMILIES 

Two  men  known  to  have  lived  in  the  Dilton  area  in  the  post  Civil 
War  years  who  have  brief  biographical  sketches  in  the  Goodspeed  His- 
tories are  Dr.   Robert  N.  Knox    and  John  A.   Gilley.    According  to  Goodspeed, 
Dr.   Knox,   born  in  1846,   was  a  Baptist,   a  democrat,   and  a  Civil  War 
veteran;  he  was  a  physician  as  well  as  a  farmer,  and  a  member  of  the 
Rutherford  County  Medical  Society,  who  had  articles  published  in  the 
Nashville  Journal  of  Medicine  and  Surgery.  ^    Two  children,   Sallie  and 

O 

William,  were  born  to  Dr.   and  Mrs.  Knox  (nee  Lucy  Catherine  Fox).  "^ 


1  Interview  with  Mrs.  Robert  M.   Sanders,  January,  1976. 

2  Goodspeed,  p.  817. 

3  Ibid. ,  p.  1046. 


39 
Goodspeed  records  the  following  facts  about  John  A.  Gilley  (1843- 
1917):    After  a  period  of  service  in  the  Civil  War  which  culminated  in  his 
capture  and  imprisonment  for  two  months,  Mr.  Gilley  was  released. 
In  1878,  he  moved  his  family  from  Big  Springs  to  the  Dilton  community. 
Four  sons  (Ephraim  D.  ,  John  F.  ,  Jessie  P.  ,  and  Arthur  T. )  were  born 
to  John  and  Nancy  McCrary  Gilley.  -^    Their  names  may  be  seen  on  the 
1915  map  of  Rutherford  County,  the  Dilton  portion  of  which  has  been  repro- 
duced and  included  with  this  history.    William  A.  Gilley,   son  of  Ephraim, 
and  James  W.  Gilley,   son  of  Jesse,  live  at  Dilton  today  on  land  inherited 
from  their  fathers. 

A  biographical  sketch  of  Reuben  C.   Harrell  has  been  written  by  his 
great  grandson  Raymond  B.   Harrell.     Harrell  is  spelled  as  "Heared" 
on  the  1878  map.    According  to  the  author  of  the  sketch,  the  name  Harrell 
has  been  spelled  and  pronounced  many  different  ways  over  the  years. 
Raymond  Harrell 's  sketch  supplied  vivid  details  about  a  man  of  integrity 
whose  word  was  as  good  as  his  bond.     The  following  information  is  para- 
phrased from  his  sketch. 

Having  once  been  denied  credit  at  a  store  when  a  young  man,  Reuben 
Harrell  resolved  never  to  charge  anything  again,  but  rather  to  pay  cash 
at  the  time  of  purchase.    Because  of  his  extraordinary  thriftiaess,  his 
astuteness  as  a  trader,  and  his  willingness  to  work  hard,  he  had  no  trouble 
keeping  this  resolution.     His  "bank"  was  an  old  pair  of  overalls  with  a 
knot  tied  in  one  leg  to  keep  his  money  from  falling  through,   and  his  "purse" 

1  Ibid.  ,  p.  1036. 


40 

was  his  boot.    Periodically,  he  took  the  money  he  had  accumvilated  to  the 
bank,  not  for  deposit,  but  to  exchange  it  into  bills  of  large  denominations. 
When  he.  had  accumulated  enough  money,  he  would  buy  a  farm  and  pay  cash 
for  it,  which  he  pulled  from  one  of  his  boots.    Mr.  Harrell,  known  as 
"Greenback  Rube",  continued  in  this  fashion  until  he  had  purchased  a 
large  number  of  farms  between  Bradyville  and  Murfreesboro.     His  name 
appears  many  times  in  the  indexes  to  the  deed  records.    Reuben  Harrell 
had  seven  children,  for  whom  he  provided  educational  opportunities  which 
he  had  lacked.     Their  names  were  James  N.  ,  Thomas,  John  Wesley, 
Elisha  M.  ,  Lorenzo  Dow,  William  L.  and  Matilda.  ^ 

Elisha  Monroe  Harrell,  well  educated  for  his  time,  became  a  suc- 
cessful Methodist  minister.     The  house  which  he  inherited  from  his  father 
was  originally  the  home  of  Captain  Ed  Arnold,  one  of  Nathan  Bedford 

Forrest's  officers,  and  is  described  in  Hearthstones,  ^  as  is  the  home 

3 

which  was  owned  by  Lorenzo  Dow  Harrell,  later  known  as  Bellwood. 

Reuben  and  Catherine  Hastings  Harrell  were  buried  in  a  vault  in  the 
Harrell  Cemetery  located  on  the  farm  at  Dilton    on  which  Mr.   Harrell 
lived  until  his  death  in  1899  at  seventy-two  years  of  age. 

Mr.  and  Mrs.  William  Henderson  (nee  Fannie  Bell  Jarman)  lived 
for  many  years  as  well-known  and  respected  members  of  the  Dilton 

1  Raymond  B.  Harrell,   "The  Harrell  Generations"  (Mss.  .  n.d. ) 

n.  pag. 

2  Mary  B.  Hughes,  Hearthstones  (Murfreesboro;  Mid  South,  1942), 
p.  11.  ^Ibid.  ,  p.  12. 

4  Rutherford  County.  Tenn.   Cemeteries   (Murfreesboro:  Rutherford 
Co.  Historical  Society,  1975),  vol.   2,  pp.  81,  82.     The  Harrell  Cemetery  is 
Cemetery  no.   93  on  the  map  of  the  Dilton  Quadrangle  in  this  volume. 


41 

community.     Their  daughter,   Mrs.   lanthia  Ross,   has  provided  the  follow- 
ing information  about  her  father.  ■'■    Born  into  slavery  in  1862,   William 
Henderson  lived  almost  the  entirety  of  his  ninety-two  years  as  a  free  man. 
After  the  slaves  were  freed,  his  grandmother  and  her  husband  purchased 
a  small  farm  at  Dilton,  which  at  the  grandmother's  death,  became  Mr. 
Henderson's.    Later,   he  purchased  additional  land,  all  of  which  is  still 
owned  by  his  daughter,   Mrs.  Ross,  who  lives  in  Nashville,  Tennessee. 
In  addition  to  his  farming  activity,  Mr.  Henderson  was  a  blacksmith  who       ^ 
could  design  anything  out  of  iron  or  wood.     He  worked  as  a  barber  and 
as  a  cobbler.     Having  learned  to  make  medicine  and  liniment,   he  was 
often  called  upon  by  his  neighbors  to  lance  a  boil  or  to  administer  medical 
aid  to  a  person  or  an  animal.     After  planting  a  garden  for  his  family, 
Mr.  Henderson  planted  another  for  anyone  in  the  neighborhood  who  needed 
vegetables.     He  once  gave  one  of  the  last  two  sides  of  meat  in  his  smoke- 
house to  a  man  who  was  in  need.    A   minister  for  sixty-two  years,  he  ^ 
preached  for  a  number  of  churches,   including  Prosperity  Baptist  Church 
at  Dilton  and  Mt.   Zion  in  Murfreesboro.     Mr.  Henderson  was  a  self- 
educated  man  with  a  library  composed  of  an  eight-volume  set  of  Shakespeare, 
a  let  of  leather  bound  encyclopedias,   many  books  about  the  Bible,  books 
about  the  presidents  and  books  of  poetry.     He  never  sat  down  without  a 
book  in  his  hand  and  a  stack  of  books  beside  his  chair.    Appreciative  of 
his  opportunity  to  vote,   he  only  missed  voting  once  in  his  life  and  that 

■^  Letter  from  Mrs.  lanthia  Henderson  Ross,  April  7,  1976. 


42 

was  due  to  an  illness  which  confined  him  to  the  hospital.!    Those  in  the  -^ 

community  who  knew  William  Henderson  remember  him  as  a  large,    strong 
man  with  a  good  mind  and  a  generous  heart,    who  practiced  the  Bible  princi- 
ples he  preached.  2 

When  a  post  office  was  established  at  Dr.   James  Madison  Dill's 
store  in  1887,    the  community  officially  acquired  the  name  of  Dilton.  '^^ 
Dr.   Dill  and  his  first  wife,    Jestina  Kelton  (a  descendant  of  William  and 
Elizabeth  Kelton^)     had  lived  in  Carlocksville,   a  community  south  of 
Dilton  which  may  be  seen  on  the  1878  map  of  Rutherford  County.     Jestina 
Dill   died  in  1880;  in  1883,   Dr.   Dill  moved  into  the  community  which  was 
destined  to  be  named  for  him  and  married  Mary  Catherine  Hill,   the 
daughter  of  James  and  Olivia  Hutchinson  Hill.  5 

Mary  Hill  Dill  was  known  not  only  for  her  talkativeness  and  outspoken 
manner,   but  also  for  her  charitable  nature,   and  for  her  excellent  knowledge 
of  the  Bible.     Her  grandson,   Raymond  Harrell,    remembers  her  best  as 
a  tall,   thin,   white-haired  woman  sitting  by  the  fireside  with  a  Bible  in 
hand,    smoking  her  pipe  and   telling  Bible  or  family  stories  to  her  grand- 
children. ^ 

Dr.  Dill,   who  had  a  lovable  and  humble  disposition,   was  willing  to 
serve  anyone  in  the  community  regardless  of  his  ability  or  inability  to 

^  Letter  from  Mrs.   lanthia  Henderson  Ross,   April  7,   197  6. 

2  Interview  with  William  Hoyt  Smith,   April,   197  6. 

■^  Raymond  B.   Harrell,   "The  Dill  Family"  (Mss.  ,   n.d.),   n.   pag. 

'^Armstrong,   p.  228. 

5  Raymond  B.   Harrell,    "The  Dill  Family"  (Mss.,    n.d.),   n.   pag. 

6  Ibid. 


43 

pay  for  those  services.     He  is  said  to  have  been  a  friend  to  everybody 

but  himself.     Jack  R.   Mankin,   in  his  autobiography,   writes,   "Papa  said 
he  went  into  his  store  one  day  to  buy  two  spools  of  thread  but  Dr.  Dill 
only  had  two,   so  he  said  "John,   I  can't  sell  you  but  one  of  them  because 
someone  else  might  come  along  and  want  the  other  one.  '"      Even  so, 
his  work  as  storekeeper  and  postmaster  was  probably  necessary  to  his 
financial  survival  because  he  never  sent  anyone  a  bill.     When  he  was  paid 
for  administering  medical  aid,   it  was  often  with  farm  produce.     Dr.   Dill 
received  his  medical  training  from  the  University  of  Nashville  Medical 
School.     He  is  listed  in  the  school's  catalog  of  students  in  1856  and  1857. 

Some  of  the  later  catalogs  are  missing,   making  it  impossible  to  deter- 

2 
mine  the  year  of  his  graduation.       He  was  a  member  of  the  Rutherford 

County  Medical  Society  and  was  a  democrat.  ^ 

Dr.  Dill  and  his  wife,  Mary,   are  credited  with  having  founded  the 

Dilton  Church  of  Christ,   which  met  in  their  home  until  it  acquired  a 

building  in  1894.       Their  home  was  situated  on  property  indicated  on  the 

Beers  map  of  1878  as  owned  by  J.  W.  Jacobs.    Those  who  remember  visiting 

the  Dill  home  describe  it  as  a  six- room  log  structure  with  an  upstairs 

bedroom  and  an  enclosed  back  porch,   which  was  used  as  a  bedroom.     A 


1  Jack  R.    Mankin,   "Autobiography"  (Ms.,   n.  d. ),  p.  155. 

2  Raymond  B.   Harrell,    "The  Dill  Family"  )Mss.  ,   n.  d.),   n.  pag. 

3  Goodspeed,  p.  1031. 

^  Register's  Office,  Rutherford  Co. ,  Tenn.  ,  Deed  Book  35,  p.  517. 


44 

yuest  bedroom  was  maintained  for  use  by  the  preachers  who  came  and 

went. 

On  June  23,   1916,  Dr.  Dill  died  at  the  age  of  eighty-four.     He  was 
survived  by  his  wife,   Mary;  their  children,  Kate,  Annie,   and  Scobey; 

and  one  son,   Joseph,   by  his  first  wife.     Mrs.   Dill  died  in  1928  as  a  result 

2 
of  injury  incurred  from  smoke  inhalation  when  her  home  burned  in  1927. 

Ilcr  widowed  daughter,  Annie  (Mrs.   Oscar  Harrell)  and  Mrs.   Harrell's 

children  were  living  with  her  at  the  time  of  the  fire.     A  new  house  was 

built  by  the  people  of  Dilton  for  this  family.     It  was  a  small  contribution 

in  comparison  to  all  that  Dr.   and  Mrs.   J.M.  Dill  had  done  for  the  Cora- 
's 

munity. 

In  the  late  1870 's,   three  brothers  named  J.   Philip  (1833-1904),  A. 
Jackson  (1838-1913),   and  Benton  P.  Mankin  (1843-1921)  moved  into  the 
Dilton  area.     Philip  and  his  wife,   Jane  Robinson  (1836-1901),   had  two  sons, 
John  Benton  and  Welcom  Hodge.     Their  homeplace  was  situated  just  south- 
west of  the  point  where  Dilton-Mankin  Lane  today  crosses  Lytle  Creek. 
Jackson  Mankin  settled  across  the  road  from  Philip.     He  and  his  wife, 
Fannie  Miller  (1838-88),   had  three  children:  Oscar,   Horace,   and  Irene. 
Oscar  was  for  many  years  a  magistrate  on  the  county  court  and  was  known 

1  Interview  with  William  Hoyt  Smith,   March,   1976. 

2  Raymond  B.   Harrell,    "The  Dill  Family"  (Mss.  ,   n.  d.),   n.  pag. 

2  Interview  with  William  Hoyt  Smith,  March,  1976.  The  house  is 
presently  owned  by  the  Dill's  granddaughter,  Mrs.  Houston  Brown  (nee 
Mary  Catherine  Harrell). 


45 

as  "Square"  Mankin  not  out  of  disrespect  but  because  of  local  custom.  ^ 
Benton  P.   Mankin  settled  on  the  east  side  of  the  Manchester  Pike  about  two 

and  one-half  miles  south  of  Murfreesboro.     He  and  his  first  wife,  Alice  F. 

2 
Hearn  (1853-1882),  had  two  daughters,   Mardilla  H.   and  Mary  L.       By  his 

second  wife,   Sally  Atkinson  (1851-1935)  he  had  one  daughter,  Jessie,  who  died 

early.  ^    All  three  brothers  were  veterans  of  the  Confederate  army  and  are 

believed  to  have  fought  in  the  battle  of  Murfreesboro.  '^    There  were  so  many 

Mankins  in  the  community  by  1900  that  the  little  hamlet  which  grew  up  at  the 

intersection  of  the  Manchester  Road  and  the  lane  which  led  to  Dilton  became 

known  as  Mankinville.  ^ 


^  The  title  "Square"  is  derived  from  the  Middle  English  title  Squire  or 
Esquire  sometimes  applied  to  certain  public  officials  in  the  United  States 
such  as  magistrates. 

2  Mary  L.   Mankin  became  the  wife  of  A.  T.  Gilley  of  the  Dilton 
Community. 

•^  Goodspeed,   p.  1049. 

4  Interview  with  Jack  R.   Mankin,  August,  1976. 

5  Interview  with  Mr.   Mankin,  August,   1976.     Mr.   J.  R.   Mankin  is  a 
son  of  John  Benton  and  Octavia  Hendricks  Mankin,   and  grandson  of  J.   Philip 
and  Jane  Robinson  Mankin  all  of  whom  lived  in  the  Dilton  community  for  vari- 
ous periods  of  time.     His  great  grandparents  were  John  (1798-1883)  and 
Elizabeth  Hodge  Mankin  (1800-1878),   who  came  to  Tennessee  from  North 
Carolina  and  settled  in  the  Big  Springs  community  a  few  miles  south  of  Dilton. 
John  and  Elizabeth  Mankin  were  the  parents  of  eleven  children  who  lived  to 
adulthood. 


-i^-S^i^  ^XbHsftinw^ 


•  itu>.Broi]iberg 

•  AltiM  Sundeti 


•W4..f<at,tt 


B.6.H 
'jiim,,,  Conch 


L  »  Mrt.nogers 
s  Qrc«Q 


\  .  B  U.nendereon  \  ^ISo-r  JoiiijN/,^t 

\lowe         J^  ^ 

j.r.Pukett  \        y^ 


T.O., 


;^        \  [.A.W00A        '"/"•""o 

^;>iKS.     ...     X 

A^Dr&adons  Form  I  XJ  Ear? 
F.Jo  hi 


. — .'jemlgan 


-Sfflltli , 
ChoB 


•Vi'f    -Ar  l^ettle  Zumbro   °"»" 
/       /.fciSuc.F^filaod  N 


'"'ft'u-'"""- 


,/oB*) 


Ski  >  t*.  ":^;  n}"^  ■ 


■X: 


S^'-::-^^ 


^Ai*^^^?*"™***- 


ISam.ril 


LAdC«»' 


BA1cxmatf«r 
LnUa 


•von  TisM< 


Luks 
Anitt*?'       J 


\,  :■■■■■: ^^r^t^^:  : 

--■      t-  '■  -  *■     '■•it     '^'• 


^<°K 


=?^' 


,U>Tttn  Boov 


■y^-'y^- 


:/■.> 


■'  ■  -V  V 


•^ 


-•  r  C*  •i«:?i ■        jflrSir*  w-.j?3Ei^i.^ -v*»-'^\      -It     ■  ■■; 'n  -  •»"- •  •■ -i"--»,  <•  .  \  t^*^    -sltA   ••^J^BU^SKfcV*"'^ 


47 

FOLKLORE  AND  FOLK  MEDICINE 
Dr.   Dill  was  a  trusted  friend  and  physician  to  the  community,   but  the 
people  had  confidence  in  their  home  remedies  as  well.     Joe  Jernigan,   who 
lived  at  Dilton  in  the  late  1800's  and  early  1900's  remembers  that  asafetida, 
coal  oil  and  sugar  and  sassafras  were  frequently  used  for  medicinal  purposes. 
Asafetida  bags  were  put  on  strings  and  placed  around  the  necks  of  children  to 
ward  off  colds  and  fevers.     It  had  a  strong  and  impleasant  odor,   which  could 
keep  all  children  at  a  distance,    including  those  with  colds  or  fever.     This  may 
have  been  the  reason  for  its  effectiveness.     Coal  oil  and  sugar  was  the  medi- 
cine used  for  croup  both  externally  and  internally,   and  a  mixture  of  turpentine 
and  lard  was  applied  to  the  chest  of  children  with  bronchial  colds.     Sassafras 
tea  was  made  from  the  dried  bark  of  roots  of  the  sassafras  tree  which  were 
boiled  in  water.     This  was  a  favorite  of  the  people  who  believed  it  would  help 
them  stay  well.^    In  the  decade  between  1910  and  1920,   a  child  was  believed 
to  have  "caught"  pellagra  by  eating  too  much  corn  bread.  ^    In  Joel  Childress' 
time,   there  were  "bleeders"  in  the  community  who  were  called  to  the  home 
of  an  ailing    person  to  draw  blood  from  him.     Major  Woods  said  that  the 
tin  cup  which  his  mother  had  bought  for  him  at  Joel  Childress'  store  was  put 

to  use  as  a  receptacle  for  the  blood  drawn  off  from  those  in  the  family  who 

3 
wore  .sick;  this,   he  said,    separated  him  from  his  cup. 

When  the  children  of  Dow  Harrell  misbehaved,   it  did  not  take  long  for 

"Aunt  Jo"  to  bring  them  back  into  line.     Mrs.   Annie  Harrell  Smith  knew 


1  Interview  with  Mr.   Joe  J.   Jernigan,  December,  1975. 

2  Letter  from  Jack  R.   Mankin,   January  12,   197  6. 

3  Nashville,   Daily  American,   October  9,   1884,   p.  5. 


48 

about  this  from  her  own  experience  as  a  child.     When  Annie  and  her  sister 
Clemmie  were  young  children,   their  mother  died.     Mrs.   Jo  Lasseter,   house- 
keeper for  the  Harrells,   was  given  the  added  duty  of  caring  for  them.     When 
Annie  and  Clemmie  were  bad  children,  they  were  told  that ''old  bloody  head  and 
raw  bones"  would  get  them  if  they  didn't  behave.     This  prospect  sent  shivers 
down  their  spines  and  they  instantly  reformed  their  behavior.        They  were 

told  that  this  sinister  creature  lurked  about  near  the  apple  barrell  in  a  dark 

2 
hallway.       It  may  be  that  some  children  in  the  community  were  frightened 

during  the  Civil  War  by  soldiers  who  had  bloody  heads  and  raw  bones;  hence 

its  use  later  to  scare  children  into  good  behavior  and  to  make  the  apples  last 

longerl 

A  small  pox  epidemic  in  the  1890's  caused  terrible  misery  for  many 

3 
and  even  death  for  a  few  people  in  the  community,     but  there  is  a  legend  that 

it  did  one  man  some  good.    One  of  the  community's  prominent  citizens  who 

lived  no  more  than  a  mile  from  the  present  Dilton  store  had  a  son  who  was 

the  "black  sheep"  of  the  family.     At  the  time  of  the  small  pox  epidemic,   the 

young  man  was  said  to  be  in  jail,   which  was  his  frequent  habitat.     Some  said 

he  died  in  jail  of  this  dreaded  disease,   but  others  believed  he  was  "buried 

out  of  jail.  "    On  the  day  he  was  buried,   the  father  rode  his  mule  ahead  of  the 

son's  casket,   which  rested  on  a  horse  drawn  cart,   and  warned  the  people 


■'•  Interview  with  Charles  B.   Smith,   grandson  of  Ernest  and  Annie 
Harrell  Smith,  July,   1976    . 

2   Interview  with  Mrs.    Clemmie  Harrell  Ring,   August,    197  6. 
•^  Interview  with  Joe  J.   Jernigan,  December,   1975. 


49 


along  the  way  to  stand  back  as  the  coffin  passed  in  order  to  avoid  contagion. 
Some  who  helped  to  carry  the  coffin  from  the  cart  to  the  grave  were  of  the 
opinion  that  it  contained  rocks  rather  than  a  corpse  and  believed  the  supposed 
"corpse"  to  be  well  on  his  way  to  Texas.     There  are  those  who  are  alive  today 
who  know  the  location  of  the  grave,   although  a  tombstone  was  never  placed 

there. 

The  most  widely  known  legend  originating  in  the  area  was  that  of  the 
disappearance  of  the  Black  Fox  in  the  spring  which  now  bears  his  name, 
which  has  been  related  in  a  previous  section  of  this  history. 

UNUSUAL  EVENT 
When  Ernest  Smith  was  in  his  early  twenties  (1891-95),   an  unusual 
event  occurred  which  he  witnessed  as  he  was  putting  his  horse  in  the  barn 
for  the  night.     He  had  been  to  see  a  girl  friend  and  had  just  arrived  home  some 
time  after  dark  when  a  "star"  whizzed  by  the  barn  making  a  sizzling,   hissing 
noise  and  lighting  up  the  countryside  as  it  went.     Ernest  Smith  never  found 
the  object  that  startled  him  that  night,  but  he  told  his  chHdren  and  grand- 
children about  this  unusual  experience  several  times  over  the  years.     It  was 
assumed  tliat  it  could  have  been  a  meteor  and  that  it  probably  burned  itself  " 
out  in  the  atmosphere. 

In  February  of  1976,  almost  ninety  years  later  and  eight  years  after 
Ernest  Smith-s  death,   it  was  learned  by  the  writer  that  a  boy  found  an  object 
hich  may  have  been  a  meteorite  about  two  miles  from  Ernest  Smith's  home - 
place.     In  a  letter  of  February  24,   1976.   Jack  R.   Mankin  wrote  that,   around 
1910,   his  oldest  brother,   Hendrick,   brought  to  the  house  an  object  about  the 


v/ 


50 


size  of  a  skull  which  was  quite  heavy  and  had  a  melted  look  on  the  outside. 
Judging  by  its  weight,   Mr.   Mankin  believes  it  was  an  iron  containing 
meteorite  rather  than  just  stone.     The  Mankin  family  used  it  as  a  door  prop. 
T  he  idea  he  has  of  the  parent  meteorite  is  that  it  is  "roughly  the  size  of  a 
barrel  and  was  almost,   if  not  quite,   buried  in  the   earth."    Since  igneous  rocks 
are  not  found  in  this  area,   he  believes  this  one  to  be  significant.       More 
meteors  are  said  to  survive  their  passage  through  our  atmosphere  in  the  even- 
ing than  in  the  morning  hours.  ^    T  he  parent  meteorite  has  been  an  object  of 
search  in  recent  years  by  several  people,  but  it  has  not  been  located  at  this 
time. 


^  Letter  from  Jack  R  .   Mankin,   F  ebruary  24,   197  6. 
2  Charles  P.  Olivier,   "Meteorite."    Encyclopedia  Americana, 
1974,   Vol.   18,  p.  713b. 


51 
CHURCHES 

The  United  Baptist  Church  of  Christ 

The  Missionary  Baptists  organized  a  church  at  Fletcher's  Schoolhouse 
on  June  9,   1843,   and  for  the  following  six  years  the  church  met  in  this  one 
room  log  structure  which  stood  a  little  more  than  a  mile  from  Murfreesboro 
and  about  two  and  one  half  miles  northwest  of  Black  Fox  Spring.  •'■    Although 
it  was  closer  to  Murfreesboro    than  to  the  spring,    it  is  mentioned  here  because 
it  was  the  first  church  known  to  have  assembled  near  the  Black  Fox  Spring      -^ 
settlement.     Calling  themselves  the  United  Baptist  Church  of  Christ,   they 
selected  Burrell  Gannaway,   John  Mollow,   and  James  Fletcher  as  deacons.  2 
On  August  12,   1843,   the  church  became  affiliated  with  the  Concord  Associa- 
tion and  Joseph  H.   Eaton  was  ordained  to  preach  following  Robert  January 
who  had  served  as  interim  pastor.  3    The  membership  included  slaves  of  the      j 
members  and,   upon  recommendation  from  Eaton  and  January,   the  Associa- 
tion purchased  E.  Kelly  in  1846  from  his  owner  in  order  that  he  might  devote 
his  time  to  preaching  to  those  of  his  race.  ^    In  January  of  1849,   the  congre- 
gation left  its  location  at  Fletcher's  Schoolhouse  and  moved  into  its  new 
building  on  the  corner  of  Sevier  and  Spring  Streets  in  Murfreesboro.  ^ 
Mount  Hermon  Baptist  Church 

Although  Mount  Hermon  Baptist  Church  was  not  established  at  Dilton  until 
1879  when  a  building  was  erected  on  the  chruch's  present  building  site,    it  had 
its  beginnings  on  Cripple  Creek  about  four  miles  east  of  Dilton.     In  a  land 

survey  book  of  Rutherford  County,   1822-1936,   the  surveyor  records  having 

r 

1  Homer  P  ittard,   P  illar  and  G  round  (Murfreesboro,   1968)  ,   p,  9. 

2  Ibid,  .p. 11.       3  Ibid.  ,   p.  14.      ^  Ibid.  ,   p. 18.        ^  jbid^   p.  24. 


52 


surveyed  four  acres  of  land  includiag  the  Cave  Spring  Meeting  House  on 
Cripple  Creek  for  John  Earwood  (sic)  and  Jonathan  Hall,  trustees  for  the 
Baptist  denomination  of  Christians  on  Nov,  5,  1825. ■*■   On  Nov.   2,  1856  its 
members  adopted  the  Articles  of  Faith  and  Church  Convenant;  its 
members  being  Jacob  and  Isack  Yearwood,  John  Stroope,  John  Yearwood 
John  Prater,  Jane  and  Mary  Beasley,  Sally  Cotton,  Samuel  and  Eliza  Cox, 

Samuel  Mitchell,  William  and  Cinthia  Zumbro.  John  McFadden  and  Emily 

2 
Warren.      After  their  building  burned  in  1877,  thejr  worshipped  in  different 

places  until  1879  when  another  building  was  erected  on  the  northeast  comer  of 

Mt.  Hermon  Road  and  Bradyville  Pike  under  the  name  of  Mt.  Hermon  / 

3 
Baptist  Church.       The  original  deed  could  not  be  located,  but  it  is  thought 

that  the  land  was  given  by  Mrs.  Ann  Stewart,  a  daughter  of  Archibald  and 

4 
Margaret  Jetton  Sloan. 

William  Yearwood  was  one  of  the  leaders  of  the  Mt.  Hermon  Church 

in  the  early  1900's.    When  the  men  and  boys  lingered  outside  on  SutfiKiays 

after  worship  had  begun,  Mr.  Yearwood  would  go  to  the  door  and  urge 

them  to  come  in.    He  and  wife  Sarah  Sloan  Yearwood  and  their  large 

family  lived  in  a  two  story,  wiiite  house  with  fancy  bannistered  verandas 

on  the  west  and  south  sides,  both  upstairs  and  downstairs,^    The  house, 


Land  Sirvey,  Rutherford  County,  1822-1836. 

^C.  S,  Abemathy,  "History  of  Cripple  Creek  and  Mt.  Hermon  Baptist 
Church."  (Mimeographed  sheet)  .  Ibid. 

'^Interview  with  Mrs.  Erskine  Thompson  (nee  Mattie  Eugenia  Sloan)  , 
March,  1976,  Mrs,  Thompson    is  a  great  neice  of  Mr.  and  Mrs,  Wm, 
Yearwood. 

^Interview  with  Mrs,  Erskine  Thompson,  March,  1976. 


53 


facing  west,    stood  on  Yearwood  Hill  behind  the  Mt.   Hermon  church  and  could 

be  seen  for  miles  around.     Many  were  invited  to  Sunday  dinners  by  the  Yearwoods 

who  were  known  for  their  plentiful  supply  of  food  and  for  their  hospitality. 

During  the  1930's  Dee  Roberts  and  Ed  Yearwood  were  deacons.     Some  of 
the  members  during  those  years  were  members  of  the  families  of  Jesse  Harrell, 
Ode  Medlock,   Jim  Davenport,    Irvin  Wallace,   Alf  Hayes,   Arthur  Watts,    Byivui 
Sloan,   and  Comer  Jakes.     Ode  Medlock  was  the  father  of  Woodrow  Medlock, 
pastor  of  the  Bellwood  Baptist  Church  in  Murfreesboro;  and  Jesse  Harrell ,   who 
worshipped  at  Mt.   Hermon  for  sixty  years,   was  the  father  of  Mrs.   Medlock. 

In  1939  a  small  frame  building  was  erected  on  the  same  site  to  replace  the 

2 
old  church.       A  deed  was  not  registered  for  the  church  property  until  1958.     As 

one  was  necessary,   Mr.   and  Mrs.   Comer  Jakes  and  Mr.   and  Mrs.   Clint  Medlock 

sold  the  property  for  one  dollar  to  the  Executive  Board  of  the  Tennessee  Baptist 

Convention,   who,   in  turn,   deeded  the  property  to  the  following  trustees  of  Mt. 

Hermon:    Adam  Phillips,   Leo  Harrell,   Dorris  Willard,   Charles  Lowe,   Raymond 

Harrell.       In  1961,   a  pastorum  was  built  and  additional  property  was  purchased 

for  the  church  in  1966  from  W.   M.   Wolfe  and  Lloyd  R.   Wolfe  on  Mt.   Hermon's 

southeast  boundary.       Trustees  at  this  time  were  Cliff  Ghee,   Jr.  ,  J.   H. 

Davenport,   and  James  O.  Rowland.     A  new  brick  educational  unit  was  added 

5 
in  1967  and  the  church  entered  its  new  brick  sanctuary  in  April  of  1971. 


•'•  Interview  with  Mrs.   Jim  Davenport  (nee  Bertha  Tolliver) ,  January  1976. 

^  Abernathy  (Mimeographed  sheet). 

2  Rutherford  Co.  ,  Deed  Book,   125,   pg.   47;  Book  127;  pg.   162. 

^  1972  Directory  of  Mt.   Hermon  Baptist  Church,   pg.    2.  Ibid. 


54 


Through  the  years  the  following  have  served  as  pastors  of  the  Cripple 
Creek  and  Mt.  Hermon  Baptist  Churches:  Pastors  A.  J.  McNabb,  Jared 
Warren,  Hutchinson,  Vance,  Carr,  Grimes,  John  T.  Oakley,  Gregory 
Ogles,   McPherson,  W.  J.  Watson,  W.  G.  Mahaffey,  Jaggers,  Ratcliff, 
S.  P.  Devault,  J.  D.  Barbee.  O.  T.  Drake,  Hoyte  Huddlestou,  Elvin  L. 

Burnett,  J.  O,  Oglesby,  Frank  Messick,   C.   S.   Abemathy,     Lewis  York, 

2 

Eldrich  Dorris,  Nolan  Tobias,   and,   at  the  present  time,  James  A.  Davis. 

Some  have  been  ordained  to  preach  by  the  Mt.  Hermon  Church. 
Woodrow  Medlock  was  ordained  on  the  third  Sunday  of  October,  1937,   and 
on  April  4,  1943,  Frank  Messick  was  ordained.       Later,  Joe  White  was 
ordained,   and  on  May  6,  1973,  Randy  Sledge  was  licensed  to  preach. 
The  deacons  of  the  church  at  this  time  are  Leo  Harrell,  James 

Rowland,  James  Haynes,  Bill  Baines,  Joe  McCluskey,  R.  Q.  Jaco,  and 

5 
Don  Harrell. 

The  Prosperity  Baptist  Church 

About  four  years  after  the  Cripple  Creek  Baptist  Church  was  established, 

the  black  members  of  the  Baptist  faith  established  the  Prosperity  Baptist 

Church.     The  church  first  met  about  1860  in  a  building  on  the  Virgil  Haynes 

place  on  the  northwest  of  Tennie  Beard's  farm,  less  than  a  mile  away  from 

its  present  location.       The  first  building  at  the  present  location  had  been 

Abemathy  (Mimeographed  sheet). 

Interview  with  Mrs.  Bertha  Davenport,  January,  1976. 


y 


Abernathy  (Mimeographed  sheet). 

Intei*view  with  Nathan  Sledge,  January,  1976. 
^  Interview  with  Mrs.  Davenport,  January,  1976. 
^  Interview  with  Robert  Randolph,  February,  1976. 


erected  by  1892  when  the  church  acquired  a  deed  to  its  property;  William  Hope 
deeded  one  acre  to  Zack  Gresham,  William  Fleming,  George  Francis,   and 
Caleb  Jarrett  as  trustees  "in  consideration  of  their  having  erected  a  church 
house  for  the  pui*pose  of  worshipping  Almighty  God  according  to  their  faith 
and  belief  as  they  understand  the  Scriptures. '       The  property  was  bordered 
by  that  of  Taz  Fleming,   Caroline  Las  seter,   and  Rube  McKnight,  "" 

Older  members  remember  its  history.    Robert  Randolph  recalls  several 
facts:  The  first  pastor  known  to  have  served  the  Prosperity  Church  was  William 
Henderson,    William  Henderson,  Taz  Fleming,  and  Simon  Leigh  were  leaders 
of  this  church  during  the  latter  part  of  the  nineteenth  century  and  the  earJy     ^ 
part  of  the  twentieth  century.    Other  pastors  who  have  served  were  Lewis 
McCord,  Charles  Evans,  Aron  Jordan,  Hendrix,  J.  T.  Ridley,  Charles 

Vanderleer,  Harry  Alexander,  George  Wade,  Marcel  Kellar,   and  Jolm  Oscar 

3 
Jordan,  who  is  pastor  at  the  present  time.       Tennie  Beard  said  that  his 

father,  Albert  Beard,  and  Bill  Fleming  bought  a  bell  for  the  first  church  con- 
structed on  the  present  site,  but  the  bell  has  not  been  used  by  the  church  since 
its  present  building  was  constructed  in  1960.     The  old  bell,   a  five  tone  bel] 

weighing  fifty  poiuids,   is  now  iii  the  possession  of  Mr.   Beard,   the  oldest 

4  , 

deacon  in  the  Prosperity  Baptist  Church  at  this  time. 

According  to  Mrs.   Sarah  Lyons,   some  of  the  leaders  during  the  early 

years  of  this  century  were  her  father,  Nels  Lasseter,  Mr.  and  Mrs.  ^ 

William  Henderson,  Mrs.  Lizzie  Gris so m,   and  Mrs.   Sarah  Ldgh. 

•'Register's  Office,  Ruth.   Co.,   Tenn, ,  Deed  Book  34,   p.   52. 

2  Ibid.  IntervieTW  with  Robert  Randolph,  February,   1976. 

^Interview  with  Tennie  Beard,   February,  1976. 


56 


Mrs.  Lyons'  son,   Samuel  McHenry  Lyons,  was  ordained  to  preach  at  the 
Prosperity  Baptist  Church  aad  serves  as  pastor  of  the  Cedar  Grove  Baptist 
Church  in  Eagleville.      Simon  and  Sarah  Leigh's  daughter,  Mrs.  Mollie  Leigh 

Jones,  has  served  her  commimity  as  a  teacher  and  later  served  throughout 

2 
Middle  Tennessee  as  a  registered  nurse.       The  Leigh's  grandson.  Judge  Luther 

Glanton,  Jr.  of  Des  Moines,  Iowa,  has  been  nominated  for  District  Court 

Judge  by  the  Des  Moines  Chamber  of  Commerce  whose  nominating  commission 

said  he  "has  been  an  invaluable  asset  to  the  commuinity  and  has  conducted 

3 
himself  in  the  highest  tradition  of  the  court.  "      Judge  Glanton' s  father, 

Luther  Glanton,   Sr. ,   served  as  a  teacher  at  Dilton's  Gladeview  School  during 
the  193  O's.^ 

Robert  Randolph  reports  that  the  deacons  in  the  Prosperity  Church  of  today 
are  Tennie  Beard,  James  Randolph,  Kenneth  James,  James  Beard,  Charles 
Bass,  George  Sneed,   and  himself.    Tolbert  Sawyer  Randolph,   son  of  Robert 
and  Mary  Randolph  was  ordained  at  this  church,  but  presently  preaches  for 
the  Hurricane  Creek  Baptist  Church  near  Shelbyville.      The  Prosperity  Baptist 
Church  has  about  sixty  members  at  the  present  time„ 
Morgan's  Chapel  /  Pleas aat  Grove  Church 

Although  no  longer  in  use,  the  building  of  the  Pleasant  Grove  Methodist 
Church  still  stands  on  the  east  side  of  the  Dilton  Cemetery.    On  Sept.  15,  1873, 

1  2 

Interview  with  Mrs.  Sarah  Lasseter  Lyons^  Dec,  1976.        Ibid. 

^  Murfreesboro,  Daily  News  Journal,  Aug.   22,  1976,  p.   20. 

Rutherford  Co. ,  School  Supt. ,  School  Records,  Gladeview  folder. 

Interview  with  Mrs.  Mary  Goodman  Randolph,   March,  1976. 
^  Interview  with  Tennie  Beard,  January,  1976. 


57 


Nacc  S.  Overall  deeded  to  B.   M.   Neal,  Robert  M.  Ward,   W„  P,   Henderson, 
John  W.  Overall,  W.  T.  Overall,  W.  F.  OveraU,  and  Nace  S.  Overall  (in- 
cluding himself)  one  acre  of  laxid  for  the  use  of  the  Methodist  Episcopal  Church 
South.      The  building  was  probably  completed  in  1874  and  was  used  as  a 
subscription  school  as  well  as  a  meeting  place  for  the  church.       The  studs  of 
the  building  are  of  hewed  cedar  poles  and  the  nails  are  square. 

In  1878  the  church  was  known  as  Morgan's  Chapel  and  is  labeled  as  such 
on  tlie  Beers  Map.     We  know  from  a  descendant  of  William  McAllister  Moore, 
for  whom  Moore  Hill  was  named,  that  he  was  a  member  of  this  church  in  the 
early  days  of  its  existence.  '*    Reuben  and  Catherine  Harrell,  who  had  moved 
into  the  neighborhood  by  this  time,  were  members,  and  their  son,  E.   M. 

Harrell,  later  an  elder  of  the  Murfreesboro  district  of  the  Methodist  Episcopal 

5 
Church  South,  often  preached  at  Pleasant  Grove.        Pastor  Tucker  is  said  to 

have  preached  for  the  church  around  1896,       It  is  not  known  for  whom  Morgan's 

Chapel  was  named,  but  it  is  reasonable  to  assume  that  it  was  named  for  a 

man  who  preached  there.    J.  W.  Cullom  mentions  in  his  book.  Warm  Hearts 

ajid  Saddlebags,   a  Methodist  minister  named  G.  A.  Morgan  who  preached  a 

7 
funeral  of  a  prominent  man  in  Murfreesboro  in  1906. 

H.  E.  Baker,  pastor  of  the  Pleasant  Grove  Church  in  1919  and  1920,  re- 
called that  stewards  at  that  time  were  John  Overall,  William  Knox,   and  James 

■'•Register's  Office,  Ruth.  Co,,  Tenn. ,  Deed  Book  19,  p.  349. 

Ibid.  3 Interview  with  Roy  E.  Tarwater,  December,  1975. 

^Interview  with  Mrs.  Margaret  Lee  Knox  Sanders,  January,  1976, 
^Interview  with  Mrs.  Clemmie  Harrell  Ring,  February,  1976. 
6 Ibid.  "^J.  W.  CuUum,  Warm  Hearts  and  Saddlebags  (n.p.),  p.   241. 


58 
Delbridge  and  that  John  Overall  was  song  leader  and  the  keeper  of  the  keys 

to  the  building.    Mr.    Baker  remembered  staying  often  in  the  home  of  L.  D  . 
Harrell  when  he  came  here  from  Woodbury  to  preach.    Other  members  at  this 
time  included  the  Robert  N.  Justice,  George  Weeks,  and  William  Elrod  families, 
Mrs.   Jesse  Gilley,   Mr.   W.   Frank  Overall,   and  Mr.   Tom  Overall.  1    Uncle 
Dave  Macon,   of  Grand  Ole  Opry  fame,   visited  the  church  from  time  to  time 
and  led  singing  on  some  occasions. 2 

In  the  late  1920's,   Neal  D.   Frazier,   an  English  professor  at  Middle 
Tennessee  State  Normal  School  in  Murfreesboro,    served  the  Pleasant  Grove 
Church  witn  one  afternoon  service  a  month.  3    James  Reed  Cox,   now 
Tennessee  Conference  Historian  of  the  United  Methodist  Church,   began  serv- 
ing this  congregation  of  about  eleven  in  the  fall  of  1929.     Mr.   Cox  remembers 
that  he  and  his  wife  organized  a  Sunday  School  before  the  regular  preaching 
services  on  Sunday  afternoons  and  every  summer  they  conducted  a  week's 
revival.    Some  members  of  the  church  mentioned  by  him  as  having  attended 
during  his  period  of  service  were  Mrs.   Roy  E.   Tarwater  and  her  daughter, 
Frances  (now  Mrs.    Frances  Johns);  Mrs.   George  H.   Lynch  and  her  son  Jack 
(Dr.    Howell  J.   Lynch);  Mrs.   Lela  B.   Pate  and  her  daughter  Aileen  (Mrs. 
Aileen  Bilbrey);  the  George  Landrum  and  Thomas  Paschal  families,   and  Mr. 
and  Mrs.   William  Knox  and  their  daughter  Margaret  Lee  (now  Mrs.   Robert 
Sanders).'^    Mrs.   Tarwater,    a  granddaughter  of  Reuben  Harrell,    served  as 
church  organist.     ^    Mrs.   Sanders  is  a  granddaughter  of  William  McAllister 


Interview  with  Rev.   H.  E.  Baker,  December,   1975. 

2  Interview  with  Roy  E.   Tarwater,   January,   1976. 

3  Letter  from  Rev.   James  Reed  Cox,   December  8,    1975.       "*  Ibid. 
5  Interview  with  Mrs.   Frances  Tarwater  Jolins,    March,    197(;. 


59 

Moore,    and  Mrs.   Lynch  is  a  granddaughter  of  Nace  S.   Overall.     The  congfc^- 

gation  disbanded  in  the  early  1940 's;  the  last  funeral  conducted  there  was  for 
Mrs.    Thomas  Pascal  (nee  Lizzie  Overall)  in  1943.  ^ 

Those  who  attended  church  at  Pleasant  Grove  in  the  1930's  remember 
rocks  in  the  front  yard  of  the  church  which  marked  graves.     The  deed  to 
the  property  indicates  there  to  be  several  graves  there^     "it  having  been  used 
as  a  burying  ground  many  years  ago  for  the  servants  of  Isaac  Jetton.  "  ■'  In 
the  early  years  of  the  church's  existence,   before  the  black  Methodists  con- 
structed Walkup's  Chapel,   they  worshipped  with  the  white  Methodists  at        :-i^ 

r> 

Pleasant  Grove. 

Walkup's  Chapel  /  Gray's  Chapel 

On  December  10,   1877,    Lamb  and  Agnes  Smith  deeded  to  Starling 
Philips,   James  Blackstock,    and  Lamb  Smith,    as  trustees  of  the  Methodist 
Church  known  as  Walkup's  Chapel,   one  fourth  of  an  acre  of  land  bound  by 
property  owned  by  Abe  Carney  and  William  Mayberry.  ^    The  church  was 
probably  built  during  that  year  and  its  location  was  just  around  the  corner 
from  the  present  location  of  the  Prosperity  Baptist  Church  on  Mt.   Hermon 
Road.     In  the  1890's,   its  pastor  was  Charlie  Todd.       Some  of  the  members 
at  that  time  were  Mrs.   Jo  Lasseter,   Mrs.   Tulley  Weatherly,   Mrs.   Hannah 
Henderson,    Miss  Mariah  Lasseter  and  Mrs.    Sally  Carney.  ^    In  the  earl}' 
years  of  this  century,   Nell  Lyons  rang  the  church  bell  of  Walkup's  Chapel  on 


Interview  with  Mrs.   Cannon  J.  Overall,   January,   1976. 

2  Register's  Office,   Ruth.   Co.,   Tenn.  ,   Deed  Book  19,   p.  349. 

3  Interview  with  Roy  E.   Tarwater,   January,   1976. 

4  Register's  Office,   Ruth.   Co.  ,   Tenn.  ,   Deed  Book  25,   p.  220. 
Interview  with  Tennie  Beard,   January,   197  6. 

^  Interview  with  Mrs.    Mary  Lizzie  Beard,   January,    197(). 


60 

Sunday  mornings  and  for  funerals.        In  1928  the  church  moved  its  location 
a  short  distance  away  when  John  Beard  and  his  wife,    Lena,    sold  one  acre 
of  land  to  the  following  trustees:    William  Goodman,    William  Gordon  Ernest; 
[loyte  Henderson,    and  James  Bass.  2    According  to  the  deed,   the  church  had 
become  known  as  Walker's  Chapel,    instead  of  Walkup's  Chapel,    by  this  time. 
The  church  was  later  re- named  for  J.  R.   Gray,   who  preached  there  for  inany 
yc;ars.     In  ]936  the  elders  and  trustees  of  Gray's  Chapel  were  Robert 
Ilciidorson,   Dick  Goodman,   Waverly  Grissom  and  J.   B.    Gordon."^    Gray's 
Chape]  is  no  longer  in  active  use,    although  the  building  still  stands  in  tlio 
community. 
Keeble's  Chapel 

Fourteen  years  before  the  white  people  built  a  Christian  Church  in  the 
community,    the  black  members  of  the  Christian  Church  built  Keeble's  Chapel. 
In  1880  Isaac  Henderson  deeded  one  half  acre  of  land  to  the  trustees  of  this 
church,    which  had  been  built  across  the  road  and  about  one  fourth  mile  to  1lio 
cast  of  the  Dilton  store  and  next  to  Mrs.   Parrish's  southwest  corner.  4    Mrs. 
Parrish's  home  site  may  be  found  on  the  1878  map  of  Rutherford  County. 
According  to  the  deed,   the  church  stood  on  the  west  side  of  the  location  of 
the  Dilton  School,    which  was  built  later  and  has  since  been  torn  down.     The 
fi'ustccs  named  in  the  deed  for  this  church  were  Marshall  Keeble,    Sr.  , 
Marshall  Keeble,   Jr.  ,    Robert  Keeble,   Rusk  Henderson,    and  Isaac  Henderson. 


-'-  Interview  with  Mrs.    Sarah  Lasseter  Lyons,   January,   197  6. 

2  Register's  Office,   Ruth.   Co.,   Term.,   Deed  Book  7  2,   p.  211. 

3  Ibid.  ,   Book  33,   p.  109. 

'^  Register's  Office,   Ruth.   Co.  ,   Tenn.  ,   Deed  Book  25,   p.  341. 


61 


Mr.  Tennie  Beard,  bom  in  1884,  remembers  the  church  but  reports  that  it  -^ 
did  not  last  for  very  many  years. 

Although  this  church  did  not  enjoy  growth  or  longevity,  three  of  its 
trustees  were  closely  related  to  Marshall  Keeble,  who  was,   according  to 
his  biographer,  the  most  outstanding  evangelist  of  his  time  in  the  Church 

of  Christ,  black  or  white.      Robert  Keeble  was  his  father,  Marshall 

2 
Keeble,  Sr. ,  his  grandfather,  and  Marshall  Keeble,  Jr. ,  his  uncle.         > 

The  first  church  that  Marshall  ever  saw  was  undoubtedly  Keeble 's  Chapel, 

3 

although  it  was  not  the  first  that  he  remembered.       He  was  bom  on 

December  7,  1878,   about  two  and  one  half  miles  from  Murfreesboro  in  a  log 
house  on  the  Bradyville  Pike.      His  father,  Robert  Keeble,  bom  into  slavery, 
was  owned  by  Major  Horace  Pihkney  Keeble,  who  owned  a  small  acreage  on 
the  Bradyville  Pike.      During  the  Civil  War,  when  the  Yankees  took  the 
home  of  Major  Keeble,  his  wife  went  to  Murfreesboro  to  live  with  her  sister- 
in-law.       Marshall  Keeble,  Sr. ,   Marshall's  grandfather,  traveled  with 

7 
Major  Keeble  during  the  war  as  his  valet.      On  January  21,  1870,  Marshall's 

^grandfather  bought  forty  acres  from  George  G,  Tompkins,       This  property 

is  indicated  with  the  initials  "M.  K."  on  the  1878  map,  but  deed  records 

show  that  the  small  farm  was  sold  on  December  23,  1891  to  Reuben 

Harrell.  ^    Robert  Keeble  moved  his  family  to  Nashville  in  1882,  but  young   ^/ 

■'■Julian  E.  Choate,  Roll  Jordan  Roll  (Nashville,  Gospel  Advocate 
Co.,  1968),  p.  ix. 

2ibid. .  p.  14.  -^Ibid. ,  p.  16.  _^Ibid. ,  p.  14. 

5  Ibid.  6  Ibid.  '^Ibid. 

8  Register's  Office,  Rutherford  County,  Tenn. ,  Deed  Book  17,  p.  41. 

9  Ibid.  ,   Book  33,   p.    23  2. 


62 
Marshall  spent  his  summers  with  his  grandparents  on  their  farm.  -'■    Durinsr 
his  last  years,    he  recalled  for  his  biographer  pleasant  memories  of  riding  the 
work  horse  on  the  farm  and  enjoying  his  grandmother's  cooking.  2 

Marshall  Keeble,   in  his  adult  life,   preached  all  over  the  nation  and 
throughout  the  world.     He  preached  in  tents,   dance  halls,   tobacco  warehouses, 
log  cabins,   lumber  sheds,   prisons,   brush  arbors,   the  bush  country  of 
Africa,    the  Far  East,    and  in  air-conditioned  municipal  auditoriums.  "^ 
Noted  for  his  use  of  parables  and  humor  in  his  sermons,    he  was  unusuaJly 
effective  as  an  evangelist  in  the  Restoration  Movement,   which  had  its  begin- 
nings in  the  United  States  in  the  early  part  of  the  19th  century  with  the 
efforts  of  Alexander  Campbell  and  Barton  W,   Stone.       Keeble  is  said  to 
have  baptized  30,  000  people  and  to  have  established  350  congregations.^ 
Dilton  Christian  Church  /  Dilton  Church  of  Christ 

The  building  for  the  Christian  Church,   which  became  known  as  the 
Dilton  Church  of  Christ  during  the  early  part  of  the  1900 's,   was  built  in 
1894.  ^    According  to  Joe  J.   Jernigan,   Mrs.   Alexander  T.    Smith  donated  the 
lumber  for  construction  of  the  building  from  her  farm.     Mr.   Jernigan  remem- 
bers going  with  his  father,   William  Jernigan,    to  haul  the  poplar  logs  fi-om 

7 
her  farm  to  the  sawmill.       Dr.   and  Mrs.   J.   M.   Dill  gave  the  land  for  the 

church,    which  first  began  meeting  in  their  home  in  1883,  °  and  their  home 

continued  to  be  "home"  for  the  preachers  who  came  and  went.     The  original 

organizers  were,   besides  the  Dills,   John  Nelson,  Philip  Mankin,   Jack 

1  Choate,   p.  14.  ^  Ibid.  ^  Ibid. 

4  Earl  Irvin  West,   The  Search  for  the  Ancient  Order,  vol.   1 
(Nashville,   Gospel  Advocate  Co.  ,    1953),    p.  18. 

5  Choate,    p.  xiii. 

6  Register's  Office,   Ruth.    Co.,    Tenn.  ,   Deed  Book,    35,    p.  517. 

'^  Interviewwith  Joe  J.    Jernigan,   December,   1975. 

S  Raymond  B.    Harrell,    "The  Dill  Family"  (Mss.  ,    n.d.),    n.pag. 


63 

Mankin,  John  Benton  Mankin  and  William  Jernigan.  •'■ 

Joe  Jernigan  recalls  that  Charles  M.   Pullias  preached  for  this  church 
when  he  was  about  eighteen  years  of  age.     The  first  protracted  meetings  were 
held  by  H.   G.   Fleming  and  C.   S.  Denton.  2    Q.   C.    Brewer  preached  in  pro- 
tracted meetings  at  the  church  in  1908,   1909,   and  1910.  ^    Other  preachers  who 
came  to  conduct  meetings  were  L.   L.   Brigance,   L   B.   Jones,   Charles 
Brewer,   John  T.   Smithson,   E.   P.   Smith. '^    The  time  for  the  meeting  was 
usually  set  for  the  first  available  two  weeks  of  the  preacher's  time  after  crops 
were  laid  by,   which  happened  to  be  about  the  third  week  in  July  during  the      •^' 
very  hottest  summer  weather. 

The  appearance  of  the  church  as  it  was  in  the  early  1900 's  is  described 

by  Jack  R.   Mankin  in  his  autobiography: 

.  .  .a  rather  unpretentious  frame  building  set  in  a  low," 
flat  plot  of  ground  on  a  poorly  kept  country  road.  .  .  the  build- 
ing was  paid  for,   however.     The  interior  was  not  any  more 
imposing  than  its  box-like  exterior.     The  pews  were  hand 
made  and  uncomfortable  wooden  benches.     The  walls  were 
ceiled  and  had  never  been  painted  or  varnished.  .  .  For  the 
few  occasions   on  which  the  building  was  used  at  night,   there 
were  coal  oil  lamps  with  reflectors  back  of  them  around  the 
walls.  6 

Around  1912  to  1918,   the  church  is  known  to  have  been  composed  of  about 

twenty  families.     Besides  the  Dills,   there  were  the  John  Benton  Mankin, 

Ernest  Smith,   Will  Harris,   Arthur  Tolbert,  Albert  McCrary,   and  Oscar 

Harrell  families,   Mrs.   Fannie  Overall  and  her  children,    Ike  Mayo,   Week 

and  Oscar  Mankin,   Mrs.   Lola  Mankin  and  her  children,   the  Arnettes,   and 

Richard  Carter,   who  led  the  singing."^    Mr.   Mankin  provides  us  with  a 

1  Murfreesboro,   Daily  News  Journal,  Oct.    21,   1962,   p.  10. 

2  Ibid.  ^  Ibid.      '  ^  Ibid. 

5  Jack  R.   Mankin,   "Autobiography"  (Mss.  ,   n.  d.),   p.  17. 

6  Ibid.  ,   p.  13.  "7  Ibid.  ,   p.  14. 


•  -  64 

description  of  the  manner  in  which  the  church  carried  out  its  mundane  tasks 

of  cleaning  and  heating  the  building  in  those  days: 

In  theory,   the  building  was  to  be  heated  by  a  large  cast 
iron  stove  in  one  corner.     In  practice,   it  wasn't  heated  very 
much.     The  windows  were  few,    small  and  propped  up  with 
sticks  when  they  were  open.     Screens  had  not  yet  become  a 
necessary  convenience.     Country  people  were  not  afraid  of 
wasps  and  dirt  daubers  which  inhabited  the  building  in  abun- 
dance.    Spiders,   too,   liked  the  quietness  of  it  and  built  webs 
between  the  pews  and  from  the  ceiling.     Dr.   Dill's  wife  served 
as  voluntary  janitor  and  usually  had  most  of  them  cleaned  up 
before  Sunday  morning..  .  In  the  winter  time  it  was  the  duty  of 
the  first  arrivals  to  bu/ld  the  fire.    This  was  no  small  chore 
as  there  was  seldom  any  paper  or  kindling,    and  the  ashes  from 
the  last  week  needed  taking  out.     After  getting  there  early  sev- 
eral times  and  having  to  build  the  fire.   Papa  began  to  carry  a 
bundle  of  kindling  and  a  coal  oil  cob  (a  cob  soaked  in  kerosene) 
so  as  to  be  prepared.     There  wasn't  much  need  for  rivalry  for 
the  honor  of  being  the  first  there.     We  children,   to  avoid  hav- 
ing to  do  any  work  in  connection  with  the  fire,   usually  ran  into 
the  surrounding  wood  to  hunt  for  persimmons  or  hickory  nuts. 
We  rarely  found  any,   but  we  got  away  from  any  responsibility 
for  the  fire.  •'■ 

Mr.    Mankin  goes  on  to  describe  the  people  and  the  activities  in  and 

around  the  church  on  Sunday  mornings: 

The  congregation  arrived  piecemeal.     All  of  them  were 
farmers,   and  most  of  them  lived  a  mile  or  more  away.     The 
Harrises  were  among  the  first  arrivals.     They  had  a  two 
seated  surrey  with  a  top  that  looked  like  an  inverted  mortar 
box  with  fringe  around  it.     Mr.   Will  Harris  and  wife,   Lela, 
were  blest  by  being  the  parents  of  boys,   Ellis  and  Ray,   about 
the  age  of  Clyde  and  me.     I  privately  thought  that  Mr.   Harris 
was  still  further  blessed  in  having  only  the  slightest  fringe  of 
hair  left  to  comb  and  one  of  the  roundest  and  shiniest  bald 
heads  I  ever  saw.   Mrs.  Harris  always  brought  a  wicker  basket 
that  contained  the  communion  emblems  and  linen,   spotlessly 
clean,   for  the  communion  table.     I  thought  then  and  I  still  think 

1  Jack  R.   Mankin,    "Autobiography"  (Mss.  ,   n.  d.),   p.l4  . 


65 


now,    that  if  there  was  ever  a  good,    kind,    generous,    hospit- 
able man.   Will  Harris  was  he.  .  .After  the  horses  were 
securely  hitched,   the  men  folk  and  what  boys  that  had  not 
gone  to  the  woods,   would  saunter  toward  the  steps  as  if  they 
had  formed  a  good  resolution  to  go  in  immediately,   but  once 
close  to  the  steps,   they  faltered,    started  to  discuss  the  crops 
or  the  weather  until  finally  Mr.   Harris  would  reluctantly 
break  away,    go  inside  the  door,   stick  his  head  back  out  and 
announce,    after  ceremoniously  looking  at  his  watch,   that  he 
expected  they  had  better  come  in  and  "lets  get  started.  ".  .  . 
Once  in  and  seated,   Richard  Carter  would  take  charge. 
The  first  verse  of  the  first  song  was  the  signal  for  us  chil- 
dren who  had  taken  to  the  woods  to  get  back  and  we  came 
scurrying.  .  .  Several  songs,   which  members  would  select, 
prayers  usually  led  by  Dr.   Dill,  Papa,   or  Mr.   Harris,   the 
Sunday  School  lesson,   and  communion  usually  composed  the 
service.     What  it  lacked  in  beauty.  .  .  was  generously  made 
up  for  in  sincerity,   and  I  still  feel  that  the  Kingdom  of 
Heaven  would  be  nearer  realization  today  if  there  were  more 
congregations  whose  devoutness  went  all  through  the  week 
with  them  as  it  did  with  the  members  of  that  one.  ^ 

During  the  1930's  and  early  1940's,   Will  Harris,   Cannon  Overall, 
Calvin  Carter,   Ben  Arnette  and  P.    V.   Irby  were  some  of  the  leaders  of  the 
Dilton  Church  of  Christ.  2    William  Harrell  remembers  that  the  old  building 
was  torn  down  and  the  present  building  was  completed  in  1963.     Today's 
congregation  is  made  up  of  about  fifty  members.     Its  leaders  include  tWo 
grandsons  of  Dr.   Dill:    William  and  Wesley  Harrell,   J.   W.   Duncan,   Herbert 
Batey  and  Carl  Dabbs.     Ben  Arnette  served  as  a  leader  until  his  death  on 
May  20,   1976.     The  minister  at  this  time  is  T.   Coy  Porter,   a  faculty  mem- 
ber at  Middle  Tennessee  State  University.     Other  ministers  who  have 
preached  regularly  for  this  congregation  in  recent  years  are  Charles  Locke, 
Granville  Brown,   Fred  Winslett,   Boone  Douthitt,   and  Leon  Stancliff.  ^ 


■•■  Jack  R.   Mankin,    "Autobiography"  (Mss.  ,   n.d.),  p.  16. 
2  Murfreesboro,   Daily  News  Journal,   loc.    cit. 
"^  Interview  with  William  Harrell,    March,    1975. 


66 

The  Bible  Church  of  Jesus 

In  an  interview  with  Mrs.   Mabel  J.   Mofield,   the  following  facts  were 
learned  about  the  most  recently  established  church  in  Dilton,   the  Bible 
Church  of  Jesus.     Mrs.   Mofield  is  prayer  band  leader  for  the  church  and 
was  married  to  the  church's  founder,   James  P.  Mofield.     Averaging  65  to 
70  members,    the  church  was  founded  by  James  Mofield  on  Battle  Avenue 
in  1947,   and  in  1971  a  building  was  purchased  from  the  Apostolic  Church  at 
a  location  on  Bradyville  Road  two  miles  southeast  of  Dilton  Store.  ■'■    The 
Apostolic  Church  came  to  the  community  from  California  in  1969  with  the 
belief  that  California  was  doomed;  the  earthquakes  that  had  occurred  in  that 
state  were  considered  a  sign  of  impending  destruction.  2    When  the  Apostolic 
Church  sold  its  building,    it  moved  on  to  Virginia.  3    The  trustees  of  the 
Bible  Church  of  Jesus  are  Gains  Walker,   Douglas  Mofield,   Charles  Spurlock, 
Powell  Pendergrast,   Don  Stacy  and  Luther  Judkins.  ^    Elder  Mofield  served 
as  pastor  of  the  church  from  1947  until  his  death  in  1974,   and  Elder  Olen 
Carden  presently  serves  the  congregation  a§  pastor  with  the  assistance  of 
Thomas  Hewell.  ^    Mrs.   Mofield's  father,   Benjamin  Rice  Judkins,    served 
as  trustee  for  the  church  until  his  death  at  ninety-s  even  years  of  age  in 
1973.^    Douglas  Mofield,    a  son  of  Mr.    and  Mrs.   James  P.   Mofield,    serves 
as  song  leader  for  the  church,   and  his  wife,  Dorothy,   is  secretary  treasurer."^ 


Interview  with  Mrs.   Mabel  Judkins  Mofield,   March,   197  6. 


2  Ibid  .  3  j|3i^_  4  Ibid. 


^Interview  with  Mrs.   Mabel  Judkins  Mofield,   March,   1976. 
6  Ibid.  7  Ibid. 


SCHOOLS  67 

The  Firs^t  J^chools 

The  first  school  believed  to  have  been  in  the  neighborhood  near  Black 
Fox  Spring  was  closer  to  Murfreesboro  than  to  the  spring;  however,    it  is 
mentioned  here  since  it  was  attended  by  children  known  to  have  lived  in  the 
Fox  Camp  community.     Anson  and  Fanny  Nelson,    in  their  biography  of  Sarah 
Childress  Polk,   wrote  that  Sarah  went  with  her  brothers  to  "the  common 
sclinol.  "1    In  a  newspaper  account  of  the  highlights  in  1hc  life  of  John 
Whitsett  Childress,   Jolin  Woods  tells  of  attending  school  with  him  and  his 
sister,   Sarah,   "in  a  little  log  house  just  over  there  (pointing  across  the 
field).     Our  teacher  was  Daniel  Elam."^    Major  Woods  lived  about  a  mile 
out  of  town  on  the  road  which  led  to  Brady-viUe.  ^    The  137  8  map  of  Rutherford 
County  shows  the  J.   F.  Fletcher  farm  to  have  been  close  enough  to  the  Woods 
property  to  have  been  the  location  of  the  school  "just  across  the  field"  from 
John  Woods;  however,   there  is  no  evidence  that  the  Fletcher  family  owned 
the  plantation  at  the  time  Joel  Childress'  children  and  John  Woods  attended 
school  at  this  location.     Fletcher's  School  was  a  one  room  school  built  of    ^ 
logs  and  known  to  have  been  in  existence  prior  to  the  Civil  War.       It  is  men- 
tioned in  the  minutes  of  the  Missionary  Baptist  Church  which  met  at  the 
schoolhouse  for  a  period  of  six  years  from  1843  until  1849.  4 
The  Subscription  School 

The  deed  of  1873  to  the  property  donated  by  Nace  S.   Overall  for  the 


1  Nelson,   p.  4. 

2  Nashville,   Daily  American,   loc.    cit. 
Spittard,    p.  9.  Ibid.  ,   pp.9,    24. 


68 

Methodist  Church  at  Dilton  reveals  plans  for  the  church  building  to  be  used 
also  for  a  subscription  school.  ^    Assuming  that  the  building  was  coinplcted     "^ 
soon  after  the  time  of  the  deed,   this  school  began  its  four- month  sessions2 
about  1874.     Its  first  and  only  known  teacher,   Charles  McNabb,    rode  his  horse 
each  day  of  the  school  session  from  Burk's  Hollow.  ^    Burk's  Hollow  is 
located  amid  the  steep  hills  ten  miles  southeast  of  the  school.     Mr.    McNabb's 
salary  was  eight  dollars  a  month.  ^    Among  his  students  were  Elisha  Monroe 
Harrell,    Lorenzo  Dow  Harrell,    Matilda  Harrell,   Minnie  Overall,   Tom 
Overall,   and  Ernest  Smith.  ^ 

Elisha  M.    Harrell,    who  grew  up  to  preach  many  times  at  this  church, 
was  among  the  mischievous  little  boys  who  went  to  school  to  Mr.   McNabb. 
One  typical  mischievous  prank  is  told  by  his  niece.     It  seems  that  he  and 
other  boys  liked  to  catch  fleas,   which  were  easy  to  find  because  hogs  made 
themselves  at  home  underneath  the  schoolhouse  floor.     They  took  the  fleas, 
one  at  a  time,   to  the  front  of  the  school  room,    and  on  the  pretense  of  want- 
ing to  ask  their  teacher  a  question,   they  would  drop  one  down  his  back.    At 
recess,   to  the  delight  of  the  boys,   the  teacher  would  disappear  into  the 
woods  nearby,   presumably  to  rid  himself  of  the  fleas.  " 

Ernest  Smith  recalled  that  Mr.   McNabb  would  select  a  boy  to  go  with 
him  to  the  well  on  the  Overall  farm  on  days  when  the  weather  prohibited 
the  entire  class  from  going.     No  boy  wanted  to  be  chosen,    preferring  to 
stay  behind  to  have  some  fun  while  the  teacher  and  his  helper  went  for  water. 


1  Register's  Office,   Ruth.   Co.,   Tenn.  ,   Deed  Book,   19,   p.  349. 

2  Interview  with  Mrs.    Clemmie  Harrell  Ring,   February,    1976. 

^  Interview  with  Wm.    Hoyt  Smith  who  quoted  Ernest  L.    Smith,   Jan.   ]07f) 
4  Interview  with  Mrs.    Ring,    Feb.  ,   1976.  ^  Ibid.  ^  Ibid. 


69 

On  days  when  the  weather  was  pleasant,   the  children  would  all  go  to  the 

well  with  Mr.   McNabb  for  water.     The  well  was  a  "dug  well"   with  a 
platform  of  planks  over  it.     Mr.   Smith  said  he  had  some  concern  about  the 
water  drawn  from  the  well  because  of  the  large  cracks  between  the  planks 
and  the  gaggle  of  geese  which  were  also  frequent  visitors  to  the  well.  1 

The  subscription  school  continued  in  existence  until  1882,   when  a 
public  school  called  Oaklands  Academy  was  established.  ^ 
Oaklands  Academy 

On  June  5,  1880,  William  H.   Smith  and  his  son,  Alexander  T.  Smith, 
deeded  an  acre  of  land  (on  the  corner  of  property  presently  owned  by  Hoyt 
Smith  at  a  location  where  Overall  Road,   Wilson  Road  and  Lytle  Creek  Road 
come  together)  to  W.   J.  Knox  and  others  as  school  directors  for  the 
18th  district.  ^    The  deed  indicates  that  this  property  was  bordered  on  the 
west  by  property  of  John  W.    Childress.     A  school  was  built  in  1882  after  con-  / 
siderable  controversy  over  its  location.  ^    Prior  to  the  school's  construction, 
William  Yearwood  hauled  the  lumber  during  the  night  from  the  corner 
deeded  by  the  Smiths  to  a  location  about  a  mile  away  on  the  corner  of  the 
Bradyville  Turnpike  and  Overall  Road,   and  on  the  next  day,   Jasper  Knox 
had  the  lumber  moved  back  to  its  first  location  and  the  new  school  was  soon 
constructed.  ^    Because  of  the  large  oak  trees  in  the  school  yard,   the  school 
was  named  Oaklands  Academy.  6    According  to  Mrs.    Clemmie  Ring,  Oaklands 

^Ernest  L.  Smith,   "Memories  of  My  Early  Life"  (Ms.  ,  1961), 
n  .   pag.  ^  Ibid. 

3  Register's  Office,  Ruth.  Co.  ,   Tenn.  ,   Book  25,   p.  212. 

4  Interview  with  Joe  J.   Jernigan,   Dec.  ,   1975.  ^  Ibid. 
6  Interview  with  Hoyt  Smith,   December,   1975. 


70 
was  a  two- teacher  school  having  two  rooms  and  a  side  room  called  "the 

music  room.  "    Some  who  served  as  teachers  were  Lee  Yearwood,   John  L,ee, 

Lavata  Mitchell,    Flint  Speer,   John  Northcutt,    Joel  Coates,   Ona  Morrison, 

Mattie  Tucker,   Elisha  M.    Harrell,   Flora  Montgomery,    Emma  Ring  and 

Stanton  Smith.       In  1885  the  average  teacher's  salary  in  the  public  schools 

^  was  twenty-five  dollars  per  month.  ^    The  length  of  the  school  term  was 

J  four  to  five  months. 

A  more  serious  controversy  arose  in  1896  than  had  occurred  over  the 
school's  location.     Most  of  the  details  have  been  told  by  Mrs.   Ring,   the 
author's  great  aunt.     Edgar  Puryear  and  Jolin  Harrell  were  prospective 
teachers  at  Oaklands.     L.  D.   Harrell,   a  school  director,    interviewed  the 
two  men  in  his  home  one  evening,    after  which  they  slept  together  in  the 
guest  room.     On  the  following  morning  at  the  breakfast  table,    Mr.    Harrell 
made  known  his  preference  for     Mr.    Puryear,   a  man,    twenty-seven  years 
o]d.     That  day,   January  15 ,   1896,   John  Harrell  and  Edgar  Puryear  became 
involved  in  an  argument  over  the  appointment  at  the  Dilton  store  operated 

by  Jim  Tolbert.  When  the  argument  increased  in  intensity,   the  two  men 

3 
stepped  outside  the  store  and  John  Harrell  fatally  shot  Edgar  Puryear. 

Mr.    Puryear  was  buried  in  the  Abernathy  Cemetery  at  Kittrell.        He  was 

the  son  of  P.   M.  Puryear,   a  graduate  of  Princeton  University  and  principal 

of  the  Science  Hill  Academy  from  1870  to  1887.  ^    Within  the  year  John 


•'•  Interview  with  Mrs.   Clemmie  Harrell  Ring,   February,   1976. 

^  Goodspeed,   p. 835. 

3  Nashville  Banner,  Jan.  16,  1896,  p.  5. 

^  Interview  with  James  A.   Gilley,   March,   197  6. 

5  Interview  with  Miss  Mary  Hall,    April,    197  6. 


i^i^-ar  if^   M-r-j^^  /va^^A^j^J-.h,     ^^?'2l^K^c^'^i^'^' 


U.U.     f-  y    i+t- 


These  dressed-ip  young  folks  attended  old  Oakland  School  on  the  BracJfville 
Pike  in  the  good  year  1896.  Left  to  right,  they  are:  front  rcw  -  Mattie 
Overall  (Mrs.  R.  K.  Harrell) ,  Grace  Harrell,  Viola  Nelson,  Freeland  Harrell, 
Qna  Harrell,  Bartie  Nelson,  John  Yearwood,  Oscar  Jemigan,  Milton  Tolbert 

(last  four  boys  seated) ;  second  rCTv  -  Miss  Emna  Ring  (teacher) ,  Gin*/ 
Hutton,  Shellie  Tolbert  (Mrs.  Jess  Jacobs),  Vivian  Yearwood,  Anna  Nelson, 
Mamie  Overall,  Ella  Tolbert  (Mrs.  Hurley  Mingles) ,  Gleta  Arnold,  Lula  Tolbert 

(Mrs.  MDran  Shuler)  ,  Russell  Gordon,  Tom  Overall,  Will  Helton,  Joe  Jemigan, 
White  Yearwood,  John  Lee  (teacher,  of  Eldorado,  Okla. ) ;  third  rcw  -  Annie 
Smith  (Mrs.  B.  H.  Lckeyi  Ethel  Nesbitt,  Cleinrnie  Harrell  (Mrs.  B.  M.  Ring)  , 
Ella  Hutton,  Florence  Tolbert  (Mrs.  Will  Hayes),  Alice  Harrell,  Annie 
Yearwood,  Enma  Hutton,  Ida  Hutton,  Annie  Harrell  (Mrs.  E.  L.  Smith),  Bettie 
Arnold,  Cora  Harrell;  back  row  -  Edgar  Overall,  Virgil  Year^^rood,  Colvin 
Tolbert,  Edd  Yearwood,  Will  Lee,  S.  N.  Overall,  X.  Gordon,  R.  L.  Tolbert, 
Will  Yearwood,  John  Gordon,  Ellis  Arnold,  Frank  Tolbert. 


.e^  ^ 


X- 


V 


72 

Harrell  died  of  typhoid  fever  before  his  case  came  up  for  trial.     A  list  of 
students  who  attended  Oaklands  around  this  time  may  be  seen  with  the  school 
picture  included  in  this  paper. 
Gladeview  School 

On  Septeniber  13,   1884,   one  half  acre  was  deeded  to  school  directors 
J.    C.    Coleman,    W.    J.    Knox,   and  M.    Frank  Overall  by  F.    G.    Carney  for  a 
school  house  "now  standing  on  the  lot.  "^    Gladeview  school  was  originally 
I    on  Mt.    Hermon  Road  near  Walkup's  Chapel,   which  was  just  around  the  cor- 
ner from  the  Prosperity  Baptist  Church.  ^    In  1909  John  Overall  deeded  a 
half  acre  for  Gladeview  School,   but  it  was  moved  during  that  year  to  its  later 
location  across  the  road  from  Prosperity  Baptist  Church.       Some  of  the 
teachers  at  Gladeview  were  Henry  and  Lula  Bright,   Leanna  Smith,   Annie 
Ransom,   Luther  Glanton,   Robert  Meeks  and  Mollie  Leigh  (Mrs.   Anse  Jones) .  "^ 
There  were  also  teachers  named  Robinson,   Bass  and  McGowan.  "^    Tennie 
Beard,    a  student  in  the  school  in  the  1890's,    recalls  that  they  went  to  sclioo] 
in  January,   February,   May,   June,   August  and  part  of  September.     School 
was  not  in  session,   he  said,   between  February  and  May  because  the  chil- 
dren were  needed  to  assist  with  the  planting  of  corn  in  March  and  cotton  in 
April.     School  was  out  again  in  September  when  cotton  was  ready  to  be 
picked.     Mr.    Beard  adds  that  in  those  days  school  began  with  a  prayer  and 


^  Register's  Office,   Ruth.   Co.  ,   Tenn.  ,   Book  27,   p.  417. 

^  Interview  with  Tennie  Beard,   January,   197  6. 

3  Register's  Office,   Rutherford  Co.  ,   Tenn.  ,   Book  50,   p.  585. 

Interview  with  Tennie  Beard,   January,   197  6. 
5  Rutherford  County,   School  Superintendent's  Office,   School  Records, 
Gladeview  folder. 


73 
a  song  and  subjects  studied  were  reading,   writing,   and  arithmetic.  1 

Another  school  for  the  children  in  the  black  community  at  Dilton  was 
established  about  a  year  after  Gladeview,   but  its  name  is  not  known.     School 
directors  W.   P.    Henderson,   W.   A.   Sloan  and  James  Gilley  were  deeded  one 
half  acre  by  Marshall  and  Mary  Keeble.  2    Its  location  was  on  the  Bradyville 
Pike  about  two  miles  northwest  of  the  Dilton  Store  on  property  presently 
owned  by  R.   C.   Bell.  "^    At  that  time,   the  land  deeded  to  the   school  directors 
was  bordered  by  property  owned  by  M.    Crass  and  Reuben  Harrell.        The 
school  remained  in  existence  until  about  1910.  ^ 
Dilton  School 

During  the  winter  of  1898,   the  Oaklands  schoolhouse  was  rolled  through 
the  fields  to  a  new  location  three- tenths  of  a  mile  east  of  the  Dilton  Store  and 
on  the  north  side  of  the  Bradyville  Pike.  ^     When  the  building  began  to  lean 
during  the  early  1920 's,   it  was  propped  up  with  cedar  poles.  '    About  1927, 
when  it  was  considered  too  deteriorated  to  be  used  any  longer,    it  was  torn 
down  and  replaced  by  a  new  building  similar  to  the  old  one.  ^    Some  of  the 
teachers  who  taught  at  Dilton  School  were  B.   H.   Lokey,   Ellen  Brown,   Genoa 
Bowling,   Lela  Osborne,   Tom  Gregory,   Sallie  McClain,   Annie  Bell  Becton 
(Mrs.   J.   D.   Roberts),     Miss  Owen,   Elizabeth  Puckett  (Mrs.    Calvin  Carter) , 

1  Interview  with  Tennie  Beard,   January,   197  6. 

2  Register's  Office,   Rutherford  Co.  ,   Tenn.  ,   Deed  Book  28,   p.  86. 

3  Interview  with  Fred  Rogers,   May,   1976. 

4  Register's  Office,   Ruth.   Co.,   Term.,   Deed  Book  28,   p.  86. 
^  Interview  with  Mr.   Beard,   January,   197  6. 

6  Interview  with  Mrs.    Clemmie  Harrell  Ring,   February,   1976. 

7  Interview  with  Ernest  Howard  Smith,   April,   197  6. 

8  Interview  with  William  Hoyt  Smith,   April,   1976. 


74 
Pauline  Jennings  (Mrs.    White  Wood),    Frank  White,    Virginia  Bock  (Mrs. 
Cannon  Overall),    Mrs.   A.   R.    Craddock  (Nee  Alice  Hill),    Irene  Ycarwood 
(Mrs.   Kenneth  Williamson),   Bessie  Puckett,   Susie  Ashley  (Mrs.   Grover 
Sneed),   Bright  Brandon  (Mrs.    Howard  Smith) ,    Elizabeth  White  (Mrs.   Hoyt) 
Davenport),   James  Haynes,    Zella  Potts,   Macy  Whitfield,   Grady  Biggers 
(Mrs.   Wliite),   Christine  Harrell  (Mrs.   Ray  Donnell) .  ^  In  the  1930's,   Mrs. 
J.   Ellis  Harris  (nee  Clara  Parman)  directed  the  parents  and  friends  of 
the  school  in  the  performance  of  stunts,    skits,   and  songs  which  she  had 
written.     The  community  derived  much  enjoyment  and  the  school  acquired 
a  stage  as  a  result  of  these  efforts.  ^    The  foundation  of  the  school,     being 
still  in  place,    reveals  the  school  to  have  been  approximately  66  feet  in 
length.     The  width  of  the  building  was  34  feet,    except  at  the  rear,   where  it 
measured  23  feet.     A  small  room  across  the  front  of  the  building  was  used 
for  a  kitchen  when  the  hot-lunch  program  began  about  1936  with  Mrs.   Ann 
Jones  in  charge  of  the  preparation  of  the  food.     Between  the  kitchen  and  the 
stage  was  the  large  class  room.  ^    On  the  southeast  side  of  the  building  were 
two  small  rooms  and  a  small  porch.     A  deed  to  a  part  of  the  school  property 
mentions  a  persimmon  tree  in  the  school  yard.  ^    The  girls  at  Dilton  School 
were  fond  of  the  tree,    considering  it  theirs  because  it  stood  behind  their 
privy.     In  the  fall  of  the  year  and  after  the  first  frost,   when  the  fruit  of  the 
tree  grew  ripe  and  fell  to  the  ground,    there  was  always  a  sharp  increase  in 


■*•  Interview  with  Mrs.   Ernest  Howard  Smith,   April,   197  6. 

2  Interview  with  Mrs.   J.   Ellis  Harris,   April,   1976. 

3  Interview  with  Mrs.   Ernest  Howard  Smith,   April,   197  6. 

4  Register's  Office,   Ruth.   Co.  ,    Tenn.  ,    Deed  Book  55,    p.  506. 


75 

ss. 


the  number  of  girls  who  held  up  their  hands  to  ask  to  be  excused  from  clas 
More  often  than  not,   their  thoughts  were  on  the  tree  and  the  newly  fallen 
fruit  which  might  be  found  beneath  it.  ^    The  school  and  the  tree  are  gone,   but 
the  foundation  of  the  school  and  the  roots  of  the  tree  are  still  there.     The 
school  closed  in  1942  when  the  children  began  to  be  bussed  to  the  consoli- 
dated grade  schools  in  the  town  of  Murfreesboro2  and  the  tree   fell  during  a 

o 

severe  storm  of  June  20,   1970.  -^ 
Henderson  School 

Henderson  School,   according  to  Jack  R.    Mankin,   was  a  reasonable 
facsimile  of  Whittier's  schoolhouse.     The  schoolhouse  was  "T"  shaped  with 
one  large  room  and  two  small  rooms  on  each  side.     It  was  a  frame  building 
with  weatherboarding  on  the  outside  and  wood  ceiling  on  the  inside.     The  roof 
was  covered  with  wood  shingles  and  there  was  a  belfry  on  the  front  contain- 
ing a  bell  which  called  the  students  in  to  "books.  "    "Literally,  "  Jack  Mankin 
writes,    "we  were  taught  reading,  writing  and  'rithmetic  to  the  tune  of  a 
hickory  stick,    except  that  privet  switches  were  more  available  and  made  an 
acceptable  substitute  for  hickory.  "^    The  school  was  located  on  the 
Manchester  Pike  near  the  southeast  corner  of  that  pike  and  Dilton-Mankin 
Lane,   but  on  the  opposite  side  of  the  pike  and  a  short  distance  to  the  south. 
Since  a  number  of  children  in  the  Dilton  community  attended  school  at 
Henderson,   it  is  mentioned  here.     It  is  thought  to  have  been  built  in  the 

1  Interview  with  Mrs.   Pearl  Marlin  Smith,   May,   197  6. 
^Interview  with  Charles  B.    Smith,   February,   1976. 
■^  Interview  with  Dr.   Fowler  Todd,   May,   1976. 

4  Letter  from  Jack  R.    Mankin,   March  30,   197  6. 

5  Ibid. 


1 


76 


late  1800 's  when  the  Fimixklin  Hendersons  owned  the  plantation.     This  land 
with  its  antebellum  house  was  purchased  from  the  Hendersons  by  Henry  Pfeil 
in  1897    and  is  presently  owned  by  the  Price  Harrisons.       Since  no  deed  is 
on  record  for  the  sale  or  donation  of  the  property  for  the  school,   when  it 
was  established  is  uncertain. 

A  number  of  teachers  who  taught  at  Henderson  are  remembered  by 

their  former  students.     Professor  Parker,  who  was  teaching  in  1906  and 

3 
before,   was  the  first  teacher  known  to  have  taught  at  Henderson.       Some 

others  who  taught  there  were  Carroll  Brown,   Shellie  Tolbert,   Mattie 

Overall  (Mrs.  R.   K.   Harrell) ,   Mary  Snell  (Mrs.   Ellis  Ransom),   Fannie 

Snell,   Alline  Youree,   Ethel  McCrary,   Ann  Puckett  (Mrs.   Arthur  Watts) , 

Bessie  Puckett,   Willie  Mary  Watson  (Mrs.  DeLeon  Horton),   Irene  Downing 

(Mrs..  AndrewPrice),   Mrs.   W.   I.   Sade  (Fannie  Robison),   Irene  Yearwood 

4 
(Mrs.   Kenneth  Williamson) ,   and  Mary  Frank  Auberry.       Alline  Youree 

remembers  teaching  at  Henderson  in  1914  and  1915  for  thirty  dollars  per 

month.  ^    By  this  time,    she  recalls,    school  sessions  were  eight  months  long. 

Miss  Youree  remembers  having  seventeen  children  in  the  early  grades  in  a 

small  room  with  a  stove  in  the  center.     John  Benton  Mankin,   who  was  in 

first  grade  at  Henderson  School  the  year  the  school  closed  (1934)  remembers 

being  very  much  in  love  during  that  year  with  his  teacher,   Mary  Frank  Auberry. 

^  Register's  Office,  Ruth.   Co.  ,   Tenn.  ,  Deed  Book  38,  p.   269. 

2  Ibid.,   Book  186,   p.   152;  Book  194,  p.    6. 

3  Letter  from  Jack  R.   Mankin,   March  30,   1976. 

^  Interview  with  Mrs.   William  M.   McNeill  (nee  Mary  Frances  Snell). 
^   Interview  with  Miss  Alline  Youree,   April,   1976. 
^  Interview  with  John  Benton  Mankin,  April,   197  6. 


77 


SOCIAL  ACTIVITIES 
As  in  all  typical  communities  during  the  1800's  and  early  1900's, 
before  the  automobile  and  consolidated  schools,   the  social  activities  of  the 
community  were  closely  associated  with  the  school  and  with  the  churches, 
not  only  for  children,   but  for  the  adults  as  well.     The  "grown  folks,  "  as  the 
children  called  them,    especially  enjoyed  the  box  suppers  which  were  given 
to  raise  money  for  the  school.     Each  woman  of  the  family,   including  the 
daughters  who  were  of  marriageable  age,   would  prepare  a  delicious  supper, 
pack  it  in  a  fancy  box  which  had  been  carefully  decorated,    and  upon  arrival 
at  the  schoolhouse,   place  it  on  a  large  table  with  the  other  boxes.     A  "crier" 
(auctioneer)  was  called  in  to  "cry"  the  box  supper  sale.     One  of  the  men 
often  called  upon  to  "cry"  the  Dilton  School's  box  suppers  in  the  early  1900's 
was  John  Puckett.  •*•    The  boxes  were  auctioned  to  the  highest  bidders.     A 
young  man  would  bid  high  to  buy  the  box  prepared  by  his  choice  of  girls 
because  the  girl  shared  the  supper  with  its  buyer.     Some  men  who  believed 
their  wives  to  be  the  best  cooks  would  bid  for  their  boxes,   or  maybe  some 
bid  for  fear  of  a  tongue  lashing  when  they  got  home  if  they  failed  to  do  sol 
Plays  or  minstrels  were  sometimes  performed  by  the  parents  or  by  any 
local  talent  which  could  be  found.     Admission  was  charged  and  funds  were 
thereby  raised  for  equipment  for  the  school.        The  children  derived  much 
pleasure  as  well  as  "book  learning"  from  school.     At  recess  periods,   they 


1  Interview  with  William  Hoyt  Smith,   April,   1976. 
^  Interview  with  Mrs.   J.   Ellis  Harris,  April,   197  6. 


78 

played  games  called  hares  and  hounds,  ante-over,  town  ball,  niunVolc  peg, 
roley  holey,  or  skip-to- me-lou.  If  the  weather  made  it  necessary  to  stay 
inside  for  recess,    they  played  games   such  as  clap-in-and- clap-out. 

Behind  Henderson  School  was  Mr.   Pfeil's  woods  with  a  dense  growth 
of  cedars  and  a  few  hardwood  trees.     There,   a  good  game  of  hares  and 
hounds  could  be  enjoyed.     Two  boys,    chosen  to  be  "hares",   were  given  a 
few  minutes  start.     They  ran  ahead  dropping  small  bits  of  paper  to  make 
a  trail  for  the  rest  of  the  boys  (the  "hounds")  to  follow.     Jack  Mankin.   a 
student  at  Henderson  around  1910,   writes  that  this  was  no  small  job  in  a  (iO 
acre  plot  of  dense  wood.     "But,   oh,   it  was  fun,   and  how  we  did  hale  to  near 
that  old  bell  on  the  schoolhouse  toll  the  doleful  warning  that  it  was  just  five 
minutes  to  books.  "•'■ 

Roley  holey  was  a  marble  game,   sometimes  taken  seriously  by  some 
boys.     Joe  Jernigan,   who  was  an  elementary  school  student  at  Oaklands  and 
at  Dilton  School^ tells  of  being  hit  in  the  leg  by  a  rock  by  a  boy  who  grew 
angry  with  him  over  a  marble  game.     At  ninety  three,   Mr.   Jernigan  still 
has  the  scar.  2    Roley  holey  was  a  favorite  marble  game.     Four  holes  were 
placed  in  the  ground  and  boys  took  turns  shooting  their  marbles  from  hole 
to  hole.     The  one  who  got  his  marbles  in  the  fourth  hole  first  was  rewarded 
with  the  privilege  of  shooting  marbles  at  the  knuckles  of  the  other  boys  as 
ihey  held  them  to  the  ground. 

Another  game  with  a  hard  penalty  for  losing  was  mumble  peg,   which 


^  Jack  Mankin,   "Autobiography"  (Ms.,   n.d.),   p.  33. 
2  Interview  with  Joe  J.   Jernigan,   December,    1975. 


79 

was  played  with  pocket  knives.     Every  boy  carried  a  pocket  knife.     Many  older 
men  who  are  in  their  sixty's  and  seventy's  today  carry  pocket  knives  because 
they  acquired  the  habit  when  they  were  boys.     Mr.   Jernigan  recalled  the 
rules:    The  players  took  turns  throwing  their  knives  at  the  ground  with  both 
blades  out.     If  the  knife  stuck  in  the  ground  with  the  blade  straight  out,    cer- 
tain   points  were  scored;  if  it  stuck  in  the  ground  by  the  blade  which  was  at 
an  angle,   a  certain  number  of  points  were  scored.     The  boy  who  scored  the 
most  points  in  the  game  had  the  privilege  of  driving  a  wooden  peg  into  the 
ground  as  far  as  he  could  drive  it,   and  the  boy  who  scored  the  least  had  to 
pull  the  peg  out  with  his  teeth. 

All  the  boys  and  girls  would  participate  in  games  such  as  town  ball  and 
ante-over.     Town  ball  was  similar  to  baseball.     It  acquired  its  name  from 
the  rule  that  the  team  at  bat  was  "in  town.  "    The  team  out  on  the  field  was 
said  to  be  "in  the  country.  "    Ante-over  was  played  with  a  ball  made  of  yarn 
from  old  socks  wound  very  tightly  together  to  the  size  of  a  soft  ball.     The 
children  divided  into  two  teams  and  assembled  on  opposing  sides  of  the 
school  building.     When  a  team  member  threw  the  ball  over  the  roof  of  the 
school,    he  yelled  "ANTE-OVER!"    The  child  who  caught  the  ball  would  rush 
ar-ound  the  school  house  and  try  to  hit  one  of  the  children  with  the  ball.     If 
he  succeeded,   his  team  acquired  this  child  as  a  new  member,   but  if  the 
child  dodged  the  ball  successfully,    he  had  to  return  to  his  team  alone.     The 
game  continued  until  one  side  lost  all  its  team  niembers  to  the  other  side 
or  until  recess  ended,    in  which  case,   the  team  with  the  most  members  won 

■'•  Interview  with  Joe  J.    Jernigan,   December,   1975. 


80 
the  game 

Clap- in- and- clap-out  wa^  an  indoor  game.     The  girls  would  remain  in 
the  rooni  and  the  boys  would  go  out  of  the  room  or  vice  versa.     A  girl  would 
call  for  a  particular  boy  to  the  doorkeeper,   who  would  call  him  in.     When  he 
entered  the  door,   the  girls  began  to  clap.     If  he  sat  down  by  the  girl  who 
called  for  him,   he  "stuck"  as  the  clapping  ceased.     If  he  did  not,   the  clap- 
ping increased  and  he  was  "clapped  out"  of  the  room.  -'■ 

Jack  R.   Mankin,    in  an  autobiography  for  his  children,    describes  liis 
memories  of  the  protracted  meetings  at  the  Dilton  Church  of  Christ  in  tiio 
early  1900 's,    some  of  which  typify  the  social  life  of  any  of  Dilton  churches. 
According  to  Mr.   Mankin,   nothing  could  compare  with  the  followship, 
excitement  and  pleasure  provided  by  the  annual  church  affair  known  as  the 
"protracted  meetin'.  "    The  following  is  paraphrased  from  Mr.   Mankin's 
manuscript:    People  came  from  fifteen  to  twenty  miles  away  to  attend  a 
meeting,    where  boys  had  opportunity  to  meet  girls  from  other  communities. 
Such  meetings  often  resulted  in  romance  and  marriage,   and  in  those  days, 
marriage,   whether  for  better  or  for  worse,   was  for  keeps.     Young  men  had 
opportunity  to   show  off  their  newly  acquired  smoking  habits,   their  sideburns 
and  their  moustaches,    and  the  girls  had  a  chance  to  show  off  their  wasp-like 
waists,   their  hairdos,   and  their  pretty  new  organdy  or  satin  dresses.     The 
woods  nearby  would  be  full  of  younger  boys  who  were  more  interested  in 
whatever  the  woods  contained  and  in  each  other  than  in  girls.     The  women 
and  the  girls  inside  the  church  awaiting  the  beginning  of  the  service   exchanged 

1  Interview  with  Mrs.   Pearl  Marlin  Smith,     December  1975. 


81 

recipes  and  secrets  and  every  woman  carried  a  fan.     Their  faces  were  white 

with  dover  chalk  and  they  wore  large  hats  which  were  attached  to    their  hair 

with  long  hat  pins.     Many  of  the  men  would  stay  outside  and  talk  during  the 

services  and  later  offer  the  excuse  to  their  wives  that  there  was  no  more 

room  available  inside.     The  men  were  dressed  in  overalls  or  suits.     In  the 

early  1900 's  there  were  a  few  celluloid  collars,   but  these  gave  way  to  stiff 

linencollars  worn  high  up  under  the  chin.     The  men  who  wore  suits  would 

wear  gaudily  striped  silk  shirts,    cuff  links  and  sleeve  bands  to  hold  the 

shirt  sleeves  up.  ■'■ 

When  the  services  were  over,   the  family  who  had  the  honor  of  getting 

the  preacher  to  go  home  with  them  for  dinner  would  invite  as  many  others 

as  they  could  get  to  come.     It  was  the  housewife's  day  of  glory,   but  it  was 

not  easy.     The  protracted  meeting  was  scheduled  for  a  week  in  July,    the 

warmest  month  of  the  year,    and  the  housewife  prepared  the  meal  over  a 

hot  stove.     If  the  family  could  afford  it,    a  servant  was  hired  to  help  with 

the  cooking  and  dish  washing.     There  was  an  unbelieveable  abundance  of  food 

on  the  table  on  such  a  day:  "three  or  four  fried  chickens  fried  to  a  delicious 

golden  brown  and  served  hot  from  the  stove,  roast  beef  or  mutton,  fried  ham, 

potato    salad,    slaw,   hot  biscuits,   home  made  light  bread,   fried  corn,   butter  beans, 

stewed  tomatoes,   pickled  peaches,  preserves,  butter  and  jelly  for  dessert  -  home 

made  ice  cream  reckoned  in  gallons,  not  quarts,  and  at  least  two  kinds  of  cakes; 

to  drink  -  coffee,  iced  tea,  buttermilk  or  sweet  milk  "^    When  dinner  was  over,  -/ 

the  children  came  in  for  the  "second  table."    Mr.   Mankin  writes: 

^  Jack  R.   Mankin,   "Autobiography"  (Ms.   n.d.)  pp.  17-19. 
2  Ibid.  ,   p.  20. 


It  was  infinite  torment  to  be  helpless  and  voiceless 
while  the  last  piece  of  white  meat  was  eaten  or  the  last 
good  piece  of  ham  had  the  heart  cut  out  of  it.     And,    it 
seenu'd  as  if  the}'  would  eat  foreverl     We  would  think 
there  was  a  lull  and  begin  to  be  hopeful  when  the  good 
housewife  would  insist  that  the  preacher  try  some  of 
this  or  that  and  then  they  would  start  all  over  again.    Our 
hopes  sank  as  low  as  the  pancreas.     Finally,    though, 
they  did  quit,    and  then  some  mother  would  remember  the 
children  hadn't  eaten  yet.     We  didn't  get  much  service  or 
choice  dishes,   but  we  didn't  need  much.     What  we  lacked 
in  finesse,   we  made  up  for  in  appetite,    and  in  spite  of 
our  thinking  a  few  minutes  before  that  there  would  not  be 
anything  left,   I  never  knew  of  a  child  leaving  the  second 
table  without  having  had  more  than  he  should  have  eaten; 
even  ice  cream.  ■'■ 

When  dinner  was  over,   the  women  washed  dishes  and  the  men  would  sit  under 

the  shade  trees  and  smoke,    chew  tobacco  and  talk,    and  perhaps  take  a  walk 

to  look  over  the  crops  until  it  was  time  to  go  home  and  do  the  farm  chores 

before  going  back  to  "meetin'  "  that  night.  ^  ./- 

Social  gatherings  among  the  adults  often  had  a  serious  purpose  as  well 

as  recreational  value.     This  was  true  in  the  case  of  the  schools  and  the 

churches,    and  it  was  even  more  true  in  the  black  community,   where  the 

men  enjoyed  the  fellowship  of  a  lodge  in  the  early  1900's  called  the  United 

Sons  of  Relief.     Some  of  the  officers  who  served  the  lodge  were  Simon  ^ 

J.,cigh,   Ncls  Lassiter,    Jess  Alexander,    and  Tennie  Beard.  "^    They  met 

once  a  month  and  continued  to  do  so  for  about  four  years.     Their  primary 

purpose  was  to  help  one  another  when  there  was  a  need.     If  a  member 

became  ill  and  unable  to  work,    each  of  the  other  members  contributed  a 

^  Ibid,  p.  20.  ^Ibid.  ,   p.  21. 

^  Interview  with  Tennie    Beard,   January,   197  6. 


83 
dollar  a  week  for  his  family's  support  until  he  was  able  to  work  again.  ^ 

DLii-ing  the  depression  years,    the  "pound  supper"  was  popular  in  the- 
community.     Since  times  were  hard  and  money  scarce  during  the  1930 's, 
it  was  probably  not  practical  to  invite  a  very  large  group  to  one's  lionit,- 
wilhoui  ir.viting  each  family  to  also  bring  a  pound  of  food  to  contribute  to 
the  meal.     These  social  gatherings  were  similar  to  the  "covered  dish  SLip- 
pers"  with  which  we  are  familiar  today. 


^  Interview  with  Mr.   Beard,   January,   1976. 


84 


ROADS,   TRADE,   AGRICULTURE,   AND  INDUSTRY 
The  oldest  trading  post  known  to  have  been  in  the  Dilton  area  was  near 
the  Black  Fox  Spring  many  years  before  Rutherford  County  was  established 
when  traders  came  from  the  Cumberland  settlement  to  exchange  goods  with 
the  Indians.  1    The  animal  furs  which  the  Indians  obtained  in  the  wilderness 
were  in  demand  by  the  colonists  as  well  as  the  Europeans.     Because  of  this 
demand,   traders  found  it  profitable  to  exchange  guns,   knives,   hatchets, 
cloth,   whiskey,   and  trinkets  for  pelts.  ^    The  first  store  known  to  have  been 
operated  in  the  area  by  a  white  settler  was  Joel  Childress'  store  on  the  old 
road  near  Black  Fox  Spring.  ^    In  those  days  stores  are  said  to  have  sold  dry 
goods,   products  from  the  farm  and  the  woods,    guns,    ammunition,   whiskey, 
and  hides. 

Dr.   J.   M.   Dill  opened  a  store  in  18835  across  the  Bradyville  road  and 
about  200  yards  northwest  of  today's  Dilton  Store.  ^    By  1900  there  were  two 
other  stores  and  two  blacksmith  shops  near  Dr.   Dill's  store.  '^    The  black- 
smiths were  George  Blair  and  William  Henderson,   and  some  of  the  store- 
keepers were  James  Hill,   Leighton  Tolbert,   Jim  Tolbert,   Dave  Bivins,   Will 

^Sims,   p.  210. 

2  S.E.   Scates,   A  School  History  of  Tennessee  (New  York:  World 
Book  Company,   1925),    p.  23. 

3  Nashville,   Daily  American,   loc.    cit. 

4  Goodspeed,   p.  812. 

5  Harrell,    "The  Dill  Family",   loc_.    cit. 

^  Interview  with  William  Hoyt  Smith,   March,   197  6. 

'^  Interview  with  Joe  J.   Jernigan,   Dec.  ,   1975.   Mr.  Jernigan  is  a  son 
of  William  and  Betty  Thompson  Jernigan,   who  owned  a  farm  in  the  Dilton 
Commvinity  across  the  road  and  east  of  Moore  Hill. 


DILTON  STORE 


PLEASAMT  GROVE  CHURCH 


LYTLE  CREEK 


DILTON  COUNTRYSIDE 


A  Dilton  store  of  about  1906.  Storekeeper  Sylvester  Willard  is  standing 
with  ants  crossed  near  the  center  of  the  picture.  Ernest  Smith  is  second 
person  to  the  ri^t  of  Mr.  Willard  with  dark  hat  and  moustache.  Mr.  Willard 's 
wife  and  child  are  standing  in  front  of  the  windcw  on  the  left  side  of  the 
picture. 


-...  f  nii.-Mn  ■»■ 


A  Dilton  store  of  about  1900.  The  store  was  CTvned  by  John  Overall  and 
operated  by  M.  V.  Baugus.  -Rvo  people  in  the  picture  are  said  to  be  Tom 
Benson  and  Hugh  Kirk,  Jr.  The  store  burned  around  1904. 


Overall,    Sylvester  Willard,    M.V.  Baugus,   Oscar  Harrcll,    and  Grovor 
ArnolU'.  1       After  Dr.    Dill,    Leighton  Tolbert  began  a  term  as  poslriia.stor 
in  1803  and  Sylvester  Willard  in  1901.        The  post  office  was  discontinued  in 
l90fi.  ■^    Oscar  Harrell  i-an  the  store  from  about  1910  until  1925.  ^    His  son. 
William  Harrell,    presently  owns  and  operates  the  only  Dilton  store,    a  con- 
crete block  structure.     Hatton  Adams  operated  the  only  store  on  Moore  Hill 
until  1905.  5  and  Hendrick  Mankin  was  storekeeper  at  a  store  on  the  corner 
of  the  Manchester  Pike  and  the  old  road  which  led   to  Dilton  during  the  years 
from  1914  to  1917.  ^ 

Agriculture  was  the  main  means  of  livelihood  for  the  people  in  the  com- 
munity.    The  first  plantation  owner  raised  corn,    cotton,    and  wheat  and  kept 
"milch"  cows,    a  yoke  of  oxen,    horses,    mules,   hogs,    chickens,    geese  and 
ducks.'''    The  products  of  the  farm  which  were  not  used  for  the  families 
sustenance  were  sent  to  market.     Mr.   Joe  Jernigan,    a  youngster  during  the 
inCO's  and  ICOO's  rcrneml:)ers  that  hogs,    turkeys,    and  cattle  wei'e  driven  to 
Murfrecsboro  past  his  home  near  the  Dilton  store  from  farms  as  far  away 
as  Bradyville  and  that  the  drivers  frequently  stopped  along  the  road  with  the 
animals  to  spend  the  night.     The  Murfreesboro  and  Bradyville  Turnpike  was 


•'•  Interview  with  Joe  J.   Jernigan,    December,   1975. 

2  Henry  G.   Wray,    "Rutherford  County  Post  Offices  and  Postmasters,  " 
Pcutherford  Co.    Historical  Society,   Publication  No.    5,    p.  31. 

"^  Ibid.  ^  Interview  with  William  Hoyt  Smnth.   March,   197  6. 

5  Interview  with  Mr.    Smith,   March,   1976. 

6  Jack  R.   Mankin,    "Autobiography"  (Ms.  ,   1973),    p.  ISO. 

'^  Register's  Office,   Ruth.   Co.,   Tenn.  ,   Deed  Book  Y,   p.  123.     These 
products  are  mentioned  in  this  deed  of  1857  of  property  from  William  Nelson 
to  John  Nelson.     The  property  was  located  in  the  area  to  become  knov/n  as 
Dillon. 


88 
in  operation  at  this  time,    but  it  had  little  resemblance  to  our  present  con- 
cept of  a  turnpike.     The  road  was  barely  wide  enough  for  wagons  to  pass  when 
they  met,    and  horses  and  cattle  would  sometimes  sink  knee  deep  in  mud.  •'■ 
Turnpike  companies  perforined  valuable  service  for  the  people.     The 
companies  chartered  by  the  state  legislature  were  inade  up  of  men  who  owned 
rock  crushers,   wagons,    and  teams  of  horses  and  who  hired  drivers  and  labor- 
ers for  the  purposes  of  constructing  roads  and  bridges  and  charging  tolls. 
Some  of  the  toll  money  was  considered  income  on  their  investments  and  the 
remainder  was  used  for  repairs.  "^    The  legislature  set  the  amount  of  toll  that 
-could  be  charged.  ^    When  the  Murfreesboro  and  Bradyville  Turnpike  Company 
was  chartered  in  1855,   the  directors  were  L.H.  Carney,   Levi  W.  Reeves, 
E.  A.  Keeble,    and  William  Spence.  ^    On  the  day  that  the  turnpike  opened,    it 
was  toll  free  and  "wagons  and  carts  and  horses  came  out  the  pike  all  day.  "^ 
Receipts  recorded  by  Goodspeed  for  the  Murfreesboro  and  Bradyville  turn- 
pike in  1886  were  $1,  793.  18  and  expenditures  were  $1,  5  60.  78.  6    There  were 
three  toll  gates  along  the  pike  about  five  miles  apart.     The  first  was  along 
the  road  to  the  northwest  of  Todd  Lake,    another  was  at  the  foot  of  Moore 
Hill,    and  the  third  was  located  in  the  Donnell's  Chapel  community.       The 
directors  of  the  turnpike  in  1903  were  Charles  R.  Holmes,    W.  H.  Woods, 
Hugh  Kirk,   D.  B.  Murray  and  J.  C.  Carnahan.  ^ 

■'■  Interview  with  Joe  J.   Jernigan,   December,   1975. 

2  Joseph  H.  Parks,  The  Story  of  Tennessee  (Norman,  Okla:  Harlow, 
1963),   p. 185. 

3  Acts  of  the  State  of  Tennessee,   1875,   p.  241. 

4  Ibid.,   1855-56,   p. 385;  1857-58,   p. 373. 

^  Interview  with  Roy  Tarwater  who  quoted  W.  A.  Sloan  (1853-1933), 
January,   1976.  6  Qoodspeed,   p.  817. 

7  Interview  with  William  Hoyt  Smith,    March,   197  6. 

^  Letter  from  Joe  C.  Carr,  Sec.    of  State,   Tenn.  ,    May  4,   1976. 


89 
People  in  the  community  took  turns  working  the  roads  which  woi'c  not 
liii'iipikes  with  picks  and  shovels.     Gravel  was  hauled  from  creek  'oeds  in 
wagon  loads  pulled  by  teams  of  horses.     Both  men  and  horses  worked  l^ard 
1o  keep  the  roads  in  good  condition,    but  it  seemed  a  losing  battle  as  both 
weather  and  wagon  wl>eels  would  soon  undo  what  had  been  done.     Alexander 
T.   Smith  was  appointed  overseer  of  the  road  between  the  turnpike  and  the 
home  of  Mrs.   Dorothy  Philips  and  served  in  that  capacity  from  187  3  to  1879. 
The  1878  map  reveals  several  cotton  gins  scattered  over  the  Dilton 
countryside.     One  was  owned  by  John  W.   Childress  and  another  by  W.  Fr-ank 
Overall.     Mr.   Frank  Overall  is  also  remembered  by  several  people  today 
for  his  cherry  orchard.     When  the  cherries  ripened,   boys  were  hired  to  pick 
them  only  if  they  were  qualified  by  the  ability  to  whistle.     Mr.   Overall  wisely 
required  that  the  boys  whistle  while  they  worked  1^ 

William  Yearwood  operated  a  grist  mill  on  his  farm  in  the  latter  part 
of  the  19th  century  and  in  the  early  part  of  this  century.     Most  grist  mills 

were  propelled  by  water  power,   but  Mr.  Yearwood's  mill  was  powered  by  a 

3 
large,    stationary  gasoline  engine  which  was  started  by  a  kitchen  m.atch.       A 

miller  was  expected  to  keep  an  eighth  of  the  meal  which  he  had  ground  for  the 

farmer.     Some  millers  were  inclined  to  keep  a  little  more,    but  Mr.  Yearwood 

was  said  to  have  been  fair  and  just  in  his  dealings  with  the  farmers,   always 

giving  good  measure.        In  addition  to  the  grist  mill,    William  Yearwood  had 

a  small  home  broom  factory.     Some  of  the  farmers  in  the  neighborhood 

^    County  Court  Clark's  Office,   Ruth.    Co.  ,   Tenn.  ,   Road  Books,  1872-79. 
2  Letter  from  Jack  R.   Mankin,   Jan.   12,   1976.  ■^  Ibid. 

4  Interview  with  William  Hoyt  Smith,    March,   197  6. 


90 
raised  broom  corn  and  took  their  harvests  to  Mr.   Yearwood  who  made  brooms 
on  the  shares.     Jack  Mankin  recalls  that  they  were  good  brooms  without  the 
fancy  trimming  and  fancy  handles  found  on  today's  factory  made  brooms. 
John  Benton  Mankin,   father  of  Jack  R.   Mankin,   was  a  progressive 
farmer  of  the  early  1900's  who  was  willing  to  try  new  gadgets  such  as  the 
hay  fork.     Dr.   Mankin  was  the  first  farmer  in  the  community  to  try  it.    Jack 
Mankin  explains  its  use  in  his  Autobiography: 

"The  hay  fork  was  a  device  for  unloading  loose  hay  from 
a  wagon  by  means  of  a  large  fork  on  a  track.    The  fork  was  let 
down  into  the  load  of  hay  and  the  triggers  set  to  hold  it.    Then 
a  pair  of  mules  attached  to  a  long  rope  would  pull  the  fork,    hay 
and  all,   high  up  into  the  roof  of  the  barn  where  it  would  roll  on 
the  track  to  the  place  it  was  to  be  tripped.    A  man  pulled  the 
trip  rope  when  the  load  was  where  it  was  wanted,   and  it  dropped 
from  the  fork.    Mules  instead  of  men  furnished  the  power  to 
unload  the  hay.     It  was  a  sensation  in  the  neighborhood  and  was 
the  forerunner  of  many  more  to  be  installed  by  farmers  of 
Dilton."2 

From  1906  to  1918  Raleigh  W.    Marlin  owned  the  property  shown  on  the 

Beers  Map  of  1878  as  belonging  to  Jasper  Knox,    property  presently  owned 

by  William  Elrod.  ^    Mr.   Marlin  may  be  credited  with  having  acquired  the 

first  tractor  in  the  community.     His  daughter,   Mrs.   Hoyt  Smith  (nee  Peai-1 

Marlin),    recalls  that  she  had  to  meet  her  father  with  a  bucket  of  water  for 

^    the  tractor  each  time  he  made  a  round  in  the  field.     It  was  a  gasoline  or  coal 

oil  powered  tractor,   but  it  was  "thirsty"  for    water.     When  it  backfired,    and 

it  often  did,    it  could  be  heard  throughout  the  countryside.     People  came  from 

town  and  from  miles  around  to  see  the  tractor  in  operation.  ^ 

1  JackR.  Mankin,   "Autobiography"  (Ms.,   n.d.),   p.  26.        ^  Ibid. 
^  Interview  with  Mrs.   Pearl  Marlin  Smith,    March,   1976. 
4  Ibid. 


91 
Jolin  Harris  owned  and  operated  a  saw  mill  on  the  Marlin  property  near 
J.ytlc  Creek  during  the  years  of  1912  and  1913,   when  he  and  his  large  family 
lived  in  the  Marlin  house.       Mr.    Harris'  daughter,   Mrs.    Hugh  Hooper,  recalls 
that  her  father  was  the  first  man  in  Dilton  to  own  a  car.     The  car  was  pur- 
chased about  1906  and  kept  until  1912.  2 

After  having  lived  in  Dilton  as  a  young  man,    Kelly  Harrell  moved  to 
Chattanooga  with  his  family  and  operated  a  grocery  store  in  that  city.  ^ 
His  daughter,   Mrs.    J.    W.   Duncan,   provided  the  following  information  about 
her  father:    Mr.    Harrell  returned  to  Dilton  in  the  early  1940's  and  built  a 
house  near  the  southwest  corner  of  the  Bradyville  Pike  and  Overall  Road. 
He  purchased  two  block  molds  while  in  Chattanooga  and  brought  them  to 
Dilton,   where  he  made  the  concrete  blocks  with  which  to  build  his  house. 
His  interest  stirred  by  concrete  blockmaking  as  a  means  of  livelihood,    he 
purchased  a  rock  crusher  and  a  block  machine.     The  block  making  machine 
is  believed  to  have  been  the  first  in  Rutherford  County.     He  established  the 
Rutherford  County  Lime  and  Block  Company  and  made  concrete  blocks  for 
sale  on  his  property  at  Dilton.     During  World  War  H,   he  established  the 
R.   K.   Harrell  Bottling  Company.     Soft  drinks  were  scarce  due  to  a  shortage 
of  sugar.     Mr.    Harrell  obtained  a  sugar  allotment,   built  and  equipped  a  bot- 
tling plant  on  his  property,    and  bought  two  trucks  with  which  to  distribute 
the  drinks.     He  marketed  the  drinks  to  stores  throughout  middle  Tennessee.  ^ 


Interview  with  Mrs.   Mildred  Harris  Hooper,   December,   197  6. 
2  Interview  with  Mrs.   Hooper,   December,   1976. 
^  Interview  with  Mrs.   Nadene  Harrell  Duncan,   March,   1976. 
4  Ibid. 


92 
Roy  E.    Tarwater  and  Cannon  J.    Overall  were  outstanding  agriculturists 
in  the  county  as  well  as  in  the  community  because  of  their  specialized  farming. 
Mr.    Tarwater,    who  is  now  retired  and  lives  in  Murfreesboro,    supplied  the 
following  facts  about  his  life  and  work:    Born  in  Missouri,    he  came  to 
Rutherford  County  in  1918  after  serving  in  the  army  during  World  War  I.     He 
married  Susie  Mae  Harrell  in  that  year  and  bought  a  farm  at  Dilton.     Mr. 
Tarwater  did  general  farming,    improving  his  land  and  using  the  latest  agri- 
cultural methods.     He  was  the  first  farmer  in  the  community  to  use  contoui- 
farniing  and  to  build  terraces.     His  specialty  was  raising  certified  and  founda- 
rion  seed.     When  hybrid  corn  was  introduced, he  was  the  first  farmer    in  the 
county  to  raise  hybrid  corn  for  sale.     Seed  from  Mr.    Tarwater's  farm  was 
mailed  far  and  wide  and  planted  in  several  foreign  countries  such  as  Italy, 
Egypt,    and  other  African  countries.     A  processing  plant  was  built  on  his 
farm  and  operated  for  several  years. 

Cannon  Justiss  Overall  was  born  to  Fannie  Justiss  and  Thomas  R. 
Overall  at  Dilton  in  1899  and  lived  at  his  birthplace  until  his  death  in  1974.  -^ 
His  daughter,    Jean  Thompson,   provided  these  facts  about  her  father:    In 
1924  Mr.   Overall  married  Mary  Virginia  Bock,   who  was  teaching  at  Dilton 
School.     Mr.    and  Mrs.    Overall  gardened  on  a  large  scale  and  supplied  the 
markets  of  Murfreesboro  with  a  wide  variety  of  garden  vegetables  throughout 
his  life.     Mr.    Overall  became  a  genial  and  successful  salesman  of  his  products. 
During  the  Christmas  season,    he  sold  evergreens  such  as  holly,    mistletoe, 

■'-  Interview  with  Roy  E.    Tarwater,    March,   1976. 

2  Interview  with  Mrs.    William  H.    Thompson,   Jr.    (nee  Jean  Overall), 
August,    1976. 


93 


pine,   and  cedar  ia  lots  and  in  handmade  wreaths.     In  1949  he  expanded  the 
sage  and  pepper  business  by  constructing  and  equipping  a  concrete  block, 
multi-purpose  building  used  for  the  processing,  packaging,  and  storing  of 
his  homegrown  seasoningSo    Thirteen  acres  of  sage  and  pepper  were  grown, 
processed,  and  packaged  during  the  years  of  peak  production.     Mr„  Overall 
sold  to  grocery  stores  throughout  middle  and  west  Tennessee  these  seasonings 
bearing  recipes  for  their  use  on  the  labels. 

Agriculture  continued  to  be  a  primary  source  of  income  in  the  Dilton 

community  for  thirty-five  to  forty  years  into  this  century-    On  a  joyous  day 

2 
in  1937,  the  Dilton  commionity  acquired  electricity.       Some  people  who  lived 

there  at  the  time  remember  well  just  where  they  were  and  what  they  were 
doing  when  the  lights  came  on.     With  this  and  other  technological  advancement, 
Lliis  community,  as  all  other  communities  in  the  land,  began  to  change.     People 
who  lived  during  those  early  times  remember  the  good  and  the  bad,  but  mostly 
they  remember  the  good  and  they  miss  it.    The  feeling  is  as  one  of  homesick- 
ness.    The  young  think  of  those  times  as  another  world  and  wonder  what  they 
have  missed.    Today's  older  generations  have  had  the  unique  privilege  of 
living  in  "two  worlds"  or  eras:  the  agricultural  and  the  industrial. 

Interview  with  Mrs.  Jean  Overall  Thompson,  August,  1976. 
^An  entry  in  the  author's  diary  on  January  31,  1937  reads  "My  grandparents 
are  just  now  getting  their  electricity.  " 


94 


Index  for  Publication  Number  9 


Abernathy 

54 

.  Coates 

70 

Adams 

87 

Coleman 

72 

Al exander 

55-82 

Conway 

36 

Ararat  te 

63-65-87 

Cotton 

52 

Arnold 

40 

Cox 

52-58 

.^  shley 

74 

Crass 

73 

Atkinson 

45 

Craddock 

74 

Auberry 

76 

Cullora 
Cumraings 

57 
10-36 

Raines 

54 

Dahbs 

65 

Ba^er 

57-58 

Davenport 

53-74 

rtarbee 

54 

Davis 

54 

Hass 

56-60-72 

Delbridge 

58 

Bates 

25-36 

Denton 

63 

Ratey 

65 

Devault 

54 

Raugus 

87 

Dill 

1-42-43-44-47-62- 

Beasley 

52 

64-65 

Heard 

54-55-56- 

•60- 

-61 

Dismukes 

19-32-33 

72-82 

Donnell 

74 

Hicton 

73 

Dorris 

54 

BpII 

73 

Douthitt 

65 

Bellah 

37 

Downing 

76 

Riggers 

74 

Dragging  Canoe 

4 

Bilbrey 

58 

Drake 

54 

Bivins 

29-84 

Duncan 

65-91 

Black 

18 

Black  Fox 

2-3-4-5-6-7- 

-49 

Eaton 

51 

Blackstock 

59 

Elam 

67 

Blair 

84 

Elrod 

58-90 

Blount 

5 

Ernest 

60 

Hock 

74-92 

Evans 

55 

Bowling 

73 

Brandon 

74 

Fleming 

36-55-63 

Brewer 

63 

Fletcher 

51-67 

Brigance 

63 

Forrest 

40 

Bright 

72 

Fox 

38 

Brooks 

36 

Francis 

55 

Brown 

44-65-73- 

-76 

Frazier 

58 

Buchanan 

5 

Fulks 

25-36 

Burnett 

54 

Gannaway 

51 

Campbell 

23-36-62 

Ghee 

53 

Crnnon 

21 

Gilchrist 

25-28-29 

Harden 

66 

Gilley 

12-38-39-45-58-73 

Carnahan 

88 

Glanton 

56-72 

Carney 

59-72-88 

Goodman 

60 

Carter 

63-65-73 

Gordon 

60 

Castleman 

4-5 

Gray 

60 

Childress 

1-14-15-17-] 

L8-19 

Gregory 

73 

20-21-27- 

■28- 

-29-32 

Gresham 

55 

33-36-47- 

■67- 

-69-84 

Grimes 

54 

89 

Grissom 

55-60 

95 


Harrell 

1-39-40-42-43-44-47-53 

La\.;rence 

15-36-37 

54-57-58- 

-61 

-63- 

-65- 

-68 

Lee 

70 

71-72-73- 

-74 

-76 

-87 

Leigh 

55-56-72-82 

91-92 

Locke 

65 

Harris 

10-36-63- 

-64 

-65- 

-74- 

-91 

Lokey 

73 

Hastings 

40 

Love 

36 

Hawkins 

10-36 

Lowe 

53 

Hayes 

53 

Lynch 

58-59 

Haynes 

54-74 

Lyons 

55-56-59 

H^arn 

45 

Lytle 

36 

Henderson 

40-41-42- 
73-76-84 

-55' 

-57- 

-59- 

■60 

Maberry 

36 

Hendricks 

45 

Macon 

58 

Hendrix 

55 

Mahaffey 

54 

H ewe 11 

66 

Mankin 

43-44 -45-49-5n-6''- 

-63 

Hill 

42-74-84 

64-75-76-78-80-H2 

-ay-Qn 

Hodge 

37-45 

Marlin 

15-36-90-91 

Holraes 

88 

Mayberry 

59 

Hooper 

91 

McClain 

73 

Horton 

76 

McCluskey 

54' 

Huddleston 

54 

McCord 

55 

Hutchinson 

42-54 

McCrary 
McDowell 

39-63-76 
10 

Irby 

65 

McFadden 
McGowan 

52 
72 

Jackson 

10 

McKnight 

55 

Jaco 

54 

McLaughlin 

20 

Jacobs 

43 

McLean 

23 

Jaggers 

54 

McNabb 

54-68-69 

Jakes 

53 

McPherson 

54 

James 

56 

Med lock 

53 

January 

51 

Meeks 

72 

Jarman 

40 

Meigs 

7 

Jarrett 

55 

Messick 

54 

Jennings 

74 

Miller 

36-44 

J^nigan 

47-62-63- 

-78- 

-79- 

-87 

Mitchell 

52-70 

Jetton 

15-36-37- 

-52- 

-59 

Mofield 

66 

Johns 

58 

Mo  Hoy 

51 

Jones 

56-72-74 

Montgomery 

36-70 

Jordan 

55 

Moore 

37-38-57-59 

Judkins 

66 

Morgan 

57 

J-istice 

29-33-58 

Morrison 

24-70 

Justiss 

92 

Murray 

88 

Keeble 

60-61-62- 

-73- 

-88 

Ncal 

57 

Kellar 

55 

Neely 

36 

Kelly 

51 

Nelson 

31-32-36-62-67 

Kelton 

1-10-11-12-36-42 

Nesbett 

38 

Kinqsley 

20 

Northcutt 

70 

Kirk 

36-37-88 

¥  nox 

28-29-38- 
72-90 

•57- 

-58- 

-69 

Oakley 
Ogles 

54 
54 

Lackey 

12 

Oglesby 

54 

L?ndrtini 

58 

Osborne 

73 

i.asset'»r 

48-55-59 

Ore 

5-6 

96 


Overall 

29-30-33-37-57-58 

Sraithson 

63 

59-63-65-67-68-72 

Sneed 

56-74 

74-76-87-89-92-93 

Snell 

76 

Owen 

73 

Speer 
Spur lock 

70 
66 

Parker 

76 

Stacy 

66 

Parman 

74 

Stancliff 

65 

Parrish 

60 

Stephenson 

20 

Paschal 

33-58-59 

Stewart 

52 

Pane 

58 

Stone 

62 

Pendergrast 

66 

Stroope 

52 

Pfeil 

78 

Summer 

24-25 

Philips 

14-19-23-24-25-26-27 

28-29-32-33-36-59-89 

Tarwater 

1-37-58-92 

Phillips 

53 

Tatura 

36 

Polk 

17-18-19-26-33-67 

Thompson 

33-52-92 

Pope 

24 

Tobias 

54 

Porter 

65 

Todd 

37-59 

Potts 

74 

Tolbert 

63-76-84-87 

Prater 

52 

Tompkins 

61 

Price 

76 

Tucker 

57-70 

P'lckett 

73-74-76-77 

PuLlias 

63 

Vance 

54 

Purdy 

24 

Vanderleer 

55 

Puryear 

70 

Wade 

55 

Randolph 

55-56 

Walker 

60-66 

Ransom 

72-76 

Walkup 

60 

Ratcliff 

54 

Wallace 

53 

Reeves 

88 

Ward 

57 

Rhea 

15 

Warren 

52-54 

Ridley 

55 

Watson 

54-76 

Ring 

32-37-69-70 

Watts 

53-76 

p.-ibertson 

5-6 

Weatherly 

59 

Roberts 

15-73 

Webb 

33 

Rohinson 

44-45-72 

Weeks 

58 

Robison 

76 

White 

54-74 

Rogers 

37 

Whitfield 

74 

Rowland 

53-54 

Wiggins 

36 

Ross 

41 

Willard 

53-85 

Rucker 

11-14-26 

Williams 

14 

Rutledge 

15 

Williamson 
Wilson 

74-76 
36 

Sade 

76 

Winburn 

36 

Sanders 

38-58 

Winslett 

65 

SflTsora 

21 

Wolfe 

53 

Fledge 

54 

Wood 

15-74 

Sloan 

12-52-53-73 

Woods 

47-67-88 

S pence 

88 

Sraith 

2-19-21-26-27-28-29 

Yeardley 

36 

30-32-33-36-47-49-59 

Yearwood 

52-53-69-70-76-8 

O-90 

62-63-68-69-70-72-74 

York 

54 

89-90 

Youree 
Zumbro 

76 
52 

3    3082    00527    7024 

976.857 

R931p 

V.9 


78-019^45 
Rutherford  Coimty  Hist.    Society 

AUTHOR 

Publication 


LIBRARY 

MIDDLE  TENNESSEE  STATE  UNIVERSITY 

MURFREESBORO, TENNESSEE 


K 


DATE  DUE 


"Hp-^ 


^  tT"/'^^  I