Quarterly journal of microscopical science

| Ribrary of the Museum
COMPARATIVE ZOOLOGY,

AT HARVARD COLLEGE, CAMBRIDGE, MASS.

Founded by private subscription, in 1861.

Deposited by ALEX. AGASSIZ.

| ae * gs és

i)

te
|
, %

QUARTERLY JOURNAL

oF

MICROSCOPICAL SCIENCE:

EDITED BY

JOSEPH FRANK PAYNE, M.B. Oxon., B.Sc. Lonp.,
Fellow of Magdalen College, Oxford ; Assistant Physician to St. Thomas’s Hospital ;

EK. RAY LANKESTER, M.A., F.R.M.S.,
Fellow and Lecturer of Exeter College, Oxford ;

AND

W. T. THISELTON DYER, M.A. Oxon., B.Sc. Lonp., F.L.S.,
Professor of Botany to the Royal Horticultural Society.

VOLUME XIV.—New Szrrizs.
GHith Allustrations on Wood and Stone.

LON D.ON :
Jd. & A. CHURCHILL, NEW BURLINGTON STREET.
1874,

To Binder :—Insert to face page 142. |

CORRIGENDA.

Page 142, line 10, for “too intimate connection,” read “ combined use.”

”

?
2

145,
147,
154,

155,

158,
159,
161,
163,

To Binder

+P)

20, omit “if.”
25, omit “so.”
31, for “ Boguslaus,” read “ Bogislaus.”
9, for “‘ effective,” read “ efficient.”
4 (of the note), for ‘‘ when,” read “ that is to say.”
6 (from bottom of the note), for “ extremities,” read “ ex-
tremity.”
8, for “ casual,” read “ causal.”
29, for “furrowed cells,” read “ cleavage-cells.”
2, for “in,” read “ upon.”
29, for “ grooving,” read “ cleavage.”
30, for “indistinguishable,” ead “ not an independent one.”
8, for “as an organ of departure for the skin,” read
“ having as an organ of departure—the skin.”
10, for ‘‘as an organ of departure for the intestine,” read
“ having as an organ of departure—the intestine.”
30, for “ latter, just,” read “latter. Just.”
4, for ‘‘ during the grooving,” read “‘ during cleavage.”
4, for “furrowed cells,” read “ segmentation-products.”
5, for “ germinal vesicle,” read “ blastodermic sac.”
15, for “before it developed the true body cavity,” read
“before the true body cavity developed.”

:—Insert to face page 223. |

CORRIGENDA.

Page 227, line 4, omit ‘‘ the.”

”?

228,
230,
236,

238,

239
240

”

”
”

”

”

12, omit “ much more.”

19, for “ germ-lamelle,” read “ germ-lamella.”

18, for “‘ is of different epochs and of phylogenetic origin,”
read “is phylogenetically of different epochs and
origin.”

3 (from Bava}: jor “furrowed cells,” read “ cleavage-
masses.”

32, for “ constitutive,” read “ constituent.”

8, for “ improvement,” read “ development.”

19, for “very,” read “ every.”

. et “

pines t 4

. LP ot ee er > “a a ee he fO ;
' 7 I

be ent ve . -
« e788 ¢ reuse 7
P > a ke wane 58 of

' , a NP o
4

me:

»
4

te

Plt t So . ie & f es

Arb

oe ne ee

SALT ae re ae ee

“a siermofatley 6 freee *
s difetisala. 10 lene

i Ns soem ‘i

ei
ac

" beey HH ar nit %

ERP: ty: i fy o Et tog

ce

nen 13 er tok oY
+ a 8S sary supe
a ~

MEMOIRS.

Some Account of KLEINENBERG’s RESEARCHES on the
Anatomy and DEVELOPMENT of Hypra. By Professor
Autiman, M.D., LL.D., F.R.C.S.1L., F.R.S., M.R.I.A.

Since Abraham Trembley about a hundred and thirty years
ago first made us acquainted with some of the most important
facts in the morphology and vital phenomena of Hydra, this
remarkable little animal, which, along with Cordylophora,
constitutes all we as yet know of the hydroid fauna of the
fresh waters of our globe, had become the subject of various
investigations. Many of these, however, had led to results
manifestly erroneous, while even the most careful and com-
plete of them had left much to be still determined regarding
the anatomy, development, and life-history of an animal whose
examination by Trembley marked out one of the great epochs
in the progress of biological research.

Quite lately, however, a memoir on Hydra! has been pub-
lished by a German zoologist, Dr. Nicolaus Kleinenberg,
which, in exhaustiveness and in the value of the results
arrived at, must take its stand among the most important of
recent contributions to the zoology of the lower members of
the animal kingdom. It is proposed to give here a résumé of
the most significant facts which the researches of Kleinenberg
have made known to us—researches which extend over the
fields of both anatomy and development. His observations
have been made chiefly on Hydra viridis, but they also
include the forms which he mentions under the names of
HI. aurantiaca and H. grisea, and which are probably only
varieties of H. vulgaris.

The anatomical section of the memoir embraces the struc-
ture of both endoderm and ectoderm—tissues which differ in
some very important points from one another.

The endoderm is composed entirely of cells, which are
arranged in a single layer. ‘These cells are simple nucleated

1 «Hydra, eine Anatomisch-entwicklungsgeschichtliche Untersuchung.’

Von Dr. Nicolaus Kleinenberg. Mit vier lithographirten Tafeln. Leipzig,
1872.

VOL, XIV.——NEW SER. A

2 PROFESSOR ALLMAN.

masses of protoplasm, quite destitute of investing membrane.
In the tentacles and basal portion of the animal each encloses
a vacuole, which is filled with a clear fluid, which, in its
behaviour with reagents, scarcely differs from pure water.
In the cells of the stomach-region there is no constant vacuole,
these cells being here usually in the condition of solid proto-
plasm masses.

Imbedded in the protoplasm of the endodermal cells of
H. viridis there occur not only the nucleus, but the green
granules. ‘These have a diameter of 0°009 mm. ‘They con-
sist, fundamentally, of a firm mass, very rich in albumen,
coloured dark brown by iodine and deep red by carmine or
aniline. Lying over this is an exceedingly thin layer of green
colouring matter, which, in its optical and chemical proper-
ties, is intimately allied to the chlorophyll of the vegetable
cell, if it be not absolutely identical with it. It will be here
seen that the conclusions of Kleinenberg correspond with
those of Cohn, who had already maintained, as the result of
careful investigation, the identity of the green matter of
Hydra, and of certain green infusoria with the chlorophyll of
plants.

With the green granules are also associated smaller cor-
puscles which have an angular shape, and instead of the pure
green of the others, possess a dark sooty colour. These are
frequently found conglomerated into heaps of very small, dark
brown or black granules. The free end of the cell never
contains chlorophylle granules; here, on the contrary, the
brown and black granules are accumulated.

In Hydra aurantiaca and H. grisea the place of the chloro-
phyll spherules is taken by colourless, round or oval, firm
albuminous corpuscles, which are developed in the cells
forming the endoderm of the stomach cavity. Apart from
the want of chlorophyll, these are quite like the green cor-
puscles of Hl. viridis. They are also associated, as in the
latter species, with dark granules. In all the species fatty
particles and oil-drops are also found imbedded in the endo-
dermal protoplasm.

In all parts of the body cavity certain cells of the endoderm
may be seen carrying a long very slender cilium ; rarely two
such cilia may be foundonone cell. The ciliated cells, how-
ever, are isolated, and do not constitute a continuous ciliated
lining of the body cavity, and Kleinenberg calls attention to
the interesting analogy between this and an entirely similar
form of vibratile tissue (the Geisselzellen of Haeckel) which
occurs in the sponges.

Such are the most important points of structure which we

ANATOMY AND DEVELOPMENT OF HYDRA. 3

may now regard as established in the endoderm of Hydra.
Most of them, it is true, have already been made known by
other observers, but it is, nevertheless, a matter of no little
value that they should be thus confirmed by the very careful
researches of Kleinenberg.

While the endoderm thus forms a simple cell layer, the
ectoderm on the other hand is a complex membrane. It is
in Kleinenberg’s statements regarding the structure of this
part of the Hydra body that the most original results of his"
anatomical investigations are to be found. The methods
which he has employed with most success in his examination
of the ectoderm consist in making transverse sections of the
animal after it has been hardened by being allowed to remain
during a period varying from one to three days in a solution
of chromic acid of 0°025 per cent., and then steeping these
sections for a quarter or half an hour in dilute acetic acid
0:25—0:05 per cent. The preparations may then be coloured
with fuchsin and preserved in dilute glycerine.

In sections thus made we find externally a simple layer
of large cells, which are in the condition of solid protoplasm
masses, with large ellipsoidal nuclei. These cells touch one
another only by ‘their broad bases, which are turned towards
the surface of the body ; while lying below and running up
between them there is a multitude of smaller cells, some of
which contain a_ thread-cell, some only a_ well-marked

-nucleus; finally, lying beneath these, and in close contact
with the endoderm, is a narrow clear zone in which the
well-known fine muscular fibrille are imbedded.

The very important statement is now made that each of
the large cells which form the most superficial part of the
ectoderm, tapers away towards the centre of the section and
either terminates in a single process or becomes cleft dich-
otomously, so that the inner end of the cell appears many-
times branched. ‘The cell-processes thus formed all run
towards the endoderm; when they meet this the finest of
them bend sharply at a right angle, and thus form the simple
layer of longitudinal soft fibrille which lies in contact with
the endoderm.

To these fibrille he assigns the name of muscle-processes
(Muskelfortsatze). They are all bound together by an
abundant intervening substance into a continuous lamina,
which is everywhere included between the endoderm and
the ectoderm. The substance by which the fibrille are bound
together not only fills the spaces between the fibrille, but,
increasing in volume towards the endoderm, forms a con-
tinuous thin membrane, which by maceration and tearing

4 7
f i |
, GAA

4 PROFESSOR ALLMAN.

may sometimes be detached from the muscle processes. It
is during life very soft, clear and colourless, and destitute of
granules. It is not coloured by iodine or carmine, but under
the action of gold chloride it acquires a straw colour. It
is to the membrane thus formed by the muscular fibrillee and
their connective medium that Reichert has given the name
of “ Stiitzlamelle.”

From the peculiar form of the large dermal cells there
necessarily lies between their outer ends, where they are in
close contact with one another, and the muscular lamina,
which lies in contact with the endoderm, a system of inter-
communicating lacune. These lacune are filled by the
smaller cells already mentioned. The tissue thus formed by
the small cells he names the interstitial tissue of the
ectoderm; it necessarily forms a network and not a con-
tinuous layer. The cells composing it are fusiform or
flattened, and their protoplasm surrounds a relatively large
nucleus which often forms the chief mass of the cell.

It is in the cells of this interstitial tissue that the thread-
cells are formed. These bodies are described as commencing
in the form of a spherical clear space which shows itself
by the side of the nucleus, and which, without being sharply
circumscribed at first, gradually acquires a double contour,
and assumes the definitive form of the thread-cell within
which the spirally wound filament is developed. It would
seem that some time after the completion of the thread-cell
the nucleus of the generating cell regularly disappears. This
cell then loses its granular contents and surrounds the thread-
cell as a spherical or oval covering. The thread-cells are ©
now pushed forward from the deeper parts where they
originate towards the surface, where they lie between the
large cells or become even imbedded in their protoplasm.
Kleinenberg is unable to add any fact to what is already
known regarding the structure of the mature thread-cell.

The structure of the foot differs from that of the rest of
the body in the fact that the interstitial tissue, and con-
sequently the thread-celJs which originate in this tissue, are
entirely absent from it.

Kleinenberg’s speculations as to the physiological signi-
ficance of the large ectodermal cells and their fibre-like
processes are full of interest. These processes alone
possess contractility, the cell-bodies belonging to them being
entirely passive during the motions of the animal. He
does not think that we can compare morphologically
the tissue thus formed to the known tissues of any other
animals, or that we can recognise in it physiologically

ANATOMY AND DEVELOPMENT OF HYDRA. 5

only one function. It appears to him as the most logical
view to regard this tissue of the ectoderm of Hydra as the
lowest stage of development of the nerve-muscle system in
which an anatomical differentiation of the two elements, as
this occurs in all the higher animals, has not yet taken place.
Every cell is thus the bearer of a double function, those parts
which constitute the long processes and lie upon the inner
side of the ectoderm being contractile and performing the
function of muscles, while the cell-bodies from which these
proceed, and which stand in immediate relation to the
surrounding medium, receive the stimulus and by transference
of this upon the processes effect the contraction of the latter ;
in other words, they operate as motor nerves. He proposes,
therefore, for these cells the name of “ nervo-muscle cells.”’

If these views be accepted, a step will at once be gained
towards the solution of one of the most important
questions with which modern physiological research has
occupied itself, namely, the nature of the motor-nerve termi-
nations throughout the animal kingdom. While, however,
we freely admit the care with which our author has worked
out the structure of the parts, and the consistency of the views
which he has founded on such structure, we cannot regard
these views as supported by reasons so strong as to induce us
unhesitatingly to accept them. Kleinenberg supports his
doctrine on the assumption that nerve and muscle are corre-
lative and inseparable. The fact, however, of our always
finding them so associated in the higher animals affords no
proof of such a connection being necessary in the lower,
while the direct morphological continuity of nerve and muscle
has not been established by’any of the repeated histological
researches which have been especially brought to bear on the
elucidation of this very point. It is almost certain that the
fibrille in the hydroid body constitute a contractile tissue ;
but that the superficial cell-stratum, from which Kleinenberg
regards them as direct prolongations, represents a true
nervous system, is still nothing more than a reasonable
hypothesis.

The sketch now given of Kleinenberg’s researches into the
anatomy of Hydra will show that, while he has confirmed
many of the statements of former observers, he has shown
the incorrectness of others, and has, at the same time, ad-
vanced our knowledge of the animal by the discovery of
several new and important points in its structure.

He next takes up the subject of development, and here his
memoir is even richer in new facts and deductions than that
part of it which dealt with the anatomy.

6 PROFESSOR ALLMAN.

With regard to zooidal development as presented in the
well-known budding of Hydra, we find nothing of importance
added to the facts already known. But in the formation of
the sexual organs and in embryonal development we have a
series of most careful researches, which have elicited many
unexpected facts and thrown new light on the entire subject.

It has been long known that at certain seasons there are
found on the body of Hydra pustule-like swellings, which
were regarded by the earlier observers as the result of a
diseased condition of the animal. Ehrenberg was the first to
detect their true nature when he showed them to be sexual
organs—in some cases containing spermatozoa, in others ova ;
in other words, they are the testes and the ovaria of the
Hydra, and the mode of formation of these and of their
contents have been carefully followed by Kleinenberg.

According to him the formation of the organ on which the
preparation of the spermatozoa devolves commences by a
more active growth of certain cells of that part of the
ectoderm which has been already described as the “ inter-
stitial tissue.” This change is limited to roundish, circum-
scribed spots; the cells enlarge considerably, and assume the
form of polyhedral plates, their protopiasm becomes clearer,
and the spherical nucleus comes out distinctly. Then they re-
peatedly divide and pass into small, irregular, apparently
amoeboid cells, which become closely pressed together so as
to form a compact lenticular body. This is the testis. It
becomes gradually elevated into a conical projection, with its
summit produced into one or two papille. In this state it is
invested by the other element of the ectoderm (nervo-muscular
tissue), whose cells have here become so much atrophied
that only a thin protoplasmal layer remains of them as an
external covering of the testis.

In the mean time the nuclei of the testis cells break up into
numerous dark corpuscles, which soon disappear, and in their
place sharply-contoured, strongly refringent corpuscles make
their appearance. The cells then become converted into
little clear, spherical bodies, and it is out of each of these
that the spermatozoon is developed. On some one spot of the
surface of the sphere there is formed a fine process of proto-
plasm which soon exhibits active undulatory movements.
The time for the separation of the mature spermatozoon
from the mother cell has now arrived, the cilium is found
to be in union with one of the bright corpuscles in the
interior of the cell, and by its strong undulations, the cor-
puscle with its attached cilium is extricated as a mature
spermatozoon from the formative cell, which then becomes

ANATOMY AND DEVELOPMENT OF HYDRA. rg

dissolved. In this way the whole of the included tissue of
the testis becomes converted into spermatozoa, which are
ultimately discharged through an opening in the summit.

The formation of the ovarium—which is usually asso-
ciated with the testes in one and the same individual—is
next described. The interstitial tissue is here also the basis
in which the new structure originates. Withina zone which
embraces about half the circumference of the body, the cells
of this tissue become multiplied and accumulated into groups
composed each of a single layer of cells. These cells now in-
crease in size, the groups come into union with one another,
and there is thus formed between the endoderm and the
superficial cells of the ectoderm an elongated cellular plate.
The cells which belong to the middle of this plate increase
still further in size; in their protoplasm there appear nume-
rous, strongly refringent corpuscles, which collect about the
nucleus, while the cells themselves become arranged in
‘superposed series, which all converge towards a common
central point, thus giving to the organ a striated appearance.

The organ thus formed is the ovarium. It must be ad-
mitted that in its mode of formation it differs essentially
from the gonophores of the marine Hydroida. These are, in
all respects, genuine buds, possessing a true zooidal inde-
pendence, while the spermatozoa-producing and ova-produc-
ing bodies of Hydra can scarcely be regarded otherwise than
as mere organs. Hydra would thus seem to offer an excep-
tion to the universality of the generalisation that the prepa-
ration of the generative elements among the Hydroida devolves
on special zooids. Kleinenberg sees this difficulty, and meets
it by the ingenpxous supposition that in Hydra the sexual
individual represents the gonophore of other hydroids, while
those hydra-buds which reach maturity without developing
generative elements correspond to their non-sexual or nutritive
zooids.

Another very important point of divergence between the
account given by Kleinenberg of the origin of the sexual
elements and that maintained by other observers will be
found in the seat of their origin being here assigned to the
ectoderm.

My own observations on the origin of the sexual elements in
the marine hydroids are, on the contrary, quite in favour of
their being products of theendoderm. In these hydroids their
first foundation shows itself as a thin, homogeneous stratum,
lying between the endoderm and ectoderm of the manubrium
of the gonophore, and it must be admitted that as yet we have
no grounds for referring this to the one membrane more than

8 PROFESSOR ALLMAN,

to the other. From this mass the ova or spermatic cells
become differentiated; it increases rapidly in volume, and this
increase appears to take place from additions at the side which
is in contact with the endoderm, thus leading to the conclu-
sion that additions are made to it by continuous transforma-
tion of the endodermal tissue. It is at all events certain
that the generative elements are developed from it in a cen-
trifugal direction, so that the more mature ova or spermatozoa
are always found towards its ectodermal surface, and the
nearer we approach the endoderm the more immature does
the entire tissue appear—a state of things which though not
absolutely conclusive as to the endodermal origin of the gene-
rative tissue, is most easily explained by regarding this tissue
as so formed.

Another fact in favour of the same view is the occurrence
of a delicate membrane which, in some cases, may be seen
lying upon the outside of the mass of the ova and separating
this from the surrounding ectoderm. This membrane I believe
to be the “‘ muscle lamella ” of Kleinenberg much atrophied
by the pressure of the included mass, and thus reduced to an
extremely thin pellicle without any trace of fibrille. If so, it
is impossible that the ova could have had their origin in the
tissue of the ectoderm.

A still further argument in favour of the endodermal origin
of the generative elements may be derived from the very ex-
ceptional condition presented by a few hydroids, and notably
by Sertularia pumila. In this species ova are produced in the
usual way within a sporosac. But besides occurring in the
sporosac, they are also found in the walls of the blastostyle
or columnar zooid from which the sporosac springs as a bud.
These blastostylic ova, though probably originating, as in
other cases, between the endoderm and ectoderm, are here
deeply imbedded in the endoderm so deeply that they project
into the cavity of the blastostyle, from which they are sepa-
rated only by a very thin layer of the endoderm.

On the whole, the evidence, so far as the marine hydroids
are concerned, appears in favour of the endodermal rather
than the ectodermal origin of the generative elements. Klein-
enberg, however, is very positive that in Hydra these elements
are derived from the interstitial cells of the ectoderm. With
his very careful observations and unexceptionable manipula-
tions it is scarcely possible to believe that he has been led into
error, and yet it would be a curious anomaly to find that so
fundamental a difference in this respect lay between the fresh-
water hydra and its marine representatives.

The formation of the egg is next described, and here w

ANATOMY AND DEVELOPMENT OF HYDRA, 9

find several new and important observations. When the
ovarium has attained the development just described, a cell,
which usually lies almost exactly in the middle of the organ,
attracts attention by its rapid growth. ‘This is the young
egg. It continues to increase in size and assumes a flattened
shape with irregularly-lobed margin. With further growth
it becomes divided by two deep indentations into two lateral
halves united to one another by a central isthmus in which
the nucleus (the germinal vesicle of the ovum) is imbedded.
This nucleus now begins to increase considerably in size, and
so also does the sharply-contoured nucleolus which is noticed
within it. The nucleolus, however, after it has attained a
certain size, disappears, and the nucleus now shows itself asa
sharply, double-contoured vesicle filled with a very finely
granular, weakly refringent mass.

The egg continues to increase in width, and the irregular
lobes of its margin become more strongly developed. Its
shape in this state with its two large, flat lobes and their
connecting isthmus, is compared by Kleinenberg to that of a
butterfly with its wings expanded and torn at their edges.
In the germinal vesicle there now appears close under its
membrane a clear, circular, flat body, the germinal spot.

In Aydra viridis chlorophyll granules now become deve-
loped in the egg, both in its central parts and in its peripheral
lobes. As we know chlorophyll to be in Hydra a product of
the endoderm, the ectoderm being entirely free from it, we
are called upon to reconcile this fact with its appearance in
the egg, which, according to Kleinenberg, is exclusively de-
rived from the ectoderm. Our author anticipates this objec-
tion, and dismisses it with the remark that it only shows that
the egg long before the occurrence of fecundation has liberated
itself from the physiological tradition of the tissue in which
it had its origin.

The marginal lobes and processes of the egg now greatly
increase in size, extend further from the central protoplasm,
become dichotomously branched, and form, in fact,the principal
part of the egg. The shape of the egg thus becomes remark-
ably different from the ordinary one, and is stated by Kleinen-
berg to be ‘exquisitely amcebiform.”

I can fully confirm Kleinenberg’s statement of the irregu-
larly-lobed condition of the egg in this stage, having, some
years ago, noticed it very distinctly in H. vulgaris, but I feel
very doubtful as to the propriety of designating this condition
as ameebiform, a term which may tend to give an incorrect
impression, as the processes cannot be regarded in the light
of protrusible and retractile pseudopodia,

10 - PROFESSOR ALLMAN.

At the same time, peculiar structures make their appear-
ance in the interior of the egg. In Hydra viridis these
bodies present the appearance of sharply-coloured spherical cor-
puscles, which lie embedded in the protoplasm. When liberated
and treated with diluted acetic acid, they are seen to possess
a thick wall surrounding a cavity; the wall is flattened at
one spot, and to the inner side of this is attached the base of
a thick conical body, which projects deeply into the cavity.

It is these bodies which, according to Kleinenberg, have
been mistaken by Ecker for embryonal cells, resulting from
the segmentation of the egg. Kleinenberg, however, cannot
regard them as cells; they take no direct part in the building
of the embryo, and remain as intercellular form-constituents,
which have manifestly the signification of material reserved
for future use; they become gradually brokenup. He names
them “ pseudo-cells,” and compares them to the so-called
yolk-spherules of the eggs of vertebrata. ‘The resemblance
of these pseudo-cells of H. viridis to certain bodies which I
have elsewhere (‘ Gymnoblastic Hydroids,’ p. 59) described

-as occurring free along with the eggs in the gonophore of
Antennularia is very striking.

The formation of pseudo-cells continues until these bodies
constitute a large proportion of the mass of the ovum. The.
ego has now attained in its greatest diameter the dimension
of about 1:5 mm. ; the projections of its edges are gradually
withdrawn and become fused into the central mass, and the
egg has assumed the form of a smooth, ovoid body.

About the time when the formation of the pseudo-cells is
finished a retrograde metamorphosis begins in the germinal
vesicle and spot which finally results in their disappearance.
It is here of importance to notice that the germinal vesicle
has disappeared without a trace long before the occurrence of
fecundation. The egg has now replaced nearly the whole of
the original ovarium, and is closely invested by the outermost
layer of the ectoderm.

. From the account now given it will be seen that the egg is
developed out of a single cell of the ovarium, that it main-
tains to the last its morphological value as a simple cell, dif-
fering from the other cells of the ovarium by its independent
growth and development—an important fact in its relation to
the essential nature of the egg, and in its bearing on the
general question as to whether the completely formed animal
egg is a simple cell or a compound structure.

Soon after the disappearance of the germinal vesicle the
time arrives when the egg is to escape from its confinement.
An opening is formed in the summit of the membrane within -

ANATOMY AND DEVELOPMENT OF HYDRA. 11

which it is included. Through this the soft, protoplasmic
substance of the egg is gradually forced out, and finally the
whole egg has been expelled.

The naked egg still holding on by a narrow point to
the remains of its former covering is now fecundated, the
testes discharge their contents, which become distributed
through the surrounding water, and the spermatozoa come in
contact with the egg and fix themselves by the head to its
surface, but they were never observed to penetrate its
substance.

After fecundation the process of segmentation setsin. This
is preceded by the occurrence of two or three delicate pseudo-
podia-like processes on that spot of the egg which is diametri-
cally opposite to the point by which it still adheres to the
body of the Hydra, and, at the same time, a shallow depression
shows itself between them. ‘This depression deepens into a
narrow groove, which gradually extends through the substance
of the ege down to its base, and thus the division of the egg
into two germ-cells is completed. During this process the
bottom of the groove is seen to be set with pseudopodia,
which present their characteristic movements of protrusion
- and retraction.

The entire process from the first appearance of the groove
to the complete division lasts from two to two and a half
hours. The protoplasm of the two germ-cells shows very lively
movements, and the second cleavage now begins. ‘This com-
mences from the opposed surfaces of the two first-formed
cells: it lasts from three to three and a half hours, and the
ege thus becomes divided into four germ-cells ; during the
process the formation of pseudopodia is still more marked
than during the first cleavage ; it occurs chiefly on the sur-
faces of division. The cleavage thus continues in the usual
binary order, and after the fourth cleavage is completed the
ege has assumed the “mulberry form.” It subsequently
becomes quite smooth—the result not of the smallness of the
cells composing it, but of the filling up of the interspaces
between the cell boundaries. .

After the completion of the segmentation two forms of
germ-cells may be distinguished: one of these, consisting of
prismatic cells, constitutes a single layer, forming the surface
of the germ; the other set consists of polygonally flattened
cells, and forms its inner main mass. These cells are all
naked protoplasm masses, and at first show no trace of
nuclei; a nucleus is subsequently formed in each, and this
arises independently of any pre-existing form element.

_A long discussion here ensues as to the essence of cell-

12 PROFESSOR ALLMAN.

division and the nature of protoplasm movements, in which
the author contends that the essential distinction between
proper contractility as presented by muscle, and the move-
ment which shows itself in every other form of protoplasm,
consists in the fact that muscular contractility is essentially a
motion in definite directions, consisting solely in a shortening
of the muscle simultaneously with an increase of its trans-
verse section; while in every other form of protoplasm—in
an amoeba, a connective-tissue particle, &c.—every molecule
of its mass is moveable in every direction; and since we know
that the all-sided mobility is a property of the indifferent pro-
toplasm, we must regard muscle-substance as a modification
of this, in which there has occurred a peculiar arrangement
of the molecules, which excludes all movements but one.
The views of botanists and animal physiologists regard-
ing the nature of cell-division are discussed at length;
and in opposition especially to the hypothesis of Hof-
meister, who maintains that cell-division is identical with
the formation of drops in a liquid, Kleinenberg regards
it as having its origin essentially in a destruction of the
uniformity of the protoplasm, local differences in the
cohesion of the mass setting themselves up; in some places
the molecules attract one another more strongly, while in
others the uniform weak attraction is maintained; and this
cohesion-difference will induce a general or local change of
position of the molecules relatively to one another. If we
designate by the name of currents the continuous movements
of a mass of protoplasm, which are the result of cohesion-
differences, we may distinguish in the Hydra egg two forms
of currents: 1, those which show themselves in the forma-
tion of local and superficial pseudopodia; and 2, currents
which change the whole form of the egg. He thinks it very
probable that the same forces which cause the currents cause
also simultaneously the division; and he thus regards the
division of the cell as a protoplasm-current phenomenon.
A very important process in the development of the Hydra
germ next begins to show itself. ‘This is the formation of
the external covering or shell of the germ. In Hydra viridis
this is first seen as an exceedingly thin structureless pellicle,
which invests the free ends of the prismatic cells, which, as
we have already seen, form the surface of the germ. This
pellicle sends in short processes between the cells, and
extends uninterruptedly over the whole surface of the germ,
from which, by maceration in acetic or very dilute chromic
acid, it may be separated as a continuous membrane. The
formation of this first pellicle is followed by that of a second

ANATOMY AND DEVELOPMENT OF HYDRA. 13

beneath it, then of a third, and so on, so that at last the
germ, instead of being surrounded by a layer of naked pris-
matic cells, is surrounded by a thick laminated hard shell of
chitine.

After the outer shell is thus formed there is produced
between this and the closely-applied germ a second covering
consisting of a colourless, transparent, and very elastic pel-
licle. Of the origin of this Kleinenberg can say nothing
positive, though he thinks it probable that it is caused by
the hardening of a liquid secreted between the germ and the
first-formed shell.

Kleinenberg has convinced himself that the outer germ-
shell of Hydra is not due to the secretion and subsequent
hardening of a liquid, but that it consists in a total meta-
morphosis of the entire outer cell-stratum of the germ. Every
one of its component elements is thus a cell, which, as the
result of the conversion of its protoplasm into chitine, loses
its vitality, its proper physiological value, yet retains its
morphological equivalence. ‘The shell is therefore an epi-
dermal formation, and in relation to the entire germ is one
of its tissues.

The outer germ shell in Hydra vulgaris differs in some
important points from that of ZH. viridis, for instead of the
thick shell, with its smooth surface, which occurs in the latter,
it consists in H. vulgaris of a thin chitinous capsule, which
is set round with a multitude of irregular spines mostly cleft
at their free extremities. This peculiar form is due to the
origination in each of the superficial prismatic cells of a large
vacuole immediately below the free surface of the cell, the
rupture of the cells over the vacuole, the fusion of several
vacuoles into one, the consequent formation of a sort of
labyrinthine tissue, and the conversion of this into the
chitinous shell.

It appears, then, established that the first differentiation
of the germ of Hydra consists in the formation of a peripheral
cellular lamina, the protoplasm of whose cells becomes con-
verted into chitine, and thus forms a solid shell. The first
organ which is developed from the germ is thus a provisional
embryonic one, which takes no part in the formation of the
definitive body, and on the liberation of the young is simply
cast off.

The period of the proper embryonal development takes a
far greater time for its accomplishment than has been needed
for the processes just described. While the whole of the
processes from the first appearance of the egg to the com-
pletion of the germ-shell are mostly completed on the fourth

14 PROFESSOR ALLMAN.

day, from this to the liberation of the young animal embraces
a period usually extending over six to eight weeks.

The first event which occurs during this period is a very
remarkable one. After the completion of the shell the
boundaries of the cells composing the mass of the germ
become indistinct and are finally effaced, the cells themselves
have become fused together, and the germ is once more like
the unsegmented egg, a single continuous mass of protoplasm.
This is filled with pseudo-cells, albumen granules, and, in
Hydra viridis, with chlorophyll granules. So enormous a
histological retrogradation might lead us to suspect its
reality, but Kleinenberg has no doubt of it, and he refers to
analogous cases, such as the currents in the protoplasm of
Myxomycetes, which show that the cells from which this
protoplasm originates have entirely lost their individual dis-
tinctness ; while even among the higher animals he can
adduce the observations of Bischoff as to the dissolution of
the germ-cells in the guinea-pig and the roe-deer. As it is
quite certain, however, that this phenomenon does not occur
in other hydroids, it can have no general significance for the
development of the order.

In the uniform protoplasm mass thus produced there is
next formed a small excentric cavity. This is the foundation
of the body cavity. By the solution of the surrounding
protoplasm it increases in size and becomes nearly uniformly
developed within the germ; it is filled with a clear liquid.
There is thus formed a closed sac—the germ-sac.

It is clear that the formation of a body cavity by invagina-
tion of the walls, with the significance which Kowalewsky
has assigned to it in other animals, does not exist in Hydra,
and just : as little will it be found in any other hydroid.

In the condition now described the germ-sac remains for
several weeks. In the meantime the outer germ-shell loses
its firmness, and is finally burst by the expansion of the
contained germ, which now escapes into the surrounding
water, covered only by the transparent, elastic, inner shell.

A further important change next occurs in the germ-sac.
The pseudo-cells which had previously been distributed
throughout the whole thickness of the walls of the sac have
uniformly withdrawn themselves from the surface, so that the
sac now presents a clear superficial zone. ‘This is the first
indication of the splitting of the walls into the two definitive
germ-lamelle. The clear superficial zone is to become the ecto-
derm, the darker zone which lies beneath is the endoderm.

The thickness of the clear outer zone gradually increases,
and cells now become differentiated in it. These are the

ANATOMY AND DEVELOPMENT OF HYDRA. 15

nervo-muscle cells. The interstitial tissue subsequently
shows itself between them in the form of irregular or fusi-
form cells. ‘The embryo stretches itself out, and assumes an
ellipsoidal figure; its walls become thinned at one end, where
a stellate cleft suddenly makes its appearance. This is to
become the mouth. Simultaneously with the appearance of
the mouth the foundation of the tentacles has been laid in
the form of tubular offsets of the body cavity. That layer of
the body walls which is to form the endoderm remains as a
stratum of continuous protoplasm until after the formation of
the mouth, when we find it converted into a layer of pris-
matic cells. The thin inner shell which had continued to
invest the embryo after the destruction of the outer one now
becomes softened and dissolved, and the young animal is set
free, corresponding in all respects except in size with the
adult, all the tissues having differentiated themselves to their
definitive form, and even the thread-cells, though still few,
being already ripe for emission.

From what we have thus seen of the development of
Hydra it is evident that this animal passes through no
proper larva stage. It differs in this from all other known
hydroids. We know that the egg of every other hydroid—
if we except that of the monopsean medusee—becomes
directly developed either like Sertularia into a planula, or
like Tubularia into an actinula. A certain resemblance
between the young Hydra and the young Tubularia induced
me to include the early free stage of both under the name of
actinula. As it appears now, however, that Hydra passes
from the condition in which it first becomes free to its adult
state by continuous growth without any true metamorphosis,
I accept, so far, the justice of Kleinenberg’s criticism, and’
believe with him that the term actinula is not strictly appli-
cable to it. It is otherwise, however, with regard to Tubu-
laria. Here we have a true metamorphosis, and the young
is a free larva which undergoes important transformations
before it becomes converted into the fixed adult. The term
actinula is thus a convenient designation for the larva of
Tubularia and of the apparently similar larva of Myriothela,
and in this sense I have employed it in contradistinction to
the term planula, by which the earliest free stage of other
hydroids had been already known.

I would accordingly distinguish three different modes in
the development of the hydriform trophosome :

1. The development subsequently to the liberation of the
young animal takes place by continuous growth without any
metamorphosis. ‘This mode exists in Hydra alone.

16 PROFESSOR ALLMAN,

2. The development takes place by a true metamorphosis,
the hydroid passing through the larval form of an actinula.
Of this Tubularia affords an example.

3. The development takes place by a true metamorphosis,
the hydroid passing through the larval form of a free ciliated
(or non-ciliated) planula. Of this we have an example in
Sertularia.

A comparison of the embryonal development of Hydra with
that of other’ hydroids shows that while in some respects
important differences are apparent, yet that in all the more
essential features there is a complete agreement, and by
widening the comparison so as to embrace in it what we know
of the development of the higher animals we arrive at certain
comprehensive generalisations which include not only the Hy-
droida, but even the highest members of the animal kingdom.

Huxley was the first to point out the equivalence of the
ectoderm and endoderm of the Ccelenterata with the outer and
inner germ-lamelle of the vertebrate embryo, and this im-
portant generalisation is fully confirmed, not only by the
development of hydra, but by that of all other hydroids whose
development has been carefully studied.

There are many groups of the animal kingdom of whose

developmental history we as yet know little or nothing, but
all which have been studied with anything like completeness
—all at least above the Protozoa—show that the germinal
‘matter which results from the segmentation of the ovum
differentiates two concentric germ-lamellz out of which the
whole animal body is built up. In animals above the
Coelenterata there is further formed between the outer and
inner germ-lamelle a middle germ-lamella, but whether
derived from the outer or the inner remains an unsettled
point. This middle lamella is not formed in the Hydroida
unless, as Kleinenberg with considerable reason supposes, it
be represented by the fibrillated layer or muscular lamella,
and as there can be no doubt that this really belongs to the
ectoderm, an argument is afforded in favour of the middle
lamella being a derivation from the outer. The muscular
lamella, however, is not in the Hydroida an independent
layer; but, as Kleinenberg has shown, passes continuously
into the superficial cells of the ectoderm. The ectoderm
should thus be regarded as the united outer and middle
germ-lamellz of the higher animals.

It should be noted that the study of hydroid development
proves that the digestive cavity is here formed by a simple
hollowing out of the interior of a solid germ, the mouth
subsequently making its appearance by a rupture of the

ANATOMY AND DEVELOPMENT OF HYDRA. 17

walls of the sac-like body thus formed, and not, as main-
tained by Kowalewsky and Semper, in nearly allied

‘animals, by an invagination of the walls.

Another question of great importance in this inquiry is
how far the origin of the various tissues and organs in the
respective germ-lamelle corresponds through the several
groups of the animal kingdom. We know that in the
Vertebrata there are formed from the outer lamella, the great
nerve centres and organs of sense, and the epidermal struc-
tures ; from the middle lamella the muscular, skeletal, and
vascular systems; and from the inner lamella the lining of
the digestive system and the glands connected with it.
Opinions vary as to the original seat of the generative
system.

Now, accepting the view that the ectoderm of the Celen-
terata represents the united outer and middle germ-lamelle
of the higher animals, and accepting also the hypothesis
that the superficial cells of the ectoderm in Hydra with their
processes represent a nervo-muscular system, we shall find a
remarkable correspondence as to the origin of the specialised
tissues between the Hydroida and the Vertebrata. In the
Hydroida the tissues are few, but these few are similar in their
origin from the primitive embryo layers to the equivalent
tissues of the higher; for the nervo-muscular tissue of the
Hydroida has its foundation in the ectoderm, which is equiva-
lent to the united outer and middle germ-lamella, while the
digestive surface is plainly formed by the endoderm or inner
germ-lamella. Here as in the higher animals, the origin of
the generative system is still an open question, and it is
probable that it is not in every case derived from one and the
same lamella, for while Kleinenberg is very certain of having
traced it to the ectoderm in Hydra, my own researches are in
favour of its endodermal origin in other Hydroida.

A still further interesting point of identity follows from
Kleinenberg’s discovery of the origin of the germ shell in
Hydra. This chitinous investment he shows to be a true
epidermal structure formed by the entire conversion of the
most superficial cells of the germ at a very early period in
the development ; and then entirely cast off after remaining
for a time as a transitory embryonal organ.

We have thus exactly, as in the Vertebrata, the most
superficial portion of the outer germ-lamella developing an
epidermis whose very early appearance and transitory. nature
are the only important points in which its history differs
from that of the epidermal layer in the Vertebrata.

It is true that nothing of this kind can be detected in the

VOL. XIV.—NEW SER. B

18 PROFESSOR ALLMAN.

other Hydroida; in these the superficial ciliated cells of the
planula almost certainly pass into a permanent constituent of .
the body walls, while the chitinous perisarc is not a tissue at
all, but a mere hardened excretion from the surface. I regard
the perisarc, notwithstanding its persistence, as hgmologous
with the internal germ shell of Hydra; indeed in some species
(e.g., Eudendrum ramosum) we find it forming a closed sac
in which the whole of the young hydroid continues to be
included even after the appearance of the rudimental tentacles
exactly as seems to be the case with the inner germ shell of
Hydra.

There is thus a difficulty in applying Kleinenberg’s deduc-
tions to the marine Hydroida and regarding the superficial
cells of these as the representative of a nervo-muscular sys-
tem, for we should then be compelled to derive the nervo-
muscular system of these hydroids from that part of the outer
germ lamella which in the Vertebrata gives origin to the
epidermal structures, and thus reduce to a mere non-essential
resemblance the parallelism which appears in other respects
so well established between vertebrate and celenterate
development.

When we bear in mind that the embryonic condition which
shows itself in the presence and primary relations of the germ-
lamella becomes soon lost during the process of development
of the higher animals, while the outer and inner germ-la-
melle with their relations to one another and to the sur-

‘rounding world are retained as ectoderm and endoderm through
the life of the Coelenterata we at once see wherein consists
the low position of the Celenterata in the animal kingdom,
and can compare the permanent Cceelenterate type with au
early stage in the development of the higher animals.

It will be seen from the account now given that the re-
searches of Kleinenberg have resulted in some very valuable
additions to our knowledge of the structure and life-history
of Hydra. In some respects they differ from those made by
myself on the same animal; but as my opportunities of inves-
tigating Hydra have been comparatively few, while such exa-
mination as I was enabled to make were not aided by the
very reliable methods adopted by our author, I am not pre-
pared, at least in the absence of additional observations under-
taken with the view of verification, to defend them, and am
willing to accept, not only those points of the memoir which
agree with my own conclusions, but most of those also which
take a different view.

MOTION AND GROWTH IN THE FUCACES. 19

On the Motion AccoMPANYING ASSIMILATION and GRrowTtH
in the Fucaczm. By Prof. P. Martin Duncan, M.B.,
Lond., F.R.S., &. (With Woodcut.)

(Read in Section D, at the Meeting of the British Association at Bradford,

How do the dark olive-coloured Fucoids respire? and
whence do they obtain their recondite elementary belongings ?
are questions which most physiological botanists have asked
themselves during their sea-side rambles. Authority answers
readily enough respecting the respiration, and will probably
insist that the nitrogenous and non-nitrogenous combinations,
the iodine, bromine, the potash, soda, and the phosphates
are separated from the sea-water in which they all exist as
inorganic substances. It is assumed that the plant exercises
a selective function, and that the rushing wave yields up the
elements in binary compounds to the superficial cells. These
can alone be the agents of the nutrition of the plant, for
there is no true root and no special circulatory system.
Washed by the sea, the cell-wall permits of an endosmosis,
and a liquid enters which is barely salt, and which contains
the well-known ultimate principles of these cellular plants.
Were the colouring matter of the Fucus green, and were its
proximate compounds only combinations of C,H,O, and
C,H,O,N, the effect of light and life on the carbonic acid and
free ammonia in the sea water would be deemed sufficient to
account for the assimilation.

But the colouring matter is peculiar. The plants may be
exposed to the glare of the sun, or hidden in cavities where
there is ever a gloomy darkness, with the same result on their
pigment. The presence of sufficient ammonia in sea-water to
account for the weight of nitrogenous matters in the rapidly
growing Fuci is a myth, and it is quite as probable that
decaying Fuci contribute the small percentage of salts of
iodine and bromine to the sea as that they should enter the
plant in solution in pure sea water.

The Fuci like the shore, and live best where the waves are
saturated with air, and doubtless much of the nitrogen may
come from this source. Is there not another ? is a question
which commends itself, and which may be answered by a
second: why should not these plants without green chlo-
rophyll! absorb organic matter in a state of solution? matter

1 [Millardet has detected chlorophyll in Fucacee#, ‘Comptes Rendus,’
Feb. 22nd, 1869.—Ebs. ]

20 PROFESSOR P. MARTIN DUNCAN.

consisting of carbon, oxygen, hydrogen, and nitrogen, with
other elements,—such matter as is absorbed by animals and
by entities which have irritability and powers of motion, but
whose position in the sub-kingdoms is uncertain. That
there is abundance of such soluble matter not yet resolved
into its ultimate elements, floating in the sea, no one can
deny. Wyville Thomson found it deep in the Atlantic, and
every excreting marine animal and plant contributes some of
it. Evanescent it probably is, but its amount must be
enormous.

Whilst thinking over such heresies as these, some other and
contingent probabilities suggested themselves. For instance,
if the dark-coloured Fuci absorb this organic solution—animal-
like—do any ameebiform motions accompany the assimilation ?
and what is the cell-growth like? It is hopeless to manipu-
late the superficial cells of Fucus vesiculosus with a view to
examine into their method of growth and assimilation ; but
the so-called ‘ conceptacles” on the clavate ends of the
fronds, which contain both round oogonia, and a vast number
of extremely delicate finger-shaped processes composed of a
succession of cells, yield admirable examples.

Each hollow enclosed by the frond, or the conceptacle, is
full of oogonia, and of the dactylose processes, bathed in a
- glairy homogeneous viscid colourless fluid. Growth pro-
gresses very rapidly in these structures, for the cells are
extremely delicate, and it is evidently due to the direct
assimilation of the mucus-like fluid which bathes them.

The following observations were made on a hot and light
day in August, upon the growth of the terminal cells of two
sets of finger-shaped processes :

After removing several conjoined processes, and placing
them in sea water mixed with the mucus upon a glass slide,
due precautions being taken to prevent pressure of the thin
glass cover, the relative position of the tops of two processes
was carefully noticed and drawn.

One process (a) had a fine tapering cylindrical terminal
cell surmounting a proximal cell (a’). The other process
(5) had a short and stout terminal cell, the distal end of
which was exactly on a level with the base of the terminal
cell of the other process, a.

Four prolonged examinations of these cells oceupied three
quarters of an hour, and during that time important amounts
of assimilation and growth occurred.

At the commencement of the observations the condition of
cells a and a’ (see woodcut, fig. 1) was as follows:

‘The terminal cell (@) had a homogeneous thin and very

j

MOTION AND GROWTH IN THE FUCACEZ. 21

Fic.
1. Two cells of a process in the conceptacle of Fucus vesiculosus.
a. Distal cell.
a’. Proximal cell.
a", Appearance of distal cell after ? hour.
2. Two cells of another process.

6. Distal cell, with its top on a level with the intercellular wall of

process l.
é'. Appearance and position of the distal cell after 3 hour.
BI" a 2 after 4 hour.

wn. * x after 2 hour.

The object-glass was a good penetrating ¢-inch.
transparent cell-wall, and its contents were, 1, a homogeneous
protoplasm less transparent than water ; and 2, four refractile
circular granules.

The cell-wall gave for the most part the usual double line
under the microscope ; but here and there the external line
was alone apparent, the inner being represented by a curve
in one place and by a sharp inward bend in another. The
substance included between the external straight line and the
curved line was homogeneous, but had a different refractibility
to the rest of the cell contents.

In the lower cell (a') two large incurvings of the cell-wall
were noticed, and the wall between the cells was single, and
presented two lines to view, the ends of which, where they
joined the outer cell-walls, were slightly curved.

The top of the second process (fig. 2, 0) was exactly ona
level with this intercellular partition.

There were no refractile granules in the distal cell (4) of
this second process, and its.cell-wall had a double line
throughout. The contents of the cell were a transparent
homogeneous protoplasm, and a portion of more opaque struc-
tureless material quite at the end.

After the lapse of a quarter of an hour the distal cell just

22 PROFESSOR P. MARTIN DUNCAN.

mentioned had its top slightly beyond the level of the inter-
cellular wall of the first process. The opaque spot had in-
creased in size, and there were two places where the outer
line of the cell-wall was in its normal curve, whilst the inner
was sharply bent inwards, so as to pmeteien) on the interior of
the cell (6’). Both were in the immediate neighbourhood of
the opaque spot, the longest of the two bounding it below.

In a second quarter of an hour the longest ‘of the bends
had reached across the cell in a slanting direction, and had
united with the opposite wall (6”). The smaller curve had
increased so as to separate the lines of the cell-wall for some
distance, and the opacity had diminished. The top of the
cell was further in advance of the intercellular wall of the
first process.

In the third quarter, and at the expiration of three quarters
of an hour from the beginning of the observations, the new
cell-top had grown far in advance, and had become very
considerably rounded (6), whilst slight irregularities in the
direction of the inner line of the wall were noticed in it and
also in the lower cell.

During this lapse of time the first process (fig. 1) bad
grown in length, and the distal cell (@) had altered con-
siderably in its details. The curve in the inner line of
the cell-wall had diminished, but a large and conical one
had reached the opposite cell-wall, thus forming a dissepi-
ment and dividing the cell into two (a”). Moreover, irregu-
larities in the contour of the inner wall existed in the
opposite side to those just noticed; the refractile granules
were not so numerous, and the whole cell had increased in
breadth as well as in length. The so-called curves could be
noticed to change their form by a slow undulating move-
ment, which was singularly suggestive of the method of
movement of Amoeba, and it was evident that the motion
extended beyond the curve amongst the more mobile included.
protoplasm. There was no trace of gas bubbles around the
cells, and the elongation, increase in bulk and the molecular
changes were not attended by any visible chemical action.

The impression left on the mind was that the cell-wall
was merely a more solid condition of the protoplasm of the
cell, and that the movement was determined by portions of
it returning to their more fluid state, owing to the transmission
or absorption of the surrounding medium.

Could one of the cells have been removed from the contact
of the others, it would have greatly resembled a Protameeba
in movement within a homogeneous tissue. Movements
like these are not observed in most alge which are

RHABDOPLEURA MIRABILIS. 23

nourished in water where organic matter in solution does
not exist. It becomes, then, a matter of some interest to
attempt to connect such movements and such cell-growth
with nutrition by such organic matter as would be assimilated
by low animal forms.

On RuaBpoPLEURA MIRABILIS (M. Sars). By Grorce
Osstan Sars. (With Plate I.)!

In the year 1866 I dredged, together with other deep-sea
animals, from a depth of 120 fathoms at Skraaven in
Lofoten, a small “ Phytozoon,” to which at first I paid no
great attention, as I took it to be a colony of Hydroids; I
took, therefore, only a few specimens, and put them in spirit
with some other uncertain forms of animal life from the
same depth. After my return home, however, on examining
more closely this supposed hydroid colony, my father found
immediately that we had before us a very peculiar animal,
which quite certainly could not be a Hydroid, but seemed
rather to be related to the Polyzoa; although the shape and
appearance of the single cells had undeniably a great re-
semblance to the former, especially to some Campanularides.
As a satisfactory examination of the animal could not be
made with the specimens brought home in spirit, my father
urged me, the next time I visited Lofoten to examine the
animal in a living state as minutely as possible, as we should
without doubt obtain interesting and instructive results.
This I had an opportunity of doing in the following year
1867 ; and I then examined, as carefully as possible with the
instruments at my disposal, the structure of this fragile little
animal, which I found peculiar in the highest degree, and
different from all that I had previously known. My father
was greatly surprised on learning the result of my examina-
tion, and, looking over the numerous drawings which I had
made from the living animal, it was clear that we had before
us not only an entirely new genus and family, but even the
type of a still higher division; and we found no small
difficulty in referring it to any known animal type. But as
it appeared most nearly related to the Polyzoa, my father
classed it with these, and noted it in his catalogue of deep-

' Reprinted from ‘The University Programme’ for the first half year,
°1869. Christiania, 1872.

24 GEORGE OSSIAN SARS,

sea animals, compiled in 1868, as Halilophus mirabilis" (the
generic name taken from a certain resemblance of the
tentacular arms to the so-called lophophore of the fresh-
water Polyzoa). The next year appeared Allman’s treatise
on Rhabdopleura, a new form of Polyzoa, from deep-sea
dredging in Shetland ;* and my father, as well as myself, at
once recognised in the species therein described and de-
lineated,! R. Normanni, a form closely agreeing with the
Halilophus mirabilis, but which evidently, from the form and
attachment of the polyzoarium, must belong to a different
species from ours. Allman’s communications concerning the
organisation of the animal show indeed, as will appear from
the sequel, many essential differences from what I have had
occasion to observe in our northern form; so that if these
communications were in reality correct, there could scarcely
be any doubt that both forms were also generically distinct.
But the fact is that Allman has only had the opportunity of
examining specimens preserved in spirit ; and both my father
and myself know from experience how extremely difficult it
is to obtain results with specimens in this state, and what
imperfect and false notions may thus be formed of the
animal’s real structure. Taking this into consideration, we
may really be astonished that Allman has been able ta see so
much as he actually has seen, and that he has not misunder-
stood the animal’s organisation in a greater degree than
appears from his description and delineations. Allman has
indeed seen in the Rhabdopleura a very aberrant form of
Polyzoa, but is far from having apprehended that the form is
abnormal in so high a degree as it has proved to be according
to investigations which I have executed with the utmost care
and minuteness.

With respect to the method of examination, there is little
or no use in dissecting so small and fragile an object as the
animal of the Rhabdopleura, even if the finest imaginable
instruments are employed. It is, therefore, necessary to
study the animal entire, or at most, after separating the
individual animals from their cells or tubes, which, as will be
seen, may be done with the greatest ease in operating on the
living colony. In order to get a sharper and better view of
certain parts, I have found it very useful to effect a gentle
compression of the animal between two glass plates, so that
the pressure can be moderated at will. I cemented a thin

1 ¢Forsatte Bemerkninger om det dyriske Livs Udbredning i Havets
Dybder,’ p. 12. ee;

* Quarterly Journal of Microscopical Science,’ vol. ix, 1869, pp. 57—63,
pl. 8

RHABDOPLEURA MIRABILIS. 25

glass plate to the upper arm of my compressorium, by which
means the desired result was obtained far better than by the
use of the so-called “aquatic boxes.” Moreover, most of the
parts of the living animal may be easily examined without
pressure, and without even taking the animal out of its cell.
A colony, or part of one, can be placed under the, micro-
scope, and the most important parts will plainly be seen
through the transparent walls of the cells, even if the animal
has not stretched itself out of the aperture.

Besides the outer chitine-like tube, with its off-shoots or
cells (polyzoarium), there may be distinguished in the animal
under consideration the following principal parts :—1l. The
polypide itself, which again shows three principal parts—(a)
the body; (4) the tentacular arms; and (c) the buccal
shield; 2. the contractile cord; and 3. the axial cord. I
shall treat each of these parts separately.

The polyzoarium (ccencecium) in the Rhabdopleura mira-
bilis (see Pl. I, figs. 5 and 6) has the form of a thin, elastic,
flexible, chitine-like, transparent, most frequently quite
colourless, cylindrical hollow tube, consisting of a stem,
which creeps along the bottom of the sea, now and then
attached to other bodies, irregularly winding, and only
seldom, here and there, forked, which at short intervals sends
up perpendicular, free, undivided, more or less winding
branches, of the same form, calibre, and nature as the stem,
and all terminating with a circular aperture. A difference
_ between the stem and the branches strikes the eye imme-
diately ; the stem is always more or less thickly covered
with extraneous particles (sand, mud, fragments of shells,
Rhizopod-shells, &c.), while the branches are always, with
exception of the very lowest piece, quite free from such
particles, and consequently quite transparent, appearing in
their whole extent very distinctly and ornamentally ringed.
The rings, which are only exterior, form close, equidistant,
sharp, circular transverse folds, strongly prominent over the
surface of the tube, causing the edges everywhere to appear
crenulated (see fig. 5). If one can separate from the stem
the very closely adhering extraneous particles (which is
effected with no small difficulty), it will be seen that
this outer formation of folds is also continued on the stem
itself, although far less sharply marked, and also more
irregular, the transverse folds being often divided fork-wise,
or in other words, not forming completely separate rings.
It will also be remarked (fig. 6) that the branches of free
tubes are not at all sharply distinguished from the stem, but
that their interior cavity is prolonged immediately into, or

26 GEORGE OSSIAN SARS.

continuously with, the cavity of the stem. This latter, the
interior walls of which, like those of the tubes, are quite
smooth, is divided at certain intervals by tolerably thick
trausverse lamellz, or septa, into several successive cylindrical
chambers, which do not communicate with each other, but
each one of which is continued immediately in one of the
perpendicular tubes proceeding upwards from the stem.
Through the whole of the creeping’ stem, extending along
through all its chambers, runs a thin cylindrical chitinous
cord (the axial cord), very remarkable from its dark, nearly
black, colour, of which more hereafter. This cord is never
continued up through the free tubes, but may now and then,
rarely, divide itself fork-wise, namely, when the creeping
stem divides itself in this manner.

Every one of the perpendicular branches or tubes contains
an animal, which is connected by a long, cylindrical, fleshy
cord (the contractile cord), near the bottom of the corre-
sponding chamber in the stem, with the axial cord, which
thus unites all the individuals of the colony with each
other.

The creeping stem in the R. mirabilis may indeed attain
a very considerable length, but it is very difficult to get the
whole separated from the substances which adhere to it.
One can usually, therefore, only get up small pieces of the
colony, and seldom more connected portions. The largest
connected piece of stem which I succeeded in getting
loose from its attachment was about 40 mm. long, and was
at irregular distances four times bifurcated; another piece
was of about the same length, but only three times divided,
These branches, which proceed from the stem at a more or
less acute angle, are also creeping and irregularly bent, and,
like the main stem, produce cells, the number of which in all
on these pieces of stem amounts to about 60. The stem is
thus only seldom branched, and usually runs to great length
without producing any branch.

The cells or tubes, which proceed from the stem by lateral
budding, are of very different length, while their thickness is
everywhere, and in all, about the same. The largest are
6—7 mm. long and +—1 mm. thick. They are, as stated,
erect, yet seldom, or never perfectly straight, but always
more or less bent in some part, or in the whole of their
length, sometimes like an S, sometimes in several bends or
turns, like a drawn out screw, but most frequently irregularly
bent, in rare instances so strongly curved, that the curve is
nearly circular.

From the above description, it will be seen that the poly-

RHABDOPLEURA MIRABILIS, 27

zoarium in the Rhabdopleura mirabilis is decidedly different
from that of the Shetland R. Normanni. Firstly, the
creeping stem of the latter, of which one surface everywhere
adheres to old shells or other solid substances, is much more
strongly branched (‘‘ subalternately”’), and, like the cells,
quite naked, without trace of attached extraneous particles.
Then the cells themselves are not, as in our species, free in
their whole length, but at the base for some distance, like the
stem itself, fixed and creeping, for which reason also the free
perpendicularly rising ringed part of the same is much
shorter than in the Rh. mirabilis. Finally, there appears
some difference between the two species with regard to the
manner of the division of the stem into chambers.

The polyzoarium in the Rhabdopleura does not coincide
with any other species of Polyzoa. The cells in their tubular
form resemble most of those of the Cyclostomata, but are
horny or chitine-like (in the Cyclostomata they are chalky),
and are distinguished by their surface, covered with promi-
nent transverse folds or rings, which are also foreign to the
Polyzoa, but are found in many Hydrozoa, such as certain
Tubulariadz and Campanulariade.

The individual animals or polypides seem at first glance to
resemble the ordinary Polyzoa (see fig. 5). The body, which
is only a little over 1 mm. long, is oblong, and appears to be
occupied almost entirely by the digestive system ; on closer
examination, we find, however (see figs. 1, 2, and 4), that
a thin glassy skin surrounds the digestive apparatus,
which therefore is not, as in all other Polyzoa, freely sus-
pended in the “ perigastric fluid,” which latter, as _ will
appear in the sequel, is entirely wanting in the Rhabdo-
pleura. In all other Polyzoa, without exception, there is
besides the so-called ectocyst, corresponding with the Poly-
zoarium, also a so-called endocyst, which always represents
a thin membrane, lining the interior of the ectocyst or cavity
of the cell, and, from the aperture, recurved and attached
round about to the polypide, under the base of the lopho-
phore. The interior cavity of the cells in the other Polyzoa
is thus actually completely closed by the endocyst and the
body of the polypide; and the so-called perigastric fluid
therein contained, wherein the intestinal canal of the animal
is freely suspended, does not stand in any direct connexion
with the surrounding medium. The retraction of the poly-
pide into the cell is effected only by a folding (invagination)
of the anterior elastic part of the endocyst, by which the
so-called tentacular sheath is produced. The case is quite
different with the Rhabdopleura. Here is no endocyst at all

28 GEORGE OSSIAN SARS.

(unless we should consider the glassy skin which closely
surrounds the digestive apparatus to be an endocyst), con-
sequently also no perigastric fluid; and, further, the cavity
of the cells stands in direct communication with the
surrounding medium, without being closed at the aperture
by a skin connecting it with the animal’s body. The retrac-
tion and protrusion of the polypide is, therefore, not effected
as usual by in- and evagination, but in a totally different
manner, of which more hereafter. Allman has indeed (1. ec.)
imagined that he has perceived a trace of a real endocyst of
the same nature as that observed in the other Polyzoa, but
he has quite certainly deceived himself. The polypide of
the Rhabdopleura lies quite free in the cell, and is only
attached to the colony by means of the contractile cord,
neither by any endocyst nor special muscles, as appears
clearly enough from the fact that when the contractile cord
is severed, the polypide can be taken entire and uninjured
out of its tube with the greatest ease.

From the anterior part of the body where the mouth is
situated, yet, as will appear in the sequel, not as usual in a
terminal position, but rather in a ventral situation behind the
peculiar oval prominence (the bucal shield), the gullet or
w@sophagus, rather short, but wide, and furnished with thick
walls, proceeds right downward or backward to the stomach,
from which it is separated by an also outwardly apparent
constriction, and by a sort of internal valve (the cardiac
valve).

The stomach (f), which is simple, without any armament
of teeth or hard parts in its interior, and furnished with tole-
rably thin walls, is elongated, rounded cylindrically, slightly
and somewhat irregularly curved, with ventral concavity, and
in its anterior part, where it has its greatest breadth, only a
little wider than the gullet, and occupying about two
thirds of the cell’s calibre. In the anterior half it is of
about uniform thickness, but diminishes towards the pos-
terior end (pylorus) very rapidly, and goes imperceptibly
over, after turning a little to one side, into the intestine, sud-
denly curving itself upward and forward. The intestine (g),
which is not by any constriction, nor yet by any interior
valve (pylorus-valve), distinguished from the stomach, of
which it forms the immediate continuation, is narrow, cylin-
drical (its thickness scarcely one third of that of the stomach
in the widest part), only slightly tapering towards the end
(see fig. 3), and has a tolerably straight course forward,
lying close to the dorsal side of the stomach and gullet, and
terminates with a circular anal aperture, situated just behind

RHABDOPLEURA MIRABILIS. - 29

the spot from which the tentacular arms proceed. Immedi-
ately behind the anal aperture, between the terminal part of
the intestine and the dorsal wall of the gullet, which here
forms a little concavity, there appeared a clear cellular body
(fig. 1, r), in which several evident nuclei were visible. I
cannot, however, pronounce any decided opinion as to the
signification of this object ; it can scarcely be a nervous gan-
glion, as it does not lie in the substance of the body itself,
but only in the thin external skin which encloses the body.
The stomach and the intestine usually show in the living
animal a bright, opaque, yellowish-brown colour, which colour
seems mainly to be derived from the contents. When the
stomach and intestine are more empty, they shew a far paler
yellowish-white colour. ‘The walls of both show plainly a fine
cellular structure.

It is evident that the digestive system in the Rhabdopleura
differs, in many points which have not been remarked by
Allman, from the normal system of the Polyzoa. In the
latter the stomach usually consists, as is well known, of two
distinctly separate parts, one shorter cylindrical cardiac part,
and a longer and wider pyloric part, which ends in a large.
rounded, bottle-shaped cecum (cul de sac). Therefore the
intestine usually takes its origin in these high up, or about
on a level with the.transition of the cardiac part to the py-
loric part; while in the Rhabdopleura, where no such divi-
sion of the stomach occurs, the intestine proceeds from the
posterior end of the stomach or fundus, as the immediate
continuation of the same.

The tentacular corona or lophophore, situated in the
Rhabdopleura on the anterior end of the body, is of a totally
different appearance from that of the other marine Polyzoa,
while, on the other hand, it appears at first sight to show an
unmistakable resemblance to that of most freshwater Polyzoa
(P. Hippocrepia), and is also thus represented by Allman.
However, when it more closely examined, it displays many
essential differences, although by its strongly marked bilateral
symmetry, it appears to be most nearly connected with the
same, in respect of the semilunar or horse-shoe form peculiar
to them.

As in the said freshwater Polyzoa, the lophophore or ten-
tacular frame does not form a circular ring, but is drawn out
iuto two lobes or arms, each of which bears a double
row of tentacles. These lobes or arms (fig. 5, &c., d), which
also here proceed from the dorsal side, are, however, consi-
derably longer and narrower, or more cylindrical than in any
other of the known Polyzoa; and while in those freshwater

30 GEORGE OSSEAN SARS,

Polyzoa they only form a part of the tentacular corona, they
represent here the whole lophophore, as it is only on these
arms that the tentacles have their place. The tentacles in
the Rhabdopleura do not form, as in the other Polyzoa, a
continuous series, but are interrupted, as well dorsally as
ventrally, by an evident interval; in other words, we have
not one single tentacular crown, but two symmetrical tentacular
arms, which take their beginning on each side of the anterior
part of the body, and extend out from the same dorsally and
diverging to each side. If we examine these tentacular arms
in the living animal, we find that they are also in many re
spects different from the lophophore of the Hippocrepia.
While the latter always retain unchanged their form and
somewhat inclined direction, the tentacular arms in Rhadb-
dopleura are in a high degree flexible and variable in their
direction relatively to the body of the polypide and to
each other. As long as the polypide is withdrawn into
the cell, they are always extended straight forward and
nearly parallel with each other, forming, together with the
tentacles attached to them, a close fascicle extending in the
same line with the body. As soon as the polypide reaches
the aperture of the cell, they spread out from each other, but
this takes place in various manners. Sometimes they are
bent with the ends only a little out from each other, while
otherwise they are nearly parallel (see fig. 5) ; sometimes
they spread themselves out so widely on each side that
they stand almost diametrically opposite; sometimes they
bend themselves with the ends downwards (see fig. 5) ; some-
times—and this is most usual, and always occurs when the
animal is taken out of its tube—they are bent upwards
and backwards, and that often so strongly that they describe
a nearly semicircular curve, so that the extremities even
touch the dorsal side of the polypide’s body (fig. 1). This
great mobility of the tentacular arms or lophophore (so
different from what is observed in the other Polyzoa), which
appears to be produced at will by the animal, sometimes in
one manner and sometimes in another, must certainly,
although it always takes place very slowly and with litle
energy, be brought about by means of auxiliary muscles or
muscular tissue. I have, however, only succeeded in observ-
ing very faint traces of anything of the kind. When the
animal is gently compressed between two glass plates, one
may observe on each side some very fine fibres (figs. 1 and 2,
p) passing obliquely over the gullet, proceeding from the
ventral side, where the body of the polypide forms on each
side a small conical prominence (ibid., 0, 0), which may per-

RHABDOPLEURA MIRABILIS. 31

haps be considered as the ventral corners of the lophophore,
and losing themselves at the root of the tentacular arms.
They appear to represent the retractile muscles of the tenta-
cular arms, which produce their flexion upwards and back-
wards. It has not been possible for me to discover any dis-
tinct trace of any such thin membrane connecting the basis
of the tentacles (the so-called calyx), as is found in the fresh-
water Polyzoa. As regards the tentacles themselves, they
are, indeed, of the usual cylindrical form for Polyzoa, and are
as usual furnished with cilia, but in the living auimal they
have a very different appearance from that of the tentacles in
the ordinary Polyzoa. While in the latter they are always in
the greater part of their length extended straight, forming a
regular corona, which only slightly changes its form, the end of
some one or other of the tentacles being only sometimes bent
alittle in one direction or another, the tentacles in the Rhab-
dopleura are always bent and curved in the most irregular
manner in all directions (figs. 1 and 2), so that there can
be no question of any regular tentacular corona. The num-
ber of these tentacles, which, as above mentioned, are at-
tached in a double row along the anterior side of the tenta-
cular arms, is somewhat various (about forty on each arm) ;
they are longest about in the middle, and are in this part.
about one third of the length of the arm, and diminish some-
what towards the base, but more towards the extremity,
where they are often quite rudimentary. The tentacular
arms themselves, each of which, at the base on the dorsal
side, is furnished with a little fascicle of unusually long cilia
attached to a small tubercular prominence (figs. 1 and 3, n),
are of very considerable length—quite as long as the whole
of the rest of the body—of uarrow cylindrical form, thickest
at the base, and tapering regularly to the end, which is ob-
tusely pointed. Anteriorly they are separated (see fig. 4)
by a naked, somewhat concave part (extending a little down-
wards), here contiguous to the basis of the remarkable oval
shield (c), which, both by its enormous development and
peculiar function, below described, forms one of the most
peculiar features of the Rhabdopleura.

Between the bases of the tentacular arms, and from
a somewhat ventral point, proceeds in an anterior direc-
tion a large and very remarkable prominence, situated
longitudinally, which has the form of an oblong thick disc
or shield, one surface of which (the dorsal surface) is in the
middle grown together with the anterior end of the body,
while the ventral surface is free and bordered by a rather
thicker raised ridge, distinct from the adjacent parts. The

32 GEORGE OSSIAN SARS.

form of this disc is, as above mentioned, oval, or rather,
rounded pentagonal (see fig. 2, c), nearly half as long again
as wide, the width about equal to that of the body at the be-
ginning of the stomach. Its posterior border, which at
once shows itself separated by a deep constriction from
the part of the body lying behind it, is in the middle slightly
incurved (fig. 3). The side borders are, a little in front of
the middle, strongly, almost angularly bent, and then con-
verge strongly towards the anterior freely projecting extre-
mity, which is narrowed obtusely. The whole disc is every-
where, and especially distinctly on the edges, thickly covered
with small vibratory cilia. Allman, who also mentions this
prominence, but without having gained a correct notion of
its form and connexion with the other parts, says of it that
one might take it for a large and peculiarly developed epi-
stome, if its position on the ventral side of the mouth, and
not, as in the freshwater Polyzoa, between the mouth and
the anus, did not oppose such a supposition. Allman sup-
poses, thus, that the mouth in the Rhabdopleura, in analogy
with the other Polyzoa, is terminal, and situated above or on
the dorsal side of this prominence, between it and the anus.
Such is, however, not the case. The anterior extremity of
the body above the prominence described is completely closed,
without any trace of aperture (see fig. 4). On the other
hand I have, by gently compressing the animal, been able
distinctly to see (see fig. 1) that the buccal aperture (q) is
situated just on the ventral or hemal side behind that promi-
nence, and seems to have the form of a cross slit, which is
bordered behind by an oval lobe (m), furnished with vibratory
cilia like a sort of underlip. By increased pressure the
buccal shield could be moved more out from the base of the
tentacular arms, and it appeared then everywhere very dis-
tinctly constricted from the rest of the body, and in the middle
of the dorsal surface fixed to the body by a sort of short stalk,
while the upper and the lower parts were free. Further, it
was observed that on each side of the buccal shield there ex-
tended, from the base of the tentacular arms downwards, a
strongly projecting nearly semilunar border of thin skin (1),
ciliated on its edges, so that between this and the buccal
shield there is formed on each side a narrow half-tube or
channel leading to the buccal aperture, and through which
the nourishment is probably conveyed to the mouth by the
abundantly ciliated tentacles. Since, as above stated, the
said buccal shield is really situated between the mouth and
the anus, I think we may consider it as morphologically
answering to the so-called epistome in the fresh water

RHABDOPLEURA MIRABILIS. 33

Polyzoa. Its enormous development in the present instance
seems, however, to indicate that it must have a very peculiar
and important function in the economy of this animal. My
observations on the living animal have also guided me to a
decided opinion, to which, however strange it may appear, I
have been forced again and again to return, and which I
therefore must retain, namely, that the animal uses this
buccal shield (according to my observations) as a sort of
creeping organ, by means of which it can draw itself up to the
aperture of its tube. Since, as above stated, both endocyst
and all muscles of protrusion are wanting, it is in reality
quite inexplicable how the polypide, which is often found
drawn back, not only to the bottom of the free cell, but even
partially into the corresponding chamber of the creeping
stem (see fig. 6), should be able in any other manner to get
forward again so far as to the aperture of the cell. It
might, perhaps, be supposed that this could be effected by
means of the elasticity of the contractile cord; but I have
convinced myself that such is not the case, by cutting
through the contractile cord at its base; the polypide has
continued undisturbed its slow protrusion, and has also at
_ length really reached the opening of the cell without any
remarkable change. The direct observations made on the
uninjured animal have also confirmed me in the view ex-
pressed above. It will be seen that during the slow pro-
trusion of the polypide (which often lasts for hours)
the buccal shield is always in immediate contact with the
wall of the tube, the whole of its ventral side being closely
pressed up against the same; it retains this position un-
changed as long as the protrusion lasts; and the protrusion
does not stop until the whole length of the buccal shield is
extended outside of the aperture of the cell; then the Poly-
pide is completely expanded. On examining more closely
this buccal shield we observe in the middle of it an
opaque part, which seems to contain an interior glandular
organ. Continuing the investigation, and slightly pressing
the animal, we notice, however (fig. 2), that this opaque
appearance is not produced by any such internal organ, but
by a peculiar and seemingly muscular structure of the
substance of the shield itself. It exhibits, seen from below,
in the middle numerous small bubbles, situated rather far
from each other, or somewhat irregularly formed small cells,
which, however, when more closely examined (and this is
particularly evident in those which lie nearer to the periphery
of the disc), show themselves to be the external rounded ex-
tremities of small, inwardly prolonged cylinders, which
VOL, XIV.——NEW SER, Cc

34 GEORGE OSSIAN SARS.

together appear to form a thick fascicle of incompletely
differenced muscular fibres, penetrating into the stalk of the
buccal shield.

The animal is, with the aforesaid exception of the stomach
and the intestine, which are opaque yellow, colourless and
transparent. The tentacular arms, and the tentacles, as also
the anterior part of the body before the stomach, are
covered with numerous very small, irregularly shaped, in-
tensely dark violet spots of colouring matter, which also
occur on the buccal shield, and especially on its anterior
freely projecting extremity, where they are very close
together, forming a large, roundish, dark spot. In speci-
mens in spirits all these parts are dark reddish brown, which
probably arises from the diffusion of the dark colouring
matter produced by the spirit.

As above stated, the polypide is without any sort of
attachment to the cell, in which it lies quite free. But it is
attached by means of a long and thin fleshy cord to the axial
cord, which runs through the creeping part of the Polyzoa-
rium or stem. The attachment does not take place imme-
diately at the bottom of the free cell, but at the bottom of
the corresponding chamber of the creeping stem, close
to the transversal septum which divides the chamber
from the next preceding. This cord, issuing from the
body of the polypide (figs. 5, 6, &c., h), is of very con-
siderable length; as, when the polypide is expanded, it
extends not only through the whole length of the cell, but
also through the corresponding chamber of the stem. The
cord is, however, very thin, filiform, when fully extended
five or six times less than the calibre of the cell, and four
times thinner than the stomach. It is of cylindrical form,
and lies quite free, without being attached at any point to
the wall of the cell; but it is nearer to the one side (the
ventral) than to the other. Along all one (the dorsal) side
it is covered with the same sort of small, dark violet spots of
colouring matter as the anterior part of the body, the
tentacular arms, &c., but is otherwise quite colourless and
transparent, and is of a soft fleshy consistency. It shows
on closer inspection, in a part of its substance, an ex-
tremely fine fibrous structure of fine parallel, longitudinal
lines and less sharply marked transverse lines; but in the
dorsal part these fibres are entirely wanting, and the struc-
ture of this part seems to be cellular, and its edge appears
somewhat irregularly wavy. With regard to its attachment
to the polypide, this does not take place at the bottom of
the stomach, but rather high up on the ventral side, where it

wi

RHABDOPLEURA MIRABILIS. : 35

seems to go over into the thin skin which encloses the
digestive apparatus. Its ventral fibrous part may still be
traced (see fig. 1) to a considerable distance forward, in the
form of a rather wide, clear skin border, which gradually
disappears in front of the cardia. In this skin border the
fine longitudinal fibres may still be distinctly observed
diverging like radii; but I was not able to trace their course
further. The posterior end, which, as beforesaid, is attached
to the axial cord at the bottom of the chamber in the
stem which corresponds to the cell, is somewhat enlarged ;
and all through of a very distinctly marked cellular structure,
without any evident fibre. In spirit specimens the con-
tractile cord shows itself often irregularly thickened in
particular places, and is also thus represented in Allman’s
figures; but this appears to be only a result of the action of
the spirit. In living exemplars I have always found it,
whether fully extended or contracted, of a cylindrical form.
When the polypide, as is frequently the case, is very strongly
retracted, not only to the bottom of the free cell, but also
partly in the corresponding chamber of the stem, the con-
tractile cord is always spirally convolved, so that the coils
are closer or looser, accordingly as the retraction is stronger
or weaker (see fig. 6). Also when, after severing the con-
tractile cord at its base, we take the animal out of its cell,
the cord always convolves itself in spiral coils.

- Allman has considered this contractile cord as correspond-
ing with the so-called funiculus in the ordinary Polyzoa,
although it is not, as in these, attached to the end of the
stomach (the terminal czecum), but on the ventral side of the
polypide’s body (Allman has represented it erroneously
as attached near the end, on the dorsal side). Moreover,
Allman indicates that this funiculus is accompanied by a
long fascicle of muscular fibres, attached to the chitinous
cord (axial cord) at the point where the funiculus is joined
to the same; and that at the point where the funiculus is
joined to the animal’s body, this muscular fascicle divides
itself in two bands, of which one goes along the right side,
and the other along the left side of the body, finally attach-
ing themselves, each on its own side, to the pharynx below
the lophophore. These fibres form, according to Allman,
the great retractor muscles of the polypide. This representa-
tion, which in fact only depends on spirit specimens, does
not, as may be seen, agree with what I have had occasion to
observe in our northern species, in which the fascicle of
muscles (if one really may venture to use this appellation
here) is everywhere, as an integral part, intimately con-

36 GEORGE OSSIAN SARS.

nected with the contractile cord, and is produced only by a
peculiar modification of. its tissue on the ventral side. Special
retractor muscles cannot, therefore, any more than other
muscles, be said to be distinguished in the Rhabdopleura.

Through all the creeping stem there extends, as already
mentioned, a filiform cord, very remarkable by its dark,
nearly black colour, and, unlike the contractile cord, to
which it is about equal in thickness, only slightly flexible,
and of a very hard, chitine-like consistency. This cord (figs.
5, 6, &c., i), which we will call the axial cord (“ chitinous
rod,” Allman), is freely extended in the hollow of the indi-
vidual chambers into which the stem is divided, and only
attached to the septa, which it perforates, enlarging itself a
little. In conformity with the rarely branched form of the
stem, it is only now and then forked, and when this takes
place, it is always at one of the septa. Otherwise, it forms
everywhere a cylindrical tube with very strong, almost horny,
walls, but always enclosing in its interior asoft, cellularcord (s),
of similar appearance tothe contractile cord, and, like it, colour-
less and transparent, with small dark violet spots of colouring
matter, but scarcely half sothick. This fine cellular marrow,
which extends through the whole length of the axial cord,
seems entitled to be considered as a sort of incompletely
defined nervous trunk, connecting all the individuals of the
colony, as at each partition in the stem it sends forth a
branch, which enters into the contractile cord of each re-
spective individual animal; and the latter cord does also
probably contain in its dorsal part the imperfectly developed
elements of nerves. We may, therefore, herein observe the
analogue of the so-called colonial nervous system (so strongly
developed in the other marine Polyzoa), and specially in the
marrow of the axial cord, the common main trunk of the
whole colony.

Allman, who has drawn special attention to this peculiar
chitinous axial cord (which does not exist in any of the
known Polyzoa), and has precisely derived from it his generic
appellation, calls it a “ blastophore,” being of opinion that
it is destined to bear the so-called statoblasts, which he
represents as projecting from the posterior part of the con-
tractile cord. I regret that I cannot, from my own ex-
perience, give any decided opinion as to the axial cord having
likewise this destination, because I have not been able to
observe the formation of these so-called statoblasts.

The animal, unlike the other Polyzoa, is very slightly
sensitive, and is not much affected by having its tentacles or
body touched. If the irritation is strong, it draws itself,

RHABDOPLEURA MIRABILIS. 37

but only very slowly, and usually only a little way, back into
its tube. This very slow and sluggish retraction, which may
last a very long time before it ceases, contrasts strongly
with the extraordinary, almost lightning-like, rapidity with
which the retraction takes place in the other Polyzoa, and is
evidently accounted for by the want of special retractor
muscles, and by the slightly developed contractile elements,
not distinguishable as evident muscular fibres, in the con-
tractile cord, the only instrument by which the retraction of
the animal in the Rkabdopleura is effected.

The extension (protrusion) of the animal is yet far more
tardy than the retraction; the process is extremely slow and
almost imperceptible ; several hours may often elapse before
the animal progresses from the stem or bottom of the cell to
the aperture of the latter. Neither do we, as before re-
marked, find in the animal under consideration the slightest
trace of any special muscles for such progression, since the
endocyst, and also the parietal and parieto-vaginal muscles
connected with it, are entirely wanting. The protrusion
seems, on the other hand, as already mentioned, to take place
in a very peculiar, and in the highest degree remarkable,
manner, that is, solely by means of the enormously developed
epistome (buccal shield) which the animal uses, strange as
this may sound, as a sort of creeping organ, like the foot, or
creeping disc of the Gasteropods, tu draw itself upwards,
little by little, along the wall of the cell to the aperture.

The Rhabdopleura mirabilis seems to be a genuine deep-
sea product, which I have never found at a less depth than
100 fathoms; but it is probably to be found extensively at ~
greater depths, where it appears to be more and. more
plentiful. I have hitherto only found it in Lofoten, where
it is not uncommon, in soft clay bottom, at depths of 100 to
300 fathoms. As the polyzoarium is both very small and
entirely colourless, it is rather difficult to discover. Its
presence is, however, easily detected by stirring the washed
mud in a fine sieve with a feather or other instrument, when
irregular fibres will be noticed therein. These fibres,
covered with particles ‘of mud, Rhizopod-shells, and frag-
ments of mussel shells, will prove to be the creeping stem,
whereon, by closer investigation, there will be discovered the
small, transparent, perpendicularly projecting cells. One
seldom, however, succeeds in raising these colonies entire ;
_ they are most frequently broken into several pieces by the
dredging operation itself, or in washing out the mud.

We may, according to the preceding description, charac-
terise the Genus Rhabdopleura in the following manner ;

38 GEORGE OSSIAN SARS,

Gen. RuasporLevra, Allman.

Polyzoarium tubum formans tenuem, flexibilem, cylindri-
cum, chitinosum hyalinum ex stirpe compositum repente
intus septis transversis in cameras plures discretas divisa
quarum utraque in cellulam cylindricam plus minusve libe-
ram et erectam stirpe vix angustiorem subtiliter annulatam
vel plicis acutis circularibus dense ornatam, orificio simplice
circulari terminatam exit. Stirps in tota longitudine chorda
chitinosa, obscura, tenui, cylindrica, rigida, pulpa vero molli
cellulosa impleta trajecta.

Polypides nullo endocysto vel pallio parietibus cellularum
connexi, sed modo funiculo contractili tenui et carnoso chordz
stirpis chitinose affixi, corpore forma elongato-ovata, extre-
mitate anteriore paulo dilatata et in ramos divisa duos cylin-
dricos et attenuatos supra vergentes et a se divergentes,
quibus series duplex tentaculorum flexuosorum affixa est.
Series tentaculorum minime continua sed et supra et infra
intervallo distincto interrupta, quare nulla. adest corona tenta-
culorum vel lophophorus proprie dictu sed modo duo rami
tentaculifert valde flexibles. Inter bases horum ramorum
inferne adest prominentia magna carnosa scutiformis ovalis
vel subpentagonalis pedicello brevi et crasso affixa facie in-
feriore subplana extremitate antica libere prominente at-
tenuato-truncata, inferiore corpori incumbente medio leviter
emarginato superficie ubique dense ciliata.

Orificium oris subventrale, transversum pone prominentiam
scutiformem situm, postice rotundato ciliato limitatum:
(Esophagus brevis et spatiosus constrictione distincta a ven-
triculo sejunctus; ventriculus simplex subteres, postice at-
tenuatus et sine fine, ansam subitam formans in intestinum
transiens ; intestinum antice porrectum tenue - cylindricum
lateri dorsali ventriculi et cesophagi incumbens ; orificio anali
circulari ad basin ramorum tentaculiferorum supine sito,
Tractus intestinalis, vel corpus proprium polypidis minime
nudus, sed cuticula distincta, tenui, hyalina circumcirca arcte
circumdatus.

Masculi adsunt nulli distincti, neque retractores, neque
protractores. Retractio Polypidis solummodo funiculo con-
tractili effecta; protrusio singulari modo prominentia effici
videtur scutiformi preeorali, at modum solex gasteropodum.
Et retractio et protrusio polypidis segnissima.

Spec. Rhabdopleura mirabilis (M. Sars).

Polyzoarium irregulariter flexuosum sed raro modo et
parce ramosum, stirpe corporibus alienis modo ex parte ad-

RHABDOPLEURA MIRABILIS. 39

herente ubique particulis alienis vel quisquiliis dense obducta,
cellulis vero nudis in tota longitudine liberis perpendicu-
lariter ascendentibus, vario modo flexuosis, valde elongatis
(15'**—16** circiter longioribus quam latioribus) stirpe vix
angustioribus. :

Habitat ad insulas Lofotenses in profunditate 100—300
orgyarum fundo limoso, non infrequens.

I have unfortunately not been able to make any observa-
tions on the development of the living animal, in which I
have also in vain sought for the organs of generation. It was
only by critically passing in review the specimens, which I
had brought home one by one, that my father at last suc-
ceeded in discovering in the creeping stem a couple of poly-
pides in course of formation. Allman has, however, been
more successful, and has even found in the specimen of the
Rh. Normanni examined by him, a whole series of develop-
ments, which is of great interest. I can, therefore, only
add very little to Allman’s communications on this subject.
Both of the buds observed by me had their place in
separate everywhere closed chambers of the creeping stem,
without these chambers having as yet prolonged them-
selves into any cell, and, like the developed polypides,
appeared here attached to the axial cord near the bottom of
the chambers, at a short distance from the transversal
septum. The youngest of the buds (fig. 7) corresponds
approximately with the youngest stadium observed by
Allman, as only two parts were to be distinguished, a short
stalk and an enlarged terminal part, which had not however,
the form indicated by Allman, of two compressed valvules,
but of a wide, scutiform; slightly curved plate (see fig. 7).
The stalk (h), which is strongly, almost globularly enlarged,
is continued for some distance along the concave side of the
scutiform plate mentioned; but this continuation, which is
not visible from one (the ventral) side, is by an evident
instriction separated from the proper stalk, and _ repre-
sents the groundwork of the polypide’s real body, whence
as well the tentacular arms as the digestive system are after-
wards developed. ‘The other bud (figs. 7, 8, and 9) will
about answer to the stadium delineated by Allman, |. c.,
fig. 6. The peculiar scutiform part (c) has also here the
form of a wide, evenly curved plate, which already has
assumed a somewhat pentagonal form, and completely covers
on one side the still only slightly developed real body, from
which, however, there project in front, two tentacular pro-
cesses (d, d), extending beyond the border of the shield, and

40 GEORGE OSSIAN SARS.

slightly crenulated at the edges, representing the tentacular
arms; the stalk (h), which represents the contractile cord,
has lengthened itself considerably (see fig. 9), and its
anterior part forms a strong enlargement, marked with
evident traces of the spots of dark violet colouring-
matter peculiar to the adult animal. The real body was, as
stated, still very slightly developed, and appeared only as a
small rounded part projecting dorsally between that enlarged
part of the stalk and the basis of the tentacular arms ; on the
ventral side, or that which turned towards the concave sur-
face of the scutiform plate, it was in the middle, and to a
small extent united to the same by growth; and behind this
union there appeared already an evident incurvation or inci-
sion in the body of the polypide as the first indication of the
buccal orifice. That the large scutiform plate is the homo-
logon of the buccal shield in the fully developed polypide is
sufficiently evident, both from its position relatively to the
animal’s body and from its shape. Allman has also recog-
nised this; however, when he assimilates this plate in the
Rhabdopleura-buds with the mantle lobes of the Lamelli-
branchiata, the notion seems to me very hazardous and diffi-
cult to establish. In any case, the early appearance and
enormous development of this part in the buds of the Rhab-
dopleura are extremely remarkable.

Allman has—guided especially by the mode of develop- |
ment in the Rhkabdopleura—come to the conclusion that the
Polyzoa are not, as was formerly imagined, most nearly re-
lated to the Brachiopods, but to the Lamellibranchiata, and
gives, 1. c., some schematic figures, in order to represent
more evidently the agreement of the Rhabdopleura-buds with
a Lamellibranch. Allman, however, presupposes, as taken
for granted, that the Rhabdopleura is furnished with an en-
docyst of the same nature as the other Polyzoa, which, as
above stated, is not the case, as also his conception of the
buccal shield seems to be inaccurate.

As will be seen in the sequel, my father has acquired a
very different notion with regard to the relationship of the
Polyzoa; for—guided by the organization of their lowest
representative, the Rhabdopleura—he has arrived at the sur-
prising conclusion that the Polyzoa in all probability have
taken their orgin from the Ccelenterates, namely, the
Hydrozoa.

Like Allman, I sometimes found in the middle of the
stem of the polyzoarium individual chambers, which, with-
out containing any bud in process of formation, were
quite closed and not continued into any cell. The interior

RHABDOPLEURA MIRABILIS. 41

wall of these chambers was always of very dark horn-brown
colour, and so little transparent that the axial cord, also here
running in the middle, was but dimly discernible through the
wall, This dark colour was particularly intense at one of the
ends, and appeared to proceed from the axial cord fixed in
the middle of the septa, and here somewhat enlarged. Its
exterior horny substance seemed to be directly continued
into the adjacent chamber of the stem. Allman considers
these closed chambers, wherein he has thought to perceive a
stratum of large polygonal cells—of which, however, I have
not been able to observe the slightest trace in any that I
have examined—as statoblasts, and thinks that they are
formed by the posterior enlarged part of the contractile cord.
This seems to me, however, to be far from probable, at least
in reference to the closed: chambers examined by me; for
they looked far more like remains of old cells decayed, owing
to the destruction of the Polypide, as is found to be the case
with other Pdlyzoa in the oldest part of the polyzoarium.

It will be seen from the foregoing description that the
genus LAabdopleura differs in nearly all essential points from
the ordinary Polyzoa far more than Allman seems to have
conceived. If we compare what is here communicated with
the chief points which have been briefly enumerated by various
authors, for instance, Allman, Hyatt, &c., others, as charac--
teristics of the Polyzoa in general, and which, therefore, are
considered as essential marks most intimately connected with
the idea Polyzoa, the anomaly of this form becomes so strik-
ing as finally even to justify a doubt as to whether it really
can be referred to the class of Polyzoa. First and foremost
stands the want of a so-called endocyst or mantle, which
sharply distinguishes this form from all other known Polyzoa,
all of which possess such an appendage. This mantle is so
essential a component part of a Polyzoon that it is difficult
to imagine one without it. One would rather imagine the
ectocyst wanting, as this plays a far less important part in the
economy of the animal, generally remaining passive, and
properly only serving as a protection for the soft animal.
The mantle is likewise a characteristic for the Tunicates and
the Brachiopods, which two classes have also been united by
M. Edwards with the class Polyzoa, under the common ap-
pellation of Molluscoidea (Hickel’s Himatega or Mantle-
animals).

Next, and as a consequence of the absence of a reai endo-
cyst, the retraction and protrusion of the animal in the Rhadb
dopleura are effected in a manner totally different from that

42 GEORGE OSSIAN SARS.

of the genuine Polyzoa; it moves up and down in its cell
without being attached to the opening, not by invagination
and evagination of the anterior part of the cell, and not by
several sets of special separate muscles.

The following remarks on the affinity of Rhabdopleura are
from my father’s manuscript notes :

The Rhabdopleura shows in many respect an unmistakable
resemblance to certain Hydrozoa. Just as in these, the
individual animals are not attached to the anterior part of
the cells (in the Polyzoa the anterior involved part of the en-
docyst is attached all round to the basis of the tentacular
corona) ; the cells are therefore open, filled (not with the so-
called perigastric liquid, but) with the sea-water entering
from without, and the aperture of the cell is of a defined and
invariable shape (while the cells of the Polyzoa are always
closed by the attachment of the endocyst to the basis of the
tentacular corona, and have, therefore, no proper opening,
for what is called aperture is nothing more than the part of
the cell through which the animal passes in an and out).”

“Moreover, the refraction of the animal, effected in the
Rhabdopleura by means of the contraciile cord, at the end of
which the animal is suspended, coincides essentially with
that of the Hydrozoa, in which the part corresponding to that
cord (‘the fleshy stalk or axis, ‘the intestinal canal’
(Lovén), ‘ the branched or unbranched ceenenchym, on which
the individual animals are situated, and which is perforated
by a canal-like continuation of the abdominal cavity of the
individual animals’) is, indeed, usually less free (often in ~
many places attached to the wall of the cell), and possesses a
less degree of contractility than the Rhadbdopleura, but yet,
in some genera, f. ex. Grammaria, also nearly approaches the.
Rhabdopleura in these respects. On the contrary, the pro-
trusion in the Rhadbdopleura is effected in a peculiar manner,
and different from that of either Polyzoa or Hydrozoa,
namely by a sort of creeping, executed by the preoral promi-
nence (buccal shield), which appears to answer-to the epis-
tome in the other Polyzoa, although in these it must have an
entirely different function.” '

On the other hand, the highly developed digestive system,
the presence of an anus, the juxtaposition of the mouth and
anus, and, finally, the bilateral /ophophore, are all characters
peculiar to the Polyzoa, and entirely foreign to the Hydrozoa.

tis clear that we have under observation in the Rhabdo-
pleura, a form of animal life which stands as it were in the
middie between the Hydrozoa and Polyzoa, or forms a tran-
sition from one to the other; one of those “ perplexing

RHABDOPLEURA MIRABIL18 43

forms” which will not fit rightly anywhere in the system of
zoologists.

When, finally, and as the object of the whole investiga-
tion, we will give account of our conception of the Rhabdo-
pleura, and decide on the class to which we will refer it, our
opinion is that these questions, like so many others, can only
be properly answered through the medium of the Darwinian
theory.

The Rhabdopleura is, undoubtedly, like many other ani-
mals which at present inhabit the greater depths of the sea,
and with some of which we have in the latter times become
acquainted, a very old form, which in its organisation has
still retained several features from the time when the animal
type that we call Polyzoa first developed itself from a lower
type.
The Polyzoa, which most authers agree in referring to the
main type or trunk (phylon) of the Molluscs are usually
supposed among the other animal types, to show the greatest
affinity with the Vermes ; and they are even considerod by
many zoologists as not being molluscs at all, but as genuine
worms. Their affinity to worms has, however, not been
demonstrated by any evident and distinct transition-form
between the two are not known. The Rhabdopleura shows
how evidently that the Polyzoa are not most closely related
to the worm-type, but in the type of the Celenterates, and
especially to the class of Hydrozoa. The Polyzoa have already
in the earliest primordial times (for fossil remains of them
are found in the lowest silurian formations) developed them-
selves from the Hydrozoa by transmutation. We have in
the Rhabdopleura manifestly such a form of Polyzoa in course
of development out of aform of Hydrozoa. The changes
which must take place in order that a Hydrozoon can be
transmuted into a Polyzoon consists in the following points,
Instead of the simple abdominal cavity of the Hydrozoa,
with a single aperture which functions as both mouth and
anus, there is formed an intestinal canal with special walls,
dividing itself intothree sections—gullet, stomach, and intes-
tine, which last ascends alongside of the stomach and gullet,
terminating with an exterior aperture or anus in the vicinity
of the mouth. This formation is completed in the Rhabdo-
pleura, but no more. The following phases of this develop-
ment which consist in the formation of a wide sack-like
contractile endocyst or mantle, which in its anterior part is
detached from the ectocyst or cell, involved in itself (inva-
gination) and attached round about the basis of the tentacular
sheath, vaginal, whereby the animal that formerly was free in

44, CHARLES 8. TOMES.

in its cell now becomes attached to the anterior part of the
cell, and the complicated system of the special retractor and
protractor muscle, all the mutations have not yet taken place
in the Rhabdopleura. This animal has thus remained sta-
tionary in the first stage of development from a Hydrozoon
to a Polyzoon, but must, nevertheless, be considered as be-
longing to the type (trunk) of the Polyzoa, since the
development of the completely organised digestive system,
which is so entirely foreign to the Hydrozoa, sufficiently
stamps it as a Polyzoon.

Finally, we remark that it may appear strange that the
Rhabdopleura, which in all probability is of so ancient origin,
should possess a similar, although modified, form of tenta-
cular Corona (bilateral) to that which belongs to most fresh
water Polyzoon (P. Hippocrepia, Gervais, Phylactolemata,
Allman), and which is usually considered as a more perfect
formation that the circular (in P. infundibulata, G.). It is,
however, possible, that the first is properly the circular
form, from which the latter has subsequently arisen. The
fresh waters appear, as Heckel lately has remarked, to con-
tain the direct descendants of some of the eldest animal
forms which, by reason of the less complicated accident of
the fresh waters, have often in the “ struggle for life,” only
slightly altered their original more simple structure ; as for
instance, among the Ceelenterates, the Hydra; among the
Rhizopods, the <Actinophrys, Gromia, and the shell-less
Radiolaria lately discovered by Focke ; among the fish, the
Ganoidea, &c.

On the ExtstENCE of an ENAMEL ORGAN tm an ARMADILLO
(Tatusia Peba). By Cuaries 8. Tomes, M.A. (With
Plate II.)

AccorDING to the views of Arnold and Goodsir, which for
many years have passed current amongst anatomists as being
a correct interpretation of the early stages of tooth develop-
ment, the dental germs first make their appearance as free
uncovered papille, rising up from the bottom of an open
groove, to which was applied the name “ primitive dental
groove;” and our anatomical text-books have hardly kept
pace with advancing knowledge in this matter, for even in
some of the most recent these views of Arnold and Goodsir,
now in some important particulars obsolete, are to be found,

bXiSTENCE OF AN ENAMEL ORGAN IN AN ARMADILLO. 45

With the subsequent stages in the development of the
teeth we are not for the present concerned; the prominent
feature of Arnold and Goodsir’s view, which was long adopted
by almost every writer, was the appearance, in the first place,
of a free, uncovered papilla, which was afterwards destined to
be calcified into dentine.

As expressing the matter clearly and concisely, I may
quote the words of Professor Owen: !

In the development of a tooth a matrix or formative
organ, corresponding in complexity with the kind of tooth .
to be formed, is first developed. It consists either of a soft
vascular papilla—a free conical process—as in certain fishes,
which mould of the future simple tooth is called its ‘ pulp,’
or ‘the dentinal pulp,’ or it consists of the pulp enclosed
in a ‘capsule,’ or of a pulp with such a modification of its
peripheral part, situated between the pulp proper and the
capsule, as to merit a distinct definition as an ‘ enamel
organ.’ The first and most constant of these parts is termed
the ‘ dentinal pulp, the second is the capsule or ‘ cemental
pulp,’ and the third is the ‘ enamel pulp.’”

To this I may add that the simplest teeth consist only of
dentine, the next stage in complexity being the addition of
cementum, while the presence of enamel marks a third
stage in complexity ; so that it would be quite in accordance
with the little that we know of the laws of development that
in an animal whose teeth ultimately possess all three struc-
tures the dentine germ should appear first, next that of the
cementum, and lastly that of the enamel ; it would, in fact,
then be an illustration of “progress from the general to
the special in development.”

But unfortunately more accurate observations do not con-
firm this. The order of appearance of the three several germs
is not by any means that above described, and the researches
of Professors Koélliker and Emil Dursy have shown (1) that
there is never at any time a deep, widely open groove, from
the bottom of which spring up free, uncovered papillz, but
that the “‘ primitive dental groove,” as seen and described by
Arnold and Goodsir, was “artefact ;”’ and (2) that ata period
when the dentine germ has no histological characters, but is
only distinguishable from the surrounding tissue as a slight
opacity of no very definite form nor definite limits, the enamel
germ has undergone active growth and very manifest histo-
logical differentiation of its component cells (see fig. 2).

Thus, although a skilled observer can detect faint indica-

1 Article “Odontology,” ‘Encyclopedia Britannica, p. 414. The
talics are my own.

46 CHARLES S. TOMES,

tions of the future dentine germ, the first thing of which he
can be positive is the enamel germ, which at this early period
is far in advance of the other component parts of the tooth
in respect of its development. In thinking over the in-
creased importance from a homological point of view, which
is given to the enamel organ by its very early appearance and
its entire independence of the dentine and cemental germ in
its origin, it occurred to me that it would be exceedingly
interesting and instructive, to examine the tooth germ
of a mammal whose teeth are not coated with enamel ;
and I hasten to acknowledge the kindness of Professor
Agassiz in America, of Professors Rolleston and Westwood
at Oxford, and of Professor Flower at the Royal College of
Surgeons, for placing all the material which they possessed
at my disposal.

The difficulty of the inquiry was very greatly enhanced
by the condition of the specimens, which had all been kept
in methylated spirit of varying strength, and it was extremely
troublesome to make sufficiently thin sections, as the tissues
were very friable. The best results were obtained by placing
them in absolute alcohol, whence they were transferred to
strong glycerine, and then imbedded and cut in the usual
way.

In order to make my description more intelligible 1 have
placed side by side with the figures of the dental germs of
the armadillos a drawing of a section through the lower
jaw of a calf (fig. 1), to some few points in which I will
draw attention before comparing and contrasting them with
one another.

The enamel organ (c) in this figure forms a cap, em-
bracing the upper part and sides of the dentine germ (4) ;
it is seen to be still connected with the epithelium (deep
layer) of the mouth by a thin dark line, which, under
favorable conditions of lighting, &c., may be seen to consist
of a double row of cells. Where this merges into the enamel
organ these two rows of cells separate and pass round the
periphery of the enamel organ, forming what is known as
the “ external epithelium of the enamel organ ;”’ near to the
base of the dentine germ this layer of epithelium is reflected
upon it, and forms a complete investment to its surface, in
which situation it is termed the “internal epithelium of the
enamel organ.”

But in the calf these external and internal epithelia are
widely separated and form but asmall proportion of the whole
bulk of the enamel organ, the intermediate space being
occupied during the formation of the enamel by a stellate

EXISTENCE OF AN ENAMEL ORGAN IN AN ARMADILLO. 47

reticulum, which seen by the naked eye looks almost semi-fluid
or gelatinous. When the deposition of enamel is completed
this gelatinous mass disappears and the external comes into
_ contact with the internal epithelium ; a fact of some interest
incom. ‘tion with the dental germs of the armadillo.

From the line of cells which connect the enamel organ with
the deep layer of the oral epithelium (by an inflection of
which it was originally formed) runs downwards a process
consisting of a double row of cells, not unlike a simple tubular
gland; this has been shown by Professor Kolliker to be the
enamel germ of the permanent tooth.

The earliest condition of dental germ which I have
observed in the armadillo is represented in fig. 2; the
section was taken from a foetus about an inch long. At ¢ is
seen the enamel germ, consisting of a mass of cells, those
upon its surface being distinctly differentiated from those in
its interior, and forming a sort of epithelial investment to it;
it is connected with the epithelium of the oral cavity by the
usual thin neck of cells, and it is similar to, and in fact per-
fectly indistinguishable from, the enamel germs of those other
mammals which do have enamel upon their perfected teeth.

The future dentine germ and its processes forming the
capsule are as yet only represented bya slight opacity, which
has been rather exaggerated in the drawing.

The next stage which I have observed is represented in
figs. 3 and 4; the dentine papilla (0) has taken a definite
form; the cells on its exterior have become differentiated to
form an odontoblast layer, and towards the top a thin cap of
dentine (2) has already been formed.

Closely applied to the formed dentine, and extending below
it on the surface of the dentine germ, is an investment of
columnar cells, exactly lke the internal epithelium of the
enamel organ (enamel cells) of other mammals, and at first
sight this might appear to be all that there is. But in speci-
mens which have been slightly displaced or torn, the epithelium
is seen to really consist of two layers, one of which adheres
closely to the dentine, and the other to the capsule; and to-
wards the base of the dentine germ, where the epithelial layer
is reflected over it, it can always be seen to be double (see g,
figs. 3 and 4). In fact this apparently single layer is really
made up of the internal and external epithelia in close con-
tact with one another, owing to the absence of that reticu-
late tissue which separates them in the enamel organ of
those animals which form enamel on their teeth. And this
is just what has already been noted to be the condition of
all enamel organs after the completion of the enamel,

48 CHARLES S. TOMES.

Although I have examined six or seven specimens, I have
not been successful in getting satisfactory sections illus-
trating any other stage in the tooth-development.

I have, however, examined a large number of the teeth .
of armadillos, removed from the tooth sacs prior to their erup-
tion, and have not discovered the least vestige of enamel
upon any of them; the cementum covers them nearly to the
tip, but [ have never seen it quite reach to the tip of the
tooth.

The results of my inquiries may be summarised thus:

1. In Yatusia Peba, a creature which has no vestige of
enamel upon its teeth, the first histological structure
distinctly recognisable in the tooth germ is a well-developed
enamel germ, perfectly identical with that seen in other
mammalian foetuses of similar age.

2. That, without any enamel having been formed, and at
a very early period in tooth development (namely, contempo-
raneously with the formation of a very thin cap of dentine),
this enamel organ assumes a condition precisely similar to
that attained to by other enamel organs after their function
has been completed by the deposition of the whole thickness
of the enamel.

The persistent connection of the enamel with the oral
epithelium from which it was derived is very well shown by
many of the sections, some of which also show well the
second inflection of epithelium which forms the enamel germ
of the permanent tooth, thus affording an additional confir-
mation of the fact, to which attention has been drawn by
Rapp, Gervais, and Professor Flower, that amongst armadillos
Tatusia Peba at all events is not a monophyodont, but pos-
sesses two well-developed and functional sets of teeth.

The occurrence of a structure which is destined to be made
no use of in the further course of development would of itself
be noteworthy, but this observation on the teeth of the arma-
dillo possesses a wider interest, for it bears on the whole
question of the affinities and genealogy of that peculiar group,
the Edentata ; it would, however, be out of place to enter
into a discussion of its probable significance in the pages of a
journal specially devoted to Histology ; and, moreover, our
knowledge of the development of the teeth of the mammalia
being limited to those of a very few species, it would be un-
safe to enter upon generalisations built upon so imperfect a
basis.

RESEARCHES ON THE MUCORINI, 49

ReEsEARcHES on the Mucorinti, by Pu. Van TieGHEM and
G. Le Mownter (with Plates III and IV).!

Since modern research has demonstrated the existence of
polymorphism in the reproductive organs of Fungi, there has
been a general agreement as to the necessity of a revision of
the entire class. No species of fungus can now be said to be
thoroughly understood until all the reproductive structures
have been discovered which its mycelium is capable of develop-
ing as well as the order in which they succeed one another,
or alternate. From being acquainted with but one kind of
reproductive apparatus we may easily fall into error in
assigning to the species to which it belongs a wrong place in
a natural classification. Such a determination must be
‘necessarily provisional, and it is most essential to endeavour
to arrive at a knowledge of those other reproductive states
which can alone enable us to certainly determine its true
systematic position. It may even happen that two species
belonging to distinct genera may each have a reproductive
apparatus (and this may also happen to be at the time the
only one known) which may have so close a resemblance as
to all but justify us in regarding them as identical. The
number and nature of the reproductive structures which a
species posseses cannot be deduced @ priori from any general
law; in different families of the same class the vegetative
cycle may embrace an altogether different series.

It is evident, therefore, that the study of fungi presents
great difficulties which explain the slowness as well as the
uncertainty of its progress, and even the retrograde direction
it has taken and the confusion into which it has fallen
in the hand of some authors. These difficulties are of two
kinds, synthetic as well as analytic. The first present them-
selves when we attempt to correlate with the species to which
it belongs some reproductive structure which we meet with
altogether isolated. The others arise when we seek to
distinguish amongst the numerous forms which habitually
grow mixed together those which have a true genetic

1 [This article is a free but condensed translation of portions of a memoir
occupying nearly 140 pages of the 17th volume (pp. 261—399) of the
current series of the ‘Annales des Sciences Naturelles. The extremely
interesting results arrived at by the authors derive a special importance
from the precision of the method which they have devised and employed.
It is much to be hoped that this will attract the attention of microscopists
in this country, and lead to the repetition and extension of similar observa-
tions.—W. T. T. D.]

VOL. XIV.——NEW SER. D

50 VAN TIEGHEM AND LE MONNIER.

connection ; it is necessary to carefully discriminate cases of
epiphytism or parasitism from true polymorphism.

In order to attain this complete knowledge of any given
species derived from the observation of the whole cycle of
its development, and to avoid the two kinds of difficulties
just mentioned, there is obviously only one method. In
principle this is extremely simple ; it is necessary to proceed
exactly as in dealing with one of the higher plants. We
sow a seed and follow the complete vegetative and re-
productive development of the plant which is derived from
it until the production of new seeds brings us back to the
point from which we started. In the present case we must
sow a spore and follow without any interruption, and ex-
cluding all extraneous organisms, the vegetative and re-
productive evolution of the plants which originate from it
until we have exhausted the whole series of reproductive
forms which the vegetative system of the plant is capable
of originating in the different media in which it may
be necessary to study it in order to obtain the whole
of them.

The method which we have followed for carrying out
practically this principle so simple in theory—the culture of
a single spore—includes two distinct parts, which may be
termed respectively ‘ pan-culture’ and ‘ cell-culture.’

In pan-culture the nutritive medium, previously, if neces-
sary, freed from extraneous living germs, is placed in saucers or
pans of porcelain or some porous material, and enclosed under
a bell-jar or covered with a glass plate. The nutriment being
abundant, the vegetative system acquires extreme vigour, and
the fructification attains its most complete development.
Specimens can, therefore, be obtained at regular intervals of
time, which enable one to judge of the principal characters
of the mycelium and its mode of growth, and to study the
different stages of development and the structure and dimen-
sions of the different forms of fructification which it bears
under the most favorable possible conditions. The pan-
culture, in addition to this, supplies us with spores for the
cell-culture.

By cell-culture we mean a method in which a spore taken
from an unmixed pan-culture is placed, with all necessary
precautions, in a drop of liquid accessible in every part to
microscopic observation, and known to be free previously
from other spores, and which, being enclosed in a cell, is pre-
served from subsequent contamination. ‘These cell-cultures
allow of the continuous observation of the plant during every
phase of its development, and they are indispensable for

RESEARCHES ON THE MUCORINI. 51

elucidating and authoritatively deciding all the obscure and
critical points in its life-history.

The cell is constructed by fastening with Canada balsam,
upon a glass slide, a glass ring 4-5 mm. in height, cut from a
piece of combustion tubing, and afterwards ground flat at its
edges. A thin covering-glass, of the same diameter as the
outer edge of the glass ring, forms the upper side of the cell,
and is kept in its place by three minute drops of oil placed
on the edge of the ring. To keep the contained air always
moist, a few drops of water are placed at the bottom of the
cell. Finally, a small drop of the nutritive fluid is placed on
the under surface of the covering glass, and in this drop the
spore to be cultivated is sown.

This drop of fluid can be examined microscopically in every
part, provided that too high magnifying powers are not em-
ployed although its margin may be studied with high immer-
sion objectives. With low powers the whole of the interior
of the cell can be explored, and the fructifications which are
produced can be followed in the air of the cell. If we are
willing to sacrifice the culture, we can remove the covering-
glass and examine the growing fungus in any way we please.

The cell itself must be kept in an atmosphere saturated
with moisture. A tin box with a closely-fitting lid, or
covered with a glass plate, will answer this purpose. The
slide with the attached cells may be placed on a slab of
moistened brick, or the bottom may be covered with moist
sand or plaster, and the slides may then be allowed to rest on
metal supports (Pl. III, fig. 1). ‘The same box may, in this
case, be arranged to hold two series of slides, and a number
of such boxes may be placed, one upon the other, in a hot-
air bath at a constant temperature, so that a large number of
cell-cultures can be carried on simultaneously.

This method allows the observer to follow with the great-
est ease, hour by hour, all the details of the germination of a
spore, the character of the mycelium which it developes, and
every phase in the development of its fructification—in fact,
the whole cycle of the life-history of the plant, however pro-
tracted that may be. There are other obvious advantages in
this plan of study. Not the least, of course, is the elimina-
tion of the possibility of error which must always attach to
any culture where the access of extraneous germs during the
progress of the investigation has not been prevented.

Yet, notwithstanding all precautions, it will often happen
that extraneous spores are introduced into the drop of fluid
either before or during the culture. But, as the whole drop
is under observation, these are immediately detected and their

52 VAN TIZGHEM AND LE MONNIER.

position noted. No doubt, also, we must trust to chance for
success in only introducing a single spore into a drop, but in
a large series of experiments chance is sure sometimes to
favour us, and if we are careful to sow the smallest possible
number, it is generally possible to fix one’s attention on a
particular spore and keep that steadily under observation.

The minute quantity of nutritive fluid which suffices for
successful culture is really astonishing, but the result of our
observations leaves no doubt on that head. The liquids
which we have most frequently employed are orange-juice
boiled and filtered which is an acid and saccharine liquid, and
decoction of horse-dung also boiled and filtered which is
a neutral and alkaline one rich in nitrogenous principles.
The latter is suitable for the culture of a much larger num-
ber of species than the first, but it is apparently poorer in
nutritive matters, since the mycelium is always much less
vigorous in it. It has also the additional disadvantage of
lending itself very readily to the development of bacteria,
which are destructive to the cultures. Orange-juice, being
acid, is not open to this objection, and the only enemy fo fear
with it is Penicillium glaucum ; we have given it the prefer-
ence whenever possible. In addition, we have also em-
ployed, for the sake of comparison, brewers’ wort, ordinary
water, and a saline solution of the following composition,
with or without the addition of 7 grms. of sugar :—

Calcium nitrate . ; . 4 grammes.
Potassium phosphate ; eRe Biss S:
Magnesium sulphate ‘ 7 + Aen ie
Potassium nitrate . F Act “
Water ; . ; ~fO0n ny

It must be remarked that the causes of failure in these
cell-cultures are very different, and by no means obvious.
The condition of the spores, especially as to age, exerts an
effect which must not be attributed to the nutrient medium.
Too much importance must not, therefore, be attached to
2 cape features ; at the best they will only have a negative
value.

General character of the group of Mucorint.

The characters which define a group of fungi should be
drawn from the vegetative system or mycelium; the single
sexual reproductive apparatus; the often extremely poly-
morphic asexual reproductive structures, and the order in
which these different arrangements succeed one another,
and which consequently determines the alternation of
generations.

RESEARCHES ON THE MUCORINI. 53

The mycelium of the Mucorini always originates from a
spore of asexual origin; the sexually produced spore or zygo-
spore never produces mycelium, but developes at once an
asexual reproductive apparatus.

Placed under favorable conditions the asexual spore puts
out one or more tubes or hyphz, which elongate and ramify,
forming a mycelium, which in the first instance is always
unicellular, as in the Peronosporee and Saprolegniacee.
The more or less granular protoplasm which the hyphe
contain possesses characters different from those met with
amongst Ascomycetes and Basidiomycetes. Later on, as the
protoplasm disappears from the hyphe, septa, more or less
uregularly distributed, make their appearance. Usually the
hyphe preserve a complete independence, but in some genera
of the family (Chetocladium, Mortierella, Syncephalis) they
form numerous anastomoses. ‘Their membrane is always
colourless. The mycelium sometimes develops exclusively
in the interior of the nutrient medium; sometimes it de-
velops.itself equally both in this medium and in the air. In
some Mucorint it may occasionally attach itself to the
mycelium or productive apparatus of other plants of the same
family, and derive nutriment from them—in fact, become
parasitic (Chetocladium, Piptocephalis, Syncephalis). But
this parasitism appears to be far from essential, since the
same mycelium fructifies and vegetates almost equally well
when completely isolated. No species of the Mucorini appears,
therefore, to be parasitic in the fullest and absolute sense of
the word.

Asexual reproduction ; Sporangia. All the Mucorini de-
velope from this mycelium erect hyphz, in some cases
energetically responding to light (Mucor, Phycomyces, &c.),
in other cases wholly insensible to it (Rhizopus, Circinella) ;
their membrane is coloured blue or, at any rate, violet or
rose colour by Schultz’s solution, and they terminate
in a system of sporangia, in which the asexual spores originate
by a process of division. Sometimes these sporangia are
globular, and they then usually contain a large number of
spores, ranging from 500,000 to 10 (Phycomyces, Mucor, &c.).
Occasionally the sporangia are uniformly monosporic ( Cheto-
cladium). In Piptocephalis and Syncephalis the spores are
arranged in a narrow sporangium in a single row. ‘The de-
hiscence of the sporangium takes place in different ways; its
membrane may become totally absorbed without leaving any
trace as soon as the spores become mature. A drop of fluid
secreted from the apex of the sporangiferous hypha envelope
the liberated spores (Mortierella, Piptocephalis, Syncephalis),

54 VAN TIEGHEM AND LE MONNIER,

In other cases the membrane persists and the spores escape
by a fissure, which may be circular and at the base (P2lobolus)
or about the middle (Circinella) ; sometimes it is only sub-
sequent to the fall of the sporangia that the liberation of the
spores takes place. An intermediate case is produced when
the base of the membrane is absorbed and becomes dissolved
with more or less facility, leaving merely the dark granules
or particles of calcium oxalate, which incrusted it (Mucor

bifidus, M. Mucédo, &c.; Rhizopus, &c.). ‘The septum which
separates the sporangium from its hypha is sometimes flat
(Chetocladium, Mortierella, &c.). Sometimes it is more or
less strongly bulged inwards, forming the so-called columella
(Mucor, “Phycomyces, Circinella, &c.). Generally speaking,
the Mucorini have only a single kind of sporangium. In
some genera, however, there are two distinct sporangial
systems distinguishable at maturity both by the structure of
the sporangia and of the hyphe which bear them ; the spores,
however, are identical.

Chlamydospores.—These are a second kind of asexual
spores, differing from the first in their mode of formation
as well as their structure and formation. They are found in
some genera of Mucorini and, perhaps in all, and are produced
singly in the interior of the hypha by a local condensation
and transformation of the protoplasm. They are set at
liberty by the absorption of the membrane. The chlamy-
dospores may assume two different forms depending on the
degree of differentiation of the portion of the mycelium
which produces them. In some cases the mycelium develops
branches which elevate themselves into the air, and which,
being either simple or ramified, terminatein a large endogenous
spore, with a thickened external echinulate or tuberculate
membrane. The mycelium may continue its growth for a
considerable period without producing any other kind of
fructification, and producing only these axial pedicellate
chlamydospores. In this state the plants have been often
mistaken for Mucedines, especially for species of Sepedonium.

In other cases it is within the hyphz themselves and not
at the extremities of special branches that the protoplasm
aggregates especially towards the close of the period of growth
to form asexual spores. They are very irregular in form and
size, and are only set free by the destruction of the enclosing
membrane ; these are, therefore—as opposed to the pedicel-
late chlamydospores with which, however, in Mortierella there
are connecting links—mycelial and sessile. They may be
terminal or distributed throughout the hypha, and isolated or
in rows ; they may occur either in the sporangiferous hyphz

RESEARCHES ON THE MUCORINI, 55

which after the maturation of the sporangium are reduced to
the condition of mere mycelial filaments. In fact, they may
be found in every part from the cavity of the original spore
to the columella of the empty sporangium. But all the
genera and all the species of the same genus do not develope
them to the same extent. The difference in this respect is
especially noticeable in the case of Mucor.

Chlamydospores are not confined to the -Ascomycetes.
Woronin has in fact described pedicellate ones in Ascobolus
pulcherrimus, and we have also met with them ourselves in
Kickzella alabastrina.

We see therefore that amongst the Mucorini the poly-
morphism of the reproductive organs is very restricted, since
it only ranges between the sporangial form, which may, it is
true, be of two kinds, and the chlamydial which also put on
somewhat different aspects. What, however, is remarkable
is, that the asexual spore is always endogenous; it is always
formed within a cell at the expense of the whole or part of
the protoplasm, and to permit its escape the containing
membrane must be either ruptured or absorbed.

Chetocladium at first sight appears to establish a transition
between the sporangial and chlamydial forms of spores, but
this is only in appearance, since by its mode of formation,
structure, and function, the spore of Chetocladium is clearly
a sporangiospore and not a chlamydospore. The chlamydial
form is still far from completely understood, and its occurrence
may, perhaps, not be possible in some genera.

Sexual reproduction.— After the production of asexual
spores the mycelium of the Mucorini produces at particular
points, either in the air (Sporodinia), on the surface of the
nutritive medium (Phycomyces), or within it (Mucor Mucedo)
zygospores, the result of the mutual interpenetration of two
protoplasmic masses of distinct origin. ‘Two perfectly similar
hyphe, either straight (Mucor, Rhizopus, Chetocladium), or
arcuate, like the teeth of a vice come into contact by their
swollen extremities. At the same time the protoplasm con-
tained in each cell contracts into a sphere. The double
partition between the two protoplasmic spheres is absorbed,
and they coalesce into a single mass or zygospore, which
increases in size and clothes itself with a tuberculate or
echinulate membrane. ‘This is inclosed in addition by the
thinner coat of the two original conjugating cells, which
becomes coloured (often black), and adapts itself to all the
projections of the internal membrane. Generally, the
zygospore occupies the whole internal space of the two
conjugating cells; in Prptocephalis, however, Brefeld has

56 VAN TIEGHEM AND LE MONNIER,

shown that it only occupies a small part of this space, and
projects externally. The zygospore is therefore, Jike the
asexual spores, endogenous in its origin.

It does not germinate till it has undergone a desiccation
and has experienced a certain period of rest. Placed in a
moist atmosphere it produces at once, without the inter-
vention of mycelium, a sporangial system possessing all the
_ characters which belong to that of the species which pro-
duces it. The asexual spores which these contain develope
a mycelium, in their turn producing sporangia, chlamydo-
spores, and zygospores.

In the actual state of our knowledge it is difficult to affirm
that all these kinds of reproductive apparatus exist in every
representative of the group. In point of fact, only one—the
sporangial—has been observed in all the species. Zygospores
are only at present known in the genera Sporodinia, Rhizo-
pus, Mucor, Phycomyces, Chetocladium, and Piptocephals.
Brefeld does not admit that Chetocladium and Piptocephalis
possess sporangia, but only conidia. According to his views,
therefore, the term Zygomycetes is more expressive than
Mucorini, which he restricts to the sporangiferous Zygomy-
cetes. This, however, appears to us founded on an error,
and there appears, therefore, no reason for changing, on this
ground, the old and.established name of the group.

PILOBOLUS.

J. Klein! has been led, owing toa faulty method of obser-
vation, to the erroneous result that Plobolus is capable of con-
version into Mucor. It is quite true that he sowed the spores
on a slide, but he used a drop of fruit juice covered with a piece
of thin glass, and it was on the uncovered edges of the drop,
exposed to every source of error and inaccessible to rigorous
examination, that he observed the development and fructifi-
cation of Mucor.

It is rather remarkable that the suspicions of Klein were
not aroused by the unexpected nature of his results. Thus
the spores of P. crystallimus sown in a watchglass produced
a Mucor with sporangia. Spores of the same crop of P. crys-
tallinus sown in horse-dung decoction produced the fructifi-
cation of P. crystallinus. Spores of this second generation
sown on saccharine fruit juice produced, in their turn, a
Mucor, but one different from the first. We therefore arrive
at the result, not a little surprising, that Pzlobolus-spores

' « Zur Kenntniss des Pilobolus,” ‘ Pringsh. Jahrb. f. w. Bot.,’ viii, pp.
362—372.

RESEARCHES ON THE MUCORINI, 57

produce a different species of Mucor, according to the genera-
tion they belong to. But the spores of these species of
Mucor, when sown in their turn, only produced a similar
kind of Mucor, and never returned to Pilobolus.

When these results were published we were naturally
anxious to confirm them. But both the’ spores of P. edipus
and of P. crystallinus have refused to germinate with us in
the juice of cooked plums, or, at any rate, they have only
produced very short tubes, and nothing more has come of
them. It is quite true that some of our cultures yielded abun-
dance of Mucor, and belonging to more than one species, but
we were quite prepared for this, for we had previously detected
the presence of their spores. In one case amongst seventeen
spores of Pilobolus, three spores of Mucor developed a
vigorous mycelium and abundantly fructified. Another time,
among nine spores of P7/lobolus there was a spore of another
species of Mucor, and this also fructified. In other cases,
extraneous spores produced Botrytis cinerea and Alternaria
tenuis.

PHYCOMYCEsS.

This plant was discovered by C. Agardh on the walls and
wood-work of oil mills and storehouses for oil in Finland.!
Being unacquainted with its reproductive apparatus,and being
especially struck with its dark green colour and the shining
aspect of its large flattened filaments, he supposed it to be
an alga, and named it Ulva nitens—a name which he
stili retained for it in 1823.2, In this year, however, G.
Kunze met with it under the same conditions in Saxony, and
especially in the neighbourhood of Leipzig and Dresden ;
having detected the columella which terminates the fruc-
tiferous hyphe and the elongated spores with which the colu-
mella is covered, he assigned it a place amongst Fungi,
under the name of Phycomyces nitens.2 But the existence
of the sporangium, which envelopes at first the whole of the
spores together with the columella, appears to have escaped
his notice. It consequently did not occur to him to place his
plant near Mucor, and, on the contrary, he thought that it was
allied to Aspergillus. More recently Berkeley met with this
organism on oil-casks, and observed the structure of. the
sporangium previous to dehiscence. The analogy which it
presents with that of Mucor led him to place it in that genus

1 «Synopsis Algarum Scandinavie,’ 1817, p. 46.
2 Species “ Algarum,” 1823, i, p. 425.
3 G. Kunze, ‘ Mykologische Hefte,’ ii, 1823, p. 113.

58 VAN TIEGHEM AND LE MONNIER.

under the name of M. Phycomyces.1 De Bary, who had no
better materials for study than those contained in the herba-
rium of Kunze, also describes it under Berkeley’s name.’

The plant is only rarely met with. It does not appear to
have been observed in France till recently :— Ist, at Toulouse,
by MM. Joly and Clos, on a rag used for wiping a hydraulic
machine and impregnated with oil; it was also found on the
parts of the machine itself, on the oil-vessels, and on the
flooring of the building; 2nd, by MM. Crouan,? in a candle
manufactory on' tallow scum. ‘These authors have, however,
added nothing to our knowledge of this curious plant.

The circumstances under which this species has occurred
has supported the opinion that it is exclusively addicted to
fatty matters. This will be seen not to be the case, and it
is this which explains why M. Carnoy, having met with it
at Rome on human excrement and afterwards cultivated it
on slices of orange and citron, failed to identify it with the
plant of Kunze, and described it as Mucor romanus, a new
species.* We did not make this identification till after we
had long cultivated the plant, and had discovered one by one
the facts in its history correctly described by Carnoy.

We first heard of it from a dyer at Wesserling (Alsace) as
a large kind of Mucor, which made its appearance in acid
cochineal dye. The spores of the specimen sent to us were
sown in ordinary cochineal dye, and also in other media, but
without any result. We then had recourse to M. Lange-Des-
moulins from whom the dye originally came, and the supply
which we got from him, when placed under a bell glass in
the laboratory, developed, in a few days, a magnificent crop
of Phycomyces. It was evident that the dye from his estab-
lishment was naturally impregnated with the Phycomyces,
since it developed upon it in continuous succession, and it
was also evident that success in its cultivation depended upon
the freshness of the spores, which rapidly lose their power of
germination—a circumstance which explains the feeble power
of dissemination possessed by the plant, as well as its rarity.
We soon had an additional proof of this. Our first series of
cultivations, carried on during several months, were inter-
rupted by the vacations. On our return it proved impossible
to recommence them. The spores of the old crops had lost
by a desiccation of two or three months their power of germi-
nation. The plant appeared also to have disappeared from

1 Berkeley, ‘ Outlines,’ p. 28 and 407.

2 ‘Mém. de l’Acad. des Sc. de Toulouse,’ 7 Déc. 1865.

3 ¢Florule du Finistére,’ 1867, p. 13.

4 « Bull. de la Soc. Roy. de Bot. de Belg.,’ t. ix, 1870, p. 162, et seq.

RESEARCHES ON THE MUCORINI. 59

the dye of M. Lange-Desmoulins. At length it made its
appearance on horse-dung placed under a glass shade in the
laboratory, and its long, isolated filaments developing at con-
siderable distances, one after another, proved that they origi-
nated by the germination of so many zygospores. This
enabled us to recommence a second series of cultivations,
especially as we received at the same time from the dye
manufactory a fresh fertile tuft of the plant.

These facts prove that Phycomyces nitens may develope
in the most different media, oily or fatty, excrementitious,
horse-dung, or dyes. The only necessary condition is the
presence of fresh spores or zygospores. It is seldom met
with, only because the asexual spores speedily lose their
germinating power. Once established in a place favorable
for its complete development, it is indefinitely perpetuated by
zy gospores, but it quickly disappears from localities where
the formation of zygospores is prevented.

We have cultivated Phycomyces nitens (1) in pans on
cochineal dye, excrement, pounded cochineal, oranges, bread ;
(2) in cells on. horse-dung decoction, cochineal dye, orange
juice, and also our saline solution, both with and without
sugar.

Spores.—The asexual spores of Phycomyces nitens, which
will serve as our point of departure, vary a little in form
according as they belong to the small sporangia of young
mycelium, or to the large sporangia which terminate the long
filaments arising from the adult mycelium. The first are
spherical (Pl. ILI, fig. 2a), or slightly ovoid, ‘016 mm. in
diameter; their centre is intensely yellow and granular;
their coat, on the contrary, and the peripheral portion of their
protoplasm colourless and homogeneous. The others are of
a very elongated ellipsoidal form, often flattened, or even
concave upon one of their sides, with a transverse diameter a
little less than that of the preceding ones, that is to say, ‘012
to 015 mm.; they attain a length of -020 to ‘030 mm. (fig.
2b); their central yellow matter forms an axile granular
band. It is, therefore, to the protoplasm of their spores that
the sporangia owe the golden-yellow colour which they possess
as long as their coat remains transparent and colourless. As
long as the spore is young its membrane has no distinct in-
ternal lining of protoplasm ; later on it separates, and acquires
a double contour ; at the same time the protoplasm becomes
more granular (fig. 2c). ,

Placed in a moist medium, but in conditions which pre-
clude their development, the spores alter; the protoplasm
exhibits granules which become larger and larger, and finally

60 VAN TIEGHEM AND LE MONNIER.

concentrates itself into a variable number of spherical nodules
sufficiently regular to present sometimes the aspect of spores
in an ascus (fig 3a). Later on the coat, often bristling exter-
nally with bacteria, becomes pierced at several points, and
these nodules are set at liberty. But the nodules, even under
the most favorable conditions of the medium, never ger-
minate. When dried the spores lose equally their power
of germination; we have not succeeded in making them
germinate after three months. ‘The spores, therefore, do not
long resist either moisture or dryness.

Germination.—In ordinary water germination will not take
place; it does so, however, very readily in a cell in the
saline solution without sugar, in orange-juice, horse-dung de-
coction or cochineal dye, and in pans on slices of orange, horse-
dung, different excrements, cochineal dye, or broken cochineal.
Placed in a film of liquid under a covering of glass, so as
to have a very small supply of air, the spores failed to ger-
minate ; those at the extreme border of the film produced
filaments, those within it none. They appear, therefore, not
to possess the power which the spores of Mucor Mucedo,
Thamndium, and Helicostylum, have of germinating by a
kind of gemmation, and of giving rise to chains of irregularly-
sized cells.

The spore first of all loses colour, swells, and absorbs the
nutrient fluid, without, however, emitting a filament; it thus
doubles its size and becomes ovoid. It then puts out from
one of its extremities, or from both, a thick hypha, which
elongates, forming, at the same time, pinnately-arranged
branches destitute of partitions. If the young spore had not
previous to germination acquired a double contour there is
no exospore pierced by the hypha, and the external contour of
the spore is merely darker than that of the filament which
proceeds from it; but if the coat had become separated from
the spore by an internal contour the spore in dilating rup-
tures an exospore, which often detaches itself over its whole
surface, continuing to partially invest it (fig. 2d). After
having thus developed in the liquid about forty-eight hours
after sowing, the mycelium sends some of its branches into
the air within the cell, which ramify there abundantly, a first
point of difference with the true species of Mucor. Besides
these large aérial branches, short branches occur here and
there on the submerged filaments which are either simple
or have tuft-like ramifications terminating in a point,
and forming beneath the apex a sort of forest of spine-like
hairs.

The mycelium begins to develope its fructification from the

RESEARCHES ON THE MUCORINI. 61

second day in the saline solution or the decoction, both of
which are feebly nutritive liquids and in which its vegetative
activity is soon exhausted ; in orange juice this did not take
place till the third day. In both cases the temperature was
about 59° Fahr. Abruptly-swollen branches, club-shaped in
form, make their appearance upon the hyphe both in the
nutritive medium and in the air. Sometimes these branches
prolong themselves directly into an equal number of sporangi-
ferous hyphe; but most frequently they first divide at their
swollen apices into numerous branches of which ordinarily one
(fig. 15), sometimes two or three (fig. 16), develope into spo-
rangiferous hyphz, while the rest, which are short and pointed,
form a tuft of rootlets. Sometimes these rootlets reduce
themselves to one or more rounded protuberances situated
towards the base of the sporangiferous hypha and giving to
its lower region an undulating outline. The sporangiferous
hyphze of Phycomyces are normally therefore produced in
groups, and this is indicated generally by the presence of
sterile hyphe, in the form of rootlets. This is a second
character which separates our plant from Mucor, and indi-
cates a nearer affinity with Rhizopus.

There are often also a certain number of the branches
which are swollen into a club- or pear-shaped form and
do not erect themselves above the surface; instead of pro-
ducing a sporangiferous hypha, which would seem to have
been their first destination, they become abruptly attenuated,
and are merely prelonged into a mycelial filament (fig. 17).
But the protoplasm never aggregates in the interior of these
basal swellings of the mycelial ramifications, even to the
extent of simulating a chlamydospore, and we have never,
indeed, under any circumstances, met with a single one in
Phycomyces. Occasionally when the process of germination
has been prematurely arrested, as by the development of bac-
teria in the decoction, certain portions of the hyphe, in which
the protoplasm preserves its vitality after the rest of the tube
is destroyed, are partitioned off. This is certainly a tendency
towards the formation of chlamydospores; but there is no
condensation of the protoplasm, and it never invests itself
with a special membrane. Later on, as in the case of the
spores, this isolated protoplasm undergoes a gradual altera-
tion separating into tolerably regular ovoid or fusiform
nodules, which to a certain extent have the appearance of
spores contained in an ascus but appear to be incapable of ger-
mination. The figure 3d represents one of these cavities,
which happens to have been formed at the very base of the
germinating hypha, and corresponds to the original cavity

62 VAN TIEGHEM AND LE MONNIER.

of the spore, being still covered with the exospore and filled
with fusiform nodules.

We do not think it necessary to describe in detail the
structure of the sporangium, the development and dispersion
of the spores, or the mode of elongation of the sporangiferous
hypha; these phenomena take place exactly as in Mucor,
and Carnoy has fully described them. We will merely remark
that the membrane of the sporangiferous hypha does not
become incrusted with granules of calcium oxalate, and that
it becomes gradually coloured from below upwards, before
the formation of the sporangium, in a very remarkable
manner, which is in singular contrast with the golden-yellow
colour of the protoplasm filling the apex of the tube, and
later on forming the spores. Beginning with bronze green it
gradually becomes reddish brown, or violet brown; its
surface is shining, and exhibits iridescent reflections and a
bright metallic lustre, a circumstance to which the plant
owes its specific name and which allows of its immediate
identification. The membrane of the sporangium encrusts
itself, on the contrary, with calcium oxalates, which gives it a
dull and velvety aspect and renders it opaque and dark.

We will now trace the progressive advance in the vigour
of the fructification which accompanies the more vigorous
growth of the mycelium in different nutritive media.

In a drop of the saline solution the spores form a
mycelium which begin to fructify at the end of the second
day ; the spores are mature about sixty-five hours from the
time of sowing, the temperature being 57° F. The first
sporangiferous hyphe are not more than‘100 mm. in length,
and may even be no longer than ‘024mm.; the corresponding
diameter of the sporangium may be no more than 025 mm.,
and it may contain as few as ten spores with a very depressed
columella. The hyphe produced on successsive days become
gradually taller with sporangia correspondingly larger ; their
columella, which is more and more prominent, becomes at
first hemispherical, then cylindrical, and the spores are more
oval and more numerous. These changes are all concomitant.
At length, after twelve days, the sporangiferous hyphe pro-
duced outside the cells on the mycelium which has insinuated
itself between the covering glass and the cell have a length
of as much as seven to eight centimetres, a proportional
breadth, and a very large sporangium. Sucb a result is no
doubt astonishing when one reflects that, before the formation
of a hypha of this kind takes place, the mycelium nourished
by this minute drop of a saline solution has produced suc-
cessively larger and larger sporangia. It is still more

RESEARCHES ON THE MUCORINI. 63

astonishing if one compares it with the conditions of the
medium ordinarily affected by the plant, since nothing can
be more different than a mass of some greasy substance anda
drop of our saline solution.

In orange juice, which is evidently more nutritious, the
mycelium developing at first more vigorously, fructifies rather
later, about the third day; but the branches first formed
are stronger, taller, and the sporangia larger, although haying
wholly spherical spores and a depressed columella. Just as
with the saline solution a progressive increase takes place,
and the last hyphe which form in the moist chamber in
which the growing cell is placed attain a length of as much
as ten centimetres.

Sexual reproduction ; Zygospores.—In the cell-cultures, no
doubt owing to the unsuitableness of the medium, and even
on fruit in pan cultivations, we have failed to obtain the
sexual apparatus. On crushed cochineal and on cochineal dye,
on the contrary, we have repeatedly obtained it in the greatest
abundance. The mycelium produces at first its forest of
sporangiferous hyphe, shining and iridescent. If, when new
hyphe cease to be developed, we remove the whole of this
forest of hyphz, we see on the surface of growth large black
grains, which catch the eye at a first glance on the red back-
ground: these are the zygospores. It is easy then to meet with
them in all the states of development about to be described.

The hyphe which conjugate to form the zygospores are
slender and stand erect on the surface of the substratum; they
are analogous to the hyphe forming the tufts which we de-
scribed in the cell-cultures. ‘T'wo of these hyphe come into
close contact through a considerable length, and dovetail
with one another by aiternate protuberances and constric-
tions. Some of the protuberances are frequently prolonged
-into slender tubes (fig. 4). At the same time the free
extremities of the hyphe dilate and arch one_ towards
the other until their tops touch, forming a kind of vice, of
which the teeth rapidly increase in size. Each tooth forms
a partition which cuts off a cell, at first hemispherical
(fig. 5), and afterwards becoming cylindrical by pressure
(fig. 6). In each of these discoid cells the protoplasm
ageregates itself into a mass. The double membrane at the
point of contact is absorbed, and the two confluent masses of
protoplasm form a zygospore, which is invested with a tuber-
cular coat, and enveloped by the primary wall of the two
conjugating cells (figs. 10 and 11).

While this is taking place the two arched cells develope
on the zone adjoining the walls which separate them from

6+ VAN TIEGHEM AND LE MONNIER,.

the conjugating cells a series of repeatedly dichotomous
processes (figs. 11, 12, 13). These processes appear in the
first place upon one only of the arcuate cells, and in succes-
sive order. ‘The first makes its appearance above upon the
convex side; the succeeding ones to the right and left in
descending order: the last is in the concavity underneath
(figs. 7 and 8). It is only after the development of this that
the ‘first process makes its appearance above upon the other
cell (fig. 9), followed by the others in the same order. The
processes grow and dichotomise in the same order in which
they are developed.

The first dichotomy always takes place in the plane, passing
through the point of dichotomy as well as the line join-
ing the centres of. the conjugated cells (figs. 9, 10);
the others follow in planes alternately at right angles
with one another. The two branches of the first dicho-
tomy are slightly unequal; that which is situated next the
zygospore is the most developed, and lying upon it dicho-
tomises again repeatedly, interlacing its branches so as
to envelope and protect the zygospore. ‘These dichotomous pro-
cesses are nothing more than branches of the arcuate cells ;
in fact, when the “ vice ”’ is arrested in its development, it is
not unusual to see one or more of the processes already formed
develope into ordinary mycelial hyphe (fig. 14). During
all these changes, while the zygospore enlarges, the wall of
the arcuate cells becomes coloured brown. This coloration
is more marked on the convex side, and it shows itself first
in the cell on which are produced the first dichotomous
branches and which long retains a darker tint than the other.
The zone of origin of the processes and the processes them-
selves have their wall of a deep black, while the walls of
the conjugated cells which continue to ‘clothe the zy gospore

‘during the whole period of its development is itself a ‘bluish-
black ‘(figs. 11, 13). When its development is complete the

zygospore may ‘attain 2 zmm., but many occur which are much
smaller. It is more developed on its external than upon its
internal side, and its lateral faces by which it is attached to
the teeth of the vice are slightly inclined one to the other,
which is the result of the curvature of the primary cells. By
pressure the black, thin, and brittle coat which envelopes the
zygospore is ruptured, and the coat of the zygospore itself is
exposed as a thick, cartilaginous membrane studded by large
irregular protuberances. The contained protoplasm, like that
of all zygospores, is very rich in fatty matters. The dichotomous
processes which interlace their branches round the zygospore
as if to protect it distinguish the reproductive apparatus of

RESEARCHES ON THE MUCORINI. 65

Phycomyces nitens from all others which are at present known.
The previous connection of the two conjugating hyph and
their terminal curvature in the form of a vice grasping the
zygospore can only be compared with the arrangement in
Piptocephahs which Brefeld has made us acquainted with.

The mode in which the processes are developed indicates
that there is a difference in the age and properties of the two
teeth of the vice, similar as they appear in other respects, and
similar as are the conjugating cells. We may trace in this
dissimilarity a first step in the differentiation of the two ele-
ments whose union forms the germ-cell, an indication as yet
feebly marked, but still very distinct, of sexuality in the
process of conjugation.

We have not yet succeeded in making these zygospores
germinate ; but it is probable that the process is similar to
what takes place in the case of zygospores of which we know
the mode of germination, especially those of Mucor fusiger
and M. Mucedo. We were the first to describe the zygospores
of this last plant.t A short time after we discovered their mode
of germination. Brefeld has also recently figured and described
these organs and their germination.” We shall not touch on
this point, therefore, except to detail some new observations.
The black membrane, which is generally regarded as belong-
ing to the zygospore, of which it forms the exospore, is really
absolutely foreign to it, since it is nothing more than the
original cell-walls of the cells which have conjugated. This
black membrane ruptures in germination. The thick, black,
cartilaginous, colourless, tubercular coat splits also on one
side, and its delicate internal coat elongates itself externally
as a tube which is filled with protoplasm and oil-drops ; it
is covered in its lower third with granules of calcium oxa-
late, while it is smooth higher up; it attains a height of
three centimétres, and terminates in an ordinary sporan-
gium. ‘Thus, the zygospore produces directly, not a myce-
lium, but an asexual reproductive apparatus. The axis of
this apparatus—that is to say, the axis of growth of the new
individual plant, is perpendicular to the line joining the
centres of the two conjugating cells—that is, to the coales-
cent axes of growth of the two sexual branches. In the
zygospore, therefore, the protoplasm has, so to speak, a
polarity (est ortenté), the direction of which is at right angles
to the line joining the centres of the two conjugating masses
of protoplasm, or oospheres. It is also probable that each
oosphere is polarised in a direction at right angles to the

1 «Comptes Rendus,’ Ap. 8, 1872, vol. Ixxiv, p. 1000.
2 «Bot. Unt. ub. Schimmelpilze,’ p. 31, pl. i.
VOL. XIV.—NEW SER. E

66 VAN TIEGHEM AND LE MONNIER,.

axis of growth of the conjugating cell, from which it is pro-
duced. The two oospheres have their axes parallel and
consequently when fused produce a zygospore whose axis
preserves the same direction. In this change of direction in
the axis of the new individual we find an additional analogy
with the sexual process in Alge.

Usually, the amount of nutriment stored up in the zygo-
spores is exhausted by the formation of the terminal sporan-
gium, and this is the only case described by Brefeld ; but in
the germinations which we have watched ourselves we have
often seen the formation of a partition at about one third of
the length of the principal filament from its base, and below
this partition a strong branch given off, which is also termi-
nated by a large sporangium. In one instance this branch
also exhibited near its base a partition beneath which a
small branch was given off, terminated by a small sporangium
with very few spores and a minute columella.

Contrary to the opinion of Berkeley and De Bary, we regard
this plant as belonging to a distinct genus. Its partly aérial
mycelium, the mode of origin of the fructiferous hyphe in
groups with tufts of rootlets, the remarkable colouration of the
protoplasm of the spores and of the wall of the fructiferous
hypha, and above all the curious vice-like arrangement of its
reproductive apparatus and the dichotomous processes with
which it surrounds the zygospore, are characters which are
not met with in any species of Mucor. A similar sexual
apparatus only occurs in Prptocephalis which is remotely
allied to Mucor ; and the dichotomous processes have not at
present been detected in any others of the group. From all
these points of view this plant merits a generic rank.

Brefeld has proceeded hastily in following De Bary and
Woronin and in reducing all the types of Mucorini to the
two genera Mucor and Pvlobolus. It is true that Chetocla-
dium and Purptocephalis, which he holds to be distinct, are,
according to him, not Mucorii at all. But in this we
ourselves believe that he is mistaken.

THAMNIDIUM.

Link described in 1816 under the name of Thamnidium
elegans a Mucorinious fungus of which the principal
fructiferous hypha terminated in a large sporangium, with
a columella similar to that of Mucor, and which produced
laterally numerous repeatedly dichotomous branches, of
which the final ramifications, according to him, bore spores.!

1 Link, ‘ Observ. in Ord. Nat. Plant. Dissert.,’ i.

RESEARCHES ON THE MUCORINI. 67

Fries, only regarding this production of lateral spores as a
specific character, placed the plant in the genus Mucor under
the name of MV. elegans. But Corda showed subsequently
that the reproductive lateral organs are not spores, but small
sporangia destitute of a columella and containing four spores
similar to those of the terminal sporangium.? Like Fries he
only regarded this system of small lateral sporanges as a
specific character, and as the terminal sporange exhibited
all the characters of his Ascophora Mucedo, he placed the
plant next to it as A. elegans.

However, Eschweiler had long previously described and
figured under the name of Melidium subterraneum a dicho-
tomous fructification with small sporangia destitute of a
columella and containing a small number of spores, usually
four. This is identical with the dichotomous lateral system
of Link’s Thamnidium, of which Corda ascertained thetrue
nature, and which, as,we now know, may occur isolated and
deprived of its large terminal sporangium. The observations
of Link and Eschweiler relate to one and the same plant,
and mutually complete one another.

De Bary and Woronin,’ going further than Fries and
Corda, have asserted the identity of the terminal sporangium
of Thamnidium with that of Mucor. According to their
view the dichotomous system of small spores is a reproductive
structure which belongs to Mucor Mucedo, but which only
appears on the ordinary filaments of this plant under certain
conditions. At the commencement of our researches we had
at first adopted this view, but we soon found that the supposed
identity of the large terminal sporangia in the two plants
was an error, and that Thamnidium is a perfectly autonomous
species.

It will not be necessary to describe here in detail the
mature fructification ; an erect filament, which may attain
five or six cm. in height, terminates by a large sporangium
with a columella, and produces, laterally, one or more tiers
of isolated or whorled dichotomous branches, the ultimate
ramifications of which have small sporangia destitute of
columella. ‘This is not, however, the only form met with
in pan cultivations. Simple and naked filaments terminating
in a large sporangium are also met with as well as filaments
equally simple, but ending in dichotomous fructification with
small sporangia, Melidium Eschw. (fig. 18, a—). Later on

1 Fries, ‘ Systema,’ i, 183.

* Corda, ‘ cones Fungorum,’ iii (1840), p. 14.

3 Eschweiler, ‘ De Fructif. gen. Rhizomorphe, Comm. Elberfeld,’ 1822.
‘ © Beitrag. z. Morph. und Phys. der Pilze,’ ii (1866), p. 16.

68 VAN TIEGHEM AND LE MONNIER.

the first may produce simple lateral branches with a large spo-
rangium ; the second may also give rise to new lateral branches,
but these are dichotomous and bear small sporangia.

Thus, in pan cultivation we may meet with one or other
of the two forms of sporangia, either exclusively or both
together in different regions of the mycelium, and the spore-
bearing systems will be accordingly either homogeneous or
heterogeneous. When both kinds of sporangia occur on the
same hypha sometimes the large sporangium is borne on the
summit, and the small sporangia laterally ; and this is the
most common combination, but sometimes it is the reverse.
The hypha terminated by a tuft of small sporangia bears
a lateral branch with a large sporangium. The two arrange-
ments may even occur successively in the same complex
system; an erect hypha with a large sporangium bears a
horizontal branch terminated by a dichotomous tuft; this
produces in its turn an oblique lateral branch terminated by
a large sporangium, which in its turn produces a lateral
branch with small sporangia (fig. 18, 2).

The two forms of sporangium are always sharply dis-
tinguishable. The large sporangium is always borne by a
simple hypha, and has a large columella, a wall incrusted
with granules and fine spicules of calcium oxalate which
becomes diffluent in water, dispersing the granules and
spicules and a large number of spores which in this way are
disseminated. ‘The small sporangia are always produced by
dichotomous hyphe. Their short and very fragile pedicels
are separated from their cavity by a partition, which is flat
or only slightly curved ; their wall is also studded with more
or less prominent granules of calcium oxalate, but is not
soluble in water; their spores are usually four in number,
but may be as many as six, eight, or ten, or as few as three
or two, or even be reduced to one filling the whole spo-
rangium. It is by the falling off of these sporangia and the
final rupture of the membrane that the spores are set free.
Whether produced by a large or a small sporangium the
spores are in all other respects similar ; they are homogeneous,
colourless, or bluish, oval, about ‘008 to ‘010 mm. in length,
and ‘006 to (008 mm. in breadth.

When the sporangium contains only a single spore, which
occasionally happens almost exclusively over a large extent
of the crop, the spore is spherical, intimately applied to the
membrane of the sporangium, from which it is distinguished
with difficulty (fig. 20), but from which it can be freed by
pressure ; it measures often ‘012 mm. in diameter, but it may
vary from ‘008 mm. to ‘016 mm. It is probable that it is

RESEARCHES ON THE MUCORINI. 69

under this form that Thamnidium was discovered by Link,
which explains how this author came to describe the spo-
rangia as spores.

Cell-culture has shown that, on the first appearance of the
mycelium, there are innumerable transitions between the two
forms of sporangia sown in a cell; in ordinary water the.
spores did not germinate; in the saline solution, on the
contrary, they germinated, but their hyphz speedily became
empty, owing to the protoplasm concentrating itself at
certain points and forming isolated chlamydospores, but not
producing fructification. In horse-dung decoction and orange
juice, on the contrary, it succeeds well.

The oval spore at first swells, becomes spherical, and
continues to increase for some time ; then, without the least
trace of a ruptured exospore, it puts out one or two hyphae,
which ramify progressively, and form here and there on its
principal ramifications attenuated branches, divided into
tufts of radicles, and separated from the main branch by a
partition near their base. After forty-eight hours the
mycelium thus formed has produced in the air within the
cell a large number of erect sporangiferous branches. They
bear sometimes a single sporangium, variable in size (fig. 18,
a, g), spores of which may, if the nutrition be insufficient, be
reduced to two or even a single one, sometimes two or three,
or four to thirty-two or more sporangia (fig. 18, 8, c, d, e).

In proportion as the dichotomy increases, the size of
the sporangia and the extent to which their septum
bulges inwards decrease, and finally they only have four
spores. The earliest fructification produced by the young
mycelium presents all possible transitions between the two
kinds of hyphe and sporangia. Amongst these transitions
small sporangia without a columella terminate simple hyphe,
and large sporangia with a distinct columella terminate
dichotomies, in which case the spores are often very unequal
in size; and all these transitions occur not only on a
mycelium, which is the product of numerous spores, but even
upon that which is derived from a single one. One branch of
a mycelial hypha, for example (fig. 19), will produce a single
large sporangium, while another will terminate in a system
three times dichotomous with eight moderate-sized spo-
rangia. .

We have also observed on the branched hyphz horizontal
branches, usually also dichotomous, develope with or without
a septum, and bearing sporangia both smaller and more
numerous than those of the terminal dichotomy (fig. 19). In
such cases it often happens that when the sporangia of the

70 VAN TIEGHEM AND LE MONNIER.

terminal dichotomy contain sixteen spores, those of these
secondary lateral ones will only contain a single spherical
spore of from *005 to'006 mm. These spores, in germinating,
either rupture the closely-applied sporangium (fig. 20) or the
spore pierces its wall, elongating directly into a hypha, and
leaving its basal portion enclosed.

It is important to remark that in our cell-culture the fruc-
tification was often exclusively composed of dichotomous
hyphz with small sporangia, without a trace of the large
hyphe bearing a single sporangium.

We have also observed the germination of the spores of
Thamnidium in a layer of a nutritive liquid, such as orange
juice, so arranged as to prevent, as far as posssible, the access
of air, and to prevent the plant from fruiting. Under these
conditions the spores absorb nutriment and swell into large
homogeneous spheres, which, by a process of gemmation, pro-
duce more or less irregular chains of spherous cells. When
the mycelium is subjected to the same treatment the hyphe
form also at their extremities chains of irregular joints, in
which the protoplasm temporarily condenses, and which are
an approach, therefore, to chlamydospores. Under the same
conditions we have also seen short branches of the hyphe
swell at intervals, often at their extremities, into large
spheres, with granular walls, and containing protoplasm
filled with large vacuoles.

We have not as yet detected the zygospores of Tham-
nidium.

CHZTOSTYLUM.

Fresenius in searching for Thamnidium discovered two
other Mucorint. One is Piptocephalis Freseniana of De
Bary; the other is the plant to which we have now given
the name of Chetostylum Fresenti Fresenius believed it to
be areprodnctive system belonging to Mucor Mucedo. It is
also very probable that it is identical with the reproductive
system ascribed by Klein to the same plant, and named by
him Bulbothamnidium elegans.*

Chetostylum occurs mixed with Chetocladium upon horse-
dung, and closely resembles it in appearance. It differs,
however, in having a strictly definite instead of indefinite
mode of growth. It is heterosporangious, like Thamnidium,
and may have large sporangia with a columella, and a difflu-
ent wall, terminating simple and vertical hyphe, or small

1 Fresenius, ‘ Beitr. z. Mykol.,’ 1863, p. 96.
2 Klein, ‘ Verhandl. dev. k.k. Zool. Bot. Ges. in Wien,’ 1870, t. xx.

RESEARCHES ON THE MUCORINI. 71

caducous sporangioles destitute of a columella. All the
branches except those which bear the sporangioles terminate
in a point and the branches of each successive order, which
are shorter than those of the preceding, are placed in a kind
of false verticil on a more or less swollen dilatation (fig. 21).
Whatever the size of the sporangium the spores are always
nearly uniform. They are colourless or slightly bluish, oval,
and ‘008 mm. in length, by “005 in breadth.

CH#TOCLADIUM.

The type of this genus was first described by Berkeley and
Broome as Botrytis Jonesi.' This was erected into a genus
by Fresenius, who called it Chetocladium Jonesii.2 Quite
recently it has been studied by De Bary and Woronin.? At
first, we ourselves accepted the conclusion arrived at by these
latter writers, that Chetocladium belonged to the cycle of
Mucor Mucedo.*

Chetocladium Jonesii.—By sowing, unmixed with other
spores, in a drop of orange juice or decoction, in a cell, a
small number of the reproductive bodies of this species, or
better still, a single one, and by watching from hour to hour
its development, it is easily proved that the reproductive
bodies of Chetocladium Joneswi, regarded hitherto as simple
acrogenous spores, such as those of Botrytis, are really small
caducous sporangia, containing only a single spore, like those
of Helicostylum, Thamnidium, Chetostylum, in fact, that
Chetocladium Jonesu is perfectly independent of Mucor
Mucedo, or of any of the Mucorini, either as a reproductive
system or as a parasite.

These reproductive bodies (fig. 22), when detached from
the plant at their maturity, are a more or less slaty blue.
Their external surface bristles with calcareous granules,
more or less developed, which have not escaped the observa-
tion of Berkeley and Broome, and a small portion of the
broken pedicel is sometimes still attached (fig. 25, a). It is
not rare to find an external membrane distinguishable from an
internal spherical body, since the spore does not in this
case completely fill the cavity of the sporange; but it is
frequently difficult to observe this, from the spore being
everywhere in intimate contact with the inner wall of the
sporangium ; thisis also the case with the monosporic spo-

1 ¢ Ann. and Mag. Nat. Hist.,’ 2ad ser., 1854, xiii, pl. 15.

2 «Beitr. z. Mykol.,’ 1863, p. 97.

3 Beitr. z. Morph. u. Phys. der Pilze,’ 2nd ser., 1866, pl. 18.
* «Comptes Rendus,’ Ap. 8, 1872.

72. VAN TIEGHEM AND LE MONNIER.

rangioles of Zhamnidium. By pressure the thin granular,
brittle, and greyish membrane of the sporangiole is easily
broken, and the smooth, often dark slate-coloured spore is
extruded (fig. 23,4). But germination affords the most con-
vincing proof of the sporangial nature of the reproductive
body.

A fruiting branch of Chetocladium Jonesii, terminating in
a point, and bearing upon its middle dilatation eight ripe
reproductive bodies, still attached to their pedicels, is placed
in a drop of orange-juice in a cell. Seven hours afterwards
the external membrane is ruptured, and the contained spore
either completely (fig. 23, cc) or partially (d) extruded, re-
quiring in the latter case a little manipulation to detach it
from the sporangiferous branch. The spores now change
colour, and gradually swell to three or four times their
original diameter without, however, changing form; a
large vacuole occupies its centre (fig. 24, a). They then
become oval, and afterwards form projecting angles (0, ¢, d),
which develope into short stout tubes, spreading in all
directions and dividing immediately into close or palmate
dichotomies (fig. 24, e to fig. 27), and forming a small mass
of mycelium, which grows slowly by additions to its peri-
phery, attaining sometimes the size of a pin’s head. No long
diffuse branching mycelium with radicles is formed, as in
Mucor, where the mode of germination is altogether differ-
ent. This enables us to detect as early as the second day
an accidental admixture in our cell-culture of Mucor spores.

It is not till three or sometimes four days from the time
of sowing the spores that branches of these white mycelial
masses erect themselves into the air to ramify in all direc-
tions. These long aerial hyphe bear laterally either singly
or in verticils of two or three branches, which terminate in
a point, and which bear in turn at about their middle two
or three shorter pointed branches. These last bear on a
swelling at their middle, a small number of slender simple, or
sometimes dichotomous pedicles, each terminated by a mono-
sporic dark slate-coloured granular sporange, and measuring
006 to ‘008 mm. in diameter (fig. 22). As the fructification
develops, the protoplasm, slowly accumulated at first in the
large radiating mycelial hyphe is used up, and the hyphz
become empty. At the same time the extremities of some of
them abruptly taper off, while others become enormously
inflated into large balloon-like bodies, with a granular sur-
face, and often prolonged into a point (fig. 28, a, 6). But we
have never detected chlamydospores.

This is the uniform course of development in Chetocladium

RESEARCHES ON THE MUCORINI. 73

Jonesti, which cannot therefore be normally parasitic on
Mucor. Inasmuch also as it reproduces itself for an indefi-
nite number of generations, it can have no genetic bond
either with Mucor Mucedo, or any other of the Mucorini.

The aerial sporangiferous hyphe of Chetocladium, like
those of Circinella and Rhizopus, have an indefinite growth
after the fashion of a liane.! But it is not rare to find one of
the vegetative hyphe put out laterally a short and thick
branch, which frequently divides repeatedly dichotomously,
and forms a white tubercle tangent to the hypha or even
enveloping it entirely. These tubercles or mycelial masses
are altogether similar to those which proceed from the germi-
nation of the spores. Some of their branches may be pro-
longed into the air as new, fructiferous, indefinite hyphe.
They are, perhaps, homologous with the tufts of radicles
which develope on the aerial indefinite hyphe of Rhzzopus,
and are the point of origin of new fructifications.

Sometimes it happens that the mycelial mass resulting
from germination is very much reduced; the spore puts out
five or six palmate tubes, one of which immediately raises
itself in the air and becomes covered with fructification, while
the others are like the fingers of a glove, and terminate at a
short distance from the spore. In this case the submerged
mycelium is a mere base of support for the aerial hypha, pro-
ducing fructification.

Besides sowing the pure spores of Chetocladium Jonesit,
we sowed them mixed with those of Mucor Mucedo. The
mycelia of the two species so different in their characters,
the one condensed into masses, the other diffuse, vegetated
as if they were independent, and without forming any
attachment the one to the other. The first put out its more
slender branching sporangiferous hyphze, the other its simple
ones, but wherever a hypha of Chetocladiuwm came in contact
in the air with one of Mucor, an intimate adhesion took
place, and at the point of contact the filament of Chetocladium
put out large branching processes, which, becoming felted
together, formed round the two hyphe a large white tubercle,
from which new fruit-bearing filaments of Chetocladium
originated. If the hypha of Mucor is very young and still
in process of elongation when thus attacked, it ceases to
develope, but if its protoplasm has already accumulated in
its terminal dilatation it produces a sporangium, and forms
and ripens its spores.

1 Sometimes degraded forms which are more or less definite in their

growth are produced in liquids, such as horse-dung decoction, which are
insufficiently nutritive (fig. 37, a—/).

74: VAN TIEGHEM AND LE MONNIER.

The Chetocladium grows in the air amongst the tall, rigid
hyphee of Mucor like parasitic lianes among trees. But the
plant is not, strictly speaking, parasitic, though it can live
parasitically and becomes more vigorous when it does so.

It is necessary in growing the two plants together to avoid
sowing too large a number of spores of Mucor. These ger-
minate sooner than the others and if present in any quantity
completely suppress their growth leading to the belief held at
first by ourselves, as well as by De Bary and Woronin of an
imaginary transformation of the Chetocladium into the
Mucor.

Chetocladium Brefeldii—We have given this name to a
species very similar to the preceding, but more slender in all
its parts, and which differs from it by its bluish sporangia,
which are much smaller, being only from -003 to 005 mm.
We believe it to be identical with that studied by Brefeld,
and of which he obtained zygospores.

Brefeld believes that the reproductive bodies of this species
are simple naked conidia, and that it is parasitic on Mucor
Mucedo and Rhizopus nigricans. He deduces this parasitism
from two supposed facts—(1) that it fails to develop, either
alone or associated with any other of the Mucorimi ; (2) if, on
the contrary, it is associated with these species, it attaches
itself to them and develops and fruits abundantly.

To test Brefeld’s observation, we traced the result of the
cell-culture in a drop of orange juice of a single reproductive
body. It measured ‘0035 mm.; six to eight hours after it
was sown a large crack formed in its external membrane,
anda bluish spherical spore escaped. The empty membrane
is often hyaline, slightly greyish, and sometimes finely
granular’; it is thinner than in Ch. Jonesiz, and soon under-
goes solution in the liquid. The existence of this membrane
from which the spore escapes in germination proves that the
reproductive body must be regarded as a monosporic sporan-
gium, and not, as Brefeld thought, as a spore.

The spore now swells to many times its original size, while
still remaining spherical, and puts out one or two hyphe,
which elongate, ramifying in a fan-like manner. The
branches are at first destitute of lateral ramifications, but
later they develop as they lengthen lateral protuberances
and, subsequently, short and hooked branches, which are
simple or again ramified. These lateral processes are quite
different from the radicular filaments of the mycelial filaments
of Mucor; they are never, like those, separated from the prin-
cipal hypha by a basal partition (fig. 29). This production
in germination of one or two elongated hyphe, the branches

RESEARCHES ON THE MUCORINI. 75

of which gradually diverge and are studded with hooked
branchlets, gives a habit altogether different from that of Ch.
Jonesit, and supplies, perhaps, the best proof of the specific
difference of the two plants.

This diffuse mycelium, the offspring of a single spore,
spreads itself in four days, little by little, through the whole
drop, passes its borders, and extends over the covering-glass
and covers a circular space 5-6 mm. in diameter. On the
fourth day a few of the principal hyphe exhibit a few trans-
verse septa. The fifth day, the extremities of the hyphe
which occupy the periphery of the drop put out slender
branches into the air of the cell. Occasionally, these aerial
prolongations may be the ends of the hyphe themselves, but
more usually they are a development of one of the branches
of a lateral process (figs. 30,31). In this case the other
branches of the process grow, and, becoming felted together,
form a more or less complicated mass investing its base. On
the sixth day a large number of these aerial filaments bear
on lateral branches groups of bluish monosporic sporangia
(figs. 30, 32).

Cultures of this kind often repeated prove that Cheto-
cladium Brefelditi may be perfectly autonomous, and Brefeld’s
failure attributable to many causes, possibly amongst others
to an unfavorable medium, is not conclusive.

When the spores of Ch. Brefeldi are mixed with those of
Mucor Mucedo, wherever the apex of a branch of one of the
lateral processes of a hypha of the former comes in contact
with any part of a hypha of the latter, it forms an intimate
attachment, and finally, by the absorption of the intervening
walls a complete continuity between the branch and the hypha
(figs. 33,34). The other branches of the process immediately
develope and form about the point of union a felted mass,
more or less complicated. Some of them in different stages of
development will be found from the second day after the
sowing and indicate points of union between the two
systems of mycelium. L

Union of hyphze may take place when only those of
Chetocladium are concerned. Fig. 35 represents three spores
s, &, 8’, of Ch. Brefeldii, which have generated side by
side, and the hyphe of which have fused, so that it is
impossible to determine their points of union. Fig. 36 shows
that two branches of a hypha have curved towards each
other, forming a loop. This property of anastomosis of
the mycelium which is possessed in so high a degree by
Ascomycetes, Penicillium, Botrytis, Arthrobotrys, here
appears for the first time amongst the Mucorimi, al-

76 VAN TIEGHEM AND LE MONNIER.

though we now know that others of the group also mani-
fest it. |

On the third day the Mucor produced fructification ; the
Chetocladium did not do so till it had developed in the
air its long slender branching hyphe. These generally
originated from a mycelial tubercle or from a point adjacent
to one, but much more frequently they were developed from
the ordinary hyphe of the Chetocladium remote from any
point of union with the Mucor ; on the other hand, many of
the tubercles produced no aerial hyphe at all. On the fourth
day the aerial hyphz developed branches with more or less
complicated groups of sporangia, but always destitute of
pointed terminations which only develope subsequently with
increased vigour of growth. Whenever in the air within the
cell the sporangiferous hyphz of Mucor come into contact
with the long flexuous hyphe of Chetocladium, unions of the
same kind are effected as occur in the case of those which
are submerged.

These observations quite confirm all that Brefeld has
stated, and it must be allowed that the Chetocladium attains
by virtue of its parasitism a much more considerable de-
velopment. Chetocladium Brefeldw is not a parasite in the
absolute sense of the word, which would imply that parasitism
is a necessity of its existence. Yet it undoubtedly possesses
the power by forming unions with Mucor of appropriating
nutriment from it. Yet we have cultivated the two plants
together, without being able to detect any union between
them.

The species of Chetocladium are then indifferently
parasitic or not. Other species of Mucorini exhibit the same
phenomena, in appearance so contradictory—one plant fixing
itself upon another and drawing from it part of its nutriment,
yet able at the same time to develope, live, and fructify
autonomously. But perhaps, after all, this kind of am-
biguous parasitism need not very much surprise us. In fact,
all, fungi, like all animals, are parasites in relation to
chlorophyll-containing plants, from which ultimately they
must needs draw their supply of carbon. Being then in the
last resort parasitic we need not be astonished if the extent
of their parasitism should in different cases be a little more
or a little less marked.

77

Remarks on the AFFINITIES of RHABDOPLEURA. By E.
Ray Lanxester, M.A. (With Woodcuts.)

THE memoir of Mr. G. O. Sars, reproduced from his own
English publication in the preceding pages, is of very great
interest, in that it clearly makes known to us the anatomy of
the remarkable genus established by Allman in this Journal,
with so much shrewdness on the examination of a few spirit
specimens. I desire to take this opportunity of pointing out
that the supposed relation of Rhabdopleura to the Hydrozoa,
supported above by Sars, is not really indicated by the facts
he has adduced. There is, I venture to affirm, on the
contrary, no important feature in which Rhabdopleura really
approximates to the Hydrozoa. It is separated by a huge
gulf from the Diploblastica, from the animals devoid of true
body cavity, and possessing extensive gastric ramifications.

The real and great interest of Rhabdopleura seems to me
to consist in this, that it tends to upset that classification
which has been adopted by such distinguished investigators
as Gegenbauer and Haeckel. These authorities remove the
Polyzoa from association with the Mollusca, and place them
in the central or proliferous ancestral group, Vermes. Huxley
and Allman, on the other hand, remain staunch to Milne-
Edwards’ arrangement of the Polyzoa under the Molluscan
sub-kingdom.

Though one class of the so-called Molluscoidea, namely,
the Tunicata, has to be removed from the Molluscan family-
tree in consequence of recent researches—if our classifications
are to have any genealogical signification, and very few
persons doubt that they must have such a signification—yet
there really has not been a serious attempt to contravert
those reasons which have been assigned, especially by Allman,
for associating the Polyzoa with the Mollusca. In passing I
may say that still less is there reason for removing the
Brachiopoda from such association. In Rhabdopleura we
have a form which binds the Polyzoa fast to the Molluscan
series, and with the Polyzoa undoubtedly go the Brachiopoda,
as the recent observations of Morse on the development of
Terebratulina, and my own on Terebratula vitrea, show.

When it is once admitted, as it may be most fully, that
the great family-tree of the Mollusca has developed directly
from the Vermes, and more largely than any other of the
four great trees springing from Vermian ancestors has re-
tained the essential organization of its ancestors 1n a primitive

78 E. RAY LANKESTER.

condition, then it ceases to be surprising that, with so much
.confidence, lowly developed or degraded groups of Mollusca
are detached by systematists from the Molluscan tree, and
referred back to the fundamental group of Worms.

There are three modifications of structure which are dis-
tinctive of the Mollusca, and are of significance in the order
in which they are mentioned, viz. foot, gill, mantle-shell.
They each have their representative, their homogen, in the
commonest worms, but unspecialised, not elaborated in the
Molluscan style. The foot is a muscular specialisation of
the ‘neural’ or ‘ ventral’ post-oral body-wall. It is the
most characteristic of all Molluscan features. The gills,
again, are lateral and post-oral diverticula of the body-wall,
such as are found as respiratory organs in many Vermes.
But in some classes of the Mollusca they have taken on
special functions with accompanying changes of form and of
apparent relations, which strangely obscure their origin. The
mantle, with the calcareous matter to which it gives origin, is
again fully represented in the tubicolous Annelids, and is,
after all, a mere flap of the body-wall, which may be de-
veloped to an enormous extent or be absent altogether as well
as the shell. At the same time the production of an em-
bedded chitinous shell (pen of Cephalopoda, embryonic plug
of Gasteropoda, ligament of Lamellibranchs), together with
a superficial calcareous valve or valves, must have at a very
early period of its branching off have become characteristic of
the Molluscan pedigree.

There is a consideration of a general character, which relates
to the probable effect of a long-continued process of evolution
of organic forms, and is of the greatest importance in the ex-
amination of the Molluscan pedigree, as, indeed, in all such
inquiries. That consideration is this, that the lowly organised
forms which we at present see are by no means necessarily,
though they are possibly, and often, no doubt, are actually,
representatives of the lowly organised ancestry of the higher
forms to which they are most nearly allied. They often, on
the contrary, must be degraded forms, or forms which have
progressed in the direction of simplification from a more
highly elaborated or more ‘typical’ ancestry. Thus, very
probably, both Amphioxus and the Ascidians do not indicate
to us the direct way backwards from the Vertebrata to an
invertebrate ancestry. They both very probably have become
vastly modified and simplified in their own way, as compared
with the ancestor common to them and the Vertebrata.
Long ago Goethe perceived the tendency to substitute the
order in which things become known to us for the order of

REMARKS ON THE AFFINITIES OF RHABDOPLEURA.

79

M
'
'
1
i
1
!

\

Fig. 3. Frig.4
Explanation of the woodcuts, being a series of Acephalous Molluses.

M. Mouth, A. Anus. Ac. Blind ending of intestine. F. Foot.
G. Gill-tentacles. H. So-called heart of Zerebratula. ng. Nerve-
ganglion. Ov. Oviduct.

Fig. 1.—Hippocrepian Polyzoon. Fig. 2.—Rhabdopleura.
» o—Terebratula. 4 » 4.—Young Cyclas.
» 5.—Dentalium. .

80 E. RAY LANKESTER.

their true or causal relationships, when he said, ‘‘ Was
wiirden wir von einem Architecten sagen, der durch eine
Seitenthiire in einen Palast gekommen ware, und nun, bei
Beschreibung und Darstellung eines solchen Gebaudes, alles
auf diese erste untergeordnete seite beziehen wollte? Und
doch geschieht dies in den Wissenschaften jeden Tag.”

It is possible that in this way we may be led to look at
the Mollusca through a side door, if we do not remember
that the simplest forms referable to that group, known to us
at this day, are not necessarily the most nearly representa-
tive of the Molluscan ancestry.

In Rhabdopleura we find a large and well-developed foot
{the buccal shield), justifying the previous assumption that.
the epistoma of the fresh-water Polyzoa represents the foot
of Mollusca.

In Brachiopoda there is even less trace of the foot than is
afforded by the Polyzoan epistoma; but.in Terebratula there
is a bare indication of it—a so-called lower lip. Would it
be right from this to conclude that the Brachiopoda are more
nearly related to the Vermes, and that we have an ascending
series from them, through the Hippocrepian Polyzoa to
Rhabdopleura, and thence to Mollusca proper? It seems
not; but far more probably we have a descending series—a
loss of this powerful foot—accompanying the acquisition of
immobility and subsequent arborescent stock-building.

With the assumption of these habits we have further the
abortion of the cephalic region common to Polyzoa, Brachio-
poda, and Lamellibranchs; and further, the huge develop-
ment of the gill-tentacles—not as respiratory organs, for
which function they are far larger than needful—but in all
three classes as excitors of currents, by means of their cilia,
bringing food to the mouth. The gill-tentacle of Rhabdo-
pleura is even more like to an arm of Terebratula than to one
side of a hippocrepian lophophore. Still more justly may
it be compared in form and in relation to other parts with
the gill-plume of some Gasteropods ; whilst its relative, posi-
tion as regards foot, mouth and anus, is precisely that of the
budding gill-lamine of a young Lamellibranch.

In the accompanying woodcuts I have diagrammatically
indicated these fundamental points of agreement among
Acephalous Mollusca. The comparison of the Cephalophora
with the Acephalous forms is rendered easy through the
Chitons on the one hand and the Lamellibranchs on the
other.

It has not been my object in the above few lines to discuss
the details of Molluscan morphology, but to give what I believe

RECENT RESEARCHES IN THE DIATOMACEA. Sl

to be its true significance to this admirably worked-out form,
Rhabdopleura, and that I conceive to depend upon the large
development of that most Molluscan of organs, the “ foot.”
The absence of a mantle-fold is of small significance, being
paralleled in various Mollusca proper. The abortion of the
cephalic region is characteristic of the whole branch of
Acephala, and the same region suffers in Dentalium, and
even in the Cephalopoda also, to the advantage of the ever-
more function-annexing foot.

Recent RESEARCHES in the DIATOMACER.
By Rev. E. O’Mzara, A.M.!

VI.

In the family Achnanthee the valves are symmetrical in the
longitudinal axis, but unsymmetrical in the plane of separa-
tion ; the frustules are more or less geniculate, so that of the
valves one is concave while the other is convex; the former
only possesses a central nodule. The genera Achnanthidium
and Cocconeis agree in these general characteristics, but are
separated into a distinct family, the Cocconeidee, for reasons
that shall be hereafter assigned, so that the family Achnanthee
embraces the solitary genus Achnanthes. The two species
of this genus which have been observed abundantly in a living
state, A. brevipes and A. subsessilis, correspond with the
Naviculee in the structure of the cell-contents, inasmuch as
they possess a middle granular plasm-mass and two endo-
chrome-plates lying on the girdle-bands, and thence passing
over the valves. ‘The endochrome-plates exhibit a slit in the
middle, and separate by an incision proceeding from the ends.
The well-defined nucleus lies always nearer to the concave
than to convex valve. In the few specimens of A. longipes
which came under Dr. Pfitzer’s notice, the endochrome-plates
were split up into numerous small pieces ; but whether this
be the normal condition or not remains to be determined.

The marine A. longipes was observed by Smith in the act
of forming auxospores, the same form, as well as A. subsessilis,
by Liiders. In respect to the former Smith maintained that a
single cell forms two auxospores, Liiders supposed that two
cells co-operate to produce the same result ; while in the case
of A. subsessilis a single mother-cell gives birth to a single
auxospore. In both cases, according to Liiders, the cell-

1 Continued from Vol, XIII, p. 15.

82 REV. E. O MEARA.

contents divide and afterwards re-unite, alternately in the
case of A. longipes, directly in that of A. subsessilis. Ac-
cording to Liiders, there is always found a gelatinous sheath
surrounding the infant cells, which force themselves out by
an opening at the end.

It appears confusing that two species so nearly related
should exhibit such different conditions in the formation of
their spores, and therefore the author expresses a wish that
observers residing near the sea-shore will carefully examine
fresh specimens with a view to ascertain satisfactorily the
process of spore-formation.

After the <Achnanthidee Pfitzer ranges the group Coc-
coneidee, in which are embraced the two genera, Achnan-
thidium and Cocconeis. Achnanthidium has been distinguished
from Achnanthes by the fact that while the latter is stipitate
the former is free. To this Pfitzer adds another mark of
distinction founded on the character of the endochrome-plates.
Achnanthes has two endochrome-plates, while in Achnanthi-
dium lanceolatum there is but one, which lies upon the convex
valve. This peculiarity places Achnanthidium in intimate
relationship with the next genus, Cocconeis. Cocconeis
Pediculus at least possesses a single endochrome-plate, occu-
pying a position similar to that of Achnanthidium lanceolatum,
split up on the edge, and with its scallops reaching the girdle-
band. It exhibits also a strong slit on one side, a circum-
stance which in the author’s opinion shows that the Cocco-
neidee are not decidedly symmetrical in the longitudinal
plane. This feature discovers itself in Achnanthidium like-
wise, in the structure of the concave valve, by a stronger
development of the central nodule on one side than on the
other. The endochrome-plate is more deeply scalloped in
proportion as the valve is large. The central incision some-
times extends so far as to effect a complete division of the
plate. A nucleus is clearly seen in Cocconeis Pediculus,
as is also a central accumulation of plasm. So the Coc-
coneidee are essentially distinct from the Naviculee, and ex-
hibit a decided analogy to the similarly epiphytic Amphoree,
inasmuch as in neither does the occurrence of the longi-
tudinal line exhibit anything to correspond with it in the
structure of the primordial cell. In the Amphoree and
Cocconeidee the endochrome-plate stands related to the surface
of attachment. The former attaches itself by one girdle-band,
and upon this plane lies the middle of the plate; the latter
are fixed to foreign bodies by one valve, on which the middle
of the plate lies. As respects the formation of auxospores,
in Achnanthidium it has never been discoyered, but in

RECENT RESEARCHES IN THE DIATOMACEZ, 33

Cocconeis frequently. Carter first found that two cells
secrete a gelatinous envelope, open, and by a true act of
copulation construct a single spore, which is first globular,
then becomes ellipsoid, and finally separates into two longi-
tudinal portions, each of which is an auxospore. On the
contrary, Smith maintained that a single cell pours out its
contents, and therefrom developes a single spore; but the
author adds that while Carter’s observations refer to Cocconeis
Pediculus, Smith refers to what he calls the nearly allied
species, Cocconeis Placentula. Liiders agrees in this point
with Carter, and Dr. Pfitzer confirms their position in regard
to C. Pediculus. The following differences are noticeable.
One supposes the separation has been completed within the
envelope, the other not tillit has been thrown off. According
to Carter the firstling-cells turn the concave sides one to
the other ; according to Liiders they are parallel. Dr. Pfitzer
observes that the material at his command was too young to
enable him to decide this question.

Gomphonemee.

In this are included three genera—1l. Sphenella; 2. Gom-
phonema ; 3. Rhoicosphenia. 'They are distinguishable by
the fact that in the general structure of the valves they re-
semble the Naviculee. Like the latter, the frustules possess
three nodules on each side, and two median-lines divided into
two parts by the centralnodule. Still they are unsymmetri-
cally constructed, the upper end being broader than the lower.
As the Achnanthee exhibit a want of symmetry in the axis
of separation, and the Cymbellee in the longitudinal axis,
the Gomphonemee are unsymmetrical in the transverse axis"
The two last-named groups are more closely related than has
been hitherto believed both in respect to the structure of their
valves and also of their cell-contents. On the one side
the Cymbellee so far as they are stipitate show a distinction
between the upper and under ends, which is not noticeable in
the case of valves exposed to the action of heat or in the free-
living forms; and on the other side the Gomphonemee are
unsymmetrical not only in the transverse axis, as was before
stated, but also in the longitudinal axis. In all, this feature
manifests itself in the structure of the primordial cell; in
some, in the structure of the valve itself. In Sphenedla
vulgaris, Kiitz., the valves are noticeably more decidedly con-
vex on one side than on the other; and in other cases in
which the margin of the valve appears symmetrical, the
sculpture on the two sides of the longitudinal line is different.
Tuffen West’s delineation of Gomphonema geminatum in

84. REV. E, O MEARA,

Smith exhibits on one side of the central nodule a group of
four or five separate depressions which do not occur on the
other side ; and this is a regular occurrence. Besides, the
median lines at the central nodule and the under end-nodule
bend toward the same side—namely, that in which the above-
mentioned depressions occur, and which are situated in a
well-defined area. At the upper-end nodule the median line
at first takes the same bend as at the other nodules, but
afterwards changes round to the opposite side, towards a
small space in which no depressions occur. ‘These peculiari-
ties render manifest the unsymmetrical character of the
valves. In many specimens the median line is bowed, how-
ever slightly, so as to present its concave side to the group
of depressions. In addition it is important to observe that
where these depressions le to the right on the upper valve,
they are found also on the right in the underlying valve.
So that the Gomphonemee are not diagonally constructed as
the Pinnularie are, but unsymmetrically on the homologous
sides, like Anomoeoneis and the Cymbellee. The structure
of the primordial cell corresponds: there is but one plasm-
band situated on the cell wall; only one endochrome-plate
occurs ; but while the former and the middle of the latter in
the Cymbellee lie on the more strongly-arched, we find them
in the somewhat unsymmetrical Gomphonemee (e.g., in Sphe-
nella vulgaris) on the less convex girdle-band. The central
plasm-mass is not so broad on the one side as it is on the
other, on which lies the nucleus and the turned-up edges
of the endochrome-plate, this is also the case in the greater
number of the Cymbellege. The endochrome-plate has the same
structure as in the last named, although its position differs to
the extent of 180 degrees. The division of the endochrome-
plate proceeds by an incision from the ends. The free edge
grows across the valve until the original position has been
reached. A transverse section of the Gomphonema-cell
would more clearly represent the relative position of the parts.
The genera Gomphonema and Sphenella are distinguished
from one another only by the circumstance that the frustules
in the former are stipitate, and non-stipitate in the latter,
which Pfitzer, following Grunow and Rabenhorst, considers
an inadequate generic distinction, for this reason, that the
stipitate forms occur free and with active motion. As respect
the substance of the stipes, it appears in this instance, as in
the case of Cocconema and Brebissonia, in its early stage as
a simple, colourless, well-defined gelatinous band ; but in its
more advanced stage of growth it presents a brownish central
thread, surrounded by a broad, colourless investment.

RECENT RESEARCHES IN THE DIATOMACEA, 85

As regards the construction of auxospores, Thwaites in-
forms us that in this genus, as well as that of Cymbella, two
mother-cells develope two auxospores lying parallel to them.
Thwaites made this observation in the case of a species
related to Gomphonema dichotomum, Sm.; in G. dichotomum,
G. tenellum, G. olivaceum ; Pfitzer, in the last-named species.
An actual union of the two primordial mother-cells does not
occur, but only a diffusing of the contents through the gelati-
nous investment. When the auxospores have nearly reached
their definitive length they develope a fine membrane,
within which the valves are formed one after the other.
They are at first strongly arched and bent on the longitudinal
axis ; the striation developes itself clearly in a direction pro-
ceeding from the centre towards the ends. The firstling-
cells at first have girdle-bands as narrow as those in Navicula,
the outer larger valve, even in its earlier stage, embracing
the smaller inner valve. After the second division, out of
the bent-valved firstling-cells spring normal cells with two
straight valves, just as in the case of Navicula. The plane
of separation in the firstling-cell is at a right angle to that of
the mother-cell from which it has sprung—the valves of the
former being seen when the girdle-band of the latter is turned
towards the observer.

Rhoicosphenia.

This may be regarded as a Gomphonema unsymmetrical
in its three dimensions. In addition to the want of symmetry
in the longitudinal and transverse axis, there occurs in this
genus a bending in the plane of separation, and also an un-
similarity of the two valves, of which one only—namely, the
concave—possesses a central nodule; besides, the fillets
which occur on the upper end of Gomphonema are here most
strongly developed. In the primordial cell no remarkable
distinction is found compared with Gomphonema; but it is
far otherwise with Achnanthes, Achnanthidium, and Cocconeis,
to which genera Grunow and Rabenhorst attachedit. Rho-
tcosphenia curvata (Kiutz.), Grun., and R. marina (Kiitz.),
possess a single endochrome-plate, the middle line of which
lies on the plane of one girdle-band, covering the two valves,
and even folding itself over upon the other girdle-band.
Viewed in this aspect it appears broken into four parts, the
division between two of these parts being observable on the
F.V. Normally this occurs in a Rhvicosphenia lying on one
valve on the same side of the upper and under valve. The
middle portion of the valves is for the most. part covered
with endochrome, which is not the case in Gomphonema, A

86 REV. E. O’MEARA.

slight indentation is observable at the ends of the plate, in
which there is an approach to the Cocconeidee, similarly
geniculated in the axis of division. The division of the
endochrome plate proceeds just as in the case of Gomphonema,
towards which genus many transition-forms from Rhoicos-
phenia tend.

The formation of auxospores was observed by Thwaites
in the case of R. curvata so early as 1847. This process
goes on precisely,as in Gomphonema, only the plasm-sac, ac-
cording to Thwaites, does not emerge at the side, but from an
opening at the end of the cell. Smith found the same species
as well as R. marina in conjugation. In the case of the form
last-named, Liiders has added the remark that the auxo-
spores before they have attained the length of the older cells
are invested with a very fine silicious coating, which exhibits
broad transverse strie. This investment is at first cy-
lindrical, but becomes bent in the firstling-cells, which issue
from it.

Vir.

_ The forms embraced in the four groups to be now con-—

sidered are placed by Dr. Pfitzer, in reference to themselves
and to other groups, in a relationship very different from
that assigned to them by most writers of authority on the
subject. The groups referred to are Amphipleuree, Plagio-
tropidee, Amphitropidee, and Niizschiee. Heiberg indeed
places the genus Amphipleura under that of Nitzschia, and
that because the species of the former family, which he had
specially examined, was that named by Smith A. sigmoidea
—a form which I believe to be identical with Nitschia
sigmoidea. So under the supposition that the form named
is to be properly regarded as really belonging to the genus
Amphipleura, he was quite right in the position he assigned
to it; but regarding Amphipleura pellucida as a genuine
type of the family, its position, according to Heiberg’s
system of classification, is widely apart. Grunow at first
placed Amphipleura among the Surirellee, but afterwards
made it the type of a distinct group, in which he included
Berkeleya., Pfitzer agrees with Grunow as to the compre-
hension of Berkeleya in the group, though he places the
group itself in a very different relation. The position of
Amphipleura, according to Ralfs, is between the Nitzschiee
and Surirellee. Rabenhorst placed it under the Navicu-
lacee in his Sissw. Diat., but subsequently, in Fl. Eur.
Alg., ranges it between the Synedree and MNitzschiee.

ee

RECENT RESEARCHES IN THE DIATOMACER. 87

According to Kiitzing, William Smith, and Professor H. L.
Smith, Amphipleura is assigned to a position more or less
intimately associated with the Naviculacee.

The two next groups, Plagiotropidee and Amphitropidee,
are intimately associated with the genus Amphiprora, Ehr.,
which has been regarded as nearly related to the Navicu-
lacee, but the allied forms are by Ptitzer associated with the
Nitzschiee. The character which these four groups possess
in common, and in consequence of which they are so inti-
mately associated by that author, is the development of
certain longitudinal lines into more or less prominent keels.
Whether this characteristic should be deemed a sufficient
reason to justify the arrangement referred to may be con-
sidered as liable to doubt; it is, however, important to keep
this common feature in view. ;

Let the author now speak for himself—

Amphipleuree, Grun.

This embraces two genera, Amphipleura, Kiitz., and
Berkeleya, Grev. The only European fresh-water form of
this group, distinguished from the Naviculee by the deve-
- lopment of the central nodule on one longitudinal line, and
the three keels of the valve—namely, Amphipleura pellucida
(Ehr.) Kiitz.—possesses two endochrome-plates lying on the
girdle-bands. A central plasm-mass is also observable. In
the process of constructing auxospores, only Berkeleya Dill-
wynit (Ag.), Grun., has been observed by Liiders. For this
purpose many cells unite in a common gelatinous envelop-
ment on the extremities of the tubes, or smaller expansions
arise on the sides and middle of the tubes ; two mother cells
then develope two auxospores. |

«The structures described by Kiitzing, Bac., p. 112, t.
23, f. ii, 2a be, as the fruit of Berkeleya tenuis (Kiitz.),
appear to me,” adds Pfitzer, “‘ not to belong to the Bacilla-
riacee at all.” It appears then that, so far as the internal
structure of the cell is concerned, Amphipleura bears a
strong resemblance to Navicula.

In case the character noted by Pfitzer—namely, the
development of a central nodule on one median line, by
which I understand its occurrence on one valve and not on
the other—be sustained by fact, the position of Amphipleura
will be seriously affected. In special reference to this
subject I have examined very many specimens of Amphi-
pleura pellucida and could observe no trace in any of a
central nodule.

88 REV. E, O’MEARA,

Plagiotropidee..

This embraces only one genus, Plagiotropis, gen. nov.
The development of the median lines into prominent keels,
which in the preceding group occurred to a slight extent, is
more strongly marked in the two to be next treated, in
which the six nodules appear again in the normal manner.
The only species to be here assigned which occurred to the
author in a living state was found in brackish water in the
harbour of Pillau, and is distinguished from the next related
genus, Amphiprora (Ehr.), by the position of the keel,
which, instead of being central, is strongly excentric; and
also by the disappearance of the prominent longitudinal
strie, which along with the same occur in all the Amphi-
proree. The valve of P. baltica is sharply lanceolate in
outline, resembling Navicula serians (Kitz.), in breadth
from one-fifth to one-sixth of its length; the keel describing
a gentle curve, not sigmoid, but, as in the Amphiproree,
sinking down at the central nodule to the plane of the valve
which it divides into two parts in the proportion of one to
four, so that it is very excentric. Supposing the Plagio-
tropis to lie so as to present its valve-surface to the observer,
on the upper valve the keel deviates towards the right, on ~
the under-valve towards the left, so that Plagiotropis, like °
Pinnularia, is diagonally constructed. The valves exhibit a
very fine striation, and when dry are nearly colourless.
The girdle-band view strongly resembles that of an Amphi-
prora, pretty much that of Amphiprora indica (Grun.), only
that the two keels obviously lie in different planes. The
inner structure is similar to that of Navicula. Two endo-
chrome-plates lie upon the girdle-bands, and thence with
their edges stretch to some extent over the valves. Each
plate covers the greater part of the valve from the keel of
which it has extended, the opposite margin going a shorter
distance towards the other keel. The structure of the soft
parts corresponds with the diagonal construction of the cell-
cover.

Amphitropidee.

In this group we have only a single form—Amphitropis
paludosa (Rab.), quere Amphicampa paludosa, Rab. F). Eur.
Alg., p. 257. The Amphitropidee, says Pfitzer, are related
to the Plagiotropidee somewhat as the Cymbellee, still sym-
metrical in outline, are to the Naviculee. The form of the
cell-cover differs little, but the inner structure is quite
different. The Amphitropis paludosa (W. Sm.) Rab., is dis-
tinguished by means of its sigmoid keels, constructed in

RECENT RESEARCHES IN THE DIATOMACES. 89

relation to one another, as in the case of Scoliopleura, as
also by the two accompanying longitudinal strie. It has
only a single endochrome-plate, lying on one girdle-band,
and with its margins reaching to the valves; fission takes
place from the ends throughout. A central plasm-mass is
obvious. Whether the similarly keeled genera, Amphiprora
(Ehr.) and Donkinia (Pritch.), belong to this or to the pre-
ceding group remains to be determined. Auxospores in all
these forms are still unknown. The concluding observation
of our author suggests the propriety of subjecting the
various related forms to a careful examination, with a view
to a satisfactory arrangement.

Nitzschiee (Grun.).

The forms hitherto treated of agree in this particular,
that, with the exception of the Epithemiee, which have a
very indistinct median line, they exhibit nodules and dis-
tinct median lines; and that the transverse section is rec-
tangular or trapezoid, except KHncyonema, in which case
it is slightly rhomboid. The Nitzschiee, on the contrary,
possess neither nodules nor median lines, and besides, their
transverse section is ever distinctly rhomboid. ‘This group
embraces three genera, Nitzschia, Ceratoneis, and Bacil-
laria,

Nitzschia.

In which we have species of a twofold structure, which
may be distinguished as similarly striate (gleichriefige) and
alternately striate (wechselriefige). The valves of every
Nitzschia exhibit on one margin a row of nodulated thick-
enings, called keel-puncta, which are situated in the two
valves either on the same or on opposite sides. All the
Nitzschiee examined possess a central granular plasm-mass,
in which a large nucleus may be distinguished, as also
a single endochrome-plate, either completely interrupted in
the middle, or nearly so by an elliptical opening.

The endochrome-plate in the case of the similarly striate
Nitzschiee, so far as the author has been able to investigate
(N. elongata (Hantzsch), N. flexa (Schum.), lies on one
girdle-band, and that the one which stands more remote
from the keel-puncta; it then covers the valve, and with
small folds extends to the opposite girdle-band. Some of
the alternately striate Nitzschiee—for example, N. palea
(Kiitz.), W. Sm., N. sigmoidea, W.Sm., N. Clausit, Hantzsch
—present the same position of the endochrome-plate, while
N. dubia, Hantzsch, and N. linearis (Ag.), W. Sm., differ
widely in the inner structure. In them the endochrome-

90 REV. E. O MEARA.

plate passes freely across the cell, reaching from one row of
keel-puncta to the other. When the frustule so stands as
that the keels are to the eye of the observer super-imposed
one on the other, a narrow dark brown longitudinal band
appears between two broad colourless ones. If, again, the
frustule lies on one obtuse-angled edge, it appears entirely
light yellow-brown. And again, if the frustule or one
girdle-band lie parallel to the slip on which the object les,
the colouring of the cell, which would naturally be white, is
of a somewhat darker hue, because the endochrome-plate
will be projected in a direction inclined to the plane of its
acute-angled side.

We have consequently among the Nitzchiee species with
the inner and outer structure symmetrically diagonal, some

having the silicious envelope and the soft inner parts unsym-

metrical to one another on the homologous sides ; and lastly,
intermediate forms in which the silicious envelope is dia-
gonal, and the inner structure unsymmetrical to it on the
homologous sides. The cell-division has been followed out
in Nitzschia elongata and N. sigmoidea. It commences with
a longitudinal division of the endochrome-plate from the
ends throughout, then the nucleus separates into two,
‘and the division of the plasm ensues. The daughter-cells at
first lie in the longitudinal axis of the cell, and then after a
time assume their natural position.

Ceratoneis, Ehr.

The minute forms, C. acicularis (Kitz.), Pritch., and C.
reversa (W. Sm.), Pritch., as regards their inner structure
differ in no respect from the normal Nitzschice, with a single
endochrome-plate lying on one girdle-band; but on the
contrary, C. longissima (Brib.), Pritch., exhibits numerous
minute plates.

Bacillaria.

The single cells of Bacillaria paradoxa, Gmel., have like-
wise a single endochrome-plate covering one girdle-band ;
nevertheless in the greater number of the cells of a colony
the endochrome-plate appears separated into two through
means of division. As respects the development of auxo-
spores in the Nitzschiee, we know only this, that Schuman
found a form belonging to Nitzschia with zone-covers
(zonenkleide). In addition to the coarse dark zones, there
was present also a system of fine longitudinal lines on the
sheath.

It is to be regretted that Dr. Pfitzer should have given
the authority of his justly-distinguished name to the revival

i

THE LYMPH SPACES IN FASCIA. 91

of the Ehrenbergian genus, Ceratoneis, for the purpose of
separating the forms embraced under it from the genus
Nitzschia, to which they belong. Grunow has well
described Ehrenberg’s genus, Ceratoneis, as a medley of
heterogeneous forms, and retained the generic name to
receive the single species = EHunotia arcus, W.Sm., in which
he is followed by Professor H. L. Smith. There may
indeed be good reason for retaining the generic name so
limited, but strong objections may be urged against the
genus as Ehrenberg and Kiitzing left it. Too much praise
cannot be given to Dr. Pfitzer for his observations on the
genus Nitzschia. No doubt the forms investigated by him
constitute but a small proportion of those comprehended
under this extensive family; but the structural characters
he has illustrated, in such as he has examined, may serve as
a clue to further investigations, and can scarcely fail to lead
to satisfactory results.—[From the ‘Journal of Botany.’]

The Lymrxu Spaces in Fascia; a New Metuop of Insxc-
tion. By H. P. Bownircu, M.D., Assistant Professor of
Physiology in Harvard University. ?

THE lymph spaces existing between the tendinous fibres
of fascize, and the connection of these spaces with lymphatic
vessels, have been well described and figured by Ludwig
and Schweigger-Seidel in their monograph on this subject.’

The researches of Dr. Genersich® have shown that the
fascize, in virtue of this structure, play a very important part
in keeping up the flow of lymph through the lymphatic
vessels. His first experiment was as follows :—A piece of
fascia was removed from the leg of a dog, and tied over the
mouth of a small glass funnel with the inner side (2. e. the
side next to the muscles) uppermost. A few drops of a tur-
pentine solution of the extract of alcanna root were then
placed upon this surface, and the fascia alternately stretched
and relaxed by partially exhausting the air from the funnel
and letting it return again. In this way the colouring
matter was made to penetrate into the spaces between the
fibres of the fascia, and to enter the lymph vessels on the
opposite side. The same result was obtained when the
colouring matter was injected between the muscle and the

' Reprinted from the ‘ Proceedings of the American Academy of Arts and
Sciences,’ Feb. 11th, 1873.

2 ‘Die Lymphgefiisse der Fascien und Sehnen.’ Leipzig, 1863.

3 © Arbeiten aus der Physiologischen Anstalt zu Leipzig.’ Vv. Jahrgang,.
p. 53.

92 DR. H. P. BOWDITCH.

fascia, and the latter stretched and relaxed by passive move-
ments of the limb. Experiments on animals where the flow
of lymph through the thoracic duct was measured showed
that passive movements of the limbs increased this flow in a
very striking manner. Galvanization of the muscles had a
similar but less powerful effect.

The alternate widening and narrowing of the lymph
spaces between the tendinous fibres seems therefore to cause
the absorption of the lymph from the neighbouring parts as
well as its onward flow into the lymph vessels, the valves in
these latter preventing, of course, a flow in the opposite
direction.

In this function of the fascie we may perhaps find an
explanation of the success of the Swedish movement-cure
and of all methods of treatment which involve passive move-
ments of the limbs, the removal of effete matters from the
tissues being favoured by an increased flow of lymph.

The turpentine solution of alcannine has several advan-
tages for the injection of lymph spaces. Since turpentine
does not mix with water, there is no possibility of the
colouring matter being diffused by imbibition through the
tissues, and thus obscuring the anatomical relations of the
parts. The same immiscibility prevents also all swelling or
shrinking of the tissues as a consequence of the injection.
This is alw ays tv be feared when watery or alcoholic fluids
are used.

A very good method of injecting the lymph spaces is as
follows :—Let a piece of fascia, carefully freed from loose
connective tissue, be stretched somewhat tightly over the
neck of a bottle. The point of a hypodermic syringe filled
with the turpentine solution must be then passed obliquely
into the fascia, care being taken that the point does not
penetrate entirely through. If the fluid is then forced from
the syringe, it will pass for a short distance into the lymph
spaces, but a large portion of it will form a sort of extrava-
sation in the neighbourhood of the point of injection.
Several such partial injections may be made near the border
of the piece of fascia, which must then be allowed to dry,
still stretched upon the neck of the bottle. In drying, the
tendinous fibres seem to shrink together, causing a dilata-
tion of the spaces between them, in consequence of which
the extravasated fluid is sucked onwards into the finest
lymph spaces. In this way two, three, or even four layers
of lymph spaces lying between as many different layers of
tendinous fibres may be clearly demonstrated. The dried
fascia may be mounted in Canada balsam between glass plates,

——— ee

REVIEW.

Natural History of the British Diatomacee. By ArtHur
Scorr Donxin. M.D. Part III. Van Voorst.

AFTER an interval of two years the second part of the
‘Natural History of the British Diatomacee,’ by Arthur
Scott Donkin, M.D., has been followed by the third, the
letter-press in all respects such as might be expected from
the publisher, Van Voorst, and the plates, although not
equal to those the readers of the ‘ Quarterly Journal of Micro-
scopical Science’ were accustomed to from the exquisite
pencil of the late Dr. Greville, are still fairly executed.

A great deal of useless and confusing nomenclature has
been advantageously discarded by the author, as an exempli-
fication of which the synonymy of NV. dimosa may be referred
to. Some few matters there are which require special notice.
Stauroneis pulchella has been removed from the genus
Stauroneis, and placed under the genus Navicula, under the
name of Navicula aspera.

This raises the question whether the genus Stawroneis
might not be altogether abandoned. ‘The characteristic is
the lateral expansion of the central nodule, so as to form
what has been designated a stauros. There is no species in
which this character is more marked than in that under con-
sideration ; and if this, notwithstanding, be removed to the
genus Navicula, there seems no valid reason why the other
species of the old genus Stawroneis should not be similarly
treated. Following Rabenhorst, Dr. Donkin has identified
Pinnularia Johnson, W. Sm., with Navicula scopulorum,
Bréb., and NV. mesotyla, Ehr. The two latter, judging from
the figures, are probably identical, but if Rabenhorst’s de-
scription of the former be correct, “gegen die gerundeten
enden Verlaufend,” it can scarcely be regarded as identical
with P. Johnsonii, the ends of which are expanded, as accu-
rately described in the figures of Smith and Donkin.

Amphiprora constricta, Ehr., has been removed from the
genus to which it has hitherto been assigned, and included
in the genus Navicula, under the name of Navicula semulans.
Smith’s description represents this form as more symmetrical
than it is in reality. The characters of the genus Amphi.

94. REVIEW.

prora are certainly not so strongly marked in this species as
in others, but in the specimens I have noticed the connecting
membrane is slightly diagonal, the lobes of the valve do not
lie in the same plane, nor is the central nodule of the upper
valve exactly superimposed on that of the under one. Com-
paring the figure of Navicula simulans, both on the side and
front views, with Smith’s figure of Amphiprora constricta,
I am disposed to doubt the identity, and to suppose that
Donkin’s form: is a new species.

Pinnularia Pandura, Bréb., has been correctly identified
with Navicula Crabro, Ehr., and N. nitida, Greg., as wellas
NV. didyma, var. costata, Greg., reduced to the same species
of which, at best, they are but varieties. The description of
the species is exactly as it appears under a low power ; striz
interrupted by a straight longitudinal groove into a broad
outer and a narrow inner section, the latter consisting of a
longitudinal row of conspicuous hemispherical dots ; with a
higher power the striz are traceable down through the groove
and emerge again, the extremities appearing as an elevated
ridge along the median line.

Dr. Donkin has greatly contributed to a more satisfactory
definition of the constricted forms of Navicula. Here there
has been great confusion, and though something more remains
to be done, there will henceforth be no difficulty in recog-
nising NV. Apis, N. Bombus, N. interrupta, not to mention
others.

EuGEnE O’MEara.

eS

QUARTERLY CHRONICLE OF MICROSCOPICAL
SCIENCE.

MICROZOOLOGY AND EMBRYOLOGY.

New Observations on Infusoria.—O. Birscui1, in
‘Schultze’s Archiv,’ vol. ix, 4th part, 1873, has an in-
teresting and important series of notes on the organiza-
tion and reproduction of Infusoria. He has studied species
of Paramecium and Amphileptus as to the question of
sexual reproduction. He points out that there is no suffi-
cient evidence to warrant the view which has practically
passed into a common-place of zoological teaching — that
the striated body seen both by Stein and Balbiani is a
testicle. He denies that there is reason to hold that this
fibrillated body breaks up into filaments, or that if it does that
these filaments should be considered to be spermatozoa. There
is no evidence that they pass over to the nucleus and fertilise
it in the way assumed either by Balbiani or Stein. Again,
he ‘is not satisfied as to the nature of the viviparously pro-
duced acinetiform young said to be developed from the
nucleus. He failed to find them in a long series of observa-
tions on Paramecium, and thinks it still possible that they
are parasitic, or, at any rate, not the normal development of
the ripe nucleus. The structure of the nucleus he describes
in several cases, and fully demonstrates for it—in the ripe
condition—a multicellular structure. The nucleolus never
presented any trace of a finer structure—and_Biitschli
seems inclined to regard the striated capsular bodies (testes
of Balbiani, Stein, and others), not as metamorphosed nu-
cleoli, but as parts of the altered nucleus, the signification
of which is not understood. There is, no doubt, much justice
in the position taken up by Butschli, and his critical notes and
observations cannot fail to excite new inquiry. Is it too
much to hope that English microscopists will do some serious
work in this matter ?

Biitschli further notes the occurrence of an amyloid sub-
stance in Gregarina Blattarum, in Nyctotheres which accom-
panies it, and in a marine Infusorian—Strombidium sulcatum.

He also gives a minute account and figure of the structure
of the trichocysts in an Infusorian Polykrikos Schwartz.
From this there remains no possibility of regarding the

96 QUARTERLY CHRONICLE OF MICROSCOPICAL SCIENCE.
trichocysts as anything but identical with the nematocysts of
Coelenterata. Biitschli argues that their occurrence is no
reason for doubting that the Infusorian body is of unicellular
character, since we may compare a single ectodermal cell
of Hydra witha single Infusorian, and we find that nemato-
cysts have the same relations to the protoplasm in both cases,
developing in Hydra as in an Infusor, simply in the proto-
plasm, independently of the nucleus, and independently of
anything like cellular elements. In fact, the nematocysts of
both Infusoria and Hydrozoa are striking examples of the
great generalisation, that the phenomena of life, whether ex-
hibited in the building up of structure or in the transforma-
tion of.energy, are solely dependent on the life-stuff—pro-
toplasm—and that the corpuscular or cellular condition of
that life-stuff is a secondary accident.

A new Infusorian, Wagneria cylindroconica.—In the
first part of vol. x of ‘Schultze’s Archiv’ Wladimir Alen-
itzen describes a new Infusorian under the above name.
The interest of this form, which was found in the mud of
the Newa, consists in its presenting the two circlets of cilia
characteristic of the Vorticellidan Zrichodina, &c., whilst
at the same time its pharynx anda little capitular prominence,
together with the position of the contractile vesicle, render
it similar to such genera as Prorodon and Lacrymaria.

The Morphology of the Infusoria.—Professor Haeckel, in
the ‘ Jenaische Zeitschrift,’ vol. vii, part 4, 1873, discusses
in his clear methodical style the question of the unicellular
nature of the Infusoria. Both he and Gegenbauer have
been inclined at one time to regard the ciliate Infusoria as
disguised multicellular organisms. Haeckel, however, now
gives in fully his adhesion to the view that they present
nothing comparable to cell-differentiation. He gives a his-
tory of the views which have been held on the matter, and
now demonstrates, from the known facts of the development
of the Infusoria, that they are units of the first* order of
aggregation—simple corpuscles of protoplasm, and not mul-
tiples of such corpuscles. The whole morphology of the
class is passed in review, and the various structures and
organs presented by Infusoria are put in their true light.
Finally, a revision of the classification of the Protozoa is

iven.

New Shell-bearing, Surface-swimming, Marine Infusoria,
—In a second chapter of the same paper Haeckel describes
very curious and beautiful forms of ciliate Infusoria, which
come nearest to the genus Z’ntinnus of Claparéde and Lach-
mann. Haeckel forms two families for them in the order

-——- = —-

QUARTERLY CHRONICLE OF MICROSCOPICAL SCIENCE. 97

Peritricha, viz. Dictiocystida, and Codonellida. Déctyocysta
has a fenestrated siliceous cell exactly like that of a Radio-
larian, of the Cystidan group, but the animal which hangs
from this basket is a ciliate Infusorian with large cilia on the
peristome. Codonella has a more delicate bell-like shell and
a very curious structure of the peristome. Nucleus and
vacuoles are figured init. The species of these genera were
observed by Haeckel at Messina in 1859 and 1860, and
others at Lanzarote in 1866 and 1867. ‘The species of Tin-
tinnus aud Tintinnopsis described by Claparéde and Lachmann
are representatives of the same interesting families. We
might most nearly, perhaps, indicate the condition of these
Infusoria to the reader by comparing them to a Cothurnia
or Vaginicola whose sheath has become detached from its
support, so that the animal now swims hanging from the
sheath like the tongue of a bell.

A new Ameboid Organism from Fresh Water, Pelomyxa
palustris—In the same number of the same journal Dr.
Richard Greef, of Marburg, describes at length the very in-
teresting amceboid organism which he was known to have
under observation, and for which he some time since pro-
posed the name Pelobius. This name was intended as a
pair to Bathybius, but has to be abandoned since it is in use
for an insect, and, moreover, the similarities between Pelo-
myxa and the structure known as Bathybius are not so close
as Greef at one time supposed. Pelomyzais figured in three
plates, and, as its discoverer remarks, has great similarity to
the plasmodium of some Myxomycetes, which it may very
possibly prove actually to be. It has been found in old
ponds at Popplesdorf, near Bonn, and also more recently
near Marburg. The amceboid masses are large, often dark
brown in colour, protruding lobose hyaline pseudopodia. ‘The
ground substance contains numerous nuclei, hyaline, homo-
geneous, highly refractive bodies, and delicate rod-like bodies.
Under certain conditions the Pelomyzxa mass gives rise to
large swarms of minute Ameebe, which Greef followed in
some cases to a flagellate, freely-swimming condition. Greef
regards Pelomyxa as a multicellular, or, rather, multi-
nuclear amveboid organism, allied to the Myxomycetes, but
to be classed under the Rhizopoda.

News of Bathybius.—The reference which Greef makes
in his paper to Bathybius, and the continual references in
zoological writings to that profoundly interesting structure,
makes it desirable to record the latest information which has
come to hand bearing upon that supposed organism. It must
be remembered that the Bathybius of to-day is not Huxley’s

VOL. XLV.—NEW SER. G

98 QUARTERLY CHRONICLE OF MICROSCOPICAL SCIENCE.

Bathybius, but Haeckel’s. Professor Huxley suggested the
association of the coccoliths and coccospheres with the albu-
minoid slime which he clearly demonstrated to exist in spe-
cimens of Atlantic ooze, and which gives to that ooze a pecu-
liar glairy character. Professor Haeckel removed the
coccoliths from association with this albuminous material,
showing that they were either formed in a, Radiolarian fre-
quenting the surface, or were independent surface-organisms
taken inas food near the surfaceby that Radiolarian. Therere-
mained, then, the albuminous ooze-cement, which Professor
Haeckel still considered as a definite organism, and of which
he gave some drawings in the form of networks derived from
the study of Atlantic ooze preserved inalcohol. Noone would
certainly be more willing to admit than both Professor Huxley
and Professor Haeckel, that Bathybius now became a very sug-
gestive subject for investigation, but could not be admitted asa
satisfactorily established independent organism. The deep-
sea explorations of the Lightning and Porcupine brought
no news of Bathybius. To establish its claim, what was ob-
viously necessary was the observation of it in fresh ooze,
inthe living state. Professor Wyville Thomson, in his ‘ Depths
of the Sea,’ is exceedingly cautious in dealing with Bathybwus.
He gives a graphic account of the presence of this slimy
matter, and he also says it may be seen in movement, but not
that he has himself seen it. He also speaks of “ the viscid
streams” of Bathybius, but has not stated that he has himself
witnessed the phenomenon of ‘ streaming’ in the albuminous
slime in question. Finally, he states that he is by no means
satisfied that Bathybius is the permanent form of any distinct
living being. Different samples differ in appearance and
consistence, and Professor Thomson thinks it not impossible
that a great deal of ‘ bathybius’ is a formless condition, con-
nected either with the growth and multiplication or with the
decay of many different things. From the Challenger we
hear that one of the naturalists has paid great attention
to the ooze, with the object of ‘making out’ Bathybius.
He finds that the Globigerina mud is fuli of the pseudo-
podia of that Foraminifer, worked up more or less into
a general slime. When alcohol is added to this the pseu-
dopodial matter is precipitated, and this is the precipi-
tate figured by Haeckelas Bathybius. If large living spe-
cimens of the Foraminifera are separated by the sieve from the
mud, and then placed in alcohol, a similar precipitate is ob-
tained. So far, the prospect is not very hopeful for the
ultimate success of Bathybius. But it would be a mistake
to give up the hypothesis as yet. Professor Edouard van

QUARTERLY CHKONICLE OF MICROSCOPICAL SCIENCE. 99

Beneden, who recently spent some time on the coast of Brazil,
had the intention of making a special investigation of the
Bathybian question, and his results have not yet been
announced.

Development of the Mollusca.—The embryology of the
Mollusca is beginning to find students in Germany. In the
‘Niederlandisches Archiv fiir Zoologie,’ vol. i, part 1,-is a
paper by Dr. Emil Selenka, the editor, on the “ First Forma-
tion of the Embryo in Tergipes claviger,” illustrated by a
plate. In part 2 the same author has a paper on “ The
Primitive Layers of the Embryo in Purpura lapillus,” also
well illustrated. Both these papers belong to the newer
embryology; that is to say, the author occupies himself with
the exact following out of the origin and disposition of the
cellular elements of the embryo. In his paper on Purpura
Dr. Selenka proposes to distinguish two modes of formation
of the blastoderm—* epiboly”’ and “emboly.” The former
is accompanied by the presence of a large food-yelk, and the
egg is consequently meroblastic, or partially so. The first
formative cells grow over the partially segmented or wholly
unsegmented coloured yelk. In emboly the egg is holo-
blastic, and a pushing in of the cells of the primitive blasto-
sphere takes place.

Dr. Salensky, of Kasan, has a paper with several plates,
on “‘ The Development of the Prosobranchiata,” in ‘ Kolliker
und Siebold’s Zeitschrift, 4th part for 1872, which has
much interesting matter on the “ Veliger” larval-form of
various genera, but does not deal with histogenesis.

The Development of Gastropoda opisthobranchiata is the
title of a paper by Dr. Paul Langerhans in the same journal,
part 2 for 1873, in which some points in the early develop-
ment of Acera bullata, Doris sp., and diolis peregrina are
shortly treated from the point of view of the germ-layer
theory.

Development of Rotifera.—The paper by Dr. Salensky, of
Kasan, on ‘‘The Development of the Rotifer Brachionus
urceolaris,’ of which we gave last year a brief notice, is pub-
lished in full, with a coloured plate, in ‘ Koll. und Sieb.
Zeitschrift,’ 1872, 4th part.

Development of the Bryozoa. —Dr. Heinrich Nitsche, in the
same journal, has an interesting note apropos of Metschni-
koff’s observations on the development of Alcyonella. Nitsche
has made a detailed study of this at Leipzig, and we may
anticipate a memoir from him on the subject. Meanwhile
Professor Smitt points out that in relation to certain repro-
ductive processes he has been misunderstood by Nitsche,

100 QUARTERLY CHRONICLE OF MICROSCOPICAL SCIENCE,

owing, as he supposes, to the difficulties of the Swedish
language. We may hope. that Professor Smitt will add
himself to the number of those Scandinavian naturalists—
including Mr. G. O. Sars and Professor Thorell—who have
recently adopted the English language for the purposes of
scientific publication.

The Formation of the Ovum, Fate of the Germinal Vesicle,
and First Appearance of the Blastoderm in the Bony Fishes
and other Vertebrata——We are not able to do more on the
present occasion than draw the reader’s attention to the

important work and controversy which is going on upon ”

these questions.

The papers of Dr. Oellacher are to be found in ‘ Schultze’s
Archiv,’ vol. viii, part 1, and a more recent paper in ‘ Koll.
und Siebold’s Zeitschrift,’ vol. xxiii, 1873.

Van Bambecke has published in ‘Comptes Rendus,’ t.
lxxiv. No. 16, April, 1872, a paper entitled ‘* Premiers effets
de la fécondation sur les ceufs des poissons,” &c.

Professor His has published a separate work at Leipzig,
lavishly illustrated, on the structure and mode of growth of
the egg of bony fish.

Dr. Goette treats of the same general questions in a paper
in ‘Schultze’s Archiv,’ vol. ix, 4th part, 1873. References
to the earlier papers of Stricker, Klein, &c., are given in the
above papers.

PROCEEDINGS OF SOCIETIES.

Royat Microscorican Socrery.

June 4th, 1873.
Caarters Brooxrs, Esq., F.R.S., President, in the chair.

A paper was read by Mr. Kitton, of Norwich, on “ Aulaco-
discus formosus, Omphalopelta versicolor, &c.’’ giving an account
of certain species of Diatomacezx, some of them new, from the
harbours of Peru and Bolivia.

Mr. J. W. Stephenson took the opportunity of stating that to
his surprise, he found that the mode of dividing the cone of
light in his erecting binocular microscope by means of two prisms
was used by Professor Riddell, of New Orleans, in the year 1853,
in his form of binocular. The arrangement of that instrument
differed, however, from his own in certain respects. He had only
just heard of Professor Riddell’s invention.

Mr. Stephenson then read a,paper entitled “Observations on
the Inner and Outer Layers of Coscinodiscus when Examined in
Bisulphide of Carbon and in Air.” The paper introduced a
method of “ Determining the structure of minute organisms
by means of the refractive indices of the media in which they
areexamined.” Attention had lately been drawn to this method
by Mr. Charles Stewart, who had applied it to determine the com-
position of specules in Echinodermata. Its result in the preseut
instance was to show that the central spot in certain hexagonal
areole of Coscinodiscus was really a perforation and not a de-
pression or elevation.

October 1st, 1878.
C. Brooxs, Esq., F.R.S., President, in the chair.

A paper was read by Dr. Maddox “On an Organism found
in Fresh-pond water.” These bodies, found in a small pond in
the New Fforest, appear to belong to the Protozoa. They con-
sist of irregularly circular or sub-globular sarcodic or muco-
gelatinous masses, often very bright at the edge, containing small
granular or corpuscular bodies of various sizes and of a highly
refracting nature, the whole having a very strong violet or lilac
tint when seen by transmitted light. The masses differ very con-
siderably in dimensions, the smallest containing only a few of the
capsules, the largest avery great number. In many of the
medium size and most, if not all, of the larger ones, the general

102 PROCEEDINGS OF SOCIETIES.

mass appeared to be vacuolated, often very irregularly, with the
outlines of the vacuoles indistinct, or rather ill defined. Upon
long watching, the relation of these to each other might now
and then be seen to alter, yet there was no appearance of pulsa-
tion. In only those examples were any projections noticed having
the character of pseudopodial protrusions, and these were ex-
ceedingly delicate, short, and seemed ill-fitted for progression of
the masses in the ordinary manner of pseudopods. There was a
slight change of general shape, but no complete revolution. No
motion was seen in the imbedded masses. Some of the masses
appeared to have a certain tendency to diffluence ; in others, the
substance was condensed into a distinct structureless cell mem-
brane or cell envelope. When this was ruptured, the small
granules or corpuscles were set free and moved about much after
the fashion of mobile zoospores. The author finds it difficult to
relegate these bodies to any definite place amongst either the
Phytozoa or Protozoa, though they fall he thinks more nearly to
the naked Rhizopoda. ’

A paper by Mr. Kitton of Norwich, on some new species of
Diatomacez, was taken as read. The species described were
from the genera Aulacodiscus, Stictodiscus, Isthmnia, Nitzschia,
Tryblionella.

Mr. Wenham made some remarks upon the microscopical
effects produced upon glass, by which the “sand-blast process,”
which was exhibited at the recent meeting of the British Asso-
ciation. ;

Mr. Stewart exhibited under the microscope a specimen of a
spermatophore of the common squid (Loligo vulgaris).

November 5th, 1873.
Cartes Brooks, Esq., F.R.S., President, in the chair.

A paper was read by the Rev. W. H. Dallinger and Dr. J.
Drysdale on some further researches into the Life History of the
Monads.

The authors have succeeded in making out the life history of
three forms which they believe to be hitherto undescribed,

The form which they specially notice is met with in vast num-
bers in the putrefying fluid resulting from the maceration of
any of the Gadide. Its average length is about 5,'55th of an
inch, its form oval and it is furnished with flagella. 1t exhibits
a remarkable mode of fission, by close observation of which (with
a =th of an inch object glass), the authors arrived at the life
history thus summarised. The usual method of multiplication .
is by fission, which goes on apparently to exhaustion. Amongst
enormous numbers there are a few distinguished from the others
by a slight increase in size, and the power to swim freely. These
become still ;—for a time amceboid—then round; a small cone of
sarcode shoots out dividing and increasing with another part of
flagella. The disk splits, each side becomes possessed of a nuclear

MEDICAL MICROSCOPICAL SOCIETY. 103

body, and two well-formed monads are set free. These swim
freely until they attach themselves to an ordinary form that has
just completed fission, so that the nuclei are approximate. Sar-
code and nuclei melt into cach other; the form becomes free,
swimming and irregular in shape—rests—loses its flagella; be-
comes clear and distended ; then bursts at the angles, pouring out
indescribably minute granules from which myriads of new forms
arise and repeat the cycle.

Mr. Alfred Sanders read a paper “On the Art of Photo-
graphing Microscopic Objects,” in which he showed that the
costly apparatus and elaborate arrangements frequently regarded
as essential to success might readily be dispensed with, and the
most satisfactory results obtained with appliances of the simplest
kind.

Mr. 8S. J. M‘Intire read a paper entitled “ Notes on Acarellus,”
in which he described certain insects found parasitic upon Obisiwm,
and closely resembling the Hyopus of the Micrographic Dic-
tionary, and the insect mounted by Mr. Topping under the name
of “ Parasite of House-fly.” The paper was illustrated by draw-
ings and specimens, both alone and mounted.

Mepicat Mroroscopicat Socrery.

The following is an abstract of Mr. Hogg’s paper read ata
previous meeting of the Society on “ the Pathological Relations of
the Diphtheritic Membrane and the Croupous Cast.”

Much misapprehension rests on this subject; some practi-
tioners decide at once on what they believe to be the character of
the membrane. Other authorities, as, for instance Sir T. Watson,
give in their adhesion to the unity of all membranous affections.
Although the epidemic of diphtheria in 1858 and 1859 attracted
much attention to the subject, and many specimens were exhibited
by members of the Pathological Society of London, very conflict-
ing statements were made about their histological character. In
the author’s opinion, the diseases are very different. ‘‘ While one
disease, diphtheria, is most decidedly epidemic and endemic, often
wide-spreading and affecting a large proportion of adults, and
probably belonging to a specific form of fever; the other, croup,
is essentially sporadic, often a local affection, not communicable,
or only so in a small degree, as when a family predisposition
exists, mostly occurring in childhood, and rarely after it is fairly
passed.” Histologically, also, he maintains that a sharp line can be
drawn between the diphtheritic membrane and the croupous cast.

As to the naked-eye appearances, the diphtheritic membrane is
a dense compact, opaque, yellowish-white or reddish-grey coloured

104 PROCEEDINGS OF SOCIETIES,

mass, of from half a line to five or six lines in thickness. It is
usually firmly adherent to the subjacent membrane, upon which it
is moulded ; is more or less friable, so that when traction is made
upon it with a pair of forceps, it comes away piecemeal, or in a
Jayer somewhat resembling felt or chamois leather. If forcibly
detached, a breach of surface is made, and bleeding generally
follows its separation, as the mucous membrane is much
congested.

The croupous cast, on the other hand, is semitransparent,
delicate, and tender to handle, often gelatinous or white-of-egg-
like, and of a pale yellow colour; easily separable from the sub-
jacent surface, as an imperfect cast of the part on which it is
formed, and never so closely connected with it, as to cause bleed-
ing when removed. It is, in short, a simple epithelial layer closely
resembling the skin shed by some of the lower animals—an out-
growth of epithelial cells undergoing degeneration of protoplasm
and entangling granular molecules.

As to the histological characters, in diphtheria the normal
tissues are seen to be replaced by an aggregation of compressed

cells, molecules of fat, connective or fibrous tissue, a few crystals —

muco-purulent or granular corpuscles, foreign bodies as starch
granules, or other portions of food, and spores of Oidium
albicans. It is surmised, therefore, that the felt-like membrane
is made up of superficial and deep tissues ; mucous membranes,
voluntary and involuntary muscles, and glands, and produces
great tension and decomposition, or ulcerative destruction. Not
a trace of columnar epithelium was seen in any specimen. ;

The croupous cast is seen under the microscope to consist of
pavement and cylindrical or columnar epithelium, and is a trans-
parent albuminous substance entangling the scattered contents of
epithelial cells, molecular matters, fat and mucous corpuscles,
and a few foreign bodies, as starch, granules involved in a homo-
geneous matrix. The columnar epithelium retains its cilia, each
cell being filled with clear protoplasmic and nucleated contents.
Fungus spores are rarely found in these films, which appear to
partake of the nature of an extensive cell proliferation rather
than of a transudation or true exudation.

The objects were partly examined in the fresh state, partly
stained and dried; fine sections being then made and mounted
in dammar or Canada balsam.

DUBLIN MICROSCOPICAL CLUB. 105

Dustin Microscorroan Croup.
26th June, 1873.

Synedra investiens, W. Sm. exhibited—Rerv. E. O’Meara
showed a slide of Synedra investiens (W.Sm). He had found this
form in Kingstown Harbour, where he believed it had been found
by Captain Crozier ; recently, too, Mr. O’Meara had found it on
seaweeds collected by him at Howth.

Microscopie Finger.—Dr. J. Barker showed a “ microscopic
finger” he had himself constructed after the American model, with
certain improvements, and spoke of some modifications he had
been thinking of to effect certain further improvements, so as to
cause the prehension of the object to be effected by a purely ver-
tical, not sweeping, action; he hoped to experiment ere long in
carrying out these alterations.

Conjugated state of Desmidium Swartzii.—Mr. Crowe re-
corded the occurrence of the conjugated state of Desmidium
Swartz, a very common desmid, but very rarely found show-
ing zygospores. In fact, it does not seem to have presented
itself to any members of the Club in that condition since the
occasion on which it was recorded by Mr. Archer, 18th May,
1867. The figure given by Ralfs is very graphic, though,
ag pointed out on that occasion, ¢wo filaments are really con-
jugated and the spores formed from the combined contents of
two distinet apposed joints, not, as Ralfs supposed, owing to the
extremely close juxtaposition of the pair of flat-sided fila-
ments, by the mere consolidation of the contents of a single
joint.

; Green Epistylis.—Mr. Porte showed fine examples of the green
Epistylis commonly found growing on the shells of aquatic snails.

Reade’s Prism.—Mr. Robinson exhibited some beautifully
mounted diatoms by the aid of ‘Reade’s prism,’ which, however,
was not pronounced so satisfactory as that of Amici, which he had
shown to the Club on a recent occasion.

Hairs from flower of Cypripedium caudatum.—Dr. Moore
showed the hairs from the flower of the curious Cypripedium
caudatum. The hairs seemed of two sorts—colourless, rather
stout threads, with clavate ends, and more attenuated threads, with
light red contents, these together forming the pretty pile apparent
to the unaided eye.

29th July, 1873.

Funqus on Sanguisorba-leaf.imMr. Crowe showed Xenodochus
carbonarius, a fungus found on Sanguisorba-leaf forwarded b
Rev. J. H. Vize; the elegant moniliform arrangement of the cells
caused it to form an interesting object.

New Stand for Amici’s Prism.—Mr. Porte showed a new
arrangement by means of two “ ball-and-socket’”’ joints and

106 PROCEEDINGS OF SOCIETIES.

“telescopic” stem for mounting Amici’s prism, which he had
devised and constructed, and which he found in use a very conve-
nient form of stand ; he thought this could be produced by makers
more cheaply than the ordinary stand. He was strongly in fayour
of this illumination, as both readily managed as well as highly
effective in showing the test markings of critical diatoms, and
hence as valuable in ordinary use.

Diatomella Balfouriana exhibited—Mr. Porte showed Dia-
tomella Balfouriana taken at Killarney on a late excursion
thither ; this diatom was in Mr. O’Meara’s experience rather a
rare one.

Corrigendum in reference to locality for Tryblionella debilis, Arn.
—Rev. E. O’Meara desired to correct an error which had crept
into the “ Minutes” in reference to the record of Tryblionella
debilis, Arnott (see the Club Minutes of 2nd Nov., 1872), which
was quoted asfound by Dr. Arnott in “S. Brittany,” in place of
“ North Britain,” having been found at Mary-Hill Bridge, Glas-
gow. For this correction the Club is indebted to its corresponding
member, Mr. Kitton.

Navicula spectatissima (?) from Seychelles.—Rev. E. O’Meara |
exhibited a Mavicula which he considered identical with JV. specta-
tissima, Grev. The striation is precisely the same as that of
Greville’s form, but the marginal portion not by any means so
wide, and the edges not waved. Only two specimens were found
in the gatherings from the Seychelles.

Dasydytes antenniger, Gosse, and Chetonotus gracilis, Gosse,
exhibited for the first time as Irish—Mr. Archer showed, side
by side, examples of the seemingly rare forms of “ hairy-
backed” animalcules Dasydytes antenniger, Gosse, and Che-
tonotus gracilis, Gosse. The former he had never happened
to notice before, and the latter only rarely. Both occurred
in gatherings from Co. Westmeath; they were both rare to
Gosse himself, he having seen but one specimen of C. gracilis,
and D. antenniger occurred but once to him in a pond near
Leamington. - They are both very elegant creatures. C. gracilis
is large and long, elegantly marked, comparatively slow and very
graceful in its movements as it glides about hither and thither;
the much more minute D. antenniger is a headlong and restless
swimmer, very difficult to catch a steady view of. Luckily on
the present occasion one was caught in a little vacant enclosure
amongst the dirt on the slide, and a good view was obtained. The
creature seemed to have the power to depress and elevate the
“ antenne.”

Anthoceros levis exhibited for the first time as Irish—Pro-
fessor Lindberg, of Helsingfors, with whose company the Club
was honoured on this occasion, showed specimens of Antho-
ceros levis taken by himself and Dr. Moore (on a recent journey
to Cos. Kerry and Cork,) at Ventry, this being the first occasion
of this species being found in Ireland. Dr. Lindberg showed the
minutely verrucose spores, with their elaters, under the micro-

DUBLIN MICROSCOPICAL CLUB. 107

scope, and explained the peculiarities of structure of this
genus.

Minute egg-shaped deposits on shell of hen’s egg—Mr. Ro-
binson showed a portion of the shell of a hen’s egg having
a group of little egg-shaped deposits on its surface, crowded
densely, which when viewed under a moderate power looked
wonderfully like a group of full-sized real eggs. Such little
deposits are occasionally seen on egg-shells.

28th August, 1873.

Diatoms from Hot Springs of Azores.—Rev. E. O'Meara
brought before the meeting the general results of his examination
of some collections, from Hot Springs and some way-side
streams in Azores collected by Mr. Mosely, of the Challenger
expedition. The majority of the sediments, in the form of
solid lumps, from the former, contained no diatomaceous forms ;
however, one of these, described as found floating on the
surface of the Lake of Furnas, and producing a tough mass like
india rubber, but tenacious, contained diatoms in abundance.
The gatherings put up in bottles with spirit, whether from the
hot or cold water, produced diatoms, but of the common British
kinds. The collections which were of the most interest were
those from the very hot water, inasmuch as from such a habitat it
was to be expected some light would be thrown on the question
as to what high temperature can the lower organisms, animal and
vegetable, endure without detriment. The following diatoms,
amongst alge and some desmids, occurred in these hot-water
gatherings :—Synedra lumaris, Pinnularia gibba, Himantidium
arcus, Cymbella affinis, Gomphonema tenellum, G. dichotomum.

Alge and Rhizopoda from Hot Springs of Azores.—Mr. Archer
showed several forms of Alge met with by him in the same
gatherings from Agores collected by Mr. Mosely. Amongst
these were not only, as would be to be expected, phycochro-
maceous forms, but also chlorophyllaceous, both filamentous
and unicellular. None of the former could be specifically identified,
as not any examples were seen in a fertile condition. Amongst
these were species of Conjugate—Spirogyra, Mesocarpus (most
probably); various Desmidiex; of Gidogoniee— Cidogoniwm, Bulbo-
chate; of Coleochzetex— Coleochete ; of Scytonemez —Tolypothriz ;
of unicellular forms—Botryococcus Braunii, and others ; various
Pediastree ; also Ankistrodesmus falcatus. Not only were there
these alge, but the remains of various Rhizopoda occurred—Areella
aculeata (so called), Trinema acinus, Euglypha alveolata, one or two
Difflugie ; Dinobryon sertularia also occurred. Thus in this hot
water occurred so many forms equally met with in our home cool
pools. How high the temperature exactly of Furnas Lake, whence
these emanated, was not certain. Mr. Mosely, having at the
time no means of taking the temperature, seems to quote from
other sources the temperature of this lake as ranging from 22°

-108 PROCEEDINGS OF SOCIETIES.

to even as much as 90°C. The form-species in the gatherings,
or those whose identity is recognisable without fructification,
were absolutely the same in every respect to their congeners at
home; so, no doubt, would the others prove to be, had they been
in fruit. Mr. Archer hoped to revert on another occasion to
the forms which had presented themselves in this interesting
gathering.

Crystals from a Cactus.—Dr. Moore showed crystals from the
cells of an unknown species of Cactus, of handsome appearance,
probably of oxalate of lime; they produced rotund groups, the
crystals radiating from a common centre, their facetted extremi-
ties forming the superficies of the globe. Mr. Tichborne under-
took to examine these in a chemical point of view.

Ameboid movements of corpuscles of frogs blood.—Mr. B.
Wills Richardson made a very satisfactory demonstration of the
‘amceboid’ movements of the white corpuscles of the frog’s
blood and of the corpuscles charged with refractive granules.
The movements were truly amceboid and highly characteristic ;
the refractive granules likewise were seen in active motion in each
amceboid mass containing them. Several of these were seen to
move across the field, and in doing so passed, on more than one
occasion, either over or under stationary red blood-corpuscles.
Two of the granule-containing amceboid corpuscles, when moving
in opposite directions across the field, came in contact with one
another. Their apposed surfaces then became parallel, and the
corpuscles themselves were carefully watched by some of the
members present to see if they would “conjugate’’ or coalesce.
Instead of doing so, however, they immediately separated, and each
retraced its course to the portion of the field whence it came.. .
The stage used for the occasion was an ordinary Stricker’s hot-
stage, made and slightly modified for Mr. Richardson by Spencer,
of Grafton Street, Dublin. The blood, when taken from the frog,
was at once placed on the glass and with a very thin cover. To
prevent evaporation a little spermaceti oil was applied with a
fine sable pencil to the margin ; this was done sparingly and very
carefully, in order that the oil might not runin. The objective
used was 4” Ross, but probably a +1," or 5" would be a better
power for demonstrating the movements of the refractive
granules to those who might be inexperienced in microscopical
observation.

MEMOIRS.

ConrrisuTions fo the ANATOMY of the SYMPATHETIC GANGLIA
of the BuappER in their Retation to the VascuLAR
System. By Francis Darwin. (With Plates V and VI.)

Tue work which forms the basis of this paper was under-
taken at the laboratory of the Brown Institution, at the
suggestion and under the supervision of Dr. Klein ; and it is
a pieasure to me to express my great obligation to him for
the kind manner in which he has in every way aided me.

In Cohnheim’s latest work on Inflammation (‘ New Re-
searches on Inflammation,’ by Dr. Julius Cohnheim, Berlin,
1873) he describes the dilatation which may be produced in
the vessels of the frog’s tongue by the direct irritation of that
organ. And in his discussion as to the manner in which the
phenomena are produced, he states his opinion that there is
no reflex mechanism effected by peripheral ganglion cells,
*< for, in the first place, such ganglia are not demonstrated as
yet, and, in the second place, no case is known in which
reflex action takes place independently of the central nervous
system.” It is with the first of these reasons only that we
are at present concerned. It is undoubtedly true that no such
ganglia have been as yet pointed out in the frog’s tongue, but
in other organs they have been demonstrated. Dr. Lionel
Beale, in the ‘ Philosophical Transactions’ for 1863, has
described and figured cells of this nature; fig. 46, plate xl,
represents ‘‘a portion of the coat of a branch of the iliac
artery of the frog ; upon the surface external to the muscular
fibres are seen some ganglion cells in process of development
with their fibres, which ramify upon the muscular coat.” Dr.
Beale also says, in the ‘ Monthly Microscopical Journal’ for
August, 1872, p. 57, “ In the bladder of the frog I have been
able to follow fine nerve-fibres from the ganglia both to
arteries and capillary vessels.” In another place Dr. Beale
says that similar fibres may be traced in small mammals,

VOL. XIV. H

110 4 FRANCIS DARWIN.

from the ganglia situated between the mucous and muscular
coats of the intestine to capillary vessels. Dr. Klein sug-
gested that the relations of ganglia to blood-vessels might be
conveniently studied in the rabbit’s bladder, where he has
already pointed out the existence of numerous sympathetic
ganglia (‘ Handbook for the Physiological Laboratory,’ p. 73).
The ganglia are found in considerable numbers in the bladder
of this animal, but are more especially numerous in that of
the dog. In ‘the rabbit’s bladder they are found most
abundantly on the thickened lateral edges of the organ, along
which the main blood-vessels also take their course ; in the
dog they are more numerous on the posterior than on the
anterior surface of the bladder.

The method employed was that recommended by Dr. Klein
(loe. cit.), viz. “ bits of the fresh bladder are coloured with
chloride of gold, and then steeped in acidulated water until
they swell out into a gelatinous translucent mass, then mem-
branous fragments stripped off with the forceps, or snipped
off with the scissors, are spread out and covered in glycerin.”’
I found it best to keep the bladder intact until after it had been
treated with the acidulated water ; if itis cut in half, the two
pieces turn inside out as they swell up, and it is then very
much more difficult to snip off thin strips from the external
surface. The fragments should be placed on the glass slide
with their external surface downwards.

The ganglia are situated in the external coat of the bladder,
and are of such a size that many of them, in the dog’s bladder
at least, can be seen with the naked eye. Fig. 1 represents
the posterior surface of the bladder of a young puppy, as seen
with a very low power. It shows the general arrangement
of the ganglia and the manner in which they are connected
with each other by nerve-trunks ; it will be noticed that they
form chain-like plexuses running with the principal blood-
vessels of the bladder; a chain of minute ganglia may also
be remarked running partly round the base of the bladder.

The ganglia are of various sizes: the largest one observed
has a long diameter of 0°9 mm., and a transverse one of
0°72; one of the small ganglia is 0°09 mm. in length by
0°045 mm. in breadth. They present considerable variety in
their shapes and have irregular outlines, which may be
roughly circular, oval, or polygonal. The nerve-trunks with
which they are connected are made up of non-medullated
nerve-fibres, with a few medullated fibres appearing oc-
casionally. ‘The ganglia are either situated at the points of
intersection of several nerve-trunks or they are found seated
ou single trunks. In the former case the groundwork of the

ANATOMY OF SYMPATHETIC GANGLIA OF BLADDER. lll

ganglion is made up of fibres passing in different directions,
which form the means of communication between the different
nerve-trunks ; around this fibrillar core the ganglion cells
are arranged, and with it their processes are incorporated.
Contiguous nerve-trunks often communicate with each other
by fibres which do not pass through the ganglion, but
which form a peripheral meshwork, as at the smaller end of
ganglion 1 in fig.3. When the ganglia are not thus situated
at points of intersection and interchange, they are found to
be connected, as before stated, with single nerve-trunks.
The simplest form of ganglion is that figured by Dr. Klein
in the Handbook, where the nerve-trunk is enlarged at one
place by a group of ganglion cells lying among its fibres. In
other cases the number of cells is greater, and the ganglion
presents the appearance of a cluster of cells traversed by a
nerve-trunk ; there is a variety of this arrangement in which
part of a nerve-trunk forms the axis of a ganglion, while the
remainder of the fibres pass close underneath the ganglion
without being connected withit. Lastly, a ganglion may be
situated on a nerve-trunk at its point of departure from a
larger one, and in that case usually receives recurrent fibres
coming from the parent trunk beyond the point of division.

The ganglion cells are of irregular spherical and ovoid
shapes, and are about 0°02 mm. in length; they are made up
a finely granular substance, and contain a single vesicular
nucleus (or two nuclei), which is usually eccentric, and
always contains a large shining nucleolus. All the cells
whose processes can be distinguished are unipolar; fig. 6
shows a number of such pear-shaped cells forming a small
ganglion ; also the nucleated capsule in which each cell is
contained.

In many of my preparations these ganglia possess a special
system of blood-vessels, small arteries, and capillaries. In
one of them there is a small artery running along one border
of a very large ganglion ; it gives off branches, which accom-
pany the principal nerve-trunks arising from the ganglion,
and also two branches for the blood supply of the ganglion ;
one of these passes up on the right, the other on the left, of
the ganglion ; they curve round to the upper border of the
ganglion, so that it is nearly surrounded in an arterial circle.
Of the branches given off from this circle, some anastomose
with capillaries running with the nerve-trunks of the
ganglion, and others pass into the ganglion and supply it.
In many cases the ganglia are surrounded by networks of
capillaries ; an example of this arrangement may be seen in
fig. 3. It will be noticed that the nerve-trunks belonging to

112 FRANCIS DARWIN.

the ganglion are accompanied by capillaries (p), which run
either singly, or in pairs, one on each side of the trunk. As
they approach the ganglion they give off branches, which
anastomose with similar branches of other capillaries, and
thus form a network, from which branches pass into the
ganglion. In other cases there is no such entwining plexus,
and capillaries may be seen simply running up to the
ganglion, and entering it in the intervals between the gan-
glion cells.

Having thus briefly described the ganglia and the nerve-
trunks, I shall proceed at once to consider their relations to
the blood-vessels. Fig. 1 shows, as already stated, that the
course of the nerves corresponds in a general way with that
of the principal blood-vessels. Fig. 2 is a portion of a
nerve-plexus seen with Hartnack No. 4, and shows in a more
minute way the character of this relation. A description of
this preparation will serve, perhaps, better than remarks of a
more general nature, to make the reader acquainted with the
usual relations existing between arteries, veins, and nerve-
trunks in the bladder of the dog.

The vessels represented are an artery (A) and a vein (4g),
with a large branch given off by each of them. A large
nerve-trunk (B), on which are situated a number of ganglia
(c), runs parallel with the artery, and at some distance from
it; a somewhat similar trunk runs with the vein. We may
call these two, for the sake of convenience in description, the
“arterial ’’ and the “ venous” nerve-truaks. ‘The venous
nerve-trunk is not in reality connected more with the vein
than with the artery, and might more fairly be called a
second arterial nerve-trunk. Indeed, it does not occur at all
in most of my preparations; what we usually find is an
artery accompanied by its vein on one side, and by a gan-
glionated nerve-trunk running on its other side.

The figure shows in what sort of way these two large
nerve-trunks, the arterial and the venous, are connected by
smaller trunks. The already mentioned branches of the
artery and vein are accompanied by a ganglionated nerve-
trunk, coming from a large ganglion on the arterial nerve-
trunk.

In addition to the two large nerve-trunks, it will be seen
that the main artery is accompanied by smaller ones, which
are connected with the ganglia of the plexus, especially with
those on the arterial nerve-trunk ; these trunks run close to
the artery, and are connected with each other by transverse
nerves, so as to enclose the artery in a kind of coarse mesh-
work.

ANATOMY OF SYMPATHETIC GANGLIA OF BLADDER. 113

These smaller trunks are represented in fig. 2 as abruptly
truncated in some places; in reality, it is at these points that
the artery receives its nervous supply, the trunks being here
seen to enter the adventitia, where they fade away, and
gradually lose themselves. The veins are not accompanied
by any such plexus of smaller nerves.

In some preparations, chiefly from the bladder of the
rabbit, there is a somewhat simpler method of supply; here
we cannot distinguish a large nerve-trunk, and an entwining
plexus of small nerves, but the artery is accompanied by a
ganglionated nerve-trunk, whence branches pass directly into
its adventitia.

Figures 3 and 4 are drawn from a preparation of the
rabbit’s bladder, showing this kind of arrangement. The
artery Ain Fig. 3 is accompanied by a nerve-trunk, on which
are situated the two ganglia 1 and 11, which are in reality
connected by the continuity of the trunks B, and B,. A nerve-
trunk (supposed to be interrupted at the line ef) comes off
from ganglia 1; it enters the adventitia of the artery, and
disappears at a, where it almost meets a similar trunk
coming from ganglion 11. (Ganglion 1 gives off another
trunk, which supplies the artery in a different manner.

This is shown in fig. 4, B representing the nerve and
A the artery. ‘The diminution in size, which may be
noticed in the nerve after it has crossed the artery, is due to
the loss of several of its fibres, which enter the adventitia of
the artery at a.

The fact that nerves are found arising from ganglia, and
distinctly supplying arteries, is again illustrated in fig. 5.
A ganglionated nerve-trunk, not shown in the figure, runs,
roughly speaking, parallel with the artery (4); B, and a,
the principal nerve-trunks of the artery, are connected with
two ganglia situated close together on this trunk. Where
B, reaches the artery it divides into two sets of fibres, one
of which passes superficial to, the other in the depth beneath
the vessel. The superficial division gives off a few fibres,
which enter the adventitia (a), and then divides into two
branches ; one of these loses itself in the adventitia on the
opposite border of the artery, the other ends by spreading out
into an irregular fan of nucleated fibres on the superficial
surface of the vessel. The nerve-trunk a, also divides into
two branches, one of which terminates close to the last
described branch of 3,, and in the same way, 2. e. by
spreading out on the artery, and the other comes to an end
in the adventitia. The distribution of that part of B, which
passes beneath the artery is unimportant; it is connected

114 FRANCIS DARWIN.

with a small nerve-trunk running with the main artery, and
with another one accompanying a branch which the artery
gives off.

Cohnheim appears to think that it is necessary for the
supply of an artery that there should be ganglion cells
situated in the coats of the vessel itself. From what has
been said, it will be seen that this is not necessarily the case.
The arteries are accompanied by ganglionated nerve-trunks,
and the ganglia are sometimes situated on the adventitia, but
in that case they do not appear to be more instrumental to
the nervous supply of the artery than ganglia which are not
so situated.

There is very little to be said concerning the smaller arte-
ries. I have already mentioned that the branches of large
arteries are accompanied by ganglionated nerve-trunks,
which are connected with the nerve-plexus belonging to the
main vessels. Arteries of smaller size are often entwined
with delicate, nucleated, nerve-fibres, but I have not been
able to trace these fibres to ganglia.

The veins appear to be very scantily supplied with nerves ; I
have only been able to make out, in one preparation, any con-
nection between them and ganglionated nerve-trunks. In this
preparation there are a small number of ganglia, and a few
rather small nerve-trunks; these form a very irregular
plexus, which appears to be connected with two large veins,
but not with the artery which accompanies them. A gan-
glion is seated on one of the veins, and a trunk arising from
it most probably supplies the vein, as it appears to lose itself
in the adventitia.

With regard to capillaries my observations are more satis-
factory; I have distinctly seen delicate nerve-fibres arising
from the cells of a ganglion, and supplying the neighbour-
ing capillaries, which in some cases for part of the vascular
plexus which surrounds the ganglion.

RECENT OBSERVATIONS ON THE GONIDIA QUESTION. 115

A Furtruer Risumst or Recent OsserRvAtions on the
**Gonrp1A-QuEsTion.’” By Wm. Arcuer, M.R,I.A.

In his critical enumeration of the Lichen-flora of Denmark,
Norway, Sweden, and part of Russia, Dr. T. M. Fries!
criticises the remarkable hypothesis of Schwendener as
to the nature of lichens, of the literature of which a general
résumé has lately appeared in these pages.? As the obser-
vations upon this hypothesis by Dr. Miiller® had escaped
being alluded to, it appears advisable, in order to place the
matter as fully as possible before the readers of this journal,
to give an abstract of them as well as of the conclusions arrived
at by Bornet and ‘Treub in recent memoirs, which fully
endorse Schwendener’s views.

As will be now widely known, Schwendener’s theory sup-
poses Lichens to consist of two primarily distinct elements—
Alge and Ascomycetes—in such a way that the Algz, or group
of algal cells, becoming surrounded and involved, or (more
rarely) permeated by the Ascomycete, serve the latter as
assimilating host-plant. ‘The two together form the
*‘Lichen;” hence the former, long known as “ gonidia,”’
are not organs of the Lichen, but foreign organisms pressed
into its service, and so compelled to lead a new life.

Fries asks the all-important question, ‘ In what manner
do the gonidia enclosed in the lichen-thallus originate ?”
Prof. Schwendener, in his lately published discussion of
the subject, argues that no one has observed the develop-
ment of the gonidia from terminal cells of the hypha.t How-
ever, Dr. Fries asserts that the hypha-branches swell up at
the apex, gradually become globular and afterwards filled with
green contents. ‘Thus each becomes eventually a gonidium,
which subsequently subdivides. As Dr. Miller observes, if
this were true the Schwendenerian theory would evidently
be no longer tenable. Fries does not state in what lichens
he had made his observations. However, Miller refers to a
previous observation of his own in Synalissa, bearing out the
statement, and showing the gradual formation of gonidia

} Fries, ‘ Lichenographia Scandinavica,’ Pars prima, Upsala, 1871.
2 ¢ Quart. Journ. Micr. Sc.,’ vol. xiii, n. s., p. 217.
8 ¢ Flora,’ 1872, p. 90.
4 Schwendener: ‘ Erorterungen znr Gonidienfrage,” in ‘Flora,’ May,
1872. Translated (in part) in ‘Quart. Journ. Mier. Sc.,’ vol. xiii, n. s.,
35.

p. 235

116 W. ARCHER,

from the hypha-branches ; hence, for the Omphalariee or for
the Gleolichenes (Fries), he holds the new theory to be im-
possible. He would be inclined to assume for the remainder
of the class that—at least as regards the primordial gonidium
of the gonidia-colonies—there must have existed a genetic
connection between it, the gonidia, and the hypha, but that
it may be probable that this formation of gonidia from the
hypha-branches may take place only in the very young con-
dition of the thallus, and that subsequently the gonidia
increase merely by subdivision.

As regards Collemee, indeed, and the experiments insti-
tuted by Reess! in causing its spores to germinate on Nostoc,
and develope in the substance of the latter a richly-ramified
mycelium, and thus (as Reess and Schwendener hold) convert
the Nostoc into Collema, Miiller, whilst accepting the facts,
has another interpretation to propound. This he sums up
in the following terms :—

1. Collema is dimorphic, and it has (L) a perfect state in
which it possesses hyphe and fructifies, and (2) a secondary
state (known as Nostoc) which never bears either hyphz or
apothecia.

2. The secondary (not, perhaps, merely younger) Nostoc-
state of Collema reaches the perfect state only through the
penetration into it of the hyphe belonging to its perfect
condition, which are derived from a spore or simply from
“yoot-hairs,” and through a “ vegetative copulation”’ (so to
say) of the hyphe with the gonidia.

3. Collema in perfect (hypha- and apothecia-bearing)
individuals propagates itself mostly by soredia.

4, An increase of perfect individuals is also possible by
spore-germination, but a secondary development of simple
gonidia (Nostoc) must precede it; the former then acquires
the faculty of producing apothecia by means of the spore-
filaments or root-hairs (of Collema) penetrating into the
latter.

5. Simple spore-germination without the co-operation
of the secondary state (Nostoc) produces no thallus (gonidia
and hyphz), and, on the other hand, simple gonidial
Nostoc-formation, without the co-operation of the perfect
state (spore filaments or root hairs), .remains destitute of
apothecia.

Thus, Dr. Miler would take Collema for the complete
state, Nostoc for the secondary state of this dimorphic plant,

1 Reess: “Ueber die Entstehung der Flechte Collema glaucescens
Hfmm. etc.,” in ‘Monatsbericht d. k. Akad. d, Wiss. zu Berlin,’ Oct.,
1871, p. 523.

RECENT OBSERVATIONS ON THE GONIDIA QUESTION, 117

but he declines to assent to the idea that an alga, Nostoc,
through the parasitism upon it“of a fungal mycelium, forms
the aggregate which, merely from custom, as he holds, we
please to calla Lichen. The whole is, accordingly, in his
view, a ‘ special kind of partial alternation of generations,”
which calls to mind certain of the phases of the complicated
fructifications in Alge. Different other conditions in the
Lichens are doubtless still to be expected.

Nor does Miller hesitate to regard the heteromerous
Lichens in the same way, and thus many of the beautiful
researches of Dr. Schwendener will, he holds, find a new and
more natural interpretation. In the high Alps, amongst
huge expanses of rocks, far removed from woods, where no
Ascomycetes occur, where alge are but rare, and mosses
scanty, Lichens are yet met with, often in great multitudes.
That view in such cases seems most reasonable which, in
conformity with the foregoing conception, restores to the
Lichens their autonomy, and concedes to them the power of
reproducing themselves in two, perhaps in several, ways,
and makes their existence not merely dependent upon a
fortuitous parasitism.

A very elaborate memoir bearing on the question, with
copious figures, has lately appeared from the pen of Dr. E.
Bornet. As an abstract of this most interesting communica-
tion has already appeared in “ Grevillea,”® it is unnecessary
to attempt to repeat at any length, or even to try to success-
fully condense, the substance of so extensive a memoir.

The object of the author is to put forward a series of
observations, which he regards as fully confirmatory of the
parasitic theory in lichens, and as being, indeed, the only one
which satisfactorily accounts for all the established facts.
Passing in review a long series of lichens, first those with
chlorophyllaceous, then those with phycochromaceous goni-
dia, he avers that there is nowhere any evidence that these
ever originate from the hyphe, but, on the other hand, that
the union of the latter with the alge is a subsequent occur-
rence. He brings forward certain cases in which this union
is something more than any mere contact, and in which a
penetration by the hypha into the interior of the cell of
the alga takes place ; whereupon, an increase im Its size
with a thickening of the wall ensues, succeeded by a

1 Bornet, ‘ Recherches sur les Gonidies des Lichens,’ in ‘ Ann. des Sciences

Naturelles,’ 5 sér., t. xvi, p-
2 € Greyillea,’ No. 15, Sept. 1873, p. 36.

118 W. ARCHER,

change in the appearance of the contents, which become
colourless, the wall shrivels up, and the cell finally appears
as a dead sac.

In Synalissa, which, as seen above, forms a strong point,
in the opinion of Miller, against the parasitic theory, Bornet
adduces figures tending to show that the relations of the
gonidia to the hyphe are not genetic, but due solely to
mere subsequent mutual apposition, and this sometimes of
quite distinct hypha-branches to cells of the alga manifestly
arising from the'subdivision of one and the same gonidium,
He avers that he has seen in a fertile example of S. conferta
some of the gonidia changed into “ spores”’ (?), as if some of
the Gleocapsa cells (herefregarded as forming the gonidial
element), uninfluenced by their novel position, had pursued
their normal algal course of development.

Bornet sums up the result of his researches (extending
over sixty genera belonging to the various tribes of lichens)
in the two following propositions:—1. Every gonidium of a
lichen may be referred to a species of alga. 2, The relations
of the hypha with the gonidia are of such anature as to exclude
all possibility that one of these organs can be produced by
the other, and the theory of parasitism is alone able to give
a satisfactory explanation of them.

Sometimes, according to the author, the alteration sub-
mitted to by the alge is not very visible. This happens
mostly when they are composed of independent cells. When
they are filamentous the change is often very marked; they
become distorted and broken up, the cells isolated, and the
gelatinous envelopes disappear. Again, in certain cases, the
general appearance of the alga is little changed, but it is the
individual cells of the alga which become altered. As regards
Protococcus and Trentepohlia (Chroolepus), these are, at first
glance, little changed, but the empty cells met with in the
deeper parts of the thallus seem to the author to show that
they are subject to a real action of the hypha, although this
may not manifest itself by any very marked deformations.
The cells of the gonidial-algz preserve, though mainly in the
peripheral parts, their faculty of multiplication in the ordinary
manner, though, owing to the restricted limits in which they
are confined, they rarely take their characteristic form. In
certain cases the vegetation of the algz appears to be singu-
larly stimulated by the hypha (as Gleocapsa and Stigonema,
when transformed into Omphalaria, Synalissa, Ephebe, &c.).
The gonidia again, in their turn, exert an evident influence
on the hypha. Oncontact with them, it acquires an increase
of vitality, manifested by a rapid multiplication of cells, and

RECENT OBSERVATIONS ON THE GONIDIA QUESTION. 119

production of numerous branches; the vigour of the develop-
ment evidently bears a relation to the mass of the alga.

When the hypha penetrates into the frond it may become
equally distributed in the mass of the alga (Ephedbe, Syna-
lisse), and then the general form of the alga is but little
modified. But more frequently the increase of the hypha-
threads takes place in a determined direction: when they are
parallel the fronds become cylindrical or clavate (Synalissa
conferta), when they are radiate or fanlike they give rise
to orbicular (Omphalaria) or lobed fronds (Collema), in
the form of which the alga co-operates but feebly. But
in the great majority of lichens the hypha envelopes the
alga; a more or less embracing network surrounds the
host-plant. It is not rare to see organs of fructification
appear on a thallus hardly more than beginning to be con-
stituted.

The theory of parasitism, the author urges, explains the
origin of dead gonidia found in the deeper parts of lichens ;
it does away with the remarkable fact of the coincidence in
the same thallus of dissimilar gonidia, some containing
chlorophyll, others phycochrome—a very important distinctive
character between two great groups in the lower alge; it
expiains, at the same time, the almost identity of the gonidia
of very diverse lichens, and the marked differences between
the gonidia of certain other lichens of which the thallus and
fructification are identical.

To each single species or genus of lichen there does not
correspond a different alga: on the contrary, a small number
furnish the gonidia for a great variety of lichens. Some
lichens, under certain circumstances, accessorily invade alge
of a species different to those which normally form their
gonidia. But is there sometimes a complete substitution of
one species for another? Pannaria triptophylla shows, in-
deed, that this substitution is possible to a certain extent,
although Bornet has in vain sought in very many lichens
to effect the substitution of Protococcus by Trentepohlia
(Chroolepus).

Bornet concludes by admitting that, as regards the ordi-
nary mode of life of algee and lichens, there exists a certain
antagonism. Moisture, abundant and prolonged, which is
favorable to the algz, is injurious to the lichens; plunging
the thallus of the latter in water for some time causes the
hyphe to perish. It was in this way that Famintzin and
Baranetsky set free the gonidia and obtained zoospores from
them. The partial death of the hyphe, due to indeterminate
causes, is sometimes encountered in nature. On examining

120 Ww. ARCHER.

Collema pulposum after recent rain, when the thallus is swollen
up by moisture, certain examples are to be met with which
are In a manner dimorphic—one portion has its normal form,
another much resembles Nostoc commune. The examination
of a thallus thus deformed shows that the difference of aspect
is due to the decay or local death of the hyphe.

Professor Schwendener comes forward once more in
explanation and defence of his new theory in a communica-
tion made to the Natural History Society of Basel.? This is,
however, hardly more than a recapitulation of his already
published views, put together at the request of the Society,
and it does not seem to contain any absolutely new matter.
After dwelling upon the parallelisms between Lichens and
Fungi, he proceeds to review recent researches, from which
he holds that the old views as to lichen-gonidia are rendered
questionable ; whilst, on the one hand, the genetic con-
nection between the gonidia and the hyphe remains un-
proved, on the other, the agreement of the former with the
algze is placed in aclear light. The more important points
which he proceeds to recapitulate are :—

1. He reasserts that those hyphz which show a con-
nection with the gonidia do not prove that the latter
originate from them. The gradual development of the gonidia
by a swelling up of the end cell of a hypha has been observed
by no one. On the other hand, he has seen in certain gela-
tinous lichens that this union occurs by a growing-together
or “conjugation”? of a hypha-branch with a fully-formed
gonidium. He has seen two and three stipites passing off
from the same thread in union with the cells of one connected
chain, which would not be possible if, like cherries or apples
to their pedicels, they stood to them in a genetic relation.

2. He then dwells on the resemblance or identity of the
gonidia with certain Palmellacee, Chroolepus, &c. (already
discussed in previous communications).?

3. These alge in the free state reproduce themselves by
zoospores. So it has been proved do the gonidia, but the
author repeats his objections to the interpretation of Famintzin
and Baranetsky.

4, Some lichens possess a gonidia system with apical and
stem -cells — that is, with independent terminal growth
(Ephebe, Spilonema).

The author then gives an epitomized résumé of the “ eight

1 Schwendener, ‘ Die Flechten als Parasiten der Algen,’ in Verhandl. der

Naturf. Gesellschaft in Basel,’ 1873, p. 527.
? See ‘ Quart. Journ, Mic, Se.,’ yol, xiii. n. s,, pp. 217 e¢ seg.

——eo CL CrrttrttSt—swSSSCti

RECENT OBSERVATIONS ON THE GONIDIA QUESTION, 12]

algal-types ” of the “ lichen-gonidia.”” !_ He points out that
there is a large number of lichens in which the gonidia con-
stantly belong to the same type, this indeed being the preva-
lent case, whilst there are other lichen forms which evince a
certain amount of oscillation in their selection of gonidia
between related algal-forms. ‘These he briefly discusses, con-
cluding by a reference to the question of ‘parasitic algz.”
He admits that the parasitism which, in conformity with his
theory, must be assumed for the lichens, would remain
unique in the vegetable kingdom. However, certain
recent observations bring to notice cases of adaptation in
a certain sense analogous. He especially quotes the occur-
rence of Nostoc-chaplets in the substance of Azolla recorded
by Strasburger, who found these algz in the leaves of every
species of Azolla which he had examined, no matter from
what quarter of the world they originated, which fact
almost led him to suppose that this plant could not have
been: altogether passively related to alge. “One might
almost believe”’ (says Strasburger) “‘ that the Nostoc-chaplets
are useful to the leaves of the Azol/a in their work of assi-
milation, and thus, in a certain manner, play a similar part
in them as in the interior of the lichen-thallus.” Schwen-
dener then alludes to Reinke’s observation of a Scyto-
nematous plant in the interior of Gunnera (loc. cit.”), also
to those of Cohn (loc. cit.*), and proceeds to remark that in
what the dependence consists—especially as regards the pro-
cesses of nutrition—is at present unknown, but that it cannot
be assumed from Cohn’s case that the relation is a reciprocal
one. The questionable “parasitic”? alge accordingly, he
holds, stand in decided opposition to the gonidia-formers ;
in how far, indeed, they are true parasites appears to him in
the meantime still doubtful. However it may be, such
phenomena, he holds, abundantly show that the conditions of
dependence in which organisms may stand to one another
are bound up in no particular law, but rather may make
themselves evident as the expression of mutual adaptation in
the most diverse modes. And thus, he urges, his doctrine of
the algal nature of lichen-gonidia may contribute to place in
a correct light a series of the most noteworthy adaptations
which occur in the vegetable kingdom.

1 Cohn: ‘ Beitrage zur Biologie der Pflanzen,’ Heft I], p. 87. See also
© Quart. Journ. Mier. Sc.,’ vol. xiii, n. s., p. 366.

2« Die Algentypen der Flechtengonidien,” Basel, 1869. See ‘Quart.
Journ. Mic. Sc.,’ vol. xiii, n. s., pp. 222 ef seg.

3 Reinke: ‘ Bot. Zeitung,’ 1872, p. 59.

122 W. ARCHER.

The brief result of experiments made by Bornet in causing
lichen-spores to germinate in company with alge is incor-
porated below with an English version of the record of the
experiments instituted for this purpose by Dr. Melchior Treub,
and detailed by him in a Memoir laid before the University
of Leiden in November last.1_ Theauthor of this memoir begins
by giving in the first section an interesting and com-
plete epitome of the history of Lichenology—more especially
in its bearing on the subject in question—from Tulasne to the
present. It is a pity that so thorough a résumé of the scat-
tered literature of the subject is written in Dutch, a language
not much read in this country ; however, the more important
of the references touching on the “gonidia question ” have
already been placed before the readers of this journal. The
second section of the 'Treub Memoir is devoted to an ac-
count of the author’s original researches in 1872 and 1873
on this question, and is repeated below pretty nearly in full,
for, notwithstanding that a large proportion of his experiments
ended abortively, much interest attaches to them. He ulti-
mately arrived at results in accordance with those of Bornet,
and, so far as they go, apparently very much in favour of the
de-Bary-Schwendener theory.

The two following paragraphs allude to Reess’s experi-
ments, already referred to in a previous number of this
journal, and to Miller’s views as given above :—

1. The conclusion drawn by Fries from the experi-
ments of Reess that, if parasitism in lichens were true,
the parasite should originate first and then the host, is
incorrect. The colonies of Nostoc lichenoides with which
Reess experimented must have reached even the size of a
pea; it is therefore not to be wondered at that the ger-
minating filaments of the spores, which were designedly
placed upon the Nostoc-colonies, did not become long
enough to be able to reach the substratum, and, by taking
up food fromit to enable the filaments which had penetrated
into the Nostoc to continue growing. If, then, Collemaspores
merely fall upon freely growing Nostoc-colonies, Collema would
not necessarily originate in consequence. 'This does not, how-
ever, prevent Nostoc-colonies which have already grown for
some time upon a substratum being subsequently able to pass
over into Collema ; for this it is only necessary that the spores

1 Treub, ‘Onderzoekingen over de Natuur der Lichenen,’ Leiden (22
November, 1873). Previously the author had published a brief communica-
tion, “ Lichenencultur,’ in ‘ Botanische Zeitung,” No. 46, Nov. 1873, but
written in September, in anticipation of his more copious Memoir, giving the
complete history cf the question and the full details of his experiments.

RECENT OBSERVATIONS ON THE GONIDIA QUESTION. 123

fall not just upon but close to the Noséoc-colonies ; the ger-
minating filaments in this case may partly penetrate into the
Nostoc and partly into the substratum, and all the con-
ditions for the production of Collema would be complete. With
much more minute alge, which are the gonidia-formers of
heteromerous lichens, these may in any case originate by later
importation of spores, because even if the spore falls just
upon the alga, it is possible that the germinating filaments
may still reach the substratum, since they mostly far exceed
in length the diameter of the alge.

2. The explanation given by Miiller of the relation be-
tween Nostoc and Collema, founded on Reess’s experiments,
—that we have to do with a peculiar kind of alternation
of generations,—is nothing else than the last desperate effort
to hold by the organic individuality of the homoiomerous
lichens by means of a mere fight about words. ‘he expres-
sion ‘alternation of generations’ (generatiewisseling), taken
in its widest sense, is applied to the phenomenon of an
organic individual in reproduction producing first a form
wholly different from that which brings it forth, and only the
direct or indirect progeny of ¢his generation becoming like the
first. Thus, to regard JVostoc as an ‘alternation’ of Collema
it should alone be able to furnish Col/ema ; this, in reality, is
not the case, so that, without completely overstraining the
expression ‘alternation of generations,’ it cannot be applied
to the relation between Nostoc and Collema. It is clear,
however, that Muller merely wants to replace the word para-
sitism by the phrase ‘a special kind of partial alternation of
generation’ when he says, if the increase of perfect indivi-
duals of Collema takes place by spores, some gonidia must
be already present, which then, in combination with the
intruding hyphe, furnish the perfect apothecia-bearing indi-
viduals. No competent judge will, I think, controvert that,
following Miiller’s own description, we have here to do with
parasitism in the strictest sense of the word.”

The following reproduces the principal portions of the
second section of Treub’s memoir, recording his original
researches :—

Relations between Gonidia and Hypha.—Although, in the
course of the present summer, the copious treatise of Bornet
has appeared, in which the relation between the gonidia and
hyphe is discussed in a decisive manner, I still feel myself
compelled briefly to communicate my own long-continued
researches on the above point. * i 2

It is well known that it is upon Bayrhoffer and Speer-
schneider’s authority that the origin of the gonidia from the

124 W. ARCHER,

hyphe has been generally accepted up till about three years
ago. According to Bayrhoffer the threads of the ‘ fibrous
stratum’ swell at the top, which swellings afterwards become
‘male gonidia.’ ‘That the correctness of the observation may
be strongly doubted, and must rather be credited to the ob-
server’s fancy, every one will agree with me who is acquainted
with Bayrhoffer’s work, in which are to be found the most
extraordinary ideas about lichens. Thus, for example, accord-
ing to Bayrhoffer, the thallus is composed of a male anda
female stratum.

As regards Speerschneider, he stated that in Hagenia
ciliaris at the place of transition between cortical and medul-
lary hyphe, gonidia originate on the hyphe, which, apart from
the green colour, very much resemble at first young hypha-
branches, besides which larger gonidia occur intimately united
with the hyphe, which is a further reason for assuming that
the gonidia originate from these. In his work he subsequently
assumes the same mode of origin of gonidia for other lichens ;
inRamalina several gonidia are said to originate from one
hypha-swelling, and in Pedtigera to be formed in the hypha.
The statement is also especially noteworthy that in Hagenia
some gonidia, amongst which very young and minute ones
contain zo chlorophyll. How is this to be reconciled with
his just quoted opinion, expressed a year earlier, that the
existence of their colouring substance alone distinguishes the
young gonidia from commencing lateral branches ?

Th. M. Fries and J. Miiller last year have cursorily
made known some observations of the origin of the gonidia
from the hyphe, without, however, giving figures or any
description of their mode of observation.’

“© My own researches, which were chiefly carried out with
Xanthoria parietina, and the conclusions deduced therefrom,
briefly amount to this :—

The origin of the gonidia from the hyphe will be clearly
proved only when cells still uncoloured green are found on
the hyphe, and which can be recognised as gonidia by the
cellulose reaction of their walls. The occurrence of minute
but already distinctly green gonidia united with lypha-
branches at least furnishes no proof, because (1) Schwendener,
more than ten years ago, showed that the so-called stipites
might be the result of the growth of the hyphe against the
gonidia ; (2) gonidia are to be found (which I have succeeded
in doing many times) which are furnished with more than one
stipes. Just as little is it possible to recognise by the form

1 ¢ Flora,’ 1872, p. 90. Vide supra.

RECENT OBSERVATIONS ON THE GONIDIA QUESTION. 125

whether we have to do with a gonidium not yet coloured
green, or with a very young hypha-branch, because, as
has already been frequently mentioned by various writers,
even the very young green gonidia attached to the hyphe are
not different in form from young hypha-branches ; how much
the more should this be the case with the younger still un-
coloured gonidia?

After 1 had satisfied myself that this was the only direc-
tion in which the research must be carried out to furnish
wholly decisive results, I tried to gain my object by making
very thin sections from the lichen-thallus, which were then
treated with various reagents. I obtained the sections as
thin as possible by the method of Gibelli of embedding the
thallus in stearic acid. From the lump thus obtained, upon
cooling, a section is made as thin as possible ; afterwards the
thallus-sections were freed from the surrounding stearine
by means of a fine needle, or, better, by meansof warm alcohol.
I never succeeded, however, in perceiving very young gonidia,
which were not yet coloured green, so that I did not thus
make any observation in the least supporting the origin of the
gonidia from the hyphe.

During the research it occasionally happened that I met
with detached gonidia with larger or small portions of hypha
attached, from which the contents were removed in conse-
quence of the treatment, and which had thus become com-
pletely hyaline, and seeming as if the hypha pressed some-
times a little zxfo the gonidium. In order to satisfy myself of
the correctness of the observation, it was necessary to view.
such a gonidium, by means of turning, from all sides. This,
indeed, was generally not possible, because the portions of.
hypha attached to the gonidium were too long to admit of
rolling it over in all directions. That this is necessary in
order to arrive at any certainty as to the fact, follows from
the possibility of ocular deception, and from the fact that we
might have to do with a gonidium divided into two, between
whose secondary-cells the end of the stalk-cell had penetrated,
and we might only see the secondary cells superposed above
one another.1 Turning upon all sides showed me in very few
cases that hypha-ends had penetrated into a gonidium. In
uninjured gonidia—still with contents—I never saw it;
& priori, one might certainly say that in such a case the
observation of the penetrated hypha-end is as good as impos-
sible. Still it deserves to be mentioned here that the observa-
tion of the hypha-ends which had penetrated never gave

1 See Nageli’s ‘ Beitr. zur Wissensch. Botanik,’ II Heft, t.i, f. 18, a. b.
VOL, XIX.—NEW SER. I

126 W. ARCHER.

grounds for the supposition that the penetration was the
result of any mechanical violence during the manipulation.

Experiments in Sowing Spores.—In order to obtain a suffi-
cient quantity of spores, ‘Tulasne’s method was employed.
The lichens were placed on plates, well moistened, and then
covered by the slides, upon which, after twelve to twenty-
four hours, a number of spores were found. ‘The lichens
from which the spores were taken were always gathered just
previously, indeed, I took, perhaps, overmuch care not to use
examples which were gathered more than a day before,
and this with a view to avoid giving rise to the objection
that the small quantity of the spores obtained, or the unsatis-
factory results of the germination of the spores, were a result
of the specimens not being fresh. It is known, indeed, that
the germinative power of spores subsists but for a short time,
and also that herbarium-examples of lichens, upon being
moistened, give off no spores. - ‘g . + -

To produce germination the spores were placed in a moist
atmosphere. For this purpose a basin or deep plate was filled
about halfway with water, and in it was placed a small saucer
or a piece of stone or marble. Upon these objects, which
projected above the water, were placed the slides with the
spores ; and over the whole a bell-glass reaching to the water
in the basin, so that in this way the air of the space containing
the spores soon became moist. In other cases the same end was
attained by laying a sheet of glass or an ordinary plate over
the basin, the last for experiments on germination in the
dark.

As regards the other circumstances under which the spores
were placed for germination, these varied according to the
end in view in observing the germination. For different
purposes, two different methods were followed, and these
will be separately treated :—

I. The observation of the germination of the spores had for
its object to ascertain if the germinating filament produce a
kind of mycelium, some cells of which pass over into young
gonidia, as must happen if the lichens are to be regarded
as autonomous.

The majority of the experiments were conducted in the

same way as by previous observers who had the same object —

in view: that is to say, the spores were placed in a moist
medium. I generally left the spores upon the slides whereon
they were taken; the progress of germination could thus
readily be examined under the microscope. Sometimes,
also, I placed the spores, by means of a drop of water, upon
pieces of bark from the same tree on which the lichen grew

———<Ke—x——— ——

RECENT OBSERVATIONS ON THE GONIDIA QUESTION, 127

which had furnished the spores; by making very thin sections
of these pieces of bark the progress of germination was
observed. ‘The method followed by Tulasne of letting the
spores germinate on stone I never adopted, because it appeared
to me that the due examination of the process of germination
is by this plan very difficult; one must then, indeed, either
remove the germinating spores from the substratum,—and to
do this without injury is very difficult, especially when the
germinating filaments are very long—or one must make
the microscopic observation by means of reflected light,
in which case certainly no very good results are to be
expected.

On two occasions I caused the germination to take place
in the presence of a small quantity of the ash of the lichens ;
if the substratum were then moistened by vapour some of the
ash-constituents would thus be dissolved, and serve for food
to the germinating filaments, in case this inorganic food were
necessary in order to cause the gonidia to originate.

_ A great number of the experiments were partly carried

on in the dark, because there was thus perhaps more chance
of good results; in the new formation of cells light can,
indeed, not only be done without, but it ordinarily operates
even injuriously, and darkness favorably.!

From the middle of April to the beginning of July, 1872,
I made forty experiments with spores of Xanthoria, Ramalina,
and Lecanora.

Two to eight days after the sowing the first appearances
of germination make themselves evident, the more unfavora-
ble the circumstances so much the later. Amongst the cir-
cumstances unfavorable to germination are a too copious
supply of water on the substratum, and the direct proximity
of other objects as well as of other spores. If many spores
lie, for instance, on the top of one another this impedes ger-
mination. ‘The very imperfect germination of spores placed
under none of these unfavorable conditions shows that there
must be still other conditions which are not understood.

About a month after the sowing the protoplasm becomes
in great part used up in the formation and elongation of the
germinating filaments. In the first year of my experiments
the germination very rarely reached the last stage, wherein the
spore is wholly empty and the protoplasm used up, probably
often owing to the influence of the first-mentioned unfavorable
circumstances, but above all to the early occurrence of a mould
upon the substratum on which the spores were placed, whereby

1 See Sachs, ‘ Experim, Physiologie,’ pp. 30, 31.

128 WwW. ARCHER,

the process of germination becomes speedily stopped. In all my
cultures the mould-formation was then, amongst the obvious
difficulties, not only the greatest, but, at the same time, the one
against which, notwithstanding all the means applied, nothing
could be done. Now, a repetition of my researches in this
year at last taught me the circumstances under which the
formation of mould is to be obviated, and I carried on cultures
for even three months free from this vexatious foe. I saw
more spores than formerly of which all the protoplasm was
used up in the growth of the germinating filaments, and in
which, therefore, germination proper was at an end; I never
saw, however, young gonidia on the germinating filaments i in
which, by the application of reagents, I satisfied myself com-
pletely of the presence of cellulose. If the gonidia originated
from the germinating filaments, they should have already
made their appearance when the filaments have used up all
the reserve nutriment from the spores; they do not them-
selves contain chlorophyll, and thus cannot assimilate and
have not the opportunity of taking up organic food for
further growth.

II. Starting on the supposition that Schwendener’s theory
of the lichens is the true one, the spores about to germinate
were brought into contact with nutritive solution for the
purpose of trying in this way to cause the germinating fila-
ments to grow, after, indeed, the reserve nutriment from the
spore was used up.

It is very probable that both the plan of operations and
the purpose of this part of my experiments may be at first
glance taken by many as merely haphazard, above all because,
so far as I know, no one has ever tried to cultivate a strictly
parasitic fungus by nutrient solution only, without the co-
operation of the host. This has, indeed, been done for sapro-
phytes, and with good results, by sometimes making use of
prepared nutrient substances in a fluid state, at other times
of decoctions or solutions of the substances whereon the
saprophytes grow. Still I think I can quite justify my plan
of operation. It is known that most parasitic fungi can live
only on one, or, at most, very few hosts, but the conclusion
constantly drawn that the hosts are the only plants which
contain the nutrient substances necessary for the parasite
may scarcely hold good. The phenomenon may have another
explanation. Of all the plants which contain the necessary
nutritive substances for any parasitic fungus, its host (or
hosts) alone fulfils the conditions of containing, at the same
time, none of the substances injurious to the parasite.

Were this mode of explanation of the union of a parasitic

RECENT OBSERVATIONS ON THE GONIDIA QUESTION. 129

fungus with a definite host the true one, there would have
been a chance that it would have been possible to make
spores from such a parasite germinate and grow in a nutri-
tive solution, and I still think that the second mode of ex-
plaining the restricted choice of most parasitic fungi as much
holds as the first.

I applied this second method in all kinds of ways in
arranging the spores for germination. If I had succeeded in
causing the germinating filaments to continue growing in
this manner for some time, I should have at once been able
to combat the organic individuality of the lichens with a
wholly new weapon.

In the choice of the nutrient fluids for the culture, I
supposed that it was best to select such as had been applied
with good result for the germination and development of
other fungi. From the small number of these fluids I chose
the two foilowing :

(A) Culture fluid, made use of by Boussingault for develop-
ment of the Mycoderms.'—Milk is coagulated with acetic acid
when, all the caseine being deposited, the whey is filtered ;
this contains albumen phosphates, potash, soda, lime, mag-
nesia, oxide of iron, and water. This fluid, dilated in
different degrees with distilled water, was used ; at the same
time, in many cases there was added a little ash of the
_ lichens whose spores were to be germinated.

(B) Pasteur’s fluid, used for the development of the
Mucedines.2—The composition of this culture fluid is:—
Distilled water in which is dissolved an ammoniacal salt,
sugar-candy, and phosphate, obtained by the combustion of
yeast, the last constituent introduced by means of the ash of
the lichens. This fluid was also used diluted in different
degrees.

In two different methods, by means of a number of
experiments, lasting from 15th April to the middle of June,
1872, it was attempted to germinate the spores of Ramalina,
Xanthoria, and Lecanora by means of the culture fluid, and,
above all, to be made to go on to develop the germinating
filaments.

1. The spores were brought upon a slide with a drop of
the fluid, and this placed, in the known manner, in an
atmosphere moistened by vapour; here, likewise, some of the

1 Boussingault, “ Observ. relat. au Dévelop. des Mycodermes,”’ ‘ Comptes
Rendus,’ 1860, p. 672.

2 Pasteur, “Recherches sur le mode de Nutrition des Mucedinées,”
‘Comptes Rendus,’ 1860, p. 710.

130 W. ARCHER,

experiments were conducted in the dark. Though the placing
of the spores in pure water acted prejudicially upon germina-
tion, still the possibility may have been that in a nutritive
solution the reverse was the case; in Peziza Fuckeliania,}
for example, the spores refuse to germinate in fresh water
but in grape-sugar solution ; on the other hand, they do so
once.

2. The spores were placed on shreds of flannel saturated
with the nutrient fluid, so that they should be in contact
with the nutrient substances (the degree of concentration
remaining constant), without being wholly immersed ; the
experiments were again partly made in the dark.

The pieces of flannel, which were smaller than an
ordinary slide, were previously boiled for half an hour in
nutritive solution, then immediately brought upon a slide
into the space kept moist by vapour, and after cooling, only
just taken out to place the spores upon them.

To my great regret, the results were very small; the
culture fluids show themselves to be peculiarly adapted for
the purpose to which they were applied by Pasteur and Bous-
singault ; after a short time, on most of the slides on which
were drops of these fluids, perfect examples of Penicillium
glaucum might be found, whilst in the course of a week the fluid
imbibed by the pieces of flannel, notwithstanding the previous
boiling, upon being squeezed out appeared almost milk-
white, owing to the presence of a surprising quantity of
Saccharomyces ; the lichen-spores, on the other hand, in
certain cases, either did not germinate at all, or produced
at any rate in germination germinating filaments, which in
length stood far behind those produced by the spores which
had germinated, under favorable circumstances, in a moist
atmosphere.

Since the object for which these experiments were under-
taken did not appear in the least capable of being attained,
the result of my culture of spores of the different lichens in
conjunction with Cystococcus-examples would thus alone
have to determine whether I should succeed or not in
demonstrating the true nature of the heteromerous lichens.
The following will show the modus operandi and the result of
these culture experiments.

In these cultures I set before myself the final aim of
making up one or more of the heteromerous lichens out of its
presumptive constituents and thereby demonstrating the just-
ness of the theory originated by de Bary and Schwen-
dener, in the same manner as Rees had succeeded for

1 De Bary, ‘Morph. und Physiol. der Pilze,’ p. 212.

RECENT OBSERVATIONS ON THE GONIDIA QUESTION, 138]

the homoiomerous lichens in his culture of Collema glau-
cescens.

In any case, after the Co/lema-cultures, it remained of
great importance to confirm experimentally the presumption
of a double nature for the heteromerous lichens, and the
more so as such a man as Cohn acquiesces in Schwendener’s
views for the homoiomerous lichens, and still he regards the
same views as bearing upon the heteromerous lichens as
untenable.}

Before describing the plan and results of my own
cultures I may be permitted to mention what has been done
in this direction by others.

Woronine obtained no positive result by bringing theca-

spores of Parmelia pulverulenta into contact with the young
gonidia in a drop of water.*? ‘The second who has made
experiments in the culture of spores and alge together is
Bornet, who says*—I placed on the fragments of lime-stone
freshly broken and on fragments of bark which I had boiled
in water for about a quarter of an hour a layer of Protococcus
viridis and some spores of Parmelia parietina. The Pro-
tococcus taken on a damp and shady wall was almost pure.
There were with difficulty to be found mingled some Micro-
coleus filaments, a very slender Oscillatoria and a smal] number
of Cladosporium-spores ; but I did not perceive any trace of
spores or filaments of lichens, The Protococcus diluted in
water rapidly became resolved into Zoospores. Other frag-
ments of stone and bark received exclusively Protococcus or
spores. . . . Germination took place in some days in
the manner described and figured by Tulasne, Towards
the fifteenth day the hypha was already large and ramified.
Wherever it came in contact with the cells of the Proto-
coccus, either isolated or in groups, it adhered either directly
or by a lateral branch. I may add that the hypha attached
itself exclusively to the Protococcus, and not to other bodies
mingled therewith, It is by hundreds that I have obtained
these germinations, and | have been able to ascertain
with certainty that I was not deceived by accidental
adherences.

The spores sown apart at the same time as the others
germinated alike, but became much less ramified, and did

' « Sitzungsberichte d. Bot. Sect. d. Schles. Gesellschaft,’’ | inBot.
Zeitung,’ 1872, p. 16.

2 Woronine, ‘ Rech. sur les gonid. du Lichen Parmelia pulverulenta,”
‘Amn. d. Sci. Nat. Bot.,’ 5 sér,, t, xvi, p. 324,

3 Bornet, “ Recherches sur les Gonidies des Lichen,” in ‘ Ann. d. Sciences
Naturelles,’ 5 sér., t. xvii, p. 65, 1873.

182 W. ARCHER.

not produce chlorophyll. The Protococcus-cells remained
as they were and did not produce filaments.

In another series of experiments I placed spores of
Biatora muscorum on a corticolous form of Protococcus a
little larger than the preceding. ‘The results were the same.
Unfor tunately, I have not been able to conduct these germi-

nations on to the production of a thallus. The excess of
moisture and the development of a Mucedine destroyed the
young plants at the end of some weeks.

My own culture experiments were conducted in two dif-
ferent ways. In one I sowed the lichen spores with Cys-
tococcus upon the substratum, whereon the species are
mostly found, in the hope of obtaining a young lichen-thallus,
as Reess succeeded in doing for Collema glaucescens in his
“culture in the mass.” In the other the spores were
brought along with Cystococcus on slides, and tried under
different circumstances, in order to make the spores germi-
nate, for the purpose of seeing if the germinating filaments,
on coming into contact with the Cystococcus individuals,
would wholly or partially include them, and thus, as
readily perceptible, demonstrate the beginning of lichen-
formation.

Culture experiments in the mass (“ Kultuurproeven in het
groot ”).—These cultures had for their object the production
of a young perfect lichen-thallus, and by this means to
become acquainted at the same time with the processes
whereby this production takes place in nature. The sub-
strata whereon the spores and alge were sown were con-
stantly those whereon the lichens I was trying to cause to
originate mostly occur.

I last year went to work in the following manner :

Xanthoria-spores were sown with Cystococcus (1) on
willow-bark, (2) on pieces of tile, (3) on very fine tile-dust
(obtained by hammering), and pressed as firmly as possible
in little saucers. This last substratum was chosen as admit-
ting better than the pieces of tile, after the culture, of micro-
scopical examination of the results.

Lecanora spores were sown with Cystocoecus (1) on
willow-bark and apple-bark, (2) on pieces of stone, (3) on
stone-dust, the last for the same purpose as in the Xanthoria
cultures,

Ramalina spores finally were sown with Cystococcus on
oak-bark.

Shortly before use the substances serving as substratum
for the culture were immersed in boiling water ; in by far
the greater number of cases these were, before the sowing,

RECENT OBSERVATIONS ON THE GONIDIA QUESTION. 133

further saturated with a little of the solution of the ash of the
different lichens.

All these “cultures in the mass” took place in a moist atmo-
sphere. Verysoon I used instead of freely growing Cystococcus
for my cultures, that which I had previously set free from the
lichen thallus (see below). The Cystococcus was always
furnished by another lichen than that wherefrom the spores
were taken; for example, spores of Xanthoria were sown
upon a substratum with Cystococcus from Ramalina, in order
that the presumption should never occur, in case of eventual
success of the culture, that the thallus was caused by the
continuous growing of portions of the hypha set free whilst
still attached upon some Cystococcus-examples, as, indeed,
thin sections of some homoiomerous lichens may, under
favorable circumstances, grow on afresh to become a perfect
thallus. .

The greater part of these experiments were carricd on in
the way made known by Reess as necessary to cause
homoiomerous lichens to originate ; the spores were first
sown, and about ten days after the alge. When this mode,
however, did not afford me the least result, I then, between
15th October and Ist December, 1872, made further culture
for the fifteenth time, in which spores and alge were sown
simultaneously in order to see if the mode of culture requisite
for the homoiomerous lichens had acted possibly injuriously
for heteromerous lichens, and was the cause of the failure of
the experiment.

In this summer I have not repeated the cultures “‘in the
mass” in a moist atmosphere; however, I have tried to
obtain Xanthoria parietina by sowing its spores with Cysto-
coccus humicola in the open air upon tiles and bark of trees,
lasting from 8th July to 3rd October.

All my cultures ‘‘in the mass”? of the preceding year had,
in no case, the least result. After a month and a half (taken
as the mean of those cultures), with the naked eye there was
no trace of thallus-formation perceptible, but even a micro-
scopic examination presented nothing resembling lichen-
formation. ‘This non-success was almost always the result
of formation of mould.

In my cultures in the open air during this summer I
found, more than once, on the very limited spots of the bark
on which I had sown spores and alge, after about three
weeks’ culture, very distinct commencing thallus-formation ;
I was never able, however, with minute microscopic examina-
tion, to find the connexion between such a young thallus and
a germinated Xanthoria spore ; this appeared almost to be

134 W. ARCHER.

impossible. Thick sections from this substratum are much
too indistinct, and very thin ones do not admit of the course
of the hyphe being followed. Now, so long as this con-
nexion is not clear, no conclusion can be drawn from the
occurrence of young Xanthoria thalli in the place where
spores and alge were sown, since soredia indeed might give
rise to the same phenomenon. However, I may here add
that the commencing lichen formations almost always
were without the aspect of haying owed their origin to
soredia.

Culture experiments on the minnte scale (*‘ Kultuurproeven in
het klein ”).—The spores were brought upon slides and kept in
moist air. In the beginning of my experiments I occasionally
placed the slides under the microscope for the purpose of
examining the advance made in germination by the spores
and the growth of the alge; afterwards, however, I left the
slides uninterruptedly in the moist medium, in order to follow
out the results microscopically in the conclusion of the
culture. The last is much preferable, since the frequent
transporting of the slides whereon the cultures take place
adds to the opportunities for the dire enemy of these experi-
ments—mould—to reach the slides.

In a part of my cultures of last year along with the
spores and alge, a little solution of the ash of those lichens
whence the spores proceeded was sprinkled upon the slides
by means of a little brush; in this way the moisture falls on
the substratum only in little drops ; this was done in order
to supply the inorganic nutriment which, according to Reess,
the lichens derive during their development from the sub-
stratum. That thisdid not take place in allcases was owing :—
(1) to the fact that, however carefully I went to work, large
drops occasionally formed uponthe substratum, which not only
hindered the germination of the spores, but also favoured the
formation of mould; (2) that the application for the purpose
of my cultures on the minute scale (“in het klein’’) was not
directly necessary ; the germinating filaments of a parasitic
fungus must still be forced into or against the host (the first
in endo-, the second in epiphytes), before a// the protoplasm
is used up from the spore, because otherwise the necessary
organic nutriment is absent to enable it to execute this move-
ment of growth.

It is probable, indeed, that on the germinating filament
of lichen-spores reaching the Cystococcus-cells the spores often
contain sufficient reserve material to enable the germ-tubes
to continue growing for some time. It would further be
very probable that, even after the whole of the reserve nutri-

RECENT OBSERVATIONS ON THE GONIDIA QUESTION. 135

ment of the spores was used up, the germinating filaments
would still be able to continue growing for some time, with-
out addition of inorganic food, but simply at the cost of the
organic food from the alge. Should, then, the branches of the
germinating filaments probably be more delicate than the
hyphe from the perfect lichen-thallus, it might be possible
to observe distinctly the first result of the contact of the
germinating filaments and the alge.

After I had gone through the course of my first culture
it at once suggested itself to me that the impurity of the Cys-
tococcus masses must operate peculiarly unfavorably on the
success of my experiment.

Indeed, upon gathering small quantities of the alge for
my cultures, it always appeared, upon looking them over,
that they were contaminated by hyphe of minute fungi, fre-
quently by protonemata, but, above all, by other alge. ‘To
obviate this I determined to employ the freely-growing Cys-
tococcus no more, but only that which I had disengaged from
the lichen-thallus; this, indeed, I could do without in the
least diminishing the results to be obtained, since, indeed,
the most violent opponents of Schwendener’s theory acknow-
ledge the perfect agreement of the gonidia of most hetero-
merous lichens with Cystococcus humicola, and in this
very agreement find a reason, indeed, to remove Cysto-
coccus humicola from the alge. We find von Krempel-
huber, for instance, saying, “ Den Nachweis jener Aehnlich-
keit gewisser Flechtengonidien mit gewissen niederen
Algen, oder meinetwegen Identitat,’ &c.

One great difficulty being obviated, there still appeared
a much greater and more troublesome one, namely, mould-for-
mation. In the first period of my research (February to
December, 1872) I found, I might say invariably, moulds on
the substratum. Of course, the growth of the alge and
germinating filaments was in consequence very much
interfered with or usually wholly stopped. I tried, in
the following ways, to get rid of these troublesome
enemies.

1. By means of carbolic acid, of which a drop was added
to the water in the vessel intended to receive the slides, or a
wad moistened with it was placed in the damp space in the
bell glass. In this manner I succeeded, in some cases, in
preventing the formation of mould during the culture ; still
this was constantly coupled with non-germination of the
lichen-spores, and with a total loss of colour and contraction
of the contents of the alge. ‘The cure was worse than the

disease. By employing extremely little carbolic acid the

136 W. ARCHER.

spores commenced germinating and the alge remained in a
living condition, but the formation of mould upon the slides
was not kept down.

2. By carrying on the culture in a space supplied with:
air, previously purified by passing through a plug of cotton
wool, In this way I anticipated that I should get rid of
mould; it was further probable that the continuous access of
fresh air would operate favorably.

The apparatus which I employed consisted of a horizontally
placed lamp-chimney, connected at one end with an aspi-
rator; two slides covered with spores and algze were intro-
duced into it, and under the slides there was a stratum of
water, intended to maintain the moisture of the air; the
chimney was then closed at the other end with a perforated
cork, wherein fitted a glass tube, twice bent, and at the end
blown out into a globe, open at one end and filled with
cotton wool.

I could not expect that in this way fungal spores would
be absolutely excluded from my cultures, because Pasteur
found that air passed through one cotton plug still leaves
germs upon a second one. Since, however, the tube through
which the air passed was further bent in two places, there
was a good chance that fungal-spores, which were carried
by the air through the wadding would not arrive at the
cultures.

An experiment with this apparatus (from October Ist to
November 8rd, 1872) showed me, indeed, that it was well
adapted for the purpose ; still it taught me afresh how little
certainty one has in the success of experiments in the culture
of lichen-spores; on both the slides, though the alge had
remained in a good condition, the spores had sent out no ger-
minating filaments, and this notwithstanding that there were
present no apparently unfavorable circumstances.

Of all my cultures made last year on the minute scale, in
which the spores germinated and the Cystococcus-cells re-
mained alive, by far the most did not last longer than some
three weeks; just as with Bornet, mould prevented the cul-
tures being longer extended.

I then this year began anew some experiments on the minute
scale carried on in a somewhat different manner, but still with
the object of struggling against the mould-formation, in order to
prolong cultures for a longer period. ‘The slides with the
spores and alge thereon were first brought into the moist-
ened space till there was no further trace of water and spores,
and alge had become quite dry (these were always placed upon
the slides ina drop of water). By this plan one of the circum- -

RECENT OBSERVATIONS ON THE GONIDIA QUESTION, 137

stances most favorable to mould-formation—moisture—was
much diminished ; however, it was d priori much to be feared
that on a dry substratum, and merely in a moist atmosphere,
neither the spores would germinate nor the algz continue to
live. Fortunately the conjecture was contradicted by the
event. After the culture had lasted for a month, micro-
scopic examination showed that not only mould-formation
was as good as altogether absent, but also that the spores had
germinated very well, and that the Cystococcus-cells were
equally alive. I was then, indeed, able to make my cultures
last from 23rd January of this year to 30th April, and had
the opportunity of observing very distinctly the results of
germination, which will presently be described.

Amongst my cultures on slides during the summer of
1872, amounting to seventy in number, it once happened by
accident that the slides, with the spores and alge thereon,
were quite dry at starting; this, however, never struck me
as a favorable circumstance ; the cultures equally suffered
from the mould. In this summer I have again made some
cultures with slides on a perfectly dry substratum, with spores
of Xanthoria parietina and Cystococcus humicola, from 25th
July to 4th October, if possible with still more care than those
of this winter. From these cultures, owing to mould, I ob-
tained absolutely no result. It hence follows that summer is
the most unmanageable time of year for cultures such as these,
so that it is explicable how so great a number of experiments
as I made in the summer of 1872, in the most different
methods, have led to small a result.

After three weeks’ culture (in 1872) I saw that when ger-
minating filaments and Cystococcus cells had met together, the
filaments had grown more or less over the surface of the
alez and become firmly attached thereto.' The constant
adhesion of the filament to the walls of the alge proves that the
mutual apposition is more than an accidental circum-
stance.”

After siz weeks’ culture (in 1873) I observed that as the
first result of the contact branches begin to originate; the

1 The contents of the Cystococcus-cells, shaded dark in the original
plate, became greatly contracted under the treatment with warm caustic
otash—part of Schwendener’s process for rendering the hyphe distinct :
further, the cultures were afterwards put up in glycerine.

2 By pressure on the covering-glass Treub caused the germinating fila-
ment to move vigorously to and fro; the little branch of the germinating
_ filament now appeared to be so firmly attached to the Cystococeus cell
that this indeed also underwent this rough action without becoming
detached.

138 W. ARCHER.

reserve nutriment appeared to have been not yet wholly
used up from the spore.

After a three-months’ culture (in 1873) I at last saw as
the result of the meeting of the filament and alge, in the
neighbourhood of the place of contact, there had originated a
very great number of branches of the filaments, of which the
greater number had attached themselves afresh to the surface
of one or more of the alge and had produced afresh lateral
branches. The nutriment from the spores was after this
period of culture wholly used up, so that the spores had
become hyaline. Certain cases of copiously branched hyphze
might readily give rise to the conjecture that the hypha-mass
must be supported from some other source besides the reserve
material from the spore; this conjecture becomes indeed
fully confirmed by comparison with those spores which under
the very same circumstances have germinated for an equally
long time, but without the filaments having encountered
algee in their way.

The results of my research may be thus briefly expressed :

So soon as a germinating filament of a spore of a hetero-
merous lichen, or indeed one of its lateral branches, comes in
contact with an alga of the species which plays the part of
gonidia-former in the thallus of the lichen, it becomes
attached on the surface of the alga, growing thereupon to a
greater or less extent. The first result of the adhesion is
more intense growth and increase of the number of hypha-
branches, which partly in their turn again become attached
to algz, and also give off. lateral branches, so that ultimately
the alga or algal-colony which has come into contact with the
germinating filaments, becomes completely encompassed by
hyphe.

Bornet’s cultures, like mine of last year, were brought to
a standstill by intruding fungi. I may then indeed express
my opinion that the results obtained by me the previous year
and those published this summer by Bornet are equivalent.
Although the results of our cultures would lead us both to
infer the truth of Schwendener’s theory for the heteromerous
lichens, they would not however be wholly decisive, because
our cultures did not last long enough to cause the whole
of the reserve material to have become used up from the spores.
I consider, however, as regards the nature of the organic indi-
viduality of the heteromerous lichens, the results obtained in
my three-months’ culture at the beginning of this year as
decisive on the question, because not alone the Cystococcus-
cells were wholly involved by the branches of the germinating
filaments, but further the numerous ramifications of these last

ON STAINING SECTIONS WITH MAGENTA. 139

were furnished only in part by the reserve-stuff from the
spores, and thus of course for the other part were produced
at the cost of the organic nutriment from the alge involved ;
in other words, the germinating filaments and their branches
had continued to grow parasitically when once in contact
with the alge.

Though I have then not yet succeeded in producing a
perfect heteromerous lichen-thallus from its component ele-
ments, I still think I am perfectly justified in affirming that
the results of my cultures are alone explicable by assuming
the double nature of lichens; so that from the upholders of
the organic individuality of the heteromerous lichens all
arguments in its affirmation are equally taken away in an
experimental way as has been previously done by Schwen-
dener in an anatomical way.”

On Starnine Sections with Magenta. By W. HatcuHertt
Jackson, B.A., Oxon., F.L.S.

STAINING with magenta has its advantages and dis-
advantages. Like the ammoniacal solution of carmine,
magenta stains all parts of a tissue indifferently, but, unlike
carmine so used, it gives (as far as my experience goes) a
much greater depth and gradation of colour. When a thick
section is stained with carmine the tint given is so uniform
as to be but little help towards deciphering the complex
structure, but with magenta the various parts generally
assume such different tints that this is not the case.

On the other hand, magenta does not answer well when a
tissue has got rather a dark greenish colour from long soaking
in chromic acid, nor is the staining once done permanent.
This want of permanency seems to me to be due to two
causes—either the colour soaks out into the preservative
medium, or a salt of magenta (triacid) is formed by decompo-
sition, especially in the presence of light.

Some time, more than a year, ago it was suggested to me
by a friend that it would be a good thing if some method of
preserving magenta-stained specimens could be discovered.
Accordingly I set to work, and after some trouble have hit
on a process which, perhaps, may be found of service. The
_ considerations which have led me to adopt it are the
following :

Rosaniline, or magenta, is a triamine, and therefore with

140 W. HATCHETT JACKSON,

monobasic acids forms three salts, in which one, two, or
three atoms of hydrogen are replaced by the acid radicle.
The triacid salts are obtained in the presence of an excess of
acid, and are all colourless, or nearly so, for the most part
having a dull reddish-brown tint.* Adi salts of rosaniline
are soluble in alcohol, ether, glycerine, and chloroform, and
in fluids containing more than a certain percentage of these
substances. Some, e.g. the mon-acetate or mono-chloride,
are soluble also in water or watery solutions. Hence a
stained tissue plunged into water loses a certain amount of
colour, and is ultimately left in a most unsatisfactory condi-
tion. Moreover, under the influence of light and in the
presence of organic matter some of the mon-acid salts undergo
a decomposition by which a nearly colourless compound is
formed and the preparation thereby spoilt.

It appeared to me that two things were necessary :

(1) To find a stable mon-acid magenta salt.

(2) To obtain a proper preservative fluid.

The second condition can only be fulfilled by employing a
watery solution, as a// magenta salts will dissolve in glycerine,
glycerine and water, Canada balsam, dammar varnish, &c. ;
the first, by employing a mon-acid salt, insoluble or other-
wise, unchangeable in such a preservative fluid.

The salt I have found preferable is the mono-tannate; my
preservative fluid is syrup prepared in a new way.

(1) At first I stained the given tissue in magenta (solution
of crystallized magenta, or Judson’s magenta dye), and then
washed the stained tissue in a weak solution of tannic acid.
This plan is troublesome in practice, and the results are
uncertain, so that at last it was given up and the tissue
stained from the first with the mono-tannate. The best way
of making the staining solution is this:—Prepare a strong
solution of tannic acid in water, dissolve a little crystallized
magenta in water (or pour some of Judson’s dye into a test-
tube and add some water); both solutions must be cold.
Add the tannic acid solution ¢o the magenta drop by drop,
shaking the test-tube from side to side after adding each
drop, and taking care not to precipitate the magenta solution
completely. Let the precipitate settle; pour off the fluid, and
wash the precipitate by decantation several times with cold
water. Finally, let it partially dry, and add first a drop of
acetic acid, then alcohol guttatim till it dissolves. The solu-
tion is pink, and stains very quickly and deeply.

(2) Of the preservative solution I have used two kinds, and

1 But the mon-acid salts, on the contrary, are brilliantly coloured.

ON STAINING SECTIONS WITH MAGENTA. 141

prefer the second. They are both prepared with sugar. Make
a strong syrup and add to it, while hot, 3 to 4 per cent. of
either sodium chloride or, what is better, calcium chloride. The
first, or common salt syrup, does not readily crystallize, but
will do so if left exposed to the air too long (a week or so) ;
the second, or calcium chloride syrup, crystallizes with much
greater difficulty—in fact, is practically uncrystallizable.
Both are very much concentrated by exposure to air, and
become quite as dense as glycerine ; both mix readily with
water and exercise no action on tissues beyond rendering
them transparent. Neither fluid seems so liable to grow
fungi as ordinary syrup, and, as far as my experiments go, I
believe the growth of fungi may be entirely prevented by
boiling in the water one or two pieces of white pepper. I
have kept the syrup through the whole summer without a
single fungus making its appearance. If ordinary sugar is
employed in making the syrup it is always good to filter it
before use.

Besides preserving specimens stained with magenta very
well, I have found these syrups of great service in all cases
where glycerine is employed.

As to the staining fluid, I use one of two modifications—
either the simple alcoholic solution, or the fluid obtained by
adding water short of precipitation. The best way is to add
the water slowly till a slight opacity appears in the alcoholic
solution, then alcohol drop by drop till it becomes clear again,
but for most purposes the alcoholic solution answers very
well. When a specimen is kept for some time in a rather
dilute staining fluid, [ have found that the effect produced is
much better than when it is rapidly stained in a strong one.
In fact, nuclei and cells are most stained, as by Beale’s
carmine. As soon as the preparation is stained it is to be
thoroughly washed with water, which sets the colour at once.
It is then soaked and mounted in the syrup, which can be
used of any degree of concentration suitable to the tissue.
A little of the colouring matter oozes out of the interstices of
the tissue very often, but not from the tissue itself.

I generally mount the specimen on a slide, and, if thick,
in a cell, and seal the thin glass with dammar varnish or
Brunswick black.

Specimens thus prepared and mounted have been kept for
more than a year. The colour is quite unchanged, and they
have become very transparent from their long soaking in

syrup.

VOL. XIV.—NEW SER. K

142 . ERNST HAECKEL.

The GastRAEA-THEORY, the PHYLOGENETIC CLASSIFICATION
of the AntmMAL Kinepom and the Homoxoey of the
GeEeRM-LAMELLH. By Ernst Harcxer. (Translated by
E. PercevaL Wricut, F.L.S., Sec. R.I.A., Professor
of Botany, Trin. Coll., Dublin. With Pl. VII.)

I.—Tue CausaL SIGNIFICANCE OF PHYLOGENESIS IN ON-
TOGENESIS.

THE history of the development of organisms has in
these latter times entered upon a new period, in that
it has raised itself from the mere empirical inquiry into
facts requiring to be investigated to a philosophical interro-
gation into their natural causes. Indeed, the thoughtful
inquirer in the domain of biogenesis has been troubled
for more now than half a century in attempting to dive
beneath the mere knowledge of biogenetic appearances to a
deeper intelligence of their meaning, or to search after ‘‘ the
laws of organic development,”’ by the too intimate connection
of empirical observation and philosophical reflection. But so
long as the subject of the development of the organic indi-
vidual was exclusively pursued, so long could not even
such praiseworthy efforts aim at a causal knowledge. Indeed,
this satisfying of the necessities of scientific causality is only
possible since we have begun within the last decade to
investigate the natural development of organic species, and
by the story of the descent of organic species to explain the
story of the first appearance of the organic individual.

After Caspar Friedrich Wolff, in the year 1759, by his
‘Theoria generationis’ had built up epigenesis on the im-
movable foundations of a history of common development,
and after that with this strong foundation-stone for more than
half a hundred years overlooked, Christian Pander had
sketched out, in 1817, the first outlines of the germ-lamella
theory, Carl Ernst Baer, in 1828, in his ‘ Entwickelungs-
geschichte der Thiere,’ determined the direction, and defined
the path along which all subsequent embryological re-
search must move. In this classical work the quite new
science of the individual development of animals has been
laid down by the happy combination of most careful obser-
vation with philosophical reflection, as well as by the blending
together of the researches of the embryologist, the comparative
anatomist, and the systematic zoologistic, as the starting-point
of all scientific zoology, and has become the focus around
which all the different laws of this science must eventually

THE GASTRAEA-THEORY, ETC, 143

arrange themselves. The brilliant and pregnant works of
Johannes Miiller and Heinrich Rathke, which immensely
enlarged our knowledge, especially among the lower animals
have kept themselves quite entirely to this path; and
the most important work next to Baer’s essential work,
which has dealt with the history of development in animals,
the very valuable ‘ Untersuchungen iiber die Entwickelung
der Wirbelthiere,’ of Robert Remak (1851), must be looked
upon as an immediate continuation of Baer’s researches in
this path. Its principal original value consists in this,
that the empirical philosophical investigations into the
details of embryology are removed from the section treating of
organs to that treating of histology, and that the justness of
the principles which Baer had posited in reference to the
individuals of the second order—the organs, were put by him
to the proof on the individuals of the first order—the cell.
Through the wider extension which Remak gave to the
germ-lamella theory it was at the same time raised to be
the starting point of histogenesis.

If, on the one hand, the manifest correctness and perfect
validity of the ideas thus introduced by Wolff and Baer into
the history of development, and before all the fundamental
germ-lamella theory show themselves most decidedly by the
immense influence which they exercised on the very im-
portant investigations of their numerous successors; so, on
the other hand, not less, though in a negative way, was their
importance shown by the weakness of the few opponents
who attempted to leave the path which had been pointed out
to them, and to strike out into a new and quite different
direction. The most pretentious of these attempts proceeded
from Carl Boguslaus Reichert, who endeavoured, in nume-
rous separate papers, but more especially in his Memoir on
‘ das Entwickelungsleben in Wirbelthier-Reich.’ (1840), and
in his ‘ Beitragen zur Kenntniss des Zustandes der heutigen
Entwickelungsgeschichte’ (1843) to reject the germ-lamella
theory, and with it the essential first principles of zoogenesis
depending thereon, and in their stead to set up a wild con-
glomerate of fantastic conceits, that do not for one second
deserve the name of scientific hypotheses, still less to be
called theories. Whereas the before-mentioned authorities
on embryology had laboured, by clearly expressing their ideas,
and by the exposition of the laws of development, to bring
both light and order into the chaotic fulness of embryological
facts, and to explain by. falling back on simple principles
the complicated phenomena met with, Reichert attempted to
reverse this process, and thereby to obtain a temporary

144 ERNST HAECKEL,

authority, representing the simplest facts to be highly
complicated, the homogeneous as heterogeneous, and those
closely allied as being very far apart. His highly ob-
scure and confused bundle of thoughts, both on embryo-
logical and histological subjects would doubtless be very
quickly indeed forgotten, were it not that he knew how to
envelope them in a parti-coloured covering of bombastic
phraseology, garnished with an edging of philosophical tech-
nical terms, and by such a mantle to hide the emptiness that
prevailed within. Although a few were thereby truly deceived
and allowed an admiring acknowledgment of his confused
opinions to overcome them, yet these were themselves very
soon shown up in their true emptiness by Baer, Rathke,
Remak, Bischoff, Carl Vogt, and others; and thereby only
showed the more clearly the fundamental security of the
germ-lamella theory which Reichert had in vain sought to
destroy."

Just one hundred years elapsed from the appearance of the
‘Theoria generationis” when the history of development
received an impulse which gave a new direction to the beaten
path. In 1859 Charles Darwin published his epoch-making
work on the Origin of species, which, by the theory it con-
tained of Natural Selection, brought about a highly fruitful
reform of the theory of descent. This latter theory had
already been put forward in 1809, by Jean Lamarck, in his
deeply-meditated ‘ Philosophie Zoologique,’ with full con-
sciousness of its importance as a true basis of thought where-
with to found a Biological Philosophy ; but it was even with
it as with Wolff’s equally important ‘Theoria generationis,’

1 In historical reviews of the subject of the development of organic
bodies, one will frequently find mentioned with the names of Wolff, Baer,
Remak, &c. &c., also that of Reichert, as one of the meritorious promoters
of this subject. This can only be understood to mean that Reichert
contrived through his completely erroneous and unsubstantial views"of the
subject of development, and by his trifling, pretentious essays, to “bring
about a powerful reaction. Just as in histology he helped not a little to
strengthen the protoplasm theory by his strange attacks upon it, so also
bas he in a manifold manner, though indirectly, furthered scientific
embryology by his incorrect doctrine of “enveloping membranes,” by his
untrue “laws of formation,’ and by his completely erroneous views of
histogenesis. But there is no reason why, for all this, his negative services
should be compared with the positive ones of Baer, Rathke, Remak, and
the others, who have also energetically guarded themselves against such.
There are, indeed, among Reichert’s extensive embryological investiga-
tions some few useful observations (even a blind hen will sometimes stumble
on a grain of corn), but, in the gross and on the whole, they are to be classed
as works of the lowest class, and to be grouped with those by a Dénitz,
Dursy, His, and the like. A few significant ideas, which Reichert parades
as his own, he has only borrowed from Rathke and others.

’ THE GASTRAFA-THEORY, ETC. 145

it was allowed to fall into oblivion for a full half century, in
the presence of a so-called “ exact ” natural history. Lamarck
had already, with perfect precision, affirmed the common
origin of all organic beings from either one or a very few of
the simplest primitive forms. But as Darwin grounded his
theory of natural selection on the struggle for existence, and
pointed out how, under this influence, organised forms under-
went a constant slow transformation, so he went far beyond
Lamarck, and taught us to recognise the true effective causes
of the facts taught by Lamarck—the changes brought about
through inheritance and adaptability. So, also, when he
next proceeds to explain thereby the origin of organic species
and to build up a history of the development of species, he
must needs throw, at the same time, a quite new light on the
history of the development of the individual and on embry-
ology. The intimate connection in which these two branches
of the history of organic development—that of the species
and that of the individual—stand to each other could not
escape Darwin’s notice. But in his great book, that had for
its principal object the founding of the theory of selection,
and also in his subsequent works (particularly in his famous
work on the Descent of Man), he only devotes a proportionally
small space to embryology, and its great significance is but
incidentally appreciated.

In my general history of the development of organisms (in
the second volume of my ‘ Geueral Morphology,’ 1866) I
have made an attempt to establish the closeness of the inti-
mate relation of both branches of Biogenesis, and to point out
its true significance. I have there represented the paleeonto-
logical history of the development of species—Phylogenesis or
genealogical history—as the true causes of the mechanical
efficacy of the entire developmental history of the individual
which Ontogenesis or germ-history in general depends upon.
Without the former the latter could, in general, ngt exist.
The difficult part of these relations lies in this, that the con-
nection between the two is a mechanico-causal one. Onto-
genesis is a brief recapitulation of phylogenesis, mechanically
dependent on the functions of inheritance and adaptability.’

‘ In my thesis on Ontogenesis in the twentieth chapter of my ‘ General
Morphology’ (vol. 2, pp. 295—300), I have expressed this biogenetic funda-
mental law thus: “Ontogenesis, or the development of the organic in-
dividual, when the series of alteration of form which each individual organism
passes through during the whole term of its individual existence, is imme-
diately conditional on Phylogenesis, or the development of the organic stem
(Phylon) to which it itself belongs. Ontogenesis is the short and rapid
recapitulation of Phylogenesis dependent on the physiological functions of
inheritance (reproduction) and adaptability (nutrition). ‘Lhe organic indi-

146 ERNST HAECKEL.

Inheritance from a common ancestor causes the typical
agreement in form and structure which is met with in the
early stages of each class. Adaptability to the various sur-
rounding conditions of life causes the differences in form
and structure which the forms evolved therefrom exhibit in
the different species of each class.

Inheritance as a physiological function appertains to the
phenomena of reproduction. Adaptability as a physiological
function appertains to the group of phenomena of nutrition
as is pointed out in detail in the nineteenth chapter of the
‘ General Morphology ’ (p. 148—294),

Phylogenesis is the mechanical cause of ontogenesis. In
this single proposition our principal monistic conception of
organic development is clearly pointed out, and on the verity
of this principle the truth of the Gastraea-theory pre-eminently
depends. The consequences of this will unfold themselves a
little further on. For or against this proposition must every
naturalist in the future decide who, not satisfied with merely
wondering at the remarkable phenomena occurring in Bio-
genesis, will aspire beyond this to understand their full signi-
ficance. By this proposition, at the same time, is the never-
to-be-filled-up gulf marked out which separates the older
teleogistic and dualistic from the newer mechanical and
monistic morphology. If the physiological functions of
inheritance and adaptability are pointed out as the only
causes of organic structure, so therewith, at the same time,
every species of teleology, or of dualistic and metaphysical
speculation, is withdrawn from the realm of biogenesis, and
the sharp antithesis between the leading principles is there-
with clearly defined. Either there exists a direct and causal
connection between ontogenesis and phylogenesis, or there
does not. Either ontogenesis is a concise abstract of phylo-
genesis or it is not. Between the acceptance of these two
there is no third! Either epigenesis and descent, or pre-
formation and creation.

In reference to this decided alternative, His deserves speeial
notice, because he has repeatedly and definitely pronounced
himself against our fundamental laws of biogenesis, and

vidual repeats during the rapid and short course of its individual develop-
ment the most important of those changes of form which its progenitors
have passed through during the slow and long courses of their palzonto-
logical development, according to the laws of inheritance and adaptability.
This true fundamental law of organic development is the indiana basis,
upon which rests the whole inner concord of the history of develop-
ment. I repeat it here, because, firstly, its acceptation is required for the
understanding of the following discussion ; and, secondly, because it is still
combated by many respected naturalists.

THE GASTRAEA-THEORY, ETC. 147

against there being any condition between ontogenesis and
phylogenesis.! He seeks, instead of this, to explain the onto-
genetic phenomena in the most superficial manner by bend-
ings, foldings, &c. &c., without being able to assign any
further ground whatever, any operative cause, for these
“mechanical” developmental processes. The useless display
of mathematical formula which His makes cannot thereby
hide the want of a true causal principle, nor lend any worth
to his paradoxical fancies. As I have already explained in
the ‘ Biology of the Calcareous Sponges’ (p. 472), such fancies
appear only as humorous illustrations, not fit for earnest
refutation ; at the same time these big blunders prove how
necessary, for the workers in the difficult field of ontogenesis,
is the finding one’s position in the province of comparative

1 His ‘Untersuchungen iiber die erste Anlage des Wirbelthierleibes,’
Leipzig, 1868, pp. 211—223, and elsewhere. Very characteristic of his con-
ception of biogenesis are his general remarks on the subject in his dis-
course, ‘ Ueber die Bedeutung der Entwickelungsgeschichte fiir die Auffas-
sung der organischen Natur’ (Leipzig, 1870, p. 35). His considers it
necessary to guard the claims of the history of individual development
against the overwhelming power of the Darwin intuition,” and thinks “ that
the whole of the arguments derived from morphology, or the history of
development, in favour of Darwin are not for this reason of sufficient
strength, because they by no means require, as the immediate consequences
of the physiological principles of development, the explanation of the widely
circuitous genealogical relationship. If the genealogical relationship of
organic existence actually undergoes such expansion as enables it to take in
everything which the theory undertakes to sustain, so must all typical and
developmental coincidences appear as quite indisputable consequences (! !).
To reason @ posteriori from the typical and developmental coincidences to a
blood relationship, rather than more practically to acknowledge the demon-
strated growth, might, on a first glance, but not longer, be allowed. Such
a prospect discloses the different aims of development like empty realisations
of a mathematically defined circle.’ This explanation of His refutes itself
on accurate examination. But to understand the perfect baselessness of
his point of view, one need only look a little closer into the “ physiological
principles of development” by which His tries to “illustrate mechanically ”
the ontogenetic events; to eliminate the theory of descent and to deny the
connection between ontogenesis and phylogenesis. Here it needs but the
quoting of asingle example—so characteristic is it—to show the style and
manner in which His thinks to prove the principles of morphology to be
necessary consequences of a mechanical development (doe cit., p. 34). His
says: “ How simple the homology of the fore and hind limbs appears when
we know that their tirst appearance is determined by the crossing of four
folds encircling the body, like the four corners of a letter (!). How clear
also becomes the once difficult comparison of the anterior with the posterior
extremities of the body, when we also here go back to the primitive
fact that the head as well as the posterior extremities of the body finds
its termination in an unflapped fold, and that all the mechanical conditions
which accompany such an unflapped fold must make their appearance in
front as well as behind.” It would be difficult, indeed, in the whole range
of the literature of morphology, to find an example of an equally crude and
superficial explanation of a morphological relationship.

148 ERNST HAECKEL.

anatomy and the referring the ontogenetic processes to their
mechanical phylogenetic causes—their true “ cause effi-
cientes.”’ If His had only known a little of the facts of
comparative anatomy and of the ontogenesis of Invertebrata
he would scarcely have published his essays.

To perceive quite clearly the complete antithesis between
this pretended exact “ physiological” conception of ontogenesis
and our antecedent explanation of the same by phylogenesis, it
is only necessary to compare these abortive inquiries of His’s
with the masterly outline of the history of the development of
the Crustacea which Fritz Miller has given in his eminently
suggestive work, ‘ Fiir Darwin’ (Leipzig, 1864). Here the
immediate dependence of ontogenesis on phylogenesis is
proved from the multifarious range of forms of one whole
class of animals, and the former is actually explained by
means of the latter.

Here we find both the formative forces—inheritance and
adaptability—referred to as the true “ physiological” causes
of ontogenesis and the laws regulating their activity recog-
nised. ‘Two of the most important propositions which Fritz
Miller herein lays down, and which have a special bearing on
our present subject, are as follows :—The historical witness
(of ancestral development), preserved in the developmental
history (of the individual), will gradually become obliterated.
Such development always follows a direct path, from the ovum
to the perfect animal, and it will frequently, in the struggle
for life which the free living larval form must undergo, put
on a deceptive appearance.

The past history of the species (phylogenesis) would be so
much the more fully preserved in its developmental history
(ontogenesis) in proportion to the duration of its younger
stages, which also themselves pass through similar phases,
and so much the more truly the less the life-habits of the
young deviate from those of the adult forms, and the less
the peculiarities of the individual younger stages present
themselves as retrogression from a later to an earlier division
of life, or as independent entities (‘ Fir Darwin,’ pp. 77-81).
Whilst Fritz Miiller founded these laws on the ontogenesis of
various Crustacea, and from the common nauplius young
form of the most different kinds thereof, he concludes that a
common nauplius form was the ancester of the whole class,
and he explains, at the same time, a number of remarkable
phenomena, which, without this application of the theory of
descent, would remain perfectly unexplicable, not to say
incomprehensible. The causal bearing of phylogenesis on
ontogenesis may be at once perceived therefrom.

THE GASTRAEA-THEORY, ETC, 149

2. Tue CausaAL SIGNIFICANCE OF THE GASTRAEA-THEORY.

The application of the general biogenetic principles to the
different departments of special biology, and especially to the
natural systems of organisms, is a scientific problem which,
it is true, must be claimed, as a matter of course, by all
thinking biologists, but which encounters the greatest diffi-
culties at every attempt to carry it thoroughly into execution.
These difficulties in general chiefly depend on the low condi-
tion of development of our biological knowledge, on the little
participation which biology has hitherto had in the funda-
mental formative developmental functions of inheritance and
adaptability, but more especially on the great deficiencies
and incompleteness of the empirical so-called “ records of
creation” which the three schools of ontogenesis, paleon-
tology, and comparative anatomy offer us.

In spite of these great obstacles and difficulties, the import-
ance of which I do not lose sight of, I have ventured, in
1866,in my ‘ General Morphology,’ to make a first attempt to
arrive at the natural system of organisms with the help of
the biogenetic principles of the theory of descent, and in the
“ Systematic introduction to the general history of develop-
ment” (vol. 2, pp. xvii—clx) to establish phylogenesis as the
basis of the natural system. I have renewed and improved
this attempt in a more popular form in my ‘ Naturlichen
Schopfiingsgeschichte’ (1868; 4th ed., 1873). But, never-~
theless, these first attempts (as I expressly designated
them from the beginning) have, with few exceptions,
encountered only lively disapproval and decided disap-
probation among my immediate colleagues; but no one
has troubled himself to supersede my phylogenetic system by
a better one. This problem lies before any one who admits
the theory of descent, and aims at a causal comprehension of
organic forms.!

’ The best defence against the numerous attacks which my phylogenetic
system of organisms has endured seems to me to be that I am always trying
to improve it, and thus to arrive at an understanding of the causal connection
of the organic form, which cannot be arrived at in any other way. The
attacks of Riitimeyer, one of the most energetic of my opponents, in whose
opinion my genealogical tree does not agree with Darwinism and the theory
of descent, have been already disposed of in the preface to the third edition of
the ‘ Naturlichen Schopfiingsgeschichte.’ It is enough at present to quote
the naive sentence in which Rutimeyer himself aptly characterises his com-
prehension of the theory of descent :—“ Darwin’s views appear to me to be
a species of naturalist’s religion, which we can only be for or against, but
the odium theologicum is admitted as a proverb, and I do not, therefore,
imagine that much can come of it.”

150 ERNST HAECKEL.

I am now about to attempt, in the following pages,
materially to improve that first genealogical sketch of the
natural system, and with the aid of the biogenetic principles
on the one hand, and the fundamental germ-lamella theory
on the other, to establish a theory, to which I attribute a
causal importance, for the natural system of the animal
kingdom, for the comprehension of the development of its
“ types,” and for the natural relationship of its main groups,
and which I will briefly designate, in a word, as the Gastraea-
theory. Thereal purport of this Gastraea-theory depends on
the conception of a true homology of the primordial rudiment
of the intestine [Urdarm], and of the two primary germ-
lamelle in all animals except the Protozoa, and may be
briefly summed up in the following words :—“ The entire
animal kingdom divides into two chief divisions: the older,
lower group of the Protozoa (Urthiere), and the younger,
higher group of the Metazoa(Darmthiere). The main group
of the Protozoa or Urthiere (animal Monera and Ameeba,
Gregarina, Acineta, Infusoria) always increases only by the
development of the animal individuality of the first or second
order (Plastide or Idorgan); the Protozoa never form germ-
lamellz, never possess a true intestinal canal, and, especially,
never develop a differentiated tissue; they are probably of
polyphyletic origin, and branch off from many different
primevally generated Monera. ‘The main group of Metazoa,
or Darmthiere (the six races of Zoophyta, Vermes, Mollusca,
Echinodermata, Arthropoda, and Vertebrata) is, on the con-
trary, probably of monophyletic origin, and arises from a
single common root form, the Gastraea, which has sprung
from a Protozoan form; it always multiplies by developing
the animal individuality of the third or fourth order (Person
or Cormus) ; the Metazoa always form two primary germ-
lamelle, always possess a true intestinal canal (a few retro-
graded forms only excepted), and always develop differen-
tiated tissues; these tissues always arise from the two
primary germ-lamelle only which have been transferred as an
inheritance of the Gastraea of all the Metazoa, from the
simplest sponge up to the man. Next, the group of Metazoa
divided again into two sub-groups, first the Zoophyta (or
Ceelenterata), which, in consequence of their habits in life,
form the so-called radiate type ; and, secondly, the Bilateria
(or Sphenota), which, in consequence of their crawling habits
of life, form the so-called “ bilateral type.” Among the
Bilateria, the lower worms (Acelomi) agree with the
Zoophyta in the want of the ccoelom (body-cavity), and of a
circulatory system; and then, again, from these primary

THE GASTRAEA-THEORY, ETC. 151

older acwlomatous worms the higher worms (Czlomati)

have secondly developed themselves by the formation of a

celom and of acirculatory system (depending thereon). Four

divergent descendants of the ceelomatous worms form the four

typical most highly developed races of animals: the animal

stems or phyle of the Mollusca, Echinodermata, Arthropoda,
“and Vertebrata.

The firm foundation for this Gastraea-theory, and for the
widely extending consequences which we are about to deduce
from it, is explained in my monograph of the Calcareous
sponges (1872). In the preparation of this monograph I
chiefly endeavoured—firstly, to give as thorough and com-
prehensive a representation as possible of all the biological
relations of this interesting little group of animals; and,
secondly, to attempt, upon the ground of their extreme
plasticity of form, ‘“ an analytical solution of the problem of
the origin of species,” to give an analytical proof of the truth
of the theory of descent. But besides these special objects,
the developmental history of the calcareous sponges, the
discovery of their gastrula form, as well as the question of
their natural affinities, and their place in the animal system,
necessarily, and of itself, led me on to the general question of
the homology of their germ-lamelle with those of the higher
animals, and thus further on to that series of ideas whose
nucleus, in a word, forms the Gastraea-theory. The leading
ideas, which will be developed subsequently, are all con-
tained already in the monograph of calcareous sponges, but
in it there was neither room nor fitting opportunity to
develop them further. In giving here this explanation of
the Gastraea-theory, I must refer throughout to the mono-
graph of calcareous sponges for the series of special observa-
tions which serve me as a sure empirical basis."

The surest possible ground from external evidence was

* The following passages in the first volume of the ‘ Calcareous Sponges ’”
are especially to be compared :—Doctrine of individuality (pp. 89—124),
histology (pp. 1830—180), organology of the canal-system (pp. 210—292),
development (pp. 328—360), adaptability (pp. 381—391), inheritance
(pp. 899—402), and philosophy of the calcareous sponges (pp. 453—484).
In the last’ division are the reflections on the primordial form of the sponges
(p. 453), the germ-lamella theory, and the genealogical tree of the animal
kingdom (pp. 464, 465), the biogenetic principle (p. 471), and the causes of
the production of form (p. 481), are of special importance with respect to
the Gastraea-theory. In order to avoid useless repetitions, I must again
refer to these passages in the first volume (‘The Biology of Calcareous
Sponges’). Many relative observations are specially detailed in the second
volume (‘The System of Calcareous Sponges’). Illustrative figures are to
be found in the sixty plates which form the third volume (‘The Atlas of
Calcareous Sponges’).

152 ERNST HAECKEL.

obtained for the accurate division of the animal kingdom into
the two primary sections of Protozoa and Metazoa, between
which the Gastraea stands as a fast boundary-stone, by my
proving the existence of a primordial rudiment of an intes-
tine in the sponges, and my pointing out the development
from it of the two primary germ-lamelle, which furnish the
same common basis for the original formation of the body, in
all Metazoa up to the Vertebrate. On the other hand, the
demand arose to obtain for this firm boundary line a decisive
negative security by internal evidence; that it should be
proved that all the Protozoa were totally without both a
rudimentary intestine and the two primary germ-lamelle.
In this respect the Infusoria only, especially the Ciliata,
presented considerable difficulties, as their position, till very
recently, has wavered backwards and forwards between the
primitive animals, the Zoophyta, and the worms. I hope
that through my lately published investigations into the
morphology of the Infusoria'! I have definitely decided this
difficult question, and-also have thoroughly repelled the
attacks which have recently been made on the view first put
forward by Siebold (1845), that the Infusoria are unicellular
organisms, and therefore true Protozoa.

The celebrated researches into the ontogenesis of several of
the lower animals, which A. Kowalevsky has published
during the last seven years (in the Memoirs of St. Peters-
burg Academy), and which I must consider the most important
and suggestive of all recent ontogenetic works,” were of espe-
cially high value to me in proving the true homologies of
the two primary germ-lamelle, in all the Metazoa, without
which the Gastraea-theory cannot be maintained. However
Kowalevsky does not accede to the homology asserted by
me to be complete, of the two primary germ-lamelle in the
different groups of animals, and considers, for instauce,
that the intestinal glandular layer of Insecta, and the
entoderm of the Hydroida, &c., are special structures.
He also differs from me considerably about the significance
of the secondary germ-lamelle. But, on the whole, I
think I may assert, that the important facts which he has

1 *Jenaische Zeitschrift,’ vol. vii, 1873, p. 516, tt. 27, 28.

2 The ontogenetic works of Kowalevsky, especially those on Amphioxus,
Ascidia, Euaxes, Holothuria, &c., have not found by far the estimate which
they deserved. ‘This misfortune is, perhaps, chiefly due to his extremely
careless and unmethodical method of description. It is very difficult to
understand him, not only because his train of thought is deficient in logical
sequence and consecutive arrangement, but because the illustrations are
partly not described at all, partly wrongly numbered, or given without
sufficient reference to the text.

THE GASTRAEA-THEORY, ETC. 153

discovered are strong proofs of the truth of the Gastraea-theory.
This may also be said of the remarkable and valuable investi-
gations on the ontogenesis of the lower animals which Edouard
van Beneden, jun., has published in several memoirs, especi-
ally in his prize essay on the composition and significance of
the animal ovum! (1870.)

K. Ray Lankester has lately published (in May, 1873)
an essay well worth reading on the primitive germ-lamelle,
and their significance in the classification of the animal
kingdom.’ which is in substantial agreement with the suc-
cession of ideas which have led me on to the Gastraea-
theory. It is true that, in particulars, we in different ways
diverge, and especially different are our views of the secon-
dary germ-lamellz, as well as of the celom, and of the
relation of the vascular system with the primitive segment
organs. But in most respects, and especially with regard to
the homologies of the primary germ-lamelle, Ray Lankester’s
ideas completely agree with mine. This agreement is so
much the more satisfactury, as we have been working inde-
pendently of each other, and have arrived at thé same result
by different methods.

In regard to the conclusions which I subsequently draw
from the Gastraea-theory, and some of which affect the
most important principles of comparative anatomy and de-
velopmental history, as well as the classification of the animal
kingdom, I must lay claim to that liberty of natural philo-
sophical speculation (or in other words, intelligent com-
parison of empirical results), without which, in my opinion,
general biology cannot advance a step forwards. I have
fully explained my ideas of the right of necessarily combin-
ing the empirical and philosophical methods in my “ critical
and systematic introduction to the general morphology of
organisms,” as well as in my systematic introduction to the
monograph of calcareous sponges, and can here simply refer
to these detailed justifications for my adopting this stand-
point.

In any case, proof may be given by the following disqui-
sition, that Cuvier’s and Baer’s theory of types which has
formed the basis of zoological classification for more, up
to the present day, than half a century, has been rendered
untenable by the progress of ontogenesis. In its place, the

1 Edouard van Beneden, ‘ Recherches sur la composition et la signification
de |’ceuf,’ Bruxelles, 1870.

2 BK. Ray Lankester “On the Primitive Cell-layers of the Embryo as the
Basis of Genealogical Classification of Animals, and on the Origin of Vascular
eae Systems ;” ‘Annals and Mag. of Natural History,’ 1873, vol. xi,
p. 321.

154 ERNST HAECKEL.

Gastraea-theory builds up a new system on the basis of phy-
logenesis, the fundamental principles of which, as regards
classification, are the homologies of the germ-lamelle, and
the primordial rudiment of an intestine; and, secondarily,
the differentialism of the tranverse axis, and of the ccelom.

But the Gastraea-theory may attain to great importance
by this fundamental remodelling of the system of zoology, as
it is the first attempt to lead to a casual knowledge of the
most important morphological relations, and the principal
typical differences in the structure of animals, as well as to
discover the historical sequence in the origin of the animal
organization. Inheritance and adaptability here appear in
tbeir full light as modifying agents, and as the only two for-
mative factors of the organic relations of form. Inheritance
and adaptability are the only ‘‘ two mechanical causes,” with
the help of which the Gastraea-theory explains the origin of
the leading natural groups of the animal kingdom, and the
characteristic relations of their organizations.

3. THE PHYLOGENETIC SIGNIFICATION OF THE TWO
Primary GERM-LAMELL&.

The individual developmental form of the animal kingdom,
by the general distribution of which the Gastraea-theory
next supports itself, is the Gastrula (Pl. VII, figs. 1—8). In
the ‘ Biology of the Calcareous Sponges’ I have applied this
name to that very early stage of development in which the
embryonic animal-body exhibits the simplest conceivable
form of entity: a uniaxial segmented hollow body without
appendages, the simple cavity (primitive intestine) opens on
one pole of the axis by an orifice (primitive mouth), and the
body-wall consists of two cellular membranes or lamelle;
entoderm or gastral-lamella, and exoderm or dermal-lamella.!

The gastrula is the most important and suggestive em-
bryonic form in the animal kingdom. The extreme sig-
nificance which I attach to it is, firstly, supported by its
recurrence in animals of the most different groups, from the
sponges to the vertebrata in the same characteristic form and
arrangement; and, secondly, because the morphological and

1 About the right comprehension of the individuality of the entity (as of
the morphon, or of the morphological individual of the third order), compare
my ‘ Biology of the Caleareous Sponges,’ p. 113; about the right notion of
the gastrula, compare 1. ¢., p. 333. Our gastrula is identical in many
respects with the embryonic animal form, which was formerly called

planula; but in many other respects the so-called “Planula” is a very
differently constituted body.

THE GASTRAEA-THEORY, ETC, 155

physiclogical condition of the gastrula-form throws the
clearest light on the monophyletic genealogical tree of the
animal kingdom. If anybody wished to construct @ priori
as simple an animal form as possible which should possess
that most important primitive animal organ, the intestine,
and the two primary germ-lamelle, he would arrive at the
same form which the gastrula actually represents.

I have fully described the arrangement and structure of
the gastrula in the Ontogenesis of the ‘ Calcareous Sponges’
(loc. cit., pp. 383—337). It recurs in all three families of this
group of animals, and always in the same form, in the
Ascones (Asculmis armata, t. xiii, figs. 5, 6); in the
Leucones (Leuculmis echinus, t. xxx, figs. 8, 9); in the
Sycones (Sycyssa Huzleyi, t. xliv, figs. 14, 15). It every-
where displays the same essential structure, and only differs
in quite unimportant proportions. The uniaxial unsegmented
body is sometimes globular, sometimes egg-shaped or oyal ;
more rarely spheroidally flattened or lens-shaped. The
diameter mostly measures from 0:1 to 0:2 millimétre. The
primitive stomachal cavity, or the primitive intestine (pro-
gaster), is of the same conformation as the body, and opens
at one pole of the longitudinal axis by a simple oral cavity
(the primitive mouth, prostoma). The two cell-layers or
lamellae, which compose the wall of the stomach, become
differentiated in a very characteristic manner. The inner
cell-layer, the entoderm or gastral-layer, which corresponds
to the inner or vegetative germ-layer of the higher animals,
consists of large, dark, globular, or subspheral-polyhedric
cells, which differ in little from the furrowed cells of the
morula, and average 0:01 millimétre in diameter. The
outer cellular layer, the exoderm or dermal layer, which
represents the outer or animal germ-layer of the higher
animals, consists of smaller, paler, cylindrical, or prismatic
cells, each of which carries a long cilium, or vibratile body, and
is 0°02 millimétre long and only 0°004 millimétre thick.
(In the schematic representations of the gastrula, on Pl]. VII,
figs. 1—8, which belongs to this section, the cilia of the
exoderm are purposely omitted.)

In the section of the plant-like animals (Zoophyta or
Celenterata) the same gastrula-form occurs not only
in the most dissimilar sponges, but also widely distributed
in the Acalephe,! in the Hydroid polypus and Meduse, in

1 The gastrula of the plant-like animals has already been more or less
plainly described and figured in many of the older and newer works on
sponges, Hydromeduse, &c. Compare Kowalevsky’s remarks “ On the
Development of the Celenterata” (‘Gottinger Nachrichten,’ 1868, p. 154) ;
also the works of Agassiz, Allman, &c.

156 ERNST HAECKEL.

the Ctenophora and corals (P]. VII, fig. 2). In the class of the
worms the same gastrula (the so-called ‘ infusorian-like
embryo’’) occurs sometimes in exactly the same, sometimes
in a more or less modified form, in the flat-worms (Turbel-
laria, Pl. VII, fig. 3, and Trematoda); in the round worms
(Nematoda, Sagitta) ; in the Bryozoa (Polyzoa) and Tunicata
(Ascidia, Pl. VII, fig.4); in the Gephyrea and Annelida (Pho-
ronis, Kuaxes, Lumbricus, Chetopoda!). In the class of the
Kchinodermata the gastrula appears to be very widely distri-
buted in allfour-divisions, especially in the Asteride and Hoio-
thuridea? (Pl. VII, fig. 6). In the class Arthropoda the gastrula
is, indeed, nowhere any longer completely preserved in its
original simple form, but it is very easy to reduce the earliest
embryonic forms of the nauplius (as the common root-form
of the Crustacea), and of many of the lower tracheal breath-
ing forms to the gastrula? (Pl. VII, fig. 7). Im the class
Mollusca, the gastrula appears to be widely distributed,
especially in the groups of Mussels and Snails, and probably
also in the Spirobranchia ; among the snails it has been first
observed in Limnaeus* (Pl. VII, fig. 5). Lastly, in the class
Vertebrata the orginal gastrula form is only fully preserved in
the Acrania (Amphioxus, Pl. VII, fig. 8). Nevertheless the
continuity which exists between the ontogenesis of the Am-
phioxus and of the other Vertebrata leaves no doubt remain-
ing that the ancestors of the latter have passed through the
gastrula form in earlier periods of the earth’s history at the
commencement of their ontogenesis.®

The phenomenon, that the gastrula recurs in the same

‘ On the gastrula of the worms, the works of Kowalevsky are especially
to be consulted— Mémoires de |’Académie de St. Pétersburg,’ tom. x, No.
15 (1867) ; tom. xvi, No. 12 (1871); his ontogenesis of Phoronis, of the
Ascidia, and his embryological studies on worms and Arthropoda.

2 The gastrula of the Echinodermata are made intelligible to us by the
figures of Johannes Miller, of Alexander Agassiz (‘ Embryology of the
Starfish,’ Pl. I, fig. 25—28), and by Kowalevsky (‘ Ontogenesis of the
Holothuria’).

3 That the ancestors of the Arthropoda must also have developed them-
selves from the gastrula, is clearly proved by the comparison of their
simplest and earliest immature condition with the gastrula of the worms.
Compare especially the works of Edouard van Beneden and Bessels ‘On
the ontogenesis of the Crustacea,’ and of Weismann ‘ On the ontogenesis
of Insects.’

4 HE. Ray Lankester has described the gastrula of the Mollusca in a
recent paper (‘Annals and Mag. of Natural History,’ Feb., 1873, pp. 86,
87). In many mussels and snails it is developed in exactly the same
manner as in the Zoophytes, worms, Echinodermata, Amphioxus, &c.

© The gastrula of the Vertebrata, which only now persists in Ampbioxus
has been made known to us by Kowalevsky in his ontogenesis of this oldest
Vertebrate animal (1. c., Pl. I, figs. 16, 17).

THE GASTRAEA-THEORY, ETC. 157

actual construction and form as the earlier condition of indi-
vidual development in representatives of all the animal
groups (except only the Protozoa), is a biogenetic fact of the
greatest significance, and confirms the safe conclusion accord-
ing to a biogenetic fundamental law, that all the phyle of
the animal kingdom (except the Protozoa) branch off from a
single common unknown root-form, which was formed
essentially like the gastrula. In the ‘ Philosophy of the
Calcareous Sponges’ (I. c., pp. 345, 347, 467) I have called
this primitive, long extinct root-form; which must have
existed already in the earlier primordial time (during the
Laurentian period) the Gastraea. ‘The acceptation of this
root-form, whose next descendants during that period pro-
bably appeared in many different genera and species of
Gastraeada, is firmly established by the homology or mor-
phological identity of the gastrula in the most different
- groups of animals. It is therefore a witness of special sig-
nificance that the cells of both germ-lamelle have everywhere
retained their distinctive characters (by inheritance). The
cells of the inner germ-lamella or entoderm are everywhere
distinguished by their undifferentiated condition ; their shape:
is globular or irregularly polyhedric, their protoplasm is
opaque, granular, diffluent, with oil-globules, and is quickly
and intensely coloured by carmine ; their nucleus is generally
globular; for the most part they are not vibratile. On the
other hand, the cells of the outer germ-lamella, or exoderm,
are further differentiated ; their form is mostly cylindrical or
conical ; their protoplasm is pale,clear compact, with no oil-
globules, and is coloured more slowly and less intensely by
carmine ; their nucleus is generally elongated ; the exoderm
cells mostly vibratile.! These are apparently more strongly
modified by adaptation to the surrounding outer world than
the interiorly placed entoderm cells, which have more truly
preserved the original character of the morula cells. ‘The
ontogenetic formation and increase also proceeds more rapidly
in the exoderm than in the entoderm cells.

From the gastrula homologous in all the groups of
animals (except the Protozoa) follows necessarily the true
homology of the primitive rudiment of the intestine in all
animals, as well as the homology of the two primary germ-
lamellz, in all those higher animals which have lost the
original gastrula-condition by the law of contracted inherit-

1 The differences between the protoplasm of the exoderm and entoderm
cells are altogether analogous to the differences between the hyaline cortical
Jayer (exoplasm) and the granular medullary layer (endoplasm) in the uni-
cellular animal bodies of the Infusoria, Amceba, &c.

VOL. XIV.—NEW SER, L

158 ERNST HAECKEL.

ance. I consider this homology so extremely important that
I accept in this evidence the monophyletic origin of the six
groups of higher animals from the common root-form of the
Gastraea, and place them all together as germ-lamella
animals (Metazoa or Blastozoa) as opposed to the primitive
animals which have not yet arrived at the germ-lamella
stage. This consideration forms the nucleus of the Gastraea-
theory, the most important consequences of which will be
subsequently developed.

Huxley had, in 1849, already asserted that the two per-
manent foundation membranes of the Acalephe, entoderm
and exoderm, were truly homologous to the germ-lamelle of
the higher animals, see his excellent dissertation ‘‘ On the
anatomy and the affinities of the Meduse.”! Subsequently,
Kowalevsky has laboured in a series of very suggestive
ontogenetic works, to extend this homology over the largest
part of the animal kingdom, and to show that (with few —
exceptions) the two well-known original germ-lamelle of
the Vertebrata also make their appearance in invertebrate
animals of the most different groups. His brilliant dis-
covery of the identical ontogenesis of the Amphioxus and
the Ascidia (1867), one of the most significant and sug-
gestive discoveries of modern zoology, was especially im-
portant in this respect.” This homology of the two primor-
dial germ-lamelle, and the organs immediately originating
therefrom is carried out furthest, but, at the same time,
in a partially restricted manner, in Kowalevsky’s latest
work, the ‘ Embryological Studies on Worms and Arthro-
poda’ (1871). This theory has next met with the most
acute discernment and the most decided advocacy from

‘ ¢ Philosophical Transactions,’ 1849, p. 425 :—“ A complete identity of
structure connects the ‘foundation membranes’ of the Meduse with the
corresponding membranes in the rest of the series ; and it is curious to remark,
that throughout, the inner and outer membranes appear to bear the same
physiological relation to one another as do the serous and mucous layers of
the germ; the outer becoming developed into the muscular system and
giving rise to the organs of offence and defence; the inner, on the other
hand, appearing to be more closely subservient to the purposes of nutrition
and generation.”

2 The significant importance which we attribute to Kowalevsky’s
discoveries, which were corroborated by Kupffer, rests, in our opinion, on
two points. First, because the deep gulf between the Vertebrata and
Invertebrata, hitherto considered impassable, and a chief impedient to the
theory of descent, is thereby filled up. Secondly, the original ontogenetic
development of the Vertebrata, as well as of the most dissimilar Inverte-
brata, from the gastrula, with their common descent from the Gastraea, is
thereby also proved. All the attempts which have recently been made by
different authors to dispute the fact of this fundamental discovery, or to
weaken its signification, appear to be so feeble, that they need no refutation.

THE GASTRABA-THEORY, ETC. 159

Nikolaus Kleinenberg, in his excellent monograph of
Hydra, a work which occupies a prominent position among
recent morphological works by the happy union therein
of the most accurate objective observation, and clear phi-
losophical reflection. Finally, I have myself proved in the
biology of the calcareous sponges (1. c. 464), that the two
primary germ-lamellz persist throughout life in the sponges
in their simplest form, and that the outer animal germ-la-
mella simultaneously fulfils the animal functions of sensation
and locomotion, the formation of the skeleton and integu-
ment, while the inner vegetative germ-layer performs solely
the vegetative functions of nourishment and reproduction. I
have, at the same time, applied the germ-lamella theory
directly to the monophyletic genealogical tree of the animal
kingdom, and have thus attempted to supply a firm bio-
genetic basis for a Natural system.

Only the two primary germ-lamelle and the primitive in-
testinal cavity which they enclose can be considered as
completely homologous, in the strictest sense, throughout the
whole animal kingdom (?. e. after excepting the Protozoa, in
all Metazoa, from the Sponges to the Vertebrata). The two
cell-layers of the gastrula and of the Gastraeada which it
repeats, as well as the exoderm and entoderm of the sponges,
are, in this strictest sense, doubtless completely homologous
with the two primary germ-lamelle in the embryos of the Ver-
tebrata, Arthropoda, Mollusca, Echinodermata, and Vermes.
The apparent difficulties in the way of this complete homology
caused by the formation of a nutritive yelk (and the conse-
quent partial grooving incident thereto) in most of the higher
animals are easy to set aside and to explain by secondary
adaptation. On the other hand, this homology becomes in-
complete as soon as the two primary germ-lamelle begin to
differentiate and to develop between them a middle cell-layer
(mesoderm). ‘The ontogenesis of the plant-like animals and
worms plainly teaches us that this middle germ-lamella is
constantly derived as a secondary product from one of the two
primary germ-lamellz, or perhaps from both simultaneously.
One or both of the primary germ-lamelle must, therefore,
necessarily undergo a differentiation in the production of the
mesoderm, and can consequently be no longer exactly com-
pared with the two unaltered and permanent germ-lamelle
of the Gastraeada and Sponges (exoderm and entoderm).
They must now, like the mesoderm-layer itself, rather be
distinguished as secondary germ-layers.'

' The primitive homology of the gastrula in all the different animal
groups, from the sponges to the Vertebrata, from which we directly infer

160 ERNST HAECKEL,

4. Tur PHYLOGENETIC SIGNIFICATION OF THE FouR
SECONDARY GERM-LAMELL”.

Whereas the homology of the two primary germ-lamelle
with the exoderm and entoderm of the gastrula, and their
phylogenetic identity in all the groups of animals (except the .
Protozoa), may be accepted with tolerable certainty, on the
other hand, the comprehension and interpretation of the so-
called mesoderm, or of the middle (third) germ-lamella, and
of all the parts which spring from this between the two
primary germ-lamelle, is still subject to many doubts. The
contradictions which exist, in this respect, between the dif-
ferent authors are so great and fundamental that it is
altogether impossible, in the present condition of ontogenetic
literature, to bring them into agreement. Not only is the
origin and further development of the middle germ-lamella
quite differently described in the different groups of animals, but
even in one and the same animal (for instance, in the common
hen or in the trout) different observers affirm completely
opposite facts with equal certainty. One author makes the
mesoderm to proceed from the lower germ-lamella just as posi-
tively as a second author makes it proceed from the upper
germ-lamella; a third author thinks that one part of the meso-
derm arises from the lower, and another part from the upper
germ-lamella ; while a fourth author actually makes a portion
of the middle germ-lamella, or perhaps even the whole, wander
inwards “ from the outside!’’ from the unorganised nutritive
yelk. Even if we wish to make excuses for a large part of these
irreconcilable contradictions on account of the difficulty of
observation, yet the larger portion is certainly due only to the

the true homology of the intestine in all these animals, and their common
descent from the Gastraea, is of such importance, that I will at least reply
‘to the most important of the objections which may be raised against it.
These objections concern the apparently very different origin of the gastrula
from the morula. In most cases a globular cell-vesicle arises from the
morula, the wall of which is formed by a cell-membrane. As this
vesicle inverts itself at one point, it forms a cup with two surfaces. If this
inversion is complete, so that the invaginated portion (entoderm or gastral
layer) attaches itself on the inside to the outer, uninvaginated portion
(exoderm or dermal layer), the gastrula is complete. This seems to be
the original manner of the formation of the gastrula. On the other hand,
in other cases the morula hollows itself out internally, and the central
hollow (stomachic cavity), the wall of which consists of two layers, subse-
quently breaks through externally (oral opening). This mode of formation
of the gastrula seems to he abridged from the first by inheritance. The
result is just the same in both cases, and the apparently significant
difference of the genesis is secondary, and to be considered as the result of
adaptation, as Ray Lankester (1. ¢., p. 330) has very well shown.

THE GASTRAEA-THEORY, ETC, 16]

careless or unmethodical methods of the observers. It is just
in the ontogenesis of the mesoderm that it strikingly appears
how necessary for ontogenétic investigations is it to constantly
look to comparative anatomy and phylogenesis.

In order to overcome the difficulties which the origination
of the middle or motor germ-lamella really presents, it may be
advisable, first of all, to separate from the beginning the two
really different substances of which it subsequently appears
to be composed, namely, first, the outer lamella: Baer’s mus-
cular layer, Remak’s cuticular layer ; (better fibrous cuticular
layer) or the muscular cuticular layer (parietal layer of the
mesoderm); and, secondly, the inner lamella: Baer’s vas-
cular layer, Remak’s intestinal fibrous layer or muscular
intestinal fold (visceral layer of the mesoderm). There are
very important reasons for supposing that these two lamell
are phylogenetically originally distinct, although they ap-
pear ontogenetically in many animals as secondary diffe-
rentiations of an appareutly simple middle lamella. This view
was already maintained by Baer, who makes the two primary
germ-lamelle divide each into two lamelle. From the division
of the outer or animal germ-lamella arises the cuticular layer,
and the muscular layer ; from the division of the inner or vege-
tative germ-lamella arises the vascular layer, and the mucous
layer. But this view was subsequently almost entirely aban-
doned, and it was believed that at first, a third central lamella
arises from one only of the two primary cell lamelle, and that
the “‘ muscular layer” and the ‘ vascular layer” are products
of the division of the latter.

In any case the first appearance of the mesoderm seems in
the Vertebrata to be indistinguishable, so that its entire cellular
mass must be derived form one of the two primary germ-lamelle.
Only the fact that some of the more reliable observers derive
the middle lamella from the upper (animal) cell lamella, while
others derive it, in one and the same vertebrate animal from
the lower (vegetative) cell lamella, with equal positiveness,
gives rise to the suspicion that both the primary germ-lainellz
subdivide for the construction of the middle germ-lamella.
This suspicion becomes almost a certainty by a comparison
with the development of the mesoderm in the different Inver-
tebrata, where, in many cases, only the cuticular muscular
layer is developed from the upper germ-lamella, whereas the
intestinal muscular layer is developed from the lower germ-
lamella. Among many observations relating to this, those of
Kowalevsky on Euaxes are especially significant. (Petersb.
Mem., 1871, vol. xvi, No. 12, pp. 16,t. III). There are also
numerous yery recent observations on Vertebrata, which

162 ERNST HAECKEL,

appear to show that the same method of development occurs
originally and primarily in them, and that the union of the
two muscular layers in the simple middle germ-lamella is a
secondary occurrence, while the consequent division of the
latter into the two first is a tertiary process (vide Pl. VII,
fig. 11—16, with explanation). In connection with this sub-
ject the closest examination of the processes in the axial parts
of the vertebrate germ-lamella seems to be specially important.
Here all the cell-layers appear to be very early already more
or less intimately united to the undifferentiated cell mass,
which His designates by the name of the axial cord, and
which he considered with the germ-lamella to form part of
the original coverings of the embryo. This last view is cer-
tainly quite talse. For the division of the two primary germ-
lamellz is above all things originally complete, as we learn by
comparing the gastrula in the different groups of animals ;
and their union in the axial cords of the Vertebrata is to be
regarded as a secondary coalescence. But it appears to be
a very important observation that this axial cord is composed of
cells of the lower and upper germ-lamella, and that it furnishes
cells for the lower as well as for the upper lamella of the
mesoderm. The fact is also very suggestive, that a hori-
zontal division of the side layers, which extend nearly to
the axis, takes place also very early indeed, in many Verte-
brata just after the separation of the chorda from the side-
layers, and even before the differentiation of the layers of
the rudimentary vertebre. In any case this separation of
the mesoderm into two middle layers vanishes again during
the separation of the layer of the rudimentary vertebra; but
it is perhaps to be regarded as a precursor of the later per-
manent separation of the side layer. As decidedly of im-
portance for this question, I might quote the observation of
Kowalevsky, according to which only the dermal muscular
layer in Amphioxus undoubtedly arises from the outer, while
the intestinal muscular layer arises from the inner germ-
lamella. Both muscular layers are here completely separated
originally (1. c., p. 6, t. ii, fig. 20). Comp. Pl. VII, fig. 13.
If we examine this difficult problem by the light of the
‘Theory of Descent,’ it appears to be most probable that the
cells of the intestinal fibrous layer or of the intestinal mus-
cular layer are developed from the cells of the gastral or
vegetative lamella in a similar manner to that in which the
cells of the dermal fibrous layer or of the dermal muscular layer
are originally formed from the cells of the dermal or animal
lamella. For the last process the important discovery of
Kleinenberg is highly significant, according to which the

THE GASTRAEA-THEORY, ETC. 163

muscular threads of the Hydra (the first beginning of the
mesoderm) do not become independent cells, but remain as
only thread-like processes of the nervous cells of the outer
cell-layer, the ‘“‘ neuro-muscular cells.”

It is not intended to imply by this that the mesoderm
is always originally composed of these two layers. As both
muscular layers subsequently arose independently of each
other, the dermal—the cuticular muscular sheath—as an
organ of departure for the skin ; the gastral—the intestinal
muscular sheath—as an organ of departure for the intestine ;
therefore the case is also phylogenetically conceivable that
only one of the two developes itself. This is actually
the case in some Hydroida, and probably in the majority of
the Acalephe ; the intestinal muscular layer is here absent
and the entire mesoderm is a product of the exoderm, and,
therefore, with all its parts, corresponds only to the cuticular
muscular layer. —

As the two muscular layers in the axial portions of the
body cohere at first in the Vertebrata, and only separate
afterwards, we can explain, by a very old process of growth, the
four originally separated secondary germ- lamelle, which are
found in the axis of the body in the ‘oldest Acrania, and stand
in original connection with the origin of an inner central
axial skeleton (the chorda). As the germ-lamelle are already
early intimately connected in the “ axial cord,” from which
results many an ontogenetic obscuring and abridgment of the
original phylogenetic processes, it indicates also the very
early differentiation of the chorda and many other special
processes, which occur early in these axial portions of the
body. On the other hand, we can satisfactorily explain, not
only many of these peculiar processes, but also the contra-
dictions of most authors by the view that this central “ axial
cord” isa secondary process of growth, and that subsequently
both primary germ-lamellz (in the five higher groups of ani-
mals) take part in the composition of the mesoderm.

By this view the origin of the body-cavity can be very
easily physiologically explained. It can be _ pictured
quite mechanically as soon as it is remembered that the two
muscular layers just developed have a simultaneous action
independently of each other. A division is then necessarily
produced between the two, and fluid collects in the cavity
thus formed. This fluid transfuses through the intestinal
wall into the primitive body-cavity, and is the first blood,
and separate cells of the intestinal fibrous layer, detached
during the transudation, which remain in this primitive blood-
fluid and multiply, are the first blood-cells.

164 ERNST HAECKEL.

The true body-cavity of animals, the ccelom (or the so-
called ‘‘ pleuroperitoneal cavity’) has, therefore, also arisen
phylogenetically in a similar manner by the two muscular
layers or middle germ-layers shrinking apart, as is known
to be the fact ontogenetically, since the time of Remak, in
the embryology of Vertebrata. ‘The mesentery is formed
where the two layers remain in connection, and keep the in-
testine firmly attached to the body-wall.. I have already
fully detailed my morphological idea of the body-cavity in
the ‘ Biology of 'Calcareous Sponges’ (p. 467), and, therefore,
content myself here with again expressly making it promi-
nent that, according to my view, the ccelom has first arisen
in the Vermes by the above-mentioned process (shrinking
apart of the two muscular layers), and has been transferred
as an inheritance from these to the four higher groups of aui-
mals. On the other hand, the ccelom, or true body-cavity, .
is “absent in all the Zoophyta (sponges and Acalephe), as well
as in the lowest worms, the Plathelminthia (Turbellaria,
‘Trematoda, Cestoda). With the colom, the blood, and
the vascular system is at the same time absent in these
animals, for these parts are inseparably united. Where the
first trace of true body-cavity appears, the first blood is
also already present, namely, the secretion which fills the
latter, the primitive ‘‘ Hemolymph” or “ Hemochyle.”

This view of the coelom places me in direct antagonism with
the view of Leuckart, already shared by most zoologists, who
attributes to the Zoophytes (his Coelenterata) a true ceelom,
and as late as 1869 represented his opinions thus: ‘‘ The
body-cavity of the Coelenterata does not lie between the
exoderm and entoderm, but is enclosed by the latter,” just

1 The technical term c@lom, which I have proposed in the ‘ Biology of
Calcareous Sponges’ (p. 468), for the true body-cavity of animals, is prefer-
able to the hitherto customary expression “ pleuroperitoneal cavity,” not only
on account of its greater shortness and convenience, but, before all, because
the other term is not applicable at allin a strict sense to the Iuvertebrata,
and applies to the latest and most differentiated condition of the ccelom, as
it occurs only in the highest Vertebrata.

2 Leuckart says (in the ‘Archiv fiir Naturgeschichte,’ 1870, II, p. 270),
“The opinion that the inner hollow structure of Coelenterata corresponds in
its morphological significance to the body-cavity of otler animals, has met
with pretty general acceptance in our science—a view which anatomical
relations not only justify, but also compel the observer to agree with,” &c.
In reply to this we may remark that Van der Hoeven characterised the
Acaleph twenty years ago in his ‘ Natural History’ (furnishing corrections
to Leuckart) quite correctly in the following words :—“ Ventriculus paren-
chymato corporis sine cavitale abdominali welusus: cauales e ventriculo
ortum duceutes.” Gengenbaur (1861), Noschin (1865), Semper (1867),
and Kowalevsky (1868), have subsequently in the same sense correctly

ATMOSPHERIC MICROGRAPHY. 165

as little can I share the opinion of Kowalevsky, who declares
the invaginated cavity or segmentation cavity to be. the first
trace of the body-cavity. I can enly perceive in the hollow
which is formed during the grooving between the furrowed
cells, and which afterwards forms the hollow of the germinal
vesicle (vesicula blastodermica), a casual hollow without
any permanent morphological signification. It, indeed, always
disappears again in the course of ontogenesis, and never passes
directly into the true celom. This last makes its first
appearance much later, as a really new formation, a division
between the two muscular layers. According to Kowalevsky’s
view, the celom would be phylogenetically much older than
the intestinal cavity, whereas the reverse is actually the case.
The intestine has certainly existed very long as a primitive
organ in the Zoophyta and Accelomi, before it developed (in
the Coelomati) the true body-cavity between the intestinal
wall and body-wall.

(To be continued.)
“

ATMOSPHERIC MicroGrapHy, by the Rev. M. J.
BERKELEY, M.A., F.L.S.

Since Ehrenberg’s remarkable treatise on the ‘ Dust of the
Trade Winds,’ numerous observations have been made on the
various substances which float in the atmosphere, either in
connection with their supposed influence in the production or
promotion of disease, or with reference to the great contro-
versy respecting spontaneous generation. ‘These observations
were, however, frequently made in utter ignorance of the
true nature of the organisms in question, or with strong pre-
judices in favour of some particular theory, in aid of which
they were interpreted. It became part of the duties of Dr.
Cunningham and Dr. Lewis, who were sent to India by our
Government to investigate thoroughly everything which
might throw light on the origin of cholera aud other for-
midable diseases to which our Eastern possessions are
especially subject, and from which one of the most formidable
in other countries certainly originated, amongst other mat-
ters, to see what was really carried about by the winds, and
the results of the inquiry which more peculiarly fell to the
share of Dr. Cunningham are certainly most extraordinary.

regarded the celenteric system of cavities in the Zoophyta as an intestinal
cavity.

166 ' REV. M. J. BERKELEY.

The pains which he has taken to collect all accessible previous
information on the subject, and the entire freedom from all
prejudice, added to an accurate knowledge of the minuter
forms of vegetation and of animal organisms, are amply
manifested in the valuable treatise which has lately been
received in this country from Calcutta.!

The work commences with a review of the literature of
Atmospheric Micrography, the necessity for which is thus
stated: ‘‘ Similar observations have been previously recorded
by numerous other authors, and before proceeding to those
forming the subject of the present report, it may be well
briefly to review the literature relating to them, with a view
to ascertain what our knowledge of the question really
amounts to. It is the more desirable to do this as no
general summary of the kind has, as far as I know, ever been
attempted, and the information is scattered through scientific
journals and the transactions of learned societies in isolated
papers, many of which are, when taken separately, likely to
lead to very imperfect conceptions regarding the subjectyas a
whole. In attempting anything of this kind I am well aware
that the result is likely to contain numerous omissions and
other imperfections, more especially in a country such as this,
where there is great difficulty in obtaining access to the
requisite information, but, such as it is, it may yet be of use
in rendering the latter part of the report more intelligible
than it might otherwise be, and in facilitating an estimate of
the value of any conclusions there stated. A chronological
order has been as much as possible adhered to, the first obser-
vation recorded by any author being taken asa starting point
for a sketch of his after work; and where this is not so, or
when due prominence does not seem to have been given to
any set of observations, the error is to be entirely ascribed to
lack of information, and not to any desire to undervalue or
neglect any one’s work.”

The observations were made at the two large jails in Cal-
cutta, with the view of determining, if possible, whether there
were any connection traceable between the prevalence of any
special bodies in the atmosphere, and the occurrence of par-
ticular forms of disease. They were fifty-nine in number, the
date of the first being the 26th of February, and that of the
last the 18th of September, 1872.2 The apparatus was a

1 “Microscopic Examinations of Air,’ by D. Douglas Cunningham, M.B.,
Surgeon H.M. Indian Medical Service (on special duty), attached to Sanatory
Commissioner with Government of India. Calcutta, Fol. p. 78, tab. xiv,
Diag. iv, fig. 10.

2 The climate at Calcutta is very dry from the former date to the beginn-

ATMOSPHERIC MICROGRAPFHY. 167

modification of that employed by Dr. Maddox, the whole
turning freely, so as to present its orifice constantly to the
wind, the particles impinging on a vertical slip of microscopic
glass painted with glycerine, and capable of being transferred
without danger of their being rubbed off, to the table of the
microscope, care being taken that everything was made pre-
viously as clean as possible.

In the Presidency jail the apparatus was placed within the
largest enclosure, on an open space of grass, to the east of a
large tank in which the native prisoners bathe. The most
convenient locality at Alipore was to the north of the hospital-
tank, between the compound ef the jail and the tidal nullah,
from which it was separated by the wall of the enclosure.
The diaphragm was removed every twenty-four hours. The
magnifying power was in general 400 diameters, but higher
powers, ranging from 800 to 1000 diameters, were used for
more minute bodies. Dust from shelves of iron or stone was
purposely excluded, as alge or other bodies might have grown
up from particles conveyed from the soil, rather than from the
atmosphere. The mouth of the apparatus was about five feet
from the ground.

On microscopic examination the deposits were found to
consist of various matters.

1. Particles of silicious matter.

2. Particles of carbonaceous matter.

3. Fragments of hair and other animal substances.

4, Fragments of cellular tissue of plants.

5. Pollen grains, amongst which those of several common
grasses could be easily recognised,' and a few belonging to.

ing of June, and more or less wet to the beginning of September, which
accords with the dates appended to the figures.

1 This may be of importance after the very interesting observations of
Mr. Blackley on the connection between the pollen grains of grasses and
hay asthma. [A brief record may be given here of Mr. Blackley’s
results. ‘I'hey were commenced in April, and continued till the end of
July. In one series the air of a meadow at the average breathing level,
4 feet 9 inches from the ground, was examined. A slip of glass, coated
with athin layer of a non-drying liquid, was exposed horizontally. ‘The
daily results are tabulated. The highest number of pollen grains obtained
on asurface of a square centimetre in twenty-four hours was 880 on June 28.
Sudden diminutions in the quantity of pollen—when these occurred in tlie
ascending scale between May 28 and June 28—were invariably due to a
fall of rain, or to this and a fall in the temperature combined. ‘The amount
of pollen in the higher strata of the atmosphere was examined by means of a
kite, which by being attached to other kites sometimes attained an elevation
of 1000 feet. Pollen was found to be much more largely present at the
upper levels than at the “ breathing level,” in the proportion, in fact, of 19 to
1. Abundant proof was also obtained of the presence of fungoid spores in

168 REV. M. J. BERKELEY.

plants of other natural orders. It is not certain that any
seeds of Phanerogams reached the diaphragm, though one or
two of the figures, except for their small size, might at first
seem to intimate as much.

6. Algee. These were, in comparison, few in number, but
besides those lower genera which appear to be early stages of
lichens, there were undoubted fragments of Oscillatorie,
as in t. iv, fig. 2, t. vili, fig. 4, of Desmidiacee, as in t.
v, fig. 1,1 of Clostercum in t. xii, fig. 3, and apparently of
Diatomacee in t. i, fig. 4. These latter are, however, if
present at all, extremely rare.

7. Sporidia of lichens are frequent.

8. Far the greater part of the bodies are spores or sporidia
of fungi, often at once referrible to their proper genera.
Spores of Macrosportum, and one or two allied genera are
extremely common. Cladosporium herbarum, one of the
most universally diffused fungi, appears in one case with a
spore in sitd. Helminthosporium is represented (apparently
HT, Smithii) in t. vi, fig. 1. Sportdesmium is not un-
frequent. True Torule do not appear to be present,
but the yeast fungus, which, after proof that it is nothing
more than a condition of common species of Penicilium,
Aspergillus, and Mucor, is so often referred to TYorula,
or to Alye, frequently occurs, either in scattered particles,
or branched. A young Mucor with its sporangia is visible
in t. ii, fig. 3. The curious genus Tetraploa, which has
occurred once only in England and once in Cuba, is not un-
frequently represented, most probably being not uncommon
on some of the native grasses, and Zrzposporium appears in
t. vi, fig. 2. Spores of Uredinee are frequent, Puccinia,
except in an early stage, much less so. Far the most
common bodies are sporidia of Spheriacee frequently in a
state of germination, both in dry and hot seasons. So little
is known of the species belonging to this order of fungi in
the neighbourhood of Calcutta, that they cannot with cer-
tainty be referred to their proper group, much less to their

large quantities in the air. Jn one experiment the spores of a cryptogam,
at 1000 feet, were so numerous that they could not be counted; at a rough
estimate they could not be less than 30-40,000 to the square inch. That
these organized contents travel through the air to a considerable distance
was proved by a series of experiments made in the outskirts of Manchester,
but within the boundary of one of the most densely populated parts, and in
no direction within less than one third of a mile of grass land. The quantity
of pollen was about one tenth of that collected in the country.—‘ Experi-
mental Researches on the Causes and Nature of Catarrlus zstivus,’ by
C. H. Blackley, 1873.—Eps. |
1 At least, the lower figure seems to suggest as much.

EE SL

ATMOSPHERIC MICROGRAPHY. 169

species, nor is it certain that they are derived from the im-
mediate neighbourhood. It is very probable that several of
the bodies are spores of Myzogastres, the amcebe which
appear in certain specimens of pure rain water, being very
probably the mere development of Myzogastres-spores, in
accordance with the well-known observations of Prof. de Bary.
It would be easy to point out many which are more probably
referrible to Myzxogastres than to any other fungi. Spores
of some of the higher! fungi may possibly be intermixed,
but their structure is in general so simple that they are not
easily recognized. In one instance, however, in the miscel-
laneous observations recorded in Section III, fig. 4, there is
apparently the germinating spore of Tremedla or some neigh-
bouring genus. The extraordinary quantity of fungus spores
carried about by the air is very remarkable, and the more so,
when contrasted with Ehrenberg’s observations of the dust of
the trade winds.

It is necessary to take notice of some observations which
were made on matters contained in the air of sewers, care
being taken that there was no communication with the out-
ward air. Many years since Lord Sydney Godolphin Osborn
made a very praiseworthy attempt to ascertain what bodies
might be derived in the air from the mouths of sewers.
These observations were communicated to ‘ Household
Words.’ It is, however, obvious, that the plan then adopted
would not insure the derivation from the sewer, as similar
bodies might be conveyed from the external air; peculiar
cautions, therefore, were taken to avoid this uncertainty. The
results were very different from the open-air observations. The
only spores*(with very few exceptions, and those far from
certain) which appeared, were those of Aspergillus and Peni-
cillium, which were developed abundantly on the walls of the
sewer, and these in four out of eight experiments were
accompanied with bacteria. Oily particles were frequent,
and fine molecular matter of an uncertain nature, in addition
to small quantities of carbonaceous and silicious particles,
and a few minute portions of cellular vegetable tissue.

The following observations on the presence of bacteria
are important, as not opposed to the atmospheric trans-
mission of these organisms :—‘‘ The existence of distinct
bacteria in half of the specimens is also very worthy of
consideration when the extreme rarity of such organisms

1 In two melted flakes of snow from Highgate sent to me mounted on
slides many years since, there were undoubted spores of fungi, some of
which were possibly referrible to higher fungi. All were perfectly colourless
and transparent.

170 REV. M. J. BERKELEY.

in a recognisable form as a constituent of common atmo-
spheric dust is recollected. Their presence here accords with
Cohn’s observation on their conveyance by watery vapour,
and suggests that their apparent absence in ordinary atmo-
spheric air is due, not to their not entering in it in large
quantities, but to the fact that unless the amount of watery
vapour present is very great they lose their characteristic
appearance, by which, in default of movement, they can only
be recognised’: (p. 52). The addition of dry dust to fluids
capable of undergoing putrefaction was followed by their
copious appearance, and they also were met with in pure
rain-water. It might, however, have been expected that
they would have appeared at the commencement of the rainy
season, which is generally preceded by a peculiar vaporous
condition of the air in many parts of India, but whether
this is the case at Calcutta there is no means at present of
ascertaining.

It is not necessary to give at length the general conclusions
here, and, indeed, most of them have been anticipated above.
The main and most important is the following :—“‘ No con-
nection can be traced between the numbers of bacteria,
spores, &c., present in the air and the occurrence of diar-
rhea, dysentery, cholera, ague, or dengue, nor between the
presence or abundance of any special form or forms of cells
and the prevalence of any of these diseases.”

In a more strictly botanical point of view the occurrence
of such numerous fungus-spores of such various kinds, in a
situation where they could scarcely have been suspected to
be present, and the fact of so many of them being in a
state of germination is most interesting. It is impossible to
say from whence the greater part of them were derived, but
one understands at once how it is possible that the same
fungus may occur in very different latitudes, provided the
climatic conditions are sufficiently favorable.

It is possible that some of the spores may have germinated
on the diaphragm during the twenty-four hours in which it
was exposed to the air, but, as Dr. Cunningham says, it is
impossible to think that this is the case in such prepara-
tions as t. xii, fig. 2, and he believes ‘that germination may
take place while the spores or sporidia are wafted through
the air. And this is the more probable, as they would very
rarely be taken up in such a condition. If this be true the
germs would settle on their proper matrix in a condition
most favorable for immediate propagation.

Some interesting observations were made on the or-
ganisms which appeared in rain-water at Calcutta, alge

ATMOSPHERIC MICROGRAPHY. V7

forming, as might be expected, a more decided feature than
in the deposits derived at once from the air. The conclusions
at which Dr. Cunningham arrived are the following:

1. Specimens of rain-water in Calcutta, collected with every
precaution to ensure their freedom from contact, contamina-
tion, sooner or later, frequently show the presence of spores,
mycelium, zoospores, monads, bacterioid bodies, and distinct
bacteria.

2. They do not, as a rule, contain any of the higher forms
of infusoria.

3. The zoospores are demonstrably derived from the my-
celium arising from common atmospheric spores.

4, There is every probability that the monads and bacteria
have a similar origin, but it remains quite uncertain whether
their development is due to heterogenesis or to the presence
of their germs within the parent cells, or as the result of a
process of normal development in the latter.

The above is but a slight sketch of a most interesting
memoir, every page of which deserves careful attention.

REVIEW.

The Microscope and Microscopical Technology. By Dr.
H. Frey, translated by G. R. Currer, M.D., from the
fourth German Edition. New York, 1872. London,
Sampson Low and Co.

Tuer admirable text-book of Professor Frey is too well
known to require any lengthened eulogium at our hands. It
has long been familiar to all histologists acquainted with the
German language, and we must now congratulate English
readers on having it presented in a form accessible to them.

Dr. Frey follows the practice of other writers on the micro-
scope in prefixing a general account of the instrument itself,
and the methods of observing with it. This appears to us to
be the least satisfactory portion of the manual. The optical
part is, perhaps, sufficient, but barely so; that relating to
the use and manipulation of the microscope is in several
respects defective. For instance, in the case of “ correction”
for thickness of cover-glass some description is given of the
apparatus, but it is hardly explained, and no practical direc-
tions for using it, so that a student relying on Professor
Frey’s instructions would find himself much at a loss, or
obliged to use his “correction” by mere guesswork. The
subject of illumination is also treated in a very cursory
manner, some of the English condensers being figured, but
not explained ; and though this, of course, is a less important
matter in Germany, where artificial light is more rarely used
than with us, still some of these contrivances are practically
indispensable for displaying the minutiz of high-power defini-
tion, which Professor Frey afterwards shows that he does not
despise.

It was, of course, natural that English microscopes should
receive little notice, since the work was originally intended
for German observers and students. The translator has
hardly supplied this deficiency, even for American readers,
by his lengthy account of the history of microscope-making
in the United States.

There is a tolerably full account of test objetts, and their
influence in the improvement of the microscope, The author

REVIEW. 173

disclaims (and we think with good reason) an unreasonable
contempt for these minutiz. Doubtless a great deal of time
has been wasted in ‘resolving diatoms,” and if that were
an end in itself, it would be a very poor one; but there can
be no question that these minute observations have done
much to stimulate the energy and skill of microscope makers.
Moreover, microscopes are actually corrected—-that is, vir-
tually made—by the help of these test objects. Herein lies
the fallacy pointed out by Dr. Royston Pigott; the instru-
ment is made to show a certain appearance (such as exclama-
tion marks on the Podura scale), and altered if it does not
» show it. Of course, then, it will always exhibit the same
structure, but the vaiue as an independent test is gone, since
we do not know that the appearance may not depend on
some fault in the glass which we go on perpetuating. This
source of error is not noticed by Professor Frey, but he gives
one additional test, too little used by our makers, namely,
Nobert’s lines. Even these, however, test one quality only of
a microscope. The only really independent test is that sug-
gested by Dr. Pigott, the image formed by the microscope of
a known object visible with the naked eye. Here we have at
once a standard of comparison, and the photographic achieve-
ments of our American colleague, Dr. Woodward, remove
another element of much uncertainty, the interpretation of
observations with a view to their representation.

These data supply the bases for a really scientific system of
testing microscopes, which has yet to be constructed.

Perhaps the most valuable portion of Professor Frey’s work
is that relating to the methods of preparing histological
objects, and the various sections on staining, injecting, and
mounting. For the purposes of the medical student and
histologist there is no doubt that this is by far the most
useful and complete body of instruction that has ever been
put together ; it stands, indeed, without a rival. The happy
eclecticism of the writer preserves him from the one-sidedness
which is the great defect of some of our English text-books ;
and though his own technical skill is well known, he has
not been unwilling to receive hints from all quarters.

It is, of course, impossible to notice the multifarious topics
of this part in detail; but we may note in passing that Dr.
Frey still looks upon carmine as the best colouring material,
and, for permanent preservation of objects, upholds Canada
balsam in preference to dammar or other substitutes lately
recommended.

He also shares the distrust of many skilful histologists for
mechanical appliances intended to come in aid of manual

XI.— NEW SER. M

174 REVIEW.

dexterity, and objects to all forms of section-cutters or mi-
crotomes, of which he gives no description. The American
translator has, however, inserted a description of a section-
cutter invented by Dr. Edward Curtis, of New York, which
resembles, in the main, the instrument of Drs. Stirling and
Rutherford, but without the freezing apparatus, and having
this peculiarity, that the knife is held in a frame, which
elevates it slightly above the table of the “ holder,” in which
the object to be cut is contained. The table is, moreover,
made of glass, an improvement recently suggested by Mr.
Needham in the English microtome.

The remaining part of Dr. Frey’s work is devoted to special
histological methods, and will be found most useful by
workers at normal or pathological histology ; for botanists
and zoologists it is, of course, less suited.

The translation is, on the whole, fairly executed, though
we think the principle of literalness has been carried to excess,
and has certainly often involved a sacrifice of elegance as well
as sometimes of clearness. With regard to the form of the
book, we must only regret that it has not been found possible
to make it smaller and less expensive.

NOTES AND MEMORANDA.

A Finder for Hartnack’s Microscopes—In working with
one of Hartnack’s microscopes, I found an inconvenience
which must have been felt by others, from the impossibility
of adapting any one of the ordinary finders to a stage so
simple in construction. Bridgman’s finder, as described,
p-. 48, of Beale’s “‘ How to work the microscope,” at first sug-
gested itself as available; but this is clearly suited only to
microscopes having at least a sliding movement to the stage,
unless two are employed, one on each side of the stage.

The following contrivance will, I think, meet every require-
ment. A line is ruled across the centre of the stage from
side to side, crossing this line at right angles are ruled two
lines about two inches apart, one on either side of the central
aperture of the stage. In order to use the finder, it will be
necessary to have a small white label affixed to each end
of the slide, the most convenient size being a round half
inch label. The portions of the lines on the stage left un-
covered by the slide being used for guidance, corresponding
lines are continued across the labels on the slide with a
pencil mark. Thus, at each end of the slide a cross-mark
will be formed, and whenever the cross-marks on the slide
are made to coincide with the crossing of the lines on the
stage, the part of the object required is in the field of the
microscope.

This plan answers very well, but I was enabled to render
the effectiveness of the arrangement almost equal to the
graduated stages of the larger microscopes for accuracy in
finding, by the following very simple device. I roughened
each end of the slide by means of a corundum file and some
water, so that that the lines on the stage could still be seen
through the ground glass ends, and the points where they
cross marked on the slide with a pencil or ink spot. Many
points may thus be registered on the same slide.

Not only are the ground glass slides useful for this pur-
pose, but I think they will serve a much more valuable pur-

176 NOTES AND MEMORANDA.

pose to all miscroscopists, by enabling them to label all slides
at once with the minimum expenditure of time and trouble.
I tried, but without success, to discover where a sand-blast
for etching glass was to be found in operation; for this
would obviously be the most simple means of roughening the
ends of the slides. Freverick J. Hicks.

The Potato Disease.—From a statement in the ‘ Agricultural
Gazette’ (February 7th, 1874, p. 185), a sum of £100
appears to have been granted to assist Professor de Bary,
of Strasburg, in the investigation of the life-history of the
potato-fungus (Peronospora infestans). In the next number
an explanation was published (p. 210) from Mr. Jenkins,
the Secretary of the Society, of the grounds which had induced
the Council to take this step. It is as follows:

“The scientific aspect of the potato disease also received
the careful attention of the judges of the essays, and in their
report to the Council they expressed their regret that no
essayist appeared to be acquainted with the most recent
discoveries in that field of inquiry. They therefore recom-
mended the Council to grant a sum of money for the pur-
pose of inducing a competent mycologist to undertake a
special investigation into the life-history of the potato-
fungus. The Council have adopted this course also; and it
is most gratifying to be able to announce that Professor de
Bary, of Strasburg, the highest living authority on the fungi
of our farm crops, and especially on the potato-fungus, has
undertaken this important investigation.”

It may be interesting to recapitulate the present state of our
knowledge of the Peronospora. It was first described by
Montagne in 1845. In the following year Berkeley pub-
lished a paper in the ‘ Journal of the Horticultural Society,’
in which he gave the drawings which Montagne communicated
to him for the purpose, in addition to those of himself and
Broome. At that time Berkeley in this country and Morren in
Belgium stood alone against the whole weight of eminent
botanical authority, in regarding the Peronospora as the cause,
and not the effect, of the potato disease. This paper established
the general habit of the fungus, and also described its
asexual spores.

In 1854 Tulasne published in the ‘Comptes Rendus’ his
discovery of the oospores or resting spores resulting from the
sexual reproduction of the Peronosporee. Down to the
present day, however, this has never been verified in the case
of Peronospora infestans, although Berkeley, as long ago as
1857, suggested that a fungus described by Montagne in

NOTES AND MEMORANDA, 177

1845, under the name of Artotrogus, might be this second
form of fruit.

In 1861 De Bary published an investigation of the potato
disease, in which he described for the first time the mode
in which the filaments of the germinating spores penetrate
the potato plant. About the same time he also announced
that the sporidia (which had been first detected by Montagne)
of the Peronospora were ciliated—were, in fact, zoospores.
Prévost, however, had discovered zoospores in the nearly
related genius Cystopus in 1807.

In 1863 De Bary published an elaborate memoir ‘On
Parasitic Fungi,’ in which the history of the Peronosporee
was carefully investigated. No one, however, has succeeded
in detecting the sexual mode of reproduction of the species
which infests the potato, and it remains to be seen whether
Professor de Bary-will obtain under the auspices of the Royal
Agricultural Society the information on this important point
which has hitherto eluded him. While all botanists will
look forward with interest to Professor de Bary’s report, it
seems almost a matter for regret that the Society did not
endeavour simultaneously to enlist the aid of some English
microscopists in the investigation. It would, perhaps, have
been possible for the Council to request the botanical adviser
of the Society, who would necessarily be versed in ‘ the fungt
of our farm crops,” to report upon the subject, and to
associate with himself some of the not undistinguished crypto-
gamic botanists of this country, with a view of organizing
during the present year a systematic plan of investigation of
the resting stage of this terrible parasite.

Mounting in Balsam—Mr. W. H. Walmsley’s success in
mounting objects gives great value to his practical suggestion
contributed to Science Gossip. He regrets that beginners
should be confronted with spring clips, spirit lamps, and
over-heated balsam, when balsam, dried to the point of
brittleness and then dissolved to the consistency of rich
cream in chemically pure benzole, would obviate the neces-
sity for such annoyances. He frees the specimen from
moisture by drying, or preferably by passing successively
through weak and absolute alcohol, treats it with oil of
cloves which is more desirable than turpentine because
more readily miscible with balsam, and not calculated to
harden the specimens even if they are left in it for a long
time, transfers it to the slide, and arranges it with needles,
places a drop of the balsam solution on it and applies the
glass cover in the usual manner. Ina few days the mount
will be sufficiently hardened to be handled with safety, espe-

178 NOTES AND MEMORANDA.

cially if after twenty-four hours it should be slightly warmed,
and the cover carefully pressed down with the forceps, and
held down with a small weight. The best finish for the
edge of the circle he finds to be the same balsam that is
used in mounting, laid on with a camel’s hair pencil; since
this is neat and handsome, and will not spoil the specimen
by running in, as may happen with coloured varnishes.—
American Naturalist

An aid to Microscopical Drawing.—I wish to call the atten-
tion of those interested in microscopical work to a modifica-
tion of the existing apparatus used for microscopical drawing.
The instrument I use and find more useful than any other
for this purpose, on account of its simplicity and the ease
with which it is worked, consists of the thinnest possible
covering glass placed at a proper angle in front of the eye-
piece. The advantage of this thin film of glass over the
camera lucida, the neutral tint reflector or the steel disc, is
that it enables the pencil to be easily followed in tracing the
image which is thrown upon the paper below. An ordinary
piece of white glass does not answer the purpose, as it throws
two pictures of the object. This doubling of the image is
reduced to nothing in proportion to the thinness of the glass.
The instrument which I have had made for me by Mr.
Sutton, instrument maker, 108, Holloway Road, cost the
moderate sum of three shillings and sixpence. It is com-
posed of a brass collar (to affix to the eye-piece of the micro-
scope) to which are attached two light brass arms, between
which revolves the glass, so that it may be placed at the
required angle.—W. KerstEven, Jun.—Lancet.

Cryptogams in the Interior of Eggs.—Professor Panceri
made a communication to the Institut Egyptien at its
meeting on December 138th, on the cryptogamic vegetation
which he had found within the egg of an ostrich. This
ege had been given him at Cairo, and was still fresh, the
air space having not even been formed. He soon, however,
noticed the appearance of dark blotches within the shell,
and having broken it open to ascertain the cause, he found
that they were produced by the growth of minute fungi.
Instances of a similar kind had already been studied by
him, and he had communicated the results to the Botanical
Congress held at Lugano, in 1859. The believers in the
reality of the spontaneous generation of living organisms
have not been slow to seize on these cases as an argument in
their favour, since @ prior? it would seem that the shell of an
egg would be quite impermeable to germs derived from
without. Panceri has succeeded in satisfying himself, how-

ae OE

‘ NOTES AND MEMORANDA, 179

ever, that the unbroken shell of an egg is permeable to
liquids, and that these may introduce germs into its interior.
He has, in fact, actually inoculated uncontaminated eggs
with a fungus which he had obtained from the interior of
one in which it had made its appearance in a way appa-
rently so mysterious, and had cultivated in egg albumen.—
Academy. [The Rev. M. J. Berkeley states that he has
found Cladosporium herbarum, in the interior of ordinary
fowls’ eggs.]

Supposed encysted Entozoon with ova.—Dr. Maddox’s ac-
count of the occurrence of an encysted entozoon with ova,
in the muscles of a sheep noticed in our last volume (p. 302),
is seriously questioned by Dr. Cobbold, who thus writes in
‘The London Medical Record’ (p. 487, 1873).

It forms an important contribution to our knowledge of
the structure of the mutton measles (Cysticercus ovis, T. 8.C.);
but the author has, without doubt, fallen into errors of in-
terpretation, which are too important to be passed over with-
out comment. The entozoon in question is clearly the same
as that which was first described by the writer of this notice
at a meeting of the Pathological Society, April 3rd, 1866
(Trans. Path. Soc.,’ vol. xvii. p. 463); other particulars
having subsequently been given in the writer’s small volume,
‘On Tapeworms’ (1867, p. 83), and in the supplement to
‘his larger treatise (‘ Entozoa,’ vol. ii. p. 30), 1869). These
references appear to have escaped Dr. Maddox’s attention,
but the actual facts observed by him are particularly valuable,
as adding numerous particulars to those already observed.

That we have here a larval cestode entozoon, cystic hel-
minth, small bladder worm, or meat measle shown to be
capable of developing ova in its interior is the conclusion
arrived at by Dr. Maddox. He has evinced the most pains-
taking care in comparing the so-called calcareous corpuscles
of this cysticercus with the ova of a mature tapeworm; and,
notwithstanding the accuracy of his admirably drawn figures,
he is perfectly satisfied that his encysted entozoon contains
well-formed eggs. Dr. Maddox even ventures (though with
evident hesitation, as the marks of.interrogation placed here
and there imply) to refer to such structures as the intromittent
organ, the ovarium, and vitelligene organ. .

From Dr. Maddox’s own figures, apart from the over-
whelming evidence derived from the records of helminthology
and personal experiences, the writer of this notice is quite
satisfied that the so-called ova are not in reality eggs, but
merely large calcareous corpuscles closely resembling them.
The cystic entozoon removed by Dr. Maddox from the

180 NOTES AND MEMORANDA.

muscles of the lower part of the neck, and the ‘ measle’
removed by Mr. Heisch ‘from the centre of a mutton chop’
(‘Entozoa,’ loc. cit., p. 30), are clearly referable to one and
the same form of armed cestode larva. Setting aside the
errors of interpretation above-mentioned, Dr. Maddox’s con-~
tribution is most interesting, not only as confirming the
experiences of three separate English observers (as to the
fact of the occurrence of measles in mutton), but as adding
numerous and useful microscopic details.

Lostorfer’s Syphilis-corpuscles.'—The observations of Los-
torfer who described certain bodies which he affirmed became
developed in the blood of syphilitic persons have been very
generally discredited.

Lately, however, Biesiadecki (Untersuchungen aus dem
Pathologisch-Anatomischen Institute in Krakau. Vienna,
1872), following Lostorfer in a large series of experiments,
has come to the conclusion that the assertions of Lostorfer
are, with some slight modifications, correct. ‘The mode in
which Biesiadecki proceeds in his observations is similar to
that employed by Lostorfer. By means of a pointed needle,
a small drop of blood is taken from the perfectly clean finger,
brought on a clean glass slide, and covered with a glass. By
a slight pressure on one edge of the cover-glass with the nail
of the finger, the blood can easily be made to spread out so

that the blood-corpuscles lie only in one layer, without being "

broken up and destroyed. Preparations in which the blood-
corpuscles have not spread out into one layer, or in which
they appear to be squeezed, are to be put aside as useless.

A number of preparations are brought into a moist chamber,
where they are kept at a temperature of 14—18° C. (67—
64° Fahr.). .

In most of the preparations which have not become dry
at the edges of the cover-glass, taken either from syphilitic
or other patients, e.g. arthritic or rheumatic, there appear on
the second, third, or fourth day numerous needle-shaped or
rhombic hzmoglobin-crystals, varying in diameter from that
of a blood-disc to twice or three times as large. In blood-
preparations of syphilitic patients the following changes take
place, beginning from the fourth day. In the yellowish
coloured plasma there appears a cloudy opacity, which is due
to the presence of small flakes. These latter are seen to
contain extremely small spherical bright granules, which
generally possess a filamentous appendix. The fifth day the
number of these granules becomes much greater ; they become

1 See ‘Quart. Journ. Mic. Sci.,’ 1872, p. 169.

NOTES AND MEMORANDA. 181

much larger, perfectly bright, spherical or irregular-shaped,
whereas at the same time the filamentous appendix disappears.
These granules make their appearance all over prepara-
tions; they are not limited to certain foci. The most of
them are to be found on those places in which plasma is still
unclosed.

After the twelfth day, up to which time their number has
increased immensely, no material change can be maile out,
even up to the twentieth day, except that some become a
little larger, brighter, and more sharply outlined.

In preparations of the blood of patients suffering from
different diseases (endocarditis, acute rheumatism, Addison’s
disease, gout, jaundice, pneumonia, tuberculosis, variola,
puerperal peritonitis, septiceemia), the above-described cor-
puscles make their appearance only in an extremely limited
number. Consequently, a preparation of blood which con-
tains only a few of those corpuscles is unavailable for a
diagnosis; whereas a preparation that contains a great
number of them can be said to have been taken from a syphi-
litic patient. Biesiadecki succeeded in this respect, just as
Lostorfer, in being able to point out in a series of mixed
preparations, submitted to him and prepared in the above-
mentioned manner, which of them had been taken from
syphilitic patients, and which not; except in one prepara-
tion, in which Lostorfer’s corpuscles were present abundantly,
and which was taken from a patient suffering from pustuia
maligna; it could not be ascertained, however, whether this
patient did not suffer from syphilis.

Biesiadecki shows that these corpuscles are not fat, not
sarcina, not granules of colourless corpuscles, and not fungi,
as Lostorfer was inclined to assume, but that they are
granules of precipitated paraglobulin; for, a. if a current of
carbonic acid be allowed to pass through a preparation of
diluted serum (plasma ?’—Rep.) of a dog, similar corpuscles to
those above described make their appearance ; on replacing
carbonic acid by oxygen they disappear; 6, if through a
blood-preparation, in which numerous syphilis-corpuscles
have developed, a current of oxygen be allowed to pass, the
small ones disappear, whereas the larger ones diminish con-
siderably in size; ¢. the syphilis-corpuscles do not dissolve
in either, but they dissolve almost entirely in a large quan-
tity of saline solution (one part of concentrated saline solution
in two parts of water). All these are properties which belong
to paraglobulin.

In blood-preparations, therefore, which are kept in a moist
chamber, that is, in which, on the one hand, the plasma

182 NOTES AND MEMORANDA.

becomes gradually diluted by absorption of water, and in
which, on the other hand, as it must be supposed, carbonic
acid is developed by decomposition, all the conditions are
present under which paraglobulin may be _ precipitated.
That Lostorfer’s corpuscles are to be met with abundantly
generally only in blood-preparations from syphilitic patients,
seems to show that their blood contains either more para-
globulin or less fibrinogenous substance than other blood.—
EK. Kuen, M.D., (tn Medical Record.)

A New Section Cutter—Professor Biscoe has contrived
a new section cutter which is principally adapted for pre-
paring sections of soft vegetable tissues and organs, such as
leaves, buds, &c. It consists essentially of a large glass stage-
plate upon which the object is fastened, and a movable
frame to slide upon this, carrying a razor blade at an adjust-
able distance from the plate. This apparatus cuts sections
of objects while they are under observation on the stage of
the microscope, under powers as high as the ¢ inch (x 80);
and with it Prof. Biscoe has been able to cut series of fifteen
consecutive sections, each one of which was perfect and the
average thickness of which was =>; inch. The following
is his description of the contrivance :

Fig. 1 is a plate that fits on to the stage of the microscope
with a tight friction, yet so that it has movements of an inch
or more in any direction, so that the object can be brought

Fria. 1.

'
1
Hy
1
1
Hi
t!
MH
!
!
i
'

into the field of view; @ is a glass plate held in place by the
two pieces of wood, with screws on the right and left; 3 is
the wooden base of the affair with an oval opening for the
illuminating apparatus to come up; this wooden base being
covered on the inner or upper side with velvet to make smooth

NOTES AND MEMORANDA. 188

the friction on the under side of the stage. For use with a
mechanical stage this arrangement is modified and much
simplified, the large glass plate being merely attached to the
stage, whose screw movements enable the object to be brought
into the field of view. On the middle of the upper side of
the glass plate are cemented four strips of glass as shown,
just far enough apart to take in a common glass slide, which
is held in place by a couple of wedges of common sheet brass ;
and on the middle of a slide is fastened the object to be cut,
either with gum arabic or sometimes with collodion. For
holding hard objects like wood the arrangements are not yet
quite perfected, but no special difficulty is expected.

Fig. 2 gives a perspective view of the triangular wooden
frame that holds a razor blade, 7, whose edge and back come
down lower than the rest of the frame. By means of the
three screws with graduated heads the whole frame, razor
and all, is raised cr lowered from the glass plate (a, Fig. 1) on
which the triangle rests and slides with these three screws as
its feet. These three supporting screws are cut witha thread
that counts forty to the inch; the screw head is divided into
one hundred equal parts, and can be moved without much
difficulty through half of one division, giving a vertical
motion of ;,,, inch to the cutting edge.

Fig. 3 is a large view of one of the screws, with its indi-
cator. The indicator may be a simple pin set in the wooden
frame, but is more convenient if made movable around the
axis of the screws, so that when the razor is returned after
sharpening they may be all turned around to the 0 of their

Fig. 2. Fig. 3.

respective screws, and therefore all read alike, while the
successive cuts are being made. On the side of the indicators
are scales which show how many complete revolutions of the

184. NOTES AND MEMORANDA.

screws have been made. These indicators should move
quite stiffly, so as not to be accidentally misplaced when
turning the screw heads.

With the hands upon the triangle and the eye at the
microscope tube, the razor can be moved so that its edge
shall either make a drawing cut or push straight through the
object like a chisel, according as either method or any grada-
tion between them suits best the nature of the substance
cut. Thus perfectly even slices can be cut, and it is quite
easy to take them in consecutive order even when called off
in the midst of the work and compelled to wait half an hour
before resuming it. It is a luxury to take off slice after slice
and know that there is no danger of losing just the slices you
want especially to see. The object is kept wet with glyce-
rine, and just as the razor begins to cut, a drop of glycerine
is placed on its edge in which the slice floats without
sticking ; though care must be taken in the case of very thin
and small sections not to lose them in a large drop of glyce-
rine in which they would be found with difficulty. By this
method slices ;3;, of an inch in thickness, or rather in
thinness, can be all worked out nicely, though before it was
adopted such thin slices were all torn, so as to be unrecog-
nisable. Whether a blade can be made to cut any thinner
than that has not been tried; but it may be remarked that
the first razor blade used gave out at 7,5, Inch thick, and
would not take an edge capable of cutting finer than that.”—
American Naturalist.

Dr. Reijner on Synovial Membranes.—We are reluctantly
compelled to defer till our next number a paper by Dr. Reijner,
of Dorpat, communicating the results of an investigation
conducted in Professor Sanderson’s laboratory, at University
College, on the articular cartilages and synovial membranes.
This is in continuation of a previous memoir by Dr. Reijner
on the same subject published in the ‘ Deutsche Zeitschrift
fiir Chirurgie.’

—

—_—sY

QUARTERLY CHRONICLE OF MICROSCOPICAL
SCIENCE.

HISTOLOGY.

II. The Cell! 1. Action of Quinine on Leucocytes—Some
years ago, Binz showed that quinine arrests the motions
of the white blood-corpuscles, and this effect is now explained
by the diminution in the oxidizing power of the red corpuscles
which the drug produces. The white corpuscles are only
active when they are supplied with oxygen, and their move-
ments are arrested by want of it. On this account they can
only creep through the walls of the blood-vessels when oxy-
gen is supplied to them by the red ones as they pass by.
When no red corpuscles are present, Binz has found that the
white ones cease to wander altogether ; and this observation
has also been made by Heller and Zahn (Binz, ‘ Archiv fir
Experiment Pathologie,’ vol.i; ‘ London Medical Record,’
1873, p. 308).

2. Contractility of cells—Hosch (‘ Pfluger’s Archiv,’ 1873,
vol. vii, p. 515-521) has observed the contractility of carti-
lage-cells under the influence of the induced current, as
described by Heidenhain and Rollett, in the hyaline cartilage
of the frog and newt. Similar phenomena are seen in the
corneal corpuscles. Both, he thinks, may be explained by
the thermic action of the current, since the same appearances
are seen under the influence of heat or merely after death.
This explanation applies with less certainty to the newt than
to the frog.

3. Dr. Hollis (‘Journal of Anat. and Phys.,’ November,
1873, p. 120) continues his researches on “ Tissue metabo-
lism,” or the artificial induction of structural changes in
living organisms.

1 The articles in this division are arranged under the following heads :—
1. Text-books and Technical Methods. II. The Cellin General. IIT. Blood.
IV. Epithelium. V. Connective Tissues. VI. Muscle. VII. Nervous
System. VIII. Organs of Sense. IX. Vascular System. X. Digestive
ae and Glands. XI. Skin and Hair. XII. Urinary and Sexual

rgans

186 QUARTERLY CHRONICLE OF MICROSCOPICAL SCIENCE,

IV. Origin of Epithelium.—The question whether epi-
thelium alone can generate or regenerate epithelium, or
whether it may not sometimes be formed from connective
tissue elements, lies at the foundation of very important
problems of pathology, and even of surgery. We take from
the ‘ Medical Record’ (p. 466, 1873) the following summary

of the evidence furnished by the modern practice of “ skin- |

grafting :”

“Considerable difference of opinion still exists regarding
the histology of this subject. Page, in the ‘ British Medical
Journal,’ December, 1870, thought that he had established,
by microscopic investigation, that the epithelium of the skin-
graft comported itself in the same manner as ordinary cica-
tricial epithelium ; and Jacenko (of Kiew) stated that he
found a multiple nucleus in the interior of the cells of the
Malpighian layer of the skin-graft. But most observers
deny the theory of proliferation. M. Poncet and M. Colrat
have both given papers founded on microscopic study, which
appear separately in the ‘ Lyon Médical,’ and these observers
arrive at conclusions nearly similar to those expressed by M.
Reverdin in his essay which appeared in the ‘ Archives
Générales de Médecine’ (March, May, and June, 1872). M.
Reverdin, on examining the graft forty-eight hours after it
had been transplanted, saw that granulations were separated
from the graft, and plunged down between the body of the
graft and the embryonic tissue of the ulcer, with which the
granulations ultimately coalesced to form a single tissue. To
these prolongations he gave the name of ‘ bourgeons d’en-
chassement,’ or stilt granulations.’ He next describes the
formation of the cicatrix round the graft. The cells, spring-
ing from the graft, have apparently only one nucleus, and he
never saw any appearance of it dividing, so that there is
nothing to indicate a proliferation of the elements, and in
this MM. Poncet and Colrat agree with him. And M.
Reverdin further states, seeing that there is nothing to indi-
cate formation of cells from a blastema, that the only hypo-
thesis at which he can arrive is, that the transplanted
epidermis determines, by its presence, the transformation of
the embryonic cells of the granulations into epidermic cells ;
that is to say, that the epidermis of the graft will only form a
mould or model to the embryonic cells. In practising zoo-
grafting, however varied the animals were from which he
obtained the grafts, they always produced the same kind of
cicatrix, namely, the ordinary cicatricial tissue found in man.

“Opposed to this view, we have the theory which ascribes
the principal ré/e in the production of the cicatrix to the con-

——

QUARTERLY CHRONICLE OF MICROSCOPICAL SCIENCE. 187

nective tissue ; and this is advocated by M. Ollier, who cites,
in support of his views, the success obtained by him in pro-
ducing cicatrisation by means of a graft of periosteum. He
might also have added the clinical observation of Howard,
with his muscle grafts, as at least opposing the theory of
Reyerdin.

** Probably the matter would be much more easily solved
did we know the mode of growth of the ordinary epithelium.
We might then be able to ascertain the difference between
the formation of ordinary and cicatricial epithelium ; and we
would also be better able to ascribe the correct theory to the
production of the cicatrix from the grafts. Dr. Otto Weber,
long ago, stated that he had seen new cells emanate from
connective tissue corpuscles of granulating surfaces. Again,
many believe that the epidermic and epithelial cells are
derived from the primitive embryonic cells, and that each
must be derived from its parent by division of its nucleus;
and several observers state that they have seen cells actually
undergoing a process of subdivision. The view of Reverdin
has been accepted by many j but we think that there is some
other cause, some other influence or agency at work in pro-
ducing the cicatrix from the islets instead of the mere presence
of a‘ mould.’ It finds no homotype in the animal body.”

V. The Connective Tissues—1. Parenchymatous canals.—
Arnold (‘ Centraiblatt,’ 1874, No. 1, p. 1) describes a system
of fine parenchymatous canals in the tongue and web of the
foot of the frog, the relation of which to the saftcanadlchen of
Recklinghausen and to the connective tissue corpuscles he
proposes further to discuss.

&. Connective tissue of insects.—Graber (‘ Schultze’s
Archiv,’ x, p. 124) describes a sort of fibrilloid connective
tissue in the integument of insects, and its importance in
- suspending the trachez.

3. Development of bone.—Kolliker’s most recent contribu-
tions to this subject are thus summarised by Dr. Klein in the
‘London Medical Record’ (p. 482, 1873) :

“1. The typical absorption of bone tissue.—The doctrine of
the normal absorption of bone tissue by osteoclasts (myelo-
plaxes), in the Howship’s absorption-lacune, brought for-
ward by Kolliker,! has been lately contradicted by Strelzoff,
who found that bone-tissue, once formed, is never absorbed
again, but grows interstitially. In the present paper KOlli-
ker brings forward some new facts to meet these objections.
At the diaphysal extremities of long bones, the external ab-
sorption attacks first the periosteal portion of the bone-cortex.

* “Quart. Journ, Mic. Sci.,’ 1873, p. 89.

188 QUARTERLY CHRONICLE OF MICROSCOPICAL SCIENCE.

This being here very thin, the intra-cartilaginous bone there-
fore is soon involved in the process of absorption. Such
absorption-lacunee remain for many years in the superficial
layers of the intra-cartilaginous bone. In transverse sections
through the humerus of a human feetus, especially if they are
stained with hematoxylin, this is quite clearly to be seen.
Such sections, if they are made through the upper extremity
of the diaphysis, show laterally a distinct periosteal cortex,
and on its external surface an apposition of bone-substance.
At the median side, however, this periosteal cortex is absent
altogether, and the periosteum is in immediate contact with in-
tra-cartilaginous bone, in which the residua of the trabecule of
the cartilaginous matrix are brought owt remarkably well by
heematoxylin—a fact first pointed out by Strelzoff himself.
At these points the surface of the intracartilaginous bone
contains very numerous Howship’s lacune, and in them as
usual osteoclasts. Transverse sections through the tibia
below the condyles show exactly the same. Substantially
the same was found in the tibia of a male aged fifteen years.

«2. Formation of the first vessels in bone, developed from
cartilage ; origin of the osteoblasts and osteoclasts.—In this
paragraph Kolliker confirms the asertion of Loyén, Sharpey,
and especially of Gegenbaur, that the marrow of bones
which are preformed as cartilage, originates, in all its consti-
tuent elements, from the perichondrium or the periosteum
respectively. The circumstances that led Kdlliker to this
conclusion are these:

“ (a) In the cartilage of the epiphyses and in the short bones
the well-known processes of the perichondrium, which project
into the cartilage, and which contain, besides blood-vessels, a
fibrillar matrix with spherical and spindle-shaped cells, do
not develop from the cartilage (Virchow), but from the peri-
chondrium. The cartilage itself does not become dissolved,
as supposed, by the progressive growth of those processes.
but is simply pushed aside.

(6) In the diaphyses of the phalanges of the embryo of calf,
sheep, pig, and man it can be shown that after the appear-
ance of the first thin periosteal crust of true bone substance
and the first calcification of the imner cartilage, processes
grow from the osteogenetic layer of the periosteum, which
spread out gradually towards all sides, and penetrate into the
cavities of the cartilage-capsules. ‘The tissue of which these
processes consist is similar to that of the perichondral pro-
cesses, previously mentioned, except that it is more loose, and
that it contains more spherical elements. From these latter
the osteoblasts and osteoclasts (myeloplaxes) take their origin,

QUARTERLY CHRONICLE OF MICROSCOPICAL SCIENCE. 189
By the growth of those processes the calcified parts of the
_ cartilage-matrix are gradually absorbed, in which proceed-
ings the osteoclasts play an important part.

“The cartilage-cells themselves do not become transformed
into cells of the marrow.

*““(c) Exactly the same takes place at the ossification-margin
of the diaphysis, for here the elongated vascular processes,
which gradually penetrate from the diaphysal extremity into
the cartilaginous epiphysis, are also offsprings of the perios-
teal processes. Those vascular processes are always and
everywhere sharply defined from the cartilage. Osteoclasts
are generally not to be met with at the terminal points of the
vascular processes, but they occur in great numbers near the
ossification-margin ; so that they play certainly a part in the
absorption of calcified cartilage-matrix, but not in the
dehiscence of the cartilage-cavities.

“3. Growth of bones in length—By the well-known
method of feeding very young animals with madder, Kolliker
arrived in agreement with Ollier and Humphry to the follow-
ing conclusions as regards the growth of bones in length.

*(a) In long tubular bones with epiphyses on both ex-
tremities, that extremity of the diaphysis grows quicker whose
epiphysis remains longer separated.

** (6) Short tubular bones, with only one epiphysis, grow
quickest at the diaphysis touching that epiphysis (calcaneus,
metatarsi, metacarpi, phalanges).

*(c) All free edges and apophyses of any bone show a
very marked growth (crista ossia ilii tuber ischii, processus
spinosi et transversi, processus xyphoideus sterni, processus
styloideus ulne).

*(d) The same holds good with certain extremities of
long bones, which are provided with a considerable layer of
cartilage—e. g. the ribs.

“(e) Short bones, with and without epiphyses, grow pretty
equally on all cartilaginous surfaces, which are in contact
with other bones (vertebral diaphyses, tarsus, carpus,
sternum).

**(f) All epiphyses which touch an articulation grow most
at the extremity touching the articulation.

“(g) Those parts of bones that are covered with cartilage
and are not in contact with other bones show a considerable
growth. (The edges of the vertebral epiphyses, the lateral
parts of all epiphyses.)

“(h) The thickness of the cartilage, whose cells are in the
act of proliferation, stands generally in relation to the energy

VOL. XIV.—NEW SER. N

190 QUARTERLY CHRONICLE OF MICROSCOPICAL SCIENCE,

of the growth of the bone in length. There are, however,
certain exceptions (vertebral apophyses).

“In the last paragraph of this paper Kolker produces a
new scheme for explaining the growth of long bones. For
this, however, we must refer the reader to the paper itself.”

Kolliker’s important researches, which we have already
referred to, are now published in a complete form, with eight
plates and many additions (‘ Die Normale Resorption des
Knochengewebes,’ Leipzig, 1873, 4to, pp. 86).

4, Histogenesis of bone.—Strelzoff (‘ Eberth’s Untersuch-
ungen, Zurich, 1873, pp. 64, four plates) has published some
elaborate researches on the histogenesis of bone, beautifully
illustrated, contradicting in some points those of Kolliker.

VI. Muscle—1. Structure of voluntary muscle.—Krause
(‘ Pfliger’s Archiv,’ 1873, vol. vii, pp. 508— 514) discusses
the contraction of muscle fibres and the apparent reversal of
the characters of the singly-refracting and doubly-refracting
substance, as to darkness and lightness (‘ Umkehrung’ of
Engelmann) of which he gives a different interpretation
from any arrived at by other observers.

Wagener (‘ Schultze’s Archiv,’ vol. ix, p. 712) concludes
that in striated muscle the fibrilla is the ultimate element of
the fibre; that all the forms of transverse discs take their
origin only out of the subdivision of the contractile substance
in different parts of the fibrilla; and that the intermediate
discs are not definite structures.

The observations of Engelmann and Schafer are thus
summarised by Klein (‘ London Medical Record,’ 1878, pp.
647 and 665) with those of other observers already noticed
in this journal:

“'T. W. Engelmann describes his microscopical observa-
tions on the striped muscular tissue in ‘ Pfliiger’s Archiv,’
vol. vii, part 1. He studied the striped muscular fibres of
arthropoda. They were observed in a moist chamber with-
out the addition of any reagent, for reagents produced very
marked changes. The fibres were in a perfectly fresh and
living condition, showing still very lively contractions.

“ Each muscular fibre is divided into a number of divisions
of equal sizes by transverse dark membranes—intermediate
discs, which are closely united with the sarcolemma. Each
division contains in the centre a bright, slightly refractive
transverse median stripe—median disc of Hensen, on each
side of which lies a dim, highly refractive band—the trans-
verse disc; then comes on each side a bright, slightly
refractive band—isotropous substance; then a dark, highly
refractive stripe—the lateral disc; and finally, again, a thin,

eo oe ee

QUARTERLY CHRONICLE OF MICROSCOPICAL SCIENCE, 191

bright, slightly refractive band—isotropous substance; so
that each division contains, between the two intermediate
discs, one median disc, two transverse discs, then two isotro-
pous bands, two lateral discs, and finally again two isotropous
bands.

“‘a. The intermediate disc, or the membrane of Krause, is
distinctly to be recognised as a separate structure in the per-
fectly fresh fibre in the state of rest, when examined without
a reagent, and if the height of a muscular division exceeds
0:008th part of a millimétre. In those cases where the
lateral disc is very dark, and is in close contact with the
intermediate disc, this latter may easily escape observation ;
it can, however, be brought into view by slightly stretching
the muscular fibre. The intermediate disc appears under the
microscope as a single dark line, being a homogeneous, highly
refractive membrane; it is very elastic, and, when observed
in polarised light, in preparations that have been hardened
in alcohol or osmic acid, and mounted in dammar, dis-
tinctly anisotropous.

“6. The isotropous thin band being at the side of the
intermediate disc is in fresh fibres only recognisable when
the height of a muscular division amounts to 0:008th of a
millimétre and more. Otherwise the lateral disc seems to be
in contact with the intermediate disc. In this latter case the
isotropous band can be brought into view by adding one per
cent. of acetic acid, which causes the isotropous band to swell
on and be perceptible.

“‘¢. The lateral disc is in the fresh fibre always darker than
the isotropous band; it is seldom homogeneous, commonly
granular. ‘The granules are generally of equal size, and iso-
diametric in such a way that, where the muscular contents
are divided into fibrils, each granule represents a part of a
fibril. ‘The lateral disc is not very distinctly anisotropous ;
it is also not so elastic and not so closely connected with the
sarcolemma as the intermediate disc.

“ d. ‘Vhe isotropous band between the last-mentioned stripe
and the anisotropous transverse disc is always easily to be
recognised in the living fibre. Its thickness stands in a re-
verse proportion to that of the lateral disc. A two per cent.
saline solution, water, or very diluted spirit, causes at once
this isotropous band to turn dark. When heated up to 50°
Cent. (122° Fahr.) it becomes opaque and more firm, and
finally it shrinks. It is not a fluid substance, but consists of
a number of soft granules of equal size, which are so much
swollen that they touch each other completely ; the number

192 QUARTERLY CHRONICLE OF MICROSCOPICAL SCIENCE,

of these particles corresponds to the number of fibrils into
which the muscular contents split up occasionally.

“‘e, In the fresh living muscular fibre the dim broad trans-
verse dise appears to be divided into two by a median bright
homogeneous transverse band. In some cases, however, the
latter is not to be made out as aseparate structure. Between
crossed Nicol’s prisms, both the transverse discs and the
median disc are seen to be anisotropous. If fresh living
muscular fibres be treated with a 5 per cent. saline solution,
the transverse discs become swollen and pale, whereas the
median disc becomes darker and narrower. Diluted acids
and alcohol of 25 to 60 per cent. have a similar action.
Heating brings out the median disc and the transverse discs
alsu, as anerent structures.

« When a muscular fibre dies spontaneously, or is subjected
to the influence of water, diluted chromic acid, alcohol, cor-
rosive sublimate, &c., the anisotropous substance appears to
be composed of highly refractive anisotropous rod-like bodies
—sarcous elements, muscle-rods—and of a less refractive
isotropous amorphous intermediate substance. Engelmann
distinctly denies that these elements are distinguishable in
the muscular fibre while in a living condition ; for those
parts, in which these elements have made their appearance
are without exception non--irritable.

“In some cases the anisotropous discs are the only parts
of the muscular divisions which have split into rods, the other
parts not showing any sign of a longitudinal differentiation ;
é. g- in muscular fibres of insects “which have died spon-
taneously or which have been treated with water, very diluted
saline solution, or diluted alcohol. In most cases, however,
especially in locustida amongst insects, and in vertebrate ani-
mals in general, the disintegration takes place through all the
discs of the individual divisions; in this way the so-called
primitive fibrils make their appearance. On observing the
optical longitudinal section of a fresh muscular fibre for some
time the discs of the divisions, at first absolutely homogeneous,
show immeasurably fine pale isotropous longitudinal lines ;
they are in most regular distances from each other, not more
than 0°001 of a millimétre. These lines gradually become
brighter, and at the same time broader—their thickness
exceeding the 0°0005th part of a millimétre—at the expense
of those parts that lie between them, without the muscular
fibre, as a whole, altering in diameter. Consequently it may
be said that the appearance of the longitudinal bright line is
caused, not by the swelling of a pre-existent intermediate
substance, but by the shrinking, i. e. coagulation, of elements,

QUARTERLY CHRONICLE OF MICROSCOPICAL SCIENCE. 193

which have been previously in close contact with each other ;
so that all the discs of the muscular division must be regarded
as consisting in the living state of prismatic elements, which
are so swollen that they touch each other completely, and
which possess different chemical and physical properties in
the different discs, but the same properties in the same disc.
An intermediate fluid substance is not pre-existent, but is
pressed out by those elements when they coagulate. Ina
second paper (ibid., vol. vii, part 2 and 3) Engelmann treats
of the changes of the individual discs of the muscular division
during contraction of the muscular fibres. For studying
these Engelmann uses, like Flogel, osmic acid. The living
muscular fibre is dipped into a solution containing 0°5 to 2
per cent. of this reagent for a few seconds; it is then trans-
ferred into a half per cent. saline solution, which is afterwards
replaced by alcohol in a slightly rising concentration (50 to
90 per cent.), and is finally placed in turpentine. The con-
clusions which Engelmann draws from his observations are
briefly these :

“‘qa. The shortening force has its seat exclusively in the
anisotropous layer; this latter thickens itself much more than
the isotropous.

“©. The isotropous substance decreases, the anisotropous
increases in volume during contraction ; it must be therefore
assumed that fluid which is expressed by the isotropous is
imbibed by the anisotropous substance, viz. the latter swells,
the former shrinks, during contraction.

““¢, The isotropous substance becomes darker, more opaque,
the anisotropous brighter, more transparent, during contrac-
tion; the median disc, however, does not become brighter.
From this it may be deduced that—

“dq, The isotropous substance becomes firmer, the aniso-
tropous softer, during contraction.

« . A. Schafer (‘ Proceedings of the Royal Society,’ vol.
xxi) studied the structure of striped muscle on the muscular
fibres of the limbs of the common large water-beetle, mounted
without any reagent, and under high magnifying powers.
According to Schafer, every muscular fibre consists of a
homogeneous anisotropous ground-substance, in which are
imbedded dim cylindrical rods; these are isotropous, and
arranged in regular series. In the absolute state of rest the
muscular fibre presents, therefore, only the appearance of a
longitudinal fibrillation. In the normal state of slight ten-
sion the cylindrical rods change into rods with a swelling
at each extremity ; we have then muscle-rods consisting of a
shaft and two little knobs or heads. When this change has

194 QUARTERLY CHRONICLE OF MICROSCOPICAL SCIENCE.

taken place the muscular fibre presents the appearance of a
transverse striation, viz. dim bands alternating with bright
ones. ‘The former correspond to the dim shafts of the rods,
whereas the latter are due to an optical effect, produced by
the presence of the globular heads of the rods, which have a
different refraction-index from that of the ground-substance.
In this case the muscle-rods are so arranged that the heads
of two successive series meet in the middle of the bright
band ; when the muscular fibre is somewhat extended the
bright band appears to be double, for then the heads of two
successive series of rods have become separated, and each
series of heads possesses its own halo. During contraction
the heads of the rods become enlarged at the expense of the
shafts, and at the same time they approach each other in the
transverse as well as in the longitudinal direction to such an
extent that they form one dark transverse band with bright
borders. As the contraction proceeds, and the dark bands
approach each other, the bright borders encroach upon the dim
stripe, which finally disappears, its place being taken up by
a single transverse bright band. ‘The contracted muscular
fibre shows, therefore, alternate dark and bright bands, the
latter representing merely the ground-substance, which has
become accumulated between the shafts of the muscle-rods.
In polarized light these bright bands are seen to be aniso-
tropous, whereas the dark bands are isotropous. From this
it is evident that the ground-substance is anisotropous, the
muscle-rods isotropous, although in the state of rest the whole
fibre appears to be anisotropous ; this, however, may be easily
explained by bearing in mind that the muscle-rods are sur-
rounded by the anisotropous ground-substance and are there-
fore illuminated by light that has previously traversed this.

** Schafer is inclined to assume that the ground-substance
is comparable to a protoplasmic matrix, which is the true
contractile part, whereas the rods are elastic structures, which
serve merely to restore the muscular fibre to its original length
after the contraction has ceased.”

2. Termination of nerves in voluntary muscle. — Arndt
(‘Schultze’s Archiv,’ ix, 481) publishes a long and elaborate
memoir on this subject, illustrated with three plates, which
our space does not permit us fully to notice.

3. Petrowsky (‘ Centralblatt,’ No. 49, 1873, p. 769) has
studied the growth of muscular fibres in the frog.

VII. Nervous System.—1l. Nervous structures in general.—
Axel Key and Retzius (‘ Schultze’s Archiv,’ 1873, ix, pp. 808
— 368, 3 plates) publish a long memoir, translated from a
Norwegian journal, on the anatomy of the nervous system,

QUARTERLY CHRONICLE OF MICROSCOPICAL SCIENCE. 195

partly microscopic, partly histological, describing the nerve-
centres with their membranes, the structure of nerve-trunks,
the Pacinian corpuscles, &c.

2. Regeneration of nerve-—Benecke (‘ Virchow’s Archiv,’
1873, vol. lvii, pp. 496—511) has studied the histological pro-
cess in the regeneration of nerves after section.

3. Ganglion-cells of the sympathetic.—Arndt (‘ Schultze’s
Archiv,’ x, p. 208) has investigated the structure of the
ganglionic cells of the sympathetic in fish, birds, mammalia,
and in the human subject. He worked partly on prepara-
tions macerated in neutral chromate of ammonia and teased
out, partly on hardened specimens, using chromic acid and
chloride of gold. He thus summarises his results :—1l. All
ganglionic cells of the sympathetic, provided with several
processes, that is, bipolar and multipolar cells, correspond to
whoie groups of cells, and are derivatives of such groups. 2.
All unipolar ganglion-cells, on the other hand, correspond
to and are derived from simple cells. 3. Of the so-called
apolar ganglion-cells, the larger represent abnormal develop-
mental forms of the original embryonic cells ; the smaller are,
in fact, themselves embryonic cells.

4. Cortex of the brain.—Golgi (‘ Centralblatt,’ No. 51, 1873,
p- 806) publishes a preliminary communication on the grey
substance of the brain, especially with reference to the large
_ pyramidal ganglion-cells of the cerebrum, the ‘ basal process’
of which he finds to branch and finally to enter into connec-
tion with the connective-tissue-cells of the cerebral cortex.
Similar relations he finds to exist in the cerebellum.

5. Nervous system of Nematoda.—Bitschli, “ Contribu-
tions to the Knowledge of the Nervous System of the Nema-
toda” (2 plates), ‘ Schultze’s Archiv,’ x, p. 74.

6. Electrical organs.—Boll (‘ Schultze’s Archiv,’ x, p. 101)
has studied the electrical plates of the Torpedo with high
powers, and the same organs in Malopterurus (ibid., p. 242).

7. Aniline blue as a staining materval for ganglion-cells.—
Zuppinger (‘ Schultze’s Archiv,’ x, p. 255) recommends for
the demonstration of the axis-cylinder process of the ganglion-
cells in the spinal cord the use of soluble aniline blue, ac-
cording to the following method :—Sections of brain or cord
hardened in bichromate, and washed with acidulated water, are
brought into a slightly acidified solution of commercial aniline
blue and kept in the dark till they are stained of a tolerably
deep colour. The sections must not overlap or cover one
another. They cannot be dehydrated by alcohol, since this
extracts the colour, but a little absolute alcohol may just be -
poured over them to remove some of the adhering water, and

196 QUARTERLY CHRONICLE OF MICROSCOPICAL SCIENCE.

then white anhydrous creosote added, which soon makes them
translucent without destroying the colour, and they can then
be transferred to Canada balsam or dammar. They must not
be left more than two hours in creosote, and must still be
shielded from the light, which precaution is to be observed
even when the preparations are complete and transferred to
the cabinet.

VIII. Organs of Sense.—1. Olfactory mucous membrane.—
Martin (‘ Journal of Anatomy and Physiology,’ November,
1873, p. 39) has worked at the structure of the olfactory
mucous membrane, especially with a view to examine the
distinction drawn by Max Schultze between the two classes
of cells, epithelial and olfactory, met with in this region, a
distinction which Exner denies. In the olfactory epithelium
of the newt these two kinds of cells are very distinct, and no
intermediate form is seen. They are clearly demonstrable on
teasing out preparations hardened in spirit or Miiller’s fluid.
The epithelial cells possess a large oval granular nucleus, sur-
rounded by a homogeneous structureless layer, from which
proceed one or more ‘ central processes ;” a ‘ peripheral pro-
cess’ proceeds from the other end of the cell. In the olfac-
tory cells the nucleus is round, hardly granular, and has a
single central process. In the frog the two kinds of cells are
less distinct, partly because the nuclei of both are oval. In
the olfactory epithelium of the dog the two forms are quite
distinct, though differing somewhat from the corresponding
cells in the newt.

The conclusion is that the two forms of cell met with in
the olfactory region are anatomically quite distinct, as
described by Max Schultze, and do not shade off into one
another. The contrary opinion arrived at by Exner is due in
great part to his having chiefly worked at the frog, where the
olfactory and epithelial cells do approximate to one another
in several points. It is doubtful whether the cells possess
any such difference of function as is implied by these terms.

IX. Vascular System.—1. Morano (‘ Centralblatt,’ No. 1,
1874, p. 3) describes the lymphatic sheaths of the capillary
blood-vessels in the choroid coat of the eye.

2. Klein (‘ Proc. Royal Society,’ No. 149, 1874) publishes
his “ Contributions to the Normal and Pathological Anatomy
of the Lymphatic System of the Lungs,’ of which we must
defer a notice.

X. Digestive Organs and Glands—1. Teeth.—Legros and
Magitot have studied the development of teeth in mammalia,
and describe, in their first memoir, the origin and formation
of the dental follicle. (Robin’s ‘ Journal de |’Anatomie,

QUARTERLY CHRONICLE OF MICROSCOPICAL SCIENCE, 197

September and October, 1873 ; also separately, pp. 56, with
six plates).

2. Thyroid—Boéchat (‘ Recherches sur la Structure nor-
male du Corps Thyroide,’ Paris, 1873, 8vo, pp. 44, one plate)
describes the normal structure of the thyroid.

XI. Skin and Hair.—1. Tactile corpuscles.—Thin (‘Journal
of Anatomy and Physiology,’ November, 1873, p. 30) describes
the structure of the tactile corpuscles. After referring to the
views of several observers, he gives an account of his own
observations, made on recently amputated skin, hardened
chiefly in osmic acid. A vertical section through the meridian
of a corpuscle shows either a simple homogeneous, more or
less rounded body, enclosed in a capsule, or two or more
such simple capsulated bodies arranged in a row parallel to
the vertical axis of the papilla, and enclosed in a common
oblong capsule.. The former he designates single, the latter
compound corpuscles. Each single corpuscle,and each member
of acommon corpuscle, is penetrated by one, and never by more
than one, medullated nerve-fibre. A nerve never leaves a
corpuscle after having entered it, but when it has penetrated
to a certain depth bends round and describes part of a circle.
In this terminal course the nerve retains its medulla, and
between the medulla and corpuscle substance a space is seen
which corresponds to the position of the sheath of Schwann.
Thin has never seen the nerve-fibre divide, either in-
ternal or external to the capsule, and does not hesitate to
deny the alleged division. The conclusion is that each single
corpuscle, and each member of a compound corpuscle, repre-
sents the termination of a single medullated nerve-fibre.

The so-called transverse elements (querelemente of German
authors) are the nuclei of oblong cells which anastomose
with one another, by means of prolongations of elastic-tissue-
fibres. The capsule of the corpuscle is formed by a circular
layer of elastic tissue made up of the anastomosing continua-
tions of cells. The network of elastic tissue and the cells do
not communicate with the medullated nerve-fibres. The
division of the papille of the skin into vascular and nervous
is not borne out by these investigations, since in the
majority of the so-called nerve-papille vascular loops are
found.

2. Lymphatics of the skin—Neumann (‘ Zur Kenntniss
der Lympbgefiasse der Haut des Menschen und der Sauge-
thiere.”’ Mit 8 chromolithographirten Tafeln. Wien, W.
Braumiiller, 1873. ‘Medical Record,’ 1873, p. 664) has
arrived at results which may be summed up as follows:

(1). The lymphatics of the skin present an enclosed tubular

198 QUARTERLY CHRONICLE OF MICROSCOPICAL SCIENCE.

system, with independent walls, whose interior is lined with
flat epithelium. These walls are nowhere interrupted by
openings. There exists, therefore, no communication with
the so-called juice-canals, or with other interspaces of the
skin. Neither can spaces be seen anywhere between the
epithelium, not even in examples of disease where there exists
an enlargement of these vessels.

(2). The relation of the blood- and lymph-vessels is only
constant to the extent that the former are always found much
nearer the surface than the latter. The branches of the
lymphatics, together with their meshes, are found spreading
themselves in the deeper tissue in all directions. Nowhere,
however, within a lymph-tubule could a second vessel be
detected ; so that there can be no ground for considering the
question of invagination.

(3). The lymphatics form two close and separate networks in
the corium, the deeper being the more extensive of the two.
Their walls are markedly capable of extension. The more
superficial vessels are in general thinner; the deeper ones
are thicker, and, like the first, are, to.all appearances, without
valves. Only among the subcutaneous vessels is it possible to
demonstrate the valves plainly.

The larger lymphatics possess a number of branches with
blind endings, which are of variable calibre. The lymph-
vessels make their way into the papille of the skin, partly in
the shape of single tubules, and also in the form of loops.

(4). The appendages of the skin, as the hairs, hair-follicles,
and sweat-glands, possess their own lymphatic capillaries
situated about their periphery, but they do not enter into the
follicles. The aggregations of fat are also surrounded by
lymphatics. ‘The vessels were found to be greatly developed
in the subcutaneous tissue.

(5). The number of lymph-vessels of the skin was found to
vary according to locality. They occur in greatest numbers
about the scrotum, labia majora, palms of the hands, and
soles of the feet. In pathologically altered skin an enlarge-
ment of the vessels was at times demonstrable.

In ulcerative processes the lymphatics are, in part, de-
stroyed, though they may be regenerated. They occur only
sparsely in cicatricial tissue. No vegetations were observed
upon the walls of the vessels.

XII. Urinary and Sexual Apparatus.—1. Kidney epithelium.
—Heideuhain (‘ Schultze’s Archiv,’ vol. x, p. 1) describes re-
markable and hitherto unobserved peculiarities of structure
in the epithelium of the kidney. In the convoluted tubes
the epithelia are not simple cells, but very complicated

QUARTERLY CHRONICLE OF MICROSCOPICAL SCIENCE, 199

organized structures. A considerable portion of the proto-
plasm of the cell has undergone important modifications,
being converted into a large number of very delicate cylin-
drical bodies, which Heidenhain calls rods (stabchen).
Attached by their outer ends to the tunica propria, they
traverse the epithelial layer in a radial direction, being im-
bedded in a very small quantity of amorphous interstitial
substance. The nuclei, which lie at regular intervals, sur-
rounded by a more or less considerable quantity of undifferen-
tiated protoplasm, are enveloped by these rods, and what have
been till now described as dark granules in the body of the
cells are for the most part nothing but cross sections of the
rods. This conclusion is arrived at from investigations chiefly
on the dog’s kidney, but the author recommends (for the
study of the organ in a perfectly fresh state) those of the rat
and the hedgehog. The perfectly fresh specimens, examined
either in longitudinal or transverse section (with objective 8
or 9 of Hartnack), show a striated appearance, indicating the
presence of the rods. The latter are seen more clearly in
sections from specimens hardened in neutral chromate of am-
monia (5 per cent.) and alcohol successively. Another method
of hardening is to inject a saturated solution of potassium
chloride into the renal artery, and then harden in spirit.
Isolation of the elements is best effected by maceration in
caustic soda (33 per cent.), or in the 5 per cent. solution of
neutral chromate of ammonia. The rods thus isolated are
found to be cylindrical structures, somewhat variable in size,
some being as long as the whole thickness of the epithelial
layer, others shorter, and varying also in breadth. The
nuclei of the epithelium are also isolated by the same means,
and found to be surrounded by a protoplasmic mass, which
in some animals is separated from the rods, in others con-
tinuous with them. There is also asmall quantity of residual
cement substance between the rods. The nuclei and their
surrounding cell body never touch the wall of the tube, which
only shows the attachment of the rods. In the looped tubes
of Henle substantially the same relations are seen, but no rods
were discernible in the epithelium from the straight tubes of
the pyramids or the large collective tubes of the papille.
The comparative structure of the kidneys of birds and
snakes is illustrated -by observations which we must pass
over. rc
Experiments on the function of the kidneys were made by
Chronsezewski’s method of injecting indigo sulphate of soda
into the circulation (pure and specially prepared solution is
necessary, that usually obtained being impure). Heidenhain

200 QUARTERLY CHRONICLE OF MICROSCOPICAL SCIENCE,

concludes that the kidney is the specific excreting organ for
this substance, as for urea, but that in this the Malpighian
capsules take no part. The secretion is effected by the epi-
thelium of the convoluted tubes, which have a certain power
of reducing the indigo solution. The single tubes may act
quite independently of one another. The straight tubes
serve merely for conveying away the secretion when formed.

The conclusions drawn as to the function of the kidneys
are that not all the constituents of the urine are secreted in
the Malpighian capsules; and Ludwig’s view, that the urine
as a whole is a filtrate from the blood in the capsules, is un-
tenable. If the results attained with indigo may be extended
to the normal urinary products, Bowman’s view, that the
Malpighian corpuscles exude only water, with perhaps salts
of low atomic weight, must be adopted.

Rods similar to those seen in the kidney are met with in
the ducts of the parotid and submaxillary glands, and those
of certain glands of the nose, but not in the submaxillary.
These glands, however, show no corresponding difference of
function.

2. Spermatozoa.—Merkel publishes a preliminary notice
on the development of spermatozoa (‘ Centralblatt,’ No. 4,
1874, p. 65).

PROCEEDINGS OF SOCIETIES.

Royat Microscorican Society.
December 3rd, 1878.
Cuarzes Brooxe, Esq., F.R.S., President, in the chair.

A PAPER was read by the Rev. W.H. Dallinger and Dr. J.
Drysdale on “ Further Researches into the Life-History of the
Monads,” in continuation of that read at the November
meeting.

The authors subjected, as before, certain forms of monads
obtained in a maceration-fluid to continuous observation with high
powers, especially with a view to discover the method of increase
or multiplication. Fission has not proved in any case persistently
inquired into by them to be the essential method of multiplica-
tion ; though, since it is an accurate statement of facts so far as
they go, it is not surprising that it should be generally accepted
as the entire method. Nor has fission itself, they think, in these
minute forms, been described with sufficient care. It is not a
mere division of undifferentated sarcode into two parts. Before
separation takes place there is always a germination of the
anatomical elements, which make the new monad complete;
while in many instances the fission is completed by a suddenly
induced ameeboid condition. The original form has two flagella,
one permanently hooked, the other flowing. In fission similar
structures are formed for each new individual thus produced.
Multiplication by this method may continue without apparent
interruption for many days; but eventually two, four, or even six
of the monads may unite together, take a flaccid sac-like form,
becoming quickly distended, and dividing internally into seg-
ments, which go on subdividing till the sac is filled with beautiful
oval bodies which eventually escape, and are found to possess a
single flagellum; these rapidly grow, acquiring in a manner not
clearly made out the second (hooked) flagellum; and when thus
mature recommence multiplication by fission. This is the coin-
paratively simple life-history of the form. The paper is
published at length, with illustrations, in the journal of the
Society.

Mr. Charles Stewart called the attention of the meeting to a
section of the leaf of an india-rubber plant, which showed con-

202 PROCEEDINGS OF SOCIETIES.

cretions or “ cystoliths”’ existing in some of the cells. It was a
question whether these concretions were really composed of
erystals of carbonate of lime. He thought that they might be
regarded as cellulose or some gum-like material deposited upon a
cellulose stem.

A scientific evening was held in the Hall of King’s College on
December 10th, when a number of interesting objects were
exhibited.

January 7th, 1874.

A paper was read in continuation of the Rev. W. H. Dallinger
and Dr. Drysdale’s “Researches into the Life-History of the
Monads.” They described the development of avery simple form
of monad,—oval with a single flagellum, and not exceeding z755th
of an inch in diameter. One mode of increase was by multiple
fission. An ordinary egg-shaped monad passes through a series
of mutations of form till it settles as a minute sphere. A white
cruciform mark suddenly appears, and is succeeded by others at
right angles to the first. A rapid interior action ensues, and at
length the whole body of the sarcode is divided into a large
number of long bodies packed closely together, which separate as
flagellate monads. Conjugation is also observed. There is a much
smaller number of larger rounder monads, distinguished by their
granular aspect, which seize and absorb the common form, ‘The
result is a still condition in the form of a sphere. This eventually
opens, and a fluid is poured out, or what appears like it; no
sporules can be seen. The result of this, however, is the growth
of minute specks, which we can only ‘suppose to come from
invisible germs; and from these forms grow like the parents, and
the circle is by them re-entered.

A paper was read on“ The Origin and Development of the
Coloured Blood-Corpuscles in Man” by Dr. H. D. Schmidt, of
New Orleans.

The author had the rare opportunity of examining a human
ovum which was not less than three weeks and not more than
three months old, immediately after expulsion. It did not exceed
2+ centimetres in diameter, and when opened contained a balloon-
shaped vesicle, the umbilical vesicle, and a mass of cells and
nuclei, representing the embryo. On cutting into the wall of the
vesicle it was found to contain many blood-corpuscles, in various
stages of development, moving through smaller or larger canals.
Most of the corpuscles resembled fully developed human
corpuscles, but some larger ones appeared to be breeding or
mother-corpuscles, and contained blood-embryo disks within them.
Many of them had on their surface certain regularly formed
concave depressions, indicating the place where young corpuscles
had been detached. The process of multiplication consisted in
the separation from the mother-body, and near its surface, of a
‘small globular portion which represents the embryo bloud-
corpuscle. This enlarges and makes its way to the surface, where,

MEDICAL MICROSCOPICAL SOCIETY. 203

on being detached, it leaves behind a concave depression. This
differs from the prevailing belief that multiplication takes place
by division of coloured nucleated corpuscles. The process repre-
sents a transition from endogenous formation to budding or
gemmation.

Accumulations of blood-corpuscles were seen, beside in the
canals, in certain spaces limited by two layers of hexagonal cells,
forming a system of primary glandular follicles. The nuclei of
these hexagonal cells become the breeding- or mother-corpuscles
before mentioned. The author concludes that the primary birth-
place of the coloured blood-corpuscles in the human embryo is to
be sought in the above-described gland-like follicles of the umbi-
lieal vesicle. This view differs, of course, entirely, as he admits,
from the older observations, as from the later of Klein and those
of Balfour published in this Journal last year. Further observa-
tions are given on the later development of the blood and on the
structure of the corpuscles, for which we must refer to the
original paper and plates published in the Society’s journal.

Another paper by the Rev. W. H. Dallinger, on “ A Method
of Preparing Lecture Illustrations of Microscopic Objects” was
alyo read.

Meptoat MicroscoricaL Socrery.

At the ninth ordinary meeting of the Medical Microscopical
Society, held at the Royal Westminster Ophthalmic Hospital, on
Friday, November 21st, Japuz Hoge, Hsq., President, in the
chair; the minutes of the previous meeting were read and
confirmed.

Dr. Bruce described at some length the various methods of
studying inflammation. He considered that observing inflam-
mation in the frogs’s foot was useless for two reasons:—1l. The
epithelial surface soon becomes dim with the action of reagents,
so as to obscure the vessels. 2. The vessels are not altogether suit-
able, and, besides, there is sometimes difficulty in stretching the
web between the toes without interfering materially with tbe
circulation.

He therefore preferred the mesentery—and recommended Hart-
nack’s microscope—beginning the examination with a low power
and afterwards using Hartnack’s No. 7 objective (equal to an English
quarter in magnifying power). The frog plate should consist of a
piece of glass with a cork (having a circular hole in the middle and
covered with a small cover of glass) cemented with sealing wax to the
one end of it. The mesentery is then pinned out upon the cork over
the glass. The frog should be injected with one minim of a } per cent.
solution of curare subcutaneously, because this paralyses all the
muscles’ except the heart; then make an incision along the right
side of the body about an inch in length in a line with the leg and

-

204 PROCEEDINGS OF SOCIETIES.

arm, avoiding all blood-vessels, so as to prevent blood corpuscles
getting on to the mesentery, then draw out the intestine, and
having placed the mesentery on the cork plate moisten its surface
with salt solution. It is best to expose the mesentery for three
hours before the observation be made, and a large vessel is best for
examination. The chief difficulties which may be experienced are
(a) imperfect curarization, (6) adhesions, or (ce) tearing the
mesentery.

The mesenteries of warm-blooded animals had been used by
Stricker on his large warm stage, but Dr. Bruce had no experience
with them himself, and their examination was attended with a good
deal of difficulty.

The tongue of the frog is useful for studying inflammation.
Cohnheim first used it, placing the frog on its back and observing
the dorsum of the tongue, in which he excited inflammation by
snipping the mucous membrane; caustic has also been used for
this purpose. Cutting the mucous membrane, however, gives rise
to hemorrhage, therefore Cohnheim prefers making use of the
under surface, in which he causes inflammation by passing a ligature
round the root of the tongue. At the end of forty-eight hours he
undoes this and then white blood-corpuscles are seen to be passing
freely through the vessels. Dr. Bruce has found, however, that
after ligature the circulation does not always recover. To prevent
the ligature injuring the tongue it is best to place a piece of leather
between the ligature and the tongue. Dr. Bruce also referred to
the tail of the tadpole, the wing of the bat, and the cornea of the
rabbit, &c., as structures in which inflammation may be observed;
and then concluded by asking an opinion as to the origin of pus,
whether the members held with Cohnheim, that all pus comes from
the vessels, or from the connective tissue corpuscles, or from both
sources.

The President stated his opinion that investigating living tissues
would probably be the only means of advance in pathological
research. Paget even gave but crude information on inflammation,
while Cohnheim has elucidated much in living tissues.

Dr. Payne referred to the difficulty of Cohnheim’s experiment on
the mesentery. He also thought that Virchow’s idea of the
origin of pus, though now old-fashioned, was far from being over-
turned by Cohnheim, and that in inflammation of mucous surfaces
we see instances of small cells in larger (mother) ones, though he
acknowledged it might be true that the small cells migrated into
the larger. In the cornea and omentum proliferation has been seen.
One view may be taken of all these structures, viz. that some parts of
the body, and especially those of embryonic character show greater
tendency to reproductionthan others. He hadheard Virchowstate his
conviction that the more perfect endothelium of the peritoneum cou'd
not go on producing other elements while the more simple endothe-
lium of the lymphatics might do so. Dr. Payne then stated that
at present only a small class of tissues had been studied in a living
and inflamed condition, and until all tissues have been examined it

MEDICAL MICROSCOPICAL SOCLETY. 205

was not fair to speak generally on the subject. The escape of
colourless blood-corpuscles was undoubtedly an abundant source of
pus whatever other origin it might have.

Dr. Evans asked what effect curare had on the tone of the
vessels.

Mr. White asked if Dr. Bruce had tried the effect of chloroform
vapour on a curarized frog, because he had noticed a regurgitation
or stoppage in the circulation as a result. :

Mr. Schafer preferred the mesentery of the toad to that of the
frog because it is longer and has a lymphatic sac in its centre.

Dr. Matthews suggested the use of a spring clip instead of a
ligature for the frog’s tongue, and said that the use of curare might
be obviated by immersing the frog for a short time in warm
water. ,

Dr. Bruce, in -reply, stated that he was not aware that curare
had any influence upon the process of inflammation. He had not
tried chloroform for frogs. He also stated that the same results as
Dr. Matthews produced by placing a frog in warm water might
more conyeniently be brought about by holding the frog in the hand
for a few minutes.

Mr. Needham then showed his modification of Dr. Rutherford’s
microtome, which consisted in its having a movable glass plate on
the upper surface, through which the cylinder containing the
embedded specimen projected nearly, but not quite, to the level of
the cutting surface.

Dr. Matthews showed another modification of the same micro-
tome, and also a diagonal razor with the shoulder ground down flush
with the rest of the blade, which he found more handy than the
ordinary razor.

Mr. Miller advocated the use of a steel plate for the upper
surface of a microtome, the great drawback to its use being the
liability to rust. He preferred a thick razor.

Mr. Clippingdale showed a micro-spectroscope, in which two
spectra could be compared in one and the same field.

Mr. Kesteven described a method of microscopic drawing in
which the neutral tint glass of Dr. Lionel Beale’s reflector was
removed and an ordinary thin cover glass substituted.

Dr. Bruce then exhibited his specimens illustrative of inflam-
mation.

At the tenth ordinary meeting, held Friday, December 19th,
Jabez Hogg, Esq., President, in the chair—

Mr. J. W. Groves read a short paper “On methods of examining
circulation and urinary deposits by means of water-tight caps over
the higher powers of the microscope, after the fashion of Mr.
Stephenson’s submersion microscope.”” By this means he said that

VOL. XI1V.—NEW SER, oO

206 PROCEEDINGS OF SOCIETIES.

the circulation in a frog’s foot could be watched for several consecu-
tive days, because having half an inch or more of water over it the
web could not become dry, and moreover there was no necessity for
irritating it in any way, whereas it was scarcely possible to avoid
irritating it if an immersion lens were made use of, because a single
drop of water only being used at a time this was constantly evap-
orating, and had as constantly to be renewed. In his opinion, for
class demonstration this method of showing circulation was superior
to every other, not even excepting the immersion-lenssystem. He
had himself used it for this purpose and had found it to answer
most admirably.

Mr. Groves then said that if the sediment of a pint or more of
urine were emptied into a small flat glass dish with as little of the
urine as necessary, by means of the water-tight cap over an object
glass, the whole deposit could be examined in the course of a few
minutes, whereas if examined drop by drop on a slide, much of the
deposit would be lost and hours would be required for the examina-
tion of such as was secured.

In the discussion which followed, Dr. Matthews, Dr. Foulerton,
Mr. Giles, Mr. Miller, Mr. Hogg, and Mr. White, took part.

Mr. T. C. White described a small and painful tumour which he
had found in the cavity of a decayed tooth.

Mr. Hogg read notes and exhibited specimens of a case of
Bright’s disease.

In the discussion which followed Mr. Hogg’s remarks the follow-
ing gentlemen took part, viz. Dr. Matthews, Dr. Foulerton, Dr.
Bruce, Mr. Atkinson, Mr. Needham, Mr. Stowers.

Mr. Hogg exhibited charts of the spectra of chlorophyll.

Mr. White considered that probably at some future time charts
of the spectra of chlorophyll might prove of great service in medico-
legal inquiries.

The first annual meeting of this society was held January 16th,
at 8 p.m. o’clock, at the Royal Westminster Ophthalmic Hospital,
JaBrez Hoae, Esq., President, in the chair. From the report of
the committee it appeared that the society, though only one year
old, was in a most flourishing condition. During the year 129
members had joined it and sixteen papers had been read, each of
which was followed by a lively discussion, and at no meeting was
there any lack of specimens for exhibition. é

The following gentlemen were elected officers for the ensuing
year :— President, Mr. Jabez Hogg; Vice-presidents, Mr. W. B.
Kesteven and Drs. H. Lawson, J. F. Payne, and W. Rutherford ;
Treasurer, Mr. T. C. White ; Hon. Secretaries, Messrs. C. H. Golding
Bird and J. W. Groves; Committee, Drs. M. Bruce, E. C. Baber,
U. Pritchard, W. S. Greenfield, W. H. Allchin, J. Matthews, and
Messrs. H. Power, F. T. Paul, J. Needham, G. M. Giles, S.
Coupland, E. A. Schafer.

MEDICAL MICROSCOPICAL SOCIETY. 207

The President then delivered his address, after which votes of
thanks were accorded to the various officers, and the proceedings
terminated.

At the eleventh ordinary meeting of this Society, held on Friday,
February 20th, Jabez Hogg, Esq., President in, the chair, the
minutes of the previous meeting were read and confirmed. The
names of those gentlemen for proposal were read, and three other
gentlemen were duly elected members.

In the unavoidable absence of the Secretaries, the Treasurer,
Mr. T. C. White, read a communication from Mr. J. W. Groves,
“ On cataloguing and arranging microscopical specimens,” which will
be published in the next number of this Journal.

A vote of thanks having been passed; the President said he
thought the method proposed would superséde all others in use at
the present time. ,

Mr. Needham endorsed these remarks, and said he had been in
the habit of classifying his slides in physiological series, thus—
respiratory, digestive, &c., but this system had one great objection
which Mr. Groves’s obviated, viz.—that one slide might deserve to
be placed in several series but could not be, and, consequently there
was a great multiplication of specimens, and some difficulty often
in finding any particular preparation.

Mr. Giles, Dr. Matthews, Dr. Donkin, and Mr. R. P. Miller also
joined in the discussion.

Mr. Sidney Copeland then made some remarks on _prepara-
tions of “ Tuberculosis of the Choroid” in a child xt. 8 years.
After describing the normal structures, and stating that he in-
tended to confine himself wholly to the histological characters,
he said—That on removing the retiva the tubercles were
seen as translucent bodies, averaging !," in diameter, the
centres of which were mostly white and opaque from degenerative
eauses. The chorio-capillaries could be traced partially over the
tubercles. There was a marked deficiency of pigment and a notable
increase in the number of the large pale spheroidal bodies. The
tubercles were composed of nucleated cells 71,5” to gg455" in di-
ameter, and with these were seen some larger and variously shaped
cells, having more than one nucleus, some of which were possibly
derived from the normal pale spheroidal cells, though these were
quite as numerous.

The tubercles appeared to arise from the middle layer of the
choroid and always around the vessels. In the older tubercles the
central portions were made up of semifibrous and caseous material,
the peripheral only exhibiting the small cell growth. From this
distribution it was evident that the growth was perivascular, and
this had probably arisen from a proliferation of the lymphatic
endothelia, as in tubercles of the pia mater.

208 PROCEEDINGS OF SOCIETIES.

A vote of thanks having been accorded to Mr. Coupland, the
President, Messrs. Power, Cowell, Atkinson, Needham, and Miller
joined in the discussion.

In reply, Mr. Coupland said he had not examined the retina mi-
croscopically, but that the ophthalmoscope showed nothing abnormal.
The eyes had been removed two hours after death, placed in Miiller’s
solution for two weeks, thence into a solution of gum acaciz, from
that to methylated spirit which rendered it horny and fit for embed-
ding. The gum was removed from the sections by immersion in
water, or by simply placing them direct into the staining fluid.

There was a short discussion on the subject of Finders, and the
Meeting then resolved itself into a conversazione, when several in-
teresting preparations were exhibited.

The meetings for the next three months will be Fridays, April
17th, May 15th, June 19th, at the Royal Westminster Ophthalmic
Hospital, at 8 p.m. o’clock.

Liverroot Mepicat Instirution.—MIcRoscoPicaL
SEcTION.

Tut fifth Session of the Microscopical Section of the Liverpool
Medical Institution was inaugurated with a conversazione on
October 9th, 1873, given by the President of the Society—Dr.
John Cameron. Besides a very attractive exhibition of paintings
and works of art, there were exhibited a. number of the most
recent physiological instruments, microscopes illustrating various
branches of natural science, and a large collection of pharma-
ceutical preparations. ;

The second meeting was held on November 14th, 1873, when
Dr. Davidson read a paper on ‘‘ The Histology of Cancer of the
Liver.” Basing his remarks on the careful examination of several
cases of this disease which had recently been under his care, Dr.
Davidson commenced by inquiring—“ Do the normal tissues give
way before the cancer, or do they take part in its formation; and
if so, which tissues of the liver are converted into cancer, and
what part of the cancer do they individually go to form?” In
examining sections made from a liver affected secondarily by
cancer, showing nodules interspersed here and there, while the
hepatic tissue was also “infiltrated without losing entirely the
appearances of normal liver,” the author observed the cancer to
make its way along the portal canals, and at intervals the lumen
of the portal veins was completely occupied by a plug of cancer
cells. Passing to the lobules, cancer cells could be detected
within the blood-vessels, causing their dilatation, and pressing on
the surrounding hepatic substance. Dr. Davidson considers this
form of hepatic cancer to be originated either by cancerous
emboli being carried into the vessels, or by the epithelium of the

LIVERPOOL MEDICAL INSTITUTION, 209

vessels taking on a cancerous growth. The liver cells appear to
take no part in the formation of cancer, but are stretched by the
growth taking place in the vessels, and ultimately disappear.
On examining livers affected with primary cancer, Dr. Davidson
observed their connective tissue to be greatly increased both in
the portal canals and between the rows of liver cells; while at
intervals are seen groups of liver and other cells enclosed by the
bands of newly formed connective tissue, so that itis very difficult
to say whether in these cases the liver cells do not by degrees
pass into cancer cells.

At the same meeting Mr. Newton exhibited a specimen showing
“seeds of a foreign fruit, uric acid crystals, very large crystals
of the triple phosphates, and mannite,” which had been passed
per rectum by a patient presenting the symptoms of passing gall-
stones. In the discussion which followed several gentlemen
mentioned instances of patients passing phosphatic and uric acid
crystals, for several days in succession, along with the fxces.
The meeting was brought to a close by the members proceeding
to examine the specimens placed under about a score of micro-
scopes, and illustrative of the paper and communication for the
evening. ;

The third meeting was held on December 12th, 1873. The
paper read on this occasion by Mr. D. J. Hamilton on “ The
Morbid Auatomy of Epilepsy’ was very exhaustive and replete
with original research. At the author’s request we refrain from
further notice of it, as he intends ere long to publish it in extenso,
Mr. D. J. Hamilton illustrated his paper by numerous sections
of the spinal cord from epileptics ; and exhibited also a section of
an hypertrophied lymphatic gland.

The fourth meeting was held on January 30th, 1874, when
Mr. Rushton Parker read a paper on “The Development and
Growth of the Mammary Gland, and its Minute Anatomy in
Health and Disease.” Developed from the outermost layer of
the blastoderm, the mammary gland is first recognisable in the
foetus of the third month as a series of single tubes converging to
a central point and which afterwards extend beneath the skin by
a budding and lengthening of themselves and their offshoots ;
the nipple being substituted at this date by a depression. At
birth the gland consists of a number of tubes radiating from the
nipples, lined with columnar epithelium, and ending blindly at
the tip of each ray. At puberty in the female these blind tips of
the gland ducts grow out into vesicles (termed acini) lined by
spherical epithelial cells which under the influence of mutual
pressure become polyhedral and slightly angular. The acini next
multiply, form clusters like grapes, and are surrounded by an
abundance of connective tissue, When the first pregnancy takes
place the acini become further multiplied, each mammary lobe
enlarges, more blood passes through, and the connective tissue
gets succulent. Each acinus acquires an increased epithelial area,
new cells forming rapidly. and becoming insinuated between

21U PROCEEDINGS OF SOCIETIES.

those already existing, much epithelium is shed, each cell under-
going fatty degeneration and lying in a serous medium; in fact,
milk is formed. The connective tissue also shows increased
developmental activity and is charged with leucocytes that have
escaped from the blood-vessels. The blood-vessels surround the
secreting passages, but do not penetrate their epithelial layer.
The author next described the minute anatomy of the nipple,
and the probable arrangement of the lymph-vessels and lymph-
lacune in the mammary gland. Having alluded to the retro-
gressive changes which occur after each lactation, and still further
after menstruation has ceased, he mentioned the abnormalities
which have been met with in the number and position of the breast
and nipples. Having described shortly the varieties of ulceration
which attack the nipples—simple, syphilitic, eczematous, and very
rarely cancerous—Mr. Parker referred to atheroma of the seba-
ceous glands around the nipple, to acute and chronic abscesses of
the mamma at various periods of life, and to that very rare condi-
tion—true hypertrophy of the mamma, and then proceeded to
examine the microscopical characters of mammary tumours.
These he divided into two classes: (a) those arising in the
connective tissue of the gland; and (6) those which have their.
origin in its secreting substance. Although mammary tumours
arise in one of the above two ways, in nearly all secreting sub-
stance is found mixed up with the tumour, more or less altered,
but present nevertheless throughout. Lipoma or fatty tumour,
enchondroma or cartilaginous tumour, and fibroid or fibrous
tumours, were mentioned as rare affections, the usual tumour
found in the mammary connective tissue being one of the varieties
of sarcoma. The seat of sarcoma here is immediately beneath the
glandular epithelium, that is, in the connecting tissue surrounding
the secreting tubes. It causes primarily aswelling, with dilatation
of the ducts and acini in its neighbourhood ; later on projections
of sarcomatous mammary tubes protrude into the already dilated
ducts, so that a cystic growth is formed—a complicated cyst
with winding glandular projections. The usual form met with
is the round-celled, less frequently the spindle-celled sarcoma.
Among the tumours arising from the epithelium of the gland the
author described rare true adenoid tumours in which a morbid
extension of the whole secreting structure took place with or
without the formation of milk. Also partial adenoma (of which
he had met with two instances); and lastly Billroth’s epithelioma
of the mamma, in which the epithelium is so excessively increased
‘n quantity that the acini become enlarged to the size of millet
seeds or even to a diameter of jth inch. Of this variety of
tumour the author had met with one example—removed two
years ago, and, so far, proving clinically innocent. He concluded
by describing the minute anatomy of carcinoma of the breast.
His observations were illustrated by a large collection of beautiful
and well-selected specimens of sections of the healthy mamma
of a girl, old woman, and man; cf an epithelioma (Billroth’s) ;

DUBLIN MICROSCOPICAL CLUB. 211

of an intracystic growth, or “hernia of adenoid mammary tissue ;”’
of a fibrous tumour; of a round-celled sarcoma; and of carcinoma
from eight different cases.

Destin Microscoproan Cus.
25th September, 1873.

Sections of Miocene Zeolite-bearing Trap, exhibited —Prof. Mac-
alister exhibited a section of the Miocene Zeolite-bearing trap from
Trotternish, Isle of Skye, showing the relations of the Labradorite,
Augite, and Olivine crystals of which it is composed.

Spectroscopic examination of Crystals from a Cactus.—Mr. Tich-
borne stated that, since the previous meeting, he had at Dr. Moore’s
request, examined the crystalline masses, as they might be called,
found by him in a species of Cactus. These had proved themselves
to consist of oxalate of lime. When examined with the spectroscope
the calcium bands were given in a striking manner, showing the
value of this instrument for minute analysis. When the crystals
were ignited they gave white opaque particles without blackening ;
these were seen to effervesce when treated on the slide with acetic
acid. They were not soluble in acetic acid, but were so in hydro-
chlorie acid, and the resulting solution gave a precipitate on the
addition of ammonia. They were evidently, therefore, crystals of
oxalate of lime.

Exhibition of Alge from Hot-water Springs, Azores.—Mr. Archer
exhibited some further examples of alge and other organisms from
the Azores gatherings made by Mr. Mosely. Amongst these was the
alga ere now brought before the Club and spoken of as “ Animated
Sand” (see Club Minutes of July, 1871). He showed, too, a
curious gemma-growth on a moss stem, resembling the ‘ radical
tubercles’ (tubercules radiculaires, Schimper), but he hoped to
revert to this collection on a future occasion.

23rd October, 1873.

Structure of Ganoid bone of Ganorhynchus Woodwardi, Traquair.
—Dr. Traquair exhibited a section of the ganoid bone on the surface
of the fossil fish-snout, which he had recently described as Gano-
rhynchus Woodwardi. ‘Though the fish belonged to the Order
Dipnoi, and not to the Ganoids proper, the section exhibited cha-
racters essentially similar to those found in the polished plates and
scales of many Ganoid fishes. When the section was taken the
bone was very thin, being only about {,” in thickness. It showed
first a thin superficial layer of structureless ganoine about 7,55”
thick ; through this the punctures of the surface opened into a set
of short vertical canals, widening downwards so as to assume a
somewhat conical figure; these communicated with each other at
their bases, and also with the close, irregular network of Haversian
canals which ramified through the remaining inferior part of the

212 PROCEEDINGS OF SOCIETIES,

section. Below the ganoine the interval between the short vertical
canals, more or less cup-shaped in the section, were seen to be, for
the most part, traversed each by a short vertical tube coming up
from the Haversian network below, and dividing in an arborescent
manner into a multitude of minute ramifying tubules, passing
towards, but not into, the ganoine above. The branches of adjacent
trees of this kind also fr eely communicated with each other around
and between the short vertical canals, between which their stems
were situated. It must be noted, however, that osseous lacunz
were occasionally seen among its minute tubules. Lacune of the
normal type abounded in the substance of the bone below.

“ Winter Eqq” of Notommata.—Mr. Crowe showed the “ winter
egg ”’ of a Notommata-species, much resembling in external figure the
zy gospore of certain Desmids, its long spines dilated below, covering
the surface and extending radially i in all directions, the apices some-
what curved.

Irish Thysanura.—Dr. E. Perceval Wright exhibited a small col-
lection of Thysanura made within the compass of a two-acre field at
Howth, consisting of Orchesella cincta, Tomoceros longicornis,
T plumbea, Lepidocyrtus curvicollis, L. purpureus, Degeeria nivalis,
Isoloma anglicana, Lipura maritima, and Machilis maritimus.
Several of these had not previously been recorded as Irish. No
group of Arthropods needed investigation more than this, and none
required a more patient microscopical investigation to determine
not only the limits of the species, but also of the genera.

In noticing the recent ‘ Monograph on the Collembola and Thy-
sanura’ by Sir John Lubbock, Dr. Wright pointed out afew errors,
both of commission and of omission, that had struck him on a hasty
glance over the volume; the typographical errors were not only
very numerous, but in some places extremely puzzling.

Ameba with remarkable posterior linear processes.—Mr. Archer
drew attention of the meeting to a remarkable and well-pronounced
example of the same condition in Ameeba once before shown to the
Club (see Minutes of the Club, February, 1866), consisting in the
projection from the posterior end of a number of linear prolongations
of the body substance (like a bundle of dip-candles, if the candles
were of varying lengths!). These prolongations or processes
possessed a certain amount of temporary rigidity, and gave a very
odd-looking appearance to the specimen ; it was in active progression,
and the behaviour (as regards flow of contents, locomotion, &c.)
was quite that of an 4. villosa.

Cosmocladium Saxonicum, de Bary, exhibited —Mr. Archershowed
examples from Connemara of the seemingly widely distributed, but
always extremely scanty, alga, Cosmocladium Saxonicum, de Bary,
drawing attention to the points dwelt upon by de Bary as dis-
tinguishing this form from C. pulchellum, Bréb., which latter had
not appeared in this country. ‘The supposition is, however, open
that these may be one and the same thing, and the confusion (if
any) due to a certain want of definiteness as regards de Brébisson’s
description and figure.

DUELIN MICROSCOPICAL CLUB. 213

Zygospore of Micrasterias papilliferd, for the first time found in
Ireland.—Mr. Archer showed the zygospore of Micrasterias papil-
lifera, Bréb. from Glencolumbkille, Co. Donegal. This rather common
species, though not at all abundant, does not seem to have been
met with conjugated since recorded by Ralfs. As is shown by that
author, the zygospore is very like, though, of course, smaller than
that of Micrasterias denticulata, Bréb., though the mature plant is
quite dissimilar, and it is seemingly of interest to note this fact,
seeing the very dissimilar zygospores of the latter and that of M.
rotata, Ralfs, although these two forms, from possessing a con-
siderable resemblance to one another, have ere now by some been
held to be but varieties one of the other. The present examples
formed exceedingly ornate objects.

New Species of Oolpocephalum, exhibited.—Mr. H. W. Mac-
kintosh showed a new species of Colpocephalum from Ardea
purpurea, of which he would, ere long, prepare a figure and due
description; its nearest ally was C. flavescens.—Dr. Macalister
showed, as further illustrative of the genus and for sake of com-
parison, Colpocephalum zebra.

20th November, 1873.

Cosmarium Holmiense, 6 Lundell, exhibited. —Mr. Crowe
showed a Cosmarium taken by him, in company with Dr. J. Barker,
from a wet rock at the Falls of the Rhine, which turned out to be
identical with Cosmariwm Holmiense, 6 Lundell; this form has
now been taken in Norway and Spitzbergen.

Sections from a puzzling Fern-like stem—a marine waif—ex-
hibited. Mr. Mackintosh showed sections made by him from
a stem of fern-like or lycopod aspect, found cast ashore on
the Kerry coast, and forwarded by Rev. M. H. Close; this was
about nine inches long, about an inch in diameter, twice dichoto-
mously branched, and densely covered in an imbricated manner by
the scale-like bases of former leaves, the whole of a black colour.
These sections showed scalariform vessels, The origin of this
curious waif was quite unknown, the general opinion being that it
was of fern nature.

Action of Chloroform on Hair affected by Porrigo decalvans.—
Dr. Frazer showed the action of chloroform in bleaching hairs
affected with Porrigo decalvans or true ring-worm, a reaction lately
discovered by Dr. Dyce Duckworth. Under this reagent the
diseased hairs and portions of the epithelium affected become of
pale yellowish-white colour, and an excellent criterion is afforded of
the extent of the disease.

Sections of Nail and Walrus Tooth, exhibited.—Mr. Pearsall
showed with the polariscope sections of human nail and of walrus
tooth.

Micrasterias furcata, found for the first time in Ireland, ex-
hibited along with M. radiosa.—Mr. Archer showed two very rare
forms (as Irish) of Micrasterias, from Co. Galway, viz. Mi-
crasterias furcata (Ag.) and Mf. radiosa (Ag.). The former

214 PROCEEDINGS OF SOCIETIES.

he had never before found in Ireland, and had, indeed, only once
before seen it from near Ambleside, in Westmoreland ; the latter
he had taken only once before in Ireland (Connemara). As
previously mentioned, MMicrasterias furcata (the handsomest
British form!) was to his eyes quite a distinct thing from IZ. erua-
melitensis, though, ere he had seen an indubitable example of JZ.
furcata, he had conjectured they might possibly be one and the
same.—Mierasterias radiosa he had taken previously in Wales, but
only in Ralf’s single locality for it, Llyn Gwernan, near Dolgelly,
and once before in Ireland, (Connemara); Irish specimens did not
seem quite so large as the Welsh.

Staurastrum arctiscon (Ehr.), Lund., new to Ireland.— Mr. Archer
likewise showed, new to Ireland, from Connemara, that very fine
form Stawrastrum arctiscon (Ehr.), Lundell ; of this, indeed, he had
found only three or four examples, though he had most patiently
gone over the material in the hope of increasing the number, and it
is so large and striking a form it could hardly escape observation
in an ordinary field of view, even under the lowest powers. It is
quite distinct from Staurastrum sexangulare, Bulnh., upon taking
which species for the first time Mr. Archer had thought to be S¢.
arctiscon possibly.

Docidium coronatum, Ehr., exhibited.—Mr. Archer also showed
the, with us, rare Docidiwm coronatum (Ehr.), a fine species, not
unlikely, however, to be overlooked for Docidiwm nodulosum.

Heterophrys Fockii, Archer, exhibited in groups.—Mr. Archer
showed a very fine collection, presenting many groups conjoined,
sometimes as many as a dozen or so of individuals of Heterophrys
Fockii ; this rhizopod, when nicely illuminated, forming then a pretty
and curious-looking object, calling to mind Haeckel’s figure of
Myzxodictyum sociale, but it need not be said a wholly different
thing. These examples showed the pseudopodia extended to a very
great length; longer, in fact, than he had ever before seen, say three
or four times the body-diameter.

Form of Navicula lyra (possibly a distinct species ?)—
Rev. E. O’Meara showed a form of Navicula lyra, Ehr., from
stomachs of Ascidians (Roundstone Bay, Co. Galway), which in all
its details coincided with the form described by Grunow, ‘ Ueber
neue oder ungeniigend gekannte Algen,’ p. 582, t. ili, f. 22. The
striation is minutely but distinctly punctate and quite unlike that of
the well-known forms of Navicula lyra. On this ground he con-
sidered it as a well-marked variety thereof, but not entitled to be
considered as a distinct species.

18th December, 1873.

Closterium linea, Perty, exhibited.—Mr. Crowe showed Closteriwm
linea, Perty, from the little Stephanosphera-pool on Bray-head,
the first time that that species had been met with in that restricted
site.

A Form of Navicula didyma, W. Sm. (possibly a distinct species’),
exhibited.— Rev. EK. O’ Meara showed a form he considered identical

DUBLIN MICROSCOPICAL CLUB. 215

with Wavicula didyma, sporangial variety, W. Sm., ‘ Brit. Diat.,’
vol. i, t. xvii, f. 154, a. This bears a strong resemblance to JV.
Smithit, var. fusca, Greg., so that it is not surprising that some
should have identified it with the last-named species. A close in-
spection, however, of the peculiarities led him to the conclusion that
it is quite distinct. The central panels in both are somewhat
rhombical, and the striation in this portion very similar, apparently
costate ; Navicula fusca, indeed, in some aspects, appears slightly
incurved at the sides, but this is plainly constricted. In the former
the general striation is moniliform—in the latter it consists of some-
what elongated lines, and much coarser than the other species.

Nostochaceous filaments in tissue of Azolla, exhibited.—Professor
M‘Nab exhibited an illustration of the presence of Nostochaceous
filaments in the tissue of higher plants, an occurrence recently
drawn attention to by observers (Reinke and others), as exemplified
by Azolla. These he had extracted from the tissue and placed
under the microscope, stating that, on looking over the collection he
possessed of different Azolla-species, all had shown him the presence
of these algz within their tissue, adverting also to the fact that,
whilst these had for some time been noticed, they had been by certain
observers interpreted as in some way connected with the reproductive
apparatus of the Azolla. The presence of foreign algee forms within
the tissue of higher plants had lately acquired a double interest,
that which attached to their living and seemingly flourishing in so
unexpected a habitat, as well as that which these “ parasitic” alge,
so called ad interim, had in relation to the new theory of
the nature of “lichen-gonidia” propounded by de Bary and
Schwendener. ,

Lilustrations of the Reproductive Apparatus in Marchantiee.—
Dr. Moore exhibited plants of Morckia hibernica, Gottsche, and
Petalophylium Ralfsii, Gottsche. The latter had the male and
female flowers in good condition. Groups of young archegonia
ready for impregnation, and some impregnated, were shown.
Dr. Moore mentioned that he had seen numbers of the thread-like
bodies like spermatozoa floating about among the archegonia, but
could not observe that they entered at the apex of those bodies.
The observation was made with a moderately good French 4 object
glass. On another slide Dr. Moore had the male flowers of Lunu-
laria vulgaris, which, he observed, were in good condition at this
period of the season. He further observed that when the male
flowers are fully ripe, if the plant be put into a pan or saucer and
covered over with a pane of glass, a quarter of an inch or so apart
from the surface of the plant, the glass, though well cleaned when
put on, will after a few days become discoloured. If the substance
which causes this be gently scraped off and put on a slide with a
little water, and covered with a covering glass, it will be found to
consist chiefly of the ovate antheridia, which led him to conjecture
that those minute organisms are ejected from their cavities on the
surface of the thallus by a jerk. He had not seen this take place,
but he could not account otherwise for this being on the surface of

216 PROCEEDINGS OF SOCIETIES.

the glass, which was so far apart from the plant. The phenomenon
can also be well observed in plants Fegatella coniea, Corda.

Bulbochete minor, Prings., exhibited in fruit (mid-winter).—Mr.
Archer showed examples in various more or less developed and
nearly perfect fruit of Bulbochete minor, Pringsheim, possibly
possessing an additional interest as being taken in fruit in midwinter.
The commencing formation of the oogonia and variously advanced
stages were well seen, also of the antheridia. The fully-formed
oogonia showed the characteristic longitudinal ribs ; further, what
seemed to be a new character was noticeable in some empty speci-
mens, that these ribs were connected by numerous transverse, though
delicate, lines, giving a scalariform appearance.

East Kent Naturat History Socrery.
Honorary Secretary, Gtorce Guuuiver, F.R.S.
October 2nd, 1873.

Crystals in Leguminous Plants—The Hon. Sec. exhibited
drawings and preparations, and gave practical demonstrations in
the fresh plants, of the crystals of oxalate of lime which he had
discovered in the leaves, pods, liber, and other parts of Legu-
minose, since illustrated by a plate in the December number of
the ‘Monthly Microscopical Journal.’ These crystals, mostly
belonging to one or the other of the prismatic systems, he calls
short prismatic crystals, thus distinguishing them from raphides,
spheraphides, long crystal prisms, or other forms of plant-crystals.
The short prismatic crystals resemble those in the testa of the
elm, described and figured in last July number of the ‘ Quarterly
Journal of Microscopical Science,’ and are about 5555th of an
inch in diameter, and occur very abundantly in chains of cells
along the fibro-vascular bundles of the leaves, calyx, and pods,
and also scattered throughout many membranous parts. In one
inch of one vein of a single leaflet of clover he counted no less than
17,500 of the short prismatic crystals ; and his lecture was con-
cluded by observations on the significance of these crystals in the
economy of animals and plants.

Dentate Scales of Plewronectide.—Mr. Hayward showed some
prepared slides of the notched scales (ctenoid) of the sole, being
a good example, contrary to the rule, of this form of scale in
soft-finned fish.

November 6th, 1873.

The late Maor William Augustus Munn.—Referring to the
recent death of this eminent apiarian, and the loss which his
widow and family and eutomological science had sustained thereby,
a motion expressive of the sympathy and regret of the society, of
which he had long been a most valuable member, was unanimously
carried. ;

EAST KENT NATURAL HISTORY SOCIETY. 217

Statoblasts of Plumatella.—-Colonel Horsley remarked the
abundance of Plwmatella repens about Canterbury, and how
easily this beautiful species may be kept in the aquarium. This
had enabled him to confirm Dr. Allman’s observations, that the
statoblasts are not ova, but a peculiar form of bud produced in
the funiculus. The Colonel exhibited the statoblasts under the
microscope, and suggested, for future research, the question as
to how far they may admit of comparison with the winter ova of
Rotifera, and the ephippia of Daphne.

Hydras and their Prey—Mr. Fullagar showed many live
specimens of Hydra viridis and Cyclops quadricornis. When the
Cyclops was put to the Hydra, the former was instantly taken
by the latter, sometimes ingested immediately, and often only
seized or touched by the polyp’s tentacles, and allowed to float
away. But in either case the death of the prey was sure, as
proved in many trials. Hence he concludes in the affirmative
as to the vexed question of the power of the fresh-water polyp to
destroy its prey by mere stinging.

December 4th, 1873.

Eggs of Fresh-water Polyps.—Mr. Fullagar exhibited and made
some observations thereon. The ovum of Hydra vulgaris is of
an orange colour, and about ,;th of an inch in diameter; the
ovum of Hydra viridis is of a light brown colour, and about th
of an inch in diameter ; these ova of both species are spherical.
Anegg of Hydra viridis, detached from the parent towards the
end of May, was hatched in his aquarium about thirty days
thereafter.

Utricular Hairs of Chenopods.—The Hon. Sec. showed, by
drawings and preparations, that the so-called mealiness of these
plants is produced by simple hairs of two or three cells, the
terminal cell being dilated into a globular vesicle, numbers of
which so reflect the light as to produce the mealy appearance.
By transmitted light they appear colourless and transparent. The
dilated terminal cell is about 54,;th of an inch in diameter.

Calcareous granules on Bryonia dioica.—These, commonly de-
scribed by botanists as “ asperities” or “ callous points,” he proved,
by extemporaneous preparations and experiments, should be
rather called Calcareous granules ; tor this is their true nature,
as they are composed of carbonate of lime. Each callous point is
about ;1,th of an inch in diameter, and the smooth, shiny, con-
stituent granules composing that point have an average size of
gi,th of an inch. This profusion of calcareous matter on the sur-
face of the leaf of bryonia is remarkable, as this plant is throughout
devoid of any raphides, and contains an unusually small number of
other saline crystals.

Spheraphides and Epidermis of the leaf of the Tea Plant.—The
public mind being now much interested about the adulterations
of tea, the Hon. Sec. gave some demonstrations, and exhibited
preparations of the leaf of a fresh plant of Thea viridis. The

218 PROCEEDINGS OF SOCIETIES.

epidermis on both sides of the leaf was shown to be composed
alike of cells with sinuous margins (colpenchyma), with the addi-
tion to the epidermis on the under surface of oval stomata, and
shortish, smooth, taper, slightly curved hairs. Throughout the
parenchyma of the leaf were sphzraphides, thickly studded, and
with a mean diameter of about +,)55th of an inch; and here and
there were short strings of similar spheraphides, only about half
as large, on the fibro-vascular bundles. ‘The composition of the
spheraphides appears to be chiefly oxalate of lime. They are not
easy to find, in'consequence of the density and opacity of the
surrounding parts; and this is probably the reason why these
beautiful crystals have hitherto escaped discovery.

Value of Potash in Histological Phytotomy.—At the same time
he remarked that the value of potass in separating the fibres,
membranes, or cells, and clearing parts of plants for microscopical
investigation, seems to have been insufficiently appreciated. He
showed, for example, that by treatment with cold solution of this
alkali, and still better by boiling in it portions of the tea leaf, the
epidermis could easily be detached from both sides, leaving quite
distinct the intervening layer of parenchyma and nerves, and thus
beautifully exposing the spheraphides. He had found the potass
equally useful in disclosing the short prismatic crystals in legu-
minous and many other plants, and in examination of the tea of
commerce ; so that the heretofore refuse of the teapot may be made
a very interesting subject for microscopical inquiry.

paw

MEMOIRS.

On the Term Enpotuertium. By Micuaen Foster, M.D.,
F.R.S., Prelector in Physiology, Trin. Coll., Cam.

Tue word “ endothelium” has been recently introduced
into histology, and the use of it has rapidly become common,
if not general. The speedy acceptance of a new term may,
in many cases, but not in all, be taken as an indication that
something of the kind was wanted; and the already frequent
use of endothelium,” both by Continental and English
histelogists, would seem to show the need of some other
phrase besides “‘ epithelium.” Nevertheless, there are cogent
reasons why the new term should not be allowed to take any
further root.

In the first place, its etymology is of the most grotesque
kind. This is of course an objection of secondary value ;
but still it carries some weight. When aterm has come into
daily use, with a clear, well-defined meaning attached to it,
it does not matter much what its etymology is or how it is
spelt, except on historical grounds. Many terms get so
altered in their meanings before they finally acquire a per-
manent application, that the chief interest in their etymology
is confined to the light it throws on the ideas of the man who
first introduced them. This is the chief reason why new
terms should be etymologically correct, in order that future
inquirers may read back through them into the minds of
earlier observers. When a word is etymologically pure non-
sense, this is apt to become impossible. Such is the case
with endothelium.

It appears to have been first introduced by His, to desig-
nate the kind of epithelium (pseudo-epithelium, wndchte epr-
thelien’’) which is found lining the vascular, lymphatic, and
serous cavities of the body, in contradistinction to the real
epithelium of mucous membranes. He says (Die Haute und
Héhlen des Korpers. Academisches Programm. Basel, 1865,
p- 18) :—

VOL, XIV.—-NEW SEK. P

220 DR. MICHAEL FOSTER,

Alle die Zellenschichten, welche den Binuenraumen des
mittleren Keimblattes zugekehrt sind, zeigen nun aber unter
sich so viel Gemeinsames und sie differiren von der ersten Zeit
ihres Auftretens auch so erheblich von den Zellenschichten,
die aus den beiden Granzblattern hervorgegangen sind, dass
man, im Interesse physiologischen Verstandnisses wohl
thun wird, sie von diesen durch eine besondere Bezeichunng
zu scheiden, sei es, dass man sie als undchte Epithelien den
dchten gegeniiber stellt, sei es dass man sie Endothelien
neunt um mit dem Wort ihre Beziehung zu den innern
Korperflachen auszudricken.

Endothelium is here contrasted with epithelium, so that
the latter may be considered as the “‘ thelium” of free surfaces
(whether invaginated or not), and the former as the ‘‘ thelium”
of internal closed spaces ; “ thelium” apparently being taken
to mean “a layer or layers of cells.”

Now, what is the derivation of “epithelium?” I am in-
debted to Dr. Sharpey for the following account. He says,
in a letter to me :—‘* Epithelium, or rather ‘ epithelida,’ and
especially ‘ epithelia’ (first declension), was introduced by
F. Ruysch. In describing a preparation of the face of a child
finely injected, he refers to the cuticle over the red part of
the lip (prolabium), and says, ‘I cannot call this “ epi-
dermis,” seeing that the subjacent tissue is not skin, but a
different substratum covered with sensitive (nervous) papillz,
which are finely injected red.’ He then goes on to say that
as the cuticle lies on papille he will call it epithelida, or
epithelia, from exc and @nAn, ‘ papilla’ or ‘mammilla,’ and
he adds that for the same reason he calls the inside coating
of the cheeks by the same name. The original is as
follows (Ruysch, F., ‘Thesaurus Anatomicus III,’ No. xxiii,
p-. 16) :—

<< * * * Nulla sabest huic integumento cutis, ergo epidermis
dici nequit quamvis analogiam summam et connexionem cum
illa habet * * * * comperi prolabia constituta esse ex meris
papillis non cutaneis (cutis enim hic revera deest) sed papillis
nervosis ; itaque integumentum illud supradictum potius
epithelida dixero vel integumentum papillare prolabiorum
quod revera nil est nisi efflorescentia seu expansio extremita-
lum papillarum.’

‘“‘In €Thesaurus Anatomicus VI,’ No. exv, p. 49, he
says, ‘ Anterior pars prolabii inferioris—epithelia adhuc est
obducta.’ ”

From this it is evident that epithelia, changed in course of
time into epithelium, just as platina has become platinum,
means “that which covers or is upon a papilla,” and conse-

ON THE TERM ENDOTHELIUM, 221

quently endothelium means “ that which is inside a papilla.”
. The extension of the phrase epithelium to the cellular covering
of such parts of the corium as are destitute of papille may be
easily allowed, but it does seem a most daring defiance of all
meaning of words to apply the phrase “ within the papilla ”
to the cells coating surfaces of which one great characteristic
is that they are devoid of papille! There seems to be some-
thing attractive about “thelium” that tempts writers to
make use of it. Already endothelium has given rise toa new
“ectothelium,” and probably after a few years “ thelium”
will become a sort of histological maid-of-all-work, with as
many prefixes as there are kinds of cells.

In the second place, there are objections to the use of
endothelium not etymological in their nature.

The peculiar views of His on the origin of the connective
tissues of the body would, if true, afford a strong argument
for the use of some special term to denote such kinds of
epithelium as were formed out of his parablast. Putting these
aside as mistaken, there still remains the question whether it
is not desirable to have some distinctive appellation to denote
the epithelium which is formed out of the elements of the
middle of the three layers of the germ (the mesoblast of Mr.
Huxley and myself), the word epithelium itself being reserved
for the nether layer (or hypoblast).

If so, the word endothelium cannot be employed with this
meaning, for it would then include structures still called epi-
thelium, and differing in no essential characters from the
epithelium derived directly trom the hypoblast.

The cells lining the Wolffian duct, and its derivative the
ureter, with their branches, would then come under the head-
ing endothelium. Whatever be the exact mode of the first
formation of the Wolffian duct, whether by the central solu-
tion of a solid ridge, or by an infolding of the lining of the
pleuroperitoneal cavity, it is lined by cells which are clearly
mesoblastic in origin, not hypoblastic nor, as was once sug-
gested, epiblastic.

The case of Miiller’s duct is still more clear. This un-
doubtedly arises by an infolding of the lining of the pleuro-
peritoneal cavity. Its epithelium is distinctly mesoblastic in
origin. The germinal epithelium which gives rise to the
ovaries is also essentially mesoblastic.

If the word endothelium, then, be taken to denote an epi-
thelium derived from the mesoblast, it must be extended to
include the epithelium of the Wolffian and Miillerian ducts,
and of the parts which are formed ultimately out of those
structures. But if these be included, the phrase loses all its

222 DR. MICHAEL FOSTER.

practical utility. If they are excluded, all the little meaning
it ever had vanishes.

It may be urged that we need a word to denote the epi-
thelium which is found in the vascular and lymphatic spaces.
There does not, however, appear to be sufficient reason why
the same term should be applied to the whole of this
epithelium. As we have seen, its common mesoblastic origin
will not justify this. From a structural point of view, three
distinct varieties may be recognised in it, viz. the spindle-
shaped cells of the blood-vessels and larger lymphatic vessels,
the sinuous cells of the commencing lymphatics and the
polygonal cells of the large serous cavities. The fact that
the epithelium of the peritoneum is continuous with that of
the lymphatics affords no argument whatever for classing
them together. We find continuity everywhere. The epi-
dermis is continuous with the alimentary epithelium, and with
the urinary and generative epithelium; and the generative epi-
thelium is in turn continuous with the peritoneal epithelium.
In short, there is no reason why the cells spoken of as form-
ing endothelium should have a common title, distinct from
the general term epithelium.

The introduction of the new term is really a step backwards
from instead of an advance beyond the old classification
adopted by Dr. Sharpey in Quain’s ‘ Elements of Anatomy.’
He divides epithelium either physiologically into epidermic,
mucous, glandular, vascular, serous, &c., or structurally into
columnar, spheroidal, ciliated, tesselated, squamous, &c.

Surely some such nomenclature as this satisfies all require-
ments, either morphological or physiological, at least for the
present.

The chief morphological importance, as far as our know-
ledge goes, attaches itself to the question from which of the
three primary layers any given epithelium is derived, whether
from epiblast, hypoblast, or mesoblast; and it is precisely
because the phrase endothelium is in this respect misleading
that its use is so undesirable. Beyond this, it is difficult to
see any morphological interest, unless future research should
show that in the common mesoblast there are factors morpho-
logically distinct. When that is clearly shown, it will be
time to invent new terms which may be as lasting and as
valuable as ectoderm and entoderm.

For physiological purposes all we need is some system of
phrases which shall clearly indicate the individual characters
and the arrangement of any group of cells. The few terms,
“columnar” or “cylindrical” and “spheroidal,” either
“ciliated” or “‘ non-ciliated,” are almost all we want for

THE GASTRAEA-THEORY, ETC, 223

mucous membranes in general. The word “squamous”
sufficiently clearly indicates the general character of an
epithelium made up of flattened cells which overlap, as
*tesselated” equally clearly signifies an epithelium of flat-
tened cells fitting into each other at their edges. These
are general distinctions. Such special forms as the sinuous
cells of the commencing lymphatics or the jagged cells
of the epidermis do not need any distinctive general ap-
peliation.

We perhaps do want easy terms which shall denote
whether the epithelium in any spot consists of several layers,
or of one pronounced layer only. The latter might be called
monoderic (Sepoc = depua), the former polyderic.

Epithelium itself would simply mean cells lining a cavity
or coating a free surface.

The GASTRAEA-THEORY, the PHYLOGENETIC CLASSIFICATION
of the Anima Kinepom and the Homotocy of the
GrrM-LamMeLLe. By Ernst Haxrcxen. (Translated by
K. Prercevan Wricut, M.D., F.L.S., Sec. R.IA.,
Professor of Botany, Trin. Coll., Dublin. With Pl. VII.)

(Continued from p. 165.)

5.—Tue SystTEMATIC SIGNIFICATION OF THE GASTRAEFA
THEORY.

Tue following conclusions relating to the natural system
of the animal kingdom, or, what is the same thing, to its
genealogical tree, result from the foregoing discussions,
which I have already explained, partly in the ‘ Biology of
the Calcareous Sponges’ and partly in the fourth edition of
the ‘ Naturliche Schopfungsgeschichte’ (in the eighteenth
lecture). The whole animal kingdom divides into two
large principal groups, the gastrula forming the separating
boundary line between them; on the one side the stem-
group of the primary animals (Protozoa); on the other,
the six higher stem-groups which we oppose to the others
as animals with germ-lamelle (Metazoa or Blastozoa).
In the primary animals (the Protozoa) the entire body
consists either (1) of a simple cytode (Monera, Monotha-
lamia), or (2) of an aggregate of cytodes (Polythalamia), or
(3) of a simple cell (Ameebe, unicellular Gregarine, Infu-

224 ERNST HAECKEL.

soria), or (4) of an aggregate of simple, similar cells (poly-
cellular Gregarine, Synameeba), or, lastly (5), those where
the cells of the body may even be differentiated to a slight
extent, but which still form no germ-lamelle, and enclose
no true intestinal cavities. The individuality of the Protozoa
always remains fixed at a very low point; that is, they either
form a morphon of the first order, a simple plastid (a cytode
or a cell), or they form, at most, a morphon of the second
order, an “organ” in a purely morphological sense, an
idorgan (see the doctrine of individuality in the ‘ Biology of
the Calcareous Sponges,’ p. 103, &c.). But the Protozoa
never raise themselves to the importance of a morphon of
the third or fourth order, a Person or a Stock (in the sense
defined in the passage quoted). Just as a true intestine (the
first and oldest organ of the germ-lamellar animals) is want-
ing in the Protozoa, so are absent also all the differentiated
systems or organs which we find in the former. ‘The
Protozoa have no nervous system, muscular system, vascular
system, dermal system, &c. ‘They also want the differen-
tiated tissues.

On the important grounds which I have fully developed
in the second volume of the ‘ General Morphology’ and in
my ‘ Monograph of Monera,’ it seems to hea real advantage,
especially towards the comprehension of general biology, to
separate a large portion of the so-called Protozoa from the
animal kingdom, and to relegate them to the neutral kingdom
of Protista, intermediate between the animal and vegetable
kingdoms. ‘To this would belong part of the Monera, the
Ameeboida, and Flagellata, in addition to the Catallacta, the
Labyrinthulea, the Myxomyceta, and the entire class, so rich
in forms, of Rhizopoda, with all its different divisions ;
Acyttaria, Radiolaria, &c. All these Protista are to be re-
garded as independent organic stems or phyla, which do not
stand in any kind of genealogical connection with the animal
kingdom,and consequently do not belong to its natural system.
On the other hand, there are very simple organisms which
either belong to the actual stem-forms of the animal kingdom,
and form the true root of the animal genealogical tree, or
represent independent offshoots from that root, as well as
those very simple organisms which display an undoubtedly
animal character (as the Infusoria), which are to be separated
from these neutral primary forms or Protista as true primary
animals or Prorozoa. ‘These Monera and Ameebe should
be regarded as true primary animals, representing the
oldest stem-forms of the animal kingdom, and I have classed
these in the fourth edition of the Schdpfungsgeschichte

THE GASTRAEA-THEORY, ETC, 225

as egg-animals (Ovularia), because they possess a shape cor-
responding to the simplest (nucleus-containing) egg-cell or
the egg-cytode (without nucleus). With these must also be
reckoned the planula representing animal forms (Planeada),
and, finally, the Gregarine, the Acinetz, and the true ciliated
Infusoria (Ciliata).

The second main division of the animal kingdom is com-
posed of the six higher stem-groups, which are all derived
‘from the common stem-form of the Gastraea. We class them
together as germ-lamellar animals, Mrrazoa (or Blastozoa),
or animals with an intestine (Gastrozoa). In all these animals,
from the sponges up to the Vertebrata, the body always
originally develops itself from two primary germ-lamelle, the
animal exoderm, and the vegetative endoderm. The latter
always encloses a true intestinal cavity with a mouth-opening.!
Therefore the body has the form-value of a morphon of the
third order, a true person, or is composed of several persons,
and is then an individual form of the fourth order, a
stock (‘ Biology of the Calcareous Sponges,’ p. 103, &c.).
All these germ-lamellar animals possess at least two different
systems of organs, namely, the dermal system (the covering
of the outer germ-lamelle with its derivatives) and the
intestinal system (the intestinal outfolding of the inner
germ-lamella with its derivatives).

In further classifying the Metazoa, we may, in the first
place, advantageously make use of three different principles of
division—1. The want or possession of the celom. 2. The
different number of the secondary germ-lamelle. 3. ‘The
radial or bilateral fundamental form.

If we would attach a principal importance to the celom
and the vascular or blood system depending upon it, then the
main division Metazoa divides next into two distinct groups ;
on the one side the lower germ-lamellar animals without
ceelom or hemolymph; Zoophyta and Accelomi (Plathelmin-
thes) ; on the other the higher Metazoa with ceelom and hemo-
lymph ; the Ceelomati and the four highest groups of animals
springing from these—Kchinodermata, Arthropoda, Mollusca,
and Vertebrata (vide the ‘ Biology of Calcareous Sponges,’
pp. 467, 468). We could adopt for these two groups the

original terms, in their strictest sense, of Aristotle, Anema

1 The few animals among the Blastozoa which are without an intestine,
the Cestoda and Acanthocephala, eannot be considered here as an exception,
as they have apparently lost the intestine in consequence of their parasitic
habits, and originally sprung from worms provided with an intestine. This
follows, unquestionably, from their comparative anatomy and ontogencsis,—
Vide * General Morphology,’ vol. ii, p. Ixxx. |

226 ERNST HAECKEL.

and Enema (but in any case not with the expressed limits of
their author). Anema or true “ bloodless” Metazoa are the
Zoophyta and Plathelminthes (Accelomi). Enema or true
“blood animals” are, on the other hand, the Cclomati
(worms with blood and ccelom), and the four highest animal
races arising from these. ‘The former could be defined as
Anemaria and the latter as Hemataria.

The attempt to employ the number and differentiation of
the constituent germ-lamelle, as the fundamental principle
of division for the main groups of the animal kingdom, has
very recently been twice carried out in different ways by
Gustav Jaeger and KE. Ray Lankester. ‘The first gives
in his suggestive ‘Manual of General Zoology’ (1871) a
special chapter on the “ Principles of the Layers and of the
Groups of Layers: Stratography of the Animal Body.”
Jaeger separates here—l. Two-layered animals (“ the lowest
multicellular animals”). 2. Three-layered animals (Celen-
terata). 3. Five-layered animals (Enterata or animals with
intestines ; our Bilateria, the five higher groups of animals).
Praiseworthy as the attempt is, to apply “‘stratography” in
this manner to animal morphology, it must yet be regarded
as misleading in details. ‘lhis becomes at once apparent
by comparing Jaeger’s explanation (especially §§ 55, 67) with
our explanation in the present essay, which has the Gastraea-
theory for its basis. Just as little can I concur in details with
the attempt of E. R. Lankester (loc. cit., p. 325). He divides
the animal kingdom into—1l. Homoblastica, without dif-
ferentiated germ-lamelle (Protozoa). 2. Diploblastica (with
two germ-lamelle (Cclenterata). 3. Tripoblastica, with
three germ-lamelle (the five higher groups, our Bilateria).

In our own opinion, if a man wished to characterise in this
way the main groups of the animal kingdom by the number of
the germ-lamellz, he would do much better to separate them
into the following four or five sections: —1. Ablasteria: Animals
without germ-lamelle (Protozoa). 2. Diblasteria: Animals
with two permanent germ-lamelle (Gastraeade, Spongie, and
the lowest Acalephe). 3. Triblasteria: Animals with three
germ-lamelle (the bulk of the Acalephe—Hydromeduse,
Ctenophore, Corals). 4. Tetrablasteria: Animals with four
germ-lamellz (cuticular nervous and muscular layers, and
intestinal muscular and glandular layers). The Bilateria, or
the five higher groups of animals collectively. Among these
last the Accelomi (the worms without body-cavity or blood,
the Plathelminthes) would represent the lower condition of
development, from which the Celomati (the worms with
body-cavity and blood) have subsequently developed them-

THE GASTRAEA-THEORY, ETC, 227

selves by the shrinking apart of the two muscular layers.
The four highest groups of animals, the Echinodermata,
Arthropoda, Mollusca, and Vertebrata, are diverging descend-
ants of the four different forms of Coclomati. It is not diffi-
cult to derive these four typical phyla from the common
root-group of the worms. ‘heir comparative anatomy and
ontogenesis still shows us, even now, that they have near
relatives among the Ceelomati. The Annelida lead to the
Arthropoda and Echinodermata, the Bryozoa (?) to the Mol-
lusca, the Tunicata (Ascidia) up to the Vertebrata (vide
Lecture 18 in the ‘ Natiirliche Schépfungsgeschichte). If
we wish to regard the coelom (which has originated by sepa-
ration of the animal and vegetative muscular layer) and the
cells which belong to it (ccelom-epithelia, lymph-cells, blood-
cells) in Jaeger’s sense as representatives of a special fifth
layer, an intermediate fifth germ-lamella, we should have to
refer the Accelomi only (Plathelminthes), and perhaps a
portion of the Acalephe, to the Tetrablasteria. On the other
hand, all the animals provided with a ceelom (the Celomati
and the four highest groups of animals) would form a special
fifth main group: Pentablasteria, with five germ-lamellz or
principal layers of tissues:—1. Cuticular nervous layer. 2.
Cuticular muscular layer. 38. Colom layer, or lymph
layer, vascular layer in a modified sense. 4. Intestinal
fibrous layer. 5. Intestinal glandular layer.

An arrangement of these five principal groups of the animal
kingdom, with their known and generally accepted “ types,”
would yield the following results:

1 Ablasteria. . . I Protozoa . Protozoa Protozoa.

; ; Gastraeada .
2 Diblasteria . { Spongia Zoophyta
3 Triblasteria . . 3 Acalephe
4 Tetrablasteria. . 4 Acclomi . Vv
(Celomati . } ermes ¢ Metazoa.
5 Mollusca .
5 Pentablasteria . 54 Echinodermata
Arthropoda Typozoa
Vertebrata .

However attractive it may appear to us froma phylogenetic
point of view, to employ the number and differentiation of the
germ-lamelle in this manner as a basis for the classification
of the animal kingdom, yet on a closer examination important
obstacles present themselves, which do not justify the strict
carrying out of this principle of division. Independently of
the fact that we do not yet know the ontogenesis of many
animals (especially of the lower orders) at all sufficiently,
there are intermediate transitional forms between the five

228 ERNST HAECKEL.

groups mentioned, which admit of no sharp division, and,
moreover, cases occur in the lower phyla of the Metazoa, in
which nearly related forms of one stock must be placed
in different groups of Blasteria. Although most of the
Acalephe (Hydromedusz, Ctenophore, Corals) are probably
blasteria, yet Diblasteria are among their lower forms
(Hydra), and probably many Tetrablasteria are among their
higher forms. Among the Accelomi (Plathelminthes) pro-
bably many Triblasteria, or even Diblasteria, may be found
among the predominating ‘Tetrablasteria forms; and so in
other cases.

On these and other grounds it appears much more preferable
to employ only characters drawn from the phylogenesis of the
Metazoa as the leading principle for their further division, in
which the stereometric (radial or bilateral) essential form of
the parts of the body plays a decisive part. ‘The further
development of the gastrula here appears next defined.
Following this I have already arrived at the opinion (in the
‘ Biology of Calcareous Sponges’) that the descendants of
the Gastraea, as the common root-form of all the Metazoa,
subsequently divided into two branches, the Protascus, which
is to be regarded as the root-form of all the Zoophyta, and the
Prothelmis, which is to be regarded as the common root-form
of all the five higher groups of animals. ‘The division of
these two principal branches is quite mechanically dependent
onthe two different modes of life to which the descendents of
the monaxial (neither ‘‘ radiate” nor “‘ bilateral”) Gastraea first
adapted themselves. The one group resigned the freely
moving habits of the swimming Gastraea, attached itself by
the pole of the axis of its body opposite to its mouth, and
then developed eo ipso further into the so-called “radiate type”
(Zoophyta). The other group of the descendant of the
Gastraea retained the power of moving freely from place to
place. proceeded from the swimming method of moving to
creeping on the sea-bottom, and developed eo ipso into the
so-called “‘ bilateral type” (the five higher groups of animals,
Vermes and Typozoa). I therefore regard only on the one
side the fixed habits of life in the root-form of the Zoophyta
(Protascus) as the mechanical “ acting cause”’ of their radiate
type, or, more correctly expressed, of their actinote (regularly
pyramidal) essential form ; and, on the other side, the creep-
ing habits of life in the root-form of the worms (Prothelmis)
as the mechanical causa efficiens of its bilateral type, or, more
correctly expressed, of its dipleural (amphithect-pyramidal)
fundamental form. ‘This has been inherited from the worms
by the four highest stem-groups of animals.

THE GASTRAEA-THEORY, ETC, 229

On the ground of this phylogenetic consideration we can
class together the whole of the originally bilateral descendants
of the Gastraea (the successors of Prothelmis) in a natural
main group, which we will briefly designate Bilateria or
Sphenota (‘‘ wedge-animals,” on account of their wedge-shaped
essential form in the sense of Bronn). ‘This group includes
all the worms and the four highest groups of animals derived
from them; the Mollusca, Echinodermata, Arthropoda, and
Vertebrata.'

6. SIGNIFICATION OF THE GASTRAEA-THEORY IN RESPECT
To THE HomouoGy or TyPEs.

By comparing the germ-lamelle in the different groups of
animals we are led to the important question, how far the
organs and systems of organs in general are capable of a
morphological comparison in the seven phyla of the animal
kingdom, and how far a true homology in the strictest sense
(i. e. homophyly) is to be carried out between them? Those
who maintain Baer’s and Cuvier’s doctrine of types in its
original rigid sense, and consider all the types of the animal
kingdom as perfectly separated morphological units, must
naturally answer this question generally in the negative.
Those, on the other hand, who regard the theory of types in
the light of the theory of descent, and those who admit the
modification of it, which we have attempted here by the
Gastraea-theory, as well as the generalisation of the germ-
lamellz theory which depends upon it, must, to a certain
extent, agree to such a morphological comparison. In fact,
Gegenbaur? has recently expressed himself in this sense,
and Kowalevsky ? also in his latest work.

Although this question about the homologies of the groups
of animals is extremely important and interesting for com-
parative anatomy and phylogenesis, yet its positive solution
seems difficult and entangled in the present imperfect

1 Tn all the Vertebrata, Annulosa, and Mollusca, the dipleural or bilateral
essential form is just as undisputed as in the Vermes. But the root-form
of the Echinodermata possesses also the same fundamental form. According
to our theory of Echinodermata we consider as such the articulated worm-
person which has still preserved most of its independence in the “ Arm” of
the Asterida. The radiate form of the developed specimens of Echinoder-
mata (star-shaped Cormi, composed of five or more Persons), therefore forms
just as little of an objection as the radiate form of specimens of the Synas-
cidian stock (Botryllus).

2 Gegenbaur, ‘ Grundziige der vergl. Anatomie,’ ed. 2, p. 82.

% Kowalevsky, ‘ Embryologische Studien an Wiirmern und Arthropoden,
1871, conclusion.

230 ERNST HAECKEL,

condition of morphology. I therefore lay no more stress on
the following explanation than that of a provisional attempt.
The phylon of the Protozoa is naturally entirely excluded
from this consideration, as, according to our previously ex-
pressed opinion, no animal of this root-group rises to the
formation of germ-lamellz, and therefore the organs de-
veloped from the latter are also completely absent in the
Protozoa. We therefore, for instance, consider any morpho-
logical comparison of any part of the body of an infusorium
with an apparently representative (and physiologically,
perhaps, equally important, and therefore analogous) portion
of a germ-lamellar animal as quite inadmissible. As I have
already shown in an essay ‘On the Morphology of the
Infusoria,” the intestine of the Ciliata can, for instance, be
looked upon as such and compared with the intestine of the
Metazoa. But in a morphological aspect these parts cannot
generally be compared at all. The intestine of the Ciliata is
but a portion of a single highly differentiated cell; the in-
‘testine of the Metazoa is a cavity enclosed by the many-celled
inner germ-lamelle. Homologies can only exist between
the six stem-groups of the Metazoa, which are all derived
from the Gastraea.

As the most certain and universal homology which is
applicable throughout the whole series of Metazoa (from the
sponges to the vertebrates), we may take the comparison of
those organs which are already differentiated in the simplest
Metazoa (the Gastraeada and the lowest sponges), and which
persist in them throughout their lives in their simplest con-
dition ; that is, firstly, the primitive intestinal canal with its
epithelium (the intestinal glandular layer, the entoderm of
the gastrula); and, secondly, the most superficial covering
of the body (the cuticular layer or the epidermis, the exo-
derm of the gastrula). With reference to this latter, it is
expressly to be noticed that, indeed, the originally complete
homology of the epidermis in the six phyla of the Metazoa
may be unsatisfactory and frequently disturbed, in conse-
quence of earlier commenced cuticular processes, by which
the original outer epidermis layer is changed or stripped off
into a transitory embryonal covering (as in Hydra, Kleinen-
berg), but that none the less the epidermis constantly retains
at least a layer of cells, and serves as a foundation for the
others, consequently the epidermis, as a whole, and as a
derivative of the simple exoderm of the gastrula, is homo-
logous in all the six stem-groups of the Metazoa.’

1 The formation of many embryonal coverings, which arise ontogenetically
from the uppermost germ lamella (the horny layer), is perhaps to be explained

THE GASTRAEA-THEORY, ETC. 251

The question of the homology of the central nervous system
is much more difficult. This has, doubtless, arisen from the
exoderm in all six stem-groups of the Metazoa, but the central
nervous system of the zoophytes has certainly arisen inde-
pendently of that of the worms, and is in no respect to be
compared to it. On the other hand, the simplest form of the
central nervous system, which is found in the worms, espe-
cially the simple pair of ganglia lying over the cwesophagus, the
so-called upper pair of ganglia or primitive brain, is to be
regarded as homologous, firstly, in all classes of the group of
worms, and, secondly, is to be compared also to the corre-
sponding parts in the Mollusca and Arthropoda, as well as to
the original medullary tube of the Vertebrata (from which the
brain of the latter is only the furthest differentiated division!).
This original central organ has been lost inthe Echinodermata,
and their oesophageal ring is only a secondary commissure
between the five radial nervous threads, which appear in the
Asterida in their most original form. Each of these five radial
threads of the Echinodermata is homologous to the jointed ven-
tral cord of the Annelida and Arthropoda. It is necessary to
accept the correctness of my theory of the origin of the
Echinodermata for the conception of this apparently para-
doxical comparison, according to which the root-form of the
phylon of the form of the Asterida is to be regarded as a
stem composed of five-jointed worms united into a star-shape.
This theory has, indeed, been rejected by Claus, Leuckart,
Semper, and others, but without their putting any other

phylogenetically by moultings (or “ Mauserungen”) which the ancestors of
the organism im question have suffered in earlier periods of the earth's
history. So is, especially, to be explained the larval form of many of the
higher Crustacea, which originates within the egg-shell, and is itself fre-
quently changed, upon repeated moultings of the root-form of the Crustacea,
the Nauplius, and other old root-forms which have arisen from this. (Com-
pare the statements and explanations relating to this in the detailed works
of Fritz Miller, Edouard von Beneden, A. Dohrn, &c.) ‘This is, perhaps,
also the explanation of the so-called Amnion in many animals. On the other
hand, the amnion of the vertebrata is certainly of a different origin. As for
the special homology of this amuion in Vertebrata and Arthropoda, as main-
tained by Kowalevsky and others, it is already contradicted, independently
of other reasons, by the fact that the amnion only occurs in the three higher
classes of Vertebrata (Amniota). This has, therefore, apparently first
developed itself here, during the origination of the root-form of the Amniota
from the Amphibia, and is entirely unconnected with the amnion of the
Arthropoda. The latter is only analogous (and homomorphous) to the
former, but not truly homologous (homophylous).

1 The spinal marrow of the Vertebrata, and the ventral nervous cord of
the Annulosa, are of course not analogous from this point of view, and these
can just as little be compared as the sympathetic marginal cord of the former
and the ventral nervous cord of the latter.

232 ERNST HAECKEL.

natural theory in its place, and without their having made
any attempt to explain the origin of the Echinodermata. On
the other hand, my theory, which fully explains its origin,
has received the full sanction of two zoologists of the first rank
upon whose judgment I lay the greatest weight, Gegenbaur
and M. Sars (senior), the last recognised as one of the natu-
ralists most thoroughly acquainted with the Echinodermata.}

The organs of sense of the different groups of animals are
for the most part (perhaps entirely, with the exception of the
skin as the organ of touch) not homologous; moreover, the
homology is often not to be proved even within one of these
groups, or is even positively negatived within a given class, as,
for instance, in the organs of hearing of different insects. All
point to these as of polyphyletic origin, and as having
originated at different times from different portions of the
upper germ-lamelle. This manifoldly different and inde-
pendent origin of the organs of sense is also very well con-
ceivable phylogenetically.

The primordial kidneys have probably also originated from
the upper germ-lamellz, and these organs are probably homo-
logous in all the Bilateria (in all the members of the five
higher animal groups). The simplest form would be repre-
sented by the so-called “excretory organs” or “ water-
vascular system ” of the Plathelminthes, which are originally
nothing more than strongly developed tube-shaped dermal
glands (like the sweat-glands). Comparative anatomy will
perhaps later be in a position to prove that these primary
kidneys of the unarticulated Plathelminthes, which reappear
in each metamer of the articulated Vermes as so-called
looped canals or segmental organs, have given rise both to
the kidneys of the Mollusca and to the primary kidneys of
the Vertebrata.*”, Gegenbaur has already proved the homo-

1 The origin of the central nervous system from the original outer layer of
the body of the animal, the horny layer, is one of the most striking examples
of the value of the phylogenetic view, and its signification for the compre-
hension of the ontogenetic process. Hitherto this origination of the “ in-
ternal” nervous system from the outer germ-lamelle has been almost
universally considered wonderful and paradoxical. But as soon as the pro-
blem is thus stated: “‘ How can the nervous system generally have originated
at first (phyletically) ?’ only the one answer, after ripe reflection, will be
given to it: “ From the most superficial parts of the body, which were con-
stantly in communication with the outer world.” Only from this constant
communication could the first ‘‘sensation” develop itself. The nervous
system has then withdrawn itself secondarily into the protected interior of
the body, “ separated from the horny layer.” I do not consider the idea of
a special “nervous layer,’ which many embryologists separate from the
cuticular sensitive layer, to be confirmed.

? In Amphioxus the broad caual discovered by von Rathke, and more fully

THE GASTRABA-THEORY, ETC. 233

logy of the “ shell-glands ” of the lower Crustacea among the
Arthropoda (and the “ green glands” of the Decapoda) with
the primary kidneys of the Vermes. The Tracheata have
quite lost this excretory organ, and the Malpighian tubes
of the intestinal canal have taken its place. If we regard
the primary kidneys as originally (phylogenetically) in
this manner separated skin-glands, it also explains their
originally superficial position in the vertebrate embryo.
_They are here undoubtedly derived from the upper germ-
lamelle, either directly from the horny layer or indirectly
from cells of the “ axial cord,” which have passed from the
horny layer into the dermal fibrous layer.

The dermal muscular layer, or the dermal fibrous layer
(the ‘‘ flesh-layer ” of Baer, the dermal layers and primary
vertebrate layers of Remak), is, as a whole, in its original
simple commencement, probably homologous in all the six
branches of the Metazoa, or certainly, at least, in the five
phyle of the Bilateria. It has probably originated in the
Vermes, as well as in the Zoophyta (Hydra, &c.), from the
upper germ-lamelle, and has been inherited from the Vermes
by the four higher groups of animals. The corium and the
muscular dermal sheath are to be regarded as the two earliest
products of its subdivision; both are perhaps of the same
origin, and therefore homologous within the five higher
phyle (the Bilateria). The muscles of the trunk of the
Vertebrata also proceed from this layer.

On the other hand, the skeleton system in the different
groups of animals is not homologous. Both the internal
skeleton formations of the Zoophytes, as well as those of the
Echinodermata and the Vertebrata, are entirely different
formations, peculiar to each phylon, although all three
appear to originate from the dermal fibrous layer.

The external skeleton of the Vermes and Arthropoda,
which is only a chitinised differentiation of the epidermis
(the so-called hypodermis or chitinogen membrane), as well
as the calcareous shells of the Mollusca (also exudations from

described by J. Miiller, which runs on each side in the folds of the skin of
the ventral surface (immediately at the outer surface of the sexual glands),
and which opens externally behind on both sides of the Porus abdominalis,
is perhaps to be considered as a homologue, or as a rudiment of the original

rimary kidneys. (A second further opening in the mouth-cavity is pro-
Finatical.) If the comparison of this dermal canal of Amphioxus (fig. 40,
Pl. I, of J. Miiler’s work) with the primary kidneys of the Vertebrata,
and with the similar excretory organs of the Vermes, were correct, this
would establish a very interesting connection between the two latter sets of
organs, and would at the same time explain the origin of the passage of the
primary kidneys in the Vertebrata from the outer germ lamella.

234 ERNST HAECKEL,.

the epidermis), do not come under consideration here
at all.

The ccelom or the body-cavity, the original “ pleuro-peri-
toneal cavity,” which is entirely absent in the Protozoa, Zoo-
phyta and Accelomi (Plathelminthes), is certainly homolo-
gous in the Ceelomata, and in the four higher stem-groups of
animals. It originates everywhere as a slit between the two
muscular layers, and has apparently descended from the
Celomati, the worms with blood, to the four higher groups
of animals. However, this homology is not to be established
by comparison with the cavity of segmentation, from which
Kowalevsky makes the ceelom proceed (comp. above, p. 165).
The ccelom is originally filled with a fluid, which, on account
of its varying characters, can be defined as hemolymph or
hemochyle. But in the higher worms this nutritive fluid is
already differentiated into two different constituents, into the
colourless chyle or lymph which fills the body-cavity, and
into the coloured blood, which circulates in the closed vas-
cular system. This differentiation also recurs in the
Vertebrata.

The intestinal muscular layer, or the intestinal fibrous layer
(the “‘ vascular layer’ of Baer, the intestinal fibrous layer
and middle layer of Remak), appears to be entirely absent
in part of the class Zoophyta (in the sponges and the lowest
Acalephee), and to develop itself in a peculiar form in another
part (in the higher Acalephz).

In the Acclomi it already begins to shape itself out as
the ‘“‘intestinal muscular sheath,”’ and has descended from
these to the higher worms (the Ccelomati), and from the latter
to the four higher stem-groups of animals. There is nothing
in the way of our recognising a universal homology in this
within these five groups of animals (the Bilateria).

The vascular system, which, as a whole, has developed
itself in connection with the ccelom, is, therefore, also to be
compared within the five higher stem-groups of animals; but
the question as to how far its separate parts, and especially the
heart, are homologous, is very difficult to decide. Accord-
ing to the sharp-sighted comparison of Gegenbaur, the
heart of the Arthropoda and Mollusca is originally homolo-
gous to a section of the dorsal main vascular stem of the
Vermes, while the heart of the Ascidia and Vertebrata is
homologous to a section of the ventral stem.

The intestinal glandular layer, which remains constant as
the epithelial outer covering of the intestinal canal and its
glandular appendages, is certainly, throughout the whole
animal kingdom (only excepting the Protozoa), from the

THE GASTRAEA-THEORY, ETC. 235

sponges to the vertebrata, everywhere homologous, and every-
where is derived directly from the entoderm of the gastrula.
‘To be sure, Kowalevsky has lately arrived at the opirion
that the intestinal glandular layer of insects forms an excep-
tion, and is much rather to be regarded as a special new
formation sui generis (‘ Kmbryologische Studien an Wiir-
mern,’ 1871, p. 58). This view seems to me untenable. If
any organ can be homologous in all six phyla of the Metazoa,
it is certainly the intestinal canal, with its outer covering
epithelium, the intestinal glandular layer. On the other
hand, the question of the homology of the openings of the
intestine, the mouth, and anus, is at present still quite ob-
scure, and so much only is certain that the opening of the
mouth is not always the same. The original oral opening
of the gastrula, the rudimentary mouth or the Prostoma,
seems only to have descended to the Zoophyta, and, per-
haps, to a part of the Vermes. It, nevertheless, seems to
reappear in the Rusconian anus of the Vertebrata. On the
other hand, the oral openings of the Vertebrata, the Arthro-
poda, and the Echinodermata, are peculiar new formations,
and certainly not homologous with the rudimentary mouth.

7. Tur PHYLOGENETIC SIGNIFICATION OF THE ONTO-
GENETIC SUCCESSION OF THE SYSTEMS OF ORGANS.

The regularly graduated series in which the system of organs
appear one after another in the different groups of animals
during ontogenesis, furnishes us with a sure key, according
to the biogenetic principle, to the historical series in which
the animal systems of organs have developed themselves after
each other and from each other, during the long and slow
course of the organic history of the earth. This paleonto-
logical seniority of the systems of organs, as it is empiri-
cally found @ posteriori from the facts of ontogenesis, com-
pletely anticipates on the whole the demonstrations which
could be formed on the subject d priori by physiological
reflection and by philosophical consideration of forces at work
(Causal-Momente).

In the first place, it follows from the comparison of the
gastrula, and of the bilamellar cell-condition which represents
it in the most dissimilar groups of animals, that two primary
systems of organs, the inner intestinal system, and the outer
tegumentary system, are simultaneously differentiated in
the first series, in the oldest Metazoa, the Gastraeada. The
original and perfectly simple stomachic cavity or primary
intestine of the Gastraea is, indeed, the oldest organ of the

VOL. XIV.—NEW SER. Q

236 ERNST HAECKEL,

body of the Metazoa; but, simultaneously with its origin,
has proceeded the separating of the two cell-layers of its
wall, the inner nourishing epithelia (the gastral lamelle or
entoderm), and the outer investing epithelia (the dermal
lamella or exoderm).

In the second line of succession the elements of the
skeleton-system (in the majority of the Metazoa?) formed
themselves, and this in the layer of the exoderm, as the
sponges teach us. Although in the sponges the two pri-
mordial germ-lamellz have (universally ’?) remained constant
in their original simplicity, and no third germ-lamella has
developed itself from them, yet in the thickened exoderm of
many of them we find present a very complicated and ex-
tensively differentiated skeleton-system. Indeed, already the
Protozoa have very generally formed skeleton-parts both for
protection and support. It is unnecessary to mention in
addition that the skeleton-system in the different groups of
animals is of different epochs and of phylogenetic origin.

In the third line of succession the nervous and muscular
systems develop themselves simultaneously. The beautiful
investigations of Kleinenberg on the ontogenesis of Hydra?
have informed us of the simultaneous origin of these two
systems of organs which here exist in the most intimate
reciprocity. The highly interesting neuro-muscular system
of the Hydra is placed immediately before our eyes in statu
nascenti. The neuro-muscular cells developed from the
exoderm of the Hydra show us the functions of both still
united in a single individual of the first order. The two
systems of organs first appear independent and opposed to
each other, through a separation and a division of labour
into nerve-cells and muscle-cells. True muscles, in the
strictest sense of the term, therefore, occur first in those
animals in which true nerves also appear, and vice versd.
As the Acalephe show us, only the dermal or parietal neuro-
muscular system has originated at first from the outer germ-
lamellez. The gastral or visceral neuro-muscular system
(intestinal muscles and nerves) has probably originated in-
dependently in a perfectly analogous manner from the intes-
tinal glandular lamelle. Hitherto nothing has been said
against the view that the visceral nervous system has arisen
independently of the parietal; the former is just as much in
connection with the intestinal muscular layer as the latter
with the dermal muscular layer.

In the fourth line of succession the kidney or excretory

1 An account of these investigations is given by Prof. Allman in the
January number of this Journal.—Ep.

THE GASTRALA-THEORY, ETC. 237

system has developed itself, the physiological signification of
which to the animal organism in general is greater than that
of the younger blood-vascular system and the ccelom which
is connected with it. This opinion is confirmed by the
Plathelminthes, which still possess no coelom and_ blood-
system, but perhaps possess rudimentary kidneys (excretory
canals), and also by their universal occurrence throughout
the whole animal series, and, lastly, especially by the early
appearance of the “‘ primary kidneys” in the embryo. All
‘which shows that we have here to do with a very old and
important arrangement of organization, which already existed
in the Accelomi before the formation of the blood-system and
the coelom, and has descended from thence to the higher
groups of animals.

In the fifth line of succession the blood-vascular system
and the ccelom developed themselves first after the kidney
system. We have already shown that these two parts stand
in inseparable connection, and that the true body-cavity or
the ccelom is to be considered as precisely the first commence-
ment of the vascular system. After the commencement of
the development of the intestinal fibrous layer, by its de-
tachment from the adherent dermal fibrous layer, a cavity 1s
first formed between these two muscular layers, which fills
with the chyle which has transuded through the intestinal
wall. This was the cclom in its simplest form, and this
hzemochylic-system or primordial primitive blood-system has
subsequently become differentiated into two different systems
of fluids, into the lymph-system and the true blood-system.'

In the sixth line of succession the genital system has
first developed itself morphologically as an independent
system of organs (!) Certainly this has already been physio-
logically present the longest of all, before any other system
of organs became differentiated. We certainly already meet
with single cells scattered in the endoderm of the intestinal
tube in the sponges, some of which develop into germ-
cells, and others into sperm-cells; and this was pro-
bably already the case in the Gastraeada. Only in all

! A very different view of the ccelom and of the blood-system, as well as
of the kidney-system, has been developed by E. R. Lankester in his oft-quoted
article (‘ Annals and Magazine of Natural History,’ May, 1873). He regards
these two systems of organs as identical, and thinks that the “excretory
organs or water-vessels ” of the Accelomi form the first commencement of a
body-cavity, and that this ccelom is therefore opened externally from the
beginning. On the contrary, my opinion is that the ccelom is primarily
closed, and originated subsequently to and independently of the older
primary kidney-system. The connection of the two would then be secondary.
The ontogenesis of the Bilateria seems to me to contradict E, Kk. Lankester’s
opinion.

238 ERNST HAECKEL.

the Zoophyta does the formation of both kinds of sexual
cells from the epithelium remain confined to certain parts of
the gastro-canal system; and even in many worms there are
still no independent persistent sexual organs present in a
morphological sense. In many worms (Bryozoa, Annelida,
&c.) individual ceelom-cells, scattered cells of the “ pleuro-
peritoneal epithelia,” develop themselves periodically into
sexual cells. An independent differentiation of special sexual
organs seems, therefore, to occur later, perhaps at different
times in the different groups of animals. The decision of this
very difficult question is, in general, connected with the
problem of the homology of the sexual organs, and with the
primary phyletic origin of the sexual cells, one of the most
difficult problems of ontogenesis and phylogenesis. I would
in addition here to the observations which I have made on
this subject in the ‘ Biology of Calcareous Sponges’ (pp. 469,
471), wish to hint as to the possibility of both primary
germ-lamellz sharing in the formation of sexual cells. For,
although in most cases the origin of the sexual cells from
cells of the intestinal fibrous layer, or even of the primary
gastral layer, is proved, yet in other cases they appear to
originate just as certainly from the dermal muscular layer, or
even from the primary dermal layer (Hydra).

On account of the positiveness with which opposite views
concerning the origin of the sexual cells are maintained even
within the single group of Zoophyta, it may finally still be
suggested whether a translocation of them has not occurred
so early (already within the Laurentian period) that their
apparently original conditions may now, indeed, be their
second home. I have proved that in the calcareous
sponges the egg-cells which originally arise in the endo-
derm often pass very early into the exoderm by their
ameeboid movements, and there continue their growth.
In many Calcispongie the egg-cells are much easier to be
found in the exoderm (their secondary place of abode)
than in the endoderm (their primary original position),
so that I even believed at one time that they arose origi-
nally in the former. We may now, perhaps, venture to
suppose that this early transport of the cells from one
primary cell-layer to the other, by continued “shortened or
contracted inheritance,” in the course of generations, would
be continually thrown further back in ontogenesis, till it
finally takes place already during the differentiation of similar
furrowed cells into the two forms of cells of the two primary
germ-lamellee. Then the cells which originally (phylo-
genetically) belonged to the inner germ-lamellz nevertheless

THE GASTRAEA-THEORY, ETC, 239

(ontogenetically) apparently occur first in the outer germ-
lamellee, and vice versd. I suspect that this is often actually
the case in the sexual cells, and that, generally, such an
early transport of the cells has played a significant part
through the change of place and change from one germ-
lamelle to the other becoming constant by inheritance. ‘This
transport also possesses great significance for our above-stated
view of the original difference of the two muscular layers,
and may, for instance, explain much in the early axial
concrescence, in the blending of the germ-lamella in the
axial cord of the Vertebrata, as well as in their later diver-
gence.

8. THE SIGNIFICANCE OF THE GASTRAEA-THEORY FOR
THE TuHrory oFr TYPE.

If one judges the above-given confirmation of the Gastraea-
theory as sufficient, and acknowledges the conclusions drawn
therefrom as on the whole right, one will then have arrived
at the conviction that as a consequence the so-called
type-theory—which to this very time is in general looked
on as the profoundest basis for a zoological system—has
been abolished, at least so far as its present significance goes,
and an essentially different classification of the animal king-
dom put in its place. As is known, this highly renowned
and highly meritorious theory of types, which in the second
decennium of our century two of the most important con-
temporary zoologists attained to by different ways, culmi-
nated in the idea that in the animal kingdom many funda-
mentally different principal groups are to be discerned; for
each of which peculiar “types” there is a quite charac-
teristically immanent and persistent “‘ plan of structure.”
This plan of structure is determined through the peculiar
position and connection of the constitutive organs, and is
entirely independent of the grade of perfection and develop-
ment traversed by the various classes of animals of each type
within its sphere. Both George Cuvier, who, by the path of
comparative anatomy, and Carl Ernst Baer, who, alone and
independently of Cuvier, arrived at this idea by the path of
comparative ontogenesis distinguished in the whole animal
kingdom but four such types, which Baer, according to the
different manner of ontogenesis, characterised in the follow-
ing manner :—(1) Radiata, with a radial development (evo-
lutio radiata) ; (2) Mollusca, with a contorted development
(evolutio contorta) ; (3) Articulata, with a symmetrical de-
velopment (evolutio gemina) ; (4) Vertebrata, with a double
symmetrical development (evolutio bigemina). Cuvier, as

240 ERNST HAECKEL,

also Baer, took each type for something absolutely persistent,
and, in spite of all modifications, in the deepest sense un-
alterable ; consequently here they allowed no connection of
any sort and no transition between the four different types.
Baer, besides, insists that the type of the lowest forms of
each of the four groups must be pronounced as well defined
as in the highest, and that, consequently, the type of develop-
ment is entirely independent of the grade of improvement.
In contrast with the earlier prevailing erroneous opinion
that the whole of the animal kingdom represented a single un-
interrupted gradual scale of beings, and that a single con-
tinuous succession of development proceeded from the lowest
of the Infusoria through the different classes up to Man him-
self, the light which the type-theory threw over the different
portions of zoology, but particularly over comparative
anatomy and over the history of development, procured for
it a speedy entrance into the zoological system, and the four
types were soon pretty commonly looked upon as the basis
of very exact scientific system of animals. One was, in-
deed, soon compelled, through the advance in one’s know-
ledge of the lower animals, to pull to pieces that very un-
natural type Radiata. First, Siebold in 1845 separated from
it the Protozoa, and at the same time he divided the Articu-
lata into Arthropoda and Vermes. Leuckart, in 1848, was
the first to distinguish as two distinct types the Celenterata
and Echinodermata. So, from the original four types arose
the seven diverse main groups, which to this day are still
also in vogue in most systems equally as the highest and
most general of the chief divisions of the animal kingdom.
But the peculiar essence and the original signification of the
theory of types was not touched by the augmentation of the
number of types. ‘The aims of the later zoologists was much
more directed to defining by the same standard the four new
types (Protozoa, Coelenterata, Echinodermata, and Vermes),
and combining each of these as an isolated form entity, with
the peculiar “plan of structure,” in which was the basis of
arrangement for the three retained older types (Arthropoda,
Mollusca, Vertebrata) of Baer and Cuvier. The idea, ever
since then, growing stronger of the entirely independent cha-
racter and the immanent “‘structure plan” of these seven
types of animals is to this day still generally prevalent; so
that, for example, Claus, even in the newest edition of his
‘ Zoology’ (1872, p. 41), points out the type-theory as the
most important advance in science since Aristotle, and as
the very foundation of the natural symptom systems ~ Even
Hopkins names the types, moreover, ‘“‘the Kepler’s laws

THE GASTRAEA-THEORY, ETC, 241

of the animal kingdom,” and sees in them, with Keferstein
and others, the “ most brilliant confutation of the Darwinian
heresy,” and the strongest argument against the truth of the
theory of descent.

‘This last point our adversaries have themselves, without
foreseeing it, pointed out-as the Achilles’ heel of the theory
of types. For it is quite certain that the theory of types, in
the original sense of its authors, does, without doubt, stand
in a fundamental contradiction to the theory of descent.
This contradiction les not so much im this that the types
are considered as completely independent and separate higher
groups of the animal kingdom, but rather in the teleogical
principal of their conception. ‘The idea that the types form
entirely independent groups of forms is of course inconsistent
with any monophyletic conception of the animal kingdom,
which traces all animals as descendants from a single com-
mon root-form; but it would allow itself to be brought
into unison with the theory of descent in this that one
requires for each type an independent stem-form, conse-
quently the entire animal kingdom requires a polyphyletic
descent—so many types, so many phyla. The conception of
the immanent original “ plan of structure of the types,”
which forms the true teleogical ground principle of the
theory of types, is, on the contrary, perfectly inconsistent
with the theory of descent.

As soon, therefore, as the theory of descent reformed by
Darwin attacked the Baer-Cuvier theory of types, it com-
pelled the latter to defend itself by, first, freely giving up its
teleogical ground principle, and, secondly, at the same time,
the connection of the types with one another had to be
modified. The first attempt towards this I made in 1866
in my ‘General History of Development’ (‘‘ General Mor-
phology,” 2nd volume, chapters xvi, xix, xxiv, and xxv).
First, | have there already pointed out that Baer’s type of
development is nothing further than the consequence of in-
heritance, and Baer’s grade of improvement is nothing further
than the consequence of adaptability (l.c., p.11); therewith,
on the one side, the dualistic notion of types or the teleogical
plan of structure is brought back to the mechanical prin-
ciple of inheritance (consequently to the physiological func-
tion of increase), l. c., p. 171; on the other hand, the dualistic
idea of perfection or the teleogical aim of increase is conse-
quently reduced to the mechanical principle of adaptability,
that is, to the physiological function of nutrition (1. ¢., p.
193). Secondly, I have, then, already shown that the
different higher types of the animal kingdom can be only

24.2 ERNST HAECKEL,

conceived in a genealogical sense as stems or phyla, but that
the higher phyla of the animal kingdom (Vertebrata, Mol-
lusca, Arthropoda, Echinodermata) are to be considered as
diverging descendants from the lower stems of the Vermes,
_ which have taken their origin from diverse branches of this
numerous lower animal group; and that, lastly, the
Vermes and the Celenterata must have started off from those
still lower groups of organisms, the Protozoa or Protista (I. c.,
pp. 415, 414). I have more definitively expressed this
opinion in the first edition of my ‘ Naturliche Schépfungs-
geschichte’ (1868), and in the succeeding editions I have
sought to state it more clearly. I failed in evolving it into
perfect clearness, because the Gastraea-theory, to which I first
of all was led by my ‘ Monograph of Calcareous Sponges,’ was
not yet formed. It was only by means of the Gastraea-theory
and its consequences that the phylogenetic relationship of
the types of animals to one another was completely cleared up.

It might be asserted that the Gastraea-theory is only a
reform or modification of the theory of types, because three
of the primitive four types (Vertebrata, Mollusca, and Arthro-
poda) have been retained nearly within the original limits of
their conception, but the content of this conception has
become completely different. Besides, moreover, between
the two theories there is this most essential difference, that
in the “ type-theory ” the types appear as co-ordinate, self-
existing groups of forms of equal morphological value, along-
side each other, and yet independent one of another; whereas
in the “ Gastraea-theory”’ the phyla exist as partly co-ordi-
nate, partly subordinate, groups of completely different
morphological value ; partly near, partly alongside each other,
but all in a common connection.

In the excellent explanation which Gegenbaur has given
in the second edition of his ‘Grundzige der vergleichenden
Anatomie’ (1872, p. 72) of the animal types, these various
references of types of different value to one another have.
been clearly explained, and, through the most sagacious
investigation of details, has been further strongly built on
the sure foundation of comparative anatomy. Gegenbaur
shows that the seven types or phyla have their limits some-
times tolerably distinctly fixed, and sometimes are by no
means to be distinguished from one another ; that one must
distinguish between the lower and higher types, and that the
different higher types or phyla disclose in their common
point of departure the lower. Through this demonstrable
connection of the phyla it will appear that the whole of the
members of the animal kingdom can be placed in a near

THE GASTRAEA-THEORY, ETC. 243

alliance, whereby the ground is got ready for a monophyletic
system. Through these cognisable connections the hard
and fast conception of the stems, as derived from the earlier
doctrines of type, must become significantly more pliant, for
we find the relationship of the types to one another in the
manner as we meet the subdivisions within the types, 7. e., in
genealogical partition (1. c., p. 77).

With this conception the type-theory of Baer and Cuvier
is at once destroyed, as well in the extent as in the content
of the idea of type. ‘The type has consequently completely
lost its earlier significance, and so far as it 1s a category of
the system, possesses no other philosophical significance than
the lowest category of class, order, genus, species, and so
forth, it is now only relatively (through its height), not
absolutely, distinguished from the latter ; so even Gegenbaur,
from the line of comparative anatomy, has attained to the
same position in respect to the type-theory as that to which
the way of comparative ontogenesis has carried us. The
type-theory has an extraordinary merit for zoology, and,
as the highest principle of the classification of the animal
kingdom, had effected on all sides an uncommonly fruitful
and stimulating work. Its efficaciousness is, however, to be
looked on now as ended. The consistent application and
carrying out of the theory of descent which we have com-
pared with it is no longer sufficient ; in its place must now
come the phylogenetic classification of the animal kingdom, the
essential basis of which is formed by our Gastraea-theory.

APPENDIX.—Synortic PuoyLocENetic TABLES.

For a hasty survey of the general results which appear to
develop themselves from the Gastraea-theory, the following
four phylogenetic tables are appended. ‘To avoid the many
misinterpretations which I have put on the similar tables and
stem-structures in my ‘ General Morphology’ and in my
‘ Natural Creation,’ as also in my ‘ Monograph of Calcareous
Sponges,’ I may here expressly mention that these claim
absolutely no dogmatic currency, that they are merely essays
to give a clear insight, with the help of the Gastraea-theory,
into the important relationships of the ontogenetic and the
phylogenetic development of animals and their primary system
of organs. Should the attempt not be agreed with, let some
better positive be put in its place, but let the objector not rest
contented, as too often happens, with a mere negative rejec-
tion. At all events, the herein proposed system of animals
coincide closer to the important facts of developmental history
than all other hitherto attempted experiments of classification.

ERNST HAECKEL.

244

‘unIpayyide avpnpurys [vutysayuy
‘uunipoygida [euiqseyuy

*(sSuII9A00 pu) saposnuT jeuIysaqUy
*£1OjUOSOT

‘(om ‘aaozds ‘soryvydurd]) spuvps repnose A
*(Qavaq,
‘sua4s-poojq puv -ydutXy) smieys aRpnosea [edioulg
*(mumiayyIda-wio[ao [wrdosTA) (4) ABja~ooopuny
“(pinbyy
jemey perproursd—pooyq oarqiatid) ydutjomeayy
*(untpayytda-mroyao [ejotaed) (4) repoooxg
"(om “BaqaqaaA ‘epazoyo) WoyoTeysopuny
*SOPOSNUL MOT[OFT

*(sOpOSNU ULYS puB ULYS) uIMILO/

*(¢ S[1o0-Mapoxe
aatpimtid Aypeorjoueso[fyd) (¢) spuvps yeyuesorg
‘(spueps [vusopide
aalgiutad Ayeoyouasopfyd) (¢) sfoupry oAgratg
*(qavd 10j3¥er9 943) SUBS.I0 AsTIOg
Braaince |
“MOLVA TRUIdG
‘(‘osp‘spuvls snoadeqas‘spuv[s-4voms) spurvys [vutsepidg
‘(op ‘sdoyvos ‘s[teu ‘arey) sasepuodde [emuaopidy
*(e7o1gnd) stutopid gy

as
rian

Oo iS Oo NO
Sag ef Ae A

onn

-

ror)

*(stjvaqgsvSoy ur vypotmery) LSVIE
-OMA J 10 “(wang ‘okey snoonyq)
MXAV']T UVIOGNVIN IVNILSHIN
“Bl [ouv]-wAeH Lavpuodag YANO

fe

‘snsoonul SNQNT,
‘dao y, sd000j{
‘INIA

>

: | *qsv[qod Ay
‘SITVALSYO VNINV'T

‘rohV] [BUIZSOIUT

‘VITENVI-NAAX)
TAILVLGDS|

"sna1daquasaul SNQNT,
‘HOY, OIUALINASA
‘ITA ‘(steaqseSour vyjomery) LEVI
-OWN]{ 10 “(wang ‘aaXkury avpNo
“SUA )HAAV'[SAOUAI | TVNILSHIN I | *B]TOUNR]-WH1d 4)
‘B[[OWB[-Wdex) ATepuodeg pay, earqtontad reuUuy
‘a

|
; | en
|
|

“snawnbuns Snqny,
‘aaoy, IVAN
‘IA

"SNSOUMDI SNQNT,
‘dao yy, UVIOOSoOW
vin
*SN9ODIL0I SNQNT,
‘Ma OJ, SQOMOVINOD
“AI

‘(st[vULIepour vljomery) )
ISVIAON[ 10 “(wang ‘aoXvry
Iev[MNosn) LAV] TVNULG-OUdI
*B][aWLT- Way Lawpuoddg puodag
9

‘qsvyqida
"SITVNYAE YNIAVYT

‘ra Vy [RULIOCy

‘VITENWYT-WAas)
TVWINY

“sypzMabown Sngny,
‘daO], TVAXas
‘III *(sI[eMiaepornon vT[aute’T)
ISVTAOUNDAN 10 “(wang ‘aakvry
[euog,) HAV] TVWUAd-OUNAN *B][OUTB]-Ul.Lay)
"e]oulvy-wi1a Arepuodoeg 4SalT oarpTutad [VUIE4x A
D ‘VNUACOX

Vv

"snaalau SNQnT,
‘aay, TVAOEN
"II
"snaULOD SNANT,
‘Gao ], ANYOW
a

‘DynAgazuaauy ay? yp v7n.19Ga710,4 ay) fo Uosrumduoy oyauabojuQ ay? pup hsooy],
-nanusv.y ayy uo papunof nyniga7la4 fo sunbig, fo wagshy ayn fo quawudojaaegy poonauahophyg ayp £0 290 —']

THE GASTRAEA-THEORY, ETC. 245

IL.—Synoptical Table of those Primitive Organs which, with
probability, are considered as homologous in the Vermes,
Articulata, Molluscous and Vertebrated Animals.

VERMES. VERTEBRATA.

ARTHROPODA. | MOLLvsca.

I.— Products differentiated from the Newro-dermal Layer.

Epidermis. Hypodermis Epidermis. Epidermis.
(chitine mem-
brane).
Primitive brain Brain Brain Marrow-bone or
(upper cesophageal (upper cesophageal (upper esophageal} medullary tube
ganglia). ganglia). ganglia). (foremost part).
Organs of excre- | Shell-glands of Kidneys. Primitive kidney
tion crustacea. processes.
(“ water vascular,
segmental or-
gans’’).

Il.— Products differentiated from the Fibro-dermal Layer.

Corium Corium = (rudi- Corium and _ | Corium and dermal
(and annular mus- ment). dermal muscles | muscles
cular sheath). (First appearance!) (First appearance!)

Straight muscular! Hollow muscles | Inner hollow mus-| Lateral hollow
sheath. (longitudinal). cles. muscles.

Ill.— Products differentiated from the Fibro-intestinal Layer.

Celom, Body cavity. Body cavity. | Pleuro-peritoneal
cavity.
Principal dorsal Heart. Ventricles. Aorta (primordi-
vessels. alis).
Principal ventral fae oe re aoe Heart (together
vessels. with bulbus arte-
riosus).

Intestinal wall | Intestinal wall Intestinal wall | Fibro-intestinal
(exclusive of epi- | (exclusive of epi- | (exclusive of epi- | layer and mesen-
thelium). thelium). — thelium). tery.

IV.—Products differentiated from the Intestinal Glandular Layer.

“Intestinal epithe- | Intestinal hypo- | Intestinal epithe- | Intestinal epithe-
lium. dermis (for the | lium(for the most | lium (excepting
most part). part). mouth and anus).

246

ERNST HAECKEL.

IlI.—Sketch of a Phylogenetic Classification of the Animal
Kingdom, founded on the G‘astraea-Theory and the
Homology of the Germ-lamelle, the Primitive Intestine,

and the Celom.

2 Sus-

PROTOZOA

<

e 3 SYNTAGMATA.
Ss

.| First principal (
S| group of the
=| Animal King-
Al dom: Pro-
i"

=! TOZOA. PRI-
| MITIVE ANI-
=| MALS, without
S8) Germ-lamelle
é or Intestine,
an] or Celom or

Hemolymph. |

Secon@ principal (
group of the
Animal King-
dom: ANZ-
MARIA. INTER-
MEDIATE ANI-
MALS (blood. |

less intestinal 4 (Coelenterata).

animals}, with
two primary
Germ- lamelle
and Intestine,
but without
Celom and
Hemolymph. |

Third principal
group of the
Animal King-
dom: HaMma-

intestinal ani-
mals), animals
with two pri-
mary Germ-
lamelle, with
Celom and
Hemolymph ;
all having at

|
(blood-carrying |
4

Mzrazoa (Subregnum secundum): Descendants of Gastraea.

a muscularand
a nervous sys-
tem.

rc

the same time |
L

. Spongiz. { .
8.

Acalephe. Sh
10.
. Accelmio nt I

(Vermes I). | 12.

(Vermes IT).

ae ey
. Colobrachia. { 55. Crinoida.

16 PHYLOCLADI. | 40 CLASSES.
1. Monera.
. Ovularia. | 2. Amecebina.
3. Gregarine.
Tnfosenta { 4. Acinete.
4 c 5. Ciliata.

Gastraeada.
Porifera.
Coralla.
Hydromeduse.
Ctenophore.
Archelminthes,
Plathelminthes.

. Nematelminthes.
. Polyzoa.

. Celomati 7

Tunicata.

16. Rhynchocela.
17.
. Rotatoria.
L19.
. Brachiopoda. { 20.

21.
. Otocardia. 12
. Cephalopoda,

Gephyrea.

Annelida.
Spirobranchia.
Lamellibranchia.
Cochlides.

Asterida.

26. Echinida,

. Lipobrachia. { 27.

Holothuriz.

. Carides. + 28. Crustacea.
29. Arachnida.
. Tracheata. 30. Myriapoda.
31. Insecta.
. Acrania. 4 32. Leptocardia.
Maiisestinck ‘ee Cyclostoma.
‘ * | 34, Pisces.
35. Dipneusta.
. Anamnia. 36. Halisauria.
37. Amphibia.
38. Reptilia.
. Amniota. 39. Aves.
12 Mammalia.

THE GASTRAEA-THEORY, ETC. 247

IV.—Monophyletic Stem-structure of the Animal Kingdom,
founded on the Gastraea-Theory and the Homology of the

Germ-lamelle.
om nS
Es VERTEBRATA. 3 $4
fo} = a
= ~Q Pai ise!) IC
is ARTHROPODA. | Ser
aa Seer
e. a EcHINODERMATA. Mor3vsea. a5 e k
BHO ae eet 44a38
as s H C@LOMATI a 988
a BO (Vermes with body-cavity.) hs aes a
Be 2s | <4
aees
4aon =)
as = a ZOOPHYTA Plathelminthes. 5
SS i (Ceelenterata.} AS
Sees ae
Het 3 Acalephe. See
S33: torre BB
S8°S Spongie. AC@LOMI of3
Nos | (Vermes without body -cavity.) ow. 5
gisé °) Ba
as £6 Protascus. Prothelmis. ae is
is) Aiave
Ral gz. eae P . a
> 28 Gastraea radialis Gastraea bilateralis es 3
Bo (sedens). (repens). = F
£33 U——_—_—_— — oe
=o GASTRAEA. aq
2 (Ontogenesis : Gastrula.) ‘9
& <
Pas)
as PROTOZOA.
2 Planeada
cee (Ontogenesis: Planula.) Ciliata.
oe ae Acinetz.
anae
gSa 5 |
‘e808 onda a id
4,28 Infusoria.
a
eEsa |
a Gregarine
° °
FS a Synameebee
a 5 a (Ontogenesis: Morula.)
ico] >
3 S 2 fe Amebina.
No.
Se a Sky sin
on 8 AMG@BH.
as a2 (Ontogenesis: Ovulum.) PnP ee
$ oO
9 og ead
Ses MOoNERA. Monera.
cS (Ontogenesis: Monerula.)

248 J. W. GROVES.

On Arrancinec and Catratocuinc Microscopic SPEcI-
MENS. By J. W. Groves, F.R.M.S., Hon. Sec. to the
Medical Micro. Soc.

Tuts subject seems to be one of some difficulty, from the
fact that most authors who have written upon it, and most
people who possess collections, follow different methods
without being altogether satisfied with any of them ; more-
over, it is a question of importance, for upon the arrangement
adopted, and the convenience of the catalogue, depends the
space gained or wasted in the cabinet, and the comparative
ease or difficulty of finding any given preparation.

Manifestly, the system to be recommended must depend
upon whether the collection be large or small, and also
whether miscellaneous or only of certain classes of specimens.
For small collections I am inclined to advocate an absence of
classification in the cabinet ; because, if a small collection be
miscellaneous—and it generally is—such arrangement would
only involve a great waste of space, without the slightest ad-
vantage being derived therefrom, provided only such a cata-
logue be adopted as the one I am about to propose.

For large collections a systematic arrangement of the
specimens becomes necessary, and also, I think, more sys-
tematic catalogues than suchias are generally written.

In large collections—for instance, that in the Hunterian
Museum of the Royal College of Surgeons (the arrangement
of which is so well described by Dr. J. Murie in vols. I and
VIII of the ‘Monthly Microscopical Journal,’ in his excel-
lent article ‘On the Classification and Arrangement of
Microscopic Objects ”’)—I would have a separate catalogue
for every series or subseries in the classification of the speci-
mens, while for small collections one catalogue will generally
suffice.

By the method ordinarily adopted, if one does not happen
to know the slide required by its general appearance, it is
necessary to examine several under the microscope, or at any
rate to read the labels of several, before it is found, and con-
sequently much loss of time is involved; whereas, by my
method, which is of universal application and very simple,
one has only to refer to the proper heading in the catalogue
or index, and so to pick out the very preparation wanted
without further trouble. Thus it is evident that my method
is of extreme use to those who, like myself, frequently have
to demonstrate certain points of structure to a class.

As my own collection is comparatively small, miscellaneous,

ARRANGING AND CATALOGUING MICROSCOPIC SPECIMENS. 249

and yet required for special purposes, I will describe its
arrangement, and the catalogues which I use with it.

My collection is divided into three parts, viz.—A, a
general one for diatoms, plants, insects, minerals, &c.; and
two special ones, B for normal, and C for pathological histo-
logical preparations.

Each of these divisions has a separate catalogue, and as
each of these is drawn up ina precisely similar fashion, I will
describe that for normal histological preparations, as it is the
most complete.

It consists of a simple alphabeted note-book, in which is
contained an alphabetical index to everything contained in
every preparation, each reference being numbered according
to the numbers on the slides. These are placed in the
cabinet without any regard to arrangement, and simply num-
bered consecutively, thus—7, Auerbach’s ganglia; 8, stomach
of dog, showing gastric peptic glands ; 9, voluntary muscle,
&e. As the collection increases, aud a new cabinet is
required, the numbers are continued as though there were but
one cabinet.

To show the method of entering in the catalogue the con-
tents of each preparation, I will run over my specimens of
small intestine.

Under the heading “‘1” is found :—

Intestine small, 106, 107, 108, 109, 117, 120, 209, &c.
Muscular coat, external trans. sect. 108.
ai mA long. sect.
internal trans. sect.
long. sect., 108.
Villi, 106, 107, 108, 117, 120, *149, 150, 162, 207, 208.
epithelium of, 117, 209, *108.
muscl. invol, of, *207, 149, 150.
s»° lacteals of,
», blood-vessels of, 120, #106, 107, 108.
lymphatic tissue of, 207, 208, 149, 150.
Peyer’ s patches, 109, 147, 148.
" columnar epithelial cap of, *209, 147.
Peyer’ s patches, trabecule of, 147, 148.
i 33 lymph-corpuscles of, 147, 148.
» vessels of, 109.
Brunner’s glands, 117.
P vessels of, 117.
Lieberkuhn’s glands, from surface.
Pe » vert. sect., 106, 107, 108, 117.
5 > trans. sect.
» vessels of, 106, 108.
Muscularis mucose, 207, 150, 107.
Lieberkuhn’s glands penetrating, 107.
Brunner’s glands fi
Peyer's $3 us 209.

»?

250 J. W. GROVES.

Intestine, small—continued.
Mucous membrane.
vert. sect.
i, ss corp. cells of, 117.
Blood-vessels of, 106, 107, 108, 117, 109, 120.°
Nerves of.
Then each of these components of the small intestine is
entered again under its approximate heading, thus :—
Under “M”—
Muscle, involuntary of small intestine, vide intestine.
Muscularis mucose of small intestine, vide intestine.
Mucous membrane of small intestine, vide intestine.

Under “ V ”—

Villi of small intestine, vide intestine.

Under “*L”—

Lymph-follicles of small intestine, vide intestine,
and so on.

It will be observed that some of the numbers are marked
with a star (thus, *247). This denotes that those prepara-
tions show the part mentioned under the heading specially »
well, though the others also show it more or less perfectly.
Thus—Peyer’s glands, epithelial cap., 147, *209. Of these
No. 209 is the best. Again, Villi, muscle in, *247, 149. Of
these *247 shows it most perfectly.

The other divisions of my collection are treated in a pre-
cisely similar manner, and from what I have now said, it will
be seen that, in a small collection, no space need be wasted,
because the cabinets are gradually filled up, and when others
become necessary the numbers simply follow on consecu-
tively from the last slide in the cabinet just filled ; while, at
the same time, it will be evident that for small or large
collections, and whether the slides contained in them be
arranged systematically or not, there will not be, in either
case, the slightest difficulty in finding any given slide in a
moment.

I may add that it will be found handy to have a simple
numerical list of slides, as well as that arranged alphabetically,
because then if a preparation be mislaid, it will be easier to
find out what it was, and thus to replace it, if the clue thus
given do not enable it to be traced and found again.

In conclusion, let me add that it will be found to save time,
and, what is of more consequence, the preparations will be
preserved with less risk of injury if kept in cabinets which
will take them horizontally, instead of ‘‘ on edge.” This
remark applies with special force to all specimens put up in °
a fluid medium, no matter of what kind.

9? 9

‘6 PICRO“CARMINATE OF AMMONIA.” 251

Nore on “Picro-CARMINATE of Ammonia.” By E.
CresswELL Baser, M.B. Lond.
(Read before the Medical. Microscopical Society, March 20, 1874.)

In this note I wish to draw attention to a microscopic
staining fluid which, as far as I am aware, is very little, if at
all, known or used in England. ‘This fluid is the picro-
carminate of ammonia, invented by M. Ranvier, and largely
used in his laboratory at Paris.

M. Ranyier first described this fluid in 1870, but since
that time he has made considerable changes in its method of
preparation.

I propose to describe shortly the method of preparation
and employment, the way in which it colours tissues, and,
finally, to indicate some of its advantages over other staining
fluids in use. The picro-carminate of ammonia is made by
mixing—

Carmine (best) . ‘ : ; . 1 gramme.
Liq. Ammoniz : ; : . 4 cubic centimet.
Water. : : d . 200 grammes.

Add to the mixture five grammes of picric acid, and after
agitating, decant, leaving the excess of picric acid. The
decanted liquor is then left for several days in a bottle, being
agitated from time to time. Then evaporate to dryness by
exposure to the air in a shallow vessel. This takes two,
three, or more weeks, according to the time of year. The red
powder which has thus formed is then scraped from the
bottom, and can be kept either in this form or as a liquid
ready for immediate use. The liquid is made by simply
dissolving the powder in water in the proportion of about
two parts of powder to 100 of water, allowing it to stand for
a few days and filtering. The filtering is best done through
a double layer of filtering paper, as otherwise solid particles
are apt to pass through. ‘The liquid thus made ought to
have a yellowish red appearance and ought not to smell of
ammonia. To prevent the formation of fungi a few drops of
a solution of carbolic acid must be added. The liquid can
then be kept an indefinite time, requiring only occasional
filtration.

The picro-carminate of ammonia not being a definite
chemical compound, is sometimes troublesome to prepare,
but the quantities mentioned in the above method appear to
give as goodresults as any.! It is therefore always advisable

1 For the above quantities, as well'as for several other hints on Picro-

Carmine, I am indebted to M. Malassez, Répétiteur at the Collége de
France, Paris.

VOL, XIV.——NEW SER. R

252 E. CRESSWELL BABER.

to test its goodness when emerging from the filter; this is
done in the following manner :—Place a drop of the solution
on to a piece of white filtering paper, and allow it to dry,
when, if the picro-carminate be good, a yellow spot is formed
surrounded by a distinct red ring.

Observers’ differ in the exact shade of yellow or red, which
they prefer, but if, with the fluid prepared as above, the two
colours be distinctly marked, and the solution sufficiently
concentrated, there can be no doubt about its goodness.
If the picric acid be in excess the yellow colour will prepon-
derate over the red, and vice versd. Should the solution be
too dilute, as indicated by the colours being very faint, it
may be strengthened by concentration, by the digestion in
it of more of the desiccated powder, or by repeated filtra-
tion through the same filter, by which latter method more of
the picro-carminate is taken up by the water each time.

In order to be sure of having the right proportion of the
ingredients to start with, it is as well to apply this test also
to the mixture Jefore drying, as after desiccation the relative
proportion of the picric acid, carmine, and ammonia cannot be
altered without evaporating to dryness again.

Specimens can be put from water into the staining fluid,
but from this, if the full coloration of the picro-carminate is
required, they must be put directly into glycerine, for, if placed
first in water, the picric-acid is dissolved out. If, on the
other hand, the staining by carmine only is desired, the
preparation is passed through water before being put in
glycerine, and it is said that the colouring thus obtained is
more regularly disposed than that obtained by ordinary
carmine.

As the picric acid does not fix itself to the tissues like the
carmine, in order that the yellow colour that it produces be
permanent, it is necessary to add a small quantity of picro-
carminate to the glycerine in which the specimen is
preserved.

The following method of staining and mounting is con-
venient :—The section is placed on a glass slide and a drop
of the colouring fluid dropped on it; after a few minutes,
when the specimen is seen to be sufficiently stained, the
cover glass is put on, and some of the following mixture
drawn under by means of filtering paper—

Solution of Picro-Carminate : ©” UPdrop:
Glycerine . ’ : : ; A . 10 drops.
Water. : : F : ; . 10 drops.

The specimen can then be sealed up. The exact propor-

* pPICRO-CARMINATE OF AMMONIA.” 253

tion of the picro-carmine contained in the glycerine is not
of much consequence, provided there is an excess of picric
acid present. ‘The colours of specimens mounted in this way
improve very much for some time after they are put up.

Specimens hardened in chromic acid or Miiller’s fluid,
likewise those which have been kept long in osmic acid, do
not stain so easily as others. The picro-carminate of am-
monia stains the tissues in several colours, varying from a
bright red to an intense yellow. It colours yellow the horny
layer of the epidermis, the central cells in the bird’s nests of
epithelioma, hairs, nails, cartilage (very slightly), and elastic
fibres; nuclei of cells are coloured bright red ; the fibres of
connective tissue of a rose colour ; the protoplasm of most
cells takes a reddish-yellow colour ; and, lastly, the red blood-
corpuscles assume a brown tint.

In the epidermis, for example, the picro-carminate dis-
tinguishes three layers :—

I. Most superficially the horny layer, consisting of
flattened cells, coloured of an intense yellow.

II. An intermediate layer of cells filled with granules,
which are coloured of a bright red.

III. And, lastly, a layer of cells under this coloured of a
dull yellow, with their nuclei stained red.

These three layers can often be distinguished in the bird’s
nests of squamous epithelioma, the centre containing the
intensely yellow cells, outside this is the red layer, and, most
externally, the dull yellow cells with red nuclei. This
indicates plainly the development of the epidermal cells
inwards, passing through the three stages.

The great advantage the picro- -carminate has over other
staining fluids is its property of staining tissues in a series of
colours varying from red to yellow; it has the minor ad-
vantages of colouring rapidly and equally, and of being able
to be kept in the dried form.

I may mention that in Frey’s ‘ Microscopic Technology ’
(4th German edition) picro-carminate of ammonia is alluded
to in a few lines, but only the original method of preparation
employed by M. Ranvier is given.

1 These colours will vary slightly, according to the quality of the Picro-
Carminate.

254. REV. E. 0 MEARA,

On DiatoMaAcE® from SP1tzBERGEN. By the Rey. E.
O’Meara, A.M. With Pl. VIII.

Tue collections which are the subject of the present paper
were made by Rev. A. E. Eaton, who went out to the Arctic
Sea in Mr. Leigh-Smith’s yacht. They consisted, Ist, of
some stones coated with mucor, in which no diatoms were
found ; 2nd, of several bottles of various size. Of these a
large number had unhappily been broken in the conveyance
and the contents lost except the material that remained
attached to the surface of the glass. This material was
carefully examined, but not a single diatomaceous frustule
appeared to requite the labour, so that it may be inferred
that no loss was sustained by the casualty. Of the bottles
which came uninjured one was rich in forms, the others
contributed only a few to the general result. 3rd, of a large
package of a very miscellaneous nature, made up of broken
shells, pieces of seaweed, sand, and such like; its general
appearance was not encouraging, nevertheless it yielded
forms of sufficient number, variety, and interest, amply to
requite the labour of preparation.

Cleve and Lagerstedt have investigated the diatomacez of
Spitzbergen, and favoured us with the result. The latter in
his treatise, ‘Sdtvattens Diatomaceer fran Spetsbergen och
Beeren Eiland,’ confined to the fresh-water forms of the
district ; the former in his ‘ Diatomaceer fran Spetsbergen,’
16th Dec., 1867, published in the ‘ Ofversigt af Kongl.
Vetenskaps Akad. Forhandlingar,’ Stockholm, 1868, and also
in a more recent publication in English, ‘On Diatoms from
the Arctic Sea,’ Stockholm, 1873, in which frequent reference
is made to forms from Spitzbergen.

The gatherings placed in my hands, so far as those are
concerned in which diatoms occurred, were exclusively
marine, so that I could pursue the track only of Professor
Cleve, and that only in respect to the marine forms described —
by him in the two treatises referred to; and, considering the
limited nature of the available material, with most satisfactory
results.

Cleve calculates the number of diatomaceous species
hitherto discovered within the entire range of the Arctic Sea
at 181. These Spitzbergen gatherings of Rev. Mr. Eaton
yielded no less than 92; of these the following have been
noted by Professor Cleve:

DIATOMACEH FROM SPITZBERGEN, 255

Achnanthidium arcticum,* Cleve.

Amphiprora nitzschioides,* Cleve.
pa longa,* Cleve.

Amphora granulata, Greg,

» cymbifera, Greg.

3» lanceolata,t Cleve.

» proteus, Greg.
Biddulphia aurita, Lyng.
Campylodiscus angularis, Greg.
Cocconeis costata, Greg., = C. pacifica, Grun.,= C. Archeri,

O’M.

», decipiens,* Cleve.
>» scutellum, Ehr.
Coscinodiscus radiatus, Ehr.

ee oculus iridis, Ehr.
ud excentricus, Ehr.
3 subtilis, Ehr.

Grammatophora macilenta, W. Sm. = G. oceanica, var.
macilenta, Grun.
arctica,* Cleve.
Navicula arctica,* Cleve.
és Bombus, Ehr.
2 directa, W. Sm.
~ estiva, Donk.
a fusca, Greg.
pe Lyra, Ehr.
9 pinnularia,+ Cleve.
7 pygmea, Kitz.
Smithii, Bréb.
Nitzschia angularis, W. Sm.

a constricta, Kiitz.
s distans, Greg.
ba macilenta, Greg.

socialis, Greg.
Rhabdonema arcuatum, Lyngb.

ss Torellii,® Cleve.

Pleurosignia angulatum, W. Sm.
= delicatulum, W. Sm.
‘a intermedium, W. Sm.
$s naviculaceum, Bréb.
os longum,* Cleve.

Stauroneis pulchella = St. aspera, Cleve, Navicula aspera,
Ehr. and Donk.
Synedra Kamscatica, Grun.
23 thalassothrix,* Cleve.
» superba, Kitz.

256 REV, E. 0 MEARA,

Surirella fastuosa, W. Sm. = Novilla fastuosa, Cleve.
Systephania anglica, Donk., possibly = * Thalossosira
Nordenskioldii, Cleve.

Those marked with an asterisk are new forms described
by Cleve in his work ‘On Diatoms from the Arctic Sea,’ to
which those interested on the subject are referred for further
information. I may be permitted, however, to make a few
remarks concerning two of them, namely, Amphiprora longa
and Navicula (Amphiprora ?) arctica—the author is doubtful
to which genus the latter-named species belongs.

Amphiprora longa seems to me to bear a very strong
resemblance to Amphiprora lepidoptera, Greg. (‘ Diatomaceze
of the Clyde,’ Pl. xii, fig. 59); so much so that I should be
almost disposed to consider it identical with that species.

Of Navicula arctica I have found, as I suppose, some few
specimens ; at least, they so closely resemble in shape and
general character of the striation that figured by Cleve under
that name that I would consider them scarcely distinct,
although there is this difference between them, that, while in
Cleve’s form the inner band curves inward towards the central
nodule, in my specimens the same band bends nearly parallel
with the curvature of the external margin of the frustule, as
shown in Pl. VIII, fig. 1.

The species thus marked + in the above list, namely, Gram-
matophora arctica, Amphora lanceolata, and Navicula pinnu-
laria, are very distinct and beautiful forms, described and
figured in papers of Cleve written in Swedish, and therefore
unavailable to the generality of English students ; I therefore
take the liberty of figuring them, and the rather, as I wish
to supply some additional particulars concerning them.

Grammatophora arctica, Cleve, “* Diatomaceer fran Spets-
bergen,” ‘ Ofversigt af Kongl. Vetenskaps Akad. Forhandlin-
gar,’ Stockholm, 1868, p. 664, Taf. xxii, fig. 1, is of very
frequent occurrence, as are also the other two forms just
noticed. Cleve’s figure of the side view presents no ap-
pearance of striation ; in some of my specimens the striz are
moniliform, as in Pl. VIII, fig. 2 6.

Amphora lanceolata, Cleve, ‘ Diatomaceer fran Spets-
bergen, Taf. xxiii, fig. 2, is described as having persistent
cost, only becoming very faint as they approach the median
line; in the very many specimens which came under my
notice the median line is more strongly developed than in
Cleve’s figure, and a considerable portion of the valve in its
proximity is quite free from striz, as shown in PI.VIII, fig. 3.
These specimens from Spitzbergen agree in all respects with
some of the same species found by me many years ago in a

DIATOMACE FROM SPITZBERGEN, 207

gathering from Jamaica, a fact which shows how indepen-
dent these forms are of climatial influences.

Navicula pinnularia, Cleve, ‘Om Svenska och Norska
Diatomaceer,”’ ‘ Ofversigt af Kongl. Vetenskaps-Akad. For-
handlingar,’ Stockholm, 1868, p. 224, Taf. iv, figs. 1 and 2.
Of this species I found in the gatherings under consideration
two well-marked varieties, one just as figured by Cleve, the
other a much narrower form, and with finer strie, which I
have given in fig. 4.

Concerning the forms in the preceding catalogue I have
further to remark that Synedra Kamscatica, Grun., ‘ Die
Osterreichischen Diatomaceen,’ p. 404, Tab. viii, fig. 6, is of
very frequent occurrence, but the valve, instead of being
bowed as Grunow figures it, is invariably straight. It is also
much larger, but in all other respects identical. In the
middle of the valve, where the striz fail, there is a slight
thickening of the margin on either side, and this feature is
observable in the F as well asin thes v. (Pl. VIII, fig. 5.)

This species is at first view liable to be confounded with
~ Synedra tabulata, but it is more slender, the striz very much
finer, and the middle of the valve is destitute of striz.

In addition to the forms included in the foregoing list
several species occurred already described, but not included
in Cleve’s enumeration of Diatoms from the Arctic Sea, viz. :

Amphora crassa, Greg.
costata, Greg., not W. Sm.
levis, Greg.
robusta,* Greg.
lyrata, Greg.

“s proboscidea,* Greg.
Amphiprora alata,* Kitz.
¥ costata, O’M.
Cocconeis arraniensis, Grev.
binotata, Grun. = C. scutellum, var. Roper.
coronata, Brightw.
distans, Greg.
fimbriata, Ehr.
major, Greg.
nitida,* Greg.
A ornata,* Greg.
- pseudomarginata,* Greg.
‘ splendida,* Greg.
Coscinodiscus lineatus, Ehr.
4; radiolatus, Ehr.
Donkinia compacta, Ralfs.
Epithemia constricta, W. Sm.

33
33
33

3)

3)
3)
bP)
+)
3)

33

258 . REV. E. O MEARA.

Grammatophora marina,* Kiitz.
maxima, Grun.

vs serpentina,* Ralfs.
Navicula Crabro, Ehr.

elegans, W. Sm.

pusilla, W. Sm.
rhombica, Greg.
scopulorum, Kiitz.
didyma, Ehr.

2 » _-Var. Y, Greg.

Nitzsehia bilobata, W. Sm.

Fe lanceolata,* W.Sm.
A parvula, W. Sm.
ii perpusilla, Grun.

Pleurosigma strigosum, W. Sm.

Podocystis adriatica = Surirella adriatica, Kiitz.

Podosira hormoides,* Kitz.

Synedra nitzschioides, Grun.

Concerning Podocystis adriatica, Grunow, ‘ Die Oster-.
reichischen Diatomaceen,’ p. 467, observes that this species
had not come under his notice from either the North Sea or
the Atlantic Ocean. Many years since I found it in abundance
on a specimen of Grinnellia Americana, gathered from the
Atlantic Ocean in the vicinity of New York, and now I have
found it in these gatherings from Spitzbergen.

In a note to his work ‘ On the Diatoms of the Arctic Sea’
Professor Cleve alludes to a paper of mine published in the
‘Journal of the Royal Dublin Society,’ July, 1860, contain-
ing a list of diatoms found by me in gatherings made in the
Arctic Sea by Sir Leopold McClintock, and mentions that
thirty-seven of the forms included in my catalogue had not
occurred in any of his samples from that region. It is with
much gratification, therefore, I have to notice that eleven of
these, viz. those marked with an asterisk, have occurred in
these gatherings of Rev. Mr. Eaton, and, for the most part,
in such numbers as to leave little doubt of their being
indigenous.

Cocconeis binotata, C. coronata, and C. fimbriata, seem
almost cosmopolitan forms. I have found them in collections
from various parts of the Indian Ocean, not unfrequently on
the West Coast of Ireland, and now also in the neighbour-
hood of Spitzbergen.

The specimens of Navicula didyma, var. x, Greg. (‘ Journ.
Mier. Sc.,’ vol. iv, Pl. v),‘fig. 16, were of very frequent oc-
currence. I cannot but think this form is entitled to rank as
a distinct species, The space about the median line expands

33

+)

DIATOMACE FROM SPITZBERGEN, 259

on both sides so as to include a somewhat rhomboid area,
very different, indeed, from the outline of this same space in
Navicula didyma. ‘This peculiarity appears in the speci-
mens I have obtained in various parts of Ireland, as also in
all the very numerous forms that came under observation
while examining these collections from Spitzbergen. In ad-
dition to this striking peculiarity, the character of the striz
differs from that of N. didyma, being greatly coarser than
they are in that species. I would suggest that the form
should be named Navicula Gregoriana.

Over and above the forms included in the two foregoing
lists the following came under notice, which appear to me
not to have been hitherto described :

Asterionella Cleviana, n.s., Pl. VIII, fig. 6.—Length of

valve ‘0036 ; the lower end small and roundish; the upper
end much larger and somewhat rhomboid in its outline ;
strie marginal, costate. Several specimens of this occurred,
always single, as might have been expected, so that I am not
quite certain that I have assigned the form to its proper
genus.
i Amphora Eatoniana, n. s., Pl. VIII, fig. 7.—Length of
valve -0056; breadth -0010; ends not produced ; broadly
rounded; dorsal margin strongly arched; ventral margin
slightly expanded ; expansion rounded ; median line strongly
marked, inclining inwards in an angle at the central nodule,
and gently curved towards the dorsal margin at either side.
Three longitudinal lines divide the valve into four com-
partments on the dorsal side of the median line. The two
nearest to the median line, like it, are doubly arched, and in
the same direction, except that they bend downwards at the
middle towards the central nodule. The third line is gently
arched nearly in the direction of the dorsal margin, and
anastomoses with the second some distance from the ends of
the latter. The striz are finely costate, and appear on all
the valve except the portion included between the second
and third longitudinal lines. ‘There are also two small un-
striated spaces included between the ends of the first and
second longitudinal lines. This is a very beautiful and
peculiar form, to which, with much gratification, I give the
name of the gatherer, Rev. A. E. Eaton.

Amphora Leighsmithiana, n. s., Pl. VIII, fig. 8.—Length
of valve ‘0058; breadth ‘0008; dorsal margin slightly arched,
nearly linear in the middle; ventral margin nearly linear,
slightly incurved at the middle; ends attenuated; median
line strongly developed, slightly arched towards the dorsal
margin; central nodule small, but well defined. Strix

260 REV, E. O’MEARA.

strongly costate, distant. This form at first view might be
confounded with Amphora cymbifera, but the coste in that
species are very much finer and closer than in the present.

Navicula Archeriana, n. s., Pl. VIII, fig. 9—Valve con-
stricted; length ‘0036; greatest breadth ‘0012; breadth at
constrictor ‘0008. Striz marginal costate, parallel in the
middle, slightly radiate towards the apices. A longitudinal
line on either side of the median line divides the inner portion
of the valve into three compartments without strie. This
form had been previously found by me in Ireland, namely,
in gatherings by Professor E. Perceval Wright at the Arran
Islands, and also in the stomachs of Ascidians from the
Coasts of Clare, as well as in stomachs of Ascidians collected
in Roundstone Bay, Co. Galway, by A. G. More, Esq.

Navicula nebulosa, var., Pl. VIII, fig. 10.—Valve ellip-
tical ; length ‘0032 ; breadth ‘0015. Marginal striz obviously
costate, not of uniform length as in Navicula nebulosa, Greg., .
but short in the middle and parallel, gradually lengthening
towards the apices, and again becoming shorter as they ap-
proach the apices. Median line well defined, slightly en-
larged towards the central nodule ; on either side of median
line and close to it there isa faint longitudinal line; between
this latter and the marginal band of costate strie the valve
ismarked with fine moniliform striz radiately arranged. In
Nav. nebulosa, with good illumination, similar strie may be
detected, but they are parallel, and extending not more than
half way between the marginal band of striz and the median
line. A row of strong, short coste extends along the longi-
tudinal lines from the apices about one quarter the length of
the valve ; near the apices they are short, gradually increase
in length, and then diminish till they vanish. Although
this form in its main features so strongly resembles Navicula
nebulosa that it could scarcely be considered distinct from it,
yet the peculiarities I have noticed are such as are worthy of
special attention.

Synedra arctica, u. s., Pl. VIII, fig. 11.—Valve expanded
at the middle and ends; length ‘0052; strize marginal,
finely costate. The valve on front view is linear, with a
slight expansion at the ends; striz marginal. This peculiar
and well-marked form occurred with tolerable frequency.

T have only to add that some specimens were found of a
form which at first I was disposed to consider new, but which,
upon more mature consideration, I think, is not unlikely
identical with Navicula Auklandica, Grun. I was unable to
obtain a front view, so cannot say whether the striz on the
connective membrane noted by Grunow in N. Auklandica

ON CLAVOPORA HYSTRICIS. 261

were present or not. Although on the side view the form,
as figured by Grunow, differs from mine, still, in most
respects, the form under consideration corresponds with
Grunow’s description, ‘“‘ Ueber einige neue und ungeniigend
bekannte Arten und Gattungen von Diatomaceen,’ ‘ Ver-
handl. der K. K. Zool. Bot. Gesel. Wien.,’ Band xiii, 1863,
p- 151, Taf. v, fig. 14. In Grunow’s figure the outline
sufficiently resembles that of mine, Pl. VIII, fig. 12, but
the median line is straight; in mine it is doubly arched.
The strie are of uniform length throughout, slightly radiate,
not reaching the median line, but forming a tolerably broad
longitudinal space in the middle of the valve. In my form
the strie run up to the median line, except at the middle,
where they form a tolerably large free space round the central
nodule. They are parallel, rounded off towards the margin.

On Ciavopora uystricis—a Nrw Poryzoon belonging
to the Famity HatcyoneLtem. By G. Busx, F.RS.,
F.R.M.S. With Pl. IX.

THE curious form here described was procured during
the expedition of the Porcupine in the Mediterranean from
deep water off the African coast, and was kindly submitted
to me for examination by Dr. Carpenter.

From the inspection of a single specimen it is, of course,
difficult to determine whether or not it represents the mature
growth of the species, or may not be regarded as a young
and growing bud. I am, however, inclined to think that it
is full grown, from the circumstance that the substance
appears to be completely differentiated into definite polypides
and tissues. Amongst the latter the muscular seems to me
to present such a remarkable peculiarity that even on that
account alone it is worth while to place a brief notice of the
animal on record.

The growth is about one eighth of an inch in height, and
in the form of a club, with an expanded subglobular head,
and it appears to have been affixed to some foreign base by
short radical fibres. The stem or peduncle is constituted of
a cellular tissue, not unlike that of plants. In each cell may
be observed several fibres crossing it for the most part in a

262 G. BUSK.

direction parallel with the longitudinal axis of the stem.
These fibres, in many, if not in most, of which an elongated
nucleus may be perceived at about the middle of its length,
are attached at either end by a slight expansion. Here and
there one may be perceived bifurcated, but for the most part
they are undivided. In general character they bear so close
a resemblance to one form of involuntary muscular tissue
that it can scarcely, perhaps, be doubted that they are con-
tractile in function, and, consequently, that by their agency
the Clavopora is capable to bending its stem in various
directions.

The club-shaped upper extremity, as well as can be made
out in the spirit specimen, consists of cells similar to those of
which the peduncle is constituted, and containing like them the
same peculiar contractile fibres. The cells, however, in this
portion of the polyzoary are more expanded, and in several
of them (fig. 3 a) may be distinctly perceived the body of a
polypide in the contracted condition, and proceeding from
it elongated, slender, nucleated fibres, representing the
retractor muscles. I have been unable to determine with
any certainty the number of tentacles with which the poly-
pide is furnished, but should estimate it at from twelve to
fourteen. ‘The outer wall of the cellular space or zoocecium
presents an infundibuliform depression, marking the point at
which the polypide was protruded.

From the characters above given I have little hesitation in
referring the genus to the family of the Halcyonellee, with
the following diagnosis :

Class.—Po.tyzoa.
Order.—CTENOSTOMATA.
Fam.—Halcyonellee.

Gen.— Clavopora, Bk.

Zoarium, simple claviform, subcapitulate, composed of
distinct cells, traversed by nucleated (probably contractile)
fibres.

Sp.—C. Hystricis. The only species.

Hab,—Mediterranean ; Carpenter.

ON THE ETIOLOGY OF MADURA-FOOT. 263

On the Ertotocy of Mapura-roor; Note by the Rev. M.
J. BERKELEY, M.A., F.L.S.

[Tux following article appeared in the ‘ Indian Medical
Gazette’ of April 1, 1874. The Rev. M. J. Berkeley has
favoured us with a reply to the objections which it raises to
the hitherto received theory of the cause of the Madura-foot.
—LEps.]

Whilst perusing a particularly able essay in a recent
number of the ‘ Medico-Chirurgical Review ’ on the * Causes
of Epidemics,’—an essay which we heartily commend to
such of our readers as have not seen it,—we were not a little
surprised to observe that a writer who, whilst manifesting
such discrimination as was evident on every page of this
Review, should nevertheless have cited “ Madura-foot ”
disease as an example of “lesions indubitably dependent on
extraneous vegetable growths.”

We were surprised because we were aware that numerous
carefully conducted experiments had recently been made in
this country, with a view of definitely ascertaining whether any
evidence of special “‘ vegetable growths” could be detected
in connection with this malady. The results of these expe-
riments were of an entirely negative character.

We are not unmindful of the lessons conveyed by the
numerous instances on record of vain attempts at verifying
statements regarding the existence of parasites where their
presence has been established beyond doubt ; nor of the fact
that probably seven-tenths of the profession regard the
etiology of “ Madura-foot” as satisfactorily demonstrated.
Still, the evidence elicited by these experiments was so strong
as to convince us that some serious mistake had been made
before any such views could have been propounded.

We have recently received a pamphlet on the subject from
the author, Dr. H. Vandyke Carter,! but, after careful study
of its contents, have not been able to alter our opinion in the
slightest degree. This pamphlet and its accompanying
plate may, we presume, be taken as an epitome of the author’s
previous writings and drawings in connection with this
malady, doubtless embodying also the experience gained
during the dozen years or so which have transpired since
his views were first placed before the profession.

| “The Parasitic Fungus of Mycetoma,” by H. Vandyke Carter, M.D.,
‘Transactions Pathological Society of London.’ 1872-73.

264 REV. M. J. BERKELEY,

These views are so well known that it is scarcely necessary
to refer to them at any great length. Suffice it to say that
Dr. Carter believes that he has shown that the disease is
caused by a distinct fungus—a peculiar red mould, which
has not been seen except in connection with Madura-foot.
This mould was first observed by Dr. Vandyke Carter in
May, 1861, “upon part of a diseased foot which had been
placed in water for maceration.......The next occasion of its
occurrence was during the following year, in the month of
April, in connection with a specimen of Mycetoma preserved
in spirits; and again, also about the same date, the mould
was seen on some rice paste in which some fresh black fungus
particles had been placed, in order to ascertain if they could
be made to grow artificially.”

It will be observed that the mould referred to as having
developed under these varying conditions was identified as
one and the same kind of fungus—a fact which, per se,
contains a sufficient refutation of the whole theory; for it is
a physical impossibility that spores of fungi which had been
preserved in spirits should retain their vitality, consequently
the mould which grew on the spirit-preserved specimen must
have been of extraneous origin ; not only must it have germi-
nated after the evaporation of the alcohol, but it must have
originated from some source other than the interstices of the
macerated tissue. We are, therefore, compelled to infer that
the red mould, of various shades, described as having spread
over portions of these three and other Madura-foot specimens,
was but some developmental form of our ordinary pink-tinted
moulds—bearing no relation whatever to the black, yellow,
or orange-coloured particles frequently found in diseased
tissues of this nature—no closer relationship, in fact, than a
crop of various tinted mould on the surface of rice paste does
to any coloured particles which may chance to be in its
substance.

No mould with which we are acquainted, however, presents
the slightest resemblance to the pink-coloured objects figured
in the plate, purporting to represent “ the structure of the
red mould found in connection with Mycetoma (Chionyphe
Carteri) ’’—figures, by the way, differing materially from
those appended to the original text in the ‘ Bombay Tran-
sactions, or any others which we have seen elsewhere, and
which, we presume, must be considered as representing
the Chionyphe Carteri more accurately than the early figures.
So long as the forms here delineated are associated in the
mind with the idea of moulds, one is certainly puzzled to
account for their presence ; fortunately, however, a sentence

ON THE ETIOLOGY OF MADURA-FOOT. 265

’ in the descriptive text, attached to the plate, supplies us with
a key: the objects depicted are referred to as representing
“a fragment of the new growth as this appeared upon a
specimen of the foot disease placed in water to macerate,”
and a very good representation it is of “ fragments” which
may very frequently be obtained in some specimens of tank
water in which, however, no diseased foot need necessarily
have been macerated.

Looking at the drawing, without reference to the text, we
should describe the objects as being, probably, some con-
fervoid growths, and the “ spore-capsule,” filled with pink-
coloured globules, as the encysted gonidium of some Alga,
not very unlike the gonidia of Pandorina, as figured in late
editions of the ‘ Micrographic Dictionary,’ or Pritchard’s
‘Infusoria.’ To the Alga articles and plates of either of
these volumes, or, better still, to some neighbouring tank at
certain seasons of the year, we refer our readers for further
explanation concerning the objects figured in this plate.

It is with much regret that we write in this manner con-
cerning any of the labours of so industrious and accomplished
an observer as Dr. Carter is known to be, but, when we find
a doctrine, which we believe to be altogether erroneous—
the result of a misinterpretation of microscopic appearances—
used by men of eminence (who themselves may not have the
opportunity, or. possess the special training, necessary for this
particular branch of study) as a basis upon which to found
the etiology of other diseases, we feel that the time has
arrived for giving free expression to our opinion regarding it.

Note by the Rry. M. J. BurKeE ey.

It must be presumed that the writer in the ‘ Indian
Medical Gazette,’ who has attacked Dr. Carter with reference
to the fungous origin of the formidable disease known as the
Fungus-foot of India, is not acquainted with the botanical
articles on the subject in the ‘ Intellectual Observer’ for
November, 1862, or more especially in the ‘ Journal of the
Linnean Society,’ vol. viii, p. 139, even’ supposing that he
had an intimate knowledge of fungi, or he could not at once
condemn Dr. Carter for considering Chionyphe Cartert as a
fungus rather than an alga. I must, however, take the
whole responsibility on myself, as I consider myself justified
after a most careful consideration of the subject, in confirming
Dr. Carter’s views. I have given in detail an account of
the points of resemblance between the Chionyphe and certain
Saprolegnie, and the reasons which induce me to consider

266 W. G. FARLOW.

these curious plants as related to Mucorini, amongst which
they are less anomalous than they would be amongst alge.
The very fact alone of the Chionyphe being capable of culti-
vation on rice paste is almost sufficient to show what its real
affinities are, for with the exception of Chroolepus, which is
a very doubtful alga, no alga could be so completely a creature
of air. Though several undoubted alge (without elimi-
nating such as are believed to be conditions of lichens) are
not immersed, they flourish only in situations where there is
an abundant supply of moisture. But allowing as little as
possible for this consideration, no instance, as far as I am
aware, has been recorded of the possibility of cultivating
algze on rice paste, the paste draining off its superfluous
moisture, and no fresh fluid being added. I have no infor-
mation as to the point whether the specimens’ transmitted to
me from India were raised from samples which had been
“immersed in alcohol. ‘They were perfectly dry when they
came to me, and fragments of the large sclerotioid nuclei, when
placed on the paste, at once communicated to it a red tint.
I know of no observations which show that the spores of
fungi would certainly be killed by alcohol, and I should not
be surprised to find that they survived immersion. There
is, however, no reason to assert that the specimens sent
to me had ever been immersed in alcohol. In conclu-
sion, I would observe that there is no other reason to sup-
pose that the Chionyphe has any relation to alge, except so
far as it is related to Saprolegnie; and those persons who
have paid the closest attention to fungi, and haye at the
same time made alge an especial object of study, are for the
most part of one opinion as to the affinities of these curious
aquatic organisms.

An AsExuAL Growrn from the Proruatius of Preris.
CreticaA. By Witiiam G. Fartow, M.D., Harvard
University. (With Plates X and XI.)

WHILE studying the development of the archegonium in
the Polypodiacee, in the botanical laboratory of the Univer-
sity of Strassburg, a peculiarity was first noticed in the pro-
thallus of Pteris cretica which seems to have an important
bearing on the question of the fern prothallus in general.

The material used was taken from a pot in which Péeris

ASEXUAL GROWTH FROM PROTHALLUS OF PTERIS CRETICA. 267

eretica and Aspidiwm molle had been sown. At the begin-
ning of the investigation there were a number of seedlings
of both the above-named species which were considerably
advanced in growth; and in addition there were numerous
prothalli, from some of which young plants had begun to
grow, and others still younger on which no incipient plant-
lets could be discovered with the naked eye. A search was
made among the latter for prothalli in a condition suitable
to demonstrate the earliest stages of growth after the fertilisa-
tion of the archegonium. Some of these prothalli were
normally developed, having both antheridia and archegonia,
from which occasionally an embryonal growth was seen.
During the search, however, numerous specimens were found
presenting the anomaly of scalariform ducts in the substance
of the prothallus ; and such prothalli, when still further de-
veloped, showed that the young fern-plantlets produced by
them were the result of a direct budding of the cells, and
not of the changes caused by the act of fertilisation in a single
embryonal cell. The number of cases in which the above-
mentioned peculiarity was manifested was about fifty ; but,
undoubtedly, the actual number was greater, inasmuch as
some of the young fern-plantlets in the pot, which were too
old to allow one to say whether they had been regularly
developed (that is, by growth from an embryo) or not, probably
belonged to the number of those developed by direct bud-
ding. The shape of the prothalli was, as usual, more or
less obcordate ; and those in which the anomaly presented
itself, although variable in outline, were narrower than the
others. This narrowness may have been only accidental and
the result of crowding in the pot, as very often happens in
the cultivation of ferns. In a single case one side was
developed into a sort of secondary prothallus. The cells
of the prothalli were perhaps somewhat paler than usual ;
and those which, near the concavity of the heart, are gene-
rally more numerous than in other portions and isodiametrical,
were here much longer than broad,—that is, longer in the
direction from thecentre of the prothallus towards theconcavity.
Asis well known, fern prothalli are generally heart or kidney-
shaped, and the two sides composed of a single layer of
polygonal cells, the centre of a portion decidedly thicker and
consisting of several layers, which we may call the cushion ;
and in this last-named portion are situated the archegonia,
while the antheridia, are much more widely dispersed, being
found also in the lateral lobes. As before said, the most
striking feature of the abnormal prothalli was the presence
of a scalariform duct in thecushion a short distance back of the
VOL. XIV.—NEW SER. s

268 WwW. G, FARLOW.

concavity, just where the archegonia are generally found.
But wherever such scalariform vessels were present there
were no traces whatever of archegonia to be found, although
antheridia were always abundant, as well as the hairs, which
here fulfil the offices of roots. (See Pl. X, figs. 1 and 2, in which
a shows the position of the scalariform ducts.) As may be
seen from figs. 6 and 9, the scalariform ducts arise singly,
and are situated in the central portion of the tissue of the
prothallus. They scarcely differ in shape at first from the
adjoining cells, which are longer and relatively narrower
than the superficial cells. The ‘ducts increase by division in
a direction parallel to the surface, so that, in a longitudinal
section, we find several lying one above ‘he other.

Another peculiarity often, but not always, accompanying
the presence of scalariform ducts, was the formation of a
process or outgrowth in the concavity of the thallus, as shown
in Pl. X, figs. land2. This outgrowth was variable in length,
often being short and imbedded between the lateral lobes, but
sometimes. projecting as a narrow tapering process. In one
case, it was forked at the extremity. The growth by means
of a single terminal cell is shown in Pl. XI, fig. 9. As just
mentioned, the existence of a process in the concavity is a
striking peculiarity, but not quite a constant occurrence,
like the presence of scalariform ducts. ‘The first scalariform
duct arises in the prothallus, as I have just remarked; and
others soon appear, always in a line between the original
duct and the nearest point of the concavity. In this way arises
an interrupted row of ducts, which may extend, when a
process is present, nearly to its extremity. The cells sur-
rounding the original duct soon assume the form of ducts
themselves, and thus a rudimentary bundle is formed. It
happens rarely that two such scalariform ducts appear simul-
taneously in parts of the prothallus remote from one another.
I only saw one such case.

It now becomes necessary to consider the relation of the
scalariform ducts to the other cells of the prothallus, and this
must be done by making longitudinal and transverse sections
of the region in which the ducts lie. From such longitudinal
sections (Pl. X, figs. 6 and 9), we see that the prothallus forms
acompact tissue in which certain cells have assumed the cha-
racter of scalariform ducts, while the others remain unchanged.
From no section made was I able to see any trace of an arche-
gonium. In two instances, when seen from above, a com-
bination of four cells led me to suppose that there was some
signification to be attached to this arrangement. But as a
longitudinal section (Pl. X, fig. 7), shows no connection

ASEXUAL GROWTH FROM PROTHALLUS OF PTERIS CRETICA, 269

between the four surface cells (two of which are seen at z)
and the scalariform ducts, I am compelled to regard the two
cases as having only accidentally such a superficial cell-con-
formation.

So far the changes mentioned have taken place in the plane
of the prothallus itself. Now a change occurs which pro-
duces a growth in a direction perpendicular to the prothallus,
and this growth is easily distinguished from the usual embryo
growth. A swelling is seen, generally on the under surface
of the prothallus, shortly after the appearance of the sealari-
form duct. ‘This swelling is situated on or very near the line
connecting the original duct and the nearest point of the
concavity. When there is a process, this swelling very often
appears near its extremity, as in Pl. X, fig. 2,6. When two
such swellings appear simultaneously, they are generally
situated side by side. In all cases, there is seen behind
the swelling the scalariform duct or ducts lying in the sub-
stance of the prothallus itself. It is impossible for me
to say in which cells of the prothallus this swelling or
outgrowth originates. Longitudinal sections show no change
by which the cells of the outgrowing portion—which is,
in this case, on the upper instead of the lower surface
of the prothallus as is more commonly the case—can be
distinguished from the cells which are to remain a portion of
the prothallus. From the not unfrequent appearance of a
bursting through the surface, it may perhaps be inferred that
the superficial cells take no part in the growth. Certainly
no particular mother-cell or cells seem to be the place of
origin of the new growth, but it seems to be a direct continua-
tion of the prothallus cells, and not a distinct organisation
temporarily attached to it, as is the case with an embryo
growth. ‘This swelling, to which I have intentionally avoided
giving the name of bud, develops and shows all the character-
istics of a fern leaf, and is, in fact, not a stem, but a true
leaf. When it arises on the under surface of the prothallus,
this leaf grows forwards, curves round the border of the
concavity, and raises itself into the air, as in Pl. X, fig. 4, d.
When two such swellings occur by the side of one another,
one generally grows from the upper, the other from the
under surface of the prothallus, as in Pl. X, fig. 5. In the
meanwhile, there appears on the base of the leaf, or on
what is now so far differentiated that it is evidently the
leaf-stalk, a bud, which very soon can, by means of the cell-
cap on its end, be recognised as a root (fig. 4, 7). This
grows always in a direction the reverse of the leaf; that
is, backwards away from the concavity. After the appear-

270 W. G. FARLOW.

ance of the root, a bud appears on the base of the leaf-stalk,
looking towards the concavity, and from this grows the stem
(fig. 4, s). As a rule, the leaf is tolerably far advanced
in its development before the root appears, and the root in-
variably precedes the stem-bud. ‘The terms forward and
backward with relation to the concavity of the prothallus are,
of course, inapplicable when the young plantlet is formed at
or near the end of a process of the character above described,
when the leaf and root shoot out ad libitum. In all cases a
vascular bundle traverses the leaf and root, and these
are in connection with the vascular bundle of the pro-
thallus.

If now we compare PI. XI, fig. 10, with fig. 257, m Sachs’s
‘ Lehrbuch der Botanik,’ p. 346, which represents a longi-
tudinal section of a prothallus and a normally developed
embryo attached, we shall clearly see that the cases we have
been discussing differ widely from the ordinary cases of
embryonal growth. Fig. 10 represents a longitudinal section
through the spot where a young plantlet, such as we have
described, shoots out from the prothallus (p, p), 5 represents
the leaf, r the root, and s the stem-bud, which was cut a little to
one side of the median line. First, at a glance, the figure in
Sachs’s ‘Lehrbuch’ differs from fig. 10in the fact that the young
plant in the latter case is so intimately connected with the pro-
thallus that one cannot decide where the one begins and the
other ends; while, in the former, it is perfectly easy to trace the
outline of the young fern. Secondly, we have in the former a
structure known as the foot, f, by which the developing fern is
separated from the prothallus—a structure to which we find
no equivalent in fig. 10. Thirdly, the vascular bundle of the
plantlet is in direct connection with vessels which lhe wholly
in the prothallus. Fourthly, the order of evolution is different
in the two cases. In the one, the leaf arose first, as we saw,
and was tolerably well developed before a root and afterwards
a stem-bud made their appearance. In the other the root
anticipates by far both the leaf and stem-bud in its develop-
ment ; and, in fact, the root and stem are not produced from
the leaf-stalk, but (and this fact is not to be learned from
the figure, but from the accompanying description in Sachs)
by the subdivision of a single cell into four, one of which
forms the foot.

So far as I know, a budding similar to that in the cases
described is only mentioned by Wigand,‘ Botanische Zeitung,’
Feb. 16, 1849, and by him in language which, it must be
confessed, is not a little obscure :—‘ Eine beachtenswerthe
Erscheinung begegnete mir bei einigen Exemplaren, namlich

ASEXUAL GROWTH FROM PROTHALLUS OF PTERIS CRETICA, 271

eine Sprossenbildung, ungefahr an der Stelle des Lagers wo
das beblatterte Pflinzchen angelegt wird, entspringen junge
Vorkeime von derselben Gestalt, wie die Hauptvorkeime im
jungen Zustande, mit dem verschmilerten Ende (dem Spore-
nende entsprechend), an dem Lager festsitzend, spater sich
loslésend und wie ein selbstiindiger Vorkeim sich verhaltend.”
From the above paragraph, it would be, perhaps, difficult to
say whether Wigand had seen anything similar to our case.
But, taken in connection with his Tafel 1, fig. 25, where a
process in the concavity is clearly seen, it seems probable
that he had seen a growth which did not proceed from a
fertilized archegonium."

The bearing of the facts already enumerated upon the
question of the function of the fern-prothallus is very im-
portant. Since the publication by Leszcyc-Suminski, in
1848, of his observations concerning the sexuality of ferns,
the prothallus has been regarded as an organ intermediary
between the spore and the fully-developed plant, growing
out of the former, and bearing sexual organs which by mutual
co-operation produce the latter.. It has been considered im-
possible for a spore to produce a fern-plant directly without
the intervention of a sexual union.” But, from the cases we
have been considering, it is evident that this process is not
absolutely necessary, since we have seen that a young fern
can be produced from the spore by a purely vegetative or
budding process—a process as clearly unsexual as, for instance,
the production of plantlets on the fronds of Asplenium vivi-
parum. ‘This fact is an unexpected one for those who con-
stantly see unity and simplicity in nature. Although in by
far the majority of cases the prothallus does bear archegonia
whose embryos develop into ferns, the monstrosity, if so we
please to call the present cases, having once been noticed,
may of course be expected to occur at any time; and, now
that the attention of botanists has been called to it, it may
prove not to be rare. As, in the present instance, certain

! As far as I am aware, no similar cases are described in any of
Hofmeister’s writings ; but, on the authority of Dr. Askeuasy, of Heidelberg,
an example of a similar prothallus was shown by Hofmeister, when pro-
fessor at Heidelberg, to the students in his laboratory. At any rate, a fern
prothallus containing one or more vessels was seen by him, and probably a
scantiness of material prevented a further study of the subject.

2 [Sachs remarks that, like the thalli of Hepatice, the prothalli of ferns
develop adventitious branches from some of their marginal cells, and this
takes place especially in Osmunda, where the adventitious shoots detach
themselves, and so constitute a means of vegetative propagation. Appa-
rently it is only the thallus that is produced in this way, and not, as in the
present case, the asexual generation.—ED. |

272 E. RAY LANKESTER.

examples bore archegonia with embryonal outgrowth, and
others only direct bud-development, it is of course interest-
ing to know whether the young plantlets of the two kinds of
origin exactly resemble one another in their after develop-
ment. For this purpose, a number of specimens evidently
belonging to the category of abnormal growths were trans-
planted into'a pot where their growth could be watched.
During a recent visit to Strassburg I examined the specimens
which had already attained the height of five or six inches,
and they were sufficiently well developed to make it evident
that they were plants of Pteris cretica, not of P. serrulata, as
had been at first supposed.

In conclusion, I would take this opportunity heartily to
thank Professor De Bary of Strassburg for material and
advice kindly afforded during the course of the foregoing
investigations.

ToRQUATELLA TYPICA; @ New Tyre of INFusORIA, ALLIED
to the Cittata (with Plate XII, figs. 1—5). By E. Ray
LanKeEstER, M.A., Fellow and Lecturer of Exeter College,
Oxford.

Two years ago, at Naples, I found and made sketches of a
very curious little Infusorium, which is sufficiently remark-
able to deserve record, though I have but few details of its
structure to communicate, and only met with it in one
“gathering.” It occurred in connection with a mass of eggs
of Terebella which I was keeping for the study of the develop-
ment of that annelid. Other Infusoria—true ciliate hetero-
trichous forms—were abundant in the same vessel of sea water,
feeding on such of the eggs as were in a decaying state. Some
of these contained red masses which they had engulphed—
detached fragments of the broken-down Terebella eggs. Others
were busy in making their way through slits in the chorion of
certain eggs, eager to enjoy the feast within, and some of the
egg-shells contained two or three Infusoria hopelessly drifting
round and round, having eaten all the semi-decayed egg-yelk
and apparently unable to return by the slit which had
admitted them—most unquestionable cases for the founda-
tion of elaborate theories of “‘ heterogenetic metamorphosis ”
on the part of rashly speculative nature-philosophers —
but such as are well enough known to assiduous students
of the minuter forms of life. Here and there, among

TORQUATELLA TYPICA. 273
these swarming ciliate Infusoria, I observed the speci-
mens drawn in Pl. XII, figs. 1—d. They were exceed-
ingly active, and had to be examined both in the living con-
dition and after their movements had been arrested by the
administration of a trace of Osmic Acid, in order to ascertain
definitely their characteristics. Though having the appear-
ance and habit of a ciliate Infusorian, this form—for which I
propose the name Torquatella—does not possess any cilia at
all. The body is oblong, and has the same mobility as that
exhibited by most of the Ciliata. At the anterior extremity
is placed the mouth, overhung by a capitular prominence, or
upper lip (¢ ¢), as is not unfrequent in the group. There is
a definite cuticular membrane to the body-sac, but, contrary
to what occurs in most ciliate Infusoria, this does not transmit
any delicate processes of vibratile protoplasm. ‘There is not
even a ring of such cilia surrounding the oral region and
capitular prominence, as in Vorticellide, but in its place a
complete delicate bell-like prolongation of the body wall,
which may well be compared to an Elizabethan frill or
plicated collar. This large collar quite overhangs the
cephalic region, and reaches in front of it. It is no mere
cuticular expansion, but has protoplasmic characteristics,
being continually in a state of vibration, alternately closing
up and expanding with a twisting movement, and exhibiting
the same rapidity and regularity in this movement as doa
series of cilia in a similar position. In fact, the movements
of this collar may be best understood by comparing them to
the movement of a series of cilia united to one another along
their length by delicate membrane. In figs. 1—3 the collar
is seen in a quiescent condition, when it exhibits obliquely-
directed folds. In figs. 4 and 5 it is seen at the other
extremity of the stroke, that is to say, expanded.

The vibrating collar of Torquatella functions as an organ
of locomotion, and also serves to bring food-particles into the
region of the mouth. In fig. 4, a Torguatella is sketched as
seen in active progression. Locomotion is effected in the an-
terior direction, and consequently the cup or collar becomes
fully expanded, its active “ beat ” being probably downwards
and backwards. Wher the beat is sufficiently vigorous, the
motion produced tends to prevent the collar, in its passive
recoil, from gathering up round the mouth. But when the
stroke of the collar (comparable to the stroke of a cilium) is
less powerful, the organism remains unchanged in position,
and the collar recoils to its full extent after each beat, gather-
ing itself in folds round the oral region. ‘The tendency of
this less violent movement will be to bring a series of waves

274 E. RAY LANKESTER.

of water against the oral surface, and consequently occasional .
food-particles. ‘The rounded masses seen in figs. 1 and 2
are of an intense blood-red colour, probably due to foreign

-food-matters. I did not make out, in the few specimens

which came under my notice, nucleus or vacuoles ; it is very
possible that more ample opportunity of observation would
have enabled me to do so.

There is no Infusorian described which exhibits the
replacement of cilia by a vibrating collar. In this jeurnal,
in October, 1871, I described a curious minute parasite from
the blood of the frog (Undulina), which seemed to be a
mouthless parasitic Infusorian, comparable to Opalina (0.
naidos), but having, in place of cilia, an undulating mem-
brane in the form of a crest. I have since learned from
Professor Leuckart’s report that it has been long known,
being the Trypanosoma sanguinis of Gruby. Torquatella is
much more nearly allied to the normal Infusoria Ciliata than
is the minute, possibly immature Trypanosoma of the frog. It
is not parasitic,and has mouth and cephalic prominence, in the
former of which characters it definitely indicates its affinities
with the one group of unicellular organisms which is mouth-
bearing—namely, the Ciliata—whilst in the latter it presents"
a special point of agreement with particular genera of Ciliata, -
If the possession of a mouth were taken as the family mark
of the highest branch of the Homoblastica or Protozoa, we
might class, under such a group of Stomatoda, the Ciliata
(including some forms become astomatous by parasitism), the
Calycata (represented by Torquatella), and the Flagellata
(containing Noctiluca and Peridinium, and excluding forms
referable to the Alge).

On the Heart of ApPENDICULARIA FURCATA and the
DeEvELOPMENT of its MuscutaR Fisres. By E. Ray
LanxesteER, M.A., Fellow and Lecturer of Exeter College,
Oxford. (With Plate XII, figs. 6—8.)

Appendicularia (Fritillaria) furcata of Gegenbaur occurs
not uncommonly in the spring on the surface of the Bay of
Naples. The drawings and observations which I made two
years since relating to this species have, to a large extent,
been anticipated by the very valuable work of M. Hermann
Fol, who has described and figured in a lavish manner several

ON THE HEART OF APPENDICULARIA FURCATA. 275

species of the genus. ‘There are some points, as to the mode
of communication between the exterior and the branchial
region of the pharynx, in which I do not find my notes quite
confirmed by M. Fol’s observations, and I hope to look
further into that subject during the present spring. But
at this moment I may draw attention to a structure in
Appendicularia which has not hitherto been noticed by any
one who has observed these interesting forms, excepting in a
note by myself in the ‘Annals of Nat. History,’ 1873. The
matter to which I now allude is one of histological interest
bearing more or less directly upon the nature of transversely-
striped muscular fibre. It also has a wider embryological
interest, for I shall point out that an organ so important—
usually so complex—as the heart—is in Appendicularia formed
by only two nucleated cells, and actively functions whilst
consisting of no more than two ultimate units, corpuscles, or
plastids. The figures 6, 7, 8, in Pl. XII, represent the heart
of A. furcata, drawn whilst under observation with a
Hartnack’s 10, & immersion, the movement having been
caused to cease and the structure rendered clearer by the
action of a solution of Picric Acid allowed to flow under the
- covering glass which held the specimens.

The heart (fig. 6) is that of a smaller and less mature
specimen than those to which the hearts represented in
figs. 7 and 8 belong. It consists of two conical or
pyramidal cells or nucleated corpuscles, each connected
to the other along one edge of its broad base by fourteen
delicate filaments. During life these filaments are kept
in rapid vibration, corresponding in character to the move-
ment of cilia, held fast at each end, rather than to any
movement of muscular fibres with which we are familiar.
The movement is so rapid that during life the separate fibrils
cannot be seen, and the vibrating region connecting the two
conical cells has the appearance of a membranous sac. Iam
not certain that there is not an excessively delicate mem-
branous connection between the fibrils, but I failed to con-
vince myself that there is. Even in this younger heart (fig.
6) some of the fibrils are seen to exhibit an alternation of
light and dark bands, transversely disposed. In this trans-
verse striation the fibrils of the adult heart exactly correspond
with the fibrils of the muscular mass which runs parallel
with the notochord in the flabelliform tail, which structure,
as well as other histological details of Appendicularia, is most
satisfactorily brought into clear definition and preserved for
future study by the use of Picric Acid, as above described,
followed by a similar introduction of the clarifying and pre-

276 E. RAY LANKESTER.

servative medium, Glycerine. This latter fluid is caused to
flow under the glass cover by means of absorption along
one of its sides, produced by a piece of blotting paper.

In the hearts of mature full-grown A. furcata the
structure is a little more complicated, as seen in figs.
7, 8. In fig. 7 the fibrillar part of the heart is obscured
by the esophagus which runs across this particular part,
and has not been displaced in the slide from which the
drawing has been made. Fig. 8 shows but one: heart-cell,
with its connected fibrils. There are thirteen fibrils in
the former of these hearts, and twelve in the latter. The
variation in their number can have no significance. In
fig. 7 they are most clearly seen to arise from one edge only
of the broad base of each heart-cell, and to leave the rest of
the margin free. As an addition to what was observed in the
smaller heart, there are now present small secondary cor-
puscles, lying at the base of the fibrils, sometimes between
two, sometimes closely embracing two or three. These
small secondary corpuscles (s,s) are not nucleated cells, and
it is not easy to form an idea as to the mode of their origin.
They are not indicated in the earlier condition of the heart,
and it is clear that they are not the morphological equivalents
of the two large conical heart-cells: One cannot be sure that
the condition represented in figs..7, 8 is the final, adult
heart,—a strange reduction of that .organ if it be so, since it
has not even a tubular structure or cavity, still less are
there vessels connected with it. It:is simply a most vigorous
churn, beating and stirring up the fluid in the great peri-
visceral hemolymph space without propelling it in any
particular direction.

The reduction of the. number of the constituent cell-
elements or plastid-units in such small organisms of elaborate
organisation as are the Appendiculariz and the Rotifera,
may help to make clear some of the processes of growth and
development in organisms generally. To what extent can
this reduction be carried? May we not possibly even arrive
at a stage in retrogressive metamorphosis where cells no
longer differentiate at all? Are we not prone to assign too
important an office to the plastid, even as an element in com-
plexity of organisation? The living matter of the organism
is what develops and elaborates structure; its segregation
into a greater or less number of corpuscles is a simple effect
of the relations of bulk and cohesion. At the same time the
limits of size on the side of minuteness which can be presented
by the higher types of organisms seem to be determined by
the impossibility of reducing the number of constituent units

ON THE HEART OF APPENDICULARIA FURCATA. pt

beyond a certain point. After this point the typical organi-
sation itself is no longer maintained. The Rotifera are
reduced to the smallest possible size compatible with their
high organisation. ‘The smallest exhibit loss of organs (e. g.
the ciliated canals), and appear to be at the extreme point in
reduction of the number of plastids, whilst Appendicularia
furcata is in a similar condition among Notochordate
Pharyngobranchiata.

REVIEW.

The Anatomy of the Lymphatic System. By E. Kix1n, M.D.,
Assistant-Professor at the Laboratory of the Brown Insti-
tution, London. Part I. The Serous Membranes (with
ten plates). London: Smith and Elder. 1873.

Tuts valuable memoir is doubtless one of the most impor-
tant contributions made to histology within the past year.
We are, however, relieved from the necessity of giving a very
elaborate notice of the contents, since a portion of the work
has already appeared in our journal (‘Quar. Jour. Micro.
Sci.,’ 1872, p. 142).

It deals partly with the normal, partly with the patho-
logical conditions. As regards the normal conditions the
following summary is given by Dr. Klein :—“ The attention
of histologists has been chiefly, if not wholly, directed to
three questions—(1) the distribution of the lymphatic vessels
in the serous membranes; (2) the origin of the lymphatic
capillaries from the lymph-canalicular system of Reckling-
hausen; and (3) the free communication between the
lymphatic vessels and the serous cavity by means of stomata.
The description refers to the minute structure of the omen-
tum, the centrum tendineum of the diaphragm, and the pleura
mediastini.”

The first chapter treats of the endothelium of the free sur-
face of the serous membranes. The most noticeable point
here is the normal germination of endothelium observed by
Dr. Klein in the peritoneum of guinea-pigs, cats, dogs, and
monkeys. In the fenestrated portion of the omentum are
seen on the surface of the trabecul “ small groups of club-
shaped or polyhedral granular cells, projecting from the
surface of the trabecule like buds.” These appearances are
seen in healthy organs, though they become more abundant
and strongly marked in acute or chronic inflammation."

' Similar features in the human omentum were described in a paper

REVIEW. 279

In the second chapter are discussed the cellular elements
of the ground-substance or connective-tissue-corpuscles.
These are described as flat branched cells lying parallel to
the surface, and, as shown by Rollett, in the cornea, the lymph
canalicular system corresponds to these cells. Spherical or
lymphoid cells, of which all intermediate sizes exist, from a
rounded nucleus with a thin zone of protoplasm up to those
which are twice as large as a common colourless blood-
corpuscle are seen in the lymph canalicular system. The
origin of fatty tissue is illustrated partly by a description of
a gelatinous body which lies in the infra-orbital fossa of
young rabbits, and which is composed of rudimentary adipose
tissue or mucous tissue.

It is not easy to give a condensed account of Dr. Klein’s
observations on the lymphatic vessels of the serous mem-
branes, which form the subject of the third chapter. The
essential points have, however, been already stated in this
journal, in the article before referred to.

With regard to blood-vessels, Dr. Klein holds that new
capillaries are formed from those previously existing both by
the continuous excavation of the branched cells connected
with their walls, and are also formed in an isolated manner
in the branched cells themselves, becoming united ultimately
with the existing capillaries. This method is similar to that first
pointed out by Stricker in the new formation of blood-vessels
in the tadpole and in inflammation, which was afterwards
confirmed by Arnold.

We cannot here enter upon the pathological relations, but
they illustrate ina surprising manner the normal anatomy of
the parts, and supply fresh example, if any were needed, of
the close connection of physiology with pathology.

We may also point out that many of these observations
have more than a professional or pathological interest. The
morbid changes of the cell-elements, which he describes and
figures in great detail, are of the highest importance for the
general question of the vital phenomena of protoplasm.
Moreover, the full account, such as we now have, of the
histology of the serous membranes of the peritoneal cavity,
cannot but excite the attention of the comparative anato-
mist, who will not fail to recognise in many of the structures
and processes of growth described the counterpart of pheno-

communicated to the Medical Microscopical Society in June of last year.
See this Journal for 1873, p. 309; also ‘British Medical Journal,’ March
Q1st, 1874.

280 REVIEW.

mena known to him among the invertebrate relatives of the
Vertebrata, such as Annelida, Gephyrea, and Mollusca.

The work is illustrated by ten very beautiful plates,
executed in Germany, the expense of producing which was
borne by the’ Government Grant Committee of the Royal
Society. The researches were conducted in the laboratory of
the Brown Institution, under the management of the Uni-
versity of London. We are glad to see such valuable work
appearing under the auspices of these learned bodies.

ey ee ee

NOTES AND MEMORANDA.

Cement for Mounting Objects in Cells containing Fluid.—As
I have found great convenience in the use of the material I
am about to mention, I have thought others might find
it equally convenient when they have occasion to enclose
objects either microscopic or others in glass cells. The ad-
vantage it possesses arises chiefly from the circumstance that
it can be used under water, or weak spirit, so that the cover
can be affixed beneath the surface of the fluid; and thus the
admission of air-bubbles can be effectually prevented. It
has also the advantage of retaining its adhesive property for
several days if requisite.

The preparation, which may be termed “ caoutchouc size,”
is prepared by melting pieces of caoutchouc in an iron or
porcelain cup until it is reduced to the condition of a very
viscid tar. As this tar, however, in its primitive state is too
viscid for use, it should be dissolved in benzine so as to form
a fluid of the consistence of thick gold size.

When spread over the edges of the glass cell or vessel in-
tended to contain the object, it should be allowed to dry for
a quarter or half an hour, by which time the benzine will
have evaporated, leaving the surface exceedingly sticky ; and
this stickiness is not impaired, by immersion in water. Con-
sequently, if the cell or vessel with its contents is wholly
immersed, the cover may be applied and pressed firmly in its
place while still under the surface of the fluid.

No other fastening is absolutely required, but it is better
when the surfaces are dry to apply a solution of shellac or
other varnish round the edge of the cover.—GrorGE Buskx.

Mode of Staining Animal Tissues of a permanent Purple-grey
Colour.—Having from time to time been very successful in
staining some animal tissues of a rich transparent permanent
purple-grey colour, it may be of use to some of your readers
were they acquainted with the particulars of this staining
process which is a very simple one, and are as follows:

282 NOTES AND MEMORANDA.

Submerge the tissue to be stained, in the necessary quan-
tity of an ordinary carmine-staining fluid, such as either
Beale’s or Rutherford’s fluid, until it has become of a de-
cided carmine tint ; next drop into this fluid containing the
preparation a little of Draper’s! dichroic ink in the propor-
tion of about four drops of the ink to each drachm of the
carmine stain. Shake the containing vessel gently until the
two fluids are thoroughly mixed.

The length of time the preparation should remain in this
mixed fluid will depend upon its thickness, and will vary
from six to twenty-four or to forty-eight hours.

When sufficiently coloured, remove the preparation from the
fluid and wash carefully with either filtered or distilled water
until it ceases to impart a tint to the water. Itis then ready
for mounting in Price’s glycerine.

I believe that logwood is one of the ingredients of the ink,
the true composition of which is a trade secret. Possibly
ordinary logwood stain would answer the purpose as well as
the ink, but of this I have no experience, having found the
ink so efficacious.

I have some very beautiful preparations staimed in the
manner above mentioned and mounted in glycerine ; of these
organic muscle and delicate fascie are probably the most
striking.—B. Witis Ricuarpson, F.R.C.S.I.

Dr. Reyher on Synovial Membranes.—The memoir promised
in our last number has been withdrawn by the author (whose
name was printed by an error as Reijner), with a view to its
earlier publication in Germany and this country.

Action of Fresh Cholera-Ejections upon Animals.—Hogyes
(Centralblatt fiir die Medicinischen Wissenschaften, Nos.
50 and 51) states the results of his experiments on the action of
fresh cholera-ejections upon dogs and rabbits. The injections
were employed one and one and a half hours after passing from
the patient. The author has found—l1. That fresh cholera-ejec-
tions act injuriously upon the animal organism, and, as it
seems, on different animals in different degrees. 2%. The chief,
or at least most constant, phenomenon of the injurious action
after every form of introduction of the cholera-injections, is a
more or less strongly pronounced inflammatory change of the
stomach and intestinal tract. 3. A catarrh of the stomach
or intestine artificially produced renders the animal more
susceptible of the injurious effect. 4. Inspiration of air
saturated with particles from non-disinfected cholera-ejec-

' Mary Street, Dublin.

NOTES AND MEMORANDA, 283

tions can produce the same symptoms as the immediate
action in the stomach, rectum, or nervous system, whilst the
particles of cholera-ejections disinfected by carbolic acid
appear to be quite innoxious. 5. A current of air carries
with it small particles from non-disinfected ejections with
vegetate rapidly under favorable circumstances, whilst the
fungi from cholera-ejections disinfected by carbolic acid are
capable of propagation. 6. Cholera-ejections freed from form-
elements can produce, by their chemical constituents, the
same pathological effects as with their form-elements.—

W. Sriruinec, D.Sc., M.B.—WMedical Record.

Causes of Decay of TeethThese are not, according to
Leber and Rottenstein, internal or vital so much as external
and chemical. The process of decay begins from the surface,
and if it can be controlled or arrested at the surface it is
entirely controlled. The great causes of caries are two—
viz., acids and fungus found abundantly in the mouth,
Leptothric buccalis. This latter agent is characterised by
certain microscopic appearances and by its reaction with
iodine and acids, which give to the elements of leptothri a
beautiful violet tinge. Under the microscope the fungus
appears as a grey, finely granular mass or matrix, with
filaments delicate and stiff, which erect themselves above
the surface of this granular substance so as to resemble an
uneven turf. The fungus attains its greatest size in the
interstices of the teeth. No one can deny nowadays the
action of even weak acids in dissolving the salts of the
enamel and the dentine, making the enamel, naturally
transparent, first white, opaque, and milky, and, in a more
advanced state, chalky, and the dentine more transparent
and softer, so as to be cut witha knife. The acids which
may actually effect the first changes in the production of
caries are such as are taken with food, or in medicines, or such
as are formed in the mouth itself by some abnormality in
our secretions, which should be alkaline, or by an acid fer-
mentation of particles of food. Acids play a primary part,
making the teeth porous and soft. In this state, the tissues
haying lost their normal consistency, fungi penetrates both
the canaliculi of the enamel and of the dentine, and by their
proliferation produce softening and destructive effects much
more rapid than the action of acids alone is liable to accom-
plish. Bowditch, in examining forty persons of different
professions, and living different kinds of life, found in almost
all vegetable and animal parasites. The parasites weie
numerous in proportion to the neglect of cleanliness. The

VOL. XIV.—NEW SER. An

284 NOTES AND MEMORANDA.

means ordinarily employed to clean the teeth had no effect
on the parasites, whilst soapy water appeared to destroy
them.—Lancet, December 15th, 1875.

Holman’s “Siphon Slide” for the microscope is composed
essentially of a strip of plate-glass, three inches by one inch
wide, but double the usual thickness, in the upper surface
of which has been ground a shallow groove, elliptical in both
its transverse and longitudinal section, and deeper towards
one extremity. The excavation is so arranged as to receive a
small fish, tadpole or triton, and retain it without, on the
one hand, injury from undue pressure, but without, on the
other, permitting any troublesome movements beneath the
thin glass cover, which, when applied, forms the ceiling of
the cell. The great improvement of this slide consists, how-
ever, in the imbedding of a small metallic tube (communi-
cating with each extremity of the groove), in either end ot
the slide, and the adaptation to these two tubes of pieces ot
slender caoutchouc pipe, about eighteen inches in length,
one of these being intended for the entrance, and the other
for the exit of any fluid, cold or hot, which it might be desir-
able to employ.

For examination of larger reptiles, and for demonstrations
with the gas-microscope, a slide four inches long, with two
oval concavities, and a narrow groove more deeply cut for the
body of the creature, has been devised. With such an appa-
ratus, through which a current of ice-water can be passed,
the injurious heating effect which ordinarily attends the use
of calcium or electric light to illuminate living specimens is
entirely counteracted.

When in use it is only necessary to place the animal with
some water in the groove of the slide, cover with a sheet of
thin glass, immerse the end of one of the caoutchouc tubes
in ajar of water, and then, applying the mouth to the ex-
tremity of the other rubber pipe, make sufficient suction to
set up a flow of the liquid through the apparatus. The
stream of fluid (of course bathing the animal in the cell
during its passage)*can readily be kept up as in any other
siphon for hours or days, and its rapidity exactly regulated
by graduated pressure upon the entrance-pipe, so that in
this way a triton may be examined continuously (as stated
by Dr. J. Gibbons Hunt) for a whole week without material
injury.

Among the great advantages of this very ingenious con-
trivance may be enumerated—first, its security,—the animal
being prevented from escaping, and the joints of the appa-

————

NOTES AND MEMORANDA. 285

ratus being kept tightly closed by the pressure of the atmo-
sphere ; second, its portability,—the whole preparation being
made at home, carried to a lecture-room in the pocket, and
exhibited to an audience hours afterwards; and third, its
convenience,—this arrangement permitting the removal of
the slide at any time from the microscope-stage, to make
way for other experiments, and its instant readjustment when
desired.

The Microscopical Society of Victoria, which, at this early
stage of its existence, has a good member-roll, has held its
first general meeting at Melbourne, the president (Mr. W. H.
Archer) being in the chair. A rich and varied collection of
microscopes and objects was shown by members of the society,
and during the evening these exhibits were examined with
interest. The president, in delivering his inaugural address,
explained that the society would consist of two classes of
persons—viz. skilled workers, who were called members, and
students and amateurs, who were called associates. Mr.
Archer went on to say that in Victoria there were micro-
scopists who were possessors of good instruments, and who
knew thoroughly how to use them. The establishment of
this society, it was hoped, would induce most of these gentle-
men to co-operate, sooner or later, with one another; for
though at intervals certain very valuable special professional
work had been accomplished in Melbourne and elsewhere,
yet so far as published results were concerned, not only
Victoria, but Australia generally, was, microscopically speak-
ing, almost altogether an unknown land. The address was
followed by some interesting statements and demonstrations,
and altogether the inaugural meeting was a very successful
one. The holding of ordinary meetings has commenced, and
the society appears to have a useful career before it.— London
Medical Record.

The Silver Method.—Dr. Reyher, in his paper referred to
above on the cartilages and synovial membranes of joints, takes
occasion to discuss the value of the silver treatment in similar
investigations, and makes the following remarks :—

“« As is well known, the usual interpretation of the images
obtained by means of the silver treatment has been called in
question by Schweigger-Seidel, and doubt has been thrown
upon the cellular uature of the figures and appearances which
are produced in the synovial membrane by means of this re-
agent. His objections have been fully answered as regards
other organs (é. g., the cornea), in which, with different
methods of treatment, corresponding outlines are always

286 "NOTES AND MEMORANDA,

attainable. Whilst I am firmly convinced that the same
holds good with regard to the synovial membrane, it must be
remembered that, so long as neither the treatment with
chloride of gold nor combined methods had been employed
in the investigation of this tissue, a gap was left in the
evidence as to the nature of the silver outlines. I anticipated
that these methods would render service, more especially in _
bringing to light the exact meaning of the large white
stellate fields, apparently belonging to the same category as
those demonstrable in the cornea, but as to which it was un-
certain whether they belonged to groups of cells or only to
single ones. My investigations with respect to this point
have been principally made on the joints of full-grown sheep
and oxen, the tarso-metatarsal joints of which, and especially
of the last-named, yield marginal zones a finger’s breadth
wide. The sections were always made subsequently to the
occurrence of the silver precipitation ; in this way the clearest
images are obtained, and there is no fear of cutting sections
of cartilage from which the marginal zone has been acci-
dentally rubbed off.

“‘ T had so often attempted, without any great measure of
success, to combine the staining by other reagents, such as
carmine and aniline, with that obtained by the silver method,
that I was extremely pleased to find that hematoxylin, which
I made trial of at Professor Burdon Sanderson’s suggestion,
furnished a perfectly reliable means of staining the cell-
nuclei. By the employment of sections which are sufficiently
thin to obviate any sources of fallacy arising from the pre-
sence of the nuclei of the more deeply seated cartilage cells,
it is not difficult to convince oneself that the white fields on
the brown ground of the silver preparation from the more
circular spaces of the cartilage to the stellate and epithelioid
forms of the inner layer of the capsule, each contain either
one or several (violet-coloured) nuclei. By this method,
then, it is demonstrable that in each of the white fields of
the silver preparation there lie, according to the size of the
fields, one or several cellular elements. It is, however, im-
possible by this means to say whether the cells entirely fill
the cavities, and by means of their processes extend into the
lymphatic canaliculi, forming a complete anastomosing net-
work or not. For the elucidation of these points the
treatment with gold is necessary. Thus, in two kinds of
preparations, one treated by the combined silver and hema-
toxylin method, the other with gold, appearances are met
with which in general form and the mode of branching of the
processes are more or less similar. |

NOTES AND MEMORANDA, 287

As the hematoxylin shows the presence in the silver pre-
parations of cell-nuclei corresponding to the whole spaces,
so the treatment with gold shows that these nuclei correspond
to protoplasmic bodies which—the conclusion will hardly be
assailed—correspond, on the whole, to the spaces in the silver
preparations. It is quite another question whether these
masses of protoplasm completely fill the spaces or not. Proof
of this could only be obtained were it possible to produce
both the gold and the silver appearances in the same pre-
parations. As is well known, however, if a preparation be
treated first with silver, then with gold, the effect is only to
produce a reduction of the latter in the parts impregnated
with silver, whilst the converse mode of treatment altogether
fails to yield the silver spaces. The question must, there-
fore, so far remain unsettled. All one can say is, that on
both silver and gold preparations appearances are frequently
obtained which, as regards form, are precisely similar, appa-
rently even to the minutest details, although it is not every-
where possible to trace the same exact resemblance ; for
instance, the protoplasmic masses of the one might be said
to be smaller relatively than the spaces of the other; the
sizes, however, in both are so varied that it is difficult to
compare them. If the forms obtained by the gold treatment
differ from those obtained by the silver treatment, in one
point more than in another, it is in the diameter of the pro-
cesses, which here and there appear somewhat smaller and
more tapering than those proceeding from the spaces of the
silver preparation. On the other hand, the appearances pre-
sented in silver preparations which have been placed in
spirit are in favour of the idea that the spaces are completely
filled by protoplasm. In these it occurs here and there,
although it must be admitted, not generally, that both
nucleus and protoplasm may be made out, the latter appear-
ing as a finely granular substance, which is separated from
the brown intercellular substance by a crescentic clear zone
or space (perhaps caused by a shrinking of the protoplasm).
We may conclude, therefore, that the white spaces and canali-
culi shown to exist in the synovial membrane by treat-
ment with nitrate of silver, correspond generally to a proto-
plasmic network (made evident by chloride of gold),
consisting of connective-tissue-corpuscles.

A similar statement may be made with regard to the car-
tilage-cells of the surface, which appear after treatment with
silver as round white spaces, in which hematoxylin brings
the nuclei into view; whilst, on the other hand, chloride of
gold colours the protoplasm of the cells.

288 NOTES AND MEMORANDA.

Bacteria in Malignant Pustule—The fatal malady known
by this name amongst ourselves, and when it occurs in cattle
as ‘the Blood,’ to which the French give the name of
Charbon, and the Germans that of Milzbrand, though
happily rare in England, does occur occasionally amongst
cowkeepers, butchers, and others who have to do with cattle
or horses; and on this account the careful description of two
such cases, given by Dr. B. Frankel and Dr. J. Orth, in the
‘ Berliner Klinische Wochenschrift’ for June Ist and 8th,
1874, deserves attention.

Both patients were admitted into the Augusta Hospital at
Berlin, the second being a sick-warder and post-mortem
room assistant in that institution. Both cases were fatal.
At the post-mortem examination of the first the following
appearances were found:

The whole of the cervical connective tissue was infiltrated
with reddish serum. ‘This sanguineous infiltration, following
the course of the trachea, extended into the mediastinum,
along the bronchi, and over the pericardium. Everywhere,
along with this edema, the lymphatic glands were enlarged,
some to the size of walnuts, and so swollen with dark blood
as to strongly resemble blood-clots. The spleen was much
enlarged, and extremely soft. ‘The whole mucous membrane
of the stomach was greatly swollen, pulpy, and reddened.
In five or six large spots there was especial swelling, partly
due to extravasated blood, partly to local gangrene, with a
sreenish-yellow tint. This appeared, not only on the sur-
face, but on section. Professor Virchow pronounced the
case to be one of malignant pustule directly he saw this
stomach. The microscope confirmed this, for not only on
the surface of these greenish-yellow spots, but also in the
parenchyma of the gastric walls, there were found enormous
quantities of the parasitic elements generally known by
Davaine’s name of Bacteridia. For the most part these
appeared as masses of felted, but not branching, threads,
which were seen, at the edges of the groups, to be composed
of a number of little rod-like bodies of equal length. ‘There
were also masses, though less numerous, composed of groups
of equal-sized granules (micrococci). It was now clear that
the case was one of the so-called mycosis intestinalis, a
special form of the pest known as Milzbrand, or spleen-
gangrene, or malignant pustule; and the marked swelliug
and hemorrhagic appearances of the mesenteric and retro-
peritoneal lymphatic glands, the softened spleen, sanguineous
cedema of the connective tissue of the abdominal cavity,
ascites, &c., described by Dr. Frankel, perfectly agreed with

NOTES AND MEMORANDA, 289

the descriptions given by other observers (see E. Wagner,
‘ Archiv der Heilkunde,’ 1874).

The appearances in the second case were very similar, as
regards the lymphatics, &c. The appearances in the ab-
domen were like those in the last case, including the stomach.
The spleen was enlarged and softened. Bacteridia in masses
were found in the blood of the heart (examined at once),
and on the next day in a mesenteric vein. The white cor-
puscles were increased. No movements were seen in these
bacteridia; but that they were not coagula of any kind was
shown by their having kept perfectly well for some months
with acetic acid. The blood had carried these into all the
organs, but in the gangrenous-looking spots in the intestines
there were no rods or fibres, but heaps of micrococci.

This is the first published case of direct communication
from man to man, though Lube and Miiller’s cases (‘ Deutsches
Archiv fiir Klin. Med.’) show that such transmission has been
suspected. Dr. Orth inoculated a rabbit with the fresh
blood of the second case, and from this one another, and so
on, till eight were injected. Masses of bacteridia were
found in the blood and connective tissue of all these animals.
— Medical Record.

QUARTERLY CHRONICLE OF MICROSCOPICAL
SCIENCE.

BOTANY.

I. Algw.—tl. Spores of Nostochacee.—In a paper (‘Aun. des
Sc. Nat.,’ 5e sér., xix, p. 119) on the reproduction of some
species of this group ‘belonging to the genera Spermosira
and Nostoc, Janczewski announces the discovery of spores in
the latter genus, an observation already anticipated by Archer
in Nostoc paludosum, one of the species in which it has now
again been detected (‘ Quart. Journ. Mier. Sce.,’ 1872, p. 367).
In a subsequent number of the volume, Bornet (p. 318)
confirms this discovery in numerous other species. He had
‘already in his memoir published, in the seventeenth volume,
announced the reproduction by spores of Gleocapsa.

2. Conjugation of Zoospores in Confervacee.—Areschoug
has recorded the interesting fact (‘ Act. Reg. Soc. Se. Ups.,’
ser. ili, vol. ix) of the conjugation of the zoospores of various
Confervacee ; amongst others, of two very widely diffused
species— Cladophora sericea and Enteromorpha compressa.

3. Morphological Differentiation of the Sphacelaria-series.
—i. Pringsheim points out (‘ Abhl. der k. Akad. d. Wiss. zu
Berlin,’ 1873) that some Thallophytes offer distinct transi-
tions to a cormophytic mode of bud-formation. These increase
in interest when they occur as terminal links of a series, for it
appears natural to assume that such a series corresponds to
the genetic progress of development of the forms, and indicates
the various paths which have led on to cormophytiec bud-
formation. In the different subdivisions of the Algz, several
progressive and parallel series lead from the simple con-
fervoid type of growth up to bud-structure. Amongst the
Floridee the Ceramium-series affords an example.

A far more perfectly developed and almost rectilineal series
is presented by the Sphacelaria-series, belonging to Ph@os-
poree. It comprehends the Ectocarpee, the Sphacelariee
proper, and some smaller genera. The final link of this series,
Cladostephus, shows a great approximation in its mode of
growth to cormophytes. The Ectocarpee, which form the
lowest links of the series, are plants of purely confervoid

QUARTERLY CHRONICLE OF MICROSCOPICAL SCIENCE. 291

growth. The middle links of the series, the Sphacelariee,
and the genera Halopteris, Stypocaulon, &c., are more and
more differentiated in their structure, and, in the morpho-
logical distinctions of their systems of ramification, almost
step by step approach the bud-lke jointing and the
structure of Cladostephus. Thus the manner in which the
Sphacelaria-series attains in Cladostephus its more distinct
and established cormophytic configuration, seems well suited
to illustrate certain correlations between the anatomical
structure, the origin, and the configuration of the systems
of ramifications. As the basis for the comparison, Pring-
sheim copiously.describes two of the links in the Sphace-
laria-series in respect to their structure and the development
of their systems of ramification ; Cladostephus verticillatus
as the most perfectly differentiated link in the series, and
Sphacelaria olivacea as one of the lower forms in which the
differentiation of the ramification has scarcely advanced.

The first differences which occur in the forms of ramifi-
cation in this series, commencing with the confervoid type,
are presented by the formation of the fruit, and begin vege-
tatively by the formation of trichoma-like apices and inde-
pendent trichomata. Both appear only as portions of branches,
originally uniform, but checked and modified in their growth.
In a further stage entire branches suffer these modifications.
Further differences afterwards appear between the purely
vegetative branch-forms. In this stage (of which the Sphace-
lariee proper present numerous examples) we meet with
branches close together, in some of which the growth be.
comes extinguished earlier than in others. By degrees these
differences increase in Chetopteris, Halopteris, Stypocaulon.
Still later further differences amongst the limited and un-
limited ramifications become more definitely distinguished,
and the systems of ramification in the final link of the whole
series, the genus Cladostephus, become sharply separated
into the different modifications of branch and leaf-forms.
A distinct connection of the morphological configuration
with the structure and the origin of the bud-formation does
not admit of being overlooked.

The first indications of a differentiation in the ramifications
occur in the purely confervoid Kctocarpus-species, which
still show no kind of differentiation of their tissue. These
morphological distinctions only become noticeable with
the distinct separation of the tissue into permanent and
formative cells, and especially with the advancing localisation
of the latter at the apex of the thallome, and with the
separation of the tissue of the axis into central and peri-

292 QUARTERLY CHRONICLE OF MICROSCOPICAL SCIENCE.

pheral portions, entailing a more and more sharply expressed
differentiated origin of the lateral buds from unequivalent
elements of the tissue.

In the smaller Sphacelariee, growing with an apical cell,
the origin of the thallome-branches does not appear connected
with any definite position. In the further advanced links
of the series (Halopteris, Stypocaulon, Chetopteris) the dit-
ferentiation of the purely vegetative branch-forms become
more considerable, but still exhibits numerous transition-
stages. Also the thallome-forms originate at definite places
of the mother-axis; but still the places of origin of the
thallome-forms are common to several of them. Adven-
titious buds make their appearance besides the normal rami-
fications.

In the most highly differentiated terminal links of the series,
the Cladostephus-species, we finally see all these differen-
tiations of the thallome-forms constant, and their place of
origin definite. With the differentiation, also the variety of
the thallome-forms has increased. Normal ramifications and
adventitious buds, leaves and fruit-leaves, fruit-branches,
hairs aud root-threads, occur as completely individualised
and strictly distinct thallome-forms, and each of these
has its separate place of origin. In Cladostephus the normal
ramifications proceed from dichotomy of the apex, the
adventitious buds from the central cells of the axis, the
leaves from the oldest cortical cells, the fruit-leaves—that‘is
to say, a higher stage of the leaf-metamorphosis—from the
youngest cells of the cortex, the hairs from the apex of the
tip of the leaf, the fruit-branches from the joints of the
fruit-leaves.

ii. Cladostephus verticillatus is a perennial whose buds
possess a normal vegetation-pause, just like shrubs and trees.
It consists of a system of dichotomously branched stems
beset by numerous many-jointed whorls of leaves. The
stems and leaves grow by successive subdivisions of their
apical cells. By the division of these primary joint-cells
secondary joint-cells are formed by means of walls following
each other in definite sequence and direction; in this way
also the tissue of the joints is differentiated into medulla and
cortex.

In the production of branches by dichotomy the apical cell
is divided into three portions—two new apical cells and a
terminal portion of the old axis. A portion of the apical cell
is first cut off by a septum directed obliquely and laterally
from its apex. This newly formed cell is the mother-cell of
one of the commencing bifurcations. In the remaining por-

QUARTERLY CHRONICLE OF MICROSCOPICAL SCIENCE, 293

tion of the old apical cell a second septum originates vertical
to the first and directed to the opposite side; this forms the
mother-cell of the second bifurcation. The lower portion
remains the basis of the bifurcation, and afterwards, by cel-
lular increase, gives rise to a special portion of the divided
stem—the “ ramification-node.”

In Halopteris the apical cell produces, not branches exclu-
sively, but sometimes leaves, sometimes branches, according,
apparently, as the lateral septum cuts off a smaller or larger
portion of the apical cell. Here only a single new direc-
tion of growth takes place, only one septum is formed, the
old apical cell merely becomes deflected, but still remains as
apical cell.

The adventitious buds originate from the joints; the
quadrant-cell (‘innovation-cell” or “ brood-cell”) which is
to give rise to one does not form any cortical cells. In some
of the lower genera these adventitious buds show a regular
arrangement, but in Cladostephus this is not the case. The
connection of the medullary tissue in the stem and adven-
titious bud is produced by the first medullary cells within
the rudimentary adventitious buds reaching to the centre of
the stem, and appearing as lateral branches of the medullary
region of the stem. Hence there does not exist, as in the case
of dichotomy, any “ ramification-node” belonging in common
to both branches, but at the place of ramification a new first
joint belonging to the branch is laterally apposed to the stem-
joint.

The leaves in Cladostephus originate exclusively from the
peripheral cells of the joints. The first peripheral cells which
are produced are the mother-cells of the leaves and of the
cortex. These cells behave as apical cells, and are divided by
transverse septa. The first of the cells so formed give rise to
the primary cortex of the stem, and may be designated “ leaf-
bases ;” their upper divisions appear to form a transition
between cortex and leaf, and may be described as the “ basilar
node” of the leaf. Some cells of the basilar node may oc-
casionally grow out in a papilla-hike manner, and form a
second leaf. These may give rise to whorls of “ supple-
mentary leaves.” By repeated radial subdivisions of the
cortical cells of the joints in Cladostephus the origin of the
leaves becomes deeply immersed in secondary cortex. The
further growth of the leaves takes place by subdivisions of
primary cells produced by division of the apical cell. In the
immersed basilar joints the division of the secondary cells
for the formation of the cortical and medullary tissues are
analogous to those of the stems. In the free middle leaf-

294 QUARTERLY CHRONICLE OF MICROSCOPICAL SCIENCE.

joints the medulla becomes reduced to a single large cell.
The terminal joints become attenuated, and often spine-like ;
in other cases, however, they become cellular, or end club-
shaped. In the formation of the cortex of the leaf-jomts no
general rule prevails. The formation of “ hairs” is restricted
to the axil of the leaf-tip. The leaves of Cladostephus branch
by a division of the apical cell similar to that of the axis in
Halopteris.

Cladostephus possesses, besides vegetative ‘leaves,’ a
second form of leaves, or “ fruit-leaves.’ These were re-
garded by their first observers as a foreign epiphytic growth,
and described by them under the name of Sphacelaria
Bertiana. They originate only at the end of the period of
vegetation on the old joints, after all increase in the thick-
ness has completely ceased; their configuration is much
simpler than that of the foliage leaves. The outermost peri-
pheral cells of the internodes of the old joints are the
mother-cells of the fruit-leaves ; they grow out in a papilla-
like manner, and become the apical cells of these organs.
They ordinarily bear the sporangia on special “ fruit-
branches ;””? more rarely the apex of the fruit-leaf itself
becomes the fruit-branch. They are ramifications of the
undivided joint-cells, or, more usually, of the “ imnovation-
cells” of the lower and middle joints of the fruit-leaves.
These innovation-cells grow out laterally from the joints of the
fruit-leaf,and become the apical cells of the fruit-branches. The
number of their joints varies from one to eight. The resulting
uni- and multilocular sporangia are distributed on different
plants. The former are terminal, the apical cell increasing
in size, and its contents emerging en masse, enclosed in a
common mucus, presently breaking up into zoospores. The
supporting cell of the sporangium may continue growing
as a new apical cell, and thus the younger sporangia may
come to be surrounded by the empty coats of several older
sporangia. The multilocular sporangia are likewise terminal ;
the apical cell becomes divided into 3-5-celled series ; the
individual cells, by repeated vertical and horizontal divisions,
give rise to the mother-cells of the zoospores, one in each.
The zoospores are not emitted en masse, but each forms its
own mother-cell; they do not appreciably differ from those
of the other kind of sporangium, and resemble those of
other Pheosporee. They possess two cilia—one, the longer,
directed in front, the other behind.

About the end of November (at Genoa) the vegetation-
pause in Cladostephus commences. Some of the buds remain
dormant, and resume their growth the following year. This

QUARTERLY CHRONICLE OF MICROSCOPICAL SCIENCE. 295

may be effected by certain cells persisting as “ innovation-
cells,’ and growing into adventitious buds next year, or the
apical cell of the old bud continues unaltered during the
vegetation- pause to eventually resume its growth.

ili. Sphacelaria olivacea, Dillw., shows in the structure and
development of its stem and branches no essential differ-
entiation beyond that of size; the latter are, without excep-
tion, products of the joint-cells. The unilocular sporangia
occur on the smaller branches, whose terminal cells, as in
Cladostephus, swell up directly to form them ; the supporting
cell also grows through, but gives rise, not to a new spo-
rangium, but to anew branch. Besides these certain lateral
branches, shorter than the merely vegetative, modify their
terminal cell into globular sporangia, whose contents become
divided into cubical cells. Pringsheim has reason to think
that the zoospores in the unilocular sporangia arise in a
transitory cell-net. Hence he is led to the conclusion that
the difference between the two sporangial forms in the Phe-
osporeé is not an absolute one, but only expresses a different
degree of persistence in the mother-cell-tissue; consequently,
this second form of sporangia in S. olivacea may be com-
parable to multilocular sporangia. SS. olivacea would there-
fore seem to be a species in which the definitive separation
of the two sporangium forms is not yet fixed, but only about
to be originated.

Other asexual modes of increase occur. Amongst these
are the three-four-rayed gemme (Brutknospe). These, as
regards position, structure, and morphology, are manifestly
metamorphosed fruit-branches; they fall off, grow to new
plants, and are thus comparable to the gemmz of mosses and
liverworts. After separating from it, their supporting cell
grows out again, to produce a cell higher up than the last, a
new gemma.—W. ARCHER.

4, Batrachospermum.—Sirodot (‘Comptes Rendus,’ May
and June, 1873) finds that Chantransia is an asexual gene-
ration, which is developed from the sexually produced spores
of Batrachospermum.

5. Parasitic Alge.—Kny (‘Sitz. der Gesellsch. Natur.
Fr. zu Berlin, Nov., 1872) describes two additional instances
of algze with a parasitic habit. On examining, in September,
1872, at Heligoland, decayed specimens of Delesseria san-
guinea, of which the fronds had to a great extent decayed,
leaving only the midribs beset with adventitious sprouts, he
met with examples showing abnormal brown bands and spots.
On making thin superficial sections through these portions
he found that they were covered by an irregular network of

296 QUARTERLY CHRONICLE OF MICROSCOPICAL SCIENCE.

delicate-jointed branching filaments. From the examination
of transverse sections it was readily seen that the filaments
passed into the tissues of the Delesseria, penetrating the
cuticle, and pressing asunder the subjacent cells, thence
finding their way into the intercellular spaces.

Kny subsequently found similar filaments in the imterior
of other Floridee, as also in Laminaria saccharina. He
discovered no fructification, but the superficial filaments had
their parietal protoplasm tinged uniformly with a brownish-
yellow colouring material which in the internal filament was
granular. He supposed the plant to belong to the Pheo-
sporee.

In Polyides rotundus Kuy found red sterile filaments,
which he conjectured to belong to Floridee.—W. ARcHER.

II. Fungi.—1. Ancylistee, a new group of Phycomycetes.
—Pfitzer has described in great detail the life-history of
Ancylistes, a new aquatic parasite, and the type of a new
group, in the ‘ Monatsb. der Akad. der Wiss. zu Berlin,’
1872, p. 879. In August, 1871, he met with examples of
Closterium acerosum, Ehr., which appeared to have been to
a great extent killed by a parasite. In the spring of the
following year he was able to follow out its history. In the
interior of living Closteria, between the chlorophyll-plates,
were found from one to eight extremely slender, delicately
bounded cylindical and colourless bodies, of about 0-01 mm.
in thickness, permeating the cell from end to end. They
appeared to consist of plasma without a cell membrane, but
coutaining minute granules, which moved in various direc-
tions but without altermg the form of the plasma-mass.
Ultimately they acquired a cell-membrane, and were then
divided by septa into a number of longish cylindrical cells.
The infected individuals of Closteriwm at first retained much
of their ordinary appearance; the starch-granules, however,
first disappeared, and the death of the host-plant finally
ensued on the further development of the parasite. Each of
its constituent cells sent out from near one end a short blunt
process, which perforating the wall of the Closterium—mostly
on the same side—projected outwards as so many papille,
which eventually grew out into elongate hyphze, into which
by degrees the plasma passed. The hyphz were found, by
actual measurement, to exhibit an apical growth of ‘01 mm.
in a minute; very rarely they became branclied.

As soon as a hypha came in contact with a neigh-
bouring Closterium its apex became enlarged and firmly
attached. The plasma passed up into the enlarged apex,
which was once more, ewt” off by a septum from the

QUARTERLY CHRONICLE OF MICROSCOPICAL SCIENCE, 297

remaining portion of the hypha. In a few hours the para-
site began to perforate the membrane of the Closterium ;
this finally effected a thin process from the extremity of
the parasite passed into its cavity. A minute colourless,
gradually increasing globule terminated the filament, and
the plasma by degrees passed into it. Ultimately it sepa-
rated from the filament, elongated itself in the direction of
the axis of the Closterium, and in a few days grew into one
of the long cylindrical bodics described at the commence-
ment.

In addition to this alternation of vegetative generations
there occurred finally a sexual one. When the formation of
hyphz has gone on for some time, individual Closteria are
found to contain parasitic cells of two forms. One resembles
that of the divided cells already described, but somewhat
thicker; the others are at once distinguishable by being
considerably narrower. The Closterium now dies, and the
thinner cells contained in it send out towards their thicker
neighbours slender lateral processes, which sometimes
become septate. Resorption takes place where the hyphz
come in contact, and although a backward and forward move-
ment takes place between the plasma of the two connected
bodies, the aggregate mass is at last gradually retracted into
the larger cell, which is now, in fact, an oogonium. This
becomes somewhat inflated, and the contents retracted
from the wall and shut off by a septum at either end;
this process may be several times repeated, each time
the contracting contents leaving behind a septum, until
finally the oogonium consists of a nearly round central cell,
and two to four lateral cells containing fluid only. The
contents of the central cell again contract, and become sur-
rounded by a new wall or exosporium.— W. ArcHER.

2. New types allied to Chytridiee.—N. Sorokin has de-
scribed (‘ Bot. Zeit.,” 1874, May 15), from the neighbour-
hood of Kazan (Russia), two new and singular species closely
allied to Chytridiee. The first, Zygochytrium aurantiacum,
produced on dead insects in water an orange-red gelatinous
coating. This consisted of a mass of a fungoid plant of
great simplicity. A single tubular stem-cell was expanded
at its base into a lobed organ of attachment or foot, while it
divided above into two branches, each bearing an ovoid oper-
culate sporangial cell. Beneath each sporangium a short
bluntly pointed lateral branch—the “ appendix” —was given
off, but its function remained uncertain. The whole plant
was filled with golden-yellow protoplasm, containing vermi-
lion granules, and enclosed in a colourless membrane. In

298 QUARTERLY CHRONICLE OF MICROSCOPICAL SCIENCE,

the formation of zoospores the protoplasmic mass became
contracted towards the upper part of the sporangium, the
operculum was thrown off, and the protoplasmic mass was
discharged as a rounded naked body, which in about fifteen
minutes became coated with a delicate cell-wall. The red
granules were first collected towards its centre, but were
subsequently equally distributed, and the protoplasm sub-
divided into individualised portions, each containing a
granule, and which were finally set free as rapidly moving,
zoospores with a posterior cilium. The zoospores ceased to
move, became amoeboid, the cilium was drawn in, and the
zoospore in a few minutes began to germinate. This was
effected by its elongating into a tube, developing a foot at
one end and dichotomously branching at the other. Besides
the production of zoospores, zygospores, of a blood-red
colour, very thick-walled and covered by irregular protuber-
ances, were formed by the conjugation of two horizontal
lateral branches thrown out from the two ramifications of
the plant. These germinated very readily.

A second nearly related form (Tetrachytrium triceps) was
found on various submerged objects, with cell-contents of a
greyish-blue. The stem-cell was also furnished with a foot,
and divided above into three branches, each bearing an oper-
culate zoosporangium, and beneath them an involuted “ ap-
pendix.” The zoosporangium discharged its protoplasmic
contents as before, but then separated into only four por-
tions, which were ultimately set free by the rupture of the
mother-cell-wall, as four blue-coloured bodies with a median
clear spot. They did not exhibit any amceboid movements
on coming to rest, but conjugated in pairs. Zoospores, which
were unable to conjugate, never germinated, but the zygo-
spores readily germinated, reproducing the plant with its
triple branches and “‘ appendix.”

These two ofganisms appear to differ from Chytridiee, on
the one hand, in the presence of zygospores in Zygochytrium,
and the conjugation of the zoospores in Tetrachytrium.
The author considers that these new types may form a
special natural group, with Chytridiee, Ancylistee, Sapro-.
legniee, Zygomycetes (Mucorini), and Peronosporee, for
which he proposes the name S1pHomyceres. Of this group,
Amebidium, Cienk., may be regarded as the simplest form
(‘ Bot. Zeit.,” 1861, p. 169).

The author announces his intention of describing the
whole group in a forthcoming work, which microscopists
will be glad to know is almost completed W. Arcuer.

3. Hemileia.—The Ceylon Coffee Fungus.—Owing to the

QUARTERLY CHRONICLE OF MICROSCOPICAL SCIENCE. 299

misapprehension which still largely exists as to the real
nature of the coffee leaf disease (Hemileia vastatrix), and the
erroneous views and wild conjectures propagated respecting
it, I feel that it is desirable I should again offer some obser-
vations on the subject. The disease consists in the parasitic
growth within the coffee-tree of a well-defined species of
fungus, originated and reproduced by means of spores, easily
identified by employment of the microscope, and thus readily
distinguishable from every other known fungus. There can
be no question that this fungus is communicated from coffee
plant to coffee plant through dissemination of the spores,
and that it may be conveyed by the wind, or by streams of
water, or by animals of any kind moving from place to place.
The fungus has only yet been detected, in a definitely organ-
ised form, in the cellular tissue of the coffee leaf, lying
immediately under the diseased spots, in the spores them-
selves, and in the filaments produced by the germinating
spores. The fungus would appear, however, to be present in
the growing tissues generally of the coffee plant in a diffused
form, altering the character of the cell-contents, and thus
producing the stains observable on the bark of the young
branches, and the pale somewhat translucent spots to be seen
in the leaves previously to the outbreak of the orange-coloured
spores.

Investigations with the microscope with reference to the
germination of the fungus spores have been made by my
friend, the Rev. R. Abbay, and by myself. The process has
been observed by both of us. Mature spores removed from
a diseased coffee leaf and laid upon charcoal kept constantly
moist, commence to germinate in a few days. ‘The germi-
nation consists in the spore becoming somewhat enlarged,
and its contents converted into one or more globular trans-
lucent masses. From each of the latter a filament is de-
veloped, which grows very rapidly, and becomes more or less
branched. At the termination of some of these branches
secondary spores are produced in the form of radiating
necklace-shaped strings of little spherical bodies of uniform
size, and this form closely resembles the fructification of an
Aspergillus. Mr. Abbay has also observed another form of
secondary spores arranged in single rows of spherical bodies,
a good deal larger than those radiately arranged, but still
exceedingly minute. These inconceivably numerous second-
ary spores may be easily carried by the wind into sur-
rounding districts, and thus convey infection to distant
plantations.

The effect of the fungus upon the coffee-tree would seem

VOL. XIV.—NEW SER, U

800 QUARTERLY CHRONICLE OF MICROSCOPICAL SCIENCE.

to be the gradual loss of vital energy. The tree, after the
first attack of the disease, which is often apparently the
most severe, throws out fresh healthy-looking leaves, and
exhibits for a certain period the appearance of having per-
fectly recovered. These fresh leaves, however, after the
expiration of a few months, exhibit the characteristic spot-
ting, and, as on the previous attack, fall prematurely. These
repeated attacks occurring periodically, at length seriously
affect the health of the tree if old and ill-cultivated, and it be-
comes of little or no value asa crop-producer. There is great
reason to believe, however, from what has been observed, that
high cultivation, with judicious manuring, enables the tree
to better sustain the attacks of the fungus, and to retain
strength and vigour enough to produce a fair yield of berry.
It is indeed ardently to be hoped that this beneficial effect
will be permanent. .

Whether each outburst of the disease implies a fresh in-
troduction of the parasite into the coffee plant, or merely
a periodical spore production of a permanent parasitism,
remains to be discovered. It is just possible to imagine
some subtle destructive agency operating, in addition to the
little red maggot which feeds on the spores, to arrest the
development of the fungus, but there is nothing to support
such a view at present.—From Dr. Thwaites’ Annual Report
of the Peradeniya Botanic Gardens.

4, Hetercecism.—Dr. Wolff announces that Peridermium
Pini, Lév., is the zcidiosporous state of Coleosporium Com-
positarum, Lév., forma Senecionis (‘ Bot. Zeit.,’ 1874, p. 184).

5. Development of the Rye-Smut, Urocystis occulta, Rabh.—
Dr. Reinhold Wolff gives an elaborate paper on this subject,
illustrated by a plate, in the Botanische Zeitung, for Oct.
17-31, 1873. The species is known in Europe only as a
parasite on the rye (but in Australia occurs also on the
wheat), penetrating into the cellular tissue of the leaf, leaf-
sheath and culm, between the vascular bundles. (Cooke,
however, states that it occurs also on the leaves of Carex.)
The spores are generally collected in groups, with other
smaller spore-like bodies attached to them, but are occasion-
ally found simply without any of these appendages, and can
then only be recognised after germination. Germination
takes place after three or four days, the pro-mycelium filled
with five grained protoplasm bursting through the epispore,
and forming at its extremity, by a peculiar process of
division, from two to six ‘‘sporidia,” about equal in length
to the pro-mycelium, which then become separated from it
by a septum after all the protoplasmic contents of the pro-

QUARTERLY CHRONICLE OF MICROSCOPICAL SCIENCE, 301

mycelium have passed into them. From these sporidia
(before they have become separated from the pro-mycelium)
the elongated germinating filaments are developed, the pro-
toplasm gradually accumulating towards the growing apex,
which becomes separated by a septum from the posterior
part. Both sporidia and germinating filaments have the
power of penetrating the epidermis to reach the cellular
tissue of the host. But when the apex of the filament has
penetrated into the interior of a cell, it does not grow free in
its cavity, but becomes enclosed by the inner layers of the
cell-wall as by a sheath. This sheath shows the ordinary
reaction of cellulose, and can often only be recognised by
treating the preparation with potash, covering, as it does, every
branch of the germinating filament of the parasite as it ramifies.
The mycelium of the Urocystis takes from eight to ten
weeks to become fully developed. The ends of the filaments
then swell greatly, and become filled with protoplasm, but
without dividing, the terminal portions of several filaments
become closely attached to one another, and form a kind of
ball which gradually becomes uniformly filled with a fine-
grained protoplasm, containing drops of oil, and enveloped
in a membrane. This ball finally develops into the group
of spores with its peculiar spore-like appendages, which
appear to be the detached apices of other filaments of the
mycelium.—A. W. Brenner.

6. Penicillium glaucum.—Brefeld gives in ‘ Flora,’ 1873,
p. 331, a short account of the results, fuller detailed in his
recently published memoir on this “ asexually propagated
form of a hitherto unknown species of the group of Asco-
my cetes.”

Mucor racemosus and Yeast.— Brefeld contributes to
‘Flora’ (1873, p. 385) a paper on this subject, with some
remarks on the systematic arrangement of Fungi.

7. Protomyces microsporus, Ung.—In the ‘ Botanische
Zeitung’ for February De Bary describes in detail the
history of this species. Protomyces macrosporus, Ung.,
remains the type of a family of doubtful affinity, but P.
microsporus, now Entyloma Ungerianum, De Bary, is shown
to be clearly entitled to a place amongst Ustilaginee.

III. Lichens.—The literature of the lichen-question has
been fully noticed in this Journal. Bornet has added an addi-
tional confirmation to the theory which daily gains ground in
a note (‘ Ann. des Sc. Nat.,’ 5e sér., xix, p. 314), in which he
announces that he has met with cases in which T’rentepohlia
(Chroolepus, Auct.), which constitutes the gonidia of Ope-
grapha, has emerged from the lichen, resumed its normal

302 QUARTERLY CHRONICLE OF MICROSCOPICAL SCIENCE,

structure, and produced sporangia from which zoospores
were discharged. He has also met with cases in which
Collema produced young individuals of Nostoc by a kind of
pullulation.

IV. Hepatice.— Kienitz-Gerloff has published (‘ Bot.
Zeit.,’ March'and April, 1874) the result of his studies in the
development of the sporogonium of Riccia, Marchantia,
Preissia, Pellia, Metzgeria, Frullania, Radula, Liochlena,
Lepidozia, Jungermannia, and Calypogeia.

V. Marattiacee.— 1. Angiopteris. —Tchistiakoff has re-
published (‘ Ann. des Sc. Nat., 5e sér., xix, p. 219) an
elaborate memoir originally printed in Russian on the
development of the sporangia and spores of Angiopteris.
The purport of the research is rather to throw light on the
general theory of the vegetable cell. The detailed obser-
vations differ in some respects from those of Luerssen and
Russow. The theoretical considerations are in harmony with
those of Brucke and Hanstein in regarding the protoplasm
as an organism inferior to an amoeba because deprived of its
individualisation. The nucleus and nucleolus are regarded
as structures brought about by the equilibrium of forces to
which the protoplasm is exposed, and are therefore by no
means characteristic of it in its most active condition.

2. Scolecopteris—E. Strasburger describes in the ‘ Jen-
aische Zeitschrift ? (1874, pp. 81-95) the structure (especially
of the sporangia) of Scolecopteris elegans, Zenk., a species
of Marattiacee from the Permian of Chemnitz. The details
were perfectly preserved in chalcedony, which allowed admi-
rable sections to be studied. In an additional plate he
figures the structure of the sori of Angiopteris evecta, and
Marattia Kaulfussii.

VI. Lycopodiacee.— Asterophyllites.— Prof. Williamson
has described the histology of this very remarkable extinct
type in an elaborate memoir (‘ Phil. Trans.,’ 1874, pp. 41—
81) with illustrative plates.

The Oldham form in its youngest state first appears as a
mere twig, having a central vascular axis enclosed in a
cortex. The vascular axis consists of reticulated vessels ;
its transverse section is triangular. The cortex consists of
an outer prosenchymatous (sclerenchyma?) and an inner
parenchymatous layer. As the plant grew successive vas-
cular layers appear to have been added to the exterior of the
vascular axis. In the Burntisland type the features were
essentially the same, but the vessels were barred and not
reticulate. The fructification already described by the
author as Volkmannia Dawsoni is now regarded by him as

QUARTERLY CHRONICLE OF MICROSCOPICAL SCIENCE, 303

belonging to Asterophyllites, and he suggests that the curious
spinous bodies from the coal measures described by Mr.
Carruthers as a carboniferous type of Radiolarians may be the
spores of this plant. The Volkmannia Binneyi of Carruthers,
who with Binney and Schimper had referred it to Calamites,
Williamson supposes also to belong to a species of Astero-
phylhtes. Carruthers has described the spores as furnished
with elaters, which was a strong point in favour of their
equisetaceous aflinity, but Williamson “ rejects this interpre-
tation, regarding the so-called elaters as merely the torn
fragments of the ruptured mother-cells in which the true
spores have been developed.” Asterophyllites appears,
therefore, to belong to an extinct type of Lycopodiacee, its
axial structures having some points in resemblance with the
existing Psilotum triquetrum.

VII. Phanerogams.—1. Trichomes.—Oscar Uhlworm in a
series of papers in the last four numbers of the ‘ Botanische
Zeitung ’ for 1873 discusses the development of Trichomes
especially in reference to the formation of prickles,

2. Lenticels—kKH. Stahl describes the development and
anatomy of lenticels (‘ Bot. Zeit.,’ 1873, 577, 593, 609).

3. Chlorophyll.—i. G. Briosi describes the normal forma-
tion of fatty matter in chlorophyll (‘ Bot. Zeit.,’ 1873, 545).
ii. Prillieux (‘ Ann. des Sc. Nat.,’ 5e sér., xix, 108) has care-
fully studied the curious observation first made by Wiesner
that Neotiia Nidus-avis becomes green on immersion in
alcohol, and afterwards communicates its colour to the
liquid. He finds that the brown colour of the plant is due to
erystalloids or minute corpuscles with a crystalline figure,
which they, however, lose in consequence of swelling when
the composition of the cell-sap is notably altered. When
these crystalloids are treated with alcohol or acids or the
plant is immersed in boiling water, they become green by
the production of chlorophyll. Prillieux, however, alto-
gether doubts whether this chlorophyll is present in the
crystalloids previously in a disguised state, and finds no
reason for believing that it performs any physiological
role.

4. Crystals in Cells.—Vesque (‘ Ann. des Sc. Nat.,’ 5e sér.,
xix, 310) has succeeded in reproducing some of the forms
of calcium oxalate met with in plants. In a 5 per cent.
solution of glucose and a 2 per cent. solution of dextrine he
obtained raphides, while in acid solutions he obtained simple
oblique prisms.

5. Parasites—Count Solms-Laubach describes in the
‘ Botanische Zeitung’ for January the ‘ thallus’ of Pilostyles

304 QUARTERLY CHRONICLE OF MICROSCOPICAL SCIENCE,

Haussknechtii, Boiss, a small Rafflesiaceous parasite which
lives upon species of Astragalus in Syria and Kurdistan.

6. Ramification and Partition of Punctum Vegetationis.—
i. Warming has published an elaborate memoir on this
subject with eleven plates and a French résumé (‘ Vid. Selsk.
Skr’? 5 R. Naturv. Math. Afd., 10 Bd.). The punctum
vegetationis is that region the special function of the cells
of which is to furnish new cells to the plant or its
organs. It, therefore, does not include regions the func-
tions of whose cells is the genesis of lateral organs, or of
particular tissues in the interior of organs. The terminal
cells (‘ schietelzellen”), or homologous groups of cells, are
therefore the puncta vegetations of Cryptogams, and the
group of apical cells discovered by Hanstein in Phanerogams
(“ scheitelzellgruppe ”’) 1s equivalent. Defined in this sense
the inferior limit of the region will somewhat vary. If it is
held to be limited by the uppermost cell of the procambium,
it may be found below the highest lateral structures of the
stem, especially if these happen to be buds without subtend-
ing leaves.

Warming’s investigations on the histology of the summit
of the stem quite confirm those of Hanstein. In all the
phanerogamic plants which he has examined he found it
covered with a layer of dermatogen divided usually only by
radial partitions and sharply defined on its inner contour.
A single terminal cell never occurs even in Utricularia com-
parable with that of Cryptogams. Of the three systems
of meristem in the stem the dermatogen is the most con-
stant and the best characterised ; it is never absent even when
the periblem and plerome are undifferentiated. Generally
speaking, the dermatogen covers a more or less regular
cellular tissue. Immediately beneath it are 1-7 layers of peri-
blem which cover the top of the stem like a sheath, and of
which the cells are usually divided by radiating partitions.
Below these layers the stem is ordinarily composed of plerome
—the mother-meristem of the fibro-vascular system and the
pith—the cells of which are usually arranged more or less
vertically and regularly. Warming has not succeeded in de-
tecting in the different layers of periblem the cell, or group
of cells,which might be regarded as the punctum vegetationis of
each layer. But the series of cells of the plerome terminate
above by a group of cells segmented in all directions and
forming a tissue more or lessirregular. This “ initial group”
of the plerome may even consist of a small number of cells
arranged with great regularity or (as in the peculiar shoots
of Utricularia studied by Pringsheim) of a single cell, but

Oo

QUARTERLY CHRONICLE OF MICROSCOPICAL SCIENCE. 305

there appears to be no reason for accepting with Sanio the
existence of a terminal cell to the plerome segmented after
the fashion of the terminal cell in Cryptogams.

In many cases the essential distinction between periblem
and plerome cannot be recognised. The external layers of
periblem give origin, in all cases, to the phyllomes. According
to Hanstein, they originate in the second, third, and fourth
layers, but Warming considers that it is only exceptionally that
the first layer does not also take part, especially in the case
of floral leaves, and that in some cases this is the only one
that is active. The dermatogen also plays an essential part
in the formation of leaves, especially the floral; in many
cases the bracts, stipules, and bud-scales consist principally of
epidermis.

Hofmeister appears to have been wrong in supposing that
buds are always formed on the summit of the stem. Usually
vegetative buds envelope after their subtending leaf; in
Aisculus, Syringa, etc., it is easy to show that there are 1-4
pairs of leaves above those of the axils, of which the first
segmentations for the formation of a bud have taken place.
In the case of inflorescences the highest new structure de-
veloped from the stem is frequently a bud, which may arise
before, simultaneously with, or after its subtending leaf, or
without there ever being even a trace of this as inCrucifere and
Composite. The question then arises whether these buds—
originating, as they do, on the summit of the stem—are to
be considered as formed by a partition of the punctum vege-
tationis. Generally speaking, however, especially when the
apex of the stem is very conical, it is easy to make out that
the buds which originate at the base of the cone are below the
group of apical cells, forming the true punctum vegetationis
(as in Composite). In asmall number of cases buds originate
so near the actual summit of the stem that the peripheral
cells of the punctum vegetationis actually do take part in their
formation.

In some such cases there is a true dichotomy of the
vegetative point ; its cells divide into two or more groups, and
each of these becomes a point of departure for a new forma-
tion of buds. This has been ascertained in Hydrocharis and
Vallisneria, in the ramification of the tendrils and less dis-
tinctly of the principal axis of Vitis vulpina, in the inflores-
cences of Aslepiadacee, in the scorpioid cymes of Hyoscyamus
and Borraginucee, and in some other cases.

Ramification by partition of the punctum vegetationis and
by the formation of lateral branches have been regarded as
very different modes. Warming considers them as not

306 QUARTERLY CHRONICLE OF MICROSCOPICAL SCIENCE.

essentially distinct. In the vegetative part of the stem the
formation of the leaves is the main object, aud the buds do
not arise till they have acquired a considerable size. In the
region of inflorescence the formation of buds becomes of
primary importance; they increase in vigour and gradually
advance from a lateral position to a position on the summit
of the stem near the median line.

It has been supposed that abuormal formations such as
fasciations are due to a partition of the punctum vegetationis.
Warming, therefore, studied the development of Celosia
cristata and of Brassica oleracea var. botrytis. The first
developes its inflorescence like a Composite, with the only dif-
ference that its receptacle is irregular and compressed, and
the second by avery rapid formation of buds. But in neither
was there any trace of a partition of the vegetative point.

The distinction of phyllomes from caulomes by morpho-
logically and genetically distinct characters is impossible.
They both arise from the peripheral tissues at a depth which.
varies with the size they subsequently attain; thus bracts
arise very often in the first layer of the periblem, while caulomes
hardly ever do so, but most usually in the third or fourth
layers. A distinctive character, perhaps, consists in the fact
that in the centre of phyllomes procambium cells originate
very rapidly, and the tissue is consequently far from offering
the same regularity as the plerome of young caulomes.

The majority of buds are axillary; this is so uniform
that it has been regarded as the only normal one, and has
led to the supposition that the buds in all ebracteate inflores-
cences arise from a partition of the punctum vegetationis.
The causal nexus between the leaf and its axillary bud at
present remains unexplained. In their origin they are
always united at their base, and they may be, perhaps,
regarded as forming a whole of which the two constituent
portions have a different morphological character according
to the role which they have to fill; it is sometimes one, some-
times the other part of the double organ which is developed,
while in other cases both are in equilibrium.

7. Perigynium of Carex.—Dr. McNab and W. T. Thiselton
Dyer contribute observations on this structure to the
‘Journ. Linn. Soc.,’ xiv, 152 and 154, which appear to
prove that it is a foliar organ, consisting of a bract alter-
nating with that which subtends the whole flower.

8. Development of Buds of Malaxis.—Prof. Dickie describes
in the ‘Journ. Linn. Soc., xiv, 180—182, the develop-
ment of the buds on the leaves of Malaxis. ‘The bodies in
question agree with the ovule in this: the nucleus appears

QUARTERLY CHRONICLE OF MICROSCOPICAL SCIENCE. 307

first, and the coat next in order—both, however, being pro-
duced by differentiation from the same mass of parenchyma.”
It is difficult to accept this view—unsupported as it is by
similar facts—without further investigation.

9. Ovule and Seed.—i. In an elaborate paper (‘ Ann. des
Se. Nat.,’ 5 sér., xix, 5) on the development of these structures
in Schrophulariacee, Solanacee, Boraginacee, and Labiate,
Chatin appears to have arrived at no general result of import-
ance. He congratulates himself on having seen a pollen tube
enter the micropyle of Veronica Chamedrys. Schacht long
ago pointed out that this phenomenon might generally be
demonstrated in V. serpyllifolia, when the corolla had just
fallen.

ii. Dr. Hooker, in a paper in the ‘ Journ. Linn. Soc.,’ xiv,
182-188, identifies the Hydnora americana of R. Brown
with De Bary’s Prosopanche. He confirms De Bary’s
observation of the ovules being actually buried in and con-
fluent with the placental tissues.

ii. According to Warming (l.c., xviand xxxv) ovules
are most frequently metamorphosed caulomes. They origi-
nate beneath the first layer (Huphorbia, Scrophularia) of the
periblem, sometimes in this layer itself (Ranunculus acris),
or as buds on the base of foliar organs (Salix). The in-
teguments of Euphorbia originate in a great measure in the
dermatogen. Warming regards these as phyllomes and the
nucleus as a caulome. The embryo-sac is sometimes formed
of acell of the first layer of periblem (Scrophularia.) - In
Luphorbia it appears to originate from the second layer.

PROCEEDINGS OF SOCIETIES.

Royat Mtcroscopicat Soctery.
February 4th, 1874.

Tats being the Annual General Meeting, the Officers and
Council for the ensuing year were elected as follows, viz.—

President.—Charles Brooke, M.A., F.R.S.

Vice-Presidents. — Robert Braithwaite, M.D., F.L.S.; John
Miller, L.R.C.P., F.L.S.; Wiliam Kitchen Parker, F.R.S.; Francis
H. Wenham, C.E,

Treasurer.—Jotn Ware Stephenson, F.R.A.S.

Secretaries.—Henry J. Slack, F.G.8.; Charles Stewart, M.R.C.S.,
F.LS.

Council—James Bell, F.C.S.; Frank Crisp, LL.B. B.A.;
William J. Gray, M.D.; John E. Ingpen, Esq.; Samuel J. McIntire,
Esq.; Henry Lee, F.L.S.; Wilham T. Loy, Esq. ; Henry Lawson,
M.D.; Henry Perigal, F.R.A.S.; Alfred Saunders, M.R.C.S.;
Charles Tyler, F.L.S.; Thomas C. White, M.R.C.S.

The Aunual Report of the Society was read, from which it
appeared that nine Fellows had been elected during the past year,
and five had died during the same period. Among the latter was
Mr. Cornelius Varley, one of the founders of the Society, and, like
his distinguished brother John Varley, well known as a water. -
colour painter. He contributed several papers to the ‘ Transactions’
of the Society, and invented many improvements in the microscope.
Mr. Varley died in his ninety-second year.

A new bye-law relating to the election of Corresponding Fellows
was proposed and passed.

The President then delivered the annual address.

He stated that renewed application had been made to the Govern-
ment for accommodation for the Society in Burlington House,
but that the matter was still under consideration.

The President referred to some of the papers which had been
published in the Journal of the Society, especially one by Dr.
Pritchard, on the cochlea, read before the Medical Microscopical
Society ; Mr. Wenham’s on a new formula for an object-glass, and
some contributions by Dr. Royston-Pigott.

The President, having filled the office of scientific juror at the
Vienna Exhibition, spoke of some of the microscopes and objectives
there exhibited, singling out those of Hartnack for special com-

ROAYL MICROSCOPICAL SOCIETY. 3809

mendation, while others by Gundlach and Nachet were also
described as good. None by English makers had come under his
notice.

March 4th, 1874.
Cares Brooks, Esq., F.R.S., President, in the chair.

Mr. Alfred Saunders read a paper entitled ‘A Contribution
towards a Knowledge of Appendicularia,” in which he minutely
described the appearance and structure of specimens found at
Torquay and Weymouth. A paper by Dr. Royston-Pigott, F.R.S.,
entitled ‘‘ A Note on the Verification of Structure by the Motion of
Compressed Fluid,’’ and another by the same author on ‘‘ A Note on
the President’s Remarks on Dr. Pigott’s Searcher for Aplanatic
Images,”’ were read.

The first paper gave an account of some appearances produced
in the “ beads”’ and other minute structures of certain microscopic
objects by the movements and currents in the fluid produced by
pressure applied to the covering glass. The objects were immersed
in various fluids, such as Rangoon oil, glycerine containing
chloride of gold in solution, &c., and pressure applied by the
direct contact of the objective (a 4 or 4) with the cover glass.
The method was chiefly applied to determine certain points in the
structure of the Podura scale.

In his second paper Dr. Pigott gave an explanation of his

‘aplanatic searcher,’ which he defined as being a new expedient for
balancing spherical and chromatic aberration, being on a large
scale precisely what the adjusting screw collar of an objective is on
a minute scale. The collar separates the front lens by thousandths
of an inch. The searcher traverses inches.

April \st, 1874.
F. H. Wennam, Esq., Vice-President, in the chair.

A paper by Dr. Anthony, ‘On the Structure of a Lepisma
Scale,’’ was read by the Secretary, Xc.

Mr. Wenham made a communication on an instrument for
excluding extraneous rays in measuring apertures of microscope
object-glasses, and demonstrated his method to the Society.

Mr. S. J. McIntire read a ‘Note on a curious proboscis of an
unknown Moth.” ‘The proboscis ended in a hard chitinous point,
and was furnished with several formidable recurved spines, so as to
be fitted, apparently, both for penetration and retention. The spe-
cimen came from Western Africa.

A “scientific evening’’ was held on April 15th, in the great
Hall of King’s College, when a number of iuteresting objects were
exhibited.

310 PROCEEDINGS OF SOCIETIES,

Mepricat MicroscopicaL Socrery.

20th March, 1874.

Staining with Aniline Dyes for Balsam Mounting.—Mr. George
Gibbs read a paper on this subject, which he was first led to study
from reading the following passage in Frey’s ‘The Microscope :’
—<“ It is very unfortunate that alcohol soon extracts the colour [of
aniline red], so that it is impossible to preserve the specimen in
Canada balsain.”

To obviate this inconvenience he tried a 2 per cent. solution of
aniline in spirit, and then found that by staining sections that
had been in spirit with this solution for three or four minutes,
rinsing in spirit, and placing subsequently in oil of cloves, the
colour was perfectly preserved when the specimen was mounted
in Canada balsam.

Oil of cloves was preferable to turpentine, the latter at times
precipitating the colouring matter; but should this occur, brush-
ing with a camel’s hair pencil would remove the deposit. Mr.
Gibbs claimed three advantages for this method:—lst. Its
cleanliness. 2nd. That one has the most perfect control over the
depth of colour obtained by regulating the time of the subsequent
washing in spirit. 3rd. That the colour is less trying to the eyes
than that of carmine. Its selective power was greater than that
of Frey’s aqueous solution of aniline, the nerve-fibres of the
spinal cord as well as the nuclei of cells being vividly brought
out.

Staining with Picro-carminate of Ammonia.—The Secretary read
Dr. E. Cresswell Baber’s paper upon this subject, which is pub-—
lished in extenso in the present number of the Journal.

Dr. Matthews remarked that some tissues attract-red rather
than purple colours; thus nuclei generally were more easily
stained by the former. Judson’s dyes he had found useful.
Referred to Frei’s methods if employing pico-carmine; had ob-
tained good results from first staining in carmine, and subse-
quently in a solution of picric acid. He had found Stevens’
writing fluid a ready and useful stain for sections.

Mr. White had found a section of epithelioma stained with
logwood, and then with picric acid, showed the yellow centres of
the “ birds’ nests” described by Mr. Baber, while the surrounding
parts were tinted by the hematoxylin. Had only used carmine
and picric acid as separate solutions, but by this means had seen
yellow channels of communication from one bird’s nest to
another.

Mr. Kesteven asked if aniline dyes were permanent.

Mr. Atkinson found that crystallized magenta, when first used
for staining sections became blue, and then after a time disap-

MEDICAL MICROSCOPICAL SOCIETY. SII

peared ; but mounting in one third per cent. of corrosive sublimate
prevented this.

_ Mr, Schafer had given up carmine because of its too brilliant
colour, and always used logwood, which he found selective in pro-
perty. He thought osmic acid better than picric carmine for
nerve-tissues, and remarked that Dr. Sharpey had long ago used
magenta for staining the axis cylinders of nerves.

Mr. Miller had found a solution of carmine and a 1 per cent.
solution of picric acid in alcohol and water especially good for
splenic and unstriped muscular fibres. He preferred carmine to
logwood.

Mr. Groves, except in the case of nerve-structures, preferred
logwood to carmine. The double staining of logwood and gold
chloride was good for nerves and nuclei, and especially for such
structures as frog’s bladder.

Mr. Golding Bird mentioned Dr. Moxon’s use of Stevens's
writing fluid for staining nerve-structures, and mentioned a fact
communicated to him by Dr. Malassez, of Paris, that aniline dis-
solved in spirit was especially good for studying ossification of
cartilage ; for it stained the cartilage but not the newly formed
bone, while an aqueous solution of aniline stained the canaliculi
and not the bone substance, but was not permanent like the
alcoholic solution.

The President, in proposing a vote of thanks to the authors of
the papers, which was duly accorded, remarked that more in-
vestigation was required on the subject of staining fluids, and
recommended it as an object of special study that would certainly
be productive of useful results.

Miliary Sclerosis. — Mr. W. B. Kesteven read a _ paper
upon a form of grey degeneration occurring in the brain and
spinal cord, and designated by Drs. Batty Tuke and Rutherford,
“miliary sclerosis.” The author showed examples of this lesion
by sections and drawings. ‘The change is associated with a wide
range of diseases of the nervous centres. He enumerated as
many as twenty morbid conditions in which he had met with the
so-called miliary sclerosis, The essential characters of this lesion
Mr. Kesteven showed to consist in the absence, in circumscribed
patches, of the normal nerve-tissue, and its replacement by an
altered and degenerate state of the neuroglia. The spots vary in
size from =5th in. to =45th in. in diameter. Their physical cha-
racters were described in detail, and the author then proceeds to
discuss the question of how this character was connected with
previous symptoms, and whether it is possible that they could be
the result of mere post-mortem changes. These questions, he
submitted, were as yet unanswered. Judging from the great
diversity of pathological conditions in which this degeneration is
‘met with, he deemed the solution of the problem impossible, with
our present amount of knowledge in neuro-pathology.

Dr. Payne asked whether Mr. Kesteven had found miliary

312 PROCEEDINGS OF SOCIETIES.

sclerosis in a spinal cord or brain otherwise quite healthy, and
discussed the question as to whether the changes described might
not be the commencement of secondary degenerations of nerves,
as is seen to result from inactivity of a nerve arising from any
cause, or of the wasting of certain nerye-fibres, that might go on
to worse changes.

Mr. Schafer took exception to the name as giving the idea of
fibrous or cicatricial tissue, whereas what had been deseribed was
rather colloid in nature, for at times it could be stained intensely.
He had seen miliary sclerosis in the brain of a supposed healthy
dog that had been hardened in chromic acid, and from this he
concluded that the alcohol used to prepare the specimens could
not be the cause of the “sclerosis,” as had been alleged, seeing
that he had used none. As the disease followed no special tracts
he considered it could not be simply degeneration of nerve-
fibres.

Dr. Matthews asked whether coincident disease—as atheroma—
of the vessels of the brain had been noticed.

The President had seen miliary sclerosis accompanied by cal-
careous change in the vessels, and in a case where death resulted
from cerebral hemorrhage ; also in preparations of brain made by
Dr. Crisp from the lower animals, and hardened in chromic
acid. !

Mr. Kesteven, in reply, considered the term sclerosis certainly
more applicable to the cases where the disease occurs en plaques.
There was nothing of fibrous nature in the condition he had been
describing ; still, Dr. Tuke had given the name originally. He
did not consider the alteration colloid, though at first sight re-
sembling it; nor had he noticed the change in connection with
atheromatous vessels, though at times the bodies described were
calcareous and gritty (“ brainsand”). Agreed with Mr. Schafer
in not considering the condition as one of nerve-fibre degeneration,
and was, in fact, still seeking an explanation.

18th April, 1874.

Diphtheria— Dr. Greenfield read a paper which was founded upon
the microscopical examination of specimens from five cases of diph-
theria, and was illustrated by preparations. The author, in remark-
ing upon the obscurity and doubt which still seemed to exist upon
the origin and structure of the diphtheritic false membrane, stated
his belief that this arose in part from the confusion in the
nomenclature in common use, especially the fact that ‘ croupous’
and ‘diphtheritic’ were terms used in diflereut senses, clinically
and histologically.

An examination of his cases showed in all, in the larynx and
trachea, the mucous membrane surrounding the deeper tissues in
a state of more or less intense inflammation of ordinary character,
whilst the false membrane consisted for the most part of a

MEDICAL MICROSCOPICAL SOCIETY. 313

stratified network of a substance giving the reactions of fibrin, in
the meshes of which were contained altered epithelial cells and
corpuscles.

The amount of adhesion to the mucous membrane was various,
but in no case did the exudation actually pass into its substance,
although in some cases it appeared adherent by fibrinous bands to
the papille.

After describing the views of Wagner and of other German
pathologists, the author stated his belief that the false mem-
brane consisted in part of a catarrhal process with modifications
in the epithelium, and in part of a true fibrinous exudation.
These views were supported by the comparative examination of
specimens taken from cases in various stages.

In the pharynx the inflammatory process was stated to extend
much deeper than in the trachea, and to be accompanied by a
more rapid destruction of tissue. The false membrane was
believed to consist in a larger measure of altered cells.

The question of the occurrence and importance of fungous
growth in the mucous membrane was then described, and the
author showed specimens from the pharynx containing numbers
of minute fungus spores and a delicate mycelium deeply pene-
trating the inflamed mucous membrane. He had not, however,
been able to find any similar appearance in the larynx or trachea
of the same or other cases, and he considered it, therefore, still
an open question how far the fungus was an accidental occurrence,
and what was its relation to the disease.

The President, after proposing a vote of thanks to the author
of the paper, stated his belief that fungous growths might be
always found in the mucous membranes in certain low states of
health, and considered a fungus in diphtheria an accidental rather
than an essential occurrence. He could not agree with Dr.
Oscar, who held that the disease was owing to the presence of
fungus. He had examined more than one case of diphtheritic
conjunctivitis, in which disease the exudation forms very rapidly,
but had never found any fungus. The position of a vegetable
parasite upon the body had much to do with its influence upon
the disease it accompanied or of which it was the cause ; hence
some importance might be attached to the specimen shown, where
the fungus was deep in the inflamed mucous membrane.

Dr. Bruce remarked that croup is generally defined as owing
to a false membrane, on the removal of which healthy mucous
membrane is left; this, however, the paper would disprove, since
Dr. Greenfield had shown that not only the mucous and sub-
mucous tissues were at times reached in croup, but that even the
tracheal rings might be in part destroyed. He had also noticed
the small cavities or vacuoles described in the false membranes,
and thought them owing to the exudation from the ducts of mucous
glands. These spaces were at times filled with exudation cells.
The muccus epithelium is not necessarily destroyed by the false
membrane; it may sometimes be seen covered by the latter.

314 PROCEEDINGS OF SOCIETIES.

Exudation of fibrin would fully account for the false membrane
upon the mucous membrane, without interfering with the epi-
thelium covering the latter, through which wandering cells might
easily pass; and a precedent for fibrinous exudation on a mucous
surface might be found in croupous pneumonia.

Mr. Needham thought that, as pus could come from a serous,
fibrin might from a mucous membrane.

Dr. Coupland thought the different layers in the false
membrane showed a mixed origin; thus the surface of it was
more coarsely fibrillated than the deeper parts, which were much
finer, as though there had been first a catarrh, destroying the
epithelium, and then fibrinous exudation last of all.

Mr. Stowers asked for a verification of the observation made,
that the histological appearances in the angina form of scarlatina
and in a blistered surface were those of diphtheria.

Mr. Miller referred to Rindfleisch’s remark that the exudation
in pharyngeal affections was more cellular and less fibrillated
than in laryngeal; as well as to the existence of apertures in the
basement membrane of the affected parts.

The President thought the non-homogeneity of the false mem-
brane might be explained by the different ages of its component
parts, and suggested that the fungi so commonly found in diph-
theria might owe their presence to the open-mouthed mode of
respiration in diphtheritic patients; in the two cases of diphthe-
ritic conjunctivitis already mentioned the eyes had been kept
constantly bandaged, and, as stated, no fungus had been found.

Dr. Greenfield, in reply, quoted German authority for the
constant presence of fungus in diphtheria; and, since fungi in
the kidney had also been described, they might serve to explain
the renal complications so constantly present. The only way to
get at a life-history of a false membrane was to examine in the
same subject the patches in all stages of growth. He had done
this, but had only found at first a catarrhal state, and later on
pus-globules and fibrillation on the deeper surface of the mem-
brane. ‘The fibrinous exudation in pneumonia was no precedent
for the same process in diphtheria, since the air-cells might be
proved, and were by some thought to be, part of the lymphatic
system. Epithelium in place would not allow fibrin to exude, but
once destroy the former and then exudation was easy. ‘Two
theories existed with regard to the part played by fungi in diph-
theria, one that they were its cause, the other only the cause of
the rapid disintegration of the membrane; it was a subject still
sub judice.

Numerous specimens in illustration of Dr. Greenfield’s paper
were exhibited, as well as others of new growths, and of the
glandular stomach of the crow.

MEDICAL MICROSCOPICAL SOCIETY, 315

15th May, 1874.

Molluscum fibrosum (? Cheloid).—Dr. Pritchard ‘mentioned the
ease of a negro, who for twenty years had been subject to a growth
originating behind one ear, and gradually extending over nearly
all the body. After death a portion of the skin with growth was
forwarded to him (from America), as illustrating “ Cheloid simu-
lating Molluseum fibrosum.” Microscopically, the cutis vera was
found hypertrophied ; here and there masses of cells between the
fibres of the areolar tisssue; epidermis much thickened, hair-
follicles normal; papillze had grown regularly and sideways, and
not vertically as normal. He considered it simply a case of Mol-
luscum fibrosum, not of Cheloid. Engravings of the patient, with
specimens of the disease, were exhibited.

Mr. Needham thought the condition of the papille normal in
the negro.

Perwascular Spaces in the Brain.—-Mr. Kesteven read a paper
on this subject, illustrated by drawings and specimens. These
spaces had been considered normal structures, intended to relieve
intracranial blood-pressure; but Mr. Kesteven had never seen
them in a really healthy brain ; had often noticed them associated
with chronic cerebral mischief, and hence concluded they were
owing to absorption of brain-substance by the irregular circulation
that goes on in chronic disease, the vessels being at one time full,
at another nearly empty. Though the mode of preparation in
chromic acid might render these spaces more evident by the
shrinking of the blood-vessel, he did not think it sufficient to
account entirely for them. He could find in the perivascular
spaces no resemblance to normal lymphatic structure, while Dr.
Batty Tuke had now abandoned the idea that they denoted a
healthy condition of brain. Dr. Pritchard considered them entirely
owing to the mode of preparation in chromic acid; he had never
found them in sections made by freezing the brain. Mr. Need-
ham argued their belonging to the lymphatic system, though not,
strictly speaking, “lymphatics.” The President explained them in
some cases by the giving way of the capillaries around which they
were found; he had seen the brain-substance stained with hz-
matin in their vicinity ; hence an explanation, perhaps, for some
of the anomalous convulsions of childhood. Thought proof was
wanting of their connection with the lymphatie system. Mr.
Toirard asked if in injected brains these spaces were seen, or
were obliterated by the distension of the vessel. In reply, Mr.
Golding Bird stated that he had never seen them ir injected
specimens. Mr. Groves asked if Mr. Kesteven had ever examined
the spaces by staining with nitrate of silver? Mr. Kesteven,
quoting Mr. Batty Tuke, stated that the spaces had been found
in the lower animals (e.g. cats) after strangulation; and that,
though the vessels thus remained full, a space could be seen
beyond. He had never seen anything to warrant the supposition
that they were owing to hemorrhage. He knew of no anatomist

VOL. XIV.—NEW SER. x

315 PROCEEDINGS OF SOCIETIES.

having traced these spaces into lymphatics; they had been
injected by His by the puncture method.

Multiple Cystic Tumour of Breast.—A specimen of this, ex-
hibited by Mr. Needham, seemed to show, from the excess of
epithelium in the mammary tubules, and the epithelial infiltra-
tration of surrounding parts, at once a cystic, adenomatous, and
cancerous nature. Mr. Needham founded his idea of cancer on
the arrangement and not on the intrinsic form of the cells
composing it.

Dusutmn MicroscoricaL Civ.
22nd January, 1874.

Hairs and Epidermis of Oxalis—Dr. Moore showed hairs of a
Cape species of Ovalis, studded, as is so common with most species
of the genus, with transparent papille.—He also showed the
epidermis of the lower surface of a leaf of Oxalis fragrans, which
showed the cells filled with purple sap, amongst which were
abundance of transparent stomata.

Notes on Bermuda Diatoms.—Rev. E. O’Meara showed some
Diatoms from Bermudas in a collection made by Mr. Moseley, of
the ‘‘ Challenger’ expedition, at the south-west bank, Bermudas,
from a depth of thirty-one fathoms, 23rd April, 1873. This
abounded with forms belonging to the genera Rhabdonema,
Isthmia, Podocystis, Grammatophora, and Cocconeis. The Isthmia-
form was similar in some respects to J. enervis (Ehr.), but it was
considered by Mr. Kitton, of Norwich, to be identical with 8S.
minima (Harvey et Bailey). Several specimens of Grammatophora
serpentina (Bhr.) occurred, which were remarkable for the stria-
tion being much coarser and the internal spiral structure being
longer and of greater tenuity than is usual with the forms of that
species found commonly in our country. Some few specimens of
Navicula apis, Ehr., Surirella fastuosa, Ehr., Actinoptycus senarius,
Ehr., Coscinodiseus radiatus, Ehr., Synedra robusta, Ralfs, were met
with, as also numerous specimens of Cocconeis crebristriata, Grev.,
C. coronata, C. punctatissima, Greville, and C. fimbriata, Ebr.
Four specimens were found of a new species of Navicula,
previously found in Ireland by Mr. O’Meara and named JW.
Pfitzeriana. There were also other forms requiring further
study.

Silivm Chloride Crystals in presence of Urea.—Mr. B. Wills
Richardson exhibited some crystals of sodium chloride which he
obtained from a saturated solution of this salt to which a solution
of urea had been added. The crystals were much modified in
form by the presence of the urea; one very large (microscopic)
rhombic dodecahedron attracted a good deal of attention, its form

DUBLIN MICROSCOPICAL CLUB, 317

being most perfect. The crystals were mounted in Klein’s
dammar fluid.

Trichomanes radicans.—Dr. McNab showed some preparations
illustrative of the Indusia and Sporangia of this fern.

Structure of Spines of Strongylocentrotus lividus.—Mr. Mackin-
tosh exhibited transverse section of a spine of S. lividus, showing
the main mass of the spine to be composed of a structureless
calcification of a pale yellowish colour, exhibiting strie, the
two most internal being the most distinct, the middle occupied
by a network of the ordinary echinoid structure, and proceeding
outwards from this to the deep but narrow furrows, which flute
the outside of the spines, are a number (twenty-two) of rays
which are also reticulated. One of these rays exhibited the
peculiarity of bifurcating a short distance from the circumference,
each prong going to a furrow, this ray was scarcely, if at all,
larger than its fellows, and there was not the least appearance
of asymmetry or irregularity in the ridge which its two sub-
divisions enclosed.

Beryl Crystals ; sections exhibited —Dr. Reynolds showed some
sections of beryl crystals from Mourne Mountains, exhibiting a
peculiar internal structure indicating a change of form during its
apparently interrupted growth.

Head of Tenia tetragonocephalus, exhibited.—Prof. Macalister
showed the head of Yenia tetragonocephalus, a parasite of the
maned anteater, Myrmecophaga jubata.

On Structure of Lambay Porphyry.—Prof. Hull, F.R.S., ex-
hibited two thin sections of Lambay Porphyry—one taken from
the rock at Lambay Island, the other from the opposite coast of
Portrane, north of Dublin. The examination of these under a
low magnifying power of twenty-five diameters showed that the
dark base was composed of felsitic material, more or less crystal-
line, containing large numbers of black crystalline grains of mag-
netite, together with a little chlorite. It was evident that the
dark colour was due entirely to the presence of magnetite, and
not to hornblende, as had sometimes been supposed. In this base
were included large crystals of orthoclase, giving the rock the
porphyritic structure. Some cells were seen to be lined with
chlorite and magnetite arranged in peculiar stellate or feathery
forms, whilst the interior was filled by calcite. The exhibition
was accompanied by excellently drawn figures by Prof. Hull,
illustrative of the structure of the rock.

Exhibition of « preparation of, and cursory remarks on, a
seemingly new and problematic Rhizopod.—Mr. Archer showed a
preparation in Beale’s carmine fluid of a Rhizopodous form he had
encountered in various places, but always exceedingly sparingly
(be had hoped to show a recent example, but failed on this oc-
easion to alight on one). This was quite globular, the inner
greyish or slightly yellowish body-mass surrounded by a colour-
less hyaline, thick, doubly-contoured envelope, marked by spar-
ingly scattered dots, which seemed to indicate so many tubular

318 PROCEEDINGS OF SOCIETIES.

openings in the same, as they appeared, on being transversely
viewed, to form lines (or striz) passing inwards in a radial direec-
tion. In the living state Mr. Archer had very rarely been able
to see pseudopodia, and but extremely sparingly protruded ; it
must be assumed that these made their way outwards through
the minute tubular perforations in the outer envelope. In the
specimens now under view (there were two on the slide) he
thought a nucleus or “capsule” could be readily enough per-
ceived, but, contrary to almost universal experience in similar
cases, it might be said to have taken no dye from the carmine
solution. The chief action of the fluid seemed to be that the
central body-mass became contracted and completely withdrawn
from the outer envelope in an externally more or less “ crumpled ”’
manner, the outer envelope remaining unaltered, showing these
were quite differentiated portions of the structure ; indeed, in a
few instances, now and again, the empty, colourless and hyaline
wall, then almost glassy looking, had been met with, and still
retaining its quite globular figure. The question becomes, to
what existent genus could this be referred? Of course the
genus Astrodisculus (Greeff) at once suggests itself; but two
other forms, two or three examples only of which Mr. Archer
had ever seen, and which he had thought must be referable to.
Greeff’s Astrodisculus, did not agree with the present form in
some particulars. Greeff, indeed, ascribes to his Astrodisculus a
porous and siliceous envelope—those previously found by Mr.
Archer, very like, if not truly (?) referable thereto, had soft
envelopes (destroyed by sulphuric acid). As regards the present
form the envelope doubtless appeared porous, but Mr. Archer had ~
not yet met with examples sufficient to experiment satisfactorily
with acids; he had more than once tried to treat this form with
reagents, but Jost the specimen in the effort (they often will
vanish from sight out of sheer cross purposes!) ; he must, there-
fore, relegate it to the future, in hopes this form may again turn
up, when he would claim for it once more some attention from
the Club.

19th February, 1874.

Remarks on Hairs of Platycerium.—Dr. Moore exhibited the
beautiful stellate hairs which closely cover the whole surface of-
Platycerium grande. These were mostly 9-rayed, and were seen
to good effect when polarized. Dr. Moore observed that these
hairs revealed to us an adaptability of a wonderful nature, enabling
the plant not only to control too rapid transpiration from the
fronds during dry weather, but, he believed, to imbibe moisture
from the atmosphere as well. He knew that it was a disputed
point amongst physiologists whether plants were able to imbibe
moisture through their leaves ; some experiments lately made tend
to prove they have no such function, but botanists, whose testi-
mony is valuable, including the late Dr. Lindley and Dr. Asa
Gray, believe that plants have the power of imbibing moisture

DUBLIN MICROSCOPICAL CLUB. 319

through their leaves, aud with the latter he was much inclined to
concur, judging from primd facie evidence, without having made
special experiments on the subject. The beautiful hairs ex-
hibited aided the plant, he thought, very materially to perform
this function.

New form of Diaphoracephalus, exhibited —Mr. Geoghegan
showed a form of Diaphoracephalus, which appeared to be unde-
scribed, and of which he was preparing an account.

Structure of tubercle of Oreaster tuberculatus —Mr. Mackintosh
presented a very successfully prepared transverse section of a
tubercle of Oreaster tuberculatus. This showed three distinct
regions—a central, in which the interspaces are large and the
solid rods anastomose irregularly in the middle, but become more
definitely arranged according as the intermediate portion is
reached ; this part consists of small oval spaces, with the rods
intersecting more or less at right angles, and exhibits no indi-
cation whatever of circular arrangement; the third, or cortical
layer, consists of very small rounded spaces, which increase in
number on the inner border, and a large quantity of interstitial
substance with a finely crenulate external edge.

Problematic ovum-like cyst, exhibited.—Mr. Archer drew attev-
tion to the empty coat of a puzzling ovum-like cyst now and
again very sparingly noticed by him, and from gatherings made
in various parts of the country. This was smooth, ovate, stipitate,
the stipes furnished with a small globose thickening under the
body, the base of the stipes somewhat scutate, by which attached
to foreign objects. The upper portion of the ovate case was seen
to have been removed, as is usual (as one removes’ the top of egg
to get at the contents), and this by a “clean” cut or suture,
leaving the body-portion like an elegant vase borne aloft on its
delicate stalk ; the colour of the whole yellow. Most probably
this was really the “shell” of the ovum of some creature, the
truncate upper part representing where the upper, and much the
smaller, portion of the wall had become removed on the young
animal making its exit. But, if an ovum, to what could it
belong? Perhaps others might be able to throw a light on the
nature or identity of this pretty ‘‘ vase,”’ which has always, as yet,
shown itself without an owner.

* Triceratiwm Campeachianum and Navicula aspera, exhibited —
Rev. E. O’Meara presented two slides, kindly supplied by the
Club’s corresponding member F. Kitton, Esq., of Norwich, one
containing TZriceratium Oampeachianum, Grunow, which Mr.
Kaitton considered a 10-angled variety of ZT. favus, the other con-
taining beautifully mounted specimens of Navicula aspera, which
Dr. Donkin regards as identical with Stauroneis pulchella, but
which Mr. O’Meara was disposed to consider a distinct species,
notwithstanding the striking resemblance of the striation.

Micrococcus prodigiosus (Ehr.), Cohn, exhibited—Mr. Archer,
referring to Professor Cohn’s late interesting and valuable
paper on Bacteria “ Untersuchungen itiber Bacterien” (trans-

320 PROCEEDINGS OF SOCIETIES.

lated in abstract Q. J. M.S., 1873, pp. 156—163), exhibited
examples of Micrococcus (Monas) prodigiosus (Ehr.), Cohn, which
had occurred on some slices of raw (“‘diseased”’) potatoes which
had been left lying under a bell-glass. He remarked on the

points dwelt on by Cohn as regards the Spherobacteria (Cohn),

to which sub-group the curious production now shown belong,
falling under the category of “ Pigment Bacteria,” on account of
the remarkable colours evinced, not by the cells themselves, but
apparently due to the matrix. These examples showed at first a
blood-red colour, but more recently a deep brick-red, changing to
a brown. Prof. Cohn’s illustration (Q. J. M.S., Pl. V, fig. 1)
gives the cells as if typically globular, in the present instance
they were elliptic, say one third longer than broad (the longest
scarcely sj5’); the walls very delicate. These cells are de-
scribed as colourless, but they appeared rather to evince that bluish
hue characteristic of phycochrome, and in tint came very near
some Wostoc-cells. It might be worthy of remark that, though
the production flourished best on the potato-surface, a very good
crop had become developed underneath the slice, covering the
lower surface of a piece of paper on which the potato-slice lay ;
thus too nearly, if not quite, in the dark—that is to say, the
paper (to some extent, however, macerated) was between the
potato and the Micrococcus-stratum.

19th March, 1874.

Fern-scales,and a new Fish-trough, exhibited—Mr. Porte showed
a series of mounted preparations of fern-scales from various ferns,
some, when polarised, were of singular beauty.— He also showed a
new trough of his own design and construction for viewing the cir-
culation of the blood in the tailofa minnow. This consisted of a
glass plate about three inches square, having two narrow wedge-
shaped pieces of tin, about a quarter of an inch thick, and taper-
ing to a point, cemented to the plate near its middle and about
half an inch apart; over these a slip of glass was cemented, thus
enclosing a narrow wedge-shaped space, “tapering to nothing ”
below, and sealed all round except at the upper oblong opening
into which the fish is dropped tail foremost.

Pinnularia cardinalis, very rare in Ireland, exhibited.—Rev. E.
O’ Meara showed a specimen of Pinnularia cardinalis from a pond
near Armagh. This is of extremely rare occurrence in Ireland.
Smith attributes it to the Lough Mourne deposit, but though he
(Mr. O’Meara) had often searched for it there, he had never been
fortunate enough to find it. Ina peat deposit from Dromore,
Co. Down, kindly supplied by Mr. Gray, of Belfast, the middle of
a valve was discovered, but no perfect example had previously
come under his observation.— Mr. O’Meara also showed examples
of Rhabdonema Torellii, Cleve, “ Diatoms of the Arctic Sea.” The
form occurred not unfrequently in some gatherings made at
Spitzbergen by Rey. A. E. Eaton. :

DUBLIN MICROSCOPICAL. CLUB. 321

Remarks on Structure of Pits in Taxus.——Dr. McNab exhibited
a section of yew, Taxus baccata, under a Gundlach +4-objective,
and pointed out that the central pore or pit of the bordered pits
of the yew were not round as generally described, but were in
most cases elongated. The examination of a number of sections
shows that the form of the pits varies, being in some round, but
in the majority more or less elongated ; the openings in the two
sides cross, and thus produce the seeming circular opening as
seen with a low power. In these general characters the bordered
pits of the yew agree with those of the Cycads and with the genus
next Taxus, namely, Salisburia. In examining the pits a high
power is required ; and if the wood-cells are treated with the iodo-
chloride of zine solution, the opening can be very easily demon-
strated.

Structure of spines of Astropyga radiata. — Mr. Mackintosh
exhibited transverse sections of the spine of Astropyga radiata.
The spines vary in length from 4" to 13", are fusiform, elliptical,
very strongly serrated, and pink-orange or green in colour. In
section the central part is seen to be occupied by a reticulation
with very wide interspaces, the solid rods of which unite at its
outer part to form a ring, from which pass outwards a number of
clavate rays of homogeneous structure, ending externally in
ridges, which vary in their degree of prominence according to the
part of the serration through which the section passes, and are
joined to one another by two or three rather slender bars, the
whole forming a structure remarkable for its lightness and
fragility.

Villi from Stomach of Myrmecophaga jubata, exhibited.—Mr.
Geoghegan exhibited a preparation showing villi from stomach
of Myrmecophaga jubata.

A Black Micrococcus (Cohn), exhibited, and cursory notes
thereon.—Mr. Archer showed examples of a form appertaiming
to the Spherobacterian genus Micrococeus, Cohn, which in the
mass appeared of a very nearly black colour. Referring to the
exhibition at last meeting of Micrococcus prodigiosus (Ehr.), Cohn,
occurring on slices of raw potato, now, for sake of comparison,
again shown to the meeting, Mr. Archer mentioned that, when
he noticed the occurrence of that singular production on the
potatoes in question, he had soon after introduced under the bell-
glass covering them two pieces of boiled potato, one of which he
rubbed on the older raw piece bearing the Micrococcus prodigiosus
so as to well inoculate it therewith—the other he left untouched.
Tt was this second piece of boiled potato which had become covered
by the “black” Micrococcus. A blue Mierococcus is recorded ;
many, it is true, might discern in the example now shown a bluish
shade—in fact, it might be denominated a “blue-black” (like cloth).
But on being*placed under the microscope (say a 1", or, better,
a 1), there was a very noticeable difference from MZ. prodigiosus
(now placed under two microscopes side by side). In the latter
the cells were comparatively long and narrow, elliptic, with a

322 PROCEEDINGS OF SOCIETIES,

faint outline ; in the “black” form they were still elliptic, but
relatively to their width much, and absolutely somewhat, shorter,
and showed a dark, it might be said thick, outline. The latter, or
“black” form, was more prone to show the cells arranged in such a
position in twos or fours, as was indicative of recent self-division.
Four could sometimes be seen in a plane, their inner surfaces of
contact of a thinner appearance, flat and sub-rectangular within
at the central common point of union. Both, under a high (4)
power, showed a hyaline, not deep, rather sharply marked, “halo”
surrounding the cells, the former (JZ. prodigiosus) more noticeably.
The latter showed a “ molecular ” motion much more vividly than
the former ; it need not be said that no other motion was evinced.
In both forms the colouring substance showed imbedded therein
a more dense, as if granular, body, posed in the former more
towards one end of the cell, and very minute ; in the latter more
nearly central, by comparison considerably larger. To call this
granular body in either a “nucleus’’ would, of course, be far too
great a begging of the question. Mr. Archer had called the inner
substance “colouring substance,” for, as previously mentioned,
it gave to the eye a very Nostoc-like hue. ‘The colour of the mass
seems thus to be due mainly, if not altogether, to the tenacious
medium binding the cells into a common stratum, and it is, to a
great extent, borrowed by any mycelioid filaments should they be
present. This colour in the aggregate Prof. Cohn regards as
being of “specific” value, or, to say the least, of “race” value ;
that is, as indicating forms or types, which, by a continuous
heredity, run on and on, each, as it were, in its own groove.
Prof. Cohn supposes that the fitful and rather isolated manner in
which these productions seem to occur is explained by their
“oerms”’ being carried from one suitable nidus to another by the
atmosphere. Here, however, were two forms quite distinguish-
able by the eye, either in the mass or under the microscope, oc-
curring one on each of two pieces of the same potato; one of
these forms Mr. Archer had “sown,” the other “came there,”
and both were under the same bell-glass. The original (boiled)
potato was in no way “diseased” (he knew from practical ex-
perience, indeed, it was excellent, having eaten the rest of it some
days before at dinner; he would rather not venture on the
remainder now!). Probabilities, he thought, were much in favour
of Prof. Cohn’s views, but Mr. Archer gave this little history
quantum valeat. .

MEMOIRS.

A Pretiminary Account of the DEVELOPMENT of the
ELasMoBRANCH Fisuzs.1 By F. M. Batrour, B.A.,
Trinity College, Cambridge. (With Plates XIII, XIV,
and XV.)

Durtinc the spring of the present year I was studying at
the Zoological Station, founded by Dr. Dohrn at Naples, and
eutirely through its agency was supplied with several
hundred eggs of various species of Dog-fish (Selachii)—a far
larger number than any naturalist has previously had an
opportunity of studying. The majority of the eggs belonged
to an oviparous species of Mustelus, but in addition to these I
had a considerable number of eggs of two or three species of
Scyllium, and some of the Torpedo. Moreover, since my return
to England, Professor Huxley has most liberally given me
several embryos of Scylliwm stellare in a more advanced
condition than I ever had at Naples, which have enabled me
to fill up some lacunz in my observations.

On many points my investigations are not yet finished,
but I have already made out a number of facts which I
venture to believe will add to our knowledge of vertebrate
embryology ; and since it is probable that some time will
elapse before 1 am able to give a complete account of my
investigations, I have thought it worth while preparing a
preliminary paper in which I have briefly, but I hope in an
intelligible manner, described some of the more interesting
points in the development of the Elasmobranchii. The first-
named species (Mustelus sp.?) was alone used for the early
stages, for the later ones I have also employed the other
species, whose eggs I have had; but as far as I have seen at
present, the differences between the various species in early
embryonic life are of no importance.

Without further preface I will pass on to my investiga-
tions.

The Egg-shell.

In the eggs of all the species of Dog-fishes which I have

examined the yolk lies nearest that end of the quadrilateral

1 Read in Section D, at the Meeting of the British Association at Belfast.
VOL, XIV.——NEW SER. b

324 ¥F. M. BALFOUR.

shell which has the shortest pair of strings for attachment
This is probably due to the shape of the cavity of the shell,
and is certainly not due to the presence of any structures
similar to chalaze.

The Yolk.

The yolk is not enclosed in any membrane comparable to
the vitelline membrane of Birds, but lies freely in a viscid
albumen which fills up the egg-capsule. It possesses con-
siderable consistency, so that it can be removed into a basin,
in spite of the absence of a vitelline membrane, without falling
to pieces. This consistency is not merely a property of the
yolk-sphere as a whole, but is shared by every individual
part of it.

With the exception of some finely granular matter around '
the blastoderm, the yolk consists of rather small, elliptical,
highly refracting bodies, whose shape is very characteristic
and renders them easily recognizable. A number of striz
like those of muscle are generally visible on most of the
spherules, which give them the appearance of being in the act
of breaking up into a series of discs; but whether these strize
are normal, or produced by the action of water I have not
determined.

Position of the Blastoderm.

The blastoderm is always situated, immediately after im-
pregnation, near the pole of the yolk which lies close to the
end of the egg-capsule. Its position varies a little im the
different species and is not quite constant in different eggs
of the same species. But this general situation is quite
invariable.

Segmentation.

In a fresh specimen, in which segmentation has only just
commenced, the blastoderm or germinal disc appears as a
circular disc, distinctly marked off by a dark line from the
rest of the yolk. ‘This line, as is proved by sections, is the
indication of a very shallow groove. The appearance of
sharpness of distinction between the germ and the yolk is
further intensified by their marked difference of colour,
the germ itself being usually of a darker shade than the
remainder of the yolk ; while around its edge, and apparently
sharply separated from it by the groove before mentioned, is
a ring of a different shade which graduates at its outer border
into the normal shade of the yolk.

These appearances are proved by transverse sections to be

ON THE DEVELOPMENT OF THE ELASMOBRANCH FISHES. 325

deceptive. There is no sharp line either at the sides or be-
low separating the blastoderm from the yolk. In the passage
between the fine granular matter of the germ to the coarser
yolk-spheres every intermediate size of granule is present;
and, though the space between the two is rather narrow, in
no sense of the word can there be said to be any break or
line between them.

This gradual passage stands in marked contrast with what
we shall find to be the case at the close of the segmentation.
In the youngest egg which I had, the germinal disc was
already divided into four segments by two furrows at right
angles. These furrows, however, did not reach its edge ;
and from my sections I have found that they were not
cut off below by any horizontal furrow. So that the four
segments were continuous below with the remainder of the
germ without a break.

In the next youngest specimen which I had, there were
already present eighteen segments, somewhat irregular in size,
but which might roughly be divided into an outer ring of
larger spheres, separated, as it were, by a circular furrow
from an inner series of smaller segments. The furrows in
this case reached quite to the edge of the germinal disc.

The remarks I made in reference to the earlier specimen
about the separation of the germ from the yolk apply in
every particular to the present one. The external limit
of the blastoderm was not defined by a true furrow,

-and the segmentation furrows still ended below without
meeting any horizontal furrows, so that the blastoderm was
not yet separated by any line from the remainder of the yolk,
and the segments of which it was composed were still only
circumscribed upon five sides. In this particular the seg-
mentation in these animals differs materially from that in the
Bird, where the horizontal furrows appear very early.

In each segment a nucleus was generally to be seen in
sections. I will, however, reserve my remarks upon the
nature of the nuclei till I discuss the nuclei of the blasto-
derm as a whole.

For some little time the peripheral segments continue larger
than the more central ones, but this difference of size becomes
less and less marked, and before the segments have become
too small to be seen with the simple microscope, their size
appears to be uniform over the whole surface of the
blastoderm.

In blastoderms somewhat older than the one last described
the segments have already become completely separate masses,
and each of them already possesses a distinct nucleus. ‘They

326 F. M. BALFOUR.

form a layer one or two segments deep. ‘The limits of the
blastoderm are not, however, defined by the already com-
pleted segments, but outside these new segments continue
to be formed around nuclei which appear in the yolk.
At this stage there is, therefore, no line of demarcation
between the germ and the yolk, but the yolk is being bored
into, so to speak, by a continuous process of fresh segmen-
tation.

The further segmentation of the already existing spheres,
and the formation of new ones from the yolk below and to
the sides continues till the central cells acquire their final
size, the peripheral ones being still large and undefined
towards the yolk. These also soon reach the final size, and
the blastoderm then becomes rounded off towards the yolk
and sharply separated from it.

The Nuclei of the Yolk.

Intimately connected with the segmentation is the appear-
ance and history of a number of nuclei which arise in the
yolk surrounding the blastoderm.

When the horizontal furrows appear which first separate
the blastoderm from the yolk, the separation does not occur
along the line of passage from the fine to the coarse yolk, but
in the former at some distance from this line.

The blastoderm thus rests upon a mass of finely granular
material, from which, however, it is sharply separated. At
this time there appear in this finely granular material a num-
ber of nuclei of a rather peculiar character.

They vary immensely in size—from that of an ordinary
nucleus to a size greater than the largest blastoderm-cell.

In Pl. XIII, fig. 1, m, is shown their distribution in this
finely granular matter and their variation in size. But what-
ever may be their size, they always possess the same charac-
teristic structure. ‘This is shown in Pl. XIII, figs. 1 and 2,n.

They are rather irregular in shape, with a tendency when
small to be roundish, and are divided by a number of lines
into distinct areas, in each of which a nucleolus is to be seen.
The lines dividing them into these areas have a tendency (in
the smaller specimens) to radiate from the centre, as shown
in Pl. XITI, fig. 1.

These nuclei colour red with hematoxylin and carmine
and brown with osmic acid, while the nucleoli or granules
contained in the areas also colour very intensely with all the
three above-named reagents.

With such a peculiar structure, in favorable specimens
these nuclei are very easily recognised, and their distribution

ON THE DEVELOPMENT OF THE ELASMOBRANCH FISHES, 327

can be determined without difficulty. They are not present
alone in the finely granular yolk, but also in the coarsely
granular yolk adjoining it. They form very often a special
row, sometimes still more markedly than in Pl. XIII, fig. 1,
along the floor of the segmentation cavity. They are not,
however, found alone in the yolk. All the blastoderm-cells
in the earlier stages possess precisely similar nuclei! From
the appearance of the first nucleus in a segmentation-sphere
till a comparatively late period in development, every nucleus
which can be distinctly seen is found to be of this character.
In Pl. XIII, fig. 2, this is very distinctly shown.

(1) We have, then, nuclei of this very peculiar character
scattered through the subgerminal granular matter, and also
universally present in the cells of the blastoderm. (2) These
nuclei are distributed in a special manner under the floor of
the segmentation cavity on which new cells are continually
appearing. Putting these two facts together, there would be
the strongest presumption that these nuclei do actually be-
come the nuclei of cells which enter the blastoderm, and such
is actually the case. In my account of a segmentation I
have, indeed, already mentioned this, and I will return to it,
but before doing so will enter more fully into the distribution
of these nuclei in the yolk.

They appear in small numbers around the blastoderm at
the close of segmentation, and round each one of them there
may at this time be seen in osmic acid specimens, and with
high powers, a fine network similar to but finer than that
represented in Pl. XIII, fig. 2,2 y. This network cannot,
as a general rule, be traced far into the yolk, but in some
exceptionally thin specimens it may be seen in any part of
the fine granular yolk around the blastoderm, the meshes of
the network being, however, considerably coarser between
than around the nuclei. This network may be seen in the
fine granular material around the germ till the latest period
of which I have yet cut sections of the blastoderm. In
the later specimens, indeed, it is very much more distinctly
seen than in the earlier, owing to the fact that in parts of the
blastoderm, especially under the embryo, the yolk-granules
have disappeared partly or entirely, leaving only this fine
network with the nuclei in it.

A specimen of this kind is represented in, Pl. XIII, fig. 2,
n y, where the meshes of the network are seen to be finer
immediately around the nuclei, and coarser in the intervals.
The specimen further shows in the clearest manner that this
network is vot divided into areas, each representing a cell
and each containing a nucleus. J do not know to what

828 F. M. BALFOUR.

extent this network extends into the yolk. I have never yet
seen the limits of it, though it is very common to see the .
coarsest yolk-granules lying in its meshes. Some of these
are shown in Pl. XIII, fig. 2, y &.

This network of lines! (probably bubbles) is characteristic
of many cells, especially ova. We are, therefore, forced to
believe that the fine granular and probably coarser granular
yolk of this meroblastic egg consists of an active organized
basis with passive yolk-spheres imbedded init. The organized
basis is especially concentrated at the germinal pole of the
egg, but becomes less and less in quantity, as compared with
the yoke-spheres, the further we depart from this.

Admitting, as I think it is necessary to do, the organized
condition of the whole yolk sphere, there are two possible views
as to its nature. We may either take the view that it is one
gigantic cell, the ovum, which has grown at the expense of the
other cells of the egg-follicle, and that these cells in becoming
absorbed have completely lost their individuality; or we may
look upon the true formative yolk (as far as we can separate it
from the remainder of the food yolk) as the remains of one cell
(the primitive ovum), and the remainder of the yolk asa body
formed from the coalescence of the other cells of the egg-
follicle, which is adherent to, but has not coalesced with, the
primitive ovum, the cells in this case not having completely
lost their individuality ; and to these cells, the nuclei, I have
found, must be supposed to belong.

The former view I think, for many reasons, the most
probable. The share of these nuclei in the segmentation, and
the presence of similar nuclei in the cells of the germ, both
support it, and are at the same time difficulties in the way of
the other view. Leaving this question which cannot be
discussed fully in a preliminary paper like the present one,
I will pass on to another important question, viz.—

How do these nuclei originate? Are they formed by the
division of the pre-existing nuclei, or by an independent
formation. It must be admitted that many specimens are
strongly in favour of the view that they increase by division.
In the first place, they are often seen “two together;” examples
of this will be seen in Pl. XITI, fig. 1. In the second place, I
have found several specimens in which five or six appear
close together, which look very much as if there had been an
actual division into six nuclei. It is, however, possible in
this case that the nuclei are really connected below and only

1 The interpretation of this network is entirely due to Dr. Kleinenberg,
who suggested it to me on my showing him « number of specimens ex-
hibiting the nuclei and network,

ON THE DEVELOPMENT OF THE ELASMOBRANCH FISHES, 329

appear separate, owing to the crenate form of the mass.
Against this may be put the fact that the division of a
nucleus is by no means so common as has been sometimes
supposed, that in segmentation it has very rarely been
observed that the nucleus of a sphere first divides,' and that
then segmentation takes place, but segmentation generally
occurs and then a new nucleus arises in each of the newly
formed spheres. Such nuclei as I have described are rare ;
they have, however, been observed in the egg of a Nephelis
(one of the Leeches), and have in that case been said to
divide. Dr. Kleinenberg, however, by following a single egg
through the whole course of its development, has satisfied
himself that this is not the case, and that, further, these
nuclei in Nephelis never form the nuclei of newly developing
cells.

I must leave it an open question, and indeed one which
can hardly be solved from sections, whether these nuclei
arise freely or increase by division, but I am inclined
to believe that both processes may possibly take place.
In any case their division does not appear to determine
the segmentation or segregation of the protoplasm around
them.

As was mentioned in my account of the segmentation, these
nuclei first appear during that process, and become the nuclei
of the freshly formed segmentation spheres. At the close of
segmentation a few of them are still to be seen around the
blastoderm, but they are not very numerous.

From this period they rapidly increase in number, up to
the commencement of the formation of the embryo as a
body distinct from the germ. Though before this period
they probably become the nuclei of veritable cells which
enter the germ, it is not till this period, when the growth
of the blastoderm becomes very rapid and it commences to
spread over the yolk, that these new cells are formed in
large numbers. I have many specimens of this age which
show the formation of these new cells with great clearness.
This is most distinctly to be seen immediately below the em-
bryo, where the yolk-spherules are few in number. At the
opposite end of the blastoderm I believe that more of these
cells are formed, but, owing to the presence of numerous yolk-
spherules, it is much more difficult to make certain of
this.

1 Kowalevsky (“ Beitrage zur Entwickelungsgeschichte der Holothurien,”
‘Mémoirs de l’Ac. Imp. de St. Petersbourg,’ vii ser., vol. xi, 1867) describes
the division of nuclei during segmentation in the Holothurians, and other
observers have described it elsewhere.

330 F. M. BALFOUR.

As to the final destination of these cells, my observations
are not yet completed. Probably a large number of them are
concerned in the formation of the vascular system, but I
will give reasons later on for believing that some of them
are concerned in the formation of the walls of the digestive
canal and of other parts.

I will conclude my account of these nuclei by briefly
summarizing the points I have arrived at in reference to
them.

A portion, or more probably the whole, of the yolk of the
Dog-fish consists of organized material, in which nuclei ap-
pear and increase either by division or by a process of
independent formation, and a great number of these subse-
quently become the nuclei of cells formed around them,
frequently at a distance from the germ, which then travel up
and enter it.

The formation of cells in the yolk, apart from the general
process of segmentation, has been recognised by many ob-
servers. Kupffer (‘Archiv. fiir Micr. Anat.,’ Bd. iv, 1868) and
Owsjannikow (“ Entwickelung der Coregonus,” ‘ Bulletin der
Akad. St. Petersburgh,’ vol. xix) in osseous fishes,’ Ray Lan-
kester (‘ Annals and Mag. of Nat. History,’ vol. xi, 1873,
p- 81) in Cephalopoda, Gotte (‘Archiv fur Micr. Anat.,’
vol. x) in the chick, have all described a new formation of
cells from the so-called food-yolk. The organized nature of
the whole or part of this, previous to the formation of the cells
from it, has not, however, as a rule, been distinctly recognised.
In the majority of cases, as, for instance, in Loligo, the
nucleus is not the first thing to be formed, but a plastide is
first formed, in which a nucleus subsequently makes its
appearance.

Formation of the Layers.

Leaving these nuclei, I will now pass on to the formation
of the layers.

At the close of segmentation the surface of the blastoderm
is composed of cells of a uniform size, which, however, are
too small to be seen by the aid of the simple microscope.

The cells of this uppermost layer are somewhat columnar,

1 Gotte, at the end of a paper on “ The Development of the Layers in the
Chick” (‘ Archiv. fir Micr. Anat.,’ vol. x, 1873, p. 196), mentions that the
so-called cells in Osseous fishes which CEllacher states to have migrated
into the yolk, and which are clearly the same as those mentioned b
Owsjannikow, are really not ced/s, but large nuclei. If this statement is
correct the phenomena in Osseous fishes are precisely the same as those I
have described in the Dog-fish,

ON THE DEVELOPMENT OF THE ELASMOBRANCH FISHES, 331]

and can be distinguished from the remainder of the cells of
the blastoderm as a separate layer. This layer forms the epi-
blast; and the Dog-fish agree with Birds, Batrachians, and
Osseous fish in the very early differentiation of it.

The remainder of the cells of the blastoderm form a mass,
many cells deep, in which it is impossible as yet or till a very
considerably later period to distinguish two layers. They
may be calied the /ower layer cells. Some of them near the
edge of this mass are still considerably larger than the rest,
but they are, as a whole, of a fairly uniform size. Their
nuclei are of the same character as the nuclei in the yolk.

There is one point to be noticed in the shape of the blas-
toderm as a whole. It is unsymmetrical, and a much larger
number of its cells are found collected at one end than at the
other. ‘This absence of symmetry is found in all sections
which are cut parallel to the long axis of the egg-capsule.
The thicker end is the region where the embryo will subse-
quently appear.

This very early appearance of distinction in the blas-
toderm between the end at which the embryo will appear,
and the non-embryonic end is important, especially as
showing the affinity of the modes of development of Osseous
fishes and the Elasmobranchii. O6ellacher (‘ Zeitschrift fiir
Wiss. Zoologie,’ vol. xxxiii, 1873) has shown, and, though
differing from him on many other points, on this point
Gotte (‘ Arch. fir Micr. Anat.,’ vol. ix, 1873) agrees with
him, that a similar absence of symmetry by which the
embryonic end of the germ -is marked off, occurs almost
immediately after the end of segmentation in Osseous fishes.
In the early stages of development there are a number of
remarkable points of agreement between the Osseous fish
and the Dog-fish, combined with a number of equally remark-
able points of difference. Some of these I shall point out as
I proceed with my description.

The embryonic end of the germ is always the one which
points towards the pole of the yolk farthest removed from
the egg-capsule.

The germ grows, but not very rapidly, and without other-
wise undergoing any very appreciable change, for some time.

The growth at these early periods appears to be particularly
slow, especially when compared with the rapid manner in
which some of the later stages of the development are passed
through.

The next important change which occurs is the formation
of the so-called “‘ segmentation cavity.”

This forms a very marked feature throughout the early

B32 F. M. BALFOUR.

stages. It appears, however, to have somewhat different re-
lations to the blastoderm than the homologous structure in
other vertebrates. In its earliest stage which I have observed,
it appears as a small cavity in the centre of the lower layer
cells. This grows rapidly, and its roof becomes composed
of epiblast and only a thin lining of “ lower layer” cells,
while its floor is formed by the yolk (Pl. XIII, fig.3, sc). In
the next and third stage (Pl. XIII, fig. 4, s¢) its floor is
formed by a thin layer of cells, its roof remaining as before.
It has, however, become a less conspicuous formation than
it was; and in the last (fourth) stage in which it can be
distinguished it is very inconspicuous, and almost filled up
by cells.

What I have called the second stage corresponds to a
period in which no trace of the embryo is to be seen. In
the third stage the embryonic end of the blastoderm projects
outwards to form a structure which I shall speak of as the
“* embryonic rim,” and in the fourth and last stage a distinct
medullary groove is formed. For a considerable period during
the second stage the segmentation cavity remains of about the
same size; during the third stage it begins to be encroached
upon and becomes smaller, both absolutely, and relatively to
the increased size of the germ.

The segmentation cavity of the Dog-fish most nearly
agrees with that of Osseous fishes in its mode of formation
and relation to the embryo.

Dog-fish resemble Osseous fish in the fact that their
embryos are entirely formed from a portion of the germ
which does not form part of the roof of the segmenta-
tion cavity, so that the cells forming the roof of the
segmentation cavity take no share at any time in the forma-
tion of their embryos. ‘They further agree with Osseous fish
(always supposing that the descriptions of Oellacher, loc. cit.,
and Gétte, ‘Archiv fir Micr. Anat.,’ Bd. ix, are correct)
in the floor of the segmentation cavity being formed at one
period by yolk. Together with these points of similarity
there are some important differences.

(1) The segmentation cavity in the Osseous fish from the
first arises as a cavity between the yolk and the blastoderm,
and its floor is never at any period covered with cells. In
the Dog-fish, as we have said above, both in the earlier and
later periods the floor is covered with cells.

(2) The roof in the Dog-fish is invariably formed by the
epiblast and a row of flattened lower layer cells.

According to both Gotte and Oellacher the roof of the
segmentation cavity in Osseous fishes is in the earlier stages

ON THE DEVELOPMENT OF THE ELASMOBRANCH FISHES. 333

formed alone of the two layers which correspond with the
single layer forming the epiblast in the Dog-fish. In Osseous
fishes it is very difficult to distinguish the various layers,
owing to the similarity of their component cells. In Dog-
fish this is very easy, owing to the great distinctness of the
epiblast, and it appears to me, on this account, very probable
that the two above-named observers may be in error as to
the constitution of its roof in the Osseous fish. With both
the Bird and the Frog the segmentation cavity of the Dog-
fish has some points of agreement, and some points of dif-
ference, but it would take me too far from my present subject
to discuss them.

When the segmentation cavity is first formed, no great
changes have taken place in the cells forming the blastoderm.
The upper layer—the epiblast—is composed of a single layer
of columnar cells, and the remainder of the cells of blasto-
derm, forming the lower layer, are of a fairly uniform size,
and polygonal from mutual pressure. The whole edge of
the blastoderm is thickened, but this thickening is especially
marked at its embryonic end.

This thickened edge of the blastoderm is still more con-
spicuous in the next and second stage (Pl. XIII, fig. 3).

In the second stage the chief points of progress, in addition
to the increased thickness of the edge of the blastoderm,
are—

(1) The increased thickness and distinctness of the epi-
plast, caused by its cells becoming more columnar, though it
remains as a one-cell-thick layer.

(2) The disappearance of the cells from the floor of the
segmentation cavity.

The lower layer cells have undergone no important
changes, and the blastoderm has increased very little if at
all in size.

From Pl. XIII, fig. 3, it is seen that there is a far larger
collection of cells at the embryonic than at the opposite
end.

Passing over some rather unimportant stages, I will come
to the next important one.

The general features of this (the third) stage in a surface
view are—

(1) The increase in size of the blastoderm.

(2) The diminution in size of the segmentation cavity,
both relatively and absolutely.

(3) The appearance of a portion of the blastoderm pro-
jecting beyond the rest over the yolk. This projecting rim
extends for nearly half the circumference of the yolk, but is

334 F. M. BALFOUR.

most marked at the point where the embryo will shortly
appear. I will call it the ‘embryonic rim.” .

These points are still better seen from sections than from
surface views, and will be gathered at once from an inspection
of Pl. XIII, fig. 4.

The epiblast has become still more columnar, and is
markedly thicker in the region where the embryo will ap-
pear. But its most remarkable feature is that at the outer
edge of the ‘embryonic rim” (e7) it turns round and becomes
continuous with the lower layer cells. This feature is most
important, and involves some peculiar modifications in the
development. I will, however, reserve a discussion of its
meaning till the next stage.

The only other important feature of this stage is the appear-
ance of a layer of cells on the floor of the segmentation
cavity.

Does this layer come from an ingrowth from the thickened
edge of the blastoderm, or does it arise from the formation of
new cells in the yolk?

It is almost impossible to answer this question with cer-
tainty. The following facts, however, make me believe that
the newly formed cells do play an important part in the
the formation of this layer.

(1) The presence at an earlier date of almost a row of
nuclei under the floor of the segmentation cavity (Pl. XIII,
fig. 1).

(2) The presence on the floor of the cavity of such large
cells as those represented in fig. 1, 6 d, cells which are very
different, as far as the size and granules are concerned, from
the remainder of the cells of the blastoderm.

On the other hand, from this as well as other sections,
I have satisfied myself that there is a distinct ingrowth of
cells from the embryonic swelling. It is therefore most
probable that both these processes, viz. a fresh formation and
an ingrowth, have a share in the formation of the layer of
cells on the floor of the segmentation cavity.

In the next stage we find the embryo rising up as a
distinct body from the blastoderm, and I shall in future
speak. of the body, which now becomes distinct as the em-
bryo. It corresponds with what Kupffer (loc. cit.) in his
paper on the “‘ Osseous Fishes ” has called the ‘‘ embryonic
keel.” This starting-point for speaking of the embryo as
a distinct body is purely arbitrary and one merely of con-
venience. If I wished to fix more correctly upon a period
which could be spoken of as marking the commencing forma-
tion of the embryo, I should select the time when structures

ON THE DEVELOPMENT O# THE ELASMOBRANCH FisuHES. 335

first appear to mark out the portion of the germ from which
the embryo becomes formed; this period would be in the
Elasmobranchii, as in the Osseous fish, at the termination of
segmentation, when the want of symmetry between the
embryonic end of the germ and the opposite end first ap-
ears.

: I described in the last stage the formation of the ‘‘em-
bryonic rim.” It is in the middle point of this, where it
projects most, that the development of the embryo takes
place. There appear two parallel folds extending from the
edge of the blastoderm towards the centre, and cut off at
their central end by another transverse fold. These three
folds raise up, between them, a flat broadish ridge, ‘the
embryo” (Pl. XIV, fig. 5). The head end of the embryo
is the end nearest the centre of the blastoderm, the tail end
being the one formed by its (the blastoderm’s) edge.

Almost from its first appearance this ridge acquires a
shallow groove—the medullary groove (Pl. XIV, fig. 5, m g)
—along its middle line, where the epiblast and hypoblast are
in absolute contact (vide fig. 6a, Ta, 7b, &c.), and where the
mesoblast (which is already formed by this stage) is totally
absent. ‘This groove ends abruptly a little before the front
end of the embryo, and is deepest in the middle and wide
and shallow behind.

On each side of it is a plate of mesoblast equivalent to the
combined vertebral and lateral plates of the Chick. These,
though they cannot be considered as entirely the cause of the
medullary groove, may perhaps help to make it deeper. In
the parts of the germ outside the embryo the mesoblast is
again totally absent, or, more correctly, we might say that
outside the embryo the lower layer cells do not become differ-
entiated into hypublast and mesoblast, and remain continuous
only with the lower of the two layers into which the lower
layer cells become differentiated in the body of embryo. ‘This
state of things is not really very different from what we find
in the Chick. Here outside the embryo (#. e. in the opaque
area) there is a layer of cells in which no differentiation .
into hypoblast and mesoblast takes place, but the layer
remains continuous rather with the mesoblast than the
hypoblast.

There is one peculiarity in the formation of the mesoblast
which I wish to call attention to, 7. e. its formation as two
lateral masses, one on each side of the middle line, but not
continuous across this line (vide figs. 6a and 6 4, and7 aand
76). Whether this remarkable condition is the most primi-
tive, 2. ¢. whether, when in the stage before this the mesoblast

336 F. M. BALFOUR,

is first formed, it is only on each side of the middle line that
the differentiation of the lower layer cells into hypoblast and
mesoblast takes place, I do not certainly know, but it is
undoubtedly a very early condition of the mesoblast. The
condition of the mesoblast as two plates, one on each side of
the neural canal, is precisely similar to its embryonic condi-
tion in many of the Vermes, e.g. Ewaxes and Lumbricus. In
these there are two plates of mesoblast, one on each side of
the nervous cord, which are known as the Germinal streaks
(Keimstreifen) (vide Kowalevsky Wiirmern u. Arthropoden;
Mém. de l’Acad. Imp. St. Petersbourg, 1871).

From longitudinal sections I have found that the seg-
mentation cavity has ceased by this stage to have any distinct
existence, but that the whole space between the epiblast
and the yolk is filled up with a mass of elongated cells, which
probably are solely concerned in the formation of the vas-
cular system. The thickened posterior edge of the blastoderm
is still visible.

At the embryonic end of the blastoderm, as I pointed out
in an earlier stage, the epiblast and the lower layer cells are
perfectly continuous.

Where they join the epiblast, the lower layer cells become
distinctly divided, and this division commenced even in the
earlier stage, into two layers ; a lower one, more directly con-
tinuous with the epiblast, consisting of cells somewhat re-
sembling the epiblast-cells, and an upper one of more
flattened cells (Pl. XIII, fig. 4,m). The first of these forms
the hypoblast, and the latter the mesoblast. They are indi-
cated by Ay and m in the figures. The hypoblast, as I said
before, remains continuous with the whole of the rest of
lower layer cells of the blastoderm (vide fig. 7 6). This
division into hypoblast and mesoblast commences at the
earlier stage, but becomes much more marked during this
one.

In describing the formation of the hypoblast and mesoblast
in this way I have assumed that they are formed out of the
large mass of lower layer cells which underlie the epiblast at
the embryonic end of the blastoderm. But there is another
and, in some ways, rather a tempting view, viz. to suppose
that the epiblast, where it becomes continuous with the hy-
poblast, in reality becomes involuted, and that from this
involuted epiblast are formed the whole mesoblast and
hypoblast.

In this case we would be compelled to suppose that the
mass of lower layer cells which forms the embryonic swelling
is used as food for the growth of the involuted epiblast, or

ON THE DEVELOPMENT OF THE ELASMOBRANCH FISHES. 33%

else employed solely in the growth over the yolk of the
non-embryonic portion of the blastoderm; but the latter
possibility does not seem compatible with my sections.

I do not believe that it is possible, from the examination
of sections alone, to decide which of these two views (viz.
whether the epiblast is involuted, or whether it becomes
merely continuous with the lower layer cells) is the true one.
The question must be decided from other considerations.

The following ones have induced me to take the view that
there is no involution, but that the mesoblast and hypoblast
are formed from the lower layer cells.

(1) That it would be rather surprising to find the mass of
lower layer cells which forms the “embryo swelling” playing
no part in the formation of embryo.

(2) That the view that it is the lower layer cells from
which the hypoblast and mesoblast are derived agrees
with the mode of formation of these two layers in the Bird,
and also in the Frog; since although, in the latter animal,
there is an involution, this is not of the epiblast, but of
the larger cells of lower pole of the yolk, which in part cor-
respond with what I have called the lower layer cells in the
Dog-fish.

If the view be accepted that it is from the lower layer
cells that the hypoblast and mesoblast are formed, it becomes
necessary to explain what the continuity of the hypoblast
with the epiblast means.

The explanation of this is, I believe, the keystone to the
whole position. The vertebrates may be divided as to their
early development into two classes, viz. those with holo-
blastic ova, in which the digestive canal is formed by an
involution with the presence of an “‘ anus of Rusconi.”

This class includes “ Amphioxus,” the “‘ Lamprey,” the
“ Sturgeon,” and “ Batrachians.”’

The second class are those with meroblastic ova and no
anus of Rusconi, and with an alimentary canal formed by the
infolding of the sheet of hypoblast, the digestive canal re-
maining in communication with the food-yolk for the greater
part of embryonic life by an umbilical canal.

This class includes the ‘‘ Elasmobranchii,” ‘‘ Osseous
fish,” “ Reptiles,” and ‘‘ Aves.”

The mode of formation of the alimentary canal in the
first class is clearly the more primitive; and it is equally
clear that its mode of formation in the second class is an
adaptation due to the presence of the large quantity of food-
yolk.

In the Dog-fish I believe that we can see, to a certain

338 ¥. M. BALFOUR,

extent, how the change from the one to the other of these
modes of development of the alimentary canal took place.

In all the members of the first class, viz. ‘““Amphioxus,” the
**Lamprey,” the “Sturgeon,” and the “ Batrachians,” the
epiblast becomes continuous with the hypoblast at the so-
called ‘anus of Rusconi,” and the alimentary canal, poten-
tially in all and actually in the Sturgeon (vide Kowa-
levsky, Owsjannikow, and Wagner, ‘ Bulletin der Acad. d.
St. Petersbourg,’ vol. xiv, 1870, “ Entwicklung der Store’),
communicates freely at its extreme hind end with the neural
canal. The same is the ease in the Dog-fish. In these,
when the folding in to form the alimentary canal on the one
hand, and the neural on the other, takes place, the two
foldings unite at the corner, where the epiblast and hypo-
blast are in continuity, and place the two tubes, the neural
and alimentary, in free communication with each other.

There is, however, nothing corresponding with the “ anus
of Rusconi,” which merely indicates the position of the
involution of the digestive canal, and subsequently completely
closes up, though it nearly coincides in position with the
true anus in the Batrachians, &c.

This remarkable point of similarity between the Dog-fish’s
development and the normal mode of development in the first
class (the holoblastic) of vertebrates, renders it quite clear
that the continuity of the epiblast and hypoblast in the Dog-
fish is really the remnant of a more primitive condition, when
the alimentary canal was formed by an involution. Besides
the continuity between neural and alimentary canals, we have
other remnants of the primitive involution. Amongst these
the most marked is the formation of the embryonic rim,
which is nothing less than the commencement of an inyolu-
tion. Its form is due to the flattened, sheet-like condition
of the germ. In the mode in which the alimentary canal is
closed in front I shall show there are indications of the
primitive mode of formation of the alimentary canal; and in
certain peculiarities of the anus, which I shall speak of later,
we have indications of the primitive anus of Rusconi; and
finally, in the general growth of the epiblast (small cells of
the upper pole of the Batrachian egg) over the yolk (lower
pole of the Batrachian egg), we have an example of the
manner in which the primitive involution, to form the ali-
mentary canal, invariably disappears when the quantity of
yolk in an egg becomes very great.

I believe that in the Dog-fish we have before our eyes

! This has been already made out by Kowalevsky, “‘ Wurmern u. Arthro-
poden,” loc, cit.

ON THE DEVELOPMENT OF THE ELASMOBRANCH FISHES. 309

one of the steps by which a direct mode of formation comes
to be substituted for an éndirect one by involution. We find,
in fact,in the Dog-fish, that the cells from which are derived
the mesoblast and hypoblast come to occupy their final
position in the primitive arrangement of the cells during
segmentation, and not by a subsequent and secondary
involution.

This change in the mode of formation of the alimentary
canal is clearly a result of change of mechanical conditions
from the presence of the large food-yolk.

Excellent parallels to it will be found amongst the Mol-
lusca. In this class the presence or absence of food-yolk
produces not very dissimilar changes to those which are
produced amongst vertebrates from the same cause.

The continuity of the hypoblast and epiblast at the em-
bryonic rim is a remnant which, having no meaning or
function, except in reference to the earlier mode of develop-
ment, is likely to become lost, and in Birds no trace of it is
any longer to be found.

I will not in the present preliminary paper attempt
hypothetically to trace the steps by which the involution
gradually disappeared, though I do not think it would be
very difficult todo so. Nor will I attempt to discuss the
question whether the condition with a large amount of food-
yolk (as seems more probable) was twice acquired—once by
the Elasmobranchii and Osseous fishes, and once by Reptiles
and Birds—or whether only once, the Reptiles and Birds
being lineal descendants of the Dog-fish.

In reference to the former point, however, I may mention
that the Batrachians are to a certain extent intermediate in
condition between the Amphiovus and the Dog-fishes,
since in them the yolk becomes divided during segmenta-
tion into lower layer cells and epiblast, but a modified involu-
tion is still retained, while the Dog-fish may be looked upon
as intermediate between Birds and- Batrachians, the
continuity at the hind end between the epiblast and hypo-
blast being retained by them, though not the involution.

It may be convenient here to call attention to some of the
similarities and some of the differences which I have not yet
spoken of between the development of Osseous fish and the
Dog-fish in the early stages. The points of similarity
are—(1) The swollen edge of the blastoderm. (2) The
embryo-swelling. (3) The embryo-keel. (4) The spreading
of the blastodern over the yolk-sac from a point corresponding
with the position of the embryo, and not with the centre of
the germ. The growth is almost nothing at that point, and

VUL, XIV.—NEW SER. Z

340 ¥. M. BALFOUR.

most rapid at the opposite pole of the blastoderm, being
less and less rapid along points of the circumference in pro-
portion to their proximity to the embryonic swelling. (5) The
medullary groove.

In external appearance the early embryos of Dog-fish
and Teleostei are very similar; some of my drawings could
almost be substituted for those given by Oellacher. This
similarity is especially marked at the first appearance of
the medullary groove. Inthe Dog-fish the medullary groove
becomes converted into the medullary canal in the same way
as with Birds and all other vertebrates, except Osseous fishes, .
where it comes to nothing, and is, in fact, a rudimentary
organ. Butin spite of Oellacher’s assertions to the contrary, I
am convinced from the similarity of its position and appearance
to the true medullary groove in the Dog-fish, that the groove
which appears in Osseous fishes is the true medullary groove ;
although Oellacher appears to have conclusively proved that
it does not become converted into the medullary canal. The
chief difference between the Dog-fish and Osseous fish, in ad-
dition to the point of difference about the medullary groove,
is that the epiblast is in the Dog-fish a single layer, not
divided into nervous and epidermic layers as in Osseous fish,
and this difference is the more important, since, throughout
the whole period of development till after the commence-
ment of the formation of the neural canal, the epiblast remains
as a one-cell-deep layer of cells, and thus the possibility is
excluded of any concealed division into a neural and epi-
dermic layer, as has been supposed to be the case by Stricker
and others in Birds.

Development of the Embryo.

After the embryo has become definitely established, for
some time it grows rapidly in length, without. externally
undergoing other important changes, with the exception of
the appearance of two swellings, one on each side of its tail.

These swellings, which I will call the Caudal lobes
(figs. 8 and 9, ¢s), are also found in Osseous fishes, and
have been called by Oellacher the Hmbryonal saum. ‘They
are caused by a thickening of mesoblast on each side of
the hind end of the embryo, at the edge of the embryonic
rim, and form a very conspicuous feature throughout the
early stages of the development of the Dog-fish, and are still
more marked in the Torpedo (Pl. XIV, fig. 9). Although
from the surface the other changes which are visible are
very insignificant, sections show that the notochord is com-
mencing to be formed.

ON THE DEVELOPMENT OF THE ELASMOBRANCH FISHES. 341

I pointed out that beneath the medullary groove the
epiblast and hypoblast were not separated by any interposed
mesoblast. Along the line (where the mesoblast is defi-
cient) which forms the long axis of the embryo, a rod-like
thickening of the hypoblast appears (Pl. XIV, figs. 7 a and
76, ch and ch’), first at the head end of the embryo, and
gradually extending backwards. This is the rudiment of the
notochord ; it remains attached for some time to the hypo-
blast, and becomes separated from it first at the head end of
the embryo, and the separation is then carried backwards.
This thickening of the hypoblast projects up and comes in
contact with the epiblast, and in the later stages with bad
(especially chromic-acid) specimens the line of separation
between the epiblast and the thickening may become a little
obscured, and might possibly lead to the supposition that a
structure similar to that which has been called the “ axis
cord” was present. In all my best (osmic-acid) specimens the
line of junction is quite clear; and any one who is aware
how easily two separate masses of cells may be made indistin-
guishably to fuse together from simple pressure will not be
surprised to find the occasional obscurity of the line of junc-
tion between the epiblast and hypoblast. In the earlier
stage of the thickening there is never in the osmic-acid pre-
parations any appearance of fusion except in very badly
prepared ones. Its mode of formation will be quite clear
without further description from an inspection of Pl. XIV,
figs. 7a and 76, ch and ch’. Both are taken from one
embryo. In fig. 74, the most anterior of -the two, the
notochord has become quite separated from the hypoblast.
In fig. 7a, ch, there is only a very marked thickening of
hypoblast, which reaches up to the epiblast, but the thick-
ening is still attached to the hypoblast. Had I had space
to insert a drawing of a third section of the same embryo
there would only have been a slight thickening of the hypo-
blast. In the earlier stage it will be seen, by referring to
figs. 6a and 6 d, that there is no sign of a thickening of the
hypoblast. My numerous sections (all made from embryos
hardened in osmic acid) showing these points are so clear that
I do not think there can be any doubt whatever of the noto-
chord being formed as a thickening of the hypoblast. ‘Two
interpretations of this seem possible. ;

I mentioned that the mesoblast appeared to be primitively
formed as two independent sheets, split off’, so to speak, from
the hypoblast, one on each side of the middle line of the
embryo. If we looked upon the notochord as a third median
sheet of mesoblast, split off from the hypoblast somewhat later

342 F. M. BALFOUR.

than the other two, we should avoid having to admit its hypo-
blastic origin.

Professor Huxley, to whom I have shown my specimens,
strongly advocates this view.

The other possibility is that the notochord is primitively
a true hypoblastic structure which has only by adaptation
become an apparently mesodlastic one in the higher verte-
brates. In favour of this view are the following con-
siderations :

(1) That this is the undoubtedly natural interpretation of
the sections. (2) That the notochord becomes separated
from the hypoblast after the latter has acquired its typical
structure, and differs in that respect from the two lateral
sheets of mesoblast, which are formed coincidently with the
hypoblast by a homogeneous mass of cells becoming differen-
tiated into two distinct layers. (8) That the first mode of
looking at the matter really proves too much, since it is
clear that by the same method of reasoning we could prove
the mesoblastic origin of any organ derived from the hypo-
blast and budded off into the mesoblast. We should merely
have to assert that it was really a mass of mesoblast budded
off from the hypoblast rather later than the remainder of the
mesoblast. Still, it must be admitted that the first view I have
suggested is a possible, not to say a probable one, though
the mode of arguing by which it can be upheld may be
rather dangerous if generally applied. We ought not, how-
ever, for that reason necessarily reject it in the present case.
As Mr. Ray Lankester pointed out to me, if we accept the
hypoblastic origin of the notochord, we should find a partial
parallel to it in the endostyle of Tunicates, and it is perhaps
interesting to note in reference to it that the notochord is the
only unsegmented portion of the axial skeleton.

Whether the strong @ priori arguments against the hypo-
blastic origin of the notochord are sufficient to counter-
balance the natural interpretations of my sections, cannot,
I think, be decided from the single case of the Dog-fish.
It is to be hoped that more complete investigations of the
Lamprey, &c., may throw further light upon the question.

Whichever view of the primitive origin of the notochord
is the true one, its apparent origin is very instructive as
illustrating the possible way in which an organ might come
to change the layer to which it primarily belonged.

If the notochord is originally a mesoblastic structure, it
is easy to be seen how, by becoming separated from the hypo-
blast a little later than is the case with the Dog-fish, its true
mesoblastic origin would become lost; while if, on the other

+ aS hy

ON THE DEVELOPMENT OF THE ELASMOBRANCH FISHES. 343

hand, it is primitively a hypoblastic structure, we see from
higher vetebrates how, by becoming separated from the
hypoblast rather earlier than in the Dog-fish, viz. at the same
time as the rest of the mesoblast, its primitive derivation
from the hypoblast has become concealed.

The view seemingly held by many embryologists of the
present day, that an organ, when it was primitively derived
from one layer, can never be apparently formed in another
layer, appears to me both unreasonable on @ priori grounds
and also unsupported by facts.

I see no reason for doubting that the embryo in the
earliest periods of development is as subject to the laws of
natural selection as is the animal at any other period.
Indeed, there appear to me grounds for the thinking that it is
more so. The remarkable differences in allied species as to
the amount of food-yolk, which always entail corresponding
alterations in the development—the different modes of
segmentation in allied species, such as are found in the
Amphipoda and Isopoda—the suppression of many stages
in freshwater species, which are retained in the allied
marine species—are all instances of modifications due to
natural selection affecting the earliest stages of development.
If such points as these can be affected by natural selection
I see no reason why the arrangement of individual cells (or
rather primitive elements) should not also be modified ;
why, in fact, a mass of cells which was originally derived
from one layer, but in the course of development became
budded off from that layer and entered another layer, should
not by a series of small steps cease ever to be attached to
the original layer, but from the first moment it can be dis-
tinguished should be found as a separate mass in the second
layer.

The change of layers will, of course, only take place
where some economy is effected by it. The variations in the
mode of development of the nervous system may probably be
explained in this way.

If we admit that organs can undergo changes, as to the
primitive layer from which they are derived, important
consequences must follow.

It will, for instance, by no means be sufficient evidence of
two organs not being homologous that they are not deve-
loped from the same layer. It renders the task of tracing
out the homologies from development much more difficult
than if the ordinary view of the invariable correspondence of
the three layers throughout the animal kingdom be accepted.
Although I do not believe that this correspondence js invari-

B44 F. M. BALFOUR.

able or exact, I think that we both find and should expect
to find that it is, roughly speaking, fairly so.

Thus, the muscles, internal skeleton, and connective tissue
are always placed in the adult between the skin (epidermis)
and the epithelium of the alimentary canal.

We should therefore expect to find them, and, as a matter
of fact, we always do find them, developed from a middle
layer when this is present.

The upper layer must always and does always form the
epidermis, and similarly the lower layer or hypoblast must
form a part of the epithelium of the alimentary canal.
A full discussion of this question would, however, lead me
too far away from my present subject.

The only other point of interest which I can touch on in
this stage is the commencing closure of the alimentary canal
in the region of the head. This is shown in Pl. XIII, fig.
6a,66, and Pl. XIV, 74, 7.a. From these figures it can be
seen that the closing does not take place as much by an in-
folding as by an ingrowth from the side walls of the alimentary
canal towards the middle line. In this abnormal mode of
closing of the alimentary canal we have again, I believe, an
intermediate stage between the mode of formation of the
alimentary canal in the Frog and the typical folding im which
occurs in Birds. There is, however, another point in refer-
ence to it which is still more interesting. The cells to form
the ingrowth from the bottom (ventral) wall of the alimentary
canal are derived by a continuous fresh formation from the
yolk, being formed around the nuclei spoken of above (vide
p-. 829). All my sections show this with more or less clear-
ness, especially those a little later than fig. 6 6, in which the
lower wall of the alimentary canal is nearly completed. This
is the more interesting since, from the mode of formation of
the alimentary canal in the Batrachians, &c., we might expect
that the cells from the yolk would take a share in its forma-
tion in the Dog-fish. I have not as yet made out for certain
the share which is taken by these freshly formed cells of the
yolk in the formation of any other organ.

By the completion of its lower wall in the way described,
the throat early becomes a closed tube, its closing taking
place before any other important changes are visible in the
embryo from surface views.

A considerable increase in length is attained before other
changes than an increase in depth of the medullary groove
and a more complete folding off of the embryo from the
blastoderm take place. The first important change is the
formation of the protovertebree,

_

ON THE DEVELOPMENT OF THE ELASMOBRANCH FISHES. 345

These are formed by the lateral plates of mesoblast, which
I said were equivalent at once to the vertebral and lateral
plates in the Bird, becoming split by transverse divisions into
cubical masses,

At the time when this occurs, and, indeed, up till a con-
siderably later period, the mesoblast is not split into somato-
pleure and splanchnopleure, and it is not divided into
vertebral and lateral plates. The transverse lines of division
of the protovertebre do not, however, extend to the outer
edge of the undivided lateral plates.

The differences between this mode of formation of the
protovertebree and that occurring in Birds are too obvious
to require pointing out. I will speak of them more fully
when I have given the whole history of the protovertebre
of the Dog-fish.

I will only now say that I have had in the early stages to
investigate the formation of the protovertebre entirely by
means of sections, the objects being too opaque to be other-
wise studied.

The next change of any importance is the commencement
of the formation of the head. The region of the head first
becomes distinguishable by the flattening out of the germ at
its front end.

The flattened-out portion of the germ grows rapidly, and
forms a spatula-like termination to the embryo (Pl. XIII,
fig. 8).

ha a region of the head the medullary groove is at first
totally absent (vide section, Pl. XIV, fig. 8 a).

Indeed, as can be seen from fig. 8 J, the laminz dorsales, so
far from bending up at this stage, actually bend down in the
opposite direction.

I am at present quite unable even to form a guess what
this peculiar feature of the brain means. It, no doubt, has
some meaning in reference to the vertebrate ancestry if we
could only discover it. The peculiar spatula-like flattened
condition of the head is also (vide loc. ant. cit.) appa-
rently found in the Sturgeons; it must therefore almost
undoubtedly be looked upon as not merely an accidental
peculiarity.

While these changes have been taking place in the head
not less important changes have occurred in the remainder
of the body. In the first place the two caudal lobes have
increased in size, and have become, as it were, pushed in
together, leaving a groove between them (fig. 8,¢s). They
are very conspicuous objects, and, together with the spatula-
like head, give the whole embryo an almost comical appear-

346 F. M. BALFOUR.

ance. The medullary canal has by this time become com-
pletely closed in the region of the tail (figs. 8 and 8 d).

It is still widely open in the region of the back, and,
though more nearly closed again in the neck, is, as I have
said, flattened out to nothing in the head.

The groove! between the two caudal lobes must not be
confused (as may easily be done) with the medullary groove,
which by the time the former groove has become con-
spicuous 1s a completely closed canal.

The vertebral plates are not divided (vide fig. 7) into a
somatopleuric and splanchnopleuric layer by this stage, ex-
cept in the region of the head (vide fig. 8 a, pp’), where
there is a distinct space between the two layers, which is
undoubtedly homologous with the pleuro-peritoneal cavity of
the hinder portion of the body.

It is probably the same cavity which Oellacher (loc. cit.)
calls in Osseous fishes the pericardial cavity. In the Dog-
fish, at least, it has no connection with the pericardium.
Of its subsequent history I shall say a few words when I
come to speak of the later stages.

The embryo does not take more than twenty-four hours in
passing from this stage, when the head is a flat plate, to the
stage when the whole neural canal (including the region of
the head) is closedin. The other changes, in addition to the
closing in of the neural canal, are therefore somewhat insig-
nificant. The folding off of the embryo from the germ has,
however, progressed considerably, and a portion of the hind
gut is closed in below. ‘This is accomplished, not by a tail-
fold, as in Birds, but by two lateral folds, which cause the
sides of the body to meet and coalesce below. At the extreme
hind end, where the epiblast is continuous with the hypo-
blast, the lateral folds turn round, so to speak, and become
continuous with the medullary folds, so that when the various
folds meet each other an uninterrupted canal is found
passing round from the neural into the alimentary canal, and
placing these two in communication at the tail end of the
body. Since I have already mentioned this, and spoken of
its significance, I will not dwell on it further here.

The cranial flexure commences coincidently with the closing
in of the neural canal in region of the brain, and the division
into fore, mid, and hind brain becomes visible at the same
time as or even before the closing of the canal occurs. The
embryo has now become more or less transparent, and proto-

1 This groove is the only structure which if seems possible to compare

with the so-called “ primitive groove” of Birds, It is, however, doubtful
whether they are really homologous, o

ON THE DEVELOPMENT OF THE ELASMOBRANCH FISHES. 347

vertebre, of which about twenty are present, can now be
seen in the fresh specimens. The heart, however, is not yet
formed.

Up to this period, a period at which the embryo becomes
very similar in external appearance to any other vertebrate
embryo, I have followed in my description a chronological
order. I shall now cease to do so, since it would be too long
for a preliminary notice of this kind, but shall confine myself
to the history of a few organs whose development is either
more important or more peculiar than that of the others.

The Protovertebre.

I have thought it worth while to give a short history of the
development of the protovertebre, firstly, because it is very
easy to follow this in the Dog-fish, and, secondly, because I
believe that the Dog-fish have more nearly retained the primi-
tive condition of the protovertebre than any other vertebrate
whose embryology has hitherto been described with sufficient
detail.

I intend to describe, at the same time, the development of
the spinal nerves.

I left each lateral mass of mesoblast in my last stage as
a plate which had not yet become split into a somatic and
a splanchnic sheet (Pl. XIV, fig. 8 a, v p), but which had
become cut by transverse lines (not, indeed, extending to the
outer limit of the sheet, but as yet not cut off by longitudinal
lines of cleavage) into segments, which I called proto-
vertebre.

This sheet of mesoblast is fairly thick at its proximal
(upper) end, but thins off laterally to a sheet two cells deep,
and its cells are so arranged as to foreshadow its subse-
quent splitting into somatic and splanchnic sheets. Its upper
(proximal) end is at this stage level with the bottom of the
neural canal, but soon begins to grow upwards, and at the
same time the splitting into somatopleure and splanchno-
pleure commences (Pl. XIV, fig. 10, so and sp),

The separation between the two sheets is first visible in its
uppermost part, and thence extends outwards. By this means
each of the protovertebrze becomes divided into two sheets,
which are only connected at their upper ends and outside the
region of the body. Ispeak of the whole lateral sheet as being
composed of protovertebrz, because at this time uo separa-
tion into vertebral and lateral plates can be seen; but I may
anticipate matters by saying that only the upper portion of the
sheet from the level of the top of the digestive canal, becomes
subsequently the true protoyertebrz; so that it is clear that

348 F, M. BALFOUR.

the pleuro-peritoneal cavity extends primitively quite up to
the top of the protovertebre ; and that thus a portion of a
sheet of mesoblast, at first perfectly continuous with the
splanchnic sheet from which is derived the muscular wall of
the alimentary canal, is converted into a part of the voluntary
muscular system of the body, having no connection whatever
with the involuntary muscular system of the digestive tract.

The pleuro-peritoneal cavity is first distinctly formed at a
time when only two visceral clefts are present. Before the
appearance of a third visceral cleft in a part of the imner-
most layer of each protovertebre (which may be called the
splanchnic layer, from its being continuous with the meso-
blast of the splanchnopleure), opposite the bottom of the
neural tube, some of the cells commence to become distin-
guishable from the rest, and to form a separate mass. This
mass becomes much more distinct a little later, its cells
being characterised by being spindle-shaped, and having an
elongated nucleus which becomes deeply stained by reagents
(Pl. XV, fig. 11, mp’). Coincidently with its appearance thé
young Dog-fish commences spontaneously to move rapidly
from side to side with a kind of serpentine motion, so that, even
if I had not traced the development of this differentiated mass
of cells till it becomes a band of muscles close to the noto-
chord, I should have had little doubt of its muscular nature.
It is indicated in figs. 11,12, 13, by the letters mp’. Its
early appearance is most probably to be looked upon as an
alaptation consequent upon the respiratory requirements of
the young Dog-fish necessitating movements within the egg.

Shortly after this date, at a period when three visceral
clefts are present, I have detected the first traces of the
spinal nerves.

At this time they appear in sections as small elliptical
masses of cells, entirely independent of the protovertebre, and
closely applied to the upper and outer corners of the involuted
epiblast of the neural canal (Pl. XV, fig. 11, sp). These
bodies are far removed from any mesoblastic structures, and
at the same time the cells composing them are not similar to
the cells composing the walls of the neural canal, and are
not attached to these, though lying in contact with them. I
have not, therefore, sufficient evidence at present to enable
me to say with any certainty where the spinal nerves are
derived from in the Dog-fish. They may be derived from
the involuted epiblast of the neural canal, and, indeed, this
is the most natural interpretation of their position.

On the other hand, it is possible that they are formed from
wandering cells of the mesoblast—a possibility which, with

ON THE DEVELOPMENT OF THE ELASMOBRANCH FISHES, 349

our present knowledge of wandering cells, must not be thrown
aside as altogether improbable.

In any case, it is clear that the condition in the Bird,
where the spinal nerves are derived from tissue of the proto-
vertebre, is not the primitive one. Of this, however, I will
speak again when I have concluded my account of the
development of the protovertebre.

About the same time that I have found the rudiments of
the nerves the division of the mesoblast of the sides of the
body into a vertebral and a lateral portion occurs. This
division first appears in the region where the oviduct (Miiller’s
duct) is formed (PI. XV, fig. 11, ov).

At this part opposite the level of the dorsal aorta the two
sheets, viz. the splanchnic and the somatic, unite together,
and thus each lateral sheet of mesoblast becomes divided into
an upper portion (fig. 11, m p), split up by transverse partitions
into protovertebre, and a lower portion not so split, but con-
sisting of an outer layer, the true somatopleure, and an inner
layer, the true splanchnopleure. These two divisions of the
primitive plate are thus separated by the line at which a fusion
between the mesoblast of the somatopleure and splanchno-
pleure takes place. The mass of cells resulting from the
fusion at this point corresponds with the intermediate cell-
mass of Birds (vide Waldeyer, ‘ Hierstock und Hi’).

At the same time, in the upper of these two sheets, the
splanchnic layer sends a growth of cells inwards towards
the notochord and the neural canal. his growth is the
commencement of the large quantity of mesoblastic tissue
around the notochord, which is in part converted into the
axial skeleton, and in part ito the connective tissue adjoining
this.

This mass of cells is at first quite continuous with the
splanchnic layer of the protovertebre, and I see no reason
for supposing that it is not derived from the growth of the
cells of this layer. The ingrowth to form it first appears
a little after the formation of the dorsal aorta; but, as far
as I have been able to see, its cells have no connection with
the walls of the aorta.

What I have said as to the development of the skeleton-
forming layer will be quite clear from figs. 11 and 12 a;
and from these it will also be clear, especially from fig. 11 a,
that the outermost layer of this mass of cells, which was the
primitive splanchnic layer of the protovertebree, still retains
its epithelial character, and so can easily be distinguished
from those cells which will form the skeleton. In the next
stage which I have figured (fig. 12 a), this outer portion of the

350 F M. BALFOUR.

splanchnic layer is completely separated from the skeleton-
forming cells, and at the same time. having united below as
well as above with the outer (somatic) layer of the two layers
of which the protovertebre are formed, the two together
form an independent mass (fig. 12, mp), similar in appearance
and in every way homologous with the muscle-plate of
Birds.

On the inner side of this, which we may now call the
muscle-plate, is seen the bundle of earlier-developed muscles
(fig. 12, mp’) which I spoke of before.

The section represented in fig. 12 is from a very consider-
ably later embryo than that represented in fig. 11, so that
the skeleton-forming cells, few in number in the earlier
section, have become very numerous in the later one, and
have grown up above the neural canal, and also below the
notochord, between the digestive canal and the aorta. They
have, moreover, changed their character; they were round
before, now they have become stellate. As to their further
history, I will only say that the layer of them immediately
around the notochord and neural canal forms the cartilaginous
centra and arches of the vertebre, and that the remaining
portion of them, which becomes much more insignificant in
size as compared with the muscles, forms the connective tissue
of the skeleton and of the parts around and between the
muscles.

A muscle-plate itself is at this stage (shown in fig. 12)
composed of an inner and an outer layer of epithelium
(splanchnic and somatic) united at the upper and lower ends
of the plate, and on the inner of the two lies the more
developed mass of muscles before spoken of (mm p’).

Each of these plates now grows both upwards and down-
wards; and at the same time connective-tissue cells appear
between the plates and epidermis; but from where they
come I do not know for certain; very probably they are
derived from the somatic layer of the muscle-plate.

While the muscle-plates continue to grow both upwards and
downwards, the cells of which they are composed commence
to become elongated and soon acquire an unmistakably
muscular character (Pl. XV, fig. 13, m p).

Before this has occurred the inner mass of muscles has also
undergone further development and become a large and
conspicuous band. of muscles close to the notochord (fig.
13, m p’).

At the same time that the muscle-plates acquire the true
histological character of muscle, septa of connective tissue
grow in and divide them into a number of distinct seg-

ON THE DEVELOPMENT OF THE ELASMOBRANCH FISHES, 351

ments, which subsequently form separate bands of muscle.
I will not say more in reference to the development of the
muscular system than that the whole of the muscles of the
body (apart from the limbs, the origin of whose muscular
system I have not yet investigated) are derived from the
muscle-plates which grow upwards above the neural canal and
downwards to the ventral surface of the body.

During the time the muscle-plates have been undergoing
these changes the nerve masses have also undergone develop-
mental changes.

They become more elongated and fibrous, their main
attachment to the neural tube being still at its posterior
(dorsal) surface, near which they first appeared. Later they
become applied closely to the sides of the neural tube and
send fibres to it below as well as above. Below (ventral to)
the neural tube a ganglion appears, forming only a slight
swelling, but containing a number of characteristic nerve-
cells. The ganglion is apparently formed just below the
junction of the anterior and posterior roots, though probably
the fibres of the two roots do not mix till below it.

The main points which deserve notice in the development
of the protovertebre are—

(1) That at the time when the mesoblast becomes split
herizontally into somatopleure and splanchnopleure the
vertebral and lateral plates are one, and the splitting extends
to the very top of the vertebral plate, so that the future
muscle-plates are divided into a splanchnic and somatic
layer, the space between which is at first continuous with
the pleuro-peritoneal cavity.

(2) That the following parts are respectively formed by
the vertebral and lateral plates :

(a) Vertebral plate. From the splanchnic layer of this, or
from cells which appear close to and continuous with it, the
skeleton, and connective tissue of the upper part of the body,
are derived.

The remainder of the plate, consisting of a splanchnic
and somatic layer, is entirely converted into the muscles of
the trunk, all of which are derived from it.

(6) Between the vertebral plate and the lateral plate is a
mass of cells where, as I mentioned above, the mesoblast of
the somatopleure and splanchnopleure fuse together. This
mass of cells is the equivalent of the intermediate cell mass
of Birds (vide Waldeyer, ‘ Hierstock und Ei’).

From it are derived the Wolffian bodies and duct, the
oviduct, the ovaries and the testis, and the connective tissue
of the parts adjoining these.

352 F. M. BALFOUR.

(c) The lateral plate. From the somatic layer of this is
derived the connective tissue of the ventral half of the body;
the mesoblast of the limbs, including probably the muscles,
and certainly the skeleton. From its splanchnic layer are
derived the muscles and connective tissue of the alimentary
canal.

(3) The spinal nerves are developed independently of the
protovertebrz, so that the protovertebre of the Elasmo-
branchii do not appear to be of such a complicated structure
as the protovertebrz of Birds.

The Digestive Canal.

I do not intend to enter into the whole history of the
digestive canal, but to confine myself to one or two points
of interest connected with it. These fall under two heads:

(1) The history of the portion of the digestive canal
between the anus and the end of the tail where the digestive
canal opens into the neural canal.

(2) Certain less well-known organs derived from the
digestive canal.

The anus is a rather late formation, but its position
becomes very early marked out by the hypoblast of the
digestive canal approaching at that point close to the surface,
whilst receding to some little distance from it on either side.
The portion of the digestive tract I propose at present dealing
with is that between this point, which I will call, for the sake
of brevity, the anus, and the hind end of the body. This
portion of the canal is at first very short; it is elliptical in
section, and of rather a larger bore than the remainder of
the canal. Its diameter becomes, however, slightly less as it
approaches the tail, dilating again somewhat at its extreme
end. It is lined by a markedly columnar epithelium.
Though at first very short, its length increases with the
growth of the tail, but at the same time its calibre con-
tinually becomes smaller as compared with the remainder of
the alimentary canal.

It commences to become smaller, first of all, near, though
not quite, at its extreme hind end, and thus becomes of a
conical shape; the base of the cone being just behind the
anus, while the apex of the cone is situated a short distance
from the hind end of the embryo. The extreme hind end,
however, at the same time does not diminish in size, and
becomes relatively (if not also absolutely) much larger in
diameter than it was at first, as compared with the remainder
of the digestive canal. It becomes, in fact, a vesicle or
vesicular dilatation at the end of a conical canal.

oe

ON THE DEVELOPMENT OF THE ELASMOBRANCH FISHES, 353

Just before the appearance of the external gills this part of
the digestive canal commences to atrophy. It begins to do
so close to the terminal vesicle, which, however, still remains
as or more conspicuous than it was before. The lumen of
the canal becomes smaller and smaller, and finally it becomes
a solid string of cells, and these also soon disappear and not
a trace of the canal is left.

Almost the whole of it has disappeared before the vesicle
begins to atrophy, but very shortly after all trace of the rest
of the canal has vanished the terminal vesicle also vanishes.
This occurs just about the time or shortly after the appear-
ance of the external gills—there being slight differences
probably in this respect in the different species.

In this history there are two points of especial interest :

(1) The terminal vesicle.

(2) The disappearance of a large and well-developed por-
tion of the alimentary canal.

The interest in the terminal vesicle lies in the possibility
of its being some rudimentary structure.

In Osseous fishes Kuppfer has described the very early
appearance of a vesicle near the tail end, which he doubtfully
speaks of as the “allantois.” The figure he gives of it in
his earlier paper (‘ Archiv. fiir Micro. Anat.’ vol, li, pl. xxiv,
fig. 2) bears a very strong resemblance to my figures of this
vesicle at the time when the hind end of the alimentary
canal is commencing to disappear ; and I feel fairly confident
that it is the same structure as I have found in the Dog-fish:
but until the relations of the Kuppfer’s vesicle to the ali-
mentary canal are known, any comparison between it and the
terminal vesicle in the Dog-fish must be to a certain extent
guess-work.

I have, however, been quite unsuccessful in finding any
other vesicular structure which can possibly correspond to
the so-called allantoic vesicle of Osseous fish.

The disappearance of a large portion of the alimentary
canal behind the anus is very peculiar. In order, however,
to understand the whole difficulties of the case I shall be
obliged to speak of the relations of the anus of the Dog-fish
to the anus of Rusconi in the Lamprey, &c.

In those vertebrates whose alimentary canal is formed by
an involution, the anus of Rusconi represents the opening of
this involution, and therefore the point where the alimentary
canal primitively communicates with the exterior. When,
- however, the “ anus of Rusconi” becomes closed, the wall of
the alimentary canal still remains at that point in close
juxtaposition to the surface, and the new and final anus is

354 F. M. BALFOUR,

formed at or close to that point. In the Dog-fish, although
the anus of Rusconi is not present, still, during the closing
of the alimentary canal, the point which would correspond
with this becomes marked out by the alimentary canal there
approaching ‘the surface, and it is at this point that the
involution to form the true anus subsequently appears.

The anus in the Dog-fish has thus, more than a mere
secondary significance. It corresponds with the point of
closing of the primitive involution. If it was not for this
peculiarity of the vertebrate anus we would naturally sup-
pose, from the disappearance of a considerable portion of the
alimentary canal lying behind its present termination, that
in the adult the alimentary canal once extended much
farther back than at present, and that the anus we now find
was only a secondary anus, and not the primitive one. It is
perhaps possible that this hinder portion of the alimentary
canal is a result of the combined growth of the tail and the
persisting continuity (at the end of the body) of the epi-
blast with the hypoblast.

Whichever view is correct, it may be well to mention, in
order to show that the difficulty about the anus of Rusconi
is no mere visionary one, that Gotte (“ Untersuchung ther
die Entwickelung der Bombinator igneus,” ‘Archiv. fir
Micro. Anat.,’ vol. v, 1869) has also described the disappear-
ance of the hind portion of the alimentary canal in Batra-
chians, a rudiment (according to him) remaining in the shape
of a lymphatic trunk.

It is, perhaps, possible that we have a further remnant of
this “hind portion” of the alimentary canal amongst the
higher vertebrates in the “ allantois.”

Organs developed from the Digestive Canad.

In reference to the development of the liver, pancreas, &c.,
as far as my observations have at present gone, the Dog-fish
presents no features of peculiar interest. The liver is de-
veloped as in the Bird, and independently of the yolk.

There are, however, two organs derived from the hypoblast
which deserve more attention. Immediately under the noto-
chord, and in contact with it (vide P]. XIV, fig. 10; XV, 11
and 12, 2), a small roundish (in section) mass of cells is to
be seen in most of the sections.

Its mode of development is shown in fig. 10, xz. That
section shows a mass of cells becoming pinched off from the
top of the alimentary canal. By this process of pinching off
from the alimentary canal a small rod-like body close under
the notochord is formed. It persists till after the appearance

ON THE DEVELOPMENT OF THE ELASMOBKANCH FISHES, 355

of the external gills, but later than that I have not hitherto
succeeded in finding any trace of it.

It was first seen by Gétte (loc. cit.) in the Batrachians,
and he gave a correct account of its development, and added
that it became the thoracic duct.

I have not myself worked out the later stages in the de-
velopment of this body with sufficient care to be in a posi-
tion to judge of the correctness of Gdtte’s statements as to
its final fate. If it is true that it becomes the thoracic duct
it is very remarkable, and ought to throw some light upon
the homologies of the lymphatic system.

Some time before the appearance of the external gills
another mass of cells becomes, I believe, constricted off from
the part of the alimentary canal in the neighbourhood of the
anus, and forms a solid rod composed at first of dark
granular cells lying between the Wolffian ducts. I have
not followed out its development quite completely, but I
have very little doubt that it is really constricted off from a
portion of the alimentary canal chiefly in front of the point
where the anus appears, but also, I believe, from a small
portion behind this.

Though the cells of which it is composed are at first
columnar and granular (fig. 12, s wu, 7), they soon begin to
become altered, and in the latter stage of its development
the body forms a conspicuous rounded mass of cells with clear
protoplasm, and each provided with a large nucleus. Later
still it becomes divided into a number of separate areas of
cells by septa of connective tissue, in which (the septa) capil-
laries are also present. Since I have not followed it to its
condition in the adult, I cannot make any definite statements
as to the fate of this body; but I think that it possibly
becomes the so-called supra-renal organ, which in the Dog-
fish forms a yellowish elongated body lying between the two
kidneys.

The development of the Wolffian Duct and Body and of the
Oviduct.

The development of the Wolffian duct and the Oviduct in
the various classes of vertebrates is at present involved in
some obscurity, owing to the very different accounts given
by different observers.

The manner of development of these parts in the Dog-fish
is different from anything that previous investigators have
met with in other classes, but I believe that it gives a clearer
insight into the true constitution of these parts than
vertebrate embryology has hitherto supplied, and at the same

VOL. XIV.—NEW SER. AA

356 F. M. BALFOUR.

time renders easier the task of understanding the differences
in the modes of development in the different classes.

I shall commence with a simple description of the observed
facts, and then give my view as to their meaning. At about
the time of the appearance of the third visceral cleft, and a
short way behind the point up to which the alimentary canal
is closed in front, the splanchnopleure and somatopleure —
fuse together opposite the level of the dorsal aorta.

From the mass of cells formed by this fusion a solid knob
rises up towards the epiblast (Pl. XV, fig. 11 6, ov), and from
this knob a solid rod of cells grows backwards towards the ©
tail (fig. 11 ¢, o v) very closely applied to the epiblast. This ©
description will be rendered clear by referring to figs. 11 4
ande. Fig. 11 bisa section at the level of the knob, and
fig. 11 ¢ is a section of the same embryo a short way behind ~
this point. So closely does the rod of cells apply itself to
the epiblast that it might very easily be supposed to be
derived from it. Such, indeed, was at first my view till I cut
a section passing through the knob. In order, however, to
avoid all possibility of mistake I made sections of a large ©
number of embryos of about the age at which this appears, —
and invariably found the large knob in front, and from it the —
solid string growing backwards.

This string is the commencement of the Oviduct or Miiller’s
duct, which in the Dog-fish as in the Batrachians is the first
portion of the genito-urinary system to appear, and is in the
Dog-fish undoubtedly at first solid. All my specimens have
been hardened with osmic acid, and with specimens hardened
with this reagent it is quite easy to detect even the very —
smallest hole in a mass of cells.

As a solid string or rod of cells the Oviduct remains for
some time; it grows, indeed, rapidly in length, the extreme
hind length of the rod being very small and the front end
continuing to remain attached to the knob. The knob, how-
ever, travels inwards and approaches nearer and nearer to the ©
true pleuro-peritoneal cavity, always remaining attached to
the intermediate cell mass.

At about the time when five visceral clefts are present the
Oviduct first begins to get a lumen and to open at its front
end into the pleuro-peritoneal cavity. The cells of the rod
are first of all arranged in an irregular manner, but gradu-
ally become columnar and acquire a radiating arrangement
around a central point. At this point, where the ends of all
the cells meet, a very small hole appears, which gradually
grows larger and becomes the cavity of the duct (fig. 12, ov).
The hole first makes its appearance at the anterior end of the

ON THE DEVELOPMENT OF THE ELASMOBRANCH FISHES. 357

duct, and then gradually extends backwards, so that the hind
end is still without a lumen, when the lumen of the front
end is of a considerable size.

At the front knob the same alteration in the cells takes
place as in the rest of the duct, but the cells become deficient
on the side adjoining the pleuro-peritoneal cavity, so that an
opening is formed into the pleuro-peritoneal cavity, which
soon becomes of a considerable size. Soon after its first
formation, indeed, the opening becomes so large that it may
be met in from two to three consecutive sections if these are
very thin.

Thus is formed the lumen of the Oviduct. The duct still,
at this age, ends behind without having become attached to
the cloaca, so that at this time the Oviduct is a canal closed
behind, but communicating in front by a large opening with
the pleuro-peritoneal cavity.

It has during this time been travelling downwards, and is
now much nearer the pleuro-peritoneal cavity than the
epiblast.

It may be well to point out that the mode of development
which I have described is really not very different from an
involution, and must, in fact, be only looked upon as a
modification of an involution. Many examples from all
classes in the animal kingdom could be selected to exemplify
how an involution may become simply a solid thickening.
In the Osseous fish nearly all the organs which are usually
formed by an involution have undergone this change in their
mode of development. I shall attempt to give reasons later
on for the solid form having been acquired in this particular
case of the Oviduct.

At about the time when a lumen appears in the Oviduct
the first traces of the Wolffian duct become visible.

At intervals along the whole length, between the front
and hind ends of the Oviduct, involutions arise from the
pleuro-peritoneal cavity (fig.12, a,p, w d) ou the inside (nearer
the middle line) of the Oviduct. The upper ends of these
numerous involutions unite together and form a string of
cells, at first solid, but very soon acquiring a lumen, and
becoming a duct which communicates (as it clearly must
from its mode of formation), at numerous points with the
pleuro-peritoneal cavity. It is very probable that there is
one involution to each segment of the body between the front
and hind ends of the Oviduct. This duct is the Wolffian duct,
which thus, together with the Oviduct, is formed before the
appearance of the external gills.

For a considerable period the front end of the Oviduct

358 ¥, M. BALFOUR.

does not undergo important changes ; the hind end, however,
comes into connection with the extreme end of the ali-
mentary canal. The two Oviducts do not open together into
the cloaca, thongh, as my sections prove, their openings
are very close together. The whole Oviduct, as might be
expected, shares in the general growth, and its lumen be-
comes in both sexes very considerably greater than it was
before.

It is difficult to define the period at which I find these
changes accomplished without giving drawings of the whole
embryo. The stage is one considerably after the external
gills have appeared, but before the period at which the
growth of the olfactory bulbs renders the head of an elongated
shape.

During the same period the Wolffian duct has undergone
most important changes. It has commenced to bud off
diverticula, which subsequently become the tubules of the
Wolffian body (vide fig. 13, wd). I am fairly satisfied that
the tubules are really budded off, and are not formed inde-
pendently in the mesoblast. The Dog-fish agrees so far with
Birds, where I have also no doubt the tubules of the Wolffian
body are formed as diverticula from the Wolffian duct.

The Wolffian ducts have also become much longer than
the Oviduct, and are now found behind the anus, though
they do not extend as far forward as does the Oviduct.

They have further acquired a communication with the
Oviduct, in the form of a narrow duct passing from each of
them into an Oviduct a short way before the latter opens
into the cloacal dilatation of the alimentary canal.

The canals formed by the primitive involution leading from
the pleuvro-peritoneal cavity into the Wolffian duct have
become much more elongated, and at the same time
narrower. One of these is shown in fig. 13, p, w d.

Any doubt which could possibly be entertained as to the
true character of the ducts whose development I have de-
scribed is entirely removed by the development of the
tubules of the Wolffian body. In the still later stage than
this further proofs are furnished involving the function of
the Oviduct. At the period when the olfactory lobes have
become so developed as to render the head of the typical
elongated shape of the adult, I find that the males and
females can be distinguished by the presence in the former
of the clasping appendages.' I find at this stage that in the
female the front ends of the Oviducts have approached the

) For the specimens of this age I am indebted to Professor Huxley.

ON THE DEVELOPMENT OF THE ELASMOBRANCH FISHES. 359

middle line, dilated considerably, and commenced to exhibit
at their front ends the peculiarities of the adult. In the
male they are much less conspicuous, though still present.

At the same time the tubules of the Wolffian body
become much more numerous, the Malpighian tufts appear,
and the ducts cease almost, if not entirely, to communicate
with the pleuro-peritoneal cavity. I have not made out
anything very definitely as to the development of the Mal-
pighian tufts, but I am inclined to believe that they arise
independently in the mesoblast of the intermediate cell mass.

The facts which I have made out in reference to the deve-
lopment of the Wolffian duct, especially of its arising as a
series of involutions from the pleuro-peritoneal cavity, will be
found, I believe, of the greatest importance in understanding
the true constitution of the Wolffian body. To this I will
return directly, but I first wish to clear the ground by
insisting upon one preliminary point.

From their development the Oviduct and Wolffian body ap-
pear to stand to each other in the relation of the Wolffian duct
being the equivalent to a series, so to speak, of Oviducts.

I pointed out before that the mode of development of the
Oviduct could only be considered as a modification of a simple
involution from the pleuro-peritoneal cavity. Its develop-
ment, both in the Birds and in the Batrachians as an involu-
tion, still more conclusively proves the truth of this view.

The explanation of its first appearing as a solid rod of
cells which keeps close to the epiblast is, 1 am inclined to
think, the following. Since the Oviduct had to grow a long
way backwards from its primitive point of involution, it was
clearly advantageous for it not to bore its way through the
mesoblast of the intermediate cell mass, but to pass between this
and the epiblast. This modification having been adopted, was
followed by the knob forming the origin of the duct coming to
be placed at the outside of the intermediate cell mass rather
than close to the pleuro-peritoneal cavity, a change which
necessitated the mode of development by an involution being
dropped and the solid mode of development substituted for
it, a lumen being only subsequently acquired.

In support of the modification in the development being
due to this cause is the fact that in Birds the modes of
development of the Wolffian duct and the Oviduct are in-
verted. The Wolffian duct there arises differently from its
mode of development in all the lower vertebrates as a solid
rod close to the epiblast.’

If the above explanation about the Oviduct be correct,

1 If Romiti’s observations (‘Archives fiir Mikr. Anatom.,’ vol. ix, p.

360 F. M. BALFOUR.

then it is clear that similar causes have produced a similar
modification in development (only with a different organ)
in Birds; while, at the same time, the primitive mode of
origin of the Oviduct (Miiller’s duct) has been retained by
them.

The Oviduct, then, may be considered as arising by an
involution from the pleuro-peritoneal cavity.

The Wolffian duct arises by a series of such involutions,
all of which are behind (nearer the tail) the involution to
form the Oviduct.

The natural interpretation of these facts is that in the place
of the Oviduct and Wolffian body there were primitively a
series of similar bodies (probably corresponding in number
with the vertebral segments), each arising by an involution
from the pleuro-peritoneal cavity ; and that the first of these
subsequently became modified to carry eggs, while the rest
coalesced to form the Wolffian duct.

If we admit that the Wolffian duct is formed by the
coalescence of a series of similar organs, we shall only have
to extend the suggestion of Gegenbaur as to the homology
of the Wolffian body in order to see its true nature. Gegen-
baur looks upon the whole urino-genital system as homo-
logous with a pair of segmental organs. Accepting its
homology with the segmental organs, its development in
Elasmobranchii proves that it is not one pair, but a series of
pairs of segmental organs with which the urino-genital system
is homologous. The first of these have become modified so
as to form the Oviducts, and the remainder have coalesced to
form the Wolffian ducts.

The part of a segmental organ which opens to the exterior
appears to be lost in the case of all but the last one, where
this part is still retained, and serves as the external opening
for all.

Whether the external opening of the first segmental organ
(Oviduct) is retained or not is doubtful. Supposing it has
been lost, we must look upon the external opening for the
Wolffian body as serving also for the Oviduct. In the case of

all other vertebrates whose development has been investi- |

gated (but the Elasmobranchii), the Wolffian duct arises by
a single involution, or, what is equivalent to it, the other
involutions having disappeared. This even appears to be
the case in the Marsipobranchii. In the adult Lamprey
the Wolffian duct terminates at its anterior end by a large
200) are correct, then the ordinary view of the Wolffian duct arising in

Birds as a solid rod at the outer corner of the protovertebre will have to
be abandoned.

-
ee eee

ON THE DEVELOPMENT OF THE ELASMOBRANCH FISHES. 361

ciliated opening into the pleuro-peritoneal cavity. It will,
perhaps, be found, when the development of the Marsipo-
branchii is more carefully studied, that there are primitively
a number of such openings.! The Oviduct, when present,
arises in other vertebrates as a single involution, strongly
supporting the view that its mode of formation in the
Dog-fish is fundamentally merely az involution.

The duct of the testes is, I have little doubt, derived from
the anterior part of the Wolffian body; if so, it must be
locked upon as not precisely equivalent to the Oviduct, but .
rather to a series of coalesced organs, each equivalent to
the Oviduct. The Oviduct is in the Elasmobranchil, as
in other vertebrates, primitively developed in both sexes.
In the male, however, it atrophies. I found it still visible
in the male Torpedos, though much smaller than in the
females near the close of intra-uterine life.

Whether or not these theoretical considerations as to the
nature of the Wolffian body and oviduct are correct, I believe
that the facts I have brought to light in reference to the de-
velopment of these parts in the Dog-fish will be found of
service to every one who is anxious to discover the true
relations of these parts.

Before leaving the subject I will say one or two words
about the development of the Ovary. In both sexes the
germinal epithelium (fig. 13) becomes thickened below the
Oviduct, and in both sexes a knob (in section but really a
ridge) comes to project into the pleuro-peritoneal cavity on
each side of the mesentery (fig. 13, p, ov). In both sexes,
but especially the females, the epithelium on the upper
surface of this ridge becomes very much thickened, whilst
subsequently it elsewhere atrophies. In the females, how-
ever, the thickened epithelium on the knob grows more and
more conspicuous, and develops a number of especially large
cells with large nuclei, precisely similar to Waldeyer’s (loc.
cit.) “‘ primitive ova” of the Bird. In the male the epithe-
lium on the ridge, though containing primitive Ova, is not as
conspicuous as in the female. Though I have not worked
out the matter further than this at present, I still have no
doubt that these projecting ridges become the Ovaries.

1 While correcting the proofs of this paper I have come across a memoir
of W. Miiler (‘ Uber die Persistenz der Urniere bei Myxine Glutinosa,’
‘Jenaische Zeitschrift,’ vol. vii, 1873), in which he mentions that in Myxine
the upper end of the Walffian duct communicates by numerous openings
with the pleuro-peritoneal cavity; this gives to the suggestion in the
text a foundation of fact.

362 F. M. BALFOUR,

The Head.

The study of the development of the parts of the head, on
account of the crowding of organs which occurs there, always
presents greater difficulties to the investigator than that of the -
remainder of the body. My observations upon it are cor-
respondingly incomplete. I have, however, made out a few
points connected with it in reference to some less well-known
organs, which I have thought it worth while calling attention
to in this preliminary account.

The continuation of the Pleuro-peritoneal Cavity into the
Head.

In the earlier part of this paper (p. 346) I called attention
to the extension of the separation between somatopleure and
splanchnopleure into the head, forming a space continuous
with the pleuro-peritoneal cavity (Pl. XIV, fig.8 a, p p’) ; this
becomes more marked in the next stage, and, indeed, the
pleuro-peritoneal cavity is present for a considerable time in
the head before it becomes visible elsewhere. At the time
of the appearance of the second visceral cleft it has become
for the most part atrophied, but there persist two separated
portions of it in front of the first cleft, and also remnants
of it less well marked between and behind the two clefts.
The visceral clefts necessarily divide it into separate parts.

The two portions in front of the first visceral cleft remain
very conspicuous till the appearance of the external gills,
and above the hinder one of the two the fifth nerve bifur-
cates.

These two are shown as they appear in a surface view in
fig. 14, pp’. They are in reality somewhat flattened spaces,
lined by a mesoblastic epithelium, the epithelium on the
inner surface of the space corresponding to the splanchno-
pleure, and that on the outer to the somatopleure.

T have not followed the history of these later than the time
of the appearance of the external gills.

The presence of the pleuro-peritoneal cavity in the head
is interesting, as showing the fundamental similarity between
the head and the remainder of the body.

The Pituitary Body.

All my sections seem to prove that it is a portion of the
epiblastic involution to form the mouth which is pinched off
to form the pituitary body, and not a portion of the hypo-
- blast of the throat. Since Gotte (‘ Archiv. fiir Micr. Anat.,’

ON THE DEVELOPMENT OF THE ELASMOBRACBH FISHES, 31,3

Bd. ix) has also found that the same is the case with the
Batrachians and Mammalia, I have little doubt it will be
found to be universally the case amongst vertebrates.

Probably the observations which lead to the supposition
that it was the throat which was pinched off to form the
pituitary body were made after the opening between the
mouth and throat was completed, when it would naturally
be impossible to tell whether the pinching off was from the
epiblast of the mouth involution or the hypoblast of the
throat.

The Cranial Nerves.

The cranial nerves in their early condition are so clearly
visible that I have thought it worth while giving a figure of
them, and calling attention to some points about their em-
bryonic peculiarities.

From my figure (14) it will be seen that there is behind
the auditory vesicle a nervous tract, from which four nerves
descend, and that each of these nerves is distributed to the
front portion of a visceral arch. When the next and last arch
(in this species) is developed, a branch from this nervous
mass will also pass down to it. That each of these is of an
equal morphological value can hardly be doubted.

The nerve to the third arch becomes the glosso-pharyngeal
(fig. 14, gl), the nerves to the other arches become the
branchial branches of the vagus nerve (fig. 14,vg). Thus the
study of their development strongly supports Gegenbaur’s
view of the nature of the vagus and glosso-pharyngeal, viz.
that the vagus is a compound nerve, each component part of
it which goes to an arch being equivalent to one nerve, such
as the glosso-pharyngeal.

Of the nerves in front of the auditory sac the posterior is
the seventh nerve (fig. 14, v1). Its mode of distribution to
the second arch leaves hardly a doubt that it is equivalent
to one such nerve as those distributed to the posterior arches.
Subsequently it acquires another branch, passing forwards
towards the arch in front.

The most anterior nerve is the fifth (fig. 14, v), of which
two branches are at this stage developed. ‘The natural inter-
pretation of its present condition is, that it is equivalent to
two nerves, but the absence of relation in its branches to any
visceral clefts renders it more difficult to determine the mor-
phology of the fifth nerve than of the other nerves. The
front branch of the two is the ophthalmic branch of the
adult, and the hind branch the inferior maxillary branch.
The latter branch subsequently gives off low down, 4. e.

364 ¥. M. BALFOUR ON DEVELOPMENT OF THE DOG-FisH.

near its distal extremity, another branch, the superior
maxillary branch.

In its embryonic condition this latter branch does not
appear like a third branch of the fifth, equivalent to the
seventh or the glosso-pharyngeal nerves, but rather resembles
the branch of the seventh nerve which passes to the arch in
front, which also is present in all the other cranial nerves.

Modes of Preparation.

Before concluding I will say one or two words as to my
modes of preparation.

I have used picric and chromic acids, both applied in the
usual way ; but for the early stages I have found osmic acid
by far the most useful reagent. I placed the object to be
hardened, in osmic acid (half per cent.) for two hours and a
half, and then for twenty-four hours in absolute alcohol.

I then embedded and cut sections of it in the usual way,
without staining further.

Ifound it advantageous to cut sections of these embryos .
immediately after hardening, since if kept for long in the
absolute alcohol the osmic acid specimens are apt to become
brittle.

List of Works referred to.

Gegenbaur.—‘ Anat. der Wirbelthiere,’ III Heft, Leipzig, 1873.
A. Gotte.—‘ Archiv. fiir Micr. Anat.,’ vol. x, 1873.
“Der Keim der forelleneies,” ‘ Archiv. fiir Micr. Anat.,’ vol. ix,
1873.
“ Untersuchung iiber die Entwickelung der Bombinator igneus,”
© Archiv. fir Micr. Anat.,’ vol. v, 1869.
“Kurze Mittheilungen aus der Entwicklungsgeschichte der
Unke,” ‘ Archiv. fiir Micr. Anat.,’ vol. ix, 1873.
Kupffer —‘ Archiv. fir Micr. Anat.,’ vol. ii, 1866, p. 473.
ef Ibid., vol. iv, 1868, p. 209.
Kowalevsky.—* Entwickelungsgeschichte der Holothurien,” ‘Mémoirs de
Y Acad. Imper. des Sciences de St. Petersbourg,’ vii
ser., vol. xi, 1867.
Kowalevsky, Owsjannikow, und Wagner.—* Entwickelung der Store,” ‘ Bul-
letin der K. Acad. St. Petersbourg,’ vol. xiv, 1873.
Kowalevsky. —* Embryologische Studien au Wurmern und Arthropoden,”
‘Mémoirs de |’Acad. Impér. des Sciences de St. Peters-
) bourg,’ vol. xvi, 1871.
E. Ray Lankester, ‘ Annals and Mag. of Nat. History,’ vol. xi, 1873, p. 81.
W. Miller —< Uber die Persistenz der Urniere bei Myxine Glutinosa,’
‘ Jenaische Zeitschrift,’ vol. vii, 1873.
Oellacher.—* Zeitschrift fiir Wiss. Zoologie,’ vol. xxiii, 1873.
Owsjannikow.—* Entwickelung der Coregonus,” ‘Bul. der K. Akad. St.
Petersbourg,’ vol. xix.
Romiti.—‘ Archiv. fir Micr. Anat.,’ vol. ix, 1873.
Waldeyer.—‘ Kierstock u. Kie.’

ON THE DEVELOPMENT OF THE POND-SNAIL. 365

OBsERVATIONS on the DuvELOPMENT of the PoND-SNAIL

(Lymneus stagnalis), and on the Karty Staces of other

- Mottusca. By E. Ray Lanxester, M.A., Fellow and

Lecturer of Exeter College, Oxford. (With Plates XVI
and XVII.)

§ 1.—Somz or THE DEVELOPMENTAL PHENOMENA OF
Mo.3uvsca.

Four years since, I determined to make a study of the de-
velopmental phenomena of a series of Mollusca, with the
view of ascertaining from the minute comparison of a number
of cases what phenomena might be common to the group, or
be considered as indicating ancestral conditions inherited from
common ancestors.

The success which had attended Fritz Miiller’s investiga-
tion of the Crustacea, and his celebrated “recapitulation
hypothesis,’ according to which we have, in the development
of every individual organism, a more or less complete
epitome of the development of the species, so that the series
of changing forms passed through between ovum and adult
form are but a series of dissolving views or portraits (often
very much marred) of its line of ancestors—this, I say, led
me to hope that materials might be found in the develop-
mental history of the Mollusca for constructing their genea-
logical tree. During the past fifteen years but little has
been done in the study of the embryology of the Mollusca,
and it was therefore to be expected that the application of
improved methods of investigation and new hypotheses would
yield valuable results. The result of my study of the de-
velopment of the Lamellibranch Prsidiwm and of the
Gasteropods Aplysia, Neritina, Tergipes and Polycera, are
now in course of publication elsewhere.

I have also, during this spring, completed the examina-
tion of the development of the Cephalopod Zoligo from an
early stage of the ovarian egg up to the escape of the embryo
from the egg-jelly, which, together with less complete ac-
counts of the development of Octopus and Sepia, I hope soon
to see published. Before proceeding to give here an account
of observations on Lymneus which I carried out during
July in the laboratory of Exeter College, Oxford, I may
briefly summarise the chief results of my previous observa-
tions, which are remarkably confirmed by the facts to be
subsequently related in regard to Lymneus.

Kowalevsky, in his account of the development of Amphi-

366 E. RAY LANKESTER:

oxus and of Phallusia, pointed out that the inner series of
cells which give rise to the alimentary canal in those animals
take up their position as the result of an invagination of part
of the wall of an original multicellular sac. I found the
same mode of origin for the primitive alimentary canal or
endoderm of the Lamellibranch Pzs¢dium, of the Pulmonates
Inmazx and Lymneus, of the Nudibranchs Tergipes and
Polycera. 'This led me to compare the early development
of members of other groups of the animal kingdom, the
Planule of Sponges and Ccelenterates, the frog’s embryo
with Rusconian anus, &c., and I was thus led to infer that
in this simple double-walled sac, composed of ectoderm and
endoderm, we have the transitory indication of a primeval
ancestor of all the higher groups of the animal kingdom,
whose essential structure is permanently retained in the
corals and polyps (Ceelenterata), but is in the course of
development improved upon by the evolution of a body-
cavity, and an additional third or intermediate mass of em-
bryonic cells, giving rise to muscular and vascular structures
in worms, molluscs, arthropods, star-fishes, and vertebrates.
I proposed to call this developmental form the Planula, its
immediate predecessor (the multicellular sac) a Polyblast,
and indicated three large divisions of the animal kingdom—
Homoblastica, Diploblastica, and Triploblastica—correspond-
ing respectively to a lower stage than the Planula, to the
Planula itself, and to a higher development of the essential
Planula-structure.}

Almost simultaneously Professor Haeckel, of Jena, arrived
at similar conclusions, which he first made known in his
‘Monograph of the Calcareous Sponges,’ and subsequently
developed in the essay entitled ‘‘ The Gastraea-Theory,” which
has been translated by Professor Perceval Wright for the
April and July numbers of this Journal. The terms Gastrula
and Gastraea, introduced by Professor Haeckel, are preferable
to the term Planula which I had adopted; and I may
further take this opportunity of admitting to some extent
the justice of his criticisms on my use of the term Triplo-
blastica. It appears to me more and more certain that (as
he has definitely pointed out) the third layer, or those masses
of cells which in the embryos of Triploblastica are regarded
as belonging to such a layer, are phylogenetically derived
either from one or other of the two primitive cell-layers, and
only appear by suppression of the historical steps of de-
velopment as an intermediate and independent layer.
Nevertheless, the fact that they do so appear, and that there

1 ¢ Annals and Mag. Nat. History,’ June, 1873.

ge

ON THE DEVELOPMENT OF THE POND*SNAIL. 367

is a third plane of development really brought about by
the formation of a body-cavity, seems to justify the use of
the terms Diploblastica and Triploblastica. The latter
corresponds essentially with Haeckel’s Metazoa. With re-
gard to the difference between Professor Haeckel and myself
as to the relation of the body-cavity and the water-vascular
system, I must at present maintain the view expressed in my
essay. The difference is not so great as Professor Haeckel
appears to believe. I do not accept his existing groups of
aceelomatous worms as such, for in the Planarians and
Cestods there appears to me to be evidence that the ramifi-
cations of the water-vascular stems are to be regarded as
corresponding to a commencing body-cavity. The terminal
portions of those stems, which open to the exterior, on the
other hand, are, as I pointed out in the essay referred to, to
be regarded as something distinct—an involution of the epi-
dermic layer subsequently developing into the segmental
organ. It does not by any means follow that the body-
cavity is primitively open to the exterior, a view which
Professor Haeckel has by misapprehension attributed to me.
It will not, however, be useful to discuss this matter further
without reference to renewed investigation of the facts.

A second and third phase in the development of the Mol-
lusea, which have long been known, and which may or may
not make their appearance in any particular case, are (what
may be called) the Trochosphere and Veliger forms, the
former an early condition of the latter. Both are well known
and characteristic of various groups of Worms and Echino-
derms, and the latter is seen in its full development in the
adult Rotifera and in the larval Gasteropoda and Pteropoda.
The identity of the velum of larval Gasteropods with the
ciliated discs of Rotifera seems to admit of little doubt, and
it would be well to have one term, e.g. velum, by which to
describe both. The Trochosphere is the earlier, more or less
spherical form in which the velum is represented by an an-
nular ciliated ridge, and which is sometimes (e. g. Chiton)
provided with a polar tuft of long cilia.

The cell, polyplast (morula), gastrula, trochosphere, and
veliger phases of molluscan development are not distinctive
of the molluscan pedigree; they belong to its pree-molluscan
history. The foot, the shell-gland, and the odontophore are
organs which are distinctively molluscan—the last character-
istic of the higher Mollusca only —the other two of the whole
sroup, and their appearance must be traced to ancestors
within the proper stem of the molluscan family tree. The
foot is essentially a greatly developed lower lip.

368 E. RAY LANKESTER.

With regard to the shell-gland, which has not up to the
present moment been recognised by any observers, my studies
have yielded most interesting results. This organ appears
to have a very wide distribution among the different classes
of Mollusca, and to be present even in the most remote
members of the group—the Polyzoa and Brachiopoda.

I do not propose here to give a detailed account of this

Diagram of an embryo of Pisidium pusillum. f. Foot. m. Mouth. pA.
Pharynx. gs. Gastrula-stomach (now bilobed). pz. Pedicle of in-
vagination (terminal intestine). s/s. Shell-gland.

Diagram of an embryo of Pleurobranchidium. f. Foot. ot. Otocyst. m.
Mouth. v. Velum.. zy Nerve-ganglion. ry. Residual yelk-spheres.
shs. Shell-gland. 7. Intestine.

ON THE DEVELOPMENT OF THE POND-SNAIL, 869

organ, but shall refer to the woodcuts (figs. 1 and 2) as illus-
trating its position and character in the embryos of Pisidiwm
and of Aplysia (Pleurobranchidium) respectively. The
gland (shs) under certain circumstances, connected with
an arrest of regular development, becomes filled with a
chitinous plug in the case of the Aplysia embryo. When
at Messina, during May of this year, I found that Dr.
Herman Fol had discovered the same shell-gland in embryo
Pteropods, and, strangely enough, he had found the same
plugging with a chitinous secretion in specimens abnor-
mally developed. I have observed the same “ shell-gland”’
in an early stage of Neritina, and, as will be seen below, it
has a very well-marked development, accompanied by occa-
sional plugging with a chitinous material, in Lymneus.

The position of the gland in Pés¢dium, and its relation to
the pair of calcareous valves which develop on either side of
it, suggests that it may in the Lamellibranchs be repre-
sented in adult life by the ligament; but this connection I
have not been able to demonstrate; on the other hand, in
Aplysia, Neritina, Lymneus, and the Pteropods, it certainly
disappears—is, in fact, an evanescent embryonic structure.

One naturally turns, after detecting this organ in Lamelli-
branchs, Gasteropods, and Pteropods, to the classes which
have been (I think a little invidiously) separated as Mollus-
coida from the other Molluscs—I mean the Brachiopoda and
the Polyzoa—to see if in them any trace of the shell-gland
can be found. I do not know, at the present moment, of any
such organ having been as yet observed in the young stages
of Polyzoa. But in a very strange form, which must be
classed with the Polyzoa, there is such an organ, occupying
exactly the required position.

Loxosoma neapolitanum was described first by Keferstein,
and subsequently by Kowalewsky, from whose memoir the
accompanying woodcut (fig. 4) is taken. The large gland
of attachment (sks) appears to me to be very probably the
homogen of the shell-gland. Further, in the Brachiopoda we
have a gland developed at the same point in many forms, ap-
pearing at avery early stage in Terebratula and Trebratulina,
and well known as enabling the animal to fix itself by means
ofits pedicle. The position of this gland corresponds accurately
with that of the shell-gland in theembryo Pis:diwm, Aplysia,
and Lymneus. Uence I consider that we have evidence for
considering this organ as one common to Polyzoa, Brachio-
poda, Lamellibranchia, Gasteropoda, and Pteropoda.

A question which at once presented itself after the general
presence of this organ had been ascertained was this—Does

370 i. RAY LANKESTER.

it correspond in any way to the sac in which the internal
shell of Zzmaz, and, further, that in which the pen of the

Diagram of Lorosoma. m. Mouth. st. Stomach. shs. Shell-gland.

Dibranchiate Cephalopods, is developed? These two heads of
the question must be kept apart.

We know, among Aplysia and its allies, and, further, in
Spirula, of external shells which have become internal, or,
we should better say, enclosed, by the overgrowth of the sur-
rounding folds of the mantel. That is apparently the indi-
vidual history of the concealed shell of Aplysia, and probably
is that of the concealed nautiloid shell of Sperula also; and,
consequently, it may be inferred that such is also the genea-
logical history of those shells.

But the development of Limaz, &c., has been sufficiently
studied by Gegenbaur (‘ Zeitschr. f. Wiss. Zool.,’ Bd. iii),
and Schmidt (‘Archiv f, Anatomie,’ 1851), to show that

ON THE DEVELOPMENT OF THE POND-SNAIL. 371

in these animals the shell is from the first formed in a sac.
In fact, we should only have to retain the shell-giand of the
allied pulmonate Lymneus, in adult life, in order to produce
precisely the required internal shell of Zemaz. It seems,
therefore, very probable that the shell of Zimaz is identical
with the plug of the shell-gland, which has so wide a dis-
tribution among the embryos of Mollusca. At the same time
further knowledge of the development of Limaz and other
Pulmonata, is necessary for a satisfactory conclusion on this
point.

The further question as to the identity of the shell-gland
and its plug with the pen-sac and pen of the dibranchiate
Cephalopods is of very great importance and great difficulty.
Professor Gegenbaur, in his ‘ Grundz. der vergleich. Ana-
tomie,’ puts forward the view that the Cephalopoda, on
account of their bilateral symmetry and general anatomical
relations with the other Mollusca, are to be regarded as the
least specialised group of the whole stock ; that is, as more
closely retaining the characters of the common ancestors of
existing Mollusca than do any other forms. If this be so,
we should expect to find a representative of the shell-gland
in the organization of the Cephalopods, and our attention is
immediately directed to the pen-sac and pen of the Dibran-
chiata. If the shell-gland and pen-sac are identical structures
we have a brilliant confirmation of Gegenbaur’s view. This
was one of the chief matters to which I directed my attention
in a recent study of the development of Loligo, Sepiola,
Sepia, and Octopus. I was anxious to determine the exact
mode of the first commencement of the sac in which the
“nen” of these cuttle-fish develops. I have only space here
to state that it makes its first appearance as a relatively very
small circular pit, the sides of which close in above so as to
form a shut sac, which enlarges and elongates with the later
growth of the embryo. In fig. 3 is given a drawing of a sec-
tion of a very young embryo (the drawing is cut off so as to
omit the yelk-sac and give only the embryonic portion of the
specimen) at a stage ‘when the pen-sac is still open, and
its lips commencing to close in. Its position and mode of
development exactly agree with that of the shell-gland as
seen in the other molluscan embryos figured in this paper.
We are, therefore, fairly entitled to conclude, from the em-
bryological evidence, that the pen-sac of Cephalopoda is
identical with the shell-gland of other Mollusca.

But here—forming an interesting example of the inter-
action of the various sources of evidence in genealogical
biology—paleontology crosses the path of embryology. I

VOL. XIV.—NEW SER BB

372 E. RAY LANKESTER.

think it is certain that if we possessed no fossil remains of
Cephalopoda the conclusion that the pen-sac is a special

Diagram of vertical right-and-left section through mantle-region of an
embryo Loligo. ep. Hpiblast. y. Food-yelk. m. Mesoblast. m’.
Deep-layer of cells (query, hypoblast) separating embryo from food-
yelk. shs. Open pen-sac.

development of the shell-gland would have to be accepted.
But the consideration of the nature of the shell of the
Belemnites, and its relation to the pen of living Cuttle-fish,
brings a new light to bear on the matter. Reserving anything
like a decided opinion as to the question in hand, I may
briefly state the hypothesis suggested by the facts ascertained
as to the Belemnitidee. The complete shell of a Belemnite
is essentially a straightened nautilus-shell (therefore an
external shell, inherited from a nautilus-like ancestor),
which, like the nautiloid shell of Spzrula, has become en-
closed by growths of the mantle, and, unlike the shell of
Spirula, has received large additions of calcareous matter
from those enclosing over-growths. On the lower surface of
the enclosed nautilus-shell of the Belemnite—the phragma-
cone—a series of layers of calcareous matter have been thrown
down forming the guard; above, the shell has been continued
into the extensive chamber formed by the folds of the mantle
so as to form the flattened pen-like pro-ostracum of Huxley.
Whether in the Belemnites the folds of the mantle which
thus covered in and added to the original chambered shell
were completely closed so as to form a sac or remained par-
tially open with contiguous flaps must be doubtful. In
Spirula we have an originally external shell enclosed but not
added to by the enclosing mantle-sac. In Spirulirostra, a
tertiary fossil, we have a shell very similar to that of Spirula,
with a small guard of laminated structure developed as in
the Belemnite (see the figures in Bronn, ‘ Classen u. Ordnungen
des Thierreichs’). In the Belemnites the original nautiloid

ON THE DEVELOPMENT OF THE POND-SNAIL. 378

shell is small as compared with Sprulrostra. It appears
to be largest in Huxley’s genus Xitphoteuthis. Hence, in the
series Spirula, Spirulirostra, Xtphoteuthis, Belemnites, we
have evidence of the enclosure of an external shell by
growths from the mantle (as in Aplysia), of the addition to
that shell of calcareous matter from the walls of its enclosing
sac, and of the gradual change of the relative proportions of
the original nucleus, (the nautiloid phragmacone,) and its
superadded pro-ostracal and rostral elements tending to the
disappearance of the nucleus (the original external shell). If
this view be correct as to the nature of these shells, it is clear
that the shell-gland and its plug has nothing to do with them.
The shell-gland must have preceded the original nautiloid
shell, and must be looked for in such a relation whenever the
embryology of the pearly Nautilus can be studied. Now,
everything points to the close agreement of the Belemnitidee
with the living Dibranchiata. The hooklets on the arms,
the ink-bag, the horny jaws, and general form of the body,
leave no room for doubt on that point; it is more than pro-
bable that the living Dibranchiata are modified descendants
of the mesozoic Belemnitide. If this be so, the pens of
Loligo and Sepia must be traced to the more complex shell of
the Belemnite. This is not difficult if we suppose the
originally external shell, the phragmacone, around which as
a nucleus the guard and pro-ostracum were developed, to
have finally disappeared. ‘The enclosing folds of the mantle
remain as a sac and perform their part, producing the
chitino-calcareous pen of the living Dibranch, in which parts
can be recognised as corresponding to the pro-ostracum, and
probably also to the guard, of the Belemnite. If this be the
case, if the pen of Sepa and Loligo correspond to the entire
Belemnite shell minus the phragmacone-nucleus, it is clear
that the sac which develops so early in Loligo, and which
appears to correspond to the shell-gland of the other molluscs,
cannot be held to doso. The sac thus formed in Zoligo must
be held to represent the sac formed by the primeval upgrowth
of mautle-folds over the young nautiloid shell of its Belem-
nitoid ancestors, and has accordingly no general significance
for the whole molluscan group, but is a special organ belong-
ing only to the Dibranchiate stem, similar to—but not
necessarily genetically connected with—the mantle-fold in
which the shell of the adult Aplysza and its congeners is
concealed. The pen, then, of Cephalopods would not repre-
sent the plug of the shell-gland. In regard to this view of
the case, it may be remarked that I have found no trace in
the embryonic history of the living Dibranchiata of a

374 EB. RAY LANKESTER.

structure representing the phragmacone; and further, it is
possible, though little importance can be attached to this sug-
gestion, that the Dibranchiate pen-sac, as seen in its earliest
stage in the embryo Loligo, &c., is fused with the surviving
remnants of an embryonic shell-gland. When a zoological
observatory has been established in the southern seas, and the
embryology of Nautilus pompilius worked out, we shall
probably know with some certainty the fate of the molluscan
shell-gland in the group of the Cephalopoda. By the use of
no very great ingenuity it might be possible to conceive of
the pro-ostracum alone of the Belemnite as being the plug of
the shell-gland, and thus to save the homogeny of the
embryonic pen-sac of living Cuttle-fish with the so closely
corresponding sac (the shell-gland) of other Mollusca. I will
only venture one additional remark of a speculative tendency
here, and that is that the siphuncle of the chambered
shells of Nautilus and Spirula is so placed as to suggest an
inquiry as to whether it may have any relation to this pro-
blematical shell-gland.

The preceding discussions and speculations have been
introduced with the object of rendering more clear the points
of interest in the facts of the development of Lymnaus
stagnalis which are recorded below.

§ 2.—DeEvVELOPMENT oF LyMNa#&US STAGNALIS.

The well-known egg-jelly of the common pond-snail is to
be found on water-plants in most ponds from June to Oc-
tober. The jelly encloses a number of tense capsules, each
of which contains one, rarely two, eggs.

Many points of interest in the earliest stages of the de-
posited egg demand minute investigation with the highest
power, and have been entered into in a suggestive rather
than a conclusive manner by M. Lereboullet in his extended
** Monograph of the Development of Lymneus” (‘ Annales
des Sciences Naturelles,’ ser. iv, t. 18, 1862). I shall here
only record a few facts tending to show the general disposi-
tion of the masses resulting from the segmentation of the
primitive egg-sphere, reserving the consideration of the
minute structure and relations of the various elements of the
yelk for another occasion. The egg-sphere, as laid, has a
diameter of about =}, of an inch. By the middle of the
third day from its deposition in the warm season it has
assumed the form seen in Pl. XVI, figs. 8—12, and is then
1 of an inch in diameter. The intermediate steps are not

180

easy to follow with certainty. It is necessary by sharp

ON THE DEVELOPMENT OF THE POND-SNAIL. 375

pressure or by needles to remove the egg from its envelope,
to avoid anything like actual contact with it, and to study
it with high powers (250 to 400 diameters) by both trans-
mitted and reflected light. The egg is not a transparent
one, and is very easily distorted by manipulation. Osmic acid
solution of one per cent. is useful in the earlier but more
especially in the later stages of the investigation, and en-
abled me to preserve specimens permanently.

Formation of the Gastrula.—With the first contractions of
cleavage one or two pellucid drops are extruded from the
brown yelk-mass, and remain adherent to the axial point of
the egg, as in many other molluscs and worms ; they are the
well-known “ Richtungsblaschen,” and disappear, becoming
detached at a later stage of development. They may serve a
useful purpose for the embryologist if they enable him to re-
cognise at any subsequent period when they are present the
original pole at which they made their appearance. But it must
be borne in mind that such droplets of albuminous matter are
occasionally extruded from eggs of the same character as those
of Lymneus at other points during later stages in the process
of segmentation of the egg-sphere. In Pl. XVI, figs. 2 and 3,
lateral and polar views of the egg when exhibiting four
divisions are given. In figs. 5 and 6 a series of smaller
segmentation cells is seen extending itself so as to surround
four larger spheres. The stage intermediate between this
and the simple quadripartite form I have not yet observed,
nor is it clear from M. Lereboullet’s figures whence precisely
these smaller cells arise. He figures an egg consisting of
four large cells with four little ones surmounting them, but
does not demonstrate whence these four smaller cells have
originated. I have not seen the egg in this state. If we
compare the case of Aplysia we find there a series of smaller
cells growing over and enclosing two larger segmentation
spheres, but the origin of these smaller cells is clear from the
beginning; even in the unsegmented egg the pale trans-
parent portion of the egg from which they are formed is
distinguishable from the more granular opaque mass which
forms the two large enclosed spheres. ‘This is the first point
of obscurity in the transition from fig. 3 to fig. 10. It
can, no doubt, be readily cleared up by painstaking observation
of a large number of eggs. In fig. 4 we have a lateral view
of the same egg as that of figs. 5 and 6. The drawing is so
placed that the smaller cells are below the large spheres
above. This is for comparison with the succeeding fig. 7.
At the pole of fig. 4 is seen a clear albuminous corpuscle,
undoubtedly of the nature of Richtungsblaschen, sticking, as

876 E. RAY LANKESTER.

it were, in the point of intersection of the sectors of the large
yelk-masses. It is possible that this is mo¢ the same cor-
puscle as that seen in figs. 1 and 2. If it be the same we
have this to observe —that whereas in Aplysca the Rich-
tungsblaschen escapes from the paler pole of the unsegmented
egg, where the smaller enveloping cells are formed, in
Lymneus the pole from which the Richtungsblaschen is
detached does mot exhibit the more active, but the /ess active,
segmentation. Accordingly, the small cells in Lymneus
would appear not to correspond with the small cells in
Aplysia ; they are not advancing, in the case of Lymneus,
to enclose the four larger masses as they do enclose the two
large spheres of Aplysia, but are growing in the opposite
direction. In fig. 7, taking the position of the Richtungs-
blaschen and the general shape again as a guide, we find the
larger cells still left unenclosed by the smaller, which are
now sinking in on the lower surface to form the primitive
alimentary canal of the gastrula-form seen in the sub-
sequent figures. This interpretation depends upon the
assumption of the constancy of the position of the Richtungs-
blaschen, and also on the marked agreement in form of the
embryos when placed as drawn in figs. 4 and 7. If we might
disregard this, and invert fig. 6, we should have what would
appear to be a much more intelligible mode of formation of
the primitive in-pushing of the gastrula of Lymneus. Fig.
4 being inverted, we should, looking at it in the light of fig.
7, and disregarding Richtungsblaschen, see in this stage the
gradual extension of the smaller cells over the larger, so as:
to enclose them, just as certainly does occur in Aplysia,
and the in-pushing in the base of fig. 7 would be the final
result of the growing over and approximation of the cireum-
ferential border of the cap of enclosing cells. Unfortunately
the embryo or segmented egg-mass in the stage seen in
fig. 7 is too opaque to allow of our obtaining evidence on
this point from its actual structure. The question as to the
precise mode of formation of this gastrula, and, indeed, of
all gastrula-forms, is one of such very great interest at
present that I have not kept silence about the difficulties
which this has presented to me, though a little more time
and care than I have given to this part of the developmental
history of Lymneus would settle the point.’ In figs. 8, 9,

' M. Lereboullet’s account does not help one very much in this part of
the history. He figures one embryo as perfectly spherical and composed of
“twenty equal spheres.” I did not come across such embryos, but they
would clearly be later than the stage given in fig. 4, and intermediate

_ necessarily between it and the youngest gastrula-phase, namely fig, 7, In

ON THE DEVELOPMENT OF THE POND-SNAIL. 377

10, 11, 12, we have various views of the gastrula of Lymneus.
In assuming this form the embryo gets rid of a very delicate
envelope, which appears to be of a slightly viscid nature,
and which, together with the Richtungsblaschen, is now lost.
It is seen in a loose detached condition in the stage repre-
sented in fig. 7.

The gastrula of Lymneus has been figured and described
by Lereboullet, who takes the fossa and orifice of invagina-
tion for the rudiment of the adult’s mouth. I believe, how-
ever, that this is a mistake, and that the orifice of invagina-
tion in Lymneus closes up, as I have observed, in the
gastrula of the Lamellibranch Prsidiwm, and in that of
Limaz and of Polycera, Tergipes, and Doris.

The Lymneus-gastrula has the same curious cushion-like
form as observed in the Nudibranchs. ‘The orifice of invagi-
nation, in its most strongly marked period of development,
is a long, trough-like depression, running from one side of
the cushion towards the middle, and there sinking deeply
into the substance of the mass. Accordingly, as it is turned
this way or that, the extent and direction of the orifice
presents apparent differences, which are, however, merely
apparent.

The figures will give a more correct notion of these appear-
ances than any description.

Besides, by Lereboullet, who did not appreciate its true
character, the gastrula of Lymneus has been figured dia-
gramatically by Professor Haeckel in his Gastreea-theory.
(See Pl. VII.)

I have elsewhere distinguished two classes of gastrula.
forms, according to the mode of their development, namely,
“invaginate gastrule” and ‘“delaminate gastrule,” the
latter forming by an internal movement of stratification in a
mass of embryonic cells, and not by a process of involution.
The Lymneus-gastrula is clearly an “ invaginate” one; but
amongst invaginate gastrule we may distinguish those which
are formed by emboly (the growth inwards of a number of
small cells), and those formed by epiboly, in which large
cells remain, as it were, stationary, and are grown oyer by
smaller cells. These terms are adopted from Selenka, who
has given a very valuable account of the development of
Purpura lapillus in the ‘Niederlandisches Archiv fiir
Zoologie,’ Bd. I, July, 1872.

I am obliged to leave for further inquiry the interesting

this there is certainly not much if any difference in the size of the com-
ponent cells, those in the apex of the pyramid being ouly apparently larger
on account of their prominence.

378 E. RAY LANKESTER.

question as to whether the invaginate gastrula of Lymneus
forms by emboly or epiboly, or has an intermediate
character.

The Trochosphere-—The orifice of invagination of the
gastrula now, closes up, and its shape commences to undergo
a change due to the development of a kind of equatorial
ridge, the earliest rudiment of the velum. At the same time
the movements of rotation of the embryo commence. ‘The
phase in which there is as yet no trace of the mouth, and
in which the gastrula’s orifice of invagination has disap-
peared, is not figured in the plates accompanying this paper ;
but I may refer to Lereboullet’s pl. xii, fig. 36, for a good
drawing of that particular phase, though the French natura-
list does not recognise the significance of his illustration,
since he believes that the Gastrula’s orifice becomes the
mouth. ,

The movements of rotation in the embryo Lymneus are
caused by very short cilia, which it is not difficult to see
even with a quarter-inch (English make), after the embryo
has been treated with osmic acid. These cilia have entirely
escaped M. Lereboullet, who says, ‘‘ J’ai cherché en vain la
cause de ce mouvement qu’on attribue généralement a des
cils vibratiles. Je puis affirmer que ces derniers n’existent
pas, et qu’ils ne se voient jamais, a aucune epoque de la vie
embryonnaire, sur toute la surface de l’ceuf.”

With a No. 10 @ immersion Hartnack the cilia can be
observed, even in the early period, when rotation first
begins; later they are obvious enough in the region of the
velum.

The phase which the embryo now enters upon with a
distinct circumferential ciliated band is that which I have
designated in the introductory remarks above as the trocho-
sphere. In the earliest of the forms referable to this phase
(Pl. XVI, fig. 13) the embryo has a very peculiar outline when
viewed from the oral pole, the ciliated band appearing to
commence its development in connection with the two lobe-
like outgrowths right and left of the mouth. The remaining
figures on P]. XVI give various views of later trochospheres.
The movements of rotation are now very rapid, and vary
around two axes at right angles to one another, so that it is
difficult to get a correct notion of the actual superficial form
of theembryo. The figures supply such information as I can

ive.

i The changes in the histological elements of the embryo
from the earliest gastrula-form (fig. 7) to the latest trocho-
sphere are no less marked and important than the changes in

ON THE DEVELOPMENT OF THE POND-SNAIL. 379

external shape. I am not prepared to give a detailed account
of those changes, but can only draw attention to some general
features.

The invaginated cells or segmentation-products, * which
form the endoderm or primitive alimentary sac of the gas-
trula, are not at first distinguishable through the walls of the
widely excavated pyramidal embryo. But as the wide orifice
narrows to a slit, the two sets of cells become clearly dis-
tinguishable, a result due, not merely to the clearing-up of
the outer cells, but also to the gradual assumption of a
specific character—globular form, dark granulation, and high
refrangibility—by the invaginated cells. During the whole
of the later development, as far as I have watched it in
Lymneus, the gastrula’s endoderm-cells are undergoing modifi-
cation, resulting at last in the separation of a pellucid material
from a more superficial granular matter, which appears ulti-
mately to give rise to a cellular network (Pl. XVII, fig. 22).
The minute history of the changes in these cells would be an
important matter to determine, since it appears that the history
of other invaginated gastrula-endoderms is not so simple as
one might suppose beforehand. ‘They are by no means
simple masses of formative protoplasm, which merely multiply
by division, but appear in many cases to contain other
elements analogous to the nutritive yelk (whence obtained is
not clear), which in earlier stages have accumulated in each
endodermal cell. Each endodermal cell then appears to play
a part analogous to that of a whole ovum in its early stages,
segregating and giving rise to new cells by endogenous forma-
tion. A process of this sort appears to go on in the gastrula-
endoderm of Piszdium as well as in that of Lymneus, and
probably also in the “residual yelk-spheres” of Pleuro-
branchidium. An important histiological arrangement seen
in the specimen (Pl. XVI, fig. 14) is the connection of the
endodermal mass of cells with those forming the body-wall
by means of long processes. This is seen again in a later
phase in Pl. XVII, fig. 19. The processes appear to be
actual filaments of the cell-substance of the endodermal
cells.

In the trochosphere so far the shape is nearly spherical,
excepting for the raised ciliated ridges, which together make
a heart-shaped outline on the surface of the embryo, the
indentatiou of the heart being occupied by the mouth.

The Veliger-phase.—In fig. 1 of Pl. XVII we have a some-
what more advanced stage, and in figs. 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, the
definite Veliger-phase is attained. In the Veliger the area
of the velum has a definite development, occupying relatively

880 E, RAY LANKESTER.

the same position and having something of the same rela-
tive size as the wheel-apparatus of a Rotifer. , Moreover,
in the Veliger the foot takes on a large relative growth,
so as to form a projecting lobe ; at first it is simple, but soon
becomes, what is exceedingly important, bilobed. This
bilobed condition of the foot need but be carried a very little
further than it is in the Lymneus-veliger, and we should
have the Pteropod-veliger, with fully developed velum and
two epipodial ‘‘ wings,” such as I had the opportunity of
examining last spring at Messina through the kindness of
Dr. Herman Fol.

In fig. 1 some interesting features are exhibited which
happened to be unusually well-presented by the particular
specimen from which the figure is drawn. The letter g
indicates the spot at which the gastrula’s orifice of invagina-
tion has closed up, and the delicate pedicle of tissue (p72) ex-
tending from this to the enlarged gastrula-endoderm-cells is
the “ pedicle of invagination,” precisely similar to the pedicle
formed in the same way in the Lamellibranch Pisidiwm (for
an account of which I must refer to the forthcoming volume
of the ‘ Philosophical Transactions’). The thickened super-
ficial tissue to the left of the closed orifice of invagination is
the shell-disc—the earliest commencement of the mantle area.
This again will be seen from the woodcut (fig. 2) to have
its equivalent in other molluscs, and has, indeed, been
especially described by Paul Stepanof in his account of the
development of the pulmonate Ancylus fluviatilis. The
further development of this region has, however, escaped him
and all other previous observers. It is as a pushing in from
this shell-dise that the shell-gland to which I have referred
in the introduction, and which is seen in Pl. XVII, figs. 11,
12, 13, 14, and 17, is developed.

The Shell-gland.—The shell-gland—a name which suggests
itself merely from the position of the gland, and not from any
necessary functional connection with the formation of theshell—
was seen figured and described by Lereboullet in his account of
the development of Lymneus. Lereboullet accurately described
it at one period of its growth as a hollow cone, truncated and
closed at its deeper extremity. He regarded it as the anal
portion of the alimentary canal, and consequently termed it
the “anal cone.” From this it follows that he had failed
to detect, as his figures also show to be the case,. the
‘pedicle of invagination” and the true commencement of
the terminal part of the alimentary tract. If we follow the
shell-gland through the various figures on Pl. XVII, in which,
it appears, we shall find that occupying at one time a very

ON THE DEVELOPMENT OF THE POND-SNAIL. 381

prominent position, and pushing its way right up into the
central mass of gastrula-endoderm-cells, it subsequently
dwindles, and very rapidly disappears altogether, as the shell
forms and the mantle-area becomes raised up as a convex dome
with margin distinctly projecting to form a rudimentary mantle-
flap. The drawings (Pl. X VII, figs.11, 12) represent the shell-
gland in its most strongly marked condition, the conical
lumen of the gland being filled by a highly refracting chiti-
nous substance. Curiously enough, the cases in which this
occurs appear to be abnormal. In a mass of eggs which
have for the most part advanced to the stage seen in Pl. XVII,
fig. 10, two or three may be found which have hung back, and
have an abnormal proportion of foot, mantle-flap, &c., besides
being much smaller than the further advanced normal speci-
mens. Such retarded specimens frequently exhibit the con-
dition of the shell-gland figured in figs. 1 and 12. Not
only is there this plugging of the gland, but the commencing
shell (not at this period calcified, but entirely of a horny
composition) is thick and rough as compared with the
normal shell of the same size, and sometimes the plug is
united to the disc-like shell, so that the two can be picked
out by careful teazing as a separate plate and handle. In
the introductory remarks above I have referred to my obser-
vations on Aplysia (Pleurobranchidium), where I found
a precisely similar condition accompanying a retarded
development.

The Velar Area.—Let us now return to the velum for the
purpose of tracing its development, and that of the velar area.
It is an extraordinary fact that the existence of a velum in the
embryos of Pulmonata has been denied, and its absence is at
this moment mentioned in so authoritative a work as Bronn’s
‘Thierreich’’ as characterising the young stages of that
group. Pouchet, who appears to have seen it in the trocho-
sphere-phase of Lymneus, and whose figures are copied in
Bronn’s plates, traces it to the free edge of the mantle, for
the first rudiment of which. he mistakes it. Lereboullet
appears to have missed it altogether. The fact is, as will be
seen from the figures in Pl. XVII, that it not only is: well
developed in the youngest stages of Lymneus, but persists in
an altogether exceptional way, and is actually retazned in the
adult, having become the lip-like masses which are known
in Lymneus as the “ subtentacular lobes.” The margin of
the velum is easy to trace in the Veliger-phase of Lymneus

on account of the large, granular, epidermic cells of a.

yellowish-brown colour which compose it. When the em-
bryo passes from the Veliger-phase to the definite rolluscan

bee

382 E. RAY LANKESTER.

phase with creeping foot, with mantle-flap and eye-tentacles,
the cilia no longer predominate on the velum, but it remains
as a well-marked ridge swelling out into a pair of lobes, one
on each side of the mouth, and terminating bluntly on each
side at the back of the head (Pl. XVII, figs. 7 and 10).

At the same time during the Veliger-period in which the
foot commences to assume a bilobed form, a conical eminence
appears on each side within the heart-shaped velar area.
These two eminences are the eye-tentacles, and rapidly grow
so as to overshadow the margins of the velum. In this phase
of the development, as the embryo rotates, it often presents
itself in the position seen in Pl. XVII, fig. 6, in which the
foot is stretched in front, and the velar area with the growing
eye-tentacles, and the mouth placed centrally, complete the
rest of the visible part of the Veliger. The dark coloured
margin of the velum itself is seen forming a curious saddle-
shaped cincture placed transversely. It is easy enough to
demonstrate that the velum actually persists in adult life by
comparing such embryos as figs. 7 and 10 with full-grown
Lymnei. The fact that some of the Pulmonata thus retain
this larval organ in the adult condition is important, be-
cause, so far as I know, no other mollusc has been shown
to do so; and, in fact, no other organism which possesses a
velum in its younger phases of development, such as the
Echinodermata, Nemerteans, Gephyreans, and Cheetopodous
Annelids, with ‘the exception of the Rotifers. Parts of the
prostomial region in some of the Chetopodous Annelida may
perhaps be traceable to the larval velum, as are the sub-
tentacular lobes of Lymneus.

The retention of the velum and the strongly bilobed cha-
racter of the young foot mark the Pulmonata as an archaic
group of odontophorous Mollusca. The presence of these
archaic features is in accordance with the generalisation that
such features may be looked for in the fresh-water repre-
sentatives of large sea-dwelling groups, other examples being
found in the fresh-water Radiolaria, in Hydra and Cordy-
lophora, and in the living Ganoid fishes.

Nerve-ganglion.—Within the velar area coincidently with
the commencing development of the eye-tentacles a bilobed
mass of cells commences to develop, apparently from a local
multiplication of cells belonging to the epidermic layer.
They form a conspicuous mass, and enter into gonnection
with the pharyngeal mass (figs. 8,17, 23 ng). This is the
supra-cesophageal nerve-mass, and it is to be noted that its
mode of development is identical with that which I have
elsewhere described in Aplysia,

ON THE DEVELOPMENT OF THE POND-SNAILL. 3883

I have no details to record with regard to the develop-
ment of the eyes; but with regard to the otocysts may
draw attention to the fact that they are absent in the stages
studied by me, though in a corresponding period of develop-
ment in the Nudibranchiata they have attained a high degree
of: perfection. This I imagine may be explained by the
relatively smaller importance of the auditory organ in the
adult Zymneus than in the Sea-slugs, and their near allies
the free-swimming snails (Heteropoda).

Mantle-flap and lung.—In Pl. XVII, fig. 8, a stage in which
the shell-gland has disappeared, and the shell itself (sh) is
already projecting like a watch-glass from the aboral pole of
the embryo, the edge of the mantle first becomes raised up and
definitely emarginated. Following this through figs. 7 and
10, we find its rim becoming more and more detached or
lengthened, until in fig. 18, on the right-hand side, a con-
siderable space is overhung by this marginal flap. It is here
that the lung develops as a simple recess covered in by the
mantle-flap. In the specimen drawn in fig. 18 the rudi-
ment of the heart is also seen (4), and other organs in con-
‘nection with the enlarged border of the mantle, viz. the
tubular dark-coloured body opening to the exterior (x), which
I take to be the young kidney, and the prolonged delicate
terminal portion of the alimentary canal, which still ends
blindly (er).

Alimentary canal.—The fact that the alimentary canal
ends blindly in so late a stage of development as that of
fig. 18 should have made clear to M. Lereboullet that he was
wrong in interpreting the shell-gland as an anal cone; but
it must be admitted that to follow out fully the development
of the alimentary canal is exceedingly difficult, even as far as
its general contour is concerned, still more so when a his-
tological and histogenetic point of view is attempted. In
fact, here, as in all the embryologies which have been
attempted, the dark point is in connection with the middle
portion of the alimentary canal. If we knew with certainty
whence and how its cellular elements are developed in all
types which have been studied, we should have little diffi-
culty in reducing the facts of development of the whole
animal kingdom to satisfactory order.

We have seen that there results from the gastrula-invagina-
tion an outer cellular body-wall, from the elements of which
the epidermic and muscular structures of foot, velum, mantle,
and shell-gland, develop, and an inner invaginated sac com-
posed of larger celis, supported on a short pedicle (the cells

384 E. RAY LANKESTER.

of which are not large and granular, but scarcely distinguish-
able), the pedicle of invagination.

The sac composed of large celis very early becomes con-
stricted, so as to present two lobes, as seen in Pl. XVII,
fiz. 1. ‘In looking at the figures in Pl. XVII it must be
remembered that the specimens are often compressed, and -
that only an optical section or partial view can be given of
the various parts; hence the mass of large cells (the gas-
trula-endoderm) is frequently distorted. The lobes appear
at first to lie right and left, the pedicle being in the median
plane.

The pharynx now commeaces to develop with the in-
pushing of the mouth from the body-wall, and gradually
extends downwards into the mass of endoderm-cells, so as to
be partly concealed by them (figs. 8, 11, 17 ph). At the
same time the cells in the pedicle of invagination differentiate.
The pedicle assumes.a tubular character, and its parietal end
becomes bent round, so that the tube terminates as a shortly
reflected cecum. Whilst the pharynx and the intestinal
portion of the alimentary canal are thus differentiating,
changes have been going on in the gastrula-endoderm-
cells, to which changes I have already alluded. ‘ In place
of a bilobed group of large granular cells we now have a net-
work of fine granular filaments with nuclei at intervals
completely enclosing and surrounding on all sides pellucid,
highly refracting spheres (fig. 22). Moreover, a tunic of
fusiform cells, of the same character as the elementary mus-
cular cells which are seen in other parts of the embryo, has
spread itself over the whole of the alimentary tract (fig.
17, tge). They are closely fitted to the pharynx and rectum
(figs. 21, 22), and also extend over the pellucid spheres and
their granular network, whence they send branches to the
similar cells lining the body-wall (figs. 17, 22). Whence has
this tunic developed? At the pharyngeal end the cells are
clearly continuous with those of the body-wall, and at the
rectal end also; but those enclosing what was the gastrula-
endoderm are probably developed from the processes which the
invaginate gastrula-cells send to the body-wall, even in the
trochosphere stage of development, as seen in Pl. XVI,
fiz. 14. If this is the case the musculature of the terminal
portions of the alimentary canal will have been developed,
like the musculature of the body-wall, from the ectoderm of
the gastrula, whilst the musculature of the middle portion
of the alimentary canal and its appendices will have been
developed from the gastrula’s endoderm.

We have, however, yet to see what eventually comes of

ON THE DEVELOPMENT OF THE POND-SNAIL. 385

this middle group of cells—the histologically changed, but in
coarser features unchanged, bilobed group which formed the
gastula’s stomach. TI have failed to penetrate to the centre
of this mass of cells in earlier phases, and can, therefore, not
explain how the structure to be described comes about.
What can be observed is this, that as soon as the pharynx
and its appendix, the odontophore’s sac, becomes well
marked, and the tubular structure with epithelial lining in
the pedicle of invagination is clearly visible, then a little
compression and manipulation renders clear the continuation
of a tube-like structure with walls formed of small cells from
pharynx to intestine, traversing the mass of large pellucid
cells (Pl. XVII, fig. 21). This tubular structure is un-
doubtedly ta be regarded as the so-called stomach of the adult
Lymneus. 'The metamorphosed gastrula-endoderm-cells now
lie on each side of it as a pair of grape-like bunches, and
long after it has become well-defined these two agglomerations
of pellucid spheres, with their enclosing network and meso-
blastic coat (the tunic of fusiform cells), remain. They are
apparently eventually adsorbed as nutritive matter by diver-
ticula of the alimentary canal, which give rise to the liver,
they themselves not giving rise subsequently to any per-
manent tissue. Now, it is a most important question whether
the cell-elements which build up the so-called “stomach”
(the middle piece of the alimentary canal) arise in any way
from the large gastrula-endoderm-cells, or from the pharyn-
geal in-pushing, or from the intestinal pedicle of invagination.
If from this last, they would just as much, as if they arose
from the material of the central mass of gastrula-endoderm,
be traceable to the invaginated cells of the gastrula-phase.
On the whole, it seems probable that this is their origin ;
but the matter is still obscure. The analogy of other
Mollusca does not take us very far towards a clearing up, for
in all cases that I have studied the exact mode of origin of
the middle portion of the alimentary canal is equally obscure.
It is, however, interesting and of considerable importance for
a true understanding of the matter, to note that in this case
of Lymneus we have a large proportion of the material
which at one time formed the wall of the gastrula-stomach
left outside the permanent alimentary canal and absorbed as a
kind of food-yelk. The case of Pleurobranchidium, of which
an embryo is represented in the woodcut, is, in a measure,
parallel to this, for the two large nucleated spheres (7y) are that
portion of the original cleavage-product of the egg which are
overgrown or invaginated by epiboly. Hence they represent
the gastrula-stomach, and, as in Lymneus, a middle intes-

386 E, KAY LANKESTER,

tine appears between them without our being able to deter-
mine whence it takes its origin; possibly it is from some
of the material of these very cells, but they remain unem-
braced by the walls of the alimentary canal so formed,
and gradually dwindle by the absorption of their material.
In Pisidium, again, we have in the earlier condition a
still closer agreement with Lymneus, for there a very defi-
nitely marked, bilobed gastrula-stomach is formed by in-
vagination (see woodcut, fig. 1). But in Puésidium, too,
after this epoch, a great change comes over the cells forming
the wall of the gastrula-stomach, its cavity becomes con-
stricted, narrowed, and contorted, and apparently a new mid-
portion of the alimentary canal is formed with separation of
nutritive and formative elements from the original gastrula-
endoderm-cells. Therefore it seems that the history of the
development of the gastrula-stomach into the permanent
middle intestine is by no means a simple one. It, in fact,
involves the whole question of the part played by the so-
called nutritive elements of the original egg-yelk, and we
may expect gradations between the developmental processes
of a simple unencumbered egg-cell (free from yelk-granules),
such as that of the Nematoid Cucullanus (in which I should
anticipate that the primitive alimentary canal would be
directly enlarged so as to form the adult one), and those of
the eggs of Cephalopods and birds, in which the egg-cell is
well-nigh lost in an excess of superadded nutrient material.

Wherever these nutritive yelk-elements come in they
derange and obscure the usual processes of cell-growth ; in
the earliest stages they give a paradoxical twist to the
multiplication by fission of the primitive egg-cell, later to the
mode of formation of the hypoblast or gastrula-endoderm,
and finally, to the mode of development of middle intestine
and liver from this last, whilst they may even have something
to say to the development of other organs in which their too
ready offer of nutritional assistance is accepted.

The later development of the alimentary canal, the break-
ing through of the anus to the exterior, and of the pharynx
to the stomach or middle intestine, I have not followed, nor
have I observed the development of the liver and absorption
of the two masses of pellucid cells which Lereboullet has
described, since I have not pursued the embryos to that
phase. I may, however, here mention that in the Cephalopod
Loligo I have determined, by means of transverse and longi-
tudinal sections, that the great mass of “ unorganised ” yelk
enclosed by the embryo is in that animal gradually absorbed,
whilst the growth of a pair of diverticula from the alimentary

ON THE DEVELOPMENT OF THE POND-SNAIL. 387

canal proceeds, which diverticula penetrate the unorganised
yelk, and, filling up the position once occupied by it, become
the two lobes of the Cephalopod liver. This process is
probably a general one throughout the animal kingdom, with
variation in non-essentials.

Muscular layers and museles.—I have above spoken of
fusiform cells arrauged as a layer on the inner surface of the
body-wall, and as surrounding the alimentary canal and
bilobed mass of pellucid cells. These represent the meso-
blastic elements of the embryo. I have not been able to
find in the early stages of Lymneus a layer or group of
undifferentiated embryonic cells lying definitely between the
gastrula’s body-wall and stomach ; such a layer would be a
mesoblast. Itis possible that there are some such loosely placed
cells during a particlar phase of the development, just as
there are in Prsedium, but they are derived either from the
enclosing ectoderm or the invaginated endoderm in the first
instance. The appearances are strongly in favour of the
fusiform cells which lie in apposition to the epidermic cells
of the body-wall, being derived from ectoderm or epiblast cells.
The most noticeable groups develop at the circumference of
the shell-gland (Pl. XVII, fig. 8 mu). The processes which
pass from the gastrula-endoderm-cells to the body-wall appear
(fig. 19), eventually to become muscular, but whether they
should then be attributed to the latter or the former is
doubtful. The term Triploblastic is applicable to Lymneus
and to other molluscs in which there is no definitely consti-
tuted layer intermediate between the gastrula’s ectoderm
and endoderm, since in it and them, as in all the groups
filiated to Vermes the musculature has not only relations to
the outer world and to the gastric space, but to a third inter-
posed space—the hemolymph cavity—in which a vascular
system and blood-lymph spaces develop.

It is clear (and in saying this I am qualifying, though not
recalling, what I have stated in my essay in ‘Ann. and Mag.
Nat. History,’ June, 1873) that a mesoblast or third inter-
mediate layer must ether be derived from epiblast or hypo-
blast (either or both), and so cannot be spoken of as of co-
ordinate value with those two layers; or, on the other hand,
it must be a separate entity originating simultaneously with
the epiblast and hypoblast from the egg-cell or its segmenta-
tion products. The latter case is one which certainly has
not been usually contemplated in the use of the term “ me-
soblast” or “ middle layer,” and there is very small warrant
for assuming it as expressing the historic or phylogenetic
mode of origin of the layer in question. It is possible that

VOL. XIV.—NEW SER. cc

388 E, RAY LANKESTER.

in some cases, when the gastrula’s ectoderm and stomach-
wall are differentiated by invagination, a certain number of
the primitive segmentation-cells should remain involved,
neither in the one nor the other, but lying intermediately,
thus forming a simultaneously differentiated mesoblast, but
even then we should be able to trace such cells to an earlier
connection with the cells of either epiblast or hypoblast. In
point of fact, such cases have not been brought forward from
actual observation for discussion.

Thus, then, the term mesoblast and its correlative term “ tri-
ploblastic” have not reference to the existence of an embryonic
layer of co-ordinate value with the two primary layers, but
to a disposition and growth of some of the early structural
elements of the higher animals in and around a strongly
marked space separating the two primary layers.

Summary.—The observations of fact which have been
brought forward above are to a large extent disjointed, and
even as far as concerns the period of development to which
they refer, very far from exhaustive. They must rather be
regarded as suggesting the desirability of more detailed and
long-continued study.

As evidence of the value which may be assigned to them,
I shall quote the summary of the development of the water-
Pulmonata, given by Keferstein in Bronn’s invaluable
‘ Thierreich,’ followed by a statement of the points in which
my observations traverse or supply important omissions in
that summary.

Keferstein says (p. 1230 of the third volume of the above-
named work):

“The Pulmonata of fresh waters exhibit the closest agrec-
ment with the Prosobranchiata, excepting that in them ad/
trace of a velum ts wanting (A). We possess very numerous
and elaborate memoirs on the development of Limneus, espe-
cially by Stiebel, Dumortier, Pouchet, Karsch, Warneck,
Lereboullet, &c. ; on that of Planorbis we have the researches
of Jacquemin, &c.; so that the facts are here accurately
known. We confine ourselves in the following remarks to
Linneus.

**Two hours after the egg is laid its cleavage commences,
as a consequence of which at once one or two so-called
Richtungsblaschen are pushed out by the contraction of the
yelk, and then a first circumferential cleft extends itself
round the spherical egg-mass. The germinal vesicle is no
longer visible in the impregnated yelk ; but shortly before the
equatorial cleft is formed a clear speck is visible in the yelk,
which, according to Warneck, becomes biscuit-shaped, and

ON THE DEVELOPMENT OF THE POND-SNAIL. 389

finally divides into two clear specks, of which one is found in
each half of the cleft yelk-mass. These clear specks are
undoubtedly true nuclei of the cleavage spheres, but no con-
nection between them and the germinal vesicle could be
demonstrated. These nuclei divide again, and at the same
time the yelk is seen to fall into four masses by the formation
of a second cleft. According to Lereboullet all the cleavage-
spheres fuse themselves into a homogeneous mass before each
new segmentation every time, and then separate again and
commence the process of further cleavage. According to Quatre-
fages the same thing occurs in the annelid Sabellaria. From
the midst of four cleavage-spheres so formed and lying in one
plane arises now a clear vesicle, which quickly divides into
four small nucleated spheres, and soon both the four large and
four small spheres—always preceded by their nuclei—again
divide, so that the egg now consists of sixteen nucleated
cleavage-spheres (B). ‘The large spheres overgrow now with
their progeny the smaller, and we have at last a spherical
mass, which consists externally of large, internally of small
cleavage-spheres, accordingly exactly the reverse of what
occurs with the cleavage-spheres of the Opisthobranchiata
and Prosobranchiata (c). Finally, however, the segmented
egg consists of large nucleated cells 02 to ‘025 mm. in
diameter, which do not as yet present any cell-membrane.

“At the end of the second day modifications of this cell-
mass are seen. On one side the cell-mass hollows itself
out, then flattens itself, and at the same time the in-sinking
narrows its area, so that the mass presents a cavity within
and a narrow emarginated opening leading into it. These
are the alimentary cavity and the mouth (p); the outer cells
are still larger than the inner ones. Beneath the mouth the
body now flattens itself out and forms a process—the foot, and
the embryo begins now its well-known and—since the time
of Leuwenhoeck—celebrated slow movements of rotation.
This rotation must be ascribed to cilia; but they-are so fine
that they have not been seenin Limneus, although one may
suppose by analogy that they exist especially on the foot (z).
The foot grows more and more prominent, and the body
becomes partially embraced by an annular ridge, in which the
later mantle-margin is soon recognised (Fr). From behind
now—over against the mouth—a new in-sinking is formed,
anus and rectum, which grows up against the primitive
alimentary cavity, and finally unites with it (a). The ali-
mentary tract now becomes hollowed out, and in its neigh-
bourhood large yelk-spheres are formed, the first rudiments
of the liver (H).

390 E, RAY LANKESTER:

‘As yet the alimentary tract traverses the body almost in a
straight line (1); but, now as the body becomes more
elongated and cylindrical, it begins to bend on itself, and the
anus takes up a position forward on the right-hand side. At
the same time the mantle-margin grows greatly, and the
hinder part of the body rises up in a dome-like fashion. On
it one can now observe the small cap-like shell (g), and in
the body a to-and-fro circulation, such as is seen in a much
more marked manner in the land Pulmonata.

“The foot forms now a prominent bilobed process, and above
it near the mouth, which also begins to push forward in a
snout-like fashion (kK), the tentacles are seen, and at their
bases the eyes. The mantle ridge arches now more and more
widely forward and raises itself up, so that we can now
clearly distinguish a lung-chamber, in which ciliary move-
ment is observed; also the heart is recognised by its
contractions in the middle line behind the mantle-ridge.

“In the neck region the first rudiment of the nervous
system is now seen (L), whilst the foot grows considerably,
as also the shell-bearing hind-body.

“In the pharynx the commencement of the odontophor is
seen, and in the further developed lung-chamber the kidney.
Upon the eye-pigment a lens is now clearly seen, and now,
at last, according to Lereboullet, the otocysts make their
appearance, which in most snails appear in a much earlier
stage.

* At first the otocysts are empty, but gradually the otoliths
are secreted, and cilia appear on the walls of the sacs.

“The embryo is now so large that it fills up the egg-shell,
and soon breaks it and creeps out. The rate of development
varies much, according to temperature, but lasts at least
twenty days, and may take double that time.”

In reference to the passages lettered in the preceding quo-
tation, the observations recorded in this paper lead to the
following corrections :

A. The velum is not wanting in the freshwater Pulmonata ;
in its earlier annular and in its later heart-shaped form it is
well developed, and becomes the subtentacular lobes of the
adult Lymneeus.

B. The origin of the four smaller cells from a single
pellucid cell, coexisting with four larger cells, is not satisfac-
torily demonstrated, such a single pellucid cell being possibly
only a Richtungsblaschen.

c. Nor is the enclosure of the smaller by the larger
cleavage-spheres clearly made out, though possible enough.

D. The in-sinking and its orifice are not the alimentary

A NOTE ON ENDOTHELIUM. 391

cavity and mouth, but the gastrula-stomach and orifice
of invagination ; the latter closes up, and the pedicle so
formed becomes the rectum, which terminates blindly.

x. With a good English quarter, or, better, with Hartnack’s
10 immersion, and the use of osmic acid, the cilia which
cause the rotation may be seen. They are disposed on an
annular band, the commencing velum.

F. The annular ridge has nothing to do with the mantle’s
margin, but is the velum.

G. The new in-sinking has no connection with the anus or
rectum, which latter already is taking shape in the pedicle
of invagination. It is the “ shell-gland,” a structure com-
mon to many embryo mollusca, but hitherto unrecognised.

H. The so-called large yelk-spheres are not now first
formed, but have been there all the time, forming the wall of
the invaginated gastrula-stomach. They now undergo im-
portant segregative changes, and present the appearance of
large clear globules, covered in by a fine granular reticulum.

1. The alimentary canal is from the first bent, the cecal
termination of the rectum lying a little forward, and not
opposite the mouth.

J. The shell, as an exceedingly delicate membrane on the
surface of the shell-patch (in the centre of which lies the
shell-gland), is observable long before this.

xk. The mouth never pushes forward, but rather becomes
sunk and enclosed by the increasing development of the
border of the velum, where it overhangs the mouth. This
part of the velum forms the subtentacular lobes of the
adult.

L. It can be seen at a very much earlier period.

A Nore on Envotuetium. By Joun Cavary, M.D.,
Assistant-Physician and Lecturer on Physiology at St.
George’s Hospital.

In the last number of this Journal’ there is a paper by
Dr. M. Foster, “ On the term Endothelium,” in which he
gives various reasons against the further use of this word in
histological terminology. He objects to the word, both
because its etymology is “‘ of the most grotesque kind,” and
also on far more important anatomical grounds.

Much that is brought forward by Dr. Foster is, doubtless,
true; but some portion of his statement must, I think, be

1 «Quart. Journ. of Mic, Sci.,’ 1874, p. 219,

392 DR, CAVAFY.

admitted to be mistaken, and he has completely passed over
some important reasons which exist for maintaining the
separate terms originally proposed by His.

In the first place, the word is not quite so ridiculous, ety-
mologically,.as it is represented to be by Dr. Foster. The
word endothelium is obviously a contraction of endo-epithe-
lium, and means an epithelium which is within (odov or
évroc, intus) or internal, ¢.e. it means precisely what His
intended to signify, and is only so far a misnomer as (epi)-
thelium is concerned, since it covers “‘ surfaces of which one
great characteristic is that they are devoid of papille ;” but,
as Dr. Foster says, this extension of the meaning of Ruysch’s
original terms epithelis (of which epithelida is the accusative
case) and epithelia “ may be easily allowed.” Endothelium
does not mean “ that which is inside a papilla” any more
than entoderm means “ that which is inside a skin ;” endo-
plast, “ that which is inside a formation ;” or even entozoon,
“that which is inside an animal.” The real meaning of
these terms Dr. Foster will, doubtless, admit to be “an
internal skin, formation (nucleus), and animal.” The
etymological objections, therefore, do not hold.

Let us now consider, shortly, whether the physiological
differences between epithelium and endothelium are sufficient
to warrant the use of separate terms.

Dr. Foster says that endothelium cannot be employed to
denote the epithelium derived from the mesoblast, “ for it
would then include structures still called epithelium, and
differmg in no essential characters from the epithelium
derived directly from the hypoblast.” But we should not
forget that the mesoblastic origin of genito-urinary epithe-
lium may be more apparent than real. Waldeyer! has sug-
gested that its real origin is most probably from cells of the
epiblast, which have become mixed with those of the meso-
blast at the time of the formation of the primitive groove.
This view is not, of course, susceptible of actual demonstra-
tion ; but it is known, at any rate, that the mesoblast becomes
closely fused with the epiblast in the region of the axial cord
of His, and then again separates; and that it is after this
separation that the Wolffian and Millerian ducts are formed.
It is therefore quite possible that the cells lining these
organs and their derivatives may be really derived from the
epiblast. Physiologically, at any rate, they are true epithe-
lium, and not endothelium, 2. e. they are concerned with
secretion, which is never the case with endothelium, The
small quantity of fluid which bathes the surface of serous

1 «Wierstock und Ei,’ pp. 113—114.

NOTE ON ENDOTHELIUM. 393

and synovial membranes is a filtration or transudation, not a
true secretion in the ordinary physiological sense of the word,
for endothelium never forms glands, whereas a share in gland-
formation, and, consequently, secretion, is a constant charac-
teristic of epithelium, whether derived from epiblast or
hypoblast.

As Dr. Foster says, continuity “affords no argument
whatever for classing.... together. We find continuity
everywhere.” But in the case of endothelium we find in one
most important instance, not only continuity, but something
more. What takes place in the growth and development of
capillary blood-vessels and fymphaties ? We have in each
‘case a vacuolation and excavation of connective-tissue-cor-
puscles, whose protoplasm becomes ultimately changed into
endothelial plates, and we may find every transitional form
between a flattened connective-tissue-corpuscle occupying
the lymph canalicular system and the endothelium forming the
wall of the lymphatic vessel with which it communicates. _
We have here, therefore, to do with convertibility as well as
continuity; and if Dr. Foster admits that the connective
tissues form a natural group derived from the mesoblast, of
which convertibility of one member into another (well seen
in pathological conditions) is one of the most striking cha-
racteristics, I do not see how he can exclude endothelium
from a very close connection and relationship with the
members of that group. In fact, the most recent researches
on connective tissues have established a nearly complete
identity between endothelium and connective-tissue-cor-
puscles, and this identity is strikingly evidenced by the
close similarity of the pathological changes which they
both undergo.!

Now, in the case of epithelium, not only has no such
connection with connective tissues been observed, but
there are marked differences between their respective
pathological changes. The views of Heidenhain as to the
continuity of the cylindrical epithelium covering the villi
of the small intestine with branched connective-tissue-cor-
puscles in the stroma haye been rendered more than

1 “Tes cellules du tissu conjonctif sont plates, contiennent des noyaux
lats, et sont simplement appliquées sur les faisceaux du tissu conjonctif.
il serait complétement impossible de reconnaitre une cellule endothéliale
isolée de Ja plupart des cellules du_ tissu conjonctif.”—Ranvier, art.
* Epithélium,” ‘ Nouveau Dictionnaire de Médecine,’ vol. xiii, p. 687.

“Les altérations des séreuses . . . présentent une analogie com-
pléte avec celles du tissu conjonctif.”—Cornil and Ranvier, ‘ Manuel
d’Histologie pathologique,’ p. 456.

394 E. A. SCHAFER,

doubtful by the important observations of Mr. Watney! on
intestinal absorption, which he has shown to take place, not
through the epithelium itself, but by pseudo-stomata formed
by processes of connective-tissue-corpuscles, which project
between the epithelium, with which they are never anato-
mically continuous.

We have, then, in the case of endothelium, not only an
undoubted mesoblastic origin, but a close relationship with
connective tissues; its cells, moreover, never form glands
nor secrete. Epithelium, on the other hand, has a doubtful
derivation from the mesoblast ; gland-formation and secretion
are among its most constant and striking characteristics,
and it has absolutely no relationship with the connective
tissues. Notwithstanding, therefore, Dr. Foster’s statement
(p. 292) that, “In short, there is no reason why the cells
spoken of as forming endothelium should have a common
title, distinct from the general term epithelium,” I must
confess that I am not convinced, but think that the reasons
I have given above are sufficient to render the use of sepa-
rate terms at least opportune—‘‘im Interesse physiolo-
gischen Verstandnisses.”

Description of an Apparatus? for Matntarnine a Con-
sTANT TEMPERATURE under the Microscors. By EH. A.
ScuArer, Assistant-Professor of Physiology in University
College, London.

THE necessity of having the means of conveniently, but at
the same time accurately, maintaining objects, especially the
living tissues, under observation at a uniform temperature
(generally that of the body) becomes more obvious every day.
The existing methods of effecting this are, as a rule, not
sufficiently accurate for exact investigations; and, on the
other hand, the more accurate modes are frequently in-
convenient of application. For example, the apparatus
described by Stricker and Burdon-Sanderson in this Journal
for 1870,—although it is possible by its aid to maintain
a constant temperature under the microscope for a con-
siderable time,—yet requires that there should be a vessel
of water constantly boiling near the observer, and that
the water in this vessel should be maintained at a uni-
form level, necessitating a supply tube from a cistern, and

1 «Proc. Roy. Soc.,’ vol. xxii, p. 293.
? Made for me by Mr. Casella, of 147, Holborn Bars.

APPARATUS FOR’ MAINTAINING CONSTANT TEMPERATURE. 3%

an overflow tube to a waste pipe. Moreover, since the tem-
perature of the stage is regulated by the rate at which the
heated water is allowed to flow through it, and this again is
made to depend upon the difference of level between the
orifice of the exit tube which leads from the stage and the
height of the boiling water in the reservoir, and since this
requires a rather complicated screw mechanism accurately to
adjust the level for different temperatures (not to mention
the numerous india-rubber tubes requisite for connecting the
various parts of the apparatus), it is evident that, although
the apparatus in question may be well enough adapted for a
laboratory, it is less applicable to individual and private
work. The apparatus to be here described, the main prin-
ciples of which are a constant circulation of water and the
introduction of a gas regulator, will, it is believed, be found
simple and convenient in application, and capable of main-
taining with almost absolute constancy any desired tempera-
ture for an indefinite time.

The apparatus consists of a closed brass box, oblong in

Fre. 1.

Fic. 1.—a. View of warm stage with inlet and outlet tubes, unconnected
with heating apparatus. «. Horizontal section of stage, showing the manner
in which the thermometer is passed into the central chamber, and the direc-
tion of the current of water in the stage.

form (fig. 1, a), which rests upon the stage of the microscope,
a cylindrical chamber (fig. 2, 4, in vertical section) being left
in the centre of the box for the transmission of light from
the mirror to the object (as in Stricker’s warm stage). From
each end of the box a tube passes (inlet and outlet), and the
tubes are connected the one to the other by india-rubber
tubing, so that there is thus formed a closed circuit, which,
when the apparatus is ready for working, is entirely filled
with water. A vertical reservoir (fig. 2, c), of not much
greater capacity than an equal length of the connecting tube,
is interpolated in the circuit at a point not far from the inlet
of the stage, in such a manner that the upper end of the
reservoir is connected with the inlet tube, the lower end
with the outlet. The reservoir surrounds the bulb of a
mercurial gas regulator (fig. 2, d; and fig. 3), and is heated
below by a minute gas flame; it will be readily understood

that the heated water in the reservoir must rise up through

396 E. A, SCHAFER,

the inflow tube into the stage, while the colder fluid passes
into the reservoir through the lower tube to supply its place.

Fie. 2. Fie. 3.

Fie. 2.—Ideal section of apparatus. 4. Central chamber in stage.
c. Vertical reservoir heated by small gas flame below, and enclosing bulb of
mercurial regulator, d. e, e. Connecting tube of india rubber. The arrows
show the direction of the gas in the regulator and of the currents of water
in the heating apparatus respectively.

Fic. 3.—Gas regulator, about natural size. 7,7. Upper part of bulb
(rather small in proportion). a. Tube with side openings, to the lower of
which is attached the steel collar 4, in which works the screw g. . Small
steel tube with slit. 2,2. Mercury. The arrows show the direction of the gas,

The chamber in the centre of the stage is, when in use,
closed below by a circular cover-glass, which is placed on a
rim made for its reception, and previously oiled ; above, it is
covered by the cover-glass, on which the object is placed; it
communicates, however, with the exterior by means of a
small lateral tube which passes through the body of the
stage, but is entirely shut off from the surrounding fluid.
The bulb of a small thermometer may be introduced through
this lateral tube whenever it is wished to ascertain the tem-
perature of the central chamber (see fig. 1, ¢, in horizontal
section). This method of measuring the temperature has a
considerable advantage over that in which the thermometer-
bulb encircles the wall of the chamber and lies in the
surrounding fluid, for this last is always very perceptibly
warmer than the interior of the chamber. It has the dis--
advantage that observations cannot be made while the ther-
mometer is in sit#, but this can be met by slightly withdrawing
the instrument into the lateral tube. Indeed, ordinarily it
will be sufficient, when the desired temperature is attained

APPARATUS FOR MAINTAINING CONSTANT TEMPERATURE. 397

and the regulator set, to remove the thermometer altogether ;
the lateral tube may then serve, if necessary, for the intro-
duction of a small tube conducting gas or vapour to the
specimen under observation.

The gas regulator may be described as a mercurial thermo-
meter with its tube open above, and with two side tubes leading
from it, one near the bulb, the other near the top (fig. 3), To
the lower side tube is cemented a steel collar (f), in which a
screw of the same metal accurately fits ; by working this screw
the mercury may be raised or lowered in the thermometer
tube. A fine steel tube (f), with a slit at its lower end, passes
down a certain way into the thermometer, being cemented
around its upper orifice. The gas is made to pass down this
fine steel tube, and then up between it and the walls of the
thermometer tube; finally, it is conducted out by the upper
side tube, and by means of india-rubber tubing to the burner
below (as indicated by the arrows in figs. 2 and 3).

To “set” the regulator, when the central chamber of the
stage has attained the desired temperature, all that is
necessary is to turn the steel screw until the mercury is
forced up to the slit in the steel tube; the gas is now cut off,
except what can pass through the slit, and the flame is con-
sequently very small; the temperature of the water in the reser-
voir consequently tends to be diminished, and the mercury
in the thermometer tube to fall, but the moment this com-
mences more of the slit becomes uncovered, more gas passes
through, the flame is increased, and the temperature re-
established. It is easy to understand that if the steel screw
below is withdrawn somewhat, the mercury will not rise up
to the slit, and will not therefore cut off the gas until the
temperature of the water has risen proportionately higher
than before. By screwing out or in every needful variation of
temperature of the water in the reservoir, and through this
of the stage, may, as before said, be obtained.

It is easy to fill the closed circuit before described—con-
sisting of the reservoir, the stage, and the connecting tube of
india-rubber— with water (which should have been previously
boiled and allowed to cool), and once filled it will remain so,
provided the india rubber be'securely “ wired ” over the metal
so as to exclude the possibility both of leakage and of the
admission of air. The india rubber will, of course, readily
adapt itself to the varying volume of the fluid, consequent on
the changes of temperature to which it is exposed. It is im-
portant to employ as wide india-rubber tubing as the metal
tubes will allow, so that no obstruction may be offered ta
the free circulation of the water.

398 E. A. SCHAFER,

In the first experiments the gas regulator, which in that
case was made to depend on the expansion of air, was placed
within the body of the stage, but under these conditions the
temperature was found to vary within slight limits, according
to the varying pressure of the gas supply, just as an air
thermometer varies with the barometric pressure ; there is,
besides, a disadvantage in having the regulator at a distance
from the source of heat. By employing the expansion of
mercury to cut off all the superfluous gas, and by placing the
regulator directly over the flame, the utmost constancy and
delicacy are attained.

Tt is much to be regretted that, although we can learn the
exact temperature of the chamber, we have at present no
means of ascertaining how much that of the object under ex-
amination may differ from this; nevertheless, it is certain
that the proximity of the objective of the microscope produces
a considerable amount of cooling. If it be desired to reduce
this by warming the objective, it is not difficult to mtroduce
by means of glass T-tubes a secondary circuit of india rubber,
the middle of which shall coil around the objective, whilst
the ends shall be connected, the one with the ascending or
inflow tube of the primary circuit, the other with the
descending or outflow tube.

The reader will have noticed that the method by which
the circulation is maintained in the apparatus here described
is precisely the same as that employed in the hot-water
apparatus now so extensively used for warming houses and
conservatories ; moreover, the principle of gas regulation is
familiar to every laboratory student, and the screw regulator
below is a modification of a contrivance used in some forms
of barometer for altering the level of the mercury. Nothing,
therefore, is claimed on the score of novelty, at the same
time it is hoped that this adaptation of ordinary means to
microscopical ends may prove of some service to the
histologist.

1 The author regrets that the figures have been executed on too small a
scale. The following are some of the actual measurements (in inches and
fractions of an inch) of the different parts of the apparatus :

Stage.-—33 x 14 x 3% inch; diameter of central chamber of stage 2 inch ;
diameter of inlet and outlet tubes {7 inch; diameter of tube for thermometer
vs
3 eastbott Feit 2 inches; outside diameter 13 inch; diameter of
cavity for gas-regulator 1 inch; stand for reservoir (containing pin-hole gas
burner) about. 22 inches high. The stand may be of the same diameter as
the reservoir, but, for the sake of stability, should have a broad, heavy foot.

Gas-regulator.—Bulb 13 x inch; lumen of tube about 35 inch; length
of tube 3 or 4 inches; thickness of side-screw about + inch,

NOTES AND MEMORANDA.

On the Smallpox of Sheep.—Klein (‘ Proc. Roy. Soc.,’ 1874,
No. 153) describes the development of the primary pock at
the point of inoculation in this disease, which closely re-
sembles human smallpox; the fresh lymph used for inocula-
tion contains very minute spheroidal micrococci and other
forms not previously described, but closely related to micro-
cocci. He notes three stages in its development—l. A pro-
gressive thickening of the integument over a rapidly in-
creasing but well-defined area. 2. The formation of vesicular
cavities containing clear liquid in the rete Malpighu; and 3,
the filling of these cavities with pus-corpuscles and other
structures. About the third day after the pock has ap-
peared, there appear in the granular material, which now
distends the lymphatics, spheroidal or ovoid micrococci, and
branched filaments, either sparse or closely fitted together.
This vegetation, after one or two days, presents the character
of a mycelium, from which moniliform terminal filaments
spring, each of which breaks off at its free end into conidia.
The vesicles coalesce into irregular sinuses, and contain
similar masses of vegetation, the filaments of which, how-
ever, are of such extreme tenuity, and the conidia so small
and numerous, that the whole possesses the characters of
zoogleea rather than of mycelium. The rete Malpighii be-
comes filled with migratory cells which originate in the
corium ; these soon find their way to the cavities formed by
the coalesced vesicles, which are thus converted into micro-
scopical collections of pus-corpuscles.

The Peach-coloured Bacterium (‘ Quart. Journ. Micr. Sc.,’
1873, p. 408).—Professor Ferdinand Cohn, of Breslau, writes,
under date August 8th, to Mr. Ray Lankester:

“ Your Bacterium rubescens is the same thing which
Ehrenberg described (but did not figure) in his great work
under the name Monas Okent. The zoogleea-like form was
called by Kiitzing Protococcus roseo-persicinus, but was pub-
lished by myself last year in Rabenhorst’s collections ‘ Cen-

4.00 NOTES AND MEMORANDA.

turien der Susswasser Algen Kuropas, under the name of
Clathrocystis roseo-persicina, the adult form belonging to the
genus Clathrocystis of Henfrey. 1 took much pains with the
study of these curious organisms last year, before I was ac-
quainted with your memoir on Bacterium rubescens, and I
had in view to publish my researches in the next part of my
‘ Beitrage zur Biologie,’ but the number has been delayed up
to this moment.

“J must confess that, though I had strong suspicion of a
genetic connection between Monas Okeni and Clathrocystis
roseo-persicina, both being commonly found together, yet I
could never find any convincing proof of it.

*T shall put the growth you favoured me with into the
conditions described in your letter, and I hope to find, after
my return from my summer’s holiday, the development of
the organism.”

Mr. Lankester has observed further very interesting phases
in the-life history of this alga, which will be described in an
early number of the Journal. The most remarkable are large
subspherical bodies, reaching as much as 200th inch in dia-
meter. These are entirely homogeneous in structure, and
deeply stained with Bacterio-purpurin. They appeared in
the winter months, when the growth died down to a very
small size. Finely granular bodies and somewhat more
coarsely granular bodies of the same character were also
found, leading by an easy transition to the spherical agglome-
rations of homogeneous oval plastids (zoogloea-like aggrega-
tions) figured in the Journal, October, 1873, from which it
appears probable that the large structureless bodies develop by
a multicentral segregation into the loosely connected aggre-
gations of Bacterium-like plastids.

The Mode of Occurrence of Chlorophyll in Spongilla.—Mr.
H. C. Sorby is at present engaged in an examination of the
green colouring matter of Spongilla with the spectroscope.
In 1869 I made some observations of the kind (published in
the ‘ Journal of Anatomy and Physiology”), and showed by
spectroscopical evidence that chlorophylloid colouring matter
was present in this organism. Mr. Sorby informs me that
he has recognised in Spongilia all six of the chlorophyll-
constituents which he has distinguished in the higher plants
(see his paper on “‘ Vegetable Chromatology,” ‘ Proc. Royal
Society,’ 1873), I have recently examined the morpho-
logical character of the chlorophyll of Spongilla. I find
that among the amebiform sponge-particles of a green-
coloured specimen of Spongilla, some are composed of naked,
finely molecular, colourless protoplasm, throwing out abso-

NOTES AND MEMORANDA. 401

lutely hyaline lobose pseudopodia. The outline of the nucleus
is not strongly marked, but the nucleolus is obvious enough.
In others you may find one or two, three or four, or a crowd
of twenty green-coloured granules. These granules have a
uniform size, and a peculiar form, being concavo-convex discs
or cups.

Spongula, as is well known, is frequently colourless, or
rather of a palesalmon colour, Hence it might be suggested
that the green granules (the chlorophyll-bearers) are para-
sitic, as it has been suggested that the starch-bearing yellow
cells of Radiolaria are parasitic. However, in the colourless
Spongilla sponge-cells are found which contain colourless
granules, corresponding to the green-coloured granules of
the green sponge-particles. These colourless granules are,
however, less definitely disc-like in form than the green ones,
and are often irregular and angular.

It has been found that in the orchid Neottia, where
chlorophyll is absent, a green colour may be developed by
the action of strong sulphuric acid.

I have found that precisely the same thing is true of the
colourless specimens of Spongilla fluviatilis. When im-
mersed in strong sulphuric acid they gradually develop a
strong leaf-green colour, fully as intense as that of the
naturally green specimens. Microscopic examination after
or during this treatment is not very satisfactory, but the
colourless granules appear to be the parts which first turn
green, though after the reagent has acted the whole mass of
coagulated sponge-sarcode is uniformly impregnated with a
green colour.

I remember to have seen it stated somewhere, on chemical
evidence, that Spongilia contains a starch-like body. I
should be glad if any reader of the Journal can refer me to
an authority for this statement.

The above observations tend to show that chlorophyll in
Spongilla, as in the higher plants, is preceded by a distinct
chlorophyll-evolving substance, which is colourless.—H. Ray
LanxEstEr, September 20th.

Scalariform Ducts in the Prothalli of Ferns.—I have lately
detected scalariform vessels in the prothalli of ferns which
are quite similar to those described by Dr. Farlow in Pteris
cretica. I am uncertain, however, of the species to which
the prothalli belong, as I pick them out of a fern case in
which I grow a variety of species of different genera. The
scalariform vessels make their appearance just below the
notch and run out towards it. In some there is a linear
thread of one or two strands, in others a cluster of vessels—

402 NOTES AND MEMORANDA,

only one or two running forward. In the prothalli which
produce the vessels neither antheridia nor archegonia were
found; the root-hairs are produced on both sides, so that it
is difficult to say which is the upper or under side. A very
young leaf, formed as an asexual outgrowth in one instance,
did not appear to contain any vessels, but a great many hairs
proceeded from it, generally 3-celled, and such as commonly
occur about the first leaves of the normally developed embryo.
On many of the prothalli containing archegonia the leaf was
produced before the root. On the prothalli with asexually
produced embryos I found the leaf on one side of the pro-
thallus and the root on the other, which is’never the case
with embryos normally produced. JAMES ABBOTT.

[It may be well to state how the bibliography of Dr.
Farlow’s interesting discovery stands at present. His first
paper upon the subject was communicated to the American
Academy, January 27th of this year, and printed in its
‘Proceedings,’ pp. 68—73. Only separate copies have at
present reached this country, and it is, therefore, uncertain
if the paper is actually published in America. An inde-
pendent communication, without figures, from Dr. Farlow
appeared in the ‘ Botanische Zeitung,’ March 20th, p. 180.
The paper published in this Journal was revised by the
author, and all the figures for the plates were also redrawn
by him. Figs. 1, 2, 3,4, and 8 were different to any that
had previously appeared.—Eps. ]

New Work by Prof. Haeckel—We have received an early
copy of Prof. Haeckel’s new work published by Engelmann,
of Leipzig. It is entitled ‘ Anthropogenie: Entwickelungs-
geschichte des Menschen,’ and gives in a popular form the
facts of the development of the human ovum and also the
zoological facts which bear on the ancestry of man. The
werk is, in fact, an enlargement with much new matter of
the final chapters of the ‘ History of Creation’ of the same
author, now in its fourth edition. The embryologist will
find in this work—although addressed to the “ laity ”—many
important and highly suggestive views as to such questions
as the homology of the germ-layers, the genital glands, and
the primordial kidney.

QUARTERLY CHRONICLE OF MICROSCOPICAL
SCIENCE.

HISTOLOGY.!

I. Technical Methods.—1.A new Hot-stage.—Panum (‘Nord.
Medic. Arkiv.,’ viii) finds that in the hot-stages for micro-
scopical observation now in use it is impossible to determine
with accuracy the temperature of the object under ob-
servation, and there is the further inconvenience of con-
densation of water on the object. To remedy these defects
he has constructed a hot chamber of tin plate, which sur-
rounds the lower part of the microscope.as well as the stage,
light being admitted to the mirror through a movable pane
of glass in front. The sides and back of the chamber are
double, and thus form a large vessel containing water, which
can be easily heated. The roof is perforated to allow the
tube of the microscope to pass through, and also to admit a
small thermometer, the bulb of which is placed near the
object-glass. The object is introduced or manipulated
through openings in the sides of the chamber, which can be
closed with corks. The circulation of water enclosed in the
walls of the chamber maintains a very uniform temperature ;
so large is the mass of heated material that the existence of
small openings has little effect on the temperature of the
air inside, nor is this materially affected even by opening the
side or front windows.

2. On the use of Chloral Hydrate in Histology.—André
(* Journ. de Anat. et de la Physiol.,’ Jan., 1874) recommends
the use of this reagent for the study of the retina. Witha
solution of 4 grms. chloral in 30 grms. water (sometimes
with the addition of 16 grms. glycerine), the fibres of

1 The articles in this division are arranged under the following heads :—
I. Text-books and Technical Methods. II. The Cell in General. III. Blood.
LV. Epitheliam. V. The Connective Tissues. VI. Muscle. VII. Nervous
System. VIII. Organs of Sense. IX. Vascular System. X. Digestive
and Respiratory Organs and Glands. XI. Skin and Hair. XII. Urinary

and Sexual Apparatus.

The Editors will be glad to receive, for the purpose of making this
record more complete, copies of separate memoirs or reprints from pe-
riodicals, which must otherwise often escape notice. We have to acknow-
ledge the assistance of Dr. Cavafy in making these abstracts.

VOL. XIV.—NEW SER. DD

404 QUARTERLY CHRONICLE OF MICROSCOPICAL SCIENCE.

Miiller may be easily studied, and it is then evident that they
represent axis-cylinders, as Miiller supposed.

3. On Freezing applied to Histology—Axel Key and
Retzius (‘ Nord. Med. Arkiv.,’ 1874, No. 7) find that if fine
sections of frozen tissues be hardened before thawing, so that
the tissues remain in the state they have assumed by freezing,
they are generally pierced by a number of holes, fissures, and
canals. Thus, in tendon there are longitudinal canals; in the
skin, fissures and holes; in brain, spinal cord and liver,
numbers of lacunz and wide spaces traversed by trabecule.
Precisely similar appearances are presented by sections of
frozen blood, gelatine, and starchy matters. On following
the process of congelation under the microscope they found
that, at the moment of freezing, the water, in separating
from the organic matter (brain, blood, or starch), forms
branched acicular columns of ice which spread in various
directions. If the mass be now hardened by alcohol or osmic
acid, the spaces occupied by the ice remain as canals and
cavities. If it be thawed, the mass becomes confused as it
softens, so that the canals may be easily mistaken for normal
structures. It follows that conclusions must only be drawn
with the greatest caution from frozen objects, and never
without verification by other methods. Still, freezing has a
real value in certain cases, e.g. for transverse sections of deli-
cate membranes, and some other objects in the fresh state.

II. The Cell in General.— Development and Proliferation
of Epithelia and Endothelia,—Zielonko has studied, under
Recklinghausen’s direction, the growth of the cornea and
other tissues detached from their normal situation. We
must defer a notice of this important paper (‘ Archiv f.
Mikr. Anat.,’ x, 351).

III. Blood.—1. On the value of High Powers in the Diag-
nosis of Blood-stains.—Dr. Joseph Richardson (* American
Journ. Med. Sci.,’ July, 1874) advocates the measurement of
the corpuscles from suspected stains by means of a micrometer
eye-piece and high powers (1-50th or 1-25th immersion lens).
He finds that by this means it is easy to distinguish with
certainty stains produced by human blood from those of
sheep’s or ox blood. The method was successfully applied
by Dr. Richardson in the following cases :—Prof. Reese and
Dr. Weir Mitchell furnished him each with three packages of
dried blood from stains made by sprinkling the fresh fluid
from an ox, a man, and a sheep, upon white paper ; the two
series were simply numbered 1, 2, and 3, and each gentleman
preserved a memorandum of the kind of blood composing each
sample. Dr. Richardson then proceeded as follows :—Small

QUARTERLY CHRONICLE OF MICROSCOPICAL SCIENCE. 405

particles of No. 1 of Prof. Reese’s set were broken up with a
sharp knife upon a slide and covered with a thin glass. The
minute masses of dried clot thus obtained were then irrigated
by ~ per cent. salt solution until nearly decolorised; a
drop of aniline solution was then allowed to flow in beneath
the cover, and in half a minute washed away and replaced
by salt solution. The object was then examined with
1-25th immersion lens, and numerous coloured and colour-
less corpuscles were easily found. Ten measurements of
coloured corpuscles gave a maximum of 1-3125th of an inch, a
minimum of 1-3572nd, and a mean of 1-3407th. Specimen
No. 2, similarly treated, gave a maximum of 1-4444th, a
minimum of 1-4878th, and a mean of 1-4694th; and No. 3
gave a maximum of 1-5405th, a minimum of 1-6666th, anda
mean of 1-5828th. Dr. Richardson concluded that No. 1 was
human, No. 2 ox, and No. 3 sheep’s blood, and was “entirely
correct.” The second series was similarly examined, and
yielded the following results:—No. 1 gave a maximum of
1-4347th, a minimum of 1-4878th, and a mean of 1-4662nd;
No. 2,a maximum of 1-5405th, a minimum of 1-6450th, anda
mean of 1-5952nd; while No. 3 gave a maximum of 1-3175th,
a minimum of 1-3572nd,and a meanof 1-3430th. Dr. Richard-
son here again rightly decided that No. 1 was ox, No.2 sheep’s,
and No. 3 human blood. In no instance do the minimum
diameters of human blood-corpuscles closely approach the
maximum even of those of the ox. Dr. Richardson recom-
mends that in examining spots of blood more than 1-10th ofan
inch in diameter fragments should be scraped from the edges
or thinnest part of the stain, because the central portions show
numerous fibrin filaments which form a meshwork more or
less obscuring the corpuscles. He found that a specimen of
dried human blood five years old still showed multitudes of
corpuscles, which could easily be distinguished from those of
the ox or sheep in the above manner, a mean of ten measure-
ments giving 1-3425th inch. Dr. Richardson has thus proved,
in opposition to the statements of writers on medical jurispru-
dence, that human blood-stains can be positively distinguished
by the microscope even five years from the date of their
production from those caused by some other animal’s blood.
2. Numeration of Red Corpuscles in the Blood. By Dr.
Malassez, Paris (Abstract in ‘ London Medical Record,’ 1874,
p. 132). ee ii » Front
IV. Epithelium.—1. On the Epithelial Arrangement in Efron
of the Retin and on the External Surface of the Ca
the Lens.—Ewart (¢ Journ. of Anat. and Physiol.,’ May, 18 ;
p- 353) examined these parts in the eyes of various animals

406 QUARTERLY CHRONICLE OF MICROSCOPICAL SCIENCE,

by the silver process. He found the membrana limitans
interna to consist of (or to have immediately in front of it)
a mosaic of epithelial cells. These, in the ox, are multiform,
fit closely into each other, forming a continuous layer over
the whole retina. The small spaces between the larger cells
are occupied by hexagonal small ones, forming a centre from
which the larger cells radiate. The margins of the cells are
irregular, but not serrated, and there are round or crescentic
nuclei well brought out by hematoxylin and acetic acid. Ewart
also describes the lymphatic sheaths of His, as enveloping all
the vessels of the retina, and not only the small and medium
sized ones. The above-described epithelial layer could not
be traced beyond the ora serrata. The posterior surface of
the capsule of the lens is also covered by a layer of epithe-
lium, which in the ox consists of large polygonal cells with
a distinct nucleus and irregular margins, processes from one
cell dovetailing into those in immediate contact with it.

2. Epithelium of the Bile-Ducts.—Ch. Legros, “Sur la
structure et l’épithelium propre des canaux sécréteurs de la
bile” (‘ Journal de l’ Anatomie,’ 1874, p. 137; ‘ Centralblatt,’
1874, p. 581).

. V. Connective Tissues and Lymphatic System.—1. On the Sub-

arachnoid Trabecule.—Axel Key and Retzius (« Nord. Med.
Arkiv.,’ No. 7, 1874) describe these as consisting of fibrillar
connective tissue entwined by elastic fibres, and covered bya
cellular sheath. At the base of the brain and cerebellum
there are trabecule completely enclosed in a delicate fibrillated
sheath, whose fibres run circularly for the most part, but
sometimes obliquely, forming spirals. There are also longi-
tudinal fibres in the sheath, and sometimes it is composed of
alternate layers of longitudinal and circular fibres with inter-
calated nuclei. One fibrillar sheath may enclose several con-
nective-tisue bundles. Acetic acid does not cause the fibres
of the sheaths to swell up, but, again, they are not rendered
more distinct, as is the case with elastic fibres. On the con-
trary, they become paler and less clear. These trabecule
ae also covered by a single layer of easily detached flattened
cells.

2. Contributions to the Histology of Connective Tissue.—
Lowe (‘Centralblatt, 1874, p- 145) makes the following
Statements :—Every serous membrane has two layers. The
superficial layer is formed of endothelial plates. The deeper
layer consists of a homogeneous matrix, containing flattened
square, distinctly nucleated cells, arranged in regular rows.
If elastic fibres are present they are situated between the
two layers. The same structure can be shown (1) on the

QUARTERLY CHRONICLE OF MICROSCOPICAL SCIENCE, 407

delicate membranes which everywhere cover trabeculz of con-
nective tissue (endothelial membranes); (2) on the sarco-
lemma ; (3) very easily on the delicate membranes surrounding
primitive bundles of tendon. Thus, around each muscular
fibre and each primitive tendinous bundle a serous cavity can
be shown to exist, as has been done for nerves by Axel Key
and Retzius. Lowe concludes that all fibrillar connective
tissue is composed of membranes of the nature of serous
membranes, and that consequently every cavity in the tissue
must be viewed as a serous cavity.

2. On the Medulla of Bone-—Robin (‘ Journ. de l’ Anat.
et de la Physiol.,’ Jan., 1874) has a long memoir on medul-
lary cells, of which, according to him, two coexistent varieties
may be found, the first being a complete cell, the second a
free nucleus, similar to the nuclei of the preceding cells.
These elements are always most numerous in those parts
in which there are few fat-cells (foetal medulla, red medulla).
The size of the complete medullary cells is about that of leu-
cocytes, but their reactions with water and acetic acid are
quite different. Water does not make them paler, and only
causes them to swell very slightly. The granular appearance
is not modified, and no Brownian movement of the granules
is produced; their nuclei are not affected by acetic acid.
Robin does not agree with Hoyer, that the capillaries, arte-
rioles, and venules of medulla are destitute of walls, nor does
he admit the opinions of Bizzozero, Monat, and Neumann,
who consider the medulla as an organ for the formation or
destruction of coloured blood-corpuscles. The first of these
opinions is based essentially on an identity between the me-
dullary cells and leucocytes, and this, according to the reac-
tions above given, is denied by Robin.

4. On the Endothelium of Serous Membranes,—Tourneux
studied these (‘ Journ. de l’Anat. et de la Physiol.,’ Jan.,
1874) on newts, frogs, and toads, by the silver process. New
results, or rather new interpretations, are given as to the
relation between the peritoneal endothelium and that of the
cisterna lymphatica magna. The pits or depressions seen at
the points from which the peritoneal endothelial cells radiate,
and which have been considered as natural perforations
(stomata) in the wall of the lymphatic sac, by which it com-
municates with the peritoneum, are, according to him, cra-
teriform depressions of the peritoneum, which are occupied
by one or two delicate protoplasmic masses, representing endo-
thelial cells in their first stage of development. If these
young cells are partly or entirely destroyed in the preparation
of the object, true perforations of the wall of the cisterna

408 QUARTERLY CHRONICLE OF MICROSCOPICAL SCIENCE,

result, but these are only accidental. In many cases these
young cells only form the entire thickness of the cisterno-
peritoneal wall at these points. Finally, an examination of
the contents of the cisterna, and some experiments on inflam-
mation of the ‘peritoneum, tend to confirm the author in his
belief that these cavities do not communicate.

5. On the inner Boundary Layer of Human Serous Mem-
branes.—Bizzozero (‘ Centralblatt,’ 1874, No. 14) examined
the pleura, pericardium, and peritoneum, and in each case
found an extremely thin connective-tissue layer immediately
under the endothelium, which can often be more or less
easily detached as a delicate membrane. This is most easily
effected on the intestinal peritoneum and parietal pleura,
both in fresh preparations and in those which have had their
endothelium removed by pencilling, and then been hardened
in dilute spirit, potassium bichromate, or very dilute chromic
acid (0:01 per cent.)._ The isolated membrane is one to two
inches thick, homogeneous, finely granular, or fibrillar, con-
tains no cells, and swells up and becomes pale by acetic acid.
Its inner surface is covered by the endothelium, while its
outer surface rests on the wavy, felted connective-tissue
bundles of the serous membrane, in which there are numer-
ous cells. In the intestinal peritoneum it is separated by a
few thin connective-tissue bundles from the already known
reticulated elastic membrane. Both here and in the parietal
pleura this membrane forms an uninterrupted layer. Accord-
ing to the above it appears that, at least in the human pleura,
there can be no direct opening of lymphatic vessels into the
pleural cavity as described by Dybkowsky, E. Wagner,
Klein, and others. This structureless layer apparently cor-
responds to the basement membrane described by Todd and
Bowman, and denied or ignored by later writers.

6. On the Lymphatic System of the Cornea.—Dr. Thin
(‘ Lancet,’ 1874, p. 225), by means of impregnation with
silver and gold, shows that the tubes described by Bowman
in the cornea are lined by a layer of endothelium, which he
considers to be of a lymphatic nature. The endothelium
may be easily seen in old preparations, but may also be made
out in recent ones, and shows the existence of lymphatic
vessels in the cornea. His drawings of preparations of the
rabbit’s cornea show large lymphatic vessels lined with a
distinct endothelium, and smaller vessels joining to form a
trunk. There are also clear spaces corresponding to the
lymph-canalicular system, in which the corneal corpuscles
are lodged. These canaliculi all communicate with each
other and with the lymphatics. In preparations in which

a

QUARTERLY CHRONICLE OF MICROSCOPICAL SCIENCE. 409

the silver nitrate has penetrated more deeply, one may even
see that the endothelial layer extends to the canalicular
system, and is continuous with the endothelium of the tubes.
Hoyer and Schweigger-Seidel have noticed the dark lines seen
in silver preparations of the cornea, but have not considered
them to show the presence of an endothelium. Rollett
thinks that these lines can only be seen in the cornes of young
animals, whose fibrillar substance is in course of development,
but Dr. Thin has observed them in the adultalso. Further,
by using both silver nitrate and gold chloride he has seen
that the nerves coloured by the latter reagent are contained
in the cavity of the lymphatic, which they fill almost com-
pletely ; but a narrow, clear space can be distinctly seen be-
tween the nerve and the wall of the lymphatic. The branches
of the nerves given off from the chief trunk have a similar
relation to the smaller lymphatic vessels in which they are
contained.

7. On the Structure of Lymphatic Glands.—Bizzozero
(separately printed memoir) has investigated the reticulum
of the lymph-paths in the dog, man, rabbit, and calf. This
is commonly described as consisting of homogeneous or deli-
cately striated fibres, with here and there a nucleus, or in
some places as composed of stellate connective-tissue-
corpuscles, communicating with each other and with the
fibres by numerous processes. Billroth (‘ Virchow’s Archiv,’
vol. xxi, p. 347) had already stated that in chronically in-
flamed glands the nuclei had partly developed into spindle
cells, which were merely applied laterally to the fibres. This,
however, appears to be the normal condition, according to
Bizzozero. In fine sections of hardened glands of the dog,
which have been freed from lymph-cells by shaking in water,
the cellular elements of the reticulum can be recognised as
spindle-shaped, stellate, or flattened cells, with a coarsely
granular protoplasm, often containing fat- and pigment-
granules. The nucleus is oval, finely granular, and contains
one or two shining round nucleoli. Their number varies
with the time for which the preparations are shaken. At
first there are large numbers of them, even in adult animals,
but the longer the sections are shaken the more is the reti-
culum freed from them, so that in good preparations they
may all be dislodged without injury to the adenoid network.
This fact is enough to prove that the cells are simply applied
to the fibres—that they are contiguous to but not continuous
with them. This can also be seen with high powers in
sections in which the cells are still present. The cell may
then be seen either to surround a fibre, which then becomes

410 QUARTERLY CHRONICLE OF MICROSCOPICAL SCIENCE.

enclosed in a tube of protoplasm, the nucleus being closely
applied to the side of the fibre ; orit may be thin and flattened
and spread out in one of the meshes of the reticulum, which
it occupies as a picture does its frame; the nucleus then
occupies the centre of the mesh. A similar arrangement
holds good in the other animals examined.

Bizzozero affirms that in the reticulum of the follicular
cylinders the same relations may be seen. The reticulum
here consists of delicate, homogeneous, communicating fibres,
flattened and broad at the nodular points. It is on, and not
in, these nodular points that the cells lie. They consist of
an oval nucleus with a very narrow protoplasmic zone, and
can also be dislodged by prolonged shaking, without injury
to the reticulum.

Bizzozero has also succeeded in demonstrating the exist-
ence of a layer of endothelium covering the follicular
cylinders, and thus forming the wall of the lymph-paths.

8. Normal and Pathological Anatomy of the Lymphatic
System of the Lungs.—Klein (‘ Proc. Roy. Soc.,’ 1874, No.
149) gives a full description of the above, as seen in guinea-
pigs, dogs, cats, rats, and rabbits. The endothelium of the
surface of the pulmonary pleura consists of a single layer of
polyhedral cells, which are not flattened, but shortly columnar
and granular, that of the costal pleura being formed of much
flattened, almost hyaline plates. The pulmonary pleura
consists of a thin layer of connective tissue, with a very rich
network of elastic fibres, the matrix usually contains one
layer of flattened connective-tissue-corpuscles. Beneath the
pleura, in the guinea-pig, there is a membrane consisting of
unstriped muscle, arranged in bundles so as to form a mesh-
work, with elongated large meshes, which have a greater
diameter in the distended than in the collapsed lung. These
muscular bundles radiate from the apex to the base of the ©
lung, and are most abundant on the anterior external and
internal surfaces; on the posterior surface they are scanty,
and become more and more so near the spinal column, the
fibres being most richly distributed over those parts of the
lung which move most actively in respiration. In rats,
rabbits, cats, and dogs, the muscular bundles occur more
sparingly.

Pleural Lymphatics.—The meshes of the muscular mem-
brane in the guinea-pig’s lung are lined by a single layer of
flattened endothelium, and constitute a communicating system
of lymphatic sinuses, which communicate freely by true
stomata with the pleural cavity. The cells of the membrana
propria of the pulmonary pleura (lymph-canalicular system)

QUARTERLY CHRONICLE OF MICROSCOPICAL SCIENCE. 41]

send forth processes which project between the endothelium
of the free surface, forming pseudostomata.

Sub-pleural Lymphatics—The pleural lymphatic sinuses
communicate with lymphatic tubes lying in grooves cor-
responding to the most superficial groups of the alveoli of the
lung. These vessels have valves, and anastomose to form a
network, which receives branches originating between the
alveoli of the superficial portions of the lung. These inter-
alveolar lymphatics commence in the lymph-canalicular system
of the alveolar septa, whose cells are in direct continuity with
the endothelium of the lymphatics.

Perwascular Lymphatics—These originate also from
branched cells in the alveolar septa, the capillaries being
collected into trunks which accompany the branches of the
pulmonary artery and veins. They either run in the adven-
titia of these vessels in twos or threes, anastomosing with
each other, or the blood-vessel is entirely or partially invagi-
nated in a lymphatic. The branched cells of the alveolar
septa, from which the capillaries of this system originate,
send processes between the epithelium into the cavities of
the alveoli, thus forming pseudostomata. This is the only
means of communication between the alveolar cavities and
the lymphatics.

Peribronchial Lymphatics.—These vessels are usually
distributed in the adventitia of the bronchi, anastomosing
with each other and with the perivascular lymphatics. Their
capillaries originate in the mucous membrane of the bronchi
and pierce the muscular coat. The wall of these capillary
branches is continuous with the branched cells of the mucosa,
which also penetrate, as a nucleated reticulum, between the
epithelium of the bronchus and project on its free surface,
forming pseudostomata. The lymphatics are always most
numerous on that side of a bronchus which is turned towards a
branch of the pulmonary artery. In the course of the smaller
_ bronchi, whose walls have no cartilage, there are generally
several vascular lymphatic follicles, which are surrounded by
a lymphatic vessel, as the lymph-follicles of Peyer’s patches
are by their lymph-sinuses. These follicles extend to the
muscular coat, and in some cases may be traced through it
to the mucosa. These follicles always lie in the wall of a
lymphatic vessel, between the bronchus and the accompa-
nying branch of the pulmonary artery. They are of different
sizes, and generally spherical or elliptical. These peri-
lymphangial follicles are especially numerous in the guinea-
pig’s lungs, and are constantly growing and being repro-
duced, The lymphatic vessels of the two last-mentioned

412 QUARTERLY CHRONICLE OF MICROSCOPICAL’ SCIENCE.

systems anastomose with each other in the ligaments of the
lung, and finally enter the bronchial lymphatic glands.

The second portion of Klein’s paper is occupied by a
description of the pathological changes which occur in arti-
ficial tuberculosis ‘in animals, of which we can only give a
very short account. The first structural changes which
appear in the guinea-pig’s lung consist in the appearance of
perivascular lymphatic nodules and cords. These commence
in the ultimate branches of the pulmonary artery, whose
endothelium germinates until the lumen of the vessels is
nearly blocked by its products; the lymphatics become con-
verted into adenoid tissue, which grows from the endothelium
both internally (endolymphangial) and externally (peri-
lymphangial). These perivascular lymphatic (tubercular)
cords spread both along the lymphatics to the larger branches
and also towards the interalveolar branched cells. The
capillaries of the affected alveoli then become converted into
solid nucleated bands and threads, which are continuous
with the surrounding reticulum. Secondary to the above
_ process, there is a thickening of the alveolar septa, and a
proliferation of the epithelium filling the alveoli, often inter-
mixed with lymphoid corpuscles. Sometimes the enlarged
epithelial cells become fused into one multinuclear “ giant-
cell.” When this is the case the giant-cells gradually
become changed into a fibrillated tissue with few cells, which
rapidly spreads, and finally undergoes first a fibrous, then a
cheesy degeneration. The adenoid tissue of the perivascular
cords never degenerates. ‘The secondary process passes from
the infundibula to the bronchi, whose epithelium proliferates
abundantly, while the branched cells of the mucosa become
converted into adenoid tissue. The process above described
takes place in man in inverted order, 3. e. the first changes
are seen in the alveoli and interalveolar septa, and these
changes are followed by the appearance of perivascular
cords.

9. Lymphatics of the Thyroid.—J. Nawalichin (of Kasan)
in * Pfliiger’s Archiv,’ vol. i11; abstract in ‘ London Medical
Record,’ 1874, p. 262.

10. On the Cartilages and Synovial Membranes of the
Joints.—Reyher (‘ Journ. of Anat. and Physiol.,’ May, 1874,
p- 261) investigated the formation and development of the
so-called ‘‘ marginal zone” of the synovial membrane, 7. e.
the portion which extends over those parts of the articular
surfaces which are not ordinarily in contact, the question
being whether this is an ingrowth from the synovial mem-
brane or not. For this purpose the joints of embryos and

QUARTERLY CHRONICLE OF MICROSCOPICAL SCIENCE. 413

young animals were examined, and compared with those of
adults and with human joints at different ages. These were
treated by silver, hematoxylin, and gold, and studied on
surface sections. On examining the head of the femur of a
sheep’s embryo one and three quarters inch long, the layer of
cells described as an epithelium by Todd and Bowman and
Reichert was found not to exist; there is only a homoge-
neous substance with nuclei embedded, surrounded by a
variable amount of protoplasm. Precisely the same appear-
ances are shown by the deeper parts of the cartilage. In
more advanced embryos (sheep, two and a half inches long)
other places are also found in which the nuclei are rather
more separated, brown lines appearing here and there
between them. Later on, the brown lines become more
frequent and broader, and in some places form a network
like that on the surface of serous membranes, but with
smaller and more irregular territories. In other embryoes the
greater part of the articular surfaces is covered with these
flat epithelioid cells. This appearance is due to the gradual
development of intercellular substance, which increases, the
cells becoming separated by broad bands of matrix, and at
the same time becoming irregularly angular, stellate, or
elongated, with long processes which dip down obliquely
into the matrix. The matrix grows over as well as between
the cells, so that in the adult there is a distinct hyaline layer
covering the surface of the cartilage. While this is occurring
the irregular, stellate, angular, and elongated cells become
gradually transformed in parts where the articular surfaces
are constantly in contact, with loss of their processes, into
the round scattered cells of ordinary cartilage.

At the time when the articular surface proper has the
above epithelioid appearance, the same can be traced over its
margin as far as the insertion of the capsule, where, in the
adult, vessels and irregularly disposed cells are to be found.
The cells are of the same size as those covering the cartilage,
but less polygonal, and separated by more intercellular sub-
stance, into which they send short’ knobbed processes, not
long and tapering ones, as in the adult. There is every
transitional form between these and the cartilage cells, which,
as they approach the synovial membrane, begin to exhibit a
gradually increasing number of processes, and become more
irregular, until they precisely resemble those on the inner
layer of the capsule, with which they are connected by freely
communicating branches. As development proceeds these
appearances are reversed, the cells being widely separated
and of irregular forms over the cartilage, whilst near and

414 QUARTERLY CHRONICLE OF MICROSCOPICAL SCIENCE.

upon the capsule they are epithelioid. These cells, whether
possessing processes, or arranged like an epithelium, must be
Jooked upon as connective-tissue corpuscles. In the synovial
membrane itself Reyher also denies the existence of an
epithelium. , Places may be found on the inner surface of the
capsule with the cells regularly arranged, but these patches
are never extensive. The irregular branched form of cells
persists throughout life on the inner surface of the capsule ;
but on the surface of the cartilage a change occurs, depending
on the growth of the articular surfaces and on the varying
conditions of contact and pressure to which they are exposed.
On concave articular surfaces, whose growth is more or less
uniform both near the centre and at the periphery, the cells,
whether epithelioid, stellate, or rounded, are more or less
similar throughout ; whereas on convex surfaces, such as the
head of the humerus or femur, the superficial cells near the
neck are far less separated than those nearer the centre of the
articular surface, when growth and development are more
rapid. Again, in parts of the surface which are always in
contact, the epithelioid cells become as development pro-
ceeds irregularly stellate, finally losing their processes and
becoming round, so that at birth the epithelioid arrangement
has mostly disappeared. The converse had been already
shown by Reyher by keeping the joints of dogs at rest, so
as to remove all effects of pressure and movement. The cells
on the articular surfaces then again take on a more or less
epithelioid arrangement, accompanied by an absorption of
intercellular substance, and this extends also to the deeper
layers of the cartilage. Hence the synovial process is not to be
looked upon as an ingrowth of the synovial membrane as,
some have asserted, but rather as being formed 7n si¢@ as the
development of the joint proceeds, its cells being intimately
related both by the history of their development and by the
presence of intermediate forms with the cartilage cells of the
articular surface.

11. Development of Bone.—Ranvier (‘ Quelques faits
relatifs au Developpement du Tissu Osseux,’ ‘ Comptes
Rendus,’ 1873, ii, Ixxvii, 1105; ‘ Centrablatt,’ 1874, p. 452).

12. Connective Tissue of the Spinal Cord.—Ranvier
(‘Comptes Rendus,’ 1873, ii, lxxvii, 1299; Centralblatt,’
1874, p. 483) contends that this is similar to the connective
tissue of the peripheral nerves.

13. Bone-Absorption by Means of Giant-Cells.—Mr.
Alexander Morison (‘ Edinburgh Medical Journal’ for October,
1873), taking up the researches of Kolliker on absorption of
bone by means of giant-cells (see ‘ London Medical Record,’

QUARTERLY CHRONICLE OF MICROSCOPICAL SCIENCE. 415

1873), finds, on examination of sections through the jaw
prior to the formation of the tooth-sac, that many giant-cells
contain clear round or oval holes of various sizes. The larger
and more distinctly defined ones, in the centre of which a
débris resembling fatty particles is sometimes to be detected,
appear to be originated by a disintegration of minute portions
of the protoplasm of the giant-cell. From this the author
takes it as possible that the giant-cells, after having ceased to
exercise their destructive, ¢. e. absorbing function, become
disintegrated. Morison takes it also as probable that sequestra
are separated from living bone by means of giant-cells, for,
on examining a fresh sequestrum from a case of necrosis of
the tibia, there were found Howship’s lacune covering all
aspects of the sequestrum, and the blood and pus around
the preparation contained multinuclear giant-cells floating
about.

As regards the origin of giant-cells, Morison agrees with
Kolliker and others that many of them are in genetical con-
nection with the osteoblasts, but that others probably develop
from embryonic connective tissue ; for there occur bone-spaces
with here and there a giant-cell entirely destitute of osteo-
blasts, but containing the nuclei of embryonic connective
tissue. These nuclei, generally scattered, are here and there
closely aggregated and show an internuclear opacity, which,
however, has not the distinctly granular appearance of the
opaque cell-substance of a fully developed giant-cell ; but this
appearance is in variable degree, even in fully formed cells.
It is possible that the aggregation of nuclei may be the first
stage in the formation of a giant-cell; one has only to
imagine that these nuclei prepare a cell-material each
around itself, which, coalescing with that round its neigh-
bours, produces the multinuclear giant-cell.—E. Kein, M.D.,
in ‘London Medical Record,’

14. On the Absorption of Bone. Rustizky (‘ Virchow’s
Archiv.,’ lix., p. 202) confirms the presence of giant-cells in
normal and pathological absorption of bone. He finds that
there are three modes in which they occur, either only in a
single layer immediately on the surface of the affected portion
of bone, or also in the periosteum; or lastly, also, in the
interior of the bone. The presence of giant-cells could not
be shown in all cases of bone-absorption, and notably not in
the little depressions formed on the inner surface ‘of the
calvaria by the Pacchionian bodies, nor in a sternum which
was partially atrophied by the pressure of a hypertrophied
heart. Hence the author does not accept Kolliker and
Wegener’s views, that long-continued pressure against a bone

416 QUARTERLY CHRONICLE OF MICROSCOPICAL SCIENCE.

is the chief cause of the formation of giant-cells; which are,
moreover, found in large numbers on the external surface of
masses of callus, where there is no appreciable pressure. Still
it was possible to produce atrophy with giant-cells artificially
in animals, by long-continued local pressure on a bone; but
they were also found in the interior of the bone, where
pressure could not of course operate directly. Further, the
author found that giant-cells were developed in the lymph-
sacs of frogs, after the irritation caused by the introduction of
various foreign bodies, so that he considers their formation to
be largely due to an alteration of nutrition, which is perhaps
brought about by pressure. Amoeboid movements were seen
in some giant-cells, but not in others, especially in those
whose protoplasm contained fatty granules. The author
therefore draws a distinction between “fixed” and “migratory”
giant-cells. In the latter, division was seen. The author
concludes that giant-cells may be developed from any form of
cell, and that their appearance in bone is not secondary to the
formation of Howship’s lacune.

VI. Muscle.—1. Structure and Action of Striated Muscular
Fibre-—Dwight (‘ Proc. Boston Soc. Nat. Hist.,’ vol. xvi,
Nov., 1873) used the legs of G'yrinus, which are sufficiently
transparent to permit the examination of their muscles
sitd. When at rest, but extended between its points of
attachment, the fibre is straight-bordered, and shows a series
of broad grey bands with a white border, separated by narrow
black granular bands. When the fibre is free from all strain
or resistance (as when one of its attachments is divided or
moved much nearer to the other), the fibre is much broader,
the black bands a little narrower and closer together. The
white and grey stripes are also narrower, especially the
former. The fibre has a scalloped border, the greatest
bulging being opposite the middle of the grey. When the
fibre is stretched it is narrower, with a more sharply defined
outline. The black granular bands become separated into
two parallel dotted lines, separated by a clear space. The
grey bands become lighter and the white borders darker, so
that the distinction between the two is less clearly marked.
The state of active contraction is difficult to observe, owing
to the incessant changes as the wave passes along the fibre.
A part of the fibre is seen to dilate, the black bands become
more prominent, approach each other, and seem to run with
the wave along the fibre. The grey bands (the contractile
element) disappear, so that there is only an alternation of
black and white stripes, the borders of the fibre being very
frequently, probably always, festooned or scalloped. The

ee

QUARTERLY CHRONICLE OF MICROSCOPICAL SCIENCE. 417

grey band seems to disappear in an early stage of contraction,
but this is not easy to make out. There seems to be no law
regulating the wave of contraction, which may run towards or
away from the tendon. Dwight has never seen the fibre
assume a homogeneous appearance during contraction, as
stated by Merkel, nor during repose, as Schafer thinks. Lon-
gitudinal striation was only seen in unhealthy fibres. It is
superficial, and probably only in the sarcolemma. Dwight
concludes that ‘ the fibre consists of a sheath, the sarcolemma,
and of a ground substance, in which elements which may be
provisionally called granules are embedded in transverse
double rows. There is no reason to suppose that the differ-
ence between the white and the grey has any other than an
optical cause, namely, that the part of the ground substance
nearest the black bands receives, not only the rays of light
that would naturally strike it, but others reflected or refracted,
or both, from the black bands, and which do not strike the
middle of the space between the latter (Heppner, Schafer).
If this be admitted, it is merely a corollary that in con-
traction the grey should disappear, as is the case. No
appearances have been seen that are suggestive of the
bundles of Schafer’s dumb-bell-like rods, which, indeed
(judging from the abstract of his paper), he has assumed
rather than demonstrated. As has been already stated,
nothing like fibrillar structure is to be seen in the living and
healthy fibre.

The sarcolemma is firmly attached to each edge of the ends
of the black bands, and the granules must, in some way, be
prevented from spreading laterally, so as to give support for
the folds into which the muscle contracts. The ground
substance is the contractile element ; it is also highly elastic.
When the fibre is stretched all parts become narrower, and
when contracted broader, but in the latter case the change
is chiefly in the ground substance.

2. Some Points relating to the Histology and Physiology
of Striped Muscles—Ranvier (Arch. de Physiol.,’ Jan.,
1874) has examined the action and structure of the two kinds
of striped muscles (excluding the heart) that are found in
some animals. Theseare pale and dark red muscles. Thus,
in the rabbit the semitendinosus, crureus, quadratus femoris,
and soleus, are red ; while the internal vastus, triceps femoris,
adductor magnus, biceps, &c., are pale muscles. The same
distinction is found in fishes, and in skates and torpedoes
there are muscles formed of the two kinds of fibres. The
dark colour of the red muscle does not depend on its contain-
ing more blood, as when all the blood has been washed out

418 QUARTERLY CHRONICLE OF MICROSCOPICAL SCTENCE,

by injection through the aorta the semitendinosus of the
rabbit remains distinctly redder than the biceps (see Lankester
on “ Distribution of Hemoglobin,” ‘ Proc. Roy. Soc.,’ 1873).

Physiologically, these two kinds of muscles differ from
each other. When stimulated directly, the red muscles con-
tract slowly and progressively, and on cessation of the
stimulus again gradually relax. The contraction of the pale
muscles, on the other hand, is brusque and sudden.

If the sciatic nerve be cut in two places, first, at its exit
from the sciatic notch ; second, in the middle of the thigh,
and the isolated portion stimulated, a contraction of the semi-
tendinosus (red) and of the neighbouring pale muscles takes
place—the former slowly and gradually, the latter sharply
and suddenly. Ou cessation of the stimulus the pale muscles
relax suddenly, while the red muscle returns slowly to its
former dimensions. _

As these differences can be observed by direct stimulation
in curarised rabbits, it is plain that they are inherent in the
muscles themselves, and do not depend on the nervous system.

There are striking differences of structure in the two
groups. The ultimate fibres of the red muscles show very
abundant nuclei, disposed in longitudinal rows. In the pale
muscles they are scattered and few in number. On trans-
verse sections, made after drying and coloured by carmine,
four to nine spherical nuclei can be distinguished in each
fibre of the red muscles, occupying slight depressions in the
muscle substance, or even embedded in its centre. The trans-
verse section of a pale muscle-fibre shows no more than one
to four flattened nuclei immediately beneath the sarcolemma.
In skates and other fishes the muscle substance is separated
from the sarcolemma by a granular layer. Flattened nuclei
surrounded by a thin layer of protoplasm cover the deep sur-
face of the sarcolemma, and others are embedded in the
muscle substance. Those which occupy the deep surface of
the sarcolemma are much more numerous in the red muscles.

Ranvier concludes by suggesting that the pale muscles
with their sudden contraction may be the muscles of action,
while the slowly and more persistently contracting red
muscles may have a function of equilibration or regulation.

3. Living Muscle-—Wagener has made observations on
living muscles in the transparent larve of Corethra plumi-
cornis, which he specially recommends for this purpose
(‘ Archiv f. Mikr. Anat.,’ x, 293).

4. Muscles in Typhus.—In another memoir (Ibid, 311),
Wagener studies the alterations of muscular tissues in typhus
and typhoid fever.

(Heads VII—XII are unavoidably postponed.]

PROCEEDINGS OF SOCIETIES.

Mepicat Microscoricat Society.
Friday, June 19th, 1874.

Osteo-sarcoma.—Mr. Needham read a paper upon this subject,
taking as a foundation the ease of a young man who entered one of
the metropolitan hospitals with what appeared to be an osteo-
sarcoma of the head of the tibia. Hard tumours, small in size, were
felt in the groin, as well as deeply beneath the muscles of the
thigh. The patient eventually died from chest complication, fre-
quent hemoptysis being a leading symptom.

At the post-mortem the growth on the leg was found, as dia-
gnosed, to be an osteo-sarcoma, while similar growths were found in
various parts of the body, and especially in the lungs. Micro-
scopically the growth on the tibia—which was subperiosteal—had
the characters of true osteo-sarcoma; but elsewhere only calcareous
material was found, instead of bone with lacunex, &c.

Specimens and drawings illustrative of the case were exhibited.
The case will be published fully elsewhere.

Mr. Golding Bird objected to the term osteo-sarcoma, since
calcareous deposit in lieu of bone was found, except in one place.
He considered the earthy deposit as accidental rather than essential
to the growth as indicating degeneration.

Dr. Pritchard did not consider calcification in all cases a degene-
ration; from its early appearance at times in morbid tissues he
considered it as much a part of the growth in which it occurred as
was true bone in an osteo-sarcoma.

Mr. Needham, in reply, agreed with Dr. Pritchard in not con-
sidering the calcification as degenerative, and was willing to con-
fine the term osteo-sarcoma to the parts of the growth only where
osseous tissue with lacunze could be found.

Imbedding in Elder Pith—Mr. Golding Bird read a paper on
the method adopted abroad of cutting sections of tissues imbedded
in elder pith, and packed in a microtome especially adapted for the
purpose. The various steps in the operation were exhibited and ex-
plained at the same time. The principle on which the process
depends is the expansion of the dried elder pith on the addition of
water, so that if packed in the tube of the microtome in the dried
state, and then allowed to imbibe moisture, anything previously
imbedded in it is firmly gripped. The paper will appear zn extenso
in the ‘ Quarterly Journal of Microscopical Science.”

VOL, XIV.—NEW SER. EE

420 PROCEEDINGS OF SOCIETIES.

In the discussion that followed,

Mr. Needham thought the pith would not give sufficient support
on all sides of the tissue.

Mr. Groves approved of the combined use of pith and wax in the
way that had been shown, as overcoming many difficulties in the use
of wax for imbedding in a microtome, and as rendering the pith more
efficient in some cases. He did not prefer a microtome that had to
be held in the hand.

Mr. Giles thought the small size of the bore of the instrument
might be at times objectionable. Suggested the use of dried carrot,
if pith could not be obtained; it would swell and soften on the
addition of water, like pith.

The Chairman objected to the pith-packing in the case of diseased
spinal cord, though in a healthy specimen the pressure exerted
might not be deleterious. On the whole, he thought the method
described simple, quick, and one giving comparatively no trouble ;
while the microtome, being held in the hand, was for some reasons
an advantage. He should certainly adopt the pith-process in
future.

Mr. Golding Bird, in reply, stated that, if properly arranged,
equal support could be given to the specimen on all sides by the
pith, or even the combined use of wax with pith would overcome
every difficulty on that point. He thought that carrot on swelling
would be too hard to cut conveniently, or would exert too much
pressure, The only reason for using a microtome with small bore
was to save pith, and large specimens he did not as a rule imbed,
but cut by hand. Had never used pith with diseased and there-
fore softened spinal cords, but for normal nerve-tissue had seen it
used with the very best results ; a proper degree of hardening in some
fluid first was all that was required.

Friday, July 17th, 1874.

Skin Grafting. —Mr. Golding Bird read a paper on the mode of
growth of the new epithelium after skin grafting, or at the edge of
a skinning ulcer. Specimens illustrative of the subject were ex-
hibited. é

A summary of the changes observed is as follows :—A prolonga-
tion of the epithelium forming the rete mucosum of the adjoining
skin, in a horizontal direction over the surface of the neighbouring
granulation tissue ; the vertically placed cells of the rete mucosum
losing their upright position, and becoming more and more inclined
till quite horizontal; the epithelial scales placed more superficially
taking no part in the process, but becoming shed, so that the new
epidermis was only one third the thickness of that of the skin from
which it had sprung, He ascribed the adhesion of the new epi-
dermis to the underlying granulation-tissue to the insertion of the
former into the most superficial layer of the latter, the inter-
cellular material of which may be seen becoming fibrillated like the

DUBLIN MICROSCOPICAL CLUB. 42)

fibrin of blood-clot coincidentally with the growth onwards of the
epithelium, the granulation-cells disappearing in great numbers at
the same time. He had never yet been able to find the granulation-
cells becoming developed into epithelium, but he had seen a few
of them lying beeween the cells of the epidermis. The granulation-
tissue beneath the earliest formed epithelium was the first to become
developed into fibrous tissue.

Mr. Coupland thought the disappearance to the naked eye at
times of a graft, and the subsequent growth of epidermis at the
spot grafted some time after, was a proof of the development of
epithelium from granulations.

Mr. Schifer referred to the observed transformation of white
blood-corpuscles on the recently blistered surface in the frog.

Mr. Golding Bird, in reply, denied that a graft that reappeared
as stated had ever in reality disappeared. He believed that the
deepest layer of epithelial cells was always left, though not visible to
the naked eye.

Pacinian Corpuscles.—Mr. Schifer gave an account of these
bodies, discussing generally the various opinions held regarding
them. He explained their several component parts, and held that
the “core” was the layer of protoplasm described by Ranvier as
covering the medullary sheath of the nerves. He had seen a nerve
pass from one Pacinian body to another.

Dr. Pritchard asked if the Pacinian bodies in the cat’s mesentery
were the same as in the skin.

In reply Mr. Schafer stated he considered them identical.

Mycetoma.—Microscopic specimens of the “ Fungous Foot of
India” were exhibited by the President.

Dustin Mioroscorroan Crus.
23rd April, 1874.

An Apparatus for Collecting Dust Particles—Dr.J. Barker
showed an apparatus he had devised and constructed, intended to
obtain “ dust samples” from the air, having modified for the purpose
a “ fan-bellows,” to cause a draught inwards by means of the fanners
through a wide lateral tube, within which were fixed a number of
grooves to receive a few slips of glass moistened with glycerine,
These were, of course, removable for examination for spores, &.,
under the microscope. By bringing this apparatus into use upon
heights, &., samples of the particles carried by the atmosphere
could be obtained.

Nucleus of Ovule of Welwitschia.— Dr. McNab exhibited a
preparation of the apex of the naked nucleus of the ovule of Wel-
witschia, to which numerous pollen-grains with the pollen-tubes

422 PROCEEDINGS OF SOCIETIES,

were attached. He remarked that, whether we accept the carpellary
theory or not, the pollen-grains of archisperms or gymnosperms are
invariably applied to the naked nucleus of the ovule, and not to a
stigma.

Microscopical Structure of Spine of Oolobocentrotus atratus,
Agassiz.—Mr. Mackintosh showed a transverse section of a spine
of Colobocentrotus atratus, Agassiz, which forms a somewhat elon-
gate ellipse, the major being about twice as long as the minor
axis. When viewed under a low power the general appearance is
Accrocladia-like, but differs in the irregular arrangement of its
periodical rings, in the absence of the wide central reticulation, and
in its oval form ; the radiating solid lines, also, which are so strongly
marked a feature in Accrocladia, are absent in Colobocentrotus.
When examined under a higher power the central part is seen to be
occupied by a regular network with very small interspaces, and
bounded by a ring of solid pillars, outside which the reticulation
becomes irregular, and continues so to the circumference, the largest
spaces being situated at the extremities of the major axis. The ex-
ternal edge is crenulated, the prominences forming the longitudinal
ribs which project on the surface.

Navicula Jamaicensis, Grev., and a Form of Surirella fastuosa,
Grev., from Philippine Islands.— Rev. HE. O’meara showed Navicula
Jamaicensis. Greville; also the peculiar form of Surirella fastuosa
described by Greville (‘ Quart. Journ. Micr. Sci.,’ vol. x, Pl. III,
fig. 1). These were found in material scraped from shells brought
from Cebu, one of the Philippine Islands, and kindly supplied by
G. M. Browne, Esq., of Liverpool.

Spores of Preissia commutata, exhibited.—Dr. D. Moore showed
spores of Preissia commutata, found by him in one of the tanks
in the Victoria House at the Botanic Garden, and which he was
momentarily puzzled to find in water; but the circumstance was
explained by his finding the plant established hard by.

Muscle Spindle-shaped Cells, exhibited.—Mr. B. Wills Richard-
son exhibited a slide containing several isolated organie muscle
spindle-shaped cells, slightly stained by carmine. He observed that
although, in almost all the cells, the nucleus of each was visible, it
did not appear to be so wide as represented in the organic muscle-
cells as illustrated in many works on histology.

A new Species of Staurastrum, exhibited.—Mr. Archer showed a
minute new species of Staurastrum with its zygospore ; but without
a complete techninal description, if not a figure, further reference
be of no use.

Specimens of Isotoma arborea, remarkable for the vast quantities
in which it occurred, exhibited—Mr. A. G. More exhibited a minute
creature, evidently belonging to the Collembola of Lubbock, which
had been found in amazing quantities beneath the floor of a green-
house ; they were removed by thousands.

Dr. E. P. Wright, on a casual examination, seemed to think
they were specimens, in almost all stages of coloration, of Isotoma
arborea.

DUBLIN MICROSCOPICAL CLUB. 423

Trichophyton tonsurans, exhibited. —Dr. Arthur Barker exhibited
a slide of Trichophyton tonsurans, and drew attention to its myce-
lioid growth, occasionally presenting a somewhat torulose appear-
ance.

Microscopical Photographic Negatives, exhibited—Mr. Wood-
worth showed some excellent photographic negatives taken by himself
of several microscopic objects—diatoms, insects, various sections, &c.
—mounted for employment with the oxyhydrogen lantern; they
were of great sharpness and accuracy of detail.

Double-spored or Twin-spored form of Cylindrocystis Brébissonii ?
shown.—Mr. Archer showed the conjugated state of a Cylindro-
eystis, which, if taken in the unconjugated condition, would be at once
pronounced to be Cylindrocystis Brébissonii, but the zygospore, or
rather zygospores, for they were ¢win, were so remarkably like those
of Penium didymocarpwm, Lundell, as scarcely to differ, except in
being notably larger. Thus, these very singular examples suggest
oneor other of two conclusions—ezther that Cylindrocystis Brébissoniz
conjugates in two ways ; at one time with a single spore, as often met
with, and as figured by de Bary (‘ Untersuchungen ueber die Familie
der Conjugaten,’ T. VII, fig. 12,13,16,17), and at another time with
a double spore or twin spores, like Peniwm didymocarpwn, Lundell—
or there is a distinct species of Cylindrocystis, so like Cylindrocystis
Brébissonii that observation as yet furnishes no tangible distinction
in the unconjugated state, but which differs in the conjugated state
therefrom. Penium didymocarpum, Lundell, so like in its conjugated
state to the present examples, is a perfectly distinct plant per se ; it
is very rare in Ireland (found as yet only at Connemara, and once or
twice conjugated, quite agreeing with Lundell’s figure) ; on the other
hand, Oylindrocystis Brébissonii is extremely common, and, indeed,
frequently met with conjugated (in the single-spored way). 'To the
former view, for the present, Mr. Archer was inclined to lean, that
is, that O. Brébissonii conjugates both ways, but in the double way
far more rarely ; indeed, it was the first time he had ever noticed
its occurrence.

28th May, 1874.

Hypertrophied Bark of Ulmus campestris.—Dr. E. Perceval
Wright exhibited a section of the bark of Ulmus campestris, from
Killarney, remarkably hypertrophied, producing on the small
underwood stems several irregular, elevated, horizontal ribs of con-
siderable height, and forming almost a disconnected or independent
growth of extremely exuberant degree of development.

Nitzschia grandis, Kitton, and Amphora lanceolata, Cleve, ex
hibited.—Rev. E. O’Meara presented a slide containing a new species
of Nitzschia, mounted by our corresponding member, Mr. Kitton,
and named by him WV. grandis.—He also showed Amphora lanceo-
lata, Cleve (‘ Diat. fr. Spitzbergen’), and which Mr. O’Meara had
found in great abundance in gatherings made at Spitzbergen by
Rev. Mr. Eaton,

4.24 PROCEEDINGS OF SOCIETIES.

Artificial Production of Crystals of Oxalate of Lime.—Professor
Tichborne showed some artificial crystals of oxalate of lime. These
were of various shapes, but the well-known typical crossed octohedra
were there in great abundance. The point of interest in connection
with them was the ease with which they could be formed. A deep
glass was taken, into which was placed a very thin layer of a satu-
rated solution of chloride of calcium and a piece of marble ; floating
upon this was put a considerable depth of glycerine, and again on
the surface of this a weak solution of oxalate of ammonia; the
whole was then placed on one side in a situation where it would not
be disturbed for a space of two months. Diffusion of the liquids
took place, and on examination a fine crop of this crystal was found,
capable of being mounted in the ordinary manner.

The Connection of the Peritoneal “ Endothelial” Oells.—Mr.
B. Wills Richardson exhibited several preparations of his own
mounting to illustrate the connection of the peritoneal “ endo-
thelial’ cells with one another. The specimens were prepared after
the nitrate of silver process, which had been very successful. The
so-called cementing substance connecting the margins of the endo-
thelial plates with one another was almost black, having the appear-
ance of a beautiful network. This was very well seen on the under
surface of the abdominal wall of the mouse and in the peritoneal sur-
face of a rabbit’s bladder. The preparations were submitted to the
action of the nitrate of silver solution (one grain of nitrate to every
drachm and a half of distilled water) for two minutes, then carefully
washed in distilled water, and afterwards submitted to the action of
bright sunlight for about one minute, when they were ready for
mounting in glycerine.—Mr. Richardson also exhibited a carmine-
stained piece of the desquamated epithelium of the frog, and
observed that he had failed in staining the cementing substance
connecting the cells together with the nitrate of silver; at least the
nitrate would not differentiate this substance by tinting it of a
darker colour than the cells.

On the Structure of Anorthite Dolerite —Professor Hull, F.B:S.,
exhibited a translucent thin slice of anorthite dolerite from Carling-
ford mountain, which was apparently similar in structure and
composition to the dolerites of the north of Ireland, except that the
usual labradoritefelspar was replaced by anorthite. The determination
of this felspar had been made by the Rev. Professor Haughton, who
found, from the large proportion of lime, that it was anorthite,
which he attributed to its proximity, when in a state of fusion, to
the carboniferous limestone of the district. In composition it con-
sists of a base of augite, in which the felspar is very definitely de-
veloped in the form of distinct crystals, or groups of crystals; witha
low power, and under polarized light these display a very rich play
of colours, some of ruby tint being particularly beautiful, while the
parallel bands and fine lines, characteristic of the triclinic group of
felspars, are strongly pronounced. Along with these are a few
opaque grains of magnetite, and one or two large rounded grains,
with a fainter play of colours than in the case either of the felspars _

DUBLIN MICROSCOPICAL CLUB. 425

or augite, which are, in all probability, grains of olivine or pseudo-
morphic after that mineral. The rock is largely crystalline, granular,
and has been called ‘ anorthite-syanite ;” but, as the basic mineral is
augite rather then hornblend, and as silica is altogether absent, the
name already applied to it seems the most appropriate.

Microscopical Structure of Spines of Centrostephanus Rodgersii,
Agassiz.—Mr. H. W. Mackintosh exhibited transverse sections of
spines of Centrostephanus Rodgersti, A. Agass. In this form the
spines, though agreeing in being hollow and deep crimson in colour,
differ considerably in external appearance and internal structure.
One set are fusiform and longitudinally costate, and, in section,
show the central cavity to be surrounded by a network of consider-
able extent, which sends out short prolongations to bound the
wedge-shaped solid pieces, whose external rounded projections form
the surface ridges, and which show a series of striz (like those on
starch-grains of potato) surrounding a more or less distinct point
situated near the base of the wedge ; the interspaces of the reticula-
tions are irregular, both in shape and disposition, except along the
line joining the bases of the solid pieces with the centre, where they
are tolerably uniformly quadrilateral, and placed directly behind one
another. The other form of spines tapers gradually from the base
to the point ; they are abruptly serrate, and have the central cavity
much wider; they display in section a series of urn-shaped solid
pieces (with thin strie, much less distinct than in the wedges),
whose stems arise from a narrow ring surrounding the central space,
and are joined by an extremely irregular band of reticulations ;
the solid pieces are also united by bread solid bands irregularly
placed.

Sporangium-like Structure in Polyactis——Mr. Pim showed a
seemingly peculiar condition of a form of Polyactis, presenting,
supported on branches of the hypha, what appeared to be fruit-like
or sporangium-like bodies of a globular figure, in which he believed
he had seen a division of the contents into a number of spores. The
present specimen had somewhat altered since being put up, and
these bodies now offered the appearance of globular mucous heads
to the supporting stipes, with a number of minute granules or
corpuscles within.

Pentastomum proboscideum, Diesing, exhibited—Dr. A. Mac-
alister exhibited a specimen of Pentastomwm from the lung and
peritoneal cavity of Boa imperator. ‘The species is closely allied to,
if not identical with, Pentastomum proboscideum, Diesing. The
specimens found were all females, and showed eggs in different de.
velopmental! stages. He deferred any further account until he had
time to examine all his specimens, and to compare them with
another species of Pentastomum recently obtained by him from
Aonyx.

py ieadeosaald involuta, Reinsch, new to Britain, exhibited.—
Mr. Archer showed an algal form, doubtless identical with Oylin-
drocapsa involuta, Reinsch (‘ Algenflora des mittleren Theiles von
Franken,’ p. 66, T. VI, f.1, a, b,c), though that author’s description

426 PROCEEDINGS OF SOCIETIES.

his plant appears not quite complete, as he omits to mention (ad-
mitting the identity) that the cylindrical hyaline outer envelope of
the generally but few, say 2 to 8 or 10, component cells is closed at
both extremities, rounded off at one—the upper—and produced and
(at least temporarily) attached to other objects at the other, or
lower, extremity. This plant, therefore, simple as it appears, seems
to offer a differentiation of extremities—a basal and an apical. The
examples agreed with Reinsch’s in the dimensions of the cells them-
selves, their ovate figure, and their being involved, withiu the outer
cylindrical envelope, by a number of special hyaline investments ;
these, however, not seemingly uniformly fowr (as Reinsch depicts),
but sometimes two, three, or four, and standing off from the cells at
uneven distances. Some of the examples showed cells recently
divided, quite as shown by Reinsch, enclosed in the tubular common
envelope, with their longer diameter in the direction of its length,
thus unlike C. nuda, in which the cells are placed transversely. That
author does not state that the contents are not a bright, but a dull
lurid green, very opaque. Thus, the morphology of this plant seems
to point toa close affinity with Hormospora, which, too, has its
forms with the cells longitudinally placed (H. mutabilis and others),
and transversely (H. transversalis), but the filaments of Hormospora
are bright and beautiful green, the cell-contents characteristically
arranged, and they form very long filaments, seemingly unattached.
But as forms or form-species (for they cannot be accounted more so
long as no reproductive process is known), those referable to Oylin-
drocapsa seem quite distinct, and none more so than the form now
exhibited ; it seems to be very rare; Mr. Archer had never before
noticed it (and now it was extremely scanty), anfl C. nuda had only
once turnedup. But whether these be mere stages of other growths
—mere form-species or permanent parthenogenetic forms—at least,
just as well as many others, constantly recurring and _ perfectly
distinct things, such as Nageli’s genera <Apiocystis, Ophiocytiwm,
de Brébisson’s Hormospora, &c. &c., the much more rare forms
now drawn attention to, referable to Cylindrocapsa, are entitled to
hold a place for purposes of reference until at least more may per-
chance be known as to their true nature and position,

INDEX TO JOURNAL

VOL. XIV, NEW SERIES.

Acarellus, M‘Intire on, 103

Alge from hot springs of Azores,

107, 211
Allman, Prof., account of Kleinen-
berg’s researches on Hydra, 1
Ameba with 1emarkable posterior
linear processes, 212
Amphora lanceolata, Cleve, 423
Anthoceros levis, 106
Anthony, Dr., on structure of a Le-
pisma-scale, 309
Appendicularia furcata, heart of, 274
Archer, W., further réswmé of recent
; | hare on gonidia-question,
5

pod, 317
Armadillo, existence of an enamel
organ in, 44:
Astropyya radiata, 321
Atmospheric micrography, 165, 421
Azolla penetrated by Nostoe, 215

on a problematic rhizo-

Baser, E. Cresswell, on picro-carmi-

— nate of ammonia, 251, 310

Bacteria in malignant pustule, 288

Bacterium, peachi-coloured, 399

Balfour, F. M., on development of
Elasmobranch fishes, 323

Berkeley, Rev. M. J., atmospheric
micrography, 165

99 ”
of Madura-foot, 263
Beryl crystals, 317
Bladder, contributions to the ana-
tomy of the sympathetic ganglia of,
in their relation to the vascular
system, 109
Blood- corpuscles, red, origin and deve-
lopment of, 202
white,amceboid move-

on the etiology

” ”
ments of, 108
VOL. XIV.—NEW SER,

Bowditch, H. P., lymph spaces in
fasciz, 91

Bruce, Dr., on inflammation, 203

Bryonia dioica, calcareous granules
on, 217

Busk, G., cement for mounting objects
in cells containing fluid, 281

sy on Clavopora hystricis, 261

Cactus, crystals from, 108, 211
Cancer of liver, histology of, 208
Caer Dr. J., note on endothelium,
~391
Cement for mounting objects in cells
containing fluid, 281
Centrostephanus Rodgersiit, Ag., 425
Chetonotus gracilis, Gosse, 106
Chlorophyll in Spongilla, 400
Cholera ejections, action of fresh, upon
animals, 282
Choroid, tuberculosis of the, 207
Chronicle, Quarterly, of Microscopical
Science—
Botany, 290
Histology, 185, 403
Microzoology and embryology, 95
Classification of animal kingdom,
phylogenetic, 142, 223
Clavopora hystricis, Busk, 261
Closterium linea, Perty, 214
Colobocentrotus atratus, Ag., 422
Colpocephalum, new species of, 213
Coscinodiscus, markings of, 101
Cosmarium holmiense, B, 213
Cosmocladium saxonicum, De Bary, 212
Crystals in Cactus, 108, 211
» in leguminous plants, 216
Cylindrocapsa involuta, Reinsch, 425
Cylindrocystis Brébisonii, 423
Cypripedium caudatum, hairs from
flower of, 105 a
Cystic tumour of breast, 316

FE

428

Cystoliths, 201

DatturnceEr and Drysdale, life-history
of monads, 102, 201, 202

Darwin, F., anatomy of sympathetic
ganglia of bladder, in relation to the
vascular system, 109

Dasydytes antenniger, Gosse, 106

Desmidium Swartzii, conjugated, 105

Diutomacee, Donkin’s natural history
of, 93

oy from Bermuda, 316

9 » hot springs
Azores, 107
», Peru and Bolivia,

ee », Spitzbergen, 254
5 new species of, 102
recent researches on, 81
Diatomella Balfouriana, 106
Diaphoracephalus, undescribed, 319
Diphtheritic membrane and croupous
cast, pathology of, 103
Diphtheria, 312
Docidium coronatum, Ehr., 214
Dolerite, on the structure of anorthite,
424
Duncan, P. Martin, on motion accom-
panying assimilation and growth in
Fucacee, 19
Dust-particles, apparatus for collect-
ing, 4.21

Eaes, cryptogams in interior of, 178
Elasmobranch fishes, development of,
323
Endothelial cells,
peritoneal, 424
Endothelium, note on, 391
En the term, 219
Entozoon, supposed, encysted with
ova, 179

Fartow, Dr. W. G., on asexual
growth from the prothallus of Péeris
cretica, 266

Fern-like stem cast ashore on Kerry
coast, 213

Finder for Hartnack’s microscopes,
175

Finger, microscopic, 105

Foster, Dr. Michael, on the term en-
dothelium, 219

Frey, microscope and microscopical
technology, 172

Fucacee, motion accompanying assiuni-
Jation and growth in, 19

connection of the

of |

INDEX.

Ganorhynchus Woodwardi, Traq., ga-
noid bone of, 211
Gastraea-theory, the, 142, 223
Germ-lamelle, homology of, 142, 223
Gouidia question, further résumé of
recent observations on, 115
Groves, J. W., on arranging and cata-
loguing microscopic specimens, 207,
248
5» on water-tight caps
“for use with higher powers, 205

HarckEt, Prof., new work by, 402

3 » the gastraea-theory,
142, 223

Heterophrys Fockii, Archer, 214

Hogg., J., pathology of diphtheritic
membrane and croupous cast, 103

| Holman’s siphon slide, 284

Hydra, Kleinenberg’s researches on, 1

ImBepDING in elder-pith, 419
Inflammation, 203

Infusoria, a new type of, 272
Injection, new mode of, 91
Isotoma arborea, 422

Jackson, W. H., on staining sections
with magenta, 139

Kern, anatomy of lymphatic system,

5, smallpox of sheep, 399

_ Kleinenberg’s researches on Hydra, 1

Lanxester, E. R., development, of
Anis stagnalis, 374
mode of occur-
rence of chlorophyll in Spongilla,
4.00
= on heart of Appen-
dicularia Jurcata, 274
on some of the
developmental phenomena of the.
Mollusca, 365
of a on Torguatella ty-
pica, 272
remarks on the
affinities of "Rhabdopleura, (Ki
Lepisma-scale, Dr. Anthony on the
structure of, 309
Live-cell, new, 320

_ Liver, histology of cancer of, 208

Loligo, spermatophore of, 102
Lostorfer’s syphilis-corpuscles, 180

INDEX.

Lymneus stagnalis, development of,
374
Lymph-spaces in fasciz, 91

M‘Intrrg, 8. J., on Acarellus, 103
Maddox, Dr., on a fresh-water Pro-
tozoon, 101
Madura-foot, etiology of, 263
Malignant pustule, Bacteria in, 288
Mammary gland, development and
growth of, 209
Marchantiee, reproductive apparatus
of, 215
Micrasterias furcata, 213
» papillifera, zygospore of,
213
Micrococcus, black, 321
ra prodigiosus, Cohn,
321
Microscopic specimens, on arranging
and cataloguing, 207, 248
Microscopical drawing, aid to, 178
e Society of Victoria, 285
Miliary sclerosis, 311
Mollusca, developmental phenomena
of, 365
Molluscum fibrosum, 315
Monads, life-history of, 102, 201, 202
Mounting in balsam, 177
Mucorini, researches on, 49
Mycetoma, 263, 421
Myrmecophaga jubata, villi from sto-
“mach of, 321

319,

Navicula aspera, 319

>» didyma, W. Sm., 214

3 jamaicensis, Grev., 422

» lyra, Khr., 214

» spectatissima, Grev., 106
Nitzschia grandis, Kitton, 423
Nostoc in Azolla, 215
Notommata, winter egg of, 212

O’Meara, Rev. E. O., on Diatomacez
from Spitzbergen, 254
b. recent- researches on the
Diutomacea, 81
Oreaster tuberculatus, 319
Osteo-sarcoma, 419
Oxalate of lime, 108, 211
is > artificial production
of crystals of, 424
Oxalis, hairs and epidermis of, 316

Pactnian corpuscles, 421
Pentastomum proboscideum, 425

429

Perceval Wright, E., translation of
Haeckel’s Gastraea-theory, 142, 223

Perivascular spaces in the brain, 315

Photographing microscopic objects,
103

Picro-carminate of ammonia, 251

Pinnularia cardinalis, 320

Platycerium, remarks on hairs of, 318

Plumatelia, statoblasts of 217

Polyactis, sporangium-like structure
in, 425

Porphyry, structure of Lambay, 317

| Porrigo decalvans, action of chloroform

in bleaching hairs affected with, 213
Potato-disease, 176 ;
Preissia commutata, 422
Prothallus of ferns, asexual growth

from, 266, 401
“e » scalariform ducts

in, 401
Protozoon, fresh-water, 101
Pteris cretica, asexual growth from

the prothallus of, 266

Rep blood-corpuscles in man, origin
and development of, 202
Reviews:
Donkin, Natural History of British
Diatomacex, Part II], 93
Frey, Microscope and Microsco-
pical Technology, 172
Klein, Anatomy of
System, 278
Rhabdopleura, G. O. Sars on, 23
= remarks on the affinities
of, 77

Rhizopod, new, 317

Rhizopoda from hot springs of Azores,
107

Riddell’s binocular microscope, 101

Roysteon-Pigott, Dr.,aplanatic searcher,
309

Lymphatic

B on verification of
structure by the motion of a com-

pressed fluid, 309

Sanpars, A., photographing micro-
scopic objects, 103

Sars, G. O., on Rhabdopleura, 23

Schafer, E. A., apparatus for main-
taining constant temperature, 394

Schmidt, Dr. H. D., on origin and
development of red blood-corpus-
cles in man, 202

Scction-cutter, new, 182

4.30

Shell of hen’s egg, egg-shaped depo-
sits on, 107
Silver method, 285
Siphon-slide, 284
Skin grafting, 420
Smallpox of sheep, 399
Spheraphides in tea plant, 217
Spongilla, ahidro phylisin, 4.00
Staining with aniline dies, 310
» with magenta, 139
Staurastrum arctiscon, Lund., 214
ys n. sp., 422
Strongylocentrotus lividus, 317
Surirella fastuosa, Grev., 422
Sympathetic ganglia of the bladder, in
their relation to the vascular system,
contributions to the anatomy of, 109
Synedra investiens, W. Sra., 105
Syphilis-corpuscles, Lostorfer’s, 180

Tenia tetragonocephalus, 317

Tatusia peba, existence of an enamel
organ in, 44

Taxus, remarks on structure of pits in,
321

INDEX.

Teeth, causes of decay of, 283

Temperature, apparatus for maintain-
ing constant, 394

Thysanura, Irish, 212

Tieghem, Ph. van, and G. Le Monnier,
researches on the Mucorini, 49

Tomes, C. 8., on existence of anu
enamel organ in an armadillo, 44

Torquatella typica, 272

Trap with zoolites from Skye, 211

Triceratium campeachianum, Grun., 319

Trichophyton tonsurans, 423

Tryblionella debilis, Arn., 106

Ulnus campestris, hypertrophied bark
of, 423

Urea, sodium chloride erystals in,
presence of, 316

WateER-TIGHT caps for use with
higher powers, 205

Welwitschia, nucleus of ovule, 421

White blood - corpuscles, ameeboid

movements of, 108

—

PRINTED BY J. E, ADLARD, BARTHOLOMEW CLOSE.

rat

Sc

=

© Fatlane & Erskine, Lith

JM

a : nt Bere

-

JOURNAL OF MICROSCOPICAL SCIENCE.

EXPLANATION OF PLATE I,

‘Illustrating G. O. Sars’s Paper on Rhabdopleura.

Fic. ;
1.—The animal taken out of the cell and slightly compressed, seen from
the left side.

Buccal shield.

Tentacular arms.

(sophagus.

Stomach.

Intestine.

Contractile cord.

Hyaline semilunar border at base of tentacular arms.
. The under lip.
z. The ciliated tubercle at the base of the tentacular arm.

The flexor muscle of the tentacular arm.
The buccal aperture.
The cellular body between the end of the intestine and the
cesophagus.

2.—The animal seen from the ventral side.
(Letters as in fig. 1.)
3.—The animal seen from the dorsal side.
(Letters as in fig. 1.)
4,—The anterior part of the body seen from in front; ¢, d, /, as in fig. 1.
5.—A part of a living colony magnified about sixteen times.
aa. The cells with their polypides in different states of protrusion.
6b. The creeping stem.
ce. The buccal shield.
dd. The tentacular arms.
ff. The stomach.
g. The intestine.
hh, The contractile cord.
a. The axial cord.

6.—A piece of the creeping stem freed from adhering particles, together
with the bases of the cells and their polypides mostly strongly re-
tracted, about 20 times magnified, showing the single chambers into
which the stem is divided.

cc. The buccal shield.
Bf. The stomach.

hh. The contractile cord.
wt. The axial cord.

7.—The earliest stage of development noticed.

8.—A further developed polypide seen from the dorsal side ; cc, the buccal
shield; d, the tentacular arms; 4, the contractile cord.

9.—The same polypide with the axial cord (2) seen from the ventral
side.

Sense reas

>

aoe

JOURNAL OF MICROSCOPICAL SCIENCE.

DESCRIPTION OF PLATE II,

Illustrating Mr. C. S. Tomes’s Paper on the Development of
the Teeth, in an Armadillo.

Fic.
1.—Section through the lower jaw of a feetal calf, 6 inches long.
a. Meckel’s cartilage.
4. Dentine germ.
e. Enamel organ.

d. Process connecting the enamel germ with the deep layer of the
oral epithelium.

e. Epithelium heaped up over the situation of the developing tooth.
J. Enamel germ of the successional permanent tooth.

2.—From the lower jaw of a fcetal armadillo (Zatusia Peba) 14 inches
long.
6. Dentine germ.
c. Enamel germ.

3 and 4.—From a feetal armadillo (7. Peba) 3 inches long.

6. Dentine germ.

c. Enamel germ.

Jj. Germ of permanent tooth.

g. Extremity of the cornua of the enamel germ.
h. Thin cap of formed dentine.

Mer beurnt VMN SPM

Mf Farlane & Erskine, Litht# Edin?

4 r SR, & OP)
% Wier Cou TV. Vey IW WS Lp THE

M¢Farlane & Erskine, Lith'> Edin*

Fy q Q 7 “DD
Mer Pour UA UMS LOM,

MC Failane & Exdkine, Lid? Edin

SEPHEGLa H e ecod PEPPPEESP LRT ReTR

JOURNAL OF MICROSCOPICAL SCIENCE.

DESCRIPTION OF PLATES III & IV,

To illustrate MM. Van Tieghem and Le Monnier’s Researches
on the Mucorini.

Fig. 1.—Section of a zine box for cell-cultures ; it is arranged to hold
two rows of slides, and is closed above by a glass plate; the bottom is
covered with wet sand or moistened plaster.

Phycomyces nitens.

Fig. 2.—a, spherical spores from small sporangia, the central granules are
yellow; 4, fresh, elongated, ellipsoidal or concavo-convex spores from large
sporangia; c, older spores, the wall has a double contour; d, older spores
germinating with rupture of the exospore (x 160).

. Fig. 3.—a, spores in process of alteration in a moist medium, the proto-
plasm condenses into nodules; 4, a germinating hypha in process of destruc-
tion, its base still inclosed in the epispore is partitioned off, and the contained
protoplasm is condensed into oval corpuscles (x 320).

Figs. 4—12.—Successive stages in the development of a zygospore ;
4—6, before the development of the processes (x 40); 7, 8, processes
making their appearance from above downwards upon one of the arcuate
cells (x 40); 9—1], their appearance upon the other arcuate cell simul-
taneously with the increase in the size of the zygospore (9 x 120, 10 and
11 x 40), in fig. 11 a slight traction has been applied to the two conjugat-
ing filaments; 12, mature zygospore enveloped by the dichotomous processes,
many of which are broken (x 50).

Fig. 13.—Side of attachment of an arcuate cell with processes*radiating
all round (x 40).

Fig. 14.—“ Vice” arrested in its development; the first process is developed
in its ordinary position, but has been prolonged and developed into ordinary
mycelial hyphe (x 120).

Fig. 15.—Base of a sporangiferous hypha (a); 4d, sterile branches (cell-
culture) (X 120).

Fig. 16.—Group of three small sporangia inserted with two sterile branches
on a branch (a) of the mycelial hypha (m) (cell-culture) (x 120).

Fig. 17.—Basal dilatations of lateral branches (4, 4) of a mycelial hypha
(cell-culture) (x 120).

Thamnidium elegans.

Fig. 18.—Different stages of the fructification.
Fig. 19.—Mycelium which has produced—(i) a large sporangium, (ii) a

dichotomy of eight small sporangia, (iii) a secondary lateral dichotomy of
monosporic sporangioles.

Fig. 20.—Monosporic sporangioles with granular walls (x 250).

Chetostylum Fresenii.

Fig. 21.—Lateral branch inserted, with numerous others, on the top-

of a hypha; it terminates in a point, and bears two false verticils of branch-
lets. The lower sporangioles are of the fourth, the upper of the third
order (X 250).

Chatocladium Jonesit.

Fig. 22.—Fruiting hypha terminating in a point, and bearing upon a
middle dilatation monosporic sporangia with granular walls aud simple or
dichotomous pedicels (x 270).

Fig. 23.—a, a monosporic sporangium, with a portion of its pedicel; 4,
one ruptured by pressure, sliowing the inclosed smooth spore; ¢, ¢c, spores
entirely freed from their sporangia; d. a spore escaping from its sporangium
at the commencement of germination (Xx 270).

Figs. 24—27.—Successive stages of germination.

Fig. 28.—Granular-walled balloon-like bodies terminating some of the
branches (x 270).

Fig. 37.—Successive stages of fructification in cell-culture.

Chatocladium Brefeldii.

Fig. 29.—Mycelium proceeding from a single spore after sixty-seven
hours ; ; the lateral processes are only figured on a single branch (m).

Fig. 30.—End of a principal branch after five and a half days: a lateral
process (¢) has developed a sporangiferous branch (@), of which the aerial
portion is shaded; it bears fertile branches (¢ and/), and also sterile ones,
at its base (x 190).

Fig. 31.—Extremity of a hypha after four and a‘half days’ culture; one of
its heihchies (a) is prolonged into an aerial filament, bearing laterally nu-
merous groups of ripe sporangia (x 190).

Fig. 32.—One of these groups of monosporic sporangia (x 400).

Figs. 33, 34.—Lateral processes in contact with a hypha of Mucor
Mucedo (x 400).

Fig. 35.—Three spores (s, s’, s') which have germinated, and the hyphe of
which have fused C4190).

Fig. 36.—Two branches of a hypha which have fused, forming a loop
(x 190).

2

Oe dag th)

j

| hear MSY

'

}

|

|

=|

B

s REIS ga —=

— ae
TU

ihe re

Mf Farlane & Erskine, Lith'® Edin®

ary

JOURNAL OF MICROSCOPICAL SCIENCE.

DESCRIPTION OF PLATES V & VI.

Illustrating Mr. Darwin’s paper on the Anatomy of the
Sympathetic Ganglia of the Bladder in their Relation to
the Valvular System,

PLATE V.

Fies.
1.—Posterior surface of the bladder of a young dog, stained with chloride
of gold, seen under a very low power. It shows the distribution of
uerve-trunks and ganglia in relation to large branches of blood-vessels.
The blood-vessels are coloured green, the nerve-trunks and ganglia
are purple.
2.—From a dog’s bladder stained in chloride of gold, showing an artery
and vein with the accompanying plexus of nerve-trunks and ganglia.
Hartnack, No. 4.
A, Artery (red).
- Ag Vein (blue).
B, B. Nerve-trunks (purple).
c, c. Ganglia (purple).

PLATE VI.

Fics.
3.—From the bladder of a rabbit, stained with chloride of gold, showing

an artery and two ganglia. The larger ganglion (1) is surrounded by
a plexus of capillaries. A nerve-trunk from each ganglion passes

down to supply the artery. Hartnack, No. 5.

A. Artery.
3B, B. Nerve-trunks.
c, c. Ganglia (1, and 1).
a. The place where the nerve-trunks disappear in the ad -

ventitia.
e f. Transverse line at which the nerve-trunk from ganglion 1 g

is supposed to be interrupted.
B, and B,. Nerve-trunks which ought to be continuous with each
other, and to connect the ganglia 1 and 1 together.

pp. Capillaries.

4.—Nerve-trunk arising from ganglion m1 of fig. 3, and supplying the artery
A of the same figure. Hartnack, No..2. :
a. Artery.

B. Nerve-trunk.
a. Nerve-fibres ending in the artery.

p. Capillaries. a

5.—From the bladder of a dog stained with chloride of gold. Hartnack,

No. 5.
a. Artery.
B, anda,. Nerve-trunks arising from ganglia situated close
together on a nerve-trunk not shown in the figure.
a. Nerve-fibres ending in the adventitia.

6.—Ganglion situated on a large nerve-trunk, with smaller accessory
ganglion, from the bladder of a dog stained with chloride of gold.

Hartnack, No. 5.

union

ej,

aS yr

Fa Lj!
Boxsrrsnrssee
pieeentecuadt

Mo Farlane & Erskine, Lith Edin®

i

Jo

NWI

S

= { :
= 4 ATO\Oo AANA /
2) C% 510} 2 so} \\ Lf /
sy YoORTY ALY he 4/7
Y Sy Slolgiaio\0\o\ . ei $ lem
ey ae oh t ~~ 4
tp VAoe ' 5 : :
17/6 ARARG . z = oo
« Wo) 1 VAAN , : ; Z Bs
: Glo) ojajo\e\e\P a I — = a ;
at =e ee ee , aI oa = on Ae
1 ‘ PAT 17%) -' = 4 H tenn
‘ . AAR Cita) ‘So is ‘
RS KA cho\o|oj2/0}0}0}8 S81") 8 =
VE} y =
=e RAF i a : ze mS
; Clay Wh 4 . SA a '
, HOC Ley, \ A
\ 4 r\\ .
‘ oe b \ \\)
\ Ss f 1X

EO
dal] MARY
{2 }olo}e\o\o\F
ALiejole\o\o

JOURNAL OF MICROSCOPICAL SCIENCE.

DESCRIPTION OF PLATE VII,

Illustrating Ernst Haeckel’s memoir on the Gastraea-Theory,
the Phylogenetic Classification of the Animal Kingdom,
and the Homology of Germ-Lamellz. Translated by
E. Perceval Wright.

Plate VII contains a schematic section through the young stages of re-
presentatives of all the different phyla of Metazoa, and will give a clear idea,
not only of the homology of both primary germ-lamelle, but also of the origin
of the four secondary germ-lamelle. Figs. 1—8 are schematic longitudinal
sections; figs. 9—16, schematic cross sections. Jn all the figures the
primary inner germ-lamella (ventral lamella, entoderm, vegetative germ-
lamella), including the parts derived therefrom, is indicated by the red colour ;
while, on the other hand, the primary outer germ-lamella (dermal lamella,
exoderm, animal germ-layer) is indicated by blue. The letters are through-
out the same.

. Primitive intestine (progaster); primitive intestinal tube.
. Ventral lateral hollow muscles.
. Colom (body-cavity or pleuro-peritoneal cavity).
. Intestinal glandular layer (mykogastral layer).
. Dermal layer (exoderm); outer primary germ-lamella; intestinal
layer.
Fibro-intestinal layer (inogastral layer).
. Neuro-dermal layer.
Gastral layer (entoderma); inner primary germ-lamella, dermal
layer.
: Gérinial glands (appendages to the sexual glands).
. Skin (corium).
. Fibro-dermal layer (inodermal layer).
. Primitive brain (medullary canal).
. Primitive mouth (prostoma) ; primitive oral opening.
. Dorsal lateral hollow muscles.
. Dorsal intestinal vessels (aorta).
. Primitive kidneys (excretions-canal).
. Chorda dorsalis or vertebral column.
. Ventral intestinal vessel (heart).

Figs. 1—8 represent schematic longitudinal sections of gastrula from
eight diverse animal forms, 7. e.—
Fig. 1.—Gastrula of Sponges (Olynthus).
by ke lie » Corals (Actinia).
1 sles » Acclomi (Turbellaria).

SAS SQ

SDS

RHEKKSOCRSNS

Fig. 4. ,, » Lunicata (Ascidia).
Nee ts Vis » Mollusca (Limneus).
Pig. Gs » Asterida (Uraster).

ie. Vy » Crustacea (Vauplius).
a: ee » Vertebrata (dmphioxus).

Figs. 9—16 represent schematic cross-sections through representatives of
eight different types, 7. e.—

Fig. 9.—Through a simple Sponge (Olynthus) or a simple Hydro-
medusa (Hydra). The wal) of the primitive intestine re-
mains (as in Gastrula) for life only by the two primary germ-
lamelle.

DESCRIPTION OF PLATE VII—continued.

Fig. 10.—Through a simple Acalepha (Hydroid). Between the gastral
layer (¢) and the neuro-dermal layer (4) lies the fibro-dermal
layer.

Fig. 11.—Through an Accelomatous embryo (Turbellaria). The section
goes right through the primitive brain or cesophageal
ganglion (z). Between the neuro-dermal layers (4) and the
intestinal glandular layers (d) are visible, moreover, the two
fibrous lamelle which lie compactly on one another—the
outer the fibro-dermal layer (m), and the inner the fibro-
intestinal layer (/).

Fig. 12.—Through an Ascidian larva, from the base of the tail, so as to
put in the lowest end of the chorda (#) between the medullary
canal (z) and the intestinal tube (¢). Between the fibro-
dermal layer (m) and the fibro-intestinal layer (7) the ceelom
is visible.

Fig. 13.—Through an Amphiorus larva (compare Kowalevsky’s ‘ De-
velopment of Amphiozrus,’ plate ui, fig. 20). The fibro-
intestinal layer (/) is still entirely separated from the
fibro-dermal layer (m); the entire body becomes barely
formed from the four secondary germ-lamelle. }

Fig. 14.—Through an older Amphiorus larva. The medullary canal (7)
has become completely unravelled out of the horny layer (4).
The fibro-dermal layer (m) is blended together with the fibro-
intestinal layer (/) in the dorsal middle line (mesenteric
line), and is differentiated into the skin (7) and hollow
muscles (7). Between the intestinal tube and the unravelled-
out medullary canal () is seen the commencement of the
chorda ().

Fig. 15.—Through a worm-embryo (cephalic segment of an Annelid).
Between the dorsal (7) and ventral (4) longitudinal muscles
are interposed the primitive kidneys (segmental organs, ~)
from the outer dermal layer throughout the body-cavity (c).
On the upper side of the primitive intestine (@) is the dorsal
longitudinal vessel (4), below the same the ventral longi-
tudinal vessel appears (z), both enclosed in the fibro-intestinal
layer (/).

Fig. 16.—Through a vertebrate embryo (central section of a fish)
Between the dorsal (7) and ventral! (4) hollow lateral muscles
is interposed the first appearance of the primitive kidney
system (z) from the skin throughout the body-cavity. On the
upper surface of the primitive intestine (a) 1s the primordial
aorta (¢), below the same the outline of the heart (or the
bulbus arteriosus, z) is to be seen, both enclosed in the fibro-
intestinal layer(f/). The only real difference between the
typical transverse section of the vertebrate body and that of
the worm-body (fig. 15) is that in the former, between the
medullary tube () and the primitive intestine (a), the chorda
(z) makes its appearance.

Jena ; 29th September, 1873.

\
J,
s
|
»
2

SS ee ee

—s

\
KasevesrerttteT CREEY CTE TSE V ERT TNT TTT
\
NE

Tm
HVTAUvtunaeatsz
ee

ANAM A
tie

TT ELT
PLL
TT

i

nn
anny

A anne
er stl

cg pM, =
Dy) rn nvnTMMOAEC ECU CLApRADDDDDDDDDDDDDD EU enitteecz-=

Fig. XII.

400 Diameters.

¥ié IX.

Oo

NM
aT

These are all magnified

an

* y y *
r
7 ~h
. . x
5
- , “.
‘ i
le , a ‘
,
* \ i
b
- ‘
‘
: ’
. ” ,
7 P
, \
\ ‘
7 I
/
‘
’ .
1 ‘
1
\ ‘ .
Pee ; : : 3
; : 3) ‘
er ike ‘ i
ed
Se
ae
— t
i | rs c .

JOURNAL OF MICROSCOPICAL SCIENCE.

DESCRIPTION OF PLATE VIII,

To illustrate the Rev. O’Meara’s paper on Diatomaceze

| Fie.
. Navicula arctica, Cleve.

OoW oO oP w DO

es
tio H oO

from Spitzbergen.

. Grammatophora arctica, Cleve; 6, side view.
. Amphora lanceolata, Cleve.

. Navicula pinnularia, Cleve.

. Synedra Kamscatica, Grun.; 4, side view.
. Asterionella Cleviana, n. s., O’Meara.

. Amphora Eatoniana, un. s., O’Meara.

. Amphora Leighsmithiana, un. s., O’Meara.

. Navicula Archeriana, un. s., O’Meara.

. Navicula nebulosa, var.

. Synedra arctica, nu. s., O’ Meara.

. Navicula Auklandica, Grun. ?

JOURNAL OF MICROSCOPICAL SCIENCE.

DESCRIPTION OF PLATE IX,

Illustrating Mr. G. Busk’s paper on Clavopora Hystricis—a
New Polyzoon belonging to the Family Halcyonellee.

Fig 1. Magnified view of the entire growth. (a) One of the zoocecia.
», 2. A portion of the stem, showing the peculiar fibres.

» 3. A portion of the capitulum, magnified to the same degree, showing
one of the zooccia containing a polypide.

SEO oe OF

:
:

,

QUMWNS. PLL

Lt

M& Farlane & Erskine Lith’ Kdin™ —

a

E11

\__a

Ses
mae

ME Fatlane & Erskine, Lith? Edin j

Mor. burr Ve MNSGa Te

t

/
]
|
' \
' Y
}
\
' { af
os oe. 1 Se,
AWW

\

Whe.

WN m

B77)

JOURNAL OF MICROSCOPICAL SCIENCE.

DESCRIPTION OF PLATES X & XI.

Illustrating Dr. Farlow’s paper on an Asexual Growth from
the Prothallus of Pteris cretica.

Fics.
1— 3.—Different forms of the prothallus of Péeris cretica, with antheridia

and root hairs on their lower portions.

a. Scalariform duct.
b. First leaf.

r. Root.

s. Stem bud.:

4.—Vertical section of prothallus somewhat less advanced than in fig. 3 ;
the letters indicate the same structures as before.

5.—Prothallus producing two leaves side by side; a, scalariform ducts,
6, leaf from upper, 4’, leaf from under side.

6.—Longitudinal section of prothallus in fig. 1, in the direction of the
arrows.

7.—Longitudinal section parallel to y in fig. 6, and more highly mag-
nified.

z. Two of the archegonium-like group of four cells, which are
seen to have no immediate relation with the subjacent scala-

riform ducts.

DESCRIPTION OF PLATES X & XI.—continued.

8.—Transverse section of the prothallus in fig. 4 at the pointz; this is
ficured in the plate with the under side of the prothallus uppermost.

9.—Longitudinal section of prothallus in fig. 2 in the direction of the
arrows.

10.—Longitudinal section of a prothallus p p, similar to fig. 4, made
through the place of origin by budding of a young plant ; the other
letters as in figs. 1—3.

11.—More magnified view of a portion of the prothallus in fig. 5.

Me

Y/,

VENUS.

-

Mbwcr.

<

M‘ Farlane & Erskine, Lith® Ediné

JOURNAL OF MICROSCOPICAL SCIENCE.

EXPLANATION OF PLATE XII,

Illustrating Mr. Ray Lankester’s papers on “A new
type of Infusoria,’ and on “The Heart of Appen-

dicularia furcata.”

Fics.
1—3.—Torquatella typica; three specimens. c. Capitular prominence or

upper lip over-hanging the mouth.
4.—The same, a side view of another specimen, as seen swimming.
5.—The same; another specimen seen from above.
6.—Heart of young Appendicularia furcata.
7.—Heart of a full-grown specimen. s. Secondary corpuscles.

8.—One heart-cell, with out-growing fibrille ; from another specimen.
s. Secondary corpuscles.

leltoltorofte 0 \c
seu

Z >
FS)
{es
2

iY

7 M<Faclane & Exekine Lith? Edin?
Rte A

y
ro
fv
%
A
4
fal
cal
s
a
oe
=

’

SS

it

JOURNAL OF MICROSCOPICAL SCIENCE.

EXPLANATION OF PLATES XIII, XIV & XV,

Illustrating Mr. F. M. Balfour’s Paper on the development
of the Elasmobranch Fishes (Dog-fishes).

Complete List of Reference Letters.

. Peculiar nuclei formed in the yolk.

. Similar nuclei in the cells of the blastoderm.

. Formative cell probably derived from the yolk.

. Network of lines present in the food-yolk.

. Yolk spherules.

. Line of separation between the blastoderm and the yolk.
. Epiblast.

. Epidermis.

. Lower layer cells.

. Mesoblast.

. Hypoblast.

. Segmentation cavity.

. Embryonic swelling.

. Embryonic rim.

. Line indicating the edge of the blastoderm.

. Medullary groove.

. Medullary canal.

. Caudal lobes.

. Cells which help to close in the alimentary canal, and which

are derived from the yolk.

. Vertebral plates.

h. Head.

. Alimentary canal.

. Notochord.

. Thickening of hypoblast to form the notochord.
. Pleuro-peritoneal cavity.

. Remains of pleuro-peritoneal cavity in the head.
. Protovertebre.

. Stalk connecting embryo with yolk-sac.

. Ist, 2nd, and 3rd &c. visceral clefts.

. Hye.

. Olfactory pit.

. Auditory vesicle.

. Fifth nerve.

. Seventh nerve.

. Glosso-pharyngeal nerve.

. Vagus nerve.

. Spinal nerve.

. Somatopleure.

. Splanchnopleure.

. Peculiar body underlying the notochord derived from the

hypoblast.

. Dorsal aorta,

EXPLANATION OF PLATES XIII, XIV & XIV—Continued.

List of Reference Letters—continued.

ca v. Cardinal vein.
m p. Muscle-plate.
m p'. Early formed mass of muscles.
ov. Oviduct.
p ov. Projection which becomes the ovary.
wd. Wolffian duct.
pwd. Primary points of involution from the pleuro-peritoneal
cavity by the coalescence of which the Wolffian duct is
formed.
su.r. Supra renal body.
pz. Pineal gland.
At. Heart.
v. Blood-vessel.

All the figures were drawn with the Camera Lucida.

Fie. 1.—Section parallel with the long axis of the embryo through a
blastoderm, in which the floor of the segmentation cavity (sc) is not yet
completely lined by cells. The roof of the segmentation cavity is broken.
(Magnified 60 diam.) The section is intended chiefly to illustrate the dis-
tribution of nuclei (z) in the yolk under the blastoderm. One of the chief
points to be noticed in their distribution is the fact that they form almost
a complete layer under the floor of the segmentation cavity. This probably
indicates that the cells whose nuclei they become take some share in
forming the layer of cells which subsequently (vide fig. 4) forms the floor of
the cavity.

Fie. 2.—Small portion of blastoderm and subjacent yolk of an embryo at
i time of the first appearance of the medullary groove. (Magnified 300

iam.)

The specimen is taken from a portion of the blastoderm which will form
part of the embryo. It shows two large nuclei of the yolk (~) and the net-
work in the yolk between them; this network is seen to be closer around
the nuclei than in the intervening space. The specimen further shows that
there are no areas representing cells around the nuclei.

Fie. 3.—Section parallel with the long axis of the embryo through a
blastoderm, in which the floor of the segmentation cavity is not yet covered
by a complete layer of cells. (Magnified 60 diam.)

It illustrates (1) the characters of the epiblast, (2) the embryonic swell-
ing (e s), (3) the segmentation cavity (sc). It should have been drawn
upon the same scale as fig. 4; the line above it represents its true length
upon this scale.

Fic. 4.—Longitudinal section through a blastoderm at the time of the
first appearance of the embryonic rim, and before the formation of the me-
dullary groove. (Magnified 45 diam.)

It illustrates (1) the embryonic rim, (2) the continuity of epiblast and
hypoblast at edge of this, (3) the continual differentiation of the lower
layer cells, to form, on the one hand, the hypoblast, which is continuous with
the epiblast, and on the other the mesoblast, between this and the epiblast;
(4) the segmentation cavity, whose floor of cells is now completed.

N.B.—The cells at the embryonic end of the blastoderm have been made
rather too large.

Fic. 5.—Surface view of the blastoderm shortly after the appearance
4 ec medullary groove, To show the relation of the embryo to the
astoderm,

EXPLANATION OF PLATES XIII, X1V & XV—Continued.

Fie. 6 a and 4.—Two transverse sections of the same embryo, shortly
after the appearance of the medullary groove. (Magnified 96 diam.)

a. In the region of the groove. It shows (1) the two masses of mesoblast
on each side, and the deficiency of the mesoblast underneath the medullar
groove ; (2) the commencement of the closing in of the alimentary ean
below, chiefly from cells (~ a) derived from the yolk.

4. Section in the region of the head where the medullary groove is de-
ficient, other points as above.

Fic. 7 a and 4.—Two transverse sections of an embryo about the age or
rather younger than that represented in fig. 5. (Magnified 96 diam.)

a. Section nearer the tail; it shows the thickening of the hypoblast to
form the notochord (ch’).

In & the thickening has become completely separated from the hypoblast
as the notochord. In a the epiblast and hypoblast are continuous at
the edge of the section, owing to the section passing through the embryonic
rim.

Fic. 8—Surface view of a spatula-shaped embryo. The figure shows (1)
the flattened head (4) where the medullary groove is deficient, (2) the caudal
lobes, with a groove between them; it also shows that at this point, the
medullary groove has become roofed over and converted into a canal.

Fie. 8 a.—Transverse section of fig. 8, passing through the line a. (Mag-
nified 90 diam.) The section shows (1) the absence of the medullary groove
in the head and the medullary folds turning down at this time instead of
upwards; (2) the presence of the pleuro-peritoneal eavity in the head (p p’) ;
(3) the completely closed alimentary canal (a 7).

Fic. 8 .—Transverse section of fig. 8, through the line 4. (Magnified
90 diam.) It shows (1) the neural canal completely formed; (2) the vertebral
plates of mesoblast not yet split up into somatopleure and sphanchnopleure.

Fic. 9.—Side view of an embryo of the Torpedo, seen as a transparent
object a little older than the embryo represented in fig. 8. (Magnified 20
diam.) The internal anatomy has hardly altered, with the exception of the
medullary folds having closed over above the head and the whole embryo
having become more folded off from the germ.

The two caudal lobes, and the very marked groove between them, are
seen at ¢s. The front end of the notochord became indistinct, and I
could not see its exact termination. The epithelium of the alimentary
canal (a/) is seen closely underlying the notochord and becoming continuous
with the epiblast at the hind end of the notochord.

The first visceral cleft (I » c) and eye (op) are just commencing to be
formed, and the cranial flexure has just appeared.

Fie. 10.—Section through the dorsal region of an embryo somewhat
older than the one represented in fig. 9. (Magnified 96 diam.)

It shows (1) the formation by a pinching off from the top of the alimen-
tary canal of a peculiar body which underlies the notochord (7); (2) the
primitive extension of the pleuro-peritoneal cavity up to the top of the
vertebral plates.

Fre. 11 a, 4, and c.—Three sections closely following each other from an
embryo in which three visceral clefts are present; a is the most anterior
of the three. (Magnified 96 diam.) In all of these the muscle-plates are shown
at mp. They have become separated from the lateral plates in 4 and ¢, but
are still continuous with them in a, The early formed mass of muscles
is also shown in all the figures (m p'). ;

The figures further show (1) the formation of the spinal nerves (sp) as

EXPLANATION OF PLATES XIII, XIV & XV—Continued.

small bodies of cells closely applied to the upper and outer edge of the
neural canal.

(2) The commencing formation of the cells which form the axial
skeleton from the inner (splanchnopleuric) layer of the muscle-plate. Sec-
tions 4 and ¢ are given more especially to show the mode of formation of
the oviduct (ov).

In @ it is seen as a solid knob (ov), arising from the point where the
somatopleure and splanchnopleure unite, and in ¢ (the section behind 0)
of a solid rod (ov) closely applied to the epiblast, which has grown back-
wards from the knob seen in 8.

N.B.—In all three sections only one side is completed.

Fic. 12 a and 4.—Two transverse sections of an embryo just before the
appearance of the external gills. (Magnified 96 diam.)

in a there is seen to be an involution on each side (p w d@), while 4
is a section from the space between two involutions from the pleuro-peri-
toneal cavity, so that the Wolffian duct (at first solid) (# d@) is not connected
as in @ with the pleuro-peritoneal cavity. The further points shown in the
sections are—

(1) The commencing formation of the spiral valve (a /).

(2) The suprarenal ae (su r).

(3) The oviduct (ov), which has acquired a lumen.

(4) The increase in length of the muscle-plates, the spinal nerves, &c.

Fic. 13.—Section through the dorsal region of an embryo in which the
external gills are of considerable length. (Magnified 40 diam.) The chief
points to be noticed :

(1) The formation of the Wolffian body by outgrowths from the Wolffian
duct (wd).

(2) One of still continuing connections (primitive invoiutions) between
the Wolffian duct and the pleuro-peritoneal cavity (p w @).

(3) The oviduct largely increased in size (ov).

N.B.—On the left side the oviduct has been accidentally made too small.

(4) The growth downwards of the muscle-plate to form the muscles of
the abdomen.

(5) The formation of an outgrowth on each side of the mesentery (p ov),
which will become the ovary.

(6) The spiral valve (a 7).

Fic. 14.—Transparent view of the head of an embryo shortly before the
appearance of the external gills. (Magnified 20 diam.) The chief points
to be noticed are—

(1) The relation of the cranial nerves to the visceral clefts and the manner
in which the glosso-pharyngeal (g /) and vagus (v g) are united.

(2) The remnants of the pleuro-peritoneal cavity in the head (p p’).

(3) The eye (op). The stalk, as well as the bulb of the eye, are sup-
posed to be in focus, so that the whole eye has a somewhat peculiar
appearance.

le = aa -
eee

Pomc arene ia wes ssesteetssse etree rinaersieees haan re ee ee

AW

Wc,
M¢ Farlane & Erskine,

7

Mer burn

E.Ray Lankester, delt

JOURNAL OF MICROSCOPICAL SCIENCE.

EXPLANATION OF PLATE XVI,

Illustrating Mr. Ray Lankester’s Memoir on the Develop-
ment of the Pond-snail.

Fic. 1.—An egg after the formation of the first cleavage groove. Two
Richtungsblaschen (#.) are seen. Nat. size of the egg = ;1, inch.

Fic. 2.—An egg after division into four cleavage-masses, three of which
are seen, and the Richtungsblaschen(&.). Nat. size =4, inch (long measure-
ment).

Fic. 3.—The same quadripartite egg seen from below.

Fic. 4.—An egg of a later stage in which smaller cleavage-spheres have
made their appearance at one pole. A Richtungsblaschen (#.) is seen
attached between the four larger cleavage-spheres.

Fic. 5.—The same egg seen from above.
Fic. 6.—The same egg seen from below.

' Fie. 7.—A later stage. At the pole g m the gastrula-invagination is now
commencing. At £& the Richtungsblaschen, entangled in the discarded
vitelline (?) membrane, is seen.

Fics. 8—12.—Various views of the Gastrula of Zymueus. Natural
size = 54, inch. The appearance varies according to the position which
is assumed. Fig. 9 gives a surface view as seen by reflected. light. Fig.
10. The same specimen seen by transmitted light. Fig. 11. Another speci-
men, two thirds profile view; gm is the gastrula-mouth or orifice of invagi-
nation.

Fic. 13.—The early phase of the Trochosphere with large lateral lobes (the
figure is turned sideways). m. Commencing formation of the permanent
mouth. Long measurement of this specimen ;4, inch.

Fic. 14.—Trochosphere with ciliated annular ridge and commencing
mouth, m. The large cells of the Gastrula-endoderm are seen to be in
connection with the body wall by means of delicate processes. Longest
measurement of this specimen = ;4, inch.

Fig. 15.—a, 4, c, d. Successive outlines presented by such a trochosphere
as that in the preceding figure during rotation in the antero-posterior direc-
tion. The small prominence seen in 4, and also in fig. 13, in a similar posi-
tion, is probably the first indication of the foot.

JOURNAL OF MICROSCOPICAL SCIENCE.

EXPLANATION OF PLATE XVII,

Illustrating Mr. Ray Lankester’s Memoir on the Develop-
ment of the Pond-snail.

Fic. 1.—An embryo between the Trochosphere and Veliger phases—
somewhat compressed; longest diameter about ;1, inch. m. Mouth.
v. Velum. /. Foot. g e. Gastrula-endoderm, now assuming a bilobed
character—the sac enclosed by it having therefore a double cavity, a right
and a left. g. Point of closure of the gastrula-mouth. yp @. Pedicle of in-
vagination—the future rectum. sp. The shell-patch—a thickened area of

- the body wall, on the surface of which the shell first forms, and by invagi-

nation of which the shell-gland is produced.

Fic. 2.—-Young Veliger, surface view, showing—m. Mouth. ~y. Velum.
7. Foot. Longest diameter about >%, inch.

Fie. 3.—A similar specimen from the oral aspect.

Fic. 4.—A similar specimen somewhat compressed and seen in incom-
plete optical section. m. Mouth. fL Foot. pi. Pedicle of invagination.
s h. Shell overlying the depression of the shell-gland, which is now visible.

Fie. 5.—Surface view of a more advanced Veliger, longest diameter
about 5 of an inch. /. The foot, showing bilobation. o. Velum now
forming a heart-shaped area, with m, the mouth, at its base. ¢. The eye-
tentacles.

Fic. 6.—Surface view of a more advanced embryo, in a position fre-
quently assumed at this period of development. Length of the specimen,
about 7; inch. fy. A doubtful structure, lying between the two lobes
of the foot, possibly a foot-pore. Other letters as above.

Fic. 7—A much more advanced embryo, about 2, of an inch long.
J. Foot. fp. Foot-pore. ». Velum now assuming the character of “ sub-
tentacular lobes.” 7. Tentacles. 7. Lung-chamber. m / Mantle-flap,
or free border of the mantle. sf. Shell.

Fie. 8.—An embryo, a little older than that of fig.5. Length about
so Of an inch, compressed, treated with osmic acid, and seen in partial
optical section. m. Mouth. ph. Pharynx. ods. Odontophore-sac. /. Foot.
p t. Pedicle of invagination (rectum) with cecal termination. m/f. Mantle-

E. Ray Lankester, delt “Vf Farlane & Erskine, Litht® Edin?

EXPLANATION OF PLATE XVII.—continued.

flap. mz. Muscular-cells passing from body wall to centrally placed gas-
trula-endoderm, sf. Shell-rising up as a watch-glass. 2 g. Nerve-ganglion.
¢. Tentacle. v. Velum.

Fic. 9.—a, 4, c. d—Four conditions of cells of the gastrula-endoderm
from embryos a little younger than that of Fig. 8.

Fig. 10.—A similar embryo to that of fig. 7. Letters as before.

Fic. 11.—A small embryo (about 2; inch long) from a mass containing
embryos similar to those of figs. 7 and 10. It is irregularly developed and
has the shell-gland occupied by a bright highly-refracting plug, 7s. f Foot.
ph. Pharynx. v. Velum. m/f. Mantle-flap. sf. Shell. is. Plug of the
shell-gland. p 7. Pedicle of invagination (rectum).

Fie. 12.—Shell-gland with plug 7s, and external shell es, of the same
embryo.

Fig. 13.—Shell-gland of another embryo and circular shell-area covered
by the disc-like shell.

Fie. 14,—Shell-gland and widely open mouth of the same from another
embryo.

Fic. 15.—Optical section of the central portion of the shell-secreting area
at a laterstage (viz. that of fig. 8), showing the last vestige of the shell-
gland as a small depression.

_ Fic. 16.—Optical section of shell-secreting area of an embryo, similar to
that of fig. 17, showing the superficial columnar and deeper fusiform cells,
and the delicate shell, sf.

Fic. 17.—An embryo younger than that, of fig. 5, considerably younger
than that of fig. 8, compressed and treated with osmic acid. Long diameter,
as thus seen, about 3, inch. f Foot. pA. Pharynx. v. Velum. xg.
Nerve-ganglion. ¢ge. Tunic of fusiform cells covering in the gastrula.
endoderm. sf. Shell. ss. Shell gland. pz. Pedicle of invagination.
gs. Right-hand cavity of the bilobed gastrula-stomach. Observe the
fusiform cells passing from the body-wall to be connected with this.

Fie. 18.—An embryo of nearly the same age and size as that of fig. 10,
treated with osmic acid. ». Velum.. f. Bilobed foot. p/. Pharynx.
ng. Nerve-ganglion. /. Heart. m/f. Mantle flap. x. Kidney formed as
an in-pushing from the reflected flap of the mantle. m. Muscular fibres
attached to the bend of the intestine. 7. Intestine. g. Problematical mass
of cells lying close to the kidney. /. Lung-chamber. cr. Cecal termina-
tion of the intestine. +r m. Retractor (?) muscle.

Fic. 19.—Cells of the body-wall and gastrula-endoderm connected by
processes of the latter, from an embryo of the same age as that of fig. 4.

Fic. 20.—Recurved and cecal termination of the rectum developed from

EXPLANATION OF PLATE XVII.—continued.

the pedicle of invagination, from an embryo a little older than that of
fig. 17.

Fie. 21.—Alimentary canal of an embryo about the age of that of fig. 8.
ph. Pharynx. a. Csophagus not yet open to pharynx. sf. Stomach; its
structure concealed and obscured by the adjacent gastrula-endoderm cell-
masses. 7. Intestine. c. Its cecaltermination. ge. Two of the gastrula-

endoderm cells, now assuming the character of pellucid globules with super- -

ficial granular nétworks. m. Branched muscular cell passing from the
body-wall to the latter. The intestine is seen to have a superficial tunic of
fusiform cells, and to be connected by such cells to the body-wall.

Fic. 22.—Body-wall and some of the modified gastrula-endoderm cells,
from a stage between those of fig. 17 and fig. 8. ep. Epiblast. ¢ge. Tunic
of fusiform cells covering the pellucid bodies and their granular networks.

Fie. 23.—Anterior part of the alimentary canal and body-wall, of same
age as fig. 21. ep. Epiblast. m¢. Muscular tunic. m. Muscles. uy.
nerve-ganglion.

CUES ree aE SRR NTN Nh wath ng

oi ree ptt ob oy aa
vee senett ‘ Shia :
t
Mpc

.
t
.
‘
.