Skip to main content

Full text of "The rapid pack method of packing fruit"

See other formats


i^K 


Division       of      Agricultural       Sciences 


UNIVERSITY  OF  CALIFORNIA 


*''^*Q 


The  RAPID  PACK 

METHOD  of 

PACKING  FRUIT 


ROY  J.  SMITH 


CALIFORNIA  AGRICULTURAL 
Experiment  Station 
Extension    Service 


MKMXKXKXX 

CIRCULAR  521 


THE  SIDE  PACK  OPERATION  requires  packers  to  turn  sideways  and  stoop  to  pick  up  the  fruit — 

contributes  to  excessive  fatigue. 

This  circular  describes  a  new  and  fast  method  of  packing  citrus 
fruit — a  method  which  could  very  probably  be  applied  to  other  fruits 
and  to  some  vegetables. 

Many  of  the  operations  and  much  of  the  machinery  described  here 
have  been  tried  out  and  proved  workable;  some  of  the  suggestions 
made  are  just  that — suggestions  for  further  refinement  of  machinery 
and  techniques. 

The  subjects  discussed  are  as  follows: 

Special  Requirements  for  Rapid  Pack 5 

Carton  Forming  for  the  Rapid  Pack 9 

Seating  the  Packers 12 

Training  the  Packers 14 

Rapid  Pack  Bagging 16 


THE  AUTHOR: 

Roy  J.  Smith  is  Professor  of  Agricultural  Economics,  Department  of  Horti- 
cultural Science;  Agricultural  Economist  in  the  Agricultural  Experiment  Station 
and  Citrus  Research  Center:  Agricultural  Economist  on  the  Giannini  Founda- 
tion, Riverside. 

The  drawings  used  in  this  circular  were  made  or  developed  by  Charles  C.  Papp. 
Scientific  Illustrator  in  the  Agricultural  Experiment  Station  and  Citrus  Research 
("enter.  Riverside. 


APRIL,  1963 


THE  RAPID  PACK  METHOD  has  the  packers  working  face-on;  eliminates  much  of  the  turning  and 
twisting — is  conducive  to  greater  speed. 


THE  RAPID  PACK  METHOD  .  . 

how  it  works 

The  photos  above  show  the  two  basic 
methods  of  packing  oranges  now  being 
used  by  packing  houses.  In  the  older,  side 
pack  method,  the  packer  is  obliged  to 
lean  twisted  over  the  bin  side  as  she 
reaches   for    fruit.    In    the    newer,    rapid 


pack  method,  the  packer  simply  reaches 
forward  across  the  rollboard,  picks  up 
the  fruit  and  places  it  in  the  carton. 

The  rapid  pack  method  is  aimed  at 
eliminating  body  bending  and  twisting, 
maintaining  an  erect  posture,  developing 


[3 


f 


short,  easy  motions  that  will  save  time, 
and  cut  down  on  the  strain  and  fatigue 
present  under  the  side  pack  method. 

The  rapid  pack  method  (or  what  pur- 
ports to  be  the  rapid  pack  method)  has 
been  observed  in  nine  packing  houses  in 
California,  two  in  Florida,  and  one  in 
Australia.  Other  houses  are  converting 
to  the  system. 

Packing  rates 

Table  1  presents  some  of  the  data  ob- 
tained in  several  packing  houses.  Rates 
of  pack  range  from  26.1  cartons  per  hour 
to  32.6  for  the  side  pack  and  from  30.4 
to  46.7  for  the  rapid  pack.  In  all  opera- 
tions the  rates  have  been  adjusted  from 
the  actual  average  rates  to  an  estimated 
one  based  on  an  average  fruit  size  at  113 
fruit  per  carton.  The  reduction  in  cost 
from  rapid  pack  in  House  A,  as  compared 
with  the  side  pack  in  other  houses,  ap- 
proximates 2%  cents  per  carton.  As  com- 
pared with  the  other  rapid  pack  houses, 
the  reduction  in  cost  in  House  A  approxi- 
mates 1%  cents. 

The  packers  reported  on  in  table  2 
had  all  had  at  least  10  years  of  experience 
with  the  side  pack  prior  to  1956  and  had 


been  using  the  rapid  pack  method  since 
that  time.  The  increases  in  rate  of  pack 
range  from  28  per  cent  to  51  per  cent 
and  are  for  the  entire  season  of  work — 
nearly  six  months'  packing  each.  Every 
regular  experienced  packer  in  the  house 
is  included. 

Some  instalations  have  not  resulted  in 
any  significant  change  in  rate  of  pack. 
In  one  house  (not  recorded  in  the  tables) 
there  had  been  no  increase  in  rate  of  pack. 
In  still  another  house  (not  recorded)  the 
packers  would  not  use  the  rapid  pack 
position  but  returned  to  the  side  pack  and 
worked  at  about  the  same  rate  as  from 
earlier  bins.  (See  pages  6-7.) 

Worker  fatigue  and  strain 

Strain  is  a  very  complex  subject — it 
can  result  from  many  different  actions 
such  as  twisting  and  stretching.  Because 
of  the  more  or  less  straight-line  action 
required  in  the  rapid  pack  system,  twist- 
ing and  stretching  have  largely  been 
eliminated. 

While  fatigue  cannot  be  eliminated 
entirely,  the  possibility  of  excessive  tired- 
ness in  rapid  pack  houses  has  been 
watched  for  on  numerous  occasions  and 
the  conclusion  is  that  there  is  no  undue 


Table  1. 

Comparison  of  rates  of  pack  and  cost  per  carton 

Packing  house 

Variety 

Year 

Rate  of  pack 

Person 
forming 
carton 

Cost  of 

Side  pack 

Rapid  pack 

packing 

Val 

Val 

Val 

Val 

Nav 

Val 

Nav 

Val 

Val 

Val 

1956 
1959 
1960 
1960 
1960 
1960 
1960 
1960 
1960 
1960 

Cartons  per  hour 

packer 
packer 
packer 
former 
former 
packer 
packer 
packer 
packer 
packer 

Cents  per 
carton 

A 

A 

A 

52.6 

46.7 
46.5 
33.3 
32.9 
31.6 
30.6 
30.4 

4.60 
3.21 
3.23 

B 

B 

4.50 
4.56 

C 

4.75 

C 

4.90 

D ...  . 

4.93 

E 

27.6 
26-1 

5.43 

F 

5.75 

These  are  seasonal  average  rates  of  pack  in  cartons  per  hour,  per  person  in  crew,  including  packers,  special 
formers,  and  time  of  others  distributing  flats.  Rate  of  pack  has  been  adjusted  to  size  of  113  fruit  per  carton.  Costs 
of  packing  show  seasonal  average  rates  of  pack  per  person  in  crew  to  return  $1.50  per  hour  to  each  crew  member. 


[4] 


Table  2.  How  rapid  pack  system  increased  rate  of  pack  in  House  A 


Rate  of  pack  in  cartons  per  hour 

Per  cent  increase  over  1956 

Packer  No. 

Side  pack 
1956 

Rapid  pack 

1959 

I960 

1959 

I960 

1 

43 

62 

65 

44 

51 

2 

36 

46 

28 

3 

38 

49 

51 

29 

34 

4 

35 

47 

50 

34 

43 

These  were  the  experienced  packers  of  House  A.  The  figures  are  for  their  seasonal  rates  of  pack  in  cartons 
per  hour,  adjusted  to  113  count  size. 


fatigue.  Packers  themselves  state  that 
they  are  not  so  tired  at  the  end  of  the  day 
as  they  were  using  the  side  pack  method. 
This  lessening  of  fatigue  is  due  to  the 
natural,  simple,  short,  hand,  wrist,  and 
arm  movements  made  in  the  rapid  pack 
system.  No  body  motions  are  required, 
but  if  used,  they  are  very  simple.  In  fact, 
no  significant  physical  effort  is  required 
other  than  that  associated  with  speed. 
Under  an  incentive  wage  system  the  mat- 
ter of  speed  is  up  to  the  packers'  choosing 


between  the  extra  effort  required  and  the 
extra  earnings  to  be  obtained.  If  freedom 
is  assured  the  packer  to  set  the  pace, 
there  would  appear  to  be  no  serious  rea- 
son for  concern  as  to  fatigue. 

Packers  occasionally  race  each  other, 
but  proper  management  can  usually  pre- 
vent this.  If  packers  think  they  will  soon 
run  out  of  fruit,  they  tend  to  overexert 
themselves  while  fruit  is  available.  Thus 
fruit  supply  for  all  packers  is  an  ex- 
tremely important  factor. 


SPECIAL  REQUIREMENTS 

for  the  rapid  pack  method 

Storage  at  packstands 

At  best  there  is  variation  in  the  supply 
of  fruit  by  sizes  to  the  packstands  but 
this  variation  can  be  materially  modified 
if  there  is  storage  in  bins  at  the  pack- 
stands.  Such  storage  has  been  standard 
for  the  side  pack  operations.  However,  if 
the  old  standard  sizers  with  their  bins 
are  properly  rebuilt  for  rapid  pack,  the 
storage  space  can  be  increased.  Part  of 
the  increase  can  come  from  the  rollboard 
and  baffle  systems,  the  designs  for  which 
are  extremely  exacting. 

When  converting  standard  sizer  and 
bin  units  into  a  rollboard  system  for 
rapid  pack  operation,  design  the  ma- 
chinery to: 


•  Deliver  to  the  rollboard  edge  a  row 
or  layer  of  fruit  to  be  easily  picked  up. 

•  Allow  individual  fruits  to  roll 
through  an  empty  bin  to  the  rollboard 
edge,  but  never  allow  them  to  gain 
enough  momentum  to  roll  over  the  edge. 

•  Provide  for  as  much  storage  space 
as  possible. 

The  key  to  such  storage  is  a  baffle 
system  which  will  hold  back  a  pile  of 
fruit  and  automatically  allow  a  single 
layer  of  fruit  to  roll  out.  The  drawing  on 
page  6  shows  such  a  baffle  system. 

Maintaining  correct  posture 

Good  posture  for  the  packers  is  essen- 
tial to  the  success  of  the  rapid  pack  sys- 


[5] 


Baffle  system  for  a  rapid  pack  rollboard. 
Slope  in  floor  is  314  inches  to  a  foot.  The 
longer  baffle  slows  individual  fruits  and  pre- 
vents them  from  gaining  a  speed  that  will 
carry  them  over  the  edge.  The  two  baffles  to- 
gether hold  back  the  pile  and  allow  only  one 
layer  to  reach  the  rollboard  edge.  Wing  nut 
allows  adjustment.  Drop  in  rollboard  floor  pre- 
vents fruit  from  wedging  against  the  baffles. 


Posture  and  positioning  of  rollboard,  carton, 
and  fruit  for  rapid  pack  method.  Rollboard 
edge  and  carton  top  are  just  41  inches  above 
the  floor. 


tern.  The  system  encourages  good  posture 
which,  in  turn,  enables  the  packer  to 
work  faster  without  strain. 

The  rapid  pack  method  is  designed  to 
keep  the  packers  standing  erect.  Some  tall 
packers  may  have  to  stoop  a  little  to  fill 
the  bottom  layer  of  a  carton.  In  some  in- 
stallations it  was  noted  that  the  cartons 
were  placed  much  too  low,  causing  the 
packers  to  stoop  and  resulting  in  strain. 
To  avoid  such  conditions  arrange  the 
cartons  so  that: 

•  The  packers'  elbows  will  just  swing- 
clear  of  the  carton  edge  when  packer 
stands  naturally. 

•  No  stoop  is  required  except  a  mo- 
mentary one  for  very  tall  packers  when 
filling  the  bottom  row. 


•  The  far  edge  of  the  carton  and  top 
front  edge  of  the  rollboard  are  together 
and  at  the  same  level. 

•  The  rollboard  edge  is  low  enough  so 
that  the  packers'  forearms  need  not  work 
at  a  slope  greater  than  15°. 

These  requirements  leave  little  margin 
for  variation.  The  rollboard  edge  must 
be  about  41"  above  the  floor  and  the  near 
edge  of  the  carton  about  38".  (See 
drawing  above.) 

Wrist  alignment  for  packers  is  ex- 
tremely important.  When  rollboard  edges 
are  too  high  packers  must  stretch  their 
arms,  wrists,  and  hands  to  reach  the 
fruit  and  this  results  in  a  condition  illus- 
trated on  page  7. 

In  one  packing  house  studied  the  roll- 
boards  were  too  high  and  the  rate  of 
pack  was  no  faster  than  that  for  the  side 
pack  method.  In  fact  the  packers  found 
it  so  diffieult  to  reach  the  fruit  they  turned 
their  boxes  and  resumed  the  position 
used  in  the  side  pack. 


6] 


s^ 


Packstand   is  too  low.  Stooping  causes  serious 
strain  and  fatigue. 


High  rollboard  edge  makes  it  difficult  for 
packers  to  pick  up  fruit. 


Sketch  of  wrist  bones  showing  (top)  normal  position  of  the  wrist,  and  (bottom)  area  where  strain 
occurs  when  reaching  over  high  fruit  stop  on  the  rollboard  edge. 

[7] 


Removing  packed  cartons 

The  above  picture  of  a  rapid  pack 
installation  shows  the  most  common 
equipment  for  removing  packed  cartons. 
Smoothed  waxed  boards  are  installed  at 
intervals  reaching  from  the  packstand 
to  a  conveyor  belt  running  behind  the 
packers.  A  space  is  provided  in  each 
board  for  workers  to  pass.  The  packer 
can  push  her  packed  carton  easilv  around 
back  to  the  conveyor. 

Careful  design  as  to  level  is  required 
so  bottom  flap  edges  will  not  catch.  The 
conveyor  belt  should,  if  possible,  be  below 
the  level  of  the  packstand.  Care  must  be 
taken  also  as  to  the  number  of  such 
boards  and  the  spacing  between  them;  a 
packer  should  always  have  one  at  hand, 
on  one  side  or  the  other,  yet  no  more 
should  be  installed  than  are  needed. 

A  second  method  of  removing  packed 
cartons  is  to  install  a  conveyor  belt  below 
the  rollboard,  back  of  the  packstand.  The 
photo  (right)  shows  such  an  installation. 
The  complication  with  the  system  is 
placing  the  packstand  so  that  it  will  be  at 
just  the  right  height  for  packing  and  yet 
allow  space  to  move  the  packed  carton 
back  under  the  rollboard  to  the  conveyor. 


Proper  packstand  positioning  requires 
that  the  edge  of  the  carton  next  to  the  roll- 
board  be  at  the  same  level  as  the  rollboard 
top  edge.  In  such  an  arrangement  the  roll- 
board  edge  prevents  the  carton  from  be- 
ing pushed  back  onto  the  conveyor. 

Consequently  a  mechanism  must  be 
provided  for  moving  the  carton.  A  trip 
mechanism  might  drop  the  packstand  a 
few  inches,  thus  allowing  the  carton  to 
be  pushed  back.  Such  a  trip  mechanism 
appears  simple  but  none  has  yet  been 
seen. 


Spacing  of  packers  and 
supply  of  fruit 

It  is  recommended  that  a  minimum  of 
3  feet  per  packer  be  allowed  along  the 
I  packstand.  Materially  lower  rates  of  pack 
have  been  observed  where  there  was 
crowding  among  packers  but  there  is  no 
reason  to  think  that  crowding  had  any 
bearing  on  the  differences  listed  in 
table  1. 

Where  the  supply  of  fruit  fluctuates 
materially,  crowding  of  packers  around 
the  peak  sizes  can  limit  the  efficiency  ob- 
tainable. A  better  distribution  of  fruit 
along  the  rollboard  and  among  the  pack- 
ers would  eliminate  this  problem. 

There  is  no  particular  problem  as  to 
p  sizes,  however — the  problem  is  within  a 
given  size  of  fruit.  If  there  is  only  enough 
fruit  to  keep  one  packer  busy  it  should  be 
sent  to  one  position  only  (as  is  now  usu- 
ally done) .  The  flow  should  be  narrow 
enough  so  that  the  packer  will  not  have 
to  reach  too  far  to  one  side. 

Where  there  is  enough  fruit  in  a  size 
for  two  or  more  packers,  the  fruit  should 
be  distributed  in  such  a  way  that  each 
packer  has  enough  room  and  that  only 


one  end  packer  has  the  partial  supply. 
(This  assumes  a  "pack-around"  system 
with  each  packstand  position  being  taken 
in  rotation  to  equalize  the  opportunity  for 
maintaining  rate  of  pack.) 

It  will  be  noticed  in  table  1  that  House 
A  packed  fruit  in  1956,  under  the  old 
side  pack,  materially  faster  than  the  other 
houses  using  the  side  pack.  This  differ- 
ence was  almost  entirely  due  to  the  con- 
stancy with  which  fruit  was  kept  in  front 
of  the  packers.  It  is  normal  to  find  pack- 
ers in  these  other  houses  idle  part  of  the 
time  because  of  the  fruit  supply  in  the 
bins  being  low.  This  lack  of  fruit  rarely 
happens  at  House  A.  The  reasons  for  this 
difference  are  largely  matters  of  manage- 
ment policy  and  apparently  subject  to 
control.  The  relationships  involved  are 
very  complex,  however,  and  will  not  be 
discussed  here. 

It  should  also  be  noted  that  House  A 
has  continued  these  policies  as  to  supply 
of  fruit  with  the  Rapid  Pack  and  they 
constitute  one  reason  for  the  very  high 
rate  of  pack  that  now  obtains.  In  fact  the 
policies  are  relatively  more  important 
under  Rapid  Pack  than  they  are  under 
the  old  pack. 


FORMING  AND  HANDLING  CARTONS 


for  the  rapid  pack  method 

While  both  House  A  and  House  B 
-  (table  1)  used  the  rapid  pack  system  of 
packing,  the  packers  in  House  A  formed 
their  own  cartons;  those  in  House  B  had 
the  cartons  delivered  to  them  already 
formed  by  someone  else. 

Both  work-sampling  and  motion  pic- 
ture studies  were  made  of  these  tasks  in 
House  A.  A  standard  work  time  of  19 
seconds  was  established  for  forming  and 
handling.  (In  the  studies  the  average 
time  came  out  to  18.6  seconds  but  when 
some  inexperienced  people  were  included 
in  the  tests  and  some  crowding  occurred, 
the  time  went  to  19.6  seconds.)  A  break- 
down of  the  time  required  for  the  differ- 
ent tasks  is  shown  in  table  3. 


The  average  packer  takes  7.8  seconds 
to  form  her  carton.  This  time  includes 
reaching  for  the  flats.  She  takes  a  total 
of  11.2  seconds  to  do  the  handling  tasks. 
The  rates  of  the  very  fast  packer  (table 
3)  indicate  what  perfection  in  motions 
will  enable  a  worker  to  do.  It  may  be 
noted  that  at  another  packing  house 
(House  D)  packers  appeared  to  have  a 
more  consistently  good  procedure  in 
forming  their  cartons  than  those  in 
House  A.  They  were  judged  to  be  faster, 
although  timing  was  not  attempted. 

An  additional  cost  in  time  must  be  in- 
cluded for  the  distribution  of  flats  in 
houses  like  House  A.  Since  flats  come  in 
bunches,  usually  of  20.  constant  attention 


[9] 


Table  3.  Time  required  for  carton 
forming  and  handling 


Task 

Average 
packer 

One  very 
fast  packer 

Seconds 

Carton  forming 

7.8 

2.2 

9.0 

19.0 

6.4 

Fitting  to  packstand, 
placing  treated  paper 

After-packing  tasks 
(stamping,  etc.) 

2.2 

7.7 

TOTAL 

16.3 

This  table  shows  the  total  time  required  for  carton 
forming  and  handling  between  the  packing  of  two  suc- 
cessive cartons.  The  overall  time  accuracy  for  the  aver- 
age packer  rests  on  a  work  sampling  coverage  of  a  total 
of  2,551  cartons  being  packed  under  normal  conditions. 
The  breakdown  in  time  and  the  rates  for  the  very  fast 
packer  are  based  on  motion  picture  studies.  The  study 
of  the  very  fast  packer  did  not  include  the  addition  of 
treated  paper;  time  shown  for  her  is  assumed  to  be  the 
same  as  for  average  packer. 


is  not  required.  The  responsibility  is  usu- 
ally assigned  to  one  man,  who,  however, 
always  has  other  responsibilities.  Other 
people  often  gave  the  matter  some  atten- 
tion. An  exact  study  was  not  possible,  but 
in  House  A  with  2.000  cartons  packed 
daily,  it  was  estimated  that  a  total  of  two 
hours  was  required.  This  calculates  out 
to  3.6  seconds  per  carton.  Adding  this 
time  to  the  standard  time  of  19  seconds 
for  forming  and  handling  by  the  packer 
gives  a  total  carton  forming  and  handling 
time  of  22.6  seconds.  The  figure,  3.6  sec- 
onds, is  included  in  the  total  time  re- 
quirement per  carton  (table  1)  for 
houses  where  packers  form  their  own 
cartons. 

Time  required  by  "formers"  in  House 
B  was  established  from  the  incentive 
wage  records.  Over  a  full  season  the 
time  per  carton  averaged  13.8  seconds. 
Phis  time  was  for  forming  cartons,  some- 
times the  inserting  of  treated  paper,  and 
pushing  the  cartons  down  the  chute. 

The  men  who  formed  cartons  in  House 
B  were  capable  of  considerable  speed. 
They  averaged  10.1  seconds  per  carton 
for  one   11 -hour  week.   10.6  seconds   for 


one  34-hour  week,  and  10.8  seconds  for 
one  39.5-hour  week.  Even  then,  however, 
their  time  never  equalled  that  of  average 
packers  at  House  A,  which  was  7.8  sec- 
onds per  carton.  The  forming  at  House  B 
was  in  the  chute;  pushing  it  could  take 
only  a  moment,  even  though  it  required 
some  strength.  When  treated  paper  was 
added,  it  also  required  but  a  moment. 

The  synchronization  of  formers  with 
the  needs  of  packers  is  very  difficult. 
Much  of  the  time  the  formers  could  not 
be  kept  busy.  The  number  of  cartons  re- 
quired per  week  varied  from  2,169  to 
13,154.  During  one  week  the  rate  of 
forming  dropped  to  20.2  seconds  per  car- 
ton, simply  because  the  packing  was 
slow. 

At  any  given  time,  synchronization  of 
forming  and  packing  is  difficult.  A  solid 
line  of  packers  can  empty  a  full  chute 
of  formed  cartons  in  about  two  minutes. 
The  former  must  maintain  an  exceptional 
zeal  if  a  full  supply  of  formed  cartons  is 
to  be  maintained  for  all  packers. 

Enough  formers  must  be  on  hand  to 
take  care  of  peak  packing  demands  and 
the  incentive  rate  per  carton  must  be 
high  enough  to  attract  formers  during 
times  of  low  demand.  Thus  costs  cannot 
be  kept  as  low  as  when  forming  is  a 
minor  task  of  the  total  packing  job. 

A  further  difficulty  with  forming  car- 
tons beforehand  is  that  when  formed 
cartons  are  squeezed  tightly  in  the  chute 
they  are  often  difficult  to  get  out.  In 
many  instances  the  bottom  flaps  come 
loose  and  more  time  is  taken  to  fold  them 
in  again  than  was  needed  to  put  them  in 
originally. 

A  further  generalization  but  a  very 
pertinent  one  is  that  the  interval  between 
the  packing  of  two  cartons,  when  used  to 
form  a  new  carton,  constitutes  a  com- 
plete change  in  motion  for  the  packer 
and,  as  such,  provides  a  moment  of  re- 
laxation. This  interval  of  change  is  quite 
in  contrast  to  the  task  of  the  specialized 
former  who  does  one  simple  task  over 
and  over. 


I  KM 


Supply  of  carton  flats.  Where  the 
cartons  are  formed  by  the  packers,  ob- 
servations have  shown  that  efficiency  can 
be  gained  in  supplying  flats  by: 

•  Keeping  the  level  of  the  feed  line  as 
low  as  possible  to  prevent  the  strain  of 
reaching.  (This  may  require  lowering 
the  level  of  the  packed  carton  conveyor, 
then  lowering  the  feed  line  to  a  point 
where  it  just  clears  the  top  flaps  of  the 
cartons  on  the  conveyor.) 

•  Setting  bunches  of  flats  on  the  feed 
lines  in  such  a  way  that  they  can  be 
pulled  out  and  formed  without  having 
to  be  turned  around.  I  sually  this  is  done 
by  having  the  flaps  pointed  toward  the 
packers. 


•  Keeping  a  watchful  eye  on  the  feed 
lines  to  make  sure  they  are  fully  sup- 
plied at  all  times. 

Forming  motions.  Certain  specific 
procedures  can  be  suggested  for  efficient 
forming  of  cartons  by  packers. 

•  The  packstand,  the  point  where  the 
packed  cartons  are  disposed  of,  the  sup- 
ply of  carton  flats,  and  the  place  for  form- 
ing should  be  close  together. 

•  There  must  be  a  fixed,  solid  place 
for  forming  the  carton. 

•  The  two  carton  halves  can  be  fitted 
together  best  by  fitting  the  bottom  half 
into  flaps  of  top — or  by  fitting  flaps  of 
top  half  over  the  bottom  half. 


BACK       BOARD 


Packer  in  third  sequence  grasps  ends  of  bottom  flaps,  squares  them  up  and  forms  the 

half — all  in  one  motion. 


[in 


Any  of  the  following  sequences  may  be 
used  by  packers  working  standing  up, 
and  able  to  turn  around  easily: 

1.  Pull  out  the  bottom  half  by  the  ends 
of  the  end  flaps;  square  the  carton; 
place  carton  butt-end  down  on  the 
solid  surface;  fold  (push  down)  in 
the  end  flaps  (already  being  held 
in  hands)  ;  fold  in  side  flaps,  all  in 
one  smooth  motion.  Pull  out  top 
half;  square  it;  fit  its  flaps  down 
over  the  bottom  half  in  a  second 
single  smooth  motion.  The  whole  is 
then  turned  over,  pushed  together, 
and  fitted  to  the  packstand.  Or, 

2.  Pull  out  the  top  half  by  its  end  flaps; 
square  it  and  set  it  in  the  packstand. 
Pull  out  bottom  half  by  end  flaps; 
square  it;  set  it  down  on  a  solid 
place  and  push  in  flaps.  Slide  hands 
to  corner  of  the  formed  half,  turn 
it  over  and  set  it  down  between  flaps 
of  top  half;  push  it  to  the  bottom 
and  fit  whole  to  packstand.  Or, 

3.  A  third  sequence  is  proposed  and 
may  be  used  if  a  space  of  about  22 
inches  in  height  can  be  provided 
above  the  bundle  of  bottom  halves 
so  that  these  halves  can  be  formed 
right  there.  The  packer  then  squares 
up  the  bottom  half  (see  drawing) 
by  grasping  ends  of  end  flaps  and 
twisting  with  hands.  As  half  is 
squared,  end  flaps  can  be  pushed  in 
almost  in  the  same  motion;  push  in 
side  flaps  and  slide  hands  to  corner 
of  the  formed  half  and  grasp  it. 
Turn  with  formed  half  and  set  it 
down  into  flaps  of  top  half  (as  in 
2nd  sequence). 


To  use  third  sequence,  bottom  halves  must 
be  at  right  height  so  packer  can  use  weight  to 
push  in  flaps. 


This  3rd  sequence  differs  from  the  2nd 
in  that  height  of  feed  chute  for  bottom 
halves  must  be  close  to  36  inches,  other- 
wise packer  cannot  use  her  weight  when 
pushing  flaps;  there  must  be  a  back- 
board against  which  packer  pushes  to 
form  flaps.  But  no  other  "place"'  is 
needed  for  forming  bottom  halves,  and 
the  packer  saves  time  of  setting  down  the 
bottom  halves  to  form  them,  and  then 
picking  them  up  again. 


SEATING  THE  PACKERS 

requires  adjustments  in  equipment 


The  possibility  of  seating  packers  has 
been  tested  several  times  and  the  idea 
has  both  advantages  and  disadvantages. 
The  packers  found  they  could  work  just 
as  fast  seated  as  when  standing  and,  of 


course  preferred  to  work  seated  as  it  was 
less  tiresome.  It  is  common  to  find 
graders  who  had  to  give  up  packing  be- 
cause of  the  strain  of  standing:  all  dav 


so 


t  is  possible  that  if  seating  can  be 


[12 


Diagrammatic  outline  of  seating  for  rapid 
pack.  Note  level  of  foot  rest  relative  to  the 
floor. 


made  practical  for  packing,  older  ex- 
perienced packers  can  be  kept  on  the  job 
over  a  longer  period  of  years.  Such  pack- 
ers can  do  much  to  keep  down  costs. 

On  the  other  hand,  seating  packers 
would  require  additional  investment  in 
equipment  and  will  decrease  the  ease  with 
which  packers  can  move  about. 

Changes  in  equipment.  Use  of  seats 
requires  that  rollboards  and  cartons  be 
at  exactly  the  right  height  and  that  the 
cartons  be  sloped  as  shown  in  the  draw- 
ing. 

The  seat  is  actually  only  a  partial  seat 
with  just  enough  space  for  the  buttocks 
to  catch  hold.  The  packers'  legs  must 
extend  straight  down  at  the  same  slope 
as  the  carton  side  and  right  against  the 
carton.  To  keep  the  packers  from  slip- 
ping off  the  seats,  a  foot  rest  must  be 
placed  at  exactly  the  right  height  for 
each  packer  and  must  hold  the  feet  firmly 
in  place. 

The  seat  cushion  must  be  resilient  but 
not  slippery — a  cushion  which  will  allow 


Experimental  test  of  rapid  pack  with  packers 
seated.  Note  plywood  to  hold  carton  on  the 
packstand. 

the  packer  to  settle  in  1  inch  is  advisable. 
An  adjustable  back  rest  similar  to  those 
used  on  "Secretary"  chairs  must  be  pro- 
vided and  should  normally  be  from  4  to 
6  inches  back  from  the  front  edge  of  the 
seat. 

Rollboard  and  cartons  must  be  at  the 
height  specified  for  standing  so  that  pack- 
ers can  stand  at  intervals  for  relaxation 
and  still  continue  to  pack. 

Foot  rests  should  be  movable  so  that 

This  shows  how  carton  and  legs  are  sloped  at 
same  angle  when  packers  are  seated. 


the  packers  can  use  them  while  seated 
but  push  them  out  of  the  way  when 
standing.  Also,  taller  and  shorter  packers 
might  have  to  take  their  foot  rests  with 
them  when  moving  to  different  stations 
in  the  pack-around  system  because  all  of 
the  seats  would  be  at  a  standard  height. 
Forming  cartons  while  seated  pre- 
sents some  problems.  Delivery  of  the  flats 
involves  using  two  conveyors — one  for 
tops  and  another  for  bottoms — or  alter- 
nating bundles  of  tops  and  bottoms  on 
one  conveyor.  The  latter  system  would 
require  less  room  but  would  demand 
very    close    attention    from    the    person 


keeping  the  feed  lines  supplied.  The  flats 
must  be  arranged  so  they  reach  the  pack- 
et "s  with  the  butts  of  the  bottom  halves 
and  the  top  flaps  of  the  top  halves  facing 
out. 

A  suggested  sequence  for  forming  car- 
tons while  seated  is:  Pull  out  bottom 
flaps:  turn  butt  of  carton  down  and  drop 
onto  packstand;  square  carton;  push 
flaps  down  and  in. 

Pull  out  top  half  by  flaps;  square  up 
carton;  turn  flaps  down  and  fit  over  bot- 
tom half.  Turn  whole  carton  over;  fold 
top  and  side  flaps  back  as  carton  is  fitted 
into  packstand. 


TRAINING  THE  PACKERS 

will  pay  off  in  efficiency 

There  is  considerable  difference  in  the 
rate  of  pack  among  packers  and  undoubt- 
edly some  of  this  difference  is  in  the 
temperament  and  native  ability  of  the 
individuals.  But  there  are  also  differences 
that  are  due  to  faulty  ways  of  doing 
things- — ways  that  can  be  changed  or 
never  allowed  to  develop  if  packers  are 
correctly  trained  in  their  work. 

This  is  especially  true  if  the  training 
can  be  given  to  new  packers — it  will  be 
difficult  to  break  bad  habits  of  long 
standing  in  experienced  packers. 


might    be    de- 


While  some  traini 
sirable  in  the  tasks  of  forming  cartons, 
stamping,  use  of  treated  paper,  and  re- 
cording the  pack,  most  of  these  routine 
procedures  will  be  learned  quickly  by  the 
packers  from  watching  those  alongside. 

The  various  pack  patterns  take  a  few 
days  to  learn,  but  two  weeks'  experience 
seems  to  be  sufficient  to  make  these  al- 
most automatic. 

Picking  up  fruit  is  one  of  the  diffi- 
culties of  inexperienced  packers.  Train- 
ing might  help  here. 


t 


thumb 


fingers 


B 


t 


weight  balance 


fruit 


thumb 


fingers 


Contrast  in  methods  of  picking  up  fruit;  A — with  all  fingers  above  middle  of  fruit, 
and  B — with  fingers  below. 


[14] 


Some  packers  have  the  ability  to  pick 
up  two  fruits  in  one  hand  and  this  gives 
them  an  advantage  in  speed  over  others. 
Practice  can  be  important  in  learning  to 
pick  up  two  easily. 

A  flat,  tight  layer  of  fruit  can  be  diffi- 
cult to  pick  up;  the  fingers  do  not  easily 
reach  under  the  fruit  and  occasionally 
fingers  have  become  sore  from  pushing 
between  the  fruits. 

The  drawing  on  page  14  shows  two 
commonly  used  methods  of  picking  up 
fruit — the  pressure  grasp  (A)  and  the 
full  hook  grasp.  In  the  pressure  grasp  all 
fingers  and  the  thumb  are  above  the 
largest  circumference  of  the  fruit  and 
pressure  must  be  exerted  to  prevent  the 
fruit  from  slipping  out  of  the  hand.  In 
the  full  hook  grasp  fingers  and  thumb 
are  on  the  lower  part  of  the  fruit  and  no 
pressure  is  required  to  hold  it.  Obviously, 
the  full  hook  method  is  less  tiring.  Two 
measures  can  be  suggested  to  help.  The 
rollboard  recommended  (see  drawings 
below )  has  a  "riser"  at  the  edge  and  the 
floor    of    the    rollboard    is    flattened    for 


about  four  inches  to  reduce  the  pressure 
on  the  first  row  of  fruit  behind.  This  fea- 
ture, together  with  the  low  fruit  stop,  or 
rollboard  edge,  makes  it  possible  to  pick 
up  the  first  row  of  fruit  quite  easily.  The 
second  measure  is  to  have  beginners 
watch  experienced  packers  and  see  how 
they  fit  their  fingers  around  the  fruits. 
It  is  not  simply  a  matter  of  pushing  but 
of  watching  for  spaces  between  fruit  and 
of  fitting  fingers  into  these  spaces.  Alert- 
ness in  eye  and  practice  in  finding  these 
spaces  can  help  a  great  deal. 

Arm  motions.  Observations  have 
shown  that  usually  one  of  four  different 
arm  motions  is  used;  two  hands  in  uni- 
son, one  hand  alone,  hands  alternating, 
or  an  arm  sweep.  Using  two  hands  in 
unison  is  undoubtedly  the  fastest  method, 
but  a  variation  in  arm  methods  is  recom- 
mended to  reduce  fatigue. 

The  use  of  one  hand  alone  should  be 
avoided  except  when  it  is  necessary  to 
use  the  other  hand  to  hold  fruit  in  posi- 
tion to  build  a  pattern  in  the  carton.  The 
alternating  motion  is  very  fast  at  times, 


Left — how  packer  should  get  her  fingers 
between  fruits  in  a  solid  layer.  Above,  leaning 
over  the  fruit  is  an  unnecessary  exertion  and 
can  be  avoided. 


[15] 


Standing  on  one  leg  is  awkward  and  leads 
to  fatigue.  Tall  women  should  wear  flat  heels 
and  short  women  should  wear  elevator  shoes. 


but  usually  results  in  only  one  fruit  be- 
ing picked  up  at  a  time  whereas  using 
two  hands  in  unison  seems  to  make  it 
more  practical  to  pick  up  two  fruits  in 
each  hand. 

In  the  arm  sweep  method  the  packer 
simply  leans  over  and  encircles  a  dozen 
or  so  fruit  with  her  arm,  then  sweeps 
them  over  the  edge  into  the  box.  While 
fast,  this  method  tempts  the  packer  not  to 
arrange  the  fruit  in  the  desired  pattern 
and  may  also  lead  to  damaged  fruit. 
Some  packing  houses  prohibit  the  prac- 
tice. Its  proper  use  seems  to  depend  on 
supervision  by  management  and  a  sense 
of  responsibility  by  the  packers. 

Posture.  A  prime  purpose  of  the 
rapid  pack  system  is  to  enable  the  pack- 
ers to  stand  or  sit  erect  while  working, 
and  thus  reduce  strain  and  fatigue.  Draw- 
ings on  pages  15  and  16  show  two  bad 
habits  followed  by  packers.  While  bad 
posture  habits  may  be  extremely  difficult 
to  break  in  the  more  experienced  packers, 
management  (and  workers)  would  both 
benefit  greatly  by  training  new  packers 
in  good  posture. 


RAPID  PACK  BAGGING 

has  worked  well  in  trials 

Mechanical  equipment  for  bagging 
has  long  been  available  and  considered 
satisfactory  for  large-scale  operations 
working  over  long  periods  of  time,  but 
where  the  use  of  bags  is  intermittent  or 
on  a  small  scale,  the  operation  has  usu- 
ally been  performed  by  hand.  Doing  the 
job  by  hand  has  been  slow  and  inefficient. 

The  following  are  suggestions  for  ma- 
chinery and  procedures  that  could  be 
adapted  to  the  rapid  pack  rollboard 
equipment  for  small-scale  bagging  of 
many  kinds  of  fruit  when  desired.  The 
recommendations  made  are  based  on 
trials  with  experimental  machinery,  none 
of  which  is  currently  available  commer- 
cially. 


Rapid  pack  bagging  equipment  may 
be  used  in  conjunction  with  a  rapid  pack 
rollboard.  The  fruit  on  the  rollboard  is 
at  a  convenient  height  for  efficient  opera- 
tion and  can  be  rolled  down  through  a 
slot,  directly  into  the  bag.  The  equipment 
needed  is  not  expensive,  but  its  design  is 
quite  specific.  (See  drawing  page  17.) 

The  drawings  on  page  18  show  the  se- 
quence of  motions  for  bagging  fruit.  The 
packers  can  maintain  a  comfortable  pos- 
ture and  stretching  is  reduced  to  a  mini- 
mum. 

The  empty  bags  are  laid  in  bundles 
on  the  machine  board.  A  new  bag  is 
always  at  fingertips,  ready  to  be  opened 
and  fitted  over  the  bag  mouth  holder.  It 
need  only  be  moved  about  3  inches. 


[16] 


Plan  view  of  bagging  equipment.  A — rollboard  of  rapid  pack  equipment;  B — rollboard  edge 
with  opening  at  F;  C — packstand;  D — bag  holding  machine;  E — bag  ready  to  be  fitted  over  gate; 
F — gate  or  bag  mouth  holder;  G — sealing  equipment;  H — bagged  fruit  in  container.  The  bag 
holding  machine  was  designed  and  built  by  Haruo  Najima,  former  Assistant  Specialist  in  the 
Agricultural  Experiment  Station,  Los  Angeles. 


Drawing   of  side  view  of  bag   holding   machine.   Note  the 
bundle  of  new  bags  lying  underneath  the  bag  being  filled. 


[17] 


CLOSES  BAG  AT 
CLOSING   UNIT 


t 


Sequence  of  motion  activities  in  bagging  fruit. 


[18] 


The  bag  mouth  holder  and  the  gate 
are  the  same  device.  When  the  gate  is 
opened  the  fruit  can  roll  through  into  the 
bag;  when  closed,  the  same  device  pre- 
vents fruit  from  rolling  through. 

The  bag  filling  machine  (as  shown  in 
the  drawing  on  page  17)  would  be  sup- 
ported at  one  end  by  the  rollboard  and 
at  the  other  by  legs.  The  length  of  the 
legs  should  be  adjustable  so  the  slope  of 
the  filling  machine  can  be  changed — the 
tighter  the  fill  wanted,  the  steeper  the 
slope  should  be.  Some  testing  of  tightness 
of  fill  (and  hence  slope)  will  be  required 
to  determine  just  what  management 
wants,  but  it  should  be  kept  in  mind  that 
the  bag  of  fruit  is  given  a  final  settling 
as  it  is  taken  off  the  mouth  holder  and 
lifted  for  closing. 

As  the  bag  is  being  filled  its  bottom 
end  rests  against  a  cleat  set  crossways. 
The  cleat  prevents  the  fruit  from  pulling 
the  bag  off  its  holder  when  the  fruit  hits 
the  bottom  of  the  bag. 

The  bag  mouth  holder  shown  in  the 
photo  has  a  thin  plywood  board  for  its 
lower  side  and  a  wire  frame  for  its  top 
and  movable  side,  but  a  plastic  material 
molded  into  a  rounded  form  would  be 
better  for  both  sides.  The  inside  surfaces 
should  be  smooth  and  nonabrasive;  the 
outside  surfaces  should  not  be  slippery 
but  should  hold  the  bag  securely.  A 
clamp  to  aid  in  holding  the  bag  might  be 
built  into  the  lower  side  and  should  be 
actuated  with  the  opening  and  closing  of 
the  gate. 

When  a  bag  is  full  and  the  gate  is 
closed,  the  gate  may  come  to  rest  on  top 
of  fruit  which  was  held  back  by  that  in 
the  bag.  Thus  care  must  be  exercised  in 
design  of  the  gate  so  that  there  will  be 
no  chance  of  damage  to  the  fruit.  Also, 
the  mouth  of  the  gate  must  be  flexible 
enough  so  that  a  single  fruit  will  not  hold 
the  mouth  open  and  let  other  fruit  roll 
by. 

Fruit  being  counted  into  bag  of  prototype 
machine. 


Prototype  bagging  machine  with  bag  being 
fitted  over  bag  mouth  holder. 


Bag  closing 

If  a  simple  band  or  tie  is  used  to  close 
the  bags,  the  bagging  machine  described 
offers  an  ideal  position  for  holding  the 
bag  as  it  is  closed.  As  the  bag  is  released 
from  the  mouth  holder,  the  bag  top  can 
be  drawn  together  and  fastened.  The  ties 
or  clasps  could  be  held  in  a  small  box 
near  the  closing  mechanism. 

If  heat-sealing  or  stapling  are  used, 
both  hands  would  lift  the  bag  from  the 
bag  mouth  holder,  into  the  sealing  mech- 
anism, then  lower  the  sealed  bag  into  the 
container. 


Design  and  manufacture 

As  stated,  the  equipment  proposed 
here  will  require  a  degree  of  exactness 
in  design.  A  different  size  bag  holder 
will  be  required  for  each  bag  size  and 
since  various  manufacturers  offer  bags 
in  different  dimensions  and  materials  it 
would  seem  desirable  that  each  build  his 
own  gate  and  bag  mouth  holder.  These 
could  be  sold  or  leased  as  an  adjunct  to 


the  sale  of  bags.  The  same  might  apply 
to  closing  units. 

Bagging  at  wholesale  or  retail 

Where  the  operation  is  of  sufficient 
size,  the  machinery  and  procedures  out- 
lined here  could  be  adapted  to  wholesale 
or  even  retail  locations  that  could  pro- 
vide a  rollboard  or  circulating  belt.  If 
fruit  is  shipped  in  bulk  bins,  the  bins 
could  be  emptied  directly  onto  the  roll- 
board. 


Co-operative  Extension  work  in  Agricullure  and  Home  Economics,  College  of  Agriculture,  University  of  California,  and  United  Stales  Department  of  Agriculture 
co-operating.  Distributed  in  furtherance  oi  the  Vets  of  Congress  of  Maj  8,  and  June  30,  1914.  George  B.  Vlcorn,  Director,  California  Agricultural  Extension  Service. 


10m-4,'(;:5(I>l  l.MiiWl'