liii
^[jSTnT^^S^^
.'\:
Zot
OtilSALSf
*\1^
mr
Church foetroff^^^^i^'^
Records ofthe^o "'^^- ^
e twentyj
RECORDS MoGmsoJV*
THE SEK/ATICEIS
CONNECTED WITH THE
1-Jfi1
.^tr
ttl
C".
ORGANIZATION
— OF THE —
S^ort Street f^resbyteriai) dljurcl)
DETROIT, MICH.
Compiled under Direction of the Session.
DETROIT,
O. S. GULLET'S 8TBAM PBINTINQ HOUSE 10 AND li LARNEID STREET.
1874.
S Clikptef of f^i^eliniii^krie^.
On the seventeenth day of December, 1873, the Elders and
Deacons, of the Fort Street Presbyterian Church of Detroit, con-
vened at the study of the pastor. Attention was called to the fact
that the church was organized upon the third Wednesday of Feb-
ruary, 1849, (February 21st,) and that, consequently, the third
Wednesday of February, 1874, (February i8th,) would be an
appropriate day to be observed as marking the completion of
the first Quarter-Century of its history.
It was, accordingly, resolved to hold, upon that day. Anniver-
sary Services. The pastor, the Rev. Arthur T. Pierson, was
requested to conduct the correspondence ; and with the aid of
George W. Hoffman, elder, and Douglas Payne, deacon, to act as
a general Committee of Arratigements. Edward C. Walker, elder,
was invited to act as Historian and Necrologist^ George W. Hoff-
man, to report upon the Financial and Benevolent Outlay of the
quarter-century, and Bradford Smith, deacon, upon the Sabbath
School and its Officers.
It was further determined to invite the Rev. James B. Shaw,
D. D., of Rochester, N. Y., to preach the Anniversary Sermon ;
and to set apart the evening of the Anniversary for the hearing of
brief addresses from brethren of other churches, and for a colla-
tion and social gathering.
The Choir, consisting of Henry Meakin, Esq., Organist, Prof
F. Abel, Mr. A. Mensell, Miss Mary C Brewster, Miss Frances L,
Chaffin, were constituted a Committee on Music, and the following
ladies, committees on decoration and collation :
TWENTY-FIFTH ANNIVERSAEY
Committee o?i Decoration .—Mrs. EDWARD C WALKER,
Miss Minnie Abbott, Mrs, R. A Alger, Mrs. G. F. Bagley, Miss Anna Eots-
ford, Mrs. Mary Buckley, Mrs. C. H. Buhl, Mrs. C. A. Cliamberlain, Mrs. J.
W. Dailey, Mrs. Anna M. Evans, Mrs. J. S- Jennings, Miss Lottie Ladue, Mrs.
E D. Lay, Mrs. M. F. Merrick, Miss Mary Orr, Mrs. G. H. Prentis, Mrs.
Chas. Root, Miss Mary E. Sherrill, Mrs. S. P. Wilcox, Miss Alice Woodruff.
Committee ofi Collation .—Mrs. FRANKLIN MOORE,
Mrs. F. Adams, Mrs. E. W. Bissell, Mrs. C. C. Blodgett, Mrs. F. Buhl, Mrs. C.
C. Cadman, Mrs. A. P. Cameron, Mrs. S. Davis, Mr.s. Geo. Foote, Mrs. R. W.
Gillett, Mrs. J- F). Hayes, Mrs. William Hull, Mrs. W. M. Johnson, Mrs. J. F.
Joy, Mrs. A. G. Lindsay, Mrs. J. W. Longyear, Miss Mary Penny, Mrs. Allan
Shelden, Mrs. Mary Thompson, Mrs. S. W. Thompson, Mrs. Samuel Zug.
Beside special invitations issued to the previous pastors and
stated supplies of the church, and to the families of such previous
ministers as are now deceased, the following circular letter was
printed and sent to those former members of the church now
living, whose present residences were known, and to various
clergymen and prominent laymen in the city, state, and country
at large :
FORT STREET PRESBYTERIAN CHURCH.
^,^ quarter of a Century having- passed since
the org-anization of iho Fort Street Presbyterian Oturch
of Detroit, Wednesday, the eighteenth day of February inst.,
will be observed as the
If it :l i 1,1 , #ft If i i t liU'l iiff aU (Pt M iU «
At eleven o'clock in the morning, a
will be preached hy the Rev. JAMES B. SHAW, D. D.,
of Rochester, N. Y.
At three o'clock in the afternoon, a paper,
will be read by the Hon. EDWARD C. WALKER, fol-
loTv^ed by reports, covering the financial and be-
nevolent outlay and christian ^vork of the last
tw^enty-flve years.
At hah'-past seven o'clock in the evening,
there wiU be a SOCIAL REUNION AND COLLATION,
"With brief addresses by various brethren, whose
names are linked "with the history of the church
of Christ in our city and "^acinity.
It is hoped, also, that the Rev. JOHN HALL, D. D.,
of Ne^w York City, will taivc part in these Memo-
rial Services.
We urge the presence of all friends, and espe-
cially all former members of the congreg-ation.
In behalf of the Church :
ARTHUR T. PIERSON, Pastor.
GEORGE W. HOFFMAN, Elder.
DOUGLAS PAYNE, Deacon.
TWENTY-FIFTH ANNIVERSAKT
Was one of rare beauty, with an atmosphere, at once balmy and
bracing; the glorious sunshine from a cloudless sky, beaming
upon our gathering, like the smile of God.
The interior of the church was elaborately and exquisitely
decorated with evergreens, and flowers in tropical profusion and
luxuriance. Upon the wall panels, to the left and right of the
pulpit, appeared the significant dates: " 1849 " and " 1874." The
communion table bore a bank of living, blooming plants, artisti-
cally arranged in the form of a quadrangular pyramid, which
almost hid the pulpit, whose balustrades were gracefully wreathed
and festooned in evergreens, and whose chief balusters supported
basket bouquets. The front of the choir gallery bore a silver
shield with a group of callas at its center, and bouquets at its
angles, while living vines of ivy wound about the carved openings
and standards.
A large portion of the floral decoration was in memory of the
dead. From the canopy above the pulpit, hung a colossal crown,
fit tribute to those godly ministers who have received their immor-
tal diadem, and whose names and memories are especially dear to
the Presbyterians of Detroit, viz : the Revs. John Monteith,
George Duffield, D. D., Robert R Kellogg and James
Means.
In the window, on the left of the pulpit, seven superb crimson
flowers represented the name Rowland, and a floral cross, on the
right, commemorated McFarren, both deceased elders. From
the opposing brackets supporting the roof-truss, were suspended
crosses of evergreen, expanding at the base into quadrangular
tablets, which bore, respectively, the names of Knight and Ray,
two other departed members of the session, who were also super-
intendents in the Sabbath School. A floral anchor, a widow's
tribute to her husband, Henry J. Buckley, and a broken column
rising Irom a mossy base, and bearing the initial " P," reared by
a sister to the memory of Selden Jones Phillips, completed the
memorial decorations.
PORT STREET PRESBYTERIAN CHURCH.
The following hymns, composed by the pastor, for the occa-
sion, were printed on slips and distributed in the pews :
h: ^ nvn :n- s
FOR THE
Twenty-Fiftli Anniversary.
Happy is that people whose God is Jehorah."
I.
Thou God of Love and Grace,
To Thee we bow !
O, let Thy radiant face
Beam on us now !
To every humble heart.
Thy life and love impart ;
Our hope and help Thou art.
And only Thou !
Years fly on fleetest wing :
Thine may we be !
Then shall they only bring
Us nearer Thee !
O, be our guard and guide,
Walk ever at our side.
Till with Thee we abide.
Thy face to see !
III.
To Thee we gladly give
Our every power ;
In serving Thee, to live
Till life's last hour.
Help us the cross to bear ;
Thy throne and bliss to share.
Then give the crown to wear,
Joy's perfect dower.
TWENTY -FIFTH AJSTNIVEESART
«* Hitherto Hath the Lord Helped Us."
I.
Hear, thou God of gifts and graces,
While our prayers and praise we bring.
Gathered in these hallowed places,
Grateful songs to Thee we sing.
Thou, with gentle hand, hast led us,
In the midst of foes and fears ;
And, with lavish bounty fed us.
Through these five and twenty years.
Thanks for ceaseless care and kindness,
Countless ministries of love ;
In our darkness and our blindness,
Light and guidance from above.
For the heirs of life immortal.
Saved by blood and sealed by grace,
And for those who, through the portal
Now have passed, and see Thy face.
III.
Spread Thine own pavillion near us,
Where our pilgrim tents delay ;
Let Thy Pillar guide and cheer us,
Through the yet untrodden way.
And when we, our journey ending.
Stand upon the golden shore ;
All our songs in chorus blending.
Will we bless Thee evermore.
FORT STREET PRESBYTERIAN CHURCH,
" Honsehold of God."
I.
Thou, to whom all praise belongs,
Hear Thy children's thankful songs ;
From Thy throne, where seraphs bow,
Pour Thy blessing on us now !
Bearing Jesus' hallowed name,
Breathing His inspiring aim,
Be our freedom and our joy
Found, like His, in Thine employ !
III.
Here may heralds speak Thy word,
And with docile hearts be heard ;
Many souls be saved by grace,
And prepared to see Thy face.
IV.
And when all Thy children meet.
Where the household is complete ;
May we join that countless throng.
Praising Thee in perfect song !
The building was well filled both morning and afternoon, and
crowded in the evening, with members of the Presbyterian
churches of the city, and christians of every name.
10 TWENTY-FIFTH ANNIVEESAKY
Opened at ir o'clock with a " Te Deum," by the choir. The six-
tieth chapter of the Prophecy of Isaiah was then impressively
read by the Rev. J. Ambrose Wight, of Bay City, and prayer
offered by the pastor, in grateful recognition of the goodness of
God, and with fervent entreaty for the continuance of His favor,
and for increased consecration upon the part of His people. The
first of the special hymns was sung, and the Anniversary Sermon
was preached, with great earnestness and power, by the Rev.
James B. Shaw, D. D., from Revelations VI. : 9, 10, 11. The
theme was " The Martyr Spirit ; tfs necessity in order to the
vitalitv and spirituality of the churchy It was heard with the most
absorbed attention and interest, as the venerable and beloved
preacher proceeded to speak especially of the martyr-saints of
Scotland, and the effect of their lives and deaths upon the church;
imparting to his discourse all the enthusiasm kindled by a recent
visit to that land. From the closing portion of this memorable
sermon, we are permitted to publish the following personal
address to the pastor and the church :
" We have been speaking of the martyr spirit as essential to
to the life and growth of the church :
" Dear brother, may I put your name on the illustrious roll of
martyrs ,? Pause a moment. The question may have a deeper
import than you suppose ; it may involve more than at first sight
you would be willing to believe. What if I should tell you, and
I do tell you, that a man is a christian, only so far as he is a mar-
tyr— only so far as he yields an implicit obedience — makes Christ
supreme ? You have sometimes asked, no doubt, " Could I die
as the martyrs did?" "Could I meet the lions, could I face the
flames.''" Brother, there are no lions to meet, no flames to face —
that day has gone ; and, as we devoutly hope, never to return.
But can you meet the temptations peculiar to the times in which
you live } Can you make the sacrifices which the Master is now
calling for : Can you part with your luxuries .' Can you forego
your comforts 1 Can you renounce your earthly aspirations 1 Can
you lay your pride in the dust .? Can you walk in the Master's
blessed footprints, no matter whither they may lead }
FORT STREET PRESBYTERIAN CHURCH. 1 1
" O, remember, do remember, that a man is a christian, only so
far as he is a martyr — only so far as he yields an implicit obe-
dience to Christ. C), remember, do remember, that the martyr
spirit, is the essential element of your spiritual life !
" My dear brother, the pastor of this people, this is an auspi-
cious hour for you — the twenty-fifth anniversary of your church,
the fifth anniversary of your pastorate, coming thus together, lend
a peculiar interest to the present occasion. Two suns have com-
bined their light and glory, to make this day. You know how I
love you. You know that you are the same as a son to me. You
know that I have a father's interest in you. You know that I
have scarcely any thing so much at heart, as that you should be a
star, and a star of the first magnitude, in the right hand of Him,
who standeth in the midst of the golden candlesticks. When I
think of your rare gifts, your high position, your growing influ-
ence, your golden opportunities, I thank God that you are not so
far along on the journey of life, as I am — I thank God that there
is not a furrow in your face, nor a gray hair on your head, nor the
slightest indication of declining strength — that your eye is not
dim, nor your natural force abated. I must number my days,
while you may number your years, and I thank God for it. Now,
it is because you are so dear to me, that I feel constrained to
remind you, that everything in your ministry, as well as every-
thing in your individual life, depends on your having the martyr
spirit. We are told that Calvin's seal contained a burning heart,
held by a steady hand — that, over the burning heart, were the
words : '''' I keep nothing for myself" and, under the burning heart)
the words : ^^ I give all to Thee!" Let that heart, all on fire, be
your emblem. Keep nothing for yourself — give all to Christ !
" My dearly beloved brother, it is my heart's desire and prayer,
that your ministry among this people, may be an exceptionally
long and successful one ; and that here it may end ! May your
last sermon be preached in this pulpit. Heed no call, but such
as took the prophet away — when the King sends the chariot, then,
of course, His servant must go.
"And what is so true of the christian, is just as true of the
church. A church can live and grow, only so long as the martyr
spirit is kept alive. As the glory departed from Rome, when the
last spark of that fire over which the vestal virgins watched, went
12 TWENTY-FIFTH ANNIVEESAET
out, SO the extinction of the martyr spirit in any church, is the
signal for God to go ; and when God goes, all sweet, and good,
and gracious, and gentle, and hallowed, and vital influences go
with Him. There is the holy and beautiful house which stood on
Mount Zion. Can you discover anything amiss ? Not a stone is
gone, not an ornament is missing — the altar, the victim, the priest,
the worshiper — they are all there. And there too is the Most
Holy Place, and the thick darkness, and the mercy-seat, and the
overshadowing cherubim, and the tables of the law, and the pot
of manna, and the rod that budded. Do you discover anything
amiss? Call, and see if any answer comes back, but the echo of
your own voice ! God has gone — the martyr spirit is extinct — and
that holiest of all, and the thick darkness, linger only to testify
against an ungrateful and degenerate people. So, beloved in the
Lord, these walls may stand, and, as often as the door opens,
crowds may flock to the place, and there may be every outward
indication of prosperity ; and other congregations may vainly
wish, that it were as well with them, as it is with you ; but if the
martyr spirit is extinct, if God has gone, what can this strong, and
rich, and intelligent, and influential church do, but die ! "
After the sermon and this most affecting address, prayer was
again offered by the pastor, who then proceeded to read, as his
own contribution to the anniversary,
V]:\e JVTenioi'ikl f^oerq.
BY REV. ARTHUR T. PIERSON:
Like birds that fly across the sky,
Tlie heralds of the spring,
Or noiseless sweep along the deep,
On swift and silent wing ;
With hopes and fears, with smiles and tears.
With sob, and song, and sigh,
With burdens borne and garlands worn.
The years go gliding by !
And so a score of years and more.
Their rapid course have run.
FORT STKEET PRESBYTERIAN CHURCH. 13
As planets trace their paths in space,
Swift cycling round the sun,
And move not back along their track,
Plowe'er our work is done !
Their solemn scroll, the years unroll —
What record there appears !
Success secured, with toil endured,
And triumph reached through tears !
The page here shines as though the lines
Were writ by rays of liglit ;
And there the mark of shadows dark
Suggests the gloom of night.
The changing hues, the varied views
Which autumn scenes present,
Or Western skies, when daylight dies.
Beneath his gilded tent,
Portray the strange and wondrous change
'Mid which our life is spent.
We look along the lines of light.
Which memory illumes.
And trace these five-and-twenty years
Back toward the twilight glooms.
A little band of twenty-six
Through distance dim. appear.
Who, on the precious corner stone,
A church of Christ uprear ;
They seek another flock to form.
Another fold enclose.
Where shepherds shall keep watch for souls
Against malignant foes ;
Where, from the strife of struggling life,
The weary may repose.
Where Christ's dear name, by loyal hearts.
Shall as a badge be worn.
And lambs be fed with tender care,
On throbbing bosoms borne.
Through paths of sacrifice they trod.
By faith and not by sight,
Like him who climbs the mountain slopes
To reach the cloudless height ;
But God has blessed and crowned their work
With garlands of delight !
14 TWENTY-FIFTH ANNIVEKSART
Most of that band have reached the land
Where Eden builds her bowers ;
Their work survives their fleeting lives,
And wreathes their names in flowers !
The links of tive-and-twenty years
Join in one chain of gold,
And bring this anniversary
Which our glad eyes behold.
We come with joyful, grateful voice,
To swell the choral lay.
And hail, with sacred festival.
This " silver wedding day !"
From distant homes or near at hand,
We gather, young and old,
A re-united family
Within one common fold !
With hands that clasp in love's strong grasp.
Each other to behold.
A " nursing mother" is the church,
God's precious gift of love;
Next to the Word and Christ the Son,
Best blessing from above !
To-day we gather in response
To this our Mother's call,
To kiss the lips that taught our youth
• To love the God of all.
As sweet her charms, as strong her arms.
As warm her heart, to-day,
As when she led our feet to tread
In wisdom's narrow way,
And shun the road which sinners trode,
That leads from God astray !
Well may we love our mother church
And bless the household bands.
Which make in Christ one family,
Uniting hearts and hands.
With holy harmonies of praise,
We lift our grateful song
To Him who wove the golden strand
Which has endured so long.
And shall unite, in realms of light,
A countless, spotless throng.
FORT STREET PRESBYTERIAN CHURCH. 15
Thrice cordially we welcome all
Our brethren and our friends,
In faith, that where His children meet,
Our Lord, Himself, attends.
Time weaves his web with threads of change
How fast his shuttles shift !
Yet all shall show a plan divine
When God the veil shall lift ;
The faithful souls, who, years ago,
Within the vineyard bore
The heat and burden of the day,
Toil with us now no more.
This Mother watched their ebbing life
And closed their sightless eyes,
And bade the soul attain its goal.
And grasp the shining priee.
While earth in trust receives their dust,
Till Jesus bids them rise !
Yet others, with their life-work done.
Stand almost at the gate,
Within which victor's palms and crowns
The ransomed soul await.
And so to-day our future way.
Untried, untrodden lies.
Yet at God's word our loins we gird,
And upward lift our eyes.
What toilsome loads, o'er desert roads,
We shall be called to bear,
We cannot tell, but He knows well.
Whose love can sweeten care,
And Whose repose is shared by those.
Who learn His yoke to share !
One glance we cast along the Past,
Its five and twenty years.
And with a smile the hours beguile —
A smile that shines through tears !
'Twere sweet to stay upon our way ;
Here rest our moving tent ;
For heart from heart is loth to part.
By hallowed converse blent.
But Time is fleet ; with tripping feet
He speeds his onward course.
16 TWENTY-FIFTH ANNIVERSAET
And we are drawn forever on
By his resistless force,
Till life shall end and being blend
With being's wondrous Source !
God's onward word will soon be heard,
• That bids us fold our tents ;
The Cloud shall rise before our eyes,
And, moving, lead us hence.
So glides away our festal day
Into that realm so vast.
Where clouds abide and memories hide —
The dream-land of the Past.
But ere we part, afresh to start
For Life's uncertain goal.
Be this our vow, recorded now.
Our future to control ;
That Duty's call shall never fall
Unheeded on the soul !
What though our life be full of strife,
Whose struggles never cease ;
Though yoke be worn and burden borne
Till dying brings release !
God's ways invite to true delight ;
And all His paths are peace.
Let me rehearse, in simple verse,
A myth of Eastern sages.
Which, like a flower from Eden's bower,
Has floated down the ages ;
Beneath the veil of mystic tale,
Its lesson still is plain:
That those, who will God's law fulfil.
The purest bliss obtain.
Duty kud Deli^lit.
A PARABLE IN A POEM.
I.
Somewhere in Oriental climes,
Among the tales of olden times,
And legendary lore,
We read in weird and wondrous words,
That when at first God made the birds,
They had no power to soar.
FORT STREET PRESBYTERIAN CHURCH. IT
They had sweet voices and could sing,
With gorgeous plumage, yet no wing,
With which to mount and fly.
In lowly meads the warblers sang,
Hut no lark's notes in echoes rang
Along the arching sky.
III.
Then at God's word the wings were wrought,
And by angelic hands were brought,
While to the birds He spake :
"Go bear these burdens at my beck.
And wear this yoke upon the neck,
For God's and Duty's sake."
IV.
At first they seemed a heavy load.
And, bowing with the weight, they trode
Along the verdant fields;
But he, who bears, increases strength.
And so the heaviest yoke at length.
Before his patience yields.
V.
Thus on their shoulders meekly borne.
From mom to night, from night to morn.
Upon each side a wing;
The burdens, folded o'er the breast,
Instead of weariness brought rest,
And led the birds to sing.
VI.
And so, the legend says, at last
The warblers found the wings were fast,
Each to its socket grown !
In form and fashion still the same,
The burdens, pinions, now became,
And each possessed his own.
vn.
Then, pouring from each golden throat,
The silver streams of music float
And mingle into one ;
On pinions, which just now they bore.
The songsters all together soar
In triumph toward the sun.
18 TWENTY-FIFTH ANKIVEESART
VIII.
We are the birds — without the wings
Our duties are the loads God brings
And lays before our feet ;
At first but burdens they appear,
But. borne with faith and holy cheer,
To wear the yoke seems sweet.
With daily growing strength to bear
The weight of duty and of care,
The load is daily less ;
Easy the yoke of Jesus grows.
His burden light, His work repose,
When He shall deign to bless.
At first we think our service hard,
Perhaps like slaves we feel debarred
From privilege and joy ;
But by and by His servants learn
Their highest freedom to discern,
Alone in His employ.
XI.
Freedom to rise and reign with Him,
Beneath the skies that never dim
Their all unclouded light ;
To him who bears his daily cross,
And, for his Lord, counts gain as loss,
Duty becomes delight.
XII.
So be it ours, while life shall last,
Our cheerful lot with those to cast
Who love to do his will.
Then dark may be our future way.
But out of darkness dawns the day.
That knows no shade of ill !
After the reading of the poem, an offering was made to the
cause of Presbyterian Church Extension in the city, to be expend-
ed by the Presbyterian Alliance of Detroit; the second of the
special hymns was sung, and the assembly dismissed with the
benediction by Dr. Shaw.
FORT STREET PRESBYTERIAN CHURCH. 19
¥l\e Sftefi\ooi\ 5<xei^di^e'^
Began promptly at 3 o'clock, with a " Jubilate " by the choir, and
prayer was offered by the Rev. George D. Baker, of the First
Presbyterian Church. The following paper, was then read, and,
though occupying nearly two hours in delivery, was listened to
with unflagging interest to its close :
BY THE HON. EDWARD C. WALKER.
"On the 2ist day of February, A. D., 1849, in the one-story
brick session-room of the First Presbyterian Church, in Detroit,
there assembled Revs. Geo. Duffield, D. D. and Robert R. Kellogg,
and Elders E P. Hastings and Thos. Rowland, a Committee of
the Presbytery of Detroit, to organize a second church of
our order, in the city. With them came twenty-six persons,
sixteen from the First Church, who then and there entered into
covenant relations with each other and their God, to walk together
as a christian church.
This event, after the lapse of a quarter of a century, we have
to-day met to commemorate. Twenty-five years seems a long
period to anticipate. How short it seems to many of us as we
look back over its fleeting hours.
That we may fully appreciate the bearings of this small
beginning, that scarcely caused a ripple in our city life, let us
glance, for a moment, at the surroundings of this event.
Gen. Zachary Taylor had just been elected President of the
United States, Epaphroditus Ransom was the Governor of Mich-
igan, and Charles Howard had just succeeded Frederick Buhl as
Mayor of Detroit. The city had then only eight wards, and was
bounded on the east by the Pontiac Rail Road, and on the west
by the high board fence of the Woodbridge Farm. The State,
three years before, had sold the Central Rail Road to Boston cap-
italists, under the lead of John W. Brooks (long an honored
member of this congregation). In the spring of iS-ig the road
reached Lake Michigan, and the " T " rail took the place of the old
20 TWENTY-FIFTH AJTlSriVEKSART
flat bar as far west as Jackson. The Pontiac Rail Road had its
depot beside the Rail Road Hotel on the site of the present Opera
House. Colin Campbell kept the Scotch Store in a low, two story
building on Smart's corner, now the Merrill Block. The rest of
that block, to Larned Street, was mostly covered with low, wooden
tenements. The next block was nearly all occupied by the Pres-
byterian and Episcopal churches. Copland's block on the next
corner had just been built, and the old "Odd Fellow's Hall"
(so long the India Rubber Store) loomed up all alone as the only
building of any note on the opposite side. Woodward Avenue
had hardly yet began its triumphant rivalry over Jefferson. The
old City Hall, the Capitol, the French Church and the two church-
es on Woodward Avenue, were the noticeable public buildings.
The dwellings of Judge Sibley, (late the residence of Edmund
Trowbridge,) of Robert Stuart, (now of Dr. Morse Stewart,) of E. P.
Hastings, (now of Governor McClelland,) and of C. C. Trowbridge
on Jefferson Avenue — of Albert Crane, (now of Mr. Grout,) and of
Charles Howard, (now of Gen. Alger,) on Fort Street, were the
admiration of our citizens. The present Jones mansion was not
yet, but its predecessor was a low, white house, embowered in
trees and shrubbery, on the River Road. It was to be yet five
years before an architect located in Detroit. The population was
just about 20,000, one-fifth of its present number. We then had
nineteen churches ; four Roman Catholic, two Presbyterian, one
Congregational, four Episcopal, four Methodist, two Baptist, one
Lutheran, one Swedenborgian. Now there are fifty-nine, three
times as many ; nine Roman Catholic, seven Presbyterian, two
Congregational, seven Episcopal, nine Methodist, six Baptist, ten
Lutheran, two Swedenborgian, two Christian, one Unitarian, two
Synagogues, and two Christadelphians.
The Catholic churches were : St. Anne's, on Larned Street,
claiming to be the religious home of 5,000 souls ; the Cathedral, on
Jefferson Avenue, which was dedicated in June, 1848, and under
the care of Bishop LeFevre, was attended by most of the non-
French-speaking people this side of the eighth ward. The tem-
porary roof over the base of its tower, gave promise of a spire
soon to come, a hope which the lapse of a quarter century has not
turned to fruition. There was the German church on St. Antoine
Street, in the " extreme north-eastern part of the city," as the
FORT STREET PRESBYTERIAN CHURCH, 21
record says, and Trinity church, founded among the rapidly in
creasing population of the eighth ward. These churches repre-
sented probably one-half of our city population.
The Congregational church was five years old, and the earnest
work and classic sermons of their new pastor, Rev. Mr. Kitchell,
were soon to change their little church on Jefferson Avenue, with
its unique Detroit architecture, (now Rolfe's Livery and Sale
Stables,) into the elegant building just above us.
Bishop McCoskry, (long may he be spared !) was rector of St
Paul's, which stood about where Wetmore's crockery store now is,
soon to give place to business, and be succeeded by the ivy-cov-
ered sanctuary on Congress Street. He had also under his Epis-
copal care, Christ Church, with its slight wooden building on its
beautiful lot on Jefferson Avenue; and the colored church on St.
Antoine Street, of Father Monroe, whose shining black face and
gold spectacles are a part of our city's history. The Mariners'
Church was not dedicated till December, 1849.
The First Methodist Church, (now St. Andrew's Hall,) had
been finished in 1848, and the record says that "great credit was
due to John Owen, James Burns and Elisha Eldred for the build-
ing of the same." The Second Church, which afterwards united
with it to form the Central, had a small, plain building on the
corner of Congress and Randolph Streets. There were also a
'colored and German Methodist Church. The old Methodist
church which stood so many years on the corner of Woodward
Avenue and Congress Street, where Gunn's store now is, had been
moved to the corner of Lafayette and Fourth Streets. It has just
now given place to Mr. Tefft's new house, and its now enlarged
congregation are finishing a new edifice on Howard Street.
The Baptist Church had its home on the corner of Fort and
Griswold Streets, on the present site of Music Hall, and was then
ably ministered to by Rev. (now Dr.) Haskell, of Ann Arbor. The
Tabernacle Baptist Church was not organized by Rev. James
Inglis, of fragrant memory, till September, 1849. The African
Baptist, the Lutheran and Swedenborgian Churches completed the
list, outside of our o\vn denomination.
The First Protestant Society was the corporate name of the First
Presbyterian Church, so called because it was the first protestant
organization in Detroit, and for years embraced all denominations
22 TWENTY-FIFTH AN"N"IVERSARf
in its fold. As the city grew, one by one the different sects with-
drew, and the church which was organized on a very broad basis
in t8i6, was, on the 23d of January, A. D. 1825, forty-nine years
ago, converted into a strictly Presbyterian Church. It was the
largest and most influential church in the city. It had on its roll
the names of many who have been efficient in moulding the histo-
ry of the State and nation. During one term, not only the Gov-
ernor, but nearly all his cabinet, were from its ranks. It has
furnished at least three members of Congress, Stuart, Buel and
Wm. A. Howard, and five United States Senators, Woodbridge,
Porter, Cass, J. M. Howard and Chandler.
At this time. Dr. George Dufifield had been for ten years its pastor,
and was then in the full vigor and strength of his intellect, and of
his influence, which was widespread and powerful. Nothing that
pertained to humanity was foreign to him. His reputation in his
own church was national. The eldership of that church had con-
tained some remarkable men. Robert Stuart was one in a million
in personal appearance, intellectual power and vigor of character.
His manner and presence, as it impressed us boys, is ineffaceably
photographed on our memory. We called him the " Apostle
Paul," in honor of our conception of what a splendid man Paul
must have been, rather than in accordance with the Apostle's own
account of his " bodily presence." Converted late in life, he car-
ried into his Christianity the same stern purpose and indomitable '
will which had marked his worldly career, only softened by the
new life within.
Major Frank Larned, U. S. A., was a most polished, courteous
christian gentleman — loved and respected by all ; his house, now
the residence of Solomon Gardner, was for years the center of a
large and christian hospitality.
Major Jonathan Kearsley, who left a leg at the sortie of Fort
Erie, was a bluff", blunt old soldier, who made his mark upon our
State's history, especially upon our educational institutions. The
University owes much to him as its regent. His Perfect Latinity
and his Ross' Latin Grammar were the terror of the boys upon
examination day, who, in the Branch University, on the site of
Farrand, Williams &: Go's present store, were preparing for col-
lege, under the able instruction of Chaplain Fitch, now of Fort
Wayne.
FORT STREET PRESBYTERIAN CHURCH. 23
Eurotas P. Hastings is a name inseparably connected in this
State, with the history of our denomination. It may ahnost be
said that the church crystallized about him. As one of our earli-
est pioneers, his influential position for the first twenty years of
his residence here, enabled him to exert a controlling influence in
the formative period of the church. The preciolis memory of his
earnest piety, and his christian fidelity to the last, has survived
every member of his immediate family.
Equally conspicuous and noble at an early day, but less
known to this generation, was Edward Bingham. The sterling
honesty and unswerving devotion to duty of Alexander McFarren
(for a time also an elder in this church) were worthy of his Scot-
tish ancestry, and would have carried him to the stake if the cause
had demanded. Of the old board of elders, Horace Hallock,
whom we all know and love, alone remains.
The church at this time had 450 members. The congrega-
tion was so large that for some years there had been no desirable
pews to rent in the church. This was located on the corner of
Woodward x\venue and Larned Street, where Tunis now dispen-
ses books and papers. The society owned one-half of the block
up to the line of St. Paul's, where stores now rent for $3,000 per
annum. A brick-session room, surrounded with tomb-stones, was
between the two churches. The following description of the
church is from ' Welling's Directory,' of 1846: " It cost $25,000.
" It is deemed one of the best churches in the western States.
" The beauty and finish of the building have been often noticed.
"It is arched, and the arch is divided into four panels, enclosing
" a quadrangle which overhangs the center of the floor. The quad-
" rangle is ornamented by two elegant center-pieces, from each of
"which is suspended a bronze chandelier."
With such a church, such a pastor and such an eldership, it is
not strange that no movement was made for church extension.
All clung with tenacity to the revered associations of the old
church. There was no wealth in Detroit at the time, except in
French farms. There was not a farthing of surplus capital. Our
present wealthy men were just laying the foundations of their
wealth, and such outlays as we are now making, were not only
unthought of, but impossible. The large congregation of the First
Church, had its famous " Dwight Debt " of $2,500 hanging over
24 TWEKTT-FIFTH ANNIVEESART
it, which never was paid till the burning of the church in 1854.
The same church could raise and pay :|25,ooo easier to-day, than
the whole body of Detroit Presbyterians could then raise $2,500.
In the summer of 1848, Rev. Robert R. Kellogg, a brother of
Mrs. Edward Orr, who had just resigned a pastorate at Romeo,
happened providentially to be in Detroit, and thought he saw an
open door for a second church. He found very many who were
earnest in saying that a second church was demanded, but only a
handful who said, " we will join in such an enterprise." He
appeared before the session of the First Church on the 7th of
August, 1848, and asked their co-operation in his plan. The ses-
sion appointed Thomas Rowland, Alexander McFarren, Samuel
Zug, Sylvester Lamed, T. W. Lockwood, Alanson Sheley and J.
S. Farrand, a committee to aid Mr. Kellogg, and to raise a sub-
scription of $1,000 to defray the expenses of the first year. On
August 31st the committee reported that they had raised only
$500, but that Mr. Kellogg was willing to commence his labors,
and rely upon future subscriptions for his support.
Accordingly, having procured the use of the Capitol School
building, he began his labors September loth, 1848. A Sabbath
School was commenced on that or the next Sabbath, and the
enterprise, whose results we now see about us, was fairly launched.
Mr. Kellogg was an indefatigable worker. He went from house
to house. He hunted up every family in the city, who had their
church letters from the east, (as some of you have yet,) stowed
away in bureau drawers, and who made the fullness of the First
Church an excuse for not showing their christian colors. He
went into the streets, and "compelled them to come in." A
respectable congregation was at once gathered. After five months
of this preparatory work, on February 5th, 1849, an application
was made to the Presbytery for leave to form a church, which
was done on February 21st, 1849, three days short of a quarter
of a century ago.
The names of the original twenty-six, were as follows : From
the First Church — Samuel Zug and wife, Sylvester Larned and
wife, S. p. Wilcox and wife, Thomas Rowland and wife, William
Gilbert and wife, Mrs. John H. Harmon, Robert Beattie, Mrs.
Charlotte Thompson, Miss Catherine A. Fisher (afterwards Mrs.
William Walker), and Delia Mather (now Mrs. Edwin Jerome, Sen.)
FORT STREET PRESBYTERIAN CHURCH. 25
From other churclies — Mrs. Elizabeth Weir and two daughters, Mrs.
R. R. Kellogg, William Haworth, Marion Rutherferd, U. O. Penfield
and wife, J. J. Briscoe and wife, and Mrs. William Stewart. Of
these, only thirteen, just one-half, are living to-day, as far as we
know. Only three remain in the church : Mr. and Mrs. Zug and
S. P. Wilcox. Prior to the organization of the church, a request
was presented to the First Church session, asking that elders Row-
land, McFarren and Sheley might be dismissed, to constitute the
Board of Elders of the new church. The session unanimously
directed its clerk to grant letters to such of said elders, as should
apply for them.
" Major Rowland alone asked for such letter. The others did
not see their duty clear, or lacked faith in the enterprise. Major
Rowland and Mr. Zug were elected the first elders, but Messrs.
McFarren and Sheley for some time sat and counseled with the
new Board, at the special request of Mr. Kellogg, and by appoint-
ment of their own session.
In March, 1849, the corporation of this society was organized,
and the question of a church building was at once agitated. The
financial ability of the little church was small, but it had pluck,
courage and faith, especially in the person of its pastor. General
Cass donated a lot on Lafayette Avenue, where R. W. Gillett now
lives, but that was so on one side, so out of town, that it was not
suitable for the site of a new church, and the Trustees bought of
James A. Van Dyke, Esq., for $1,500, the lot on the corner of
Lafayette and Wayne Streets, and applied General Cass' lot
towards the payment for the same, at $700. Messrs. Zug and
McFarren were appointed a building committee, and obtained
plans and estimates for a church ; but, on the 25th of July, 1849,
the society put the whole matter into the hands of the pastor, with
full power to raise the money and build the church, " provided
that he should not run the corporation in debt." Accordingly,
Mr. Kellogg raised the subscription, collected the money, let the
contracts in his own name, superintended the whole work, put in
all the money he had received from the sale of his house in
Romeo, and turned it over to the Trustees complete, on the 7th
of April, A. D. 1S50, when it was dedicated with rejoicing.
It cost $4,364, of which Mr. Kellogg had raised and collected
$3,260, leaving him personally responsible for $1,104. In the
4
36 TWENTY-FIFTH ANNIVEKSAKT
light of the present day, that subscription paper is a study. The
largest donor, after General Cass, was Samuel Zug, $300, the next,
Mrs. DeGarmo Jones, $200, the third, Sylvester Larned, $150,
while Mrs. Zug (who has been doing just such good things ever
since) is credited with $400, the proceeds of a fair. She also col-
lected all the money with which to furnish the church, from ladies,
mostly of the First Church ; and of all the sums donated, only
two were as large as five dollars.
In November, A. D. 1849, ^ call was extended to Mr.
Kellogg, at a salary of fSoo, but as the Trustees, by S. P. Wilcox,
their Treasurer, long an able and efficient officer, reported that it
was impossible to raise but $600, the pastor agreed to donate
the deficiency for the first year. He was installed during the
session of the General Assembly, May 21, 1850, and Drs. Riddle,
of Pittsburgh, and Mason, of N. Y., took part in the services.
The salary, actually paid to Mr. Kellogg the first year, was
$329, and the second year, $520, but these deficiencies were all
eventually made up to him. The history of this first five years is
one of intense financial struggle of a few determined men of fee-
ble resources, left to sustain, alone, an enterprise too great for
their strength.
But there is a bright side to this picture — a silver lining to
this cloud. Hardly a communion occurred during the time with-
out accessions to the church upon profession of faith. During
that five years, 190 names were entered on the roll, 69 upon pro-
fession of their faith. A Mission School on Elizabeth Street was
established, and a nice building erected in 1851, which lived and
flourished under other hands, many years.
In 1853, Mr. Kellogg, seeing the complication that might
arise, owing to the swarming of the old hive, and the contemplat-
ed erection of a new church on Fort Street, tendered his resigna-
tion, to take effect September ist, of that year, thus leaving the
way open for the Second Church to join the Fort Street move-
ment, if desired.
Rev. Robert R. Kellogg was born at Hudson, N. Y., May
iSth, 1813. He graduated at New York University, and studied
his profession at Auburn Seminary, that noble School of the
Prophets. He had preached at Gowanus, N. Y., and there erect-
ed a church, and in 1841, became pastor of the Congregational
FORT STREET PRESBYTERIAN CHURCH.
37
Church at Romeo, where he was also principal of an academy.
He was also at one time a Regent of our University. After leav-
ing Detroit, he was settled at LeRoy and Lima, N. Y., and died
suddenly, after a five years' pastorate at Milford, Pa., in Septem-
ber, 1866, aged 54 years. Rev. David M. Cooper, of Albion, son
of Elder David Cooper,-of the First Church, was converted under
his ministry, while attending school at Romeo, and afterwards
united with this church, and was only taken from us by his ordi-
nation vows. In a letter I have seen of Mr. Kellogg's, dated
July 13th, 1841, he speaks of one John S. Newberry as "a boy
of great promise," just about to unite with his church on pro-
fession.
No one can thoroughly search the records of the first five
years of our church life, without being impressed with the devout
earnestness and self-sacrificing spirit of its first pastor. His was
a pure missionary work. He displayed the same untiring energy
in leading sinners to Christ, that he manifested in building our
first edifice, almost unaided and alone. Though only eight mem-
bers, admitted under his ministry, Mr. and Mrs. Zug, Mr. Wilcox,
Mrs. Shepard, Mrs. Mair, Mrs. Knight, Mr. and Mrs. Bloss
remain among our active members, his memory and his work here
should not be forgotten by us, and the record ever remaineth on
high. Like the first pioneers in our western wilds, who clear up
the forest and then leave the smooth meadows and fruitful orchards
to be enjoyed by others — he labored, and we have entered into
his labors.
His widow, in a letter written in view of this day, from Brook-
lyn, N. Y., thus sweetly tells of the last day of his life : " Not soon
" will be forgotten his last public service as his heart dilated upon
" a text so appropriate to the close of his ministry : ' The Lord
" ' direct your hearts into the love of God and into the patient wait-
" ' ing for Christ.' The abundance of his pulpit labors on that day
" was followedup by visiting the sick and dying, and conversing about
" the interest of Christ's kingdom, until evening came, when he re-
" turned to his home, only to lay himself down to die ; and in the
" presence of his family, to breathe out his life before the morning's
" light, upon the bosom of that Saviour to whom all his energies
" had been consecrated.
28 TWENTY-FIFTH ANNIVEESART
" Servant of God, well done —
" Rest from thy loved employ ;
" The battle fought, the victory won,
" Enter the Master's joy."
After the organization of this society, the mother church pro-
ceeded in the even tenor of her way, prospering outwardly and
spiritually. In January, 1851, it leased the seventy-five feet in
front next to St. Paul's, to Holmes and Sheley, for twenty years,
at an annual ground rent of $975- In November of the same
year, a special meeting was called of that society, on the petition
of E. P. Hastings, F. Wetmore, W. A. Bacon, W. A. Raymond,
Cullen Brown, M. H. Webster and J. W. Tillman, to consider the
propriety of selling some of their real estatt, and building a third
church in the eastern part of the city. On motion of Dr. Morse
Stewart, it was voted to be inexpedient. This was only an index
of a desire for church extension, which was afterwards more fully
developed.
At the annual meeting of February 7th, 1853, Shubael Conant
in the chair, after the election of Trustees, Wm. A. Howard, Esq.
introduced a resolution, providing for the sale of all the Wood-
ward Avenue property, and building, eventually, from the proceeds,
three churches, one on Fort Street, one on Jefferson Avenue and
one near the Grand Circus. It was, after discussion, referred to a
committee of nine persons, viz : B. Wight, A. Sheley, T. W.
Lockwood, W. A. Howard, F. Moore, J. Kearsley, J. S. Farrand,
F. Buhl and F. Wetmore, to which the Elders were afterwards
added. On the loth instant the majority of the committe, by T.
W. Lockwood, reported in favor of the project, a minority, by A.
McFarren, against it. After long and heated discussions, and
two other adjournments, on January 24th a preamble and four
resolutions were introduced, and, upon a vote by ayes and noes,
were adopted, by a vote of forty-seven to sixteen. They provided
that the 160 feet in front on Woodward Avenue should at once be
conveyed to James F. Joy, E. P. Hastings and J. S. Farrand in
trust to sell the same within twenty months, but not to give pos-
session of the church for two years^; and, after paying all the debts
of the First Protestant Society, to pay over to said society four-
tenths of the residue, for the purpose of building a new church,
either on Jefferson Avenue or in the 5th or 6th ward as it should
FORT STREET PRESBYTERIAN CHURCH. 2f9
elect ; 2d, to pay three-tenths to a church to be built on Fort
Street, and three-tenths to a church in the locality which the First
Protestant Society should not choose. They also provided that if
the Second Church should accede to this plan and unite with the
Fort Street project, that its property should be divided in the same
way. It was understood that the decision as to the location
of the First .Church, was to be left to the pastor, who
was at that time abroad ; and that only two new churches
should be built at once. This Y)\an was carried out to
the letter, except that the providential burning of the old First
Church January loth, 1854, permitted an immediate sale of the
premises, and imposed the necessity under the selection made by
the First Society, upon all three churches, of building at one
time.
On the 3d of March, A. D. 1853, the parties, interested in
building a church upon Fort Street, assembled in Judge Conant's
famous office, in rear of the Michigan Insurance (now First
National) Bank building, on Griswold Street, and resolved to
organize temporarily for the purpose of building a church, under
the name of the Fort Street Presbyterian Church Society. F.
Moore was made President, Z. Chandler, Treasurer, and E. C
Walker, Secretary. A building committee was appointed, consist-
ing of F. Moore, F. Buhl, Capt. A. Canfield, S. Conant, Z. Chand-
ler, T. W. Lockwood, J. W. Brooks. After discussing the question
of site, some advising the purchase of the corner of Cass Street,
where Dr. T. A. McGraw's house now is, it was decided to buy
this lot, which was purchased of Shadrach Gillett — 100 feet front —
for $7,000, he moving off the house, which was one of the first
built on the Cass Farm, and now is occupied by Marcus Stevens,
PLsq., corner of Second and Lafayette Streets.
The first subscription for church building was at once taken
up, and twenty persons subscribed $20,200. A supplementary
subscription by the same parties brought up the amount to just
$30,000. Near the completion of the church, a third subscription
was made by other and new parties, amounting to $6.850 — total,
$36,850 — all of which was paid except $1,000. The sum received
from the First Church was about $15,000. The cost of the church
and lot was $70,000. After selling the pews, there remained a
permanent mortgage debt of $15,000 on the building. Four of
30 TWENTY-FIFTH ANNIVERSARY
the subscribers paid $3,000 each, three paid $2,000 each, and four
paid $1,500 each. The architect of the church was A. H. Jordan,
late of San Francisco.
On the 13th of July, A. D. 1853, a committee of the society,
Messrs. Moore and Lockwood, proposed to the Second Presby-
terian Chuich to unite with its organization, and transfer the
new church and society to the new building on Fort Street, when
completed, the edifice on Lafayette Street to be sold and proceeds
divided among the three churches. This overture was cordially
accepted, and soon the families connected with the Fort Street
enterprise took pews in the Second Church.
On the 12th of September, A. D. 1853, a committee was
appointed to call a pastor ; Messrs. Gibson and Bloss from the old
members, Messrs. Moore and Walker from the new. The services
of Rev. E. O. Haven, then a Professor in the University and after-
wards its President, were secured, and he ministered to us most
acceptably till a pastor was obtained. On the 4th of December
thereafter, a call was extended to Rev. (now Dr.) Henry Neill, of
Lennox, Mass., at a salary of $1,500, to be increased to $2,000
upon going into the new church. He entered upon his work on
January 22d, 1854, but was not formally installed till October 15th,
1854, when Dr. R. W. Patterson, of Chicago preached the install-
ation sermon. Mr. Neill preached almost two years, till Novem-
ber, 1855, in the old building. On the 8th of that month, the
special Trustees of the Fort Street Presbyterian Church Society,
conveyed the title and delivered the keys of this finished House
of God to the corporation of this church. On the i8th of the
same month it was dedicated with joy and thanksgiving. On the
next day the pews were successfully sold at auction, Zachaiiah
Chandler officiating as auctioneer. The building we left was sold
to the United Presbyterians for $6,000, and it is a great pleasure
that such a congregation, with such a pastor, should have succeed-
ed to the tenement we had outgrown.
The following is a list of those who took letters from the First
Church during the first year of Mr. Neill's ministry : Mr. and Mrs,
Angus McKay, Mr. and Mrs. John Brown, T. W. Lockwood, wife,
mother and sister, Mrs. Franklin Moore, Mrs. Chris. Reeve and
daughter, Mrs. Solomon Davis, Mrs. F. Buhl, Mr. and Mrs. E. C.
Walker, Mrs. J. M. Welch, Shubael Conant, Alex. McFarlane,
' FORT STREET PRESBYTERIAN CHURCH. 31
Geo. B. Dickinson, George Foote, Mr. and Mrs. J. W. Hodgkin,
Mrs. T. H. Hinchman, Mrs. Cornelius Wickware, Dr. E. M. Clark,
Mrs. James Stephens, Mrs. De(iarmo Jones, Shadrach Gillett,
wife and daughter, and Mrs. F. H. Steevens — twenty-nine persons
in all — of whom twelve have gone from us in twenty years, for-
ever, and only nine remain upon the rolls to-day, viz : Mrs. Buhl,
Mrs. Davis, Mr. and Mrs. Walker, Mrs. Welch, Geo. Foote, Mrs.
Hodgkin, Mrs. Wickware, and Shadrach Gillett.
Many heads of families then or soon after united with us, not
represented on this list. Many did not present their letters till we
entered the new church. Many joined our congregation from other
churches. Among those were Cyrus W. Jackson, Col. Levi Cook, C
H. Buhl, J. W. Brooks, Geo. E. Hand, Capt. E. B. Ward, Cap. Eber
Ward, T. F. Abbott, Edward Orr, David Thompson, Jas. F. Joy,
Z. Chandler, J. P. PhilHps, Geo. F. Bagley, B. B. and W. R. Noyes;
Geo. W. Bissell, M. H. Webster, John Palmer, Elisha Eldred, John
Q. Dudley, Charles Ducharme, John Stephens, James Williams,
Allan Shelden, Jacob Beeson, F. J. B. Crane, J. G. Erwin, H. J.
Buckley, Hovey K. Clarke, Catherine Hinchman, Jos. Law, Jr.,
Walter Chester, Philip Thurber, Bradford Smith and J. W. Smith,
his brother, Duncan Stewart, Ransom Gardner, Wm. L. Wood-
bridge, C. G. Brownell, Waldo M. Johnson, S. G. Caskey, Alfred
Russell, A. P. Cameron, R. Hosie, C. D. Farlin, J. V. Beane, W.
P. Yerkes, Chas. Root, L N. Swaine, Sarah Perkins, Jas. Menzies,
Geo. McMillan, H. Morrison, and J. W. Ray.
On the 17th of June, A. D. 1857, Rev. Mr. Neill, after a pas-
torate of three and one-half years, tendered his resignation.
During his ministry, ninety-four members were admitted to the
church ; thirteen upon profession of their faith. Mr. Neill was a
man of decided but peculiar genius. Sometimes as an orator he
rose to great heights of poAver, and carried his auditors with him
by storm ; but his efforts were unequal and irregular. His piety
was true and earnest. His social qualities were most charming
and delightful. So strong a hold had he upon the hearts of those
who knew him best, that when, after leaving this church, he was
invited to organize still another Presbyterian Church in Detroit,
he drew from us by the jK)wer of his personal attraction, fifteen or
twenty families of the congregation of the highest social and relig-
ious culture, whose departure was felt at the time as a heavy blow
32 TWENTY-FIFTH ANNIVERSARY
to our new enterprise. Now, in view of the good work Westmins-
ter has done in the past, and what we know she will do in the
future, when before long she shall stand with completed church
on Woodward Avenue; and in view of the most cordial and happy
relations that exist between us, we have no regrets to remember,
but rather joy and pride, that such a daughter has gone from our
household in the first quarter of a century of our church life.
From June i8th, 1857, we were without a pastor for sixteen
months, but providentially were not as sheep without a shepherd.
Rev. T. S. Byington, then a young man under commission from
the American Board, now returned from the foreign field on
account of health, and preaching at Newton, N. J., ministered to
us with great acceptance and profit, for three months.
The Rev. James Means, of Andover, Mass., in feeble health,
ventured to preach to us for a little while ; but we held him for
six months. Beyond any man I ever met, he seemed one after
God's own heart. Winning souls to Christ was to him as spon-
taneous and natural as breathing. A blessed revival was given us
under his labors, and many of the young whom he specially loved,
were gathered into the church, as well as many of the older ones
of the congregation, among them Franklin Moore and Elder F.
Buhl. Forty-eight were added to the church in this interregnum;
all but fourteen upon profession of faith. Mr. Means died as
chaplain in the army during the war. If ever any christian soul
will have a crown studded with stars, James Means will, I believe,
be among the blessed number.
After him, we enjoyed for two months, the ministry of Dr. Edwin
Hall, of Auburn Theological Seminary, and were then fortunate
enough to procure the services of one you all know. Rev. W. A.
McCorkle, till a new pastor arrived. During this time, a call had
been extended to Dr. Walter Clarke, ot Hartford, and declined.
At a meeting of the American Board in this city, in October,
A. D. .i85<S, Rev. Azariah Eldridge was present. He was born
upon Cape Cod, had graduated with high honor at Yale, where he
was a college-mate of S. Earned, J. W, Waterman and myself, through
whom his name was given to the church. He was converted in his
senior year, and entered at once into the ministry. He was called
to a churcl\ in New Bedford, to which he ministered successfully
for several years ; had then traveled several years in Europe, and
FORT STREET PRESBYTERIAN CHURCH. 33
was just returned ready again for ministerial work. In 1853, the
committee appointed to call a pastor, had heard Dr. Eldridge at
New Bedford and were delighted with the ability and strength of
his sermons, but he was then immovable. Now he was approach-
ed on the subject of the pastorate of this church. He intimated
that if the debt was paid he would come. An effort was at once
made in that direction, and the whole debt of $19,000 was provid-
ed for in a week. He accepted our call at a salary of $2,500, and
was duly installed as pastor on the 2d of December, A. D. 1858.
He was a man of thorough learning and high culture. His dis-
courses were models of purity of diction, and power of expression.
He faithfully and conscientiously ministered to this people for six
and one-half years, to June, 1865, when he resigned on account
of ill health. The proof of Dr. Eldridge 's ministry is shown in
the roll of the church, to which one hundred and sixty names were
added during his term, seventy-three of them upon profession of
faith. His name is specially loved by the poor and sick among
his people, for whom his heart always went out in sympathy and
benevolence.
It is right to speak of pastors' wives, after they are no longer
with us. No church ever had better ones, than Mrs. Kellogg, Mrs.
Neill and Mrs. Eldridge, Of the two latter best known to us, it
is enough to say of Mrs. Neill, that she was a daughter of Dr,
Heman Humphrey, and in every way worthy of her family and
parentage. "The heart of her husband did safely trust in her."
Mrs. Eldridge, without being specially demonstrative, won and
held the love of every member of the congregation, by her
thorough goodness, crowned by every grace of social and intel-
lectual culture.
In 1859, by act of our Legislature, the name of the society
was changed from the " Second," to the "Fort Street" Presby-
terian Church.
After the resignation of Dr. Eldridge, Rev. W. H. Clark,
nephew of Elder Farrand, filled the pulpit very happily for three
months. The session then, in October, 1865, emplyed Rev. Sam-
uel T. Clarke, of Buffalo, to supply the pulpit for a short time,
during which the society extended a call to Rev. Dr. James
Eells, of Brooklyn, N. Y., since of San Francisco and Cleveland
and San Francisco again, which call was declined.
5
34 TWENTY-FIFTH ANNIVERSARY
After the declination of Dr. Eells, in December, 1865, Mr.
Clarke was engaged to preach for us for six months, at a salary of
$2,500 per annum. He was the son of Rev. Walter Clarke, D. D.,
and a licentiate, not yet ordained. He was a graduate of Hamil-
ton College and Union Theological Seminary. Before the expi-
ration of the six months, he had performed his duties with so
much acceptance to the congregation, that he was called to the
pastorate on the 14th of May, 1866, at the same salary, and was
duly ordained to the ministry and installed as pastor on the first
day of July thereafter. Dr. Walter Clarke, his father, preached
on the occasion, a sermon of great power and ability.
Mr. Clarke continued in the pastorate till November, 1868,
when he resigned. He filled the pulpit as pastor and supply,
three years and one month, during which period sixty persons
united with the church — thirty by letter, and a like number on
profession. He is now the successful pastor of a church at Owego,
N. Y.
We now enter upon what we may well call the " golden age "
of the church — the last five years under the pastorate of Rev.
Arthur T. Pierson. On the 14th of December, 1868, a committee
to procure a pastor was appointed, consisting of J. F. Joy, F.
Buhl, Duncan Stewart, J. D. Hayes, E. Y. Swift, Allan Shelden,
and E. C. Walker. One of our committee, J. D. Hayes, who
belongs not only to the " Blue Line " of rail roads, but the blue
line of Presbyterianism, asked Dr. J. B. Shaw, of Rochester, N.
Y., to recommend the right man for the vacant pulpit. He point-
ed at once to Rev. Mr. Pierson, of Waterford, N. Y.. as the man
for the place. Mr. Hayes, with the promptness and decision
which belong to Michigan Central Rail Road officials, at once
went to hear him. He reported, without any doubt or misgivings,
that he was the " coming man." Mr. Pierson was induced to come
and look at us, and I was appointed a committee of one to go
and look at him and his antecedents. I shall not say a word
of what I learned and saw — while mousing around among the
archives of colleges and churches, and interviewing all sorts of
people — except what most of you already know : that he is a native
of New York City; age, uncertain; graduated at Hamilton Col-
lege in 1857, in the same class with Dr. Herrick Johnson ; studied
theology at Union Seminary ; preached a while in Connecticut ;
FORT STREET PRESBYTERIAN CHURCH" 35
was settled three years over a Congregational church at Bing-
hamton, N. Y., and had enjoyed, for six years, a most hap|)y and
successful ministry at Waterford, near Troy, N. Y.
On the 8th of February, 1869, we gave him an unanimous
call at a salary of ^3,000 — since increased to 84,000. He entered
at once upon his work, and was installed May 5, 1869, Dr. Shaw
very appropriately preaching the sermon. If our pastor is
sorry that he ever enlisted and took this large congregation upon
his shoulders, (and I think he is not) we emphatically sorrow not,
but all the time — Sabbaths and week days — we bless God and are
thankful that He in His i)rovidence, sent us such a man to preach
the Gospel to us,
" To point to brighter worlds, and lead the way."
His earnest and faithful labors were crowned with success in
the very first year of his ministry. God rejoiced his heart by the
out-pouring of the Spirit upon the congregation — mostly ujjon the
young people and Sabbath School. Some forty were converted in
the revival. Twenty-seven united with the church at one time,
on the 2d of March, 1870, a day long to be remembered by many.
Among the elements of progress and growth, and the events of
this five years, we may mention the following :
The "Young People's Union" began Noveml^er i ith, 1869, and,
continuing for two years, was a source of grent good. It accom-
plished the object at which it was aimed, viz ; by joint social and re-
ligious intluence, to unify and bring into mutual knowledge and sym-
pathy, all the young people of the society, and thus make them inis-
sionaries in drawing other young people into the church and
congregation. The young element of our church had always been
small to the great regret of former pastors and office-
bearers of the church. This " Union " wrought a decided change
for the better in this respect. Its influence still lives and breathes
among us, after the organization itself, which fulfilled its destiny,
has passed away.
The " Young People's Prayer Meeting " was commenced Jan-
uary 30, 1870, Otto Kirchner leading the first meeting. It has
ever since been held one-half hour before the Sunday evening
service, and has been a source of life and strength, to many young
souls.
In March, 1870, the congregation felt so happy, united and
36 TWEKTT-FIFTH ANNIVERSAET
prosperous, that they determined, at the suggestion of the pastor,
to make a thorough renovation of the interior and basement of
the church. When the original plans of the church were under
consideration in 1854, the architect was instructed to cut down
the cost to a certain amount. He did so, but in order to save his
exterior design, of which he was justly proud, he made his reduc-
tions entirely on the interior finish of the church. The result was,
the inside of the edifice was not at all in keeping with the beauty
of the exterior. The basement was badly arranged, without areas,
the earth lying against the walls, and was unventilated, damp and
unhealthy. A committee of sixteen was appointed to raise the money
and do the work. They began the repairs in March, 1 870, and we re-
entered this upper sanctuary, made new and beautiful, on January
first, 1 87 1. The basement and the very foundations of the build-
ing were overhauled, a thorough and elaborate system of drainage
adopted, and the rooms made cheerful and pleasant, without
dampness or mildew from that time forward. The old furnaces
were taken out, and a satisfactory system of steam-heating intro-
duced. The badly-laid roof was re-slated ; the organ was
improved and enlarged ; a gallery was added to the audience-
room, increasing its capacity one-third ; and the whole interior
made over, as you see. The cost was ^34,000, which the commit-
tee raised and paid. They did their work so faithfully and so
well, that their names should be recorded : Geo. E. Hand, Chair-
man, F. Moore, F. Buhl, J. F. Joy, C. H. Buhl, J. D. Hayes,
Bradford Smith, S. G. Caskey, R. W. Gillett, A. G. Lindsay, Francis
Adams, Allan Shelden, J. Huff Jones, George McMillan, Robert
Hosie, and Emory Wendell. " Si qua'ris iiioimmentu/n, circiiinspice."
If you would know their labors, behold and see.
In 187 1, the Annual Meeting of the congregation was estab-
lished, which occurs about this time each year, wherein the work
of the year is fully reviewed. The pastor, the session, the dea-
cons, the trustees, the treasurer of the benevolent fund, and the
Superintendent of the Sabbath School, all render an account of
their stewardship, and report the history, in detail, of the year's
work. After this, by the help of good things to eat and drink,
served up on Mr. Hayes' beautiful crockery-gift from the church
kitchen, an hour or two is passed in delightful social intercourse.
The influence of such gatherings is most excellent, giving unity and
FORT STREET PRESBYTERIAN CHURCH. 37
esprit du corps to the congregation, making strangers better known,
and posting up the whole people in the work of the church.
The Pastor's Bible Class, interrupted necessarily for a while,
and now again resumed, has been a new and interesting feature of
the church. No one who has attended has failed to be interested
and profited, and many have come in from other churches to hear
and enjoy. When a whole congregation shall come together, as it
should, to study Clod's Word, we may well think the approach-
ing Millenium near at hand.
The Monthly Concert has been re-established. The first action
taken by the little session in 1849, was to vote that the Monthly
Concert should always be held. May that resolution never again be
l)ractically suspended !
The great increase in the benevolences and in the benevolent
spirit of the congregation, and its more intelligent ac<[uaintance
with, and appreciation of, the work of our denomination, will be
alluded to by another. Especially has the interest of the church
in the cause of Foreign Missions, been enlarged. Our ladies
belong to and attend the Women's Board, composed of members
of all our churches. We have a most successful Young Ladies'
Missionary Society, organized by Mrs. Hoffman, whose annual
festival has become an event among us, and which has just
assumed the entire support of a female missionary in the capital
of Persia. There has just been organized also, the "Rhea Mis-
sion Band," among the little girls under fifteen years of age.
A new and complete Manual of our church was made in 187 1,
containing, among other things, the name and address of every
man, woman and child in the congregation. Though a work of
great labor on the part of pastor and session, it has been, and
is, most useful in all the work of the church.
In 1872, we had the pleasure of receiving beneath our roof-
tree, the General Assembly of the United States. The opinion
has gone abroad, as wide as the denomination, that it was the best
managed and most delightful meeting of the Assembly, ever held.
We think the opinion is justifiable and correct. This success was
due to three things: ist, To the organizing power, executive
ability and excessive labor of the Chairman of the Committee of
Arrangements, the pastor of this cluirch. 2d, To the capital men
and workers on the committee, who stood by him and held up his
38 TWENTY-FIFTH ANNIVERSARY
hands all the time : Dr. Hogarth, Rev. Mr. Baker, Hovey K.
Clarke, J. S. Farrand and Elisha Taylor*. 3d, To the unbounded
hospitality and liberality of the citizens of Detroit, of every
name and church. How few among us will live to see the Gen-
eral Assembly, in its cycle of thirty years., again in the City of
the Straits.
To summarize the work of the five years : one hundred and
eighty-five have been added to the church, ninety-one upon pro-
fession. Twenty-eight adults have been baptized, and fifty chil-
dren. The number of paying pewholders in 1869, was eighty-two;
now, one hundred and fifty-one. The income from pew rent for the
year ending in March, 1869, was ;|4,203^for the year ending
March, 1873, ^8,214, nearly double. The number of members on
the roll in spring, 1869, was 238 — the number now, after a thorough
sifting and striking off all lost members, is 359. The benevolent
contributions reported to Presbytery, March, 1869, were $1,927.64.
Those reported March, 1873, were $3,677.91. The past year will
show a large increase upon that amount.
During these five years, some interesting facts have occurred,
which concern our whole church in Detroit.
The severed Presbyterian Church has, by God's blessing, again
become a unit. We that were two, have now become one band.
This happy event was duly celebrated by a union meeting of all
the churches, on the evening of December 5th, 18O9, in the house
of the First Church, the loved mother of us all.
During these five years, every other Presbyterian church has
gained or lost a pastor. Rev. Mr. Baker has succeeded Dr.
McCorkle; Dr. Aikman has followed Mr. McLaren; and Dr.
Hogarth, the Nestor of the Detroit Pulpit, has left a great vacancy
in Jefferson Avenue, not yet filled. May God be as kind to that
church, in sending one to go in and out before her, as He has
been to her sister churches, in this regard.
On the 20th of November, 1872, was formed the "Presbyteri-
an Alliance, of Detroit." It is composed of all the ministers and
elders of our denomination in the city. Its object is to promote
co-operation and unity in city evangelization, and in extending
our church work; to select sites for, and organize new mission
*The modesty of the speaker prevented his adding the name of one of the most efficient
members of that committee. A. T. r.
KOUT STREET PRESHYTEKIAN CHUKCH. 30
schools; to determine when and where a new church shall be
built, and then take hold and build it altogether. It bids fair to be
a power in our Presbyterian Zion, and to illustrate in the church,
what is so often seen in business and commerce — the result of
combined capital and effort. Its first work was to take hold of
Calvary Mission, the child of Westminster, pay its debts, put it on
its feet, and make it a church. The amount to be raised, was
$1,500. It was divided among the four churches, and was at once
forthcoming. Calvary Church, though just begun, is to-day a
prosperous and growing church under the fostering care of Dr.
Atterbury.
Offidei'^s^ of tlic Cl(tii'cl|.
The first elders were Samuel Zug and Thomas Rowland. The
latter was one of Detroit's best citizens. He held many positions
of honor, having been post-master of Detroit and Secretary of
State under (Governor Woodbridge. His piety was of the clear-
est type. Doing good and leading souls to the Saviour was the
leading passion of his life. Leaving the old church, and casting
in his lot with this little band of workers, was characteristic of the
man. He died within six months of the organization of the
church, and his wife followed him four years later. His home-
stead was the late residence of William J. Waterman, on Wash-
ington Avenue, now the rectory of St. Aloysius' Catholic Church.
In 1850, Jonathan R. Axtell was elected elder. He was a good
man and a good elder, but in 1850 he removed to Howell, where
he still lives.
Henry C Knight was elder in 185 i, and filled the post (most
of you know how nobly and how well) sixteen years, till his death
in 1867. What he was, and what he did and what a blessed mem-
ory he leaves behind, will be told you by another.
After the accession from the First Church, in March, 1854,
Hovey K. Clarke and Edward C Walker were elected elders.
The former was already an experienced officer, coming from the
Board of Elders of the Marshall Church, in this State ; and he
has since, in the great courts of the church, made his name most
favorably known, as wide as American Presbyterianism itself. We
lost him, and AVestminster gained him in 1857.
In 1859, Alexander McFarren, an elder of the First Church,
came to us and was soon after elected elder, and served the church
40 TWENTY-FIFTH ANNIVERSARY
and his Master faithfully till he returned to the First Church,in 1866.
About the same time elder Zug, who had for seventeen years been
clerk of session, and the most laborious worker in it, withdrew
from the duties of the eldership.
In 1867, the church, by an almost unanimous vote, adopted the
rotary system of eldership, which so far has worked to the entire
satisfaction of the congregation. In making this change, elders
Knight and Walker, all that remained of the old Board, were
elected for six years, and Frederick Buhl and Samuel P. Wilcox,
for four years. In November, 1869, Joseph G. Ray was elected
elder in place of Mr. Knight, and two additional ones were chos-
en— Philip Thurber and George E. Hand. In less than two
years, in September, 1871, elder Ray followed him, whose place
he was" chosen to fill, to another and better world, to the great
sorrow and grief of us all. He was the child of foreign mission-
aries, born at Islington, England, on the 19th day of July, A. D.
1832. He had one brother in the ministry. With such a train-
ing, and with great reverence for religion, he had never given his
heart to God, till in the revival of 1865, he was struck under con-
viction one Sabbath evening under a sermon of Dr. Eldridge, (I
well remember where he sat in the pew just before me,) and
there and then, before the benediction was pronounced, he sur-
rendered his whole being into the hands of his Heavenly Father.
I never shall forget his beaming face as he told us the good news
in the vestibule at the close of the service, or Dr. Eldridge's
look of joy and almost of wonder that God should have blessed
his sermon to the conversion of a man like Mr. Ray. He seemed
to grow from that moment in all the graces of a christian charac-
ter. It has never been my lot to witness so rapid a spiritual
development. He was at once imbued with love for souls,
and took hold manfully in every field of christian labor. In two
years he was, by the vote of the church, made a deacon, and in two
years an elder. As faithful to his business, as he was to the church,
he died from overwork, in doing even more than duty demanded.
His death was triumphant and glorious. How much these depart-
ed elders were loved by this ])eople, these tablets of flowers are but
a slight token.
In March, 1872, George W. Hoffman was elected elder in
place of elder Ray, and in September last, our Board was increas-
FORT STREET E'RESBTTERIAN CHURCH. 41
ed to seven, by the election of Charles G. Brownell. So far no
elder, once elected, has fallen off the wheel of rotation. If our
pastor sometimes wishes, as I think he ought, that he had a
more devoted Board of Elders, he cannot wish for one, more
harmonious and united.
Deacon^.
This church had no deacons till 1867. Elder Zug always did
all the deacon's work, besides his work as an elder, clerk of ses-
sion and trustee. Brother Ray was elected the first deacon in
1867.
In 1869, George B. Dickinson and Charles G. Brownell were
elected deacons. In 1871, Lucien E. Smith was elected in place
of Mr. Ray, made an elder. In 1872, Bradford Smith was elected
in the place of George B. Dickinson, resigned ; and in September
last, Douglas Payne succeeded C. G. Brownell, transferred to the
eldership, making an active Board of three persons to serve tables
and care for the poor.
)«I u )ji i c .
The end of the church, opposite the pulpit, deserves mention
in a history like this. The organ was built by Stevens, of Cam-
bridge, Mass., and with its enlargement and improvement made in
1870, has ever given most perfect satisfaction. L. C. Smith, now
of Howell, presided at the keys at the beginning, with great
acceptance, and Vas succeeded by Richard Yarndley, whose ris-
ing reputation as an organist, opened to him some more inviting
field, and he left us, to be succeeded, happily, for a time, by Mrs.
Ketchuni, a daughter of Solomon Davis, who, after a few months,
resigned, and was succeeded by George L. Whitney, whom all
old citizens will remember. After he had served us a year, he
was succeeded by Henry Meakin, our present organist, who, for
twelve years, in heat and cold, in rain and shine, has faithfully
and wisely not only fulfilled his duties, but won beside the lasting
gratitude and good-will of pastor and people. Long may he serve
us.
Those who, in the twenty-five years, have aided in the worship
and service of song, have many of them left echoes of sweet
sounds still ringing in our hearts. The church owes a special
6
42
TWENTY-FIFTH AKNIVERSAKT
debt of gratitude to those who, in an early day, without fee or
reward, except the consciousness of duty done and the Master
served, conducted so long that important part of our worship.
Many of them are still with us — others we trust are singing the
song of the redeemed in heaven.
¥lie ¥fti^tee^
The prosperity and growth of a church depends mainly on the
piety and earnestness of pastor and people ; but there is a secular
side to a church as there is a worldly side toman's life and nature.
Without money, churches cannot be built, pastors cannot be sup-
ported, the ordinances of religion sustained, missionaries sent out,
or the nations evangelized. A successful and prosperous church
needs faithful and judicious trustees as well as a godly and able
pastor, devoted elders and pious laymen. Moreover, it is of little
importance how much wealth there is in a congregation, unless
there is a heart to give, and that, liberally and cheerfully.
The financcial exhibit of a quarter of a century will be made
by another. It remains for me to express, to the individuals who
have managed the temporalities of the congregation, the great
debt of gratitude we owe to them, for their gratuitous and suc-
cessful labors.
The following persons have been trustees of the society :
A. McFARREN, 2 years, from 1849 to 1851.
SAMUEL ZUG, 11 "
D. O. PENFIELD, 7 "
S. EARNED, 5 "
J. J. BRISCOE 6 "
S. P. WILCOX 3 •'
HOVEY K.CLARKE 2 "
E. C. WALKER i "
GEO. B. DICKINSON, 7 "
ELISHA ELDRED 3 "
F. MOORE, 6 "
Z. CHANDLER 2 "
C. H. BUHL, 9 ■•
GEO. E. HAND, 15 "
J. HUFF JONES, 14 "
JOHN GIBSON, 5 "
DUNCAN STEWART, 5 "
ROBERT HOSIE, 7 "
"
' i860.
"
' 1856.
" " '
' 1854.
" " '
' 1855.
" I85I '
' 1854.
" 1854 •
' 1856.
" '
1855.
" 1855 '
' 1862.
"
' 1858.
" 1856 '
1862.
"
1858.
" I85S '
1867.
"
1873.
" i860 '
1874.
" 1862 '
1867.
" "
1867.
" 1867 '
1874.
FORT STREET PRESBYTERIAN CHURCH. 43
GEO. McMILI.AN 4 1871,
ALLAN SIIEl-DEN 3 1870.
J. D. HAVES 4 " " 1870" 1S74.
S. G. CASKEY 3 '■ " 1871 " 1874.
R. A. ALCiER, I " " 1873" 1874.
No one without exjierience can estimate the amount of labor
it has cost these twenty-three men to raise the amount of money,
they have disl)ursed in twenty-five years.
As we look back for fifteen years over the term of Judge
Hand, it looks, humanly speaking, as if the ship would have
foundered without him — without his unfailing courage, his indomi-
table perseverance and his skill in collections. We do not believe
it would have done so, for we have faith that, if necessary, God
would have raised up some other man to take his place, as no
man is indispensable in this world ; yet, none the less, the Fort
Street Church owes to Judge Hand a debt it can never pay, except
bv not forgetting the past, and generously holding up the hands
of all the trustees who shall come after him. He closed his last
annual report in March, 1873, as Chairman of the Board, when
he refused to be re-elected, with these words, •' The kindness of
the Society to me during my long service is fully felt and appre-
ciated; its liberality in subscriptions has been wonderful. The
cordial and earnest co-operation of my associates receives my
grateful and heartfelt acknowledgements."
Next to Judge Hand, we owe most to Sam'l Zug, at an early
day, and to the clear head and able financial management of
C. H. Buhl, for nine years; to J. Huff Jones, whose pains-taking
devotion for fourteen years to the interests of pew-holders, we all
appreciate and admire.
¥lie IJedoi'd of the f^oi't ^t. dbtii'd^ dtii'ir)^^ tl^e War.
This Church was ever forward during the war in contributing
to the Sanitary and Christian Commissions, and Dr. Eldridge and
one of the Elders (the speaker) each served at the front in the
hospital work of the latter organization. That we were always
true and faithful to the flag is no credit, when all were alike loyal.
Our young men were few at that time. The following list, as far
as I have learned, comprises all who left our congregation for the
war.
44 TWENTY-FIFTH ANNIVERSARY
John Goring enlisted at the first call of his country in the
rst Michigan Infantry, (three months men,) under Col. Wilcox ; was
at the first battle of Bull Run. Re-enlisting, he was through all of
McClelland's seven day's battles in the peninsula. He earned
promotion by brave and faithful service, and was discharged as a
ist Lieutenant in October, 1862, from permanent disability, caused
by a fall from his horse. He re-enlisted in the Veteran Reserve
Corps as soon as it was formed, and remained till Jefferson Davis
was captured by a Michigan regiment. He served with efficiency
for a long time on the staff of Gen. O. B. Wilcox.
William H. Perkins, whose mother and sisters are with us,
enlisted as a private in Col. Broadhead's ist Mich. Cavalry, in
July, 1861 ; was made lieutenant before leaving the State, and
served as lieutenant and captain four years. He was for a while on
the staffs of Gen'Is Stahl and Wilson, and two years on that of
Gen. Kilpatrick, as ordinance officer of the 3rd Cavalry Division.
He was actively engaged in the battles of Falling Waters and of
Winchester, and in the latter battle had two horses shot under
him. He made a brave, capable and active officer.
Emile Shepard, whose mother and grand mother areamong
the very oldest members of the church, enlisted also in the ist
Mich. Infantry, (three month's men) in the company of the la-
mented Horace S. Roberts. He was in the first battle of Bull
Run, and while hunting for a surgeon to save the life of his lieu-
tenant (Mauch, who died soon after at Richmond) he was struck
by a ball and lay three days unnoticed upon the field. He was
at last cared for by the rebels, and his leg amputated. He was
taken to Richmond, and was the first Michigan soldier exchanged
in the war.
On his return, his elder brother must needs take the place that
the wounded Emile could not fill, and Adolph Shepard enlisted
in 1862, in the 24th Michigan — that historical regiment of Detroit.
He was at Fredericksburg and several other battles. On the first
day at Gettysburgh he was on detached service upon a regular
battery when he was fatally shot by a minnie ball. He lived only
long enough to say to his comrades ; " Take my bible to
sister Katie, and tell them at home I died doing my duty," —
words worthy of a soldier and an hero.
Still another brother, Edward Shepard, enlisted in the navy.
FORT STREET PRESBYTERIAN CHURCH. 45
at the age of fifteen, and being discharged, from illness, re-enlisted
in the 52d N. V". Regiment and served to the end of the war.
Htram M. Towne, was a teacher in our Sunday School, — a
nephew of Col. C H. Towne. so well known as an officer of the
[st Michigan Cavalry. He enlisted as a private in Battery C, ist
Michigan Light Artillery ; won his promotion by steady steps to
a first-lieutenancy; and remained in active and faithful service to
the end of the war.
CuTHBERT W. L.AiNG, vvas for a while a lieutenant in Battery
" R." of the same regiment; and was mustered out in April, 1863.
(lEO. L. MAi.rz, now of Alpena, enlisted in the 4th Michigan
Infantry; was made second lieutenant in 1862 and first lieutenant
in 1864; and was badly wounded in the sanguinary battle of Cold
Harbor ; and was mustered out on account of his wound in June
1S64. He was a most capable, efficient and praiseworthy officer.
Geo. W. Hill, enlisted as a private in the 5th Michigan Cav-
alry in August, 1862 ; was made a second lieutenant in the 7th
Cavalrv ; and was with Custer in all his famous raids in 1863.
He was with Kilpatrick in his bold dash around Richmond ;
was in all the battles of the Wilderness till May nth, when he was
taken . prisoner at the Yellow Tavern ; vvas in Libby Prison, at
Savannah and Charleston (under the fire of Federal guns) ; and
was exchanged after ten months incarceration. He remained in
the army and saw active service on the plains till 1866 ; and was
mustered out a first lieutenant, with a capital record.
L.\NDON Warren, son of Joseph Warren, once editor of the
Tribune, now of Washington, D. C, enlisted as a private in August,
1862, in the 20th Michigan Infantry; was three years in service;
was present at Fredricksburgh, and the Wilderness, and with the
9th Corps in front of Petersburgh ; and was commissioned a first
lieutenant in 1864.
Robert Spear Warren, his brother, entered the army as
second lieutenant in the ist Cavalry, in November, 1863. After
being in active service for six months, was killed by a shell on the
1 2th of June, A. D. 1864, at Custer's disastrous battle of Trevillian
Station, Va. He died in the arms of Capt. Joseph Bullock, now
of this congregation. He was a noble lad ; and many an eye was
moist when the news of his sad death came.
Frederick Augustus Buhl, of all those who perished from
46 TWENTY-FIFTH ANNIVERSARY
this congregation in the war, was best known and best beloved.
Of nol)le form and feature; of good intellect and of the most
kind and lo\'ing ways, he was a favorite with all. As a member
of my bible class for many years, I had every trust in his Christian
character ; and loved him almost as a son. He was in the Univer-
sity at Ann Arbor ; and there seemed to be every possible tie of
love, ambition and a happy home, to keep him from the service.
But a conscientious sense of duty was stronger than all these silk-
en bands. He offered himself to the government ; and went out
as second lieutenant, 24th Michigan Infantry, in July, 1862, and was
promoted to first lieutenant in December after. He was in all the
battles of the regiment till November, 1863. He had hair-breadth
escapes at P^redericksburg ; and was shot through the thigh at
Gettysburgh. He then recruited a company and became captain
in the ist Michigan Cavalry in November, 1863. On the 25th
of August, 1864, at Shepardstown, Va., he received a fatal wound
while on a skirmish, from which he died in hospital at Annapolis,
Md., on the 15th of September, thereafter, nursed by a mother's
loving hand. He was a brave and noble soldier to the end. It is
well with him, — those left behind can mourn only for themselves.
Selden Jones Phillips, son of Capt. J. P. Phillips, and broth-
er of Mrs. George F. Bagley, enlisted in the navy in 1863, receiv-
ing from Commodore Porter a commission as acting master's mate.
He served as a brave and gallant officer on the Mississippi fleet,
but mostly on Red River, till he was discharged in 1864, on
account of illness, contracted from exposure and the climate, and
which caused his death May loth, 1865. He was in that famous
retreat of the Red Ri\ser Squadron, when, for three days, with
cotton bales lashed to their sides, they ran the dreadful gauntlet
of the rebel batteries. The Juliet, on which young Phillips
belonged, was almost torn to pieces with shells, and being disabled,
had to lash herself to another steamer. She was only saved from
utter destruction, by the sudden advent of a Federal iron clad,
from below. During his service, a bible put in his trunk by a
loving mother, and read and re-read in hours of enforced idle-
ness, first called his attention to religious truth. Daring his long
and tedious illness, he turned still more to these blessed themes.
He gave his htart to the Saviour, and died rejoicing in His love.
I never shall forget the sweet and solemn scene, when, just before
FOKT STREET I'RESBYTEUIAN CHUKCH. 47
his death, Dr. Eldridge and the session gathered around his bed
to administer the ronimunion and allow him to take upon himself
those vows, which he could never enter the luKise of God to
assume. His face seemed to shine as though he anticipated
already the communion of the saints in heaven.
His brother, John P. I'Hii.i.ii's, Jr., at the age of i8, in August,
1 86 1, enlisted in Captain Howrigan's Company, of First Michigan
Cavalry, and served his three years of enlistment, with courage
and fidelity, as a soldier and non-commissioned officer.
Ai.EXANDiiR H. McGk.aw, SOU of Virgil W. Mc(;raw, entered
the service as quarter-master's sergeant, in the Fifth Michigan
Infantry, and served assiduously and faithfully in that capacity
for three years.
Thomas S. McGraw, his brother, enlisted in the Sixteenth
Michigan Infantry, (Colonel Stockton) in March, 1862. On the
2d of September, after, he was in the disastrous fight at Gaines'
Mill, where sixty of his company (I) fell at a single volley. He
was struck by a ball, which went clear through his chest. He
lay on the field for six days, saved from death only by a flask of
brandy given him by a rebel colonel. He was taken to Libby
Prison, and after thirty-two days was exchanged to go north. In
visiting him at Bellevue Hospital, N. Y., I took my first lesson in
seeing how nobly northern soldiers could suffer and endure, as
well as fight, for their country.
\Vh.liam Rekd was in the Second Michigan Infantry, and was
all through the seven days' battle under McClellan. The expo-
sure almost deprived him of his eye-sight, and after the battle of
Harrison's Landing, he was discharged for this disability He is
said to have been as brave in battle, as he is now, in another church,
earnest and faithful in the work of his Master.
EinvARD WiLSiJN was assistant librarian of our Sunday School,
and enlisted in August, 1862, in the I'wenty-Fourth Michigan
Infantry, Company H, Captain Vinton, and after faithful service,
died of disease contracted in the field, at Brook's Station, Va.,
in December, 1862.
Norman Johnson, of Hay City, enlisted in Captain Lum's
Company A, First Michigan Infantry, May, t86i, at the first call,
and was badly wounded in the chest and shoulder, in the first bat-
48 TWENTY-FIFTH ANNIVBK8AET
tie of Bull Run, and mustered out at the end of his service, with
a high record for gallantry.
David A. Granger was a leader of our choir. He recruited
a company in the Fourth Michigan Infantry, in 1861, but his
record is unknown.
Besides these who went from us to the war, may we not men-
tion one or two who came from the war to us ?
I well remember, after working for six weeks among the wound-
ed at City Point, of spending the 5th of July, A. D. 1864, on the
beautiful banks of James River, with Custer's corps, just resting
after one of his daring raids. There first I met General (then
Colonel) R. A. Alger, of the Fifth Michigan Cavalry, whose record
as a soldier, is surpassed by few of all the brave men which Michigan
sent to the conflict. Now in the pursuit of peace, forgetful of
sabre and trumpet, he fills well his part, as a man of business, and as
a member and trustee of this church.
It may not be generally known that another officer of this
church, Deacon Lucien E. Smith, won laurels in the army, before
entering the ranks of trade. He enlisted as a private in the
One Hundred and Thirty-Sixth Regiment, New York Volunteers,
was promoted at Fredericksburg, Chancellorsville and Getteys-
burgh, was then transferred to the west under General Hooker,
was made first lieutenant at Lookout Mountain, and in command
of his company, made, with Sherman, that whole glorious " March
to the Sea." He will care for the poor none the less tenderly, that
he has mingled nobly and well in so many scenes of carnage and
suffering.
Captain F. C. Adamson also deserves mention as a most
able and capable officer. He went out as second lieutenant, in
1861, in the Third Michigan Cavalry, was promoted to first lieu-
tenant April, 1862, and to captain in October, 1862. He was seri-
ously wounded and permanently disabled in .\ugust, 1864, at
Duvall's Bluff, in Arkansas.
i^etiofd of ©edeajs'ed jVlembei'ji.
We now come to those whose names have been transferred, as
we trust, from the roll of the church on earth, to the roll of the
redeemed in heaven. Oj)posite their names in the Lamb's Book
of Life will never be written the date of their departure, for "there
FORT STllKKT PKESBYTKRI A N CU rilCH. 40
is no death there." We approach this theme, not with sorrow and
sadness, but rather with exultation and joy, that so many have
gone from our number, in the hope of a blessed immortality, and
are there awaiting us as, ''one by one," we shall cross the river.
Of those who left us in the first five years of Mr. Kellogg's
ministry, the present officers knew but little. The ranks of those
gathered into a missionary church, as this was, are not stable and
permanent. Many died away from the city, and the entry, ' died "
at such a date, opposite their names, is all we know of their spir-
itual life. Little more than a list can be furnished. Marked with
a star, are the names of Chester Spaulding, Helen, Mary and
Cherry Weir, (all sisters of Judge J. D. Weir) Sarah Burroughs,
Hannah C. Smith, Mrs. John (iibson, John Cook, Albert G. Ful-
ler, Martha Fielding, Elizabeth Schoonmaker, Eiisha Wells, Mrs.
Captain W. W. Allen, Mrs. William Stewart, Harriet Prentis, (a
sister of George H. Prentis, now of this chuich) Mary Conner,
Louisa Praigg, David W. Ellithorpe, and Mrs. William Walker.
The first death among those of us who joined the church in
1854, was that of one greatly regretted by us all, Mrs. Ahnis C.
Moore, a woman of marked character, religiously and intellectu-
ally. A sister of Senator Chandler, she was a worthy specimen
of a New England woman. She had ever dispensed a large hos-
pitality, and left a void, not easily filled, in our social life.
The next year (1857) took from us two most estimable heads
of families : Mrs. Christopher Reeve and Mrs. James Stephens.
In 1858, one name only is on the roll of the departed — Mrs.
Phoebe Foote. She was a woman of great activity and energy, and
without doubt one of the most earnest and efficient christian
women in the city. The record of her work for the souls of
others is on high.
In 1859, also one only, — Mary E. McGraw. She was convert-
ed in the revival of 1857. The day she gave her heart to Cod, is
as fresh as yesterday in my recollection. Her dt.'ath, in the
very hey-day of her youth, was one of triumphant hope, peace
and joy, the sight of which was enough to convince the most
skeptical of the value of christian faith in a dying hour.
In i860, one also — Mrs. A. H. Jordan — who died in Scotland,
on a visit to her childhood's home.
In 1 86 1, one also — John V. Beane — whom we all had reason
7
50 TWENTY-FIFTH ANNIVERSAKT
to love as a christian and to respect as the founder and teacher of
the Detroit Kemale Seminary. Those who have had daughters
under his wise care, or in the school he founded, owe much to
him. The very next year there followed him his daughter, Mrs. Caro-
line G. Page. In 1864 another daughter of great promise, Emma
L. Beane; and in 1873 his only son, John B. Beane — all rejoicing
in the love of Christ, till now there is more of the family together
in heaven than on earth.
In 1862 we lost away from us Mrs. Mary E. Perry, (sister of
Henry N. Walker,) and Mrs. Helen M. Boardman, (sister of Philo
Parsons.) The former died away from us. The glorious christian
life and triumphant ha})py sickness and death of the latter, has
lew parallels in our history.
In 1863 the Angel of Death passed us by untouched ; but in
1864, beside Mrs. Page, he took from us Mrs. Charity Southard,
Mrs. James Henry. Mrs. Theodosia Snow, (the mother of Mrs.
Heath, and Mrs- Knight,) an aged saint, and Mrs. Mathilde G.
Moore. The last, a native of sunny France, with all the spirit
and vivacity of her race, refined by culture and travel, with great
capabilities of enjoyment and usefulness, was called away in her
young motherhood ; but not without a bright hope beyond. Two
years before she had united with this church ; and her exami-
nation before the Session will long be happily remembered by all
present.
In 1865 the call came for Mrs. Henrietta Pond, Selden Jones
Philips, of whom we have spoken, and Mrs. Levi Cook, the wife of one
of our oldest and most worthy citizens. Thus death, that year,
gathered his harvest equally from youth, middle and old age.
In 1866 the number increases, and six are on the list of the
departed. Miss Eliza A. Rosebrook, almost a stranger among us,
Mis. William L. Woodbridge,' Mrs. Julia L. Jenks, Mrs. Joseph
Nicholson, Mrs. Theodore Ronieyn, and Joseph C. Heath. Mrs.
Woodbridge was a daughter of Dr. Ebenezer Hurd, and sister of
Mrs. G. W. Hoffman. She was a devoted and loving christian
mother, and, like Mrs. Nicholson, was taken from a group of little
ones, left to be cared for by Him, who careth always for the
orphan and the bereaved.
Mrs. Romeyn was long known in this city — a woman
of mark and influence in every circle in which she moved, with
FORT STREET PRESBYTERIAN CHURCH. 51
culture, position and abilities, fitting her for, and making her, a
leader in society. Her whole life was consecrated by a pure and
earnest piety.
Joseph C. Heath, a brother-in-law of P:ider Knight, was a
man of singular and simple piety, to whom devotion and religion
seemed inborn, and prayer but the natural breathing of his life.
In 1867, five went before us: Mrs. Anna Bryant, (mother of
Mrs. E. C.Walker) John Gibson and Shubael Conant— all aged— all
having lived beyond their fellows, and left comparatively alone in
life; and two others : Mrs. Lucia W. Smith and Mrs. Harriet N.
Cameron, just in the ripeness of womanhood, each from a circle
of dependent little ones, each with clear hope and confiding trust,
called to go up higher.
John Gibson was one of those solid, reliable men, in whom
every one believes, and whom every one trusted. His character
as a christian and a man, was one any of us might covet without
sin. For several years he was ah efficient trustee and treasurer of
this society.
Shubael Conant, at his death aged 84, had been a resident for
sixty years of this city, and its history would not be complete
without a record of his life. Beginning his career when Detroit
was but a fur-traders' station, he had prospered with its growth.
A merchant and a trader, his honesty was unimpeachable. No
man in Detroit was ever so perfectly trusted by his fellow-citizens,
or so often made an arbiter or trustee for the interests of others ;
with happv, pleasant ways, winning the love and respect of all;
full of charity in word and deed ; having no family of his own,
the door of every family in Detroit was freely open to him. He
was converted after he was fifty years of age, and even then God
gave the life of an ordinary generation to illustrate the purity and
sweetness of a well poised, harmonious christian character. When,
from a peaceful and happy death -bed, he was gathered to his
fathers, the Fort Street Presbyterian Church lost one of its best
supporters and fastest friends.
Five names were also starred in 1869, of those in whose crowns
above, we hope are many stars : Lyman Briggs, Mrs. Catherine
H. Jones, Miss Mary L. Palmer, Mrs. Catherine Hinchman, and
Mrs.-Elmira Green.
Mrs. Hinchman had a motherly christian spirit, which not only
52 TWENTY-FIFTH ANNIVERSARY
her death bed, but her life witnessed. She had ever been faithful
to the work that God had imposed upon her widowed life. Two
years years later, we carried from the same house, to Elmwood,
Joseph Law, Jr., the husband. of her only daughter.
So, also, two years from the death of Mary Palmer, went up
from the same household to meet her whom he so much loved,
and on whom he so much leaned, her father, John Palmer. His
history, like Judge Conant's, goes back to the early history of
Detroit. His old homestead and the sweet garden about it on
the present site of Moffat's building, are inseparable from the re-
ccollection of Detroit, as it has been for forty years. An honest
merchant, a faithful agent, a consistent christian, his record, to our
eyes, has no blemish.
Mrs. DeGarmo Jones came to this city as a bride on the first
trip of the ''Walk in the Water," in 1819, fifty-five years ago.
They soon located in a charming spot on the brink of the river,
then some ways below the city, on the front of the Jones Farm,
where the Michigan Car Works have lately stood. Colonel Jones
was a man of high character and position in the community, and
she made his house always the center of a refined, delightful
social life, full of all the hospitality for which Detroit was famous,
and which we trust will never entirely leave us. Left a widow
many years ago, the same social life remained, only modified by
her new position. Left with wealth, she used it^conscientiously
and wisely. She was the third largest contributor to the building
of our first edifice, when she was in no way connected with the
congregation ; and in the building of this church, she stood side
by side with the very largest donors, in each successive demand
for means and money. That christian is well along in the divine
life, who has learned that he is only a steward of God's bounties,
and who gives to His cause liberally and cheerfully.
Our number was diminished by four in 1870 : Mrs. Harriet
C. Boyd, Mrs. Mary Ward, Mrs. Abbey E. Stevens, widow of F-
H. Stevens, a leading citizen of thirty years ago ; and Anna S.
Gillett, daughter of Shradrach Gillett. The last left behind a
bright and shining record. For many months before her depar-
ture, she was brought face to face with death, and suffered pain
bevond measure ; but her faith and hope and spiritual joy deep-
ened to the end. The close of her life seemed meant by God as
FOKT STREET PRESBYTERIAN CHURCH. 53
a long and ])ointed lesson to all around her, to teach them how a
christian should suffer and should die. Again, after two years,
her mother, a sweet and sainted character, followed her to the
home above.
In 1871, there left us — beside Elder Ray, Joseph Law, Jr. and
John Palmer, already alluded to — Mrs. William Champ and David
Stewart.
In 1872, beside Mrs. Gillett, there left us one of the original
twenty-six members of this church : Mrs. Louisa Wilcox. Some-
what retiring in her ways, a life-long invalid, those that knew her
most, loved her best. Her long, last sickness, developed to her
pastor, and all who stood by her bedside, an unexpected force of
christian character and christian knowledge. She died in triumph
at the last, and her memory is a rich legacy to her children.
In the year just drawn to a close, we have followed to the
grave, one by one, all that was mortal of John B. Beane, Albert S.
Knight, son of our beloved elder, Silas L. Fuller, suddenly cut
down away from home, within one week from his reception into
this church, and Mathilde Foex. The impression of their lives
and deaths is too fresh in your minds to need one word from me.
Beside these, we have, within these years, lost from
the congregation, several heads of families, whom we
have greatly mourned, and many whose hearts were deeply
interested in the success and upbuilding of this church. Among
whom, we would not forget Captain Augustus Canfield, U. S. A.,
son-in-law of General Cass, who did us good service on the build-
ing committee of the church ; Cyrus W. Jackson, alwas liberal in
his benefactions to us ; James Williams, steady, faithful and true
in every relation of life ; Colonel Levi Cook, the veteran mer-
chant, ever kind and genial to all ; David Thompson, the success-
ful business man, only prevented, by an unwise statute, from mak-
ing a noble gift out of his wealth, to the educational interests of
our denomination ; Charles Ducharme, a model of mercantile
honor, trustworthiness and success, doing his share in every benev-
olent work ; and, though educated in another communion, giving
freely and generously to this church ; Henry J. Buckley, cut off
from wife and little ones, in the prime of his years, just as integ-
rity and capacity in business, had earned distinguished success;
and Henry W. Standart, the most devoted and loving of fathers
54 TWfiNTY-FIFTH ANNIVERSARY
to sons and daughters, who returned his love with interest. Time
would fail us to say all that might wisely be said of these men,
and others, who have left us within the quarter-century now closed.
In conclusion, we have, as a church, great cause to " Thank
God and take courage," — thank God, because all we have done,
and all we are to-day, comes from Him; "take courage," be-
cause He is " the same yesterday, to-day and forever,"
and will, if we serve Him, bless us in the future as He
has in the past. We have no occasion for pride or
vain glory. May every heart, amid the congratulations of this
happy day, be enabled to say, from its deepest recesses, " Not
unto us, O, Lord, not unto us, but unto Thy name be the glory."
Let us remember, that, with growth and prosperity, come enlarged
duties and responsibilities. Our first need is a new baptism of
the Holy Spirit, that all those who have in any way aided in
building up this church and society, may themselves be living
stones in God's Temple. Let us aim to be a living, working giv-
ing church, full of the missionary spirit of the Master, laboring,
not for ourselves alone, but for Detroit, for our country, for the
world.
After the reading of Mr. Walker's address, Mr, George W.
Hoffman presented the following financial exhibit of the pecuni-
ary outlay of the quarter-century, for congregational and benevo-
lent purposes ;
^l]e S^iiiki^c^e)*^ ki|d ©ei^evoleride^.
It is sometimes said that the prayer meeting is an index to the
spirituality of the church. May it not also be said with propriety,
that the money contributed is an inde.x to its benevolence and its
prosperity.
With reference to the latter proposition, I think it will be fully
shown by the statement I have to make of the expenditures by
this congregation from its organization to the present time, that
in proportion as it has bestowed liberally, so it has prospered.
It has increased in numbers and wealth, and has realized the
FOliT STKKKT I'liKSlt YTKIU A X CIirKCH- 55
assurance given in God's Holy Word: "Give, and it shall be
" »;iven unto you, good ineasure, |)ressed down and shaken togeth-
" cr, and running over; for with what measure ye niele, it shall be
" measured to you again."
The small beginnings of this church, may at this day, seem
strange to us, and perhaps as much so to the few of its first mem-
bers who are still with us.
The salary of its lirst pastor was fixed at eight hundred dollars
a year.
A committee to whom was confided the then difhcidt task of
raising that amount by subscription, after some days of dilligent
effort, reported they had obtained pledges for about six hundred
dollars, and that there might not be any failure in the result, the
pastor himself had subscribed the other two hundred. Of this
six hundred dollars, there was a considerable deficiency at the
close of the year.
The benevolent contributions for the first year amounted to
fifty-five dollars and fifty-two cents.
But it is not my province to go into the history of the church,
that ha\ing been left to other hands. It seemed however not out
of place to allude to these items as a starting point in a report of
the benevolent collections and contingent expenses of this church
and congregation, during the first twenty-five years of its exist-
ence.
.>ot to go too minutely into detail, I have thought it advisable
and as fully covering the object of this report, to condense it into
periods of five years, embracing, in brief, expenditures by the
trustees as found upon the records, for contingent and current
expenses ; and collections by the session for missionary and other
benevolent purposes, which have been as follows :
For Corningent Expenses, lirst five years, to 1S54 $ 3,203 68
second" "1859, 26,31180
third " " 1S64, 27,635 81
fourth " "1869 32,74658
fiftli " " 1S74 46,61640
Total of Contingent Kxpt-nses foi twenty-five years, $136,514 27
56 TWENTY-FIFTH ANNIVERSARY
For benevolent purposes :
Fiist period of five years, to 1854 $ 1,276 15
Second " " " 1859 3.84699
Third " " " 1864 , 7,27687
Fourth " " " 1869 8,50978
Fifth " " " 1874, $26,712 43, In addition to this
last named sum, there has been given for various specific,
benevolent and charitable purposes, $10,426 55, making for
the last period of five years. 37,i38 98
Total for benevolence for twenty-five years $ 58,048 77
Thus it is shown, that the amount given for benevolent and
charitable purposes within the last five years, has been nearly
double the amount given during the previous twenty years.
The expenditure for church property, has been as follows :
For the lot on virhich the church stands $ 7,000 00
Original cost of building 63,000 00
Remodeling and rebuilding in 1870 35. 000 00
Organ 5, 500 00
Total $110,500 00
The gross sum expended for all purposes so far as can be ascertain-
ed from the books, has been $305,063 04
Many contributions have been made in answer to appeals for
aid, that do not appear on the records. Added to these, have
been numerous donations from sympathising and loving hearts,
" where the left hand knoweth not what the right hand doeth."*
The Ladies' Benevolent Society has, during the past winter,
sent clothing and other useful articles to families of home mission-
aries in this State and Kansas, to the amount of $391.08.
The Young Ladies' Society has provided for the continuance
of two schools for girls in India, established last year, and are
expending between three and four hundred dollars among the
poor of the city.
I will also take the liberty of mentioning one other generous
gift desirable and appropriate for social purposes, from one whose
liberality is too well known to need mention at my hands,
*It is due both to justice and to generosity, to state, what really belongs to this history, that
during the past five years, the present pastor of this church has been made the recipient of
various sums of money from the members of his congregation, amounting in the aggregate, to
nearly four thousand dollars, which he here gratefully acknowledges. A. T, p.
FORT STREET PRESBYTERIAN CHURCH. 57
of some fifteen hundred pieces of china and glass, from which to
dispense the good things always so cheerfully and bountifully pro-
vided by our ladies whenever called upon.
The method of benevolent collections in this t:hurch during
past years (except the last four) was the same as practiced in
most churches: by subscriptions, donations, and plate collections,
on the Sabbath.
Four years ago cards were introduced on which was designated
one of the objects of church benevolence for each month in the
year, with a blank column in which the donors stated the amount
they would give to each object named.
This system was found to be an improvement on the former
method, but passing the plate was still necessary to collect the
card-subscriptions, and to give those who did not adopt them, an
opportunity to contribute.
Recently, former methods have been discontinued, and the
envelope system (so called) adopted, which it is believed will prove
much more agreeable and convenient, and will lead to a com[)li-
ance with the scri|)ture injunction : " Upon the first day of the
week let every one of you lay by him in store as God hath pros-
pered him," and by which all members of the congregation, old
and young, may, as an act of worship, present their offerings unto
the Lord.
To carry out this system, a small, tin rack has been placed in
each pew, and in the rack a leather envelope, in which each per-
son may deposit an offering (after the sermon, and before the
final hymn) during morning service. After service the envel-
opes are collected and the amount, found therein, appropriated to
the several objects of benevolence stated on a printed card which
is also placed in the rack with the envelope.
Any persons wishing to designate the particular purpose or
object to which their contribution shall be given, can do so by
writing on a slip of paper and depositing it with the gift in the
envelope.
This system was introduced on the first of January of this
year, and has thus far proved much more successful than was
anticipated, and it is believed will receive the liearty and cordial
co-operation and approval of this entire congregation, and will
58 TWENTY-FIFTH ANNIVERSARY
prove to be the most popular and efficient method ever practiced,
to develop the beneficence of the church and people.
The Fort Street Presbyterian Church is now free from debt,
save a small amount, and has money in its treasury to meet all
current demands, and has adopted Paul's injunction to the
Romans: ''Owe no man anything, but to love one anoiher."
This was followed by an address by Bradford Smith, Esq., on
For a long time before the organization of our church, the
friends of " Mission Work " had not been idle in the vineyard of
the Lord ; but had been doing what they could to keep pace with
the growth of the city. The old First Church was full of praying
earnest and faithful men and women, who could not remain at ease
within her walls and see the city extend East and West, without the
Gospel of Peace. And, although the First Congregational Church
had gone out from her and planted the Banner of the Cross of
Christ in the eastern part of the city, they determined, early in
the autumn of 1848, to plant another colony in the western portion
of the city. Accordingly a few courageous and faithful ones went
forth from the mother church, as Mr. Samuel Zug says, " burning
their ships behind them." At once they organized a Sabbath
School. Mr.' Alanson Sheley was asked to take the superinten-
dency of the new enterprise, as he had had experience in such
matters as superintendent of the First Church Sabbath
School, (in which place he has continued faithful until this day).
Mr. Sheley refused, saying, wisely, " Let those, who have confi-
dence in the thing, take charge of it." Consequently, Messrs.
Sylvester Larned and Samuel Zug were elected joint superintend-
ents of the school, the former being called the " Aaron," and the
latter the " Moses " of the Exodus.
The first records of the school show that, on the twelfth of
November, A. D. 1848, there were present, superintendents Sylves-
ter Larned, Samuel Zug; also. Miss Delia Mather, Teacher of the
infant class. Miss Isabella G. Duffield, (now Mrs. Or. Morse Stew-
art,) Mrs. A. E. Mather, Miss Laura Brisco, Miss Harriet Bond.
Miss Cherry Wier, Miss Roberts, Miss Norton, Mrs. Kellogg,
Messrs. Alexander McFarren, John Stevens, William Hannorth,
S. P. Wilcox, and seventy-six children. Of these, Mr. Samuel P.
FORT STREET PRESBYTERIAN CHURCH. 59
Wilcox alone remains in the school ; and of him it is not too
much to say, he has ever been at his post of duty. He has so
deported himself towards all the superintendents, as to make them
regard him as their true friend.
Mr Larned continued in the school only a short time, but on
account of failing health, went south, leaving the superintendency
entirelv in the hands of Mr. Zug. He bore the burden and heat
of the day, and the work prospered under his management. At
the end of three years he resigned The teachers urged upon
him the importance of his remaining in office; he kindly but positive-
ly declined to serve them any longer in that capacity. He advised
the election of Henry C- Knight, then a teacher in the school.
Flis advice was accepted, and Mr. H. C. Knight became the super-
intendent. Mr. Zug took Mr. Knight's class, and continued as a
faithful worker and teacher in the school many years. His sym-
pathy and attention are now turned towards another mission field
of labor, still farther west in our beloved city, north of Michigan
Avenue.
Henry C. Knight was born in East Bethlehem Township,
Washington County, Pa., September 3d, 1817. He was a loving
and dutiful son, and early in life won the confidence and affection
of his youthful companions, and was respected and trusted by all
who knew him. He loved books and study, and so diligently did
he devote himself to them, that in 1836 he graduated at Jefiferson
College. He studied law in Boston. Mass. one year ; came to Detroit
and was admitted to the bar in 1839, when but twenty-two years of
age. He soon thereafter removed to Pontiac, where he practiced
law until 1848, when he gave up the law for the ministry. In 185 1,
he removed to this city, having reluctantly given up the ministry
on account of the failure of his voice. He again resumed the
practice of law, and was ever the faithful advocate and friend of
the poor and oppressed — without regard to recompense or reward.
He remembered that He, in whom alone there is salvation, had
said : *' Inasmuch as ye have done it unto one of the least of
these my brethren, ye have done it unto me." Men soon learned
to trust him. and his fellow-citizens called him to fill many places
of trust and honor. He was Alderman, member of the Board of
Education, Regent of the State University of Michigan, and, at
the time of his death. Prosecuting Attorney for the County of
60 TWENTY-FIFTH ANNIVEESAEY
Wayne. He was the uncorrupted, and ever faithful public ser-
vant. When chosen superintendent of the Sabbath School, he
entered upon the work with all his heart. Mr. Knight loved chil-
dren, and they soon learned to love him. There is no power like
love to win the young to a life of obedience to law and usefulness
in the world. He continued in the good work as superintend-
ent, for sixteen years, until his death, in the spring of 1867.
" Blessed are the dead who die in the Lord ; they rest from their
labors, and their works do follow them."
Joseph G. Ray was chosen, after the death of our beloved
brother. Henry C. Knight, to fill the place thus made vacant. Mr.
Ray was born of missionary parents, in Islington, near London,
England, 1832. He came with his parents to this country, and
settled in Rochester. N. Y., 1841 ; removed to Michigan and made
his home in Detroit, about the year 1853. He was a good boy,
and became an honest and upright man. He inherited from his
godly mother, a remarkable sweetness of temper, amiability of
disposition, and gentleness of manner, which, when permeated
with the spirit of his Divine Master, made him a most faithful
and efficient worker in the vineyard of the Lord. He won the
esteem and love of us all, but on account of his nearness of sight,
he resigned the superintendency in October, 1869, and took
a class in the school. He was ever the faithful friend of his suc-
cessor in office. Mr. Ray was a sun-beam in the school. Who
does not remember how he came into the room singing, and as he
would stop, saying, " I feel like singing all the time "? His work
here and with us was soon ended. His Lord called him up higli-
er. Truly, '' God moves in a mysterious way." Of our departed,
sainted brother, it may truly be said : " Well done, good and faith-
ful servant."
His friend, Bradford Smith, who succeeded him, did what he
could during three years, to advance the permanent interests of
the school.
In January, 1873, Mr. E. C. Walker was elected superintend-
ent, and still continues to hold the office. The school is in a
prosperous condition. Mr. Walker needs no one to write his his-
tory for him, for he has been compelled, in giving the history of the
church, to be his own ^''auto-biographer^'' which has been faithfully
done. I may add, however, he has been identified with the work
of the school, for about twenty years.
FORT STREET PRESBYTERIAN CHURCH. 61
^\\e '^im I^iV>i'ki'y of tlie ^dliool.
About a dozen little girls met at the house of Mrs. Zug in the
winter of 1S49, and organized themselves into a sewing society, to
work for benevolent and religious causes. They determined first
of all to raise money to buy a small library for the school.
Accordingly, they went to work in earnest to make fancy articles
for a fair. They made a complete success. Their generous
frientls, one of wiiom it is distinctly remembered was ('aptain E.
V,. Ward, attended their fair, and soon bought them all out. They
raised, to their surprise and great gratification, one hundred dol-
lars. Of this sum, they took twenty-five dollars and bought their
longed-for library, and the remaining seventy-five dollars they
appropriated to purchase materials for further benevolent enter-
prises, connected with the church and Sunday School.
During these twenty-five years, the school has increased from
year to year, and numbered at one time between 400 and 500
teachers and scholars ; our average has been about 250. Three
"Missions" have been off-shoots from us; and many of their
most faithful and devoted teachers were some of our own most
self-sacrificing workers.
The Ninth Avenue " Mission," of which our Congregational
brother, D. M. Richardson, is superintendent, and our Scotch
Presbyterian friend, Mr. F. Lambie, is the bible class teacher, took
off from us at one time about 200 children. We bade them "God
speed " in their labors of love. Christ's kingdom is progressive
and aggressive. His last command to His disciples, "Co ye unto
all the world and preach the gospel to every creature," should be
heeded. Let the churches of Jesus Christ plant " Missions." and
nourish them, till they are fairly established in the community
where they are located.
•p^iHiit^^ of tlic Work.
We find, from a careful examination of the imperfect records,
that at least 120 children and youth have united with our own
church on profession of faith, from the Sabbath School, while
many others have joined sister churches in the city ; and may we
not hope that many more, if not all who have been with us so
long in this most interesting relation, if not members of the visi-
«
62 TWENTY-FIFTH ANNIVERSAET
ble church here, may become citizens of the heavenly kingdom.
Some of the dear lambs of the Hock have been taken from us by
the Good Shepherd to His fold above. And while our hearts
have been almost crushed by the blow of separation, still, when
we realized that it was given by our Heavenly Father's hand, and
that He has taken the little pets to His divine love and care, we
have, as we hope, been able to say, " Even so, Father, for so it
seemed good in Thy sight."
When this changing life, with its cares, duties, trials, tempta-
tions, hopes, fears, joys and sorrows, is ended, may we have the
unspeakable pleasure and eternal satisfaction of a glorious re-un-
ion with the dear ones we so loved, whose memory is so sacred,
who have gone before and are now on the "shining shore," wait-
in^T, as we trust, to welcome us to the heavenly mansions which
our blessed Saviour has gone to prepare for His faithful followers.
Pfe^eiit Offidef^ ai|d l^ekdl^ef^.
E. C. Walker, Superintendent.
S P. Wilcox, Assistant Superintendent.
Robert M. Zug, Secretary and Treasurer.
Robert W. Standart, Librarian.
Bradford Smith, Teacher Bible Class.
Geo. W. Hoffman, Teacher Bible Class.
Mrs. H. C Knight, Teacher Infant Class.
Miss Jennie Wilson, Teacher Infant Class.
Messrs. George N. Ladue, Charles B. Woodruff, Lucien
E. Smith, James R. Button, Walter Buhl, Otto Kirchner,
Henry M. Park, John McFarlane.
Miss Julia A. Knight, Miss Mary Penny, Miss Jennie A.
FooTE, Miss Sarah H. Standart, Miss Mary L. Orr, Miss
Mary C Brewster, Miss Mattie Joy, Miss Cora Woodruff,
Miss Anna Botsford.
Mrs. A. G. Lindsay, Mrs. Geo. F. Newland, Mrs. S. P.
Wilcox, Mrs. H. M, Park, Mrs. Margaret E. Hodgkin, Mrs.
M. F. Merick, Mrs. Henry Graham.
At the conclusion of these interesting historical papers, the hour
was so late, that the exercises were at once concluded with the
benediction by the Rev. John P. Scott, pastor of the United Pres-
byterian Church, of this city.
FORT STREET PRESBYTERIAK CHURCH. 63
Was introduced by prayer, offered by the Rev. S. M. Freeland, of
the Second Congregational Church, of this city.
The pastor, acting as chairman for the evening, then e.xjjlained
the absence of the Rev. John Hall, 1). D., of New York City, who
was e.\pected to have been present, and to have preached on the
evening previous, but who was detained at home by the religious
interest prevalent throughout the city, and by the consequent mul-
tiplied services in connection with his own church.
Letters of congratulation were then read from the widow of
the Rev. R. R. Kellogg, first pastor of the church, from the Rev.
Henry Neill, D. D., Rev. Azariah Eldridge, D. D., and Rev. Sam-
uel Taylor Clarke, successive pastors ; from the brother of Rev.
James Means, who acted for a time in the same capacity, and
from the Rev. S. D. Burchard, D. D., of New York City, under whose
preaching and pastoral care, Mr. Pierson himself passed his youth.
These letters, with others, will appear in their proper place, in
subsequent pages.
Short congratulatory addresses were then delivered by various
brethren, who were introduced with brief, appropriate remarks,
by the chairman. Much that was said cannot be re-produced,
and much, that might be preserved, naturally dies with the occa-
sion, as the aroma of a flower ceases to exhale when the blossom
fades. But so much was said which contributes to the history of
tlie period commemorated on this day, and which evidences and
exemplifies the unity of all true christians, and inspires enlarged
effort and enterprise in the cause of Christ, that we have secured
from each of the several speakers, an outline of his remarks, by
which we are thus enabled to complete our otherwise imperfect
record of this pleasurable and memorable anniversary.
Coiigfkturatoi'y s^ddfe^^e^.
The chairman said : " Our first speaker this evening, is our
Detroit bulwark of orthodoxy, a beloved brother, the longest
settled here of any of our city pastors, and who, for fifteen years,
has demonstrated that the preaching of the pure and simple gospel
does not ' dislodge a preacher,' nor wear out. He reminds me of
64 TWENTY-FIFTH ANNIVERSARY
a home missionary in Kansas of whom it was said, that ' he kept
teUing men that they were sinners and needed a Saviour, until they-
actually believed it!' 1 take pleasure in introducing the Rev
John P. Scott, of the United Presbyterian Church."
Mr. Scott responded : " From the depths of my heart I thank
my good brother Pierson for the high honor conferred upon me in
representing me as '' the bulwark of orthodoxy in this city." He
could scarcely have done me greater honor, and I do not know
how I can better re-pay him, than to express to you my gratifica-
tion at having such an able and efficient co-laborer in the main-
tenance of orthodox principles. I will not say anything about
these other brethren, but will assume that they are not present,
and say to you that any doxy that does not agree with our doxy,
is not ortho-doxy. We were told this afternoon in that very inter-
esting paper read by Mr. Walker, that this congregation worshipped
at first in the church building in which the congregation to which
I minister, now worships ; perhaps that is what has caused this
congregation to flourish so well ; it had a good orthodox begin-
ning. We have been watching you with a special interest to see
whether you would remain steadfast to the faith, and are happy
this evening to congratulate you on your theological, congrega-
tional and financial status; and as you have done so well for the
quarter of a century that is past, I think you may be safely trusted
in the future, especially so long as you have such an orthodox
leader as my brother Pierson : and these orthodox men are not
given to frequent change, either as to location or theological
views ; they stand on such a firm basis, that they stand very steady ;
they build long and they build strong.
" I thought this afternoon when listening to that very minute
and interesting review of your history as a congregation for a
quarter of a century, how full that same period had been of events
of the highest importance to the church at large — to this nation
and to all the nations of the earth.
" Within this period the foundations of our government have
been tested as we did not expect; and severe as the test was, we
have demonstrated to the hereditary rulers and crowned monarch-
ists of the world, that there is a central power in republicanism
that they had not dreamed of; and during the same i)eriod the
church has made aggressions on the territory of the enemy great-
FORT STREET PRESBYTERIAN CHURCH. 65
er, I believe, than during any previous quarter of a century since
the days of Christ and His apostles. In proof of this, we need
only to consider what has been done for the spread of the gospel
in India, and China, and Egypt, and Spain, and Italy, and
Turkey, and Mexico, and in other nations. In many of these
countries, twenty-five years ago, it required not only a martyr
spirit, but a martyr's head would have been the result of attempt-
ing to distribute the Bible or to preach the glad tidings of salvation ;
but during this period, barrier after barrier has been removed ;
tyrannical and wicked laws against the dissemination of christian
truth, and the proclamation pf the gospel, have been rescinded ;
prejudices removed ; and treaties formed between nations ; until
now the missionaries of the cross from the two great christian nations
of the world, can go, with the assurance of protection, and preach
the gospel throughout the wide world. The way being now open,
we may expect glorious results.
'' But the services of this occasion demand that we should con-
sider specially the past and present religious condition of our own
city; and what are the facts? Twenty-five years ago, with a popu-
lation of twenty thousand, we had nineteen churches, nearly one
church organization to each one thousand inhabitants. We have
now one hundred thousand inhabitants and fifty- nine churches —
almost two thousand inhabitants to each church organization.
Some of these churches are large and strong, but many of them
are small and feeble ; thus, while the population has increased
five-fold, the churches have only increased three-fold ; and, as
to church accommodations, were all the population disposed to
attend some place of public worship, there would not be church
accommodations for more than one in five of the inhabitants.
"Is this as it should he? Shall we remain indifferent and
inactive in view of these facts ? Does not the comparative increase
in population over the increase in churches, and the large numbers
of our population who do not attend any place of public worship,
and who could not be accommodated if they did desire to attend,
call for increased activity, and devotion, and zeal upon the part of
the officers and members of the various churches in our city.?
Let us consecrate ourselves afresh to the work and service of our
Master, in this city."
66 TWENTY-FIFTH AJSTNIVERSART
Chairman : " In the year 1867, in the General Assembly of the
Old School Presbyterian Church at Cincinnati, I heard an elder
deliver a long and elaborate speech, and I felt like the Scotch-
man, who joined the debating club because he ^ wanted to contra-
dict a wee !' But I have since learned to sympathise with that
brother and love him, as one of the most trustworthy of men, and
to understand why the farmer called his team ' new school ' and
' old school,' saying that 'one horse was fast and the other sa/e, but
both together made a splendid span.' We will now hear from the
Hon. Hovey K. Clarke-"
Mr. Clarke, after some playful allusions to his impressions of
Mr. Pierson in that same Assembly, proceeded to say : " I believe
in anniversaries. They have their uses, and some of them are
valuable. Even the sad ones have lessons in them which we
cannot afford to lose. They have their abuses, too, sometimes
most conspicuous in religious observances. When the Saints'
days and Fast days of the year become more numerous than the
Sabbaths, and are observed with more devotion, we may conclude
that the anniversary business is overdone. But of all events which
have their origin in associated action, I am sure that there are
none more worthy of commemoration, than the founding of a
church.
"' The evil that men do,' says the great English poet, 'lives
after them.' In an ever-widening circle, it extends and perpetu-
ates itself. No fact can be more solemn than this. I would fain
believe that some of tlie evil which some men do is obliterated in
the blood of Christ ; otherwise, it seems to me that there must be
reflections, even in the world above, closely akin to remorse.
'The good is often interred with their bones:' — but not always;
for the blessed dead are assured when they rest from their labors,
that " their works do follow them " There may be some who
now, from the spirit world, are permitted to mingle in the rejoic-
ings of this occasion, and who were in that little company, gathered
in the Senate Chamber of the old Capitol., on the fourth Sabbath
in February, twenty-five years ago, to found this church ! And
are there not, among the experiences by which this church has
been led to its present position, some to be most gratefully remem-
bered, and which are the last that the brethren of that company —
two of whom I see before me — Zug and Wilcox — would relinquish .''
FORT STREET PRESBYTERIAN CHURCH. 67
" But I am not permitted to extend these reflections. What
is the lesson of the hour? is the question. This building is a
power. This congregation — tiie mcMi and women who compose it,
and the means they command — is a power. This pastor is a pow-
er; and in all, there is an aggregate involving a great responsibili-
ty. It is in your hands — what are you going to do loith it ? The
usefulness of a church is to be measured, not by what is does, or
is capable of doing for its members ; but by what it stimulates its
members to do for others. Colonization is the lesson which the
facts before us this evening are teaching the Presbyterian Church-
es of Detroit. Colonization— '^\\'tx^\(S.t, Grand Trunk Junction,
Ilamtramck — unless we see our duty to these localities, we shall
miss the most striking and important lesson of this most interest-
ing occasion."
Chairman: "When our Congregational neighbors on Fort
Street wanted to get a pastor, they took good care to choose one
whose preaching must be to edification ! All I have against this
brother is that he is a Congregationalist. but he is so near a Pres-
byterian that we can hardly tell the difference; and I will only
remind him that Congregationalism, like .•Jew Hampshire is a
'good State to go from ! ' Let us hear from the edifyitig pastor of
the Fort Street Congregational Church, Rev. Zachary Eddy, D. D.''
Dr. Eddy spoke as follows : " I have been courteously intro-
duced by the pastor, as a Congregationalist; but I would thank
some friend to decide the question, whether I ought to be called
a Congregationalist or a Presbyterian. My father was a Congre-
gational minister, and the pastor of a Congregational church, but
at the same time a member of Buffalo Presbytery. In my early
youth I became a member of the same Congregational church,
which was represented by delegates in the Presbytery, and once
or twice furnished lay commissioners to the General Assembly. I
was ordained in the Presbyterian church, was for several years a
member of Presbytery ; but was also, for some time, the pastor of
a Congregational church, and the scrib- of a Congregational
Association. The truth is, in those days, many of us scarcely
knew whether we were Congregationalists or Presbyterians; for
it was in the time of the glorious old " Plan of Union," whose
memory is blessed.
" In those days I loved the Presbyterian church ; but not more
68 TWENTY-FIFTH AISTNIVEKSAKY
than I love it now. When I was a raw, undisciplined youth, I
was tenderly taken in hand by the noble Presbytery of Buffalo,
trained, encouraged and started on my career as a minister, not
without prayers and benedictions. Till my heart stops beating, I
can never cease to love the great orthodox, learned, orderly and
evangelical Body, under whose cherishing and genial nurture, I
passed the earlier years of my ministry.
" This is not the time to boast of it, but I cannot help saying
that, though our revered and beloved Dr. Shaw did not mention
my name this morning as one of the " noble company " of Pres-
byterian martyrs, I had the honor to suffer in the cause of genu-
ine 'Constitutional' Presbyterianism. In 1837, my head was
taken off so neatly, by the Breckenridge guillotine, that I felt no
pain. I was a member, at that time, of one of the four exscinded
synods. For a considerable period after that event, I, with many
of my brethren, stood aloof from both Assemblies, almost ready
to say — ' A plague on both your houses !' I must confess, that the
excision quickened the love of the free Congregational Order,
which my revered father had planted in my heart, but which had,
for several years, been in a state of suspended animation. With a
true, but not idolatrous love of that Order, T now recognize, with
filial affection, in the re-united Presbyterian Church, the spiritual
alma mater of my youth. God bless the Presbyterian Church in
the United States !
"And God bless the Fort Street Presbyterian Church, of
Detroit ! Though I am a new comer among you — almost a strang-
er, indeed — I enter heartily into your joy, and offer my sincere
congratulations on this twenty-fifth birth-day of your church.
You will permit me to say, that I rejoice in your prosperity, not
so much because yours is a Presbyterian church, as because it is,
in my belief, a living and fruitful church of Jesus Christ. The
value of a true church to such a city as this, cannot be told. Its
purifying and beneficent influences can only be measured by the
Omniscient One. For what is a christian church, considered with
reference to the work which God has given it to do } A hospital
for the cure of sick, death- smitten souls; a fold for the protec-
tion and safe-keeping of the weak and unwary ; a school for the
nurture of christian disciples; a gymnasium for the training of
spiritual athletes, to wrestle with principalities and powers; a
FORT STREET PRESBYTERIAN CHURCH. 69
FELLOWSHIP OF LOVE, satisfying the social cravings of rich and poor,
of old and young, of rude and cultured ; a fountain of reno-
vating VIRTUE, sending streams of moral purity and health
through all the ramifications of society, cleansing and hallowing
the household, the drawing-room, the workshop, the school, the
court of justice, the ballot-box, the political caucus, the municipal
assembly, and the legislative chamber. The church is a camp of
INSTRUCTION for drilling the soldiers of the sacramental host, in
all the arts and exercises of glorious war, and sending them forthi
armed in panoply divine, to conquer new provinces for King
Immanuel. The church is to raise the fallen, succor the tempted,
heal the broken-hearted, visit the sick, feed the hungry, clothe the
naked, care for the widow and the fatherless, point the heavy-laden
sinner to the Lamb of God, and the dying saint to the open gates
of ' Jerusalem, the golden.' Such is the work of the church —
your work, my brethren. In the belief that you are, with a good
degree of earnestness, doing this work, I wish you all joy, and bid
you God speed ! May your future be more prosperous and fruit-
ful than your past ! May floods of grace descend from the open
windows of heaven, on this beloved church ! "
Chairman : " There is another brother here whom Ave have all
learned to respect and love, as filling out the Miltonian concep-
tion of a man, 'fitted to .perform justly, skillfully and magnani-
mously all the offices, both public and private, of peace and war,
in church and state.' He was prominently instrumental in bring-
ing about the re-union of our beloved Presbyterian church ; and
if there be any man, whom I should like to have near my dying
bed, and whose hand I should like to grasp in a dying hour, it is
he, in whom we all recognize a bulwark of integrity^ the Hon.
Jacob S. Farrand."
Mr. Farrand then said : " Twenty-five years is not long in
the life of a church. It is long in the life of an individual who
has grown to manhood — twenty-five years ago Dr. Duffield was in
the full strength of his manhood, wielding that intellectual and
moral power, that has and will continue to make his name a strong
tower, and a fragrant memory forever. Then, Rev. Dr. R. W.
Patterson had been here on his return from his first trip east of
the AUeghanies, and had preached in the old hive several weeks,
70 TWENTY-FIFTH ANNIVERSARY
and had just commenced his life work in Chicago, which has
given his church great renown, and made him illustrious; but the
past has been so fully gone over to-day, that it may be well to
look a moment at the future.
" When you celebrate your fiftieth anniversary, Detroit will
contain a half-million of inhabitants, and we, as christians, can
measure our responsibility by this statement.
" The gospel will then be preached in all the lands and lan-
guages of the earth.
" The christian religion will not only have broken down all
obstacles in its spread, but will have established, through a con-
gress of nations, a common currency ; weights and measures,
universally recognised and used by mankind ; and the swiftly-
moving shuttle of commerce, under its influence, will have woven
a seamless robe for our race.
'' I believe in the universal Fatherhood of God, and the uni-
versal Brotherhood of man."
Chairman : " The next speaker is one, in whose calm, clear
judgment, large experience, varied learning, and theological
soundness, we have all been accustomed implicitly to confide.
We look upon him as a brother, while we look up to him as a
father. You remember the good old Scotch woman who, in send-
ing her sons into the wide world, said to them, ' Lads, if ye can
find a lassie, that can make p:;ude butter, sing aiild hundred and say
the catechism, why lads, ye may bring her alang ! ' vSome such
mother must have had the training of the Rev. J. F. McLaren, D.
D."
Dr. McLaren said : " However many good deeds may have
been done by others, there is, always, some good left for us to do.
But, really, after the many good things said on this pleasant occa-
sion to-day, there appears to be little left for the rest of us to say.
So, at least, it seems from my point of view. But I am open to
the contrary conviction, when the other brethren shall have spok-
en. Indeed, my conviction has been, already^ somewhat shaken
by those who have preceded me. this evening.
" This day has been called the silver wedding-day of the Fort
Street Church. I reckon it to be, rather, a birth-day celebration.
I like such memorial days in a church. They give special oppor-
FORT STREET PRESBYTERIAN CHURCH. 71
tiinity, not only for recounting the Lord's providential favors and
tlie triumphs of His grace, but also for bringing to grateful remem-
brance those persons, sleeping in Christ, who have been, while
living, His faithful and exemplaiy followers. We have many
examples of such reminiscences in the Bible; as in the 105th and
106th Psalms, and in the nth chapter of Hebrews.
" Dr. Shaw this morning told us about the noble army of mar-
tyrs. Let us remember that, in our churches, if we have not
martyrs, we have confessors ; and Fuller well says, '« confessor is
a martyr in bullion, wanting only the stamp of a violent death to
be impressed upon it.'
" How many cases of faith and love, shown in christian
patience and christian activity, the Lord has given to His church.
These should not fade away from our remembrance. There is
much material of this kind, honoring to God and helpful to piety,
which we leave unused in our common Sabbath discourses.
English poe"ts never tire of allusions to the lark of their country,
rising from its lowly nest, singing as it ascends higher and higher,
till its sweet notes reach the ear after the form is no longer visible
to the eye. So, many a christian's song of faith and hope and
joy, as they ascend to heaven, leaves its sweet tones echoing in our
hearts, long after their persons have disappeared from our sight,
i^et them be remembered, to strengthen our trust in Christ, to
brighten our hopes, to stimulate our activity.
*' Twenty-five years old ! That seems pretty old — not to me.
I was a minister for twenty years, before this church was born.
But a good deal has been done for Christ's cause in this city,
during this quarter of a century. There are five limes as many
people here, as there were twenty-five years ago ; and there are
five times as many Presbyterian congregations, of our order: and
these others, as good Presbyterians as ourselves, and still more
who, though not so good Presbyterians, are as good christians.
The multiplicity, or even the variety, of churches does not prove
that we have different religions. Evangelical churches, holding
essentially the same faith, ha\e multiplied hopefully in these twen-
ty-five years. So many churches, with faithful men in the over-
sight of them, are a blessing beyond computation, to this city.
The ancient Patristic rule, still followed by some, was one over-
seer or bishop in one city. The more ancient, apostolic rule was,
72 TWENTY-FIFTH ANNIVERSART
to have as many as were needed to feed the flock over which the
Holy Ghost had placed them. This rule, we and most of the
Protestant churches, follow, as did the church of Ephesus. whose
Presbyter bishops Paul met at Miletus, and as did also the church
of Philippi, which he addressed, by letter, together with their
bishops and deacons.
"While we rejoice with all the churches that honor Christ and
His truth, we especially, here and now, congratulate this congre-
gation and its pastor, and the Presbyters associated with him in
the oversight of the flock."
Chairman : '' I had expected next to introduce to you our
beloved brother from the Jefferson Avenue Presbyterian Church,
the Hon. Elisha Taylor; who would have probably entertained us
with an account of his experiences as a committee of supply for that
vacant pulpit. I have been told that, so numerous have been the
letters received by him from aspiring candidates, that he medi-
tates establishing z. paper manufactory, to use up the waste material.
'' Inasmuch as he is detained by illness, I have been asking
whom I might best put in his place ; and I think, were the matter
put to vote, you would unanimously say that we must have a few
words from our venerable and beloved friend, the Rev. James B.
Shaw, D. D."
Dr. Shaw : " First of all, let me help Dr. Eddy out of his
dilemma. He said he hardly knew whether he was a Congrega-
tionalist or a Presbyterian, or whether he might not be both.
Now the fact is, my good brother is too big — there is too much of
him — for any one church to monopolize. We all own an interest
in him. We all claim him as part of our spiritual patrimony.
" And now I feel constrained to say, that the pastor of this
Fort Street Church has been a regular problem for me. I have
been puzzled to know for what the Lord made and meant him. A
few years since he delivered a poem in Rochester which met with
great favor, and then I thought that the Lord meant him to be a
poet. Not long after, I read some profound articles of his, on
Aristotle, and then I thought that the Lord meant him for a phi-
losopher. When I saw his Report on Music, which the General
Assembly of 1867 was so glad to accept and publish, and know-
ing, at the same time, how skillfully he played and how sweetly
FOKT STREET PRESBYTERIAN fllURCII. 73
he sang, I was ([uite sure that the Lord sent him into the world to
look after the service of song, and see that His church in this
respect did not bring Him any more vain oblations. But, on
looking the whole matter over, I have concluded that he was
intended for something better than any or all these, — that he was
intended to be just what he is, a preacher and pastor.
" A brother, who gave us an excellent speech this evening, was
introduced to the audience as the bulwark of orthodoxy in
Detroit. He is the oldest pastor in the city, having been over the
same church fifteen years. Now I do not set up any claim to
being a bulwark of. orthodoxy, but perhaps I may be allowed to
say, that on the first Sabbath of last December, I celebrated my
thirty-third anniversary. When I first went to the city of Roches-
ter. I was then pale and broken in health. I had to put on an
overcoat, to cast a respectable shadow. The church, up to my
going, had never been able to retain a pastor any length of time.
My immediate predecessor was one of the Beecher family, with
his full share of the hereditary genius of that tribe in Israel, and
he stayed less than two years. The wisest man in the city, a man
regarded as an oracle, said that I would not stay a year. Every-
body thought that I was installed over a capped volcano, and
some, no doubt, were disappointed because the predicted
eruption did not take place. More than once I have told my
people, that, if they had known how long I meant to stay,
they never would have given me such a unanimous call. They
said to themselves, his health is so poor that if we should
make a bad bargain, he will not trouble us long ; and yet,
I have entered on the thirty-fourth year of my ministry. My
continuance there is a wonder unto many, and a still greater won-
der to me. But, 1 can give you a key which will unlock the mys-
tery. Immediately after my installation, overwhelmed with a
sense of my utter insufficiency, I called the church together and
besought them never to draw nigh unto God without remember-
ing how poor and weak a man had been sent to serve them. In
the closet, before the altar, in the house, at the place of prayer,
and when the great congregation came together, I begged them
with tears in my eyes, to remember me. I told them that they
could make me just such a minister as they wanted me to be ;
that it would be their own fault if in any respect I came short of
74 TWENTY-FIFTH ANNIVEKSART
their expectations ; that if I were not right they could pray me
right, and they took me at my word ; they have remembered me.
Scarcely a prayer is ever offered at any of our meetings, in which
the pastor is not mentioned. Your hearts to-day, dear friends,
are full of prophetic hopes, and you can more than make those
hopes good. Never go to the Throne of the Heavenly Grace,
without taking this dear brother with you. Remember him as my .
dear flock has remembered me. Whatever else you may deny
your pastor, I beg you on my bended knees, I beg you, not to
deny him a place in your prayers. A praying people, will make
a permanent pastorate. The whole thing is in your own hands."
Chairman : " There are confessed disadvantages in the sys-
tem of ministerial itineracy, as was exemplified in the little girl
who, being asked where she was born, replied : ''leant tell ; my
father was a Methodist minister, you kiioti.' ! ' But one compen-
sating advantage of the system is, that each point in the periphery
of the great wheel of rotation returns to its original place, eventu-
ally, and if a man only holds on to the wheel long enough, it will
drop him where he lodged before. And so we can forgive Metho-
dist rotation for having removed, since it has returned io our city,
the Rev. L. R. Fiske, D. D , of the Central Methodist Church,
whom I introduce as our next speaker."
Rev Dr. Fiske : "Mr. Chairman — I am glad of the privilege
of presenting my personal gratulations on this joyous and festive
occasion; and also that I am able to assure you of the very kind-
ly feelings of the body of christians with whom I am more inti-
mately associated. The history, to which I have listened to-day,
has greatly interested me. 1 see that you have had a feeble
infancy, a troublous childhood, but a growing youth ; and that
now, at the age of twenty-five, in your greater maturity, you have
become strong— strong financially, strong numerically, and I trust,
strong spiritually. The future will certainly show bra\e, noble,
and successful work for the Master.
"As I have attended your exercises during the day, and now
unite with you in the festivities of the evening, 1 have said to
myself that I am glad we are not thrown back fifty years in the
history of the church. You would not then have invited me
here ; but if for any reason you had done so, I surely would have
FOUT STREET PRESBYTERIAN CHURCH.
hesitated a long time before accepting the invitation. Could a
Calvinibt and Arminian meet without breaking swords.' To have
had a Methodist with you, would have been decidedly out of
character; and would he not have been (X)mmitting sin by endors-
ing a Calvinistic gathering.'
" 1 am not going to say we are better than our fatiiers. There
were noble men in those days — strong, bra\e, of intense convic-
tions of right — men who would risk everything in defense of right,
as it appeared to them. But this led to war, for reciprocal dis-
trust ])ervaded the different wings of the christian army, and
sometimes they fought each other more than the common foe.
This however I do say, that the gospel is preached more in love
than it formerly was, and hence we get a jnirer and richer gos])el.
Denominationalism is being reduced to a minimum, and Christ, as
the Head of our undivided church, is being exalted.
" But I must not forget that I am, after all, in a Presbyterian
meeting this evening, and ought not to feel that 1 am standing
strictly on a common platform. .\nd yet somehow I have an
impression that 1 have a right to be here, as much as some of you.
1 remember hearing the chairman of this meeting say that, when
he was converted, he united with the Methodist church. You see
he must have "'fa/Ir// from i(race," for he subsequently joined the
Presbyterians. Is not this case alone sufficient to establish the
Methodist doctrine of falling from grace .^ I had a Presbyterian
mother and hence did not "fall from grace,' but have remained in
the Methodist church all my life. Our venerable friend. Dr.
Shaw, has discoursed to us eloijuently to-day upon the martyr
spirit. Mav I not i)ut in a claim in this direction ? With a Pres-
byterian mother, a Presbyterian brother, three Presbyterian sisters,
a Scotch Presbyterian wife— Presbyterian, until I proselyted her into
the Methodist church, a Presbyterian mother-in-law. Presbyterian
brothers and sisters-in-law, Presbyterian grand-parents on both
sides, and Presbyterian ancestry extending back to the time where-
in the memory of man runneth not to the contrary — to stem all
this Presbyterian influence and remain a steadfast Methodist, must
not a man display the martyr spirit ; and does not such a case
illustrate the doctrine of the '' perseverance of the saints}"
" But, to speak soberly, the grand feature of this age is that
with the minor differences among the sects, the churches are
76 TWENTY-FIFTH ANNIVERSAEY
becoming thoroughly joined in heart. Distrust is being scattered
to the winds, and it thus seems to me that the millenium with its
glories is hastening on.
" In behalf of the Methodist church — no, I take that back — in
behalf of our common Christianity which knows neither Metho-
dist, nor Presbyterian, but only Jesus Christ and Him crucified, I
bid this church God speed. May the next twenty-five years see
thousands of penitents at this altar, and witness the rejoicing of
thousands of converts saved through the blood of the Lamb.
May many in heaven have it to say that just here is the one
precious place on this earth, because it was here they were born
into the family of God."
Chairman ; " I understand that, on the recent visit of an English
prince to this land, Duncan Stewart, Esq., of this city, caused one
of his vessels to bear aloft this beautiful motto : ' Welcome, laddie,
for t/iy fnit/ier's sake I ' lam sure that, aside from his personal
merits, and all other considerations, we should all welcome, for
his father s sake, the son of Rev. Dr. Dufifield, whom this church
still looks back to as its spiritual father. I introduce D. Bethune
Dufifield, Esq., of this city."
" Mr. Dufifield said : " Mr. Chairman — After all that has fallen
on our ears to-day, there are none of us who do not feel that * the
light of other days ' is about us. As we turn our vision back to
the Detroit of twenty-five years ago, we behold, not the stately
stores and well paved avenues of to-day, but the muddy streets
and wooden shells of buildings that then were almost universally
occupied for mercantile purposes; and as my mind's eye looks
back upon the edifice of the 'Mother Church,' of which we
have heard so much to-day, I see it lifting itself in almost moun-
tain-like proportions among the fragile and lowly tenements around
it. It was an attractive building in the interior, and not without
impressiveness in the exterior. Built by Alanson Sheley, Esq., in
the days when material was abundant and labor cheap, and con-
tractors honest and fair in their dealing, its entire cost did not
exceed $30,000 ; yet it was an admirable structure. I wish all
our Presbyterian churches of to-day could boast of equally liber-
al aisles ; equally ample galleries, with pannelled fronts running
round all three sides of the building; as neat a pulpit; as fine an
FORT stre?:t pkesbyterian church.
organ ; as sweet a choir; and above all, as grand a congregation.
1 look into it to-night as it first opened to my view, more than
thirty years ago. and see its pastor, then but forty-five years of
.age, in his early prime, and with a congregation around him sel-
dom equalled in any community. There were United States Sena-
tors, Members of Congress, the Governor of the State, the State
Treasurer, Auditor General, and Secretary of State. There were
United States, and Supreme, and Circuit Court Judges, and a large
l)roportion of one of the most cultivated Bars that could be found
west of Albany There were Officers and Paymasters of the army ;
active merchants (some of whom have since become merchant
jirinces), master mechanics, well represented by that sterling old
giant of a man, Turner Stetson, (a giant in form, but graced as a
christian, with the humility of a child), besides scores of other
men representing the various avocations and industries of life.
And in all that crowded congregation, there was scarcely one gray
head to be seen ; all were men in the prime of youth or the
strength of middle life, and all, or nearly all, hailing from other
States than the one in which they had staked their chances for the
future.
" Its then bench of elders — now all gone save one (Mr. Hallock)
— was a very imposing body of men. Many here present can
recall with me the white cravat, and the stern, determined expres-
sion that frowned over it from the shaggy eye-brows of Robert
Stuart; the bland and smiling countenance of Eurotas P. Hast-
ings; the grim, 1812 look of Major Jonathan Kearsley ; the
solemn mien of David French ; the gentle and sincere face of the
ever reliable Edward Bingham ; the honored face of the soldier
Larned ; the generally anxiovis look of Thomas J. Hulbert ; the
strong and earnest countenance of Horace Hallock, Superintend-
ent of the Sunday School; and the rough but honest Scottish
brogue of the large-hearted Alexander McFarren." (Here Mr. D.
related an interesting incident showing the generous sympathy of
Elder McFarren with young men, and his ready benevolence
toward all who needed a helping hand.) "They were truly an
extraordinary band of earnest, christian men, and the impress
they have left on this community, will not soon die out.
"But the old church went down in the fire of January, 1854,
and thereafter three churches sprang. Phoenix-like, from its ashes
78 TWENTY-FIFTH AJSTNIVERSAKY
— this one on Fort Street being one of the three. I said the old
church was a noble one, and none before me will dispute the asser-
tion, for by its fruits of to-day even the stranger may know what
it must have been. Not only in the city, but throughout the State,
was its influence felt, and to-night we look back upon it with rev-
erence as the Common Mother of us all. God grant that the future
of all her daughters may be more glorious, even than that of the
mother !
"And on this pleasant anniversary of this prosperous church,
we offer not only our congratulations over the past, but our best
wishes for the future. The exercises of the day have been, I
doubt not, inspiring to us all. The noble discourse of the morn-
ing, shedding down upon us as it were, the very fire from heaven,
strengthened us, as in the afternoon, we listened to the roll-call of
your beloved dead ; and grouping the events of the entire day
together, we seemed to be furnished with a fresh testimonial and
a new argument for the reality and beauty of the christian faith.
What, Mr. Chairman, means this elegant bank of flowers, dropped
from milder climes into your winter anniversary, and piled with
such tropical magnificence, to your pulpit's very top .'' Think
you, if Christianity was a mere myth, a rose-colored dream of the
East, we could sit by the graves of our dead, as we have done
to-day with hearts at peace while our eyes were full of tears ? ' If
the dead rise not,' we should not witness anniversaries such as
this has been to-day. If the dreary grave is ' the be all, and the
end all of life,' instead of being here crowned with flowers and
singing the ever-enduring hymns of the christian church, we
should have been seen sitting with dust and ashes upon our heads,
mourning over the departure of those gone out never to return —
the mother's heart rent anew over her dead child ; the wife's over
the absent husband; the father's over the son fallen in battle, and
all voices commingling in the sad chorus of a grief that is forever
barren of hope — bewailing life's sorrows as the heathen bewail
thei)- dead; no wiser, no better off than they. But we know that
'Christ has risen!' and given not Himself only, but all His
followers, an immortal life ! And these lovely flowers lying in
mass, are typical of that life in the land where there is no more
death, and where sorrow and crying shall forever flee away. These
are your tributes to those who have died in the Lord ; these tall
FORT STREET PRESBYTERIAN CHURCH. T9
and graceful Hllies beautifully commemorating the names of the fair,
christian women who have walked and labored among you, and
the remainder, symbolizing the great multitude who have gone
hence during the last twenty-five years, each one having his name
and life thus brought fragrantly into memory.
"Says the (ierman Poet Schiller, 'he who would reap a harvest
of tears upon his gra\ e, must sow the deeds of love' — and that is
just what the christian does. The spirit of love to God in his
heart, insjjires him to deeds of love towards his fellow men. Such
were the lives of your departed dead, and hence these tender tri-
butes of christian love — These friends are not here, their dust
sleeps in Elmwood, but they have risen ! 'This day', (that is the
language of Scripture,) the very day of death, they were with
their Savour, the risen Redeemer, in Paradise ; and while we
weej) that here we see their faces no more, we rejoice that they
have already become citizens of the Heavenly City, the new Jeru-
salem. And now the years below fly swiftly on. Another twenty-
five years and this church will touch its Golden Anniversary. How
many of those into whose faces we now look will be here to share
in its joy.' (iod grant that you all may so live, and when the
>ummons comes, may so die, that when that golden day
shall dawn, each departed member of this church may have
blooming round these altars, his memorial flower, emblem of the
immortal life which is the sole heritage of those who follow Christ."
Chairman : " There are two good things, at least, about our
Baptist friends ; first : they are sound in the faith. They do not tire
of the pure gospel, although 1 did know a Baptist minister once
who told me he had " exhausted the Bible " and was going to preach
the ''''Pilgrims Progress," and I foresaw that both he and his peo-
ple would get stuck in the Slough of Despond, and they did !
However there is no danger of such a catastrophe under the
])reaching of the pastor of the Lafayette Ave. Bajjtist Church.
He don't believe in exhausting the Bible. The second good thing
about our Baptist brethren is they baptize a man all orer, brain,
heart, stomach '' pocket ", — all share the consecration. Let us
hear from my i>ersonal friend Rev. Alfred Owen, D. D. "
Dr. Owen replied : — '*' Circumstances forbade my presence at
the afternoon session, and I have been able to be here this evening
80 TWENTY-FIFTH ANNIVEESAEY
only a few moments ago. I feel that I am not up to the spirit of
the occasion and would gladly have escaped my brother's eye.
And yet I am glad to have the opportunity to give expression
to my deep interest in this church, and my sincere affection for
its pastor. The strength of this place is a common support to all
who cherish the faith of the gospel, and I am sure that here the
truth is uttered fearlessly and faithfully."
" I am glad to be able to congratulate my brethren here on
the wonderful progress so quickly made, and the noble record of
the church in its private and public labor.
" I recognize also the fact that I stand here in a representative
position, to bear to you the fraternal regards and affection of the
body which I have the honor to serve. I am sure no one can do
this more heartily than I, for no one, not even among yourselves,
can feel a greater admiration for the history which the Presbyterian
body has been permitted to make, and no one is more ready to
confess the inestimable value of its service to the world.
In the body of which I am a member and with which I am in
fullest sympathy, perhaps the representative idea of all is liberty ;
by which we do not at all mean license, or anarchy, but simply
the right of each soul, without interference or control from another,
to do the thing which he believes the Lord requires. To interfere
with a man's conscience is to do injury to him, and equally it harms
him who interferes. The time has been when this idea needed all
the prominence that could be given to it, nor is that time yet
wholly gone by.
" At this moment Presbyterianism seems to me to represent
more than anything else, organization in the church, compact, co-
gent. Perhaps circumstances have impressed upon me more than
ever before the value of this. Your growth and power are wonder-
ful. But in any case, we are all brethren of one household. Each
in his own way doing his own work as the Lord has put it in his way
and in each other's prosperity we will alike rejoice. There is no
danger that too much will be done. All that all disciples can do,
is too little for the world which yet sighs and suffers under its
heavy burdens.
'' I may be permitted to add a word in the way of exhortation.
My brethren here have reached a very interesting point in their
history and naturally jjause to survey "the path already trod."
FORT STKEET PRESBYTERIAN CHURCH. 81
If this occasion shall lead you to count your work done, it will
l)c a sorrowful day for you. It will be happy only if it shall
l)e so gratefully remembered as to be an encouragement to new
labors. One who climbs a mountain side, may pause on the way
to gaze on the widening scene that opens to his vision. But he
only stops to refresh himself and gather up his strength for new
toils, ever to continue till the summit is gained. Much of your
work, your greatest work, is yet before you. How much this
great city needs the power of a divine life in the churches. Your
day of refreshing should be truly a memorial of the past mercies
of God, in whose recollection faith and devotion may be quick-
ened for the toil which the future will surely bring upon you. In
this hope I give you my sincere congratulations on your past histo-
ry, and express the earnest hope that for generations to come this
church may remain as now faithful to its calling and zealous in
every good work.
Chairman : " On the western borders of our city, there stands
a new Presbyterian church — an infant enterprise, few as yet in
numbers, but strong in graces. When I think of them, I remem-
ber what one of the delegates at the Evangelical Alliance, Pastor
Fisch, of Paris, said with regard to the small body of christians
which he and his colleagues represented : ' Don't measure us, but
7c>eig/i us.' Such a church as Calvary ^cit/i such a pastor, weighs
heavily, however small in numbers. I need not introduce to a
Detroit audience, the Rev. J. G. Atterbury, D. D."
Dr. Atterbury remarked: "You have called me on this plat-
form as the pastor of Calvary, the youngest of the sisterhood of
Presbyterian churches in this city. But, sir, my interest in this
occasion has a far deeper and e.irlier root. I have a closer his-
torical relation with this church, than you probably are aware,
having ])reached the first sermon heard within any walls it could
call its own.
" It was my privilege to know and love that brother of fragrant
memory, by whose labors the stones were gathered and the foun-
dations laid of the spiritual edifice which you now call the Fort
Street Church. Mr. Kellogg was one of the Presbyters who passed
upon my earliest trials and licensed rne to preach the gospel as
a candidate for the holy ministry. As his co-presbyter on the
II
83 TWENTY-FIFTH ANNIVERSARY
ground for several years, I had opportunity to learn his simplicity
and godly sincerity. Of his plans and hopes when entering on
his work in this city, and of his subsequent discouragements as
well as of his confidence of success in God's strength, he freely
opened his heart to me. When at length, after much struggle, the
completion of the first house of worship was reached, he invited
me, with the concurrence of his session, to share with him and his
people the joy of its occupancy, and to preach the sermon of
dedication.
" Hence, of the earlier experiences of your history, so well
traced in the discourse of this afternoon, I have perhaps a livelier
sense than the most of those who now constitute the officers and
members of this congregation.
" That historical discourse marshalled before the thought such
a noble band of Presbyterian elders, as this land is rarely permit-
ted to see. They might be recalled with interest and profit for
further study on this occasion, did not the crowded condition of
the hour forbid. These men are now but names to the mass of
this audience, but they are living parts of my experience. Each
one of them, with his salient characteristics, is associated with the
birth and development of my own christian life. I should delight,
were it permitted me, to render my grateful tribute to their memory,
by adding some lines to the picture already drawn so graphically,
but only too briefly, by Mr. Walker.
"' In reviewing your early trials, and labors, and triumphs ; in
placing the beginning of your history by the side of your present
consummation, I am not surprised at the exultation so manifest
to-day ; or should I not rather say exaltation — with the sense of
the goodness and faithfulness of God, who has led you, all this
way. But as I have sat here through this day, an earnest sympa-
thiser in all your services, there has been vibrating through my
mind a deeply serious thought which this church ought to accept
even in the fullness of its jubilation. It is a thought of responsi-
bility. It relates to those workings of power which lie in every
true christian church, for the use of which an account must be
given. 'No man liveth to himself;' and no church liveth for
itself. God has given you the Word, the Holy Ghost, the Office of
Prayer, the Sacred Ministry — the enginery and material of power,
which in the great spiritual conflict are to conquer the kingdom
FORT STREET PRESBYTERIAN CHURCH. 83
of darkness, and wrest the world from Satan. The twenty-five
years commemorated by you, are twenty-five years of control of
this divine artillery. How fully has it been used by you in the
common assault on the gates of hell ? It is not enough to be per-
mitted to i)oint to this elegant temple of worship, and to increased
membership and wealth, and throngs of worshippers, with large
social and moral influence ; to call the roll of faithful men who
have lived and died among you ; and to report augmented contri-
butions to christian benevolence. The lines of the great enemy
crowd us closely all around. We are to be pressing them back ;
to strive to throw the light further and further into the realm of
darkness.
'■ May the Lord dispose both pastor and people to accept the
accomplishments of the past but as a preparation for a new depar-
ture in a more vigorous warfare for hasting the conquest of this
city and the world to Christ."
Chairman : '' In the Spring Street Presbyterian Church, of
New York City, thirty years ago, I knew and loved a lad, a little
younger than I, who, like myself, now occupies one of the Pres-
byterian pulpits of this city. I cannot tell you how much I
rejoice that the fellowship so happily begun, so long ago, grows
dea'er every day, now that we who were boys together, are, as
pastors, working side by side. When I think of the i)urity and
simplicity of that brother's preaching, I remember what Landor
answered, when asked where Dickens got his style : ' JF/iv, from
the Neiv Testament, to be sure !' Let us hear from a New Testa-
ment preacher, Rev. George D. Baker, of the First Presbyterian
Church."
Mr. Baker responded: "It seems to me ahiiost unfair to
inflict another speech upon this patient audience at so late an
hour. I am reminded of an incident which occurred in a certain
Mission School, not long since. A collation was to close the even-
ing's entertainment, and the speaker commenced his address to
the restless children, with the question, 'And now what shall I say
to you ? ' \Vhereui)on a curly-headed little fellow, from a remote
corner, cried out, 'Say Amen!' I shall not, therefore, venture to
interrogate you as to what you would have me say on this occa-
sion— seeing the air is already redolent with savory odors — lest I
84 TWENTY-FIFTH ANNIVERSAKY
might be obliged to make a speedy exit ; and this, I confess, I
should dislike exceedingly to do, for there are some things in my
heart which I should be sorry not to be able to express openly
upon this festal day. My brother has referred to the manner in
which his path and mine have blended from our very childhood,
and without any fuller expression, I have only this to say to him
personally, to-night : I am glad because he is glad — glad with him
and for him.
"But I' stand here to-night rather in behalf of others than for
my own sake. I have the honor and privilege of conveying to you
the congratulations of the Mother of the churches of this. city, the
First Protestant Society, to which so many kind allusions have
been made to-day. I would that another were here to extend his
hand in blessing upon you — one whose shoes' latchet I truly feel
I am not worthy to unloose, whose name more than that of any
other, is identified with Presbyterianism in this City and State.
But this may not be ; and rather than that the kindly word should
be left unsaid, I will venture to say it. Other children — God bless
them every one — went out from beneath the roof of the old church
in a somewhat irregular manner — ecclesiastically speaking — but
you were the first who asked and obtained permission to set up
house-keeping for yourselves. Regretfully, yet affectionately, she
bade you go, and commissioned certain brethren to accompany
and abide with you, until you should be fairly settled. Since that
time you have no need that I tell you she has watched you
with sincere interest. Over and over again, around the family
altar, has she prayed for your welfare. In all your prosperity she
has rejoiced, and sympathised with you in adversity. And to-day
she stretches forth her hand and blesses you in the name of the
Lord. Paul had no greater joy than to hear that his children
'walked in truth,' and your spiritual Mother to-night rejoices most
of all that through all these eventful years, so full of excitement
and temptation throughout our land, you have been right loyal to
the truth as it is in Jesus ! She congratulates you upon all your
abundant outward prosperity, upon this beautiful sanctuary, whose
attractions can scarcely be enhanced even by these rare flowers so
exquisitely arranged; but most of all, we joy and rejoice with you
all when ' we behold your order and the steadfastness of your
faith in Christ.'
FORT STREKT PHESRYTERIAN CHURCH. 85
" Tn the name therefore, dear brethren, of your mother in the
Lord. I say to-night, M'eace be within thy walls, and prosperity
within thv palaces. I-'or my brethren and companions' sake, I will
now sav, ])eace be within thee.'
"Suffer me another word. I have been thinking all day what
a blessed gift memory is, and what a means of grace ! And I am
sure we do not sufficiently employ it as such. How often did the
God of Israel remind that people of the past, in order to strength-
en their faith in Him for the future. 'Do you not remember.'*"
was the gentle rebuke of the Master to the disciples of wavering
faith. Truly has it been said, ' We must go into our yesterdays to
find God.' Men are poor indeed who permit the blessed memo-
ries of other days to slip away and be lost ; for of the multiplied
enjoyments of the christian life, one of the most blessed is to call
up hallowed recollections of the past, to strengthen us for the
duties of the present. If a child of God would have a rich expe-
rience, let )iim cultivate memory.
" But you cannot chronicle all the memories of these five and
twenty years ! When our brother was reading that wonderfully
comprehensive history this afternoon, I said in my heart, ' Well
done; but you can't give us all that is written in God's book ; you
cannot tell us of all the prayers that have entered into the ears of
the Lord God of Sabbaoth : of all the tears that have fallen into
God's bottle; of all the longings after holiness; all the aspirations
heavenward ; all the sacrifices of broken hearts and contrite spir-
its which have here been offered !'
" Brethren, what a hallowed, never-to-be-forgotten place is this
to many who throng these courts to-night ; some seen, not a few
unseen. In these pews battles have been fought, and crowns won.
When, in the decline of life, the Duke of Wellington re- visited the
scenes of his education and boyish sports, he exclaimed aloud, ' It
is here that Waterloo was won!' So in this 'gate of heaven,'
immortal souls have obtained eternal victory over sin and self,
through Jesus Christ our Lord ; and forevermore they will remem-
ber this sanctuary as the place where heaven was won ! As it has
been in the past, so may it be still more in the future, the birth-
place of souls. May the Lord love these gates of Zion ; and
when He ' shall count and write up the people,' may it be said of
multitudes, that they were here born into the Kingdom of God."
86 TWENTY-FIFTH ANKIVERSART
Chairman : " I have told you about my early acquaintance
and friendshi]) with brother Baker, in the Spring Street Presby-
terian Church,, of New York City. Well, after he and I had set-
tled here, and Westminster Church became vacant who should
come out here to look after us and take a kind of pastoral and
paternal oversight of us, but the very man w/w, after our day, was
the pastcv of that old Spring Street Church ? I almost fear to call
upon him, lest he may report something unfavorable. However,
let me introduce to you the Rev. William Aikman, D. D., of West-
minster Presbyterian Church."
Remarks of Dr. Aikman : " I will not say all the pleasant
things that are in my heart ; many have been worthily said, and I
will not make a surfeit of sweetness. My brother Pierson knows
that I love him ; and this church can easily believe that I pro-
foundly rejoice in all their good of to-day.
" I look around on this beautiful structure, I listen to the
recital of your success, and I know the blessed results over which
you rejoice ; but while I mingle my congratulations with you, I see
here more than the present. In these lofty and decorated walls and
solid foundations, I see the material representation of immaterial
but of very precious things. Here is the result of endeavor, of
prayer, of toil, of tears, of anxieties through protracted years. I
heard the statistics of expenditures this afternoon, but what a wealth
of care and prayer those figures presented ! I see one before me with
ear bent to catch tones which perhaps are not full enough to reach
him. I heard his name mentioned as for many years the president
of the board of trustees (Judge Hand). He knows what I mean
when I say that this edifice, as it rose from foundation to top-stone,
as it passed from point to point to its completed beauty, at each
stage has spoken of what men do not, have not seen — labor, wearing
anxiety, and tearful cries to the Infinite Helper. The ministry
has been a power here, and other forces have been in view, but much
of that which has made you what you are, lies out of sight, like
those great foundation stones, all unseen, covered up under ground,
but holding all above them.
"■ I listened too, to the necrological list. For a little while it
seemed to me dry and uninteresting. To me, a stranger, those
names carried no associations and awakened no memories. But I
soon bethought me, that to many who listened, that list was the most
FORT STEEET PRESBYTERIAN CHURCH. 87
touching part of all the history. The name came in its order, the
name of some one loved and away — father, or sister, or mother, or
brother, husband or wife, and with the word straightway your
look became dreamy, and you saw the familiar forms again as they
sat in yonder pew. Vou lost the other names as memory sum-
moned them to your side. The long list was not wearisome to
you. The living and the sainted dead seemed to mingle in the
congratulations of these hours.
"And then how I rejoiced that you have put on record the roll
of your sons that you sent to the war. 1 wondered, as name suc-
ceeded name, that you had sent so many forth. They are your
glory — those soldier boys who fought so well and won the price-
less boon of salvation for our fatherland. They are not all here
to-day. Some of them lie sleeping in far-off graves, perhaps with
' unknown ' written over them ; but they are not unknown here !
Memory and affection hold them in everlasting honor. Kossuth,
a score of years and more ago, spoke in his own majestic and
impassioned way of the heroes who fought and died for Hungary
in her great struggle : 'And so they fell,' cried he, ' those unnamed
demi-gods I ' So we, to-night, think of our heroes living and dead.
Living, they walk among us clad in the garments of peace, these
veterans of a hundred fights ! I meet them, and would fain bare
my head in their honored presence ! They saved what was dear-
er than all beside to me, what had in it the well-being of all that
was dearest — my country ! Ah, you did well to record their
names, and make them a part of your joy to-day !
" W'e may take this mention of soldier life, and have it give
direction to our thoughts at this hour. It has been said here to-
night, and it has been said well, that the church is a home for the
weary and the sad, a sweet resting place for tired pilgrims. It is
all that. It is the place where the sorrowing and the sin-weary
may find repose ; it is the home all blessed, where the family of
God are gathered, where there are songs and sweet communings.
Around it gather a thousand hallowed associations; there center
our joys, there are found our hopes —
' There my best friends, my kindred dwell ;
There G- d, my Saviour reigns ! '
But this is not all. This does not fill and cover all the idea of the
Church. The New Testament thought is different. In many a
88 TWENTY-FIFTH ANNIVERSARY
varying phrase, this life of the believer is a race and christians run
eagerly after a prize ; it is warfare and they fight the good fight of
faith ; they are warriors, and each day is a battle, a tramping
onward to victory and to glory !
" So we, as we look each other in the face at this anniversary
hour, may send along the line a shout of encouragement, and
make it a call to rush forward to the conquest of earth for our
Lord ! There never was a time in all the history of this world,
when the encouragements were so great and the inducements so
strong to work for the Master. We shall lose all the blessed fruits
of this anniversary, if we gather no strength for the future. You
stand on this eminence with the sunlight of God's favor upon you,
with the voices of the twenty-five by-gone years calling to you.
Go forward now with a new consecration. The voices are full of
joy, of favor; they speak of blessings untold, and your hearts echo
back answering calls of joy and gratitude. Then step forward
bravely, boldly as never before in the work that lies in front of
you. The rejoicings of to-day will then be not all empty gladness,
but have in them all promise of greater good and more glorious
success."
Chairman : " I think it was Sidney Smith who said that in
preaching, ' The sin against the Holy Ghost, is dullness.' Now, I
know that with all their sound scriptural learning, Scotch preach-
ers have been charged with dullness. But whatever sins he may
have been guilty of, this one will not be laid to the account of my
friend and brother, the pastor of the Scotch Presbyterian Church,
of Detroit, the Rev. George M. xMilligan, A. M."
Response of Mr. Milligan : " Mr. Chairman and Christian
Friends — The fraternal feelings and acts manifested, in our day,
among the different branches of the christian church, furnish a
cheering contrast to the polemic and exclusive spirit of former
times.
"We most cordially rejoiced in listening to-night to the kindly
greetings extended to you, Mr. Chairman, and your people. I am
sure that these congratulations are not only pleasing to you
because you happen to be their recipient; but because they also
express your abstract belief respecting the relation that ought to
subsist between the various denominations of christians. In this
FORT STREET PRESBYTERIAN CHURCH. 89
regard, permit me to say that my opinion is in exact accord with
your own.
*' Care, however, is needed lest the virtue of catholicity degen-
erate into an evil. Effective religious work, and true broth-
erliness of spirit among christians of different ecclesiastical names,
demand well-defined ideas of the genesis of a vital, christian
catholicity. Let us offer a few words that may be helpful to the
formation of such ideas.
" We should, at this time, like to have spoken concerning the
structure and function of the religious aggregate — a christian
congregation. It was our purpose to have noticed the dependence
of the phenomena and factors of this aggregate upon the elements
and structure of its units. We must, however, forbear, at this
late hour carrying out this purpose, and content ourselves with
presenting a few suggestions upon the point above indicated.
" He is possessed of a false spirit of christian brotherhood who
alleges that he has a general love for all churches, but has no
special attachment for, or allegiance to, any individual denomina-
tion or congregation.
" All real attachments towards the universal must be individual
in their beginnings. First, that which is special, and then, that
which is general, expresses the law of intellectual, social and
religious life and progress.
" He looks upon the events and surroundings of his daily life
with an intelligent eye, who has his special seasons of devotion to
mental culture. He bears a loving heart to his race, whose tendril
affections have been reared upon the stay of parental love and
service, and whose maturer attachments have been blessed with
the gift of loyal, personal friends. Is not misanthropy often the
dark outcome of the frequent betrayal of misplaced friendship ?
He who has never found a friend has not learned to love his kind.
Special friends are the alphabet of which the literature of philan-
thropy is composed. Charity must begin at home, although it
should not remain there. We need one holy day in the week, that
all the other days may have clearly and distinctly written upon
them — " holiness unto the Lord." The patient, accurate factualist
is the parent of the wise and comprehensive theorist. We never
love children so well in general, until we have had sons and
daughters of our own. We repeat, therefore, the declaration we
90 TWENTY-FIFTH ANNIVERSARY
have made above : First, that which is special, and then that
which is general, expresses the law of intellectual, social and
religious life and progress. The bearing of this pleading upon
the origin and growth of a genuine catholicity of spirit and.action
among christians of every denomination is, we trust, now suffi-
ciently obvious.
" Pastor and people owe their first and choicest love and ser-
vice to their own congregation, because they mutually determine
each other's character and efficiency as christian workers in an
exceptional degree.
" The power of the pulpit is largely dependent upon the
regular and attentive presence of the members and adherents of
the congregation upon all the services of the sanctuary. That
congregation is in a truly prosperous state whose people hear no
preacher so acceptable to them as their own, and who recognize
as of special obligation upon them all claims he may present to
their liberality and prayers.
" We have spoken, in very general terms, of the duties requir-
ing to be fulfilled by the people to insure congregational success.
Did time permit, we should have indicated the pastoral require
ments necessary to the achievement of the same end. The adage :
" Rolling stones gather no moss," is true of pastor as well as
people. It is our belief that " a settled ministry " conduces to
the best developments of pastoral and pulpit work. It enables a
man to infuse, more thoroughly than he could otherwise do, his
excellencies of head and heart into the thoughts and aff"ections of
his people. The valuable minister is he who has the ({ualifications
and desire to sustain a lengthened pastorate.
"We rejoice to think that these mutual conditions of congre-
gational success exist among you.
" My dear brother : after a five years' pastorate in this charge,
you have proven yourself " a workman that needeth not to be
ashamed." You give evidence of but beginning your work, at a
time when a merely " starring " preacher would be planning a
change of field as he " 'gins to pale his uneffectual fire."
'' May this occasion mark a new departure in your labours.
This event may be regarded as the celebration of your wooden-
wedding in connection with your present charge. May God, at
this time, present you with a wood-gift, in that " instead of the
FORT STREET PRESHYTERIAN CHURCH. 91
thorn, shall come up the fir tree, and instead of the brier, shall
come up the myrtle tree."
•' To you, the c hristian friends of this congregation, we extend
(uir sincere and cordial congratulations on this imj)ortant and
ha])py occasion. May you, while gathering inspiration and
wisdom from the i)ast, to impart strength and improvement to
the thoughts and actions of the future, keep clearly before you
the end for which God has given you those sweet and noble lives,
the revival of whose memories is sought in the exercises of to-day.
May you, by this event receive, in mulliijlied degree, the glow of
the heavenly fire which animated your earth-de])arted, spiritual
fathers and accpiaintances, so that you may bring to a worthy
development the desires of their hearts and the labors of their
hands. May the material beauty of your edifice and of your
anniversary decorations be emblematic of a beauty forming here,
excelling that which eye can see — a beauty which will survive
" the wreck of matter and the crash of worlds."
Chairman : " You will see that our next speaker, though
'Wast," is not '''■leasts I was lately playfully reminding my mother
that some fault for which she censured me might be attributed to
in\ descent, when Dr. C. S. Robinson, of New York, who was pres-
ent, observed that sometimes the descent is verv rapid. Looking
at the stature of this brother, and remembering his father, I am
sure we cannot say the 'descent has been rapid.' Let me intro-
duce, as the last to address you, my tall brother, Rev. George
Duffield, D. D., whose ' head tcnvers higher' even than his famous
and eminent father's."
Dr. Duffleld : " My very dear brother : After meeting you so
often at different places in the State, at Young Mens' Christian
Associations, and Christian and Sabbath-School Conventions, it
gives me no little pleasure to greet you on such an interesting anni-
versary as this in your own church. I have never heard that they
complained of your labors of love elsewhere, and, certainly T do
not think that they are any the worse for your thus ''looking on
the things of others."
" It has more than once occurred to me to ask who was your
model in your abundant labors; but never until to-day was I
aware that it was Dr. Shaw, of Rochester. That sermon of his
92 TWENTY-FIFTH ANNIVEKSARY
this morning was a rich means of grace to us all — it struck pre-,
cisely the right chord ; and that which vibrated the deepest in every
Christian heart — and if you and all the rest of us are not the
better for it in a new consecration of heart and life, it will be our
fault and not his. O, for a return of the '' Martyr Spirit " in deed
and in truth I
" At first, on receiving your invitation, I confess that I looked
at the word " Presbyterian " with some suspicion, lest there might
be too much of the denominational and too little of the Christian ;
but then I remembered your truly Catholic spirit, and how recently
we had been together on that high mountain, where we had
breathed so pure an atmosphere — and came so near to Christ and
to one another — with the dear brethren of the Alliance, and I felt
certain that I could trust you, if I could trust any one.
" Presbyterianism hitherto in the City of Detroit, and in the
State of Michigan, has been but of one kind — evangelical and
co-operative, rather than sectarian. To this present moment the
style and title in law of the " Old First," which has been so cor-
dially remembered this day as the " mother of us all," is " The
First Protestant Society of Detroit." Not the first Presbyterian^
but the first Protestant church ; and in that very title we perceive
at once that the original spirit with which they were animated was
to magnify the things in which they agreed, rather than those in
which they differed, according to the admirable rule of the
apostle: " Whereto we have attained, let us walk by the same rule,
let us mind the same thing, and if in anything we be otherwise
minded. God shall shew even this unto us."
" Of the same noble spirit were the brethren who formed the
Synod of Michigan in 1834: earnest, evangelic, missionary and
reform — loving Christian men — " Plan of Union " men — among
whom Dr. Eddy would have found himself perfectly at home.
"Twenty-five years after, when celebrating the first quarter-cen-
tury of their ecclesiastical existence, the one characteristic in
which they seemed to rejoice more than any other was their
catholicity. They had made common cause with their brethren of
other churches against a common foe, and had stood for others'
rights as well as their own.
" This has been the very spirit exemplified here this evening,
and in all the exercises throughout the day. From first to last we
FORT STREET PRESBYTERIAN CHURCH. 93
have been under the outstretched wings of the Holy Dove, and so
delightful is the aroma of Christian union that even the odor that
comes up to us from the lecture room seems for the time being
greatly wanting in its usual attraction. It has been so " good for
us to be here," that it is no wonder we have taken so little notice
of the passing hours, and are so unwilling to separate.
"When on my way for the first time to Detroit, I noticed some-
thing on the part of the pilot which I did not (piite understand.
He stood with his back to the wheel, and for ten minutes or more
kept his eye steadily fixed on the light-house of the port he had
just left. What could it mean .' He told me " he was taking his
departure," and from that, as his base line, he could make his
angles from one light and headland to another, until the dangers
of the lake were passed- This whole scene comes before me in
a new form this evening, my dear brother, as applicable to you
and your people. You have done well to observe such a day as
this, and you have good precedents for it, to " remember all the
way that the Lord thy God hath led thee." In the history of the
last twenty-five years, as so admirably brought out this afternoon,
you have a most magnificent " departure," in view of which
" to thank God and take courage." Henceforth in your Christian
experience and your Christian labors may your silver be turned
into gold ; and when the great golden wedding shall have arrived,
when so many of us shall have gone over " to the great majority,"
may it be your still higher honor here to stand in your lot at the
end of days, and receive congratulations even warmer and more
numerous than those of to-day.
" The beautiful crown that hangs suspended over the pulpit is
but a corruptible one ; it soon will fade and vanish away. But
let it remind you of that other crown, high and far above this or
any other earthly crown, which belongs to the faithful minister of
Christ — when your people, who are truly the people of Christ,
shall be your crown of rejoicing in the day of the Lord Jesus."
Stepping forward, then, to Mr. Pierson, and grasping him warmly
by the hand. Mr. D. said in conclusion : '' In the name of those
whom you have asked me to represent on this occasion, I once
more extend to you the hand of Christian fellowship, and pray
not only for a blessing on you and your beloved people, but that
you and they, in your mutual harmony and co-operation, may
94 TWENTTY-FIFTH ASTNIVERSART
long continue to be a blessing on all around you in this city and
commonwealth. God bless you. Amen."
At the conclusion of this brilliant series of fraternal congratu-
lations, which, with marvellous pithiness, terseness and brevity,
had been condensed within the space of two hours, the benedic-
tion was pronounced by Rev. Maltby Gelston, and the audience, or
as many as could remain, adjourned to the basement, where ample
and varied refreshments were bountifully served to hundreds of
friends. And so the Anniversary Day was brought to its close,
amid a not unfitting participation in God's bounties around a com-
mon board. Who of us shall live to enjoy such another day of
holy festivity, over which fell not a single shadow ! Let us hope
that at our Father's table, in His Kingdom, we shall together eat
and drink, and be filled with all the fullness of God !
FORT STREET PRESBYTERIAN CHURCH. 95
Cor^^fktulatofY I(ettei'^
Were received from all sources in response to the invitations, sent
out by the committee. Among them were the communications
which are, wholly or in part, incorporated herewith as a necessary
addition to our little Memorial. The first four of the following
letters, together with those of Dr. Burchard and Dr. Edwin Hall,
were read at the opening of the evening meeting. The rest, for
want of time, received only a grateful mention — or, failing to
arrive in time, were not read on the anniversary day, but will be
perused with interest as they appear in these pages.
The first letter is from the widow of the Rev. R. R. Kellogg,
the founder and father and first pastor of the church.
No. 64 Kosciusko St., Brooklyn, February 13th, 1874.
Rev. Arthur T. Pierson :
DE.A.R Sir : — On receiving your letter, and the card of invitation for myself
and daughter, to your approaching anniversary, we felt you had exceedingly
honored us, and I assure, you it would be " especially agreeable" to us to be
present on that occasion ; but, as this is impossible, permit us most sincerely
to send you our hearty greetings.
The Lord be with you, and verify His promise to " bless his people with
peace." Could I be present, I imagine I should feel as Paul did when he met
the brethren at Appii Forum. I should " thank God and take courage" — thank
Him that He ever put into the heart of my dear husband to be His instrument
in planting this vine, and thank Him that He has caused it to take root not
only, but abiatdantly to grow. Work for the Master ever brings with it its own
reward, and I shall ever be cheered, the short remaining period of separation
from my dear husband, as I realize more and more that his works are following
him to glory. " To save a soul from death," he thought worth every other
achievement — this animated him amid all the discouragements attending upon
(what was twenty-five years ago) a w/w enterprise. And I doubt not his harp
is often strung anew with praise to the Master, as one after another greet him
in the upper sanctuary, who were brought, through his instrumentality, to accept
the great salvation. And may we not believe (I love to think) that his pure
and holy soul may be among the " great cloud of witnesses " at your joyous
gathering ?
He has not forgotten the church in Detroit, and for aught we know, may be
among the " ministering spirits " in their heavenward progress.
May you long be spared to the people of your charge, and continually
blessed in your labors among the flock, and unitedly, may Jesus not only be
96 TWENTY-FIFTH ANNIVERSARY
with you, but in you by His blessed spirit, endowing you more and more plen-
teously with His grace, for " the promise is unto you and to your children, and
to as many as the Lord our God shall call."
As I have already sent, at the request of my niece, Miss Lizzie Orr, a short
account of Mr. Kellogg's life and labors, answering for her some inquiries of
Mr. E. C. Walker, I will not detain you longer with this letter.
In christian bonds, your friend,
MARY E. M. KELLOGG.
The second letter is from the Rev. Henry Neill, D. D., who
succeeded Mr. Kellogg in the pastorate.
Philadelphia, February 14th, 1874.
Rev. and Dear Sir : — Your letter of the gth of February has just reached
me To its fraternal invitation and to its object, I am not insensible.
To trace the way of the Past, and to learn its lessons, is strengthening even
to an individual overlooking his own life How full of instruction and of encour-
agement may it not be to a church.
Twenty-five years of history have enough in them to stir many a fountain
of gratitude, and to make apparent gates of usefulness yet unopened, and to
plant impulses never to be rooted out, and approved of God. And is it not a
blessed thought that as on the fields of rural labor the good seed live, whilst
the defective ones are also made to be useful in their way, so on the wider and
more enduring plains of moral life, right aims take root, whilst the evil is over-
ruled for good? How patient and long-suffering is our God! Surely His
mercy endureth for ever.
I well remember the early days of the Fort Street Church : the convocations
in the brick building on Lafayette street ; the first communions ; the names
and forms of those who there professed their faith in Christ, some ot whom are
now sleeping in Jesus, Nor can I forget the ardor of the young, the generosity
of the middle aged, and the fidelity and aff'ection of large numbers whose
names, if not now recorded in the books of the church, may yet shine in the Lamb's
Book of Life. I hear of your growth. Faith and love, once sown, never die.
" Tho' tliy beginning was small, thy latter end shall greatly increase," is the
promise. And now that which was " sown in weakness is raised in power."
So it will ever be. I hear that .the building, always a model of architectural
beauty, is made still more commodious, and that the banner of the Ancient
Covenant is still a glory in your midst.
With best wishes for all who worship with you, I may be permitted to quote
the words of Haggai : " Be strong, O, Zerubbabel, and be strong, O, Joshua,
son of Josedech, the high priest ; and be strong all ye people, according to the
word that I covenanted with you ; so my spirit remaineth among you ; and
I will fill this house with glory, saith the Lord of Hosts."
Though unable to be present, yet, affectionately yours,
HENRY NEILL.
The Rev. Arthur T. Pierson.
FORT STREET PRESBYTERIAN CHURCH. 97
The third letter is from Rev. Azariah Rldridge, D. I)., the third
pastor of the Fort Street Church.
Nice, J.-inuary 28th, 1874.
RkV. a. T. PlERSON" :
Dear Brother : — \'onr kind letter of January 5th, has just reached me,
and I hasten to thank you and the dear people of your charge for the kind
invitation which it contains. It will, of course, not be possible for me to
attend the ([uarter-century anniversary in contemplation, but I hope this
response may arrive in season for that pleasant occasion, and that you will duly
emphasize the expressions thus conveyed of my strong interest in all that relates
to the prosperity of the Fort Street Church at Detroit.
From these borders of the old Mediterranean sea, I send greetings to all the
members of my former charge, without exception, to-day, and not to them only,
but to all those, even, who, through God's blessing on your successful ministry,
have been drawn to worship and labor there with them in the Lord. May He
continue to bless them as a church and a congregation, and as a special grace,
may He keep alive in the very midst of their gratitude and thanksgivings a
strong sense of responsibility for that which He so lavishly bestows. Tell your
noble hearted people, dear brother, as from me now afresh, that distance from
what they enjoy, and the absence of those mercies which flood them is needful
in order for one most clearly to see and feel how God is distinguishing them.
And it is by such contrast with the wants of others and the destitutions of the
world, that we can ever best perceive the Master's will concerning those to
whom much has been given. For at no time in history, and in no place on
earth, are the faithful so called upon to let their light shine, that the Father
may be glorified, as are they there where you are standing this day. That
church is set on a hill. All the churches of our land, especially those of the
West towards which emigration looks, and more especially those of command-
ing power and position, are there at the center of world-wide observation, and
should be the source of boundless influence for good ; for is not this the day,
already come, and this the promised hour at which God is working all abroad
with foreordained energy and signal success to prepare the way of the Lord ?
Has He not girdled the Upas tree at Rome, rooted up many oppressive
despotisms, and is He not planting far and wide those institutions, civil and
religious, which spring from the New Testament ? Let American churches
hold forth the true light, let American influence, chastened by christian charity
and justice, be iully high advanced and steadily extended for one quarter of a
century more, and may we not hope that the worst will have been passed ; the
darkest time be over and gone ; the great organized systems of evil overthrown
and demolished ; these gigantic obstacles to human progress swept out of the
way, for the gospel to run and be glorified I That day, as a return of this
happy festival, some of us may be permitted to behold in the flesh ; but
whether then to be present or absent, let us live in the faith of Christ and
prepare to die, when the time comes, in the hojie of meeting again where the
sweet relations of this life will be recalled, and where the memories of those
13
98 TWENTY-FIFTH ANNIVEESART
who have loved and labored together for the same good cause, may prove a
source of endless enjoyment.
Farewell, dear brethi'en and friends. Th5.t God may continue to bless you.
and keep you, and make His face to shine upon you and give you peace like a
river, will ever be the prayer of
Your former pastor and constant friend,
A. ELDRIDGE, .
Hotel et Pension Suis<:e, Nice, France.
The fourth communication is from the Rev. Samuel T. Clarke,
the fourth pastor, and immediate predecessor of Mr. Pierson in
the ]mstoral office.
OWEGO, N. Y , February i6th. 1874.
Dear Mr. Pierson : — Many thanks for your kind remembrance of me upon
the occasion of the " Silver Wedding " of your parish. It was a very happy
thought, upon your part, to invest the day with such bright memories. Silver
is rare now, save on the heads of the aged. But " Fort Street " is by no means
venerable. May its future, under your devoted care, be not only silvery but
golden.
May the Lord give to you the pleasure of gathering many vvhom I knew as
infants, about the holy table of communion, as one by one they arrive at
maturity, and are accepted in the Beloved.
With kindest regard,
SAMUEL TAYLOR CLARKE.
To Rev. Arthur T. Pierson, Detroit.
The six letters immediately following are from, or concerning,
brethren, who for a longer or shorter time served the church as its
ministers, but were not inducted into its pastorate. The first of
these — fifth in the order of publication — is from the Rev. T. L.
Byington, already referred to in the pages of Mr. Walker's histori-
cal address :
Newton, N. J., February 17th, 1874.
My Dear Brother Pierson : — Your kind invitation was duly received.
It would give me great pleasure to be present at the Twenty-fifth Anniversary
of the Fort Street Church.
Although my connection with that church was of short duration, it was of a
very pleasant nature. It was my maiden effort to minister statedly to any
church. I entered upon my brief work there with many misgivings, but the
uniform kindness and the very generous treatment I experienced were very
encouraging to a young man.
I have ever regarded the few months I spent in Detroit as among the most
pleasant of my life.
I rejoice to learn of the prosperity of the church under your labors. May
the Lord make that church a tower of strength ; may its influence for Christ
FOHT STREET PRESBYTERIAN (HI KCH. 99
be perpetuated with ever increasing power, and the blessing of God rest upon
both pastor and people.
Thanking you again for your kind remembrance,
I remain yours in the gospel,
T. L. byin(;ton.
The next two letters arc from the widow and the brotlier of Rev.
James Means, another who temporarily sujiplied tliis pulpit, and
whose memory is blessed among us.
Akdover, Mass., April ist, 1874.
Rev. Arthur T. Pierson :
Mv Dear Sir : — Your kind note of March 23d, I received the last week.
I send you a copy of the address delivered by Prof Park at the funpral of my
husband, not, of course, because it would be fitting and proper to use m re
than a small part of it, but because the analysis of his character, drawn by one
who had known him long and intimately, was so much better than anything
which I could prepare.
The few months which Mr. Means spent in Detroit were always remem-
bered with much pleasure, and the warm affection of the members of the Fort
Street Church was most heartily reciprocated. lie often expressed a wish to
visit the place where he had received, what seemed to him, such unaccountable
kindness.
May I ask you to give my regards to those friends who were so kind as to
extend their interest in my husband, to his family also ?
With much regard yours,
ELIZABETH P. MEANS.
Boston, February i6th, 1874.
My Dear Sir, — I am only this morning in receipt of your note covering
invitations to my sister and family, and to myself, to be present at the Memorial
services of the " Fort Street Church," too late to make any response in time for
the meeting of the rSth. I, myself, know but little of my brother's ministry
in Detroit, only remembering that he was greatly interested in his work there
and the people of his charge, among whom he found several friends of his
youth who had attained to merited honor and distinction in their chosen home.
I do not remember the year of my brother's stay in Detroit; and cannot there-
fore speak intelligently of his former or his subsequent life, but enclose to you
a letter written by Rev. Horace Jame^ wiio sacceeded him in the office of
Superintendent of Blacks (this was before the Freedman's Bureau was estab-
lished), upon the occasion of his death.
Thanking you for your invitations and remembrance of my brother,
I am. dear sir, very respectfully yours,
WM. G. MEANS.
To Rev. Arthur T. Pierson,
Pastor of Fort Street Presbyterian Church, Detroit
100 TWENTY-FIFTH ANNIVEESARY
The letter referred to above will be of so much interest to those
who knew and loved Mr. Means that we publish it in full.
CHAPLAIN JAMES MEANS.
Plymouth, N. C, April 17th, 1863.
Before this can reach the eye of the reader it will be generally known at the
North that our dear brother, Rev. James Means, hospital chaplain at Newbern,
and more lately " Superintendent of Blacks " in this department, is no more.
He fell a victim of typhoid fever, on the 6th inst., at the age of 50 years.
Knowing and loving him most tenderly, it falls upon me as a personal affliction
for many a time have we taken sweet counsel together, and felt our spirits
refreshed thereby in this far country of our banishment. Ofien were the great
questions of morals, government, liberty and humanity which underlie the
national struggle now pending, themes of earnest discussion with us, while the
events of the war slowly unfolded the history of the last summer's campaign.
It was by reason of an uncommon interest in these questions that he was led to
leave his home and engage in army work. Entering the department in the
month of July, 1S62, he was immediately assigned to the general hospital
known in Newbern as the ■' Academy Green Hospital." the capacity of which
is sufficient for only 70 or 80 patients, and which on its first occupancy was
nearly filled with wounded men from the battle of Newbern. Up to the period
of Mr. Means' appointment it shared only such spiritual attentions as could be
devoted to it by the regimental chaplains stationed at the post. Some of the
most touching incidents of hospital life that ever fell under my notice were in
this place and at this time. When about to enter upon the duty assigned him,
it is pleasant now to recollect with what earnestness and Christian simplicity
our brother inquired how he could gain access to the patients, and possess him-
self of our experience, who had been some months upon the ground. But he
needed not our aid. He brought to the work such ripeness of Christian char-
acter and attainments, together with such a virinning and graceful address as
opened his way at once to the hearts of the soldiers, and made him the valued
and beloved friend of every patient.
He was also well fitted for this work by the training of the sick room, and
by years of struggling dyspeptic weakness. He had learned sympathy, like the
Carthagenian queen, in the school of adversity, and could say with her :
" Haud ignara mali miseris succurrere disco." It was not in vain that he had
personally suffered, for a beautiful patience, and a chastened tenderness breathed
through his life.
Having mastered the details of his duty in the hospital, and still finding
himself with time to spare, and few books at hand, or congenial friends, he
turned his attention toward the contrabands in this department, and wished to
do something for their good. He taught a little school at his room, of evenings.
He entered their church, and preached the gospel to them. " Wonderful man !"
some of them exclaimed. " He told us right smart of things ; all about
Jerusalem, and the temple, and every other place. We were greatly lifted up."
His subject was Christ weeping over Jerusalem as expressive of his divine
FOKT STREET rUESBYTEKlAX CUL'UCll. lUl
compassion. And he improved his personal knowledge of those interesting
localities obtained in travel, to illustrate divine truth to their eager minds.
They always loved to hear him preach. Subsequently, on the ist day of
January, and after he had assumed the special oversight of them by appoiut-
ment of Gen. Foster, and a commission from Gov. Stanl«y, he gathered them
together in their churches, and read to them the President's proclamation, and
plainly instructed ihem respecting their new relations to society, and their new
duties and obligations as free citizens.
Another object dear to him at this period of his chaplaincy was the support
of a regular service in the Presbyterian church on Sabbath mornings. In
March and April, 1862, while the 25th Mass. Regiment were doing provost
guard duty in town, it was regularly maintained by the chaplain of that regi-
ment Subsequently, and through the summer, Chaplain Clark, of the 23d
.\fass. preached there. But after this regiment had given place to the 17th
Mass., who then had no chaplain, Mr. Means volunteered to uphold the service.
Most acceptably did he do it, until he had gathered a congregation larger than
had worshipped there for many months before.
One sermon delivered there by Bro. Means was from this te.\l : " Thv gentle-
ness hath made me great." It illustrated his own taste, and as the discourse
fell with sweet and delicate intonations from his lips, enriched with valuable
thought, clothed in a chaste and scholarly garb, one could scarcely refrain from
saying that he was himself an eminent example of his theme.
When appointed .Superintendent of Blacks he had serious doubts, as did
aho his friends, whether his delicate organization would be sufficient for the
endurance of its arduous cares and labors. But his warm interest in those
oppressed people, and desire to benefit them, led him to hazard the undertaking,
at the risk, as it now appears, of his precious life. " I will just take the weight
upon my shoulders," said he to a friend " give it a brief trial, and resign the
load if it be too heavy for me.'' He assumed it hopefully and lovingly, and
for two or three months to all appearance, endured well. He organized the
work, superintended the camps of contrabands, systematized the labor depart-
ment, carried on large correspondence, and in general, very ably and acceptably
discharged the duties of his important trust. How much it had cost him in
expenditure of mental and physical energy, did not appear till he was suddenly
prostrated with nervous fever early in March, from which he had scarcely
recovered when the more severe typoid seized upon his exhausted frame, and
hurried him to the grave.
It was the method by God ordained in which to take his servant home. It
was given him to be a pioneer in new and hallowed labors, to lay foundations
upon which others, and yet others, shall build, until in the next ages the work
should be complete. His life is another costly sacrifice, cheerfully laid upon
the altar of patriotism and religion.
Mr Means was born in Amherst, N. H , graduated at Bowdoin College in
1833, entered the Christian ministry and became pastor of the church in Con-
cord, January, 1840, .subsefjuently assumed charge of the Lawrence Academy,
at Groton, spent two years abroad, traveling in Egypt and Palestine, as well as
K)2 TWENTY-FIFTH ANNIVERSARY
European lands, returning, engaged in teaching a ladies' school in Auburndale.
which position he had left but a few months prior to his going to Newbern
His illness was of that distressing character which clouds the reason, and
deprives attending friends of the poor satisfaction of listening to last messages
and dying words. He had lucid intervals, however, in which he recognized
the friends that stood beside him, and inquired tenderly for others. After some
days of extreme prostration, during which the tide of life was imperceptibly
ebbing away, he sweetly breathed his last a little after 9 o'clock in the evening,
just as the band of the 45th, that had been serenading Dr. Upham, (to the
regret of all, about to leave the department) were playing the last strains of
" Home, sweet Home." What more angelic symphonies were just then engaging
his ear, as he was wafted toward "the Christian's home in glory," who of us
can tell? The stillness of his chamber was undisturbed, except by the soft
rustling of wings from the spirit land, the voice of the Master saying to his
faithful servant, " Come up higher." He was eminently fit to go. The grace
of God had made him a pillar, the Holy Spirit a temple. As we remember
him, his speaking countenance was radiant with benevolence ; how resplendent
it now must be with the glory of God and the Lamb !
H. J.
Mr. Means, though only a temporary supply in the pulpit of
the Fort Street Church, left so deep an impress on the hearts of
those that knew him, that we are constrained to add somewhat
lengthy extracts from the address of Prof. Park, upon his character
as preacher and teacher.
EXTRACTS FROM PROF. PARK'S ADDRESS DELIVERED IN
ANDOVER, APRIL, 1863.
" Mr. Means preached the simple gospel, and in an earnest and honest way.
His tones of voice bore witness that he believed what he said, and felt what he
believed. He was so graceful in his manners, and so sincere in his words, that
he commended himself at once as a pastor, especially to the sick and the
troubled. ********
"As Principal of Lawrence Academy, he will be long remembered for the
bounties which he distributed among his indigent pupils, as he was the active
and the happy almoner of the charities coming to these pupils from his kinsman
and friend, the late Amos Lawrence, a prominent benefactor of the academy.
* * * * * "* *
" He moved with ease among all classes of men, from the most affluent to
the most indigent. All classes felt an interest in him, because his heart was so
sensitive and sympathetic. There was a courtesy in his manners, correspond-
ing with the delicacy of his sentiments. The suavity of his address and the
tenderness of his sensibilities, made him a favorite with refined circles, who
might have been otherwise repelled by his decision of thought and aim. For,
although he was characterized by a shrinking modesty, he was noted as well for
his positive opinions and firm purposes. His personal attachments were not
FORT STREET PRESBYTERIAN CHURCH. lOii
stronger than were his convictions of duty. With all his nicety of taste, he
combined such an inflexible adherence to what he deemed right, that men were
often surprised at the boldness of sentiment which he uttered in such bland
and gentle accents. He could say what few other men would dare to say. He
gained friends where others, as strenuous as he, would have made enemies. His
decision of character was manifest in his self-denials for the wellare of his
race. Wlserever he lived he labored in the service of the community. * *
" His pecuniary charities transcended the proportion of his pecuniary
resources. He was whole-souled in every good scheme to which his mind was
called, and he often sacrificed his comfort and his health to a philanthropic
enterprise which had no more claim upon him than upon those who lived at
ease around him
" His enterprising spirit had the peculiar tincture of the Gospel. It was
commonly exhibited in behalf of the poor. He became the friend of those
who had no other friend. In order to enlist his sympathies in any work, it was
only needful to assure him that the work was hard as well as useful, and if he
7coiilii not, no one woztld take hold of it. He never labored for a cause that
was popular, so successfully, as for a cause that was unpopular, when he was
fully convinced that the cause was right and good He seemed to have a kind
of instinct, as well as a Biblihal faith, that " truth, though crushed to earth,
would rise again," and that the structure of the world, as well as the promises
of grace, would in the end secure the triumph of christian love. Ten years ago
I heard him foretell the methods in which the down-trodden and the oppressed
of our land would gain their freedom at the last I did rot believe in his
predictions. He was no prophet. Still, tuhat he foretold has come to pass.
In that kind of intuition which is lighted up by sympathy, he anticipated the
very scenes which our journalists are now recording. And when the terrible
calamities which he then predicted, if he did nol then foreknow, did come upon
his afflicted country, he gave himself as a free-will offering. He did not love
political strife, but whenever he mingled in it, he espoused the interests of the
poor. He was like his Master, who came from heaven to earth for the sake of
those who had no other helper. * * * *
" As Superitendent of Blacks, he had the direct guardianship of 2,500, and
had the indirect control of about 12,000 liberated slaves. Many of them were
miserably clothed ; he provided raiment for them. Many of them were incapa-
ble of procuring their daily food ; he fed them. Many of them were diseased ;
he sent them medical aid. Many of them complained of wrong treatment
from their fellow-men ; he inquired into their grievances, and obtained redress
for their injuries. W\ of them were ignorant; he gave them bread for their
famishing minds. All of them needed religious counsel ; he was a spiritual
father to them as well as a temporal iriend. He was their legal defender and
also their civil judge, the Provost Marshall committing these offices to him.
Occasionally he would hold a court in his rooms, and at this court the negroes
would appear before him and plead their own cause, and he would pronounce
the decision in his gentle, loving tones. He would never allow any one to
sneer at the negroes, in his presence, and would always allege in their behalf
104 TWENTY-FIFTH AI^ISTIVEKSARY
the various reasons for a mild estimate of their character. We know how
scrupulously neat he was in his own person ; yet, he would walk among the
crowd of degraded negroes, giving his right hand to those on one side of him,
and his left hand to those on the other side of him, not shrinking from contact
with those for whom he came to lay down his life, as his Blessed Lord had come
to die for publicans and sinners. His opinion of the negroes he often expressed
in his wanted style of clear decision. In a letter dated only a month ago, he
writes . " All questions of the capacity and intelligence of the blacks are
impertinent. It is the white man who troubles the negro, the government, the
world and its Ruler. The black man is brave, and sensible, and patient, and
willing and obedient. We call him a coward, and refuse to allow him to prove
his courage. We call him vicious, and deny him all opportunity to demonstrate
his virtue. We oppress and depress him, and then complain that he is not
equal to the free white man. Oh ! pray for the poor blacks ; they are the Lord's
uncomplaining poor. He will avenge them."
" On the i6th of January he wrote : " The negroes are capable enough in
the main. I have never had reason to change a single opinion about them.
Indeed, the elements of a judgment are very simple. Thus : they are rational
beings, with all the faculties ; they are moral beings, with all the rights, privi-
leges and responsibilities ; therefore, the axiom, ' what man has done, man
may do,' applies to them as to all colors. The conclusion is modified only by
the circumstances of successive generations of barbarizing servitude. The
solution of all questions about them is sure in time to be wrought out."
" On the 27th of last December, he wrote : " My contrabands ! my contra-
bands ! Not for money, not for sflver and gold, would I labor in their cause.
My soul is sustained by a steady purpose and desire to do them good. How
have I desired the high, the noble privilege of working for them, of shaping
their condition, of organizing their infant society, of regulating their nascent
institutions? It seems a dream to me, but so it appears: God has accounted
me worthy of the opportunity. At present my cares are almost purely secular,
relating to their day's work, their wages, their clothing, their food, their lodging,
their protection. But soon I shall emerge from this and expatiate in efforts for
their elevation as intellectual and moral beings. I am making a little progress
in winning their confidence, and causing them to feel that I mean to be kind
and good to them. **=!=****
"On Ma'ch 17th, shortly before his death, he wrote one of his familiar and
characteristic letters : " The Lord is always so much better to me than I deserve,
that I can't help thinking He has a ' favor to me.' At any rate I mean to try
and be much better than ever before, out of gratiiude for past favors. What a
sweet christian theory it is, that ' whom the Lord loves. He chastens !' He
don't neglect His favorites, but keeps after them, and blesses them, and scourges
them, and smiles on them, and uses all acts to make them worthy at last, to be
brought home with honor. It will be a wonderful talk we will have together
in tlie Paradise of God, over all the checkered experiences of this life. I very
often give you my thoughts and prayers ; I hope you don't forget me. If you
do not keep a sharp look out, I shall slip in before you, and one of these days
FORT STREET PRESBYTERIAN CHURCH. 105
go up. Let us turn our regards more than ever, more and more, towards the
future recompense of reward. We can win it by our faith, never by our works.
It is all purchased and promised. When we yet it, we can't be proud of it, for
it will be stained by no merits of ours. But it is all the mo>e sure to us if we
love Jesus, the meritorious sacrifice and High Priest. He gives it; we must
accc]it it. Thai is the whole of salvation. He gives, we take; He suffers ;
we enjoy." *:■:**** :i-. *
" Three of the hymns which he reiterated often during his last illness were
singularly pertinent to his condition. He had left his wife and children, sepaiate
from each other as well as from himself: so he uttered the verses :
" Jesus, I my cross have taken,
All to leave and follow Thee."
" He was wearied out and worn down with the tale which was daily brought
to him, of man's inhumanity to man ; so he soothed himself with the stanza :
•' Well, the delightful day will come." &e.
" The city in which he was lingering out his last hours had been threatened
with an attack from the rebel army. It was alive with troops ready to defend
it, but the women and children had been ordered to retire into the suburbs for
safety. He had heard the roar of cannon ; so he whispered forth the words :
" No more fatigue, no more distress."
* * * * if * *
" No rude alarms of raging foes."
" Just before he became too weak to converse, he slightly raised his head
and said : " All is so clear, so bright, so beautiful."
" The last syllables he uttered aloud were evidently tliose of a prayer, for
his hands were clasped and his lips moved as if in devotion, and he whispered
forth the two words : " Heavenly Father," And these were a fitting close of his
child-like life. *******
" A friend who was present, wrote the following description of the funeral
scene on April Sth ; " When I, with several friends, drew near the church, we
-aw a crowd of blacks in waiting for the doors to be opened. The large galleries
were crowded with negroes. Their presence had all the effect of a heavy
drapery of mourning. As I entered the church, this was very impressive, this
li^'ittg sable curtain. ******
"Dr. Stone, of Park Street Church, Boston, offered the prayer. He gave
God thanks for the boon to friends, and to the world, of such a lovely, gentle,
able, faithful servant of the Most High In his pastoral work ; as teacher ; in
all the sweet relations of life ; for all the graces, divinely bestowed, he returned
thanks to the Great Giver. For his labors as chaplain, and his later efforts for
the uplifting of men oppressed and degrade.!, he blessed the Lord. Most fer-
vently he prayed that He would raise up for tki'in another who should receive
the mantle of him who had gone up higher. At this stage of the prayer, it was
alTecting indeed to notice the suppressed " aniens " and groans of the negroes,
who are wont to be demonstrative in their worship. They evidently felt that
106 TWENTY-FIFTH ANNIVERSARY
here they must not give way to their emotions ; but from every portion of the
house the subdued responses could be heard. * * * *
" I noticed that as the procession moved along, both officers and soldiers
who were passing on the sidewalks, stopped respectfully and, removed their caps,
every sentinel presented arms, the patrol guard of che city stopped and presented
arms ; in short, every token of respect which it was possible to show to any
high official, was voluntarily offered to the remains of him who was so universally
beloved, so much respected. But I have omitted the most prominent feature of
the procession, viz: the motly crowd of blacks of all ages and conditions.
Some walked in the street, behind the procession, but they mostly followed on
the sidewalks, in no order ; many, however, were in the street on each side of
the hearse and procession. I noticed aged men and women, white-headed,
tottering along, groaning aloud. I could fancy that they were saying in their
hearts , " We thought it had been he who would redeem our Israel." All felt
that they had lost a friend. Everybody had a kind word to speak of the
departed, and a hope to express that the "poor lady at home should not take it
hard ; God bless her." *****
" When we stand at the bar of Him who came to save the poor and down-
trodden, we shall be astonished at the welcome to us : " Well done, good and
faithful servants," for the grace of God will be always amazing to those who
receive it. Still, there does seem to be more of a fitness in the words of the
Judge to our friend, who died in the service of the poor, than to the great
majority of us who hope to hear these wondrous words: " I was an hungered,
and thou gavest me meat ; I was thirsty, and thou gavest me drink ; I was
sick, and thou didst visit me ; I was in prison, and thou didst coiii^ unto me."
'' Inasmuch as thou hast done it uato one of the least of these my brethren,
thou hast done it unto 7ne"
The eighth letter is from Rev. Edwin Hall, D. D., of Auburn
Theological Seminary. It was read on anniversary evening.
Auburn, N. Y., February gth, 1874.
Rev. a. T. Pierson :
Dear Sir : — It would give me great pleasure to be present at the commem-
oration of the Twenty-fifth Anniversary of the organization of the Fort Street
Church, were it not that my duties in the seminary, and my ill-health, render
it impracticable. I remember with much interest the two pleasant months
which I spent with the people of that church while supplying their pulpit
during our seminary vacation of 1S58. I have great reason to remember the
great generosity of the ladies of the congregation, who, after hearing of the
great need of our seminary, sent to us, after ray return, a box of bedquilts and
comfortables, the largest and most valuable, I think, that ever came to the
seminary, and which have ever since, as often as I have visited student's rooms,
reminded me of the pleasant and liberal donors. With such helpers, and with
the common blessing of the Lord upon those who love to do good, the Fort
Street Church may well be expected to flourish. I should love to meet with
FOUT STIIKET I'RESliYTKUlAX CllUiail. JO"
many of the people with whom I became ac(|iiainted there, and should rejoice
to be present at the proposed anniversary, but it is ([uite beyond my power
\'ours with much esteem,
EDWIN IIAl.L.
Mr. Walker's address mentions, with gratefid recognition, the
services of Rev. W. A. McCorkle, (now D. 1).), from whom this
ninth letter comes.
Princeton, April 2d, 1S74.
Rkv. a. T. Tiekson :
My Dear Brother : — My remembrance of the Fort Street Church goes
back as far as the year 1858. I knew something of it before, but not until
then had I any intimate acquaintance with its people and its affairs. During
July of that year I made my entry into Michigan as a citizen. Arriving in
Detroit with my family, I took up a temporary residence there until a suitable
held of labor should upen to me. The Fort Street Church had, for .some time,
been without a pastor ; they had opened a correspondence with Dr. Eldridge,
and were then waiting, until he could visit them, with the expectation of calling
him. As he was just returning from Europe considerable time would neces-
sarily pass away before the question would be finally settled. I was, therefore,
called upon by one of the Elders : first, to supply for a sabbath or two ; and
then to continue during my convenience, or until Dr. Eldridge could arrive on
the ground. Thus, I became a temporary supply for the Fort Street Church,
and for four months ministered to its congregation. It was the gateway by
which I entered into the State and Synod of Michigan. My first friends in the
State, with a few exceptions, were made in it, and, so far as I know, they are
all friends to this day.
The Eldership, if I remember rightly, was composed of Messrs. Walker,
Knight and Zug. Of these, the first and last remain to this present ;
brother Knight is not, for the Lord has taken him.
I accepted a call to the church in Marshall a few weeks before Dr. Eldridge
took charge of the Fort Street Church, and thus terminated my connection
with it as a supply.
I have only pleasant remembrances of my service in conection with the
people. They were kind to me then ; they have been kind ever since. After
years brought me in contact with the church under different circumstances.
When illness laid me aside from my work in Marshall, I found a temporary
residence again in Detroit, and a home among the people of the Fort Street
Church. As a hearer, I sat with them in their house of worship, until a kind
Trovidence restored my health. And when Detroit was no longer a temporary,
but a permanent home, and when I was pastor of the First Church, and they
were destitute of a pastor, it was very pleasant to have them turn to me for
such offices as they needed, and I could render.
Vou will remember, my dear brother, that it was my pleasure to welcome
you upon your arrival in Detroit, and, at your installation, to deliver to you the
charge which still rests upon you, and with which, by Divine grace, I believe
it is your earnest endeavor faithfully to comply.
108 TWENTY-FIFTH ANNIVEESAEY
The church ha>, througli many vicissitudes and not a few discouragements,
made its way, under Divine guidance, from a state of feebleness to a condition
of strength. Since your pastorate began, much has been done, and now the
church stands among the strong ones in the central part of our country.
I congratulate you, my brethren, upon having reached so desirable a posi-
tion ; upon the memorial services you have so lately held upon your Twenty-
fifth Annivei'sary ; and upon the bright future which lies before you. May the
present pastorate be long continued, and may abundant blessings rest upon
pastor and people.
Sincerely yours,
WM. A. McCORKLE.
The tenth letter is from the Rev. Edwin B. Raffensperger, who
preached for some \veeks immediately previous to Mr. Pierson's
call and settlement. It arrived too late for reading on Anniversary
Day.
Cumberland, Md., February r6th, 1874.
Rev. a. T. Pierson :
My Dear Brother : — Were it possible for me to come down just now from
my mountain parish into the plains of Detroit, I would like to join you in
celebrating the Twenty-fifth Anniversary of the Fort Street Presbyterian
Church. Your beautiful card of invitation brings to mind the few Sabbaths
I spent with your dear people when they were waiting for the man whom they
had selected as their pastor. Great expectations had been raised in their minds
concerning you, and I am happy to know that all these have been realized ;
that the great Head of the church has signally blessed your ministry in Detroit,
and that through your instrumentality such great praise has been conferred on
your congregation. Long may you live to fill the distinguished position that
you now occupy.
The Fort Street Church is celebrated throughout the nation for its princely
hospitality. The Lord grant it, in coming years, a corresponding celebrity for
the effusions of His grace, is the prayer of
Your fellow worker,
EDWIN B. RAFFEN.SPERGER.
The eleventh letter was read in connection with the anniversary
exercises, from the personal connection of the writer with the
present pastor, as will appear from the letter itself.
New York, February nth, 1874.
My* Dear Brother Pierson: — I have just received an invitation to the
Twenty-fifth Anniversary of the Fort Street Presbyterian Church, of which
you are the esteemed pastor. It would afford me real pleasure to be present,
and to take part in the exercises of an occasion so interesting to your people
and to yourself, calling up to memory so many changes, so many joys and so
many sorrows ; so much culture, so much toiling, sowing, and yet so much fruit,
such a harvest of blessings ! You may all, on such an occasion, raise your
FORT STREET I'UESIJ YTEHIA.N ('IIL'KCII. 109
Kbene/.er, and with united voice say: " Hitherto hath the Lord helped us."
In your personal success as a minister I greatly rejoice, and pray that the past
may be the earnest, the pledge of yet larger blessings in reserve. The twenty-
five years to come are pregnant with mighty events — untold blessings to the
church of our God. Blessed is the man that can live and labor for the Master
during these eventful years, and be in the conflict, and witness the coming
triumphs of His kingdom. This, my dear brother, will be your privilege.
Clladly would I tarry and toil on, that I might rejoice with the sowers and the
reapers in the great harvest of the world. But my work is almost done. Still
I desire to be out in the field doing my allotted and remaining work, until the
shadows of life's evening fall, and the voice of the dear Master is heard through
all the vineyard saying : " Call the laborers and give them their hire." There
is even now a voice continually sounding in my ears urging me to " Work
whilst it is called to-day, for the night cometh, when no man can work." Of the
brevity of our season of spiritual toil I am deeply conscious. Of all the
Presbyterian pa.-tors laboring in this city when I was ordained to the work of
the ministry, not one now abides at his post, and only three, out of more than
twenty, survive, so that I am the oldest in the pastorate, of all the Presbyterian
minister: of the city, and yet I do not feel old. My eye is still undimmed and
my natural force unabated. Still I know that my time draweth near. But I
rejoice that I i-hall live in my sons, natural and spiritual — those ' that I have
begotten in the gospel." Thou art my Timothy, and I charge thee, " Preach
the Word " — " Neglect not the gift that is in thee, which was given thee by
prophesy, and with the laying on of the hands of the Presbytery. Take heed
unto thyself, and unto the doctrines, continue in them, for in doing this, thou
shalt both save thyself and them that hear thee."
Wishing you all joy in the Lord, and the fellowship of His spirit, and many
years of labor and fruition,
I am yours affectionately in the gospel,
S. D. BURCHARD.
The following words of cheer, from one who, as a co-laborer,
occupied the pulpit of the Jefferson avenue Presbyterian Church
during more than half of the years which measure the life of our
own church, would have been read at the anniversary but for the
fact that they, through some mistake, made their appearance not
until several days after ; their herald on the day of our festival
being a beautifully directed envelope containing a blank envelope
whicli liad been accidentally enclosed instead of the leffer.
Geneva, N. Y.. February i6th, 1874.
My Dear Piersun : — I have looked at that programme and that beautiful
card of invitation very often within the last ten days, and until to-day have
hoped I might " turn up" and become a " magna pa — rs to a stirring speech."
One thing I could do with success, I am sure, J. e.. give attention to the
matters that will go off — not come off — in the parlors of your church on Wed-
110 TWENTY-FIFTH ANNIVERSARY
nesday evening. The fame of the entertainments given by your good people
cannot exceed the fact. You have faith in eating and drinking, and " show
your faith by your works," and I am sorry that I cannot be with you.
But pray tell me why you are celebrating this Twenty-fifth Anniversary ?
Is it because you have lived so long? have grown to such a stature? Why,
my dear brother, that church is good for a century. Or, are you keeping a holi-
day because you are so old, yet feel so young? The whole affair seems to me
as hilarious as the pranks of a frisky boy. I trow the church is well cared for,
and in the tide of prosperity ; has good substantial provender every Sabbath,
or they would be gaunt and spiritless.
Sincerely do I rejoice in your festival, g,nd in the occasion for it. If I may
depute some one to speak for me on that oceasion, I will depute jj'i?« to give my
congratulations and compliments to old friends assembled with you. May the
Fort Street Presbyterian Church stand for another twenty-five years, and throw
abroad an increasing light, in the city and in the State ; be a church of genuine
revivals and signalized by the rich gifts of God's grace. May its entire mem-
bership be devout, loyal to truth, and a strong support of their much loved
pastor, who is loved by none more than by his
Affectionate brother,
W. HOGARTH.
The next letter deserves a place here, if only for the long con-
nection of the writer with the evangelical work of the State.
Big Rapids. February 14th, 1874.
Rev. a. T. Pierson :
Dear Brother : — I received from my wife, a day or two since, a letter,
saying that an invitation had come to me to attend the Twenty-fifth Anniversary
of the organization of the Fort Street Church As I am the oldest working
minister in the Synod, and have long been acquainted with many of the mem-
bers of the church, and my wife was for a time a member of your church, I am
gratified to receive the invitation, though my appointments are such that I shall
not be able to accept I have written ray wife, requesting her to attend, and
hope she will be with you on that interesting occasion. I am glad your church
celebrate that event. It is right that they should recount the day of small
things ; it is right that they should talk over the past and praise the Great
Head of the church for what He has done.
I wish to say that I was well acquainted with the first pastor of your
church. Rev. R. R. Kellogg. My acquaintance was formed in a revival at
Romeo. I labored with him in scenes of deep interest among his own people,
when the Spirit of God was present in power I was with him, also, in a time
of deep distress, when his heart was wrung with anguish, at the time of his
dismission from that church. I knew him to be a man of culture, an excellent
spirit and an earnest christian. I also read with deep emotion the account of
the close of his ministry and his useful life, as he passed from earth to his rest
and reward in heaven.
I was also acquainted with Major Rowland, oae of the first elders of your
FORT STREET PRESBYTERIAX CHURCH. Ill
church, a noble-minded, large-hearted christian gentleman, and his amiable,
<;odly wife. I had shared their hospitality some days, with my wife I loved
him, and trust he received an abundant entrance into the presence of his Saviour
and God. v
II. K. Knight, Esq., another Elder of your church, was a man of a choice
spirit, and' in many respects a man of rare qualifications to do good. Asa
sabbath school superintendent he had few equals. He loved children ; he
loved the church ; he loved to work for the building up of the church. He
died in the midst of life with the harness on. Ills memory is fragrant and
his influence will long live.
I trust your anniversary will do much good. The reminiscences of the
past wake up the tenderest emotions in our hearts. I trust the good Spirit of
our God may be with you all and showers of blessings descend on your church
and congregation.
\'ours sincerely and trulv,
CALVIN CLARK.
For a similar reason, we publish the following brief note of
congratulation :
i8^i. July 10, 1844. 1874.
Organized. Present Pastor Installed. Nearing the city.
I Tim. 6:20 Rev. 21:23.
Richland, Mich., February i6lh, 1874.
RkV. a. T. I'lERSON :
De.vr Brother, — The oldest pastor, Presbyterian, in Michigan, sendeth
greeting to the Rev. bishop of the Fort Street Presbyterian Church of Detroit,
Mich. Thank you for the invitation to be present at your Anniversary Services
of the iSth instant. Distance, time and work will not permit. May the bless-
ing of our Lord rest upon you, " All that are with me salute thee. Greet
them that love us in the faith. Grace be with you all. Amen."
^'ours fraternally,
MILTON BRADLEY.
As has already been explained, the Rev. Dr. John Hall, of New
York city, was expected to take part in the Anniversary. The
sul)joined communication explains his absence.
30 West i8th Street, N. Y., February 3d, 1874.
Dear Sir, — Doctor Hall has gone by the night train to Philadelphia, and
has begged of me to write to you and express how very much he regrets not
being able to go to Detroit at all this season. He is overrun with work ; the
pressure is so great that I sometimes dread, notwithstanding his iron frame,
that he will be broken down.
There are at present public services held all over this city, and the anxiety
is very great that a special blessing will follow and attend them. He says he
cannot be absent. He is really quite grieved at being obliged to write to you
to this effect. Trusting, dear sir, thai the Lord will direct you to some one
whose words and preaching he will greatly bless,
I am vours very sincerely,
EMILY HALL.
The Rev. A. T. Pierson.
112 TWENTY-FIFTH ANNIVERSARY
Beside these letters, which have been embodied here, fully or
by extract, it should be mentioned that very courteous responses
came to us, among many others, from the following Reverend
gentlemen :
Roswell D. Hitchcock, D. D., L. L.D., Henry Kendall, D. D.,
Henry M. Field, D. D., C S. Robinson, D. D., of New York city;
Robert W. Patterson, D. D., Arthur Mitchell, F. L. Patton, D. D.,
of Chicago, Illinois ; Henry A. Nelson, D. D., E. D. Morris, D. D.,
of Cincinnati, Ohio ; Wm. Speer, D. D., of Philadelphia ; F. A.
Noble, D. D., of Pittsburgh ; R. A. Sawyer, D. D., of Irvington,
N. Y. ; T. Ralston Smith, D. D., of Yonkers, N. Y. ; Wm. C
Dickinson, of Lafayette, Ind. ; A. D. Moore, of Northumberland,
Pa. ; M. W. Jacobus, D. D., of Allegheny, Pa.; John Scott, of Lon-
don, Ont. ; Robert Norton, of St. Catherines, Ont.
Also, from the following clergymen in our State :
The Revs. J. Morgan Smith, of Grand Rapids ; G. L. Foster,
of Howell ; Job Pierson, of Ionia; J. M. Allis, of Lansing; D. M.
Cooper, of Albion ; E. J. Boyd, of Monroe, and J. W. Brown and
George Worthington, of Detroit.
We may mention, also, the following, as among the persons
whose letters we would be glad to publish, did space permit :
Hon. D. B. Greene, of Ypsilanti, Mich. ; J. A. Peck, Esq., of
Kalamazoo, Mich. ; D. M. Stiger, Esq., of Jersey City, N. Y. ; E.
P. Woods, Esq., of Lowell, Mass, ; John Gray, Esq., of New
York City ; S. H. Wheeler. Esq., of Newark, N. J. ; William K.
Muir, Esq., of Hamilton, Ont., and Hon. J. V. Campbell, and
Hon. C. C. Trowbridge, of Detroit.
In closing this volume, to which nothing remains to be added
but the lists of members of the church and congregaticn, the
compiler has only to add a personal expression of gratitude to
all whose cheerful co-operation has helped to make his burden
lighter ; and, with the devout hope that all, who in any way con-
tributed to this delightful commemoration, may join in the celebra-
tion of that Love which alone made the existence of the Christian
Church possible, which alone has preserved it amid the convul-
sions of human history, and which alone shall crown its militant
experience with its triumphant estate,we close these records of
our
TWENTY-FIFTH ANNIVERSARY.
FORT STREET PRESBYTERIAN CHURCH.
113
Si^torid^l I<i0t>^
Ol members of the church from the beginning, and of the pres-
ent congregation, are added, to make this history complete to the
date of the issue of this ])am|)hlet. In the list of menil)ers the fol~
lowing marks are used ;
*Withdra\vn by Letter.
fDropped from the Roll, because non-attendant or present
residence unknown.
JDeceased.
II Suspended.
v^Now in the Ministry-
1849
Samuel Zug,
Anne S. Zug,
*Sylvester Larned,
*Helen L. Larned,
*Sarah I,. Harmon,
fWilliam Gilbert,
fElizabeth Gilbert,
♦Robert Beatty,
*CharIotte Thompson,
* Helen Weir,
Samuel P. Wilcox,
I Louisa Wilcox,
^Catharine A. Fisher,
♦Delia Mather,
{:Thonias Rowland,
^Catharine Rowland.
*Mary E. Kellogg,
♦William Ilaworth,
fMarion Rutherford,
♦David O. Penfield,
♦Sarah Penfield,
♦Elizabeth Weir,
f Mary J. Weir,
♦John J. Briscoe,
♦Mary Briscoe,
J Margaret Stewart,
♦Eliza S Elder,
♦Harriet L Bond,
t Harriet Prentis,
^Cherry Weir,
15
♦Rebecca Abernethy,
♦Albert G. Fuller,
♦Eunice Fuller,
ifChester Spaulding,
f Fanny Spaulding,
lEunice Mitchell,
Nancy Hoxie,
♦Lydia E. Pond,
fMargaret Mattison,
♦Maria Hoag,
IJohn Cook.
♦Delia E. Norton,
♦Fanny B. Reed.
♦Jane Van Allen,
♦Washington E. Moore,
♦Rachel Moore,
§ David M. Cooper,
♦John Ronieyn,
♦Joseph (i. Selden,
Catharine Shepard.
Margaret Mair.
♦James Elder,
♦Letitia Elder,
♦Esther Elder,
♦Jonathan R. Axtell.
♦Mary Axtell,
JHannab C. Smith.
fMary A. Schoonniaker,
|Elizabeih Schooninaker,
♦Mary A. Coburn.
114
TWENTY-FIFTH AJTNIVERSARY
1 8.1iO.
:|Sarah Allen,
f Lucinda Allen,
*Ann McGraw,
^Mary Conner,
*Mary Bodine,
fMaiy Grout,
Mary A. Shaw,
Emily C. McMichael,
:{:Sarah Burroughs,
*John Robinson,
*James A. Hinchman,
Benjamin F. Bush,
^Louisa Praigg,
*James Rankin,
"Margaret Rankin,
* David B, Reeve,
*Ellen J. Reeve,
^Martha Fielding.
*Diana E. Parker,
*Mariah Guild,
"Simon Guild,
* Hubbard Trowbridge,
*Edna I. Trowbridge,
* Henry P. Hoag,
fSarah Ferguson,
*Julia Collins,
'Dewitt Putty,
||William Gunning,
|]Charles Brooke,
^lAlbert G. Fuller,
"Eunice Fuller,
"Anna D. Collins,
"Mary J. Kellogg,
"Jane A. Jack,
"Agnes Robertson,
Selumiel Champ,
Anna A. Dickson,
"Albert Hoag,
"Nathan P. Simonds,
tEmeline Simonds,
IJames Guild,
*Cornelia Guild,
*Jane Wood,
fMary Rowe,
*Francis C. Clark,
William N. Evans,
*Margaret C. Sprague,
* Laura A. Briscoe,
*Delia Sprague,
* Eliza Beaty,
"Mary A. Beaty,
"Margaret Beaty,
f Mary Connelly,
"Martha E. Gulley,
Edwin S. Benedict
Caroline Y. D. Benedict,
JHenry C. Knight,
Frances A. Knight,
^Harriet E. Gibson,
"Michael Henderson,
llJames Weir.
1 8.? 1 .
"George Eden,
f James Delgarno,
"William Candler,
"Albert N. Reynolds,
"Sophia L. Orr,
"William Briscoe,
"Ann Hammond,
"Louisa B. Cromwell,
IDavid W. EUithorpe,
fSophia L. EUithorpe,
"Henry McMullen,
"Sarah McMullen,
"Jane Ramsey,
Sophia Roe,
f Augustus Walker,
lElisha Wells.
1852.
"Douglass H, Donovan,
George A. Bancroft,
FOUT 8TREET PRESBYTERIAN CHURCH.
JElmira Green,
IJohn Gibson,
•Charles H. Axtell,
•Julia Rodgers.
f lessee Page,
'Susan Champ,
•Mary A. Peters,
"Thomas R. Spence,
•Emma Spence,
•Ellen Wray,
•Margaret Sutherland,
•Cecelia Van Every,
•Frederick Watson,
•Lucinda Simmons,
•Abraham S. Myrach,
•Eliza S. Myrach.
*Lucy Pratt,
1 s.i:t.
•John G. Beekman,
Joseph B. Bloss,
Caroline A. Bloss.
115
I H.14.
Edward C. Walker,
r>ucy B. Walker,
•Angus McKay,
"Margaret McKay,
•John Brown,
•Emma Brown,
•Mary N. Lockwood,
•Mary W. Lockwood,
:tAnnis C. Moore,
:t Marion H. Reeve,
fSarah E. Reeve,
Elvira Uavis,
Matilda Buhl,
Lydia S. Welch,
|:Shubael Conant,
"Alexander McFarlane,
"George B. Dickinson,
George Foote,
t Phoebe Foote,
•Ann Warren,
•Hovey K. Clarke,
•Hannah C. Clarke,
•Thomas W. Lockwood,
•Albertine Lockwood,
iJohn W: Hodgkin,
Margaret E. Hodgkin,
•James Menzies,
•Harriet M. Chester,
•Elisha Eldred,
•Mary Eldred,
•Fidelia Drury,
"Philip Thurber,
•Frances E. Thurber,
•Eleanor S. Candler,
•Louisa Hinchman,
•Jane Short,
•Joseph W. Smith,
•Elizabeth T. Smith,
Augusta C. Wickware,
*Eliphalet M. Clark,
'Fanny B. Clark,
•Lucy Neill,
"Janette McFarlane,
ICaroline Stephens,
JCatharine H. Jones.
I S.l.l.
Shadrach Gillett,
JMaiy Gillett.
f Frances Gillett,
J Abbey E. Steevens,
^Theodosia Snow,
'Edward Bliss,
•Helen M. Dudley,
•Fanny Shipman,
•Allison Menzies,
•Eliza Wray,
"Matilda Wray,
Mary Thompson,
116
TWENTY-FIFTH ANNIVERSARY
Bradford Smith,
:j:Lucia W. Smith,
* Edward A. Drur>',
*Martha J. Maltby,
*Sophia C. Johns,
J Mary A. Woodbridge,
•Elizabeth W. Dickinson,
*John Q. Dudley,
*Turner Stetson,
*Sarah Stetson,
*M. Howard Webster,
*Martha J. Webster,
*Alice V. A. Frasier,
:j: Henrietta Pond,
*Patience Leach,
*Catharine Newberry.
1 8.16.
JEliza Cook,
*Orpha J. Bingham,
Samuel G. Caskey.
Aurelia C. Caskey,
*Henry M. Cheever,
*Sarah Cheever,
Olive Williams,
Eliza Williams,
*Albert Pixley,
Jane Morrison,
*Susan Swift,
*William E. Cheever,
*Catharine Stuart,
:J:Mary Ward,
*William H. Osgodby,
*Electa L. Osgodby,
*Alfred Russell,
*Ellen P. Russell,
W. Leverett Woodbridge.
Franklin Moore,
Frederick Buhl,
*Sallie E. Yerkes,
Emily Shackleton,
*Mai7 A. Cromwell.
*Sarah L. Cromwell,
Sarah L. Coddington,
^lAnnie S. Gillett,
tMary R. Roberts,
■{■Elizabeth Roberts,
:);Mary E. McGraw,
Mary E. Morrison,
*Sarah C, Short,
* Harriet N. Pixley,
*Miriam Dwight,
Agnes Morris,
*James McMillan,
*E. Willard Smith,
*Charlotte M. Smith,
|David Stewart,
*Anna S. Kibbee,
*John L. Strong.
1857-
Adaline A. Phillips,
*Isabella M. Warren,
George E. Hand,
Margaret McDonald.
I8d8.
*Charles G. Brownell,
*Mary Brownell,
Sarah A. Perkins,
f Anna Kidd,
:};Charity Southard,
*Mary E. McFarland,
Mary A Slocum,
*Marietta Stoddard,
Stewart McDonald.
*Henry L. Leach,
*Richard Shipman,
*Norman Johnson.
William H. Perkins,
George L. Maltz,
*Alexander Hosie,
Alexander H. McGraw,
John Harvey,
*Julia F. Swift,
Elizabeth Hosie,
FORT STRKKT PRESBYTERIAN CHURCH.
II
JMary K. Walker.
*Alvah H. Walker.
♦Minerva Walker,
*Mary A. Walker.
*OIivia .-V. (iardncr,
JJohn ralmer,
[ane M. Palmer,
^Catharine Hinchman,
^Joseph C. Heath,
*Mar>' S. Heath,
JLyman Briggs,
*Ann Mary S. Briggs,
*ElIen Mary Briggs,
I Fanny Champ,
Kate Wing,
*Henry M. Warren,
* Alexander McFarren,
♦Elizabeth McFarren.
Charles D. Farlin,
Sarah M. Farlin,
Jjohn V. Beane,
Caroline Beane,
*Ellen C. Beane,
Ellen Eldridge,
Adaliza F"rench,
*Eliza A. Bush,
+ Harriet N. Cameron,
Eliza Thomas.
|Caroline G. Page,
*Ann E. Carter,
♦Caroline C. Spencer.
♦George Parsons,
♦Emily B. Parsons,
Archibald Ci. Lindsay,
Katharine D. Shelden,
♦Angeline Squire.
♦Jacob Beeson,
♦Elizabeth Beeson,
♦Maria Beeson,
JAnn W. M. Roraeyn,
♦Susan V. Rom«yn,
Jane Stewart,
Margaret McMillan,
Mary E Steevens.
.Susannah Perkins.
1^«.>».
Elmira R. Tower,
Mary Jane Eraser,
Flora L. Ray,
Sarah L. Wilcox.
Eliza J. Roe,
John Goring,
fWilliam Allen,
♦.Vlhert H. Jordan.
IJane Jordan.
♦Hiram M. Towne.
Jane E. Johnson,
♦William Reed.
George W. T. Hill,
♦William Allen,
♦Catharine Allen.
I860.
♦George B. Boardman,
:]: Helen .M. Boardman.
♦Eliza C. Spencer,
♦Theodore C. White,
♦Ann Monroe,
♦Stephen A. Peck,
♦Susan H. R. Peck,
f Adaline Brooks,
♦Cuthbert Laing,
Martha F. Stewart,
Maria Dickson,
Ellen L. Foote.
ISO I.
Ruth L Maginnity.
James F. Joy,
Mary B Joy,
James R. Dutton,
Deborah Dutton,
Georgianna E. W. Spence,
J Margaret Henry,
Frances A. Adams.
118
FOET STREET PRESBYTERIAN CHURCH.
Elleanor J. Swain,
*Emma Beeson,
Morris B. Tooker,
Caroline Tooker,
*Susan L. Merritt,
JMathilde G. Moore,
+ Emma L. Beane,
*Joshua Windoes,
*Carrie R. Windoes,
Emory Wendell,
Jennie E. Wendell,
William Findlater,
Elizabeth Findlater,
:j:Mary S. Palmer,
Sarah H. Palmer,
George McMillan,
Isabella G. McMillan,
Mary Buckley,
Frances Hitchcock,
*Jacob V. Haan,
*Mary Seymour,
Alexander McGaw,
Ann F. McGaw,
Catharine Woodvvorth,
Angeline Quigley,
Margaret Cuddy,
Eliza Ramsey,
William Morris,
Nettie Ames,
Katie Shepard,
*Joseph A. Tibbetts,
*Elvira Tibbetts,
Isabella G. Beane,
Joseph Nicholson,
J Henrietta L. Nicholson,
IJoseph G. Ray,
*Jennie B. Frazier,
■^Caroline F. Bloss,
Mary W. Thomas,
■*Euphemia Murray,
1863.
Sarah Joy,
*Mary Eldred,
|Anna Bryant,
Charles Root,
Alice Root,
Anna M. Evans.
i86:t.
1864.
186.1.
Eliza Bridge,
Julia A. Knight,
*John M. Tupper,
*Sarah Tupper,
Betsey Coit,
*Sarah Whiting,
*Mary Otis,
Alice K. Jones,
Susannah Stewart,
fMary G. Zug,
Lillie Walker,
Jane Lindsay,
Robert Hosie, Jr.
*Alfred Howard.
*Hattie Rosebrook,
ifEliza M. Rosebrook,
Edward W. Jenks,
IJulia L. Jenks,
Jane M. Jenks,
Phoebe Seeley,
Charles McNeil,
■^Cornelia Frasier,
*Perlinah Van Vleit,
tJulia Van Vleit,
Angelina Ames.
Kate Dupont,
Letitia G. Chandler,
Mary Douglass Chandler,
Hattie A. Wilco.x,
■•^Camilla Richardson,
Jane B. McGaw,
*Anna E. Eastman,
Jane Lindsay,
KOIJT S'lUKKT I'KESIIYTEKIAS <;UL'K<JH.
Frank H. Buhl,
( ieorgc S. Davis,
James K. l>avis,
IJohn r.. Heane,
Mary K. lialch,
Frances Shepard,
*EIla Shepard,
*F. J. R. Crane.
*Edward Warren,
William Wilson,
Fsther Wilson,
Isabella T. Hosie,
Margaret Conway,
*Julia Stephens,
Sarah J. McQueen,
*Fannie Stephens,
John S. Dickson,
*Mary Taylor,
*"Mary S. Lamson,
Frederick C. Adamson,
Cassie Adamson,
Mary B Dudley,
Lucien A. Smith,
Maria B. Garrison,
Russell A Alger,
Annette H. Alger,
*Neil McDougal,
*Catharine E. McDougal,
Mary R Brown,
Mary E. Park,
Henry M. Park,
Walter Buhl,
Charlotte M. Gillett,
Angelina Quigley,
Eliza Purdue,
Albert Pixley,
Henrietta N. Pixley,
Sophia L. Orr,
Elizabeth H. Abbott,
I soo.
IS60.
JJoncs Phillips,
George S. Adams,
Emma T. Beatty,
*l,izzie J. Carter,
Sarah H. Standart.
Stephen S. Bather,
*Virginia M Balsley,
John B. Hughes,
Philip Thurber,
Frances E. Thurber,
*Dewitt C. Smith,
■"■Mary Lepper,
*Mary B. Stephens,
*Helen E. Foote,
George Leckie,
Isabella Leckie.
1H07.
186S.
Martha Joy,
*Caroline W. Morse,
Mary F. Thompson,
William S. King,
Alice King,
Emilie A. King,
*Jennie C. Morse,
Cecelia Van Every,
Catharine Graham,
Emma Kennedy,
Otto Kirchner.
Anna E. Hentig,
Sarah M. Herrington,
Rebecca W. Smith,
Sybil C. Alger,
Anna Botsford,
*Hugh Wilson.
Sally A. Pierson,
Flora Goodfellow,
*John Goodfellow,
Electa W. Holbrook,
120
TWENTY-FIFTH ANNIVERSARY
Mary Penny,
Elizabeth Nicholson,
Charles G. Browfiell,
Mary E. Brownell,
Sarah F B Pierson,
Helen M. Moore,
Adelaide D. Morrison,
Mary L. Orr,
Margaret E. Wickware,
Walter E. Adams,
Jane M. Adams,
George S. Moir,
Theresa Moir,
Mary Botsford,
Elizabeth M. McKelvie,
*Sarah A. Snyder,
Julia A. Smith,
:|:Joseph Law, Jr.,
Frances A Pine,
Eliza J. Agnew,
*Harriet Snyder,
Martha J. Marshall,
Henry E. Chamberlain,
Jennie L. Wilson,
Sarah A. Stewart,
Mary D. Foote,
Carrie S. Foote,
*Ella G. Childs,
Robert M. Zug,
Phoebe D. Perkins,
^Albert S. Knight,
Kate McGaw,
Bryant Walker,
Jessie R. Walker,
*Warner W. Dickinson,
Annie E. Fleischman,
Mary Lewis,
Floretta Stupinsky,
Ettie Stupinsky,
Ellen M. Lowe,
*Ellen Johnson,
Janet A. Stewart,
Frederica Buhl,
Catharine L. Law,
*Mary H. Lepper,
John Wilson,
Marion Wilson,
Margaret Lindsay,
^Maxwell Lepper,
Elizabeth Marshall,
18 70.
Mina E. Botsford,
Minerva A. Curtis,
*E]izabeth C. Richardson,
Abner W. Smith,
Elizabeth K. Orr,-
Henry O. Walker,
Annie M. Adams,
Alexander Cuddy,
Jared A. Smith,
^Harriet C H. Boyd,
Maria S. Ballard,
Anson Young,
Jennie Young,
George H. Snover,
Marcella M L. Snover,
Charles P. Woodruff,
Mariette Woodruff,
Alice Woodruff,
Cora Woodruff,
Eva Woodruff,
Charles B Woodruff,
John Swift,
Maggie Mcllwain,
Sarah Mcllwain,
Jennie Mcllwain,
*Ruth Walker.
1871.
Maria J. Tate.
Douglass Payne,
Elizabeth Payne,
Mary Hale Abbott.
George B. Ayers,
Mary R. Ayers,
Mary Ladue,
FOKT STREET FliE6H YTR 111 A N «'HUK<;H.
m
Thomas Sharp,
*Calharine J. Atterliury,
*James A. Dubuar,
John F. Fenerly,
Margaret Kenerty,
Margaret McLean,
Margaret Howe,
Mary L Michelsen,
Camilla Richardson.
Martha Ann Lamb,
Chauncy C Sharp,
Elizabeth Robertson,
Irene B. Swift,
Julia Hull.
Mary Collins,
Rachel Clark,
Emma L. Fowler,
John E. Chaffin,
Laura A. Chaffin,
Thomas Y. Taylor,
Mary E. Taylor,
Fanny A. Smith.
E. William Cobb,
Robert Morton,
Marion R, Morton,
Thomas Watson,
Mary Watson,
Julia M. Wallace,
Fannie C. Perlev,
*Sarah A. Snyder,
Harriet M. Longyear,
Sarah Jennings,
Anna M. Goldsmith,
George N. Ladue.
Mary W. Lathrop,
Mary B Davis,
JMathilde Foex,
Albert C. Lanyon,
James W. Green.
Frances M. Stone,
Kezia Francis,
i6
^i7:i.
Charlotte Ladue,
Mary A. J. Conway,
Ella Courtney,
*Mary A. Chappell,
Ebenezer Ward,
Olive A. Gardner,
Antoinette M. Yerkes,
George W. Hoffman.
♦Elizabeth R. Hoffman,
Caroline A. Hoffman,
Charlotte W Hoffman.
I S 7'J.
William Manson.
Marion Manson,
Helen E. Gibson,
Hortenie P'oex,
Henry Graham,
Eliza C. Bissell,
Emily C. Cameron,
Jennie A. Foote,
Kittie Miller,
Charlotte Burr,
Neil McDougall,
Catharine McDougall,
Frankie A. Hunt.
John A. Freeman,
Mary A. Freeman,
Helen C. Blodgett,
Frank Whitney,
Elizabeth N. Hinchman.
Elizabeth C. Dailey.
Harriet Newcomb.
M. S. D. Story,
John McFarland,
James Clark,
Agnes Clark,
Elizabeth Clark,
Josiah Reaume,
♦Angelina Lincoln,
Amanda M. Rice.
Sarah M. Stone,
Lovina C. Prentis,
122
FORT STREET PRESBYTERIAN CHURCH.
Harriet Pratt
Mary E. Newland,
Martha Harris,
Lucretia N. Dean,
Edmund Sloan,
Catherine A. Sloan,
Mary E. Ives,
Louisa P. M. Foex;
Edwin W. Morris,
Stanley H. Cline,
James C. Hill,
George F. Newland,
JSilas L. Fuller,
Ella P. Fuller,
18 74.
Emma R Green,
Margaret M. Chambers,
Mary W. Merrick,
Clayton J. Perley,
Fremont Woodruff,
Susan M..A. Cameron,
Mary S. Cameron,
Mary A. Chaffin.
Four STkKKT I'UESBYTERIAN CHURCH.
123
¥he f^i'e)^ei]t Oongregcitioi).
In the following list of Few-Holders and Attendants, families
are represented by the name of the head or the oldest incmher of
the household. This roll represents the congregation at the date
of the publication of this memorial volume. :
Thomas F. Abbott, E. S. Adams,
Francis Adams, F". C. Adamsoh,
George S. Adams, Russell A. Alger,
Walter E. Adams, E. S. Alford.
Mrs. Mary Backus,
George F. Bagley,
George W. Balch,
O. L. Ballard,
C. B. Barnes,
Mrs. Rebecca Bates,
James A. Bates,
Mrs. Caroline Beane.
Philo G. Belknap.
. Eben C. Beach,
Edward W. Bissell,
George W. Bissell,
Tames S. Blair,
Charles C. Blodgett,
Joseph B. Bloss,
Charles C. Cadman,
William Cahoon,
Allen P. Cameron.
J. W. Carson,
Samuel G, Caskey,
A. B. Case,
Homer Case,
John E. Chaffin,
Ernest Chamberlin,
Zachariah Chandler,
Douglass J. Chase,
Charles A. Chamberlain.
Joseph Dailey,
James E. Davis,
Solomon Davis.
I. N. Dean,
William J. Deering,
Lawrence Depew.
James W. Blue,
Anna Botsford,
H. W. D. Brewster.
David Bridge,
Charles G. Brownell,
Alden S. Brown,
Mrs. Caroline E. Brooks,
Mrs. Mary Buckley,
Christian H. Buhl,
Frederick Buhl,
Theodore D. Buhl,
Joseph H. Bullock,
Harvey W. Burr,
C. H. Burnham,
F. W. H. Chambers,
Francis L. Childs,
Dr. H. A. Cleland,
James Clark.
E. William Cobb,
N. P. Collins.
Olney B. Cook.
John C. Corning,
Mrs. Mary A. J Courtney,
Rachael Clark,
Alexander Cuddy,
H. .\. Dickerson,
David Dickson,
Mrs. Elsie E Ducharme,
William Du|)ont,
fames R. Dutton,
124
rVVKN'TY-FIFTH ANNIVERSARY
Mrs. Anna M. Evans,
Charles D. Farlin,
John F. Fenerty,
M. S. Fitzsimons,
Anna Fleischman,
Mrs. Hortevise Foex,
Solomon Gardner,
Charles M. Garrison,
John J. Garrison,
James Gibson,
Rufus W. Giliett,
George E. Hand,
John Harvey,
Frederick W. Hayes,
Josiah D. Hayes,
Andrew M. Hastings,
Mrs. Anna E. Hentig,
Willard H. Herrington.
George W. Hill,
James C. Hill,
Mrs. Elizabeth N. Flinchman,
Richard Inglis, M. D.,
Edward W. Jenks, M. D.,
Jarvis S. Jennings,
Mrs. Maria E. Jennings,
David Kennedy,
Otto Kirchner,
John T. Ladue,
Mrs. Mary Ladue,
George N. Ladue,
F. Lambie,
George C. Langdon,
James W. Langdon,
Henry K. Lathrop,
Joseph Lathrop,
Mrs. Catharine S. Law.
Stewart McDonald,
Neil McDougal,
John McFarland,
Andrew McFarland,
George Foote,
James H. Ford.
Robert S Forbes,
Mrs. Ella P. Fuller,
Shadrach Giliett,
James H Goldsmith,
James S. Goodrich,
Henry GraRam,
James W Cireen,
F. D. C. Hinchman,
Henry C. Hodges,
Mrs. Margaret E. Hodgkin,
F. H. Holmes,
George W. Hoffman,
John C. Holmes,
Robert Hosie,
Mrs. Elizabeth Hosie;
Mrs. Margaret Howe,
William Hull,
Butler Ives,
Waldo M. Johnson,
J. Huff Jones,
James F. Joy,
George E. King,
Mrs. Frances A. Knight,
William F. Lay,
Albert C. Lanyon,
George Leckie,
Archibald G. Lindsay,
Mrs. Jane Lindsay,
John W. Longyear,
O. M. Locke,
Elleiii McGregor Lowe,
Eugene S. Lowe,
x\lexander McGaw,
John W. McGrath,
Miller W. McGraw,
Andrew Mcllwaine,
KOKT STKKKT l'KE«BYTEBJ A N CHUKCH.
125
Mrs. Margaret McKay.
Mrs. fane McLott,
George McMillan,
John McMillen,
Mrs. Barbara McNeil,
T. C. Manchester,
William Manson,
Mrs. Elizabeth Marshall,
Herman Markham,
Henry Meakin,
Walter Newcomb,
George F. Newland,
Henry Newland,
Edward Orr,
Mrs. Jane M. Palmer,
Henry M. Park,
J. T. Patton,
Douglas Payne,-
Frank Peavey,
Henry C. Penny,
Mrs . Sarah A. Perkins,
Jonas H. Perley,
John <^uigley,
Mrs. Flora L. Ray.
Josiah Reaume,
John Robertson,
William N. .Sandford,
John J. Scanlan,
Mrs. Phoebe Seeley.
Richard Shackelton.
Allan Shelden,
Mrs. Catherine Shepherd,
Prof. J. M. B. Sill,
Dr. A. G. Sinclair,
Edmund Sloan,
Benjamin F. Smith,
Mrs. J. E. Seymour
A. P. Sherrill,
Bradford Smith,
Lucien A. Smith,
George W. Snover,
Robert W. Standart,
Melzer F. Merrick,
Kittie Miller,
Barrett B. Mitchell.
Franklin Moore,
Stephen Moore,
William Morris,
Hamilton Morrison,
Robert Morton,
William D. Morton,
Joseph Nicholson,
Charles Noble,
John P. Phillips,
Arthur T. Pierson,
Jonathan P. Pine,
Albert Pixley,
A. Pardee Piatt.
Samuel L. Potter,
George H. Prentis,
James Purdue,
Mrs. Amanda M. Rice,
Charles Roe,
Charles Root,
Bliss Standish,
Albert M. Steele,
Sears Steevens,
Miss Elizabeth Steevens,
John Sterling,
Duncan Stewart,
Robert Stewart,
Mrs. Susannah Stewart,
F. M. Stone,
John .Stupinsky,
Mrs. M. S. D. Story,
Isaac N. Swaine.
William P. Sumner,
Edward Y Swift,
Marcus G. W. Swift
126
TWENTY-FIFTH ANNIVERSARY
Thomas J. Taylor,
Philip Thurber,
Mrs. Cecilia Van Every,
Eber B. Ward,
George S. Wales,
Emily Ward,
Edward C. Walker,
Henry O. Walker,
Isaac Wallace,
Thomas Watson,
James M. Welch,
Emory Wendell,
Eben S. Wheeler,
Frank H. Whitney,
Joseph P. Whittemore.
Lyman A. Yerkes,
Samuel Zug.
Mrs. Mary Thompson,
John J. Whittlesey,
Cornelius Wickware,
Samuel P. Wilcox,
Edward C. Wilcox,
Julia A. Wilson,
Mrs. Olive Williams,
John Wilson,
Charles P. Woodruff,
C. D. Wood,
Peleg Wood,
William L. Woodbridge,
Anson Young,
1 1012 01251 7944
DATE DUE
mm.
GAYLCRO
PRINTED IN USA.