The
Roman Catholic Bible
and the
Roman Catholic Church
Allen W Johnston.
Class _L
Book
T
Copight}^?-
CQESilGHT DEPOSm
THE ROMAN CATHOLIC BIBLE
AND THE
ROMAN CATHOLIC CHURCH
THE ROMAN CATHOLIC BIBLE
AND THE
ROMAN CATHOLIC CHURCH
BY
ALLEN W. JOHNSTON
A PROTESTANT BUSINESS MAN
WITH FOREWORD BY
DAVID JAMES BURRELL, D.D.
New York Chicago
Fleming H. Revell Company
London and Edinburgh
Copyright, 1921, by
FLEMING H. REVELL COMPANY
Printed in United States of America
DEC 12 1921
New York: 158 Fifth Avenue
Chicago: 17 North Wabash Ave.
London: 21 Paternoster Square
Edinburgh: 75 Princes Street
©CI,A630746
FOREWORD
David James Burrell, D.D.
IF I were to write a book on any phase of Romanisni
it would be likely to reek with Protestant prejudice,
I having been born and bred and theologized that
way. But my friend Allen W. Johnston, who is a plain
business man and therefore without any dyed-in-the-
wool bias, is in a position to give, as they say, even the
devil his due.
If the book seems to militate against the Catholic
Church — and I confess it squints that way to me — the
reader will at once perceive that not the author but his
facts are to be blamed for it. Unless I am much mis-
taken he will be set down as one of the most magnan-
imous pirates that ever scuttled a ship. He reasons so
well and withal in such a kindly spirit that if I were to
offer any criticism — as he has frankly challenged me to
do — it would be on the ground that he is so oppressively
polite. However, his argument must stand on its own
bottom and there, in my modest judgment, it stands well.
To hale the Hierarchy before the bar of the Douay
Version was a happy thought, not unlike that of John
Bunyan who wrote his apologia for Pilgrims Progress
on this wise:
"I find that Holy Writ, in many places,
Hath semblance with this method; where the cases
Do call for one thing to set forth another :
Use it I may then, and yet nothing smother
Truth's golden beams ; nay, by this method may
Make it cast forth its rays as light as day."
5
PREFACE
THE purpose of the author is to set forth the Holy
Scripture, while pointing to the application made
of it in tenets of the Roman Catholic Church.
If the reader will give impartial attention, the author's
purpose will have met with success, and as we believe,
the reader edified.
[The author's work herein is from consideration given
the subject matter at various times during the past eight
years. Scriptural quotations are from the Douay Version
of the Holy Bible as used by the Roman Catholic Church.
As we ask attention in particular to the Douay Version
of Scripture, it is expected that copious quotations will
be made therefrom, in treating the subjects of these
pages.
The following quotations relating to its inspiration are
from the title pages of the Holy Bible according to the
Douay and Rheims Versions, with annotations by the
Rev. Dr. Challoner, authorized by the various CathoHc
bishops :
^'Inspiration as understood in this matter means a
certain influence of the Divine Spirit upon the mind of
a writer, moving h m to write, and so acting upon him
while he writes, that his work or writing is truly the
word of God."
*The proof of the inspiration of the Scriptures is easy
on Catholic principles. The Church of Christ has al-
ways held and taught the doctrine of the Scripture and
as the Church cannot err in what she teaches therefore
the Scriptures are inspired."
— Title Page — Douay and Rheims Version.
7
8 PREFACE
May not the time be approaching when Christendom
holding to faith in the Trinity, the Incarnation of the
Only Begotten Son of God, and His resurrection, will
for its own protection and for the needs of the world at
large require some material form of Christian union?
If Supremacy and Infallibility of the Popes, Invoca-
tion of Saints, the Worship of Mary, Purgatory, and
Prayer for the Dead, the construction placed upon the
Last Supper of Our Lord with His disciples by the
Roman Catholic tenet of "The Holy Eucharist," the Sac-
rifices of the Mass, Penance, Indulgences, the Forgive-
ness of Sins by Other Than Christ, are at variance with
the Scripture, they must therefore be placed in the cata-
logue of the church dogma, which is so large a part
of the tenets of the Roman Catholic Church.
A. W. J.
Schenectady, N. Y.
CONTENTS
CHAPTER PAGE
I. Primacy of Peter ii,
II. Infallibility and Supremacy of the
Popes 32
III. Invocation of Saints 50
IV. The Worship of Mary^ and the Immacu-
late Conception 60
V. The Holy Eucharist 71
VI. Purgatory 83
VII. The Sacrament of Penance ... 96
VIII. Indulgences ....... 109
IX. The Bible and the Church . . .116
X. Conclusion . . .; . . . . 134
PRIMACY OF PETER
CONSIDERATION of church unity is in recent
years fortunately augmented by public state-
ments of the late James Cardinal Gibbons. That
so highly esteemed a personality and authority should
present so plain a statement of the Roman Catholic posi-
tion, is most opportune.
We quote from an interview with the Archbishop, pub-
lished in a New York daily several years ago: (He was
reported not long before his death as again expressing
his willingness to lend such helping hand.)
"The re-union of the scattered branches of Christen-
dom is a consummation devoutly to be wished, and I
would gladly sacrifice the remaining years of my life in
lending a helping hand toward this blessed result. The
first essential requirement is the successor of St. Peter
as the divinely appointed head of Christendom. Once the
proper position of the Pope is recognized, I do not be-
lieve that the other contraverted doctrines are as formida-
ble as is commonly imagined."
No one outside of the Roman Catholic Church could
consistently question its privilege to select its own ec-
clesiastical rulers. It is when presuming that such rulers
should be at the head of Christendom, as an essential
requirement divinely appointed in effecting a union of
branches, that questioning becomes consistent.
There is room in Christ's Kingdom for all mankind
who will work in His name, though that Kingdom is not
II
12 THE ROMAN CATHOLIC BIBLE
of this world, for this world shall become the Kingdom
of our Lord and Saviour Jesus Christ.
So much truth is held in common in Christendom that
(using the word ^'Christendom" in its broadest sense)
we who are a part of it ought to have little or no dif-
ficulty in receiving and acknowledging the invitation.
"A just God and a Saviour; there is none beside me,
be converted to me, and you shall be saved, all ye ends
of the earth." ^
Where the invitation has been both received and ac-
cepted, may not the word given by the inspired and cou-
rageous Apostle Paul be accepted?
"For you are all one in Christ Jesus." ^
Paul's ministry was given amid daily experiences which
threatened disaster, yet he looked beneath the surface of
troubled waters and discerned the oneness of God's peo-
ple. Finding warring minds could be one in His own
love, much more were they one in a Supreme love; and
thus he wrote to the Philippians,
"In one spirit, with one mind laboring together for
the faith of the gospel." ^
May we not be hopeful that some day not far off
Christendom may realize how good it is for "brethren to
dwell together in unity " ?
With deep respect for the feelings of those w^ho hold
a belief either in the "Primacy of Peter" and the su-
premacy of the popes as his successors (or in the " His-
toric Episcopate") we submit that if those doctrines are
divinely appointed, and are essential in the Church of
Jesus Christ, then the barriers they raise against a com-
mon communion with those who refuse to accept them
are also divinely appointed and not to be called in ques-
tion. If, however, such doctrines are not of Divine
* Isaiah 45. ' Gal. 3. * Phil. i.
PRIMACY OF PETER 13
appointment nor essential in the Church of Jesus Christ,
there can be no substantial ground for the existence of
the barriers they raise.
In considering the question submitted, to present less
than one's sincere behef would be trifling with the ques-
tion; to assert one's belief without setting forth its
source, would be doing so without due consideration for
the question raised.
Charles Dickens truthfully wrote :
"There is nothing so strong or safe in any emergency
of Hfe as the simple truth."
A proven last will and testament forever bars out all
contradictory evidence of the purpose of the testator.
An executor of the will must base his acts upon the
proven Vv^ill. For the basis of our belief in Jesus Christ,
we must accept therefore the Old and New Testament,
and with them accept the admonition of the Apostle
Peter,
" The more firm prophetical word, whereunto you do
well to attend, understanding this first, that no prophecy
of Scripture is made by private interpretation."^
To the impulsive, genuine Peter, with his desire to be
at the front, was given a leadership among the disciples.
The deliberate, conservative James was made the pre-
siding head of the disciples at Jerusalem. To the loving
John, whose theme was the unity of God the Father
with man through Jesus Christ, was given a place on
the Saviour's breast. To Thomas was given the needed
placing of his hand in the side of his Lord, that he be
not faithless. To Paul, to whom is due the breaking
of the bread of life more than to any other disciple,
was given the opportunity to give that bread to the
Gentiles.
* II Peter i.
14 THE ROMAN CATHOLIC BIBLE
The question may fairly be asked by all ^vho unite
in belief in the Trinity, the Incarnation and the Resur-
rection if their neighbor organization, the Roman Cath-
olic Church, is utilizing its profession in these doctrines
as well as its Douay Version of the Holy Scriptures,
to best advantage. Is it giving forth from its high posi-
tion among the Christian people of the world, teach-
ings which accord with those doctrines and its version
of the Scriptures?
It is a privilege to take from a work entitled "The
Faith of Our Fathers," by the late James Cardinal Gib-
bons, of Baltimore, ^Id., an authentic review of these
"tenets" of the Roman Catholic Church referred to.
In the introduction to his book, the reverend author
says :
"I have imbibed her doctrine with my mother's milk.
I have made her history and theolog}^ the study of my
life."
From this authority we take the tenets which are un-
doubtedly those of the Romish Church.
Incidentally, in discussing the "Primacy of Peter,"
we also discuss the "Historic Episcopate."
Archbishop Gibbons has offered scriptural authority
for the various tenets of the Roman Catholic Church.
It is our purpose to review here his expressed convic-
tions of the Primacy of Peter and the supremacy of
the popes as Peter's successors, in the light of the
Scriptures, believing that in doing so we make plain the
supremacy of Jesus Christ only, in His own church,
both in the past and in the present, and the unity of the
apostles and all believers in Him, without respect of per-
sons. ^Manifestly, if such is the truth, the evidence of
such truth must perA^ade the Scriptures and not be de-
pendent solely upon a particular sentence of Scripture.
PRIMACY OF PETER 15
If, on the other hand, a supremacy so great in its re-
lation to
**the Church of the First Born who are written in the
heavens." ^
has indeed been given to an apostle who may act as a
sovereign ruler over His church and to popes who may
succeed, it must also follow, that evidence of such di-
vinely appointed authority must necessarily pervade the
Scriptures, especially that portion written during the
formation of the Christian Church.
If a pontiff and his advisers are divinely appointed as
sole and supreme custodians of the Holy Spirit in His
interpretations of the Word which is above all words,
then we may expect to find so profound a truth per-
vading all Scriptural teaching, and not to hinge upon
any one of its sentences.
In Archbishop Gibbons' expressed views of the
Primacy of Peter occurs the following:
"Any church that does not recognize Peter as its
foundation stone is not the church of Christ."
—Page 123
Is it possible for an apostle of our Lord to be a por-
tion of Plis Body and also to be the foundation of His
Body?
"He is the head of the body, the Church." «
"and cherisheth it as also Christ doth the Church be-
cause we are members of His Body, of His flesh, and
of His bones." ^
"The Lamb which was slain from the beginning of
the world." «
"In the beginning was the word and the word was
«Heb. 12. «Col. I. ''Eph. 5. ^Rqv, 13.
i6 THE ROMAN CATHOLIC BIBLE
with God and the word was God. . . . And the word
was made flesh and dwelt among us." ®
Shall we not therefore hold unitedly to the Gospel
message ?
And thus in holding on to the precious truth, must we
not of necessity agree that no disciple of Christ saved
by the Word, could possibly be the foundation of the
Church of Jesus Christ (His body) the Word made
flesh.
"For he is our peace who hath made both one, and
breaking down the middle wall of partition, the enmi-
ties in his flesh." ''
We however give space to a more ample quotation
from Archbishop Gibbons, in which the doctrine of Peter
as the foundation of the Church of Jesus Christ ap-
pears in his discussion of the 'Tnfallibility of the Pope,"
as follows :
The following passages of the Gospel spoken at dif-
ferent times were addressed exclusively to Peter — "Thou
art Peter and on this rock I will build my church, and
the gates of hell shall not prevail against it." *T the
Supreme Architect of the Universe," says our Saviour,
"will establish a church which is to last till the end of
time. I will lay the foundation of this church so deep
and strong on the rock of truth that the winds and
storms of error shall not prevail against it. Thou, O
Peter, shall be the foundation of this church. It shall
never fall because thou shalt never be shaken, because
thou shalt rest on Me, the rock of truth." The church
of which Peter is the foundation is declared to be im-
pregnable, that is, proof against error. How can you
suppose an immovable edifice built on a tottering foun-
dation, for it is not the building that sustains the founda-
tion, but it is the foundation that supports the build-
ing. —Page 151
»John I. lOEph.
PRIMACY OF PETER 17
In the above quotation from Cardinal Gibbons' book,
for first part given in quotation marks, reference is given
to Matthew 16. Although stating that "the following
passages of the gospel spoken at different times were
addressed exclusively to Peter," no such passages as
are in quotation marks have any reference given for
them, nor can they be found in the Roman Catholic
Bible, or in any version of the Bible known.
Further, the interpretation given by the Reverend
Author to the first quotation from Matt. 16, is not borne
out by Scripture.
The desire among the disciples for supremacy worked
itself out on various occasions. Once "in the way they
had disputed among themselves, which of them should
be the greatest" (and this apparently after the Rev-
erend Cardinal claims that Peter had been told by Our
Lord that he was to be the foundation for the church).
Our Lord, although addressing all of the disciples at
first, when Peter gave the true revelation of Jesus as
the Christ, addressed him, saying:
"Blessed are thou, Simon Barjona, because flesh and
blood hath not revealed it to thee, but my Father who
is in heaven." ^^
"And I say to thee: That thou art Peter, and upon
this rock I will build my church, and the gates of hell
shall not prevail against it."
Having thus declared against flesh and blood as the
power that enlightened Peter as to the Saviour's mis-
sion and His Deity, how can we properly interpret His
words as applying to flesh and blood as a foundation for
His church?
Having called attention before the disciples to Peter's
name of a stone or a rock (one word answering to both
11 Matt. 16.
i8 THE ROMAN CATHOLIC BIBLE
in the mother tongue of the country), He now speaks
of Himself as ''this Rock," upon which He will build
His church, witnessed by the Father's revelation through
Peter that He was the Christ, the Son of the living
God. Had the designation been Peter as the rock, it
would undoubtedly have been similar to the designa-
tion, "Thou, O Peter, shall be the foundation of this
church," as quoted above from Cardinal Gibbons' book,
instead of ''this rock," one name of the Deity, "The
Rock."
The Saviour evidently desired this witness of Him-
self ; and His command to the disciples that they should
"tell no one that He was Jesus Christ," is evidence that
they believed in Him as the Christ, although Peter was
the foremost to make the answer.
"And the rock was Christ." "
One difficulty found in the way of accepting these de-
ductions of Cardinal Gibbons, lies in the fact that when
looking for Peter's position in the Scriptural structure,
we find him to be a stone built on the Chief Corner
Stone.
"If so be you have tasted that the Lord is sweet,
unto whom coming as to a living stone, rejected indeed
oi men but chosen and made honorable by God. Be ye
also as living stone built up, a spiritual house, a holy
priesthood to offer up spiritual sacrifices acceptable to
God by Jesus Christ, wherefore it is said in the
Scripture; Behold I lay in Sion a chief corner stone,
elect, precious. And he that shall believe in him, shall
not be confounded." ^^
The chief corner stone of a structure is fundamental,
being rather of that completed foundation to which the
stones to be built up into a building are brought.
12 1 Cor. 10:4. ^^I Peter 2.
PRIMACY OF PETER 19
The Apostle Paul writes :
"You are God's building. According to the grace of
God that is given to me, as a wise architect, I have laid
the foundation; and another buildeth thereon. But let
every man take heed how he buildeth thereupon, for
other foundation no man can lay than that which is laid
which is Christ Jesus." ^*
"Christ as the Son in his own house: which house
are we, if we hold fast the confidence and glory of hope
unto the end." ^^
Built upon the foundation of the apostles and prophets,
Jesus Christ himself being the chief corner stone: In
whom all the building, being framed together, groweth
up into an holy temple in the Lord." ^^
We meet with yet another difficulty in accepting the
Apostle Peter as the foundation of the Church of Christ ;
thus if we make the Lord's words to apply to Peter
as the rock upon which the church is to be builded, we
must of necessity make a personal application to Peter
of the Lord's words on the same occasion, when
"Turning, who said to Peter, Go behind me,
Satan." ^^
It is true that afterward Peter became strong, par-
taking of the nature of the Rock, but so did the other
apostles, including the doubting Thomas.
Peter had made in the one a confession of the Rock
on which the spiritual house was to grow into an holy
temple in the Lord ; in the other instance he was rebuked
for unbelief in the Lord's broken body as the Church
of Jesus Christ. There we have a consistent interpre-
tation of our Lord's words. For if the gates of hell
could on this occasion and later prevail even though
^* I Cor. 3 : 9, 10, II. i« Eph. 2.
15 Heb. 3. 1^ Matt. 16.
20 THE ROMAN CATHOLIC BIBLE
temporarily against Peter, such a foundation for the
Church of Christ would be insecure, when he temporarily
denied Him who prayed for him, and rescued him from
the desire of Satan to sift him as wheat. On the con-
trary, Peter's confession of Christ as the Son of the
living God is a sure foundation, making us one with
Him who is the Rock, Christ Jesus.
''And they drank of the spiritual rock that followed
them and the rock was Christ." ^^
The giving of the keys of the Kingdom of Heaven to
Peter, and the binding and loosing which naturally fol-
lowed the use of the keys, was no greater gift of power
than that which later was a gift to all the disciples, of
binding and loosing, namely:
"Again I say to you that if two of you shall consent
upon earth concerning anything whatsoever they shall
ask, it shall be done to them by my Father who is in
Heaven." ^^
How can the giving of the keys of the Kingdom of
Heaven have any other meaning than the preaching and
teaching of Christ and Him crucified, that work which
the disciples were to take up in His name who Himself is
the door of the fold.
"For you are all the children of God by faith in
Christ Jesus." ''
"And believing shall rejoice with joy unspeakable and
glorified receiving the end of your faith, even the salva-
tion of your souls." ^^
The college president who reminds the graduate that
he now has the keys to a great degree of success, may
consistently say the same to every member of the gradu-
ating class.
18 I Cor. 10. 19 Matt. i8. 20 Gal. 3. 21 1 Peter i.
PRIMACY OF PETER 21
The Mayor of London in giving the keys of the city
to a guest, does not give with them a lordship over the in-
habitants; an opportunity only is given
In sending forth the disciples, Jesus said,
"As the Father hath sent me, I also send you. When
he had said this, he breathed on them and he said to
them. Receive ye the Holy Ghost." ^^
The guidance of the Holy Spirit is made supreme,
and no other authority was placed between Him and
his early disciples. They chose from among the number
of disciples those to whom a special work was given,
and all followed the Spirit.
'Teter is even called by St. Matthew The first
apostle.' " — Cardinal Gibbons. — Page 126
Both Andrew and Peter met the Saviour when He
was with John the Baptist, but now when called into
discipleship, with the promise that He would make them
fishers of men, they are mentioned in the order in which
they were chosen.
"And Jesus walking by the Sea of Galilee, saw two
brethren, Simon who is called Peter, and Andrew his
brother." ^3
"And going on from thence he saw other two brethren,
James the son of Zebedee and John his brother."
In the synoptic gospel, Peter's name uniformly appears
first in this group of four.
Immediately following an admonition there is given
to Peter the warning that Satan desired him, that he
might sift him as wheat, and the Lord's saying,
"But I have prayed for thee that thy faith fail not." "*
Upon this statement of our Lord, Cardinal Gibbons
makes the following comment :
22 John 20. 23 Matt. 4. 24 Luke 22.
22 THE ROMAN CATHOLIC BIBLE
"It is worthy of note that Jesus prays only for Peter.
And why for Peter in particular? Because on his
shoulders was to rest the burdem of the Church. . . .
We know that the prayer of Jesus is always heard, there-
fore the faith of Peter will always be firm. He was
destined to be the oracle which all were to consult."
—Page 152
But how may we reconcile the Archbishop's expres-
sions with the following Scripture from the Apostle
Peter :
"If any man speak, let him speak as the words of God.
If any man minister, let him do it as of the power which
God administereth" ^^
The apostle, if he had been given a primacy over the
church of Jesus Christ, endowed with the responsibility
of being the "oracle which all were to consult," would
have been throwing off that responsibility if he had ex-
horted all speaking to "speak as the words of God."
Peter when writing this Scripture, was impelled by the
same Spirit which prompted this prayer of his Lord,
when about to leave His disciples,
"That they all may be one as thou, Father, in me, and
I in thee, that they alsd may be one in us." ^^
The strife between the disciples as to which should
be greatest is sufficient evidence that their Lord had
never instituted a primacy in Peter, nor had made known
that one of their number was an oracle whom all were
to consult.
On the other hand, they were expressly told that
"The Holy Ghost whom the Father will send in my
name, he will teach you all things." ^^
The leavetaking would seem to have been, of all
times, the time, when had there been a supremacy ac-
corded to any disciple of our Lord, such a supremacy
25 1 St. Peter 4:11. 26 John 17. 27 John 14.
PRIMACY OF PETER 23
would have been made known, and the apostle so ap-
pointed have been acknowledged as "Vicar of Christ."
Instead of such a manifestation at the Last Supper,
we find the disciple whom Jesus loved, leaning upon His
breast, and the lovable and impulsive Peter asking him
to question his Lord as to who should be the betrayer.
Could language be used more effectually in setting
forth the Saviour's love for His disciples and His desire
to have them understand their oneness in Him, than that
used by our Lord on this occasion? How could their
desire of supremacy have had a more gentle rebuke than
by having their Lord gird Himself and wash their feet?
"In the apostolic council of Jerusalem, Peter is the
first whose sentiments are recorded. Before his dis-
course 'there was much disputing,' but when he had
ceased to speak 'all the multitude held their peace.' St.
James and the other apostles concur in the sentiments
of Peter without a single dissenting voice."
— Archbishop Gibbons — Page 127
We find upon referring to the Book of Acts, that it
was the Apostle James who presided at Jerusalem in a
general assembly.
"and when we were come to Jerusalem the brethren
received us gladly, and the day following Paul went in
with us unto James, and all the ancients were as-
sembled." 28
At the apostolic conference referred to by Archbishop
Gibbons, after much disputing, in which opposite sides
evidently appeared, Peter set forth his argument, siding
with Paul and Barnabas. Then Peter rested,
"And all the multitude held their peace." ^'^
Then Paul and Barnabas were heard,
28 Acts 21. 29 Acis 15.
24 THE ROMAN CATHOLIC BIBLE
*'And after they had held their peace, James answered,
saymg: Men, brethren, hear me."
Here the Apostle James sums up the case and renders
his decision, as follows :
"For which cause I judge that they, who from among
the Gentiles, are converted to God, are not to be dis-
quieted."
Does Peter appear as an oracle here, differing in any
way as such from Paul or Barnabas, and does not James
render the decision rather than Peter?
This decision was incorporated in a letter which was
sent to Antioch, *'For it hath seemed good to the Holy
Ghost and to us to lay no further burden upon you than
these necessary things."
It is not Peter who spoke, nor James the brother of
our Lord, who presided, nor John the beloved disciple,
who are mentioned here as holding a supremacy, but the
Holy Ghost, a recognition of a fulfillment of our Lord's
promise to send them the Holy Ghost, who should teach
His disciples all things, and it was on His teaching
they relied in rendering their decision embodied in the
letter to Antioch.
Such a primacy as made Peter a Vicar of Christ would
therefore seem not to have existed, for such a confer-
ence as that held at Jerusalem would have been out of
the question with such a responsibility resting upon Peter
as the following quotation from Archbishop Gibbons in-
dicates :
**To my mind the New Testament establishes no doc-
trine unless it satisfies every candid reader that our Lord
gave plenipotentiary powers to Peter to govern the whole
Church." — Page 122
Paul's controversy with Peter at Antioch brings out
plainly a withstanding against Peter's time serving, and
PRIMACY OF PETER 25
in Paul's reference to the Mother Church at Jerusalem,
there is no supremacy of Peter recognized.
"And when they had known the grace that was given
to me, James and Cephas and John, who seemed to be
pillars, gave to me and Barnabas the right hands of fel-
lowship: that we should go unto the Gentiles, and they
unto the circumcision." ^^
It is of import in considering such a question as the
supremacy of one of the apostles, that the inspired
Scripture account should in naming pillars of the Mother
Church, make no distinguishing feature of a Vicar of
Christ, but, on the contrary, mention the Apostle Peter
after James who presided at Jerusalem.
The following statement of Paul in referring to Peter,
indicates Peter's deference to James :
"For before that some came from James, he did eat
with the Gentiles, but when they were come, he withdrew
and separated himself, fearing them who were of the
circumcision."
The equality in the Church of the Apostles and Dis-
ciples is again distinctly noted by Paul.
"For he who wrought in Peter to the apostleship of
the circumcision, wrought in me also among the Gen-
tiles." 31
As among themselves, the apostles were subject one
to another, as also they unitedly looked to the Head of
the Church, as Paul wrote to the Colossians :
"And he is the head of the body, the church ; who is
the beginning, the firstborn from the dead ; that in all
things he may hold the primacy." ^-
Is it in any manner likely that Paul when making
such expressions of the government of the church, would
have made no mention, especially to churches being
«o Gal. 2 : 9, 12. 81 Gal. i : 8. 3- Col. i : 18.
26 THE ROMAN CATHOLIC BIBLE
formed, of a Vicar of Christ who had been given "pleni-
potentiary powers to govern the whole church/' had such
a power been given?
Instead of having given plenipotentiary power to Peter
or to any of His apostles "to govern the whole church/'
we find Christ recognized by Paul as being still the
Apostle and High Priest.
"Wherefore, holy brethren, partakers of the heavenly
calling, consider the Apostle and High Priest of our con-
fession, Jesus/' ^^
That Paul's rebuke to Peter was not such an offense
as would have been justly considered an act of dis-
obedience to one to whom Christ had given the governor-
ship, with infalHble power to rule, may readily be ob-
served when in Peter's own words we read:
"And accounting the long suffering of our Lord's sal-
vation, as also our most dear brother Paul, according
to the wisdom given him hath written to you," "As also
in all his epistles speaking in them of these things/'
"In which are certain things hard to be understood,
which the unlearned and unstable wrest, as they
do also the other Scriptures to their own destruc-
tion/' 3*
We find that it is the infallibility of the Scriptures
that proves the fallibility of mankind, and of all church
organizations. None are excepted save Jesus Christ, the
Head of His own Church, who through long suffering
offers His mercy to all. We find the Interpreter of the
Holy Scriptures to be the Holy Spirit.
"Now we have received, not the spirit of this world,
but the spirit that is of God; that we may know the
things that are given us from God. Which things also
we speak, not in the learned words of human wisdom,
»3 Heb. 3:1. ^^ II Peter 3 : 15, 16.
PRIMACY OF PETER 27
but in the doctrine of the Spirit, comparing spiritual
things with spiritual." ^^
It is not enough to say that unity in common com-
munion of all who hold to the Apostles' Creed is de-
sirable; it is obvious from many points of view that
such unity is becoming more and more essential to good
government in every land.
God's people may in their various denominations, say
with Peter on the Mount of Transfiguration:
*'Lord, it is good for us to be here; if thou wilt, let
us make here three tabernacles ; one for thee, and one
for Moses, and one for Elias."^^
But when the bright cloud which overshadows, and
the Voice shall have passed, only Jesus will be seen and
heard.
Francis J. Hall, D.D., in his article, "The Anglican
Position," appearing in the September, 1913, "Construc-
tive Quarterly," defines such position in the following
words :
"The Anglican Church is instinctively cautious and
patient because it aims ultimately to bring about visible
unity among all who confess our Lord Jesus Christ as
God and Saviour."
This declaration, like that recently given by Arch-
bishop Gibbons, is an encouraging sign of the working
of the spirit of unity in the minds and hearts of eminent
preachers and teachers, whose daily influence extends
throughout a wide circle.
We quote again from Dr. Hall's article :
"But no results of historical inquiry have altered the
validity of the Anglican assertion that apart from the
Historic Episcopate, the organic unity of Christendom
cannot be obtained."
3^1 Cor. 2:12, 13. 8«Matt. 17.
28 THE ROMAN CATHOLIC BIBLE
While all who devoutly desire a visible unity of
Christ's people, may without hesitation accept the declar-
ation that "it is part of the equipment of the Anglican
Communion to be a church of reconciliation," it is ap-
parent that apart from the communion of the Anglican
Church, such visible unity is considered by Dr. Hall to
be impossible.
Unlike Archbishop Gibbons, w4io presents Scripture
in support of the Roman Catholic Church's position, the
author of ''The Anglican Position" leaves the reader to
infer that support for the Anglican position exists as
well in history as in the present attitude of that Church,
and may be ascertained by scholarly investigation.
Dr. Hall further defines the Anglican position as fol-
lows :
"The Anglican position summarily described is the
ancient Catholic position guarded by a limited range of
definitions and embodied in a working system which at
once protects the Catholic faith and religion from sub-
version and permits constant adjustment of the chang-
ing conditions of human thought and life."
Since we find that the gift above every gift is to all
who will receive believing, and that to him who hath
an ear may come the Gospel message, shall we not de-
voutly believe that w^ithout making the definitions or
working system of any particular position supreme, we
have as Christ's children, already come a long way to-
ward presenting to all people the Church of Christ, un-
trammeled by any preempting supremacy.
If we cannot with good conscience accept a doctrine
which precludes a consideration that the Supreme Head
of the church may, at any period in its history, establish
a priesthood of which Melchisedick was a type, one with-
out genealogical record, we may however be in accord
PRIMACY OF PETER 29
with the doctrine contained in the seventh chapter of
Hebrews, and beHeve that there was a Man, a
'Triest of the Most High God" (without pedigree), ^^
before bishops were ordained in any denomination of
the Christian Church, and that He whom we most adore
is after his order.
We have in the following statement of Dr. Hall,
an important admission from the viewpoint of a scho-
lar:
"The Anglican Church began its properly organized
existence under Archbishop Theodore in the Seventh
Century, as both Catholic and National . . . the papal
supremacy was not then fully developed, and formal
definitions of its scope and implications were as yet lack-
ing: but that some kind of supremacy over the whole
church on earth had been divinely given to Saint Peter
and to his successors in the Roman See, was taken for
granted by all Western Christendom, not less in Eng-
land than elsewhere. This initial factor of acceptance
of the Catholic faith and order in its Western form,
with an indeterminate papal supremacy, has had, in spite
of the rejection of the papal government in the Six-
teenth Century, a determinate influence in the subsequent
development of the Anglican position/'
If we are to believe that, after seven hundred years
of the "Vicar of Christ" in successions of authority
over His church, there existed no formal definitions
of the papal supremacy, what must we believe as to the
existence or to the efficacy of such successions of suprem-
acy? That there were no such successions of divinely
appointed supremacy over the whole church on earth?
Or that Christ, the Head of the Church, had left His
Church to a supreme ruler or authority, who with his
87 Heb. 7.
30 THE ROMAN CATHOLIC BIBLE
successors had failed to impress the church with formal
definitions of so extraordinary a charge?
During the First Century of the Christian Church in
which the letters of the Apostles were written for the
edification and government of the Church, no definite
record is given to the church of such a supremacy of
Peter, or of any supremacy in the church, except that
accorded by the disciples to those they chose to govern
the churches and the natural precedence which pertained
to those disciples who were witnesses of Christ's per-
sonal ministr}', His first chosen disciples.
If development of the ''Historic Episcopacy" is due
to an "initial factor of acceptance of the Catholic faith
in its Western form, with an indeterminable papal
supremacy," why may there not be also other forms of
the Catholic faith, in which there might be no indeter-
minate papal supremacy or any succession of such
supremacy? And if so, should the ''Historic Episco-
pacy" become a barrier to a common communion of
Christ's people in an organic unit of Christendom?
If we agree that the initial factor at the beginning
of the visible Christian Church, was the work of the
Holy Spirit in the hearts and minds of a group of "igno-
rant and unlearned" disciples of Christ, may we not also
agree that the same spirit may bring into one organic
communion in Christ all who are open to the light?
When the Apostle John was in Patmos and saw
*'The Bride, the Wife of the Lamb,"^^
the city which he saw coming down out of heaven from
God, had therein no temple. He was told that those
who entered in were written in the Book of Life of the
Lamb, which writing we may all acknowledge with re-
3S Rev. 21 : g.
PRIMACY OF PETER 31
joicing is a more enduring and satisfactory recording
of our names than could be made in any temple.
If as denominations we were long ago halted on our
way to Damascus, when "the light from heaven shined
round about," and we listen to the voice of Jesus, we
may rest assured that which we left was but a shell,
while the wings we have taken on are bringing us swiftly
to the Holy City.
*^And the Spirit and the Bride say, Come." ^^
This loving invitation is from the Holy Spirit and
from the Church of Jesus Christ.
Two ambassadors representing themselves to be from
one country, each claiming supreme authority to repre-
sent their country, would not be received.
Can we deny the Scriptures which repeatedly inform
us that the Holy Spirit is to guide into all truth the
Church of Jesus Christ?
Listen to Peter's words at Pentecost : *^
*'But this is that which was spoken of by the Prophet
Joel: 'And it shall come to pass in the last days (saith
the Lord) I will pour out of My Spirit upon all flesh,
and your sons and your daughters shall prophesy.' "
Which supreme authority shall we accept? That of
the Holy Spirit with credentials from every book of
the Holy Scripture, the Prophets and Apostles, or that
of the Pope of Rome, whose credentials are all within
the Romish Church, none from Scriptures.
8« Rev. 22 : 17. 40 Acts 2:16.17.
II
INFALLIBILITY AND SUPREMACY OF THE
POPES
I
N his purpose to prove the infaUibility of the popes,
Cardinal Gibbons has this significant passage :
"First, The infallibility of the popes does not
signify that they are inspired. The Apostles were en-
dowed with the gift of inspiration and we accept their
writing as the revealed word of God."
*'No Catholic on the contrary claims that the pope is
inspired, or endowed with divine revelation, properly so
called."
"Bear in mind also that this divine assistance is guar-
anteed to the pope, not in his capacity as private teacher,
but only in his official capacity, when he judges of faith
and morals as head of the Church."
"What then is the real doctrine of infallibility? It
simply means that the pope as successor of St. Peter,
Prince of the Apostles, by virtue of the promises of
Jesus Christ, is preserved from error of judgment when
he promulgates to the Church a decision on faith or
morals." '- — Pages 146-9
Thus we learn from the above quotations the claim
is, not that the pope is inspired or endowed with divine
revelation, properly so called, but that when he promul-
gates to the church a decision on faith or morals, he
is infallible. But we learn from the prayer of Jesus for
His disciples (John 17: 14, 17, 18, 20, 21) that His prayer
was not only for the disciples, but for all who believed
on Him through their word, and also that they might
32
INFALLIBILITY OF POPES 33
be one as He and the Father were one, that the world
might beheve. Also that they might be one in the Father
and the Son. Furthermore, that the Father's Word had
been given them, *'I have given them thy word and the
world hath hated them because they are not of the
world/' ''Sanctify them in truth, thy word is truth."
We further learn that His disciples were to receive the
Holy Spirit, and that they were to be taught all truth.
"But I tell you the truth. It is expedient to you that
I go; for if I go not the Paraclete will not come to you;
but if I go I will send him to you." ^
"But when he the Spirit of Truth is come, he will
teach you all truth ; for he shall not speak of himself ;
but what things soever he shall hear he shall speak, and
the things that are to come he shall show you."
Thus we find the pope although infallible in his deci-
sion to the church on "faith and morals," is not claimed
to be inspired, nor endowed with divine revelation prop-
erly so called; while all of Christ's disciples were to re-
ceive the Holy Spirit and be taught in all truth, and
that even the Holy Spirit, unlike the pope, would not
speak of Himself, but would speak of the things He
should hear. It seems to be impossible to reconcile in
this respect the Holy Scripture and the claim made for
the pope, that Peter, a pope, was inspired, but no other
popes, but all popes infallible on a decision of faith.
That those who are one with Jesus and His Father
throughout all ages speak that which they hear from the
Holy Ghost, is fully proven by the Scriptures.
"I have baptized you with water, but He shall baptize
you with the Holy Ghost." ^
"Going therefore teach ye all nations, baptizing them
i John 16 : 7 and 13. - Mark i : 8.
34 THE ROMAN CATHOLIC BIBLE
in the name of the Father and of the Son and of the
Holy Ghost." 3
"And unto all nations the gospel must first be
preached. And when they shall lead you and deliver
you up, be not thoughtful beforehand what you shall
speak; but whatsoever shall be given you in that hour,
that speak ye; for it is not you that speak, but the
Holy Ghost." ^
"But the Paraclete, the Holy Ghost whom the Father
will send in my name, He will teach you all things and
bring all things to your mind, whatsoever I shall have
said to you." ^
"And on the last and great day of the festivity, Jesus"
stood and cried, saying, If any man thirst let him come
to me and drink. He that believeth in me, as the
Scripture saith, out of his belly shall flow rivers of
living water. Xow this he said of the Spirit, which they
should receive who believed in him ; for as yet the Spirit
Avas not given, because Jesus was not yet glorified." ^
From Scripture then, as plain as language can present
it, is the knowledge that the Holy Ghost represents
and brings to all who believe in Jesus as their Saviour,
the things of God; that the Holy Spirit is one with the
Father and with the Son, and that they who believe
and are His are also one with Christ, even as He is one
with the Father.
Surely His Reverence, Cardinal Gibbons, if he would
have the pope of equal authority in Christendom with
any believer in Jesus as his Saviour, must admit that
the pope is "endowed with divine revelation properly
so called," and if so, that when he speaks to his people
it is not he that speaks, but the Holy Ghost the same
3 Matt. 28 : 19. 5 John 14 : 26.
^ Mark 13 : 10. * John 7 : 37-39-
INFALLIBILITY OF POPES 35
Holy Spirit that teaches all things to all who believe in
Jesus as their Saviour.
*'And he that keepeth His Commandments abideth in
Him and He in him. And in this we know that He
abideth in us by the Spirit which He hath given us." ^
For possible want of other Scriptural texts from
which to fortify some of the particular tenets of the
Roman Catholic Church which we are discussing.
Cardinal Gibbons in his book frequently quotes the pas-
sages from Matt. 16 and John 20; upon which passages
we believe an unwarranted emphasis and interpretation
have been placed in the use made of them by the Rev-
erend Cardinal, as we find no Scripture in support of
such use. In referring again to these passages, we also
quote from the chapters the portion of Scripture im-
mediately preceding and following the verses quoted
by Cardinal Gibbons so frequently.
''Jesus saith to them, But whom do you say that I
am? Simon Peter answered and said: Thou art Christ,
the Son of the Living God. And Jesus answering said
to him: Blessed art thou, Simon Barjona: Because flesh
and blood hath not revealed it to thee, but my Father
who is in heaven. And I say to thee: That thou art
Peter: and upon this rock I will build my church,
and the gates of hell shall not prevail against it. And
I will give to thee the keys of the kingdom of heaven.
And whatsoever thou shalt bind upon earth, it shall be
bound also in heaven: And whatsoever thou shalt loose
on earth, it shall be loosed also in heaven. Then he
commanded his disciples, that they should tell no one
that he was Jesus the Christ. From that time Jesus
began to show to his disciples that he must go to Jeru-
salem, and suffer many things from the ancients and
scribes and chief priests, and be put to death, and the
third day rise again. And Peter taking him, began to
"' I John 3 : 24.
36 THE ROMAN CATHOLIC BIBLE
rebuke him, saying: Lord, be it far from thee, this
shall not be unto thee. Who turning, said to Peter:
Go behind me, Satan, thou art a scandal unto me : Be-
cause thou savourest not the things that are of God,
but the things that are of men." ^
At an earlier period in his ministry, before this meet-
ing with Peter and the other disciples, our Lord had
said:
*The law and the prophets were until John ; from that
time the Kingdom of God is preached and every one
useth violence towards it." ^
The people believed John the Baptist to be a prophet
and the common people heard Jesus gladly. The Sun
of Righteousness had risen with healing in His wings.
All creation being awakened, the birds, the blossoms,
the field, the brook, the sea, were all to lend their voices
to the putting forth of the Word of Life. The blind
were brought by a way they knew not. The lame
walked, the lepers were cleansed, and the poor had the
Gospel preached unto them. Now, in the closing months
of our Lord's ministry, after the teachings of the
Sermon on the Mount and His going about with His
disciples, they were to be drawn closer to Him in serv-
ice and love and eventually to receive those keys of
the Kingdom of Heaven, which would be delivered to
them after the tarrying at Jerusalem, and the receiving
of the Power which was to accompany the Holy Ghost
which after His resurrection He breathed upon them.
The Kingdom of Heaven would be told in likeness by
parables. The teachings of our Lord would continue
to fit the disciples for their future work. They would
eventually find the door of the sheepfold of which He
has spoken. The Good Shepherd, the Pearl of Great
8 Matt. i6: 15 to 23. ^ Luke 16: 16.
INFALLIBILITY OF POPES tj
Price, they would see the falling of the seed into the
poor soil and into the good. They were to cast the
gospel net, and all to be guided by the Holy Spirit
whom they were to follow and with Christ Jesus who
was to work with them. The keys which He held
they were to use, and those keys have been used by all
devout followers of the Lord in all ages since, and will
be used by all of His followers in the Gospel for all ages
to come, " 'til every knee shall bow and every tongue
confess."
As Simon Peter was the first to answer, he was the
first to receive the keys which were afterward so men-
tioned as being given to all of His disciples.
No sooner had Peter in his exaltation realized that
he was thus to be one of the apostles upon whose teach-
ings of the Gospel, together with those of the prophets
who had preceded him, the Church of our Lord was
to be builded, than he took, at the instigation of Satan,
to rebuking our Lord for His teaching that He was to
suffer as our atonement.
It was then that the revelation was made to him by
Our Lord that whereas the Father in Heaven had re-
vealed the Christ to him, that now his anything but in-
fallibility had led him to accept the teachings of anti-
Christ as he had heretofore accepted the teaching of the
Spirit. And the rebuke of his loving Saviour when he
was told that he savored not of the things of God, but
of men, prepared him to meet later with a penitent heart
the Christ who was to forgive him for his later denial.
"And when He had said this, He shewed them His
hands and His side. The disciples therefore were glad
when they saw the Lord.'' *'He said therefore to them
again. Peace be to you." "When he had said this, He
breathed on them, and He said to them. Receive ye the
38 THE ROMAN CATHOLIC BIBLE
Holy Ghost." "Whose sins you shall forgive they are
forgiven them, and whose sins you shall retain, they
are retained." ^^
By these words and this act of making ambassadors
of His disciples, Jesus did not give over His preroga-
tive, that which is written in words w^hich will stand
although heaven and earth pass away.
"God hath spoken once, these two things have I heard,
that power belongeth to God, and mercy to thee, O
Lord. . . ."^1
"O Lord, to us belongeth confusion of face, to our
princes, and to our fathers that have sinned."
"But to thee the Lord our God, mercy and forgive-
ness, for we have departed from thee." ^^
"I the Lord, this is my name : I will not give my glory
to another, nor my praise to graven things." ^^
To infer from the words of Jesus to Llis disciples,
as quoted from John, Chapter 20, that He was to leave
them and give over to them, or to Peter alone. His pre-
rogative for forgiveness of sins, is contrary to all
Scripture. He was ever with them.
"Now Thomas, one of the twelve who is called
Didymus, was not with them when Jesus came." "The
other disciples therefore said to him: We have seen
the Lord, But he said to them, Except I shall see in
His hands the print of the nails and put my finger
into the place of the nails, and put my hand into His
side, I will not believe."
"And after eight days again His disciples were with-
in and Thomas with them. Jesus cometh, the doors
being shut, and stood in the midst and said, Peace be
to you." "Then He said to Thomas, Put in thy finger
1^ John 20 : 20-23. ^- Dan. 9 : 8-9.
11 Psalm 61 : 12. is isa. 42 : 8.
INFALLIBILITY OF POPES 39
Jhither, and see my hands : And bring hither thy hand,
and put it into my side : And be not faithless but behev-
ing." Thomas answered and said to Him, My Lord
and My God/' "Jesus saith to him, Because thou hast
seen me, Thomas, thou hast beheved. Blessed are they
that have not seen, and have believed." ''Many other
signs also did Jesus in the sight of His disciples which
are not written in this book." "But these are written
that you may believe that Jesus is the Christ the Son of
God and that believing you may have life in His
name." ^*
It is apparent that these words were written, not that
centuries after the Roman Catholic Church should claim
a special privilege of commanding the Church of Christ
and a prerogative for the forgiveness of sins, but rather
that "you may believe that Jesus is the Christ the Son
of God, and that believing you may have life in His
Name."
Thomas was converted, received the Holy Ghost which
bade him cry out, "my Lord and my God," and his sins
upon that confession were remitted, as also were the sins
of all who believed on the day of Pentecost. Those who
believed not, their sins were retained both upon earth
and in heaven, as it has ever since been, as in John 3 : 18,
"But he that doth not believe is already judged," and
*'he that believeth in him is not judged."
Let us here consider the phrase, "And upon this Rock
I will build my Church."
In Douay Version of Holy Scripture, Deut. 32 : 3 & 4,
we read,
"Because I will invoke the name of the Lord, give ye
magnificence to our God."
"The works of God are perfect, and all his ways are
1* John 20: 4-31.
40 THE ROMAN CATHOLIC BIBLE
judgments. God is faithful and without any iniquity,
he is just and right."
In the 4th Verse, the name of the Lord, "The Rock/'
is given in King James Version and left out in Douay
Version. Notice the difference in the translation:
"Because I will publish the name of the Lord, ascribe
ye greatness to our God.'' ''He is the Rock." "His
work is perfect; for all his ways are judgment, a God
of truth and without iniquity, just and right is he."
— King James Version.
Whatever the significance may be, the Hebrew w^ord
for "Rock," Exodus 17: 6, the Rock Horeb w^hich Moses
w'as commanded by the Lord to "strike," is not the same
word as that for "Rock," Numbers 20:8, "The Flint
Rock" at Kadesh, which Moses was to "speak to." The
name "Kadesh," meaning holy, is the same w^ord as the
Arabic name of Jerusalem.
A study of the Hebrew word "hatzur" reveals the
"ha" standing for the definite article "the." This article
here used has the same meaning as in the New Testa-
ment, where it is applied to Jesus as "the Son of God."
The word "tzur" used for rock, refers to flint; a rock
out of which implements with sharp edges w^ere made.
We may therefore read the sentence, "He is the flint
rock."
The song contained in II Kings (II Samuel), Douay
Version, is the same song contained in the 17th Psalm,
Douay Version (i8th Psalm, King James Version).
In the Douay Version, II Kings (II Samuel), 22nd
Chapter, 2nd Verse, it reads :
"And he said: the Lord is my rock and my strength
and my Saviour."
while in the Douay version of the song in the 17th Psalm,
3rd Verse, the reading is
INFALLIBILITY OF POPES 41
"The Lord is my firmament, my refuge and my de-
liverer." ^^
The word ''rock" as above in Douay Version, II
Kings, 22nd Chap., 2nd Verse, is the same as in Deut.
32 : 4th Verse of King James Version, ''tzur," flint.
The deduction from the study of the word "hatzur"
rock, the flint rock as the name of our Lord, is reason-
able, made so by the following reference to His name
given in Douay version, Deut. 8: 15, ''Who brought forth
streams out of the hardest rock," or as in the same
Chapter and Verse of King James Version,
"Who brought thee forth water out of the rock of
flint."
We here have one reason for God's judgment upon
Moses and Aaron, Numbers 20: 12,
"And the Lord said to Moses and Aaron, Because
you have not believed me to sanctify me before the
children of Israel, you shall not bring these people
into the land which I will give them."
Instead of obeying the command of God to speak
to the rock, which symbolized their Lord as the flint
rock. Numbers 20 : 8, Moses used the rod which was to
be used in assembling the people to strike the rock which
was the "hatzur," "the flint rock," the name of Deity.
"Take the rod and assemble the people together, thou
and Aaron thy brother, and speak to the rock before
them, and it shall yield waters." "Moses therefore took
the rod which was before the Lord, as he had com-
manded him," "And having gathered together the multi-
tude before the rock, he said to them, Hear, ye rebelHous
and incredulous : Can we bring you forth water out of
this rock?"
^5 Psalms 17:3, Douay Version, reads ^'firmament" ; Psalms
18 : 2, King James Version, reads "rock."
42 THE ROMAN CATHOLIC BIBLE
"And when Moses had Hfted up his hand and struck
the rock twice with the rod, there came forth water
in great abundance, so that the people and their cattle
drank."
We desire to make the connection now with the Lord
Jesus' words to Peter, Matt. i6: 15 to 19:
"Jesus saith to them : But whom do ye say that I am ?
Simon Peter answered and said : Thou art Christ the Son
of the living God."
"And Jesus answering said to him, Blessed art thou,
Simon Barjona, because flesh and blood hath not re-
vealed it to thee but my father who is in heaven."
"And I say to thee that thou art Peter and upon this
rock I will build my church and the gates of hell shall
not prevail against it."
"And I will give to thee the keys of the Kingdom of
Heaven, and whatsoever thou shalt bind upon earth, it
shall be bound also in heaven, and whatsoever thou
shalt loose on earth, it shall be loosed in heaven."
It is not possible that after having been proclaimed as
the "Rock," "The Good Shepherd," "The Door," "The
Vine," "I am the way, the truth and the life : no man
cometh to the Father but by me," that Our Lord and
Saviour would have given over His name to mortal
fallible man. Can any thoughtful person hesitate in de-
ciding as to whom Our Lord refers as the foundation
for His Church, when He speaks of Peter (a stone) and
"This Roc.c"?
Could it be otherwise than that the Peter who was
to be joined to his Lord by a living faith, through which
he even now recognizes the Christ, was to be one with
his Lord as were also all who should abide in Him and
He in them even as He was one with the Father?
"Abide in me and I in you. As the branch cannot
INFALLIBILITY OF POPES 43
bear fruit of itself unless it abide in the vine, so neither
can you except you abide in me."
"If you abide in me and my word abide in you, you
shall ask whatsoever you will, and it shall be done unto
you." i«
We learn from the Scripture that all believers are not
fully inspired as oracles of God for the purpose those
were to whom was committed the writing of the Holy
Scriptures, for except in the gift to His Only Begotten
Son, God gives by measure, but every disciple who by
the Spirit of God speaks as the oracle of God, speaks
infallible words, as the Scripture here says :
"But he who is joined to the Lord is one spirit." ^'^
"According as God hath divided to every one the
measure of faith." ^^
"But to every one of us is given grace, according to
the measure of the giving of Christ." ^^
"How much more will your Father from Heaven give
the good spirit to them that ask him." ^^
Does not the written word of God both inspire and
reveal, and yet no disciple of Jesus Christ named in
Scripture calls himself "infallible."
Shall we not then, every soul who feels the need of
building his house upon a Rock, and not on sinking sand,
cry out in the Holy Spirit as did David:
"The Lord is my rock, my strength, and my
Saviour." ^^
"The spirit of the Lord hath spoken by me and His
word by my tongue." ^^
Seemingly with prophetic foresight, even after all the
prophesies of Jesus Christ as the one foundation of
i« John 15 : 4-7. 1^ Eph. 4:7. 21 u Kings 22 : 2.
17 I Cor. 6 : 17. 20 i^xike 11 : 13. 22 n Kings 23 : 2.
1® Romans 12 : 3.
44 THE ROMAN CATHOLIC BIBLE
which no other could be laid for His Church, there is
given by Peter himself a refutation of certain claims that
in these later days of the world are made in his name —
refutation like that of both prophets and apostles who
have witnessed in Scripture, so clear as to be unmis-
takable to sincere seekers of truth.
*Tf so be that ye have tasted that the Lord is
sweet."
"Unto whom coming as to a living stone, rejected in-
deed by men but chosen and made honorable by God."
"Be you also as living stones, built up a spiritual
house, a holy priesthood to offer up spiritual sacrifices,
acceptable to God by Jesus Christ." ^^
What is the meaning of "church" where it proposed
that the "church" is and shall be custodian of the Holy
Spirit who is in the Written Word of God, by faith.
Spirit and life? The "church" that is infallible, and pro-
poses to dictate the policy of all Christendom, or of
believers in Christ?
Shall we make answer by saying it is the Roman
Catholic Church, the pope and hierarchy, a governing
power? The pope being the Vicar of Christ? If so,
where in such an institution do we find the church of
the Roman Catholic Bible — His church, His body?
"Again I say to you, that if two of you shall con-
sent upon earth concerning anything whatsoever they
shall ask, it shall be done to them by my Father who is
in heaven." -*
The above verse of Scripture was uttered by Our
Saviour after it is claimed that Peter was made the Vicar
of Christ, an oracle whom all were to consult.
And there is no restriction as to the time when the
request should be made, simply that if made with con-
23 I Peter 2 to 5. 24 Matt. 18 : 19.
INFALLIBILITY OF POPES 45
sent by any two of the disciples whatsoever it might be
that was asked, it should be done by the Father. Who
is the oracle consulted^ here ? Peter, or the Father in
heaven ?
The Roman Catholic Bible thus describes the Church :
"As Christ is the head of the Church He is the Saviour
of His Body." 25
"And He is the Head of the Body, the Church, Who
is the beginning." ^^
Paul evidently makes the church to be the believers
in Christ Jesus when he writes thus of his experience
before he was himself a believer :
"According to zeal, persecuting the church of God."
All references to the church of Jesus Christ who was
the Beginning, show it to be the sheep whom Peter was
to feed, himself a part of it, as have been all pastors
since, who have been bishops of the flock.
Not infallible oracles, who should claim the place of
the Holy Ghost in determining and governing the be-
lievers in Christendom irrevocably.
The church of Christ is made to be a body governed,
and that primarily by Christ Flimself through the Holy
Ghost, rather than a governing agency composed of men
who claim to have been appointed by God to a primacy
over the church of Christ.
The claim that the Roman Catholic Church is infal-
lible and that the pope is the Vicar of Christ on earth,
falls through of its own weight, for if it were infallible,
it would have performed an infallible part in history,
and as a Vicar of Christ the pope would have had a
monopoly of the things of Christ which history shows
they have been far from having. God is one, and is not
divided.
25 Eph. 5 : 23. 2« Col. 1 : 18.
46 THE RO:\L\X CATHOLIC BIBLE
"In this we know that we abide in Him and He in us
because He hath given us of His Spirit."-^
"The history of the United States with the presidents
left out would be more intelligible than the history of
the church to the exclusion of the vicar of Christ."
"You cannot, my dear reader, be a loyal citizen of
the L^nited States while you deny the constituted author-
ity of the president."
—Cardinal Gibbons, "Faith of Our Fathers/'
The \'icar of Christ is recognized by all Protestant
churches. lie is the Holy Ghost promised to be sent
by Our Saviour when He was about to go away. The
Vicar of Christ is not the pope of Rome.
But what must we believe when we find the presidents
of the L^nited States by their acts, their signed docu-
ments as President filling pages of history, while when
looking for some such correspczdine evidence of a Vicar
of Christ in the ::rr: :* :. 3 t :: ? ::.e, we find no
such constituted au:v. i: : t : :r I ::. Scripture, but
do find definite sta: : t: :s ciitn : : : :3ut the Bible,
of the personal gi::i : r :: His Ch ::/. : v Jesus Christ
and by the Holy 5 : :.
Think of the Preside:.: :: :' e L':: :ed States directing
an official letter or 'pTCzL:.:zi^ZLzr. :: :::e citizens of tbe
L^nited States, and making no n:e:.:::r. of his officml
position as Chief Executive or President, yet where do
we find in any of Peter^s preaching, a reference to his
having been appointed by Jesus Christ His vicar on
earth, or of any such reference on the part of any other
writer of the New Testament?
How can any portion of the Church of Jesus Christ
or any body of men calling themselves the church of
^1 John 4:13.
INFALLIBILITY OF POPES 47
Jesus Christ justly claim to be infallible in their own
dogma ?
"But you will say: The people of the United States
prefer to be a Christian nation. Do you also claim
them? Most certainly: for even those American
Christians, who are unhappily severed from the Catholic
Church, are primarily indebted for their knowedge of
the gospel to missionaries in communion with the Holy
See/' ...
"Thus we see that the name of the Pope is indelibly
marked on every page of Ecclesiastical history. The
Sovereign Pontiff ever stands before us as commander-
in-chief in the grand army of the church." . . .
"You might as well shut out the light of day, and the
air of heaven from your daily walk, as exclude the Pope
from his legitimate sphere in the hierarchy of the
Church.^' : — ^"Faith of our Fathers," page 142.
How did the gospel come to those to whom Peter ad-
dressed his first letter?
Was it not by the accompanying Holy Ghost?
"Peter an apostle of Jesus Christ to the strangers dis-
persed through Pontus, Galatia, Cappadocia, Asia,
Bithynia, Elect."
"Receiving the end of your faith even the salvation
of your souls."
"Of which salvation the prophets have inquired and
diligently searched, who prophesied of the grace to come
to you."
"To whom it was revealed, that not to themselves
but to you they ministered those things that are now de-
clared to you. By them that have preached the gospel
to you, the Holy Ghost being sent down from heaven
on whom the angels desire to look."^^
The only reference in thq New Testament to any pre-
^s I Peter i : 9, 10, 12.
48 THE ROMAN CATHOLIC BIBLE
eminent authority claimed or possessed by any person-
age, that could be construed as a supremacy in the
Church of Christ, by any of its members, is found in
the third letter of the Apostle John, which letter is di-
rected to the "dearly beloved Gaius,'' instead of to the
church ; the reason therefor is given by the Apostle John
as follows:
"I had written perhaps to the church : but Diotrephes,
who loveth to have the preeminence among them, dotH
not receive us."^^
Thus we find entrenched in the early church a man
loving preeminence, who received not the gospel of
Christ nor the apostle himself.
Why was the Son given to us that the government
might be upon his shoulders? Was it Peter who was
prophesied of, or was it He whose name should be called
"Wonderful"?
"For a child is born to us and a son is given to us and
the government is upon his shoulder, and his name shall
be called Wonderful, Counsellor, God the Mighty, the
Father of the World to Come, The Prince of Peace." ^^
"And there are three that give testimony on earth,
The Spirit and the water and the blood." ^^
The Pope of Rome is not mentioned as one of the
Three, who give testimony on earth, as the Vicar of
Christ.
The gospel of Jesus Christ places the Church govern-
ment within itself. Where members are subject one to
another, the government of the church does not require
the pretended infallibility of men for arbitrary govern-
ment. The infallible Christ, the Son of God, through
His Holy Spirit, has promised to be with and to guide
2» III John 1:9. 30 Isaiah 9 : 6. ^i i John 5 : 8.
INFALLIBILITY OF POPES 49
His Church. He will come to claim the Bride, the
perfect church. Here is His word for it:
"And if I shall go and prepare a place for you, I
will come again, and will take you to myself ; that where
I am you also may be." ^^
"Let us be glad and rejoice and give glory to Him;
for the marriage of the Lamb is come, and His wife hath
prepared herself." ^^
32 John 14:2. 33 Apocalypse 19:7.
I
III
INVOCATION OF SAINTS
N his support of the doctrine of the Invocation of
Saints as taught by the Roman CathoHc Church,
Cardinal Gibbons thus declares himself :
"I might easily show, by voluminous quotations from
ecclesiastical writers of the first ages of the Church, how
conformable to the teaching of antiquity is the Catholic
practice of invoking the intercession of the saints. But
as you, dear reader, may not be disposed to attach ade-
quate importance to the writings of the Fathers, I shall
confine myself to the testimony of Holy Scripture."
'The venerable patriarch Jacob, when on his deathbed
prayed thus for his two grandchildren : 'May the angel
that delivereth me from all evils bless these boys.' Here
we see a holy patriarch — one singularly favored by Al-
mighty God and enlightened by many supernatural
visions, the father of Jehovah's chosen people — asking
the angel in heaven to obtain a blessing for his grand-
children. And surely we cannot suppose that he would
be so ignorant as to pray to one that could not hear
him." —"Faith of Our Fathers," Pages 183-4.
The Douay version from which all our Scripture refer-
ences are taken, cites the word "dehvereth," which in
the King James version is "redeemed." However,
Jacob here refers to the Lord's promise given him:
"And I will be thy keeper whithersoever thou goest
and will bring thee back into this land, neither will I
leave thee till I shall have accomplished all that I have
said."
50
INVOCATION OF SAINTS 51
*'And when Jacob awaked out of his sleep, he said,
Indeed the Lord is in this place ; and I knew it not." ^
"And the angel of God said to me in my sleep, Jacob :
and I answered, Here I am." ^
"And trembling he said. How terrible is this place,
this is no other but the house of God and the gate of
heaven."
"And Jacob arising in the morning took the stone
which he had laid under his head and set it up for a
title, pouring oil upon the top of it." "And he called the
name of the city Bethel, which before was called Luza."
"And he made a vow, saying. If God shall be with me,
and shall keep me in the way by which I walk, and shall
give me bread to eat and raiment to put on, and I shall
return prosperously to my father's house: The Lord
shall be my God." ^
Here is plainly the Scriptural evidence that the angel
to whom Jacob refers was none other than the Lord.
As in Gen. 31 : 13 :
"I am the God of Bethel, where thou didst anoint the
stone and make a vow to me; now therefore, arise and
go out of this land and return unto thy native coun-
try."
And Psalm 120: 7:
"The Lord keepeth thee from all evil, may the Lord
keep thy soul."
And Gen. 28: 15
"And I will be thy keeper whithersoever thou goest."
Does it seem reasonable that (as in the 15th and i6th
Verses of Genesis 48, after citing God as One who
feedeth him), in asking His blessing he should asso-
ciate with the source of that blessing, the blessing of
1 Gen. 28: 15-16. 2 Gen. 31 : 11. s Gen. 28: 17-18- 19-2021.
52 THE ROMAN CATHOLIC BIBLE
another? The blessing is asked only after God in three
attitudes is invoked, namely:
*'God in whose sight my fathers Abraham and Isaac
walked,"
*'God that feedeth me from my youth until this
day,"
*'the angel that delivereth me from all evils, bless these
boys."
The term "the angel" (if used in preference to the
word ^'Redeemer" as in King James Version) is the vis-
ible form of Christ before His incarnation, the special
form in which God manifested Himself to man.
Note the following :
"This is that Moses who said to the children of Israel :
A prophet shall God raise up to you of your own breth-
ren as myself, him shall you hear. This is he, that was
in the church in the wilderness with the angel who spoke
to him on Mount Sina, and with our fathers : who re-
ceived the words of life to give unto us." ^
"And the Lord appeared to him in a flame of fire out
of the midst of a bush, and he saw that the bush was on
fire, and was not burnt." "^
"And behold an angel of the Lord from heaven called
to him, saying: Abraham, Abraham; and he answered,
Here I am. And he said to him. Lay not thy hand upon
the boy, neither do thou anything to him, now I know
that thou fearest God and hast not spared thy only
begotten son for my sake." "And the angel of the Lord
called to Abraham a second time from heaven, saying, By
my own self have I sworn, saith the Lord, because thou
hast done this thing and hast not spared thy only begot-
ten son for my sake : I will bless thee, and I will multiply
thy seed as the stars of heaven, and as the sand that is
« Acts 7 : Z7-Z^. "^ Ex. 3 : 2.
INVOCATION OF SAINTS 53
by the sea shore; thy seed shall possess the gates of their
enemies
>' 8
But Cardinal Gibbons says :
"We read in the Gospel that Dives while suffering in
the place of reprobates, earnestly besought Abraham to
cool his burnmg thirst, and Abraham though then de-
tained in Limbo, was able to listen and reply to him.
Now if communication could exist between the souls of
the just and of the reprobate, how much easier is it to
suppose that interchange of thought can exist between
the saints in heaven and their brethren on earth,"
^— Faith of Our Fathers — Page 185-6.
But does the Scripture place Abraham in Limbo or
purgatory or in any place at his death other than where
God the Father, his Friend, who redeemed him, is, and
endowed him with His own self as a reward?
"Now when these things were done, the word of the
Lord came to Abraham by a vision, saying, Fear not,
Abraham, I am thy protector, and thy reward exceeding
great." ^
"Because Abraham obeyed my voice and kept my pre-
cepts and commandments, and observed my ceremonies
and laws." ^^
"Therefore thus saith the Lord to the house of Jacob,
he that redeemed Abraham, Jacob shall not now be
confounded, neither shall his countenance now be
ashamed." ^^
"But thou Israel art my servant Jacob whom I have
chosen, the seed of Abraham my friend." ^-
"And I say to you that many shall come from the east
and the west, and shall sit down with Abraham and
Isaac and Jacob in the Kingdom of Heaven."
8 Gen. 22:tt-T2 and 15-16-17. 11 Isa. 20:22.
oGen. 15: I. i-Isa. 41 : ^-
10 Gen. 26 : 5.
54 THE ROMAN CATHOLIC BIBLE
"But the children* of the Kingdom shall be cast out
into the exterior darkness, there shall be weeping and
gnashing of teeth." ^^
"Abraham your father rejoiced that he might see my
day: He saw it, and was glad." ^*
"Therefore they that are of faith shall be blessed with
faithful Abraham." "And if you be Christ's, then are
you the seed of Abraham, heirs according to the
promise." ^^
Are we to learn that Abraham, to whom God gave
Himself as a reward exceeding great, Abraham the
friend of God, who saw by faith the day of Christ, slain
from the foundation of the world, who was redeemed by
Christ, needed to go into some Limbo or purgatory, while
the thief on the cross walked with Christ in Paradise?
Or may we not continue to believe the blood of Jesus
Christ cleanseth from all sin and that there remaineth
now no condemnation to those who are in Christ Jesus.
"Amen, Amen, I say unto you that he who heareth my
word, and believeth him that sent me, hath life everlast-
ing, and cometh not into judgment, but is passed from
death to life." ^«
If the God of both Heaven and earth, and who has the
keys of hell and death, ordains any communication be-
tween those on earth and those who have passed beyond,
it certainly is not that they be prayed to or worshiped,
for the Lord our God is a jealous God, to whom alone
belongs salvation, and His glory He will not give to
another.
"Salvation is of the Lord, and thy blessing is upon thy
people." ^^
"I the Lord, this is my name," "I will not give my
glory to another, nor my praise to graven things." ^^
^^ Matt. 8 : II, 12. ^^ Qal. 3 : 9-29. ^^ Psalms 3 : 9.
1* John 8 : 56. ^^ John 5 : 24. is Isa. 42 : 8.
INVOCATION OF SAINTS 55
The Reverend Cardinal says :
"But did our Lord at any time reprove the Jews for
their belief in a middle state, or for praying for the dead,
a practice which to His knowledge prevailed among the
people? Never. On the contrary, more than once both
He and the Apostle of the Gentiles insinuate the doctrine
of Purgatory." — "Faith of Our Fathers/' page 249.
We fail to find in any portion of the Old Testament
or the New, any scripture that points to a middle state of
existence of souls between that of the rest of God's
people and the unrest of the wicked, where the worm
dieth not and the fire Is not quenched. If such a place
exists. Scripture does not lift the veil, nor do we find any
authority for offering prayer for the dead, in any prayer,
or suggestions from any Patriarch or Prophet of the
Old Testament, or from Our Saviour or any of His
apostles or disciples in the New Testament.
As to any or all traditions that may have furnished
church dogma for the Hebrew people, if such be, we
know that the Saviour rebuked the Pharisees in these
words :
"But he answering said to them. Well did Isaias
prophesy of you hypocrites, as it is written, This people
honoreth me with their lips, but their heart is far from
me."
"And in vain do they worship me, teaching doctrines
and precepts of men." "Making void the word of God
by your own tradition, which you have given forth,
And many other such like things you do." ^®
We cannot but feel that as the Written Word contains
many allusions to every doctrine taught by the Holy
Spirit, and as it does not make mention of those in which
i» Mark 7 : 6, 7 and 13.
56 THE ROMAN CATHOLIC BIBLE
the Romish Church finds its authority for such tradi-
tions and church dogma, it is evident that such dogma
did not find a place in the plans of the apostles for
preaching the Gospel of Christ and Him crucified.
As to ''insinuating" any doctrine on the part of Jesus
and the Apostle Paul or the other disciples, the simple,
direct teachings of Christ preclude such an idea. It was
yea and nay with Him in His teachings, and the same
with His apostles who spoke with His Spirit.
The Saviour in rebuking those who asked why was the
waste of the ointment when Jesus was anointed in the
house of Simon the leper, said :
"Amen, I say to you wheresoever this gospel shall be
preached in the whole world, that also which she hath
done, shall be told for a memorial of her/' ^^
This would not have been spoken unless the Saviour
had known what would and what would not be written,
and this memorial was to be written among the many
things which Jesus did.
"But there are also many other things which Jesus
did, which if they were written every one, the world
itself, I think, would not be able to contain the books that
should be written.'' ^^
We are reminded also that there was a safeguarding of
the Apocalypse by Jesus in its closing verses :
"For I testify to every one that heareth the words of
the prophecy of this book : If any man shall add to these
things, God shall add unto him the plagues written in
this book." "And if any man shall take away from the
words of the book of this prophecy, God shall take away
his part out of the book of life, and out of the Holy City
and from these things that are written in this book." ^^
Should we not therefore question closely, any and all
20 Mark 14 : 9. 21 John 21 : 25. 22 Rev. 22 : 18-19.
INVOCATION OF SAINTS 57
traditions, or tenets of men, not founded on the Written
Word, and where such confliction with the Written
Word exists, can there be any question as to whether
they or the Written Word should be held to? Is there
not a danger line to be avoided lest we teach doctrines or
tenets above that which is written?
"But these things. Brethren, I have in a figure trans-
ferred to myself, and to Apollo for your sakes, that in
us you may learn that one be not puffed up against the
other for another, above that which is written." ^^
Cardinal Gibbons in his book makes this statement :
"When Our Saviour the founder of the new law ap-
peared on earth, He came to lop off those excrescences
which had grown on the body of the Jewish Ecclesiastical
Code, and to purify the Jewish Church from those human
traditions which in the course of time, became like chaff
mixed with the wheat of sound doctrine."
— Page 249
That which Our Saviour came to do was that which He
did, as written in Revelations (Apocalypse) 21:5:
*'And he that sat on the throne said: Behold I make
all things new: And he said to me, Write: for these
things are most faithful and true."
And also the Apostle Paul wrote :
"If then any be in Christ a new creature, the old things
are passed away, Behold all things are made new." ^*
The old was fulfilled in the new.
"Now in saying a new, he hath made the former old.
And that which decayeth and groweth old is near its
end." 26
May not the words last quoted from Cardinal Gibbons
apply as well, and even more properly, to all creeds hold-
ing belief in the Trinity, the Incarnation and the Resur-
23 I Cor. 4:6. 24 n Cor. 5 : i7- " Heb. 8 : 13.
58 THE ROMAN CATHOLIC BIBLE
rection? And may there not be those in ever}' land and
under every creed who could profit by the Saviour's quo-
tation from Isaias?
''This people honoreth me with their lips, but their
heart is far from me." ''And in vain do they worship
me teaching doctrines and commandments of men."^^
And if so, why need the Romish Church be any excep-
tion to the rule where Church dogma takes the place of
Scripture, or when it prevails over that which is revealed
to man in the Holy Scripture?
"For all the law is fulfilled in one word, Thou shalt
love thy neighbor as thyself.'*' "But if you bite and de-
vour one another, take heed you be not condemned one
of another." -■
"He that loveth not, knoweth not God, for God is
charity."
"^Nly dearest, if God hath so loved us, we also ought
to love one another." -^
With the invitation given by the Holy Spirit in the
Psalms of David to pour out our hearts before God, the
invitation of His Son who so loved us that he died for
us, to come unto Him, to ask and receive, is it any won-
der that Protestants are taught from their childhood to
seek God in prayer rather than His saints?
"Trust in him, all ye congregation of people. Pour
out your hearts before him. God is our helper for-
ever." 29
"Come to me, all ye that labor and are burdened, and
I will refresh you.'^
"All things are delivered to me by my Father." ^°
"Ask, and it shall be given you ; seek, and you shall
find; knock, and it shall be opened to you."
26 Matt. 15 : 8, 9- -^ Psalms 6i : g.
2" Gal. 5 : 14. 15. so Matt. 11 : 28, 27,
2SI John 4:8 and 11.
INVOCATION OF SAINTS 59
"For every one that asketh receiveth." ^^
Why Cardinal Gibbons under the head of "Invocation
of Saints," makes frequent allusion to prayer for others,
is not explained. That is in such common usage as to
be a tenet of all Christian people who love and pray.
We have thus elaborated an answer by Scriptural
passages from the Douay Version of the Bible, to the
only strictly Scriptural reference made by Cardinal Gib-
bons in support of the "Invocation of Saints."
However often our thoughts may go out to our loved
ones in Heaven, there is no suggestion in Scripture that
we should pray to them. The directing of prayer to man
must necessarily detract from our proper attitude in
prayer to God, by reason of our lack of faith in Him as
supreme and all sufficient
When the disciples asked Our Lord to teach them to
pray, their request implied as much whom to pray to as
what manner of prayer to make.
When Our Lord answered them it was "When ye
pray, say, Father, hallowed be thy name." Those words
included every person in the Trinity, Father, Son and
Holy Ghost. Neither man nor woman is included.
31 Luke 11:9-10.
I
IV
THE WORSHIP OF MARY, AND THE
IMMACULATE CONCEPTION
N chapter fourteen of Cardinal Gibbons' book, 'The
Faith of Our Fathers," a heading of the chapter
reads as follows :
*Ts it lawful to honor the blessed Virgin j\Iary as a
Saint : to invoke her as an intercessor and to imitate her
as a model ?''
—Page 195
'To invoke her as an intercessor" is the only clause to
which reply is here made ; a reply to the other two ques-
tions asked in the caption would of course be in the
affirmation of all believers. That Mary was blessed
among women as bringing into the world the incarnate
Son of God is now and always has been asserted by all
Evangelical Protestant Churches, as well as Roman Cath-
olic Churches, according to the Scripture,
"And the angel being come in said unto her, Hail full
of grace, the Lord is with thee, blessed art thou among
women." ^
We now quote from Cardinal Gibbons' book, "The
Faith of Our Fathers" in reference to worshiping
Mary : —
"Mary is exalted above all other women, not only be-
cause she united a mother's love with maiden purity, but
also because she was conceived without original sin. The
dogma of the Immaculate Conception is thus expressed
^ Luke 1 : 28,
60
THE WORSHIP OF MARY 6i
by the Church. We define that the Blessed Virgin Mary
in the first moment of her conception, by the singular
grace and privilege of Almighty God, in virtue of the
merits of Jesus Christ, the Saviour of the human race,
was preserved free from every stain of original sin."
"Unlike the rest of the children of Adam, the soul of
Mary was never subject to sin even in the first moment
of its infusion into the body. She alone was exempt
from the original taint. This immunity of Mary from
original sin is exclusively due to the merits of Christ as
the Church expressly declares. She needed a Redeemer
as well as the rest of the human race and therefore was
redeemed, but in a more sublime manner. Mary is as
much indebted to the precious blood of Jesus for having
been preserved, as we are for having been cleansed from
original sin."
— Pages 204-5
Here Cardinal Gibbons presents in support of the
above dogma of the Romish Church :
"I will put enmities between thee and the woman, and
thy seed and her seed. She shall crush thy head and
thou shalt He in wait for her heel." ^
King James and also later revised versions both read :
"And I will put enmity between thee and the woman
and between thy seed and her seed; it shall bruise thy
head, and thou shalt bruise his heel."
From the above Cardinal Gibbons argues that
"Now the enmity of Christ or the seed toward the evil
one was absolute and perpetual, therefore, the enmity of
Mary, or the woman, toward the devil never admitted of
any momentary reconciliation which would have existed
if she was ever subject to original sin."
"But if she (Mary) had been created in original sin
instead of being superior, she would be inferior to Eve
who was certainly created immaculate."
— Pages 205-6
^ -Gen. 3: 15.
62 THE ROMAN CATHOLIC BIBLE
The Apostle Paul in his first letter to the Corinthians,
says:
"The first man was of the earth earthly; the second
man from heaven heavenly/'
''Therefore as we have borne the image of the earthly-
let us bear also the image of the heavenly."
"Now this I say, brethren, that fiesh and blood cannot
possess the Kingdom of God, neither shall corruption
possess incorruption/' ^
There is no exception to Eve or Mary given here, nor
can there be any if the Scripture is to be adhered to, as
also in Gal. 3 : 18-24
"For if the inheritance be of the law, it is no more of
promise, but God gave it to Abraham by promise. Why
then was the law? It was set because of transgressions
until the seed should come to whom he made the promise,
being ordained by angels in the hand of a mediator.
Now a mediator is not of one; but God is one. Was the
law then against the promises of God? God forbid.
For if there had been a law given which could give life,
verily justice should have been by the law. But the
Scriptures hath concluded all under sin, that the promise,
by the faith of Jesus Christ, might be given to them that
believe. But before the faith came, we were kept under
the law shut up, unto that faith which was to be revealed.
Wherefore the law was our pedagogue in Christ, that we
might be justified by faith." ^
"But when the fullness of the time was come, God sent
his Son, made of a woman, made under the law. That
he might redeem them who were under the law: that
we might receive the adoption of sons." ^
The Apostle John recognizing these truths regarding
created man, says :
3 1 Cor. 15 : 47-SOo * Gal. 3 : 18-24. 5 Gal. 4 : 4-
THE WORSHIP OF MARY 63
"If we say we have no sin we deceive ourselves and
the truth is not in us. If we say we have not sinned, we
make him a liar and his word is not in us." ®
But here is the testimony of Mary :
"And Mary said : My soul doth magnify the Lord." ^
The angel who announced to Mary the coming birth
of Jesus, said:
"Hail full of grace, the Lord is with thee : blessed art
thou among women." ^
Had such an unnatural condition existed as that Mary
the mother of Our Saviour had been born of a father and
mother with a miraculous, supernatural intervention of
God, separating her kind and nature from that of all
other women, she would not have been of the human
race nor have been the Mary "blessed among women"
for she would not have been among women, but a
divinely appointed being of another kind. Nor would
Jesus, who knew no sin, have been "made sin" by bear-
ing. Himself without sin, a form different in no respect
from that of the first Adam.
"But now in Christ Jesus, you, who sometime were
afar off, are made nigh by the blood of Christ."
"For he is our peace, who hath made both one, and
breaking down the middle wall of partition, the enmities
in his flesh."
"Making void the law of commandments contained in
decrees ; that he might make the two in himself into one
new man, making peace. And might reconcile both to
God in one body by the cross, killing the enmities in
himself." «
Could any supernatural personage have added to the
perfected scene at Calvary? — The Son of God upon the
« I John 1 : 8, 10. « T.uke i : 28.
'^ Luke 1 : 46. ^ Eph. 2 : 13-16.
64 THE ROMAN CATHOLIC BIBLE
cross bearing the burden of our common humanity. — At
the foot of the cross, His mother, Mary of Cleophas, and
Mary Magdalene, and the disciple whom Jesus loved.
This little group standing nearby while the suffering
Saviour upon the cross drew our humanity into His own
person, mindful still of the faithful mother who had
brought Him into the world and those who had followed
Him so closely in His ministry. May it not be that only
to the Father Himself is known all that was wrought
when Jesus said upon the Cross, *'It is finished." ?
"For Jesus is not entered into the holies made with
hands, the patterns of the true; but into heaven itself,
that he may appear now in the presence of God for
us." i«
Christ appears for us. Nowhere Mary or any other
saint; our prayer should be directed to "Our Father who
art in Heaven."
"Jesus answered and said to him (Nicodemus), Amen,
Amen, I say to thee unless a man be born again, he can-
not see the Kingdom of God." ^^
No exception is here made to Mary the mother of
our Lord.
"The first man Adam was made into a living soul.
The last Adam into a quickening spirit."
"Yet that was not first which is spiritual, but that
which is natural : afterward that which is spiritual."
"The first man was of the earth earthly, the second
man from heaven heavenly." ^^
No exception is here made to Mary the mother of our
Lord.
"In whom we have redemption through his blood, the
remission of sins;"
10 Heb. 9 : 24. 11 John 3:3. 12 1 Cor. 15 : 45-47.
THE WORSHIP OF MARY 65
"Who is the image of the invisible God, the first-bom
of every creature ?'' ^^
The Virgin Mary gave birth to Jesus the Son of the
Most High, as the angel announced that she would. The
conception and the birth were by the Holy Ghost, who
should come upon her, and the power of the Most High,
which should overshadow her.
Such was the birth of the Son of God, the Son of
Man. The Word made flesh. Jesus the Christ. The
Only Begotten of the Father.
This was the new thing in the earth spoken by the
Prophet Jeremiah. All other sons which had been born
were sons of descendants of Adam and Eve.
This holy, this second Adam, was a quickening Spirit
from Heaven and was called by the angel who spoke
of His birth to Mary, The "Son of God," He is the
Incarnation, The Atonement, sent by the Father.
Thus Mary was not the mother of Jesus by exactly
the same course of events that mothers had conceived
and borne sons heretofore. Therefore Jesus was justi-
fied in saying to her in those majestic words,
"Woman, What is that to me and to thee? My hour
is not yet come." ^*
"He saith to his mother. Woman, behold thy son."
"After that he saith to the disciple. Behold thy
mother." ^^
Thus Mary who had filled the mission that made her
forever blessed among women, was now the mother of
John.
^t5
"Style her if you will the mother of the Man Jesus, or
even of the human nature of the Son of God, but not
the mother of God."
13 Col. 1 : 14-15. ^* John 2:4. i^ John 19 : 26-27.
66 THE ROMAN CATHOLIC BIBLE
''I shall answer this objection by putting a question.
Did the mother who bore us have any part in the pro-
duction of our soul? Was not this nobler part of our
being the work of God alone ? And yet who would for
a moment dream of saying, The mother of my body'
and not 'my mother/ "
r— Faith of Our Fathers, Pages igg-200.
His Reverence seems to have forgotten the Scriptural
distinction between that which pertains to the natural
person of man and that which pertains to the Person
of God.
We give here by calling attention to the Douay Version
of Scripture, the Roman Catholic Bible authority,
'The first Adam was made into a living soul. The
last Adam into a quickening spirit." ^^
Thus the Virgin ilary gave birth to the soul and body
Df Jesus. The Quickening Spirit was that of the Son of
God from Heaven. Thus was there born of !Mary 'The
Son of God," who is "the First and Last," 'The Alpha
and Omega," 'The Word made flesh." The human
mind alone may never comprehend this birth. It was
not the work of man, but of the "power of the Almighty
that over-shadowed" the virgin.
Let us worship therefore
"The Beginning and the End, the Lord God, who is,
who was, and who is to come, the Almight}'." ^'
A mother imparts all she has to her offspring, both
of soul and body. ^Mary could have Deity only by faith.
To supply this deficiency, the Holy Ghost came upon her,
and the power of the Most High overshadowed her,
that the Son of God might be born of -Mar}% and the
Scripture be fulfilled, and His Name was to be called
Jesus.
i«I Cor. 15:45. 17 Apocalypse 1:8.
THE WORSHIP OF MARY 67
'Tor a child is bom to us and a son is given to us,
and the government is upon his shoulders." ^^
You will notice that in this prophecy it is a child that
is born, while a Son is given.
"For God so loved the world as to give his only be-
gotten son, that whosoever believeth in him may not
perish, but may have everlasting life." ^^
Mary is never called the ''Mother of God" in Scrip-
ture. They who so call her speak "above that which is
written"; God the "Beginning" had no mother.
In being the mother of Jesus, Mary was not to be
worshiped, only God the Father, the Son and Holy
Ghost; Three in One is to be worshiped. For the
"Holy," the Son of God, is to become subject to the
Father.
Here is what the man Paul, the Apostle to the Gentiles,
tells us was wrought in Jesus when the Power of the
Most High overshadowed the virgin Mary.
"But now in Christ Jesus, you who sometime were
afar off are made nigh by the blood of Christ."
"For he is our peace, who hath made both one, and
breaking down the middle wall of partition the enmities
in his flesh."
"Making void the law of commandments contained in
decrees : that he might make the two in himself into one
new man, making peace."
"And might reconcile both to God, in one body by the
cross, killing the enmities in himself." ^^
"Afterward the end when he shall have delivered up
the kingdom to God and the Father, when he shall
have brought to naught all principality, power and
virtue."
"And when all things shall be subdued unto Him then
i^Isa. 9:6. 10 John 3:16. 20 Eph. 2:13, 14, 15, 16.
68 THE ROMAN CATHOLIC BIBLE
the Son also Himself shall be subject unto Him who put
all things under Him, that God may be all in all." ^^
"And I fell down before his feet to adore him, and he
said to me. See thou do it not, I am thy fellow servant
and of thy brethren who have the testimony of Jesus
adore God." ^^
"And prepare your hearts unto the Lord, and serve
him only." ^^
"When we call the blessed virgin the Mother of God
we assert our belief in two things. First that her Son
Jesus Christ is true man else she were not a mother.
Second that he is true God else she were not the mother
of God. In other words, we affirm that the second per-
son of the Blessed Trinity, the Word of God, who is his
divine nature, is from all eternity begotten of the
Father. Consubstantial with Him was in the fullness
of time again begotten by being born of the Virgin, thus
taking to himself from her maternal womb, a human
nature of the same substance with hers."
— Faith of Our Fathers, Page 199
His Reverence becomes doubly unfortunate in this
attempt to enforce the assertion that "Mary is the Mother
of God"; first, by asserting the truth that "Jesus Christ
is very man, else she were not a mother," he proves the
reverse by the same principle, namely, that Mary was
very woman, and not as in another place as discussed in
the beginning of this chapter, where he asserts that the
Virgin Mary "was in the first moment of her conception"
"preserved free from every stain of original sin."
The reason for Jesus Christ being born without sin,
was not that Mary was other than very woman, but
because of being conceived by the Holy Ghost, He was
without sin. And we who are sinners, believing on Him
become one with Him.
21 1 Cor. 15 : 24-28. 22 Apocalypse 19 : 16. 23 j Kings 7 : 3.
THE WORSHIP OF MARY 69
"And you know that he appeared to take away our
sins, and in Him there is no sin."
"Whosoever abideth in Him sinneth not/'
"Whosoever is born of God committeth not sin, for
His seed abideth in him and he cannot sin, because he is
born of God." ^^
"Jesus answered and said to him, Amen, Amen, I say
to thee, unless a man be born again, he cannot see the
Kingdom of God." ^^
Thus by the Roman Catholic Bible, we find the Roman
Catholic Church doctrine of the Immaculate Conception
of Mary relegated to its proper place as dogma of that
church and not to be found in Holy Scripture or in any
way authorized by it, but the contrary proven by the
Written Word.
And all who have entertained such conceptions of the
blessed Virgin Mary can afford to discard them for the
association afforded by her Son Jesus the Son of God,
with Himself, as follows :
"And now I am not in the world, and these are in the
world, and I come to thee. Holy Father, keep them in
thy name whom thou hast given me, that they may be
one, as we also are."
"And not for them only do I pray, but for them also
who through their word shall believe in me."
"That they all may be one, as Thou, Father in me, and
I in Thee, That they also may be one in us. That the
world may believe that Thou hast sent me." ^^
Secondly, referring again to Cardinal Gibbons' state-
ment regarding the birth of our Saviour, that Jesus was
true man, we then naturally look for true human mater-
nity in the birth of Jesus, and can find only that in
Mary.
2* I John 3 : 5-6-9. ''^^ John 3 : 3. -^ John 17 : ii, 20, 21.
70 THE ROMAN CATHOLIC BIBLE
Mary the mother of Jesus? Yes, the expression is
harmonious and accords with Scripture.
"Mary the mother of God V No, it is out of keeping
with the personages of each, and has no Scriptural
basis whatever; God, and the "Word" who was made
flesh, the Son, were in the beginning; no mother is pos-
sible. That "Holy" who was born of Mary, was to be
called "the Son of God."
Mary herself was given the spirit to understand her
true part in bringing into the world the new man, Jesus
the Christ, to know in what relation the blessing of God
was thus bestowed upon her; in her humility, her low
estate.
"And Mary said, My soul doth magnify the Lord."
"And my spirit hath rejoiced in God, my Saviour."
"Because he hath regarded the humility of his hand-
maid: For behold from henceforth all generations shall
call me blessed." ^^
The prophecy of Jeremiah made six hundred years
before, was thus fulfilled. It was a Man who was com-
passed by a woman. It was the New Man whom Mary
brought forth:
"For the Lord hath created a new thing upon the
earth."
"A woman shall compass a man." ^^
27 Luke 1 : 46, 47, 48. 28 Jeremiah 31 : 22.
u
y
THE HOLY EUCHARIST
NDER the title 'The Holy Eucharist," Cardinal
Gibbons says:
"But why multiply authorities? At the present
day, every Christian communion throughout the world,
with the sole exception of Protestants, proclaims its
belief in the Real Presence of Christ in the Sacra-
ment." — Page 340
We give the following Scriptural authority from
Matthew, Mark and Luke :
"And whilst they were at supper Jesus took bread and
blessed and broke, and gave to his disciples and said,
Take ye and eat, this is my body. And taking the
chalice, he gave thanks, and gave to them, saying, Drink
ye all of this. For this is my blood of the New Testa-
ment which shall be shed for many unto remission of
sins. And I say to you I will not drink from henceforth
of this fruit of the vine, until that day when I shall drink
it with you anew in the Kingdom of my father." ^
"And whilst they were eating, Jesus took bread, and
blessing, broke and gave to them and said: Take ye,
this is my body. And having taken the chalice, giving
thanks, he gave it to them, and they all drank of it. And
he said to them : This is my blood of the New Testament,
which shall be shed for many. Amen, I say to you, that
I will drink no more of the fruit of the vine until that
day when I shall drink it new in the kingdom of God." -
1 Matt. 26 : 26, 27, 28, 20. 2 Mark 14 : 22-25.
71
J2. THE ROMAN CATHOLIC BIBLE
''And having taken the chaHce, he gave thanks and
said, Take and divide it among you. For I say to you
that I will not drink of the fruit of the vine till the
kingdom of God come. And taking bread he gave
thanks, and brake and gave to them, saying, This is my
body, which is given for you. Do this for a commemora-
tion of me. In like manner the chalice also. After he
had supped, saying, This is the chalice, the New Testa-
ment in my blood which shall be shed for you.'' ^
"Behold I stand at the gate and knock. If any man
shall hear my voice and open to me the door, I will come
in to him and will sup with him and he with me.'' *
Under this title ("The Holy Eucharist") Cardinal
Gibbons would show that where the Saviour spoke of the
bread and Vv'ine in the communion as given by ]\Iatthew,
Mark and Luke above, He spoke of a literal body and
blood ; that in other instances in speaking of His Body
and His Blood, he explained that a literal construction
was not to be put upon the words. His Reverence then
quotes from John, 6 : 53, as follows : —
''How can this man give us his flesh to eat ?"
and says :
"Even his disciples though avoiding the disrespectful
language of the multitude gave expression to their doubt
in this milder form 'This saying is hard and who can
hear it.' (John 6:61.) So much were they shocked at
our Saviour's promise, that 'after this many of his dis-
ciples went back and walked no more with him.' (John
6: 67)" —Page 330
Quoting Cardinal Gibbons : —
"They evidently implied by their words and conduct
that they understood Jesus to have spoken literally of
His flesh; for had they interpreted His words in a figur-
3 Luke 22 : 17, 18, 19, 20. ^ Rev. 3 : 20.
THE HOLY EUCHARIST 73
ative sense, it; would not have been a hard saying, nor
have led them to abandon their Master."
*'But perhaps 1 shall be told that the disciples and the
Jews who heard Our Saviour may have misinterpreted
His meaning by taking His words in the literal accepta-
tion, while He may have spoken in a figurative sense.
This objection is easily disposed of. It sometimes hap-
pened, indeed, that Our Saviour was misunderstood by
His hearers. On such occasions He always took care
to remove from their mind the wrong impression they
had formed, by stating His meaning in simpler language.
But in the present instance does Our Saviour alter His
language when He finds His words taken in the literal
sense? Does He tell His hearers that He has spoken
figuratively? Does He soften the tone of His expres-
sion? Far from weakening the force of His words. He
repeats what He said before and in language more em-
phatic: 'Amen, Amen, I say unto you, unless ye eat the
flesh of the Son of Man and drink His blood, ye shall
not have life in you.' "
—Pages 330-1
His Reverence appears to have overlooked that which
he avers the Saviour did not do, namely, ''alter His lan-
guage." He does do so in the following verses, which
interpretation of the meaning of His words is perfect in
the simplicity of its teaching:
"But Jesus knowing in himself that his disciples mur-
mured at this, said to them: Doth this scandalize you?
If then you shall see the son of man ascend up where he
was before? It is the spirit that quickeneth, the flesh
profiteth nothing. The words that I have spoken to you
are spirit and life." ^*
It is evident from Our Saviour's words that it is the
body and blood of Christ spiritually discerned through
the word spoken, and not the literal flesh that profiteth.
Where can we find hope of man's resurrection if we fail
^ John 6 : 62-64.
74 THE ROMAN CATHOLIC BIBLE
to discern that it was the flesh and blood of the Son of
Man, the Son of Mary, that lay in the tomb of Joseph,
while Our Saviour, the Word made flesh, was walking
in Paradise with the robber who died beside Him?
"Who are born not of blood nor of the will of the
flesh, nor of the will of man, but of God." ®
Did He not say,
*'Amen, Amen, I say unto you, he that believeth in me
hath everlasting life. I am the bread of life."?'^
It was indeed His flesh they were to eat and His blood
they were to drink. It was the Word made flesh, not
mere flesh.
"He that eateth my flesh and drinketh my blood, hath
everlasting life : and I will raise him up in the last day." ^
It was His body which came from above, and not the
temple of His body only, as Jesus made plain when
speaking of His resurrection.
"Jesus answered and said to them: Destroy this tem-
ple, and in three days I will raise it up."
"The Jews then said: Six and forty years was this
temple in building: and wilt thou ra'ise it up in three
days?"
"But he spoke of the temple of his body." ®
"Wherefore when he cometh into the world he saith:
Sacrifice and oblation thou wouldst not : but a body thou
hast fitted to me." ^«
Does not Scripture thus present that it is the spiritual
body of Christ, the Word made flesh, discerned by grace,
through faith given us, by which we possess eternal life?
"The chalice of benediction, which we bless, is it not
the communion of the blood of Christ? And the bread,
which we break, is it not the partaking of the body of
« John 1:13. 8 John 6 : 55- ^^ Heb. 10 : 5.
"^John 6:47, 48. »John 2:19, 20, 21.
THE HOLY EUCHARIST 75
the Lord? For we, being many, are one bread, one
body, all that partake of one bread." ^^
Since then we who commune are one body, how can
it be otherwise than that we were one with that Body,
Christ Jesus, before we communed? Is it not then in
commemoration, a remembrance of Him, that we unite
when we partake of the wheat-made bread and the fruit
of the vine, representing the body and the blood of our
Lord, with whom we have already been made one?
**And all drank the same spiritual drink (and they
drank of the spiritual rock that followed them, and the
rock was Christ)." ^^
And this Rock is the Body of Christ, of which we who
believe on Him are one and of His body, which is the
Church.
"For in one spirit were we all baptized into one body,
whether Jews or Gentiles, whether bound or free, and in
one spirit we have all been made to drink." ^^
It is not what we do at the Communion table that
justifies us, but rather faith in what Our Lord does for
us, namely, the efficacy of His body and His blood, which
we commemorate with the bread and wine. Redeemed be-
fore the foundation of the world : Before the manifes-
tation of Christ crucified upon the Cross of Calvary,
the Lamb was slain.
**Foreknown indeed before the foundation of the
world, but manifested in the last times for you." ^^
"Written in the book of life of the Lamb which was
slain from the beginning of the world." ^^
May we not then in good conscience accept the com-
memoration of Our Lord's death till He come as a form,
the bread as His Body, the wine as His blood, as we also
^^I Cor. 10:16, 17. 1*^1 Cor. 12:13. ^^ Apocalypse 13:8.
"I Cor. 10:4. "I Peter i: jo.
^6 THE ROMAN CATHOLIC BIBLE
receive baptism in a form, and rest in faith as being the
evidence and substance thereof?
*'Which had been some time incredulous when they
waited for the patience of God in the days of Noe, when
the ark was a building wherein a few, that is eight, souls
were saved by water."
"Whereunto baptism being of the like form, now
saveth you also, not the putting away of the filth of the
flesh, but the examination of a good conscience toward
God, by the resurrection of Jesus Christ." ^^
"Now faith is the substance of things to be hoped for,
the evidence of things that appear not." ^^
It is written:
"He that eateth my flesh and drinketh my blood hath
everlasting life, and I will raise him up in the last day." ^^
It is nowhere written in Scripture that by partaking
of bread and wine in remembrance of Him, we have
eternal life.
Was it not the spiritual being of Christ who walked in
Paradise on the day of His crucifixion that quickened
and brought back to life the Son of Mary, the Son of
Man, on the third day?
Was it not likewise the same spiritual body of Christ,
the Word made flesh that also was broken for us, and
will raise our mortal bodies at the last day ?
Was it not then the spiritual discerning of the body of
Christ in the bread and in the wine as well, as that of
the elements of a body that required the Spiritual Being
of Christ to raise it from the dead?
"And Jesus crying with a loud voice said : Father into
thy hands I commend my spirit. And saying this he
gave up the spirit." ^^
i« I Peter 3 : 20, 21. is John 6 : 55.
17 Heb. II : I. i^ Luke 23 : 46.
THE HOLY EUCHARIST ^J
It is to be noted that in the Gospels of Matthew,
Mark and Luke, later {after the partaking) in referring
to this, His Last Supper with His disciples, He speaks
of the *'fruit of the vine," which He had here used as
a symbol of His blood. He also plainly directs: ''Do
this in remembrance of me."
No supernatural injection of His body and blood into
bread and wine was necessary in order that His disciples
whom He had chosen, and would never leave, should
have a part in Him.
"That Christ may dwell by faith in your hearts; that
being rooted and founded in charity," ''You may be able
to comprehend with all, the saints what is the breadth
and length and heighth and depth."
"To know also the charity of Christ which surpasseth
all knowledge, that you may be filled with all the full-
ness of God." -^
The bread and wine would take the course of nature.
"The Spirit which quickeneth" and the "words which I
speak unto you they are Spirit and life," had made and
were to make a part in Him of all who believe.
Since the word of God is true, it is therefore evident
that this commemoration of His death until He come,
was His broken body imparted through faith in Him, to
each of His churches that all might be one in Him, and
any literal construction of the bread and wine used
other than as a symbol, must partake of ecclesiastical
dogma, rather than of the Holy Scripture.
"For as often as you shall eat this bread and drink
the chalice, you shall shew the death of the Lord till
he come." "^
In these words to the Corinthians, the Apostle Paul
states that it was "shewing" the death of the Lord, and
20 Eph. 3 : 17, 18, 19. -1 I Cor : 1 1 : 26.
78 THE ROMAN CATHOLIC BIBLE
as in other verses in the same Chapter, that the Com-
munion was Hkewise a "commemoration."
In the first chapter of Paul's letter to the Ephesians,
Verses 22 and 23, we are told :
"And he hath subjected all things under his feet, and
hath made him head over all the church." "Which is
his body, and the fullness of him who is filled all in
all."
His body being the Church itself, does it not appear
that in the breaking of the bread and the giving of the
wine His body broken, His blood shed, in remembrance
of Him there was to be a commemoration of the Lord's
death till He come?
But it may be said: What harm is there in believing
that the bread and the wine taken at Communion con-
tain in physical substance the body and blood of Christ?
This is the error of holding to such a doctrine.
It is the "believing on Him," the Redeemer of Man,
which makes the union of God with man, the eternal life.
If the bread and wine are presented as the media by
which man comes to God, then place is given to a
medium in the hands of men ; an ecclesiastical body : the
Spirit who giveth life is thus not discerned as the life-
giving One who is never under the control of men.
"Nicodemus saith to him: How can a man be born
when he is old?"
"The Spirit breatheth where he will : and thou hearest
his voice, but thou knowest not whence he cometh and
whither he goeth, so is every one that is born of the
spirit." 22
Nicodemus made a like mistake of taking the letter
instead of the spirit contained in the words of Christ,
and was answered by Our Saviour as above.
22 John 3 : 4 and 8.
THE HOLY EUCHARIST ^^
Must not every tenet of any or every church organi-
zation, and any church dogma at variance with the Holy
Scripture, eventually give way to the written word of
God?
It becomes us to stand in awe when considering the
wonderful mystery of the incarnation. The Word
made flesh, wherein lies the life-giving power of the
Holy Spirit who takes of the things of Christ and gives
them unto His loved ones.
But need there be such mystery in the simple par-
taking of the bread and wine wherein through faith we
discern His body and His blood, shewing forth the
Lord's death till He come?
May we not recall that the Lamb was slain from the
foundation of the world and that our names were writ-
ten in the Book of Life from the foundation of the
world, before we partook of the bread and wine in re-
membrance of Him? So that our eternal life comes not
merely from eating the bread and drinking the wine in
remembrance of Him, but from our discerning therein
the body and blood of the "Lamb of God."
May we not believe that in the sublime truth of the
bread and the wine in relation to eternal life, and our
abiding in Him and He in us, that in saying,
"For my flesh is meat indeed and my blood is drink
indeed," -^ that Our Lord was conveying the sublime
truth that by His incarnation He became life eternal
and One with every soul who believed on Him.
If by a miracle an actual substance of His body and
blood were in the wheat and the fruit of the vine, would
it avail anything to one who believed not? And if His
actual body and blood were in these elements, why would
it ever be needful to partake more than once to have
23 John 6 : 56.
8o THE ROMAN CATHOLIC BIBLE
eternally the eternal life and His presence in us? But
if the bread and the wine are symbols of His incarna-
tion, the giving of the "word made flesh for us," then by
faith as often as we do this in remembrance of Him, we
are reminded of the body broken and the blood shed for
us, and of the eternal life and the abiding in us of the
Son of God. Judas partook and failed to benefit, because
of unbelief. Because the substance was in faith, in the
incarnation of which the bread and wine were symbols,
for
"Faith is the substance of things to be hoped for, the
evidence of things that appear not." ^^
and expressed so completely by Our Lord, thus
"As the living Father hath sent me and I live by the
Father, so he that eateth me the same shall also live
by me." ^5
"And this is the will of my Father that sent me that
every one who seeth the son and believeth in him, may
have life everlasting and I will raise him up at the last
day." '^
Thus considering this verse from John, the blessing of
bread and wine by a pope, or priest of any denomination,
does not of itself bring eternal life to those who partake
of the Communion, but only when the Son is seen in the
Communion and the participant believes in Him ; neither
is He in the bread and wine unless seen by faith, which
the Father above gives, and as told by the Apostle
Paul.
"As he chose us in him before the foundation of the
world that we should be holy and unspotted in his sight
in charity." ^^
"For the Lord himself shall come down from heaven
with commandment, and with the voice of an archangel,
24 Heb. 1 1 : I. 25 John 6 : 58. 26 John 6 : 40 27 Eph. i : 4.
THE HOLY EUCHARIST 8i
and with the trumpet of God; and the dead who are in
Christ shall rise first/' ^s
In the sixth chapter of John, there are at least fifteen
references which may be considered as directly referring
to the bread and life eternal, and most of them are
coupled with the promise of life eternal, some promises
to those who believe, some to those who see the Christ,
but all evidently including those who take hold of Christ
by faith and call upon His name. Let us examine these
statements from John's gospel :
"Now this is eternal life, that they may know thee
the only true God and Jesus Christ whom thou hast
sent." 29
Apparently after, according to the Gospel of Luke, our
Lord had given thanks, we remember that Judas Iscariot
partook with the Lord and His disciples of the first sup-
per from which we derive our communion. Then this
was called the Last Supper. While partaking with them
and with the blessing of our Lord who gave thanks, yet
as the Spirit was not in Judas, he in reality had no part.
But thank God, that we who meet in His name, in what-
ever communion we meet, have no such purpose as
animated the heart of Judas. That Judas Iscariot re-
ceived eternal life, in the sense that Jesus mentioned it,
may well be questioned.
Jesus was glorified when raised from the dead, with
the glory that He had with the Father before the world
was.
**And now glorify thou me, O Father, with thyself
with the glory which I had, before the world was, with
thee." -"^^
Jesus was raised from the dead with the glory he
prayed for, and after He had repeated the words :
2«I Thes. 4:15. -»John 17:3. ^ojohn 17:5.
S2 THE ROMAN CATHOLIC BIBLE
"My God, my God, why hast thou forsaken me ?" ^^
Is not the purpose of our Lord clear, that this Com-
munion Service should be an ordinance of His Church
so that His people might have in mind His death till
He come ; rather than that there was to be miraculously
injected into the bread and wine His body and His
blood. It could not have been literally the body and
blood shed before the world was, because then His
body was not flesh and blood as born of Mary.
Nor would his saying ''till I come" nor His saying
"now with you in the Kingdom of my Father" be intel-
ligent on such a supposition, for "till I come" was
perpetuating His death and "now with you in the King-
dom of my Father" evidently is to the coming again
in His glory. And since the service was to be a com-
memoration with the bread and wine as symbols no
miracle of substitution was required, nor would it have
been a substitution at the first communion because there
was no crucified flesh and blood of man to miraculously
substitute.
31 Matt. 27:46.
VI
PURGATORY
CARDINAL Gibbons starts off in his defense of a
"Purgatory" as follows : —
*'The Catholic Church teaches that, besides
a place of eternal torments for the wicked and of ever-
lasting rest for the righteous, there exists in the next
life a middle state of temporary punishment allotted
for those who have died in venial sin, or who have not
satisfied the justice of God for sins already for-
given." — Page 247
From the Scripture texts throbbing with the truth of
the prophets and apostles to the end that the justice of
God is only satisfied by Christ; that there is no remnssion
of sin save by the blood of Jesus Christ ; we select a few.
First regarding the sentence from Cardinal Gibbons, "or
who have not satisfied the justice of God for sins already
forgiven" (as quoted above).
In no instance in Scripture under the new covenant
does God ask that His justice be satisfied ; except by the
blood of Jesus Christ, the one sacrifice for sin.
"And enter not into judgment with thy servant, for
in thy sight no man living shall be justified." ^
"I am, I am he that blot out thy iniquities for my own
sake, and I will not remember thy sins."
"Put me in remembrance, and let us plead together:
tell if thou hast anything to justify thyself." "
"Who was delivered up for our sins and rose again
for our justification."^
1 Psalms 142 : 2. 2 jsa. 43 : 25-26. ^ Rom. 4 : 25.
83
84 THE ROMAN CATHOLIC BIBLE
'Tor all have sinned, and do need the glory of God."
"Being justified freely by his grace through the re-
demption that is in Christ Jesus."
"Whom God hath proposed to be a propitiation through
faith in his blood to the shewing of his justice for the
remission of former sins/' ^
"Knowing this, that our old man is crucified with him,
that the body of sin may be destroyed, to the end that
we may ser^^e sin no longer."
"For he that is dead is justified from sin."
"Now if we be dead with Christ, we believe that w^e
shall live also together with Christ." ^
"There is now therefore no condemnation to them
that are in Christ Jesus, who walk not according to the
flesh."
"For the law of the Spirit of life in Christ Jesus hath
delivered me from the law of sin and of death." ^
The quotations from the Scriptures are given to call
to mind that they who have accepted Jesus Christ in
their hearts by faith in Him, have passed from death
unto life eternal.
The Reverend Cardinal Gibbons further says :
"If then it is profitable for you to pray for your
brother in the flesh, why should it be useless for you to
pray for him out of the flesh? ... If this brother of
yours dies with some slight stains upon his soul, a siii
of impatience, for instance, or an idle word, is he fit to
enter heaven with these blemishes upon his soul? No,
the sanctity of God forbids it, for 'Nothing defiled shall
enter the Kingdom of Heaven.' Will you consign him
for those minor transgressions to eternal torments wnth
adulterers and murderers? No, the justice and mercy
of God forbid it: Therefore your common sense de-
mands a middle place of expiation for the purgation of
4 Rom. 3 : 23-25. s j^om. 6 : 6-8, « Rom. 8 : i.
PURGATORY 85
the soul before it is worthy of enjoying the companion-
ship of God and His saints. God will render to every
man according to his works, 'to the pure and unsulHed,
everlasting bliss ; to the reprobate, eternal damnation ;
to souls stained with minor faults, a place of temporary
purgation.'' — Page 261
It having been proven by the texts from Scripture last
above quoted that there is no condemnation for those
who are in Christ Jesus, let us examine if there be any
minor defect which might distinguish between one who
had broken the least of God's Commandments and one
who was an adulterer or a murderer, as regards their
common need of the Redeemer Jesus Christ to fit them
for Heaven.
^'For amen, I say unto you till heaven and earth pass,
one jot or one tittle shall not pass of the law till all be
fulfilled."
"He therefore that shall break one of these least com-
mandments and shall so teach men, shall be called the
least in the Kingdom of Heaven. But he that shall do
and teach he shall be called great in the Kingdom of
Heaven." '
"And whosoever shall keep the whole law but offend
in one point, is become guilty of all."
"For he that saith : Thou shalt not commit adultery,
said also. Thou shalt not kill. Now if thou do not com-
mit adultery, but shalt kill, thou art become a transgres-
sor of the law." ®
"Whosoever hateth his brother is a murderer, and you
know that no murderer hath eternal life abiding in him-
self." «
It seems well to refer to Scripture again to learn if
there may be imperfections in Christ's people at the
^Matt. 5:18. sjames 2:10-11 "I John 3:15.
86 THE ROMAX CATHOLIC BIBLE
time of their departure from this world, which would
prevent their immediate entrv^ into Heaven and the com-
panionship of Christ Jesus and His saints.
*'But of him are you in Christ Jesus, who of God is
made unto us wisdom and justice, and sanctification, and
redemption." ^°
"For both he that sanctineth and they who are sancti-
fied are all of one, for which cause he is not ashamed
to call them brethren, saying, 'I will declare thy name to
my brethren; in the midst of the church will I praise
thee/"^
"And for them do I sanctify myself that they also may
be sanctified in truth." "And not for them only do I pray,
but for them also who through their word shall believe
in me."
"That they all may be one as thou Father in me and
I in thee, that they also may be one in us that the world
may believe that thou hast sent me . . . and hast loved
ihem as thou hast loved me.''
"Father, I v. i I that v, here I am they also whom thou
hast given me may be ' ::h me, that they may see the
glory which thou hast gWtn n:e, because thou hast loved
me before the creation of the world.'' ^
Cardinal Gibbons further says :
"'For the souls consigned to this middle state have not
reached the term of their journey. They are still exiles
from heaven and fit subjects for divine clemency. Is it
not strange that this cherished doctrine shotdd also be
ca.led in question by the leveling innovators of the Six-
teenth Centur}', when we consider that it is clearly taught
in the Old Testament, that it is at least insinuated in the
Xew Testament?" — Page 247
1^1 Cor. 1:30. iiHeb. 2:11, 12.
12 John 17: 19, 2p| 21, 23, 24,
PURGATORY 87
As no quotation is made by Cardinal Gibbons from
any book of the Old Testament in support of the exist-
ence of Purgatory, excepting a book known to Protes-
tants as an apocryphal book contained in the Douay
Version, but not in the King James Version (namely, a
Book of Maccabees), we are left to imply that he has
found nothing from the Old Testament which can be
used in support of such a place as Purgatory is taught
to be, in the teachings of the Romish Church.
Considering that the whole world was lying in dark-
ness at the coming of Our Saviour, it is not strange tliat
the author of the historical second Book of Maccabees
should have related of the "most valiant Judas" that he
ordered prayers for the dead soldiers at a time when
the Maccabee rulers were fighting this revolution in the
name of the Plebrew race.
From the following verses of Scripture, we find that
there is variation in Heaven, also that there is prepara-
tion going on in Our Father's House. But we fail to
find in Scripture any intermediate place between earth
and Paradise, or earth and a place of torment.
"The heaven of heaven is the Lord's." ^^
"I know a man in Christ above fourteen years ago
(whether in the body I know not, or out of the body I
know not, God knoweth) such a one caught up to the
third heaven." "And I know such a man (whether in
the body or out of the body I know not, God know-
eth)." "That he was caught up into Paradise and
heard secret words, which it is not granted to man to
utter." ^^
"In my Father's house there are many mansions, if
not, I would have told you, because I go to prepare a
place for you." "And if I shall go and prepare a place
1^ Psalms 113: 16. 1* II Cor. 12: 2-4.
88 THE ROMAN CATHOLIC BIBLE
for you, I will come again, and will take you to myself;
that where I am you also may be." ^^
"And all his children being gathered together to com-
fort their father in his sorrow, he would not receive
comfort, but said, I will go down to my son into hell
(grave) mourning. And whilst he continued weeping," ^^
"And Samuel said to Saul: V/hy hast thou disturbed
my rest?" . . .
"And the Lord also will deliver Israel with thee into
the hands of the Philistines, and to-morrow thou and
thy sons shall be with me." . . .^^
"But go thy ways until the time appointed, and thou
shalt rest and stand in thy lot unto the end of the days." ^^
"And to you who are troubled, rest with us when the
Lord Jesus shall be revealed from heaven with the angels
of his power." ^^
"Who by the power of God are kept by faith unto sal-
vation ready to be revealed in the last time." ^^
The Reverend Prelate says further :
"Our Saviour says 'Whosoever shall speak a word
against the Son of Man it shall be forgiven him. But
he that shall speak against the Holy Ghost, it shall not
be forgiven him, neither in this world nor in the world
to come. When Our Saviour declares that a sin against
the Holy Ghost shall not be forgiven in the next life, he
evidently leaves us to infer that there are some sins
which will be pardoned in the life to come."
— Pages 249-50
As Cardinal Gibbons has implied that there are two
places to come, "one a middle place of expiation," does
he mean that this middle place (Purgatory) is the "world
to come" mentioned by Our Saviour? If so, how then
are we to account for this saying of Our Saviour?
15 John 14: 2, 3. 17 I Kings 28: 15, 19. ^^ II Thess. i : 7.
i« Gen. zi ' 35. ^^ Dan. 12 : 13. 20 i Peter i : 5.
PURGATORY 89
"Who shall not receive an hundred times as much
now in this time, houses and brethren and sisters, and
mothers, and children, and lands, with persecutions, and
in the world to come life everlasting." ^^
"Then Peter said : Behold, we have left all things and
have followed thee." "Who said to them : Amen, I say
to you there is no man that hath left house or parents or
brethren, or wife, or children, for the Kingdom of God's
sake," "Who shall not receive much more in this present
time, and in the world to come life everlasting." ^-
Are we to infer that they with Peter, Who have ob-
tained everlasting life in the world to come with Jesus
their Saviour who went to prepare a place for them, that
where He was they might be also, were in a middle place
of expiation? Or, on the other hand, that forgiveness is
not complete in Heaven when it is reached by the re-
deemed? Should we not rather take the plain meaning
of the text Cardinal Gibbons quotes, which is a reason-
able one, that blasphemy against the Holy Ghost is not
forgiven, neither here nor in time to come, but is as also
told in Mark 3 : 29 :
"But he that shall blaspheme against the Holy Ghost,
shall never have forgiveness, but shall be guilty of an
everlasting sin."
As further evidence bearing on this tenet of the Roman
Catholic Church, Cardinal Gibbons offers the following : —
"St. Paul tells us that 'every man's work shall be
manifest' on the Lord's Day; 'the lire shall try every
man's work of what sort it is. If any man's work
abide,' that is, if his works are holy, *he shall receive
a reward. If any man's work burn,' that is, if his
works are faulty and imperfect, *he shall suffer loss, but
he himself shall be saved yet so as by fire,' his soul will
21 Mark 10:30. --Luke iS :j8, 29, 30.
90 THE ROMAN CATHOLIC BIBLE
be ultimately saved, but he shall suffer for a temporary
duration in the purifying flames of purgatory. This
interpretation is not mine. It is the unanimous voice of
the Fathers of Christendom.'' — Page 250
The quotations from Scripture made by Cardinal
Gibbons in the last above, are from I Cor. 3: 13-15.
We will quote from previous verses in the chapter to
show that it is to the Corinthians as a church and upon
the foundation which he, Paul, had laid for them, that he
has reference to, ^'which foundation is Christ Jesus."
Therefore, it was to those who had confessed their
faith in Christ Jesus that he refers when he considers
the value of their works built on Plim.
"According to the grace of God that is given to me as
a wise architect, I have laid the foundation ; and another
buildeth thereon. But let every man take heed how he
buildeth thereupon." ''For other foundation can no man
lay than that which is laid; which is Christ Jesus."
"Now if any man build upon this foundation, gold,
silver, precious stones, wood, hay, stubble": "Every
man's work shall be manifest; for the day of the Lord
shall declare it, because it shall be revealed in fire; and
the fire shall try every man's work, of what sort it is."
"If any man's work abide, which he hath built there-
upon, he shall receive a reward."
"If any man's work burn, he shall suffer loss; but he
himself shall be saved, yet so as by fire." "Know you
not that you are the temple of God and that the Spirit
of God dwelleth in you?" "But if any man violate the
temple of God, him shall God destroy, for the temple of
God is holy, which you are." ^^
"For we must all be manifested before the judgment
seat of Christ, that every one may receive the proper
23 1 Cor. 3 : 10-17.
PURGATORY 91
things of the body, according as he hath done, whether
it be good or evil/' ^^
This admonition was given to behevers. They were
told that the Spirit of God dwelt in them, and that they
v\7ere temples of God. The foundation they built upon
was laid of Christ Jesus; that their works should be
tried in the day of the Lord. That "day of the Lord"
is evident from the Scriptures the day of judgment in
which all shall appear and be judged. Here is the gospel
all pointing to that day.
*Tor yourselves know perfectly that the day of the
Lord shall so come as a thief in the night." ^^
*'That you be not easily moved from your sense, nor
be terrified neither by Spirit nor by my word, nor by
epistle, as sent from us, as if the day of the Lord were
at hand."
"Let no man deceive you by any means, for unless
there come a revolt first, and the man of sin be revealed
the son of perdition." "Who opposeth, and is lifted up
above all that is called God or that is worshiped, so that
he sitteth in the temple of God showing himself as if he
were God."
"And then that wicked one shall be revealed, whom
the Lord Jesus shall kill with the spirit of his mouth;
and shall destroy with the brightness of his com-
ing." 2«
"But of that day and hour no one knoweth, no not the
angels of heaven, but the Father alone." "And as in the
days of Noe, so shall also the coming of the Son of
man be." "Wherefore be you also ready, because at
what hour you know not, the Son of man will come." -^
"To deliver such a one to Satan for the destruction
24 II Cor. 5 : 10. 20 n Thess. 2 : 2, 3, 4. 8.
2s I Thcss. 5:2. 27 Matt. 24 : 36-37 and 44.
92 THE ROMAN CATHOLIC BIBLE
of the flesh, that the spirit may be saved in the day of
our Lord Jesus Christ." '^^
"Being confident of this very thing, that he who hath
begun a good work in you, will perfect it unto the day
of Christ Jesus." ^^
"As to the rest, there is laid up for me a crown of
justice, which the Lord the just judge will render to me
in that day, and not only to me but to them also that
love his coming. Make haste to come to me quickly." ^^
"The Lord knoweth how to deliver the godly from
temptation, but to reserve the unjust unto the day of
judgment to be tormented." ^^
"And the angels who kept not their principality but
forsook their own habitation, he hath reserved, under
darkness in everlasting chains unto judgment of the
great day." ^^
We have selected these various Scripture verses to
show that "the Lord's Day," as quoted by Cardinal Gib-
bons from Paul's letter to the Corinthians, refers to a
day when all are judged, the good and the evil, and not
to an intermediate place and judgment. The fire re-
ferred to by Paul in his letter is on the last day.
In the parable of the rich man (Dives) and Lazarus,
Our Saviour gives scenes from the Unseen World. The
parable follows the parable of the unjust steward, and
shows demands that will be made of those to whom God
has intrusted riches, but between the stories are verses
of Scripture which tell us that no part of the law will
fail; that practices which the Pharisees legalized and
shared in, involved them as violators of the Command-
ments.
In the parable in which Dives appears as a certain
28 I Cor. 5:5. ^^ H Tim. 4 : 8. ^2 j^de i : 6.
29 Philip 1:6. 31 II Peter. 2 : 9.
PURGATORY 93
rich man, nothing is said of his having any traits of
character that would have placed him outside of a circle
which the Pharisees would have deemed respectable.
He failed in that he did not make such use of the riches
entrusted to him as would have won for him friends
such as Lazarus secured.
"And it came to pass that the beggar died, and was
carried by the angels into Abraham's bosom; and the
rich man also died, and he was buried in hell." *'And
lifting up his eyes, when he was in torments he saw
Abraham afar off, and Lazarus in his bosom." "And
he cried and said: Father Abraham, have mercy on me
and send Lazarus, that he may dip the tip of his finger
in water, to cool my tongue, for I am tormented in this
flame."
"And Abraham said to him. Son, remember that thou
didst receive good things in thy lifetime, and likewise
Lazarus evil things; but now he is comforted and thou
art tormented." "And besides all this between us and
you there is fixed a great chaos, so that they who would
pass hence to you, cannot, nor from thence come hither."
"And he said, Then, Father, I beseech thee, that thou
wouldst send him to my father's house for I have five
brethren." "That he may testify unto them, lest they
also come into this place of torments." "And Abraham
said to him. They have Moses and the prophets, let them
hear them." "But he said. No, Father Abraham, but if
one went to them from the dead they will do penance."
"And he said to him: If they hear not Moses and the
prophets, neither will they believe if one rise again from
the dead." ^^
As in other parables of Our Saviour, it is here sought
to show conditions that are unseen by presenting those
22 Luke 16: 22-31.
94 THE ROMAN CATHOLIC BIBLE
things that are before us in everyday life, here the letter
cannot be taken without killing the story, the purpose
of the story being destroyed. By taking the spirit of
the parable, conditions are revealed from which we learn
the following truths.
In the eyes of the God of Abraham, Dives who had re-
ceived good things, had failed in his trust, refusing to
hear and obey either Moses or the prophets. On the
other hand, Lazarus had received evil things in his asso-
ciation with the world, and in the eyes of the God of
Abraham was fit to be carried by angels into Abraham's
bosom. Dives, clothed in purple and fine linen, unmind-
ful of his fellow man, passed through the gates of his
dwelling, where Lazarus lay in pitiable condition. Laz-
arus needed help which God had given Dives the oppor-
tunity to bestow. Dives imparted to those of his house-
hold his own spirit. It is mentioned that no one gave
to Lazarus the crumbs that he craved, or prevented the
dogs from Hcking his sores. At his death, Lazarus is
carried to Abraham's bosom, while Dives in torment
looking up, beholds the blessed state of the beggar who
lay at the gate. Dives cries for mercy, not to God but
to Abraham. He asks that Lazarus, who was refused
the crumbs that once fell from his table, be sent to
touch his tongue with the water that might be contained
on the tip of his finger. He was in flames, tormented.
How could bliss and torment be more effectively pic-
tured to Our Saviour's hearers?
In reply, Abraham reminds Dives of the good things
he had received in his lifetime, and which w^hen he had
the opportunity, he refused to supply to Lazarus (con-
trary to the teachings of Moses and the prophets) and
that now Lazarus was comforted.
"Besides all this between us and you there is fixed a
PURGATORY 95
great chaos, so that they who would cannot pass from
one to the other."
What words more definite could be used than those
given by Our Saviour, conveying the idea of there being
no intermediate place between the two conditions in
which Lazarus and Dives found themselves?
There is a further appeal from Dives, again not to
God, but to Abraham, whom the Pharisees relied in as
their father, rather than in the God of Abraham. Dives
beseeched that Lazarus be sent to his five brothers, con-
tending that if one rose from the dead, they would be-
lieve, but Abraham says, "If they hear not Moses and
the prophets, neither will they believe if one rise again
from the dead."
yii
THE SACRAMENT OF PENANCE
IN dealing with this question Cardinal Gibbons says:
"But the important question here presents itself :
How was man to obtain forgiveness in the church
after our Lord's ascension?
"Was Jesus Christ to appear in person to every sinful
soul and say to each penitent as he said to Magdalen,
'Thy sins are forgiven thee/ or did He intend to dele-
gate this power of forgiving sins to ministers appointed
for that purpose?" — Page 389
These questions are plainly answered in the Saviour's
last discourse to His disciples:
"And I will ask the Father and he shall give you
another Paraclete, that he may abide w^ith you forever."
"The Spirit of truth whom the world cannot receive
because it seeth him not, nor knoweth him, but you
shall know him, because he shall abide with you, and
shall be in you." ^
"He shall glorify me: Because he shall receive of
mine and shall shew it to you." -
"I will not leave you orphans, I will come to you." ^
"And not for them only do I pray, but for them also,
who through their word shall believe in me." "I in
them, and thou in me : That they may be made perfect in
one." ^
Far from desiring a separation between men and Him-
self, that some intermediate intercessor beside His own
ijohn 14:16, 17. 3 John 14:18.
2 John 16 : 14. •* John 17 : 20-23.
96
THE SACRAMENT OF PENANCE 97
Spirit might fill a gap, Our Saviour taught directly the
contrary.
"And I say to you, Ask and it shall be given you.
Seek and you shall find. Knock and it shall be opened
to you.
*Tf you then being evil know how to give good gifts
to your children, how much more will your Father
from Heaven give the good Spirit to them that ask
him." '
Like the sun in its course, the Spirit of Christ broods
over the earth and men, bringing light and life to all
that will receive.
"Thine is the day, and thine is the night: Thou hast
made the morning light and the sun." "Thou hast made
all the borders of the earth : the summer and the spring
were formed by thee." ^
"And the moon shall blush and the sun shall be
ashamed when the Lord of Hosts shall reign in Mount
Sion, and in Jerusalem, and shall be glorified in the sight
of his ancients." "^
"I Jesus have sent my angel to testify to you these
things in the churches. I am the root and stock of
David, the bright and morning star. "And the Spirit
and the Bride say Come, And he that heareth let him
say Come, and he that thirsteth, let him come, and he
that will, let him take the water of life freely." ^
It is to be noticed that in the invitation given above,
as in all invitations of the gospel, it is to come to Christ
to partake of the water of life. The Bride, the church,
joins in the invitation. In no case whatever in Scripture
is the partaking of anything short of Christ said to effect
salvation. Therefore the following plea for "The Sac-
5 Luke IT : 9, 13. '^ Isa. 24 : 23.
0 Psa. 73 : 16-17. 8 Apocalypse 22 : 16-17.
98 THE ROMAN CATHOLIC BIBLE
rament of Penance," by Cardinal Gibbons, is without
Scriptural support, namely:
"If God is able to save us without any priestly minis-
trations, why then are not the people informed, that they
can in future dispense altogether with the services of the
clergy without any detriment to their own salvation:
St. Augustine, who lived 1400 years ago, will answer
the objection for me — 'Let no one,' remarked this illus-
trious doctor, 'say to himself, I da penance to God in
private : I do it before God : Is it then in vain that Christ
has said. Whatsoever ye shall loose on earth shall be
loosed in heaven? Is it in vain that the keys have been
given to the Church?' The question for us is not what
God is able to do, but what He has willed to do; God
might have adopted other means for the justification of
the sinner, as He might have created a world different
from the present one. But it is our business to take our
Father at His word and to have recourse with gratitude
to the system He has actually established for our justi-
fication. Now we are assured by His infallible word,
that it is by having recourse to His consecrated ministers
that our sins will be forgiven us." — Pages 411-12
Here reference is made to the 20th Chapter of John.
This passage in John is referred to as the Scriptural
evidence held by the Reverend Cardinal Gibbons, to-
gether with Matt. 16: 18, 19, as proving his own asser-
tions.
"Our Saviour did confer on the Apostles and their
successors the power to forgive sins." — Page 391
Also that
"In the Gospel of St. John we have a still more strik-
ing declaration of the absolving power given by our
Saviour to His apostles." — Page 392
THE SACRAMENT OF PENANCE 99
It is well to point to the manifest truth in these Scrip-
ture references before pointing to any of the hundreds
of other Scripture references which plainly place the
forgiveness of sins by God solely and only with the
Father, the Son and Holy Ghost. In no instance is it
recorded in Scripture that the Apostles acted as an inter-
mediate between God and man in forgiving sin, except
as preachers of the Gospel they taught repentance and
belief in the Saviour; nor is there any instance where
they said to any, "Thy sins are forgiven."
**He said therefore to them again, Peace be to you.
As the Father hath sent me I also send you."
"When he had said this he breathed on them, and he
said to them. Receive ye the Holy Ghost." "Whose sins
you shall forgive, they are forgiven them, and whose
sins you shall retain they are retained." ^
Here are also the parallel accounts given by Mark and
Luke : —
"At length he appeared to the eleven as they were at
table : and he upbraided them with their incredulity and
hardness of heart, because they did not believe them who
had seen him after he was risen again." "And he said
to them. Go ye into the whole world and preach the
gospel to every creature."
"He that believeth and is baptized shall be saved. But
he that believeth not shall be condemned." ^^
"Then he opened their understanding that they might
understand the Scriptures." "And he isaid to them.
Thus it is written and thus it behooved Christ to suffer
and to rise again from the dead the third day."
"And that penance and remission of sins should be
preached in his name unto all nations, beginning at
Jerusalem." "And you are witnesses of these things." ^^
0 John 20 : 21-23. 1^ Mark 16 : 14-16. i^ Luke 24 : 45-49.
lOO THE ROMAN CATHOLIC BIBLE
It was immediately following and connected with the
Saviour's breathing upon the disciples and saying to
them, ^'Receive ye the Holy Ghost/' that He said,
*'Whose sins ye shall forgive they are forgiven them,
and whose sins you shall retain, they are retained."
It plainly appears in this command and in the parallel
passages in Mark and Luke, that it was the Christ and
His Spirit through whom forgiveness was to come, and
they were simply the witness of this Gospel which they
were commanded to preach.
The heart of man is wholly known to God only.
*'Hear thou from heaven, from thy high dwelling-
place and forgive, and render to every one according to
his ways which thou knowest him to have in his heart:
(for thou only knowest the hearts of the children of
men)."^^
Prayer was m.ade the medium by the apostles through
which forgiveness in Christ Jesus was to come to those
to whom they preached. They never assumed the re-
sponsibility of pronouncing forgiveness to any man.
Peter directed Simon the magician to pray to God for
forgiveness, not assuming to accept his penance and him-
self pronounce forgiveness, but contrariwise it is men-
tioned that the disciples testified and preached the word
of the Lord.
"Keep thy money to thyself, to perish with thee be-
cause thou hast thought that the gift of God may be pur-
chased with money."
"'Thou hast no part nor lot in this matter. For thy
heart is not right in the sight of God.
''Do penance therefore for this thy wickedness and
pray to God that perhaps this thought of thy heart may
12 II Paralipomenon (II Chronicles) 6:30.
THE SACRAMENT OF PENANCE loi
be forgiven thee." "For I see thou art in the gall of
bitterness and in the bonds of iniquity."
"Then Simon answering said, Pray you for me to the
Lord, that none of these things which you have spoken
may come upon me." "And they indeed having testi-
fied and preached the word of the Lord, returned to
Jerusalem and preached the gospel to many countries of
the Samaritans." ^^
No one but the Father, Son and Holy Ghost could
make the declaration following in Luke, and assume the
responsibility involved in it; and never has that respon-
sibility, so far as Scripture shows, been delegated to any
other person.
"And I say to you, whosoever shall confess me before
men, him shall the Son of Man also confess before the
angels of God." "But he that shall deny me before men
shall be denied before the angels of God."
"And whosoever speaketh a word against the Son of
Man it shall be forgiven him ; but to him that shall blas-
pheme against the Holy Ghost it shall not be forgiven." ^*
The disciples were sent forth as preachers of the
Gospel, to testify to Christ's crucifixion, resurrection
and His power to forgive sins, and of the finished atone-
ment by His blood. Whose sins were forgiven by this
witnessing and preaching on earth were thus verified as
forgiven from His throne in Heaven. Whose sins were
retained were so verified as retained from His throne
in Heaven, for he that believed not the Christ they
preached was condemned already. His seal was thus
placed upon the results of the preaching and witnessing
of the apostles.
Christ never left His disciples or apostles: His per-
18 Acts 8 : 20-25. ^"^ Luke 12 : 8-10.
I02 THE ROMAN CATHOLIC BIBLE
sonal prerogatives were never delegated: He is a jealous
God.
**But they going forth preached everywhere : the Lord
working withal, and confirming the word with signs that
followed." ^^
The fellowship of Christ with His apostles and dis-
ciples was closer after His ascension than when with
them in the flesh because of His presence with the
Father in the glory that He had before the world was,
and because of His presence at the same time with His
brethren, whom He had brought into oneness with Llim-
self, even as He was one with the Father.
*'That they all may be one, as thou Father in me and
I in thee that they also may be one in us ; that the world
may believe that thou hast sent me." ^^
"Teaching them to observe all things whatsoever I
have commanded you, and behold I am with you all
days." ^'
"Behold I stand at the gate and knock. If any man
shall hear my voice, and open to me the door, I will
come in to him, and will sup with him and he with me." ^^
The Incarnate Son of God did not speak or work of
Himself, but performed the mission upon which He was
sent of His Father. Nowhere is it stated in Scripture
that He was to leave a vacancy that was to be filled by
man. His Spirit was to be sent and was sent and His
presence is with all who will receive Him, and that
which His Father committed to Him for His disciples
He gave to them.
"For I have not spoken of myself but the Father who
sent me. He gave me commandment, what I should
say, and what I should speak." ^®
15 Mark i6 : 20. ^'^ Matt. 28 : 20. ^^ John 12 : 49.
i« John 17 : 21. IS Apocalypse 3 : 20.
THE SACRAMENT OF PENANCE 103
"Do you not believe that I am in the Father and the
Father in me? The words that I speak to you, I speak
not of myself, but the Father who abideth in me he
doeth the works." ^^
"And the glory which thou hast given me, I have
given to them; that they may be one, as we also are
one." 2^
With this Presence of God the Father, God the Son
and God the Holy Ghost, forever with the penitent one
in that union made known by the words of Our Saviour,
how can we find need of a fourth personage in man to
supplement by forgiveness to the sinner that which is
already vouchsafed to him by the perfected work of the
Redeemer? How can we reconcile the delegating to
another of that which He stated so plainly was not of
His own but the command of His Father? But rather,
how consistent and in keeping with the written word is
His command to His disciples that they teach and preach
and witness, and receive the promise of the Father?
"But you shall receive the power of the Holy Ghost
coming upon you, and you shall be witnesses unto me in
Jerusalem, and in all Judea, and Samaria, even to the
uttermost part of the earth." ^^
That the forgiveness of sins was through faith, and
not through any dogma of ecclesiastical bodies, is illus-
trated by Paul in his letter to the Romans.
"As David also termeth the blessedness of a man to
whom God reputeth justice without works."
"Blessed are they whose iniquities are forgiven and
whose sins are covered."
"Blessed is the man to whom the Lord hath not im-
puted sin." ^^
2« John 14: 10. 22 Acts t:8.
21 John 17 : 22. 23 Romans 4:6, 7, 8.
I04 THE ROMAN CATHOLIC BIBLE
Again in Acts, the Lord's commission to the Apostle
Paul:
*'To open their eyes, that they may be converted from
darkness to light, and from the power of Satan to God,
that they may receive forgiveness of sins, and a lot
among the saints, by the faith that is in me/' ^^
Also we find in the following, both repentance and for-
giveness are from God.
''But he whom God hath raised from the dead saw no
corruption/'
''Be it known therefore to you, men, brethren, that
through him forgiveness of sins is preached to you, and
from all the things from which you could not be justi-
fied by the law of Aloses." -^
"Him hath God exalted with his right hand, to be
prince and Saviour to give repentance to Israel, and re-
mission of sins."
"And we are witnesses of these things and the Holy
Spirit whom God hath given to all that obey him." -^
His Prophet Daniel places forgiveness as belonging to
the Lord,
"O Lord, to us belongeth confusion of face, to our
princes and to our fathers that have sinned."
"But to thee the Lord our God, mercy and forgiveness
for we have parted from thee." -•
Through the prayer of faith and not by a prerogative
of any man save Christ Jesus, was sin to be forgiven,
and still faith must be exercised in the promise of for-
giveness.
"And the prayer of faith shall save the sick man, and
the Lord shall raise him up; and if he be in sins they
shall be f ormven him." ^^
^&^
24 Acts 26 : 18. 26 Acts 5 : 3i, 32. 28 James 5 : i5-
25 Acts 13 : 37, 38. 27 Daniel 9:8, 9.
THE SACRAMENT OF PENANCE 105
Had it been necessary that the penitent should go to
a priest to confess his sins and receive absolution, it
would have been somewhere in Scripture so directed, or
some instance cited; but nowhere in Scripture do we
find such a practice among Christ's disciples or any com-
mand to such efifect. On the contrary, the Scripture is
full of instances of the direct appeal to God by the
sinner, and direct encouragement to the sinner to come
to Him; neither is there to be found any practice of the
Apostles of Christ asking or requiring or countenancing
any such confession through which they pronounced ab-
solution upon the penitent sinner.
While confession to a priest may be made without
harm to any one, and in cases with possible benefit to
the one who confesses, yet such is not the invitation from
Christ, who says, ''Come unto me"; and in no case is it
said. And my apostle or my minister will absolve you.
The injunction is. Confess your sins one to another,
but as elsewhere in the Written Word, it is by prayer
that the faith in God's forgiveness is exercised, and not
by absolution granted by man in God's stead.
The letter of James was to the twelve tribes without
discrimination.
"Confess therefore your sins one to another : and pray
one for another that you may be saved, for the continual
prayer of a just man availeth much." "^
*Tf we confess our sins, he is faithful and just to for-
give us our sins and to cleanse us from all iniquities." ^^
"In whom we have redemption through his blood, the
remission of sins." ^^
"And I prayed to the Lord my God, and I made my
confession, and said, T beseech thee, O Lord God, great
and terrible, who keepest thy covenant, and mercy to
2» James 5 : 16. 30 j John 1:9. 3i Col. i : 14.
io6 THE ROMAN CATHOLIC BIBLE
them that love thee and keep thy commandments,"
**We have sinned, we have committed iniquity, we have
done wickedly, and have revolted, and we have gone
aside from the commandments and thy judgments/' ^^
*T have acknowledged my sin to thee and my injustice
I have not concealed. I said I will confess against my-
self my injustice to the Lord : and thou hast forgiven
the wickedness of my sin. For this shall every one that
is holy pray to thee in a seasonable time." ^^
*'But thou, why judgest thou thy brother? Or thou,
why doest thou despise thy brother? For we shall all
stand before the judgment seat of Christ." "For it is
written, As I live, saith the Lord, every knee shall bow
to me and every tongue shall confess to God."
"Therefore every one of us shall render account to
God Himself." ^^
The penitent heart is not here led by the "Sacrament
of Penance" direct to the Saviour or the Saviour's
words, but by implication of the Reverend Cardinal
Gibbons is directed first to confession before a priest
that he may be absolved by him. We give the Saviour's
words, which we should consider when we pray "for-
give us our debts as we forgive our debtors" as one
way in which the absolution of Him whom we have
sinned against, may be given, and the peace which
passeth understanding may be ours through the inter-
cession of the "Prince of Peace."
"But when thou shalt pray, enter into thy chamber,
and having shut the door, pray to thy Father in secret;
and thy Father which seeth in secret will repay thee." ^^
Here is Cardinal Gibbons' version of the authority of
the Roman Catholic Church to absolve from sin,
32 Dan. 9:4, 5. 34 Romans 14 : 10.
33 Psalms 31 : 5, 6. 35 Matt. 6 : 6.
THE SACRAMENT OF PENANCE 107
"Naman went and washed and was cleansed. Our
opponents like Naman, cry out, *Why should you go to
a priest, a sinner like yourself, when secretly in your
own room you can approach God, the pure fountain of
grace, to be washed from your sins?' I answer because
Jesus Christ, a prophet and more than a prophet, has
commanded you to do so."
— Faith of Our Fathers, Pages 412-413
But when did Jesus give such a command? Fie did
give the command quoted above from Matt. 6.
"Let it be understood once for all that the priest abro-
gates to himself no divine powers. He is but a feeble
voice. It is the Holy Spirit that operates the sanctity in
the soul of the penitent."
— Faith of Our Fathers, Page 410
But if the priest abrogates to himself no divine powers,
how is he a representation fitted to act for divine
powers? Is a priest teaching the gospel of Jesus Christ
not an ambassador for Christ, with full power to pre-
sent that gospel which loosens the captive from his chains
of sin through "the Holy Ghost who operates sanctity
to the soul"?
But an ambassador, though a feeble voice, fully rep-
resents his government in that which he has been in-
structed to represent. But he is withholden from acting
for his government in matters in which he has not been
instructed.
Where in Scripture has any man or any priest been
given the power on earth to forgive sins, save Jesus
Christ, "the Son of Man"?
Were the disciples given instructions to forgive sins,
in the commission imparted to them by the Saviour?
Many specific instructions were given them, but none
to forgive sins. They were even to raise the dead, but
io8 THE ROMAN CATHOLIC BIBLE
no instructions were given them to absolve any person
from sin. The gospel and the Holy Spirit in the gospel
would direct to seek Christ Jesus, and asking they would
be forgiven.
"And as ye go, preach, saying, the Kingdom of
Heaven is at hand." ^^
They were to preach repentance. God alone can lead
to repentance. They were to preach the forgiveness of
sins. God alone can forgive sins, in His person of
Father, Son and Holy Ghost.
''O Lord, to us belongeth confusion of face." "But
to Thee, the Lord our God, mercy and forgiveness.'*^^
36 Acts 13 : 38. 37 Daniel 9 : 8, 9.
VIII
INDULGENCES
A NATURAL sequence to its claim as head of
Christendom and a delegated power for for-
giving sins, is the Roman Church tenet of In-
dulgences. Here is given Cardinal Gibbons' definition
of this tenet of the Roman Church.
"An indulgence is simply a remission in whole or in
part through the superabundant merits of Jesus Christ
and His saints of the temporal punishment due to God
on account of sin, after the guilt and eternal punish-
ment have been remitted. It should be borne in mind
that even after our guilt is removed, there often remains
some temporal punishment to be undergone, either in
this life or the next, as an expiation to divine sanctity
and justice." r—Page 428
To this His Reverence adds :
"Now there are two impediments that withhold a man
from the heavenly Kingdom — sin and the temporal pun-
ishment incurred by it." — Page 429
We are unable to bring together in harmony these
separate statements. Either Cardinal Gibbons wishes to
inform us that the Roman Church does not hold that
the Kingdom of Heaven has been obtained by the peni-
tent through merits of Jesus Christ "after the guilt and
punishment have been remitted," or else that the merits
of Jesus Christ are insufificient to effect both an entrance
to the Kingdom of Heaven and at the same time to
satisfy "divine sanctity and justice."
109
no THE ROMAN CATHOLIC BIBLE
Where in the Scripture can be found such a division
of impediments withholding a man from the heavenly-
Kingdom? There is no such division. When a man
turns to Jesus Christ from his sins, it is because the
Spirit of God has so led him, and he is accepted as he is.
"And the church having power to remit the greater
obstacle which is sin, has power also to remove the
smaller obstacle, which is the temporal punishment due
on account of it/' — Page 429
How can the Roman Catholic Church reach iniquities,
which when forgiven of God are "removed as far as
the east is from the west" ? ^
Or how can temporal punishment be exacted from
man as due to God from those iniquities which He has
"blotted out"?
"Be penitent therefore and be converted that your sins
may be blotted out." ^
"I have blotted out thy iniquities as a cloud, and thy
sins as a mist: return unto me for I have redeemed
thee." ^
"I am, I am he that blot out thy iniquities for my
own sake and I will not remember thy sins."^
"Blotting out the handwriting of the decree that was
against us, which was contrary to us, and he hath taken
the same out of the way, fastening it to the cross." ^
What is "the obstacle" that yet remains, and "the
punishment due" after the handwriting of the decree
has been blotted out, and fastened to the Cross? Is
there something left as a stain after God has blotted out,
or is the cross weak and insufficient that we should turn
from the cross to the Roman Catholic Church for
1 Psalm 102 : 12. ^ Isaiah 44:22. ^ Col. 2 : 14.
2 Acts 3 : 19. ^ Isaiah 43 : 25.
INDULGENCES iii
"power to remit" the iniquities and sins already nailed
to the cross, remembered no more by the *'I am" ?
How plainly the Apostle Paul expresses our redemp-
tion in Jesus Christ, in the following three lines :
"And their sins and iniquities I will remember no
more : Now where there is a remission of these, there is
no more an oblation for sin." ^
It is to be noted that the word "oblation" is in Roman
Law "a formal tender by a debtor to his creditor of a
sum of money in payment of a debt."
The Holy Spirit in a Psalm of David conveys the
following purport of sin:
"To thee 'only have I sinned and done evil before
thee." ^
Why then need the Roman Catholic Church place
itself between the sinner and the one sinned against,
when Christ Jesus has already placed Himself there,
and directed His apostles to witness for Him? Does
not every true church consist of those who become the
church of God, "which He hath purchased with His own
blood"?
"The word indulgence originally signified favor, re-
mission or forgiveness."
— Faith of Our Fathers, Page 428
Is it consistent for man, who should daily pray like
the prayer He taught us, beginning "Father, hallowed
be Thy name," to assume the power to "favor" by "re-
mitting" or "forgiving" the effects of sin, or to assume
that any church has "power to remit the greater ob-
stacle which is sin"?
Did not Nathan the Prophet when accusing King
David, say to him :
"And David said to Nathan, I have sinned against the
6 Heb. 10 : 17, 18. '^ Psalm 50 : 6.
112 THE ROMAN CATHOLIC BIBLE
Lord. And Nathan said to David, The Lord also hath
taken away thy guilt." ^
We find our Lord thus forgiving David, although ab-
sent from earth as regards mention of any bodily pres-
ence. Why may He not forgive the sinner who comes
to Him at His call, although He may not be here in
bodily presence? And that without committing His pre-
rogative to a pope or priest?
Does not Scripture make plain that the Church of
Christ consists of His own people? Would not then a
church be forgiving its own self if it was the only
source of forgiveness on earth?
Read the following from Paul's letter to Ephesians.
*'That he might sanctify it, cleansing it by the *laver
of water' in the word of life."
"That he might present it to himself a glorious church,
not having spot or wrinkle." ®
"Now you are clean by reason of the word which I
have spoken to you."
"Abide in me, and I in you." ^®
Under strange teaching, God is supposed to hold the
penalty of sin still against the sinner, in the form of
temporal punishment for it. As sin in such case relates
not to the ills which sin brings to man's nature, but as an
impediment to his entering the Kingdom, therefore the
forgiveness of the Only Begotten Son of God becomes
insufficient until supplemented by the forgiveness or re-
mittance of the Roman Catholic Church through an in-
dulgence, as Cardinal Gibbons would make it.
"Indulgences continue to be necessary now, if not as a
substitute for canonical penances, at least as a mild and
merciful payment of the temporal debt due to God."
— Faith of Our Fathers, Page 431
8 11 Kings (Samuel) 12:13. ^ Eph. 5:26-27.
10 John 15:3-4.
INDULGENCES 113
We imagine something akin to a chill would come to
the intelligent child who is given such teaching regarding
forgiveness, instead of that which it receives at its
mother's knee when in its confession of wrong it receives
the fond, forgiving kiss and the restored favor of a
loving parent who has taught her child, "J^sus loves me,
this I know, for the Bible tells me so."
"And forgive us our debts as we also forgive our
debtors." ^^
"All that the Father giveth to me shall come to me
and him that cometh to me, I will not cast out." ^^
"For in Him dwelleth all the fullness of the Godhead
corporally."
"And you are filled in Him who is the Head of all
principality and power."
"Buried with Him in baptism in whom also you are
risen again by the faith of the operation of God, who
hath raised Him up from the dead." "And you when
you were dead in your sin and the uncircumcision of
your flesh. He hath quickened together with Him, for-
giving you all offenses." ^^
What pleasure is felt in turning from Roman Catholic
Church dogma to the Roman Catholic Bible, from which
we so often quote, and which contains so much that en-
lightens and gives joy. No dispensation of man can
ever compete with that of the Son of God.
Here we give Scripture touching upon the all suffi-
ciency of the merits of Jesus Christ. As to the merits of
His saints, are they not all agreed that Christ Jesus is
their all and in all?
"For the end of the law is Christ unto justice to every
one that believeth." ^*
11 Matt. 6:12. 13 Col. 2:9, 10, 12, 13.
12 John 6:37. 1* Rom. 10:4.
114 THE ROMAN CATHOLIC BIBLE
"For whether we live we live unto the Lord, or
whether we die we die unto the Lord." "Therefore
whether we live or whether we die, we are the Lord's." ^^
"Who shall accuse against the elect of God? God
that justifieth." ^^
"But all things are of God who hath reconciled us to
himself by Christ, and hath given to us the ministry of
reconciliation. . . . Him who knew no sin, he hath made
sin for us, that we might be made the justice of God
in him." ^'
"And let the peace of Christ rejoice in your hearts
wherein also you are called in one body, and be ye thank-
ful." ^«
There being then no temporal punishment due on ac-
count of sin, to those who are "elect of God," there can
be no room for the granting of indulgences by the Roman
Church.
Under the title of "Indulgences," Cardinal Gibbons
again refers to what he calls the power of granting in-
dulgences, as follows : —
"That our Lord has given to the church the power of
granting indulgences, is clearly deduced from the sacred
text. To the Prince of the Apostles, He said What-
soever thou shalt bind on earth, shall be bound also in
Heaven, and whatsoever thou shalt loose on earth shall
be loosed also in Heaven. By these words our Saviour
empowered His church to deliver her children (if
properly disposed) from every obstacle that might re-
tard them from the Kingdom of Heaven."
— Page 429
The substitution of the Roman Church where Scrip-
ture places the work of the Holy Spirit, is the main-
15 Rom. 14 : 8. 17 n Cor. 5 : 18, 21.
16 Rom. 8:33. ^^Col. 3:15.
INDULGENCES 115
spring of all the inharmonious dogma which pertains to
the tenets in question, as Cardinal Gibbons describes
them. Here is Scripture, the gospel; no indulgence re-
quired.
*'And the Book of Isaias the Prophet was delivered to
him, And as he unfolded the book, he found the place
where it was written, 'The Spirit of the Lord is upon
me, wherefore he hath anointed me to preach the gospel
to the poor, he hath sent me to heal the contrite of
heart. To preach deliverance to the captives, and sight
to the blind, to set at liberty them that are bruised, to
preach the acceptable year of the Lord, and the day of
reward." ^^
"Jesus answered and said to him. Amen, Amen, I say
to thee, unless a man be born again he cannot see the
Kingdom of God. That which is born of the flesh is
flesh, and that which is born of the Spirit is Spirit." ^^
We can but reason that if the forgiveness of sins is
divinely appointed to the Roman Catholic Church, then
since God is the God of the living and not of the
dead, those living in Purgatory, so called, must like-
wise be susceptible of the divinely appointed authority
of that church for forgiveness of their sins; if other-
wise the act of forgiveness by such authority, is held
to be only to those who are living here, and that all are
beyond the jurisdiction of that prerogative after death,
then must the prerogative claimed for "Absolution" as
administered by that church be brought in question, and
forgiveness of sins by God the Father, God the Son and
God the Holy Ghost, only be valid.
i» Luke 4:17, 19. 20 John 3:^^ 6.
IX
THE BIBLE AND THE CHURCH
THE church consists o£ those whom Jesus Christ
wins to himself by His sacrifice upon the cross,
those given Him by the Father,
"And I if I be hfted up from the earth, will draw all
things to myself." ^
*^No man can come to me except the Father who hath
sent me draw him, and I will raise him up in the last
day." -
"Every one that cometh to me and heareth my words,
and doeth them, I will show you to whom he is like."
"He is like to a man building a house who digged deep
and laid the foundation upon a rock, and when a flood
came the stream beat vehemently upon that house and it
could not shake it, for it was founded on a rock." ^
"Every one therefore who heareth these my words
and doeth them, shall be likened to a wise man that built
his house upon a rock. And the rain fell and the floods
came and the winds blew and they beat upon that house,
and it fell not for it was founded upon a rock." ^
Cardinal Gibbons' interpretation of the above Scrip-
ture is here given :
"But if Jesus predicted the truth when He declared
that the gates of hell should not prevail against His
Church, and who dare deny it? Then the Church never
^ John 12 : z'2-^ ^ Luke 6 : 47, 48.
2 John 6 : 44. ^ Matt. 7 : 24, 25.
116
THE BIBLE AND THE CHURCH 117
has and never could have fallen from the truth. Then
the Catholic Church is infallible, for she alone claims
the prerogative, for she is the only church that is
acknowledged to have existed from the beginning.
Truly is Jesus that wise architect mentioned in the gospel
who built His house upon a rock and the rain fell, and
the floods came, and the winds blew, and they beat upon
that house, and it fell not, for it was founded upon a
rock." r— Faith of Our Fathers, Page 88
Cardinal Gibbons directly connects the Roman Catholic
Church with this parable of our Saviour, and with the
words of Our Lord to Peter, as the rock upon which
that church is founded, and against which the gates of
hell shall not prevail.
Let us notice the error of his interpretation as to who
the Rock is — whether Jesus Christ **the Word made
flesh," or Peter, His disciple.
Likeness to the wise builder is made by our Saviour
to every one that cometh to Him and heareth His words,
and doeth them.
Cardinal Gibbons would make it to appear that Jesus
Himself IS here represented as a wise architect who built
upon a rock, meaning that the Roman Catholic Church is
.built upon Peter the rock, as he states in other places of
his book which we have quoted from, and thus he would
make the words of Our Lord, who makes every one that
cometh to Him to be the builders, to be altered to fit the
dogma of the Roman Catholic Church.
Instead of those who coming to Jesus hear and do His
words, being the builders, and forming themselves His
church, Cardinal Gibbons makes Jesus to be the builder
and the people who coming to Him, hear and do, are left
out of the reckoning entirely. Christ becomes the archi-
tect who builds, Peter a pope and his successors with the
Roman hierarchy forming the Roman Catholic Church,
ii8 THE ROMAN CATHOLIC BIBLE
the church represented in the "Faith Of Our Fathers'*
as being the "mother" of those who adhere to it.
"The Catholic Church the enemy of the Bible? As
well might you accuse the Virgin Mother of trying to
crush the Infant Saviour at her breast, as to accuse the
Church, our mother, of attempting to crush the existence
of the Word of God/'
— Faith of Our Fathers, Page 112
Thus Cardinal Gibbons teaches that the Rock is a
pope, upon which Christ Jesus as an architect built an
infallible church which he claims to be the Roman Cath-
olic Church, no mention being made of "every one who
cometh to me" and who are likened to the wise
builder.
How different from the words of the parable which
makes the "Word made flesh," Himself, the Rock and
every one who comes to Him hearing His words and
doing them, to be the wise builders, who thus become His
church.
This parable is not only impossible of the interpreta-
tion given it by his Reverence, Cardinal Gibbons, but
directly controverts the interpretation he makes of the
words of Our Saviour in Matthew 16 : 18, thus assum-
ing that Christ would build His church upon Peter in-
stead upon Peter's witnessing. "Thou art Christ the Son
of the living God," for which Peter was blessed by Our
Lord for having witnessed.
It is clearly demonstrated that the parable of the wise
builder has an entirely different meaning from that put
upon it by Cardinal Gibbons. The wise builder in this
parable is likened by the words of Our Saviour to hear-
ing and doing, because the wise builder hears the words
of Jesus and does them, and such interpretation must be
THE BIBLE AND THE CHURCH 119
given to the meaning in Matt. 16: Jesus heard the words
of His Father and did His will. **Upon this Rock I will
build my Church." Assertions of Christ concerning the
building of His Church and Kingdom could not contra-
dict each other.
"For by grace you are saved through faith, and that
not of yourselves for it is the gift of God/' ^
"Take heed to yourselves and to the whole flock
wherein the Holy Ghost hath placed you Bishops to rule
the church of God, which He hath purchased with His
own blood." ^
How is it possible to hold to any other meaning of
this Scripture from Acts, 20th Chapter, just quoted, than
that the Church of God is composed of the whole flock
over which the Holy Ghost places Bishops to rule, and
that Bishops who rule cannot themselves be the church,
but are only a part of it?
The truth is that nowhere in Scripture can we find
that the church of Christ is other than the people of
Christ with Christ Himself as the Head.
Those who have come to Jesus hear and do His words,
wherever they may be the world over, in whatever
environments they may exist, they with Him whose words
they do, form the true church.
The Holy Ghost having placed those who rule His
own church, it must necessarily follow that the Holy
Ghost, one of the "Three in One" must be the infallible
One rather than a pope. Him whom Christ sent when He
went away. He is a vicar of Christ on earth,
"He will teach you all things." '^
"For the Lord loveth judgment and will not forsake
His saints." ®
"And all flesh shall know that I am tlie Lord, that
6 Eph. 2:8. 0 Acts 20 : 28. '^ John 14 : 26. « Psalm 36 : 28.
120 THE ROMAN CATHOLIC BIBLE
save thee, and thy Redeemer the mighty one of Jacob." ^
*''And in thee and thy seed all the tribes of the earth
shall be blessed."
''Neither will I leave thee till I shall have accomplished
all that I have said." ^'
"And behold I am with you all days, even to the con-
summation of the world." ^^
In these verses w^e have the names of the Deity — the
Lord ; The Redeemer, in Isaiah and Psalms ; The Seed ;
The Son of God in Genesis; and The Holy Ghost in
Matthew. Father, Son and Holy Ghost. Thus we
have Three in One, "the fullness of the God Head"
dwelling in Jesus Christ, the only Begotten Son of God,
w^ith His people to the consummation of the world.
With this assurance, surely the rule of a pope cannot be
vital to Our Lord's church; for Jesus Himself is "the
way, the truth, and the Life."
Far be it from the writer to judge those who adhere
to the Roman Catholic Church. Nevertheless the Roman
Catholic Bible proves the Star of Bethlehem to be a
better guide than the Vatican.
May God grant that those who seek and yet have
failed to find, may have the Day Star rising in their
hearts.
"And we have the more firm prophetical word, where-
unto you do well to attend as to a light that shineth in a
dark place, until the day dawn, and the Day Star arise
in your hearts." ^^
Nowhere in all Holy Scripture can we find a verse or
sentence that represents the Church to be other than the
"Body of Christ," His redeemed people "purchased with
His blood."
» Isa. 49 : 26. 11 Matt. 28 : 20.
10 Gen. 28 : 14-15. 12 u Peter i : 19.
THE BIBLE AND THE CHURCH 121
Nowhere in all the 483 pages of Cardinal Gibbons'
book, ''The Faith of Our Fathers," can we find the
Roman Catholic Church represented by that author to be
other than the authority of a ''Supreme Ruler," "handed
down" to all generations in the form of a Pope, and that
authority which emanates from him.
By such authority of the hierarchy the Holy Ghost in
His function as teacher of the faith of Jesus, to every
living believer, is not given free course. Substituted
therefor, is this man-made authority which must pass
upon all which might otherwise through the operation
of the Holy Spirit be built up in man, such authority
acts without due regard to the Spirit of God whom
Jesus promised to send and who is the Supreme Au-
thority.
This dogma is taught throughout the book, "The Faith
of Our Fathers." At every point, the same water flows.
It is not the water of life flowing from the Roman
Catholic Bible. The fountain is corrupted by keeping
therefrom the purifying work of the Spirit, which ema-
nates from the Written Word of God.
"The words that I have spoken to you are spirit and
life." ^'
Let us honor every truth wherever spoken, whether
from the lips of Roman Catholic priest or from any
Catholic Church pulpit, and him who speaks it, but let
the Holy Spirit which testifies within us, testify whether
it be the truth or not — not a Pope or hierarchy, but
rather the Spirit Himself.
"And there are three who give testimony in heaven,
the Father, the Word, and the Holy Ghost, and these
three are One."
"And these are three that give testimony on earth,
13 John 6 : 64.
122 THE ROMAN CATHOLIC BIBLE
the Spirit, and the Water, and the Blood, and these
three are One." ^*
"He that believeth in the Son of God hath the testi-
mony of God to himself." ^^
"And in this we know that He abideth in us by the
Spirit which He hath given us." ^^
Shall we not give heed to these words of John the
beloved of our Lord? Words that give us a freedom
that is denied by the Roman Catholic Church. Words
that make us thankful for a country that protects free-
dom of worship. And may we not also read the fol-
lowing words of Paul, to whom the world through the
Spirit owes so much of the breaking of this bread, the
written Word of God.
"Now the Lord is a spirit and where the Spirit of
the Lord is there is liberty." ^^
Cardinal Gibbons in his book says :
"Therefore the church is the divinely appointed cus-
todian and interpreter of the Bible, for her offer of
infallible guide were superfluous if each individual could
interpret the Bible for himself."
■- — Faith of Our Fathers, Page 98
Here is something of what the Scripture says about it :
"And the Jews wondered, saying. How doth this man
know letters, having never learned?"
"Jesus answered them and said. My doctrine is not
mine, but His that sent me."
"If any man will do the will of Him he shall know
of the doctrine, whether it be of God, or whether I
speak of myself." ^^
1^ I John 5 : 7-8. ^^ H Cor. 3 : 17.
^5 I John 5 : 10. IS John 7 : 15-17.
1^ I John 3 : 24.
THE BIBLE AND THE CHURCH 123
Is it possible that teachers of so great a body of
worshipers as is the Roman Catholic Church have not
as yet themselves learned that light comes by the en-
trance of the Word?
*The .declaration of Thy words giveth light: and
giveth understanding to little ones."
'Thy testimonies are wonderful, therefore hath my
soul sought them."
"My eyes to Thee have prevented the morning that
I might meditate on Thy words." ^^
"I have understanding more than all my teachers,
because thy testimonies are my meditation." ^^
"That God never intended the Bible to be the Chris-
tian's rule of faith, independently of the living authority
of the Church, will be the subject of this chapter."
— Cardinal Gibbons, Page 98
"Thus we see that in the old and the new dispensa-
tion the people were to be guided by a living authority,
and not by their private interpretation of the Scrip-
tures." — Cardinal Gibbons, Page 103
Thus we have this teaching from an authority of the
Roman Catholic Church, in contradiction to the author-
ity of the Roman Catholic Bible which teaches that
"The Paraclete the Holy Ghost" "Whom the Father
will send in my name will teach you all things." ^^
And if, the Holy Spirit within us, teaching us all
truth, we may not safely interpret His truths, how can
it be hoped that we will find the truth in Cardinal Gib-
bons' book, "The Faith of Our Fathers," the forty-
seventh edition of which he has commended to our
private interpretation for that purpose?
1® Psalms 119:130, 129, 148. 20 Psalms 119:99.
-ijohn 14:26.
124 THE ROMAN CATHOLIC BIBLE
Is that which Cardinal Gibbons wrote a safer means
of interpretation than the Word which is Spirit? We
remember that Our Saviour said:
"If any one love me, he will keep my word, and my
Father will love him and we will come to him, and will
make our abode with him/' ^^
With the Father within us, who loves us, may we not
trust the interpretation which we are led to receive
from our reading of Scripture: which Scripture is also
"Spirit" and "Life."
The saying of our Saviour to Peter in Matt. i6: i8:
"And I say to thee, That thou art Peter and upon
this rock I will build my church, and the gates of hell
shall not prevail against it" — frequent allusions to which
are made by the Reverend Cardinal — in its very wording
is such an evidence of what the Church of Christ is, that
we ask here attention to its meaning. It is obvious that
the gates of hell are those avenues found in the world
and the flesh which vie with the spiritual avenues to the
Kingdom of Heaven.
The one the deceiving power of evil in the wages of
sin, ''which is death," and the other the gift which is
life eternal. The one, the house built upon the sand,
the other the house built upon the Rock. The floods
that destroyed the one shall not prevail against the
other. The gates of hell shall not prevail against the
house built upon the prophets who prophesied of the
Christ, and of the apostles who preached Christ.
"This is that jMoses who said to the children of
Israel, a prophet shall God raise up to you of your own
brethren as myself, him shall you hear."
"This is he that was in the church in the wilderness
with the angel who spoke to him on Mount Sina, and
22 John 14:23.
THE BIBLE AND THE CHURCH 125
with our fathers : who received the words of Hf e to give
unto us." "^
It is manifest that the church was in the wilderness
with the Prophet Moses. It is also true from the fol-
lowing that the church was a body of believers, founded
on the prophets and apostles, rather than an hierarchy-
given by a pope whose decree was claimed to be in-
fallible.
*'If therefore the whole church come together into
one place, and all speak with tongues, and there come
in unlearned persons or infidels, will they not say that
you are mad? And let the prophets speak two or three
and let the rest judge. But if anything be revealed to
another sitting, let the first hold his peace." -^
^The churches of Asia salute you; Aquila and Pris-
cilla salute you much in the Lord, with the church that
is in their house, with whom I also lodge." -^
**Built upon the foundation of the apostles and
prophets, Jesus Christ himself being the chief corner
stone."
'Tn whom all the building being framed together,
groweth up into an holy temple in the Lord."
*Tn whom you also are built together into an habita-
tion of God in the spirit." ^^
The church which Christ calls "my church" when
promising to build it upon the Rock, is subject to Christ
and therefore must be subject to the teachings of Christ
and to all Scripture which came not by the will of man.
'^Therefore as the church is subject to Christ, so also
let the wives be to their husbands in all things." -"
Had there been a "Vicar of Christ, a prince of the
23 Acts "I'.Zl. 38. 2f»Eph. 2:20, 21, 22.
24 I Cor. 14: 23, 29, 30. 27 Eph. 5 : 24.
25 1 Cor. 16:19.
126 THE ROMAN CATHOLIC BIBLE
apostles," how natural it would have been for the
apostles in their work of establishing churches, in writ-
ing letters to them, to have made at least some one
reference to such an authority: not only is the New
Testament void of any such reference by the apostles,
including Peter himself, but in the work of the Holy
Spirit in the Book of Acts, Luke makes no mention of
such an office existing when recording the establishing
of churches by the founders, the apostles.
Everywhere in the many references made to churches
in the New Testament, the church appears as ordained
by Christ, His body; Believers in Him, communing in
Him, and subject one to another according to the word
of Scripture delivered to them by the apostles, such
word being that dictated by the Spirit of Christ.
In referring to "the Church and the Bible," Cardinal
Gibbons says:
"The church as we have just seen is the only divinely
constituted teacher of Revelation. Now the Scripture
is the great depository of the word of God. Therefore
the Church is the divinely appointed custodian and in-
terpreter of the Bible, for her office of Infallible Guide
were superfluous if each individual could interpret the
Bible for himself." — Page 98
To the above he adds :
^ "Thus we see that in the old and the new Dispensa-
tion the people were to be guided by a living authority."
— Page 103
In his purpose to prove his theory, the Reverend
Cardinal further says:
"No nation ever had a greater veneration for the Bible
than the Jewish people. . . . And yet the Jews never
THE BIBLE AND THE CHURCH 127
dreamed of settling their religious controversies by a
private appeal to the word of God. Whenever any
religious dispute arose among the people, it was de-
cided by the High Priest and the Sanhedrin, which was
a council consisting of seventy-two civil and ecclesias-
tical judges. The sentence of the High Priest and of
his associate judges was to be obeyed under penalty of
death." — Pages 98-9
It seems proper to follow history and note the result
of the teachings of those ecclesiastical judges when they
thus relied upon their interpretation of the Holy Scrip-
ture, independent of the Holy Spirit which was in the
word "which is Spirit and which is life" and which
Holy Spirit they resisted. Such results are not to be
commended.
Again Cardinal Gibbons states, also quoting from
Scripture :
**Does He tell the Jews to be their own guides in the
study of the Scriptures? By no means; but He com-
mands them to obey their constituted teachers, no matter
how disedifying might be their private lives.
'* *The scribes and the Pharisees sit upon the chair of
Moses.' *A11 things therefore whatsoever they shall say
to you observe and do.' "
— Faith of Our Fathers, Page 100
We quote from the same verse quoted by His Rever-
ence, the portion which is a partial answer to his ques-
tion.
"But according to their works do ye not, for they say
and do not." ^^
A further answer from the Scripture, considering "all
things therefore" as the dividing phrase between what
"the multitudes and His disciples" were to observe and
do when taught from Moses' chair, and that which the
28 Matt. 23 : 3.
128 THE ROMAN CATHOLIC BIBLE
Scribes and Pharisees taught of the things they them-
selves practiced, while they themselves obeyed not the
law of Moses.
"Woe to you Scribes and Pharisees, hypocrites, be-
cause you go round about the sea and the land to make
one proselyte, and when he is made, you make him the
child of hell twofold more than yourselves." ^^
The Lord had indeed come to fulfill the law and the
prophets which were from Moses' seat, but not to teach
compliance with such teachings of the Scribes and Phar-
isees as by their traditions made void the command-
ments of God. The "church that was in the wilderness''
he exalted by fulfilling in His own flesh that which was
imperfect.
There was to be no Pope (Latin Papa, Father) of
the Church of Jesus Christ on earth, other than our
^'Father in Heaven."
Our Saviour when referring to those who ''sat in
Moses' seat" said to His disciples and to the multi-
tude:
"And call none your Father upon earth, for one is
your Father who is in Heaven." — Matt. 12:9,
We give the testimony of St. John as written in the
Apocalypse regarding the seven churches of Asia,
"The revelation of Jesus Christ which God gave unto
him, to make known to His servants the things which
must shortly come to pass, and signified, sending by his
angel to his servant John." ^^
"John to the seven churches which are in Asia, Grace
be unto you and peace from him that is, and that was,
and that is to come, and from the seven spirits which
are before his throne. And from Jesus Christ, who is
the faithful witness, the first begotten of the dead, and
29 Matt. 23 : 15. 30 Apocalypse i : i.
THE BIBLE AND THE CHURCH 129
the prince of the kings of the earth, who hath loved us,
and washed us from our sins in his own blood/' ^^
"He that hath an ear, let him hear what the Spirit
saith to the churches." ^^
The words of the Apocalypse are addressed as the
Revelation of Jesus Christ to His servants. By John,
4th Verse, they are addressed to the seven churches in
Asia. In Chapter i, Verse 20, the seven stars are men-
tioned as the angels of the seven churches, and the seven
candlesticks are mentioned as the seven churches. In
Chapter 2, ist Verse, He who speaks is represented as
holding the seven stars in His right hand, and as walk-
ing in the midst of the seven golden candlesticks. As
history states that there were other churches in Asia, it
appears that the seven churches were addressed by John
as embodying the sacred or complete number of seven,
implying the church of Christ universal.
The various names and possessions mentioned in the
First Chapter, as held by Him who speaks to the churches
and also as the churches are separately spoken to, indi-
cate that the universal church of Christ is addressed
through the seven churches of Asia. The various char-
acteristics of the churches described are like various
churches now existing, in respect to their devotion or
relapse to the teachings of Christ Jesus. The direction
to John to send the word contained in the Book, the
Apocalypse, to the seven churches of Asia, was given
him in Verse 11 of Chapter i, each church being men-
tioned by name, and when John turned to see the Voice
that spoke to him, he saw seven golden candlesticks and
in the midst of the seven golden candlesticks, one like to
the Son of Man.
Instead of this Scripture being interpreted by an eccle-
2^ Apocalypse 1:4, 5. 3- Apocalypse 3 : 22,
I30 THE ROMAN CATHOLIC BIBLE
siastical body only, such as the Roman hierarchy, it is
written in the First Chapter, Verse 8, ''Blessed is he
that readeth and heareth the words of this prophecy,
and keepeth those things that are written in it for the
time is at hand." ^^
And also after each recital of the word to each of the
seven churches, it is written,
"He that hath an ear let him hear what the Spirit
saith to the churches," ^^
evidently not restricted to that which any interpreter of
the Spirit may say, but to what the Spirit saith.
"For the Spirit himself giveth testimony to our Spirit
that we are the sons of God." ^^
"I speak the truth in Christ. I lie not, my conscience
bearing me witness in the Holy Ghost." ^^
"For whosoever are led by the Spirit of God, they are
the sons of God." ^^
"Search the Scriptures for you think in them to have
life everlasting, and the same are they that give testi-
mony of me." ^^
"Now these were more noble than those in Thessa-
lonica, who received the word with all eagerness, daily
searching the Scriptures whether these things were so."
"And many indeed of them believed and of honorable
women that were Gentiles, and of men not a few." ^^
We must therefore conclude that the written word was
intended for the people who had ears and eyes. They
were to be blessed in reading and hearing what the
Spirit said, although it is the opposite of Cardinal Gib-
bons' statement which follows :
"But when our Redeemer abolished the old law and
established His Church, did He intend that His Gospel
33 Apocalypse 1:3. ^o Romans 9:1. ^8 John 5 : 39.
3* Apocalypse 2:7. 37 Romans 8 : 14. 39 Acts 17:11, 12.
35 Romans 8 : 16.
THE BIBLE AND THE CHURCH 131
should be disseminated by the circulation of the Bible,
or by the living voice of His disciples : This is a vital
question: I answer most emphatically that it was by
preaching alone that He intended to convert the nations^
and by preaching alone they were converted. No nation
has ever yet been converted by the agency of Bible Asso-
ciations." — Faith of Our Fathers, Page 102
We make answer to the above by quoting the follow-
ing Scripture, the letter to the Ephesians addressed as
follows : —
"Paul an Apostle of Jesus Christ, by the will of God
to all the saints who are at Ephesus, and to the faithful
in Christ Jesus." ^^
The letter to the Philippians to
*Taul and Timothy, the servants of Jesus Christ, to
all the saints in Christ Jesus, who are at Philippi, with
the bishops and deacons." ^^
And so throughout the letters of the apostles there is
none directed so that it could be implied that instruction
from these Scriptures should be by voice of ecclesiastical
interpreters only; Timothy was enjoined by Paul. What
could be plainer ?
''And because from thy infancy thou hast known the
Holy Scriptures which can instruct thee to salvation by
the faith which is in Christ Jesus." ^^
The Apostle James' letter is addressed to the "twelve
tribes which are scattered abroad." It is manifest that
where the written Word of God was to be had, no re-
striction was placed upon the reading of it by the dis-
ciples of Christ, and no evidence that the term "teach"
so often used in the New Testament meant teaching by
the voice only.
We had not known the beauty and joy of the new
covenant or the hope of the prophets, and of the apostles,
40 Eph. 1:1. 41 Phil. 1:1. 42 Tim. 3 : 15.
132 THE ROMAN CATHOLIC BIBLE
except the message of the Gospel and the prophets had
been written. We would not have rejoiced in the inter-
pretation of the Gospel given by Paul had he not written
his letters. We would not have heard the testimony of
the multitudes who have been made glad and at peace
with God by the faith which is of our Saviour, had not
the writings of the apostles and prophets been their
study and delight, as well as the study and delight of
their teachers.
We are therefore bound to conclude with the Apostle
Paul that there is danger of our missing the simplicity
of the Gospel.
"But I fear least as the serpent seduced Eve by his
subtlety, so your minds should be corrupted, and fail
from the simplicity that is in Christ.'' ^^
**But yet rejoice not in this that Spirits are subject
unto you, but rejoice in this that your names are written
in Heaven.'*
"In that same hour he rejoiced in the Holy Ghost, and
said, I confess to thee, O Father Lord of Heaven and
earth, because thou hast hidden these things from the
wise and prudent and hast revealed them to little ones.
Yea, Father, for so it hath seemed good in thy
sight." ^^
Thus we may go to Him direct in His written word,
which is Spirit and which is life.
And in rejoicing and thanksgiving to our Redeemer,
we may daily rest in Him "with malice toward none,
with charity for all."
**And we know that to them that love God, all things
work together unto good to such as according to his pur-
pose are called to be saints. For whom he foreknew, he
also predestinated to be made conformable to the image
43 II Cor. 11:3. ^^Liike 10:20, 21.
THE BIBLE AND THE CHURCH 13a
of his Son, that He might be the firstborn amongst many
brethren." ^^
The writer, when in one of the large cities of New
York State, stepped into a principal book store con-
ducted by a Roman Catholic, and inquired for a Douay
Version of the Bible. This was the reply: *T doubt if
we have one ; perhaps there may be one about the store.
You see the Catholics run to prayer books and the Prot-
estants to Bibles."
It would be interesting to know how many Douay
Versions of the Bible have been published and sold in
the United States during the past year or past ten
years.
45 Rom. 8 : 28, 29.
X
CONCLUSION
IN conclusion, it is estimated that within the jurisdic-
tion of the Roman CathoHc hierarchy there are
actually and nominally near twenty million of per-
sons who are under the government or supervision of
the United States. This large body of people of our
country vary as to nationality, and differ in their re-
ligious customs, but adhere more or less to an eccle-
siastical organization holding at the head of its doctrines
that of belief in the Triune God ; also making use in all
of its tenets, of the preeminent name of the only be-
gotten Son of God, giving prominence to the sacredness
of the marriage tie, and holding the Douay Version of
the Bible as ''of divine origin,'' thus presenting to the
world a religious organization influencing perhaps one-
sixth of the population of the United States and its
supervised islands.
That so great a body of worshipers as that of the
Roman Catholic Church would utilize all advantages in
accord with the proclaimed purpose of its ecclesiastical
rulers, is but natural to believe.
Is such proclaimed purpose manifest in the tenets
herein discussed and are these tenets in accord with
its Douay Version of the Bible?
The title to these pages permits the question.
These pages are prayerfully written with the purpose
of showing that such accord is lacking.
There is a federation of Christ^s people now, and
134
CONCLUSION 135
there always will be in spirit, for they are one in Christ
Jesus, their Shepherd, wherever they exist.
A federation of the churches in which Christ's people
are found, is not only believed by many to be desirable,
but as daily events portend, such federation may become
imperative for the upholding of society founded upon
the law of the Ten Commandments and the gospel of
Jesus Christ.
It is believed, that for the political power existing at
the Vatican in Rome, nations are seeking favor there by
sending official representatives to the Pope. Is it of
more importance that political power emanating from
the Vatican at Rome be sought, than that the yoke of
church dogma and tradition, that has for centuries bound
down and is now binding down adherents to the Romish
Church, be broken?
Will the Christ under whom all things are put by the
Father, look with favor upon the people who look to the
Pope of Rome, when they should be looking to Him for
the political power that makes for the coming of His
Kingdom ?
Let all hope and pray that the time will speedily come
when the kingdoms of this world will **become the King-
dom of Our Lord and Saviour Jesus Christ," and there
will be *'one shepherd and one fold.'*
Upon what authority then shall this great nation
"work out its own salvation" and fulfill its obligations,
as one of the nations of God's footstool?
Shall it be in an attempt to work it out by might and
power, regardless of any organized trust in the Almighty?
Can it be by an ecclesiastcal organization formed by
all who will acknowledge the Pope of Rome as the Vicar
of Christ?
It is impossible to make Peter such vicar of Christ by
136 THE ROMAN CATHOLIC BIBLE
reason of the Scripture statement of the Apostle Paul
in his account of his apostleship in the first chapter of
Galatians, as follows :
"For I give you to understand brethren that the gospel
which was preached by me is not according to man.
"For neither did I receive it of man nor did I learn it,
but by the revelation of Jesus Christ.
"But when it pleased Him ... To reveal His Son
to me . . . Immediately I condescended not to flesh and
blood,
"Neither went I to Jerusalem to the apostles who were
before me but I went into Arabia and again I returned
to Damascus.
"Then after three years I went to Jerusalem to see
Peter and I tarried with him fifteen days but other of
the apostles I saw none saving James the brother of our
Lord/'
— Galatians i: 11-19.
In the light of Peter's commendation of the Apostle
Paul, which follows, no possible mistake can be made of
his approval of Paul and his disavowal thereby of any
Vicar of Christ with plenipotential power having been
appointed by our Lord.
"And account the long-suffering of our Lord Salva-
tion. As also our most dear brother Paul according to
the wisdom given him hath written to you."
"As also in all his epistles speaking in them of these
things ;
— n Peter 3: 15-16.
Peter would have been faithless to his charge as such
a vicar and Paul would not have been faithful to the
Church of Jesus Christ had such vicarship existed, nor
could possibly have received the approval of his Scripture
by Peter.
Or shall there be a union of God's people in all Chris-
CONCLUSION 137
tendom, based and federated upon the first great com-
mand and the second like to it, of which no annulments
have ever been made, and of which union the Christen-
dom of our land will form a part, and through which
God will work "both to will and to accomplish according
to his good will."
"And one of them, a doctor of the law, asked him,
tempting him, Master, which is the great commandment
in the law ? Jesus said to him, Thou shalt love the Lord
thy God with thy whole heart, and with thy whole soul,
and with thy whole mind. This is the greatest and the
first commandment. And the second is like to this:
Thou shalt love thy neighbor as thyself. On these
two commandments dependeth the whole law and the
prophets." ^
The smoking firebrands of lawlessness thrown into
this age, may cause consternation in the hearts of many.
They should not in the hearts of God's people. The
doom is already sealed of all that combat the swelling
buds of a springtime which the Church of Christ is to
welcome.
Nineteen centuries ago there came from the cross the
cry, "It is finished."
The force of that spirit which brings all nature into
life, is behind the developments of each day, bringing
forth to greet the eyes of those who wait upon the Lord,
a blossom more beautiful than any conceived in the heart
of man.
The times and the seasons thereof are in the hands of
the Lord. His people may trust Him, and wait upon
Him with watching, praying and working for His coming.
It has been the purpose of the author throughout these
pages, to discuss tenets and not peoples, apart from his
1 Matt. 22 : 35-40.
138 THE ROMAN CATHOLIC BIBLE
text, the title to this book. Now at closing he asks per-
mission to relate one incident of his early boyhood which
just now memory brings to him.
One day in early Springtime, when the warming sun
gave fresh start to the grass, two little fellows of about
six years were happy in their play along the roadside.
The writer one of them, the other a boy of Roman Cath-
olic parentage. In a moment of childish dispute, I gave
the little fellow a kick. There was no retaliation. The
joyous passing moments having ended, he turned away
sobbing toward his home. I passed through my home
gate with a guilty conscience. A day later, as I passed
our neighbor's home, my little playmate came to the
front of their yard, and facing me, his bright face aglow
with anything but resentment, and in a childish voice as
sweet, sang a ditty, the refrain of which with the spirit
which accompanied it, still follows me after these many
years. These were the words, "There's a rose in the gar-
den for you, young man." It was only a few months
later when my playmate passed away, leaving to me the
memory of the Christ Spirit that accompanied him to a
more beautiful Springtime, and better playmates. But
the flower has been given to me. I possess the rose,
"the Rose of Sharon," and to any who in Springtime
days, or in late years, whoever they may be, have
Him not, to those I repeat the line, "There's a rose in
the garden for you, young man."
"The wilderness and the solitary place shall be glad
for them: And the desert shall rejoice and blossom as
the rose."
"It shall blossom abundantly, and rejoice even with
joy and singing. The glory of Lebanon shall be given
unto it, the excellency of Carmel and Sharon, they shall
CONCLUSION 139
see the glory of the Lord and the excellency of our
God."^
•'Faith of our Fathers ; living still
In spite of dungeon, fire and sword,
Oh, how our hearts beat high with joy
Whene'er we hear that glorious word.
Faith of our Fathers, holy faith.
We will be true to thee till death."
— Faber
2 Isa. 35 : 1-2 — King James Version.
THE NEW WORLD ORDER
HUGH BLACK
*'Lest We Forget'*
i2mo, net $1.50.
Dr. Black subjects Democracy,
Patriotism, State-Rights, Re-
ligion, War, Peace, Pacifism and
the League of Nations to a close,
searching scrutiny, indicating
how, by a just and sane inter-
pretation, they may^ be made to
provide a larger incentive to
truer living, and a finer appre-
hension of the duties and respon-
sibilities of world-citizenship.
RT. REV. CHARLES FISKE, D,D.,LL,D.
Bishop Coadjutor of Central New York
The Perils of Respectability
and Other Studies in Christian Life and Service
for Reconstruction Days. i2mo, net $1.50.
"The approach to the great problems of the day is con-
structive, with the spiritual note predominant. There is
no other solution for the conditions which face the world
than is to be found in the application of the spirit of
Jesus Christ by minister and layman alike. A worthy ad-
dition to the library of any one who is interested in the
promotion of real, vital religion in its application to the
needs of modern men.'* — Reformed Church Messenger,
L R, SAUNDERS Introduction by George W. Truett
The Cross and the Reconstruction
of the World
i2mo, net $1.50.
Dr. Saunders is a Christian optimist. He is not un-
mindful of the unrest to-day, but he believes that men
must turn again with renewed interest towards the death
of Christ, and ponder with impetus its significance for all
the race. Having died with Him, mankind may hence-
forth live unto God, and find in this rich experience the
one hope for world reconstruction on a rock of certainty
which cannot be moved.
JOSEPH JUDSON TAYLOR, P.P., LL,D.
The God of War
i2mo, net $2.00.
An able, analytical examination of the place and power
that the extolling of militarism has had in the history of
civilization. Having traced its pernicious path through the
centuries, the author turns to the teachings of Christ, and
shows by apt quotation and unanswerable argument that
His followers cannot, without doing violence to the prin-
ciples of His gospel advocate militarism, either in spirit
or practice.
THE NEW WORLD ORDER
JOSEPH FORT NEIVTON, D,D,
Pastor of The Church of the Divine Paternity ^ New York
The Religious Basis of a Better
World Order
By the Author of "An Ambassador," etc. i^mo,
net $1.25.
"These sermons speak especially to cultivated minds,
yet through their simplicity and naturalness and human-
ness, they make the universal appeal. Here is their real
power. They do not speak the language of the church,
but the language of humanity. ^ They are real sermons
of a warm, spiritual, enthusiastic manhood." — American
Journal of Theology.
HENRY CHURCHILL KING President of
- Oberlin Collegt
A New Mind for the New Age
Cole Lectures for 1920. i2mo, net $1.50.
President King's new book is the work of one whose
opinions are of great weight in these times of uncertainty
and doubt. Contents: I. The New Age: Its Evidence.
II. The New Age: Its Perils. III. The New Age: Its
Values. IV. The New Mind: The Political Challenge.
V. The New Mind: The Educational Challenge. VI. The
New Mind: The Religious Challenge.
ROBERT WELLS VEACH, M.A., D,D.
Associate Director Dei>art7nent of Social Service
New Era Movement
The Meaning of the War for Reli-
gious Education
i2mo, net $1.50.
•*A Book for our Day. It begins and ends right and
deals with the elements of reconstruction wisely and in
the right order. The book is strong, the argument appeal-
ing, the conclusion inevitable and the spirit optimistic It
is just the kind of a book the Church needs to read and
act upon in these strategic days of social unrest and world
reconstruction." — Marion Lawrance.
JAMES E, FREEMAN, D.D,
Rector of St. Mark's Church, Minneapolis, Minn,
Everyday Religion
Little "Minneapolis Tribune" Sermons. i2mo,
cloth, net $1.50
Here is a "live" volume of addresses particularly.
The themes have direct bearing on the problems of
every day existence in these critical, heart-searching days.
The work cannot fail to furnish stimulus and enhearten-
ment for all who recognize the deeper and larger problems
oi life.
BIBLE STUDY
PHILIP MAURO Author of' God's Present Kingdom'^
Ruth: The Satisfied Stranger
i2mo, net $1.25.
Ruth is rich in lessons applicable in a special way to the
present democratic era of Christendom. The author sets
forth some of the more striking of these lessons; and also
the significance _ of the foreshadowings of Redemption-
glory contained in this deeply interesting portion of Scrip-
ture.
F. B, MEYER, D.D. Author of ' Old Testament
' Characters"'
Peter : Fisherman, Disciple, Apostle
i2mo, net $1.50.
**A picturesque and intimate character-study of Peter,
in which the various phases of his life are set forth —
phases which trace his transformation from the headstrong
fisherman and denier of Jesus to the submissive servant
and fearless champion of his Crucified and Risen lyord/' — «
S, S. Times,
REV. J, /. ROSS, P.P.
The Kingdom in Mystery
A Study of the Parables' of Our Lord Concern-
ing the Kingdom of God. i2mo, net $2.50.
An able examination of the Parables of Jesus and their
teaching concerning the Kingdom of God. The "King«
dom" as typified in Israel, in the present-day Christian
Church, its growth, work, purposes and rewards are all
passed under review in an able and even exhaustive fash-
ion. A volume every preacher and teacher and Bible
student should possess.
HANPY POCKET EPITION
Twentieth Century New Testament
New Popular Size. Cloth, net $1.25.
A new pocket edition of the modern IJnglish version of
the New Testament. Dr. Wilfred T. Grenfell says:
"When I read the Bible to the Labrador fishermen I wish
them to understand every word. That is the reason I
use the T. C. N. T. only."
TIVO NEW ISSUES IN
THE PELL BIBLE STORIES
Illustrated, i2mo, cloth, each, net 50c.
The Story of Paul as told by himself.
The Story of Abraham as told by Isaac.
Earlier Issues in the Same Series
The Story of Jesus for Little People ; The Story of Joseph —
The Dreamer; The Story of David— The Idol of the PeoDle.
Deacidified using the Bookkeeper process.
Neutralizing agent: Magnesium Oxide
Treatment Date: Jan. 2006
PreservationTechnologies
A WORLD LEADER IN PAPER PRESERVATION
111 Thomson Park Drive
Cranberry Township, PA 16066
(724)779-2111
Live Music Archive
Librivox Free Audio
Metropolitan Museum
Cleveland Museum of Art
Internet Arcade
Console Living Room
Books to Borrow
Open Library
TV News
Understanding 9/11