Skip to main content

Full text of "Serving agriculture : Canada's Ministers of Agriculture, 1867-1997"

See other formats


1+1 


Agriculture  and  Agriculture  et 

Agri-Food  Canada      Agroalimentaire  Canada 


Serving 
Agriculture 


Canada's  Ministers  of  Agriculture 


1867-1997 


Canada 


Digitized  by  the  Internet  Archive 

in  2011  with  funding  from 

Agriculture  and  Agri-Food  Canada  -  Agriculture  et  Agroalimentaire  Canada 


http://www.archive.org/details/servingagricultuOOmcgr 


Preface 


Agriculture  is  one  of  the  most  complex  and  demanding  portfolios  in 
the  Government  of  Canada.  The  industry  is  diverse,  encompassing 
everything  from  conservation  and  resource  issues  to  processing 
technology  and  international  trade.  The  agriculture  and  food  sector 
represents  businesses  both  big  and  small;  it  is  simultaneously  the 
subject  of  sophisticated  international  trade  negotiations  and  a 
traditional  way  of  life  for  thousands  of  farm  families.  Finally,  it 
affects  not  only  rural  communities  but  also  urban  manufacturing, 
processing  and  transportation  conglomerates.  From  early  settlers 
stepping  off  boats  at  Grosse  Isle  to  Asian  businesspeople  sampling 
maple  syrup  on  a  trade  mission,  the  department  has  presided  over  an 
industry  that  in  many  ways  defines  Canada's  unique  character. 

Summarizing  each  of  these  ministers'  careers  and  contributions  has 
not  been  easy.  Some  of  these  gentlemen  served  for  many  years  or  over 
multiple  terms.  Others  served  only  for  a  few  months.  It 's  hard  to 
profile  a  minister  who  served  for  22  years  in  the  same  manner  as 
someone  who  served  for  only  three  months,  but  I've  done  my  best.  If 
I've  omitted  something  important  or  made  an  error,  please  let  us 
know. 


The  department  has  had  a  spectacular  array  of  personalities  and 
talents  in  its  minister's  office  over  the  years.  Some  were  farmers,  some 
were  not.  Some  were  veteran  politicians  for  whom  this  was  just  one  of 
many  roles.  For  others,  their  time  as  minister  of  agriculture  defined 
their  professional  and  political  careers.  Through  crisis,  triumph  or 
controversy,  each  minister  left  a  unique  legacy  with  the  department. 
Some  went  on  to  serve  in  other  portfolios,  to  lead  provincial 
governments,  or  to  accept  appointments  as  board  members,  senators 
or  lieutenant-governors.  We've  not  yet  seen  one  become  prime 
minister,  but  perhaps  this  is  still  to  come. 

The  following  profiles  tell  the  story  of  our  department,  our  industry 
and  our  country  over  the  last  130  years.  I'd  like  to  thank  my  library 
colleagues  for  all  their  help,  and  former  ministers  Bud  Olson,  Eugene 
Whelan,  John  Wise,  Don  Mazankowski  and  Charlie  Mayer  for 
agreeing  to  be  interviewed  for  this  project. 


Janyce  McGregor 

Canadian  Agriculture  Library 

September  1997 


Introduction 


When  I  reflect  upon  the  Ministers  of  Agriculture  who  have  preceded 
me,  I  confess  it  is  a  little  humbling. 

I  know  something  of  the  fabric  of  my  recent  predecessors,  but  there 
are  so  many  more.  That 's  why  this  book  is  valuable  to  me.   On  each 
page,  there  is  evidence  of  the  stimulating,  and  indeed,  demanding 
nature  of  this  portfolio.   Canada 's  first  agriculture  minister,  Jean- 
Charles  Chapais,  had  hardly  begun  his  term  when  he  was  faced  with 
a  possible  plague  of  "texian  fever"  carried  on  imported  horned 
cattle.    Our  third  Minister,  John  Henry  Pope  was  already  grappling 
with  exhausted  virgin  soils  as  early  as  the  1880s.  And  by  the  1890s, 
the  department  under  John  Carting  was  experimenting  with  300 
varieties  of  potatoes  and  mailing  information  to  some  30,000 
farmers. 

What  this  book  captures,  above  all,  is  the  humanity  in  the  job;  its 
trials  and  triumphs  come  in  a  surprising  number  of  forms.   After  the 
First  World  War,  for  example,  the  department  sponsored  egg-laying 
contests  to  stimulate  poultry  flock  performance:  Canada's  champion 
hen  produced  a  world  record  351  eggs  in  a  single  year. 

I  can  quite  honestly  say  that  I  have  a  passion  for  stories  such  as 
this  —  and  in  fact  for  the  agriculture  and  agri-food  industry  in 
Canada.   I  have  lived  and  breathed  agriculture  all  of  my  life. 
It's  an  incredible  industry  with  incredible  opportunities  for  growth. 

As  Canada's  27'h  agriculture  minister,  I  will  have  the  privilege  of 
guiding  the  department  in  the  next  few  years  —  years  in  which  the 
sector  stands  to  figure  prominently  in  meeting  Canada's  goals:  to 
spur  economic  growth  and  reap  the  benefits  of  liberalized  trade. 


These  are  not  new  directions  for  Canada.  In  1876,  our  fourth 
Minister  Luc  Letellier  de  Saint-Just,  exhibited  some  international 
acumen  when  Canada  participated  in  its  first  trade  show:  the 
Philadelphia  World  Fair.     Through  130  years  of  nationhood,  trade 
has  become  increasingly  important,  and,  thanks  in  large  part  to  the 
efforts  of  my  predecessors,  we're  doing  very  well  indeed.  We 
produce  some  of  the  best  food  products  in  the  world  and,  clearly,  the 
world  knows  it. 

A  key  trademark  of  the  nineties  is  partnership:  the  industry  is 
actively  involved  in  taking  Canada  into  the  global  arena.  It's 
through  partnership  that  Canada  continues  to  solidify  its  reputation 
for  food  quality  and  safety,  for  world-class  agricultural  science  and 
technology,  and  for  innovation.   These  are  our  tickets  to  expanding 
our  markets  throughout  the  world,  for  the  benefit  of  all  Canadians. 

My  long  involvement  in  agriculture  has  taught  me  to  have  a 
profound  respect  for  the  sector  and  its  people.   History  has 
demonstrated,  generation  after  generation,  what  can  be 
accomplished  by  those  who  work  to  put  food  on  the  tables  of  the 
nation,  and  indeed,  tables  around  the  world. 

Our  strong  foundation  was  laid  in  years  past,  and  ably  maintained 
by  determined  and  talented  people  across  the  country.  It's  this  strength, 
this  ability  to  work  together,  that  will  enable  us  to  continue  to  meet 
the  challenges  of  the  marketplace.   I  am  proud  to  be  a  part  of  it. 


Lyle  Vanclief 

Minister  of  Agriculture  and  Agri-Food 

and  Minister  Coordinating  Rural  Affairs 


III 


Canadian  Ministers  of  Agriculture  Since  Confederation 


Jean-Charles  Chapais 
1867/07/01   -   1869/11/15 


Martin  Burrell 
1911/10/16  -   1917/10/12 


John  J.  Greene 
1965/12/18  -  1968/07/05 


Christopher  Dunkin 
1869/11/16  -   1871/10/24 


Thomas  Alexander  Crerar 
1917/10/12  -   1919/06/11 


Horace  Andrew  (Bud)  Olson 
1968/07/06  -   1972/11/26 


John  Henry  Pope 

1871/10/25  -   1873/11/05 
1878/10/17  -   1885/09/24 


Simon  Fraser  Tolmie 
1919/08/12  -   1921/12/29 
1926/07/13  ■   1926/09/25 


Eugene  Francis  Whelan 
1972/11/27  -   1979/06/03 
1980/03/03  -   1984/06/29 


Luc  Letellier  de  Saint-Just 
1873/11/07  -   1876/12/14 

Charles  Alphonse  Pantaleon  Pelletier 

1877/01/26  -   1878/10/08 

John  Carling 
1885/09/25  -   1892/11/24 

Auguste-Real  Angers 

1892/12/07  -   1895/07/12 

Walter  Humphries  Montague 
1895/12/21   -    1896/01/05 
1896/01/15  -   1896/07/08 


William  Richard  Motherwell 
1921/12/29  -   1926/06/28 
1926/09/25  -   1930/08/07 

Robert  Weir 
1930/08/08  -   1935/10/23 

James  Garfield  Gardiner 
1935/11/04  -  1957/06/21 

Douglas  Scott  Harkness 
1957/06/21   -   1960/10/10 

Francis  Alvin  George  Hamilton 
1960/10/11   -   1963/04/22 


John  Wise 

1979/06/04  -   1980/03/02 

1984/09/17  -   1988/09/14 

Ralph  Ferguson 
1984/06/30  -   1984/09/16 

Donald  Frank  Mazankowski 
1988/09/15  -   1991/04/20 

William  Hunter  McKnight 
1991/04/21   -   1993/01/04 

Charles  James  Mayer 
1993/01/04  -  1993/11/04 


Sydney  Arthur  Fisher 
1896/07/13  -   1911/10/06 


Harry  William  Hays 
1963/04/22  -   1965/12/17 


Ralph  Goodale 
1993/11/04  -   1997/06/11 


*  Excluding  interim  acting  ministers 


V 


Compiled  in  1997. 

Publication  1990/E 

Available  from 

Canadian  Agriculture  Library 

Agriculture  and  Agri-Food  Canada 

Ottawa,  Ontario  Kl  A  0C5 

©  Minister  of  Public  Works  and  Government  Services  Canada  1998 
Cat.  No:  A22- 183/1 998E 
ISBN:  0-662-27416-4 

Egalement  disponible  en  frangais  :  1990/F  -  Au  service  de  I  'agriculture 

Ministres  de  V Agriculture  du  Canada 
1867-1997 


® 


Printed  on  recycled  paper  with  vegetable  ink. 


Serving 
Agriculture 

Canada's  Ministers 
of  Agriculture 

1867-1997 


M 


Agriculture  and  Agriculture  et 

Agri-Food  Canada      Agroalimentaire  Canada 


Jean-Charles  Chapais 

July  I,  1867-  November  15,  1869 


3 


Jean-Charles  Chapais 

(1811-1885) 

Birthplace 

Riviere-Ouelle,  Lower  Canada 

Federal  Constituency 

Kamouraska  (Quebec) 

Education 

Nicolet  College  (1824-1830) 

Professional  Background 

General  retail  merchant,  fishery  owner  and 
cattle  farmer;  helped  establish  local  church, 
library 

Political  Affiliation 

Conservative 


"As  a  farmer  and  longtime  representative 
of  one  of  the  most  beautiful  farming 
regions  of  Quebec,  working  for 
agricultural  prosperity  is,  to  my  way 
of  thinking,  more  than  a  duty.   It  is  also 
a  source  of  immense  pleasure.  " 
—  Jean-Charles  Chapais,  letter  to  his 
supporters,  July  8,  1867 


Political  Career 

The  Chapais  were  one  of  the  wealthy, 
politically  active  families  that  guided  the 
development  of  the  parish  community  of 
St-Denis.  Jean-Charles  Chapais  was  the  first 
mayor,  while  his  father-in-law,  the  wealthy 
merchant  and  seigneur  Amable  Dionne, 
served  in  the  colonial  government 
representing  Kamouraska. 

Dionne  encouraged  Chapais  to  run  for 
election  to  the  legislative  assembly  when  a 
seat  became  vacant.  After  one  unsuccessful 
attempt,  Chapais  was  elected  in  1851  and 
re-elected  in  four  consecutive  elections. 

In  1 864,  a  coalition  of  parties  agreed  to 
prorogue  the  assembly  and  concentrate  on 
achieving  Confederation  to  end  the  political 
stalemate  in  Upper  and  Lower  Canada, 
which  are  now  the  provinces  of  Ontario  and 
Quebec.  Chapais  was  appointed 
commissioner  of  public  works  and  served  in 
cabinet  through  the  Confederation 
conferences  and  debates.  He  established  the 
Intercolonial  Railway  and  developed  the 
Grand  Trunk  Railway — infrastructure  that 
laid  the  groundwork  for  Confederation. 

On  July  1,  1867,  Chapais  became  Canada's 
first  minister  of  agriculture.  He  understood 
the  industry  well,  having  written  a  13-part 
report  on  Quebec  agriculture  in  1851. 


Later  that  summer,  he  ran  to  represent 
Kamouraska  at  both  the  provincial  and 
federal  levels.  Rioting  and  a  scandal  over 
irregularities  in  voting  procedures  cancelled 
the  election  and  the  riding  lost  its  right  to 
representation  for  two  years.  Chapais  was 
acclaimed  for  Champlain  in  the  Quebec 
national  assembly  in  December  1 867  and 
was  appointed  to  the  Senate  in  January  1868. 

Chapais'  agriculture  portfolio  became 
onerous  over  time.  His  party's  popularity 
also  was  waning  under  the  pressures  of 
governing  a  new  country.  Prime  Minister 
John  A.  Macdonald  needed  to  bring  new 
people  into  cabinet — especially  MPs  from 
the  House  of  Commons.  Chapais  was 
transferred  to  the  receiver  general  portfolio, 
a  less  demanding  but  thankless  job.  In  1873, 
he  resigned  from  cabinet  because  he  was 
disenchanted  with  Ottawa  life  and  wanted 
to  spend  more  time  with  his  family  and 
business.  He  continued  to  serve  as  a  senator 
until  his  death  in  1885. 


Industry  Issues 


Accomplishments  as  Minister 


Worth  Noting 


Canadian  agriculture  in  the  19th  century 
reflected  a  diversity  of  farm  climates,  soil 
types  and  growing  seasons.  Some  regions, 
such  as  Quebec,  had  been  farmed  for 
generations.  Others,  such  as  the  Northwest 
Territories,  hadn't  yet  been  settled. 

Early  farmers  and  new  settlers  lacked  the  time 
and  resources  to  solve  their  own  problems.  The 
department  acted  first  in  an  area  of  immediate 
concern:  the  impact  of  animal  disease  on  dairy 
and  livestock  production. 

Departmental  Developments 

Before  Confederation,  the  province  of 
Canada  had  a  small  and  relatively  ineffective 
bureau  of  agriculture.  Chapais  oversaw  a 
small  Ottawa  office  of  just  23  clerks — a  far 
cry  from  the  thousands  of  professionals 
employed  by  the  department  in  the  1990s. 

In  1 868,  the  federal  government  passed  an 
Act  to  organize  and  establish  the  Department 
of  Agriculture.  Its  mandate  went  beyond 
traditional  agriculture  concerns  to  include 
immigration  and  emigration;  public  health 
and  quarantine;  the  marine  and  emigrant 
hospital  at  Quebec;  arts  and  manufacturing; 
census  activities,  statistics  and  registration; 
patents;  copyright;  and  industrial  designs  and 
trademarks. 


Chapais'  first  recorded  action  was  an  Order 
in  Council  on  August  13,  1868  prohibiting 
imports  of  horned  cattle  from  the  United 
States  into  Ontario  and  Quebec.  A  plague  of 
"texian  fever"  in  cattle  threatened  to 
contaminate  livestock  transported  by  rail. 
Chapais  appointed  Canada's  first  two 
agricultural  inspectors  to  enforce  the  ban  at 
two  Ontario  border  crossings. 

The  first  departmental  legislation  was  An  Act 
Respecting  the  Contagious  Diseases  of 
Animals,  passed  in  1869.  Farmers  trying  to 
establish  livestock  herds  needed  protection 
from  rinderpest  and  other  European  diseases. 

Canada's  first  chief  veterinary  inspector 
oversaw  early  inspections  and  quarantines  at 
maritime  ports  and  American  border 
crossings  to  prevent  diseased  animals  from 
entering  Canada.  Existing  diseases  were 
monitored  and  controlled.  These  basic 
principles  of  inspection  and  disease  control 
still  exist  in  the  current  Health  of  Animals 
Act  (1990). 


Canada's  first  prime  minister,  John  A. 
Macdonald,  nicknamed  Chapais  "my 
little  nun"  for  his  dedication  to  the 
Catholic  Church  and  the  civil  institutions 
of  French  Canadians. 

Chapais  was  a  delegate  to  the  Quebec 
Conference  of  1 864,  where  the  72 
Resolutions  that  led  to  Canadian 
Confederation  were  debated  and  passed. 
He  is  one  of  the  Fathers  of  Confederation 
seated  around  the  table  in  Robert  Harris' 
famous  portrait. 

Dr.  J.C.  Tache,  the  first  deputy  minister 
of  the  department,  was  both  a  nephew  of 
former  Quebec  leader  Etienne-Pascal 
Tache  and  Chapais'  trusted  ally  from 
Kamouraska. 

Two  of  Chapais'  political  rivals  in 
Kamouraska  also  became  ministers  of 
agriculture. 


Early  annual  reports  hardly  mention 
agriculture,  focusing  on  more  immediate 
colonial  concerns  such  as  immigration. 


M 


Agriculture  and  Agriculture  et 

Agri-Food  Canada      Agroalimentaire  Canada 


Christopher  Dunkin 

November  16,  1869  -  October  24,  1871 


Christopher  Dunkin 

(1812-1881) 

Birthplace 

Walworth,  England 

Federal  Constituencies 

Drummond-Arthabaska,  Brome  (Quebec) 

Education 

University  of  London,  Glasgow  University, 
Harvard  University 

Professional  Background 

Harvard  professor;  editor  of  Montreal's 
Morning  Courier,  secretary  of  Lord 
Durham's  education  commission  (1838)  and 
the  postal  service  commission  (until  1842); 
assistant  provincial  secretary,  Canada  East, 
1842-1847;  called  to  the  bar  in  1846. 
practised  law  in  Montreal  and  later  in 
Knowlton,  Quebec;  served  on  the  Council  of 
Public  Instruction  in  1859 

Political  Affiliation 

Conservative 


Political  Career 

Christopher  Dunkin  was  defeated  in  his  first 
attempt  to  represent  Drummond  in  the 
colonial  legislative  assembly  in  1844.  His 
second  attempt  at  politics  was  more 
successful,  although  his  tenure  was  brief:  he 
was  elected  to  the  assembly  in  1 858  to 
represent  Drummond-Arthabaska,  but  he  lost 
the  seat  in  1861.  Finally,  the  resilient  Dunkin 
was  elected  to  represent  Brome,  a  seat  he 
held  from  1862  until  Confederation. 

Dunkin  contributed  to  the  crisis  in 
government  that  eventually  led  to  Canadian 
Confederation  when  he  refused  to  support 
the  government  of  fellow  Conservatives  John 
A.  Macdonald  and  Etienne-Pascal  Tache  in 
1864.  The  loss  of  his  vote  denied  their 
ministry  the  majority  it  needed  to  stay  in 
power.  The  legislative  gridlock  that  resulted 
from  the  government's  fall  led  to  the 
desperate  coalition  of  parties  that  eventually 
achieved  Confederation.  Ironically,  Dunkin. 
who  represented  the  English  Protestant 
minority  in  Quebec's  Eastern  Townships, 
opposed  Confederation  during  the 
parliamentary  debates  of  1865.  He  predicted 
that  the  new  country  would  have  too  many 
regional,  racial,  religious  and  political 
differences  to  develop  as  a  nation. 

In  1867,  Dunkin  was  elected  to  both  the 
House  of  Commons  and  the  Quebec  national 
assembly  for  Brome.  He  turned  down  a 
Quebec  cabinet  position  because  premier- 
designate  Joseph  Edouard  Cauchon  would 


not  introduce  and  support  a  bill  giving 
Protestants  their  own  schools.  Pierre  Joseph 
Olivier  Chauveau,  a  former  associate  of 
Dunkin's,  was  more  willing  to  address 
Protestants'  needs.  Chauveau  became 
premier  and  formed  Quebec's  first  provincial 
government.  Dunkin  was  his  treasurer  from 
1867  to  1869  and  was  so  influential  that 
people  nicknamed  it  the  "Chauveau-Dunkin" 
government. 

In  1869,  Prime  Minister  Macdonald 
rearranged  his  cabinet  and  needed  a  new 
English-speaking  Quebec  representative. 
When  his  first  choice,  John  Henry  Pope, 
refused — only  to  accept  two  years  later — 
Macdonald  appointed  Dunkin  minister  of 
agriculture.  Dunkin,  however,  was  in  poor 
health  and  losing  political  support.  In  1871, 
Dunkin  resigned  and  left  politics  to  become  a 
puisne  judge  of  the  Superior  Court  of 
Quebec  until  his  death  in  1881. 

Departmental  Developments 

Dunkin  owned  a  316-acre  industrial-sized 
farm  in  Knowlton  on  Lac  Brome  and  was  no 
stranger  to  agricultural  issues.  Like  Chapais 
before  him,  most  of  his  concerns  at  the 
Department  of  Agriculture  had  little  to  do 
with  what  would  appear  to  be  important  to 
agricultural  policy  today.  Annual  reports  of 
the  period  dwell  on  immigration  issues  and 
the  collection  of  statistics. 


Accomplishments  as  Minister 


Worth  Noting 


The  only  agricultural  concern  Dunkin 
appears  to  have  faced  was  a  brief  scare  over 
a  resurgence  of  the  cattle  plague  that  caused 
Chapais  to  ban  American  horned  cattle 
imports  for  several  weeks  in  1868.  In  1870, 
after  an  investigation  by  Ontario  government 
officials,  Dunkin  concluded  there  was  no 
cause  for  alarm. 


Dunkin's  political  legacy  may  have  more 
to  do  with  his  role  as  Quebec's  minister 
of  finance  than  his  achievements  as 
Canada's  minister  of  agriculture. 

Dunkin  started  a  tradition  in  Quebec 
politics  that  lasted  over  a  century: 
appointing  an  English-speaking  member 
of  the  assembly  as  Quebec's  treasurer. 


Dunkin  might  have  been  ahead  of  his 
time  on  federal-provincial  issues, 
strongly  advocating  the  equality  of 
federal  and  provincial  governments  and 
espousing  what  biographer  Pierre  Corbeil 
calls  a  "true  Quebecker's  view  of  politics 
and  the  Constitution."  Dunkin  believed 
the  provincial  government  had  to  take  an 
active  role  in  Quebec's  economic 
development,  even  though  provinces 
depended  on  Ottawa  for  revenue. 


8 


■*l 


Agriculture  and  Agriculture  et 

Agri-Food  Canada      Agroalimentaire  Canada 


John  Henry  Pope 

October  25,  1871  -  November  5.  1873 

and  October  17,  1878  -  September  24,  1885 


{jr*\ 


?//**'.   'if  >Yi 

• !        3 


//> 


AV  TV 


^J  >•       v 


«r      /, 


Canada 


/       / 


John  Henry  Pope 

(1824-1889) 

Birthplace 

Eaton  Township,  Lower  Canada 

Federal  Constituency 

Compton  (Quebec) 

Education 

Compton  High  School,  Eastern  Townships 

Professional  Background 

Farmer,  investor  and  promoter  in  Cookshire, 
Quebec;  owner,  president  or  director  of 
lumber  mill,  railway,  bank,  public  utility  and 
woollen  mill 

Political  Affiliation 

Conservative 

"This  Department,  although  charged .  .  . 
with  the  subject  of  Agriculture,  has  not 
hitherto,  except  incidentally,  dealt  with 
it .  .  .  The  subject  is,  however,  of  the 
greatest  importance  to  Canada,  and 
the  branch,  properly  organized,  would 
be  of  very  great  service.  .  .in  facilitating 
improvements  in  agriculture.  .  .  to 
enable  our  farmers  to  compete  with 
those  of  other  countries. " 
—  John  Henry  Pope,  1 87 1  Department  of 
Agriculture  annual  report 


Political  Career 

Pope  represented  his  township  on 
Sherbrooke  county  council  in  the  1 840s.  He 
ran  unsuccessfully  for  a  seat  in  the  colonial 
government  in  1851,  1853  and  1854  before 
being  acclaimed  to  the  legislative  assembly 
in  1857.  He  represented  the  riding  of 
Compton  in  the  assembly  and,  later,  in  the 
House  of  Commons  until  he  died  in  1889. 
Once  in  office,  he  proved  to  be  a  popular 
representative.  He  often  ran  unopposed  or 
won  with  large  margins. 

As  was  the  case  with  many  Confederation- 
era  politicians,  Pope's  mix  of  politics  and 
business  was  frequently  controversial.  He 
was  involved  in  questionable  land  deals  and 
his  efforts  to  secure  a  railway  link  for  his 
county  and  his  businesses  tangled  him  in  a 
web  of  deal-making  with  local,  provincial 
and  federal  government  officials. 

Pope's  farm  was  his  original  and  constant 
business  interest.  He  was  one  of  the  first 
Canadians  to  try  to  improve  cattle  herds  by 
importing  thoroughbred  stock.  When  he  was 
appointed  minister  of  agriculture  in  1871,  he 
became  the  first  minister  to  focus  on 
agricultural  issues.  Pope  resigned  with  the 
rest  of  Macdonald's  cabinet  over  the  Pacific 
railway  scandal  of  1873.  When  the 
Conservatives  were  re-elected  in  1 878,  Pope 
went  back  to  his  old  portfolio. 


Later  in  Pope's  second  term,  he  also  became 
acting  minister  of  railways  and  canals.  When 
the  government  could  not  find  British  capital 
to  complete  the  Canadian  Pacific  Railway 
(CPR),  Pope  took  action  to  secure  the 
necessary  construction  contract,  persuading 
Macdonald  to  offer  the  CPR  a  controversial 
$30-million  loan  in  1884  so  it  could  finish 
construction.  In  1885,  Pope  officially  became 
minister  of  railways  and  canals.  Even  though 
he  had  cancer  of  the  liver,  he  continued  to 
serve  in  that  portfolio  until  he  died  in  1889. 

Industry  Issues 

Canadian  agriculture  was  in  a  "transition 
state"  between  a  system  where  farmers 
depended  on  virgin  soil — fast  becoming 
exhausted  from  use — and  a  more 
sophisticated  system  of  soil  maintenance. 
Farmers  needed  new  farming  techniques  to 
diversify  and  improve  productivity  and 
sustainability  on  farms. 

The  Conservatives'  "National  Policy",  a 
scheme  of  preferential  tariffs  designed  to 
promote  east-west  trade  across  Canada,  also 
developed  agriculture.  As  shipping  methods 
for  livestock  improved,  disease  and  injury  in 
transit  decreased.  More  valuable,  pedigreed 
animals  were  imported  to  improve  the 
quality  of  Canadian  herds  and  exports. 
Farmers  established  large  cattle  ranches  at 
the  foot  of  the  Rocky  Mountains  in  the 
Northwest  Territories. 


10 


Departmental  Developments 


Accomplishments  as  Minister 


Worth  Noting 


By  1878,  the  department  oversaw  the  new 
Library  of  Parliament,  an  infant  public 
archives,  and  the  national  census.  It 
continued  to  be  responsible  for  immigration, 
since  many  settlers  arrived  ready  to  buy 
farms  or  land  thanks  to  an  agricultural 
depression  in  the  United  Kingdom. 

The  department  also  expanded  its  efforts  in 
animal  disease  control.  It  began  actively 
discouraging  the  use  of  American  ports  with 
inferior  health  facilities  after  some  Canadian 
animals  had  to  be  destroyed  because  of  foot 
and  mouth  disease  before  reaching  the 
United  Kingdom.  Pope  banned  the  import  of 
American  cattle  in  1879  and  1884,  except  at 
points  where  quarantine  and  inspection  were 
available,  to  avoid  an  outbreak  of  pleuro- 
pneumonia and  to  maintain  Canada's  strong 
reputation  for  disease  control  in  the  eyes  of 
British  trade  officials. 


Pope  presided  over  early  attempts  to  gather 
agricultural  statistics.  By  1883,  he  was 
supervising  a  comprehensive  system  of  crop 
reporting  for  Manitoba  and  the  Northwest 
Territories.  The  findings  showed  great 
potential  for  wheat  production,  settlement 
and  economic  development  in  the  Canadian 
West. 

International  and  domestic  exhibitions 
promoted  Canadian  agricultural  products  at 
home  and  abroad.  Pope  presided  over  the 
awarding  and  distribution  of  medals  as  well 
as  the  organization  and  funding  of  these 
events. 

In  1883,  Pope  responded  to  recent  crop 
damage  due  to  insect  attacks  by  appointing 
the  first  departmental  entomologist. 


Pope  served  in  the  militia  during  the 
Lower  Canada  Rebellion  of  1837. 

Pope  was  a  loyalist  and  opposed  the 
American  annexationist  movement.  He 
became  friends  with  John  A.  Macdonald 
at  a  meeting  of  the  British  American 
League  in  Kingston.  He  later  acted  as  an 
intermediary  between  Macdonald  and 
George  Brown  in  the  Confederation 
negotiations. 


Department  inspectors  were  dispatched  to 
implement  quarantines  to  control  livestock 
diseases  in  Canadian  communities.  Pope  was 
the  first  minister  to  recognize  that  producers 
would  co-operate  with  disease  control 
measures  only  if  they  realized  a  net  benefit 
from  the  government's  interventions.  For  the 
first  time,  farmers  whose  diseased  animals 
were  slaughtered  received  compensation. 


11 


1+1 


Agriculture  and  Agriculture  et 

Agri-Food  Canada      Agroalimentaire  Canada 


Luc  Letellier  de  Saint-Just 

November  7,  1873  -  December  14,  1876 


*'* 


I'  r 


/ 


tv  , 


/y* 


;  /'        , 


Canada 


12 


Luc  Letellier 
de  Saint-Just 

(1820-1881) 

Birthplace 

Riviere-Ouelle,  Lower  Canada 

Federal  Constituencies 

Kamouraska,  Grandville  (Quebec) 

Education 

College  of  Ste.  Anne  de  la  Pocatiere, 
Petit  Seminaire  de  Quebec 

Professional  Background 

Trained  as  a  notary,  admitted  as  a 
notary  public  in  1841  and  practised  in 
Riviere-Ouelle 

Political  Affiliation 
Liberal 

"His  initiative  and  daring,  legal 

knowledge  and  speaking  proficiency 
predestined  him  to  take  up  a  career 

in  politics. " 

—  Philippe-Baby  Casgrain,  Letellier  de 

Saint-Just  et  son  temps 


Political  Career 

Letellier's  first  political  rival  was  Canada's 
first  minister  of  agriculture,  Jean-Charles 
Chapais.  Letellier  won  only  the  first  of  five 
electoral  contests  he  waged  in  Kamouraska 
against  Chapais  and  served  briefly  in  the 
colonial  legislative  assembly  in  1851.  These 
political  confrontations  were  bitter  and  hard- 
fought — violence  and  corruption  plagued 
both  sides.  Both  candidates  received  support 
from  family  connections  and  local  rivalries. 

Alter  10  years  of  defeats,  Letellier  was 
appointed  to  the  legislative  council 
representing  Grandville  in  1860.  He  served 
briefly  as  minister  of  agriculture  for  the 
united  colonies  of  Canada  East  and  Canada 
West  in  1863  when  the  Grit/Rouge  coalition 
government  sent  the  struggling  Conservative/ 
Bleu  alliance  to  the  opposition  benches 

Letellier  originally  opposed  Confederation 
because  he  feared  for  the  future  of  French 
culture.  He  eventually  came  to  support  the 
union  and  agreed  to  lead  the  Liberals  in  the 
Senate.  Like  other  political  leaders  of  the 
period,  Letellier  also  sought  election  to  the 
Quebec  national  assembly  but  w  as 
unsuccessful  in  winning  a  seat. 


When  the  Macdonald  government  fell  in  the 
face  of  the  Pacific  scandal  of  November  1873, 
the  new  Liberal  prime  minister,  Alexander 
Mackenzie,  appointed  Letellier  minister  of 
agriculture  and  leader  of  the  Senate. 

Three  years  later,  when  the  lieutenant- 
governor  of  Quebec  died,  Mackenzie 
reluctantly  parted  with  Letellier,  his  second- 
in-command,  and  appointed  him  to  that  post. 
Letellier  was  a  controversial  lieutenant- 
governor,  dismissing  Boucher  de 
Boucherville's  government  in  March  1878 
over  a  railway  policy  of  which  he  did  not 
approve.  The  federal  government  refused  to 
tolerate  what  Quebec  Conservatives  saw  as  a 
"coup  d'etat".  Prime  Minister  Macdonald, 
who  had  recently  been  re-elected,  removed 
Letellier  from  office  in  July  1879.  Letellier 
retired,  and  died  two  years  later  of  a  heart 
attack  at  his  home  in  Riviere-Ouelle. 

Industry  Issues 

As  minister,  Letellier  actively  encouraged  the 
import  of  foreign  seeds,  grains  and  plants  to 
enhance  the  quality  and  variety  of  Canadian 
agricultural  products.  To  support  this  kind  of 
international  exchange,  Letellier  advocated 
the  establishment  of  agronomic  institutes. 
These  institutes,  along  with  institutions  of 
higher  education  and  technical  training  in 
agriculture,  would  supply  the  kind  of 
specialists  needed  to  direct  agricultural 
development  in  Canada. 


13 


Departmental  Developments 


Accomplishments  as  Minister 


Worth  Noting 


Threats  of  contagious  disease  in  cattle,  this 
time  originating  in  the  United  Kingdom  and 
Europe,  were  averted  in  1875-76  through 
conscientious  monitoring  of  cattle  imports  at 
Canadian  ports  and  strict  quarantine 
measures.  Importers  supported  these 
preventative  measures. 

An  invasion  of  grasshoppers  devastated 
Manitoba  crops  in  the  summer  of  1876. 
Letellier  visited  Manitoba  to  investigate  the 
extent  of  the  losses  and  lent  $60,000  to 
affected  farmers  "to  prevent  actual 
starvation,  and  to  enable  the  purchase  of 
necessary  seed  grains".  At  the  same  time, 
Letellier  was  impressed  by  the  potential  for 
agriculture  in  Manitoba. 


Letellier  was  more  of  a  politician  than  an 
administrator.  But  he  was  active  in 
organizing  funding  and  committees  to  ensure 
Canada's  participation  in  the  Philadelphia 
World's  Fair  of  1876.  For  the  first  time, 
Canadian  industries  and  products  were  put 
on  display  internationally  to  promote  trade. 


As  lieutenant-governor,  Letellier  meddled 
in  electoral  contests  and  once  outright 
refused  to  sign  an  order-in-council  "on 
principle".  Quebec's  Attorney  General  at 
the  time,  Auguste-Real  Angers,  refused 
invitations  to  functions  at  Letellier's 
official  residence,  and  eventually  the 
mutual  distrust  between  Letellier  and 
Angers  peaked  when  he  dismissed  the 
government  over  a  controversial  railway 
policy.  The  public  approved  of  Letellier's 
stand  on  the  issue,  but  his  fellow  Liberals 
in  Ottawa,  did  not.  Angers  became 
Canada's  seventh  minister  of  agriculture 
in  1892. 


The  department  also  had  to  contend  with  the 
effects  of  the  gradual  spread  of  the  potato 
beetle  eastward  across  Canada.  In  1 876,  the 
insects  were  found  on  steamers  bound  for 
Germany,  and  the  Imperial  government  in  the 
United  Kingdom  asked  for  an  investigation 
by  departmental  officials  into  precautionary 
measures  that  could  be  taken  in  Canada  to 
prevent  the  spread  of  the  pest  into  Europe. 
The  department  recommended  monitoring 
the  situation  at  ports,  while  handpicking, 
crushing  and  poisoning  insects  and  their  eggs 
to  help  control  their  spread  across  Canada. 


14 


M 


Agriculture  and  Agriculture  et 

Agri-Food  Canada       Agroalimentaire  Canada 


Charles  Alphonse  Pantaleon  Pelletier 

January  26,  1877  -  October  8,  1878 


15 


Charles  Alphonse 
Pantaleon  Pelletier 

(1837-1911) 

Birthplace 

Riviere-Ouelle,  Lower  Canada 

Federal  Constituency 

Kamouraska  (Quebec) 

Education 

College  of  Ste.  Anne  de  la  Pocatiere, 
Laval  University,  Military  School 

Professional  Background 

Called  to  the  bar  in  1860,  practised  law 
in  Quebec  City;  director  for  Quebec  and 
Charlevoix  Navigation  Co.  and  Quebec 
Fire  Insurance  Co. 

Political  Affiliation 

Liberal 


Political  Career 

Pelletier's  first  election  campaign  was  over 
before  voters  had  a  chance  to  have  their  say. 
Recruited  by  the  Liberals  and  supported  by 
Jean-Charles  Chapais'  longtime  rival  Luc 
Letellier  de  Saint-Just,  Pelletier  challenged 
Chapais  in  the  first  election  for  the  House  of 
Commons  in  1867.  Irregularities  in  voters' 
lists  and  rioting  caused  officials  to  refuse  to 
hold  the  vote,  denying  Kamouraska 
constituents  a  representative  for  two  years. 

Pelletier  eventually  won  the  seat  in  a  special 
double  by-election,  held  in  1 869  to  select 
members  for  both  the  provincial  and  the 
federal  governments.  Pelletier  sat  as  MP  for 
Kamouraska  until  1877.  He  also  represented 
Quebec  East  in  the  Quebec  national 
assembly  from  1873  until  dual  representation 
was  abolished  in  1874. 

In  1877,  Pelletier  was  appointed  minister  of 
agriculture  and  called  to  the  Senate.  His 
term  as  minister  of  agriculture  ended  with 
the  defeat  of  the  Liberal  government  in 
September  1878. 

Pelletier  was  selected  speaker  of  the  Senate 
in  1896  and  served  until  1901.  He  resigned 
from  the  Senate  to  accept  an  appointment  as 
puisne  judge  of  the  Superior  Court  of 
Quebec  in  1904. 

In  1908  he  resigned  from  the  Superior  Court 
to  serve  as  lieutenant-governor  of  Quebec 
until  his  death  in  Quebec  City  in  1911. 


Departmental  Developments 

In  1877,  Pelletier  found  it  necessary  to 
further  modify  the  cattle  quarantine 
regulations  and  ban  the  import  of  neat  cattle, 
as  well  as  cattle  parts,  straw,  fodder  or  other 
products  capable  of  carrying  disease,  in  order 
to  protect  against  rinderpest  from  England 
and  other  parts  of  Europe.  Diligent 
quarantine  efforts  also  helped  prevent  the 
introduction  of  contagious  hog  typhoid  into 
Canada  that  year. 

By  1878,  the  department's  annual  report 
stated  that  "owing  to  the  selection  and  care 
of  our  importers,  and  partly  owing  to  our 
Cattle  Quarantine  establishments,  no  disease 
has  been  introduced  into  the  country".  The 
Imperial  Government  in  the  United  Kingdom 
found  Canada's  new  inspection  and 
quarantine  system  so  reliable  in  preventing 
the  spread  of  contagious  animal  diseases  that 
Canada  was  exempt  from  the  provisions  of 
imperial  disease  control  legislation,  which 
required  all  animals  imported  into  the  United 
Kingdom  to  be  slaughtered  immediately. 
Even  1 20  years  ago,  Canadian  efforts  to 
prevent  and  control  animal  disease  facilitated 
international  trade  in  livestock. 


16 


Accomplishments  as  Minister 


Worth  Noting 


Pelletier  oversaw  the  creation  of  the  first 
Dominion  Council  of  Agriculture  in  1877. 
Thirteen  representatives  of  agricultural 
societies,  provincial  agriculture  councils  and 
commodity  groups  from  every  province  were 
appointed  to  the  council.  Pelletier  became 
honorary  president,  while  David  Christie,  the 
speaker  of  the  Senate  from  Paris,  Ontario, 
was  selected  president.  Twelve  standing 
committees  were  formed  to  study  timely 
agricultural  concerns. 

Based  on  the  department's  success  in 
promoting  Canadian  agriculture  at  the  1 876 
World's  Fair  in  Philadelphia,  Pelletier 
organized  a  Canadian  exhibition  for  the 
Metropolitan  Exhibition  held  in  Sydney, 
Australia  in  1877.  Exhibitors  and  the 
department  had  little  time  to  research  what 
types  of  products  might  be  suitable  for 
Australian  trade — some  goods  were  shipped 
directly  from  Philadelphia  to  Sydney — but 
the  exhibits,  totalling  550  cubic  tons  of  ocean 
freight,  were  well  received.  Some  exhibits 
won  prizes,  while  others  helped  spark  trade 
in  several  industries  and  commodities.  The 
total  cost  to  the  department  was  $26,433,  a 
sum  Pelletier  called  "moderate"  in  his  annual 
report. 

Additional  awards,  trade  opportunities  and 
national  recognition  resulted  from  Canada's 
participation  in  a  similar  international 
exposition  in  Paris  in  1878. 


Pelletier  was  a  major  in  the  9th  Battalion 
Voltigeurs  de  Quebec  during  the  Fenian 
Raids  of  1866. 

Pelletier  founded  Quebec's  Parti  National 
in  1872,  a  party  that  went  on  to  form  a 
nationalist  government  in  Quebec  under 
Honore  Mercier  in  1887. 

Adolphe  Routhier,  a  lawyer  from 
Kamouraska  defeated  by  Pelletier  in  the 
1 869  election,  wrote  the  French  words  of 
our  national  anthem:  "O  Canada!  Terre 
de  nos  a'ieux!" 


17 


M 


Agriculture  and  Agriculture  et 

Agri-Food  Canada      Agroalimentaire  Canada 


John  Carling 


September  25,  1885  -  November  24,  1892 


18 


John  Carling 

(1828-1911) 

Birthplace 

London,  Upper  Canada 

Federal  Constituency 

London  (Ontario) 

Education 

London  Common  School 

Professional  Background 

President  of  Carling  Brewing  and  Malting 
Co.;  director  of  Great  Western  Railway. 
London-Port  Stanley  Railway  and  London- 
Huron-Bruce  Railway 

Political  Affiliation 

Conservative 


Political  Career 

Carling  inherited  his  family's  brewing  and 
malting  company  and  was  an  established 
businessman  long  before  he  entered  politics. 
He  started  as  a  city  alderman  in  London  in 
1854  and  stayed  in  municipal  politics  for 
four  years.  He  also  represented  London  in 
the  colonial  legislature  from  1857  until 
Confederation.  In  1862  he  was  appointed 
receiver  general. 

In  the  first  general  election  after 
Confederation,  Carling  was  elected  to  both 
Ontario's  legislative  assembly  and  the  House 
of  Commons,  representing  London. 
Provincially,  he  served  as  minister  of 
agriculture  and  public  works  from  1867  to 
1871.  He  was  re-elected  as  London's 
representative  to  the  Ontario  legislative 
assembly  in  1871  but  resigned  in  1872  to 
concentrate  on  federal  politics. 

Carling  served  as  the  federal  MP  for  London 
from  1 867  to  1 874  but  was  defeated  along 
with  Macdonald's  Conservative  government 
in  the  1874  general  election.  He  was  re- 
elected when  the  Conservatives  regained 
power  in  1878  and  appointed  to  cabinet. 

Carling  served  as  postmaster  general  from 
1882  to  1885  and  minister  of  agriculture 
from  1885  to  1892.  When  he  was  defeated  as 
an  MP  in  the  election  of  1891.  Carling  was 
appointed  to  the  Senate  and  continued  to 


serve  as  minister  of  agriculture.  He  was  re- 
elected MP  for  London  in  1 892  and  served  as 
minister  without  portfolio  from  1 892  to  1 894. 

Carling  was  recalled  to  the  Senate  in  1896, 
where  he  served  until  his  death  in  1911. 

Industry  Issues 

In  Carling's  time,  farmers  urgently  needed 
advanced  agricultural  knowledge  to  help 
them  farm  in  new  Canadian  climates.  Prairie 
farmers  needed  a  spring  wheat  that  would 
ripen  before  early  western  frosts;  if  the 
government  could  develop  a  superior  baking 
wheat  for  this  climate,  opportunities  for 
immigration  and  economic  development 
would  follow.  Experimental  stations  in  other 
countries  and  government  stock  farms  in  the 
Maritimes  already  had  proved  valuable  in 
agricultural  development.  International  trade 
also  inspired  agricultural  research.  For 
example,  an  American  tariff  on  Canadian 
barley  encouraged  the  development  and 
promotion  of  a  new  malting  barley  for  the 
British  market. 


19 


Departmental  Developments 

Disease  control  efforts  of  the  period  further 
underscored  the  need  for  experimental 
stations.  The  testing  and  development  of 
vaccines  for  diseases  such  as  anthrax 
required  proper  scientific  laboratories  and 
controlled  test  environments. 

After  a  1889  convention  of  dairymen's 
associations  in  Ottawa,  the  department 
extended  its  activities  to  cover  the  dairy 
industry.  Departmental  bulletins,  conventions 
and  lectures  educated  farmers  about 
manufacturing  butter  and  cheese  and  feeding 
cattle  for  milk  production.  Uniform  methods 
for  processing  dairy  products  improved  their 
quality  and  enhanced  their  potential  for 
export.  Experimental  dairy  stations  and 
systems  of  co-operative  dairying  were 
established  in  each  province  after  1891. 
A  dairy  school  also  was  established  at 
St-Hyacinthe,  Quebec  in  1892. 


Accomplishments  as  Minister 

Carling's  legacy  as  minister  of  agriculture 
was  the  experimental  farm  research  program. 
Based  on  a  1884  House  of  Commons 
committee's  recommendation  and  research 
done  by  Professor  William  Saunders,  the 
eventual  director  of  the  first  experimental 
farms,  the  Experimental  Farm  Station  Act 
was  given  royal  assent  in  June  1886. 

The  legislation  was  so  well  conceived  that 
only  minor  amendments,  mostly  to  establish 
additional  farms  or  make  administrative 
changes,  were  necessary  for  110  years. 

The  land  for  the  central  farm  in  Ottawa  was 
purchased  first,  followed  by  sites  for  the 
other  regional  farms  in  Brandon,  Manitoba; 
Indian  Head,  Northwest  Territories  (now 
Saskatchewan);  Nappan,  Nova  Scotia;  and 
Agassiz,  British  Columbia.  The  first  research 
activities  on  the  farms  were  testing  crop 
varieties  and  cultural  methods,  and  gathering 
information  about  climate  conditions.  Once 
they  identified  new  crops  for  a  region, 
researchers  distributed  samples  of  the 
improved  varieties  to  local  farmers  and 
published  information  in  public  bulletins. 


India  and  the  already-popular  Red  Fife  wheat 
led  to  the  development  of  Marquis  wheat, 
world  famous  for  its  milling  quality  and  high 
prairie  yields.  Indian  corn  and  spring  rye 
were  developed  as  effective  hay  substitutes 
for  use  in  years  where  the  prairie  hay  crop 
was  insufficient  to  feed  livestock  through  the 
winter.  Upwards  of  12,000  seed  samples 
were  distributed  to  farmers  and  more  than 
30,000  people  were  on  the  farms'  mailing  list 
for  information. 

Thoroughbred  livestock  available  from  the 
farms  for  breeding  also  improved  local  dairy 
and  beef  herds.  Carling  took  a  keen  interest 
in  the  farms'  development  and  frequently 
visited  the  Ottawa  property. 

Worth  Noting 

•     The  French-speaking  assistant  to 
Canada's  first  dairy  commissioner, 
Dr.  James  Robinson,  was  Jean-Charles 
Chapais,  the  son  of  Canada's  first 
agriculture  minister. 


Records  from  1 890  show  that  the  Central 
Experimental  Farm  in  Ottawa  was  already 
experimenting  with  300  varieties  of  potatoes, 
100  varieties  of  wheat,  100  varieties  of  oats 
and  80  varieties  of  barley.  Crosses  made  in 
1892  between  an  early-ripening  wheat  from 


20 


1+1 


Agriculture  and  Agriculture  et 

Agri-Food  Canada      Agroalimentaire  Canada 


Auguste-Real  Angers 

December  7,  1892  -  July  12,  1895 


& 


fcfe 

'         If     7 

/ 

/ 

i 

r 

M 

V                             > 

/ ,      Canada 

/             vV 

>  'i 

21 


Auguste-Real  Angers 

(1838-1919) 

Birthplace 

Quebec  City,  Lower  Canada 

Federal  Constituency 

Montmorency  (Quebec) 

Education 

Nicolet  College,  Laval  University  (1888) 

Professional  Background 

Called  to  the  bar  in  1 860,  practised  law  in 
Quebec  City;  director  of  Credit  Foncier 
Franco-Canadien  and  La  Societe 
d' Administration  Generate 

Political  Affiliation 

Conservative 


Political  Career 

Angers'  political  career  began  when  he  was 
elected  to  the  legislative  assembly  of  Quebec 
in  1 874  in  a  by-election  for  Montmorency. 
He  was  immediately  appointed  solicitor 
general  in  Boucher  de  Boucherville's 
government,  and  served  until  appointed 
attorney  general  in  January  1876.  Angers  was 
also  government  leader  in  the  assembly 
from  1875  to  1878. 

In  1878,  the  lieutenant-governor  of  Quebec, 
Luc  Letellier  de  Saint- Just,  dismissed 
Angers'  government  over  a  controversial 
railway  policy.  Angers  became  leader  of  the 
opposition,  and  in  the  next  election  the 
public  supported  Letellier's  dismissal  of  the 
Conservatives.  Angers  lost  his  seat. 

Undeterred  from  public  life,  Angers  was 
elected  to  represent  Montmorency  in  the 
House  of  Commons  in  a  February  1 880  by- 
election.  In  November,  he  resigned  his  seat 
to  serve  as  puisne  judge  for  the  Superior 
Court  of  Quebec.  In  October  1 887,  Angers 
resigned  from  the  Superior  Court  to  become 
lieutenant-governor  of  Quebec.  This  time  it 
was  Angers'  turn  to  dismiss  a  government  of 
which  he  did  not  approve,  when  Honore 
Mercier's  nationalist  government  became 
tangled  in  a  railway  scandal  of  its  own. 


In  December  1892,  Angers  resigned  as 
lieutenant-governor  and  was  called  to  the 
Senate  and  appointed  federal  minister  of 
agriculture.  He  served  under  the  short-lived 
administrations  of  John  Thompson  and 
Mackenzie  Bowell.  Bowell's  leadership  on 
the  Manitoba  schools  controversy  so 
dissatisfied  Angers  that  he  resigned  from 
cabinet  in  1895.  Angers  briefly  resumed  his 
law  practice  but  declined  an  appointment  to 
the  Supreme  Court — he  wasn't  ready  to  end 
his  political  career  just  yet. 

After  Charles  Tupper  replaced  Bowell  as 
Conservative  leader  and  prime  minister, 
Angers  served  briefly  as  president  of  the 
Privy  Council  from  May  to  July  1 896.  He 
subsequently  resigned  from  the  Senate  to  run 
for  the  House  of  Commons  representing 
Quebec  City  in  the  general  election  of  1896. 
He  failed  to  win  the  seat  as  Wilfrid  Laurier's 
Liberals  swept  to  power.  Angers  resumed  his 
law  practice  in  Montreal  as  head  of  the 
successful  firm  A.  De  Lorimier  &  Godin.  He 
died  in  Montreal  in  1919. 


22 


Industry  Issues 


Departmental  Developments 


Accomplishments  as  Minister 


Minister  Angers  wanted  to  diversify 
Canadian  agriculture.  Mixed  farming,  he 
believed,  offered  the  best  protection  for 
Canadian  farmers  and  the  broader  agriculture 
industry  against  market  fluctuations,  poor 
growing  conditions  and  other  unforeseen 
obstacles.  His  1893  trip  to  Manitoba  and  the 
Northwest  Territories  illustrated  the  need  for 
farmers  to  look  beyond  wheat  and  grains.  A 
combination  of  poor  weather  and  low  prices 
that  summer  adversely  affected  communities 
entirely  dependent  on  grains.  Mixed  farming 
fostered  home  industries  and  offered  settlers 
additional  products  to  trade  locally.  Although 
Angers  no  longer  had  immediate  responsibility 
for  immigration,  the  well-being  of  new 
settlers  in  farm  communities  was  still  a 
concern. 

Canada's  impressive  presence  at  international 
exhibitions  such  as  the  1893  World's  Fair  in 
Chicago  proved  that  the  country's  agriculture 
industry  was  coming  of  age.  The  United 
Kingdom  was  starting  to  feel  real  agricultural 
competition  from  its  former  colony,  thanks  to 
superior  training  and  research.  The  Central 
Experimental  Farm's  Agriculture  Museum 
opened  in  1895,  with  more  than  12,000 
visitors  each  year. 


Disease  control  and  animal  inspection 
remained  a  priority,  with  new  quarantine 
stations  and  inspection  points  established 
along  the  American  boundary  with  the 
Northwest  Territories  in  1894.  That  same 
year,  bovine  tuberculosis  emerged  as  a 
serious  threat  to  animal  health.  A  tuberculin 
test  developed  at  the  Central  Experimental 
Farm  was  used  across  Canada  and  at  points 
of  entry  to  control  disease  by  identifying  sick 
animals  for  isolation  and  slaughter. 

Canadian  cattle  exports  faced  a  serious 
setback  during  Angers'  tenure.  In  October 
1892,  the  British  government  imposed  an 
embargo  on  Canadian  cattle  because  of 
suspected  pleuro-pneumonia  in  cattle  shipped 
from  Montreal.  False  rumours  also  circulated 
in  the  United  Kingdom  that  cattle  from  the 
United  States,  where  pleuro-pneumonia  did 
exist,  were  imported  into  Manitoba  and  the 
Northwest  Territories  without  inspection. 
Despite  the  department's  best  efforts  to 
investigate  and  disprove  the  allegations,  the 
British  government  refused  to  relent  on  its 
embargo. 


Angers  continued  the  work  begun  by  Carling 
to  promote  and  regulate  Canada's  emerging 
dairy  industry.  The  Dairy  Products  Act  of 
1 893  provided  for  the  branding  of  dairy 
products  and  prohibited  the  sale  of  filled  or 
imitation  cheese.  By  1895,  the  Dairy  Branch 
was  also  carrying  out  non-dairy  activities, 
such  as  investigating  the  export  possibilities 
for  Canadian  hay,  apples,  bacon  and  other 
pork  products.  Successful  shipments  of 
butter  and  cheese  to  British  ports  were  made 
possible  because  the  department  fitted 
commercial  steamers  with  insulated  and 
refrigerated  food  storage  chambers. 
Experimental  shipments  of  other  fruits  and 
preserved  eggs,  which  also  needed  these 
cold-storage  facilities,  weren't  as  successful. 

Angers  was  responsible  for  the  first  tobacco 
grown  on  Canadian  farms  in  1893. 
Departmental  research  identified  the  ideal 
varieties  and  growing  techniques  for  use  in 
eastern  Ontario  and  western  Quebec. 


23 


1*1 


Agriculture  and  Agriculture  et 

Agri-Food  Canada      Agroalimentaire  Canada 


Walter  Humphries  Montague 

December  21,  1895  -  January  5,  1896 
and  January  15,  1896  -  July  8,  1896 


Walter   Hump  hies   Montague 
1895-1896 


. 


//>/* 


'Cafiada 


24 


Walter  Humphries 
Montague 

(1858-1915) 

Birthplace 

Adelaide  Township,  Canada  West 

Federal  Constituency 

Haldimand-Monck  (Ontario) 

Education 

Woodstock  College;  Victoria  University, 
Cobourg;  Toronto  School  of  Medicine 

Professional  Background 

Obtained  MD  in  1 882  and  practised 
medicine  in  Dunnville,  Ontario  and 
Winnipeg,  Manitoba 

Political  Affiliation 

Conservative 


Political  Career 

Montague's  political  career  started  slowly. 
He  lost  his  bid  to  represent  Monck  in  the 
Ontario  legislative  assembly's  general 
election  of  1883.  In  1887,  he  was  elected  to 
the  House  of  Commons  for  Haldimand, 
Ontario — but  the  election  was  declared  void. 
Later  in  the  year,  he  won  a  second  election, 
which  was  also  plagued  by  controversy  and 
voided  in  court.   Montague  was  defeated 
again  in  a  by-election  in  1889. 

Montague  finally  won  the  Haldimand  seat  in 
a  1890  by-election.  He  was  re-elected  as  MP 
for  Haldimand  (later  Haldimand-Monck)  in 
1891,  1895  and  1896.  He  also  served  as  vice- 
president  of  the  Conservative  Union  of 
Ontario  in  1892. 

Montague  was  appointed  to  the  Privy 
Council  in  1894  and  served  as  minister 
without  portfolio  from  December  1894  to 
March  1895.  and  as  secretary  ol  state  from 
March  to  December  1S95.  In  December 
1895,  he  was  appointed  minister  of 
agriculture. 


Montague  resigned  briefly  in  January  1 896 
as  one  of  the  cabinet  ministers  Prime 
Minister  Mackenzie  Bowell  called  a  "nest  of 
traitors"  for  deserting  the  government  in 
protest  of  Bowell's  inaction  on  the  Manitoba 
schools  issue.  Montague  returned  to  cabinet 
when  the  controversy  passed,  but  the 
Conservative  caucus  was  slowly  unravelling. 
Charles  Tupper  (the  Conservatives'  fifth 
leader  since  Macdonald's  death  in  1891) 
became  prime  minister  before  the  1896 
election,  but  the  Conservative  government 
was  soundly  defeated  by  Wilfrid  Laurier's 
triumphant  Liberals. 

Montague  lost  his  Haldimand-Monck  seat  in 
the  1900  election  and  left  politics  to  return  to 
his  medical  practice.  In  1908  he  moved  to 
Winnipeg,  and  five  years  later  he  again  ran 
lor  public  office.  In  November  1913 
Montague  was  elected  to  the  legislative 
assembly  of  Manitoba,  representing 
Kildonan-St.  Andrews.  He  was  re-elected  in 
1914  and  appointed  minister  of  public  works 
in  the  Roblin  government  from  November 
1913  to  May  1915.  Montague  died  in 
Winnipeg  in  1915. 


25 


Accomplishments  as  Minister  Worth  Noting 

Montague's  seven-month  tenure  as  minister  •     Montague's  predecessor,  Angers,  also 
coincided  with  a  turbulent  period  in  the  life  resigned  as  minister  of  agriculture  to 

of  his  government.  As  a  result,  his  legacy  is  protest  Prime  Minister  Bowell's 

one  of  maintenance  of  existing  programs  leadership, 

rather  than  considerable  policy  or 
organizational  innovation. 


26 


■+■ 


Agriculture  and  Agriculture  et 

Agri-Food  Canada      Agroalimentaire  Canada 


Sydney  Arthur  Fisher 

July  13,  1896  -  October  6,  1911 


27 


Sydney  Arthur  Fisher 

(1850-1921) 

Birthplace 

Montreal,  Canada  East 

Federal  Constituency 

Brome  (Quebec) 

Education 

McGill  University  and  Trinity  College, 
Cambridge  (B A,  1871) 

Professional  Background 

Owner-operator  of  Alva  Farm  in  Knowlton, 
Quebec;  president  of  Montreal  Ensilage  and 
Stock  Feeding  Association;  founder  and 
president  of  Quebec  Fruit  Growers' 
Association;  member  of  Canadian  National 
Livestock  Association,  Provincial  Dairy 
Association  and  Brome  Agricultural 
Association;  charity  board  member  and 
founder  of  arts  organizations 

Political  Affiliation 

Liberal 


Political  Career 

Fisher  was  elected  as  a  Liberal  MP  in  1882 
and  served  until  he  lost  by  a  majority  of  one 
in  the  face  of  Prime  Minister  Macdonald's 
Conservatives'  final  electoral  victory  in 
1891.  Fisher  accepted  an  appointment  to  the 
Quebec  Council  of  Agriculture.  Five  years 
later,  he  was  re-elected  when  Laurier's 
Liberals  swept  to  power.  His  passion  and 
experience  as  a  farmer  and  agricultural 
activist  as  well  as  an  MP  made  him  a  logical 
choice  for  agriculture  minister.  He  served  as 
an  MP  and  as  minister  of  agriculture  for  the 
next  15  years. 

Laurier  and  his  Liberal  party — including 
Fisher — lost  the  1911  general  election  over 
the  reciprocity  issue.  Fisher  retired  from 
public  life  and  died  in  Ottawa  in  1921. 


Industry  Issues 

In  1896,  the  public  land  once  available  in  the 
American  west  was  closed.  The  Canadian 
Prairies  became  the  "Last  Best  West"  and  a 
new  era  of  settlement  and  agricultural 
expansion  began.  Rising  prices  and 
inexpensive  shipping  created  a  world  market 
for  hard  spring  wheat,  and  prairie  production 
grew  from  29  to  209  million  bushels  a  year. 
Marquis  wheat,  developed  mostly  by  Charles 
Saunders  (son  of  experimental  farms  director 
William  Saunders),  was  introduced  in  1907 
and  soon  accounted  for  90  per  cent  of  prairie 
production.  Western  settlement  and 
development  led  to  the  creation  of  two  new 
provinces,  Saskatchewan  and  Alberta,  in  1905. 

In  1901,  bad  management  kept  the  CPR  from 
moving  more  than  a  third  of  a  bumper  wheat 
crop  before  freeze-up  on  Lake  Superior. 
National  Policy  tariffs  prevented  western 
farmers  from  buying  inexpensive  American 
machinery  and  manufactured  goods. 
Dissatisfied  farmers  formed  co-operatives  to 
advance  their  political  and  business  interests. 
By  the  fall  of  1910,  grievances  climaxed  as 
1 ,000  farmers  staged  the  "March  on  Ottawa" 
to  protest  government  inaction  on  tariffs, 
freight  rates  and  land  policies.  Laurier 
drafted  a  reciprocity  (free  trade)  agreement 
with  the  Americans,  but  both  Laurier  and 
farmers  were  defeated  when  eastern  business 
interests  and  blue-collar  workers  would  not 
support  reciprocity. 


28 


Departmental  Developments 


Accomplishments  as  Minister 


Worth  Noting 


Fisher's  legacy  as  agriculture  minister 
includes  a  major  expansion  of  the  scope  and 
activities  of  the  department.  Amendments  to 
the  Experimental  Farms  Stations  Act  in  1900 
extended  the  branch  farm  system  and  new 
research  stations  opened  in  every  province. 
The  Tobacco  Branch  was  organized  in  the 
department  in  1905  to  encourage  and 
develop  this  new  industry. 

In  1 897,  the  Canadian  and  American 
departments  of  agriculture  agreed  to  co- 
operate in  the  reporting  and  tracking  of 
livestock  diseases.  The  new  co-operative 
inspection  agreement  significantly  increased 
livestock  trade  between  the  two  countries.  In 
1899,  the  department  appointed  a  livestock 
commissioner.  A  biological  laboratory  was 
established  on  the  Central  Experimental  Farm 
in  1902  to  research  animal  disease  control. 

After  1907,  the  Meat  and  Canned  Foods  Act 
provided  for  the  inspection  of  meat  packing 
plants  and  canning  factories.  Departmental 
veterinarians  and  inspectors  have  worked  at 
food  establishments  ever  since. 

A  seed  laboratory  was  established  in  Ottawa 
in  1903  to  test  seeds  for  their  germination 
and  purity.  The  Seed  Control  Act  of  1905 
allowed  the  government  to  regulate  the 
quality  of  Canadian  seeds  under  the  authority 
of  a  new  seed  commissioner.  Additional  seed 
laboratories  across  Canada  continued  this  work. 


The  Grains  Act  (1900)  regulated  and 
provided  inspectors  for  the  western  wheat 
industry. 

An  Animal  Contagious  Diseases  Act 
amendment  (1904)  compensated  livestock 
owners  whose  animals  were  slaughtered  to 
control  the  spread  of  disease. 

The  Act  Respecting  the  Incorporation  of 
Livestock  Records  (1900,  1905)  created 
one  record  association  to  validate 
credentials  for  each  breed,  making  it 
easier  to  export  purebred  animals. 

The  Fruit  Marks  Act  (1901)  standardized 
fruit  grades  and  grade  marks  on  fruit 
packaging,  and  introduced  inspection  at 
ports  to  facilitate  commercial  production 
and  trade. 

New  dairy  products  legislation  (1903) 
prohibited  margarine  and  introduced 
quality  control  regulations  for  butter  and 
cheese  to  facilitate  exports. 

The  Cold  Storage  Act  (1907)  and  similar 
regulations  encouraged  the  use  of  public 
cold  storage  warehouses  and  refrigerated 
shipping  for  dairy  products  and  fruit. 

The  San  Jose  Scale  Act  ( 1 898)  and 
Destructive  Insect  and  Pest  Act  (1910) 
introduced  inspection  and  quarantine  to 
prevent  pests  and  disease  spreading 
through  fruit  trees  and  crops. 


The  prairie  protest  movement  that  was 
active  during  Fisher's  tenure  started  the 
political  careers  of  two  future  Liberal 
ministers  of  agriculture:  Thomas  Crerar, 
founder  of  what  became  the  United  Grain 
Growers,  and  W.R.  Motherwell,  founder 
of  the  Territorial  (Saskatchewan)  Grain 
Growers'  Association. 

Reports  show  that  the  government  was 
recovering  costs  for  services  even  at  the 
turn  of  the  century.  Fees  charged  for 
livestock  inspection  ranged  from  two 
cents  to  one  dollar  per  animal. 


29 


■+i 


Agriculture  and  Agriculture  et 

Agri-Food  Canada      Agroalimentaire  Canada 


Martin  Burrell 

October  16,  1911  -  October  12,  1917 


30 


Martin  Burrell 

(1858-1938) 

Birthplace 

Faringdon,  Berkshire,  England 

Federal  Constituency 

Yale-Cariboo/Yale  (British  Columbia) 

Education 

St.  John's  College,  Hurstpierpont,  England; 
Queen's  University  (LLD  (Hon.),  1928) 

Professional  Background 

Bank  clerk;  fruit  farmer  in  Niagara  and 
Grand  Forks,  B.C.;  lecturer  for  Farmers' 
Institute  and  Ontario  Fruit  Growers' 
Association;  member,  B.C.  Board  of 
Horticulture;  B.C.  fruit  commissioner; 
lecturer  in  England 

Political  Affiliation 

Conservative 


"Our  laws  would  be  better — there 
would  be  less  bitterness  in  our  strife — // 
we  were  oftener  moved  by  a  sincere 
desire  to  lighten  the  work  and  brighten 
the  lives  of  those,  who,  in  the  silence 
and  solitude  of  the  fields  and  the  woods, 
are  doing  the  foundation  work  of  our 
common  country. " 

—  Martin  Burrell,  speech  in  the  House  of 
Commons,  1913 


Political  Career 

Burrell  began  his  political  career  as  mayor  of 
Grand  Forks  in  1903.  He  was  elected  to  the 
House  of  Commons  as  MP  for  Yale-Cariboo 
on  his  second  attempt  in  1908.  Burrell's 
background  as  a  fruit  farmer  and  horticulturalist 
in  both  Ontario  and  B.C.  gave  him  a 
different  perspective  from  prairie  wheat 
farmers'.  In  the  1911  election,  he  opposed 
free  trade —  a  position  that  brought  his 
Conservative  party  into  power.  Prime 
Minister  Robert  Borden  appointed  Burrell 
minister  of  agriculture. 

Burrell  served  as  an  MP  until  1920.  But  by 
the  election  of  1917,  his  health  had 
deteriorated  and  he  could  no  longer  handle 
the  demands  of  the  agriculture  portfolio.  The 
face  of  the  Borden  government  changed  to 
reflect  the  increasingly  serious  consequences 
of  the  First  World  War.  Party  lines  had 
blurred  and  partisanship  was  on  hold: 
Borden  masterminded  a  coalition  Union 
government  dedicated  to  conscription, 
wartime  prohibition  and  the  elimination  of 
political  patronage. 

The  new  government  agenda  needed  a  new 
team  to  execute  wartime  policy,  and  in  the 
subsequent  cabinet  adjustments,  Burrell  left 
the  agriculture  portfolio  to  become  secretary 
of  state  and  minister  of  mines  from  October 
1917  until  December  1919  (after  the  end  of 


the  war).  Burrell  also  served  as  minister  of 
customs  and  inland  revenue  (December  1919 
to  July  1920)  before  quitting  politics  in  1920. 

After  his  public  life,  Burrell  served  as 
librarian  for  the  Library  of  Parliament  until 
his  death  in  1938. 

Industry  Issues 

A  major  drought  in  Palliser  Triangle  in  1913 
and  1914  slowed  once-prosperous  prairie 
wheat  production  to  a  comparative  trickle. 
But  then  came  a  blessing  in  disguise:  the 
First  World  War.  With  Russia  unable  to 
export,  world  demand  for  North  American 
wheat  raised  grain  prices  to  a  level 
previously  unseen  and  new  crops,  such  as 
flax,  could  be  grown  profitably.  Burrell 
called  for  an  all-out  war  effort  and  Canadian 
farmers  responded.  Even  as  yields  fell  later 
in  the  war,  world  consumers  accepted  what 
they  believed  were  temporarily  higher  prices 
and  kept  grain  production  profitable  for 
farmers. 

Departmental  Developments 

The  Census  and  Statistics  Office  was 
transferred  to  the  Department  of  Trade  and 
Commerce  in  1912.  The  Publications  Branch 
was  created  to  distribute  information,  handle 
correspondence  and,  eventually,  maintain  a 
departmental  library. 


31 


The  department  launched  educational  and 
marketing  campaigns  to  inspire  the  war 
effort — for  example,  wool  growers,  whose 
product  was  in  demand  for  military 
uniforms,  learned  to  grade  and  pack  wool 
and  to  form  co-operative  marketing 
associations.  Department  officials  were  in 
charge  of  securing  supplies  of  hay,  oats  and 
grain  for  wartime  food  production  and 
shipment  overseas.  Telegraphic  market 
reporting  between  Canada  and  Europe 
improved  trade  after  1915. 

When  a  rust  epidemic  in  1916  threatened  the 
supply  of  seed  for  the  next  year's  crop,  a 
seed  purchasing  commission  was  appointed 
to  purchase,  clean,  store  and  distribute  the 
necessary  inspected  seed  grain  at  cost. 

The  war  affected  the  department's  research. 
By  1916,  more  than  100  employees  from 
experimental  farms  alone  had  enlisted  in  the 
military,  threatening  the  quality  of  the 
research  service.  Still,  researchers  overcame 
a  threat  to  Canadian  cheese  production 
during  the  war.  Rennet  imported  from  eastern 
Europe  was  no  longer  available.  Pepsin, 
developed  in  1916  at  Ontario's  Finch  Dairy 
Station,  proved  to  be  an  effective  alternative. 

The  experimental  farms  started  a  publicity 
division  in  1915  to  organize  exhibits  and 
promote  their  research  work. 


Accomplishments  as  Minister 

•  The  Agricultural  Instruction  Act  (1913) 
offered  $10  million  to  the  provinces  over 
a  10-year  period  to  establish  and  improve 
agricultural  colleges  and  other  forms  of 
agriculture-related  training.  The 
Agricultural  Instruction  Branch  was 
formed  to  administer  these  programs. 

•  In  1914,  a  system  of  certified  field 
inspection  and  tuber  examination  for 
potato  exports  not  only  lifted  an 
American  embargo,  but  also  improved 
the  quality  of  seed  stock  and  exports. 
Today's  seed  potato  certification  program 
evolved  from  these  measures. 

•  The  Municipal  Testing  Order  (1914) 
fought  bovine  tuberculosis  by  licensing 
dairies  and  encouraging  communities  to 
test  all  dairy  cattle  every  two  years. 

•  First  attempts  at  co-operative  marketing, 
quality  control  regulations  and  inspection 
for  eggs  were  implemented. 

•  An  Act  Respecting  Livestock  (1917) 
authorized  the  minister  of  agriculture  to 
supervise  the  management,  fees  and 
conditions  of  public  stockyards. 


Worth  Noting 

•  In  1915,  a  future  experimental  station  in 
the  Abitibi  district  served  as  a  prisoner- 
of-war  camp.  Prisoners  cleared  155  acres 
of  forest  and  2,500  cords  of  wood  were 
sold  for  pulp. 

•  Burrell  was  trapped  and  seriously  injured 
in  the  1916  fire  in  the  Parliament 
Buildings. 

•  Between  1924  and  1938,  Burrell  wrote  a 
weekly  literary  column,  Literature  and 
Life,  for  the  Ottawa  Journal.  His  articles 
became  the  basis  for  two  books:  Betwixt 
Heaven  and  Charing  Cross  (Toronto: 
1928)  and  Crumbs  are  Also  Bread 
(Toronto:  1934). 


32 


1+1 


Agriculture  and  Agriculture  et 

Agri-Food  Canada      Agroalimentaire  Canada 


Thomas  Alexander  Crerar 

October  12,  1917  -  June  11,  1919 


33 


Thomas  Alexander 
Crerar 

(1876-1975) 

Birthplace 

Molesworth,  Ontario 

Federal  Constituencies 

Marquette,  Brandon,  Churchill  (Manitoba) 

Education 

Portage  la  Prairie  Collegiate 

Professional  Background 

Rural  schoolteacher;  grain  farmer  and 
manager  of  Farmers'  Elevator  Co-op; 
president  of  Grain  Growers  Grain  Company 
(later  United  Grain  Growers  Limited); 
director  of  Great  West  Life  Assurance 
Company,  Canada  Steamship  Lines  Ltd., 
Algoma  Steel  Corp.  Ltd.  and  Modern 
Dairies  Ltd. 

Political  Affiliation 

Liberal  (Unionist)  (1917-21),  Progressive 
(1921-25),  Liberal  (1925-66) 

"In  T.A.  Crerar,  Minister  of  Agriculture 
for  the  Unionists,  the  farmers  had  a 
leader  who  even  wrote  his  ministerial 
letters  on  United  Grain  Growers' 
paper. " 

—  Canadian  historian  Desmond  Morton, 
A  Short  History  of  Canada 


Political  Career 

Crerar  developed  his  taste  for  politics  as  the 
first  reeve  of  Silver  Creek,  Manitoba.  He 
entered  the  national  political  scene  when  he 
was  elected  as  MP  for  Marquette  in  1917. 

Crerar's  impressive  credentials  as  a  farmer, 
grain  buyer  and  rural  activist  made  him  an 
ideal  candidate  for  the  agriculture  portfolio. 
He  was  appointed  minister  of  agriculture  in 
October  1917,  serving  in  a  wartime  coalition 
(Union)  government  dedicated  to  non- 
partisanship  and  to  the  effective  channelling 
of  Dominion  resources  toward  the  war  effort 
in  Europe. 

The  Canadian  Council  of  Agriculture  drafted 
a  farmers'  platform  in  1916.  Farmers 
proposed  a  different  national  policy: 
reciprocity,  lower  freight  rates,  bank  reforms, 
railway  nationalization  and  a  graduated 
income  tax.  In  1918,  farmers  were  furious  at 
the  cancellation  of  their  sons'  exemption 
from  conscription. 

Minister  Crerar  was  listening  and  fought  for 
farmers'  interests  around  the  cabinet  table. 
But  he  didn't  succeed.  When  Finance 
Minister  Thomas  White's  1919  Budget  again 
fell  short  of  farmers'  expectations,  Crerar 
quit  the  cabinet. 

Farmers'  parties  were  governing  Ontario, 
Manitoba  and  Alberta.  While  Crerar  was 
reluctant  to  support  these  political 


movements — he  was  a  pragmatist  and 
recognized  the  appeal  of  these  policies  to  the 
soft  Liberal  vote — his  party  wasn't  listening 
to  farmers.  Crerar  worked  to  form  a  national 
farmers'  party,  the  Progressives,  and  became 
its  leader  in  1920. 

In  the  1921  election,  Crerar  was  re-elected  as 
an  MP,  and  the  Progressives  won  65  seats  in 
Ontario  and  the  West.  Crerar  refused 
opposition  leader  status,  hoping  instead  for 
the  accommodation  of  farmers'  policies 
within  the  government  agenda.  The  strategy 
didn't  work,  and  his  party  became  divided 
over  policy.  Frustrated,  Crerar  resigned  as 
party  leader  in  1922.  He  sat  as  an  MP  until 
the  end  of  the  14th  parliament  but  didn't  run 
in  the  general  election  of  1925. 

After  a  brief  absence  from  politics,  Crerar  re- 
emerged  as  a  Liberal  cabinet  minister  under 
King  in  1929.  He  served  as  minister  of 
railways  and  canals  from  December  1929 
until  August  1930  and  was  re-elected  as  an 
MP  in  a  1930  by-election  for  Brandon.  Later 
in  1930,  he  was  defeated  in  the  general 
election  that  removed  Mackenzie  King's 
Liberals  from  power. 

In  1935,  Crerar  became  MP  for  Churchill 
and  returned  to  cabinet  as  minister  of  mines, 
of  immigration  and  colonization,  and  of  the 
interior  and  as  superintendent-general  of 
Indian  affairs  (October  1935  to  November 
1936).  His  appointment  was  later  simplified 
to  minister  of  mines  and  resources 


34 


(December  1936  to  April  1945).  As  the 
cabinet  minister  responsible  for  natural 
resources,  Crerar  was  an  important  decision- 
maker in  King's  cabinet  during  the  Second 
World  War. 

Crerar  was  re-elected  as  MP  for  Churchill  in 
1940  and  sat  in  the  House  of  Commons  until 
the  dissolution  of  19lh  parliament  in  April 
1945.  King  called  him  to  the  Senate,  where 
he  served  until  his  resignation  in  May  1966. 
Crerar  died  in  1975. 

Industry  Issues 

Prompted  by  the  soaring  world  demand  for 
Canadian  wheat  at  a  time  of  declining  prairie 
yields,  the  government  closed  the  Winnipeg 
Grain  Exchange  in  1917  and  created  a  single 
wheat  board  to  market  the  Canadian  product. 
Wheat  prices  soared  to  $3.15  per  bushel, 
offering  farmers  relative  prosperity  despite 
the  psychological  strain  of  watching  their 
sons  go  to  war.  After  the  1919  harvest,  the 
wheat  board  was  dissolved  and  free 
enterprise  returned  to  prairie  farming. 


Departmental  Developments 

Matters  unrelated  to  agriculture  were 
removed  from  the  department's  jurisdiction 
in  1917:  exhibitions,  patents,  copyrights, 
trademarks,  public  health  and  quarantines 
were  transferred  to  the  Department  of 
Immigration  and  Colonization. 

Oleomargarine  was  prohibited  as  a  butter 
substitute  under  the  Dairy  Industry  Act 
(1903).  But  in  1917,  the  Canada  Food  Board 
passed  an  order  permitting  the  use  of 
oleomargarine  under  the  provisions  of  the 
War  Measures  Act.  The  department 
supervised  its  manufacture  and  sale. 

Near  the  end  of  the  war,  livestock  feed 
contaminants  became  an  issue — mill  feeds 
were  being  mixed  with  harmful  weed  seeds. 
In  1918,  the  Seed  Branch  began  microscopic 
studies  of  allegedly  contaminated  feeds. 
These  investigations  placed  pressure  on  feed 
suppliers  to  improve  the  overall  quality  and 
accuracy  of  labelling  on  feeds  offered  for 
sale  in  Canada. 


Worth  Noting 

•  Crerar  is  the  only  minister  to  have 
resigned  over  farmers'  issues. 

•  In  1974,  Crerar  became  the  first 
politician  recognized  as  a  companion  of 
the  Order  of  Canada. 


At  the  end  of  the  war,  Canadian  breeders  had 
difficulty  shipping  cattle  to  the  United  States 
because  of  Canada's  inadequate  tuberculosis 
control  record.  The  department  responded 
with  regulations  providing  for  accredited 
tuberculosis-free  herds  in  September  1919. 


35 


M 


Agriculture  and  Agriculture  et 

Agri-Food  Canada      Agroalimentaire  Canada 


Simon  Fraser  Tolmie 

August  12,  1919  -  December  29,  1921 
and  July  13,  1926  -  September  25,  1926 


36 


Simon  Fraser  Tolmie 

(1867-1937) 

Birthplace 

Victoria,  British  Columbia 

Federal  Constituency 

Victoria  (British  Columbia) 

Education 

Ontario  Veterinary  College,  Guelph; 
University  of  British  Columbia  (LLD  (Hon.)) 

Professional  Background 

Farmer  and  breeder  of  purebred  cattle  in 
Victoria,  British  Columbia;  chief  inspector, 
B.C.  Health  of  Animals  Branch;  Dominion 
livestock  commissioner  for  B.C.;  Dominion 
organizer  for  the  Conservative  Party 

Political  Affiliation 

Conservative 


Political  Career 


Tolmie  was  elected  MP  for  Victoria  in  1917 
and  served  in  the  Union  government  under 
prime  ministers  Robert  Borden  and  Arthur 
Meighen.  He  was  appointed  minister  of 
agriculture  after  the  resignation  of  Thomas 
Crerarin  1919. 


The  Conservatives  lost  the  1921  general 
election  to  Mackenzie  King's  Liberals. 
Tolmie  retained  his  seat  but  lost  his  cabinet 
portfolio.  Tolmie  again  held  the  agriculture 
portfolio  for  a  few  months  in  the  summer  of 
1926  when  Meighen's  Conservatives  were 
asked  to  form  a  government  during  the 
King-Byng  constitutional  crisis.  King's 
Liberals  were  re-elected  in  1926  and  Tolmie 
returned  to  the  opposition  benches. 

Tolmie  became  active  in  provincial  politics 
and  was  elected  leader  of  the  B.C. 
Conservative  Party  in  November  1926.  He 
resigned  his  federal  seat  in  1928  and  was 
elected  to  represent  Saanich  in  the  legislative 
assembly  of  British  Columbia.  He  became 
premier  of  British  Columbia  and  minister  of 
railways  until  November  1933,  when  his 
government  lost  the  election  and  he  lost  his 
seat.  Tolmie  was  re-elected  to  represent 
Victoria  in  the  House  of  Commons  in  a  1936 
by-election  but  died  in  office  in  1937. 


Industry  Issues 

The  Prairies  had  a  problem:  declining 
productivity.  Farmers  were  beginning  to 
experience  serious  crop  failures  from  their 
fast-depleting  soils.  And  as  world  market 
conditions  returned  to  normal  after  the  First 
World  War,  grain  prices  plummeted  to  45  per 
cent  of  their  wartime  peak  within  two  years. 
Buoyed  by  their  relative  prosperity  several 
years  earlier,  many  prairie  farmers  had 
heavily  invested  in  land  and  machinery,  only 
to  see  their  industry  falter.  Farmers'  political 
parties  were  in  power  in  Ontario,  Manitoba 
and  Alberta,  and  the  federal  government  was 
under  pressure  to  improve  farmers'  fortunes 
or  risk  losing  their  votes. 

Departmental  Developments 

Once  the  war  ended,  the  department's 
research  work,  previously  limited  by 
employee  absences  and  diffused  by  unique 
wartime  demands,  resumed  at  full  strength. 
But  new  staffing  challenges  emerged.  As  the 
Canadian  economy  strengthened,  technically 
trained  employees  were  often  lost  to  the 
private  sector,  where  salaries  were  higher. 
Jobs  were  plentiful  and,  unfortunately  for  the 
department,  Canadian  universities  were  only 
just  beginning  to  produce  agriculture 
graduates. 


37 


With  the  war  effort  over,  the  department 
could  discontinue  some  areas  of  research  and 
begin  new  projects.  The  Seed  Purchasing 
Commission,  for  example,  was  no  longer 
needed  to  guarantee  stock  in  peacetime. 
New  research  activities  investigated 
everything  from  binder  twine  to  sunflowers. 
The  Horticulture  Division  was  expanded 
and  began  investigating  not  only  fruit  and 
vegetable  culture,  but  also  ornamental 
gardening,  greenhouses  and  canning.  The 
Fruit  Branch  was  created  to  oversee  the 
marketing,  grading,  inspection  and  transport 
of  fruits  for  export.  New  botanical 
laboratories  were  established  at  branch 
farms,  and  new  experimental  stations  and 
substations  were  established  according  to 
research  needs. 


Accomplishments  as  Minister 

•  A  1920  federal-provincial  agreement 
established  that  grading  dairy  products 
for  export  was  within  federal  jurisdiction, 
while  grading  for  home  consumption  was 
a  provincial  concern. 

•  Grading  was  introduced  for  eggs  and 
hogs,  in  consultation  with  industry.  These 
quality-control  measures  helped  exporters 
obtain  premium  prices,  particularly  for 
bacon-type  hogs  in  the  British  market. 

•  Regulations  were  also  passed  for  the 
inspection,  grading  and  sale  of 
commercial  feeds,  fertilizers  and 
vegetables. 


Worth  Noting 

•     In  1926,  the  Agassiz  Experimental  Farm 
received  worldwide  publicity  from  an 
egg-laying  contest  when  a  bird  owned 
by  the  University  of  British  Columbia 
produced  a  world  record  35 1  eggs  in 
365  days. 


Market  information,  both  national  and 
international,  became  more  important  as  the 
agriculture  industry  expanded.  The 
department  assembled  telegraph  services  for 
daily  markets  and  interstockyard 
communication.  It  created  weekly  reports 
and  distributed  them  through  the  Canadian 
Press  wire  and  by  regular  mail.  Newspapers 
and  other  organizations  used  these  reports 
and  services  to  disseminate  standardized, 
reliable  market  information. 


Performance  testing  was  introduced  for 
poultry.  Department-sponsored 
inspections  and  egg-laying  contests 
motivated  producers  to  improve  flock 
quality  and  performance. 

Under  1920  amendments  to  the  Criminal 
Code,  the  minister  of  agriculture  was 
assigned  responsibility  for  horse  racing. 
RCMP  officers  under  departmental 
supervision  enforced  regulations  at 
racetracks. 


38 


1*1 


Agriculture  and  Agriculture  et 

Agri-Food  Canada       Agroalimentaire  Canada 


U^SA 


William  Richard  Motherwell 

December  29,  1921  -  June  28,  1926 
and  September  25,  1926  -August  7,  1930 


'// 


m  ■ 


-   ~\' 


39 


William  Richard 
Motherwell 

(1860-1943) 

Birthplace 

Perth,  Canada  West 

Federal  Constituencies 

Regina,  Melville  (Saskatchewan) 

Education 

Ontario  Agricultural  College,  Guelph  (1882); 
University  of  Saskatoon  (LLD  (Hon.)  1928) 

Professional  Background 

Farmer;  secretary  of  Abernethy  school 
district;  magistrate  of  the  peace  for  the 
Northwest  Territories;  founder  and  president 
of  Central  Canada  Seed  Growers 
Association;  co-founder  and  president  of 
Territorial  (later  Saskatchewan)  Grain 
Growers'  Association 

Political  Affiliation 

Liberal 

"Motherwell  is  not  what  I  call  a 
political  farmer.   He  has  been  in  politics 
for  many  years,  but  during  all  those 
years  he  has  always  been  regarded  as  a 
good  farmer,  even  among  his 
neighbours;  and  this  is  the  acid  test.  " 
—  Yorkton,  Saskatchewan  banker,  as  quoted  in 
the  Country  Guide  and  Nor-West  Farmer,  1941 


Political  Career 

Although  he  was  born  and  educated  in 
Ontario,  Motherwell's  economic  and  political 
roots  took  hold  in  the  wheat  fields  of 
Saskatchewan.  He  ran  unsuccessfully  to 
represent  Qu'Appelle  North  in  Northwest 
Territories  assembly  in  1894  and  1896.  But 
after  the  CPR  failed  to  transport  prairie 
wheat  to  lake  ports  before  freeze-up  in  1901, 
Motherwell  founded  the  Territorial  Grain 
Growers'  Association,  took  the  CPR  to  court, 
and  lobbied  for  legislation  to  curb  railway 
and  line  elevator  monopolies.  This  success 
led  to  his  election  to  the  Saskatchewan 
assembly  in  1905. 

Motherwell  was  Saskatchewan's  first 
commissioner  of  agriculture  from  1905  to 
1909,  and  its  first  minister  of  agriculture 
from  1909  to  1918.  As  minister,  Motherwell 
initiated  co-operative  schemes  to  manage 
creameries,  grain  marketing  and  hail 
insurance.  He  supported  research  into  prairie 
dry  belt  cultivation  and  oversaw  the  founding 
of  the  college  of  agriculture  at  the  new 
University  of  Saskatoon  in  1908.  Motherwell 
was  also  provincial  secretary  between  1905 
and  1912.  He  served  as  a  member  of  the 
assembly  almost  continuously  until  his 
resignation  in  1918  over  a  school  language 
controversy. 


Motherwell  continued  his  political  career  in 
federal  politics.  Defeated  in  a  by-election  for 
Assiniboia  in  1919,  he  was  elected  as  MP  for 
Regina  from  1921  to  1925  and  for  Melville 
from  1925  to  1940.  In  1921,  Motherwell  was 
the  only  Liberal  MP  from  Alberta  or 
Saskatchewan  and  a  natural  candidate  for 
minister  of  agriculture,  given  his  experience. 
He  served  until  1930,  except  when  the 
Conservatives  held  power  during  the 
King-By ng  constitutional  crisis  of  1926. 

By  1930,  the  Liberals  were  in  as  much 
trouble  as  the  prairie  economy.  They  lost  the 
1930  general  election,  but  Motherwell 
continued  to  be  active  in  agricultural  issues 
as  an  opposition  MP  through  the  Depression. 
When  he  retired  in  1 940  at  age  80,  he 
reflected  that  his  farm  took  more  out  of  him 
than  politics.  He  died  in  Regina  in  1943. 


40 


Industry  Issues 


Departmental  Developments 


Worth  Noting 


The  1920s  brought  rapid  technological 
change.  But  with  limited  resources,  farmers 
couldn't  test  new  machinery,  seeds  or 
techniques  without  considerable  risk.  They 
needed  non-partisan  departmental  research  to 
keep  up. 

After  several  years  of  prairie  crop  losses,  a 
conference  on  rust  control  for  wheat  was 
held  in  September  1924.  Researchers  from 
the  experimental  farms,  the  National 
Research  Council,  and  Canadian  and 
American  universities  co-operated  to  found 
the  Dominion  Rust  Research  Laboratory  at 
the  Manitoba  Agricultural  College  in 
Winnipeg.  New  rust-resistant  varieties  of 
wheat,  oats  and  other  cereals  were 
developed. 

After  a  bountiful  harvest  in  1928,  the  Wheat 
Pool  had  an  excess  of  wheat  to  sell.  The 
pool-guaranteed  price  paid  to  farmers  was  no 
longer  competitive  on  the  world  market;  a 
market  correction  was  inevitable.  Farmers 
and  other  businesspeople  cancelled  orders 
and  cut  consumption.  Inventories  were  large 
and  terms  of  credit  came  due.  The  stage  was 
set  for  an  economic  downturn — the  drought 
of  1929  only  served  to  make  things  official. 


In  1923,  the  British  embargo  against 
Canadian  cattle  ended,  providing  new  export 
options  for  Canadian  producers.  Departmental 
veterinarians  supervised  quarantines  and 
inspections  and  accompanied  the  shipments  of 
cattle  overseas.  To  facilitate  cattle  exports  to 
the  United  States,  Canada  adopted  a  new 
restricted  areas  plan  to  control  tuberculosis. 
Other  supervised  and  accredited  herd  plans 
registered  cattle  free  of  disease  and  suitable  for 
breeding  and  export. 

Despite  the  department's  best  efforts,  foot 
and  mouth  disease  from  the  United  Kingdom 
penetrated  Canadian  livestock.  By  1927, 
rabies  also  crossed  the  Canadian  border  from 
the  United  States.  Sheep  scab,  however,  was 
successfully  eradicated. 

In  1923,  bacteriology  became  a  division  of 
the  Experimental  Farms  Service.  By  1929, 
186  illustration  (experimental  project) 
stations  were  established  across  Canada. 

The  Agricultural  Economics  Branch,  formed 
in  1929,  was  a  first:  never  before  had  a 
government  department  focused  so  intently 
on  economics  and  the  integrated  management 
of  scientific  and  financial  issues. 


In  1882,  Motherwell  became  one  of  the 
first  graduates  of  the  Ontario  Agricultural 
College. 

Motherwell  was  recommended  for  the 
Saskatchewan  agriculture  portfolio  in 
Premier  Walter  Scott's  cabinet  by  some 
of  the  CPR  staff  he  took  to  court  for 
mismanagement  and  monopolistic 
practices. 


The  shared  field  of  agriculture  policy  continued 
to  require  federal-provincial  co-ordination  to 
maintain  quality  standards.  Federal  grading 
regulations  developed  for  international  trade 
were  extended  to  interprovincial  trade  by 
enabling  provincial  legislation. 


41 


1+1 


Agriculture  and  Agriculture  et 

Agri-Food  Canada      Agroalimentaire  Canada 


Robert  Weir 

August  8,  1930  -  October  23,  1935 


' 


,*i^ 


.<  A 


Cerf>a$a 


/      / 


42 


Robert  Weir 

(1882-1939) 

Birthplace 

Wingham,  Ontario 

Federal  Constituency 

Melfort  (Saskatchewan) 

Education 

University  of  Toronto  (BA,  1911) 

Professional  Background 

Teacher  in  Huron  County,  Ontario  and 
Regina,  Saskatchewan;  actuary  with 
Confederation  Life;  major,  78lh  Battalion, 
Canadian  Expeditionary  Force; 
Saskatchewan  public  school  inspector; 
farmer  and  breeder  of  horses,  cattle  and  hogs 

Political  Affiliation 

Conservative 


Political  Career 

Robert  Weir  was  elected  MP  for  Melfort  in 
the  general  election  of  1930  and  served  the 
department  during  one  of  the  most  challenging 
periods  in  Canadian  agricultural  history. 

The  Depression  was  a  difficult  time  to  be  in 
government.  Communist  organizers  agitated 
in  prairie  relief  camps  and  orchestrated  the 
"On  to  Ottawa"  trek  to  protest  the 
Conservative  government's  policies. 
Established  Tories  and  business  leaders 
deserted  Prime  Minister  R.B.  Bennett  and  his 
social  policies  to  organize  their  own 
Reconstruction  party,  which  aimed  to  reform 
capitalism.  The  Co-operative  Commonwealth 
Federation  (CCF)  party  gained  strength  and 
popularity  in  Weir's  Saskatchewan,  while  the 
Social  Credit  party  dominated  the  political 
agenda  in  Alberta.  Bennett's  Depression- 
fighting  tariffs  hurt  more  than  helped  the 
economy. 

Weir  lost  both  his  seat  and  his  portfolio  when 
the  Bennett  government  was  defeated  in  1935. 
He  died  in  Weldon,  Saskatchewan  in  1939. 


Industry  Issues 

Some  regions  and  commodities  continued  to 
expand  at  a  satisfactory  level  during  the 
Depression.  But  the  prairie  wheat  pool  was 
ruined  when  its  payments  to  farmers  exceeded 
the  world  price  for  wheat  in  1929.  The 
Conservatives  kept  it  alive  with  secret 
subsidies,  and  Bennett  gave  $20  million  in 
emergency  relief  to  ailing  prairie  farmers 
in  1930.  ' 

Prairie  winds  began  lifting  topsoil  in  1931. 
The  grasshoppers  came  in  1932  and  in  1933 
drought,  rust,  hail  and  frost  joined  them  in 
destroying  the  once-prosperous  prairie  wheat 
industry.  Land  that  yielded  23  bushels  per 
acre  in  1928  was  reduced  to  an  unviable 
three  bushels  per  acre  in  1937.  Wheat  prices 
dropped  from  $1 .28  to  60  cents  per  bushel 
between  1928  and  1931.  Many  farmers  quit 
or  moved  away  from  the  Prairies.  Previous 
ministers'  fears  about  the  vulnerability  of 
prairie  farmers  who  failed  to  diversify  their 
operations  were  realized. 


43 


Departmental  Developments 


Accomplishments  as  Minister 


Worth  Noting 


Departmental  researchers  at  Indian  Head, 
Scott,  Swift  Current  and  Lethbridge  taught 
farmers  how  to  prevent  soil  drifting.  Some  of 
the  less-viable  land  was  returned  to  pasture, 
for  which  it  was  more  suitable.  The 
department  also  provided  funding  for  soil 
surveys  in  dry  areas.  The  new  Soil  Research 
Laboratory  at  Swift  Current  studied 
moisture,  drifting  and  fertility.  The  new 
Forage  Crops  Laboratory  at  the  University  of 
Saskatchewan  established  an  international 
reputation  for  breeding  and  genetic  studies 
with  grasses  and  legumes,  as  well  as  for 
teaching. 

Officials  from  several  branches  collaborated 
on  a  major  grasshopper  control  campaign  in 
1933.  Working  with  the  provinces,  they 
succeeded  in  dramatically  reducing  crop 
losses  caused  by  these  pests. 

Between  1931  and  1933,  the  Agricultural 
Economics  Branch  conducted  a  farm  power 
and  machinery  survey  to  compare  the  costs 
of  horse  versus  tractor  power.  The  survey 
was  one  of  the  first  farm  management  and 
social  change  studies  conducted  in  Canada. 


Weir's  Prairie  Farm  Rehabilitation 
Administration  Act  passed  in  April  1935.  It 
provided  $1  million  per  year  to  help  farmers 
solve  their  own  problems  in  three  ways:  by 
improving  cultural  practices,  conserving 
water  supplies  and  changing  land  use.  Other 
federal  agencies  and  prairie  provincial 
governments  collaborated  in  these  efforts. 
Originally,  experimental  farms  staff 
administered  the  Act;  today,  a  separate 
administration  continues  this  work. 

Weir  opposed  centralizing  all  government 
research  under  the  National  Research 
Council  (NRC),  even  though  the  rest  of  the 
members  of  the  Privy  Council  committee 
studying  the  issue  favoured  the  change. 
Rather  than  remove  research  from  his 
department.  Weir  suggested  a  parallel 
agricultural  research  council.  By  1934, 
committees  involving  agriculture  were 
reorganized  as  joint  committees  of  the 
department  and  the  NRC.  They  also  included 
representatives  from  industry,  academia, 
other  departments  and  provinces.  This  co- 
operative structure  still  exists  in  the  form  of 
the  Canadian  Agricultural  Research  Council. 


Weir  was  a  First  World  War  hero, 
wounded  at  Passchendaele. 

The  department's  1932  annual  report 
notes  an  increase  in  enquiries  about 
ornamental  horticulture,  presumably 
because  the  unemployed  had  more  time 
for  home  improvement. 

During  the  Depression,  Newfoundlanders 
tried  to  help  by  sending  salt  cod  to 
destitute  prairie  farmers.  But  prairie 
settlers  didn't  know  what  it  was — some 
soaked  it  and  used  it  to  plug  holes  in 
their  roofs! 


Jurisdictional  debates  arose  over  the  federal 
government's  right  to  establish  standards  for 
trade.  In  1934,  the  Natural  Products 
Marketing  Act  was  declared  unconstitutional 
for  going  beyond  the  federal  government's 
jurisdiction  in  creating  the  single  Dominion 
Marketing  Board. 


44 


1*1 


Agriculture  and  Agriculture  et 

Agri-Food  Canada      Agroalimentaire  Canada 


James  Garfield  Gardiner 

November  4,  1935  -  June  21,  1957 


45 


James  Garfield 
Gardiner 

(1883-1962) 

Birthplace 

Farquhar  (Huron  County),  Ontario 

Federal  Constituency 

Melville  (Saskatchewan) 

Education 

Manitoba  College,  Winnipeg  (BA,  1911) 

Professional  Background 

School  principal;  farmer 

Political  Affiliation 

Liberal 


"[Gardiner  was]  so  single-minded  in 
espousing  western  affairs  that  he 
frequently  exasperated  his  colleagues... 
His  faith  in  individual  effort  and  in 
limited  government... never  wavered, 
and  he  consistently  applied  his  ideas  to 
building  his  province... through 
depression,  war  and  reconstruction. 
Notably  partisan,  he  held  that  a 
minister  should  be  fully  responsible  and 
believed  frankly  in  patronage.  " 
—  Biographer  Norman  Ward 


Political  Career 

Gardiner  won  his  first  provincial  by-election 
for  Qu'Appelle  North  in  1914  and  was  re- 
elected to  Saskatchewan's  legislative 
assembly  five  times.  He  served  as  minister  of 
highways  (1922-26),  minister  of  railways 
(1926-27),  and  treasurer  (1926-27  and  1934- 
35).  When  Premier  C.A.  Dunning  was  called 
to  the  federal  cabinet,  Gardiner  was  chosen 
leader  of  the  Saskatchewan  Liberals  and 
served  as  premier  from  1926  to  1929.  The 
Liberals  catered  to  farmers  and  the  ethnic 
community  for  support,  but  their  affinity  for 
patronage  contributed  to  their  electoral  defeat 
in  1929. 

Gardiner  sat  as  leader  of  the  opposition 
through  the  early  years  of  the  Depression. 
The  Liberals  won  the  1934  Saskatchewan 
election  and  Gardiner,  now  MLA  for 
Melville,  became  premier  for  the  second  time 
in  July  1934. 

Prime  Minister  Mackenzie  King  needed  a 
new  federal  minister  of  agriculture  and  asked 
Gardiner  to  leave  provincial  politics  to  join 
him  in  Ottawa.  Gardiner  agreed  and  resigned 
as  premier  on  November  1,  1935.  The 
following  January,  he  was  elected  MP  for 
Melville.  He  was  re-elected  federally  five 
times. 


In  addition  to  his  responsibilities  in  the 
agriculture  portfolio,  Gardiner  served  as 
minister  of  war  services  in  1940  and  1941. 
His  political  ambitions  went  beyond 
cabinet — he  unsuccessfully  contested  the 
federal  Liberal  leadership  in  1948.  Gardiner's 
only  defeat  came  during  Diefenbaker's 
electoral  sweep  of  the  Prairies  in  1958.  He 
retired  from  politics  and  died  in  1962. 

Industry  Issues 

Gardiner  continued  efforts  started  by  Weir  to 
rejuvenate  prairie  soils  and  rebuild  the  prairie 
economy  through  farm  assistance.  The 
Second  World  War  required  leadership  to 
secure  a  supply  of  agricultural  products  for 
Europe  and  for  Canadian  troops  overseas. 
Canada  had  bumper  crops  after  1939,  but  the 
war-stricken  United  Kingdom  could  not  buy 
products  without  a  $1.5-million  loan  from 
the  Canadian  government. 

Until  1947,  the  agricultural  supplies 
committee  planned  and  managed  food 
production  and  marketing.  Commodity- 
specific  boards  conserved  materials;  secured 
seed;  bought,  sold  and  stored  supplies;  and 
licensed  products  for  export.  Feed  freight 
assistance  was  implemented  to  overcome 
shortages  in  Eastern  Canada.  When  world 
production  and  trade  returned  to  normal  after 
the  war  and  prices  dropped,  an  appointed 
board  marketed  farm  products  and  provided 
subsidies  and  equalization  payments  to 
ensure  adequate  farm  returns. 


46 


Departmental  Developments 

In  1937,  a  major  departmental  reorganization 
grouped  similar  functions  under  one 
administrative  head.  Four  operating 
services — production,  marketing, 
experimental  farms  and  science — were 
created  in  place  of  the  previous  nine 
branches.  The  separation  of  basic  research 
activities  (Science  Service)  from  the  applied 
research  activities  (Experimental  Farms 
Service)  caused  some  controversy  and 
confusion.  A  fifth  service,  administration 
service,  encompassed  the  Prairie  Farms 
Rehabilitation  Administration  (PFRA), 
library,  publicity  and  extension  activities. 

Important  rehabilitation  research  occurred  at 
new  district  experimental  substations  across 
the  Prairies.  After  1935,  the  national  soil 
survey  committee,  funded  by  the  PFRA  and 
consisting  of  provincial,  departmental  and 
university  researchers,  began  analysing  soil 
samples  to  better  monitor  and  understand 
changing  soil  resources.  With  PFRA  money 
and  training,  field  shelterbelt  associations 
planted  hedges  to  prevent  drifting  and  to 
protect  buildings  from  high  winds. 

When  vegetable  seed  supplies  were  cut  off 
during  the  war,  experimental  farms  produced 
additional  stock.  Soybeans,  sunflowers  and 
rapeseed  provided  new  forms  of  industrial 
oils.  Milkweed  was  studied  as  a  potential 
rubber  substitute  and  as  floss  for  marine  life 


preservers.  Researchers  also  advised 
Department  of  National  Defence  officials  on 
the  planting  and  maintenance  of  airfield 
grasses. 

When  Newfoundland  joined  Confederation 
in  1949,  the  department  gained  a 
demonstration  farm  and  agricultural  school. 

In  1951,  forest  biologists  and  entomologists 
were  almost  moved  to  the  Department  of 
Resources  and  Development.  To  keep  them 
in  the  department  and  improve  service  to 
industry,  the  Department  of  Agriculture 
created  a  new  division  of  forest 
entomologists  and  plant  pathologists  to 
encourage  co-operative  research. 

When  a  serious  foot  and  mouth  disease 
outbreak  hit  Saskatchewan  in  1952,  the 
department  realized  that  officials  diagnosing 
the  disease  worked  in  a  separate  service  from 
those  administering  quarantines  and  that  this 
was  inefficient.  Gardiner  ordered  animal 
pathology  moved  from  the  Science  Service 
to  the  Production  Service.  In  1956,  plant 
protection  moved  to  the  Production  Service 
lor  similar  reasons. 


Accomplishments  as  Minister 

•  The  Prairie  Farm  Assistance  Act  (1939) 
provided  direct  payments  to  farmers  who 
suffered  low  yields  through 
circumstances  beyond  their  control. 

•  The  Wheat  Acreage  Reduction  Act  (1942) 
implemented  grain  delivery  quotas  for 
the  first  time  to  overcome  wartime 
surpluses.  Farmers  were  compensated  for 
losses,  while  additional  payments 
encouraged  seeding  coarse  grains  and 
extending  summer  fallow. 

•  The  Agricultural  Prices  Support  Act 
(1944)  created  a  board  to  market 
products  and  provided  subsidies  and 
equalization  payments  for  farmers  during 
the  post-war  transition. 

Worth  Noting 

•  Gardiner  was  the  longest-serving  cabinet 
minister  in  one  portfolio  (22  years). 

•  The  South  Saskatchewan  River  dam, 
built  during  the  Diefenbaker  government 
to  promote  irrigation,  is  named  after 
Gardiner.  The  reservoir  it  created  is 
called  Diefenbaker  Lake. 


47 


M 


Agriculture  and  Agriculture  et 

Agri-Food  Canada      Agroalimentaire  Canada 


Douglas  Scott  Harkness 

June  21,  1957  -  October  10,  1960 


48 


Douglas  Scott 
Harkness 

(1903-) 

Birthplace 

Toronto,  Ontario 

Federal  Constituency 

Calgary  North  (Alberta) 

Education 

University  of  Alberta  (BA); 
University  of  Calgary  (LLD  (Hon.)) 

Professional  Background 

Teacher;  farmer;  lieutenant  colonel  in  Royal 

Canadian  Artillery 

Political  Affiliation 

Conservative 

"He  was  the  only  person  who  could 
make  both  farmers  and  city  folk  mad  in 
the  same  speech.. .He  was  against  all 
forms  of  subsidies  to  farmers  and  you 
don 't  say  that  sort  of  thing  to  farmers. 
Then  he  'd  go  out  and  blast  city  people 
for  trying  to  get  low  prices  for 
agricultural  goods  when  they  already 
had  the  lowest  priced  food  in  the 
world. " 
—  Alvin  Hamilton 


Political  Career 

Harkness  returned  to  Calgary  a  hero  after  the 
Second  World  War,  and  was  quickly  elected 
MP  for  Calgary  North  in  1945.  He  was  a 
popular  local  politician,  re-elected  for  either 
Calgary  North,  East  or  Centre  over  nine 
successive  elections. 

By  June  1957,  western  farmers  were 
unimpressed  with  the  governing  Liberals  and 
blamed  them  for  unsold  grain  stocks  left 
sitting  on  the  Prairies.  After  the  election  that 
month,  John  Diefenbaker's  Conservatives 
formed  a  minority  government  with  a  margin 
of  only  seven  seats.  For  the  first  time, 
Western  Canadians  dominated  in  Ottawa. 
Harkness  became  minister  of  both  northern 
affairs  and  natural  resources,  and  agriculture. 
Two  portfolios  soon  proved  onerous,  and  his 
Saskatchewan  colleague  Alvin  Hamilton  took 
over  the  northern  affairs  and  natural 
resources  portfolio  a  few  months  later. 

In  1958,  Diefenbaker  called  another  election 
and  won  an  unprecedented  53.6  per  cent  of 
the  popular  vote,  taking  208  seats  in  the 
biggest  majority  government  ever.  His 
government  was  popular  with  rural  voters, 
which  made  it  easier  for  Diefenbaker, 
Harkness  and  Hamilton,  chair  of  the  cabinet 
wheat  committee  and  longtime  agriculture 
policy  activist,  to  introduce  and  implement 
an  aggressive  national  agricultural  program 
over  the  next  two  years. 


Harkness  was  effective  but  not  popular  as 
agriculture  minister,  so  Diefenbaker  moved 
Hamilton  into  agriculture  and  switched  Harkness 
to  the  defence  portfolio.  Defence  was  a  difficult 
assignment  in  the  early  1960s  given  the  Cold 
War,  Diefenbaker's  poor  relations  with  the  U.S. 
and  the  recent  cancellation  of  the  Avro  Arrow 
aircraft  project.  Diefenbaker  was  always 
against  nuclear  arms,  but  after  the  Cuban 
missile  crisis  most  Canadians  saw  a  need  for 
nuclear  protection.  When  Diefenbaker  refused 
Harkness'  recommendation  to  arm  Canadian 
missiles  with  nuclear  warheads,  a  leadership 
crisis  emerged  in  cabinet.  Ministers  wavered  in 
their  support  for  Diefenbaker,  and  Harkness 
resigned  from  cabinet  on  February  4,  1963. 

The  Conservatives  were  defeated  in  the 
general  election  of  1963  but  Harkness 
remained  an  MP  until  he  retired  in  1972.  He 
still  lives  in  Calgary. 

Industry  Issues 

Agriculture  was  one  of  the  few  sectors  not  to 
benefit  from  the  post-war  boom.  Despite  the 
Conservatives'  free  enterprise  rhetoric, 
Harkness'  tenure  was  relatively  interventionist. 
Harkness  and  Hamilton  believed  the  long-term 
effects  of  their  policies  would  help  farmers 
adjust  to  changing  market  conditions.  But  faced 
with  increasing  pressure  to  help  farmers  over 
short-term  financial  crises,  the  government 
offered  modest  acreage  payments.  Farmers 
were  not  satisfied  with  this  help,  and  expressed 
their  frustration  to  Minister  Harkness  and  the 
cabinet  wheat  committee  through  petitions  and 
a  march  on  Ottawa  in  March  1959. 


49 


Departmental  Developments 


Accomplishments  as  Minister 


Worth  Noting 


Harkness  reorganized  the  department  and 
reunited  pure  science  with  the  experimental 
farms  in  the  Research  Branch.  Production 
and  marketing  formed  a  second  branch,  and 
administration  (including  economics)  formed 
a  third. 

The  Research  Branch  was  organized 
geographically  into  research  institutes, 
regional  laboratories  and  branch  farms. 
Senior  scientists  co-ordinated  research  on  a 
problem  rather  than  a  discipline  basis. 
Authority  was  decentralized  among  regional 
and  institute  officers  so  headquarters  could 
focus  on  planning  and  development. 
Illustration  stations  were  renamed 
experimental  project  farms  and  consolidated 
in  order  to  better  equip  the  most  important 
facilities. 

The  Department  of  Forestry  was  created  in 
1 960  and  incorporated  the  Forest  Biology 
Division  and  its  10  regional  laboratories. 


The  Prairie  Grain  Advance  Payments  Act 
(1957)  provided  payments  for  harvested 
grain  in  storage  while  the  Canadian 
Wheat  Board  disposed  of  surpluses  from 
the  early  1950s. 

The  Agricultural  Stabilization  Act  (1958) 
established  a  system  of  flexible 
guaranteed  prices  for  key  commodities 
based  on  a  10-year  moving  average 
formula. 

The  Farm  Credit  Act  (1959)  established 
the  Farm  Credit  Corporation  to 
encourage  and  facilitate  new  farm 
investments. 

The  Crop  Insurance  Act  (1959)  allowed 
the  federal  government  to  make  direct 
contributions  to  provinces  that 
established  crop  insurance  schemes. 

The  government  intervened  to  help 
farmers  deal  with  increasing  freight  rates 
and  established  a  royal  commission  on 
rail  transportation  in  1959. 

The  Humane  Slaughter  of  Food  Animals 
Act  (1959)  established  standards  to  guide 
livestock  processing  establishments  in 
dignified  killing  practices. 


Harkness'  principal  when  he  taught  at 
Calgary's  Crescent  Heights  High  School 
in  the  early  1930s  was  William  "Bible 
Bill"  Aberhart,  Alberta's  famous  Social 
Credit  premier. 

Harkness  received  the  George  Medal  in 
the  Second  World  War  for  "courage, 
gallantry  and  devotion  to  duty  of  a  higher 
order"  during  the  Sicilian  campaign. 

Douglas  Harkness  Community  School  in 
Calgary  commemorates  his  accomplish- 
ments. 

Harkness  was  admitted  to  the  Order  of 
Canada  in  1978. 


50 


1+1 


Agriculture  and  Agriculture  et 

Agri-Food  Canada      Agroalimentaire  Canada 


Francis  Alvin  George  Hamilton 

October  11,  I960-  April  22,  1963 


51 


Francis  Alvin  George 
Hamilton 

(1912- ) 

Birthplace 

Kenora,  Ontario 

Federal  Constituency 

Qu'Appelle/Qu'Appelle-Moose  Mountain 
(Saskatchewan) 

Education 

Normal  School,  Saskatoon;  University  of 
Saskatchewan  (BA,  1937,  LLD  (Hon.),  1989) 

Professional  Background 

Teacher;  flight  lieutenant,  Royal  Canadian 
Air  Force;  Chairman,  Resources  and  Industries 
Associates;  partner,  Baker  Trading  Co.; 
mining  investor;  writer/lecturer;  consultant 

Political  Affiliation 

Conservative 

"...probably  the  most  popular  minister 
of  agriculture  in  Canadian  history... a 
true  prairie  radical  and  an  able 
parliamentarian... " 

—  Peter  Newman,  Renegade  in  Power:  The 
Diefenbaker  Years 

"If  you  let  Alvin  loose  in  a  40-acre  field 
with  just  three  cow  pies  in  it,  Alvin 
would  step  in  all  three.  " 

—  John  Diefenbaker 


Political  Career 

In  university,  Hamilton  cut  his  political  teeth 
writing  speeches  for  John  Diefenbaker  and 
organizing  Conservative  election  campaigns. 
Saskatchewan  Tories  were  both  unpopular 
and  disorganized;  Hamilton's  ideas,  papers, 
committee  work  and  speeches  contributed  to 
their  1957  comeback. 

Hamilton  worked  full  time  as  federal 
Conservative  director  in  Saskatchewan  from 
1948  to  1957,  and  although  his  eyes  were  on 
the  federal  arena,  he  was  chosen  provincial 
Conservative  leader  in  1949.  By  1957,  after 
unsuccessfully  contesting  the  1948,  1952  and 
1956  provincial  elections,  he  became 
frustrated  with  provincial  politics  and 
resigned  as  Saskatchewan  leader  to  focus  on 
the  1957  national  campaign. 

After  defeats  in  the  1945,  1949  and  1953 
federal  elections,  he  vowed  that  if  he  did  not 
become  an  MP,  he  would  quit  politics  and 
look  for  a  job.  On  the  strength  of 
Diefenbaker's  national  development  policy, 
Hamilton  was  finally  elected  MP  for 
Qu'Appelle  in  1957.  At  first  he  told 
Diefenbaker  he  did  not  want  a  cabinet 
portfolio,  but  both  his  supporters  and 
Diefenbaker  felt  he  deserved  one  so  he 
became  minister  of  northern  affairs  and 
national  resources  and  chaired  the  cabinet 
wheat  committee  from  August  1957.  In  a 
1960  cabinet  shuffle,  Diefenbaker  turned  the 
agriculture  portfolio  over  to  Hamilton. 
Hamilton  became  ill  and  could  not  actively 


campaign  in  the  1962  election.  The 
Conservatives  won  only  a  minority 
government,  retaining  most  of  their  rural 
ridings  but  losing  the  support  and  confidence 
of  eastern  and  urban  voters.  Many 
Diefenbaker-era  policies  appeared  to  benefit 
only  the  west — for  example,  Hamilton 
solved  the  problem  of  grain  surpluses  but  did 
little  to  overcome  surpluses  of  butter  or  other 
dairy  products.  Voters  were  impatient,  and 
despite  efforts  to  develop  new  policies  in 
support  of  easterners,  the  Conservatives  lost 
the  1963  election. 

Hamilton  resisted  the  pressure  to  return  to 
Saskatchewan  politics  after  1963.  He  became 
opposition  critic  for  agriculture,  finance  and 
energy,  and  chaired  caucus  committees  on 
agriculture  and  policy.  He  also  sat  on  the 
House  committee  on  northern  affairs  and 
natural  resources  and  was  active  in 
international  trade.  Hamilton  also 
unsuccessfully  contested  the  federal 
Conservative  leadership  in  1967. 

Hamilton  lost  his  seat  in  the  1968  federal 
election,  but  returned  as  MP  for  Qu'Appelle- 
Moose  Mountain  in  1972.  He  held  the  seat 
for  the  next  16  years.  After  the  Conservatives 
won  the  1984  election,  he  served  as  a  policy 
advisor  to  the  Mulroney  government. 

Hamilton  retired  from  federal  politics  in 
1988  and  lives  in  Manotick,  Ontario. 


52 


Departmental  Developments 

Hamilton  took  a  hands-off  approach  to  the 
department,  leaving  administration  to  his 
deputy  and  focusing  on  trade  and 
development. 

He  transferred  the  Canadian  Wheat  Board 
from  the  trade  and  commerce  portfolio  to 
agriculture  because  he  felt  that  to  solve 
farmers'  cash  flow  problems,  he  needed 
control  over  grain  sales.  The  Board  of  Grain 
Commissioners  also  came  under  his  authority 
after  1960. 

In  1962,  the  Health  of  Animals  Division  split 
from  the  Production  and  Marketing  Branch. 
Hamilton  also  established  the  Food  Research 
Institute,  combining  three  related  institutes 
into  one  to  study  food  quality  and  consumer 
acceptance,  storage  and  processing. 


Accomplishments  as  Minister 

At  the  height  of  the  Cold  War,  Hamilton  sold 
Canada's  surplus  grain  to  communist  China. 
Beijing  had  a  food  shortage  and  started 
buying  Canadian  wheat  in  1958.  Under  a 
I960  agreement,  over  $422  million  worth  of 
wheat  and  barley  was  sent  to  China  over  two 
and  a  half  years. 

The  trade  and  diplomatic  negotiations  were 
controversial.  Cabinet  almost  didn't  approve 
the  credit  arrangements.  Americans  opposed 
trading  with  "enemy  communists". 
Commonwealth  loyalists  opposed  China's 
aggression  towards  India.  And  textile 
manufacturers  feared  lost  market  share  if 
reciprocal  Chinese  goods  entered  Canada. 
However,  these  sales  restored  western 
agricultural  prosperity — the  average  farm 
income  tripled — and  created  a  lasting  legacy 
for  the  Conservative  party  across  the  Prairies. 
Today,  grain  sales  to  China  are  worth  $750 
million. 

Hamilton  helped  establish  the  United 
Nations'  World  Food  Program  and  the 
Agricultural  Economic  Research  Council,  a 
joint  industry-government  agency  dedicated 
to  independent  policy  evaluation  and 
research  in  agricultural  economics  and  rural 
sociology. 


His  final  legacy  was  the  Agricultural 
Rehabilitation  and  Development  Act 
(ARDA)  of  1961.  This  legislation  made  it 
easier  for  joint  federal-provincial  programs 
to  help  farmers  operating  small  or 
unprofitable  farms  pursue  alternate  land  use 
or  employment,  to  promote  soil  and  water 
conservation,  and  to  fund  research  and  rural 
development  projects. 

Worth  Noting 

•  Hamilton  won  the  Burma  Star  Decoration 
for  his  service  in  the  Second  World  War. 

•  In  1987,  Parliament  recognized  Hamilton 
for  his  30'h  anniversary  as  a  MP.  John 
Turner  toasted  and  roasted  his  career, 
concluding,  "The  farmers  of  this  country 
will  always  remember  him  as  a 
spectacularly  successful  minister.. .The 
only  weakness  in  judgement  he  has  ever 
shown  is  having  hired  Brian  Mulroney." 
(Mulroney  worked  on  Hamilton's  1962 
campaign.) 


53 


1+1 


Agriculture  and  Agriculture  et 

Agri-Food  Canada      Agroalimentaire  Canada 


Harry  William  Hays 

April  22,  1963  -  December  17,  1965 


54 


Harry  William  Hays 

(1909-1982) 

Birthplace 

Carstairs,  Alberta 

Federal  Constituency 

Calgary  South  (Alberta) 

Education 

St.  Mary's  High  School,  Calgary 

Professional  Background 

Auctioneer,  cattle  exporter,  rancher/farmer 
and  Holstein  breeder;  president  of  Canadian 
Swine  Breeders  during  the  wartime  "Bacon 
for  Britain"  campaign;  founding  member/ 
president.  Alberta  Poultry  Breeders' 
Association;  president,  Alberta  Holstein 
Breeders'  Association;  chairman,  Calgary 
Board  of  Trade  agricultural  bureau;  radio 
broadcaster 

Political  Affiliation 

Liberal 

"I  don 't  want  to  present  myself  as 
a  country  bumpkin  or  a  hayseed, 
whatever  political  advantages  that  folksy 
image  may  have  seemed  to  have... 
I  don 't  believe  you  have  to  pose  as  a 
country  cousin  with  barnyard  on  your 
overalls...  to  do  a  decent  job  as  minister 
of  agriculture. " 
—  Harry  Hays 


'Wo  minister  seems  more  inept  inside 
Parliament  and  few  get  so  much  done 
outside  it. " 
—  Walter  Stewart,  Toronto  Star  Weekly,  1965 

Political  Career 

When  Harry  Hays  sold  his  dairy  herd  and 
became  mayor  of  Calgary  in  1959  he  said  he 
had  "made  his  fortune  as  a  rancher  and 
dairyman  and  needed  something  to  do  in 
retirement." 

Hays  admired  Lester  Pearson  and  was 
offered  the  chance  to  develop  Liberal 
agriculture  policy  if  he  ran  in  the  1963 
election.  He  became  the  only  Liberal  elected 
in  Alberta  or  Saskatchewan  that  year.  After 
he  was  appointed  minister  of  agriculture,  his 
frequent  absences  in  Parliament  were 
controversial — his  time  was  precious  as  he 
continued  to  serve  briefly  as  Calgarj  's 
mayor,  travelled  as  Rotary  Club  district 
governor  and  refused  to  stop  auctioneering. 

Hays  was  a  colourful  politician,  using  poor 
grammar  and  swearing,  then  telling  reporters 
who  smoothed  the  "roughage"  from  his 
quotes  that  he  was  misquoted.  Hays  once 
described  his  goal:  "We  want  a  flush-toilet, 
not  an  outhouse,  farm  economy  for  Canada". 
He  was  popular  in  caucus,  and  would  often 
invite  rural  backbenchers  to  review  draft 
legislation  and  offer  opinions.  But  he  found 
Ottawa's  slow  pace  "a  burr  under  my 
saddle".  He  antagonized  farmers'  organizations 
by  shooting  down  proposals  he  didn't  like. 


He  thought  Canada  was  behind  other 
countries  in  establishing  prices  to  ensure  a 
strong  industry  and  said  subsidies  led  to 
surpluses.  He  advocated  a  minimum  farm 
income  and  a  comprehensive  marketing 
system  for  farmers. 

In  1965,  Hays  was  defeated  as  an  MP. 
Albertans  were  unimpressed  with  Liberal 
policies  on  medicare,  pensions  and  the  new 
Canadian  flag.  Hays  was  appointed  to  the 
Senate  in  1966  and  continued  to  develop 
agriculture  policy  as  member  of  the  Senate 
agriculture  committee. 

Hays  also  co-chaired  the  special  joint 
committee  of  the  Senate  and  the  House  of 
Commons  on  the  Constitution  in  1980,  and 
played  a  key  role  in  developing  the  Charter 
of  Rights  and  convincing  his  fellow  senators 
to  dilute  their  power  to  veto  legislation.  He 
died  following  heart  surgery  in  1982. 

Departmental  Developments 

•  Trade  Minister  Mitchell  Sharp  oversaw 
the  Canadian  Wheat  Board  during  Hays' 
tenure. 

•  Computers  were  used  to  process  milk 
production  records  after  1963. 

•  In  1 964,  the  Economics  Division  became  a 
branch,  responsible  for  marketing  and  trade. 

•  Some  experimental  stations  were  closed  and 
consolidated  to  improve  research  efficiency. 


55 


Accomplishments  as  Minister 

After  successful  imports  of  Charolais  cattle 
from  the  United  States  in  1951,  Hays 
responded  to  farmers'  demands  for  quality 
exotic  breeds  and  developed  a  European 
importation  plan.  One  hundred  and  thirteen 
Charolais  cattle  were  imported  directly  into 
Canada  from  Europe  in  1965,  subject  to  strict 
quarantines  and  inspections.  Simmental, 
Limousin,  Main  Anjou  and  Brown  Swiss 
imports  followed. 

In  return,  Hays  established  Canada's 
showcase  herds  of  dairy  and  beef  breeds.  The 
herds  were  kept  on  experimental  farms;  the 
Production  and  Marketing  Branch  managed 
and  funded  their  activities.  In  1965,  a 
travelling  exhibit  of  Canadian  Holsteins  was 
flown  to  France  for  a  two-month  tour  of 
agricultural  shows  to  promote  two-way  trade. 
Similar  European  and  North  American  tours 
were  organized  in  subsequent  years. 

Hays'  Dairy  Commission  Act  (1966)  created 
a  regulatory  agency  to  purchase,  process, 
ship,  store  and  dispose  of  product;  make 
payments  to  stabilize  prices;  investigate 
production,  processing  and  marketing;  and 
promote  the  use  of  dairy  products  and 
improvements  in  their  quality  and  variety. 
However,  Hays  believed  farmers  needed  to 
expand  and  diversify  because  "price  alone 
cannot  correct  the  economic  difficulties 
of.. .small  producers". 


The  Farm  Machinery  Syndicate  Credit  Act 
(1964)  offered  groups  of  farmers  loans  to 
purchase  machinery  on  a  co-operative  basis 
and  expanded  the  size  of  loans  available. 

The  federal  government  revised  its  support 
for  farm  fairs  and  exhibitions  in  1965  and 
created  controversial  new  product 
classifications  emphasizing  utility  over 
appearances. 

Hays  also  established  the  Veterinary  College 
at  Saskatoon,  expanded  the  crop  insurance 
system  and  originated  a  national  farm 
accounting  system. 

Worth  Noting 

•  Hays  introduced  cattle  exports  by  air, 
shipped  purebred  cattle  to  the  United 
Kingdom  and  Mexico  for  the  first  time, 
and  opened  new  markets  as  North  America's 
biggest  livestock  exporter  in  the  1950s.  He 
once  had  Canada's  largest  Holstein  herd 
and  held  numerous  world  records. 

•  He  also  developed  Hays  Converter  beef 
cattle,  the  first  new  breed  recognized  for 
registry  in  Canada. 

•  Hays  regretted  his  lack  of  formal 
education  and  dreamed  of  running  the 
experimental  farm  at  Lethbridge.  When 
he  became  minister,  his  wife  joked  that 
he  now  ran  all  38. 


•  Douglas  Harkness  (also  from  Calgary) 
was  a  good  friend  of  Hays.  But  Alvin 
Hamilton  was  a  bitter  political  opponent. 
Hamilton's  image,  according  to  Hays, 
was  inflated  "to  the  dimensions  of  a 
latter-day  saint  of  the  back  forty".  Hays 
once  challenged  Hamilton  to  go  to  the 
Central  Experimental  Farm  to  prove  he 
could  milk  cows — but  the  milking 
contest  never  occurred,  much  to  the 
media's  chagrin. 

•  Calgary's  federal  building  on  Fourth 
Avenue  SE  is  named  after  Hays. 

•  Hays'  son  Dan  is  currently  a  Liberal 
senator  for  Alberta. 


56 


■*l 


Agriculture  and  Agriculture  et 

Agri-Food  Canada      Agroalimentaire  Canada 


John  J.  Greene 

December  18,  1965  -  July  5,  1968 


57 


John  J.  Greene 

(1920-1978) 

Birthplace 

Toronto,  Ontario 

Federal  Constituencies 

Renfrew  South,  Niagara  Falls  (Ontario) 

Education 

University  of  Toronto  (BA,  1948),  Osgoode 
Hall  (LLB,  1950) 

Professional  Background 

Northern  Ontario  mine  worker;  flight 
lieutenant,  Royal  Canadian  Air  Force  (1941- 
45);  established  law  firm  in  Arnprior,  Ontario 
in  1949 

Political  Affiliation 

Liberal 


I  find  it  hard  not  to  go  like  hell.  If  I 
can 't  do  it,  I'll  just  have  to  quit. 
—  J.  J.  Greene,  speaking  about  his  1969 
heart  attack 


Political  Career 

Although  his  upbringing  in  Toronto  was  very 
different  from  a  farm  lifestyle,  Greene  was 
once  described  in  the  Toronto  Star  as  "folksy, 
friendly  and  successful... easy-going  and 
rustic. ..one  of  the  best  stump  politicians  in 
the  Commons".  As  one  of  Canada's  few  non- 
farmer  ministers  of  agriculture,  Greene  used 
his  experience  in  small-town  and  county 
politics  in  Arnprior  and  Renfrew  County  to 
gain  an  understanding  of  rural  communities. 

Greene  unsuccessfully  contested  the  Ontario 
Liberal  leadership  in  1959.  He  was  elected 
MP  for  Renfrew  South  in  1963.  After  his  re- 
election in  1965,  Greene  became  Lester 
Pearson's  minister  of  agriculture — the  first 
easterner  in  54  years  to  hold  the  post.  He  was 
criticized  for  being  an  urban  lawyer  who 
knew  nothing  about  agriculture  and  had 
simply  lobbied  harder  than  anyone  else  for 
the  job. 


In  1968,  Greene  contested  the  federal  Liberal 
leadership,  delivering  an  inspiring  speech  on 
national  unity  and  making  it  to  the  third 
ballot  before  supporting  Pierre  Trudeau. 
Later  that  year  he  was  re-elected  as  MP  for  a 
new  constituency,  Niagara  Falls,  and 
appointed  minister  of  energy,  mines  and 
resources  in  Trudeau's  first  cabinet.  As 
energy  minister,  he  prevented  the  sale  of  the 
largest  oil  company  under  Canadian  control 
and  Canada's  largest  uranium  producer  to 
American  interests. 

Greene  suffered  a  heart  attack  in  1969.  In 
1971,  he  suffered  a  stroke  while  attending  a 
nuclear  conference  in  Japan.  He  retired  from 
cabinet  in  January  1972  and  was  called  to  the 
Senate  in  September  1972.  Greene  never 
stopped  working  for  Canadians.  He  was  still 
participating  in  Senate  debates  the  week 
before  he  died  in  Ottawa  in  1978. 


58 


Departmental  Developments 

•  In  1 966,  the  Board  of  Grain  Commissioners 
computerized  the  warehouse  receipts  and 
accounting  documents  of  Canadian 
government  elevators. 

•  During  Canada's  Centennial  in  1967,  the 
department  produced  several  special 
publications  to  document  the  history  of 
the  department  and  of  Canada's 
agriculture  industry.  Higher  than  average 
numbers  of  visitors  were  noted  at 
experimental  farm  establishments  and  the 
agriculture  museum  throughout  1967. 

•  The  Sir  John  Carling  building  opened  in 
Ottawa  in  1967.  For  the  first  time, 
administrators  from  different  department 
divisions  and  branches  were  brought 
together  at  an  administrative  headquarters 
on  the  Central  Experimental  Farm. 

•  In  addition  to  assisting  the  nine  original 
commodities  it  was  designed  to  help,  the 
Agricultural  Stabilization  Board  provided 
subsidies  for  sugar  beets,  potatoes,  and 
milk  and  cream  for  manufacturing. 

•  Departmental  research  started  to  place 
more  emphasis  on  livestock  and 
agricultural  engineering. 

•  The  Canadian  Livestock  Feed  Board, 
created  under  the  jurisdiction  of  the 
minister  of  forestry  in  1966,  was 
transferred  to  Greene's  portfolio  in  1968. 


Accomplishments  as  Minister 

Under  Greene's  leadership,  five  prominent 
agricultural  economists  were  appointed  to  the 
1967  Task  Force  on  Agricultural  Policy  to 
make  recommendations  to  the  minister  on 
how  best  to  ensure  farmers'  income  and 
welfare.  The  task  force  commissioned  12 
studies  on  current  agriculture  issues. 

In  1965,  the  Economics  Branch  began  a 
long-term  appraisal  of  Canadian  agriculture, 
researching  projected  supply  and  demand 
figures  for  commodities  and  anticipating  the 
market  behaviour  of  producers  and 
consumers.  These  studies  considered  the 
implementation  of  marketing  boards  for  a 
variety  of  Canadian  commodities  and  paved 
the  way  for  future  marketing  legislation. 

Amendments  to  the  Crop  Insurance  Act  in 
1966  made  insurance  available  to  more 
farmers  and  reduced  the  costs  of  farmer 
participation  by  increasing  federal 
contributions.  The  program  was  also 
extended  to  cover  production  units  such  as 
fruit  trees,  berry  plants  and  forage  stands,  as 
well  as  the  costs  of  preparing  summer  fallow 
should  seeding  be  impossible  the  following 
spring  due  to  excess  moisture.  Greenes 
amendments  worked:  the  1968-69 
departmental  annual  report  notes  a  93-per- 
cent increase  in  the  number  of  farmers 
participating  in  provincial  insurance  schemes 
over  the  previous  year. 


Greene  was  elected  chairman  of  the  World 
Food  Program  Pledging  Conference  at  the 
United  Nations  in  1966  and  led  the  Canadian 
delegation  to  the  Food  and  Agricultural 
Organization  Conference  in  Rome  in  1967. 

Worth  Noting 

•     Greene  won  the  Distinguished  Flying 
Cross  for  his  service  in  the  Second 
World  War. 


59 


M 


Agriculture  and  Agriculture  et 

Agri-Food  Canada      Agroalimentaire  Canada 


Horace  Andrew  (Bud)  Olson 

July  6,  1968  -  November  26,  1972 


60 


Horace  Andrew  (Bud) 
Olson 

(1925- ) 

Birthplace 

Iddesleigh,  Alberta 

Federal  Constituency 

Medicine  Hat  (Alberta) 

Education 

Medicine  Hat  High  School 

Professional  Background 

Rancher/wheat  farmer;  general  store 
merchant  and  owner  of  farm  supply  business; 
member  of  Farmers'  Union  of  Canada  and 
Western  Stock  Growers'  Association  until 
elected  to  Parliament;  member  of  Economic 
Council  of  Canada  (1975-79) 

Political  Affiliation 

Social  Credit  (until  1967),  Liberal 

"A  man  of  great  civility  and  intelligence. " 

—  Jean  Chretien,  speaking  about  Olson  on 
his  appointment  as  lieutenant-governor  of 
Alberta,  1996 

"Farmers  regarded  the  minister  and  the 
Department  of  Agriculture  as  their 
champion  of  everything  and  if  you're  a 
good  politician  you  'd  better  accept 
that's  the  vision  they  have  of  you  and  do 
something  useful  for  them...  " 

—  Bud  Olson 


Political  Career 

Olson  became  a  Social  Credit  MP  for 
Medicine  Hat  in  1957.  Although  he  was 
defeated  in  the  1958  election,  he  won  the 
seat  again  in  1962  and  was  re-elected  in 
1963  and  1965.  By  1967,  the  federal  Social 
Credit  party  was  disintegrating.  Though 
many  of  Olson's  colleagues  switched  to  the 
Conservatives,  former  Liberal  agriculture 
minister  Harry  Hays  helped  persuade  him  to 
sit  as  a  Liberal  MP.  Always  the  pragmatist, 
Olson  decided  his  chances  of  making  a 
difference  with  the  Liberals,  who  had  no 
seats  in  Alberta  at  the  time,  were  greater  than 
with  the  Conservatives,  who  dominated 
western  Canadian  seats. 

Olson  supported  Pierre  Trudeau's  Liberal 
leadership  campaign  and  was  appointed 
minister  of  agriculture  after  winning  his  first 
election  as  a  Liberal  in  1968.  But  in  the  early 
1970s,  federal  Liberal  policies  were 
unpopular  in  Alberta.  (Trudeau  even  asked 
struggling  western  farmers  "Why  should  I 
sell  your  wheat?")  Olson  was  defeated  in  the 
1972  and  1974  elections. 

In  1977,  Olson  was  called  to  the  Senate.  He 
served  as  opposition  House  leader  in  1979 
and  government  leader  from  1982  to  1984. 
Olson's  favourite  cabinet  portfolio  was  one 
he  held  as  a  senator — minister  of  economic 
and  regional  development  from  1980  to 
1984.  As  one  of  Trudeau's  most  powerful 
ministers,  he  chaired  the  cabinet  committee 
on  economic  development  from  1980  to 


1983.  He  was  also  the  minister  responsible 
for  the  Northern  Pipeline  Agency  from  1980 
to  1984.  "Selling"  the  National  Energy 
Policy  in  his  home  province  was  a  major 
political  challenge,  but  he  tried  to  work  with 
oil  company  representatives  on  regulatory 
reforms.  A  1982  Maclean's  article  described 
him  as  "low-key,  affable,  unflappable  and 
shrewd  as  a  fox". 

Olson  became  Alberta's  14,h  lieutenant- 
governor  in  April  1996.  Some  considered  the 
appointment  controversial,  but  Olson  said, 
"If  you  want  someone  to  do  this  well,  get  a 
politician". 

Industry  Issues 

In  1969,  a  special  task  force  studied  the 
challenges  and  conditions  facing  farmers  and 
processors  and  released  a  report  called 
Canadian  Agriculture  in  the  Seventies. 
Overproduction  was  a  chronic  problem  with 
many  commodities,  and  marketing  systems 
were  a  top  priority  for  policy  development. 
Olson  reflects  that  his  role  "was  a  selling  job 
all  the  time.  We  had  great  surpluses  of  wheat, 
pork  in  storage,  a  mountain  of  skim  milk 
powder... and  we  had  to  get  out  in  the 
international  market  and  sell  it.  And  that  was 
not  easy.. .other  countries  also  had  surpluses 
and  we  had  to  try  to  get  a  decent  price". 


61 


Departmental  Developments 

Popular  ideology  suggested  a  "food  systems" 
approach  would  be  appropriate  for  planning 
and  co-ordinating  government  activities.  In 
1972,  the  Food  Systems  Branch  was  created 
to  "review,  evaluate  and  monitor  federal 
government  food  programs  as  they  related  to 
the  production  and  marketing  of  agricultural 
products".  These  changes  introduced  a 
market-oriented  approach  to  commodity 
management  that  included  not  only  primary 
producers  but  also  processors,  distributors, 
retailers  and  consumers.  The  new  approach 
was  controversial  among  some  farm 
organizations,  who  feared  a  loss  of  control 
over  agricultural  policies. 

The  department  was  actively  involved  in 
implementing  programs  to  curtail 
overproduction,  particularly  in  grains.  A 
grassland  incentive  program  was  introduced 
and  research  branch  scientists  sought  ways  to 
encourage  grain  farmers  to  seed  their  poorer 
land  to  permanent  grass.  Scientists  also  tried 
to  find  new  uses  for  surplus  cereals  and 
identify  innovative  new  crops  that  could  be 
marketed  to  both  Canadian  and  world 
markets. 


The  size  and  scope  of  government  activities 
were  restricted  for  the  first  time.  Some 
research  stations  were  closed  to  reduce 
overhead  costs.  For  example,  in  1971  the 
Institute  for  Biological  Control  in  Belleville 
closed  and  many  employees  moved  to 
Winnipeg  or  Regina. 

Some  research  was  contracted  out  to 
universities  or  the  private  sector.  This 
stimulated  private  sector  employment  and 
innovation  in  areas  where  the  department 
lacked  sufficient  resources.  Contracts  were 
awarded  for  solutions  to  specific  problems, 
which  ensured  results  could  be  quickly  and 
effectively  used  in  the  economy. 


Accomplishments  as  Minister 

•  Olson  oversaw  the  early  and 
controversial  steps  towards  supply 
management,  including  enabling 
legislation  for  marketing  boards  for 
turkey  and  chicken.  "I  tried  to  persuade 
farmers  that  their  job  was  to  participate 
in  marketing  and  not  expect  someone 
else  to  do  it  for  them,"  says  Olson. 
"Others  would  only  be  interested  in 
margins.  Farmers  needed  to  be  active  to 
get  a  good  price." 

•  The  LIFT  (Lower  Inventories  for 
Tomorrow)  program  was  introduced  to 
curtail  western  wheat  production  and 
reduce  grain  surpluses. 

•  The  department  revised  the  Canada 
Grains  Act  for  the  first  time  in  30  years. 

•  It  also  introduced  the  Small  Farms 
Development  Program,  which  would  both 
help  struggling  producers  and  also  offer 
other  options  to  those  who  wanted  to  quit 
farming. 


62 


1+1 


Agriculture  and  Agriculture  et 

Agri-Food  Canada       Agroalimentaire  Canada 


Eugene  Francis  Whelan 

November  27,  1972  -  June  3,  1979 
and  March  3,  1980  -  June  29,  1984 


/'* 


/  <      Canada 

•    '        /       i   ■' 


63 


Eugene  Francis 
Whelan 

(1924- ) 

Birthplace 

Amherstburg,  Ontario 

Federal  Constituency 

Essex  South/Essex-Windsor  (Ontario) 

Education 

Walkerville  Vocational  and  Technical  School, 
University  of  Windsor  (LLD  (Hon.)  1983) 

Professional  Background 

Mixed  farmer,  trained  as  a  tool  and  die 
maker;  director  and  president  of  Harrow 
Farmers  Co-op;  director  of  United  Co- 
operatives of  Ontario,  Co-operators 
Insurance  Co.,  Ontario  Winter  Wheat 
Producers  Marketing  Board;  president  of 
Essex  County  branch,  board  member  of 
Ontario  Federation  of  Agriculture 

Political  Affiliation 

Liberal 

"Paper  doesn  'tfeed  cows  and  it  doesn  't 
feed  people. " 
—  Eugene  Whelan 


Political  Career 

Whelan  learned  about  grassroots  democracy 
from  his  experiences  in  municipal  politics, 
working  his  way  from  the  local  separate 
school  board  in  1 945  to  township  council 
and  the  Essex  County  road  committee  in  the 
1950s  and  eventually  serving  as  warden  of 
Essex  County  in  1962.  After  an  early  defeat 
in  the  provincial  election  of  1959,  he  was 
elected  MP  for  Essex  South  in  the  general 
election  of  1962  and  held  the  seat  until  he 
retired  from  politics. 

Agriculture  and  resource  issues  were 
Whelan's  consistent  focus  as  an  MP;  he 
became  involved  in  politics  because  "he 
wanted  farmers  to  have  a  bigger  say".  He 
chaired  the  House  of  Commons'  agriculture 
committee  (1965-68)  and  served  as 
parliamentary  secretary  to  the  minister  of 
fisheries  and  forestry  (1968-70).  After  the 
1972  election  he  was  appointed  minister  of 
agriculture,  a  post  he  held  for  the  next  12 
years,  except  for  the  nine-month  tenure  of 
Joe  Clark's  Conservative  government  in 
1979-80. 

Whelan  took  a  particular  interest  in 
international  parliamentary  and  agriculture 
organizations,  representing  Canada  at  the 
founding  conference  of  the  United  Nations 
World  Food  Council  ( 1 974)  and  serving  as 
its  president  (1983-85).  As  both  a  minister 
and  an  MP,  he  was  active  in  foreign  aid  and 


agricultural  development  issues  and 
participated  in  several  trade  missions  and  in 
conferences  of  the  Organization  for  Economic 
Co-operation  and  Development  (OECD)  and 
the  Food  and  Agriculture  Organization 
(FAO)  of  the  United  Nations. 

Whelan  ran  unsuccessfully  for  the  Liberal 
leadership  in  June  1984.  He  decided  not  to 
contest  the  1984  election  and  became  an 
agriculture  and  agri-food  policy  consultant, 
continuing  his  involvement  in  international 
agriculture  issues.  On  his  retirement  in  July 
1984,  he  was  appointed  the  first  Canadian 
ambassador  and  permanent  representative  to 
the  FAO  in  Rome.  His  appointment  was 
cancelled  by  the  Conservatives  that  October 
because  they  felt  it  was  an  example  of 
Liberal  patronage.  He  accepted  a  Senate 
appointment  in  August  1996. 

Industry  Issues 

Whelan's  government  introduced  food  price 
controls  to  offset  inflation.  Even  though  the 
Food  Prices  Review  Board  blamed  marketing 
boards  and  not  supermarkets  for  high  prices, 
Whelan  championed  farmers'  rights  to  good 
prices.  He  saw  their  problems  as,  not 
overproduction,  but  producing  the  wrong 
things  for  the  wrong  market. 


64 


Departmental  Developments 


Accomplishments  as  Minister 


Worth  Noting 


By  1977,  the  food  systems  approach  had 
permeated  management  across  the 
department.  The  Food  Systems  Branch  was 
absorbed  into  the  Regional  Development 
Branch.  The  other  five  branches  were  also 
realigned  to  promote  a  "food  policy" 
orientation.  A  further  reorganization  in  1978 
created  the  Policy,  Planning  and  Evaluation 
Branch  as  a  liaison  between  domestic  and 
international  development  issues.  More  and 
more,  the  department's  work  overlapped  with 
food  policy  work  in  other  departments,  and 
Whelan  worked  to  establish  collaborative 
policies. 

Whelan's  commitment  to  international 
agriculture  and  his  strong  personal  concern 
about  the  potential  famine  conditions  in 
Africa  led  to  increased  departmental 
participation  in  many  CIDA-approved 
agricultural  research  and  development 
projects. 

Whelan  spent  a  lot  of  time  in  direct  contact 
with  departmental  staff  and  is  still 
remembered  as  one  of  the  most  popular  and 
respected  ministers.  Whelan  says.  "When  I 
arrived  in  1972  I  was  handed  one  of  the 
finest  outfits  in  the  government...  Since 
Confederation,  Agriculture  had  been  the 
most  decentralized  department  of 
government...  we  were  doing  it  before 
anyone  was  talking  about  it". 


Whelan  was  committed  to  supply 
management  and  marketing  boards, 
particularly  for  the  dairy  industry.  He 
proclaimed  the  Canadian  Egg  Marketing 
Agency  in  1973  and  the  National  Turkey 
Marketing  Agency  in  1974  and  created 
the  National  Chicken  Broiler  Agency  in 
1976.  He  was  unsuccessful  in  achieving 
marketing  boards  for  other  commodities. 

The  New  Crop  Development  Fund 
( 1973)  helped  develop  new  crops  and 
varieties. 

A  domestic  feed  grain  policy  ( 1974, 
1976)  co-ordinated  the  transportation  and 
stocks  of  feed  grains  for  domestic  and 
export  markets.  Additional  feed  storage 
programs  in  1977  increased  the 
production  and  efficiency  of  the  livestock 
feed  industry. 

Whelan  wanted  to  establish  a  farmers' 
bank.  Although  he  didn't  achieve  this 
goal,  amendments  to  the  Farm  Credit  Act 
( 1975,  1978)  raised  the  ceiling  for 
borrowing. 

The  Advance  Payments  for  Crops  Act 
( 1977)  guaranteed  loans  to  producers 
requiring  advance  payments  for 
perishable  crops. 

Whelan  worked  with  farm  organizations 
to  create  CANAGREX,  the  Canadian 
Agricultural  Export  Corporation,  as  a 
federal  Crown  corporation  in  1983. 


Whelan  was  one  of  Pierre  Trudeau's  best 
constitutional  campaigners.  But  in  1976, 
angry  Quebec  dairy  farmers  threw  diluted 
milk  on  Whelan  after  cabinet  refused  to 
approve  dairy  subsidies  to  compensate 
farmers  in  a  collapsed  world  market. 
Whelan  says  this  refusal  helped  elect  the 
Parti  Quebecois  in  rural  ridings  that  fall 
(half  of  Canada's  dairy  farmers  are  from 
Quebec). 

Mikhail  Gorbachev,  as  Minister  of 
Agriculture  for  the  USSR,  visited  Canada 
at  Whelan's  invitation  in  1983  —  his 
only  major  trip  to  a  western  country 
before  becoming  General  Secretary  of  the 
Communist  party. 

Whelan,  "The  Great  Canadian  Farmer", 
was  made  an  officer  of  the  Order  of 
Canada  in  1987. 

The  Hon.  Eugene  F  Whelan  Experimental 
Farm  near  Woodslee,  part  of  the  Harrow 
Research  Station,  recognizes  his 
contributions. 

Whelan's  daughter  Susan  is  now  MP 
for  Essex. 


65 


M 


Agriculture  and  Agriculture  et 

Agri-Food  Canada      Agroalimentaire  Canada 


John  Wise 

June  4,  1979  -  March  2,  1980 

and  September  17,  1984  -  September  14,  1988 


66 


John  Wise 

(1935-  ) 

Birthplace 

St.  Thomas,  Ontario 

Federal  Constituency 

Elgin  (Ontario) 

Education 

University  of  Guelph  ( 1956) 

Professional  Background 

Fifth-generation  dairy  farmer;  president  o\' 
Elgin  Jersey  Breeders;  director  and  president, 
Oxford  and  District  Cattle  Breeders 
Association  (now  Western  Ontario  Breeders); 
dairy  cattle  judge;  chairman  of  Elgin  and  St. 
Thomas  Planning  Boards;  director  of  Elgin 
Co-operative  Services 

Political  Affiliation 

Conservative 


"In  this  job,  the  roof  usually  fell  in  on 
you  every  day.  You  're  dealing  with 
Mother  Nature  and  you  never  know 
what  to  expect. " 

—  John  Wise,  quoted  in  The  Globe  and  Mail 
in  1988 


Political  Career 

Wise  was  active  in  farm  organizations  and  in 
municipal  politics  and  planning  for  more 
than  15  years  before  his  election  to 
Parliament.  He  served  as  councillor,  deputy 
reeve  and  reeve  of  Yarmouth  Township 
through  the  1960s  and  became  warden  of 
Elgin  County  in  1969.  Three  years  later,  he 
was  elected  MP  for  Elgin,  a  seat  he  held 
through  five  consecutive  elections  until 
1988,  when  he  did  not  run. 

Based  on  his  experience,  Wise  was  a  natural 
fit  for  the  roles  of  opposition  dairy  and 
agriculture  critic  through  the  1970s.  He  also 
served  as  critic  for  supply  and  services 
( 1983-84).  He  developed  Conservative 
agriculture  platforms  and  policies  and 
chaired  his  caucus'  agriculture  committee  in 
1976.  When  Joe  Clark's  Conservatives  won 
the  1979  election  and  formed  a  minority 
government  for  nine  months,  he  was 
appointed  minister  of  agriculture.  Four  years 
later,  he  became  one  of  the  few  Clark-era 
cabinet  ministers  to  retain  the  same  portfolio 
in  Brian  Mulroney's  majority  government. 

Wise  held  the  agriculture  portfolio  through 
the  first  term  of  the  Mulroney  government 
but  decided  to  retire  from  politics  before  the 
1988  election.  He  remains  active  in 
agriculture  issues  and  currently  serves  as  a 
board  member  for  Amtelcom  and  chairman 
of  the  board  for  the  Canadian  Livestock 


Exporters  Association  and  the  Canadian 
Embryo  Exporters  Association.  He  sold  his 
dairy  herd  when  he  was  elected  to 
Parliament,  but  he  still  lives  on  his  farm  near 
St.Thomas,  Ontario. 

Industry  Issues 

When  Wise  began  his  second  term  in  1984, 
the  industry  was  experiencing  some  of  its 
worst  financial  conditions  since  the  1930s. 
Record  high  interest  rates  and  low  market 
prices,  in  combination  with  a  trade  war  over 
grains  between  the  European  Community 
and  the  United  States,  brought  unprecedented 
challenges  to  the  farm  community.  Record 
levels  of  government  compensation  for 
droughts,  floods  and  poor  harvest 
conditions — particularly  the  Special 
Canadian  Grains  payments  in  1986  and 
1987 — were  responses  to  the  industry's  cries 
for  help.  Wise  also  had  the  challenge  of 
protecting  the  principles  of  supply 
management  while  introducing  his 
government's  free  trade  policies  to  the 
agriculture  industry. 


67 


Departmental  Developments 

In  1979,  the  Health  of  Animals  Branch 
became  part  of  the  Food  Production  and 
Inspection  Branch  in  a  reorganization 
designed  to  strengthen  the  regional 
development  and  marketing  activities  of  the 
department.  Decentralized  plant  and  animal 
inspection  activities  were  integrated  with 
some  of  the  plant  and  animal  production, 
quarantine  and  racetrack  supervision 
activities. 

The  same  reorganization  formed  the 
Regional  Development  and  International 
Affairs  Branch,  amalgamating 
intergovernmental  and  international  services 
with  farm  development,  some  animal  and 
crop  production  activities,  and  the 
Agricultural  Development  Directorate  of  the 
Policy,  Planning  and  Economics  Branch.  A 
director  of  regional  development  was 
appointed  in  each  province. 

The  Marketing  and  Economics  Branch  was 
created  to  increase  trade  promotion  as  part  of 
a  government-wide  priority  to  increase 
international  trade. 


Accomplishments  as  Minister 

The  department's  budget  increased  from 
$1  billion  to  $4  billion  during  Wise's  tenure. 
He  reflects  that  "we  invested  a  lot  of  money". 

•  The  Farm  Debt  Review  Act  (1986) 
established  farm  debt  review  boards  in 
every  province  to  help  farmers  and 
facilitate  financial  arrangements  with 
creditors  in  times  of  crisis. 

•  Wise  amended  the  Farm  Credit  Act  and 
increased  assistance  for  farmers 
borrowing  through  the  Farm  Credit 
Corporation  by  increasing  the 
corporation's  funding  and  accessibility. 
New  programs  also  reduced  farm  interest 
rates,  shared  mortgage  risks  and  offered 
commodity-based  loans. 

•  Amendments  to  the  Agricultural 
Stabilization  Act  (1985)  increased  the 
number  of  commodities  covered, 
increased  the  level  and  changed  the 
calculation  of  support,  and  allowed  for 
regional  support  programs.  The  Tri- 
partite Stabilization  Program  also 
provided  a  national  plan  for  federal- 
provincial-industry  co-operation  in 
stabilizing  farm  incomes. 


•  The  Canadian  Rural  Transition  Program 
(1986)  helped  families  who  were  forced 
to  stop  farming,  providing  assistance  for 
retraining  or  offering  targeted  initiatives, 
such  as  the  Tobacco  Diversification  Plan, 
to  diversify  into  other  businesses. 

•  The  Farm  Improvement  and  Marketing 
Cooperatives  Loans  Act  (1987)  offered 
individuals  and  co-operatives  loan 
guarantees  for  processing,  distributing 
and  marketing  products. 

•  The  Grape  Revitalization  Program  (1987) 
improved  the  competitiveness  of  Ontario 
and  British  Columbia's  grape  and  wine 
industries. 

•  In  1986,  Wise  announced  a  new  long- 
term  dairy  policy  following  an  extensive 
review.  The  five-year  program  and  its 
multi-year  financial  commitment  brought 
increased  stability  to  the  dairy  sector. 

•  Wise  oversaw  the  establishment  of  new 
research  stations  and  laboratories  at 
St-Hyacinthe,  Guelph,  Calgary, 
Lethbridge,  Brandon  and  London. 

Worth  Noting 

•  Wise  is  the  honorary  founding  president 
of  Soil  Conservation  Canada. 


68 


1+1 


Agriculture  and  Agriculture  et 

Agri-Food  Canada       Agroalimentaire  Canada 


Ralph  Ferguson 

June  30,  1984  -  September  16,  1984 


69 


Ralph  Ferguson 

(1929- ) 

Birthplace 

Middlesex  County,  Ontario 

Federal  Constituency 

Lambton-Middlesex  (Ontario) 

Education 

Alvinston,  Ontario 

Professional  Background 

Farmer;  charter  member  of  National  Farm 
Products  Marketing  Council;  member, 
Ontario  Federation  of  Agriculture;  co- 
founder,  Lambton  Pork  Producers 
Association,  advocate  of  Ontario  Pork 
Producers  Marketing  Board  in  late  1950s; 
chairman,  Lambton  County  Egg  Producers 
and  worked  to  create  Ontario  Egg  Producers 
Marketing  Board  in  mid-1960s;  county 
delegate  to  the  Ontario  Egg  Board;  served  on 
county  wheat,  white  bean  and  soybean 
associations 

Political  Affiliation 

Liberal 


Political  Career 

Ferguson  was  elected  to  the  House  of 
Commons  in  1980  and  appointed 
parliamentary  secretary  to  the  minister  of 
state  (small  business  and  tourism)  in  March. 
In  the  early  1980s,  he  also  served  as 
parliamentary  secretary  to  the  minister  of 
finance  and  as  deputy  government  whip. 

Ferguson  was  a  proponent  of  export  market 
expansion  and  participated  in  several  trade 
missions.  He  encouraged  farm  organizations 
and  the  federal  Liberals  to  create 
CANAGREX,  the  Canadian  Agricultural 
Export  Corporation,  as  a  Crown  corporation 
in  1983.  Ferguson  was  appointed  minister  of 
agriculture  by  John  Turner,  who  became 
prime  minister  in  June  1984,  and  served  until 
the  Liberals'  electoral  defeat  three  months  later. 

Ferguson  lost  his  seat  in  the  1984  general 
election  but  was  re-elected  in  1988.  His 
concern  over  growing  corporate  concentration 
in  U.S.  agriculture  made  him  a  strong 
opponent  of  free  trade  with  the  United  States. 
He  served  as  opposition  agriculture  critic  and 
assistant  co-critic  for  international  trade.  His 
continued  involvement  in  policy  development 
led  to  the  adoption  of  a  comprehensive 
agriculture  policy  by  the  Liberal  party  in 
1970.  He  retired  from  politics  in  1993  but  is 
still  an  agricultural  activist  in  southwestern 
Ontario,  a  practising  conservationist  and  a 
proponent  of  environmentally  friendly, 
renewable  fuels. 


Accomplishments  as  Minister 

Because  Ferguson  served  for  a  limited 
period,  it  is  difficult  to  identify  a  specific 
legacy  for  him  in  the  department.  With 
increasing  pressure  from  industry  for  plant 
breeders'  rights  legislation,  Ferguson 
recognized  the  need  to  protect  parent  seed 
stocks  and  was  instrumental  in  establishing 
the  first  in  a  series  of  controlled 
environment  seed  banks  for  this  purpose  at 
the  Morden  research  facility.  He  is  best 
known  for  his  later  work  and  studies 
comparing  farm  gate  and  consumer  prices 
and  lobbying  against  corporate  concentration 
in  the  Canadian  food  system. 


70 


M 


Agriculture  and  Agriculture  et 

Agri-Food  Canada      Agroalimentaire  Canada 


Donald  Frank  Mazankowski 

September  15,  1988  -  April  20,  1991 


71 


Donald  Frank 
Mazankowski 

(1935- ) 

Birthplace 

Viking,  Alberta 

Federal  Constituency 

Vegreville  (Alberta) 

Education 

Viking,  Alberta;  Technical  University  of 
Nova  Scotia  (D.Eng.  (Hon.),  1987) 
and  University  of  Alberta 
(LLD  (Hon.),  1993) 

Professional  Background 

Owner  of  a  car  and  farm  machinery 
dealership  in  a  farm  community;  separate 
school  board  trustee 

Political  Affiliation 

Conservative 

"We  were  aiming  for  a  partnership  with 
farmers  and  the  provinces  .  .  .  trying  to 
grow  the  pie  rather  than  haggling  over 
the  size  of  the  piece. " 
—  Don  Mazankowski,  1997 


Political  Career 

Mazankowski's  long  and  distinguished  career 
in  federal  politics  began  with  his  election  to 
the  House  of  Commons  in  1968.  He  was  re- 
elected as  MP  for  Vegreville  (Alberta)  in  six 
consecutive  elections  and  served  in 
Parliament  for  the  next  25  years. 

When  the  federal  Conservatives  were  in 
opposition  in  the  1970s,  Mazankowski 
served  as  caucus  chair  from  1973  to  1976 
and  co-chair  of  both  the  1976  leadership 
convention  and  the  1981  general  meeting.  He 
served  as  transportation  critic  and  chaired  the 
Conservative  caucus  committee  on 
transportation  and  communications,  as  well 
as  serving  as  the  Conservative  spokesperson 
on  government  operations  and  economic 
development.  He  served  briefly  in  Joe 
Clark's  cabinet  in  1979-80  as  minister  of 
transport  and  minister  responsible  for  the 
Canadian  Wheat  Board. 

When  the  Conservatives  formed  a  majority 
government  in  1984,  Mazankowski  was 
appointed  minister  of  transport,  as  well  as 
acting  minister  for  industry,  science  and 
technology.  He  served  in  these  capacities 
until  June  1986.  He  then  became  government 


House  leader  and  president  of  the  Privy 
Council,  roles  he  filled  until  1989  and  1991 
respectively.  In  1986,  he  was  also  appointed 
deputy  prime  minister,  a  position  he  held 
until  his  retirement  from  federal  politics 
in  1993. 

Mazankowski  served  as  president  of  the 
Treasury  Board  (1987-88),  minister 
responsible  for  privatization  and  regulatory 
affairs  (1988-91)  and  minister  of  agriculture 
(1988-91).  His  final  portfolio  was  finance, 
which  he  held  from  1991  until  his  retirement. 
Throughout  his  career  in  cabinet  he  served 
on  powerful  committees  such  as  priorities 
and  planning,  operations,  expenditure  review, 
Treasury  Board,  Canadian  unity,  and  security 
and  intelligence.  Over  time,  Mazankowski 
was  nicknamed  the  "Minister  of  Everything". 
He  was  awarded  the  title  Right  Honourable 
in  June  1993. 

Since  his  official  retirement  from  public  life 
in  October  1993,  Mazankowski  has  been 
named  to  the  board  of  directors  of  1 1  major 
corporations  involved  in  international  trade 
and  commerce.  He  also  serves  on  the  board 
of  governors  of  the  University  of  Alberta  and 
is  currently  the  agriculture  and  rural 
development  sector  facilitator  for  an  Alberta 
government  task  force  on  economic  growth. 


72 


Industry  Issues 

Mazankowski  reversed  the  interventionist 
tendencies  of  previous  subsidy  programs.  He 
aimed  for  a  market-driven  approach  to 
agriculture  policies  that  focused  on  adding 
value.  Trade  issues  dominated  his  term  as 
minister.  The  Canada-U.S.  Free  Trade 
Agreement  was  implemented  to  improve 
access  to  American  markets  and  eliminate 
tariffs  while  protecting  Canadian  supply 
management  systems. 

Canada  also  participated  in  the  Uruguay 
round  of  negotiations  on  the  General 
Agreement  on  Tariffs  and  Trade  (GATT), 
calling  on  member  countries  to  implement 
comprehensive  agriculture  reforms  and 
reduce  trade-distorting  measures  for 
agricultural  commodities.  The  Canadian 
industry  had  to  agree  to  phase  out  its  support 
systems  over  the  course  of  the  multilateral 
trade  negotiations.  This  development 
advanced  Mazankowski 's  free  market 
ideology  but  was  controversial  with 
producers  and  farm  organizations. 

Departmental  Developments 

In  1989,  as  a  result  of  an  industry  task  force 
review,  the  department  developed  a  new 
comprehensive  policy  called  Growing 
Together:  A  Vision  for  Canada's  Agri-Food 
Industry.  It  was  based  on  four  pillars  for 
Canadian  agriculture  in  the  1990s:  market 
orientation,  regional  diversity,  greater 


self-reliance  and  environmental  sustainability. 
A  parallel  mission  review  was  underway  in 
the  department,  which  evolved  into  a 
comprehensive  regulatory  review  and 
industry  consultation  process  to  consolidate 
and  refine  departmental  activities  in  the  years 
to  come.  Risk  assessment  studies  related  to 
food  safety  set  departmental  priorities  for 
food  sampling.  Evaluations  of  Canadian 
trading  partners'  practices  laid  the  groundwork 
for  future  improvements  in  food  inspection. 

The  1991  Budget  created  a  special  operating 
agency  to  manage  the  department's  racetrack 
supervision  responsibilities. 

Accomplishments  as  Minister 

•  The  Farm  Income  Protection  Act  (1991 ) 
promoted  economic  stability  in  the 
agriculture  community  by  bringing 
together  elements  of  previous  farm  safety 
net  programs  into  a  comprehensive, 
whole-farm  strategy.  The  Gross  Revenue 
Insurance  Program  (GRIP)  offered  price 
supports  and  yield  protection  while  the 
Net  Income  Stabilization  Account 
(NISA)  helped  producers  secure  a  steady 
farm  income. 

•  The  Canadian  Agri-Food  Development 
Initiative  (1989)  funded  industry 
diversification  and  innovation,  such  as 
the  development  of  apple  chips  for 
market  in  British  Columbia. 


The  Domestic  Dairy  Product  Innovation 
Program  of  the  Canadian  Dairy 
Commission  (1989)  added  flexibility  to 
the  national  system  for  managing 
industrial  milk  supply  by  providing  an 
amount  of  milk  additional  to  provincial 
milk  quotas  to  introduce  innovative 
products  on  the  domestic  market. 

National  soil  conservation  program 
agreements  were  signed  with  almost 
every  province  to  encourage  federal- 
provincial  co-operation  in  improved  soil 
management. 

Amendments  to  the  Crop  Insurance  Act 
(1990)  increased  maximum  coverage 
levels  and  offered  greater  flexibility  in 
average  yields  and  support  payments. 

New  plant  breeders  rights  were 
established  to  guarantee  protection  and 
royalties  for  new  and  innovative  plant 
varieties  and  to  encourage  private  sector 
research  and  development. 


73 


M 


Agriculture  and  Agriculture  et 

Agri-Food  Canada      Agroalimentaire  Canada 


William  Hunter  McKnight 

April  21,  1991  -  January  4,  1993 


w\ 


":7& 


Jf 


/' 


74 


William  Hunter 
McKnight 

(1940- ) 

Birthplace 

Elrose,  Saskatchewan 

Federal  Constituency 

Kindersley-Lloydminster  (Saskatchewan) 

Education 

Elrose,  Saskatchewan 

Professional  Background 

Farmer 

Political  Affiliation 

Conservative 

"In  1977  and  1978,  I  got  disgusted  .  . 
I  wanted  to  make  a  change  for  my 
province,  for  Canada  I  guess,  and  1 
decided  I  was  bloody  well  going  to 
run. " 
—  Bill  McKnight,  1988  interview 


Political  Career 

After  three  years  as  president  of  the 
Conservative  Party  of  Saskatchewan  from 
1974  to  1977,  McKnight  was  elected  MP  for 
Kindersley-Lloydminster  in  1979.  He  was  re- 
elected in  the  next  three  federal  elections. 

When  the  Conservatives  took  office  in  1984, 
McKnight  was  appointed  minister  of  labour 
and  minister  responsible  for  the  Canada 
Mortgage  and  Housing  Corporation.  In  1986, 
he  switched  portfolios  and  became  the 
minister  of  Indian  affairs  and  northern 
development.  He  added  to  this  assignment 
the  role  of  minister  responsible  for  western 
economic  diversification  in  1987. 

McKnight  left  these  portfolios  for  defence  in 
1989  and  switched  assignments  yet  again  in 
1 99 1  when  he  succeeded  Don  Mazankowski 
as  minister  of  agriculture.  McKnight  had  a 
reputation  as  a  straightforward,  competent 
and  down-to-earth  minister. 

His  final  cabinet  assignment  was  as  minister 
of  energy,  mines  and  resources  from  January 
to  October  1993.  He  retired  from  federal 
politics  before  the  1993  general  election. 

McKnight  currently  serves  as  chair  of 
NAFTA  Trade  Consultants  Inc.  and  Anvil 
Range  Mining  Corp.  He  is  also  on  the  board 
of  directors  of  five  different  commercial 
enterprises  and  served  as  the  honorary  consul 
to  Ecuador  in  1995. 


Industry  Issues 

Trade  issues,  particularly  those  arising  from 
North  American  Free  Trade  Agreement  and 
General  Agreement  on  Tariffs  and  Trade 
negotiations  and  specific  commodity 
disputes,  continued  to  affect  international 
market  development. 

Industry  groups  consulted  with  government 
officials  to  find  ways  to  streamline 
government  operations  and  harmonize 
federal  and  provincial  regulations  while  still 
providing  agri-businesses  with  the  support 
they  needed  to  compete  internationally. 

Departmental  Developments 

During  McKnight's  time  as  minister,  the 
department  continued  to  focus  on  the  four 
priorities  established  during  Mazankowski's 
tenure:  market  orientation,  regional  diversity, 
greater  self-reliance  and  environmental 
sustainability.  Extensive  industry 
consultations  continued  to  shape  program 
and  regulatory  reviews  within  the 
department. 


75 


Accomplishments  as  Minister 

The  Trade  Opportunities  Strategy,  announced 
in  November  1992,  funded  market 
development  initiatives  introduced  by 
industry,  especially  for  value-added  products. 
Regional  trade  contacts  across  Canada  co- 
ordinated information  to  help  External 
Affairs  and  International  Trade  Canada 
resolve  international  trade  disputes.  Agri- 
food  specialists  based  at  Canadian  embassies 
in  strategic  international  markets  worked  to 
improve  access  for  Canadian  exports  and  to 
provide  market  intelligence. 

An  export  advisory  committee  led  by 
industry  offered  suggestions  on  trade  strategy 
and  the  integration  of  government  resources 
for  trade  policy  and  market  development.  In 
partnership  with  the  Canadian  meat  industry, 
the  department  developed  new  international 
training  programs  to  increase  foreign 
customers'  awareness  of  and  demand  for 
Canadian  red  meat  products. 


The  National  Farm  Business  Management 
Program  provided  $10  million  in  annual 
federal  funding,  matched  by  provincial 
funding,  to  improve  farm  sector 
competitiveness  by  training  producers  in 
marketing  and  promotion,  accounting  and 
computer  technology. 

Agriculture  Canada  contributed  $7  million  in 
research  and  development  funding  to  the 
federal  Ethanol  Action  Plan  to  reduce  the 
cost  of  ethanol  production  and  establish  a 
potential  growth  market  for  renewable  fuels 
made  from  agricultural  commodities. 

McKnight  also  worked  to  implement  the 
federal  Green  Plan  Sustainable  Agriculture 
Initiative.  This  initiative  provided  $170  million 
over  six  years  for  programs  to  promote 
environmentally  sound  practices  in  the  agri- 
food  sector.  The  provinces  shared  the  costs 
of  these  programs  with  the  federal 
government. 


Worth  Noting 

•  McKnight  shared  an  apartment  with  Don 
Mazankowski  during  their  time  as  fellow 
MPs  and  cabinet  ministers  in  Ottawa. 


McKnight  introduced  "check-off  legislation 
into  the  House  of  Commons  to  allow 
commodity  groups  to  collect  levies  on 
domestic  sales  and  imports  to  fund  their 
commodity  research  and  promotional 
activities. 


76 


M 


Agriculture  and  Agriculture  et 

Agri-Food  Canada      Agroalimentaire  Canada 


Charles  James  Mayer 

Januarx  4,  1993  -  November  4,  1993 


77 


Charles  James  Mayer 

(1936- ) 

Birthplace 

Saskatoon,  Saskatchewan 

Federal  Constituency 

Portage-Marquette/Lisgar-Marquette 
(Manitoba) 

Education 

University  of  Saskatchewan  (B.Sc,  1964) 

Professional  Background 

Mixed  farmer;  president  of  Manitoba  Beef 
Growers  Association;  member  of  Manitoba 
Farm  Bureau,  Canadian  Cattlemen's 
Association;  member  of  Manitoba  Institute 
of  Agrologists,  Agricultural  Institute  of 
Canada 

Political  Affiliation 

Conservative 

"/  don 't  think  the  Canadian 
consumer/taxpayer  is  aware  of  the 
strength  of  this  industry.  We  need  better 
salesmanship  and  communication. " 
—  Charlie  Mayer,  1997 


Political  Career 

Mayer  was  elected  to  the  House  of  Commons 
in  1979,  representing  Portage-Marquette.  He 
was  re-elected  in  1980  and  1984  for  this  riding 
and  in  1988  for  the  riding  of  Lisgar-Marquette. 
As  an  MP,  he  worked  with  Minister  of 
Agriculture  John  Wise  as  an  advisor  on 
agriculture  policy  and  chaired  the  Manitoba 
Progressive  Conservative  caucus. 

Mayer's  path  to  becoming  minister  of 
agriculture  led  him  through  a  variety  of 
junior  cabinet  positions,  all  of  which  dealt 
with  agricultural  policy  in  some  way.  In 
1984,  he  was  appointed  minister  of  state  for 
the  Canadian  Wheat  Board  and  minister 
responsible  for  liaison  with  Canada's  co- 
operative sector.  He  changed  assignments 
slightly  in  1987  when  he  was  appointed 
minister  of  state  for  grains  and  oilseeds.  In 
1989,  he  added  to  these  responsibilities  those 
of  minister  responsible  for  western  economic 
diversification. 

In  January  1993,  Mayer  was  appointed 
minister  of  agriculture,  small  communities 
and  rural  areas.  After  new  prime  minister 
Kim  Campbell's  cabinet  shuffle  in  June 
1993,  his  position  was  renamed  minister  of 
agriculture  and  agri-food. 

Mayer  was  defeated  in  the  1993  federal 
election.  He  continues  to  be  active  in  the 
agriculture  industry  and  serves  as  chair  of  the 
Manitoba  Crop  Insurance  Corporation  and  on 
the  board  of  Canada  Bread. 


Industry  Issues 

Incorporating  agricultural  products  into  the 
General  Agreement  on  Tariffs  and  Trade 
(GATT)  required  a  tremendous  amount  of 
work  on  the  part  of  the  department  and 
industry  groups.  Canadian  farmers  depended 
on  exports  for  their  prosperity,  so  trade 
negotiations  were  a  top  priority.  Mayer 
described  the  goal  of  the  GATT  negotiations 
as  ensuring  farmers  "competed  on  quality 
and  price,  not  on  the  size  of  their 
government's  treasuries". 


78 


Departmental  Developments 


Accomplishments  as  Minister 


The  mandate  of  the  department  was  officially 
revised  and  expanded  to  reflect  ongoing 
regulatory  and  program  reviews.  At  the  same 
time,  government  spending  restraints  and  a 
10-per-cent  departmental  budget  cut 
necessitated  a  climate  of  restraint. 

In  consultation  with  industry,  the  department 
conducted  an  extensive  regulatory  review 
and  revised  obsolete  regulations.  Eight  pilot 
projects  found  ways  to  reduce  duplication 
between  federal  and  provincial  inspection 
agencies.  The  Food  Safety  Enhancement 
Program  promoted  new  international 
standards,  known  as  HACCP  (Hazard 
Analysis  Critical  Control  Points)  inspection 
systems,  at  federally  registered  plants.  The 
department  reduced  its  seven  branches  to 
five  to  streamline  overhead.  It  also  cut  levels 
of  management  and  launched  a  regional 
review  to  improve  service  to  departmental 
clients  nationwide. 

Food  inspection  activities  and  personnel 
formerly  under  the  jurisdiction  of  the 
departments  of  Consumer  and  Corporate 
Affairs  and  Industry,  Science  and  Technology 
merged  with  those  oi  the  Food  Production 
and  Inspection  Branch  after  June  1993.  The 
department  was  given  a  new  name, 
Agriculture  and  Agri-Food  Canada,  to  reflect 
its  new  emphasis  on  working  with  the  food 
industry  as  well  as  primary  producers. 


Mayer  believed  there  was  too  much 
government  regulation  in  some  areas  of  the 
industry.  He  changed  grain  marketing  policy 
and  announced  that  farmers  were  free  to  sell 
barley  outside  the  Canadian  Wheat  Board. 
While  this  departure  from  accepted 
procedure  was  eventually  reversed,  at  the 
time  it  meant  that  farmers  were  free  to 
market  their  products  to  American  clients. 

Mayer  appointed  the  Producer  Payment 
Board  to  recommend  ways  to  transfer  grain 
rail  subsidies  to  farmers.  The  railways 
received  $520  million  annually  in  Crow  Rate 
benefits.  Because  the  government  couldn't 
afford  to  invest  new  money  in  grain 
subsidies,  it  sought  alternate  means  of 
supporting  farmers. 

The  Canadian  Rural  Opportunities  Initiative 
provided  $25  million  over  three  years  for 
counselling,  training  and  business 
development  assistance  for  farm  families 
with  below-average  incomes. 

Mayer  also  worked  to  update  and  expand  the 
mandate  of  the  Farm  Credit  Corporation  to 
include  funding  for  diversified  farm 
operations,  value-added  processing  and  part- 
time  producers 


79 


■*■ 


Agriculture  and  Agriculture  et 

Agri-Food  Canada      Agroalimentaire  Canada 


Ralph  Goodale 

November  4,  1993  -  June  11,  1997 


80 


Ralph  Goodale 

(1949- ) 

Birthplace 

Regina,  Saskatchewan 

Federal  Constituencies 

Assiniboia,  Regina-Wascana  (Saskatchewan) 

Education 

University  of  Regina  (BA,  1971),  University 
of  Saskatchewan  (LLB,  1972) 

Professional  Background 

Called  to  the  Saskatchewan  bar  in  1973, 
member  of  Law  Society  of  Saskatchewan; 
special  assistant  to  the  minister  of  justice  and 
attorney  general  (1973-74);  operated  family 
farm  until  1975;  worked  for  CBC  News  and 
Public  Affairs  (1968-72) 

Political  Affiliation 

Liberal 


Political  Career 

Goodale  was  elected  to  the  House  of 
Commons  in  1974  for  the  large  rural 
constituency  of  Assiniboia.  Over  the  next 
five  years,  he  occupied  a  variety  of  positions, 
including  parliamentary  secretary  to  several 
ministers,  among  others  minister  of 
transport,  minister  responsible  for  the 
Canadian  Wheat  Board,  president  of  the 
Privy  Council  and  deputy  prime  minister. 

As  parliamentary  secretary  to  the  minister 
responsible  for  the  Canadian  Wheat  Board, 
Goodale  piloted  the  Western  Grain 
Stabilization  Program  through  Parliament  in 
1976.  Between  1974  and  1979,  he  was  also 
vice-chairman  of  the  House  of  Commons 
standing  committee  on  agriculture,  vice- 
chairman  of  the  special  joint  committee  on 
the  northern  gas  pipeline,  deputy  government 
whip  and  chairman  of  the  government's 
prairie  caucus. 

In  198 1 .  Goodale  was  chosen  leader  of  the 
Saskatchewan  Liberal  Party.  He  was  elected 
MLA  for  Assiniboia-Gravelbourg  in  the  1986 
Saskatchewan  election.  He  resigned  from 
provincial  politics  to  run  as  the  Liberal 
candidate  for  Regina-Wascana  in  the  1988 
federal  election  but  was  defeated. 

For  the  next  five  years,  Goodale  took  a  break 
from  politics  and  worked  as  director  of 
regulatory  affairs  and  corporate  secretary  of 
Pioneer  Life  Assurance  Company  and 


Pioneer  Lifeco  Inc.,  both  Regina-based 
financial  institutions,  and  as  corporate 
secretary  of  Sovereign  Life  Insurance  Co. 

When  he  was  re-elected  as  MP  for  Regina- 
Wascana  in  October  1993,  he  was  appointed 
minister  of  agriculture  and  agri-food.  After 
the  January  1996  cabinet  shuffle,  he  also  was 
appointed  chairman  of  the  cabinet  committee 
on  economic  development  policy. 

Goodale  was  re-elected  in  1997  and 
transferred  to  the  natural  resources  portfolio. 
He  is  still  the  minister  responsible  for  the 
Canadian  Wheat  Board. 

Industry  Issues 

Goodale's  term  as  minister  coincided  with 
government  budget  cuts  to  programs  and 
services,  as  well  as  a  rapid  expansion  of 
export  markets  and  information  technology 
for  the  agriculture  sector.  The  Liberal 
government's  focus  on  restraining  spending 
and  cutting  the  deficit  reduced  the  level  of 
financial  and  administrative  support  the 
department  could  offer  producers  and 
processors.  Fortunately,  strong  world  grain 
prices  reduced  the  need  for  government 
support. 

"Team  Canada"  trade  missions  and  enhanced 
market  information  available  through  new 
online  support  services  helped  create  new 
opportunities  for  innovative  production  and 
marketing.  The  Uruguay  round  of  the 


81 


General  Agreement  on  Tariffs  and  Trade  was 
completed  in  December  1993  and  implemented 
in  August  1996.  The  creation  of  the  World 
Trade  Organization  (WTO)  helped  Canadian 
producers  and  agri-businesses  secure  access 
to  world  markets. 

Departmental  Developments 

The  1995  Budget  announced  that  federal 
government  food  inspection  services  would 
be  consolidated  into  a  new  agency  called  the 
Canadian  Food  Inspection  Agency  (CFIA). 
The  department  rose  to  the  challenge  of 
transforming  its  current  inspection  services, 
administered  by  the  Food  Production  and 
Inspection  Branch,  into  a  consolidated 
agency  that  would  also  include  inspection 
responsibilities  and  personnel  formerly  under 
the  jurisdiction  of  Health  Canada  and  the 
Department  of  Fisheries  and  Oceans. 

In  1995,  in  co-operation  with  Foreign  Affairs 
and  International  Trade  Canada,  the 
department  created  the  Agri-Food  Trade 
Service  (ATS)  to  give  exporters  easy  access 
to  government  programs,  market 
information,  trade  regulations  and  other 
types  of  support.  The  industry  set  a  goal  of 
$20  billion  in  annual  agricultural  exports  by 
the  year  2000.  In  1996  the  sector  exported 
$19.95  billion  worth  of  agri-food  products. 

The  Rural  Secretariat  was  established  to  co- 
ordinate the  work  of  federal  departments  and 
agencies  focused  on  the  economic  renewal  of 
rural  communities. 


Accomplishments  as  Minister 

•  The  Agricultural  Marketing  Programs 
Act  (effective  1997)  replaced  four 
previous  programs.  It  provides  more 
efficient  administration  of  interest-free 
cash  advances  to  help  producers  market 
their  products. 

•  The  end  of  both  the  "Crow  Rate" 
subsidies  for  prairie  grain  transport  (the 
Western  Grain  Transportation  Act)  and 
the  feed  freight  assistance  subsidy  to 
livestock  producers  outside  the  Prairies 
(1995)  encouraged  efficiency  and  self- 
sufficiency  in  the  grain  and  livestock 
sectors.  A  one-time  payment  of  $1.6 
billion,  with  an  additional  $300  million  in 
adjustment  funds  over  the  next  three 
years,  helped  former  beneficiaries  adapt 
and  invest  in  new  opportunities. 

•  The  Western  Grain  Marketing  Panel 
consulted  industry  and  offered 
suggestions  to  modernize  the  governance 
of  the  Canadian  Wheat  Board  (CWB), 
provide  greater  flexibility  in  CWB 
operations  and  services,  and  offer  farmers 
a  wider  range  of  grain  marketing  options. 
As  the  minister  responsible  for  the  CWB, 
Goodale  continues  to  work  on 
amendments  to  the  Canadian  Wheat 
Board  Act  based  on  the  panel's  July  1996 
recommendations. 


Goodale  provided  leadership  during  the 
Canadian  government's  successful 
defence  of  supply  management  principles 
against  an  American  challenge  through  a 
North  American  Free  Trade  Agreement 
dispute  panel.  The  panel  upheld  Canada's 
right  to  apply  tariffs  to  certain  U.S. 
imports. 

The  Canadian  Adaptation  and  Rural 
Development  Fund  (1996)  provides  $60 
million  annually  for  national  and  local 
rural  development  and  community 
diversification  programs. 

The  Matching  Investment  Initiative 
(1995)  allows  the  department  to  match, 
one  for  one,  industry  contributions  to 
collaborative  scientific  research  projects. 
By  mid- 1997,  more  than  1,000 
agreements  on  projects  totalling  more 
than  $42  million  in  research  and 
development  had  been  established. 


82