Skip to main content

Full text of "Station bulletin"

See other formats


STATION   BULLETIN  416 


Avian  Mass  Immunization  for 

Infectious  Bronchitis  and 

Newcastle  Disease 


W.  R.  Dunlop 


R.  G.  Strout 


AGRICULTURAL   EXPERIMENT  STATION 

UNIVERSITY    OF    NEW    HAMPSHIRE 

DURHAM,    N.    H. 


ACKNOWLEDGMENTS 

The  authors  wish  to  express  their  appreciation  to  Professor 
W.  C.  Skoglund,  Head  of  the  Department  of  Poultry  Husbandry 
at  the  University  of  Xew  Hampshire,  for  his  guidance  in  the  re- 
search program  and  the  preparation  of  this  liulletin. 

We  are  also  grateful  to  Mr.  Robert  E.  Leventhal,  Graduate 
Research  Assistant  in  Poultry,  and  to  Mr.  Donald  E.  Coller, 
Senior  Laboratory  Technician,  both  of  the  Poultry  Department. 
University  of  New  Hampshire. 

Thanks  also  are  extendetl  to  the  many  poultrymen  in  New 
Hampshire  who  cooperated  in  this  study.  The  Poultry  Disease 
Research  Committee  of  the  New  Hampshire  Poultry  Growers 
Association  was  instrumental  in  organizing  the  poultrymen.  With- 
out their  financial  help  and  willingness  to  provide  experimental 
flocks  this  study  would  not  have  been  possil)le. 

Acknowledgement  is  also  made  to  the  Lederle  Laboratories 
Division  of  the  American  Cyanamid  Co.  for  providing  a  research 
grant  to  make  part  of  this  study  possible. 

In  addition,  thanks  are  also  extended  to  the  following  poultry 
students  at  the  University  who  did  the  actual  spra}'ing  in  the  field : 
Edwin  Antz,  Harold  Albin,  Charles  Avery,  Andrew  Brochu,  John 
Dodge,  Fred  Jennings,  Roger  Laber,  Jerald  Uuimby,  and  Dean 
Towle. 


COVER:  One  method  of  mass  immunization  by    spray. 


JANUARY   1955 


Avian  Mass  Immunization  for  Infectious 
Bronchitis  and  Newcastle  Disease 

By  W.  R.  Du nlop  and  R.  G.  Strout=^ 

Introduction 

THE   PHENOMENAL   growth   of   the   poultry    industry    in    the   last 
decade,  manifested  in  size  of  flocks  rather  than  in  number  of  flocks,  pre- 
sents the  need  for  an  entirely  new  approach  to  poultry  disease  control. 

Areas  of  heavy  poultry  populatidu  lend  themselves,  unfortunately,  to 
rapid  spread  of  acute  diseases.  An  example  of  this  is  readily  observed  in  the 
prevalence  of  respiratory  conditions,  such  as  infectious  bronchitis  and  New- 
castle disease.  The  control  of  the  diseases  over  the  entire  country  presents  a 
very  pressing  problem.  In  spite  of  the  highly  specialized  technicjues  of  vac- 
cinations carried  on  today,  this  problem  is  increasing  in  magnitude. 

It  is  apparent  that  in  keeping  pace  with  the  industry  of  today,  a  method 
of  mass  immunization  is  needed.  The  arduous  task  of  vaccinating  individual 
birds  not  only  presents  an  expensive  labor  problem  but  also  invites  a  factor 
known  as  human  error.  This  factor  is  considered  by  some  to  be  largely  re- 
sponsible for  the  inadequacy  of  avian  immunization  programs. 

Mass  immunization,  whether  a  dust  or  a  spray,  is  based  on  one  of  the 
soundest  principles  in  the  study  of  the  spread  of  virus  diseases.  Specifically, 
it  is  understood  that  most  virus  diseases  of  the  respiratory  tract  are  spread 
by  means  of  the  virus  particles  riding  on  dust  particles  or  moisture  droplets 
in  the  air. 

Review  of  Literature 

In  1948,  Hitchner  and  Johnson  (7)  reported  the  use  of  the  Bj  strain  of 
Newcastle  virus  in  the  intranasal  vaccination  of  day-old  chicks.  While  the 
duration  of  immunity  was  not  established,  day-old  vaccinated  chicks  were 
immune  at  4  months  of  age.  It  was  also  demonstrated  that  the  vaccinatio;i 
of  laying  birds  did  not  produce  any  marked  drop  in  egg  production.  At- 
tempts to  immunize  baby  chicks  by  atomization  of  the  Bj  virus  resulted  in 
a  high  morbidity  and  mortality,  but  there  was  no  evidence  of  paralytic 
symptoms. 

Later,  Bankowski  ( 1 )  concluded  from  laboratory  and  field  vaccination 
trials  with  an  attenuated  Newcastle  virus  that  the  length  of  exposure  to  V:W 
air-borne  virus  and  the  age  of  the  chickens  being  vaccinated  are  important 
considerations.  The  results  were  of  a  highly  encouraging  nature. 


*  Dr.  Dunlop  is  Research  Poultry  Pathologist  and  Mr.   Strout  is  Assista-it 
Pathologist,  New  Hampshire  Agricultural  Experiment  Station. 


Hitchner  in  1950  (5)  ohserved  that  ])ai"fntal  iniunniit\  nuiy  he  over- 
come in  day-old  chicks,  and  that  imninnit\'  from  da\-iild  vaccination  mav  he 
ohtained  even  in  the  face  of  parental  immnnitw 

Hitchner  and  Keising  in  1952  (6j,  however,  demonstrated  hy  labo- 
ratory and  field  trials  that  atomization  of  the  H,  strain  of  virns  offered  a 
l)ractical  method  for  vaccinating  and  revaccinating  hirds  ^  weeks  old  or 
older.  By  such  administration,  successful  revaccination  was  accomplished  in 
l)roiler  flocks  4  weeks  old  after  intranasal  vaccination  at  one  day  of  age.  Re- 
placement flocks  revaccinated  at  15  to  20  weeks  of  age  demonstrated  a  good 
antigenic  res])onse. 

It  was  noted  also  hy  Hitchner  and  Keising  in  this  same  study  that  the 
Bj  strain  of  virus  produced  a  greater  reaction  when  administered  to  chicks 
as  a  spray  than  when  administered  intranasally.  The  respiratory  reaction 
varied  from  flock  to  flock  with  negligi])]e  mortality  exce])t  in  those  cases 
where  it  appeared  that  a  concurrent  infection  was  |)resent. 

Luginhuhl  {^>)  was  one  of  the  first  workers  to  combine  the  vaccinations 
of  Newcastle  and  infectious  l)ronchitis  at  an  early  age.  The  administration 
of  this  vaccine  involved  the  intranasal  route  applied  to  each  bird. 

Crawley  in  1953  (2)  and  1954  (3)  has  demonstrated  that  chicks  could 
])c  inoctflated  by  a  spray  technique  from  one  da_\"  of  age  up  to  20  weeks.  It 
was  observed  that  the  com])ination  of  infectious  bronchitis  virus  and  New- 
castle disease  virus  into  one  vaccine  produced  less  interference  in  growth 
when  the  2  vaccines  were  applied  at  the  same  time  than  if  given  separately 
In  regards  to  Crawley's  work  it  has  been  found  by  many  investigators  dif- 
ficult to  duplicate  Canadian  results  under  American  field  conditions. 


Candling  embryos  in  preparation  for  vaeoine  prodiu'lion. 

4 


Experimental  Materials 

Newcastle  Disease  Virus 

I'he  strain  oi  Xewcastle  disease  virus  used  was  the  Wi  or  Blacksburg 
strain.  In  the  field  trials  (with  one  exception,  in  which  a  commercial  vaccine 
was  used),  the  avian  embryo  titre  of  this  virus  was  10  "''-^''.  This  strain  was 
obtained  directly  from  llitclmer  in  1951. 

Infectious  Bronchitis  Virus 

From  observations  of  held  outbreaks  of  infectious  l>ronchitis,  it  was 
quite  ap])arent  that  variations  in  strains  occurred. 

In  1951,  fifteen  strains  of  infectious  l)ronchitis  were  isc^lated,  and  for 
the  remainder  of  that  year  and  up  to  'the  fall  of  1952,  repeated  screenings 
of  these  strains  were  carried  out.  This  work  resulted  in  tlie  selection  of  one 
strain  which  appeared  to  be  adaptable  to  mass  imnuuiization  procedures. 
This  strain  was  found  to  have  high  antigenic  properties. 

Screenings  of  embryo  passages  were  carried  out  and  it  was  found  that 
the  twentv-fourth  and  twenty-fifth  embryo  passages  were  desirable  for  the 
field  trials.  The  avian  enil)ryo  titre  was  10  ■'•^.  using  one  tenth  ml.  of 
inocuhun  per  embryo. 

Sprayers 

Four  different  s]M"ayer>  were  used  in  the  field  trials. 

1.  Binks  power  spra}er  (electric) 

2.  Aerosol  hand  sprayer 

3.  Common  hand  fly  sprayer 

4.  Z  &  \\'  hand  spraxer 

The  type  of  sprayer  first  mentioned  was  used  in  tlie  application  of  the 
commercially  dehydrated  Xewcastle  vaccine  and,  later,  in  the  application  of 
the  experimental  combination  of  Newcastle  and  infectious  bronchitis  viruses 
under  the  direction  of  a  commercial  concern. 

The  three  latter  types  oi  sprayers  were  used  in  conjunction  with  the 
experimental  vaccine  prepared  in  the  University  of  New  Hampshire  lab- 
oratories. 

Diluents 

The  diluents  used  in  the  experiments  were  modified  l)uffered  saline 
solutions. 

Chicks 

The  chicks  u.^ed  in  the  experimental  lal)oratory  trials  were  obtained 
from  the  poultry  department  at  the  University  of  New  Hampshire. 

The    chicks    used    in    tlie    field  trials    were    provided    1)y  cooperating 

pouhrynien  in  the  state  of  Xew  llam]xshire. 

Experimental  Procedures 

Field  Trial  Procedure 

Due  to  the  fact  that  the  University  of  Xew  Hami)shire  did  not  have 
sufficient  facilities  for  Ivophili/.ation  of  the  viruses  involved,  the  vaccines 


used  were  niaintaiued  in  a  frozen  state  until  time  of  use.  Commercial  de- 
hydration of  similar  strains  of  infectious  In-onchitis  did  not  materially  afTect 
the  response  to  the  vaccination.  In  the  maj(jrity  of  trials  the  vaccine  was 
mixed  at  the  farm  h}-  a  representative  of  the  poultr}-  department.  As  the 
\'(jlume  increased  in  the  state,  however,  it  was  necessary  in  manv  instances 
to  mix  the  vaccine  beforehand.  Such  vaccine  was  picked  up  at  the  laboratory 
by  the  farmer  or  field  service  man.  Xo  difference  in  results  was  noted  be- 
tween those  flocks  sprayed  by  a  member  of  the  University  or  those  sprayed 
l)y  tlu'  ])oultrvman  himself. 

Due  to  the  ease  of  uKjre  complete  coverage,  the  majority  of  flocks 
spray-vaccinated  were  done  so  at  night  when  the  chicks  were  bedded  down. 
Night  administration  was  later  observed  not  to  be  necessarv  providing 
complete  coverage  of  the  chicks  could  be  accomplished.  This  factor  of  suc- 
cessful daytime  inoculation  depended  <in  the  type  of  brooding  facilities 
encr)untered. 

On  those  farms  utilizing  space  heaters,  the  fans  were  turned  off  during 
administration  of  the  vaccine.  The  type  of  brooding  equipment  used  did  not 
aff'ect  the  results  of  the  vaccination. 

In  the  case  of  birds  being  carried  through  the  growing  period  to  the 
laying  period,  it  was  found  necessary,  as  with  commercial  vaccines,  to  re- 
vaccinate.  This  revaccination  was  carried  out  at  night  when  the  birds  were 
bedded  down  or  had  gone  to  roost.  Simply  spraying  the  vaccine  over  the 
heads  of  the  birds  was  all  that  was  necessarv  to  restimulate  immunity  which 


Drilling   and  disinfecting   the   embryos   prior   to   inoculation. 


Inoculation  of  the  embryo-*  witli  virus  for  vaccine  jiroduclion. 

lasted  through  the  laying  year.   Individual  handling-  of  the  birds  was  not 
necessary. 

Blood  samples  were  taken  from  the  chicks  at  the  time  of  vaccination. 
An  attempt  was  made  to  procure  samples  at  four-week  intervals  thereafter. 
As  the  volume  increased,  however,  samples  were  taken  from  different  flocks 
at  different  ages  by  random  sampling. 


Explanation  of  Serological  Tests 

The  H.  I.  test  emploN'ed  in  this  work  has  been  tised  as  a  method  of 
determining  antigenic  response  to  vaccination  with  the  Vt^  strain  of  New- 
castle virus.  This  test  is  of  the  beta  type,  described  l)y  F.  S.  Markham.  It 
has  been  shown  by  challenge  with  a  known  virulent  strain  of  virus  that 
negative  tests  are  not  a  reliable  indication  of  susceptibility. 

The  geometric  mean  titre  is  a  metlTod  used  in  experimental  and  field 
studies  in  serology,  and  is  employed  wlien  it  is  desired  to  compare  one 
group  with  another.  Unlike  the  average,  which  may  be  entirely  misleading, 
the  geometric  mean  titre  has  a  hxed  value. 

The  serum  n.eutrali/.ation  test  used  was  a  variation  of  the  test  described 
Ijy  f'^abricant  (4).  A  serum  dilution  of  1  :10  was  made  and  mixed  with  10, 
100.  and  1000  neutralizing  doses  of  eml^rvo-adapted  infectious  bronchitis 
virus.  Three  embryos  per  diliuion  were  used.  Results  were  considered  pos- 
itive when  two  out  of  three  emI)ryos  in  the  dilution  of  100  or  more  neutra- 
lizing doses  lived. 

The  same  test  was  used  in  the  detection  of  Newcastle  antibodies, 
except,  of  course,  an  embryo-adapted  strain  of  Newcastle  virus  was  used 
as  antigen. 

In  challenging  for  infectious  l)ronchitis,  a  field  strain  of  bronchitis 
\irus  was  used.  This  strain  underwent  a  bird  titre.  It  was  found  that  a  di- 
lution of  10^*^  was  the  end  point  of  infectivity  in  susceptible  birds.  A  di- 
lution of  10~-\,  or  1000  infective  doses,  was  applied.  .2  cc.  intranasally  and 
.2  cc.  intratracheallv. 


[hit  challenge  for  Xeuca.stle  inuminit)  \va>  carried  mit  1)_\  injecting" 
.5  CO.  of  10  nild's  (oljtained  by  l)ird  titre  )  of  the  Honey  strain  of  virus  in- 
tramuscnlarlv.  l^iirds  showing  s\mptoms  of  paralysis  were  considered  as 
dead. 

Preliminary   Laboratory  Results 

'liiiKiv  CHICKS,  parentalh'  immune  to  Newcastle  disease,  were  u>ed  in  the 
first  laboratory  trial.  The  chicks  were  sprayed  on  the  second  day.  A  respir- 
atory "take"  occurred  5  days  later  which  lasted  for  an  additional  5  days.  At 
5  weeks,  blood  samples  were  taken  for  an  H.  I.  and  S.  X.  test,  and  the  en- 
tire group  was  challenged  with  10  mld's  (»f  the  P)oney  challenge  strain  of 
Newcastle  virus.  Two  birds  died  and  one  showed  paralysis.  Seventy  and 
one-half  (70.5)  per  cent  of  these  birds  showed  positive  Td.  I.  tnres  while 
79.3  per  cent  showed  positive  neutralization  litres. 

Diu'ing  this  same  period  laboratory  trials  were  being  run  on  the  se- 
lected strains  of  infectious  bronchitis  mentioned  previously.  .\t  this  juncture 
it  was  decided  to  combine  Newcastle  and  infectious  bronchitis  vaccines.  The 
Blacksburg  strain  of  Newcastle  \irus  and  selected  strains  of  infectious  bron- 
chitis were  used  in  these  trials. 

Four  parallel  groups  of  30  susce])tible  4- week-old  chicks  were  sprayed 
with  combination  Newcastle  and  infectious  bronchitis  strains.  In  addition. 
2  groui)s  of  30  chicks,  3  and  4  days  of  age.  i)arentally  imnnnie  to  Newcastle 
and  infectious  bronchitis  were  sprayed. 


Recording  sterility   aiul   pott'iu-v, 

8 


The  respiratory  take  was  apparent  in  the  \oiinger  chicks  on  the  third 
or  fourth  dav,  l)eing  quite  mild  until  the  fifth  day.  The  4-week-old  birds 
showed  a  take  on  the  second  day.  The  length  of  respiratory  take  in  all 
groups  was  about  15  days.  Xn  mortality  appeared  in  the  older  birds  during 
this  time  while  one  chick  was  lost  in  the  younger  group. 

All  birds  were  challenged  4  weeks  later.  One  half  were  challenged  by 
the  intratracheal  route  with  1000  infective  chick  doses  of  a  field  strain  of  in- 
fectious bronchitis  virus.  'Vhe  second  half  were  challenged  with  the  Boney 
challenge  strain  of  Newcastle  virus  as  previously  described.  Two  birds  died 
as  a  result  of  the  Newcastle  challenge  and  one  showed  paralysis.  Three  birds 
showed  mild  respirator)-  symptoms  for  two  days  when  challenged  with  in- 
fectious bronchitis. 

Following  this  trial  a  further  laboratorv  test  was  conducted  on  some 
600  chick  divided  into  6  pens.  The  parent  stock  was  vaccinated  with  a  field 
strain  of  infectious  bronchitis  virus  and  with  wing  web  vaccine  for  New- 
castle disease  just  as  they  came  into  production.  Random  blood  samples 
were  taken  from  all  groups  of  chicks  and  it  was  apparent  that  parental  im- 
munitv  existed  for  Newcastle  disease  and  infectious  bronchitis. 

The  birds  were  vaccinated  with  combination  Newcastle  and  infectious 
bronchitis  vaccine  by  the  spvay  technique.  The  take  was  mild  on  the  second 
and  third  days.  About  the  fifth  day  the  take  was  quite  apparent.  Respiratory 
take  had  disappeared  from  all  groups  by  the  17th  day. 

At  8  weeks  random  blood  samples  were  drawn  for  serological  test.  On 
Hemagglutination  Inhibition  test  63.3  per  cent  showed  positive  H.  I.  titres. 
while  on  serum  neutralization  test  for  infectious  bronchitis  76.8  per  cent 
showed  positive  titres. 

At  16  weeks  onlv  55.1  per  cent  showed  positive  H.  I.  titres  for  New- 
castle disease;  68.8  per  cent  were  capable  of  neutralizing  better  than  100 
embryo  lethal  doses  of  infectious  bronchitis  virus. 

Experimental  Results 

Spraying  with  UNH  Newcastle  Vaccine 

During  a  three-month  period.  25  flocks  involving  67.280  birds  were 
inoculated  in  the  field  at  2  to  3  days  of  age  with  the  Bi  strain  of  Newcastle 
virus.  The  spray  technique,  utilizing  the  Z  &  W  type  sprayer,  as  well  as 
others,  was  used  in  the  administration  of  this  vaccine.  The  size  of  the  flocks 
ranged  from  550  to  10.000  chicks.  Brooding  systems  of  all  types  were  en- 
countered. 

In  all  cases,  respiratory  symptoms  were  observed  around  the  fifth  or 
sixth  day  post  inoculation.  The  average  length  of  response  was  6.5  days.  The 
mortality  from  all  causes  averaged  1.8  per  cent  for  the  first  two  weeks  fol- 
lowing vaccination.  Blood  samples,  taken  at  random,  were  withdrawn  at  4. 
8,  12,  and  16  weeks,  respectively.  Geometric  mean  titres  are  shown  in  Table 
1.  (In  the  compilation  of  geometric  mean  titres  for  this  bulletin,  serum 
samples  in  the  H.  I.  test  were  diluted  no  higher  than  1  :128.  This  explains 
the  relatively  low  figure  obtained.  It  must  be  remembered  here  that  the  geo- 
metric mean  titre  is  merely  a  value  obtained  for  the  use  of  comparison 
purposes.) 

9 


8oo 


Figure   I 

RESULTS  OF  INFECTIOUS    BRONCHITIS 
VACCINATION  BV   SPRAY 

(weeks) 


C/O 

CO 

O 


CD 

Zi 
< 

I— 

z> 

LU 


UNH   SPRAY  

PARENTAL    IMMUNITY   "— ■ 


PARENTAL 

IMMUNITY 


WEEKS 


9  |0  II  IX 


CO 

O 


CD 

—I 
< 


900, 


8oc 


600 


SOO 


400 


Figure     H 

RESULTS    OF    INFECTIOUS 

BRONCHITIS    VACCINATION 
BY    SPRAY 


UNH    SPRAY 
PARENTAL   IMMUNlTy 


3         ■^  S  6  7  6  9  lo        II  la.         i3         14-         15 


PARENTAL 
IMMUNlTy 


REVACCINATIOM 


MONTHS 


10 


Table  1.     Results  of  UNH  Newcastle  Spray  Vaccine 

Age  4  weeks         5-8  weeks       9-12  weeks      13-16  weeks 

Geometric  mean  titre         ~.7S  6.94  7.11  5.582 

Serum  neutralization  tests  indicated  that  y^KS  i)er  cent  of  the  samples 
neutralized  100  or  more  neutralizing  doses. 

Random  samples  of  l)irds.  withdrawn  at  the  same  time  for  challenge, 
exhibited  a  resistance  of  d7 .S  per  cent,  with  98.8  per  cent  of  the  susceptible 
controls  dying. 

Spraying  of  Commercial  Newcastle  Vaccine 

During  a  period  covering  approximately  3  months,  experiments  were 
undertaken  using  the  Binks  power  paint  spraver  in  the  administration  of  a 
commercially  dehydrated  Newcastle  vaccine. 

Approximately  45.750  birds  were  sprayed  at  2  to  3  days  of  age  with 
this  equipment.  The  mortality  from  all  causes  for  2  weeks  following  vac- 
cination was  1.7  per  cent.  The  fluration  of  the  respiratory  symptoms  was  an 
average  of  9  days. 

Blood  samples,  taken  at  random,  were  withdrawn  at  4.  8.  and  12  weeks, 
respectively.  The  geometric  mean  titres  are  recorded  below. 

Table  2.     Results  of  Spraying  a  Commercial  Newcastle  Vaccine 

Age  4  weeks  8  weeks  12  weeks 

Geometric  mean  titre  5.821  5.743  5.133 

Unfortunately,  due  to  the  lack  of  adequate  space  for  challenge,  this 
process  was  omitted. 

Serum  neutralization  tests  showed  that  80.9  per  cent  of  the  samples 
tested  neutralized  100  or  more  neutralizing  doses. 

Spraying  of  Combination  Newcastle- 
Infectious  Bronchitis  Vaccine  (UNH) 

Field  trials  were  carried  out  utilizing  the  Bi  strain  of  Newcastle  virus 
in  combination  with  the  strain  of  infectious  bronchitis  previously  described. 

The  first  spray  vaccination  utilizing  the  combination  of  Newcastle  and 
I)ronchitis  vaccines  took  place  on  a  farm  where  100.000  broilers  are  raised 
every  12  weeks,  and  50.000  breeders  are  kept  each  year.  Newcastle  disease 
was  a  very  serious  problem  on  this  farm,  for  it  had  experienced  outbreaks 
of  31  per  cent  and  85  per  cent  losses  in  the  past.  Infectious  bronchitis  and 
chronic  respiratory  diseases  were  also  a  definite  problem. 

Blood  samples,  taken  at  random  on  2-  or  3-day-old  chicks,  showed  a 
significant  H.I.  titre  in  88.7  per  cent  of  the  samples. 

The  inoculations  took  place  on  either  the  second  or  third  day  of  age. 
Respiratory  symptoms  were  observed  on  the  second  day  post  inoculation 
and  lasted  approximately  16.5  days. 

Random  samples  taken  at  intervals  of  4  weeks  presented  the  following 


geometric  mean  titres. 


11 


Table  3.     Results  of  Newcastle  Spray  at  Farm  No.  1 

Age  4  weeks  8  weeks  12  weeks 

Geometric  mean  litre  1.111  7.464  7.127 

At  ten  weeks  of  age,  two  groups  of  ten  Ijirds  were  withdrawn  for  chal- 
lenge purposes.  One  group  was  challenged  with  1000  infective  doses  of  a 
held  strain  of  infectious  bronchitis,  employing  .2  cc.  intratracheally.  One 
bird  showed  respiratory  symptoms  against  challenge.  In  the  other  group, 
wdiich  was  challenged  with  the  Boney  strain  of  Newcastle  virus,  two  birds 
showed  paralysis. 

The  mortality  from  all  causes  on  the  100.000  liroilers  was  2.3  per  cent 
for  three  weeks  following  vaccination. 

According  to  serological  test,  adequate  parental  immunity  was  present 
in  chicks  hatched  from  the  spray-vaccinated  parents.  These  chicks  were 
spray-vaccinated,  showing  a  geometric  mean  titre  of  16.14  at  day-old,  with 
95.0  per  cent  of  the  samples  tested  for  bronchitis  antilxxlies.  neutralizing 
100  or  more  neutralizing  doses  of  an  embryo-adapted  bronchitis  virus. 

During  the  past  two  years  over  3,000,000  birds  have  been  vaccinated 
in  the  State  of  New  Hampshire,  with  over  200  individual  farms  having  been 
involved.  The  size  of  the  flocks  ranged  from  100  to  100,000  chicks. 
Brooding  systems  of  various  types  were  used  on  these  farms.  Management 
conditions  of  all  types  were  also  encountered.  The  age  of  the  chicks  ranged 
from  1  to  7  days  at  the  time  of  vaccination. 

The  mortality  figures  on  the  entire  number  of  birds  sprayed  averaged 
2.4  per  cent.  This  figure  includes  losses  from  all  causes,  not  merely  losses 
resulting  from  the  vaccination  alone.  At  one  period  during  the  fall  and  early 
winter  of  1953,  the  average  mortality  was  3.1  per  cent,  but  a  change  in  the 
technique  at  that  time  lowered  the  mortality  figures.  The  figures  for  the 
three  months  following  presented  an  average  mortality  from  all  causes  of 
1.9  per  cent. 

The  symptoms  appeared  on  an  average  of  three  days  post  inoculation. 
Such  symptoms  were  generally  mild  and,  in  isolated  instances,  went  un- 
noticed. The  average  length  of  symptoms  was  approximately  17  days. 

Blood  samples,  taken  at  the  time  of  vaccination,  and  at  4-week  intervals 
thereafter,  exhibited  the  following  geometric  mean  ])attern.  (Samples 
labeled  as  day-old  may  actually  be  from  2-  to  3-day-old  chicks,  but  in  all 
instances  they  are  pre-inoculation  titres.) 

Table   4.     Results   of   Newcastle    Spray   When   in   Combination   with    Infectious 

Bronchitis 

(Pre-Inoc.) 
Age  Day-Old  Weeks 

4  5-8         9-12       13-16       16-19        20-f 

Gcometric  mean  titre         15.32         7.52         6.97         8.82         121         4.34         18.24 
Positives  86.8%     76.7%      72.57^     73.0%     75.67c     70.5%       91.8% 


'o 


Serum  neutralization  tests  for  Newcastle  disease  antibody,  while  of 
necessity  very  limited,  demonstrated  that  76.8  per  cent  neutralized  100  or 
more  neutralizing  doses  of  an  embr}o  adapted  Newcastle  virus  strain  at  16 
weeks  of  age. 

12 


Fi 


2£ 


a* 


gu 


iqure 


m 


111 

2i 

QC 

h- 

ao 

l— 

^ 

le 

<: 

lij 

5: 

16 

0 

14- 

a- 

f- 

1^ 

LU 

2: 

0 

10 

LU 

^ 

RESULTS  OF  NEWCASTLE  VACCINATION 

By   SPRAY 

(months) 


UNH    SPRAY      

PARENTAL    IMMUWIT/  — ^ 
MO    REVACCI  NATION 


MONTHS 


O 
Ct: 


O 

Li_) 


Figure  GZ 

!  RESULTS  OF  NEWCASTLE  VACCINATION 
i  BY  SPRAY 


(weeks) 


UNH     SPRAY  — 

COMMERCIAL      SPRAY    —  - 
PARENTAL    INMUNiry   -  — 


1  a. 

PAPENT/M-    ■^' 


WEEKS 


13 


The  serology  on  the  infectious  bronchitis  presented  the  data  indicated 
in  Figures  3  and  4.  Individual  blood  samples  were  used. 

The  results  on  the  graphs  show  that  74.2  per  cent  of  the  samples  neu- 
tralized 100  neutralizing  doses  or  better  at  day-old:  85.7  per  cent  at  4 
weeks,  84.2  per  cent  at  5-8  weeks,  89.0  per  cent  at  9-12  weeks,  73.5  per  cent 
at  13-16  weeks,  96.6  per  cent  at  17-20  weeks,  and  96.7  per  cent  at  20  weeks 
or  more.  The  reason  for  the  higher  percentage  of  positives  at  16  weeks  and 
beyond  is  the  result  of  revaccinations  carried  out  from  16  to  20  weeks. 

At  the  time  blood  samples  were  withdrawn  for  serological  purposes, 
birds  were  also  withdrawn  for  challenge.  The  ages  of  the  challenge  birds 
ranged  from  4  to  16  weeks.  The  results  are  shown  in  Table  5. 


Table  5.     Results  of  Bronchitis  Challenge 

Vaccinates 
Number  Birds         Symptoms 

Controls 
Number   Birds 

Symptoms 

Group 
Group 
Group 

I 

II 

III 

25                             0 
20                              1 
25                             0 

2 
2 
2 

2 
2 
2 

Table  6.     Results  of  Newcastle  Challenge 

Vaccinates 
Number  Birds             Died 

Controls 
Number  Birds 

Died 

Group 
Group 
Group 

I 

II 

III 

25                           2 
20                           2 
25                           3 

2 

2 
2 

2 
2 
2 

One  hundred  thirty-eight  chicks,  found  to  be  susceptible  to  Newcastle 
disease  at  4  weeks  of  age  by  random  sampling,  were  spray-vaccinated  at 
the  age  of  4  weeks.  Two  birds  died  during  the  period  of  symptoms.  Twelve 
random  samples  taken  at  6  weeks  of  age  exhibited  a  geometric  mean  titre  of 
14.25.  confirming  previous  work  (8)  that  older  birds  develop  higher  levels 
of  antibody  than  young  chicks.  Six  samples  run  on  S.  N.  tests  for  infectious 
bronchitis  antibody  showed  that  one  sample  neutralized  10  neutralizing 
doses,  one  sample  100  neutralizing  doses,  and  4  samples  1000  neutralizing 
doses.  The  numbers,  while  of  necessity  small,  indicate  susceptible  birds  pro- 
duce a  higher  titre  upon  vaccination. 

Discussion 

There  is  one  period  in  the  life  of  a  chicken  when  carefully  controlled 
factors  result  in  optimum  conditions  for  life  and  growth.  This  period,  when 
variables  are  more  constant  than  at  any  other  time,  is  when  the  chicks  are 
being  brooded  under  the  hover.  It  is  at  this  time,  when  the  optimum  con- 
ditions exist,  for  any  early  age  vaccinations  to  be  carried  out. 

With  this  factor  in  mind,  early  field  trials  of  spray  vaccination  of  New- 
castle vaccine,  or  Newcastle  in  combination  with  infectious  bronchitis 
vaccine,  were  carried  out  from  2  to  3  days  of  age  in  some  cases.  Recent 
work  indicates  that  any  age  prior  to  production  may  be  satisfactory  for  vac- 
cination, however. 

14 


The  data  presented  in  this  hnlletin  was  gathered  entirely  from  the 
State  of  New  Hampshire,  a  state  on  the  eastern  seal)oard,  in  which  consid- 
erable poultry  population  exists  at  the  present  time. 

Birds  raised  on  some  farms,  according  to  random  samples,  possess  im- 
munity to  infectious  bronchitis  at  all  times.  This  situation  exists  because  of 
a  constant  exposure  to  the  virus.  The  majority  of  breeding  farms  do  not 
find  this  situation  to  exist,  and  as  a  result,  a  field  strain  of  bronchitis  is 
given  to  the  birds  prior  to  coming  into  egg  production.  The  general  picture 
of  breeding  flocks  in  Xew  Hampshire  is  that  practically  all  flocks  have  been 
exposed  to  bronchitis  either  by  artificial  means  or  by  naturally  occurring 
field  strains.  Consequently,  with  very  few  exceptions,  chicks  hatched  from 
these  breeding  flocks  possess  a  high  parental  immunity  during  the  first  week 
of  age.  Furthermore,  it  must  be  kept  in  mind  that  such  immunity  has  been 
stimulated  by  an  unmodified  strain.  Luginbuhl  demonstrated  immunity  to 
infectious  bronchitis  at  5  weeks  when  the  chicks  were  vaccinated  at  day-old 
intranasally  with  modified  infectious  bronchitis. 

As  may  be  seen  from  the  tal)le.  the  majority  of  chicks  hatched  from 
Xew  Hampshire  breeders  possess  high  parental  immunity  to  Newcastle 
disease.  The  practice  of  applying  Newcastle  vaccine  by  the  wing  web 
method  has  been  a  favorite  of  the  breeders  of  this  state.  In  the  presence  of 
this  high  parental  immunity,  however,  it  has  been  shown  to  be  possible  to 
infect  chicks  with  the  Bj  strain.  Hitchner  (5)  showed  that  it  was  possible 
to  do  so  at  an  early  age.  and  Markham  and  Bottorff  (TO)  proved  that  it  was 
possible  to  immunize  chicks  by  use  of  the  intranasal  or  intraocular  route  in 
tlie  presence  of  parental  immunity. 

Another  important  factor  to  be  mentioned  in  connection  with  the  pre- 
vious results  is  that  of  chronic  resi)iratory  disease.  It  has  l)een  determined 
by  the  oljservation  and  study  of  pipped  embryos  which  showed  enlarged 
hocks  and  caseous  material  in  the  air  sacs,  also  by  isolation  of  CRD  agents 
from  day-old  chicks,  that  the  incidence  of  CRD  in  the  chicks  hatched  in 
X"ew  Hampshire  is  exceedingly  high.  In  those  instances  in  which  high  mor- 
tality was  encountered  in  the  field  trials,  CRD  was  found  to  be  present  in 
over  90  per  cent  of  the  cases. 

While  it  was  originally  felt  that  the  chicks  to  be  spray  vaccinated  must 
possess  parental  immimity  to  infectious  bronchitis,  results  of  field  trials  and 
laboratory  trials  on  susceptible  chicks  would  seem  to  indicate  that  parental 
immunity,  while  desirable,  is  not  necessary.  From  all  observations,  the  in- 
dications are  that  the  CRD  complex  presents  the  biggest  problem  in  af- 
fecting the  results  of  any  mass  immunization  or  other  vaccination  pro- 
cedures todav. 


IS 


Summary 

1 .  It  has  been  demonstrated  that  mass  immunization  of  young  chicks 
with  the  l^i  strain  of  Newcastle  virus,  employing  spray  techniques,  is  a 
safe  method,  and  will  produce  sufficient  immunity  to  withstand  10  min- 
imum lethal  doses  of  Boney  Newcastle  disease  challenge  virus  at  approx- 
imately 12  to  16  weeks  of  age. 

2.  It  has  been  demonstrated  that  there  is  no  apparent  interference  in- 
volved in  the  combination  of  Blacksburg  strain  of  Newcastle  and  the  UNH 
strain  of  infectious  bronchitis  viruses  when  such  a  combination  vaccine  is 
administered  to  young  chicks  utilizing  the  spray  method  of  mass  im- 
munization. 

3.  It  has  been  demonstrated  that  mass  immunization  by  the  spray 
methods  of  a  combined  Newcastle-bronchitis  vaccine  is  a  safe  method  of 
vaccination  and  will  produce  sufficient  immunity  to  withstand  10  minimum 
lethal  doses  of  Boney  Newcastle  challenge  and  1000  infective  doses  of  field 
strain  of  infectiou.s  bronchitis  up  to  approximately  12  to  16  weeks  of  age. 

4.  It  has  been  demonstrated  that  the  spray  method  of  mass  immun- 
ization is  an  easy  and  rapid  method  of  vaccination.  One  man  may  vaccinate 
up  to  10.000  chicks  per  hour,  using  this  method,  depending  on  brooding 
conditions. 

References 

1.  Bankowski,  R.  A.  1950.  Further  Studies  /;/  vitro  Cultivated  Pheuinoenoeqhalitis 

(Newcastle  Disease)  Virus  and  Its  Use  as  a  Vaccine,  Vet.  Med.  45:  322-327. 

2.  Crawley,  J.  F.  1953.  Spray  Immunization  of  Broiler  Chicks  with   Combined 

Bronchitis — Newcastle   Disease   Live  \'irus   Vaccines.  25th   .Annual   Conf. 
Lab.  \\'orkers  Pullorum  Disease  Control. 

3.  Crawley,  J.  F.  and  Fahey,  J.  E.  1954.  The  Spray  Method  for  Bronchitis  and 

Newcastle  Disease  Vaccination.  Southwest  Vet.  7. 

4.  Fabricant,  J.  1951.  Studies  on  the  Diagnosis  of  Newcastle  Disease  and  In- 

fectious Bronchitis  of  Fowls.  IV.  The  Use  of  the  S  N  Test  in  Diagnosis 
of  Infectious  Bronchitis.  Cornell  Vet.  41:  68-80. 

5.  Hitchner,  S.   B.   1950.   Further   Observations  on  a   Virus   of   Low  Virulence 

for  Immunizing  Fowls  .Against  Newcastle   Disease   (Avian   Pneumoencc- 
phalitis).  Cornell  Vet.  40:  60-70. 

6.  Hitchner,  S.  B.  and  Reising,  G.   1952.  Flock  Vaccination  for  Newcastle  Di- 

sease by  Atomization  of  the  Bi  Strain  of  Virus.  Proc.  Bk.  Am.  Vet.  Med. 
Assoc:  258-264. 

7.  Hitchner,   S.   B.,  and  Johnson.   E.   P.   1948.   A   Virus   of  Low  Virulence  for 

Immunizing    Fowls    .\gainst     Newcastle     Disease      (Avian     Pneumoeno- 
cephalitis).  \'ct.  Med.  43:  525-530. 

8.  Jungherr,  E.  L.   and  Terrell,   N.   L.    1948.   Naturally   Acquired   Passive   Ini- 

munity  to  Infectious  Bronchitis  in  Chicks.  Am.  Jour.  Vet.  Res.  9:201-205. 

9.  Luginbuhl.  R.  E.  1952.  Studies  on  Serologic  Diagnosis  and  Immunization  of 

Avian   Infectious  Bronchitis.   Master's  Thesis,  University  of  Connecticut, 
Storrs,  Connecticut. 

10.  Markham.  F.  S.,  Bottorff,  C.  A.,  and  Cox,  H.  R.  1951.  The  Conjunctival 
.Application  of  Newcastle  Disease  Vaccine  (Intranasal  Type)  in  Paren- 
tally Immune  and  Susceptible  Chicks.  Cornell  Vet.  41:  267-282. 

16