SUCCESSFUL FAMILY LIFE
ON THE MODERATE INCOME
ITS FOUNDATION IN A FAIR START. THE
MAN'S EARNINGS. THE WOMAN'S CONTRIBU-
TION. THE COOPERATION OF THE COMMUNITY
LIPPINCOTT'S
HOME MANUALS
Edited by BENJAMIN R. ANDREWS, PH.D.
TEACHEBS COLLEGE, COLUMBIA UNIVEBSITT
CLOTHING FOR WOMEN
BY LAURA I. BALDT, B.S.
TEACHEBS COLLEGE, COLUMBIA UNIVEBSITT
454 pages, 7 colored plates, 262 illustrations in text
SUCCESSFUL CANNING AND PRESERVING
BY OLA POWELL
DEPARTMENT OF AGBICULTUBE, WASHINGTON, D. C.
370 pages, 4 colored plates, 153 illustrations in text
HOME AND COMMUNITY HYGIENE
BY JEAN BROADHURST, PH.D.
TEACHEBS COLLEGE, COLUMBIA UNIVEBSITT
428 pages, 1 colored plate, 118 illustrations in text
THE BUSINESS OF THE HOUSEHOLD
BY C. W. TABER
AUTHOR OF TABER'B DIETETIC CHARTS,
NURSES' MEDICAL DICTIONARY, ETC.
438 pages. Illustrated.
BY L. RAY BALDERSTON, B.S.
TEACHEB8 ^^ COLUMBIA Mnmar
450 pages, 1 colored plate, illustrated in text
MILLINERY w PBEPABATION
BY EVELYN SMITH TOBEY, B.S.
TEACHEBS COLLEGE, COLUMBIA UNIVEBSITT
LIPPINCOTT'S
FAMILY LIFE SERIES
Edited by BENJAMIN R. ANDREWS, PH.D.
TEACHEBS COLLEGE, COLUMBIA UNIVEBSITT
CLOTHING
CHOICE CARE COST
BY MARY SCHENCK WOOLMAN, B.S.
290 pages. Illustrated.
SUCCESSFUL FAMILY LIFE ON THE
MODERATE INCOME
247 pages BY MARY HINMAN ABEL
LIPPINCOTT S FAMILY LIFE SERIES
EDITED BY BENJAMIN R. ANDBEWS, PH.D., TEACHEBS COLLEGE, COLUMBIA UNIV.
•SUCCESSFUL FAMILY LIFE
"ON THE MODERATE INCOME
ITS FOUNDATION IN A FAIR START. THE
MAN'S EARNINGS. THE WOMAN'S CONTRIBU-
TION. THE COOPERATION OF THE COMMUNITY
BY
MARY HINMAN ABEL
LATE EDITOR OF THE JODBNAL OF HOME ECONOMICS
PHILADELPHIA AND LONDON
J. B. LIPPINCOTT COMPANY
COPYRIGHT, IQ2I, BY J. B. LIPPINCOTT COMPANY
FEINTED AT THE WASHINGTON SQUAEE PHI
BY J. B. LIPPINCOTT COMPANY
PHILADELPHIA, U. 8. A.
TO THE MEMORY
OF
ELLEN H. RICHARDS
;HS
PREFACE
THE following discussion is addressed to all those who are
inclined to give thoughtful attention to the present-day problems
of the family, an institution which is imperfect as man in his
development is imperfect, but which reflects every advance in social
standards, and is doubtless destined to be modified very profoundly
by further social evolution. Such progress will turn in part upon
the results of scientific inquiry.
Among those to whom the book may be of interest are pro-
fessional students of the social and economic aspects of the family,
home economics students in schools and colleges, men and women
who are trying to solve the problems of their own homes, and
groups of club women and others who are taking up part-time
studies of the home. While it has seemed desirable to draw illus-
trations from one group, that which is living on the "moderate"
income and made up of adults and dependent children, yet it is
hoped that principles are evolved which are applicable to many
other types and conditions. The whole object of the study is to
discover what are the factors of success in its best sense.
For those who are debarred from creative self-expression in the
recognized forms of art, there is yet the Art of Living, which
includes self-development, a use of all personal resources 'and an
adjustment of our relations to those near us and to the community.
For most people this art of living, especially as practiced in the
family group, must remain the greatest of all the arts.
The author's thanks are due to Dr. Edward T. Devine for the
use of five of the- family monographs gathered by his classes in
Social Economics in Columbia University, the facts and figures of
which have been arranged! on a uniform plan, to make com-
parison easy.
Grateful acknowledgment is made to many friends whose con-
tribution of data has broadened the fact basis of the book.
THE AUTHOK.
March, 1921.
CONTENTS
PAGE
I. CHARACTERISTICS OP THE MODERATE INCOME FAMILY 1
The Relation of the Moderate Income Group to Poverty
and Riches. The Power of Choice. Effect on Development
of Character and Leadership. Influence on the Children.
The Woman's Position. Financial Status of the Moderate
Income Family.
II. THE HIGHER VALUES IN FAMILY LIFE 9
The Normal or Standard Family Defined. The Family
Group. Its Determining Conditions. Standard of Living.
The Plan of Life. Family Building. The Child and the
Home. Adoption, Outright and Partial. Looking Ahead.
III. THE FINANCIAL PARTNERSHIP 17
Wages or Salary for Service. Interest or Rent on Property
Owned. Personal Services in the Home as Income. Social
Wealth as Source of Income. Illustrations of an Income.
Will the Family Cooperate? The Man's Part. Is the
Woman Equal to Her Assigned Part? Summary.
IV. MONEY INCOME AND PROPERTY OWNED 25
Wealth and Income Compared. The Fixed Income. Defi-
nition of Income. General Ignorance as to Income. Our
Sources of Knowledge. Six Income Groups. Summary
of Groups. The National Income Divided Among Families.
Comparison with Foreign Countries. The Purchasing Power
of the Income. Effect of the Standard of Living. Dis-
tribution of Property. Property Owned by the Moderate
Income Group.
V. THE START IN LIFE AS GIVEN BY THE PRECEDING GENERATION . . 35
Beginnings are Important. Debt is Dangerous. Illustrations
from Family Histories. Standards are Inherited. The
Older Way. Evils of the Dower. What Form Shall Sav-
ings Take? The Bequest. The Gifted Child. Personal
Saving. The Girl Must Save. Summary.
ix
CONTENTS
VI. THE HOUSEWIFE'S CONTRIBUTION AS BUYER AND MANAGER . . 43
The Importance of the Buyer. Power Over Production.
Power Over the Family Life. Measuring the Value of the
Buyer's Services. Standards. Knowledge of Values. The
Need of Training. The Scope of Her Knowledge. Who Now
Trains the Buyer? Knowledge, the Real Defence. Value of
Special Teaching. Start with the Budget Plan. Lists.
Cash or Credit. Cooperative Buying. The Spending Partner;
Her Qualifications. The Account Book. The Essential
Points. The Home-made Form. An Illustration. The
Family Diary. Help From the Bank. The Envelope System.
VII. THE HOUSEWIFE'S CONTRIBUTION THROUGH CONTROLLED
FINANCE — THE ALLOWANCE 59
Who Holds the Purse? The Man's View. The Woman's
Training. The Partnership Method. The Importance of
Frankness. The Children's Allowance. The Common Mis-
take. When Shall the Child's Allowance Begin? A Method
Suggested. Objections. Summary.
VIII. THE HOUSEWIFE'S CONTRIBUTION THROUGH HOUSEWORK 71
Is There a Better Way? One Kitchen or Fifty? The Indi-
vidual Home Will Persist. Housework vs. Business. The
Housewife's Advantage. Overhead Charges in Business. Are
Business Profits Too Large? Bread-making. The Laundry.
Other Economic Factors. The Personal Element. The
Housewife's Money Value to the Home. Other Than
Economic Reasons. Money and Variety. Better Household
Methods and Education. Sanitation. The Expert is Scarce.
Housework or Outside Earning. Housekeeping Compared
with Boarding.
IX. THE TIME ELEMENT IN HOUSEWORK 89
The Price Paid for Housework. Importance of Time Saving
to the Working Housekeeper. The Eight-hour Day. Re-
ducing the Amount of Work to be Done. The House as
Making or Saving Work. Adjustment of Present Housing.
Advice from Outside Needed. Arrangement of Equipment.
Labor-saving Devices. Fatigue in Housework. Scientific
Studies of Fatigue. Conditions for Work. Effect of Over-
work. Worry. Other Factors of Fatigue. Interest and
Variety. What Will the Housewife Do About It? The
First Use of Time Saved. Good Health a Requirement.
Intellectual and Social Needs. Housekeeping Standards.
The Need for Planning. The Clock as a Help. Cooperation
of the Family Where the Rules of Efficiency Do Not Apply.
Hospitality. In Conclusion.
X. THE MOTHER'S CONTRIBUTION IN RELATION TO HER CHILDREN 105
Letter from a Farmer's Wife. Letter from a Village Mother.
Development of the Child Through Household Activities.
Housework as a Teaching Plant. Precept Alone is Useless.
The Working Mother's Advantage. Personal Hygiene.
CONTENTS xi
Proper Speech. The Little Child. The School Child.
The Adolescent Boy and Girl. Advantages of Struggle.
The Part That Money Plays. The Boy and the Indian
Suit. The Value of This Service to the Family.
XI. THE COMMUNITY'S CONTRIBUTION IN PROMOTING HEALTH AND
IMPROVING LIVING CONDITIONS 119
Five Requirements. The Individual in the Community.
Modern Industrial Changes. Country Life. City Conditions.
The Family's Share in the City's Prosperity. Responsibility
of the Community for the Health of Its Members. Sanitation .
Losses from Preventable Illness and Death. The Rural
Health Problem. Lessons from the War. The Moderate
Income and the Care of Health. The Extension of the
Public Health Service. The Medical Inspector of the School
and the Visiting Nurse. The Hospital. Public Help to
Reduce the Cost of Food Materials. Food Distributors.
The Terminal Market. Cold Storage. What the Con-
sumer Can Do. Cooperation. Public Kitchens.
XII. COMMUNITY HELP IN RECREATION AND EDUCATION 132
The Playground and Recreation Association of America.
Ilural Recreation. Community Help in Music and Drama.
Singing Soldiers. Music in the Schools. Music as a Social
Force. Help from Trained Musicians. Dramatics. Sources
of Community Help. Community Help in Education.
Libraries. Industrial Training. Industrial Training for the
Housewife. Help Through the Home Economics Movement.
Public School Classes. Vocational Classes for Adults. How
Many are Reached? Subject Matter and Methods. Demon-
strations and Exhibits. The Permanent Home Bureau.
Questions That Will be Asked on Nutrition, on Household
Management, in Money Spending. Noble Impulse and Sec-
ond Wind. The Housewife Needs Advice. The Home Train-
ing of Children. The Importance of the Early Years.
XIII. THE FAMILY BUDGET 151
Use of the Word Budget. The Expense Account Versus the
Budget. Early Studies of the Budget. Engel's Laws and
Bondy Budget. Mrs. Richards' Suggested Division of the
Income. The Minimum Budget for Health and Decency.
The U. S. Thrift Budgets. How to Begin a Budget. Plans
and Purposes. A Budget that Does Not Know It is a Budget.
The Foundation of Success. An Advance in the Art of Living.
XTV. MINIMUM EXPENDITURE FOR THE NECESSITIES OF LIFE 163
Definition of the Minimum. Scientific and Social Studies.
Food Requirements. The Amount of Money Required. How
to Obtain Knowledge of Food and Housing Requirements.
Present Cost of Housing. Helps Toward Better Housing.
Minimum for Clothing. Instructions Required. Operating
Expenses. The Budget Plan Helpful.
xii CONTENTS
XV. THE SAVINGS FUND AND ITS USE 173
Saving Comes First, a New Idea. Thrift Habits Compared.
The Reasons for Saving Money. Economy Need Not be
Petty. What Form Shall Savings Take? Six Uses Considered.
Professional and Clerical Pursuits. Illustrations. Artisan
and Business Families. The Age of the Children in Relation
to Form of Family Savings. When the Children Begin to
Earn. The Individual's Income. The Uncertain Income.
XVI. SPENDING THE ADVANCEMENT FUND 182
Three Divisions. Health. The Open Forum. Honesty in
the Family Life. For Children the Budget Must be Visual-
ized. Three Rules for Success. The Dribbler. Money
Spending as an Educator. Spending as a Fine Art. There
is Never "Enough." Restatement.
XVII. SEVEN FAMILY HISTORIES 192
Standards that Apply to All Families Studied. Adjustment
of Prices to the Present Time. The Need of Family Budgets.
Subsistence Incomes and Our Knowledge of Them. The
Moderate Income Less Known. The True Value of Budgets.
A Plea for Budgets. Histories of Seven Actual Families.
XVIII. THE STANDARD OF LIVING 213
The Standard of Living Defined. Our Standard Compels Us.
Comparison with Living in Foreign Countries. Keeping Up
Appearances. The Standard of Living and the Family of
Moderate Income. First, Understand It. Two Ways of
Progress. Young People and the Standard of Living. Group
Action. An Individual Matter.
XIX. THE SATISFACTIONS OF LIFE 222
The Foundational Things. Limitations Fixed by the Income.
Pleasure in Work Together. Pride in the Home. Out-of-
door Life. Nature Study and Skill of Hand. Human Re-
lations. A British Instance. The Dinner Table. The
Father's Part. The Mother's Part. The Cheapest of All
Home Pleasures. Reading Aloud. Story Telling. Story
Telling by the Child. The Creative in Play. The Festival
Play. Music in the Family. Part Singing. The Outside
World. Free City Amusements. The Family in the
Country. Summary.
XX. THE LOOK AHEAD 240
What Changes are to be Expected? The Fair Start. The
Earner ana the Spender. The Household Occupations.
Public Help. We Penalize Parenthood. The Waste of the
Present System. Money Spending Important. Ample
Courses of Instruction in Home-making Needed. Society
Must Help.
SUCCESSFUL FAMILY LIFE
ON THE MODERATE INCOME
CHAPTER I
SOME CHARACTERISTICS OF THE MODERATE
INCOME FAMILY
WHAT is success and how are the great number of families
living on the average income in this country to win it? How are
they to obtain development and happiness? Are any principles
to be laid down, or examples cited? Are " disruptive tendencies "
as great as has been claimed?
Ethical discussions of home life abound, but except in studies
of the homes of the poor, economic conditions as affecting the
character of home life have not, perhaps, been given sufficient
weight. It may be that in the family groups above the poverty
line the reaction to> all that concerns the spending of the money,
what they choose as necessary and what they reject as non-essential,
will be found to be of great significance.
The Moderate Income Family. — In order that concrete illus-
trations may be furnished, especial attention will be given in the
discussions that follow to a definite type of family, that living on
a moderate income, the income that provides a margin of several
hundred dollars beyond the minimum, whatever that may be in
any time or place.
Its Relation to Poverty and Riches. — The first reason for
selecting this income group for study is that any solution of its
problems throws light on the condition of the great mass of 'families
living below this level. In the " moderate " income we have a sum
on which normal living as -possible, while what is below the ac-
knowledged minimum is more or less abnormal ; in the latter case
the income must be supplemented from various sources in order to
furnish even bare existence, while a good standard of health and
1
2 SUCCESSFUL FAMILY LIFE ON MODERATE INCOME
efficiency cannot possibly be" Maintained on it. In these pages there
is necessarily much dwelling on duty, for life on this income level
is not to be carried to success without a girding up of the loins;
but it is really in the light of privilege that we must regard the
possession of a yearly income which is some hundreds of dollars
beyond that subsistence line around which livet the great mass of
every nation, where every cent is mortgaged for the necessities of
life. Here is the dark background where dwell the true " prisoners
of poverty," those who are surrounded by walls so high as to shut
out early knowledge of opportunities and chances for training;
many of them living in what has been called " a state of economic
serfdom," It is from this dead-line of the grinding minimum
" where a man earns what he can and spends what he must " that
our family of the moderate income has escaped. Are they to feel
straightened on an income larger than that on which more than
three-fourths of the population live? If it is found difficult to
work out a condition of well-being for them, we shall have solid
grounds for knowing what a serious matter is life and develop-
ment for the families that have less.
The Power of Choice. — The second reason for selecting this
moderate income group for study is that we have here reached
conditions that make a broader education and development possible,
because this family has to a considerable degree the power of choice
over its expenditures. That is, after meeting the minimum require-
ment for food, shelter, and clothing, they may dispose of the rest
of their income as they will, as in adding to the attractions of the
table, in buying better dress, in providing more spacious living
quarters, or in gaining that feeling of freedom and relief from
care which >comes from provision against illness or old age, they
may help in some form of public welfare or buy books or hear good
music. The main thing as concerns this discussion is that none
of these outgoes shall be considered necessities, but as desirable
additions which must be weighed against each other since all cannot
be obtained.
Suppose, for instance, a family living on $2500 income be-
comes possessed of $3500. According to the usual practice, they
would move into a more expensive neighborhood and distribute
the extra $1000 over rent, operating expenses, dress, etc. They
SOME CHARACTERISTICS 3
have changed their scale of living, but they have not a penny more
of unmortgaged surplus than they had before. Is it not conceivable
that this family might conceal from their neighbors their rise in
fortune so as to dodge that tyranny expressed in the " standard of
living" or "what is expected of us" and sit down behind closed
doors to consider their treasure and to discuss the comparative
value of the many claims on it? In short, they might regard their
former expenditure of $2500 as covering necessary requirements,
and the recently gained $1000 as surplus, so that by intelligently
comparing all the proposed uses of it they may secure a better
living. By this method of comparing proposed expenditures every
item is given its measure in terms of something else, and money-
spending is thus removed from the ignominious region of the hap-
hazard; that is, if the line that separates needs from desires is
drawn even tentatively, this family possesses after necessities are
met, what may be spent in one way or another according to choice,
and this is the very foundation of that education in comparative
values which will raise them in the scale of living. Poverty has
been called an " automatic standardizer," the outlay is dictated by
the absolute needs of life ; you cannot waste what you do not possess ;
mistakes :begin in spending the surplus.
Effect on Development of Character and Leadership. — The
third reason for selecting this group for study is that the moderate
income affords probably the very best conditions for discipline, the
best stimulus for family development. Although, contrary to the
general impression, this income is relatively high in the general
scale, 88 per cent, of American families having in 1910 what was
below this level, yet it by no means affords all that is wanted and
the family possessing it will need to plan even more carefully than
the one below them in the scale, because of the higher requirements
upon them as to housing, dress and other items that meet the public
eye. Limitations are felt on all sides, and yet life is not so cramped
as to dull ambition. Conditions are thus favorable for development,
and from the past history of this and other countries it would seem
that such families will furnish a large proportion of the leadership
needed in a democracy. It has been found that from the farm, and
from business and professional families of moderate means the high
schools and colleges draw their largest quota; here is found the
4 SUCCESSFUL FAMILY LIFE ON MODERATE INCOME
keenest desire for learning and advancement. Fifteen years ago
Mrs. Richards said that the family living on $1500 to $3000 had
come to where they " could look on life historically and have some
mental equipment/'
This great middle group in America probably furnishes much
of the progressive power in society. Doorst of opportunity are
ajar, but they are to be pushed open only by that energy and initia-
tive which is best developed by difficulties, just as the jaw grows by
chewing and the hand by grasping and as the discipline of earning
and saving money may have high value for the individual. Accord-
ing to one investigation, out of one hundred executives responsible
for great business institutions, 75 per cent, were found to be
sons of farmers, laborers, teachers, doctors, country lawyers and poor
country preachers.1
Students of social conditions often record the conviction that
few human beings can be trusted to discipline themselves; they
need the spur and limitations furnished in the very conditions of life
where natural forces do the teaching, just as the farmer's boy learns
that if the plow is left out of doors it will rust, if the cow is not
well milked she will go dry. What is true of families seems to be
true of whole communities. Thomas N. Carver says : " The nations
which take their leisure in the form of frequent holidays, graceful
consumption (of goods), and elegant leisure have long since fallen
behind in the progress of civilization, while those nations which
have preserved a kind of emotional interest in the austere and
productive life, whose ideals of life have centered in the future
rather than in the present, have become the great nations in every
modern sense." 2
Influence on the Children. — It is this nearness to natural
conditions and forces which gives to the moderate income family
an immense advantage in the rearing of children. It seems prob-
able that a man who has been obliged from early youth to do some-
thing to contribute to the family resources, who has had to help
his father and mother, who has worked with his brothers and
sisters for some common end that all have enjoyed together, has
developed a very definite grasp of the facts of life in the only way
1 Roger W. Babson, Increasing Net Profits, p. 8.
8 War Thrift, T. N. Carver, p. 24.
SOME CHARACTERISTICS 5
in which it is gained ; that is, by actual practice and contact. Earn-
ing and spending are not, as with the rich, so widely separated that
their true relation is concealed. If a desired good cannot be
obtained until the money that represents it is earned the great
lesson of deferred enjoyment is being taught, as also the turning
away from a lesser good to wait for a greater.
Nor will there be much danger that a man thus brought up
will fail to understand the motives and feelings of that three-
fourths of our people who are below him on the ladder. " If
the Lord do prosper us in this place, the -poor shall taste of it,"
said Martha Crossley, as she passed through the yard of her
husband's woolen mills at four in the morning ; and it was her son,
Sir Francis Crossley, who gave its public park to the city of Halifax.
On the other hand, it may be that the conditions which go with
inherited wealth, or wealth which is easily amassed by the advantage
of a good start given by financial and social position, may dull the
conscience, and even the mind, toward any possible change in social
adjustments which promise to curtail the profits and privileges
of the few.
The Woman's Position. — Another reason for the importance
of this income group, making it worthy of study, is that the position
of the woman who presides over it is such that her normal develop-
ment and self-respect are assured if her character measures up to
the requirements. She contributes her full share to the support of
the family by her daily labor in the many ways that are needed for
its very existence and efficiency. She has a chance by and through
these activities, and in the leisure which her diligence and fore-
sight may gain for her, to contribute also the immaterial values
which create and feed the home spirit and bind the family together.
These contributions which she makes are so indispensable that her
value cannot be ignored and the result is that she, as much as
the man, determines the financial policy of the family and has
control of the necessary funds, just as the wife of the day laborer
expects to receive the pay envelope unopened. She thus plays a
self-respecting part and may obtain such power through it that
she is to be envied in many cases by wealthier women who are
" given " money at irregular intervals and without system, and who
have credit at stores rather than ready money in hand.
6 SUCCESSFUL FAMILY LIFE ON MODERATE INCOME
Financial Status of the Moderate Income Family. — There
were about a million and a half families in this country in 1910
with incomes of $1400 to $2000 a year, a sum that is equivalent in
buying power to probably $2500 to $3500 more or less in 1921.
This group, representing six per cent, of American families in
1910, forms in general what may be called " the moderate income
group " ; there should perhaps be added to it many families with
somewhat larger money incomes (that is, part of the group with
1910 incomes of $2000 to $5000, page 27)— all families, in fact, in
which the financial margin above the minimum is only enough
when supplemented by the housewife's full time service, to secure
some freedom in ordering the life.
These moderate income families in no way constitute a social
class, for they have widely varying standards1 of living and draw
their support from many different occupations; but there is one
great point of agreement, they have about the same amount of
money to spend. The financial status of this family is perhaps most
accurately described by saying that they have one and a half to
two or three times as much as is required to meet primary needs as
expressed in the minimum or " fair living wage," which before the
war was placed at $800-$900 and is estimated in 1921 to be $1500
or more for the city family of five members.
With war and post-war shifting of wages and prices and without
the aid of a digest of the figures furnished in the 1920 census and
income tax, it is not possible to state with more exactness the
present income of this group of families. The relative position
to the rest of the community of a group that possesses several hun-
dred dollars beyond the estimated minimum, whatever that may be,
will, however, be very little changed, and the proportions of an
income spent to cover various needs and desires will remain a
rather constant phenomenon, since our decision as to what we must
have and what we can go without depends on habits and standards
that do not fluctuate with the market reports.
It is by virtue of the surplus possessed above the recognized
sum needed for health and efficiency that these families, whose
method of living we are to consider, will be able to secure a certain
better quality of life.
It cannot be claimed that the " statistical " xf amily of five living
SOME CHARACTERISTICS <
on a $2500 income is representative in every respect of a large group
in this country. It may, however, serve as a point of departure for
estimating the needs, the desires, and the assets, so to speak, of the
families that go to make up what we might call, were we to use
the European term, our " middle classes." The family group may
be larger or smaller ; its standards may range between those of the
skilled workman and the college professor; the income in question
may be held for only a brief period in the life of a family ; but what
must be taken from this income more or less to cover the absolute
necessities of life has been estimated by government experts and
others, while the standards and circumstances which will influence
what use shall be made of the amount of money left over after these
needs are met is a legitimate subject of inquiry.
Granted that this family group on the moderate income has
a great opportunity, it is fair to enquire whether it does in fact
set ideals for the rest of society as to upright and honest living,
as to sane recreation, as to desirable expansion along the best lines
when resources increase? Is the training of its children really
better than that seen on the poorer or the richer levels? Do the
adults make themselves felt as valuable members of the community ?
Our answer to such questions can not be according to our acquaint-
ance with a few individual families. In the following pages an
effort will be made to show that successful family life is possible to
this income group if certain conditions are afforded. These con-
ditions or requirements may be stated as follows, and their discus-
sion will follow in later chapters:
The Four Conditions for Success. — 1. The money income of
the family tolerably certain and earned wholly or chiefly by the man.
2. A fair start in life for the heads of this household, includ-
ing wholesome liome training, education, both general and voca-
tional, and money enough, or things of money value, furnished
chiefly from their own savings, to enable them to meet with courage
the financial problems that present themselves, especially in the
difficult early years of married life.
3. The right attitude of the woman of the family toward her
part in its success, with a growing capacity to meet its requirements.
4. Generous help on the part of the community in promoting
the success of the family.
8 SUCCESSFUL FAMILY LIFE ON MODERATE INCOME
QUESTIONS
1. What is your estimate, without reference to census reports, of the num-
ber of these moderate income family groups in the United States —
one-half, one-fourth, or what part of the total number? Look over
your own community in trying to estimate.
Is it probable that family groups with a few hundred dollars more
than the actual requirements of life will increase relatively to the
whole population — if so, how increase? by the poorer people getting
more, or the rich getting less?
2. Is this group more dependent for its well-being than those of higher
income on forces beyond its control? Is any form of united action
likely to increase its independence?
3. Do you agree with the text that the woman's position in families
living on this income scale is a good one?
4. If you personally think that the world owes you more than you are
getting, make a list of your contributions to society and estimate
their value.
5. What large choices or decisions has your family made in the past, the
effects of which can be traced in its present standards of living?
6. What seem to you the worst results of too small an income upon the
family receiving it?
7. What are the chief dangers to the family from opulence?
8. As your own family's income has changed in the past, what changes
were made in the scale of living? Can you trace any changes in
the spirit of the family?
9. See if you can define any characteristics of the moderate income family
as illustrated by families within your observation.
10. Look over the list of successful men in your community — how many
inherited wealth, and how many rose out of the " middle class " ?
Or, examine the first one hundred names in " Who's Who," or some
similar compilation.
CHAPTEE II
THE HIGHER VALUES IN FAMILY LIFE
The Normal or Standard Family. — The phrases the "nor-
mal " family and the " standard " family will be often used in
these pages, and they require explanation. Families are of all
sizes, and since a given income expresses a greater degree of well-
being when spent for the smaller group, students of social con-
ditions find it important to standardize the family unit> so that
comparisons can be made on the same basis.
The International Statistical Congress, meeting in Brussels
in 1855, defined the standard family as " father, mother and four
children between two and sixteen/' The United States Commis-
sioner of Labor in 1891, from a study of 2132 families, gave the
membership of the typical American family as 5.7. The Eighteenth
Annual Report of the Commissioner of Labor in 1903 on the " Cost
of Living and Retail Prices of Food/' in a study of 25,440 families
(104,108 persons), defines the normal family as one which has
the husband at work; a wife, not more than five children, and
none over fourteen years of age; no dependent, boarder, lodger
or servant.
In recent years the agreement seems to be that the normal family,
as concerned with statistical inquiries, consists of father, mother,
and three dependent children. It has also been called the " census
family." The statesman, the economist, all those who take broad
views of national development, think of the community as composed
of these family groups which conserve the means of life and make
ready the next generation. Statistical enquiries, such as those con-
ducted on a large scale by the United States Department of Labor,
are concerned not with individuals, but with the normal family.
The Family 'Group. — In actual life the family group may be
united by ties of blood or of friendship, but to meet our ideal of
a family it is not enough that the same roof shelter them and that
they eat at the same table; we do not call the inmates of a hotel
9
10 SUCCESSFUL FAMILY LIFE ON MODERATE INCOME
or boarding house a family, although they may be so regarded
by the census taker. The group must be small enough to have
common interests, and the closer those interests, the nearer the
group comes to the ideal relationship.
Of all normal social relations the most important is that which
exists between a man and woman and their own children, what we
call the true family group. It has been the soul and center of early
settlements and the solid foundation of civilized states.
Its Determining Conditions. — What are the determining con-
ditions of the home and family at various times?
Our American ancestors seem to have been able to compass
normal living in this regard; in general they early chose their
mate, established a home and raised a family, although the comforts
that have become daily necessities for this generation were then
unheard-of luxuries. In the communities which they founded,
public sentiment favored family life as the means by which men
and women could best provide for their most pressing needs. Homes
were centers of production, each one was a factory, and of all its
products, the child, the potential worker, was perhaps the most
valuable. It was easier for young people to marry than not to do
so when public opinion favored it, when for the women most avenues
of money earning were closed and for men there were few inns,
and no 'dubs, and when the most ordinary ^comforts and pleasures
were obtainable only in the home. The woman's economic contribu-
tion to such a home was without question; she not only did the
housework in the modern sense of caring for the daily needs of the
family, but she was a producer of cloth, food and other things which
were of marketable value and whose sale added to the income.
Economic conditions, especially the cost of living, are the very
foundation of variations in the marriage rate. Statisticians have
found that a distinct relation could be traced between that rate and
the price of wheat in England and of rye on the continent. As
civilizations develop and individuals require more and more of life,
and are besides better served by society outside the home than was
formerly the case, the matter is less simple. One economist, Ely,
gives a jiarrow but suggestive definition of the standard of living
as " the number and character of the wants which a man considers
more ^important than marriage and family." That is, he may make
THE HIGHER VALUES IN FAMILY LIFE 11
sure that this standard of life is obtainable for himself and his
family before he can " afford " to marry ; he may otherwise elect
to hold this standard for himself alone. This attitude, once so
familiar, has a strangely old-fashioned sound, as it wholly ignores
the woman's part in the decision. She may not quail before risks
and privations, she may have more daring and initiative, be more
resourceful than the man himself in a difficult situation.
Standards of Living. — All material and social advances in
the standard of living in the community may enter into the decision
when a home is undertaken, and these advances up to a certain
point place the home on a higher level of achievement, while
beyond -this point of comfort and efficiency high standards of
living may be an enemy of home making, deferring it for years or
perhaps making it forever impossible. The decisions that concern
these standards are of great importance, as the choice of what ones
are necessary for health and decency and reasonable comfort, as
compared with what are dictated by meaningless and tyrannical
custom. What are these things in the household which represent
that "tithing of mint, anise and cummin/' and what are the
" weightier matters of the law " ?
The Plan of Life. — Suppose the home to have been started,
what is the plan of life ? Will it endure, and will it produce those
immaterial values which round out life to an organic whole, those
values which cannot be weighed and measured, but which lie back
of all the comings and goings, all the daily plans ? In short, why
a home at all ? Adult experience does not hesitate to predict that
the married couple without unselfish plans and purposes of some
sort are apt to drift toward superficial pleasures, and if these pleas-
ures are not the same for both man and woman, they sometimes
develop different ways of life and thus fall apart.
Family Building. — But there is at least one aim that will
unite the two and which promises permanence. If they undertake
from the first what has been nobly called " family building," they
have a common interest of an engrossing character, one which
stimulates the very best that is in them. To look forward into
other lives, and to plan fruitful relations to the community, may
unite the lovers by new bonds in line with natural development.
There is wisdom in realizing the dangers that beset even ideal
12 SUCCESSFUL FAMILY LIFE ON MODERATE INCOME
personal relations unrelieved by other interests; children are the
natural buffers in married life. With their birth ought to begin
for the parents that wider education for the family's permanent
place in the scheme of things, an education which becomes im-
portant according as it is intelligently chosen and pursued.
Even if the ends sought in the home are not always gained, here
at least is the opportunity. The home at its best, or even at its
second best, is a wonderful tiling, the place in which social and
domestic instincts are cultivated, where there may be mutual under-
standing and sympathy in success or in failure. Here is the cooper-
ating group, here is the extension of oneself, a chance to do for
others and to be done for, with its wholesome check or rank indi-
vidualism, and its training for team work in the social and business
world. Here is the sense of security, the retreat from outside
annoyances, a place to recreate ourselves for labor.
The family is really a way of living that may enhance what is
put into it, it gives more life to all; if all contribute of their best
they receive more than their best, transformed by that world-old
alchemy which may make the home of the poorest a glowing center
of comfort and cheer, where may be found that "warm, easeful
feeling " which the homesick child pines for in absence, which fills
the adult with deep content and comforts the old. The charm
of home is found in this chance for growth and development in an
atmosphere of affection; it is by no means perfect, but the best
way yet devised for meeting human needs, and the reward which
its founders may expect for their labors. All of us discover finally
that we must do our share in building up some form of home
life ; a home has much to do with our happiness and our usefulness
in the wonderful years between thirty and sixty for which youth
seldom realizes that it must prepare.
The Child and the Home. — All ages and degrees of experience
may contribute to the enrichment of home life, but the contribution
made by the child is probably the most important. All men and
women, whether they marry or not, should bear some vital relation
to a home, and preferably a home in which there are children. How
adults need the intimate personal touch with youth they do not
themselves always realize; still less do they realize their own duty
to youth or how to perform it. It was said of Robert Owen, that
THE HIGHER VALUES IN FAMILY LIFE 13
remarkable man who conducted a hundred years ago the first infant
schools in Great Britain, that "he looked with royal eyes on
children." When we come to realize what the community has at
stake in the proper development of its children, that here is in
reality the only hope of the future, we shall find better ways of
serving them, not only our own children in our own homes, but
children in imperfect household relations.
Adoption Outright and Partial. — Adoption of children by
unmarried as well as married people should become much more
common than it is ; a small group adopting and supporting several
children seems to be a method also worth trying. This matter of
adoption is now brought to the front because of the losses of war
which will leave many orphans and enforce celibacy on great num-
bers of the women of Europe and to a smaller degree on our
own women.
A less exacting relation, what might be called partial adoption,
by which an adult becomes the intimate friend and helper of a child
or a family of children, deserves to be recognized at its full value;
a relationship depending on tact and affection, and giving a service
which has been the salvation of many an overworked or puzzled
parent. The adult who craves an hour's visit from an attractive
child because of the entertainment it affords does not always realize
that the child has been fed and clothed and cared for by other
hands, and that for this hour of pleasure a real debt has been
incurred to the parent. Why should not this adult friend of the
family undertake seriously to help some department of the child's
education ? For instance, a child who is invited to visit for some
days in a family with standards like its own home is shown that
others value the same refinements and hygienic laws, and this re-
sults in the home requirements being met with a better spirit of
cooperation, and the parents' task is thus lightened. When are we
to realize that the child is to be served by all the forces of society ?
It may be mentioned that those interested in adopting children
should get in touch with such modern agencies as The State Chari-
ties Aid Society of New York. The " Big Brother " and "Big
Sister " movements are vital efforts in the line of partial adoption.
As to how children of unknown parentage will "turn out,"
students of human heredity are ever reminding us that, always
Id SUCCESSFUL FAMILY LIFE ON MODERATE INCOME
excepting the feeble-minded, there is no means of predicting the
natural abilities and characteristics of the children of any given
ctiuple; in short, the adopted child may turn out as well as our
own or better.1
Another side to this matter of adoption was well expressed in
the remark " There is no doubt of your need of the child, but what
of the child's need ? Can you fill it ? " The serious study of child
life is to broaden and increase, and there will be no more earnest
students of it than some of these foster parents.
Looking Ahead. — Anything of such priceless value as success-
ful family life is worth effort. Each generation will seek the higher
or imponderable values in family life in a different way, but the
best are all gained slowly as a matter of growth and of conscious
effort; there must always be a long look ahead even into old age,
a knitting of relationships and an accumulation of experiences that
contain elements of permanence and provide enrichment of the
emotional life. This requires in the members of a family patience
and unselfishness, and, perhaps above all, the live-and-let-live toler-
ance that makes allowance for the individual and yet requires
cooperation for general ends ; in short, an acceptance of the modern
view of equal partnership between the man and the woman in enjoy-
ment and in work whatever may be its form, and, above all, a
recognition of the duty to raise sound children who will play their
part in the national life. A rich family life is not an accident,
it is earned.
This economic and social unit that we know as the family is
always being assailed ; it is said that its economic foundation is gone,
that it is the enemy of individual rights, that all of its products are
unsatisfactory. It is not in the scope of this book to enter into
the debate, but it must be admitted by all that the family is an
extremely persistent type, the only way of living that is eternally
to be reckoned with, the one to which society always swings back after
times of abnormal stress and hectic experiments. Changes and
adjustments are being made, but they seem to modify rather than
upset in any fundamental way the institution " out of which men
and women have gotten the most hope, dignity and joy; the place
1 Suggestions from Modern Science Concerning Education, H. B.
Jennings, 1918, p. 11.
THE HIGHER VALUES IN FAMILY LIFE 15
through which, whatever its failures and illusions, they get the
fullest development, and the opportunity to render the most useful
social service."
If one may venture into a field that has been injured by cheap
sentimentality, it would be to express the conviction that this insti-
tution we call the family has before it a future greater than we
have dreamed, for home life at its best, like religion, is yet to be
tried. Better means of developing human beings are to be dis-
covered, but to apply and work out these methods science will need
the cooperation' of affection, patience and other personal qualities
that have always nourished in the home.
To produce these imponderable values in home life is largely
the privilege of the woman, and it may be recognized as a true
economic function since it adds to the " pleasure-giving power of
commodities." In the family of the income level which we are
considering, she will, in general, contribute these values by and
through her daily services, which may be held, indeed, to be the
natural medium through which she establishes that close cooperation
and understanding with her family. To work and play together
with common aims and interests, to serve and be served in small
daily ways, is to weave the strong fabric of many threads which
symbolizes the ideal family relation.
Summary. — The establishment of the family group will be
influenced by the standard of living at any given time, and the
plan of life which includes " family building" would seem to be
the one which offers the best promise of permanence and success.
No contribution to family life is so great as that offered by the
child, and all adults should have some relation to a home in which
there are children. Adoption, either outright or partial, is the
privilege of those to whom childhood makes a strong appeal, and
is to be strongly recommended.
QUESTIONS
1. Name a few marks of successful family life, that is, such marks as
casual acquaintances would agree on.
2. If family life is unsuccessful, who suffers besides the family itself?
Just what interest have we in the success of families other than
our own?
16 SUCCESSFUL FAMILY LIFE ON MODERATE INCOME
3. How long a time is necessary to measure family success? Are con-
ditions affecting children and grandchildren a part of this meas-
ure ? Illustrate.
4. Make a mental survey of five successful families that you have known.
Also five unsuccessful. What are the leading traits in each group?
Can you account for the difference in the outcome?
5. Mention three material satisfactions which the individual usually
secures through the family. Arrange in order of importance. Com-
pare with the quality, cost and ease of obtaining them elsewhere.
Are any of these essential to a real home?
6. Compare the life of students in a college dormitory with that of stu-
dents living in their respective homes.
7. Compare hotel life with family life for adults and for children. What
adults have you in mind?
8. Give concrete individual instances of values that have accrued to you
from living in your own home. What personal values came to your
parents from your being a member of the home?
9. If you were running an orphan asylum what would you do to make
it as much as possible like a home?
10. Are the " higher values " exclusively the product of family life ? What
is contributed by the school, the church?
11. In starting a home what ideals do you think should be adopted?
12. Is the childless home an unsuccessful home in a social sense? To
what extent? What may a childless couple do to broaden their
lives, besides adopting children?
13. Do you consider that the limitations of the moderate income are
really incentives to ambition, as has been claimed, or do they bring
discouragement? Illustrate from any families that you may know.
14. If you have knowledge of any family for three successive generations,
indicate the degree of success reached, financial and otherwise, and
give what you consider to be the reasons for either success or failure?
15. Have young people away from home any responsibility for contributing
to their parents' happiness? In what ways can they meet it?
16. What contribution can the schools make, through the children, to home
happiness ?
17. Do teachers sufficiently realize their duty to combat modern tendencies
toward the disintegration of family life? Illustrate.
18. Suggest five " dont's " that will promote family happiness.
CHAPTER III
THE FINANCIAL PARTNERSHIP
INCOMES are earned by individuals, but in the great majority
of cases they are distributed in a family group and spent to meet
general as well as personal needs.
The financial partnership, or the right cooperation in the earn-
ing and spending of the money, is as important as that emotional
and social partnership whose product is what we have called the
higher values in family life. It underlies them indeed and makes
them possible.
The sources of family income are more numerous than is
generally supposed; including the equivalents of money there are
at least four such sources.
Wages or Salary for Economic Service. — Money wages or
salary received by the day, month or year is generally the most
important source of the family income, whether received for physical
strength or skill of hand in actual production of things of value, or
through the thousand ways known to business by which labor and
its results are grouped, utilized or distributed; or as received for
services rendered by teacher, doctor, lawyer and others who all have
their place in a complicated society.
Interest and Rent on Property Owned. — Rent or interest
makes the next important contribution to the money income. It
may be in the form of rental for a house owned by the family, or
interest on a Liberty Bond or on a deposit in the savings bank,
or on a mortgage on land or other investment.
This form of income may represent the combined family savings,
that for which the members have worked together. A chance to
invest safely and profitably is said to be the greatest incentive to
thrift. This form of income arises from property permanently
held and it thus has an element of stability not possessed by the
weekly or monthly pay for services rendered. Since income from
property furnishes a certain security independent of personal earn-
ing power, it is well for a family to derive part of its money from
2 17
18 SUCCESSFUL FAMILY LIFE ON MODERATE INCOME
this source. Gifts and inheritance should be considered additions
to property rather than a part of recurrent income derived from
wages or interest.
Property owned and kept for family use rather than rented for
money may be said to contribute a "use" income of value equal
to the cost of renting similar property. Do not the owned home,
the furnishings, the automobile, etc., add to the real income secured
in terms of this factor which may be called " use income " ?
Personal Services in the Home as Income. — The third source
of income is in the form of unpaid personal services contributed
by members of the family. These all swell the actual income, even
though they are not estimated or recognized at their full money
value. When the man of the family relieves the stoppage in the
kitchen waste pipe, he may be said to add to his income the $4 or $5
that would have gone to pay the plumber's bill for this service.
He may construct a storage closet in his cellar on Saturday after-
noons, or till a garden or mow his lawn, and in each case this service
adds to his income the money that would hire it from other hands.
If he shaves himself, he contributes an easily calculated sum
per year.
These personal services to the home represent not only a money
value, but standards of living, to attain which the members are
willing to make an effort; also when rendered by young people,
they are nearly all of educational character.
The children of the family make contribution to the income
when they help with the housework or do errands, or keep the
premises in order. Beginning when very young, children may
learn to be helpful with the idea that their services contribute to
the well-being of the home. As these services come to be of sub-
stantial character, they are not to be taken as a matter of course
by the parents, but their money value should be recognized and
perhaps devoted to some special purpose, such as to help furnish
pleasures for the family. As soon as the youthful imagination can
be brought to bear on the subject, the value of these services may
be used to begin the fund which is dedicated to education or the
start in life. It will be noted that in the families whose financial
history is given in Chapter XVIII, the parents are in the prime
of life and best able to bear their burden, but their earning power
THE FINANCIAL PARTNERSHIP 19
will decrease and the time will come when such a fund accumulated
through small earnings and gifts may be absolutely necessary to
give the children help in education or a start in business.
The woman of the family has the chance to make so large a
contribution to this third source of income that the subject will
be separately treated. Every material thing that comes into the
house may be increased in value by her labor or her intelligence.
The furniture bought reflects her knowledge and taste; the fifty-
cent steak acquires the restaurant value of a dollar and a half when
broiled and served, the bag of flour when made into loaves of bread
becomes worth two or three times as much as it cost ; the cleanliness
and order needed for the comfort of the family is due to her, and
the value of the service may be stated in the terms of current
wages for such work. In short, the labor of the woman of the
family as buyer, manager, houseworker, teacher and trainer of
children must all be regarded as of money value and a true addition
to the family income. That is, all these services would cost a
calculable amount of money if they were hired, and it is taken
for granted that they would be hired, for the family on the moderate
income in this country possesses the standards of living which
require all these services; whereas, in the home of the very poor,
where the woman works outside to help buy the necessities of life,
the household arts are little practiced, and there is no question of
standards, the children being brought up on the streets, as may be
seen in the slums of any city.
Social Wealth as Source of Income. — The fourth source of
family income is from the use and enjoyment of what is called
accumulated social wealth, common examples of which are smooth
roads, good water provided at public expense free, or nearly free,
for use in house, street or garden, paved streets kept clean by the
city, parks and recreation grounds. In New York City, for in-
stance, for a five-cent fare a man has the use of a subway provided
by a municipal investment of many millions. To this must be
added the immense machinery of free education by schools, libraries,
free concerts and art galleries. It must be remembered that even
where a fee is charged, as for college courses, the fee pays but a
part of the actual cost of the education afforded; individuals,
municipalities, state and nation have provided buildings, outfit
20 SUCCESSFUL FAMILY LIFE ON MODERATE INCOME
and funds. In one year New York State gave over $100,000,000
to education.
Formerly the city dweller had an immense advantage in this
fourth source of income over the rural citizen, but education and
material assistance for the farmer and the dweller in small towns
have now taken many forms and will be more and more generously
supported by the government. The rural traveling library is mak-
ing great headway in some states, and the same may be said of the
rural hospital which will serve a fifty-mile radius.
Illustration of an Income. — All these sources of income may
not apply to all families, but the illustrations are here given to show
that the family on the moderate income is much better off financially
than the man's earnings would indicate. The following attempt to
name the money value of these various additions to the income can
be no more than suggestive :
1. A man's income as clerk in a village store may be $1800;
this is the money in hand, the steady, main reliance of his family.
2. If there has been a good start in life so that the family can
begin saving from the first, they should own after fifteen or twenty
years, say, a house and lot, house furnishings, and perhaps in addi-
tion, some other investment; in any case a life insurance. From
these sources there may come as a fair 'average over twenty years
from $200 to $500 income a year, generally in the form of rent.
The! city dweller for whom house owning may be impossible,
should have an equivalent in the savings bank or in some other
safe investment.
3. The personal services of the family, the wife being the chief
contributor, cannot be estimated at present prices of labor at less
than $1000 to $1500 in the country or small town; somewhat less
in the city, at least as far as the children's contribution is concerned.
The laboring man's wife has been estimated to contribute by her
services some $800 a year, and this at pre-war prices of service.
4. The contribution from the aggregated social wealth will vary
so greatly that it is difficult to estimate it, but its solid value for the
enjoyment of life may be seen in the class of citizens which a pro-
gressive community will attract, as compared with one which
is backward.
It is a conservative statement that the money income as earned
THE FINANCIAL PARTNERSHIP 21
by the man of the family may be more than doubled by the other
sources of income. Therefore the moderate income family which
we are considering is actually better off than we are accustomed
to think.
Will the Family Cooperate? — We must examine more care-
fully the duties and responsibilities of this cooperating group or
financial partnership, for if any refuse to play the part assigned,
full success will not be attained.
The Man's Part. — That the man's business is to " support the
family " is the understanding in this prosperous country ; he may
even be compelled to do so under the law. He it is who furnishes
the money basis on which the fabric rests, his contribution being
the chief reliance even in cases where the wife and children also
earn money.1
This is directly in line with the principle of division of labor,
and still more important, it is the very foundation of the man's self-
respect and sense of responsibility. Students of social conditions
agree in considering it a mistake to relieve the man of this burden,
if for no other reason, because of its developing and steadying effect
upon him. He may even lose interest in a home to which he does
not contribute. His success as a money earner is not a measure
of his success as a man, but the requirements of family life, as sus-
tained on the moderate income, make his contribution in this form
a prime necessity. It is even found to be one of the most important
functions of the home to -provide the conditions that make it pos-
sible for the man to become and remain the money earner; for
instance, the good squaw as hewer of wood and drawer of water
kept her brave supple for war and enduring in the chase, for it was
of prime importance that the family be defended from enemies
and provided with venison and hides. That she continued to do all
the work when war and the chase had passed was due to a lack
of adjustment to changed conditions, a mistake which is not confined
to any time or people. It will be noted in the study of family
number four in Chapter XVII that the most serious mistake of
the woman was in so ruling the life of the family that the income
1 In a recent study of 260 working men's families in Philadelphia, the
men were found to earn 84.87 per cent, of the money income. Working
Men's Standards of Living, W. C. Beyer, p. 30.
22 SUCCESSFUL FAMILY LIFE ON MODERATE INCOME
earner never had enough sleep or the proper recreation and in
spending so much money in pleasure that no fund was accumulat-
ing on which the family could fall back while he stopped work
long enough to find a more suitable occupation than the one he
was pursuing.
That the man must put his whole force into earning the bulk of
the money income has become necessary under modern conditions,
and this has led to a new acceptance of functions, the man as chief
earner, the woman as chief spender, of the income. In general,
it may be said that the man brings in the raw materials of
life, the woman works them up into products of material and
immaterial value.
But this does not imply that the man is simply a money-making
machine or a flowing well of benefits for the family ; he has his share
in recreation and development, and the true partnership requires
him to contribute toward maintaining the proper spirit in which
the aims of the family are pursued. That requires his keeping in
touch with the daily life by frequent consultations concerning those
aims and how the income is to meet them, by giving help in the
training of the children and taking part in the social life, and for
the same reasons he should have some part, no matter how small,
in the running of the house, as organized by the wife.
In spite of the facts gathered by charity organizations as to
the "married deserter/' it would seem to the ordinary observer
that no one in the community stands up to the task of life with
more cheerfulness than this man who is earning what we have
called the moderate income, and he is inclined to consider his home
and his family as an adequate reward for his labors. In this grade
of life, when the home breaks down, we are justified in examining
other factors than the failure of the money earner.
Is the Woman Equal to Her Assigned Part? — The function
of the man as money earner for the family is easily stated, but not
so the relation of the married woman to the exchequer. That is
complicated by her relation to the child and to family life, a relation
which is not physical alone. Since the human infant is very help-
less and adolescence extends over a number of years, necessitating
education of various kinds beginning very early, civilized nations
admit the importance of giving the woman time and opportunity
THE FINANCIAL PARTNERSHIP 23
to care for the child and to maintain conditions in the home that
are necessary for its proper development. It is also taken for
granted that while she cares for its physical wants she has a chance
to train in right habits and attitude toward the family and society,
and to maintain a home life which is full of courage and happiness
and which reaches a good standard of general efficiency. If, in
addition, this woman is helping to develop the family's social life
and thus contributing to well doing in the community, the claim
that in order to perform these services to home and society she
should be removed from industry, by which we mean any form of
money earning carried on outside the home, seems fully justified
at least for certain years. But on the moderate income, the woman
of the family will be obliged to fill all these so-called higher func-
tions as she may, in connection with the substantial addition to the
income which she must make through her part as manager and
buyer and performer of household labor. Women are now making
these contributions to family life in countless homes, and increasing
efficiency may be expected if the right helps are provided them.
Summary. — In any given family, the income is derived from
several sources, wages or salary for economic services, interest on
property owned, personal services in the home by all members of
the family and from accumulated social wealth in the community.
Of these the earning power of the man is the most important and
it must be conserved by the conditions of family life. That of
the woman comes next and may even equal in its estimated money
and other values that of the man. Success depends on the family
becoming a true cooperative unit.
QUESTIONS
1. How is a business partnership formed? What are the legal respon-
sibilities of partnership ? Is the family properly likened to a partner-
ship, or is it more like a business corporation? Why?
2. Name three types of workers whose money incomes are relatively fixed,
three whose incomes are uncertain. What advantages in each situa-
tion?
3. Illustrate in a given case the difference between money wages and real
wages ( the living secured ) .
4. Does salary differ from wages except that it is received at longer inter-
vals? In each case who pays for loss of time?
24 SUCCESSFUL FAMILY LIFE ON MODERATE INCOME
5. Suppose housewives went on a strike and refused to do the house-
work, what would be the effect on the family incomes? On
the total amount of useful products made by the nation, or the
national product?
6. By law the husband is, in most states, made responsible for the living
expenses of the family. Is this just? Should the law place a
similar obligation on the woman regarding her financial relation,
to the family in the duty to perform housework, care for chil-
dren, etc.?
7. Do you think that the woman has a right to more leisure time than
the man? If so, why?
8. Should she expect to contribute less than he does to the support of
the family? Does work necessarily mean earning money?
9. Give illustrations in your town of accumulated social wealth that
contributes to the income of the residents.
10. What contributions may a child of six make to the family income?
11. Should the earnings of all members of the family be pooled, that is,
deposited in bank and considered as entire income, or should chil-
dren be allowed to keep their own earnings? What conditions con-
trol the answer?
CHAPTEE IV
MONEY INCOME AND PROPERTY OWNED
Wealth and Income Compared. — The difference between prop-
erty, or the capital sum owned, and income, or the annual amount
received, is not always considered. Property, as real estate, or
money in the bank represents in most cases savings, the result of
past labor rather than present ; it is supposed to be stable in charac-
ter, " something to fall back on," yielding income in the form of
rental or interest ; while money income in most families as received
at stated times in the form of wages or salary for services rendered
may be more uncertain. Property produces annual income, but
income is also received as the result of services given.
Another relation between property and income is evident when
we consider, for instance, that a man who has an income of $5000
is said to be "capitalized" at $100,000, the sum which invested
at 5 per cent, would produce that income. In the same way, a
machinist earning $2000 a year could not stay his hand and expect
to see his family as well off as when he was working, unless he had the
sum of $40,000 invested at that rate.
Income will first be considered, since in families of the financial
grade that we are considering earning and saving is the first requisite
step toward securing property.
General Ignorance as to Income. — Unless their income is
absolutely regular by the day, week or month, families may be quite
uncertain as to what the income averages over a term of years,
and they are in general wholly ignorant as to where it places them
in relation to income received in the country at large. To know
their financial relation to the rest of their community, to the
nation, and even to the population of other countries, should have
a steadying and enlightening effect on a family. Figures that give
this relation, even approximately, are therefore of great interest
and value, and the following facts and conclusions are cited in
this connection.
25
26 SUCCESSFUL FAMILY LIFE ON MODERATE INCOME
Our Sources of Knowledge. — Concerning the wage-earning
class, those whose incomes fall below the one which we are con-
sidering, there is much data at hand. Intensive studies of life in
actual families have been made by a few highly qualified students,
as Mrs. More 1 and Dr. Chapin,2 who directed their attention to
wage-earners in New York City, and Mr. Beyer 3 and his associates
who studied similar families in Philadelphia. Of wider bearing
are those investigations made under the United States government
and by commissions appointed by State and Federal authorities
for the study of great industries, as factories, mines, railroads, and
other large corporations employing in the aggregate hundreds of
thousands of workers. Such are the annual and special reports issued
by the United States Department of Labor, special reports of the
Interstate Commerce Commission and such federal investigations
as those of the telephone companies, the Bethlehem Steel Works,
the cotton mill operatives, and recently the shipbuilders and others
studied during the war.
Nearly all of these investigations concern wage-earners whose
incomes were less than $1000 before the war and in more recent
studies those whose incomes are from $1500-$2000 or thereabouts.
Concerning higher incomes the information is very incomplete.
The earlier students of the subject searched probate records, federal
and state income tax lists and the lists of depositors in savings
banks, but the knowledge derived from these various sources was
far from covering the field.
Every writer on this subject laments the inadequacy of the
facts at hand ; only the trained statistician can weigh and compare
this material, imperfect and often contradictory as it is, and in most
cases his conclusions are estimates only. W. I. King, a recent
student in this field, quotes with approval Mr. Streightoff, who
said in 1912 that ee it is at present impossible to give any accurate
picture of the distribution of incomes among the population as a
whole." * But much statistical work has been done along these
JWage Earners' Budgets, L. B. More, 1907.
"Standard of Living among Working Men's Families in New York
City, Robert C. Chapin, 1909.
'Working Men's Standard of Living in Philadelphia, W. C. Beyer,
1920.
4 Distribution of Incomes in the United States, F. H. Streightoff, 1912.
MONEY INCOME AND PROPERTY OWNED 27
lines in the last ten years, extension of the state and federal income
taxes has 'greatly added to our knowledge of incomes, and since
the need of facts even approaching accuracy is so pressing, econo-
mists have ventured to give certain estimates.
Six Income Groups. — The following table is condensed from
figures given by W. I. King,5 based on the census of 1910.
The Estimated Percentage Distribution of Money Income in the
Continental U. S. in 1910 (outlying possessions excluded) among
the 28 million family groups.
Percentage of Families6
Family Income having given Incomes No. of Families*
1. Less than $600 26 7,220,000
2. From $600 to $1000 43 12,040,000
3. From $1000 to $1400 19 5,320,000
4. From $1400 to $2000 6 1,680,000
5. From $2000 to $5000 4 1,112,000
6. Above $5000 1 280,000
" Family " in this table refers not alone to the usual husband,
wife and child group; one-third of the "families" making up
groups 1, 2 and 3 are single men and women; but above that
income line the separation is not made by the statistician, "the
number being inconsiderable in the higher incomes " ; that is,
with few exceptions, all of the incomes above $1400 are possessed
by family groups with children.
Summary of Groups. — The distribution of population among
the income groups of Dr. King's tables is noteworthy.
Group 1 with incomes under $600, and consisting one-third of
single men and women and two-thirds of families, made up in
1910 over one-fourth of the population (26 per cent.). This
income, if used for the support of a family, was below the sub-
sistence level as figured out for a large city ten years ago. This
income as used for a family was often supplemented by the earn-
ings of the mother and young children, or by gifts; and in most
cases the standard of living was reduced in all directions below
that necessary for health or efficiency.
6 W. I. King. Wealth and Income of the People of the United States,
1915. Macmillan Co.
'In stating the percentage and number of families, round numbers
have been used, therefore, in each case the result is a little short of the
actual figures.
28 SUCCESSFUL FAMILY LIFE ON MODERATE INCOME
Group 2, with incomes between $600 and $1000, made up
nearly one-half of the families of the country (43 per cent).
They, too, were apt to slip into the ranks of the dependent if losses
or misfortune assailed them ; there was no margin for safety or for
saving: Groups 1 and 2 belong in the ranks of unskilled labor.
Group 3, with incomes ranging between $1000 and $1400, in-
cluded in 1910 about one-fifth of our population, or over five million
families. Considering prices for that time, they were for the most
part on good financial footing and could meet the living standards
of their class. In the upper levels we find the skilled workmen.
Group 4, with incomes ranging in 1910 between $1400 and
$2000, whose present equivalent is $2500 to $3500, more or less, is
the " moderate income group " selected for study in these pages.
It included over one and a half million families in 1910 and
formed the first group that could be said to have a steady surplus
beyond the subsistence line.
Group 5, receiving from $2000 to $5000, included somewhat
over one million families. Part of its families would be classified
in our view as having the moderate income.
Group 6 comprised three hundred thousand families with in-
comes of $5000 or over in 1910. It is interesting to know the
estimated subdivision of this last or sixth group made in 1918,
when it was said to comprise 368,460 families. The estimate was
made by the Bankers Trust Company of New York City :
Between $5000 and $6000 75,000 families
Between $6000 and $10,000 146,086 families
Between $10,000 and $50,000 128,339 families
Between $50,000 and $100,000 11,960 families
Between $100,000 and $1,000,000 6,860 families
Between $1,000,000 and $5,000,000 205 families
Between $5,000,000 and over 10 families
Total ' 368,460 families
A comprehensive digest of the census of 1920, similar to the
one made for 1910 by W. I. King, together with tax returns, will
doubtless show many changes in the make-up of these groups, but
comparisons must still be made with pre-war figures and conditions,
and a partial return to those conditions is already indicated. The
MONEY INCOME AND PROPERTY OWNED 29
six groups of families,, as described according to their incomes,
will continue to be represented in our population, but perhaps in
different proportions and earning their living in other ways than
was the case with those who filled the ranks five years ago.
The National Income Divided Among Families. — It is fre-
quently stated, and perhaps generally believed, that if the income
of the nation were divided up equally among its citizens, all families
would be in easy circumstances. That this is not the case is shown
by two studies made by the most competent authorities, one in the
United States and one in Great Britain.
Dr. W. I. King 7 estimated that the total income of the United
States in 1910 was $30,550,000,000. If two" billions be deducted
for necessary capital saving and the remainder divided among
92,000,000 people, the income per individual would be $310, or
$1020 for families of an average of four and one-half persons.
Dr. A. L. Bowley,8 Professor of Statistics in the University of
London, using the same methods on the British income tax re-
turns of 1911, found that in Great Britain there would be available
for the hypothetical average family of four and a half members
less than $750 a year.
In both cases it is assumed that such a distribution of the
agencies of production would not affect their efficiency, an assump-
tion which is by no means proved.
Income Comparisons with Foreign Countries. — The attempt
to compare any given income with that of the same class in another
country is beset with difficulties, especially if we wish to include
a knowledge of what a given income will buy.
The incomes of English and Scotch families were computed on
the basis of the proportion known to be expended for rent, or
about 22 per cent. Figured on this basis, 80 per cent, of English
and Scotch families had in 1912 incomes under $681; 90 per cent,
under $1022.9
In the United States the corresponding percentages in 1910 are
as follows: 39 per cent, had less than $700 and 69 per cent, less
than $1000.
TW. I. King, ibid.
8 A. L. Bowley, the Divisions of the Products of Industry, 1919.
9 F. H. Streightoflf, ibid.
30 SUCCESSFUL FAMILY LIFE ON MODERATE INCOME
The comparison with Prussia in 1910 is thought to be quite
exact. Professor King says that " every fraction of the American
people receive double or nearly treble the income of the correspond-
ing class in Prussia." 10 Thus, in money income our people of all
classes would seem to have been somewhat better off than the
corresponding class in those foreign countries in which studies
have been made, as the United Kingdom, France and Prussia. As
concerns the comfort of the common people these four European
states are far in advance of the poorer states — Austria, Italy, Spain,
and the Balkans — with which countries the comparison would be
still more in our favor.
The Purchasing Power of the Income. — There are two
general modifications of the purchasing power of an income, the
price of commodities and the standard of living; their restricting
power is known to every housewife, whether she is familiar or
not with the phraseology of economic science. If transportation
facilities are normal, prices differ very little in different parts of
our country except for perishable foods. Between the different
European countries prices of staple articles also differed but slightly
at that time. In the comparison of the United States with Prussia
only house rent and the price of vegetables were found to be cheaper
in Prussia.
Effect of the Standard of Living. — The standard of living in
different parts of the same country and in different countries is a
factor less easy to calculate, and it may have a great effect on the
" satisfactions " derived from that part of the income beyond what
ia needed for the absolute necessities of life. Thus, in general, a
given income " goes further " and places a family in a better rank
in the country than in the city because the standard of living is
lower, and also in foreign countries than in our own for the same
reason. In comparing incomes in the United States with those
of any foreign country we have also to consider such factors as the
tax rate and the amount of help furnished by the state in housing,
education, insurance, etc. If a state offers substantial help in
cheapening these needs of life, a smaller income will suffice. The
effect of the standard of living1 and of the community's contribution
are presented in detail later.
M W. I. King, iUd, p. 236.
MONEY INCOME AND PROPERTY OWNED 31
Distribution of Property. — The distribution of property among
the individuals and families in a country is a very different thing
from the distribution of income, "the inequality, in the case of
income being very decidedly less than in the case of wealth." As
illustration, " the poorer half of the people of Wisconsin own but
2 or 3 per cent, of the wealth, but they receive more than 25 per
cent, of the income." In Prussia the richest 1 per cent, own
49 per cent, of the wealth, but receive only 19 per cent, of
the income.11
Charles B. Spahr estimated in 1896 12 that " Less than one-half
the families in America are propertyless ; nevertheless, seven-eighths
of the families hold but one-eighth of the national wealth, while
1 per cent, of the families hold more than the remaining 99 per
cent, of the families."
The comparative distribution of wealth or property owned in
distinction from income received in our country seems to have
remained fairly constant for several decades. The next studies
made may or may not confirm the general impression that in late
years wealth has been concentrating in the hands of the few.
Dr. King has made interesting comparisons of wealth between
two of our typical states, Wisconsin and Massachusetts, and Prussia,
France, and the United Kingdom. The relative distribution of
wealth among different classes of the people was found to be very
nearly the same in all of these countries, the richest 2 per cent, of
the population owning considerably more property than all the rest
together. In England the concentration was so great that this
2 per cent, of the people owned nearly three times as much as
the poor and middle classes combined, or, to state it some-
what differently:
In the United Kingdom one-half of the property was owned
by % per cent, of the people. In Prussia and in France one-half
of the property was owned by 1 per cent, of the people. In
Wisconsin and Massachusetts one-half of the property was owned
by 2 per cent, of the people.
That the relative distribution of wealth was found to be so
11 W. I. King, ibid, p. 231.
"Charles B. Spahr, An Essay on the Present Distribution of Wealth
in the United States.
32 SUCCESSFUL FAMILY LIFE ON MODERATE INCOME
nearly alike in the countries studied is explained by the fact that
they are all governed by substantially the same body of laws, and it
is with the consent of the laws of a country that its wealth is dis-
tributed. Law also governs the conditions under which it is held,
so that great changes are possible in future, as notice the increases
that recent years have shown in income and inheritance taxes.
Property Owned in the Moderate Income Group. — The
ownership of property in this moderate income group in which we
are especially interested we have little means of knowing. Dr. King18
says that only the "upper middle class " (18 per cent, of our
families) and the 2 per cent, of the so-called " wealthy " class
" possess enough property to derive any considerable income there-
from to supplement the proceeds of their toil"; our moderate
income group, comprising about a million and a half families,
according to the census of 1910, comes within these limits.
Little statistical work has been done on this point. The fol-
lowing is an attempt to estimate what a thrifty family with an
income which would be an equivalent of $2500, more or less, at the
present time may have accumulated after, say, twenty years:,
1. House and lot owned wholly or in part, $1500 to $4000
or more.
It must be remembered that many farmers own their houses with
some land and that the ownership of house and lot in villages and
small towns is very common among families in these income limits.
2. House furnishings, $750 to $2000.
This will vary greatly in different families; the value of the
furnishings depending on how long the family has existed in a stable
condition, on what it has inherited from a former generation, on
the amount of sickness and other drawbacks that have decreased
savings, on the habits and tastes of its members. For instance, a
stay-at-home family with a taste for reading and music will be
found to have acquired books and a piano or phonograph, money
being spent in this way which another family gives out for public
amusements. In the average home where this income is spent the
furnishings will consist of outfit for dining-room and kitchen, bed-
room and parlor furniture, books, piano, victrola, rugs, etc. A
»W. I. King, ibid, p. 100.
MONEY INCOME AND PROPERTY OWNED 33
government study (1919) of the income of $2262.67 estimates that
the family will have $1000 worth of furniture.14
8. Life insurance, the cash value varying according to amount
of payments made, $2000 to $3000.
4. Savings : a mortgage, savings bank deposit, Government Sav-
ings stamps, or Liberty Bonds, $300 to $500.
It would thus seem possible for a family that has been in
receipt of the moderate income, for, say, twenty years, to have
acquired property in the neighborhood of $5000, but much depends
on their standard of living, on their good fortune in avoiding such
extra expenses as come from illness, and perhaps still more on their
habits of thrift. In the latter case, however, there may be danger
of too rigid economy, since the margin for saving is small after the
reasonable needs of life are met for any single year.
Summary. — In arranging the families that make up the popu-
lation of the United States in groups according to income it is seen
that nearly 75 per cent, in 1910 were living under or near the
subsistence line, that not until we had passed in the upward scale 88
per cent, of the population did we reach the $1400 income which
we agreed to call the starting point of the moderate income at
that time.
A comparison with foreign countries showed that every fraction
of our people had better incomes than a like fraction in the more
highly civilized countries of Europe. While the price of standard
commodities is much the same everywhere, standards of living differ,
and a given income may furnish in a European country more
" satisfactions " than in our own.
The distribution of wealth in this and other countries is much
more unequal than the distribution of income a small percentage
of the people in all countries holding the bulk of the property.
The changes in incomes and prices of living that have been
brought about in the last ten years will alter the make-up of groups
of families receiving the six grades of income; all will be repre-
sented, but in what proportions it is impossible to state until studies
based on recent income statistics are available.
"Tentative Quantity and Cost Budget for a Standard of Comfort and
Decency. U. S. Bureau of Labor Statistics, 1919.
3
34 SUCCESSFUL FAMILY LIFE ON MODERATE INCOME
QUESTIONS
1. In the locality with which you are best acquainted what is considered
the minimum, and what a comfortable or average income for a family
of five (the children too young to contribute) ?
2. Do you know cases in which the man does not earn the entire money
income ?
3. What is the objection to the term "middle class" in America? Have
we social classes which we refuse to recognize?
4. If all incomes were to increase in proportion to what has been the
increase in the cost of living, would the families in question have
the same degree of prosperity that they had before the prices began to
rise?
5. Ask a number of intelligent people what they think would be the family
income if all the money earned in the country were divided up equally
and ascertain, if possible, what grounds they have for their conclusion.
6. Ascertain if possible the amount and kinds of property that have been
accumulated by middle life by a number of moderate income families.
7. In the case of your own or some other family that you know, what
items of income-producing property are owned? How much money
income is received from property? How much in wages or salaries for
services rendered ? Would these figures by typical of families generally ?
CHAPTEE V
THE START IN LIFE AS GIVEN BY THE PRECEDING
GENERATION
As the first requirement for successful family life, it was stated
in the introductory chapter that the heads of the household shall
have that fair start which comes only through a share in the results
of personal thrift and energy as practiced in the preceding genera-
tion. This includes not only an education and good home training,
but, if possible, some money or that which is of money value, to
help in the early years of married life. Careful observation seems
to prove that the making of such a provision has a good effect on
both generations. The family living on the income which we are
considering cannot gather even a small fund for this purpose without
such cooperation as becomes a bond between old and young and
affords the best means for training in labor and thrift.
The Beginnings are Important. — The beginning in any enter-
prise is held to be very important. In the Bible illustration the
king about to go to war is advised to first sit down and count his
men and compare with those of his enemy; the estimates of a
business undertaking are worked out on paper before contracts are
signed ; the plans of the house and all building specifications are in
hand before the work starts. But when the business of home
making is begun, emotion plays the leading part and takes glorious
risks; the cost is not too carefully counted, and the sour goddess,
Prudence, is not invoked as the sole presiding spirit. Just here is
where age may step in with its fund of experience and play a
helpful part; for if the new undertaking is .to be one of dignity
and permanence, its plans, however modest, must be well made and
adequately financed.
Debt is Dangerous. — It is found by those who have studied
low income and moderate income family life that a fertile source
of trouble in the first few years after marriage is the discouragement
that comes from debts which the young couple have incurred for
35
36 SUCCESSFUL FAMILY LIFE ON MODERATE INCOME
what seemed absolutely necessary means of living. These young
people need help of many kinds in order that they may make a
success of their great venture, great in its possibilities for them
and for others. A very important thing is to realize that there is
a financial basis to the undertaking and that every day they are
to meet decisions regarding money. Just as the marriage cannot
be dissolved without due process of law, so there are laws regulating
responsibility for debt, support of children and other family rela-
tions and decisions, all involving money. The young couple have
entered into a serious business which concerns not themselves alone
but their families, the community, even the state. Not to give
sufficient weight to this fact is common in a new country ; to over-
estimate its importance belongs to older communities.
Illustrations from the Family Histories. — The family his-
tories given in Chapter XVII illustrate the importance of the good
start in life. In family No. II it will be seen that the young couple
lived for the first year with the husband's parents, and when it
seemed best for the man to change his business, money was loaned
him by his father for a course in a business college. The result
proved the wisdom of the step ; the family became prosperous and
well established, and its success was largely owing to this help.
Family No. VI shows the possession by the young people of
some shares of dividend-paying stock which supplemented the earn-
ings of the husband. On the other hand, the families Nos. Ill
and VII, while equally worthy and industrious, were barely able to
win out and for the very lack, it would seem, of such help. In one
case the effort to pay off a debt contracted before marriage was
felt as a strain on the resources for many years, and in the other
case there were cramping conditions which limited the develop-
ment of the wife and mother and were sure to lower her ability
to train the children properly.
Standards are Inherited. — It must be borne in mind that
standards of living which we are expected to keep up have been
in large measure created for us by the family and social group, and
it may be at first difficult to meet these standards as to hygiene
and reasonable comfort and refinement, all of which are not only
necessary to the advancement and success of the family, but indi-
rectly affect the scale of living in the community.
THE START IN LIFE 37
If society is to improve, the accumulations of the past must be
utilized by the present. It is said that the sprout from a chestnut
stump will grow as much in five years as that from a seed in twenty
years. We know that a child of ten, as described in Daudet's
"Jack," thrown out on the world with his only capital his own
brain and muscle, is heavily handicapped as compared with a child
of the same inheritance who is surrounded from the first with the
loving and purposeful help of good family life. The question is,
should this help cease with childhood? Those who have a strong
racial sense, who feel themselves a part of the flowing stream of
life, rather than lost in the side eddies and standing pools, who
themselves note the steadying influence of the past working within
them, are the ones who, in their turn, look forward and make what
sacrifices are necessary to pass on not only a sound physical
inheritance and good training but some practical help to start the
new generation on its way. To maintain the custom of providing
the " start in life," of however modest a character, is simply to
admit that it is extremely important that the dignity and stability
of the new home should be maintained and that it is dangerous for
the young people to be unable to keep up decent standards of living.
We may be in danger by the opposite method of sacrificing frank-
ness as to the future needs of the family and of developing a spirit
of undue hopefulness, even blindness, as to what is actually required
to make a success of home making.
The Older Way. — A provident care for the future has always
accompanied successful ventures. In our own country for the
first century and a half of its existence we see the family holding
together as a unit against the dangers and difficulties of the new
life. In that modified form of the patriarchal family, as it existed
on the eastern seaboard even two generations ago, the family roof
tree often sheltered thei next generation in the first years of
married life; here it was customary for the older son to take over
the homesitead at the death of his father, reserving for the widow
her "rights of dower," with a separate portion of the house and
her own doorway as often mentioned in old wills; the scanty
resources of the time constrained them to make the best of a mode
of life that had many drawbacks. The prosperity of our country
in the last two generations, together with our lack of historical
38 SUCCESSFUL FAMILY LIFE ON MODERATE INCOME
background, has kept this generation from realizing the value of
the family bond as continued past childhood, together with the actual
duty of one generation to the next expressed in whatever form best
meets special needs and conditions.
Evils of the Dower. — Besides, there is a feeling of hostility
toward anything like the European system of dower as placing
too heavy a burden on the parents and leading to a commercial view
of life, especially in matters of marriage.
There is no doubt of the possible evils of the European system.
Parental love is a great stimulus to labor, and in a country like
France, where public opinion sets in a strong tide toward thrift,
it might lead to saving too carefully and denying to the parents
reasonable comforts, while the children are made selfish by the
acceptance of too great sacrifices. But in America the tide is all
the other way; public opinion and general practice discourage
extreme sacrifice to that end and the little that, will be saved out
of the present $2500 or $3000 family income will hardly corrupt the
young. Such savings as will be possible to a couple that has been
supporting a family of children during their non-earning years,
giving them a good physical development and time to obtain a public
school education, will be only enough to afford proof of the wisdom
of thrift and to teach children its practice. The children are en-
couraged to do their own -part in saving for their future and also
to find ways of earning extra sums to add to the family funds.
Thus it would seem that the growth of good habits and family
loyalty, sure to accompany labor toward a common end, is of chief
importance in looking forward to a provision for the start in life.
In an ideal world parents and children would work and save
just as gladly for unknown human beings on the other side of the
world as for those to whom they are united by bonds of blood and
affection, but in actual practice it is proved to be difficult to provide
a substitute for the age-long natural motive to labor and thrift
for the sake of the children's start in life, and in any given case
such virtues may not be developed if this stimulus is lacking. Then
the family life may be to that extent imperfect and its influence in
the community not of the best.
What Form Shall Savings Take?— If by good fortune our
moderate income family is able to make some solid contribution
THE START IN LIFE 39
to the next generation, in addition to good training, what form
shall it take ?
With the help of the children themselves furniture for their
own room may be bought, a few simple and beautiful pieces that
will set the standard for future additions to be used in their own
home. A savings bank deposit in the child's name may be started
very early through birthday or other gifts, and it will foster a feeling
of independence.
The premiums on a life insurance for the young contribute
toward a desirable form of investment on which money can be
borrowed if desired. The same may be said of investment in Build-
ing and Loan Associations in states where their supervision is strict.
The government bond and savings stamp are now among the
most desirable forms for the small investor. For other forms of
investment expert advice must be obtained.
The Bequest. — Probably the most welcome help to the growing
family is the interest, however small, on invested capital. A young
housewife said that four bright days of the* year were marked by
the receipt of the $25 check which came in payment of the quarterly
interest on a savings account started by her mother, and which
had for her a peculiar value because she had herself witnessed as a
girl the small sacrifices joyfully made by which the sum had been
brought together. Half of this interest received each quarter was
always put in the bank to add to a similar fund started for her own
children; the other half was used for some delightful treat to be
chosen by the children themselves, and whatever form it might take,
it was called " Grandmother's party ."
Another woman said : " One of the joyous things in life for
me is the interest on a little legacy that my aunt left me. It
eases up on every hard place. I always feel that it will do far more
than it will, but there's fun in that, too; I don't feel so shut in,
there's a door open into all kinds of possibilities. And nothing
could tempt me to touch the principal. It shall be left for my
daughter, and I hope it will give her the same happiness that it has
given me." It may be that when we are well past youth we feel
our truest gratitude to those who have looked ahead to our need.
The Gifted Child. — The maintenance of such a family fund is
of especial help when more than ordinary talent appears in one
40 SUCCESSFUL FAMILY LIFE ON MODERATE INCOME
of the children. Talent must be fostered and trained and it must
be protected from the severest forms of poverty. The Scotch
schoolmaster of Barrie's stories was always on the lookout for the
" lad o' pairts " who must be educated, and the whole community
was expected to help him along if the parents were not equal to
this obvious need. The child of unusual ability in a Jewish com-
munity, according to Mary Antin, is prized and helped in the same
way. In any special case public help may not be available. Pride
and good sense are both on the side of help from the family to as
great an extent as possible.
Personal Saving. — To what extent shall such a fund be made
up from the saving of the young people themselves ? It may be said
without hesitation : To as great an extent as possible, and especially
if the accumulation of the fund is never allowed to eclipse in im-
portance the effect of saving on the one who saves. The benefit of
successful struggle with difficulties, the development of the sense
of responsibility and self-denial may be counted on as the result
of individual saving.
The Girl Must Save. — Men are more apt to take for granted
than are women that they must work hard and save for the home
they hope to have. It is, however, equally incumbent on the girl
who is now entering all manner of occupations and demanding
a man's pay. But in many cases she is still under the spell of a
former time when she expected to be " supported " after she mar-
ried, and she does not save as the man saves. The young woman,
as well as the young man, while paying out of her earnings a fair
share toward the home living expenses, should be able to start the
collection of books, to buy pictures or pieces of furniture, a rug,
a musical instrument and to begin a bank account, and she may
feel that whether she marries or not, a home with its cherished
possessions, slowly accumulated and reflecting personal taste, will
still be necessary to her happiness.
" The Colonial bride, marrying into industry, brought her full
economic value to her husband ; the modern bride, marrying out of
industry leaves most of her economic value behind." * Which is all
the more reason, it would seem, why she should save while in indus-
try for the home to be, where she will not add to the money income,
except in the various forms of housework.
1 The Woman of To-morrow, p. 17. William Hard.
THE START IN LIFE 41
The filling of the wedding chest in olden times gave to the Ibride
a knowledge of textiles, a liberal course in fine needlework, a sense
of pride in her own achievement; to accumulate the desirable fur-
nishings of a modern house may well require as great thrift and1
industry and a still better training in economic and artistic values.
Summary. — The family unit generally requires for its full
success more or less help from the preceding generation. This is
contributed chiefly through education and home training; even if
there are no school fees to be paid, the child must be supported for
a term of years during its education. A share in the accumulated
savings of the family toward which the children have contributed
is also of great assistance. Unless the training of youth is taken
over by the state and extensive provision made for sickness and
accident and other individual needs by something like universal
social insurance, a provident look into the future is required in
every family.
The plan of providing the start in life —
1. Furnishes the natural motive for thrift and the formation
of good habits for both generations.
2. Helps the new household toward the attainment of good
standards of living, gives the young people a sense of security and
allows them to plan a like assistance to their own children.
QUESTIONS
1. What items of house furnishings might a young man or young woman
accumulate which would finally be placed in their own home?
2. What is the bearing of the custom of wedding presents on the start
in life? What principles might well guide parents and friends in
selecting them? Is there any objections to presents in the form of
money, leaving the expenditure to the young people?
3. Should the start in life be upon the scale of living to which the young
people have been accustomed in their parents' homes or should that
be a gradual achievement?
4. Does the state actually pay for high school education as generally
understood, or do the parents contribute their full share through
taxes and by supporting high school children while they are studying?
5. A farmer gave each of his sons the choice of a farm or $2,000 to start in
business ; what should have been the share of the daughters ?
6. How do the child labor laws make it harder than formerly to bring
up children? Which generation do they favor?
7. Would the custom of saving for the home- to-be overemphasize the
factor of prudence by establishing a standard of greater thrift?
Would young people without money have a poorer chance for mar-
42 SUCCESSFUL FAMILY LIFE ON MODERATE INCOME
riage, or would this advanced standard stimulate a habit of thrift
in the whole community? Would this advanced standard affect the
size of families?
8. How soon should children begin saving? How soon should they be
given the idea of a future home of their own, bachelor or otherwise,
as something to save for?
9. Should' the fund for the future be saved by the parents, by the chil
dren or by both? Should it be restricted to a marriage portion or
used for education and the economic start?
Is the plan of starting a fund for each child at its birth a good one?
Would it be better to put savings into a general fund to be drawn
on as needed? Would it be wise to expect a return of such money
when possible, the fund to be carried along as an old age fund for
the parents?
10. Is there any injustice to the other children in the special help advo-
cated for the gifted child ?
CHAPTEE VI
THE HOUSEWIFE'S CONTRIBUTION AS BUYER
AND MANAGER
THE woman of the family makes her contribution to its support
and life in several distinct ways, which are made the subject of the
five following chapters.
The housewife is, first of all, the manager of the house and
the buyer of nearly all the commodities that are consumed by the
household. It is she who in most cases has the deciding vote as
to the house in which the family lives, and how it shall be fur-
nished; she buys the food, she chooses the clothing, at least for
herself and the younger children; she makes arrangements con-
cerning the social life of the family. This activity has its acknowl-
edged place in economics, and is well known in the business world ;
the buyer contributes final or " place value " to goods of all kinds
by choosing and purchasing them and by establishing conditions
in which they will be used. To realize that the element of choice
adds to the value of purchased goods, we have only to remember
that this is exactly the function of the buyer for a mercantile house ;
he must select from what is offered by the wholesaler those goods
which he believes will find sale in the retail establishment, and his
salary indicates the value of the services he thus renders through
the exercise of his knowledge and judgment.
The housewife who does not put her hand to any actual labor,
even an invalid who never leaves her chair, may yet be a true pro-
ducer of values by the exercise of this function of decision and choice
in its effect on the family life. This is in line with the teaching of the
modern school of economists who have brought into prominence the
study of the " Consumption of Wealth " in contrast with the older
school, which was almost wholly concerned with the making of
economic goods for the market, or the " Production of Wealth/'
And yet in the United States census, even that of 1920, " gainful,"
occupations alone are recognized. Women who are not receiving
43
44 SUCCESSFUL FAMILY LIFE ON MODERATE INCOME
wages from sources outside the home are all classed as "unoccu-
pied/' although among them are found the housewives who are
true producers of wealth in the newer sense ; that is, they " create
utilities that satisfy human needs." Out of raw materials they
produce the finished product, not only in food and clothing but
in immaterial forms that make up the very character and atmos-
phere of home. "They are the makers of the intimate things
of life."
We know that the combined expenditures of the homes of our
country reach many billion dollars annually; where accuracy is
impossible a billion more or less is of little account; it is enough
to know that the amount is enormous and that approximately 90
per cent, of it goes through the hands of women. Even when the
husband signs the check, the wife has been responsible for choosing
most of the items on the bill. It is acknowledged that a newspaper
in its effort to obtain advertisements must be able to prove that it
is a " family paper/' that it reaches the eye of the woman, for it is
she who spends the bulk of the household money. In the wholesale
district of a city women are little seen, but in the retail shopping
streets, where are bought house furnishings and clothing, also food
in its raw state and as prepared by baker, canner and caterer,
women buyers far outnumber men, and back of these retail stores
at which the women purchase are the great factories and wholesale
houses which supply their needs as indicated by sales and the ships
and railroads that bring raw material from all countries. Eeal
estate firms and the building trades are all affected by the prefer-
ence of women regarding the house and its location ; the vast busi-
ness of amusements and means of recreation is greatly influenced
in policy by what women like and dislike. Spending is spoken of
by one economist as the new "new function of women";1 Mrs.
More says of the women who came under her observation in her
studies of wage-earning families in New York : " It is she who sets
the pace as to what is desirable and what is to be endured/'
Power Over Production. — There is a sense in which the
function of the buyer must be taken very seriously and that is in
the power exerted on production ; what is not bought does not con-
1 Edward Devine, Economic Function of Woman. Annals of American
Academy of Political and Social Science, vol. 5.
HOUSEWIFE AS BUYER AND MANAGER 45
tinue to be made; what is persistently demanded will find its way
to showcase and counter. This should be a sobering thought to
the rash spender. To buy a piece of porcelain of real worth has its
effect on a pottery in far-off Tokio or Paris ; to buy a style of cloth-
ing so extreme that it is certain to lose favor in a short time helps
to inflict on the garment worker alternate seasons of idleness and
overwork; while to buy what bears the label of the Consumers'
League is to encourage one of the wisest efforts yet made to improve
conditions of labor. Careful and intelligent buying of food helps
not only the inspector of weights and measures, but everyone who
buys, since demands for cleanliness in the handling of food, or for
labels that tell the true story as to the contents of a package or an
absolute guarantee of the wearing qualities of a fabric will all be met
by the trade if such demands are persistently made by any con-
siderable number of buyers.
Power Over the Family Life. — Not only does the family buyer
influence production for public good or ill, but her selection of
what the family is to use has an immense influence on their health,
habits and cultural standards. She may overfurnish the house with
unsubstantial and tawdry things which will soon fade and look
shabby, or she may buy for the same money a few excellent pieces
of furniture or a rug or two that will be a lifelong delight. She
may refuse to buy poor pictures simply that walls may be covered,
or clothing of poor design and material to gratify a passing whim
In every department of life she has an opportunity to direct their
choice and to mold their taste.
Measuring the Value of the Buyer's Services. — Can the
contribution of the housewife to the family income as manager
and buyer be stated in terms of money ? It would be easy to account
for the number of hours she gives to shopping by adding to the
price of all articles bought the 10 per cent, charged by the com-
mercial shopper, but the value of her decisions is more difficult to
estimate. The household arts have all been standardized in the
market. In any given city we know the price per hour of different
kinds of housework, as window washing, the cleaning of rugs,
laundry work, cooking and sewing, and can easily compute the value
of the time the housewife spends in such work, but we have no such
comparison to use as a guide in estimating the value of the time
46 SUCCESSFUL FAMILY LIFE ON MODERATE INCOME
spent in the choice of housefurnishings and clothing, food and
other articles. It depends on :
First. — The value of her standards as to what ends the home
is to meet.
Second. — The extent and character of her information regard-
ing the articles purchased.
Standards. — The standards as to what is beautiful and con-
venient in housefurnishings and dress are said to be different in each
individual household. They will »be what the members have been
accustomed to, modified by what they see in other houses and by
what the advertiser suggests. The only measure of the buyer's
success seems to be the degree of satisfaction that the purchases
bring to the family, but these standards are capable of great
improvement by the education of both men and women in practical
and artistic values. There are well-established principles which
should govern color and line in house furnishing and in dress.
Knowledge of Values. — The knowledge of the buyer as to the
value of the articles between which she must choose is a very definite
thing, and her usefulness to the family can be greatly increased by
informing her as to qualities and prices and the reason for the
prices; even those women who are so zealous to save for the family
purse that they should be locked up on 'bargain days can be taught
the folly of spending ten cents in carfare and twenty-five cents
worth of time to save a trifle at a cut-rate sale.
The Need of Training. — For service so important to family
life some adequate preparation is needed. Ida M. Tarbeil, that
keen observer of American life, has said on this point :
" Scientific household management is of basic importance . . .
Unless the manager of the house, the buyer and user of what comes
into it, is trained in purchasing, knows values, has a keen sense
that it is her duty as a citizen not to be cheated ; unless she respects
quality, has learned the possibilities of cooperation, she is not going
to be able to meet her individual problem . . . Housekeeping
needs as varied qualities as any business known to human beings,
and yet, as things are now, girls and women are getting only the
most superficial and artificial training for it/' 2
'Annals of the American Academy of Social and Political Science.
July, 1913, p. 129.
HOUSEWIFE AS BUYER AND MANAGER 47
Every good high school has now a course on the management of
family expenditures ; it is taught also in evening classes for adults,
and the subject is dealt with extensively in home economics litera-
ture. Any woman who wants to become a good manager and buyer
for her family can now obtain the underlying principles and then
by careful study can apply them to her own case.
Scope of Knowledge Needed. — The argument is conclusive.
Whoever is to manage the household money must know how to
spend it wisely. She must know certain essential things about
food, the wearing qualities of fabrics, and be able to decide whether
a labor-saving device is really a labor saver for her as it would be
used in her special household. When she is to rent a house, she
must know how it meets the demands of hygiene, and she must also
know the routine of housework necessary in her family and thus
be able to decide whether in the houses offered her this routine
can be followed without loss of time and effort; she must know
when a bargain is a bargain and seek it in reputable stores only and
at certain times of year when room must be made for the new stocks
and where certain things are " featured " on certain days. Such
stores are also those which are willing to give guarantee that goods
are as advertised and there is no trouble about exchange or refund-
ing of money in case of a mistake. That " cheap " stores necessarily
give more for the money is a common error.
Who Now Trains the Buyer? — The main source of her knowl-
edge at present is the newspaper advertiser and the show window.
It is by these means that wants are stimulated and even created,
and the dealer who can satisfy these wants is always near at hand.
The psychology of advertising lies in suggestion. Set before us
what promises to improve our appearance, ease our labors, amuse or
divert us and we hasten to purchase, quite forgetting the use for
which our money had been designed.
" I couldn't resist it, my dear," says the woman who holds up
before her spouse a new gown, " and it was such a bargain, just half
price, the clerk said it had sold for double." " You mean it didn't
sell for double, they got it off on you," is the heartless reply. This
is indignantly denied, but next day the buyer remembers that the
gown requires for its setting an evening reception to which she may
not be invited, and that its price must come out of the sum set aside
48 SUCCESSFUL FAMILY LIFE ON MODERATE INCOME
for her winter coat. She wonders why she did not think of this
while in the store.
And what psychologist will analyze for us the peculiar witchery
exerted by the auction room, its power over the imagination in
multiplying wants and suggesting new activities, so that men and
women may be seen lugging home the clock that will not go, the rug
that fits nowhere, the shoemaker's mending kit, or the half set of
dishes to a house already overstocked ?
The old theory of supply and demand seems to have been re-
versed. It is supply that suggests, even creates the demand and
waits not for its unaided action.
Knowledge the Only Defense. — But the business man has not
engaged to give us a course in economics. It is useless to rise
in wrath against those who make frail toys to be broken to-morrow,
who fill the installment houses with furniture upholstered in colors
that are. sure to fade to still uglier tints, who tempt the work-
man's wife on Monday morning while the bloom is still on the
pay envelope. Instead of calling business a " vast conspiracy/' we
have to realize that these recognized methods of making money call
for no regulation by law, since they simply offer their wares to
responsible adults, it is for us to decide whether these articles meet
our need. A knowledge of what we really want is our best, and
indeed only, defense.
Nor let us forget what we owe to business enterprise in offering
really excellent housekeeping devices, in helping us to change habits
that are out of date, in employing artists to furnish the manufac-
turer with right combinations of color and beautiful lines, in sug-
gesting ways of meeting new economic conditions. We can always
find what is enduringly good if we make the demand, for it is said
to be most profitable to manufacture that which gives lasting satis-
faction to the buyer. Some experienced buyers purchase only what
is persistently advertised, on the ground that only a good article
can pay for the heavy cost of advertising. The advertiser denies
that this charge is transferred to the buyer; he maintains that the
profits which come from the increased sales that follow wise adver-
tising reduce the price to all.
HOUSEWIFE AS BUYER AND MANAGER 49
Value of Special Teaching. — Most women who have come to
be good buyers have taught themselves, but it is apt to be a long
and costly process, and, like most of the practical arts, it needs help
from the student and expert through systematized courses of in-
struction. Even the brief courses offered in school or in the evening
class give improved methods and awaken observation. A few les-
sons in textiles with the aid of a microscope and a gas jet or other
flame for the examination of cotton, wool and silk fibers will be a
great help in the purchase of fabrics ; 3 as to food a course in
marketing will work an enormous improvement over the haphazard
buying of the past by revealing new and cheaper sources of food, and
by showing when it will pay to use carfare and time to go to market
and when one may as well purchase near at hand. The buyer learns
the secret of buying in " the flush of the season " and finds other
ways of tempting a jaded appetite than by furnishing green peas
and strawberries in January; she learns to buy cereals in bulk
instead of in boxes and to compare the price of bacon in the piece
with that of the delicate slices in jars. Above all, she learns to
make out a menu for a week ahead and it goes with her in her purse.
By such help a new light is shed on the factors that make up the
price of an article of food, it shows what part is due to labor, what
to greenhouse heat and care, how much to transportation; the
maxim " the best is the cheapest " no longer excuses her for paying
a high price when she has learned that the cheaper article is a
perfect substitute in food value, at least for her own table.
If such courses are taken by girls in the high school and by
adults in evening classes, the buyer will have such information
as will make of her an intelligent spender, which is necessary before
she can become a good saver. Where school courses for the adult
woman are not available, as in small towns, women frequently unite
in groups for discussion and exchange of information, or a trained
leader is hired to lead such discussion and to answer questions.
In school courses and in special classes, what are the important
points that will be brought up?
3 Clothing: Choice, Cost, Care. M. S. Wolman. J. B. Lippincott,
1920.
50 SUCCESSFUL FAMILY LIFE ON MODERATE INCOME
b Start with the Budget Plan. — It must be understood that a I
unplete plan for spending the money of the household underlies all '
ise buying. Such an outline for the division of the money income
is discussed in Chapters XIII to XVI. To decide on the sum that
must not be exceeded in each department of the expenditure may be
the first step toward orderly methods of housekeeping. When the
household financier is face to face with, all the family needs and
is obliged to weigh and compare their claim on the purse according
to their importance, it is all over with the temptation to buy a piece
of furniture simply because a neighbor has bought it, or to .give
a party because some friend has a house guest to entertain. The
plausible salesman speaks now to deaf ears. As one woman said,
" there's no more fun in shopping " ; the gay and thoughtless spender
has grown up to a knowledge of her responsibilities. The housewife
who is working on the budget plan must concentrate on essentials
or she cannot face the account book with a good conscience. The
business woman has made good, the home woman must not
fall behind.
Lists. — Having decided on the sums that can be spent on house-
keeping, dress, etc., the buyer takes the important first step in her
system which is the making out of memoranda or lists of articles
to be bought and for as long ahead as plans can be made, in most
cases for the entire season. Take, for instance, the purchase of
clothing. The little book in which these lists will be kept is the
sheet-anchor of her whole system. It will contain the size of hose,
gloves, collars and other articles of dress for the members of the
family for whom the housewife must purchase, and the number of
yards of material of different widths needed for articles of clothing
to be made at home. Some sign will designate those articles which
are to be bought at once ; others may wait on her convenience, they
will be thought over, perhaps never bought at all. As one woman
said: "I spend my money many times in mind before I really
give it out."
Such lists are great savers of time and money. Armed with this
little book, a woman is safe at the bargain counter. Her needs
have been well considered, she knows whether the article offered
really fits into her plan.
HOUSEWIFE AS BUYER AND MANAGER 51
Cash or Credit.— This is a much-discussed point. It is un-
doubtedly best for the young housekeeper who is going through her
apprenticeship as a buyer to pay cash for everything, and to
continue to do so in cases where it is a distinct advantage as in the
" cash-and-carry " stores, or in certain stores which offer lower
prices for Saturday afternoons with no delivery under a
stated amount.
But for those buyers who are not made extravagant by the
chance to run up bills, credit has great advantages. The system on
which a store runs may not allow of a discount for cash ; the book-
keeper must be there, to send the monthly bill is in the routine and
the store prefers regular customers who have a habit of buying there.
The buyer receives substantial benefits from being known, and the
best way to be known is by the account. The advantages are that
mistakes are easily rectified, orders over a telephone or by mail
are well filled, and the customer is notified of special offers in
advance of the newspaper advertisement. Many buyers have found
it a help to know personally a clerk in each department of a store
which they frequent. The advantage from leaving cash in the bank
for thirty days is also to be considered.
A mercantile house must have its well-equipped buying depart-
ment always at work, but the housewife who counts buying as but
one of her many functions must always consider the time needed
to make a purchase. She goes shopping chiefly to gain information
and she cannot go often. On this account it may be cheaper for
her to use a few reliable houses for most of her purchases, but it
is a great mistake not to know many sources of supply, as the five-
and-ten-cent stores, the specialty shops, the chain groceries, and
mail-order houses, and she must try them all in oi'der to determin
to what extent they can serve her needs.
The Account Book. — The very foundation of family thrift is
the account book — without it the best of plans and resolves will
be given up. Suppose a family has been living carelessly on all
their income, without much plan, perhaps running in debt now and
then, and suddenly something happens to sober them, as an expen-
sive illness, or the call to care for a relative or friend in misfortune.
52 SUCCESSFUL FAMILY LIFE ON MODERATE INCOME
They begin to look ahead with an anxiety they have never felt
before. Now is the time to look into their finances. Also the
temper of the times now encourages it, there is a changed attitude
in the very air, a thrift campaign is on hand, home finance is being
seriously discussed in the newspapers, and many a family is saying,
" We must begin to save."
This is the hour of the account book. The housewife gives new
attention to her bills, -perhaps sets down the day's items of expendi-
ture on the back of an envelope which she brings out for anxious
study at night; the next day she uses for this purpose a grocer's
bag; she loses the envelope of the first day and she is apt to give
up, saying : " I have no time for it, and what good is it anyway ? "
The tale of her failures is considered a good joke in the family
and an indulgent husband may say, " Never mind, you haven't lost
the money; it's all been used for something. What's the use of
worrying over five cents or fifty ? "
But in reality this is a very important day with the housewife.
If she gives up, the family goes back to drifting, and they will
never gain serenity and freedom of mind ; mortification and haras-
sing debt will be only too probable as their portion. They will
never know where they stand if they have no calculated plan regu-
lating their givings and their withholdings. It is now that this
housewife needs a system, however simple, and a little help from
someone of business experience to prove to her that the task is
very important and after all not difficult. She needs help in decid-
ing how to use the brief time at her disposal for account-keeping so
as to be able to compare her expenditure in certain important lines
one month or one year with another, or to find out how to best
increase or diminish certain expenses. This is the end and aim
of her account-keeping.
In what way does the household account book differ from that of
the business house? Exact balances are of secondary importance
except in dealing with employees, tradesmen and others outside
the family, while, on the other hand, summaries of different depart-
ments of expenditure are imperative, for they must be grouped and
compared according to the estimates of the budget. All recom-
HOUSEWIFE AS BUYER AND MANAGER 53
mended methods 4 of account-keeping for the housewife have cer-
tain disadvantages. In most of them the time required is too great.
The one here suggested (page 56) takes for granted that settling
up will be done but once a month. No column is given to the day
of the month; if the date is considered important, it is affixed to
the item. Foods are listed under the five groups, among which it
has been advised to divide the money about equally.
The Home-made Form. — In order to learn her own needs
it may be well for the inexperienced housewife to begin with a plain-
ruled blank book, say eight by ten inches, one large enough to
allow of the memoranda and suggestions that are indicated below.
Since out of the account book of the past year grows the budget
of the next, she must have ready access to the answers to such
questions as the following: How much coal did we buy last year?
How much was left over and was the quality satisfactory? When
did I buy my aluminum utensils ? What did my ready-made sum-
mer dresses cost, and how have they worn? Are we eating more
butter than we used to ? How can I save for a vacation trip ? For
such purposes certain seasonal memoranda will be needed.
An Illustration. — When, for instance, the coal dealer gave his
prices in May, 1920, the housewife could find in May, 1919, the
order for that year. On the October page she finds a note of the
date when the furnace fire was lighted and later, perhaps in January,
a note as to the burning quality of the coal. Since coal prices have
advanced she sets the lighting of the furnace fire a fortnight later
than last year, helps out with oil or gas heaters and decreases the
size of the order.
The lower half of the page may be used on another month for
an itemized account of what a seamstress accomplished in one week,
to help in a comparison between the cost of ready-made and home-
made clothing, or the entry will show an attempt to compare the
wearing qualities of two table cloths. For instance, "Rose pat-
tern $3.16, Greek border $2.25, put into daily use alternately
November 25 " (the cloths supposed to be examined for signs of
4 For lists and criticisms of recent Household and Personal Expense
Account Forms, see Journal of Home Economics, June, 1920.
54 SUCCESSFUL FAMILY LIFE ON MODERATE INCOME
wear one year from date). Or, this space may be taken up with
an estimate of food consumed per person per week with the date
for comparing wholesale and retail buying, or such notes as will
record experience in methods as, for instance, success in preserving
eggs, with suggestions for the coming season.
The back part of the account book will contain pages in which
the year's summary is placed. This is very simple. Along the
top of a page will appear the various divisions of expenditures, and
the sum expended under each head is entered for the months, which
are given on the left-hand column. This system allows of com-
parison from year to year as well as from month to month. The
annual estimate of property (page 57) also belongs with the finan-
cial summaries.
These suggestions for the simplification of account-keeping are
not designed for the woman who feels equal to the use of a card
catalogue or other elaborate system of records. For her there are
manuals giving every step in the process. But the woman of small
income and many cares needs special consideration and is to be
encouraged to such a degree of order in accounts and memoranda
as her scanty time may compass.
A very simple method of keeping track of outgoes and which
allows of checking up the budget is used by some women who find
it easier than the account book. A number of large envelopes are
provided, each labelled with its subject, as food, clothing, and the
amount that can be expended for each during the year. No actual
money is kept in the envelope. When anything is given out, the sum
is entered on the back. To see how the oujtgo tallies with the budget
allowance is very easy. The envelope itself is used for notes and
memoranda. For an illustration of the use of this method see
Chapter XIII.
Help from the Bank. — By depositing in the bank all moneys
received and by paying as many bills as possible by check the
housewife has a great help in her accounts. The bank stub when
properly filled out and carried on is an accurate record of the
expenditure of most of the money and shows at any time just how
much is on hand. Banks now give check books with a large space
HOUSEWIFE AS BUYER AND MANAGER 55
for the stub on which may be kept as many items of the bill paid
as is desired. The single man or woman, with a smaller number of
outgoes than has the housewife, frequently uses no other method of
keeping accounts. Contrary to the general opinion, the moderate
income is not too small for this method. The banker will not
despise a regular deposit of $150 a month and the depositor will
have the use of the system as readily as the man whose account is
ten times as large, if a specified amount is left always on deposit.
It is probable that the domestic financier is yet to receive sub-
stantial help in the way of advice from savings banks. One savings
bank, the Society of Savings of the City of Cleveland, a few years
ago opened a department called the Bureau of Home Economics in
order to give free advice to all comers on the financial organization
and management of the family. The response which very soon
met the advertised offer has been an astonishment to those who
hold that the spending of our own money is an intimate and sacred
matter, the last thing which we would submit to the eye of a stranger.
The Bureau has been made a permanent part of the organization
of the bank and is entirely separated from its actual business. The
best division of the income and a method for keeping household
accounts are among the subjects on which advice is given, and the
calls for advice on the part of both men and women have averaged
one hundred per week during the past year. Other banks are now
starting similar " budget bureaus."
Summary. — The importance of the managing and buying func-
tions of the housewife is very great. Probably 90 per cent, of the
family money goes through her hands, and what she buys has a
definite relation to what is produced in factories and also to the
family standards. To meet modern requirements the knowledge
demanded on her part is considerable and her present method of
training, which is now chiefly in the hands of the advertiser, should
be improved by attendance on classes or courses of study conducted
by qualified people. The budget system must underly all her plans
and she must learn the value of keeping lists of what is to be pur-
chased. The time factor in buying must be duly considered and
both cash and credit systems used. In the use of the account book
summaries are of greater importance than exact balancing.
56 SUCCESSFUL FAMILY LIFE ON MODERATE INCOME
a 3
si
Ml
.ss?
isl
o^
g
OQ
^
^J 3 0 WT37?
-
PQOOfoO
:§3
HOUSEWIFE AS BUYER AND MANAGER 57
Sample Annual Estimate of Property. — Are we solvent?
Are our possessions increasing or diminishing? These questions
come within the scope of the housewife's accounts. An inventory of
property should be made every year and its final figure of net
worth or excess of property over debts be made a matter of record.
A sample of inventory of property is here given :
INVENTORY OF PROPERTY
Property Jan'y. Jan'y. Jan'y.
1919 1920 1921
Cash on hand $100 $200
Deposit in Savings Bank 500 600
House and Lot 5000 4800
Household Furniture 750 780
Clothing 250 300
Liberty Bonds 300 300
Total Property $6900
Debts
Mortgage on house $2000 $1800
Notes at bank 100
Accounts with merchants 50 .....
Total Debts $2150 $1800
Net worth of Property less Debts 4750 5180
Net increase over preceding year j 430
QUESTIONS
1. Reply to the following objections that are sometimes made:
a. That many women seem to get on very well as buyers without train-
ing. Is this belief due to a lack of right standards; how is the
untrained woman to be made to see that she does not possess them?
b. That the woman of this moderate income group is too heavily taxed
with actual household labor to allow of her taking this training.
How is public opinion to be brought to support the movement that
requires of women that they train for housekeeping before they
are married?
2. Give all the methods of such training available in your community in
the way of classes and good printed matter.
3. Would it be feasible for a group of women to unitel in sending a good
housekeeper for a course of training of the intensive sort, at the State
College, for example, that she may pass on this knowledge to
the group?
4. Can the overladen housewife secure some help from her husband as
assistant buyer? Should she abdicate entirely in his favor, or get
his active cooperation where needed under her leadership?
5. What of the children as cooperative marketers — as to the economic
service rendered — its educational value to them?
58 SUCCESSFUL FAMILY LIFE ON MODERATE INCOME
6. Is buying an act of economic consumption or economic production?
The test of production is " creation of utility." Does the housewife's
skill in selecting secure increased utilities over those arising through
haphazard buying?
7. The services of the leader or enterpriser in industry are rated as most
productive, since they direct the productive energy of others; accord-
ingly the leader is compensated more highly than routine workers.
Show the importance of leadership in the home; show that there is
compensation for good leadership in a better living secured.
8. The enterpriser is the " decision-maker " and " risk-bearer " in industry.
List the important decisions in housekeeping — and in homemaking —
on which success depends, from the initial decision to start the
new home.
9. What are the risks of failure, of economic loss, of personal disappoint-
ment, etc., in founding and conducting a family ? Are benefits usually
secured in business or anywhere without assuming risks?
10. Make a plan for self-improvement in home management by studying
the elements of your own or some other housekeeping situation that
you know well.
CHAPTEE YII
THE HOUSEWIFE'S CONTRIBUTION THROUGH
CONTROLLED FINANCE— THE ALLOWANCE
IF it be accepted that the woman is to be the manager and buyer
for the household, we now need what the lawmakers call "the
enabling act." Has she such control of the family money as is
necessary in order that she may plan and buy to advantage ? There
should be at her command whatever has been agreed on for upkeep
and the running expenses, which will include food, light, heat, and
service, and also the allowance for herself and the children for dress
and other personal needs. And this money should be at her
disposal, either in the form of cash or as a bank account on which
she can draw. Such an understanding will do more than anything
else to bring order out of the financial chaos which now prevails
in many a household.
Who Holds the Purse? — In the majority of households does
the woman have this control of money? ISTo requirement would
seem to be more reasonable ; the family has adopted a certain style
of living which they are supposed to be able to keep up, and yet
the man who is promptness itself in paying off on Saturday night
the workmen in his business may refuse his high-school daughter an
allowance for her clothing and grudgingly dole out irregular sums
of money to his wife for expenses that have been agreed on as neces-
sary, but which come up again and again for heated discussion.
Family life is not a self-respecting or happy one, unless mutual
confidence in money matters exists. If the wife does not know the
extent of the income and has no housekeeping or dress allowance,
she is apt to find out what bills are paid most readily, as probably
those for food, and seeing no advantage in economy in that line she
is less apt to practice it, while in other directions she may find her-
self forced to unwise and humiliating restrictions. She has no
chance to develop as an all-round economist and this is a great loss
to the family in many ways.
60 SUCCESSFUL FAMILY LIFE ON MODERATE INCOME
Inquiry among women goes to show that this bad system of
managing the household finances is exceedingly common. " If
only I need never ask for money " sighs many a woman. It seems
to be rare that a complete understanding exists as to the sum agreed
on as needed by the week or month to cover the regular outgoes.
The Man's View. — Before condemning the money earner for
this condition of things, it will be well to get his point of view.
We may at once exclude the exceptional types of men, those who
want more than their share of the income for their own use, and
those who feel that because they have earned the money they can
dictate just how it shall be spent. Said one of these men regarding
a regular allowance for wife and daughter : " Do you suppose I'd
give my women-folks as much rope as that ? Not for a good deal."
He did not know how antiquated is the system recorded in the
nursery rhyme:
" Clap hands, clap hands till father comes home,
For father has money but mother has none."
But the most right-minded and generous man often sees no
way to run the household without extravagance except to dole out
the money in irregular sums. He is often unjustly called stingy
because he is trying to practice thrift by an unwise system ; that is,
without gaining the cooperation of the family. It is the just pride
of the money earner to show his success by a steady improvement in
his circumstances. He may be planning an enlargement in his
business, a 'better house for the family to live in, or security for
them by a larger life insurance, and he must accumulate the means
to these ends. If disaster comes, it is he who will be blamed ; at all
costs the expenses of the family must come well within the income
and he may find that the rest of the family do not share this view.
Again, the man's natural attitude of caution resulting from his
sense of responsibility is often increased by the belief that his wife
does not know how to spend wisely the hard-earned dollars. In
many cases she has not been trained before her marriage to manage
money. To quote a business man, " It is a great discipline to have
to look a payroll in the eye every Saturday night," and this disci-
pline the man may have had and the woman not. Again, because
of wrong standards in the community she may not feel her full
THE ALLOWANCE 61
responsibility to the family interests. Thus the young couple get
started wrong ; the man may have the greatest respect for his wife's
character and her devotion to the family, but none for her business
sense. Besides, " she is careless, she makes mistakes, she has been
known to lose money — she has no -pockets ! " So he haggles and
scales down, determined to keep up the life insurance premiums and
to slip something into the savings bank each month. A crude
method, but he knows no other, and before she wakes up to the
importance of the matter, the young wife may have lost ground
which it is very difficult to recover. How can she have business
knowledge without any training in it? A woman who has had to
earn her own living has some idea of the value of money, but a
" care-free " girlhood, which too often in this country means one
that is wholly lacking in discipline or practical training, does not
qualify a woman to undertake the admittedly difficult post of
domestic financier. Only the most rosy optimism can believe that
she will " pick it up easily."
The man has perhaps no time to train his wife in business
i methods, and worst of all he does not see the importance of it.
! Nor perhaps is he quite free from the attitude reflected in so many
; plays and novels that lack of sense as to money is very feminine
and appealing, at least in the early years of marriage ! And so
\ the most well-intentioned people drift into the galling financial
; relations seen in many families.
The Woman's Training. — The whole matter, then, turns on
! the qualifications of the woman for making good on this practical
side of life, and thus winning her rights. Native business ability
is found quite as often in women as in men ; they may be even more
competent in that devotion to detail which is one factor in success.
Witness the workingman's wife, as so frequently described in this
I country and in England. In her family the margin of income be-
jyond the absolute requirements of life is so small that the pay
I envelope is generally put into her hands and she returns to her
I husband the amount agreed upon for his carfares, tobacco, etc.
I Said the laborer's wife when questioned as to the custom in the
•families she knew: "I think every woman hands over a dollar
lor two." She thought a friend of hers badly used because her
Jhusband who earned $25 a week when work was good exacted $5
62 SUCCESSFUL FAMILY LIFE ON MODERATE INCOME
as his share. But at least the sum was agreed on and accepted
by both parties. The laboring man who hands over his earnings
to his wife may be neither broad-minded nor unselfish, he is simply
following a custom that has grown up around the fact that the
family must have that money to meet the actual needs of life, and
the wife must learn to manage it, for any other way leads to ruin
and disgrace. The trouble seems to come in the management of the
surplus which is over actual needs, when, in fact, a given outlay
is no longer necessary but discussible.
It is vain to refer to the law or to depend on the phraseology
of the marriage service ; the practical question is : Does the man as
the money earner look upon the wife as a financial partner in just
the sense that he does his business partner with whom he shares,
as a matter of course, all power and all knowledge as to income
and outgo?
While this ideal understanding is probably reached in few fami-
lies, there is a growing tendency to agree on the sums necessary
for certain outgoes, as for food and clothing, and the money is
set aside monthly without question. The change has come partly
through the experience in the earning of money, now common to
the younger women of even well-to-do families. To know what it
means to earn and spend one's own dollars in the business world is
to gain sympathy and understanding for the larger problems. The
married woman ought to be able in most cases to win over her
husband to the great advantages of the partnership method of
managing the entire family income ; she can claim her rights as the
disbursing partner to know all the items of income and outgo only
by proving her ability to manage and plan better than can her busy
husband the spending of all that part of the money income which
finances the household.
The Partnership Method. — 1. It is economical. The first step
is to decide on what is the just outlay in every department, and to
do this in a committee of the whole where the mother presents the
needs of the household, the older children outline what are their
requirements in the matter of dress and pocket money and where
they can all hear from the money earner the prospects in business,
his larger plans for the future of the family and his reasons for
economy and saving. This is to gain the cooperation of all. In
THE ALLOWANCE 63
many cases as the result of discussion what were thought to be
absolute necessities will be scaled down to provide for a need that
would otherwise not have been acknowledged by all. Each one in
his or her own department of earning and spending is apt to feel a
duty to the family purse, whereas, by the old way the members of
his family dependent on the money earner for funds adopt a
" catch-as-catch-can " policy and become very astute in "'managing
father/' thus in many cases obtaining more for some item than the
right distribution of the whole income warrants.
2. The partnership method is an education. It is easy to for-
get in our eager counting of pennies that family life is a great
training ground, where the young ought to be prepared to manage
their own homes in the future and to do good, teamwork in the
community. In the school of life few things can equal the disci-
plinary value of money-spending if the results of the expenditures
are reviewed and compared, and this development is denied to any
individual who is provided for by the decision or will of another
person. There are women living in luxury who are filled with
humiliation and a sense of wrong because they have no control of
money, hardly a dollar in their pockets, although limousines are
at their command and they may order expensive clothing and
furnishings on a charge account !
The Importance of Frankness. — All who are trusted with
money will make their mistakes in the use of it, and it must be
taken for granted that they will do so; with this understanding,
"owning up" will not be humiliating. If frankness in money
matters is made a point of honor the aims of family life and the
way to reach them will become more and more clear, and this frank-
ness should begin early. If there are debts to be paid that were
incurred before marriage, if parents or other relatives are to be sup-
ported, if the woman has no knowledge of housekeeping to enable her
to play her part and contribute her share to the income, all this should
be known before marriage, for it is well to reckon beforehand on the
strain that average human nature will stand, not to speak of the
manifest justice of concealing no fact that can bear on partnership
relations. A girl who was brought up to see her father constantly
deceived or " managed " will be apt to try the same method with
her husband ; a man who has seen his mother kept on the " doling-
64 SUCCESSFUL FAMILY LIFE ON MODERATE INCOME
out " system will know no other way to treat his wife. Those who
run apartment hotels are familiar with a type of family that has
had to give up housekeeping because even a large income has proved
wholly inadequate in untrained hands. To diminish the number
of ways in which the money can leak away, the outlay for house-
keeping is thus put in the hands of the hotelkeeper, and becomes a
fixed charge met with one check. The wife thus misses her chance
to play her dignified part in the economics of the household.
The Children's Allowance. — Perhaps of all forms of outlay
none so intimately affects personal development as does the money
allowance to the children. By this system something quite differ-
ent is meant than what is known as " spending money " or the indi-
vidual savings bank accounts made for the child 'by parents or
friends. A common method is to provide each child a savings de-
posit started at birth and to this account on every birthday as many
dollars are added as represent the age of the child. This investment
if often increased by gifts from relatives and friends, and the final
sum, whose interest during these years has been compounded, is
supposed to be available when the owner comes of age, or it may be
drawn on earlier for expenses of education. This is an admirable
method of family saving, but it has no connection with the allowance
system for the child, since he has no control of it.
Nor do children in general lack spending money, in many cases
they have too much; if it is not given them, they obtain it by
teasing1 first one parent and then another. Since the war pressure
to induce children to buy thrift stamps was removed, the spending
money seems to go again to amusements and for candy and sweets,
if the results of a questionnaire taken in the schools of La Crosse,
Wis., can be taken as typical of the whole country. It was found
that for these purposes the average amount spent per student in the
high school was $1.52 a week, while pupils in the grades spent on
an average of $.42. The total expenditure for the year was placed
at $106,660 for 4014 children.1 %
But neither investments made for them nor spending money
given at random is in the nature of the allowance, which is a
definite sum paid regularly and with the understanding that it is
to cover certain necessary items, as school supplies, carfare, clothing,
1The Wisconsin Journal of Education, October, 1919.
THE ALLOWANCE 65
the amount being according to the means of the parents and the
age and judgment of the child, in addition to a small proportion
for spending-money proper. It is understood, of course, that most
of the allowance will be spent under advice and direction, for this
family cannot afford actual money waste, but as time goes on an
increasing responsibility is placed on the child, since the object Is
wholly educational.
The Common Mistake. — No mistake is more common than for
parents who have limited means to make all the decisions as to
money matters and to do all the buying on the plea that the
income allows too slight a margin for mistakes. But before they
realize it, responsibility has passed into the hands of the children
who are earning their own money and making their decisions
without the training which comes only by partial successes and
failures during the maturing years. The real way to make a rash,
uncalculating spender is to pen up an all-desiring youngster with
a peremptory " You can't have it," instead of giving sympathy and
understanding regarding the things so desperately longed for and
the help of older resourcefulness to obtain some of them. Other-
wise, the child either gains the point by sheer insistence or is made
sullen by refusal and determines to "blow it in" when earning
time comes.
To provide schools and clothing would seem to be no more
necessary than to see that children have this discipline in money
spending in order to learn the real relation of nickels to dollars
and of dollars to the definite sum which is to bring the coveted
pleasure or advantage. On the moderate income you cannot both
eat your cake and keep it, and to learn this early is to make the
acquaintance of natural law, that very old-fashioned teacher who
uses the rod without fear or favor and punishes mistakes as well
as sins.
When Shall the Child's Allowance Begin? — It seems prob-
able that the education of the boy and girl as to money spending
will have reached definite results by the time they are fifteen. What
are the steps toward that end ?
A child of five who is, perhaps, in the kindergarten, has already
begun to know that money buys things. Let the allowance start, we
will say, with ten cents a week, and the education in its use begin
5
66 SUCCESSFUL FAMILY LIFE ON MODERATE INCOME
at the same time. If there is not leisure to work out this educa-
tional plan better delay giving the allowance until it is ready. As
the dog trainer said, " This puppy ought to begin its lessons, but I
shall have to let it run wild a few weeks longer until my head man
comes back. This is a valuable dog, and I do not want to risk
a mistake."
For this child of five, by one method that is known to have been
successful, a box is provided having five compartments and two
cents are placed in each. The child is still too young for the written
account. The first compartment holds what is the child's very
own, to be spent for what is most wanted. It may be a better pencil
than has been provided, and in that case the purchase can be made
the first week; something more expensive must wait on accumu-
lation. The second compartment is "for somebody else," as the
beginning of the Christmas fund or church money.
The third may be called education, and the unbelieving older
person will be amazed to see now quickly the child comprehends that
there is something beyond to work for, something which the school
typifies. In one case a box of colored crayons was chosen to use
on the little blackboard. A set had already been given by the
grandmother, but almost as quickly broken up. This set bought
with the child's own money was treasured and really used.
The fourth division is for entertainment or fun. The first
week it was spent for the materials for a paper cap to be used
in a home play. The fifth division, reversing the rule that is used
for adults, is for savings, for some yet unknown end. It typifies
for the child the long look ahead, the awesome big bank to which it
is taken by the parent to obtain the savings bank book.
Later, the field broadens, and it is found that children will
themselves make efforts to carry out this properly balanced system
of life. They must make their own contribution to church funds,
and they may be led to start what will be a life-long connection
with such good agencies in the community as the Civic League,
the Associated Charities, the Music Association or Settlement. How
is it to be done when the amount that can safely be assigned to
philanthropy out of the family budget is barely sufficient to pay
church dues and to help a sick neighbor? Just as it was done for
patriotic ends in wartime. We have only to change names, to
THE ALLOWANCE 67
appeal to the imagination by different routes, and the habits of
sacrifice and generosity cultivated during the war will remain alive
and growing. Then young people earned money by doing odd jobs
mornings and nights and Saturdays to buy their share of a Liberty
bond, they may continue to do so in order to take their part in work
for public betterment.
By the time the child is ten years old the allowance has been
increased and the proportions have changed. The clothing allow-
ance will soon be in this young person's hands and some training
in that department of spending must gradually be acquired. For
instance, a helpful talk like the following may take place : " Do
you want better shoes, or more ties, or what is it that you are most
particular about ?" may be said to the boy who begins to feel fussy
about his clothes. " All right, but you must go without something
else to make it come out. The shoe money is very important. You
will have to buy two pairs for the same purpose and alternate in the
wearing, and the pair that is resting must be soaked with oil."
It takes more than one demonstration to convince a boy that a shoe
sole will soak up an astonishing amount of oil and finally become
so smooth and hard that its wearing time is trebled. And such
a boy no longer breaks a shoelace in putting it on from being too im-
patient or lazy to unlace it fully. Education is progressing. But
if mistakes are made the results must be borne, unless it is a very
unfortunate and disastrous mistake ; for father or mother to readily
make the loss good is to upset the whole educational system.
It is, of course, understood that at any age a certain -part of the
allowance is the child's very own to spend as he will. It gives
a cherished independence and it allows the balancing of values.
The boy who can jingle his week's money in his pocket in full hear-
ing of his mates may say, " I'm not going to the circus, I'm
saving up for a tent." He has within his grasp a desired possession
chosen of his own free will; the circus is a rejected alternative,
the sting of " going without " has been drawn.
Objections. — What is to be done about the stingy child, the
one who saves out of the clothing money until he becomes so shabby
that his family is ready to disown him, who stints on his luncheons
until he comes home faint and sick, and all to swell some pet fund,
as for athletics? It is easily managed by cutting down for a
68 SUCCESSFUL FAMILY LIFE ON MODERATE INCOME
time exclusive control of the allowance on the ground of still
unripe judgment.
It has been urged that the allowance system makes children
too independent of the family. On the contrary, those who have
carefully watched its workings find that it is more apt to bring
intelligence and sympathy with the general financial problems.
One college youth felt that his allowance of spending money must
be raised because all the other boys had more than he. His father
very wisely took an entire evening to explain to him from his own
account books what was his income and what were the family
liabilities that must be met, together with all the plans for the next
five years. The son became satisfied that he had his full share of
the family money.
Another point sometimes made against the allowance is that
much discussion of money matters makes young people petty and
commercially minded. Something depends on the method of train-
ing and the objects for which the saving is done. On the other
hand, habits and a viewpoint may be acquired early so that they
work automatically, allowing less rather than more thought to be
given to the matter; whereas, to be obliged to make a whole set of
habits in later life regarding so important a thing as money spend-
ing may prove to be so difficult that it is never done, and the person
drifts on helplessly to the end. It is this method which buys a
sealskin coat or cutglass for a wedding gift with money that should
go to pay the grocer. It was the youth who had never had any
training of this kind who paid $110 for silk shirts and $35 for
neckties with his first wartime wages; it was the woman from the
back country farm who had known only privation until her hus-
band went to work in the cantonments who bought large show
pieces of solid silver and costly furniture for her two-roomed cabin.
Another objection that has been made to the child's allowance
is that it develops too early a sense of responsibility. But it must
be remembered that helplessness in a child does not fit in with
modern conditions in the average income family, whose every
member must contribute efficient service. Children of ten have been
trusted to do all the Christmas shopping for the family in certain
well-known stores to which they had been frequently taken, and
with amazingly good results.
THE ALLOWANCE 69
But what if there are emergencies in the family and the meas-
ured demands of the allowance cannot always be met? The sums
agreed on appear just the same in the child's account book, but for
the present loaned to the parents.
Summary. — To achieve the best results in the spending of the
family money, the mother should have such control of the income
as will ensure her efficiency as manager and buyer.
Very early there should be a complete understanding between
husband and wife as to income, property, debts and financial plans
for the future. Just as the man engages to provide the necessary
funds, the wife should feel it her duty to study her work and make
ready to carry her responsibilities.
They should make out together a plan of spending and there
should be consultations over weekly or monthly bills with a view
to improving the plan and noting whether theories are being cjirjied
out in practice.
The housewife should adopt a simple method of keeping accounts
and she should enter her purchases daily. She must sum up and
balance with tolerable exactness, but she should not worry over small
sums that have been forgotten; it is better to enter them in the
" unclassified " or sundry column.
She will study her weekly or monthly summaries with a view
to improving the apportionments made and to examine into the
wisdom of her purchases, and she must classify the most important
outgoes, as for food for the family per week and month. Criticism
of results is the important thing and it makes possible a better plan
of spending for the year or years to come.
The housewife should have the actual command of money that
has been agreed on as necessary to meet expenditures, either cash in
weekly installments, a joint bank account on which both she and
her husband check, or, better still, a bank account in her own name,
for the possession of the bank book adds to the dignity of her
position and to her sense of responsibility.
QUESTIONS
Outline a plan by which, a woman may obtain the confidence of the
husband as to her ability to spend the family money wisely.
Do you think that a more accurate and detailed system of accounts is
necessary than the one suggested in the preceding chapter? Estimate
70 SUCCESSFUL FAMILY LIFE ON MODERATE INCOME
the time required for keeping it. Is not the accurate account neces-
sary until the housekeeper has acquired experience?
3. In how many families of your acquaintance is there a perfect under-
standing as to the division and use of the money of the family?
4. How often do the husband and wife consult about household expenses,
so that they may get the benefit of each other's judgment?
5. Is a joint bank account on which both may check the best plan, the
understanding being that at frequent intervals they go over the
canceled checks together and discuss the items which they cover?
Or shall the weekly accounts be discussed in advance, the necessary
cash being put in the hands of the wife?
6. Give illustrations of advantages that come from exchange of expe-
riences and views of each other's expenditures ?
7. If you were drawing up a set of financial lessons for young couples,
what topica would you include? Would you have the course takett
by the wives alone or by men also? Do you think such a course
could be given successfully in your community?
8. In a club meeting or similar group gather personal experience regard-
ing allowances: for adults in the family; for children. Experiences
may be put down anonymously in written form.
9. Enquire from some local banker as to his experience with household
checking accounts, and his suggestions as to the " model depositor."
Ascertain the minimum sum to be left in the bank on account in order
to obtain the checking privilege.
CHAPTER VIII
THE HOUSEWIFE'S CONTRIBUTION TO THE
FAMILY INCOME THROUGH HOUSEWORK
IT has been taken for granted that the family of five, which
is the subject of this study, cannot maintain a good standard
of living on the man's earnings of $2500, more or less, unless the
wife contributes most of the work of the household; that is, the
general management and care of the house, preparation of food,
care of children, etc. To keep a regular helper to do the housework
is impossible with this grade of income at the rates now paid.
Laundry and other heavy work, extra help in sickness and in the
care of little children will be arranged for by the day.
The value of the housewife's services is her necessary contri-
bution to the family income. But can she contribute this sum in
some other than this time-honored way?
Is There a Better Way? — Great changes have come about in
the last two generations. Young women are earning their living in
more ways than was possible fifty years ago, and the advantage has
been great indeed as compared with the time which restricted
the wage-earning woman to housework, sewing and teaching, and
when only absolute need was held to justify her working outside
the home at all. The too heavy load on the earning powers of the
fathers and the brothers has been lifted, and the young woman
has been given a priceless independence to work and earn in her
own name. But shall the woman remain in "gainful occupa-
tions " after her marriage ?
On higher income levels many factors enter into the decision, as
the money rewards of the occupation, the interest and zeal that the
woman has for her work, and chiefly, the character of the work
itself, as to whether it is easily combined with home life, leaving
her enough time and energy for what society requires of her in that
relation. The woman lawyer, physician, architect, writer, actress
and others of the more highly skilled and paid professional careers,
71
72 SUCCESSFUL FAMILY LIFE ON MODERATE INCOME
will, in many cases, continue their work or return to it after a time.
Their high earnings will enable them to obtain the services of the
few really qualified people who are available for housework and for
the care and education of little children. Even in these cases it
may be best for non-economic reasons for the woman to devote her
whole time to the family if the earnings of the husband are sufficient
for its support.
But it is the woman of smaller earning power with whom we are
chiefly concerned, the average woman whose husband is receiving
only a moderate income. We also assume the presence of children
in the family.
1. Which methods of money earning will be better from the
strictly economic point of view, working in her own home or work-
ing outside for wages?
2. Which method will better conduce to the happiness and
development of the woman and her family, with the inevitable
reaction on the community?
To determine the financial facts in this matter is of f oundational
importance; no institution will continue to flourish which has not
a sound economic basis ; sentiment will not avail to keep it going.
The very latest government provision for industrial education, the
Smith-Hughes Act, includes the household arts in its scheme, and
takes for granted that they are pursued in the home and that home
making, as a profession, requires a knowledge of buying, house fur-
nishing, the choosing and preparation of food, the buying and
making of clothing and the care of the child. Indeed, the provisions
of the act assume that the present method of housekeeping justifies
itself by its results and calls for public instruction for the woman
who is to practice these arts in her own home. Nevertheless, many
are the criticisms of the housekeeper who herself does the house-
work, instead of hiring it done with money which she earns outside.
The efficiency expert calls this home an anomaly, and asserts that it
is based on outworn conditions and that a comparison with results
obtained in the business world by division of labor shows conclu-
sively that we must reform it altogether.
One Kitchen or Fifty? — According to the critics, the home
in which most of the housework is done by the wife and mother
reduces her to lonely slavery in which she performs her too varied
THE CONTRIBUTION THROUGH HOUSEWORK 73
tasks very badly. Here she brings up children without knowing
how to do it; here she forces the unwilling husband to spend the
time he would prefer to spend elsewhere with men; in short, her
course is marked by waste and inefficiency and the product of her
labors is not up to modern standards.
" Light one kitchen fire instead of fifty, beat the combined eggs
by machinery, put the children from the first under the care of
trained nurse and kindergartner, keep the woman at the productive
task she learned before her marriage and let the family have their
pleasures, and more of them, in public places." This is the remedy
offered, and the growth of apartment hotels and restaurants, also
of laundries, bakeries, canneries and other means of serving the
family from outside together with the increasing number of married
women found in all branches of industry are cited as proof that
the remedy is being applied. Those who cling to the individual
home are said to do so from sentiment only.
The Individual Home Will Persist. — And yet this home,
which is assumed to be tottering under the assaults of organized
business, education, and recreation, remains with its accompanying
odds and ends of household arts as firmly fixed as an institution
as ever. Architects continue to meet the demand for the individual
kitchen and dining-room, even if they must reduce them to
tiny proportions.
Human needs are various and there will always be many ways
of meeting them; in towns and cities, where alone the choice is
possible, the elderly couple, the wealthy, the childless, the excep-
tionally gifted, the unmarried man or woman, may all choose other
ways of living, but for several reasons housekeeping on the modest
scale we are considering holds its own and is even growing in popu-
larity ; and they are important reasons, well worth our consideration.
Housework vs. Business. — Since this woman of the family
must work somewhere, business as a means of money earning is to
be compared with housework, and there are plenty of opportunities
for doing this, since women are in many industries that were not
open to them even one generation ago. According to the census of
1910, ten per cent, of the married women over sixteen were " gain-
fully employed," as compared with 4.6 per cent, twenty-five years
previous. Twenty-five per cent, of all women at work were married
74 SUCCESSFUL FAMILY LIFE ON MODERATE INCOME
as compared with 15.9 per cent, in 1900. The number of women in
industry greatly increased during the war, and it is prophesied
that they will stay in many lines of work once unknown to them.
If the older view that the woman makes her best money contribu-
tion to the family income through housework in her own home is
incorrect, if it can be shown that she is wasting her time there as
much as if she were still using the spinning wheel, if organized
business can serve the home better and more cheaply, then we ought
to know it, ^nake readjustments of the most radical character in our
daily life and in the methods of home economics training.
The Housewife's Advantage. — As a workshop the average
small home is not ideal, but it gives to the woman certain very
definite advantages over business. The home exists in any case
for the general purposes of family life, and, however it is to be
served, it must afford scope for the woman who is to be manager and
buyer and caretaker of children. The outfit for daily life must be
furnished, and certain expenses, as light, heat, rent and insurance,
will go on and do not have to be added as " overhead charges " to
the cost of its manufactured products. Equipment could, in some
cases, be cut down, as, if the laundry is done outside, the tubs
would not be needed, or if a public kitchen could be relied on to
furnish the main dish of the meal, a certain contraction in kitchen
space and utensils might be effected, but the saving would not be
great. The kitchen and dining-room cannot be wholly omitted,
considering the need of children and all but the most robust
adults for regular, perhaps frequent, meals, and also because of
the part that the home table plays in family life. These rooms, in
fact, are such a desirable part of the house, even for occasional use,
that they have become fitted into our habits and needs. Only
families made up of a few adults can reduce their quarters to the
bedroom and parlor basis. Again, in home production the impor-
tant item of labor cannot be reckoned at its full value, since the
woman's work, for instance, in the production of cooked food, may
be accomplished in connection with other duties in periods of time
too short to be utilized for outside earning.
Overhead Charges in Business. — On the other hand, in busi-
ness the overhead or fixed charges must be distributed over every
item of the finished product ; these must be paid in addition to cost
THE CONTRIBUTION THROUGH HOUSEWORK 75
of materials before any profit can be figured. For instance, when
the restaurant keeper sets forth an order of chops, he must charge it
with its share of rent and care of premises, of fuel and light, taxes,
insurance, wages, and superintendence ; he must buy food at whole-
sale and manage his complicated business with skill in order to
make the profit that skill rightly demands. An experienced hotel
man is quoted as saying that for a fifty-cent order the raw materials
must not cost more than eighteen cents, thirty-two cents being
needed to meet its share of business expenses and very modest
profits. In restaurants and hotels, according to the skill in cooking
and the elegance of service, from three to ten times the price of
raw materials in it will be charged for the finished dish. None of
those heavy overhead charges are to be considered by the housewife
who buys the chops at the market and broils them in ten minutes'
time with fuel whose value cannot be reckoned at more than a frac-
tion of a cent. Nor do these charges affect the cost of the laundry
for the home woman who in half a day, even with old-fashioned
equipment, will wash fifty pieces of clothing, big and little, while
she contrives to meet the back-door vendors and give the baby his
nap and cook lunch in the range oven, the surplus heat being used
to warm the kitchen and dining-room and the water for the evening
baths. As one woman said : " I did not even count the soap, for
the water was used afterward to scrub a rug whose cleaning, if
sent out, would have cost seventy-five cents. I did it in. fif-
teen minutes."
Even the making of laundry soap she found in war-time to be
one of the simplest and quickest of processes; otherwise useless fat
she combined with a ten-cent can of lye, and in ten minutes' time
produced seven pounds of soap worth seventy-five cents. It was
not wrapped and labelled ; it had paid for no " premium " dishes,
no bad debts; it had contributed nothing to the profits of jobber,
wholesaler or retailer, nor to the high cost of assembling, trans-
porting and distributing.
One of the constantly recurring charges on business is trans-
portation. It steps in at every turn to increase the price of the
commercial product for the consumer. When the price of launder-
ing a collar was two cents, one-half cent was said to go for collecting
and returning, a twenty-five per cent, expense. It is this heavy
76 SUCCESSFUL FAMILY LIFE ON MODERATE INCOME
cost of transportation which puts a premium on individual effort
at home, as in the raising and canning of vegetables and fruits on
the premises. The housewife who is "on the ground/' who con-
ducts her household in any case for the general purposes of family
life, cuts down this heavy tax, for her products are consumed where
they are produced, her factory has no outgoing freight bills.
Are Business Profits too Large? — Another reason why many
household industries linger in the home which might be taken out
of it seems to be that the organization of business is still very
imperfect and wasteful and that there is no public control of prices
and profits except where a public utilities board controls obvious
monopolies, as gas, electricity, telephone and trolley service, which
the inhabitants of a city are absolutely obliged to use and where
competition is not feasible. All business nourishes on the public
whose wants it serves, but its whole organization at present looks
to the increase of dividends and not at all to the decrease of prices,
except as such decrease tends to increase sales. Such orders as
" figure the profits for all that the traffic will bear " have a sinister
sound to the " ultimate consumer " who has no longer the comfort
of knowing that free competition is his friend. In ways that evade
all law, it seems easy for producers to agree on prices. The manu-
facturer says : " Who can rival your housewife who counts no over-
head charges in manufacture and makes our products in odds and
ends of time ! " But notwithstanding, business has taken many
activities away from the housewife ; she no longer spins and weaves,
for she cannot afford to. Why does not business with its enormous
advantages drive her entirely out of the manufacture of cooked food
and the washing of clothes and do for her a hundred other services
more cheaply than she can do them for herself? Business must
offer the housewife of the moderate income better terms than it has
yet done, cheaper and better service, before it can wrest from her the
domestic labor which small income now obliges her to perform.
Bread-making. — When one visits a great modern bakery and
inspects its perfect machinery and its accurately heated ovens, it
seems absurd that the housewife, with materials bought at retail,
a small and poor equipment and tiny output can vie with the baker
in the cost and quality of bread. But 70 per cent, of the bread used
THE CONTRIBUTION THROUGH HOUSEWORK 77
in this country before the war was home-made/ and with the use of
the improved home methods, now extensively taught in the schools,
it is in most cases both better and cheaper bread than that produced
in the average bakery. This is not the case in Europe, however, for
the bakers of France and Germany make bread of such excellence
and cheapness that even the poorest families cannot afford to make
bread in their own homes; bread-making as a household art does
not exist in those and other European countries, except in remote
country districts. But according to tests made in France the price
of bread some years ago was about the same per pound at any given
time as the price of flour, the profit of the baker being reckoned on
the water content of the loaf, which is about 40 per cent, of the
weight. In the United States bread costs -per pound at any given time
from two to three times the price of flour.2 Some of this difference
is due to the higher price of labor in the United States, the other fac-
tors are probably less economy in management and a larger profit to
the baker, both of which factors need investigation. We should know
by what means certain municipal and cooperative bakeries estab-
lished by war needs reduced the price of bread ; it seems very prob-
able that so important a food staple should be under more direct
public control, as to quality and price, as it is in England.
The Laundry. — Another comparison in labor may be made
with the commercial laundry, which, in spite of its machinery and
equipment, does not offer the prices that put the " by-the-day "
washer woman out of business, much less the housewife, who must
utilize every -penny. The water power and electric washing ma-
chines are giving a new lease of life to home laundry work.
Laundry work and bread-making are extreme instances; they
have nothing to do with the intimate life of the home; they are
suited to the use of machinery and will doubtless yet be done by
outside agencies for even the very poor. But if baking and laundry
are still carried on to such an extent as they are in the small house-
hold, what can be said of those arts which do have an intimate
1 Lafayette B. Mendel, Changes in the Food Supply and Their Rela-
tion to Nutrition, 1916, p. 33. Since that date the use of baker's bread
seems to have greatly increased.
2 Alonzo E. Taylor states that " in France the cost of the flour is 76
per cent, of the price of the bread; here the cost of the flour is about 36
per cent, of the price of the bread."
78 SUCCESSFUL FAMILY LIFE ON MODERATE INCOME
connection with health and comfort in the home, as the cooking
of the three meals; also of the many minor arts which require
taste and skill? If the woman who must make part of her con-
tribution to the family income by doing the housework finds the
price of bread too high, she will consider prohibitive the price of
cakes and other delicacies, and the cold meats and salads of the
delicatessen shop.
Other Economic Factors. — The householder has still other
economic advantages in the tussle that is going on with organized
business for the possession of the household industries.
She has control of her market. She has no advertising ex-
penses nor losses of goods left unsold on the shelf ; she decides what
is best for the family, calculates their needs and meets them. If
she decides that underclothing cannot be ironed, that the wrong
side of garments need not be too carefully finished by the seam-
stress, that table service shall not be too exacting, the family will
accept her decision. She is generally a more efficient worker in
the home than out of it, for self-interest and a free command of her
methods and time bring a better result than can be obtained by those
who work for wages with their eye on the clock. At her best, she
represents individual effort fully utilized, for, working as she does
on her own initiative, she is an illustration of the vast power that
lies latent in all of us and which a sufficient incentive brings into
action. War work furnished many illustrations of this hidden
power and its effective development and use. These small savings
of time and effort by people who " do for themselves " are amazing
in the aggregate and enable the housewife to be a successful rival of
many kinds of business. Self-interest furnishes a compelling
motive toward efficiency. She fits her tasks together, she utilizes
bits of time, she invents short cuts in her work. She thus repeats
the experience of the farmer who has learned that a farm of varied
crops may win out over the single-crop type, which was once the
ideal from the standpoint of efficiency.
Mrs. Bosanquet found that in six weeks the average person could
master any one of the small trades practiced in the East End of
London. At the present high price of labor it will pay any house-
wife to attain a degree of skill that will enable her to make small
repairs. If she can learn the use of the wrench and a few other
THE CONTRIBUTION THROUGH HOUSEWORK
79
tools she will even hold the plumber at bay for months. She
paper a small room ; she will upholster a chair and repaint a set of
furniture. She knows of no other way by which she can earn the
money that she would be obliged to pay out for these services.
But there are other and far more important reasons for con-
tinuing housework in the individual home by the woman of the
family. In choosing her work, for work she must, she should
consider her chances for individual development and for health, and
also the effect on the family life of the kind of occupation she
chooses. What occupations are best suited to women is a question
of national importance. It concerns the effect on the work and
wages of men, as already seriously considered, for example, in
the Report of the British Labor Party, the effect on the development
and the health of the women themselves, especially as concerns the
bearing and rearing of children, and also on the need of their pres-
ence in the home for the higher purposes of family life.
Monotony or Variety in Work. — The work of the household
is not " organized/' but this may be to some extent an advantage
to the worker. In every kind of organized labor the adjustment is
more and more to the unskilled hand ; the cunning machine is made
to this end still more cunning until it seems like a sentient being
compared with the man of vacant eye who pulls a lever and adjusts
a screw, and there is no denying that this perfect organization and
division of labor means less and less interest and development for
the worker. It is only in the first few years of office, store and
factory, that their systematic requirements' furnish discipline and
experience which is of value to the woman worker; after that the
deadening or irritating effects of monotony begin to tell.
The fact is that the more intelligent the woman, the more she
values the chance to perform a number of related kinds of work
in her own way rather than the same task over and over as part of
the relentless and impersonal machinery of labor.
It would also seem to be certain that housework when done with
intelligence and with a reasonably good modern equipment is a
much more healthful occupation for women than are most kinds
of business. Physiologists in their studies of fatigue place among
its many causes " often-repeated monotonous single acts, constant
strain of body or attention, and those tasks carried on in crowded
80 SUCCESSFUL FAMILY LIFE ON MODERATE INCOME
or unhygienic quarters." 2 If there must be overwork at times in
our difficult modern life it would seem to be best endured where it
is with and for our own, with all that brings personal incentive and
reward. As we have seen, the causes of fatigue are psychic as well
as physical, and to enjoy one's work and to see a corinection between
it and the well-being of those who are dear to us may take out a
certain element of fatigue.
Better Household Methods and Education. — Housework is
also made more attractive by the changes that have come in sanitary
and artistic standards. This change has abolished the heavy, nailed-
down carpet and the tidies and "throws" along with the uphol-
stered furniture which they once adorned. The hearty breakfast
that took an hour and a half in its preparation has gone, together
with the tradition that the pantry must be stored with indigestible
goodies as proof of its owner's accomplishments. The garret is no
longer packed with unusable things and there has been a clearing
out and lightening up all over the house as decreed by sanitary
science and improved taste ; more rarely, for instance, is time spent
in making elaborate underwear and keeping it laundered, and the
result of these changes is that the work necessary to run the average
house is greatly decreased. Labor-saving devices, especially the
many applications of electricity, are offering a help which is to be
still further extended.
Of all the influences that have been at work to bring to the
individual home more dignity, interest and efficiency, none are
more important than the new education in household .standards
and processes. Schools have arisen by the hundred, maintained
by both private and public funds, to teach the household arts accord-
ing to the newest scientific methods. The school girl is thus given
a clearer idea of their dignity and importance, while the education
of the adult woman is continued by means of columns in the daily
and monthly press, often ably edited, and by state and government
" extension classes/' The national government is planning to
spend enormous sums for teachers, for scientific investigation and
for literature, all for the training of the woman who is to preside
over the individual household. The effect of this teaching has
already been very great. It has put housework in a place of honor,
"Science, 1916, p. 727. F. S. Lee.
THE CONTRIBUTION THROUGH HOUSEWORK 81
because the most intelligent and scientific methods have been applied
to it. This instruction has turned drudgery into interesting work,
and has changed the whole business of housekeeping for the woman
of intelligence. The creative impulse is one of the strongest within
us. Our grandmothers and great-grandmothers found its expres-
sion in the manufacture of butter and cheese and cloth for sale,
our mothers were in many cases a misfit in the home robbed of
these interesting industries, and not yet adjusted to home-making
on newer lines. Education and the improvements that accompany
it are showing the woman of to-day the possibilities of the home
in which the household arts are practiced. Whatever is touched
by science and art and reduced to orderly and efficient methods goes
up in public regard ; the best illustration is that of the trained nurse
of to-day who bears no relation to the " Sairy Gamp " of the past
in character, in equipment, or in social position. When like in-
fluences are brought to bear on the art of cookery it will no longer
be associated with dirty, dark holes called kitchens and with slat-
ternly garments. In the same way a better knowledge of sanitation
is making the housewife more vigilant as to the service furnished
her from outside, more conscious of possible dangers to health in
food cooked in public eating places; a volume is expressed in her
preference " to wash her own lettuce/'
The Expert is Scarce. — But the all-compelling force that holds
the conscientious woman to her tasks in the home is the knowledge
gained through many trials and failures that the much-advertised
expert, who is supposed to teach her children, feed her family, keep
her accounts, do her shopping, and perform the thousand other tasks,
big and little, which now forbid her taking a working job outside her
family, does not exist! When the housewife has earned her money
outside, as she has been adjured to do in order to pay for these tasks,
she does not find the people on whom to spend it. They are few
in number and wholly beyond her purse.
If such fully developed agencies are to be expected in a civilized
country, then ours is very backward indeed. We hug many de-
lusions. One of them concerns the "trained expert." In cities
whose streets are badly cleaned and where ashes and garbage are
allowed to pile up in the icy floods of winter, where personal vigil-
ance is necessary to secure uncontaminated even the raw materials
6
82 SUCCESSFUL FAMILY LIFE ON MODERATE INCOME
of life, how can we expect the niceties of service which require a
degree of training and organization only to be found in a highly
organized society ?
The Conclusion as to Housework vs. Outside Earning. —
Whether the woman who presides over the family of the moderate
income will continue to make her contribution by doing the house-
work or by money earning outside the home must be decided on
grounds that are both economic and social. In comparing these two
ways of money earning we are not concerned with which is the
more honorable, that question belongs to a past-and-gone attitude
toward labor ; we are concerned simply with a comparison of values.
To sum up : the woman who adds to the value of raw materials
by making them into the finished product in her own home, as seen
in the cooked food or the finished garment, or by renewing the
service of articles as in washing dishes or cleaning, seems to have
at present certain advantages over outside labor which is offering
the same service:
1. Since the house exists and is conducted for the general pur-
poses of family life, the housewife is not obliged to add to the price
of what is manufactured in the home certain " overhead charges,"
which must be paid by business and added to the price of the finished
product as sold.
2. The fact that what she produces in the home is consumed
there, cuts out transportation charges, except those connected with
the assembling of raw materials.
3. The time-factor, which on account of the high price of labor
is the heaviest charge on outside business, is not, in the housewife's
case, to be put at the same high figure, since part of her time is
always necessary in her household for other than economic func-
tions, and she " works in " to a certain extent her odds and ends
of household arts. To make a complete comparison on this im-
portant point more facts are needed than we now possess.
4. There are many other economic factors to be taken into
account, such as the superior efficiency of the home worker who
is impelled by self-interest to improve methods and to use materials
with economy and who, on account of the variety and interest of
her tasks, and the command over her time which enables her to
THE CONTRIBUTION THROUGH HOUSEWORK 83
plan periods of rest, can work longer hours without fatigue than
can the woman in business.
5. There seem to be many non-economic reasons for retaining
some of the household arts in the individual home, such as the
control over healthful conditions requiring personal vigilance, the
development it affords to the worker and the educational value of
the household " plant " in the rearing of children. To make her
necessary contribution to the family income by doing the work in
her own home seems at present to be the only way by which the
woman of small means can keep up her intimate relation with the
family and perform her valuable non-economic functions.
It is taken for granted in this comparison that standards of
living in the home are very important in their bearing on the com-
fort and development of its members. When the mother is obliged
to go out to earn the living, leaving the house to half -grown chil-
dren, only through exceptional good fortune, as in the help and
advice of near-by relatives, can such standards be maintained.
These comparisons apply for the most part only to town and
city life; in all rural communities, where nearly one-half of our
population lives, individual housekeeping must still be the rule
and most of the household arts be performed at home.
It will be noted that many of the reasons for retaining the
household arts in the home are subject to change. At any time
improvements in business methods may so lower prices of essential
products as to entirely remove certain processes from the home.
It is such advances that must be watched by all those interested
in home economics. The time factor used in making the com-
parison is also subject to change, labor it may be found possible to
utilize half days or certain hours in lucrative employment inside or
outside her house, while the bulk of the housewife's time is still
devoted to her home interests. At present the half-time work of
this character is difficult to find.
The home economics extension work of the Department of
Agriculture has had great success in helping women and girls to
make money by canning fruit and vegetables for sale, and by
giving them better methods in poultry raising and butter making;
the cooperative laundry is a part of cooperation plans as developed
among the fanners of the northwest. City women are beginning
84 SUCCESSFUL FAMILY LIFE ON MODERATE INCOME
to unite in the care of little children during certain hours of the
day and all such enterprises will have their effect on the form
of the housewife's labor.
Housekeeping Compared with Boarding. — An actual family
account book is here used to illustrate the contribution which the
woman may make to the family income by doing the housework in
her own home. The study was made in 1916.
This estimate does not concern itself with any outlay for indi-
vidual needs, since that would be the same whether the family lived
at home served by the woman of the family, or whether they bought
shelter, food and operating needs of some boarding-house manager
for a stated sum per week.
The comparison covers three items: First, house rent; second,
operating expenses ; third, food. The income of a family living in a
middle-size city was $1600 (in 1916) ; the number in family, four,
of different ages (reckoned as four adults in food requirements).
WHEN THE WIFE DOES HOUSEWOEK
Per person
Per Year per week
1. House rent (eight rooms) $300.00 $1.44
2. Operating (heat, light, and wet wash) 138.48 .67
3. Food (materials) 491.24 2.36
4. Value of labor of housewife for year, 2262 hours,
at 15 cents an hour (reckoned at cost of
hiring substitute) 339.30 1.63
Cost per person per week of rent, operating ex-
penses, food and labor $6.10
In the above estimate of the cost of the family way of living
the labor of this housewife, which averages seven hours a day for
six days in the week throughout the year and one and a half hours
on Sunday, covers all of the housework except the washing and
certain jobs of outside cleaning that are attended to by the man
of the family, who also cares for the furnace. It includes buying,
cooking, cleaning, ironing and mending, but no making of clothes.
The time set down for labor on Sunday requires explanation.
In many families Sunday is the day of the week which calls for
unusual exertions on the part of the housewife as the family is all
together and at leisure and they enjoy a more elaborate dinner, to
THE CONTRIBUTION THROUGH HOUSEWORK 85
which they may perhaps invite friends. But in this family a
different policy was followed ; they cooperated in the Sunday work
expressly for the purpose of reducing the labor of the housewife.
The reason for putting the price of fifteen cents an hour (ex-
clusive of food) on the housewife's time is that this price held
in her city at that time for the by-the-day or hour houseworker.
It will be urged that the degree of skill and general intelligence
required of such a woman is considerable, and that, therefore, the
price put on her time should be much higher; but it was possible
in that community at that time (1916) to find a woman capable
of filling such a post, called " working housekeeper," for the fol-
lowing remuneration:
1. Her share of the family living expenses, as calculated
above, rent, operating expenses and food $6.10 per week.
2. Wages 5.00 per week.
$11.10
The reason why such a position was easily filled at a moderate
price seems to be that the number of intelligent and practical
women available for such positions was rather large, while the
number of wholly satisfactory steady positions for such women,
yielding a certain income of $5 a week, or $260 a year, besides all
living expenses, except clothes, were not plentiful, and such women
were attracted by a position of recognized dignity where the working
hours could be reduced to six or seven a day.3
Speaking commercially, the wife and mother of the family
whose budget we are considering receives the above living expenses,
and in place of wages her share of all the other times of the house-
hold budget, that is, what is spent for clothing, medical attention,
culture, amusements, etc., together with the security afforded by
steady employment, " a life position," and generally what may be
called a pension in the form of the husband's life insurance, or
interest on invested savings. She has also the honor and the
independence coming from her position as married woman
and householder.
8 During and since the war more kinds of work have become avail-
able for women answering the above description, and whether this state-
ments holds true at present is doubtful.
86 SUCCESSFUL FAMILY LIFE ON MODERATE INCOME
The position of such a housewife is thus seen to be comparable
from a financial point of view with that of her sister working out-
side, and the husband who puts into the home partnership earnings
that amounted in 1916 to $1600, is doing his share in a financial
sense. He, as well as his wife, is supposed, of course, to make
further contribution of a non-material kind necessary to the family
happiness, contributions which are purely personal, whatever may
be the income level and not affected by their mode of daily life.
We have now to compare the cost of family life at home, as
managed by the wife and mother in her seven hours a day of labor,
with what the board of this family would cost in the same locality
and in a place that maintained about the same standards as held
in their home. Prices are used which prevailed in the city where
this family lived at the time.
WHEN WIFE WOBKS OUTSIDE
Table board and room and its care
(two persons in a room) $8.00=: a week per person
Laundry 1.00 = a week per person
$9.00= cost per person of board-
ing
Deduct from this 6.10 = cost of home living
$2.90 = excess of cost of boarding
per person over cost of
living at home.
Thus $2.90 per person per week, or $11.60 for the entire family,
was in this instance the excess of cost of boarding over cost of
living at home with the mother of the family doing the housework.
That is, if the housewife were to choose boarding for herself
and family, that amount of money would have to be brought in
by her in some kind of labor outside her home. Moreover, if she
is to keep her present degree of leisure, which seems to be necessary
to the health and efficiency of a middle-aged woman, she must earn
this money in the time she now gives to labor ; that is, seven hours
a day. Seven-hour-a-day jobs are not easily found, and if she is to
work outside her house, carfare and time for transportation is in
any case to be added, also a much larger outlay for the better cloth-
THE CONTRIBUTION THROUGH HOUSEWORK 87
ing needed for public places. This makes the comparison still
more favorable financially for housework in her own home. The
woman who values some degree of leisure in her day, and variety
rather than monotony in her tasks, may well hesitate to make the
exchange in her form of labor from her own housekeeping to outside
work, even if there were no other considerations.
Other Considerations That Favor Housekeeping. — In mak-
ing this comparison some considerations have been omitted which
vitally concern the health and happiness of this family, and there-
fore their efficiency as individuals.
Food chosen and cooked by the homekeeper will usually be
more wholesome, more suited to the individual needs, and it is eaten
in home surroundings. Individual sleeping rooms are possible and
there is a whole house or apartment to range over and to which
to invite friends. The woman has that control of leisure time which
enables her to make a true home for herself, her husband and her
children. Home pleasure reduces the amount of money spent in
outside amusements.
All these considerations are of great importance; although it is
difficult to express their value in money, they together contribute
to the attractiveness of the individual home for which men and
women have always been willing to labor and sacrifice.
We must conclude that this housewife who can do the work for
herself and three other adults in a home of their own with a wise
use of material and time, who can bring to them health and satis-
faction, and in addition gain for herself so large an amount of
leisure, is an " economic success." At that time (1916), unless she
could bring in from outside work at least $600 a year in money,
she would find it necessary to stick to the home task, and allowance
is still to be made for the four considerations above stated, which
the family may consider worth as much more.
In the four years since this study was made household labor has
greatly increased in price, while the pay in clerical or teaching
positions to which this housewife would turn for money earning
has advanced far less, therefore the comparison at present is prob-
ably still more in favor of housework done in her own home as being
her best way of making her contribution to the family income.
88 SUCCESSFUL FAMILY LIFE ON MODERATE INCOME
QUESTIONS
1. Repeat this study of comparative costs of home life vs. boarding for
some family and community that you know, estimating values for
any facts on which you cannot get exact information.
a. for a family with children.
b. for a family without children.
2. In a family of five, three of them children, money income $2000.00,
where the woman is doing all of the housework, including laundry,
make an estimate as to the cost of hiring all the housework done (a)
by a working housekeeper, (b) by hiring by the hour laundress, cook,
child's nurse, seamstress and cleaner, as long as needed.
3. On the above basis estimate the money value of the products produced
by a woman in twenty-five years of houskeeping, covering cooked
meals, canned food, clothing made, clothes washed, cleaning done,
the sick nursed, etc. Include only absolutely necessary service for
health and efficiency.
4. At what price can you hire a girl of sixteen to help in office work for
eight hours a day? A school girl of sixteen may help her mother
for four hours a day, what are her services worth to the family?
Compare with the cost of her maintenance, room, food, clothes, etc.
6. In a boarding house, who pays for planning meals, for marketing, cook-
ing, washing dishes, cleaning the house, laundering of table linen?
Have you any idea what proportion of the price of table board goes
for these services? Suppose the housewife does such work for the
family, is the service of less worth?
6. What activities can be taken from the home and industrialized with-
out harm to the home life? The laundry? Kitchen? Dining room?
Library? Living room? Sleeping room? Nursery?
7. List possible half time jobs for women including any that you think
might be developed. How develop them?
8. We are told that women are dissatisfied with the narrowness of home
life. Compare this degree of dissatisfaction, whatever you may judge
it to be, with that felt by men and women in general with business life.
CHAPTER IX
THE TIME ELEMENT IN HOUSEWORK
SINCE labor must be reckoned at its real value, whether per-
: . formed by the housewife or paid for in money to an employed
| person who comes in from outside, time saving becomes the central
I problem. Some light is thrown on the question by the various
f estimates of the cost of the hired worker in the household, which
1 vary at present between $600 and $1000 a year, including board
and room. Work by the day requiring average skill is paid $2
to $3 or more. Not only is household help high-priced, it is scarce
at any price, and on that account families with incomes of even
$4000 to $5000 have made readjustments in many ways, as in closing
1 unused rooms, buying labor-saving devices and making free use of
j electric current for all household purposes so as to reduce the labor
to what can be performed by the family. A new money value is
j thus placed on the time required to perform each act of household
I service, which has led to a study of time saving, the cutting out of
| certain kinds of work and a reduction in the time required to
perform others.
The Eight-hour Day. — Is the eight-hour day feasible for the
housewife ? Not as households are at present run. It would require
something like a revolution in both standards and methods to enable
one woman to do the work of the average household of five members,
including washing, ironing and cooking and care of children in
eight rounds of the clock. We have also to ask whether there is the
same requirement for the eight-hour day for the woman in the
household as for the man or woman in industry who must allow
from one to two hours a day for travel to and from the place of
work and who, in most cases, labors at a task which has but little
interest or variety, one which is minutely supervised by another and
thus offers few chances for individual initiative and control of time.
But even when this allowance is made we know that the present
length of the working day in the home must be shortened while at
the same time the essentials of family life are met.
90 SUCCESSFUL FAMILY LIFE ON MODERATE INCOME
Reducing the Amount of Work to be Done. — Elimination
is the first step. Household methods must be scanned with new
eyes in order to determine whether they forward such essentials
or have become a part of an outgrown system. Are they decreed
by habit or custom or do they meet a basic requirement, as hygiene ?
Take an illustration from the laundry. One housewife who deter-
mined to cut down the size of the weekly washing, having first
eliminated all luxurious extras, was moved to inquire whether the
requirement for a weekly change of sheets on her five single beds
did not go back to a time of double beds when people bathed less
frequently and wore their day underwear at night. She reduced
the amount of bed linen, and allowed a more generous use of all
clothing that came next the skin, thus establishing in one depart-
ment of her housekeeping hygiene as more important than habit
or custom. Again, woven underclothing and other articles were
pulled into shape as taken from the line, because there was no time
available for ironing them without encroaching on the afternoon
rest hour. In another house it was decided that time was saved
by having two laundry days in the month instead of four ; and table-
cloths were ruled out, doilies and runners of Japanese crepe being
substituted, as being very easy to launder.
In the same way all inherited household customs will be exam-
ined, in order to see whether they have outlived their day and
should give way to better methods. Probably no one in the com-
munity is so bound by custom as is the housewife. An observing
eye may find illustrations of outworn habits in every room of
every house; it would seem that the housewife of the present day
must be urged to be an iconoclast ; no inherited method should be
sacred from her examination.
The House as Making or Saving Work. — Is such housework
as we have agreed on as necessary done by the most efficient methods ?
Of first importance is the place where it is done. Is the working
plant or house so built and furnished as to make the work easy?
Much of the deplorable waste seen in daily living comes from the use
of houses planned, if planned at all, for conditions now outgrown.
Thus, a family may be seen trying to do their own work in a house
that was built at a time when two or three servants could be
afforded because all together their wages were not more than what is
THE TIME ELEMENT IN HOUSEWORK 91
paid to one, and their food was too cheap to be seriously con-
idered. Unfortunately, the family with a small income, the one
in which the item of labor is so important, is seldom the family that
can plan its own house. Building plans for houses are adjusting
all too slowly to the new housekeeping, and this is especially true
of the eastern part of the country, where household labor has only
recently become dear and scarce. The housekeeper on the Pacific
Coast has paid high wages for help for a whole generation, and the
result has been that houses carrying a moderate rental are built
with many conveniences such as are found elsewhere only in the
homes of the well to do.
Readjustment in Present Housing. — Since most of us must
live in houses or apartments that were built with little regard to
the family life or the work that will go on within their walls, we
must consider how they can be improved with a limited amount of
money. Much, very much can be done by the observing house-
keeper herself, but it is often the case that in order to see what
is needed she must stop her busy rounds and observe someone else
at work in her domain. A woman who had to spend a month in
an invalid's chair recovering from an operation, was wheeled from
room to room of her house and used the time finding out " why
it took so long to do the work/' She said afterward that no month
of her life had been better spent.
Advice from Outside is Needed. — It is not easy to look upon
the familiar scene with new eyes. It remained for a friend of the
family to discover that in a rebuilding of a farm kitchen, when the
pump and sink were moved to another side of the room, the roller
towel had not followed it, and that for three years the family had
washed hands at the sink and crossed the room to wipe them,
no one thinking of the inconvenience. An outsider, especially
one experienced in such matters, as the county demonstration
agent, who has made over many a farm kitchen, will often give
excellent advice. To improve the light in a room whose wall space
is already taken up she may advise high horizontal windows; for
better ventilation she proposes the transom over the door worked
with convenient cords; to lessen time in cleaning she advises that
floors be kept well painted, or varnished, or even new floors laid,
whatever the expense may be. She may advise the cutting of a
92 SUCCESSFUL FAMILY LIFE ON MODERATE INCOME
doorway so as to shorten a path often traveled, the putting up of
shelves or the enclosure of corners for closets. The kitchen may
be quite made over merely by rearrangement of its furniture as seen
in diagrams that are found in publications devoted to arrangement
of kitchens ; 1 as to better equipment she will know what can be
-made with moderate skill at home, as a kitchen cabinet out of an
old bookcase or chest of drawers, or the small table fitted with
good casters to wheel between dining-room and kitchen.
Arrangement of Equipment. — The saving of steps and there-
fore of time, by means of convenient arrangement of work units,
is well illustrated by the relation of the kitchen to the dining-room.
If the kitchen is small, the table must be in the room adjoining
or in that most delightful of built-on rooms, the "breakfast
alcove," where both table and seats are fixed. If the kitchen is
large it will accommodate the dining table, at least in winter, and
this will be greatly to the advantage of the person who serves the
meals and to those of the family who desire her companionship.
This family which must " do for themselves " cannot afford too
great a distance between the preparation of the food and the place
of its consumption. There are other reasons for the arrangement.
It has even been claimed that farm cookery began to decline in
quality when the family no longer ate in the kitchen ! Some of
our returned soldiers are homesick for the intimate cheer and
hospitality that they found in the living-rooms of French homes
in the country villages where they watched the delicious meal being
cooked on the coals of the open fireplace or saw the spit run by
clockwork turning the roast.
Labor-saving Devices. — The saving of time in housework also
depends on the proper equipment and tools. It may be taken for
granted that all small tools and such equipment as has been proved
to really reduce the time needed to perform daily processes are
at hand for the woman who does her own work ; indeed, she cannot
afford to go without them. A halting eggbeater, a poor sieve, a
utensil that easily burns on the bottom, must be replaced because
of the time that they waste.
Regarding the more expensive devices, as the vacuum cleaner
and washing machine and dish washer, a more careful decision is
1 The Farm Kitchen as a Workshop, Farmers' Bulletin, 607.
THE TIME ELEMENT IN HOUSEWORK 93
to be made. Are such appliances to be recommended to the woman
of the moderate income? Will they enable her to dispense with
labor for which she must -pay $2 to $4 a day ? If the family is large
and the housewife not equal to all of the work, she generally hires
the washing and the weekly cleaning done. Will such appliances
cut down labor charges? If so, she must buy. Business is con-
stantly adjusting to the rising price of labor. " Save us one man's
time and we will buy of you," says the manufacturer to the maker
of a labor-saving device. Here is a good illustration of the house-
wife's need of expert advice in making her many difficult decisions.
Granted that if the laundry is done at home a machine of some
kind should be afforded, what kind of a machine it is to be depends
on a calculation as to the cost of the machine, the cost of running
it, whether by hand, by water power or electricity, the space for
installation, the size of the washing and yet other factors not easy
lifor the average housekeeper to determine unaided. This is also
! true of the vacuum cleaner and much other equipment. The house-
:iwife should be granted free expert advice from federal or state
.paid agents, just as the farmer has it regarding machinery that he
! buys, the right fertilizer for his fields, the testing of seed corn,
i the best methods of -planting. The manufacturers of prepared food
ihave had to submit to the truthful label, the firms that make com-
jmercial fertilizers expect to meet government analysis, but the
1 buyer of household equipment is still largely helpless in the hands
]of the advertiser and salesman.
No utensil should be bought simply because it is a labor saver
for someone else or makes a brave showing in the hands of a skilful
demonstrator in the booth of the food show. The buyer must
determine whether in her own kitchen and with her own require-
ments it will save its price by saving labor or strength. Otherwise
'she cannot afford it.
The grouping of utensils is also important in the reduction of
labor; kitchen utensils must be hung in plain sight near where
they are to be used. No adjustment is too small to be considered if
it saves a step or a moment of time, even to the tying of a pencil to
the order book to prevent running about for one.
Fatigue in Housework. — Suppose the "plant," that is, the
house, and especially the rooms in which most of the work is done
94 SUCCESSFUL FAMILY LIFE ON MODERATE INCOME
and also the equipment in the way of furniture and utensils to
reasonably adapted to time saving,2 we must next enquire whether
the conditions under which the work is done and the methods em-
ployed are such as to reduce the attendant fatigue to its lowest limits.
Scientific Studies of Fatigue. — Some excellent work has been
done in the study of fatigue in its relation to output by the leaders
in scientific shop management, Gantt, Taylor, Emerson, and others,
by means of so-called practical tests, while physiologists with labora-
tory appliances have experimented on men and animals to determine
the effect of resting periods of various length, of overtime, of night
work, of ventilation, of heat and humidity and other conditions.
The observations so far conducted along these lines are admittedly
too few in number and have been carried on for too short a time to \
warrant sweeping conclusions, but they certainly justify the state-
ment made in Dr. Lee's 3 critical summary of this work that " the
present ways of handling the human machine are empirical and
crude," words which apply to the houseworker as well as to the
polisher of metals, the piler of bricks, or the digger of trenches.
Common sense furnishes a rough estimate of the importance of these
factors, but many exact tests must be made before a fair working dav
can be established on this basis for the household.
There must be more knowledge as to the degree of fatigue that
follows the performance of the tasks of different character of which
housework is made up. The housewife says, " I am tired/' the
expression of a feeling which varies from slight weariness to ex-
treme exhaustion. Is it not possible to know the kind and the
degree of her fatigue and how it is related to the character of the
task and to the conditions under which it is performed, as the
efficiency of her tools and other equipment, ventilation, light; the,
worker's strength and training and methods, the planning of the
work, the use of resting periods, the character of the food, andj
also certain psychological data, as the interest taken in the process,
that is, whether the mental attitude of the worker is full of courage
and interest or of irritation at what she feels to be drudgery ?
* Conveniences for the Farm Home, Farmers' Bulletin, 270. Farm
Kitchen as a Workshop, Farmers' Bulletin, 607. Home Labor Saving
Devices, Rhea C. Scott, Lippincott. Housewifery, L. Ray Balderston,
Lippincott.
3 Frederick S. Lee, The Human Machine and Industrial Efficiency, 1918.
THE TIME ELEMENT IN HOUSEWORK 95
Studies of the energy used iii performing various household
ji tasks, as tested by the calorimeter, are under way in more than one
I laboratory ; it is already safe to predict that the output in housework
by the use of a given amount of effort is to be greatly increased by
attention to all of the conditions under which the work is done ; *
! experimenters say that here is an open field for research.
Conditions for Work. — The conditions of all kinds under
! which housework is done must have the most searching examina-
tion, for they have a direct relation to fatigue. Does the worker
! know how to stand properly ? Are there high chairs and f ootrests
provided so that as much work as possible is done in a sitting posi-
tion? Why not utilize the electric fan in kitchen as well as
parlor to keep the air moving? Is it not possible to keep
'the temperature of workrooms between 60° and 68°, which
fhas been found in industry the limits between which work is done
with least fatigue? Does the houseworker utilize the established
fact that in the early morning hours the muscles act with greater
ease and the mind is clear for difficult decisions ? Are rest periods
arranged for? The habit of relaxing and falling asleep instantly
in a quiet, darkened room can be cultivated, and ten minutes of such
complete rest may be found to be worth an hour of ordinary quiet.
Effect of Overwork. — In certain experiments in industry it
was found that overtime work was followed by such a degree of
fatigue that double time was needed for recuperation and thus
the fancied gain was turned into loss. Sometimes a state of ner-
vous exhaustion is the cause as well as the result of overwork, and
brings on that " zeal for finishing " which attacks the energetic
when a job lengthens out beyond calculation and threatens exhaus-
tion to the worker. " To-morrow is also a day " is the maxim
of the lazy, but it may well be used by the woman to whom self-
restraint at such times requires a great effort. The children of a
certain family were wont to say : " Mother's going to be sick ; she's
determined to clean the woodshed chamber." The woman who
cannot rule herself in this matter of working until her nerves are
frazzled is the one who is constantly reminding her family of how
she toils for them and how grateful and helpful they ought to be.
4 The Energy Loss of Young Women during the Muscular Activity of
Light Household Tasks. Am. Phil. Soc., vol 58, No. 1, 1919.
96 SUCCESSFUL FAMILY LIFE ON MODERATE INCOME
A generous child is vaguely troubled and resentful at such appeals.
If he were to think it out he would say : " I did not ask to be born
and I am making as little trouble as I can/' A youth of twenty,
on being asked by his mother what mistakes she had made in bring-
ing him up, replied : " Mother, don't ring in the sobstuff on the
younger ones/'
Worry. — Conditions that worry, irritate and depress reduce
the working power and bring on fatigue. The habit of dwelling
on what has gone wrong must be looked on as the deadly enemy of
efficiency. A nerve specialist said recently that many of his women
patients were those who had been made ill by their worry over the
adjustment of household expenses to the high price of living, a state
of mind which could not bring down prices or do anything except
lower the efficiency of the household manager.
Other Factors in Fatigue. — Disorder in one's surroundings
brings on worry and weariness, unless disorderly surroundings have
become so familiar as to lower all standards ; this fact alone would
justify putting things in place and requiring cooperating from the
family in this regard.
Uncomfortable and ill-looking dress is responsible for much
irritation and fatigue. Probably nothing so helps to keep up the
morale of the woman of the family as the resolve that, come what
will, her dress is to be not only comfortable and suited to her task,
but clean and attractive ; she will then never feel like a drudge, nor
fly around distractedly to " fix up," or open the front door with a
cringing air ; she is " queen of herself though china fall/' What
kind of work-dress is most comfortable, most easily laundered, most
quickly put on, is worth careful study. The one-piece dress, the
skirt with middy blouse, both have their advocates. The shoes must
be broad with low heels, the kitchen is not the place for wearing out
old, ill-fitting shoes.
Interest and Variety. — Among the devices to speed up work at
munition factories during the war were constant appeals to patriot-
ism; and the effect on output was always good. In the same way,
interest in her task will enable the housewife to accomplish more
in a given time. Looked at rightly, her work is full of interest and
variety as compared with the often monotonous tasks of industry.
The spirit in which the work is done may diminish fatigue and
THE TIME ELEMENT IN HOUSEWORK 97
make the work effective, and, if exact tests could be applied, this
interest and enthusiasm for her household tasks in their relation
to the well-being of the family might prove to be as great a stimulus
to the worker as was patriotism to the maker of gas masks.
What Will the Housewife Do About It? — These are a few
of the factors which affect fatigue and therefore have an intimate
relation to the most important item in running expense, the estimate
for labor. It remains to ask what is the solution of this complicated
problem which the housewife of small means is called upon to face ?
Nothing less than the rearrangement of her daily life according to
an estimate of comparative values, which is so important that it
deserves no smaller name than her philosophy of life. First comes
her higher relations to her family, not to be attained unless she
herself is in good health and spirits, with at least a little leisure.
And she knows that this leisure is to be gained only through a
mastery of her work ; she must decide what is important and then
learn to do it by the best methods. An old-fashioned housekeeper
said : " Housework seems to me like one of those examples in long
division where there is always a remainder." But the woman of
the new view feels that in such a case the work is dictating to the
worker. What cannot be done to-day belongs of right in to-morrow's
schedule ; it is not there on sufferance as a disgraceful left-over.
No one will make a study of the saving of time who has not a clear
idea of what that time saved is for. One of its first uses must be to
furnish the wife and mother some daily rest and recreation. The
effect of having her " nose always to the grindstone " is to lack
perspective, to exaggerate the importance of small things, and to
begin to lose respect for herself as an individual who has a right
to continued development, one who should look well and feel well.
The sacrifices made by the mothers of a former generation have
in many cases been stupid. A better way could have been found.
It is often the mother who is to blame for the daughter's aversion
to undertaking the care and responsibility of a family. The girl
does not know what is the matter, but she does not want to lead
the life her mother has led. She wants to board after she is mar-
ried ; boarding looks to her like an easy way out.
'Good Health a Requirement. — It must be decided, to begin
with, that the wife and mother needs certain free hours every day
7
98 SUCCESSFUL FAMILY LIFE ON MODERATE INCOME
to maintain her health and to make sure that she is not too tired
to contribute to the family life the courage and gayety and the clear
view of essentials which helps her to steer straight through all
difficulties. Those who cry out over the heavy task of the house-
worker are apt to speak of the " delicate wife and mother " She
is always " dragging around " half alive. " Mother/' protested a
little boy, " when you look so, we feel so." One of the first require-
ments on a woman ought to be abounding health and the knowledge
of how to maintain it, and since so much illness is due to ignorance
and laziness it is fair to say that most women can gain and keep
good health and develop working power if they are resolved on it.
It will do any family good to learn that the "mother's hour"
must be as much a part of the daily schedule as the "chil-
dren's hour."
A woman threatened with invalidism said : " I must not try to
do any work in the afternoon," and when lunch was over she went
forth with her children to sit in the park in the sunshine. The
household survived and the woman recovered her health and learned
meanwhile to cut out some non-essentials in housekeeping.
Intellectual and Social Needs. — To meet her physical needs is
not enough, there must be some attention to the mental and social
cravings. This is not a matter of self-indulgence or luxury, but a
very real need to the average housewife. She may be a perfect
mother to her children when they are young, and yet be unable
to adjust to their changing interests as they grow older, because she
has not herself grown and developed.
Doubtless one of the sacrifices that the mother of a family must
expect to make is in putting off much that she would like to do
for her own cultivation and pleasure until family cares are less
pressing, and there is no better argument for a good education and
a habit of reading in youth than that it allows of this putting off
without any risk that the loss will be permanent. Moreover, a back-
ground of early training gives courage to attempt new things with
odd moments of time. One woman kept a Greek grammar in the
baby's cradle, and taught herself the elements of a noble language.
Another, with the help of a correspondence course, studied geology,
and it brought to her the greatest refreshment of mind and put a
new interest into the walk with the children. A fine young matron
THE TIME ELEMENT IN HOUSEWORK 99
moved with her family to a distant city. She met new domestic
conditions, new social demands. At the end of a year she wrote to
an old friend, " I thought at first that I should go insane trying to
keep up my standards of good housekeeping. Then I realized that
I was getting out of touch with my husband and my children and
that my nerves were all on edge. I reformed, and all is well, but I
wouldn't for worlds have you see my back porch ! "
These are dilemmas that do not come to the managers of fac-
tories. This woman could not move to another town, could not
invent a better type of service nor kill off the children. She had
to compromise according to her best intelligence. Confronting as
serious difficulties as these the factory would have to close its doors
because the " twelve points of efficiency " could not be applied.
Are " high standards " of housekeeping to be accepted without
qualification ? They may typify those " heavy burdens and grievous
to be borne/' which are always being laid on too patient shoulders.
Dr. David Snedden, of Teachers College, in addressing the Ameri-
can Home Economics Association, said : " The first tendency which
is, perhaps, wrong in much of the current teaching of Home Eco-
nomics lies in the direction of its bearing on current overrefinement
or overelaboration of standards of living. We focus our attention
so largely upon quality of service, upon standards of taste, that we
fail to give sufficient attention to the cost of what we produce in
terms of money, time, and energy. Many of us must believe that
in middle-class society, as it is to-day, an overwhelmingly dispro-
portionate amount of energy is expended upon refinements of per-
sonal decoration, household cleanliness in non-essential lines, in
table service, and in other related directions. We believe that our
attainments in these directions are purchased at the very serious
expense of more children in the family, the freedom of development
of the children already there, the health of the mother, and the
development of all the members of the family along other more
wholesome and enduring lines/'
The Need for Planning. — The woman of the new housekeep-
ing will understand the need for planning her daily activities and
will make the most careful outline of her time, not only for the day,
but for the week ahead. This plan, reviewed and adjusted by the
housewife in the fresh moments of each beginning day, will prevent
100 SUCCESSFUL FAMILY LIFE ON MODERATE INCOME
her from throwing herself into whatever comes first to hand, if
she is without a plan once the foot on the treadmill she is as helpless
as the dog at the churn, and the day flies past filled perhaps with
the unimportant rather than with the essentials.
A farmer's wife who had moved to the village to spend the
rest of her days said to a neighbor: "You can't think how I
miss my pork barrel." " Why, didn't you know you could
buy salt pork ? " exclaimed the neighbor. " Oh, it isn't that," was
the reply, "but on the farm the first thing I used to do in the
morning was to slice the pork for breakfast, and down <in the cool,
quiet cellar I said my prayers and straightened out my work for the
day, and it did help so. Here I don't think of it till noon, and by
that time the day's gone." If there is no other place then let it be
the cellar in which the housewife "straightens out things" for
the day!
" Am I not busy ? " says a harassed woman, who has a family
of two 'and keeps a good maid, and she details an appealing list of
doings, which prove that she has flown from one thing to another
all day long without plan. When scanned, this list shows, first,
that her high standard of cleanliness is overtaxed with, the care of
a houseful of furniture, including hundreds of books in open cases,
a great layout of silver on the dressing table, white paint every-
where, white curtains at every window of three stories, that she
keeps a tiny dog and many house plants, that she did nine errands
at nine different times in the day without the help of telephone or
mail and that the telephone rang six tmes, calling her to various
fields of outside " duty."
Of course she is busy, for she does not dodge, omit, grade,
sift, or systematize. The vast mass of requirements that we call
civilized life dribble in on her unresisting head, whatever offers first
or calls most loudly has her time and attention.
Said Florence Nightingale to a gifted woman who was at the
beck and call of a large, selfish household : " Are you going on forever
packing other people's carpet bags? You will never reach the art
of life." Or, to quote Eobert Louis Stevenson : " If I knew how
to omit, I would make an Odyssey of every daily newspaper."
Omitting the non-essentials implies an intelligent choice of
THE TIME ELEMENT IN HOUSEWORK 101
essentials; therefore, nothing can equal in importance this sorting
of the claims upon us into lists of first, second and third values.
Cooperation of the Family. — The woman who studies time
values will know also how important it is to gain the cooperation
of the family ; for instance, the hours necessary to do the housework
cannot be reduced without reforming the habit of being late to meals,
and it is generally a habit only, but it brings extra work and vexa-
tion of soul to the housewife. The town girl who had married the
farmer finally laid down her ultimatum: "You men folks have
been spoiled with indulgence; it's just as easy to stop hoeing in the
middle of the row as at the end. After this, late dinners are going
to be cold dinners."
Nor must anyone older than the baby expect to be e< waited on."
Even very young children can be taught to keep their rooms and
their own clothes in order and to be helpful in many ways. Boys
may be taught to press their own trousers and to sew on their own
buttons. Happily, the boy scout and campfire girl movements have
brought honor to all forms of self-help.
Where the Rules of Efficiency Do Not Apply. — As we have
seen, the processes of housekeeping may be greatly facilitated by a
good system, but the rules of efficiency do not apply to the things
of the spirit, and family life is all interwoven with immaterial needs.
Nothing is more inefficient than an open wood fire; if judged by the
heat calories that it delivers, it is to be wholly condemned, but a
family has been known to drag wood from the forest to keep it going.
Just as lawns may be too cleared up to allow of any hiding places
for shy wild birds, houses may be so -carefully ordered that children
are unhappy in them; the housewife's heart may be so set on her
polished floors that she esteems her guests according to the nails
in the heels of their shoes ; a beautiful inherited chair may be ban-
ished to the attic because it has too many spindles to dust ; a grand-
aunt beloved of the children may fail to receive her invitation
because, alas! she takes snuff and is not careful to conceal the
evidence ; and the woman possessing all the housewifely virtues may
pursue her sewing and her cleaning with such vigor that she is a
dull companion at the evening meal.
Time for Hospitality. — Among the decisions that have to do
with these non-material standards and which must be made very
102 SUCCESSFUL FAMILY LIFE ON MODERATE INCOME
early is the degree of hospitality that can be afforded by this family.
We are not discussing the simple give-and-take of children and
their friends, the picnic in the spring, the sandwiches and cake
that belong with the tumult around the back door when a snow fort
is being built, or the simple merrymakings that the young people
manage for themselves, but hospitality extended to the adult is a
more serious thing for the family of small means. The woman
of experience does not hear with patience that "no family should
live so that there is not a seat at the table for the occasional guest/'
She knows better, because that guest may not be one who will
"make allowances," as will the relative or the close friend whose
company is so precious that it is cheaply bought at any price.
So long as " entertainment " includes eating as its main feature
it may be better to give up the undeniable charm of the impromptu,
whose success, like many other apparently simple things, requires
a background of preparedness, and to substitute stated times for
entertaining, when preparation may be made at leisure and the
outlay that can be afforded economically planned.
The perfect dinner, noiselessly served, that most delightful of
all social functions, is not to be achieved; the party will take an-
other form, but entertainers and guests will be dressed with care
and will approach each other with a free and cordial mind. Is
this very delightful person the same man whom you met on the
street the other day, a little shabby and careless in dress, whose
absorbed eyes you could scarcely draw to your business query?
Great is the civilizing influence of social forms ! Hospitality, well-
planned and not too informal, cannot be left out of the scheme
of family life ; however small the income may be, it helps to develop
that gay and generous home spirit in which we sun ourselves and
without which all the planning and economy and account-keeping
is in vain.
In Conclusion. — The housewife will best make her contribution
to the family life through housework if she has regard to the fol-
lowing principles :
1. The elimination of work that is due to custom and habit
rather than dictated by established principles, such as the require-
ments of hygiene.
2. The careful planning of the day's work.
THE TIME ELEMENT IN HOUSEWORK 103
3. The better planning of houses and arrangement of equipment.
4. The use of labor-saving devices.
5. The study of fatigue and the best conditions for work.
6. The full cooperation of the family.
The working day in the household should be shortened, but
without injury to any of the essentials of home life.
The principles of business efficiency are applicable to many
processes that go on in the household, but they must always be made
secondary to the standards of family life, which make for happiness
and development.
The woman of the average income who is trying to bring about
a reasonable working day will find that no element in her complex
problem compares in importance with the study of herself as a
worker. The housewife needs access to expert advice in order to
adjust to modern conditions and standards. The farm woman has
already such help through her county home demonstration agent.
City women must demand an extension of this work to meet their
own needs by Home Information Bureaus such as are outlined in
Chapter XII.
QUESTIONS
1. What labor-saving devices of moderate cost do you consider to be of the
greatest value?
2. Give some suggestions not mentioned in the text for reducing the labor
of the household, more " short cuts."
3. Do you think there is danger to the best interests of the home in
urging that the hours of work be reduced? Is it your experience
that more women of this group need to be urged to do their duty
to husband and children rather than to have the number of their
hours reduced?
4. Give illustrations of processes now carried on in the home which would
better be performed outside and show how the extra price of such
work is to be afforded by the family on the average income.
5. Can you give any additional illustrations of where hygiene should
take the precedence of custom in dictating what work is to be under-
taken and how it should be done?
6. Indicate a good schedule for work by the day for the housewife who
is doing the entire work for a family of five. Same for the week.
7. What is your idea of the forms of hospitality that may be afforded
by this family?
8. Give instances of how cooperation of members of the family reduces
the work of the mother. What ought to be expected of the man of
the family? What of the children? Is it not common to expect
too much actual work from them?
104 SUCCESSFUL FAMILY LIFE ON MODERATE INCOME
9. Illustrate how correct and incorrect dress affects the worker and her
family.
10. Since industrial progress has gained a shortened day for the man, how
are the women of the household which he represents to obtain their
share of such gains without loss to the family life?
11. Would the better organization of the leisure time of working men
affect their wives' working hours? How?
12. How could an "eight-hour-day Household League" composed of house-
wives work to effect a reduction of the working day for women?
Would they try some form of cooperative housekeeping?
13. What fundamental reasons are there for so little power-machinery
in the household as compared with a factory?
14. Suppose you were asked to go over the operating expenses of a house-
hold in order to suggest ways of reducing expenses; make a list
of ten leading questions which you would ask the housekeeper whom
you were trying to help.
15. How does service by workers living outside the house differ in the costs
it brings upon the family as compared with service of persons
"living in"?
16. Mention several economies which you consider unwise. Several which
have been abandoned by the present generation, but which must be re-
sumed by the family of small means.
CHAPTER X
THE MOTHER'S CONTRIBUTION IN RELATION TO
HER CHILDREN
IF the family made up of adults and older children cannot
spare the mother from her home tasks, what shall be said of the
family made up partly of little children ? In this case, to the value
of the housewife's time in the wages already mentioned must be
added that of a caretaker and trainer of children. The need for
such service is universally acknowledged, and, if any decent home
standard is to be maintained, the mother of little children in the
moderate income family stays at home and " works in " her maternal
duties along with the housework.
A Letter from a Farmer's Wife. — " You ask me to calculate
the time it takes every day to care for two little children. It takes
all the time there is! Or, you can unite it with housework and
hardly count it an extra. I know, for Fve done it both ways.
This is especially true if you live in the country, for in the town
two or three hours must be given to taking the child out for the air.
But housework and babies seem to go together; I shouldn't know
how to separate the time given to each ; the mother just ' mixes them
in ' as she can. And I say again, if it is in the country where there
is a clean, safe place out-of-doors for them to roll around in, and
interesting things going on indoors and out, you do the really
necessary things for the children along with the other work. They
learn to do a great deal for themselves and the older ones help
the younger. And that's good for them both; I found that they
are much more affectionate than when they have nothing to do
for each other.
" To begin with, my baby didn't get his full bath in the morn-
ing. I hadn't time for that. He sat at the breakfast table in his
high chair with a little wrapper slipped over his nightdress. After
breakfast an hour was kept sacred to preparing the bottles for
twenty-four hours; the milk was sterilized, bottles prepared and
filled. If the mother nurses her baby it takes rather longer, twenty
105
106 SUCCESSFUL FAMILY LIFE ON MODERATE INCOME
minutes every three or four hours, but it is such a rest for her since
she must give herself entirely to it, and quiet is necessary. All
day the mother is busy and the child must be near her when it is
awake, in high chair or on the floor, or on a blanket, or playing out-
side on grass or sand. It is a very poor mother who cannot use
such a chance ; she generally keeps a child happy with part of her
own task. When you stop to think of it, there are a great many
interesting things going on with real work. If I was baking, baby
had a piece of dough to play with ; if I was shelling peas, he played
with the pods ; if I was washing, nothing pleased him so much as to
squeeze and rub a wet cloth in imitation. When I was ironing we
always had a great visit as he sat beside me in the high chair.
Clothes-pins make a first-class toy ; they can be sucked without harm
or used for pounding without making a deafening noise, and they
can be fitted into each other in all kinds of ways. I cannot help
thinking they are more attractive because the child sees them in
actual use by older people. Children like most of all to find out
what older people are about and watch them at it. All their youth,
if you'll notice, they are imitating someone, ( trying on ' I They
have to flounder a good deal to find themselves.
"You see, the working mother's child must learn obedience,
also patience with the older people and with their necessary work ;
its wants cannot be met on the minute. And I think it is a good
thing for a child to get very early the right idea of its relation to its
parents and to the work of the world. It learns that nothing comes
ready-made.
" But I didn't see that until afterwards. I should have spoiled
my babies if I had had the time. I must tell you what those habits
of obedience and patience meant later on. When my younger boy
was five and a half he was taken ill with pneumonia. We put him
in the sunniest room, but it was upstairs and the very farthest
from my kitchen. I took care of him and he recovered without a
setback, and I continued to do all my housework, including the
washing and ironing. I own that the work was slighted now and
then; the sick child came first. He had to be left alone a good
deal, of course ; and with the help of a screw in the ceiling I rigged
up a little trolley line over his bed, to which his toys were fastened,
so that he could pull one or the other toward him as he wanted
THE MOTHER'S CONTRIBUTION 107
them. As I said, the children had to learn obedience and patience ;
the doctor said he believed from watching this case that little invalids
were better off without as much attention as they generally received.
"Now I don't mean to say that a hard-worked farmer's wife
makes an ideal mother, but if she is intelligent, the times when the
child is actually neglected will be few; if I were a baby and could
choose, I'd take my chances in such a home rather than in one where
I was left much to a nurse girl, though perhaps of the best type,
being given my exercise in a park or on a perfect lawn, all my
wishes attended to quickly, all my toys constructed to fit my sup-
posed intelligence and having nothing to do with the activities of
older people. I've met a good many ineffective young people that
seem to me the product of this kind of bringing up."
Letter from a Village Mother. — A village mother writes : " My
children's ages are seven and a half, six, and two and a half. The
oldest goes to school. For the little ones a pan of sand with spoons
and tin dishes keeps them amused for hours while I work.
" As soon as they were big enough to help I let them dust, make
beds, wipe dishes, set and clear the table. They liked this and they
saved me many steps by bringing articles that I needed. When I
was sewing they strung spools or buttons and they spent hours in
cutting pictures from magazines and pasting them into an old
ledger. In summer in our large yard and garden with pets and a
sand pile they need no one to care for them. When I came to read
about the Montessori system I found that because I was too busy
to do any other way I had unknowingly followed a good method.
The children enjoy doing things themselves rather than having
someone overseeing them all the time.
" Time each day for keeping the children clean is as follows : One
and a half hours for the frequent washings, three-quarters of an
hour for cleaning teeth, one hour for baths, half an hour for hair.
If the two older ones help themselves and each other, then one-third
of this time on my part is enough. At two and a half years a
child ' wants to do it mine own self ' ; that is, if his act is praised and
encouraged and he is helped over the hardest parts.
" For dressing these children in the morning fifteen minutes
is our average allowance of time; it varies with the seasons of the
year; ten minutes are allowed for undressing. I simply oversee
108 SUCCESSFUL FAMILY LIFE ON MODERATE INCOME
this last while we tell stories. A child of two and a half need only
to have clothes unfastened. At four a child can dress himself with
a little assistance from an older one. But clothes must of course
be simply made and easily fastened. One-piece dresses have elastic
at the waist instead of waistbands with buttons; so also pants of
Russian suits; all petticoats are made princess style and slip over4
the head; they have one-piece sleeping garments, and underwaists
button in front.
" The playthings are simple ; they have few boughten toys. A
rag doll with padded box for a bed, kindergarten scissors and old
magazines, blocks, small boxes, bottles, spools, etc., interest them.
The girl of six loves to make chains of yarn by crochet and spool
knitting. Out-of-doors a cart, a ladder, a smooth board as a < slide/
a sand pile with spoons, shovel and pans will do more for children
than expensive store toys. I am so busy that I play with them very
little except as we make play of their work.
" My time spent with them tells best in reading to them and
teaching them songs and quotations. A little song, ' Be Ye Kind/
breaks up threatened quarrels ; another, ( Work While You Work/
overcomes the inclination to dawdle.
" Their help in housework, in caring for each other, in keeping
the yard neat, and in running errands has been considerable. They
are generally glad to help and proud to be allowed to do certain
tasks. I ask rather than demand this help and manage to call
attention to its part in maintaining the home. Opportunities for
teaching the principles of hygiene are found in killing flies, dusting,
laundry work and their personal cleanliness. My little girl is
being trained in accuracy when she helps in cooking; she makes
muffins, graham bread or a simple pudding and shows -delight in
having prepared something good for the whole family. They like
to please me by completing a task very nicely or quickly when I
am in another part of the house. I find there is- magic in the word
' together/ Praise works better than criticism and I have learned
what to ignore.
"These three children volunteered to help clear out a store-
room that was to be made into a bedroom for one of them. For
three days they cheerfully carried magazines, fruit cans and clothing
up a ladder to the attic; they took off wallpaper and cleaned up
THE MOTHER'S CONTRIBUTION 109
the room for the painter. Had they not helped in this way they
| could not, I am sure, have felt such pleasure as they did in the
^ room when finished."
Development of the Child Through Household Activities. —
[ The two foregoing letters show the vantage ground occupied by
] the working mother in the rearing of her children. One cannot
j estimate her value to the home simply by adding to the price per
j! hour of housework the wages of a nurse or kindergartner ; the ques-
j tion is whether the mother who has had half a chance at training
j and is possessed of a little leisure can be replaced at any price and
whether her natural environment can be equalled by the best of
';i school equipment.
When we are asked to define a home we find that the first
' reason for its existence is to meet the needs of the adults who have
created it. If they did not get from it more happiness, rest and
jj refreshment than they get elsewhere they might not continue to use
I their earnings to keep it going; but its second reason for being
;. is also founded deep in the needs of the race; it is the nest of
the child, who is here nourished during its helpless years and taught
• some of its earliest and most important lessons.
As seen in the two letters describing the care of young children
; the routine of the household, rich in teaching material, may be con-
sciously directed by the intelligent mother to definite ends which
J concern the child's development. This teaching of the child may
I indeed be the very guiding spirit of her days, giving interest to
: every task, and furnishing the highest reward for her labor. It
would seem that the mother is the person now held chiefly respon-
sible for the very early years whose importance is becoming more
and more evident. While the college is blaming the high school for
the poor preparation it gives the boys and girls, and the high school
! falls back on the intermediate and primary with the same complaint,
I the primary teacher says the mischief is all done before the child is
six years old ! If this latter statement is true, society would better
bestir itself regarding this home woman and give her training and
equipment and some leisure for her great task of teaching the
child. This preparation may not consist in entirely freeing the
woman from housework, but in teaching her how to use it as far as
it is usable to these ends.
110 SUCCESSFUL FAMILY LIFE ON MODERATE INCOME
Housework as a Teaching Plant. — The home alone does not
furnish all of the groundwork for a child's early training, but it
gives a very large part of it, and, whether they will or no, the mother
and father and other relatives are the teachers. In the home of
wealth the activities through which the child is taught may be
well worked out and the trained caretaker be a competent person,
although in many cases the children are left to more or less irre-
sponsible servants, and their playground is the public park. But
m the home of moderate income there is no money for the hired
person of any grade whatever; the working mother must be the
teacher and her daily activities instead of being a hindrance may be
a great help to her, since they furnish a natural teaching plant con-
nected with real living conditions ; especially the case if a yard and
garden are connected with the home.
These arts of life have been found to be of the greatest value by
educators and have been made the basis of all systems for child
training, such as the kindergarten and the Montessori ; the mother
in the home has all the material at hand, but she needs the help
of the educator in using it to these ends. The very fact that
these services are necessary to the comfort of the family give them
a decided advantage over the more artificial activities of the kinder-
garten and the manual-training class. It is a real coal scuttle to be
filled, a real clothes line to be put up, and the relation is very
apparent to the cooked dinner and the clean shirt. Parents may yet
be taught to suit the services they exact, both in amount and kind,
to the age of the child, and to keep always in view the effect on
its development.
Theodore Roosevelt's "Letters to His Children" shows what
care was taken in a well-to-do family to train the children through
home interests to be responsible citizens and how they acquired the
amenities and graces of social life by and through all their relations
to what went on in the home.
Precept Alone is Useless. — The failure to see that some kind
of " plant " is necessary for teaching the right habits and attitude
toward life may be traced to the universal trust in didactic teaching ;
but precepts not illustrated by life have never had any teaching
power; development comes through our reaction to our surround-
THE MOTHER'S CONTRIBUTION 111
ings, and here in the home is the active teaching situation and the
stage all set for the part.
Two generations ago, when there was so little " ready made," all
departments of practical life had to be conquered in the home.
By and through the industries carried on for the support of the
family, as in the farm home, a school of life was in progress and
the precious inheritance of standards and customs, the very founda-
tion of national character, was being formed and handed on. The
working mother of our moderate income family to-day is doing
actual housework and she must continue to do it until conditions
radically change, for it is at present, as we have seen, the most
feasible way of making her necessary contribution to the income, and
it is this fact which gives her a substantial advantage in child
training which she must learn to use.
The Working Mother's Advantage. — The mother of a family
is on the spot, ready to meet the various needs as they arise. She
is not absorbed by outside activities, and the effect of much con-
scious and unconscious thinking over her home problems is often
seen in great wisdom of decision in emergencies ; interest and affec-
tion bring out the best that is in her ; the love of the children and
their interest in the common home give her an added advantage.
It must be remembered that the school and kindergarten teacher
who, it is urged, is so superior to this mother and to be trusted
with the whole business, is also a limited being, whose training
varies from poor to middling and whose task is a heavy one, each
child being favored with a very small part of her time. Expert
work of high order is rare as yet, chiefly for the reason, it would
seem, that " there are not enough first-class people to go around " ;
and in this difficult matter of child training we must utilize the
woman who controls what we have called the housekeeping plant
and whose mind is stimulated by self-interest, to train a few chil-
dren who are dear to her. If she can be taught to use her advan-
tages and be honored by the public in her work, she will in general
do far better for those little ones than would the unaided outsider
"whose own the sheep are not/'
What are some of the lessons that the child learns better with the
help of the working mother ?
112 SUCCESSFUL FAMILY LIFE ON MODERATE INCOME
Personal Hygiene. — In these first years the child is forming
habits in the choice of food and ways of eating, in the care of skin
and teeth; it is then that some rudiments of bacteriology may be
acquired which will ensure the proper care of slight wounds and
the protection of all body openings from foreign substances; also>
may be learned the reasons for the eternal war on dirt, and these -
lessons it will learn all the better since it sees the daily campaign
in progress. It is now that regularity of bodily functions becomes
fixed, now that the child learns to stand and walk as he should,
now that the habits of speech are formed and the voice pitched
properly or the reverse, it is now that good manners may be made
second nature. These bits of knowledge do not come as set lessons,
but as a part of the life the family lead together, and they are
mastered only by many repetitions and illustrations.
Proper Speech. — One of the most important things in a child's
development is free expression through speech. This can only be
brought about by great sympathy between parents and children, by
talk and play and laughter about inconsequent small things, much
friendly gay chatter and discussion ; there must be a wide range of '
subjects and it is better to have heated arguments than no talk.
It is this sympathy which is endangered by day-long absences of
the mother and by her absorption in outside interests. A child:
quickly realizes when the answers to his questions are perfunctory, ,
and he is chilled by a weary and bored attitude ; time and pains are
needed to gain an intimate, chummy companionship and to meet
the child's craving to be taught.
Self-control and Responsibility. — Of the many habits that
are being started in these early years, take as illustration those that
are closely connected with the life of the household, the habit of
industry, the habit of obedience or cooperation, and the attitude
toward work and life that makes the valuable citizen. We are1
assured by educators that all life and development is built up on
labor and effort, that every individual must have discipline in the
steady performance of some kind of hand work, and that this isi
needed for physical development, for discipline of the will and for •
later team work and efficiency, and should be given as a purely
disciplinary measure without any regard to what the trade or1
profession is to be.
THE MOTHER'S CONTRIBUTION 113
Helping with the Housework. — This training in industry and
responsibility is well begum by helping in the household tasks, and
just here the parents, greatly needing the actual assistance, and
seeing more or less clearly that to render such help is good for the
child, should be met with wise advice as to how much work is to be
exacted at different ages and how the child's cooperation is to be
gained, not lost. It is often found that the parents are full of
interest in the subject, but do not know how to work out the problem.
The difficulties are not to be ignored ; they are shown in typical
remarks made by parents :
" I don't know how much work I ought to require."
" School claims so much home time for preparing lessons that
the children need what is left for play."
" Other children have no tasks and it is hard to compel ours
to work."
" My boy says he is going to be a lawyer and he doesn't need
to learn to work."
" Life will soon enough be hard for them."
" I would rather do the work myself than bother to teach
the girls."
These remarks show how much the parent needs enlightenment
from educators who have given close study to the subject on both the
physical and psychological sides, and also that school and society
must uphold this home training when the best methods have been
decided on and adopted.
That the mother " cannot bother to teach," that it " does not
pay," shows a failure to see that the effect on the child is more
important than the help rendered, and the often-heard remark that
life will soon enough be hard," reveals another great mistake; it
will be indeed hard if the habit of industry and a pleasure in the
results of industry are not made a part of early experience. When
a boy of fifteen is taken direct from play or idle loafing and put to
a man's work, the result may be rebellion or a total failure to make
good, which results in deep discouragement. It is reported that the
boy " cannot stick_jto anything." It_is not his fault. A sharp
compulsion has been put on a will untrained by tasks properly
graded in difficulty, therefore sustained application is found intoler-
able. Such neglect to prepare a boy for his life in the world is
8
114 SUCCESSFUL FAMILY LIFE ON MODERATE INCOME
cruel, and should not be allowed any more than are the severe
beatings, overwork and neglect now punishable by law.
It is the same with the girl of our average home, if she is
brought up to do as she pleases. When she marries it is found
that clumsy fingers and weak muscles unused to steady work are
overtaxed in, her first efforts at housework and baby-tending, and if
in addition she has no training in household methods, weariness
and rebellion are often the result.
It is high time, indeed, that we were about the task of assisting
the home to improve its teaching functions. Those who are engaged
in working out a scheme of industrial education under the Smith-
Hughes Act must, it would seem, begin with the preliminary
education which is to take place in the home. With their help
more materials and methods for this home teaching may be devel-
oped. It is also hoped that the Children's Bureau, in addition
to its valuable pamphlets on the physical care of the baby and
young child, may make contributions on the training of the child.
Until a good scheme for home work, detailed and definite for
every year of the youthful life, is formulated with the same care as
that with which the present school curriculum has been brought
together, the following suggestions gathered from the experience of
parents may be of some value :
The Little Child. — Until the age of six or seven the small
household tasks, carefully adapted to age and strength, should be
exacted from every child somewhat after the plan outlined in the
letters of the two mothers as already quoted. The important thing
is that there should be regularity and no escape from a satisfactory
standard in the performance. For instance, it takes but a moment
longer to pile the wood in a wood box in an orderly manner than to
dump it in. The boy will come to take pleasure in the sight, as will
the little girl in the dish towels hung in a neat row. The mother
must reconstruct her view of the objects to be attained by her day's
•work; it is not first and foremost the neat house, the well-cooked
meal, but the child's development obtained by helping to bring about
these results. Let a good housekeeper try to get this new view for
a day and note the result on the children.
The School Child. — When the child, begins school these duties
to the home must not be given up. Little girls of eight to twelve
THE MOTHER'S CONTRIBUTION 115
should put their rooms and their clothes in order in the morning
and should help with the supper dishes at night. On Saturdays
they should give some help with cleaning the house, should darn
their stockings and perhaps do a little sewing. In vacations boys
and girls of ten to twelve can do several hours' work a day to their
great advantage, as can the boy and girl between twelve and sixteen,
but the latter need regular employment even more than do the
younger ones. Their own choice as to what the work shall be may
be allowed considerable scope. The girl has become acutely conscious
of her appearance and will work with great persistence in making
clothes for herself. This matter of clothes is for her just now the
great business of life and she must be helped to achieve a pleasing
result with the means at hand.
Boy and girl may unite at this time in work that makes the homo
attractive. They have decided, we will say, that the living room is
shabby, but, when no money is available for refurnishing, young
hands can learn to paint woodwork, to upholster chairs, to paste
on wallpaper, to braid rugs. Not only is the desired end attained,
but a distinct advance has been made in skill of hand, in knowledge
of materials and of color effects; the children are full of pleasure
in their accomplishment. Younger children sometimes do won-
ders in thus reconstructing a playroom, but they need wise help and
encouragement over the hardest places to avoid such poor results
as will discourage and block any future attempt. If a mother who
is directing the work and play of children at this difficult age finds
in them a consuming desire to make or do some one thing, she may
be thankful and should follow rather than lead, always granted
that the work is constructive in character.
Advantages of Struggle. — It is not the practical end gained
but the training of the will that results from overcoming difficulties
which is the most important thing; it is now that the moral fibre
may be strengthened for the hard times that are to come to every
individual. Nothing is gained by urging the timid into situations
in life that call for pioneer qualities, but why are so many men and
women timid? To place before the child difficulties properly
graded to his intelligence and to provide the stimulus and incentive
for overcoming them, and then to proceed to the next harder task,
sums up one of the most important principles in education.
116 SUCCESSFUL FAMILY LIFE ON MODERATE INCOME
It is here that the family of limited means has the advantage.
It is more difficult for people of wealth to train their children in
habits of industry ; the boy does not see why he should clear away
the remains of the fireworks Avhen the gardener's duty is to attend
to the lawn; it is a resolute mother who will refuse to allow the
seamstress already in the house to make the garment that has been
set as the task for the indolent little girl. Can hobbies of travel,
collecting, or self-culture take the place for the average young per-
son of a really constructive task? Eelease from work has been
called " a tainted blessing/' " effort is the law, whether for a liveli-
hood or for enjoyment/3
The Part That Money Plays.—" Things are in the saddle and
ride mankind," said Emerson. A home may be swamped by an
income greater than its development calls for; the clean, artistic
setting of a life may be cluttered up with mere " things " to which
it has no vital relation because it did not help to make or to choose
them; money may hamper the development of initiative and
smother by too easy attainment that most stimulating thing in a
young life, longing. It may blur the differences that exist between
two desired objects, differences that we must carefully consider if
we are to choose between them. But why bother, if we may have
both? Discrimination thus becomes of no importance; the rose-
bush unwisely watered sends down 110 deep roots to provide nourish-
ment in time of drought ; exercise is lacking to build the foundations
that make fortitude possible in later life.
The Boy and the Indian Suit. — A little boy made his Indian
suit himself. Visits to an art gallery were needed to decide on
the length of the leg fringe; he wrote letters of appeal, and later
of thanks, to a country cousin who sent the precious turkey feathers,
a few at a time, for the headdress. He felt the pleasure of an artist
in the perfect slant of those feathers cunningly wound and attached
to the beaded forehead band. His little hands knew no weariness ;
there were not hours enough in the day. Work enough to fill the
whole vacation stretched ahead of him and his playmates, for his
growing skill and ambition were fitting him for leadership and he
was planning the construction of a tent that should house them all.
He dreamed of jt nights ; it was to be made of sailcloth, the money
to buy said sailcloth not yet in sight, but he had plans for earning it.
THE MOTHER'S CONTRIBUTION 117
: And on its side was to be painted a rearing buffalo ! Happy boy
with his plans !
But in an evil moment a well-meaning relative presented him
with a ready-made khaki tent. He received the gift joyfully, its
store smartness was praised by the boys ; like his elders, he thought
possession the 'great good. But for this little boy the khaki was
the wooden horse of the Greeks filled with enemies; it robbed him
of what would have filled long summer days, the plans, the measur-
ing, the figuring, the failures and successes, and, alas, the
painted buffalo !
Another child made himself a little violin by stretching wires
over a cigar box and with this he strummed delighted when his
mother played the piano ; he imagined rather than made harmonies.
This seeming precocity so delighted his parents that a real violin
was bought for him and an effort made to instruct him. But the
discords he made were now too evident ; he was caught between the
joy of constructive play and a serious development for which he
was not yet old enough. Both the play violin and the real one
were abandoned. When the same child made an imitation of roller
skates with empty spools, his inventive ability was again foiled by
a gift from the shop. Is it not a wonder that our well-meant
interference does not wholly prevent the development of
our children?
Value of the Mother's Service to the Child. — The money
value of the time given by the working mother to the training
of her children will depend on the degree of intelligence and devo-
tion which she brings to the task. According to her equipment it
will be the sum -paid to a nursemaid, to a nursery governess, or to a
trained kindergartner, and this sum must be considered as added to
the family income. The potential value to the family and the state
of this woman's teaching and influence would seem to warrant
extensive plans for her education and help on the part of
the community.
QUESTIONS
1. List ten household tasks and grade them in the order in which they
may be undertaken by children of different ages.
2. Should any distinction be made between tasks for little boys and those
for little girls? If so, when should such a distinction come in?
118 SUCCESSFUL FAMILY LIFE ON MODERATE INCOME
3. When may children begin to be taught the use of money? Shall they
be given an allowance, shall they be paid for work done or for follow-
ing rules about health, taking1 medicine, etc? Is there a danger in
making such payments? Can this danger be avoided?
4. How is the mother to get work done by the children without friction?
Illustrate the game spirit in housework, the competitive spirit.
5. Suppose a child to be given ownership of the furnishings of his own
room, what advantages may be secured.? Shall he select? Buy with
his own money?
6. What working tools should a boy gradually accumulate? What a girl?
8. Mention a half dozen natural household situations that have teaching
possibilities. Is it better to use such, even to create them, rather than
expect to teach by didactic precepts ?
CHAPTER XI
THE COMMUNITY'S CONTRIBUTION IN PROMOT-
ING HEALTH AND IMPROVING LIVING CON-
DITIONS
As seen in the first chapter, one of the four conditions necessary
for the success of our moderate income family is that the com-
munity shall do its part. Their income will not suffice to cover
actual needs and to maintain decent standards of living unless
community help is available on:
1. Sanitation, including prevention and care of illness as an
extension of the public health service.
2. Prevention of unreasonable prices for food. Under means
to this end are helps to agriculture and the marketing of agricultural
produce, and well-supervised markets with inspection of weights and
measures. A related agency is the proposed public kitchen.
3. Proper control of public services, as water, gas, electric light,
telephone and transportation, all of which the citizen is obliged to
use and whose price is not controlled by competition.
4. A complete system of free education.
5. Free parks, playgrounds, and other helps in recreation.
The Individual and the Community. — While the conditions
that favor individual and family development include personal
effort and the overcoming of obstacles, yet if the task proves too
difficult, effort is felt to be useless and ambition dies; the family
in consequence deteriorates and becomes a burden on the community
instead of a helpful part of it. To what extent shall the com-
munity help the individual family? To that point which makes of
it the efficient unit on which the state can be built? It would
seem that nothing less will suffice. But how is this help to be
given so as not to impair the development of personal initiative
and independence ?
Only by the extension of free public service for all citizens, such
as now provides roads and water and parks, service which is taken
119
120 SUCCESSFUL FAMILY LIFE ON MODERATE INCOME
by citizens without loss of self-respect and with no idea that they
are receiving more than their just due. It may well be considered
a duty of the state to stabilize life and health, to see that comfort
and education and play are possible, just as banks and government
agencies stabilize finance and prevent panics by large measures that
reduce the danger from individual failure and mistakes.
The health and happiness and effective labor of all citizens is of
vast importance to the state, and the average citizen cannot in our
modern complicated life attain these ends without help.
Modern Industrial Changes. — Such help is sometimes de-
nounced as tending to undermine self-reliance, but this view does
not take into account the profound changes that have come about in
a generation. As Simon Patten has said, sacrifices which were once
a biological necessity cannot be required in a time when the world
has accumulated riches. For instance, motherhood should no
longer be at the expense of the mother ; for her the risks and priva-
tions once necessary are now out of joint with the times ; protection
for such women " should now come from the current body of social
riches — by whose help we are passing on to a new type of family lif e"
As the development of a country proceeds, the dependence of the
individual on the community increases. Gone are the primitive
conditions in which every man, as in the rebuilding of the wall of
Jerusalem, "builded over against his house/' The modern com-
munity, even in rural regions, is made up of households that possess
very unequal power to contribute to the general well-being and
defense. In the last two generations great numbers of our people
have exchanged life on the farm or in the small town for city con-
ditions, and in doing this they have surrendered without realizing
many natural advantages. The man who has come from the
country to work in a town must be furnished pure water in lieu
of the spring on the hillside near his farm home ; factory inspection
and tenement house laws must be adequate and well enforced
to make up for the "tang of winds/' the free sunshine and large
spaces which have been his uncounted right ; since he can no longer
walk to his work, nor his wife to the market at which she can
advantageously buy, the transportation problem must be solved for
him; if he cannot command a garden in which to grow vegetables
and fruits, adequate market inspection for sanitary reasons and
THE COMMUNITY'S CONTRIBUTION 121
to prevent extortion is for him a matter of vital concern. His
requirement for gardening land is not in our cities met by a share
in the community garden as seen in the suburbs of European cities,
where he may build his arbor and spend evenings and holiday hours
with his family. These and other needs of his family cannot be
furnished by his own unaided action. An enlightened policy must
rule the city, and community funds must be devoted to building
up a system which is to serve the family at every hand.
We are probably to see in the next few years a great extension
of state and municipal help toward efficient living among families
of moderate and small income. Cities are beginning to bid against
each .other for desirable citizens, such men and women as realize
the effect of good public conditions on their earning power and on
the buying power of their dollars and who are intelligent enough
to demand such conditions. It has long been common for a city
to offer to a manufactory a free site or low taxes as an inducement
to settle ; now the attention of the man who is to work in this factory
is being called to low trolley fares, to a fine park system, to low
rates in a local gas plant, for it has been found to be useless to start
factories where good workmen cannot be kept because of unfavorable
conditions for family life.
Responsibility of the Community for Health of Its Mem-
bers.— Just as the state is concerned in the development of its
mines and forests, its harbor facilities, and other sources of natural
wealth, so it is concerned in developing a still greater source of
wealth, the efficiency of its citizens. The first requirement of the
dtizen on the public purse is for adequate sanitation. There must
be pure water and plenty of it, clean streets, and the proper disposal
of refuse; also building laws that will ensure air and sunshine in
places of business and in dwelling houses, laws that will prevent
overcrowding and make decent and cleanly life possible. There
should be smoke abatement laws in cities for reasons of health
and to lessen the great expense of keeping dwelling houses clean,
noise and fire hazard and danger of accidents must be kept within
bounds. There should be such inspection of markets as will insure
the protection of food from dirt during delivery, and prevent the
sale of unwholesome foods and contamination by flies and vermin ;
as by such special requirements, as that all food be placed two feet
122 SUCCESSFUL FAMILY LIFE ON MODERATE INCOME
above the too-exposed pavement or floor, and that abundant wash-
ing facilities be afforded to market people. Also the provision, as
yet effective in but few places, that only persons proved by examina-
tion to be healthy and cleanly in their habits, incapable of carrying
contagion, shall have the handling of food in market, hotel, and
restaurant, or in the manufacture of foods, as in bakeries, canneries,
and candy factories.
Losses from Preventable Illness and Death. — Very great are
the present losses from inadequate sanitation, from lack of care in
illness, from failure to foresee the conditions that will conduce to
the spread of infectious diseases,1 from preventable accidents, as
those that result from the rapid driving of automobiles. In 1908
30,000 to 35,000 fatal injuries were reported in the United States
and 2,000,000 non-fatal. A comparison with war losses is very
significant. Of the 2,000,000 soldiers who went to France in nine-
teen months about 50,000 were killed in battle or died of wounds,
while in America during the same period there were 126,652 deaths
by accident of men, women and children at home, in streets or in
factories ; that is, more than twice as many !
The Income and the Care of Health. — It is not too much
to say that the provision for illness is the next great tax on the
family income after the minimum of food, clothing and shelter have
been met. Modern conditions and higher standards have so raised
the cost of preserving health that the average family whose income
we are considering cannot meet it without the help of the com-
munity. What was the sum spent under this head two generations
ago by the town families of average and more than average income ?
It was confined to the moderate fee paid now and then to the
general practitioner or family doctor. If a tooth ached, it was
pulled out ; now the bill of the dentist is a constant factor, however
fortunate we may be in avoiding that of the physician. Then there
were few specialists, but to-day a serious illness whose cause is
obscure may call for the services of the specialist for the heart and
lungs, on another who has made a special study of the digestive
tract, with probably the aid of throat, ear, eye, and teeth specialists.
1 The Life Extension Institute estimates that the loss from earnings cut
off by preventable disease and premature death amounts to $1,500,000,000
annually in this country.
THE COMMUNITY'S CONTRIBUTION 123
These men have had a long and expensive training and their fees
cannot be low. Moreover, to carry out their directions may require
the services of a trained nurse, who, although one of the greatest
blessings of our time, must be paid $30 to $35 a week with board
whereas the village general nurse of a generation ago received $5.
How are these bills to be met by the moderate-income family ? In
our large endowed hospitals both the rich and the very poor are
receiving the best of care. They are treated by doctors and nurses
of equal skill and they profit alike in the application of every
advance in medical knowledge. The out-patient department or
polyclinic is under the oversight of well-trained men, and with the
recently added social service which follows the patient to his home
and helps to provide what may be necessary in diet and care is of
the greatest assistance to the sick poor of our cities. Such help is
accorded because it is everywhere admitted that the savings of
the family of the unskilled workman are wholly unequal to meeting
the losses and expense of illness, although sick benefits may tide
them over minor ailments; therefore for them the free clinic and
the free hospital ward must be provided, for them also the compul-
sory accident insurance and proposed health insurance.
But for the million and more families that make up what we
have called the moderate-income group with present incomes of
$2500, more or less, the cost of illness without such helps may draw
so heavily on their savings as to wholly upset their standard of
living for the time being and perhaps permanently. It is yet to be
recognized that the family having an income of only a few hundred
dollars above the subsistence line, whatever that may be, has almost
equal need with the very poor for help in illness, but at present
free hospitals are closed to them. In this moderate-income family
serious illness is nothing short of tragedy, especially if the illness
is that of the income earner. When ill they must choose the less-
skilled or inexperienced practitioner, and the same is true of their
dentist. The examination for slight or suspected ailments is not
to be thought of ; they have recourse to the casual advice of a drug-
gist and to patent medicines. A clerk's family on a $1200 income
was known to be obliged to practice the strictest economy for five
years in order to pay $100 for a surgical operation and care. A
skilled mechanic on a $1800 income, because of the continued illness
124 SUCCESSFUL FAMILY LIFE ON MODERATE INCOME
of his children was obliged to mortgage his home to pay doctors'
bills, and this proved to be such a serious setback to his plans for
a comfortable old age that he became deeply discouraged, did his
work less well, and was not advanced in his business as he had
hoped to be.
The Extension of the Public Health Service.— If the health
requirements of the family of moderate income are to be met,
there would seem to be no way but to extend still further the free '•
public health service. The requirements of health are f oundational ;
if we are not well, we cannot work.
To quote Dr. B. S. Warren, of the United States Public Health
Service : <e The people of the United States are beginning to wake
up to the fact that health is no longer a matter for individual
concern alone, but is one for collective action on the part of all
persons or groups of persons responsible for conditions affecting
health. When this idea of the necessity for collective action is thor-
oughly understood, and it is realized that instead of weakening indi- ;
vidual endeavor it will improve the conditions of the individual by
making him economically more independent, the American people
are going to demand that the responsibility for disease-causing con-
ditions (and the same may be said of accidents) be fixed and that
this matter of sickness be provided for in a businesslike way and
no longer left to haphazard methods."
Regular examinations, not only of sick, but of supposedly well
persons, is in line with what is now fully recognized, that disease
and conditions that lead to disease may exist long before pain or
other outward sign compels attention. Physicians are now agreed
that the rational way is to examine people at regular intervals, look-
ing to the prevention as well as the cure of disease ; such has long
been the accepted practice in dentistry. To quote C — E. A. Winslow,
Professor of Public Health, Yale University : " It is to the interest
of the patient that he should receive attention at the time when he
can reap the largest results — this means medical attention before,
and not after, the development of acute disease/' The hearty
approval that has been given to the compulsory free examination of
children in the public schools is cited as an acceptance of the
principle that the health of the whole people must be safeguarded,
THE COMMUNITY'S CONTRIBUTION 125
and, if necessary, through public health officers, as a natural exten-
sion of the public health service.
This situation, as it affects an important class in the com-
munity, is well realized by the medical profession, and attempts
are being made to meet the need. In some hospitals clinics have
been opened where patients of small income pay a fee of $5 to $10
for complete examination by as many specialists as are necessary.
The treatment is outlined so that it can then be carried out by the
family doctor. But these hospitals are few. Well-equipped rural
hospitals that will offer swift automobile service to a region of
fifty miles around is something that rural women's clubs should
work for unceasingly until they are established and endowed with
state and community help, it is women in childbirth whose needs
are always to be kept in mind.
The Medical Inspector and the Visiting Nurse. — Much is
being done through the medical inspector and the school and visiting
nurses and also by the societies devoted to child hygiene now estab-
lished in most large cities. The public nurses are becoming an
invaluable means of educating1 the public as to health, because of
their knowledge of food values and of all matters that tend to
improve permanently the conditions in the families that they visit.
The few illustrations that have been given show how far-reaching
must be the efforts to improve the health of the people. The sub-
ject is too large to be handled by the individual and the family,
although it is on them that the burden of ill health chiefly falls.
What help might be expected from compulsory health insurance
cannot yet be stated with certainty.
Public Help to Reduce Cost of Food Materials. — It is the
privilege of any city dweller to visit the wholesale food markets
before dawn, and note the delivery from wharves and from railroad
sidings and the reloading of wagons or motor drays which are to
convey the food to retail markets. Here he may see a part of the
vast machinery by which a city is fed, and the background of
knowledge thus gained gives him new eyes with which to view,
later in the day, the purchase of food in the retail markets and
provision stores. He is impressed at once with the helplessness
of the buyers ; they must buy what is set forth and they are wholly
ignorant of the conditions that determine the quality and price of
126 SUCCESSFUL FAMILY LIFE ON MODERATE INCOME
what is offered. We are not considering the conditions that deter-
mine the production of food, such as the education of the farmer,
undertaken in order that he may both increase his income and lower
the cost of products for the buyer an education which is being under-
taken by our government on a vast scale and is already showing
results; the most difficult problems seem to lie in the domain of
marketing and in transportation necessary to bring food to
the consumer.
Food Distribution. — This distribution of food, whether it is
produced on our farms or brought in by fishermen or delivered
in ships from foreign countries, is demanding more and more atten-
tion. The consumer will in time do more than idly wonder at the
sight of three automobiles and three men delivering three different
brands of high-priced butter, and this in the space of one city block.
It was ascertained by a study made in New York City in 1916
" th'at about 37 cents out of every consumer's food dollar goes for
the cost of municipal food transportation/' 1 Marcus M. Marks,
late President of the Borough of Manhattan, New York City, esti-
mated that one-third of the cost of food to the consumer is due to
the expense of retail distribution, whereas only one-tenth is due
to wholesale charges.
When we consider that probably one-half of the inhabitants of
these large cities are spending from 40 per cent, to 50 per cent, of
their incomes for food, a possible reduction in the sum spent for
distribution is seen to be of very great importance. The late George
W. Perkins, when some years ago Chairman of the Governor's
Market Commission in New York City, said that few citizens realize
the profound change that has gone over this country in two genera-
tions as to transportation ; that while the needs of a growing popu-
lation have been adequately met as far as individual passenger
travel is concerned, food, for which we pay out four or five times
as much as for travel, is brought into a city and distributed accord-
ing to the methods that were in vogue twenty-five years ago. Little
planning or thought has been given to the matter, and the result is
congestion of traffic, excessive cost for handling, and waste of perish-
able food material. He affirmed that the many factors that enter
into the transportation of food must be made to work together in
1 Donald B. Armstrong, Journal of Home Econ., Nov., 1916, p. 577.
THE COMMUNITY'S CONTRIBUTION 127
the most thorough and intelligent manner, and that this com-
bination must be carried on openly under proper protection and
control. A " combination/' if run in the interest of the public, is
nothing to be afraid of.
The Terminal Market. — That the very foundation of reform
in this regard lies in the establishment of terminal city markets
with cold storage cellars and warehouses, these markets to be situated
where both water and railroad freight can be discharged, is main-
tained by students of these conditions. Foreign countries have been
so long face to face with a strictly limited food supply that measures
to prevent undue marketing charges from raising the price of food
are worked out in all great cities. Before the war at the Halles
Centrales, the wholesale terminal market of Paris, all food was
received, weighed, inspected, and sold at auction by a bonded city
official for a regular fee of 2 per cent. This method insures such
supervision as makes the sale of bad food impossible and also prevents
extortion and trickery. This market has ten pavilions and open
structures covering twenty-two acres, and is located on the water
front, where 'railroad lines converge.
Dr. Clyde L. King, in a detailed study of the cost of distributing
food products, maintains that this cost may be diminished by a
more thorough development of freight service, both on steam and
trolley lines, and an increased use of the motor truck and boat.
The number of reloadings must be lessened, with a consequent
reduction in the number of middlemen and their fees.2 The
middleman," whether commission merchant, huckster or pro-
vision dealer, now bears in the public mind most of the blame for
high prices, but he seems to be needed at every joint of the present
cumbrous machinery to keep things moving at all.
Cold Storage. — Attention has been called to the fact that cold
storage, one of the greatest developments of our time, has hardly
been incorporated on a large scale into our system of food distri-
bution. Millions of pounds of perishable foods are condemned and
destroyed every year by food inspectors, a dead loss of originally
valuable material, which could be kept from deterioration by proper
use of cold storage, especially in connection with adequate terminal
markets. Such facilities must also be afforded the household buyer
a Clyde L. King, ibid.
128 SUCCESSFUL FAMILY LIFE ON MODERATE INCOME
who has in many cases no storage place in her cramped quarters. The
cold-storage cellars under the Philadelphia and Reading Railway
station in Philadelphia are thus used, in addition to their use for
large buyers. Cleveland places at the disposal of its citizens at least
one refrigerating plant, that on the West Side, where fruit, vege-
tables, eggs, butter, etc., may be kept at very reasonable rates.
It may be expected that some of the greatest changes in business in
the next few years will be in the field of distribution, so that it will
cost less to put goods into the consumer's hands ; that water carriage
by river and canal for heavy commodities, as coal, will be revived,
that the parcels post system will yet redeem the promise made for
it as a means of bringing producer and consumer together; that
terminal markets and better routing in large cities will diminish
the time and money now lost in reloading perishable food, and that
better refrigeration will stop the waste by spoilage.
What the Consumer Can Do. — The helplessness at present of
the household consumer as to conditions and prices is typified by the
woman who may be seen in any small street sweeping her front steps
and pavement, and then seeing an uncovered ashcart stirred by
the wind undo all her labors. She protests, but in vain; she does
not know where to turn for redress. Consumers must unite to
obtain, first, information, and then concert of action.
The question of better housekeeping, taken in the broader sense,
is pushing out from its secluded place in the four walls of home
into the community itself. Like all important and vital concerns,
it needs that organization which takes into its service all arts and
all knowledge. The devotion of women to their households has
kept these households going and has obscured the fact that the feed-
ing and housing and clothing and all the rest of the household
budget are immense matters in the aggregate and as worthy of
public help as any branch of money earning. The housewife must
become intelligent as to the use of public money in its relation to
the private purse. She will analyze the printed list of outlay of
tax money in her city or town or country and demand that it be
made plain to those who have no financial training. She will not
accept graft with easy pessimism, but vigorously oppose it, knowing
that it comes finally out of the pocket of the individual citizen ; she
will know how it shrinks the content of the market basket when
THE COMMUNITY'S CONTRIBUTION 129
a ship-load of fruit is dumped off the coast to raise the price of
other cargoes ; when the inspection of market weights and measures
is found to be on the iniquitous fee system. She will enquire into
the duties of the public service commissions which have been de-
veloped in most of the states and which exist to set fair prices for
certain forms of public service, as water, gas, electricity, and trans-
portation when furnished by monopoly companies. Organizations
of housekeepers have as one of their privileges, scarcely appreciated
as yet, presentation before such boards of the housekeeper's or
consumer's point of view when new schedules of prices for public
services and other matters of vital interest to the family purse are
being considered.
To gain information as well as to act on it effectively women
must unite in such organizations as Home Economics associations
or in sections of the Civic League, the State Federation of Women's
Clubs or other associations that have been successful in bringing
the women of many needs and little leisure together with those
practiced in reaching results through organization.
What helps at present exist in the way of class instruction in
household arts and home management should be made known to all,
and the proper authorities should be asked for more help of the kind.
The extent to which consumers' cooperative enterprises have been
successful should also be investigated for the benefit of all. An
organization for supplying reliable information (The Cooperative
League of America) was formed in 1916 and has an office in
New York City. Cooperative stores, bakeries, laundries and
creameries have all been successful, and promise a growth in
the future comparable to what has long been known in European
countries where one-third of the population is embraced in coopera-
tive societies.
Public Kitchens. — In our own country kitchens have not been
undertaken by public agencies, except for brief periods to tide over
some emergency or disaster ; but it may be found that such centers
run in the interest of the public, perhaps as an adjunct of the
Department of Health and presided over by trained dietitians, would
be of the greatest service. There the main dish of the meal could
be purchased in quantities estimated to furnish full nutrition for
the family with the proper number of calories and drawn from
130 SUCCESSFUL FAMILY LIFE ON MODERATE INCOME
the right sources to make a balanced menu. Such a dish or dishes
would meet nutritional requirements, making it safe for the family
to spend the rest of their food money with a clear conscience on some
preferred accessories. Recent advances in scientific knowledge of
food and nutrition have revealed new causes for diseased conditions
of the human being ; many of them are traced to wrong food ; there-
fore the choice and preparation of food from a nutritional stand-
point has become a serious matter for all classes of people. Such
a demonstration would have great educational value. Moreover,
the relief offered by such a food service for the overburdened house-
hold would meet an increasing need brought about by the scarcity
of household help.
It is said that real estate and development companies have
become interested in community kitchens because the greatest diffi-
culty they find in disposing of houses and lots in suburbs is due
to the disinclination of people to leave the city, where there is ready
access to cafes and restaurants in case of need.
The housewife of the moderate income family cannot patronize
cafes and restaurants whose charges for the cooked dish are nor-
mally from three to ten times the price of raw materials, according
to quality of cooking and grade of service, for she " works in " the
buying and cooking of the food along with her other duties and
thus makes a contribution to the family income, but she could buy
of an institution like school lunch kitchens where prices that average
double the cost of the raw material prevail.
Whether such community kitchens can be developed and run on
a self-supporting basis depends on careful experiments yet to be
made by people trained in Home Economics methods and with the
necessary business background.1
QUESTIONS
HEALTH
1. Name the diseases which to your knowledge are better controlled by
modern medicine than they were, say, twenty-five years ago. Regard-
ing any of these is community control important?
2. Can a family in your community obtain services of a trained nurse by
the hour, and at what price? If not now available, how might such
service be provided?
3. Are there any rural hospitals or rural health laboratory stations in
your state (enquire of State Board of Health) ?
1 Public Kitchens. By Mary Hinman Abel. Journal of Home Economics,
June, 1920.
THE COMMUNITY'S CONTRIBUTION 131
4. Some municipalities in Switzerland and in other countries control
funerals and burials as a health and economic measure. If we were
interested in bringing about such a reform in our country, what
methods would be taken?
5. State a minimum of health functions which a city government should
undertake.
6. Are we tending toward community provision for all medical and sur-
gical service, including dental and optical? Are the obstacles against
providing such helps insuperable? What will be the bearing of com-
pulsory health insurance, if adopted, upon such a proposal?
7. Sketch the desirable conditions regarding care in accidents and sick-
ness for workers in a large industrial plant. What space and equip-
ment would be required ? Sketch similar provisions for a large school.
8. What is to be done in case hygienic dress is not to be bought for any
reasonable price? For instance, a woman may seek in vain for a
good-looking, low-wheeled shoe at a moderate price.
REDUCING COST OF FOOD
1. Considering what was done by the Fair Price Committees of the Food
Administration during the war and the later campaign against the
high cost of living, may a permanent agency be established to deter-
mine the fair margin between wholesale and retail prices? What
are the difficulties and objections?
2. Is the boycott a defensible method for reducing the price of commodi-
ties, as butter and eggs? If so, how should it be conducted?
3. What is the route of country produce from farmer to consumer in your
community? Through how many hands does it pass? Is shipment
made by rail, boat, or trolley, or in farm wagons — what is the source
of supply of milk, of butter, of eggs? Could local production of these
agencies be increased?
What is your explanation of the failure of the parcels post system
to meet expectations? Were such expectations too high? What degree
of success is met in foreign countries by parcel post?
4. Does the war-garden movement suggest the desirability of permanent
public encouragement to home food production in cities? What
agencies might undertake it, the schools, the agricultural agent?
Outline an appeal that would be apt to arouse cooperation.
5. Outline plan for a woman's club or other organization to study the local
milk supply, in order to find the daily receipts, standard of product,
the incentive now at work on the milk producer to improve both
quantity and quality. The State Agricultural College will help in such
a campaign. What other officials and agencies are available?
6. How many food inspectors have you for your markets? How many
inspectors of weights and measures? Are they overworked? From
what funds are they paid? Are they expected to give their whole
time to the work? Does the fee system prevail?
7. Have cooperative methods made any headway in your community?
One State, North Carolina, has a Superintendent of Credit Unions
who is responsible for organizing and supervising local groups that
wish to form cooperative mutual benefit banks. Might similar official
direction be given to cooperative consumers, buying clubs, or coopera-
tive stores? Might Home Economics agents be useful in this regard?
CHAPTER XII
-COMMUNITY HELP IN RECREATION AND
EDUCATION
IT would seem that we are moving toward a larger participation
with the community in varied and rational pleasure. Far-sighted
people have long felt that there must be public provision for recrea-
tion, especially in cities, and the movement for providing such
facilities has grown rapidly in the last ten years. It is only by
such community help that the family on a moderate income and the
great mass of those living on smaller incomes can secure reason-
able recreation.
The Playground and Recreation Association of America. —
This association, founded in 1906, has done much to forward the
opening of parks and playgrounds, to devise the best forms of
recreation, and to train teachers for conducting physical training
and play centers. It stands behind the compulsory physical train-
ing laws which have been passed or are being considered by a
number of states to remedy the conditions which led to the failure
of such a startling proportion of young men to qualify for the army.
In 1916 the total number of cities having playgrounds was 480.
In many cities the public schools are utilized as centers. The
supervision and teaching in the playgrounds and recreation centers
has become a profession, over 6000 persons being employed in that
capacity. Public parks as playgrounds for the people have a great
future. Wild tracts are constantly bein£ opened and put under the
care of a state board of forestry, which protects against trespass
and fire. Camp sites are located for the use of visitors, as boy
ecout troops; fishing, swimming, canoeing and skating have been
developed, and tents and camping outfits are loaned at cheap rates.
These wild tracts, which are often reached by a single carfare from
the city, offer the great opportunity for families to spend a part of
the heated term in the open, and much better facilities will yet
be available.
In many city -parks tennis grounds and golf courses are laid out.
IS
HELP IN RECREATION AND EDUCATION 133
When the system of parks and playgrounds is developed it will
supply healthful and delightful outdoor life, fundamental to the
health and happiness of the people. Athough as yet too few in
number, small parks in the midst of the most crowded parts of cities
now give playgrounds and breathing space. Here are chances for
the public athletic leagues and the story-telling centers and for the
production of little plays which may later grow into pageants.
Rural Recreation. — The play movement starting in the cities,
where it was so bitterly needed, is now spreading to village and
country. No group of houses is too small for a community center,
although it may be at first a barn or a vacant room in which dances
and plays are organized. For the best results help must come from
outside. Advice may always be asked of the Playground Associa-
tion, No. 1, Madison Avenue, New York. It reports that among the
many questions that have been submitted are: What plans do
you suggest for celebrating the Fourth of July? What pieces of
playground apparatus have been found most valuable? Suggest
program and method of conducting a community Christmas tree.
Please give the names of men and women engaged in rural recreation
work with whom I can correspond about some of our problems here.
What recreation development do you advise for a town of 2500?
What can our university do to develop commundty music and drama
throughout the state?
Community Help in Music and Drama. — Musicians have
called attention to the fact that " our only claim to being a musical
nation is that in the cities large sums are paid out by private indi-
viduals for concerts, instruments and instruction. Thirteen million
out of our eighteen million school children receive no instruction
in music and many more millions of adults have little or no music
in their lives. At the same time taste for music is almost universal
and it is one of the simplest of the arts to obtain."
It is this latter statement which seems incredible to those who
do not realize the changes that have come about in the last few
years and the helpful agencies that are at work which will in time
bring music within the reach of all.
Music as a Social Force. — Mr. Arthur Farwell has called
attention to the fact that people in the mass will listen to music
which as individuals they would find taxing and without interest.
134 SUCCESSFUL FAMILY LIFE ON MODERATE INCOME
It is this social and uniting force of music that is yet to be of
immense value in every community ; it would seem to be especially
needed among a people that is reserved and self-centered. Music
seems to be truly democratic, in that people of widely different
cultural attainments and attitude toward life, those who would find
any other united action difficult, meet on a common ground in its
enjoyment and production. A love of music bridges what would
seem to be impassable social gulfs, and perhaps our growing feeling
of need for whatever will help to unite our heterogeneous popu-
lation will explain our new interest in community music.
We have never been wholly without our local choral societies and
singing unions, some of many years' standing and of great repute
like that in Bethlehem, Pa. In the great Northwest many musical
festivals are enjoyed. They show what is possible in even the
smallest community. West of the Mississippi there is a little town
of two thousand inhabitants, peopled mostly by Swedes, where
Handel's " Messiah " is performed every Easter by a chorus of five
hundred voices and an orchestra of forty pieces. To the three-hour
performance, which is "like a religious meeting," thousands of
people come from the surrounding country.
Help from Trained Musicians. — In this movement for com-
munity music everything depends on the help of the trained
musician. To arouse interest and start the formation of local
bands and chorus classes money should be raised to pay for the
services of such a person. But if the money is not forthcoming
because of lack of interest, such help may still be obtained, for no
professional people give of their time more generously than
do musicians.
Small country towns are often started in community music by
city musicians during a summer vacation. In one case the printing
office gave the programs, the visiting musician swung the baton,
and 5000 people sang old songs together. This was repeated the
following summer, a ten-cent admission fee was charged, and the
$300 realized was set aside as the nucleus for a fund toward making
a park on the river bank where pageants were to be given.
In any community citizens who have some knowledge of music
have a great opportunity. It is they who should endeavor to put
the public school music on as high a plane as possible. An appeal
HELP IN RECREATION AND EDUCATION 135
may always be made through the school board to the extension
division of the state university or state college to furnish advice,
to send a lecturer on music, or an organizer, or to put the inquirer
in touch with other agencies that are now helping in this movement.
Small towns and country districts are most in need of such help.
Even in the smallest towns there are people who sing in the church
choirs who could unite as a working nucleus. Perhaps some one is
capable of training a chorus class or the beginnings of a small band.
In any case, a man or woman should be brought from outside who
will give an inspiring address on music, illustrated by instrument
or voice. Musicians assure us that the chief reason for failure in
home-made music is a scorn of small successes, a failure to find
joy in little triumphs and achievements which look toward the
larger success.
Music in Schools. — It would be difficult to tell how the change
has come, but at least half of the students in some four hundred
high schools are now being trained in chorus singing and many
schools are giving credit toward graduation for this chorus work.
Moreover, schools are beginning to give credit toward graduation
for properly supervised private lessons in music. Cities as far
separated at Berkeley, Calif., Pittsburgh, Pa., Hartford, Conn., and
Chelsea, Mass., are among those that have made the beginning.
Moreover, certain colleges and universities allow these credits to
count for admission. The importance of this acknowledgment of
music in the scheme of education cannot be exaggerated. More
children will undertake the study of music if it can be placed on a
plane with other studies in the school, for overwork threatens all
who undertake it as an extra.
Our conservatories of music are broadening their courses to
reach more classes of people, state universities are giving extension
courses in music which are in touch with all parts of the state.
A high point in the development seems to have been reached
in Wisconsin. The music experts of the extension department of
the university of this state may be consulted 'personally or by
correspondence regarding music in school and community, and they
supply lists of materials, books and speakers. They lend music for
choruses, for bands and orchestras, rolls for mechanical players and
disks for phonographs, to be used in a course in musical apprecia-
136 SUCCESSFUL FAMILY LIFE ON MODERATE INCOME
tion. They also assist through their Department of Public School
Music in providing teachers of music for communities that are
too small, unaided, to maintain them. This help applies to vocal
music and also to the building up of bands and orchestras, the
performers being not professional musicians but those who have
business during the day.
Many city libraries lend both sheet and bound music, and in a
few cases victrola records and rolls for the player-piano.
Dramatics. — In the last few years the acted play has been
brought to the front by cities and schools and by many private
volunteer agencies. Young people in amateur dramatics throw
themselves with zest into the vicarious character and are seen to
develop under the experience in the most remarkable way.
In response to this new impulse, in hundreds of schools plays
are now acted which once were merely read by students as part of the
literature course.
In settlement work among the very poor the delight taken in
the acted play has been found to have deep meaning. The director
of the Children's Theatre in New York City says : " I studied these
efforts of the people from in front and behind the footlights and
I found that what lay behind the tremendous instinctive effort of
every man, woman and child was the desire to get beyond the
restricted limits of factory, shop and schoolroom and grow out,
if only for a few hours, into the broad phyletic or race life."
The same enthusiasm that has followed the recent revival in
England of the songs and games and dances that were a normal
part of English country life a century and more ago has been seen
in America accompanying the remarkable growth of the people's
drama, not only in cities but in remote country districts and in
sparsely settled states, like North Dakota.1
Sources of Community Help. — It will be noted that the sources
of community help are various, especially in their origin. Some
which have their start in individual enterprise justify themselves
through years of careful experiment on a volunteer basis and are
then taken over by the city or state. Many organizations that
1 The Drama League, New York City, will furnish selected lists of
dramas suitable to a purpose named. A useful list is also found in General
Federation Magazine, September, 1919.
HELP IN RECREATION AND EDUCATION 137
have been helpful in education and recreation start in the church,
•the Y. M. C. A., the Y. W. C. A., and various guilds and societies
which render social and industrial service of solid value. From this
source we are to look for increasingly valuable contributions. One
church has recently held a six days' meeting on the general subject
of the relation of the church to the community.
Community Help in Education. — For the schooling of the
children of our moderate income family little provision can be made
in the household budget. That a thing so important as education
for the efficiency and happiness of citizens should be provided by
the state is now taken for granted in our country. Moreover, the
broadening view of what is comprised in a modern education is
resulting in new help in the preparation of the boy and girl for
their place in life.
Libraries. — Under free education must be classed loan and
consultation libraries, now to be found in towns large and small,
also the system of travelling libraries which in some states serve
the rural regions. The town family living on $2500, more or less,
must learn to use the public library and reserve what money they
have for books for the purchase of dictionaries and encyclopedias,
Few citizens fully understand the various kinds of help afforded
by the modern city library, the wealth of classified material, the
special helps given by trained librarians, and the lectures on special
subjects, which are also a feature. In every city and town, not only
in connection with the public library but with other organizations,
free lectures and exhibits of high educative value are now common,
some being on secure, long-established foundations, as the Lowell
lectures in Boston. The list of free lectures advertised in the New-
York dailies in the winter season often reaches a hundred for the
week, and they cover a wide range in science, art, travel and general
information. Every town dweller should investigate these helps
and utilize them to the fullest extent, and where they do not exist
start a movement to secure them.
Excellent as are many of the libraries in cities and towns, it
cannot be claimed that the people as a whole are well served. The
United States Bureau of Education has recently reported that in
thirty states less than 50 per cent, of the population have access
to libraries; in six states less than 10 per cent., and in one state
138 SUCCESSFUL FAMILY LIFE ON MODERATE INCOME
less than 2 per cent. The income of public libraries is estimated as
only one-sixth of the amount needed for adequate service.
Vocational Training. — In addition to the regular school cur-
riculum almost every state now furnishes in one or more of its
institutions of advanced grade instruction free, or at a nominal cost,
in many technical lines, including agriculture. As to the public
school courses, it has been suggested that they be divided for those
who elect technical work into two periods — the first period to be
spent in the elementary and the second in the high school, the latter
to be made up of alternate weeks or months of school and of outside
work in shop or office, or in other application of the course chosen,
so that the boy and girl may be kept under the close supervision
of the school and thus made ready for their future work while
contributing something to the family funds. The chance to earn
money afforded by such a plan enables the youth to continue the
school life with all its helpful influences beyond the usual time at
which earning would otherwise begin. A good example of such
an experiment is seen in the High Schools of Cincinnati. Among
the courses offered are "two " Technical Cooperative Courses," one
for girls and one for boys. At the end of the second high school
year those who have chosen this course are placed in positions by
the school in some chosen trade or business under the arrangement
that every fortnight they spend alternately in business and in school.
They receive pay for their work from their city employers. In
the schools of that city the cooperative courses are constantly being
extended ; it is considered no longer an experiment. It is claimed
that largely on account of this new method of instruction high school
attendance has doubled, and promotion from the lower grades has
also greatly increased. Such opportunities need not be interpreted
as furthering industrial as compared with liberal education, which
has been heretofore far more accessible, but as furnishing a necessary
help since the breakdown of the apprenticeship system to those
who are to earn their living in trade and industry. The Federal
Child Labor Law forbids continuous employment of children under
the age of fourteen, twenty-one states are requiring continuation
attendance on school courses of from four to eight hours a week
after that age, and in time all of the states will adopt this policy.
To meet the need of a full curriculum and a good teaching
HELP IN RECREATION AND EDUCATION 139
force in these continuation day and evening schools, the funds
appropriated under the Smith-Hughes Act, frequently referred to
in these pages, are now operative.
Vocational Training for the Housewife. — There is one de-
partment of education which is of especial interest to the moderate
income family, that which will train the woman for her service to
the household in managing and buying, in doing housework and
caring for children. We train our teachers, our architects, our
lawyers, our engineers, we even establish a system of examinations,
diplomas and licenses to defend the public from the dishonest or
incompetent among them, but our house mothers, the largest indus-
trial group in the state, and one having the most important social
and educational relations to the present and the coming generation,
we have only begun to train by advanced modern methods. In
actual practice we still take for granted that a woman knows by
instinct how to take care of her baby, to train her children, to choose
the food for the family, how to make ends meet on the income,
whatever it may be. But inadequate as are our present methods
for training in this line, a promising beginning has been made of
which we must first take account. All improvements must be built
upon the system already established.
Help Through the Home Economics Movement. — Thanks
to the growth of the Home Economics movement, there is now an
admirable body of trained professional workers, teachers and ad-
ministrators who are organized under various governmental and
other agencies, and to them we look to take a leading part in the
new education for home-making.
The most important work, foundational in character, is that done
by government specialists :
1. Those working in the Office of Home Economics, United
States Department of Agriculture for research and publication on
problems pertaining to the home. Beginning with "Nutrition
Investigations " in 1894, it has broadened its scope in recent years
to include research and publication on food, clothing, shelter and
household management, and it has created and collected the body
of information which is at the basis of modern education in house-
keeping. Its leadership in the research that has made intelligent
control of family consumption possible was recognized during the
140 SUCCESSFUL FAMILY LIFE ON MODERATE INCOME
war by foreign governments as well as our own, its standards being
used as the basis of war-food control. Its publications, both, popu-
lar and scientific, have made large contributions to the subject mat-
ter of home economics, which is now receiving additions through
research done in state universities and other centers of learning.
2. The specialists in the Home Economics Divisions of the
United States Bureau of Education and of the Federal Board of
Vocational Education which furnish a national information service
for the teaching of Home Economics, including replies to personal
inquiries regarding local problems.
3. The specialists in the United States Children's Bureau under
the Department of Labor which investigates problems related to
child welfare, maintains in many centers a staff of physicians and
nurses for examination and treatment of children, and publishes
technical and popular bulletins of great value on such subjects as
child labor, infant mortality, physical care of the mother, of infants
and of children and the training of children in the home.
4. The Savings Division of the United States Treasury Depart-
ment with its thrift studies, as frequently quoted in these pages,
the specialists in the United States Bureau of Labor Statistics
with its budget studies, the United States Bureau of Standards with
its investigations of household measures and materials, the United
States Public Health Service, and the workers in the individual
states in State Departments of Education, Boards of Health, De-
partments and Colleges of Agriculture and State Libraries.
The above sources furnish the solid background on which must
be built up a comprehensive system of instruction in housekeeping
and home-making for the girls and adult women of the country.
As a beginning in the actual teaching force we had, according
to the figures of 1914, the Home Economics teachers in some two
hundred and fifty colleges, one hundred and seventy-five normal
schools and twenty-five hundred or more high schools.
Public School Classes in Home Economics. — The state of
public opinion now justifies the establishment of classes in the public
schools for the teaching of sewing and cooking, while in the more
progressive schools other branches have been added which have
a direct effect on housekeeping and home-making. The aim of these
courses is nothing less than the teaching of the age-old household
HELP IN RECREATION AND EDUCATION 141
arts in their new significance and meaning, informed with modern
science and adapted to the new requirements now made on the indi-
vidual and the family. The educative value of these practical
courses so long and so strenuously debated seems now to be granted,
if the character of the teaching and the subjects treated are rightly
adapted to the age of the pupil.
The place of the family in society, personal and home hygiene,
care of children, the keeping of accounts, the family budget, dress-
making and millinery, laundry work, home management, the choice
and the preparation of food, are among the subjects that have their
place in such courses. Some of this work is required and some is
optional ; it would be more frequently chosen by students if a liberal
system of credits for college admission were adopted, including
all these subjects.
Extension Courses for Adults. — All of the state agricultural
colleges and a few women's colleges, as well as many special insti-
tutions, offer Home Economics courses for older girls and women,
and the short courses in agricultural colleges given in winter fill up
a fortnight with attractive lectures and demonstrations. " Exten-
sion " courses are also given in localities remote from the college,
while in the rural districts the county home demonstration agent,
under the provisions of the Smith-Lever Act, reaches farm women
in groups or in their own homes, thus giving assistance in housekeep-
ing equipment and methods. This legislation recognizes the teach-
ing value of courses carried on outside the schoolroom in clubs for
women and girls, in demonstrations given in the home in such
subjects as canning and poultry-keeping for profit and through
neighborhood cooperative enterprises. Some of this instruction is
of excellent quality, while in many instances it leaves much to be
desired, largely for the reason that the training of competent
teachers has not kept pace with the rapidly growing demand for
such courses.
Vocational Home Economics. — Extension or "field" teach-
ing of home economics does not follow schoolroom and class methods,
but the plan for vocational education under the Smith-Hughes
law returns to these methods and works in every state under the
State Board of Education. In 1918 "the National Government
assumed its responsibility in the matter of training women for the
142 SUCCESSFUL FAMILY LIFE ON MODERATE INCOME
vocation of home-making by the inclusion of home economics, along
with agriculture and trade and industry, in the Federal Vocational
Education Act. The forty-eight states likewise have assumed theirs
both by their acceptance of the provisions of the Act and, on the part
of a number of states, by the enactment of further legislation which
provides additional state funds to establish schools and classes for
home-making instruction/' This vocational movement promises to
alter the type of home economics teaching given to young women of
high school age by emphasizing its practical aspects and it will also
develop new evening schools and classes in home-making which can
be attended by young women employed in industry, by home women,
and others who desire to fit themselves professionally in the general
art of household management or in institutional work.
The funds available under this Act have certain restrictions
on their use, and the state claiming such help must contribute an
amount of money equal to the sum it receives from the federal grant.
In general, local interest and cooperation will be necessary to induce
the state to make such grants, and it is for organized groups of
citizens in clubs and other associations to unite in demanding that
these courses be given in the community. Such groups should also
follow the further development of the home economics division of
the Federal Vocational Education law, and support the request
now before Congress for additional funds.
Vocational Subject Matter and Methods. — Setting aside as
more nearly settled by the experience of a generation the courses
that shall be given to the schoolgirl under fourteen, what are
the needs of the two far larger groups as stated by the Vocational
Education Board:
1. The women employed in the occupation of home-making,
either in their own home or for wage-earning in some one's
else home.
2. The girls and women employed outside of homes in industrial
or commercial occupations.
Their needs are various. To quote from Miss Anna E.
Richardson, Assistant Director for Home Economics Education,
Federal Board for Vocational Education:
" Homemaking, as has been said, ia a composite occupation. The mod-
ern home is much less a production plant than it was, yet the home is and
HELP IN RECREATION AND EDUCATION 143
will continue to be concerned with productive jobs; and the woman is,
therefore, a worker in the several semi-skilled occupations which are prac-
ticed in the home. In addition, the homemaker's job is a management job.
She is largely responsible for the buying of supplies, the planning of the
work in the home, and the management of the family life. No two homes
offer quite the same conditions and the management and work jobs vary with
the income, size of family, location of home and the ability of the home-
maker. For one homemaker the job is largely that of a worker in the
various occupations that make up the life in the home; for another it is
largely that of a manager of a business enterprise, for the majority it com-
bines both elements. We have never made a thoroughgoing study of the
successful homemaker and the elements of her success. Do we know the
amount of time necessary to train a girl in the fundamental operations of
the work of the home and at the same time give her sufficient related in-
struction to make of her an intelligent, independent worker?
" For the group employed in homemaking activities, the instruction
offered should do three things: First, it must offer opportunity to learn
simple processes as they are carried on in the home; second, it must
supplement any skill which the home worker already possesses and increase
her, ability to do the work of the home; and third, it must develop an
understanding and appreciation of what the job as a whola means, develop
managerial ability and appreciation for the finer an'd more spiritual and
aesthetic side of homemaking. The extent to which these three aims of
instruction can be carried out will depend upon the ability, general educa-
tion and training of the women.
" Neither must we rest content with merely offering courses ; we must
see to it that the women are reached, interested and attracted to come
for instruction. We have so little machinery, no compulsory-attendance laws,
no hope of advancement in wages for most of those who come — nothing to
bring them, unless we have something to give which they want. With
about twenty million women to reach through short courses, we can not
feel that we have a really national vocational program until a large pro-
portion of these are reached by short courses in homemaking."
Demonstrations and Exhibits. — These will play a large part
in the education of women who are not students or even readers.
During the war when food conservation was urgent, the ignorant
or indifferent householder was not allowed to go her way, but was
approached by all the methods which the food administrator could
devise, and it was found that those who were not interested in study
or reading would look at demonstrations and exhibits and listen to
a persuasive talker who knew how to arouse interest. For instance,
the value of canning demonstrations and of exhibits of food sub-
stitutes was at this time fully proved. But the methods that had
then to be used because time was pressing may be greatly improved
for permanent effect. Exhibits can be held together for a longer
time and moved from place to place so as to fully utilize their
144 SUCCESSFUL FAMILY LIFE ON MODERATE INCOME
teaching value. And the best of these exhibits should find a per-
manent place in teaching centers or Home Economics institutes.
The Permanent Home Bureau. — It is idle to say that the
mere existence of these helps, as classes, literature, exhibits and
lectures, will suffice for the improvement of housekeeping and home-
making on a large scale ; a very active propaganda is needed to catch
the attention, to break up the isolation in which the housekeeper
of the past has worked and to arouse in her a demand for such help.
It would seem that a permanent Home Bureau might prove to be
the connecting link between the home and the many interests and
activities which exist to serve it. Such a bureau would naturally
be in control of county and city agents working under the pro-
visions of various federal acts. It should become a " clearing
house/' Here the housewife will come in contact with trained
and experienced people who can answer her questions and tell her
the result of work done in research laboratories on food and nutrition
or on the efficiency of new household appliances ; here she may learn
the wearing quality and fastness of color of fabrics she must buy,
such help as was given out during the war by the Clothing Infor-
mation Bureau of Boston. Here she will find the best books and
expert advice on such subjects as the care and training of children ;
here she will meet groups of women interested in the same subjects.
This ideal has already been realized in part. The State of Utah has
in Salt Lake City such a central bureau fully equipped to serve the
people. It houses the Child Welfare Clinic and offers free to various
organizations the use of assembly rooms; and its staff of trained
Home Economics men and women are at hand to answer questions
and to advise individuals and groups on a wide range of topics.
Their building has been furnished rent free; office expenses with
heat, light and demonstration material are paid from an annual
budget of $5000 furnished by the city. Its lecturing and teaching
staff is made up of men and women from the Utah State Agricultural.
College and the University of Utah, and there is a close cooperation
with the City Board of Health and the public school system. With
such a Home Bureau might cooperate the many experimental enter-
prises which were developed in wartime and are still doing work along
special lines, such as the Food Facts Bureau and the Dietetic Bureau
of Boston. Among the subjects that would be covered in lectures
HELP IN RECREATION AND EDUCATION 145
and in groups and individual conferences are home hygiene, civics,
nutrition, clothing, household decoration, household management
and budgeting; also such cooperative -projects as the cooked-food
center, cooperation with public schools, community kitchen, co-
operative buying, and cooperation with the Bed Cross, Boy Scout
Masters, Allied and Associated Charities, and other organizations.
It is reasonable to expect that such a bureau would prove to be a
natural rallying point for all interested in the improvement of
home life, gathering around it libraries and exhibits and other
educational facilities, and that it would mee,' a need which is
acutely felt by intelligent housekeepers and ii\ time help those
who as yet hardly realize the importance of the problems that
confront them in every branch of efficient management of the home.
Its most valuable feature would be the chance for contact between
the housekeeper and the women of broad training and sympathies
who should be found to head such an undertaking.
Questions That Will be Asked at the Home Bureau. — In
order to furnish concrete illustrations of the work of such a bureau,
we may ask what are some of the questions that will be asked of the
women who preside over it ? To take a number at random will show
the scope of the subjects on which information is sought and already
available for the home-maker:
First, and perhaps most pressing, are all those questions that have to
do with nutrition, as "What must I expect to spend on the table for a
family of four ? " and " What special food should I buy for the younger
children? " " Shall I make my bread or buy of the bakers? "
To answer such questions the leader will have already at hand avail-
able tables and charts and literature on nutrition to supplement her own
knowledge and experience, and being in close touch with the Departments
of Home Economics in Washington and in the State Agricultural Colleges,
she can lay special cases before higher authorities by letter. She will
be acquainted with all local agencies and will receive from them advice
and help, and also be able to cooperate with them in their work for im-
proving the home table.
Then next are the questions of wise household management: "Which
is my cheapest fuel, coal or gas or kerosene?" "Is it safe to set away
cooked food in aluminum vessels?" "Does it pay to sift cinders? The
coal I buy has much slate in it, but' I can get no satisfaction from the
dealer. How can I know that I get the right weight? How many bushels
go to the ton ? " " What is the best refrigerator and what ought it to
cost? If I can't afford it, what shall I do wih the baby's milk? " " Would
you advise an electric washing machine for a family of six? And of
what type shall it be? Please compare it for my needs with the water-
10
146 SUCCESSFUL FAMILY LIFE ON MODERATE INCOME
power machine." " Can you show me how to make a fireless cooker, or
should I buy one? " " I'm spending five or ten times as much on cleaning
substances as my mother used to — can you show me how to make a saving
in that item? " " Has the government made any analysis of these cleaning
powders, soaps, etc. ? "
"Does our city inspect the laundries? Are there any that do not
use chemicals? In using the wet wash of the public laundries am I safe
from some other family that may have an infectious disease?" "Our
underclothes certainly wear out faster than they used to. How am I to
find out whether the cloth is poorer or the laundry methods at fault? Is
there any way of finding out how long a dozen collars ought to wear ? "
These are but random illustrations of the questions that would be
asked. It becomes evident that the present adviser of the housewife in
the line of equipment is the advertiser or the dealer in such commodities,
whose interest is solely in, making a sale. Why should she not be helped,
just as the farmer is helped in buying seed and machinery, by the advice
of expert people who have the interest of the buyer, not the seller, at heart?
Another set of questions will have to do with money spending, or
investing, or with the use of the housewife's time: "We are a family of
two adults and two children and we are running in debt on our income
of $3000. Must I do my own housework, put the children in the public
schools, or move into a smaller house? Can you tell me what we ought to
do to become solvent and begin to save ? "
" My husband brings me the pay envelope of $40.00 a week. How
much of this ought he to have for his own use? We have a family
of four." " We want to go to housekeeping. What do you think of the
installment houses? Unless we buy of them we'll have to wait six months
for furniture." " Would it be better to borrow the money and pay cash
for It?"
" What shall we do with our savings ? "
" Shall I keep up the home garden now that the war is over, or do
something else with my time?" "I'm called handy with my needle, but
the street clothes I make don't look right. Where shall I learn, or do you
advise me to buy ready made ? " " My husband earns $50.00 a week. He
thinks we can afford an automobile. Can we?" "We're just married
my husband earns $30.00 a week. We don't see any way but to board,
and yet we don't want to — can you help us figure it out how we can go
to housekeeping?" "What is the best system of keeping accounts for a
small family? I cannot give more than a quarter of an hour a week to it."
" I have some free time, now that all my children go to school. Can,
you tell me of any half-time jobs for money earning ? "
" I have three hours time free in the day, can you tell me how I can
use it to learn how to bring up my children better ? "
" We are trying to decide whether or not to buy a home in the suburbs ;
it would take all of our savings. Is it a good thing to do? Who can,
advise us ? "
Noble Impulse and Second Wind. — Here are questions that
strike deep into the foundations of daily life; their solution might
well make part of a " Bride's Baedecker " to guide those young
women who now too often go through two stages in their housekeep-
HELP IN RECREATION AND EDUCATION 147
ing, one where noble impulse and ignorance rule and the other
where they get their " second wind " and reach out for all the helps
which the community may offer them. As one said : " When I was
married, if only someone had talked this all over with me and had
shown what was possible and what was not possible with our money !
It makes me shiver now when I realize how near we came to
making shipwreck/'
The list of interesting and important practical subjects with
which such a Home Bureau promises to deal is very striking. Its
work ought to improve housekeeping as a business and also home-
making in any community in which it opens its hospitable doors.
Home economics so far offers a far more adequate program
for instruction in housekeeping than in home-making; that is, all
that has to do with the non-material life of the household, the
relations between parents and children, all that affects the family
spirit and happiness, its choice of amusements, the right training
for the children, its relations to the community.
The Home Training of Children. — The question is often
asked : Has science anything to offer to parents regarding the mental
and moral training of children ? General opinion on these subjects,
even of the wisest, seems to change greatly from generation to
generation ; what we crave is the application of principles that have
the solid backing of research done by the trained investigator in
psychology and allied sciences. Such a demand has brought forth
a few series of lectures and timely books,1 but it must be admitted
that the amount of available data of an accurate character is as yet
small, and the number of people who can apply it wisely is smaller
yet. The immense importance of the subject, especially for the
young mother, warrants a plea for the organization of such knowl-
edge as exists and that it be made accessible through some means yet
to be devised. Why should not the Home Bureau make connection
with people who could give help in matters of such great importance ?
The mother of two active, temperamental children said of them :
(< They simply terrify me. They need so much and I don't know
how to give it to them." Was she a neglectful and careless mother ?
Quite the contrary ; she was thoughtful and very honest. She knew
1 Suggestions of Modern Science Concerning Education, 1917. H. S.
Jennings and others.
148 SUCCESSFUL FAMILY LIFE ON MODERATE INCOME
that she needed advice and she saw no way of obtaining it. If
she had had access to a psychologist educator of wide experience,
she would have said : " My older boy is the greatest puzzle to me.
He is rebellious, idle and untruthful. If I could only know which
of his faults must be rooted out and which he will outgrow! I
think my children must be different from all other children." Is
it too much to believe that there might be advisers wise enough
to reply: "By no means; I have known any number who display
such characteristics at the same age ; here is my card catalogue that
will show you how such children have been successfully treated."
Such work once organized would partake of the system and accurate
knowledge found in hospital methods for the treatment of disease,
where generations of doctors have left on record the description of
cases, treatment and results as an aid in diagnosis of new cases.
There will always be great individual differences, but it is much,
very much, to know what tendencies have been found in some degree
common to certain ages and certain types of children and some of
the ways which have been used in their treatment.
Probably no greater help and relief could be offered parents than
to be shown what they can do for the best development of their
children, especially in those wonderful pre-school years when the
child is wholly in home care. In addition to being taught to care
for the child physically, parents should be helped through some
agency to know something of the psychology of childhood, to get
insight into its swiftly changing phases, and thus find an absorbing
and beautiful study in place of what is now so often a puzzle
or a bore.
In our coming Home Bureau even a shelf of books devoted to
the subject would be a beginning. It would contain popular books
like Professor McKeever's Training the Boy and Training the
Girl that assist by their good sense and their observation of family
life, while studious parents will find there copies of the few inten-
sive studies tha/t have been made of individual children.
QUESTIONS
BECBEATION
1. A woman in a Maine village trained the young people in chorus sing-
ing and taught piano and voice culture for a generation and thus
gave the town musical expression. Who are the people in your com-
HELP IN RECREATION AND EDUCATION 149
nrunity who are rendering like service, or is it furnished to any
extent by schools?
2. A father on an Oklahoma farm taught every child to play a musical
instrument. Might not the inhabitants of several small villages
unite in paying a teacher?
3. Do you know of any active singing club? Have the church choirs or
any fraternal organizations in your community ever put on a
musical production?
4. Do the municipalities of your state have the right to own park lands
outside the city limits? Los Angeles has a recreation park with
cottages and other facilities for campers.
5. Are there public museums of art and natural history in your town?
What are the important collections in cities of your state? Is there
any provision for travelling exhibits of such collections? If not,
would it be impossible to work up a system by which day-long visits
of children and adults could be made to such collections, including
special railroad fares and guides? Could a collection be started in
connection with your public library, beginning with whatever illus-
trates early local history?
6. Are moving pictures, even when censored, to be substituted for forms of
recreation which have constructive and social character? Are they
healthful? (Eyestrain.) Do they emphasize right impulses and
instincts? Do they stimulate the mind, or do they bring about
apathy and a desire for more entertainment that calls for no personal
effort? What are the dangers of all commercialized recreation?
7. A small village that had been using a hay barn in summer for dances
and plays, raised money to add to what could be voted from the
taxes to build a town hall adapted to many uses. A small fee was
charged for its use until the money was repaid. Why isi not such a
plan more generally followed?
EDUCATION
1. Are you in touch with associations and journals devoted to special
phases of homemaking. They should be to the housewife and mother
what the medical society is to the doctor, the Chamber of Commerce to
the business man.
Are you on the mailing list, of the Office of Home Economics, U. S.
Department of Agriculture, Washington, D. C., and your State
College of Agriculture, that you may receive free bulletins on sub-
jects of interest to the housekeeper? Is your community benefiting
from free courses given under the Smith-Lever Act?
For information as to courses given under the Smith-Hughes Act, address
your State Superintendent of Public Schools at the State Capital.
2. Is the present interest in industrial training tending to obscure the
importance of broadening the intellectual basis of life by attention
to non-vocational studies?
3. Suggest subjects for study for a young man of eighteen who will be a
plumber so that he may also play his part as an American citizen.
4. If no library is available in your community, how could a group of
families organize a book club or a magazine club for exchanging
reading material? Suggest practical rules for operating such a club.
150 SUCCESSFUL FAMILY LIFE ON MODERATE INCOME
How will you ascertain whether you can obtain the loan of a travelling
library in a farming community or small town?
5. How far should parents concern themselves with courses of study in
the schools which their children attend? Is there a parents' teachers'
association in your community? If not, could you organize one?
(Get information from U. S. Bureau of Education, Washington, D. C.).
6. Plato said more than 2000 years ago that the first act of a wise gov-
ernment would be to send out into the country all the inhabitants
of the city who were more than ten years old and then take possession
of their children who were as yet unaffected by the habits of their
parents. Would it not be already too late, and do you know of any
government wise enough to undertake their education?
7. A prominent psychiatrist says that we might well have " marriage
counsellors" as a kind of professional service. Do you think there
is a need for such service? Describe the qualifications of the person
who could fill such a post. Might it be connected with some institu-
tion? For instance, it is well known that families on the brink of
disaster are sometimes saved by the friendly advice of the court or
some social agency.
8. The Home Economics agent in an eastern city sent a letter ,and liter-
ature to every young woman who was given a license to marry. The
service in a large number of cases was accepted and was probably
useful. Might not a course in, for instance, family finance, be offered
to men in the new public vocational courses or by classes of the
local Y. M. C. A.?
9. Should the compulsory school-attendance age be advanced to eighteen
years? How do the young people feel about it? What is the view
of employers?
CHAPTER XIII
THE FAMILY BUDGET
WE have considered the various sources of the income as derived
from the earnings of the different members of the family, the sav-
ings of the preceding generation and the contributions from the
community, and we shall now in several chapters consider the
handling of the money income. This is the problem of the family
budget. Technically, the budget, whether of a nation or of a family,
is concerned with dividing up the estimated income before the money
is spent. As applied to household finances, it is distinctly new ; it
is yet to be accepted in any but very progressive families.
But this should occasion no surprise perhaps, since our national
government with full control of its income in the form of taxes,
and with all the necessary machinery for calculation and record, is
still floundering in the expense-account stage. " The present plan/'
we are told, " by which appropriations are made and the people then
taxed to meet them, would not be tolerated in private business for a
single year." When the government of city, state, or the United
States comes to be run on the budget plan the entire cost for the
next fiscal year will be known in advance and the people will have
ample time to approve or disapprove the various items and to ask
for additional information. Then, waste in all departments ought
to be disclosed to view and there should be a chance to discuss the
relative importance of proposed expenditures.
Misuse of the Term. — The word budget, as applied to house-
hold finance, is often wrongly used. It should have the same mean-
ing that it bears in public finance, a forecast or estimate of expendi-
tures for the year to come, while the items for which the money
was spent in the year past would appear as expense account or a
summary of it; but perhaps because domestic finance is in such an
Undeveloped state, the compact word budget, suggestive of large
and exact methods, seems to have been seized on and put to a
double use and so the expense account of the past as also the calcu-
lated plan for the year to come is sometimes called the budget.
151
152 SUCCESSFUL FAMILY LIFE ON MODERATE INCOME
The principles that are to guide in the division of the income
of any given family may be worked out by a study of its previous
expenditures aided by a comparison with similar records of other
families, all made to bear on the attainment of aims and plans for
the future. Past financial history is represented by the summary
of the expense account; the plan for future spending is shown by
the budget.
Expense Account vs. the Budget. — The account book in some
stage of development is known to most households. It is felt that
" you must put things down/' But account keeping cannot be said
to be popular. Many would applaud the saying of Cardinal
Manning : " Keeping accounts is writing epitaphs on dead money,"
and this distaste is found even in families that have learned to set
down every item and to balance every page.
The explanation is found in the fact that -few have discovered
that the real value of the individual or family expense account lies
in its summaries, which furnish the basis of comparison with the
preceding years and those which are to come. Viewed in this light
the work takes on new meaning, the budget is in sight. The budget
is interesting because it is forward looking ; all the plans and pur-
poses of the family are seen to depend on it while the trouble, with
the old-fashioned expense account was that it led nowhere; it did
not connect up with future desires and their attainment. The most
painstaking keepers of the itemized account are sometimes found
to be least able to, make these connections, they have lost their way
in the forest of figures.
Early Studies of the Budget. — Before taking up the spending
of the individual family income of to-day, it will be interesting to
note wfaat previous study has been put on the subject up to this time.
The study of family incomes and their expenditure was practically
begun in the last century by a French engineer and economist,
Frederic Le Play. For twenty-five years he had spent his vacations
travelling in different countries of Europe and everywhere he stud-
ied the condition of the workingnmn. His method was to live a
week or more with a typical family, and as he had rare social gifts,
great tact and spoke five languages, he always learned what he set
THE FAMILY BUDGET 153
out to learn. This man, so capable as an engineer that he was
selected by Napoleon III to organize the Exposition of 1855, did a
unique service to the science of economics by publishing in the same
year his thirty-six budgets of workmen's families or Family Mono-
graphs. He drew no statistical conclusions, but his material became
the basis of later work of the kind done by others. Ernst Engel
a few years later compared the Monographs with other available
Budgets, added similar data of his own gathered in Saxony, and
announced what the student of economics knows as Engel's Laws
of Consumption.
EngeL's Laws. — 1. As the income of a family increases, a
smaller percentage is expended for food.'
2. As the income of a family increases the percentage of expendi-
ture for clothing remains about the same.
3. The percentages for rent, fuel and light remain the same
whatever the income.
4. As the income increases in amount a constantly increasing
percentage is expended for education, health, recreation, amuse-
ments, etc.
Thus, to illustrate the first law, it would be found that at present
out of a $1500 income perhaps 50 per cent., or some $700, would be
spent for food for the family of normal size; while of a $2500
income, the amount spent might remain about the same, but the pro-
portion of the income required would fall to possibly 28 per cent.
According to the second and third laws the family will use a
larger sum for clothing, housing und all that goes to the upkeep
of the house in order to meet the higher standard of living which an
increased income will allow, but the same relation of these outgoes
to the entire income is apt to be kept.
As concerns the fourth law, the money spent for other than
physical necessities, or the items that are classed in the modern
budget under the word advancement, will be very small in amount
and in percentage in the lower range of incomes, but as the family
becomes better off, the percentage left over for education, recreation,
cultural expenditures and luxury of all kinds will increase, it may
even reach one-half of the income.
Engel's Laws are not concerned with any recommended or
advised division of family incomes, only with observed customs of
154 SUCCESSFUL FAMILY LIFE ON MODERATE INCOME
his time, and these relationships between the items in budgets of
all sizes seem to hold good to a surprising extent up to the present,
based 'as they are on well-known habits of people. They are falsi-
fied only when the owner of the income elects to spend or economize
in an unusual way, as, for instance, by one who continued to live
by preference in the same house or in the same style after his
income had doubled. These proportions are also upset when prices
become deranged, as was seen in the price of food, and later, clothing
and rent, in wartime.
The Bondy Budget. — An interesting budget that reflected the
customs prevailing in middle-class families in central Europe at the
time was brought out in 1890 by Ottilie Bondy, of Vienna. In this
case the division of the income was into six parts and was designed
to answer the question : " How to maintain the equilibrium in
domestic expenses, without which neither dignity nor peace of mind
can be preserved." The income was divided into six parts:
1. Rent 16%% or y6
2. Operating Expenses; i.e., fuel, light, service, dress, laundry. 16%% or y6
3. Life insurance, sickness and accident 16%% or %
(That which is saved by keeping well is used for recrea-
tion the following year.)
4. The children's heritage, not to be disturbed except in case
of dire necessity 16%% or %
5 & 6. Food and other daily expenses 33y3% or y3
Unfortunately, exact figures were not given as to the outlay
for food and the items coming under running expenses, but this
budget is suggestive as differing in several points from the Ameri-
can estimates, as in granting a somewhat smaller proportion for
rent and in reducing dress to a subordinate place, while insurance
and health is granted a main division of the income. Still more
important is the prominence given to the children's heritage arid
to the safeguards placed around the use of this comparatively large
proportion. According to foreign custom, this fund may be bor-
rowed from for the youth's education, or to start 'him in business, or
to meet some great family emergency; but it is held sacred as a
trust fund and it must be again built up through savings and
handed on intact so that the generation following may have the
same advantage by its use as a safe backing to the family life.
These apportionments suggest the tremendous economic pressure
THE FAMILY BUDGET 155
felt by the middle classes in older countries and the consequent
incentive to caution and economy and the long look ahead.
Mrs. Richards' Suggested Division of the Income.— The
following figures were brought out some twenty years ago by
Ellen H. Eichards as the suggested " ideal budget " in the United
States for the division of a $2000 to $4000 income to cover the
needs of the normal family :
1. Rent 20% or */.
2. Food 25% or %
3. Running expenses 15% or */T
(This in case the wife does most of the housework. Other-
wise running expenses, chiefly service, will equal rent. )
4. Clothing 15% or VT
5. Recreation, health, church and charity, savings and insurance. 25% or 14
This estimate, suggestive only, has remained for a long time
our most useful generalization on the American family budget.
The Minimum Budget for Health and Decency. — The United
States Bureau of Labor Statistics reported in December, 1919,
$2262.47 as the result of their estimate of the budget that shall
be sufficient to maintain " a standard of health and decency " among
government employees for a family consisting of husband, wife and
three children below the age of fourteen years in the City of
Washington, D. C. Its divisions are as follows : *
I. Food $773.93
II. Clothing:
Husband $121.16
Wife 166.46
Boy ( 11 years) 96.60
Girl (5 years 82.50
Boy (2 years) 47.00
513.72-
III. Housing, fuel, and light 428.00
IV. Miscellaneous 546.82
Total budget at market prices 2,262.47
Possible saving upon market cost by a family of extreme thrift,
of high intelligence, great industry in shopping, good fortune in
*A valuable detailed account of the items under each head is found in
a government publication, entitled " Tentative Quantity and Cost Budget —
Necessary to maintain a family of five in Washington, D. C., at a level of
health and decency." U, S. Bureau of Labor Statistics, Washington.
156 SUCCESSFUL FAMILY LIFE ON MODERATE INCOME
purchasing at lowest prices, and in which the wife is able to do a
maximum amount of home work:
I. Food ( 7y2 per cent. ) $58.04
II. Clothing ( 10 per cent.) 51.37
III. Housing 30.00
IV. Miscellaneous . 107.50
Total economies
246.91
Total budget minus economies 2,015.56
The U. S. Thrift Budgets. — A budget estimate of much interest
has been sent out by the Savings Division of the United States
Treasury Department, p. 157, working in conjunction with the De-
partment of Agriculture.2 It undertakes to advise upon such a
plan for spending the family money as will permit of substantial
savings .to be invested in government bonds or other securities
and since it was a part of a widespread thrift propaganda for the
country, it involved a careful study of the minimum expenditure
of the normal family for the necessities of life. Several estimates
are here quoted :
For the $2400 budget, the percentages by the month and year
stand as follows :
THE $2400 INCOME FOR FIVE
Percentage.
Savings 10y2
Kent u • 13y2
Food 32
Clothing 15
Housekeeping 10
Church and charity
Health, recreation and
education
Personal and miscellaneous
Advancement
19
100
Month.
$21
27
64
30
20
38
$200
Year
$252
324
768
360
240
456
$2400
This suggested arrangement of the family budget is the result
of careful work on the part of Home Economics experts and it comes
with greater authority than anything of its kind that has been done
in recent years. It offers, therefore, a good basis for the discussion
2How Other People Get Ahead. Government Printing Office, Washing-
ton, D. C.
THE FAMILY BUDGET
157
1 li'fff
S |: ||f
I o: I "
I_IH- I-H-" fO CO to •
OJtO OH-O-^O-
SS
«DO ^J tO tO 00 IO O
h-i h-> t-j >-• tOrf* tO i-
O5*- OiOOtOOOitOC
s;^ B88fe8^I| I
t-l-« I-COW*.W S
•^00 •^lOCOOOOrf^CO
H-I-. H--COCCO5CO CO
O505 C5 tO CO rf* 01 tO O
tOtO CO 01 *• rf* C" i-i tt
O« pi O5 p pi Cn p On cJi
88 888888i
88
tOtO to O5 Cn O5 05 1- CO
i-ito ^jcooipipoop
88 888888J
tOtO IOO505VJC5I-1-.J
J-1 IO pi pi O Cn O tO p
88 888888S1
SK-
I!
n *"
II
158 SUCCESSFUL FAMILY LIFE ON MODERATE INCOME
of iihe subject of this chapter. For actual use the proportion
assigned to each division must be adjusted to individual needs.
It must be repeated that this and all other estimates of the kind are
suggestive only. There is no " model " budget in the sense of one
that can be applied without change to any income whatever.
How to Begin a Budget. — Suppose a given family to be a unit
regarding the disposal of the income, or if not fully agreed, to
have developed a generous give-and-take that furnishes a working
basis, how would they start out to assign to each department of their
expenditure what it should have?
If they have the expense account for the preceding year it will
help greatly as giving the actual family practice, whatever may
have been the reasons for it; moreover, the results of spending as
they did will still be fresh in mind. The results, we will say, have
not been wholly satisfactory; perhaps no money has been saved —
they may even have run in debt. They must have been spending
more in some line than they had a right to ; the question is where ?
Plans and Purposes. — The first thing for this family to con-
sider is, what do they want to accomplish, say in the next five years
and how much money can be set aside to carry out those plans?
What present outgoes must be cut down ? Such decisions are espe-
cially important for the young married couple who will certainly
be able to make enough of a plan to prevent the disagreeable experi-
ence of two young people who started out gaily on a $2500 salary,
and in the last month of the year were nearly reduced to a bread-
and-water diet to keep from going into debt. But they did not
go into debt and the keeping of that resolve was the founding of
their later success.
It would be a great deal if this typical young couple could be
persuaded that there really is a science of seamanship in these new
waters, not perfect, but charting the worst rocks and the most
dangerous currents ! For they sometimes seem to start out on their
voyage without rudder or compass, and as for chart they have only
the yarns of old sailors now safe in port. And many of these
ancient mariners have drifted in rather than steered their course
and some have lost their cargo and barely saved their lives !
Any really definite plan for the future will furnish the begin-
nings of a good division, for it will be based on a thoughtful com-
parison of needs. Thus, the couple who have begun to live on a
THE FAMILY BUDGET 159
budget have a better rule than doing what other people think they
should. Perhaps an expensive wedding trip is not taken, they
may choose a more unpretentious way of living than has been
expected of them, but they have bravely "struck their gait," for
they know exactly what they want to do with the money saved.
Moreover, their example makes it easier for everyone thev know
to live the honest life.
A Budget That Does Not Know it is a Budget. — One family
started out with just three aims for the next twenty-five years:
1st. To make the utmost out of the man in his profession.
2nd. To be able to give the children a good education.
3rd. To have enough to live on in old age.
After twenty-five years they look back on all three accomplished
and done on a moderate income. And yet this family denies that
it kept a budget, or even an expense account in detail. What they
felt to be necessary was a knowledge of the large outgoes, so that
they might be scanned and compared with what will be called for
in the following year or years. If they did not keep a budget it was
in the same sense that the experienced cook does not need a written
recipe for making bread, because she has long had it by heart and
is frequently practicing it.
The Foundation of Success. — This, then, is the foundation of
budget-making ; to know what you want to do with your life — it is
the wand which marshalls the figures in order ! Of all those groups
of figures which we are now calling family budgets, the most
valuable in their suggestion for others are those which have been
evolved by families having a clear purpose in life, a purpose
which they carried out with courage and the single eye. Their
success makes easier the adoption of the budget by the next
generation of housekeepers who have had the better school training
in family finance. By this plan careful attention is given to the
different claims on the purse, and decisions are reached which the
members of a family agree to consider binding unless unusual
circumstances arise to make a readjustment necessary. Such
decisions bring to any family a feeling of dignity and command
over their future which, once experienced, makes any other method
seem childish and makeshift and likely to bring disaster. The
" beasts that perish " show a better directing intelligence than does
the man who drifts. Decisions made in advance, tentative and
160 SUCCESSFUL FAMILY LIFE ON MODERATE INCOME
general though they may be, help enormously to steady us when we
are tempted to courses of action involving outlays not in the original
estimate for good judgment tells us that we are apt to have been
right when we coolly compared in advance the claims of our different
needs and desires. On these decisions we may rely as we do on
social conventions and rules of conduct which become second habit
and relieve us from the necessity of making an independent decision
each time, but which on the other hand, are not ironclad and can
be amended for good and sufficient reasons.
An Illustration. — " How much will you give me for the Old
Ladies' Home ? " says a friend with that taken-f or-granted expres-
sion which means, " Of course you will help with my pet charity."
The woman who is living on the budget plan does not put on that
cold, self-defensive look which informs the wretched visitor that
her request will be granted only under social pressure. She says
cordially, " I'd. love to help ; nothing appeals to me more than those
old ladies, but it all depends upon how much is left in envelope
No. 6 ; you see, I live on the budget plan." The label on envelope
No. 6 reads, " Church and charity $100," and a slip inside shows
what has been expended. Church subscription, $20 ; church supper,
$1 ; charity organization, $5. Since the account shows a good
surplus, $3 is given to the Old Ladies' Home and the sum is
written on the slip.
Use of Money Comparatively New. — Perhaps one reason why
it is difficult to grasp the importance of money spending as an .edu-
cator is that the majority of our people are still so near the time
when, as dwellers on farms, people had hardly any money. A great-
aunt remembers the sixty-three cents which was the first money she
ever owned, and she was eighteen years old ! Barter in what might
be called its secondary phase was the method of exchange, farmers
" helped each other out " at harvest and other times, the women
at quiltings. If the family went to town it was in the farm wagon,
and they bought at stores which would take farm produce, those
which would not take butter and eggs having no chance with the
women buyers. Rent, fuel, food were not represented in the
mind by money, they came from the farm, and the farmer even of
to-day is unable to separate these items from what he sells.
The Budget Marks an Advance in the Art of Living. —
There are those who still say that they have no interest in a plan
THE FAMILY BUDGET 161
of spending which divides the income before any of it is given out,
who do not believe in the educational value of the allowance for
children and are averse to giving the time and thought that older
people must render in order that it may become a valuable depart-
ment of home education; to such must be recommended an actual
trial and a faithful one of the new plan, for in most cases such a
trial would convince them that it marks a distinct advance in satis-
factory living.
The following is a concise statement of the results that may be
expected to follow the Thrift and Household Budget campaign
of the Treasury Department:
" There are three reasons why it is fortunate that banks and banking
associations are helping to promote the study of the family budget, and
that the U. S. Treasury Department has taken up this work. First, it will
bring more directly to the attention of heads of families who mistakenly
believe the way to make a woman economize is to give instead of share,
that no one can save without the right kind of knowledge and purpose, or
something to save from. Again and again women desire to run their homes
by approved business methods, but cannot because they lack the right kind
of cooperation from the one upon whom support depends. A budget compels
cooperation in the family.
" Second, it promotes the study of economics and supplements the work
of home economics departments by giving practical assistance to those
who might otherwise fail to find the right kind of help in economic adjust-
ments. Third, it may in the course of time compel state and national
legislatures to adjust their finances by intelligent economic methods. When
enough citizens recognize the results of applied budget principles, the
demand for a proper system of Government expenditures based on actual
known income will be too insistent to be refused." *
Restatement. — 1st. It will be found important to make a
somewhat definite separation between necessities as required by
health and efficiency on one side, and on the other, things important
but exchangeable to a degree with each other.
2d. A definite written budget or plan of spending the income
should be made in advance for the week, month or year, possibly in
outline for several years, this plan to embody the aims and purposes
of the family; it will not be perfect, but it will furnish a good
working outline. The plan of spending will naturally be based on
the account book of a previous year or term of years, and a study
of the budgets of other families, as found in home economics litera-
ture, will be helpful.
"General Federation Magazine, April, 1919.
11
162 SUCCESSFUL FAMILY LIFE ON MODERATE INCOME
3rd. The making of this family budget will be a matter of
family conference to which the children will be admitted, nor will
the plan once adopted be changed without bringing it before
this conference.
4th. Partial budgets, as a housekeeping or a clothing budget,
are also of value, and sometimes offer the necessary training for the
keeping of the whole budget. To live on them with satisfaction
requires careful saving for the larger items and forbids the drib-
bling away of money on unconsidered trifles.
5th. One of the most important budgets is that of the child's
allowance which should be used as a means of education in com-
parative values.
6th. The budget plan once adopted should have a year's fair trial,
and the proportions agreed on in advance should be adhered to if
possible, even at considerable inconvenience. The next year changes
may be made as suggested by experience.
QUESTIONS
1. Which is the strongest influence in deciding how you will divide up
your money, present habits and standards or a thrifty outlook on,
future needs?
2. Is it easier to change standards of spending to meet a lowered income
or to earn more money to keep up the old standards?
3. Has a lack of unity as to the money spending in a family any direct
relation to the increasing number of divorces?
4. If a family has $2500 and then gets $3000, will it be likely to spend
as much or more money on the table? Will the amount be the same
percentage or a smaller percentage of the total income? What is
Engel's rule?
5. What goals ahead seem to you worth saving money for ? How much of
your income would it take every month to reach one, at least, of
these goals.
6. What would be the benefits to the nation if it became common to budget
personal income as to proposed savings and expenditures?
7. Outline reasonable plans for children's participation in family budget-
ing and finance — for example, at what age can they help plan for
recreation expenses, for their own clothing, for buying a new home
for the family?
8. If budgeting is planning in advance for expenditures and then carry-
ing out one's plan is it true that good housekeepers have always
budgeted? What is new, then, in the present budget movement?
9. "Every budget is an individual problem" — why then consult average
budgets, percentage divisions and the like?
10. Ask business men, bankers, lawyers, doctors and others how far they
use what might be called a budget system (though they may not
use the word) in, their business.
CHAPTER XIV
THE MINIMUM EXPENDITURE FOR THE
NECESSITIES OF LIFE
IN the division of the income we must first set aside the require-
ment for food, clothing, shelter and operating for the household;
not until we have provided for these essential physical needs, which
we call living expenses, can we know what is left for the fifth great
division, which has been called advancement, made up of items
which may be compared with each other as to their desirability and
which therefore come within the region of choice.
Definition of the Minimum. — By the "minimum family in-
come " is not meant the sum which is barely enough to sustain life,
but the smallest sum on which health, working power and self-
respect may be maintained. There are widely different decisions
as to what is necessary to this end, but an attempt to set such a
limit will at least suggest the line to be drawn between the foun-
dational needs of life, on the one hand, for any family, and on
the other, what must be classed under comfort and luxury, a depart-
ment of expenditure which admits of a comparison of values.
Scientific and Social Studies. — The determination of this
necessary minimum is in some respects no longer guesswork;
scientific and social enquiries give a basis for the estimate. As to
food, the estimate has reached something like certainty, since the
science of nutrition is able to state the amount of the essential ele-
ments needed for growth and working power for man, woman
and child; the minimum would be found in furnishing those ele-
ments in cheap rather than in dear foodstuffs.
As to housing and clothing we have no standards so conclusive,
but social studies in a large number of cases have shown the per-
centage of the income devoted to these needs beyond which it is not
safe to go in justice to other demands on the purse; for instance,
to meet the requirements of hygiene and decency it has been stated
that at least five rooms will be needed for the family which contains
163
164 SUCCESSFUL FAMILY LIFE ON MODERATE INCOME
both boys and girls ; that clothing should provide for the demands o
health in different reasons and it must also provide occupationa
dress and what will meet simple social requirements. Likewise, tin
items included under operating expenses may be reduced to ;
minimum list that covers necessities.
Much more difficult is it to state the minimum outgo whicl
is to maintain self-respect ; it will differ widely in different f amilies
and in times of restlessness and social upheaval is not to be state<
at all. It is found in the " fair " rather than the minimum allow
ance of the economist, which provides for " a degree of comfort an<
mental satisfaction in addition to physical efficiency/'
Ryan says : * " In order to live becomingly men must possess no
only those goods which are objectively necessary, but in som
measure those that they think are ... Not to be able to satisf;
the more important of the conventional needs always involves i
grave injury to self-respect."
Luxury has been defined as "that which is not necessary fo
health, strength and efficiency," but "the universal consensus o
opinion " must be regarded, as that it is decent to wear shoes, evei
in hot weather. Still the line between luxuries and decencies wil
be an obscure and wavering one." 2
The Committee on Industrial and Social Problems of th(
Lambeth Conference of Bishops of the Episcopal Church, July
1920, calls for what is necessary to live " a decent and complete, j
cleanly and noble life."
To what extent the families that make up a community can liv<
up to these requirements is beside the question. Standards of effi
ciency and comfort should be outlined at stated intervals to mee
changing prices and needs.
Food Requirements. — That food, sufficient in quantity and o:
the right variety, is the first great requirement of the human being
is as evident as is the need of fuel and repairs for the steam engine
Until the family has enough to eat of the proper kind it will be idl<
to talk of the use of money in other ways. Here is a factor 01
which depends the sense of well-being for the whole family, th<
development of the young and the working power of the adul
1 John A. Ryan, " The Living Wage."
3 T. N. Carver, " War Thrift."
MINIMUM EXPENDITURE FOR NECESSITIES OF LIFE 165
members, whether that work be of mind or of muscle. No depart-
ment of expenditure is more dependent on knowledge, nowhere will
false economy be so ruinous.
Food requirements are chiefly affected by the size and age of the
individual and by the degree of activity involved in the labor per-
formed, while the relish with which the food is taken depends some-
what on habit, especially on long-standing racial habits. Economy
consists in providing the needed food elements in cheap rather than
in dear materials, and in making the prepared dish acceptable
through the arts of cookery.
The United States Thrift Budget quoted in the previous chapter
allows for the $2400 family of five persons of different ages, whose
food requirement is equal to three and a half adults, $768 a year, or
$15 a week. Many other estimates result in similar figures for
food prices now current.
The Amount of Money Required. — A helpful suggestion s has
been made as to the division of this money so as to obtain proper
balance from a nutritional point of view ; that is, an approximately
equal amount of money should be spent on the five food groups
now known to be necessary for a satisfactory daily diet. For
instance, in using $10, $2, or a little more, should go for grain
products, $2 for milk, $2 for meat, eggs and cheese, $2 for fruit
and vegetables and $2, or a little less, for sugar, fat and condiments.
For children milk is the first necessity, a pint, or better, a quart
per child, is the standard amount, some milk daily for adults being
also desirable. If the requisite variety is furnished and the food
well prepared, the normal appetite of the family, especially in the
case of children, furnishes a good guide as to amount.
How to Obtain Knowledge of Food. — The housewife must
first be convinced that she needs advice about feeding her family.
Then the requisite knowledge of food, how to purchase and to
prepare it is to be gained in many ways. Instruction for young
girls as afforded by the public day schools, and by evening classes
for older girls and adult women, should be utilized to the fullest
extent and more help of the kind called for in no uncertain tones
by women who have come to realize their need of more knowledge
•Adequacy and Economy of some City Dietaries, 1917. Sherman &
Gillett, New York Association for Improving Condition of the Poor.
166 SUCCESSFUL FAMILY LIFE ON MODERATE INCOME
on these matters. Helpful literature, simply expressed and up to
date in its statements, is furnished free by the U. S. Department of
Agriculture; any woman may obtain it by asking for Farmers
Bulletins on food and nutrition; a full list of titles will be sent
her by the Superintendent of Documents, Washington, from which
to choose. Here again the woman in need of instruction should ask
for more literature on a greater variety of topics. Then when a
plan for better feeding of the family has been evolved, she must
try it with much persistence, she must learn the art of cookery,
adjust to the tastes of the family and watch results. No economies
are so difficult to put through as those which involve a change
in food habits ; if they are at -present unhygienic and extravagant,
skill, patience and time will be needed by the purveyor to effect
improvement. The home economics teacher, the school physician
and the school nurse are among the most helpful agencies for advis-
ing the housewife how to provide proper food for the family and
how to judge the results by means of weighing and other tests of
their health.
Housing Requirements. — The house must provide facilities
for household processes and for the personal and social life of the
members of the family. The dwelling chosen is of great importance
because many other outgoes are affected by it for all operating ex-
penses, as heat, light, cleaning and other forms of labor, bear a
distinct relation to the size of the house and its interior arrange-
ment and finish. For instance, in planning the improved houses
for workingmen, the War Industries Board suggested that a family
could not afford more rooms than their actual needs required, even
though the larger house cost no more than the smaller, because
furnishing, light, heat and care had to be taken into account.
Again, such items as good floors, convenient arrangement of rooms,
good heating and cooking stoves diminish labor; well-fitting or
double windows cut down the coal bill, while a poorly built house
is in many ways expensive to run.
The location of the house, its distance from business, school,
markets and centers of social life, determines the expense for trans-
portation. If, for instance, three members of the family have to
use the street car daily, from $100 to $150 must be considered as
added to the rent as compared with the house which is within
MINIMUM EXPENDITURE FOR NECESSITIES OF LIFE 167
walking distance of these centers. The time used in going to and
fro and the fatigue of travel must also be reckoned for those who
live in suburbs and balanced against the larger living quarters and
healthful surroundings.
Socially the house sets the pace, as it were, announcing what
the family expects to live up to. It is an external, like dress, not
to be hidden from the public, something by which our means, our
taste and requirements may be judged. That is, this would be true
if the houses that suit individual requirements were as readily
obtained as is a suit of clothes of any desired grade.
Present Cost of Housing. — But this is not the case. The
matter of housing for the family of moderate income has long since
reached the dignity of a " problem " in this country, a problem
which is especially acute in our cities, and since the war too large
a proportion of the income is needed to pay for the type of dwelling
which will meet modern requirements for health and social effi-
ciency, and too few of such houses are available at any price. We
are thus confronted with an entirely different situation from that
found in dress and food, for in these lines what can be afforded can
generally be obtained.
The National Housing Association reports tnat all outlay for
rent that reaches one-quarter of the income is too large. One-fifth
or less spent for rent should be the limit until the income passes
$3000, and even then it is wise to hold to the smaller proportion.
According to Mr. Lawrence Veiller, in some of the model housing
enterprises of foreign countries the management refuses to rent to
workingmen apartments whose rental would exceed this ratio of
one-fifth. Although the abnormal conditions that prevail in hous-
ing at present make it impossible to conform to this rule, it is true
that in justice to other requirements on the income, one-fifth should
be the limit of what is paid for rent. If the house is owned it is
not considered wise to invest in it more than twice the amount of
the annual income.
The Thrift Budget of the United States Treasury Department
allows for rent $300 to $400 a year, or about 17 per cent., out of an
$1800 to $2400 income but the difficulty of meeting decent hous-
ing requirements for this sum emphasizes the fact that the old
commercial relations between landlord and tenant have been out-
168 SUCCESSFUL FAMILY LIFE ON MODERATE INCOME
grown. To quote from a Government report, " Private initiative
has proved inadequate to deal with the problem, and systematic
government regulation, encouragement and financial aid must
be given."
It would seem that housing may in the future ,be rated with
health, education and insurance as a question for government
control and help, based on the results of investigation by trained
people. Its relation to city planning and systems of transporta-
tions, to the erection of industrial plants, to land valuation, the tax
system and other large national and municipal questions is
readily seen.
Helps Toward Better Housing. — Of great importance are
the standards adopted by the United States Shipping Board for the
erection of houses during the war, standards that met the approval
of the most prominent architects and are destined to have a great
effect on all house building.
The rebuilding of houses, especially in the country and small
towns, is receiving attention in current journals, and advice may
be obtained through their system of correspondence, while the free
use of plans for building and for rebuilding with reliable specifi-
cations are offered in some states by a department of the agricul-
tural college or by other state institutions.
Cooperation in house owning by a copartnership method long
in use in the " garden cities " of England and on the continent, has
been adopted in certain building schemes in this country, and it
promises help to the man of small means, both by reducing the cost
of building and by helping him to sell his house, if he wishes to move.
Much is to be expected from the work of Housing Associations,
national, state, and city, and from conferences on city planning
which are discussing desirable standards of housing and spreading
such knowledge among the people. One State Homestead Com-
mission, that of Massachusetts, has made an interesting experiment
to show what can be done by state purchase of tracts of land near
large cities and the erection of dwelling houses on a large scale.
It would seem that for the present the individual must take
what he can get in the way of housing, holding his expenditure
for rent as nearly as possible to one-fifth of his income in justice
i
MINIMUM EXPENDITURE FOR NECESSITIES OF LIFE 169
to the other demands on it, but paying more if it is found necessary
in order to obtain decent living conditions for his family.
Minimum for Clothing. — Clothing to meet the demands of
comfort and of the social and occupational standards of one's
group comes next in importance after food and housing. The
minimum for clothing is very difficult to state. To quote the
United States Bureau of Labor Statistics : " Scientific dietary
studies have laid down generally accepted standards of the kinds
of food and the expenditure necessary to feed a family or an indi-
vidual so as to maintain health and a reasonable degree of comfort.
No corresponding standards in regard to clothing have ever been
made. The task of working out standards of the kinds, the quali-
ties, and the cost of clothing indispensable for an average working-
man's family or for individual workers in different occupations
is well-nigh impossible," and this because of " wide variations
in individual tastes, in knowledge of materials and styles, in oppor-
tunities to buy advantageously, in capacity to make and mend
garments and in ability to consume clothes with the minimum of
wear and tear."
One factor, however, was held to be fairly constant in its
effect on clothing plans and expenditures. This is the occupational
requirement. The worker must adjust to ruling standards of dress
in his or her occupation, else there will be no true efficiency for
lack of a feeling of ease and self-possession on the part of the
worker. Even the holding of a position may depend on this
degree of conformity to what others do.
Money to be Used for Clothing. — The proportion of the in-
come to be used for clothing was established by early students of
the subject to be nearly constant; that is, as the income rises the
family is more able to indulge its desire for dress in order to meet
higher standards of what is beautiful and fitting and will continue
to spend about the same proportion of income for dress. In the
middle-class European family clothing is not given a seat in the
front row of requirements ; it is apt to appear as one item in " run-
ning expenses." In the United States Thrift Budget of $2400,
15 per cent., or $360, is allowed for clothing. In the Budget issued
by the Department of Labor in December, 1919, 2%y2 per cent, of
the $2262.47 is allowed for clothing, or $513.72— an allowance that
170 SUCCESSFUL FAMILY LIFE ON MODERATE INCOME
was larger than normal because of the relatively inflated prices of
clothing prevailing at that time.
Instruction Required. — That clothing requirements may be
met on the sum that can be afforded by the family living on the
moderate income requires intelligent thought given to the matter
and abundant help on the part of the community in providing good
classes of instruction in purchasing and in designing and making
clothing with skill and taste. Through the Agricultural and Home
Economics Extension Instruction, maintained by State Colleges of
Agriculture in cooperation with the United States Department of
Agriculture under the provisions of the Smith-Lever Act, help on
clothing has been for sometime available for women living in rural
districts and villages. Similar help is now to be offered by evening
classes to towns and villages through the Smith-Hughes Vocational
Education Act, since Home Economics is included under its pro-
visions for vocational schools and classes and it is hoped that future
legislation will increase the money available for this work. The
U. S. Department of Agriculture in its Home Economics Division
issues bulletins on clothing, as do also the State Agricul-
tural Colleges.
Operating Expenses. — The operating or running expenses of
a house include such items as fuel, light, telephone, insurance on
furniture, and house supplies of all kinds except food, and also
most important and costly of all, household labor, a subject which is
treated in a separate chapter. The Thrift Budget for $2400 allows
$240, or 10 per cent., for operating expenses. The " Health and
Decency Budget " of the United States Department of Labor for an
income of $2262.47 allows for operating expenses, upkeep of home
and furnishings, $70 ; laundry, $107 ; cleaning supplies, $32.92 ; fuel
and light are estimated at $128— a total of $337.92, or nearly
15 per cent.
The Budget Plan Helpful. — So many items come under oper-
ating expense that all manner of small economies must be prac-
ticed. Similar outgoes must be grouped for comparison; for in-
stance, the postage stamp must be used instead of the more expensive
telephone and telegram, a substitution that requires foresight which
may be stimulated by the knowledge that these means of communi-
cating with the outside world have together a very small appropria-
tion in the budget, not to be increased except from the carfare
MINIMUM EXPENDITURE FOR NECESSITIES OF LIFE 171
allowance. Again, if laundry and house cleaning go together in
the budget, the girl who wants a fresh dress every day in summer
will perhaps take better care of half that number rather than to
herself launder them, or be obliged to scrub the kitchen to eke out
the time of the laundress.
The family will be obliged to study the best use of the material
equipment of the house, as the construction of stoves and ranges
and the comparative values of different fuels. They must learn how
to make small repairs; above all, they must know where to obtain
advice on difficult questions involved in the business of running
the house.
QUESTIONS
FOOD
1. Name the five food groups.
2. What group or groups of foods must be more largely used, if one wishes
to reduce the costs of the table while giving full nutrition?
3. What single food is most important in providing adequate diet for those
who are in the period of growth?
4. Explain the large use of meat in America compared with European
countries.
5. It is said that a woman requires eight-tenths as much food as a man;
should any qualifications be added to such a statement?
6. Keep a record of kinds of foods used during a day or a week in your
own or another's family; what items could be changed to reduce cost,
and what to improve the menu from a nutritional standpoint? If
your food expenditure could be decreased, what would you do with the
money saved? If it must be increased, from what other department
of expenditures would you take the money?
7. What influences are at work in your community to increase knowledge
of food values ? What additional measures might be employed ? What
action might be recommended to a woman's club? What might a
public library do besides keeping books on the subject?
CLOTHING
1. Remembering that the laundering of clothes is an essential item in cost,
make a list of necessary articles for a girl of ten to last a year's time.
Give the purchase cost of such a wardrobe, the items and the total.
Deduct partial value of what could be worn still longer than a year.
2. Illustrate the effect of age, climate and occupation on clothing costs.
3. Name three garments of men and three of women of which it is good
economy to buy the best possible quality with the idea of long-
term service.
4. Point out ways in which careless use of clothing increases cost. State
five practical rules which may be given to children for the care
of clothing.
5. What losses have you sustained by a change of style which has made a
good piece of clothing useless? Add experience of others. How
avoid this loss?
172 SUCCESSFUL FAMILY LIFE ON MODERATE INCOME
6. A girl away at school spends $500 on her clothing. On the basis of 15
per cent, of the income spent for dress and assuming that there are
three other members in the family, what ought the income to be in
order to justify this expenditure?
7. How can Home Economics teachers and mothers cooperate to influence
the standards of dress among high-school girls?
8. Would you criticise our whole scheme of balanced economy as resulting
too seldom in what is beautiful in dress ? What would you do about it ?
HOUSING
1« Do children need a special living room or nursery? Under what cir-
cumstances? Lacking such a room, could a children's corner in the
living room be devised to meet some of their needs?
2. What are the arguments for ownership of the home for families of
small income? What against it? Are the latter to be overcome
in any way?
3. Arrange in order of importance the following improvements for farm
houses: bathroom, kitchen sink with piped water, indoor toilet, fly
screens, porch, sleeping porch. Which would you select for use in a
campaign for better rural housing?
4. Suggest a program of popular education for a housing association in
your community.
5. How is a Building and Loan Association organized under the laws of
your state? Is it subject to state inspection? How are citizens to be
assured of its honest and efficient management?
6. Criticise floor plans, heating, lighting, ventilation and working equip-
ment of the house in which you live and suggest improvements that
might have been made with a little or no expense at the time the
house was built.
7. Shall a family of moderate income, now paying too much for their
housing, take in a roomer either temporarily or permanently, or shall
they seek a house with lower rent? What are the fundamental con-
siderations that should govern such a decision?
8. What should be the general requirements of a housing law to control
construction and occupancy of houses, tenements, etc.? Should legal
housing standards concern one-family houses occupied by the owners,
as well as tenement property? Give reasons.
9. Granted that our ideal for a family should be the detached house with
some lawn and garden, owned by the family, what other features do
you consider essential? Name in order of importance.
10. Suppose a house that is lived in by the owner would rent for $600;
about what would be its present market value if $200 is paid out
yearly for taxes, insurance and repairs? Estimate what the house
would probably sell for in ten or twenty years, and what must be
set aside for deterioration.
11. Would it be feasible for a number of families to undertake a group
housing scheme, as, for instance, a house to be used for vacations,
each family of the group possessing it for a fortnight?
12. Draw up a house plan for a family of moderate income, one in which
the housekeeper will do her own work and care for her children. Also
a plan for a grown-up family in which there are several daughters.
CHAPTER XV
THE SAVINGS FUND AND ITS USE
Saving Comes First. — The new thrift budget of the United
States Government in its suggested division of the family income
places saving at the head of the list. This recommendation, as
indicating the practice that ought to prevail in the American family,
is nothing short of revolutionary in character. It comes with all
the force of a discovery, a veritable new idea; nothing like it in its
power to catch the imagination has appeared in many a day. It
is the very opposite of the older method, which has been to save what
was " left over." To place savings first is to ask the money-earner
to consider that his or her income is chargeable, first of all, with
a duty to the future, and that this duty should be met by setting
aside a certain proportion of the income on every pay day before
a cent is spent. What is left is the actual money income and the
whole scale of living must adjust to it. " What ! before the primary
needs of life are met ? " Yes, for only so can the right habit be
established ; only so, the provision for future needs be made stable.
However small the sum that can be saved, it must be set aside and
the principle established.
Of the importance of this thrift campaign for our people there
can be no doubt. It was our lack of providence for the future that
brought out a generation ago the trenchant words of James J. Hill,
the railway president, in which he told young men, "If you
want to know whether you are going to be a success or a failure in
life, you can easily find out. The test is simple and infallible.
Are you able to save money? If not, drop out. You will fail as
sure as you live. You may not think so, -but you will. The seed
of success is not in you." It would seem that this dictum, long
scorned in our hopeful and prosperous country, is on the way
to acceptance.
The Reasons for Saving Money. — It cannot be denied that
even when given the more alluring name of " deferred spending "
the habit of saving has not been generally established in this country.
" Why should I save, " says reckless youth. " For liberty, for
power to choose your way of life, to change your occupation if
need be, to be able to carry out plans that will some day appeal to
173
174 SUCCESSFUL FAMILY LIFE ON MODERATE INCOME
you with an urgency that you cannot now credit ! " As the am-
bitious young workman said to his bride, " We must save, Annie ;
only low-down folks don't save ! "
To have an aim and to know the way to it is to realize that we
cannot spend all we earn on what we want to-day ; and better yet, to
hold to a good plan of life against all temptations is to build up
character and to attain standards far more valuable than the savings
account itself.
Economy Need Not be Petty. — Perhaps the greatest enemy to
the practice of thrift is the conviction which is held by the majority
of people, that it is all made up of petty decisions and cheese-paring
economies ; this is especially to be seen in the attitude of the young
who detest saving and other forms of thrift unless the good to be
gained is immediate and personal. Why be careful of the gas and
electricity in a hotel? It is not included in the bill. Why use a
pad of cheaper paper for notes or first drafts? The saving is too
small to consider. Why "clean the plate," now that the war is
over? It is very important for our people to change this attitude
and it can be done only by gaining a broader view of the material re-
sources of the community and of the country ; indeed, of the whole
world, in their relation to the well-being of peoples. If we except
a now fast-receding period in our own country's history, there has
never been a time when the stock of manufactured goods and raw
materials was beyond the common need if there were ahundant
means of exchange.
Jane Addams says : " Those of us who have lived among immi-
grants realize that there is highly developed among them a certain
reverence for food. Food is the precious stuff men live by, that
which is obtained only after long and toilsome labor; it is the
cherished thing which the poor have seen come into their homes,
little by little, and often not enough, since they were children, until
to waste it has come to seem sinful and irreligious."
The destruction of the late war which reduced the world's stock
of finished products and raw materials, the urgency of the plea to
save, which was forced home by the lecturers who multiplied for
their audiences the spoonful of flour in one family kitchen by
twenty millions to show the astounding amount of waste in the
whole country, ought to have broadened the vision and have shown
how inadequate are present resources of all kinds for the world's
THE SAVINGS FUND AND ITS USE 175
needs if we are to have any high standards of prosperity. It is
this broader view which raises thrift to a dignified and noble place.
Accumulations of capital are necessary to allow of large enterprises,
dollars are made up of pennies and nickels, and great aggregations
of material out of many small hoardings. It removes all pettiness
from the practice of thrift if our aim is to conserve the stock of
necessaries for the common good. Thus, saving would seem to
depend on an attitude of mind rather than on the following out
of a set of rules. It accepts as a principle that all of our income
is not ours to spend on immediate needs, however pressing they may
seem to be; a certain proportion must be set aside to be used for
purposes that have nothing to do with the minimum of present
needs which we have agreed to consider the basis of our eco-
nomic life.
What Form of Savings? Five Considered. — As seen in a
preceding paragraph, the Government budget suggests that the
family of five receiving the $2400 income can save 11 per cent, of it,
or $264. This savings fund may be assigned to many differ-
ent uses.
1st. Investment of money as such, in order to obtain interest on
it in the form of government securities, saving bank deposits or
other investment.
2nd. Premiums on a life insurance for security of the family
against death of the money-earner, or an accident insurance if the
business is hazardous, possibly a sickness benefit.
3rd. The buying of what is necessary for the very basis of
living, as the house and lot and household furniture, an investment
which brings income through the use of goods which it would
require money to hire.
4th. Education or training for self-support for any member of
the family; this must be considered one of the best forms
of investment.
5th. Such rest and recreation for the money-earners as will
make continued earning possible should also be considered an in-
vestment, and an absolutely necessary outgo, not to be placed at
the end of the list under the division advancement to take its chances
with the thousand and one things that the family desire. The
first and second methods for the use of savings makes a universal
appeal for security of some kind for old age is imperative. There
176 SUCCESSFUL FAMILY LIFE ON MODERATE INCOME
are sights around us which drive home the lesson that while
poverty in youth may be a stimulus to effort, poverty in middle life
and old age is a calamity. Failing powers and growing infirmities
need easy circumstances to make life tolerable and to prolong use-
fulness, some variety in the days as given by travel, the dear privi-
lege of giving. On this subject of provision for the future, the
older people in the family must stand firm, since the younger ones
have no experience to contribute. "It is a good rule to make/'
said an old lady who was spending her last days in the house to
which she had come as a bride, " that when you get old you'll' put
your knees under your own table." The fund for investment and
for life insurance must grow at the expense of temporary indulgence ;
it is a part of that fearless facing of life and its possibilities which
characterize the steadfast mind. The other forms of savings are
sometimes not looked on as such, they are, however, true methods
of investment to make sure of present development, including happi-
ness and future earning power.
Two Conditions. — Among the many conditions in family life
that will affect the use made of the savings fund are two which will
be found to have controlling influence in a large number of cases :
first, the occupation of the income-earner; second, the age of the
children in the family.
Professional and Clerical Pursuits. — In professional and
other pursuits that require a more or less expensive preparation for
money-earning this outgo for training is considered as an invest-
ment that increases earning power. It may have to be repaid
as money borrowed for the purpose.
For instance, the preparation of the teacher will have required
a period of higher schooling, and even after earning begins, there
may be a small salary for years on account of low-paid, preparatory
positions. Such outlWs constitute a sort of lien on the present
income and must be considered.
The social requirements on the professional or clerical family
are apt to be larger than on the artisan's family. Their dress will
cost more, at least for the money-earner, who also has needs in the
way oi vacation, travel, attendance on conferences, and other outlays
required by mind-workers to keep efficient in their chosen field.
This requirement is seen more pointedly in older countries, such
as England, where the bank clerk and others of his class are required
THE SAVINGS FUND AND ITS USE 177
to dress in black and until recently to wear the high hat, and they
ars not allowed by custom to occupy a house that does not meet
certain standards. In this class, because they have no means
through combination of obtaining an increase in salary sufficient
to meet changing costs of living, unrest and dissatisfaction is the
prevalent state of mind. It is evident that such families can invest
less of their saving in the forms that will bring them financial
returns in the future than can the family of the artisan. The
savings fund will be heavily drawn on to pay for training, to meet
the requirements of social position, and to keep earning power at a
high level. In the budget of government employees, quoted in
Chapter XIII, it will be noted that no provision was made for
savings except for a small life insurance. It is this comparative in-
ability to save for old age that seems to justify the system of pensions.
In the teacher's budget submitted by L. C. Karpinski, giving an
average of the actual outgoes in the families of twenty assistant
professors in the University of Michigan in the years 1917-18 and
also the minimum estimated as necessary for the same families for
1919-20, we see the urgency of the demands due to the nature of
the occupation and to the position which this occupation gives the
family in the community. The other methods of investment men-
tioned for savings, as the buying of the house and what is needed
to keep the earning powers at a high level, will be apt to be used.
A MINIMUM DECENT LIVING BUDGET1
(FOR A PROFESSIONAL WORKER'S FAMILY)
Average actual Estimated
expenditure of necessary
20 assistant expendi-
professors in ture for
1917-18 1919-20
Rent . , , , , ^ $530 $600
Food 581 700
Heat, light, water, telephone, repairs and
renewal 261 300
Clothing 348 450
Laundry and help 259 300
Income tax 82 100
Professional and personal 68 100
Church and charity 65 75
Physician and dentist 189 150
Society, books, travel and recreation 165 225
Insurance and savings 125 300
$2673.00 $3300.00
School and Society, December 63 1919.
12
178 SUCCESSFUL FAMILY LIFE ON MODERATE INCOME
Artisan and Business Families. — The artisan or business man
who earns $2500, more or less, has in general invested a smaller
sum in his training than has the professional man. He may have
begun earning at fourteen and become self-supporting a few years
later. His whole education was at the expense of the state, and so
probably will be the education of his children. The occupational
requirements to be met by his family in housing, dress and other
expenditures that meet outside criticism, are also less; for in-
stance, the $324 set aside for rent in the government budget he will
be more likely to find adequate than will the family of the pro-
fessional man. For these reasons they will be able to place more
of their savings in the form of direct investment than will the other
family, but on the other hand, they may need to save more, as
both artisan and business man is in general a less competent worker
after middle age than is the man of the professions.
The Age of the Children in Relation to Form of Saving. —
Another important consideration which bears on the principles that
will govern the expenditure of the income, and especially the savings
fund, is the age of the children in a given family.
If a young married couple looks ahead at all they know that
in the early years savings must be large to make up for the heavier
expenses that are coming later. They must save as much as possible
now, so as to average well for the next ten years. The time is com-
ing when the children will require an adult's share of fdod and
shelter and clothing and recreation, although not yet able to add
to the income from their earnings. The young couple will economize
in dress, in amusements and in other ways to increase this fund for
future outgoes remembering also that there will be additions to the
operating expense because of extra service at the birth of the chil-
dren and for help in housework while the cares of the wife and
mother are the heaviest.
In this family, because of the risks they are running, life and
sickness insurance for the money-earner will come first; next, some
safe investment, perhaps in a house, on the building-and-loan plan,
or in savings-bank or government securities. It is in the early years
that investment in good furniture and household equipment is espe-
THE SAVINGS FUND AND ITS USE 179
cially to be recommended because, if wisely purchased, it may be
enjoyed for many years.
A family whose children are in their early teens is passing through
its most difficult years financially. As one thrifty manager said :
" Sometimes at the end of the year I haven't ten dollars in the bank ;
we just squeeze through and hold our breath till next pay day."
During these years it would seem impossible to set aside out of the
monthly income the recommended 11 per cent, for savings of any
kind ; the family that has been able to increase this percentage in
former years now sees the wisdom of their action. A family of five
members require at least the five rooms that have been called the
minimum for housing, and they will probably manage to get six.
The children require as much food or more than adults ; they must
be properly dressed for school, they must have their money allow-
ance and be trained to use it so as to play their part happily in their
little world, they may require no service from the paid physician,
but their teeth must be carefully looked after. The pressure at this
period of family life may be so great that the children will find
some way to add to the income by working after school and on
Saturdays. Parents must consider that they are now investing
their savings in their children, their health and general develop-
ment and their future earning ability.
When the Children Begin to Earn. — The next condition in
family life that affects savings and all other outgoes, and which
decides certain principles in expenditure, is when the young people
go out to begin to earn their own living ; this marks a critical time
for them and for their relation to the home. They may not be able
to fully support themselves and the parents must help. Or they may
be in possession of enough money, but they spend it on themselves,
in that case they are to be reminded that they have not yet reached
safety, and any failure brings them back on the family. It will
be a false kindness to give them their living at home free, and they
must hear what the government has told us all about saving —
" This money you are earning is partly owed to the future."
The Individual's Income. — The Government budget has also
a plan for the Individual's Income, which should be put in the
hands of the young earner.
180 SUCCESSFUL FAMILY LIFE ON MODERATE INCOME
THE INDIVIDUAL'S INCOME2
$15 a Week, or $65 a
Month, or $780 a Year
$17.30 a Week, or $75
a Month, or $900 a
Year
A Week
A Year
A Week
A Year
Savings
$0.25
8.00
1.50
.60
3.00
.45
.20
.75
.25
$13.00
416.00
78.00
31.20
156.00
23.40
10.40
39.00
13.00
$1.00
8.00
1.50
.60
3.50
.50
.50
1.00
.70
$52.00
416.00
78.00
31.20
182.00
26.00
26.00
52.00
36.40
Room and board
Lunches
Carfare to business
Clothing
Laundry
Church, charities, gifts
Health, recreation, education
Miscellaneous ... .
Total
15.00
780.00
17.30
899.60
.40
Balance for extra Thrift Stamps
900.00
$23.08 a Week, or
$100 a Month, or
$1,200 a Year
$34.60 a Week, or
$150 a Month, or
$1,800 a Year
A Month
A Year
A Month
A Year
Savings
$12.00
1.00
40.00
8.00
2.60
16.75
3.25
4.40
8.00
4.00
$144.00
12.00
480.00
96.00
31.20
201.00
39.00
52.80
96.00
48.00
$30.00
4.00
45.00
11.00
2.60
25.00
4.00
10.00
12.00
6.40
$360.00
48.00
540.00
132.00
31.20
300.00
48.00
120.00
144.00
76.80
Federal income tax
Room and board
Lunches
Carfare to business
Clothing
Laundry
Church, charities, gifts
Health, recreation, education
Miscellaneous
Total
100.00
1,200.00
150.00
1,800.00
These estimates were made in 1919. They may not fit a given
case, but this budget, like the family budget, offers an excellent
basis for comparison.
The Uncertain Income. — It is often claimed that on an uncer-
tain or varying income it is impossible to set aside a definite sum
for saving. On the contrary, planning and forethought is more
necessary in this case, since the variable income tempts a family
*"How Other People Get Ahead." Savings Division, U. S. Treasury
Dept. Government Printing Office, Washington.
THE SAVINGS FUND AND ITS USE 181
to drift. For safety, the lowest income received during a term of
years may be selected, or an average over those years as a basis for
planning savings. The requirements for reporting the income for
government tax has had a wholesome effect on the family which has
never before known its financial standing.
QUESTIONS
1. Give illustrations of where savings for investment may be unwise.
2. Give both sides of the argument often heard: "We must live up to
our meansi or beyond in order to meet the expectations of business
acquaintances and to give the impression that we are prospering. If
we do not seem to be successful we may not be trusted or advanced."
Is this true worldly wisdom?
3. " Save first." Is this principle used in buying a house by monthly pay-
ments through a building and loan association? In the case of a
young couple struggling to buy housefurnishings for the new home?
4. Suppose the " bread-winner " in some family you know well were to
be taken away, how much net savings and property are available to
care for the family? What annual income could they secure from it
and from wages possibly earned by other members? Is their scheme
of living rational in view of this possibility? What do you suggest?
5. " When I was just starting my savings, I carried heavy life insurance,
but as my savings grew I decreased my life insurance." Is that a
wise plan?
6. What is the relation of children to the need and possibility of savings
in some definite family situation that you know? At what age are
the children the heaviest financial liability? When will they begin
to earn? When to be fully self-supporting? Can the parents reason-
ably anticipate being cared for in old age? Or do you think all parents
should prepare to care for themselves in old age?
7. In your community what savings institutions are there — for people of
the smallest means, for those with larger? Show how the following
may serve the purpose of savings institutions: life insurance com-
panies; securities; building and loan associations; real estate; real
estate mortgagee.
8. Suppose a committee were formed by a local women's club to promote
savings in your community: what would you do about a school sav-
ings system; publicity for Postal Savings and for Government Savings;
industrial savings in shops and stores ; credit unions ?
9. Suppose a family expects to inherit property, should that expectation
make unnecessary the budgeting of the income? Should it affect the
savings fund?
CHAPTER XVI
SPENDING THE ADVANCEMENT FUND
ALWAYS at the end of our list, and promising to reward our
economies, is that department of the budget to which is consigned
all that is left after necessities are met, the fund which has been
called advancement, the one on whose items we are to exercise our
choice to some extent. According to accepted home economics
nomenclature advancement includes the last three headings given in
the Government Budget:
1. Health, Becreation, Education.
2. Church, Charities.
3. Personal and Miscellaneous.
Divisions of the Advancement Fund. — If we have been op-
pressed by the iron limitations of the necessities of life, here is
our breathing space. Here, to some extent, we are to do as we will.
And the sum allowed in the government budget is a goodly one, or
it seems such until we come to spend it, $456, nearly one-fifth of
the $2400 income, or approximately one hundred dollars apiece for
this family of five. The actual size of the sum set aside for advance-
ment is perhaps less important than that the line has been drawn
which separates it from the minimum outgo which must provide
necessities, comfort, and decency. Up to this point there has
been little scope for choice for there must be adequate food and decent
shelter and clothing for at least occupational needs.
The items that make up advancement, however, may be discussed
and compared with each other. Shall it be greater comfort in the
home, more sizable rooms, a better street to live on, more becoming
clothes, help to a neighbor in distress, greater security for the
future through life insurance or savings banks, some extra training,
as in music for one of the children, a theatre ticket for father
and mother, new curtains for the parlor, or time and money spent
in forwarding some public enterprise? All are desirable, but
choice must be made.
182
SPENDING THE ADVANCEMENT FUND 183
Health the Great Essential. — So important is health as a means
to earning or enjoying, that if we may judge from the few reports
at hand made by the Labor Statistics Bureau, families pay out for
doctor, dentist and medicine in direct proportion to the size of
income; that is, all they can. The single man and woman in the
government employ was found to pay on the average $32 and $43
a year, respectively, for this purpose. As said in Chapter VII, the
burden for maintaining health is a very heavy one on all but the
rich, who can afford it, and the very poor, who are given medical
services free. It is agreed that much more must be done for the
moderate income family in this regard than is now done and as
an extension of the free public health service.
In the family great emphasis must be placed on the personal
care of health, as the cleaning of the teeth, proper dress and exercise,
for much illness is preventable by simple means. Note the principle
that was introduced in the Bondy budget, Chapter XIII, of putting
care of illness in the same division with pleasure. By this plan
preventable sickness is punished by taking the doctor's bill out of
the fund set aside for pleasure and recreation ! Thus, the child who
overeats, the man who overworks, those who gulp their dinner or
neglect their teeth, find their punishment in seeing the money for
doctor and dentist paid out of what has been assigned for their
dearest pleasures.
With the exception of this item of health, which the majority
of families would rank among the necessities, the spending of the
sum which we have put under advancement, will be most intimately
connected with individual development and expression. The method
of making their choice is important to consider because it is the
expression of the family tastes, standards, and ideals.
The Open Forum on Other Needs. — In the whole business of
home-making there is perhaps nothing more important than the
open discussion of comparative values of that for which the family
spends its money. These questions are not theoretical, they are not
out of a book or proposed as part of a schedule of social economy.
They are imminent and pressing on the very people who discuss
them ; they range between the desirability of ice cream for Sunday
dinner and the price of music lessons; they compare a new set of
furniture with a week's stay at a world exposition. The result
184 SUCCESSFUL FAMILY LIFE ON MODERATE INCOME
is a constant striving to get things of first rank into the front row
and to retire those of secondary rank to the back seats. Shall $60
be spent for wedding cards when the daughter is married? Oh,
poignant question ! Shall they buy a phonograph on the install-
ment plan? Do georgette waists belong in the clothes budget of
a girl earning $15 a week? No " primer of logic/' no " manual for
teaching morals to the young " can equal the training that may
come through such discussions if led by parents who have good
standards and who have not forgotten their own youth.
The Chancellor of the British Exchequer must discuss with the
other members of the Cabinet whether the income tax and the liquor
tax shall be used for the building of a dreadnought or for harbor
improvements, or whether by calling on the contingent fund both
needs shall be met. Just as important from the family point of
view, and only to be decided in a committee of the whole, is whether
Mary shall be allowed to visit her cousins in the next town and
have the new gown required for the occasion, or John go with the
boys on that fishing trip. Such decisions call for sympathy with
each other's need, for family helpfulness, as who will do the home
work of the member who goes forth, or can a cheaper outing be
devised so that both may go ? Can Mary make the dress and John
cut his own fishing pole in the woods ?
Children have a natural good sense that should be more used
than it is in this branch of education. A little visitor remarked,
" I like sugar on my oatmeal, and cream, too, the thick kind/' But
he got on very well with milk when his your entertainers owned
their own liking for the "thick kind." "But cream's gone up,
mother says, and she gives us the money for Thrift Stamps. We
just can't have both, for that would grab into the summer money."
And when the plans for that summer trip are enlarged on,
Mr. Greedy wishes that his family could swap cream for mountains.
The children of a certain family so ardently desired to live in
a larger house, whose rental was beyond the prescribed fifth of
the income, that they volunteered to divide among themselves all
house service except the laundry work; and they performed their
tasks without complaint. There was as their constant reward space
and beauty and guest rooms for dear friends.
"I want a college education," says the boy. Is he willing to
SPENDING THE ADVANCEMENT FUND 185
work summers, to go without high-priced amusements, to take care
of his clothes in order to extend their life ? Or does he say vaguely,
" I'd rather economize some other way " ? But where ?
Honesty in the Family Life. — The right use of money is an
essential part of honesty, whose cultivation is hy no means unneces-
sary in the modern family. Courage, the high heart, liberty of
spirit are not to be attained by people who are habitually in debt,
who grasp at joys they have no money to pay for. A life of subter-
fuge and dodging in money matters is often seen to undermine
the moral nature, and perhaps nothing so hardens the heart and
dulls the conscience as does the habit of living beyond the income.
" The world owes you a living," " One must live up to one's stand-
ards," are mischievous phrases founded in dishonesty and false
pride. There is nothing, on the other hand, that gives such dignity
to individual and family life as a determination to keep solvent
and to gather even a small surplus for emergencies.
That there is a relation between honesty as taught in the home
and honesty in public life is a subject that might well engage the
attention of statesmen as well as parents. The amount of embezzle-
ment in this country is starting, for 1917, $31,000,000 is reported
as lost to bonding companies alone. How much of this comes from
the habit, begun in early youth, of taking what we want rather than
what we can afford? The tendency to it is common enough in
childhood and wholly natural, for the child cannot earn his keep;
whether this tendency is to become a habit depends on the
practice and attitude of the family, and the standards upheld in
their conversation.
A man said : " One of the memories that somehow has stuck
in my mind is of seeing my mother, when I was a tiny boy, remedy
a mistake in the grocer's account by which she was the loser by $1.10.
I remember exactly the sum." What if he had heard instead the
sly maxim : " Let him look out for himself ! " The same man
remembers that once his father brought home a basket of wonderful
hothouse nectarines, the gift of a man with whom an important
business deal was pending. Should the gift have been accepted?
The discussion of this question, in which the older children were
encouraged to take part, brought to them an understanding of graft
in some of its subtlest forms in the business world.
186 SUCCESSFUL FAMILY LIFE ON MODERATE INCOME
For Children the Budget Must Be Visualized.— Only the
experienced or elderly economist is content to know that the account
in the savings bank is growing; for the majority of the family the
savings must be expressed in actual tilings, so that their comparative
desirability may be openly discussed.
For instance, if the little boy has helped father save a $5 plumb-
ing bill, the sum ought not to be swallowed up in the general sav-
ings fund. That $5 bill is an individual thing with a history
of its own and the boy helper has a vote as to its disposal. Its
many possible uses with all the lessons they -bear as to com-
parative values are apt to furnish rich topics of conversation, and
when its final use is chosen retrospect may still add to the ripening
judgment of the child. The baseball suit bought with its help may
not turn out to be the thing he wanted most of all.
In short, the child must always be shown the reverse side of
the coin and the reward for a sacrifice must not be too long delayed.
Let the money that another family uses for the movies be set aside
in the form of visible nickels and dimes to pay for tickets to a
great Shakespearean play the next month, or for a Saturday outing,
and let that Saturday be this week rather than next ! It has been
found that money is more easily diverted from the said " movies "
to a fund that is to purchase the properties for an Easter Punch
and Judy show if Easter be very near at hand.
Three Rules for Success. — What are some of the rules that
successful families have evolved?
1st. Never live up to your income and never borrow. How like
is this to our modern " saving comes first " !
2nd. Set aside weekly or monthly what will be needed to build
up the sum agreed on for the larger aims and live on the rest. It
may be life insurance or some form of investment for the children
or buying your house or training for the next step in your business
or profession.
Again, how like to our new scanning of the minimum to cover
the physical demands of food, clothing and shelter, and other abso-
lutely necessary outgoes, and then putting all the rest together
so that every possible use of it, as better food, more spacious dwell-
ing, more beautiful dress, may have their " swapping value " with
SPENDING THE ADVANCEMENT FUND 187
each other and with what is needed to carry out those larger plans.
3rd. Never dribble your spendings; respect the penny and the
nickel. Save up till a really good thing can be bought, something
that will satisfy you either with its serviceableness or its beauty, or
whatever quality you bought it for.
The Dribbler. — In this third rule we see outlined an attack
on one of the bad habits too frequently seen, a disregard for small
sums, the result, of course, of a far deeper and more significant
thing, the failure to hold a desired good clearly in the imagination.
" Sixty dollars for a suit ! " said a woman to a friend no better off
than herself. " Why, Fd be scared if I had that much in hand at a
time for clothes ! "
"Of course I had to save for it," was the reply. " I go to a
store sometimes to buy just one little thing that I need. I do not
look to right or left for fear of what I might be tempted to do."
The dribbler, on the other hand, returns each time with an empty
pocket and many odd trifles; there is nothing saved for a hidden
box in which grows the $60 for a coveted season's outfit. " I never
spend the pennies I get in change/' she says. " I empty my purse
when I come from town and the pennies go into a jug for the
children ; sometimes we get out $5 at a time."
" But for what ? " " Oh, almost anything that they want ; I can't
bear to deny them." These are the children well known to teachers
who helped in the Thrift Stamp campaign, children who were always
provided with expensive candies and always able to produce a
quarter for a gift, but who would not buy Thrift Stamps.
Perhaps the reader may know a trio of rules as good as those
here quoted; then hold to them, for rules there must be to enable
the owner of an income to reach his aims whatever they may be.
Those who are making their first effort at the keeping of a budget
will run up against many snags. It cannot be claimed that the
family will be a unit even after long discussion. As Lowell said :
" The the'ry's plain enough,
It's just the human nature side that's tough."
But some compromise will be made, something learned on both sides.
The consumption of values in which the family is constantly
engaged gives the means by which the relation of the individual to
188 SUCCESSFUL FAMILY LIFE ON MODERATE INCOME
the material world may be taught, but this rich teaching plant, vital
and living because of its intimate connection with our daily needs
and decisions, can only be utilized at its full value by careful
thought on the part of the older members of the family.
Money-spending as an Educator. — Said Mrs. Van Vorst in
"The Woman Who Toils": "In America, where tradition and
family play an unimportant part, the great educator is the spending
of money." And yet we hear little of money as an educator in a
democracy, only of its power for evil.
As an instance in point, take the testimony of a cultivated
Englishwoman, who said: "My mother's income was £2000, or
$10,000, and it was spent with the greatest care in order to make
it cover all that it must cover. First, of course, was the keeping up
of our home in the country — the house, the lawn, the garden, in the
style that was expected of us; next came the payment of the many
servants and the pensioning of old ones ; next our duty to the church
and the village, a duty which we all held sacred ; then the education
of both boys and girls. To maintain our social position a few
weeks in London in the height of the season seemed necessary, and
to bring this about meant anxious consultation as to ways and
means. I assure you that there was little left to divide up among
us four children to be spent according to our individual desires.
And that is the reason why English women are badly dressed, as you
say, on what you count a large income. We haven't the money."
In such a case the great bulk of the income is disposed of accord-
ing to traditions that were firmly laid down before the holders of
this income were born, and the power of choice is applied only
to the items that make up the larger divisions of outlay already
determined. On the other hand, in a new country where public
opinion draws its roots from a shallower soil, the attitude toward
the income is more individual, and the scope offered for choice, and
therefore of course for education in comparative values, is greater.
The working girl who earns $50 a month is sometimes allowed by
her family to spend $40 on her clothing, and she has perhaps more
pin-money than has the English gentlewoman in the family with a
$10,000 income.
Family and individual spending depends on standards ; a French
family which has dessert only on Sunday and allows no cream for
the morning coffee may be educating two sons for professions. The
SPENDING THE ADVANCEMENT FUND 189
art student says : " I hear music from a gallery seat, in that way
I am saving money for a lovely copy of Delia Robia's ' Sing-
ing Boys.' "
Spending is a Fine Art. — It must be freely admitted that the
perfect management of an income of any size is an achievement;
it is, in fact, the expression of a highly disciplined life. To have
definite aims and to keep them well sorted as to their relative
importance is the great thing, but this achievement comes only after
many attempts and failures. Said old Eoger Ascham : " Experience
is the schule house of fules"; Benjamin Franklin expressed much
the same idea, adding out of the fullness of his knowledge of human
nature: "But men will learn in no other/'
Therefore, a study of costs does not lead to materialism, but is
a needed help in placing and comparing values. It has been said
that " Money is the blood of the body politic and the body domestic.
When you discover how a household or a nation spends its
money you have something tangible on which to hang guesses as
to character."
Said Francis Walker, the economist: "It matters far less for
the future greatness of a nation what is the sum of its wealth to-day
. . . than what are the habits of its people in the daily con-
sumption of that wealth."
We have yet to learn as a people that the expenditure of money
belongs to the social sciences and is a worthy subject of study;
that the whole community is affected by the way in which every
individual and family income is distributed to cover needs and
desires, and that the ethical and cultural value of the decisions
involved may outweigh the material.
The power of choice is a magic word — it offers a playground to
the imagination ; here we exchange and balance and enjoy in fancy
a thousand possible ways of spending the surplus, and end, perhaps,
by returning the treasure to the bank that it may grow large enough
to furnish forth a still finer dream.
There is Never Enough. — As in the old fairy tale, there is
never enough silver paper to cover the basket; we have always to
choose which shall be bare, the handle or the bowl. The balancing of
our desires, the one against the other, enters into the use of any grade
of income. Even the millionaire who marries his daughter to a
foreign nobleman may have to take from what he had expected to
190 SUCCESSFUL FAMILY LIFE ON MODERATE INCOME
give his other children in order to provide the dowry that is to
rebuild a ruined castle. To take from a $5000 income $500 for
Liberty Bonds may mean a readjustment that upsets many cherished
habits and customs. The fact is, there is never enough; spending
is always a question of which rather than of what. Is the com-
parison of values a simple thing? It requires judgment, whose
training must be begun in childhood and is never finished.
Emerson said : " I suppose no wise man was ever rich in the
sense of freedom to spend, because of the inundation of claims."
Needs and desires come knocking at the door like the spirit babies in
" The Blue Bird," " Let me come in. I will make you so happy ! "
This family may spend but a part of their surplus in bettering
their material state and the rest on one or two other objects listed
under Advancement; they may unfortunately need to spend it all
on health ; they may give very generously to the church ; social life
may claim most of it during certain years ; some artistic or intellec-
tual craving may swallow it all up, and even encroach on the
absolute necessaries, for, from the psychic point of view, it may not
be so easy to define the " necessities of life."
" There is always a surplus ! " says the student of social con-
ditions, who knows life on the poverty line in mean streets, under
cramping conditions. There is no one so poor that he may not
choose, else life would be unendurable. Even the tramp chooses
his freedom and irregular meals rather than hard work with civilized
bed and board. The woman who cannot exist without help from
charity funds borrows $10 to buy silver-plated handles for her
child's coffin !
But the fact remains that our progress in physical and economic
science has made it possible to draw the very important line, which
sets on the one side the minimum necessary to obtain for a family
health and working power and leaves the rest of the income, what-
ever it may be, free to an extent for that great modifier of life, the
Power of Choice. The poor can apply it in only the narrowest sense,
as in the choice of one substantial food rather than another, or in
the color and cut of a needed garment; but for the family with a
surplus the range widens to cover the cultural as well as the material
things of life.
It was a fortunate day for the home economics movement when
it took up the spending of the family money as a serious study.
SPENDING THE ADVANCEMENT FUND 191
It vitalizes all the processes of daily life and is found to have deep
roots in ethics as well as economics. Men acquire knowledge, skill,
power over material things, and yet go to pieces because of lack
of purpose. The eye must be fixed on the goal, to know what you
want is to know very soon what you cannot have, and with a clear
aim in view, miracles are wrought out of unpromising beginnings ;
new ideas of thrift are adopted, there is new stimulus to earn in
outside ways, the judgment as to value grows apace. The difference
soon appears between mere wishing for a good and that passionate
desire for it which moves to sacrifice for its sake. The best system
of ethics is mere theory until it comes to living it out, for it may
be truly said that sacrifice is the measure of devotion; we really
desire a thing only so far as we are willing to give up other
things for it.
QUESTIONS
1. The "advancement fund" has been called the fund for "higher life,"
" personal and social expenses," " sundries " or " general expense,"
"elective expenses or those of the region of choice," and recently,
"welfare expenses." Why this confusion of terms? Do you see ad-
vantages and disadvantages in any of them?
2. Many families give one-tenth, the tithe, for church and charity. If pos-
sible talk with some one who has this or some other plan of liberal
giving, as to their experience with the plan.
3. Some families are saving one-tenth. Are both this and the tithe pos-
sible to the moderate income?
4. What local philanthropic institutions are worthy of your financial sup-
port? How can you find whether some new local agency is worthy?
If there is no local investigation bureau (as in large city charitable
societies) has the individual approached for a contribution any re-
sponsibility for making an investigation himself and possibly report-
ing it publicly?
5. If you have no visiting nurse service, write to the Visiting Nurse Asso-
ciation, New York City, for information and make a plan at least as
to how such work could be started in your community.
6. "There are educational possibilities in choosing objects of expenditure
beyond the necessity line. Is this education a fact that concerns
the adults as well as children ? Illustrate.
7. Outline a plan that will insure the children of the family as well as
the adults having a voice in choosing different objects of expenditure.
8. Is it just to spend because our group does? Who is to set rational
scales of spending unless persons come out against unreasonable
customs? Can a child get this point of view by discussion in the
family circle?
9. How early can a child project ahead plans for his fund for self-develop-
ment and the start in life? Sketch the growing interest of a child in
this matter, and the varied expression it may have — gifts — from
whom; allowance — how much and when to start, etc.
CHAPTER XVII
SEVEN FAMILY HISTORIES
IN order to study family living conditions, with special regard
to the money income, it has been necessary in this book to limit
the enquiry to a certain group, the family of five living on what
has been called the moderate income of $2500, more or less, the
equivalent of what was $1400 to $2000 before the war. The fol-
lowing family histories that illustrate these conditions are of real,
not imaginary, people, only enough changes being made in their
report to conceal identity. The details of their life are presented at
some length in order to give human meaning and interest to the
financial statements, since a certain dreariness and unreality seem
to hang about the expense account or budget which consists of
figures only; to the special student they may be full of meaning,
but people in general are unable to visualize the family life as built
on these various expenditures. If we know something of the ante-
cedents and early history, the present problems and future plans,
just as we know conditions in our own family or that of a relative,
we have then the real situation in hand.
The family histories given here have been- selected because of
their similarity as to income, size of family and age of its members,
thus giving a basis of comparison for the points under consideration.
Such a selection is necessary, for a study of this kind must be
strictly limited in scope if it is to be of any value in adding to our
body of conclusions as to the working out of principles as stated
in different parts of this book.
Standards That Apply to All Families Studied:
1. Size of Family. — Four to five members, including two or
three children under fifteen years.
2. Date of Study.— 1913 to 1917.
3. Nationality. — American of at least two generations.
4. Money Income. — Fifteen hundred dollars to $1800, earned
entirely by the man.
192
SEVEN FAMILY HISTORIES
193
5. Wife's Contribution to Income.— Through buying and
management, housework, sewing, and sometimes gar-
dening; care and training of children.
6. Health and Ability. — It is understood that the parents
are of average health and ability and that the children
are expected to share the family responsibilities accord-
ing to their age.
7. Comparison. — In the following tables the grouping, head-
ings, etc., have been made as simple as possible. If
certain necessary items do not appear where expected,
it should be remembered that these histories were gath-
ered in various parts of the country, by different people,
and that the classification is not exactly the same.
The figures given are the actual outlay for the preceding
year and it is assumed that they will hold for the
following year, thus furnishing a true budget. In
some cases the expense account was kept for the entire
year, in others an estimate was made on a three
months' account.
No attempt has been made to bring the histories up to date, as
far as prices are concerned, for the reason that it is uncertain what
prices will hold in the future. They must stand for thejr value
in adjustment of proportions in the expenditure and for their
human interest.
The Need of Records of Family Budgets. — It is very im-
portant that we should have on record many household expense
accounts and budgets on the moderate income level, and indeed
on all levels, covering various conditions and requirements, includ-
ing the standard of living and the experience of families in meeting
it. Unfortunately, no such body of classified information exists.
We do not know enough of household finance as actually practiced
in the moderate income household to serve as a basis for any system
| of averages that will be more than suggestive. The only method
[possible at present is the intensive study of a few budgets, the
| method which is applied in this chapter.
Subsistence Incomes and Our Knowledge of Them. — The
I reason for this scarcity of material as to the middle-class income
is seen when we consider how we have come by our comparatively
I full information regarding incomes which are nearer the subsistence
13
194 SUCCESSFUL FAMILY LIFE ON MODERATE INCOME
level. Thousands of pre-war family budgets under $1200 have
been collected; how has it been done? Chiefly at the instance of
public officials concerned with the wage problem and of officers
of charitable societies concerned with families that are apt to fall
into the dependent class in case of misfortune. Those who receive
public aid must answer questions as to their earnings and their
spendings, just as the charity patient in a hospital must allow the
medical student to accompany the visiting physician and learn from
his case. Another large group whose financial histories are on
record consists of the workingmen's families whose incomes and
expenditures have been collected by the Bureau of Labor and which
appear in the valuable reports of that department. This work
has been necessary because the standard of living in such families
bears such direct relation to the wage scale and to industrial con-
ditions in general that it must receive the most careful study.
The Moderate Income Less Known, — But valuable as are
these records of -the subsistence income, they throw little light on
the problems of families living on the "moderate" income, those
that possess several hundred dollars beyond the subsistence line,
on the spending of which they can exercise more or less intelligent
choice. They are independent of public help and are thus able to
guard their affairs from the eyes of strangers, and they see no reason
why they should hand over their household accounts to persons who
call themselves students of social conditions. An English econo-
mist reports that when he asked for such data he met "pained
surprise/' and his request was called "inquisitorial"; he was
given to understand that rack and thumb screw would not elicit
information so "purely personal" to the owner of the income
in question.
The True Value of Budgets. — It is a question of great impor-
tance to this branch of home economics study to persuade the
family group to look upon their expenditure from a broader point
of view and to be willing to furnish the results of their experience
in family finance in order to help build up the " theory and prac-
tice," to borrow a medical term, of money-spending in the family.
A given expenditure is proved wise or unwise only as it 'can be
shown to have given pleasure or profit as compared with what the
same money would have given spent according to another plan.
JIow, for instance, are young people in schools and colleges to be
SEVEN FAMILY HISTORIES 195
taught the principles on which wise expenditure is based ? Chiefly
by placing at their disposal many records of this kind with their
results. The financal history of a family is a very real and living
thing, if accompanied by an account of how standards were met
by a given way of dividing the income to cover needs and desires.
Such records, built around the budget, would furnish the necessary
groundwork for a social study of great value to all classes of the
community. Only as this fact comes to be realized will a sufficient
number of budgets be intrusted to students and teachers.
As yet even the most intelligent people are ignorant of the value
of a family expense account. Only recently on the breaking up of
a Scotch household a family account book, kept in the same hand
over a period of two generations, was destroyed as being of no value.
The record extended over the long lifetime of the gentlewoman who
had been the head of a large household, and had been kept with an
exactness that took note of every farthing. Such a record, including
an estimate, actual or inferable, of how far the standards of such a
family have been met, could not fail to be a valuable document.
A Plea for Budgets. — Copies of account books and budgets of
families living on incomes between $1500 and $3000 or more are
earnestly requested by the American Home Economics Association ;
address, Baltimore, Maryland. Outlines and directions for filling
them out will be furnished on application. Here is a public service
which readers of this book can render. Their importance can be
judged from the histories of families that follow :
FAMILY HISTORY No. 1, 1913
Family made up of grandmother, aged fifty-four; man, thirty-
nine ; woman, thirty-five ; boy, fifteen ; girl, fourteen.
Place of residence9 suburb of large eastern city.
Occupation of man, bank clerk in city.
Parentage, Education, Character. — Man: Born of industrious
parents of no special attainments. One year in High School. In-
telligent, strong character. Takes pleasure in carpentry — has bench
and tools; made study table, book shelf, window seat, and attends
to many repairs.
Woman: Of similar parentage. Went through High School.
Married six months after graduation. Intelligent, sensible. With
the help of grandmother does all housework except washing, much
196 SUCCESSFUL FAMILY LIFE ON MODERATE INCOME
canning and all the sewing for three women. Grandmother has
small garden.
Children: Healthy and well endowed. Have ideal home train-
ing. Boy learns use of tools with father; girl, housework with
mother ; boy cleans windows and keeps lawn, helps with garden.
Helps to Start Housekeeping. — The man had saved $800.
The woman received from her family $500. Relatives and friends
gave trousseau, linen, furniture, piano, etc.
BUDGET I
FINANCIAL REPORT— INCOME $1600.00
Rent or Equivalent
Operating
Expenses
Food
Clothing
Interest on a
$1500 mort-
gage at 7 per
cent $105.00
Fuel and
light.. $102.60
Laundry
and
clean-
ing. .. 75.00
Calculated for five
adults. Groceries
bought wholesale,
moderate use of
meat, returns from
garden counted at
cost of seed. Outlay
for food on this basis
is about $2.00 apiece
weekly
Total $527.38
This item in-
cludes suits
for two men
and mate-
rialsforthree
women.
Total. $318.82
Taxes . 90.00
Repairs . . 6.00
Water 20 00
Carfare and res-
t a u r a n t
lunches
of man 101 20
$177.60
$321.20
Recreation, Health, Church, Charity and
Sundries
Savings
(Not itemized) $127 22
Payment on house $80.00
Savings 48.00
$128.00
' Total Outlay
Rent or its equivalent (20 per cent, of income) $321.20
Operating expenses (11 per cent, of income) 177.60
33 per cent, of income) 527.38
20 per cent, of income) 318.82
8 per cent, of income) 128.00
( 8 per cent, of income) 127.00
Food
Clothing
Savings
Recreation, church, charity, health, etc.
Total .. $1600.00
SEVEN FAMILY HISTORIES 197
Family Life, Recreation, Etc. — Evenings generally spent in
reading aloud or in music, nuan plays violin, the wife and children
the piano. There is much discussion of ethical and social ques-
tions in this family.
Social Ufe is simple, being made up largely of visits and outings
with relatives living near. Children never go to the theater. Satur-
day afternoons they are apt to separate, the grandmother taking
the children to visit relatives, to the public library, or to free lectures
or concerts, while father and mother go to the city to attend some
entertainment and to take dinner together at a restaurant.
Holidays are spent together and are well planned ahead. Father
and son sometimes go fishing.
Church is regularly attended and the Sunday School lesson
studied together.
The Prospects for the Future. — Standards of living of this
family have advanced beyond that of the former generation.
Financial. — The habit of saving was begun at once at $1 a
week. Eleven years ago they began to buy a house with first pay-
ment of $900; $25 a month has been paid since; $1500 still owed.
The house has nine rooms and bath, cellar and furnace, a 25 x 40 ft.
garden. Value, $4500.
The savings are small and would be swept away by accident or
sickness, but all are healthy and the children will be able to support
themselves in a few years. They are both to go to college. If
college is free this may be accomplished df children work summers
and help in other ways.
The Future. — The prospects are bright. They have congenial
tastes, cheap and elevating pleasures. An ideal family life gives
prospect of unity in carrying out future plans.
FAMILY HISTORY No. II, 1913
Family made up of man aged thirty-five years ; woman, thirty-
seven ; three children, aged ten, eight, and one year.
Place of residence, western town of 23,000 inhabitants.
Occupation of man, cashier in business house; an eight-and-a-
half -hour day.
198 SUCCESSFUL FAMILY LIFE ON MODERATE INCOME
Parentage, Education, and Character. — Man of well-to-do
farmer stock; parents own 260 acres of fine land; went to school
winters and worked summers ; energetic, public spirited. Attended
Normal School and was a teacher when he married.
Woman similar parentage ; public school to seventeen years, good
abilities, industrious, cheerful, contented, does all housework and
sewing (some help since birth of last child), very careful of health
of family.
Children show good parts; boy of eight learning use of tools
with father, girl of ten has done well with piano lessons; they
attend an excellent public school.
Helps to Start. — The young people lived the first year after
marriage with man's parents, who gave financial aid also in the
second year, when man went to a business college, so that he might
change his occupation.
BUDGET II
FINANCIAL REPORT— INCOME $1620.00
Rent or Equivalent
Operating
Expenses
Food
Clothing
Interest on a
$1500 mort-
gage $106 00
Fuel.. . $40.00
Light... 22.00
Furnish-
ings.. 95.00
Service.. 110.00
Tele-
phone 15.00
Total $282.00
Cereals $85.00
Total $145.00
Fats 32.00
Meats . 83.00
Taxes . 76 00
Milk and cheese 47.00
Fruits and veg-
etables 49.00
Other items. .. 21.20
Repairs . 55.00
Water rent.... 18.00
Total $255.00
Total . . $317.20
Outlay for food, count-
ing the family as
three adults, is $2.00
apiece weekly
Recreation, Health, Church, Charity and
Sundries
Savings
Outings $15.00
Paid on house $370.00
Church 85 00
Life insurance . . . 91.00
Health 40.00
$461.00
Music lessons 20.00
$160.00
SEVEN FAMILY HISTORIES 199
Total Outlay
Rent or its equivalent ................ (15^ per cent, of income
Operating expenses .................. (17 per cent, of income
Food ............................... (19 per cent, of income
Clothing ............................ ( 9 per cent, of income
Recreation, health, etc ............... ( 9}^ per cent, of income) 160.00
Savings and insurance ................ (29 per cent, of income) 461.00
$255.00
282.00
317.00
145.00
Total ...................................................... $1620.00
NOTE. — An automobile is kept in this family but no mention is made of interest
on investment, upkeep or gasoline in the expense account.
Family Life, Recreation, Etc. — Public meetings invariably
attended; family much interested in town improvement. They
enjoy piano playing of girl of ten, but parents are not musical.
They own an automobile and take many rides together.
There is regular attendance at church and Sunday school.
" Our wants are not overstimulated."
Prospects for the Future. — Financial: These are excellent.
The man's salary has been raised several times and he now has an
interest in the business. He has good judgment and is capable of
intense application. They began six years ago to buy an eight-room
house on lot 40 x 160, valued at $400; still owe on it $1500. They
enjoy life, but are thrifty.
College education is planned for the children. Their aim is to
give good training and high standards to children and to leave life
insurance and some accumulated property.
COMPARISON- OF I AND II
These two family histories have so many points in common that
the importance of the one factor in which they differ is plain. That
factor is —
The Place of Residence. — It would seem probable that to attain
the essentials of family life a given income " goes farther " in the
small town than in the large city, and this assumption is so generally
made that similar positions are better paid in city than in small
town, a fact that may offset .any financial advantage that the latter
may give. There are, however, other considerations of much im-
portance from the standpoint of family life.
200 SUCCESSFUL FAMILY LIFE ON MODERATE INCOME
Rent — The rent of the city flat may be no more than that of
the house in the small town, but the space is very restricted and the
conditions for the bringing up of young children not good. In the
city or the suburbs there must be added to rent the cost of carfare
and restaurant luncheon for the man of the family and perhaps
for others. In Budget I, this amounts to $100; no similar item
appears in the financial report of No. II.
It must be remembered that living at a distance from the place
of work separates the man from his family. In the case of young
children he may be obliged to leave before they are awake and to
return after they are in bed.
Cost of Food. — The difference in the cost of food between city
and country is less than generally supposed; staple groceries cost
the same, but milk, eggs, fresh vegetables and fruits will be cheaper
in the country and there is the chance to raise vegetables in the
home garden. If milk products, fresh fruits and vegetables enter
largely into the diet, a healthful variety can be furnished there
for less money.
Intelligent selection and preparation of food are, however, more
important than the market. The two families in question spent the
same amount for each adult eater and according to the report they
were equally healthy.
Clothing is probably cheaper in a city, but better clothing may
have to be worn there to meet requirements.
The standard of living is perhaps more important than the price
of commodities, it is less exacting in the small town and this
affects the amount spent on clothing, pleasures and hospitality.
Among their neighbors family No. II was "considered to be in
easy circumstances."
Savings. — The above facts explain to some extent why the
savings in No. II are larger.
Personal and social considerations play a large part in the de-
cision where there is free choice as to residence, one family may
more easily manage conditions to which they are accustomed;
another finds great zest in new surroundings.
A family whose parents and grandparents were solid citizens in
the same small town in which they live are conscious of a support-
ing background in public opinion that does not exist for them
SEVEN FAMILY HISTORIES 201
elsewhere. The respect and regard of neighbors is to a certain
extent guaranteed by the past; it is not so much to be gained as
to be kept.
A given family living where they are well known may, for
instance, live very plainly in order to save for the future without
losing public approval ; whereas, if they live in newer surroundings
where only the externals of their life are noted, they may be tempted
to larger outlays than they ought to afford in order to make desirable
social connections.
It would seem that the most careful attention should be given
by the young couple in choosing a place of residence before making
ties that will be hard to break. What a town offers in the way
of public improvements must be taken into account and how exten-
sive and good are the courses offered in free education — whatever,
in fact, will help the income to cover the needs of the family.
FAMILY HISTORY No. Ill, 1913
Family made up of man, aged thirty-six years ; woman, thirty-
four ; and three children of seven, five, and two.
Place of Residence. — Large eastern city.
Occupation of Man. — Inspector 'of immigration; seven-and-a-
half hours work a day and three weeks vacation.
Parentage, Education, and Character. — Man: In ability this
man shows, perhaps, a reversal to his grandfather, who was a man
of unusual parts, but his father, though possessing talent, was weak
of will, squandered opportunities, was intemperate, had no regular
occupation, and was useless to his family. His mother, though
uneducated, had a fine character. The boy was obliged to leave
school at thirteen to help support the family, began as newsboy at
$6 a week, went into railroad, became brakeman, then con-
ductor. He saved and studied, and at twenty-seven took civil ser-
vice examination and stood high ; he was sent to the main office and
is called their " learned man " ; has a passion for reading, owns
five hundred choice books, bought after careful examination in
library; reads evenings and Sundays. He is credited with the re-
mark : " I call that man friend who says c Good evening and good
night * and leaves me to my books/' He is a "free thinker/' a
good talker, and " can hold his own with college men."
202 SUCCESSFUL FAMILY LIFE ON MODERATE INCOME
The man is remarkable for the determination with which he has
overcome early defects in education; he raised himself to a good
position in congenial work that gives him some leisure; he is also
fortunate in a wife that does not interfere with his form of happiness.
Woman: Comes of plain people and has little education, but in
character as interesting as is her husband, because she is working
out a successful family life under singular difficulties. She is
high-minded, tolerant, reasonable, and gets on well with neighbor?,
but has no intimates ; cooperates with her husband in maintaining a
high standard of health for the family, is a good housekeeper, and
does all housework and sewing in order to meet her husband's
desire for a large savings account which is to buy a farm. She is
devoted to her husband and helps him to the fullest enjoyment of
his pleasure in reading by going out evenings with the children,
so that the house may be quiet. Only a woman of character and
self-control could play her par(t, if she were not equal to it the
family would doubtless fall apart. She is very happy in her children.
The children: Seem to be well endowed, are obedient and well
trained, but see too little of their father and too much of the movies.
Helps to Start Housekeeping. — None.
BUDGET III
FINANCIAL REPORT— INCOME $1600.00
Rent or Equivalent
Operating
Expenses
Food
Clothing
Rent for flat of
five rooms... $216.00
Carfare of man 48.00
Fuel and
light.. $73.80
Furnish-
ings . . 16.20
Total . $347.52
$216.60
$2.23 weekly for three
adults
$264.00
$90.00
Recreation, Health, Church, Charity and
Sundries
Savings
Travel, movies, etc $ 72.00
$431.68 Used in buying a farm.
Education . 45.00
Health. . ... ... 133.20
$250.20
SEVEN FAMILY HISTORIES 203
Total Outlay
Rent or its equivalent (163^ per cent, of income) $264.00
Operating expenses ( 5% per cent, of income) 90.00
Food (22^ per cent, of income) 347.52
Clothing (13^ per cent, of income) 216.60
Recreation, health, etc (15 per cent, of income) 250.20
Savings (27 per cent, of income) 431.68
Total $1600.00
Recreation and Family Life. — The family all together make an
annual visit to the father's mother; this trip is greatly prized.
The children have a half hour's play with the father after dinner.
There is a phonograph. Social life is much restricted, but the chil-
dren will make friends in school.
There are no parties or entertainments of any kind in the house,
as this is counted a useless expense.
Prospects for the Future. — The family has one great ambition
which they will undoubtedly achieve, to buy a farm to which they
will go as soon as possible ; the savings are large, health of family
good. The plan is to make a teacher of the girl, a physician of
the boy.
The home life is not ideal, but may work out well as the man
comes to realize what his part must be in the development of his
children. Considering the great handicaps of his early life, this
man has achieved a remarkable degree of success.
FAMILY HISTORY No. IV, 1913
Family made up of man, thirty-three years; woman, thirty-one;
boy, seven; girl, five.
Place of Residence. — Large eastern city.
Occupation of Man. — General manager in packing house; ten-
hour day, work uncongenial.
Parentage, Education, and Character. — Man.: His father was
unsuccessful in business; the boy had to leave school when in the
grammar grades and go to work to help the mother. He had a good
mind, loves reading and is well informed. Had no chance to get
training — became cashier in butcher shop; there met wife and
married at twenty-five. He gets little time for reading and has
no congenial friends, -as he yields to the wife's love of society and
tries to make himself agreeable to her friends.
204 SUCCESSFUL FAMILY LIFE ON MODERATE INCOME
Woman: Has little education; early became self-supporting as
clerk in a packing house ; is neat, industrious, of happy disposition.
She has spirit and vivacity and is well-meaning; loves to cook for
company, has no time for sewing, is ignorant and never reads; is
inordinately fond of amusement.
Children: The boy is well endowed. The children are little
trained, too much left to themselves and to the neighbors, are
not in good health.
Start in Life. — None.
BUDGET IV
FINANCIAL REPORT—INCOME $1650.00
Rent or Equivalent
Operating
Expenses
Food
Clothing
Rent for six
room flat,
steam heated $360.00
Light and
fuel for
cook-
ing.... $36.00
Furnish-
ings . . . 25.00
Fire in-
surance 7.00
Total ..$509.00
Man.. $75.00
Woman 150.00
Chil-
dren 100.00
Total.. $325.00
On basis of three adults
$3.27 apiece weekly
$68.50
Recreation, Health, Church, Charity and
Sundries
Savings
Entertaining . . $100.00
Premium on a $2000.00 life in-
surance policy $45.00
Vacation for woman and chil-
dren 75.00
Church 15.00
Doctor's fees 75.00
Miscellaneous . 87 50
$352.50
Total Outlay
Rent . « (223^ per cent, of income)
Operating expenses ( 4 per cent, of income)
Food (31^ per cent, of income)
Clothing (20 per cent, of income)
Recreation, etc (22 :* per cent, of income)
Savings ( 3 per cent, of income)
Total .
$360.00
68.50
509.00
325.00
352.50
45.00
.$1660.00
Recreation and Family Life. — There is no community of tastes
or ideas between husband and wife, little effort to enjoy with chil-
dren or to influence them.
SEVEN FAMILY HISTORIES 205
She has little understanding of her husband's needs, insists on
his going out with her alter a long day's work, so thlat he never has
enough sleep. She refused to live in the country, which he prefers.
She is pleasure-loving, especially enjoys card-playing, belongs to an
afternoon bridge club and both belong to club for playing "five
hundred." They go often to theater and have many guests who are
served with expensive food. They have better furniture than they
can afford, a piano which the wife cannot play and a victrola with
high-priced records. She takes children for vacations, which the
man needs far more, but cannot afford a day's idleness.
Prospects for the Future. — To the experienced eye this family
is approaching disaster.
As to Health. — The earner of the income is on a strain; long
hours of uncongenial work, constant inroads on needed sleep
because of pleasures that do not really recreate, worry as to the
future and lack of vacations are all together sapping his vitality.
His health is in danger and might give way under an attack of
disease or any extra call for effort. Both he and his wife are
reported as pale and tired looking. The children are often sick.
Happiness. — There is no real happiness in the family as they
lack community of tastes and ideals and the pleasures are badly
chosen. There is already friction between man and woman regard-
ing training of children.
Causes of Failure. — The man's plans for the family are far
superior to those of the wife, but he has yielded to a strong-willed
woman incapable of getting his point of view. He has tried, failed,
and given up in his attempt to influence her.
He was so heavily handicapped in youth by the failure of his
family to give him any help that he was unable to make the social
connections that would have brought him in touch with the kind of
woman that would have made him a congenial and helpful wife.
The Woman. — The mismating is so evidently the chief cause of
failure that it seems unfair to lay upon the wife the responsibility
that apparently belongs to her.
As the wife of a laboring man, her ignorance would have brought
no friction and her energy would of necessity have been directed
to adding to the income by hard work for the family itself, rather
than in dissipating the money in social pleasures.
Her blindness as to the future and her determination to have
206 SUCCESSFUL FAMILY LIFE ON MODERATE INCOME
diversion at any cost has made them live beyond their means and
rendered saving impossible. There is nothing to fall back on but
a small life insurance and the man dare not take the necessary time
off to find more congenial work.
The Family History Illustrates. — 1. Importance of help from
preceding generation, in furnishing money for training, proper
standards and social connections.
2. Importance of saving from the first to establish future posi-
tion and conditions. Only the bank account can give ease of mind
regarding sickness and accident or the need for change of work.
COMPARISON OF NOS. Ill AND IV
Both family histories give proof of the difficulties under which
a family struggles when no help comes from a former generation.
Both men are naturally well endowed ; the father in both cases
failed to support the family, so that the sons had to leave school
early and go to work to help support younger brothers and sisters.
Both were of studious habit and by reading at night became well
informed men "able to hold their own with college men." But
they could not enter a profession which would have been more con-
genial than business, nor were they able to manage the social affilia-
tions which would have brought them in touch with women who
were their equals in education and ambition.
This resulted in the one case in a great limitation of common
interest of husband and wife, although a working compromise is
effected ; while in the other case there was such a failure to choose
the right woman as will probably wreck the family prospects.
FAMILY HISTORY No. V, 1913
FamUly made up of man aged forty; woman, forty; children,
sixteen twelve, ten and eight years.
Place of Residence. — On farm in southern state.
Occupation of Man. — Farmer.
Parentage, Education, and Character. — Man: Comes of
farmer stock; parents poor as to accumulation of property; he
is industrious, went to school winters, but barely learned to read
and write. At twenty-one left home and worked as farm hand,
saved, and had when married enough for tools, stock and house-
hold furniture, took an eighty-seven-acre farm on $1000 mortgage
SEVEN FAMILY HISTORIES 207
which was paid up iu eight years. He is a man of character, a
leader in his community, deacon in the church, choir leader, and
superintendent in the Sunday School.
Woman: She is of similar inheritance and education, is one
of nine children, a devoted wife and mother, her judgment much
relied on by her husband. She does, with help of her two daughters,
ten and eight years, all housework and sewing, makes butter, tends
poultry ; does some sewing for neighbors which is paid for in labor.
Children: All normal. Boy of sixteen is working on a neigh-
bor's farm, other three go to school winters. Boy of twelve " does
the work of a man " in summer.
Helps to Start. — None.
Recreation and Family Life. — Social life centers round the
church as has that of their forbears for generations ; the family are
devout Baptists. Two weeks in the year there are revival services.
In July and August there are picnics and barbecues ; in winter,
husking and quilting bees, political meetings, and hunting. Christ-
mas is always celebrated. The children go everywhere with their
parents, and the possession of a buggy and phaeton shows that the
family go about a good deal. The woman is a member of the Bible
Class and of the Missionary Union.
Home life is very happy, as the pair are congenial and deeply
attached to their children and give them much religious and other
training. Children are to be further educated in town school.
Prospects for the Future. — Habits of industry and thrift are
established, health of family is excellent, so that the future looks
bright. They are in affectionate accord and will doubtless work
out their plans together.
Since paying for the farm, their savings have been used to buy
a house in the outskirts of a town fifteen miles away and in this
house they are planning to live for the better education and social
advantages for the children. In this case the farm would be leased ;
what would be the man's occupation for the support of the family
is not stated.
BUDGET V
FINANCIAL EEPOET
Income $1727, of which $800 is in Cash
This report will be lacking in many details since fanners have
rarely used any schedule by which they can easily separate salable
208 SUCCESSFUL FAMILY LIFE ON MODERATE INCOME
products from those used by the family, or make a full accounting
for the value of labor performed by different members of the family.
The main facts are that the eighty-seven-acre farm bought
seventeen years ago is now valued at $3000, that accumulated stock,
implements, etc., have added $1175, which with the town house
bought at $2500 makes property equal $6675.
Income (estimated value of farm products) .... $1,787.00
Earned by man by outside work 50.00
$1,837.00
From this must be deducted $110.00, the expenses
of fertilizer, fire insurance and tools 110.00
$1,727.00
But no deduction is made for labor, taxes or depreciation. Eight
hundred dollars of this $1727 has been realized in cash by sale
of products. The rest of the produce is used as food for family
and stock and to trade for labor at cotton-picking time.
The income from the farm is in reality much more than $1727,
as it includes rent for the house, fuel cut in winter on wood lot,
use of vehicles for pleasure, upkeep of house and implements from
skill of farmer in mending. If but one-third the surplus products
are used for food of family the sum for food would amount to
over $300.
Here is economic and social success. Health, contentment, up-
right living, a good-sized family to be given a better start than
parents had, and it is done by an uneducated couple on a medium-
sized farm. Could they achieve this degree of success in any
other occupation?
FAMILY HISTOKY No. VI, 1916
Family made up of man aged thirty ; woman, twenty-seven ; chil-
dren, six, four and two years.
Place of Residence. — Village in a northern state.
Occupation of Man. — Skilled mechanic.
Parentage, Education, and Character. — Man: Of industrious
and capable farmer stock ; one year high school.
Woman: Of educated and industrious parents. High school
and normal college. Was a teacher when married. Does nearly
all housework and sewing. Has help of a schoolgirl mornings and
SEVEN FAMILY HISTORIES
209
nights. A devoted and intelligent mother, giving much thought
and time to the training of the children.
Children: Healthy and well-endowed. They are well-trained
and will be given all the educational advantages they will take.
Helps to Start Housekeeping. — An inheritance of $2000 out at
interest. Clothing and house-furnishings.
BUDGET VI
FINANCIAL REPORT— INCOME $1287.77
Rent or Equivalent
Operating
Expenses
Food
Clothing
The house is partly
$332.38 Fuel and
owned and the above Service
light..
49.29
of Laundry 36.31
sum is made up
taxes, interest on the Furnish-
mortgage, insurance
and repairs
Total $299.23
$47.03 Being $1.91 per week
per adult eater
Total.. $120.00
ings.. 34.11
$166.74
Recreation, Church, Health, Charity
and Sundries
Savings
Church and Men's Club . . .
Books and newspapers
Recreation 24.07
Doctor and dentist
$64.40 Life and accident insurance $67.13
17.87 Invested in stock of firm for
which the man works 157.10
17.90 Paid debt of preceding year.. 20.95
$124.24
$245.18
Total Outlay
Rent or equivalent (25 per cent, of income)
Operating expenses (123^ per cent, of income)
Food (23 per cent, of income)
Clothing ( 9 per cent, of income)
Recreation, health ( 9^ per cent, of income)
(19 per cent, of income)
$332.38
166.74
299.23
120.00
124.24
245.18
Total $1287.77
In 1918 the budget of this family shows that $800.00 has been added to
the yearly income. Expenses remain about the same except that $70.00 has
been added to food, $70.00 to education and $100.00 to doctor and dentist
beyond the 1916 outlay. $629.00 was added to saving and insurance.
Family Life, Recreation, Advancement. — Social Life cen-
ters around church and relatives who live near. They are contented
and happy, meeting social and other demands of a small town where
family has lived for three generations.
Financial outlook good; savings large and advance in income
certain in the near future.
14
210 SUCCESSFUL FAMILY LIFE ON MODERATE INCOME
This budget illustrates how easily well-being is attained if :
1. A good start in life is given.
2. Habits of thrift practiced from the first.
3. The standard of living is one established by many other fami-
lies in the community of like income or less, so that it is met
with ease.
FAMILY HISTORY No. VII, 1916
Family made up of man aged fifty ; woman, forty-five ; two boys,
thirteen and eleven years.
Place of Residence. — Large eastern city.
Occupation of Man. — Teacher.
Parentage, Education, and Character. — Man: Of industrious
parents of small means. Determined on a college education, he in
part worked his way through for Ph.D. degree, borrowing $800.
Of excellent attainments and character.
Woman: Ancestors were farmers for generations, parents of
good social standing, but little money. They gave her a college
education and she was teaching in a college when married, she has
good health and is exceptionally cheerful and sensible, devoted to
the family interests and a true companion to husband and sons,
does all housework except washing (no sewing).
Children: Well endowed physically and mentally. Training
excellent; are to be well educated. They help with the housework
and are soon to work summers.
Start in Life. — Wife's savings furnished house.
BUDGET VII
FINANCIAL REPORT— INCOME $1600.00
Rent or Equivalent
Operating Expenses
Food
Clothing
Interest on
mortgage. . .$130.00
Taxes 75.00
Repairs 50.00
Fuel for heat
and gas for
cooking $41.10
Electricity for
light and iron 23.32
House furnish-
ing 36.56
Wet wash 31.00
Ice 6.50
Total... $491.24
Being $2.40 per
week per
adult eater
Father $41.00
Mother 39.24
Boy. - 39.48
Boy... 36.18
$155.90
Fire insurance. 5.00
Water tax 9.00
$269.00
Insurance on
furniture 3.00
$141.48
SEVEN FAMILY HISTORIES 211
Recreation, Health, Church, Charity
and Sundries
Savings
Amusements $ 20.00 Total $375.85
Reading 11.20
Church 20.00
Allowance to boys 33.80
Doctor 22.00
Dentist 32.00
Ophthalmologist 12.55
Medicines 14.98
$166.53
Total Outlay
Rent or equivalent (17 per cent, of income) $269.00
Operating expenses ( 8^ per cent, of income) 141.48
Food (31 per cent, of income 491.24
Clothing (10 per cent, of income 155.90
Recreation, health, etc (10^ per cent, of income 166.53
Savings (23 per cent, of income 375.00
Total $1600.00
Family Life, Recreation, Advancement. — Social life has close
connection with church activities. In the summer there are always
excursions to visit relatives.
They attend free concerts and lectures and make constant uise
of the free library. All the family are great readers.
The family life is congenial and affectionate.
Prospects for the Future. — The financial margin is small but
all are healthy and hopeful. Savings are large now. They are
buying their house as being a good investment, and will then apply
savings to payment of the $800 debt.
The budget gives a good illustration of the handicap of debt.
Several times in the twenty years since marriage they have been
free, but a bad investment or some accident has plunged them in
again. Now deliverance is near, but it is late to begin saving for
old age. There has been a good deal of strain and aging in this
process, which would have discouraged people of less character
and poorer mental resources.
QUESTIONS
1. Make a study of the history of your own family as. to educational and
other factors ; go back to your grandfathers' families for all the con-
trolling conditions that you can discover, work out in detail as sug-
gested in this chapter and apply to your parents' family.
212 SUCCESSFUL FAMILY LIFE ON MODERATE INCOME
2. Make a similar study of some family not your own.
3. Make a study of the factor of aid given by a preceding generation for
the start in life by asking five friends to secure such facts regarding
their own or others' families and also their judgment as to the effect
of the amount of help granted or withheld. Draw such conclusions
as you can.
4. Ask members of a woman's club to contrast the plans they have for
their own children's education and start in life with what their own
parents had for their children. Are the differences due to differences
in general economic conditions or to what other factors?
5. In Budget III, what is your opinion of the wisdom of such sacrifice on
the part of the wife and mother ? Do you see any other way in which
she could have made the home happy and successful?
6. Will you not add to the slender body of statistics on the subject of
money spending by sending in one family expense account of a past
year or an estimated budget of a year to come, to the American Home
Economics Association, Baltimore, Md.?
7. Suggest how the women of these different families could have met their
problem better than they did.
CHAPTER XVIII
THE STANDARD OF LIVING
FOOD, shelter and clothing, that masterful trio under which
we group the absolute needs of our material life, hold the whip
over us; from otir labor each must be satisfied, else labor itself
fails. But when we have set aside out of our income the minimum
for comfortable existence, when we are warmed and clothed and
fed and safe from the storm, may we then begin to divide up the
rest of our money as we will? That godlike thing, the Power of
Choice, which has been our goal, have we reached it? No, there
is another compelling power which also holds the whip, and it may
be the most stinging whip of all. We call it the Standard of Living.
The Standard of Living Defined. — What does the term mean ?
It is everywhere different and always changing. It is " what is
expected of us " and it records community decisions for the time
being as to what is obligatory on its members according to their
station and ability. Tradition forms customs, custom makes the
rule of life ; we seem to be free, and yet are not.
As we study the matter more closely, we see that the different
groups to which different standards apply are divided from each
other for the most part by income lines, and it would seem that
the lower we descend in the scale of living, the more imperative
become the requirements on the individual and the family as set
by the narrowing lines of their own group. Those who have made
a study of primitive peoples find that their every act is decided by
traditions that go back countless generations; they are the slaves
of ancient usage, their bathing, the cutting of the hair, eating, drink-
ing, and fasting must not vary from inherited custom.1 Civilized
man is only a little more free, but that little is the basis of
all advance.
Our Standard Compels Us. — Whatever our standard, whether
we have chosen it or it has been forced upon us, we must reckon with
it. It is not to be defied without counting the cost. The peasant
1 Folk Ways, by W. G. Simmer.
213
214 SUCCESSFUL FAMILY LIFE ON MODERATE INCOME
woman who descends the gang plank at Ellis Island with a shawl
over her head has come from a place where all women of her class
wear some such covering or go bareheaded, but her relatives who
landed five years ago soon force her to reach into her savings to buy
a hat. Her chestful of solid linen, her handsome silver-trimmed
peasant costume inherited from her mother and grandmother,
avail her nothing here, although they were necessary to her standing
among her own people in the land she has left.
Comparison with Living in Foreign Countries. — This illus-
trates how in any discussion of the cost of living in foreign coun-
tries compared with our own, the difference in prevailing standards
ds the factor of greatest importance. Living, we say, is cheaper in
Paris than in New York, but this is true only if the Paris standard
is adopted. In the furnished apartment in a foreign city which
the American family has rented, there is no bath, the rooms are
small *and have scant floor covering; it is reached from a narrow
street and there are long stairs to climb, but people whom they
meet sociallv are living in a similar way, and they are therefore
content. Before the war thousands of English families were to be
found living in Continental cities, not only because of the cheaper
schooling, music and other cultural opportunities which these cities
offered, but because they could meet the scale of living of people in
their own intellectual and social rank on an income which would
not avail for that purpose in England.
" The American lady will buy strawberries ? " said the Alsatian
landlady ; " very well, they are not dear. They used to be dear, and
poor people looked on them as luxuries ; so we still do, for no reason
at all. If I were to buy strawberries and carry them in my basket,
my little grandson who always runs to meet me would spread the
news and all the family and neighbors would call me an extrava-
gant woman."
Why is the French peasant thrifty ? Why are the savings banks
in Holland full? Because the community upholds the citizen in
this habit and has made, as we are trying to do in America, " saving,
not spending, a badge of honor." Community standards are more
important to the budget than is the price of flour.
Keeping Up Appearances. — To " keep up appearances " is the
pathetic phrase that covers the effort to retain a social position
THE STANDARD OF LIVING 215
which is beyond ones means. A novelist who deals with European
life depicts the sordid economies of a noble Italian family who
half starve on vegetables in their palace in order to afford the
smart pair of horses in public and a coachman on the box of a new
victoria, and the compulsion in this case is exactly the same as that
which moved the East Side woman to say to the charity visitor,
"Fve heard of women who could go out on the street without a
clean dress, but / can't/'
It is this Standard of Living, varying as it does for every
decade, which explains how life was accepted with some degree of
contentment in pioneer times in our country for the mass of people
who lived on farms or in small villages, where one fire sufficed
in a house in winter, and the family took turns bathing in a
washtub in the kitchen, where the bedrooms were icy cold and the
sanitary conveniences of the most primitive kind, water being often
brought in pails from a distance ; where a long walk to school was
a matter of course — where food for even the well-to-do was monoto-
nous, and amusements few. But others had the same privations !
These farm women, we are told, had often but one extra dress hang-
ing in the closet at a time, but their neighbors were no better off.
It was this same moral support from united action which helped
during the war in the economies which all had to share. To go
without new clothes was easy since others did also. It is false
that one generation is more heroic than another in these matters;
standards are set we know not how; no question is more complex
than that of custom or fashion.
The Standard of Living and the Family of Moderate
Income. — In all countries at present the pressure is greatest on the
people of good standards, living on small salaries or fixed incomes.
They are generally city dwellers and they stand as consumers help-
less between the laborers 'on the one hand, who can tie up industry
if their wage is not increased, and on the other, the business men
who can "hand on" the prices that they themselves must pay.
It has been truly said : " The laborer may live as cheaply as he
must, the farmer can reduce his personal expenditure to equal his
income, but the salaried worker must live up to certain conventions
of dress and surroundings at peril of forfeiting the chance to
earn a living/'
216 SUCCESSFUL FAMILY LIFE ON MODERATE INCOME
This class come in contact with the well-to-do, even the rich.
The teacher, the clerk, and the minister do not live on the same street
with the artisan and yet their income may be less than his. To live
up to what is " fitting " is to be comfortable, to fall below is to
writhe under criticism.
To meet these outside requirements economies are practiced
on what does not meet the public eye, the homie knows them all. A
study of household budgets reveals the fact that after absolute
necessities are met the money is spent on dress, the externals of
the house, and public recreation; in short, what meets the public
eye; for instance, when the house is presentable, the dress may be
plain, but lacking a good home to which to invite her friends the
working girl spends on her dress much more than the 15 per cent,
of her income that has been set as the ideal proportion. " I must
show somehow what I am," said a girl to a would-be adviser ; " you
have your handsome home ; you could dress in a bag."
First Understand It. — How much is our moderate income
family to yield to this Standard of Living which presses hard on the
heels of the three primal needs — food, shelter and clothing ? What
will avert the whip it holds over us ?
It is first of all necessary to understand it and to accept the
fact that it is a real force, to remember that it always has been
and always will be the habit of society to measure your success or
failure by your ability to live up to certain accepted standards.
Moreover these standards, although sometimes meaningless tyranny,
may be a great power for good ; custom, habit, tradition are civiliz-
ing agents, " much of our conscience is in other people's keeping."
Witness the tendency to deterioration in the case of men living
in the wilds far removed from social restraints. The missionary,
David Livingston, testified to the importance of keeping up the
requirements of civilized life by all small observances ; for instance,
he shaved every morning in those long years in which he never saw
a white man. Desires must always be ahead of achievement in
order to spur ambition, only by discontent with what we have does
the race advance, and it is in the power of society to m£ke us dis-
contented with a low achievement.
Two Ways of Progress. — But how are we to deal with these
community standards so that they may exert their civilizing power
THE STANDARD OF LIVING 217
and yet not tyrannize over our individuality ? To what extent we
yield, to what extent we defy or avoid is the great test of men and
women. Success along this line seems to depend on two things:
1st. A clear estimate of values in life with the necessary
hardihood to endure criticism when we know that resistance of
accepted standards is wise and necessary.
2nd. The ability to obtain group action for improvement of
standards for the community.
It must be remembered that the Standard of Living which is
applied to any rank of life has been worked out by its own members
and that it fits the average ability and needs in a general way.
Therefore he who would assert his independence of requirements
as maintained in his walk of life must have a clearly denned plan
for something better, else he may as well float with the tide. Mere
wanton defiance of what expresses the opinion of the majority is
foolish and of no avail for higher uses. The man who risks his
influence by insisting on some individual dress or way of living
which is not essentially important or involving a -principle, offends
the general public and throws away his own influence, a thing of
real value, in exchange for having his own way, which may be
worth nothing at all. " The fool said, ' The wolf has wool. I need
wool. I will go forth and shear the wolf/ " and he met the fate
he deserved.
"What advice would you give to a young couple who are
starting out with high aims and a small income ? " All the maxims
of Poor Richard will be given in reply to this question, all the
methods of thrift that have been passed on from one generation
to the next, but the following reply may well engage the attention.
" Tell them to cultivate cheap pleasures and to be independent ;
they must not be influenced by what others do and say/' Noble
advice, touching the very core of the matter, but only to be carried
out by people of great natural gifts and Spartan courage, and, may
one add, a certainty that this way is the only way for them to follow.
They must read the motto over the fourth door of the eastern temple,
for the story goes that over the first door was written " Be Bold,"
and over the second door " Be Bold," and over the third door " Be
Bold," but over the fourth door, " Be Not Too Bold."
Young People and the Standard of Living. — The parents
218 SUCCESSFUL FAMILY LIFE ON MODERATE INCOME
with a moderate income may, by courage and wise use of what the
community offers, work out their own ideals of life, but how make
the children contented with what is different from the ruling stand-
ard around them?
The young are apt to be timid and snobbish for lack of experience
and achievements of their own to lean against. They must have
the good opinion of their fellows. How early it is heard " I want
to do as the other boys do, mother/' None realize better than do the
young the bracing effect of all the accessories of social life. The
boy who was taken to hear Hamlet brought away one deep impres-
sion : " Did you notice, father, what the old man said to his son
about buying good clothes to wear when he went across ? He knew
Laertes needed to feel chesty when he met those Frenchmen; a
friend of mine whose father is a lawyer told me that when he has a
big case on, he spends more time dressing than a girl — nothing
dashing, you know, but everything just perfect. Then he's sure he's
going to win." Parents must use much ingenuity to provide sources
of pleasure that shall take the place of activities and possessions
which must be denied their children. If the girl is to wear home-
made clothing, her mother must learn to design and make what
pleases her ; if home amusements are to be relied on, parents must
cultivate their own powers of entertainment and that of the children.
'Group Action for Improved Standards. — Here is where public
opinion, which we all help to make, may come to our assistance.
Custom is powerful, but not all powerful ; in its slow modification
by individuals and by outside forces lies the secret of community
advance or retrogression. Great things have been done by people
who note the character of public opinion and use its general trend
while improving the object. Thus, the local pride of a village
may be turned toward an improved water system or the maintenance
of community music. The work of women's clubs has had wide-
spread influence on public standards.
In a number of cities the Parents' League has had a great success
in helping to control the social activities of schoolboys and girls by
publishing lists of recommended plays and other amusements;
while agreement as to how many social nights a week a student
should be allowed and at what hour the dancing should stop, makes
easy the decision of the individual parent. Parents' and Teachers'
THE STANDARD OF LIVING 219
Associations that have been started in connection with the public
chools have doubtless a great future in bringing about better
ooperation between home and school and a higher public standard,
kf rs. Julia Ward Howe once said, " I foresaw that my girls would
want to do as other girls did," and she started the Saturday Morning
lub, which made serious study popular among their friends and
acquaintances. Said an intelligent and devoted mother, " We used
o think that we were bringing up our children, but we early found
hat the community was doing it and that we must bestir ourselves
o see that it was doing it well/'
A workingman gave his view of " pulling together " in the
narrower circle of relatives and friends. He said : " It is foolish
o try to get away from your relations and old friends and pretend
o be above them. You can get together and help each other out
n all kinds of ways if you live in the same neighborhood. When
my cousins and I buy houses on the instalment plan, we don't
ive out a cent for repairs; among us we have all the trades and
we work evenings for each other. But the best of it is, the children
are satisfied with what their cousins have, and that is half the battle."
An Individual Matter. — Any family or individual may well
lave aims so important, so foundational, that they must pursue
hem whether the community approves the necessary methods or
not. Non-conformity for noble ends, moreover, wins admiration.
?or instance, a family may live very plainly in a small town where
;hey are well known if the object of their economy is to care for a
needy relative or to give better opportunities of education to the
children. On the other hand, pretense gets short shrift and the
V^oman who is setting up housekeeping on $100 a month will gain
nothing in her neighbor's esteem by managing in some way to have
, half -grown girl to answer the doorbell in order to hint at a scale
f living that does not exist.
Part of the joy of life and part of its development comes from
danger and risk. To such daring ones the world becomes a great
constructive adventure. They are determined to obtain the things
>est worth while. Such people may refuse to " conform to the
ockstep of life," to allow habit and convention to dictate their
spendings and their withholdings ; they take to themselves the
noble words of Emerson :
220 SUCCESSFUL FAMILY LIFE ON MODERATE INCOME
" A man's money should not follow the direction of his neigh-
bor's money, but should represent to him the things he would
willingliest do with it. I am not one thing and my expenditures
another. My expenditure is me. That our expenditure and our
character are twain is the vice of society." Then the time has come
for revolt, and it may be found that the reasons for the standards
apparently held are quite worn out and may be upset by a little
determined opposition, and everyone is relieved when better ones are
substituted ! It is well to remember what came to Alice at the end
of her wonderland dream — " Hold your tongue ! " said the Queen,
turning purple.
"I won't! "said Alice.
" Off with her head ! " the Queen shouted at the top of her voice.
Nobody moved.
" Who cares for you ? " said Alice. " You're nothing but a pack
of cards ! "
QUESTIONS
1. What do community standards most affect, clothing, food, amusements,
kitchen outfit, parlor furnishings?
2. Do standards explain at all the attitude of the citizen soldier toward
regular army life ? Why does the professional soldier regard it more
favorably ?
3. Does legislation ever affect standards of living? Have we to-day any-
thing comparable to the sumptuary laws of an older time regarding
dress ? Does prohibition belong to this class of laws ?
4. What new standards of living were adopted among civilians in the
United States during the late war ?
6. Are young people who are brought up in wealthy homes handicapped
for married life on small incomes?
6. Are they to be encouraged to undertake life on a lower financial level
than they have been accustomed to, and under what circumstances ?
7. Who sets the standards for the children's amusements in your town?
Is there any joint consideration of such matters by parents? What
organizations might help, and how?
8. Does your community favor home or church weddings, home or church
funerals? Has the practice of funeral insurance any effect on funeral
standards in certain income groups, or do the standards require the
insurance?
9. Which is the stronger force, the one which drives a family to reach the
standard of those with higher incomes or the fear of falling back to
the standards of those with less income?
10. If some prevailing standard, as, for example, the custom of making
formal calls in a college town, becomes oppressive, how can it be
changed ?
11. It is taken for granted that the home will induct young people into the
customs of the family group, for example, those concerning honesty,
THE STANDARD OF LIVING 221
attitude toward the property of others, industry, good manners, per-
sonal cleanliness, dress, social relations ; if it fails to do this, to what
institutions shall we look for setting and transmitting standards ?
12. Are standards more important as a method of educating youth or of
controlling adult action? Does the same standard function in both
cases? Are standards chiefly to bring about conformity, or do they
make for permanent progress? What standards may be considered
basic or permanent? How about the modern feeling that one should
get all the schooling possible? How has it come about?
13. Is not a skilled workman on $30.00 a week ($1500 a year) better off
than a teacher on the same salary, that is, can he not more easily
meet the needs of his family and keep himself in condition and train-
ing for his work? Has the teacher's family any compensations?
14. Do we not in general exaggerate the amount of independent decision)
that people use in their decisions as to money-spending ? "Convention,
imitation of others and submission to the bullying of the advertiser "
is credited with the making of these decisions rather than intelli-
gence. Do you agree with this, and if so, how can the condition be
improved ?
15. Is there a better rule than the following: "Stand firm on essentials;
give way on non-essentials ? " Illustrate what are essentials and non-
essentials.
16. Is not the compulsion to uniformity too great in this country and does
it not repress, individual development? It is said, "A man may go
out in a straw hat in Paris and no one notice it; if he did it here
they would have him in a lunatic asylum before night."
CHAPTER XIX
THE SATISFACTIONS OF LIFE
THE preceding suggestions for money-spending have been for
the most part devoted to meeting bodily needs. All the grim guard-
ians of thrift should have been placated, and it is time to ask whether
the family living on this moderate income with its necessary re-
strictions are to find such joys and satisfactions as make life
worth living.
To quote a late chief of the Federal Bureau of Labor Statistics :
" Some economic theorists who do not know anything about eco-
nomic theory have held that amusement is a luxury, but it is as much
a necessity as food and clothing."
Contentment, satisfaction, even joy, make their imperative
claim before the first pay day. Of what use the divisions and sub-
divisions of the income, to what end labor and thrift, if happiness
is forever to wait on the doubtful assembling of a bank account ?
But what do we mean by amusement ? There is probably nothing
in which people differ so much as in what gives them pleasure. It
is so often taken for granted that enjoyment is a thing to be
" sought," and sought, of course, in some distant flowery field where
there is neither sowing nor reaping.
The Foundational Things. — On the contrary, unless daily life
with its development of our powers is to lay deep and broad the
groundwork of happiness, "amusements" will but thinly cover
the poverty of our emotional life. We shall be forever seeking and
never be enriched. Our moderate income family may have already
gained through their everyday life many of what President Eliot
has called "the solid satisfactions of life"; labor, health, home,
friends, a degree of success among our fellow-men. According to
their estimate of the value of these things do men strive for them.
Some take them as their right, but those of any experience or
imagination see even the modest successes of life against a dark
background where lurks cruel chance and misfortune, and they are
222
THE SATISFACTIONS OF LIFE 223
deeply thankful for a sufficiency of things needful, for the priceless
value of affection, for the opportunity to help in the development
of a child. Those who are still more far-seeing realize how few there
are who can return to the world as much as they are receiving from
it in their share of a rich civilization developed by myriad unknown
hands, or, as one modestly expressed it : " I am always afraid I shall
cost more than I come to."
We have here a question of more than superficial importance,
for it concerns what makes life worth living for this family of the
moderate income, and indeed for the great majority of our people.
Limitations Fixed by the Income. — There is a degree of satis-
faction where there is success, and the success of this family, such
as it is, is believed to be largely due to the discipline which results
from the normal conditions of life and work which are forced upon
it by its very limitations. Its members have no more innate power
of goodness than the ones above or below them in the income scale ;
they are simply placed by good fortune in conditions which they
would not have been wise enough to choose for themselves, and there
results a system which offers at least an opportunity for growth.
Success for this family is not to be reached without hard work.
They will all work, and it is well that one of the deepest satisfactions
which life gives is in work well done; nothing else will take its
place. Work is the greatest blessing in life; it is overwork under
bad conditions that maims and destroys. Thus the first and most
important factor in the development of the moderate income family
is secured in the necessity to labor together for a desired end. The
home must be served by its own members, by the father who is spurred
to his task by the knowledge that he provides the sinews of war, that
without his efforts material comforts will be lacking for those he
loves ; by the mother, who is not " supported " but who contributes
her share in working up the raw materials of life into what nourishes
body and spirit, just as surely as the plant in the sun uses the
mineral constituents of the soil to build organic foods; by the
children, who contribute not only the tremendous stimulus of their
need and helplessness, but of their labor according to their ability.
Here is a chance for comradeship, for happy and effective work
together, and this experience and discipline continued year after
year help toward normal development, and the happiness that is
224 SUCCESSFUL FAMILY LIFE ON MODERATE INCOME
gained through self-expression. As idle and aimless surroundings
never do.
Through all folklore and every form of national art we see the
background of the primitive home. The touching Irish plays and
poems are never far from the market place and the circle around
the peat fire. Padriac Colum's " Old Woman of the Road " dreams
in the mist and the cold of a little house with the shining row of
delft on the dresser and the pile of sods by the door. A simple
domestic environment seems especially favorable to the develop-
ment of little children, for homes that are full of those activities
which minister to the comfort of their inmates are near to the
simple tasks and events, the primitive experiences of the race which
children are re-living.
" I know now," said a woman in middle life, " that when I was
a child we were very poor, but we never felt poor; we were so happy,
and we still talk of the good times we had together ." For this
woman the things that are of real value shine undimmed through
the years; privations, if felt at the time, are forgotten. It would
seem certain that the childhood looked back upon most fondly is
one with a background of domestic needs and amenities, the home
served by its inmates ; and not only children but adults of healthy
mind and instincts have this same enjoyment in simple processes
by which daily life is carried along. " If you had lived in the
stony-hearted city as long as I have/' writes a woman, " you would
know what bliss it is to be sitting on a country doorstep pitting
cherries for a pie."
We speak of a subtle pervading thing which we call the home
atmosphere. It does not come down from the skies, it seems to be
made of very substantial happenings and events, the work together,
the being together, the mutual services that build up sympathy
and understanding year after year. The nearness to families of
relatives, the presence of elderly people in the home is for children
an extension of their small horizon, a growth of possessions within
safe limits ; for what is within the circle is known and trusted, what
is outside is not yet " ours." " Is he mine, my own ? " said a lonely
child with something like ecstasy, when told that a cousin was
coming to visit.
Pride in the Home. — "Do they keep hold of their children!
THE SATISFACTIONS OF LIFE 223
when they have grown out of childhood ? " was asked of a woman
who knew intimately the life of the families in whole blocks of
two-story houses.
"Yes, almost invariably, the chief pleasure for all of them is
in the home itself. You see, most of these families own their
houses, and the improvements they make belong to them. 'We
are going to have a sleeping porch/ and the news is so precious that
it goes through the block. Mary's making her own graduating
dress/ is of no less thrilling interest, and all the family work for
Mary to give her time to sew. The family are all proud of the way
mother keeps the house ; f you don't have to be afraid to bring
someone home to supper/ "
Out-of-door Life. — Out-of-door life for its beauty and for the
physical exercise to which it invites has a prominent place in the
pleasures of this family, especially if living in the city. Walking
for the vigor and refreshment that it gives, and the long ramble
which has some branch of nature study as its end, are for old and
young alike, and free out-of-door games for which provision is
made, or should be demanded, in the public parks, are to give
health and pleasure to this family.
The absolute necessity for finding pleasure without the expendi-
ture of money develops these and other resources to the utmost.
A long walk with a friend takes the place of the matinee ticket,
while a friendship is being cultivated rather than a number of
passing acquaintances formed; just as reading, taken up, perhaps,
because there is nothing else to do, may start a habit which will
enrich the life. Everything must be done out-of-doors that can
be done there. The children who have free range in farm or village
have a great start in life, but the tiniest back yard or porch has
its possibilities.
Nature-study and Skill of Hand. — Out-of-door life may well
center about that very tangible thing, the collection ; the collecting
and naming of moths and butterflies, for instance, leads to minute
observation and considerable skill in mounting. Such pursuits and
also the gaining of skill of hand for which youth offers such leisure
and opportunity will require help. The child soon reaches the limit
of his own skill and inventiveness. If a home-made archery set is
planned, for instance, the boy of twelve cannot produce arrows and
15
226 SUCCESSFUL FAMILY LIFE ON MODERATE INCOME
bow and target good enough to satisfy when used. He must be
helped and encouraged; he must be furnished good materials and
tools and a book on sports from, the public library.
The whole fascinating repertory of the sailor in the tying of
knots may be mastered by father and children together, helped by
the same illustrated book. A father may consider Saturday after-
noons well spent if he can teach his boys and their friends the ele-
ments of wood craft, as skill with the boat, the fishing rod, the
simplest cutting instruments. Skill of hand and its results are
highly prized by children. One may see in the school yard a
poorly dressed boy lord it over the sons of the well-to-do because of
his skill with a jack-knife. In all lines even a moderate degree of
effort carries one beyond the average attainment to some degree of
satisfaction; it is too common to stop with naming a half dozen
of the best-known flowers or birds, or such striking constellations
as the Great Bear and Orion. Popular books for self -instruction in
all the subjects here suggested are to be found in public libraries,
and faithful work with their help will soon carry the enquirer far
beyond the superficial level of achievement to attainments that give
real satisfaction.
It was said during the European war that the American soldier
made a very unhappy prisoner — as a rule he had no fads, no skill
of hand, no accomplishments of any kind, while the foreign soldier
was tolerably happy whittling out toys, even making toy villages
and playing on musical instruments, some of which he himself made.
Human Relations. — The joy of life for all people is largely
in human relationships. A home that is a real home has something
about it glowing, comforting and attractive to the lonely. How
many people are socially hungry it is well for even little children
to learn ; to realize that gayety and affection and comradeship may
be shared with the help of the home background is to hold in the
hand gifts that are without price. The American family must learn
that the cultivation of the mind and heart does not depend on money
and that no rank of life is debarred from culture. But it cannot be
denied that conscious effort will be needed for cultural development.
For instance, it cannot be taken for granted that expression through
speech, except in its most primitive form, will come by itself. There
is nothing more stimulating to the intelligence, nothing that so
THE SATISFACTIONS OF LIFE 227
helps the sluggish mind as good talk, just as there is nothing more
stunting to the nature than morose silence. Does anyone suppose
that conversation is not an art, something to be practiced with
direct aim at self-expression and to bring pleasure to others ? How
is this important part of the social side of family life to be developed
without those too obvious efforts at " improvement," which may be
the mistake of the overzealous parent ?
A British Instance. — Our failings in this regard seem to be
shared by our British relatives. Arnold Bennett thus describes tea
time in a certain English household. " This tea which is the daily
blossoming time of the home that Mr. Smith and his wife had
constructed with twenty-six years' continual effort ought to be a
very agreeable affair. Surely the materials for pleasure are present !
But it does not seem to be a very agreeable meal. There is no regular
conversation. Everybody has the air of being preoccupied with his
own affairs. A long stretch of silence; then some chaffing or sar-
donic remark by one child to another; then another silence; then
a monosyllable from Mr. Smith; then another silence. No subject
of wide interest is ever seriously argued at that table. No discussion
is ever undertaken for the sake of discussion. It has never occurred
to anyone named Smith that conversation in general is an art and
may be a diverting pastime, and that conversation at table is a duty.
Besides, conversation is nourished on books, and books are rarer
than teaspoons in that home. Further, at back of the excellent,
honest, and clean mind of every Smith is the notion that politeness
is something that one owes only to strangers/'
Why is the home life so often bleak, shallow, joyless? Family
happiness would seem to be dependent not only on affection and
sympathy, but on their frequent expression in some form, and yet
" excellent people may live together day in and day out without
ever voicing the pleasant thoughts they have of one another."
The Dinner Table. — Breakfast, at least in city families, is apt
to be a hurried meal. It has been too difficult to get up until the
last minute, the day ahead is near and its problems pressing. But
the dinner table may be used as one of the great social forces for
this family. The mother has done her best to provide something
they like to eat; there will be at least one favorite dish and perhaps
a surprise dessert. Some member of the family helps at the last
228 SUCCESSFUL FAMILY LIFE ON MODERATE INCOME
so that an unhurried mother sits down with them, and whatever
getting up there must be during the meal is not done by her. Then,
no grouchiness is allowed, no unpleasant subjects are to be brought
up; bickering and fault-finding are barred.
This cultivation of the social life may not come easily. It will
start as the result of persistent effort and finally all will catch the
spirit. It is essentially the spirit of unselfishness — to encourage
the telling of adventures, the expression of views and to seek out
what will truly entertain from one's own doings or thoughts. To
this conscious direction of home life the parents will bring all their
resources; but the entire plan will fail if they assume the didatic
or introduce their own favorite topics without the most skilful
camouflage. Good talk has something of spontaneity about it; it
chooses its own ways, and if those ways are not treated with respect
the younger ones at least feel a frost in the air. One excellent
method used in a family much interested in public events has been
to hang on the dining-room wall a map of the world, so that they
become familiar with countries and cities that are alluded to in
conversation during the best visiting hours of the day, those spent at
the table.
The Father's Part. — A guest at the table helps with the intro-
duction of fresh interests; but it will be novelty enough if the
father enters into the conversation and does his share in contribut-
ing to the talk ! Here is the father's chance to play a part. He
comes from outside and brings another point of view. But in some
families he makes this the time for what the children call, " review-
ing the forces." The whole meal may be taken up with reminders of
shortcomings, and if any protest is made against the too public
punishment and the spoiling of the meal, the father's reply is " what
other time have I to rake 'em over ? " He has his part in discipline
and training, but he may have regard to times and seasons. We
read of " the diminishing figure of the father in American family
life." He ought to be made wholly unsatisfied with merely furnish-
ing the money for his family to spend. And those guests which the
children are looking forward to for Sunday's dinner may oftener
be father's friends ! It may be said in passing that children need
more fathering than they are apt to get, and in general more real
friendship with those of an older generation.
THE SATISFACTIONS OF LIFE 229
The Mother's Part. — But because of the greater amount of
time that the mother gives to the family life, because she is in the
center of the household doing her work in close contact with all
its members at least some part of the day, choosing, deciding,
helping, with a chance to ease up hard places, to understand and
sympathize, to fill every smallest service with affection and wise
suggestion, it is she who has the greatest responsibility for the spirit,
courage, and joyousness of the family. If she is glum and dispirited
all will feel it. If it is her determination to stimulate and en-
hearten, new life courses through the talk and work; to do this
she must be a woman who prizes at its full worth her vantage ground
at the heart of a family group, with all its social and
spiritual possibilities.
Why not a course in high schools and vocational classes for young
married women whose distinct aim would be, not only housekeep-
ing, but home-making with emphasis put on its social side?
The Cheapest of All Home Pleasures. — The limitations of the
moderate income bear most heavily on the large number of educated
people, to whom travel and other expensive means of broadening the
intellectual life make a strong appeal. On the other hand, they
have already access to the cheapest of all pleasures, reading; for
two carfares all that the public library has to offer is theirs. To
give children a taste for good reading is to bring them in touch
with the great of all time. The family with a " reading mother "
enjoys a priceless advantage.
Reading Aloud. — Reading aloud as a source of cultivation and
happiness in a family is utilized far less than it might be. Nothing
will equal it for improving the speaking voice, for providing topics
of conversation interesting to all and which may take the place
of the constant repetition of trivial things which is too apt to
monopolize the table talk. A good comedy whose parts are taken
by the members of the family and read without rehearsals gives
great enjoyment.
Here again the limitations of the family income may be a help
to this end. A couple with little children during the evenings which
they spend at home, not only save the money they would -pay out for
cheap amusements, but they have been known to take to reading
aloud or to music in some form and thus begin to develop the
230 SUCCESSFUL FAMILY LIFE ON MODERATE INCOME
home pleasures which are to help in holding the family together and
maintaining such standards as the father and mother are capable
of setting.
But it would seem that only in the very exceptional family is
this habit of reading aloud now to be found. There are few good
readers since no point is made in school of this accomplishment.
Then, "it goes too slow." Nevertheless, here is a great oppor-
tunity wasted, one which was more used, it would seem, in a previous
generation. As a matter of course the mother reads to her little
children and she has always this chance to form the habit for what
is worth while in literature.
Story-telling. — This is at once more easy and more difficult
than reading aloud. It depends more on personal temperament
and skill and less on education. There are people like Maxim
Gorky's peasant grandmother whose dramatic instinct seizes upon
the salient points in their own experience and they charm both
young and old by their tales. But a degree of this talent is com-
mon and can be cultivated under the spur of giving pleasure to
others. Every mother can tell nursery stories to her baby, but
she must make an effort to keep up with the growing demands of
the child between four and seven, when the imagination is perhaps
most active and the reliance on the mother for this form of enter-
tainment is at its height. She will do well to make a study of the
tales which appear in slightly different form in all languages and
have stood the test of time. A list of such stories is here given,
as compiled by one of the professional story-tellers now employed in
a public recreation center.1
From three to six years of age children enjoy Mother Goose, and such
stories as " Billy Goal's Gruff " and " Why the Bear is Stumpy " from
Popular Tales from the Norse; "The Three Bears," "Little Red Riding
Hood," " The Elves and the Shoemaker " ; or " Bremen Town Musicians "
from Grimm's Fairy Tales; "The Gingerbread Boy," "The Little Fir
Tree," and "How Brother Rabbit Fooled the Whale and the Elephant"
from Stories to Tell to Children ; " The Crow and the Tortoise " and " The
Crow and the Pitcher" from Aesop's Fables; "Wishing Wishes" from
More Mother Stories; and "Little Black Sambo," by Bannerman.
For children from six to nine years old there are " Hansel and Gretel,"
" The Frog Prince," " Briar Rose," " Hans in Luck," and " The Coal, the
Bean and the Straw " from Grimm's Fairy Tales ; " Why the Sea is Salt,"
1 These stories are all to be found in collections obtainable in any pub-
lic library.
THE SATISFACTIONS OF LIFE 231
"The Straw Ox," "The Lad and the North Wind" from Popular Tales
from the Norse; "The Brahmin, the Tiger, and the Jackal," "Little Half
Chick" from Stories to Tell to Children; "The Fox and the Crow" and
" The Town Mouse and Country Mouse " from Aesop's Fables ; " The Pea
Blossom" from Andersen's Fairy Tales; and "Cinderella" by Perrault.
From nine to twelve years : " Peter, Paul and Espen " from Popular
Tales from the Norse, is suitable; also "Robert of Sicily" from Stories to
Tell to Children ; " The Ugly Duckling " from Andersen's Fairy Tales ; " The
Wolf and the Kid " from Aesop's Fables ; " The Fisherman and the Genii "
and "Aladdin and His Wonderful Lamp" from Arabian Nights; " Toomai
of the Elephants," "Rikki Tikki Tavi," and "Mowgli" by Kipling;
"Raggylug " by Ernest Seton Thompson ; " How Little Cedric Became a
Knight " from In Storyland ; " The Rhine Gold," " Siegfried," and " Brun-
hilde " from Wagner Opera Stories ; " Robinson Crusoe " and selected
stories from Uncle Remus.
Story-telling by the Child. — There is a phase of this form
of entertainment which is often overlooked and it is a most im-
portant one. The child may be helped to make his own contribution
to the entertainment of others, instead of always receiving. This
cultivates cooperation, improves the speech and gives self-confidence
and pleasure to a timid child. A mother may say to a child who
is telling her an adventure, " How very funny ! Wait until you can
tell us all together ! "
The Creative in Play. — It has been said that "the best life
is one in which the creative impulses play the largest part and the
possessive impulses the smallest." Something is here to be con-
sidered more serious than amusement, it is the education of the artis-
tic nature, the joy of self-expression in some form of creative play.
Even a little leisure, a little money opens many doors. Beauty
does not sit on a throne to be approached only by those who can
wear fine raiment. It has been said that "we are potentially a
truer democracy in aesthetics than in economics or politics." How
is this side of the home and national life to be developed for people
of moderate means ? Did the nameless authors of the folk songs of
older nations -possess our standardized "necessities and comforts
of life" before they turned toward artistic expression? We read
that the wandering bard sang not only to kings and courtiers but
to poor peasants around the scanty fire. Did the peasantry of
Elizabethan England develop those public games and dances which
we are now trying to revive, only when they were well clothed and
fed every day?
232 SUCCESSFUL FAMILY LIFE ON MODERATE INCOME
In general it may be said that pleasures are to be chosen which
allow of active rather than passive participation. Too much of
" being entertained " is not good for young or old, and it is death
to initiative. Even the best censored " movies " are worth nothing
from this point of view compared to a crude play or a mediocre
piece of music which the young people have themselves composed
and produced. " It's only looking " as one sensible woman remarked.
How are we to meet this need of self-expression ; how feed the
imagination without expensive training under masters ? Just as it
has been done in more primitive times the world over, by uniting
with others in the simpler forms of music and drama. It is recog-
nized by artists that the great unrest which is sweeping over all
countries is not wholly economic, it is partly spiritual, and that back
of it is a great longing for artistic expression. What people long
for more or less definitely is not so-called amusement, outside their
daily life and purposes, but an infusion of beauty, fitness and har-
mony into every act and situation. It would seem to be a part of
the genius of our time to demand that more beauty and joy should
inform our -daily living, that the sanitary dwelling should also
please the eye, that convenient and inexpensive furniture should
not be ugly of outline, that clothing should satisfy in its color
and form.
How much of this craving for artistic expression is to be met
in the home? In this regard homes differ very much from each
other; in some of them delightful results have been attained, in
almost all more could be done than is now done.
The Festival Play. — Every family should learn to utilize to
the full the possibilities of the festival occasion, Christmas, the
birthday and other anniversaries. Here the play spirit should
dominate, the dear make-believe of the child. It has been noticed
that children who have good mental and emotional endowment
early show imagination of the constructive kind. They love to
"act out" scenes and stories. But not always for older people,
because they then become conscious of the more exacting adult
standards, although if older people take the lead and themselves
dress, pose and gesture, they join in with delight. Excellent collec-
tions of plays, suitable for acting by a family or a group of friends
and relatives are issued or recommended by the Drama League,
THE SATISFACTIONS OF LIFE 233
New York City ; fairy stories offer simple and attractive plots for
home dramatization.
Still better is the play which is written as well as staged by
home talent. As subjects for the original home drama, a good
beginning is the historical background of the family. In one
family it was New England history with its strongly contrasted
personnel of Indian, Puritan and Quaker. In another there was
an effort to dramatize the life of a great uncle who fought for
Italian independence under Garibaldi. It required much searching
for points in the library, help from the older people, and for all
who took part there came unconsciously as the result some grasp
of a great period in history which was, moreover, their own history.
In these plays there must be at least a skeleton of a plot, and always
action and costume. The success of these home entertainments is
sometimes amazing, and the delight they give to the performers
offers a pedagogical lesson that should be taken to heart. It is a
mistake to require a perfect performance; young people find too
much rehearsing irksome.
To produce a play as a birthday gift will be perhaps a new idea
to American children. They thus offer something of their own
creation as a gift far more valuable than what is purchased with
money, because it is original, their very own. A musical family
has a great advantage in this regard. They can present a new piece
of music on the occasion as a new song carefully rehearsed as a
surprise, or even a simple composition of their own. Gifts made
or partly made by hand, however rude or simple, should be praised
for the effort and thought they represent — to do or make for the
pleasure of others may become by skilful suggestion the very keynote
of the home celebration. In one family a feature of the birthday
is a processional with the birthday cake carried aloft, the singing of
songs and reading of original jingle verses.
In another family the summer vacation always ends with an
evening devoted to a reproduction of such of its happenings as
suggest the dramatic touch, or form the basis for witty extrava-
ganza. The family, the relatives and guests are divided into
"sides/5 thus furnishing the stimulus of rivalry in presenting
impromptu acts or tableaux. Here appears the home-made " poem "
that may be fitted to some popular air and which always delights the
234 SUCCESSFUL FAMILY LIFE ON MODERATE INCOME
hearers if only there are enough palpable "hits." It is often
accompanied by an acted scene too simple to be called a play. Its
" motif " in one case was that of a child being lost in the city
streets. There appeared the tearful little boy, the policeman who
questions him, the bystanders who advise, the telephone operator,
the joyful parents. Children who witness such a dramatization of
an incident in daily life are sure to suggest other subjects which
are at once staged.
The graphic arts have also their home development. The pen-
and-ink cartoon has great possibilities ; delightful examples of this
form of entertainment are found in Koosevelt's " Letters to
His Children."
Children have been known to conduct a newspaper written and
printed by themselves. Often they need only a little suggestion
and encouragement to start many joyful enterprises. There is at
present a vast waste in outside amusements, especially since what
has been termed the commercialization of leisure. The claims that
they make on the income are too great and the inroads on time and
health and family life are still more serious. The home must pro-
vide entertainment for its own members as far as possible.
Music in the Family. — Under Community Helps, page 133,
is to be found some account of the development of community
music; it has a distinct relation to music in the home. It helps
to answer the question just what advice is to be given to parents
who are looking forward to family life on a moderate income, those
who love music but have no means of expressing themselves in it.
In church and school the young people learn to sing, and music
in the home ought to follow as a matter of course. It may be said
that there is always music of some kind in this home of moderate
means and it ranks very high dn their pleasures. In very many
homes supported on an income of no more than $2500 the very
first outlay beyond necessities is for a piano. And in some miracu-
lous manner they learn to play it, at least for dance music and
to accompany singing. A phonograph is second choice, or it may
come first in those families whose members do not easily learn
to play an instrument, and they can both sing and dance to
its accompaniment.
Part Singing. — It would seem that part singing ought to be
THE SATISFACTIONS OF LIFE 235
the most easily attained of all inexpensive home amusements that
are approached from the artistic side. It comes very readily in
some families. There may be a natural love of music which
insists on expression, or some background in musical culture in
the preceding generation that enables the mother to play accom-
paniments, and the father to read music. Even the accompaniment
may not be necessary. One family of little children had been taught
to sing with the father and mother a large number of negro
" spirituals " picked up by ear around a southern plantation, the
strange cadences and harmonies being perfectly reproduced by the
children with the help of the steadying voices of the two leaders.
They were able to give in this way a unique form of entertainment
to friends.
Suggestions on Music in the Home. — The following sugges-
tions on how to bring about more music in the home were given by
Mrs. Henrietta Baker Lowe, of Peabody Conservatory of Music,
Baltimore, at a recent meeting of the Child Welfare Club of
that city.1
Giving of music books and books on music as presents. Use of
musical grace at meals, musical good night.
Example of elders singing everywhere, especially while busy
about the house, is useful, also hearing their elders discuss music,
going with them to music stores to buy music and records.
Also important are new songs learned beautifully for surprises,
new songs taught by older children to younger ; having the several
members of the family study different instruments so as to make
a family ensemble, singing at picnics and while walking, singing
games for younger children, talking machine and good records,
singing softly with talking machine with a good voice record.
See that children sing what they have learned at school. Sing
softly, pitch high, sing rhythmically and rather fast.
Miss Lowe gave also the following bibliography of music books and
records :
1. For Singing to Young Children and for Children to Learn:
Mother Goose's Nursery Rhymes. Elliott, 50c.
Songs for a Little Child's Day. Eleanor Smith. $1.50. Milton Bradley
Co., New York.
Records: Mother Goose — Victor No. 17004
Baa Black Sheep— Victor No. 17937
Lilts and Lyrics — Victor No. 17686.
236 SUCCESSFUL FAMILY LIFE ON MODERATE INCOME
Marching and Free Movement.
Bythm and Action. Norton. $1.00. Oliver Ditson Co., New York.
Records: Victor No. 18216
Victor No. 64201
March, hop, run, skip, fly, just as music suggests.
Singing Games:
Children's Old and New Singing Games. Mari Hofer. Flanagan Co.,
Chicago.
Record: Mulberry Bush — Victor No. 17104
2. Songs for Older Children to Sing.
Grammar School Song Book. Farnsworth. Scribner & Co. 75c.
Songs of Camp Fire Girls. Neidlinger. 25c. Camp Fire Outfitting
Co., 32 W. 24th St., New York.
Songs for Beginning Alto (Records on request). Congdon Primer No.
IV. Charles H. Congdon, 200 5th Ave., New York. N.B.: Let
mother or older friends at first sing the alto, with children singing
soprano softly so as to hear both voices.
Boy Scouts' Book. C. C. Birchard & Co., Boston.
Learn songs from good records.
3. Songs for the Family, children singing choruses and easy parts.
Twice 55 Songs. C. C. Birchard & Co., Boston.
A more complete list of books, records and suggestions has been com-
piled and can be obtained in mimeographed form at cost price by addressing
Mrs. Lowe, Peabody Conservatory of Music, Baltimore, Md.
The Outside World. — Many parents who are equal to the care
and direction of little children, at least as far as holding their
confidence and affection is concerned, fail utterly when the inevitable
connection is made with the outside world to meet social cravings
and to join in community action. This failure to keep in touch
with the adolescent boy and girl is seen on every side, and if the
parents are of foreign birth, the maladjustment of the two genera-
tions may have tragic consequences well known to social workers
in large cities.
At best the pressure on the family resources and wisdom in the
direction of adolescent children is great. It will be well if parents
realize very early the coming difficulty and make friendly connec-
tion with families whose resources are similar to their own and who
have good standards of living. They must also avail themselves
of all agencies that will give to their views the support of public
opinion and the chance for cooperation. The mother who attends
the Parents' and Teachers' Association meetings may cease to feel
that there is an impossible gulf between the home and the school.
If she follows the reports of the censorship on moving pictures
THE SATISFACTIONS OF LIFE 237
she will exchange distrust and ignorance for intelligent use of what
is to be a great force in education.
For many families the church is the most important outside
influence for development and happiness. Church-going may be
the first venture of parents and children together, there the whole
family are apt to find their friends ; the church social, the mission-
ary society, the Sunday school, the various young people's meetings,
all have something to offer.
Free City Amusements. — A city family made up of young
and old during a summer vacation resolved to spend nothing beyond
carfares for public amusements. The result was exactly opposite
to the general belief that the city dweller must spend more money
for amusements than the person living in the country. The temp-
tation to spend is there, but why yield to it? This family found
that most museums and picture galleries were open on Sunday
afternoons free, that by going from one park to another in the
evening excellent band concerts were to be heard and they dis-
covered the community "sing." Saturday rehearsals of church
music, visits to the free playgrounds and swimming pools, and the
recreation piers were always a resource, and social events in the
church, Y.M.C.A., etc., were utilized to the full. For instruction,
there were the free libraries and summer educational courses.
The Family in the Country. — The satisfactions of life in the
family of moderate income in small villages and in the country
will depend more than in the city on their own resources, but social
connections outside the home are perhaps more easily managed, for
there is a background of well-known community life, relatives are
apt to live near, >and simple outdoor sports are directly at hand.
The intellectual life is being stimulated by the endowed library
which has come to be the rule rather than the exception in small
towns, and by the traveling library in rural districts. A great
effort is now made by the country church to broaden the interests
of the community, and these efforts began along the line of the
most-needed improvements in home and community life, for better
roads and markets, for cheaper lights, better schools, cleaner sports,
for the building of community houses for gymnasium, library and
recreation, all in the line of helpfulness for lives that may be hard
pressed on the material side.
238 SUCCESSFUL FAMILY LIFE ON MODERATE INCOME
In general, both the man and the woman of the family willi
seek to enjoy forms of social activity in which the children do>
not share. The men's club in churches and the fraternal orders
keep the man in touch with other men in ways that are apart
from business routine. The mother will find a club whose dues
are small and its activities will rest her from the home routine.
It is ihe I rani -working, self-denying type of woman that espe-
cially needs tin's. It forces her to spend a little more on her
clothes even if the daughters must have less and to play her part
with others, thus gaining self-confidence and fresh points of view.
The woman of the middle group, economically speaking, would
say if she were frank, "I love my home, but to be eternally there
makes me sometimes hate it." For her this social outlet is abso-
lutely needed.
The urgent need for holding the family together for most of its
pleasures may lead to some expenditures, not otherwise justified
for the moderate income, as the purchase of a cheap automobile
which is financed in ways not discoverable by the statistician.
Summary. — In conclusion, it must be said, that although we
^hiill sometimes find members of this typical moderate income
family rebcling at what they feel to be tame and old-fashioned
restrictions, it yet remains true that many thousands of intelligent
and ambitious groups in our midst are finding success along the lines
here indicated, anil they realize that they have within their reach
a possession of -great value to themselves and to the community.
The satisfaction and contentment that make life worth living
seem to be found for all people in the foundational things, health,
home, children, friends, a degree of success among their fellow-men,
and these would seem to be more easily attained in the home of
moderate means than in any other, because of the intimate relations
that must exist in a household which is served by its own members.
The money limitations bring about this opportunity, and affection
and inielliLrenec will make use of it to develop home pleasures, thus-
placing outside amusements in their proper subordinate place. The
family group in its most successful form finds its happiness in
family relations, in pride in the home itself, in simple hospitality,
in conversation, in reading, in story- telling, in music, in the simplest:
forms of home drama or theatricals, in dancing, in out-of-door life1
THE SATISFACTIONS OP LIFE 239
ith walking punos and nature study. Such free entertainment
and instruction as is afforded by public enterprise is also to be
utilized to the full.
QUESTIONS
1. AcvtM-ilinir to your personal experience, would von consider that the
sujijiost ions nuulo in t.his chapter arc too lucking in excitement and
too rtiltural in oharaitor to appeal to tho avorano family iiroup?
'2. \\hat ooonpations v,ouM you Mibstitnto. romomborini: alwa\
must st rive for a high type of family life, and that money goes farther
it" spoilt tO::ot hor V
;•'. CiNf -.:. ..> -tuMis tor koojunu jiaronts in arroi\i with thoir chiUhvn
ilnrinj: t.lu* :uloli>si'iMU yoars.
4. Mako u}> a list of ivtYromv books whii'h it is doMrablo for a family
to h:nv.
.">. Suirir^st a program of vai-:Uii>n possibilit ios for a nunli<rai<' iiu-onu^
family list possible travol trips it\ AHUM ioa from \vhi<'h an ovvasional
fhoii-o iniirht bo iu:iilo: study tho j robU-ni of tho simplo sunuiuM i-ot
taiio. its iosts aiul risnlt-s. f-.t; , its Ix^iriuj; on tbo oihuation of tho
thililivn. a^ ooinpartxl with tho " suuunor Kiariling houso " ; in-
oxponsivo oainps for I'hiKlron what for paront<. oto '
0. SluniUl tlu* man ami woman ha\o oaoh an avi^'at ion ? What aro iH>ssi-
bilitios. t'.f].. in art. haiulioraft . natuiv. litoraturo. oto.V Mousuro MI.:-
tions i;i tt^vms i>f nicaniii:: for tho family's life.
7. Work out some facts as to the history of your own family that should
bo of intorost to mombors of tho family if not to othors'.
5. Mako iltitaiK\l plans for I'o.'-porat ivo arrani:omont s botwoon noiiihborini:
fainilios rt-i:artlinir rtn-roation. roailin<: aiul tho liko. r.j;.. magiuiuc
oxohungo i-luh. book i-lub. sin»:in>r olub, orohostra, thoutrioals. oto.
CHAPTEE XX
THE LOOK AHEAD
IN the preceding chapters an effort has been made to show that
the moderate income family in this country can make an unqualified
success of their life if certain conditions are afforded :
1. A fair start for the heads of the household as given by the
preceding generation.
2. The money income tolerably certain and earned wholly or
chiefly by the man of the family.
3. The right attitude of the wife and mother toward her part
in the enterprise, with the ability and training to be a good manager
and buyer, to do most of the housework, to care for and train the
children, and to contribute certain immaterial values that make for
happiness and success.
4. Generous help on the part of the community along many
lines, as health, education, recreation and economic service in
checking costs of living.
What Changes are to be Expected. — Every generation must
examine its social baggage in order to determine what is to be
thrown away and what is worth keeping. Are the above require-
ments to remain as urgent as they are now ? Are the disintegrating
factors that threaten the present type of family life radical in
character or will there be adjustments only ? Human nature carries
in itself a, great stabilizing principle ; revolution is not as easy as it
seems. The home, even in its present form, will not be easily over-
thrown ;' while keeping its essential characteristics it will doubtless
prove capable of adjustment to the changing times. It must be
remembered that while growing prosperity has softened the hard
conditions that surrounded the pioneer family, forcing them, as it
did, to hold together against cold and hunger, yet the effort
necessary to meet advanced standards is perhaps greater than ever,
and if success is to be reached, the solidarity of the family in earning
and spending still remains the dominant factor.
240
THE LOOK AHEAD 241
The Fair Start. — There is, perhaps, an increasing need that
each generation shall provide the fair start in life for the heads of
the new family, as outlined in Chapter V. Standards of living are
held with more definiteness while training and preparation for the
chosen work have become more imperative for the young. To per-
form this duty requires of the parents the use of their utmost indus-
try, knowledge and devotion in order to provide the conditions for
happy development in childhood, for general and special education,
for assembling with the help of the whole family such an outfit as
will start habits of thrift and foresight in the young couple and
bridge over difficulties and emergencies in the early married years.
The Earner and the Spender. — The increasing pressure for
specialization in all kinds of work gives new meaning to the demand
that the man of the family, at least that family in which there are
young children, shall be able to concentrate on the earning of the
money income, and that the woman shall be free for her important
duties in the center of home life, of choosing, adjusting, dispensing,
teaching, and there making in the many other ways that have been
indicated her necessary contribution to the income. She must
furnish these services or their equivalent if she is in any true sense
the business partner. Her qualifications for the work thus become
of financial importance and they can no more be ignored in making
plans for family life than can the size of the husband's wages or
salary. We expect a man to lift his share of the world's great bur-
den of constructive labor; if a woman is tired at night with her
tasks, why should she complain?
This attitude and ability on the part of the mother of the family
is probably the most important of all the factors in successful family
life. The preceding generation may have failed to contribute
training or financial backing; the community may be niggardly in
providing help in education, or any control of public utilities ; even
the money income may be curtailed and yet the family is seen to
win out, but if the mother proves unequal to her part, there is
almost certain disaster ahead. The family partnership seems to
afford no place for the selfish individualist ; privileges involve duties.
Public Help. — While the fair start in life and the part to be
played by the earner and the spender are under personal and
family control, the help that must come from outside is dependent
16
242 SUCCESSFUL FAMILY LIFE ON MODERATE INCOME
on public opinion and public endeavor following the establishment
of proper standards as to what the home should accomplish.
At present such help on the part of the public is neither generous
nor intelligent. If our civilization were not the imperfect thing
it is, if it were not full of waste and contradiction, we should marvel
more than we do at the contrast between soaring ideals and shabby
fulfilment in the life of the people. We hear the home as an insti-
tution proclaimed as the center of the social fabric, the unit of the
state, but what we see around us is ignorance and apathy regarding
those types of social action which would contribute certain essentials
for success in family life.
We Penalize Parenthood. — It has become a commonplace, so
often has it been said, that society has a stake in every child born,
that the children are " the only hope of the future," yet society would
seem to be so organized as to penalize parenthood, and the punish-
ment falls heaviest on the family living on the moderate income.
Parents who are raising children according to good standards and
at much personal sacrifice are expected to meet every financial and
social obligation that is set for the childless whose income can
be spent entirely on themselves. Not for them the choice dwellings
with open spaces for play, because their higher rental cannot be met
out of funds that must provide food and clothing for little bodies;
not for them the desirable apartments where "no children are
allowed," nor in case of illness free treatment in endowed hospitals
without loss of self-respect, as is the privilege of the very poor.
A little Italian girl of eleven stood waiting for the street
car with a tiny child cuddled in her arms. "Isn't the baby too
heavy ? " asked the lady who was waiting beside her. " Oh, no,"
she replied, looking fondly at the curly black head. " Tony's not
heavy, he's my brother ! "
Yes, but notwithstanding the strength of devoted love, Tony is
heavy ; society must help lift.
It cannot be denied that we fail to realize the importance of
the home as the place which has most to do with the health, efficiency
and happiness of the people, else it would be better served. Good
citizens do not come out of poor homes, and poor homes are those
that do not come up to proper standards. Health standards must
be established and parents must be taught to live up to them ; for
THE LOOK AHEAD 243
instance, a girl who has learned in school to bound the states of the
union and to do examples in percentage is quite capable of learning
also what a healthy child should weigh at different ages and what
are the most evident signs of well-being or the opposite for every
member of the family. In the same way standards of efficiency in
all lines may be established by teaching them in schools of all grades.
The woman of the household thus comes into full prominence
as the person who must have the best of training in order that she
may apply to her many tasks and duties the results of modern
knowledge. She has undertaken a business which must be learned
just as any other business is learned. She can no more make a
success of it and reach high modern standards than can the engi-
neer build a bridge without learning the principles of engineering.
When the bridge breaks down the ignorance of the builder is laid
bare. When the family life breaks down in health or efficiency, it
is not easy to assign to all the causes their share of the blame, but
we do know that if the woman of the family is ignorant and un-
trained her share will not be light.
Standards of what ought to be expected as the result of family
life in health, comfort and general efficiency of its members will
not be established at once ; they will depend on the growing intelli-
gence of the people, but the foundation of such intelligence will
be found in a well coordinated system of instruction which the
woman must realize that she needs and must demand from the
proper authorities in state and community.
Ample Courses in Home-making Needed. — For the instruc-
tion of this woman only the merest beginning has been made by the
establishment in the public schools of a few courses in cooking
and sewing. Courses of instruction covering all living conditions
and all of the housekeeping arts, amply illustrated by exhibits and
demonstrations, must be given free in the public schools, and exten-
sion classes must be furnished on the same subjects for all women
and girls beyond school age. These courses will be based on
hygiene in its many applications, and they will take especial
account of the value of the housewife's time. Even more important
than a mastery of unconnected processes will be ranked household
management, with thrift in its broadest sense as the keynote. A
study of the actual problems found in daily life will alone decide
244 SUCCESSFUL FAMILY LIFE ON MODERATE INCOME
what use is to be made of the woman's time in the home and whether
certain forms of work are to be undertaken at all.
By these courses, demonstrations and conferences, light will be
shed on all the practical problems that have been concealed by the
traditional closed door of the old-fashioned home. In a certain
city when evening courses in home economics were started, one-
fourth of the adult students chose cooking, and three-fourths dress-
making and millinery. " Why this proportion ? " " Because/' was
the answer, "every woman thinks she can buy food and cook it,
criticism from without does not reach into her home, her family
has to take what she sets forth, and frequently not one of them
knows that there is anything better. But when this woman passes
a store window she says, ' I cannot make that dress ! If I could only
make such a hat as that ! * and she goes to learn how/' In this
case a regular trade with established method and technique gives
to the home woman the standards by which she can judge her own
work. Under the system of free extension courses in Home Eco-
nomics in city and country when fully developed, the home woman
should find well-taught and demonstrated such subjects as the
principles of nutrition with the right choice and preparation of
food, the care of the child, the use of labor-saving devices, the
spending of the income ; and standards will thus be set up regarding
all home activities. There will be no more dark corners, and every
growth in interest will lead to a demand for more teaching
and investigation.
The Waste of the Present System. — It would seem that even
the most stupid would be shocked at the wastefulness of the present
system. The economic side of the question is to be considered.
The money value of what is used in these millions of homes is enor-
mous. Is the buying wisely done ? Are the raw materials worked
up efficiently so that the family is as well fed and clothed and cared
for as they should be for the money spent? A chancellor of the
British Exchequer once said that the whole debt of the nation could
be paid in a few years by the saving effected if the good housekeepers
could be sent about to teach the others how to economize. An
engineering society has 'been known to spend an entire day in dis-
cussing the height of factory chimneys as affecting the utilization
of fuel. What is the aggregate value of the coal burned in the mil-
THE LOOK AHEAD 245
lions of private homes, and is the same intelligence applied to its
efficient use?
Costly experiments are being made by men of first-class ability
to improve methods in all kinds of business, railroading, farming,
manufacturing. Business has the advice of the statistician and the
specialist on boards of trade, the faculties of universities and techni-
cal schools; as a result old methods are improved, old machines
scrapped, while the best brains of the country are drawn into
business and they play their part in what has been the immense
growth of our national wealth; and all this to increase the money-
earning power of the people. But it seems probable that in our
country the ability to earn a dollar has outrun the ability to spend
a dollar wisely. A man who can make a fortune may be a babe in
the art of living; it is evident that the same careful study must
be put on money-spending, that is, individual and family budget-
making, in order that right standards, ethical and educational as
well as economic, may be met. Such studies would work toward
improving the very foundation of home life, especially in what
relates to the most important product of the home, its children.
Few are the teachers or social workers who are trained to help
parents solve the problems of child-rearing, nor do most of our
higher institutions of learning responsible for courses for farmers
and farmers' wives, for community weeks and the like, include
work that will train people to be intelligent educators of their
children as well as generous providers and efficient caretakers. For
child-rearing parents need the advice of the hygienist, the physician,
the psychologist and the most profound students of education. We
have already noted the beginnings of such help in federal and state
educational agencies, but the organization is at present only partly
financed and the public is too little conscious of its need of instruc-
tion to utilize what is offered and to demand more. To what an
extent low standards prevail in the homes of the country and how
the present ignorance and apathy on the subject may be dissipated
are as yet hardly realized.
The Coming Home-maker. — Every woman's college, every
high school is full of good potential home-makers who will soon be
administering the homes of this country. If so many of them, as it
is claimed, are now pleasure-loving, thriftless, wholly lacking in
246 SUCCESSFUL FAMILY LIFE ON MODERATE INCOME
knowledge of household arts or child-rearing, and averse to the
sacrifices necessary to maintain home life on a good level, is the
blame entirely theirs or is it in part due to the failure of home and
school and society to give them right ideals and training and to
show them the high rewards that may be theirs, if they will put
into the profession of home-making the best they have and the best
they can learn? And what of the serious-minded and ambitious
among them whose whole interest lies in preparing for a money-
earning job outside the home?
They are following the only course that is regarded with favor
by educators and the community, but their destiny within a home
will overtake them and find them unprepared.
Everything goes to prove that we are doing a cruel and stupid
thing in not directing the splendid initiative and driving power of
the young to find its scope and expression in constructive home life.
Have these young people been shown that their future activities in
the home are not necessarily humdrum and narrow, but that they
may be full of development and happiness ? Can they be convinced
that the homes they have known which were failures were abnormal
homes and that effort and knowledge and patience and affection
might have saved them? Do they believe that the women in the
homes need not be overwhelmed by tasks which they have not been
taught to perform, need not be denied control over the money neces-
sary to carry out their plans and to evolve a family life with any
distinction? Are we ready to promise them that this business of
home-making is at last acknowledged as a profession for which
training is necessary, that they are not to be left to sink or swim,
that their most difficult problems have been thought out for them
and that science is at work on every phase of modern life? If
these young people could be made to believe that the best social
forces are pulling in this direction, they would find joy in answering
the new call to self-restraint and ambition. As one young matron
said : " I just love to feel the machinery give under my hand ! "
Certainly the time has come for all educational and social forces
to play their part in the development of home life. A sympathetic
study of its problems according to scientific methods will go hand
in hand with such cooperation.
THE LOOK AHEAD 247
Said Emerson : " Who so shall teach me how to eat my meat
and take my repose and deal with men without any shame following
will restore the life of man to splendor and make his own name
dear to all history."
QUESTIONS
1. Considering the advances that have been made during the last twenty
years in understanding and public help for the housewife in meeting
her duties, outline what will probably be educational and other
facilities offered her in 1930.
2. Read a few selected chapters of Sonnichsen's or Emerson's "Cooper-
ation," and indicate what features of this system long in successful
operation in Europe are applicable to conditions in the United
States.
3. Would it be feasible for women's organizations to conduct educational
work for the benefit of the home? Indicate what would be apt to
succeed.
4. Make a list of sources of free pamphlet material on food, child care,
clothing, cleaning, etc., which the housewife can secure.
5. Home study clubs with book and pamphlet material and one of the
members as leader have been successful in a small way. Would the
time be better spent if by contributing a fee the leadership of a
trained person should be secured?
6. Has the local Board of Education in your community done anything
for home economics education for adult women ? Ascertain the legal
basis for such a plan by consulting the local superintendent of
schools and state educational authorities. Make a theoretical plan as
to what seems desirable. How put it into effect in your community?
INDEX
Account Book, 61
sample page of, 56
Adoption, 13
Allowance, 59
age for, 65
children's, 64
objections against, 68
Amusements, for city, 237
Armstrong, D. B., 126
Artisan family and savings, 178
Babson, R. W., 4
Balderson, L. R., 94
Banks, help from, in accounts, 54
and budgetry, 161
Bennett, A., 227
Bequest, 39
Beyer, W. C., 26
Bosanquet, H., 78
Bowley, A. L., 29
Budget, art of living and, 161
Bondy, 154
British, 227
children's, 162, 186
early studies of, 154
health and decency, 155
how to begin a, 158
Karpinski, 177
men's, 155
misuse of term, 151
need of records of, 193
plea for, 195
Richards, 155
U. S. Thrift, 156, 157
Buyer, advertiser and, 47
budget for, 50
housewife as, 43
how measure value of, 45
lists for, 50
power over family life of, 48
production of, 44
training of, 49
Carver, T. N., 4, 164
Cash or credit, 51
Changes to be expected, 240
Chapin, R. C., 26
Children, home training of, 147
age of, as 'affects saving, 178
Clothing, cost of, 169
instruction in, 170
requirements, 169 \
Cold storage, 127
Cooperation in spending, 62
labor, 101
Cooperative League, 129
Community as source of income,
136
help in education, 137
relation to individual, 119
responsible for health, 121
Consumption, laws of, 153
Debt, danger of, 35
Demonstrations, teaching power of,
143
Devices, labor-saving, 92
Devine, E. T., 44
Dinner table as social force, 227
Dowry, evils of, 38
Drama League, 136
Dramatics, 136
Dribbler, The, 187
Earner and spender, 241
Economy, the larger view, 174
Education for home making, 80
Wis. journal of, 64
Eight-hour day, feasibility of, 89
Engel, E., 152
Engel's laws, 153
Envelope system of accounts, 54
illustration of, 160
Experts, scarcity of, 81
advice needed by, 93
249
250
INDEX
Expense account and budget, 152
Fair Start, The, 35, 241
Family building, 11
group defined, 9
History No. I, 195
II, 197
Nos. I and II compared,
199
No. Ill, 201
IV, 203
Nos. Ill and IV compared,
206
V, 206
VI, 208
VII, 210
normal or standard, 9
Farmer's wife, letter from, 105
bulletins, 92, 94
Father's part, 228
Fatigue, good health in relation to,
98
in housework, 93, 95
interest in relation to, 96
scientific studies of, 94
Financial status of moderate in-
come family, 6
Financial summary, illus. of, 152
Food, cost of, 165
distribution, 126
knowledge of, to acquire, 165
materials to reduce cost of, 119,
165
minimum, 164
Foundational things, 222
Girl as saver, 40
Hard, William, 40
Health, its importance, 183
service and extension of 124
Home Bureau, 55
Home, its advantages as workshop,
74
pleasures, cheapest of, 229
pride in, 224
Home economics, classes in, 139
vocational, 140
Hospitality, 101
House, as making or saving work,
90
Household activities, development
through, 109
Housekeeping vs. Boarding, 83
Housewife, intellectual and social
needs of, 99
Housework vs. outside earning, 71,
82
Housing costs, 167
association, national, 167
helps toward better, 168
minimum requirements in, 166
readjustment in, 166
Hygiene, teaching of, 112
Illness, preventable losses from, 122
Income, compared with foreign, 29
effect on of standard of living,
30
general ignorance of, 25
groups, summary of, 27
interest as source of, 17
national divided among fam-
ilies, 29
purchasing power of, 30
relation to health of, 122
sources of knowledge of, 26
subsistence, 193
uncertain, 180
Indian suit, boy and, 116
Inspector, medical, 125
Jennings, H. B., 14
King, Clyde L., 127
King, W. J., 26, 29, 31
Kitchens, public, 129
Laundry, 77
Lee, F. S., 79, 94
Le Play, F., 152
Libraries, 137
INDEX
251
Man, relation of, to family income,
21
Market, terminal, 127
Marks, M. N., 126
Marriage, rate of, affected by eco-
nomic laws, 10
Mendel, L. B., 77
Methods, better household, 80
Minimum, definition of, 163
scientific and social studies of,
163
Money, as an educator, 188
part played by, 116
spending, rules for, 186
as fine art, 189
More, L. B., 26
Music as a social force, 135
in family, 234
in schools, 135
suggestions in home, 235
Nature study, 225
Operating expenses, 170
Parenthood penalized, 242
Play, creative in, 231
festival, 232
Power of choice, 2
Professional families, 176
Property, estimates of, 32, 57
Purse, who holds the, 59
Reading aloud, 229
Rent, as source of income, 17
Richardson, A. E., 142
Ryan, J. A., 164
Savings, form of, 175
reasons for, 173
Scott, Rhea C., 94
Self-control, teaching of, 112
Services of family as source of in-
come, 18
of mother, value of, 117
Sherman and Gillett, 165
Singing in home, 234
Social wealth as source of family
income, 19
Spahr, C. B., 31
Standards of living defined, 213
and the moderate income, 215
young people, 217
compared with foreign coun-
tries, 214
group action, 218
Start in life, 35
Story-telling, 230
by child, 231
Struggle, advantages of, 115
Sumner, W. G., 213
Tarbell, I. M., 46
Taylor, A. E., 77
Van Vorst, Mrs., 188
Variety in work, effect on fatigue,
79
Village mother, letter from, 107
Wages as source of income, 17
Warren, Dr. B. S., 124
WTaste in present system, 244
Wealth compared with income, 29
Winslow, C. E. A., 124
Woman, her position in moderate
income family, 5
Woman's contribution to income, 19
Woolman, M. S., 49
Work, mastery of, 78
saving, 90
Working mother as teacher, 111
Worry, effect on fatigue, 96
THIS BOOK IS DUE ON THE LAST DATE
STAMPED BELOW
AN INITIAL FINE OF 25 CENTS
WILL BE ASSESSED FOR FAILURE TO RETURN
THIS BOOK ON THE DATE DUE. THE PENALTY
WILL INCREASE TO SO CENTS ON THE FOURTH
DAY AND TO $I.OO ON THE SEVENTH DAY
OVERDUE.
JUL 10 1
JUN 5 WUH - *
in llW 5^1*%
gBC.ClH.HK
cm SEP 3 o 1985
IT
2 9 1989
UAN 1 5 2000
IN GTACK3
LD 21-100m-12,'43(879Cs)
GENERAL LIBRARY - U.C. BERKELEY
TX32./ '•
A3
THE UNIVERSITY OF CALIFORNIA LIBRARY