THE BOOKMAN BOO TS THOMAS CARLYLE; G.K.CHESTERTON AND J.E.HODDER WILLIAMS PR C-f S BY THE SAME AUTHOR. Both Reduced to Is. net. 6rcpRards at Flap. Literature and Art for Old Gentlemen. Rhymes and Sketches, with Cover Design in Nursery Colours. By G. K. CHESTERTON. " One of the cleverest collections of this kind I have ever come across." The Sketch. " Very good and very humorous. Black and White. " We only wish for one addition to the book : more of everything." The Bookman. "THE BOOKMAN," LIKE OLIVER TWIST, BY THE SAME AUTHOR. " ASKS FOR MORE." Uniform with the Above. nonsense RDpmes. By COSMO MONKHOUSE. Illustrated by G. K. CHESTERTON. " The most diverting Christmas book of verses we have seen." Literattire. Mr. Brimley Johnson s publications include the Novels of Jane Austen" Hampshire Edition, with an entirely novel method of illustration; the dainty " York Library "- selections from Lamb, Southey, and Spencer; Lady Duff Gordon s " Letters from Egypt"- ivith an Introduction by George Meredith; " Letters from John Chinaman " ; " From the Abyss," by an Inhabitant; " 77?,? Gospel Manuscripts"; "Latter Day Parables" being Dreams and Allegories by Modern Hands ; Centenary Edition of" Mrs. Caudle s Curtain Lectures" and " The Wonderful Story of Dunder Van Haelden" by Edward Chesterton. IK Defendant BY G. K. CHESTERTON. Crown 8vo, 2s. 6d. net. Jl Jew ffotiees. " Clever and humorous . . . will interest any body who can enjoy a paradox neatly put."- Scotsman. " Really one cannot help agreeing with such an engaging advocate." Morning Leader. "We heartily commend Mr. Chesterton s many novel points of view to the earnest consideration of our readers. The Defendant is a book that will be read with both pleasure and profit."- Aberdeen Journal. " His style is limpid and lucid." Simday Sun. " He is always on the side of the high-spirited, the Quixotic, and the things of the mind." Daily Chronicle. " Bright and brilliant." The Star. "Mr. Chesterton is one of the most brilliant of the younger journalists." Observer. " At once marked by originality of thought and distinction of style." Sunday Times. " G. K. Chesterton is a master of paradox. "- Dundee Advertiser. "A series of breezy and thoughtful essays."- Christian. "Mr. G. K. Chesterton is always interesting and amusing." Echo. " Time and again in reading it we have had to lay it down and lie back in our chair and laugh. And yet, perhaps, its dominant note is its noble seriousness. " Sheffield Telegraph. "Sufficiently epigrammatic to be piquant. "- County Gentleman. " The excruciating joy of reading the Essays." Daily News. " Mr. Chesterton has a style that is all his own, a pretty wit and a happy knack of putting things, combined with a dry humour that never fails to make the most unlikely subject interesting. "- A berdeen Journal. Second Edition Ready. MORE MATTER. HALF PRICE. R. BRIMLEY JOHNSON, 8, York Buildings, Adelphi, W.C, . "THE BOOKMAN" BOOKLETS. A SERIES OF POPULAR IL L USTRA TED MONO GRA PHS ON GREAT WRITERS. Profusely illustrated, with special portrait in tint. Small 4to, 1/- each, net. (0 THOMAS CARLYLE. (2) ROBERT LOUIS STEVENSON. ( 3 ) . CHARLES DICKENS. (4 ) LEO TOLSTOY. LONDON: HODDER & STOUGHTON, 27, PATERNOSTER Row, E.G. "THE BOOKMAN" DIRECTORY FOR 1903* " THE BOOKMAN " DIRECTORY. Edited by E. H r odder Williams. OF BOOKSELLERS, PUBLISHERS, AND AUTHORS, Revised to date. Small 410, 3/6 net. THE BOOKMAN A Monthly Journal for Bookreaders, Bookbuyers, and Booksellers. The Bookman is edited by Dr. Robertson Nicoll, and is published during the first week of every month, price 6d. net. It is the only monthly magazine devoted exclusively to the interests of book readers. The Bookman chronicles the literary life of the day in pictures as well as letterpress, and is the best illustrated guide to the best books of the day. The Bookman makes appeal to every one who is interested in current literature. It is not a dry-as-dust magazine for specialists. Every line and every picture it contains is of peculiar interest to the great and ever-increasing public that delights in books. LONDON: HODDER & STOUGHTON, 27, PATERNOSTER Row, E.G. THOMAS CARLYLE FROM THE PORTRAIT BY WILLIAM BARR Photographed by T. & R. Annan & Sons. Reproduced by kind permission of the Editor of " Britannia." THOMAS CARLYLE BY G. K. CHESTERTON AND J. E. HODDER WILLIAMS WITH NUMEROUS ILLUSTRATIONS London HODDER AND STOUGHTON 27, Paternoster Row 1902 PRINTED BY HAZELL, WATSON AND VINEY, LD., LONDON AND AYLESBURY. LIST OF ILLUSTRATIONS PAGE PORTRAIT OF THOMAS CARLYLE ....... Frontispiece THOMAS CARLYLE S MOTHER .......... 1 ARCH HOUSE, ECCLEFECHAN .......... 2 THE ROOM AT ARCH HOUSE IN WHICH CARLYLE WAS BORN .... 2 ECCLEFECHAN, DUMFRIESSHIRE ......... 3 MAINHILL FARM . . . . . , . . . . .4 HODDAM HILL . . . . . . . . . . . .4 THOMAS CARLYLE (from a Portrait by Maclise) ...... 5 A PORTRAIT OF CARLYLE ENGRAVED BY F. CROLL FROM A DAGUERREOTYPE BY BEARD ............ 6 THOMAS CARLYLE (from a Sketch by Count D^Orsay) ... .7 CARLYLE S FIRST EDINBURGH LODGING IN SIMON SQUARE .... 8 1, MORAY STREET (NOW SPEY STREET), LEITH WALK, EDINBURGH ... 9 THOMAS CARLYLE (from Photo) . . . . . . . . .10 MRS. CARLYLE S BIRTHPLACE . . . . . . . . . .11 THE HOUSE IN WHICH CARLYLE LIVED WHILE FIRST TEACHING AT KIRKCALDY SCHOOL . . . . . . . . . . . . .11 SCOTSBRIG . . . . . . . . . . . .12 TEMPLAND, NEAR THORNHILL, DUMFRIESSHIRE. . . . . . .12 THOMAS CARLYLE (from Painting by Whistler) . . . . . .13 21, COMELY BANK, EDINBURGH . . . . . . . . .14 THOMAS CARLYLK (from Sir J. E. Boehnis Medallion) . . . . .15 THOMAS CARLYLE, ABOUT I860 ......... 16 iv LIST OF ILLUSTRATIONS PAGE THOMAS CARLYLE, 1865 . . . . . . . . . .17 A POKTKAIT OF CAULYLE TAKEX IX 1879 ..... .18 FACSIMILES OF CARLYLE S SIGNATURE . . . . . ... .18 CRAIGENPUTTOCK . . . . . . . . . . . .19 PORTRAIT GROUP TAKEN AT KIRKCALDY . . . . . . . .19 THOMAS CARLYLE (from Sir J. E. Boehnfs Bust) 20 CARLYLE S HOUSE AT 5 (NOW 24). CHEYXE Row, CHELSEA . . . .21 JANE WELSH CARLYLE . . . ." . . . . . . .21 CORNER IN DRAWING-ROOM AT No. 5, CHEYXE Row . . . . .22 THE GARDEN AT No. 5, CHEYXE Row ........ 23 THOMAS CARLYLE (from Drawing in " Sartor Resartus ") . . . .24 MRS. CARLYLE ABOUT 1864 . . . . . . . / ... 25 CARLYLE S GRAVE AT ECCLEFECHAN . . . . . . .26 MRS. CARLYLE S GRAVE IN HADDIXGTON CHURCH . . . ; . .26 THOMAS CAULYLE (from Sir J. E. Millais 1 Portrait) 27 THE GROUND-FLOOR ROOMS AT No. 5, CHEYNE Row (1900) . . .28 THE GARRET STUDY AT CHEYNE Row (1857) ...... 29 THOMAS CARLYLE, .ET. 73 (from Painting by G. F. Watts, R.A.) . . 30 THE SOUND-PROOF STUDY AT CHEYNE Row IN 1900, SHOWING THE DOUBLE WALLS . . . . . , . . . . . .31 THE KITCHEN AT No. 5, CHEYNE Row (1900) . . . .32 CARLYLF/S WRITING-DESK AND CHAIR ........ 33 STATUE OF CARLYLE (by Sir J. E. Boehm) ....... 35 THOMAS CARLYLE HERE are few cultivated people who do not pretend to have read Mr. Lecky s " History of Rationalism in Europe." That very able work covers the whole of one very important side of modern development. But the picture of the real progress, the real mental and moral improvement of our species during the last few centuries, will not be complete until Mr. Lecky publishes a companion volume en titled " The History of Irrationalism in Europe." The two tendencies, acting together, have been respon sible for the whole advancement of THOMAS CARLYLE S MOTHER the Western world. Rationalism is, (Reproduced by kind permission of Mr. Alexander Carlyle) ot course, that power which makes people invent sewing machines, understand Euclid, reform vestries, pull out teeth, and number the fixed stars. Irrationalism is that other force, if possible more essential, which makes men look at sunsets, laugh at jokes, go on crusades, write poems, enter monasteries, and jump over hay-cocks. Rationalism is the beneficent attempt to make our institutions and theories fit the world we live in, as clothes fit the wearer. Irrationalism is the beneficent reminder that, at the best, 1 THOMAS CARLYLE From a photo by J, Patrick, Edinburgh ARCH HOUSE, ECCLEFECHAN The Birthplace of Thomas Carlyle they do not fit. Ir- rationalism exists to point out that that eccentric old gentle- nrr^J "" l**iW : Tl man? " The World " is I I 1 1 1 1 If l : IBTwTBrnil such a curiouslyshaped old gentleman that the most perfect coats and waistcoats have an ex traordinary way of leaving parts of him out, sometimes whole legs and arms, the existence of which the tailor had not suspected. And as surely as there arises a consistent theory of life which seems to give a whole plan of it, there will appear within a score or two of years a great Irrationalist to tell the world of strange seas and forests which are nowhere down on the map. The great movement of the eighteenth and nineteenth centuries, which rose to its height in the French Revolution and the Positivist philosophy, was the last great Rationalistic synthesis. The inevitable Irrationalist who followed it was Thomas Carlyle. This is the first and most essential view of his position. In order to ex plain the matter more clearly, it is necessary to recur to our image of the old gentleman whom no tailor could fit. Not only do the From a photo by G. G. Napier, M.A. THE ROOM AT ARCH HOUSE IN WHICH CARLYLE WAS BORN tailorS tend tO think THOMAS CARLYLE From a photo by G. G. Napier, M.A. MAINHILL FARM The Home of Carlyle s Parents from 1815 to 1825 that clothes can be made to fit the old gentleman, but they tend very often to think that the whole ques tion is a question of clothes. Thus, for in stance, the Popes and Bolingbrokes of the earlier eighteenth century tried to make man a purer symbol of civilisation. They tried to pluck from him altogether his love of the savage and primeval, as they might have plucked off a shaggy wig from the old gentleman in order to put on a powdered one. A by stander of the name of Byron, who was indeed none other than the inevitable Irrationalist, startled them by pointing out that the shaggy object was not a wig at all, but the poor old gentleman s own hair ; that, in other words, the love of the savage, the primeval, the lonely and unsociable, was a part of man, and it was their business to recog nise it. Then arose the new fashion in cos mic clothes, which did recognise this natural element. Rousseau and Shelley took the old gentleman in hand, and provided him with spring-like gar ments, coloured like From a photo ly J. Patrick, Edinburgh the clouds of HODDAMHILL fi f Where Carlyle lived in 1825 I THOMAS CARLYLE From a portrait ly Daniel Maclise, R.A. ntnv in the Victoria and A Ibert Museum Rischgitz Collection 6 THOMAS CARLYLE A PORTRAIT OF CAR LYLE ENGRAVED BY F. CROLL FROM A DAGUERREOTYPE BY BEARD Rischgitz Collection principles was the absolute principle of equality. Finding, therefore, that the old gentleman was wearing a curiously shaped hat, com pounded of crown, coronet, and mitre, the great hat of Godhood, kinghood, and superiority, they proceeded, in order to make him more natural, to knock it off; and to them suddenly appeared the inevitable Irrationalist, a Scotch gentleman from Dumfriesshire, who, addressing them politely, said, "You believe that that regal object you are knocking off is his hat : believe me, gentlemen, it is his head. Such mistakes will occur after a hasty inspection, but that kingship is really a part of the old gentleman, and it is your business to recognise THOMAS CARLYLE THOMAS CARLYLE From a. sketch by Count D Orsay (1839) Rischgitz Collection it." As Byron had come, just as the classic edifice of polite deism had been completed, to point out that the fact remained that he, Byron, did prefer walking by the seashore to taking tea in the garden, so Carlyle appeared, just as the austere temple of political equality was erected, to point out that the fact remained that he did think many people a great deal better than himself, and very many people a great deal worse. Thus, then, as the asserter of the natural character of king ship against the natural character of equality, it is that Thomas Carlyle primarily stands twenty-one years after his death. Now I do not think, as I shall show later, that Carlyle ever really 8 THOMAS CARLYLK CARLYLE S FIRST EDINBURGH LODGING IN SIMON SQUARE From a photograph by Mr. Thomas Clark, Edinburgh understood the true doctrine of equality ; but it is certainly at least equally true that the egalitarians and the ordinary opponents of Carlyle have never done the least justice to Carlyle s doctrine of hero-worship. The usual theory is that he believed in a race of arrogant strong men, brutally self-sufficient and brazenly indifferent to ethical limits, and that he wanted these men to frighten and dominate the populace as a keeper or a doctor frightens and dominates the lunatic in a cell. It is not too much to say that there is scarcely a trace in Carlyle s works of this barbarous and ridiculous idea. If there be a trace of it here and there, it is mere explosion of personal ill-temper, and has nothing whatever in common with Carlyle s deliberate theory of the hero. His theory of the hero was that he was a man whom men followed, not because they could not help fearing, but because they could riot help loving him. His theory, right or wrong, was that when a man was your superior you were acting THOMAS CARLYLE 9 r, MORAY STREET (NOW SPEY STREET), LEITH WALK, EDINBURGH From a photograph by Mr. Thomas Clark, Edinburgh naturally in looking up to him, and were therefore happy ; that you were acting unnaturally in equalising yourself with him, and were therefore unhappy. Most people, except those solemn persons who are called with some humour free-thinkers, would agree, for instance, that the worship of God was a human function, and therefore gave pleasure to the performer of it, like eating or taking exercise. Now Carlyle held, rightly or wrongly, that the worship of man, of the great man, was also a human function, and therefore gave pleasure to the performer of it. It all depends upon whether we do take an egalitarian or an aristocratic view of the spiritual world. If the spiritual world is based upon equality, then, no doubt, to keep a man in an inferior position must spiritually depress and degrade him ; but if beings in the spiritual world have higher and lower functions, it is obvious that it is equally depressing and degrading to a man to take him out of his position and make him either a citizen or an emperor. 10 THOMAS CARLYLE THOMAS CARLYLE From a photo by the London Stereoscopic Co. Moreover, the real practical truth that underlay Carlyle s gospel of the hero has in other ways been misunderstood. The general idea is that Carlyle thought that, if a man were only able, every thing was to be excused to him. If Carlyle, even at any moment, thought this, it can only be said that for that moment Carlyle was a fool, as many able men may happen to be. But, as a matter of fact, what Carlyle meant was something much sounder. To say that any man may tyrannise so long as he is able, is as ridiculous as saying that any man may knock people down so long as he is six feet high. But in urging this very obvious fact the opponents of THOMAS CARLYLE 11 From a photo by G. G. Napier, M.A. MRS. CARLYLE S BIRTHPLACE Dr. Welsh s House at Haddington. Carlyle too often forget a simpler truth at the back of the Carlyle gospel. It is that, while in one sense the same moral test is to be ap plied to all men, there does remain in ordinary charitable practice a very great difference between the people who consider it necessary to see some definite thing done before they die, and the people who cheerfully admit that two hundred years will scarcely bring what they require, and that meanwhile they desire to do nothing. A Tolstoian anarchist who thinks that men should be morally persuaded for the next two or three centuries to give up every kind of physical compulsion may, it is quite conceivable, be more right than the English Home Secre tary who finds himself responsible for the sup pression of a riot in Manchester; but surely it is patently ridiculous to say that it is just as much to the anarchist s credit that he avoids shooting Manchester From a photo by A . Miilikcn, Kirkcaldy. THE HOUSE IN WHICH CARLYLE LIVED WHILST TEACHING AT KIRKCALDY SCHOOL 12 THOMAS CARLYLE From a photo by G. G. Napier, M.A. SCOTSBRIG A farm in the neighbourhood of Ecclefechan to which the Carlyles removed from Mainhill in 1826 workmen as it would be to the Home Secre tary s credit if he avoided shooting them. It would be equally ridiculous to say that, if the Home Secretary conceived it necessary to shoot them, from a sense of responsibility, that his action, even if wrong, was really as wrong as the conduct of a Tolstoian who should shoot them without any reason at all. In this sense, therefore, there is really a different test, and a perfectly fair one, for men of action and for men of abstract theories and remote hopes. Now, it must definitely be set to the credit of men like Cromwell and Mirabeau, that they were undoubtedly opposed to and embar rassed by men whose projects, even in their own eyes, were scarcely a part of practical politics. These men exist in every country and in every age. They are wilfully and etern ally in opposition. They do not agree sufficiently with the active powers even to argue with them with any profit. Their ideal From a photo by J. Patrick, Edmbitrg Ii * TEMPLAND, NKAR THORN HILL, DUMFRIESSHIRE is SO fill aWay that Thomas Carlyle married Jane Baillie Welsh on October i/th, 1826, at , , Templand, Mrs. Welsh s residence tllC do llOt CVCn From the painting by J. McNeill Whistler THOMAS CARLYLE (Reproduced by kind permissson of Messrs. T. & R. Annan & Sons, by courtesy of the Glasgow Corporation) 14 THOMAS CARLYLE it with any immediate hunger. They count it a pleasant and natural thing to live and die in revolt. They are ready to be critics, they are ready to be martyrs, they are emphatically not ready to be rulers. In this way Cromwell, considering how he might make some English polity out of a chaos of English parties, had to argue for hours together with Fifth Monarchy men, to whom the vital question was whether the children of malignants should not be slain, and whether a man who was caught swearing should not be stoned to death. In this way Mirabeau, striving to keep the tradition of French civilisation intact amid a hundred essential reforms, found his way blocked by men who insisted on discussing whether in the ideal commonwealth men would believe in immortality, or go through From a pJwto. by Mr. Thomas Clark, Edinburgh 21, COMELY BANK, EDINBURGH Carlyle and his wife lived at Comely Bank for eighteen months after their marriage THOMAS CARLYLE 15 a rite of marriage. Now, while fully granting that both types have an eternal value, it is certainly not just that precisely the same ethical test should be applied to Cromwell and the Fifth Monarchy men, to Mirabeau and the worshipper of pure reason. It is not just that we from a wood engraving by Pearson of Sir J. E. Boelun s gold medallion THOMAS CARLYLE (Reproduced by kind permission of Messrs. Chapman and Hall) should judge in precisely the same way the pace of a butcher s cart which is obliged to get to Pimlico, and the pace of a butcher s cart which is designed at some time or other to reach the site of the Garden of Eden. It is not just that we should judge in the same way the man who is simply anxious to erect a parish pump, and 16 THOMAS CARLYLE the opponent of the pump, who looks forward to a day when there shall not only be no pump, but 110 parish. The man of action, then, really has in this sane and limited sense a claim to a peculiar kind of allowance, in that it is of vital necessity to him that a certain limited grievance should be re moved. It is easy enough to be the man who lives in a contented impotence ; the man who luxuriates in an endless and satisfied defeat. He does not desire to be effective ; he only desires to be right. He does not desire passionately that something should be done ; he only desires that it should be triumphantly proved to be necessary. This is the real contribution of Carlyle to the philosophy of the man of action. He revealed, entirely justly, and entirely to the profit of us all, the pathos of the practical man. He made us feel, what is profoundly true, that the tragedy of the death of Mary, Queen of Scots, is nothing to the tragedy of the death of Elizabeth ; that the tragedy of the death of Charles I. is nothing to the tragedy of the death of Cromwell. A man like Charles I. died triumphantly ; he did not indeed die as a martyr, but he died From a photo by the London Stereoscopic Co. THOMAS CARLYLE, 1 ABOUT 1860 ;.< - THOMAS CARLYLE 17 as something 1 which is much more awful and exceptional a con sistent man. He was worse than a tyrant, he was a logician. But a man like Cromwell is in a much harder case, for he does not wish to die and be a spectacle, but to live and be a force. He has to break altogether with the splendid logic of martyrdom. He has to eat his own words for breakfast, dinner, and supper. He has to outlive a hundred incarnations, and always reject the last ; his progress is like that unnerving initiation in the wild tale of Tom Moore s, in which the disciple had to climb up a stone stairway into the sky, every step of which fell away the moment his foot had left it. This is the only genuine truth that Carlyle brought from his study of strong men. If ever lie said that we must blindly obey the strong man, he was merely angry and personal, and untrue to his essentially generous and humane spirit. When he said that we must reverence the strong man he some times expressed him self with a certain heated confusion, and left it doubtful whether he meant that we should reverence the strong man as we re spect Christ, or merely as we respect Saridow. But we should all From a photo by Elliott & Fry agree with him in his THOMAS CARLYLE, i86 5 THOMAS CARLYLE essential and eternal con tribution that we should pity the strong man more than an idiot or a cripple. It may be said that there is a certain incon sistency between these tw r o justifications of Carlyle s hero - worship : that we cannot at the same time respect a man because he is above us in a definite spiritual order, and* because he is in what is popularly called a hole ; that we cannot at once reverence Mirabeau be cause he was strong and because he was weak. This kind of inconsistency does exist in Carlyle ; it is, I may say with all reverence and with all certainty, the eternal and inevitable inconsistency which characterises those who receive divine revelations. The larger world, which our systems attempt to explain and chiefly succeed in hiding, must, when it breaks through upon us, take forms which appear to be conflicting. The spiritual world is so rich that it is varied ; A PORTRAIT OF CARLYLE TAKEN IN 1879 Rischgitz Collection FACSIMILES OF CARLYLE S SIGNATURE (Reproduced by kind permission of Messrs. Chapman & Hall THOMAS CARLVLE 19 From a photo l>y J. Patrick, CRAIGENPUTTOCK Carlyle s residence from 1828 to 1834 so varied that it is in consistent. That is why so many saints and great doctors of religion have pinned their faith to paradoxes like the " Credo Quia Impossible," the great theological paradoxes which are so much more dazzling and daring than the para doxes of the modern flaneur. The supreme glory of Carlyle was that he heard the veritable voices of the Cosmos. He left it to others to attune them into an orchestra. Sometimes the truth he heard was this truth, that some men are to be commanded and some obeyed ; sometimes that deeper and more democratic truth that all men are above all things to be pitied. It will be found relevant to what I have to say hereafter to remark at this point that I do not myself accept Carlyle s conception of the spiritual world as exhaustive. I believe in the essence of the old doctrine of equality, because it appears to me to result from all conceptions of the divinity of man. Of f . - . course there are in- From a p/loto by J - Pa - tr ^> E ,... . PORTRAIT GROUP TAKEN AT KIRKCALDY equalities, and ObVlOUS Thomas Carlyle, his niece, his brother, and Provost Swan 20 THOMAS CARLYLE ones, but though they are not insignificant positively, they are insignificant comparatively. If men are all really the images of God, to talk about their differences has its significance, but only about the same significance which may be found in talking about the respective heights of twenty men, all of whom have received the Victoria Cross, or the respective length of the moustaches of twenty men, all of whom have died to save their fellow-creatures. In comparison with the point in which they are equal, the point in which they are unequal is not merely decidedly, but almost infinitely, insignificant. But my reason for indicating my own opinion on the matter, at this point, is a definite one. Carlyle s view of equality does not happen to be mine ; but it has an absolute right to be stated justly, and to be stated from Carlyle s point of view. It was not a brutal fear or a mean worship of force ; it was a serious belief that some found blessedness in commanding, and some in obeying. Now this kind of intellectual justice was the one great quality which was lacking in Carlyle himself. He would not consent to listen to Rousseau s gospel, as I have suggested that we should listen to Carlyle s gospel. He would not put Rousseau s pr From a terra-cotta bust in the National Portrait Gallery, by Sir J. E. Boehm, R.A. THOMAS CARLYLE (Reproduced f fromJ s Past to!? gOSpel from RoUSSCau s pOlllt -. , i , of view. And consequently to the end of Ills dayS llC HCVCF THOMAS CARLYLE 21 understood any gospel exeept Carlyle s gospel. When a literary man is known to have been almost a monster of industry, when he has produced a colossal epic like " Frederick the Great " on the dullest of all earthly subjects Germany in the eighteenth century when he has piled up all the complicated material of the history of the French Revolution, lost it, and by a portent of heroism piled it all up again ; when he lias From a photo ly J. Patrick, Edinburgh CARLYLE S HOUSE AT 5 (now 24), CHEYNE ROW, CHELSEA achieved such masterpieces of research as the discovery of sense in Cromwell s speeches, and good qualities in Frederick of Prussia : when an author has done all this, it may seem a singular comment upon him to say that his main characteristic was a lack of patience. But this was in reality the chief weakness, in fact the only real weakness, of Carlyle as a moral ist. It is very much easier to JANE WELSH CARLYLE What may be Called lllOral (Reproduced by kind permission of Messrs. Chapman and Hall) 22 THOMAS CARLYLE CORNER IN DRAWING- ROOM AT 5 CHEYNE ROW, with Carlyle s Reading Chair, given him by John Forster Drawn by R. Gray from a photograph by C. Baly (1881) (Reproduced from Reginald Blunt s " The Carlyles Chelsea Home," by kind permission of the author) patience or mental patience than to have something which may best be described as spiritual patience. Carlyle was patient with facts, dates, documents, intolerably wearisome memoirs ; but he was not patient with the soul of man. He was not patient with ideas, theories, tendencies, outside his own philosophy. He never understood, and therefore persistently undervalued, the real meaning of the idea of liberty, which is a faith in the growth and life of the human mind; vague indeed in its nature, but transcending in its magnitude even our faith in our own faiths. He was something of a Tory, something of a Sans-culotte, something of a Puritan, something of an Imperialist, something of a Socialist ; but he was never, even for a single moment, THOMAS CARLYLE 23 a Liberal. He did not believe as the Liberal believes, first indeed in his own truth, which in his eyes is pure truth, but beyond that also in that mightier truth which is made up of a million lies. And this spiritual impatience of Carlyle has left its peculiar mark THE GARDEN AT No. 5, CHEYNE ROW From a drawing by E, J. Sullivan THOMAS CARLYLE (Reproduced from the illustrated "Sartor Resartus," by kind permission of Messrs. George Bell & Sons) THOMAS CARLYLE 25 in the only defect which can really be found in his historical works. Of the astonishing power and humour and poignancy of those historical works I think it scarcely necessary to speak. A man must have a very poor literary sense who can read one of Carlyle s slighter sketches, such as " The Diamond Necklace," and not feel that he has at the same time to deal with one of the greatest satirists, one of the greatest mystics, and incomparably one of the finest story-tellers in the world. Xo his torian ever realised so strongly the recondite and ill-digested fact that history has consisted of human beings, each isolated, each vacillating, each living in an eternal present ; or, in other words, that history has not consisted of crowds, or kings, or Acts of Parliament, or systems of government, or articles of belief. And Carlyle has, moreover, introduced into the philosophy of history one element which had been absent from it since the writing of the Old Testament the element of something which can only be called humour in the just government of the universe. " He that sitteth in the heavens shall laugh them to scorn, the Lord shall have them in derision," is a note that is struck again in Carlyle for the first time after two thousand years. It is the note of the sarcasm of Providence. Any one who will read those admirable chapters of Carlyle on Chartism will realise that, while all other humanitarians were insisting upon the cruelty or the inconsistency or the barbarism of neglecting the From a photo in possession of IV. Robertson Nicoll, LL.D. MRS. CARLYLE ABOUT 1864 26 THOMAS CARLYLE From a thoto by G. G. Napier M.A. CARLYLE S GRAVE AT ECCLEFECHAN Thomas Carlyle died on February 5th, 1881 problem of labour, Carlyle is rather rilled with a kind of almost celestial astonishment at the absurdity of neglecting it. But a definite defect there is, as I have suggested, in Carlyle, considered as an historian, and it flows directly from that real moral defect in his nature, an impatience with other men s ideas. In judging of men as men, he was not only quick and graphic and correct, but in the main essentially genial and magnanimous. Only a very superficial critic will think that Carlyle was misanthropic because he was surly. There is very much more real sympathy with human problems and temptations in a page of this shaggy old malcontent than in whole libraries of constitutional history by dapper and polite rationalists, who treat men as automata, and put their virtues and vices into separate pigeonholes. If I had made a mistake or committed a sin that had any sort of human character about it, I would very much rather fall into the hands of Carlyle than into the hands of From a photo by J. F. Gordon, Haddington MRS. CARLYLE S GRAVE IN HADDINGTON CHURCH Mrs. Carlyle died on April 2ist, 1866 JMr. Or JVlr. fi Front t lie portrait painted by Sir J. E. Millais, P. R. A., for Mr. /. A. Fronde in 1877 THOMAS CARLYLE In the National Portrait Gallery. Rischgitz Collection. 27 28 THOMAS CARLYLE THE GROUND-FLOOR ROOMS AT 5, CHEVNE ROW (1900) (Reproduced from Reginald Blunt s "Historical Handbook to Chelsea," by kind permission of the author) Carlyle did realise the fact that every man carries about with him his own life and atmosphere, he did riot realise that other truth, that every man carries about with him his own theory of the world. Each one of us is living in a separate Cosmos. The theory of life held by one man never corresponds exactly to that held by another. The whole of a man s opinions, morals, tastes, manners, hobbies, work back eventually to some picture of existence itself which, whether it be a paradise or a battle-field, or a school or a chaos, is not precisely the same picture of existence which lies at the back of any other brain. Carlyle had not fully realised that it was a case of one man, one Cosmos. Consequently, he devoted himself to asking what place any man, say Robespierre or Shelley, occupied in Carlyle s Cosmos. It never occurred to him sufficiently clearly to ask what place Shelley 29 Photo by Frederick Hollyer THOMAS CARLVLE, XT. 73 From the painting by G. F. Watts, R.A., now in the National Portrait Gallery THOMAS CARLYLE 31 THE SOUND-PROOF STUDY AT CHEYNE ROW IN 1900, SHOWING THE DOUBLE WALLS (Reproduced from Reginald Blunt s "Historical Handbook to Chelsea," by kind permission of the author) occupied in Shelley s Cosmos, or Robespierre in Robespierre s Cosmos. Not feeling the need of this, he never studied, he never really listened to, Shelley s philosophy or Robespierre s philosophy. Here, after a somewhat long circuit, we have arrived at the one serious deficiency in Carlyle s histories, a neglect to realise the importance of theory and of alternative theories in human affairs. The standing example of this is the " History of the French Revo lution." Carlyle s conception of the French Revolution is simply and absolutely that of an elemental outbreak, an explosion of nature in history, an earthquake in the moral world. Human nature, Carlyle seems to tell us, had been stifled more and more in the wrappings of artificiality, until, when its condition had just passed the tolerable. THOMAS CARLYLE THE KITCHEN AT No. 5, CHEYNE ROW (1900) (Reproduced from Reginald Blunt s " Historical Handbook to Chelsea," by kind permission of the author) gagged, blinded, deaf, and ignorant of what it really wanted, by a gigantic muscular effort it burst its bonds. So far as it goes, that is perfectly true of the French Revolu tion ; but only so far as it goes. The French Revolution was a sudden starting from slumber of that terrible spirit of man which sleeps through the greater number of the centuries ; and Carlyle appreciates this, and describes it more powerfully and fearfully than any human historian, because this idea of the spirit of man breaking through formulae and building again on funda mentals was a part of his own philosophical theory, and therefore he understood it. But he never, as I have said, took any real trouble to understand other people s philosophical theories. And he did not realise the other fact about the French Revolution- THOMAS CARLYLE 33 CARLYLE S WRITING-DESK AND CHAIR (Reproduced by kind permission of Mr. Reginald Blunt) the fact that it was not merely an elementary outbreak, but was also a great doctrinal movement. It is an astonishing thing that Carlyle s " French Revolution " contrives to be as admirable and as accurate a history as it is, while from one end to the other there is hardly a suggestion that he comprehended the moral and political theories which were the guiding stars of the French Revolutionists. It was not necessary that he should agree with them, but it was necessary that he should be interested in them ; nay, in order that he should write a perfect history of their developments, it was neces sary that lie should admire them. The truly impartial historian is not he who is enthusiastic for neither side in a historic stru-o-lc : oo that method was adopted by the rationalistic historians of the Hallam type, and resulted in the dullest and thinnest and most 34 THOMAS CARLYLE essentially false chronicles that were ever compiled about mankind. The truly impartial historian is he who is enthusiastic for both sides. He holds in his heart a hundred fanaticisms. The truly philosophical historian does not patronise Cromwell and pat the King on the head, as Hallam does ; the true philosophical historian could ride after Cromwell like an Ironside and adore the King like a Cavalier. The only history that is worth knowing, or worth striving to know, is the history of the human head and the human heart, and of what great loves it has been enamoured : truth in the sense of the absolute justice is a thing for which fools look in history and wise men in the Day of Judgment. It is the glory of Carlyle that he did realise that the intellectual impartiality of the rationalist historian was merely emotional ignorance. It was his only defect that he extended his sympathy, in cases like that of the French Revolution, only to headlong men and impetuous actions, and not to great schools of revolutionary doctrine and faith. He made somewhat the same mistake with regard to the Middle Ages, touching which his contributions are unequalled in picturesqueness and potency. He conceived the mediaeval period in Europe as a barbaric verity, " a rude, stalwart age " ; he did not realise what is more and more unfolding itself to all serious historians, that the mediaeval period in Europe was a civilisation based upon a certain scheme of moral science of almost unexampled multiplicity and stringency, a scheme in which the colours of a lacquey s coat could be traced back to a system of astronomy, and the smallest bye-law for a village green had some relation to great ecclesiastical and moral mysteries. It is remarkable that we always call a rival civili sation savage : the Chinese call us barbarians, and we call them barbarians. The Middle Ages were a rival civilisation, based upon moral science, to ours based upon physical science. Most modern historians have abused this great civilisation for being barbarous : Carlyle had made one great stride beyond them in so far that he THOMAS CARLYLE 35 admired it for being barbarous. But his fatal strain of intel lectual impatience prevented him from getting on to the right side of Catholic dogmas, just as it prevented him from getting on to the right side of Jacobin dogmas. He never really discovered what other people meant by Apostolic Succession, or Liberty, or Equality, or Fraternity. Probably his few mis takes arose from his un fortunate tendency to find " shams." Some have sup posed this to be the essence and value of his message ; it was in truth its worst pitfall and disaster. A man is almost always wrong when he sets about to prove the unreality and uselessness of anything : he is almost in variably right when he sets about to prove the reality and value of anything. I have a quite different and much more genuine right to say that bull s-eyes are nice than I have to say liquorice is nasty : I have found out the meaning of the first and not of the second. And if a man goes on a tearing hunt after shams, as Carlyle did, it is probable STATUE OF CARLYLE , , .,, ,, .. T i By Sir J. E. Boehm, R.A. In the Gardens on the Chelsea Embankment that he will find little Rischgitz collection. 36 BIOGRAPHICAL NOTE. or nothing real. He is tearing off the branches to find the tree. T have said all that is to be said against Carlyle s work almost designedly : for he is one of those who are so great that we rather need to blame them for the sake of our own independence than praise them for the sake of their fame. He came and spoke a word, and the chatter of rationalism stopped, and the sums would no longer work out and be ended. He was a breath of Nature turning in her sleep under the load of civilisation, a stir in the very stillness of God to tell us He was still there. Arch House, Ecclefechan see page 2 Carlyle s mother see page i Ecclefechan, Dumfriesshire see page 3 The room in which Carlyle was born see page 2 Carlyle s first Edinburgh lodging in Simon Square see page 8 1, Moray Street (now Spey Street), Leith Walk, Edinburgh see page 9 BIOGRAPHICAL NOTE. In a house which his father, a mason, had built with his own hands, Thomas Carlyle was born on December 4th, 1795. His mother, Margaret Aitken, "a woman of the fairest descent, that of the pious, the just and wise," was the second wife of James Carlyle, and Thomas was the eldest of their nine children. In the Entepfuhl of Sartor Jicxartnx Carlyle has pictured his native village. It consisted of a single street, down the side of which ran an open brook. "With amazement," he writes, " I began to discover that Entepfuhl stood in the middle of a country, of a world. ... It was then that, independently of Schiller s Wilhelm Tdl, I made this not quite insignificant reflection (si) true also in spiritual things) : Any road, this simple Entepfuhl road, will lead you to the end of the world ! The room at Arch House in which he was born now contains some interesting mementoes. On the mantelpiece are two turned wooden candlesticks, a gift of John Sterling, sent from Rome ; the table provides a resting-place for his study-lamp and his tea-caddy. Most of the furniture came from Cheyne Row. Carlyle came up from Ecclefechan to attend Edinburgh University when he was scarcely fourteen years of age, and with a companion, Tom Smail, journeyed the entire distance on foot. They secured a clean-looking and cheap lodging in Simon Square, a poor neighbourhood on the south side of Edinburgh, off Nicholson Street. After residing in various parts of the old town, Carlyle removed in 1821 to better quarters, and the most interesting of his various abodes in Edinburgh was at 1, Moray Street (now Spey Street), Leith Walk. Here lie commenced his literary work in earnest, and began to regard life from a brighter standpoint. Leith Walk is described in ton-far li,>x<i)-tnx as the Hut- Xaiiit-Thnmax >/<> / Knfer. " All at once," he writes, " there rose a thought in me, and I asked myself, What art thou afraid of ? . . It is from this hour that I incline to date my spiritual new birth or baphometic fire-baptism ; perhaps 1 directly thereupon began to be a man." BIOGRAPHICAL NOTE. The house in which Carlyle lived whilst teaching at Kirkcaldy school see page n It was at Kirkcaldy that Carlyle first met Edward Irving, the master of a rival school in the town. They became intimate friends. "But for Irving," Mainhill Farm see page 4 Hoddam Hill see page 4 Scotsbrig see page 12 Jane Welsh Carlyle see page 21 Mrs. Carlyle s Birthplace, Haddington see page n Templand, near Thornhill, Dumfriesshire see page 12 21, Comely Bank Edinburgh see page 14 Craigenputtock see page 19 he saj> I had never known what the communion of man with man means." It was here, too, that he made the acquaintance of Miss Margaret Gordon, the " Blumine " of Sartor Itesartus. C arlyle describes the town in the Reminiscences: " Kirkcaldy itself . . . was a solidly diligent, yet by no means a panting, puffing, or in any way gambling Lang Toun. I, in particular, always rather liked the people though from the distance, chiefly ; chagrined and discouraged by the sad trade one had ! In 1815 the Carlyles moved to Mainhill Farm, and hene he "first learned German, studied Faust in a dry ditch, and completed his translation of Wilhelm Meister \ " Ten years later Carlyle took possession of Hoddam Hill Farm, his mother going with him as housekeeper, and his brother Alick as practical farmer. Here they remained until 1826. " With all its manifold petty troubles," says Carlyle, in the Reminiscences, "this year at Hoddam Hill has a rustic beauty and dignity to me ; and lies now like a not ignoble russet-coated idyll in my memory." The abrupt termination of Carlyle s tenancy of Hoddam Hill occurred simultaneously with the expiration of his father s lease of Mainhill, and in 1826 the family removed to Scotsbrig, that excellent " shell of a house for farming purposes," where Carlyle s parents spent the remainder of their lives. In this unpretentious home Carlyle passed many restful holidays among his own people. " In the ancient county-town of Haddington," he writes, " on July 14th, 1801, there was born to a lately wedded pair a little daughter, whom they named Jane Baillie Welsh, and whose subsequent and final name (her own common signature for many years) was Jane Welsh Carlyle. . . . Oh, she was noble, very noble, in that early as in all other periods, and made the ugliest and dullest into something beautiful ! I look back on it as if through rainbows the bit of sunshine hers, the tears my own." Mrs. Carlyle, in her Early Letters, mentions her father s home at Haddington where she was born. " It is my native place still ! and after all, there is much in it that I love. I love the bleaching green, where I used to caper, and roll, and tumble, and make gowan necklaces and chains of dandelion stalks, in the days of my wee existence. Carlyle s marriage with Jane Baillie Welsh took place on October 17th, 1826, at Templand, where Mrs. Welsh then resided. The ceremony was of the quietest description, his brother John Carlyle being the only person present besides Miss Welsh s family. For eighteen months after their marriage the Carlyles lived at 21, Comely Bank, the "trim little cottage, far from all the uproar and putrescence (material and spiritual) of the reeky town, the sound of which we hear not, and only see over the kiiowe the reflection of its gaslights against the dusky sky." It was during this time that Carlyle contributed essays to the Edinburgh and Foreign Quarter/;/ JieHeu-x. In 1828 a removal was made to Mr. >\ elsh s manor at Craigenputtock, where in the solitude "almost druidical" Sartor Rexartnx was written. " Poor Puttock ! " he exclaims in one of his letters, " Castle of many chagrins ; peatbog castle, where the devil never slumbers nor 38 BIOGRAPHICAL NOTE. Carlyle s house at 5 (now 24), Cheyne Row, Chelsea see page 21 Corner in Drawing-room at 5, Cheyne Row see page 22 The Garden at 5, Cheyne Row see page 23 The Sound-proof study at Cheyne Row see page 31 The gurret study in 1857 see page 29 sleeps ! very touching art thou to me when I look on thy image here." In this lonely spot, cut off from all social intercourse, the Carlyles remained until 1834, when, after " six years imprisonment on the Dumfriesshire moor," they moved to Chelsea and took up their residence at No. 5, Cheyne Row, in the house which was to be their home until death. After a week s wearisome house-hunting in London under the guidance of Leigh Hunt, Carlyle sent a long description of the proposed new residence to his wife, of which the following is an extract : " We are called Cheyne Row proper (pronounced Chainie Row) and are a genteel neighbourhood, two old ladies on the one side, unknown character on the other, but with pianos as Hunt said. The street is flag-pathed, sunk-storied, iron-railed, all old- fashioned and tightly done up. . . . The house itself is eminent, antique, wainscoted to the very ceiling, and has been all new painted and repaired. . . . On the whole a most massive, roomy, sufficient old house, with places, for example, to hang, say, three dozen hats or cloaks on, and as many crevices and queer old presses and shelved closets as would gratify the most covetous Goody rent 35 ! I confess I am strongly tempted." The brightest and happiest part of Carlyle s day was the early evening. " Home between five and six, with mud mackintoshes off, and the nightmares locked up for a while, I tried for an hour s sleep before my (solitary, dietetic, altogether simple) bit of dinner ; but first always came up for half an hour to the drawing-room and her ; where a bright, kindly fire was sure to be burning (candles hardly lit, all in trustful chiaroscuro). . . . This was the one bright portion of my black day. Oh, those evening half-hours, how beautiful and blessed they were ! " The garden at Cheyne Row was much appreciated by the Carlyles, who turned to the best advantage this " poor sooty patch." Mrs. Carlyle writes : " Behind we have a garden (so called in the language of flattery) in the worst of order, but boasting of two vines which produced two bunches of grapes in the season, which might be eaten, and a walnut tree, from which I gathered almost sixpence-worth of walnuts." Here stood the quaint china barrels she often referred to as " noblemen s seats," but Carlyle generally used one of the ,kitchen chairs by preference. He found the garden " of admirable comfort in the smoking way," and sometimes in summer would have his writing-table placed under an awning stretched for that purpose, and with a tray full of books at his side would work there when the heat drove him from his garret study. The construction of this sound-proof study was proposed as far back as 1843, but not until ten years later was the enterprise put into practical execu tion. On August llth, 1853, Carlyle wrote to his sister: "At length, after deep deliberation, I have fairly decided to have a top story put upon the house, one big apartment, twenty feet square, with thin doable walls, light from the top, etc., and artfully ventilated, into which no sound can come ; and all the cocks in nature may crow round it without my hearing a whisper of them ! The scheme looked promising on paper, but the result was " irremediably somewhat of a failure." Although the noises in the immediate neighbour hood were excluded, sounds in the distance, "evils that he knew not of" in the lower rooms, became painfully audible ; nevertheless he occupied the room as his study until 1865, and here, "whirled aloft by angry elements," BIOGRAPHICAL NOTE. 39 Carlyle s writing- table and chair see page 33 The ground floor rooms at 5, Cheyne Row see page 28 The kitchen at 5, Cheyne Row see page 32 Mrs. Carlyle s grave see page 26 Carlyle s grave see page 26 lie completed what Dr. Garnett named well "His Thirteen Years War with Frederick." His writing-table and arm-chair stood near the centre, and within easy reach was the little mahogany table for the books lie happened to be using or such of them as were not on the floor. C arlyle bequeathed his writing-table to Sir James Stephen. " I know," he wrote in his will, " he will accept it as a distinguished mark of my esteem. He knows that it belonged to my father-in-law and his daughter, and that I have written all my books upon it, except only Schiller, and that for fifty years azid upwards that are now passed I have considered it among the most precious of my possessions." It was into the ground-floor room at that time spoken of as the "parlour" that Edward Irving was ushered when he paid his one visit to Cheyne Row, in autumn 1834. " I recollect," writes Carlyle in the Reminiscence*, " how he complimented her (as well he might) on the pretty little room she had made for her husband and self ; and, running his eye over her dainty bits of arrangement, ornamentations (all so frugal, simple, full of grace, propriety, and ingenuity as they ever were), said, smiling : You are like an Eve, and make a little Paradise wherever you are. No description of Carlyle s Chelsea home would be complete without mention of the kitchen where Mrs. Carlyle made marmalade " pure as liquid amber, in taste and look almost poetically delicate " ; and where, too, she stirred Leigh Hunt s endlessly admirable morsel of Scotch porridge." Readers of the Letters mid Memorial* will obtain many glimpses of this apartment and its occupants. The fittings were very old-fashioned, espe cially the open kitchen-range with its " kettle-crane " and " movable niggards." The dresser which stood there in 1834 remains against the south wall ; the table still stands in the centre, and there is a sink in the corner beside the disconnected pump. When Carlyle was resting at Dumfries, after the exhaustion of his triumphant Inaugural Address upon his installation as Lord Rector of Edinburgh University, he received the announcement of his wife s sudden death whilst driving in her carriage in Hyde Park on April 21st, 18(5(3. The effect of the calamity upon him was terrible. " There is no spirit in me to write," lie said, "though I try it sometimes." Mrs. Carlyle was buried in Haddington Church. " I laid her in the grave of her father," writes Carlyle in the Ih iiiiiim encex, "according to covenant of forty years back, and all was ended. In the nave of old Abbey Kirk, long a ruin, now being saved from further decay, with the skies looking down on her, there sleeps my little Jeannie, and the light of her face will never shine on me more." The inscription on Carlyle s tombstone is very simple : the family crest (two wyverns), the family motto (Humilitate), and then these few words : "Here rests Thomas Carlyle, who was born at Ecclefechan, 4th December, I79o, and died at 24, Cheyne Row, Chelsea, London, 011 Saturday, oth February, 1881. "No monument," writes Froude, "is needed for one who has made an eternal memorial for himself in the hearts of all to whom truth is the dearest of possessions." THOMAS CARLYLE NOTE ON SOME PORTRAITS OF THOMAS CARLYLE. From a portrait by Daniel Maclise, R.A. see page 5 From a sketch by Count D Orsay (1839) see page 7 From Sir J. E. Boehm s gold medallion see page 15 From a drawing by E. J. Sullivan see page 24 From the painting by J. McNeill Whistler seepage 13 From the painting by G. F. Watts, R.A., act. 73 see page 30 From the portrait painted by Sir J. E. Millais, P.R.A. see page 27 From a statue by Sir J. E. Boehm, R.A. see page 35 Tins portrait is now in the Victoria and Albert Museum. " Carlyle," writes David Hannay in the Magazine of Art, "already the author of Sartor Reaurtus, stands leaning against the traditional pillar with the con ventional air of colourless good breeding. There is neither line in his face nor light in his eye." " He (D Orsay) has contrived," says the same writer, "to make Carlyle look like the hero of a lady s novel an excellent young man with a curl in his upper lip and a well-combed head of hair." The medallion has been reproduced from a wood engraving by Pearson. It was presented to Carlyle in 187-% on his eightieth birthday, by friends and admirers in Edinburgh. " Professor Diogenes Teufelsdrockh, of Weissnichtwo, is nothing if he is not Carlyle in disguise, the projection of the Scotchman s individuality upon a half-humorous, half-philosophical German background." Ernest Rhys : Introductory Note to Sartor Resartus. " Mr. Whistler, in the Glasgow Corporation Art Galleries, has distinctly succeeded in making the face of Carlyle interesting. He has avoided any thing like exaggeration. He has not tried to make capital out of the rugged mass of the hair, or to give a wild-man-of-the-woods look to the face by laying stress on its deep lines and stern contours. The head is noble, quiet, and sad. The artist has tried to paint a serious portrait rather than to give a view, and he has succeeded." David Hannay in the Magazine of Art. This portrait, executed for John Forster, who was very pleased with it, is now in the National Portrait Gallery. Carlyle himself describes it as "a delirious-looking mountebank, full of violence, awkwardness, atrocity, and stupidity, without recognisable likeness to anything I have ever known in any feature of me. Fnit in fatix. What care I, after all ? Forster is much content." The picture by Millais, also in the National Portrait Gallery, was painted in 1877 for Mr. J. A. Froude. His opinion of it was as follows : " And yet under Millais s hands the old Carlyle stood again upon the canvas as I had not seen him for thirty years. The inner secret of the features had been evidently caught. There was a likeness which no sculptor, no photographer, had yet equalled or approached. Afterwards, I knew not how, it seemed to fade away. Millais grew dissatisfied witli his work, and, I believe, never completed it." In the gardens on the Chelsea Embankment stands a statue of Thomas Carlyle in bron/e by the late Sir Edgar Boehm, which was placed there by subscription in 1882. Mr. Froude considered it "as satisfactory a likeness in face and figure as could be rendered in sculpture ; and the warm regard which had grown up between the artist and Carlyle had enabled Boehm to catch with more than common success the shifting changes of his expression." THOMAS CARLYLE S WORKS. The only complete editions of CARLYLE are those published by MESSRS. CHAPMAN & HALL, INCLUDING THE CENTENARY EDITION. EDITED, WITH INTRODUCTIONS, BY H. D. TRAILL, D.C.L. In 30 volumes, square crown 8vo. Price $s. 6d. per Volume. The Centenary Edition is the most complete edition of CARLYLE S Works yet issued, containing several essays and minor writings never before published in a collected form. The volumes are printed on light paper, and bound in dark blue cloth. The illustrations consist mainly of photogravure and steel portraits, the majority of which, including some of THOMAS CARLYLE, have never appeared in any existing edition ; maps and plans. THE PEOPLE S EDITION. In 37 volumes, small crown 8vo, red cloth. Separate volumes, is. THE CHELSEA EDITION. In special red cloth binding, n volumes, with gilt tops, i 51. net. AND THE NEW EDINBURGH EDITION (ON INDIA PAPER), Price 2s. net, cloth ; 2s. 6d. net, leather. VOLUMES NOW READY. THE FRENCH REVOLUTION. Complete in i vol. SARTOR RESARTUS: On Heroes, Hero-Worship, and the Heroic in History: Past and Present, i vol. THE LIFE OF SCHILLER AND THE LIFE OF JOHN STERLING. i vol. SEND TWOPENCE FOR ILLUSTRATED BOOKLET giving a life of CARLYLE and full particulars of all the copyright editions of his works. CHAPMAN & HALL LTD., n, HENRIETTA STREET, COVENT GARDEN, W.C. A MAGAZINE DE LUXE FOR BOOK READERS. VERY READER of these lines is a book buyer and a book reader. We want every reader of these lines to become a reader of "THE BOOKMAN." If you are not acquainted with THE BOOKMAN/ will you kindly send a postcard to the Publishers for -a specimen copy, which will gladly be forwarded to all readers of this Booklet. " " THE BOOKMAN s edited by Dr. Robertson Nicoll, and is published during the first week of every month, price 6d. net. * THE BOOKMAN * is the only monthly magazine devoted exclusively to the interests of book readers. THE BOOKMAN" is the only periodi cal which in any adequate way chronicles the literary life of the day in pictures as well as letterpress. THE BOOKMAN " has already the largest circulation of any purely literary paper published in the king- dom, and its sales have increased enormously during the last twelve months. THE BOOKMAN " is the best illustrated guide to the best books of the day. "THE BOOKMAN" makes appeal to everyone who is interested in the literature of the day. ** THE BOOKMAN " is not a dry-as-dust magazine for specialists. Every line and every picture it contains is of peculiar interest to the great and ever-increasing public that delights in books. THE BOOKMAN" is the periodical for those who want to keep in touch with the books most worth reading and with the authors most worth knowing. "THE BOOKMAN" con tains each month a separate plate portrait, printed by the finest process of half-tone photogravure. These portraits, forming as they do a unique Gallery of Famous Modern Authors, have been immensely ap preciated, and many readers of THE BOOKMAN" 1-- a, complete series framed walls. Among the p have given greatest satist portraits of Carlyle, Browning, Dickens, Sec eray, Jane Austen, Ruskir Louis Stevenson, George Mae Thomas Hardy, Alexandre Du7>as, Tolstoy, Swinburne, J. M. Barife, Herbert Spencer, A. Conan Doyle, Alfred Austin, George Eliot , Matthew Arnold, etc., etc* n, ck- >bert "THE BOOKMAN" con tains each month an article on some prominent author of the day, written by an eminent critic and magnifi cently illustrated throughout, articles on topics of literary interest by well- known writers, reviews of the best new books written by the first authorities, several pages of the freshest literary news, reports as to the best selling books of the month, articles on new writers of promise, etc., etc. THE BOOKMAN" thus fulfils in a manner never before attempted the requirements of the great book-loving public. " THE BOOKMAN" is published during the first week of every month, price 6d. net. HODDER & STOUGHTON, 27, Paternoster Row, London, E.C.