UC-NRLF
$B b3M 3bS
[!lZl«:^,>tU«tfffir ■
/V w .A
"V '^r
V ^^Tp:t€^
..«'
■*.
■*.
>
^ife
.«• A«i!
%
.#
/*\
V ^^"^ ^
rti ) '^^-^^
s<
xn afkefif.
rif /?/■/»
THE SYSTEM OF TAXATION IN CHINA
IN THE TSING DYNASTY, 16444911
BY
SHAO-KWAN CHEN, A. M.
SUBMITTED IN PARTIAL FULFILMENT OF THE REQUIREMENTS
FOR THE DEGREE OF DOCTOR OF PHILOSOPHY
IN THE
Faculty of Political Science
IN Columbia University
NEW YORK
I914
Copyright. 1914
BY
SHAO-KWAN CHEN
n
n
Zo tbe
Memory of My Father
MR. BING-CHANG CHEN
WHO DIED IN I913 WHEN I
WAS STUDYING IN THE
UNITED STATES
PREFACE
The several Chinese standard works on the institutions
of the Tsing Dynasty, 1644-1911, give us simply historical
descriptions of taxation and there seems to be room for a
scientific treatise, not too detailed in historical facts of
similar nature or in local variations of insignificance, de-
signed for both Occidental and Oriental readers wishing a
general survey of our taxation system as it survives to-day.
The present work is an attempt to generalize logically the
facts connected with taxation in the Tsing Dynasty and to
interpret their causes and effects scientifically. It includes
those taxes of considerable importance which are univer-
sally imposed in all the provinces. It is not worth while to
discuss those taxes which have not developed into the typi-
cal systems of the Tsing Dynasty either due to their insig-
nificant yield or due to the fact that they are merely pro-
vincial special taxes which have been created during the
last two decades of financial chaos, and subject only tO' the
temporary regulations of the respective provinces. On the
other hand, the discussion of the political organization is
absolutely necessary to a clear conception of the system.
Consequently, we have to treat the government of the
Tsing Dynasty and its expenditures and revenues. In con-
nection with this treatment, the same plan of generalization
and interpretation is followed.
As to the sources of information, the facts have been
selected chiefly from the two standard works published by
the government, vis., the Institutes of the Tsing Dynasty,
and th^ Amendments of, the Institutes of the Tsing Dynasty.
149] 7
8 PREFACE [150
The facts have been chosen as carefully as possible
and arranged systematically according to my plan. In the
main, the work of generalization and interpretation is based
upon personal knowledge and observation. In this way, it
is hoped that the present work will fulfil the object of ren-
dering service to the readers. But it must be frankly ad-
mitted that this work is by no means satisfactory from the
statistical standpoint, but this is because nobody can solve
the mystery of the financial conditions in all the provinces
of China owing to the inefficiency of the financial control.^
My chief obligations in connection with this book are to
Professor E. R. A. Seligman, for the sincere inspiration
and the valuable supervision of the whole work, and to Mr.
R. M. Haig for his valuable review of the manuscript, his
numerous suggestions and his reading of the proof.
Shao-Kwan Chen.
Columbia University, March 26, 1914.
1 Cf. infra, pp. 106-107.
CONTENTS
CHAPTER I
The Chinese Government
PACK
Forms of Government — The Emperor — The Council of State — The
Department of Foreign Affairs— Departments of Internal Affairs
— The Department of Finance— General Position and Powers of
Heads of Departments — The Censorate — Less Important Depart-
ments— Territorial Divisions of Government— Provincial Admin-
istration—Local Administration — General Features of Govern-
ment II
CHAPTER II
Expenditures and Revenues
Classification of Expenditures — Comparative Importance of Expen-
ditures— Sources of Revenue — Appropriations — Transportation of
Products — Balance of Expenditures and Revenues— General Fea-
tures of Expenditure and Revenue 31
CHAPTER III
Taxation of Land
The Land System — The Land Policy— The Tax System— The Land
Rent — The Exemption of Payment — Existing Rates — Adminis-
trative Rules— General Features of the Land Tax 47
CHAPTER IV
Taxation of Salt
Production of Salt — Consumption of Salt — Distribution of Salt —
Taxation of Salt — Smuggling of Salt — Administration of the Salt
Monopoly— General Features of the Salt Monopoly 70
iSi] 9
10 CONTENTS [1^2
FAGS
CHAPTER V
Taxation of Commodities
The Regular Customs — The Likin Duty 93
Conclusion 106
Appendices 108
Bibliography 118
CHAPTER I
The Chinese Government, 1644-1911 ^
Forms of Government
Even though her great philosophers, like Confucius,
Mencius and many others, advocated the theory of democ-
racy, China, before 191 1, was a monarchy. Its most im-
portant aspects may be described as follows :
( 1 ) The Chinese government was monarchic, hereditary
and unlimited. It was monarchic and unlimited, because
the Emperor, representing the state as well as the govern-
ment, possessed both the sovereign and the governmental
powers of the land. Furthermore, the hereditary principle
was maintained not only by the right of inheritance but
also as a means to the end of stable government.
(2) The Chinese government was consolidated and cen-
tralized. It was not divided into three independent depart-
ments, as the legislature, the executive and the judiciary.
The Emperor, in the exercise of his powers, found it neces-
sary to create several departments to take charge of the
legislation and supervision of laws and several judicial
courts to administer justice. These offices, together with
the Council of State, generally known as the Grand Coun-
cil, constituted, as we shall see, the imperial government.
1 The reorganization of government in the period 1906-1911 is not
considered for three reasons, (a) It did not affect the typical system
of the Tsing Dynasty, (b) It was an unnecessary and unsystematic
reform causing a confusion of powers rather than a better distri-
bution of powers, (c) It bore no relation to the tax systems.
153] II
12 THE SYSTEM OF TAXATION IN CHINA [1^4
Subordinate to it were the provincial governments, each
with a governor^ at its .head. Owing to the fact
that a highly centralized government was not suited to a
state like China with vast territory and different economic
conditions, numerous grants of powers had to be made to
the governors in order that they might adapt the execution
of the laws to local conditions. But this does not mean
that the Chinese government was decentralized. First of
all, the governors were subject to the will of the Emperor.
Secondly, the heads of the imperial governmental depart-
ments made the laws which the governors were bound to
obey, unless they disregarded certain laws with the consent
of the Emperor. Thirdly, the grand councillors, being the
advisers of the Emperor, were more influential than any
other high officials in the imperial and provincial govern-
ments.
In conclusion, China had a monarchic, hereditary, un-
limited, consolidated and centralized government. Unfor-
tunately, the political philosophies of Confucius and many
other great writers were not carried out in early times, and
China did not become a democratic state until the Revolu-
tion of 191 1. With the exception of the Emperor, how-
ever, the whole government rested upon a popular basis,
because the candidates for lower offices were chosen by
competitive examinations held in the national and provin-
cial capitals, while the vacancies of higher offices were filled
by those selected among the lower officials. It is true that
only a minority of the subjects participated in the actual
work of government. But every male subject had equal
chance to pass the examinations in order to be admitted to
the government. In case of failure in any one examination,
he might take a series of examinations during his life. Al-
1 In this book, I identify the governor-general with the governor.
For the reason of this, cf. infra, pp. 23-24.
1 2^] THE CHINESE GOVERNMENT 13
though the ideal government is one in which every member
of the state has a share, a government such as the one which
existed, in which every member might have a share, is far
from undesirable.
The Emperor
As China was a monarchic state, the Emperor enjoyed
the sovereign power. His powers were neither enumerated
nor residual. He might be deprived of power only by a
successful revolution. As long as he was in power, the
governmental machinery was created and preserved by him,
and all the officials thereof were responsible only to him.
His orders were the laws of the country. By the word
" order " is meant not merely his personal orders but also
all the laws, drafted by his ministers with or without
amendments by him, and promulgated by him in the form
of an imperial order. In foreign relations, he represented
the country. Treaties and other agreements were promul-
gated by imperial orders as a part of the law of the land.
Of course, he also had power to declare both offensive and
defensive wars.
The Council of State
(i) The Inner Cabinet. The Inner Cabinet (Nai Ko)
was the old Council of State. It had two Chinese and two
Manchu ministers appointed by the Emperor through the
nomination of the Inner Cabinet itself. In addition,
there were two or four associate ministers, of which one-
half were Chinese and the other half Manchus. They were
selected from the heads of departments by the Emperor
himself. Under these ministers there were different classes
of secretaries. Their most important functions were:
(a) The discussion of state affairs.
(b) The promulgation of imperial orders.
(c) The conduct of great ceremonials attended by the
Emperor.
14 THE SYSTEM OF TAXATION IN CHINA [156
The Inner Cabinet lasted until the end of the Tsing
Dynasty. But its great powers had been gradually trans-
ferred to the Military Council.
(2) The Military Council. The Military Council
(Tsuen Tse Chu), known to the Western people as the
Grand Council, was created by Emperor Yung Tsing, 1723-
^735> primarily for the discussion of military affairs. It
was not an established office but simply a body of advisers
of the Emperor. Its members were chosen from the min-
isters of the Inner Cabinet and the heads of different de-
partments, and called the Ministers of Military Affairs or
Grand Councillors. The number was not fixed, varying
from four to six. Being the advisers of the Emperor, they
gradually encroached upon the power of the Inner Cabinet
with respect to the civil affairs. They had a certain number
of secretaries. Their chief powers and duties were as fol-
lows:
(a) The issue of decrees to announce the Emperor's
acts, to approve or veto a memorial, to order an approved
memorial to be adopted in the provinces and to order a gov-
ernor's memorial to be considered by a department.
(b) The issue of orders to give instructions to the Im-
perial Ministers in the dependencies and to the governors
in the provinces.
(c) The discussion of state affairs.
(d) The trial of the most important judicial cases when-
ever ordered by the Emperor.
(e) The investigation of military and financial affairs in
time of war.
(f) The nomination of cabinet ministers, heads of de-
partments, governors, heads of provincial departments, cer-
tain circuit governors, certain prefects, generals, lieuten-
ant-generals, commissioners of examinations and superin-
tendents of customs.
1^7] THE CHINESE GOVERNMENT 15
The Department of Foreign Affairs
Organization and functions. The Dq)artment of For-
eign Affairs was created in 1861 under the name Tsung Li
Ydmen. It was controlled by a number of princes, minis-
ters and adjunct ministers. The various classes of de-
partmental heads, whose number was not fixed, were se-
lected by the Emperor himself, the princes from the various
classes of princes, the ministers from the ministers of the
Military Council (the Council of State), ^ the adjunct min-
isters from the ministers of the Inner Cabinet (the old
Council of State) " and the heads of the other departments.
Their functions were to make all kinds of treaties and
agreements involving the tariff, the regulation of inter-
national commerce, the questions of territories, the settle-
ment of relations between the non-Christians and Chris-
tians and other kinds of intercourse. These functions were
distributed among a general committee and five special
committees which were made up by a certain number of
Chinese and Manchu secretaries.
The Departments of Internal Affairs
Organization and functions. Among the departments
which are not worthy of consideration so far as actual
government is concerned, six were well developed, namely,
the civil-service, financial, ceremonial, military, judicial and
public works departments. All the different matters requir-
ing attention from the government would fall under one of
these six departments. Each department had two presi-
dents, one being Chinese and the other Manchus, and four
vice-presidents, two being Chinese and the other two Man-
chus. It was found necessary to make a further division
of work, and thus a certain number of bureaus were estab-
1 Cf. supra, p. 14. - Cf. supra, p. 13.
1 6 THE SYSTEM OF TAXATION IN CHINA [i^g
lished in each department. The distribution of business
among the bureaus was made in accordance with its nature.
But this method was not always followed, because the quan-
tity of certain matters was too great to be transacted by a
single bureau. In that case the work was divided accord-
ing to geographical lines as well as according to the nature
of the function. In other words, a function was generally
discharged by several bureaus. Each bureau had three
classes of secretaries, and each class consisted of a certain
number of Chinese, Mongolians and Manchus.
The Department of. Finance (Hu-Pu)
Among the six departments of internal affairs as men-
tioned above, the Department of Finance should be de-
scribed more fully, because the administration of finance
was one of the most important functions of the Chinese
government. It framed and supervised the laws concern-
ing territory and population. It had power to divide the
country into administrative divisions,^ vis., provinces, pre-
fectures and districts; to classify the population according
to the permanent occupation and home ; to survey the land
of the country; to equalize the burden of taxation and ser-
vice; to appropriate the ordinary expenditures of the gov-
ernment; and to adjust the amount of reserved grain. It
had the following bureaus :
(A) The Bureau of Kiang-nan^ audited the accounts of
the land tax of Kiang-nan Provinces and the accounts of
the government silk factories in the City of Nan-king and
the City of Soo-chozv in Kiang-su Province; and prepared
the annual reports concerning the amount of the balance
1 Cf. infra, pp. 22-23.
■ Kiang-nan is the collective name of the two provinces, Kiang-su
and An-hwei.
I^p] THE CHINESE GOVERNMENT 17
charge ^ of the land tax in certain provinces, and the de-
ferred payment of the land tax in all the provinces.
(B) The Bureau of Che-kiang audited the accounts of
the land tax of Che-kiang Province and the accounts of the
government silk factory in the City of Hang-chow in Che-
kiang Province ; and prepared the annual reports concerning
the number of population and the quantity of grain pro-
duced in all the provinces.
(C) The Bureau of Kiang-si audited the accounts of
the land tax of Kiang-si Province ; and prepared the reports
of the inter-provincial support of military expenses.
(D) The Bureau of Fii-kien audited (a) the accounts
of duties on commodities carried in native vessels to Tien-
tsin, Chi-li Province; (b) the accounts of the land tax of
Fu-kien and Chi-li Provinces; and (c) the accounts of cer-
tain unprescribed expenses drawn from the treasury of the
Department of Finance.
(E) The Bureau of Hu-kwang ^ audited (a) the ac-
counts of the land tax of Hu-kwang Provinces; (b) the ac-
counts of regular customs in Hu-peh Province; and (c) the
accounts of local supplementary taxes on land, commodi-
ties {i. e., regular customs duties), salt and tea in all the
provinces.
(F) The Bureau of Shan-tung had the following duties:
(a) The auditing of the accounts of the land tax of
Shang-hmg , Feng-Hen, Ki-rin and Hei-lung-kiang Pro-
vinces.
(b) The payment of bonus to the " Eight Banners " ^
military officers.
1 This is charged for the loss due to inaccurate weighing.
2 Hu-kwang is the collective name of the two provinces, Hu-peh and
Hu-nan.
8 The Tartar soldiers are divided into eight corps, each having a
colored banner, viz., pure yellow, mixed yellow, pure white, mixed
white, pure red, mixed red, pure blue and mixed blue. The Chinese
force has the green banner.
1 8 THE SYSTEM OF TAXATION IN CHINA [i^q
(c) The control of salt and ginseng monopolies.
(G) The Bureau of Shan-si audited the accounts of the
land tax of Shan-si Province.
(H) The Bureau of Ho-nan audited the accounts of the
land tax of Ho-nan Province, and the military expenses of
the City of Sahara in Mongolia; investigated any report
designated by the Emperor; and urged the revision of pro-
vincial reports on any sort of outlay not accepted by the
Department of Finance.
(I) The Bureau of Shen-si discharged three functions,
namely,
(a) The auditing of the accounts of the land tax of
Shen-si, Kan-su and Chinese Turkestan Provinces.
(b) The control of the tea monopoly.
(c) The disbursement of the expenditures of the im-
perial government.
(J) The Bureau of Sze-chuen, in addition to its other
minor duties, performed the following two functions :
(a) The auditing of the accounts of the land tax and
regular custom revenues of Sze-chuen Province.
(b) The collection of reports on the condition of har-
vest in all the provinces.
(K) The Bureau of Kwang-tung audited the accounts of
the land tax of Kwang-tung Province.
(L) The Bureau of Kwang-si was entrusted with the
following important business :
(a) The auditing of the accounts of the land tax and
regular customs duties of Kwang-si Province.
(b) The regulation of mining.
(c) The coinage.
(M) The Bureau of Yun-nan had charge of the follow-
ing affairs :
(a) The auditing of the accounts of the land tax of Yun-
nan Province.
l6i] THE CHINESE GOVERNMENT 19
(b) The investigation of the report on the collection of
mining royalty in Yun-nan Province.
(c) The care of matters concerning the transportation
of grain from certain provinces to Peking.
(N) The Bureau of Kwei-chow audited the accounts of
the land tax of Kwei-chow Province, and supervised the
administration of both the regular and maritime customs
throughout the country.
In addition to the above fourteen bureaus there were the
following organizations :
(A) Three treasuries, viz., money, satin and sundry
articles, under the control of four ministers appointed on
the nomination of the department.
(B) Four mints in Peking under the control of two
vice-presidents of the department.
(C) Thirteen granaries in Peking and Peh-tung-chow^
under the control of two high officials having the rank
of a vice-president of a department.
(D) The Committee of Appropriation.^
(E) The Committee of Cash Payment of the " Eight
Banners " Soldiers.
General Position and Powers of Heads of Departments
The heads of every department were appointed and re-
moved by the Emperor with or without the advice of the
Council of State. They assumed joint responsibility to
the Emperor only. They, however, might be impeached by
any high official or censor who had power to present me-
morials to the Throne. But an impeachment did not nec-
essarily cause the removal of a departmental head, be-
cause the Emperor might not approve the impeachment.
Therefore, any head of a department remained in service
1 Peh-tung-chow is a river port near Peking.
2 Cf. infra, p. 34.
20 THE SYSTEM OF TAXATION IN CHINA [162
until removed for one of the following causes, vis., promo-
tion, change, degradation or dismissal of office, death of
parents, absence, or retirement. There follows a summary
of the general powers of the heads of departments.
(i) The participation in the conference on important
matters ordered to be discussed by the nine departments.^
(2) The making and amendment of laws subject to the
approval of the Emperor.
(3) The supervision in the execution of laws. This
means that the heads of departments had power to approve
or disapprove the provincial reports concerning the exercise
of functions. But they had no right to direct the governors
how to execute the laws because they did not know the local
conditions.
(4) The nomination of certain subordinate officials, not
nominated by the Department of Civil Service.
(5) The removal of subordinate officials by impeach-
ment through memorials presented to the Throne. Such
impeachments were usually accepted by the Emperor.
(6) The direction and supervision of the subordinate
officials.
The C ens orate
(i) Organization. The Censorate (Tu-Tsar Yuen) had
at its head two chief censors (a Chinese and a Manchus)
and four associate censors (two Chinese and two Manchus)
who were appointed by the Emperor. Under them there
were six groups of censors adopting the names of the six
departments, vis., civil, financial, ceremonial, military, judi-
cial and public works, and fifteen groups of censors taking
1 The nine departments include the six departments mentioned above,
vis., the civil, financial, ceremonial, military, judicial and public works
departments, and in addition the Censorate, the High Court and the
Department for the Transmission of Memorials.
163] THE CHINESE GOVERNMENT 2 1
the names of the different provmces. Each group of cen-
sors was composed of two Chinese and two Manchus.
They were appointed among the candidates of censors who
had been previously selected from the secretaries of var-
ious departments.
(2)' Powers of the censors. The general duty of the
chief censors and associate censors was to look after the
faithful execution of the laws of the country and to pre-
vent violation of law or neglect by any official, either im-
perial or provincial. They were vested with freedom of
speech. The departmental censors and provincial censors
were supposed to assist the chief censors and associate cen-
sors in the exercise of the general power of the Censorate.
But they also had the right to communicate freely with the
Emperor by means of memorials. When any censor did
not satisfy the Emperor, he was ordered to return to his
previous department without punishment.
The Less Important Departments
Besides the foregoing branches there were many other
offices of which only the following need be mentioned :
(i) The Department of Dependencies' Affairs {Li Fan
Yuen).
(2) The Department of the Imperial Clan's Affairs
{T Sling Yin Fu).
(3) The Department of Palace Affairs {Niii Wu Feu).
(4) The Department of Astronomy {Tsin Tien Tsan).
(5) The Department of Imperial Doctors (Tai Yi
Yuen).
(6) The Department of Literary Men (Han Lin Yuen).
(7) The Department of Heir Tutors (Tsien Shi Feu).
(8) The Department of Imperial Worship Ceremonies
(Tai Shiang Tsi).
(9) The Department of Horse-Breeding (Tai Pu Tsi).
22 THE SYSTEM OF TAXATION IN CHINA [164
(10) The Department of Imperial Feasts {Kwang Lm.
Tsi).
(11) The Department of Palace Ceremonies (Heng Lu
Tsi).
(12) The High Court (Ta Li Tsi).
Territorial Divisions of Government
Excluding Mongolia and Tibet, China was divided into
twenty-two provinces (Sheng). In some cases, a province
was governed by a governor-general {Tsung Tu), such as
Chi-li and Sse-chuen. In other cases a province had a gov-
ernor (ShUn Fn), for example, Shan-tung, Shan-si, and
Ho-nan. In general, a more important province was under
the immediate jurisdiction of a governor-general, while a
less important province was governed by a governor with
the nominal supervision of a governor-general. Under the
governor-general or governor were the heads of the Ex-
ecutive Department {Bu Tseng Shi), and the Judicial De-
partment {An Tsar Shi) and a number of circuit gover-
nors (Tao Tai). Each province was composed of a num-
ber of prefectures (Fu) and direct districts (Chi Li Chow
or Chi Li Ting),^ so-called because they were under the
direct control of the Executive Department like the pre-
fectures. The ruler of a prefecture was called a prefect
(Tsi Fu), and that of a direct district, a superior magis-
trate (Chi Li Chow Tsi Chow or Chi Li Ting Tung Tsi),^
and he was charged with the functions of a magistrate and
the powers of a prefect. The lowest but most important
units of administration were the districts (Shien),^ several
of which made up a prefecture or a direct district. The ad-
1 Certain Chi Li Ting were not composed of a number of sub-
ordinate districts as all the Chi Li Chow were.
2 Certain Chi Li Ting Tung Tsi had hot the powers of a prefect as
all the Chi Li Chow Tsi Chow had. See note i.
•^ Some districts were called in Chinese Ting or Chow.
165] THE CHINESE GOVERNMENT 23
ministrator of a district was called a magistrate {Tsi
Shien)} All the above officials were known as the seal-
holders {Tseng Yin Kwan), i. e., the chief officers or re-
sponsible officers. Their respective subordinates were re-
garded merely as assistant officers, and could not act with-
out instructions.
Provincial A dministration
( I ) The governor-general or governor. The governor-
general or governor was appointed by the Emperor. The.
governor-general also had the titles of the Chief Censor of
the Censorate and the President of the Department of Mili-
tary Service ; and the governor, the titles of the Associate
Censor of the Censorate and the Vice-President of the De-
partment of Military Service. Both of them remained in ser-
vice unless prevented by promotion, change, degradation or
dismissal of office, retirement, death of parents or absence.
The governor-general was different from the governor inas-
much as that the former had the nominal power of super-
vision over the government in the latter's sphere of author-
ity, besides the virtual powers of direction and supervision
over the administration of his own immediate jurisdiction.
Practically, however, each province had only one head,
either a governor-general or a governor. The powers of the
governor-general or governor may be fully stated as fol-
lows:
(A) The nomination of certain circuit governors, pre-
fects, magistrates and military officers lower than the lieu-
tenant-generals.
(B) The removal, by means of impeachment, of any
civil or military official appointed through the Council of
State, the Department of Civil Service and the Department
of Military Service as well as through his own nomination.
1 Some magistrates were called in Chinese Tung Tsi (the admin-
istrator of a Ting) or Tsi Chow (the administrator of a Chow).
24 THE SYSTEM OF TAXATION IN CHINA [i66
(C) Such direction and supervision of the actions of all
his subordinates as seemed desirable.
(D) The furnishing of such supplementary ordinances
as might be necessary to the execution of law, subject to
the approval of the Emperor.
(E) Remonstrances to laws or appointments. If the
Emperor accepted the objection, the laws or appointments
were ordered to be amended or changed by the departments.
Otherwise the governor had to accept them.
(F) The initiation of laws which were generally ordered
to be discussed by the departments.
(G) The execution of laws.
(H) The administration of justice.
(1) The command of the Chinese forces within the juris-
diction. Armed with these powers, the governor-general
or governor proceeded to discharge his executive and judi-
cial functions through the Executive Department and the
Judicial Department.
(2) The Executive Department and the Judicial Depart-
ment. The tenure and term of office of the head of each
department were the same as those of the governor. Each
head of department had the right to direct and supervise
the actions of all his subordinates. It was through the divi-
sion of functions according to their character that these two
departments were distinguished from each other. In other
words, the Executive Department discharged the executive
functions, of which the most important is the financial; and
the Judicial Department had to try and to determine the
cases of appeals and to give the final decisions of cases in-
volving murder or robbery, removed from the districts.
(3) The circuit governor was appointed on the nomina-
tion of the governor or the Department of Civil Service,
except in a very few cases when the Emperor made the ap-
pointment. After the expiration of a term, of six, seven
167] THE CHINESE GOVERNMENT 25
or eight years ^ the circuit governor was usually pro-
moted; otherwise he remained in service until he encoun-
tered one of the following conditions : change, degradation,
removal from office, retirement, death of parents or absence.
He was charged with the general duty of preserving public
order within his circuit composed of a number of pre-
fectures and direct districts. In fulfilling his duty, he acted
as a connecting link between the civil officials and the mili-
tary officers. In other words, he was the man to judge
when it was necessary to use arms for the suppression of
riots, the execution of laws and the administration of jus-
tice. He had power to direct and supervise the prefects
and magistrates and to demand the help of the Chinese
forces in his circuit. For governmental purposes he resided
in the most important city in his circuit.
Local Administration
(i) The prefect. The tenure and term of office of the
ruler of a prefecture were similar to those of the circuit
governor. He had no territory and population under his
own immediate government.^ His powers were to try and
to determine the cases of appeals, to review the cases origi-
nally decided by the magistrates and to direct and supervise
the actions of all his subordinates.
(2) The superior magistrate. Each direct district was
divided into several parts, one of which was under the im-
mediate government of the superior magistrate himself,
while the other parts, constituting the subordinate districts,
were governed by a corresponding number of magistrates
under his supervision. It was noticed that the tenure of
^ The duration of term was different in different provinces.
2 The prefects of a few prefectures had immediate jurisdictions. In
those cases the powers and duties of the prefects were like those of
the superior magistrates.
26 THE SYSTEM OF TAXATION IN CHINA [i68
office and functions of the superior magistrate were like
those of a magistrate, the term of office being six, seven or
eight years. The former was distinguished from the latter
only by the possession of the powers of a prefect.
Number of Local Administrative Districts in the Different
Provinces
Province ^ Districts Direct Districts Total
. Chi-li 144 II 15s
Feng-tien 21 3 24
Ki-rin 7 2 9
Hei-lung-kiang 2 2
Shan-tung 105 2 107
Shan-si 98 10 108
Ho-nan 103 4 107
Kiang-su 67 4 71
An-hwei 55 5 60
Kiang-si 78 I 79
Fu-kien 64 2 66
Che-kiang 78 r 79
Hu-peh 67 1 68
Hu-nan 67 9 76
Shen-si 85 5 90
Kan-su 59 7 66
Turkestan 11 15 26
Sze-chuen 131 12 143
Kwang-tung 85 10 95
Kw^ang-si 66 S 71
Yun-nan 75 8 83
Kwei-chow 57 15 72
Total 1523 134 1657
1 The figures of Chi-li, Feng-tien, Ki-rin, Kwang-si and Kwei-chow
include those administrative units under the immediate administration
of the prefects themselves. These units were practically direct dis-
tricts, and the prefects had exactly the same powers and duties of
superior magistrates. Owing to thin population and restriction of cul-
tivation, Manchuria {Feng-tien, Ki-rin, Hei-lung-kiang) and Turkestan
had not been organized as provinces until in late years, Turkestan in
1884 and Manchuria in 1906. In 1902 nine districts were added to the
original number in Turkestan; in the period 1906-1907 nine districts, in
Ki-rin ; and in the period 1904-1908 thirty-five districts, in Hei-lung-kiang.
169] THE CHINESE GOVERNMENT 27
(3) The magistrate. The ruler of a subordinate district
of a prefecture or a direct district was called the magistrate.
The magistrates of certain districts were appointed on the
nomination of the governor, while in other districts they
were selected by the Department of Civil Service. After
the expiration of a term of ten years the magistrate was
usually promoted ; otherwise he remained in service as long
as one of the following conditions did not arise: change,
degradation or dismissal from office, retirement, death of
parents or absence. Under the direction and supervision of
his superior officials, he discharged the following functions :
(A) The execution of all the administrative laws.
(B) The trial and decision of original cases. But the
decisions involving the penalty of banishment for a limited
time were subject to the approval of the prefect or superior
magistrate ; and the cases of murder or robbery were entitled
to a second trial by the prefect or superior magistrate and
to the final decision of the head of the Judicial Department.
Original cases involving robbery or murder committed
in the immediate jurisdiction of a prefect or superior mag-
istrate and decided by him, must be approved or retried by
the circuit governor.
General Features of Government
In conclusion, we may summarize the important features
of the Chinese Government as follows:
(i) The authority of general powers. As the Emperor
was the sovereign of the state, he was the final interpreter
of the laws of the land. He settled the conflicts of opin-
ions among his ministers whether they were the heads of
departments, governors or others, because they were de-
pendent for tenure upon him. In order to assist him in the
exercise of his powers he had the Council of State. In any
case which involved the councillors, he was obliged to de-
cide without the advice of any other person.
28 THE SYSTEM OF TAXATION IN CHINA [170
(2) The legislative powers. Instead of vesting the legis-
lative powers in a single organization known as the legisla-
ture, the Emperor distributed them among several depart-
ments according to the nature of their functions. The
seven chief departments at Peking were really legislative
departments although they were not shut out from all par-
ticipation in the work of administration, e. g., foreign re-
lations, appropriations of revenue, conduct of public cere-
monials and examinations etc. In the main these depart-
ments were concerned with making and interpreting laws.
This may be illustrated step by step. In the first place,
treaties concluded by the Department of Foreign x\ffairs
were a part of the laws. In the second place, the nomina-
tions by the Department of Civil Service and the Depart-
ment of Military Service for official appointments and re-
movals was merely an interpretation of the civil and military
service laws made by the same. In the third place, the ex-
ecutive functions of the Department of Finance, the De-
partment of Military Service and the Department of Public
Works were mainly connected with the control of finance.
In the fourth place, the Department of Public Ceremonials
and the Department of Military Service merely regulated
the matters of public examinations of civil and military ser-
vices, because the examinations were actually conducted by
the Imperial Examiners, appointed by the Emperor.
(3) The executive powers. The executive powers were
distributed not according to functions but according to ter-
ritories. Therefore, the provincial governments together
form the executive branch of the central government. In
each province, the governor was the chief executive. The
detailed work of administration was performed by the Ex-
ecutive Department, while the general powers of direction
and supervision were delegated to the circuit governors.
But the governor was not deprived of all participation in
171] THE CHINESE GOVERNMENT 29
the work of legislation and in the administration of justice,
because he had not only the power to initiate laws, to object
to them and to issue orders but he had also the power to
control the Judicial Department of his province.
(4) Participation of the localities in administration. The
local officials known as the prefects, the superior magis-
trates and the magistrates were regarded simply as agents
of the central government. All the duties to be performed
by the localities were fixed by the legislative branch of the
central government (the chief department at Peking). Still
there was a realm of action in which the local authorities
possessed large discretion, and they look for their authority
to the executive branch of the central government (the pro-
vincial governments). Thus it is evident that the local au-
thorities were subject to both the legislative and adminis-
trative control.
(5) Subordination of the judicial powers to the other
authorities. The judicial powers, on the one hand, were
subordinated to the executive, because they were exercised
by the Judicial Department and the local authorities, subject
to the supervision of the governor. On the other hand,
they were subject to the legislature, because the Department
of Judicial Affairs exerted the greatest influence over all
judicial cases.
(6) The control over the government. While the heads
of departments at Peking and the governors in the provinces
controlled the actions of their respective subordinate offi-
cials, their actions were in turn controlled by the Emperor
himself. Besides this, there were five other methods of
control. First, the Censorate might hear complaint by any
one person against any other person, no matter whether the
parties involved were officials or not, and report the case
to the Emperor. Secondly, any censor might impeach any
official. Thirdly, any minister might impeach any other
30 THE SYSTEM OF TAXATION IN CHINA [172
minister. Fourthly, the Department of Civil Service might
impeach any civil official according to the civil service laws.
Fifthly, the Department of Military Service might impeach
any military officer in accordance with the military service
laws. Having received the case or impeachment, the Em-
peror referred it to the proper authority, or appointed one
or more ministers to investigate the matter in detail.
(7) An attempt to secure efficient administration in the
provinces. The Department of Civil Service had power tO'
consider the right of changing domicile.^ Such questions
arose when an official applied for naturalization in his resi-
dential province, which was not his ancestral province, or
when he sought to reclaim his standing in his ancestral
province after he had once become naturalized in his resi-
dential province.^ These questions were numerous, because
the law forbade a man to be an official of his native prov-
ince. Undoubtedly this legal limitation had several advan-
tages from the point of view of efficiency of administration
in the provinces. First, when an official was a stranger in a
community, the community, having no intimate relation
with him, could exert less influence over his actions. Sec-
ondly, the government was free to choose proper men to
fill the official posts from the people of all the provinces ex-
cept one, without incurring the danger of bad feelings
among the local communities. Finally, the officials as-
sumed responsibility to the government rather than to the
different communities under their respective jurisdiction, if
they desired to maintain their positions.
1 In China the domicile was determined by the domicile of one's ances-
tors rather than by one's birthplace.
2 The qualifications of admission were the possession of certain kinds
of real property, such as a house or a piece of land, and twenty years
of residence by his grand-parents or parents.
CHAPTER II
Expenditures and Revenues
Classification of Expenditures
From a review of the government functions during the
Tsing Dynasty, it appears that the public expenditures of
China may be classified as follows :
( 1 ) Expenditures for military purposes.
(A) Regular pay of officers and men.
(B) Additional pay of officers.
(2) Expenditures for civil administration.
(A) Salaries of civil officials.
(B) Additional allowances of civil officials.
(3) Expenditures for the Emperor's family.
(A) Imperial tombs' furnishing.
(B) New Year expenses of the Emperor's family.
(C) Silk manufactures for the Emperor's use and
public use.
(4) Expenditures for communication.
(5) Expenditures for the conservation of rivers and
ponds.
(6) Expenditures for social purposes.
(A) Public worship.
(B) Public gifts and charities.
(C) Public schools and scholarships.
(D) Public examinations for the selection of com-
petent men as candidates for public offices.
(7) Expenditures for miscellaneous purposes.
i73] 31
32 THE SYSTEM OF TAXATION IN CHINA [174
Comparative Importance of Expenditures
Among all classes of expenditures, the military expendi-
tures stood in the first rank, because the existence of a state
depends especially on peace. Without an army of sufficient
strength, it is impossible to protect the weak members of a
society against the encroachment of the strong, and to save
the country from the foreign conquest. Next came the ex-
penditures of civil administration which is necessary for
the maintenance of internal order in a civil society. The
two items in the following table of expenditures, styled the
additional allowances of civil and military officials, are due
to the fact that the regular salaries did not suffice to meet
the higher standard of living. Thirdly, the Emperor was a
great consumer of public revenues. The three items con-
stituting the expenditures of the Emperor's family are by
no means exhaustive. They merely represent those sums
paid out of the treasury of the Department of Finance and
of the provincial treasuries. For tw^o reasons, it is impos-
sible to discover the amount of revenues wasted by the Em-
peror, The Department of Palace Affairs, which was charged
with the administration of the imperial finances, was not
subject to the supervision of the Department of Finance.
Moreover, a great many departments of civil administration
were established primarily for the Emperor and their ex-
penses cannot be isolated. In the fourth place, the postal
stations were established primarily for military and other
government services instead of for industrial, fiscal or other
purposes. The object of the expenditures for the conser-
vation of rivers and ponds was to protect agricultural land
against flood or draught. Next follow the expenditures for
social purposes which were composed of four elements.
(a) Public worship.
(b) Public gifts and charities, which included the pur-
chase of boards bearing signs for identifying obedient sons,
175] EXPENDITURES AND REVENUES 33
unmarried widows, persons over one hundred years old, the
gifts of five hundred sine rice and ten rolls of cloth to any
woman giving birth to three sons at the same day, the
expenses connected with care of widows, widowers, father-
less or motherless children, criminals and the defective and
helpless classes.
(c) Public schools and scholarships for the support of
poor students in the district schools.
(d) Public examinations for the selection of competent
men as candidates for public offices.^ •
According to the order of importance, the Department of
Finance made the permanent appropriations for various
functions. In addition there were extraordinary, uncer-
tain or insignificant outlays.
The Status of the Permanent Appropriations during the Nine-
teenth Century
Regular Pay of Military Officers and Men 14,862,9292
Additional Pay of Military Officers 1,398,755
Sundry Expenses in the Army 274,523
Regular Pay of Chinese and Manchu Troops in Peking 5,348,5S6
Regular Salaries of Civil Officials 1,908,086
Additional Allowance of Civil Officials 2,937,369
Salaries of Civil and Military Officials ^ in Peking 196,988
Imperial Tomb's Furnishing 106,861
New Year Expenses of the Imperial Family Paid in Peking 180,000
Silk Manufactures 107,833
Postal Stations 2,147,961
Conservation of Rivers and Ponds 1,618,081
Public Worship 210,615
Public Gifts and Charities 217,420
Public Schools and Scholarships 197,749
Miscellaneous Expenses 4iS,957
Total 32,129,683
1 Cf. Y. S. Ho, Chinese Education from the Western Viewpoint
(New York, 1913), PP- 34-41-
2 The figures are in taels. ^ Manchus are not included.
34 THE SYSTEM OF TAXATION IN CHINA [176
Sources of Public Revenues
In modern countries the revenues expended for public
purposes are often derived from a variety of sources. In
consequence of economic conditions, China, up to the late
years, was content with only one fonn of revenue, namely,
taxation.
The Department of Finance classified the sources of reve-
nues into five items, namely, land taxes {Fu) ; rents
(Tsoo) ; royalties (Kau) ; duties (Shut) ; and tributes
(Kung).^ For the convenience of consideration, it seems
better to adopt the following classification :
(i) Taxation of agricultural lands including taxes and
rents.
(2) Taxation of salt (royalties).
(3) Taxation of commodities (duties), including regu-
lar customs duties and li-kin duties.
Appropriations
Having learned in the preceding sections the different
classes of functions with their amounts of appropriated reve-
nues and the various sources of revenues, it is now pos-
sible to discuss the seasonal appropriations of revenues
made by the Committee of Appropriation in the Department
of Finance. The committee was authorized by the heads of
the department to appropriate revenues for military pur-
poses in the winter, and for all other purposes during the
spring and autumn upon the basis of the provincial reports
of the amount of collected revenues. These appropriations
were necessary for two reasons. First, there were various
uncertain elements of ordinary expenditures which could
not be accurately estimated and provided for beforehand in
1 Tributes and other insignificant sources of royalties and duties are
not worth consideration.
177] EXPENDITURES AND REVENUES 35
the permanent appropriations. ^ In the second place, the bal-
ance of outlays and incomes in the different provinces might
be favorable or unfavorable. In addition to the seasonal
appropriations, which were general in character, there were
special appropriations to meet the extraordinary expendi-
tures whenever they occurred. Appropriations were made
according to functions and provinces, because practically all
district expenditures which can be embodied in the perma-
nent appropriations were permitted to be deducted from the
land tax.
The collection of revenues provided to meet the appro-
priations was controlled partly by central and partly by local
officials. First, the land tax which is levied in every prov-
ince was divided into two parts. One part was deducted by
the magistrate ^ for the district expenditures and was called
the reserved fund, while the other part which was required to
be sent to the Executive Department ^ in the provincial capi-
tal was known as the transporting fund. All other sources
of revenues, such as salt royalties, maritime customs duties
and regular customs duties were national in character and
were administered by special officers under the supervision
of the governor. These revenues together with the trans-
porting fund of the land tax constituted the available re-
sources for meeting both national and provincial appropria-
tions. As soon, as the appropriations had been approved by
the Emperor, those provinces whose collected revenues ex-
ceeded their expenditures were required to transport their
surplus revenues to Peking or to provinces in less fortunate
circumstances. With the development of banking, the gov-
ernors often bought bills of exchange from the prominent
Chinese bankers.
1 Cf. supra, p. 2,2>- ^ Cf. infra, pp. 64-65.
•■' Cf. supra, p. 24.
36
THE SYSTEM OF TAXATION IN CHINA
[178
The Amount of the Transporting Fund and the Reserved Fund in
THE Several Provinces as Determined by Law
The transporting fund in
(aeis of silver
The reserved fund in faels
of silver
Province
Revenue from
the regular
tax
Revenue from
the compen-
satory tax
Revenue from
the regular
tax
Revenue from
the compen-
satory tax
Chi-li
1,708,521.486
20,318.646
31,956.780
2,772,630.023
2,645,503.655
2,747,240.229
2,231,264.000
1,220,310.000
1,781,607.770
1,037,992.952
2,121,750.774
961,768.653
936,647.098
1,341,361752
214,494.580
541,501.823
864,211.117
330,845-518
147,000.033
65,864.800
211,856.256
672,622.111
9,148.082
144.136
328,171.084
312,540.853
232,944-854
291,025.478
250,419.000
208,547-445
198,762.640
239,796.926
98,403.313
94,975-866
278,122.936
71,441.899
100,106.861
161,075.170
91,207.457
46,771,297
28,930.200
Feng-tien
3,293-195
228,638.666
272,846.752
244,109.554
113,231.000
113,998.200
86,651.970
13,379-707
83,584.128
71,262.860
74,935-740
66,451.728
10,535.940
44,696-557
126,259.512
12,153.603
47,641.914
5,044.100
Shan-tung
45,941.962
86,200.748
36,272.329
24,114.852
55,370.000
4,864.483
10,731.109
10,922.769
9,497.586
170,760.000
29,902.163
54,900.000
32,684.796
14,440.751
Ho-nani
Kiang-su
Kiang-si '
Fu-kien •.«..••••>
Che-kiang
Hu-peh
Hu-nan .• « -
Shen-si ...... ....
Kan-su •......-..
Sze-chuen
Kwang-tung '
Kwang-si '
Yun-nan
Kwei-chow
Total
23,722,791.689
1,830,576.382
3,715,157.608
586,603.548
Transportation of Produce
( I ) The necessity of produce to the Peking Government.
As we know, the land tax was paid both in money and in
produce, viz., rice, wheat, beans etc. Whether the money
1 These five provinces had an additional sum of the reserved
fund for the leap month whenever it occurred i. e., Shan-si had
12533.366 taels of the regular tax and .944 tael of the com-
pensatory tax; Ho-nan, 15828.521 taels of the regular tax and .038
tael of the compensatory tax; Kiang-si, 7446.035 taels of the regular
tax; Kwang-tung, 10493.378 taels of the regular tax; and Kwang-si,
5958.607 taels of the regular tax. These figures are found in The
Amendments of the Institutes of the Tsing Dynasty, ch. clxix-clxx.
179] EXPENDITURES AND REVENUES 37
revenues from the land tax of each province should be de-
posited in the provincial treasury, or transported to Peking
or elsewhere was determined by the appropriations of the
Department of Finance. On the other hand, the office-
holders and troops in the different provinces received a part
of their pay out of the collected produce of their respective
provinces, while those in Peking were entitled to get their
respective partial payment in produce from certain great
producing provinces. Thus Shan-tung, Ho-nan, Kiang-su,
An-hwei, Kiang-si, Hu-peh, Hii-nan and Che-kiang were
required to send a part of the collected produce to Peking. '^
The quantity to be supplied by each province was legally pre-
scribed, and no deduction or commutation to money was
permitted, unless upon extraordinary occasions, such as a
bad harvest or a rebellion. An extra charge was demanded
for the loss in weighing, shipping or storage.
(2) Transportation and storage. In autumn of the year
the magistrates collected the required quantity of rice and
delivered it tO' the transporters in the respective harbors.
This had to be done within a fixed period (within the winter
in Shan-tung; from the beginning of the twelfth month to
the end of the second month of the following year in the
provinces of the Yang-tze River; during the entire first
month and half of the second in South Kiang-su and Che-
kiang). In those districts which were remote from the har-
bors, or did not produce the anticipated quantity of rice,
the required quantity of rice was paid in silver according
to a fixed rate of exchange, or according to the market
price of the collecting month. The magistrates bought
rice in the districts surrounding the harbors or trans-
ferred the silver to the Department of Finance through
the Executive Department. The available rice might
1 The produce was also used for other purposes than the support of
public servants.
38 THE SYSTEM OF TAXATION IN CHINA [jgo
be transported by way of the Grain Canal, or Grand
Canal as it is usually called by the foreigners, or by
sea. Formerly, the public rice junks ^ sailing along the
canal, started for Peh-tung-chozv, the river port of Peking,
in or before the second month of the year. In 1802 the
rice of Soo-chow, Sung-kimig, and Tai-chong (Kiang-su
Province) was allowed to be transported by sea via Shang-
hai. In 1825 Emperor Tao Kwang proposed that sea trans-
portation be universally adopted. In 1852, the rice paid
by the southern part of Kiang-su and Che-Kiang began
to be transported by sea, because the public rice junks were
so crowded on the canal that many junks could not arrive
at Peh-tung-chow before the freezing of the Peh-ho River
in the winter. From 1853 to 1864, the rice was mostly
paid in money due to the Tai-ping Rebellion of 1850-1864,
and the public junks disappeared. In 1865, the canal trans-
portation of rice paid by the provinces north of the Yang-
tze River was renewed and private junks were hired to dis-
place the public rice junks. Vessels carrying South
Kiang-su and Che-kiang rice continued to leave Shanghai
for Tientsin by sea in the second month of the year. In
1873, the sailing vessels were replaced by the steamships of
the China Merchant's Steam Navigation Company in
Shanghai, while the other southern provinces sometimes
sent a part of their rice by sea in the following years.
The transportation was accomplished through the aid of
one transporter-in-chief, '^ four provincial transporters " and
many military officers and men. The civil and military
1 The number of junks in 1812 was 6242. Each junk had the privilege
of carrying goods equal in value to twenty per cent of the rice free of
customs duties.
- This official was equal in rank to a governor.
** These officials were equal in rank to the circuit governors. They
were the heads of the grain departments in North Kiang-su (including
An-hivei), South Kiang-su, Che-kiang and Shan-tung.
i8i]
EXPENDITURES AND REVENUES
39
transporters with their soldiers went to Peh-tung-chow and
delivered the rice of their provinces to the granary keeper-
in-chief. Then the rice and other produce were kept either in
the granaries in Peking and Peh-tung-chow at. the disposal
of the Peking Government or in the granaries in Tsi-chow
and Yi-chow for the garrisons of the imperial tombs. For
the services of collection, transportation and storage, var-
ious kinds of fees were demanded for the collectors, trans-
porters and keepers.
After 1 90 1, the legal quantity of produce had been com-
muted to money in order to save the extravagant cost of
The Quantity of Rice Required to be Transported to Peking
Rice due to the Rice due to the
Province
Shan-tung
Ho-nan . .
Kiang-su .
An-hwei .
Kiang-si .
Che-Kiang
Hu-peh . .
Hu-nan . .
Total
Peking Gran-
ary
28,000,000 sine
27,000,000 "
111,300,000 "
38,700,000 "
40,000,000 "
60,000,000 "
12,294,271- "
12,705,728- "
330,000,000 "
Peh-iung-ckow
Granary
9,560,000 sine
11,000,000 "
9,395,000 "
20,045,000 "
17,000,000 "
3,000,000 "
70,000,000
Rice due to both
granaries
37,560,000 sine
38,000,000 "
120,695,000 "
58,745,000 "
57,000,000 "
63,000,000 "
12,294,271 "
12,705,728 "
400,000,000 "
The Quantity of Wheat and White Rice Required to be Trans
PORTED TO Peking
Wheat due to
Province the Peking
Granary
ggi,S7(>sinc
Wheat due to the
Peh-tun^-chow
Granary
White rice due to
both granaries
Shang-tung .. .
Ho-nan 2,465,278
Kiang-su ^ . . .
Che-Kiang ^ . .
Total .... 3,456,854
9Z9MO sine
1.276,696 "
2,215,866 "
15,043,847 ^t«<r
6,620,000 "
^1,663,847 "
1 The white rice paid in Kiang-su was really required from only four
prefectures, vis., Soo-chow, Sung-kiang, Siang-ehow and Tai-ehong ;
and that paid in Che-kiang, from two prefectures, viz., Tsa-sing and
Hu-ehow.
40
THE SYSTEM OF TAXATION IN CHINA
[182
canal transportation. Still in the first decade of the twen-
tieth century one hundred million sine of rice from Kiang-su
and Che-kiang were transported from Shanghai to Tientsin
by steamers every year, because the cost of transportation
was reasonable.
Bean and Siu^er Substitutes for the Required Rice
Province.
iS-3 g
J3 tS &■
— •2-'
0 3 0J_
tn va
e « w, •-
g j2 ^ 0
<y
sine
11.319.655
9,616,985
Quantity of white
rice for which
other rice might
be substituted."''
Quantity of rice for
which silver was al-
ways substituted,'
Quantity of rice de-
ducted from the
original quantity
as exemption
since 1865.
Quantity of rice
substituted for
lime.*
Shan-tung
'FTn-naii ........
sine
sine
7,000,000
7,000,000
10,649,269
sine
sine
Kianp-su .•
8,141,347
3,622,500
54,312,600
26,676,500
2,942,422
4,807,740
f^Hp-lfli^TlOr ..-.---
7.596,131
3,252,060
521.205
Total
20,936,640
11,763,847
36,018,665
80,989,100
7,750,162
1 In the first column, the quantity of black beans varied more or
less directly with the quantity of rice in the Peking Granary.
2 In the second column, the quantity of white rice to be exchanged
was fixed.
3 In the third column, the exchange rates between silver and rice were
fixed according to the market prices in the provinces.
* In the fifth column, the quantity of rice, being substituted for a
certain quantity of lime, was not deducted from the total quantity of
rice or white rice as in case of the preceding columns ; but was, in turn,
replaced by a payment in silver. The rate was fixed as follows: 1.2
tael of silver =^ 100 sine of rice.
183] EXPENDITURES AND REVENUES 41
Minimum and Maximum Rates 1 of the Extra Charge 2 on the
Transported Rice
Extra charge on every hun- Extra charge on every hun-
Province dred sine of rice due to dred sine of rice to the
the Peking Granary Peh-tung-chow Granary
Shan-tung ^ 25 ^ 17
Ho-nan ^ 25-28 17
Kiang-su * 25-40 22-30
An-hwei 30-40 25-30
Kiang-si 40 40
Che-kiang * 40 40
Hu-peh 5 40
Hu-nan ^ 40
Transportation Fees '^
Province
Payments with every hundred
sine of rice due to the
Peking Granary
Payments with every hun-
dred sine of rice due to
the Peh-tung-chow Granary
in silver
in rice
in rice
Shan-tuns'
.05 tael
.05 «
.05 «
.05 «
.1 "
.34 "
.03 «
....
21 sine
21 "
31 «
31 "
31 «
36 «
52 «
56 «
56 "
Ho-nan
Kiang-su (North) . . .
Kiang-su (South) . .
Che-kianp
2 «
2 «
2 "
Kianp-^i ...... ....
2 "
Hu-peh ••.... ....
Hu-nan
1 See The Amendments of the Institutes of the Tsing Dynasty, chs.
cxciv-cxcvii.
2 For the extra charge, see supra, p. 37.
3 Shan-tung and Ho-nan paid to these granaries wheat and beans at
the same rates of extra charge.
* The rates of extra charge on every hundred sine of wfhite rice were
thirty sine in Kiang-su and forty sine in Che-kiang.
5 Hu-peh and Hu-nan had no rice due to the Peh-tung-chow Granary.
^ Figures are in sine per one hundred sine of the transported rice.
"^ This table does not include the collection fees which were deter-
mined by the district magistrates.
42 THE SYSTEM OF TAXATION IN CHINA [184
Balance of Expenditures and Revenues
The financial histoty of the Tsing Dynasty, 1644-1911,
may be divided into two periods by the Chino- Japanese
War, 1894-5. The former period, 1644-1893, may be
called normal, because revenues were generally sufficient to
meet expenditures in a systematic manner. Although ex-
penditures grew larger during the last five decades of this
period due to the Tai^ping Rebellion of 18 50- 1864, and the
intercourse with foreign countries, yet they could be made
up by new sources of revenues. For instance, the total reve-
nues of 1887 were in excess of the total expenditures of the
same year :
Total revenues 78,515,215 taels
Total expenditures 67,448,649
Balance 11,066,566 "
If we differentiate both the total revenues and the total
expenditures into old and new. we have the following fig-
ures:
Old revenues from land, salt, regular customs 42,448,915 taels
Old expenditures,
Permanent appropriations 32,129,683^0^/6-
Temporary appropriations 8,733,791 " 40,863,474
Balance 1,585.441 "
New revenues from maritime customs and li-kin duty 36,066,300 fa^/^
New expenditures for new army and navy, cost of col-
lecting new revenues and redemption of foreign debts 26,585,175
Balance 9,481,125 "
Then we pass to the latter period, 1894-1911, which is
abnormal in the sense that the government of the Tsing
Dynasty would have become bankrupt before the Revolu-
185] EXPENDITURES AND REVENUES 43
tion of 191 1 were it not for foreign loans.^ This condition
was brought about by the Chino-Japanese War of 1894-5,
the Boxer Disturbance of 1900 and the reforms of govern-
ment, 1 906- 191 1. The growth of expenditures and reve-
nues of this period may be learned from the first Chinese
budget of 191 1. This budget was made in 1910 by the De-
partment of Finance based on the estimates of expenditures
of the different ydmens at Peking and the provinces, and on
the average sum of annual incomes of 1908-9, as reported-
by the investigators, sent to the provinces by the Depart-
ment of Finance in 1909, and by other authorities. Al-
though its operation has been interfered with by the Revo-
lution of 191 1, it furnishes the most reliable information
concerning the financial condition on the eve of the Revo-
lution.
Public Revenues* for 191 i
Land Tax 48,101,346.273 taels
(a) Ordinary 46,312,355.022 taels
(b) Incidental 1,936,656.421 "
Salt Taxes 46,312,355.022 "
Maritime Customs Duties 35, 139.917-965 "
Regular Customs Duties 6,999,369.966 "
(a) Ordinary 6,990,845.925 "
(b) Incidental 8,524.041 "
Miscellaneous Taxes 26,163,842.177
Li-kin Duty 43,187,907.099
Public Industries * 46,600,899.753
Incidental Contributions 5-652,333.117
Miscellaneous Incomes 35,244,750.650
Internal Debt 3,560,000.000
Total 296,962,722.022 "
1 For the amount of foreign loans see H. B. Morse, The Trade and
Administration of the Chinese Empire (New York, 1908).
2 Cf. infra, p. 44, note i.
3 The public industries, excluding railways and telegraphs, are dif-
ferent in different provinces. The most common one is the mint.
44 THE SYSTEM OF TAXATION IN CHINA [i86
Public Expenditures i for 191 i
Foreign intercourse 3,544,732-977 taels
Police administration 4,227,563.742 "
Public ceremonies 792,127.940 "
Financial administration 28,130,434.754 "
Palace and imperial household 6,144,877.170 "
The Council of State and other departments 6,348,826.271 "
Provincial administration 19,822,730.489 "
National Assembly 2 786,666.666 "
Public debt redemption and interest 56,413,576.498 "
Public industries ^ 5,600,435.211 "
Public education 3,375,474-756 "
Army and its supplies 126,743,333.389 "
Navy and its supplies 10,503,202.794 "
Administration of justice 7,716,016.765 "
Administration of agriculture, industry and commerce 2,040,003,373 "
Public works 4,515,271.832 "
Administration of railways and telegraphs 55,141,906.832 "
Government of dependencies 1,705,103.877 "
Total national expenditures 338,652,295.073 "
Local expenditures 37,703,362,170 "
Grand total 376,355,657-243 "
General Features of Expenditure and Revenue
The most striking features of the period under considera-
tion may be classified as follows : ( i ) the general character-
istics throughout the Tsing Dynasty, 1644-1911; (2) the
special characteristic of the earlier period, 1644-1893; and
(3) the special characteristic of the later period, 1894-
191 1. The general characteristics consist of two points.
One is the improper division of income among the different
governmental agencies. For instance, at least one-third of
1 These tables of expenditures and revenues are abstracted from the
original budget submitted by the Department of Finance, not from the
final budget modified by the National Assembly. They represent the
actual needs of the government rather than the final appropriations.
2 The National Assembly was created in 1910.
^ Cf. supra, p. 43, note 3.
187] EXPENDITURES AND REVENUES 45
the total income was spent for military purposes, while the
total local expenditures or the reserved fund, as it was
called, was small compared with the amount needed for
local improvements. Another point is that the important
forms of taxation remained unchanged during all these
years. The special characteristic of the earlier period is the
transportation of revenues, in the form of silver or product,
due to the lack of development of commerce; and that of
the later period is the development of numerous forms of
incomes in the different provinces, termed the miscellaneous
incomes, the most undesirable forms of which may be men-
tioned as follows :
(i) The so-called contribution. This was simply a
euphonious term used for the receipts from the sale of
public offices. A person might become a candidate for
an office by contributing a certain sum of money.
The highest office which could be bought in this way was
the circuit governorship in the provinces and the office of
a first-class secretary in the department at Peking. This
source, yielding a gross return of 5,652,333.117 taels ac-
cording to the budget of 191 1, was found in Peking and
all the provinces subject to the control of the Department of
Finance which issued the official diplomas.
(2) The gambling tax. In Kwang-tung Province this
tax was advanced in a lump sum by a company which
had a monopoly of all the gambling houses in Canton,
the capital of Kwang-tung. According to the budget of
191 1, this source yielded about 4,400,000 taels, form-
ing one-eighth of the total amount of miscellaneous
incomes of the country. As compared with the re-
turns of the other important sources of revenues in
the same province, it took a third place. The re-
ceipts ran as follows: maritime customs duties, 6,103,610
taels; li-kin duty, 5,046,256 taels; gambling tax, 4,400,-
46 THE SYSTEM OF TAXATION IN CHINA [igg
cxx) taels; salt monopoly, 2,417,597 taels; public industries,
2,372,986 taels; and land tax, 1,803,637 taels.
(3) The lottery monopolies in Hn-peh, Kiang-su and
other provinces. The Hu-peh lottery was a government
monopoly, while the lotteries in Kiang-su and other pro-
vinces were monopolized by private companies, each paying
a franchise tax to the respective provincial governments.
But the lottery of one province might be sold in any other
province. The income from this source amounted to sev-
eral million taels.
CHAPTER III
Taxation of Land ^
The Revolution of 191 1 affected only slightly the gen-
eral system of taxation in China and consequently the fol-
lowing description of conditions as they existed during the
Tsing Dynasty may be accepted as a substantially accurate
account of the present situation.
The land tax has been playing the most important role
among all the sources of revenue. It owes its importance
both to the economic condition and to the historical devel-
opment. In order to describe the present system of taxing
land, it is necessary to treat separately the land system, the
land policy, the tax system, the land rent, the exemption of
payment, the rates and the administrative rules.
The Land System
The agricultural lands of the whole country liable to pay
a tax or rent consist of nine principal classes :
(A) The People's Lands are those which are the private
property of the people and subject to sale or purchase at
their own will.
(B) The Changed-name Lands are those which were
owned by the absent nobles of the Ming Dynasty, 1368-
1644, ^^^^ transferred with property rights to the people of
the respective districts in which they are situated.
(C) The Soldier-cultivated Lands are those given to the
soldiers to be cultivated in vacation, i. e., in time when they
are not called on for the periodical drilling, the capture of
' For the Chinese systems of measure and weight, see Appendix A.
189] 47
48 THE SYSTEM OF TAXATION IN CHINA [igo
robbers and the transportation of grain to Peking and its
vicinity. Since 1650, owing to the organization of regular
forces in the different provinces, the farming soldiers are
no longer actual soldiers except those engaged in transport-
ing grain, and their lands are taxed by the civil authorities.
(D) The Horse-breeding Lands are those which were
originally enclosed for horse-breeding in Chi-li, Sha}i-si,
Kan-su and certain cities in other provinces, but now in the
hands of the people for cultivation.
(E) The Weed-growing Lands are the marshes found in
the maritime provinces, such as, Kiang-su, Kiang-si, Hu-
peh and Hu-nan.
(F) The Villa Lands are those whose rents, paid in
product, flow into the treasury of the Department of Palace
Affairs. They are situated in Chi-li and Feng-Hen Pro-
vinces. .
(G) The Banner Lands are those given to the soldiers
to be cultivated for their own use. They are generally
found in Moukden (Manchuria) and near Peking, and are
not allowed to be sold or mortgaged.
(H) The Public Lands are those held by the govern-
ment. The different provinces use the revenues from these
lands for different purposes.
(I) The Education Lands are those whose incomes go
to the provincial treasuries for educational expenses.
The Land Policy
Of the nine classes of cultivated lands, only the first was
being cultivated by the owners themselves or their tenants
at the beginning of the Tsing Dynasty, 1644-1911, when the
other eight classes were public domains. As the Chinese
land policy is to develop agriculture in the country, the
government tries to put every tract of land available for
agriculture into cultivation by a free disposal of lands to
igij TAXATION OF LAND 49
the people. As the result of this policy the area of public
tillable lands put into cultivation was calculated in 1887 to
be 186,495,407 mou. Practically all of these lands, cleared
by virtue of imperial grants, were turned into private prop-
erties by those who had cleared them. The total area of
lands retained by the government and rented to the tenants
in order to secure revenues for specific purposes is compar-
atively small. The existing public cultivated lands are now
known as the Villa Lands, the Education Lands, the Public
Lands in general and the Banner Lands.
Area of Cultivated Lands in 1887
Province Area ^ of Lands in Mou.
Chi-li 69,254,823
Feng-tien 26,554,229
Ki-rin 1,429,214
Shan-tung 125,931,405
Ho-nan 71,675,185
Shan-si 56,476,803
An-hvirei 41,113,028
Kiang-su 1 10,825,370
Kiang-si 47,341,581
Fu-kien 13,400,056
Che-kiang 46,770,515
Hu-peh 117,322,955
Hu-nan 34,874,255
Shen-si 30,59i,330
Kan-su , 16,775,160
Sze-chuen 46,415,898
Kwang-tung 34,730,825
Kwang-si 8,963,783
Turkestan 11,480,101
Total in the report of 1887 911,976,606
Yun-nan 2 in the report of 1853 9,319,360
Kwei-chow 2 in the report of f8i2 2,765,025
Grand total 924,060,991
1 The Institutes of the Tsing Dynasty, 5th edition, (Shanghai, 1909),
ch. xvii.
2 Yun-nan and Kwei-chow sent their latest reports in 1853 and 1812
respectively.
50 THE SYSTEM OF TAXATION IN CHINA [192
Area of Public and Private Cultivated Lands in 1887, showing the
Result of the Land Policy
Province Area of private land ^ Area of public land ^
Chi-li 2 68,332,031 mou 972,792 mou
Feng-tien 5,239,889 " 21,314,340 "
Ki-rin 1,429,214 "
Shan-tung 123,600,758 " 2,330,647 "
Shan-si 47,918,531 " 8,558,272 "
Ho-nan 62,766,216 " 8,908,969 "
Kiang-su 65,757,338 " 45,068,032 "
An-hwei 34,063,630 " 7,049,398 "
Kiang-si 46,176,300 " 1,165,281 "
Fu-kien 12,601,238 " 798,818 "
Che-kiang 44,713,511 " 2,057,004 "
Hu-peh 2 58,102,760 " 59,220,195 "
Hu-nan2 31,304,200 " 3,57o,o55 "
Shen-si2 25,797,024 " 4,794,3o6 "
Kan-su 9,196,385 " 7,578,775 "
Sze-chuen 2 46,415,898 "
Kwang-tung 34,193,764 " 537,o6i "
Kwang-si 2 8,963,783 "
Turkestan* 11,480,191 "
Total 726,572,470 " 185,404,136 "
Yun-nan 3 8,394,238 " 925,122 "
Kwei-chow3 .. 2,598,876 " 166,149 "
Grand total .. 737,565,584 " 186,495,407 "
1 By " Private Land " is meant the People's Land while all the other
classes are included in public land because of their origin.
2 It is often found in the provincial reports that the different classes
of land are not separately calculated, there being a failure to dis-
tinguish not only between various classes of public lands, but also be-
tween the private and public lands, e. g., the area of private lands in
Chi-li, Hu-peh and Sze-chuen includes the Soldier-cultivated lands;
that in Hu-nan, the Changed-name Lands ; that in Kwang-si, the public
lands; that in Shen-si, the Education Lands.
3 Yun-nan and Kwei-chow did not send their reports in 1887. The
figures for the former are taken from the report of 1853, and those
for the latter, from the report of 1812.
* Turkestan's figure denotes the area of public lands in a few cities,
while the whole territory is practically uncultivated.
5 Thousands of mou of public cultivated lands are believed not to be
193] TAXATION OF LAND 5 1
Gradual Increase of Cultivated Lands showing the Result of the
Land Policy ^
Year Area of Land
1661 549,357,600 mou
1685 607,843,000
1722 683,791,400
1766 741,449,500
1812 791,525,100
1833 742,000,000
1887 911,976,606
1 The figures are taken from Tang Shou Chien, Inquiry into the
Institutions of China (Shanghai), bk. iii, ch. i.
The Tax System
(A) The Compound Land Tax.
The compound land tax at present is composed of five
elements :
(a) The Regular Land Tax.
(b) The Poll Tax.
(c) The General Personal Service Money.
(d) The Post Station Money.
(e) The Compensatory Tax.
(a) The Regular Land Tax. Since 594 B. C. the land
has been taxed by mott (acreage), i. e., a tax has been
levied on each mou of land. From 770 to the present time
there has been no uniform rate proportional to the amount
of gross produce. Owing to the fact that the old method
of assessment was abandoned without the introduction of a
new method, the rates to-day are fixed merely by tradition.^
The tax was originally paid in produce. Since 1436 it has
been paid partly in silver and partly in produce. This
change is not an attempt to approximate more closely the
included in this table due either to no report or to the calculation with
local standards of measure. Unfortunately, these are the only
reliable figures. They are taken from the latest (Sth) edition of
The Institutes of the Tsing Dynasty, ch. xvii.
1 For the rates in force at present, cf. infra, pp. 56-64.
52 THE SYSTEM OF TAXATION IN CHINA [194
tax-paying ability of the land-holder ; the amounts, collected
year by year, have not increased or decreased so that each
person contributes approximately the same as before.
(b) The Poll Tax. The poll tax was levied during the
early years of the Tsing Dynasty, 1644-1911, upon several
classes of people, namely, the urban people, the country peo-
ple, the rich people, the tenants and the immigrants from
other localities. Each of these was further classified under
three grades according to their ability to pay. The age of
a person was also taken into consideration because an adult,
i. e., sixteen years old, was regarded as having greater abil-
ity than a child. A census was published every five years
in order to correct the errors regarding population. This
method of assessment was soon found impracticable, due
to the lack of accurate reports of increasing members of the
individual families. In 1713, Emperor Kang-shi ordered
that the census of 171 1 should be taken as a standard and
the increased population be exempted from taxation.
During the period 1 716-1793 the poll taxes of different
provinces were amalgamated with the land taxes, except
m Feng-Hen, twenty districts of Shan-si and the greater
part of Kwei-chow. The poll tax was originally levied in
China on the assumption of an equal distribution of lands
in a primitive society. With the increase of population, the
scarcity of land and the unequal distribution of lands
among the population, the poll tax has lost its value as a
test of ability to pay.^ Whereas land is the dominant source
of wealth in an agricultural community, the only way for
the Chinese government to make good the loss of revenue
from the poll tax was to raise the rates of land taxes as she
did in the process of amalgamation. Therefore, we may
consider this modification of the tax system as an advance
step towards the goal of ability to pay in taxation.
1 Tang Shou Chien, Inquiry into the Institutions of China, bk. iii,
ch. iii, p. 3.
195 ] TAXATION OF LAND 53
(c) The General Personal-Service Money. All kinds of
public service were formerly done with forced labor. It
was the duty of everybody to serve in this way without pay-
ment. Later, money was paid instead of service, and with
it voluntary laborers were employed. This commutation
tax has been also amalgamated with the land tax in order
to save the trouble of collection.
(d) The Post-Station Money. Aside from the post-
office, China has been providing her own means of com-
munication known as the post stations established through-
out the Empire especially for military and other public pur-
poses. The service was formerly performed by the people.
It is now paid for out of the public treasury, while the peo-
ple are required to pay a tax known as the Post-Station
Money which is collected with the land tax.
(e) The Compensatory Tax. Besides the regular taxes
and the commutation taxes, there is a compensatory tax
which is so called because it was originally an illegal
charge by the magistrates for the compensation of loss of
silver from melting. At the beginning of the Tsihg
Dynasty, 1644-1911, the practice was strictly prohibited by
the following laws : ^
(i) The Imperial Decree of 1644 announcing that the
imposition of " melting loss " shall be punished as bribery.
(2) The Law of 1665 permitting the people to com-
plain of any sort of excessive charges before the courts.
(3) The Law of 1678 holding liable the provincial high
officials for the concealment of the guilt of subordinates
levying the " melting loss ".
But the practice could not be checked because the govern-
ment did not provide adequate revenues for the districts,
nor sufficient salaries for the magistrates, as it was said by
^ Wang Ching Yun, Essays on the Institutions of the Tsing Dynasty
(Shanghai, 1901), ch. iii.
54 THE SYSTEM OF TAXATION IN CHINA [196
Emperor Kang Shi in a decree of 1709. This decree is a
reply to Mr. Loo-yu, the governor of Ho-nan, saying, " It
is impossible for any magistrate to support his family and
to pay for the services rendered by his secretaries and ser-
vants, without charging a single cash in excess. A magis-
trate charging ten per cent in excess of the regular taxes
may be considered as a good official. If he were not excused
from impeachment, it seems to me, it would be irksome for
you to inflict the same penalty on so many of your sub-
ordinates." Then the rates of the compensatory taxes
in the different provinces were ten per cent of the regu-
lar taxes or less, i. e., one mace^ per tael of regular taxes;
but the rates in Hu-nan were twenty per cent or
thirty per cent. In 1722, the rates in Shen-si varied
from twenty per cent to fifty per cent of the regu-
lar taxes when the provincial treasury incurred a de-
ficit. The governor asked Emperor Kang Shi's permis-
sion to take the collected revenues from the compensatory
tax out of the magistrates' pockets; but the Emperor re-
fused, because he thought his permission would mean the
confirmation of the charge of the illegal tax. In 1724, the
Governor of Shan-si requested the legalization of the com-
pensatory tax to meet the deficit of that province. Emperor
Yung-tsing granted this request on the condition that the
compensatory tax should be abolished whenever the public
revenues shall be found adequate. From that time on one
province after another followed the precedence of Shan-si.
This source of revenue is now appropriated for official sal-
aries and local purposes.
The Land Rent
As we have seen that the government nominally owns at
present only four classes of public cultivated lands, we now
1 Ten maces are equal to one tael.
igy] TAXATION OF LAND 55
come to discuss how the government deals with such lands.
First, the Villa Lands are leased to the tenants who pay
rice to the Department of Palace Affairs as rent. In the
second place, the Banner Lands are either given to the
Tartar soldiers under the Eight Banners without any kind
of payment, or leased to the Chinese tenants in order toi
secure rents in money for some other soldiers who have no
land. These two classes of lands, therefore, are not subject
to the taxing power of the Department of Finance. Finally,
the other two classes of public lands which are under the
control of the Department of Finance are known as the
Education Lands for educational expenses, and the Public
Lands in general for other public purposes of the provinces.
Rates of rents derived from these lands are fixed by law and
are not accommodated to the fluctuation of economic rents.
The privilege of the tenants is the exemption from payment
of all other burdens, that is to say, the poll tax, the General
Personal Service Money, the Post-Station Money and the
Compensatory Tax.
The Exemption of Payments
The following classes of uncultivated land are exempt
from the payment of taxes :
(a) The Forbidden Lands are not open to cultivation,
because their low productivity is supposed to yield less re-
turn that the expense of cultivation.
(b) The Scattered Lands are those scattered in small
pieces. The exemption is subject to certain limitations, such
as fertility, size or location, i. e., on mountain or near river
bank.
(c) The Exempt Lands are those which are used as sites
for the buildings or are rented in order to augment the reve-
nues for public worship, public education and public charity.
(d) The Unmeasured Lands are occupied by various
barbarous tribes in Sze-chuen, Yun-nan and Kan-su Pro-
56 THE SYSTEM OF TAXATION IN CHINA [i^g
vinces. In lieu of the land tax, each family of these tribes
pays a poll tax.
(e) The Hunting Lands are those used for hunting game
in Manchuria.
(f) The Nomadic Lands consist of Mongolia, Turkestan
and other districts near to them, where the nomadic tribes
wander from place to place in search of pasture or game.
Existing Rates
The rates of the regular land tax and the land rent vary
to a greater or less extent in different provinces, or even in
different places of the same province. They are also dif-
ferent according to the various classes of land and the var-
ious kinds of agricultural products. This differentiation is
based upon suppositions as to the productivity of land and
the density of population.^ There is no scientific measure
of productivity by the modern method of valuation, nor
accurate census of population. But it must be known that
the determination of land fertility by the color of soil may
be traced back from the Hsia Dynasty, 2205-1766 B. C,
when the available lands were cultivated earlier or later
according to their superiority of productive power and the
number of immobile laborers already there. On the other
hand, the compensatory taxes are levied in the different
provinces at certain fixed rates per tael of the regular taxes.
In some cases these rates are uniform throughout the whole
province; while in others they are different or exempt as
determined by the customary practices in the different locali-
ties. To prevent confusion there have been included, in the
subjoined tables, only the minimum and maximum rates in
the different provinces, ignoring the variation ^ between
these limits.
1 Tang Shou Chien, Inquiry into the Institutions of China, bk. iii,
ch. i, p. 2.
2 The Comprehensive Book of Taxation and Service of the Tsing
Dynasty (Peking) contains the full text.
199]
TAXATION OF LAND
57
Minimum and Maximum 'Rates of the Regular Tax on Each Mou
OF THE PeOPLE^S LaND
Province.
Chi-li
Feng-tien .
Ki-rin' ...
Shan-tung .
Shan- si . • .
Ho-nan . . .
An-hwei^ .
Kiang-si^ .
Fu-kien . . •
Che-kiang^
Hu-peh -^ . .
Hu-nan' . .
Shen-si " . .
Kiang-su ^ .
Kan-su . .
Sze-chuen
Kwang-tung,
Kwang-si . .
Yun-nan . .
Kwei-chow
Silver,
I (.oo8i)-(.i3+)
(.Ol)-(.024-)
• (.oi)-f.o3)
I (.oo32)-(,io9i4-)
(.ooio7)-(.i+)
! (.ooi4)-(.227+)
! (.oi5i-(.io6+)
; (.001 336) -(.1 1 701 3)
! (.oi69)-(.i625+)
I (•OT503)-(-255+)
I (.2545)-(2.974i+)
|(.20238)-( 1.8404+)
! (i.o59)-(2.773+)
I (.oo9).(.i4ii+)
(.ooo2)-(.i504+)
(.ooiS9)-(.o849i+)
(.0081 )-(. 2232 -f)
(.0204)-(.2I22-f )
(.oo55)-(.0465 + )
(.oi)-(.6s-H)
Rice.
Beans.
sine
sine
(i)-(io+)
(.90o8)-(4+)
(2.o8)-(7.5+)
(2.2).(6.6)
• • • •
(.02)-(3.o6+)
• • • •
(.i5)-(27+)
• • • •
(.07).(2.2+)
■ • • •
(.2i)-(7.i+)
(.o8)-(.9i+)
{.i4)-(io.7205+)
• a • •
(.oi09)-(2.47+)
« • ■ •
(.oo3)-(i9+)
• • • •
(.ooo6)-{29.i4o8+)
• • • •
(.0209)-(i4.69+)
• • • •
(.oi)-(io.i6+)
• • . •
(i.47)-(i9.26+)
Included
in rice.
(.o3)-(8.ii-f)
• • . a
(.65)-(2.29+)
(3.7^(5-35+)
....
(i.94)-(i5+)
....
(.5001) -(45+)
1.0
Wheat.
sine
(.ooi)-(.43+)
(.05). (.08+)
(.0002)-(.03+)
1 In Ki-rin the required rice may be paid in silver, the exchange
rate being 100 sine rice = i tael silver.
2 In Kiang-su, An-hwei, Kiang-si and Che-kiang, there are two
sorts of the People's Land, — the low land, called ' Tien ' (field) and the
high land, called 'Tf (ground) — paying different rates of tax. The
figures in the table indicate the rates on each mou of low land. The
rates on each mou of high land are as follows : Kiang-su .009- .3303 tael
silver, .73-41. 6g sine rice and bean, .001-.08 sine wheat; An-hwei,
.0089-.63 tael silver, .79-5.9 sine rice, .08-.22 sine wheat; Kiang-si,
.000054-.211128 tael silver, .052-5.128 sine rice; Che-kiang, .0024-.2132
tael silver, .008-19.35 sine rice.
3 In Hu-peh, Hu-nan and Shen-si only rice is required to be paid.
If the payment of silver is preferred, the rates in the " silver " column
of this table are the exchange rates for every 100 sine of rice.
58
THE SYSTEM OF TAXATION IN CHINA
[200
Minimum and Maximum Rates of the Regular Tax on Each Mou
OF THE Soldier-cultivated Land
Province
Chi-li"
Shan-tung . .
Shan-tung. .
Shan-si ....
Shan-si ....
Ho-nan
Kiang-su* ..
An-hwei
An-hwei . . . .
Kiang-si " .
Kiang-si * . .
Kiang-si » . .
Kiang-si ^ . .
Che-kiang . • .
Hu peh ....
Hu-peh * ,. .
Hu-nan ' . . .
Hu-nan' ...
Shen-si
Kan-su . . . . ,
Kan-su ^ . . .
Sze-chuen . . .
Sze-chuen** ..
Kwang-tung
Yun-nan
Kwei-chow '°
Class'
A
A
B
A
B
A
A
A
B
A( )
A(2)
A(3)
A(4)
A
A
B
A
B
A
A
B
A
B
A
A
A
Silver
.00072-.0793 iael
.01-.065 "
.01-.0538 "
.0023-.014 "
.014 "
.00 1 6-. 1 08 "
.009-.1411 "
.01-.06 "
.0179-2.7229 "
.502975 -.548384 "
.2 "
.04166 "
.09C047-.114245 "
.00 5 7 2-. 1 49 "
Rice'
.3-1.3166
,001 9-. 1043
.56
.oo2-,c98
.0012 .006
.0125-.3
.0125-.02
.Oo8l-.22^2
.OI4I-.234
.897-9.072
sine
1.08-10.9
<(
I.47-I9.26
«
1.8-8.6
((
.3-2541
«
3.959-27-3
(f
7.973-22.803
X
15-75-24
<(
1.5-9,96
n
1.2-18
l<
.38-20
<l
1-12.5
«
1-5-30
X
5-6
«
4.187
<<
27.27
((
1.929-80
«
8.88
«
5.92-8.18
((
5-35-37-33
«
1 Class A is under the administration of civil officials and class B,
of military oiificers.
2 The word " rice " indicates rice itself or together virith other minor
cereals.
3 Chi-li also pays .438 to 3.6 sine beans and .0192 to .0417 tael straw
per mou.
^ Kiang-su also pays .002 to .03 sine wheat per mou.
5 In Kiang-si, class A(i) indicates low land; class A (2), high land;
class A(3), fractional land; and class A(4), a substitute for the non-
existence of the Soldier-cultivated Land in Fu-kien. Only rice is re-
quired from class A(i), and class A (2). If the silver payment is pre-
ferred, the figures under the "silver" column are the exchange rates for
every 100 sine of rice.
^ In Hu-peh, only rice is required from class B. If the payer pre-
20l]
TAXATION OF LAND
59
Minimum and Maximum Rates of the Regular Tax on Each Mou
OF THE ChANGED-NAME LaND
Province . Silver
Chi-li .0053 - .1173 tael
Shan-tung 2
Shan-si
Ho-nan
Hu-peh 3 . .
Hu-nan ^ . . .
Shen-si
Kan-su * . . .
.01 - .3007
.005 - .14
.011 -.129
.466
.3735 - .9244
.0069- .0751
.0048 - .0171
Ricei
stnc
1.8
tt
.07-
20
(t
.449
-6.31
«
.5-12
«
4.3s
-14.8
it
,22-
1.42
It
fers to pay silver, every 100 sine of rice is considered as equivalent to
the figure under the " silver " column.
'^ In Hu-nan class A pays both silver and rice which may be changed
to silver (100 sine rice = .1774 — 1.6531 tael silver), while class B pays
only rice, the exchange rate of 100 sine rice being included in the
" silver " column.
8 In Kan-su, class B pays .058 tael straw in addition to rice.
8 In Sse-ehuen, beans are paid together with rice and the figure under
the " rice " column indicates the amount of both.
^^ Kwei-ehow pays 30 sine beans and 23.33 — 3I.I4 ^i^^'C wheat per
mou besides the payment of silver and rice.
1 The word " rice " indicates rice and other minor cereals.
2 In Shan-tung wheat is required. The rate is .32 sine per mou.
3 In Hu-peh and Hu-nan only rice is required to be paid. If the
silver payment is preferred, the rates in the " silver " column of this
table are the exchange rates for every 100 sine of rice.
■* In Kan-su straw is required. The rate is .01-.092 tael per mou.
6o THE SYSTEM OF TAXATION IN CHINA [202
Minimum and Maximum Rates of the Regular Tax or the Land
Rent on Each Mou of the Special Classes of Lands
(a) Chi-li
Class 1 Silver
The Mulberry Land .00168 tael
The Foliage Crop Land 05 - .7251 "
The Weed-growing Land 2 01 - .06 "
The Sand Deposit Land 029 - .2565 "
The Education Land ^ 01 - .2678 "
(b) Manchuria
Province Class* Silver Produce
Feng-tien The Re-opened Land * 01-.03 tael..^.-^ -10 sine bean *
Feng-tien The Illegally-cultivated Land ' . . .48 " 2.65 " rice
Ki-rin The Discovered Land •* .08 " .442 " rice *
1 Chi-li has eight kinds of lands excluding the Banner Land and the
Villa Land which are not under the administration of the magistrates.
The rates of the three general classes are found in the foregoing
tables. Cf. supra, pp. 57-59.
2 This class is used as salt fields.
3 The Education Land pays 6 sine of wheat, corn and rice per mou
besides silver.
* In addition to these classes both Feng-tien and Ki-rin have the
People's Land mentioned above. Cf. supra, p. 57.
5 The Re-opened Land is that first enclosed as the Banner Land and
then re-opened to the cultivation of the common people.
* Of the amount of beans, a half is paid in kind and the other half,
in silver, the exchange rate being 100 sine beans = .6 tael silver.
' The Illegally-cultivated Land is that cultivated by the people with-
out the property right conferred by the government.
* The Discovered Land is that illegally cultivated by the people who
evade the tax until discovered.
^ The rice is paid in silver. The exchange rate is : 100 sine rice =
I tael silver.
203] TAXATION OF LAND 5 1
(c) Shan-tung
Class 1 Silver
The Education Land 009 - .3 tael
The Stove Land 2 .0265 - .0441 "
The Changed-name Land under the miHtary post ^ 00107 - .1 "
(d) Kiang-su
Class * Silver Rice and Beans Wheat
The Hilly Land -j
The Weed-growing Land ^ 1 .009-. 1405 (ael 34-16.52 sine 01-.03 sine
The Swamp Land ........ )
The City Ground" ^
The Granary Ground®.... I-.057-.1024 " 5.05-12.63 " ....X)i-.02 "
The House Ground ® J
(e) An-hwei
Class ' Silver Rice Wheat
The Pond or Water Land * .019 - .044 tael .47 - .78 sine .01 - .02 sine
The Grass Hill » 083
The Mulberry Land ^« 032
1 Shang-tung has six classes land. The three general classes are
mentioned above. Cf. supra, pp. 57-59.
2 The Stove Land also pays .01 - .41 sine wheat and 1.8 - 2.84 sin£
rice per mou.
2 The former rates of this class were .006-. 12 tael.
* Kiang-sn has four classes of lands. The two general classes appear
above. Cf. supra, pp. 57-58.
* This class is used as salt fields.
* This class is taxed according to the number of buildings. But it is
not a tax on buildings or house tax.
^ An-hwei has five classes of lands. We have given the two general
classes above. Cf. supra, pp. 57-58.
^ The tax on this class is estimated by mou. The figures indicate
the rate per mou.
' This class yielding grass pays taxes according to the length of the
land. The figure represnts the rate per li. Li is a Chinese standard
measure of length, equivalent to 576 metres in the Metric System.
*° The tax on this class is computed according to the weight of the
finished goods (silk) of its produce (mulberry). Each tael of silk
pays the above-mentioned sum, i. e., .032 tael.
62
THE SYSTEM OF TAXATION IN CHINA
[204
(f) Kiang-si
Class* Silver Rice
The Hilly Land 000005 - .06276 tael .017 -.1418 sine
The Pond or Water Land .000054 - .270677 " .113-6.837 "
(g) Fu-kien
Class * Silver
The Silver Payment Public Land * .0087 - -4175 tael
The Education Land 0643 - .6995 "
(h) Che-kiang
Class *
The Hilly Land .00005 - .1963 tael
The Weed-growing Land 0004 ■
The Pond or Watery Land 0002-
The Lake-region Land 0307
The Mulberry Land* 0019 ■
The Tea Land ^ 0015
The Stove Land 0161 ■
Iver
Rice
- .1963 tael
.006-5.37 sine
.073
.05 - 7.5
.1245 "
.0007- 1.68 "
.095
.0056 "
.001 "
.07
.1414 "
'2,7 - 2-7
(i) Kan-su
Class ® Silver
The land under the military chiefs of the
barbarous tribes "' 075 tael
The Fan tribes' land *
The Animal-breeding Land .006 "
Cereals
2425 sine
.4-3 "
1 Kiang-si has four classes of lands, the two general classes having
been given above. Cf. supra, pp. 57-58.
* Fu-kien has only one general class of land as given above. Cf.
supra, p. 57.
* This class consists of those lands left to the public by escheat or
by absence of property owners. The payment is made with silver only.
* There are two general classes of lands in Che-kiang. Cf. supra,
pp. 57-58.
* The rates on mulberry and tea are applied to each tree irrespective
of the area of land.
^ The three general classes of lands in Kan-su are mentioned above.
Cf. supra, pp. 57-59.
■^ The barbarous tribes are governed by their own military chiefs,
and their land, administered by them.
^ This class nominally under the magistrates pays as the land tax
.0215 - .03 tael straw together with the cereals per mou. In addition
to this, each family pays a poll tax amounting to .3 tael silver and
10 - 25 sine cereals.
205]
TAXATION OF LAND
63
(j) Hu-nan, Sze-chuen, Kwang-tung and Yun-nan
Province Class ' Silver
Hu-nan . - The Mao tribes' land 0015-.03679 tael
Sze-chuen The land under the military chiefs of the
barbarous tribes 0034- .023 1 "
Kwang-tung .... The sewages '^ .04503 "
Kwang tung The pools ^ .394 "
Yun-nan The Horse Stable land ^ 02-.03 "
Yun-nan The Yi tribes' land i sine cereals
Rice
6.42 - 20.77 sine
3 - 5.35
3-74 - 5-35 "
4.28
24.84
Rice
(k) Kwang-si
Class * Silver
The Public Land
The Yao tribes' Land
The Tung tribes' Land .009 - .0223 tael
The Lang tribes' Land 009 "
The Education Land 009 "
(1) Kwei-chow
Class * Silver
The land under the military chiefs
of the barbarous tribes 008- .1 tael
The Public Land
The Education Land ^ 1-4 "
The Rent Land .03 - .1 "
The Hilly Land ' .0136 - .05 "
The Worship Land ^ i "
The Famine-relief Land ^
1 The general classes of lands in these provinces may be found
above. Cf. supra, pp. 57-59.
2 The sewages or pools are taxed according to their number. The
figure is the rate of tax on each one of them.
3 The Horse- Stable Land was originally used for horse stables and
later thrown open to cultivation.
* Kwang-si has only one general class, the People's Land, as men-
tioned above. Cf. supra, p. 57.
* Kwei-chow has two general classes of lands, see supra, pp. 71-74.
* This class also pays 20- 110.78 sine rice per mou.
'' This class also pays 10 sine wheat per mou.
^ This class also pays 10 sine beans per mou.
' This class also pays 4.13 - 125.12 sine rice per mou.
.722
-15.
stnc
25-
50
it
20-
40
it
5
It
14.9
-50
it
64 THE SYSTEM OF TAXATION IN CHINA [206
Minimum and Maximum Rates of the Compensatory Tax added to
PER Tael of Silver of the Regular Tax
Province Minimum Rate Maximum Rate Uniform Rate
Chi4i 1 , .15 tael
Feng-tien 1 .1 tael
Shan-tung .14 "
Shan-si 1 1 tael .13 "
Ho-nan i " -iS "
Kiang-su 05 " .1 "
An-hwei 075 " .1 "
Kiang-si .1 "
Fu-kien 1 .1 "
Che-kiang 04 " .09 "
Hu-peh .11 "
Hu-nan .1 "
Shen-si 1 -iS "
Kan-su ^ -iS "
Sze-chuen -iS "
Kwang-tung ^ .169 "
Kwang-sii 08 " .105 "
Yun-nan 1 .2 "
Kvirei-chow ^ i " -iS "
Administrative Rules
The administrative rules of the land tax are very com-
plex. They may be described under three headings as fol-
lows :
(a) The Collector. The magistrate of a district is the
only responsible collector M^ithin his jurisdiction. He may
be recorded, promoted, degraded, or dismissed according
to the amount of the tax assigned to his district which he
succeeds in collecting. The general rule ^ is that a magis-
trate is recorded when he has collected the whole sum of
one year, and promoted to a higher rank when he has done
the same for three consecutive years. On the other hand,
1 In Ki-rin and these ten provinces the compensatory tax is partly
paid with rice. But it is too insignificant to be mentioned here.
2 See The Amendments of the Institutes of the Tsing Dynasty
(Shanghai, 1909), ch- cbPtiii.
207] TAXATION OF LAND 65
he is punished by postponing his promotion and forfeiting
his annual salary, for a deferred payment of less than ten
per cent of the assigned amount; by degrading him to one,
two, three or four grades below his original rank, without
removal from service, according to whether the deferred
payment is ten per cent, twenty per cent, thirty per cent,
or forty per cent; or by dismissing him from office for a
deferred payment of fifty per cent or more. His super-
visory officials ^ assume the joint responsibility and are sub-
ject to similar treatment. He, however, may recover his
office by remitting the deferred payment while he remains
in service by permission or while awaiting his successor.
For this purpose, there are numerous limitations concern-
ing the amount of deferred payment and the date of pay-
ment. No recovery is allowed, if a magistrate fails to
pay to the public treasury forty per cent of the as-
signed tax for the three years from the date of his
impeachment. In the case of deficit,^ which is not
due to the deferred payment of the people but due to
the fraud, waste, or deferred payment of the magistrate
himself, he is fined by the confiscation of his property with
or without other punishments. His supervisory officials
share his fine for the joint responsibility or bear it for the
concealment of his deficit.
(b) Method of Collection.^ The system of " single
whip'V began to be established in 1581 and has been widely
extended under the Tsing Dynasty, 1644-1911. This
system requires the different elements of the compound
1 Cf. supra, ch. i, p. 25.
2 Cf. The Amendments of the Institutes of the Tsing Dynasty,
ch. clxxv.
3 The existing method was adopted in 1728.
* By this phrase, we mean that all kinds of imposition are simplified
into a single item.
66 THE SYSTEM OF TAXATION IN CHINA [208
land tax, laid on each person, to be added together, and the
amount to be collected in ten instalments. The amount of
the tax, laid on each person, is estimated according to the
quantity and class of his lands as entered in the " Surveyors'
Book ". Before the beginning of every semi-annual col-
lection, the magistrate provides ten detachable receipts, each
with two duplicates, for each taxpayer. One of the two
duplicates of each receipt is kept by the magistrate, and the
other given to a policeman who infomis the taxpayer, but
does not collect the tax. Having been informed once
or many times, the taxpayer is expected to put his tax in
the "collecting box" of the district ydmen; and when he
has done so. he is entitled to a receipt. The process is re-
peated until ten instalments have been paid. Every ten
days the magistrate opens the box, counts the total amount,
and reports it to his supervisory officials. The money col-
lected in this manner has been wrapped up by the individual
taxpayer; and if it is found less than the required amount,
it is returned to the original payer and an entire repay-
ment is demanded rather than a supplementary sum. This
is done in order to prevent the fraud of exacting an
illegal charge, however small. At the end of each semi-
annual collection, the magistrate sends to the Executive
Department a report and the entire collected revenue ex-
cept a certain sum allowed to be deducted for the district
expenditures.
(c) Periods of Collection. The tax is collected in two
periods of the year. This system was established in 780
by Yang Yen, a prime minister in the Tang Dynasty, 618-
907, and is known as the "two taxes", or the "summer and
autumn taxes". It has the same object as the "single
whip " system, being the most important reform in the
taxation system from Yang Yen's time to the present day.
The summer tax is now collected from the second to the
209] TAXATION OF LAND (^y
fifth month; and the autumn tax, from the eighth to the
eleventh month. These periods are universal to all except
five provinces. The periods of Kwang-tmvg are froiyi the
seventh to the eighth month of a year, and from the twelfth
to the first month of the next year. Yun-itan and Kwei-
chow are permitted to collect taxes from the ninth to the
twelfth month of a year and from the first to the third
month of the next year, while Shen-si and Sse-chuen have
their own periods in the year, namely, from the second to
the seventh month and from the eighth to the twelfth
month. These changes of periods are due to the differences
of climate necessary for the staple products of those pro-
vinces.
(d) The Auditing of Accounts. With the exception of
a sum reserved for local purposes, the collected revenues
are transported to the provincial treasury immediately after
the close of each collecting period. At the end of a year,
the circuit governor and the prefect are ordered to audit
the accounts of their subordinate magistrates, such as the
reserved fund, the transporting fund, the collected fund
and the amount of deferred pa)mient, and to report the re-
sult of investigation to the governor. Next year two copies
of the provincial accounts of these items are sent to Peking,
one to the Department of Finance to be audited, and the
other to the Emperor. These reports must reach Peking
before the fourth, fifth or sixth month according to the dis-
tance of the respective provinces from Peking.
General Features of the Land Tax
The general features of the land tax which are worthy
of observation are :
( I ) The considerable amount contributed by this source
to the annual revenues. Before the creation of the mari-
time customs duties and the li-kin duties in the middle of
68 THE SYSTEM OF TAXATION IN CHINA [210
j the nineteenth century, when the amount of the annual
revenues was less than five million taels, the land tax formed
two-thirds or more of the whole, while in the last few
years before the Chino- Japanese War, 1894, it supplied
about three-eighths of the total annual return of about
eighty million taels} In recent years it has constituted one-
fourth of the annual tax revenue of a little over two hun-
dred million taels.^
(2) This important part of the revenue is inelastic. For
centuries, the amount apportioned has not been changed,
and to do so would be extremely difficult. Nevertheless,
this method has the advantage of securing a total fixed
sum.
(3) The land tax is levied on the land without allow-
ances for indebtedness.
(4) As the land tax has existed for centuries, the process
of capitalization has proceeded to the point where the greater
part of the burden has been eliminated. The persons who
have lost by its establishment are not the same as those
who own the lands at present. For the same reason, the
question of equality and that of certainty are not of par-
ticular moment.
(5) Although the greater part of the land tax has been
capitalized, yet there are some few uncertain elements
which cannot be included in the calculations. Prominent
among such elements is the depreciation of copper coins.
As the tax is collected in terms of silver which is always
scarce, the taxpayer must pay more copper coins for the
same weight of silver owing to the depreciation. This
means in effect an additional tax. This new element is
1 During the 19th century the legal amount of land tax is over
31,000,000 taels. Annual variations are not great.
2 According to the budget of 1911, the land tax revenue is 48,101,346
taels.
21 1 ] TAXATION OF LAND 69
borne by the immediate taxpayer, so far as any portion of
pure economic rent is held by him, when the action of com-
petition is not found in full force, otherwise the burden is
passed to the landlord. For this reason, the taxpayer always
prefers to pay produce,^ and the object of commuting
produce to silver is hardly attained. Nevertheless, the
method of commutation is now carried out in an irksome
manner, because the magistrate is required to sell the
produce on his own account, and to pay the required amount
of silver to the government. It is evident that the magis-
trate suffers for the people. But the shrewd magistrates
often escape the requirement or compensate themselves in
other ways. One of the most important causes of discon-
tent in recent years is the practice, indulged in by many
governors, of coining as many copper coins as possible and
circulating them in the whole country for the purpose of
securing seigniorage.
(6) The cost of collection is very low, because the ad-
ministration is vested in the district magistrates. More-
over, the method of collection is rather convenient.
1 It will be recalled that a part of the land tax may be paid in
produce or silver, but the other part must be paid in silver.
CHAPTER IV
Taxation of Salt ^
Production of Salt
(i) General considerations. Salt is one of the most
valuable products of China. It may be classified into three
kinds, namely, sea salt, lake salt, and well salt. The first
is produced in Feng-tien, Chi-li, Shan-tung, Kiang-su, Che-
kiang, Fu-kien and Kzuang-timg Provinces; the second, in
Shan-si, Shen-si and Kan-su Provinces; and the third, in
Sze-chuen and Yun-nan Provinces.
There are three methods of production, knovi^n as "field-
drying ", " board-drying " and " pan-drying," The field-
drying means that the salt water on the fields is allowed tO'
become dry on exposure to the sun, as in Feng-tien, Chi-li,
Shan-tung, Fu-kien, Kwang-timg, Shan-si, Shen-si, Kan-su
and that part of Kiang-su north of the Hwai River. The
board-drying means to let the salt water evaporate on the
boards exposed to the sun. This is used in Che-kiang and
that part of Kiang-su which lies south of the Hwai River.
The pan-drying means to heat the salt water in pans with
fire, as in Sze-chuen, Yun-nan, Che-kiang and that part of
Kiang-su, south of the Hwai River.
The quality of the salts so produced differs greatly. The
field-dried salt is the best and is most in demand. Of the
other two, the pan-dried salt is better than the board-dried
salt. Some of the Sze-chuen salt, but not all, is exceedingly
1 For the Chinese systems of measure and weight, cf. appendix A.
70 [212
213] TAXATION OF SALT yi
white and pure, while the lake salt in Shan-si, Shen-si and
Kan-su generally has a green color and an unpleasant taste.
The cost of production varies with the production
methods. The field-dried salt is the cheapest. One catty
of salt costs less than one-tenth of one cent in time of
plenty, like May and June. Even in other months of the year,
one catty of salt is sold for not more than three-tenths of
one cent. The cost of both the pan-dried salt and the board-
dried salt is higher. It varies from four-tenths or five-
tenths of one cent to one cent for one catty. The best of
the Sse-chuen salt (pan-dried) costs even more than one
cent for one catty. The average cost for one catty of salt,
however, is less than five-tenths of one cent because more
than half of the total annual product is made up of field-
dried salt.
(2) The quantity of product. The quantity of product
is fixed by law on the assumption that each person consumes
.3 tael of salt every day. Owing to the lack of reliable sta-
tistics of population, the legal determination of the quan-
tity of salt is entirely arbitrary.^ The latest report (1911)
of the Department of Finance on the quantity of product
in recent years gives the following information :
(a) Manchuria. There are eight salt fields in Feng-tien
Province. The total annual output is 700,000 shi, each of
which is equal to 600 catties in weight. Hei-lung-kiang
Province, having a salt lake, produces about 7,000,000
catties of lake salt.
(b) Chi-li. This province has eight salt fields, called
Tsang-lo or Long weed. They annually produce about
800,000 packages. Each package weighs 450 or 460 catties.
(c) Shan-tung. Seven salt fields are found in Shmir-tung
Province. Three of them produce 1,068,000 packages every
1 Cf. infra, p. 73.
72 THE SYSTEM OF TAXATION IN CHINA [214
year, each package being equal to 390 catties. The quan-
tity of production of the other four fields is unknown, be-
cause those fields are not subject to the government regu-
lations.
(d) Shan-si. This province has a great salt lake, near
v^hich are situated three salt fields which are collectively
called Ho-timg or River's ^ East. During the last five years,
the annual product exceeded 6,000 ming. Each ming is
equal to 120 yin, and each yin is composed of 250 catties.
Therefore 6,000 ming are equal to (6,000 X 120 X 250)
or 180,000,000 catties.
(e) Kiang-su. In Kiang-su Province there are twenty-
three salt fields, of which twenty are situated on the south
bank of the Hwai River, and three, on the north of it. The
annual product of the South Hwai fields is 508,385 yin, each
of which contains 600 catties, and that of the North Hwai
fields is 502,540 yin, each having 400 catties.
(f) Che-kiang. The Che-kiang salt fields are those situ-
ated on the east and the west banks of the Che-kiang River.
There are thirty-two in all, of which twenty-five are found
in the Che-kiang Province, and the remainder in the
Kiang-su Province. The quantity of production is uncer-
tain.
(g) Fu-kien. Fu-kien Province has thirteen salt fields
which turned out 244,000,000 catties in 1887. The increase
of consumption shows the growth of production, although
there is no information about the annual product of the
last twenty-five years.
(h) Kwang-tung. We find twenty salt fields ^ in this
province with an annual product of 1,628,914 packages,
each containing 205 catties. In recent years two new fields
1 The word " river " means the Yellow River.
2 In addition to these, Kwang-tung has one field for storage only.
215] TAXATION OF SALT 73
have been developed, but the quantity of their products has
not yet been ascertained.
(i) Sze-chuen. This province has 100,814 salt wells.
The annual product of these wells is unknown.
(j) Yun-nan. Among the twenty-four salt wells in
Yun-nan Province, the Black Well and the White Well
produce over half of the annual output which is less than
40,000,000 catties.
The Legal Production of Salt 1
Province ^
Sze-chuen
Kiang-su \
Chi-li
Manchuria
Shan-tung
Kwang-tung
Che-kiang
Shan-si
Fu-kien
Yun-nan ^
Kan-su '
Legally fixed number
of introductory
certificates
(576,158)
(360,000)
662,497
6oo,coo
654,920
814,509
425,155
635,760
534,414
{
Number of
catties
per certificate
(600)
(400)
600
640
320
240
400 (average)
250
(100^
(600)
Total Number of
catties produced
in the year
345,688,800
144,000,000
397,498,200
384,000,000
209,574,400
195,482,100
1 70,062,000
158,940,000
Forms of Business Enterprise in Salt Production
The production of salt is an inherited occupation; and
the producers, constituting a special class of the society,
known as the Stove Men,* may be dependent undertakers,
^This table is prepared on the basis of an official report in 191 1 by
the Department of Finance.
2 Mongolia annually consumes about 40,000,000 catties of salt.
3 In Sse-chuen, Yun-nan and Kan-su, the quantity is not counted by
certificates. Cf. infra, p. 76.
* This name is derived from the process of manufacturing salt with
stoves.
74 THE SYSTEM OF TAXATION IN CHINA [216
small independent enterprisers or merely laborers accord-
ing to the method by which capital is provided. These
methods may be summarized as follows :
(a) The field monopolists/ In Kiang-su, Shan-si and
Sze-chuen Provnices, where this type is used, the salt
fields together with the necessary equipment are owned
by the capitalists, known as the monopolistic field mer-
chants, or, in short, the field monopolists. The relation of
the producers, i. e., the Stove Men, to their respective field
monopolists are like that of the tenants to their landlords.
The Stove Men in this case produce the salt independently,
but they are dependent on the field monopolists for a
market, the law requiring that the salt be sold only to them.
The government, the monopolistic distributors ^ or other
purchasers must buy salt from the field monopolists at the
fields. Therefore, the producers of this type may be de-
scribed as dependent undertakers.
(b) The monopolistic distributors. This is a combina-
tion of the field monopoly and the monopoly of distribution,
or in other words, the monopolistic distributors are at the
same time the field monopolists. The monopolistic dis-
tributors are related to the producers (Stove Men) in like
manner as the field monopolists. But instead of selling the
salt at the fields, they distribute it themselves. This type is
found in Che-kiang Province.
(c) The independent enterprisers. In this case the pro-
ducers (Stove Men) provide and own the necessary means
of production. Their product is directly sold to the mon-
opolistic distributors or other buyers. This type prevails
in Feng-Hen, Fu-kien and Yun-nan Provinces.
1 The monopolists in Sze-chuen where weU salt is produced are
called the Well Monopolists. The type of enterprise is the same.
2 Cf. infra, p. jy.
217] TAXATION OF SALT 75
(d) The mixed type. The Kwang-tung Province adopts
the third type. In recent years, the second type has been
introduced to certain places. The third type prevails in
Chi-li Province, but the producers (Stove Men) may bor-
row capital from the monopolistic distributors through the
mediation of the salt administrators on the condition that
their product shall be sold to the creditors. Capital is de-
rived in Shan-tung Province from five sources, namely, the
Bureau of Transportation in the case of government trans-
portation, the monopolistic distributors as enterprisers, the
monopolistic distributors as creditors, the partnerships of
the producers and the individual producers. In the first two
cases the producers are merely wage-earners, while, in the
other cases, they are independent enterprisers.
Consumption of. Salt
As we have seen, the supply of salt is legally limited in
order to secure profits as public revenues. If the salt is
not properly distributed, the consumers in some places
would enjoy cheap salt at the expense of the consumers of
other places, and the profits from salt would be small. In
order to fulfil both the social and the fiscal purposes, a
plan known as the division of markets (Yin Ti) is devised.
According to this plan, the country is divided into a number
of salt-consuming territories ^ corresponding to the num-
ber of salt-producing provinces.^ As the salt of each salt-
producing province is forbidden to be sold in any salt-con-
suming territories except that legally assigned as its market.
The assignment of salt-consuming territories is determined
by the following three conditions : ( i ) the number of con-
1 Each salt-consuming territory consists of a number of districts
under the control of several provinces.
2 The salt-producing provinces are at the same time parts of the salt-
consuming territories, because they have consumers too.
^6 THE SYSTEM OF TAXATION IN CHINA [218
sumers in the territories; (2) the productive power of the
salt-producing provinces; and (3) the facilities of commu-
nication between the salt-producing provinces and the salt-
consuming territories.
The assignment having been made, each district of the
salt-consuming territories is expected to demand a certain
quantity of salt. To meet the demand, a district may be
supplied by several monopolistic distributors or several dis-
tricts constitute the market of a single monopolistic dis-
tributor. The subdivision of markets within a territory is
subject to change from time to time to bring it into accord
with the amount of invested capital of the different monopo-
listic distributors. But the subdivision of markets is some-
times not followed in certain salt-consuming territories or
parts of the salt-consuming territories which are open tO'
the free competition of the common distributors.
The Feng-tien salt is supplied to the three provinces of
Manchuria, viz., Feng-tien, Ki-rin and Hei-lung-kiang, and
a part of Mongolia adjacent to them. The consuming ter-
ritories of the other kinds of salt may be found in Ap-
pendix B.
The Total Annual Consumption of Salt at Present 1
Kind of Salt Number of catties
Sze-chuen 550,860,000
Kiang-su 489,688,800
Chi-li 397,498,200
Manchuria 384,000,000
Shan-tung 209,574,400
Kwang-tung 195,482,100
Che-kiang 170,062,000
Shan-si 158,940,000
Fu-kien 77,200,000
Yun-nan 51,230,000
Kan-su 2,258,100
Total 2,686,793,600
1 Report of the Department of Finance, 191 1. Cf. supra, p. 73.
219] TAXATION OF SALT yy
Distribution of Salt
By the phrase " the distribution of salt ", is meant the
manner in which salt is bought at the fields and transported
to the chief cities of the salt-consuming territories, ready
to be sold to the retail traders. Here are three chief
methods of distribution.
(i) The private monopoly. According to this method,
Yin Piao, literally translated " introductory certificates ",
are issued by the Department of Finance to confer on
the holders the exclusive right to buy salt at certain or
all fields in a certain salt-producing province, and to trans-
port the same product to its consuming territory for sale.
The sale of product may be carried on by their own shops
or by other retailers. This method is further differentiated
into two types according as the introductory certificates of
a certain salt-producing province are held by a holding part-
nership which is a combination of several partnerships, or
a number of separate partnerships or individuals. When
the right of distribution is monopolized by a holding part-
nership, the subdivision of markets within the consuming
territory is arranged by the partnerships, otherwise it is
determined according to the number of certificates. These
monopolistic distributors, whether they are partnerships or
individuals, may hold their privileges so long as they pay
their royalties according to the agreements, and fulfil any
further requirements laid down by the government.
(2) The public monopoly. In the salt-consuming terri-
tory where this method is adopted, the introductory certifi-
cates are held by the Bureau of Transportation.^ The work
done by the public salt monopoly may be divided into two
types. One type consists of the purchase of salt, its trans-
portation and the retail trade. The other type does not in-
clude the retail trade.
1 Cf. infra, p. 84.
78 THE SYSTEM OF TAXATION IN CHINA [220
(3) The competitive trade. Whenever the whole or a
part of a certain salt-consuming territory is open to free
competition owing to lack of applications for the monopoly,
a special certificate called Piao is issued to confer the hold-
ers with right to buy and sell salt. This method has two
characteristics which distinguish it from the private or pub-
lic monopoly, vis., that any person may apply for one or
more certificates and that wherever the method prevails,
there is no division of markets.
From the fiscal point of view, the government always
tries to adopt the method of private monopoly, if possible,
because the monopolistic distributors pay or promise to pay
in advance a fixed amount of revenue proportional to the
number of introductory certificates issued to them, irre-
spective of the amount of sale. By this means, the govern-
ment may raise revenues without the investment of public
funds as capital and the assumption of business risk. But
sometimes no capitalist applies for the monopoly and some-
times the monopolistic distributors surrender their rights,
owing to the presence of one or more of the following con-
ditions which make the monopoly unprofitable :
(A) The decrease of demand for government salt. This
may be caused by the heavy burden of taxation, the competi-
tion of smuggled salt or economic depression.
(B) The difficulty of land transportation. Where there
are no railways the cost of distribution sometimes lessens
the monopoly profits.
(C) The situation of some districts near the salt fields.
This offers a good opportunity to the smugglers.
(D) The absence of commercial development. Of these
four conditions, the first three are met either by the public
monopoly or by the competitive trade, while only the public
monopoly is resorted to as the remedy of the fourth condi-
tion.
22 1 ] TAXATION OF SALT 79
The methods of distribution in use at present are given
in the following table:
Qassification of salt by its Methods of distribution
producing provinces
f Private monopoly
Feng-tien j Pu^Hc monopoly
Chi-li Private monopoly
/ Private monopoly
Shan-tung j Competitive trade
„, . J Competitive trade
^°^""®' t Public monopoly
TT- i Private monopoly
^'^^S-s^ i Competitive trade
Che-kiang Private monopoly
„ , . f Competitive trade
^^■^'^^ 1 Public monopoly
Kwang-tung Private monopoly
f, , f Public monopoly
Sze-chuen..... j Competitive trade
Yun-nan Competitive trade
Taxation of Salt
Kuan Tsi, a prime minister of the State of Tsi,^ in the
Eastern Chou Dynasty, 770-249 B. C, thought that the
natural resources of a country should be owned by the
state, and created the government monopolies of salt, iron,
timber and other minerals as the only source of public reve-
nue, because he disapproved taxation as a means of raising
public revenues on the following grounds:^ (A) because
the productive capital of a country would be lessened by
taxation; (B) because any kind of private properties sub-
ject to taxation would depreciate in value; and (C) because
taxation cannot be disguised.
As these monopolies yielded adequate revenues the State
of Tsi became the richest and most powerful of all the
rival states. Consequently, the salt monopoly continues to
be one of the most important sources of public revenue.
Salt is now taxed in five ways. First, the stove tax is a tax
1 This state corresponds to the Province of Shan-tung.
2 See Works of Kuan Tsi.
So THE SYSTEM OF TAXATION IN CHINA [222
on land used for salt production. Secondly, the certificate
royalty is a tax on the finished product, justified on the
ground that the state is the owner of the raw product (salt
water). The royalty is levied according to the number of
certificates, each of which represents a certain quantity of
finished product. Wherever the imposition of a certificate
royalty is not adaptable, a lump-sum royalty is substituted.
Thirdly, there are various kinds of receipts such as fees
from different sorts of public services, rents of public store-
houses and other properties, interest on loans of public
money, income from surplus salt, profit from money ex-
change, fines, etc., etc., which are described by the Depart-
ment of Finance as miscellaneous revenues. Fourthly, the
" dropping to ground " ^ duty is a sort of excise duty levied
by a salt-consuming province on the salt of a producing
province. Such a duty is imposed on the Kzvang-tung salt
by Kwang-si, and on the Sse-chuen salt and the Kiang-su
salt by Kwei-chow. This is permitted in order to compen-
sate these two poor provinces which have very few sources
of revenue. Finally, there is an additional price for special
purposes. The foregoing forms of taxation are considered
the regular taxes. They are supplemented by the exaction
of provincial governments. For instance, most of the
provinces treat salt as any other commodity, and lay a
li-kin duty ^ on it. Moreover, a compulsory contribution is
sometimes paid once and for all by the body of monopolistic
distributors in some provinces when the governors are
called on to support the imperial government, while, in
other provinces, different sorts of special tax are levied for
different purposes, e. g., public education, orphan asylums,
poor relief, etc. The rates of these taxes differ from prov-
1 By the phrase " dropping to ground " is meant the place of con-
sumption.
2 See infra, pp. 103-105.
223] TAXATION OF SALT 8 1
ince to province. Mr. Chang Chien ^ estimates the real
burden of each catty of salt in the following figures :
Classification of Salt by
its producing provinces Composite Rates of the Various Taxes
Kiang-su over .033 tael silver
Kwang-tung .024 - .025 tael silver
Yun-nan " .033 tael silver
Chi-li .02 "
Shan-si .017 - .018 tael silver
Sze-chuen " " "
Che-kiang .015 - .016 "
Shang-tung " " "
Fu-kien under .01 "
Manchuria
Average 018 tael or $.027 silver.
Smuggling of Salt
As we have seen, the distribution of salt is legally re-
stricted, competition is allowed only in Shen-si, northwest-
ern Kan-su and the frontier districts of North Chi-li and
North Shan-si where the Mongolian salt is consumed. But
illegal competition is found practically everywhere. Such
is (a) the competition between private salt and govern-
ment salt; (b) the competition between different salt-pro-
ducing provinces whose distributors try to sell their salt
beyond their respective consuming territories; and (c) the
competition between different monopolistic distributors in
^ Mr. Chang Chien, now about 70 years of age, is one of China's
most learned scholars as well as one of its greatest practical men.
He never accepted an appointment from the Manchu government.
He devoted his time to industry, commerce, education and various
social activities, and has become the most influential and popular
man in South China. He is a native of Kiang-su, the greatest salt-
producing province, and is the greatest living authority on the salt
industry. President Yuen Shi Kai, who holds him in the greatest re-
spect, has appointed him President of the Department of Agriculture,
Industries and Commerce. Mr. Chang has accepted this post.
82 THE SYSTEM OF TAXATION IN CHINA [224
the same province who try to sell salt beyond their as-
signed markets. Any competitor other than the monopolist
of a certain market is regarded as a smuggler ^ of that
market, and his salt, as smuggled goods. Therefore, a
smuggler may be a tax-evader or a monopolist, sometimes
even government salt being regarded as smuggled goods.
The smugglers take advantage of the following condi-
tions: (i) the contact of markets with one another; (2)
the evasion of taxation; (3) the different tax rates in the
different provinces; (4) the difference in the cost of pro-
duction in the different provinces ; ( 5 ) the difference in the
cost of transportation; (6) the pressure of the field monopo-
lists on the producers (Stove Men), i. e., low stove price; ^
(7) the pressure of the monopolistic distributors on the
consumers, i. e., high market price; ^ (8) the pressure of
the monopolistic distributors on the field monopolists, i. e.,
low buying price; (9) the secret reduction of tax rates on
the part of some administrators in the hope of making up
the legal amount of revenue by permitting the producers to
make large sales at low rates when difficulty is experienced
in selling the proper amounts at the legal rates; (10) the
dishonesty of the administrators and detectives; and (11)
the inefficiency of the administrators. So long as one or
more of these conditions exist, it is impossible for the gov-
ernment to check the smuggling of salt even by inflicting
heavy penalties on the smugglers.*
1 Any poor person over sixty or under fifteen years old has the
right to buy and sell not more than forty catties every day without
being treated as a smuggler.
2 Cf. infra, pp. 87-88.
3 Ihid.
* According to the Penal Code of the Tsing Dynasty, no penalty
can be inflicted on a person unless the person himself and his salt
are both taken as the evidence of smuggling.
225] TAXATION OF SALT 83
Administration of the Salt Monopoly
( I ) The administrators. At the beginning of the Tsing
Dynasty, commissioners were annually appointed by the
Emperor to all the salt-producing provinces except Sse-
chuen and Yun-nan. All the administrative officials con-
nected with the salt monopoly were under the direction
and supervision of their respective commissioners, leaving
those in Sze-chuen, Yun-nan and Kwei-chow to be con-
trolled by their own governors. Somewhat later it was
found that the commissioner in a province was neither so
efficient in controling administrative officials nor so familiar
with the local conditions as the governor and that it was
difficult for the commissioner to discharge his duties satis-
factorily. During the period 16601860 the governors
superseded the commissioners one after another as the
supervisors of the salt monopoly. The changes came in
1660 (Kwang-tung) , ^72,2, (Fu-kien), 1778 (Shan-si),
1 82 1 {Che-kiang, S hen-si, Kan-su), 1837 {Kiang-su, Shan-
tung), and i860 (Chi-li). Under the governor is the Presi-
dent of the Salt Department. The latter is the active
administrator controling a number of salt administra-
tors and the district magistrates who participate the ad-
ministration of the salt monopoly. The salt administrators
who are specially appointed for this function, consist of
two classes, the departmental secretaries and the field (or
well) administrators. The departmental secretaries help
the president to discharge his duties, while the field adminis-
trators enforce the regulations governing the production
and sale of salt at the fields and collect all the taxes on salt.
In addition to these two classes, the salt departments of a
few provinces, like Kiang-Su, have one or more vice-presi-
dents and a few inspectors. Each vice-president takes
charge of a number of fields in the province and the duty of
the inspectors is to see whether the actual quantity of salt
84 THE SYSTEM OF TAXATION IN CHINA [226
passing by their bureau, situated near the fields, corresponds
to the amount of purchase as written in the " bill of draw-
ing salt "/ On the other hand, the district magistrates are
responsible for the amount of sale assigned to their re-
spective districts, and for the capture of smugglers. As the
President of the Executive Department, the circuit gover-
nors, the prefects and the superior magistrates are the
superior officials of the magistrates, they assume joint re-
sponsibility with respect to the duties of the magistrates.
It is evident that the governor and practically all of the
officials under the Executive Department and the Salt De-
partment of a province are directly or jointly responsible
for the administration of the salt monopoly. For a deficit
of the legally fixed amount of revenue, they are subject to
forfeiture of salary, degradation, removal from office or
confiscation of property, the penalty varying according to
the amount and term of deferred payment, as well as the
direct or joint responsibility which the different ranks of
officials assume. Again, the officials may be promoted or
recorded for promotion, whenever they are able, by an in-
crease of demand for salt, to secure more than the legally
fixed amount of revenue.
(2) The administrative machinery of public monopoly.
Whenever the public monopoly of distribution prevails, two
types of bureau are especially established, besides the gov-
ernment storehouses. The first is called the Bureau of
Transportation, and the second, the Bureau of Wholesale.
The bureaus of transportation, of which there may be one
or two in a province, are established in a salt-producing
province. The bureaus of wholesale are established in the
principal cities of the consuming provinces. Both types of
bureau generally have a few branches. Candidates for cir-
1 Cf. infra, pp. 85-86.
227] TAXATION OF SALT 85
cuit governorships are appointed by the governor of a salt-
producing province to be the presidents of these head bu-
reaus, while candidates of district magistrates are appointed
presidents of branch bureaus. As their ranks are almost or
exactly equal, the presidents of the Salt Department, the
Bureau of Transportation and the Bureau of Wholesale are
unwilling to be subject to one another. As a result there is
no co-operation and the management of public monopoly is
generally inefficient. When the Bureau of Wholesale is not
required to sell its salt to the merchants, the magistrates are
its selling agents. So each magistrate has to carry a certain
quantity of salt to his district, and to open a few govern-
ment salt shops.
(3) The regulation of transportation. In those prov-
inces where the private monopoly of distribution is adopted,
two schemes are devised to prevent smuggling. One is to
inspect the amount of purchase near the fields, and another,
to prescribe the waterways of transportation. For these
purposes, " introductory certificates ", " bills of drawing
salt " and " waterway tickets " are provided. The intro-
ductory certificates issued by the Department of Finance,
were formerly brought by the commissioners to the prov-
inces. Since 1748 the governor of each salt-producing
province has sent an official to Peking to apply for the re-
quired number of certificates for his province. On each
certificate the following articles are written :
(a) The certificate represents the quantity of salt thereon
stated.
(b) Salt carried with an old certificate is considered as
smuggled goods.
(c) Salt carried without the certificate is considered as
smuggled goods.
(d) Any one who counterfeits the certificate is put to
death.
86 THE SYSTEM OF TAXATION IN CHINA [228
(e) Any merchant who keeps the certificates over ten
days after the sale of salt is beaten forty blows.
(f) The name of an assigned market.
The certificates are distributed among the monopolistic
distributors by the President of the Salt Department in a
province. Then the distributor may take his certificate (or
•certificates) to the inspector whose duty it is to clip the cer-
tificate at one corner and to hand it to the President of the
Salt Department for stamping seal. The latter, then, issues
a bill of drawing salt to the distributor. This bill is written
that a certain quantity of salt may be bought by Mr.
So-and-so at a certain field during a certain period. The
quantity of salt bought with this bill must be inspected by
an inspector of the Bureau of Inspection near the field.
This bill, together with the inspector's report, having been
submitted to the President of the Salt Department for ap-
proval, is kept in the bureau, while the introductory cer-
tificate is returned to the distributor. Whenever the salt is
ready to be transported to an assigned market, a waterway
ticket is given to the distributor permitting the salt to be
carried unmolested from place to place, provided that it is
carried by the prescribed waterway and to the destination,
as written on the ticket. But the waterway ticket and the
introductory certificate are subject to examination by the
district magistrates on the voyage, and must be returned
to the Salt Department through the magistrate of the con-
suming district within ten days after the salt has been sold.
If either of these documents were not carried with the salt,
or any article of the regulations stated on them were vio-
lated, the salt would be seized as smuggled salt.
The method of competitive trade may be illustrated by the
practice in the North Hwai fields of Kiang-su Province. In
each field there is a government shop, at which any person
is allowed to buy salt. When the salt is being carried
22g] TAXATION OF SALT 87
through the exit of the field, the carrier must pay to the
Bureau of Taxation there the required amount of tax on
the quantity of salt he has bought. In return for the pay-
ment, a certificate stating the carrier's name and native
place, the quantity of salt, and the name of the consuming
district is given to the carrier. He is allowed to sell the
salt in another district with the permission of the magis-
trate of the district which he first intends to supply. But
he is forbidden to sell the salt beyond the territory which
adopts the method of competitive trade, and to carry it
without the certificate. The certificate must be returned,
after the sale, to the Salt Department through the magis-
trate of the consuming district.
(4) The regulation of price. There are two kinds of
legal price, namely, the stove price and the market price. ^
The stove price is the purchasing price from the producers
known as the stove men. It is fixed according to the cost
of production and the quality of the product. The cost of
production in the different provinces depends chiefly on the
cost of living of the stove men, and the method of produc-
tion. Secondly, the market price is the selling price to the
retail traders. This is based on the purchasing price, the cost
of management and transportation and the taxes. In gen-
eral, the farther the market is from the salt fields, the more
its consumers must pay for the salt. Theoretically, the ob-
ject of legalizing these prices is to protect, on the one hand,
the producers against the field monopolists and the monopo-
listic distributors and, on the other hand, the consumers
against the monopolistic distributors. In practice, however,
the terms are favorable to the monopolists. But the regu-
lation has not been renewed since the reign of Emperor Tao
1 The term " market price " is used parallel with " stove price " to
indicate the legal price of salt put in market instead of the economic
price determined by the laws of supply and demand.
88 THE SYSTEM OF TAXATION IN CHINA [230
Kwang, 1821-1850. Therefore, for more than a half-cen-
tury, the producers and the consumers have been entirely
at the mercy of the monopolists.
General Features of the Salt Monopoly
The foregoing discussion should be supplemented by
some general considerations. Especially worthy of notice
is the relation of the monopoly to the public welfare, the
defects of the taxation system, and the present status of
the monopoly.
(i) The pressure of the monopolistic distributors upon
the actual producers (Stove Men) is of three kinds. The
first is that the purchasing price is fixed by the administra-
tors at the expense of the actual producers. Then extra
large tubs or baskets are used, when the price is fixed in
terms of a tub or basket. The third method is to raise the
value of money. Where the fields are monopolized by the
field monopolists who are subject to the pressure of the
monopolistic distributors too, the actual producers suffer
both directly from the field monopolists and indirectly from
the monopolistic distributors. The actual producers can-
not escape the pressure, because they are compelled by law
to continue their pursuit and because they are not acquainted
with the agricultural arts or with other pursuits.
(2) The pressure upon the consumers is as great as that
upon the actual producers. Take the Kiang-su salt for ex-
ample. As means of transportation are very good within
the consuming territory of this salt, the price should be low.
On the contrary, the retail price is from sixteen to twenty
times the cost of production (the purchasing price from the
actual producers). According to Mr. Chang Chien's^
record which appeared in the Eastern Times, Shanghai,
1 Cf. supra, p. 81, note i.
231] TAXATION OF SALT 89
January 4th, 191 3, the retail price of this salt is thirty cash ^
in the producing districts ; fifty to sixty cash in the farther
districts in Kiang-sii Province; over one hundred cash in
An-hwei Province; over one hundred and ten cash in
Kiang-si Province; and over one hundred and twenty cash
in Hu-peh Province. At first, the pressure falls on the con-
sumers by raising the cost of living. Ultimately, the pres-
sure must also be felt by the landlords and the enterprisers.
But as the rise of wages is always slower than the increase
of salt price, the laborers suffer the most, though the in-
evitable effect of dear salt is the retardation of the progress
of the whole community.
(3) The treatment of tax-evaders is very unjust. The
poor people who smuggle salt are sentenced to imprisonment
or death. But the administrators, the monopolists, and the
carriers have a right to evade taxation without punishment.
For instance, the monopolists of the South Hwai fields in
Kiang-su Province in practice sell over seven hundred
catties of salt for each six hundred catty certificate. In the
second place, each vessel or wagon always carries a certain
quantity of untaxed salt, known as the " extra salt ". The
administrators en route often take a certain quantity of the
" extra salt " called the " merit salt " without paying the
price.
(4) The salt monopoly is very productive. It yields
almost one-fourth of the annual tax revenue.^ But the pos-
sibility of increasing the productivity of the tax is very
slight. For, to increase the rate, keeping the production
quota at the same figure, would be to induce more smug-
1 The legal rate of exchange is that one thousand cash is equal to
one tael of silver. But the market rate of exchange fluctuates greatly
at different times and places.
2 According to the budget of 191 1, the amount is about 46,312,355
taels.
go THE SYSTEM OF TAXATION IN CHINA [232
gling. On the other hand, it is impossible to increase the
production quota, for the additional salt could not be dis-
posed of because of the competition of the smugglers. The
administration of the monopoly is uneconomical; in 1909
and 1 9 10 it consumed about twelve per cent of the average
annual return. Further, the tax rates are different in dif-
ferent provinces and at different times ; and so this form of
taxation is very unjust and uncertain. In the last place,
the lack of uniformity in the process of collection and the
varieties of supplementary charges in the different provinces
make the system very bad. Mr. Chang Chien ^ says, " I
cannot see into the complications, though I have investi-
gated these intricate methods of collection for twenty years.
But it seems to me that such local practices are not worthy
of existence."
(5) The method of large-scale production has never been
adopted in any salt-producing province. Everywhere salt
is produced by the actual producers (stove men) using
primitive methods. The so-called field monopolists are in-
terested only in securing a share of the monopoly profit of
the monopolistic distributors and do nothing toward the
improvement of production methods. The lack of modern
methods is responsible for the high cost of production such
as that found particularly in the South Hwai fields in
Kiang-su Province, the bad quality of salt as in Shan-si,
Shen-si or Kan-su Provinces and the decentralization of
fields as in Fu-kien Province. A still more important effect
of the present system is the inability of the government to
control the smugglers whose existence strikes at the very
heart of the whole system.
(6) The assignment of a particular salt-consuming terri-
tory to a particular salt-producing province inevitably raises
. 1 Cf. supra, p. 8r, note i.
233] TAXATION OF SALT 9I
two intricate problems. First, the equilibrium of demand
and supply of the different salts cannot be preserved. For
instance, the salt of the South Hwai fields in Kiang-su
Province has a demand greater than the supply, while there
is an oversupply of salt of the North Hwai fields in the
same province. Assuming the absence of smuggling, the
consumers must decrease consumption and pay higher prices
in the former case, while the monopolists who look for
maximum profits would prefer to waste the surplus products
rather than to sell all their products too cheaply in the
latter case. In both cases the waste is due to the legal re-
striction of markets. Fortunately, the problem is solved
by the smugglers. In the second place, the demand and
supply in particular places cannot be adjusted even under
the protection of private monopoly. Two extreme cases
may be cited. The protected markets in a territory which
is situated far from any salt field, and where the means of
transportation is very difficult, have never been sup-
plied by the monopolistic distributors. On the other
hand, those markets within a short distance from any
salt field are oversupplied due to the competition of smug-
gled salt. In both cases the government is obliged to take
up the work of distribution. Thus the monopolistic
distributors are induced to supply only those places which
are neither too far from, nor too near to the salt fields, and
where the means of transportation are fairly convenient. In
a few years the salt fields will be easily accessible to all sec-
tions of the country, for the resources of salt are well dis-
tributed by nature and railway development is rapidly pro-
ceeding. Of course, railway rates will have to be properly
adjusted. Under these new economic conditions, the
monopolistic distributors will be subjected to severe compe-
tition, which they may not be able to survive. But this does
not mean that the salt monopoly is doomed. A combined
92 THE SYSTEM OF TAXATION IN CHINA [234
monopoly of both production and distribution might be very
successful and might prove to be a highly desirable institu-
tion in a transition period in the industrial development of
China.
CHAPTER V
Taxation of Commodities
The Regular Customs
(i) General considerations. The customs duty is a
general excise tax on merchandise. It finds its origin as
far back as the Western Chou Dynasty (i 12-771 B. C.)
It was originally levied not for a fiscal, but for a regu-
lative purpose, vis., in order to check the progress of
commerce in favor of agriculture. This is because both
economists and statesmen at the time thought that agricul-
ture was more fundamental and important than other pur-
suits. But, at the beginning of the Western Han Dynasty
(206 B. C.-6 A. D.), it was realized that, in spite of the
tax, commerce had progressed. Nevertheless the customs
duty was retained, so that, for centuries, the revenue pur-
pose has been primary. At present, custom-houses have been
established on the seaboard, on rivers, inland water-ways,
land routes and land frontiers. They are called the Regu-
lar Customs in order to distinguish them from the Mari-
time Customs. The jurisdictions of the two systems some-
times seem to conflict. Thus commodities carried by sailing
ships are taxed by the Regular Customs, while commodities
carried by steamers pay their duties to the Maritime Cus-
toms. Formerly, there were thirty-four customs-houses
(branches not included) under the control of the Depart-
ment of Finance. Besides these, a number of customs-
houses which was formerly under the control of the Depart-
235] 93
94 THE SYSTEM OF TAXATION IN CHINA [236
ment of Public Works has been turned over to the Depart-
ment of Finance in recent years. At present, there are
about twenty-seven important customs-houses as given in
the subjoined table.
Location of Custom Houses
Name Location
Tsung-wen Gate Peking
Newchwang Feng-tien Province
Tientsin Chi-li "
Chin-wang-tao " "
Kalgan
Che-foo Shan-tung "
Kiao-chow
Lin-ching " "
Kwei-hwa-ching Shan-si "
Sha-fu-kou
Shanghai Kiang-su "
Hwai-an
Yang-chow
Feng-yang An-hwei "
Wuhu
Kiukiang Kiang-si "
Gung
Foo-chow Fu-kien "
Hang-chow Che-kiang "
Wen-chow "
Han-yang Hu-peh "
Wu-chang
King-cho n
Sun-chow Hu-nan "
Chungking Sze-chuen "
Canton . ; ! Kwang-tung "
Tai-ping Kwang-si "
(2) Subjects of taxation. Almost all of the regular cus-
toms levy duties on merchandise which is classified into
four classes, namely, clothes, food-stufifs, articles of com-
mon use and sundry goods. This does not include the tax-
ation, as laid by certain customs, on carts, cattle, brokers,
237] TAXATION OF COMMODITIES 95
conveyance of real estate, oil shops, wine shops, salt, bam-
boo, timber and tea. Most of the customs on the seaboard
or on inland waterways also levy port dues (Chuan Liao)
on junks. At some customs, the following exemptions are
made:
(A) In the case of junks.
(a) Junks carrying government rice or other pro-
ducts.
(b) Junks carrying rice, bought for famine relief
and soldiers' pay (exempt only in Kiang-su
Province) .
(c) Junks carrying rice or wheat (at certain cus-
toms).
(d) Fishing boats sailing along the sea coast.
(e) Small boats less than five feet wide.
(B) In the case of goods.
(a) Copper, lead, tin and other articles bought for
government use.
(b) Rice and other cereals bought for famine relief.
(c) Rice and other commodities going out of Peking
through the Tsimg-wen Gate.
(d) Rice or wheat (at certain customs).
(e) Rice for local consumption, passing by the Yang-
chow customs, Kiang-su Province.
(f) Pearls and precious metals passing by the Can^
ton Customs.
(g) Food products and other articles necessary for
the use of sailors on any vessel.
(h) Any article borne by a person over his (or her)
shoulder or on his (or her) back,
(i) A certain quantity of native produce of North
China, brought southward in the government
rice junks.
C)6 THE SYSTEM OF TAXATION IN CHINA [238
(j) Tribute from the nobles and lamas of Monoglia,
Thibet, etc.
(k) Imperial presents to the nobles and lamas of
Mongolia, Thibet, etc.
(3) Rates and revenues. The rates on both junks and
merchandise are specific. In the case of junks, the number
of masts, the number of stores or the width of the junks is
taken as the basis of rate-making. At a given customs,
rates vary not only as the different classes of junks, but also
as the different size of the same class. Furthermore, junks
of the same class and of uniform size pay different amounts
of port dues at different customs. In the case of merchan-
dise the determination of the rate is based on four condi-
tions, namely, the place of production, the degree of utility,
its market price, and the distance of transportation. These
are taken into consideration for the following reasons : ( i )
the quality of an article differs with the different places of
production; (2) the utility of an article is more or less
adapted to the habits of the consumers in different places ;
and (3) the cost of transportation is directly proportional
to the distance.
It is evident that a higher rate should be charged on an
article of better quality, more adaptable to the habits of con-
sumers in a certain locality, paying cheaper cost of trans-
fK)rtation. With this end in mind, rates are calculated on
different units — weight, length, piece, roll, sheet, suit, pair,
volume, head, basket, jar, etc. — according to the nature of
goods subject to taxation. At some customs, a lump sum is
levied according to the quantity of goods, measured either
by the volume of the junk or by the size of the cart as the
case may be. The rates as such are fixed by the Department
of Finance and are subject to change from time to time by
the department. In addition to the regular duty, a sup-
239] TAXATION OF COMMODITIES 97
plementary duty of ten per cent of the regular one is levied
by almost all of the customs under the name of meltage
fee/ transportation fee,^ and others.
The amount of revenues drawn from the different cus-
toms is composed of two parts, the regular revenues and
the surplus revenues. Both parts are fixed by law. The
whole of the regular revenues and at least sixty per cent of
the surplus revenues must be paid to the Department of
Finance, It is required that deficits shall be made up by the
administrators out of their private purses as a penalty for
their inefficient administration. But if there is any surplus,
the total sum collected must be sent to the treasury of the
Department of Finance.
(4) Mode of levying duties on goods. The first step
taken by the customs officials in levying duties is to post the
existing rates of dutiable goods on the boards erected at the
markets, and to request the local authorities to print the
same rates in pamphlets for the use of shopkeepers. As
soon as any merchant hands in a report of his goods, the
customs officials must examine the goods and calculate the
amount of duty. The merchant has the right to put the
money into the " collection box " himself without any re-
straint or interference by any customs inspector or watch-
man. One shopkeeper is not allowed to pay tax for others,
except at the Tsung-wen Gate of Peking, when the goods
arrive earlier than the owner. In return for his payment,
the merchant is entitled to a red receipt, of which a duplicate
is sent to the Department of Finance for investigation.
This receipt is clipped at its corner, and stamped on its face
with a written time and date of passing, when it is ex-
hibited as the right to pass the customs lines. Duty-paid
1 This fee is charged for the los'S of silver in melting.
2 This fee is charged because the collected revenues must be trans-
ported.
gg THE SYSTEM OF TAXATION IN CHINA [240
goods are allowed to pass twice a day. It is further required
that produce from certain localities pay duties at particular
customs-houses. For example, any merchant carrying
oxen, sheep or goats, camels, horses, or skins overland
from Kiata, Ku-lon, etc. (Mongolia), to the interior must
pay duties at Chan-tsia-kou rather than at Ku-pei-kou.
Secondly, any person carrying goods, along the Yang-tse
River, from North Kiang-su or An^hzvei Provinces to the
City of Soo-chow (South Kiang-su Province) or the City of
Hang-chow (Che-kiang Province) must pay duties at the
Wu-sile Customs,^ instead of any customs on the seaboard.
Thirdly, produce from Fu-kien, Che-kiang, Feng-tien, and
Shan-tung Provinces, transported along the seacoast to
Shanghai is taxed by the Shanghai Customs. Fourthly,
produce carried from Fu-kien, Kwang-tung or Kiang-si
Provinces to the City of Soo-chozv or the City of Sung-
kiang ( South Kiang-su Province) , by the Che-kiang River,
is taxed at the Pei-sin Customs,^ while that from the latter
cities to the former provinces, at the Che-hai or the Pei-sin
Customs. Whenever any attempt to conceal the goods, or
to make an incorrect report or to escape payment by taking
another route is found, it is treated as an act of evasion.
Such an act is punished by a confiscation of half the quan-
tity of goods and a punishment of the merchant according
to the civil code, unless the amount of duty evaded is very
insignificant (only a few taels), when an additional duty of
from two to five times the regular duty is imposed as a fine.
(5) The administration of the regular customs.^ Every
customs, together with its branches, is superintended by an
official, called the Superintendent of Customs. The super-
intendent may be
1 Cf, infra, p. 99.
2 Since 1901 many regular customs are under the control of the
Inspector General of the Maritime Customs.
241 ] TAXATION OF COMMODITIES 99
(A) An Imperial High Commissioner of Customs, as
the Superintendent of the Tsung-wen Gate (Peking), that
of the Left-Wing (Peking), or that of the Right-Wing
(Peking).
(B) A Manchu general, as the Superintendent of the
Foo-chow Customs.
(C) An Imperial Commissioner of Silk-manufactures,
as the Superintendent of the Si-sin Customs (Nan-king),
that of the Wu-sue Customs (Chin-kiang), or that of the
Pei-sin Customs {Hang-chow).
(D) A Commissioner of Customs, appointed by the Em-
peror upon the nomination of the Department of Fin-
ance, as the Superintendent of the Hwai-an Customs
(Hwai-an) ,^ that of the Canton Customs, that of the Tien-
tsin Customs, that of the Tsau-liang-ting Customs {Tung-
chow),^ that of the Chang-tsia^kou Customs {Kalgan), or
that of the Sha-fu-kou Customs (a boundary town between
Shan-si and Mongolia).
(E) A Circuit governor (or lower local authority), as
the superintendents of all the customs, except thpse men-
tioned above, and the Pei-hai Customs ^ ( superintended by
the Superintendent of the Canton Customs).
The chief duties discharged by the superintendent are as
follows :
(A) To collect the duties mentioned in the preceding
section.
(B) To keep an " entry book ", a " collection account "
and a " total receipt account ". An entry book is a book in
which the merchants enter their goods themselves. A col-
lection account is a record of payments from goods as en-
1 Hwai-an is a prefecture in Kiang-su Province.
2 Tung-chow is a river port of Peking.
3 A port on the Canton River.
100 THE SYSTEM OF TAXATION IN CHINA [242
tered in the entry book. Duplicate copies of the collection
account and the total receipt account are kept in the customs
and in the superintendent's residence.
(C) To deliver the collected revenues to the Department
of Finance once every season (at some customs), or once
every half-year (at other customs), or once a year (at still
other customs).
(D) To prohibit the trade of the following contraband
goods : gambling instruments, salt, tea, opium, saltpetre, cast
iron and other munitions of war.
(E) To issue licenses to junks trading along the sea-
coast or with foreign countries, and to cancel the same upon
the return of the junks.
(F) To restrict the exportation of rice, raw silk, satin
and cast iron necessary for home use. With respect
to rice and cast iron, each junk is allowed to carry an
iron pan for cooking rice, an iron axe and a necessary
amount of rice corresponding to the number of sailors. Of
silk, satin or coarse raw silk, each vessel may carry a cer-
tain quantity according to its destination to use in exchange
for foreign goods ; the exportation of fine raw silk is abso-
lutely prohibited. The maximum quantity to be carried an-
nually by each vessel is as follows : (a) From Kiang-su or
Che-kiang Provinces to Japan, 3,960 catties (33 rolls) satin,
for 1,200 catties or less of which may be substituted coarse
raw silk, (b) From Fu-kien or Kwang-tung Provinces to
Annan 300 catties coarse raw silk, (c) From Che-kiang
Province to the Straits Settlements, 2,000 catties coarse
raw silk, (d) From Kwang-tung Province to Sweden,
10,000 catties coarse raw silk, (e) From Fu-kien Province
to any place abroad, 2,000 catties coarse raw silk.
(G) To prevent unlawful acts of the inspectors or watch-
men.
For these duties, especially the first three, the superin-
243] TAXATION OF COMMODITIES iqi
tendent is responsible to the Department of Finance. There-
fore, the entry books and accounts of every customs must be
submitted to the department to be audited once a year. If
the superintendent is a commissioner whose term is one year,
he must return to the department with the " entry books "
and accounts within a fixed period, after the expiration of
his term, the time being arranged according to the distance
of the customs from Peking. If the superintendent is a
local authority, the " entry books " and accounts must be
submitted through the governor or governor-general, once
a year, although his term is not limited to one year. If the
" entry book " or the " red receipt duplicates " are not sent
to the department at the right time, the superintendent is
fined a half-year's salary. If any merchant is excluded from
the right to enter his goods in the " entry books " himself,
or to receive a red receipt, the superintendent is fined one
year's salary. In the case of a deficit in the revenues the
superintendent is punished by a forfeiture of one year's sal-
ary, if the deficit is less than five per cent of the legal
amount; by degradation to lower and lower rank suc-
cessively, if over five per cent, ten per cent, twenty per cent,
thirty per cent, or forty per cent; and by dismissal if over
fifty per cent. To cover the cost of collection he is per-
mitted to retain the supplementary duty or, if a supple-
mentary duty is not levied, to deduct ten per cent out of the
surplus revenues.
(6) General features of the regular customs duties. The
most interesting feature is the fee system. According to
the report of the Investigation Committee sent by the De-
partment of Finance in 1906 to investigate the actual admin-
istration of the regular customs, the rates of fees are greater
than the rate of the regular duty in all the customs. For
example, three or four taels of fees are added to every one
tael of duty in the Hwai-an Customs {Kiang-su Province),.
I02 THE SYSTEM OF TAXATION IN CHINA [244
the Feng-yang Customs and the Wu-hu Customs (An-hwei
Province) ; and the amount of fees charged by the Hwai-an
Customs on timber is ten-fold the amount of duty. As the
total sum of fees and duty is sometimes too great to be
borne, the corrupt administrators often reduce the regular
duty in order to get the sufficient amount of fees for their
own account. This necessarily involves five grave defects,
namely, unproductiveness owing to the secret reduction of
duty ; various losses due to interference with trade ; and in-
justice, uncertainty and inconvenience because of the dis-
crimination involved in the bargain between the administra-
tors and the merchants. x\nother corrupt practice is the
over-supply of clerks and servants. Each customs has two
or three thousands of these persons. They are simply para-
sites receiving very low wages and trying to take advantage
of the merchants. In regard to the regular duty, four points
are worthy of mention. First, it should be more produc-
tive, as it yields only 6,990,845.925 taels according to the
budget of 191 1. Secondly, it checks the development of in-
ternal commerce, because commodities carried by the sailing
ships — and most of the internal commerce is conducted in
this manner — are subject to the repeated taxation of sev-
eral successive customs. Goods carried by steamers pay
duty to the maritime customs once and for all. Thirdly, the
burden on those goods carried by sailing ships is by no
means equal. This is due partly to the difference of trade
routes and partly to the lack of uniformity regarding to
the articles taxed. On the one hand, some goods pass
more and the others fewer customs. On the other hand,
some customs restrict themselves to a levy of either port
dues or customs duties, while the others collect both of
them. Further, the taxation of food-stuffs as well as articles
of enjoyment and the difference of tax rates and regula-
tions oppress the people with different degrees of severity.
245] TAXATION OF COMMODITIES 103
Finally, the pre-determination of the annual return leads
to the concealment of revenue. This is done in three ways.
One way is to report less than the collected amount in
order to save the remainder to remit as part of the defi-
ciency amount required to be paid to the Department of
Finance. Another way is to create a sinking fund for
a year of deficit. The third is to keep the surplus revenue
for provincial purposes, lest the Department of Finance
should know the growth of revenue, and increase the fixed
amount.
The Li-kin Duty ^
(i) General considerations. The Tai^ping Rebellion
broke out in 1850; and from that time one city after an-
other fell into the hands of the rebels. Owing to the fall
of Nanking and Soo-chozv, the two most important cities
in Kiang-su Province, in 1853, the government could not
levy the land tax in Kiang-su, the most productive of the
provinces. The only source of revenue available for mili-
tary expenses was the customs duties collected by the Im-
perial Maritime Customs at Shanghai. This drove the au-
thorities to devise new forms of taxation. Mr. Lay Yi Hien,
then leading a military force in the Prefecture of Yang-
chow, Kiang-su Province, introduced the " li-kin contri-
bution " with a collection bureau at Siit-nii Tsin, a com-
mercial town of Yang-chow; and a collection bureau was
soon established at Shanghai. The so-called " li-kin con-
tribution " is a contribution of one-thousandth of one tael
of silver charged as a transit duty on the value of goods.
The government thought that this compulsory contribu-
tion, or duty, would yield a reliable income; and, in 1854,
instructed the governor of Kiang-su tO' apply it to the whole
1 The general features of this duty are similar to those of the regular
customs duties.
I04 THE SYSTEM OF TAXATION IN CHINA [246
province, if possible. During the period 1854-1874, it was
adopted by the eighteen provinces of China Proper, and
Feng-tien and Kir-rin in Manchuria.
(2) Rate and revenue. As we have seen that the li-kin
duty means a compulsory contribution of one-thousandth
of one tael of silver, charged as a transit duty on the value
of goods, it may be called, in other words, an ad-valorem
duty of one-tenth of one per cent. But, in practice, the
imperial government has never enforced this legal rate
because of the necessity for greater revenue than it pro-
duced to defray military expenses during the Rebellion
and to carry out local improvements afterward. Rates
are different from province to province and from time to
time. Nor are they uniform in regard to different classes
of goods, which are classified, for taxation purposes, intO'
merchandise in general, salt, tea, opium and other staple
produce. According to the Institutes of the Tsing Dynasty,
the legal rates in the different provinces are one per cent,
two per cent, five per cent or nine per cent. But they vary
widely in practice. Furthermore, the burden of this tax
cannot be measured by the rate alone on a given class of
goods, in a given province, at a given time; in addition the
number of li-kin stations or barriers en route, which varies
with place and time, must be taken into consideration.
With respect to revenues, there are no legal amounts to
be delivered to the Department of Finance. But this does
not exclude it from the right to get a share of revenue by
a negotiation with the governors. In order to avoid the
great demand and possible interference of the department,
the governors keep secret the actual amounts of collected
revenues to meet the growing expenditures of their re-
spective provinces. Therefore, the amount of collected
revenue reported to the Department of Finance is recog-
nized by almost every well-informed Chinese to be false.
247] TAXATION OF COMMODITIES 105
(3) The administration. Since the li-kin duty was
created for military expenses during the Tai-ping Rebel-
lion, it was subject to the absolute control of the gover-
nors who were in command of government forces as well
as in charge of war revenues. The practice still exists, be-
cause the tax has remained after the rebellion as a local
rate levied for the purposes of local improvements.
For administrative purposes, each province establishes a
chief collection bureau at its capital, a number of branch
bureaus at the principal cities, and a number of stations.
These stations are situated not far apart, along the different
trade routes within the province for taxation and inspection
purposes. The administrators are selected by the governor
from the candidates for circuit governor, prefect, magis-
trate, etc. An administrator is recorded as efficient or in-
efficient by comparing the amount of collected revenue.
He is not allowed to report a less amount than what he has
collected, or to report paid-up duty as deferred payment.
Whenever he does either of these things, he is punished for
fraud on revenue by removing him from office and rank,
and by compelling him to make up the deficit, no matter
whether the sum is large or small. But he may deduct ten
per cent from the collected revenue as the cost of collection.
CONCLUSION
Regarded from a theoretical standpoint, the Chinese
government is centralized, the several governors being
simply the agents of the Emperor. In fact, however, the
administration is decentralized, because the governors
within their respective provinces are almost independent
in the exercise of their powers. For the sake of efficiency
and economy, the administration of finance naturally falls
in the hands of the governors. As each governor is re-
sponsible to the Emperor for his province, he tries his best
to develop its financial productiveness by using all the reve-
nues at his disposal. From the individual point of view,
the governor is loyal to the Emperor. From the national
point of view, however, he can be blamed for the neglect
of his neighbors. In order to prevent such provincial an-
tagonism, the power of financial control is vested in the
legislative departments, especially the Department of Fin-
ance. Unfortunately, this check has two undesirable
effects. One of these is the scrambling of revenues. Thus
deficient provincial governments eagerly request the sup-
port of the Department of Finance, which, in turn, must
depend entirely upon the aid furnished by the richer pro-
vincial governments. Sometimes other departments also
ask for support from the richer provinces. In all cases,
the success in securing additional revenue depends entirely
upon the personal influence of the heads of the different
departments. Secondly, there is a concealment of revenues
which arises from the fact that the governors of the richer
provinces are unwilling to share their revenues with the
io6 [248
249] CONCLUSION 107
Department of Finance. Such concealment is possible be-
cause the department is ignorant of the local conditions.
Therefore, the department's powers of appropriation and
supervision are merely nominal. If we desire to solve the
financial problem, we are first confronted with the question
of centralizing the administrative powers. But such a
question of reorganization will not be solved until the full
development of the means of communication.
The development of railways will have an enormous in-
fluence upon the tax system. As we have seen, the monop-
oly in the distribution of salt owes its existence to the dififi-
culty of transportation. Furthermore, the change of trade
routes due to the development of railways greatly affects
the productivity of the inland regular customs. A new plan
of levying the excise tax, better adjusted to the new eco-
nomic conditions, must soon be devised. Finally, the rail-
ways will alter land values, to which the land tax must be ad-
justed in the future. A general re-assessment will, there
fore, be necessary. Thus it is evident that the political or-
ganization and the taxation system now in force in China
are fit to survive only so long as backward conditions con-
tinue. But it must be remembered that such conditions
still exist in most sections of China and that they will be
slow to disappear. Radical changes will, therefore, come
much more slowly than some may expect.
APPENDIX A
The units of measure and weight of the Chinese system,
used in this work, may be expressed in terms of those of
the metric system as follows :
One mou is equal to 6TWTr ares.
One sine is equal to ItII^tt litres.
One catty is equal to 596tVA grammes.
One tael is equal to 37Tm grammes.
io8 [250
APPENDIX B
The Consuming Territory ^ of the Chi-li Salt
Number of
Number of
Names and location of the prefectures
prefectures in
direct districts
and direct districts with or without
the province
in the province
the Chi-li salt
Province
With
With
Total »
Chi-li
salt
TotaP
Chi-li
salt
Names '
Location
Chi-li*..
II
9
ID
i
1
6 ,Cheng-ta Fu
North of the Great Wall
(without)
Chao-yang Fu
« « «
(without)
Tsi-fcng Chow
« « ((
(without)
Chang - tsa - kau
(( « «
Ting (without)
Tu-shi-kau Ting
« « «
(without)
Ta-lun-nor Ting
« « ((
(without)
Ho-nan *
9
5
5
2
Chang-ta Fu
(with)
Wei-fay Fu
(with)
Hwai-ching Fu
(with)
Kai-feng Fu
(with)
Chen-chow Fu
(with)
Shii Chow
(with)
Chen Chow
(with)
North of the Yellow River
« <i «
« « «
Eastern Ho-nan
« K
« «
<l «
1 For markets of different salt-producing provinces see Amendments
of the Institutes of the Tsing Dynasty, chaps, ccxxi-ccxxix.
2 The total number of prefectures and direct districts in this and the
following tables is taken from Geography of the Chinese Empire
(Shanghai, iQii), by Professor Tu Chi of the Imperial University of
Peking.
* When the names of places without the Chi-li salt are given it is
251] 109
no APPENDIX B [252
The Consuming Territory of the Shan-tung Salt
Province
Number of
prefectures
in the prov-
ince
Number of
direct dis-
tricts in the
province
Names and location of the prefectures
and direct districts with the Shan-
tung salt 1
Total
With
Shan-
tung
salt
Total
With
Shan-
tung
salt
Names ^
Location
Shan-tung .
Ho-nan. ..
Kiang-su ^.
10
9
8
10
I
I
3
5
3
3
• •
• •
Shang-tung Province
( with )
Kwei-ta Fu
(with)
Shii-chow Fu
(with)
Northeastern cor-
ner of Ho-nan
Northwestern cor-
ner of Kiang-su
understood that the other places are supplied with this salt, and
vice versa.
* All places outlying north of the Great Wall are supplied with the
Mongolian salt.
^ Siang-ching, a subordinate district of Shii Chow is not the con-
sumer of the Chi-li salt. Wu-yang, a subordinate district of Nan-yang
Fu in southwestern Ho-nan is supplied with the Chi-li salt.
1 Su-chow, a subordinate district of Feng-yang Fu, in An-hwei Pro-
vince is near to Shii-chow Fu and supplied with the Shan-tung salt.
2 When the names of places with the Shan-tung salt are given, it
is understood that the other places are not supplied with this salt.
3 Three of the eight subordinate districts in Shii-chow Fu are not
supplied with the Shan-tung salt.
253] APPENDIX B
The Consuming Territory of the Shan-si Salt
III
.
Number of
Number of
Names and location of the prefectures
prefectures in
direct districts
and direct districts with or
the province
in the
province
without the Shan-si salt
ProTince
With
With
Total
Shan-si
salt
Total
Shan-si
salt
Names '
Location
Shan-si*
9
7
10
10
Ta-tung Fu
(without)
Shau-ping Fu
(without)
Surrounded by the
Great Wall
K «
Shen-si .
7
3
5
3
Si-an Fu
(with)
Chien Chow
(with)
Pin Chow
(with)
Tung-an Fu
(with)
Shing-an Fu
(with)
Siang Chow
(with)
Middle part of
Shen-si
« «
« u
« «
Southern frontier of
Shen-si
Southeastern corner
of Shen-si
Ho-nan'
9
2
5
2
Ho-nan Fu
(with)
Shen Chow
(with)
Yii Chow
(with)
Nan-yang Fu
(with)
South of the Yellow
River & western
part of Ho-nan
<( «
« ((
« «
1 When the names of places without the Shan-si salt are given, it is
understood that the other places are supplied with this salt, and
vice versa.
2 According to the Institutes of the Tsing Dynasty, Ta-tung Fu and
Shau-ping Fu are markets of the Shan-si salt.
* Siang-ching, a subordinate district of Shil Chow in Ho-nan Province
is supplied with the Shan-si salt. Cf. supra, p. 1 10, note 5.
112 APPENDIX B [254
The Consuming Territory of the Shen-si or Kan-su Salt
Number of pre-
Number of direct
Names and location of the prefec-
fectures in the
districts in the
tures and direct districts, with
province
province
the Shen-si or Kan-su salt
Province
With
Shen-si or
With
Shen-si or
Total
Kan-su
salt
Total
Kan-su
salt
Names ^
Location
Shen-si '
7
2 (Shen-si)
I (Kan-su)
5
I (Shen-si)
Hanchung Fu.
(Shen-si)
Yen-an Fu ....
(Shen-si)
Lu Chow
(Shen-si)
Fung-tsiang Fu.
(Kan-su)
Southwestern cor-
ner of Shen-si
Middle section of
northern corner
of Shen-si
Northern corner of
Shen-si
Western corner of
Shen-si
Kan-su '
8
5 (Kan-su)
6
2 (Kan-su)
Ping-liang Fu*.
(Kan-su)
Ching-Yang Fu*
(Kan-su)
Ning-sha Fu*..
(Kan-su)
Lan-chow Fuf .
(Kan-su)
Gung-chang Fuf
(Kan-su)
Chin Chow f . .
(Kan-su)
Tsia Chow t . . .
(Kan-su)
Eastern corner of
Kan-su
« «
Northern corner of
Kan-su
Northwestern part
of the interior of
Kan-su
Southern part of
Kan-su
« ((
Southern corner of
Kan-su
1 Those places in Shen-si and Kan-su, whose names are not given
here are supplied with the Mongolian salt.
2 The Shen-si salt is derived from the Large Piebald-Horse Lake in
Ting-bien Hsien, a subordinate district of Yen-an Fu. Ching-tsien
Hsien, a district northeast of Yen-an Fu also takes the Shen-si salt.
s There are two kinds of salt in Kan-su, one being lake salt from the
Small Fiebald-Horse Lake in Ling-chow, a subordinate district of
Ning-sha Fu, another being well salt from salt wells in Chang Hsien
(now a part of Lung-si Hsien) and Si-ho Hsien, which are subordinate
districts of Gung-chang Fu. Those places marked with (*) are supplied
with lake salt, while the others indicated by (t), with well salt.
255] APPENDIX B
The Consuming Territory of the Kiang-su Salt
113
Number of
prefectures in
the province
Number of
direct districts
in the province
Names and location of the prefectures
with or without the Kiang-su salt
Province
With
With
Total
Kiang-su
salt
Total
3
Kiang-su
salt
Names ^
Location
Kiang-su *
8
4
2
Kiang-ning Fu
Southwestern Kiang-su
(with)
Hwai-an Fu
North of the Yang-tze
(with)
River
Yang-chow Fu
« «
(with)
Tung Chow
« «
(with)
Hai Chow
<< (1
(with)
Shii-chow Fu
« «
(with)
An-hwei . .
8
7
5
4
Hwei-chow Fu
(without)
Kwang-ta Chow
(without)
Southeastern frontier of
An-hwei
Eastern frontier of An-hwei
Hu-peh ^•.
ID
9
I
I
Sze-nan Fu
(without)
Southwestern corner of
Hu-peh
Hu-nan . . .
9
9
4
2
Pin Chow
(without)
Kwei-yangChow
(without)
Southeastern frontier of
Hu-nan
(t ((
Kiang-si ..
13
10
I
Kwang-sin Fu
(without)
Nan -an Fu
(without)
Gung-chow Fu
(without)
Ning-tu Chow
(without)
Northeastern corner of
Kiang-si
Southern Kiang-si
Ho-nan . . .
9
9
S
I
Yii-ning Fu
(with)
Kwang Chow
(with)
Southern frontier of Ho-nan
Southeastern corner of
Ho-nan
Kwei-chow.
12
4
I
Tung-yin Fu
(with)
Sze-chow Fu
(with)
Chin-yuen Fu
(with)
Li -ping Fu
(with)
Eastern frontier of
Kwei-chow
« «
X «
« ((
1 When the names of places with the Kiang-au salt are given, it is
114
APPENDIX B [256
The Consuming Territory of the Che-kiang Salt
Number of pre-
fectures in the
province
Number of di-
rect districts in
the province
Names and locations of the prefec-
tures and direct districts with
the Che-kiang salt
Province
Total
With
Che-
kiang
salt
Total
With
Che-
kiang
salt
Names
Location
Che-kiang.
Kiang-su . .
An-hwei ..
Kiang-si ..
II
8
8
13
II
4
I
I
• • > •
3
5
I
• • • •
I
I
Che-kiang Province
Soo-chow Fu
Sung-kiang Fu . • .
Shiang-chow Fu...
Chin-kiang Fu . . . .
Tai-chwang Chow.
Hwei-chow Fu . . •
Kwang-ta Chow . .
Kwang-sin Fu....
South of the
Yang-tze River
(( «
(( it
ii «
li ii
South corner of
An-hwei
East corner of
An-hwei
Northeastern
corner of
Kiang-si
understood that the other places are not the markets of this salt, and
vice versa.
2 Shii-chozv Fu represents only three of its subordinate districts,
namely. Pi-chow, Su-chien and Tsui-ning. Cf. supra, p. no, note 3.
3 Hoc-feng chow and Chang-lau-hsien, two districts near to Sze-nan
Fu are not the Kiang-su salt markets.
257] APPENDIX B
The Consuming Territory of the Sze-chuen Salt
lis
Number of
prefectures in
the province
Number of
direct districts
in the province
Names and location of the prefectures
and direct districts with or without
the Sze-chuen salt
Province
Total
With
Sze-
chuen
salt
Total
With
Sze-
chuen
salt
Names *
Location
Sze-chuen .
Hu-peh ^.
Yun-nan* .
Kwei-chow
12
10
14
12
12
I
2
8
8
I
3
I
8
I
Sze-chuen Province
(with)
Sze-nan Fu
(with)
Tung-chuen Fu
(with)
Chao-tung Fu
(with)
Tung-yin Fu
(without)
Sze-chow Fu
(without)
Chin-yuen Fu
(without)
Li-ping Fu
(without)
Southwestern cor-
ner of Hu-peh
Northeastern cor-
ner of Yun-nan
(1 M
Eastern frontier
of Kwei-chow
« <<
« «
« «
1 When the names of places v^rith the Sze-chuen salt are given, it is
understood that the other places have not this salt, and vice versa.
2 Hoc-feng-chow and Chang-lau-hsien, two districts near to Sze-nan
Fu are also supplied with the Sse-chuen salt.
' Tsien-yih-chow, Nan-ning-hsien and Ping-yi-lisien, three districts
south of Tung-chuen Fu are also supplied with the Sze-chuen salt.
Il6 APPENDIX B [258
The Consuming Territory of the Kwang-tung Salt
Number of
Number of
Names and location of prefectures
prefectures in
direct districts
and direct districts with the Kwang-
the province
in the
provmce
tung salt
Province
With
With
Total
Kwang-
tung salt
Total
Kwang-
tung salt
Names ^
Location
Kwang-tung.
9
9
7
7
Kwang-tung
Province
Kwang-si • • .
II
II
2
/>
Kwang-si
Province
Kiang-si ....
n
2
I
I
Nan-an Fu
Gung-chow Fu . .
Ning-tu Chow . . .
Southern Kiang-si
« «
Fu-kien
9
I
2
....
Ting-chow Fu
Western frontier of
Fu-kien
Hu-nan
9
• • • •
4
2
Pin Chow
Kwei-yang Chow
Southeastern fron-
tier of Hu-nan
« ((
Yun-nan . • • .
H
2
3
• • • •
Kwang-nan Fu . .
Kai-hwaFu
Southeastern cor-
ner of Yun-nan
« It
1 Ku-chow-ting, a subordinate district of Li-ping Fu, eastern frontier
of Kwei-chow Province is also supplied with Kwang-tung salt.
259] APPENDIX B II y
The Consuming Territory of the Fu-kien or Yun-nan Salt
Number of pre-
Number of direct Names and location of prefectures
fectures in the
districts in the
and direct districts without the
province
province
Fu-kien or Yun-nan salt
Province
With
Fu-kien or
With
Fu-kien or
Total
Yun-nan
Total ! Yun-nan
Names
Location
salt
salt
Fu-kien.
9 i 8
2
2
Ting-chow Fu f
Western frontier
(Fu-kien)
( Fu-kien)
(Fu-kien)
of Fu-kien
Yun-nan
14 10
3
3
Kwang-nan Fu f
Southeastern cor-
(Yun-nan)
(Yun-nan)
(Yun-nan)
Kai-hwa Fu f
(Yun-nan)
Tung-chuen Fu*
(Yun-nan)
Chao-tung Fu *
(Yun-nan)
ner of Yun-nan
<( <(
Northeastern cor-
ner of Yun-nan
« «
1 Those prefectures marked with (f) are the Kwang-tung salt
markets. Those indicated by (*), together with three neighbor dis-
tricts, are supplied with the Sse-chuen salt. Cf. supra, p. 115, note 3.
A LIST OF SELECTED REFERENCES IN CHINESE
Institutes of tlie Tsing Dynasty (Shanghai; 5th ed., 1909) — Called, in
Chinese, Ta Tsing Hui Tien and edited by a board of editors ap-
pointed by the government.
Amendments of the Institutes of the Tsing Dynasty (Shanghai; 5th
ed., 1909) — 'Called, in Chinese, Ta Tsing Hui Tien Shih Li and
edited by a board of editors appointed by the government.
Inquiry into the Institutions of China (Shanghai, several editions) —
The most complete history of institutions of the different dynasties,
being called, in Chinese, Wen Hsien Tung Kao or San Tung Kao.
Essays on the Institutions of the Tsing Dynasty (Shanghai, 1901) —
Comprises a number of essays written by Mr. Wang Ching-Yun,
sometime president of the Department of Public Works. This
work is called, in Chinese, Shi Chao Tsi Tseng.
Works of Kuan Tsi (Shanghai, several editions) — Published as a
special treatise or as a part of the works of Chinese philosophers.
Governmental System of the Chou Dynasty, 1122-249 B. C. (Shanghai)
— ^Serves as a model of the governmental system in the different
dynasties, being called, in Chinese, Chou Kuan or Chou Li.
Memorials in the Reign of Emperor Kwang Shii, 1875-1908.
Memorials in the Reign of Emperor Shiian Tung, 1909- 191 1.
118 [260
VITA
Shao-Kwan Chen was born in Canton, China, Decem-
ber 21, 1886. When he was a boy, he studied English,
general European history, elementary mathematics and
general geography in addition to his major subject, the
Chinese learning. In 1903, he passed the civil service ex-
amination of the 29th year of the Reign of Emperor
Kwang Shii, held at Canton, on Chinese history, philoso-
phy, classics and current political problems, receiving the
degree of Chii Yin ( Recommendable Man), together
with the candidacy for a magistracy. In 1 904-1 908,
he studied arts and sciences under the College Fac-
ulty of the Chinese Imperial University in Peking; and
was graduated in 1908 with a degree equivalent to the
Bachelor of Science conferred by the American institu-
tions. In 1909, he was appointed to be a candidate for
assistant prefect. From 1910 to 1914, he has been
a graduate student at Columbia University, receiving
the degree of Master of Arts in 191 1. He has taken
courses under the members of the Faculty of Political Sci-
ence of Columbia University, under Professor D. R.
Dewey, of Massachusetts Institute of Technology, and under
Professors F. A. Fetter and W. M. Daniels, of Princeton
University. He has attended the seminars conducted by
Professors E. R. A. Seligman, H. R. Seager, F. A. Fetter,
V. G. Simkhovitch and H. R. Mussey.
119
\
eii
cp
3^
^ /*\
:r^ y
,1
'■; ''i;i':i;-^^';'^-b''ir:i:':'i:;'-^!:|-V^