Amphibian and Reptile Inventory on the Headwaters and Dillon Resource Areas in conjunction withi Red Rock Lakes National Wildlife Refuge Final Report to: Bureau of Land Management and US Fish and Wildlife Service 1422E930A960015 No. 8 Submitted by: Michael D. Roedel And Paul Hendricks December 1998 Montana Natural Heritage Program 151 5 East Sixth Avenue Helena, MT 59620-1800 © 1998 Montana Natural Heritage Program This document sliould be cited as follows: Roedel, M. D. and D. P. Hendricks. 1998. Amphibian and Reptile Inventory on the Headwaters and Dillon Resource Areas in conjunction with Red Rock Lakes National Wildlife Refuge: 1996 - 1998. Montana Natural Heritage Program. Helena. 68 pp. ABSTRACT A total of 81 site surveys were made from 1996 through 1998 on lands administered by the Bureau of Land Management and by the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service in south- western Montana. Localized areas across the entire region were covered in the surveys. Included during the inventories were the BLM Headwaters and Dillon Resource Areas and the Red Rocks National Wildlife Refuge. The majority of the surveys of ponds, lakes, seeps, streams or other wetlands were conducted by one individual. Each survey took from 20 to 1 20 person-minutes and consisted of a thorough search of the wetland perimeter and netting of near shore aquatic habitats for adults, eggs, larvae, and tadpoles. Stream sampling was done by hand and dipnet. At seeps, rocks and logs were overturned in and near wet areas to expose hidden specimens. An additional 49 surveys were completed by Natural Heritage biologists and others within the Resource Areas during 1994 and 1995. The data collected during those surveys has also been included in this report. In addition to surveys, observations of road kills were recorded, as were identified calls and fortuitous sightings by those conducting the surveys or other reliable individuals. Historical records and earlier surveys indicate the presence of nine species of amphibians and eleven species of reptiles within the survey area. During the period of 1994 through 1998, eight species of amphibians and seven species of reptiles were detected within the boundaries of the Headwaters and Dillon resource areas. Four species of amphibians and three species of reptiles were detected during site surveys in 1996 and 1998. A single Bullfrog {Rana catesbeiana), an introduced species, was detected during the same period. Species detected during the site surveys in 1996 and 1998 included: Spotted Frog {Rana luteiventris), Tiger Salamander {Ambystoma tigrinum), Western Chorus Frog {Pseudacris triseriata), Western Toad {Bufo boreas), Painted Turtle {Chrysemys picta), Western Rattlesnake {Crotalus viridis), and Western Terrestrial Garter Snake {Thamnophis elegans). Columbia spotted frog was the most widespread amphibian throughout the area. Western Terrestrial Garter Snake was the most widespread reptile in the area. Ill TABLE OF CONTENTS ABSTRACT iii TABLE OF CONTENTS iv ACKNOWLEDGMENTS v INTRODUCTION 1 METHODS AND MATERIALS 2 RESULTS AND DISCUSSION 3 Table 1. Amphibian site records 5 Table 2. Reptile site records 5 Species present on the Headwater and Dillon resource areas: 6 Long-toed Salamander 6 Tiger Salamander 7 Tailed Frog 8 Western Toad 9 Woodhouse's Toad 10 Western Chorus Frog 11 Plains Spadefoot 12 Bullfrog 13 Northern Leopard Frog 14 Columbia Spotted Frog 15 Short-horned Lizard 16 Sagebrush Lizard 17 Painted Turtle 18 Spiny Softshell 19 Rubber Boa 20 Racer 21 Milk Snake 22 Gopher Snake Or Bullsnake 23 Western Rattlesnake 24 Common Garter Snake 25 Western Terrestrial Garter Snake 26 RECOMMENDATIONS 27 BIBLIOGRAPHY 28 APPENDIX 1. Amphibians and reptile survey sites 1994 - 1995 36 APPENDIX 2. Amphibians and reptile survey sites 1996 - 1998 42 APPENDIX 3. Mapped locations of amphibian and reptile observations 46 IV ACKNOWLEDGMENTS We thank K. Werner and B. Maxell for conducting site surveys, M. Miller for data entry, J. Hinshaw for data retrieval, and C. Jones for mapping occurrences. Financial support for the project came from the Bureau of Land Management, U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service, and the Montana Natural Heritage Program (Montana State Library, Natural Resources Information System, and The Nature Conservancy). Thanks to Sally Sovey and Jim Roscoe (BLM) and to Danny Gomez (USFWS) for their interest, encouragement, and support with this project. Museum records were received from: American Museum of Natural History, Academy of Natural Science, Brigham Young University, California Academy of Science, Carnegie Museum, University of Puget Sound Museum, Field Museum of Natural History, Glacier National Park Museum, Illinois Natural History Survey, University of Kansas, Los Angeles County Museum, Louisiana State University Museum of Zoology, Museum of Comparative Zoology - Harvard, Milwaukee Public Museum, Montana State University Museum, Michigan State University Museum, North Carolina State Museum of Natural History, Northern Louisiana University Museum, University of Colorado Museum, University of Georgia Museum of Natural History, University of Idaho Museum, University of Michigan Museum, University of South Dakota, United States National Museum of Natural History, University of Texas - Arlington, University of Texas - El Paso, and Peabody Museum - Yale. Most museum data were received with the help of Dr. Charles Peterson, Idaho State University, Pocatello. Jim Reichel, MTNHP Zoologist, died prior to the completion of this project. Jim was instrumental in organizing this project and conducting a series of amphibian and reptile surveys across Montana, the first comprehensive inventory in three decades. This report represents one of a series of projects that contribute to a baseline inventory of the entire state. INTRODUCTION Many amphibians are apparently declining in the western U.S. and worldwide. Acid rain, ozone depletion, pollution by toxic chemicals and heavy metals, predation and/or competition by exotic species, habitat alteration, climatic changes, disease, immune system problems, and combinations of several of these factors have all been suggested as possible causes (Corn and Fogelman 1984, Phillips 1990, Yoffe 1992). Preliminary data indicate that the Northern Leopard Frog {Rana pipiens) has disappeared over much of its former range in western Montana and is declining in at least some areas of eastern Montana. Status and population trends of several toad species {Bufo spp.) are unknown, although declines of the Western {Bufo boreas) have recently been reported in northern Idaho (C. Peterson pers. comm.), northwestern Montana (Werner and Reichel 1994), Yellowstone National Park (Koch and Peterson 1995) and Colorado (Carey 1993). The Western or Boreal Toad is likely to be reclassified in the near future as Sensitive by Region I of the U.S. Forest Service (B. Maxell, pers. comm.). Land-use practices, such as large-scale logging, continue to be detrimental to resident herpetofauna in some regions of the western U.S. (Bury et al. 1 991 ), while the impacts of grazing on amphibians and reptiles and their habitats remain poorly studied and understood. Heavy grazing in and around breeding waters may also negatively impact amphibians and reptiles living in riparian and wetland sites by 1) eliminating emergent vegetation necessary for egg and larval survival, 2) lowering water quality, especially causing high siltation levels, 3) soil compaction and trampling of turtle eggs, and 4) trampling of other eggs, larvae and adults. Additionally, "improving" seeps and springs for livestock watering may make them unavailable to breeding amphibians. The Montana Natural Heritage Program currently (1998) lists five amphibian and five reptile species as Animal Species of Special Concern. Of these, one amphibian: Northern Leopard Frog {Rana pipiens), and two reptiles: Spiny Softshell (Trionyx spiniferus), and Milk Snake (Lampropeltis triangulum) are reported to occur in the area. METHODS AND MATERIALS The Headwaters and Dillon Resource Areas and the Red Rock Lakes National Wildlife Refuge in southwestern Montana were surveyed during the 1996 - 1998 inventory. Historical locations of amphibians and reptiles were recorded from literature (see Bibliography) and museum specimen records. Records were received from over 20 major museums which have computerized their collections in North America (see Acknowledgments). Records were also included from 1995 herp surveys conducted by students of San Francisco State College, in the Birch Creek drainage of the Beaverhead National Forest (Miller et al. 1995). Locations derived from these sources have been entered into a database and digitized. Distribution maps were created using survey and sighting data and historical records, including museum specimens. Survey sites were chosen based on 3 criteria: 1 ) high priority sites as determined by the BLM and USFWS; 2) location of streams, seeps and wetlands on topographic maps; and 3) accessibility of the wetlands by roads. Based on the above, between three and eight sites per observer were chosen daily for surveys. From 20 to 1 20 minutes was spent at each site, depending upon the size of the area and what was found. Initially, the entire shoreline, or a major part thereof, was searched by walking slowly along the edge and up into the surrounding vegetation, including rolling over rocks and logs. At regular intervals, the aquatic habitat was sampled for tadpoles or larvae using dipnets. If the initial sampling showed amphibian/reptile species present, further effort was expended in order to get a more comprehensive view of abundance and distribution. An attempt was made to capture at least the first few individuals of a species seen at a survey site. The species name was recorded along with developmental stage and sex (if possible); the animals were then released. On occasion, representative samples of the more common species in an area were preserved for permanent museum records and will be deposited at the Idaho State University Museum. Water temperature, air temperature, and a general description of the area were recorded. Standard data sheets were used during this project; the amphibian survey data sheet was developed by U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service and is used extensively by a variety of researchers in the western U.S. Much site-specific data was gathered during these surveys; not all data has been analyzed or is presented in this report, but is available from the Montana Natural Heritage Program. RESULTS AND DISCUSSION We surveyed 81 sites from April to September in 1 996 and in 1 998. Of tliose sites, 50 (62%) liad one or more ampliibian or reptile species present (Appendix 1). An additional 49 sites were surveyed during May of 1994 and May, July, August, and September in 1995. Twenty-nine of those sites (59%) had one or more amphibian or reptile species present (Appendix 2). Localized areas across the entire region were covered in the inventory (See Map 1 , Appendix 3). Although no species were detected at 39% of all sites surveyed, their absence may have been due to the time of day, weather conditions, or other factors at the time of sampling. During the 1996 and 1998 site surveys on BLM and USFWS administered lands, four amphibian species and three reptile species were detected (Table 1 , Table 2). Those species included: Tiger Salamander {Ambystoma tigrinum) at 2 sites. Western Toad {Bufo boreas) at 7 sites. Western Chorus Frog {Pseudacris triseriata) at 5 sites, Columbia Spotted Frog {Rana luteiventris) at 32 sites. Painted Turtle {Chrysemys picta) at 1 site. Western Rattlesnake {Crotalus viridis) at 2 sites, and Western Terrestrial Garter Snake {Thamnophis elegans) at 17 sites. Of the ten species of amphibians presently listed for the area, eight were observed between 1994 and 1998. Those species include: Long-toed Salamander {Ambystoma macrodactylum) (20 records). Tiger Salamander (3 records). Tailed Frog {Ascaphus truei) (28 records). Western Toad (37 records). Western Chorus Frog (37 records). Bullfrog (1 record). Northern Leopard Frog (7 records), and Columbia Spotted Frog (152 records). Columbia Spotted frog was the most widespread and numerous amphibian throughout the combined districts. Bullfrog {Rana catesbeiana) was reported from only one location in Lewis and Clark County in July 1996. The Bullfrog is not a native species in Montana and is not known to have successfully reproduced in this area. Two species of amphibians with historical records from the area were not detected in the area during the 1 994 - 1 998 period. Those species include Woodhouse's Toad {Bufo woodhousii) and Plains Spadefoot {Spea bombifrons), each with only three historical records. The records for Woodhouse's Toad were in 1948 and 1966. However, the two 1966 Gallatin County specimens have been properly identified as Western Toad, while the 1948 specimen is still in question. The Plains Spadefoot was collected in 1917 in Park County, 1950 in Gallatin County, and in 1988 in Lewis and Clark County. The identity of those specimens has been confirmed. There are currently eleven species of reptiles known from the area. Of those, seven were observed in the area between 1994 and 1998. Those species include: Painted Turtle {Chrysemys picta) at 10 sites. Rubber Boa {Charina bottae) at 5 sites. Racer {Coluber constrictor) at 3 sites. Gopher Snake Or Bullsnake {Pituophis catenifer) at 1 1 sites. Western Rattlesnake {Crotalus viridis) at 17 sites. Common Garter Snake {Thamnophis sirtalis) at 8 sites, and Western Terrestrial Garter Snake {Thamnophis elegans) at 75 sites. Four of the eleven species of reptiles have historical records for the area, but were not detected during the surveys. Those species include Short-horned Lizard {Phrynosoma hernandesi) and Sagebrush Lizard {Sceloporus graciosus), each with three historical records, and Spiny Softshell {Trionyx spiniferus) and Milk Snake {Lampropeltis triangulum), each with only a single historical record. Short-horned Lizard has two records from Gallatin County dating from 1903 and 1953 and one undated record from Beaverhead County. Sagebrush Lizard has been reported three times for the area, in 1 897, 1 951 , and 1 968. All records are from along the Yellowstone River near Gardiner. There is one record for Spiny Softshell at Canyon Ferry in Broadwater County. However, there is no date assigned to that record and a search of museums has not located the specimen. Milk Snake has one occurrence listed from 1949, near Three Forks in Gallatin County. Table 1 . Amphibian site records from the Headwaters and Dillon resource areas in Montana NHP databases. pecres Name Long-toed Salamander (Ambystoma macrodactylum) 20 31 Tiger Salamander (Ambystoma tigrinum) 21 Tailed Frog (Ascaphus truei) 28 46 Western Toad (Bufo boreas) 37 65 Woodhouse's Toad (Bufo woodhousii) Western Chorus Frog (Pseudacris triseriata) 37 40 Plains Spadefoot (Spea bombifrons) Bullfrog (Rana catesbeiana) Northern Leopard Frog (Rana pipiens) 21 Columbia Spotted Frog (Rana luteiventris) 152 32 222 Total records 10 Species 285 46 453 Table 2. Reptile site records from the Headwaters and Dillon resource areas in Montana NHP databases Short-horned Lizard (Phrynosoma hernandesi) Sagebrush Lizard (Sceloporus graciosus) Painted Turtle (Chrysemys picta) 10 14 Spiny Softshell (Trionyx spiniferus) Rubber Boa (Charina bottae) 32 Racer (Coluber constrictor) 13 Milk Snake (Lampropeltis triangulum) Gopher Snake Or Bullsnake (Pituophis eaten iter) 11 22 Western Rattlesnake (Cro talus viridis) 17 39 Common Garter Snake (Thamnophis sirtalis) 8 21 Western Terrestrial Garter Snake (Thamnophis elegans) 75 17 121 Total records 11 Species 129 20 270 Species present on the Headwater and Dillon resource areas: Long-toed Salamander {Ambystoma macrodactylum) AAAAA01080 Description: Adults are darl< gray to blacl< witli an irregular (and sometimes broken) green to yellow stripe down the middle of the back. Adult snout-vent length varies from 2 to 3.25". All salamanders have smooth moist skin without scales. Eggs and Larvae: Egg masses are typically laid in small clusters of 5-1 00 eggs but may be laid singly (Nussbaum et al. 1983); egg masses are typically attached to underwater vegetation or submerged branches. Within the clear gelatinous eggs, the embryos are somewhat light-colored, while frog and toad embryos are dark (except in Tailed Frogs). Larval Long-toed Salamanders are typically brown- or gray-colored, are found in ponds, have three external gills, and are relatively small (<1.75" snout-vent) and slender. They are distinguished from Tiger Salamander larvae by the 9-13 gill rakers on the inside of the 3rd gill arch (17-22 rakers on the Tiger Salamander); they are also smaller and lack the large head and mouth. Similar species: Adult Long-toed Salamanders can be distinguished from Coeur d'Alene Salamanders by the longest toe on the hind foot which is longer than the sole and a yellow throat patch. Long-toed Salamanders lack a groove running vertically from nostril to mouth. Habitat and Habits: Long-toed Salamanders are found in a variety of habitats from sagebrush to nearly alpine. They breed in ponds or lakes (very rarely in slow moving streams), usually those without fish present. Adults go to the breeding ponds immediately after snow-melt and are usually the earliest breeding amphibians in western Montana. In the Pacific Northwest, eggs hatch in 3-6 weeks and metamorphosis occurs after 2-14 months (Nussbaum et al. 1983, Leonard etal. 1993). Individuals were found in the Rocky Mountains and the Elkhorn Mountains from 4350 - 7050 ft. elevation in a survey of the Helena National Forest (Reichel 1996). Surveying: Larvae can readily be seen in ponds during the day and sampled with a dipnet; egg masses are somewhat harder to see. During the breeding season, adults may also be seen in the water, particularly during night surveys. During the rest of the spring, summer and fall, adults may occasionally be found in and under logs on the forest floor. Metamorphosed individuals are active at night, particularly when it is warm and rainy; they may be captured at this time by either night searches or pitfall traps. Status: The Long-toed Salamander is the most common salamander in western Montana. The Long-toed Salamander is also found in the northwestern part of the Elkhorns, the farthest east reported location in its range. The Elkhorns are the only isolated mountain range east of the Continental Divide where this species is found (Reichel 1995a). Montana Natural Heritage Program rank: G5 S5. Tiger Salamander {Ambystoma tigrinum) AAAAA01 1 40 Description: Adults liave smootli moist sl54° F) nights; calling peaks during the first few hours after sunset (Hammerson 1982a). "Road hunting" on warm nights may also be effective. Eggs and tadpoles are seen in ponds during the day and can be sampled with a dipnet; however, identification of toad eggs and tadpoles ranges from difficult to impossible in the field. Status: Woodhouse's Toad is relatively common in southeastern Montana, however, its status elsewhere in the state is unclear. Geographic and habitat relationships with other toads in Montana are not well known. It should be watched for at low elevations in prairie or shrub-steppe habitat; it could occur along the Missouri River. Any located should be well documented with a description indicating how the species was differentiated. Montana Natural Heritage Program rank: G5 S4. 10 Western Chorus Frog {Pseudacris triseriata) AAABC05070 Description: Adults are very small (0.75-1 .5") and have tiny, almost unnoticeable toe pads. They have a dark line extending from the snout through the eye to the groin. Basic coloration is quite variable with the background color being green, brown, gray, or reddish. Typically 3-5 dark longitudinal stripes are present on the head and back which may be broken up into spots on some individuals. Eggs and Tadpoles: Eggs are laid in small clusters of 10-100, usually less than 1" across and attached to submerged vegetation (Wheeler and Wheeler 1966, Baxter and Stone 1985). Individual eggs are about 1 mm in diameter. Tadpoles are brown/bronze and the eyes are located on the sides of the head. Similar species: Pacific Chorus Frogs {Pseudacris regilla) have obvious toe pads and an eye stripe ending at the shoulder. Recently metamorphosed Ranid frogs could be confused with this species but the coloration differs and the tiny toe pads are lacking (often visible only with a magnifying glass on small chorus frogs). Habitat and Habits: Western Chorus Frogs are regularly found in the water only during the breeding period in spring. Their presence is obvious during this time due to their call which is given frequently at night and sporadically throughout the day. Following breeding, these frogs move into adjacent uplands and are rarely seen. In eastern Montana they breed in temporary ponds and small lakes surrounded by prairie; in some locations in Montana they are also found in open forested habitats. Eggs hatch in about 2 weeks and tadpoles are about 2 months old at metamorphosis (Wheeler and Wheeler 1966, Nussbaum et al. 1983). Surveying: Adults are easily surveyed for, using their calls for identification during the breeding season in the spring and early summer. During the breeding season, adults may also be seen in the water, but their small size and habit of freezing or diving when disturbed makes observation difficult; night surveys may be more productive. Egg masses are difficult to find. Tadpoles may be seen in ponds during the day and can be sampled with a dipnet. Status: Common throughout the prairies of eastern Montana. Montana Natural Heritage Program rank: G5 S5. 11 Plains Spadefoot {Scaphiopus [=Spea] bombifrons) AAABF02010 Description: Adults are colored gray or brown with darker mottling on the back and a white belly. Some individuals have indistinct longitudinal streaking. The pupils of the Plains Spadefoot are vertically elliptical and there is a high, hard lump between the eyes. Its skin is less warty than true toads. The adult has a single tubercle on the hind feet and has a body length of less than 2.5". Eggs and Tadpoles: Oval egg masses of 10-250 eggs are attached to underwater plants or debris. Tadpoles are mottled sooty and olive-yellow above and paler below with gold metallic flecking over all; iris is gold. Similar species: Other Montana frogs and toads have round or horizontally elliptical pupils. Habitat and Habits: Adults are found in grassland and sagebrush areas, particularly in areas with sandy or loose soil (Wheeler and Wheeler 1966, Hammerson 1982a, Baxter and Stone 1985). Except during breeding, they are seldom found in the water. They are primarily nocturnal and emerge from their burrows only following heavy rains. They breed in shallow temporary pools usually following heavy spring or summer rains (Hammerson 1982a). Males call loudly, with groups being heard for up to a mile. Eggs hatch after 2-3 days and tadpoles transform in 6-10 weeks (Wheeler and Wheeler 1966, Hammerson 1982a). Surveying: Adults may be easily found by using their calls for identification when breeding at night or by "road hunting" on warm, rainy nights. Calling normally takes place only when the temperature is >50° F (Hammerson 1982). Tadpoles are seen in ponds during the day and can be sampled with a dipnet. Surveying is complicated by the long time periods which this species spends underground, especially during droughts. Status: Locally common in eastern Montana; there are large gaps in the known range. It should be watched for at low elevations in prairie or shrub-steppe habitat. Any located should be well-documented. Montana Natural Heritage Program rank: G5 S4? 12 Bullfrog {Rana catesbeiana) AAABH01070 Description: Tine largest of Nortli American frogs, adult Bullfrogs may reach 8 inches in body length. The skin is smooth. Adults are usually pale to dark green or brownish green with darker spots or blotches. There are a series of black bands across the legs. The underside is cream to yellowish with gray mottling. No dorso-lateral folds are present, however there is a prominent ridge running from the eye over the tympanum to the shoulder. Males have extensive yellow pigment on the underside, especially in the throat region, and swollen thumbs. The diameter of the tympanum is larger than the diameter of the eye in males but about the same size in females. Eggs and Tadpoles: Egg masses are a 1 -2 egg thick film of thousands of eggs and may reach several feet across. Tadpoles may reach 4.5" in total length and are olive green with numerous black spots dorsally; the belly is white to creamy with varying amounts of dark mottling. Similar species: Other Montana Ranid frogs have dorso-lateral folds. Habitat and Habits: Bullfrogs are rarely seen far from the water's edge and are usually in the water. They are associated with larger bodies of quiet water such as ponds, lakes or backwaters of streams, usually with extensive emergent vegetation such as cattails or reeds. They emerge in the spring only after air and water temperatures have warmed considerably and insect populations are beginning to proliferate. Breeding takes place in June when males attract females to their territory by a series of very deep, loud "brr-umps." The large egg mass tends to float on the surface when first laid, but sink into the water prior to hatching (Hammerson 1982a, Nussbaum et al. 1983). Tadpoles over-winter in the Pacific Northwest, transforming during their second summer (Nussbaum et al. 1983, Leonard etal. 1993). The bullfrog is a voracious feeder, eating anything smaller than itself, including ducklings, fish, mice, frogs, and small turtles. Bullfrogs have been implicated in extirpations of native frogs and turtles, and declines in waterfowl production (Hammerson 1982b, Leonard et al 1993, Kiesecker and Blaustein 1998). Surveying: Tadpoles and adults can easily be detected visually or sampled by using a dipnet; both may be found from spring through fall. Capture success of adults is enhanced by night sampling using a headlamp, as they are very wary and do not allow close approach during the day. Eggs are also easy to detect when laid in the early summer. Status: Bullfrogs are native to the eastern and central U.S. and have been introduced to the western states. It is possible that several unauthorized releases have occurred on private lands, based on conversations with ranchers. They were introduced into western Montana prior to the mid-1 960's (Black and Bragg 1968). Bullfrogs should be watched for in ponds, lakes, sloughs, or slow streams. Any located should be well documented. Montana Natural Heritage Program rank: G5 SE4. 13 Northern Leopard Frog {Rana pipiens) AAABH01170 Description: Adults are brown or green witli large, dark spots surrounded by light- colored halos on the sides and back. The dorso-lateral folds (ridges along the sides of the back) are usually lighter in color that the surrounding background. The under-side is typically white, but may be cream-colored or yellowish. The adult has a body length of 2-5". Newly transformed froglets may lack spots and are about 1" in length (Leonard et al. 1993). Eggs and Tadpoles: Eggs are laid in 2-5" globular masses composed of hundreds to thousands of eggs (Hammerson 1982a, Nussbaum et al. 1983). The tadpoles are brown to dark brown on top with some metallic flecking, whereas the underside is often nearly transparent (Nussbaum et al. 1983). Total length of tadpoles may reach more than 3"; the eyes are located on top of the head. Similar species: None, although some newly-transformed froglets may lack spots, which makes them extremely difficult to distinguish from Spotted and Wood Frogs. Habitat and Habits: Northern Leopard Frogs are found in or near water in non-forested habitats. Vegetation is typically dense, as in a cattail marsh or dense sedge- meadow. Breeding takes place in lakes, ponds (temporary and permanent), springs, and occasionally backwaters or beaver ponds in streams. In Colorado, eggs hatch in 4-15 days and tadpoles take 8-15 weeks to metamorphose, depending on water temperature (Hammerson 1982a). Surveying: Both adults, tadpoles, and eggs are easily seen in and along the water during the day and can be sampled with a dipnet; adults may also be captured by hand. At very low densities adults may be difficult to find and may be detected using a call recorder. Tadpoles are difficult to tell from those of the Spotted Frog in areas where the two species may overlap. Status: Historically, the Northern Leopard Frog was widespread in Montana but it now appears to be extinct throughout much of the western part of the state. It is still common and widespread in the southeastern corner of the state, but it may be declining in central and northeastern Montana. It appears that only localized populations are present on the western edge of the plains. Given the recent declines in this species and the unusual habitat, this record should be treated as hypothetical until verified. Due to its significant decline and lack of current reports from the HNF, all sightings of this species should be documented. Northern Leopard Frogs are now absent from many other areas in North America where they were common a few decades ago. Widespread extinctions are known from Alberta (Koonz 1993), Wyoming (Koch and Peterson 1995), Colorado (Hammerson 1982b, Corn and Fogelman 1984), Idaho (Groves and Peterson 1992), Washington, and Oregon (Leonard etal. 1993). Bullfrog and fish introductions, acid rain, ozone depletion, immune system suppression, and "Postmetamorphic Death Syndrome" have all been suggested as causes for frog extirpations in other areas (Corn and Fogelman 1984, Hammerson 1982b, Carey 1993, Leonard etal. 1993). Montana Natural Heritage Program rank: G4 S3S4. 14 Columbia Spotted Frog {Rana luteventris [= pretiosaj) AAABH01 290 Description: Tine adult lias a snout-vent lengtli of 2-4". Adults are dark to light brown, gray, or olive green with dark spots (frequently with lighter centers) found on the back, sides and legs. The number and pattern of spotting is quite variable. The back and sides are often covered with small bumps. The underside of the legs is bright red, salmon, or orange; this bright color may extend up to the chin or be replaced by a light, mottled gray on the chin, chest, and/or belly. In younger subadults, bright leg color is often lacking and instead a light, lemon-colored wash is present. In these subadults, there is often a dark mask present, with a light jaw stripe extending to the shoulder; both the mask and jaw stripe may be less obvious in larger, older animals. Eggs and Tadpoles: Eggs are laid in large, globular masses of 150-500 at the surface of the water. The tadpoles are dark green to brown on top with some gold flecking whereas the underside has an iridescent bronze or silver color. Total length of tadpoles may reach 3"; the eyes are located on top of the head. Similar species: The bright-colored pigment on the undersides of the adult's legs distinguish this species from all other frogs in Montana. Younger individuals, without colored legs, may usually be distinguished from other frogs by a combination of: 1 ) dorsal spots usually present but not surrounded by light- colored halos; 2) dorso-lateral folds present; 3) toes without pads at the tips; and 4) a pale gray, (rather than white) belly. Habitat and Habits: Spotted Frogs are regularly found at the water's edge in openings within forest habitats. Wetlands in or near treeline are also used, but populations are uncommon in the large, open intermountain valleys. Eggs hatch in 2-3 weeks and tadpoles take 2-14 months to metamorphose, depending on water temperature (Nussbaum et al. 1983, Turner 1958). Breeding takes place in lakes, ponds (temporary and permanent), springs, and occasionally backwaters or beaver ponds in streams. All the egg masses in a particular pond are often found in the same location at the margin of the pond; therefore, the eggs are susceptible to drying up if pond levels recede substantially before hatching. Young and adult frogs often disperse into marsh and forest habitats but are not usually found far from open water. Surveying: Adults, tadpoles, and eggs are easily seen in and along the water during the day and can be sampled with a dipnet; adults may also be captured by hand. Many adults may leave the breeding ponds following egg laying and move to nearby feeding areas for the summer. Tadpoles are difficult to distinguish from those of the Northern Leopard Frog in areas where the two species may overlap. Status: The most common frog in western Montana. The species was previously a U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service Category 2 Candidate species in Montana; elsewhere in its range it is listed as a C-1 , with Threatened/Endangered status warranted, but precluded by work on higher-priority species (U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service 1993). While significant declines are known from the southern end of the range (Nevada, southern Idaho, Utah) and are also apparent in coastal Washington (McAllister et al. 1993), Oregon, and California, recent (as yet unpublished) research indicates that those populations are different species. Montana Natural Heritage Program rank: G4 S4. 15 Short-horned Lizard {Phrynosoma douglasi) ARACF12030 Description: Tine Sliort-liorned lizard lias a broad, somewliat flattened body and relatively short limbs and tail. It is generally tan to gray with dark and light spots and blotches; the belly is white. There is a distinctive line of pointed scales along each side, and the head has short, blunt "horns" pointing backward. Adult lizards range from 1 .7 - 5.5" in length. Young: Young are live-born and resemble small adults. Similar species: None. Habitat and Habits: The Short-horned lizard is found in a variety of habitats, including dry open forests, grasslands, and sagebrush; the soil is usually loose or sandy. In firmer soil situations, it may use the burrows of other animals. It is active during the day, typically with the peak of activity in mid-late morning. A Short- horned Lizard may squirt blood from its eyes when disturbed. Little is known about reproduction in this part of the range; young are born in late summer. Ants are the primary food of the species. Surveying: They may be surveyed for by slowly walking through appropriate habitat and watching carefully for them; look carefully near ant mounds; this technique has low success with Short-horned Lizards however. As with many lizards and snakes, they are easily missed. Carefully documented incidental observations may provide the best clues to their distribution. They may be also taken in pitfall or funnel traps in combination with drift fences. Status: The Short-horned Lizard subspecies found in Montana (P. d. brevirostra) is currently a U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service Category 2 Candidate species (U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service 1994). It is widely distributed (but apparently localized) in eastern Montana. This species may be vulnerable to collecting for the pet trade and agricultural conversion of native habitats. It should be watched for in open pine, prairie, or shrub-steppe habitat with loose or sandy soils; all sightings should be documented. Montana Natural Heritage Program Rank: G5 S4. A Species of Special Concern. 16 Sagebrush Lizard {Sceloporus graciosus) ARACF14030 Description: Tine Sagebrusli Lizard is small (1 .5 - 2.5" body length) and narrow-bodied. The color pattern in adults consists of alternating dark and light stripes running down the back. The colors are typically brown, gray, and cream. Males have mottled blue throat patches and bright blue belly patches, while females are white or yellow below (Censky 1986). The body and tail scales appear somewhat spiny. Eggs and young: There are 2 - 7 tough, leathery, white eggs in a clutch, averaging about 7.5 X 12 mm (Nussbaum et al. 1983). Body length of hatchlings is about 25 mm, and coloration is similar to adults. Similar species: None in Montana. The Short-horned Lizard has a wide body. Habitat and Habits: Sagebrush Lizards are found primarily in sagebrush areas, but also occur in open forests and brush lands; they are found in both areas of fine soils and rocky outcrops (Hammerson 1982a, Baxter and Stone 1985, Nussbaum et al. 1983). In the Yellowstone area, they are found near thermal features (Mueller 1969). They are active during the day, with mid-morning and late-afternoon peaks of activity (Hammerson 1982a). Females lay eggs in loose or sandy soil in early summer and the young hatch in late summer. They feed primarily on insects and other arthropods. Surveying: They may be surveyed for by slowly walking through appropriate habitat on warm, sunny days and carefully watching for them; this technique is very effective for the Sagebrush Lizard. However, as with many lizards and snakes, they may be overlooked if conditions are not correct. Carefully documented incidental observations provide excellent clues to their distribution. They may be captured with a pole and noose or may be also taken in funnel traps with drift fences. Adults and juveniles have been captured inadvertently in pitfall can traps set for shrews (P. Hendricks, pers. observ.). Mark-recapture methods offer the best opportunity for determining population status. Status: The Sagebrush Lizard was a former U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service Category 2 Candidate species (USFWS 1994). It is apparently locally common in southern Montana, from Yellowstone Park eastward to at least Chalk Butte in Carter County. They are known from the western border of South Dakota south of Harding County (C. R. Peterson pers. comm., Stukel and Backlund 1997), and two disjunct populations are known from the western edge of North Dakota (Censky 1986). This species should be watched for, and any animals located should be documented. Montana Natural Heritage Program rank: G5 S4. 17 Painted Turtle {Chrysemys picta) ARAAD01 01 Description: Adult Painted Turtles have a relatively flat dorsal shell, or carapace, the length of which may reach 9" in females and 7" in males. The background color of the shell may be dark brown, olive, or black. A series of short, irregular yellow lines are often scattered across the shell, and a red and black border forms the outer edge. The ventral shell, or plastron, is red with a centrally-located yellow and black blotch with edges flaring out along the border of the scutes. The edge of the plastron also has a series of black and yellow blotches. The head, neck, and legs are marked with yellow lines and a red spot appears behind the eye. Very dark colored individuals are occasionally found. Males are distinguished by longer front claws and longer tails with the anus posterior to the margin of the carapace (Ernst et al. 1994). Eggs and Young: The elliptical, white, soft-shelled eggs are about 28-35 mm in length and 16-23 mm in width (Ernst etal. 1994). They typically number 6-23 per clutch. Coloration of young Painted Turtles is more vibrant and the shell is not quite as flattened as adults. Similar Species: None. Habitat and Habits: Painted Turtles are active during the day and are rarely seen far from ponds, lakes, or the slow-moving water of streams. Adults are primarily herbivorous, feeding on a variety of aquatic plants, but will also scavenge on animal remains. Eggs are usually laid within 1 0-20 feet of the water's edge, although some individuals will travel up to 600 m seeking a suitable site. During egg-laying, the female excavates a hole with her hind feet and deposits the eggs, which are then covered by several inches of dirt. Predation on turtle eggs by raccoons, skunks, etc. is common, and shell fragments are evidence of such activity. Female Painted Turtles may lay more than one clutch of eggs each summer. Young borne of late egg depositions overwinter in the nest and do not emerge until the following spring (Ernst et al. 1 994). Once females lay their eggs, they return to the pond, where they can often be seen basking on logs or rocks along with juveniles and males. Painted Turtles are sexually mature at 3-5 years of age and may live to be 30 years or older (Ernst et al. 1994). Surveying: Although various turtle traps can be used for surveys, visual identification is suitable for presence/absence studies since the three turtle species in Montana are easily distinguished. Basking peaks at different times during the day, depending on season and location; in the northern states and Canada it generally peaks in the morning. Surveys should be done on sunny days with a pair of binoculars. During cold or cloudy weather, turtles tend to remain underwater for long periods and can be missed on a walk-through survey. Status: Painted Turtles are locally quite common in Montana at lower elevations. They are known from lower elevation areas on the plains; any sightings should be documented. There has been some concern about Painted Turtle populations nationally; whether declines have occurred in Montana is unknown Montana Natural Heritage Program Rank: G5 S5. 18 Spiny Softshell {Trionyx spiniferus) {=Apalone spinifera) ARAAG01030 Description: Spiny Soft-sliells liave flexible, leathery shells. The carapace is olive- gray, marked with dark spots. The plastron is white or light cream-colored. Female carapace length is up to 18 inches or more, whereas males are typically 6-8 inches. The nostrils are terminal, allowing this turtle to remain entirely beneath the surface and take air through its "snorkel". Eggs and Young: The nest is a flask-shaped excavation containing 4-39 (typically 12- 18) hard-shelled, spherical, white eggs. The individual eggs range in size from 24-32 mm in diameter and average about 28 mm. Hatchlings resemble adults and are 30-40 mm in shell length (Ernst etal. 1994). Similar Species: None. Habits and Habitat: Spiny Softshells are active during the day. This highly aquatic turtle is found in rivers or their connecting backwaters with muddy or sandy bottoms. Unlike other Montana turtles, they do not move overland from one water body to another. Mud and sand banks and bars are used for both basking and nesting. Hibernation takes place beneath the water, usually beneath 5-10 cm of bottom substrate (Ernst et al. 1994). The retracted head and neck combines with the profile of the shell to produce a wedge shape, which allows this turtle to escape by literally diving into the bottom mud. If necessary, additional strokes of the legs will completely bury it in the substrate, hidden from view. Food items include fish, crayfish, frogs, toads, aquatic insects, and carrion. Spiny Soft-shells have a surprisingly long, agile neck and can inflict a painful bite. They can be safely handled by grasping the shell on each side between the front and rear legs with the head pointing ai/i/ayfrom the captor. Surveying: Although various turtle traps can be used for surveys, visual identification is suitable since the three turtle species in Montana are easily distinguished . A pair of binoculars is helpful and surveys should be done on warm sunny days; basking seldom takes place before 10:00 a.m. (Ernst et al. 1994). During cold or cloudy weather, turtles tend to remain underwater for long periods and can be missed on a walk-through survey. Care should be taken to watch for the snorkel- like nostrils projecting just above the surface of the water. Status and Distribution: Found mainly in the Yellowstone and Missouri Rivers and their major tributaries. These populations may be separated from each other and are believed to be disjunct form the population in South Dakota (Ernst et al. 1994); they have not been reported from North Dakota (Wheeler and Wheeler 1966). The Missouri River population is known from the tail of Fort Peck Reservoir upstream to the first dam above, and from most of the Mussellshell River; their presence on other tributaries is presently unknown. Considered a Species of Special Concern in Montana. Montana Natural Heritage Program Rank: G5 S3. Species of Special Concern. 19 Rubber Boa {Charina bottae) ARADA01010 Description: Tine Rubber Boa lool 50° F, may be more effective, especially on roads which follow a stream. Previous sightings are of value in locating general areas of activity and denning sites. Funnel traps may be effective. Status: Sightings of Rubber Boas are infrequent, but they are widely distributed and probably common throughout western Montana at low to mid-elevations. Of particular interest would be any documentation of denning sites. Montana Natural Heritage Program Rank: G5 S4. 20 Racer {Coluber constrictor) ARADB07010 Description: A slender, but moderately long snake, the Racer ranges from 20-65 inches in length. Adult coloration is uniform across the dorsal side but it can vary from a greenish-gray to brown or blue. The ventral side is whitish to pale yellow, the latter color extending onto the upper lip scales and nasal region. The eyes are relatively large. The scales are smooth and the nostril is bordered by two scales. Young: Snakes (up to about 20") have a much different coloration than the adults consisting of a series of dorsal brown blotches edged with black which run the length of the animal; a row of blotches is also found on each side of the animal extending onto the ventral side. Similar species: Young Gopher Snakes may be distinguished by the keeled rather than smooth scales of the young Racer. Young Western Hognose Snakes have an upturned nose. Smooth Green Snakes are smaller and colored bright grass- green and whitish below; their nostrils are centered in single scales. Also see Rubber Boa. Habitat and Habits: The Racer is associated with open habitats, in shortgrass, shrub- steppe, or forested areas (Hammerson 1982a, Baxter and Stone 1985). It is often found near water and rocks. The Racer is an extremely fast and agile snake. A clutch of perhaps 3-7 eggs is laid in the summer (Stebbins 1985). It preys on insects and small vertebrates such as mice and frogs. Surveying: They may be surveyed for by slowly walking through appropriate habitat on warm, sunny days and carefully watching for them; this technique is moderately effective for the Racer. However, as with many lizards and snakes, they may easily be missed. Carefully documented incidental observations may provide the best clues to their distribution. They may be also taken in funnel traps with drift fences. Mark-recapture methods offer the best opportunity for determining population status. Status: The Racer can be expected at low to mid-elevations across Montana. Any sightings should be documented. Of particular interest would be documentation of any den sites. Montana Natural Heritage Program Rank: G5 S5. 21 Milk Snake {Lamp rope Itis triangulum) ARADB19050 Description: Tine IVIill< SnalX Museum collections w^'^^ 10 20 30 V//////A Scale in Miles BLM Lands USFWS Areas Montana Natural Heritage Program, December 21 , 1 998 Observations of Ascaphus truei Dillon & Headwaters Resource Areas, and Red Rock Lakes NWR ▼ 1996-1998 records ^ Pre- 1996 records 10 20 30 W\zzA ~y7^^^ Scale in Miles BLM Lands USFWS Areas * '^ ^ Museum collections Montana Natural Heritage Program, December 21 , 1 998 Observations of Bufo boreas Dillon & Headwaters Resource Areas, and Red Rock Lakes NWR 1996-1998 records Pre- 1996 records Museum collections 10 20 30 Scale in Miles n BLM Lands IS3 USFWS Areas Montana Natural Heritage Program, December 21 , 1 998 Observations of Pseudacris triseriata Dillon & Headwaters Resource Areas, and Red Rock Lakes NWR ▼ 1996-1 998 records Pre- 1996 records Museum collections 10 20 30 ^a: V//////A Scale in Miles _ , ; BLM Lands fcSl USFWS Areas Montana Natural Heritage Program, December 21 , 1 998 Observations of Spea bombifrons Dillon & Headwaters Resource Areas, and Red Rock Lakes NWR 1996-1998 records Pre-1 996 records Museum collections ^^ 10 20 30 y//////A Scale in Miles BLM Lands USFWS Areas Montana Natural Heritage Program, December 21 , 1 998 Observations of Rana catesbeiana Dillon & Headwaters Resource Areas, and Red Rock Lakes NWR ▼ 1996-1998 records Pre-1 996 records "0~ Museum collections W^ ^ 10 20 30 Y/ //// /A Scale in Miles BLM Lands ^M USFWS Areas Montana Natural Heritage Program, December 21 , 1 998 Observations of Rana pipiens Dillon & Headwaters Resource Areas, and Red Rock Lakes NWR * 1996-1998 records Pre- 19 96 records Museum collections 10 20 30 V//////A Scale in Miles BLM Lands USFWS Areas Montana Natural Heritage Program, December 21 , 1 998 Observations of Rana luteiventris Dillon & Headwaters Resource Areas, and Red Rock Lakes NWR ▼ 1996-1998 records Pre-1 996 records -iSt Museum collections 10 20 30 Scale in Miles BLM Lands USFWS Areas Montana Natural Heritage Program, December 21 , 1 998 Observations of Phrynosoma hernandesi Dillon & Headwaters Resource Areas, and Red Rock Lakes NWR 1996-1998 records Pre- 1996 records Museum collections 10 20 30 Scale in Miles BLM Lands J USFWS Areas Montana Natural Heritage Program, December 21 , 1 998 Observations of Sceloporus graciosus Dillon & Headwaters Resource Areas, and Red Rock Lakes NWR 1996-1998 records Pre- 1996 records Museum collections 10 20 30 Scale in Miles BLM Lands USFWS Areas Montana Natural Heritage Program, December 21 , 1 998 Observations of Chrysemys picta Dillon & Headwaters Resource Areas, and Red Rock Lakes NWR 1996-1998 records Pre-1 996 records Museum collections 10 20 30 ^^S- IW^ Scale in Miles BLM Lands USFWS Areas Montana Natural Heritage Program, December 21 , 1 998 Observations of Trionyx splniferus Dillon & Headwaters Resource Areas, and Red Rock Lakes NWR 1996-1998 records Pre-1 996 records Museum collections 10 20 30 Scale in Miles BLM Lands USFWS Areas Montana Natural Heritage Program, December 21 , 1 998 Observations of Charina bottae Dillon & Headwaters Resource Areas, and Red Rock Lakes NWR 1996-1998 records Pre- 1996 records Museum collections 10 20 30 W^yrA V//////A Scale in Miles BLM Lands USFWS Areas Montana Natural Heritage Program, December 21 , 1 998 Observations of Coluber constrictor Dillon & Headwaters Resource Areas, and Red Rock Lakes NWR ▼ 1996-1998 records Pre- 19 96 records -\^ Museum collections 10 20 30 Scale in Miles BLM Lands USFWS Areas Montana Natural Heritage Program, December 21 , 1 998 Observations of Lampropeltis triangulum Dillon & Headwaters Resource Areas, and Red Rock Lakes NWR ▼ 1996-1998 records ^ Pre- 1996 records TX Museum collections 10 20 30 Scale in Miles BLM Lands USFWS Areas Montana Natural Heritage Program, December 21 , 1 998 Observations of Pituophis catenifer Dillon & Headwaters Resource Areas, and Red Rock Lakes NWR * 1996-1998 records Pre-1 996 records Museum collections 10 20 30 Scale in Miles BLM Lands USFWS Areas Montana Natural Heritage Program, December 21 , 1 998 Observations of Crotalus viridis Dillon & Headwaters Resource Areas, and Red Rock Lakes NWR 1996-1998 records Pre-1 996 records Museum collections 10 20 30 V^^^yy^ V//////A Scale in Miles BLM Lands USFWS Areas Montana Natural Heritage Program, December 21 , 1 998 Observations of Thamnophis sirtalis Dillon & Headwaters Resource Areas, and Red Rock Lakes NWR ▼ 1996-1998 records <^ Pre- 1996 records -yJ: Museum collections 10 20 30 ^^ IM^ Scale in Miles BLM Lands USFWS Areas Montana Natural Heritage Program, December 21 , 1 998 Observations of Thamnophis elegans Dillon & Headwaters Resource Areas, and Red Rock Lakes NWR ▼ 1996-1998 records '^ Pre-1 996 records Tr< Museum collections 10 20 30 Scale in iVIiles BLM Lands USFWS Areas Montana Natural Heritage Program, December 21 , 1 998