UC-NRLF

B 3 flSM

LIBRARY

UNIVERSITY OF CALIFORNIA.

GIFT OF

Class

. •
•*» '- ' ' '

ADDITIONAL FACTS

IN FOR M ATIO N

THE CAT ALP A TREE.

CATALPA Li o, ^ w. , . u-.i IDES

AND

ITS VAR1KTY? SPEC1OSA

K. K. B A K N i K V .

•

DAVTON Joi'UNAt BOOK ASK JOB PIMA-IIXU
1879.

ADDITIONAL FACTS

AND

USTFORMATIO

IN RELATION IT

THE CATALPA TREE

CA TAIL PA Bl&NONIOIDES

ITS VARIETY'^ SPECIOSA

R TS^ E Y

\\

DAYTON. OKI:*.

',. ' r * •

I •* •** •*•***

THE CATALPA TREE.

A PAPER READ BEFORE

THE NATIONAL AGRICULTURAL CONGRESS,

At New Haven, Conn,, August ?!?th 187$,

AND BEFORE

THE OHIO HORTICULTURAL SOCIETY,

At Dayton 0, December 6', J87S,
By E. E. BARNEY, of Dayton, Ohio.

INTRODUCTION.

When first informed that the catalpa, a tree I had been fa-
miliar with on our streets for more than thirty years, possess-
ed the power to resist decay to a wonderful degree, I was so
impressed with its great economic value that I deemed it very
important that a knowledge of its very valuable properties
should become widely extended. 1 have devoted what time J
could command from the supervision of a large manufactur-
ing business, for the last eight years, to gathering and pub-
lishing, from time to time, such facts and information as 1
have been able to obtain on this subject.

A year ago, at the request of the president of a leading rail-
road, I published these tacts and information in pamphlet
form. Since then 1 have been greatly encouraged and aided
in its general circulation by Dr. Jno. A. Warder, President of
the Ohio Horticultural Society and of the American Forestry
Association, and Prof. 0. S. Sargent, Director of the Botanic-
Garden and Arnold Arboretum of Harvard University, and
many others. Most efficient aid has been rendered also by

236842

The American Agriculturist, The Monthly Garden and Horticulturist,
The Cultivator and Country Gentleman, The Prairie Farmer, The
Scientific American, The Railway Age, The National Car Builder,
The Ohio Farmer, and The New York Tribune. Through the
notices made of the pamphlet, and the artieles on eatalpa
published in these periodicals, attention has been awakened
on this subject to such an extent that I have received letters
of inquiry from every State and Territory in the Union,
amounting in the aggregate to thousands; also from England,
South Australia, and New Zealand. As a result, if seed can
be obtained, enough will be planted the coming Spring to pro-
duce millions of eatalpa trees. During the last two or three
years several persons have been engaged in the benevolent act
of distributing packages of eatalpa seed to thousands of per-
sons in the West, notably, Suel Foster, of Muscatine, Iowa;
J. F. Tallent, Burlington, Iowa; and Horace J. Smith, Georges
Hill, Philadelphia. Many others have been engaged in the
same kindly work, but I have not their names.

The subject has been deemed of sufficient importance to
justify the occupying of your attention with a brief statement
of some of the facts that have been gathered in relation to
eatalpa.

THE SI/K TO WHICH IT ATTAINS.

No work that I have examined on botany or forestry begins
to do justice to the eatalpa in this regard. One and a half
and two feet is the largest diameter given in am^ of the books
I have seen. C. H. Miller, Landscape Gardener of Fairmount
Park, Philadelphia, writes: " There is a fine grove of common
eatalpa in the park, some of them very large, one measuring
thirteen feet in circumference." Arthur Bryant, of Prince-
ton, 111., has in his grounds a eatalpa of the Speciosa variety,
raised from the seed in 1839, that measures, stump high, three
feet in diameter. J. M. Bucklin reports eatalpa trees in South-
eastern Missouri, in 1866, three and four feet in diameter, and
fifty feet to a limb, and in a letter received last week I am in-
formed that plenty eatalpa trees of that size are there to-day.
In the Geological Survey of Indiana, 1873, Prof. John Collet re-
ports eatalpa trees three, four, and four and a half feet in
diameter. Recently, a man writes me from Southern Illinois
that he had sawed up eatalpa trees three freot in diameter,
and fifty feet to a limb. He also sent me eatalpa railroad ties,
among them a section of a limb 8 feet long and 12-J inches in
diameter at the small end, cut from the tree forty-five feet
from the stump. So that in Pennsylvana, Indiana, Illinois,
and Missouri the eatalpa attains to the diameter of three,
four, and four and a half feet, instead of one and a half and
two feet as given in the books.

ITS DURABILITY.

\Vm. K. Arthur, formerly Sup't Illinois Central Railroad,
informed me that he had visited with a friend the old home-
stead, and took up a catalpa gate-post his friend had assisted
his father to set forty-six years before. They found it as sound
as the day it was set. no signs of decay whatever. Judge
rpshcr. formerly of Indiana, informed me that old citizens of
Vineeimes had stated to him that the old stockade, built by
the first French settlers of that place, was largely from catalpa
trees, which grow native in the forests there, and that when
removed from the ground nearly one hundred years after they
had been set, were perfectly sound, and gave no indications of
decay. (.'. M. Allen, of Vincennes, writes: "During the last
thirty years I have seen much of catalpa, in fence-posts and
timber of buildings in contact with the ground, and esteem it
the most durable of all timber; in fact it may be regarded as
imperishable under or lying on the ground." Another gen-
tleman of the same place says he has fence-posts of twenty-
two years standing, as firm and sound, apparently, as the day
they were put in the ground. Catalpa posts set by General
Harrison about the Governor's house, in 1808, Mr. Pidgeon
says, were taken up a few years ago, and being sound were re-
set in another place, The'early settlers of Knox County, Ind.,
found a catalpa log that had fallen across a stream, and used
us a. foot-bridge until it was flattened on top by the pressure
of the feet. An old Indian, in answer to the question, how
long the log had been there, replied, "My father's father cross-
ed on that log,'" thus making it a hundred years old. In
Southern Illinois was another catalpa tree fallen across a
stream, still sound. A man, now living, says thai forty years
ago an old man told him that he crossed on that log when a
boy. making it nearly or quite one hundred years old. This
log was sawed into boards, and one of them, perfectly sound,
was exhibited at the Centennial by Prof. Burrill, of the Illi-
nois Industrial l:niversity. Large catalpa trees, back of New
Madrid, on the Mississippi River, in South-eastern Missouri,
killed by the eruptions in 1811, I am informed in a letter re-
ceived August 10th, from a gentleman living there, are still
standing, perfeetly sound, after (>7 years, and to use his ex-
pression, plenty of them. One of these was recently cut down,
and seven feet of the but and seven feet of the top sent to me.
The top, though worn to a point by the action of the wind
and rain is perfectly sound. The but, though showing on the
outside the result of long exposure, is as sound as it was sixty-
nine years ago when killed by the eruption. At Poplar Bluffs,
Henly, the ferryman, had a canoe made of catalpa, three feet

across the gunwales, perfectly sound, after constant use twelve
years.

Capt. Kurtz knows of catalpa trees killed by the ice on the
bottoms of the Wabash River, in the January flood of 1828, still
standing, and sound after fifty years. Prof. John Collet says,
athis timber is universally accredited with wonderful power
to resist decay and time, and that rails made by Col. Decker
in the year 1800, were in use forty-eight years afterwards, and
that after diligent inquiry among those familiar with catalpa
timber for a great number of years, I could rind no one willing
to say it is liable to rot." Fifteen years ago, W. F. Howell, of
this vicinity, saw, in the Rural New Yorker, a statement that
catalpa was the most durable wood known, and especially
valuable, arid excelling black locusts, red cedar and mulberry,
in that it had no sap wood, so that trees of three or -four yours
growth would not rot when set in the ground for fence stakes,
hop or bean poles. The above named trees have a larger pro-
portion of sap wood while young, and therefore are of far less
value while young. Mr. Howell says he has verified this state-
ment most fully, on his farm near the Soldiers Home, on which
a large number of catalpa trees are growing.

Small catalpa limbs and sprouts of two years' growth, placed
in the ground to support peas and vines, and used for that
purpose year after year, show no signs of decay.

Mr. J. P. Tallent, of Burlington, Iowa, writes that some
years ago he observed that the trunks of two cutalpa trees
which had stood in the ground for more than twenty yours,
used for clothes-line posts, showed no signs of decay, and be-
gan to study up the tree from books, from which, and personal
inquiry and correspondence, he soon learned its great value.
Some years ago, Suel Foster, of Muscatine, Iowa, observing
that limbs cut from catalpa trees, after lying on the ground
for years, did not rot like the limbs of other trees, began to
make inquiries and comparing observations with others, learn-
ed its great value.

In 1860, S. H. <fe J. B. Binkley, living near Alexandersville,
Montgomery County, Ohio, while repairing a fence Avith stakes
and a rider, fell short of stakes. As a temporary make-shift
they trimmed up some catalpa limbs, cut from two catalpa
trees in their yard, and used them for stakes. Five years
after, the cattle ran against one of these stakes and pulled it
out of the ground. Greatly to their astonishment they found
the stake perfectly sound, both in the ground and out. All
the other catalpa stakes were the same. These stakes, on ex-
amination last summer, were found to be sound, after being
eighteen years in the ground.

So Avell do farmers, in Southern Indiana and Illinois, under-
stand its value for fence-posts that it has been nearly all cut

down, where it was formerly abundant, and transported in
wagons fifty miles or more. One man, who has large numbers
of catalpa trees in his river bottoms, writes me that persons
living on the uplands come down, cut and haul them away,
by night, for posts.

A catalpa gate-post, set in the ground by Gol. Decker, of In-
diana, in 1780, was found to be sound in 1871, after doing duty
ninety years. Col. Corkum has known catalpa in use without
a stain of decay after fifty years. A catalpa bar-post was sent
me from Indiana, after if had stood in the ground seventy-five
years, by J. S. Miller, of the Indiana Central R. R. It is per-
fectly sound, as you may see in the samples before me, cut
from the bottom of the post. Horace J. Smith, of Philadel-
phia, writes: "'I had occasion to remove and re-set a gate-post
that had done service thirty years, and found it abundantly
sound to last indefinitely longer." In 1834, J. M. Bucklin, a
civil engineer, with Governor Davidson and others of Illinois,
visited Vincennes, Ind., to get information as to the durability
of catalpa for bridges. They found their preconceived opinion
of its remarkable durability fully confirmed. The facts were
notorious and unquestioned. J. P. Epping, Grahamville, South
Carolina, writes: "I use catalpa for fence-posts in preference
to any other wood." Daniel McNiel says that "both in Indi-
ana and Louisiana, where he has resided, the catalpa is re-
garded as the most valuable timber, for posts and fencing, on
account of its great durability."

Capt. Bournes, Falmouth, Mass., says he has used the limbs
cut from his catalpa trees as stakes in his field fences, and
thinks it as durable as red cedar.

President Harrison, in an address, reported in the Pi-airir
Mii'mrr in IS to, says: "Catalpa is more lasting than locust or
mulberry, is indigious on the Wabash and branches, and its
power to resist decay has been fully tested, both under ground
and in contact with it. A catalpa log. known to be lying
over the Desh;i in 1 7-S") and used as a foot bridge, was in 1840
but a little decayed. Major Andrew Powell says, "a catalpa
bar post made by his father-in-law and set up in 1770, was
taken up and reset <>n his farm and was still sound in IS-lo,
after being in use seventy-live years." James ( Mark, of South-
ern Illinois, writes: "Catalpa posts that have been in the
ground forty years are still good and still retain the bark above
ground." -lames Bell of Southern Illinois, writes, that "catal-
pa fence posts have been taken up after being in the ground
forty years, and reset as being good lor forty years more.
That catalpa is much sought after by old settlers for fence
posts and blocks in place of stone to set buildings on ; has been
nearly all carried of]' to the hill country for fence posts." lie
has sent me a fence post and a gate post that had been in the

8

ground forty-seven years, from one of which the samples
shown here are cut. D. Axtell, Superintendent Missouri Di-
vision of the St. Louis and Iron Mountain Railroad, writes:
"In regard to durability of catalpa it is useless to multiply
words; fence posts twenty years in the ground are always as
sound as when first put in, and no decayed catalpa logs are
ever found in the swamps. A section of a catalpa log known
to have laid on the ground in the swamps fifty years, is now
in the office of the land department of the road, in St. Louis,
and is as sound as it ever was."

CAN THE CATALPA BE CULTIVATED?

No tree more easily, very few as easily. It can be grown
from cuttings, but much the more readily from seed. Plant
in the spring, in warm, rich, light soil, in rows 3 to 4 feet
apart, cover lightly one inch unless the ground is liable to
bake, in which case much less. If pressed for room, li to 2 feet
apart, placing the seed 3 inches apart in the row, as all may not
germinate. When a few inches high, thin out to 1 foot in the
row, transplanting those taken up. At 1 foot apart in the
row they will make a better growth than nearer, and at that
distance, if desired, they maybe left in the seed bed two years.
They are more easily transplanted at the end of one year.
though they may be left in seed bed two or even three years.
When transplanted, place them 4 feet each way. Some prefer
3 feet by 3 feet. A year or two after transplanting, if any tree
is' not straight or puts out branches too low, it will make all
the taller and handsomer tree if cut down to the ground.
When the trees are large enough to make fence stakes, hop
and vineyard poles, cut out each alternate row one way.
When large enough to make fence posts, cut out each alternate
row the other way. In from twenty-five to thirty years, on
good ground, the remaining trees should be large enough to
make six railroad ties each. The first two cuts should be sawed
through the middle; the next two being smaller, may be flat-
tened on two sides. The rounded side of the ties sawed through
the middle should be placed down; this can be done, because
most catalpa trees show no sap wood, and none more than from
-J to J- of an inch, a fact that adds largely to its economic value.
As catalpa is fully equal to the best white walnut or cork pine
for any purpose for which they are used, and is susceptible of
finer finish and higher polish than either; it may pay better
to let the trees grow till the}^ are two feet or more in diameter
and use the timber for cabinet work or inside finishing.

WTLL CATALPA MAKK A SKR\TCKARLK RAILROAD TIK?

This is matter of conjecture in part. I think it will, for the
following reasons; Its durahility is unquestioned; it is very
elastic, and contrary to what most suppose, toujrh. 1 subjected
pieces of ratalpa, oak and ash, one inch square, to a break-
ing pressure, twelve inches between supports. The catnlpa
broke under a pressure of 70:> pounds: ash, SIM) pounds: one
piece of oak broke at 577-, one at 701), and one at 1141 pounds.
The catalpa deflected three times as much as the oak or ash
before breaking. Five thousand pounds pressure on a block of
oak. three inches louo- and one inch square, compressed it to ,'£
of an inch; a second block was compressed to j", and a third to
rH of an inch. The same pressure compressed one piece of
catalpa. same si/e, to ,76, one to ,TH, one to ,!';. and one to ,}-,. White
pine was compressed to ,'];; Xorway to ^: white walnut to ,«;
yellow ]>ine to ," ; black walnut to jjj and ,«; ash compressed
one way of the <:rain J^, another /j..

These samples were taken at random, and would indicate
that catalpa will bear the pressure to which it is subjected
when used as railroad ties. Two catalpa railroad ties were
placed in the track, near our office, five years a<r<>. and twelve
one year a«ro. All hold their spikes well, and show no si<rns
of mashing more than oak each side of them, and over both of
which heavily loaded trains pass almost hourly. The road-
master, who has watched them with much interest, says he-
has no better tics on the line of his road.

I). Axtcll, Superintendent of the Missouri division of the
Iron Mountain Railroad, writes, that "catalpa ties placed in
the track of his road ten years a,iro are perfect Iv sound, that the
rail has worn info some of them from one-half an inch to an
inch, and it has been conclusively proven, that the catalpa is
far superior for tics to white oak or any other kind of timber
iiro\vii in that latitude."

Two VAKIKTIKS OF CATALPA.

There are two varieties of catalpa in Ohio, Indiana, Illinois.
Missouri. Kentucky, and Tennessee, ^rown for shade, one of
which at least is native to the forests of the last live States.
They vary fully three weeks in time of blooming. The earlier
blooming, called also Spcciosa. and the hardy, when irrown
sinirly. is taller, strai^hter. with more compact top. with
whiter and larger blossoms, and longer and larger seed-pods,
but less in number, and is usually the handsomer tree. After
a few years the bark «jro\vs darker, is furrowed and rou«rh, re-
sembling black locust or elm of same age. It is much more

10

hardy than the common variety, and has withstood the severest
winters up to and even beyond 42° North latitude.

The later blooming, or common variety, resists the frosts of
winter usually below 40°. If the young trees of either variety
freeze, they should he cut down the following spring close to
the ground. They wrill shoot up a straight, vigorous stalk,
and after that, most likely, resist the frost. The common va-
riety, when planted singly, is often leaning, crooked, and
scraggy. But planted in groves, grows tall, erect, and makes
a handsome tree. The hark, when the tree is grown, is light
silver gray color, comparatively smooth, the1 outer coat in
flakes or scales. There are before me samples of the wood of
both varieties, and also samples of the bark.

GROWS ON ALMOST ANY SOIL.

While rich river bottoms, particularly such as are subject
to overflow, seem to furnish the most natural soil for catalpa,
it thrives well on almost any soil. J. P. M. Kpping, Grab am -
ville, S. C., writes, "Catalpa springs up in old fields, near
roads, or in old abandoned plantations; seems to like high
land with sandy clay loam host. It only grows spontaneous
in such places." Robert W. Pumas, Brownville, Neb., writes:
"Grows best on table or second bottom land." G. (1. Bracket t.
Kansas, writes: "Makes a fine tree planted on deep black' soil ;
adapts itself to groves, and becomes more luxuriant than in
open, exposed places*" E. Gale, Manhattan, Kan.: "Makes a
good growth in a forest plat upon a high, gravelly ridge : makes
a wonderful success upon low, rich bottom lands; grows finely
on all kinds of land." Win. G. Burk, Medina, Delaware Co.,
Pa.: "No tree springs up along the line of the Philadelphia A:
West Chester R. R. so freely, or grows more rapidly." Horace
J. Smith, Philadelphia: "The catalpa flourishes remarkably
well on railroad embankments, roadsides,' and other newly
turned up ground. On the spoil barren dirt of quarries, of the
hills, and on the raw clay of Philadelphia level meadows, be-
fore any other vegetation takes hold, the catalpa plants itself
and grows finely." Charles Mohr, Mobile, Alabama: "Thrives
wonderfully well on our light soil." Joseph Kirk, Morrill,
Brown County, Kan. : "Have a catalpa tree of the early va-
riety, seven years old, that is seven inches diameter two feet
from the ground. The catalpa is a very fast grower here."
Robert Millikan, Emporia, Kan. : "({rows through the central
and Southern part of the State with the greatest luxuriance,
on second bottom, low upland, river bottoms, and high upland."
J. W. Foster, Livingstone, Pratt Co., Kan. : "My catalpa seed-
lings stand the dry weather very well, and grow finely."1 D.

11

Axtell, Charleston, Mo.: "Catalpa, in South-eastern Missouri,
is found native only in heavy, stiff soil, subject to overflow,
though it tli rives well when planted in dry places."

A. M. Chapman, Apalachicola, Florida, writes: "Catalpa
grows here, hut is too small a tree for any useful purpose."

J. 11. Foster, Pratt County, Kansas: "Catalpa seedlings
stand the dry weather very well."

James Hell. I'llin, Illinois: "I took from the forests, eatal pa
trees two years old. in 1869, one and a half inches at the ground
and planted on high hill land, in 1878 they measured twenty-
four to twenty-eight inches six feet from the ground. They
had but little root when planted."

K. P. Morev, Sterling, Kansas, "Planted catalpa seed May
25th, that made a fine growth of two feet high and three-
fourths of an inch in diameter.

Robert \V. Furnas: "My grove of six thousand catalpas
three years old are from ten to fourteen feet high. Twelve
years ago t set out quite small catalpas, for shade, ahout six
feet high. They now measure forty-one inches in circum-
ference."

Prof. T. J. Hurrill, Crbana, Illinois: <k I have just measured
a common eatal pa of nineteen year's growth, grown in ordinarv
prairie soil, and find sixteen and one-half inches across the
stump. The last twelve years it increased over fourteen
inches in diameter.1'

J. F. Tallant, Burlington, Iowa: "My catalpa trees two
years old are sound, even to extreme tip, having withstood (he
frost when the mercury was :\()° below zero; though on a dry
clay hill, with thin soil, grew four feet the first year, in a very
dry season; the second, a rainy one, they grew so rapidly as to
be ten feet high and two inches diameter.'1

In Marshall County, Illinois, are several groves of Speciosa
catalpa, planted in the prairie twelve to sixteen vears airo.
They are all very straight, thrifty, handsome trees.

The catalpa, seems wonderfully well adapted to the soil and
climate of Ohio, Kentucky, Tennesse, -Indiana, Illinois, Mis-
souri, Iowa, Kansas, and Nebraska, and grows luxuriantly on
most soils in these States.

CO X C LUS1 O N.

Such are a few of the facts I have gathered, and tried to im-
part to others. From them it seems to me clearlv shown that
tlu1 catalpa occupies a prominent position among the trees
that should be cultivated. It can be so easilx propogated; so
readily cultivated over so large an extent of territory; it is so
rapid in its growth; it is of such economic value, not alone

for its durability, when exposed to moisture, but also for all
purposes for which white walnut and white cork pine, the two
woods that season the quickest and keep their place best, may
ho used, that I do not know any tree that presents higher
claims for general cultivation. From the experiments I have
made, there is no one tree 1 would as soon use for the entire
structure of a passenger car, including sills, plates, posts, and
the entire frame work, also for outside and inside finish, as
catalpa.

What 1 have said, 1 think, shows that the tree is worth a
most careful study. There is very much that needs to be
known about it. I have arranged with horticulturists of thir-
ty years experience with catalpa, to visit several places where
it grows native in the forests, also some groves of catalpa grown
from the seed, to gather such facts as may guide in its success-
ful cultivation.

'Any one having any facts or information pertaining in any
way to catalpa., will confer a favor on the public if they will
communicate them to me. There has been such a demand for
a pamphlet I published last January, on the catalpa, that the
edition is nearly exhausted. I hope to reprint a portion of
this with such other facts and information as I may obtain up
to that time. 1 wish to make this as full and complete as may
be, for the benefit of the public, and therefore ask its aid in
gathering these facts and this information.

THE GAT ALP A.

Prof. (J. S. Sargent, of the Arnold Arboretum and Botanic
(lardens of Harvard University, has kindly furnished the fol-
lowing paper :

E. E. BARNKY, ESQ.:

X/r: 1 have examined with much interest the various speci-
mens of catalpu wood, with which you have favored me at
different times.

1 find that the specific gravity of the wood of the common
('nhtlfHi bignonioides is, when perfectly dry, .405; and that the
specific gravity of the wood of the early blooming variety, also
perfectly dry, is .462.* The ratio of weight of any wood to the
weight of an equal body of water, that is its specific gravity,
gives in many respects the surest indication of its value for
construction and fuel. But to show the relative value of catalpa,
it will be well to compare its specific gravity with that of some
better known or standard woods.

Specific gravity of common Catalpa. .405.

>L early blooming Tata! pa, .4<VJ.

- Eastern Hickory. ..X/JX.

White Oak, .WL>.

" American Elm, .649.

" Rock Elm,t .832.

•• Black Walnut, .577.

" " Canoe Birch, .5:>(J.

u Wild Cherry, .488.

" Ailanthus. ' .614.

By this comparison it will be seen that catalpa is inferior
in weight, and consequently in strength and heat-giving qual-
ities, to even such soft woods as the black walnut, the canoe
birch, or even the wild cherry, which up to this time is the

-Tlic.s*- sp.-citic LM-iiviti.-s h:-iv.- I n ml'-ulnt.-.! l.y Mr. S. P. Slmrplrs-, St:it.- As^;iy..-r of

Massachusetts.

f Uhnuis rncemosa. — Thomas.

14

lightest of American hard woods, which I have examined
critically. It is remarkable that so soft and light a wood as
the catalpa should possess the power of resisting decay to a
degree almost unknown in the hardest and heaviest woods. It
is unnecessary for me to dwell at this time on tin1 indestructi-
ble nature of this wood, for so many examples of its wonderful
durability have1 of late been brought to public notice that the
fact is now established beyond question. But why the soft
wood of this fast growing tree, which is traversed with large
open ducts, nearly as broad as those of red oak, a wood which
notoriously rots very quickly, should be able to resist decay to
such a degree, is not clear; and this fact presents an interest-
ing problem,. which the chemist or the vegetable physiologist
may perhaps be able to solve.

As fuel the catalpa has but little value. For the cabinet
maker or the architect it will rank with such North Ameri-
can hard woods as the cherry, the black walnut, the ash, and
the butternut. The wood is close grained, very easily worked,
and susceptible of an excellent polish. In color and general
appearance it resembles chestnut, but unlike chestnut it is
easily "filled," and shows none of the tendency to warp or
start, which renders that wood unfit for the best cabinet w<»r\.
It is, however, for fence and telegraph posts, hop and vin •-
yard poles that the wood of the catalpa has no known equal
among extra-tropical woods. It is for these, and other em-
ployments, where a cheap material capable of resisting decav,
when exposed to the action of the soil and weather, is requir-
ed, that catalpa can be more profitably employed than the
wood of any other tree suitable for cultivation over so large
an area of the United States. Tatalpa wood seems particu-
larly suited for the manufacture of coffins, for which purpose
it promises to rival the famous \an-inti wood of the Chinese;
and it is not altogether improbable that before many years,
we may see large quantities of catalpa exported to China to
take the place of that scarce and high-priced material for the
construction of coffins. Incidentally, it is suggested that
catalpa may prove an excellent material from which to make
permanent garden labels. Much has been said in various
quarters of the excellence and durability of catalpa railway
ties. Of the power of this wood, when so employed, to resist
decay, there can be no doubt. But whether a soft wood like
the catalpa will bear the crushing and wearing of the rails,
or hold spikes as well as .harder woods, like white oak and
chestnut (the best materials from which American ties arc
made), only carefully conducted comparative experiments can
demonstrate. Such experiments, by which the comparative
value of the several woods used or recommended for railway
ties is to be fairlv tested, have been lately inaugurated both

15

in Massachusetts and Ohio: and information is expected from
them which will lead to important practical results.

The catalpa can he safely planted in strong, rich soil, in any
portion of the United States south of the 42d parallel. Fur-
ther North it often suffers in severe winters, especially when
young; and in the Xew England States, except in a few ex-
ceptional situations, the soil is not rich enough to make the
planting of this tree as profitable as that of many others bet-
ter suited to reach maturity in this section of the country.
For that portion of the treeless region of the West, south of
the 42d parallel, especially for Kansas and Southern Nebraska,
I am satisfied that no tree, which has yet been suggested for
general planting there, will at all equal the catalpa, either in
the rapidity of its growth or the value of its wood, with the
single exception, perhaps, of the Ailanthus.

The growth of the catalpa in the rich prairie soil is simply
astounding. I have now before me a specimen cut from a
tree which grew at Brownsville, Nebraska, and which shows
but four annual layers of growth from the seed. It is 9f
inches in circumference, and the growth of the first two years,
\l inches in diameter, is already changed into' heart wood.

During the autumn of 1877, the Missouri River, Fort Scott &
(iulf R. R. commenced experimental plantations of various
trees on their land, near Fort Scott, in Kansas. The super-
intendent of the road, in his report to the president on the
condition of these plantations at the end of their first year,
says: "The catalpa has certainly proved to be the strongest
grower, and most tenacious, standing the dry weather better
than other varieties, and at present rate will come to maturity
years before other varieties are of sufficient si/e to he of anv
utility."

I have said that as fuel the catalpa is of little value. Such
a statement is comparative rather than absolute. As com-
pared with the cotton woods, box elders, or white maples,
which have been heretofore almost exclusively planted on the
prairies, it is of very great value; and, though not yet proved
to be the e<|iial of white oak or chestnut for railway ties, it
is far superior to any other tree which can with certaintv be
grown (jiiickly and profitably, where there will always be' the
greatest scarcity of material for ties, namely, in those States
watered by the Missouri and its tributaries.

I add a few brief and sim pie characters of the only Tatalpas
now known, which can be cultivated in the (Tnited States
North of the extreme Southern portion of Florida, in the hope
of aiding horticulturists to more readily determine tie various
species now (|iiite generally cultivated, and in regard to which
there seems to be much confusion.

16

1. Catalpa bignonioides. — Walt.

Leaves ovate, heart-shaped at the base, pointed, and rarely
somewhat lobed. Flowers white, tinged with purple and dot-
ted with purple and yellow in throat; appearing (at the North)
from the 1st to the middle of July. Pods nearly cylindrical,
or often somewhat flattened, rarely ever one foot in length.
Seeds H inches long, their wings gradually narrowed to sharp
points, and ending in tufts of long, white hairs, often an inch
in length. Bark thin, scaly, silver gray.

2. TUP: "EARLY FLOWERING" CATALPA.

This can be distinguished from Xo. 1 by its more gradually
pointed leaves, its larger white flowers, appearing (in Ohio)
during the first week of .June; by its larger and much flatten-
ed pods, often 1H to 18 inches long, and with much thicker
walls; by its shorter, broader seeds, with wings of equal
width to their rounded ends, which arc terminated by a .copi-
ous fringe of stouter hairs; and by its darker and thicker, fur-
rowed bark.

I have already shown that the wood of this form is consider-
ably heavier than that of the ordinary catalpa. Further in-
vestigation is necessary to determine whether this is a dis-
tinct species, or only a well-marked form of Catalpa bicfnonioide*,
and connected with it by intermediate forms. If distinct it
should be known as C. speciosa.

'>. C. Kaempheri, I). C. Native of Japan.

Leaves smaller than in the American species, ovate, heart-
shaped at the base, abruptly sharp-pointed and often with one
or more sharp-pointed lateral lobes. Flowers smaller than in
the American species, spotted with purple, sweet-scented, ap-
pearing (near Boston) during the first week of . July. Pods
about one foot long, cylindrical, slender, not more than ^ of
an inch in diameter. Seeds much smaller than in the- Ameri-
can species, the wings short, blunt, and ending in a copious
fringe of soft white hairs; the seed and its appendages rarely
Y of an inch long. Bark in young plants thin, scaly, light
gray.

F have no information of the si/e this tree may attain un-
der favorable conditions, although it is spoken of as a small
tree in all works on Japanese botany. Near Boston it is rather
hardier than the American species, and flowers and ripens its
fruit freelv when not more than twelve feet high. T have no
information whatever as to the economic value of this species.

17
4. f'ntnf.po /??/.?? r/r/, C. A. Mey. Native of Northern China.

• Leaves much smaller than in No. o\ oblong, ovate,
N/I a }>c(l 'if the i^/.sr.very gradually tapering in to a long, sharp
point. Flowers smaller than in the other species, color un-
known to me. hut prohably white. Fruit unseen by inc.

(\ Hdiiiff/' is said to become a tree, but it only appears in
cultivation in this country as a spreading bush, eight to ten
feet high, and sometimes twenty feet in diameter. 1 have
never heard that it has flowered in this country, and I am
ignorant of the quality of the wood it may produce.

C. S. SARGENT.
Canibridr. .I/*/**., D

Dr. Warder's Report on the Catalpa.

THE CATALl'A (JussiEr).

Natural family HH.NONIACK.K.

< renus Catalpa i.Jiiassieu ), Scopoli. Kndlicher.

Synoniin : Bi^nonia (Michaux).
There are six species :

1. Oatalpa Bignonioides (Walter)* I', s.

Syn.: Syrinu'd't'olia (Sims, 1'ui'slii.

Qordifolia (Nnttall, Elliott, Jhihamel).

l^i.irnonia ('atal]>a (Michanx, Willdenow, Linnanis).

1>. Amei-icana ( Duhamel).

Kavvarra Fisaira ( Iv;i'in])fer). afcrorcliiiff to Siemonip.

2. ( 'atalpa lonirissiiiia ; \V. Indies.

Syn.: (\ lonu-isili<iua.
.'!. Catalpa punetata; W. Indies.
4. ('atalpa hirsnta; Hraxil.
o. Catalpa Butogei ; China.
0. Catalpa K;i'in|>l'eri ; .Japan.

This conspectus is after Hooker ami other botanists of eminence, and
was prepared with the valuable assistance of Messrs. ( ieo. Yasey, A. P.
Morgan, and others.

Our own native Catalpa, or Catalpas, alone are now to he considered.
This report will relate to their ran^r and habitats in nature, and indicate
the limits to which the trees have been extended by human agency in
our own and other countries. Reference will also be made to the char-

18

acters of the two distinct kinds we have in cultivation, their respective
merits, as to habit and hardiness for economic planting, the methods of
their propagation, and treatment, also to the character of the timber and
its value in the various purposes to which it has been and may be ap-
plied.

This paper has been epitomized from a much larger and fuller memoir
of the tree, which was found to be too voluminous for the present occa-
sion ; it will briefly treat of the catalpa bignonioides of Walter, and of its
western congener,* but recently recognized as a distinct variety or per-
haps species^ and known in Ohio as the Speciosa variety since 1853, as
the Early Blooming, and in Iowa as the Hardy Catalpa. The typical
tree, that from which the species was formed, is spoken of as the Georgia
Catalpa, from its earliest known habitat ; it is often referred to as the
common kind, and as the eastern kind, in contradistinction to our favor-
ite western tree, which is considered so very superior in form arid hardi-
ness, that it alone is recommended for extensive propagation and plant-
ing for economical purposes.

At the request of Mr. E. E. Barney, and as a labor of loye, the seri-
ous and extensive investigation of the habitats of these plants has been
undertaken within a few months. By the kind, assistance of many cor-
respondents in numerous States, accompanied, in many instances, with
samples of the fruit and seeds from various parts of the country, a largo
collection of these has been gathered, and they have proved of great
value, as aids in settling the range and the native habitats of the two
kinds, the eastern and the western, which, though not absolutely settled,
it is believed will be found on the eastern and western slopes of the
Appalachian water-shed, toward the southern extremity of that moun-
tain range.

The history and description of the species, or the Eastern Catalpa, has
been very fully set forth by the botanists; though for a long time after it
had been introduced into cultivation, and after it had been spread all
along the Atlantic coast, and was known in every town, as we are told,
from Louisiana to Massachusetts, few of the writers had ever seen the
tree in its native wilds. It was indeed for a long time a question whether
it was really indigenous any where within our borders. Meanwhile the
tree had been taken to Europe and was planted in many countries; and
as the population of the United States progressed westward, this catalpa
accompanied or followed, until it has reached far out into the plains
West of the Missouri River, crossing over and beyond the native range
of its western congener, and even mingled with it in some places, so that
both kinds may often be seen side by side in the same avenues or groups
of planted trees. This Eastern Catalpa has been so widely planted thai
it may well have been called the common kind.

The earliest accounts we have of the Western ('(t/dl/m, were reports of
the observations quoted by Mr. Nuttall from General Harrison. Mho made
its acquaintance when residing at Yincennes, Indiana, as Governor of
the North-western Territory, but it does not seem to have been suspected
that this was different from the well-known eastern tree, for which the
species, bignonioides, had been erected by Walter.

The attention of the writer was called to the showy flowers of this, the
early blooming kind, by his friend, .Jno. C. Teas, of Indiana, who re-
ferred him to the streets of Dayton, Ohio, where it had been propagated
and planted quite extensively by the late Dr. Job Ilaines. These were
visited when in bloom. In 1853 it was described and presented to the
public in the columns of the Western Horticultural Re-rieic, published in
Cincinnati, Ohio.

As a variety name, it was called Speciosa on account of its large and
showy flowers. A further study, especially within the past few months,

10

inclines the writer t<> believe that this catalpa may be worthy of being
erected into a species; in this opinion some eminent botanists concur,
and they have kindly promised their valuable assistance in diagnosing
the plant when again in blossom. The peculiarities observable in the
fruit-pods and seeds, which prove most valuable means of discriminating
between the two kinds, were suggested by Mr. R. Douglas, of AVaukegan,
Illinois, whose long experience, and his acumen in the observation of
these organs, has enabled him to detect characters that might have been
overlooked by a less observant eye.

The earlier history of this Dayton group has never been traced beyond
the two trees from which Dr. Haines first gathered seed for propagation—-
but it is now clear, that as they are the same with those found in the
delta lands of the Mississippi,' they were of the western stock. They
may have come to Ohio independently, or possibly through General Har-
rison, who, 011 retiring from office, brought plants to Jjis home at North
Bend, Ohio, some of which were distributed, and those of his own plant-
ing, with their self-sown progeny, are still to be found in that neighbor-
hood almost naturalized. *

From one or other of these groups, this form of catalpa was sent from
Cincinnati to Massachusetts many years ago, and trees are now to be
seen near Fahnouth, as reported by Mr. Jos. S. Fay, whose timber plant-
ings at Wood's Holl have been very successful.

Mr. Arthur Bryant, Sen., of Princeton, Illinois, gathered catalpa pods
at New Madrid in 1839, from which he grew trees of this variety, and he
has since propagated and distributed plants, which have been Very suc-
cessful in Northern Illinois and elsewhere, in places that were not adapt-
ed to the eastern kind. On his grounds plants spring up naturally from
self-sown seeds, showing their adaptation to the prairie soil.

Mr. John Litchfield, after settling on the prairie in Middle Illinois,
South of LaSalle, procured seeds of the catalpa from his old home in
Yanderburgh County, Indiana, from which he has planted groves that
have been verv successful. They are all of the Speciosa — not a single
tree of the specific type was to be found in the neighborhood.

The Omaha group has been received by a circuitous route. Many years
ago a traveler visiting a friend in Washtenaw County, Michigan, left a
seed-pod that he had brought from Kentucky. Ignorant of its character,
Mr. Rennet planted the seeds, and from him Mr. Joel T. Griffen purchas-
ed two plants that were taken to his home near Omaha, Nebraska, where
they have been multiplied and are scattered in that region.

The Iowa group has been traced directly to the Dayton trees by Mr.
Suel Foster, who procured them from a trader who had brought them
from the Messrs. Teas, then nurserymen of Indiana. It is curious to
observe how universally other nurserymen have introduced the eastern
form, and how widely it has been disseminated through these western
States at the expense of the native Speciosa.

THE HABITATS OF THE CATALPAS.

The Species; -In his work upon the American Forest Trees, Mr.
Michaux referred to several places where this tree had been found in
the upper parts of Georgia and Carolina; following these indications,
Nuttail wrole that at one of the habitats thus indicated, near Columbus.
< ieor<_ria. he " for the lirst time in his life, beheld this tree decidedly na-
tive, forming small, hazard, crooked trees, leaning fantastically over the
rocky hanks of 'the Chatta-hoot-shee River." Correspondents i'n Georgia
and Alabama have referred to the catalpa as being found along the
streams, dearly indigenous, and they describe it as a live of large si/e.
All the seeds received from that region, whether from wild or cultivated

20. y

trees, are of the eastern kind. Indeed it is believed that all of the plants
now found on the eastern flank of the Alleghenies are of that stock,
except .a few in Massachusetts which were sent from Cincinnati; though
others may yet be identified that have a western origin and form.

The habitats of the western plant will now be indicated. The tree is
found on the bottom lands of the Wabash and its tributary, the White
River of Indiana, on the lower Ohio and its tributaries, the Cumberland
and the Tennessee, as well as the W abash, the Little W abash, the Saline,
the Cache, and other streams. It is also found on the extensive swampy
region of the Mississippi about New Madrid, in South-eastern Missouri,
and the adjoining portion of Arkansas, as well as in the neighboring low
lands of the western portion of Kentucky and Tennessee, particularly
along the ( )bion River.

In all this region of silty soil known as the Delta country, the forests
produce this particular catalpa, the locality being in these six neighbor-
ing States. It has also been found by Mr. Teas, on the Arkansas River
near Little Rock, and on the waters of the Red River near the south-
western portion of Arkansas, and presumably it exists on 'most of the
tributaries of the lower portions of the Great River; to which region,
however, these recent special investigations have riot been extended.

In all the territory above indicated, which has been critically explored,
the Speciosa variety alone has been discovered in a state of nature — not
one of the Georgia kind, the recognized species, C. bignonioides, of Walter,
has been seen except where planted by the hand of man.

It is now so fully demonstrated that there are in nature and in cultiva-
tion two distinct trees that it may be well to point out their differences.
This will be done as much as possible in popular terms.

DIAGNOSIS OF THE Two FORMS.

The species, the native of Georgia, or the common Catalpa :

Tree — As described by the botanists, usually low-branched, short-stem-
med when in open lands, often leaning. When planted in thick groves
the stems become taller, but are seldom really straight. Young plants
often winter-killed, and older ones frequently injured North of lati-
tude 40 and 41 N. on the West of the Alleghenies.

Bark — Gray, and in mature trees, or those of ten or twelve years or more,
it is scaly, and easily detached in small, thin plates.

Leaves — Similar in both kinds, but in their young state having less of the
purple tinge that is common in those' of the Speciosa; at maturity
they are a shade darker.

Flowers — As represented in Michaux' plate, white, tinged with violet,
having purple and yellow spots inside the throat of its bell-shaped
corolla; fragrant,— blooms come later by from one to three weeks
than the western form.

Fruit — Usually very abundant, pods from 8-15 inches long, somewhat
flattened, the valves meeting at an angle form a ridge that can be felt
when it is rolled between the thumb and finger, hence the section is
lenticular; the surface is slightly uneven, somewhat grooved in some
specimens, color light brown, especially on trees cultivated in this
latitude ; the pods received from Georgia and Alabama, are darker.

Seeds — Applied end to end in one or more layers to a rather flat and
grooved placenta or pith. They are winged as described, in their
entire length, from one to one 'inch and seven lines, breadth two
lines; average 100 seeds to a pod. The coma or fringe of hairs pro-
jecting from each end, is sharply pointed as though they had been
wetted and drawn together.

'2\

The variety Speciosa. or Western Catalpa:

Tre< — .More erect, naturally growing taller, and better furnished with
limbs when exposed to the light. In thick groves, erect, straight
and tall, often lit'ty feet high to limbs, which are not unfrequently
broken in the forests when old. In cultivation this is more hardy
than the species.

H<trk- — \\\ young trees is light gray, becoming darker with age. Adhering
closely, and moderately furrowed vertically, thicker, because it does
not scale off, and in old trees it may become quite dark.

Isaiw — Like the other, but of a paler tint of green; when first expand-
ing on young seedlings they often have a dull, livid hue.

MOHVI-X — Much larger, nearly pure white, markings in the throat clear
yellow and purple, very showy, and expanding from one to three
weeks earlier.

l'\-n!t — Often less abundant, pods usually larger and longer, 15-20 and
more inches, cylindrical, ("5-7 lines in diameter. They are generally
of a darker brown color, and usually marked with distinct parallel
grooves extending their entire length.

,sv<W.s'— - Decidedly winged and fully fringed at both ends — heavier and
larger than the species, and wider, 4 lines. The texture of the mem-
brane- and tuft is more silky, compared with the satiny and harsher
tissue enveloping the seeds of the species, or common catalpa.

RANGE AND RELATIVE HAKDIXESS.

Let us' now take a glance at the range to which these trees have been
taken in their migrations, and we shall see that they differ in their rela-
tive hardiness. This is a very important consideration to the practical
tree-planter who is looking to the production of groves for economical
purposes. In the milder climate of Western Europe our trees may reach
a much higher latitude than here. Thus we find that the Georgia Catalpa
thrives in the South of France and in Italy. Its limbs or twigs are some-
times cut by frosts in Paris, where, however, it has attained fair propor-
tions. It has grown to a good si/e at Vienna, Austria. Dr. F. Brendel,
of Peoria, Illinois, to whom the writer acknowledges indebtedness for
man}' botanical references relating to the genus catalpa, has just written
that in 1S4() he collected flowering specimens in Bamberg, Germany,
latitude oO N., and 7<>0 feet above the sea. The trees were then about
ten inches diameter, and he thinks they were of the (.'astern kind. In
the .South of England it has grown well, blossoming in London at mid-
summer, but rarely perfecting its seeds. In Glasgow, Scotland, it is al-
most an herbaceous plant, not perfecting its woody fiber; and at St.
Petersburg!!, in Russia, it requires the protection of the green-house.
All these foreign trees are believed to be of the Georgia kind.

In very early times, in our own country, this catalpa was planted for
ornament and' shade in all the towns along the Atlantic coast, and it
may be found even in Massachusetts, where, however, Professor Sargent
says, though it has survived for 7"> and perhaps for KM) years, it does not
always perfect its seed, and can not be considered a perfectly hardy tree;
nor ("iocs he recommend it to planters there, "except perhaps in favored
localities, like the valley of the Connecticut."

In the later edition of Darlington's Agricultural Botany, where it is
described as a small tree, Dr. Geo. Thurber, the editor, adds this observa-
tion: " In the latitude of New York the larger branches, and frequently
whole trees are killed bv a severe winter."

22

About Philadelphia, Mr. Meehan, editor of the Gardener's Monthly, con-
siders it perfectly hardy, and indeed the writer himself long ago noticed
that it was becoming naturalized there and springing up spontaneously.

From Eli K. Price, Esq., Chairman of the Committee on Trees arid
Nurseries in the Fairmount Park, and a devotee to sylviculture, the fol-
lowing facts have been kindly furnished:

"I have been here since 1815, and have known the tree as common
since that time." He then quotes a catalogue of Dr. Muhlenberg's, dated
1791, which included the catalpa, but not native. "There is one growing
before my window on the north-west corner of Washington Square, with
a girth of eight feet, four feet from the ground. Tins was probably
planted in the spring of 1816. We have one in the

Fairmount Park, a larger catalpa, on the west side of the Schuylkill, now
surrounded by a dense growth of its seedlings."

This is a pretty good showing for that side of the mountains; let us
trace its westward migrations, and look at its deportment on tne other
slope, in the valleys of the St. Lawrence, the Ohio, the Mississippi, and
the Missouri, the Platte and the Ka\v rivers, for, with the men of the
East, this south-eastern tree has also followed the Star of Empire, reach-
ing out into the borders of what used to be called the Great American
Desert, or what is now more appropriately named, smiling Kansas.

At Rochester, New York, it is not considered perfectly hardy, for it
"suffers in severe winters," as reported by Mr. William Barry; though
it lives, grows finely, and perfects its seed, by which it has been identified
and distinguished from the western form.

At Painesville, in the north-eastern part of Ohio, Mr. J. J. Harrison
says his trees have not suffered, but appear to be hardy, perhaps pro-
tected by the lake influence. His plants were imported from France,
and the fruit and seed bear a close resemblance to those received direct
from Georgia and Alabama, where, it is most probable, M. Michaux ob-
tained the seeds he sent home to France, whence their progeny have
nowr been returned to us.

In the north-western part of this State, however, at Toledo, Ohio, as
reported by Prof. E. W. E. Koch, the catalpa is killed to the ground al-
most every winter. All through the southern part of this State, and in
the adjoining portions of Pennsylvania, West Virginia, and Kentucky,
the tree survives, and thrives, though in the middle range of counties.
and generally on the parallel of 40 degrees and northward, the young-
plants are sometimes cut to the ground. A similar report may be made
for Michigan, for Northern Indiana, and Illinois, for Wisconsin, for lov.a.
Nebraska, and for Kansas, at least North of the Kaw River, as well as
for the North part of Missouri, and even in St. Louis, in latitude 36.37,
where thousands of this kind of catalpa are to be seen in the streets and
parks, it is reported, upon the best authority, that they have suffered in
severe winters.

Let us now look at the more satisfactory record of the Speciosa Catalpa,
so far as it has been possible to trace its history and behavior through
the forced migrations it has made under man's 'interfering agency. As
informed by Mr. Jos. S. Fay, of Massachusetts, this tree was carried from
CincinnatVOhio, twenty-six years ago; it has thriven and grown to good
size at Fahnouth, near the coast, and maintains its high reputation there.
Some other trees were planted in the same neighborhood forty-five years
ago, and have attained a large size without injury.

Seeds taken from Kentucky to Michigan grow well, and are perfectly
hardy on sandy uplands in Washtenaw County, while those on clay lands,
especially whore low, had been injured ; so writes Mr. Joseph Bennett.
Some of 'this lot of trees were taken to Nebraska, and were planted on
the high exposed rolling prairie, near Omaha, where, in the hands of

23

Mr. Griffen, they have proved the nucleus of a large group of the Western
Catalpa in that region. This mav, perhaps, be considered nearly its
northern limit along the Missouri kiver. Still this tree may be recom-
mended for all the south-eastern quarter of Nebraska, if protected by
wind-breaks of the hardy trees of the country. It appeared to be per-
fectly hardy on the grounds of Governor Furnas, at Brownville.

The existence of the Speciosa Catalpa at Dayton, Ohio, has already
been referred to; there indeed it is historical; it is also found to be hardy
in Columbus, the capital, and in other places on the same parallel where
the eastern* kind has suffered to some extent.

In Fort AVayne, Indiana, the speciosa alone is reported as the catalpa
that will stand the climate. At Indianapolis, as at Terre Haute, and all
along that range it thrives, and is considered very superior in habit and
hardiness to the eastern kind.

In all Illinois, North of the Illinois River at LaSalle, the speciosa is the
only kind that can be recommended as hardy. It was introduced by the
venerable tree-planter. Arthur Bryant. Sen'., who gathered the seeds at
New Madrid in ls:'J«), planted them' at Princeton, and lias ever since1 been
propagating and distributing these trees. He rinds them perfectly hardy
where the eastern kind has succumbed to the winters. The noble tree
in his door-yard is a beautiful specimen, having grown from seed sown in
is:}<),toa hight of forty or mire feet, \vith a beautiful crown spreading
over an area of equal extent, and supported by an erect shaft that meas-
ures almost three feet in diameter.

At Waukegan, in the north-east corner of the State, the speciosa sur-
vives, while some plants of the eastern kind arc. frequently killed to the
ground, and are represented by a bunch of sprouts springing up from
the base of the dead stein, rarely producing flowers or seed.

At Galesburgh and other points on that range, the trees of the speciosa
catalpa thrive and do well; they are, of course, highly appreciated.

In Iowa the common kind was first planted. ( )n the grounds of Suel
Foster, at Muscatine, on the bluffs of the Mississippi, in latitude 41 N.,
they grew well for awhile, and a lot of the speciosa variety was planted
beside them. The winter of IS.Vi and '5(> proved a crucial' test, as in the
following spring these were perfectly sound, while the common kind were
all killed; then and there was the survivor christened The Hardy Catalpa,
and since that time it alone has been selected by the intelligent planters
of that State, who claim that it is perfectly hardy even beyond latitude
\'2 degrees, in the bleak climate of their open prairies.

Having now traced the migrations of these two trees, noted their be-
havior, and learned their relative hardiness over a wide extent of coun-
try, further discussion is deemed unnecessary, and the intelligent tree-
planter may be left to his own judgment in the selection of trees for his
groves.

(,»( ALITY OF THE LUMBER AND I'sKS.

Little need here be added to the mass of facts collected by Mr. Barney,
and which have already been presented to the public, to prove that this
lumber is possessed of great economic value, and yet it maybe well tore-
port some observations in support of the statements that have been made.

The wood of the catalpa is liurht. and yet sufficiently strong, and it i>
hard enough for most purposes of construction. It has been highly
approved for bridge-timbers where it was exposed to the weather; it has
been the favorite material for fence posts in a large tract of country; it
has been used, in the absence of stone, for the foundation supports of
buildings; it has been found an admirable material for covering -build-
ings as shingles, and it takes a good surface to receive a beautiful polish.

24

with a sufficiently varied grain or figure to make it a desirable wood for
the inside finish of our houses.

Dr. ,1. Schneck, the botanist of the Lower AVabash, writes, that though
the trees were formerly very abundant and sometimes very large, the
supply is now becoming exhausted, on account of its high repute for skiff
building and other purposes, especially for posts, it is in such demand
that it is carried to considerable distances, and very often stolen and
carried off by night. So in most of the Delta region that has been visited,
the trees which are accessible, have been nearly exhausted ; this is an
evidence of its high appreciation by the people.

On the St. Louis and Iron Mountain Railroad, a y>art of which runs
through this alluvial region, there is a section near Charleston, Missouri,
where a portion of the track was laid eleven years ago on catalpa cross-
ties, which are yet sound, while the oak ties near them have been twice
renewed. Some of the fence-posts along side the road, presumably of
oak, have already needed replacing.

Mr. David Axtel, the intelligent engineer, in charge of this part of the
road, reports that catalpa holds the spikes sufficiently well, and he said
that when the ties had suffered from mashing after 'this long use, they
were not rejected, but turned over so as to present a new bearing for
the rail. Some that had been thrown out by the trackmen were eagerly
appropriated by them as garden fence-posts where they bid fair to render
good service for many years.

Near New Madrid, in the same region, there are many fence-posts
which have stood and remained perfectly sound for long terms of years,
twenty, thirty and forty, or perhaps more, as their value has been known
since the settlement of the country. The story of the catalpa trees still
standing in the water where they were killed by the submergence of the
earthquake in 1811, which has been looked upon as a traveler's tale, may
now be fully confirmed by occular demonstration. In those lagoons
may yet be seen the broken shafts of noble trees that were then killed.
All other species of trees that were submerged by the same catastrophe
have crumbled with decay and have fallen into the water long years ago,
but these grim monuments of that event still remain as silent memorials
of the disturbance of level which caused their death — and there have
they stood defying the elements and resisting the tooth of time for nearly
three-fourths of a century, during which many of the finest have been
cut and removed for economic purposes.

The peculiar ligneous structure of the catalpa is too important to be
ignored, for though there be no sensible qualities in the wood to preserve
it from the attacks of insects and from decay, it is known to be very
durable and it must be possessed of some antiseptic properties that escape
the senses and remain to be detected by scientific investigations. There
is however a physical constitution that uin be noted by the common
observer; this consists in the remarkably small amount of alburnum or
sap-wood, that part of all trees which is most subject to decay. In these
lives the sap is reduced to the minimum, beinjr only one or at most two
layers of woody fiber, while all within -consists of duramen or heart-wood.

This fact makes the timber especially valuable for railway construction,
because a stick of twelve or more inches diameter, instead of beiny;
hewed into the usual shape, may be split or sawed into two ties, which
have the maximum extent of bearing for the rail, and, having only the
bark and a thin layer subject to decay, when laid with its convex surface
next the soil, the tie is in the best position for tamping.

There are many subordinate purposes to which this lumber may very
advantageously be applied. It will be particularly desirable for all situa-
tions where wood is to be used in contact with humidity in the soil — such
as wooden drains and culverts. It has been found verv durable when

25

used at? vine props; in the vineyard, and as stakes for supporting the
riders of our worm-fences. It will prove very valuable on account of
its durability, if used for the permanent label tallies of the nurserymen.
Add to this its lightness, and the thinnings after six years' growth may
be \vell utili/ed as poles in the Imp-yards.

PBOPAGATKWS

The multiplication of the tree is very easily accomplished. Though it
has been grown from cuttings and layers, the better mode is to sow the
seeds. The pods should be collected after the fall of the leaf, when suf-
ficiently dry, and before the seeds fall from the opening valves. They
should be stored in a dry place, and may very easily be threshed or
tramped out at any time during the winter, and the seed separated from
the piths'and shells. It must be secured from the mice.

The seeds should not be planted until the earth is warm and well pre-
pared. They may then be rather thinly strown in shallow drills, about
an inch or two apart, with sufficient intervening space, for cultivation be-
tween the rows; the covering of the see* Is should be light, from a quarter
to half an inch, according to the present and probable amount of mois-
ture in the seed-bed. They vegetate at once, and will need to be kept
clear of weeds and <rrass while small, but their broad foliage soon over-
comes all intruders.

The leaves fall with the tirst frost, and so soon as the tips have harden-
ed oh", it is well to take up the plants with a spade or with the small tree-
digger plow, and they are ready for storing in cellars, or they may be
snugly heeled-in out doors, unless immediately shipped or planted out in
their permanent stations. It is most desirable at this time to assort the
seedlings according to their si/e, so that all of equal vigor maybe planted
together and make an even growth in the grove.

PLANTATIONS.

Having made a propel' selection of The variety, no one need hesitate
attempting si plantation of the catalpa tree within the limits that have
been pointed out. Though in its native habitats the tree is found in the
richest bottom lands of our rivers, it seems to thrive equally well on the
uplands and on soils of very different texture and constitution, when
planted singly or in avenues, and, so far as we can yet judge from limited
observations in the artificial groves, which have been seen in very differ-
ent situations.

The question of grouping or mingling of species arises with this, as
with every other tree, nor have we yet had sufficient experience to de-
cide whether the catalpa should be massed alone or mingled with other
kinds, but the brief experience already had would induce a conclusion
in favor of the former plan. "Because of the rapid growth and of the
I") road foliage of these young trees, and perhaps because of their odor,
other trees do not thrive with them. Several experiments instituted
for a solution of this problem are now in progress, and seem to show that
most other species will die out when crowded among these, being unable
to compete successfully for air and light.

In the prairie countries, where this tree will be largely planted fora
supply of ties, posts, and other timber, land should be selected that is
deep and rich, and such as has already been in cultivation for one or
more crops. This should be well plowed in the fall, and may then at
once be planted, or left to lie fallow over winter. Where practicable, the
former course is recommended, as the soil is generally in better condition
then than in spring.
4

26

The planting is a simple affair; after the surface has been marked out
with furrows four feet apart, the little trees are dropped every three or
four feet, or at the intersections of the check-rows if the furrows cross ;
the planters follow at once with spades, setting them in the furrows and
tramping the mellow soil about the roots. As the rows are set a cne-
horse turning plow should follow to bank them up slightly.

In the fall-planting this furrow may be made -rat her heavy so as to pro-
tect the little plants during the winter from heaving by tlio frost. This
bank of earth needs to be harrowed down in the spring before the buds
have started, and this cultivation will destroy a multitude of weeds that
are springing from the soil. Cultivation should be continued at intervals
during the summer, so as to keep the ground clear and mellow, which
will also encourage the growth of the plants.

If some of the little trees be crooked or branched, be not concerned,
for, during the winter or very early in the following spring, they may all
be cut off together near the surface of the ground, to secure *a strong,
thrifty and even growth the next summer, when, if they have been well
cultivated up to July, the result will be most gratifying and encouraging.
There should be an even stand of sturdy trees, averaging not more than
four feet apart, and reaching a hight of five or six or more feet, covered
with broad foliage, so completely shading the ground that no further cul-
tivation will be needed, beyond cutting out a weed here and there during
the next season.

The after treatment will consist in the occasional cutting back of a tree
that may have been bent with the wind when wet, while the succulent
stem was soft before the deposit of woody fiber in the young shoots.

Owing to the peculiar arrangement of 'the leaves and their buds, the
natural habit of this plant is to throw out two or three shoots from the
top of the stem which will make a low-branched tree, and close planting-
is the more necessary to aid in preventing such a result. Occasionally it
may be advisable to cut back all but one for a leader, but when planted
sufficiently close the forces of nature will generally check and destroy
all superfluous growths, and produce tall, straight trees.

THINNING. — This may become necessary in the coming years; but,
"sufficient to the day.'"' In the limited experience and observation of
artificial groves, so far, this work appears to be in a fair way of being exe-
cuted by the forces of nature, without the necessity for human interfer-
ence.

INSECTS.

The almost universal testimony in regard to the catalpa tree, and often
cited in its favor by amateur cultivators, is that it is not troubled by in-
sects. These pests' have not been known to attack either the foliage or
the woody fiber of those which are cultivated in this latitude.

Wherever grown, the wood that has fallen under the writer's notice is
entirely free from all traces of injury or invasion by the larvae of beetles
or other insects.

But the fruit, particularly the pith of the pods, has been found dis-
organized and consequently the seeds were defective. This injury is
supposed to be caused by the larva of a small fly — species unknown.

In its native habitats, both western and southern, the foliage is eaten
to such an extent as to strip the trees at mid-summer. This is done by a
large greenish naked caterpillar. On all the southern streams this' is
known to the fishermen as the favorite bait for catching bream; one cor-
respondent described them as becoming six inches long at full growth.

Dr. J. Schneck, of Mt. Carmel, Illinois, cites the ravages of this cater-
pillar'as^one^reason why the tree has not been cultivated in that region,

It is quite common upon the trees about Vincennes, Indiana, and it
has migrated to those at Flora, Illinois forty -three miles west, where
eatalpas \\ere planted by Mr. L. B. Parsons, President of the Ohio and
Mississippi Railway, who was unwilling to have the trees ruined, and
destroyed the insects by applying Paris (Ireen and water with a garden
syringe.

After seeking for sometime in vain for information as to the scientific
classification of this insect, which is entirely unknown to our region, the
needful information was promptly supplied by Professor C. V. Riley,
United States Entomologist at Washington. District of Columbia, who
identified it as the Sjjftiiu: CataJpa, of Boisduval. He says it is one of the
most beautiful of the tribe.

The accounts of the Rooky Mountain Locusts' behavior when meeting
eatalpas on the plains, are quite contradictory, some correspondents de-
clare that the hoppers give this plant a wide berth, while others say that
they luxuriate upon the succulent leaves, and then eat the bark and
even the wood fiber of young plants.

Before concluding this report, it may be well to remind the reader that
pains have been taken to point out that we have in America two dis-
tinct catalpa trees, one of which appears to be peculiarly western, and
that it is possessed of qualities that especially adapt it to our use in form-
ing artificial groves for economical purposes. It is superior in its habit
and in its hardiness. The timber of one may be equally durable as that
of the other, and may resemble it in every particular, and yet the tree-
planter may ask which will be more available for his purpose, when he
undertakes to grow the trees for practical application in the arts.

Having distinctly set forth the differences that exist between them,
the writer leaves every one to make his own selection, but he desires to
impress upon the readers the propriety of their trying other trees in plan-
tations, also, and not to expect all excellence in any one kind. We have
a noble sylva, a rich inheritance of trees of many kinds, with properties
that adapt them to the various requirements of the arts of civilization,
and with characters and constitutions that adapt them to various soils,
climates and elevations. Some are peculiarly adapted to almost every
portion of our extended country.

Think not, that we, who have been so much interested in the catalpa,
and who have so warmly introduced it to you, would recommend you to
plant nothing else; far from it, we plant many kinds and we advise you.
and all others, to use your own good judgment in the selection of the
several kinds that may be, and such as are supposed to be, best adapted
to your own conditions.

Perhaps in the rich prairies of the west you may prefer to plant the
Cotton-woods, ftox-olders, White-willows, and similar trees of their class;
plant them, then, only plant trees; you will have the benefit of their
shade, shelter and fuel, and with these you have a preparation for more
extended sylviculture with a more extended range of varieties. In such
situations, you may feel assured that no trees will be likely to nuike
quicker returns nor of greater pecuniary value, than the one "which has
now been presented for your consideration — The Western or Hardy
Catalpa.

The greatest, the largest and most extensive plantations of forest trees
in our country must be made by the great railway corporations. Thev
will always need supplies for maintaining their lines; they can furnish
the necessary transportation from the several points of production to
those of consumption, and very many of them are at present the greatest
land holders. Surely ii is incumbent upon them to take a deep interest
in everything that relates to the subject of forestry, which will ere long

exert no small influence in the development of their immense domains,
all which will retro-act upon the interests of their business.

The managers of many of these corporations do seem to appreciate the
importance of tree-planting, and some have even begun operations along
their lines upon a scale commensurate (as initiative steps) to the great
interest involved, — in these noble efforts they are congratulated. The
liberality which has been extended toward one who has recently traveled
extensively in the investigation of the catalpa, is hereby thankfully ac-
knowledged— with the well-founded hope, however, that while he has
labored willingly and without expectation of reward, the favors of these
corporations will be amply repaid to them, if they do but put into prac-
tice the suggestions so freely offered by their friend.

Contributed by request of Mr. E. E. Barney, the disinterested patron of
a useful tree, by one who has long known it, who stood sponsor for it in
1853, and whose more intimate acquaintance only hightens his admira-
tion for its excellent qualities.

JOHN A. WARDER, M. D.,

Pretft Am. Forestry Association.
NORTH BEND, OHIO, Feb. 25, 1879.

INTERESTING LETTERS.

RALSTON STATION, TEN.V, Feb. 1st, 1879.
E. E. BARNEY, Dayton, O.,

Dear Sir: Your letter came duly to hand, and in reply would say that
time alone can tell how long the catalpa wood used here will last; posts
that were planted when the country was first settled, in 1810 to 1830, are
yet sound, and show no sign of decay. If there are two varieties, there
is but one here, at least I have never' seen but one kind — the black bark
variety, or Speciosa, as some call it. It grows abundantly*along the Obion
River, attaining a girth of sixty to ninety inches, and sixty to seventy-
five feet high. In open situations it does not grow so tall, but often
reaches the height of forty feet, with a clear trunk of twenty feet; among
other timber they will be clear of limbs three-fourths their height; have
never seen one but what would split straight, at least comparatively so.
Their peculiar habit is in rich river soil subject to overflow, but will grow
on our high ridge lands, and will make astonishing growth. I have a
specimen block from a tree fourteen years old, fourteen inches in diame-
ter. It is strictly a forest tree, and is used for posts almost exclusively.
All the finest specimens have long since been used up, but nearly every
stump has thrown up sprouts, some of them are now ten to twelve inches
in diameter, and forty to sixty feet high. During the month of July it is
attacked by a large black worm, perfectly harmless in its nature but a re-
pulsive looking creature. If the tree is isolated it will often be completely

29

denuded of foliage, but, along the river, often one-half the trees escape
their ravages entirely. Here people care nothing about cultivating the
catalpa, our ridge lands furnishing an abundance of first-class post oak.

But those living in the prairie States are greatly in their own light if
they do not plant extensively of the catalpa. Its growth is extremely
rapid, ami its durability is beyond question; and, when grown close to-
gether, ought to make the finest of timber trees. If one wants a shade
tree, there is none more beautiful ; if a post is wanted that will last for-
ever, and then turn to stone, the catalpa will come nearer filling the bill
than anything else.

Yours respectfully, F. P. HYNDS.

PORT LAV.U'A, CALHOI:X Co., TEXAS, Feb. 5, '79.
E. E. BARNEY :

Dear Sir: I planted the catalpa seed I received of you last of March,
very late for this latitude, still they grew from two to seven feet. I trans-
planted them in nine months, and yet the roots were so long, many of
them four to five feet, that I shall hereafter plant where I want the trees
to stand, and thin out while very young, and replant where I wish them
to stand. If I had let them remain till second year, I should have had a
hard job to remove them. I think the catalpa is just what we need here
where timber is so scarce. D. W. HATCH.

The Roadmaster of the Missouri River, Fort Scott tfr Gulf
R. R. makes the following report of trees planted; report dated

October 14, IS?*:

During November, 1S77, the following varieties were set out:

Catalpas, :'» years old, 150 set out. Now living, 150; are looking well,
but have made small growth.

Catalpas, J year old. 2,928 set out, — 2, 700 living; have grown 3 to 4 feet
and look thrifty.

Blaek walnut, L'.x:><) set out; l,(iOO living; look sickly and have made
slow progress.

Chestnut, 2,050 set out, 1,214 living; look badly.

Cherry, 1,000 set out; BOO living; do not look well; have grown but
little.

White ash, 15,000 set out ; 9,472 living; have grown 6 inches, but do not
look thrifty.

DFRIXG 1S7S.

Box elder, 2 years old, 1,012 set out; 944 living; have grown 12 inches.

White walnut, 2 years old, 1,010 set out; 791 living; growth 2 inches;
not looking well.

Catalpa, 2 years old, 2,600 set out; 2,449 living; have grown on an
average ."> feet ; look well.

Catalpas, 1 year old, S,:>55 set out; 8,100 living; have grown on an aver-
age 2J feet; look thrifty.

Pecan, yearlings, 1,000 set out; <>41 living; have grown f> inches; look
well.

Osage orange, yearlings, 18,000 set out; 18,100 living; have grown ti
inches and look well.

F.vergreens, 410 set out; 50 black spruce living; grown 5 inches; look-
ing well.

no

A hedge <>f Osage orange \vas planted around the entire section, and is
doing well.

The catalpas have made the greatest improvement, especially the year-
lings, and in my judgment it is economy in time and expense to plant
none older than one year. The Qsage orange tree does very well in this
climate, but is of slow growth.

I planted seeds enough last Spring to grow 30,000 plants; 5,000 came to
maturity, and have grown from one to four feet.

European larch all dead; do not think they will prosper in this climate.

The box elders look well, but I do not know that they are of much
value when grown.

The catalpa has certainly proved to be the strongest grower and most
tenacious, standing the dry weather better than other varieties, and at
present rate will come to maturity years before other varieties are of suf-
ficient size to be of any utility.

The evergreens planted were too large, being 3 to 4 feet high, and the
wind having such pressure on the large foliage, caused them to become
loose in the ground, which allowed the air to circulate around the roots,
thereby killing them.

A limited number of ornamental trees would be desirable, and I think
if very small ones were set out they would thrive.

(Signed) J. M. BUCKLEY, R. M.

George H. Nettleton, Receiver of the road, writes that in
November last, 128,000 more trees, purchased by the president
of tbe road, were being planted ; of these, 100,000 were catalpa,
of the early blooming, Speciosa, or hardy variety.

CATALPA IN ICE.

A correspondent of the Prairie Farmer, writing from Stillson, Cherokee
County, Kansas, says that region has been visited by a severe storm that
loaded' all the trees with ice. Many trees and shrubs, too tender to
"stand the pressure," broke beneath 'the enormous weight of ice. "In
the forests," says the writer, "the Lombardy poplars arid the cotton
woods suffered the most; they are badly broken. The ground is well
strewn with their tops and branches. The maples being more elastic,
would bend without breaking. Some of them, twenty feet high, bent
until* their tops touched the ground. A row of Lombardy poplars along
the road-side were so stripped of their branches and tops that they looked
more like telegraph poles than trees. The catalpa seemed to be the only
tree that escaped the injury. The weight of ice seemed to have no effect
on them. They neither break nor bend, in my forest, where they have
grown tall and 'straight; they stand perfectly upright, while the trees all
around them are bent or broken. The power to stand up under such a
great weight of ice is another thing that will recommend them as a tim-
ber tree."

The following letter from 1). Axtell, Sup't of the Missouri
Division of the St. Louis, Iron Mountain cv; Southern Railway,
is of much interest :

CHARLKSTOX, Mo., Ffh. /,', '79.
E. E. BARNEY:

Dear N/'r: There is nothing to indicate that the catalpa tics in our
track, near Charleston, Mo., do not hold spikes sufficiently well. Nearly
all the spikes are in the same holes originally made when driving them,

31

over ten years ago. There has been no spreading of the track. I have
examined the fe\v ties the rails have settled into, and find none that will
not last for a number of years yet by turning them over. These ties are
six to eight inches face. ' If they were wider, as you suggest, there would
he more resistance to crushing.' With the joint fastenings now in use, I
see no objections to making ties, as you propose, from logs twelve inches
or more in diameter, by sawing them through the middle ami placing the
round side do\vn. The bearing surface would thus be increased 50 to 100
per cent.

The section of catalpa log* sent you was from a tree lying on the ground
in a swam]), on a place owned by Mr. Henson, seven miles from Charles-
ton. Mr. II. says when he moved on the place forty years ago, the tree
was lying on the ground and looked as old as it does now. He says it
must have then been lying there at least ten years, and probably very
much longer.

Mr. Henson recently made three hundred and thirty fence posts from
one catalpa tree. He also got some good split posts from eatalpa trees six
years old. Yours respectfully,

I). AXTELL.

The following letter from the Chicago Tribmir of May 21st,
1878, should be carefully read and seriously pondered by all
who regard the future welfare of our country. Every farmer
who has even forty acres of land may do something, by tree
planting, to avert the impending calamity so graphically de-
scribed :

POREST-V ANIMALISM.

OUR DEVASTATED WOODLANDS — A CANADIAN MERCHANT ON THE UNITED
STATES TIM HER Sri'i-Lv— VAST FORESTS WANTONLY DESTROYED.

The subjoined letter wns received by the Hon. David A. Wells recently
fn>m Mr. James 1/ttle, a prominent lumber merchant of Montreal. Mr.
Little has investigated the lumber-producing regions of the United States,
and he sets forth the result of his investigation with clearness and candor.
The result as far as the older States are concerned is startling. Already
there are only four States among the twenty-six North of the old slim?
line and Kast of the Rocky Mountains whose forests are capable of sup-
plying lumber enough for transportation beyond the State limits. Mr.
Little goes over the ground thoroughly in his letter, which should com-
mend itself for its eomlmied terseness and comprehensiveness, and for
the vital importance of its subject to all legislators and public-spirited
citizens:

MOXTUKAI.. Mnii in. 7,s7,v.
Tin-: llox. DAVID A. WKI.I.S:

N/V: 'Hie deeji interrst you are known to take in the subject of politi-
cal economy and the freedom of trade induces me to bring under your
notice what is, beyond dispute, the most important question in relation

'"This section of acatnlpu l<>i:. now in my office, is perfectly sound, showing no signs
of decay, though it has Uud oij the ground certainly fifty years, possibly one hundred.

32

to the industries, necessities, and well-being of your people that has ever
been presented for their consideration, namely, the question of the tim
ber supply and consumption of the country, — a matter in which every
individual, high and low, rich and poor, of your forty millions of people
is interested. Being engaged in lumbering* — a business 1 have, followed
for close on half a century, mainly with the United States, — and witness-
ing as I did how rapidly one extensive timber section after another in
Western Ontario, where I operated, was stripped of its commercial woods,
my attention was necessarily drawn to an investigation of the sources
and extent of the supply to meet the ever-increasing consumption of both
the United States and Canada. I now proceed to give the result of mv
researches in relation thereto, so far as the United States are concerned,
as briefly as the subject will admit.

I find of the twenty-six States comprising the New England, the Mid-
dle, the Western, and Northwestern to the Rocky Mountains, only four,
namely, Maine, Michigan, Wisconsin, and Minnesota, are now able to
furnish supplies beyond their own requirements, and I will now point
out the condition these States are reduced to touching their supply of
building-timber, and how long they may be expected To stand the drain
on their forests, at the rate of consumption going on, of this indispensable
material. The State of Maine, which not long since could boast of most
extensive pine forests, is now all hut stripped of that valuable wood, and
is besides so far denuded of its once-supposed inexhaustible supply of
spruce that the lumberers are forced to the headwaters and tributaries
of every river in the State to hunt for supplies, and are stocking their
mills in a large measure with logs cut from sapling poles of from six to
eight inches in diameter, and this reckless and wasteful slaughtering is
carried on to such an extent to supply the neighboring States, and for
shipment abroad, that a few years will find the people of that State with-
out building timber, either pine or spruce, for their home consumption .
The Northern sections of Michigan, Wisconsin, and Minnesota are the
only localities of the whole twenty-six States that are able to furnish sup-
plies of white pine beyond the wants of their own respective States, and
the demand on them" is so heavy for all sections of the country that it
will not be possible for them to respond to it for more than six or seven
years longer. Their main streams are all stripped, and the lumberers
are now operating at the head waters of their tributaries, where they are
forced to bank many of their logs in dry gullies, depending on theVin-
ter's snow and spring rains to produce freshets sufficient to float them to
the main streams, and which often fail, as will be the case with many of
them this season, for want of water to move them from where the loggers
have hauled them. A number of railways have also been built to secure
the lumber traffic of these timber sections; no less than six are now run-
ning through every patch of timber otherwise inaccessible to the loggers
on the lower peninsula of Michigan, hitherto the greatest lumber-supply-
ing State of the Union, and the mill-owners themselves having, many of
them, exhausted their timber within team-hauling distance, are busy at
work building railways on their own account to enable them to reach
what are now the outskirts of their once supposed inexhaustible timber
resources. And here in these timber sections, and in the positions I have
pointed out, is to be found the whole white pine supply for the consump-
tion of your whole country East of the Pacific slope, aiid, were the whole
of that supply brought to one point, it could all be covered with the palm
of one's hand on any ordinary map of the United States; and yet, not-
withstanding this state of the case, the lumberers keep slaughtering
away as if life depended on how soon they could rob the country of its
timber wealth and bring about a timber famine, to the utter ruin of the
wood industries of the countrv, in which everv member of the com-

33

immity is deeply interested. Not satisfied with the huvoc they an- mak-
ing to keep their own markets continually largely overstocked, they have
also made extensive preparations by fitting up their mills for the manu-
facture of deals, to drive, as their lumber papers boast, they will, the
Canadian supply out of the Ihitish markets, and they are besides at work
using up the best of their white pine in the manufacture of boardwood
and square timber for the same markets, a course most destructive to the
forests. In fact, lighting the candle at both ends would fail to fitly de-
scribe the utter recklessness and folly of their proceedings, — they are-
casting it bodily into the fire.

We have theories and speculations on the forests as influencing the
rain-fall, and their value as reservoirs to keep up a supply of water for
your rivers, water-courses, and canals, and afford power for machinery,
but who has given consideration to the consequences to your whole
country of a dearth of timber? Who of your statesmen has given his
mind to think on its effects on the 173,450 industrial establishments, and
the 1,093,202 operatives, who, as shown by your census returns, as far
back as 1870, are engaged therein, providing your people with the finished
wood materials so indispensable to their well being? Who of the dele-
gations from the Northwestern timber sections, that are now praying
Congress to prevent Canada from giving any assistance to prolong the
life of these industries, has taken into account the consequences of a
failure in their timber supply on the settlement of your boundless, tree-
less prairie country, or the deprivations it will entail on its inhabitants,
and the millions who are to make it their home? Who of your whole
people has given himself the trouble to understand that it would require
you to raise $500,000,000 to send abroad to purchase an amount of lum-
ber equal to your present consumption for a single year, or that all the
tonnage of the whole world would fall far short of being able to freight
it from your Pacific Territories to your Atlantic seaboard? The aggre-
gated freighting capacity of the world is only about 18,000,000 of tons,
while the 12, 755,000,000* feet of lumber shown by your census returns of
1870 to have been sawn in 1869 would make a tonnage of 21,000,000, from
which it will be seen that, without taking into account the thousands of
millions of shingles and the millions of feet of timber consumed at the
same time, there is not tonnage enough in existence to freight that single
item of sawn lumber alone around Cape Horn, and how inadequate it
would be to meet the shipping requirements for the whole consumption
of all kinds of building timber and wood for other industrial purposes of
the present day, and how much more so by the time your present stock
is exhausted, with so many more millions of consumers to be supplied.
And what have your authorities been doing to meet this state of things?
Have' they been making provision to keep up the supply by tree-plant-
ing, as in Northern Europe? Have they been husbanding their forest
wealth and preserving it from spoil and waste1? On the contrary, have
they not been prodigal in their efforts to get rid of it by making presents
of it to corporations and disposing of it for a trifle of its value to indi-
vidual speculators— one of whom, in the West, boasting that he owns
three-fifths of the, cork pine in Michigan, Wisconsin, and Minnesota, and
another in the East, claiming to blithe owner of over 500,000 acres of
land selected for its timber value? Have they not been standing quietly
by looking on at the extensive robberies committed on the public domain
that have been carried on for years in the South and Northwest, by which
not only the home-markets have been kept largely overstocked, to the
injury of all legitimate operators, but the foreign markets as well have
been kept glutted to Mich an extent that even the plunderers themselves
received nothing for the timber, and but little for tin,' labor expended in
preparing it for market? And have they not. for the sole benefit of these.

5

34

•corporations and speculators, and to the injury of every other individual
of the community, been forcing Canada to find markets abroad for her
timber and lumber by the imposition of duties? And are they not even
now, with the present condition of things staring them in the face, pre-
paring a tariff in which the same obstructions are to be continued to pre-
vent this country from giving assistance to mitigate or protract to any
^extent the impending deluge so soon to sweep over your whole country ?

From the utter indifference and neglect with which this momentous
question of the supply and consumption of timber is treated by your
people, it might be supposed you could dispense altogether with its use,
or that you could reproduce it as easily as raising a crop, or that you
would have no difficulty in finding a substitute, but it takes a century to
grow a standard pine saw-log, and if there is a country on earth in a po-
sition to do without or find a substitute for timber, that country is Great
Britain, and yet she increased her wood consumption at an average rate
of 10 per cent, a year for the last ten years, and last year, as shown by
her trade returns, it-was :*>! per cent, more than in 1875, and the import
of that island, not half the area of your State of Texas, and being, as it
were, thoroughly finished up throughout its whole extent, showing no
further room for improvements, amounted to no less than $100,000,000.
But large as that sum is, it is comparatively small to what the United
States will soon yearly be called on to supply for its own wood consump-
tion, and it is not a luxury that can be thrown aside at will ; it is indis-
pensable to the national well-being.

I know that the impression prevails, and it is often stated by interested
parties, that it matters little what is the condition of your supplies, as
you have but to look to Canada, where can be found "enough for the
most exacting populations of the world for centuries," which is the state-
ment usually made by those utterly ignorant of its true condition, or
those who do so for a purpose ; and I will here assert from a personal
knowledge of most of the timber sections of Canada, and trustworthy
reports from others, that we nave not, from the far-off Province of Mani-
toba to the Gulf of St. Lawrence, as much pine, spruce, hemlock, oak,
;ash, elm, whitewood, and other commercial woods as would supply the
whole consumption of the United States for a period of three years, and
the whole accessible pine localities have besides been run over to such
an extent for such pine and board wood timber as would pay to ship,
that many of our lumberers have been forced to seek for these descrip-
tions of wood goods to supply the English demand in your Northwestern
timber territories, where they may now be found cutting down on an
average three trees to get one stick, and leaving the others, from some
trifling defect, to rot in the woods, — a waste of this valuable material that
you can ill afford. I will further venture the prediction that the near
future will reveal such a state of things in regard to the timber question
as will bring your Government fully to realize it would have been a wise
policy on its part to have paid a bonus for the importation of our lumber,
if by such means it could have been saved for the use of your people,
than the course it has adopted in driving it away to foreign markets by
the imposition of duties to any amount.

The first of the timber famine Avill begin to be felt in the next three or
four years, and will be fully reached throughout the Eastern, Middle,
Western, and Northwestern States in the short period of six _or seven
years, if the present wasteful course is kept up; and when the pitch pine
of the South, a description of wood unsuited for many purposes, is called
on to supply the whole consumption, all the building and saw-log timber
from the Eastern boundary of Maine to the Rocky Mountains and the
Gulf of Mexico will be swept away in as short a time as has passed since

35

the close of the war with the South, — a mere moment in the future of
your country.

I have, sir, here. endeavored to give you some idea of the slate and ex-
tent of your timber resources, and the ruinous consequences sure to fol-
low and he felt throughout the length and breadth of your entire country
when a failure in the supply which a few short years will bring about is
reached. ;md nm, sir. Respectfully Yours,

JAMES IJTTLK.

I do not think Mr. Little at all overestimates the annual
consumption of lumber or the rapidity with which our country
is being denuded of its forests, or the impending calamity
resulting therefrom, if no means are taken to avert it. The
annual consumption of my own manufactory is over 10,000,000
feet, and it is but one, and by no means the largest of the
175,000 referred to by him, over our whole country, as consum-
ing our forests all the day long and all the year round, that
have been the growth of the last 100 to 500 years.

One means of averting this calamity is the extensive yearly
planting of well selected forest trees. 1 have urged the culti-
vation of eatalpa, believing it will give the largest return in
the shortest time. Its economic uses are more varied and
•extensive than any one tree with which I am acquainted.

Ff I had a grove of common catalpa that would not be affect* >d
by the frost, I should certainly let them grow. If I wished to
plant a grove of catalpa, above or below the frost line, I would
most certainly plant only the Speciosa variety, as clearly
better adapted to forest culture.

1 by no means ignore the fact that there are other valuable
trees for forest culture — notably the white walnut or butternut,
black walnut, yellow locust, red and black mulberry, Osage
orange, ailanthus, cherry, ash, oak, and many others, of the
respective merits of which I leave others to speak.

At the time I printed my first pamphlet I was under the
impression that the examples of durability given were mostly,
if not wholly, common catalpa. As it became more and more
apparent, on further investigation, that the Speciosa variety
was much preferable lor forest planting, I felt it to be of the
greatest importance to know, beyond any question, that this
variety was equally durable.

I therefore arranged with Mr. .Jno. ('. Teas, of Carthage. Mo.,
a horticulturist who had been familiar with the common and
Speciosa variety for thirty years, to visit those localities in
the West where the catalpa was known to be indiginous, and
make a thorough investigation as to the durability of the
Speciosa and all other matters of interest pertaining thereto,
lie obtained much valuable information; the full report of
which, sickness, 1 regret to say, has prevented his preparing
in time for this pamphlet. His letters establish beyond any

question the durability of the Speciosa variety. Indeed all
the numerous examples of durability were found to be all
Speciosa, and that it was the only variety found m the forests
of Illinois, Missouri and Arkansas.

December 2, '78, he writes from New Madrid: "Two import-
ant facts are clearly established, viz. : that the speciosa eatalpa
grows wild, or native, in its pure and perfect distinctiveness,
at various points along the Mississippi River, -not to speak of
other localities not yet explored; and secondly, that its timber
possesses the wonderful durability tor which the eatalpa lias
become so noted. Just now a new idea occurs to me. May it
not be possible that the eatalpa growing east and south-east
are what we call common, and all the wild ones West speciosa?

"As the trees in cultivation have nearly all been distributed
by the nurseries, or grown from seed of trees so distributed,
and as in nursery work, as in other matters, it is ' westward
the star of empire,' &c.,.it is hardly to be wondered at that
the eastern variety should have covered the east half of the
continent before the difference and great superiority of the
western was recognized."

The more I thought of the matter, the more its importance
grew upon me, and I felt so important a question should be
established by the testimony of at least two unimpeachable
witnesses. I therefore also arranged with Dr. Jno. A. Warder,
'President of the American Forestry Association, — and who, in
1853, had, with Mr. Teas, christened this variety Speciosa, —
to make a full investigation of the same Subject. The rail-
roads, deeming the matter of sufficient public importance,
promptly furnished passes to both.

Dr. Warder's investigations confirm Mr. Teas' in every par-
ticular as to durability of the Speciosa, and establishes the
fact that it is the only variety of eatalpa native to the forests,
also of Indiana, Western Kentucky and Tennessee, as well an
Illinois, Missouri and Arkansas; and that it is unmistakably
a western tree, having clearly denned and well marked char-
acteristics that are uniformly transmitted in the seed.

His report, condensed for this pamphlet, from a much fuller
and more elaborate one, will be found on page 17.

The facts that seem to be so clearly established by Mr. Teas
and Dr. Warder's investigations are exceedingly important
and interesting to the botanist and the practical forest tree-
planter, and richly pay for all the time and money expended
in obtaining them, and the gratitude of the whole country is
due the two indefatigable workers who, through great labor
and much personal discomfort, have obtained them.

If what I have printed shall incite to an increased interest
in forest tree-planting, I shall be amply remunerated for all
time and money expended. E. E. B.

14 DAY USE ^

RETURN TO DESK FROM WHICH BORROWS

-

Renewed books are subject to

JME27 1976

fcUE EHD & fcpfcWEfc

•JJB JBCT

LD 21-32m-3,'74
(R7057slO)476— A-32

General Library .
University of California
Berkeley

236842