ROR THE, PEOPLE FOR EDYCATION FOR SCIENCE LIBRARY OF THE AMERICAN MUSEUM OF NATURAL HISTORY A.M ; ss Seo , y 7% i — - ae Cees “America,” I heard a voice complain, “The first-born children of your broad domain, The nurselings of your prairies vast and broad, Look to them—they were given you of God, And what He gives He will not give again.” —JoHn Hatt WHEELOCK. ANNUAL KEEOR T OF ELE AMERICAN BISON SO Ciba y EGOS Oo) OBJECT: THE PERMANENT PRESERVATION AND INCREASE OF THE AMERICAN BISON PuBLISHED BY THE SOCIETY 1908 a j = yes Vis \\ ifr LEN i ' / \ CopyrRIGHT 1908 BY , aoe THE AMERICAN BISON SOCIETY. : i: t : . F oh, 281% Morel A, | ne wee } * ti CONTE NLS @PBICER SANDE WINAINIA GER Stace teccstiattay meee etter nace or irae aed een ed eye Ot VII HISTORY AND PROCEEDINGS OF THE SOCIETY........ ErNEst Harotp BAYNES 1 REPORT ORME URE ASURER sey cuca serine ten eae ciate ce ieiierre CLARK WILLIAMS 14 REPORT Ole PLATHEAD, BUFFALO RANGE... . oatcacesceo seas vous nee Me Jo BERopi 15 a eee W. T. Hornapay 55 Gensus oF Ilivinc AMERICAN BISON... .5.........'.....+. W. L. HORNADAY 71: NOTES ON THE CENSUS.......... OME es Ey. ieler mak Wil ei CONSTITUTION (OF THE ISOGINT Ys ooo co os ects Scns oe As Fess ko nn te nD TET SANOR Ae VI NCBER SR gennrrn | hit Avot caw aegis RRA i GN ae A aoe tn coat 81 Etst OF ILLUSTRATIONS AMERICAN BISON (IN COLORS)..............3y SC +C¢—=7C7MMMy Vrontispiece THE KING oF THE CORBIN HERD. .:0:.-0:. 42... - Photo by E. H. Baynes VIII BIRD’SEYE VIEW OF THE PROPOSED RANGE.............. Photo by M.J. Elrod 16 VIEW OF THE WANGE FROM THE) HAST. oc... ssc. o6. ae a 5 18 (tem, WiTSSTON, -MOUNTATING: 2 o-mceacee. oasnccu. cae - is ri 20 THE SOUTHERN PORTION OF THE RANGE.............-. + 5 24 SOUTHERN FRONT OF THE RANGE (1)................. + of 26 SOUTHERN FRONT OF THE RANGE (2).................- “ : 28 ON-THE SUMMIT On RHE WANGES =./ccoume secs ee. e - e 30 WATE Wid STUER g8)O CK OM VAATEME Yi w tep-tertstnees s/t seen tava 2 i 32 THE JocKko VALLEY AND JUNCTION WITH THE FLATHEAD, i is 34 AM EHD OCHO) IRUNVDIY ASU NUS Aan ea osog ae aaes aos oe 5 a 36 RAVAETICAND MBE \OGKON VIALEEY.... sales oe aan eae: ee) . iM 38 ARETE ya OGIKOMVEAT eR yaRACD URCAV AUST Ieecrs eraveareieteie cierto areces ‘ 2 40 EASTERN SIDE OF THE PROPOSED RANGE.............. ¥ re 42 A PorTION OF THE PABLO HERD ON THE RANGE........ os oe 45 Tur PABLO HERD READY FOR SHIPMENT..:..::......- ti i 48 inp CHuir Ane ZOOLOGIGAT, PARKS ..-mc se cisc-5 Photo by E. R. Sanborn 54 THE BISON ON THE WAGONS AT CACHE............ a = 58 SPRAYING A BISON WITH CRUDE PETROLEUM........ * fi 60 PorTION OF A CORRAL, SHOWING A SHELTER SHED.. cs 5s 60 THE CorRRALS AND SHEDS OF THE WICHITA HERD.... 3 is 63 CoMANCHE INDIANS VISITING THE BISON.......... = 60 SupposepD REMAINS OF CHIEF PouNbD-MAKER’s LAST BIGs BISON MSE NUGEMDER' cies donee eieiciee extent ai a 4 70 MAPS OS chin ee ROROSED ISON PECAINGE Ady EMAWAIEIS se secle crne aise re aia eletametel vane eictenen ce Ee ETE IE OATELE AID) ENED TAIN IMESERWACETOINN elenese cicter ie coaiccl clei acre ale arersiemete etememens 21 OFFICERS OF Tar AMERICAN BISON SOCIETY 1908-1909 Hon. President, Hon. -THEODORE ROOSEVELT, President of the United States. Hon. Vice-President, His Excellency EARL GREY, Governor-General of Canada. President, WILLIAM T. HORNADAY, Director New York Zoological Park. A. A. ANDERSON, President of the Camp-fire Club of America. Prof. FRANKLIN W. HOOPER, Director of Brooklyn Institute Arts and Sciences. Secretary, ERNEST HAROLD BAYNES, “Sunset Ridge,’ Meriden, N. H. Treasurer, CLARK WILLIAMS, Columbia Trust Company, New York. BOARD OF MANAGERS Vice-Presidents, AAG ANDERSON! 2 a. ™ . . . . 80 West 40th Street, New York ERNEST HAROLD BAYNES wd yt aie i » =. Meriden; N.H: HERBERT L. BRIDGMAN. Sec’y Peary mace Club, Brooklyn, N. Y. Dr. H. C. BUMPUS . . Director American Museum of Natural History Dr. CHARLES B. DAVENPORT, Director Biological Station, Carnegie Institution, Cold Spring Harbor, L. I. Prof. MORTON J. ELROD . . University of Montana, Missoula, Mont. MADISON GRANT. .°. . . Secretary New York Zoological Society Prof. FRANKLIN W. HOOPER, Director of Bklyn. Inst. Arts and Sciences Dr. WILLIAM T. HORNADAY . .. Director New York Zoological Park CA TONES A sn / Us 4. & Topeka; Kansas Prof. DAVID STARR JORD ANS : Paland Stiitord University, California FREDERIC H. KENNARD .. . ._. 220 Devonshire Street, Boston FREDERIC A. LUCAS, Curator of Museum, Bklyn. Inst. Arts and Sciences Prof. HENRY F. OSBORN .. . . . Columbia University, New York Drs SS) PALMER 2»... Brolocicaly Survey, Washington;. Di. G: Commander ROBERT FE, PEARY, U; S, N. =. . . Washington, D; C. A. BOWEN PERRY, Commissioner Royal N W. Mounted Police, Regina, Canada JOLIN IVES PEEPS ses 9 5. 2 we eeeeen Jane Street) Rittshure sas GIEFORD:PINCHOT = i. «72 3 @. {Forester Washington, D.C. EDMUNDS SEY MOUIR 3. .. 4.5.0. 3s. 2 =45. Wall Street; NewYork FURR YS Wiese 5. ee er Worcester, Mass: Cy EY SLONEPBREDGE ye. Lasth Street faad Third Ave., New York City ORUNG EMEA Rs . . . 50 State Street, Boston, Mass. WILLIAM LYMAN UNDERW oop, Massachusetts Institute of Technology, Boston, Mass. Hon, JAMES S. WHIPPLE, N. Y. State Forest, Fish and Game Commissioner, Albany, N. Y. CLARK WILLIAMS... Care of Columbia Trust Company, New York Prof. CALVIN M. WOODWARD . Washington University, St. Louis, Mo. ‘dauH NIGdOD WHL AO ONIN FHL Pip LORY AND PROCEEDINGS, OF CEE SOCLE LY: HE national movement now on foot for the perma- nent preservation of the Buffalo began in June, rgo4, when Mr. Ernest Harold Baynes went to live on the border of the Corbin Game Preserve in New Hampshire, which for many years has been the home of one of the largest herds of Buffalo in the world. ‘The sight of these splendid creatures made a deep impression on Mr. Baynes, and excited his interest in the fate of their race, then in great danger of: becoming extinct.. He sought to- create public interest in the matter by a series of articles printed in the Boston “Transcript” that summer, and in August was aroused to greater activity by a letter written by Hon. William .;Chandler-and addressed to Hon. James Woalson, secretary yor veticulture: Im’ this letter Mr. Chandler called the attention of the United States Govern- ment to the fact that, while the owners of the preserve desired to carry out as far as possible the intention of the rounder, the late> Austin ‘Corbin, and “preserve the Buffaloes, the ever-increasing expense of maintaining so large a herd (then numbering 160 head) was already too Creatatou bey home by a private tamily. Mir. Chandler intimated that unless the Government was sufficiently interested in) the matter to provide for)or take other “Steps. wo preserve- them: permanently, ~ 1t might be necessary to dispose of them elsewhere. Early in the fall Mr. Baynes visited Prof. Franklin W. Hooper, Director of the Brooklyn Institute of Arts and Sciences, at his home in Walpole, N. H., and with him discussed the possibility of arousing wide public interest in the Buffalo. At Professor Hooper’s suggestion, letters were written to many prominent persons, including President Roosevelt, urging them to interest themselves in the fate of the vanishing Bison. President Roosevelt took immediate and active interest in the subject, as is evidenced by the following letter :— 1 White House, Washington. OYSTER BAY,.N... Y., Sept. 16, 1904: Personal. My dear Mr. Baynes :— I am much impressed with your letter, and I agree with every word you say. I remember you well. I have written Secretary Wilson, sending him your Jetter and requesting him to take the matter up with me, and [I shall treat of 1t in my annual message. With great regard, Sincerely yours, THEODORE ROOSEVELT. Mr. Ernest Harold Baynes, Cornish: lat, Ni. El. Then followed a series of some forty articles on the Buffalo, some illustrated and published in the magazines, but most of them syndicated and printed simultaneously in about twenty of the leading newspapers in different parts of the country. ‘The press was sympathetic and generous, and these articles were the subjects of many editorials favorable to the cause of Bison preservation. On Jan. 18, 1905, Mr. Baynes delivered before the Boston Society of Natural History an illustrated lecture entitled ““The American Buffalo—A Plea for His Preser- vation.” On the day after the lecture several gentlemen who had become interested met informally and discussed plans for the organization of a society which should have for its object the preservation of the Buffalo. Most of those present are now members of the American Bison Society, and some of them are among its most active workers. The above lecture was repeated before the Brooklyn Institute of Arts and Sciences, the Camp-Fire Club of America, the Harvard Travelers’ Club, the Boone and Crockett Club, and many other organizations. At the Camp-Fire Club Mr. Baynes talked over with its Presi- dent, Mr. William T. Hornaday, the advisability of organizing the proposed society, and Mr. Hornaday agreed that if the society were organized he would accept its presidency. Later, President Roosevelt was invited to 9 4 become the Tlonorary President, and, on his acceptance, arrangements were made for organization. A meeting was called for the 8th of December, 1905, and notices were sent to about two hundred persons known to be interested in the fate of the Buffalo. Of these, four- teen assembled in the Lion House of the New York Zoo- logical Park, and organized The American Bison Society. These fourteen persons were :— AA Anderson, 80 West 40th St., New York. Robert C. Auld, New York City. Einest Elarold Baynes, Meriden, N.-H.- Edward Cave, Editor of “Field and Stream,” New York City. Prof. Franklin W. Hooper, Director of the Brooklyn Institute of Arts and Sciences. William “2, Horaday, Director of the’ New York Zoological Park. Frederic H. Kennard, 220 Devonshire St., Boston, Mass. Francis Piper, Arlington Heights, Mass. Mrs. Francis Piper, Arlington Heights, Mass. Harry V. Radford, Editor of ““Woods and Waters,” New York City. Martin Schenck, Chief Engineer Department of Parks, Borough of the Bronx, New York. Gi ©! Shields, “Editor of Shields’ Niagazine, New York City. : C. H. Stonebridge, 148th St. and Third Ave., New York City: Charless-E.”) Rownsend, Wirector of the New York Aquarium. When the meeting was called to order, Messrs. Hornaday and Baynes were elected temporary chairman and temporary secretary respectively. A nominating com- mittee appointed by the chair, presented a report, and the following persons were elected officers of the Society: Honorary President, Hon. Theodore Roosevelt; President, William T. Hornaday; Vice-Presidents, A. A. Anderson and Dr. Charles S. Minot; Secretary, Ernest Harold Baynes, and Treasurer, Edmund Seymour. 3 An Advisory Board was elected, consisting of the following persons: Prof. Franklin W. Hooper, Prof. David Starr jordan, Prot, Viortons). Eliod) Prot, 1. 1: Dyche, Prof. John H. Gerold, William Lyman Under- wood, Madison Grant, Ernest ‘Thompson Seton and Frederic TH. Kennard, The President was empowered to appoint an Executive Committee of seven men, to include the President and Secretary. He appointed Messrs. Frederic H. Kennard and William Lyman Underwood, of Boston; Madison Grant and W. T. Hornaday, of New York; Mr. Gifford Pinchot and Dr. T.S. Palmer, of Washington, D. C., and FE. 1 Baynes: The Executive Committee was instructed to draft a Constitution. Professor Hooper suggested that since there were several herds of Buffalo in Canada, including the only wild herd of any size in existence, the Canadians would doubtless be much interested in the Society, and should be invited to join hands with the people of the United States in this effort to preserve an animal common to both countries. He moved that the Premier of Canada be invited to hold office in the Society, and accepted Mr. Radford’s amendment that the invitation be extended to the Governor-General of Canada also. SPECIAL MEEDINGOFR THE SOCIETY. A special meeting of the American Bison Society was held at the New York Zoological Park, in the office of Director W. 'T. Hornaday, on the 2d of February, 1906. President Hornaday was in the chair. Others present were Prof. Franklin W. Hooper, C. J. Jones (‘‘Buffalo” Jones), Dr... 5S. Palmer, Puederie Ti: hennard, and 4rnest Harold Baynes. The Secretary read many letters concerning the preser- vation of the Buffalo from well-known authorities in different parts of the country. ‘These letters were written in answer to a series of questions recently sent out by Mr. Hornaday, and the correspondents agreed that it was possible to save the Buffalo from extinction, and that the only sure way to accomplish its preservation was by estab- 4 lishing a number of buffalo herds in widely-separated parts of the country. At this meeting the Constitution was adopted and, in accordance with its provisions, the following Board of Managers was elected :— For two years.—A. A. Anderson, Ernest Harold Baynes, Franklin W. Hooper, W. T. Hornaday, Frederic He Kennard, Charles S$. Minot, T..S. Palmer, Gifford Pinchot and Edmund Seymour. For one year.—L. L. Dyche, Morton J. Elrod, John El Gerould, Madison Grant,’C. |; Jones, David Starr Jordan, A. Bowen Perry, Ernest Thompson Seton and William Lyman Underwood. A. Bowen Perry, Esq., of Regina, Canada, is Commis- sioner of Royal Northwest Mounted Police, and his name was sent to the Secretary by His Excellency, Earl Grey, Governor-General of Canada, who had been requested to suggest a Canadian to serve on the Governing Board of the American Bison Society. MEETING OF THE BOARD OF MANAGERS. After the adjournment of the general meeting, the Board of Managers met and elected the following officers for the year 1900: Honorary President, Hon. Theodore Roosevelt, Presi- dent of the United States; Honorary Vice-President, His Excellency Earl Grey, Governor-General of Canada; President, William T. Hornaday; Vice-Presidents, A. A. Anderson and Charles S. Minot; Secretary, Ernest Harold Baynes; Treasurer, Edmund Seymour. FIRST ANNUAL MEETING OF THE AMERICAN BISON SOCIETY. The first annual meeting of the American Bison Society was held on the roth of January, 1907, at the American Museum of Natural History, West 79th St. and Central Park West, New York City. President William IT. Hornaday was in the chair. The others present were: Herman C. Bumpus, Franklin W. Hooper, Frederic A. Lucas, Edmund Seymour, or Austin Corbin, George S. Edgell, William Lyman Under- wood, Frederic H. Kennard, Charles H. Stonebridge and Ernest Harold Baynes. The Secretary read a report, in which he reviewed the work of the Society during the past year. He showed that that work had been chiefly educational in its nature, con- sisting largely in the publishing of many newspaper and magazine articles in the: United States, Canada, and England, and in giving numerous free lectures on the subject. He also showed the result of his experimental effort to raise money and secure members for the Society in Worcester, Mass., by means of giving free lectures, securing the support of the newspapers, giving an exhibi- tion of buffalo heads, robes, and other relics, and particu- larly by means of strong personal letters of introduction to many of the leading people of the city. Fifty new members for the Society and the raising of the sum of $670 had been the immediate result of this effort. The Secretary briefly mentioned his experiment in rearing Buffalo calves by hand, and in breaking two young males to the yoke and to harness; told how he had exhibited this team on numerous occasions for the purpose of creating interest in the Buffalo, and how on one occasion he had driven one of the young Buffaloes to decisive victory over a domestic steer in a half-mile race at an agricultural fair. The report also gave an account of the Secretary’s experiments with buffalo wool, of which he showed samples, together with yarn spun from the wool and gloves knitted from the yarn. The report included letters from woolen manufacturers expressing the opinion that buffalo wool was very closely akin to sheep’s wool; that it was stronger, grade for grade, than the average wool; that for a long time it would demand a high price as a novelty; and, that if it could be obtained in quantity, there would be a good market for it for the manufacture of articles not requiring to be dyed the lighter colors. The Treasurer’s report showed that the total receipts of the Society from dues and subscriptions, with interest on same, amounted to $2,040; that the total expenditures had been $707.53; and that, consequently, the balance in 6 the bank to the credit of the Society was $1,332.53. The report showed that there were 9 Life Members, 125 Mem- bers, and 102 Associate Members. [In submitting his report, Mr. Seymour tendered his resignation as Treasurer, regretting that he was obliged to do so owing to pressure of other business and expected absence from home during the coming year. In resigning, Mr. Seymour suggested that Mr. Clark Williams, Vice- President of the Columbia Trust Company, New York, be elected to fill his place, and requested that a committee be appointed to audit his accounts. It was decided to have the Flathead and Crow Indian Reservations examined with a view to having suitable portions of them set apart as buffalo ranges. It was further decided to take such steps as might be necessary to establish herds of Buffalo in the Adirondack region, and in I]linois, on public lands, and the Executive Com- mittee was instructed to take steps looking to the establish- ment of buffalo herds on the forest reserves in New Hampshire and the southern Appalachian region. The following were elected or re-elected to fill the vacancies occurring on the Board of Managers: Herbert Ee brdeman. Dr. Hi. C.-Bumpus, Madison Grant, Cy J; ones; Pro David Starr, jordan. A. Bowen: Perry.C. E. Stonebridge, Clark Williams, and William Lyman Underwood. MEETING OF THE BOARD OF MANAGERS: After the general meeting, the Board of Managers met and elected the following officers :— Honorary President, Hon. Theodore Roosevelt, Presi- dent of the United States. Honorary Vice-President, His Excellency Earl Grey, Governor-General of Canada. President, William: Fy Flornaday. Vice-President. 4. A. Anderson and: Prof. Franklin W. Hooper. Secretary, Ernest Harold Baynes. Treasurer, Clark Williams. ~ ‘ SPECIAL, MEETING OF THE BOARD OF MANAGERS. On February 7, 1907, a special meeting of the Board of Managers was held at the office of Mr. Edmund Sey- mour, 45 Wall Street, New York, for the purpose of amending Article IV, Section I, of the Constitution, so as to provide for a change in the number of Members of the Board of Managers, from eighteen to twenty-seven. This change was made and the following men were elected to fill the nine vacancies created thereby :— Prof. Calvin M. Woodward, LL.D., of Washington University, St. Louis, Mo.; Harry W. Smith, of Wor- cester, Mass.; Commander Robert E. Peary, of Washing- ton; DiC Prot, Henry FF. Osborm- PhD. ior. the American Museum of Natural History, New York City; John M. Phillips, of Pittsburg, Pa.; Prof. David Starr Jordan, of Leland Stanford University, California; Fred- eric A. Lucas, Curator-in-Chief of the Museum of the Brooklyn Institute of Arts and Sciences; Dr. Charles B. Davenport, Director of the Biological Station of the Carnegie Institution, Cold Spring Harbor, L. I., and Mr. John E. Thayer, of Boston, Mass. SECOND ANNUAL MEETING OF THE AMERICAN BISON SOCIETY. The second annual meeting of The American Bison Society was held in the Board Room of The American Museum of Natural History, 79th Street and Central Park West, New York City, on Thursday morning, Janu- ary 9th, 1908, at 10:30 o’clock. President William ‘T. Hornaday was in the chair. The others present were: Miss Amy Townsend, Prof. Franklin W. Hooper, A. A. Anderson, Dr. Herman C. Bumpus, Edmund Seymour, F. A. Lucas, Charles H. Brinsmade, W. G. Langdon, Jr., H. L. Bridgman, Harry V. Radford, C. H. Stonebridge, Joseph E. Buckley and F.1D: Tansley, allot New York: 3H. A. Rdwards. or Albany; William Lyman Underwood and Frederic H. Kennard, of Boston, and Ernest Harold Baynes, of Meriden, N. H. 8 The President, in his report, spoke of the work which had been done by Prof. Morton J. Elrod for the purpose of selecting and recommending a suitable Buffalo range on the Flathead Indian Reservation, in Montana; of an Adirondack Bison Bill; of the shipment of a nucleus herd from New York Zoological Park to the Wichita Forest and Game Preserve in Oklahoma, and of a census of the Bison now existing—all of which matters are treated of elsewhere in detail. The Secretary read the following letter from President Roosevelt :— The White House WASHINGTON, Oct. 24, 1907. My Dear Mr. Baynes: I feel real and great interest in the work being done by the American Bison Society to preserve the Buffalo— the biggest of the American big game, probably on the whole the most distinctive game animal of this continent, and certainly the animal which played the greatest part in the lives of the Indians, and which most deeply imprest the imagination of all the old hunters and early settlers. It would be a real misfortune to permit the species to become extinct, and I hope that all good citizens will aid the Society in its efforts for its preservation. Sincerely yours, ‘THEODORE ROOSEVELT. Mr. Ernest Harold Baynes, Secretary, The American Bison Society, Meriden, N. H. The report of the Treasurer, Mr. Clark Williams, was read and ordered printed in full in the Annual Report of the Society. The report of the Executive Committee showed that during February, March and April of 1907 the Secretary spent several weeks in Boston, lecturing before prominent societies and clubs, writing for the newspapers, and other- wise interesting the people of the city in the fate of the Buffalo. Many new memberships and subscriptions were secured. At the Sportsmen’s Show, held in Mechanics’ Build- ing, Boston, April rst to 13th, under the auspices of the New England Forest, Fish and Game Association, the American Bison Society had a large and interesting exhi- bition, which attracted more attention than any other in the hall. The principal exhibits were six living Buffaloes, two grand old bulls, two two-year-olds, and two calves of the previous spring, all loaned by the Blue Mountain Forest Association, of Newport, N. H., which also loaned an interesting collection of buffalo robes, buffalo heads and skulls and buffalo hoofs. Our President, Mr. William ‘TY. Hornaday, contributed a most interesting and unique collection of buffalo horns, all from wild Buffalo shot on spikes of a reatdnie to the peeling “stubs” of bulls twenty years old or older. Mr. Hornaday also loaned the well- mounted head of a young Buffalo bull. With the exception of the living Buffaloes, perhaps no exhibit attracted so much attention as a collection of lithographs after George Catlin, illustrating the life of the Buffalo in early times, especially in its relation to the North American Indian. This collection, loaned by Dr. Townsend W. Thorndike, of Boston, was surrounded by visitors from the beginning to the close of the show. Dr. Thorndike also loaned a number of old guns, powder horns, etc., which had been used by Indians and which had been repaired with buffalo hide. A quantity of buffalo wool, with yarn spun from the same material, and warm garments knitted from the varn, was exhibited by the Secretary, who also loaned a collec- tion of enlarged photographs of Buffaloes. Among the other exhibits were a collection of buffalo robes, loaned by Messrs. Ordway, Loring and Ricker, of Boston; a lariat, twisted from the long coarse hair of the buffalo’s head and fore legs, loaned by E. W. Deming, the animal painter, and a splendid buffalo carriage robe, contributed by W. D. Chandler, of Concord, N. EE The exhibition, which was in charge of the Secretary, was a success in every way. One of the immediate results was an increased membership for the Society, about one hundred new members of all classes being secured during 10 the two weeks of the show. ‘The financial result was a net profit to the Society of $207.98. Incidentally, the exhi- bition attracted the attention of thousands of people, nearly all of whom were more or less interested in the movement to preserve the Buffalo, and assisted in the dis- tribution of circulars setting forth the Society’s purposes and appealing to the American public to aid in the work of preserving the Buffalo from extinction. The Executive Committee was authorized to raise a special fund with which to purchase Buffaloes or to pro- cure Buffaloes by other means, if possible, to be placed on any state or government lands, provided the maintenance of the animals is assured by state or nation. The following persons were elected to fill the nine vacancies occurring on the Board of Managers: A. A. Anderson, Prof. Franklin W. Hooper, Dr. William T. omaday, jraedernc. I. * Kennard.) Eion, .Jamies’ °S. Whipple. Gifford Pinchot, Edmund Seymour, Dr. T. S. Palmer, and Ernest Harold Baynes. SECOND ANNOAIG MEETING OF THE BOARD OF MANAGERS. After the general meeting, the Board of Managers met and elected the following officers for 1908:— Honorary President, Hon. Theodore Roosevelt, President of the United States; Honorary Vice-President, His Excellency Earl Grey, Governor-General of Canada; President, William T. Hornaday; Vice-Presidents, A. A. Anderson, Franklin W. Hooper; "Secretary, Ernest Har- old Baynes; Treasurer, Clark Williams, care of Columbia Trust Company, New York. The following persons were elected members of the Executive Committee: William T. Hornaday, Madison Grant, Frederic H. Kennard, William Lyman Under- wood, “Gittord Pinchot, Dr. IT. Ss*Palmer and Ernest Harold Baynes. It was decided to have the American Bison Society incorporated. It was also decided to hold a midsummer meeting of the Society at Newport, N. H., where the members would have an opportunity to inspect the Blue Mountain Forest 11 Buffalo herd, now one of the largest in the world. The Secretary was authorized to visit the Buffalo herds of the West, for the purpose of obtaining exact information concerning them. A committee was appointed to prepare a relief map of North America, on which should be indicated the former range of the Bison, and also the positions of the remaining herds. ‘he map will be placed in the American Museum of Natural History, at the suggestion of the Director. The foregoing report, it is hoped, will give our mem- bers an idea of what the Society is trying to do, and how it is trying to do it. The officers are making an earnest and determined effort to carry out the purposes for which we organized, and they are more than ever confident of ultimate success. “he Society itself is growing, and is in a much stronger position than it was even six months ago. Its membership has more than doubled in that time, and, thanks largely to our friends, the newspapers and maga- zines, it is much better known. Much of the preliminary work has already been done, and we have reached the point where actual results are being accomplished. With the persistent hard work which the officers are willing to do, there is no longer any doubt of our ability to accom- plish our final purposes,—viz., “the permanent preser- vation and increase of the American Bison”; but it is most important that we stand together and keep this end in view. There is enough money in the treasury to carry on the work of the Society for a short time, but much more is needed for many purposes. It is hoped that ere long some of our wealthy countrymen will recognize the im- portance of the work the American Bison Society is trying to accomplish, and by generous contributions hasten the day when our national animal will be out of danger of extinction. In the meantime every effort should be made to increase the membership of the Society; the stronger we become, the better able we shall be to accomplish our purpose. We shall, therefore, ask each member to secure from among his friends, if possible within a month after receiving this report, at least one new member. If each 12 one will carry out his own small part of this plan, the Society can at once double its activity, for the doubling of our membership means the doubling of our income. Circulars and membership blanks may be obtained by applying to the Secretary. TREASURER’S° REPORT, AMERICAN, BISON SOCIETY. JANUARY 10TH TO DECEMBER 31ST, 1907. Balance, January roth, 1907-",.. 1) $1,332:23 RECEIPTS. Dues, Subscriptions and Donations. $2,890.10 MIMEKESE SA eee au. yt! ode ea tee 24.22 —————— 2,924.32 ROUaLS ere AN Sea ey eee $4,256.55 DISBURSEMENTS OS EACH Anew out tnd eeyne), eee UN AN $709.55 Exchanger one mecksuts. 5 2) se ate 4.21 Petiy.@ashu( i. Baynes ssce ye. 34.1.4.7 Dalany We Tde Baynes, Secretary... ... 272.74. Pimntine- and Stationery...) uu. 856.75 aavelltiniosixmense ¢9) eves ia. 56.91 Miscellaneous: Eugene M. Fisher, drawing bison 20.00 Caleb P. Buckman, burlap, labor. Ions Social Register Association, all ISSUES: SONG, VERE (08. eines 25.00 Charlesslocue stock. 0 i... ne oen 5.00 New England Forest, Fish and Game HASsociationy, sacle Rails) Solatia M. Taylor, 5 frames..... Ts Prof. Morton J. Elrod, account EXPENSES amd Senvicesie 05. aA- 150.00 New England Show Case Com- Pallyew REM tuOnaCases ets .eh haa 6.00 Ek. H. Baynes, checks remitted in =) aC) eR teat Cane Bagh SSRRILY 1a 25.00 ————— 2,503.63 DAAC Soc: a roiltes cates Geena Nh oe Geen OS Py re 7.52.02 CLARK WILLIAMS, Treasurer. 14 - 4 S WZ TOWNSHIP 1/8 NORTH, RANGE 2/ WES, 2. MAP OF PROPOSED NATIONAL BISON R. i * ‘4 Es = [ejpeal S| oe : ~ ) Mh } N\ : [rm SES re | Se TN [I//, UN TV A 1) HY nl 4 \ ESS ‘ ‘| 3/3 FANGE 20 WEST. \THEAD RESERVATION, N-W MONTANA % MA Pre hoe ee NV ES | rae pty Whe a ya, Ss ”) alee tes CZ, 4 r. ‘ a Tx x fi ‘ i s +] ° ie Cite ~ Nu 5 J y ae 4S, SN ~ : x. . , ae. % a. , SS 3s . 2 “ ZZ is fe - SLESON, SH See Ky et sys = Se LS “ff \ i ee) AT OAc ; HAS Ti 755 SIAL ; : ; rs . = \ AKA. 4 z i : ae \ ee ae x is vs e. : — fae Ty A J § Se A) AN, | wee ee Sx Wi, NA OSD u : 3 2 C MNS AS ee Ad ee ee | \ Pts F i . \ os - \ iy ; - 18. 4 i & e : A td e \ AMAT ROM YMG LON? AVATAR OR ABE > stan PRN Tobe eee AD BUPFALO RANGE. A REPORT TO THE AMERICAN BISON SOCIETY OF AN INSPEC- TION OF THE FLATHEAD INDIAN RESERVATION, MON- TANA, FOR THE PURPOSE OF SELECTING A SUITABLE LOCATION FOR A NATIONAL BUFFALO RANGE. By MorTon J. ELROD, PH.D., Professor of Biology, University of Montana, Missoula. Director of the University Biological Station. Acting on instructions from the President of The American Bison Society, I examined several places in the Flathead Indian Reservation, Montana, for the purpose of selecting a suitable location for a range in which to confine and perpetually maintain and propagate a herd of American Bison, or, as it is popularly known here, the Buffalo. Having travelled over the reservation every summer forthe past ten years | had some definite ideas of the portions of the reserve that would be most suitable for such a range. To my mind there were four available localities, but just which one was ideal could be deter- mined only by close observation, covering all the points involved in preparing the range so as to make it suitable for permanent use. The chief items of importance in making the selection were outlined as follows, although not necessarily in order as here given: 1. ACCESSIBILITY.—To be of the greatest use, the range should be reasonably near to the railroad. The reasons for this are quite obvious. To ship animals in and out will be necessary from time to time. ‘There may be need for transportation of forage. Fencing material must be procured, and long hauls by wagon are expensive. Lastly, the public will want to visit the animals and see them on the range, and will desire to reach them easily from the railway. ‘J99F 000'8 A[teou Fo UOTRA[a Ue WoIT qsoM JO YINOS SI MATA oY T ‘asuey pasodo.sd ey} jo Aiepunoq 93y} Jo SMOYS OUTT YORI ayy, “Wa40}s B 19},ze Ysnf Udy] SopIs 991} EF ‘oun, ur sivadde yt se “surejUuno yy UOISSTIAT 94} jo IUTLUNS 9} Worl Vv AONVA NOSTG GASOdOUd AHL JO MAIA AAA-S.AGUIG TI €LV1d 2. THE RANGE.—This must be suitable to afford ample grazing grounds for the herd, both summer and winter, with plenty of water. There must be ample natural protection from winter storms and blizzards. Naturally, the public will not desire to see choice farm or fruit lands set apart as a buffalo range; hence non-irrigable land must be selected. 3. FENCING.—The range must be fenced; for other- wise the animals will become scattered, and poachers will molest them. To fence such a range as is desirable and necessary, is no small item; hence the desirability of a location whereon digging will not be too difficult, and where posts may be secured and delivered with a mini- mum of expense. 4. CARE-TAKING.—The range must be looked after, and the animals must be cared for. ‘The care-taker will need certain material and provisions, and should have communication with the world at large. ROURVEOCALI PIES CONSIDERED. The four localities examined with a view to selection are as follows, and may easily be located on the accom- panying maps. 1. WILD HorsE ISLAND.—This island is in the west- emmranm or. Flathead’ Wake: It is so miles from the Northern Pacific Railroad, and nearly as far from the Great Northern. The island is completely isolated, but the contiguity of Cromwell Island, on the west, would make it possible for animals to swim from Wild Horse to Cromwell; and the latter is really a part of the main- land. The island contains 2,164 acres, and rises to a height Of abouten 2008 tect above the lake, On the north it is rather densely wooded with yellow pine and red fir, with a sprinkling of cottonwood. On the southern side, the island is almost bare of timber, except the fringe around the lake. A portion of the lake shore is well adapted to fruit raising. There is no water, except that in the lake itself. alee SPRY suey prIy—sAvyIJooYMIoy AA ST HY SUL “SUIEJUNOTW UOISSITY JO UOoT}OaIp 94} wWo.rT asuey oleyng pasodoig SV FHL WOW “AONVY AHL AO MAIA IVAANAD WL 9} OT, W99F OOS*F ‘Ysos~MG sr yurod ysoys , TIL ULV Id The island is too far from transportation lines, and too difficult of access by the public. Were this otherwise, it might possibly be made a suitable location. 2. THE LITTLE BITTER-ROOT COUNTRY.—This is a beautiful country, admirably suited for a range, but is too remote, too difficult of access, and would require greater expenditure for fencing than would be permis- sible he roads to and-itom that section are hilly, not much travelled, and visitors to a herd located there would for a long time be very few. The Little Bitter- Root River, which is but a creek, flows through the valley which was formerly made by the outlet of Flathead Lake when the outlet was through the western arm of the lake. Through this valley access is easy, but it is from 60 to 90 miles distant from Kalispell, on the Great Northern Rail- road. From the Northern Pacific, at Plains, the distance is less than half of that given, but the road is difficult to travel over in its present state. 3. THE HILLS EAST OF THE PEND D’OREILLE RIVER.* —It is here that the Pablo-Allard Buffaloes have ranged a great deal of the time. ‘True, they have crossed the river often, and ranged westward toward the Little Bitter- Roots, but on several different occasions I have visited them in the very region now under consideration. The general contour of the country is as follows: East of the river there is a valley several miles wide, and quite level; eastward of this valley is a range of low hills and buttes, extending north and south; east of these is a high and level bench, gradually dropping lower to form the Mission valley; on the eastern side of that valley the majestic Mission Mountains rise abruptly from the plain, the peaks having an elevation of from 7,000 to 10,000 feet above the sea, and 4,000 to 7,000 feet above the valley. This location is fine, the conditions are favorable, with the possible exception of water supply; but the region is rather remote, and difficult of access. The new railroad from Kalispell to Dixon, connecting the Great Northern with the Northern Pacific, will go close to this range, and *Inasmuch as on most maps this river is called the Flathead, we have found it desirable to adopt the name in most general use.—Ep. 19 ‘oSuvy oreyng pesodoid ay} Jo Arepunog Uso}sva oY} IvauU WoOAF “Ysva Buryoory ‘SNIVINQNOW NOISSIW FHL “AT ULV Id THE FLATHEAD INDIAN RESERVATION AND ADJACENT TERRITORY. possibly will cut it; but the locality to be next mentioned has many more points in its favor. THE RANGE RECOMMENDED. 4. THE RAVALLI HILLS AND MEADOWS.—This is the range I have selected and recommend as offer- ing all the advantages. The section is in the form of a rectangle, with the Jocko River as the southern boundary, Mission Creek on the north and on the west is the “Big River. the Mend d Oreille Valsoucalled lathead lene eastern boundary is the ravine through which runs the main road from Ravalli to the Flathead Lake. ‘This draw rises to a high summit which forms the crest of the divide between the Jocko River and Mission Valley, the elevation being 3,104 feet. On the opposite, or northern side a ravine drops down to Mission Creek. This is approximately the boundary. The range proposed contains five Indian allotments, with a total of 800 acres, as shown in the map herewith. The selection in Section II, Town. 18, Range 21, includes the springs which form the little stream called Chim- taupeh; the selection in Section I, Town. 18, Range 21, includes a small stream with a few inches, flowing north- west, but disappearing before Mission Creek is reached; the selections in Section 7, Town. 18, Range 20, include a perennial spring with a small flow, but whose water soon sinks into the ground. All these springs are perpetual. There are fine springs in Sections 13 and 14, Town. 18, Range 21, which are also perpetual, and which furnish water for a stream sufficiently large to water many animals. These five Indian selections should be eliminated either by purchase or by lien selections. In case both these courses prove to be impossible, they may be fenced out of the range. If they are eliminated the range will then have approximately 27 sections, as follows: Beginning with the southeastern corner of Section 30, Town. 18, Range 20, run thence diagonally to the centre of 29; north on 29 to the boundary of 20; east to line between 20 and 21; north three miles to corner of Sections 99 we 4, 5,8 and 9; diagonally across 5 to township line at north- east corner of 5; north across Mission Creek, along this creek at suitable distance through Section 31, Town. 19, Range 20; in ‘Town. 19, Range 21, through sections 36, 35, 27, 28; south through 30 to township line; in Town. 18, Range 21 south through the center of sections 4, 9, 16, and to center of section 21 ; east a half; south a quarter; east a half, and south across the Jocko River, to the Northern Pacific right of way; following the right of way and river through Sections 27 and 26; crossing back nonmiyot the tivyer; through 25 and 30 to pot’ of beginning. On the map submitted herewith this line is clearly indicated as the boundary of the range proposed. In case it is impossible to eliminate the five allotments, the line may run as before to the corner of Sections 8, 9, 16 and 17 in Town. 19, Range 20; thence west one and one-half miles; north to center of 7; west two miles to the center of 11 in Town. 18, Range 21; thence north a mile to center of 2, and west to line as before marked; or north across Mission Creek to line of boundary as outlined. The line of this alternative boundary is also shown. This alternative proposition will give a little more than 17 sections if taken with the boundary first given, or almost 5 sections more as given last. In finally fixing the area and boundaries of a bison range in the region proposed, there are three possibilities: (1) If the five Indian allotments are removed, a range of 27 sections; (2) cutting out the allotments, a range of 17 sections; and (3), a range of 22 sections, but with more fencing than should be the case. In proposition No. 1 the range would include over four miles of Mission Creek, one and one-half miles of the Jocko River, and four springs or clusters of springs in gulches. In No. 2 there would be the Jocko River, one cluster of springs, and the stream from another. In No. 3 there would be over three miles of Mission Creek, besides the one and one-half miles of Jocko River. For No. 1 there would be required 20% miles of fence, in No. 2 about 18 miles, and in No. 3 about the same as in No. 1. In fencing No. 1 there will be no hills to cross 23 ‘yjtou FO jsoM OI}I] & SI ME[DIgG ‘“UTYssozeYsuy SMoys ainjzord sty, *Aa[[eA oy} UI udas SI pLoTIeEY IyIoVgG UsIYWION IY Jey petoquiyy oy} Ysnoryy “jJoT OF JYSII wWory SMOG AIATY oypof ou. ‘AONVA AHL AO NOILWOd NAYHLINOS AHL ‘A ULVIEd in the work; in No. 2 there is a high hill to cross; in No. 3 1t will be necessary to cross two hills. By all means No. 1 is first choice. This would give ample grazing ranges for a large herd, with an abundance of water, and plenty of shelter from the storms of winter. The range should accommodate from 1,500 to 2,000 Buf- faloes, including, as it will, about 18,000 acres. It will make an excellent range for antelope, deer and elk; and even mountain sheep should do well upon it. GENERAL DESCRIPTION. I will now give a description of the range, assuming that the entire range indicated as No. 1 is finally chosen byjthe. Bison Society, Ifeither of the other ranges are taken, a portion of this description in inapplicable. It is said on good authority that this is the range which Mr. Pablo wanted on which to keep his herd of Buffalo. Colonel Rankin, the government allotting agent of the reservation, 1s emphatic in his opinion that it is the place of all places on the reservation for the proposed national buffalo herd. Joseph Allard, the son of Charles Allard, originally part owner of the Allard-Pablo herd, believes that this range is ideal. Duncan McDonald, one of the most intelligent men on the reservation, and who rode over the range with me during my study of it, says that no better place could be selected. Every one who knows the coun- try, and whose opinion has been asked, says the same thing. Tourists or visitors may step off the train at Ravalh, and in five minutes be in the range. They may look into the range for nine miles as they ride from Ravalli to Jocko! Animals may be shipped in and out with very little effort. The range is strictly non-agricultural, but the greater portion of it affords excellent grazing. By non-agricul- tural is meant that it cannot be irrigated, owing to the fact that it is high above water, and irregular. For dry-farm- ing, the hills are too steep. The highest point is on the quarter section between sections 13 and 24, elevation by aneroid 4,800 feet. The quarter section stone is on the narrow summit. This is about 2,000 feet above the rail- road, and a little over two miles from Ravalli. From this 25 ‘S[[IY 94} pue peorjer oy} UaaMjoq ‘Jaquiy 9Y} YSnNoIY} SuNI JIA OYO/ ay} pue ‘ainjord ay} Jo o[pprut sy} Ysnoryy sunt ABMIIEY OloRg UsJIyWON If, “A %L[q Ur ey} UY} Jsva JY} PALMO} JOYyJIeZ asueY oy} Jo uonsod ke st sy ‘ADNVAU GASOdOUd AHL AO LNOWL NAAHLOOS pn gy toe S Neier eminent ‘ ah TA ALVId high hill, or low mountain, the range slopes in every direc- tion. On the south it drops to the Jocko River, on the west tO,the ilathead, ‘or Pend d’Oreille River, on the north to Mission Creek, and on the east to the Mission Valley. The highest mountain is called Quilseeh, which in the Flathead laneuage means “red sleep.” From Quilseeh Mountain, several ridges extend. These are excellently shown in Plate II], which was taken from the morainal hills to the eastward, or toward the Mission Mountains. he view is south-westward. In the middle of the picture is a depression, with a slope from left to right. In this depression lies the eastern boundary of the range, extending from left to right (south to north), about the middle of the picture. The highest point is Quilseeh, and the one to the left is Wheewheetlchaye.* Long Ridge slopes down to the right. The photograph shows the character of the range on the north and east. The range is hilly, but not precipitous, and is just such ground as the Pablo herd travels over daily. In the draws and ravines the grazing is fine. The selections of Alex- ander and Eneas are between the ridge on the sky line and the one immediately below it on the extreme right. The timber is scarce and the largest trees perhaps 150 to 200 years old. ‘They are the yellow pine (Pinus ponderosa) and Douglas fir (Pseudotsuga taxifolia), with spreading limbs and branches. ‘The water courses shown are dry in summer. By turning the back to the picture shown in Plate III and travelling a few miles eastward the picture shown in Plate IV was taken. This is only a portion of the beautiful Mission Mountains, which stand out so grandly, and are especially imposing from the summit of Quilseeh or Wheewheetlchaye. Quilseeh drops off to the south over a ridge called Inskaltesshin, referring to a mass of rocks, shale, etc., on the southern face, which to the Indian mind resembles a dragon stretched out on the face of the mountain. This is shown in Plate V. This is the steepest part of the range, and contains the timber. Plate VI shows the portion *For convenience, this difficult Indian name will be changed to Red Man’s Ridge.—Ep. cw) ~ ‘STTHY 94} pue pvoryier 9y} Usamjoq uses oq AvuI JOATI oY, “AdT[eA OOOL oY} SI Jey oyT ‘UMOYS ST ISULY OY} JO IOUIOD UD|svayMOS sy], ‘suo, BJSUe-opIM v YWM “TA aje[q se uolyisod ates oy} wWoiy udayey ‘HONVA NOSIA GASOdOUd AHL AO LNOWA NYAHLNOS TIA. Ghia farther east, up the river. Plate VII is from the same point as Plate VI, but with a wide-angle lens. It shows the Jocko Valley. Ravalli is almost on the edge of the picture, on the right, in the centre, where a depression separates the hills on the right from those on the left. This depression is the eastern boundary of the range. The Mission Mountains are visible in the hazy distance. Standing on the same spot from which the pictures in Plates V, VI and VII were taken, and looking down the river, northwestward, the southwestern corner of the range may be seen. This view shows the Jocko Valley to its junction with the Flathead River, which comes in from the right (north), in the distance. The Flathead or Pend d’Oreille Valley and river extend in the distance to the left. The line of the bison range is along the slope above the Jocko River, and the fence should cross the river into the valley, within the limits of the picture. The only good view of the northern side of the range is shown in Plate II. Indeed, this picture, taken from an elevation of nearly 8,000 feet in the Mission Moun- tains, gives a bird’s-eye view of the entire range except on the south. It is thus seen to be an open range of low hills, almost bare of timber on the visible slopes. ‘The range is distant from the point of view about ten or twelve miles. Clive AG R. OF HE, SOLL, Along Mission Creek and on the long slope bordering the Flathead River, there is considerable alkali. In such places the ground is quite bare of vegetation. On the steeper slopes the grazing is scanty. In the ravines, on the protected slopes, and in the wide heads of gulches, the vegetation is luxuriant. Last June the grass was waist high in the moist ravines, and knee high on the slopes. On the south, in the timber, there is considerable slide- rock, but this is a minor item. ‘The broader slopes and wider ravines have rich, pebbly loam. ‘The summits and ridges are outcrops of rock, with scanty vegetation. THE VEGETATION. In the spring the range is almost a fairyland of flowers. These continue until late in July. The broad-leaved Bal- 29 ‘JSoM JO YJIOU ST MOIA oY, ‘UoT}Ia}01d BuIMOYs ‘YaaI19 UrTYyssazeysuyT JO pesyT ‘akeyorJooyMoay AA Worf “Yaas[in() WONVA AHL AO LINWOAS AHL NO TMA a@LVId samorrhiza, with its yellow flowers, grows over most of the range. Wherever this plant grows the soil is rich. Bunch-grass grows in abundance. In the valleys, blue grass (Poa) and other nutritious grasses grow rankly. On the summit of Quilseeh, in June, within a few paces of each other, 21 species of plants were found growing. In the valleys and gulches, lupines almost shoulder high were visible everywhere. Wild geranium and Phacelia indicated, by their growth, plenty of moisture. Many species of water plants grew around the springs, and along the creek beds. In places the vegetation is rank, in other places moderate; in still others it is poor or absent. TIMBER. As has been previously stated, only a small portion of the range is covered with timber. ‘This is confined to the southern slopes, and to the draws. ‘The coniferous trees are yellow pine (Pinus ponderosa) and Douglas fir (Pseudotsuga taxifolia). ‘Yhere is no thick timber. The trees are scattered, well branched and afford good shade. Reforestation, or, more correctly speaking, the beginning of foresting, is taking place in several localities. In several of the gulches there are dense clusters of willows and alders. On the hillsides are a few scattered rock maples. A scanty growth of timber is found along Mission Creek, although a narrow belt has a few large trees. Along the Jocko the growth is dense, with both pine and fir, ‘and a thick stand of cottonwood, alder, birch and willow. As most of the timber grows on the hillsides, it is on that account difficult of access. Save a few scat- tering trees it is not commercially valuable. The fir trees will supply a large number of posts for fencing. SPRINGS AND STREAMS. The Jocko River is the largest stream touching the range. It rises in the Mission Mountains, to the southeast, always has a strong flow of pure, clear water, and will always afford a supply for the herd. When the reser- vation is thrown open to settlement much of the present flow wil! no doubt be consumed in irrigation, but the 31 yurod surddrys AvAjIVr ayy st sty yz, ‘SSO1S BG UM poyteUl SP TW[eARy ‘asueyY uosrg pasodosid ay} Jo yrwuns’ ayy WOIF ‘T[T[BARY “RATIVA OMOOL AHL AO MAIA pleMO} “Ysvayjnos SUIYOO'T “XI ALVId river will always have water. The flow of the river June 30, 1900, was 660 second feet. Mission Creek, on the northern boundary, rises in the Mission Mountains a few miles to the eastward. Per- petual snows form its source. It rises in the great amphi- theatre shown in part in Plate IV, flowing down the canyon in the middle of the picture. Its fow on June 30, 1900, was 412 second feet. Its waters are clear and cold, and as pure as a mountain stream can be. Later on, much of its water will no doubt be used for irrigation, but the stream will not go dry. Its waters may be held back in spring, by reservoirs at its source. In one branch of the creek neat tne snow-banks. 1s a lake a -mile and a half long, nearly a half mile wide, and 250 feet deep. Its outlet is dammed by a glacial moraine, so that it is easy to increase the volume of water in the lake. But, even if these two streams should be entirely used up in irrigation—-which 1s out of reason—there are springs on the range which will supply an abundance of clear, pure and cold water. On the northern slope the seepage from the mountain 1s considerable. It breaks out in springs, which by digging could be easily made into large springs or wells. Chimtaupeh Creek and Inskaltesshin Creeks both head in a number of springs, which are said by residents never to fail. The waters from these springs disappear before reaching the valley, but flow in a regular stream for a mile or more after coming out of the ground. In all but late summer there are numerous water courses which head in small springs, but which later on dry up. PROTECTION.—The prevailing winds of summer blow from the south or southwest. A breeze is quite surely to be felt on the summits of the range during the hot days of summer. ‘The springs, the trees, the creeks, will give chance for cooling the animals in summer. There is more need for winter protection. No matter which way the storms may come, there will always be protection from the sting of the wind and snow. If it comes from the north, a Bison herd would have but to move over to the gulches on the south side; if from the east, the head of Chimtaupeh is a safe retreat; and no matter how fierce the winds, the animals may escape. The thickets along 33 ‘oanqord ay} FO SHUT] OY} UIYYM AIATI dy} Sso1d pynoM adUey aSuvI pasodosd ayy, ‘}YSII 9Y} UO ST UTeJUNOT MeIa¢G ‘GVAHLVIA AHL AO LVHL HLIM IOILONNL SLI GNV AATIVA UTAIN OMOOL AHL X FLVId the water courses will of themselves alone be safe protec- tion, and the slopes of the hills will enable wild animals to find places free from storm blasts, no matter how fierce they may be. The range will always have bare surfaces, except in cases of sleet, which may glaze the surtace with ice, or with frozen rain or new snow. Rarely is the range so coated that grass 1s not to be had by range stock. In this one gulch and its tributaries, wild animals may escape cold winds from any quarter. Perennial springs are found Inthe ravine shownm Plate Vill. Phere are thickets, to the left, out of sight; timber over the ridge to the left, and ridges for grazing all around. Plate IX also shows the same thing. This is a view from Wheewheetlchaye, looking toward Ravalli, and showing the Jocko River and valley. ‘The water course is usually dry. Animals on this side would find protection from winds from any point of the compass. ‘This view shows the Jocko Valley for many miles up, toward the southeast. By looking at Plate X after viewing Plate IX a good idea of the Jocko Valley may be had. The road in Plate IX marks the limits of the proposed range. he: jliocko River at Ravalli, as seen in Plate IX, is better shown in Plate XI, taken at the railroad bridge at Ravalli. FENCING.—The fencing of the range will require posts for the greater portion of the distance. Along the southern side trees may be used for a portion of the distance. Cedar posts are to be had by rail from Idaho, at Sand Point, or they may no doubt be secured from the Mission Mountains. Arbor-vite forests are found at the head of all the Mission Mountain canyons. Fir posts may be secured without difficulty, close to the range. There is a good road entirely around the range except on the south, and teams can drive from the roads on the west and east over most of the distance. Where the lines cross the hillsides, as will be the case sometimes, posts and fence will have to be dragged up. For the greater portion of the boundary, fencing material may be unloaded from the wagon where it is to be used. No doubt the Indians and white men in the vicinity will contract to furnish posts and 35 ‘asue1 posodoid oy} Siojud JI o1oyM TITIVAVY LV ‘AAAIN ONDOL AHL xX ALVad put up fence at a very reasonable rate. Wherever possible the work should be given to the local people, as their co- operation and support will be a valuable factor in pre- paring the range. CARETAKING.—In a range the size of the one here contemplated, and with animals as large in numbers as this herd will be in a short time, a home for a caretaker will be necessary. On the range as outlined there are two small Indian cabins, both inside of the range, and both several miles from the railroad. It will be necessary either to purchase a ranch with buildings, or make a new home. This matter may be taken up after the range is established, but plans should be made beforehand. ‘There are several places wihhere-a home can be made, but, of course, there will be expenses connected with it. Duncan McDonald’s ranch is shown in Plates XII and XIII. Plate XII is a view from Ravalli, looking down the Jocko River. On the right is seen the southern limits of the range; in the valley is McDonald’s hay ranch and orchard. ‘The white house belongs to the ranch, as do also the cabins. ‘The ranch joins the range on the north. A range the size of the one proposed will need atten- tion. ‘There will be fences to look after, which will mean regular inspection. Springs will need to be walled up and looked after. “The animals themselves will need look- ing after. Owing to the fact that the range is high above the streams and dependent upon rainfall for growth of vegetation, and that the native grasses on the hills do not grow a thick mat as do cultivated grasses, a larger acreage is needed than in humid climates. A range may now be secured of sufficient size to main- tain animals in such numbers as will be desired in coming years.. If cared for properly, a herd of several hundred Buffalo may soon be bred. The land will never be fit for anything but grazing. If at first there are not enough Bison to make use of all the range, cattle or horses may be ranged at a rental, which will assist in keeping the range in condition. A good caretaker can look after all of this work. If the land is not put into a buffalo range, it will be used only for horse or cattle pastures. or ol “yy poyreur oovjd wo1Z MOIA B ST TITX eld ‘98uvI oy} JO SHUWIT UsoyNOs 94} UO o1e 4FYysII oy} UO SITY OL YMAAIN AHL NMOG DNIMOOT AYTIVA OMDOL AHL GNV ITIVAVa TIX ALV Id ENEMIES TO BUFFALO OR OTHER WILD ANIMALS.— Coyotes are not infrequent. Last May, while the Buffalo were being shipped from the reservation to Canada, I perched on some rocks at what is the corner of the range, with camera placed ready to photograph the herd as it was driven down the hill along the road. Not knowing when the herd would come, I waited several hours on this rocky eminence. While waiting, all un- known to me, a coyote came up to within a few feet, peering over the brow of the ridge at me, and leisurely trotted off. I was unaware of his presence until advised by those who were watching his performances. Almost any evening they may be heard in the hills about Ravalli. While coyotes are not uncommon, I have heard little or no complaint about wolves in this locality. ‘The puma is to be found throughout the wooded portion of Montana, but it is not giving trouble in this section. ‘There are occasional rattlesnakes reported, but during the several days that I walked and rode over the range I did not see any. Itissafe to say the enemies would be no more numer- ous here than in other localities, and I believe they would be fewer than in the eastern ranges. They will no doubt become still scarcer as the country settles up. The Pablo herd, in their range on this reservation, has increased rapidly. SENTIMENT OF THE PEOPLE.—Duncan McDonald rode with me over the proposed range, and talked freely. I told him exactly what was proposed. He was bitterly disappointed that the Government of the United States had permitted the Pablo Buffalo herd to go to Canada. ‘What is the use of hunting for a buffalo range if the Buffalo are all gone?” was his laconic query, as he turned fiercely toward me while bemoaning the loss of the herd. “Duncan, the Buffalo of America are not all dead yet, NoOware the men whorare trying to save them, ’ | replred.: Then I told him of the animals yet living, of which he had read something, and of the plans of the American Bison Society, the men back of the effort to save the noble animal, and the great value to the community if such a herd were located in its midst. 39 *SSOIO B YIM poryteUul aor d WOTF MorA ev st [IX 97e[d “TT[BARY 1e pleuoqgoyjy Ueouncy JO YoueT a4} fo j1ed pue ssnoy ‘pte yotgd TTIVAVA LY AYTIVA OMDOL FHL TIIX YLVWI1d “If we can get the range, the animals will be put on ite elestated: “Do you think so?” clean sure Of it.” “Professor Elrod, I hope they will do it. We all hope so.) Uhe Indians are yery sorry to see the Buffalo go. They all love them. ‘They all think the Government should keep them. ‘They don’t want to kill them. They love to see them roam over the hills and plains. Every Indian will be glad if the Government can and will save them, and keep them where they can be seen. And if there is anything in this world I can do to help, I want to do it.” All the intelligent men whom I have talked with on the reservation express the same opinion. Enterprising .people in Missoula with whom the matter has been dis- cussed are hopeful of the outcome, and greatly desire that the undertaking will be worked out successfully. ‘The press has in a number of cases spoken highly of the pro- posed plan. Few have knowledge of the proposed range, and when its boundaries and the character of the land are understood the plan will meet with universal favor. I have previously mentioned the efforts of Joe Allard to interest Congress in the herd. Col. Rankin, allotting agent, 1s full of enthusiasm over the plan. There will not be a dissenting man, unless perhaps it may be some one who wants a portion of the range for himself. CLIMATE.—The climate on the western slope of the Rockies is agreeably surprising to all those who stay in the country for any length of time. The absence of the great humidity of the Eastern and Central States relieves one of the disagreeable oppressiveness in summer, and the severity of cold in winter. The extremes are not great. he thermometer does not often fall below zero, and: then for a. short time.only.'-The coldest weather recorded by the Weather Bureau in a record of over twenty years was 27 degrees below zero, during the winter of 1904-05. ‘The mercury does not frequently fall below 1s degrees Fahrenheit. There have been winters when the thermometer did not fall below zero. The mean tem- 41 ‘epeury 0} JUoUIdIYS 10F ‘peor ay} Suope [If 94} UMOP UdATIp Buloq st ploy O[qed-plel[y ay} jo uornsod Wo ‘}yoyT oy} UO ST YOIYM ‘aBuet oY} FO JUN] Uta}sva oY} St ouUTARI Sit], ADNVY GusSOdOUd AHL AO ACIS NAYLSVaA "poral ff *W Aq ‘Zo6r ‘yys1Adon “AIX ALVI1d perature, summer and winter, as recorded by the Weather Bureau for 20 years, is 46 degrees Fahrenheit. In summer the days get warm, even hot. Rarely does the temperature reach roo in the shade. In the shade one almost always feels cool. It is always cool at night. The perpetual snow in the mountains tempers the air, as does the water on the sea coast. In the evening the cool air from the snowy peaks rells down the mountain sides and out across the valleys. The climate of a region is dependent upon two im- portant factors, warmth and moisture. On the Flathead Reservation the fall rains come in late September or October. During the winter the snow piles in the ravines in the high mountains for summer use. ‘The spring months are delightful. Warm weather comes as early as March, when spring flowers appear. At Missoula, buttercups are usually gathered in February. Butterflies have been taken as early as the middle of February. April and May are delightful months, the latter usually of sunshine. June brings refreshing rains, lasting until after the celebration of our country’s independence. July is likely to be with- out much rainfall, and the first of September is likely to bring showers. In July, August and September there are weeks of sunshine and glorious weather. ‘The rainfall of the year averages 16 inches, varying from 15 to 20 inches. There are no cyclones. From the configuration of the surface of the land, these are impossible. There are few fierce wind storms, such as are experienced on the great plains. Chinook winds occur in this section. ‘These warm winds lick up the snow from the valleys and lower hills, and deposit the moisture on the higher summits. On account of these winds snow does not lie long in the valleys.. There are usually several of these warm winds every winter. At the time of this writing a strong chinook is blowing at Missoula, and the few inches of snow disap- pears fast. Often snow many inches deep may be evapor- ated in a few hours. MINES, CLAIMS, ETc.—There are no mining or other claims, other than the allotments before mentioned, on the range. There are no prospect holes. There need 45 be no litigation whatever after the settlement of the allot- ment claims. The roads are such as are on any open country, where it is easiest to travel. It-will not be neces- sary to have roads through the range. They could hardly be run except around the border, on account of the hills and ridges. THE PABLO HERD.—This herd was started in 1884, with 36 animals brought together. In 1907 it numbered almost 600. Few people will believe there was such a number, but they were on the reservation, without doubt. The annual increment for several years has been between 60 and 100. ‘There have been many sales, perhaps some losses by wild animals, and still the herd has increased rapidly. This herd was sold recently to representatives of the Canadian Government. The understanding was that the entire herd was to be taken except 15 or 20, which Pablo reserved. ‘The price was $250.00 each, large and small, old and young, male and female, delivered at Strathcona, but the. Canadians paid the freight. Pablo suffered the loss in loading and in transportation, paid the expenses of bringing them in from the range, of loading, and of stalls, rope and other material. Two train loads, containing approximately 200 animals each, or about 400, were shipped, one in late spring, the Giner | in late fall. Nearly $100,000 have thus been paid by the Canadians for American animals. The expense to Pablo has been great. They were hard to bring in from the range, and weeks were required to bring together a few bands. Approximately 200 Buffalo are yet on the range, which it was impossible to bring to the shipping point. No doubt many of these are old ones, and least desirable in starting a herd, but with this number there is still a chance for saving a portion of this herd for America. Pablo cannot be blamed for the sale. ‘The reservation is soon to be thrown open, his range will be gone, and so large a herd cannot be maintained without a large and free range. he herd cost him money in the beginning, money for maintenance, and he must dispose of it to any buyer. It is said on excellent authority he would prefer to have 44 ‘NOILLVANASAM GVAHLVIA “AONVY AHL NO ‘GUAH OTAVd AHL AO NOILNOd V “AX ALWI1d them kept in America, but saw no opportunity to sell to the Government, and they could not be sold to private parties. The Pablo herd should not have been permitted to leave the country. ‘The range outlined in this report will hold a herd twice the size of the original Pablo herd of 600, and still have food for as many more animals of other species. ‘Che cost of the range will not be as great as the loss to the nation of the herd that has been sold. If the money that should have been put into the herd is now in part put into this range, and in part into animals, in a few years the increment will be such as to make a herd of which the nation may be proud. OTHERVANIMATS HAT MAY BE PUE INTO THE RANGE. ELK.—Several men in the Flathead Valley, 60 or 70 miles north of the present range, have elk parks in the valley country, where many of these noble animals are raised. One man has more than 50, some with very fine heads of horns. ‘The present range 1s admirably adapted to elk. The timber on the hills and along the streams is suited to their habits, and the range outside of the tim- bered section will give them miles of running country. A start may be had from animals in the country. ANTELOPE.—The range is admirably suited to the prong-horned antelope, which is fast disappearing, and needs greater protection. In a few places in Montana there are still herds to be found, but a range like the one proposed will give the natural conditions for a home. DEER.—Western Montana has both white-tailed and black-tailed. (mule) deer in numbers. ‘The Indians have had free range in killing on the reservation, and here they are scarce. It is quite likely that licks could be established on the range before fencing, and animals thus enticed into the limits of the range before it is fenced. A drive might bring in both species of deer. The Columbian black-tail would also thrive here, without doubt. By planning ahead, animals could in all proba- bility be secured from the wild animals of the vicinity. 46 There is considerable undergrowth in the timber, and along the rock ridges there is quite a little growth of bushy plants, enough to supply food of this kind for a fair sized herd. RocKY MOUNTAIN SHEEP.—These animals formerly roamed over this entire section, and several bands are in the adjacent mountain ranges. ‘They should do well on this range, as it has open summits, rock cliffs, timbered ridges and open slopes. Rocky MOUNTAIN GOAT.—While there are no sum- mer snow banks in the range, there are cool springs and ravines. ‘he goat should be able to hold its own, even if it does not thrive as well as the other animals mentioned. BLUE GROUSE.—Several of these birds were flushed while walking through the timber. There is an abund- ance of food for summer, and excellent nesting cover. RUFFED GROUSE.—No ruffed grouse were seen on my visits, but along the Jocko and Mission Creeks they are found, without doubt, and in the brush and thickets around the springs and along streams is their natural home. WESTERN SHARP-TAILED GROUSE.—In the cultivated fields these birds are often found in large-sized flocks. They may be on the range. BoB-WHITE.— This eastern game bird has been intro- duced around Missoula, in the Bitter-Root Valley, and in the Flathead Valley. They have done well, and have greatly multiplied. During the summer they may be heard any day around the upper end of Flathead Lake. In the range they would have plenty of food in summer, but would ‘probably need attention in winter, unless some crop was grown for them. NAMES.—The names of creeks, ridges and mountains are all of Indian origin. Quilseeh (Red Sleep), mountain, was named for Mrs. Duncan McDonald. Seelaw, mountain, named for one of the United States Indian Judges of the reservation; a leading man, who lived near Dixon and died in 1906. 47 ‘VGVNVO OL LNAWdIHS YOU ACVAN ‘GUYH OTdVd FHL AO NOILNOd Vv *poary *f “WW Aq *Zo6r GusuAdog TASS Avot Wheewheetlchaye (many grizzly bear), ridge, with summit east of Quilseeh; named for an old Pend d’Oreille Indian chief. Inskaltesshin (a dead dragon), ridge and gulch, lead- ing south from Quilseeh. Kaiimi, gulch and creek, named for an old Indian, now dead. Chimtaupeh (bob-tail), gulch, named for an old Indian. ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS.—-Duncan McDonald, of Ra- valli, was kind enough to ride with me over the range and give me much help in understanding its general features: amd character. Ele gave me the imformation about the springs and streams, and in regard to the feeding capacity of the range. Col. Rankin, Indian allotting agent for the Government, has rendered great assistance. I am indebted to him for the map of the range, and for other courtesies. Major W. H. Smead, of Missoula, permitted me to photograph and use his map of the Flat- head Reservation, marked in sections, and with all lines and streams indicated. Many others have rendered assist- ance In minor ways. 49 PoE, PROPOSED, NEW YORK*sf#A 78 BISON HERD. At the annual meeting held in January, 1907, Pro- fessor Franklin W. Hooper proposed a movement for the establishment of a herd of American Bison in the Adirondacks, to be owned and maintained by the State, on State lands. The proposal received the immediate approval of the Society, and the Executive Committee was directed to take such steps as might be necessary to carry the idea into effect. Mr. Madison Grant prepared a bill to provide the necessary legislation and a fund of $20,000.00 with which to fence a large area, of ten or twelve square miles, erect such sheds and corrals as might be necessary, purchase about 15 pure-blood bison, and transport them to the pro- posed range. The bill provided that the whole under- taking should be under the management of State Commis- sioner of Forests, Fish and Game, Mr. John D. Whipple. The bill was introduced in the Assembly by Assembly- man Frank "C. Elooper, of Essex, and in the Senate by Senator George H. Cobb. The Assembly Committee on Ways and Means promptly granted a hearing on the bill, at which Professor Hooper, Dr. Hornaday and Mr. Harry V. Radford appeared in support of the measure. There was no opposition. On the contrary, Chairman Sherman Moreland, Speaker Wadsworth, and all the members of the committee were not only friendly to the measure, but they facilitated its progress. The following are the names of the members of the Ways and Means Committee of the Assembly for 1907 :— SHERMAN MORELAND JAMES T.. ROGERS JEAN L. BURNETT JOHN K. PATTON JESSE-S. PEEPS JAMES K. APGAR EDWIN A. MERRITT, JR. J. MAYHEW WAINWRIGHT GEORGE H. WHITNEY MERVIN C. STANLEY GARY H. Woop JAMES OLIVER THOMAS J. FARRELL 50 Senator Cobb’s bill was referred to the Finance Com- mittee of the Senate. At the hearing which was granted by that committee, Mr. Hornaday appeared in behalf of the measure, and there the whole matter was received in the most friendly spirit. ‘Through the initiative of Sen- ator Armstrong, chairman, the bill was recast in the briefest form possible, and it was inserted as an item in the annual supply bill. On that basis it was approved by both Houses, and the conference committees, and finally passed as part of the supply bill. In effect, the members of both branches of the Legislature were unanimously in favor of the immediate establishment of a State Bison herd, as proposed by The American Bison Society. The membership of the Senate Committe on Finance In 1907 was as follows :— WILLIAM W. ARMSTRONG JOTHAM P. ALLDS HENRY WAYLAND HILL WILLIAM J. TULLY OWEN CASSIDY MARTIN SAXE JOHN N. CorpTs WILLIAM T. O’ NEIL JOHN RAINES SAMUEL J. RAMSPERGER DOMINICK F. MULLANEY ©CHARLES H. FULLER THOMAS F. GRADY All friends of the American Bison, in general, and the members of the Bison Society in particular, are indebted to Speaker James W. Wadsworth, Jr., Senators Arm- strong, Cobb, Hill and Raines, and Assemblyman Hooper, Moreland and Merritt. The generous spirit in which the matter was received by the New York Legislature as a whole, may fairly be regarded as an index of the interest which nearly all intelligent Americans feel in the per- petual preservation of America’s most conspicuous wild quadruped. Coincident with the final passage of the supply bill, the Bison Society received what it regarded as a trust- worthy intimation that Governor Hughes was friendly to the proposal for a State Bison herd, and might be expected to approve the item. Nevertheless, both Assemblyman Hooper and the President of the Society wrote the Gov- ernor, separately, requesting a hearing. In making the application Mr. Hornaday took occasion to state pointedly 51 some of the reasons why the proposition should be carried out, and assured Governor Hughes that its practical success was beyond question. The two requests for a hearing were not answered, and therefore it was supposed that the Governor was satisfied to act without further information. Favorable action was confidently expected, and the officers of the Society purposely refrained from troubling the Executive with correspondence. To the members of the Bison Society, and many others, Governor Hughes’ veto of the item for an Adirondack herd came as a profound and painful surprise, than which no action could have been more unexpected. The Governors’ reasons for the veto were recorded as follows :— “Tt is doubtful, to say the least, whether there ever have been any Bison in the Adirondacks, and the policy of attempting to maintain Bison there is questionable. In view of the many demands upon the Treasury of the State, and the many improve- ments which it has been found necessary to curtail, I should not feel justified in approving the item.’ Although the officers of the Bison Society are astounded, they are not in the least dismayed. The 8,000,000 people of New York State desire to have a Bison herd of their own, on land which they own in the Adiron- dacks, and they are both able and willing to pay the very trifling sums that it will cost. They know without being told in measured words that such a herd would in a short time increase to such proportions that every small city in this State could presently be supplied with a breeding pair of Bison for its public park, to interest millions of people, young and old, and to testify to the interest that the Americans of to-day feel in the splendid species which the Americans of thirty years ago so nearly exterminated. When such a measure has passed the New York State Legislature wnanimous/y, it is a sure sign that the people desire the thing for which it provides. ‘The report of Comptroller Glynn, published in December, announces that the surplus in the State treasury at the close of 1907, exclusive of all bills payable, was the very comfortable 52 sum of $13,678,138. In view of this fact, it would appear that the Legislature was within bounds when it authorized an expenditure of $20,000, with which to establish a herd of Bison in the Adirondacks. WOM Gecal: 53 WUVd TVOIDOIOOZ AHL NI STVUYAOD NOSIX AHL LV ALNHOD AHL Per POUNDING OF THE WICHITA NATIONAL BISON HERD. By WILLIAM JT. HORNADAY. In 1901, the Kiowa-Comanche Indian Reservation, in southwestern Oklahoma, was by act of Congress opened up for settlement. When Congress enacted the law throwing open the Indian reserves of Oklahoma for settlement, it also created of the Wichita Mountains and the plains adjacent thereto, a national forest reserve con- taining 60,800 acres. By a proclamation issued by President Roosevelt, on June 2d, 1905, the whole of this National Forest Reserve was designated by authority of an act of Congress (33 Stat. 614), as a national game preserve, withdrawing the whole area from agricultural settlement and dedicating it to the preservation of wild quadrupeds and birds of national importance. In view of the fact that this new game reserve em- braced some of the best grazing grounds of what once was the great southern herd of American Bison, it occurred to the Director of the New York Zoological Park that an opportunity had been created for the founding of a Gov- ernment herd of American Bison, under exceptionally favorable conditions. It seemed evident that in view of the light snowfall in Oklahoma, and the fact that formerly millions of Bison inhabited the plains of Oklahoma and Texas, all the year round,—subsisting by natura! grazing throughout the winter,—that it would be entirely possible for Bison to maintain themselves at the present day, all the year round, by grazing. Prior to 1905, it appears that no private individual nor corporation of any kind, ever had offered to the United fates, Govermment a cit of American Bison, as the nucleus of a National herd. In view of the well-known fact that no large species of quadruped can be bred and perpetuated for centuries in the confinement of zoological 55 gardens and parks,—even where the enclosures are as large as those in the New York Zoological Park,—it seemed reasonably certain that the only way to insure the perpetuation of the Bison species for centuries to come lies in the creation of several national herds, maintained by the Government on large areas of grazing grounds. It seemed ‘desirable that for the encouragement of (the National Government in the perpetuation of the Bison species, the scientific institutions of the country, and private individuals also, should do more than offer advice and exhortations to Congress. Accordingly, a formal cummunication was laid before the Executive Committee of the New York Zoological Society, suggesting that the Society should offer to the National Government, through the Secretary of Agriculture, as a free gift, a herd of not less than twelve pure-blood American Bison, of various ages, to serve as the nucleus of a new national herd, pro- vided Congress would appropriate a sufhicient sum of money to erect a suitable fence around a large area of grazing grounds in the Wichita Forest Reserve, and main- fain the gift. This suggestion met with the instant approval of the Zoological Society, and the Director of the Park and the Secretary of the Society, Mr. Madison Grant, were instructed to take all steps that were necessary to carry it into effect. he date of this action was March Loe OO5: On March 25,°1905, a detinite- offer sof a nucleus herd of Bison on the condition outlined above, was made to the Government, through the Secretary of Agriculture. It met with a prompt and cordial acceptance, and the Secretary immediately directed the Bureau of Forestry to co-operate with the Zoological Society in selecting a suit- able range. The Society was invited to send an agent to Oklahoma, to join a representative of the Forestry Bureau in making a careful examination of all portions of the Wichita Game Reserve, and with a view to selecting and recommending a location for the proposed range. On November 22d, 1905, Mr. J. Alden Loring was selected as the Society’s agent for the proposed examina- tion, and he proceeded immediately to Oklahoma, for the object stated above. 56 On February 1st, 1906, he submitted to the Zoologica! Society a report, which may fairly be regarded as a model of its kind. It sets forth with ample fullness of detail the physical character of the whole of the Wichita Forest Game Reserve—its elevations, soil, vegetation, timber, grazing-grounds, water supply and climatic conditions generally. It discusses intelligently all the difficulties that are liable to be encountered in establishing a herd of Bison in that region, and finally furnishes a map showing the area selected by Mr. Loring and Mr. E. F. Morrissey, then Supervisor of the Wichita Game Reserve. In accordance with his instructions from the Society, the bison range proposed and shown by boundaries on the map, contained twelve square miles of territory, and is situated in the western center of the Wichita Reserve as a whole. In the area proposed as the range for the new bison herd, there are abundant grazing grounds, consisting of gently rolling prairie, covered with choice mesquite grass, buffalo grass and blue-stem. ‘The grazing grounds are practically surrounded by several high, round-topned or rock-capped hills, and cliffs and ridges of red granite rock. Heavy growths of black-jack oak usually cover the slopes, and near the bases of these elevations, black-jack and post oak timber sometimes extend down into the level country fora quarter of a mile. In several portions Of the diorest ‘there’ are trees sixty feet in height. The mountains, hills and timber, taken together, afford abundant shelter for the Bison from the fiercest storms of winter. , The highest peak is about 600 feet in height. The most important grazing ground was christened by Mr. Loring “Winter Valley, “because it makes such an excellent winter range. In this we found many Buffalo wallows, and mesquite grass in sufficient quantities to winter such a herd of Buffalo as it is proposed to place on the range.” The water supply of the bison range is abundant and constant. A fine spring, situated in the northern portion of the range, is the source of Cache Creek, which flows southward through practically the entire length of the 57 AHOVOD LV SNOOVM FHL NO NOSIA AHL bison range, and furnishes a perpetual supply of pure water. There is no impure water anywhere in the range; nor 1s there any possibility that impure water could flow into the range. Mr. Loring’s report was published by the Zoological Society in its Tenth Annual Report (1905), and promptly laid before the First Session of the Fifty-ninth Congress, in which Mr. Madison Grant, Secretary of the Zoological Dociem.-and Din IS. Palmer, of the Biological Survey, rendered most important service. “(hrough the kind co- operation of Hon. John F. Lacey, of Iowa, author of the famous Lacey Bird Law; Hon. James W. Wadsworth, of New York, Chairman of the House Committee on Agri- culture; Hon. James Wilson, Secretary of Agriculture, and other members of Congress interested in the perpetual preservation of the Bison, an item was inserted in the annual Agricultural appropriation bill, providing for an appropriation of $15,000, with which to erect a substantial steel-wire fence, seven feet six inches in height, entirely around the proposed bison range, to erect suitable shelter- sheds, a barn for the storage of hay, flood-gates across all streams, and also to purchase such supplies of hay for use during the first year as might be necessary. Without the slightest opposition, either in the House of Representa- tives or in the Senate, this item was passed with the appropriation bill and became a law. Forthwith the Secretary of Agriculture requested Mr. Gifford Pinchot, Chiet ot the Forest Service, and thereby in sole charge of the Wichita Game Reserve, to take all steps that might be necessary to carry the law into effect and fully meet the conditions proposed by the New York Zoological Society. At the request of the Forestry Bureau, the Director of the Zoological Park prepared plans and specifications for the improvements to be made and designed a series of corrals and sheds for the handling of the Bison herd when not on the range. All these plans were approved by the Forestry Bureau, and forthwith a:contract for the work of erecting the fences, corrals, sheds and other buildings was advertised. The lowest bid for the work was made by Gurley & Paine, of Denton, Tex., and the Forestry Bureau immediately executed a contract with that firm. Work 59 EACH BISON WAS SPRAYED WITH CRUDE. OIL: A PORTION OF THE CORRALS, SHOWING THE SHELTER. began in the late summer of 1906, and was prosecuted thereafter with commendable diligence. It is reported by two representatives of the Zoological Society who accompanied the Bison herd to Oklahoma, that all the improvements made are of the most substantial, workman- like and generally satisfactory character. Notwithstand- ing the fact that the contractors have encountered very great practical difficulties in constructing the fence over rocky ground and up and down steep hills, often necessi- tating the carrying of all materials by hand for iong dis- tances, the work has gone forward in a most painstaking and conscientious manner. In that dry climate, the fences of the new range and corrals should last for a great many years without renewal. All the posts were of hard wood, carefully seasoned, and specially treated, to prevent decay. After extensive inquiries for the best candidate for the position of caretaker of the new Bison herd, the Forestry Bureau finally selected Mr. Frank Rush, who was appointed in the early autumn of 1907, under the tempor- ary title of Forest Guard. Mr. Rush entered upon his duties in the month of September, and established a res1- dence on the Wichita Game Reserve.* The time selected by the Zoological Society for the shipment of the herd under the conditions most favorable to its transplantation was in October, 1907. At the request Of the Society, the Forestry Bureau mstructed Mr, Rush to come to New York, in order that he might become thoroughly acquainted with the herd in its home and accompany the shipment to Oklahoma. After long and careful consideration, the Director of the Zoological Park decided that the only way in which to prevent all accidents to the Buffaloes while in transit, was that each one should be crated at the Zoological Park and transported therein to the corrals of the new bison range. Accordingly, a series of crates were prepared, and for the benefit of Buffalo shippers generally, the dimen- sions are given. *On January 1, 1908, Mr. Rush was appointed Forest Supervisor of the Wichita National Forest. 61 INTERIOR DIMENSIONS OF CRATES FOR AMERICAN BISON. No. 1—For large adult bull: 9 feet long, 5 feet 6 inches high, 3 feet 6 inches wide. No. 2—For bulls four years old and adult cows: 8 feet long, 5 feet high, 3 feet wide. No. 3—-For cows and bulls two years old: 7 feet long, 4 feet 6 inches high, 2 feet 6 inches wide. No. 4—For calves in first year: 5 feet long, 4 feet high, 2 feet 3 inches wide. *In order to get this crate into an Arms Palace Stock- Car, it was necessary to cut off six inches of its length. In these crates no feed boxes were built in. A door nine inches high, on strong hinges, was provided at each end vat the bottom, and both doors were arranged to bolt to the bottom very firmly when closed. ‘The crates were smooth inside and built solidly for two feet up. The framing timbers under the bottom all were made to run lengthwise, and there were no crossboards underneath to interfere with rollers. This precaution is exceedingly necessary, because it is usually impossible to move Buf- faloes in crates save on rollers. At one end, a strong door was made, to slide up and down. This door must always run easily, in order that it may be quickly dropped after an animal has been driven into a crate. Once the animal is inside, the door requires to be bolted with heavy wood- screws, put in with a monkey-wrench. ‘To keep the rear run across from side to side, and secured by nuts and end of a crate from springing apart, two iron rods were washers. For watering a Buffalo in a crate, the best arrangement is a wooden box, about 18 inches square, with sides six inches high, in order that it may be introduced at the feed- door and taken out again at the proper time. This is also to be used as a feed-box in feeding grain of any kind. There are two ways in which Buffaloes may be made to.enter shipping crates. “he best course is by means of a long, narrow chute, with the crate placed at one end, its entrance door raised, and a man posted on top of the crate 62 ‘STVUNOD AHL AO NOILVOOT AHL SNIMOHS ‘KATIVA UALNIM AO NOILYOd V Bix behind the raised door, in order to drop it as soon as the animal enters. The bottom of the crate should be covered with hay, and hay should be strewn along the corral for a few feet of the distance leading into the crate. For loading a large number of Bison, it is much the best that the crates should rest upon a raised platform, similar to that in use at the Zoological Park. ‘The other method is in some respects more difficult. It consists in throwing a lariat around the horns, of the Bison, or around its neck, and dragging the animal in by main strength. This method often is useful as a last resort, and once an animal is roped, it is quickly drawn to its place. When the bison corrals of the Zoological Park were rebuilt two years ago, a permanent chute was erected for the loading of Bison that might require to be sent away. The following animals were selected to constitute the nucleus of the Wichita National Bison herd :— large bull, bie yeats.old: bull, 3% years old, bulls, 2V, years old, spike bull bull calf, 6 months old, adult cows, all breeders, cow, 2% years old, cow, 1% years old, female calf, © months old: Total, 165 head. The Bison thus selected represent four distinct strains of blood, The large biceding bull) is not related” to any of the other members of the herd. It is the belief of the writer, based on recent studies of the development of wild animals derived from a small number of progen- itors, but ranging free on large areas of territory, that on any range for animals as large as that of the Wichita Bison Range, the dangers of evil results from inbreeding are too small to be considered seriously, provided the original stock is sound and healthy. Of course it is well known that diseased parents transmit their diseases to their off- spring, and the greatest evils of inbreeding arise from this source. 64 On, October 10th, between 11 A.M. and 5.20 P. M.., thirteen Bison of the Wichita herd were successfully crated and delivered at the railroad. Trouble was exper- ienced with only two of the fifteen animals. One young cow objected to entering the crate, as also did the largest bull. With a very brief delay, however, both were event- ually driven into their crates, and the whole fifteen head were placed on board the cars at Fordham Station without the slightest accident. Through the efforts of the late Charles T. Barney, Chairman of the Executive Committee, Mr. Dudley Evans, President, and Mr. H. B. Parsons, Vice-President of the Wells-Fargo Express Company, consented that their Company should transport the two Arms Palace Horse Cars containing the Bison from St. Louis to Cache, freevor charge. “Nr james *C. Parco, President of the American Express Company, also offered, on behalf of his company and the New York Central Lines, to trans- port the cars free of charge from New York to St. Louis. These complimentary services were rendered because of the public interest attaching to the object in view, and were equivalent to a gift to the Zoological Scciety of $1,000.00, or thereabouts. In fact, but for this concession on the part of the two express companies, 1t would have been impossible to have shipped the buffaloes by pas- senger train service, in which event the shipment would have been far longer in transit, and the buffaloes would have been much reduced in strength by the long journey in close confinement. The shipment left Fordham Station, New York City, on October 11th, in charge of Chief Clerk H. R. Mitchell, of the Zoological Park, and Mr. Frank Rush, who were also accompanied by Mr. Elwin R. Sanborn, of the Zoo- logical Park staff. Thanks to the experience and knowl- edge of Mr. Mitchell in matters relating to railway trans- portation, the journey from New York to Cache was made in seven days—the distance being 1,858 miles. Naturally, the fact that two carloads of Buffaloes were being sent from a crowded eastern city back to the southern Buffalo range, attracted great attention; and in Oklahoma, 65 ‘NOSId FHL FAS OL AHOVD WOT ANVD OHM SNVIGNI ZHONVWOD AO aNvd V especially, the interest of the public reached the highest pitch. All persons who never have had an opportunity to become familiar with the difficulties involved in shipping a herd of large, hoofed animals by rail, should be advised that such an undertaking involves very serious difficulties and demands first-class ability. In his narrative of the transportation of the herd from the Zoological Park to the Wichita Reserve, published in the Zoological Society’s Bulletin No. 28, page 412, Mr. Elwin R. Sanborn records the following statement :— “Tt would be churlish and a neglect unpardonable not to award to Mr. Mitchell praise for the admirable manner in which the details of the transportation were executed. In every instance, his knowledge of railroad methods and his tireless energy overcame obstacles which would have meant hardship and perhaps death to some of the Bison, and their safe arrival at Cache was due absolutely to his splendid work.” On reaching the town of Cache, it was found that Mr. W. R. Mattoon, Acting Supervisor, in charge of the whole Wichita Reserve, had perfected arrangements for transporting the animals from the railway to the range. A caravan of wagons was found awaiting the arrival of the shipment. Forthwith the crates were loaded upon the wagons and hauled twelve miles across the prairie to the new bison range. On arrival there, the crates were, with- out any great difficulty, unloaded in the corrals, and the Buffaloes were liberated. None of the animals had sus- tained the slightest injury, and all arrived at their new home in excellent condition. In establishing the nucleus herd of Bison in its new home, there is but one danger which affords ground for anxiety. The Wichita Reserve is within the range of the cattle-tick which produces Texas fever, and inasmuch as cattle have previously been grazing over the whole area of the Wichita Game Reserve, it 1s necessary that special care shall be taken to eliminate the presence of that pest from the range. Mr. Rush and Mr. Mattoon have made a careful study of the situation, and have determined upon a plan which certainly promises to be successful. In the 67 first place, the whole area of the Bison corrals has been burned over. In addition to this, all the animals were sprayed with crude petroleum before they were taken from their crates. It isithe imtention of the managers of the herd to spray the animals annually, in case it should prove necessary. A close watch will be maintained for evidences of the presence of the Texas fever tick, and if any are found to have reached any of the Buffaloes, they will be immediately destroyed by the spraying operation. It is also intended, as a further precaution, to burn over about 200 acres of the bison range adjoining the corrals, and surround it by a temporary fence, in order that the herd may be kept entirely under control and close observation during the period that it will be in danger of coming in contact with the fever tick. The Zoological Society has every confidence in the judgment of Mr. Rush and Mr. Mattoon, and believe that the intelligent efforts which they are now putting forth for the maintenance of the herd will be crowned with complete success. Since the arrival of the herd in its new home, two calves have been born, one male and one female, both of which are vigorous specimens and seem likely to SUIVIVE. We confidently look forward to the increase of the Wichita national herd at a rapid rate, and there is every reason to believe that within a very few years a herd of more than one hundred animals will be the result. It is expected and hoped that American elk, prong-horned antelope and mule deer will be liberated in the bison range, and that they will there thrive and multiply along with their natural neighbors, the Bison. There is now a small herd of wild white-tailed deer inhabiting the rough mountain tops and timber of the bison range, and now that they are fully protected, they should increase to satis- factory numbers. This completes the history of the founding of the Wichita national Bison herd up to the present date. We especially commend to the attention of the public the fact that the national Government quickly responded to the invitation of private individuals,—or to speak more 68 correctly, of a scientific corporation,—to join it in this cliore tormihe perpetual preservation’ of the American Bison species. It is highly desirable that all friends of the American Bison should show a practical interest in this work by taking an active part in it and helping to share the initial burden. It 1s reasonably safe to assume that Congress can be persuaded to establish other national herds of Bison in other portions of the United States, provided other individuals, or scientific bodies, will take the initiative in the same manner that was so successfully taken by the New York Zoological Society. AYALHONVIS NOSI€A DIG LSVI S.WUMVN-GNONOd AHIHO AO SNIVNAY GaSOddNsS Bet ¥. P ai a! > . * a oe RE a we idee 5, ~ NERC CENSUS OF LIVING AMERICAN BISON ON JANUARY ist, 1908. COMPILED BY WILLIAM T. HORNADAY. OWNER AND LOCATION MALES | FEMALES Ee TAN. 1, 1908 UNITED STATES ARIZONA: Grand Canyon Game Preserve—C. J. Jones 12 2 1 14 ARKANSAS: Wiener—Albert Huber........eseeeeererees 1 1 0 2 CALIFORNIA: San Francisco—Golden Gate IPAaTK jeje sieieies 11 7 2 18 COLORADO: Denver—City Park.......+seeeeeeerer reste 6 10 2 16 DISTRICT OF COLUMBIA : Washington—National Zoological Park.. 3 5 0 8 ILLINOIS: Chicago—Lincoln Park......:.s+e++erseeees 7 6 5 13 IOWA: Bancroft—C. J. Lenander.......++++-+++++ 4 8 2 12 Buffalo Centre—C. E. Mallory.....+--++++ 3 1 1 4 Davenport—City Park....-+--.sseesee seers 1 a 1 8 Keokuk—Rand Park.......-s+s+seeseee eee 2 2 0 4 KANSAS: Belvidere—Soldier Creek Park.........--- 12 15 8 a MASSACHUSETTS : Newtonville—Norumbega Park......-.--- 3 1 1 4 West Brookfield — Indian Rock Farm 1 1 0 2 MICHIGAN: Detroit—Belle Isle Park......-.++e-s+se00+ 1 3 0 4 Pontiac—Joshua Hill.....-.---++-+sseeeeeee 2 3 1 5 MINNESOTA : Buckman—John Schmolke.......++-++++++- i 2 0 3 Cardigan—James J. Hill......-+---+++eees 4: 2 1 6 MISSOURI: St. Louis—Forest Park.......seeeseeeseeees 3 0 0 3 MONTANA: 7 : Kalispel—Estate of C. E. Conrad....... 30 50 24 80 £7 Ronan—Michel Pablo........- .sseeers ean 106 134 49 240* ~~ NEBRASKA: Friend—J. W. Gilbert........ssseee+ ceeeee 5 2) 1 7 NEW HAMPSHIRE: Newport—Blue_ Mountain Forest Associa- r tion (Corbin Herd).....-.-:esseeeeeeeeees 65 val 20 136 £27 NEW YORK: Buffalo—Zoological Garden 5 2 2 ui Cohocton—B. G. Veeder...... 1 0 0 1 New York City—Zoological Park........ 14 19 10 3 (Also see OKLAHOMA Preserve). Central Park Menagerie.....-.+-+++sseeees 1 4 1 5 Brooklyn—Prospect Park.....--++-++++++0: 0 1 0 1 OHIO: Cincinnati—Zoological Garden..........-- 10 11 6 21 South Newberry—W. B. Cleveland....... 3 4 areas 7 Toledo—City Park.....---seseeeeeeeees ans 2 0 0 2 ieee Wee eS Se * As counted by an agent of the Canadian Government, under the direction of Mr. How- ard Douglas. The sexes were not counted, and the division has been arrived at by the rules of proportion, based on the 398 head previously taken to Canada from this herd. 71 CENSUS OF LIVING AMERICAN BISON ON JAN. Ist, 1908— Continued. OWNER AND LOCATION MALES FEMALES YOUNG BORN 1907 TOTAL ON JAN. 1, 1908 OKLAHOMA: Wichita Game Reserve—U.S. Government Bliss—101 Ranch—Miller Brothers......... Pawnee--Major J. W. Lillie............... PENNSYLVANIA : Philadelphia Zoological Garden.......... Pittsburg—Highland Park Zoo. Garden... SOUTH DAKOTA: Fort Pierre—James Philip.......... aexeistevere TEXAS: Goodnight—Charles Goodnight............ UTAH: Salt Lake City—John E. Dooly........... WISCONSIN : Milwaukee—City Park..... docsoosbadnacodds WYOMING: Yellowstone National Park—Government | Herds. Also see under ‘‘ Wild Buffaloes.” Dot Island, Yellowstone Park............. Wolf—Baton Brothers... -joce cles cer eldcwitiesie a CANADA ALBERTA: Banff—Rocky Mountain Park of Canada.. TURP aL'S Leta Pave eas rcpejeserelece teat sieiers?s eteioue eveislel steverere ATHABASCA : See under *‘ Wild Buffaloes ”’ MANITOBA : Winnipeg—Silver Heights Park.......... ONTARIO: Moronto—Riverdale Park. oot iccjiee cae sics EUROPE BELGIUM : Antwerp—Zoological Gardens ............ ENGLAND : Haggerston Castle—C. J. Leyland........ London—Zoological Gardens............. Woburn Park—Duke of Bedford......... GERMANY: Berlin—Zoological Gardens..........-.... Breslau—Zoological Gardens.............. | Dusseldorf—Zoological Gardens.......... Frankfort, A.M.—Zoological Gardens.. Hamburg-—Zoological Gardens........... Stellingen, near Hamb.—Carl Se Hanover—Zoological Gardens....... ..... Cologne—Zoological Gardens............- Leipzig—Zoological Gardens.............. AUSTRIA : Slawentzitz, U. Selesia— Prince Hohenionel Bohemia—The" Prince: Dis. sac oeseereens | NETHERLANDS: Amsterdam—Zoological Gardens......... Rotterdam—Zovoological Gardens ......... Hilversum—F. E. Blaauw’s Graveland. RUSSIA: Askania-Nova—FPriedrich Falz-Fein...... a about 63 oR Co bo eH He to bo bt 8 2 1 2 9 Roo about 95 35? 23 221* ECO cor~w 32 21 owe 16 81 rProoo°oo+tz new me boe — AMERICAN BISON RUNNING WILD. In Yellowstone Park, estimated by General S. B. M. Young In Athabasca, Canada, estimated by E. T. Seton and Mounted Police eee eee ry * Adults purchased in 1907 from M. Pablo, Ronan, Montana. + One calf born and sold during year 1907. 72 BUFFALO-DOMESTIC HYBRIDS, cCAT TALOERS.. OWNER AND LOCATION TOTAL ON JANUARY 1, 1908 UNITED STATES ARIZONA: Grand Canyon Game Preserve—C. J.Jones IOWA: Bancroft—C. J. Lenander...--.-+seerrrreee KANSAS: Belvidere, Kiowa County—Soldier Creek Tear Ieee seeder reteverecevoie aie raslolateleloseissenoveasncisieysialelerc)e MINNESOTA : Buckman—John Schmolke Cardigan—James J. Hill....---s+eeerseees ciclejeievere a0 0:0'@e\eece MONTANA: Ronan—Charles Allard .....-ssseeserereees OKLAHOMA : Pawnee—Major J. W.. Lillie.........+. ++: Bliss—101 Ranch, Miller Brothers......--- SOUTH DAKOTA: Fort Pierre—James Philip......--+++-++++: TEXAS: Goodnight—Charles Goodnight.......--++ WALAHis2 Salt Lake City—John E. Dooly......----- CANADA ALBERTA: Banff—Rocky Mountain Park of Canada. ONTARIO: Bobeaygeon—Mossom Boyd Company... QUEBEC : Quebec—Holt, Renfrew & Company:.... EUROPE ENGLAND: Haggerston Castle—C. J. Leyland.......- London— Zoological Gardens......++++++++ RUSSIA : Askania Nova—Friedrich Falz-Fein. (South Russia.) bo about 100 13 43 11 males. 46 females. 9 calves in 1907. 1 16 breed. 1 % breed. 15 breed calf. 3 males. 9 females. 2 34 blood calves, born 1907. Bred to 4 and ve. Male, 4 Hereford, infertile. 9 males and 26 females, as follows: 1 3% bison bull. bison bull. bison bulls. bison bulis. 4°34 bison cows. bison cows. bison cows. 9 1g bison cows. 8 calves born in 1907, as follows: 3 3g bison calves, the product of a & bull bison and 1% bison cows. 5 4 bison calves, the product of a 4 bison bull and 4 bison cows. Hybrid between American and European bisons. 3 half-breed males. 1 34 bison male. 1 half-breed female. 2 three-quarter bison females. 1 one-quarter breed female. 73 SUMMARY. AMERICAN, “BISON, OF PURE BLOOD 2 CALVES | TOTAL ON TOTAL MALES | FEMALES | jy 1907 |JAN. 1, 1908|| IN 1903 Captive in the United States... 506 610 203 1116 969 | Captiveiin» Canada. cic s.cccs +0 214 262 98 476 41 Total in America...... steoro(sie (sieeve 720 872 301 1592 1010 Captive in EUurepes. «1.0.6.0 sie. 54 76 22 130 109 Total im) (Captivity jar ciecolste vieicieiel= 774 948 323 1722 1119 Wild Bison in the United States, EEStimMA te leis cleis/ersicicls cls'felos'el sles 25 Wild Bison in Canada, Estimated 300 Total pure blood Bison, Jan. 1, MLGOS Weieieielelslcleicie)s/afejelolalesetess is! sieletoreicioje 2047 Number of owners of pure blood Bison, in America...... 45 Number of owners of pure blood Bison, in Europe........ 19 BUFFALO-DOMESTIC HYBRIDS, S Sp o46 conn cod oaou Philadelphia, Pa. IBICITIC ONE TUBING UB Gada beeken am Boecacae ae peo cd ade Cohassett, Mass. BIGHUO WAT OSE PES sacs aalectem Aoircrneuea sore aetetereerels Cohassett, Mass. BEAIGE WGHOR GES Hisar rare Sec ee cape orem tomie toile aries Worcester, Mass. I EAUICGED ERE Meee Pi ceseranae i artes Aeestniis Gi eodini rhe ah arse cual eereRmals Boston, Mass. 14 Ea RCIEDS EIN BISCMAS esa CIN Ie Renae cae contin ac tN aNE, ele Bien ine eS ica; Melrose, Mass. TO Alles GIA Sr We Ses tustace eet oie ware aobener setts a Gietakeee anmenacetone Chicago, Ill. BI OYMRUDINGAINI WV elec scte ce oocee scone amee a erence ees kers Washington, D. C. BONA AR an EtG WARES) Misc e ae sarc tscanlojentanste IMG VNDINCID eee eee ines ca goo Gooboosspueds Chicago, Ill. ROS SEE cA Sle pRIAURI@ING Gee. renaissance eae ne ane Boston, Mass. REGS Sis alison FIVER Vi Aa cerned eed ty cied ae al ay LIA chet eke Brockton. Mass. ISSIR EDI Se ID ihe Jee Gel SRG seen air mentees eer OR eed Sete ie Lawrence, Mass. SAE OR ID: VIMISSH Astra neo as sate cxshs te monies peste Seth oRiee ene Melrose, Mass. SATNASGAWIDEN SS ELON: oes thee eee eee ee ae Windsor, Vt. SHO TEEN eae NTE WARN Teli 209. eters creas re Ae eee oa ange Hartford, Conn. SAUNDERS iG EIEAURUD IE Sis Garett in nae ceiecies ooio ate Boston, Mass. STARS MISS, UIE ZAR eee oe eg ee et 2 Be Baltimore, Md. SGANIEOIN,; SP Rule Gores ee ae ere eile ere eee St. Louis, Mo. SC Fie RAIN IRAs oi ee ae lene Me Ai Bee oe See Calumet, Mich. SCREEN Soe cei aicvecta arenes ee eee South Manchester, Conn. SCEIUWIPERe Rev. IeiVailINGSMONPRO Willan. one eee Scarsdale, INSRYS BO Bh ey Sy Dy 2 Ne ec ar ee RU a New York City S GWT ea RS to hey eet ee ee ee Lo ee Pittsburg, Pa. SHE PAGED Ss AIC RIBIDE Weta ssojorcave seo eb se tiic see tod aoe Springfield, Mass. SIBNBIEVAIRID)) IMGIGG: IBIMOUUNG IBS. 5 bc noo.oms once oc canuascgsec Brookline, Mass. SEMONDSSGERORGE Hist. ce. cee reeeese: North Andover, Mass. STEAMING HR renga treretes oer. bre ag a ae aye nei el ng eee Boston, Mass. SINGIRET AT BERGE Vitex aL ete, reid wen eee ee ie ne ee Providence, R. I. S MAINED ales Gate Solel tenucsms her ee sr an At nek One ommcie, Vi ete cae New York City SMUT SED IVVeAGR ID Dieleoee wre no ee errs ete eae cn, Sod a Worcester, Mass. SS IVIEAETAR IVS Gy Sse Ss eo et eee aoe An, ey ou Philadelphia, Pa. SIMTAR ES SEI@TE NEG Sie retioee Glee at nope ote ata tees Meee ee St. Louis, Mo. SIMOEIM EIS ONVGNIG DIDI: XG IBOIRIG IES 355 6.50 bap aneooo Season dor Philadelphia, Pa. SIMOMRIAL Dey NWANLILIVAIME IDO)NRID)s ilios auto oeso boo aouedue ace Boston, Mass. S @OUABEVER2 a @EUN Bt eee reer e eier see eae ie Arlington, Mass. SOWA Nbc QIN gens sau cee eae agheean saben ane ocd Arlington, Mass. SIPAIRIRIR TCG SH ©.GaEN seuss arora a secu cde ie eek aar ake alae Worcester, Mass. SIPRVA GOI TS AVA Ge ea ity iad acces ae ane Le Wellesley Hills, Mass. SHARIR Die WB Ee RAN Ae its, Seer eee ae re Buffalo, N. Y. SWE ARINIS SiRIt Bcc sacs crtne ok edhe ee ee en eee Westwood, Mass. SHI RIE BIBI LIM bree Sp aI NGam nc ake tee ne bos coer aad ddim ota blie acon Se Baltimore, Md. SMDERINIS Ge A I Sip leet eit aire isles eins nine soreeyaes Brookline, Mass. SAICIGNI NRO BERT eAIDIAINS ij .crctetiaiere « 6. aise ptesne sewers 3 St. Paul, Minn. SR @ INGE GWAMRUIENIS: Siw A toe sete aerate hla t cate sco sith nieve; spwins cuee es ah oes Boston, Mass. SiOINUE, (GIRVAURI LIS SIS NAG s estes Gere Somimce Cc Ot Eanes Acme Nn ames eecs Boston, Mass. SANGIN DS AM SU OIWARS)” IRL 5 ole ee ee Danvers, Mass. SHARON ALES LA (Cs AN 0 a Ss 1c ra Philadelphia, Pa. SUETETIN ZAIN GS PAU Sys 25) clea lapstesoioretarcn onsale chart etn oem anttietere New York City SIRI RON AVA CO) RU oy 3 ce ae ek ta New York City SWARM. INGER BILE Ee 7 cantacceed orc ciate eaStre Cre oricrce Maen ee Somerville, Mass. SINS), CID HRS BYAIRU C1 IRC) Se 35 51 oc Siena Om OR nner nA New York City sIWARYAIE @ Rae) @VVINGRNGk eters sincere cece ccccete acts cielo cents b> Washington, D. C. aPARVAIE © RGU NIEIES © IN ere srkecccs ea aise popes atvereiectie ere lee New York City DEG BIR @ Glen GEUN RIEL See pena) ceerpeminisccc im docclekic semen New York City TOE) RRS (CODD A UR ee Pte tar ir ane ee ee St. Louis, Mo. AT TAGVaTSIR oe SHEDDING EU Vee i seeara.ctoriarct at sastcmyetde crtvtrs © aneG aie. ers Philadelphia, Pa. SEA @ Vie laa @ ONO] Verges cic otal. oc eile ecse o\cor'arsi gs 0 aso ovals 3altimore, Md. ATOMS Te Nitsa le CDI ONV TM teeter é : : i I ’ , —_ i pos i= -: rl A i ie i : y., , a ' ° 7 » A 7 . os if) , ss? . ‘UeLaWw Wey OC “Iq Aq Yydeusojoyd ‘Q0URISIP 94} Ul SUIBJUNOW UOISSIW ‘UOT]IOd Usa}seay Nos ‘JONVA NOSIA IVWNOILLYN WNVLNOW NI GNOd YaLVMHSAad soins oS fe sent n os ee Poe ee ‘ SECOND MNNUAL REPORT OF THE AMERICAN BISON SOCIETY OBJECT : THE PERMANENT PRESERVATION AND INCREASE OF THE AMERICAN BISON 1908-1909 PUBLISHED BY THE SOCIETY 1909 "4 i ipes Copyricur 1909 BY THE AMERICAN BISON SOCIETY CONTENTS. @PETCER SE OF TUEUE a9 O OME Looe ooo eee ee access Eee en 8 ose ee ses saeeeeeee so eee wae VII IBBOARDMOF IWAN AGERS..--.------2-- 2-2-2. aE ae ee Pe Pa ee VII VEPORINOE ME, PRESIDENT 2. --22-2222-c---ccceececwseeewceeeee eo eee aee een: W. T. Hornaday 1 SUBSCRIPTIONS TO THE Monrana Bison FUND............-.........-- W.T. Hornapay 19 3 y DH EY OF Ya Wer(G OU BU S19 D}R | Gl 211 04 09-1 ce ey ore eee Ernest Harotp Baynes 43 AIRED MEANS NT: UP AcT: Pe VEEN STEN) mee eens ee A ee ede ase ee erases sade ceueeee a sesees 65 BUR SAS URI Se LUE @ Bile wee ose Seer eee ee Uo ee Crark Witttams 69 OAR DIOR: WWEAINGA GER Si IMI ENTEN Goce. ots cn coe oe eee er ee ee ees see aeons eeeeeteacst acess 70 COSNGS STAT COTO ene ae eae soe pea Wise FS eae ne Ste ce nes wee ncresetes 71 Tor a IRI VITESINTIRISTRS oe - 2 ee See Oe ea ee eee one cece ecco ILLUSTRATIONS. FRESHWATER Ponn, Montana Bison RANGE............2-.-2--22:-2-0-200--eeeeeeeee Frontispiece GRAZING Grounp; WONTANA, “BISON [RUA NGE scccoccccscocc cee co eeccsees sa soecc eevee seeesessessseeeuees VIII SENATOR OSE Pia: Mile TX OINj soe ee Ue At nS ae ee 3 IMETSSTON: (CREEK, IMIOINTANUAS STSOIN; [RANGE ooo cccececoeoccece eo ocee scene ee roe ee see eeee eee 6 ASPEN GRovE, Mission CREEK, MonTANA Bison RANGE................22---------------0--- 10 Mission CREEK, NORTH SIDE OF MONTANA BISON RANGE..............---0-----2---000-0--0-=+ 14. Wicuitra NationaL Bison HERD ON ITS RANGE.............2.222.2222--eceeeeeneneeeeeeceeeeeeeees 18 IANTAR? VATLEN,,, VETTOWSEONE, INUATOIGAI: ge AR Kee soe ne ee 44 GOVERNMENT BUFFALO ElERD, ToAnAR VATE Y.2. 25-2222 2e2ee nc cence ee cesepceneeeeese 45 GOVERNMENT) BUFFALO PlerD, WAMAR. VAGUE Y¢. 22 <---:-2c-secs-cesee- cee --ceeeseoeee sees ese 46 Burrato Cow, From THE (CONRAD [MISTATE! 222s ee eee te eee ee 48 BUFFALO) BULL, “KALISPELL (CHER, ? CoNnRAD JHSTATE! 22. -2-2c----2ee cee seeee-- maces Rene eee Bree ses Ree Rte, 1.00 oer a FG. sf 1s ee ee en Oc to 1.00 7.00 New York City—Miscellaneous. EU RNRY, ere Psi eee soe ho se ee eet 50.00 W.7 A BUSH, brookyaiet 225 sae eee eee 50.00 Mrs: Marve Lo Buse, Brooklyn=-=2 ol. 50.00 IVT ADT SOIN; sl GrRRAUNG ok toe an cet nee a ee 25.00 PRANGCIS EYNDE. STETSON:.2--2----- ee 25.00 lee © Av O Neate O Sie eae ee 25.00 JAMES “J, TATGGINSON= oe eee ee 25.00 Mrs. Ricuarp M. Hoe...... Witiram CHurcH Ossporn *RUTHERFORD STUYVESANT Marearet L. Bauau........ CHaRures A. Cass.......-..-....- Mrs. P. Hackxury Baruypt ... W. C. Demorest...............- *RosBert E. Booraen ...... *Joun Ross DELAFIELD... *JoHn F. DEGENER....... *RaLPH. PULITZER: ..:...-.---- , *Miss Louise A. TROWBRIDGE.............--.-------- Bie elerACws eees oe ee SaMUEL P. Avery, JR....... Mrs. M. A. P. Draper... @Cuarius S. Hirscu-.-=.... Drie Lhaupe ir mee a JoHN Buriina LAWRENCE .........-..--------2-0----- Rees IOuUNSBERY 22. SAG PES DimNst Morris KINNEY ........-..-.. Fo. JAMES JRBIULY - 2.2.2. Woopsury G. LANGDON.... ELLEN COLLINS: ..2:..2::.-2.... JEFFERSON SELIGMAN ...... WarRREN DELANO, JR....... JoHn I. D:; Bristou.-.-.2.:.- Mrse DaiCy Bist. 2 Ereps SAUTER | 22 *JoHN Jay WHITE, JR..... * NELSON: (CAVLOR: <..:2 5. Dr. L. T. CHAMBERLAIN.. Miss ANNA RIKER SPRING le Borron, BANGS 2222-2. *CuHarRLes H. TowNnseEnp.. ArtHur Louis DuNnHAM .. Joun W. T. NicHors....--. *G:ATBERT (GRAY 2.22.2... CAR SEUUZ eee ee ee ee Proressor H. C. Parker *CLINTON G. ABBOTT.......- Emma C. EInpury ............ Sara Conant OstTRom...... Royce Panpock .............- GO. Suimips 2 12] OAS) Jes “top, (GaN N ee eee ee Jnwespepanie, (Gy ANs IBhovehie ees S/he Crupee se Wit Ghani Seu Ost... KENNETH BINGHAM ........ 25.00 25.00 25.00 25.00 20.00 20.00 15.00 10.00 10.00 10.00 10.00 10.00 10.00 10.00 10.00 10.00 10.00 10.00 10.00 10.00 10.00 10.00 10.00 10.00 10.00 10.00 10.00 10.00 10.00 10.00 Yonkers. Mountainville. *JuLES BREUCHAUD ...... Jal, JG, lOheanwine Se HS =P... (Miowmton:...- JoHN C. HAvVEMEYER.... Cart EICKEMEYER ........ Albany. Eye Ania mivAnD Site eee Mrs: Dran SAGE 2 DuprEy Oncorr 2. WitwiaMm O. STILLMAN.. Jess NV EIPPL Ena eo ALBERT KE. DENNISON .. Buffalo. co) the, (Ge a Garvannyaichiceeey RurPertT STARBIRD ......-- Mrs. Asner P. Nicuo.rs Mrs: Eo Mea. Cary Collected by Jules Breuchaud. Collected by Sherburne M. Shaw. Mary S. Brewster, Mountainville................ Epwarp A. Stevens, Franklin, N. H........... Aueusta W. Brown, Brooklyn, N. Y. C..... Miscellaneous Cities in New York State. = TworsHRimnpsia News blaven-2 2-2 =-- GerorGe D. Barron, Ry Ce ee eee eoete come EMiny jE. i. SKEEL,, Irvington 222 Mrs. W. A. WapswortHu Mrs. Bensgamin D. Hic , Geneseo.....----s--<---- Ks, Old Westbury... E. H. Goprerrroy, Neversink Lodge, Godeft- DRO Vines 2O oar ee ee ee Pee ee *Harry V. Raprorp, North Creek................ *CuarLes B. Davenrorr, Cold Spring Phambor ls licens en ee cer «J. ArvEen’ Ilorine; Owego ee. eae OO OO OO 00 00 OO OO OO OO 00 OO ee 10.00 5.00 100.00 50.00 10.00 2.00 1.00 1.00 A016) 00 .OO OO mt kt 2 Or .0O0 OO OO .OO .0O ee 50.00 50.00 10.00 10.00 10.00 10.00 5.00 5.00 5.00 11.00 5.00 WaLErane ns. (GaAvInn, Meyone:..02..2..2224. 5.00 Dr. LAwrRENCE Brown, Saranac Lake... 2.00 Miss#ii> le lunpy, Bronxville:..2. =... 1.00 GrorGE H. Cunnincuam, Valley Cottage... 1.00 *S. D. KrrrrepGe, Hastings-on-Hudson_....... 1.00 MASSACHUSETTS. Boston. Collected by Mrs. Ezra Ripley Thayer. *Mrs. Ezra Riptey Tuayer, Boston............ 200.00 Mrs. AcNes W. Van Brunt, Hingham........ 50.00 Mrs. Mary B. BranpreGeEr, Jamaica Plain... 50.00 Mrs. I. Morris Murray, Abington, Conn... 30.00 Mrs. Ranpotepu M. Criark, Pomfret, Conn. 25.00 Miss Exreanor J. CxiarK, Boston...........-:-...--- 25.00 Mrs. Wittiam Enpicort, Boston...............- 20.00 Miss Exizasetu R. Simmons, Cambridge.... 10.00 Mrs. WiLi1AM Brewster, Cambridge............ 10.00 Mrs. M. M. KimsBatu, Pomfret Center, Conn. 10.00 Mrs. Georce L. Brapiey, Pomfret Center.. 10.00 Mrs. Hersert T. Jounson, Boston.............-. 10.00 Mrs. CourrLtanp Hoppin, Boston.........-.....- 10.00 Miss Apetge P. Tuaver, Boston...............:. a 8.00 Mrs. M. C. Burnuam, So. Hamilton, Mass. 5.00 Muster J. 6 Daaver,’ Elingham. 2... .: 5.00 Miss Eveanor A. THayer, Hingham............ 5.00 Miss Etuet R. Tuayer, Hingham................ 5.00 Mrs. J) B.. Tuaver; Concord; Mass.....-......... 5.00 Mrs. Futuer, Saratoga Springs, N. Y....-.... 5.00 Miss Furuer, Saratoga Springs.................... 5.00 DR We So] bHAvnR,. baltimore... 5.00 Master Nep Murray, Abington, Conn....... 1.00 Miss Mary Vinron Murray, Abington........ : 1.00 510.00 Collected by Frederic H. Kennard. RMD MRC) elle wKCHIN NUARD oe. eeu ee 100.00 GAR ZANDER SONG ee eee eh ae eee ees 50.00 Dianna lee MEATCGNTAUNE <3 se eee 50.00 IGtiogspray gels 1a Gomerinpon yoy ony ee ee eye een ee 25.00 GEEARIEE SS a COO Kes = eee 10.00 ONE eS TG ENE OW eee ee 10.00 a CEVARIEETS eV Vos UR Gel Sie sae es See Sete 10.00 ILONAS? Save OCK WOOD. eres e252 ee 10.00 RircraARpy Mie SA TONST AT. wes eee ee ee 10.00 INITSSeG On Ae le(@ THA Kinin ee eee eee ee 5.00 W. H. Lincotn, Longwood, Brookline........ 5.00 Miss Ecrten Cuase, Brookline......................-- 5.00 Dr. C. CuEerver SuHattruck, Boston.............. 8.00 293.00 5 Collected by John C. Phillips. JOMN. Cee HInniPps:) (Bostonee- es. ; 150.00 Mrs. J. C..Puiriuires, Washington, D. C....... 50.00 Tuomas E. Procror, Boston. ne SEE 25.00 Mark Hopkins, Bryn Mawr, Pa. 20.00 245.00 Collected by William Lyman Underwood. AD Wate ae AUT KON Gio ne oe ey ee 100.00 He OF Unvperwoons- ae z 25.00 125.00 PermeraGe BROOKS: (ie ee 100.00 Arraur EF. EisrasrRook........-......-.... ~ 100.00 cals Jer, TOI ee ee Gy has 25.00 OTN Aula ANE OINIS UNA reese ee 25.00 Mrs. Henry S. GREw...........---- SS eee by 25.00 27 SAUMUR a LO) Sem VAUD RU Nie ee oe Se 25.00 [ee CaRmERED emNINO 22a v2 Fe 25.00 Collected by Miss Harriet BE. Freeman. *Miss HARRIET EK. PREEMAN........-------<------<--- 8.00 LOGIN, (Ge (Orowovnance eG Le 1.00 poi Dieu 2) aa gta: see in ee ea oes Snellen cnr On ee aye he Bae, 1.00 Spore iin ore eee ake eee Caen ON ses BEY DL 2 eh i ee 1.00 EERE NPOELUN Doe Luca ee Gee cee ee 1.00 Dey dd Shae) cs WA) Oe ee meee aie as JT a a Pease 4 1.00 yo © Yet) to NCH alee ee ac Ie Pan RON rt Br ce 1.00 SPU Avs UA aha as gk oe Re een cesar tees id reg ae ce 1.00 Miss Scaruet, Intervale, N. H..................... 1.00 C. L. Freeman, Intervale............. 1.00 E. H. Freeman, Intervale............................-- 1.00 EF. W. Freeman, Intervale..........-...:..:5........- 1.00 F. W. Freeman, Jr., Intervale...................... 1.00 20.00 Collected by John Phillips Reynolds. JouHn Puituirs REYNOLDS...........-.- Be Ae ree? 5.00 Francis S. Earon ............ ab paris Be SEITE Ln Phe 10.00 ROBERT SALTONSTALE, 22-22 ph ie eel ne 5.00 20.00 Collected by Hazen Clement. ule WAyAnNfe (Ghonany ouNpan Gye OT es ee 2.00 Er SV VERN Veo ic Coon eee eee eta este Ae ooh ee ae 2.00 (igs & Uae © (oh Seed Oe EE eee eB 2.00 Wise ale yoveon ne ee 2.00 JPpiavNsp Vo}, ME urbolonngoraVNigh fy 5 2.00 JoHN PETTIGREW ...... : 6 The Lae 2.00 12.00 Boston—Miscellaneous. *Wittiam Russe_L Hauuerr . 10.00 *CuHarRLes P. Bownpircm....... Did At 10.00 L. Carrerer Frnno Vee aoe 10.00 IVI seiste) NS SMM 2 ne ooo ee ce RS 10.00 ECEEMENT 95 MlOUGHTON ::2:22.. 2.224 10.00 ca(Gapvoisvevay Wee J Gaohvaroh en oy wa eee amen ee ee eae 10.00 GRENVILLE lela INORGROSS.-\-.--. 2.2.22. -22- 22. 10.00 PACs Fells Ties NWA Voces cece = ee eo 10.00 IV ie Seve heat On S EAU INU @ Keen es ae 10.00 SIOEUN: Ate URINGLAM he ed 10.00 *HRANK BREWSTER .....-------:2-------2220ees0e-0eeeee--- 5.00 S00) 6 ee AR dee OER Re 5 ee Re eee 5.00 IN [GSS ea Vee te 1 se ee see ere ee eee 2.00 ei) maa eee (Gy OT) AGING Sees eet set ees ere nes ee 2.00 VV SIFT TUE Tepes oie en ee eee a Ey SY EE ete 1 JWAtvaleel Fella VIAN TS TON ee ne es eas cee ee oe ee es 1 EVV alle LOA CT SiisTiN eee ener eee ee Te 1.00 James E. Meyers 1 1 RoswELt B. LAWRENCE ALLEN Porter, Aberdeen, Boston................ 1.00 Concord. 22) Dayan D ed bee | RYN ch tao) 8) ee eee ee ee 50.00 Mars Eanrnracel jen Vim eeele ee e 5.00 Collected by Miss Phyllis W. Brown. Miss (Prrvimis W. BROWN. --2---<2:e---<-2-2------------ 1.00 Mass) Syvrwaa IE. BROWN -.-2.:---2-------2 Reet ae. Oe 1.00 Readville. VV sroranrs THAN Team se TH G1O UI sees eee eee ee eee 25.00 Miss Corner, FP. Worcorn....-...2..2.--..<--2-2- 10.00 Milton. 2A EAU DE ROR BEG) ote seoeee cane eee ee 25.00 Collected by Edward A. Hurd. CORD VV AVR Die A ae bal UR) ste eee ee ee ee ; 2.00 (CRE el ui 1 See ee eee ee 1.00 Nisha Gs hun De oe - e ee e e 1.00 Mrs. Groner A. NBWEUi..----:-22-2:-2cccce20zens1---2 1.00 Miss Mary G.: Denny, Brookline.................. 1.00 RESP (GuAN Pe eee ee eee ee ee ee 1.00 Cambridge. AV rcriPAIGAUN Tipe Es REVISING es oe ee Senos ee esc ee 10.00 OR IIVTENIERID IE Sy eel Ve AUNT eo eee ne re ee 5.00 Leominster. Collected by W. H. Chase. ENT, 0 1) Bs (aoe On AIS pice = oe mr Ue ger eel RE ee 2.00 pA Oras NR sp reas sk Tepe nee nN Be cea APO ope ae 2.00 PAG ae Nee Tar ST) Anis ine We ase Peto eee ean SR ee ony Be De 2.00 VAVGACTH Ts obs ee VETTE se ee ee ees eens 2.00 IEG senraceum elena Gio @ eee ee as ee ee See 2.00 10.00 Arlington Heights. SOON dia MNOWMMEHTR ss a a ee ee 5.00 MRSS. JOLIN Ihe S OUSREND Ree ere 5.00 Lenox. Mass Saran Mi. ScuHimrrecpin..<.----.-.-..-.- 5.00 Miss Jaevorsm: Miryur) 2-2 5.00 North Andover. 25 (Gs ads tS TINT OUND) See eee se 2.00 2 (Ga SNE OSS a Ree oer aie ee me eee 2.00 Hingham. Rev. Georce Francis Wextp, Hingham........ 2.00 EvizABETH JT. MILES ........ NCEE ee eee re 1.00 Westfield. IN Reed Bie \ Widen Goh Spl hie meet eee ek eee 1 eae SES Le 1.00 iW iacy IME 1835 WiWaeaGponee oe ee 1.00 Miscellaneous Cities in Massachusetts. *TOHN 4. (HAVER, ILancaster, 2.93.08 250.00 Witiiam P. Wuarton, Groton..................--.- 100.00 *ArtuHuR WuHitTIN, Whitinsville .................... 25.00 *SamuEL C. Lawrence, Medford.................- 25.00 *Lemuret F. Woopwarp, Worcestev.............- 10.00 F. B. Greene, New Bedford.........-...-......:-..- 10.00 *Tsanc SPracur, Wellesley Elillse= 2.52. 10.00 “FRipnps;: Newburyport: =... 2.42.5. 10.00 *Wittarp G. Van Name, Springfield............ 10.00 Lavinta M. P. Brackett, Brookline............ 5.00 *ArtHuR A. Carey, Waltham..................-..-.. 5.00 Dry es Ce Jones \Maldent se ee 5.00 The Christian Register. Mrs. Frances C. Warinwricut, Milton........ 2.00 Miss F. H. Gunneman, Roxbury.................. 1.00 Everett CarzLeton, Rockdale ...................... 2.00 MarGaret Morsst, Amherst.................-..-------- 2.00 MINNESOTA. ‘St Paul Collected by Howard Elliot. SEOWARD Hino Des ee pene sree _ 1,013.00 Ay MCrEranpise. Se en eee oe 1.00 Re BG. Breanne: 1.00 PETER SIERUS ......-- ‘< ieee 1.00 WaLtER JACKSON 1.00 3.00 ASO Eee oa i Ge el et ee a en ee 1.00 Gia NEN CRENORSON 2 sees ore 1.00 +] Jett CAG Pe per ee Be) og 1.00 Wie i iA (D0 pe er ee 1.00 Sige Na, SONGIN NER e ous ee ee 1.00 Te POR D Wve ce en ee 1.00 eet ootped ACG ONY fees tee ee ew acme ee 1.00 AWESOME 9 221 Sit oly re ae alle oat Ra ae en AN Se EO 1.00 ESR. Bicktow 2222.22. BU pee Se ee ines ae 1.00 Wet © ee URI Dee nea eee te ee, ON aca 1.00 GUSTAVE JSCHOLLE: Scene 1.00 CPi lrrrine pismarck. No) en oes ek 1.00 Cuarues E. Perkins, Burlington, Iowa........ 1.00 1,030.00 *GEORGE M. KENYON. 20222252.224.2222.2002---0ceccee-02- 10.00 Epwin Wuite & ComMPANV..........-...-------------- 1.00 Deep Haven. *Miss ARIEL BURTON.......-......--------22--cee0eee0---- 10.00 Albert Lea. | Bras ad Gr ora 08 ee oe 1.00 WiG CHANMBERIAAUN 2-202. 22--0 22 eee 1.00 ALBERT Lea Hive anp Fur Companvy...... = 1.00 PENNSYLVANIA. Pittsburgh. Collected by John M. Phillips. *JOHN® NL. PRA UIPS: 22 202-2 ee meet 25.00 Dee Pace GO THe Oe Se te OO hens ere oN a 10.00 RoBrR Ty Eee rit EPS eee 10.00 IVVPAUE'S ONG peat ie EUs ne Sie ee ee ee 10.00 WOHING CP) SGRVESSROWIN 2.2 304o ss eed ne 10.00 WaT TANG Hye, SAN RaGY 0: ec) ett oe AY Ane e F og - 10.00 TORING. HS AUN Ron Vee oe 2 ee ce eee se 10.00 MUERONENG GA NOY 2 ek TS Oe 10.00 WitrraM J G ILe MON... ee ee 10.00 SAUER SautNese SPAR Vil Goose os Pea 3 10.00 GRORGE? Ne *MIONRO*...cele ee 10.00 eer AN One ee oe Ee ee ee 10.00 co Hee ee VO RSE sees ter ten oy ee en es Se 10.00 Wirnirante Ele GomCORD =: 2-0... Bo) 10.00 dee hat STONRHROAD ©2282 ere 10.00 AOEUINGE Cone GO) EI Viniee ee ee, aS eae RS 10.00 | alah LAs EPPO oe eee ree ete A cs ae wn Bee ee 10.00 Hianinve Onivinny a ee 10.00 ATBERT Gu IBREVRWIESER: 202.0902. 220s sees 2222-2 10.00 IE AUN TE Toles SENS © Eien ae ede Sy eae he Seed ae 10.00 CHARTERS SOD MECHE: 252... re as Bee 10.00 WiiiiamM Maxwert.t KENNEDV..........--.----------- 10.00 29 Wel, Miers ONG eS an ote eee ee nf IECRIARNT Keer SANE Vp yee a eae es Le MLE SIDE ONES 2 ae ee ences pee eee es Cae ae VV WASTE Tres Fem) ToXC IN eee eee a) (GIEEENIE EIEN) RAIN Sees ee ee eee, ete 2 eer AEE SST NS VAUNIIE. ORD eee ee ee ee JosEPH Maxkary, Carrick Boro.....................- Mrs. Wiui1am E. Sankey, Carrick Boro.. Mrs. Joun M. Puiwuipes, Carrick Boro.........- Humemr J. Karr, Carrick Boro]... ——S Grorce Wooprorp, Carrick Boro........-....-...- lL. W. Rosrnson, Punxsutawney...............----- Epwin W. Rosinson, Punxsutawney............ W. R. ScuucuMEN, Homestead...............-...--- Maurice J. Lunn, Baltimore, Mid.......:..:-.-.-- FLercuer Coniins, Pittsburgh -.....-.2:...2--:- CHARLES ScHAwRM, Pittsburgh-..................... Pe, Hoslockn,. Pittsburgh: 3 = eee ee RW. ocker, Pittsburgh = | ao eee Witiiam HENNING, Pittsburgh....................-. Winans TRore,.-bittsburehl2.22 2s Georce L. Gotpsacu, Pittsburgh.................. AV Pe MinceRr, Patisburghi-2=. 2222. Jada MGEMUNG, oP itis bume lc. 2 eesee <2 DAeAS ab mek, /Pittsbur gies ee. neste W.os. Brown; Pittsburohcn = i222... Grorcre C.) Minis, Pittsburgh 2-22-22 JosepH Ff. Eeny,: Pittsburgh...2 22 Joun Weeer, Pittsburgh. 22255-22222. Danie, 2. Bere, Pittsburgh 2.2--- Orro MvuEtueErR, Carrick Boro....-:.......-....-..--- J. S. Burrermore, Carrick Boro..............---- J Ad. Haup a, Carrick pOross.s et. James Stewart, Carrick Boro..............-...------ Joun F. Sarirz, Carrick Boro........ cae ee Wituiam P. Baumaart, Carrick Boro.......-.... Freep. H. Anrporn, Carrick Boro:-...--.--.-.-- Georce J. Knieut, Carrick Boro..............---- Cuarires Kountz, Carrick Boro-.-.......-----<---- Di Jee SMEris, Carrick DOno.sisc-s. es oe eee ees Ro 2 Rossery, Carnck is0ro!2 5 C. F. Baxmeyver, Carrick Boro.............--.------ R: By Hanser; Carrick Boro. 22. ..2---- Mark F. Roserts, Carrick Boro..........--...----- Joun Bennett, Carrick Boro...........-..--.------- Gustave Wipe, Carrick Boro .......--..---------- Joun H. Nusser, Carrick Boro........:-..----:----- B. ALinweiyn, Carrick Boro. -2--..- = Wittram McCuure Dontey, Carrick Boro-.. 30 Sr Go Or Or Gr Or ee ee ee ne ee eee Ne Ee ee ee ee ee . . . . (amtye JO5 to pitemDhe ©o OO .0O .0O OO OO OO 00 .0O 00 OO OO OO OO OO OO OO OO OO OO OO OO Wiviuiam C. Waewner, Carrick Boro.............. Ropertr A. ScHNEIDER, Carrick Boro Tuomas J. McGovern, Carrick Boro Henry LanpeFreELp, Carrick Boro Eienry: ABEL, Carrick. Borosi.2cccecc-2- awe t Atois Winter, Carrick Boro................-..-..---- JoHN SEIFERTH, Carrick Boro Rosert Trost, Carrick Boro CC) Bo Cuurcu,, Carrick. Boros:-.-5------------ Henry Scuenck, Carrick Boro J. A. Wuiteman, Punxsutawney..............-..--- A. W. Catitoway, Punxsutawney Dave FriemineG, Punxsutawney Georce P. Lutuer, Allegheny Dr. Witt G. Anpair, Allegheny Prep. GwinNer, Allegheny 2 222.4-22.25-.c.<- ALEXANDER CouLtrerR, Greensburg H. C. Burkert, Greensburg JouN REep,- Reynoldsyille: 025) 2... Joun K. Tener, Charleroi H. J. Rossins, Niles, Ohio Collected by William H. Mercur. (Through John M. Phillips.) Wi1aw o.. Mercur, Pittsburgh--_.....0..<- JOSMP ER ele AAC His ce ee Sarees sds e E. B. Matuior ICE OEW We SIN Oe ne ee eee ee ee SaMuEL C. MILLIGAN Jee Vee IBEROIR NG vse oer < tepee ee On ee oe ae ee Ae eee TST TING Sein 8 ie en ar ee se eae AE ANID Re IAN ee at 8 et ot ae ‘ VV eAvre Tap he sa DO INGAUIEI) SOINo meses te eae Wari an Acivicime Felon me @eAUN TIN OINic setae es ee ee eee ee eee Ge Gal SANinnrse eo eaten Ae IPAS VIC INU GOUMIER Va ee ee eee ee Ee Cee BinRSSIN Gln eer eee eee an eet WPI Go MS oases te ee Epwarp E. Mayenr........-..-- eas ee eee Wivianpoiuaie IME, TBS UWOSC ogee serene ee ePre OEE NBN Witelits VAI ee = ee ee se eee ee Ep win, JeIGe SNUA in ee ee Se ee Efe BRLAE 24 yon is Rage Se es ree = 9 PE CGR cel one en Ss aa ee i ee Jefe MSIE NY Wen GAO Ost) aoe aes ee ee ree meer eee SU eee (Che Gavan Ta Nese: eer ee nes Se a enon ar JSG (GE, Nie abevanpe tol OND DPR ee oe ee ee ee Wao yN MUA oren mi ag, Acer per as eee ota (Ca) ACh Giei tnt) one a ee Rane eee ee pane Pe en en ee I a ae eel oe ee ee ae OO OO OO OO OO OO OO OO OO OO OO OO .OO OO OO OO OO OO 00 OO OO 10.00 2.00 (9) 9 OO OO 2.00 2) — PO yO Oe CC en nr UU oN a ee ee OO OO OO OO OO OO mele) OO 00 OO 00 OO OO OO OO OO OO OO OO OO OO 371.00 40.00 Philadelphia. PACER LV VSAURURUENIN iat GET SIE Vance ee ee Collected by John Lyman Cow. *Joun Lyman Cox, Philadelphia.._............... AxeL Perre, Germantown, Philadelphia...... Cuarues J. Harran, New York City............ FAS IT UIUAUER Les VV © Ol) teak Seta a5 ee ec TRE eee SACNIOINIMINE OIG, 2 ae ee eae ee cee ee eel co Beep (Crew Ni sipped ea. ole TONSY OAR ae oe ee Ree Miss tHiRANCES A aVOBE RD Gia eae orem AUR VET una NIPAtis CO Mies eee eee eee PACNTIN AGE Loca i Tt BVRING SO IN eee oe eee ee eee ee Collected by Warren G. Griffith. oN A Gen AGO RIOOIg) GMEh oes ee ey IheGmevs del WWiktee ae ee ee eee Philadel phia—Miscellaneous. id POKES JEL C CI ist ee ee eS ee NY GIR Diehl Cameo iG Wie Me eaee are Lane ees pe ae ge PIER OTAUNTT) a Gx eG UR INT oe ee ee eee eee eer CREAT Ge) eT G ruins es erent eee eee ees See Ray MinS2 Greaney WDs VR CEMIe se ee ee ee ee MinnurNe Wh.) VWWiRIGHaies = Sr.se te ee eee BS) Wilkes-Barre. DORRAINIG Rein WNiO DSi ieee ees oe eee eee ake Sewickley. Collected by C. T. Harbaugh. PEP RK NAD panei eaten es Sonik en women GAIGeOWil OD Se ee ee es FREDERICK Moore .........- teak 8 Doo oem ae eee ie Nicikenrn Giana Meee BEE: Pree eae oe Bie Tva PD Asvi@iy yee ee need ea eee MONTANA. 25.00 5.00 5.00 5.00 10.00 10.00 5.00 5.00 2.00 2.00 1.00 1.00 OO OO OO OO OO OO OO Or OO OO OO OO OO Se ae Missoula. Collected by Professor Morton J. Elrod. pe a Rae a te eee te ee ee ee GeR EIN OU Gries ee ae ei ee ee GET IN tel © eee eee GoeEIe GB in Gwin ee THE CoMmMMISSIONERS OF Missouta: CounNry.. Wee AO Minin tee tenn a ee een Bene Dee ee MADE Yavin Dies aaa eS eee ee tae ca ote eee ivan) DEO MIPSOINT tee eee wate AY Hiram KinowiEs) 22... PA gy st PM eae ae m2 25.00 25.00 25.00 25.00 25.00 PAGS OKO) 25.00 10.00 10.00 10.00 10.00 15.00 2.00 5.00 le, WL SVK ENSOIN 222 ee 5.00 | (onl BRS 1S 0 22) ae ee 5.00 OLS 1A (te) BA 2X cp oD ea pa ek Oe es oe 5.00 RA RG HANI hee ee to ce 5.00 ho yyeeee) Mea G70) 0h 3 3) Ne le ey ee Oe ae 5.00 Clie MEG Y Or SONS oe 8 ee a ee 5.00 ele Vere cP RAR. 02 enn ee eo) eee 5.00 PRR es als 1 ARSON Stone. ese) ee 5.06 NE OR CARDEN DURGH! 22608 5.00 Wale Pyle Ao et nent ca 2 Be 5A ced Ps ees 5.00 Beles OHA DO Nite tase oa yc none ceese ack 5.00 DR Metre elOAUNIn een re ee A 5.00 yo Ate VVCENISICAUN EE eee (ste ewer. une fellas) 5.00 ite Gavi Nine ern oe eh ie A ht eR ee 2.50 Al Sen) Nad 8 60 5 OW ft 0 See na 2.50 ett CRESS G) bs vats Paetsch le 2.50 GEORGE Is (BROOK Ss. 2. <.-- <0 eee te 2.50 Ge SPURNED ART oe te tee we eae oa 2.50 221 Dy BUG Re NS 8): Ue eRe nen Ree ae ae RI Ne Teta 2.50 AVS ICGRTAUN DIN Gy es Oe ns fo ie a ee ada 2.00 EAU Gee GHINGNEE DY) oo eee ere ese es ee oe 2.00 RPE Sie COC eee. 2s 3 oe 1.00 te Ae ST CO cat sac aed a 2 See oe Roe ee 1.00 Teme ew Sie NR Cee wee ee he By ee des lie ee 1.00 VASE ARN Vern Tapes A Veo ake Ore! fea ekbe 1.00 Ieee NG AES ess eee ne at eee: 1.00 Sa Ua Bah SIC 51: ey ea Ee 1.00 EUREAUN SKS) VO OD ok ee ee ee 1.00 (Gg PA, VIS AiG T STIR ge ee 8 a ows 1.00 | pgm Chel BY 1(0)) 2) 5S Sean Oey Uae ee ee ee Re 1.00 A ESN 2k Me Oo) 2 eee Cn a en re EE ee 1.00 LCA IN eS SUIT INS cee ates iain eter ey nd rade a 1.00 ANTE (Cone OG Wcied a) SO. Wee eee ee gna eer ea Pee me iy Pa 1.00 (Cre EI MEA Stier ore tye oe ee ee 1.00 312.00 Collected by George Armitage. GrorGeE ARMITAGE, Missoula.......................... 5.00 OF Yeorusnon, Havana, (Cuba... 2-2-2 1.00 (GA (Ge MhtwAesopy Nose ehicna vse = eas ee 1.00 eRe GarrAe TN teleavier ties ene ene ee ee 1.00 Mrs. G. W. Armitrace, Havana...................--- 1.00 Jianres: Pur eivAd,., ilavama-c-.2 22-2 ese 1.00 10.00 Collected by Dr. R. Houston (Kalispell) and Dr. H. E. Houston (Whitefish). Kalispell and Whitefish. Dr: RS Houston, Kalispell)... 2. 22... 2.00 eG. Kerns Kalispell’, 2 eee 5.00 E. M. Cup, Kalispell Joun Neigurmun, Kalispell A. N. Tosir, Kalispell H. W. Dickry, Kalispell JAMES CoNLOoN, Kalispell W. H. Grirrin, Kalispell Grorce F. Srannarp, Kalispell J. H. O’Conne tt, Kalispell R. E. Wesster, Kalispell C. B. Harris, Kalispell O. H. Moserty, Kalispell W. B. Ruoapes, Kalispell Wituiam P. Fox, Creston Dr. H. E. Houston, Whitefish Percy F. Dopps, Whitefish Prerer Suruersoner, Whitefish Epwarp Tremer, Whitefish Miscellaneous Cities in Montana. *Waxuis HuipeKxorrer, Melville ALFoRD YERGEY, Bozeman Chicago. *WitLtiamM J. RUCKER *KeritH SPAULDING ILLINOIS. ER RANIGEV ..-OHINSON 22 teas ee a ee H. =: |W aad ofp L. 5 1B eA cee MIR DAU os een Uns oh en eee oe ee . W ish Collected by William P. Palmer. GREE Nee an Se ey a ee PAG See a se hn ae Os oe AV EAT:S OINiyesie tne coerced A em th tee TRYACW Vi Sie: oat ee Pe re ce ee eae ES IPIRYAIG Ui ese Se ae ee er na ee KONTGEDT | dips en ee, ie te Pe EW IVER AN ER Sa ls Race ae ee Lt b ACI MING) ete Lt Roe Soe ere Rk Pew, Sor ee ec dane VAAN RSY cosc2 02 er 2 coe ee Aw tes gel wh) bY C) OP See ae, Sate De ee NEN ae ae PAST OINIE ieee een om esas kee 2 eee Ne ee: SU SWICKI). So seer. se as ee eee ee MO VG RAT Le ee ee ee ee ee 3A 1.00 100.00 10.00 10.00 10.00 10.00 til etl tl ers cel <0 OY be Sar pi et ae tees Rioed Velie ely ote ot fnin lene Ss hae =) Y~ =~ — 33.00 IE ae S See VET He ead oe Reese Oly I (Gee Sag ee ee ea Chicago—Miscellaneous. PaRVOBERIN We JEUINi sees ee ee. ee Sas ELPAGNIS © Noe ee a es PLS B Crow, wine st = eae Se ae emtch *J. WINTERBOTHAM ..._..........-..---..---- ep eee DISTRICT OF COLUMBIA. Washington. Collected by Dr. T. S. Palmer. cial Us paee | RAST GSN Bai 0) 0 0) 5 og CMe Re Se oe oa GAME AND FisH PRorectTIVE ASSOCIATION OF THE District or CoLtumsia (through Dr. We WE YOUN, US CCPELON Y) ..2. 2 ot. ene HORRY con EARS Now noo 8 Se ee GrEVART MG@RRIAM << 26.2598 ooo. oe cesses VERNON BAtEmY 2.222... AB VV Se NE SON ee es a ee a Sa Een oO UN IGE VAD S20 ng one 2 ee eee TR Gye EAO WARD oe yc sone Gee errs ORR ee ASAE Te Va AGT TTS eee eee we gnc oe RDWARD AS (eREBIE.0 6 Se2 es. re Poiel ipa edt si 511: esc a a ee Pee We OSES ES ee (Ce Eee eR W SISO pte ee ee alte eg GTEC HG AGN ASETIAGN te es tino seis Jee GRANRORD esc ee cee re ote hm eee ES SONG pls ae Ose ee ee ome EpWARD J. STELLWAGEN .............--..---2------2---- T.0G. CHAMBERLIN, ‘Chicago -...._2.2...222-8.04:.- R. W. Wiuuiams, Jr., Tallahassee, Fla.....-. = Collected by T'. Gilbert Pearson. (Through Dr. T. S. Palmer.) *T. GILBERT PEarRson, Greensboro, N. C..... J.-E. Jorwan, (Greensboro: -:..s.-.22:.222-2..--2 C. M. Vanstrory, Greensboro..............-.-...---.-- ReeCz EloopeiGreensbor0-= 2 ee Cou. W. H. Ossorne, Greensboro.........-.---..-- G. A. Grimstey, Greensboro........- na ee pee Washington—Miscellaneous. *GirForD Pincuot, Washington.......... ee See Mins VRARY. bbs MiiveRseso 8 ef ae el AV Vira TSS Ip (Cr ay EU TGV EE Sites cee es en Mee wlicopeanp YC a AMAS A o(o) Tyee pee eee as hee ee A. TucKERMAN ..... GP ens Ne A. PR A 1.00 1.00 5.00 5.00 2.50 1.00 25.00 1.00. 1.00 1.00 1.00 1.00 1.00 25.00 5.00 5.00 1.00 1.00 24.00 106.00 6.00 New Haven. CONNECTICUT. EVE NIRV We ARN TAIMe = ee 25.00 WINCHESTER REPEATING ARMS COMPANY (through Winchester Bennett, Second Kace-P Tr esident\r 2s ne ee oe 25.00 Hartford. | Ee fal Beep Git 109 6) 0) ae 8 ee a eee SUP a hie A ene ASLO? 5.00 WO OS UN es COIN yee a ee 5.00 aNeumenony Wye, SOMOKCDOION Es epee ee ee 2.00 Miscellaneous Cities in Connecticut. *ERNESt THOMPSON SETON, Cos Cob...........- 25.00 JORNG Ee SAGE. (ortlandss ) tee wae UE S'ACAVG ta Coa SATS Spee oe eee ees ee ee Miscellaneous Cities in Rhode Island. *Mrs. A. G. Durer, Wickford.................... JOHN GUE NES MING W Oli rsa wee ee, NEBRASKA. Hilemorth. Collected by Bartlett Richards. BartLetr Ricuarps, Ellsworth:.................... Wirr G. Comstock, Ellsworth: =... 5-2-2. J: De Ky Rienarps, Douglas, Wyo. -----..-2 Cuarues C. JAMESON, Ellsworth.................... Jarvis: Ricwarps, Denver, Colis 23 22 Omaha. Dns El. GinhORD 2: oie eee eee ae Hort Calne COLORADO. RupoteH M. Booraem............:.:..... nett. Wawanca Denver. Wis URS KG NI DRTC Kaos. Ser co ed ARIZONA. Tucson. Dr Da VMACDOUGAL ==. =e = GagS MiKS ee ee ee See eRe ee Herspert Brown ...... FR BoP ie es de aylan rte| h Wi ROSE ae eee ee WE ea Joun O. DuNBAR ..... eee Se ee ee Collected by Dr. D. T. MacDougal. 1.00 1.00 1.00 1.00 1.00 1.00 1.00 1.00 1.00 EIS KO, 10.00 5.00 5.00 5.00 5.00 10.00 10.00 5.00 5.00 5.00 1.00 1.00 1.00 21.10 22.00 MART SME OB Riri 2. ote ee eae REINA ORMIROGEIRS@ — an le See so Watertown. FLORIDA. BONING Pte AGiIet eener. Sennen ter Wee oe a BAT VOrE: MARYLAND. Je lee DYE al oi anne tac epetatn ee ee aM) Nees Ig eee eee DOUGEASE URINE Wise =e ee ee ee Easton. BO AGNTOINEVENEO US) matte ease a ath ete estan e = ee WASHINGTON. Roslyn. Collected by P. Oakes. *P. Oakes, Roslyn ...-. eR ee oe bid WALTER OaKms. “Seattle 0-2. CoE JONmS; WVOSlyM: 28-22... 2 no eG ee Meyers Falls. Caries Ic. Smo. pad Ie er AD ae ee ae Le IOWA. Wall ake. Collected by John A, Spurrell. JiOLINE AC SPURRED bee eee ene eee ie AvupuBON Socrety oF Watt Lake (Through John A. Spurrell, President) 2) 222... OEUINIR OR URE. pee eee ee Le Da cla) PDN CY Seog ee ads ea tee ee Meee Re el aa Union. Ninsa Oe tlbemRRicn Ree cee ee eee ee Wolf. WYOMING. 5 5) Go LORRI NIEd De ON AOING oe oceans re tgs oe ee eee pee Mayfield KENTUCKY (GRAVELS ONE aes eran tn re nate a Louisville. IOAN oT eS AN ET ee et eee Res Se MAINE. Kennebunkport. Collected by Mary P. Lord. A WeRIEND,) Wennebunkpont.- 22-4222. cee Gi. We, harris) ~Kennebunlcport........---s--220 Dr. CHarures R. Waker, Concord, N. H..... Bowdoinham. NY Gast) G3] CCD aN C= ek eer ns a ed eet ee 1] 10. Sr — (aS) co — aed —" (AS) Sr (a8) (RS) a a — hm 0 00 OO OO OQ OO OO OO OO OO OO OO OO OO OO OO OO OO OO 15.00 5.00 3.00 3.00 WEST VIRGINIA. Wheeling. IMR TS ie MGreaviumye a ON ee 4.00 SOUTH CAROLINA. Columbia. MAST: ESXCAUNTID EVR Eo ld ACV Ty OIF ese ee 1.00 New Orleans. LOUISIANA, Ja Cone) [al er (COUSIN AGN cee goes Aad oO gs ae 1.00 Brattleboro. VERMONT. Rrizappom Be IDAVENPORT....-.-=.. 2. 1.00 . “Anonymous.” (NO STATE, CITY NOR NAME GIVEN ) 2.......--:-2..----. 3.00 London. ENGLAND. BRaprEny MARTIN, -(Mayiaires 922 4 ee 25.00 Viechel BRITISH COLUMBIA. Read ViepeIN OR Or eee ete see eed ee ene 1.00 Menton a M. FRANCE, EDWARD e eaieTies Aussies seen enn 5.00 Paris. WAM OTUR Naps eee eee ee meee tiers Satce ee = ee 1.90 WO TAT ese 5 eee heey eee $10,560.50 CERTIFICATE OF DEPOSIT. Tuts 1s To CerTIrY that there has been paid into the Treasury of the AMERICAN BISON SOCIETY subscriptions amounting to the sum of Ten THovusaNnpn, Five HunpRED aNp Sixty Do.iars anp Firry Cents, which constitutes the special fund for the purchase of the MONTANA NATIONAL BISON HERD, for the necessary expenses incidental to delivering the same upon the range, and for carrying out the objects of the Society in relation thereto. CLARK WILLIAMS, Treasurer. New York City, May 5th, 1909. REPORT OF THE SECRETARY :* INCE the last annual meeting of the Society, the Sec- retary has delivered one hundred and thirteen lectures, chiefly in New England, New York and the middle West, calling attention to the work of the American Bison Society, and appealing for subscriptions to the Montana National Bison Fund. Two of these lectures were de- livered at Dartmouth College, where the students now have under consideration two suggestions,—the adoption of the buffalo as the college totem, and the presentation to the United States government of a herd of buffaloes to be preserved on some national range. Both suggestions have met with the approval of President Tucker and of every member of the Faculty with whom the matter was discussed. Early in September, in obedience to instructions re- ceived at the last annual meeting of the Society, the Sec- retary left New Hampshire for the far West to visit the principal buffalo herds, with a view to learning their size and condition, and to get such other information concern- ing them as might be of interest or value to this Society. The Secretary was specially anxious to see the Pablo Herd on the Flathead Indian Reservation, Montana, recently bought by the Canadian Government, and to witness its round-up for shipment to Canada. ‘This event promised to be the last of its kind in this country, and the Secretary greatly desired to be present to obtain first-hand informa- tion and photographs which would be invaluable in creat- ing interest from the lecture platform. Acting on the best information obtainable, the Secretary started for the Flat- head Reservation, where the round-up was to take place between the first and the tenth of September. On reach- ing Missoula it was learned that there was no chance of the round-up coming off for several days, so a visit to the Government Buffalo herd in Yellowstone Park was made in the meantime. *All the photographs illustrating this article were made by Ernest Harold Baynes, Secretary. AS “jyo] atwaayXa ey) Je UlBJUNOUT OY} UO UdeES S] 9SUBI AOWILUNS JO [BIIOY saddpy oy} jo yard y ‘saojeyng aie aunjord ay} JO aajuso oy) ur s}op yoR]q eyL “Ja}UIM 9Y} Ul podnjsed sf poy JUSUTUIAAODH 94} SOYA “]BIIOT) JOM] OY} Ul St BoIv [ea] 9y} JO Yonw “yuvd IWNOLLVN ANOLSMOTISA “AATIVA AVWVT GOVERNMENT BUFFALO HERD. Galloping through Lamar Valley, Yellowstone National Park. Through the courtesy of General S. B. M. Young and the Quartermaster at Fort Yellowstone, the Secretary was driven to the buffalo range in Lamar Valley, a dis- tance of thirty miles, somewhat south of east from Mam- moth Hot Springs. Most of the way lay through open rolling grass coun- try, with distant snow-covered mountains always in view. Prong-horned antelopes were seen at frequent intervals, sometimes singly, but usually in small bands. ‘Three coy- otes showed themselves during the trip, the last one within the buffalo range. The buffalo herd, numbering eighty-four head, and in- cluding fourteen calves of 1908, was found in what is known as the Lower Corral, a long, narrow meadow lying between the south side of the road and the Lamar River. This corral is about one and one-half miles long, and con- tains nearly four hundred acres. The Upper Corral, about six hundred acres in extent, is on the slope of a mountain on the north side of the road. Here the buffaloes are kept during the summer months. while the grass in the Lower Corral is permitted to grow. In the fall about one hundred tons of hay are cut for winter feeding, and then the buffaloes are turned in to spend the winter. With the exception of one cow, which has since died, the herd was in splendid condition. 15 ‘YUVd IVNOLLVN ANOLSMOTISA ‘AATIVA UVWYT NI GadH O1VSANA LNAWNYAAOSD eR The corrals are enclosed with Montana anchor fencing. Six strands of heavy wire are stretched taut on posts set one rod apart, and between each pair of posts four upright wires are clamped upon the horizontal ones, making a stiff and very tidy-looking fence. An interesting feature of the Lower Corral is a beaver colony, which has ‘dammed Rose Creek, splitting the stream into several smaller ones which flow through the corral, and give it natural irrigation. On return to Mammoth Hot Springs it was learned that on Sept. 16, Scout McBride had seen twenty of the wild buffalo in the valley of Pelican Creek. Other scouts report signs of three calves, one of which was actually seen. So the little remnant of the wild herd is probably increas- ing slowly. The Secr etary then went to Missoula, and thence to the Flathead Indian Reservation. As the preparations for the roundup were still incomplete, the trip was continued to Kalispell, Montana, to inspect the Conrad herd. ‘The journey across the Flathead Valley was made on horse- back, and for some distance after leaving Ravalli, the route lay close to the southern border of our new buffalo range, whose grassy slopes arose from the north or left-hand side of the road. Numbers of cattle and horses could be seen grazing on the range, which seems an ideal one for the Society’s purpose. After a thirty-mile ride on horseback to Polson, at the north end of the Reservation, the Secretary left his horse and crossed Flathead Lake in one of the small steamers that make daily trips to Somers, which is about ten miles by rail from Kalispell. The Conrad buffalo herd was found on its summer range, an eight-hundred-acre hilly tract, part grass and part Ww oodland, six miles west of Kalispell. A “stout rail fence encloses the range. All the animals, numbering ninety-two head, including eighteen calves of 1908, were in good condition. As a herd they are very tractable, and as a rule can be rounded-up and handled much like domes- tic cattle. Every fall they are driven sixteen miles along the country roads, even through the streets of Kalispell, to their winter range, where they roam over sixteen hun- dred acres of grass ‘and erain land until spring, when they are driven back again. : 4 BUFFALO COW. Presented to the American Bison Society by the C. E. Conrad Estate, Kalispell, Montana. The Secretary discussed with Mrs. C. E. Conrad, executrix of the C. E. Conrad Estate, the aims of the American Bison Society, with the result that a fine pair of buffaloes from this herd was presented to the Society for preservation on the new Montana range. Soon afterwards the following letter was received from Mrs. Conrad :— KALISPELL, Monrana, October 5, 1908. Mr. Ernest Harold Baynes, Secretary, The American Bison Society, Meriden, N. H. My Dear Sir:— After considering your suggestion made while you were here a few days ago, namely, that inasmuch as Mr. Conrad was so much interested in the presen agey of the pure-blood American Bison that he gave a great deal of personal time and means to the alle one the C.-K. Conrad Buffalo Herd, his heirs might present a pair to the Bison Society in his name-—-as a nucleus of the Flathead Reservation herd, we have decided to do so. We have Is “KALISPELL CHIEF.” The first buffalo presented to the American Bison Society. Gift of the C. E. Conrad Estate, Kalispell, Montana. selected for this gift the finest pair we own, “Walispell Chief,” a nine year old male, an animal to which we believe it would be difficult to find an equal in the world today, and as his mate, the herd leader, a vigorous, sagacious cow, having a calf each year,—one which would be of the greatest value to the new herd. We have depended upon her wise head and good sense in our management of the herd, and have no cow to equal her. Hoping that the Bison Society will accept this gift in the spirit in which it is given, and wishing every success to the undertaking in which every one who gives these mat- ters thought must be keenly interested, I remain, SOULE US aie aatl ig Auxicia D. ConrapD. Mrs. Conrad agreed to deliver the buffaloes in crates at Polson, at the south end of Flathead Lake, free of charge, and the Secretary arranged with Messrs. Ethell Bros. of Ravalli, to carry them free from Polson to the range. The Secretary then returned to the Flathead Reserva- tion, meeting Michel Pablo at Ronan. Afterwards, in 19 “6061 JO Sutsds 9y} Ul SUTTJaLOS BpPBUBT) 0} juauidiys soy dn papunos aq 0} 91B pue SjuaWUIaA0D UBIPEULD ay} 0} POS useq aAvY Sao[eyNq eso] “BuB}UuOWw ‘uoNBAJASAY UBIPU] PBIyIe[y ‘aduet sj UO ‘GugdH O1VAANA OTAVd AHL AO NOILYOd V Ee eR is ee esccneman St Y. company with Messrs. Howard Douglas and Alexander Ayotte, representatives of the Canadian Government, he drove out six or eight miles to see the last of the Pablo buf- faloes, which were found on the east side of the Pend D Oreille River. The Secretary counted two hundred and fifty in one herd, and saw in the distance another group which must have numbered at least fifty. They were very suspicious, and though they permitted us to drive reasonably near, the appearance of a man, afoot or horseback, was enough to send them flying across the prairie. Messrs. Douglas and Ayotte were present to superin- tend the shipment of this splendid herd, and to accompany it to its new home, Buffalo Park, Wainwright, Alberta. This great preserve is one hundred miles southeast of Ed- monton, on the Grand Trunk Pacific. It contains one hundred and twenty-two thousand acres, enclosed with a fourteen-strand, nine-gauge wire fence, seventy-three miles in length. ‘Three hundr ed of the buffalo now at Elk Island Park will also be shipped to Buffalo Park. ‘Two hundred miles west of Edmonton is a tract of five thou- sand square miles, known as Jasper Park, a portion of which the Canadian Government will probably fence off in 1910 for another buffalo range. Extensive and costly preparations were being made to corral the Pablo buffaloes, but the Secretary on being i in- formed by Mr. Pablo that the round-up could not take place until at least two weeks later, decided to leave at once, in order that he might visit the other large herds before it was time to return to the Kast. The round-up finally took place in November, but unfortunately the buf- faloes escaped from the corral into which they had at great expense been driven, and it was then decided to make no effort to recapture them until May, 1909. On October 9th, the Secretary started for Salt Lake City, to see the Dooly buffalo herd which roams Antelope Island, in the Great Salt Lake. In passing through Butte, Montana, there was a delay of some hours, and the opportunity was taken to visit the buffaloes at Columbia Gardens, four miles east of the city. There are four full-blooded buffaloes in this herd, one bull, two cows and a yearling heifer. Besides these there 51 ANTELOPE ISLAND, GREAT SALT LAKE. View from the ford by which the southeast corner of it is approached from Salt Lake City. are two cattaloes—one female, half buffalo and half black polled Angus; and one male, three-fourths buffalo and one-fourth black polled Angus. ‘They have a range of about three acres, and they are fed on grass and hay in the summer, and on hay exclusively in the winter. All these animals are the property of Eix-Senator W. A. Clark, who has loaned them to Columbia Gardens. At Salt Lake City the Secretary met Mr. John E. Dooly, the owner of the Antelope Isiand buffaloes, and as Mr. Dooly’s guest paid a visit to the herd. The island is about twenty miles northwest of Salt Lake City, whence it is approached by a fairly good carriage road, across a wide stretch of flat, alkaline country. ‘The last four miles of the drive to Antelope Island was through the lake it- self, at a ford where the water was so shallow that it barely covered the horses’ shoes. Antelope Island is about sixteen miles long, north and south, and about five miles wide, east and west, at its widest point. It contains between twenty-five and thirty thousand acres, much of it mountainous. The island itself 52 BUFFALO CALF BEING NURSED BY A DOMESTIC COW. Antelope Island, Great Salt Lake. seems to be a continuation of the Oquirre Range, which hes west of Salt Lake City. An irregular mountain ridge extends north and south, practically the entire length of the island, its highest point being perhaps 4700 feet above sea level, or 500 feet above the shore of the lake. West of the ridge the country is very rough and precipitous, but on the eastern side there is a wide, level plain, extending north and south. Most of the island is covered with sage-brush, but quan- tities of grass grow between, and the fact that it maintains a thousand head of Hereford cattle, besides a hundred horses and a herd of buffalo now numbering forty-five, 1s proof that there is a good deal of pasture. ‘There is also an abundance of water, supplied chiefly by springs. of which there are more than twenty. Seventeen of them are on the east side of the ridge. There is also a number of very small ponds, none of them over one hundred vards in length. There is very little timber on the island. It consists chiefly of dwarf cedar,—a few acres here and there on the 53 ‘seXo] ‘JYSIUpOOD Je aduBl Ss}! UG ‘dadH O1VAANA LHOINGOOD slopes of the mountain. ‘There are also a few deciduous trees, most of them in the Anaeiate vicinity of the springs. The ford at which the Secretary crossed the lake is “at the south end of the island, on the east side. From the landing-place a hard, dirt road runs along the shore to a brick ranch house, built there by the Mormons, and now used as a dwelling by Mr. Dooly’s foreman. It is sur- rounded by out-buildingss and corrals. At the corrals were three buffalo calves that the foreman was trying to domes- ticate. ‘Two were fed on milk from a bucket, and the third had for a foster mother a graded Hereford cow, from whom the little fellow was allowed to take his nourishment at stated periods. After dinner a party of four, including the writer, set out on horseback to look for the buffalo herd. The first buffalo seen was a solitary old bull. He was quietly graz- ing down by the shore of the lake, but when the Secretary attempted to photograph him, he showed much spirit, charging the horse repeatedly. One of the party, Chaun- cey White, photographed him in one of these charges, but owing to the distance, the picture is very small. Later i in the afternoon we came upon a bunch of twelve buffaloes, half way up the east side of the mountain. They were extremely wild, dashing through the sage-brush like jack-rabbits. They were the most active buffalo the writer has ever seen. Mounted on a big, thoroughbred horse, the Secretary was able to get near enough to obtain photographs of the animals as they hurried over the rough ground, but it required continuous hard riding to keep up with them. Next morning, in company with the foreman the writer crossed the ridge and visited the west side of the island. From every point there are wonderful views of the lake. The country is very rugged and broken, and much of it rocky, but there are numerous draws and coulees, most of them with more or less pasture, and all offering excellent shelter for the animals. We saw a bunch of fifteen buffalo dash away from near the top of the ridge, and through a field glass watched them as they ran for perhaps two miles, until they were lost around a bend in the hills. Several other buffaloes were seen singly, or in small groups. Of the forty-five head now said to be on Antelope Island, the 55 Secretary saw thirty-five, including the three young ani- mals at the corrals. Five other calves were born in 1908. The writer regretted that he was unable to spend more than twenty-four hours on this island, as he believes that an exhaustive report would show it to be an ideal range on which to establish a national buffalo herd. Mr. Dooly states that all parts of the west coast and the northern half of the east coast of Antelope island may be approached by boat from a promontory crossed by the Lucin Cut-off of the Southern Pacific Railroad. Excursions to the island may be made from Saltair, a bathing resort twenty miles from Salt Lake City, on the line of the Saltair Railroad. In answer to a question by the Secretary, Mr. Dooly stated that he would consider a proposition to sell the Island for a buffalo range. It is an interesting fact that although there is every opportunity for the cattle and buffaloes to wander through the shallow water to the mainland, they never do so, and one old bull that the writer chased out into the lake several times, always turned back after going a quarter of a mile or so, sometimes landing far away from the point where he entered the water. On returning to Salt Lake City, the Secretary had an- other interview with Mr. Dooly, and the latter generously promised to contribute a pair of young buffaloes to the herd which the American Bison Society proposes to es- tablish on the new government range in north-western Montana. After leaving Utah, the writer went straight to Good- night, Texas, to see the buffalo herd of Charles Goodnight. This herd is of more than usual interest inasmuch as it is probably the only one descended exclusively from animals roped on the plains, either by the owner or under his diree- tions. But it is chiefly to Mrs. Goodnight that we are indebted for this famous herd. In 1878 when the buf- faloes were being slaughtered all around her, this lady con- ceived the idea of saving some of them. She begged her husband and brothers to get her some of the tawny calves, and let her try to rear them at the Palo Duro Ranch, then the Goodnight home. Personally, Charles Goodnight was not very enthusiastic over the suggestion, but thinking that the calves would amuse his wife in her isolated home, 56 GROUP OF CATTALO. Goodnight Ranch, Goodnight, Texas. one day when he was off with his cattle outfit, he roped two, tied their legs and sent them back to her in a cart. Soon after, her brothers, the Dyer boys, roped two more. She reared them all, though one of the heifers died before it was of breeding age, leaving one bull and two heifers as the nucleus of the now famous herd. Though the Goodnights have plenty of healthy senti- ment, this herd has not been perpetuated for sentimental reasons only. Charles Goodnight is a practical ranchman, and he has treated the buffaloes as he has treated his cattle and sheep and hogs,—as a business proposition,—as a source of revenue. He has sold many buffaloes at splen- did prices, and after a life-time’s experience, he earnestly maintains that the buffalo is the most profitable farm ani- mal in America today. So far he has made no use of buf- falo wool, but on learning of the Secretary’s experiments with this material, he said that this spring he would shear a number of the animals and send the wool to be woven into cloth. Mr. Goodnight was also the pioneer in the breeding of eattalo, an animal which, as its coined name suggests, is a ~ ( 5 “BOyed YINOS ‘adietq WOY Jeau esuvs say} uO “SHOTVSANG dITHd cross between domestic cattle and the buffalo. It has been his experience that these animals will interbreed only when they have been reared together practically from infancy. In all of his experiments he has used black polled Angus cattle, partly because this breed is very hardy, like the buffalo, and partly because of its solid black color. 'There are perhaps one hundred of the cross-bred animals on the Goodnight ranch, ranging all the way from what are prac- tically full-blood polled Angus cattle, to creatures with so little domestic blood in them that no one but the breeder could tell that they were not full-blood buffaloes. Be- tween these extremes the animals vary greatly in appear- ance. Some favoring the buffalo, have horns; others lean- ing toward the polled Angus in this respect, have none. Some are almost black; others, a rich seal brown; and among the rest, many shades of brindle are represented. Many of the animals, especially those of the first and second crosses, are of great size, much larger than either the buffalo or the Angus cattle. Where the buffalo blood predominates it is shown by the general formation of the body, by the great height of the hump, and by the length of the hair, especially the hair of the forehead, throat and fore-legs. The tail, too, is usually very much shorter than that of the pure domestic animals. As the amount of the buffalo blood is increased, these characteristics become more pronounced; as it is eliminated they tend to disap- pear. By crossing back toward either race, four or five times in succession, the characteristics of the other race are usually so nearly wiped out that no trace of them is visible, externally at least. Some of the animals observed at the Goodnight ranch, notably those with a preponderance of buffalo blood, had wonderful coats. ‘These were fairly long, lustrous and apparently silky, and in the cases of the dark-skinned animals, very beautiful. According to Mr. Goodnight, the value of the cattalo as a farm animal will be based, first on its hide, which is more beautiful and more generally useful than a buffalo- robe; second upon its beef, of which it produces a large quantity, said to be of excellent quality; and third, upon its hardiness, since it is said to be able to thrive under con- ditions which are fatal to range cattle. 59 It is not the purpose of the writer to discuss in this re- port the details of Mr. Goodnight’s interesting experi- ments, of his many failures and of his plucky fights to overcome them. Suffice it to say that although a good start has been made, the experiment will have to be carried much farther before the cattalo can be produced at a cost sufficiently low to make it commercially valuable. But it seems not unlikely that a series of careful scientific experi- ments, conducted under the direction of someone making a specialty of the breeding of hybrids, might bring results that would more than pay for the time and money ex- pended. Were such a series of experiments undertaken, I doubt not that Mr. Goodnight would co-operate by giv- ing the results of his own long and valuable experience. The Goodnight buffaloes and cattaloes roam over a range of about three thousand acres, half prairie and half broken country, the latter partly grown over with scrub trees and bushes. Natural springs supply the water, which is piped into iron tanks and into natural hollows in the ground. At the time of the Secretary’s visit, the ani- mals were in splendid condition, except that in some cases the heel fly had bothered them, so that they had licked off the hair in some places. Twenty buffalo calves were born in this herd in 1908. Mr. and Mrs. Goodnight readily consented to give a pair of yearling buffaloes ‘for the Montana Range, ‘and a little later Mr. “Goodnight formally presented the animals in the following letter :-— GooDNIGHT, TExas, November 25, 1908. Mr. Ernest Harold Baynes, Meriden, N. H. My dear sir and friend :— This is to assure you that any time during March and April, not later than May Ist, we will load you free for your National Park in Montana, and to go to no other preserve, one pair of choice buffalo yearlings, one bull and one heifer. Yours respectfully, C. GooDNIGHT. There remained but one of the large western herds to visit,_-that of James Philip. This herd is established nean Fort Pierre, South Dakota, and to this town the Secretary 60 TEAM OF THREE-YEAR-OLD BUFFALO STEERS. Loaned by the Blue Mountain Forest Association, and broken to the yoke and to harness by the Secretary of the American Bison Society. went after leaving the Goodnight ranch. Next to the Pablo herd, the Philip buffalo herd is the largest in the country, numbering one hundred and eighty-eight head at the time of the writer’s visit. In addition to the buffaloes there were nine cattaloes in the herd. ‘They have a range of about seven thousand acres of rolling country, some six miles from Fort Pierre and close to the Missouri River. This range is rapidly becoming too small to afford suffi- cient grazing, and unless it can be increased, it seems 1n- evitable that Mr. Philip will be obliged to reduce his splen- did herd. The United States Government is anxious to help him by leasing to him some public land adjoining his own, but there are certain legal obstacles in the shape of claims filed by persons, who it is said, have no intention of using the land, at least for some time to come. It is ear- nestly hoped that these claims will be withdrawn, and Mr. Philip permitted to use it as a part of his buffalo range for many years. The Philip buffaloes were in splendid condition. The Secretary visited them three times, and saw practically all 61 of them. ‘There were some splendid bulls among them. The cows in the Philip herd paid no attention to a carriage, but many of them would chase a horseman the moment he came near. So vigilant and savage were some of these cows, that it was difficult to get close enough to take good photographs of the herd. The Secretary talked with Mr. Philip of the National herd to be established in Montana, and as he said “good- bye,” Mr. Philip added, “Well, when you get your fence up, you can count on me for a pair of young buffaloes.” On his return to the East, the Secretary called upon Austin Corbin, President of the Blue Mountain Forest Association, which owns the Corbin buffalo herd of one hundred and fifty head at Newport, N. H. After listen- ing to an account of the writer’s trip in the West, Mr. Corbin remarked:—“Well! Why don’t you ask us for some buffaloes?’ The kind suggestion was promptly acted upon, and the Society was the richer by three buf- faloes, immediately. The writer regrets that limited time prevented him from visiting the smaller herds of the West. He had orig- inally planned to visit a number of them, but the delay caused by the postponement of the Pablo round-up left barely time to look over the large herds. Incidentally, however, while passing through Chicago, and Davenport, Iowa, the Secretary visited the buffalo herds in the Zoo- logical Gardens in these cities, and found them flourishing. The Lincoln Park herd in Chicago was visited on the 14th of June, and the first calf of the year was born that day. This buffalo herd has been at Lincoln Park for about twenty years, and in spite of the fact that the enclosure contains only about one-quarter of an acre, the animals appear to be in excellent health. On June 22nd, the Secretary visited Fejervary Park, Davenport, Iowa, and there found a little herd of nine head, five of which had been born in the Park. They have arange of about six acres, partly wooded and with a pretty little valley running through it. No calves had been born in 1908 up to the time of the Secretary’s visit, but the superintendent reported the birth of one later in the summer. 62 To summarize, the writer found practically all the buf- faloes visited looking well and contented, and as far as could be judged from external appearances, in excellent health. By the majority of the private owners, however, they are regarded as salable property, and like other salable property, they are disposed of from time to time to almost anyone who cares to buy them, regardless of the purpose for which they are bought. For this reason, every effort should be made to place as many as possible of these splendid animals in the hands of the federal government, for permanent preservation and increase. In closing, the Secretary wishes to express his thanks to the many people who in one way or another assisted him in the work of inspecting and photographing the buffalo herds visited in the interest of the Society. And while thanks are in order, the writer wishes to ex- press his appreciation of the services rendered to this cause by Austin Corbin and the Blue Mountain Forest Associa- tion of which Mr. Corbin is the president. Since the be- ginning of this movement, Mr. Corbin, and indeed every member of the Association, has generously helped to fur- ther it. For the carrying out of experiments, and for use in exhibitions calculated to create interest in this campaign, the splendid buffalo herd at Newport, N. H., has ever been at the Society’s disposal. Ernest Harotp BAyNEs. Since the above report was written, John E. Dooly has formally presented his pair of buffaloes in the following letter:—— Sat LAKE City, Utanu, March 6, 1909. Ernest Harold Baynes, Esq., Hotel Havlin, Cincinnati, Ohio. My Dear Mr. Baynes :— Agreeable to your request, I beg to state that it will afford me pleasure to present to the American Bison So- ciety, one pair of young buffalo for the purpose of stocking the National Government Reservation, same to be deliv- ered at the Buffalo Corrals, on Antelope Island. Respectfully, JoHN E. Doory. 63 The Secretary would add that while on business in Cincinnati, on the 21st of February last, he accepted a kind invitation from S. A. Stephan, Superintendent of the Zoo- logical Garden, to visit the buffalo herd there. There were thirteen head, five males and eight females, including two calves of 1908. They all seemed to be in excellent health. E. H. B. Ol ENTRANCE TO THE HOME OF THE WICHITA NATIONAL BISON HERD. THIRD ANNUAL MEETING. fee Third Annual Meeting of the Society was held at the American Museum of Natural History, New York City, on Thursday morning, January the four- teenth, 1909, at 10.30. President William T. Hornaday was in the chair. Others present were, Mrs. William T. Hornaday, A. A. Anderson, Herbert L. Bridgman, H. C. Bumpus, M. S. Garretson, Franklin W. Hooper, Frederic A. Lucas, Harry V. Radford, Edmund Seymour, Charles H. Stonebridge, Charles H. Townsend, Henry F. Whit- ney and Clark Williams, all of New York; Henry A. Edwards of Albany; T. S. Palmer of Washington, D. C.; Frederic H. Kennard and William Lyman Underwood of Boston; Charles Lyman Brinsmade of Wolf, Wyom- ing, and Ernest Harold Baynes of Meriden, N. H. The reports of the President and Secretary were read in the order named, and both are given in detail elsewhere in these proceedings. 65 ite Sat = - > fo’. oo e RELIEF MAP SHOWING THE EARLY DISTRIBUTION OF AMERICAN BISON. Prepared and placed in the American Museum of Natural History under the direction of The American Bison Society. The dots on the map above represent the limit of the bison’s range over North America about one hundred years ago. In 1850, at the time the mining industries in California were developing, ‘“‘buffalo”’ were still very abundant, and were seen in countless numbers by those traveling the plains. In the year 1875, they occupied only a relatively small portion of the country. The northern herd occupied the eastern foothills of the Rocky Mountains and the sparsely settled plains of the northwest, and the southern herd roamed over the country that now comprises part of the states of Nebraska, Kansas, Colorado, Texas and Oklahoma. 66 RELIEF MAP SHOWING THE STAGES IN EXTINCTION OF AMERICAN BISON AND LOCATION OF THE EXISTING HERDS, CAPTIVE AND WILD. Prepared and placed in The American Museum of Natural History under the direction of The American Bison Society. In 1886, the work of extermination was practically completed, and only a few scattered herds remained. About 325 wild buffalo are in existence to-day. Of these, 300 occupy a small area west of the Athabasca River in British America, and 25 live in the Yellowstone National Park. . The total number of living bison on January 1, 1908, was approximately 1917. 67 Mr. I’. H. Kennard reported that his Committee had placed in the Mammal Hall of the American Museum of Natural History, a large colored relief map showing the range of the buffalo in early times and the locations of the principal herds still existing. Mr. Harry V. Radford spoke of the extended trip he was about to take in the Northwest, and the Executive Committee was authorized to appropriate a sum not ex- ceeding two hundred dollars to enable Mr. Radford to visit the wild wood-bison of Athabasca, and report his observations on this herd to the American Bison Society. In order to show appreciation of the generosity of those who contributed to the fund for the purchase of the Mon- tana National Bison Herd, but who were not already members of the Society, it was decided to enroll all sub- scribers to this fund on the Society’s books, and on motion each was given the form of membership to which his sub- scription entitled him, viz:—those having subscribed one thousand dollars or more, a patronship; those having sub- scribed one hundred dollars or more, but less than one thousand dollars, a life membership; those having sub- scribed five dollars or more but less than one hundred dol- lars, a membership for one year; those having subscribed one dollar or more but less than five dollars, an associate membership for one year. It was further decided that those who had presented the Society with living buffaloes which in the opinion of the Executive Committee were worth one thousand dollars or more, should be made patrons of the Society, and that those who had presented buffaloes, which in the opinion of the Executive Committee were worth less than one thou- sand dollars, should be made life members of the Society. The following members were elected to fill the nine vacancies occurring in the Board of Managers:—Mrs. Ezra R. Thayer, Clark Williams, William Lyman Under- wood, Morton J. Elrod, Madison Grant, H. C. Bumpus, C.J. Jones, A. Bowen Perry, and Charles H. Stonebridge. The auditing committee appointed by the President reported that the accounts of the Treasurer had been ex- amined and found correct, and the meeting adjourned. 65 TREASURER’S REPORT, January 1, 1908, ro DecEMBER 31, 1908. Balances January jst; 1908)... 2.22.2 RECEIPTS. Dues, Subscriptions and Donations, General | SOT a a6 ets ene cpels Se ark Ni eee ne ee $1,507.80 Subscriptions to Montana National Bison Herd J PLDT Ui ee eee ie Se coe eae aa ee ea 5,368.00 IN GET'S tapaesse oe telnet ne ead (ee ah 39.93 BG 5 [eS pe a Seat ye ee MLM oA A DISBURSEMENTS. POS GA Cheese, hoe ee nO ene a ea NS $ 119.02 ixechangeron.@heckgrs- 2-5 te. 8 ee 5.92 Petty, ‘Cashe@E er. Baynes, Secretary )-2-.-....- POM fa Salary, Wi; Ho Baynes, Secretary... —--......- 200.38 Brinting yand Statlomeny =.) 28 5 ee 1,713.83 Miscellaneous: : Professor Morton J. Elrod, preparing report and recommendations for location of Na- tional Bison Herd on Flathead Reservation 100.00 W. T. Hornaday, official expenses, March tomo ri ly: 2 Ose O Ga. ee oes ete see oe 58.42 W. T. Hornaday, official expenses, May 5 tos diulya AiO OS ts ac 2 Set eee 59.72 E. H. Baynes, account expenses of Western LID ON eae 2M ae NE = Bs ek ere a ee eee 500.00 Henry Romeike, Press ‘Clippings ==: 22—— O44 H. F. Whitney, Clerical Assistance year 1909 120.00 Balance 6,915.73 $8,668.95 CLARK WILLIAMS, Treasurer. 69 BOARD OF MANAGERS’ MEETING ae the Annual Meeting of the Board of Managers, held at the American viaieeutn of Natural History, there were present William 'T. Hornaday, Franklin W. Hooper, A. A. Anderson, Edmund Seymour, Charles H. Stone- brdge,. Prederie (HC Kennard, “Et. -C. “Bumpus, 2)s: Palmer and Ernest Harold Baynes. The following officers were elected:—Honorary Presi- dent, Honorable ‘Theodore Roosevelt; Honorary Vice- President, His Excellency Earl Grey, Governor General of Canada; President, William 'T. Hornaday; Vice-Presi- dents, Frederic H. Kennard and A. A. Anderson; 'Treas- urer, Clark Williams; Secretary, Ernest Harold Baynes; Executive Committee:—The President and Secretary, ex- officio; T. S. Palmer, Gifford Pinchot, Madison Grant, Frederic H. Kennard and Wiliam Lyman Underwood. The President, and Messrs. Clark Willams and Fred- eric H. Kennard were appointed a committee to purchase the buffalo for the Montana Range. Prof. Hooper, Dr. Hornaday and Madison Grant were appointed a committee to take such steps as might be necessary to secure the passage of a bill providing for a herd of buffalo on a suitable range in the Adirondacks, and to secure the signature of the Governor of New York State. Prof. Hooper explained that it had been deemed wise to postpone the summer meeting of the Society at Corbin Park, on account of the absence of the Secretary in the West, and partly because President Roosevelt found that he could not be present. The Committee having the mat- ter in charge was authorized to arrange for the meeting this year, if found practicable to do so. Prof. Hooper, Dr. Hornaday and Dr. Palmer, were appointed a committee to consider the question of state buffalo herds, with power to take such steps as might be necessary to provide for the establishment of state parks for the maintenance of buffaloes. 70 CONSTITUTION OF THE AMERICAN BISON SOCIETY. ARTICLE I—NAME The name of this organization shall be The American Bison Society. ARTICLE II.—OBJECTS The objects of this Society shall be the permanent preservation and increase of the American Bison. ARTICLE III —MEMBERSHIP Section 1—The membership of this Society shall consist of Associate Members, Members, Life Members, and Patrons. Section 2.—Any person in sympathy with the objects of this Society may become an Associate Member by paying the prescribed dues. Any person in sympathy with the objects of this Society may become a Patron, Life Member, or Member upon election by the Executive Committee and payment of the prescribed fees or dues. Section 3.—The dues of an Associate Member shall be one dollar, payable annually. The dues of a Member shall be five dollars, payable annually. The fee of a Life Member shall be one hundred dollars. The fee of a Patron shall be one thousand dollars. Section 4.—A Member may be expelled from the Society upon the written recommendation of any officer, by a majority vote of the members of the Executive Committee present at any meeting, provided notice of such proposed action, with reasons therefor, be sent to the member and to the Executive Committee at least one week before such meeting. ARTICLE IV.—GOVERNMENT Section 1—The governing body of this Society shall consist of a Board of Managers of twenty-seven persons, divided into three groups of nine each. The tenure of office of the Managers shall be three years, but only nine Managers’ terms can expire by limitation in any one year. Therefore, at each annual meeting of the Society, nine new members shall be elected by ballot of a majority of the members present, due notice having been given in advance to all members. Section 2.—The Board of Managers shall elect each year at its annual meeting, from its own members, by ballot and a majority vote, a President, two Vice-Presidents, Secretary, and Treasurer, and five persons to form, with the President and Secretary, the Executive Committee of the Society. Hon- orary officers, each to serve a term of one year, may be elected at the discretion of the Executive Committee. Section 3.—Vacancies occurring in the Board of Managers and Executive Committee may be filled by the Executive Committee to complete the year in which they occur. Section 4.—At the annual meeting a Nominating Committee, consisting of three members, shall be appointed by the presiding officer; their duties shall be to present a list of candidates to fill vacancies on the Board of Managers. 1 ARTICLE V.—DUTIES OF OFFICERS Section 1.—The duties of the officers shall be such as pertain to their re- spective offices in similar societies. The President shall be ex-officio chairman of the Board of Managers and of the Executive Committee. Section 2.—The Vice-Presidents shall perform the duties of the President, in his absence, in the order of seniority of office. Section 3.—The Secretary shall record the proceedings of the Society of its Board of Managers, and of its Executive Committee, in books to be kept for the purpose; shall have charge of all records belonging to the Society, and of its publication; shall conduct the correspondence of the Society and keep a record thereof; shall inform members, Managers, and officers of their election; and shall give notice of all meetings, and inform the Managers and officers of all matters requiring their action. Section 4.—The Treasurer shall collect all bills and assessments due the Society; shall pay from the funds of the Society all bills duly approved by the President, or by three members of the Executive Committee; shall send to the Secretary once a month the names and addresses of all new members. He shall also furnish, at the request of the Executive Committee, a statement of the financial condition of the Society. ARTICLE VI—MEETINGS Section 1.—There shall be an annual meeting of the Society, for the election of Managers and other general purposes, on the second Thursday of January. Section 2.—Special meetings may be called upon seven days’ notice by the President, or on a written application signed by three members of the Board of Managers, stating the object of said meeting. Section 3.—The annual meeting of the Board of Managers shall be held immediately after the annual meeting of the members of the Society, and other meetings may be held at such times as the President or Executive Committee may deem desirable. Five members of the Board shall constitute a quorum. Section 4.—Meetings of the Executive Committee may be held at such times and places as may be appointed by the President, or, in his absence, by the Secretary, and three days’ notice of each meeting shall be given. Three members constitute a quorum. Section 5.—The order of business shall be as follows :— Reading records of previous meeting. Reports of Committees. Reading communications. Unfinished business. New business. Cushing’s Manual shall be the authority for the decision of disputed ques- tions of order and debate. ARTICLE VII—AMENDMENTS Amendments or alterations of the Constitution may be made by a two- thirds vote of a meeting of the Board of Managers at any meeting, provided written notice of the proposed change shall have been sent by mail to every member of the Board of Managers not less than seven days previous to said meeting. ~ tw MEMBERS OF THE AMERICAN BISON SOCIETY. PATRONS. CONRAD RH SmAcnmen GHARIGN Sm bie oe coer ee ee Kalispell, Mont. Brive Mountain Forest Assn. (Aucusr Corsin Est.), New York City Moony, Jou, Ei. 2. 2c-cce22) coe: Eee er ce ee eee Salt Lake City, Utah JE TAO .Re eae Ll) WAAR Siete esas teres Cae eens 2 eee ee St. Paul, Minn. GoopniGruns GEAR NS) eee ee Shee Goodnight, Texas 13 Gi Of pal 007 feel oe OP a Bre ee eo a et a New York City IPAGHETALE vec SAINTE Seeeeeron oo ete ese ae a SS ee Lee Fort Pierre, S. D. REY DEC el aiytel O28 1.1039 07 ce) ty DRS Se CoN RE On nee a New York City LIFE MEMBERS. PARNED IRS OIN spac Nee Nee 22 oe ane a goss SE et ate eae New York City TARGET OLD) iyo) OUEUN LD) sono es i ede eae New York City PACTERGIINTS St EVID WEL ose ae nee es ae ee ce se Boston, Mass. IB ANVaI Ts See VAC Rig (©, eee eee a eee ee ee Boston, Mass. 1 BSS op SIS ape Ua 6a i RC a me Pe New York City PS REURR O) Y pc) eel c et: a woe ee. la anne eee eo, SP Ae ese te Boston, Mass. IBRINSMADE, CHARLES LV MAN =< 220.002 2ec-ct2.cetsegeec-ceecee tee Brooklyn, N. Y. TRO ORS yee Pa Fa Es Cee ek, Nee tee ee a Boston, Mass. IBRUC mes Virssti Mite Woes rere we cee Boas ee eee New York City CARNEGIE rea AUNID RIN Wane eee nn ee eee ee New York City (GN Sig) ae VAG 29 07.5 0) gee te RC ee a New York City -CoLutaARD,) Mrs. 'G@ORGE WV 2222222. New York City CoNARROE, Mins: GuorGe Nas 3-2-2222. —.. Philadelphia, Pa, WC ORBENG cAUS TUNG) eerste ee estes tp 2h. ees ee ees de .....New York City I DRAPER wi lnGeebe NR Ves Bree ete ee Sa New York City AETDG Es Te peer ONG Rn ya eee ee Sc = eee a sy cee et New York City: SNS VVWANER TD Selb eee Nice eee re eee Ra es ee a ew Albany, N. Y. PSENIBR EW | MinSs Wi. EL ARRISONis-22 sss oe eee Haverford, Pa. EIS TABRO OK AUR MENU IR Byaieeere oo oe ts eet coe ee ea Boston, Mass. EO SSE rsa eee ey eee ee Ee ee ee eee New York City GEO Ta eV Vos ae mee ne Ne EO eee Pea te at New York City PEW NISED AW GV AINE UO eee ate ese ee eet ee Cambridge, Mass. | Es (Cede neg) VE te ame ie Bi eo ene epee een Aeon EUS ee New York City LiniGrn gee GMORGE ist ceo ere, ee oe North Grafton, Mass. KENNER De ERD DRTC wae lel eas eee ee Boston, Mass. ze ISRRUNGNG AUHRInD sant V Noa ss ape VA ANR TNE Ady eee wee eee ne eee eeee® Boston, Mass. IGT DT se N som eae le A Ne ee ee ee Boston, Mass. * Deceased. IGAWRENGES, SAUNORY: CAG: eta eee sent ee eee ee eee rene Boston, Mass. Mie@onrouGHy hot Ag 3s x noc) A ee ee ee New York City NUNE TERN: CrUuB in: ico". e cee ee ee eee New York City NORTON G-- oREDERICK=:. of e eee eee rs eee New York City INCOR DOIN VV oe oe ae were ee ee ee se New York City IPBARODY, GORGE Ache sere Oe ease, eee Danvers, Mass. Pant LIP sad ON Gs. c.2..o. Je ee hoe terete ee ee Boston, Mass. PI EREP Ss; ON, UNI ses etcetera eats eee ee cee Pittsburg, Pa. PARR CES URINE: (OTA ee ee oe oe ne eee New York City Rina Gi OR GE gel) eae eee oe eee ee ee New York City UG RRs VWViBL PAN oeo ee. ook eee a nee eee es Chicago, Ill. SaRGEN De @RARTAS) oie tee ed oe ee ee Brookline, Mass. SLOANE As VWTEETANG jE 0 ye 2 ere oe oe) eee! New York City PEP ACV NR MR ZARUAY UTOPIA Ve oe enn en eee aes Boston, Mass. (REPAY lo MIR Se UZ RAGURUDP LE Verse we te eee ee eee Boston, Mass. A ESSA, red OUI gee eae sane ne ees eke Lancaster, Mass. AMETONEP SON: VDSS eo Fic eee on sre eh sees, ease New York City AT UHRRINTO Re eda os oer cen aren. sees. cde em ae ee eS New York City Unperwoop, WituiaM LYMAN ..............------------- EP es ee Belmont, Mass. WIAD S WOR DET Goss ecaeeee eee ee eee ay eas eee Middletown, Conn. WASHBURN, Hon i@rmsRnms Gi 2 25.2 2 eee Worcester, Mass. VEEL AIRE GING VOID TAM ole cat einen cs Sect oe een 5, ee eee a en Groton, Mass. Wil raiviss AGS OINt a eee ee eae ee ete ge oe Buffalo, N. Y. WioLcorn, PRESCOTT 2-25 Sih ae Ss Se Readville, Mass. MEMBERS. FAD AINES;;- URO OWS Sno kt ow it Mee et lER 2 ce ee ee a ee Quincy, Mass. AATGD RIG He {OC EPARIGE Gk ee oe eras thes eee ee eee ee Worcester, Mass. Ha Fp OV Oo SPM Coeycle] Bars nay rey sein Os MRP MEAT Pe Mey RNa ean e Ses Worcester, Mass. PASTING eH ADVISOR eA oo oer ot ee a Bee ee ee Philadelphia, Pa. UASTATRIINS | Gis OWE Aenea aves. Seen eee ee ee Cambridge, Mass. TANTO RSV) BAUR EMORY cs Bee eres eee et tee Boston, Mass. FASNOR SY pptlNIGE RS Oils See ee ee ee ees Boston, Mass. CNIOINSVINEO W'S pies Grn Nis ese es ee eee Se ee PASE IVT TVACGE Tae Gr OTR GT VV em ee ee Havana, Cuba AUBREY 3 CHARLES: e255 Geet cera ee aes ee ee Browning, Montana IB AVAG TUB Die Aer eet eed eh Os A os CR eee Chicago, Ill. BAKER. DRE MORAN Koc fcc. cess eee ce een 2 oes Breas olen Washington, D. C. Biss, SGoRORGE 1 Midas. cone ke eee ene Monee eee Worcester, Mass. IBYAC VANES OR INGE! Sia be TOC © 11) eee ee Meriden, N. H. BE EMON DT, /Ry.8 SU GUR Tee tee e ee ee ee New York City BEN ARD Uy) OEMs ceees es. we Macs coe eeas! cut eS Gee New York City Benson, ALEXANDER........------ emer 2A ee a eee Philadelphia, Pa. BIGELOW), JOSEPH G22 ee. 22-22. -s-2 eee pie. se SER ep Cohassett, Mass. Brakn. GrorGm ies) Sth es a SOREN PRET Worcester, Mass. Brake, Miss Susan Sis v2.22 oc er ee ee Melrose, Mass. V BK On Do CONe Oh (Os G20 Yaad ce eee eo el ae Boston, Mass. V BYR SICH ENO yal [se eo ie Oe a Yonkers, N. Y. ISRIDGHAIN, (JOSEPH 312005 - eels toh oe, ct etenee sens ome E. Providence Centre, R. I. DRED GMUAING, ait ORB RTS Dee 2e cesses ens cece Bae st ccee oewceee Seca secede eee Brooklyn, N. Y. BROOKS, 7 OTN El WN Ve oo ee oe toe ee eee aa Boston, Mass. 18.9 SX 0) Asis Oi Oil 6290) : Seep ee - e a e a te ee ee Worcester, Mass. UNDE US el) Ree De Ccer h emer Oe ee eR NE es ee coc sees New York City BG REBIGH. (GEORGE ey W soos sesen cece c os aneee ease ee New York City UP EEN EVANS AU OLIN le ee eee re eee pte Sac oes Fate Gete eee ode ee Boston, Mass. AUR ON is PEG ecne steers aca na fees Sees s, Sock nace an oe nee hc nace Deephaven, Minn. GAB Ores OHTA Te SV ease sh eee ere cask a sees ies oak a lecoeete eS cetety Boston, Mass. GSS O ae VN Ad Ute aa ik oe Pen PRR ee SRapt RP ONAL Boston, Mass. (CAIN ANN Nig SSCA EVAN DIN 1 5 nen coc dcn case antcae-asenathntvtssdeeo New York City CART Yop AR DUR Nee se oe ater e ee ee eee Waltham, Mass. (CARTE YA PEMEINIR Vg Uc terece eect ass ose n= Pe eee ee See kc os Le New York City CARNE GIeely- NIOR RIS) ieee soe ee en ee tl New York City CARED ING EAAIME TON PM, ee fees cet actos. cas Sek eSee WUGUUANe, Bs. oi oace oe cecea cee cet n came aeecence eee Worcester, Mass. SmLTmES, Nins. VW pita oo eee ee ee eee Philadelphia, Pa. SETON, ERNEST: DHOMPSON 2.22256 -25e0 gece s-ces ocean eee eneaee Cos Cob, Conn. SEYMOUR, [UDMUND 2. cso20-ts feo s.32. haa cyte oe New York City SHUR AS DIGS ELON GOR GW fede. a cosee so neceaxeneme rete a Washington, D. C. ROP EU e (hl Bo & Gab wh LOY 0) 0 eae ae re ee Rn em a Se oR ee Worcester, Mass. SMEEET,, ERAN By ei setend oe T eee oe ates eee Worcester, Mass. SMITH, EV AIRES Wisp stom rn erent scetSeac ae ee Sat rete a ees Worcester, Mass. SMITE, 7Ji. Ge RAM. nto ose. fos eee ae co) ee ete ee New York City PSS IMEL ES ELigt -c) | OETIN Magoo se se ee eee ee New York City ROUT GaP s Bye Ji aga A NO OAc Sa ig See ae nee ee tea ed Worcester, Mass. SS MISE VV sa EN DIN CSTs Bos oes cs 2d ieee sce a ecte see, kha ae Philadelphia, Pa. SAE IN Ghigp I OEION ee pees 2 cre oe os own eee Ses ene See Boston, Mass. SSPAWMSDIN Gi, VIRGRET ET Ss ose oon co eae sae emcee acces secs ssusedcansee anes Chicago, Il. SPUAUIEIDIN Gay VV REE WAM a S)cs nse eo senen eae rk ee aes ues setae nes Boston, Mass. STEPS GOs pastes cos eee eee ee ee eh DAR eae Cincinnati, Ohio Siiitwielis lewis ab ..tes 28 ees Se ere ee ee Lakewood, N. J. STO INIE oi ary etme tear Sa ee re ee, 7 econ eeene Ws, eae Cleveland, Ohio STONRERIDGH : ©ART MS) Gly ses =. eho ee ee ee New York City SDRUORGIS, (CHART MS!) WW 6 8e se: Cocco oe See eee stan hace eee Been Boston, Mass. SG WAVES ANT On UTR WORD eae oetees ae vaca seen een ese e ee New York City ULGEWAN, < Lrto mais Tal 22.22.55 2c fen: tocaceac cs one caec cata seaqee cases Worcester, Mass. APA TOR) EOWA coos ate cue te ena ote reseed Sects tec eee ee Worcester, Mass. Tayvton, U.S. .N., Lr. Commanprmr Mi. Men. -..--.- Boston Navy Yard ALVA ORV Webs eee seeee a By ase mase 2 Soha ebd ee cl ares eee Worcester, Mass. FREE AW VEIN S/AMOUIN, oc 2s oe Se ee ec neces New York City HernAww | Miss) wale N(R Te DAY ee O22 ee Seether eee New York City BIN ER ASB eh OAR Siig see oe sates hes ens eee 2 er ee Worcester, Mass. IPTORNDIR ES 7 NUGUSTUS = cees.<2 ee belo cae ete ee Boston, Mass. TaoORNDIKW, OR, LOWNSEND: Wosi2 223 ee ee Boston, Mass. (EOWNSEND,{ CHARLES "©, 25: ls ois n teense see mene Philadelphia, Pa. TOWNSEND, (CHART WS) W gates 22ccececccccsscuees tee een eee Boston, Mass. TROWBRIDGE Winss) IGOUISE Aes e520 sees cee New York City SU pe CeTee WW tN eo ek ig 9 ae ee eats eee Boston, Mass. PING KRM AUN 5). VV Alle ER EN cnctne cease ot See ee eee Oe nes eases Washington, D. C. Ups m, GrorGneB <= 222 ie ee ee Boston, Mass. Visi VN ORDEN,. WAR NIBR, Mi oo 3 ea eee eS eecee New York City WANG Nae DR OR WEEE 2 ye eee ae, Sanne eee ene oe ee Boston, Mass. Wo ORES, SIR ODOR Ss. 222 ecoee oee cee eee e Philadelphia, Pa. AVA Tre RGN os SAUNA ED Tis oh ae ee ec oe eee eh Se ee eee Boston, Mass. VV EACS TIES USERINTT er EJ GTN: 1) re a Se renee See Worcester, Mass. VV AUD TRE Ssy VW ies Wicd ee ee SE cn cen os ee Pittsburg, Pa. Weiss" GORGE Woo) ene te rece Southbridge, Mass. WEED ARTO Ne Pls AOR eae ee are oe as FS re eet ...-Philadelphia, Pa. A162 Gop sp 0) : ew Wey 5.9 UCP U I): el & (eee caer Reais ene Ne rms Sip oer ee as Bryn Mawr, Pa. WEL ING WV DD LTA Me osc cee ee eee eee Philadelphia, Pa. NAGE Oy ose) NLU ofl ei pean ee Boston, Mass. fia tah open I cePaa (C0): @ fae) i A Re ee al New York City NiaiGis (aw is (aie O22 2 0p eee ae a a Whitinsville, Mass. WWVEHUETI Ns MEARS OMe 260 econ cel coe 8 tho ote ds Sede Whitinsville, Mass. AYES OD a ee Worcester, Mass. JAVA BG Oo. BN 7 ee eva me New York City NAVD OSH 5 Ati cad lee ie obs ale ein eine avg ir ee ae Worcester, Mass. VU COS OD 0 Ns S00 ee ay een PnP en een et nay Philadelphia, Pa. WYO OD WARD Drs MG Pe ooo ceca Bel ceetasten sweet Worcester, Mass. NVRIGH TS: WiIttTAM RED WOOD: 2.222.021: 78Rs ieedeecce Philadelphia, Pa. WoOuNG, GENERA S- B., Mes. .0b. 7 Yellowstone Park, Wyo. ZIMMERMANN UNUABGON Wilf 2 es oe es Philadelphia, Pa. ASSOCIATE MEMBERS. VaiEy roy wat © oh esto ga © dee ee he eee ee Ee Se Pe a New York City ENO VE ge oppo ce cue ae eke tee Resa ede he Boston, Mass. AmiBuENS,, Mus. (George ADOUPH..22-.2c2.---200-0-2o50o-seecccedeeetee Baltimore, Md. FeNi O48 4 0) Opa O.1-[ OF. 0 : Men ep RO, Saree mn eee ene ee Portsmouth, N. H. WANG) ODS peal RE fk ea gee er a alo eee Ee Boston, Mass. Tel gy OHM TOSS (eee Wig © eke o-e seene Sar enti eee Siew amie nen Montreal, Canada UPS ATG Cet ggs Nice re oor ee Steere ces A eee ee ese Stoneham, Mass. D BV NGE} 0) Gag ial Sede ieee i are LA ea? Oe OMe Ne eee no Pe PO oe Boston, Mass. TByReri se VV PE LA ME oe bee ee sees ee ne SB stented fete an Boston, Mass. Banks, A. BLEECKER........... epee a oak A ii eer ie Albany, N. Y. WBN eis yh odd LY EP Ne UA 18 00 gs) pe a Re ae ar Baltimore, Md. BAR TEM, sean! ez. e222 t-te CS nt cen Stsdek ee Portsmouth, N. H. SR er HES Oe cee ee are ees a ee gee Woodsville, N. H. SIRT ONG ity Tee Wie 2 sees ae Snes he foo wte eared teeth ce -aesbades Middleburg, Va. BAY Nines) Minse Bing ldc ett See. ene cass stn acne eres Meriden, N. H. 1 Bo Ue opm Ig 0c 0) mY) ene ee i co ee Oakland, Cal. IES EATS sore) OL Ng cee ae ogee ag St ape co RE cles St. Louis, Mo. I BAG UN OYSIEN Ga Opst)s 6 0/768 Of i1 1) ed 6 een ee Uae oe ga ne PPE Glen Cove, L. I. IAC IUAINT Sia ID) Bee: ow gee ee eee le ee Jobstown, N. J. IES AUER wad OIG oy pret ne eles Ee ee ee see cn ute Washington, D. C. IB TET SS aed iNin Va ieee eee ete SNe See ee New York City sO RRDMIAN: SAMO E Reis. 8 2 fee Fed Sean teeta de Hyde Park, Mass. IOGGS ste RPV ARTs Wilkes semsees cee tc UAE WS Oakland, Cal. Blomii see Avi yp bees oes ee ee East Orange, N. J. BOND ey lel GRDEK OPW. 5 tee tee eee a es oe New York City I OGRE Meg OB BRD ye oe ote eg FA) Te oes ee New York City JO WAG EING VTS eee 5 eee ee Se see eas ees deca eee ree eck Cincinnati, Ohio aXe) 'a Ded Cag 0128 OU Mell Cys a ge A ee ee ee ee ree Mansfield, Mass. BOWS TONG HO OSHIP Hise... hac epee U1. Ben ht ce eo 2 Portsmouth, N. H. BR AVION EIMNR Vs eee ene i ees Santa Rosa, Cal, BRING ee LPTONUAS Ncw oe oe ee a ees ee nil ates BEN ait Maynard, Mass. 79 RE WUS TE 5 ROR AUN Re Sah saps Sone a sep oe eee Boston, Mass. BRO WATER: WW LGrAM > 2 nd cee es eee eee eee Cambridge, Mass. BROOKS sy) ELEN Yo ee ee ee Concord, Mass. BRYAN ESD WARD oe soccer eae ee es Cambridge, Mass. IES IK Tees Fens Ce cet oe ee eet cee ce ee Melrose, Mass. Buppy, III., Lewis ....Kast Orange, N. J. | BLOT OW I) 59 Dar 0 ete 6 Ree am ner Ea ot LE NEE re Base RSP renee PEE se Boston, Mass. Burnett, Mrs. Joseru C Buzzarp, S. O CALLENDER, W. R Gainey PNR VE 2c ee eS eR, ee tat ecenee rs Cambridge. Cary, Evizasetu M. L CARPENTER, Dr. G. C CARPENTER, Dr. M. A CarRIER, P. S Carrorn,. 2s A Carson, Ropertr D CarTER, JoHN H Casemendr, D:. D........ CuaFFEE, Henry S CuapMan, WILLIAM O Cuase, H. Cuurcu, Arruur L CLARK CLARK CLARK CriarRkK, Epwarp C CruarK, Mrs. J. M CieGHoRN, F. S CLEVELAND, W. B... CopMAN, JULIAN , CLARENCE M Ge. SUNT OIEUY@MN Vite eter a RR eggs he hang ee ee Lynn, Mass. Wilmington, Del. Providence, R. I. Mass. NE e Mass. Buffalo, Lowell, Lowell, Mass. Pat Middletown, Conn. Endicott City, Md. Germantown, Pa. Lawrence, Mass. id te ene ee Ln Painsville, O. Providence, R. I. Salem, Mass. Amesbury, Mass. Philadelphia, Pa. Philadelphia, Pa. Pittsburg, Pa. Detroit, Michigan East Weymouth, Mass. Cohassett,- Mass. Boston, Mass. South Newbury, O. Boston, Mass. OTR UR NW oe pe eden so ee ee eee ee Everett, Mass. Couiins, Henry H CoMINS, ConkLIN, Frank H Coruus, Miss MarGaret CRISAND, CARL Curry, S. CurtTIN, Rotanp G Curtis, Jr., C. DanieEts, Ricuarp H DaRLING, JamMEs L Davenport, Dr. C. B Davenport, NORMAN Davis, Miss Erta A.... Davis, Harotp H DELABARRE, FRANK A.. DELAFIELD, JoHN Ross....... Philadelphia, Pa. Baltimore, Md. Boston, Mass. Philadelphia, Pa. Philadelphia, Pa. Worcester, Mass. (Siig oe /eng Oe E ROS RO EERE OSE a8. sey NMBA Dc Lai ae Sl oe Boston, Mass. Philadelphia, Pa. Boston, Mass. Boston, Mass. East Hartford, Conn. Cold Spring Harbor, L. I. Boston, Mass. Oxford, Mass. Southford, Conn. eee New York City pg ee Boston, Mass. eS New York City JD stub avd LA GCA af Cee ea ee Se ae ee ee eo ee Lowell, Mass. ID aerial O Npaeeeaee ae eee hacen sh ete th Paris, France DOE CGY GS re 8 WN VES el Be ants gtk let ee ee eee Peekamose, N. Y. Dre @ Circe) NUNS ese ee ea recA Peekamose, N. Y. DOR RANCH SANViUiE i Messe ees Providence, R. f. DING politi 0) (© uN eet ely ee Richmond, Va. VOY oar ob ofa Y Gk Toewre nd © ee A AORN ce a oe Wickford, R. I. PAS 2 ENDWAR RAS Se tete ote eed ee ee eo Sl Buffalo, N. Y. HVATIONG, IORANCIS 3922222022- 2222.22... Pu ee aes he Pose Se Boston, Mass. IE DINEO NDS aco HUN Ve esse Sens cee ee ee New York City TCO, MORSE eae eee, Newton Highlands, Mass. IB irn Som Crt Gripes ata a ee Pek 5 ee ee Norwalk, Conn. AGING Nicta bel ee orem aa a 2 ee a Be eed Stoneham, Mass. IEW VEAVINIS fe COnEU AUR Steere err ineenS, Aes A on ke ee. Wee Philadelphia, Pa. SET h DWAR Dg ieee eee See Pa ey ee FA Philadelphia, Pa. eno we leas (GARTER MI ae. ee ee ee ee ce Boston, Mass. AES EENGVAND: TD) gu LO) Fae gi Ace oes ee =e ae POL ee tl Se al oe Boston, Mass. ESTATE NDING lie eee eer AE, OS te Rate Swampscott, Mass. BOSS ur ANAM Bis basemen foes ee see sc eee ee se North Andover, Mass. ROSTER, mV EUMUAM biRNIRY 22. 228 koe ee ee Philadelphia, Pa. ISREE NAN; Rap WAIPR Rd). 2 ooo es ee eee ae Philadelphia, Pa. Brenom, Miss Main @iniZaABe ie. ....2..0. 22.2... Sale Pittsburg, Pa. GES NER OSM IRERUALe 2 se eet 5S tee West Somerville, Mass. (Gah ae DANO npn) See ah pe oe Pee oe ne ener ee Glen ‘Cove, Li. 1., N.Y. GEENANG Mins a JOSEPHINE) Mi 22-02. coe eee chee Be New York City (Gromoroieio, Jno. dios; 16k... ee Hanover, N. H. GinWistVAMESUWW G22 == 2 ee fe ee Se Buffalo, N. Y. CG ODENYien eA RV erste aoe se Ev aes Meee Ae Philadelphia, Pa. Gowip,. GEORGE Hi... 2.8.2 £2, Set eae ee eee Santa Barbara, Cal. GourpsRosmnnele.c ae eee see Le oe Fitchburg, Mass. GIANT ES AL em oC WS oh ek een a ee cee tae ee New York City GRAY, PAR BERUs/.. 25 = 22 eae ae a AES, New York City GROAN Va SEU OE SUNGDD 2 x ee ooo a a ee el Ae OR a Boston, Mass. GRAYSON CHAIN Satya ee ee eee Philadelphia, Pa. GRU ET He mV CAITRIN Ny Gets 2 oe en ee Philadelphia, Pa. Grooms List ee se ANTS Savy 9p v8 Th ee Op, les Warrenstown, Va. GUNIMER? ab REN CKGe le oar ie oo A 5. Atlantic City, N. J. PLGA, UCARURYS Ges 2o3 tees. 2 cere eee set Pe ee ora Schenectady, N. Y. EWAN NIANSOR ID Gras Witte: 2 ek wee ee ee! Portsmouth, N. H. PCSRIBIS ONE EUAN PEGE WW 2. A828 oS ret a ae ee Pittsburg, Pa. EARS OG Ein GC eeleeeee ee ELCs Re tee he eed ee ae Sewickley, Pa. IW Anre AUN eWay etiam gt Sk Les Hamilton, Ont., Canada Fle RISse NONGG ONY. eee Meme eset cease bc cceek. Philadelphia, Pa. IT ELGAVER 1 ap Le Ln NR Vane Vk ee ee deere oe ee es Be eee oe Boston, Mass. AERIS ak ©) as Oe arate ee Ls seeas See ee New Orleans, La. ISlAgHEtAR Oe, IMEOINOAR) See ee ee New Bedford, Mass. ETOAC eae IANS Kage See alee oe, Lond REN EEL ea ee ele Redlands, Cal. Fede GT AUN en Vise NAR se OE on ea, eRe Pittsburg, Pa. Jabteisyaa. Jalninese (Cron ee ee eee PN NG pee a eee Hyde Park, Mass. EU 12, aD Rem EA OiAUR De KOREN) NED Vi 2-8 2 he eee Philadelphia, Pa. | Op ot PP Ea Peron eet de a re ee Baltimore, Md. Honan < Tisro Meas) Vesa oo cas hen tose sec eeecce toca cste tees Philadelphia, Pa. On MES cOs WW saioee ee Ace eee Soe ee a eae eee Newton, Mass. PIOP KING). WiOOU WOR UE et canet ore eae eh ee oe eta Woolworth, Mass. ELOR TON, ART EUR ABs 22a, eel oe ee Lexington, Mass. FLOW ELT,” EIN DAMEN = 2. conte So eter erent eee eee Long Hills, N. J. ELUIDEKOPER;, WIA GIS i226: ee sees ee Sand Creek, North Dakota FLUMPIIR INS, RICHARD (C2222 tiie ete a ese Uphams Corner, Mass. BRN MC WARTS Wire stesso eee ce eae eee North Charlestown, N. H. ELUM ds, rz Ae et VV ces oe re eee eae Pasadena, Cal. Je Gon fanaety fw BRS! dag 8 Op igal C same: 2 ale anne Speen eee mee Pasadena, Cal. PN a ye Mass pr Ace Vee ee oe ce Bae Rea cee ee ee Pasadena, Cal. LU RD ED WA Dig Ns oon tc See eee ee ae el tt ae Milton, Mass. iy mee VAR yA TAT Dn eee oe ee ee ee ere Baltimore, Md. SJOEUNISON | Ac MURINIGSTS cee. 2 ces Bere ore eae ee Concord, N. H. VOHINAONG WERE RAT se cer eo eee ee ere Boston, Mass. JiONTS AH DWARD ALUSSHE Lecce. eed eee Fort Washington, Pa. JIORDANSS VUISS CTAR A: Ms = 4 soe ae ee re ee Brookline, Mass. Kinin ye JOSmPr: Alsi ie Se ee eae Pittsburg, Pa. 1G on Os Opera OO Te © of SINS ete ee ee eee a eR E nae San Carlos, Ariz. KUEN DAU IGy VV oy oct ete eee center caer hee Se eee Bowdoinham, Me. DG Bp) 2) 0S 7. 2 0 ee aA a tL ee Pe ey Smee Baltimore, Md. KanvER ne VirsseMiAnv yA) ee re Providence, R. I. IGEN ZAG SSeS gs cee cce see ees ee once en he Pe ee Lansdowne, Pa. KEDUREDGH SDs re eee oe Hastings on Hudson, N. Y. TSO rae oe Gp Ne Fo ec we ae as ee See St. Louis, Mo. IKKORNE ETCH: Jie Di WARD= 26.22 ine eee oe ene ee Milwaukee, Wis. pO. G23) 28.0) 1h) ete ee ge ee a ee eee ey Manchester, N. H. DO Ge op 7 ep ws (Sa De ee cn tae eee ene ea eee ee em eeene cole vee ate eee Beverly, Mass. [a Movin RAN GIs 4) 220 ee ee ae =. sPittspurg, sas en Gams TO MUA ye2ee- 202s eee Boe eh eae ea re ao Pid ee ew Pittsburg, Pa. PEDIC O TAN sy UENS EIR Tra soe sea nee ee ae eee ca ee Boston, Mass. GUNG OLIN, PRCUR Wor OR Di Re s2 oe: foe 8 eee cee te ee Pittsburg, Pa. Tessa se ey MA Noe eos eee ee cas eee ee ce Paoli, Pa: | Gs yi By of) Bou ais Ok: ee ener eae ere sees coe ar ee RRRe Tn es Boston, Mass. WomeGsrRE iE, “Wi. NORRIS