: ¢ ne ott® EDWARD AXTELL THE BOSTON TERRIER AND ALL ABOUT IT. - A PRACTICAL, SCIENTIFIC, AND UP TO DATE GUIDE TO THE BREEDING OF THE AMERICAN DOG BY EDWARD AXTELL Proprietor St. Botolph Kennels, Cliftondale, Mass., U.S.A. ASSOCIATE MEMBER AMERICAN KENNEL CLUB MEMBER OF THE BOSTON TERRIER CLUB For Twelve Years THE BOSTON TERRIER CLUB OF NEW YORK Published by THE DOGDOM PUBLISHING COMPANY BATTLE OREEK, MICH. COPYRIGHT JANUARY IQIO BY DOGDOM PUBLISHING COMPANY. ©ClA259331 TABLE OF CONTENTS. CHAPTER I. Page Sie DOStOM + LOLbIGL vine scene tas essere ss 8 oy 9 CHAPTER II. The Boston Terrier Club; Its History; The Order of Business; Constitution, By-Laws aie) ChMICIaly SEAR ATC Je c/op aia vane) si bisa 18 ihe Boston Tetrier Standards... .. 2.25.2 28 CHAPTER III. PSommelliney Vest ans ceereis ors ain einieisvensiesy ewe at CHAPTER IV. General Hints:On Breeding... .15:0:. 20.04 2 ie a7 CHAPTER V. Reames: O LP UpMesy c. ea ho sans 4 ae aah 56 CHAPTER VI. Breeding Bor Sige: ois ov. tictain'n sip ttelcaes 68 CHAPTER VII. Breeding For Good Disposition ............ 73 CHAPTER VIII. Breeding For a Vigorous Constitution...... 81 CHAPTER IX. Breeding for Color and Markings.......... 94 CHAPTER X. n Select Saat lara siege ta cuete sich ohehatels seit oxen Taha 110 CHAPTER XI. Boston Terrier Type and the Standard...... 125 CHAPTER XII. Technical Terms used in Relation to the Bos- ton Terrier and Their Meaning.......... 133 INDEX TO ILLUSTRATIONS: Proanpopiece . 2 ete ga. ences Edward Axtell Champion Remlik Bonnie ...... Opp. page 20 Champion Druid Vixen. 4.....,: Opp. page 20 Pitta. Mian rae heals guste what ate ian Opp. page 28 Champion Caddy Belle. ........ Opp. page 26 Champion Mister Jack ........ Opp. page 36 Barnard ’s, om on. sean es Opp. page 44 PU ALS WVU A Shain o%s ona kle aba aor Opp. page 44 MO MASUET oooh nln wee ee ehiauee ae Opp. page 52 Champion Osco... <.4,08 sytiberticis Opp. page 52 ee Barieed, «ot wake pen ae ee Opp. page 60 “Pop” Benson with Bunny II ...Opp. page 68 Sit MEVATOUY. GLGe. .)scnicint ees ave oe anes Opp. page 68 Champion Lady Dainty ........ Opp. page 76 Champion Todd Boy... ..6.. ..' Opp. page 84 Squat .Panch 2). 5<)) seen Opp. page 92 Champion Willowbrook Glory...Opp. page 92 Edward (Bismnett,% Jccmsistcncne Opp. page 100 Champion Queenie V1-... <_ af , if » : ’ * 7 : ‘ , ‘ ” “~ 7 i * CHAPTER IV. — GENERAL HINTS ON BREEDING. ot Having become possessed of suitable kennds to house his stock, the breeder is confsofAtedawith the great question: How and, «yh¢ereishall:Jqeb- tain my breeding stock?,, Mush:lepends enon right start and the getting of: thy; propesi doin, of dogs for thke;foundation.:1es selebraterdl Boston pgety:s@livernc Wendel Holmas,oiwheh asked ,,when 2aichild's education. should: begin, Promptly, cepled; {Ai dhundred pears: before, itbimais borssqckhis, contains ansinhereht trathnthate dll breeders: pf cheine stockio& whateyeridescriptiin atomay be; secosnise: -Ttiberiwiell, bert ia! hadf thetbkattle, andi? thir thishapplies-with pentier- dansfosee tolitheiBeston ttrrier, fornswithetitia igond Bncestry Ofiwell bred, dogs; passe’singothe Aest ofidispositions, eonstitutions.andt cenferinity to; the standard, the,is! worse;thani juselesbsov192do oft Wihethert the start isorhade withe ene bitchoar -Bodozenp di: -believen theobest-plan-té0folkowriisi tro obtaimof-acrétiablel breeder notedofarithe general excellence ioftais, dogbsin ch ddésirable! character- asties, whatnhe considers - theo besti stock: dbtaitt able;fox bregting purposes; ;/d His does not-imply, 38 THE BOSTON TERRIER of course, that these bitches will be candidates for bench honors, but it does mean that if mated with suitable sires the production of good, all- round puppies with a reasonable amount of luck will be the result. It would be useless to attempt to deal with the subject of breeding in more than a few of its aspects, for after a period of twenty-five years of expended and scientific experiments in the breeding exclusively of Bos- tons, I shall have to confess that there are many problems still unsolved. The rules and regula- tions that govern the production of many other breeds of dogs seems impotent here, the assump- tion that “like produces like” does not seem to hold good frequently in this breed, but perhaps the elements of uncertainty give an unspeakable ‘charm to the efforts put forth for the production ‘of thé dogs which will be a credit to the owner’s kennel: “The old adage that “there is nothing duller than a puzzle of which the answer is known,” can readily be applied here. I shall endeavor to confine my remarks to the laws observed and the lines followed for the produc- tion of dogs in our kennels, especially in the attainment of correct color and markings, vigor- ous constitutions and desirable dispositions. In speaking of the breeding stock I am aware that I am going contrary to the opinion of many breeders when I state that I believe that the THE BOSTON TERRIER 39 dam should possess equal or more quality than the sire, that her influence and characteristics are perpetuated in her posterity to a greater de-. gree than are those of the sire’s, especially that. feature of paramount importance, a_ beautiful disposition, hence I speak of the maternal side. of the house first. There are two inexorable. laws that confront the breeder at the onset, more. rigid than were those of the Medes and. Per-. sians, the non-observance of which will inevit-. ably lead to shipwreck. Better by far turn: one’s energies in attempting to square the circle, or produce a strain of frogs covered with feathers, than attempt to raise Boston terriers without due attention being given to those physi-. ological laws which experience has proven cor- rect. The first law is that “Like produces like,” although, as previously stated in the case of this breed, more than in any other known to the writer, many exceptions present themselves, even when the utmost care has been exercised, still the maxim holds good in the main. The second law is that of Heredity, too often paid inadequate. attention to, but which demands constant and. unremitting apprehension, as it modifies the first: law in many ways. It may be briefly described - as the biological law by which the general char- acteristics of living creatures are repeated in their descendants. Practically every one has 40 THE BOSTON TERRIER noticed its workings in the human family, how many children bear a stronger resemblance to their grandparents, uncles, cousins, etc., than to their parents, and in the lower order of animals, and it seems to me in the Bostons especially, this tendency to atavism, or throwing back to some ancestor, in many cases quite remote, is very pronounced, hence the necessity of a good general knowledge of the pedigree and family history of the dogs the breeder selects for his foundation stock. A kennel cannot be built in a day; it takes time, money, perseverance, and a strict attention to detail to insure success. “Breed to the best,” is a golden rule, but this applies not only to the animals themselves, but also in a far greater measure to the good general qualities possessed by their ancestry. Far more pregnant with good results would be the mating of two good all-round specimens, lacking to a considerable extent show points, but the prod- ucts of two families known for their general excellence for several generations, than the off- spring would be of two noted prize winners of uncertain ancestry, neither of which possessed the inherent quality of being able to reproduce themselves. It will be noted that very few first prize winners had prize winning sires and dams. The noted stud dogs of the past, “Buster,” “Sullivan’s Punch,” “Cracksman,” “Hickey’s THE BOSTON TERRIER 41 Teddy IV.,” and many others were not in them- selves noted winners, and the same statement may be made of the dams of many of the prize winning dogs, but they possessed in themselves and their ancestry that “hall mark” of quality which appeared in a pronounced form in their offspring. Experience has shown that first class qualities must exist for several generations in order to render their perpetuation highly prob- able. The converse of this is equally true, that any bad qualities bred for the same length of time are quite as hard to eliminate. If the dog or bitch possesses weak points, be sure to breed to dogs.coming from families that are noted for their corresponding strong points. In this case the principle of “give and take” will be adopted. It used to be the ambition of every breeder (or, at least, most of them), to produce a winner, rather than the production. of a line of dogs of good uniform type, of good average salable quality, but most have lived long enough to see that this has not paid as well in money or expected results as where similar endeavors have been directed towards the production of good all-round dogs, always striving to advance their dogs to a higher grade of excellence. In this way in nearly every instance prize winning dogs have been produced, and there is this peculiarity noticeable in this breed, that any one, 42 THE BOSTON TERRIER whether he be a breeder of the greatest number, or a very poor man owning only one or two in his kitchen kennel, possesses an equal chance of producing the winner of the blue. The breeder of today has a far easier time than in the early days of the dog when type was not as pronounced or fixed, and when considerable inbreeding of necessity had to be resorted to. In almost all parts of the country stud dogs of first class lineage are obtainable and the general public are educated sufficiently to understand the good points of the dog. I think the breeding of this dog appeals to a wider class of people than any other breed, from the man of wealth who produces the puppies to be given away as wed- ding presents or Christmas gifts, down to the lone widow, or the man incapacitated for hard work, who must do something to keep the wolf from the door, and who finds in the raising of these charming little pets a certain source of income and a delightful occupation combined. I do not think that any one may apprehend that the market will ever be overstocked, for as the dog becomes known, the desire for possession among all classes will be correspondingly in- creased, and as he is strictly an American product, no importation from Europe can pos- sibly supply winners, or specially good dogs, as is the case with almost all other breeds. And THE BOSTON TERRIER 43 the fact is demonstrated that dogs of A 1 qual- ity can be produced on American soil. There are two or three subjects that demand the most careful consideration at the hands of the breeder, and to which I am afraid in many cases not particular enough attention is given. I refer in the first place to the question of in- breeding, an admitted necessity in the early history of the dog, but in the writer’s estimation very harmful and much to be discouraged at the present time. I will yield to no man in the belief that the fact is absolutely and scientifi- cally true that close consanguineous breeding is the most powerful means of determining character and establishing type, in many in- stances justifiable as the only correct way to fix desirable qualities, both physical and mental, but extreme care must be exercised that both parties to the union must be of good quality and not share the same defects, and where it is evi- dent that the extra good qualities on the one side more than outbalance the defects of the other, and extreme precaution must always be paid to avoid carrying this system too far. In regard to intense inbreeding, as in the case of mating dogs from the same sire and dam, or the bitch to her sire, or dam to son, I thing it is highly objectionable and should never under any circumstances be resorted to; failure will 44 THE BOSTON TERRIER ensue. Far better to let the bitch go by un- mated and lose six months than mate her in this way because a suitable stud dog was not at the time available. I believe that this inbreeding is productive of excessive nervousness, weak- ness in physical form, the impairment of breed- ing functions, and the predisposition to dis- ease in its multiform manifestations. That eminent authority, Sir John Seabright, the originator of the early race of bantams, known as the silver and gold spangled Sea- brights, also conducted an exhaustive series of experiments on the inbreeding of dogs and dem- onstrated to an absolute certainty that the sys- tem was productive of weakness, diminished growth, and general weediness. His experiments had a world-wide reputation and the writer, when he first visited his large estates near London, little dreamed that in after years he would personally benefit by Sir John’s work. I believe the pre- vailing ideas in many quarters a number of years ago, as to the general stupidity of the Boston terrier (and in some isolated cases I believed well founded), arose from the fact that it was popularly believed he was too much inbred. I will give just one case of inbreeding in our ken- nels, tried for experiment’s sake, as a warning. I took the most rugged bitch I possessed and mated her to her sire, a dog of equal vigor. The HALL’S MAX THE BOSTON TERRIER 48 result was six puppies, strong, and as handsome as a picture. When two months old they were sold to different parties on the Eastern sea- board, from Philadelphia up to the Canadian line. This was before the West had “caught on” to the breed. About two months later I had a letter from New York stating that the pup was growing finely, but that he seemed to be hard of hearing. A few days after this I received another epistle from Salem that the puppy I had sent on was believed to be stone deaf. It would be superfluous to add that the purchase money was returned, and the other four customers were notified of the condition of the others. It may seem somewhat incredible, but two out of the four stated that they believed the pups had de- fective hearing, and declined to receive their money back, and the other two stated that be- fore my notification they had never observed that their dogs were deaf. Here was a case of the entire litter being perfect practically in every other respect, and yet every one stone deaf, and in my estimation not worth a sou. As we have never had a case of deafness in our kennels be- fore or since, we attribute this solely to in- breeding. Another important feature, little understood, and frequently much dreaded, is that of Ante- cedent Impressions. When a bitch has been 46 THE BOSTON TERRIER served by a dog not of her own breed it has been proven in extremely rare cases that the subse- quent litters by dogs of her own kind, showed traces (or, at least, one or more of the litter did) of the dog she was first lined by. The theory by physiologists is that the life-giving germ, implanted by the first dog, penetrates the serous coat of the ovary, burrows into its paren- chyma, and seeks out immature ova, not to be ripened and discharged perhaps for years, and to produce the modifying influence described. Many breeders are unwise enough to believe that a bitch the victim of misalliance is practic- ally ruined for breeding purposes and discard her. While, of course, we believe in the fact of Antecedent Impressions, we think they are as rare as the proverbial visit of angels. We have given this subject serious attention and have tried numerous experiments, using various dogs to ward our bitches, including a pug, spaniel, wire-haired fox terrier, pointer, and perhaps one other, and we have never seen a trace of these matings in subsequent litters. One case, for example: In another part of this book we al- lude to a dog spoken of by Dr. Mott, in his “Treatise of the Boston Terrier,” named “Mug- gy Dee.” The grandmother of this charming little dog was bred in our kennels, by name, “St. Botolph’s Bessie.” He sold her to a Boston THE BOSTON TERRIER “AG banker, and she matured into a beautiful dog. Upon coming in season she was unfortunately warded by a spaniel on the estate, which so dis- gusted her owner that he gave her to the coach- man. She proved a perfect gold mine to him, as she raised two litters of elegant ideal Bostons every twelve months for a great number of years, and never at any time showed any result of the misalliance. On the subject of Mental Impressions we need say but little, as the chances of it ever taking place are so small that we merely give it a passing notice and say that in all our experience we have never been troubled with a case. For the benefit of the uninitiated will briefly state that this consists of the mental impression made on the mind of a bitch by a dog with whom she has been denied sexual intercourse, affecting the progeny resulting from the union of another dog with the bitch, generally in regard to the color, and this strange phenomena, when it does occur, is apt to mark usually one puppy of each litter. A fact not generally known by breeders is that if a bitch is lined by a second dog at any time during heat, the chances are that a second con- ception may take place, resulting in two distinct sets of pups, half-sister or brother to each other. This fact we have proven. There is one other important feature which 48 THE BOSTON TERRIER must be noticed before this chapter is closed, and that is Predetermining the Sex. Most breeders, of course, are anxious to have male pups pre- dominate in a litter, and it is a demonstrated fact that ordinary mating produces from four to ten per cent more males than females. For a number of years I had always believed it was impossible to breed so as to attain more than the excess of males above noted, but several years ago I accepted an invitation from Mr. Barnett, of Deerfoot Farm, of Southboro (the owner of Kate or Gyp, the mother of the breed), to spend the day. He was, as will be recalled, one of the earliest and most enthusiastic breed- ers of the Boston, and is now a scientific breeder of choice dairy stock. We had been discussing a number of problems in regard to raising stock, when he exclaimed: ‘Mr. Axtell, I believe I have discovered the problem of sex breeding. If I want heifer calves, I breed the cow as soon as she comes in season: If a bull calf is wanted, the cow is served just before going out of sea- son.” And said he, “In nineteen experiments I have only been unsuccessful once, and I think you might try the same plan with your Bostons.” I have since done so, and although not nearly the same measure of success has attended my experiments as his, yet by breeding bitches at the close of the heat rather than at its com- THE BOSTON TERRIER 49 mencement, the number of males in a litter has materially increased. Again, I find if a young, vigorous dog is bred to a similar bitch, females will predominate in the offspring, whereas, if the same bitch is bred to a much older dog, an excess of males will generally occur. Occa- sionally some dogs will be met with that no matter what mated with, will produce largely males, and some the opposite of this will nearly always produce females, and some bitches, no matter how bred, do likewise, but these are ex- ceptions, and not the rule. A kennel man need never worry about sex, inasmuch as good dogs of either gender will always be in demand. The law of Selection must be carefully at- tended to to insure the best results. Choose your best and most typical bitches for breeding, especially those that approximate rather to the bull type and are rather long in body and not too narrow in their hind quarters. I do not care if the dam has a somewhat longer tail than the dog, my experience has been that a bitch pos- sessing a tight screw tail did not do quite as well in whelping as one having one a little longer. Do not consider this as suggesting that the tail is a matter of secondary importance, by no means, it is of primal import, and too much attention can never be given to the production of this distinguishing mark of the dog. | >» : mA - Foe, av a a aes Pte, | i. a a > aA oo A ea cs an 7 Poni eee ma + — a _ i = 7 7 ‘ aan a a > ae aon Sar | 7 a 7 - a > ya oar) - ? <. » i 7 oe =< Can <¢: \ 7 7 ‘ =) = 2 a. a - va THE BOSTON TERRIER 61 In regard to feeding the pups after weaning, it will be found an excellent: plan to feed until ten weeks old four times a day, from that age until six months old, three times daily, and from that age until maturity, twice daily. I think a good drink of milk once a day excellent, and where there are enough fresh table scraps left to feed the pups, nothing better can be given. Where the number of dogs kept is too numerous to be supplied in this way, then a good meal of puppy buscuits in the morning, a good meal of meat (fresh butcher’s trimmings, not too fat, bought daily) with vegetables at noon and at night well cooked oatmeal or rice with milk makes an excellent safe diet. Good, large bones with some meat on are always in order, as all dogs crave, and I think ought to have, some meat raw. Be careful not to over feed, and above all do not give the dogs sweets. When a puppy is delicate or a shy feeder, an egg beaten up in milk forms an excellent change, and good fresh beef or lamb minced up will tempt the most delicate appetite. Give the pup- pies a chance to get out on the fresh grass and see what Dr. Green will do for them. Above all see that they always have free access to pure, cool water. I frequently hear numerous complaints of dog’s eyes, especially pups that have been newly 62 THE BOSTON TERRIER weaned, becoming inflamed, and in many cases small ulcers form. The same thing has occa- sionally happened in our kennels, and after try- ing practically all the eye washes on the market, sometimes without success, I applied to a friend of mine in the laboratory of the Massachusetts General Hospital and was advised by him to wash the dog’s eyes two or three times a day with a ten per cent. solution of argyrol, which has been eminently successful. For slight in- flammations a boracic acid wash, that any chem- ist will put up, will usually effect a cure. The several forms of skin disease which cause so much disquiet to young stock, preventing rest and hindering growth, are sometimes due to faults in feeding which upset the work of the assimilative organs, and are to a great extent preventable. Not so those that are due to the presence of a parasite that burrows under the skin and produces that condition of the coat commonly known as mange. A dog may go for some considerable time unsuspected, but the sooner it is discovered and attended to the bet- ter, as it is highly contagious. The first thing to do is to take an equal amount of powdered sulphur and lard, make a paste, and rub it thoroughly into the coat of the dog and let it stay on for two days. Of course, the dog will lick off all he can, but the internal application THE BOSTON TERRIER 63 will be good for him. At the end of the second day take the dog and give him a thorough wash with good castile soap, and after drying rub into his coat thoroughly (care being taken that none gets into the eyes or ears) crude petroleum. Let this stay on one day, and without washing take this time enough benzine and powdered sulphur to make a paste and rub in as before. It will be found that this has penetrated deeper than the lard and sulphur did and has doubtless reached the parasites. Repeat this twice, wash- ing in between, after which give the dog a good dressing of petroleum once a day for a week, followed by a week’s anointing with the benzine, and dollars to doughnuts, the dog’s coat will come out all right. A good dressing to be ap- plied occasionally afterwards, well rubbed into the skin, is composed of equal parts of castor, olive and kerosene oils, thoroughly mixed. If the hair has long been off apply the tincture of cantharides, or the sulphate of quinine to the bald spots, taking care the dog does not lick it with his tongue. These two remedies are best used in the form of an ointment, twice a day. In regard to fleas or lice on the young stock, a good wash in not too strong a_ solution of any of the standard tar products is usually perfectly effectual. One other disease, and that 64 THE BOSTON TERRIER the most deadly of all, remains to be considered, viz., distemper. This is largely contracted at the dog shows, or being brought into contact with dogs suffering from the disease. I do not believe it is ever spontaneous, and dogs kept away from infected stock will be exempt. Well do I remember my first dose of it. I had loaned a friend of mine a young dog raised by him to show, as he was trying for a prize for Druid Merk as a stud dog. The dog in question, Merk Jr., came back from the show rather de- pressed, and in a few days I had my entire ken- nel down with the disease. It was in the spring of the year, cold and damp, and I succeeded in Saving just one of the young dogs and Merk Jr. After a thorough fumigation with a great quan- tity of sulphur I managed to get the kennels dis- infected, and did not have an outbreak again for several years. A bitch sent to be bred where a case of distemper existed, unknown to me, of course, brought it to my place again, and I had the same unfortunate experience over again; fortunately this time it was jin the early fall, and weather conditions being auspicious, we lost only about twenty-five per cent. of young stock. By extreme vigilance, in knowing the conditions of the kennels where bitches were sent for service, we succeeded in escaping an at- tack for several years, when an old bitch that THE BOSTON TERRIER 65 had had distemper several years previously, brought back the germs in her coat from a ken- nel where two young dogs, just home from the Boston show, were sick with the disease. This was in the spring, the weather was wet and cold, and a loss of practically fifty per cent. ensued. One very interesting and peculiar feature of the last attack was, that half the dogs sick were given the best medical treatment possible, witha loss of one-half; the other half were not given any medicine whatever, and the same proportion died. Of course, all had the best of care, nurs- ing, and strict attention to diet paid. I was very much gratified to observe that in. these three attacks we have never had a dog that had a recurrence of the disease, and what is of far greater importance, have never had any after ill effect (with one solitary exception, when a bitch was left with a slight twitching of one leg) in the shape of the number of ailments that frequently follow, and in all cases after the disease had run its course the dogs seemed in a short time as vigorous as ever. This we at- tribute solely to the strong, vigorous constitu- tions the dogs possessed. A breeder who raises many dogs will have a very difficult feat to ac- complish if he aspires to enter the show ring also. In our case we were convinced at the start that these two would not go together. 66. THE BOSTON TERRIER When one considers that dogs returning from shows frequently carry the germs in their coats, and even the crates become affected, and while not suffering from the disease themselves, will readily convey it to the occupants of the kennel they come in contact with, also that the kennel man (unless a separate man has charge of in- fected stock exclusively) can readily carry the germs on his hands, person and clothing, it will instantly be perceived what a risk attends the combined breeding and showing. I think it pays best in the long run to keep these two branches of the business separate. The tempta- tion to exhibit will be very strong, but before do- ing so, count the cost, especially if much valuable young stock is in the kennels. In regard to the treatment of this much dreaded disease, there are a number of remedies on the market, one especially that has lately come out, viz., “Moore’s Toxin,’ which claims to effect a cure, but having never used it can not give a personal endorsement. Whatever remedy is tried, remember that good nursing, a suitable diet, and strict hygienic measures must be given. Feed generously of raw eggs, beaten up in milk, in which a few drops of good brandy are added, every few hours, and nour- ishing broths and gruels may be given for a change. If the eyes are affected then the THE BOSTON TERRIER 67 boracic acid wash; if the nose is stopped up, then a good steaming from the kettle. While the dog must have plenty of fresh air, be sure to avoid draughts. When the lungs and bronchial tubes are affected, then put fiannels wrung out of hot Arabian balsam around neck and chest, and give suitable doses of cod liver oil. If the disease is principally seated in the intestines, then give once a day a teaspoonful of castor oil, and the dog should be fed with arrow root gruel, made with plenty of good milk, anda very little lean meat (beef, mutton, or chicken), once a day. When the dog is on the high road to recovery be very careful he does not get cold, or pneumonia is almost certain to ensue. Do not forget a thorough fumigation of the kennels, and all utensils, with sulphur. CHAPTER VI. BREEDING FOR SIZE. When I joined the Boston Terrier Club in 1895, there were two classes for weight—the light weight, from 15 to 23 pounds, and the heavy weight, from 23 to 30 pounds, inclusive. This, of course, has been changed since to three classes—the light weight, 12 and not to exceed 17 pounds; middle weight class, 17 and not to exceed 22 pounds, and heavy weight, 22 and not to exceed 28 pounds and a class, for Toys, weighing under twelve pounds, has _ been added. The Boston terrier dog was never intended, in the writer’s estimation, to be a dog to be carried in one’s pocket, but such an one as the standard calls for, and which the oldest breeders have persistently and con- sistently bred. To my mind the ideal dog is one weighing from 15 pounds for my lady’s parlor, to 20 or 25 pounds for the dog intended as a man’s companion, suitable to tackle any kind of vermin, and to be an ideal watch dog in the house should any knights of the dark lantern make their nocturnal calls. % if “POP” BENSON WITH BUNNY II SIR BARNEY BLUE THE BOSTON TERRIER 69 During the past few years we have had (in common, I ‘suppose, with all large breeders), a great many orders for first class dogs, typical in every respect, weighing from 30 to 40 ‘pounds. The constant tendency among men of wealth today is to move from the city onto country es- tates, where they stay the greater part of the year, and in many cases all the time. They are looking for first class watch dogs that can he kept in the house or stable, that are thoroughly reliable, that do not bring too much mud in on their coats, that do not cover the furniture with long hairs, that are vigorous enough to follow on a horseback ride, and which will not wander from home. I was in the company of a party of gentlemen the other day who had bought a number of estates in a town twenty miles from Boston, and the subject of a suitable breed of dogs for their residences was under discussion. All the fashionable breeds were gone over, some were objected to because they barked too much, others because of their propensity to rush out at teams; some that their coats were too long and they brought a great deal of mud, etc., in, and still others that their fighting disposition was too pronounced, but they all agreed that a good- sized, vigorous, good natured Boston terrier just about filled the bill. Said the nephew of Senator Henry Cabot Lodge to me last week: “Edward, 70 THE*BOSTON TERRIER I want a Boston big enough to take care of him- self if anything happens, and of me also, if necessary, weighing about 35 pounds.” A Bos- ton banker, who has a large place in the country, would not take two dogs weighing under 35 pounds. Last week I received a letter from a Mr. W. B. Bogert, of the firm of Bogert, Malt- by & Co., commission grain merchants, Chicago, ordering a “very heavy weight dog of kindly disposition and good blood. I can get out here any number of light weight dogs, but I do not like them. Kindly send me what you think will suit me.” These are only a few sample cases, and I can say that my orders today call for more first class heavy weight dogs than for any other size. This is, of course, a comparatively new feature, but all up to date breeders will see the necessity of being able to fill this class of orders. The small sized toys will always be in demand, as they make ideal little pets, suitable eminently for a city flat or an apartment house, to be car- ried by the lady in her carriage, or to accompany her in her walks, and they make first rate play- mates for children. This class is by far the hardest to breed. For best results mate a bitch weighing about fifteen pounds, that comes from a numerous litter, to a twelve-pound dog that comes from small ancestry. Some of the pups are bound to be small. One important feature THE BOSTON TERRIER at in the production of small pups is this: Bitches that whelp in the fall, the smallest pups are raised from, especially if the pups are fed a somewhat restricted diet, whereas puppies that are raised in the spring, that are generously fed, and have vigorous exercise in the sunshine, at- tain a far greater size. A great many breeders underfeed their young stock to stop growth, which I believe to be a very grave mistake. There is no question whatever it accomplishes the result wished, but at the expense of stamina and a fine, generous disposition. The pups from stock advanced in years, or from bitches ex- cessively fat are very apt to run small, as are also the offspring of inbred parents. One very important fact in regard to breeding for large sized dogs to be considered is this: While a great many breeders always select for the pro- duction of large pups large bitches and dogs, yet experience has proven that the majority of big ones have been the offspring of medium sized dams that were bred to strong, heavy- boned dogs of substance. I bred a bitch weigh- ing twenty pounds to a large bull terrier that weighed forty-five pounds for an experiment, and the pups, five in number, weighed at maturity from thirty-five to forty pounds, with noses and tails nearly as long as their sire’s, and his color, but were very nice in their disposition, and were 72 THE BOSTON TERRIER given away for stable dogs. Progressive up-to- date kennel men will see that they have on hand not only the three classes called for by the stand- ard, but the fourth class, so to speak, that I have mentioned above, those weighing anywhere from thirty to forty pounds. Quite a number of breeders in the past have put in the kennel pail at birth extra large pups that they thought would mature too large to sell, but they need do so no longer. This precaution must always be taken where there are one or more of these large size puppies, viz., to look out that they do not get more than their proportionate share of the milk, or later the food, as they are very apt to crowd out the others. Remember that the Boston terrier of what- ever size will always hold his own as a com- panion, a dog that can be talked to and caressed, for between the dog and his owner will always be found a bond of affection and sympathetic understanding. CHAPTER VII. BREEDING FOR GOOD DISPOSITION: This, to my mind, is the most important fea- ture in the breeding of the dog that demands the most careful attention. If the disposition of the dog is not all that can be desired, of what avail is superb constitution, an ideal conforma- tion and beautiful color and markings? Better by far obtain the most pronounced mongrel that roams the street that shows a loving, generous nature if he cost his weight in gold, than take as a gift the most royally bred Boston that could not be depended upon at all times and under all circumstances to manifest a perfect disposition. A short time ago I went to visit a noted pack of English fox hounds. One beautiful dog especially, took my eye, a strong, vigorous, noble- looking fellow, and on my asking the kennel man, a quaint old Scotchman, if he would let the dog out for me to see, he replied: “Why, certainly, Mr. Axtell, that dog is Dashwood, he is a perfect gentleman,” and this is what all Boston terriers should be. Of course, I am speaking of the well bred, properly trained, blue 74 THE BOSTON TERRIER blooded dog, not the mongrel that so often masquerades under his name. Still, as there are black sheep in every family, a dog showing an ugly, snapping, quarrelsome disposition will occa- sionally be met with which, to the shame of the owner, is not mercifully put out of the way and buried so deep that he can not be scratched up, but is allowed to perpetuate his or her own kind to the everlasting detriment of the breed. How many a one has come away from a dog show utterly disgusted with perhaps one of the best looking dogs on the bench, who, after ad- miring its attractiveness in every detail, discovers on too near an approach to him that he possesses a snappy, vicious disposition ? I am perfectly well aware that due allowance must be made for the unnatural excitement that surrounds a dog, perhaps for the first time shown, away from all he knows, and surrounded by strange noises and faces. Yet I consider it an outrage on the public who give their time and pay their money, to subject them to any risk of being bitten by any dog, I care not of what breed it may be. Ata recent show in Boston, in company with three or four gentlemen, I was admiring a very handsome looking Boston, a candidate for high honors, when his owner called out to me: “Mr. Axtell, do not go too near him or he will bite your fingers off. I THE BOSTON TERRIER 75 replied: “You need not advise an old dog man like me; I can tell by the look of his eye what he would do if given a chance. You have no right whatever to show such a dog.” Since then I went to the kennels where a noted prize win- ner is placed at public stud, and he showed such a vicious disposition and attempt to _ bite through the bars of his pen that the attendant had to cover the bars over with a blanket. Such dogs as these should be given at once a sufficient amount of chloroform and a suitable burial without mourners. If a man must keep such a brute, then a strong chain and a secure place where his owner alone can visit him is abso- lutely imperative. Boston terriers, of all breeds, must possess perfect dispositions if they are to maintain their present popularity; and yet, how many unscru- pulous breeders and dealers are palming off upon a confiding public dogs which, instead of being “put away” (I think that is the general term they use) should be put under so much solid mother earth that no one would suspect their interment. I know it takes considerable grit and force of character to cheerfully put to sleep a dog for which perhaps a large sum of money has been paid, that has developed an un- certain, snappy disposition, yet it pays so to do: honesty is not alone the best policy, but the only 76 THE BOSTON TERRIER one. In my experience as a dog man I could give many personal incidents concerning the sale of vicious dogs, but for space sake one must suffice. Last year a Chicago banker sent me an order for a dog similar in style and disposition to the one I had sold him a few years previously, to go to his neice, a young lady staying for treat- ment at a large sanatorium in southern Massa- chusetts. I replied that I had not in my kennels a large enough dog to suit, but that I knew a dealer who possessed a fairly good reputation who had, and would get him for him if he would run the chances. This was satisfactory, and I bought the dog. He was guaranteed to me as all right in every way, but I felt some- what suspicious, as the price was very low for a dog of his style. I kept him with me for a week and saw no outs whatever about him, and practically concluded my suspicions were un- founded. Upon taking the dog personally to the young lady in question, I told her his history as far as I knew it, and also that while I could give her the dealer’s guarantee of the dog I could not of course, endorse it, but that if she cared to run the risk she could have the dog on approval as long as she wished. I said in warning that there was something about his eye that did not alto- CHAMPION LADY DAINTY THE BOSTON TERRIER hi gether strike my fancy, and that if he showed the least symptom of being anything but affec- tionate, to ship him to my kennels in Cliftondale immediately. As he was a handsome dog, with beautiful color, I could see she wanted him at once, and the dog seemed to take to her in an even greater degree. I received a letter from her in a week’s time, saying how perfectly satisfac- tory the dog was in every way, and what a general favorite he had become with the lady patients there, several of whom would like me to get one like him for them. I need not say how pleased I was to hear this, but what was my surprise to receive a letter the next day asking me to send at once for the dog, as he had bitten the matron. You may depend that neither she nor any other of the inmates there would ever want to see a Boston again, and who would want them to? Of course I lost my money, but that is not worth mentioning, The sorrow I felt stays by me today. I sent for the dog and kept him at my kennels for five months, taking care of him myself and never letting him out of my sight, during which time he was as gentle as a kitten, until one day a young dog man came down into the yard, and the dog, for some un- accountable reason, as in the case of the matron, jumped on him and took hold of his sleeve. The man, being accustomed to dogs, was fortunately 78 THE BOSTON TERRIER not scared. This explained the low price of the dog, and it is needless to add, he ornamented my kennels no longer. I can only state in con- nection with this that that dealer has sold very few dogs since. I never purchase a dog now, unless I know the man from whom I buy. How to breed dogs possessing an ideal dispo- sition is the all-important question, and I give the rules as followed in our kennels with com- plete success. Breed only from stock that you know comes from an ancestry noted for this particular feature. Many dogs are naturally of an affectionate nature, but have been made snappish by ill treatemnt, or teasing. This can be bred out by judicious care, but where a vicious tendency is hereditary, look out for trouble ahead. Damages for dog bites come high, and he must be either a very rich man, or a very poor one, that can afford to keep this kind of stock. Use only thoroughly healthy stock; disease is often productive of an uneven, sullen dispo- sition. See that the bitch especially never shows a tendency to be cross or snappy. The male dog usually controls the shape, color and markings, and the dam the constitution and dis- position. Hence it is, if anything, of more importance that the female should be strong in this feature than the male, although the male, of course, should be first class also. So well known THE BOSTON TERRIER 79 is this physiological fact that breeders of stand- ard bred horses, particularly hunters and carriage horses, will never breed a vicious mare to a quiet stallion, and yet they are generally willing to risk breeding a quiet mare to a stallion not as good in this respect. The education of the puppies should begin as soon as they can run around. Very much de- pends upon a right start. We are admonished to “train up a child in the way he should go,” and this applies with equal force to the dog. Treat them with the utmost kindness, but with a firm hand. Be sure they are taught to mind when spoken to, and never fail to correct at once when necessary. A stitch in time saves many times nine. A habit once formed is hard to break. Never be harsh with them; never whip; remember that judicious kindness with firmness is far more effective with dogs, as with children. Be sure to accustom them to mingle with people and children, and introduce them as early as possible to the sights of the street, to go on ahead, and to come at your call. Prevent the pernicious habit of running and barking at teams, etc., and other dogs. The time to check these habits as aforesaid is before they become fixed. If, after all these pains, you see a dog show the slightest disposition to be vicious, then do not hesitate to send him at once by a humane 80 THE BOSTON TERRIER transit to dog heaven. Ey thus continuously breeding a strain of dogs with an affectionate nature and the elimination of any that show the least deviation from the same, in a short time kennels can be established whose dogs will not only be a source of supreme satisfaction to the owner, but will be the best advertisers of said kennels wherever they go. It will readily be admitted by ail who have given the matter any consideration that a dog of an affectionate nature, whose fidelity has always been constant, and whose devotion to its owner has always under all circumstances been perfectly sincere and lasting, makes an appeal to something that is inherent in human nature. The fact of the case is that the love of such a dog is imbedded in the soul of every normal man and woiman who have red blood in their veins. I think it is instinctive, and has its foundation in the fact that from the beginning of time he has ministered to man’s necessities, and has accompanied him as his best friend on man’s upward march to civilization and enlightenment. “There may be races of people who have never known the dog, but I very much question if, after they have made his acquaintance, they fail to appreciate his desirable qualities, and to con- ceive for him both esteem and affection.” CHAPTER’ VILE BREEDING FOR A VIGOROUS CONSTI- TUTION: I think there never was a time in the history of the breed when this particular feature needed more thoughtful, systematic and scientific at- tention devoted to it than now. For the past few years breeders have been straining every nerve, and leaving no stone unturned, to pro- duce small stock, toys, in fact, and everyone realizes, who has given the question thoughtful consideration, that this line of breeding has been at the expense of the vigor, and indirectly largely of a beautiful disposition, of the dog, to say nothing of the financial loss that must inevitably ensue. Said an old Boston terrier man (Mr. Barnard) at a recent show: “Mr. Axtell, if they keep on breeding at this rate, it won’t be long before they produce a race of black and tans.” In my estimation it will not be black and tan terriers, but nothing. It will be productive of a line of bitches that are either barren, or so small that they can not possibly whelp without 82 THE BOSTON TERRIER the aid of a “Vet.” One does not have to look very far to discover numbers of men who started in the breeding of the American dog with high hopes and enthusiastic endeavors to success, who have fallen by the wayside, owing largely to the fact that proper attention was not paid to the selection of suitable breeding stock, especially the matrons. Said a man to me last year: “Much as I love the dog, and crazy as I am to raise some good pups, I have given up for all time trying to breed Boston terriers. I have lost eight bitches in succession whelping.” We have all of us “been there” and quite a number of us “many a time.” In order to obtain strong, vigorous puppies that will live and develop into dogs that will be noted for vigorous constitutions, we shall simply, and in language that can be readily understood by the novice as well as the established breeder, lay down the rules that a quarter of a century has demonstrated to be the correct ones for the attainment of the same as used in our kennels. As all puppies that leave our place are sold with the guarantee of reaching maturity (unless shown, when we take no risks whatever in re- gard to distemper, mange, etc.), it will readily be seen that they must have a first class start, and must of necessity be the progeny of stock possessing first class vigor and the quality of THE BOSTON TERRIER 83 being able to transmit the same to their off: spring. An ounce of experience is worth many tons of theory, and it is, then, with pleasure we give the system pursued by us, feeling certain that the same measure of success will attend others that will take the necessary pains to attain the same, and they will be spared the many pitfalls and mistakes that have necessarily been ours before we acquired our present knowl- edge. It has been for a number of years (start- ing as we did when the breed was in its infancy, and only the intense love of the dog, coupled with an extensive leisure, which enabled us to devote a great deal of attention to important and scientific experiments, have enabled us to arrive where we are), an uphill road, the breeding problems have had to be solved at the outlay of brains, patience and considerable money. Unlike any established breed, there was prac- tically no data to fall back on, no books of instruction to follow, but if the pioneer work has been arduous the results obtained have far outbalanced it, and the dog today stands as a monument to all the faithful, conscientious and determined body of men who would never acknowledge defeat, but who, in spite of all dis- couragements from all quarters, and from many where it should have been least expected, have pressed forward until they find the object of 84 THE BOSTON TERRIER their unfailing endeavors the supreme favorite in dogdom the continent over. In the first place, in the attainment of vigorous puppies, we state the bitches selected are of primary importance, in our view, as already stated, far more so than the sire. For best re- sults we choose a bitch weighing from fifteen to twenty-five pounds. If they happen to weigh over this we do not consider it any detriment whatever, rather otherwise. Always select said matrons from litters that have been large, bred from strong, vigorous stock, thoroughly ma- tured, and that have been bred by reliable (we speak advisedly) men for several generations if possible. If one can, obtain from kennels that while perfectly comfortable, have not been sup- plied with artificial heat. There is more in this than appears on the surface. Dogs that have been coddled and brought up around a stove rarely have stamina and vitality enough to enable them to live the number of years they are entitled to, and fall a ready victim to the first serious trouble, whether distemper, or the many and one ills that beset their path. Intelligent breeders of all kinds of stock today recognize the value of fresh air and unlimited sunshine, and if best results are to be obtained these two things are imperative. I was very much interested in the prize herd CHAMPION TODD BOY THE BOSTON TERRIER 8s of Hereford cattle owned by Mr. Joseph Row- lands, near Worcester, England, and conceded by experts to be the best in that country, and to learn that for a number of years the herd (over one hundred in number) have been kept in the open, the cows being placed in the barn for a few days at calving, and that the prize winning bull that heads the herd, “Tumbler,” is sixteen years old, and still used, and it is stated by Mr. Rowlands is producing as good stock today as ever. The significant fact about this herd is, they are and have been perfectly free from tuber- culosis. Another herd of Jerseys (although not prize winners) are kept near there, under pre- cisely the same conditions with similar results. , A breeder of prize winning Belgian hares has kept these for a number of years without arti- ficial heat, with the best of results with freedom from disease, and the attainment of strong, robust constitutions. When puppies are four months old (in the winter time) they should be placed in well built kennels, without artificial heat. (Of course, this does not apply to a colder latitude than Massachusetts.) The reason for choosing bitches that come from dams noted for their large litters is this: the chances are (if the dog bred to comes from a similar litter) that they will inherit the pro- pensity to give birth to large litters themselves, 86 THE BOSTON TERRIER and the pups will necessarily be smaller than when only one or two pups are born. The bitch that has but that number runs an awful risk, especially if she has been well fed. The pups will be large and the dam has great difficulty in whelping. If toy bitches are bred, look out for breakers ahead; only a very small per cent. live to play with their little ones. A toy bitch, bred to a toy dog, will frequently have but one pup, and that quite a large one in proportion to the size of parents. When a toy bitch is bred, attend care- fully to these three things. See that the dog used is small in himself, comes from small stock, and does not possess too large a head. Sec- ondly, be sure the bitch is kept in rather poor condition, in other words, not too fat; and thirdly, and this is the most important of all, see that she has all the natural exercise she can be induced to take. These conditions strictly and faithfully adhered to may result in success. In the next place, the consideration of the dog to be used is in order. Whether he be a first prize winner or an equally good dog that has never been shown (and the proportion of the best raised dogs that appear on the bench is very small) insist on the following rules: Be sure that the dog is typical with first class constitution, vigorous, and possessing an ideal THE BOSTON TERRIER 87 disposition, and what is of the utmost import- ance, that he comes from a line of ancestry eminently noted for these characteristics. Breed to no other, though he were a winner of a thou- sand first prizes. I prefer a symmetrical dog weighing from sixteen to twenty pounds, rather finer in his make-up than the bitch, and posses- sing the indefinable quality of style, and evidences in his make-up courage and a fine, open, generous temperament. Do not breed to a dog that is overworked in the stud, kept on a board floor chained up in a kennel or barn, and never given a chance to properly exercise. If you do the chances are that one of three things will happen: the bitch will not be in whelp (the most likely result) the pups, or some of them will be born dead, and one runs an awful risk most likely result) the pups, or some of them of the bitch dying, or, if alive at birth, a very small per cent. only of the pups will live to reach maturity. I think Boston terriers are particu- larly susceptible to worms or distemper, and it is absolutely imperative that they should not be handicapped at the onset. One other very important factor is natural exercise for the bitch. Unless one is willing to take the necessary pains to give her this, give up all expectation of ever succeeding in raising puppies. &8 THE BOSTON TERRIER Someone asked a noted critic whom he con- sidered the best singer he had ever heard, and he answered, “Patti.” In being asked who came next, he replied, “Patti; and on being questioned who was his third choice, gave the same answer. Were I asked the three most important essen- tials for the success of the brood bitch, I should Say, . lixercise, exercise, exercise.” By this J do not mean leading with a chain, running be- hind a horse or team, but the natural exercise a bitch will take if left to her own devices. Nature has provided an infallible monitor to direct the dog the best amount to take, and when to take it. One of the best bitches I ever pos- sessed was one weighing fourteen pounds by the original Tony Boy (one of the best little dogs that ever lived) out of a bitch by Torrey’s Ned, by A. Goode’s Ned. Her name was Lottie, and she had thirteen litters and raised over ninety per cent. Those who have read that in- teresting little book on the “Boston Terrier,” by the late Dr. Mott, will readily recall the genial Doctor speaking of the first Boston he ever owned, named “Muggy Dee,” and how intel- ligent he was, and what a number of tricks the Doctor taught him, will be interested to know that Lottie was his great-grandmother, and she was equally intelligent. We had several bitches by the celebrated Mr. Mullen’s “Boxer” out of THE BOSTON TERRIER 89 her, (this is going back to ancient history), one of which, “Brownie,” was, to my fancy, the nicest dog we ever had. She, with the rest of the litter, had the run of several hundred acres, and many times I did not see them for days together. They went in and out of the hayloft at pleasure, and spent the greater part of their time hunting and digging out skunks and wood- chucks which were quite thick in the woods back of us at that time. I remember the first time Brownie was bred to that king of sires, “Buster,” owned by Alex. Goode (than whom a more loyal Boston terrier man never lived), and I was rather anxious to see the litter when it arrived, as from the mating I expected cracker- jacks. I had not seen her or her mother for two or three days, but the time for whelping having arrived, was keeping a close watch on the stable. About dusk she came in with Lottie, and in a short time gave birth to four of the most vigorous, perfectly formed little tots I had ever seen. Each one proved to be good enough to show, although only one was sold to an ex- hibitor, Mr. G. Rawson, the rest going into private hands. “Druid Pero” was shown in New York in 1808, taking first prize and silver cup for best in his class, but I think his brother, “Caddie,” beat him, his owner, a Boston banker, go THE BOSTON TERRIER being offered a number of times ten times the sum he paid for him. The day after Brownie whelped she and her mother went off for an hour or so, and they fin- ished digging out Mr. Skunk (which the atten- tion to her maternal duties necessitated a post- ponement of), the old dog dragging him home in triumph. I attribute the success these dogs, in common with the rest of the bitches in the kennels who had similar advantages, had in whelping and the rearing of their young to the fact that they always had unlimited natural ex- ercise. I can enumerate scores of cases similar to these attended with equally good results, if space permitted. In regard to mating, one service, if properly performed, is usually enough, if the bitch is ready to take the dog. Ifa bitch should fail to be in whelp I should advise the next time she comes in season two or even three visits to the dog, and where convenient I should suggest a different dog this time. In case this time these services were unsuccessful, then I should sug- gest the course that breeders of thoroughbred horses pursue, viz., to let the female run with the male for three or four days together. There are many things connected with breeding that we do not understand, and frequently going back to THE BOSTON TERRIER QI nature, as in this case, is productive of results when all else fails. One very important factor in the production of strong, rugged pups that live, is good feeding. Do not imagine that feeding dog biscuits to the bitch in whelp will give good results, it will not ; she needs meat and vegetables once a day. Bis- cuits are all right as a supplementary food, but that is all. Meat is the natural food for a dog, and it is a wise kennel man that can improve on nature. Be sure the meat is free from taint, especially at this time and when the bitch is nursing pups. The gastric juice of a dog’s stomach is a great germicide, but there is a limit. Be certain the dogs have a plentiful supply of good, pure water. This is of far more import- ance than many people imagine. Do not administer drugs of any description to your dogs, except in the case of a good vermifuge, if they are harboring worms, and a proper dose of castor oil if constipated. If the dog at any time is sick, consult a good veterin- ary accustomed to dogs, not one who has prac- ticed entirely on horses or cows. If a bitch, at the time of whelping, is much distressed and can not proceed, get a veterinary and get him quick. When the pups arrive, if all is well and they are able to nurse, let them severely alone. 92 THE BOSTON TERRIER If they are very weak they will have to be assisted to suckle—do not delay attention in this case. Be sure the box the bitch whelped in is large enough for her to turn around in, and do not use any material in the nest that the pups can get entangled with. My advice to breeders is, if the bitch is fully formed and grown to her full proportions, to breed the first time she comes in season. She will have an easier time whelp- ing than when she is older. If delicate or im- mature, delay breeding till the next time. Do not use a dog in the stud until he is a year and a half old for best results; they will, of course, sire pups at a year or younger, but better wait. To those people who live in the city, or where a kennel can not be established for want of ade- quate room to give the dogs the necessary exer- cise, an excellent plan to follow is one adopted by an acquaintance of mine, and followed by him for a number of years with a good measure of success. He owns one or two good stud dogs that he keeps at his home, and he has put out on different farms, within a radius of ten miles of Boston, one bitch at each place, and pays the farmer (who is only too glad to have this source of income at the outlay of so little trouble and expense) one hundred dollars for each litter of pups the bitch has, the farmer to deliver the pups when required, usually when SQUANTUM PUNCH % wy ip. Wh oe CHAMPION WILLOWBROOK GLORY 3 THE BOSTON TERRIER 93 three months old. The farmer brings in the bitch to be bred, and the owner has no further trouble. The pups, when delivered, are usually in the pink of condition and are, in a great measure, house broken, and their manners to a certain extent cultivated. He has no trouble whatever with pups when ordered, as he simply sends the address of customers and the farmer ships them. This, to me, is a very uninteresting and somewhat mercenary way of doing business, as one misses all the charm of breeding and the bringing up of the little tots, to many of us the most delightful part of the business. To those breeders who have newly started in, do not get discouraged if success does not immediately crown your efforts; remember, if Boston terriers could be raised as easily as other dogs, the prices would immediately drop to the others’ level. CHAPTER IX. os BREEDING FOR COLOR AND MARKINGS. Every one who has a Boston terrier for sale knows that a handsome seal or mahogany brin- dle with correct markings, with plenty of luster in the coat, provided all other things are equal, sells more readily at a far higher price than any other. When one considers the number of points given in the standard for this particular feature, and the very important factor it occu- pies in the sale of the dog, too much attention cannot be given by breeders for the attainment of this desideratum. I am, of course, thoroughly in sympathy with the absolute justice that should always prevail in the show ring in the considera- tion of the place color and markings occupy in scoring a candidate for awards. Twelve points are allowed in the standard for these, and any dog, I care not whether it be “black, white, gray, or grizzled,” that scored thirteen points over the most perfectly marked dog, should be awarded THE BOSTON TERRIER 95 the prize. But be it ever remembered that the show ring and the selling of a dog are two sepa- rate and distinct propositions. In the writer’s opinion and experience a wide gulf opens up between a perfect white or black dog comporting absolutely to the standard, and one of desirable color and markings that is off a number of points. I have always found a white, black, mouse, or liver colored dog, I care not how good in every other respect, almost impossible to get rid of at any decent price. People simply would not take them. Perhaps my experience has run counter to others. I trust it may have done so, but candor compels me to make this statement. I find that this condition of things is some- what misleading, especially to beginners in the breed. They have seen the awards made in the shows (with absolute justice, as already stated), and have naturally inferred that in consequence of this, breeding for desirable colors was not of paramount importance after all. Only a month or two ago an article appeared in a charming little dog magazine, written evidently by an amateur, on this question of color and markings. He had visited the Boston Terrier Club show last November, and speaking of seal brindles, said: “If this color is so very desirable it seems strange that so few were seen, and that so many of the leading terriers were black and white, 96 THE BOSTON TERRIER and some white entirely,” then follows his deduction, viz., “the tendency evidently is that color is immaterial with the best judges, so that a breeder is foolish to waste his time on side issues which are not material.” I can only state in passing that if he had a number of dogs on hand that were of the colors he specifies, “black and white, and some white entirely,” it would doubtless “seem strange” to him why they persisted in remaining on his hands as if he had given each one an extra bath in Le Page’s liquid glue. Pitfalls beset the path of the be- ginner and this book is written largely to avoid them. When one reads or hears the statement made that color and markings are of secondary consideration or even less, take warning. The reader’s pardon will now have to be craved for the apparent egotism evidenced by the writer in speaking of himself in a way that only indi- rectly concerns canine matters, but which has a bearing on this very important question of color, and partially, at least, explains why this partic- ular feature of the breeding of the Boston terrier has appealed to him so prominently. My father was a wholesale merchant in straw goods, and had extensive dye works and bleacheries where the straw, silk and cotton braids were colored. As a youngster I used to take great delight in watching the dyers and bleachers preparing their Tip BOSTON TERRIER: 97 different colors and shades, etc., and was anxious to see the results obtained by the different chem- ical combinations. When a young man, while studying animal physiology under the direction of the eminent scientist, Professor Huxley, whose diploma I value most highly, I made a number of extended scientific experiments in color breeding in poultry and rabbits, so that when I took up breeding Boston terriers later in life this feature particularly attracted me. I was “predisposed,” as a physician says of a case where the infection is certain, hence I offer no apology whatever for the assertion that this chapter is scientifically correct in the rules laid down for the breeding to attain desirable shades and markings. When we first commenced breeding Bostons in 1885, the prevailing shades were a rather light golden brindle (often a yellow), and mahogany brindles, and quite a considerable number had a great deal of white. Then three shades were de- barred, viz., black, mouse and liver, and although years after the Boston Terrier Club removed this embargo, they still remain very undesirable colors. The rich mahogany brindle next became the fashionable color (and personally I consider it the most beautiful shade), and Mr. A. Goode with Champion “Monte” and Mr. Rawson with 98 THE BOSTON TERRIER the beautiful pair, “Druid Merke” and “Vixen,” set the pace and every one followed. A few years later Messrs. Phelps and Davis (who, with the above mentioned gentlemen, were true friends of the breed), sold a handsome pair of seal brin- dles, Chs. “Commissioner II.” and “Topsy,” to Mr. Borden of New York, and confirmed, if not established, the fashion for that color in that city. I think that all people will agree, from all parts of the country, that New York sets the style for practically everything, from my lady’s headgear to the pattern of her equipages, and the edict from that city has decreed that the correct color in Boston terriers is a rich seal brindle, with white markings, with plenty of luster to it, and all sections of the continent promptly say amen! I have taken the pains to look up a number of orders that we have recently received, which in- clude (not enumerating those received from the New England States, or New York), three from Portland, Oregon, one from California, one from St. Louis, one from Mexico, four from Canada, two from Chicago, and one from Texas, and with the exception of two who wished to replace dogs bought of us ten or twelve years previously, they practically all wanted seal brindles. These orders were nearly all from bankers and brokers, men who are supposed to be en rapport THE BOSTON TERRIER 99 with the dictates of fashion. It goes without saying that what a public taste demands, every effort will be made to attain the same, and breed- ers will strive their utmost to produce this shade. Many who do not understand scientific matings to obtain these desirable colors have fallen into a very natural mistake in so doing. In regard to the mahogany brindles they say, why not breed continuously together rich mahogany sires and dams, and then we shall always have the brindles we desire. “Like produces like” is a truism often quoted, but there are exceptions, and Bos- ton terrier breeding furnishes an important one. A very few years of breeding this way will give a brown, solid color, without a particle of brindle, or even worse, a buckskin. If the foundation stock is a lighter brindle to start, the result will be a mouse color. The proper course to pursue is to take a golden brindle bitch that comes from a family noted for that shade, and mate her with a dark mahogany brindle dog that comes from an ancestry possessed of that color. The bitch from this mating can be bred to dark mahogany brin- dles, and the females from this last mating bred again to dark mahogany males, but now a change is necessary. The maxim, “twice in and once out,” applies here. The last bred bitches should be bred this time to a golden brindle dog, and same process repeated, that is, the bitches from 100 THE BOSTON: TERRIER this last union and their daughters can be bred to dark mahogany brindle dogs, when the golden brindle sire comes in play again. This can be repeated indefinitely. A rule in color breeding to be observed is this: that the male largely in- fluences the color of the pups. If darker colors are desired, use a darker male than the female. If lighter shades are desired, use a lighter col- ored male. If a tiger brindle is wanted, take a gray brin- dle bitch and mate to a dark mahogany dog. Steel and gray brindles are in so little demand and are so easy to produce that we shall not notice them. In regard to seal brindies. A great many breeders who do not understand proper breed- ing to obtain them have fallen into the same pit as the others. In their desire to obtain the dark seal brindles they have mated very dark dogs to equally dark bitches, which has resulted in a few generations in producing dogs absolutely biack in color, with coats that Ilcok as if they had been steeped in a pail of ink. A visit to any of the leading shows of late will reveal the fact that quite a number of candidates for bench honors are not real brindle, except possibly on the under side of the body, or perchance a slight shading on the legs. A considerable number are perfectly black, and are called by courtesy black brindles. As well call the ace of spades by the = be feet Zz 4 =) [=] Q % < 3 Q [*3) inent Early Breeder A Prom THE BOSTON TERRIER 101 same name. A serious feature in connection with this is, that the longer this line of breeding is persisted in, the harder will be the task to breed away. In fact, in my estimation it will be as difficult as the elimination of white. One important fact in connection here is that black color is more pronounced from white stock than from brindle. I recently went into the kennels of a man who has started a comparatively short time ago, and who has been most energetic in his endeavors to produce a line of dark seal _ brindles, and who is much perplexed because he has a lot of stock on hand, while first rate in every other respect, are with coats as black as crows and not worth ten dollars apiece. He secmed very much surprised when I told him his mistake, but grateful to be shown a way out of his difficulty. A visit to another kennel not far from the last revealed the fact that the owner was advertising and sending largely to the West what he called black brindles, but as devoid of brindle as a frog is of feathers. His case was rather amusing, as he honestly believed that be- cause the dog was a Boston terrier its color of necessity must be a brindle. He reminded me a good deal of a man who started a dog store in Boston a number of years ago who advertised in his windows a Boston terrier for sale cheap. Upon stepping in to see the dog all that pre- 102 THE BOSTON TERRIER sented itself to view was a dog, a cross between a fox and bull terrier. When the man was told of this, he made this amusing reply: “The dog was born in Boston, and he is a terrier. Why is he not a Boston terrier?” Upon telling him that according to his reasoning if the dog had been born in New York city he would be a New York terrier he smiled. Fortunately I had “Druid Pero” with me and said: “Here is a dog bred in my kennels at Cliftondale, Mass., that was a first prize winner at the last New York show, and yet he is a Boston terrier.” After looking Pero carefully over he exclaimed: “Well, by gosh, they don’t look much like brothers, but I guess some greenhorn will come along who will give me twenty-five dollars for him,” and on in- quiring a little later was told the green gentle- man had called and bought the dog. How to breed the dogs so that the brindle will not become too dark, with the bright reddish sheen that sparkles in the sun, is the important question, and I am surprised at the ignorance displayed by kennel men that one would natur- ally suppose would have made the necessary sci- entific experiments to obtain this desirable shad- ing. Only a short time ago a doctor, a friend of mine, told me he had just started a kennel of Bostons, buying several bitches at a bargain on account of their being black in color, and that THE BOSTON TERRIER 103 he proposed breeding them to a white dog to get puppies of a desirable brindle. He seemed quite surprised when told the only shades he could reasonably expect would be black, white and splashed, all equally undesirable. The system adopted in our kennels some years ago to obtain seal brindles with correct mark- ings and the desirable luster and reddish sheen to the coat is as follows: We take a rich red, or light mahogany bitch, with perfect markings, that comes from a family noted for the brilliancy of their color, and with- out white in the pedigrees for a number of gen- erations, and mate her always to a dark seal brindle dog with an ancestry back of him noted for the same color. The pups from these matings will come practically seventy-five per cent. me- dium seal brindles. We now take the females that approximate the nearest in shade to their mother, and mate them to a dark seal brindle dog always. The bitches that are the result of this union are always bred to a dark seal brindle dog. The females that come from the last union are bred to a medium seal brindle dog, but now comes the time to introduce a mahog- any brindle dog as a sire next time, for if these last bitches were mated to a seal brindle dog a large per cent. of the pups would come too dark or even black. This system is used indefinitely and desirable seal brindles with white markings 104. THLE BOSTON TERRIER can thus be always obtained. To the best of my recollection we have had but one black dog in twenty years. We have demonstrated, we trust, so that all may understand how golden, mahog- any, and seal brindles are obtained, and how they may be bred for all time without losing the brindle so essential, and we now pass on to the consideration of a far harder problem, the ob- taining of the rich seal brindles from all unde- sirable colors, and we present to all interested in this important, and practically unknown and misunderstood, problem the result of a number of years extended and scientific experiments which, we confess, were disheartening and un- productive for a long time, but which ultimately resulted in success, the following rules to be observed, known as “The St. Botolph Color Chart.” In presenting this we are fully aware that as far as we know this is the only scientific system evolved up to date, also that there are a number of breeders of the American dog who maintain that this is an absolute impossibility, that breed- ing for color is as absurd as it is impractical, but we can assure these honest doubters that we have blazed a trail, and all they now have to do is simply to follow instructions and success will crown their efforts. THE BOSTON TERRIER 105 We will enumerate the following colors in the order of their resistance, so to speak: No. 1. White. This color, theoretically a combination of red, green and violet will be found the hardest to eliminate, as the shade de- sired will have to be worked in, so to speak, and it will take several generations before a seal brindle with perfect markings that can be de- pended upon to always reproduce itself can be obtained. Starting with a white bitch (always remember that the shades desired must be pos- sessed by the dog), we breed her always to a golden brindle dog. The bitches (those most resembling the sire in color being selected) from these two are mated to a dark mahogany brindle dog, and the females from this last union are mated to a dark seal brindle dog. It will readily be observed that we have bred into the white color, golden, mahogany and seal brindle, and this admixture of color will give practically over ninety per cent. of desirable brindles. Al- ways see that the sires used are perfectly marked, from ancestry possessing the same _ correct markings. This is absolutely imperative, where the stock to be improved is worked upon is white. No. 2. Black. This color is the opposite of white, inasmuch as there is an excess of pig- ment, which in this case will have to be worked out. Breed the black bitch to a red brindle dog 106 THE BOSTON TERRIER (with the same conditions regarding his ances- try). The females from these matings bred always to a dark mahogany brindle dog. The females from the last matings breed to a medium seal brindle dog with a very glossy coat, and the result of these last matings will be good seal brindles. If any bitches should occasionally come black, breed always to a golden brindle dog. No other shade will do the trick. No. 3. Gray brindle. This is practically a dead color, but easy to work out. Breed first to a golden brindle dog. The females from this union breed to a rich mahogany brindle, and the bitches from this last litter breed to a seal brin- dle dog. No. 4. Buckskin. Breed bitch to golden brindle dog; the females from this union to a red brindle dog (if unobtainable, use mahogany brindle dog, but this is not so effective), and the females from last union breed to a seal brin- dle dog. No. 5. Liver. This is a great deal like the last, but a little harder to manipulate. Breed first to a golden brindle dog. The females from this union breed to a seal brindle. The bitches from this union breed to mahogany brindle dog with black bars running through the coat, and the females from last mating breed to seal brin- dles. THE BOSTON TERRIER 107 No. 6. Mouse color. Use same process as for gray brindles. No. 7. Yellow. A very undesirable shade, but easy to eliminate. Breed to mahogany brin- dle dog as dark as can be obtained, and bitches from this mating breed to a seal brindle dog. No. 8. . Steel and tiger brindles I class to- gether, as the process is the same and results areseasy. Breed first, to oa red “brindle dos; bitches from this union to a dark mahogany brindle, and then use seal brindle dog on bitch from last mating. No.9. Red brindle. No skill is required here. Breed first to mahogany brindles, and bitches from this union to seal brindles. We have now enumerated practically all the less desirable shades, but let me observe in passing, in the process of color breeding that the law of atavism, or “throwing back,” often asserts itself, and we shall see colors belonging to a far-off ancestry occasionally presenting themselves in all these matings. Once in a while a dog will be found that no matter what color bitches he may be mated with, he will mark a certain number of the litter with the peculiar color or markings of some remote ancestor. Just a case apropos of this will suffice. We used in our kennels a dog of perfect markings, coming from an immediate ancestry of perfectly marked 108 THE BOSTON TERRIER dogs, and mated him with quite a number of absolutely perfectly marked bitches that we had bred for a great number of years that had before that had perfectly marked pups, and every bitch, no matter how bred, had over fifty per cent. of white headed pups. We saw the pups in other places sired by this dog, no matter where bred, similarly marked. We found his grandmother was a white headed dog, and this dog inherited this feature in his blood, and passed it on to pos- terity. The minute a stud dog, perfect in him- self, is prepotent to impress upon his offspring a defect in his ancestry, discard him at once. I have often been amused to see how frequently this law of atavism is either misunderstood or ignored. Only recently I have seen a number of letters in a leading dog magazine, in which several people who apparently ought to know better, were accusing litters of bulldog pups as being of impure blood because there were one or two black pups amongst them. They must, of course, have been conversant with the fact that bulldogs years ago frequently came of that color, and failed to reason that in consequence of this, pups of that shade are liable once in a while to occur. It is always a safe rule in color breeding to discard as a stud a dog, no matter how brilliant his coat may be, who per- TOM SAYERS, One of the Pillars of the Breed THE BOSTON TERRIER 109 sistently sires pups whose colors are indistinct and run together, as it were. Remember, in closing this chapter, that as “eternal vigilance is the price of liberty,” so the eternal admixtures of colors is the price of rich brindles. If one has the time the works of an Austrian monk named Mendel are of great in- terest as bearing somewhat on this subject, and the two English naturalists, Messrs. Everett and J. G. Millais, whose writings contain the result of extensive scientific experiments on dogs and game birds, are of absorbing interest also. CHAPTER X. SALES. Every person who has bred Bostons for any length of time knows that a good dog sells him- self. I do not imagine there is practically any part of this great country where a typical dog, of proper color and markings and all right in every respect, fails to meet a prospective buyer, and yet, of course, there are certain places where an A 1 dog, like an ideal saddle or car- riage horse meets with a readier sale, at a far greater price than others. New York city, in particular, and all the larger cities of the coun- try where there are large accumulations of wealth, offer the best markets for the greatest numbers of this aristocratic member of the dog fraternity, and from my own personal knowledge the larger cities of the countries adjacent to the United States furnish nearly as good a market, at a somewhat reduced price. Were the quarantines removed in the mother country, which England no doubt has found absolutely necessary, it would not surprise me in the least to see an THE BOSTON TERRIER Lit unprecedented demand for the Boston at very high prices, and I am going to make a prediction that on the continent of Europe it will not be long before the American dog will follow the trotting horse, and will work his way eastward, until jealous China and strange Japan will be as enamoured with him as we are, and his devotees at the Antipodes will be wondering where he got his little screw tail, and why that sweet, serene expression on his face, like the “Quaker Oat smile,” never comes off. This to a person who knows not the Boston may seem extravagant praise, but to all such we simply say: Get one, and then see if you are not ready to exclaim with the Queen of Sheba, when vis- iting King Solomon and being shown his treas- ures: “Behold, the half was not told me!” Perhaps the system of sales that has always been followed by us may be of interest to many en- gaged in the breeding of the dog, and while we do not hold a patent on the same, or even sug- gest its adoption by others, must confess it has worked with entire satisfaction in our case, and we have never once failed to receive the pur- chase money. We must say in explanation that our customers practically are all bankers and brokers, and that our dogs have never been sold by advertising or being exhibited at shows, but by being recommended by one man to another, 112 THE BOSTON TERRIER starting many years ago by the first sale to a Boston banker, then to several members of his firm, going from Boston to their correspondents in other cities, until the orders come in from everywhere. We had three orders from as many countries in one mail last week. I merely men- tion this to show how the demand for the dog has grown. When we commenced to sell dogs we adopted the following plan, which we con- ceived to be just and equitable alike to buyer and seller: When a dog is ordered we send on one which we believe will fill the bill, accu- rately describing the dog, stating age, pedigree, etc., and stating that when the customer is per- fectly satisfied with the dog (as long a trial being given as may be wished) in every respect, a check will be accepted, and not before. Should the dog at any time prove unsatisfactory in any way, the purchase money will be cheerfully refunded, or a dog of equal value will be sent in exchange. In the case of a bitch that fails to become a good breeder, the same plan, of course, is followed. In regard to the sale of puppies, we guarantee them (barring accidents, and the showing of them, when owner assumes risks) to reach maturity, and in case they do not, refund purchase money, or send on another puppy of equal value. Of course, where the buyer is not known, or THE BOSTON TERRIER 113 personally recommended, then the seller has to adopt entirely different methods. Still, I see no reason why an honest man who has a Boston, or any other dog, for sale, or, in fact, any article of merchandise, should not be willing to send on the same to any honest buyer. This is on the assumption, of course, that both parties are honorable men. To the seller I advise the pur- chase money being received before the dog is shipped, and express charges guaranteed, if the buyer is not known or unable to supply absolutely reliable references. Decline to receive any order where the object sought is to obtain a dog to use to breed to a’bitch, or several, as the case may be, and then be returned as unsatis- factory. We have had no experience in this line, but are informed it has frequently been done. If such a customer presents himself, simply tell him he can inspect the dog or have an expert do so for him if too far away to come, but that when the deal is closed and the money paid that under no conditions whatever can the dog be returned. In regard to the seller shipping the dog to its destination, we will say that we think he will run practically no risk in so doing. If the dog is all right in every way it is dollars to doughnuts that he will arrive in perfect condi- tion. We can say that in over twenty years’ shipments of dogs to all parts of the country and 114 THE BOSTON TERRIER beyond we have never had a dog die en route, lost, exchanged, or stolen. I think the express companies of this country, Canada, Mexico, and beyond, are to be highly commended for the excellent care they take of the dogs committed to their charge, neither do I think the express charges are ever excessive, when one considers the value of the dogs carried. We will now consider the case of the buyer, assuming, of course, he is known or capable of presenting suitable references. We always advise him to deal with kennels or dealers of estab- lished reputations. Run no chances with any other unless you desire to be “trimmed.” Pray do not be misled by glowing advertisements (stating that they have the largest kennels on earth) in every paper that does not know them. I have investigated quite a number of these so- called kennels and found they usually consisted of an old box stall in a cheap stable, or a room over an equally cheap barroom, and their stock in trade consisted of two or three muts. Be very suspicious of any man who advertises that he has dogs for sale that can win in fast company for fifty or a hundred dollars, or A 1 bitches in whelp to noted dogs for the same price. Any man who possesses these kinds of dogs does not have to advertise their sale. There are plenty of people here in Boston only too THE BOSTON TERRIER 115 glad to buy this kind of stock at three or four times this price. I attended the last show in Boston with a number of orders in my pocket, but failed to discover any dogs I picked out possessing the quality described at anything less than a good stiff price, for Boston terriers with the “hall mark” of quality have been, are, and, I believe, always will be, as staple in value as diamonds. The number of letters we have received from all over the country, particularly from the West, complaining of the skin games played upon them by fake kennels and dealers, would make an angel weep, and make one almost regret that one ever knew a Boston. If the same ingenuity, skill and patience employed in the getting up of these fake advertisements had been devoted to the breeding of the dog, this class of advertising gentry (?) would have produced something fit to sell. It is stated on the best of authority that in some cases nothing was shipped for money received. In spite of this vast number of unscrupulous breeders and dealers scattered abroad, I think the chances for reliable kennels was never so good as now in the history of the breed. Cream will always rise, and right dealing, whether in dogs or diamonds, will ever meet with their just returns. Remember that one never forgets being 156 THE BOSTON TERRIER “taken in” in a horse trade, and when, instead of a horse a dog is involved, I think one never for- gives as well. To that number of persons who, in their daily walks of life are fairly honest, but who, when it comes to a trade in dogs are apt to lose that fine sense of justice that should characterize all transactions, we would say with Shakespeare: “To thine own self be true. Thou canst not then be false to any man.” Yea, we would repeat the command of a greater than Shakespeare, to whom, I trust, we all pay rev- erence, when He lays down for us all the Golden Rule: “Whatsoever ye would that men would do to you, do ye even so to them.” To go back to the responsible buyer who is in the market for a good dog, we say: Send your orders to responsible men, with said dogs to sell, stating exactly what you want, and the price you desire to pay, agreeing to send a check just as soon as dogs prove satisfactory, assum- ing, of course, express charges. Reputable dealers and breeders are looking for just such customers. To all breeders and dealers who have not an established reputation, would say: Advertise accurately what you have for sale in first class reliable papers and magazines. In regard to prices, the following scale, adopted by us many years ago, and which we have never seen DRUID MERK THE BOSTON TERRIER Dey since any reason to change, is practically as fol- lows:. For pups from two to three months old, from fifty to seventy-five dollars. When six months old, from seventy-five to a hundred: From six months to maturity, from one hundred to two hundred. These prices are, of course, for the ordinary all-around good dogs. With dogs that approximate perfection, and which only come in the same proportion as giants and dwarfs do in the human race (I believe the proportion is one in five thousand), and the advent of which would surprise the average kennel man as much as if the President had sent him a special invi- tation to dine with him at the White House, the price is problematical, and is negotiated solely by the demand for such a wonder by a compara- tively few buyers. I think Boston terriers as a breed occupy the same position amongst dogs as the hunter and carriage horse does amongst horses. Each are more or less a luxury. A well matched pair of horses of good all-round action, of desirable color and perfect manners and suitable age will sell in the Eastern cities (I am not sufficiently acquainted with the other sections of the country to know values there) at from eight hundred to two thousand dollars, but with a pair of carriage horses able to win on the tan bark, the price will 118 THE BOSTON TERRIER be regulated by the comparatively few people who have sufficient money to spare to purchase this fashionable luxury, and ten times the amount paid for the first mentioned pair would be a rea- sonable price to pay for the prize winners. I think the winners of the blue in the Bostons would fetch a relative sum. The important factor of the cost of produc- tion in the case of the dog necessarily enters into the selling price. Good Bostons are as hard to raise as first class hunters, and a correspondingly large sum has to be obtained to meet expenses, to say nothing of profit, but in the writer’s experi- ence the best dog or horse sells the readiest. Do not be misled by the remark “that a dog is worth all he will bring.” Generally speaking, this is sound logic, but not always. Many dogs have been sold for very little by people not cognizant of their value, but this in no way changed the intrinsic worth of the dog. On the other hand, many dogs have been disposed of at many times their real value, but this transaction did not enhance their worth in the slightest degree. A gold dollar is worth one hundred cents whether changed for fifty cents or five hundred. An article of intrinsic value never changes. Our advice to all who have dogs for sale (or any other article, in fact), ask what you know is a good, honest, fair value, and although you may THE BOSTON TERRIER 119 not sell the dog today, remember that there are other days to follow. What I am going to add now I know a great many dealers and breeders will laugh at and declare me a fit subject for an alienist to work on, but it is fundamentally true just the same, and is this: Never ask or take for a dog more than you know (not guess) the dog is worth. This is nothing but ordinary, common everyday justice that every man has every right to demand of his fellow man, and every man that is a gentleman will recognize the truth and force of. I was reading a novel this summer, and one statement amongst a great many good ones im- pressed me. It stated “that all men were divided into two classes: those that behaved themselves, and those who did not.” We all know that society has divided men into many classes, but I think any thoughtful man will confess, in the last analysis, that the novelist’s classification was the correct one. I need not apply the moral. It will be somewhat of a temptation to resist taking what a party, liberally supplied with this world’s goods, will frequently in their ignorance offer for a dog that appeals to them, but which the owner knows perfectly well is not worth the price offered. If he belongs to the class that behaves themselves he will tell the prospective buyer what the dog is intrinsically worth, and 120 THE BOSTON TERRIER point out the reasons why he is not worth more. You may depend that you have not only obtained a customer for life, but one that will readily advertise your kennels under all circumstances. I shall have to ask the reader to overlook the apparent egotism of the statements I am now about to make, but as this book is largely the outgrowth of the author’s own experience, of necessity personal matters are spoken of. A number of years ago I received an order from the Western coast, through a Boston house, for a good all-round puppy at two hundred dol- lars. I sent the puppy on, and much to the sur- prise of the customer, stated my price for him would be one hundred instead of two. The pup matured into a very nice dog, as I expected he would, being a Cracksman pup out of a good bitch. What has been the result of this treat- ment? Ever since (and no later than yesterday), orders for dogs from this gentleman have been coming right along. Another case, and this is only a sample of several from the same city: A number of years back a New York lady, accompanied by her husband, came to our kennels to purchase a dog. I had quite a handsome litter of five or six months old pups by “Merk Jr.,” out of Buster stock on the dam’s side, one of which, a perfectly marked seal brindle female, at once took her THE BOSTON TERRIER 121 fancy, and she said: “We have just come from another large kennel in Boston where they asked us three hundred dollars for a little female I do not like nearly as well as this one.” Her husband was one of the leading men of one of the largest trusts in the country, and money was apparently no object, and when I replied, “Mrs. Keller, that dog you select is not worth over fifty dollars (the price I afterwards sold her for) and the best dog in the litter I shall be glad to let you have for seventy-five,” she seemed much surprised. I then, of course, told her that the dogs were not worth more as their muzzles were not deep enough to be worth a higher price than I wanted. I recently received a letter from her stating that her dog was still as active and much loved as ever, and the number of orders that have come to me through the sale of this dog would surprise the owners of those kennels who stick their customers with an outrageous price, and who find to their sorrow that no subsequent orders ever come, either from the customer or any one else in the vicinity. People have a way sooner or later (usually sooner) in discovering when they have been overcharged and act ac- cordingly. One other recommendation I wish to make in place here is: ‘‘Never try to fill an order that one has not the dogs to suit.” Frankly say so, 122 THE BOSTON TERRIER and recommend a brother fancier that you know has. One good turn deserves another and he may have a chance later to reciprocate. This creates a kindly feeling amongst kennel men, and is productive of good will, and ofttimes a large increase in business. A few years ago a lady from Connecticut came to see me to buy a first class dog or a pair, if she could get suited. I knew that in the past she had paid the highest price for her Bostons, and she wanted a dog in the neighborhood of two thousand dollars. I told her at once I had nothing for sale to suit her, but that I knew a man who owned a dog I considered worth about that sum, and recommended her strongly to buy him, and sent her to Mr. Keady, who sold to her “Gordon Boy” for that price. The sequel to this is somewhat amusing and shows how reciprocity did not take place. I went to see a litter of pups at Mr. Keady’s house soon after, and expected to obtain a somewhat favorable price on the pup I picked out of the litter on account of the sale of the dog, and offered the gentleman three hundred dollars for him, upon which he replied: “Mr. Axtell, do you think that five weeks old pup is worth that sum?” and upon my replying, “I certainly do,” instead of saying, “All right, take him,” he ex- claimed: “If that is your opinion, and I know you always say what you believe, then he is THE BOSTON TERRIER 123 worth that sum to me,” and put him back in the box. He subsequently sold him to Mr. Borden for over six thousand dollars, the highest price ever obtained for a Boston. While writing on the subject of sales, I think it will be in order to speak of a matter that is a source of anxiety to a great many breeders, and that is the getting rid of the small bitches that are too small to breed. We have always found a ready sale for these when properly spayed for ladies’ pets, largely in New York city. They make ideal house dogs, perhaps more winning and affectionate in their manner than others, never wandering off, and I believe the license fee is the same as for a male. Great care must be taken that the operation is thor- oughly performed by a competent veterinary, and it is usually best done when the pup is six months old. My first experience may be of value and interest. I had a little “Buster” bitch that I felt assured to my sorrow was to small to whelp successfully, and being much fancied by a lady doctor in Waterbury, Conn., advised spay- ing before being sent. I took her to a veterinary with a good reputation in Boston, and after the dog had fully recovered from the operation, sent her to Dr. Conky. What was my surprise to hear that when nine months old she had come “in season.” I sent the ex-President of the 124 THE: BOSTON TERRIER Boston Terrier Club, Dr. Osgood, down and an additional cost of fifty dollars ensued, whereas the first charge of two dollars would have been all that was necessary if the operation had been properly done in the first place . Am glad to say I have seen no failures since. I can conceive of no reason why there should not be a ready sale for this class of dogs in all sections of the coun- try, and the disposal of the same will materially help the income of a great many breeders. In conclusion let me state: “Put a price on your dogs that in your best judgment you know (not guess) to be a fair and equitable one (and if unable to decide what is right, call in an hon- orable expert who can) and take neither more nor less. Always remember that a man can raise horses, corn, cotton, or dogs (or any other honest product) and be a gentleman, but the moment he raises “Cain” he ceases to be one. GOODE’S BUSTER CHAMPION WHISPER CHAPTER XI. BOSTON TERRIER TYPE AND THE STANDARD. The standard adopted by the Boston Terrier Club in 1900 was the result of earnest, sincere, thoughtful deliberations of as conservative and conscientious a body of men as could anywhere be gotten together. Nothing was done in haste, the utmost consideration was given to every de- tail, and it was a thoroughly matured, and practically infallible guide to the general charac- ter and type of the breed by men who were genuine lovers of the dog for its own sake, who were perfectly familiar with the breed from its start, and who were cognizant of every point and characteriste which differentiated him from the bulldog on the one side and the bull terrier on the other, and while admitting the just claims of every other breed, believed sincerely that the dog evolved under their fostering care was the peer, if not the superior, of all in the particular sphere for which he was designed, 126 THE BOSTON TERRIER an all-round house dog and companion. In the writer’s estimation this type of dog, for the par- ticular position in life, so to speak, he is to oc- cupy, could not in any way be improved, and the mental qualities that accompany the physical characteristics (which are particularly specified in the first chapter) are of such inestimable value that any possible change would be detri- mental. It may be observed that it was the dogs of this type that have led the van everywhere in the days when he was practically unknown outside of the state in which he originated. “Monte,” “Druid Vixon,”’ “Bonnie,” “Revilo Peach,” and dogs of their conformation possessed a type of interesting individuality that blazed the way east, west, north and south. Does any one imagine that the so-called terrier type one so often hears of, and which a large number of peo- ple are apparently led today to believe to be “par excellence,” the correct thing, would have been capable of so doing? No one realizes more fully than the writer the fact that the bully type can be carried too far, and great harm will inevitably ensue, but the swing of the pendu- lum to the exaggerated terrier type will in time, I firmly believe, ring in his death knell. It is a source of wonderment to me that numbers of men who don the ermine can distribute prizes to the weedy specimens, shallow in muzzle, light in THE BOSTON TERRIER 127 bone and substance, loug in body, head and tail, who adorn (?) the shows of the past few years. I am not a prophet, neither the son of one, but I will hazard my reputation in predicting that be- fore many years have rolled, a type, approximat- ing that authorized by the Boston Terrier Club in 1900 will prevail, and the friends of the dog will undoubtedly believe it to be good enough to last for all time. It will readily be recalled that Lord Byron said of the eminent actor, Sheridan, “that nature broke the die in moulding one such man,” and the same may be affirmed with equa! truth of the Boston terrier, and he will ever remain a type superior to and differ from all other breeds in his particular sphere. It may not be generally known by those who are insisting on a much more terrier conforma- tion than the standard calls for, that an equally extreme desire for an exaggerated bull type pre- vailed a number of years ago amongst some of the dogs’ warmest supporters, whose ideal was that practically of a miniature bulldog, without the pronounced contour of the same. I remember when I joined the Club in the early days that some of the members then were afraid that the dogs were approximating too much to the terrier side of the house. What their views today would be I leave the reader to imagine. The plaia 128 THE BOSTON TERRIER fact of the case is, the dog should be a happy medium between the two, the bull and the tcr- rier. Can any intelligent man find a chance tor improvement here? I admit that many peopie are so constituted that a change is necessary :n practically everything they are brought into close contact with. But is a change necessarily an improvement? If some men could change the color of their eyes or the general contour of their features they would never rest satisfied until they had so done, but they would speedily find out that such a change would be very detri- mental to their appearance, the harmony of fea- tures and corelation of one part to another would be distorted. I admit readily that one very important result would be obtained, viz., the dog of the pronounced terrier type could be bred much more easily. But is an easy produc- tion a desideratum? I certainly think not. To those who “must be doing something” and who find a certain sense of satisfaction in tinkering with the standard, we extend our pity, and state that experience is a hard school, but some people will learn in no other. To those of us who love the dog as he is, and who believe in “letting well enough alone,” we admit we might as well suggest to improve the majestic propor- tions of the old world cathedrals and castles we all love so much to see, or advocate the lighten- THE BOSTON TERRIER 129 ing up of the shadows on the canvas of the old masters, or recommend the touching up of the immortal carvings of the Italian sculptors. We advise the preacher to stick to his text, and the shoemaker to his last, and to all those who would improve the standard we say: Hands off! One very important feature in connection with the Standard is, that while breeders and judges are perfectly willing to have all dogs that come in the heavyweight class conform practically to it, when the lightweights and toys are concerned, a somewhat different type is permitted and the so-called terrier type is allowed, hence we see a tendency with the smaller dogs to a narrower chest, longer face and tail. While personally I am in favor of a dog weighing from sixteen to twenty pounds, or even somewhat heavier, there is absolutely no reason why one should not have any sized dog one desires, but please observe, do not breed small dogs at the expense of the type. Let the ten or twelve pound dog conform to the standard as much as if it weighed twenty. I think an object lesson will be of inestimable value here. Every one who has visited the poul- try shows of the past few years must have been delighted and impressed to see the beautiful varieties of bantams. Take the games, for ex- ample, with their magnificent plumage and sprightly bearing. On even a casual examina- 130 THE BOSTON: TERRIER tion it will be discovered that these little fowls are an exact reproduction of the game fowl in miniature. The same identical proportions, symmetry and shape. Take the lordly Brahma and the bantam bearing the same name, and the same exact proportions prevail. And so it should be with the small Boston terrier. They should possess the same proportions and symmetry as the larger. Remember always that when the dog is bred too much away from the bulldog type, a great loss in the loving disposition of the dog is bound to ensue. Personally, if the type had to be changed, I would rather lean to the bull type than the terrier. The following testimony of a Boston banker and director of the Union Pacific Railroad, to whom I sold two large dogs that were decidedly on the bull type, may be of interest at this point. Speaking of the first dog he said: “I have had all kinds of dogs, but I get more genuine pleasure out of my Boston terrier than all my other dogs combined. When I reach home in the afternoon I am met at the gate by Prince, and when I sit down to read my paper or a book the dog is at my feet on the rug, staying there perfectly still as long as I do. When dinner is announced he goes with me to the dining room, takes his place by my side, and every little while licks my hands, and when I go out for my usual walk before retir- THE BOSTON TERRIER 131 ing the dog is waiting for me at the door while I put my hat and coat on. He follows me, never running away or barking, and he sleeps on a mat outside my door at night, and I never worry about burglars.” All this is very simple and commonplace, but it shows why this type of a dog is liked. In regard to the differences of opinion that different judges exhibit when pass- ing upon a dog in the show room, one preferring one type of a dog and the other another, this, of course, is morally wrong. The standard re- quirements should govern, and not individual preferences. We hear a good deal said nowa- days about the cleaning up of the head, and the so-called terrier finish. That seems to be the thing to do, but does not the standard call for a compactly built dog, finished in every part of his make-up, and possessing style and a grace- ful carriage? This being the case, a dog should not pessess wrinkled, loose skin on head or neck, and the shoulders should be neat and trim. In a word, in comporting to the standard a dog is produced that possesses a harmonious whole, “a thing of beauty” and a joy as long as he lives. In short, the dog should be as far removed from the bull type as he is from the terrier. If the present judges can not see their way clear to follow the standard, why, appoint those that will, for as every fair minded man agrees, the 132 THE BOSTON TERRIER dogs should follow the standard and not the standard follow the dogs. It is needless to add that I do not share in the pessimistic view taken by many lovers of the dog who think he will be permanently injured by the differences of opinion that prevail as to the type, etc., and the personalities that sometimes mar the showing of the dog, for I am of the same opinion as was probably felt by the great fish who had to give up Jonah, “that it is an impossible feat to keep a good man (or dog) down,” and that instead of falling off, as one writer intimates, he will fall into the good graces of a larger number of peo- ple than has heretofore fallen to the lot of any variety of man’s best friend. CHAMPION ROXIE CHAMPION BOYLSTON REINA CHAPTER XII. TECHNICAL TERMS USED IN RELA- TION TO THE BOSTON TERRIER, AND THEIR MEANING. A Crackerjack—aA first class, typical dog. A Mut—A worthless specimen. A Flyer—A dog capable of winning in any company. A Weed—A leggy, thin, attenuated dog, bred so. A Fake—A dog whose natural appearance has been interfered with to hide defects. A Dope—A dog afflicted, usually with chorea, that has had cocain administered to him to stop the twitching while in the judging ring. A Ringer—A dog shown under a false name, that has previously been shown under his right name. Apple-headed—Skull round, instead of flat on top. 134 THE BOSTON TERRIER Broken-up Face—Bulldog face, with deep stop and wrinkle and receding nose. Frog or Down Face—Nose not receding. Dish-faced—One whose nasal bone is higher at the nose than at the stop. Butterfly Nose—A spotted nose. Dudley Nose—A flesh-colored nose. Rose Ear—An ear which the tip turns backward and downward, disclosing the inside. Button Ear—An ear that falls over in front, concealing the inside. Tulip Ear—An upright, or pricked ear. Blaze—The white line up the face. Cheeky—When the cheek bumps are strongly defined. Occiput—The prominent bone at the back or top of the skull, noticeably prominent in blood- hounds. Chops—The pendulous lips of the bulldog. Cushion—Fullness in the top lips. Dewlap—The pendulous skin under the throat. Lippy—The hanging lips of some dogs, who should not possess same, as in the bull ter- rier. Layback—A receding nose. THE BOSTON TERRIER 135 Pig-jawed—The upper jaw protruding over the lower; an exaggeration of an undershot jaw. Overshot—The upper teeth projecting beyond the lower. Undershot—The lower incisor teeth projecting beyond the upper, as in bulldogs. Wrinkle—Loose, folding skin over the skull. Wall Eye—A blue mottled eye. Snipy—Too pointed in muzzle; pinched. Stop—The indentation between the skull and the nasal bone near the eyes. Septum—tThe division between the nostrils. Leather—The skin of the ear. Expression—The size and placement of the eye determines the expression of the dog. Brisket—That part of the body in front of the chest and below the neck. Chest—That part of the body between the fore- legs, sometimes called the breast, extending from the brisket to the body. Cobby—Thick set; low in stature, and short coupled; or well ribbed up, short and com- pact. Couplings—The space between the tops of the shoulder blades, and the tops of the hip joints. A dog is accordingly said to be long or short “in the couplings.” 136 THE BOSTON TERRIER Deep in Brisket—Deep in chest. Elbows—The joint at the top of forearm. Elbows Out—Self-explanatory; either congeni- tal, or as a result of weakness. Flat-sided—Flat in ribs; not rounded. Forearm—The foreleg between the elbows and pastern. Pastern—The lower section of the leg below the knee or hock respectively. Shoulders—The top of the shoulder blades, the point at which a dog is measured. Racy—Slight in build and leggy. Roach-back—The arched or wheel formation of loin. Pad—The underneath portion of the foot. Loins—The part of body between the last rib and hindquarters. Long in flank—Long in back of loins. Lumber—Unnecessary flesh. Cat-foot—A short, round foot, with the knuckles well developed. Hare-foot—A long. narrow foot, carried for- ward. Splay-foot—A flat, awkward forefoot, usually turned outward. Stifles—The upper joint of hind legs. TMi BOSTON TERRIER 137 Second Thighs—The muscular development between stifle joint and hock. The Hock—The lowest point of the hind leg. Spring—Round, or well sprung ribs; not flat. Shelly—Narrow, shelly body. Timber—Bone. Tucked Up—Tucked up loin, as seen in grey- hounds. Upright Shoulders—Shoulders that are set in _an upright. instead of an oblique position. Leggy—Having the legs too long in proportion to body. Stern—Tail. Screw Tail—A tail twisted in the form of a screw. Kink Tail—A tail with a break or kink in it. Even Mouthed—A term used to describe a dog whose jaws are neither overhung nor under- hung. Beefy—Big, beefy hind quarters. Bully—Where the dog approaches the bulldog too much in conformation. Terrier Type—Where the dog approaches the terrier too much in conformation. Cow-hocked—The hocks turning inward. Saddle-back—The opposite of roach-back. 138 THE BOSTON TERRIER Lengthy—Possessing length of body. Broody—A broody bitch; one whose length of conformation evidences a likely mother; one who will whelp easily and rear her pups. Blood—A blood; a dog whose appearance de- notes high breeding. Condition—Another name for perfect health. without superfluous flesh, coat in the best of shape, and spirits lively and cheerful. Style—Showy, and of a stylish, gay demeanor. Listless—Dull and sluggish. Character—A sub-total of all the points which give to the dog the desired character associ- ated with his particular variety, which differ- entiates him from all other breeds. Hall-mark—That stamp of quality that distin- guishes him from inferior dogs, as the ster- ling mark on silver, or the hall-mark on the same metal in England. he fe 7“ Se Bits ’