AN ENVIRONMENTAL PROFILE OF THE BLACK SEA COAST: A Report for the United States Navy and PCCI Marine and Environmental Engineering Compiled by the World Conservation Monitoring Centre Edited by Dr Edmund Green Prepared by: Lorraine Collins, Harriet Gillett, Edmund Green, Joanna Hugues, Igor Lysenko, Balzhan Zhimbiev WORLD CONSERVATION MONITORING CENTRE December 1997 AlN (408 | A The World Conservation Monitoring Centre (WCMC), based in Cambridge, UK is a joint-venture between the three partners in the World Conservation Strategy and its successor Caring For The Earth: YUCN - The World Conservation Union, UNEP - United Nations Environment Programme, and WWE - World Wide Fund for Nature. WCMC provides information services on conservation and sustainable use the world's living resources, and helps others to ‘ develop information systems of their own. Prepared for the United States Navy and PCCI Marine and Environmental Engineering Acknowledgements Victoria Freeman and Heather Cross WORLD CONSERVATION MONITORING CENTRE Copyright: World Conservation Monitoring Centre, Cambridge, UK Copyright release: Reproduction of this publication for educational or other non- commercial purposes is authorised without prior permission from the copyright holders. Reproduction For resale or other commercial purpose is prohibited without the prior written permission of the copyright holders. Disclaimer: The designations of geographical entities and the presentation of material in this report do not imply the expression of any opinion whatsoever by WCMC and its collaborators and _ other participating organisations, concerning the legal or constitutional status of any country, territory, or area or of its authorities; or concerning the delineation of its frontiers or boundaries. Citation: WCMC, 1997. Environmental Profile of the Black Sea coast: a report for the United States Navy. Edited by E.P. Green. Available From: World Conservation Monitoring Centre 219 Huntingdon Road, Cambridge CB3 ODL, UK Tel: +44 1223 277314; Fax: +44 1223 277136 Email: info@wemc.org.uk; URL: http://www.wcmc.org.uk FTP: ftp://ftp.wcmc.org.uk PPUNIRO DUCTION .ocecisscccesecusscnssccecesvesciesessesecocacsscnce-cereeoMeeeenssuescseeecen gO 1.1 The structure of this report 1.2 Project Team 1.3 Information Gaps and Recommendations for Improving the Focus of this Report 1.4 Map of the Black Sea Coast. 1.5 General Information on the Environmental Condition of the Black Sea. 2. IMPORTANT COASTAL WETLANDS OF THE BLACK SEA......9 2.1 Bulgaria Lakes Durankulak (12) and Shabla (11) Baltata (10) Kamchia (9) Pomorie Lake (8) Atanassovsko Lake (7) Burgas Lake (6) Mandra Lake (5) Ropotamo (4) Stranga coast (3) 2.2 Georgia Kolkheti Lowland : Tchuria (34), Nabada (35), Pichora-Paliastomi Marshes (36) 2.3 Romania Danube Delta (16) Lake Tasaul (15) Lake Siutghiol (14) Lake Techirghio (13) 2.4 Russia The Don Delta (29) Floodplain wetlands in the Lower Don (33) The Manych system of reservoirs Ust-Manych Reservoir Vesselovskoye Reservoir Proletarskoye and Gudilo Reservoir Limans in the Sea of Azov (Jejskij: 30; Bejsugskij: 31) Kuban delta (32) Kiziltashski lagoon complex (41) Turkey Igneada Saka Longozu (2) Terkos Célii (1) The Sakarya Delta (40) Sarikum Golii (39) Kizilirmak Delta (38) Yesilirmak Delta (37) 2.5 Ukraine Danube Delta (16) Dniestr Delta Tiliguliski Liman (18) Lower Dniepr, Golayal Pristan (20) Tendrovski and Yagorlitski Bays (19) Karkinitski Bay (22) Sivash Lagoon (23) Molochni Liman (24) Obitochnaya (25), Berdyansk (26), Belosarayskaya (27) and Krivaya Peninsulas (28) 3 IMPORTANT BIRD AREAS ALONG THE BLACK SEA COAST. 3.1 Bulgaria Lake Sharkovo Reservoir (Yambol) (6) Lake Mandra (Burgas) (4) Shabla-Ezeretz complex (Tolbukhin). (12) Lake Burgas or Vaya (Burgas) (5) Lake Durankulak (Tolbukhin) (13) Atanasovko Ezero (Atanassovo Lake) (Burgas) (7) Yatata Reservoir (Varna) (10) Alepu Ezero (Buragas). (3) Cape Kaliakra (Varan). (11) Cape Emine (Burgas) (8) Kamtchia Biosphere Reserve (Varna) (9) 3.2 Romania Delta Dunarii (Danube Delta) (24) and Razelm-Sinoie complex (Tulcea Constanta) (23). Rosca-buhaiova-Hrecisca Nature Reserve. (Tulcea). (27) Perisor-Zatoane-Sacalin Nature Reserve (Tulcea) (22) Periteasca-Leahova-Gura Portitei Nature Reserve. (Tulcea) (21) Lacul Istria , Lacul Nuntasi and southern Lacul Sinoie (Constanta). (20) Padurea letea (Letea Forest) (Tulcea). (26) Padurea Niculitel-Badadag (Niculitel and Babadag Forest) (Tulcea). (25) Lacul Tasaul (Constanta) (17) Lacul Siutghiol (Constanta) (16) Lacul Techirghiol (Constanta) (15) Padurea Hagieni ( Hagieni Forest) (Constanta) (14) Canaraua Fetii (Constanta) (19) Lacul Dunareni (Constanta) (18) 3.3 Turkey Biiyiik Cekmece G6lii (Istanbul) Bosphorus (Istanbul) (1) Terkos G6lii (Durusu Gélii or Durugél) (Istanbul) (2) Cam Burnu (ordu) (56) Kackar Daglari (Artvin, Erzurum, Rize) (55) Kizilirnmak Deltasi (Samsun) (58) North-East Turkey (Artvin, Rize) (54) Yenigaga Gdlii (Bolu) (62) NO Yesihrmak Deltasi (Samsun) (57) 32 Sarikum G6lii (Sinop) (59) 32 3.4 Russia and Ukraine ayy Ukrainian Steppe Reserve, Sumy, Donetsk, and Zaporozhe (Ukraina) ( 63 ) 33 Krivaya Kosa (Krivaya Peninsula), Novoazovsk Donetsk (Ukraine) (46) 33 Belosarayskaya Kosa (Belosarayskaya Peninsula), Volodarskoye, Donetsk (Ukraina) (45) 33 Berdyanskaya Kosa (Berdyansk Peninsula), Berdyansk, Zhdanov (Ukraina) (44) 33 Molochny Liman, Melitopol (Ukraine) (61) 33 Sivasj Zaliv, Azovskoye More (Sivash Bay, Sea of Azov) Ukraine (37) 33 Krymski (Crimean) Game Reserve, Krym (Ukraine) (41) 34 Karkinitsky Zaliv, Chernoye More (Karkinitsky Bay, Black Sea) (Ukraine) (38) 34 Yalta Mountain Forest, Bolshaya Yalta, Krym (Ukraina) (40) 35 Mys Martyan, Krym (Ukraine) (39) 35 Nizovya Dnepra (Lower Dnepr), Golaya Pristanm Kherson (Ukraine) (31) 35 Askania -Nova. Kherson (Ukraine) (36) 35 Dunay (Danube) and Yagorlytski and Tendrovski Zalivy (Yagorlystki and Tendra Bays) (Ukraina) Dunay (Danube) (29) 36 Yagorlytski and Tendrovski Zalivy ( yagorlytski and Tendra Bays) (Ukraine) (29, 33) 36 Tiliguliski Liman (Tiligul Salt -Lake), Berezanka and Kominternovskoye (Ukraine) (32) 36 Nizovya Dnestra (Lower Dnestr), Belgorod-Dnestrovski and Ovidiopol (Ukraine) (31) 36 Karadag, Sudag, Krymskaya (Crimean) Oblast (Ukraine) (42) 37 Salt-Lakes (Limany) in the Primorsko-Akhtarsk/Grivenskaya area (including Akhtarski Liman and Liman Sladki) (Krasnodes Kray, RSFSR) (60) 37 Kavzkav (Caucasus) Biosphere Reserve, Sochi (Krasnodar Kray, RSFSR) (48) 37 Nizovya Reki Rioni, Ozero Paliastomi (lower Rioni, Lke Paliastomi) (Gruziya) (52) 37 Pskhuski, Abkhazskaya ASSR (Gruziya) (51) 38 Guminstin, Sukhumi, Abkhazaskaya ASSR (Gruziya) (50) 38 Ritsa, Gudauta, Abkhazskaya ASSR (Gruziya) (49) 38 Kintrishi, kobuleti, Adzharskaya ASSR (Gruziya) (53) 38 4. COASTAL PROTECTED AREAS OF THE BLACK SEA.............39 4.1 Introduction 39 4.2 Information Gaps 39 Bulgaria 39 Georgia 40 Romania 40 Russia 40 Turkey 40 Ukraine 40 Nationally designated coastal protected areas 41 Bulgaria 41 Georgia 42 Romania 42 Russia 43 Turkey 44 Ukraine 44 4.4 Internationally designated coastal protected areas 47 Bulgaria 47 Georgia 47 Romania 47 Russia 48 Turkey 48 Ukraine 48 4.5 Site sheets for some protected areas 49 Bulgaria - Réserve Kamtchia 49 Bulgaria - Réserve Ouzounboudjak 50 Georgia - Kintrishskiy State Reserve 51 Romania - Danube Delta Biosphere Reserve 53 Russia - Kavkazskiy Zapovednik 61 Russia - Teberdinskiy State Reserve 63 Turkey - Haciosman Reserve 64 Turkey - Ilgaz Dagi National Park 65 Turkey - Yedigéller National Park 67 Ukraine - Askaniya-Nova Zapovednik 68 Ukraine - Tchernormorsky State Reserve 70 4.6 National Environmental Policy and Legislation 72 Bulgaria Country Profile 72 Georgia Country Profile 77 Romania Country Profile 77 Russia Country Profile 82 Turkey Country Profile 82 Ukraine Country Profile 89 5. ENDANGERED ANIMAL SPECIES OF BLACK SEA STATES .92 5.1 Introduction 92 5.2 Recommendations for further work on endangered Black Sea fauna 92 5.3 Guide to the IUCN (World Conservation Union) Red List Categories and Criteria 92 5.4 Guide to the interpretation of CMS Appendices 97 5.5 References 97 5.6 Summary table of species richness (fauna and vertebrates only) and regional endemism 98 5.7 List of species of fauna not globally threatened but of special concern in Europe 99 5.8 List of globally threatened vertebrates restricted to Europe 107 5.9 Summary table of all IUCN Red List species of fauna occurring in the Black Sea States 111 6. ENDANGERED PLANT SPECIES OF BLACK SEA STATES ..124 6.1 Globally threatened plants endemic to single countries bordering the Black Sea 124 6.2 Status of globally threatened plants occurring in five countries bordering the Black Sea 124 4 6.3 Globally threatened plants occurring in more than one country bordering the Black Sea 124 7. INTERNATIONAL CONVENTIONS AND AGREEMENTS COVERING THE BLACK SEA COAGST............ jonkssdencsesesessss sacsseasnds 125 STRATEGIC ACTION PLAN FOR THE REHABILITATION AND PROTECTION OF THE BLACK SEA 125 CONVENTION ON THE PROTECTION OF THE BLACK SEA AGAINST POLLUTION (21 Apr 1992) 136 CONVENTION CONCERNING FISHING IN THE BLACK SEA (Varna, 7 July 1959) 149 EN LOG RA PHY foie ee Se en aes 151 1. INTRODUCTION 1.1 The structure of this report This report was prepared for the US Navy and PCCI Marine and Environmental who commissioned WCMC to compile environmental data on the Black Sea coastal zone for use in the planning of naval exercises. As such data pertaining to the Black Sea coastal zone (arbitrarily defined in this instance by the US Navy as 50 miles inland of the high water mark) of Turkey, Bulgaria, Romania, Ukraine, Russia and Georgia has been collated in one volume. The information presented here comes from a wide range of different sources. This information, and considerable amounts of additional related data, are held at WCMC in Cambridge, UK. The quality of these data will vary and WCMC is very keen to hear from any national and regional experts and organisations in order to correct, update and improve its information holdings. This same information is also freely available to interested parties, and it is hoped that in some cases it might provide a useful starting point for bodies interested in establishing biodiversity data management systems at the national level. The US Navy is interested in collecting data which may used to plan naval exercises in an environmentally informed manner. Data on endangered species, protected areas, important habitats, breeding areas and marine pollution are particularly useful in this regard. To achieve this purpose the report has been structured in six main sections: Important coastal wetlands of the Black Sea Coastal protected areas of the Black Sea Endangered animal species of the Black Sea states Endangered plant species of the Black Sea states International conventions and agreements covering the Black Sea coast 1.2 Project Team Edmund Green (Marine and Coastal) — project leader Joanna Hugues (Marine and Coastal) — wetlands and important bird areas Lorraine Collins (Trade and Environment)— endangered fauna Harriet Gillett (Biodiversity Assessment) — endangered flora Balzhan Zhimbiev (Protected Areas and Landscapes) — protected areas Igor Lysenko (Geographic Information Systems technician) — map production 1.3 Information Gaps and Recommendations for Improving the Focus of this Report This report is as extensive and complete as was possible given this time frame but inevitably there are some gaps in the information: 1. it was possible to gather good data on the wetland habitats of the Black Sea and the important bird areas but it was not possible to research some other important habitats (e.g. seagrass, sand dunes, beaches). 2. protected areas are listed by name, size and location, where possible. More detailed information (on management status, boundaries, national and international importance etc.) was available in some cases but not all. 3. it was possible to produce general lists of endangered species in the six Black Sea nations but it was not possible to separate coastal from non-coastal species. Recommendations for improving the focus of this report are presented in the introduction to each section, along with the amount of time this would require. WCMC would be happy to undertake this work should it be deemed necessary. 1.4 Map of the Black Sea Coast. A large format map of the Black Sea coast accompanies this report. This map includes important wetlands (numbered to refer to the text in Section 2), important bird areas (numbered to refer to the text in Section 3), protected areas (same, but not all, of the areas described in Section 4), infrastructure, political boundaries and bathymetry. 1.5 General Information on the Environmental Condition of the Black Sea. An overview of the environmental condition of the Black sea taken from the Religion, Science and the Environment Symposium II: The Black Sea in Crisis 20-28 September 1997: “The Black Sea is a unique environment, badly degraded. Similar in size to the North Sea or the Baltic, it is virtually landlocked, connected to the rest of the world’s oceans through the Bosphorus Straits, the Sea of Marmara and the Dardenelles. The Bosphorus, in places only 700 metres wide and 70 metres deep, carries in its deep waters a reverse stream of seawater which gradually replenishes the salty bottom waters of the Black Sea with water from the Mediterranean. This replenishment is insufficient to cope with the demands of bacteria breaking down organic material falling from the fertile surface of the Black Sea and, below about 150 metres, the Black Sea is lifeless. The surface waters of the Black Sea are replenished from numerous rivers which drain an area covering major parts of seventeen countries spanning over one third of the area of Europe. These rivers, including the mighty Danube, Dnieper and Don, bring nitrogen, phosphorus and other minerals to the Sea and the influx of river water which keeps its salinity far below that of the neighbouring Mediterranean. The Black Sea has long been a crossroads of civilisation. Its coasts are the territories of six countries — Bulgaria, Georgia, Romania, Russia, Turkey and Ukraine. Its physical beauty has long attracted millions of tourists, especially from Eastern Europe and the former Soviet Union. These coasts have also had to house cities, industries and major ports; human presence has often affected the fragile coastal ecosystems through unplanned development and competition for space. The recent political changes and the transition to market economies have also resulted in grave economic difficulties as people struggle to protect their welfare. It is hardly surprising that the coastal environment has suffered badly. Sewage treatment, for example, is absent or deficient in most coastal cities and human health has suffered. Cholera outbreaks have occurred in some places. These problems have harmed the tourist industry upon which many coastal economies depend. Spiritual health has also suffered as people lose confidence or become more selfish in their struggle for survival. Despite these challenges, many people have not lost their sense of responsibility. They question and challenge each development project, whether a new port, industrial plant or oil terminal, out of concern for the impact on their lives and on the lives of future generations. The Black Sea itself has been the victim of the changes in the economy and lifestyle of the 160 million people living in its basin, some in landlocked countries thousands of kilometres from the sea. Industrialisation and intensification of agriculture, coupled with the excessive or inappropriate use of agrochemicals, has led to the pollution of many rivers leading to the sea. The over-fertilisation of the sea itself fundamentally changed the nature of its ecosystems, particularly those of the shallow North-Western shelf where a key bed of red algae, as large in area as The Netherlands, was destroyed by eutrophication. This led to the loss of many other species including fish that depended on it for nursery grounds. In the past three decades, the healthy Black Sea ecosystem has become extremely sick. Fishery resources, already suffering the impact of pollution and other changes, buckled under the stress of overfishing. Exacerbating this situation was the arrival of a new alien species of a gelatinous organism, Mnemiopsis, (a comb-jelly) inadvertently carried in the ballast water of ships from the Eastern American seaboard. With no natural enemies, this organism flourished until it dominated the entire Black Sea. Now, the peoples of the Black Sea are faced with a difficult choice, to give the sickened ecosystem a chance to 7 recover on its own, or to intervene, for example by harvesting Mnemiopsis directly or by introducing a predator. There is reason for hope that the Black Sea can recover. The depression of industrial and agricultural production during the current economic transition has relieved the environment of the pressure of pollution. The ecosystem has started to recover. Some improvement has been registered in fish stocks. There is good reason for hope. A little time has been granted to develop and implement new policies and laws and to improve environmental awareness and education, vital tools for transition. How long will this window of opportunity last? The Black Sea is facing new threats: continued sewage pollution, new pressure from developers of beachside residences, and use as a superhighway for oil transport from the Caspian oil fields. The vital Bosphorus winds its way through Istanbul, carrying hundreds of ships every day and represents a major flash point for environmental security. The last Black Sea monk seal may have already perished. Clearly, there is no time to lose. We must act now.’ 2. IMPORTANT COASTAL WETLANDS OF THE BLACK SEA Information for this section was taken largely from Provirof, L. 1994. Conservation of Black Sea wetlands: a review and preliminary action plan based on national reports by L. Provirof. {et al} compiled by A.M. Wilson and M.E. Moser for International Waterfowl and Wetlands Research Bureau. Slimbridge: International Waterfowl and Wetlands Research Bureau. IWRB publication; 33 Wetlands are particularly important habitats along the Black Sea coast, unsurprisingly given that its drainage basin comprises an area 17 times as large as the Sea itself, and spread over 17 different nations. They form the transitional zone between the terrestrial drainage basin and the marine environment of the Black Sea. Wetlands are typically dynamic and highly productive ecosystems which support a unique diversity of flora and fauna. Black Sea wetlands include habitats such as reed dominated marshes, forested riverine flood plains, inland lakes and lagoons, limans (a coastal lagoon with a salinity gradient), deltas, coastal lagoons and bays and associated mud and sand flats, as well as artificial wetlands such as fish ponds, rice paddies and salt ponds. These wetlands have adapted to various hydrological, nutrient and salinity regimes influenced by the extensive catchment basin and semi-enclosed sea. They provide a variety of critical functions which sustain both the people and the biodiversity of the region. Individual wetland areas are numbered on the Black Sea map. Numbers in brackets after the area names refer to this map. 2.1 Bulgaria The total area of natural wetlands (lakes and marshes) in Bulgaria today amounts to nearly 11,000 ha, mostly along the Danube and the Black Sea Coast, as opposed 200,000 ha at the beginning of this century. This tenfold reduction came about through a short-sighted domestic policy between 1944 and 1989 which resulted in the drainage of large wet areas along the Danube and in the interior of the country to support agricultural development. The many large and small dams (totalling 2,200km’) built during this time cannot replace the biodiversity and biophysical functions of intact natural wetlands such as Straldzha, Belene, Karaboaz and Svishtov marshes. The adjacent marine areas are experiencing loss of biodiversity due to eutrophication, over fishing and introduced species, such as jellyfish. Many years of study have shown that 29 existing wetlands (natural and reservoirs) are of international importance according to the Ramsar Convention's criteria (as adopted by the Conference of the Contracting Parties in 1990). Their total area amounts to 18,000 ha which comprises about 0.2% of the surface area of Bulgaria. The internationally important wetlands are geographically distributed in the Black Sea Coastal area (16 sites 10,473 ha, 57.7%), the Danube plain (6 sites 3,205 ha, 17.7%) and the interior of southern Bulgaria (7 sites 4,470 ha, 24.6%). A comprehensive overview of Bulgaria's wetlands is found in the 1994 National Action Plan for the Conservation of the Most Important Wetlands in Bulgaria (Ministry of Environment ,1993). Lakes Durankulak (12) and Shabla (11) The wetland complexes of Shabla and Durankulak are considered to be of international importance. These are brackish to freshwater lakes with some reedbeds; the latter is separated from the sea by a sand bar. This area also supports extensive sand beaches and high dunes, which are at present minimally influenced by tourism. There is a unique hyper-saline marsh south east of Shabla. The area provides critical winter habitats for a majority of the world population of the red-breasted goose Branta ruficollis. The following areas are protected: Durankulak Lake has been protected as a Natural Monument since 1980 (360 ha total, 250 ha is open water), and is also a Ramsar site; it is surrounded by a 500-m buffer zone in which hunting and pesticides on arable lands are prohibited. Shabla Lake has been a protected site since 1979 covering 300 ha with 150 ha as open water, and includes a 500-m buffer zone along the coast; fishing, hunting and pesticides are prohibited. Although these areas are protected by decree of the Ministry of Environment, there is no other legislation or mechanism for regulation or administration of their management and protection. They are in urgent need of effective conservation measures and management plans. The lakes and surrounding lands are municipal property in the process of privatisation. They are valuable for fishing, especially carp Cyprinus sp.. There are 3 towns, 10 villages, 4 campsites and 1 Club-Med resort, with the whole area receiving few visitors. If large-scale, mass tourism were encouraged, the resulting infrastructure for people and recreation could damage the currently intact natural habitats, especially the wetlands, dunes and steppe areas. Industry is minimal although international companies are now investigating the possibility of oil production from Bulgaria's sea shelf which could have negative impacts on the coastal and marine habitats, if not effectively controlled. The main agricultural use of the north coast area is grain production and sheep and cattle grazing. There is concern that privatisation of the land may cause problems for the internationally important red-breasted goose populations that winter in the area. There is also an increasing potential for conflict between geese and farmers, concerning crop damage. The waterbirds of Shabla and Durankulak lakes are becoming increasingly popular for international hunting concerns. All these factors could negatively affect the international importance of these wetlands for red-breasted geese. Baltata (10) This is a small flooded forest next to the Albena tourism resort, north of Varna. While 200 ha is strictly protected and 160 ha is a buffer zone, management of the reserve does not capture potential ecotourism opportunities. A road to the north has cut off the natural flooding regime and is changing the forest composition. Kamchia (9) This is a remnant riverine, flooded forest at the mouth of the River Kamchia, which was regularly flooded 3 5 years ago. Irrigation projects since the 1 980s have negatively affected the area causing improper water flow and drainage; saltwater intrusion and lowering the water level has changed the forest composition. The area is still known for its liana (‘longos') ecosystem. This and Baltata are the only large flooded forests left in Bulgaria. The remaining flooded forest and longos area is the 842 ha Kamchia Biosphere Reserve with a surrounding agricultural buffer zone. A management plan and staff are needed. Pomorie Lake (8) This is an important hypersaline, coastal lagoon (850 ha) with saltpans that is presently unprotected. There is salt extraction, an abandoned fish and mariculture factory and nearby health resort marketing the Pomorie muds for medicinal purposes. Pollution has impacted the fishing, the muds and the birds which relied on food in the mud. Salt production is active, but is changing the character of the area. The area needs to be designated as an education/nature reserve and managed accordingly. The area has a very diverse avifauna, particularly during the breeding season. 10 Atanassovsko Lake (7) This is a 1050 ha hypersaline complex of salt ponds and reedbeds with smaller settling pools for extraction surrounded by a freshwater canal. This area is threatened by pollution from the canal, erosion and deterioration of the dykes. This area is a Ramsar site and nature reserve, with a buffer zone. Over 250 bird species are found in this area including 12 globally threatened species. It is especially important as a migration staging area. There is an Ecological Station of the Institute of Ecology, Sofia, with a staff of two biologists. The area has a management plan, but it needs further implementation. Burgas Lake (6) This is a 2800 ha shallow brackish to freshwater area with shoreline reed beds near the city. Over 230 bird species have been recorded in this area. It is connected to the Black Sea with a sluice, which has allowed agricultural pollution to reach the sea. Land-impacts include fishing, hunting, agriculture and grazing. The lake is polluted from oil derivatives requiring mitigating actions. Only a small 75 ha reserve on the NW side is protected. A management plan is required, including measures to reduce pollution and stimulate ecotourism. Mandra Lake (5) This is a 1000-ha brackish, coastal area surrounded by meadows and marshes which has been turned into a reservoir with a remnant coastal lagoon and sea outlet. Over 240 bird species have been observed. The lake is used for fishing, hunting and irrigation land is unprotected. An adjacent brackish lagoon, Poda, is protected and managed by the Bulgarian Society for the Protection of Birds (BSPB). A proposed steel plant could be detrimental to the ecological character of the site. The entire complex protection status, management plans and implementation. Ropotamo (4) This reserve of 1000-ha, is a Ramsar site, managed by the Committee of Forests and has excellent visitor facilities with ecotourism potential. It has a surrounding buffer zone of 770 ha. Inland, the area is largely flooded forest with extensive lianas (longos) and a small boardwalk for viewing the many species of forest trees. There are extensive and high dunes, marshes and rocky shores along the coast. It was one of the first strict reserves in Bulgaria, established in 1940 and enlarged in 1956. There are threats from adjacent holiday village development and hunting in the forests. A management plan is needed for the site, as well as staff to implement it. Stranga coast (3) This is a relatively undisturbed area near the Turkish border between the Veleka and Rezovska Rivers. The estuary between the rivers is the old border, and therefore undisturbed to date. The area has many endemic and Bulgarian Red Data Book species of both Mediterranean and Asian origin. The coast has extensive lagoons, marshes, dunes and beaches. It presently has low human popuiation, but is being speculated for coastal development. This unique area warrants protection status. 2.2 Georgia Kolkheti Lowland : Tchuria (34), Nabada (35), Pichora-Paliastomi Marshes (36) The Kolkheti lowlands hold the only significant Black Sea basin wetlands in Georgia. On both sides of the river Rioni there are important wetlands, especially the Tchuria, Nabada and Pichora-Paliastomi marshes. These total about 42,500 ha. The area demonstrates elements both of a subtropical and temperate climate, receiving humid air masses from the Black Sea, since the main Caucasian range protects the Kolkheti area from the invasion of cold Arctic air masses from the north. The lowest and wettest parts of the Kolkheti lowland border on the Black Sea. The surface of the Kolkheti lowland is dominated by alluvial, alluvial-lake-marsh, alluvial- marine and marine soils. There is almost no gradient along the axial river Rioni. Therefore, natural drainage is slow and the formation of wetlands is active. Some coastal areas even lie 0.3 - 0.8 m below sea level. An important factor in the formation of wetlands along the coast of the Kolkheti lowlands has been the drop in land elevation relative to sea level, due to subsidence. There are coastal peat deposits between the mouths of the Supsa, Rioni, Khobi and Inguri rivers. The peat bogs of Imnati, Schowzchala, Nabada and Tschuria have a depth of up to 11 m and play a critical role as natural filters preventing nutrients from agriculture and other upstream activities from entering the Black Sea. The Kolkheti lowlands have an extensive river network with different types of water supply, basin morphology and capacity. The rivers originating from the Caucasus are fed by snow and glacial melt; they have a spring-summer flood, and winter low-water levels. Rivers which originate on the south slope of the Greater Caucasus spurs and on the north slope of the Meskheti mountain range are supplied by snow, rain and underground water; they are characterised by spring floods and high water levels also in the autumn. Small rivers originate within the Kolkheti lowlands or in the hilly foothills of the Greater Caucasus spurs and Meskheti range and are supplied by rain and underground water. The rivers are extremely important to the wetlands of the Kolkheti lowlands, but due to the very low gradients, drainage is poor and the water floods the surrounding areas. This is particularly acute after heavy rainfall or when the sea floods the coastal areas after storms. There are about 40 lakes on the Kolkheti lowland, of which the biggest is Paliastomi. This used to be a freshwater lake, but is now saline and less productive due to human interventions. Other wetland habitats include lagoons, estuaries, lakes between dunes, and oxbow lakes, which are particularly abundant on the south side of the river Rioni. Alluvial swamp, silt-marsh and peat bog soils are widely spread in the marshy part of the Kolkheti lowlands, these include wooded areas and grasslands. Large areas of the coastal parts of the Kolkheti lowlands have aquatic and marsh vegetation. At present, the greater part of the Kolkheti lowlands, except for the lowest areas, is cultivated. The Kolkheti lowlands are an important refuge for local fauna, particularly migratory waterbirds and mammals. Large concentrations of ducks and birds of prey assemble at Paliastomi Lake and other wetlands. Presently only 500 ha (including the Lower Rioni and Lake Paliastomi) of the lowland is protected including 340 ha of forests and 157 ha of marshes. As such, the protected area is too small to maintain the high diversity and ecological functioning of the area. Major causes of degradation include upstrearn deforestation, heavy peat extraction, drainage and overfishing. 2.3 Romania The total area of wetlands in Romania exceeds 6.2% of the total land area. The wetlands consist of: flowing waters, (over 118,000 km, including the inland river flood plains, Danube and Danube Delta flood plains, approx. 5%); natural lakes (over 2300, approx. 0.9%); artificial lakes (over 1500, including the fishponds, approx. 0.3 %); and the Black Sea shore (245 km, approx. 0.05%). In recent decades, the surface area of wetlands in Romania has decreased because of hydrotechnical and drainage works, especially in the inland river floodplains and also in the Danube floodplain and in the Danube Delta. The drainage works began between the world wars through the dams on the Bega, Somes, Crisuri and Dunare. This was 12 intensified after 1950. The most extensive post-war drainage is along the Danube valleys (lakes and marshes in south Oltenia, south Muntenia, Balta Lalomitei, Balra Brailei), in large areas of the Danube Delta (Pardina) and also in the western part of the country (Tisa Plain). Between 1976 and 1980, 24,625 km’ of wetlands were drained. As a result many of the natural lakes from the Danube Delta have been turned into agricultural polders affecting the habitats of a large number of wetland species. Many new artificial lakes and reservoirs were created on the Danube River, (Portile de Fier I and 11), and on some internal rivers, (Arges, Olt, Bistrita, Lotru, lalomir.l, Sadu, Uarz.Ivl, Raul Marc, Crisuri, Prut, etc.). Many artificial ponds have also been created for fish rearing. However, these artificial wetlands do not compensate for the functions that have been lost through the conversion of natural wetlands. Danube Delta (16) The Danube Delta is the second largest relatively intact wetland complex in Europe (after the Volga Delta), covering about 565,000 ha, including 442,000 ha in Romania and the rest in Ukraine. It is an extensive network of river tributaries, canals, lakes and reed swamps, as well as high ground forests, meadows, sandy grasslands and dunes, which interact to form a complex and unique mosaic of terrestrial and aquatic habitats, each supporting a rich flora and fauna. These habitats provide a high degree of water regulation and cleansing functions that, if lost, could have an irreversibly deleterious effect on the Black Sea. The Delta exhibits classic triangular formation with branching distributaries of the Danube River extending out from an apex to nearly 100 km in length and width before discharging into the Black Sea. The Danube river branches into three main courses from north to south. These are the Chilia, Sulina and Sf. Gheorghe, discharging 60%, 21% and 19% respectively of the Danube water at low flow months, and 72%, 11% and 17% at high flow months. The Delta has a temperate to continental climate, with local influences from extensive water surfaces and marsh vegetation, as well as strong north-easterly winds from the Black Sea and Ukraine. The Delta acts as a large-scale filter between the Danube River and the Black Sea. The lake complex Razim-Sinoie has a peculiar position within the Danube Delta. It consists of several extensive lakes (former lagoons) surrounded by marshes and sandy dunes. The lakes are separated from the Black Sea by sandy belts and dunes. The closing of the two communications between these basins and the sea has produced a decrease of water salinity with effects upon local flora and fauna. In spite of intense pressure from grazing, silviculture, hydrological alteration and agriculture, the Danube Delta still supports diverse and large populations of fish, birds and rare mammals. There are over 75 species of fish, most of which are freshwater, but many Black Sea species rely on the Delta for breeding and survival of juveniles. Sturgeon Acipenser sturio formerly spawned in the Delta, but no longer do so. The Delta supports important breeding, migrating and wintering bird populations (about 275 species, of which 175 are breeding species), including several globally threatened species, such as red-breasted goose Branta ruficollis, pygmy cormorant Phalacrocorax pygmeus and five percent of the world population of Dalmatian pelican Pelecanus crispus. In addition, half of the Palaearctic breeding population of the white pelican Pelecanus onocrotalus occurs in the delta. The Delta is an important refuge for the European mink Mustela hatreola, the wild cat Felis sylvestris and the European otter Lutra lutra. The Delta's unique complex of terrestrial and aquatic habitats supports a diversity of vegetation that is both biologically and economically significant. White willow Salix alba hardwoods line the river tributaries, while the coastal dune systems support ash-oak forests (Fraxinus - Quercus). The extensive reedbeds in the Delta's lakes are harvested for export throughout Europe. The first dikes in the Danube Delta were built in 1950 to reclaim some reedbed polders that have since been utilised for fishing and reed harvesting. After the period of fishery development (1965-1975), the government started to consider the development of intensive agriculture, forestry and fisheries, planning to drain more then 160,000 ha. In 1989, this programme stopped, but 103,000 ha were already transformed into agricultural polders (approx. 49.6%), fish ponds (approx. 44.2%), and forestry polders (6.2%). Many short canals were created in this period, mainly to facilitate transport, but disturbing the hydrological regime, affecting the natural sedimentation process and the quality of water. Most of the Danube Delta has been designated as a Biosphere Reserve, World Heritage Site and Ramsar Site. The Global Environment Facility (GEF) is funding a comprehensive project to implement obligations arising from the above designations in both Romania and Ukraine. The project includes institutional strengthening, protection and restoration measures, building of public awareness, and assistance to coordination with Ukraine. Lake Tasaul (15) This is an unprotected, slightly brackish lake (1830 ha) near Constanta that is supplied by the River Casimcea. It has barren shores and marshes. Human activities include fishing and an industrial plant in the south-eastern section. The lake is an important roosting and feeding site for migratory birds in the spring and autumn, but there is little ornithological data. Breeding species include little bittern Ixobrychus minutus and ferruginous duck Aythya nyroca. Lake Siutghiol (14) This was a marine lagoon but is now a freshwater lake (2100 ha) separated from the sea by a narrow sandbank, with reedbeds and intermittent sandy shores. It is near Constanta and has no protected status. The lake is important for passage migrants and over summering immature birds, but freezes in winter. Nearly one-half of the coastal area is dominated by holiday resorts and light industry, which disturb the wildlife in the summer months. Lake Techirghio (13) This was a coastal bay (1170 ha), but is now separated from the sea by a sandbar, although it still functions as a saline lake and does not freeze in the winter. It has barren shores with some marsh vegetation near freshwater streams. The muds from the lake bottom are used by nearby health resorts. A decrease in salinity has occurred due to irrigation in the surrounding areas. It is an important area for migratory and wintering birds, particularly black-necked grebe Podiceps nigricollis, but is unprotected. 2.4 Russia Russia has several significant areas for wetland biodiversity in the Black Sea coastal zone, primarily the vast wetland complexes of the eastern Sea of Azov, and the Kerch Straits at the opening of the Sea of Azov and the Black Sea. Coastal areas of the Sea of Azov have been subject to extensive economic development, in particular fishing, aquaculture and agriculture collectively affecting the quality of this unique shallow ‘inland’ sea. These have lead to many negative changes in the marine and coastal biodiversity, and fisheries reproduction. Nonetheless significant wetland areas still remain. These are briefly described below: The Don Delta (29) This has a total area of 54,800 ha of which 46,200 ha is occupied by wetland habitats, and includes a system of channels of varying size and character, and salt lakes. In the last decade a number of commercial fish farms have been built in the Delta (with an area of 10,000 ha). The flora of the Delta is varied and includes 419 species, belonging to 245 genera and 68 families. They are found not only in the wetlands but also in other sections of the Delta. The vegetation of the wetlands is more diverse than that of the reservoirs and floodplain but the dominant species are the same. The delta is an important breeding site for mallard Anas platyrhynchos, coot Fulica arra, cormorant Phalacrocorax carbo, and grey heron Ardea cinerea. This is the most polluted section of the Don river with nitrogen, phenols and pesticides all violating norm standards, and affecting both wildlife and human health. The character of the delta has also been affected by upstream hydrological works. Floodplain wetlands in the Lower Don (33) The area of wetlands in the Lower Don floodplain during the natural regime of the river flow (up until 1952) reached 300,000-330,000 ha, with an average of 170,000 ha as a result of extensive floods (more than 8 km3) during April/May. Temporary water bodies formed practically everywhere and remained until the autumn, while marshy water bodies formed in low lying places. However, as a result of major regulation works during the last 50 years, the floodplain was completely flooded only in 1963, 1979, 1981 and 1994, and partially flooded another 6 times. The wetlands have become extremely limited in the period between flooding. They have the same vegetation as the reservoirs in the Manych system. The Manych system of reservoirs These wetlands cover 2000 km’, and were formed between 1933 and 1941 when the left tributary of the Don, the River Manych, was closed off with a succession of dams. As a result, the small flat-bottomed valleys and floodplain were flooded. The resultant reservoirs have a sharply defined structure: open water surface (more than 2 m in depth) and a shallow area (less than 2 m in depth) with beds of vegetation. With the reservoirs are included a number of saline lakes, the biggest of which is Lake Gudilo. As a result the hydrochemical composition of the waters in these reservoirs varies considerably. Territorially the reservoirs are distributed within the Rostov Oblast and the Kalmykia Autonomous Republic. Their description is given below, from the mouth of the former River Manych to its source: Ust-Manych Reservoir This is the most westerly of the reservoirs, and has an area of 7300 ha, with 3500 ha of shallows. It is 60.5 km long, and its width fluctuates from 1 km to 3 km; its maximum depth is 7 m. More than 30% of the area of the reservoir is overgrown with aquatic macrophytes. Along the edges of the reservoir is a 10-100 m belt of vegetation, while growth in the inlets may reach 100% of the area. Dominant plants are Scirpus, Typha, Phragmites, Straliola aloides, Ceratophyllum demersum, Lemna, Pozamogeton, Myriophyllum and Chara. Vesselovskoye Reservoir This has an area of 30,000 ha (including 8000 ha of shallows), is 92.3 km long, 1.5- 3.5 km wide with a maximum depth of 8.4 m. After the reservoir was created (in 1933) there was a large fluctuation in salinity. Subsequently, fresh water was drawn into the reservoir at first from the Tsimlyanskoye Reservoir and then from the Kuban Delta. As a result of the change in salinity of the water there was also a change in the flora, especially the composition of the dominant species. At present the composition of the dominant flora is identical to that of the Ust-Manych Reservoir, with an extensive littoral belt of reeds. The reservoir is an important breeding site for coot Fulica atra, mallard Anas platyrhynchos, red-crested pochard Netta rufina, spoonbill Platalea leucorodia, purple heron Ardea purpurea, and grey heron Ardea cinerea. It is an important staging area for white-fronted geese Anser albifrons, red-breasted goose Branta ruficollis, and dabbling ducks. Proletarskoye and Gudilo Reservoir This is situated in Rostov Oblast and Kalmykia. It is 81,000 ha in area and 190 km long. At its widest it is 13 km, with a maximum depth of 5.5 m. As regards its hydyrological and hydro- chemical characteristics it can be divided into 3 sections: freshwater (5000 ha in area), brackish (21,000 ha) and saline (55,000 ha). The latter includes Lake Gudilo and the salt lakes. The whole area is a state reserve. Proletarskoye Reservoir has the same vegetation as the other reservoirs in the system. However, Phragmites, Typha and Scirpus do not exceed 5-7% of the vegetation, whereas the submerged aquatic vegetation, especially Pommogeton, develop practically over the whole water body. The vegetation in Lake Gudilo is especially poor. The area supports large numbers of breeding greater black-headed gull Larus ichthyaetus, herring gull Lanes argentatus, black-headed gull Larus ridibundus, spoonbill Platalea leucorodia, gadwall Anas strepera, red-crested pochard Netta rufina, Dalmatian pelican Pelecanils crispus, and white pelican Pelecanus onocrotalus. Limans in the Sea of Azov (Jejskij: 30; Bejsugskij: 31) The two main coastal lagoons (limans) in the Russian part of the Sea of Azov are Jejski; and Bejsugsk1j Limans. They are characterised by a changing salinity from fresh water where the rivers (with the same name) empty into them, to corresponding marine salinity (Jejski - 5-7%o, Bejsugskij - 13%o) in the channels which connect them to the sea. The change in salinity determines the composition of the flora and fauna of the limans. The fore delta sections of the lagoons have a typical floristic composition, while in the saline sections there is poor marine vegetation. There are many wetlands on the floodplains inland of the two lagoons. Most frequently they are low lying marshy areas largely overgrown with Phragmites, Typha and Scirpus. They differ considerably in size, from several hundred to several thousand hectares in area. Kuban delta (32) An extensive area of wetlands occurs here, including a system of fore delta, salt lakes, lakes and channels which covers the region from Primorsko-Achtarsk to the town of Tamryuka along the coast of the Sea of Azov and as far as the place where the Kuban's largest channel, the Protoki, divides from the river. All these wetlands are fed by water from the Kuban River. The different salt lake systems have different hydrological and hydrochemical characteristics depending on their water source, depth and link v. ith the sea. The area of the Delta salt lakes in the 1 930s was up to 300,000 ha; then, under the influence of economic activity, it decreased considerably ( 190 000 ha including 87,000 ha of fore delta zone in 1969; 157,600 ha including 71,900 ha flood plain zone in the mid-1970s). As a result of the development of rice growing and massive irrigation schemes in the Kuban Delta a significant number of the salt lakes were opened up to rice cultivation, and water from the rice fields began to collect in some groups of salt lakes. The run-offs contained large quantities of fertilisers and harmful chemicals used in rice cultivation. This caused significant eutrophication and transformation of the salt lakes’ ecological systems. Part of this area is protected by state sanctuaries (zapovedniks). The delta is extremely important for nesting waterbirds (e.g. herons, dabbling and diving ducks, Dalmatian pelican Pelecanus crispus, spoonbill Platalea leucorodia, glossy ibis Plegadis falcinellus, gulls etc.). It is also an important staging, moulting and wintering area for waterbirds, particularly ducks and white-fronted goose Anser albifrons. Up to 1,000,000 ducks occur during the moulting period. Kiziltashski lagoon complex (41) In the Black Sea basin in Russia, wetlands include the group of Kiziltashski Lagoons which include the Bugazski, Tsokur, Kiziltashski and Vityazyevski Lagoons. Their total area is 31,300 ha. These salt lakes are characterised by significant vegetation growth and high salinity (22-80 %o). 16 Turkey Turkey's Black Sea coast is ca 1,800 km long. Only six wetlands are found on this part of the Black Sea coast (from west to east): 1) Igneada Saka Longozu, ii) Terkos Golu, iii) Sakarya Delta, iv) Sankum Golu, v) Kizilirmak Delta and vi) Yesilirmak Delta. Four of these sites (ii, iv, v, vi) are listed as Turkish Important Bird Areas and also occur in the Shadow List of Ramsar sites (ICBP/IWRB 1990). Igneada Saka Longozu (2) This is a very well preserved natural area near the Bulgarian border. It consists of extensive areas of flooded forests, several small lakes, a river delta and large intact dune systems. The site is a Nature Reserve and probably meets Turkish Important Bird Areas criteria. Animal husbandry Is the main human activity in the region. Long-term threats include tourist developments and the construction of a coastal highway right through the site. Terkos Colii (1) This is an area of about 5850 ha, with a 2500 ha lagoon near Istanbul (12 million inhabitants). The lake was originally a Black Sea bay but is now connected only by a small channel; therefore the salinity is very low. There are some reedbeds around the shore. Large dunes are found between the lake and sea with some woodland scrub comprising an area of 3350 ha. The lake is one of the main water sources for Istanbul. The lake is filling up rapidly with sand that blows in from the sea, and urban pollution is probably a problem. Efforts to stop the infilling included dune reforestation. Thousands of birds pass over the area twice a year, as the site lies on a major migration route, especially for raptors and storks. Yet the ornithological importance of the site is known to have declined considerably in recent years (Osprey Pandion haliaetus used to breed until 1984), mainly due to increased disturbance. Hunting pressure is immense, due to its proximity to Istanbul. The area is unprotected. The Sakarya Delta (40) This wetland is formed by the second longest river in Turkey, and has apparently lost its importance for birds and other wildlife during the last 25 years. Current ornithological importance is unknown, but deemed to be little. Two main lakes remain: one lake (ca 1800 ha) is situated near the sea, whilst Akgol (ca 350 ha) lies 12 km inland. Akgol is a freshwater lake also formed by the river and holds small numbers of waterbirds in winter. Sarikum G6lii (39) This is a small 1000-ha lagoon with flooded forests and dunes in the surroundings; it is situated at the northernmost tip of Turkey, near Sinop. It is a Nature Reserve and faces no major threat. The area is not of major ornithological importance (the 100,000 waterbirds mentioned in the IBA inventory is now considered to be erroneous). Kizilirmak Delta (38) This 50,000 ha wetland is the most important and largest wetland on the Turkish Black Sea coast, and one of the most significant in Turkey. It comprises 8,000 ha of natural areas, consisting of lakes, lagoons, large reedbeds (Phragmites and Scirpus), wet meadows, flooded forests and dunes. Between the lakes and the sea is a coastal forest of 1400 ha that is an excellent breeding habitat for raptors. Over 310 bird species have 17 been recorded so far. Agriculture is practised throughout the delta, whereas fishery, animal husbandry and reed-cutting are important sources of income for the people living near the wetland itself. The delta is seriously threatened by large irrigation and drainage projects, tourist development and forest and dune destruction. The Turkish Society for the Protection of Nature (DHKD) has run a wetland conservation project in the delta since July 1992, and the Turkish Ministry of Environment started a similar project later. In April 1993 the Turkish Ministry of Environment and DHKD signed a protocol that formalises the cooperation of the two parties with regards to the conservation of the Kizilirmak Delta. About 3000 ha has been designated as a hunting reserve by the Ministry of Forestry. Yesilirmak Delta (37) This used to be the largest delta on the Black Sea coast of Turkey, covering 60,000 ha. It was a large alluvial plain of the River Yesilirmak with a series of lakes and coastal lagoons. The area has been largely drained and converted into agricultural land during the last two decades, resulting in a decrease in size of the delta as a functioning wetland. Only one lake remains today, of which the ornithological importance is unknown but assumed to be only a fraction of its former importance. A hunting reserve has been created at Simenlik Golu. 2.5 Ukraine Ukraine stretches more than 1300 km from east to west and approximately 900 km from south to north. It occupies a territory of 604,000 km’. The length of its borders is 6500 km including 1050 km of seashore. The country is rich in wetlands, including rivers, lakes, ponds, reservoirs, limans, saline lakes, marshes, peat bogs, flood plains and swamp forests. Approximately 5.3% of the whole territory is covered by wetlands, of which 3.8% is wet meadow. Lakes comprise 2.3 km? of freshwater, the marshes 30 km* and the saline lagoons 8.6 km’. There are 22,000 rivers with a total length of approximately 170,000 km. The majority of them belong to the Black Sea catchment. The Danube is the second largest river in the Mediterranean/Black Sea Basin after the Nile. Ukraine has only a small section of this river at the boundary with Romania. Annually, the Danube obtains 5.7 km? of water from its 64,000 km? Ukrainian catchment. The Dniestr has a catchment of 72,100 km? in Ukraine, is 1352 km long and brings 8.7 km? of freshwater every year to the Black Sea. The Dniepr has the largest catchment area in Ukraine and a length of 981 km. It is the third largest river in the Mediterranean/ Black Sea Basin, and supplies the Black Sea with 52.4 km’ of fresh water from an area of 504,000 km? annually. Siverski Donets has a 54,900-km? catchment area in the Ukraine and collects 5.1 km? of freshwater annually. The South Bug collects 2.9 km? of water over an area of 63,700 km” in SW Ukraine. The West Bug is the only river that takes water to the Baltic Sea from a catchment area of 10,000 km? in Ukraine. More than 1000 reservoirs were built in order to regulate the flow of Ukrainian rivers. Six of the largest are on the Dniepr river: Kiev (922 km’), Kanev (582 km’), Kremenchuk (2252 km’), Dniprodzerzhinsk (567 km’), Dniprovske (410 km’) and Kakhov (2155 km’). The total water storage of these reservoirs is 55.1 km’. In addition, nearly 28,000 ponds and 7 large canals have been built. Along the Ukrainian coast of the Black Sea, there are three major river deltas and 14 bays and lagoons. These have undergone major transformations in recent decades due to large scale drainage works, improvement of irrigation schemes, diversion of water. Nevertheless, the region is still rich in wetlands with large natural areas which support many species. In the adjacent marine areas, the shallow bays have the highest biodiversity, especially the Sivash, Tendrovski, Dzharcylgach and Karkinitski Bays. The following is a brief description of the main coastal wetlands in Ukraine, going from west to east and includes Crimea and the Sea of Azov: Danube Delta (16) This wetland is shared with Romania, and therefore part of the second largest (565,000 ha) relatively intact wetland complex in Europe (after the Volga Delta), including about 150,000 ha in Ukraine. It has alluvial islands which have dense reedheds and Salix alba woodland, as well as an extensive coastal zone on the Black Sea with shallow open bays that are separated from the sea by low sand-spits. The Ukrainian part of the delta contains several large lakes that are not found inthe | Romanian portion, and the delta estuary of the Kilia (also called Chilia) river is the main marine deltaic part of the entire Danube Delta, where new marsh areas and coastal dunes are being formed. During this century, there has been intense pressure from grazing, silviculture, hydrological and navigational alteration, agriculture, fishing, hunting and trapping and upstream pollution, which has severely impacted the once diverse and large populations of fish and birds as well as rare mammals. Nevertheless, there are over 75 species offish belonging to 22 families, most of which are freshwater, but many Black Sea species rely on the Delta for breeding and survival of juveniles. Of the total of 410 bird species found in Ukraine, 280 live in the Delta at various times of the year. Together with the Romanian section, the Delta is visited by the majority of the world population of red breasted goose Branta ruficollis, pygmy cormorant Phalacrocorax pygmeus, half of the Palaearctic breeding population of the white pelican Pelecanus onocrotalus, 25 % of the Western Palearctic population of spoonbills Platalea leucorodia, and five percent of the world population of Dalmatian pelican Pelecanus crispus. From 50-100,000 waterbirds winter annually. The Delta is an important refuge for the European mink Mustela lutreola, the wild cat Felis sylvestris, and the European otter Lutra lutra. Only 14,851 ha has so far been given protected status; this area is called the Dounaiski Plavni Reserve. The Reserve Authority has very modest funds and staffing, and most activity has been devoted to research rather than management. Commercial fishing, the conversion of natural areas to rice fields, and pollution from Vilkovo are the main problems. It was a Ramsar site before Ukraine became independent, and may soon be designated as a Biosphere Reserve. It is proposed to enlarge the reserve substantially, including core and buffer areas. This wetland is now the subject of a US$ 1.5 million grant from the Global Environment Facility, which will finance institutional strengthening, protection, management and restoration _ initiatives, the building of public awareness, coordination with Romania, and the establishment of an Endowment. Dniestr Delta This wetland comprises the delta and coastal lakes, including salt-lakes, canals and reservoirs. The Dniestr Delta is 220km? and the lakes are 200,000 km’ in area. A small area of 7620 ha is protected as a temporary wildlife reserve but the Delta has been proposed for a reserve establishment (co-signed by the Odessa authorities and local © community members). Breeding bird species include up to 1500 pairs of glossy ibis Plegadis falcinellus, Shelduck Tadorna tadorna, cormorants, herons, mute swan Cygnus olor, greylag goose Anser anser and ducks. Although Phragmites and Typha dominate, more than 700 species of wetland plants have been recorded. Rare species include Trapa natans, Salvillia natans and Nymphaea alba. Threats include wetland drainage for agriculture, dam construction, sand extraction, urbanisation, overfishing and hunting, and pollution from the port of Belgorod-Dnestrovski. It is an important for wintering waterbirds, and meets the criteria for designation under the Ramsar Convention. Tiliguliski Liman (18) This is a shallow lagoon (12,000 ha) with reedbeds and sandy islands. Breeding species include avocet Recurvirostra azvosetta (200 pairs) and up to 80,000 wintering waterbirds. This area has been included in the Ramsar Shadow list, and 520 ha has been made a temporary reserve for breeding birds. Clay, extracted from the lagoon is used for mud baths. The main problems are summer house building and organic pollution. Lower Dniepr, Golayal Pristan (20) This region comprises extensive riverine and coastal channels including reedbeds and marshy islands. Breeding birds include hundreds of grebes and thousands of Ciconiiformes. It is a passage site for thousands of greylag geese Anser anser and dabbling ducks. It is unprotected, but is proposed for reserve status. Tendrovski and Yagorlitski Bays (19) These together comprise 113,200 ha and include island areas of the Black Sea Reserve (Chernormorski) and the protected islands and water area of Yagorlitski/ Tendrovksi totalling 39,748 ha. These large sea bays are separated from the sea by a narrow peninsula, resulting in islands with halophytic vegetation, small lakes and temporary water bodies. Phragmites, Typha and Scirpus typify the emergent lake vegetation, while the bays are surrounded by salt-meadow/steppe and forest steppe. The islands are important for breeding gulls and terns, and about 500,000 waterbirds use both lagoons. The hydrological balance has been changed due to the release of fresh water from irrigation and rice-growing, which has decreased the productivity of the ecosystem. Commercial fishing disturbs the waterbirds during the breeding season. These bays were designated as Ramsar sites before Ukraine became Independent, and have been State Reserves since 1927. Dzharylgach Bay This Black Sea bay includes numerous small islands and extensive coastal shallows. There is intense recreational tourism pressure on the islands and seasonal protection is needed. Breeding birds include hundreds of ducks and thousands of gulls. Hundreds of thousands of waterbirds occur during migration and include the red breased goose. Karkinitski Bay (22) This wetland comprises 37,300 ha and is part of the Crimea Reserve described below, with 27,646 ha. of land area protected, extending | km into the sea. The head of Karkinitski Bay has many sandy spits, shallow bays and salt lakes adjacent to virgin steppe and agricultural land. Vehicles are destroying the steppe habitats. There are small salt-marsh islands, some barren and others covered in reeds that are now declining in area due to erosion. The saltwater shallows have rich submerged vegetation, dominated by Characeae and Zostera, but their productivity has been adversely affected by freshwater inputs and pollution from fish farming and rice growing in the area. Bird species are declining due to intense hunting, agriculture, sheep grazing, tourism and changes in the macrophyte populations. This site was a Ramsar site before Ukraine became independent, but it is regarded as poorly protected with no control on poaching. Sivash Lagoon (23) The Sivash is the largest united lagoon system in Europe, covering about 2500 km2 of open water, mudflats and saltmarshes. The lagoons are non-tidal and not influenced by large river systems. Most are shallow and brackish with indented shoreline, spits and islands, including dominant habitats of saltmarsh and steppe with halophytic vegetation and extensive reedbeds. There is a gradual change in salinity from east (brackish) to west (hypersaline). The area is largely isolated from the Sea of Azov by a low spit, resulting in varying water levels and evaporation. Water flow is also altered by a dam and from agriculture development for rice and fish ponds, which have all increased the freshwater content. The economic activity is minimal except for industrial fishing, salt extraction and overfishing by recreation. The virgin steppe is often ploughed, used for hay and grazed by sheep. There are numerous species of breeding birds. In spring, the Bay is important for waterbirds, especially ducks red-breasted goose Branta ruficollis and waders (0.5 million including important populations of dunlin Calidris alpina and broad-billed sandpiper Limicola falcinellus). Part of the area is protected as the Azov-Sivash National Park (45,700 ha) with less than 1% having protection as a strict nature or hunting reserve. An important priority must be to extend these protected areas. This site was designated as a Ramsar site until Ukraine became independent. 20 Molochni Liman (24) This is a salt lake protected as a hydrological temporary reserve. It is separated from the Sea of Azov by a narrow spit with extensive shallows and islands. The irregular water supply from a canal leads to seasonal salinity fluctuations which destroys the vegetation. The upper part of the lake is polluted from the nearby town of Melitopol. It is a breeding site for grebes, waders, gulls and terns, and a migration site for many waterbirds. This site meets the criteria of the Ramsar Convention. Part of the site (1900 ha) has been designated as a temporary reserve. Obitochnaya (25), Berdyansk (26), Belosarayskaya (27) and Krivaya Peninsulas (28) These are four small peninsulas in the Sea of Azov which each have associated bays, coastal shallows, and low bare islands. They are breeding sites for ducks, waders, gulls, terns and passage and wintering waterfowl. The Krivaya Peninsula has a 154 ha reserve but is experiencing intense recreational pressure and fishpond impacts. It has the largest colony of black-winged stilt Himantopus Himantopus in Europe. Belosarayskaya is also considered to be a reserve of 616 ha. All four of these areas meet the criteria of the Ramsar Convention. 21 3 IMPORTANT BIRD AREAS ALONG THE BLACK SEA COAST. Individual bird areas are numbered on the Black Sea map. Numbers in brackets after the area names refer to this map. 3.1 Bulgaria The main wetlands lie along the Danube and Black Sea Coast. Many of Bulgaria's marshland and coastal lakes have been drained or modified since 19944; mainly for agriculture , but also because of development for tourism and industry. The north-eastern part of the Black Sea has some remnant steppe, and is similar to the adjacent Dobrogea of Romania. The remaining marshes and lakes along the Danube and the Black Sea coastal wetland are particularly important for breeding. Lake Sharkovo Reservoir (Yambol) (6) 42°05' N, 26°S0'E. 380 ha. Unprotected, although proposed Natural Monument. A water-storage reservoir, surrounded by low hills with arable land (mainly winter wheat). Human activities include hunting and fishing. Wintering species include Phalacrocorax pygmeus, Egretta alba, and Anser albifrons. Lake Mandra (Burgas) (4) 42°25'N, 27°28'E. 1000 ha. Unprotected, although plans to protect southern and eastern parts. A brackish coastal lake which has been turned into a water reservoir (now fed only by inflowing rivers) with a remnant, brackish coastal lagoon (Uzun-geren) with an outlet to the sea; surrounded by wet meadows, marshes, and hills. The lake is used for fishing, hunting and irrigation. A steel-manufacturing plant, currently under construction, is likely to be detrimental to the site. Breeding species include Phalacrocorax pygmeus, Nycticorax nycticorax, Ardeola ralloides, Egretta grazetta, E. alba (occasionally), Ardea purpurea, Plegadis falcinellus, Platalea leucorodia (10-35 points), Himantopus himantopus, Recuvirostra avosetta, Sterna albifrons, and S. hirundo. Pelecanus onocrotalus and P. crispus formerly bred. Wintering species include Phalacrocorax pygmeus (av. 180), Pelecanus onocrotalus, P. crispus, Egretta alba (av. 16), Anser albifrons (av.1250), and Oxyura leucocephala (av.5) (total figures for waterfowl: av.20,300). Shabla-Ezeretz complex (Tolbukhin). (12) 43°30'N, 28°35'E 300ha. Unprotected although hunting prohibited (403ha). Two lakes connected by an artificial canal and separated for the Black sea by a sandbar, both with indented shorelines covered with Phragmites. There is a hyper- saline lake (Shablenska tuzla:19 ha) just south of this complex. Hunting and fishing remain a problem at the site. Breeding species include Tadorna ferruginea (10 pairs) and Aythya nyroca. Very important for wintering waterfowl, with Cygnus olor (av.110), Anser albifrons (av.30, 600), Branta ruficollis(av. 7600, max 17,000+). Other wintering species include Gavia artica, Phalacrocorax pygmeus, Egretta alba and Mergus albellus. 22 Lake Burgas or Vaya (Burgas) (5) 42°30'N, 27°20'E. 2800ha. Unprotected, except for Protected Landscape (70 ha). A brackish to freshwater lake situated close to Burgas, connected to the Black Sea by a canal with a sluice. There is a belt of reeds along the northern, western, and southern shores. Land-uses include intensive fishing and controlled hunting, with agriculture and stock- grazing in the surrounding area. The lake is poliuted by oil derivatives. Breeding species include Gavia artica, Phalacrocorax pygmeus, Nycticorax nycticorax, Ardeola ralloides, Egretta garsetta, Ardea purpurea, Plegadis falcinellys (100-200 pairs), Aythya nyroca, ,Himantopus himantopus, Recurvirostra avosetta, Glareola pratincola, and Sterna hirundo. Wintering species include Phalacrocorax pygmeus, Pelecanus crispus (occasionally), and Egretta alba. Lake Durankulak (Tolbukhin) (13) 43°38'N, 28°30'E 350 ha Ramsar site. Protected landscape. A brackish to freshwater coastal lake with some reedbeds. Human activities are few. Breeding species include Botaurus stellaris, Ixobrychus minutus, Anser anser, Circus areruginous, and Glareola pratincola. Important for wintering Branta rufisollis (av. 400; max. 1710). Other wintering species include Gavis arctica, Phalacrocorax pygmeus, Cygnus cygnus, Anser albifrons (av. 17,000; max 890), and Mergus albellus, with and average of 27,000 wintering swans, geese and ducks. Atanasovko Ezero (Atanassovo Lake) (Burgas) (7) 42°30'N, 27°30'E 1690 ha Ramsar Site (1050 ha). A complex of saltpans with smaller settling pools for salt extraction, surrounded by a freshwater canal (which is wide in places) with reedbeds. There is salt extraction, but fishing and grazing are prohibited. The site is threatened by pollution of the canal (by industry to the north of the Reserve and by pig farms), erosion, and general deterioration of the dykes (on which many of the birds breed). The breeding colonies are also accessible to mammalian predators. Breeding species (breeding data mainly from 1977) include Ixobrychus minitus (many pairs), Ardea purpurea (2+pairs), Anas acuta, Aythya nyroca (2+ pairs), Circus aeruginosus (3 pairs), Himantopus (22 pairs), Recurvorostra avosetta (725 pairs), Burhinus oedicnemus, Glareola pratincola (5 pairs), Gelochelidon nilotica (35 pairs; the only Bulgarian breeding locality), Sterna sandvicensis, S.Hirundo (90 pairs), S. albifrons (30+ pairs), and probably Todorna ferugineam, Porzana prozana, P. parva, and Chlidonias niger. An extremely important bottleneck site for migratory birds (averages for seasonal counts over five autumns unless stated) with Phalacrocorax nigra (2860), C.ciconia (135,800), Platalea leucorodia (autumn max 200), Pernis apivorus (3680), Circaetus gallicus (400), Aquila pomarina (5680), Grus grus (1790), Recurvirostra avosetta (autumn max, 7570), Larus melanocephalus (autumn max. 410000, L. genei (autumn max . 7570), Larus melanocephalus (autumn max. 4100), L. genei (autumn max. 1385), and Gelochelidon nilotica (1390). Yatata Reservoir (Varna) (10) 43°11'N, 27°42'E 154 ha Natural Monument. A former sedimentation reservoir near to Beloslav now covered with 7ypha latifolia and other emergent vegetation, and with areas of open water. Formerly connected with the Varna-Devnya Canal, and a reconnection with the canal has been recommended. Breeding species include Himantopus himantopus (\0pairs) and Recurvorostra avosetta (20 pairs). Consideration numbers of Pelecanus onocrotalus and Cinonia spp. Occur on spring and autumn passage. Other species include Todorna 23 ferruginea, Pernis apivorus, Milcus migrans, Circeatus gallicus, Circus aeruginosus, C.cyaneus, C.pygargus, Aquila polorina, and Hieraetus pennatus. Alepu Ezero (Buragas). (3) 42°22'N, 27°43'E 14 ha A brackish coastal marsh with Phragmites and Typha beds and two areas of open water, alongside a sandy beach o the Black Sea coast. There is the need for a buffer zone to separate a nearby tourist complex form the lake. Breeding species include Ixobrychus minutus, Ardea purpurea, and Aythya nyroca. During spring and autumn Phalacrocorax pygmeus (c.50), Pelecanus onocrotalus (thousands), and P.Crispus (a few) occur. Cape Kaliakra (Varan). (11) 43°20'N, 23°60 'E 688 ha. Nature Reserve. A coastal headland with vertical limestone cliffs and many caves, with relict steppe vegetation inland.Breeding species inlcude Phalcrocorax aristotelis desmarestii and Oenathe pleschanka and possibly Neophron percnopterus and Bubo bubo. The cape acts as a bottleneck for birds on autumn passage with many Phalacrocorax pygmeus, Pelecanus onocrotalus, Ciconia nigra, C.cicnonia, Pernis apivorus, Milvus migrans, Circus aeruginosus, c. cyaneus, C. pygargus, Accipiter brevipes, Butep rufinus, Aquila pomarina, and Hieraaetus pennatus pygargus, Accipiter brevipes, Buteo rufinus, Aquila pomarina, and Hieraarus pennarus occuring. Wintering species include reficollis (hundreds) and Oris tarda.(30+). Cape Emine (Burgas) (8) 42°20'N, 27°54'E 100 ha Unprotected. A coastal headland and the easternmost point of the Star Planina mountains. Rocky coast with vertical cliffs abd xerophytic vegetation and sparse stands of secondary Quercus Sp. A very important bottleneck site with very large numbers oaf birds occuring during autumn passage, including Pelecanus onocrotalus (c.10,000), Ciconia (c.1500), C.ciconia (100,000+), Pernis apivorus (c.2000), Milvus migrans (c.2000), Circaetus gallicus (c.3000, C. aeruginosus (1000, Aquila pomarina c.4000), and Grus grus (c.50000). Kamtchia Biosphere Reserve (Varna) (9) 42°02'N, 27°50'E 842 ha Nature Reserve. An area of remnant riverine forest at the mouth of the River Kamtchia, dominated by mature Fraximus oxyphylla and Quercus pedunculiflora, with marshes along the river bank. All economic activities are prohibited, but drainage and forestry plans have been proposed in the past. Breeding species include Egretta garsetta ( a small colony), Ciconia nigra, and Ficedula semitorquata. 3.2 Romania There are many wetlands along the Danube (Dunarea), which forms the southern border of the country and then flows north entering the Black sea via a huge delta (one of the least-developed major deltas in Europe). 24 Extensive drainage has been carried our, mainly in the Danube valley, since 1945. For example the extensive area of lakes and marshes between Braila and Hirsova, and the string of lakes between Hirsoba and Calarasi have been drained and converted to farmland. Furthermore, drainage has significantly reduced the size of Lake Suhai (Balta Suhaia) and lake Brates (Lacul Brates) near Galati. Lake Greaca (balta Greaca) and Lake Potelu (Balta Potelu) have now disappeared, and Lake Calarasi (Lacul Calarasi)has been converted to fish-ponds. In addition, a major programme to develop the Danube Delta is currently being implemented which aims to reclaim c.97,000 ha of the Delta, mainly for agriculture. By 1987, some 50,000 ha of agriculture land had been created. The loss of such wetland habitats has been partly compensated for by the construction of water reservoirs and fish-ponds. Theses newly created areas are important for passage of migrants and winter visitors, but not as breeding habitats (although, owing to their silting and to the development of aquatic vegetation, several have become suitable for breeding birds). Only a small portion of the (Danube) Delta is protected and much of it is threatened by a major reclamation programme. Of the other wetland sites included only two are protected. A number of lakes along the Danube, not listed in the inventory, are known to be ornithologically important including : Bistref, Suhaia, boianu, Calarasi, Bugeac (Girlita), Crapina, and Jijila. Delta Dunarii (Danube Delta) (24) and Razelm-Sinoie complex (Tulcea Constanta) (23). 44°25'-45°28'N, 28°45'-29°40'E 442,000 ha Biosphere Reserve (Rosca-Letea 18,145). Nature Reserves (Rosca-buhaiova-Hrecisca: 15,600 ha; Perisor- Zatoane-Sacalin: 15,400 ha; Periteasca-Gura Portitei:3900ha; Istria: 8000 ha; Popina: 90 ha; Saraturile:100 ha; Hasmacul Mare: 700 ha). The delta of the Danube (including Rivers Chilia, Sulina and Sfinty Gheorghe) and the Razelm-Sinoie complex (inlcuding Lakes Razelm, Sinoie, Zmeica, and Golovita). An extensive delta with numerous freshwater lakes interconnected by narrow channel with huge expanses of Phragmites, Scirpus and Typha. Most of the reedbeds grow on a floating mass of decaying vegetation (‘plaur'). Higher ground support stands of Salix, Populus, Alnus, and Quercus. The Razelm-Sinoie complex to the south consists of several large brackish lagoons separated from the sea by a sandbar. A major programme to develop the delta is currently being implemented. This involves the reclamation of c.97,000 ha of the Delta for irrigated agriculture crop of reed production , construction of fish-ponds and extension of forests. By 1987, some 50,000 ha of agricultural land had been created (with very poor agricultural production in places) and ecologically most important part of the delta (despite being considered totally unsuitable for agriculture by authorities both inside and outside Romania). Another project includes the re-routing of the River Sfintu-Gheorghe by cutting a straight canal through the numerous meanders, which will speed up the flow of water and radically alter the pattern of alluvial deposition. Over 160 species of birds breed, the most important being (1986 population estimates): Phalacrocoraz carbo sinensis (3000 pairs), P. pygmeus (2500 pairs; one of the most important sites in the world), Pelecanus onocrotalus (2500 pairs), P. crispus (estimated until recently at 150 pairs, perhaps now only 25-40 pairs), Nycticorax nycticorax (2100 pairs), Cygnus olor (500pairs), Haliaeetus albicilla (c.Spairs), Circus aeruginosus (300 + pairs), Pandion halieatus (3 pairs), Falco cherrug (1-2) pairs, F. vespertinus (150 pairs), Sterna and vicensis (1700 pairs), S. hirundo (20,000+ pairs), Chlidonias hubridus (20,000+ pairs), and C. niger (10,000-20,000 pairs). Oxyura leucocephala possibly still breeds. Numenius tenuirostris occurs on autumn passage (28 in 1971). In winter, huge numbers of Anaridae occur, including (counts from 191968 unless stated) Anser albifrons (500,000; 64,000-77,500 in1982), A. Erythropus (2 in 1982; other counts include max. 500), Branta ruficollis (25,000; 12,130 om 1982), Anas crecca (150,000), A. platyrynchos 9200,000, A. nyroca 913,000), and Mergus albells (1500 in 1982). Haliaeetus albicilla also occurs in winter (30-40 in 1969, but fewer since). Additional ornithological information is given for the following subsites. 7S Rosca-buhaiova-Hrecisca Nature Reserve. (Tulcea). (27) 45 22’N, 29°25°E. 15,600 ha. Nature reserve and part of the Rosca-Letea Biosphere Reserve. Extensive reedbeds and marshes, several shallow lakes (Poliacova, Argintiu, and Rosca) and narrow channels bordered by Salix. Almost unaltered by man owing to shallow water which renders access difficult. Breeding species include Phalacrocorax carbo sinensis, P. pygmeus, Pelecanus onocrotalus (2500 pairs), P. cripus (c.25 pairs), Botaurus stellaris, Ixobrychus minutus, Ardeola ralloides, Egretta alba, E. garzetta, A. purpurea, Plegadis falcinellus, Platalea leucorodia, Aythya nyroca, C. aeruginosus, porzana, P.parva, P.pusilla, Chlidonias hybridus, C. niger, and C.leucopterus. Perisor-Zatoane-Sacalin Nature Reserve (Tulcea) (22) 44 °SO’N, 29°25’E 15,400 ha. Nature Reserve. Lakes and ponds with wide reedbeds amongst parallel strips of sand dunes (‘grinduri’). Sacalin Island is made up of alluvial deposits with sand dunes and small patches of reed and Tamarix. Sacalin Island id adversely affected by illegal grazing (with the animals destroying the eggs and chicks) and the basin between the island and the mainland is silting up. Breeding species are similar to Rosca-Buhaiova- Hrecisca (except Pelecanus onocrotalus) including P.crispus (0-20 pairs). Additional breeding species inlcude Aquila pomarina, Grus grus, (2-3 pairs), Recurvirostra avosetta (10-40 pairs), Himantopus himantopus, Glareola pratincola, Tringa stagnatilis, Sterna sandviscensis (1200-2500), S. hirundo (1000 pairs; 15,000 pairs in 1968-1970), and S. albiforms (100 pairs). Sacalin Island is an important site for passage migrants. Haliaeetus albicilla (2-6) occurs in winter. Periteasca-Leahova-Gura Portitei Nature Reserve. (Tulcea) (21) 44°45’N; 29°05’ E 3900 ha Narrow sandy strips, reedbeds, marshes, ponds and shallow lakes, with an uninterrupted sandy strip along the coast . Fishing takes place, and there is a small tourist camp on the eastern edge. Breeding species are few, but include Tadorna feruginea (c.6 pairs on Popina Island) and several species of gulls and waders. An important feeding area for birds breeding in the delta and for migrants in spring and autumn. Large numbers f geese and ducks occur in autumn and winter (with important roosting and feeding areas near Sinoie and Sarinasuf villages) notably Anser albifrons.(64,000-77,500), Branta ruficollis (max. 25,000). And Mergus albellus (15,000). Lacul Istria , Lacul Nuntasi and southern Lacul Sinoie (Constanta). (20) 44°33°N, 28°44°E. 8000ha Unprotected except Istria Sanctuary. Three main lakes ( and other small ponds) with mud and sand shores , surrounded by steppe and agricultural land. Istria has emergent freshwater vegetation including Phragmites beds, The surrounding land is used for farming and grazing , Istria is used as a fish-pond, and there is a small health resort on the western shore of Nuntasi. The intensification of grazing and the inflow of fresh water (form irrigation schemes) are adversely affecting the area. Breeding species include Botaurus stellaris (6-8 pairs) Jxobrychus minutus (50-60 pairs), Himantpus himantopus (60 pairs), Recurvirostra avosetta (100 pairs). Important during spring and autumn passage with (seasonnal totals) Pelecanus onocrotalus (500 in spring; 2000 in autumn), P. crispus (320 in spring, 10 in autumn), Egretta garzetta (2000 in autumn), Ciconia nigra (10-15 in spring), Plegadis falcinellus (1000 in autumn), Platalea leucorodia (150 in spring; 300 in autumn), and Aythys nyroca (100 in spring). 26 Wintering species include Gavia arctica (50-100), Cygnus cygnus (2000), Anser erythropus (max. 500), Branta ruficollis (max. 5000), Haliaeetus albicilla (5-6) and Falco peregrinus (2-4 pairs). Padurea letea (Letea Forest) (Tulcea). (26) ATTN, 29°33? E5700 ha Partly included in Rosca_Letea Biosphere Reserve. Partly a Nature Reserve (Hasmacul Mare: 700 ha) A forest consisting mainly of Populus and Quercus with many mature trees; belt of trees (2-10 km long and 300-500 wide) alternate with strips of steppe vegetation and sand dunes. Land-uses include agriculture, grazing, and forestry. Problems include the replacement of open areas by plantations. A detailed ornithological study is required. Breeding species include Pernis apivorus (2-4 pairs), Haliaeetys albicilla (1 pair), Circaetus gallicus (1-2 pairs), Falco cherrug (1 pairs), Burhinus oedicnemus (4-6 pairs), Bubo Bubo (3-6 pairs), Caprimulgus europaeus (50 pairs), Coracias garrulus (20-30 pairs), Lanius collurio (150 pairs) and L. minor (120 pairs). Falco peregrinus (2-4) occurs in winter. Padurea Niculitel-Badadag (Niculitel and Babadag Forest) (Tulcea). (25) 45°00'N, 28°25'E c. 10,000 ha Unprotected. A hilly area (Niculitel Hills and Badadag Plateau) with deciduous woodland interspersed with grassland and steppe; the only forested area in the northern Dobrogea. There area extensive agricultural areas in the valleys, Land-uses include forestry, agriculture, grazing, and apiculture and there are some villages and roads. Forestry operations (felling and tree-planting) and cultivation of natural grasslands are having an adverse effect on the area. Of particular importance for breeding raptors with Circaetus gallicus (8-12 pairs), Accipiter brecipes, Buteo rufinus, Aquila heliaca (4-6 pairs), although several species area declining and Gyps fulvus and Aegypius manchus no longer breed. There are isolated relict populations of Dryocopus martius and Dendrocopos leucotos lilfordi, whilst other breeding species include Bubo bubo (8--10 pairs), and Emberiza hortulana (c.1000 pairs). Aquila pomarina (200) occurs on autumn passage. Lacul Tasaul (Constanta) (17) 44°21'N, 28°35'E 1830 ha A large, slightly brackish lake, supplied by the river Casimcea with barren shores and some marshes in the north-western corner. Human activities include fishing. The south-eastern part of the lake if affected by the Navodari industrial plant. There are little ornithological data and the breeding bird fauna has not been studied (but is likely to be poor). Breeding species documented in 1965 for roosting and feeding Jxobrychus minutus and Aythya nyroca. The lake is an important place for roosting and feeding passage migrants in spring and autumn. Passage species in autumn documented in 1970 included Recurvirostra avosetta (4-25), Philomachus pugnax (100-4000, Sterna caspia9220, Chhlidonias niger (35-130) and C. leucopterus (4-120. Wintering species area better known and counts have included Branta reficolis (4000), Anser albifrons (30000, and Aythya ferina (10,000). 27 Lacul Siutghiol (Constanta) (16) 44° 16'N, 28°36'E 2100 ha Unprotected. Formerly a marine lagoon now a freshwater lake separated from the sea by a narrow (200- 500m) sandbank. The shore is float at the eastern edge abrupt at the western edge. There are narrow belts of Phragmites, interrupted by sandy shores. The water freezes in winter. About half of the shore-line is covered by villages and holiday resorts (included Marmaia holiday resort) and there is some industry. IN summer tourism and aquatic sports cause some disturbance. Breeding species include Lxobrychus minutus and Aythya nyroca. The lake is particularly important for passage migrants and for oversummering immature birds. Larus melanocephalus (immatures) occur in summer, and passage species include Egretta garzetta, Ciconia ciconia, Chlidonias hybridus, C. Noger, and C. leucpterus. Wintering species include Podiceps cristatus (300), P. nigricollis (750, and Aythya ferina (2000). Lacul Techirghiol (Constanta) (15) 44°O1'N, 28°29'E 1170 ha. Unprotected. Formerly a coastal bay, now separated form the sea by a 200m wide sandbar. A saline lake, not freezing in winter with abrupt and barren shores except for marsh vegetation in the vicinity of several freshwater streams. There are bathing resorts which use the mud from the lake bottom (for therapeutic purposes) on the northern and eastern shores, A decrease in salinity has been recorded at the lake in recent years because of irrigation in the surrounding areas. Not important for breeding species except Tadorna todorna (6-8 pairs). Large numbers of Podiceps nigicollis (700-1000; max 5000-6000) and Larus minutus (1000-2000; max 21,000) occurin summer and early autumn. IN autumn an winter Oxyura leucocephala has been recorded (max. 218), together with many other migratory species. Padurea Hagieni ( Hagieni Forest) (Constanta) (14) 43°48'N,. 28°27'E 600ha. Forest Reseve and Notures Reserve (208ha) The most important woodland area remaining in southern Dobrogea; mainly Quercus on undulating ground interspersed with numerous small clearings and patches of wet grassland. The replacement of open areas by plantation, introduction of feral Phasianus chochicus and irrigation of the surrounding land are adversely affecting the area. Particularly important for breeding and passage passerines, Breeding species include Ixobrychus minutus (6 pairs), Aythya nyroca (4 Pairs), Pernis apicorus (1 pair), Circaetus gallicus (1 pair), Circus aeruginosus, Porzana porzana, P. pusilla, Crex crex (4- 6 pairs), Bubo bubo, Caprimulgus europaeus (15 pairs), Coracia garrulus, Dendrocopos syriacus (10 pairs), D. medius (5 pairs), Sylvia nisoria (8 pairs), Ficedula albicollis (8 pairs), Lanius colurio (50 pairs), L.minor (12 pairs), and Emberiza hortulana (30 pairs). Canaraua Fetii (Constanta) (19) 44°0S'N, 27°39'E. 550 ha A canyon with abrupt barren slopes and deciduous woodland and luxuriant herbaceous vegetation in the valley bottom. Some agriculture and grazing takes place in the canyon; also reafforestation. 28 Breeding species include Pernis apivorus (4 pairs), Neophron pernopterus (1 pairs), Circaettus gallicus (3-4 pairs), Buteo rufinus (2-4pairs) Aquila heliaca (2 pairs), Hieraaerus pennarus (4-6 pairs), Bubo bubo (2 pairs), Caprimulgus europaeus (40 pairs), Coraciasgarrulus (15 pairs), Dendrofoposmedius (6-8 pairs), Sylvia nisoria (5 pairs), Lanius collurio (50 pairs), L. minor, and Emberiza hortulana. Lacul Dunareni (Constanta) (18) 44°] 1'N, 27°46' E 600 ha Unprotected. A large shallow lake in the Danube valley with reedbeds and a few Salix trees along the shore. There are villages and roads along the eastern and southern shores; vineyards, pastures and some agricultural land along the northern and western shores. Human activities include reed-cutting and private fishing. The lake holds the most important Platalea leucorodia colony in Romania (60 pairs). Other breeding species include [xobrychus minutus, Plegadis falcinellus, Aythya nyroca, and Chlidonias niger. 3.3 Turkey In the Black Sea coastal zone and along the southern coast of the Sea of Marmara, there are forests of Quercus, Fagus, and Abies. The region includes the flood plain and delta of the Meric and the lakes of Manyas and Apolyont.Many of Turkey's wetlands have been altered by drainage/irrigation programmes, Larges parts of the majors deltas (Buyuk Menderes, Seyham, Ceyham, Kizilirmakm and Yesilirmak), have been converted to agricultural land, as have parts of many of the important wetlands, such as Sultansazligi. Furthermore, some sites have been completely drained, such as Amik Golu (which was once one of the most important wetlands in Turkey with breeding Anhinga melanogaster, Pelecanus onocrotalus, and Porphyrio porphyrio), Karagol, Avian Golum Sugla Golum and the Alanya wetlands. The wetlands of Turkey are of global importance of Phalacrocorax pygmeus, Pelecanus cripus (at least five breeding sites; very important numbers occurring in winter), Marmaronetta angustirostris, and Oxyura leucocephala (180+ pairs; max. 8990 at Burdu Golu in winter, the largest wintering concentration in the world). Turkey has the largest breeding populations of these two Anatidae in Europe. Other wetland species, which are threatened in an European context and have significant breeding populations in Turkey, include several species of Ardeidae, Plegadis falcinellus, Plataliea leucoradia, Phoenicopterus ruber (max. 5000 pairs in 1970 at Tuz Golu), Tadorna ferruginea, Pophyria porphyrio (20+pairs), Recurvirostra avosetta, Glareola pratincola, Hoplopterus spinosus, Larus genei, Gelochelifon nilotica, Sterna caspia, S. albifrons, Halcyon Smyrnensis, and Ceryle rudis- the last two kingfishers occur nowhere else in Europe and are at the north-westernmost limits of their ranges. Biiyiik Cekmece G6lti (Istanbul) 41°02'N, 28°323'E 1100ha Unprotected. A slightly saline lagoon connected to the Sea of Marmama, with reedbeds along the northern and western edge. Much of the lake is surrounded by agricultural fields, industrial areas, and human settlements. The lagoon has been deepened and enlarged to provide drinking water for Istanbul. Hunting pressure is extremely high. The lake holds large numbers of non-breeding waterfowl including Podiceps cristatus (max.880 ion March), Anser albifrons (max. 1000 in December), Anax clypeata (max. 980 in March), Aythya ferina (Max 2800 in Jan.), A. fuligula (max.2350 in March, and Fulica atra (max.24,000 in Oct). Large numbers of Larus melanocephalus (max. 3320) in autumn. 29 Bosphorus (Istanbul) (1) 41°00'N, 29°00'E Unprotected. The Bosphorus is a classic bottleneck area for migrants passing form Europe to the Middle East. Biiyiik and Kiigiik Camlica (two hills on the Asiatic side of the Bosphorus), Adalar (Prince Islands) in the Sea of Mamara, and Sanyer (the latter only during spring) are well-known observation points for migration, but principally all of the Bosphorus and its surroundings habe to be treated as past oaf the migration corridor. Bosphorus and its surroundings have to be treated aspast of ahte migraiton corridor. Studies covering the whole migrations season (or even a major part of it) are rare, so that data on phenology and population changes are only badly known. As the Bosphorus area is now more or less covered by the city of Istanbul, Hunting is no longer has probably affected the migration routes. The catching of birds of prey and passerines such as Carduelis carduelis is common in the surrounding countryside. The main migrants are ( the figures are the maximum numbers recorded of a single migration period since the beginning of the 1960s): Ciconia nigra (7200), C. ciconia (315,0000, Pernis apivorus (25,700) Milvus migrans (2600), Neophron percnopterus (550), Circaetus gallicus (2300), Accipiter brevipes (5300), Aquila pomarina (18,800), Hieraatus pennatus (520), and an impressive number of other rare species. Although exact figures area lacking, it has become evident that many species have decreased drastically, especially between 1870 and 1930. Terkos Gélii (Durusu G6lti or Durug6l) (Istanbul) (2) 41°19'N, 28°32'E 5850 ha A lake (2500 ha) of low salinity (originally a bay of the Black Sea, now connected only by a small channel), with some reedbeds along the shore. Between the lake and the seam large dunes with some woodland and scrub cover about 3350 ha. Prevailing winds blow sand into the lake (filing up 75,000-80,000 m’ of the lake each year). The lake provides much of Istanbul's drinking water and efforts to prevent infilling include afforestation of the dunes. Hunting is a great problem for the waterfowl. Pandion haliaetus, which bred at least in 1984, might still do so. Other species which are presumed to breed include Botaurus stellaris, Ixobrychus minutus, Nycticorax nycticorax, Ardeola ralloidem, Ardea purpuream, Circus aeruginosus, Burhinus oedicnemus, and Chlidonias leucopterus. There is no information on wintering geese and ducks. Situated north-west of the Bosphorus, Terkos Gdlii lies on a major migration route for raptors and storks, and thousands of birds pas over twice a year and some stop over to feed. Cam Burnu (ordu) (56) 41°07'N, 37°47'E. Less than 10 ha Unprotected. Rocky cliff and small offshore islands along the Black Sea Coast. A breeding site for Phlacrocorax (20-25 pairs), P. aristotlis (2-4 pairs), and Larus argentatus (300 pairs in 1973). Kackar Daglari (Artvin, Erzurum, Rize) (55) 40°35'-41°10'E, 40°42'-41°35'E c. 80,000 Partly a Hunting Reserve. A section of the eastern Black Sea mountain range, which includes the highest mountains of the Kackar massif: Demir Dagi(3354m), Ka¢kar Dagi (3932m), and Giil Dagi (3131m); geologically and biogeographically linked to the Caucasus in the USSR. There are extensive forests mainly of Abies nordmanni, Picea orientalis, and Fagus orientalis, with large areas of Rhododendron pontium on 30 the forest zone and R. caucasicum above the treeline. Above the treeline there are also mountain pastures (which are used by semi-nomadic people) and rubble fields. The are is only thinly populated. The mountains also support populations of Brown Bear Ursus oactos , Wild Goat Capra aegagrus and Caucasian Chamois Rupipra rupicapra. These mountains are the only known breeding area for Tetrao mlokosiewiczi in Europe outside the USSR. Its occurrence is known from at least two sites but it is presumably distributed over the whole mountain ridge. Other breeding species include Gypaetus barbatusm Gyps fulvus, Neophron pernopterus, Accipiter gentilis, Aquila chrysaetos, Hieraaetus pennatus, Tetraogallus caspius, and Grus grus (breeding at 2100m). Aegypius monachus and Falco peregrinus and presumed breeders. Other mountain species breeding include Phylloscopus sindianus lorensii, Sitta krueperi, Serinus pussilus, Rhodopechys sanguinea and Pyrrhocorax pyrrhocorax. Kizilirnmak Deltasi (Samsun) (58) 41°40'N, 36°00'E 50,000ha (lakes and marshes: c.5000ha) Hunting Reserve (Ceneck Gdlii only); only a rather small and unimportant part of the area is protected form hunting. The largest wetland along the Turkish Black Sea coast. Most of the land is under agricultural use; however, there are several lakes situated along the coast in the eastern delta, the largest of which are Balik Golii (2128 ha ), Uzungél (294 ha), Ceneck Gélii 9369 ha, and Liman GOlii (175 ha). Balik Gélii and Uzungél have extensive reedbeds, and vast areas of the delta are covered by almost inaccessible Scirpus beds. Between the lakes and the sea, a forest of about 1400 ha provides an excellent breeding habitat, especially for raptors. Breeding species include Pelecanus crispus (25 pairs in 1966, 60-70 pairs in 1970-1973; possibly now breeding only irregularly on smaller numbers), Botaurus stellaris (2-3+ pairs), Ixobrychus minutus, Ardeola ralloides (10+ pairs), Egretta garzetta (1230-150 pairs), Cicornia nigra (12-20 pairs), C. ciconia (30 pairs), Haliaeetus albicilla (2-4 pairs; but probalbly not breeding since 1977), Circus aeruginosus (30+ oaurs), Aquila pomarina (1 pairs presumed), Pandion haliaetus, Falco subbutei (12 p[airs), Anas querquedula (20 pairs), Aythya nyroca, Grus grus (10-15 pairs), Himantpous jimantopus 915 pair), Burhinus oedicnemus (8 pairs), Glareola pratincola, Denfrocpos medius, Acrocephalus melannopogon, and Sylvia nisoria. During autumn large numbers if 7ringa nebularia (max.2000) and Chlidonias leucopterus (max. 200-300) have been recorded. In winter large numbers of waterfowl occur including Gavia arctica (max. 1500, but usually less than 100), Podiceps nigricollis (max. 6000, Egretta alba (max. 100-200), Anser anser (max.50000, Anas strepera (max.740), A.crecca (max.16,750), A. platyrhynchos (max. 59), and Fulica atra (max.15,300). Important also for wintering raptors especially Aquila clanga and Circus aeruginosus (max. 30-50). North-East Turkey (Artvin, Rize) (54) 41°20N, 41°30'E_ c.100,000 Unprotected. North-east Turkey, especially the Black sea coastal region extending from Ardesen eastwards to the Soviet Border, is an area where huge numbers of raptors concentrate on migration, The main area is located on the northern side of the Kuseydogu Karadeniz Daglari (Pontic Mountains). The coastal strip is densely populated, with tea, corn, and hazelnuts being the main crops. Further inland the forests (both coniferous and deciduous) dominate and are considered to be amongst the most productive forest of Turkey. In the higher parts. Areas with alpine vegetation occur (cf. Kagkar Daglan as a separate site). Of special importance for migrating raptors is the Coruh Valley. Several other valleys extend from the Black Sea coast inland and cause considerable convergence of raptors. After raptors have passed the mountain range the migration front widens. 31 Yenigaga Gélii (Bolu) (62) 40°47'N, 32°02'E 1800 ha Unprotected. A freshwater lake with reedbeds which are dense in parts by almost absent along the southern shore, There are wet meadows to the east, northern and west of the lake which are flooded when the water- level is high and Populus plantation and Salix around the lake, The grazing of cattle in the marshes and pollution for the town of Yenigaga (which discharges its sewage into the lake) are serious problems. Breeding species include Ixobrychus minutus (1-5 pairs), Ardea purpurea (1-5 pairs), Tadorna ferruginea (5-10 pairs), Circus aeryginosus (1-2 pairs), and Grus grus (8 pairs). Haliaeetus albicilla and Pandion haliaetus presumably breed. During migration , the area is especially important for raptors which use the area for resting and feeding (as it lies on the migration route to and from the Bosphorus); 25 species of raptors have been recorded so far. Yesihrmak Deltasi (Samsun) (57) 41°17'N, 36°50'E 60,000 ha Hunting Reserve (Simenlik Gdélii); a small area is a breeding station for Phasianus colchicus. A large alluvial plain of the River Yesihrmak with a series of small lakes and lagoons along the coast. Recently, large parts of the delta have been drained and the lakes have been reduced in size. Simenlik Golii is the largest of the lakes (about 150 ha), has reedbeds, and its bordered by forest. Populus plantations and fields bordered by Salix characterise the delta. A native population of Phasianus colchichs has survived in the delta and has been enlarged by releases form a breeding station which is situated in the delta. Botaurus stellaris, Nycticorax nycticorax, Ardeola ralloides, Egretta grazetta, Circus aeruginosus, Grus grus, Himantopus himantopusm, and Locustella luscinioides are presumed to breed. Winter counts (1967-1970) have included Anas penelope (max. 2200), A.crecca (max.2500), A.platyrhynchos (max.12,000), A.acura (max. 900), and Aythya fuligula (max.2000). Sarikum G6lii (Sinop) (59) 42°01'N, 34°S1'E 100 ha Nature Reserve. A coastal lake, connected to the sea by a small river. On the south side of the lake there is a forest of Fraximus excelsior There is afforestation around the lake. The site is poorly known ornothologically. In Oct. 1987, c.100,000 birds were present at the iake including Podiceps cristatus, Tachybaptus ruficollis, Phalacrocorax carbo, Ardea cinerea, Egretta garzetta, E.alba, Anser albifrons, A.anser, Anasplatyrhynchos, Netta rufina, Aythya ferina, A.nyroca, A.fuligula, Fulica atra, and Vanellus vanellus. 3.4 Russia and Ukraine The major wetlands along the Caspian and Blakc Sea coast support veryu important breeding populations of waterfowl with very large breeding colonies of Ardeidae, and Laridae including Larus ichthyaetus, L.melanocephalus (a majority of the world's population) and L. genei. Other breeding species include Pelecanus crispus and Phalacrocorax pygneus. These wetlands also hold some of the largest concentrations of passage and wintering waterfowl in Europe. Ukrainian Steppe Reserve, Sumy, Donetsk, and Zaporozhe (Ukraina) ( 63 ) C.47°30'N, 36°30'E 1634 ha Zapovednik. Khomutoco steppe, 23 km north of the Sea of Azov (Azovskoye More); Kammenye mogili; Mikhaulovskaya tselina (virgin steppe). Species occurring include Botaurus stellaris, Ixobrychus minutus, Ardea purpurea, Milvus migrans, Falco vespertinus, Anthropoides virgo, Capromulgus europaeus, and Melanocorypha calandra. Krivaya Kosa (Krivaya Peninsula), Novoazovsk Donetsk (Ukraine) (46) 47°10'N, 38°10'E 154 ha Zapovednik. Peninsula in the Sea of Azov (Azovskoye More). Heavy recreational pressure and the planned building of fish-ponds may substantially affect the site. Breeding species include Egretta alba (max.10 pairs), Ardea purpurea (max. 10 palrs), Himantopus himantopus (50-80 pairs; the largest colony in the Ukraine), Recurvorostra avosetta (30-120 pairs), S.hirundo (1700-3000 pairs). Passage speices include Ciconia nigra, Branta ruficollis, Haliaeetus albicilla, Aquila chrysaetos, and Pandion haliaeetus. Belosarayskaya Kosa (Belosarayskaya Peninsula), Volodarskoye, Donetsk (Ukraina) (45) 47°00'N, 37°18'E 616 ha Zapvednik. Peninsula in the Sea of Azov (Azovskoye More) Breeding species include Egretta alba (8-20 pairs), Recurvirostra avosetta (12-35 pairs), Sterna hirundo (1600 pairs), and S. albfrons (500 pairs). Berdyanskaya Kosa (Berdyansk Peninsula), Berdyansk, Zhdanov (Ukraina) (44) 46°S0'N, 36°45'E Unprotected. Peninsula in the Sea of Azov (Azovskoye More) including the coastal shallows, low shores, and small islands of Obitochny Bay. A site for Egretta alba (50 pairs) , breeding ducks, waders, gulls, terns, and passage and wintering waterfowl. Molochny Liman, Melitopol (Ukraine) (61) 46°20'N, 35°20'E 22,450 ha Zapovednick. A salt-lake (with fluctuating salinity) separated from the Sea of Azov (Azovskoye More) by a narrow spit, with extensive shallows and a group of islands. Irregular water supply via a canal leads to seasonal fluctuations in salinity (resulting in destruction of the water vegetation) and the upper part of the lake is greatly polluted with sewage from Melitopol. A breeding site of Grebes, waders, gulls, and terns. Brabta ruficollis and Numenius tenuisrostris occur on passage, as well as large numbers of commoner waterfowl (max.30,000). Sivasj Zaliv, Azovskoye More (Sivash Bay, Sea of Azov) Ukraine (37) 46°09-46°12'N, 34°21'-34°50' E 45,000 ha Ramsar Site. Part of Azovskoye-Sivash Zapovednik Hunting Reserve (22,389 ha), although important sites for birds remain unprotected, and some parts are not included in the Ramsar site. A shallow, saltwater bay 33 with an indented shoreline, numerous spits and islands, largely isolated form the Sea of Azov by a low-lying spit (Arabatskaya Strelka). The water-level fluctuates according to the meteorological conditions (with strong winds exposing or inundating large areas) and the extend of evaporation in hot weather. A dam at Chongar Peninsula 9Chongarski Poluostrov) also regulates the water allowed in from the Sea of Azov. The habitat is mainly saltmarshes, steppe and halophytic vegetation with extensive Phragmites beds. Agricultural development in the surrounding area, especially the creation of fish-ponds and rice-fields, has increased the area of freshwater . There is little economic exploitation except for industrial fishing and slat extraction in the eastern part, however excessive disturbance results from amateur fishing (up to 900-1200 boats per day) and recreation, and there is egg collecting. In addition, the ploughing of virgin steppe, and haymaking and sheep grazing on Kuyuk-Tuk Ostrov) are considered to be unfavourable factors. Breeding birds include Ardeidae and Threskiornithidae (at least 10,000-11,000 pairs of MNycticoraz nycticorax, Ardeola ralloides, Egretta garzetta, E. alba, Ardea purpurea, and Kuyuk-Tuk and Churyuk islands, and additional pairs on the mainland), Otis tarda (2-3pairs), Recurvirostra avosetta (700 pairs), Larus ichthyaetus (96-168 pairs), S. sandvicensis (483-5463), S. hirumdo (97-1030) and S. albifrons (70-900 pairs). There are additional colonies of Larus melanocephalus , L. genei, Gelochelidon nilotica, Sterna sandvicensis with up to 20,000 pairs. In spring, up to 1000 Otis tarda (2-3pairs) occur on Kuyuk-Tuk. The bay serves as an important staging post for waterfowl, especially spring with up to 60,000-80,000 ducks (predominantly Aythya fulifula, A. ferina, Tadorna tadorna, and Anas platurhynchos) and Fulica atra, and hundreds of thousands of waders (predominantly Philomachus pugnax, Cakidirs ferruginea, C.alpina, and Tringa totanus) with the steppe parts of Churyuk and Kuyuk-Tuk islands used by Charadrius morinellus. Krymski (Crimean) Game Reserve, Krym (Ukraine) (41) 44°50'N, 34°30'E 42,957 ha Zapovednik (14,998 ha) The northern and southern slopes of the main Crimean range, including Quercus- Pinus-Fagus forest (27,957 ha), rivers (total area of open water approaches 10,000 ha), meadows (over2400 ha), and a coastal zone including the Lebyazhi Islands. One hundred and eighty-five species occur (72 breeding), including Gavia arctica, Egratta alba (rare), Ciconia nigra (rare), Aythya nyroca, other Anatidae, Haliaeetus albacilla, Neophron percnopterus, Gyps fulvus, Aegypius monachus, Circaetus gallicus, and Bubo bubo. Karkinitsky Zaliv, Chernoye More (Karkinitsky Bay, Black Sea) (Ukraine) (38) 45°30'N, 34°30'E 42, 957 ha Zapovednik (14,998 ha) Part of Crimean Zapovednik.Hunting Reserve ; Karkinitsk Zakaznik (27,646 ha); the sea around the islands is protected to a distance oaf 1km offshore. The head of Karkinitski Bay with numerous spits, shallow bays and salt lakes adjoining areas of virgin steppe and agricultural land. There are some small; permanent islands (Lebyaszhim Ostrova) which are either vegetationless or covered by Phragmites beds and saltmarsh, although the total area of the islands has been reduced by erosion. The shallows are rich in submerged vegetaion primarily Characeae and Zostera. The development of fish-farming and rice-growing has resulted in the uncontrolled release of fresh water adversely affecting the productivity of the Characeae and Zostera. In addition, the shooting and scaring of fish-eating birds, rice growing , sheep-grazing, tourism (resulting in severe disturbance) are adversely affecting the wetland and its birds, and the movement of vehicles is destroying the remnant steppe. The site is regarded has inadequately protected with no control on poaching. As a results of these problems many species are declining. Breeding species include Phalacrocorax carbo (500-600 pairs), Ardeola ralloides (max. 200 pairs), Larus ichthyaetus (120-130 pairs), L. argentatus (6800-10,000 pairs), Gelochelifon nilotica (800-900 pairs). Large numbers of Cygnus olor (4000-5000) moult. Anatidae occur during spring and autumn migration (max. 34 75,0000abd several hundred thousand Philomachus pugnax occur. In winter more than 20,000 duck may be present. Yalta Mountain Forest, Bolshaya Yalta, Krym (Ukraina) (40) 44°30'N, 34°10'E 14,591ha Zapovednik. A band of forest (1-8 km wide), with stands of Pinus, Quercus, Fagus, and Carpinus on the southern slopes of the Crimean range. Species occurring include Gyps fulvus. Mys Martyan, Krym (Ukraine) (39) 44°30'N, 34°09'E 240 ha Zapovednik. An area of Quercus and Juniperus forest on the southern slopes of the Crimean Mountain , on the Black Sea coast. One hundred and thirty five species occur, including Phalacrocorax aristotelis. Chumaki Ostrova, Dzarylgachski Zaliv (Chumaki Islands, Dzharylgach Bay), Skadovsk and Kakanchak, Kherson (Ukraina) (35) 46°00'N, 32°55'E Unprotected. Small islands and coastal shallows in a bay of the Black Sea (Chernoye More). The islands are experiencing excessive recreational pressure and it is necessary to establish a seasonal Zajaznik. Breeding birds include ducks (hundreds) and gulls (thousands). Hundreds of thousands of wildfowl occur during migration including Branta ruficollis (20,0000) Nizovya Dnepra (Lower Dnepr), Golaya Pristanm Kherson (Ukraine) (31) 46°30'N, 32°20'E Unprotected , proposed Zakaznik. Water channels, Phragmites beds, and marshy islands. Breeding birds include grebes (hundreds) and Ciconiiformes (thousands). A passage site for Anser anser (thousands) and dabbling ducks (thousands). Askania -Nova. Kherson (Ukraine) (36) 46°27'N, '33°53'E 33,307 ha Biosphere Reserve Zapovednik (only 1500ha under total protection) An area of arid (except for a few lakes) Festuca-Stipa steppe. The totally protected area has never been ploughed, whilst the remainder is used for grazing and Haymaking. Sixteen species breed in the virgin steppe area, including Circus macrourus, Aquila rapax, nipalensis,. Anthropoides virgo, Tetrax tetrax, Oti tarda, Burhinus oedicnemus, Calandrella brachydactyla, nad Anthus campestris. The lakes and pond are hold c.70 breeding species, including Tadorna ferruginea, Circus macrourus, and Lanius minor. 35 Dunay (Danube) and Yagorlytski and Tendrovski Zalivy (Yagorlystki and Tendra Bays) (Ukraina) Dunay (Danube) (29) 45°25'-45°30'N, 29°32'-29°40'E 14,851 ha The Soviet part of the Danube Delta with alluvial islands, numerous channels and a coastal zone (with shallow, open bays divided from the sea by low sand-spits or underwater bars). The islands are covered with dense Phragmites beds or with Salix alba woodland. At present there are no protected zones where human activities area completely prohibited, and the main problem is human disturbance since commercial fishing is permitted throughout the year and the best fishing areas are the same as the main breeding , feeding and resting sites for birds. Breeding species include Nycticorax nycticorax (350 pairs), Ardeola ralloides (50 pairs), Egretta garzetta (150 pairs), &. alba (40 pairs), Ardea purpurea (400 pairs), Plegadis falcinellus (100 pairs), Platalea leucorodia (60 pairs), Recurvirostra avosetta (100 pairs), Sterna sandvicensis (2000 pairs) , S. hirundo (10,000-11,000 pairs), and S.albifrons (50 pairs). Pelecanus onocrotalus and P. cripus feed at the site breeding in the Romanian part of the delta. Non breeding Philomachus pugnax and Limosa limosa oversummer occurs on passage, the following being common; Palacrocorax pygmeus, Branta ruficollis, and Sterna caspia. Up to 50,000 waterfowl occur in winter including Cygnus cygnus (max. 1000). Anser albifrons (10,000) and A. anser (3000). Yagorlytski and Tendrovski Zalivy ( yagorlytski and Tendra Bays) (Ukraine) (29, 33) 46°07'-46°30'N, 31°49'-32°22"E 113,200 ha Part of a Ramsar Site (with Dunay); Biosphere Reserve (87,348 ha) Includes land areas of Chernomorski (Black Sea) Xapovednik and Yaforlytski/Tendrovki Xalivi islands Zapovednik (total area: 10,448 ha); Yagorlytski (30,300 ha) Large sea bays (separated from the Black Sea by a narrow peninsula) with islands, adjoined by numerous small lakes and temporary waterbodies. Emergent vegetation is represented by beds of Phragmites, Typha, and Scirpus, with the bays surrounded by salt-meadow /steppe and forest-steppe. On the islands, halophytic vegetation is dominant. Since 1975, the hydrological balance has been upset affecting the productivity of the ecosystem) by the release of fresh water from irrigation and rice growing scheme, and saline water form a drainage system near Poliyevka. In addition , there is disturbance during the breeding seas on from commercial fishing. Breeding species include Podiceps grisegena, Botaurus stellaris (common), Jxobrychus minutus, Egrettaalba (common). Tiliguliski Liman (Tiligul Salt -Lake), Berezanka and Kominternovskoye (Ukraine) (32) 46°S0'N, 31°00'E Unprotected. Shallow salt-lake with Phragmites beds and sandy islands. Breeding species include Recurvirostra avosetta (200 pairs). Up to 80,000 wintering waterfowl occur. Nizovya Dnestra (Lower Dnestr), Belgorod-Dnestrovski and Ovidiopol (Ukraine) (31) 46°15'N, 30°20'E Unprotected; proposed Zapovednik. Salt-lakes and Phragmites beds. Breeding birds include Phalcrocoracidea (220 pairs) , Ciconiiformes (3500 pairs), Cygnus olor (170 pairs), Anser anser 91600 pairs), and ducks (max. 10,000 pairs). 36 Coastal lakes between the Rivers Dnestr and Dunay (Danube), Kiliya, Tatartbunary, and Belgorog- Dnestrovski (Ukraine) (30) 45°40'N, 30°00'E 200,000 ha Unprotected. Salt-lakes , canals, and reservoirs. It is necessary to determine the most important areas. Breeding species include Tadorna tadorna (500 pairs). Very important for winter waterfowl (500,000), including swans (10,000). Other wintering species include Haliaeetus albicilla (50). Karadag, Sudag, Krymskaya (Crimean) Oblast (Ukraine) (42) 45°00'N,. 35°15 'E 1370 ha Zapovendnik. Includes 188 ha of forest 300 ha of meadows, and 600 ha of adjacent sea. One hundred and ten species occur, including Pernis apivorus, Aquila heliaca, Falco cherrug, F.peregrinus, and Alectoris chukar. Salt-Lakes (Limany) in the Primorsko-Akhtarsk/Grivenskaya area (including Akhtarski Liman and Liman Sladki) (Krasnodes Kray, RSFSR) (60) 46°00'N, 38°00'E 118,340 ha Partly a Zakaznik. Shallow salt-lakes connected by a dense network of channels alongside the Sea of Azov (Azovskoye More), with extensive beds of emergent and submerged vegetation. The development of irrigated agriculture is reducing the area of the wetland and the lakes are becoming shallower and more saline,, whilst chemical run-off from farmland is causing eutrophication of the water bodies. If the degradation of the area is halted, It will be proposed for designation as a Ramsar site. A breeding site for pelicans, herons, and other waterfowl, with Cygnus olor 932000, Anser anser (5000), ducks (648,000), and Fulica atra (460,000) present after breeding. Important for moulting ducks (600,000-1,000,000) and wintering waterfowl (hundreds of thousands). Kavzkav (Caucasus) Biosphere Reserve, Sochi (Krasnodar Kray, RSFSR) (48) 43°40'N, 40°30'E 266,000 ha Biosphere Reserve Zapovednik. The western part of the Main Caucasian Ridge and Peredovoy Ridge, with forested (162,319 ha) mountainous terrain including many glacier-fed rivers and streams. Also includes the southeast slope of Boshoi Akhun Mountain. One hundred and ninety-two species occur (132 breeding), including Gypaetus barbatus, Gyps fulvus, Aegyptius monachus, Aquila chrysaetos, Tetrao mlokosiewiczi, and Tetraogallus caucasicus. Nizovya Reki Rioni, Ozero Paliastomi (lower Rioni, Lke Paliastomi) (Gruziya) (52) 42°10'N, 41°40'E 500 ha Zapovednik. Coastal marshes, channels, and lakes on the Black Sea (Chernoye More) coast. A site for passage and wintering Ciconiiformes, ducks, and waders. There is also a bottleneck site for raptors in this region. 37 Pskhuski, Abkhazskaya ASSR (Gruziya) (51) 43°25'N, 40°50'E 27,643 ha Zapovednik. An area of the Bzybski range, between the Black Sea and the caucasus, with forest (12,600 ha). meadows 980 ha), sands (7 ha), steep slopes, screes, cliffs, and open water. The principal tree species are Fagus, Castanea, Carpinus, Quercus, Abies, and Rhododendron. Species occurring include Gypaetus barbatus, Gyps fulvus, Aegypius monachus, Aquila chrysatos, Tetrao mlokosiewiczi, and Tetrogallus caucasicus. Guminstin, Sukhumi, Abkhazaskaya ASSR (Gruziya) (50) 43°20'N, 40°40'E 27, 643 ha Zapovednik. An area of the Bzybki range, between the Black Sea and the Caucasus, with forest (12,600 ha), Meadow (80 ha), sands (7 ha), steep slopes, screes, cliffs, and open water. The principle tree species are Fagus, Castanea, Carpinus, Quercus, Abies, and Rhododendron. Species occurring include Tefrao mlokosiewiczi. Ritsa, Gudauta, Abkhazskaya ASSR (Gruziya) (49) 43°28'N, 40°34'E 16,289 ha Zapovenik. An area of Abies forest surrounding Lake Ritsa on the southern spurs of the main Caucasus range. Forest covers 14,922 ha. There are also small areas of meadows, and deep river gorges. Species occurring include Gypaetus barbatus, Gyps fulvus, Aegypius monachus, Aquila chrysaetos, Tetrao mlokisiewiczi and Tetraogallus caucasicus. Kintrishi, kobuleti, Adzharskaya ASSR (Gruziya) (53) 41°45'N, 41°SO'E 7166 ha Zapovdnik. An are of the west and north-west slopes of the Meskletsk range, with over 6500 ha of forest, subalpine lakes, and the gorge of the River Kintrishi. Species include Tetraogallus causasicus. Key reference for this section: International Council for Bird Preservation, 1989. Important Bird Areas of Europe. Compiled by R.F.A. Grimmett and T.A. Jones, 886pp. 38 4. COASTAL PROTECTED AREAS OF THE BLACK SEA 4.1 Introduction Information on protected areas of the Black Sea was gathered from the six coastal countries: Bulgaria, Georgia, Romania, Russian Federation, Turkey and Ukraine. The main sources of information were the WCMC Protected Areas & Landscape Database (PAL), the WCMC Biodiversity Map Library (BML) and regional publications on protected areas held at WCMC. This information has been arranged in four sections: 1. A list of nationally designated protected areas, by country, for those sites located within 50 miles of the coastline. Comments on idividual protected areas are provided. 2. A list of internationally designated sites (Ramsar Convention, World Heritage Convention, MAB/UNESCO Programme and others). Where there is overlap between nationally and internationally designated sites this is indicated. 3. Detailed descriptive information (‘site sheets’) on some protected areas, where this is available. The extent of the information available varies but may include [UCN management category, biogeographical province, geographical location, date and history of establishment, area, land tenure, altitude, physical features, climate, vegetation, management constraints, staff, budget, local addresses and references. 4. Information on existing national environmental legislation, designations of protected areas, system reviews and international cooperation presented in country profiles. Some information on protected areas is stored electronically but was derived from published regional reports and maps held at WCMC For example, the information on protected areas in Ukraine and Russian zakaznik was gathered from a map of protected areas published in the Ukraine in 1977. The internet is another valuable source of information especially in the case of Georgia. It provides a very detailed information on all designations of protected areas in this country and internationally designated and proposed sites. Information about Russian zakazniks (nature sanctuaries') was only available from a source published in 1985. 4.2 Information Gaps Bulgaria WCMC has information on the boundaries for less than half of. the protected areas in Bulgaria — the remainder are indicated only as dots. It may be possible to rectify this somewhat by referring to information on existing digital data in Bulgaria published in 1994 in the National Biological Diversity Conservation Strategy’. Site sheets should be compiled for the twelve national and five international reserves for which they are lacking: this would require approximately 2-3 person days per site or 50 days in total ' This designation has two levels of importancy: national and local. Last one may have a permanent status or may be protected for a limited period of 10, 25 years these terms are subjects to be prolonged if necessary. In fact this designation includes several types of protected areas deducated to protect landscapes, habitats of plants and animals, geological formations, hydrological objects, some times they have a status of hunting reserves. ? National Biological Diversity Conservation Strategy. Biodiversity Support Program, Washington, DC. 1994. P.39. 39 Georgia All identified protected areas are in PAL and BML databases and on BML, but not as a polygonal data (ie they are entered as dots not polygons). Polygonal data exists on Georgian Web site and consists of very valuable and detailed information. It also includes data on important wetlands in this country’. It is unknown how many days will be needed to enter digital data for Georgia. Compiling site sheets for Georgian nature reserves would require 8-12 days for 4 protected areas. It is unknown how many other designations occurred within the coastal line (e.g. National Parks, nature sanctuaries or former zakazniks) because of lack of information. A search for this information will probably require some 3 days of work with further compiling of site sheets. Romania Nature reserve is most important designation in terms of nature protection in Romania but site sheets are not completed for all of them. It will take up to 48-72 days to compile sheets for 24 nature reserves. Russia Identified protected areas located on territories of Krasnodar Kray (Territory), Kabardino-Balkar Republic, these are National Parks and Zapovedniks. Several zakazniks in these two administrative territories were identified through published sources. Zakazniks should be identified for Rostov Oblast’ (Region) an administrative territory on shores of the Sea of Azov. Turkey It may take approximately 10-15 days to compile site sheets for 5 protected areas in Turkey although the lack of information on protected areas in Turkey may mean more time would be required. Ukraine Before data from the Ukraine can be included in maps it must be incorporated into the digital databases (BML): this would take about 5 days. Site sheets should be written for Nature Reserves (Zapovedniks), a major designation in this country. It will take approximately 12-18 days of work for 6 sites. WCMC do not have complete country profiles for Georgia and Russian Federation : it would take about 3 days for each country to compile these. 3 See Web: http://www.grida.no/prog/cee/enrin/htmls/georgia/soegeor/english/wetlands/wetlands. htm 40 Nationally designated coastal protected areas Country, designation and IUCN Area Year of a site name Category Long/Lat (ha) establishment Bulgaria National Park Strandja** Vv 42°03'N/27°38'E 116,260 1995 Zlatni pyassatsi** IV 43°20'N/28°02'E 1,320 1943 Comment: Internationally important resort area. Protected Site Silistar** IV 2/9 773 ® Comment: Wetland of national importance at the mouth of the river Silistar. The number of species from the Red Data Book of Bulgaria reached 46. Ustie of Veleka*” IV 2/? 1,511 2 Comment: Wetland of national importance at the mouth of the river Veleka. The number of species from the Red Data Book of Bulgaria reached 46. Veleka*® IV 2/2 1,546 2 Comment: Wetland of national importance at the mouth of the river Veleka. The number of species from the Red Data Book of Bulgaria reached 46. Reserve Arkoutino*’ la 2/2 102 1975 Comment: Wetland of international importance, an important bird area in Europe (see below Bulgarian Ramsar sites: Arkoutino (Ropotamo). Amzovo* la 2/2 1 1968 Atanasovsko ozero** IV 42°33'N/27°32'E 1,650 1980 Comment: Wetland of international importance, an important bird area in Europe (see below Bulgarian Ramsar sites: Burgas Lakes). 4 Ministry of Environment of Bulgaria. National action plan for the conservation of the most important wetlands in Bulgaria. Sofia. 1995. P.8. > Ministry of Environment of Bulgaria. National action plan for the conservation of the most important wetlands in Bulgaria. Sofia. 1995. P.8,54. § Ministry of Environment of Bulgaria. National action plan for the conservation of the most important wetlands in Bulgaria. Sofia. 1995. P.8,54. 7 Ministry of Environment of Bulgaria. National action plan for the conservation of the most important wetlands in Bulgaria. Sofia. 1995. P.8. 4] Baltata* la 2/2? 198 1962 Kaliakra* la 2/9 53 1941 Kamtchia**® IV 43°02'N/27°5 1'E 1,445 1951 Comment: The reserve includes the remains of forests which once covered a large area of 5,000ha. This flood forest dominated by Fraxinus oxyphylla and Querces pedunculiflora, etc. There are marshes and rushes along the river banks. There is a variety of terrestrial and aquatic animals. Mammals include deer Capreolus capreolus, wild boar Sus scrofa, pine marten Martes martes and fox Vulpes vulpes. Over 20 species of fish live in the river. This reserve is a part of UNESCO/Man and Biosphere Program area which cover also adjacent populated areas (see below the list of sites under UNESCO/MAB program in Bulgaria). Morski Peline* la 2/2? 14 1962 Ouzounboudjak**? la 41°59'N/27°54'E DEST 1956 Comment: The reserve was set up to preserve the oak Quercus polycarpa and Q. frainetto and beech Fagus orientalis forests which are over 200 years old. This reserve is a part of UNESCO/Man and Biosphere Program area which cover also adjacent populated areas (see below the list of sites under UNESCO/MAB program in Bulgaria). Piassatchnata Lilia* la ?/? 1 1962 Ropotamo** la 42°19'N/27°46'E 1,001 1992 Comment: Wetland of international importance, an important bird area in Europe (see below Bulgarian Ramsar sites: Arkoutino (Ropotamo). Silikossa* la 2/2 390 1931 Tissovitsa** IV 42°06'N/27°46'E 749 1990 Vitanovo** la 42°02'N/27°36'E 1,112 1982 Vodnite Lilii (Velkov Vir)* la 2/9 14 1962 Zmiyskia Ostrov* la ?/? 1 1962 Georgia Nature Reserve Bichvinta-Miusera** la 43°11'N/40°25'E 3,645 1965 Kintrishi** la 41°41'N/41°59'E 13,893 1959 Kolkheti** la 42°10'N/41°48'E 500 1946 Pskhu-Gumista** la 43°13'N/41°05'E 40,819 1976 Ritsa** la 43°27'N/40°34'E 16,288 1957 Romania Biosphere Reserve (National) Danube Delta** I 44°56'N/28°56'E 580,000 199] 5 MAB Information System. Compilation 4, October 1986. IUCN. Pp.71-73. ° MAB Information System. Compilation 4, October 1986. IUCN. Pp.76-77. 42 Forest Reserve Letea** Nature Reserve Capul Dolosman** Carorman** Erenciuc** Grindul Chituc** Grindul Lupilor** Istria-Sinoe** Letea** Luncavita Forest (Valea Fagilor)* Manusoaia-Chiciu Plopii** Murighiol** Nebunu** Padurea-Letea** Perisor-Zatoane-Sacalin** Periteasca-Bisericuta-Portita** Periteasca-Gura Portita** Popina Is.** Raducu** Rosca-Buhaiova-Hrecisca** Rosca-Letea** Rotundu** Sahalin-Zatoane** Saraturi-Murighiol** Sfintu Gheorghe-Perisor-Palade** Vatafu-Lungulet** Russia National Park Sochinskiy ** Zakaznik : 10 Golovinsky *** Comment: Protection of common deer, European roe deer, Priazovskiy ***"' IV IV 45°20'N/29°28'E 44°45'N/28°SS'E 45°04'N/29°24'E 44°58'N/29°25'E 44°33'N/28°S4'E 44°40'N/28°S5'E 44°3 1'N/28°46'E 45°19'N/29°3 1'E 45°30'N/28°06'E 45°00'N/28°10'E 45°16'N/29°36'E 45°16'N/28°S8'E 45°20'N/29°32'E 44°5 1'N/29°24'E 44°43'N/29°01'E 44°44'N/29°02'E 44°58'N/28°58'E 45°15'N/29°16'E 45°22'N/29°25'E 45°20'N/29°30'E 45°13'N/28°3 1'E 44°49'N/29°25'E 45°01'N/29°09'E 44°50'N/29°20'E 45°07'N/29°34'E 43°35'N/40°10'E Ue wild pig, chamois, brown bear, 2/? Comment: Wild pig, American mink, badger, lynx, swans, great bustard. Nature Reserve (Zapovednik) Kavkazskiy** Teberdinskiy** 43°3 1'N/39°52'E 43°21'N/41°42'E '0 Shalybkov, A., Storchevoy, K. Prirodnie zakazniki.Moscow. 1985.P.95. "! Shalybkov, A., Storchevoy, K. Prirodnie zakazniki.Moscow. 1985.P.95. 43 701 600 115 55212 16,400 4,125 3,900 98 2,500 14,600 16,400 230 24,250 87 15,000 1,625 189,600 50,000 e' = Cc. 45,000 280,335 84,996 1938 1983 1968 1958 1924 1936 Turkey National Park Ilgaz Dagi** Macka Altindere Vadisi** Yedigoller** Natural Monument Duzce-Samandere** Nature Park Uzungol** Nature Reserve Haciosman** Sarikum Golu** Protected Landscape Kackar Mountains** Ukraine Hunting Reserve Azovo-Sivashskoye** Krymskoye** Zalesskoye National Biosphere Reserve Askaniya Nova** Chernomorskiy** National Nature Park Azovo-Sivashskiy* Natural Monument Agarmushskiy Les** Balka Gor’kaya***"* Belbekskiy Kanyon***"* Dzhautepe Hill***'° Gora Mangypkale***'° Granitnie Skaly***!” Kamennie Mogily***'® 9 Karadag***! «12 '2 Map of Protected Areas of Ukraine, '3 Map of Protected Areas of Ukraine, 'S Map of Protected Areas of Ukraine, 'S Map of Protected Areas of Ukraine, '© Map of Protected Areas of Ukraine, '7 Map of Protected Areas of Ukraine, '8 Map of Protected Areas of Ukraine, '9 Map of Protected Areas of Ukraine, Kiev, Kiev, Kiev, Kiev, Kiev, Kiev, Kiev, Kiev, ll Il 1977. 1977. 1977. 1977. 1977. 1977. 1977. 1977. 41°02'N/33°32'E 40°50'N/39°43'E 41°15'N/31°40'E 40°51'N/31°09'E 40°56'N/38°00'E 41°20'N/36°20'E 42°01'N/34°51'E 41°00'N/41°30'E 46°13'N/35°12'E 44°45'N/34°18'E 50°45'N/30°45'E 45°32'N/33°57'E 45°43'N/31°54'E 46°13'N/35°12'E 2/2 ?/? 2/2 2/? 2/2 2/2 2/2 2/2 44 4,142 57,430 42,957 35,089 33,307 87,343 52,154 1976 1987 1965 1988 1989 1957 1957 1957 1921 1927 1993 1963 1972 1963 1964 1963 1968 1968 1964 Comment: Territory of volcanic eruptions of Jurassic period. There are a number of rare and endemic species of flora and fauna in the site. Karauloba***”° Ill 2/9 100 1964 Krasnie Peshery***”! I 2/2 10 1947 Novokaterinovskoe Denudation***~ Ill 2/9 10 Odesske katakombi***7> Ill 2/9 1 1963 Comment: The underground system of karst caves. Soldatskaya Peshera***” Il 2/2 10 1963 Comment: Carst Cave Styl’skoe Denudation***”° ll 2/9 25 1972 Zakaznik Altagirskiy*** IV 2/2 1,100 1968 Astaninskie Plavni***”° IV 2/? 50 1964 Arabatskiy***”” IV 2/9 600 1964 Ayudag***”* IV 2/9 527 1964 Bakaiskiy***”” IV 2/2 420 1964 Bolshoy Kanyon of Crimea****” IV 2/2 300 1947 Comment: Biggest canyon of the Crimea Peninsula with several waterfall and a relic plants listed in the Red Data Book of the former USSR. Berdyanskiy***"! IV 2/2 413 1963 Berezovie Kolki***” IV 2/2 1,312 1967 Chernaya Rechka***** IV 2/? 150 1947 Dalnitskiy***™* IV 2/2 1,204 1970 Dzharylgachskiy**** IV 2/? 300 1964 Comment: Area of a habitat of a rare crop plant zolotoborodnik tsikadoviy. Kachinskiy Kanyon****° IV 2/? 100 1964 20 Map of Protected Areas of Ukraine, Kiev, 1977. 2! Map of Protected Areas of Ukraine, Kiev, 1977. 22 Map of Protected Areas of Ukraine, Kiev, 1977. 23 Map of Protected Areas of Ukraine, Kiev, 1977. 24 Map of Protected Areas of Ukraine, Kiev, 1977. 25 Map of Protected Areas of Ukraine, Kiev, 1977. 26 Map of Protected Areas of Ukraine, Kiev, 1977. 27 Map of Protected Areas of Ukraine, Kiev, 1977. 28 Map of Protected Areas of Ukraine, Kiev, 1977. 2° Map of Protected Areas of Ukraine, Kiev, 1977. 3° Map of Protected Areas of Ukraine, Kiev, 1977. 3! Map of Protected Areas of Ukraine, Kiev, 1977. 32 Map of Protected Areas of Ukraine, Kiev, 1977. 33 Map of Protected Areas of Ukraine, Kiev, 1977. 34 Map of Protected Areas of Ukraine, Kiev, 1977. 35 Map of Protected Areas of Ukraine, Kiev, 1977. 45 Karabi-Yailinskaya Kotlovina***” IV 2/2 32 Karasubashi***** IV 2/9 24 1963 Khapkhalskiy****? IV 2/2 250 1964 Comment: Khapkhalskiy Gorge with one of the biggest waterfalls in Crimea called Dzhurdzhur and old growth oak forest. Kosaya Strelka****° IV 2/9 144 1971 Molochniy Liman***"! IV Wr 19,000 1968 Noviy Svet***” IV 9 470 1964 Comment: Coastal area with a relic species of Stankevich pine listed in the Red Data Book of the USSR. Petrovskiy***" IV 2/? 340 1960 Radivonovskiy***"4 IV 2/9 400 1968 Razdol’nenskiy****° IV 2/2 100 1972 Staroberdyanskiy*** IV 2/2 1,000 1968 Velikoanadol’ skiy****° IV 2/9 2,543 1960 Comment: Forest massif artificially planted in 1843. Yagorlitskiy***”” IV 2/? 30,300 1972 Comment: Protection of wintering places of waterfowls, including swans in the Yagorlik Gulf. Nature Reserve (Zapovednik) Dunaiskie Plavni* la 49°40'N/31°20'E 14,851 1981 Karadagskiy** la 45°00'N/35°00'E 2,874 1979 Krimskiy** la 44°28'N/34°10'E 44,175 1991 Mys Martiyan**** la 43°30'N/34°16'E 240 1973 Comment: Marine-terrestrial area of the Black Sea with a relic forests of juniper trees of Mediterranean flora. Ukrainskiy Stepnoy** la 47°16'N/37° 10'E 2,756 1961 Yaltinskiy Gorno-Lesnoy**” la 44°20'N/34°10'E 14,521 1973 Comment: Territory of biological complexes of the Main Crimean Mountain ridge and many natural monuments. 36 Map of Protected Areas of Ukraine, Kiev, 1977. 37 Map of Protected Areas of Ukraine, Kiev, 1977. *8 Map of Protected Areas of Ukraine, Kiev, 1977. *° Map of Protected Areas of Ukraine, Kiev, 1977. 4° Map of Protected Areas of Ukraine, Kiev, 1977. 4! Map of Protected Areas of Ukraine, Kiev, 1977. * Map of Protected Areas of Ukraine, Kiev, 1977. * Map of Protected Areas of Ukraine, Kiev, 1977 “4 Map of Protected Areas of Ukraine, Kiev, 1977. 45 Map of Protected Areas of Ukraine, Kiev, 1977 4° Map of Protected Areas of Ukraine, Kiev, 1977 47 Map of Protected Areas of Ukraine, Kiev, 1977. 48 Map of Protected Areas of Ukraine, Kiev, 1977. *° Map of Protected Areas of Ukraine, Kiev, 1977. 46 4.4 Internationally designated coastal protected areas Country, designation and site name Long/Lat Bulgaria Ramsar (Wetlands) Convention Arkoutino (Rapotamo)**” 42°18'N/27°45'E Comment: Wetland of international importance, an important bird area in Europe. It is a territory of Rapotamo Nature reserve (see above) and one marsh from this complex is a reserve Arkoutino (see above). Burgas Lakes*”! 42°30'N/27°29'E Comment: Wetland of international importance, an important bird area in Europe. One lake from this complex is a reserve Atanasovsko ozero (see above). Durankulak and Shabla Lakes**™ 43°42'N/28°30'E Comment: Wetland of international importance and an important bird area in Europe. Globally threatened species: i. Breeding species: Lutra lutra, Crex crex, Astacus astacus, Hirudo medicinalis; ii. Migrating and wintering species: Pelicanus crispus, Halietor pygmeus, Oxyura leucocephala, Anser erhythropus, Branta ruficollis; European threatened species: Aythya nyroca, Aythya ferina, Locustella lusciniodes. UNESCO-MAB Biosphere Reserves Réserve Kamtchia* 43°02'N/27°S50'E Comment: See above details for Reserve Kamtchia. Réserve Ouzounboudjak* 42°00'N/27°45'E Comment: See above details for Réserve Ouzounboudjak. Georgia Ramsar (Wetlands) Convention Wetlands of Central Kolkheti (Kolkheti Lowland)***** 42°12'N/41°42'E Romania ° Ministry of Environment of Bulgaria. National action plan for the conservation of the most important wetlands in Bulgaria. Sofia. 1995. P.46-47. 5! Ministry of Environment of Bulgaria. National action plan for the conservation of the most important wetlands in Bulgaria. Sofia. 1995. P.52-53. * Ministry of Environment of Bulgaria. National action plan for the conservation of the most important wetlands in Bulgaria. Sofia. 1995. Pp.24,52. 53 See Web: http://www.grida.no/prog/cee/enrin/htmls/georgia/soegeor/english/wetlands/wetlands.htm 47 Ramsar (Wetlands) Convention Danube Delta* UNESCO-MAB Biosphere Reserves Danube Delta Biosphere Reserve* World Heritage Convention Danube Delta* Russia European Diploma Type 'A' Teberda** Ramsar (Wetlands) Convention Akhtar-Griva system of limans (eastern sea of Azov)* Limans between the River Kuban and the River Protoka* UNESCO-MAB Biosphere Reserves Kavkazskiy Reserve* Turkey There are no internationally designated coastal sites. Ukraine Ramsar (Wetlands) Convention Dunai Plavni* Karkinitski Bay* Sivash Bay* Yagorlits & Tendrov Bays* UNESCO-MAB Biosphere Reserves Askaniya-Nova Reserve* Chernomorskiy Reserve* 48 45°10'N/29°15'E 44°50'N/29°00'E 45°00'N/28°S0'E 41°45'N/43°30'E 44°50'N/38°30'E 45°30'N/37°48'E 40°15'N/43°47'E 42°28'N/29°36'E 45°51'N/33°33'E 46°09'N/34°21'E 46°20'N/31°50'E 46°27'N/33°53'E 46°12'N/32°00'E 4.5 Site sheets for some protected areas Bulgaria - Réserve Kamtchia IUCN Management Category | and 1X (Strict Nature Reserve and Biosphere Reserve) Biogeographical Province 2.33.12 (Balkan Highlands) Geographical Location At the mouth of the Kamtchia river on the Black Sea, south of the city of Varna, 43°02'N, 27°50°E. Date and History of Establishment The reserve was established in 1951. The Union for Nature Protection set up in 1928 was responsible for setting up many reserves. These are now protected under the 1967 Law on Nature Protection. It was accepted in January 1977 as a Biosphere Reserve. Area The original reserve covered 525ha but the Biosphere Reserve includes 842ha. Land Tenure Government Altitude 0-4m Physical Features The reserve is on the floodplain of the River Kamtchia, at its mouth. Soils are formed predominantly of alluvium, and are flooded twice a year by the river's spring and autumn flood. Climate No information Vegetation The reserve includes the remains of forests which once covered over 5,000ha. This flood forest is dominated by Fraxinus oxyphylla and Quercus pedunculiflora with Crataegus monogyna among the understorey plants. Many of the trees are over 35m in height and are about 120 years old. Climbing plants are common, including Similax excelsa, Periploca graeca, Vitis silvestris, Hedera helix and Clematis vitalba. Along the river banks there are marshes and rushes. Fauna There is a variety of terrestrial and aquatic animals. Mammals include roe deer Capreolus capreolus, wild boar Sus scrofa, pine marten Martes martes and fox Vulpes vulpes. There are many reptiles and amphibians, including European mud turtle Emys orbicularis, tessellated water snake Natrix tessellata and alligator lizard Ophisaurus apodus. Birds include a small colony of little egrets Egretta garzetta and the rare half-collared flycatcher Ficedula albicollis semitorquata. Many waterbirds nest along the river banks. Over 20 species of fish live in the river. Cultural Heritage The area has been subject to cutting and drainage attempts. Local Human Population There is a small village at the mouth of the river but the floodplains are fairly populated. Visitors and Visitor Facilities Boats may be hired from fishermen at the mouth of the river, but access is limited. Scientific Research and Facilities Comprehensive ecological studies and permanent research into the effects of human activity are indispensable. This is the only flood forest area in Bulgaria where such research can conveniently be carried out, and probably one of the few in Europe. There is no scientific research station. Conservation Value No information Conservation Management Total 49 The reserve is strictly protected and all economic activities prohibited. Access by visitors has been controlled by fencing the most vulnerable side. There is a buffer zone. From north to west stretch forests and tillable lands, while to the east a ribbon of coastal sand and biocenoses of Paliurus aculeatus have not been developed as tourist resorts. Management Constraints Before the reserve was created there was selective cutting and also all the trees of Ulmus campestris, which had been struck by Graphium ulmi (1930-35), were cut down. An embankment was partially built on the right bank of the Kamtchia River which narrowed the front of the flood-rise as it entered the reserve, and it is thought that this caused some disturbance to the forest's hydrological regime. The fact that the area is now a strict reserve is helping the flood forest to recover its original character. Staff One full-time forest guard Budget No information Local Addresses Economie forestiére, Staro Oryakhovo, Département de Varna. References Stoilov, D., Noshtev, V., Gerasimov, S. and Velev, V. (1981). Protected Natural Sites in the People's Republic of Bulgaria. Balkan State Printing House: Sofia. Date Revised August 1986 Bulgaria - Réserve Ouzounboudjak IUCN Management Category I and IX (Strict Nature Reserve and Biosphere Reserve) Biogeographical Province 2.33.12 (Balkan Highlands) Geographical Location On the Turkish border in the Strandzha Planina, on the Rezvaya River, south of the village of Kosti, 42°00'N, 27°45'E. Date and History of Establishment The reserve was established in 1956. The Union for Nature Protection set up in 1928 was responsible for setting up many reserves. These are now protected under the 1967 Law on Nature Protection. It was accepted in January 1977 as a Biosphere Reserve. Area The original reserve had an area of 2,529ha but the Biosphere Reserve encloses 2,575ha. Land Tenure Government Altitude 150-200m Physical Features The reserve is on the left bank of the River Resvaja, which forms the boundary on two sides. The terrain is hilly and the climate has marked maritime influences, being only about 20km from the sea. Climate No information Vegetation The reserve was set up to preserve the oak Quercus polycarpa and Q. frainetto and beech Fagus orientalis forests which are over 200 years old. The understorey includes Rhododendron ponticum, Daphne ponticum, Vaccinium arctostaphylos and Mespilus germanica, some of which only grow naturally in Europe in 50 the Strandzha. It is in the Bulgarian Floristic Region of Strandzha and part of the Balkan sclerophyll biotic province. Fauna This is rich and varied and includes wild boar Sus scrofa, roe deer Capreolus capreolus, wild cat Felis silvestris, badger Meles meles, red fox Vulpes vulpes and pine marten Martes martes while wolf Canis lupus occasionally come from Turkey. Cultural Heritage The reserve is on the Turkish border, and is remote. Part of the area was selectively logged, but man has affected it very little. Local Human Population This border zone is very sparsely populated; there is a village at the mouth of the Resvaja River. Visitors and Visitor Facilities Access for tourism is prohibited. The area is remote, in a border region and there are no facilities. Scientific Research and Facilities There has been little scientific research and there are no special facilities. Conservation Value No information Conservation Management Total The reserve is strictly protected and all economic and tourist activities prohibited. A buffer zone is projected Management Constraints Before the reserve was created there was successive selective cutting over a third of the area. Strandzha has seen the disappearance of Ursus arctos, Lynx lynx, Gypaetus barbatus and other fauna. Staff One permanent member of staff Budget No information Local Addresses Economie forestiére, Kosti, Département de Bourgas. References No information Date Revised August 1986 Georgia - Kintrishskiy State Reserve IUCN Management Category | Biogeographical Province 2.34.12 Geographical Location South of the Rioni valley, on the slopes of the Meskhet range, about 20-30km from Batumi, Black Sea region. 42°N LONGITUDE 42°E 51 Date and History of Establishment 1959 Area Previously 6,943ha; now 7,166ha Land Tenure State lands by law Altitude No information Physical Features The reserve lies on the western slopes of the Meskhet range, a southern spur of the main Caucasus range, to the south of the Kolkhida or Colchis lowlands around the Riono valley. It is an area of mountainous relief with deeply entrenched gorges. Soils are zheltozems, krasnozems (red earths) mountain forest brown earths and sub-alpine meadow type. Mean temperatures range from 20°in July to 3-4° with a total annual rainfall of 1,000-2,000mm. Altitude ranges from 450-2,600m. Climate No information Vegetation This is zoned with altitude and includes broadleaf deciduous forests (1.2.5.1.) including Kolkhida oakwoods Quercus pontica, Medviediev's birch Beitula medwedewii, sweet chestnut Castanea sativa and beech Fagus spp. Sub-alpine evergreen shrubs include Rhododendron ponticus. The bay Laurus nobilis is also present, as are a number of relict species of botanical interest. Fauna Larger mammals are fairly scarce but include a representative Caucasian forest fauna. Species reported from the area include wild pig Sus scrofa, red deer Cervus elaphus and pheasants. Cultural Heritage No information Local Human Population No information Visitors and Visitor Facilities No information Scientific Research and Facilities Studies into the biology of woody plants are undertaken in the area. There room for laboratory. Conservation Value No information Conservation Management Tot al Nature Reserve Management Constraints None reported. Staff No information Budget No information Local Addresses Georgian SSR, Kobuleti post office, Leselidze Street 4. References Anon. (1966) Caucasus, publ. Nauka, Moscow Bannikov, A. G. (1969) Reserves of the USSR. Publishing House Kolos, Moscow. 552 pp. Date No information 52 Romania - Danube Delta Biosphere Reserve IUCN Management Category IV (Nature Reserve) Biogeographical Province 2.29.11. (Pontian Steppe) Geographical Location Lies on the coast of the Black Sea in the eastern part of the country in Tulcea County, and encompasses the area between the branch rivers Chilia, Sulina and Sfintu Gheorghe, the former creating the boundary between Romania and the Ukrainian SSR. The site also includes the Razelm-Sinoie complex of lakes Razelm, Sinoie, Zmeica and Golovita to the immediate south of the delta. 44°25'-45°28'N, 29°42'-28°45'E Date and History of Establishment In 1938 the Council of Ministers passed Decision No 645 declaring 'Letea Forest’ as a nature reserve. In 1961 it passed Decision No 891 declaring Rosca-Buhaiova (14,600ha), St George-Perisor -Zatoane (16,400ha), Periteasca-Gura Portitei (3,900ha) and Popina Island (98ha) as nature reserves. In 1971 the Management of Forestry declared the Caraorman Forest (840ha) and Erenciuc Forest (41ha). In 1975 the Council of Ministers passed the Decision No. 524 extending the Danube Delta protected areas to cover 41,500ha. In 1979 an area of 18,145ha combining Rosca-Buhaiova Reserve and Letea Forest was designated as Rosca-Letea Biosphere Reserve. An area of 500,000ha including all previous designations was declared a biosphere reserve under National Decree No. 983 with supporting Articles 5, and 6 on 27 August 1990. Further legislation is under preparation. This area was further enlarged in early 1991 to cover 547,000ha. International recognition is imminent with submissions in May 1991 to Unesco for biosphere reserve nomination and to the Ramsar Bureau for nomination as a Ramsar site. The latest legislation gives patrimony of the biosphere reserve to the Delta Authority. Decree 264/91 passed on 12 April 1991 places all institute, agency and inspectorate staff under the administration of the biosphere reserve. The environment agency for Tulcea Judet is also subordinate. All public domain and aquatic and natural resources generated are the ownership of the biosphere reserve authority. Further legislation will significantly strengthen the administration of the site. Area 679,222ha, including 103,000ha marine. The entire delta region comprises 799,000ha of which 679,000ha are in Romania and 120,000ha in the Ukrainian SSR. The Razelm-Sinoie lagoon complex adds a further 88,000ha. The exact boundary of the site put forward for nomination has been altered to exclude less natural areas such as the Pardina polder and the fish ponds in the south-west (Vadineanu, pers. comm., 1991). Land Tenure The State owns over 90% with the rest in private hands. The latter was only recently granted. Altitude 0-15m Physical Features The origin of the Delta can be traced to the Ice Age 'Wurm 3'. The present geomorphological form has evolved in historical times. The northern part of the Delta is slowly sinking, resulting in measurable water flow increase in the Chilia arm of the Danube. Only 9% of the area is permanently above water (EEN, 1990). The Delta is extensive in European terms (some 12 times the size of Cota Donana Reserve on the Guadalquivir Delta, Spain) with numerous freshwater lakes interconnected by narrow channels with huge expanses of aquatic vegetation. The Razelm-Sinoie complex to the south consists of several large brackish lagoons separated from the sea by a sandbar (Grimmett and Jones, 1989). Every year thousands of tons of alluvial deposits are carried into the Delta by the Danube resulting in a constant reshaping of the river banks and sandbars. The overall basic hydrological and ecological systems of the Delta, although strongly degraded, are considered intact (Pons and Pons-Ghitulescu, 1990). Rosca-Buhaiova-Hrecisca Nature Reserve (part of Rosca-Letea Biosphere Reserve) is considered almost unaltered by man due to the shallow water level making access almost impossible. Perisor-Zatoane-Sacalin Nature Reserve is a mosaic of lakes and ponds and reedbeds with parallel strips of sand dunes (‘grinduri’). Sacalin Island is made up of alluvial deposits with sand dunes and Tamarix. 53 The Delta has been classified into 12 habitat types as follows: aquatic habitats - lakes (0.80m - 2.50m depth) covered with flooded reedbeds; 'plaur' - flooded islets; flooded reeds and willows; riverine forest of willows and poplars; cane-fields; sandy and muddy beaches; wet meadows; dry meadows (arid); human settlements; sandy and rocky areas; steep banks; and forests on high ground (Ciochia, n.d.). Climate The prevailing continental climate, with only 450mm of annual rainfall, is temporarily influenced by proximity to the sea and the humidity rising from countless inland lakes and small waterways (Anon., 1990). Vegetation This is the largest continuous marshland in Europe which includes the greatest stretch of reedbeds probably in the world. The marsh vegetation is dominated by reeds Phragmites australis which form floating or fixed islands of decaying vegetation (‘plaur') with some Typha angustifolia and Scirpus sp. Reeds cover some 1,700 sq. km and 'plaur’ 1,000 sq. km, whilst the total area not included is only 148 sq. km (Ciochia, n.d.). There are also water lilies Nymphaea alba and Nuphar luteus and Stratiodes alloides. The higher ground supports stands of Salix, Populus, Alnus and Quercus. Sandy areas are covered with feather grass Stipa sp. and other steppe species. Forest elements are best observed in Letea Forest, occurring in a series of bands along dunes up to 250m long and 10m wide, where trees reach 35m in height. The species present are Quercus robur, Q. pedunculiflora, Populus alba, P.nigra, Fraxinus ornus, F. angustifolia, F.palisae, Pyrus pyraster, Tilia tomentosa, Ulmus sp., and the occasional Alnus glutinosa. Among the shrubs are Crataegus monogyna, Euonimus europea, Cornus mas, C. sanguinea, Rhamnus frangula, R. catharctica, Viburnum opulus, Berberis vulgaris, Hippophae rhamnoides, Tamarix spp. and occasional Corylus avellana. The distinctive feature of the forest is the abundance of climbing plants including Periploca graeca, Clematis vitalba, Vitis sylvestris and Humulus lupus. In spring, the ground is carpeted with Convallaria majalis. Particularly rare and threatened plants include Convolvulus persica, Ephedra distachya, Merendera sobolifera, Plantago coronopus and Petunia parviflora (IUCN, 1986). Fauna Over 300 species of bird have been recorded, of which over 176 species breed (Radu, 1979), the most important being: cormorant Phalacrocorax carbo sinensis (3,000 pairs), pygmy cormorant P. pygmeus (K) (2,500 pairs comprising 61% of the world's population), white pelican Pelecanus onocrotalus (2,500 pairs comprising 50% of the Palaearctic breeding population), Dalmatian pelican P. crispus (E) (estimated at 150 pairs, perhaps now only 25-40 pairs, on the floating islands on lake Hrecisca, which represents 5% of the world population), night heron Nycticorax nycticorax (2,100 pairs), squacco heron Ardeola ralloides (2,150 pairs), great white heron Egretta alba (700 pairs), little egret E. garzetta (1,400 pairs), purple heron Ardea purpurea (1,250 pairs), glossy ibis Plegadis falcinellus (1,500 pairs), white stork Ciconia ciconia (many), mute swan Cygnus olor (500 pairs), white-tailed eagle Haliaeetus albicilla (V) (8 pairs), marsh harrier Circus aeruginous (300+ pairs), osprey Pandion haliaetus (3 pairs), Saker falcon Falco cherrug (1-2 pairs), red-footed falcon F. vespertinus (150 pairs), Sandwich tern Sterna sandvicensis (1,700 pairs), common tern S. hirundo (20,000+ pairs), whiskered tern Chlidonias hybridus (20,000+), and black tern C. niger (10,000-20,000 pairs). White-headed duck Oxyura leucocephala possibly still breeds. Slender-billed curlew Numenius tenuirostris (K) has occurred on passage (28 in 1971 and one or two in 1989). The Delta holds huge numbers of Anatidae in the winter with counts of 500,000 white-fronted goose Anser albifrons (but only 64,000-77,500 in 1982), up to 500 lesser white-fronted goose A. erythropus, 45,000 red-breasted goose Branta ruficollis (a globally threatened species with almost 95% of the world wintering population present here), 150,000 teal Anas crecca, 200,000 mallard A. platyrhynchos, 14,000 pintail A. acuta, 40,000 shovelor A. clypeata, 32,400 red-crested pochard Netta rufina, 970,000 pochard A. ferina, 13,000 ferruginous duck A. nyroca, and 1,500 red-breasted merganser Mergus albellus. In winter there is a concentration of some 30-40 Haliaeetus albicilla (R) (Grimmett and Jones, 1989; Green, 1990 ). The Delta is very important for fish with 45 fresh water species present including threatened representatives of the Acipensenidae (Anon., 1990). Otter Lutra lutra (V), Mustela erminea, and European mink Mustela lutreola (V), as well as wild cat Felis sylvestris are to be found on the floating islands (Anon., 1990). It appears that little work has been done on mammals since 1970 largely as a result of lack of funding, but the mink population, although its size is unknown, is apparently significant in European terms. The forest areas contain several rare reptiles, including Vipera ursini, Elaphe longissiuma, and Eremias arguta deserti (IUCN, 1986). 54 Cultural Heritage The very long history of trading along the Danube is evident from remains of Greek and Roman settlements (including a lighthouse). Villages surrounding the Delta show a Turkish influence. Local Human Population Estimated at between 12,000 and 16,000 (most of Ukrainian orthodox Lipki descent), depending on the definition of the area covered and residence status (EEN, 1990; IUCN-EEP, 1991). The lower figure is considered to be 50% less than 50 years ago (Pons and Pons-Ghitulescu, 1990). The population is distributed along the three main waterways, Chilia, Sulina and Sfintu Gheorghe, the main source of drinking water. Cases of cholera have been reported (EEN, 1990), the latest in August 1990 when 66 cases were diagnosed in the Tulcea region (Anon., 1990a). Most of the younger generation has left the Delta and old fishing villages of reed huts have been replaced by concrete structures, although individual fishing huts are retained. Some villages (e.g. Gorgova) have no electricity. Social problems are exacerbated by low incomes due to set prices for fish (500 lei per 1,000 kg of fish; 1989 figures). Conditions for the workers on state farms (on the newly-created polders) are reported to be extremely bad (attempts to introduce eco-farming in the near future )(IUCN-EEP, 1991); they lack basic infrastructures and the work is unpopular. It is reported that the state farms were used as prison camps (Pons and Pons-Ghitulescu, 1990). Some constructions are inappropriate to the region such as the blocks of flats and large commercial complex at Sfintu Gheorghe which remain empty (Pons and Pons-Ghitulescu, 1990). The local population has been involved in small-scale, low-intensity use of natural resources supplemented by outside interests, such as fishing (10,000 boats are registered, cattle grazing and beekeeping, thought on the whole to be integrated to preservation of natural heritage. The centre of commercial activitiy in the Delta is the freeport of Sulina. In the late 1980s the town underwent rapid expansion with 500 new dwellings being built, an hotel and a shipping centre to handle 3,500 ships annually (Anon., 1987). Other urban developments have taken place at Chilia Veche, Sfintu Gheorghe, 1 Mai, Unirea and Independenta (Anon., 1987). Visitors and Visitor Facilities Under the previous regime parts of the Delta were heavily used for tourism (EEN, 1990), with up to 100,000 visitors annually, mostly concentrated at two hotels along the Sulina channel, although many camp along major channels in the summer (IUCN-EEP, 1991). Permission is needed to visit the nature reserves which are closed during the bird breeding season (IUCN, 1986). Away from the three main channels the areas are rarely frequented with very few visitors (IUCN-EEP, 1991). Nature tourism, however, has been greatly neglected, with, for example, a detailed plan prepared in 1982 by the Institute for Research on Ecology for Tourism of the Ministry of Tourism (together with the National Council for Scientific and Technical Research and the Academy of Sciences in Agriculture and Forestry) being ignored. General tourism development was encouraged, however, on the coast (Pons and Pons-Ghitulescu, 1990). More recently the beginnings of indiscriminate tourism organised by numerous tourist agencies is evident (Roman, 1990), with 40 private agencies springing up in Tulcea (IUCN-EEP, 1991). Scientific Research and Facilities Ecological studies on the river and the Delta conducted by Grigore Antipa began at the beginning of the century (Pons and Pons-Ghitulescu, 1990). In the past two decades research on the delta was carried out in a number of phases (Vadineanu, 1990): between 1974 and 1978 an intensive programme of investigations on Rosu-Puiu complex of lakes (SE area of delta) covered morphometric measurements, physico-chemical measurements, structure and dynamics of communities, biomass, production measurements (primary and secondary), field and laboratory experiments for oxygen consumption, filtration rates, energy expenditure on anaerobic pathways and the relationship between phytoplankton and submerged macrophytes, and on energy flows; between 1979 and 1981 investigations were carried out on Matita-Merhei lakes (north-east area of delta). Measurements as above were carried out; between 1980 and 1982 an extensive programme of investigations throughout the whole delta identified eight distinct aquatic ecosystems. From each of these groups one lake was selected as being characteristic; and since 1982 investigations have concentrated on eight characteristic ecosystems and since 1987 two lakes from the Razelm-Sinoie complex have been added. Overall scientific data on the delta is being collected by a national group formed from members of the disbanded parliamentary Committee for Ecology. The Ministry of Environment has provided funds to a number of bodies to prepare research reports on past uses of the Delta and future developments (IUCN-EEP, 1990). A research programme for the Delta, the Black Sea and the Danube has been started in co-operation with the USSR. This 55 envisages investigations on the cycling of nitrogen, phosphorous, heavy metals and pesticides, the effects of the above on the biodiversity and biological productivity, as well as the role of ecotones in controlling the density of flow of chemical compounds (IUCN-EEP, 1990). In 1991, seven research groups have been established within a three-year programme. Faunal and floral surveys have been carried out (IUCN, 1986) but these have been limited and an overall species survey and long-term studies, especially for migratory waders on the eastern European/East African flyway (Harengerd et al., 1990) are lacking. It has been suggested that, due to the vast area of the Delta, aerial surveys are the only effective way of conducting surveys (Green, 1990). The national biodiversity survey of Romania includes the Delta where a biodiversity research group is preparing a detailed inventory. Over 70 scientists and 11 institutes are involved. Conservation Value The Delta is the meeting point of Palaearctic and Mediterranean biogeographic zones and represents an unique dynamic wetland ecosystem in Europe (the second largest delta) containing a rich biodiversity of wetland habitats. The site is internationally significant for birds, both breeding and migratory, including a number of globally-threatened species. It is also a vitally important buffer system between the hydrographical basin of the River Danube and the Black Sea. Conservation Management The area was previously managed by a Central Deltei, a central office set up in 1970 and abolished in August 1990 upon the creation of the biosphere reserve. The 1983 Decree for the Economic Development of the Delta gave responsibility for this work to the Central Deltei and until recently it had 2,000 employees with a budget of 5M lei (IUCN-EEP, 1991). It was reported that the Ministries of Agriculture and Industry were asked to compensate for the loss of employment in the delta as a result of the reclamation ban and the creation of the biosphere reserve (Schneider, 1990). A number of hydrological engineers are already unemployed as a result of the passage of Decree 103 (IUCN-EEP, 1990). Many of the staff have formed economic societies; six fishing and five agricultural (IUCN-EEP, 1991). Within the 'Delta’ biosphere reserve (covering some 679,222ha) 18,145ha are included in a separate biosphere designation (the core zone covers two-thirds of the area, the peripheral areas forming the buffer zone) and 43,790ha in seven nature reserves (two of which overlap with the biosphere reserve). The 18,145ha Rosca-Letea was declared a biosphere reserve in 1979 (the Rosca area has been protected since 1961 and Letea Forest since 1978); the nature reserves are:- Rosca-Buhaiova-Hrecisca (15,600ha but including part of the biosphere reserve), Perisor-Zatoane-Sacalin (15,400ha), Istria (8,000ha), Periteasca-Leahova-Gura Portitei (3,900ha), Popina (90ha), Saraturile (100ha) and Hasmacul Mare (700ha). These existing nature reserves are considered to be undisturbed zones which are totally protected. The biosphere reserve enabling legislation prohibits damaging and potentially damaging activities (Decree 983, 27.9.90) and controls intensive land use incompatible with the maintenance of the wetland ecosystem. At present there are 52,980ha of core zone, at 16 separate sites, 25,500ha of restoration zone, 230,200ha of buffer zone and 267,542ha of transition zone. A priority action programme is being prepared as part of the Danube Delta Strategy and Management Plan. The most fully developed is the research programme, consisting of seven task forces with a detailed three-year plan (IUCN-EEP, 1991). The enabling agency is the Department of Environment; the responsible agency the Danube Delta Biosphere Reserve Authority. The plan will be a "statutory plan" legally binding for all national agencies, answerable to the Ministry of Environment. The Province of Tulcea will have local representation on the Danube Delta Authority. In this context a major input is being made by the international mission led by IUCN's East European Programme and including representatives from Unesco, WWF-International, ICBP, IWRB and Ramsar Secretariat. The mission visited the Delta in September 1990 and a strategy for international conservation assistance is due to be formalised in May 1991. This is likely to take the form of an integrated management plan for the biosphere reserve together with immediate urgent practical conservation action by the individual agencies co-ordinated by the Romanian authorities. In the historical context, this is not new. A report 'The conservation situation in the Danube Delta, Rumania during the period 1963-1969', recommending a long-term conservation plan, resuited from a second visit (the first was in 1963) to the Delta in June/July 1969 by a consultant on behalf of IUCN, WWF, ICBP and IWRB (Curry-Lindahl, 1969). A parliamentary commission of enquiry visited the Delta in late 1990. 56 Decree No. 103 entitled 'Decree concerning the abolition of the reclamation works in the Danube Delta’, appearing in the Official Publication of Romania No. 22 on 7 February 1990, halted the major development projects in the delta. However, the Decree allowed 'strictly necessary works' to be completed or continued. These are listed as: maintenance of flood defences; completion of the regulation of the Sf Gheorghe branch; completion of the works to protect the coastline in the zone of Sinoe; completion of the works to protect the coastline in the zone of Portita-Sf Georghe-Sulina; navigation and bank protection of the Sulina branch; and maintenance of existing reclamations at Pardina, Sireasa, Fortuna, Rusco, Grindul Island, Chilia and Sulina. The completion of reclamation work at Pardina and Sireasca were allowed under Decree 103 on the understanding that no chemicals were to be applied (Carauscu, 1990). Previous work along the Sf Gheorghe (a relatively untouched river landscape) led to the bypassing of river meanders and the reduction in use of lateral channels, as well as the increase in pollution load deposition (Anon., 1990; Pons and Pons-Ghitulescu, 1990). The maintenance of agricultural activities in the polder areas is likely to result in soil degradation. It has been reported that many of these 'necessary works! have also subsequently been halted (Hopkins, 1990a). The embankment and canalisation have increased the rate of desiccation of the lakes in the delta (Busila, 1990) as well as resulting in the drying up of the depressions between the dunes in Letea Forest, where the water table has dropped by 50 to 60cm below summer levels. Saplings have died and older trees stunted, soil erosion has increased and trees have been attacked by parasites (Kiss, 1990). Water quality in the Delta is very much determined by the water flowing down the Danube. This was previously filtered by a network of wet grasslands along the lower Danube. Some 435,000ha, or four-fifths of the total, have now been lost (Schneider, 1990). The Decree required the Minister of Water, Forestry and Environment together with the Minister of Agriculture and Food Industry to prepare a study detailing the future economic uses of the Delta by 31 December 1990 (Pons and Pons-Ghitulescu, 1990). A report for Decree 103 was produced in May 1991 and provided guidelines by sector (e.g. forestry, agriculture, fisheries, tourism etc.) for the future use of the Delta Authority (UCN-EEP, 1991). This has been accepted by the Minister of Environment. Exceptions to the activities mentioned in the decree are thought to have come about as a result of pressure from the Centrala Deltei Dunarii, the Institute of Study and Design for Land Reclamation (ISPIF) and the Soil Research Institute (ICPA), fearing the loss of employment by staff if all previous activities were to cease immediately. They have argued that abandoning all activities would result in squandering the investment of over 16 Billion lei (the equivalent of US$ 1 billion)(Pons and Pons-Ghitulescu, 1990). To counter this, it is estimated that direct annual losses due to agricultural operations in the Delta amount to 18 million lei (Roman, 1990), in addition to which the engineering institutes had invested 5B lei in infrastructures (IUCN-EEP, 1991). Overall economic losses were estimated at 300 million lei per annum (IUCN-EEP, 1990). In 1990 the authorities invited the International Bank for Reconstruction and Development (World Bank) to assist them in the restructuring of 3.5 million ha of agricultural land in the delta and the lower Danube. It is likely that the first stage of the programme will be an environmental assessment plan for the area to be carried out in 1991. This programme may provide the opportunity to restore previous wetland areas in the delta and the lower Danube. Some measures are already being taken to restore seriously degraded sites in the empoldered areas including flooding to restore a water regime with a low intensity fishing regime. A number of authorities are having an input to the preparation of the management programme. These include: Ministry of Environment, Ministry of Agriculture, Ministry of Tourism and Commerce, Ministry of Education and Science, Romanian Academy (NGO), Ecological Society of Romania (NGO), Brailia Institute (Romanian Academy of Sciences), Iasi University, Institute of Tourism Research. Management Constraints Degradation was reaching serious proportions through engineering works and inappropriate land uses. These have now been stopped. A very detailed summary of the history of the reclamation and water engineering works in the Delta is given by Pons and Pons-Ghitulescu (1990). The previous regime had decided to use the area to economic advantage and in 1983 it was decided that agriculture should become the "principal economic activity" with plans to triple productivity by 1990. In total, 97,000ha were earmarked for agriculture (with some 50,000ha converted to irrigated croplands by 1987 by the construction of polders)(Grimmett and Jones, 1989). Of an area of 42,000ha cultivated with maize, only 17,000ha were considered productive with yields of between 500-800kg/ha. By the end of 1987, cereals covered 24,120ha, other crops 650ha, and vegetables 200ha, with 300ha planned as orchards and 280ha as Si vineyards. Further plans envisaged ground nut production (Anon., 1987). A particularly damaging construction was the Sireasa polder covering 7,500ha, which destroyed the eastern levees and riverine forest areas (Pons and Pons-Ghitulescu, 1990). A further 32,469ha were to be devoted to fish farming (although some reports gave the final area of the fish-farms to be 244,000ha, of which 63,000ha had been created (Anon., 1990)). A total of 12,838 ha was given over to forestry (replacement of native species with hybrid poplars and cypresses), but here again production was less than expected due to the salination of groundwater (Pons and Pons-Ghitulescu, 1990). Increased reed production (for the paper industry which has exploited the area since 1956) has been tried, as well as rice cultivation in former salt-marshes (Anon., 1990). Reed production fell catastrophically from 200-300,000 tons per annum in 1960 to less than 50,000 tons per annum in the late 1980s (Pons and Pons-Ghitulescu, 1990). The reeds were harvested by heavy mechanised caterpillar equipment and processed at a cellulose factory specially constructed at Tulcea (Schneider, 1990). In 1990 only 8% of the total reed surface was harvested (IUCN-EEP, 1991). The burning of reed beds is also practised (Green, 1990). The additional 47,000ha was still to be reclaimed, much of it from the central, most ecologically and most important parts of the delta. This was to have been the 23,000ha Uzlina-Gorgova polder (Pons and Pons-Ghitulescu, 1990). In total, almost one third of the Delta was to be transformed. By December 1989 one third of the targets had been achieved. A further 66,185 ha in the northern parts bordering onto the USSR had become damaged by inefficient clearing of reeds (apparently by hard labour prisoners in the 1950s). Past drainage has caused the loss of much wetland and, although some of the damage has been compensated by the creation of fish ponds, these are not suitable for breeding species (Langeveld and Grimmett, 1990). Reed exploitation, water regulation and drainage have been linked to the population decreases in 20 bird species over the past decades (Schneider, 1990). The deliberate destruction of colonially-nesting birds which has occurred in the past is now thought to be uncommon (Garnett, n.d.). Certain species (pelican and birds of prey) are at risk from collision with the many kilometres of electricity power lines present in the delta. The wintering Branta ruficollis is dependent on the agricultural lands to the immediate south of the delta and changing practices may be important for their future (Green, 1990). Other projects included the re-routing of the River Sfintu-Gheorghe by cutting a straight canal through the numerous meanders, which would speed up the flow of water and radically alter the pattern of alluvial deposition (Grimmett and Jones, 1989), and the exploitation of quartziferous sand from the sand dunes in particular on the Grindul-Caraorman barrier and exploitation of zircon and titan at Grindul Saraturile (Pons and Pons-Ghitulescu, 1990). The latter never came to fruition and lies abandoned. The site is due to reconstruction according to the biosphere reserve management plan (IUCN-EEP, 1991). Several new roads were to be built, seven industrial plants, a new harbour and a marked development of the tourism industry (4,000 beds, hydro-buses and pleasure boats)(Anon., 1990). There is some evidence that illegal hunting expeditions were organised by an Italian company (EEN, 1990). Others have noted the increase in intensive hunting tourism (Roman, 1990). A pig farm (for 25,000 animals) with slaughter facilities was apparently constructed and plans were put forward for airport construction (Schneider, 1990). The local fishing industry has also suffered with catches halved since 1980. Extensive fish farming using Chinese carp has resulted in the virtual extinction of wild carp. In 1984 the number of indigenous fish caught fell by two-thirds, the farmed fish catches doubled. The increase in fish farming activities has caused some conflict with bird colonies, especially of pelicans and cormorants (e.g. at Maliuc on the Sulina waterway). Reports suggest that fish production in the fish ponds is very low (Pons and Pons-Ghitulescu, 1990). There is a thriving poaching industry based on the Delta villages, which tends to make some official fish catch figures inaccurate (IUCN-EEP, 1991). Pollution carried downstream in the Danube is a greater threat with high levels of toxic pesticides (including DDT), herbicides and fertilisers. The resulting algal blooms threaten fish life (EEN, 1990). The polluted waters have apparently drastically reduced the numbers of migratory fish (sturgeons, hausen, ship sturgeon, and Russian sturgeon). The salt content has increased from 150mg/I to 350 mg/I and locally to 800mg/I. Nitrogen, potassium and chlorine contents are increasing strongly. Downstream of Tulcea, the water contains high concentrations of Hg and heavy metals (Pons and Pons-Ghitulescu, 1990). The connecting of Lake Razelm with the Danube has resulted in the pollution of the lake waters with a centimetre thick algal layer on the surface in the summer (Pons and Pons-Ghitulescu, 1990). Channels cut from Lake Fortunato to the main Sulina waterway caused the water level in the lake to fall from 2.5m to 1m. This apparently caused the pelican colony to be abandoned (EEN, 1990). Other sources of pollution include a bauxite smelter and ferrous metals plant at Tulcea (Rank, 1990), and a sulphur factory in the Soviet border town of Izmail (Rank, 1990a). In 1988 a political 58 scandal broke with the reporting of the dumping of 4,000 tons of toxic waste (including dioxine) at Sulina (Anon., 1988). Heavy erosion of the littoral and the river banks of the Danube, caused by the construction of the Iron Gates hydroelectric facility on the Romanian-Yugoslavian border, has resulted in "the coastline regressing between 20 and 30m a year, and in some cases even 70m a year" (Pons and Pons-Ghitulescu, 1990). Of a total Romanian coastline of 288km, some 100km are showing active erosion. Of these, 70km are situated in the Delta. The worst affected sections lie between Sulina and Sf Gheorghe and Sf Gheorghe and Partita and also along the Sinoe Lake area (Anon., 1990d). The coastline has been strengthened and protected in part, and further construction aimed at reducing erosion includes the building of a 32km canal (35m wide and 6-7m deep, with a dam at its eastern end to stop sea surges) connecting Sulina and Sf Gheorghe which will transport delta water into the sea at Cherhana Rosulet (Arhire, 1990). Some degradation can be attributed to water regulation through canal, dyke and channel realignment and agricultural intensification within empoldered areas. Nearly 80% of the lower Danube flood plain has been drained and converted to agricultural land resulting in the virtual elimination of floods within the delta itself (Anon., 1990). Threats to the nature reserves include illegal grazing (vegetation has been eliminated on Popina Island due to uncontrolled animal grazing) (Green, 1990), small-scale tourism, hunting and inflow of fresh water from irrigation schemes and the replacement of native woodland by plantations (Grimmett and Jones, 1989). Intensive grazing takes place at the biosphere reserve at Letea and at Histria and Murighiol (Anon., 1990c; Kiss, 1990). It is estimated that 5,500 head of cattle, some wild, are present in the Delta (IUCN-EEP, 1991). Some 20% of the Danube Delta lies within the Ukrainian SSR and to be fully protected this component needs to be included. There is a 14,85lha zapovednik Dunajskii Plavina, situated between the Chilia River (national border) and the Black Sea. The Danube Drainage Basin has an important influence on the Delta with a high percentage of pollution originating outside the country. Staff Total staff of biosphere reserve authority is 470; 100 in enforcement services. Administration is likely to number 50. Budget Total c. 100M lei, comprising biosphere reserve authority 65M lei; enforcement services 8.5M lei; administration 14M lei; monitoring agency 10M lei. In addition, the hydrological programme has received 300M lei over three years. It is suggested that the costs to the government of the management of the Delta will probably triple in the short-term, but in the long-term these costs may be recouped through income from tourism (IUCN-EEP, 1990). Local Addresses The Danube Delta Biosphere Reserve Authority (Governor), The Department of Environment, The Ministry of Environment, R-Bucharest, Artera Nova N-5, Tronson 5-6, Sector 5 Previously the biosphere reserve was administered by the Academia Republicii Socialiste Romania, MAB National Committee of Romania, 71102 Calea Victoriei nr. 125, Bucaresti References Anon. (1987). Agrepress. 24 June. Anon. (1988). The Times. Anon. (1990a). Cholera breaks out in Romania. The European. 17-19 August. P. 2 Anon. (1990). Okologische Bausteine fur unser gemeinsames Haus Europa= Ecological Bricks for a Common Europe. Miinchen, Verlag fiir Politische Okologie. 59 Anon. (1990c). Eco 15. Anon. (1990d). Tulcea Libera 156. 7 August. Arhire, -. (1990). Tulcea Libera 156. 7 August. Busila, S.A. (1990). Tulcea Eco 9. 15 April. Carauscu, A. (1990). Eco 17. 8 June. Ciochia, V. (n.d.). Overview on structure and dynamics of the avifauna of the Danube Delta and neighbouring area. Unpublished notes. Curry-Lindahl, K. (1969). Conservation in the Danube Delta in Rumania. WWF Year Book 1969. P. 20 & Pp. 272-276. EEN (1990). Romania - The Delta. Eastern Europe Newsletter 4(22). Garnett, M.C. (n.d.). Preliminary Solutions for the Coexistence of fisheries and pelicans in the Danube Delta. Preliminary Report IUCN/WWE Project No. 3139. Green, R. (1990). The ornithological importance of the Danube Delta and Lake Razelm-Sinoie. Draft prepared for international mission 1990. Grimmett, R.F.A. and Jones, T.A. (1989). Important Bird Areas in Europe. International Council for Bird Preservation, Cambridge, UK. Harengerd, M., Melter, J., and Reinke, E. (1990). Ornithological observations in Romania. Biologische Station Munster. IUCN Conservation Monitoring Centre (1986). MAB Information System Biosphere Reserves Compilation 4, October 1986. Prepared for Unesco. IUCN-EEP (1990). Report of Second Meeting and Follow-up Meeting Conservation Activities on Romanian Sections of the Danube. 29 June 1990 Montreux, Switzerland. 2 July 1990, Moscow. International Union for Conservation of Nature, Gland, Switzerland. IUCN-EEP (1991). Unpublished notes of mission to Delta 25 May-4 June 1991. International Union for Conservation of Nature-East European Programme. Kiss, J.B. (1990). Romania Pitoreasca 7 (223). Langeveld, M.J. and Grimmett, R.F.A. (Eds). (1990). Important Bird Areas in Europe Wetlands for the Shadow List of Ramsar Sites. International Council for Bird Preservation, International Waterfowl and Wetlands Research Bureau, Cambridge, UK. Pons, L. J. and Pons-Ghitulescu, M.N. (1990). The recent developments around the Danube. Pons, L.J. (1987). Recent information about the present ecological state of the Danube Delta and future threats by agricultural developments. Report. Pons, L.J. (1988). Report about a visit to the Danube Delta (19th -22nd October 1988). Radu, D. (1979). Pasarile din Delta Dunari. Academiei Republicti Socialiste Romania. Rank, M. (1990). Little Bitterness after Romanian Revolution in Danube Delta. Reuters, 4 February. 60 Rank, M. (1990). Wild Danube saved by Ceasescu Overthrow. Reuters, 19 February. Roman, R.A. (1990). "S.O.S. Danube Delta! An Open letter to Prime Minister Petre Roman". 22 June, 1990. Roman, R.A. (1990). Romania Libera. | August. Schneider, E. (1990). The Wet Grasslands in the Catchment Area of the Lower Danube. International Wet-Pasture Symposium, Rastatt, 1988. Wirth, H. (1979). Nature Reserves in Europe. Edition Leipzig. Vadineanu, A. (1990). Data available on the Danube Delta. Unpublished note 14 February. Date March 1991 Russia - Kavkazskiy Zapovednik IUCN Management Category I and IX (Strict Nature Reserve and Biosphere Reserve) Biogeographical Province 2.34.12 (Caucaso-Iranian Highlands) Geographical Location In the western part of the Caucasian range, split between Adygeyskaya Autonomous Oblast’, in Krasnodarskiy Kray and the Karachaevo-Cherkesrkaya Autonomous Oblast’ of the Stabropol'skiy Kray of the RSFSR, the majority lying in the former. The reserve has 21km forest of Sochi. Separate from the main territory of the reserve is the Khost yew-box forest (Khost region, near Sochi) and the Sochi zoo-forest park. 43°46'N, 40°21E. Date and History of Establishment Reserve established in 1924 and approved as a Biosphere Reserve in 1978. Area The reserve covers an area of 263,477ha Land Tenure State property, under the administration of the Ministry of Agriculture of the USSR. Altitude 0-3,360m Physical Features The territory of the reserve represents a typical mountainous landscape, with steep mountain forests, river valleys and alpine tundra along two very large elevations: the main Caucasian range and the forward range situated to the north of the main range. Glaciers and firns feed numerous watercourses; two large rivers, the Bol'shaya Laba and the Belaya, and their tributaries (Malaya Laba and Kisha) dissect the northern slope of the main range into spurs. The rivers of the southern slope - Mzymta, Sochi, Golovinska (Shakhe) - flow into the Black Sea. Between the main and the forward range lies the southern depression, parallel to which tun the valleys of the rivers Zakan, Umpyrki, Achipsty, Alous and Aspidnoi. The climate varies, with the Caucasian Range acting as a barrier separating the wet and hot Black Sea region from the drier and colder districts of Transkuban and Near Caspian. The heaviest rainfall occurs on the southern slopes of the main range, with an annual precipitation sometimes exceeding 3000mm at 1800-2500m. To the east, the rainfall decreases, and in the basins of the Malaya Laba and Bol'shaya Laba is only 700-900mm a year. Climate No information Vegetation The reserve consists of 162,319ha of forest cover and 1,994ha of water areas. The vegetation of the reserve reflects the complex history of the existing surface of the West Caucasus initially selected to represent the Black Sea-Ghirkan province of broad leaved mountainous forests, the heavy ruggedness of its relief and the variety of climate. Over 1,500 species of higher plants are present, increasing to 3,000 if we include the diversity of mosses, fungi, lichens and algae, 20% of which are endemic. Of interest are the large number of 61 tree-shrub species, 165 in all. In the reserve, Tertiary relict plants have been preserved - representatives of the ancient pre-glacial flora of the Caucasus: Caucasian fir Abies nordmanniana, oriental beech Fagus orientalis, chestnut Castanea sativa, oriental spruce Picea orientalis, Iberian oak Quercus iberica, sycamore maple Acer pseudoplatanus, Caucasian lime Tilia caucasia etc. A large part of the reserve is covered by forests. In the mountain belt, broadleaved forests grow to 1,200-1,300m, with oak forests on the light southern slopes at 800-900m. Beech forests are widespread, often covering the whole southern slope of the main range from 500m to the upper forest boundary, but firs predominate, accounting for about two-thirds of all the forest area. From 2,300-2,500m, vegetation of the subalpine meadows gives way to vegetation of the alpine belt extending up to 2,800-2,900m. Fauna The number of mammalian species recorded is 59. There are 192 species of birds, over 132 of which breed including lammergeier Gypaetus barbatus, griffon vulture Gyps fulvus, black vulture Aegypius monachus and golden eagle Aquila chrysactos. The West Caucasian fauna is most widely represented with large numbers of wild goat Capra caucasica, champi Rupicapra rupicapra and wild boar Sus scrofa; roe deer Capreolus capreolus are seen in the strip of broadleaved forests. In 1940 bison Bison bonasus were reintroduced into the Caucasus, and now number 900 in the Caucasus Reserve and the adjoining territories. Cultural Heritage No information Local Human Population No settlements within the reserve Visitors and Visitor Facilities No information Scientific Research and Facilities Since the reserve was established, an inventory has been taken of the flora and fauna, and the biology and ecology of individual (particularly rare) species are being studied. In 1976, a comprehensive programme was initiated to study the structure and dynamics of the main ecosystems of the north-west Caucasus. The effects of fire and logging on the ecosystem are also being monitored. The territory is accessible for research, both of an expeditionary and stationary character. Conservation Value No information Conservation Management Total. The Reserve was set up by Decree of the Council of People's Commissars of the RSFSR in 1924. In accordance with the Basic Principles of Land Legislation of the USSR and the Union Republics, any activity disturbing the natural complexes of reserves or threatening the conservation of natural objects of special scientific or cultural value is forbidden both in the territory of a reserve and in the protected zones set up around reserves. The Decree setting up the Caucasian State Reserve specifies the entire area as a single territory. The reserve is in two sections. The main mountainous sector and the Khostin yew-box forest covering 30lha and a buffer zone is being set up around the reserve. Management Constraints The natural complex of the Caucasus Reserve has been very little modified by human activity; most of it has never been subjected to tree-felling and a large part of the alpine meadows has never been grazed by domestic cattle. Staff 180 permanent staff Budget No information Local Addresses Caucasian Reserve, Sukhumskoe Shosse, 7a, Sochi X-67 Krasnodar Territory, RSFSR, 354067, USSR. 62 References Bannikov, A.G., Golgofskaya, J. Yu., Kotov, V.A. (1967). The Caucasian Reserve. "Znaniye" Publishing House. Borodin, A.M. and Syroechkovski, E.E. (1983). Zapovedniki SSSR Moskva, 'Lesnaya Promyshlennost'. Research Publication of the Caucasus Reserve. Vol. I-II. Publication of the Caucasus Reserve. Sokolov, V. (1985). The System of Biosphere Reserves in the USSR. PARKS, 10(3): 8-9. Date Revised September 1986 Russia - Teberdinskiy State Reserve IUCN Management Category | Biogeographical Province .2.34.12 Geographical Location On the upper reaches of the Teberda River, with a minor part of the reserve in the valley of the Kizgigh River, on north slopes of the Bolshoi Caucasus. 43°N LONGITUDE 42°E Date and History of Establishment 1936 Area Previously 83,122ha; now 84,996 Land Tenure State land by law Altitude No information Physical Features The reserve lies on the north-western slopes of the eastern Caucasus. The mountainous landscape is formed from rocks of Precambrian age, including granites, gneisses, amphibolites and schists. A major portion lies within a granitic mass. Features of the landscape include 100 glaciers, 100 mountain lakes of glacial origin and many waterfalls. The reserve is divided into two subsections in the Teberda and Kizgich valleys. The climate is temperate with 150 days above 0°C, a mean July temperature of 16°C and a mean January temperature of -8°C with 800mm annual rainfall. Soils are of brown mountain/forest type. Climate No information Vegetation Three major vegetation zones are represented. Forests are present from the valley floor to 2,400m with Pinus hamata, Abies nordmaniana, Picea orientalis, Taxus baccata, and deciduous trees including Acer, Carinus, Fagus, Malus, Pyrus, Prunus and others (1.2.5.1; 1.2.4.1; 1.9.2; 1.1.9.3.). Between 2,500m and 2,600m lie alpine meadows (5.3.2.) and above this lie alpine communities. The herbaceous flora of such zones is very rich in species. Fauna Mammals present include the European hare Lepus europaeus, wolf Canis lupus (V), red fox Vulpes vulpes, brown bear Ursus arctos, stoat Mustela erminea, weasel M. nivalis, stone marten Martes foina, otter Lutra lutra, leopard cat Felis bengalensis, lynx F. lynx, wild pig Sus scrofa, maral Cervus elaphus maral, chamois Rupicapra rupicapra and Caucasion tur Capra sibirica caucasica. Frequent birds include bearded vulture Gypaetus barbatus, golden eagle Aquila chrysaetos, Caucasian blackcock Lyrurus mlokosiewiezi, Caucasian snowcock Tetraogallus caucasicus and partridge Alectoris kakelik. Cultural Heritage No information 63 Local Human Population No information Visitors and Visitor Facilities No information Scientific Research and Facilities Studies of rational use of mountain ecosystems for watershed and soil protection, as a health resort etc., together with research on valuable game animals. There are rooms, laboratories, scientific equipment, a natural history museum, a breeding area for wild animals, plantations of ginseng Panax shinseng. Conservation Value No information Conservation Management Total There is no zoning; this is a Strict Nature Reserve. Management Constraints Forest fires, felling of trees, excessive pasturage by cattle before establishment of the reserve. Staff No information Budget No information Local Addresses Teberda town, Stavropol territory, Russia SFSR. References Bannikov, A. G. (1969) Reserves of the USSR. Publishing House Kolos, Moscow. 552 pp. Bronner, (1934) Teberda, a guidebook published by House of Scientists Moscow Knuzer, V. (1951) The Teberda State Rezserve Tecknick da Stroma publ. Tbilisi Knuzer, V. (1951) Reserves of the USSR Vol.1, Geographio, Moscow. Knuzer, V. (1957/67) Works of the Teberda State Reserve, Stavropol Knuzer, V. (1958) Teberda: essays on the Teberda Reserve, Stavropol Date No information Turkey - Haciosman Reserve Management Category I (Strict Nature Reserve) Biogeographical Province 2.11.05 (Middle European Forest) Geographical Location Situated near Haciosman by Samsun on the Black Sea coast. Represents part of the Yesilirmak delta. 41°20'N, 36°20'E. Date And History Of Establishment Designated under national legislation as a strict nature reserve in June 1987 along with four other new sites. 64 Area 86ha Land Tenure State ownership (State forest) Altitude Approximately sea-level Physical Features Alluvial deposits of the Yesilirmak delta (Karakurum, pers. comm. 1987). Climate Mild continental Black Sea climate Vegetation Coastal alluvial forest composed of temperate European types species such as black poplar Populus nigra, ash Fraxinus spp., oak Quercus spp., willow Salix spp., alder Alnus glutinosa and elm Ulmus spp. (Karakurum, pers. comm. 1987). Fauna No information Cultural Heritage No information Local Human Population No inhabitants within the reserve. Visitors And Visitor Facilities Access restricted. Scientific Research And Facilities Limited botanical and faunal surveys undertaken by the National Park Team of the Orman Genel Mudiirliigii, Ankara and the Istanbul forestry institutes (Karakurum, pers. comm. 1988). Conservation Management The area was established in order to protect one of the few remaining primaeval alluvial forests on the Black Sea coast (Karakurum, pers. comm. 1988). Normal forestry management policies are being followed and conservation master plans are being considered for future preparation. Management is currently restricted to prohibiting domestic livestock grazing and commercial timber extraction (Karakurum, pers. comm. 1988). Management Problems No information Staff Wardens Budget No information Local Administration Sinop Orman Mudiirliigii, Sinop. References Carp, E. (1980). A Directory of Western Palearctic Wetlands. [UCN/UNEP, Gland, Switzerland. Grimmett, R. (1986). Preliminary inventory of important bird areas in Turkey. International Council for Bird Preservation, Cambridge, England. Date January 1988 1543V Turkey - Ilgaz Dagi National Park Management Category II (National Park) Biogeographical Province 2.11.05 (Middle European Forest) 65 Geographical Location The park is located in the Black Sea region, midway between Kastamonu (45km) and Cankiri (60km), 200km north of Ankara. The park is located 5-6km north of the town of Ilgaz on the slopes of Avlagin Tepe, Kastamonu province. 40°55'N, 33°37'E Date And History Of Establishment Established in 1976 as a national park. Area 1,088ha Land Tenure State ownership Altitude ranges from 1,300-1,600m Physical Features Situated in the Ilgaz Daglari massif in a transition zone between central and northern Anatolia. The longest and more active fault line, the northern Anatolian Fault, passes through the northern slopes of the Ilgaz mountains. The bedrock consists of volcanic rocks, serpentine and schists. The topography is represented by steep mountain slopes culminating in crests at 1,600m. Climate Located in the climatic transitional zone between Black Sea and Central Anatolia regions. There is a Black Sea climate with characteristic high humidity and cool temperatures. Vegetation Altitudinal zonation results in gradually changing vegetation ranging from pine woods in the foothills to alpine steppe (General Directorate of National Parks and Wildlife, 1980). Pine forests are dominated by Scots pine Pinus sylvestris, black pine Pinus nigra and juniper Juniperus communis (General Directorate of National Parks and Wildlife, 1980). Highest elevations are dominated by alpine scrub and herbaceous vegetation. Fauna The rich woodland fauna includes roe deer Capreolus capreolus, boar Sus scrofra, brown bear Ursus arctos, wolf Canis lupus and fox Vulpes vulpes (General Directorate of National Parks and Wildlife, 1980). Cultural Heritage No information Local Human Population No information Visitors And Visitor Facilities Currently there are few facilities for visitors. A trout hatchery and fishing lake are available for sports fishing. Future projects include promotion of the park for recreation. Near the Catmali Pinar post a 1250 bed capacity accommodation is being planned as are camping and day-use facilities. After completion of these facilities a winter sports centre is to be developed (General Directorate of National Parks and Wildlife, 1980; Karakurum, pers comm, 1987). Scientific Research And Facilities A multi-purpose building is under construction (Kettaneh, 1980). Conservation Management The park was established with the aim of preserving the natural and recreational value of the region. Master plans have yet to be completed but it is proposed to include a protection zone and development and skiing zone (General Directorate of National Parks and Wildlife, 1980). Management Problems Future plans include the development of a number of zones for winter sport and tourist recreation, the result of which is likely to seriously affect the delicate montane ecosystem (Drucker, pers. comm. 1987). Staff One manager, one ranger, two wardens and one guard (Kettaneh, 1980). Budget 6,500,000TL (Kettaneh, 1980) Local Administration [lgazdagi Milli Park Mudiirliigii, Kastamonu. 66 References General Directorate of National Parks and Wildlife. (1980). National Parks of Turkey. Ministry of Forestry, General Directorate of National Parks and Wildlife, Ankara. Kettaneh, M.S. (1980). Protected area information sheet. IUCN, Gland, Switzerland. Date January 1988 Turkey - Yedig6ller National Park Management Category II (National park) Biogeographical Province 2.11.05 (Middle European Forest) Geographical Location Situated in the Black Sea region, 40km to the north of the town of Bolu and near to the town of Dirgine. 40°45'N, 31°40'E. Date And History Of Establishment Established as a national park on 24 April 1965. Area 2,019ha Land Tenure State ownership Altitude ranges from 700-1,600m Physical Features The park consists of part of the northern slopes of the Bolu massif (1954m), with steep slopes often susceptible to landslides. The bedrock tends to be derived from serpentine schists, limestones and volcanic materials. There are seven lakes (turkish: 'Yedi' seven and 'goller' lakes) which were formed as natural dams, after soil landslides blocked the mountain valleys. The lakes tend to be acidic and vary in altitude between 870m and 740m and in some cases are interconnected below ground. Climate Temperate climate equivalent to Balkan montane areas. Vegetation Mixed forest vegetation of western Black Sea region type, typified at lowest altitudes by species such as beech Fagus orientalis, oak Quercus cerris, black pine Pinus nigra and Scots pine P. sylvestris, fir Abies cilicica, elm Ulmus spp., hornbeam Carpinus spp. and sycamore Acer spp. The willow Salix spp., sycamore Acer spp. and alder Alnus glutinosa are most frequently found along the streams, and lime Tilia spp. on the hill slopes. In the upper regions the composition of the forest changes and poplar Populus spp, yew Taxus baccata, Scots pine P. sylvestris and fir Abies cilicica replace the beech dominant woodland (Drucker, pers comm, 1987). The ground and shrub vegetation includes rhododendron Rhododendron spp., hazel Corylus spp., bramble Rubus spp., bracken Pteridium aquilinum, Cyclamen spp. Sambucus spp., Crataegus laciniata, Crocus spp., Daphne gnidium, Urtica spp. and Geranium spp. (Drucker, pers. obs. 1987). Fauna Larger mammals in the reserve tend to be rare yet there are records of roe deer Capreolus capreolus, wild boar Sus scrofa, fox Vulpes vulpes, bear Ursus arctos, wolf Canis lupus, jackal C. aureus, wild cat Felis sylvestris, otter Lutra lutra and badger Meles meles. Birds include dipper Cinclus cinclus, long-eared owl Asio otus and eagle owl Bubo bubo. Introduced trout are also recorded from the lakes (Aktar, 1984). Red deer Cervus elaphus have been introduced into enclosures in the centre of the park (Drucker, pers. obs. 1987). Cultural Heritage Traditional forms of transport including the use of oxen are still to be found in the area (Drucker, pers comm, 1987). Local Human Population No inhabitants within the park. There are small village communities in the area. Visitors And Visitor Facilities Even though the site is relatively remote there are high visitor attendance figures (coach excursions from Istanbul and Ankara are common), and national park wardens are available to 67 assist in supplying information. Facilities and activities include sports fishing, camping, picnic sites, nature walks, cafes and simple bungalow accommodation. Scientific Research And Facilities Behavioural studies are being undertaken on the red deer Cervus elaphus, in a 26ha enclosure near the centre of the park. A local university college of science has been carrying out research on the zoology, botany and geomorphology of the park (Aktar, 1984). Studies are proceeding towards a request for the award of the European Diploma of the Council of Europe. Conservation Management The site has been designated to ensure the protection of the Yedigoller watershed, restore the balance of nature and act as a recreational area. Regulations exist which prohibit hunting, restrict fishing (1 May to 30 September) and prevent commercial timber extraction. A system of zonation results in areas being specifically set aside for tourism and recreation, for wildlife protection and for re-introduction of deer. The boundary of the park is fenced and there is a further enclosure for captive bred deer. There is a tariff for entry into the park and fees for hunting and fishing permits (Drucker, pers. comm. 1987). Management Problems Tourist pressure is high around the lakes, leading to widespread destruction of the natural ground vegetation and disturbance to any lake fauna (Drucker, pers. comm. 1987). Excessive hunting in the past has caused great damage to the wildlife populations in the area. Disturbance to the lake ecosystem has been caused by the repeated re-introduction of trout from an associated fish hatchery. Staff One manager, one ranger one zoologist, one warden and 10 guards (1980) Budget 6,000,000TL (1980) Local Administration Yedig6ller Milli Park miidiirliigii, Bolu. References Aktar, O. (1984). Yedigéller Milli Park. Ilgi 39: 2-6. Darkot, D. (1975). Géllerimiz. Redhouse Yayonevi, Istanbul. General Directorate of National Parks and Wildlife (1980). National Parks of Turkey. Ministry of Forestry, General Directorate of National Parks and Wildlife, Ankara. Giirpiner T. (1981). The Seven Lakes. Naturopa No.38 Date December 1987 Ukraine - Askaniya-Nova Zapovednik IUCN Management Category I and 1X (Strict Nature Reserve and Biosphere Reserve) Biogeographical Province 2.29.11 (Pontian Steppe) Geographical Location It is located in the southern Ukraine in the south-eastern part of the Prichernomorsky lowlands in the Chaplinski rayon of the Khersonski Oblast’, 25km north of the Sivash lagoon and 50km south-east of Novaya Kakhovka. 46°28'N, 33°55'E. Date and History of Establishment The first 'partially' protected reserve in Russia created in 1878 (for the acclimatisation of domesticated stock) and declared a reserve in 1921 with its present boundaries established in 1956. It was approved as a Biosphere Reserve in 1984. Area The biosphere reserve covers 33,307ha of which 11,054ha is declared a zapovednik. Land Tenure State owned Altitude Almost perfectly flat, with maximum drop (over 2,000ha) of 8m the rest being 30m above sea level. 68 Physical Features The plain in which the Reserve is situated slopes gently to the south and southwest, maximum difference of altitude being no more than a few metres. Of the numerous depressions known as 'pods' (2-8m in diameter and 10-20cm deep), the largest named Bol'shoy Chaplinskiy of 2,000ha, is periodically flooded in spring. Most of these pods are enclosed by hardly noticeable shallow channels whilst the larger ones have radial water collecting ditches 1-2m deep and 8-10m in width. Soils are a mixture of solonetz, southern chernozems and dark chestnut with scattered solonchak types. Rivers are absent and the water table is at 19-20m, although clay loess linings to the pods tend to retain accumulated water, sometimes into summer. The climate is dry with hot summers and short, cloudy and sometimes cold winters. The temperature range from -3.6°C in January to 23.4°C in July with annual mean of 9.4°C and an annual rainfall of only 380mm. Dry winds and dust storms occur in spring with wind speeds of 25 miles per second with frosts in October, snow cover is present from mid-December to March, with a thickness of 10cm. Climate No information Vegetation The feather grass steppe, the protection of which was a principal objective of this reserve, is dominated by the feather grasses Stipa lessingiana, S. ucrainica and S. capillata, together with fescue Festuca sulcata and crested hair grass Koeleria cristata. Herbaceous plants include abundant Pyrethrum millefoliatiatum, Galatella villosa, and Artemisia austriaca. Other typical species are Tulipa schrenkii and T. biebersteiniana, purple mullein Verbascum phoeniceum, Iris pumila, the plumbago Goniolimon tataricum and summer cypress Kochia prostrata. The swampy 'pods' have fox-tail Alopecurus pratensis, couch-grass Agropyrum pseudacaesum, sedge Carex praecox and in flooded places flowering rush Butomus umbettalus and Scirpus supinus. Over 4,117 steppe plant species have been recorded, dominated by the grasses, with 40 species endemic to the southern Ukraine, 56 species classified are rare in the 'Red Book SSSR' and a further ten as threatened. The total number of all plant species and subspecies is estimated as 3,378. Fauna The mammals of the steppe include European suslik Citellus citellus, hamster Cricetus cricetus, social vole Microtus socialis and a distinct subspecies of mouse Mus tataricus as well as polecat Putorius putorius. In total 18 mammals, six reptiles (Vipera ursini) and one amphibia have been recorded. Of the birds recorded, 16 are breeding and include the only site in the Ukraine for steppe eagle Aquila rapax as well as common species such as grey partridge Perdix perdix, stone curlew Burhinus oedicnemus, and short-toed lark Calandrella cinerea. During migration periods rarer species such as black stork Ciconia nigra, crane Grus grus, great bustard Otis tarda, demoiselle crane Anthropoides virgo, white-tailed eagle Haliaeetus albicilla and peregrine falcon Falco peregrinus are present and waterfowl such as whooper swan Cygnus cygnus and white-fronted goose Anser albifrons. Cultural Heritage The reserve has some archaeological and historical interest. Local Human Population No information Visitors and Visitor Facilities Tourism is restricted but recognised as one of the aims of the reserve. Scientific Research and Facilities The objective is to undertake long-term studies on the dynamics of the grazed steppe ecosystem and monitoring any changes due to human activities. Study of vegetation dynamics, and population dynamics and ecology of wild species of grazers and browsers, with special reference to developing methods of protecting the rarer species in the wild and improved acclimatisation to new localities, hybridisation and breeding of animals in semi-natural environments. Special attention will be given to geosystem monitoring similar to that being carried out at the Central Chernozem State Reserve. There are fully equipped laboratories, a museum, botanic and zoological gardens, breeding paddocks and a scientific library. Conservation Value No information Conservation Management Total protection afforded to zapovednik area. The strict nature reserve status is modified over certain areas by the introduction and acclimatisation of ungulates (such as Przewalski's horse, hartebeest, and gnu) and birds of the ostrich family under a paddock system and in conjunction with domestic stock. This area, the experimental stock-breeding zone, is managed by the Askania Nova Institute for steppe stock-breeding. At present, only 1,560ha is totally protected, the 69 remainder being set aside for pasture, hay, an arboretum of nearly 400 species and a zoo in which introduced species such as zebra Equus grevyi, E. zebra Przewalski's horse E. przewalskii, eland Taurotragus oryx, hartebeest Alcelaphus buselaphus, gnu Connachaetes gnou and saiga Saiga tatarica are reared with considerable success. In addition to ostrich, the Ratite birds in the collection include the lesser rhea Pterocnemia pennata and emu Dromais novaehollandiae. Total biosphere reserve covers 33,307ha which zoned into a strict protection area (the zapovednik) of 11,054ha, contains the only remaining unploughed pristine feather-grass steppe in Europe covering 1,500ha. There is also an experimental stock-breeding area of 17,453ha and an outer buffer zone 1km wide covering another 4,800ha. Management Constraints The reserve suffered damage during the war. Staff Fifty-eight of which 19 are researchers Budget 240,000 roubles Local Addresses 326332, Khersonskaya oblast’, Chaplinskiy rayon, ngt. Askaniya-Nova, Ukrainkaya SSR. References Babich, A. D. (1960). Ascania Nova steppe oasis. Kharkov. Bannikov, A. G. (1969) Reserves of the USSR. Publishing House Kolos, Moscow. 552 pp. Bannilov, A. G. (1974) Around the reserves of the USSR. 2nd Ed. Publishing House, Mysyl, Moscow. Borodin, A.M. and Syroechkovski, E.E. (1983). Zapovedniki SSSR Moskva, 'Lesnaya Promyshlennost". Date August 1986 Ukraine - Tchernormorsky State Reserve IUCN Management Category | (Strict Nature Reserve) Biogeographical Province 2.29.11 (Pontian Steppe) Geographical Location On the Black Sea coast, due east of Odessa, from the Dniepr-Bug estuary to Karkinitsky bay. 46°20'-47°N = LONGITUDE 32°30'-33°E Date and History of Establishment 1927 Area Previously 36,600ha (of which 9,500ha comprised the terrestrial area); now 71,889ha. Land Tenure State lands by law Altitude No information Physical Features The reserve includes several separate areas along the Black Sea coast, together with some islands in the Black Sea. The area is mainly flat-lying, formed from alluvial sediments and includes areas of standing water, both fresh and salt, sandspits and other coastal features. Mean temperatures range from -3.6°C (January) to 30°C (July) with 60 days below 0°C. Total rainfall is estimated at 350mm. Soils are sandy and saline. 70 Climate No information Vegetation This is of Ukrainian-Kazakh steppe type with sandy areas having associations of Festuca beckeri, Calamagrostis epigeios, wormwood Artemisia arenaria and Thymus sp. (5.2.2). More saline areas have steppe of Artemisia maritima, Suada maritima, Kochia prostrata and Festuca sulcata. Standing water and coastal zones have reeds Phragmites communis (5.6.2). Woody species include alder Alnus glutinosa and Quercus robur together with birch Betula and aspen Populus tremula forming "kolkis" association (1.2.5.1 and 1.2.5.2). The ground cover here includes lily of the valley Convalaria majalis and Solomon's seal Polygonatum officinale. Fauna Mammals include brown hare Lepus europaeus (capens), common vole Microtus arvalis, the thick-tailed 3-toed jerboa Styloiputelum and the red fox Vulpes vulpes. The reserve has outstanding numbers of migrating and over wintering birds. 260 species have been recorded. These include the great egret Egretta alba, whooper swan Cygnus cygnus, mute swan C. olor, shelduck Tadorna tadorna, gadwall Anas _strepera, red-breasted merganser Meirgus serrator, the only breeding place in the USSR of the Mediterranean gull Larus melanocephalus, slender billed gull L. genei, great bustard Otis tarda, little bustard, O. tetrax, long-eared owl, Asio otis and golden oriole Oriolus oriolus. 40 fish species are also present including mullets Mugil sp., and others. Cultural Heritage No information Local Human Population No information Visitors and Visitor Facilities No reports of tourism although earlier references cite availability of guided visits to the reserve. Scientific Research and Facilities Ecological studies of coastal ecosystems, steppe areas and bird ecology have been made. There are laboratories and facilities for sea transport. Conservation Value No information Conservation Management Total There is no zoning; this is a Strict Nature Reserve. Management Constraints Introduced species include the racoon dog Nyctereutes procyanoides and the Japanese sika deer Cervus nippon. Staff No information Budget No information Local Addresses Ukrainian SSR, Kherson regin, Golaya Prustan, Dneprovskaja Street No.1. References Works on the reserve are published periodically. Bannikov, A. G. (1969) Reserves of the USSR. Publishing House Kolos, Moscow. 552 pp. Bannilov, A. G. (1974) Around the reserves of the USSR. 2nd Ed. Publishing House, Mysyl, Moscow. 71 4.6 National Environmental Policy and Legislation Bulgaria Country Profile Area 110,911 sq. km Population 9,000,000 (mid-1989 estimate) Natural increase: 0.1% per annum Economic Indicators GDP: No information GNP: US$ 7,129 per capita (Anon., 1990) Policy and Legislation On 5 October 1908 Bulgaria declared its independence from Turkey and in September 1946 a People's Republic was proclaimed. The Constitution refers to nature conservation under Article No. 31 (1971). In Articles 22 and 23, proposals for designation of protected natural sites can be submitted by enterprises, institutions, organizations and by individuals. The new Constitution, enacted in 1991, treats the matter of the environment in a single text — Article 15 (Spiridonov ef al., 1991). Countryside protection dates from 1928 (Carter, 1977), when a "union for nature protection", the Council for the Protection of the Countryside, was formed. The first Conservation of Nature Act was issued in 1936 (Decree on protection of native nature) (Cerovsky, 1986; Spiridonov et a/., 1991). It established four categories of protected area and introduced species protection measures (Spiridonov ef al., 1991). Little more was achieved during the war of 1939-45 nor in the ten years that followed. A nature protection decree was formulated on 27 August 1960 and brought into force by rules published on 5 June 1961, with the legislation applying equally to reserves and national parks (Article 7 of the Rules) (IUCN, 1971). The 1967 Law on Nature Protection covers the preservation, restoration, rational use of nature and natural resources, monuments, historical sites, development of science and scientific research. This Law, and the 1969 Regulations for the Administration of the Law of Nature Protection, effectively repealed the Ordinance related to the protection of nature, and the Decree of 1960 (Spiridonov, 1991). According to the 1967 Law, there are five categories of protected area: nature reserve, national park, nature sanctuary, protected site and historical site. Buffer zones are managed according to Directive No. 4 (1980) of the Committee on Environmental Protection on the Council of Ministry (now the Ministry of Environment). Suggestions for establishment of protected areas can be made both by private bodies and by state organisations. The law determines the temporary protective status, defines the bodies responsible, research programmes and public support (Spiridonov et al., 1991). The duties of all organisations and agencies in the field of flora, fauna and habitat protection are further defined in a number of acts, including the Law on Protection of Air, Water and Soil against Pollution (1963), Nature Protection Law (1967), Water Law (1969), Law on protection of Cultivated Lands and Pastures (1973) Territorial and Settlement Organisation Law (1973), Hunting Enterprise Law (1982) and Fishing Enterprise Law (1982) (Spiridonov ef a/., 1991). Some other acts may also include relevant sections (ECE, 1986). The Komitet za opazvane na prirodnata sreda (KOPS) (Committee for Environmental Protection) of the Council of Ministers was established under state legislation in 1976. KOPS declares a locality or an object under protection, by order of the Committee's President, after consultation with the Academy of Science's Institute of Ecology and interested departments on whose territory the objects are located. These orders are published in the State Gazette. In 1977, a new document entitled "Guidelines for the Protection and Reproduction of the Environment in the People's Republic of Bulgaria" was approved by State Council (Cerovsky, 1986). This document covers environmental preservation, restoration and management policies and now plays a central role in formulating state environmental policy (Stoilov ef a/., 1981). Another major policy document written in the early 1980s was the General Plan of the People's Republic of Bulgaria. This treats the environment as a complex integrated 72 system. In particular, the sections dealing with "Recreation" and "Standard Regional Planning Measures" refer to the important role played by legally protected areas (Mladenova and Paychev, 1985). Resources needed for protection measures are provided for in five-year and annual plans adopted by the government and People's Assembly (parliament) (ECE, 1986). All land is state-owned and reserve boundaries are marked with symbols and occasionally fenced. Existing legislation in the field of nature protection is felt to be inadequate and inefficient. A draft Protected Area Act 1991 has been prepared and submitted by the Green Party (G. Spiridonov and L. Mileva, in Jitt., 1991). Other legislation at the discussion stage includes the Ecological Policy Law, Control of Pollution Law and two bills on Forestry Law (Spiridonov et a/., 1991). A Natural Heritage Charter has also been prepared and submitted by the Green Party (G. Spiridonov and L. Mileva, in Jitt., 1991). International Activities The Convention concerning the World Natural and Cultural Heritage (World Heritage Convention) was signed on 7 March 1974 and two natural sites inscribed in 1983. The Convention on Wetlands of International Importance especially as Waterfowl Habitat (Ramsar Convention) was signed on 24 September 1975 and the Paris Protocol instrument was signed on 27 February 1986; four Ramsar sites have been designated. Seventeen sites, covering 25,20lha, were accepted in 1977 as biosphere reserves under the UNESCO Man and the Biosphere Programme. The Berne Convention was ratified in 1991 principally as an instrument to conserve populations in protected areas (Spiridonov et al., 1991). The Institute of Ecology is active in international environmental conservation activities organised by Unesco, UNEP, FAO and CMEA. Progress is reported to have been made on the preparation of a Treaty for Environmental Protection of the Balkans (IUCN, 1991) and the first international meeting on the biodiversity of the Balkans Massif is to be held in 1992 (IUCN-EEP, in /itt., 1991). Administration and Management In 1971 the Ministry of Forests and Environmental Protection was established; it largely concentrated its attention on natural sites, establishing new reserves and improving those already in existence (Stoilov ef al., 1981). In 1972 the Research and Coordination Centre for Preservation and Restoration of Environment of the Bulgarian Academy of Sciences was established (Cerovsky, 1986)(see Annex). KOPS is the main governmental, inter-departmental coordinating and controlling body, the President is of ministerial rank and the Committee has 16 regional inspectorates and one scientific centre (Cerovsky, 1986). It had a staff of 400 and operated on one-year and five-year plans with a budget of 4,120 billion leva (1971-1981) with 500 million leva in 1989 destined specifically for nature protection (IUCN, 1991a). It had the task of controlling, coordinating and implementing the policy and decisions of the Central Committee of the Bulgarian Communist Party, the National Assembly, the State Council and the Council of Ministers on questions of environmental protection and restoration and water resource utilisation. The committee elaborates state plans on nature protection, as well as plans for research and development (ECE, 1986). The committee was also directed to establish a system to provide scientific data for matters relating to environmental protection. The Unified National System for Observation and Information on the State of the Environment was set up, which includes a subsystem of "Protected Natural Sites and Objects". A card index on protected natural sites has been prepared by the committee, as well as sets of methods for a comprehensive study of protected natural sites and objects (Stoilov et al., 1981). In December 1986 a ministerial council was set up at the Council of Agriculture, but abolished in 1987 when the Ministry of Agriculture and Forests was created (Ashley, 1988). At the party congress of April 1986, the Bulgarian Communist Party committed itself to a new "National Programme for Environmental Protection to the Year 2000 and Afterwards", a long-term ecological programme which largely concentrated on the control and reduction of pollution control. In May 1988 a Politburo decision recommended that KOPS be merged with the Ministry of Agriculture and Forests to create the new Ministry of the Land, Forests and Environmental Protection (Ashley, 1988). At the beginning of 1990, the Committee of Environmental Protection was replaced by the new Ministry of Environment (IUCN, 1991). Local elections and the general election of October 1991 will allow radical restructuring of administration, with the subsequent preparation of framework laws on environmental policy and protected areas (introducing IUCN categories into national legislation) (IUCN, 1991). The Institute of Ecology, 73 formerly known as the "Research and Coordination Centre for the Conservation and Renewal of the Environment" (NKCOVOS), at the Academy of Sciences, has worked alongside KOPS in designating protected areas. It is a research institute with a staff of 60 which coordinates ecological research within the Academy of Sciences and with other scientific research establishments and universities (Cerovsky, 1986). It is also active in international environmental conservation activities. It maintains lists and data describing protected areas (Fisher, 1990), and has prepared a programme on the scientific base and development of the protected areas system which proposed two-thirds of the existing reserves and two new national parks (Spiridonov et al., 1991). An Environmental Commission within parliament also deals with protected areas (Spiridonov ef al., 1991). Direct administration of protected areas falls to a number of bodies with varying levels of responsibility. Foremost is the Ministry of the Environment which carries out research, elaborates proposals and declares new protected areas, including document preparation, category assignment, boundary definition, financing basic and restoration research. The management body on "Conservation of Forestry and protected natural sites" is a department within the Ministry (Spiridonov ef a/., 1991). An Environmental Monitoring Centre is responsible for the control of regulations and coordination of management plans, through 16 regional inspectorates for environmental protection (Spiridonov, 1991). Others include Ministry of Forests and Forest Industry, Ministry of Architecture and Works, Balkan Tourist, Academy of Sciences, Nature Protection Commission, Ministry of Education, Committee of Arts and Culture, Academy of Agricultural Sciences and the Union of Hunters and Fishermen. The Committee of Forestry, municipal councils, agricultural and other authorities also are engaged in the direct management and protection of protected areas working closely with the land owners (Spiridonov, 1991). On-the-ground supervision of reserves is the responsibility of the Committee for Forestry and is carried out on a part-time basis by forest rangers. The local state forestry administration maintains individual protected areas, while large national parks have directorates. Over 90% of protected areas are managed by the Forestry Committee. These areas in the agricultural fund are entrusted to local municipalities and research institutes (Spiridonov et al., 1991). The control of reserves has been improved. Over 1,200 checks were carried out in 1977 and 160 violations were notified, falling in 1978 to 1,121 checks and 144 violations (Stoilov et al., 1981). Vertebrate fauna, threatened and rare species have been studied in 12% of nature reserves and in almost all national parks. Special attention has been given to research on wetland bird fauna and of higher plants on the Balkan Range reserves, under a joint ten-year programme by the Bulgarian Academy of Sciences and the Polish Academy of Sciences (IUCN, 1991a). Research stations have been established at Srebarna and Atanasovsko reserves (IUCN, 199 1a). Until 1990, voluntary environmental conservation groups were organised in the framework of the Patriotic Front, through a system of Committees for Nature Conservation at the Patriotic Front Councils on all levels. These were centralised in the All-National Committee for Nature Conservation at the National Council of the Patriotic Front, Obshchenarodniya Komitet za zashchita na prirodata, which promoted environmental awareness. The Union of Hunters and Fisherman was active in the field of conservation, while the Hiker's Union publicises natural sites within the country and promotes their care (Stoilov ef al/., 1981). "Ecoglasnost", a non- governmental organisation set up in early 1989 with a particular interest in ecological problems, has most recently transformed itself into a political forum, the Green Party (IUCN, 1991). It was a very influential movement involving a number of anti-pollution campaigns. In its "Charter '89", Ecoglasnost devotes considerable space to its policies on protected areas, which it suggests should be greatly expanded, with numerous new areas being designated in all biogeographical regions. Ecoglasnost is made up of local groups, about 50 in Sofia and 30 in the rest of the country. There is a possibility that it will become more involved in party politics in the future (Fisher, 1990). Recently, the Wilderness Fund, another non-governmental organisation, was set up. It aims to further the conservation of natural areas and to facilitate the self-recovery of areas that have suffered human alteration (Ivanov, 1989). Groups concerned with specific areas, such as the Rhodope Mountains, have also been created (IUCN-EEP, in /itt., 1991). Other prominent non-governmental organisations included the Bulgarian Society for the Protection of Birds, the Union for Nature Protection, the Association of Bulgarian Ecologists, Association Ecoforum, the Green Society Foundation, the National Ecological Club, the Ecos Foundation, the Ecoforum for Peace and the Scout Organisation of Bulgaria. Systems Reviews The country straddles the boundary between Continental and Mediterranean climates. It can be divided approximately into five regions: the fertile Danube plain in the north running along the border with 74 Romania; the Stara Planina Mountains, a large 600km mountain chain running east-west, dividing the country; the central plain and valleys of the River Maritsa immediately south of the Stara Planina; the mountains of the Rila Planina, Pirin Planina and Rodopi Planina in the south-west; and the relatively flat areas along the Black Sea coast (Grimmett and Jones, 1989). These approximate to the five recognised phyto-geographic regions of the country, namely the European broad-leaved forest region (Balkan province, Euxinian province, and Macedonian province), the Euro-Asian steppe and forest steppe provinces and the Mediterranean sclerophyll region (IUCN, 1991a). Lowlands (0-200m) cover 31% of the total surface area of the country; hills (200-600m) cover 41%; highlands (600-1,600m) cover 25% and mountains (over 1,600m) cover 3%. The climax vegetation is Quercus up to 1,000m, Fagus between 1,000m and 1,500m and coniferous woodland up to 2,200m, with some especially well-developed stands of Pinus peuce in the Rila, Pirin and Rodopi mountains. Under the initiative of the 1928 Council for the Protection of the Countryside, a number of bills and decrees were published and the first reserve was established in 1933, followed by the first national park, Mount Vitosha, in 1934. After this date few new areas were established until the 1960s. The total number of protected sites has risen from 50 in 1940 to about 130 in 1973 and to 3,922 in 1989. Most reserves (covering 33,000ha in total) were created between 1978 and 1985 on the recommendation of the Ecological and Environmental Centre of the Academy of Sciences, whilst three-quarters of the national parks were established in the period 1974 to 1988 (IUCN, 1991a). Three quarters of the reserves are over 1,000ha, with buffer zones. Some 82% of reserves and 89% of national parks are in mountainous areas (IUCN, 1991a). In 1989 these areas covered 195,155ha, or nearly 2% of the country (Anon., 1989), of which 30% are strict nature reserves (65,000ha) (IUCN, 1991). It was planned to increase this figure to 3% by the year 2000 (ECE, 1986), although current thinking is for an increase closer to 8% (IUCN, 1991). On 30 July 1991, there were 10 national parks (105,000ha), 96 reserves (66,500ha), 2,135 natural monuments (23,250ha), 79 protected areas (17,150ha), 973 historical places covering 12,200ha, giving a total of 224,000ha (Spiridonov et al., 1991). Zoogeographically, 77% of reserves belong to the Balkan and the Rila-Rhodopi Range. An inventory has been carried out of representative ecosystems covering areas over 1,000ha in separate reserves — over 20 forest formations have been catalogued. In 1982 forests covered 38,590 sq. km (35% of the land surface). More than 25% of forests are under special protection (ECE, 1986). More recent figures show that 34% of the country is under forests (35% conifers) in two categories, 71% commercial and 29% protection forests (IUCN, 1991a). The main wetlands lie along the Danube and the Black Sea coast. Many of the marshes and coastal lakes have been drained, largely for agriculture, and the remainder are particularly important for migratory bird species. The north-eastern part of the Black Sea coast has some remnant steppe areas. The lowlands have largely been converted to agricultural land, and in the uplands large areas have been devastated by grazing, mostly by sheep. Tourism and especially skiing are a potential threat to the remaining, less disturbed upland areas (Grimmett and Jones, 1989). In certain regions (sea coasts and mountains) the number of visitors to protected areas has grown as a result of urbanisation, road construction and the increase in motor traffic and access to sites. Nature trails are popular and are being constructed first of all in protected areas. Threats arise partly from the lack of sufficiently severe penalties, and from the non-application of governmental decrees. Cattle grazing is still allowed in some nature reserves, and poaching (hunting/fishing) continues to be prevalent in others. The major problems include: outdated legislation (new draft of protected areas law has been prepared, sponsored by the Green Party), inadequate administration, lack of qualified staff, insufficient funds for management and research: lack of a database, lack of training, and public education programmes. The future development of a protected areas system depends on the adoption of a law on protected areas, creation of an Agency for Management of Protected Areas, associated with the Ministry, the establishment of a Nature Conservation Fund and the creation of training and education programmes (Spiridonov, 1991). Addresses Ministry of the Environment, "William Gladstone" str. No. 67, SOFIA 1000 (Tel: 876151; FAX: 521634; Tlx: 22145 KOPS) Institute of Ecology, Academy of Science, Department of Protected Areas and Genetic Pool, ul. Gagarin 2, 1113 SOFIA (Tel: 720459; FAX: 705498) Committee of Forestry, Ar. No 17, Sofia Wilderness Fund, c/o Institute of Ecology, Academy of Science, Department of Protected Areas and Genetic Pool, ul Gagarin 2, 1113 SOFIA (Tel: 720459; FAX: 705498) Society for the Conservation of the Rhodopi Mountains, 2 Gagarin St, SOFIA 1113 iS References Anon. (1989). Protected natural sites: invaluable national heritage. Committee for the Protection of the Environment with the Council of Ministers of the People's Republic of Bulgaria. ECO facts and figures. Sofia Press, Bulgaria. Anon. (1990). PC Globe Inc.. Tempe, Arizona, USA. Ashley, S. (1988). Politburo Announces "New" Ecological Policy. Radio Free Europe 13(21): 9-13. Carter, F.W. (1978). Nature reserves and national parks in Bulgaria. L'Espace Géographique 1: 69-72. Cerovsky, J. (1986). Nature Conservation in the Socialist Countries of East Europe. East-Europe Committee, IUCN Commission on Education. Administration of the Krkonose (Giant Mountains) National Park, Vrchlabi. Cerovsky, J. (1988). Nature conservation in the Socialist countries of East Europe. East-Europe Committee, IUCN Commission on Education. Ministry of Culture of the Czech Socialist Republic, Prague. ECE (1986). Meeting Finland 25-29 August. ENV/SEM. 16/R.1. Fisher, D. (1990). Environmental Politics in Bulgaria. Report on a visit to Bulgaria 24-28 February 1990. Ecological Studies Institute, London. IUCN (1971). United Nations list of national parks and equivalent reserves 2nd Ed. Hayez, Brussels. IUCN (1991). The environment in Eastern Europe: 1990. Environmental Research Series 3. IUCN East European Programme, Cambridge, UK. IUCN (1991a). Environmental Status Report: 1990. Volume Two. Albania, Bulgaria, Romania, Yugoslavia. IUCN East European Programme, Cambridge, UK. Ivanov, L. (1989). Memorandum of Association of the Wilderness Fund. Sofia, Bulgaria. Unpublished. Johnson, H. and J.M. (1977). Environmental policies in developing countries. Erich Schmidt Verlag. Mladenova, M. and Peychev, V. (1985). Concept of the General Plan of the Peoples Republic of Bulgaria on Legally Protected Areas. In: Nedialkov, S. (Ed.), International Symposium "Conservation of Natural Areas and of the Genetic Material They Contain". Project 8, MAB-Unesco 23-28 September. Blagoevgrad, Bulgaria. Collection of reports. Three volumes. Jurautor, Sofia. Profirov, L. (1989). Internationally recognised nature reserves. In: Gerassimov, P. and Staleva, M. (Eds), Bulgaria, Special Issue. Sofia Press, Bulgaria. Spiridonov, J. (1977). Oazisi na divata priroda. Zemizdat, Sofia. (In Bulgarian) Spiridonov, J. and Juras, A. (1991). Nature Conservation in Bulgaria. In: Nature conservation in Europe. European Parliament Directorate-General for Research, Environment, Public Health and Consumer Protection Series 17. EN-9-1991. Stoilov, D., Noshtev, V., Gerasimov, S., Velev, V. (1981). Protected natural sites in the People's Republic of Bulgaria. Jurautor, Sofia. Definitions of protected area designations, as legislated, together with authorities responsible for their administration Title: The Law of Nature Protection; The regulations for the Administration of the Law of Nature Protection Date: 1967, 1969 (regulations) Brief description: Provides the legal regulation of protected areas and defines them Administrative authority: Komitet za opazvane na prirodnata sreda (KOPS) (Committee for Environmental Protection) (Ministry of the Environment) Designations: Rezervat (Strict nature reserve) Strictly protected areas containing rare plant and animal communities, threatened by depletion or extinction and used for scientific research. Economic exploitation, including any agricultural and industrial activities, is prohibited. Admittance to, and movement in reserves are restricted to defined roads and paths. 76 A special directive was adopted designating the creation of buffer zones around reserves. In exceptional circumstances clear felling is allowed for forest protection reasons. Naroden park (National park) Includes natural parks, which are comparatively large areas suitable for short-term recreation and tourism and for research. Other categories of protected areas may be included within the boundaries of national parks. Tourism development is encouraged especially by state enterprises such as Balkan Tourist. Entry is free and unrestricted. Tourism may be well developed in the form of road networks, tourist chalets, resthouses, restaurants, cable cars and camping sites. These areas have general protection throughout, with no settlement or exploitation allowed; hunting, fishing and flower-picking is forbidden. Some are zoned into a scientific zone (no exploration, visitors restricted to certain paths), a tourist zone (accommodation, tree-felling and afforestation) and a commercial forest zone. Natural monument Specific natural formation protected for its aesthetic and scientific significance, preserved for public interest due to national, geographic or scientific values as well as phenomena of aesthetic, natural or historical value, which includes single items, such as trees and rocks. Protected site Specific location with picturesque landscapes or characteristic habitats suitable for recreation. Historic site Site of major historical event, or historical monument or grave, as well as protected specific natural feature of the landscape, and their surrounding area. Certain sites are protected jointly by KOPS and the Committee for Culture and the Institute for the Monuments of Culture. Sources: IUCN, 1971; Stoilov et al., 1981 Georgia Country Profile Country profile is not completed for Georgia Romania Country Profile Area 237,500 sq. km Population 23,200,000 (1989) Natural increase: 0.5% per annum Economic Indicators GDP: No information GNP: US$ 6,453 per capita (Anon., 1990) Policy and Legislation Proposals for the protection of the landscape and natural monuments date back to 1907. The first Nature Protection Act came into force on 7 July 1930. A new Act passed in October 1950 (No. 237) on the Protection of Natural Monuments was complemented by Order of Council No. 518 of 1954. In the same year an Environment Protection Law was introduced, to be replaced by the Environmental Law passed in 1973 (No. 9/1973). Section VI, Article 29 of this Law specifies the official concept governing a national park, the legislative framework and the procedure for creating such protected areas (Oarcea, 1984). Protected areas are classified into: science reserve or nature reserve (rezervat natural), parcul natural (nature park), parcul national (national park) (see Annex). Forests are protected by the 1954 Forest Code and the subsequent 1962 Forest Code. In 1976, a national programme to protect and develop forest resources was initiated. Full protection is afforded to about 14% of 77 forest cover (Pop et al., 1965), with a further 36% of forests classified as "protective forest", where restrictions on forest operations, in some cases, result in complete protection. The scientific research category was one established (until 1990) by either the Commission for the Protection of Natural Monuments of the Academy of Sciences or by the Ministry of Forest Economy, whilst areas under the soil conservation category (on slopes over 35°) were subject to total protection, operated jointly by the Commission and the Ministry. In April 1991, Decree No. 264 established a new ministerial structure consisting of six departments (IUCN, 1991b). The government has also passed a number of decrees (Decree No. 983, 27 August 1990) which created the Danube Delta Biosphere Reserve (of 674,000ha) (IUCN unpublished reports, 1991). Law No. 9/1980, although not yet mandatory, deals with the preparation of feasibility studies for all projects likely to have an effect on "the preservation of the genetic stock". Approval is given by the Commission for Monuments of Nature of the Romanian Academy. A new law for environmental protection is drafted. Articles 38, 41, 48 and 49 define the preservation of specific biological diversity through the declaration of nature reserves; the creation of a national network of protected natural areas and monuments of nature; defines biosphere reserves, national parks, nature reserves and natural monuments; the preparation and updating of a catalogue of protected areas and a Red Data Book of plants and animal species; and describes the creation of additional types of protected areas for species protection and use of gene banks (Negoita et al., 1991). International Activities Romania has been involved in the Unesco Man and the Biosphere (MAB) programme (three areas were declared as biosphere reserves in 1979, with a fourth site added in 1990), and accepted the Convention concerning the World Natural and Cultural Heritage (World Heritage Convention) on 16 May 1990, proposing one site for listing. Romania acceded to the Convention on Wetlands of International Importance especially as Waterfowl Habitat (Ramsar Convention) in 1991 with one site listed on accession. Administration and Management In 1930, as a consequence of the Nature Protection Act, a Commission for Natural Monuments was established within the Ministry of Agriculture and Landed Estates. In 1950, a new Commission, the Commission for Natural Monuments of the Romanian Academy of Sciences (Comisia pentru Ocrotirea Monumentelor Naturii Academii Republici Socialiste Romania) was created, consisting of a Chairman and eight members. The Commission acted as the main coordinator of research and nature conservation activities, with field projects and monitoring carried out by university biology and geography departments and by other academic institutes. A scientific research base was established at Timisoara. Up until 1989, the supreme authority for environmental matters was the National Council for Environment Protection (Consiliul National pentru Conservarea Mediului) at the Council of Ministers which came under the National Council for Science and Technology (Consiliul National pentru Stiinta si Tehnologie). It was, however, ineffectual, because it had no budget and relied upon volunteers (IUCN, 1991a). Another influential body was the Academy of Agricultural and Forestry Sciences (Academia de Stiinte Agricole si Silvice) (Cerovsky, 1986). The nature conservation administration was organised on a regional basis with the three constituent territories of Transylvania, Moldavia and Walachia divided into 40 regions, Bucharest making 41. The Commission parallels this structure with sub-commissions for the Protection of Natural Monuments in Cluj-Napoca (set up in 1933), in Craiova (set up in 1936) and in Iasi (set up in 1938). At the lower administrative level, each region had a local committee (responsible to the People's Council), in charge of wildlife conservation with representatives from forestry, hunting, fishing, agriculture, and education (Cerovsky, 1986; Kirby and Heap, 1984). These were often quite efficient with regard to maintenance and conservation of sites (IUCN, 1991a). The Commission has a staff of specialists (biologists, forest engineers) and administrative personnel. Its main responsibility is to designate new science reserves (for which proposals are prepared) and to administer reserve areas (including national parks), although it carries out only limited management work. It has the right to intervene in all questions concerning road construction, siting of industrial developments and tourist camps, and any activity which is liable to deteriorate the reserves or degrade the landscape. The regional offices have staffs of approximately 200. Due to the fact that the statutes regulating the organisation and functioning of the park do not provide management guidelines to appropriate authorities, the national park lacks proper administration (IUCN, 1991a). 78 Each science reserve has at least one warden (guardian), who regulates access and controls grazing rights as well as preventing illegal entry, fishing, and hunting. The reserve guardian may be an employee of the national forest service and as such is often responsible for economic forest land in addition to his duties on the reserve (Kirby and Heap, 1984). Reserves located outside forest lands are administered by the former town and county halls (county popular councils). Often they are poorly protected and have been converted to agriculture on industrial uses (IUCN, 1991a). Since mid 1990, a new Ministry of Water Management, Forests and the Environment has been set up, which operates through the existing 41 regional offices, namely, survey and environmental protection agencies (Negoita et al., 1991). The national park comes under the administration of the Commission, a function soon to be given to The Ministry's Department of the Environment (Vadineau, pers. comm., 1990). Within the Ministry of Environment, there are departments for water and forests. In April 1991, Decree No. 264 established a new ministerial structure consisting of six departments: departments of Biodiversity and Nature Conservation; Integrated Monitoring; Systems of Research and Impact Assessment; Forestry and Water; Enforcement and Public Relations, and Risk Assessment in Nuclear Plants (IUCN, 1991b). A Commission for the Environment and Ecological Balance was established at the level of the legislative and is attached to the House of Deputies. Its members are all deputies, and it has the support of a team of technical experts in environment. Its primary role is in environmental legislation. Similarly, Commissions for the Protection of the Environment have been formed in the regional town and county halls, consisting of one or two permanent councillors and staffed, at present, by volunteers. These local commissions await confirmation in national laws. There is also a board of inspectors for the environment for each county and a County Agency for the Protection of the Environment (IUCN, 1991a). The Society for Tourism and Nature Protection was created in 1920, followed in 1922 by another voluntary body, the Mountain Brotherhood (Cerovsky, 1988). Groups formed more recently include the Ecological Movement of Romania (Miscarea Ecologista Din Romana) (MER), which at one time consisted of 112 local groups, had 100,000 members and 29 specialist working parties. It seems to have largely disappeared following the general elections in May 1990 (IUCN, 1991b), the Romanian Ornithological Society (Societatea Ornithologica Romana) and the Ecological-Cultural Party. Each has a general interest in protected areas (Fisher, 1990). In the last year or so, several new several new non-governmental organisations concerned with nature conservation have emerged, such as the Danube Delta Society, which is a nationwide grouping created to support environmental protection throughout the country. It has a staff of 5 to 10 with offices in Bucharest. The other new non-governmental conservation body is "Unesco" Ecological Club, based at the University of Bucharest, with a sub-office in Iasi and is expected to operate as clubs within universities for promotion of environmental education (Vadineanu, pers. comm., 1991). Systems Reviews The country is divisible into lowlands less than 200m (33%), hills and highlands between 200m and 300m (36%) and mountains averaging 800m (31%). Forests cover between 20% and 27% (Kirby and Heap, 1984; Cerovsky, 1986). There are three main vegetation zones; steppe in the south-east (largely under agriculture), forest-steppe in the centre of the country and montane forests in the Carpathians (Davis et al., 1986). The lowlands are intensively cultivated, as is most of the Danube valley, with nearly all natural and semi-natural vegetation restricted to the mountains where most of the forests are also to be found (IUCN, 1991a). Many of the natural forest stands have been destroyed over the last 300 years with oak woodlands reduced from the original 10 million ha to 1.2 million ha. Some 27.6% of the country is forested with 10% in the lowlands (below 150m), 70% on hill districts (150m-170m) and 60% is the mountain (700m and above). The dominant species is beech (30% of total deciduous cover which amounts to 69%). Of the conifers, 22% of the total is spruce (IUCN, 1991). Proposals for the protection of the landscape and natural monuments date back to 1907. In the 1980s, the Commission for Protection of Natural Monuments, in collaboration with the General State Forest Management Inspectorate, constructed a concept for the elaboration of a national park system, consisting of at least 12 parks. The study dealt with establishment criteria, organisation and management and preparatory studies covering four new national parks. In the early 1980s there were between 300 and 310 nature reserves covering 0.5% of the country (Alexandrowicz, 1982; Ionescu ef al., 1985). By 1986 this had risen to 420 nature reserves and one national park (Cerovsky, 1986) covering 222,545ha (Boscaiu, 1985). 79 Up to the end of 1989, there was only one designated national park with a further 11 in preparation (Cerovsky, 1988). In 1990, these 11 national parks were declared by forest authorities, but awaits formal recognition, and one further national park, Dracea, has been proposed. Together, those areas cover 664,057ha (2.79% of the country), which includes buffer and pre-park zones and also the proposed extensions to Retezat National Park. By 1991, one national park (21,000ha) and almost 400 science reserves (107,900ha) as well as a further 31 sites (364ha) classified as "monuments of nature" had been designated (IUCN, 1991a). This, however, covers only 0.42% of the country's area. Most recently, the government passed a number of decrees (Decree No. 983, 27 August 1990) which created the Danube Delta Biosphere Reserve (of 674,000ha) (IUCN unpublished reports, 1991). Once declared, all the national parks will cover 154,057ha, and all protected areas 664,057ha which will be 2.74% of the country. The aim is to designate 5% of the country's surface on protected areas (Hopkins, in Jitt., 1991). The natural environment is presently threatened by a combination of factors such as industrial pollution, intensification of agriculture (with 30% of arable land affected by soil erosion (IUCN 1991b) and tourism. For example, Rosca-Letea Biosphere Reserve has until recently been threatened by agricultural development plans, which have now been halted. However, the affects from upstream pollution sources are still a threat. Due to excessive felling and inadequate afforestation, young woodlands predominate. Acid rain has changed 5.5% of the forests (TUCN, 1991a). Addresses Department of the Environment, Ministry of Water Management, Forests and the Environment, R-Bucharest-Artera Noiia N-S, Tronson 5-6, Sector 5, BUCHAREST (Tel: 316044; Tlx: 10455/10435; FAX: 316199) References Alexandrowicz, Z. (1982). Wielkoprzestrzenne obszary rezerwatowe Rumunii. Chronmy Przyrode Ojczysta 38(6): 134-137. Boscaiu, N. (1985). Le dévéloppement d'un systéme de réserves pour la protection de la flore de Roumanie. In: Nedialkov, S. et al. (Eds.) International Symposium "Conservation of Natural Areas and the Genetic Material they Contain". Project 8 on the Programme "Man and the Biosphere" (MAB) of Unesco, 23-28.09.1985, Blagoevgrad, Bulgaria. Vol II, BAN, Sofia. Pp. 171-178. Cerovsky, J. (1986) (Ed.). Nature conservation in the Socialist countries of East-Europe. East-Europe Committee, [UCN Commission on Education, Administration of Krkonose National Park, Vrchlubi. Cerovsky, J. (1988) (Ed.). Nature conservation in the Socialist countries of East-Europe. East-Europe Committee, IUCN Commission on Education, Ministry of Culture of the Czech Socialist Republic, Prague. Davis, S.D., Droop, S.J.M., Gregerson, P., Henson, L., Leon, C.J., Lamlein Villa-Lobos, J., Synge, H., and Zantovska, J. (1986). Plants in danger: what do we know? Threatened Plants Unit. IUCN, Gland, Switzerland, and Cambridge, UK. 461 pp. Fisher, D. (1990). Developments within the environment movement. Romania. 10-12 March 1990, 28 March-8 April 1990. Unpublished report. Horeau, C. and Cogran, I. (1981). Rezervatii naturale si monumenti ale naturii din judentul Vaslui (nature reserves and natural monuments). (Unseen) Ionescu, M. and Condurateanu-Fesci, S. (1985). Parcuri si Rezervatii Naturale Pe Glob. Colectia Cristal, Bucuresti. IUCN (1971). United National List of National Parks and Equivalent Reserves 2nd Edition. Hayez, Brussels. IUCN (1991a). Environmental Status Reports: 1990 Volume Two. Albania, Bulgaria, Romania, Yugoslavia. IUCN East European Programme. IUCN (1991b). The Environment in Eastern Europe: 1990. Environmental Research Series 3. YUCN East European Programme. Kirby, K.J. and Heap, J.R. (1984). Forestry and Nature Conservation in Romania. Quarterly Journal of Forestry 78(3): 145-155. Negoita, R.T. and Juras, A. (1991). Nature Conservation in Romania. In: Nature Conservation in Austria, Finland, Norway, Sweden, Switzerland, Bulgaria, Czechoslovakia, Hungary, Poland, Romania, Yugoslavia and the Soviet Union. European Parliament Directorate-General for Research. Environment, Public Health and Consumer Protection, Series 17. EN-9-91. (90% of material straight copy of IUCN, 1991a). 80 Oarcea, Z. (1984). The evolution of the conception and the principles governing the creation and the setting up of the Retezat National Park. In: Pascu, S. et al. (Eds.), Recherches écologiques dans le Parc National de Rétézat. Travaux du Symposium du 13 avril 1984. Cluj-Napoca. Pp. 27-31. Pop, E. and Salageanu, N. (1965). Nature reserves in Romania. Meridiane Publishing House, Bucharest. Resmerita, I. (1983). Conservarea dinamica a naturii. Edit Stiinfica si encicilopedica Bucuresti. (Unseen) Seghedin, T.G. (1983). Rezervatiile naturale din Bucovina. Nature reserves in Bukovina. Edit Sport-turism, Bucuresti. (Unseen) Definitions of protected area designations, as legislated, together with authorities responsible for their administration Title: Environmental Law (No. 9/1973) Date: 1973 Brief description: Section VI, Article 29 provides the official concept governing national parks and the legislative framework and procedure for creation of protected areas Administrative authority: Department of the Environment in the Ministry of Water Management, Forests and the Environment Designations: Protected areas are classified into national park, nature park and nature reserve categories: Science or nature reserve (Rezervat natural) Divided into seven categories classified as mixed forest, botanical, zoological, geological, morphological, palaeontological and speleological. Ecosystems within nature reserves are under complete protection, and access is subject to special authorization, with tourists allowed to enter by special permit only. Several have strictly defined protected areas or scientific research zones, where, house construction and quarrying is not allowed without authorisation. Nature park (Parcul natural) Would protect large areas of the landscape. These are still at a planning stage and lacking legal guidelines. National park (Parcul national) Category has three basic functions: scientific, socio-educational and economic, and is divided into two sectors; a strictly protected zone and a protected zone. The strictly protected zone has complete protection with no permanent residence allowed, no pasturing but some biological control of insect pests is permitted. In the protected zone, hunting is forbidden, but fishing is allowed in some lakes, subject to fish stocks. Grazing of domestic stock is also permitted in July and August, and tourism is encouraged (Retezat National Park). Sources: Alexandrowicz, 1982; Cerovsky, 1988; IUCN, 1971; Oarcea, 1984 Title: Forest Code Date: 1962 (revision of 1954) Brief description: Defines types of protection and lays down restrictions on forest operations Administrative authority: Ministry of Water Management, Forests and the Environment Designations: Five categories are defined: 81 Soil conservation and the reduction of avalanches; the protection of water supplies; the use of forests for recreation; for landscape protection specifically surrounding urban, industrial, tourist and health zones; and as scientific research areas protecting rare fauna, geological and speleological formations. Source: Kirby and Heap, 1984 Russia Country Profile Russia Country Profile is not yet completed. Turkey Country Profile Area 778,000 sq. km Population 55,868,000 (1990) Natural increase: 1.95% per annum Economic Indicators GDP: US$ 1,295 per capita (1987) GNP: US$ 1,200 per capita (1987) Policy and Legislation In 2 October 1923 the National Assembly declared Turkey a republic, effectively dissolving the former Ottoman Empire. The present Constitution dates from 7 November 1982. Asia Minor was the cradle for one of the great ancient civilisations of the Mediterranean and has over the millennia been settled by ancient Egyptians, Phoenicians, Carthaginians, Romans, Byzantines and more recently by the Selcuk and other eastern dynasties. A detailed understanding of the environment was well known 5,000 years ago and the ancient Egyptians and subsequent civilisations carefully protected mountain forest resources as valuable timber reserves, imperative for constructing their vast navies. Between 370 and 285BC Theophrastus of Erosos was the first great botanical writer of classical antiquity and his works on botany, plant ecology and the environment were known throughout Asia Minor. Pedanios Dioscorides of the first century AD, a native of Cilicia near present day Adana, was renowned for his work on botany. The Byzantine emperors inherited and developed the agricultural and environmental practices developed throughout the Roman Empire, almost certainly maintaining forest administration structures and wardening systems right up till the Mediaeval period (Drucker, in /itt., 1985; Mallatt, in /itt., 1991). Traditional forms of protection continue to include a limited number of "sacred groves" and trees which are still protected in Turkey, including at Harbiya near Antakya, and traditional forms of rangeland protection which were prevalent amongst the nomadic steppe and mountain tribes (cf the Mahmeya of Syria and the Hema protection of the Arabian Peninsula) (Drucker, in itt., 1991; Khatib in Jitt., 1991). Under Ottoman law, forests came under the jurisdiction of a forest administration. Forest legislation was primarily concerned with controlling tree felling by the issue of permits, and the transportation of wood for local industry and export to neighbouring countries. Environmental legislation was covered under the Ottoman civil code (Mejellah), within the body of Islamic law. Under Article 1243 it was defined that land and the associated trees growing wild in mountains could not be possessed and should remain ownerless. Under Article 1244 cutting wood on private forests was not permitted without authorisation, infringement resulting in payment for damage caused. The Land Law was enacted in 1856, and the Forest Regulations in 1869. These laws have been incorporated into Forest Law No. 3116 and Hunting Law No. 3167,which came into force in 1937 (General Directorate of Forestry, 1987; Drucker, in /itt., 1985). The modern concept of the protected nature conservation area was introduced in 1949, with legal establishment of national parks coming into being on 5 September 1956, under Forest Law No. 6831. The law categorised forest ownership into state forest, forests of public institutes and private forests; being further sub-divided into protection forests, national parks and production forests. Articles 3, 23 and 25 gave the Ministry of Forestry the 82 authority to designate areas as national parks and national forests, as well as to provide for the inclusion of privately-owned lands (the Forest Law was amended in 1983 Act No. 2896 with sole emphasis on forests). Protected area designations include national park (milli park), nature park (tabiat parklari), natural monument (tabiat aniti), natural reserve area (tabiati korum alani) and special protected area, in addition to game breeding and protection area, game breeding station, game reintroduction area, biogenetic or nature conservation area (Forestry Defence Property) and recreation area (see Annex). In 1983 the Ministry of Agriculture, Forestry and Rural Affairs (Tarim Orman ve Koyisleri Bakanligi) enacted the current National Park Law No. 2873 in order to establish the principles governing the selection and designation of national parks, natural monuments and nature reserve areas; a law concerned with the protection, development and management of such protected areas without spoiling their natural characteristics. In the same year the Environment Law No. 2872/1983, with prime objectives of general protection of the environment and the prevention of pollution, enacted by the Ministry of Environment. Under this Law zones of special protection of the environment, special protected areas, can be declared. An enabling act of 19 October 1989 provided for protected zonation within these areas (see Annex). The purposes of the present National Park Law are: a) to establish the principles governing the selection and designation of protected areas of national and international value; and b) ensure protection, development and management of such places without spoiling their natural characteristics. There are 25 articles cited in the Law: Article 2 defines the four main protected area categories; Article 5 specifies that land can be nationalised in accordance with the Law on Expropriation No. 6830; Article 7 states that permissions for all activities are granted through the Ministry of Agriculture and Forestry, except for historic and archaeological sites (which come under the jurisdiction of the Ministry of Culture and Tourism); Article 8 concerns land-lease permits which expire after 49 years, after which time all facilities should be transferred to the Treasury. It is possible to extend the lease of land to 99 years; however, Article 10 states that no land-use permission may be granted in areas of national monuments and nature reserve areas; Article 16 refers to protection services and prosecution by forest guards in accordance with Forest Law No. 6831. Articles 17, 18 and 19 deal with the national park fund (see below). Penalties are dealt with in Articles 20-23 (see Annex). National forests (state forests) are established to preserve nature and some urban and/or agricultural land from erosion. Many types of management are prohibited according to Item 23 of the Forest Law. Forest recreation areas are established for touristic, cultural and public recreational purposes (General Directorate of Forestry, 1987). In addition to the protected areas governed by the National Park Law, a series of game forest sites is established on state forest and notified under Hunting Law No. 3167, 1937: game breeding and protection areas, game breeding stations, game reintroduction areas and biogenetic or nature conservation areas (General Directorate of Forestry, 1987) (see Annex). Additional laws relating to protected areas include Law No. 1380, 1971 for the protection of water resources, management and improvement; Culture and Natural Resources Protection Law No. 2863, 1983 for the protection of natural and cultural sites and resources (administered by the Ministry of Culture and Tourism). In 18 November 1988 the Law of the Bosphorus was enacted in order to protect the cultural, historic and scenic beauty of the Bosphorus region. In 1990 a coastal law was adopted which would delimit the coastal zone and prohibit building within this area. International Activities At the international level, Turkey has entered a number of cooperative agreements and legal obligations. Turkey is party to the Convention concerning the Protection of the World Cultural and Natural Heritage (World Heritage Convention), which was ratified on 16 March 1983. One natural site and one mixed cultural and natural site have been inscribed on the World Heritage list. In 1989 Turkey has gave its intention that it will sign the Convention on Wetlands of International Importance especially as Waterfowl Habitat (Ramsar Convention). The Convention for the Protection of the Mediterranean Sea against Pollution, usually known as the Barcelona Convention, has been formally adopted by Turkey. The contracting parties to the Convention adopted the Protocol concerning Mediterranean Specially Protected Areas on 2 April 1982, which entered into force on 23 March 1986. By 1989 three sites had been listed as representative of the Mediterranean network. 83 Although Turkey is not a member state of the European Community and not party to the 1979 EC Wild Birds Directive, 79 important bird areas (cf EC special protection areas) have been identified (Grimmett and Jones, 1989). Turkey is a member of the Council of Europe: two sites have been designated as biogenetic reserves and one site has been awarded the Council of Europe European Diploma. In 1976 Bird Paradise (Kuscenetti) National Park was awarded the European Diploma Site award; the diploma was renewed in 1981, 1986 and 1991. Turkey ratified the Convention on the Conservation of European Wildlife and Natural Habitats (Bern Convention) in 1984. Under the Mediterranean Environmental Technical Assistance Programme (CY90-92 METAP) of the World Bank, European Investment Bank, United Nations Development Programme and Commission of the European Communities, representatives from Turkey attended the first meeting of the Mediterranean Protected Areas Network (MEDPAN) meeting on 5-6 October 1990 in Monaco (Anon., 1990). Assistance has come through the Global Environment Facility (GEF) fund, METAP financing for project preparation and GEF financing for investment of the Menderes Wetland programme (Anon., 1990). There is one transboundary park: Gala Golu Proposed Reserve and Evros Delta Reserve in Greece, but there is little or no interaction or cooperation between the countries in either of these areas. An initiative where Turkey is taking the lead is towards the development of an UNEP-sponsored regional seas programme for the Black Sea, for which Turkey has already sponsored a technical meeting with the other circum-Black Sea countries, the USSR, Romania and Bulgaria (Jeudy de Grissac, in /itt., 1991). Administration and Management Responsibility for the main protected areas lies with the Ministry of Agriculture, Forestry and Rural Affairs (Tarim Orman ve Koyisleri Bakanligi), General Directorate of Forestry (Orman Genel Miidiirliigii). It is headed by a Director General and four assistant general directors. Of the eight main service units, those that deal directly with protected areas are the Department of National Parks (Milli Parklar Dairesi Baskanligi), the departments of Forest Protection and Fire Control and the Department of Forest Management and Planning. The duties of the Department of National Parks include: a) to select, protect, plan, develop, administer and operate the various categories of protected area indicated in the National Parks Law, as well as to undertake work relating to the National Park Fund; b) to conserve and develop wildlife and game resources, to manage hunting, and to undertake work relating to undertaking inventories, project preparation, planning and application (General Directorate of Forestry, 1991). The General Forest Directorate is divided into a provincial organisational network, with regional national park directorate offices either based within the provincial forest establishments, such as at Antalya Bolge, or as separate entities such as at Dilek Milli Park. These can be further subdivided into chief offices for each national park (General Directorate of Forestry, 1987). Research activities are undertaken primarily by the Forestry Research Institute at Ankara and the Forestry School at Istanbul, which are involved in projects throughout Turkey. An investigation and survey team has been set up by the National Park Office at Ankara to investigate new proposed protected areas. Subsequent work is to prepare management plans for each nature reserve once established. All proposed reserves are on state forest property (Karakurum, pers. comm., 1987). The National Parks Fund has been established under the authority of the Ministry of Agriculture and Forestry, to meet the expenditures incurred in the protection, repair, maintenance, publicity and operation of the facilities located in areas covered by the National Park Law, 1983. In 1985 approximately TL 300 million was expended on park management (General Directorate of Forestry, 1987). The National Park Fund consists of: allocations made from the budget of the Ministry of Agriculture and Forestry; proceeds obtained from the use and operation of areas covered by the Law; as well as entrance fees and revenues obtained from the sale of all kinds of publications. The Fund has been granted an annual budget (see National Park Law No. 2873, Articles 17-19). In National Park Law No. 2873 the views of the Ministry of Culture and Tourism and the Defence Ministry must be taken into account (Article 4). The ministries of Education, Tourism and Information and State Planning Organisation are also given some responsibilities, both directly and indirectly, for management of national parks. 84 Master management plans for two major national parks were drawn up with the assistance of the US National Park Service in the 1960s and early 1970s. These plans are still used and tend to concentrate on recreation management with a limited amount of information about fauna and flora or habitat conservation and management (General Directorate of Forestry, 1987). From early 1988 the Authority for the Protection of Special Areas (Ozel Cevre Koruma Kurumu Baskanligi) of the Ministry of Environment (Cevre Bakanligi) has had jurisdiction over the newly-created designation of special protected area, based on the orders within the Environment Law (Vurdu, in Jitt., 1991). There are approximately one million registered hunters, providing up to TL 200 million in revenue each year (Karakurum, pers. comm., 1987). The principal active non-governmental conservation organisations include the Society for the Protection of Wildlife (Dogal Hayati Koruma Dernegi) (DHKD) and the Environmental Problems Foundation of Turkey (Tiirkiye Gevre Sorunlari Vakfi). The former, funded partly by the International Council for Bird Preservation (ICBP), is largely involved with conservational education, and the latter with environmental issues and legislation. Other smaller organisations include the Environment and Woodlands Protection Society (Cevre Koruma ve Yesillendirme Dernegi) and the Turkish Association for Conservation of Nature and Natural Resources (Tiirkiye Tobiatini Koruma Dernegi). The greatest management constraints have included the lack of adequate nature conservation skills and technical support within the General Directorate of Forestry. Although the major national parks have master management plans, they tend to be inadequate as they were drawn up in the 1960s, with an emphasis on tourism rather than nature protection. Lack of coordination between government agencies and of cooperation of government bodies with NGO groups tends to be a major problem. Systems Reviews Consisting of Turkey in Europe (western Thrace and Istanbul) and Turkey in Asia (comprising the whole of Asia minor or Anatolia), the country extends from Greece and Bulgaria in the west, across the Aegean Sea to the western frontiers of Iran, Soviet Armenia and Georgia and from the Black Sea to the Mediterranean and the northern boundaries of Syria and Iraq. Turkey is renowned as an important centre of floristic diversity. There are up to 2,400 endemic plant species in a country which is the meeting point of three phytogeographical regions: Euro-Siberian, Mediterranean and Irano-Turanian elements. There are also Balkan and Alpine elements in the flora. Endemism is lowest in Turkey in Europe where endemic species are almost absent. Endemism is highest in the Irano-Turanian region, especially near Erzincan, Erzurum, the mountains south of Lake Van and on gypsacaceous chalk near Cankiri and Sivas; also the Lycian and Cilician Taurus in the Mediterranean region. Boreal and Tertiary relicts are abundant east of the Melet River in the north-east. The three regions consist of a) the Irano-Turanian, which comprises two sub- phytogeographical areas; degraded sub-Mediterranean scrub and forest and a treeless steppe in central Anatolia and an Artemisia steppe which gives way to black pine forest and cistus scrub; b) Euro-Siberian or Euxine, a northern belt of broad-leaved deciduous forest of oriental beech and oak extending at greater altitudes into fir and scots pine forest, ranging from the Black sea to above 1,500m; and c) Mediterranean, consisting of maquis, degraded maquis (phrygana), through cedar forest to spiny cushion communities above 1,000m in the Taurus mountains and Aegean coast (Davis et al., 1986; Green and Drucker, 1990). Wetlands are an important feature. Approximately 60% are freshwater (1,343 million ha). The most important sites include Meric tributary, Gala Lake, Manyas Lake, Apolyont Lake, Sultansazligi marshland, Eber Lake, Aksehir Lake, Karamuk Lake, Beysehir Lake, Egridir Lake, Menderes, Tuz golu, Seyfe Lake, Akyatan Lagoon, Yumurtalik Lagoon, Goksu, Bafra and Homtamis Lake (Grimmett, 1986; Karakurum, pers. comm., 1988). Land-use is divided into forests with a total of 20.2 million ha (25.9%), meadows and pasture 25 million ha (32.2%) and wetlands 1.3 million (1.7%). Agricultural areas represent 27,699,000ha (35%) of the country (General Directorate of Forestry, 1986). The total area of forest is divided into 8.9 million ha (44%) of productive forest and 11.3 million ha (56%) of low grade or no yield status (General Directorate of Forestry, 1987). 85 An investigation and survey team has been set up by the National Park Office at Ankara to investigate new proposed protected areas (Karakurum, pers. comm., 1988). Emphasis is on establishing nature reserve areas, on state forest land, from an original short list of approximately 90 proposed sites (Karakurum, pers. comm., 1987). A total of 81 proposed nature reserves was identified by 1987, with the intention of designating sites over forthcoming years at a rate of approximately seven sites per year (Orman Genel Baskanligi, 1987; Official Gazette No. 18132; Karakurum, pers. comm., 1987). Studies on the selection and establishment of nature protection areas began in 1956, and by 1987 eleven natural, one historic, two landscape, one reserve and one natural monument were set aside as national parks covering a total of over 250,000ha. This rose to a total of 21 national parks in 1990 with a total area of 263,575ha. By autumn 1987 five natural reserve area sites had been designated and a further two were in the process of being approved by the Ministry. This had risen to 18 sites totalling 25,492 ha in 1991. In 1988 the first two special protected areas were declared, rising to 11 by 1991. In 1981 at least 295,759ha were protected in 36 national forests (Orman Genel Baskanligi, 1987; Official Gazette No. 18132; Karakurum, pers. comm., 1987). In 1990, in addition to the protected areas governed by the National Park Law, there were 83 game breeding and protection areas totalling 1.1 million ha; 27 game breeding stations; 20 game reintroduction areas; seven biogenetic or nature conservation areas set up on Forestry Defence Property (General Directorate of Forestry, 1987). Approximately 180 recreation areas were established between 1956-68 and 1968-1979. By the late 1980s there was a total of 260 recreation areas (General Directorate of Forestry, 1987). Environmental problems include a lack of legal regulations relating to effective conservation in national parks. There has been no monitoring of the protection status of game reserves or breeding stations (General Directorate of Forestry, 1986). The prime management and environmental problems in Turkey are believed to be: a) "improved" agriculture and the resultant loss of wetland ecosystems and former grazing land; b) pollution from pesticides and fertilisers; c) building development, especially due to the manifold increase in tourism since the early 1980s along the entire Mediterranean coastline; and d) hunting of threatened species such as ibex, brown bear, wolf and some of the large cats, even though hunting is regulated and their status is largely unknown (Grimmett and Jones, 1989). Other Relevant Information In the 1960s the numbers of visitors to national parks approached 500,000. In 1985 about 10 million visitors made use of the national parks. Forest recreation areas are established for touristic, cultural and public recreational purposes and by 1987 there had been 30 million visitors to these areas (General Directorate of Forestry, 1987, 1991). Addresses Milli Parklar Dairesi (National Parks Department), Orman Genel Miidiirliigii, (General Directorate of Forestry), Tarim Orman ve Koyisleri Bakanligi (Ministry of Agriculture, Forestry and Rural Affairs), 11 No. lu Bina, Gazi, ANKARA (Tel: 4 212 6300; FAX: 4 222 5140) Kultur ve tabiat varliklanni Koruma Genel Miidiirliigii (General Directorate for Preservation of Natural and Cultural Heritage), Kultur Bakanligi (Ministry of Culture), II TBMM Ulus, ANKARA (Tel: 4 310 6338/324 3049; FAX: 4 3109112) Ozel Cevre Koruma Kurumu Baskanligi (The Authority for the Protection of Special Areas), Cevre Bakanligi (Ministry of Environment), Koza Sokak 32, GOP 06700, ANKARA (Tel: 4 140 6919/140 855152; FAX: 4 140 8553/6914) Dogal Hayati Koruma Dernegi (DHKD) (Society for the protection of wildlife), PK 18, Bebek 80812, ISTANBUL (Tel: 1 163 6324; FAX: 1 163 6324; Tlx: 26534 rada tr) The Environmental Problems Foundation of Turkey (EPFT), Kennedy Cad 33/3, Kavaklidere, 06660 ANKARA (Tel: 4 1 255508; FAX: 4 118 5118) Turkiye Tabiatini Koruma Dernegi (TTKD) (Turkish Society for the Protection of Nature and its Resources), Menekse Sokak No 29/4, Kizilay, ANKARA References Anon. (1970-71). National park concept in Turkey and its development. Miméo. 17 pp. Anon. (1991). Mediterranean Environmental Technical Assistance Program, activity report Spring, 1991. World Bank, European Investment Bank, United Nations Development Programme and Commission of the European Communities. 24 pp. 86 Bayer, Z. (1970). Nature Conservation and National Parks in Turkey. Natur- und Nationalparke 8(29): 33-35. Bayer, Z. (n.d.). Turkey. Unpublished report. 7 pp. Canakeioglu, H. (1987). Effects of pesticides on bird populations. Uluslararasi Simpozyum — Turkiye ve Balkan Ulkelerinde Yaban Hayati 16-20 September. Environmental Problems Foundation of Turkey (1987). Environmental law and its application in Turkey. EPFT, Ankara. General Directorate of Forestry (1980). Forest recreation areas of Turkey. General Directorate of National Parks and Wildlife, Ministry of Forestry, Ankara. General Directorate of Forestry (1986). Hunting and wildlife in Turkey (Turkiye'de av ve yaban hayati). Tarim Orman ve Koyisleri Bakanligi (Forest and Village Affairs), Orman Genel Miidiirliigii, Ankara. General Directorate of Forestry (1987). Forestry in Turkey. General Directorate of Forestry, Ministry of Agriculture, Forest and Rural Affairs, Ankara. General Directorate of Forestry (1980). The protected areas situation in Turkey. General Directorate of National Parks and Wildlife, Ministry of Forestry, Ankara. Paper prepared by M. Savas for presentation to the Third Man and Biosphere Meeting on Mediterranean Biosphere Reserves and the First IUCN-CNPPA meeting for the Middle East and North Africa, 14-19 October 1991, Tunis. 3 pp. Green, M.J.B. and Drucker, G.R.F. (1990). Current status of protected areas and threatened mammal species in the Sahara-Gobian Region. World Conservation Monitoring Centre, Cambridge, UK. 50 pp. Grimmett, R. (1986). Preliminary inventory of important bird areas in Turkey. International Council for Bird Preservation, Cambridge, UK. 888 pp. Grimmett, R.F.A. and Jones, T.A. (1989). Important bird areas of Europe. International Council for Bird Preservation, Cambridge, UK. Hunter, B. (Ed.) (1991). The Statesman's Year Book 1991-92. The Macmillan Press Ltd, London and Basingstoke, UK. 1692 pp. Istanbullu, T. (1976). Some aspects of national parks as a result of Nature Conservation in Turkey. Natur-und Nationalparke 15(52): 31-32. Kettaneh, M. and Ozbaykal, N. (1980). National parks and protected areas of Turkey. Report prepared for the 17th meeting of IUCN Commission on National Parks and Protected Areas. Garoua, Cameroon, 17-23 November 1980. Mursaloglu, B. (1987). The effects of pesticides and fertilizers on wildlife in Turkey. Uluslararasi Simpozyum — Turkiye ve Balkan Ulkelerinde Yaban Hayati. 16-20 September. Official Gazette (1983). Milli Parklar Kanunu. Official Gazette, 11 August 1983, No. 18132. Orman Genel Miidiirliigii (1987). Milli Parklar Kanunu. Tarim Orman ve Koyisleri Bakanligi, Milli Parklar Dairesi Baskanligi, Orman Genel Miidiirliigii, Ankara, Turkey. Orman Genel Miidiirliigii (1987). Av Mevsimi Merkez Av-Komisyonu Karari, 1987-1988. Tarim Orman ve Koyisleri Bakanligi, Orman Genel Miidiirliigii, Ankara, Turkey. Packard, F.M. (1958). Report on a survey of potential national parks and recreational areas in Turkey. [UCN, Morges, Switzerland. Turan, S. (1987). The works of animal protection propagation and management of hunting. Ulus/ararasi Simpozyum — Turkiye ve Balkan Ulkelerinde Yaban Hayati. 16-20 September 1987. Zengingonul, I. (1987). Tourism and hunting in Turkey. Uluslararasi Simpozyum — Turkiye ve Balkan Ulkelerinde Yaban Hayati. 16-20 September 1987. Definitions of protected area designations, as legislated, together with authorities responsible for their administration Title: National Park Law No. 2873 Date: 11 August 1983; 5 September 1956 (Forest Law No. 6831) Brief description: Also concerned with the protection, development and management of such protected areas without spoiling their natural characteristics. Administrative authority: General Directorate of Forestry (Orman Genel Miidiirliigii) Designations: 87 National park (Milli park) By definition, a national park is principally state-owned land of at least 500ha that carries high natural, historical, archaeological, recreational, scientific and aesthetic values and in which wood gathering, timber cutting, mining, and hunting is prohibited. Zonation within the parks include: 1) protection zone, where at least one third of the total land is protected against all usage except for scientific research; 2) buffer zone, areas adjacent to the protection zone which can be used for touristic and/or recreational purposes (up to one third of total land); and 3) settlement zone, areas where settlement may take place if the existence of such constructions improves the park's characteristics or, at least, does not destroy them. Article 13 states that the following activities shall not be permitted: a) the spoiling of the natural and ecological equilibrium; b) the destruction of wildlife; c) interference of any kind which would cause change of natural character or appearance of the park (or pollute soil, water or air or cause other similar environmental problems); d) extraction of forest products, hunting, grazing which will spoil the natural equilibrium may not be carried out; e) except for facilities specified in approved plans or for the requirements of the Turkish General Defence Staff, no facilities may be built. Article 4 concerns the preparation of a development plan for each site and its implementation by the Ministry of Agriculture and Forestry; Article 5 specifies that land can be nationalised in accordance with the Law on Expropriation No. 6830 and Article 6 concerns expropriation of governmental land or acquisition of Ministry of National Defence land; Article 7 states that permissions for all activities are granted through the Ministry of Agriculture and Forestry, except for historic and archaeological sites (which come under the jurisdiction of the Ministry of Culture and Tourism); Article 8 concerns permission required to build touristic complexes in national parks and nature parks. Article 11 is concerned with exploration for oil and minerals; Article 13 concerns management to ensure continuation of multi-purpose usage: production, hunting and domestic livestock grazing may be permitted in certain areas; Article 14 identifies prohibited activities (see Annex). Article 15 concerns the occupation and utilisation of property belonging to public administration and public institutions. Article 16 refers to protection services and prosecution by forest guards in accordance with Forest Law No. 6831. Articles 17, 18 and 19 deal with the national park fund (see below). Penalties are dealt with in Articles 20-23. Nature Park (Tabiat parklari) Natural area containing characteristic vegetation and wildlife features, and is also suitable for recreational activities. Two sites have been designated, those of Corum city-Catak and Oliideniz-Kidrak. In both cases special tourist facilities but no other buildings are permitted. Natural monument (Tabiat aniti) Natural area of scientific value, which was created by nature or natural phenomena and now protected within the framework of the principles on national parks. Article 10 states that no land-use permission may be granted in areas of monuments and nature reserve areas (see provisions of Law No. 2863 for the protection of cultural and natural assets); there have not yet been any specific studies on this class of protected area. Natural reserve area (Tabiati korum alani) Natural area designated for use only for scientific and educational purposes, containing rare, threatened or endangered ecosystems and/or species and outstanding natural landscape or geological features. Article 10 states that no land-use permission may be granted in areas of monuments and nature reserve areas (see provisions of Law No. 2863 for the protection of cultural and natural assets); Sources: Original legislation; Karakurum, pers. comm., 1987 Title: Environment Law No. 2872/1983 Date: 9 August 1983; enabling decree of 19 October 1989 88 Brief description: Also concerned with the protection, development and management of such protected areas without spoiling their natural characteristics. Administrative authority: Ozel Cevre Koruma Kurumu Baskanligi (The Authority for the Protection of Special Areas), Cevre Bakanligi (Ministry of Environment) Designations: Specially protected area Declared with the objective of protecting the environment, with its rich diversity of natural and historic variety as well as for the protection of flora and fauna of national importance. Regulations ensure that development projects including tourist activities, are stopped pending re-evaluation by environmental impact assessments. These sites are selected to include only those which are of international importance. The 1989 decree ensures the designation of zonation within these areas. Source: Ozel Cevre Koruma Kurumu Baskanligi, in /itt., 1991 Title: Hunting Law No. 3167 Date: 1937 Brief description: Also concerned with hunting and the protection, development and management of areas for hunting and breeding of game on state forest-land Administrative authority: Orman Genel Miidiirliigii Designations: Game breeding and protection areas Areas for the protection of game and endangered species Game breeding stations Areas for the purpose of breeding game and wild animals Game reintroduction areas Areas where game has been reintroduced into habitats where the species has disappeared or has a very small population Biogenetic or nature conservation areas Areas established for protection of endemic, endangered or internationally important fauna and flora on Forestry Defence Property Source: General Directorate of Forestry, 1987 Ukraine Country Profile Area 603,700 sq. km (Hunter, 1991) Population 51,704,000 (Hunter, 1991) Natural increase: no information Economic Indicators GDP: No information GNP: No information Policy and Legislation The Ukraine was one of the founding sovereign nations signing the United Nations Charter on 26 June 1945. In July 1990 parliament made a declaration of sovereignty, and on 5 December 1991 89 the Ukraine officially declared itself no longer part of the Soviet Union, following the referendum vote for independence on the 1 December. In the 1978 Constitution of the Ukrainian Soviet Socialist Republic general provisions for nature protection were included in Article 65 "citizens ... are obliged to protect nature and to conserve its riches". The unified Environmental Code is specified in the Ukrainian Law on the Protection of Nature of 1960 . Specific provisions on the protection of flora, fauna and their habitats were made in the Ukrainian Law on the Protection and use of Wildlife of 1981 and the Ukrainian Forest Code of 1979 (Anon., 1986a). The Status of State Nature Reserves enacted by the Council of Ministers of the USSR on 27 November 1951, together with the relevant regulations of the Republics, has been revised in the 1981 Act. The Supreme Soviet Law (also of 1981) includes regulations on protected natural areas and measures to ensure wildlife protection (Articles 21-26). The legislative status of state nature reserves (zapovedniki) is based on Article 21 (Section 6 on creating preserves and reserves) and Article 25 (on protection of animals in preserves, reserves and other protected areas) (see the annex in USSR text). Some of the first protected areas were set up as Imperial hunting reserves, such as the Crimean State Forest and Hunting preserve in 1913, the same site becoming the first zapovednik of the Soviet State in 1923. Zapovedniki are defined as tracts of land containing natural resources, withdrawn from their original landowner, administered as permanent nature preserves by a state or republic level ministry, for the purpose of preserving floral and faunal resources in their natural habitats (Newcombe, 1985; see legislation text for the USSR). International Activities A network of wetlands of international importance has been established under the Convention on Wetlands of International Importance especially as Waterfowl Habitat (Ramsar Convention), which was ratified by the USSR on 11 October 1976. The former Ukrainian SSR was actively involved in developing a network of biosphere reserves under the Unesco MAB programme, two sites having been established in 1984 and 1985, respectively. The USSR signed the Convention Concerning the Protection of the World Cultural and Natural Heritage (World Heritage Convention) on 12 October 1990 but no sites are situated in the Ukraine. Administration and Management In 1985, as with the whole of the USSR at the time, state protected areas were under the jurisdiction of all-union ministries (see text for the USSR). The Ukrainian SSR Ministry of Forestry governed the main protected areas (Newcombe, 1985). In 1986 a state committee of the Ukrainian SSR on nature protection was formed in the Republic to manage environmental policy and to coordinate activities of other bodies, inter alia, for the protection of flora, fauna and their habitats (Anon., 1986). Systems Reviews The Ukraine, formerly in south-west European USSR, borders Poland, Romania, Czechoslovakia, Hungary, Byelorussia and the Russian Republic. The region largely consists of open plains with low hills, the Carpathian mountains lie in the south-west of the country and the River Dnieper passes through the territory. Steppes and primary forests still occur in many parts of the country, such as in the Carpathians mountains. The Crimea has developed an unique flora and fauna, with over 2,400 plant species, which include numerous endemic species dating back to the Tertiary period. There are important wetlands on the Black Sea coast (Newcombe, 1985; Davis ef al., 1986; Cerovsky, in litt., 1991). Up to 480,000 sq. km of the country is under cultivation. In 1976 a book of rare and endangered animals and plant species, A Red Data Book of the Ukraine, was published; listed organisms include 18 species of insect, four species of amphibian, six species of reptile, 28 species of bird, 29 species of mammal and 151 species of vascular plant (Anon., 1986a). Protected areas in the 1980s included 5,000 sites under special protection totalling 8% of the Ukraine; this included two national parks totaling 170,694ha, 13 state zapovedniki totaling 159,000ha and 202 hunting reserves (four alone covering over 173,000ha). There are two biosphere reserves representing 121,000ha. Wetlands and important bird sites are protected by 200,000ha of Ramsar wetlands of international importance and 24 important bird areas recognized to be of European regional importance by IWRB and ICBP (Grimmett and Jones, 1989). Among the state nature reserves being set up are new landscape, forest and general zoological subcategories, including the Zhukov Ostrov Forest Area, Turye-Polyansky and Rechansky in the trans-Carpathian region. A proposed national park 90 is located at Dnepro-Desnyanskiy and Verchnednepproskiy; a national park in the Chernobyl fallout zone was being considered in 1988 (Anon., 1986a, 1986b; Gensiruk, 1985: Milne, 1988). Environmental constraints are varied, ranging from extremely high levels of atmospheric pollution, from coal, chemical, and ore industrial centres, to loss of wetlands (figures indicate a total wetland loss of up to 2.2 million ha); to large scale excavation operations (Hunter, 1991). Dneprovsko-Teterevskoe State Hunting Reserve lies partly within Zone A (total evacuation area) of the Chernobyl reactor accident site and extensive nuclear contaminants have inevitably been recorded here and elsewhere within the region (Anon., 1986b). Other Relevant Information The southern Black Sea coast of the Crimean Peninsula prior to independence was one of the busiest resort areas in the Soviet Union. Addresses Former State Committee of the Ukrainian SSR on Nature Protection, KIEV References Anon. (1986a). Organisation of the preserved territories network in Ukrainian SSR. International Symposium "Protection of Natural Areas and the Genetic Fund they Contain" Project No. 8 on the Programme Man and Biosphere (MAB) of Unesco, 23-28 September 1985, Blavoevgrad, Bulgaria. Pp. 11-17 Anon. (1986b). What reserves were affected by the Chernobyl accident? Commission on National Parks and Protected Areas Newsletter 36: 1. Bannikov, A.G. (1969). (Ed.). Zapovedniki Sovetskogo Soyuza. Kolos, Moscow. 552 pp. Braden, K. (1986). Wildlife reserves in the USSR. Oryx 20: 165-169. Davis, S. D., Droop, S. J. M., Gregerson, P., Henson, L., Leon,C. J., Lamlein Villa-Lobos, J., Synge, H., and Zantovska, J. (1986). Plants in danger: what do we know? Threatened Plants Unit. IUCN, Gland, Switzerland and Cambridge, UK. 461 pp. Hunter, B. (Ed.) (1991). The Statesman's Year Book 1991-92. The Macmillan Press Ltd, London and Basingstoke, UK. 1692 pp. Knystautas, A. (1987). The natural history of the USSR. Century, London. 224 pp. Milne, R. (1988). Chernobyl disaster zone to become national park. New Scientist. 15 September 1988. P. 34 Newcombe, L.F. (1985). Protected natural territories in the Crimea, USSR. Environmental Conservation 12(2): 147-155. Sokolov, V.Y. and Syroechkovskogo, Y.Y. (Eds). (1985). Zapovedniki SSSR. 11 volumes. Mysl, Moscow. Weisenburger, U. (1991). Nature conservation in the Soviet Union. In: European Parliament Director-General for Research Nature Conservation. Environment, Public Health and Consumer Protection Series 17. IN-9-1991. Pp. 140-149. a This information is correct at the time of going to press, but is likely to be overtaken by events which could alter the legislative, administrative and management structure of protected areas throughout the region. As of September 1991 the constituent republics of the former Soviet Union included: Armenia, Azerbaijan, Belorussia (Bielorussia or Belarus), Georgia, Kazakhstan, Kirgizia, Moldavia (Moldova), the Russian Republic (RSFSR) and its Baltic enclave of Kalingrad, Tadzhikistan, Turkmenistan, Ukraine and Uzbekistan. 91 5. ENDANGERED ANIMAL SPECIES OF BLACK SEA STATES 5.1 Introduction This species review contains the following information: Guide to the IUCN (World Conservation Union) Red List Categories and Criteria Guide to the interpretation of CITES Appendices Guide to the interpretation of CMS Appendices Summary table of species richness (fauna and vertebrates only) and regional endemism List of species of fauna not globally threatened but of special concern in Europe List of globally threatened vertebrates restricted to Europe Summary table of all IUCN Red List species of fauna occuring in the Black Sea range States Globally threatened plants endemic to one country bordering the Black Sea Globally threatened plants occurring in more than one country bordering the Black Sea This report is a preliminary review of species of conservation concern occuring in and around the Black Sea. This information is presented in two ways: 1) Species of global conservation concern, and 2) species, which are not globally threatened but are of conservation concern in Europe. 5.2 Recommendations for further work on endangered Black Sea fauna In order to assess the priority species for conservation occurring in and around the Black Sea it would be necessary to analyse: 1. Those national endemic species with a predominantly Black Sea coastal distribution 2. The national conservation status of coastal species occurring in the Black Sea Range States 3. The globally and nationally threatened species with a Black Sea Coastal distribution 4. The important breeding areas for national endemics, globally and nationally threatened species with a Black Sea Coastal distribution (c. 4 days) 5. Discussion, priorities and recommendations (c.2-3 days) Activities 1-3 would cost between 5-10 days. The cost of activity 4 would be dependent on the map scale and number of species determined in activities 1-3, but at a first estimate this would take approximately four days. Activity 5 would cost between 2-3 days. Total: 8-16 days. 5.3 Guide to the IUCN (World Conservation Union) Red List Categories and Criteria The international threat (Red List) category given to the fauna was derived from the application of the new IUCN (1994) criteria. Since not all plants have been re-evaluated using the new criteria, the old IUCN Red List Categories are still operative for flora. The category of threat provides an assessment of the likelihood of extinction under current circumstances. IUCN is in the process of developing guidelines for the use of national red list categories. IUCN (the World Conservation Union) established a system to categorise species and subspecies according to estimated risk of extinction. The system and categories used (Endangered, Vulnerable, Rare etc.) became widely used. The new IUCN Red List category (November 1994) was designed to be more objective and repeatable. There are eight IUCN categories: Extinct (EX) Extinct in the Wild (EW) Critically Endangered (CR) (threatened)* Endangered (EN) ee 92 Vulnerable (VU) sae, Lower Risk (LR) Data Deficient (DD) Not Evaluated (NE) Note: *All taxa listed as Critically Endangered qualify for Vulnerable and Endangered, and all listed as Endangered qualify for Vulnerable. Together these categories are described as 'threatened’. Listing in the categories of Not Evaluated and Data Deficient indicates that no assessment of extinction risk has been made, though for different reasons. Until an assessment is made, species listed in these categories should not be treated as if they were non-threatened, and it may be appropriate (especially for Data Deficient forms) to give them the same degree of protection as threatened taxa, at least until their status can be evaluated (IUCN, 1996). The Criteria for the Categories of Threat The three categories of threat described above are determined by quantitative criteria. There are five criteria in all (A-E), which are based on variables associated with extinction risk. The criteria A-D also have subcriteria that are used to justify the listing of the species under a given category and which provide further information to support the listing under a certain category. Declining Population Small Distribution and Decline or Fluctuation Small Population Size Very Small Population Size and Decline Quantitative Analysis (e.g., Population Viability Analysis) NOadAWS> The Criteria for Critically Endangered, Endangered and Vulnerable Prepared by the IUCN Species Survival Commission As approved by the 40th meeting of the IUCN Council, Gland, Switzerland 30 November 1994 Critically Endangered (CR) A taxon is Critically Endangered when it is facing an extremely high risk of extinction in the wild in the immediate future, as defined by any of the following criteria (A to E): A Population reduction in the form of either of the following: 1.An observed, estimated, inferred or suspected reduction of at least 80% over the last 10 years or three generations, whichever is the longer, based on (and specifying) any of the following: a direct observation b an index of abundance appropriate for the taxon c a decline in area of occupancy, extent of occurrence and/or quality of habitat d actual or potential levels of exploitation e the effects of introduced taxa, hybridisation, pathogens, pollutants, competitors or parasites. 2.A reduction of at least 80%, projected or suspected to be met within the next ten years or three generations, whichever is the longer, based on (and specifying) any of (b), (c), (d) or (e) above. 93 B Extent of occurrence estimated to be less than 100 km2 or area of occupancy estimated to be less than 10 km2, and estimates indicating any two of the following: 1.Severely fragmented or known to exist at only a single location. 2.Continuing decline, observed, inferred or projected, in any of the following: extent of occurrence area of occupancy area, extent and/or quality of habitat number of locations or subpopulations number of mature individuals onaao on 3.Extreme fluctuations in any of the following: a extent of occurrence b area of occupancy c number of locations or subpopulations d number of mature individuals C Population estimated to number less than 250 mature individuals and either: 1.An estimated continuing decline of at least 25% within 3 years or one generation, whichever is longer or 2.A continuing decline, observed, projected, or inferred, in numbers of mature individuals and population structure in the form of either: a severely fragmented (i.e. no subpopulation estimated to contain more than 50 mature individuals) b all individuals are in a single subpopulation. D Population estimated to number less than 50 mature individuals. E Quantitative analysis showing the probability of extinction in the wild is at least 50% within 10 years or 3 generations, whichever is the longer. Endangered (EN) A taxon is Endangered when it is not Critically Endangered but is facing a very high risk of extinction in the wild in the near future, as defined by any of the following criteria (A to E): A Population reduction in the form of either of the following: 1.An observed, estimated, inferred or suspected reduction of at least 50% over the last 10 years or three generations, whichever is the longer, based on (and specifying) any of the following: a direct observation b an index of abundance appropriate for the taxon c a decline in area of occupancy, extent of occurrence and/or quality of habitat d actual or potential levels of exploitation e the effects of introduced taxa, hybridisation, pathogens, pollutants, competitors or parasites 2.A reduction of at least 50%, projected or suspected to be met within the next ten years or three generations, whichever is the longer, based on (and specifying) any of (b), (c), (d), or (e) above. 94 B Extent of occurrence estimated to be less than 5000 km2 or area of occupancy estimated to be less than 500 km2, and estimates indicating any two of the following: 1.Severely fragmented or known to exist at no more than five locations. 2.Continuing decline, inferred, observed or projected, in any of the following: extent of occurrence area of occupancy area, extent and/or quality of habitat number of locations or subpopulations number of mature individuals oa0Qo0oo pnp 3.Extreme fluctuations in any of the following: a extent of occurrence b area of occupancy c number of locations or subpopulations d number of mature individuals Cc Population estimated to number less than 2500 mature individuals and either: 1.An estimated continuing decline of at least 20% within 5 years or 2 generations, whichever is longer, or 2.A continuing decline, observed, projected, or inferred, in numbers of mature individuals and population structure in the form of either: a severely fragmented (i.e. no subpopulation estimated to contain more than 250 mature individuals) b all individuals are in a single subpopulation D Population estimated to number less than 250 mature individuals. E Quantitative analysis showing the probability of extinction in the wild is at least 20% within 20 years or 5 generations, whichever is the longer. Vulnerable (VU) A taxon is Vulnerable when it is not Critically Endangered or Endangered but is facing a high risk of extinction in the wild in the medium-term future, as defined by any of the following criteria (A to E): A Population reduction in the form of either of the following: 1.An observed, estimated, inferred or suspected reduction of at least 20% over the last 10 years or three generations, whichever is the longer, based on (and specifying) any of the following: a direct observation b an index of abundance appropriate for the taxon c a decline in area of occupancy, extent of occurrence and/or quality of habitat d actual or potential levels of exploitation e the effects of introduced taxa, hybridisation, pathogens, pollutants, competitors or parasites 2.A reduction of at least 20%, projected or suspected to be met within the next ten years or three generations, whichever is the longer, based on (and specifying) any of (b), (c), (d) or (e) above. B Extent of occurrence estimated to be less than 20,000 km2 or area of occupancy estimated to be less than 2000 km2, and estimates indicating any two of the following: 95 E years. 1.Severely fragmented or known to exist at no more than ten locations. 2.Continuing decline, inferred, observed or projected, in any of the following: extent of occurrence area of occupancy area, extent and/or quality of habitat number of locations or subpopulations number of mature individuals oadapn 3.Extreme fluctuations in any of the following: a extent of occurrence b area of occupancy c number of locations or subpopulations d number of mature individuals Population estimated to number less than 10,000 mature individuals and either: 1.An estimated continuing decline of at least 10% within 10 years or 3 generations, whichever is longer, or 2.A continuing decline, observed, projected, or inferred, in numbers of mature individuals and population structure in the form of either: a severely fragmented (i.e. no subpopulation estimated to contain more than 1000 mature individuals) b all individuals are in a single subpopulation. Population very small or restricted in the form of either of the following: 1. Population estimated to number less than 1000 mature individuals. 2. Population is characterised by an acute restriction in its area of occupancy (typically less than 100 km2) or in the number of locations (typically less than 5). Such a taxon would thus be prone to the effects of human activities (or stochastic events whose impact is increased by human activities) within a very short period of time in an unforeseeable future, and is thus capable of becoming Critically Endangered or even Extinct in a very short period. Quantitative analysis showing the probability of extinction in the wild is at least 10% within100 Guide to the interpretation of CITES (Convention on International Trade in Endangered Species of Wild Fauna and Flora) Appendices Table 2, which describes all Red List Species occurring in the Black Sea Range Sates, contains two columns, one with the heading CITES species listing and the other with CMS. The roman numerals represent the Appendices in which the relevant species are listed. CITES has established a world-wide system of controls on international trade in threatened wildlife and wildlife and wildlife products by stipulating that government permits are required for such trade. Protection is provided for species in two main categories: The most endangered species . Appendix I: Includes all species threatened with extinction, which are or may be affected by trade. 96 Other species at serious risk Appendix II: a) Includes all species which although not necessarily currently threatened with extinction may become so unless trade is subject to strict regulation; and b) Other species which must be subject to regulation in order that trade in certain specimens of species referred to in sub- paragraph (a) above may be brought under effective control, i.e, species similar in appearance. Regulation of trade in Appendix II species. Appendix III: All species which any Party identifies as being subject to regulation within its jurisdiction for the purpose of preventing or restricting exploitation. The co-operation of other Parties, is therefore, needed. Regulation of trade in Appendix III species. 5.4 Guide to the interpretation of CMS Appendices The Convention in the conservation of Migratory Species of Wild Animals (CMS or the Bonn Convention) aims to conserve terrestrial, marine and avian migratory species throughout their range. The CMS Appendices are as follows: Appendix I: Migratory species which are endangered Appendix II: Migratory species which have an unfavourable conservation status and which require international agreements for their conservation and management, as well as those which have a conservation status which would significantly benefit from the international co-operation that could be achieved by an international agreement 5.5 References WCMC, 1997 (in Prep). Red Data Book of European Vertebrates. A contribution to Action Theme No. 11 (European Action Programme for Threatened Species) of the Pan-European Biological and Landscape Diversity Strategy. (Bird data provided by Birdlife International). WCMC, Cambridge, United Kingdom. The WCMC Animals Database 97 (iti oetily’s, ie i) ayo) ay | > yee Bia Pig: | Pare c nee Cia =A QR iat! ry Dp TAT Cel CONN (igi? Tey a) pee! feeb) orn HF | footy yal Ph ole ( {ahinpiya singh “abehike i f AMAA sata) Ve ; : ype tah . u te 1u y be ie i f sh) ers 86 papnjoxe saroads ysiy suLseUN “SuNsaU aJoYM Papnjoul Sa]}iN} SULIeUL “Papnjoxs suBddeI99 ‘UOITOI DY} JO JSBA IRF OY} UI S91UNOD JOJ [BUOISIAOId sayeUITYSO YsIJ (apnqiSuo] sdassap (¢ 0} Sed) AIQUNOD a4} Jo Wed 0} ATUO sJazoI DJBUIISO Jey} Sd}BOIPUI , 9ION L661 “daid Ul SINDA\ :291N0g 88 tp Ic Lal! be 9 £97 v L6 eta (%LI) $8 tor oule Dy) gor | 19 | 07 I | £0 le COE € Lad! 81 (%L1) ZI LOL Aayan |, 911 bl 07 8 LY 8 C9E 9 LIZ €cl (%E1) 06 899 #PISSNY L8 Ip 07 cl €C 9 Lv € 06 61 (%L1)_18 LOp | eluewioYy 09 6l LA ud Os 81 é é 68 07 (%67) 19 £17 BId109H 6L 8€ Li Ol ce 8 LA 4 98 LA (%91) TL psp | eueding Ayuno9 saisadg saisadg satsadg so1sadg | ul Surinos0 saisads sarsadg ysiy sorsads ueiqiyduy satoads andoy pig saisadg jemueyy | Jo Jaquinu jej}0} jo satoads ueadoing ueiqiydwy uevadoing ajuday | ueadoing soisadg | ueadoing ewe] ueadoinq asejuaoiad/adoing | sarsads jo ysy [eo] o1wapugq [PIO] o1wopugq [R10 owapug | psig [P01 o1Wopuq [R10 d1wapugq | 0} d1wWapua saisadg | ‘ou [ej0] Ayunod "S9JEJS [BISLOD Bag YouTg oy} Ul Ind90 yorym ‘adong 0} d1Wapus satdads 9}e1G9119A JO JAquINN, | 91GB], WISIWapUa [BUOIsa1 pue (A[UO S9j¥.1q9}.19A pUL BUNLJ) SsaUYydIA satdeds Jo a[qu} ATVUIUING 9°¢ asiese naga ate x eo0. iil tt ae) Te eat “eas a hee eR | meth + teampalt = | oe eae aap wt - idkest pe bebe: Sabi 2 25 Tur St Tt ih a oe 5.7 List of species of fauna not globally threatened but of special concern in Europe The species outlined below are not currently regarded as globally threatened, but are of special concern at the European level. This information has been derived from the Red Data Book of European Vertebrates (WCMC, iin prep. 1997) The countries of occurrence listed include only the European part of the range where the species occurred in one or more of the Black Sea Range States. For birds, only breeding ranges are given. For mammals, reptiles, amphibians and fishes, “special concern” is estimated by the extent to which the species have been categorised as threatened in relevant national Red Data Books. MAMMALS Order INSECTIVORA Family ERINACEIDAE Hemiechinus auritus Georgia Russia Ukraine Order CHIROPTERA Family PTEROPODIDAE Rousettus aegyptiacus Turkey Family RHINOLOPHIDAE Rhinolophus blasii Georgia Romania Russia Turkey Ukraine Rhinolophus ferrumequinum Bulgaria Georgia Romania Russia Turkey Ukraine Family VESPERTILIONIDAE Barbastella leucomelas Russia Eptesicus bottae Turkey Miniopterus schreibersi Bulgaria Georgia Romania Russia Turkey Ukraine Otonycteris hemprichi Turkey Pipistrellus kuhli Turkey Ukraine Order CARNIVORA Family CANIDAE Alopex lagopus Russia Canis aureus Bulgaria Georgia Romania Turkey Canis lupus Bulgaria Georgia Romania Russia Turkey Ukraine Family FELIDAE Caracal caracal Turkey Lynx lynx Bulgaria Georgia Romania Russia Turkey Ukraine Felis silvestris Bulgaria Georgia Romania Russia Turkey Ukraine Panthera pardus Georgia Russia Turkey Family HERPESTIDAE 99 Herpestes ichneumon Family HYAENIDAE Hyaena hyaena Family MUSTELIDAE Lutra lutra Mustela eversmanni Vormela peregusna Family PHOCIDAE Phoca hispida Family URSIDAE Ursus arctos Order CETACEA Family BALAENIDAE Order ARTIODACTYLA Family BOVIDAE Gazella dorcas Gazella subgutturosa Order RODENTIA Family SCIURIDAE Sciurus anomalus Pteromys volans Family MYOXIDAE Myoxus glis Family DIPODIDAE Sicista subtilis Family HYSTRICIDAE Hystrix indica BIRDS Order GA VIIFORMES Family GAVIIDAE Gavia stellata Gavia arctica Order PROCELLARIFORMES Order PELECANIFORMES Family PELECANIDAE Turkey Georgia Turkey Bulgaria Georgia Romania Russia Turkey Ukraine Bulgaria Romania Russia Ukraine Bulgaria Georgia Romania Russia Turkey Ukraine Russia Bulgaria Georgia Romania Russia Turkey Ukraine Turkey Georgia Turkey Georgia Turkey Russia Bulgaria Georgia Romania Russia Turkey Ukraine Bulgaria Russia Ukraine Georgia Turkey Russia Russia 100 Pelecanus onocrotalus Family PHALACROCORACIDAE Phalacrocorax pygmeus Order CICONITFORMES Family ARDEIDAE Botaurus stellaris Txobrychus minutus Nycticorax nycticorax Ardeola ralloides Ardea purpurea Family CICONIIDAE Ciconia nigra Ciconia ciconia Family THRESKIORNITHIDAE Plegadis falcinellus Platalea leucorodia Family PHOENICOPTERIDAE Phoenicopterus ruber Order ANSERIFORMES Family ANATIDAE Branta bernicla Tadorna ferruginea Anas strepera Anas acuta Anas querquedula Netta rufina Mergus albellus Order FALCONIFORMES Family ACCIPITRIDAE Milvus migrans Haliaeetus albicilla Gypaetus barbatus Neophron percnopterus Gyps fulvus Aegypius monachus Circaetus gallicus Circus cyaneus Circus macrourus Accipiter brevipes Buteo rufinus Aquila pomarina Aquila nipalensis Aquila chrysaetos Hieraaetus pennatus Hieraaetus fasciatus Family PANDIONIDAE Pandion haliaetus Family FALCONIDAE Romania Russia Turkey Bulgaria Romania Russia Turkey Ukraine Bulgaria Romania Russia Turkey Ukraine Bulgaria Romania Russia Turkey Ukraine Bulgaria Romania Russia Turkey Ukraine Bulgaria Romania Russia Turkey Ukraine Bulgaria Romania Russia Turkey Ukraine Bulgaria Romania Russia Turkey Ukraine Bulgaria Romania Russia Turkey Ukraine Bulgaria Romania Russia Turkey Ukraine Bulgaria Romania Russia Turkey Ukraine Turkey Russia Bulgaria Romania Russia Turkey Ukraine Bulgaria Romania Russia Turkey Ukraine Bulgaria Romania Russia Turkey Ukraine Bulgaria Romania Russia Turkey Ukraine Bulgaria Romania Russia Turkey Ukraine Russia Bulgaria Romania Russia Turkey Ukraine Bulgaria Romania Russia Turkey Ukraine Russia Turkey Bulgaria Romania Russia Turkey Ukraine Bulgaria Russia Turkey Ukraine Russia Turkey Ukraine Bulgaria Romania Russia Turkey Ukraine Russia Ukraine Romania Russia Ukraine Bulgaria Romania Russia Turkey Ukraine Bulgaria Russia Turkey Ukraine Bulgaria Romania Russia Turkey Ukraine Russia Turkey Ukraine Bulgaria Romania Russia Turkey Ukraine Bulgaria Romania Russia Turkey Ukraine Turkey Bulgaria Russia Turkey Ukraine 101 Falco tinnunculus Falco vespertinus Falco eleonorae Falco biarmicus Falco cherrug Falco rusticolus Falco peregrinus Order GALLIFORMES Family PHASIANIDAE Tetrao tetrix Tetrao mlokosiewiczi Tetraogallus caspius Alectoris chukar Alectoris graeca Francolinus francolinus Perdix perdix Coturnix coturnix Family TURNICIDAE Family GRUIDAE Grus grus Family RALLIDAE Porzana pusilla Porphyrio porphyrio Family OTIDAE Tetrax tetrax Order CHARADRIIFORMES Family BURHINIDAE Burhinus oedicnemus Family GLAREOLIDAE Cursorius cursor Glareola pratincola Glareola nordmanni Family CHARADRIIDAE Charadrius alexandrinus Charadrius asiaticus Hoplopterus spinosus Family SCOLOPACIDAE Limicola falcinellus Gallinago media Limosa limosa Tringa totanus Tringa glareola Family LARIDAE Larus minutus Larus audouinii Larus canus Pagophila eburnea Bulgaria Romania Russia Turkey Ukraine Bulgaria Romania Russia Ukraine Turkey Turkey Bulgaria Romania Russia Turkey Ukraine Russia Bulgaria Romania Russia Turkey Ukraine Romania Russia Ukraine Russia Turkey Turkey Bulgaria Russia Turkey Bulgaria Romania Turkey Bulgaria Romania Russia Turkey Ukraine Bulgaria Romania Russia Turkey Ukraine Romania Russia Turkey Ukraine Bulgaria Romania Russia Turkey Ukraine Russia Turkey Russia Turkey Ukraine Bulgaria Romania Russia Turkey Ukraine Turkey Bulgaria Romania Russia Turkey Ukraine Romania Russia Ukraine Bulgaria Romania Russia Turkey Ukraine Russia Turkey Russia Russia Ukraine Romania Russia Ukraine Bulgaria Romania Russia Turkey Ukraine Russia Ukraine Romania Russia Ukraine Turkey Russia Russia 102 Gelochelidon nilotica Sterna caspia Sterna sandvicensis Sterna albifrons Chlidonias hybridus Chlidonias niger Family ALCIDAE Cepphus grylle Fratercula arctica Family PTEROCLIDIDAE Pterocles orientalis Pterocles alchata Family COLUMBIDAE Streptopelia turtur Order STRIGIFORMES Family TYTONIDAE Tyto alba Family STRIGIDAE Otus scops Bubo bubo Nyctea scandiaca Athene noctua Asio flammeus Order CAPRIMULGIFORMES Family CAPRIMULGIDAE Caprimulgus europaeus Order CORACIIFORMES Family ALCEDINIDAE Alcedo atthis Family MEROPIDAE Merops apiaster Family CORACIIDAE Coracias garrulus Order PICIFORMES Family PICIDAE Jynx torquilla Picus canus Picus viridis Picoides tridactylus Order PASSERIFORMES Family ALAUDIDAE Melanocorypha calandra Melanocorypha yeltoniensis Calandrella brachydactyla Bulgaria Romania Russia Turkey Ukraine Russia Turkey Ukraine Bulgaria Romania Russia Ukraine Bulgaria Romania Russia Turkey Ukraine Bulgaria Romania Russia Turkey Ukraine Bulgaria Romania Russia Turkey Ukraine Russia Russia Russia Turkey Turkey Bulgaria Romania Russia Turkey Ukraine Bulgaria Romania Turkey Ukraine Bulgaria Romania Russia Turkey Ukraine Bulgaria Romania Russia Turkey Ukraine Russia Bulgaria Romania Russia Turkey Ukraine Romania Russia Turkey Ukraine Bulgaria Romania Russia Turkey Ukraine Bulgaria Romania Russia Turkey Ukraine Bulgaria Romania Russia Turkey Ukraine Bulgaria Romania Russia Turkey Ukraine Bulgaria Romania Russia Turkey Ukraine Bulgaria Romania Russia Turkey Ukraine Bulgaria Romania Russia Turkey Ukraine Bulgaria Romania Russia Ukraine Bulgaria Romania Russia Turkey Ukraine Russia Bulgaria Romania Russia Turkey Ukraine 103 Calandrella rufescens Galerida cristata Lullula arborea Alauda arvensis Family HIRUNDINIDAE Riparia riparia Hirundo rustica Family MOTACILLIDAE Anthus campestris Family LANIIDAE Lanius collurio Lanius minor Lanius excubitor Lanius senator Lanius nubicus Family PRUNELLIDAE Prunella ocularis Prunella atrogularis Family MUSCICAPIDAE Phoenicurus phoenicurus Saxicola torquata Oenanthe hispanica Monticola saxatilis Monticola solitarius Hippolais pallida Hippolais olivetorum Sylvia hortensis Muscicapa striata Ficedula semitorquata Family EMBERIZIDAE Emberiza cia Emberiza cineracea Emberiza hortulana Emberiza melanocephala Family FRINGILLIDAE Bucanetes githagineus Family CORVIDAE Perisoreus infaustus Pyrrhocorax pyrrhocorax REPTILES Order SAURIA Family CHAMAELEONIDAE Chamaeleo chamaeleon Family LACERTIDAE Lacerta laevis Russia Turkey Ukraine Bulgaria Romania Russia Turkey Ukraine Bulgaria Romania Russia Turkey Ukraine Bulgaria Romania Russia Turkey Ukraine Bulgaria Romania Russia Turkey Ukraine Bulgaria Romania Russia Turkey Ukraine Bulgaria Romania Russia Turkey Ukraine Bulgaria Romania Russia Turkey Ukraine Bulgaria Romania Russia Turkey Ukraine Romania Russia Ukraine Bulgaria Romania Turkey Ukraine Bulgaria Turkey Turkey Russia Bulgaria Romania Russia Turkey Ukraine Bulgaria Romania Russia Turkey Ukraine Bulgaria Romania Turkey Bulgaria Romania Turkey Ukraine Bulgaria Turkey Bulgaria Romania Turkey Bulgaria Turkey Bulgaria Turkey Bulgaria Romania Russia Turkey Ukraine Bulgaria Russia Turkey Bulgaria Romania Turkey Ukraine Turkey Bulgaria Romania Russia Turkey Ukraine Bulgaria Romania Russia Turkey Ukraine Turkey Russia Turkey Turkey Turkey 104 Order SERPENTES Family COLUBRIDAE Coluber algirus Coluber rubriceps Elaphe longissima Rhynchocalamus satunini Order TESTUDINES Family TRIONYCHIDAE Trionyx triunguis AMPHIBIANS Order ANURA Family PELOBATIDAE Pelobates syriacus Order CAUDATA Family SALAMANDRIDAE Neurergus crocatus FISHES Order PETROMYZONTIFORMES Family PETROMYZONTIDAE Caspiomyzon wagneri Order PERCIFORMES Family BLENNIIDAE Blennius fluviatilis Family CICHLIDAE Tristamalla simonis Order CYPRINIFORMES Family CYPRINIDAE Alburnus coeruleus Alburnus kotschyi Carassius carassius Cyprinus carpio Hemigrammocapoeta sauvagei Bulgaria Turkey Bulgaria Georgia Romania Russia Turkey Ukraine Turkey Turkey Bulgaria Georgia Romania Turkey Turkey Russia Turkey Turkey Turkey Turkey Bulgaria Georgia Romania Russia Turkey Ukraine Bulgaria Georgia Romania Russia Turkey Ukraine Turkey 105 Kosswigobarbus kosswigi Turkey Pararhodeus kervillei Turkey Pararhodeus meandrii Turkey Tylognathus caudomaculatus Turkey Order CYPRINODONTIFORMES Order SALMONIFORMES Family SALMONIDAE Coregonus autumnalis Russia Salmo salar Russia Salmo trutta Bulgaria Georgia Romania Russia Turkey Ukraine Order SILURIFORMES Family SILURIDAE Silurus triostegus Turkey Family SISSORIDAE Glyptothorax steindachneri Turkey Order SYNBRANCHIFORMES Family MASTACEMBELIDAE Mastacembelus simack Turkey 106 5.8 List of globally threatened vertebrates restricted to Europe The list covers terrestrial and freshwater species. Only species which occur in one of the Black Sea Range States are included. Names and taxonomic details appear in the left-hand column; the 1996 IUCN global status category is shown in the next column; followed by the criteria cited, and the countries in which the species occurs. In the case of birds, this last column shows the breeding range only. MAMMALS Order CARNIVORA Family FELIDAE Mustela lutreola European Mink Order ARTIODACTYLA Family BOVIDAE Bison bonasus European Bison Capra caucasica West Caucasian Tur Capra cylindricornis East Caucasian Tur Order RODENTIA Family SCIURIDAE Spermophilus citellus European Squirrel Spermophilus suslicus Spotted Souslik Family DIPODIDAE Sicista armenica Family MURIDAE Acomys cilicicus Mesocricetus newtoni Romania n Hamster Nannospalax leucodon Spalax arenarius Spalax graecus Greater Mole Rat Spalax microphthalmus Family MYOXIDAE Eliomys quercinus Garden Dormouse Myomimus roachi Mouse-tailed Dormouse IUCN Category EN EN EN VU VU VU CR CR VU VU VU VU VU VU VU IUCN Criteria Alace A2ce, C2a Ald+2cde Ald+2de, Cl Alc Alc D2 Alc, B1+2c D2 D2 Alc D2 Distribution Georgia Romania Russia Russia Ukraine Georgia Russia Georgia Russia Bulgaria Romania Turkey Ukraine Romania Russia Ukraine Georgia Turkey Bulgaria Romania Bulgaria Romania Turkey Ukraine Ukraine Romania Ukraine Russia Ukraine Romania Ukraine Turkey 107 MAMMALS BIRDS Order ANSERIFORMES Family ANATIDAE Branta ruficollis Red-breasted Goose Order COLUMBIFORMES Family COLUMBIDAE Order PASSERIFORMES Family MUSCICAPIDAE Acrocephalus paludicola Aquatic Warbler REPTILES Order SAURIA Family LACERTIDAE Lacerta clarkorum Order SERPENTES Family COLUBRIDAE Natrix megalocephala Large-headed Water Snake Family VIPERIDAE Vipera albizona Vipera bulgardaghica Vipera darevskii Vipera dinniki Vipera kaznakovi Caucasian Viper Vipera pontica Vipera ursinii AMPHIBIANS Family RANIDAE Rana holtzi Family SALAMANDRIDAE Mertensella luschani Lycian Salamander FISHES Order CLUPEIFORMES IUCN Category VU VU EN VU EN CR CR VU EN CR EN EN VU IUCN Criteria A2cd, B1+2cd A2c C2a Ald, Cl Bl+2e, C2a Bl+2e, C2a C2b Cl+2a Alcd+2cd C2ab, D1 Alc+2c B1+2bc+3, E Bl+2cde Distribution Russia Russia Ukraine Georgia Turkey Georgia Russia Turkey Turkey Turkey Georgia Georgia Russia Georgia Russia Turkey Georgia Turkey Romania Turkey Ukraine Turkey Turkey 108 MAMMALS Alosa macedonia Liparia Order CYPRINIFORMES Family CYPRINIDAE Alburnus akili Gokce Baligi Alburnus albidus Italian Bleak Barbus guiraonis Barbus haasi Barbo de Cola Roja Barbus microcephalus Chondrostoma holmwoodii Gobio hettitorum Dere Kayasi Ladigesocypris ghigii Ghizani Paraphoxinus alepidotus Paraphoxinus croaticus Paraphoxinus ghetaldi Paraphoxinus metohiensis Phoxinellus anatolicus Phoxinellus egridiri Phoxinellus handlirschi Cigek Family BALITORIDAE Nemacheilus tschaiyssuensis Order SALMINIFORMES Family UMBRIDAE Umbra krameri European Mud-minnow Family SALMONIDAE Hucho hucho Huchen Salmo carpio Carpione del Garda Salmo platycephalus Ala Balik Order CYPRINODONTIFORMES IUCN Category VU VU VU VU VU VU VU VU VU VU VU EN VU CR IUCN Criteria D2 Alace D2 Alace A2bcde, B1+2bce Alacde B1+2abc Distribution Turkey Turkey Turkey Turkey Turkey Turkey Turkey Turkey Turkey Bulgaria Romania Ukraine Romania Ukraine Turkey 109 MAMMALS Family CYPRINODONTIDAE Aphanius anatoliae Dislisazancik Baligi Aphanius burduricus Aphanius splendens Aphanius sureyanus Aphanius transgrediens Order GASTEROSTEIFORMES Family GASTEROSTEIDAE Order PERCIFORMES Family PERCIDAE Gymnocephalus schraetzer Striped Ruffe Percarina demidoff Zingel streber Streber Zingel zingel Zingel IUCN Category EN EN CR CR CR VU VU VU VU IUCN Criteria A2ce, B1+2abed A2e Alac, B1+2abce B1+2bc B1+2bcd Alace D2 Alce+2ce Alce+2ce Distribution Turkey Turkey Turkey Turkey Turkey Bulgaria Romania Ukraine Russia Ukraine Bulgaria Ukraine Bulgaria Romania Ukraine 110 ITI KR A A IK A || | | wa SINIOON 1assa7] Last] SnjDIOAN A A A A x | inal WUT [NOON WweID sndajdoisD] SnjDIaAN aN A A | A A Il oT | Jeg SJa1ayeN | 14a40}]DU SOAP A Al A Il aa eq paoysiuM snuiopjsdiu syodpy eg A x A Il W/YT | pores-asnopy =: OB eT sod syodpy A wa snjAjopposspu sijody Xx waT dajoif SyOodN = A A A A A IV NA yegq S,Aosjyoas Snjpuissvua syody A A Il qeg Suojuaqneg | 1uojuaqnop sioKy A A | | BY A jeg puog | auauadsnp Sod A A A | on jeg pasasuy-su07 | nuizavdpa syoApy A A A A | Il | jeg Sjpurig ipupag sod A | WAT SNUIQUIOG SOAP eg A A A aN II O/T | pores-asnopy —-Jossa‘] nYyla]g SOM A A A A A A II A | eq S,Wlajsysog quyaysyzaq syodjy xX aa 1aqv sod A IV Na sisualinssn pulinyy nN A A A Isdag1aayos snaajdouipy A A A A auljolag snuosas snoisajdq A A A A A A II ITV NA | eesseqseg W419}S9 AA Sn]JaIsDg4vg vjjaysvqivg wg A A A A A | I | ITV. DA | 2oysass0H s,4]2497A] Mjayau snydojouryy Jeg A A A A 7 A A | Il | IZV DA | 20Ysas10F] 49ssa'] sosapisoddiy snydojouny wg Al A Xx A A A | Il POUT | P0ysasIoH —_—-JNJBAIH) wnuinbaunssaf snydojouyy JB gq VOYsasiOFY A A A A A Il ITV NA UBIULIII}IPITA] ajpdina snydojouiyy SESE : A A sea A Il q/Y'T | FoysasIOY] Snise|q 11sp]q Snydojoulyy A A iL I7+14 NA uvUIsdg UvISSNy DIDYISOM DUDUSAg ae A +I AA} Maays JysnuelEg dajspsoona] xa10g sjeMmUey (payejouue JI poysays)uoisay sunst] RHOIDQ | ArosayeoD sulesyy) | Aoyiny | eissmy | erurwoy | eisioaH | euesing Rag yortg | sa1isads = Sq IO} SWO Noni NONI awieu UOWLUOD aweU d1JUaIDS EILAB PIOg UT parysiYysry usaq eavy esau} dARY JOUNXS PUP P]IM dU} UI JOUT}Xe ‘paJosuepud AT]BOIWII ‘ pousyeory) se passasse satoadg ‘saryua sfdyjnur ore osoy} snyy ‘uoNeyndod JenprArput Aq passacoe usaq SARY UOISINIg oy} ‘9'1 ‘sardads owOg “A JOquIAS ay} Aq poyeoIpuI Ud9q sey Sq} AIJUNOD B UI SINd90 satdads jsT] poy & SIdU AA $9}¥IS BIC YOR _ 24) UI SULIAINIIO vUNe Jo Sotdeds sr] pay NOMI I" JO 914") Areuruns 67S i | A | I | Party Na jenbsoy s,preqqis snjnosmu viajdouavjpg A party Na ITBYAA YSITBOD s1jpai0g viajdouavjypg A wat RUM Pd ANT pjosjsoaojnov paajdouanjog A wuld ‘TO. Na FEY AA USI Sypiapjs Duavjoqny sTeUM A Poa | shy pueusain snjaoijsdu puavjog deag A PIV NA | WRI uvdepeulyy snuvjaqiy) snss) A PIT Ieag IejOd SNUIJLADUL SNS) A ONT [eag uOWWOD DUIJNJ1A DIOYT A wea [eas [eyleg DILAIGIS DIOYUY A OAT [eag posury ppidsiy po0yg Xx OVI [Rag puejusain DIIPUD]UBOLS DIOYY A IZ+14 NA [kag uvidsey vaidsv2 vaI0ud [kag yuo 6x9 A A A xo A | eee 7a@) ULIULIIIIPITA, snyspuow snysnuopy A Il [eas Aap, sndds snsaoyouvyy A qIlv UOTRIS §,13]]233S snjoqgnt{ svidojauny A qiv NA [BIS ANY UAIYIAON SNUISIN SNUIY LODZ A Il By ips ial sndye AA SNADUSOd SNUAGOPE A A A A dELV Na yur, uvadoing Djoasny ara | A ZV ANA JULIIAJOAA ojns ony A 1 I 87D Na 20unO pigun viduy Xx Il AT e_ predoaT SISUa]D8Uag SNAN]IDUOLd 6X9 A I PITV Na AIB1], S131] DAOYIUD A A A I OAT piedooy] snpapd paayjungd XxX Il inal = Sselled [nuput 8NgGOj0I019 A A A A xa Il oT xuA‘] ueiseing xud] XUAT A A A nN A A I AIT 19 PIM SLUJSAAIIS S12] A A II ial WD pry SNDYD SI] a4 A I OT [eovsed uvisy [DIDADI [DIDADD A daa XO 9BSIOD ops409 sadjn{ A A I L7a0) NA 80d PIAA UeIpUT snurdjv uon> A A A A A A I oT JIOM aqui], sndnj stun) A A A A Ill OT jeyorp uapjoyH SNAAND S1UDD weg A A A A OUT | paiei-aeiq ueadomng SNO1UA] DpPLADpDd | A A A OWT Weg ponojosiueg snutunu oyisadsa, A A A A OVUT | IE poses-suoT AH SNIDLAJSND SNJOIA] J rg A A A A A OAT | porea-3uo07] uMOIg SNLAND SNJOIA| A A A ial a[jansidig S1Aeg maps snpjaasidi A A Rial ayjausidig UOWWOD snyjaasidid snyjaasidt A A A A OUT} ayenstdig snisnyyen usnyyou snyjaajsidi q A A oT aP-SIAtd SUNY yyny snyjaasidi A A A IX dIATT PIMION. DINJIOU SNIDIIAN (poayejouur JI poyoayo)uolsay sunsi| PHO | Aosaqea auieryy) | Aayiny | vissmy | eruewoy | erdi0ayH | euesing Bag yorig | saisads_ = SA LIO| SIO Noni Noni aueu UOLULUOD, OWIEU STJTUIINS ell auresyy | Aoyiny | eissny RIURUOY | BISIOAH | BUesing bag youl |saloeds SALIO NONI oweu UOWIIOD A at[azeH ueljosuopy] psoanyjns pidvo01q A 2PITV NA ulBl “UOUNOTA,, Si]DJUa}sO SAO A PIT daays mous DjOIIAIU SIAC A A II 2PITV NA doayg PIAA URISY uOUnUD SIAD x I P27V NA [B4105) asaulyD Snjopnvd snpaysowuavyy 9]]922D XK xa WAIT | pues ‘a]]9zeDH panioyH DSOANJINSQNS D]]azDH) A A wT ‘2P7+PT Vu NA | ANL UeIsSBINED sey suusonuipuysa nado A x 3P9Z7+PIV N@ | Iny uviseoney jso poispanv2 vidvD A A A Ipy7V NA 3805) PITA snisvdav vido A A u&Z) 9ZVu Na JUOSTAA snspuog uosig A I portly NA | 429d YSN URLIIGIS sniafiyasou snyasop x Xa MOD BIS S,123]19}S spais symunpoipaH A ll dd} 21e4UM peyxeag-asooyH siaso.uiapa sniydiz oTeUM A ll dq | pexeeq — Sladaufais ldagaulajs uopojdosay IE A I ll PIT peoyanog snjojjndiup uopoosadayy aTeUM A Poa | pesou-ajjog = yurIDH Upaing snipavsag asiodiog A POAT poyuey-SuU AA HIBS eHIOUeooOU ch A —— aaa | Sea ear ae asiodi0d 4noqieH puaoz0yd DUa0IONd A asiodiog 1n0qieH puaozoyd puao204d A nQTH1O TV. NA asiodiog 1noqieyy puaozoyd puaoz0yd A PIV NA asiodiog 1noqiey puaoz0yd puaoz0yd A ndZ+10 ITV asiodiog 1noqieyy puaoz0yd puao20yg | $Y r asiodiog 1noqieyy puaoz0yd nuaor0yg x da|_-ajeym woot | SO49IOUOU UOPOUOPY A svana] snsajdvurydjaq A A A XK A A ulydjoq pasou-a0g snyoound) sdoisan J K urydjoq auAsosydng pqjpoajn1aood pyjauals = | A aTeUM JOIIPY asyey suapISSDAI DIAOpNAsS A RIO DIAO SNUIIACQ) urydjoq A TEU YS WOYLON syjpasog siydjapossiT urydjoq A Popls-ayy A low suapinbyjgo snyoudysouasvT urydjoq A A payeaq-at4UM S14JSO419]D SNYDUAYLOUABDT uydjoq | A O17 | Papis-yM —oUeN Vy snynop snyoudydouasvT A x I dada urydjog Aap snasid4s snduipdy) urydjoq ieee < oe (ew A A A [meee 1 esi p249eq-21PPeS siydjap snuydjeaq A PIT yors dry SNJSNGOA SNYYIMYIST A =z] pely DA | ABU AA PaydequouNnyy apysuvapaou piajdvsayy A PqelV Na IBY AA PIyxIeQG-uly snjosdyd nsajdouanjug (payejouur j1 poysoys)uoisay Sul}sl] RaW | A1osajeD AWeU SIJUAIOS vit w7+TE TVs NA SniDuasD xojvds A wa NA uopoanay xvjpdsouunyy wea snupisda xpjpdsodpy wT dojooysiyos sndodpy A wT asnoyy addajg snsapiaids sn wy aJOA BNR], SNILD] SNJOLIY SISUAUIJDYIDS SNJOAIIPY | IJOA JOOY SNWMOUOIAO SNJOAIIPY wT IAOADSDU SNJOAIIY GZ) 9T+1 8 tf) sisuaupimu snjos1yy A wey 14ayjuans SnjoLIIPy a7) 97+T 8, SISUAUOLOAA SNJOLIIY x A asnoy ISOAIEH sninui SXuOsDIPY A ca NA | 499sWeH U BIUBWOY 1uOJMaU SNJaII0SAay i (40 eer Sa 6: fe) Mopvsisould XAUOJSOLIIG A A II Ja\SWUIe PY UOUWIWIOD | SNJAIIAI SNJAIAD (REI wT Jaysuiepy A215) SNLOJDASIU SNINJAI1AD, ao wy sisuaupjoyts sAumouolyjay) A wT | u4aqgoa sAuouoly) A aa wT a]0A MOUS sypaiu sduwouo1y) A wat pns sduouory) aad snoiup24dy snuapodpy qz wo sngiid sAMOIP asnoyy A WAT | YON uayINOS SUTIQNS DISIOIS ad papdpuopnasd pjsiais etal DILAOYIN]Y DISII1G 7 aes ad | DaIBaqzdy DISIIIS IT+1A Na DJDpNvd VISIIIS asnoy] xX wT | ug WOON puljnjag DISIIIS A WO OTWa tf@) DIIUAULAD DISIJIS [ wea 14aujday snjosuidjps Rial dolpu DsDvIID]] V wy poypaydna Dsvjov]] F A WAT Joavag ueiseing dagyf 40jSD) IV NA YLISNOg payjods snaysns snjiydousads: wat dolou snjiydousads A IV NA Yl[snog uvadoing snyjaqia snjiydowsads: A wy Jauinbs pay SLIDS]NA SNANIIG A wat Jauinbs ueisiag snjououn snaniag Jauinbs yyy | surdyy uvissny SUDJOA SAUOLA] [ ova jouueyy auidyy DIJOWADU DIOWADY PIT yngog DIOWADy Il BlVv NA adojajuy estes DI110]D] DES (payejouue JI poyoays)uolsay Sunsi| BLOW | AlosaeD ouresyf) | Aoyiny | eissmy | eruewoy | e1ss09yH | euesing vag yorlq | saisads = SqLIO} SIWO Noni Noni dWeU UOLULOD, SWRU IIJUIIOS A A A L A A A I II L740) NA ajseq jeluadwy povyjay vjynby is A A A A A I ll L74) Na ajseq payods péunja pjinby A A A A ll Il al wea anyINA yorlgq snyopuou snid@ap - A xX Id Ne) yonpjays paysag, DIDIS14I DULOPD J x xX IV NA Japiq pajavjaadg 1ayasyf viuawiuos A xX II vIV NA JOPIA S,491193S apjars piousdjod A A A A A II I 9TV NA | APN P2IPwIy-IIyAA pjoydazoanay vindxo | x x B7+10 NA | d9suBs1ayQ asauryD snjouonbs snésayy - A A x i= Il IZV NA yong paqiey SLSOLNSNSUD DYAUOIDULID JY A A A A A II IL|_.P97+Ta “PIZV., NA |_ 98005) prjsea.ig-pay syjooyfns pjupsg A A A A A A il I pIelV NA | Psvysod pada-aj14 AA poosdu ann A x ID BTV. NA psvyrod S 198g qiang vAyiay [e 38005) payuoay A A A A A I PIelV A | -93TU AA A9Sso'T sndosyjdsa sasuy | x sail P9Z7+PITV NA 98005) UBMS saplousda sasup A i xX II ud ‘APETV, NA [89,1 [e4!Bg psousof soup A > wea yonq ulsepueryy pIojNI1AajD3 X1p = siqi L =e Se) x = ul ‘QZ. WO | psa, asoueder uoddiu viuoddiyy xa (yaa) wo SIq] IWA3aFT Dynuasa snayuosay YA0}S A xX i) N@ | ty AA asoueder punizdog 110915 a ile =I X wT WHI S$, YOUDTYOS snuyjayana Snyodiqoxy u01d{ A x B7+HID DA | -U3IN asouvder 18pS108 sniyovsi0H A ll xX I fe) Na joisq asouryD sajoydojna vyassq | A inte A A xl WAT quesoUUoD AWwshg SNIUBAA XDIOIOAIDIDY A xX XA | juRIOWI0D s,sEled snjoppiaidsiad xpsoz019 004g A A A A A A A I I +d) NA UvIIP UBNEW LEG sndsiso snuvzajag te x I I 19 Na] sso.yeqry $,121199S snsjoqyv vapowoig Spllgq le uPZ) ‘PTV. NA eyld addayg pyjisnd nuojoyrO ouidnol0g i Ill W/YT | PalssiD uRdLy YON DIDISIAD X1dJSAP] > [> asnouuog 184 sy3 snxodpy msl asnow.iog pajiej-asnoy,] 19v04 smunuodpy SNIADUD]] AAD SNUIpADISNy snuisanb shuoy zy asnowwog [aze asnouliog uspies snanupjau SMuony pinpajiu sAwmoduq. td NA wraT ITV NA wad wy T 9SNOULIOG 4S910,] Pe bel bell poll all ad Teal > > a > WAT dasiun] sduokiq Le A za NA smujoyjydosonu xvjodg A A ca NA IVY I/O 4SsaT uopoona] xnjods as A za DA[ yey aon 1938015 Snoanss xvjods A w7+TE OTV. NA snajuvsis xvjvds =i (payejouue JI a poayoays)uolsay Suljsi| BLOW | A1osae9 auresy | Aayiny | eissmy | eruewoy |} e1d1095 | euesing Bag sot saiads Sq IO. | SWO Noni Noni aweU UOWLOD QWeU O1FWUIIOS oI (= aI Suyung | x R741 payaeq-snoyny nysmoyunl v21aquq A | wey sunung snoaiaulg DaIDAIUID DZLaQuy x 87+ NA | Jeyaysng s,uosspoyy SIUSISUI DIOIIXDS xX (== a a []iqoued pao lapnay SiudoxopDAD A I WV NA 4ajque AA Wenby pjooipnyod snjvydaz019p WAT SUIMXE AA asoueder poiuodpl pyiodquog II L745 (0) Na | IMO-USIA S,UO}sIyeg quojs1ypjq vdnjay I ite) NA J9fIAIN A pasa) auinsnznune snydupsoquyuds wey JOJOUN] parqueyy snjosousipnu snydunadyooag xa yNy }BIIH siuuadul vay oye MIT A x Rly NA possa|-pay SIMJSOLIABLG DSS1Y (7 A x I I wT IND 19119y SNJI1J Ad SNADT A A I PIT 11ND s,urnopny MUINOpND SNAoT A 1 x I Id Na} ¥uevysusa15 payjodg safins vsuisy MapIND A A A I I 14) t: (8) PoTl!q-419pua|sS S1IISOSINUD] SNIUAUTINT Xx wat MaYND wayseq ey SISUALADISDSDPDU SNIUIUNA A wT JayoUMOG oNeISy sniouyjpdiuas snuo1pouunT A A A A II wet adiug yap pipau ospuryj0H A x q7+10 NA | 4adidpues [j1quoodg snausdd snysudysouding A Il| .®Z+10 9¥Lv., Na AIAO[d 3[GBII0g Snlivdais snjjauv 4 A xX wT JOAO|d Pal [tq-3u0T] snpionjd sniappaoy gjoouneld ioe A A A I pasuim-yoer|q IUUDUIPAOU DJOAAD] OY A A xo A xa Il preisng ani] xD4Ja] XDA} A A A xo Il I ITV pavjsng jeai5 Dps0}] SUQ A I I piejsng ereqnoy, ppjnpun syopAun]y > . A Xx WAT OYPID patjaq-pueg ujjnydod puvz10g A A A A A A le II WIV NA IyBID U1OD Xadd XALD A 87+ 1A [ey MOPPIA UBISY snyisinbxa sdoniusnjoD A I =| if) NA | auesD padeu-aiy Ay odia snip A I PIT auelD papooyH DYIDUOU SNAD) A I I PIT7V Na aueig MOUS snuviasoona] snip SIE A I I B7+ID AA| auetd uBLNyouEA sisuauodnl sni | asnoiy A A Ke wT | Yori ueiseones IZIIMAISOYO]U ODAJA]. A X wT 9SNOIH uRLaqIS siuuadizjn{ sndpsp.puaq. A A A A A II I a98TV NA [9-489M 198s] juupuinou OojDy 4 A A Xx A I Il IAT oy Pea SNAPIUCSTALUN, A Il I q7+19 NA I[BVA-VIC §,19]19}S snaispjad snjaan0 Hy ajseq A x II II qt+I9 NA | “UST pople}-purg snyddsoona] snjaavyo A A A A A A X I I WAT ayseq vag Aap) p1]191q/0 snjaavyDH Ie A A A XK AK II II wyT Jo1UeH 3d SNANOAIDU SNIALD [= on (payejouue JI poyxsayo)uoIsay surst] PLOW | Alosayea aulesy | Aoyiny | eissny | eluewoy | e1s0aH | euesing vas yoerig | saisads = SqIO| SWO NONI Noni aWeU UOWILOD, aueU OIZWUIINS Lil SNIIBOAGOP SNAN}LAT MaN AeA SNDISIAD SNANIIAT apoz+ia AQpuBUE[ES UBIDAT 1yonvajs snB.1aanany SNIDIOAI SNBABANAN, MDYISH] Djjaisuayayy Japuewueyes ueiseone) wrt ud “PE+HO7+T A non pDo2IspInvI pjja1. SUa]AI POY DUDY jooyapeds uowwo0) SOL] 991], YT | uowWwoy ueadomq peol Pon | paitaq-asty_ueadoing snosn{f sajpqo]ad padogap DIA] pDUIquiog DuIqUog suviqiydury [imal ieal > > A ata ee Biesing (payejouue JI payooys)uolsay Rag yoRIA apany L740) WO | IPYSIOS UBILyy pany ITHIVLV Nd | 1PYsyos sayvsydng I P7V AA ISIOUO], PI0}-IN0] I weaT| asioyo] suuRWa}H Ul PITV NA 9S10}.10 J, YSIAOOJAL WAIT | Wun] puog ueadoing I Paeiv Na apany uwaa15 1 Pariv Na peaysass0'_7 ulO 97+18 Il ‘PT+PIV.. Na AIdIA S,19UBB AA I ITZHITV Na dadiA MOpeay] ova Jodi, ueuouy ul 487). fe) P27+PITV Na dadiA ueiseone) L74a £0) NA qw) te) u®Z) 87+T Es WO | sodi, svsing juno u®ZO 97+1 8 Na Jada uleyUNO|A| ayeug ul ‘PIV. DA | 493BAA Papway-asieT dad ayeus predoaT L740) Na es ea ld Surpieas Sunst| saisads SALI paysayo-jnuysoyo, IIEQssorD Ysm09g sinsuniy] xAuols snayvaydna snjafoy upjayssoy opnjsay 1MUUDULAaY OPNISa] D2av48 Opnisa [ SLUDINIIGAO SAULT sppdu piuojayD) Dyjasv2 Dav Mauspm vsadi4 uuisin p4iadi4 lappb4 Daadi{ payuod viadi, 1oypu2vy vsadl 4 iyjuup viadiA nysaasop vsadi, pa1ysppsvejng vsadi,4 puoziq]p vsadi A pjoydazojvsau X140N] pinyis aydojyq UINLOYIDII DILAIVT DUIG]D Dj4dIDT satndoy sisuaddijiyd snuanjs DINOS DIXOT sunung WATT paduins-o14y9Q RAW | AlosaeD OueU UOUWILUOD) sisuaossad Dzaquy DUIBU OIZIJUIIOS 8I1 | WT Jaqueg snging snqing aa dsy snidsp snidsy tact yay2oy snuangiy arty] nA | yeayg uelyery Snpiqo snuang] apcv| na | 1B1jeq 20405 Ippo snuang]y aq SnLupupaul snjijn4oyjuvo py aa | SLUJUAALAYINI Djjauoadny) atar npiqo pjjauoadnyD fatal poyuod psojpy aa | po1joapu DSO] y ad peys Weary xnj[0f Dsojy dad Peus SHIV DSO|D DSOIV Il PZ7V Na u0aBINj}S jURID osny osny] P7+IPIVTV fe) esnpg osny osnyy II PTV Na U0IB1N}S JUBI osny osny] PZ+9pIVTV Na esney snaiinvp OsnH PTV Ne) u0as.injs In/eg o1snjs sasuadioy PTV Na U0IB.1N}JS 18} snjojjajs sasuadioy PZ+9PIVTV NA U0IBIN}S 3}E[[IS Snjvjjajs sasuadiay PTV Na U0IB1N}JS 18}S Snjojjajs sasuadiap PZ+PIVITV Na uoas.injg nWy 1yauasyas Jasuadiap PZHITV NA 32]4193 snuayjns sasuadioy PITV NA 32]4123 snuayins sasuadioy PZHITV NA 39]193 snuayjns sasuadioy wIV Na U093.1N}S UBISIIG snaissad sasuadiap PTV Na U09B.1N}S UBISIIG snaissad sasuadipy WIV Na U0Id.1N}S ULISIIgG snaissad sasuadiopy PZ+9pIVLV Na uoas.injs diys siguaaipnu sasuadiop PZ+9PIVTV Na uoas.injs diys Siuadipnu sasuadiop PZ+9PIV TV Na uoas.injsg diys Siuadipnu sasuadiop | ie) Na u0ad.injg UlpeyxeS loppynu sasuadiay (930u 32s) p7V Na u0dd1NjJS UBISSNYy x pavjsuapns sasuadiopy aprely Na u0d3.1N}g UBISSNy Ypavjsuapjans sasuadiapy PTV Na u093.1NjS UBISSNYy Ypavjsuapjans sasuadiapy aporrtTy Na u093.1Njg uBISsNy Ypavjsuapjans sasuadiapy PTV NA U0IBANJS URLIIGIS isang sasuadioy wat Aaiduie] yoolg taaunjd pajadunT wey Aoiduie’T JOAry syupiany, pajadunT HDAWALAONILOV -UStd A A wy} Aoidue’y s,aoyApeyA 1aoyApoja uozAWMojUuOpNy Aoidure] A A A A A A dq | yoou1g ueluesly() aplipu UuozAUMojUuOpny Aaiduie] XA A A wT | Yoo ueiujedies Ipaofupp uozdumojuopngy IHdYONOCIdSVTVHddO -4sl (payejouur I payxoays)uoisay sunst| Bugg | A1osaqeD auresyy) | Aayiny | eissmy | eruewoy | eisi0ay | eueding Bag yorlq | saiseds = SALIO} SWO Noni Noni awieu UOWUWOD DWI SIZUIIDS 6lIl A a2 (etal = 1BIMSSOY SN}LaYIDUAUIIANT A : =] cd NA SisuanssAimyas} snpiayovuany A =r dad Ipua] snjlayopuan A aE (aa! aDdOsUuD SNJlayODUAN’ A ad zisind pinjoquvg XA [es == aa 1428aanqg al XA A aa Upupdg vjnjoqang A A A 7 A fatal YyoroyT apispjoH DJDAND viMalunqny A A A A wy ysysayea yy SYISSOf SILANSSIP Xx A nse aa yoroT u eiuewioy DOIUDUOA aa [= A A ad pjidspsau sij1go) A Al A daa yoro7T ueyeg DIDsUo]a $1]190) . A =I dda 1aljeg Zeg HID]Y snyJDUsOIAT A ra(al IDZ}IAOIDA SNIUIPADIS A A A all aa yoroy oqnueq sn3id snjyny Al At A A = A A ad yoroy Bag yorlg | ust snjuny A A A A inal Fitirestits| snaaldas snapoyy A qa snapidl snuixoydopnasq snanugdad snuixoyd 18adaz SN] aUlxoy 1YISANpUDY Sn]jauIxoyd aad Mou] dems MIplisa snjjauixoyd IV. ad IV Na Ideq BUX SNIyOJoUD snjjauixoyd aa 28217 | SNyo.yjNI sndajaq Ex ada | sapiojoydas snosionaT ata qny9 b9g yorIg snoiuayjsdiog snosionaT a1V b fe) BES! To) a wo Isyvq BEA SNSSDAD SN]JQUIXOY J snapldi snidsponaT A A n xe | ae n A in Xx A as: sear _ Al K A al: =e: a ZV NA lugziysy ué1ys syddoosasipv7 | = ial youay DjaodpIomUpAs Way] A A A — aa uoaspny aqnueq sndoosounan 01905) A “NE. A A aval UOdSPND S,1a|ssoy 1lajssay 01905) A td NA Isvdey 219q wunsonnay 01905 | Fs uoaspny A all Jl pouuly-ay1y snypuuldiqip 01905) A died uoww0d PIM oidupo snutadt) | J 7V divd uowwod prAA o1diva snuisdd A Ee ZV Mpoomujoy DUojsospuoyD A Isle 1eyoylouy 141d] Snuangjpoj0Y49, yeaiq aqnueq saplozjpyo snuing]ooj0Y4D die 5 ueronig SNISSDIDI SNISSDADD Isljegq ZelIS injsad pjaodp) sisuadjpjup pjaodp) A A ae A as Joqueg uelyey] snfaqajd snquvg A jaqieg uBoueayIpay| S1DUOIPldau snqdDg (payejouue JI A A A A A A sidajojaao snqung | poxoay9)uoIsayy SuNsI| BLOW | Alosayea auresyy) | Adyiny | eissny | BlueWOY |} e1dI095 | eesing Rag Yoel | saioads = SALIO.| SIO Noni aweu UOWLOD sueU OIJUAINS 0cl A syypianyf sniqoz0an x snpydaz0yanajng sniqososayy 7x raunn.g sapiopiydoyjuag A 997+99 TV [P3uIZ jasurz jasuiz A 997+99TV 4992.5 dagaas Jaduiz A dad JopuezZ esjoA, SISUAB]OA UOIpa|sOZ|y A ad UINULADUL UOIpaIsOZS 9 PIQET+TA A 997+99BTV,, ie) aaidsy DjOIUDS]DA SAYJYIIUDUOY A A td NA Sfopnuap ouysvrdag SSSsa A A aoVlV NA 49ZJIV1AYIS da2javayas snjoydazouudy A x dd ayny suojeg 1uojpqg snjpydazouudy) A A ad pul4aop snppydazouuAy A aT uidjnog woyinoy siudoaaponb snppydasoxoApy A A A A A ——A] ada Snypauljo4siu SNYJDUBUAG A 4ajspgp snyjpUsUuds A YSIJIT[ES SS2T2TB9S snjouonbsp skyjyoi3imssoy A poqz7+1a Sualpasssuvs] sniunydy A aqzt+ia| ow | snupdains sniupydy 9997+ A WIV, wo suapuajds sniuvydy dieoyoo], A dq | ueadoing yynos snypiospf sniupydp A [AT Steg yrouezestjsiq raajupyo sniupydy A Na snoinping sniupydy uP9QUT+TA ‘7Viu Na | seg youezesiysiq apyojouv sniuvydy aad 14akOg DULLaYI aT suljAein snypoudy) snjpoudy | sdysyiona] snpouals NA Mopidojaas smudyjaajvs qe7+18 NW) qed FIV snpoydaadind mes | 947+ A ‘aprqzV., Na uowyes aqnueg oyony oyony | | aa ysyary a wonog uolyospid snuosa10>) | | qa Ysijayiy A WoyON pajad snuosa410.) | | fatal sunnoy snyoul4dxo SNUOZAIO Ysyouy A wo0g ase] SNSDU SNUOZ2d0 JOIBART SNJAADAD] Snuo3za40,.) A yunog snuosas0) ue][Od sijpuunjnvd snuosa410) | Ysty yA pjnqjp snuosas0) | | }JOWIS snuvjtada sn4ausc MOUUIW A A -pny uvadoing MauDsy DIGQU) (payejouur JI poayoays)uolsay sunsl| Rua | Aiosaqe9 auresyy) | Aon | eissmy | eiuewoy | eidsi0aH | eiesing rag yori | saisads = SALIO | SIO. NONI Noni aluieu UOWIOD AU SIJUDIOS Icl Smuiidasiu snsiadjog sigad $1da]018sv]q naspipios Snuaxosausdy SNIMIGIS SNUAXOINULO] SISUAJDAN DIIULAO +] Juy poo Pry pfna vo1u4o 4 | Uy supaasiu/sisuajpad poom poy ueodoing DOMMAO +] wy Poon pray ueadoing Duajodjod DI1ULd0 J SLUQNSN] DINO +f pluojinbp pono ITV apap) musAuidy qunysppios pusduidy sno1inv} snuaxodajpy aaog JWI qz+14 dVT+ 1A u®7+18 OTV un qc+Ta ITV Dinuasa DUuLJapouseE snomuaf snjunyy u10913U0'T BI]ESOY u10913U0'T XAquIe.139< ayjaag punoly ong ITV o1V NA ITH TV NA wT ITV. NA 9PIT+1 A NA poqe+99d7H NA cd td = ca 9P9d7+1 A 9P9d7T+1 A 9IZ7+9IVTV NA puidjp vypsoy Snasaun{ smurop opsaa XAquivsaD SNJDI1]UI snqpdvd-) suapuajds sysasdng smujpyjydouv S11090]804 SNODISD SNIDISY sisuajpying vanyosidy lamaojdauuny snuojdpipiuayy snoyoyosnupy smuojdoipoja.1p snoiinping smuojdoipoja1p SNITYIDIDA SNdsDYdINE laqn4y snsivydiny sniinjunjd sapauojoq $9}¥.1Q9}19AU] snjpydazoido AOSSAS1AI]SOZ upulsds snigosoan snwuojsounjau sniqgosoan’ 1dajssay Snigoz0aN snjeyooajouuds sniqos0an CCl PT+14 NA punjuow pusipodojuopo eee RRR D2 TT er NA Duadl DjJAWUDLIY a aac NA snonajoson snddisoy) Seren | ER eran [eee eT A S1JDPNDD DIUYA4OONAT 1 A SUOAfIGID DIUIYALOINAT pyoyjodoasnf 9T+14 NA A snuayjdyooig eee ee oa | Anal XK qo)Sunfjiay aun pyjioao snyduoso1ydo fea uoposo0u IT+1 Na A snyduosoyaduoQ SIJTUAISSD IT+14 NA A snydwosoyoducQ IT+10 NA A appudzu sajsvdajnpsoy ZV NA A Ayjaswmeq usayynos | — ayvianosau uorssvua0D _= a7V Nd [Af __ ponysds x4a}d0}0) wT 7 eee ee | siplata DUYysay cto ator | reatasod smaciasoag eared ad sapydoddiy saj¢y aN jo/3ury uajapng poijapns piqadq aN jo[sury Asseig uRWwONO DUDUO}JO DIGaLT A Xx wea jo|sury asjey snddipao nyduduouao,) A A A A Il IPITV NA Ayaaying ojjody ojjodp snisspusvg A A WAT stupuiyjodp uoyo4p A qa Are ][ 4] 99189 | puanjou spcipodapy A A wat ang ase] 2019 | sniaja] DaUIjNoDy A A A waT anjg asuey Aysnq | snoyjIsnpu DauljnoDy A wea an|q asie'T 19}8a1H) Sapluolip paUuljnovpy A A A A wT an|gq odie] UOLID DAUI]NIDY XA A A A wat an[q ase] uosTy uog]D Dauljnonyy A A A A wT jaddog adie] dpdsip puavoaT A A a1V NA Wo yaddeT jews pyofioyy musapoy aud x aad XDIDI AdJSVBO1UT XA A A A aN Jaddryg parey[assa |, win] assa] SNJYIAAS A A aN Jaddiyg asourds UNpJadgtAd SNYYIAAS | A 7a NA ai 1ys2nd SnyjousojAsuois Mapuiquas ral NA snyjouso/Asuoys Ja]}1stoy A za snyjousojAsuoys iafompsvy A wa NA snyjwusojAsuoys 1ydojsisyao A 7d NA snyjousojAsuoys dafyayo A cd NA | snyjousojAsuoys i upjouip =| A cd DA | snyjwusojAsuoys univonusofoid A 7a NA | xaudnuossoy €Cl ‘PTV PLAID oy} YM (NA) palosuepug si satoads sty} 0} pousisse Vary} JO AJOSO}wO [[LIOAO dy], “AO¥IN] pure LIILS|Ng JO} UdyRLOPUN JOM SJUDLUISSasse YOO}s [ENPIAIPUI OU (14panjsuapjans iasuadiop) UOISINAS URISSNY OY) JO] 4x SsoX =A ‘ON =X :3]0N A A A| A | | PIT [leug s,uljnoyy soq DUDISUI]NOU O81424 [reus A PIT Bea HOuM payynow-punoy usauas 0381}124 [reus im A ESky OYA patynow-MoueN AONSNBUD 081140 ie a een dq | == eae os eel sysuatuua PIUO]/OA Jee A |. eS ee suanu ndooi}420.) [war] KL *d_so20 sanding Af ia 2 ee eee advo D103 aa DUOJSOYJ4O DIJO] f A A ad [leus snounn|5 psoulny]s spxdjy A SI/DSAaASUDA] SNXOPOAY [ pyounjduoo pjuopouppnasq pdafijlaDsADu Jassnyy] [Weaq JayeMYSOLJ DsafiplADSADY yoaoT [BUlolpayy SIDUIDIpau OPNALET 9T+99 LV Na BS a ea ie 2Z — 1 el I yD As0jUprid opad vsvg PqT+Ta f — [a+ za | MA aa | Jajjiasas snjouozUug Ea ES Eee) ipayBowop vsardounoy LSet 20 ae ale Sa puny vdydosy snomupayAssuvs} (eat SS eae OAS ae a DoyDUDG DIYSAOGnZ | peta Asis sina saposspoqouars A aN sisdousipog 6. ENDANGERED PLANT SPECIES OF BLACK SEA STATES It has not been possible, within the resources assigned to this project, to sort the plant data by region. Therefore the lists in Annex | and 2 are endangered plants from the six Black Sea nations but their habitat ranges do not necessarily occur along the Black Sea Coast. This will be most serious for Russia — some of the more obvious species (e.g. those in Siberia) have been removed but it was not possible to devote additional time to sorting the data more thoroughiy. This would have to be carefully co-ordinated with regional taxonomic experts and would take between 10 and 15 days. 6.1 Globally threatened plants endemic to single countries bordering the Black Sea A list of globally threatened plants endemic to single countries bordering the Black Sea is given in Annex | at the back of this report. 6.2 Status of globally threatened plants occurring in five countries bordering the Black Sea Table 3 Country Ex Ex/E E Vv R I Total Bulgaria 0 1 1 14 44 3 63 Georgia 0 0 0 0 0 12 12 Russia 6 ] 17 26 157 51 258 Turkey 10 l 47 168 1667 54 1947 Ukraine 0 l 7 1] 2 13 24 Total (1) 16 4 72 209 1870 133 2304 Data are given for the original IUCN threat categories: Ex = Extinct Ex/E = Extinct/endangered (suspected to be extinct) E = Endangered V = Vulnerable R= Rare I = Indeterminate (belonging to one of the classes above, but insufficient detail to determine which one) Notes on the data Data for Russia are limited. Some records have been resolved to areas local to the Black Sea, i.e. North Caucasus, but many records relate to former USSR or "former European USSR". Records clearly relating to areas of Russia away from the Black Sea have been omitted. High numbers of threatened plants for Turkey reflect the enormous importance of this country as a Centre of Plant Diversity. 6.3 Globally threatened plants occurring in more than one country bordering the Black Sea A list of globally threatened plants endemic occurring in more than one country bordering the Black Sea is given in Annex 2 at the back of this report. 124 7. INTERNATIONAL CONVENTIONS AND AGREEMENTS COVERING THE BLACK SEA COAST STRATEGIC ACTION PLAN FOR THE REHABILITATION AND PROTECTION OF THE BLACK SEA Desiring to rehabilitate and protect the Black Sea the Governments of: Bulgaria Georgia Romania the Russian Federation Turkey and Ukraine Reaffirming their commitment to the rehabilitation and protection of the Black Sea ecosystem and the sustainable development of its resources as expressed, in particular, in the Bucharest Convention and the Odesa Declaration; Continuing in the spirit of the United Nations Declaration on Environment and Development (Rio Declaration) and Agenda 21; Appreciating the progress that has been made towards attaining sustainable development in the Black Sea region through, amongst other things, the actions taken within the Black Sea Environmental Programme (BSEP) in support of the implementation of the Bucharest Convention and the Odesa Declaration; Welcoming the international initiatives undertaken to rehabilitate and protect the waters of the rivers flowing into the Black Sea, in particular, the Danube, Dnipro (Dnieper) and Don; Welcoming also, the national initiatives taken to ratify or accede to international conventions relevant to attaining the rehabilitation and protection of the Black Sea ; Noting the work undertaken towards the adoption of the Convention for Fisheries and Conservation of Living Resources of the Black Sea; Conscious of the importance of the initiatives taken by non-governmental organisations towards attaining the rehabilitation and protection of the Black Sea; Nevertheless remain concerned about the state of the Black Sea ecosystem and the limited recovery of its resources; Convinced of the pressing need to take further concrete actions, individually and collectively, at national and regional levels in order to ensure the rehabilitation and protection of the Black Sea ecosystem and the sustainable use of its resources; Recalling that the preparation of a strategic action plan was called for in Resolution 3, adopted at the Diplomatic Conference on the Protection of the Black Sea, Bucharest, April 21-22, 1992 and in the Final Act of the Ministerial Meeting on the Declaration on the Protection of the Black Sea, Odesa, April 6-7,1993; Decide to agree on the following principles, policies and actions: I. The Challenge: The State of the Black Sea Environment The state of the Black Sea environment continues to be a matter of concern due to the ongoing degradation of its ecosystem and the unsustainable use of its natural resources. The Transboundary Diagnostic Analysis (TDA), which is a technical annex to this Strategic Action Plan, leads to the following conclusions. Me The Black Sea ecosystem continues to be threatened by inputs of certain pollutants, notably nutrients. Nutrients enter the Black Sea from land based sources, and in particular through rivers. The Danube river accounts for well over half of the nutrient input to the Black Sea. Eutrophication is a phenomenon which occurs over wide areas of the Black Sea and should be of concern to the countries of the Black Sea basin. Il. Inputs of insufficiently treated sewage result in the presence of microbiological contaminants, which constitute a threat to public health and in some cases pose a barrier to the development of sustainable tourism and aquaculture. 125 Ill. IV. VI. VI. In addition, inputs of other harmful substances, and especially oil, continue to threaten the Black Sea ecosystem. Oil enters the environment as a result of accidental and operational discharges from vessels, as well as through land based sources. Almost half of the inputs of oil from land based activities are brought to the Black Sea via the Danube river. Moreover, the past introduction of exotic species, through the deballasting of vessels, has seriously damaged the Black Sea ecosystem and constitutes a threat to the adjacent Mediterranean and Caspian Seas. Inadequate resources management and, in particular, inadequate policies with respect to fisheries and coastal zone management continue to impede the sustainable development of the Black Sea region. Most fish stocks in the Black Sea, already stressed as a consequence of pollution, have been over exploited or are threatened by over exploitation; many coastal areas have deteriorated as a result of erosion and uncontrolled urban and industrial development, including the resultant construction activities. Consequently, there is a serious risk of losing valuable habitats and landscape and ultimately, the biological diversity and productivity of the Black Sea ecosystem. The above considerations led to suggestions that the process of degradation of the Black Sea is irreversible. However, environmental monitoring, conducted over the past 4-5 years, reflects perceptible and continued improvements in the state of, some localised components of the Black Sea ecosystem. These improvements appear to be the indirect result of reduced economic activity in the region, and to a certain degree of protective measures taken by governments. The challenge which the region now faces is to secure a healthy Black Sea environment at a time when economic recovery and further development are also being pursued. This Strategic Action Plan is a step in the process towards attaining sustainable development in the Black Sea region. Its overall aims are to enable the population of the Black Sea region to enjoy a healthy living environment in both urban and rural areas, and to attain a biologically diverse Black Sea ecosystem with viable natural populations of higher organisms, including marine mammals and sturgeons, and which will support livelihoods based on sustainable activities such as fishing, aquaculture and tourism in all Black Sea countries. The Basis for Co-operative Action Principles I. Il. Ill. IV. The concept of sustainable development shall be applied, by virtue of which the carrying capacity of the Black Sea ecosystem is not exceeded nor the interests of future generations prejudiced. The precautionary principle shall be applied, by virtue of which preventative measures are to be taken when there are reasonable grounds for concern that an activity may increase the risk of presenting hazards to human health, harm living resources and marine ecosystems, damage amenities or interfere with other legitimate uses of the sea, even when there is no conclusive evidence of a causal relationship between the activity and the effects and by virtue of which greater caution is required when information is uncertain, unreliable or inadequate. Anticipatory actions, such as contingency planning, environmental impact assessment and strategic environmental assessment (involving the assessment of the environmental consequences of governmental policies, programmes and plans), shall be taken. The use of clean technologies shall be stimulated, which require the replacement or phasing-out of high waste and waste generating technologies that remain in use. The use of economic instruments that foster sustainable development shall be promoted through, amongst other things, the implementation of economic incentives for introducing environmentally friendly technologies and activities; the phasing-out of subsidies which encourage the continuation of non-environmentally friendly technologies and activities; the introduction of user fees and the polluter pays principle; as well as the application of natural resources and environmental accounting. 126 VI. VI. VU. IX. XI. XI. XII. XIV. XV. XVI. XVII. Environmental and health considerations shall be included into all relevant policies and sectoral plans, such as those concerning tourism, urban planning, agriculture, industrial development, fisheries and aquaculture. Pending the resolution of ocean boundary matters in the region, close co-operation among Black Sea coastal states, in adopting interim arrangements which facilitate the rehabilitation of and protection of the Black Sea ecosystem and the sustainable management of its resources shall be pursued. Co-operation among all Black Sea basin states, and, in particular, between the Black Sea coastal states and the states of the Danube river basin, shall be promoted. The involvement of stakeholders in the implementation of this Strategic Action Plan, through, amongst other things, the determination of user and property rights shall be promoted. Transparency and public participation, shall be fostered through the wide dissemination of information on the work undertaken to rehabilitate and protect the Black Sea and through the recognition and the exercise of the right of participation of the public, including stakeholders, in the decision making and implementation of this Strategic Action Plan. The Istanbul Commission In order to implement the actions and policies agreed on, it is imperative that the regional mechanisms for co-operation among Black Sea states be strengthened. The Istanbul Commission and its subsidiary bodies, including its Secretariat, should be fully functioning, in accordance with the Bucharest Convention, by January 1997. In order to achieve this, Black Sea states agree to make available the necessary financial and other resources. The Istanbul Commission having agreed to implement this Strategic Action Plan at its second session, held in Istanbul on September 16-17, 1996, is invited to establish, by November 1997, a body to provide support for specific projects and processes related to the implementation of this Strategic Action Plan. It is recommended that, by January 1997, the Istanbul Commission establish, on the basis of the current structure of BSEP Working Parties, subsidiary bodies which can assist it in the implementation of the Strategic Action Plan. It is recommended that the Istanbul Commission initially establish the following Advisory Groups as its subsidiary bodies, the description and general terms of reference of which are given in Annex I: A. an Advisory Group on the Environmental and Safety Aspects of Shipping, co-ordinated by the Activity Centre in Varna, Bulgaria; B. an Advisory Group on Pollution Monitoring and Assessment, co-ordinated by the Activity Centre in Odesa, Ukraine; C. an Advisory Group on Control of Pollution from Land Based Sources, co-ordinated by the Activity Centre in Istanbul, Turkey; D. an Advisory Group on the Development of Common Methodologies for Integrated Coastal Zone Management, co-ordinated by the Activity Centre in Krasnodar, Russia; E. an Advisory Group on the Conservation of Biological Diversity, co-ordinated by the Activity Centre in Batumi, Georgia; F. an Advisory Group on Fisheries and other Marine Living Resources, co-ordinated by the Activity Centre in Constanta, Romania; and G. an Advisory Group on Information and Data Exchange, co- ordinated by the Commission Secretariat. It is recommended that the Istanbul Commission regularly review the status and functions of the Advisory Groups and consider the establishment of ad hoc groups for the purposes of implementing this Strategic Action Plan. It is recommended that the Istanbul Commission assume the responsibilities from the Black BSEP- PCU for the operation and maintenance of the electronic communication system which has been established for purposes of facilitating communication between the components of the Black Sea institutional network. 127 XVIII. In order to strengthen and co-ordinate the work of national and regional research institutions, it is recommended that the Istanbul Commission assume the responsibilities from the BSEP-PCU for the clearing house mechanism for the exchange of information on bibliography, data sources and research programmes. In addition, it is recommended that the Istanbul Commission organise BI- annual research conferences on topics related to the goals of this Strategic Action Plan. The first of such conferences will be held in June 1998. Wider Co-operation Black Sea countries shall individually and jointly encourage the following: a) Enhanced co-ordination between the regional bodies which contribute towards the rehabilitation and protection of the Black Sea ecosystem and the sustainable development of Black Sea resources, such bodies include the Istanbul Commission and its subsidiary bodies, the Black Sea Economic Co-operation (BSEC), the Parliamentary Assembly for the Black Sea Economic Co-operation (PABSEC), the future Black Sea Fisheries Commission, and the NGO Forum; b) Close co-operation between the regional governmental bodies and the NGO Forum through transparency of the negotiating process, widespread availability of information and documents, and, where appropriate, open access to meetings; c) Close co-ordination of the activities of donors, including multilateral financial institutions, the European Union, bilateral aid agencies and private foundations, in their aim to secure funding for projects and policies identified in this Strategic Action Plan and to be further developed in the National Black Sea Strategic Action Plans. d) Close co-operation with relevant international organisations, including UN Agencies and _ international non-governmental organisations in implementing this Strategic Action Plan. International agreements relevant to the aims and objectives of this Strategic Action Plan should be implemented by each Black Sea state and, where this is appropriate and has not yet been done, it is recommended that Black Sea states consider ratifying or acceding to such agreements. Consideration should also be given to implementing other relevant international instruments. Policy Actions A. Reduction of Pollution Land based sources of pollution Rivers I. A Black Sea Basin Wide Strategy, negotiated with all states located in the Black Sea Basin, should be developed to address the eutrophication problem in the Black Sea. The objective of the Strategy should be to negotiate a progressive series of stepwise reductions of nutrient loads, until agreed Black Sea water quality objectives are met. Such a Basin Wide Strategy may also be required to ensure the reduction of inputs of other pollutants into the Black Sea, in particular oil. Il. Given that the Danube is the largest single source of nutrient inputs into the Black Sea, it is imperative that strategies for the reduction of nutrients be adopted for this river. The provisions in the Danube Strategic Action Plan (maintenance of 1995 levels) clearly are insufficient for addressing the eutrophication problem in the Black Sea. Airborne pollution lf. More attention should be focussed on the issue of airborne pollutants, particularly those that involve transboundary movements, as well as appropriate measures for controlling them at source. In initial assessment of the magnitude of this problem should be undertaken by 1999. High priority point- sources IV. A list of high priority sites (hot-spots) for reducing discharges of pollutants has been developed. It will provide the basis for the elaboration of national strategies and timetables for realising substantial reductions of inputs of pollutants from hot-spots, in accordance with agreed water quality objectives. The following procedure has been agreed for the purpose of attaining these reduced inputs by 2006. Each Black Sea coastal state, in its National Black Sea Strategic Action Plan, will 128 VI. VIL. specify the strategies and timetables for attaining reduced inputs from the hot-spots located in its territory. In those cases where investments (as opposed to policy changes or economic restructuring) are required, in order to address specific hot-spots, pre-investment and investment studies will be pursued, with donor support where possible. National reports on the progress made in addressing the identified hot-spots will be presented to the Istanbul Commission and widely disseminated, in 2000 and 2005. It is recommended that the Istanbul Commission prepare a consolidated report on this topic in time for the Ministerial meetings in 2001 and 2006. This report should include an assessment of the progress made on the strategy for each site. If the progress made is found to be insufficient to meet the agreed water quality objectives, further steps to reduce inputs will be decided upon at the Ministerial meetings. Regulation of point sources In addition to the high priority point-sources, comprehensive national studies on the discharges of insufficiently treated sewage will be prepared by each Black Sea state by January 2000. It is recommended that this activity be co-ordinated by the Istanbul Commission, through its Advisory Group on the Control of Pollution from Land-Based sources. These studies should analyse the national and regional benefits to public health, the environment and recreation as well as the economic costs of installing sewage treatment plants. The studies shall serve as a basis for taking decisions and implementing significant reductions of the inputs of insufficiently treated sewage from large urban areas by 2006. In order to implement the Protocol on Land Based Sources to the Bucharest Convention and with a view to the gradual reduction of inputs of pollutants in general and the elimination of discharges of persistent pollutants of global significance (POPs) the following actions shall be taken. A. Water quality objectives shall be harmonised on the basis of the uses of water (drinking water, bathing water, aquaculture, ports etc.). It is advised that the Istanbul Commission, upon the recommendations of its Advisory Group on Pollution Monitoring and Assessment, adopt such harmonised water quality objectives and where necessary standards by mid-1998. Furthermore, these objectives should be subjected to a comprehensive review every five years. B. Procedures used for monitoring the actual discharge of effluent at point sources shall be harmonised. It is advised that the Istanbul Commission, upon the recommendations of its Advisory Group on the Control of Pollution from Land Based Sources, adopt such procedures by mid-1998. C. Each Black Sea state shall endeavour to adopt and implement, in accordance with its own legal system, by 1999, the laws and mechanisms required for regulating discharges from point sources. The basis for regulating discharges will be a licensing system, through which the harmonised water quality objectives can be applied, and through which effluent charges, based on the polluter pays principle, can be levied. D. Each Black Sea state will also endeavour to adopt and implement, in accordance with its own legal system, efficient enforcement mechanisms by 1999. E. In order to secure the implementation of the actions agreed to in this paragraph, each Black Sea state shall ensure that the national agencies responsible for licensing, monitoring and enforcement are adequately staffed and that the necessary resources are available to them. Where necessary, training courses at local agencies, will be organised. F. Each Black Sea state will consider the introduction of policies in which polluters are made to pay for compliance. The application of environmentally friendly production processes or other innovative process which reduce inputs of pollutants may also be encouraged through economic incentives. Vessel source pollution II. MARPOL 1973/78 shall be more effectively implemented by Black Sea states, especially with a view to giving effect to its provisions on Special Areas, by 2002. Due to the rapid increase in traffic to Black Sea ports, the capacity of harbour reception facilities needs to be enlarged in order to comply with MARPOL Special Area requirements. Harbour reception facilities will be installed: for garbage by December 1999; for oil by December 2000; and for chemicals by December 2002. The use of these facilities shall be made compulsory. In installing 129 lif. IV. VI. harbour reception facilities close co-operation with the private sector will be pursued, the advice of the IMO will be requested, and the results of the study conducted by the BSEP and the European Union will be taken into account. A harmonised system of port state control will be established in the Black Sea region through the adoption of a Memorandum of Understanding on Port State Control. It is advised that the Istanbul Commission adopt such a Memorandum, upon the recommendations of the Advisory Group on Environmental and Safety Aspects of Shipping, by December 1998. Black Sea states shall take the necessary steps to enable them to fully exercise their prescriptive and enforcement powers, in accordance with international law, in order to pursue the reduction of illegal discharges by vessels into the Black Sea. A harmonised system of enforcement, including fines, will be developed for the Black Sea region. It s advised that the Istanbul Commission, upon the recommendations of the Advisory Group on the Environmental and Safety Aspects of Shipping, adopt such a system by December 1998. The primary aim of this system will be to serve as a deterrent for illegal discharges and, where necessary, to exercise enforcement action against illegal dischargers. Black Sea states will present a joint proposal to the IMO, in 1997, for conducting an in-depth study on measures to avoid any further introductions of exotic species into the Black Sea through the deballasting of vessels. Given the danger of such species migrating to other seas in the region, the coastal states of the Caspian and Mediterranean Seas will be consulted. Pollution from dumping I. I. lif. IV. A total ban on the disposal of municipal garbage in marine, shoreline and estuarine areas shall be imposed by December 1996. Each Black Sea state shall develop a plan setting out the manner in which comprehensive enforcement of the ban will be attained by December 1999. Illegal dumping operations in the Black Sea are a matter of concern. Black Sea states, individually and jointly, shall take measures to control any dumping activities that may take place. Black Sea states, through the Istanbul Commission and in accordance with article 3 of the Protocol on Dumping to the Bucharest Convention, shall define concentration levels for trace contaminants in dredged spoils, by February 1998. Black Sea states shall consider amending the Protocol on Dumping to the Bucharest Convention, in accordance with the London Convention 1972, including its subsequent amendments. Waste management IE The Black Sea coastal states will co-operate in developing and implementing environmentally sound waste management policies, giving due consideration to waste minimisation, recycling and reuse. Transboundary movement of hazardous wastes I. Without further delay, Black Sea states, through the Istanbul Commission, and in accordance with Resolution 1, adopted at the Diplomatic Conference on the Protection of the Black Sea Against Pollution, shall complete and adopt the text of a Protocol to the Bucharest Convention concerning the transboundary movement of hazardous wastes and co-operation in combating illegal traffic thereof. 130 Contingency planning and emergency response I. Hl. IV. A Black Sea Strategy for contingency planning and emergency response shall be developed. It is recommended that the Istanbul Commission, upon the recommendation of its Advisory Group on the Environmental and Safety Aspects of Shipping, adopt such a Strategy, by December 1997. This Strategy should provide a basis for ensuring that the contingency plans developed within Black Sea states are sufficiently co-ordinated. It will also serve as a basis for the development of the regional contingency plan. National and local contingency plans, covering both vessels and offshore installations, shall be improved and, where appropriate, adopted, by December 1998. The responsibilities and obligations of governmental agencies in the event of marine emergencies shall be clearly defined. National contingency plans shall be developed in accordance with IMO guidelines, as well as other relevant international instruments, including the Black Sea Strategy for contingency planning and emergency response. A Black Sea Contingency Plan shall be adopted. It is recommended that the Istanbul Commission, upon the recommendations of its Advisory Group on the Environmental and Safety Aspect of Shipping, adopt such a plan by December 2000. The Black Sea Contingency Plan should address the compatibility of: emergency equipment, reporting forms and oil spill data; classification of the scale of spillage’s; methods for evaluating the sensitivity of the coast to hazards; and spill decision support systems, including models for forecasting oil movements. In addition, regionally co- ordinated national classification and risk assessment systems shall be developed. In order to ensure rapid and effective action by national emergency response agencies, each Black Sea state, in co-operation with the private sector and, where appropriate, with international and bilateral agencies, shall ensure that their own national agencies are adequately staffed and that the necessary resources are available to them. Close co-operation shall be sought with the shipping, oil and gas sectors in order to ensure that, to the extent possible, the cost of developing and implementing contingency plans are born by these sectors. Assessment and monitoring of pollutants If, Il. II. IV. A “State of Pollution of the Black Sea” report will be prepared and published every five years, beginning in 1996. It will be based on the data collected through the co-ordinated pollution monitoring and assessment programmes. A Black Sea Monitoring System, based upon biological effects measurements and measurements of key contaminants, will be established in compliance with the Bucharest Convention. It will consist of the integration of obligatory national monitoring programmes, to be included in the National Strategic Action Plans, and an independent quality assurance system. It is advised that the Istanbul Commission develop such a quatity assurance system through its Advisory Group on Pollution Monitoring and Assessment, by 1998. A uniform measurement technique for bathing water quality with a common quality assurance support mechanism shall be developed. It is advised that the Istanbul Commission, upon the recommendations of its Advisory Group on Pollution Monitoring and Assessment, develop this uniform measurement technique by December 1997. Transparency shall be encouraged through the publication and free exchange of data from bathing water quality measurements on at least an annual basis. Data regarding actual and assessed contaminant discharge measurements for point sources, rivers, and, where possible, diffuse sources, shall be compiled and freely exchanged every five years, beginning in 1996. It is advised that the Advisory Group Control of Pollution from Land Based Sources make these compilations in future. 131 Living resources management Commercially exploited resources I. Fish are an integral part of the marine ecosystem, fish stocks thrive in a non-polluted and protected ecosystem and the marine ecosystem profits from properly managed fishing activities. The measures to reduce pollution and to protect biological diversity, habitat and landscape, as agreed upon in this Strategic Action Plan, are therefore pre-conditions for the restoration of commercial fisheries in the Black Sea. In addition, spawning and nursery grounds require special protection. Il. In order to rehabilitate ecosystems, which are of particular importance to Black Sea fisheries as a whole, Phyllophora fields and other critical nursery areas will receive special protection, spawning areas of anadromous species will be restored, and coastal lagoons will be rehabilitated. By 2000, each Black Sea state will develop at least one pilot project which will contribute to the restoration of areas vital to the recovery of Black Sea fish stocks. Il. In order to rehabilitate the Black Sea ecosystem and achieve sustainable fisheries in the Black Sea, fisheries management policies need to be enhanced and fishing effort needs to be adjusted to the status of the stocks. In this regard, the Black Sea coastal states are expected to expedite the adoption of the Fisheries Convention as soon as possible so as to develop a fisheries management system which consists of the following components: regular regionally co-ordinated stock assessments; national fishing authorisations for all Black Sea fishing vessels; a regional licensing system; and a quota system. In addition, enforcement of fisheries regulations urgently needs to be improved. These measures and others, which are required to attain more sustainable fisheries in the Black Sea, should be taken in close co-operation with the fishing sector. Biological diversity protection I. The text of a Protocol on Biological Diversity and Landscape Protection to the Bucharest Convention shall be developed and adopted. It is advised that the Istanbul Commission adopt this Protocol by 2000, upon the recommendations of the Advisory Group on the Conservation of Biological Diversity. The aim is to present the Protocol to the 2001 Ministerial Meeting for signature, after which governments can initiate the national ratification process. Il. A regional Black Sea Red Data Book, identifying and describing endangered species, will be prepared and published by December 1998. It is advised that the work on the Red Data Book be co- ordinated by the Istanbul Commission, through its Advisory Group on the Conservation of Biological Diversity. iil. With the aim of restoring populations of marine mammals the following measures shall be taken: A. A ban on the hunting of marine mammals will be enforced by all Black Sea states with immediate effect. B. Regular population assessments of marine mammals shall be conducted and the first assessment will be completed in 1998. It is advised that these assessments be co-ordinated by the Istanbul Commission, through its Advisory Group on the Conservation of Biological Diversity. C. The Centre for the Conservation of Biological Diversity in Batumi, Georgia, shall be provided with the necessary equipment in order to function as a regional rehabilitation centre for captive marine mammals. D. National centres and sanctuaries for the rehabilitation of marine mammals shall be strengthened. E. Consideration shall be given to modify fishing practices in order to avoid catching marine mammals, as by-catch, during normal operations. It is recommended that the Istanbul Commission, through its Advisory Group on the Conservation of Biological Diversity and its Advisory Group on Fisheries and other Marine Living Resources, develop a strategy for the reduction of by-catches of marine mammals. 132 Protection of Habitat and Landscape I. I. IV. In addition to the actions referred to in paragraphs 57, 58, and 59 of this Strategic Action Plan, the following measures will also be taken to protect habitats and landscape in the Black Sea region. In marine and coastal areas, and in particular in wetlands, new conservation areas shall be designated and the protection of existing conservation areas enhanced. In drafting their National Biological Diversity Strategies, Black Sea states shall take into consideration the integrity of the Black Sea system, by, for example, designating conservation areas which are of regional significance. With a view to enhancing the protection of habitats and landscape in the Black Sea region, both national and regional regulatory instruments shall be improved through the following actions. A. A Regional Strategy for Conservation Areas shall be adopted, and it shall be reviewed every five years. It is advised that the Istanbul Commission adopt the plan by mid-1998, and conduct the reviews, upon the recommendations of its Advisory Group on the Conservation of Biological Diversity. The plan, amongst other things, should address the following: priority locations which should be designated as conservation areas; priority locations where current measures for protection should be enhanced; objectives, standards and measures for the protection of conservation areas; and fund raising aspects. B. Each Black Sea state, by 2000, shall endeavour to revise, and where applicable adopt, in accordance with its own legal system, national laws, regulations and planning instruments for the protection of conservation areas. These laws, regulations and _ planning instruments shall conform with relevant international instruments, including the Regional Strategy for Conservation Areas. The national instruments, amongst other things, should identify the responsible management authority and the responsible government agency; include procedures for the identification of conservation areas; require that management plans be developed for each conservation area; set standards for managing conservation areas; and, where appropriate, establish procedures for public participation and partnerships between governmental agencies and NGO’s for the management of conservation areas. C. Each Black Sea state, where appropriate with the support of bilateral or multilateral agencies, shall ensure that the authorities which manage conservation areas are adequately staffed and that the necessary resources are available to them. Public awareness campaigns, including programs for schools, local communities, and natural resource users in the conservation areas shall be developed. Such campaigns, where appropriate, will be co-ordinated at the regional level. Sustainable Human Development Environmental Impact Assessment 1. By 1998, all Black Sea coastal states will adopt criteria for environmental impact assessments and environmental audits that will be compulsory for all public and private projects. The coastal states will co-operate to harmonise these criteria by 1999 and where possible, to introduce strategic environmental assessments. Integrated coastal zone management I. In order to ensure proper management of the coastal zone, co-ordinated integrated coastal zone management strategies shall be developed for the Black Sea region. In order to attain this the following actions will be taken. A. A Regional Black Sea Strategy for integrated coastal zone management shall be developed. It is advised that the Istanbul Commission develop such a strategy by December 1998, upon the recommendations of its Advisory Group on the Development of Common Methodologies for Integrated Coastal Zone Management. The regional strategy should elaborate basic principles and methodologies for land- and water-use planning as well as for designing zoning systems. The methodologies and principles recommended in the regional strategy shall be taken into account when developing or reviewing national strategies and planning instruments for integrated coastal zone management. B. Each Black Sea coastal state shall endeavour to adopt and implement, in accordance with its own legal system, by 1999, the legal and other instruments required to facilitate integrated coastal zone management. C. Inter-sectoral committees for integrated coastal zone management shall be established at the national, regional 133 Il. and local levels of public administration, where appropriate, by the end of 1997. These committees shall design and implement national plans for integrated coastal zone management through participatory approaches. Erosion and land degradation have important environmental and social impacts. Coastal erosion, due to the changed hydraulic conditions in many of the regions rivers, is a problem which has transboundary implications. Deforestation is another major factor contributing to land degradation. A survey of coastal erosion problems in the region will be conducted by 1998. It is recommended that the Istanbul Commission, through its Advisory Group on the Development of Common Methodologies for Integrated Coastal Zone Management co-ordinate the work on this survey. The survey should address the magnitude of the problem, including its economic implications; propose remedial actions, and include suggestions for pilot studies and demonstration projects. Development of sustainable aquaculture and tourism I. Il. Ii. Aquaculture and tourism are two areas considered to have scope for economic growth in the Black Sea and to benefit the region in general. In order to avoid environmental damage resulting from these activities, and particularly damage with transboundary implications, their development shall be managed along common environmental norms to be established by 1999. It is advised that that the Istanbul Commission, with the support of its Advisory Groups, adopt these common norms and liaise, where appropriate, with the Fisheries Commission, once this body has been established, to adopt an industry code of practice. Sustainable aquaculture should be stimulated, amongst other things, through the conduct of feasibility studies. In parallel, legislation enabling the regulation of aquaculture should be developed. Such legislation should ensure that aquaculture itself does not present a threat to the environment and should address issues, such as, the location and density of cages, releases of commercial strains, imports and releases of exotic species, quarantining and matters of hygiene. Moreover, aquaculture projects shall be subjected to environmental impact assessments in which the potential effect of the activity upon biological diversity are given careful consideration. Eco-tourism should be stimulated in the region, amongst other things, through the implementation of concrete pilot projects in Black Sea coastal states. In close co-operation with the tourist industry and the national tourism authorities, environmental codes of conduct and training courses in sustainable tourism will be developed. The tourism industry, both for the benefit of the industry and for the benefit of the environment, needs to be more adequately planned with a view to incorporating concerns such as those related to water supply, sewage treatment bathing water quality, the use of natural resources and resort development into newly developed projects from the beginning. Moreover, it shall be required that tourist development projects be subjected to environmental impact assessments. Involving the public in environmental decision making I. Il. Hf. Participation of all sectors of society is an essential requirement for the development of sustainable policies in the region. It requires the development of education projects, transparent and participatory decision making procedures and open rules on access to administrative and judicial procedures. Municipalities will be closely involved in the implementation of this Strategic Action Plan. Both existing mechanisms, as the International Black Sea Club of Cities, as well as new mechanisms will be used for this purpose. Black Sea municipalities will also be stimulated to co-operate at the national level and with municipalities in other countries and regions. The Union of Governors of the BSEC will also be requested to co-operate towards the implementation of this Strategic Action Plan. NGOs will continue to be closely involved in the development and implementation of both national and regional policies aimed at rehabilitating and protecting the Black Sea ecosystem and the sustainable use of its natural resources. 134 IV. The Black Sea NGO Forum is encouraged to continue giving its support to the actions taken to rehabilitate and protect the Black Sea and, in particular, to support the implementation of this Strategic Action Plan. It is recommend that the Istanbul Commission adopt procedures which facilitate the participation of the NGO Forum, as an observer, in its meetings. V. Stakeholders will have to be clearly identified for each of the policy areas included in this Strategic Action Plan. Their involvement in the decision making process will be secured and their responsibilities in implementing this Strategic Action Plan defined, through mechanisms such as those provided by new Regional Environmental Centres. VI. — Each Black Sea state, in accordance with its own national legal system, will endeavour to adopt and implement, by 2000, rules which guarantee the right of access to environmental information, which provide for the right of the public and NGOs to participate in decision making, and which provide for the right of individuals and groups to appeal to administrative and judicial organs. It is recommended that the Istanbul Commission prepare a draft position paper on this topic. VI. Information about the actions taken to rehabilitate and protect the Black Sea ecosystem and achieve the sustainable use of its resources will be widely disseminated. Each Black Sea state will publish a popularised version of this Strategic Action Plan, in its own language. In addition, the following actions will taken through the BSEP, in close co-operation with the NGO Forum:. A. An educational information package for use in schools will be developed and each Black Sea state will translate it into its own language; B. A mobile exhibition will be prepared and translated into the languages of the Black Sea states for display at public functions and educational establishments; C. A user- friendly Black Sea CD ROM multimedia information package, based upon the existing GIS system, will be developed. VIII. Based on harmonised criteria, information on the state of bathing water suitable for advising the public on the potential risks to their health shall be made widely available to the public during the active tourist season, starting in 1998. Frequency of sampling and analytical methodology should be sufficient to inform bathers of conditions which may pose health risks. Additionally, a colour coding system for bathing water quality maps shall be developed and such maps shall be published annually starting January in 1999. National Black Sea Strategic Action Plans I. Each Black Sea coastal state shall prepare, by October 1997, a National Black Sea Strategic Action Plan or other corresponding document, which shall present detailed plans for the national implementation of this Strategic Action Plan. These shall include details of specific projects where possible. Financing the Strategic Action Plan I. Funding for the actions agreed upon in this Strategic Action Plan may be secured from domestic, regional or international sources, through general public funding or through the application of specific economic instruments, as well as through grants and loans. Specific projects for international funding should be prepared for bilateral or multilateral funding. Donor Conferences, for assisting in this process, shall be held on a five yearly basis, starting in 1997. Il. Specific funding arrangements for the national policies and measures agreed on in this Strategic Action Plan shall be presented in the National Black Sea Strategic Action Plans to be adopted by each of the Black Sea State. IIT. The feasibility of a Black Sea Environmental Fund shall be fully evaluated with a view to its establishment by the year 2000. The main source of finance for the Fund shall be a set of economic instruments adopted at the national level. Additional funding could be sought from the international community, including multilateral and bilateral donor organisations, international financial institutions and private sector sources. The Fund may be used to finance the work of the Istanbul 135 Commission; the development of project proposals for submission to potential funding sources; and specific projects which support the priorities set in this Strategic Action Plan or as decided on by the Istanbul Commission. Arrangements for Future Co-operation I. Given the assessment of implementation of the Odesa Declaration, which recommends that Ministerial meetings be held every five, instead of every three years, the following arrangements have been agreed. Il. It is advised that the Secretariat of the Istanbul Commission annually report to the Commission on the progress made in implementing this Strategic Action Plan. The report should also contain recommendations for enhancing implementation and adjustment of this Strategic Action Plan, taking into account the Bucharest Convention and the Odesa Declaration. The Istanbul Commission should consider the report and decide on any enhancements and/or adjustments which may be necessary to secure implementation of this Strategic Action Plan. Il. It is advised that a comprehensive report, assessing the implementation of this Strategic Action Plan, be prepared by the Istanbul Commission, upon the recommendations of its subsidiary bodies, and presented to the Governments of the Black Sea states and to the general public every five years. The report should also contain recommendations for enhancing implementation of the Strategic Action Plan as well as recommendations for its amendment, with a view to adopting any further actions which may be required to secure the rehabilitation and protection of the Black Sea. IV. Ministers responsible for the rehabilitation and protection the Black Sea states will meet every five years with the objective of evaluating the progress made in implementing this Strategic Action Plan and adopting any additional actions that may be required to attain its overall aims. CONVENTION ON THE PROTECTION OF THE BLACK SEA AGAINST POLLUTION (21 Apr 1992) The Contracting Parties, Determined to act with a view to achieve progress in the protection of the marine environment of the Black Sea and in the conservation of its living resources, Conscious of the importance of the economic, social and health values of the marine environment of the Black Sea, Convinced that the natural resources and amenities of the Black Sea can be preserved primarily through joint efforts of the Black Sea countries, Taking into account the generally accepted rules and regulations of international law, Having in mind the principles, customs and rules of general international law regulating the protection and preservation of the marine environment and the conservation of the living resources thereof, Taking into account the relevant provisions of the Convention on Prevention of Marine Pollution by Dumping of Wastes and Other Matter of 1972 as amended; the International Convention on Prevention of Pollution from Ships of 1973 as modified by the Protocol of 1978 relating thereto as amended; the Convention on Control of Transboundary Movement of Hazardous Wastes and Their Disposal of 1989 and the International Convention on Oil Pollution Preparedness, Response and Co-operation of 1990, Recognising the significance of the principles adopted by the Conference on Security and Co-operation in Europe, Taking into account their interest in the conservation, exploitation and development of the bio-productive potential of the Black Sea, Bearing in mind that the Black Sea coast is a major international resort area where Black Sea Countries have made large investments in public health and tourism, Taking into account the special hydrological and ecological characteristics of the Black Sea and the hypersensitivity of its flora and fauna to changes in the temperature and composition of the sea water, Noting that pollution of the marine environment of Black Sea also emanates from land-based sources in other countries of Europe, mainly through rivers, Reaffirming their readiness to co-operate in the preservation of the marine environment of the Black Sea and the protection of its living resources against pollution, Noting the necessity of scientific, technical and technological co- 136 operation for the attainment of the purposes of the Convention, Noting that existing international agreements do not cover all aspects of pollution of the marine environment of the Black Sea emanating from third countries, Realising the need for close co-operation with competent international organisations based on a concerted regional approach for the protection and enhancement of the marine environment of the Black Sea, Have agreed as follows: Article I Area of application Ih This Convention shall apply to the Black Sea proper with the southern limit constituted for the purposes of this Convention by the line joining Capes Kelagra and Dalyan. N For the purposes of this Convention the reference to the Black Sea shall include the territorial sea and exclusive economic zone of each Contracting Party in the Black Sea. However, any Protocol to this Convention may provide otherwise for the purposes of that Protocol. Article II Definitions For the purposes of this Convention: Ihe "Pollution of the marine environment" means the introduction by man, directly or indirectly, of substances or energy into the marine environment, including estuaries, which results or is likely to result in such deleterious effects as harm to living resources and marine life, hazard to human health, hindrance to marine activities, including fishing and other legitimate uses of the sea, impairment of quality for use of sea water and reduction of amenities. 2.a) "Vessel" means seaborne craft of any type. This expression includes hydrofoil boats, air-cushion vehicles, submersibles, floating craft whether self-propelled or not and platforms and other man- made structures at sea. b) "Aircraft" means airborne craft of any type. 3.a) "Dumping" means: i) any deliberate disposal of wastes or other matter from vessels or aircraft; ii) any deliberate disposal of vessels or aircraft; b) "Dumping" does not include: i) the disposal of wastes or other matter incidental to or derived from the normal operations of vessels or aircraft and their equipment, other than wastes or other matter transported by or to vessels or aircraft operating for purpose of disposal of such matter or derived from the treatment of such wastes or other matter on such vessels or aircraft; ii) placement of matter for a purpose other than the mere disposal thereof, provided that such placement is not contrary to the aims of this Convention. Article II] General provisions The Contracting Parties take part in this Convention on the basis of full equality in rights and duties, respect for national sovereignty and independence, non-interference in their internal affairs, mutual benefit and other relevant principles and norms of international law. Article [V Sovereign immunity This Convention does not apply to any warship, naval auxiliary or other vessels or aircraft owned or operated by a State and used, for the time being, only on government non-commercial service. However, each Contracting Party shall ensure, by the adoption of appropriate measures not impairing operations of such vessels or aircraft owned or operated by it, that such vessels or aircraft act in a manner consistent, so far as is practicable, with this Convention. Article V General undertakings 1. Each Contracting Party shall ensure the application of the Convention in those areas of the Black Sea where it exercises its sovereignty as well as its sovereign rights and jurisdiction without prejudice to the 137 rights and obligations of the Contracting Parties arising from the rules of international law. Each Contracting Party, in order to achieve the purposes of this Convention, shall bear in mind the adverse effect of pollution within its internal waters on the marine environment of the Black Sea. 2. The Contracting Parties shall take individually or jointly, as appropriate, all necessary measures consistent with international law and in accordance with the provisions of this Convention to prevent, reduce and control pollution thereof in order to protect and preserve the marine environment of the Black Sea. 3. The Contracting Parties will co-operate in the elaboration of additional Protocols and Annexes other than those attached to this Convention, as necessary for its implementation. 4. The Contracting Parties, when entering bilateral or multilateral agreements for the protection and preservation of the marine environment of the Black Sea, shall endeavour to ensure that such agreements are consistent with this Convention Copies of such agreements shall be transmitted to the other Contracting Parties through the Commission as defined in Article XVII of this Convention. 5. The Contracting Parties will co-operate in promoting, within international organisations found to be competent by them, the elaboration of measures contributing to the protection and preservation of the marine environment of the Black Sea. Article VI Pollution by hazardous substances and matter Each Contracting Party shall prevent pollution of the marine environment of the Black Sea from any source by substances or matter specified in the Annex to this Convention. Article VII Pollution from land-based sources The Contracting Parties shall prevent, reduce and control pollution of the marine environment of the Black Sea from land-based sources, in accordance with the Protocol on the Protection of the Black Sea Marine Environment Against Pollution from Land-Based Sources which shall form in integral part of this Convention. Article VIII Pollution from vessels The Contracting Parties shall take individually or, when necessary, jointly, all appropriate measures to prevent, reduce and control pollution of the marine environment of the Black Sea from vessels in accordance with generally accepted international rules and standards. Article IX Co-operation in combating pollution in emergency situations The Contracting Parties shall co-operate in order to prevent, reduce and combat pollution of the marine environment of the Black Sea resulting from emergency situations in accordance with the Protocol on Co- operation in Combating Pollution of the Black Sea by Oil and Other Harmful Substances in Emergency Situations which shall form an integral part of this Convention. Article X Pollution by dumping 1. The Contracting Parties shall take all appropriate measures and co-operate in preventing, reducing and controlling pollution caused by dumping in accordance with the Protocol on the Protection of the Black Sea Marine Environment Against Pollution by Dumping which shall form an integral part of this Convention. 2. The Contracting Parties shall not permit, within areas under their respective jurisdiction, dumping by natural or juridical persons of non-Black Sea States. Article XI Pollution from activities on the continental shelf 1. Each Contracting Party shall, as soon as possible, adopt laws and regulations and take measures to prevent, reduce and control pollution of the marine environment of the Black Sea caused by or connected with activities on its continental shelf, including the exploration and exploitation of the natural resources of the continental shelf. The Contracting Parties shall inform each other through the Commission of the laws, regulations and measures adopted by them in this respect. 2. The Contracting Parties shali co-operate in this field, as appropriate, and endeavour to harmonise the measures referred to in paragraph 1 of this Article. 138 Article XII Pollution from or through the atmosphere The Contracting Parties shall adopt laws and regulations and take individual or agreed measures to prevent, reduce and control pollution of the marine environment of the Black Sea from or through the atmosphere, applicable to the airspace above their territories and to vessels flying their flag or vessels and aircraft registered in their territory. Article XIII Protection of the marine living resources The Contracting Parties, when taking measures in accordance with this Convention for the prevention, reduction and control of the pollution of the marine environment of the Black Sea, shall pay particular attention to avoiding harm to marine life and living resources, in particular by changing their habitats and creating hindrance to fishing and other legitimate uses of the Black Sea, and in this respect shall give due regard to the recommendations of competent international organisations. Article XIV Pollution by hazardous wastes in transboundary movement The Contracting Parties shall take all measures consistent with international law and co-operate in preventing pollution of the marine environment of the Black Sea due to hazardous wastes in transboundary movement, as well as in combating illegal traffic thereof, in accordance with the Protocol to be adopted by them. Article XV Scientific and technical co-operation and monitoring 1. The Contracting Parties shall co-operate in conducting scientific research aimed at protecting and preserving the marine environment of the Black Sea and shall undertake, where appropriate, joint programmes of scientific research, and exchange relevant scientific data and information. 2. The Contracting Parties shall co-operate in conducting studies aimed at developing ways and means for the assessment of the nature and extent of pollution and of its effect on the ecological system in the water column and sediments, detecting polluted areas, examining and assessing risks and finding remedies, and in particular, they shall develop alternative methods of treatment, disposal, elimination or utilisation of harmful substances. 3. The Contracting Parties shall co-operate through the Commission in establishing appropriate scientific criteria for the formulation and elaboration of rules, standards, and recommended practices and procedures for the prevention, reduction and control of pollution of the marine environment of the Black Sea. 4. The Contracting Parties shall, inter alia, establish through the Commission and, where appropriate, in co- operation with international organisations they consider to be competent, complementary or joint monitoring programmes covering all sources of pollution and shall establish a pollution monitoring system for the Black Sea including, as appropriate, programmes at bilateral or multilateral level for observing, measuring, evaluating and analysing the risks or effects of pollution of the marine environment of the Black Sea. 5. When the Contracting Parties have reasonable grounds for believing that activities under their jurisdiction or control may cause substantial pollution or significant and harmful changes to the marine environment of the Black Sea, they shall, before commencing such activities, assess their potential effects on the basis of all relevant information and monitoring data and shall communicate the results of such assessments to the Commission. 6. The Contracting Parties shall co-operate as appropriate, in the development, acquisition and introduction of clean and low-waste technology, inter alia, by adopting measures to facilitate the exchange of such technology. 7. Each Contracting Party shall designate the competent national authority responsible for scientific activities and monitoring. Article XVI Responsibility and liability 1. The Contracting Parties are responsible for the fulfilment of their international obligations concerning the protection and the preservation of the marine environment of the Black Sea. 2. Each Contracting Party shall adopt rules and regulations on the liability for damage caused by natural or juridical persons to the marine environment of the Black Sea in areas where it exercises, in accordance with international law, its sovereignty, sovereign rights or jurisdiction. 3. The Contracting Parties shall ensure that recourse is available in accordance with their legal systems for prompt and adequate compensation or other relief for damage 139 caused by pollution of the marine environment of the Black Sea by natural or juridical persons under their jurisdiction. 4. The Contracting Parties shall co-operate in developing and harmonising their laws, regulations and procedures relating to liability, assessment of and compensation for damage caused by pollution of the marine environment of the Black Sea, in order to ensure the highest degree of deterrence and protection for the Black Sea as a whole. Article XVII The Commission 1. In order to achieve the purposes of this Convention, the Contracting Parties shall establish a Commission on the Protection of the Black Sea Against Pollution, hereinafter referred to as "the Commission". 2. Each Contracting Party shall be represented in the Commission by one Representative who may be accompanied by Alternate Representatives, Advisers and Experts. 3. The Chairmanship of the Commission shall be assumed by each Contracting Party, in turn, in the alphabetical order of the English language. The first Chairman of the Commission shall be the Representative of the Republic of Bulgaria. The Chairman shall serve for one year, and during his term he cannot act in the capacity of Representative of his country. Should the Chairmanship fall vacant, the Contracting Party chairing the Commission shall appoint a successor to remain in office until the term of its Chairmanship expires. 4. The Commission shall meet at least once a year. The Chairman shall convene extraordinary meetings upon the request of any Contracting Party. 5. Decisions and recommendations of the Commission shall be adopted unanimously by the Black Sea States. 6. The Commission shall be assisted in its activities by a permanent Secretariat. The Commission shall nominate the Executive Director and other officials of the Secretariat. The Executive Director shall appoint the technical staff in accordance with the rules to be established by the Commission. The Secretariat shall be composed of nationals of all Black Sea States. The Commission and the Secretariat shall have their headquarters in Istanbul. The location of the headquarters may be changed by the Contracting Parties by consensus. 7. The Commission shall adopt its Rules of Procedure for carrying out its functions, decide upon the organisation of its activities and establish subsidiary bodies in accordance with the provisions of this Convention. 8. Representatives, Alternate Representatives, Advisers and Experts of the Contracting Parties shall enjoy in the territory of the respective Contracting Party diplomatic privileges and immunities in accordance with international law. 9. The privileges and immunities of the officials of the Secretariat shall be determined by agreement among the Contracting Parties. 10. The Commission shall have such legal capacity as may be necessary for the exercise of its functions. 11. The Commission shall conclude a Headquarters Agreement with the host Contracting Party. Article XVIII Functions of the Commission The Commission shall: 1. Promote the implementation of this Convention and inform the Contracting Parties of its work. 2. Make recommendations on measures necessary for achieving the aims of this Convention. 3. Consider questions relating to the implementation of this Convention and recommend such amendments to the Convention and to the Protocols as may be required, including amendments to Annexes of this Convention and the Protocols. 4. Elaborate criteria pertaining to the prevention, reduction and control of pollution of the marine environment of the Black Sea and to the elimination of the effects of pollution, as well as recommendations on measures to this effect. 5. Promote the adoption by the Contracting Parties of additional measures needed to protect the marine environment of the Black Sea, and to that end receive, process and disseminate to the Contracting Parties relevant scientific,technical and statistical information and promote scientific and technical research. 6. Co-operate with competent international organisations, especially with a view to developing appropriate programmes or obtaining assistance in order to achieve the purposes of this Convention. 7. Consider any questions raised by the Contracting Parties. 8. Perform other functions as foreseen in other provisions of this Convention or assigned unanimously to the Commission by the Contracting Parties. Article XIX Meetings of the Contracting Parties 1. The Contracting Parties shall meet in conference upon recommendation by the Commission. They shall also meet in Conference within ten days at the request of one Contracting Party under extraordinary circumstances. 2. The primary function of the meetings of the Contracting Parties shall be the review of the implementation of this Convention and of the Protocols upon the report of the Commission. 3. A non-Black 140 Sea State which accedes to this Convention may attend the meetings of the Contracting Parties in an advisory capacity. Article XX Adoption of amendments to the Convention and/or to the Protocols 1. Any Contracting Party may propose amendments to the Articles of this Convention. 2. Any Contracting Party to this Convention may propose amendments to any Protocol. 3. Any such proposed amendment shall be transmitted to the depositary and communicated by it through diplomatic channels to all the Contracting Parties and to the Commission. 4. Amendments to this Convention and to any Protocol shall be adopted by consensus at a Diplomatic Conference of the Contracting Parties to be convened within 90 days after the circulation of the proposed amendment by the depository. 5. The amendments shall enter into force 30 days after the depository has received notifications of acceptance of these amendments from all Contracting Parties. Article XXI Annexes and amendments to Annexes 1. Annexes to this Convention or to any Protocol shall form an integral part of the Convention or such Protocol, as the case may be. 2. Any Contracting Party may propose amendments to the Annexes to this Convention or to the Annexes of any Protocol through its Representative in the Commission. Such amendments shall be adopted by the Commission on the basis of consensus. The depository, duly informed by the Chairman of the Commission of its decision, shall without delay communicate the amendments so adopted to all the Contracting Parties. Such amendments shall enter into force 30 days after the depository has received notifications of acceptance from all Contracting Parties. 3. The provisions of paragraph 2 of this Article shall apply to the adoption and entry into force of a new Annex to this Convention or to any Protocol. Article XXII Notification of entry into force of amendments The depository shall inform, through diplomatic channels, the Contracting Parties of the date on which amendments adopted under Articles XX and XXI enter into force. Article XXIII Financial rules The Contracting Parties shall decide upon all financial matters on the basis of unanimity, taking into account the recommendations of the Commission. Article XXIV Relation to other international instruments Nothing in this Convention shall affect in any way the sovereignty of States over their territorial sea, established in accordance with international law, and the sovereign rights and the jurisdiction which States have in their exclusive economic zones and their continental shelf in accordance with international law, and the exercise by ships and aircraft of navigational rights and freedoms as provided for in international law and as reflected in relevant international instruments. Article XXV Settlement of disputes In case of a dispute between Contracting Parties concerning the interpretation and implementation of this Convention, they shall seek a settlement of the dispute through negotiations or any other peaceful means of their own choice. Article XXVI Adoption of additional Protocols 1. At the request of a Contracting Party or upon a recommendation by the Commission, a Diplomatic Conference of the Contracting Parties may be convened with the consent of all Contracting Parties in order to adopt additional Protocols. 2. Signature, ratification, acceptance, approval, accession to, entry into force, and denounciation of additional Protocols shall be done in accordance with procedures contained, respectively, in Articles XXVIII, XXIX, and XXX of this Convention. 141 Article XXVII Reservations No reservations may be made to this Convention. Article XXVIII Signature, ratification, acceptance, approval and accession 1. This Convention shall be open for signature by the Black Sea States. 2. This Convention shall be subject to ratification, acceptance or approval by the States which have signed it. 3. This Convention shall be open for accession by any non- Black Sea State interested in achieving the aims of this Convention and contributing substantially to the protection and preservation of the marine environment of the Black Sea provided the said State has been invited by all Contracting Parties. Procedures with regard to the invitation for accession will be dealt with by the depositary. 4. The instruments of ratification, acceptance, approval or accession shall be deposited with the depositary. The depositary of this Convention shall be the Government of Romania. Article XXIX Entry into force This Convention shall enter into force 60 days after the date of deposit with the depositary of the fourth instrument of ratification, acceptance or approval. For a State acceding to this Convention in accordance with Article XXVIII, the Convention shall enter into force 60 days after the deposit of its instrument of accession. Article XXX Denounciation After the expiry of five years from the date of entry into force of this Convention, any Contracting Party may, by written notification addressed to the depositary, denounce this Convention. The denounciation shall take effect o the thirty-first day of December of the year which follows the year in which the depositary was notified of the denounciation. Done in English, on the twenty first day of the month of April of one thousand nine hundred and ninety two, in Bucharest. Annex 1. Organotin compounds. 2. Organohalogen compounds e.g. DDT, DDE, DDD, PCB's. 3. Persistent organophosphorus compounds. 4. Mercury and mercury compounds. 5. Cadmium and cadmium compounds. 6. Persistent substances with proven toxic, carcinogenic, teratogenic or mutagenic properties. 7. Used lubricating oils. 8. Persistent synthetic materials which may float, sink or remain in suspension. 9. Radioactive substances and wastes, including used radioactive fuel. 10. Lead and lead compounds. PROTOCOL ON PROTECTION OF THE BLACK SEA MARINE ENVIRONMENT AGAINST POLLUTION FROM LAND BASED SOURCES Article 1 In accordance with Article VII of the Convention, the Contracting Parties shall take all necessary measures to prevent, reduce and control pollution of the marine environment of the Black Sea caused by discharges from land-based sources on their territories such as rivers, canals, coastal establishments, other artificial structures, outfalls or run-off, or emanating from any other land-based source, including through the atmosphere. Article 2 For the purposes of this Protocol, the fresh water limit means the landward part of the line drawn between the endpoints on the right and the left banks of a water course where it reaches the Black Sea. Article 3 This protocol shall apply to the Black Sea as defined in Article I of the Convention and to the waters landward of the baselines from which the breadth of the territorial sea is measured and in the case of fresh-water courses, up to the fresh-water limit. Article 4 The Contracting Parties undertake to prevent and eliminate pollution of the marine environment of the Black Sea from land-based sources by substances and matter listed in Annex I to this Protocol. The Contracting Parties undertake to reduce and, whenever possible, to eliminate pollution of the marine environment of the Black Sea from land-based sources by substances and matter listed in Annex II to this Protocol. As to water courses that are tributaries to the Black Sea, the Contracting Parties will endeavour to co-operate, as appropriate, with other States in order to achieve the purposes set forth in this Article. 142 Article 5 Pursuant to the provisions of Article XV of the Convention, each Contracting Party shall carry out, at the earliest possible date, monitoring activities in order to assess the levels of pollution, its sources and ecological effects along its coast, in particular with regard to the substances and matter listed in Annexes I and II to this Protocol. Additional research will be conducted upstream of river sections in order to investigate fresh/salt water interactions. Article 6 In conformity with Article XV of the Convention, the Contracting Parties shall co-operate in elaborating common guidelines, standards or criteria dealing with special characteristics of marine outfalls and in undertaking research on specific requirements for effluents necessitating separate treatment and concerning the quantities of discharged substances and matter listed in Annexes I and II, their concentration in effluents, and methods of discharging them. The common emission standards and timetable for the implementation of the programme and measures aimed at preventing, reducing or eliminating, as appropriate, pollution from land-based sources shall be fixed by the Contracting Parties and periodically reviewed for substances and matter listed in Annexes I and II to this Protocol. The Commission shall define pollution prevention criteria as well as recommend appropriate measures to reduce, control and eliminate pollution of the marine environment of the Black Sea from land-based sources. The Contracting Parties shall take into consideration the following: a) The discharge of water from municipal sewage systems should be made in such a way as to reduce the pollution of the marine environment of the Black Sea. b) The pollution load of industrial wastes should be reduced in order to comply with the accepted concentrations of substances and matter listed in Annexes | and II to this Protocol. c) The discharge of cooling water from nuclear power plants or other industrial enterprises using large amounts of water should be made in such a way as to prevent pollution of the marine environment of the Black Sea. d) The pollution load from agricultural and forest areas affecting the water quality of the marine environment of the Black Sea should be reduced in order to comply with the accepted concentrations of substances and matter listed in Annexes I and II to this Protocol. Article 7 The Contracting Parties shall inform one another through the Commission of measures taken, results achieved or difficulties encountered in the application of this Protocol. Procedures for the collection and transmission of such information shall be determined by the Commission. Annex I Hazardous Substances and Matter The following substances or groups of substances or matter are not listed in order of priority. They have been selected mainly on the basis of their toxicity, persistence and bioaccumulation characteristics. This Annex does not apply to discharges which contain substances and matter listed below that are below the concentration limits defined jointly by the Contracting Parties, not exceeding environmental background concentrations. 1. Organotin compounds. 2. Organohalogen compounds e.g. DDT, DDE, DDD, PCB's. 3. Persistent organophosphorus compounds. 4. Mercury and mercury compounds. 5. Cadmium and cadmium compounds. 6. Persistent substances with proven toxic carcinogenic, teratogenic or mutagenic properties. 7. Used lubricating oils. 8. Persistent synthetic materials which may float, sink or remain in suspension. 9. Radioactive substances and wastes, including used radioactive fuel. 10. Lead and lead compounds. Annex II Noxious Substances and Matter The following substances and matter have been selected mainly on the basis of criteria used in Annex I, while taking into account the fact that they are less harmful or more readily rendered harmless by natural processes. The control and strict limitation of the discharges of substances and matter referred to in this Annex shall be implemented in accordance with Annex III to this Protocol. 1. Biocides and their derivatives not covered in Annex I. 2. Cyanides, flourides, and elemental phosphorus. 3. Pathogenic micro-organisms. 4. Nonbiodegradable detergents and their surface-active substances. 5. Alkaline or acid compounds. 6. Thermal discharges. 7. Substances which, although of a non-toxic nature, may become harmful to the marine biota owing to the quantities in which they are discharged e.g. inorganic phosphorous, nitrogen, organic matter and other nutrient compounds. Also substances which have an adverse effect on the oxygen content in the marine environment. 8. The following elements and their compounds: Zinc Selenium Tin Vanadium Copper Arsenic Barium Cobalt Nickel Antimony 143 Beryllium Thallium Chromium Molybdenum Boron Tellurium Titanium Uranium Silver 9. Crude oil and hydrocarbons of any origin. Annex III The discharges of substances and matter listed in Annex II to this Protocol shall be subject to restrictions based on the following: 1. Maximum permissible concentrations of the substances and matter immediate before the outlet; 2. Maximum permissible quantity (load, inflow) of the substances and matter per annual cycle or shorter time limit; 3. In case of differences between 1 and 2 above, the stricter restriction should apply. When issuing a permit for the discharge of wastes containing substances and matter referred to in Annexes | and II to this Protocol, the national authorities will take particular account, as the case may be, of the following factors: A. CHARACTERISTICS AND COMPOSITION OF THE WASTE 1. Type and size of waste source (e.g. industrial process). 2. Type of waste (origin, average composition). 3. Form of waste (solid, liquid, sludge, slurry). 4. Total amount (volume discharged. e.g. per year). 5. Discharge pattern (continuous, intermittent, seasonally variable, etc.). 6. Concentrations with respect to major constituents, substances listed in Annex I, substances listed in Annex II, and other harmful substances as appropriate. 7. Physical, chemical and biological properties of the waste. B. CHARACTERISTICS OF WASTE CONSTITUENTS WITH RESPECT TO THEIR HARMFULNESS 1. Persistence (physical, chemical, biological) in the marine environment. 2. Toxicity and other harmful effects. 3. Accumulation in biological materials and sediments. 4. Biochemical transformation producing harmful compounds. 5. Adverse effects on the oxygen contents and balance. 6. Susceptibility to physical, chemical and biochemical changes and interaction in the marine environment with other seawater constituents which may produce harmful biological or other effects on any of the uses listed in section E below. C. CHARACTERISTICS OF DISCHARGE SITE AND RECEIVING MARINE ENVIRONMENT 1. Hydrographic, meteorological, geological and topographic characteristics of the coastal area. 2. Location and type of discharge (outfall, canal, outlet, etc.) and its relation to other areas (such as amenity areas, spawning, nursery and fishing areas, shellfish grounds) and other discharges. 3. initial dilution achieved at the point of discharge into the receiving marine environment. 4. Dispersal characteristics such as the effect of currents, tides and winds on horizontal transport and vertical mixing. 5. Receiving water characteristics with respect to physical, chemical, biological and ecological conditions in the discharge area. 6. Capacity of the receiving marine environment to receive waste discharges without undesirable effects. D. AVAILABILITY OF WASTE TECHNOLOGIES The methods of waste reduction and discharge for industrial effluents as well as household sewage should be selected taking into account the availability and feasibility of: a) Alternative treatment processes; b) Recycling, re-use, or elimination methods; c) On-land disposal alternatives; and d) Appropriate clean and low-waste technologies. E. POTENTIAL IMPAIRMENT OF MARINE ECOSYSTEMS AND SEA-WATER USES 1. Effects on human life through pollution impact on: a) Edible marine organisms; b) Bathing waters; c) Aesthetics. Discharges of wastes containing substances and matter listed in Annexes I and II shall be subject to a system of self-monitoring and control by the competent national authorities. 2. Effects on marine ecosystems, in particular living resources, endangered species, and critical habitats. 3. Effects on other legitimate uses of the sea. PROTOCOL ON COOPERATION IN COMBATING POLLUTION OF THE BLACK SEA MARINE ENVIRONMENT BY OIL AND OTHER HARMFUL SUBSTANCES IN EMERGENCY SITUATIONS Article | In accordance with Article IX of the Convention, the Contracting Parties shall take necessary measures and co-operate in cases of grave and imminent danger to the marine environment of the Black Sea or to the coast of one or more of the Parties due to the presence of massive quantities of oil or other harmful substances resulting from accidental causes or from accumulation of small discharges which are polluting or constituting a threat of pollution. Article 2. The Contracting Parties shall endeavour to maintain and promote, either individually or through bilateral or multilateral co-operation, contingency plans for combating pollution of the sea by oil and other harmful substances. These shall include, in particular, equipment, vessels, aircraft and manpower prepared for operations in emergency situations. Article 3. Each Contracting Party shall take necessary measures for detecting violations and, within areas under its jurisdiction for enforcing the provisions of this Protocol. Furthermore, the Contracting Parties shall ensure compliance with the provisions of this Protocol by vessels flying their flag. The Contracting Parties 144 shall promote exchange of information on subjects related to the implementation of this Protocol, including transmission of reports and urgent information which relate to Article 1 thereof. Article 4 Any Contracting Party which becomes aware of cases where the marine environment of the Black Sea is in imminent danger of being damaged or has been significantly damaged by pollution, it shall immediately notify the other Contracting Parties it deems likely to be affected by such damage as well as the Commission. Article 5 Each Contracting Party shall indicate to the other Contracting Parties and the Commission, the competent national authorities responsible for controlling and combatting of pollution by oil and other harmful substances. Each Contracting Party shall also designate a focal point to transmit and receive reports of incidents which have resulted or may result in a discharge of oil or other harmful substances, in accordance with the provisions of relevant international instruments. Article 6 1. Each Contracting Party shall issue instructions to the masters of vessels flying its flag and to the pilots of aircraft registered in its territory requiring them to report in accordance with the Annex to this Protocol and by the most rapid and reliable channels, to the Party or Parties that might potentially be affected and to the Commission: a) The presence, characteristics and extent of spillages of oil or other harmful substances observed at sea which are likely to present a threat to the marine environment of the Black Sea or to the coast of one or more Contracting Parties; b) All emergency situations causing or likely to cause pollution by oil or other harmful substances. 2. The information collected in accordance with paragraph | shall be communicated to the other Parties which are likely to be affected by pollution: a) by the Contracting Party which has received the information; b) by the Commission. ANNEX Contents of the report to be made pursuant to Article 6 1. Each report shall contain in general: a) The identification of the source of pollution; b) The geographic position, time and date of occurrence of the incident or of the observation; c) Land and sea conditions prevailing in the area; d) Relevant details with respect to the condition of the vessel polluting the sea. 2. Each report shall contain, whenever possible, in particular: a) A clear indication or description of the harmful substances involved, including the correct technical names of such substances; b) A statement of estimate of the quantities, concentrations and likely conditions of harmful substances discharged or likely to be discharged into the sea; c) A description of packaging and identifying marks; d) Name of the consignor, consignee, or manufacturer. 3. Each report shall clearly indicate, whenever possible, whether the harmful substances discharged or likely to be discharged are oil or noxious liquid, solid, or gaseous substances and whether such substances were or are carried in bulk or contained in packaged form, freight containers, portable tanks or road and rail tank wagons. 4. Each report shall be supplemented, as necessary, by any relevant information requested by a recipient of the report or deemed appropriate by the person sending the report. 5. Any of the persons referred to in Article 6 paragraph | of this Protocol shall: a) Supplement the initial report, as far as possible and necessary, with information concerning further developments; b) Comply as fully as possible with requests from affected Contracting Parties for additional information. PROTOCOL ON THE PROTECTION OF THE BLACK SEA MARINE ENVIRONMENT AGAINST POLLUTION BY DUMPING Article 1 In accordance with Article X of the Convention, the Contracting Parties shall take individually or jointly all appropriate measures for the implementation of this Protocol. Article 2 Dumping in the Black Sea of wastes or other matter containing substances listed in Annex | to this Protocol is prohibited. The preceding provision does not apply to dredged spoils provided that they contain trace contaminants listed in Annex | below the limits of concentration to be defined by the Commission within a 3 year period from the entry into force of the Convention. 145 Article 3 Dumping in the Black Sea of wastes or other matter containing noxious substances listed in Annex II to this Protocol requires, in each case, a prior special permit from the competent national authorities. Article 4 Dumping in the Black Sea of all other wastes or matter requires a prior general permit from the competent national authorities. Article 5 The permits referred to in Articles 3 and 4 above shall be issued after a careful consideration of all the factors set forth in Annex III to this protocol by the competent national authorities of the relevant coastal State. The Commission shall receive records of such permits. Article 6 The provisions of Articles 2, 3 and 4 shall not apply when the safety of human life or of vessel or aircraft at sea is threatened by complete destruction or total loss or in any other case when there is a danger to human life and when dumping appears to be the only way of averting such danger, and if there is every probability that the damage resulting from such dumping will be less than would otherwise occur. Such dumping shall be carried out so as to minimise the likelihood of damage to human or marine life. The Commission shall promptly be informed. Article 7 1. Each Contracting Party shall designate one or more competent authorities to: a) issue the permits provided for in Articles 3 and 4; b) keep records of the nature and quantities of the wastes or other matter permitted to be dumped and of the location, date and method of dumping. 2. The competent authorities of each Contracting Party shall issue the permits provided for in Article 3 and 4 in respect of the wastes or other matter intended for dumping: a) loaded within its territory; b) loaded by a vessel flying its flag or an aircraft registered in its territory when the loading occurs within the territory of another State. Article 8 1. Each Contracting Party shall take the measures required to implement this Protocol in respect of: a) vessels flying its flag or aircraft registered in its territory; b) vessels and aircraft loading in its territory wastes or other matter which are to be dumped; c) platforms and other man-made structures at sea situated within its territorial sea and exclusive economic zone; d) dumping within its territorial sea and exclusive economic zone. Article 9 The Contracting Parties shall co-operate in exchanging information relevant to Articles 5, 6, 7 and 8. Each Contracting Party shall inform the other Contracting Parties which may potentially be affected, in case of suspicions that dumping in contravention of the provisions of this Protocol has occurred or is about to occur. Annex I Hazardous Substances and Matter 1. Organohalogen compounds e.g. DDT, DDE, DDD, PCB's. 2. Mercury and mercury compounds. 3. Cadmium and cadmium compounds. 4. Organotin compounds. 5. Persistent synthetic matter which may float, sink or remain in suspension. 6. Used lubricating oils. 7. Lead and lead compounds. 8. Radioactive substances and wastes, including used radioactive fuel. 9. Crude oil and hydrocarbons of any origin. Annex II Noxious Substances The following substances, compounds or matter have been selected mainly on the basis of criteria used in Annex I, while taking into account the fact that they are less harmful or more readily rendered harmless by natural processes. The control and strict limitation of the dumping of the substances referred to in this Annex shall be implemented in accordance with Annex III of this Protocol. 1. Biocides and their derivatives not covered in Annex I. 2. Cyanides, fluorides, and elemental phosphorus. 3. Pathogenic micro-organisms. 4. Nonbiodegradable detergents and their surface-active substances. 5. Alkaline or acid compounds. 6. Substances which, though of a non-toxic nature, may become harmful to the marine biota owing to the quantities in which they are discharged e.g. inorganic phosphorus, nitrogen, organic matter and other nutrient compounds. Also substances which have an adverse effect on the oxygen content of the marine environment. 7. The following elements and their compounds: Zinc Selenium Tin 146 Vanadium Copper Arsenic Barium Cobalt Nickel Antimony Beryllium Thallium Chromium Molybdenum Boron Tellurium Titanium Uranium Silver 8. Sewage Sludge Annex III In issuing permits for dumping at sea, the following factors shall be considered: A. CHARACTERISTICS AND COMPOSITION OF THE MATTER 1. Amount of matter to be dumped (e.g. per year). 2. Average composition of the matter to be dumped. 3. Properties: physical (e.g. solubility, density), chemical and biochemical(e.g. oxygen demand, nutrients), biological (e.g. presence of bacteria, etc.). The data should include sufficient information on the annual mean levels and seasonal variations of the mentioned properties. 4. Long-term toxicity. 5. Persistence: physical, chemical, biological. 6. Accumulation and transformation in the marine environment. 7. Susceptibility to physical, chemical and biochemical changes and interaction with other dissolved matter. 8. Probability of inducing effects which would reduce the marketability of resources (e.g. fish, shellfish). B. CHARACTERISTICS OF DUMPING SITE AND DISPOSAL METHOD. 1. Location (e.g. co-ordinates of the dumping area, depth and distance from the coast) and its relation to areas of special interest (e.g. amenity areas, spawning, nursery and fishing grounds). 2. Methods and technologies of packaging and disposal of matter. 3. Dispersal characteristics. 4. Hydrological characteristics and seasonal variations in these characteristics (e.g. temperature, pH, salinity, stratification, turbidity, dissolved oxygen, biochemical oxygen demand, chemical oxygen demand, nutrients, productivity). 5. Bottom characteristics (e.g. topography, geochemical, geological and_ biological productivity). 6. Cases and effects of other dumping. C. GENERAL CONSIDERATIONS 1. Possible effects on amenities (e.g. floating or stranded matter, water turbidity, objectionable odour, discoloration, and foaming). 2. Possible effects on marine life, fish stocks, mari-cultures areas, traditional fishing grounds, seaweed harvesting and cultivation sites. 3. Possible effects on other uses of the sea (e.g. impairment of water quality for industrial use, underwater corrosion of structures, interference with vessel operations or fishing due to floating matter or through deposit of wastes or objects on the sea bed, and difficulties in protecting areas of special interest for scientific research or protection of nature). 4. Practical availability of alternative land disposal methods. CONVENTION CONCERNING FISHING IN THE BLACK SEA (Varna, 7 July 1959) The Governments of the People's Republic of Bulgaria, the Romanian People's Republic and the Union of Soviet Socialist Republics, Having a common interest in the rational utilisation of the fishery resources of the Black Sea and in the development of marine fishing, Have decided to conclude this Convention and have for this purpose appointed as their plenipotentiaries: who, having exchanged their full powers, found in good and due form, have agreed as follows: Article 1 The Contracting Parties agree to co-operate and to assist one another, in accordance with the provisions of this Convention, in carrying on rational fishing in the Black Sea, in improving fishing technique, and in carrying out research in the field of ichthyology and hydrobiology for the purpose of maintaining and augmenting the stocks of fish in the Black Sea with a view to increasing the yield. The provisions of this Convention shall not affect the status of the territorial and inland waters of the Contracting Parties. Article 2 Fishing vessels of the People's Republic of Bulgaria, the Romanian People's Republic and the Union of Soviet Socialist Republics engaged in fishing in the open sea may enter the following ports of refuge in order to shelter from bad weather or in case of damage: In the People's Republic of Bulgaria: Balchik, Varna, Nesebur, Burgas, Sozopol and Michurin; In the Romanian People's Republic: Constanta and Sulina; In the Union of Soviet Socialist Republics: Odessa, Evpatoria, Yalta, Novorossysk, Sochi, Sukhum, Poti and Batum. The list of ports of refuge may be amended by agreement among the Parties to the Convention. Article 3 In the cases referred to in Article 2 of this Convention, the fishing vessels of the Contracting Parties shall where necessary be given an opportunity to repair the damage and to replenish their supplies of foodstuffs, drinking water, fuel, lubricants and other ship's stores so that the vessel may continue on its route or return to its nearest home port, and an opportunity to dispose of their catch fresh at the ports of refuge if it cannot be preserved on board the vessel. Article 4 The procedure governing the disposal of fish and payment for services rendered to fishing vessels entering ports of refuge and for fish disposed of in the cases referred to in Article 3 of this Convention shall be agreed between the competent authorities of the Parties to the Convention. Article 5 The following shall be the minimum sizes at which fish may be taken: Beluga (Huso huso). LANES, SN 140 cm Russian sturgeon (Acipenser guldenstaedti) . ............... ........80 cm Sevryuga (Acipenser stellatus) .......... 75 cm Turbot (Rhombus maeoticus) ............. 35 cm Shad (Alosa kessleri pontica) ........... 16 cm The size of a fish shall be determined by measuring its length from the tip of the snout to the base of the tail fin. Any fish taken which is under the prescribed size must be put back in the sea. The taking of fish under the prescribed minimum size shall be permissible in a proportion not exceeding the following percentage by number of the total catch of each protected species: 8 per cent in the case of shad (Alosa kessleri pontica); 5 per cent in the case of turbot (Rhombus macoticus); and 5 per cent in the case of Acipenseridae (Huso huso, Acipenser guldenstaedti, Acipenser stellatus). The taking of Acipenser nudiventris shall be prohibited for five years from the date of entry into force of this Convention. Article 6 For the purpose of preparing forecasts for fishing in the Black Sea, the Contracting Parties agree to exchange by any suitable means operational information concerning the migration of industrial fish, indicating the time and place at which they congregate, the direction of movement, the density of the schools, and the hydrometeorological conditions in which such congregations and migrations are observed. Article 7 With a view to the rational utilisation of the stocks of fish in the Black Sea, the Contracting Parties agree to exchange information annually on the results of scientific research in the fields of marine ichthyology, hydrobiology and fishing technique. The Contracting Parties shall exchange statistical data on catches of fish. Article 8 With a view to working out and co-ordinating measures for the application of this Convention, a Mixed Commission shall be established. Within one month after the entry into force of the Convention, each Contracting Party shall appoint one representative to the said Commission and shall communicate the name of its representative to the other Contracting Parties. The Mixed Commission shall meet at least once a year in the territory of each of the Contracting Parties in turn. The Mixed Commission shall function under a statute drafted by it at its first meeting and approved by the Contracting Parties. Article 9 The Mixed Commission shall have the following functions: 1. It shall work out agreed measures to regulate fishing, with a view to the conservation and augmentation of the stocks of fish in the Black Sea, and to develop industrial fishing technique; 2. It shall introduce amendments to Article 5 of the Convention concerning the species and dimensions of fish caught in the Black Sea. Proposals for such amendments must be communicated to the representatives of the Contracting Parties on the Mixed Commission not later than three months before the opening of the Commission's regular session; 3. It shall co-ordinate the planning of scientific research projects on matters relating to fishing in the Black Sea, to be conducted by the competent authorities of the Contracting Parties; 4. It shall determine the nature and extent of the statistical and other data which each Contracting Party shall furnish to the Mixed Commission for the purpose of implementing this Convention; 5. It shall exchange information concerning the application of this Convention; 6. It shall examine such other matters as the Contracting Parties may refer to it. Article 10 The Mixed Commission shall make recommendations to the Contracting Parties on the matters referred to in Article 9 with the exception of paragraph 2 of that Article, on which the Commission may take decisions. Recommendations and decisions shall be deemed to be adopted by the Mixed Commission if they receive the favourable votes of the representatives of all the Contracting Parties. The recommendations of the Mixed Commission shall be submitted to the Contracting Parties for approval and may be given effect if none of the Parties raises objections within four months. Article 11 This Convention shall not impede the conclusion of bilateral agreements on matters relating to fishing in the Black Sea between any two Contracting Parties or between a Contracting Party and any other Black Sea State, so long as such agreements do not conflict with the terms of this Convention. Article 12 This Convention shall be ratified and shall enter into force on the date of deposit of the last instrument of ratification with the Government of the People's Republic of Bulgaria, in whose archives the original of the Convention shall be kept. The Government of the People's Republic of Bulgaria shall notify the Governments of all Contracting Parties of the date of deposit of the last instrument of ratification. Certified true copies of this Convention shall be transmitted by the Government of the People's Republic of Bulgaria to the other Contracting Parties. Article 13 This Convention is concluded for a term of five years. It shall remain in force for successive terms of five years for those Contracting Parties which do not inform the Government of the People's Republic of Bulgaria, six months before the expiry of the current five-year term, that they wish to terminate the Convention. Article 14 Other Black Sea States may accede to this Convention. Article 15 The Government of the People's Republic of Bulgaria shall take the necessary action to register this Convention with the Secretariat of the United Nations. Done at Varna, on 7 July 1959, in one copy in the Bulgarian, Romanian and Russian languages, all texts being equally authentic. 148 CONVENTION CONCERNING FISHING IN THE BLACK SEA (Varna, 7 July 1959) The Governments of the People's Republic of Bulgaria, the Romanian People's Republic and the Union of Soviet Socialist Republics, Having a common interest in the rational utilisation of the fishery resources of the Black Sea and in the development of marine fishing, Have decided to conclude this Convention and have for this purpose appointed as their plenipotentiaries: who, having exchanged their full powers, found in good and due form, have agreed as follows: Article | The Contracting Parties agree to co-operate and to assist one another, in accordance with the provisions of this Convention, in carrying on rational fishing in the Black Sea, in improving fishing technique, and in carrying out research in the field of ichthyology and hydrobiology for the purpose of maintaining and augmenting the stocks of fish in the Black Sea with a view to increasing the yield. The provisions of this Convention shall not affect the status of the territorial and inland waters of the Contracting Parties. Article 2. Fishing vessels of the People's Republic of Bulgaria, the Romanian People's Republic and the Union of Soviet Socialist Republics engaged in fishing in the open sea may enter the following ports of refuge in order to shelter from bad weather or in case of damage: In the People's Republic of Bulgaria: Balchik, Varna, Nesebur, Burgas, Sozopol and Michurin; In the Romanian People's Republic: Constanta and Sulina; In the Union of Soviet Socialist Republics: Odessa, Evpatoria, Yalta, Novorossysk, Sochi, Sukhum, Poti and Batum. The list of ports of refuge may be amended by agreement among the Parties to the Convention. Article 3. In the cases referred to in article 2 of this Convention, the fishing vessels of the Contracting Parties shall where necessary be given an opportunity to repair the damage and to replenish their supplies of foodstuffs, drinking water, fuel, lubricants and other ship's stores so that the vessel may continue on its route or return to its nearest home port, and an opportunity to dispose of their catch fresh at the ports of refuge if it cannot be preserved on board the vessel. Article 4 The procedure governing the disposal of fish and payment for services rendered to fishing vessels entering ports of refuge and for fish disposed of in the cases referred to in article 3 of this Convention shall be agreed between the competent authorities of the Parties to the Convention. Article 5 The following shall be the minimum sizes at which fish may be taken: Beluga (Huso huso). eae ee 140 cm_ Russian sturgeon (Acipenser guldenstaedti) . ............. .......80 cm Sevryuga (Acipenser stellatus) .......... 75 cm Turbot (Rhombus maeoticus) ............. 35 cm_ Shad (Alosa kessleri pontica) ........... 16 cm The size of a fish shall be determined by measuring its length from the tip of the snout to the base of the tail fin. Any fish taken which is under the prescribed size must be put back in the sea. The taking of fish under the prescribed minimum size shall be permissible in a proportion not exceeding the following percentage by number of the total catch of each protected species: 8 per cent in the case of shad (Alosa kessleri pontica); 5 per cent in the case of turbot (Rhombus macoticus); and 5 per cent in the case of Acipenseridae (Huso huso, Acipenser guldenstaedti, Acipenser stellatus). The taking of Acipenser nudiventris shall be prohibited for five years from the date of entry into force of this Convention. Article 6 For the purpose of preparing forecasts for fishing in the Black Sea, the Contracting Parties agree to exchange by any suitable means operational information concerning the migration of industrial fish, indicating the time and place at which they congregate, the direction of movement, the density of the schools, and the hydrometeorological conditions in which such congregations and migrations are observed. Article 7 With a view to the rational utilisation of the stocks of fish in the Black Sea, the Contracting Parties agree to exchange information annually on the results of scientific research in the fields of marine ichthyology, hydrobiology and fishing technique. The Contracting Parties shall exchange statistical data on catches of fish. 149 Article 8 With a view to working out and co-ordinating measures for the application of this Convention, a Mixed Commission shall be established. Within one month after the entry into force of the Convention, each Contracting Party shall appoint one representative to the said Commission and shall communicate the name of its representative to the other Contracting Parties. The Mixed Commission shall meet at least once a year in the territory of each of the Contracting Parties in turn. The Mixed Commission shall function under a statute drafted by it at its first meeting and approved by the Contracting Parties. Article 9 The Mixed Commission shall have the following functions: 1. It shall work out agreed measures to regulate fishing, with a view to the conservation and augmentation of the stocks of fish in the Black Sea, and to develop industrial fishing technique; 2. It shall introduce amendments to article 5 of the Convention concerning the species and dimensions of fish caught in the Black Sea. Proposals for such amendments must be communicated to the representatives of the Contracting Parties on the Mixed Commission not later than three months before the opening of the Commission's regular session; 3. It shall co-ordinate the planning of scientific research projects on matters relating to fishing in the Black Sea, to be conducted by the competent authorities of the Contracting Parties; 4. It shall determine the nature and extent of the statistical and other data which each Contracting Party shall furnish to the Mixed Commission for the purpose of implementing this Convention; 5. It shall exchange information concerning the application of this Convention; 6. It shall examine such other matters as the Contracting Parties may refer to it. Article 10 The Mixed Commission shall make recommendations to the Contracting Parties on the matters referred to in article 9 with the exception of paragraph 2 of that article, on which the Commission may take decisions. Recommendations and decisions shall be deemed to be adopted by the Mixed Commission if they receive the favourable votes of the representatives of all the Contracting Parties. The recommendations of the Mixed Commission shall be submitted to the Contracting Parties for approval and may be given effect if none of the Parties raises objections within four months. Article 11 This Convention shall not impede the conclusion of bilateral agreements on matters relating to fishing in the Black Sea between any two Contracting Parties or between a Contracting Party and any other Black Sea State, so long as such agreements do not conflict with the terms of this Convention. Article 12 This Convention shall be ratified and shall enter into force on the date of deposit of the last instrument of ratification with the Government of the People's Republic of Bulgaria, in whose archives the original of the-Convention shall be kept. The Government of the People's Republic of Bulgaria shall notify the Governments of all Contracting Parties of the date of deposit of the last instrument of ratification. Certified true copies of this Convention shall be transmitted by the Government of the People's Republic of Bulgaria to the other Contracting Parties. Article 13 This Convention is concluded for a term of five years. It shall remain in force for successive terms of five years for those Contracting Parties which do not inform the Government of the People's Republic of Bulgaria, six months before the expiry of the current five-year term, that they wish to terminate the Convention. Article 14 Other Black Sea States may accede to this Convention. Article 15 The Government of the People's Republic of Bulgaria shall take the necessary action to register this Convention with the Secretariat of the United Nations. Done at Varna, on 7 July 1959, in one copy in the Bulgarian, Romanian and Russian languages, all texts being equally authentic. 150 BIBLIOGRAPHY WCMC has access to a Black Sea bibliography of about 5000 references. This bibliography has been searched and reduced to the following list which may be of some use. Unfortunately there was not time nor the resources to obtain all of these titles, some which are not easily available in the UK. Leslie, D.M.JR and Tissuescu A.. Beyond the Danube Delta: Forest Conservation and Research Opportunities in Romania. Conservation Biology, Volume 6, NO.2, June 1992. pp.165-167 Pringle. C.M. Us- Romanian Environmental Reconnaissance in the Danube Delta. Conservation Biology, Volume 5, No. 4. December 1991. pp 442-445. FAO.1993. Trends in catches and landings. Mediterranean and Black Sea Fisheries: 1972-1991. FAO Fisheries Circular No.855.4. FAO. 1994. Second Technical Consultation on stock Assessment in the Black Sea. Ankara Turkey, 15-19 February 1993. No.495. Berkes and Fikret. 1977. Turkish dolphin fisheries. Oryx, Journal of Fauna Preservation Society. Vol 14. Pp 163-167. UNEP. 1997. Georgian Biodiversity Country Study Report 1996 program "Assistance for the Preparation of Biodiversity Country Study in the Republic of Georgia". United Nation Environmental Programme. Ministry of Environment of Georgia. Noah's Ark Centre for Recovery of Endangered Species. Grimmet, R.F.A. and Jones, T.A. Important Bird Areas in Europe. 1990. International Council for Bird Preservation Technical Publication No.9 International Waterfowl and Wetlands Research Bureau. (held at WCMC) Ivanov, L.M. 1982. The fisheries resources of the Black Sea. Part Il. The sea and the ocean fishing of Bulgaria. Etudes et Revue. Vol 60, p2-135. (ref no.1547) Nikolaev, S.D Changes in the Romanian marine fishery in connection with the alteration of the environmental conditions and the status of the fish resources in the Black Sea. Deep Sea Research (Black Sea Special Issue). Popov, V.F. 1986. State and development of fishing technologies in the Black Sea along the Bulgarian coast. FAO Fish Report. No. 26-27. Pp1 13-128. Rome 1963/1980. Prodanov, K. 1991. Management of the biological resources and their rational exploitation. Science and management in the Black Sea. Results of an International Workshop held in Varna, Bulgaria. September/October 1991 pub: Woods Hole Oceanographic Institution. Aubrey, D.G. and Unluata, V. Science and Management in the Black Sea. 1991. Results of an International Workshop held in Varna Bulgaria. September/October. 1991. Aubrey, D.G.1993. Intergovernmental oceanographic Commission Workshop Report # 86. September 30 - October 4. 1991. Scientific Working Group Report for the Black Sea. Vol.86. p1-36. Balkas, T. 1990. State of the marine environment in the Black Sea region. UNEP. Region Sea Report and Studies. No. 126. Bologa, A.S. 1992. Review of the state of the environment and biological changes in the Romanian Black Sea sector. Problems of the Black Sea. Public Akad. Nauk. Uk. MAI. pp 91-96 151 Della Croce, N. 1992. Marine environmental studies in coastal waters. Problems of the Black sea. Publi Akad. Nauk. Uk. pp168-172.. Nikolaev, S.D. Changes in the Romanian marine fishery in connection with the alteration of the environmental conditions and the status of the fish resources in the Black Sea. Deep Sea Research . Black Sea Special Issue. Inter-library loan. Rybalka, A.T. 1993. South coast of the Crimea: environmental specificity and coast protection problems. Coastline of the Black Sea. Proceeding of 8" Symposium on coastal and Ocean Management. Coastal Zone 93. New Orleans. L/A July 19-23 Publi Series Coastline of the world. American Society of Civil engineers (ASCE). Aubray D.G. 1992. Focus on the coast: Threatened by Nature and civilization. Oceanus. Vol. 35, issue]. Pp.82-84. Aybulatov, N.A. 1993. Geoecology of the Black Sea coastal zone. Proceeding of 8"" Symposium on coastal zone 93. New Orleans. LA. July 19-23. Publi: Series coastline of the World. Pp 103-124. Konsulov, Ts. 1988. Ecological issues related to living resources ( Zooplankton and zoobenthos) along the Bulgarian coast. Hydrobiology. Vol 2 Coastline of the Black Sea. 1993. Proceedings of the 8" Symposium on coastal and ocean management. Coastal zone 93. New Orleans #. LA July 19-23. Muller, G.I. 1985 On the opportunity of a marine reserve to be established at the Romanian coast of the Black Sea. Pp97-106. Not found in UI. Petrova karakjova, J.Y. 1982. Distribution and stocks of marine seagrasses Zostera marina and Zostera nana L. of the Bulgarian Black Sea. Institute of fisheries.vol 19. Rybalka, A.I. 1993. Southcoast of the Crimea: environmental specificity and coast protection problems. Proceedings of the 8th Symposium on Coastal and Ocean Management. Coastal Zone 93. New Orleans. LA. July 19-23 1993. Publi: Series coastlines of the world. Coastlines of the Black Sea . American Society of Civil Engineurs. (ASCE). 1993. Salukvadza, N.I. 1993. New structure used for protection of the Black Sea Coast. Proceedings of the 8th Symposium on Coastal and Ocean Management. Coastal Zone 93. New Orleans. LA. July 19-23 1993. Publi: Series coastlines of the world. Coastlines of the Black Sea. American Society of Civil Engineers. (ASCE). 1993. Monolili, P 1974. Some ecological considerations on the flora and fauna of the Southern part of the Musura Bay (the delta of the Danube onto the Black Sea).Trav. Mus. Hist. Nat. "Gr. Antipe". Esin, N.V. and Ko-Yan R. D.1993. Ecology of Gelondzlorik Bay. Proceedings of the 8th Symposium on Coastal and Ocean Management. Coastal Zone 93. New Orleans. LA. July 19-23 1993. Publi: Series coastlines of the world. Coastlines of the Black Sea. American Society of Civil Engineers. (ASCE). 1993. Bologa, A.S. Review of the state of the environment and biological changes on the Romanian Black Sea sector. 1992. Problems of the Black Sea Akad-Nauk Ukr., MHI. Sevastopol. Pp 91-96. Nokolaev, S.R. Changes in the Romania marine fisheries in connections with the alteration of the environmental conditions of the status of the fish resources in the Black Sea. Deep sea Research (Black sea Species Issue) Volume 2 Della Croce, N. 1992. Marine environmental studies in coastal waters. Problems of the Black sea Publi. Akad, Nauk. Ukr..MHI.. pp 168-172. Not held in Ul nor SPL. 152 Nikolaev, S.D. Changes in the Romanian marine fisheries in connection with the alteration of the environmental conditions and the status of the fish resources in the Black sea, Deep Sea Research. Volume 2 Ozturk, I, 1992. Marine outfall applications on the Turkish coasts of the Black Sea. Water Science and Technology. Vol 25, issue 9, pp 203-210. Provirof, L. 1994. Conservation of Black Sea wetlands: a review and preliminary action plan based on national reports by L. Provirof. {et al} compiled by A.M. Wilson and M.E. Moser for International Waterfowl and Wetlands Research Bureau. Slimbridge: International Waterfowl and Wetlands Research Bureau. [WRB publication; 33 Khutsishvili, G. (Georgii). 1980. The Black Sea coast on the Caucasus: a guide/By G. Khutsinkvili. Moscow, progress. Darke, Diane. 1987. Guide to eastern Turkey and the Black Sea coast. Ovchininikov, I.M. 1991. Investigations of the Black Sea Ecosystems in winter ( the 21th cruise of the R/N Vityas) , 9 Feb-8 April Oceanology 1991. Vol 31, issue 6, p 1081-1085. 153 Annex 1 Globally threatened plants endemic to one country bordering the Black Sea Sorted alphabetically by genus WCMC Plants Programme WORLD CONSERVATION MONITORING CENTRE Explanation of Conservation Status Listing The attached listing was generated from the threatened plants database at WCMC. The list may deal with either a taxonomic group (e.g., all ferns, a family, or a genus) or a geographic area (e.g., a country or a Basic Recording Unit (BRU) (see next page). The list is sorted either by genus or family. Source of data Following the actual listing is a list of data sources used to create the list. To facilitate finding references by their DS number, these data sources are arranged by their number, not alphabetically by author. Note: Our databases are dynamic and change daily. The information on the list represents only what had been computerised as of the date shown. First line(s) 1. Original IUCN Red Data Book category at the world level (in bold). This is assigned by WCMC on the basis of national threat information available (see 5 below), and applies to the degree of threat to this taxon at the world level. Definitions are given on page 3 of this report. (NB These data do not cover the new 1994 IUCN categories). 2. Inclusion on CITES Appendix. A Roman numeral I, II, or III indicates the CITES (Convention on International Trade in Endangered Species of Wild Fauna and Flora) Appendix on which the plant appears. I, II, III (normal font): inclusion is at the species, subspecies, or variety level; I, II, II (italicised): inclusion is at the genus level; I, I, II (underlined): inclusion is at the family level. 3. Scientific mame including author (Family name) Data source of name. 4. Subsequent line(s) 5. IUCN Red Data Book category for this BRU. This applies to the degree of threat to this taxon in this area only, and is assigned according to information in a data source (see 6 below). 6. Data source number for conservation status in this BRU. 7. Distribution of taxon (geographical qualifier) Data source number for distribution. Note: A "?" directly before the area name indicates there is doubt as to the accuracy of the distribution information. If the distribution is known or assumed to be incomplete, an explanation to that effect is displayed after the last distribution. Geographic Coding Scheme WCWMNC has adopted the geographic coding system of Basic Recording Units (BRU) (Hollis and Brummitt, 1992)’. This system is used for recording plant, animal and protected area distribution information. Under this scheme the world is divided into 622 BRUS, with a hierarchy comprising four levels of subdivision. Level | divides the world into "continents" as follows: Europe Asia-Tropical Northern America Africa Australasia Southern America Asia-Temperate Pacific Antarctic Each continent is then subdivided into regions (level 2), these then being further subdivided into level 3 (mostly country level divisions) and level 4 (mostly state level divisions) which totals 622 separate units. Examples of countries broken down to level 4: Brazil (29 areas) India (32 areas) Mexico (30 areas) China (27 areas) New Zealand (8 areas) USA (60 areas) In addition to the countries listed above, oceanic islands and island groups are treated as level 4 areas regardless of their "parent" country. ‘Hollis, S. & R.K. Brummitt (1992) World Geographical Scheme for Recording Plant Distributions. Published for the International Working Group on Taxonomic Databases for Plant Sciences (TADWG). 102pp. The original IUCN Red Data Book Categories The original Red Data Book categories used by the World Conservation Monitoring Centre (WCMC) and the Species Survival Commission (SSC) of IUCN - the World Conservation Union to indicate the degree of threat to individual taxa in their wild habitats. Below are the formal definitions of the categories. Note: There is a degree of subjectivity to the application of these categories, a subjectivity that will be diminished by a thorough understanding of and a strict adherence to these definitions. Extinct (Ex) Taxa that are no longer known to exist in the wild after repeated searches of the type localities and other known or likely places. Endangered (E) Taxa in danger of extinction and whose survival is unlikely if the causal factors continue operating. Included are taxa whose numbers have been reduced to a critical level or whose habitats have been so drastically reduced that they are deemed to be in immediate danger of extinction. Vulnerable (V) Taxa believed likely to move into the Endangered category in the near future if the causal factors continue operating. Included are taxa of which most or all the populations are decreasing because of over-exploitation, extensive destruction of habitat or other environmental disturbance; taxa with populations that have been seriously depleted and whose ultimate security is not yet assured; and taxa with populations that are still abundant but are under threat from serious adverse factors throughout their range. Rare (R) Taxa with small world populations that are not at present Endangered or Vulnerable but are at risk. These taxa are usually localised within restricted geographic areas or habitats or are thinly scattered over a more extensive range. Indeterminate (I) Taxa known to be Extinct, Endangered, Vulnerable, or Rare but where there is not enough information to say which of the four categories 1s appropriate. Insufficiently Known (K) Taxa that are suspected but not definitely known to belong to any of the above categories because of the lack of information. Out of Danger (O) Taxa formerly included in one of the above categories, but are now considered relatively secure because effective conservation measures have been taken, or because the previous threat to their survival has been removed. Not threatened (nt) Taxa that are not in any of the above categories. No information (?) Taxa for which there is no information. In addition to the categories listed above, occasionally "hybrid" categories such as Ex/E are used. ai way’ ‘Te: Peotons tenes met VW aatlg: og ne i‘? Weugs i lipo s Tet i my ‘ws mit fe ay it lijnalaray et & on “ CME stil HROTAD pabety a art genes Si WI Heke le SA te cob beverly. dy end DD NeGHPET AF oc oegaal ge , OREN oo he Ala Vitae eae oat P Ce) nd sida ee | ee ee dagdoniny Whe Zcfinacsimerice-aw eh Wat A ee hey vee) ali deve 9 abi 7 ai a 7 wien etgeaioniconet et saint ele stint a 2 tinal, 8 ees wy, Tira a a Pee ee r Lf ident Aa Seva a4 Bes ro . or d teeta r ithe: att aE Seu eRe diy ‘cat ae ihe at ina si hutagh 2 Ca ea | ie! ea es suai! (eee eS dibs aha 1 ae aot ol bash : advicaeamliee itd Wit Nite oe 4 ML hati aghe et eerie: peter; ey etl Like yey oe oe } Me hear ayer esta 2m, tes Ad Bi dee te hh MAO arAth bak CN yaaa ont i aa sani ae othe! BEAP Yee i ceagny Rena ee eee he conga: wet TE why meth at. oh cepa ct | ea eee vet ark ea | rinmaidede eh aeRO iN wt Hew pall othe. 4 =] ; nodiate’ pai - y nad AM RF < FF RF RF FR BR v~] R Alyssum artvinense Busch [Cruciferae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 R Alyssum aurantiacum Boiss. [Cruciferae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 R Alyssum bornmuelleri Hausskn. ex Degen [Cruciferae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 R Alyssum caespitosum Baumg. [Cruciferae] 12840 R= 12840 Turkey 12840 R Alyssum calycocarpum Rupr. [Cruciferae] 20171 R former European USSR Vv Alyssum caricum Dudley & Hub.-Mor. [Cruciferae] 12840 Vv 12840 Turkey 12840 R Alyssum cilicicum Boiss. & Bal. [Cruciferae] 123840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 I Alyssum crenulatum Boiss. [Cruciferae] 12840 I 12840 Turkey 12840 R Alyssum davisianum Dudley [Cruciferae] 12840 x FF FR BR R 12840 Turkey 12840 Alyssum discolor Dudley & Hub.-Mor. [Cruciferae] /2840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Alyssum dubertretii Gomb [Cruciferae] 12840 I 12840 Turkey 12840 Alyssum eriophyllum Boiss. & Hausskn. [Cruciferae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Alyssum fulvescens Sibth. & Sm. var. stellatocarpum Hub.-Mor. [Cruciferae] 1/2840 i R 12840 Turkey 12840 Alyssum giosnanum Nyar [Cruciferae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Alyssum haussknechtii Boiss. [Cruciferae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Alyssum huber-morathii Dudley [Cruciferae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Alyssum lepidoto-stellatum (Hausskn. & Bornm.) Dudley [Cruciferae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Alyssum lycaonicum (Schulz) Dudley [Cruciferae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Alyssum macropodum Boiss. & Bal. var. heterotrichu n Hub.-Mor. [Cruciferae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Alyssum niveum Dudley [Cruciferae] 12840 I 12840 Turkey 12840 Alyssum pinifolium (Nyar) Dudley [Cruciferae] 12840 Vv 12840 Turkey 12840 Alyssum praecox Boiss. & Bal. var. albiflorum Dudley [Cruciferae] /2840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Alyssum pterocarpum Dudley [Cruciferae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Alyssum tetrastemon Boiss. [Cruciferae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Alyssum thymops (Hub.-Mor. & Reese) Dudley [Cruciferae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Alyssum trapeziforme Bornm. ex Nyar [Cruciferae] 1/2840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Alyssum trichocarpum Dudley & Hub.-Mor. [Cruciferae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Amelanchier parviflora Boiss. var. dentata Browicz [Rosaceae] 12840 R 20618 Turkey 20618 Amphoricarpos elegans Albov [Compositae] 5942 v 11552 Russia - North Caucasus 1/552 Amphoricarpos exsul O. Schwarz [Compositae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Amphoricarpos praedictus Ayasligil & Grierson [Compositae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Amygdalus balansae [Rosaceae] 20618 E 20618 Turkey 20618 ingle country endemic globally threatened plants Rosaceae: Amygdalus Amygdalus carduchorum ssp. serrata [Rosaceae] 206/8 R 20618 Turkey 20618 Amygdalus korshinskyi (Hand.-Mazz.) Bornm. [Rosaceae] 206/8 Vv 20618 Turkey 20618 Amygdalus nairica Feodoroy & Takht. [Rosaceae] R former USSR 6930 Amygdalus trichamygdalus var. elongata [Rosaceae] 20618 R =. 20618 Turkey 20618 Anacyclus latealatus Hub.-Mor. [Compositae] 12840 Vv 12840 Turkey 12840 Anchonium elichrysifolium (DC.) Boiss. ssp. canescens (Hausskn. & Bornm.) Coode & Cullen [Cruciferae] 12840 R = 12840 Turkey 12840 Anchonium elichrysifolium (DC.) Boiss. ssp. glandulosum Coode & Cullen [Cruciferae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Anchonium elichrysifolium (DC.) Boiss. ssp. villosum Cullen & Coode [Cruciferae] /2840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Andrachne colchica (Fischer & C.A. Meyer) Pojark [Euphorbiaceae] R former USSR 6930 Andrachne pusilla Pojark [Euphorbiaceae] R former USSR 6930 Androsace koso-poljanskii Ovcz. [Primulaceae] 5942, | 20171 | I 5942 Ukraine 5942 Anthemis adonidifolia Boiss. [Compositae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Anthemis amophila Boiss. & Heldr. [Compositae] 12840 Vv 12840 Turkey 12840 Anthemis anthemiformis (Freyn & Sint.) Grierson [Compositae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Anthemis antitaurica Grierson [Compositae] 12840 R= 12840 Turkey 12840 Anthemis arenicola Boiss. var. arenicola [Compositae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Anthemis argyrophylla (Halacsy & T.Georgiev) Velen. [Compositae] 8000, 20171 Vv 5204 Bulgaria (south) 5204 Anthemis calcarea Sosn. [Compositae] 12840 R = 12840 Turkey 12840 Anthemis cretica L. ssp. argaea (Boiss. & Bal.) Grierson [Compositae] 1/2840 R= 12840 Turkey 12840 Anthemis cuneata Hub.-Mor. & Reese [Compositae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Anthemis davisii Yavin [Compositae] 12840 R = 12840 Turkey 12840 Anthemis dipsacea Bornm. [Compositae] 12840 R= 12840 Turkey 12840 ace Anthemis fimbriata Boiss. [Compositae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Anthemis gaudium-solis Velen. [Compositae] 5204, 20171 I Bulgaria Anthemis halophila Boiss. & Bal. [Compositae] 12840 Vs 12840 Turkey 12840 Anthemis lithuanica (DC.) Besser ex Trautv. [Compositae] 8000, 20171 R former European USSR 8000 Anthemis melanoloma Trautv. ssp. trapezuntica Grierson [Compositae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Anthemis orbelica Pancic [Compositae] 5204, 20171 R 5204 Bulgaria (south and west) 5204 Anthemis oxylepis (Boiss.) Boiss. [Compositae] /2840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Anthemis pauciloba Boiss. var. sieheana (Fig) Grierson [Compositae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Anthemis pestalozzae Boiss. [Compositae] 12840 R = 2840 Turkey 12840 Anthemis pungens Yavin [Compositae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Anthemis regis-borisii Stoj. & Acht. [Compositae] 5204, 20171 R 5204 Bulgaria (east) 5204 Anthemis rumelica (Velen.) Stoj. & Acht. [Compositae] 5204, 20171 R 5204 Bulgaria (south & east) 5204 Anthemis saguramica Sosn. [Compositae] 5942 I 5942 Georgia 5942 Anthemis sancti-johannis Turrill [Compositae] 5204, 20171 R 5204 Bulgaria 5204 Anthemis sterilis Steven [Compositae] 8000, 20171 Vv former European USSR 8000 Anthemis stribrnyi Velen. [Compositae] 5204, 20171 R 5204 Bulgaria (south) 5204 Anthemis tinctoria L. var. virescens Bornm. [Compositae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Anthemis tricornis Big [Compositae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Anthemis virescens Velen. [Compositae] 5204, 20171 R 5204 Bulgaria (south & east) 5204 Anthemis wallii Hub.-Mor. & Reese [Compositae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Anthyllis vulneraria L. ssp. variegata (Boiss.) Cullen [Leguminosae] /2840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Apera bayiopiana M. Dogan [Gramineae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Apera triaristata M. Dogan [Gramineae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Aquilegia colchica Kemul.-Nath. [Ranunculaceae] 6930 Single country endemic globally threatened plants : Ranunculaceae: Aquilegia x FF FF RF FR BR R former Asiatic USSR (Caucasus) 6930 Arabis abietina Bornm. [Cruciferae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 1/2840 Arabis androsacea Fenzl. [Cruciferae] 12840 R = 12840 Turkey 12840 Arabis aubrietioides Boiss. [Cruciferae] 12340 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Arabis carduchorum Boiss. [Cruciferae] 12840 R= 12840 Turkey 12840 Arabis drabiformis Boiss. [Cruciferae] 12340 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Arabis ferdinandi-coburgi Kellerer & Siind. [Cruciferae] 5204, 20171 R 5204 Bulgaria 5204 Arabis graellsiformis Hedge [Cruciferae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Arenaria angustifolia Mc.Neill [Caryophyllaceae] /2840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Arenaria angustijolioides Kit Tan & Sorger [Caryophyllaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Arenaria angustisepala McNeill [Caryophyllaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Arenaria cariensis A. Carlstrom [Caryophyllaceae] 1/2840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Arenaria davisti McNeill [Caryophyllaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Arenaria deflexa Dec. ssp. microcephala McNeill [Caryophyllaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Arenaria eliasiana Kit Tan & Sorger [Caryophyllaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Arenaria isauricaa Boiss. [Caryophyllaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Arenaria ledebouriana Fenzl var. armeniaca McNeill [Caryophyllaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Arenaria ledebouriana Fenzl var. grandiflora Hartvig & Strid [Caryophyllaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Arenaria luschanii McNeill [Caryophyllaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Arenaria mons-cragus Kit Tan ex Sorger [Caryophyllaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Arenaria pamphylica sensu Hayek [Caryophyllaceae] 12840, 20171 Vv 12840 Turkey 12840 Arenaria pseudoacantholimon Bornm. [Caryophyllaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Arenaria rhodia Boiss. ssp. macropetala McNeill [Caryophyllaceae] 12840 Vv 12840 Turkey 12840 Arenaria sabulinea Gris. ex Fenzl -6- Ex/E [Caryophyllaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Arenaria saponarioides Boiss. & Balansa ssp. Saponarioides [Caryophyllaceae] 12840, 20171 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Arenaria scariosa Boiss. [Caryophyllaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Arenaria sivasica Kit Tan ex Sorger [Caryophyllaceae] /2840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Arenaria speluncarum McNeill [Caryophyllaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Arenaria uninervia McNeill [Caryophyllaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Aristolochia brevilabris Bornm. [Aristolochiaceae] 12840 I 12840 Turkey 12840 Aristolochia cilicica Davis & Khan [Aristolochiaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Aristolochia krausei Davis [Aristolochiaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Aristolochia lycica Davis & Khan [Aristolochiaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Aristolochia poluninii Davis & Khan [Aristolochiaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Aristolochia rechingeriana Kit Tan & Sorger [Aristolochiaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Aristolochia samsunensis Davis [Aristolochiaceae] 12840 E 12840 Turkey 12840 Aristolochia stenosiphon Davis & Khan [Aristolochiaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Armeria pocutica Pawl. [Plumbaginaceae] 2017! Ex/E 20655 Ukraine (Carpathian Mts) 20655 Armeria trojana Bokhari & Quezel [Plumbaginaceae] /2840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Arnebia purpurea Erik & Sumbul [Boraginaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Artemisia hololeuca M.Bieb. ex Besser [Compositae] 8000, 20171 Vv 11552 Russian Federation (west) 1/552 Artemisia salsoloides Willd. [Compositae] 8000, 20171 R 11552 Russian Federation (west Caucasus, west Siberia) //552 Arum balansanum R. Mill [Araceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Arum conophalloides Kotschy ex Schott var. caudatum Engler [Araceae] 12840 a R 19873 Turkey 12840 a Arum dioscoridis Sm. var. luschanii R. Mill. | [Araceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 ingle country endemic globally threatened plants ‘Araceae: Arum Arum euxinum R. Mill [Araceae] 12840 R 19873 Turkey 12840 Asparagus coodei Davis [Asparagaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Asparagus litoralis Steven [Asparagaceae] 20171 R former European USSR Asparagus lycaonicus Davis [Asparagaceae] 12840 E 12840 Turkey 12840 Asperula antalyensis Ehrend. [Rubiaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Asperula capitellata Houuskn. ex Bornm. & Bornm. [Rubiaceae] /2840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Asperula cilicica Hausskn. & Ehrend. [Rubiaceae] 12840 R = 12840 Turkey 12840 Asperula lilaciflora Boiss. ssp. lilaciflora [Rubiaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Asperula lilaciflora Boiss. ssp. mutensis Schonb.-Tem. [Rubiaceae] /2840 R =: 12840 Turkey 12840 Asperula littoralis Sibth. & Sm. [Rubiaceae] 12840, 20171 V =: 12840 Turkey 12840 Asperula lycia Stapf [Rubiaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Asperula nitida Sm. ssp. hirtella (Boiss.) Ehrend. [Rubiaceae] /2840 R = _12840 Turkey 12840 Asperula nitida Sm. ssp. subcapitellata Ehrend. [Rubiaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Asperula pseudochlorantha Ehrend. [Rubiaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Asperula sintenisii Acherson ex Bornm. [Rubiaceae] /2840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Asperula stricta Boiss. ssp. elmaliensis Schonb.-Tem. [Rubiaceae] 12840 R = 12840 Turkey 12840 Asperula stricta Boiss. ssp. grandiflora Schonb.-Tem. [Rubiaceae] /2840 R = 12840 Turkey 12840 Asperula tephrocarpa Czern. ex Popoy & Chrshan. [Rubiaceae] 20171 R former European USSR Asperula virgata Hub.-Mor. ex Ehre.& Scho.-Tem. [Rubiaceae] 12840 R = 12840 Turkey 12840 Asperula woronowii Krecz. [Rubiaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Asphodeline anatolica E. Tuzlaci [Asphodelaceae] 12840 R = 12840 Turkey 12840 Asphodeline cilicica E. Tuzlaci [Asphodelaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 ; Asphodeline damascena (Boiss.) Baker ssp. ovoidea 7s x FF FR BR x RF KF BR E. Tuzlaci [Asphodelaceae] 12840 Vv 12840 Turkey 12840 Asphodeline damascena (Boiss.) Baker ssp. rugosa E. Tuzlaci [Asphodelaceae] /2840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Asphodeline peshmeniana E. Tuzlaci [Asphodelaceae] /2840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Asphodeline prismatocarpa J. Gay ex Baker [Asphodelaceae] 1/2840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Asphodeline tenuior (Bieb.) Ledeb. [Asphodelaceae] 5942 I 5942 Russia - North Caucasus 5942 Asphodeline tenuior (Fischer) Ledeb. var. puberulenta E. Tuzlaci [Asphodelaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Asplenium reuteri Milde [Aspleniaceae] 12840 E 12840 Turkey 12840 Aster tarbagatensis (K.Koch) Merxm. [Compositae] 8000, 20171 R Russia (E.Europe) - South (South-East) 8000 Astragalus acmophyllus Bunge [Leguminosae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Astragalus adustus Bunge [Leguminosae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Astragalus aintabicus Bunge [Leguminosae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Astragalus akscheherensis Freyn & Bornm. [Leguminosae] /2840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Astragalus albicalycinus Huber-Mor. & Mathews [Leguminosae] /2840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Astragalus albifolius Freyn & Sint. [Leguminosae] /2840 R = 12840 Turkey 12840 Astragalus alindanus Boiss. [Leguminosae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Astragalus altanii Huber-Mor. [Leguminosae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Astragalus angustiflorus C. Koch ssp. amanus (Boiss.) Chamb. [Leguminosae] /2840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Astragalus antiochianus Post [Leguminosae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Astragalus argaeus Boiss. [Leguminosae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Astragalus armeniacus Boiss. [Leguminosae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Astragalus atrocarpus Chamb. & Mathews [Leguminosae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Astragalus aydosensis Pesmen & Erik [Leguminosae] /2840 Vv 12840 Turkey 12840 Astragalus badachschianus A. Boriss. [Leguminosae] R former USSR 6930 Single country endemic globally threatened plants : Leguminosae: Astragalus E xy FF FR v=] v=] 7x Fe RF BR Astragalus badamensis Popov [Leguminosae] E former USSR 6930 Astragalus balkisensis Sirj. & Rech. [Leguminosae] 12840 I 12840 Turkey 12840 Astragalus barba-jovis DC [Leguminosae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Astragalus barbarae Bornm. [Leguminosae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Astragalus barbeyanus Post {Leguminosae] 12840 R= 12840 Turkey 12840 Astragalus bashkalensis Chamb. [Leguminosae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Astragalus baytopianus Chamb. & Mathews [Leguminosae] /2840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Astragalus bombycalyx Eig [Leguminosae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Astragalus canescens DC. [Leguminosae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Astragalus cariensis Boiss. [Leguminosae] 12840 R =: 12840 Turkey 12840 Astragalus caudiculosus Boiss. & Huet [Leguminosae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Astragalus celakowskyanus Freyn & Bornm. [Leguminosae] /2840 R= 12840 Turkey 12840 Astragalus cephalotes Banks & Bornm. var. brevicalyx Eig [Leguminosae] /2340 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Astragalus cephalotes Banks & Bornm. var. sintenianus (Sirj) Chamb. & Mathews [Leguminosae] /2840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Astragalus chaldiranicus Kit Tan & Sorger [Leguminosae] /2840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Astragalus chamaephaca Freyn [Leguminosae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Astragalus chrysochlorus Boiss. & Kotschy [Leguminosae] 12840 R = 12840 Turkey 12840 Astragalus chthonocephalus Boiss. & Bal. [Leguminosae] /2840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Astragalus cicerellus Boiss. & Bal. [Leguminosae] /2840 V_—s:12840 Turkey 12840 Astragalus coadunatus Huber-Mor. & Chamb. [Leguminosae] /2840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Astragalus columnaris Boiss. [Leguminosae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Astragalus commagenicus (Hand.-Mazz.) Sirj. [Leguminosae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Astragalus comosoides Cham. & Mathews [Leguminosae] 1/2840 -8- 7 x FF FR BR v=] x 7 FR FR R 12840 Turkey 12840 Astragalus consimilis Bornm. [Leguminosae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Astragalus crinitus Boiss. [Leguminosae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Astragalus cuspistipulatus Eig [Leguminosae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Astragalus cymbibracteatus Huber-Mor. & Chamb. [Leguminosae] /2840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Astragalus cymbostegius Bunge [Leguminosae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Astragalus czorochensis Charadze [Leguminosae] /2840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Astragalus darwasicus Basilevsk. [Leguminosae] R former USSR 6930 Astragalus dasycarpus Chamb. [Leguminosae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Astragalus decurrens Boiss. [Leguminosae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Astragalus delanensis Sirj. & Rech.f. [Leguminosae] /2840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Astragalus delbesii Eig [Leguminosae] 12840 R =: 12840 Turkey 12840 p Astragalus depressus L. var. tasheliensis Erik & Sumbul [Leguminosae] 12840 R =: 12840 Turkey 12840 Astragalus diphtherites Fenzl var. karatashensis (Sirj.) Chamb. [Leguminosae] /2840 R = 12840 Turkey 12840 Astragalus dirmilensis Huber-Mor. & Reese [Leguminosae] /2840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Astragalus discessiflorus Gontsch. [Leguminosae] R former USSR 6930 Astragalus distinctissimus Eig [Leguminosae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Astragalus edinburghensis Ponert [Leguminosae] /2840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Astragalus edmodii (Kuntze) Sheldon [Leguminosae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Astragalus elatus Boiss. & Bal. [Leguminosae] 12840 R = 12840 Turkey 12840 Astragalus elazigensis Ekim [Leguminosae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Astragalus elbistanicus Huber-Mor. & Chamb. [Leguminosae] 12840 R = 12840 Turkey 12840 Astragalus eliasianus Kit Tan & Sorger [Leguminosae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Astragalus eriocephalus Willd. [Leguminosae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Astragalus ermineus Matt. [Leguminosae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 ingle country endemic globally threatened plants Leguminosae: Astragalus i Astragalus fissuralis Alexej. [Leguminosae] 11552 R 11552 Russian Federation (Caucasus) 1/552 Astragalus fodinarum Boiss. & Noe [Leguminosae] /2840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Astragalus gaeobotrys Boiss. & Bal. [Leguminosae] /2840 R = 12840 Turkey 12840 Astragalus gevaschensis Chamb. & Matt. [Leguminosae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Astragalus gilvus Boiss. [Leguminosae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Astragalus goeznensis Eig [Leguminosae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Astragalus gymnalopecias Rech.f. [Leguminosae] /2840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Astragalus hakkiaricus Chamb. & Matt. [Leguminosae] 1/2840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Astragalus hareftae (Nab.) Sirj [Leguminosae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Astragalus hartvigii Kit Tan [Leguminosae] 12840 R_=_:12840 Turkey 12840 Astragalus helmii Fischer var. permiensis C. Meyer ex Rupr. [Leguminosae] R former USSR Astragalus henningii (Steven) Boriss. [Leguminosae] 20/7/ R former European USSR Astragalus hilaris Bunge [Leguminosae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Astragalus huber-morathii Agerer-Kirchhoff [Leguminosae] 1/2840 R =: 12840 Turkey 12840 Astragalus ideae Sirj. [Leguminosae] 12840 R= 12840 Turkey 12840 Astragalus insignis Gontsch. [Leguminosae] R former USSR 6930 Astragalus isauricus Huber-Mor. [Leguminosae] 12840 R = 12840 Turkey 12840 Astragalus isparticus Kit Tan & Sorger [Leguminosae] 12840 R = 12840 Turkey 12840 Astragalus kangalicus Kit Tan & Sorger [Leguminosae] /2840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Astragalus karelinianus Popov (Leguminosae] 20171 R former European USSR Astragalus kirshehiricus Chamb. [Leguminosae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Astragalus kitianus Sorger [Leguminosae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Astragalus lagopodioides Vah\ (Leguminosae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Astragalus latistipulatus Chamb. & Matt. [Leguminosae] 1/2840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 -9- R Astragalus leptocaulis Ledeb. [Leguminosae] R former USSR 6930 R Astragalus listoniae Boiss. [Leguminosae] 12840 R =: 12840 Turkey 12840 R Astragalus longifolius Lam. [Leguminosae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 R Astragalus macrouroides Huber-Mor. [Leguminosae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 R Astragalus maximus Willd. var. dasysemius Chamb. & Matt. [Leguminosae] /2840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 R Astragalus melitensis Boiss. [Leguminosae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 R Astragalus microrchis Barbey [Leguminosae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 R Astragalus mitchellianus Boiss. [Leguminosae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 R Astragalus mokeevae Popov [Leguminosae] R former USSR 6930 R Astragalus mordiensis Nab. [Leguminosae] 12340 R 12840 Turkey 12840 R Astragalus mukisiensis Rech.f. [Leguminosae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 R Astragalus nervulosus Eig & Reese emend Huber-Mor. [Leguminosae] /2840 R =: 12840 Turkey 12840 R Astragalus nuratensis Popov [Leguminosae] R former USSR 6930 R Astragalus ocakverdii Kit Tan & Sorger [Leguminosae] /2840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 R Astragalus ovalis Boiss. & Bal. [Leguminosae] 12340 R 12840 Turkey 12840 R Astragalus ovatus DC. [Leguminosae] 12840 R —:12840 Turkey 12840 R Astragalus ovinus Boiss. [Leguminosae] 12840 R 2840 Turkey 12840 R Astragalus oxypterus A. Boriss. [Leguminosae] R former Asiatic USSR 6930 R Astragalus paecilanthus Boiss. & Heldr. [Leguminosae] /2840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 I Astragalus pallescens M.Bieb. [Leguminosae] 20171 I former European USSR R Astragalus panduratus Bunge [Leguminosae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 E Astragalus papasianus O. Schwarz [Leguminosae] /2840 E 12840 Turkey 12840 R Astragalus patnosicus Chamb. & Matth. [Leguminosae] /2840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 R Astragalus phrygius Sirj. [Leguminosae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Ex/E Astragalus physocalyx Fisch. [Leguminosae] 3000, 20171 Ex/E 5204 Bulgaria (Souther - two unconfirmed sites) 5204 Single country endemic globally threatened plants : Leguminosae: Astragalus R SE PO vA Ad v=] Y=] x Fe FR Ae a on Astragalus plumosus Willd. var. nitens (Freyn & Birnm.) Chamb. & Matt [Leguminosae] /2840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Astragalus polemoniacus Bunge [Leguminosae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Astragalus pseudocaspicus Fischer [Leguminosae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Astragalus pseudocylindraceus Bornm. [Leguminosae] /2840 Ex 12840 Turkey 12840 Astragalus pycnocephalus Fischer var. seytunensis (Bunge) Chamb. [Leguminosae] 1/2840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Astragalus ramicaudex Chamb. [Leguminosae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Astragalus rarissimus Popov [Leguminosae] R former USSR 6930 Astragalus rechingeri Sirj. [Leguminosae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Astragalus reduncus Pall. [Leguminosae] 20171 I former European USSR 8000 Astragalus renzii Huber-Mor. [Leguminosae] 12340 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Astragalus robertianus Kit Tan & Sorger [Leguminosae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Astragalus roseocalycinus Matt. [Leguminosae] 12840 R =: 12840 Turkey 12840 Astragalus sachanevii Sirj. [Leguminosae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Astragalus scabrifolius Boiss. [Leguminosae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Astragalus setosulus Gontsch. [Leguminosae] 20171 E 20655 Ukraine - Crimea 20653 Astragalus seydishehiricus Kit Tan & Ocakverdi [Leguminosae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Astragalus sorgerae Huber-Mor. & Chamb. [Leguminosae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Astragalus sparsipilis Huber-Mor. & Chamb. [Leguminosae] /2840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Astragalus stenosemioides Bornm. ex Chamb. & Matt. [Leguminosae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Astragalus stridii Kit Tan [Leguminosae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Astragalus subternatus Pavlov [Leguminosae] R former USSR 6930 Astragalus syringus Chamb [Leguminosae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Astragalus talasseus Boiss. & Bal. [Leguminosae] /2840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Astragalus tanaiticus K.Koch [Leguminosae] 11552, 20171 Vv 11552 Russian Federation (western) 11552 Astragalus taochius Woron. [Leguminosae] 12840 R =: 12840 Turkey 12840 Astragalus tatlii H. Pesmen [Leguminosae] 12840 R = 12840 Turkey 12840 Astragalus tekutjevii Gontsch. [Leguminosae] I former USSR 6930 Astragalus thiebaetii Eig [Leguminosae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Astragalus tmoleus Boiss. var. tmoleus [Leguminosae] /2840 R =: 12840 Turkey 12840 Astragalus tokatensis Fischer [Leguminosae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Astragalus trachytricus Bunge [Leguminosae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Astragalus trifoliastrum Huber-Mor. & Matt. [Leguminosae] 1/2840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Astragalus uhlwormianus Freyn & Bornm. [Leguminosae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Astragalus ulashensis Huber-Mor. & Reese [Leguminosae] /2840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Astragalus vanulosus Boiss. [Leguminosae] 12840 R_ 12840 Turkey 12840 Astragalus velenowskyi Nab. [Leguminosae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Astragalus victoriae Podlech-Ayerer-Kirchhoff [Leguminosae] /2840 R_ 12840 Turkey 12840 Astragalus viridiflorus A. Boriss. [Leguminosae] R former USSR 6930 Astragalus voronovianus (Boriss.) Boriss. [Leguminosae] /2840 R = 12840 Turkey 12840 Astragalus wartoensis Boiss. [Leguminosae] 12340 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Astragalus wilmottianus Stoj., [Leguminosae] 5204, 20171 R 5204 Bulgaria (West) 5204 Astragalus yueksekovae Matthews [Leguminosae] 12840, R 12840 Turkey 12840 Astragalus zahlbruckneri Hand.-Mazz. [Leguminosae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Astragalus zingeri Korsh. [Leguminosae] 8000, 20171 Vv 11552 Russian Federation (western) 1/552 Asyneuma babadaghensis Yildiz & Kit Tan [Campanulaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Asyneuma compactum (Boiss. & Heldr.) Damboldt [Campanulaceae] /2840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Asyneuma davisianum Yildiz & Kit Tan [Campanulaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Asyneuma ekimianum Kit Tan & Yikdiz [Campanulaceae] /2840 : : ingle country endemic globally threatened plants Campanulaceae: Asyneuma R 12840 Turkey 12840 Asyneuma ilgazensis Yildiz & Kit Tan [Campanulaceae] /2840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Asyneuma isauricum Contandr. & al. [Campanulaceae] /2840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Asyneuma linifolium (Boiss. & Heldr.) Bornm. ssp. eximium (Rech.f.) Damboldt [Campanulaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Asyneuma linifolium (Boiss. & Heldr.) Bornm. ssp. glabrum Kit Tan & Yildiz [Campanulaceae] 12840 Vv 12840 Turkey 12840 Asyneuma linifolium (Boiss. & Heldr.) Bornm. ssp. nallihanicum Kit Tan & Yildiz [Campanulaceae] 12840 Vv 12840 Turkey 12840 Asyneuma lycium (Boiss.) Bornm. [Campanulaceae] /2840 R= 12840 Turkey 12840 Asyneuma pulvinatum Davis [Campanulaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Asyneuma rigidum (Willd.) Grossh. ssp. graminifolium Huber-Mor. [Campanulaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Asyneuma trichostegium (Boiss.) Bornm. [Campanulaceae] /2840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Atriplex tatarica L. var. constantinopolitana Aellen [Chenopodiaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Atriplex tatarica L. var. pseudo-ornata Aellen [Chenopodiaceae] /2840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Aubrieta anamasica H. Pesmen & A. Guner [Cruciferae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Aubrieta olympica Boiss. [Cruciferae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Ballota cristata Davis [Labiatae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Ballota inaequidens Hub.-Mor. & Patzak [Labiatae] 12840 R= 12840 Turkey 12840 Ballota latibracteolata Davis & Droszenko [Labiatae] 12840 R 2840 Turkey 12840 Ballota macrodonta Boiss. & Bal. [Labiatae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Ballota pseudodictamnus (L.) Benth. [Labiatae] 12840, 20171 R= 12840 Turkey 12840 Ballota rotundifolia C. Koch [Labiatae] 12840 R= 12840 Turkey 12840 Ballota saxatilis Sieber ex J. &C.Presl. ssp. brachyodonta (Boiss.) Davis & Droszenko [Labiatae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Barbarea auriculata Hausskn. ex Bornm. s.1. [Cruciferae] 1/2840 -11- R 12840 Turkey 12840 Barbarea lutea Cullen & Coode [Cruciferae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Barbarea minor C. Koch var. anfiactroza Hartvig & Strid [Cruciferae] /2840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Barbarea platycarpa Hausskn. ex Bornm. [Cruciferae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Bellardiochloa argaea (Boiss. & Bal.) R. Mill [Gramineae] 1/2840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Bellardiochloa carica R. Mill [Gramineae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Bellevalia forniculata (Fomin) Deloney [Hyacinthaceae] /2840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Bellevalia lipskyi (Miscz.) E.Wulff [Hyacinthaceae] 20/7] R former European USSR Bellevalia modesta Wendelbo [Hyacinthaceae] 12840 Vv 12840 Turkey 12840 Bellevalia rixii Wendelbo [Hyacinthaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Beta adanensis Pamukc. ex Aellen [Chenopodiaceae] 12840, 20171 Vv 12840 Turkey 12840 Beta trojana (Pamuk.) Aellen [Chenopodiaceae] 12840 E 12840 Turkey 12840 Betula browicziana Guner [Betulaceae] 12840 R 20618 Turkey 20618 Betula megrelica Sosn. [Betulaceae] 5942 I 5942 Georgia 5942 Biarum eximium (Schott & Kotschy) Engler [Araceae] 12840 R 19873 Turkey 12840 Bolanthus cherlerioides (Bornm.) Bark. [Caryophyllaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Bolanthus frankenioides (Boiss.) Bark. var. fasciculatus (Boiss. & Heldr.) Bark. [Caryophyllaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Bolanthus frankenioides (Boiss.) Bark. var. frankenioides [Caryophyllaceae] 12840 R= 12840 Turkey 12840 Bolanthus spergulifolius (Saub. & Spach) Huber-Mor. [Caryophyllaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Bolanthus stenopetalum Hartvig & Strid [Caryophyllaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Bolanthus thymoides Huber-Mor. [Caryophyllaceae] /2840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Boreava aptera Boiss. & Heldr. [Cruciferae] 12840 Vv 12840 Turkey 12840 Bornmuellera cappadocica (DC.) Cullen & Dudley [Cruciferae] 12840 Single country endemic globally threatened plants : Cruciferae: Bornmuellera R R 12840 Turkey 12840 Bornmuellera glabrescens (Boiss. & Bal.) Cullen & Dudley [Cruciferae] /2840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Botschantzevia karatavica (Lipsch. & Pavlov) Nabiev [Cruciferae] R former USSR 6930 Brachypodium kotschy Boiss. [Gramineae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Brachypodium sanctum (Sanka) Janka [Gramineae] 5204, 20171 R 5204 Bulgaria (Southern Bulgaria - three areas.) 5204 Brassica nivalis Boiss. & Heldr. ssp. jordanoffii O. E. Schulz [Cruciferae] 8000, 20171 R = 5204 Bulgaria (south-west) 8000 Brassica sylvestris (L.) Mill. ssp. taurica Tzveley [Cruciferae] 5942 I 5942 Ukraine - Crimea 5942 Bromus armenus Boiss. [Gramineae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Bromus macrocladus Boiss. [Gramineae] 12840 I 12840 Turkey 12840 Bromus moesiacus Velen. [Gramineae] 8000, 20171 R 19709 Bulgaria 8000 Bromus psammophilus P.M. Smith [Gramineae] 12840 E 12840 Turkey 12840 Bunium microcarpum (Boiss.) Freyn ssp. longiradiatum Hedge & Lamond [Umbelliferae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Bupleurum anatolicum Huber-Mor. & Reese [Umbelliferae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Bupleurum davisii Snogerup [Umbelliferae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Bupleurum eginense (Wolff) Snogerup [Umbelliferae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Bupleurum eruberescens Boiss. [Umbelliferae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Bupleurum koechelii Fenzl (Umbelliferae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Bupleurum pauciradiatum Fenzl (Umbelliferae] 12840, 20171 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Bupleurum pendikum Snogerup [Umbelliferae] 12840 I 12840 Turkey 12840 Bupleurum polyactis Post ex Snogerup [Umbelliferae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Bupleurum pulchellum Boiss. & Heldr. [Umbelliferae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840. Bupleurum subuniflorum Boiss. & Heldr. [Umbelliferae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Bupleurum zoharii Snogerup (Umbelliferae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Calamintha caroli-henricana Kit Tan & Sorger -12- | x ww RB [Labiatae] /2840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Calamintha pamphylica Boiss. & Heldr. [Labiatae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Calamintha tauricola Davis [Labiatae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Calophaca sericea B. Fedtsch. ex A. Boriss. [Leguminosae] R former USSR 6930 Camelina anomala Boiss. & Hausskn. [Cruciferae] 12840 I 12840 Turkey 12840 Camelina stiefelhagenii Bornm. [Cruciferae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Campanula aghrica Kit Tan & Sorger [Campanulaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Campanula antalyensis Ayasligil & Kit Tan [Campanulaceae] 1/2840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Campanula ardonensis Rupr. [Campanulaceae] 5942 I 5942 Russia - North Caucasus 5942 Campanula argentea Lam. [Campanulaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Campanula autraniana Albov [Campanulaceae] 5942 I 5942 Russia - North Caucasus 5942 Campanula bipinnatifida Davis [Campanulaceae] 12840. R 12840 Turkey 12840 c Campanula bornmuelleri Nab. [Campanulaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 | Campanula choruhensis Kit Tan & Sorger | [Campanulaceae] /2840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Campanula coriacea Davis [Campanulaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Campanula damboldtiana Davis & Sorger [Campanulaceae] /2840 E 14197 Turkey 12840 Campanula davisii Turrill [Campanulaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Campanula dolomitica E. Busch [Campanulaceae] 5942 I 5942 Russia - North Caucasus 5942 Campanula ekimiana Guner [Campanulaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Campanula fruticulosa (Schwarz & Davis) Damboldt [Campanulaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Campanula hakkarica Davis [Campanulaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Campanula hedgei Davis [Campanulaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Campanula isaurica Contandr. et al. [Campanulaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Campanula komarovii Maleev [Campanulaceae] 5942 I 5942 Russia - North Caucasus 5942 Campanula kryophila Rupr. [Campanulaceae] 5942 I 5942 Russia - North Caucasus 5942 gt ingle country endemic globally threatened plants Campanulaceae: Campanula Campanula lanata Friv. [Campanulaceae] 19709, 20171 R = 19709 Bulgaria 19709 Campanula latiloba A. DC. ssp. rizeensis Guner [Campanulaceae] /2840 R = 2840 Turkey 12840 Campanula ledebouriana Trauty. [Campanulaceae] /2840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Campanula leucosiphon Boiss. & Heldr. [Campanulaceae] /2840 R = 12840 Turkey 12840 Campanula lycica Kit Tan & Sorger [Campanulaceae] /2840 E 12840 Turkey 12840 Campanula macrostyla Boiss. & Heldr. [Campanulaceae] /2840 R= 12840 Turkey 12840 Campanula makaschvilii E. Busch [Campanulaceae] 5942 I 5942 Georgia 5942 Campanula mirabilis Atbov [Campanulaceae] 5942 I 5942 Russia - North Caucasus 5942 Campanula munzurensis Davis [Campanulaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Campanula myrtifolia Boiss. & Heldr. [Campanulaceae] 12840 R =—-2840 Turkey 12840 Campanula oligosperma Damboldt [Campanulaceae] 12840 Ex 12840 Turkey 12840 Campanula ossetica M. Bieb. [Campanulaceae] 5942 I 5942 Russia - North Caucasus 5942 Campanula paradoxa Kolak. [Campanulaceae] 5942 I 5942 Russia - North Caucasus 5942 Campanula peshmenii Guner [Campanulaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Campanula pinnatifida Huber-Mor. [Campanulaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Campanula psilostachya Boiss. & Kotschy [Campanulaceae] 12840 R= 12840 Turkey 12840 Campanula ptarmicifolia Lam. var. capitellata Damboldt [Campanulaceae] 12840 R= 12840 Turkey 12840 Campanula pterocaula Hausskn. [Campanulaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Campanula pubicalyx (Davis) Damboldt [Campanulaceae] 12840 R= 12840 Turkey 12840 Campanula pulvinaris Hausskn. & Bornm. [Campanulaceae] 12840 R= 12840 Turkey 12840 Campanula quercetorum Huber-Mor. & Simon [Campanulaceae] 1/2840 R = 12840 Turkey 12840 Campanula raveyi Boiss. [Campanulaceae] 12840 V =: 12840 Turkey 12840 Campanula rimarum Boiss. [Campanulaceae] 12840 -13- R 12840 Turkey 12840 Campanula scoparia (Boiss. & Hausskn.) Damboldt [Campanulaceae] /2840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Campanula seraglio Kit Tan & Sorger [Campanulaceae] 1/2840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Campanula sorgerae Phitos [Campanulaceae] 12840 Vv 12840 Turkey 12840 Campanula stricta L. var. alidagensis Damboldt [Campanulaceae] /2840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Campanula strigillosa Boiss. [Campanulaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Campanula telephioides Boiss. & Hausskn. [Campanulaceae] /2840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Campanula telmessii Huber-Mor. & Phitos [Campanulaceae] 1/2840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Campanula teucrioides Boiss. [Campanulaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Campanula tomentosa Lam. [Campanulaceae] 12840, 20171 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Campanula trachyphylla Schott & Kotschy [Campanulaceae] /2840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Campanula troegerae Damboldt [Campanulaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Campanula yildirimlii Kit Tan & Sorger [Campanulaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Capsella bursa-pastoris (L.) Medik. ssp. thracica (Velen.) Stoj. & Stefanov [Cruciferae] /9266, 20171 Vv 5204 Bulgaria (south) 19266 Caragana leiocalycina (Huber-Mor.) Huber-Mor. [Leguminosae] /2840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Cardamine trifida (Lam. ex Poir.) B.M.G.Jones [Cruciferae] 20/71] R former European USSR Carduus acanthoides L. ssp. sintenisii Kazmi [Compositae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Carduus adpressus C.A.Mey. [Compositae] 8000, 20171 R 5204 + Bulgaria (Southern - two sites only) 5204 Carduus nutans L. ssp. falcato-incurvus Davis [Compositae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Carduus nutans L. ssp. trojanus Davis [Compositae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Carduus onopordioides Fisch. ex Bieb. ssp. turcicus (Kazmi) Davis [Compositae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Carduus rechingeranus Kazmi [Compositae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Single country endemic globally threatened plants : Compositae: Carduus R x FF FF FF FF FH RF FR BR v=] Carduus thracicus (Velen.) Hayek [Compositae] 5204, 20171 R 5204 Bulgaria (Southern and eastern - five sites) 5204 Carex cilicica Boiss. ssp. muglaica O. Nilson [Cyperaceae] /2840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Carex cilicica Boiss. ssp. muratica O. Nilson [Cyperaceae] /2840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Carex eriocarpa Hausskn. Kuk. [Cyperaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Carlina cirsioides Kiokov [Compositae] 20/71 I 5942 Ukraine 5942 Carlina oligocephala Boiss. & Kotschy ssp. pallescens (Wettst.) Muesel & Kastner [Compositae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Carum rupicola Hardvig & Strid [Umbelliferae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Castilleja schrenkii Rebrist. [Scrophulariaceae] 20/71 R former European USSR Centaurea amaena Boiss. & Bal. [Compositae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Centaurea amanicola Hub.-Mor. [Compositae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Centaurea androssovii Njin [Compositae] 8001 R former USSR 6930 Centaurea anthemifolia Hub.-Mor. [Compositae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Centaurea antiochia Boiss. [Compositae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Centaurea antitauria Hayek [Compositae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Centaurea aphrodisea Boiss. [Compositae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Centaurea arifolia Boiss. [Compositae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Centaurea arpensis (Czerep.) Wagentiz [Compositae] 800] R former USSR 6930 Centaurea aucherana DC. [Compositae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Centaurea austro-anatolica Hub.-Mor. [Compositae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Centaurea barbeyi (Albov) Sosn. [Compositae] 5942 I 5942 Transcaucasus 5942 Centaurea bourgaei Boiss. [Compositae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Centaurea bovina Velen. [Compositae] 20171 I Bulgaria Centaurea brevifimbriata Hub.-Mor. [Compositae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Centaurea calcitrapa L. ssp. cilicica (Boiss. & Bal.) Wagenitz [Compositae] /2840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 -14- SS AO ee on AN Sg < FPF FR < RF BR Centaurea cariensiformis Hub.-Mor. [Compositae] /2840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Centaurea cariensis Boiss. [Compositae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Centaurea cataonica Boiss. & Hausskn. [Compositae] 1/2840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Centaurea chaldaeorum Nab. [Compositae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Centaurea cheirolepidoides Wagenitz [Compositae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Centaurea chrysantha Wagenitz [Compositae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Centaurea davisii Wagenitz [Compositae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Centaurea deflexa Wagenitz [Compositae] 12840 Vv 12840 Turkey 12840 Centaurea demirizii Wagenitz [Compositae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Centaurea derderiifolia Wagenitz [Compositae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Centaurea dichroa Boiss. & Heldr. [Compositae] 12840 Vv 12840 Turkey 12840 Centaurea drabifolioides Hub.-Mor. [Compositae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Centaurea dubjanskii jin [Compositae] R former European USSR Centaurea ensiformis Davis [Compositae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Centaurea germanicopolitana Bornn. [Compositae] /2840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Centaurea gracillima Wagenitz [Compositae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Centaurea hakkariensis Wagenitz [Compositae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Centaurea halophila Hub.-Mor. [Compositae] 12840 ~ Vv 12840 Turkey 12840 Centaurea haradjianii Wagenitz [Compositae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Centaurea hedgei Wagenitz [Compositae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Centaurea hermannii F.Herm. [Compositae] 17781, 20171 Vv 17781 Turkey 17781 Centaurea hierapolitana Boiss. [Compositae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Centaurea holtzii Wagenitz [Compositae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Centaurea huber-morathii Wagenitz [Compositae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Centaurea karduchorum Boiss. [Compositae] 12840 R = 12840 Turkey 12840 Centaurea kernerana Janka [Compositae] 5204, 20171 jingle country endemic globally threatened plants Compositae: Centaurea R 5204 Bulgaria (central & west) 5204 Centaurea kilaea Boiss. [Compositae] 12840, 20171 Vv 12840 Turkey 12840 Centaurea koniensis Hub.-Mor. [Compositae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Centaurea kotschyi (Boiss. & Heldr.) Hayek var. decumbens Wagenitz [Compositae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Centaurea longifimbriata Wagenitz [Compositae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Centaurea luschaniana Heimer! [Compositae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Centaurea lycica Boiss. [Compositae] 12840 R = 12840 Turkey 12840 Centaurea lycopifolia Boiss. & Kotschy [Compositae] /2840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Centaurea lydia Boiss. [Compositae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Centaurea mannagettae Podp. ssp. pirinica (D. Jord.) Koz. [Compositae] 19709 R 19709 Bulgaria 19709 Centaurea margaritacea Ten. [Compositae] 20/7] Vv former European USSR Centaurea mathiolifolia Boiss. [Compositae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Centaurea mykalea Hub.-Mor. [Compositae] 12840 R = 12840 Turkey 12840 Centaurea nydeggeri Hub.-Mor [Compositae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Centaurea odyssei Wagenitz [Compositae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Centaurea olympica C. Koch. [Compositae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Centaurea pamphylica Boiss. & Heldr. [Compositae] 12840 Vv 12840 Turkey 12840 Centaurea paphlagonica (Bornm.) Wagenitz [Compositae] 12840 R = 12840 Turkey 12840 Centaurea pecho Albow [Compositae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Centaurea pestalozzae Boiss. [Compositae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Centaurea pinetorum Hub.-Mor. [Compositae] 12840 Vv 12840 Turkey 12840 Centaurea poluninii Wagenitz [Compositae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Centaurea psephelloides Freyn & Sint. [Compositae] 12840 Ex 19873 Turkey 12840 Centaurea pseudokotschyi Wagenitz [Compositae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Centaurea pseudoleucolepis Kieopow [Compositae] 5942, 20171] E 20655 Ukraine (south-east) 5942 Centaurea pseudoreflexa Hayek [Compositae] 12840 -15- w b=] xa Fe F BR R 12840 Turkey 12840 Centaurea ptosimopappa Hayek [Compositae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Centaurea ptosimopappoides Wagenitz [Compositae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Centaurea pulcherrima Willd. var. freynii (int.) Wagenitz [Compositae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Centaurea reuterana Boiss. var. reuterana [Compositae] /2840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Centaurea rhizocalathium (C. Koch.) Tchihat. [Compositae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Centaurea schischkinii Tzvelev. [Compositae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Centaurea scopulorum Boiss. & Heldr. [Compositae] /2840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Centaurea sericea Wagenitz [Compositae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Centaurea sipylea Wagenitz [Compositae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Centaurea sivasica Wagenitz [Compositae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Centaurea solstitialis L. ssp. carneola (Boiss.) Wagenitz [Compositae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Centaurea solstitialis L. ssp. pyracantha (Boiss.) Wagenitz [Compositae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Centaurea stapfiana (Hand.-Mazz.) Pai [Compositae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Centaurea straminicephala Hub.-Mor. [Compositae] /2840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Centaurea tardiflora Wagenitz [Compositae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Centaurea tchihatcheffii Fisch. & Mey. [Compositae] /2840 E 12840 Turkey 12840 Centaurea tossiensis Freyn & Sint. [Compositae] /2840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Centaurea vermiculigera Hub.-Mor. [Compositae] /2840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Centaurea wagenittzii Hub.-Mor. [Compositae] 12840 Vv 12840 Turkey 12840 Centaurea wiedemanniana Fisch. & Mey. [Compositae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Centaurea woronowii Bornm. [Compositae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Centaurea zeybekii Wagenitz [Compositae] 12840 Vv 12840 Turkey 12840 Centaurea zlatarskyana Urum. & J.Wagner Single country endemic globally threatened plants : Compositae: Centaurea [Compositae] 20171 I Bulgaria Centaurium serpenticola A. Carltrom [Gentianaceae] /2840 R= 12840 Turkey 12840 Centranthus kellererii (Stoj. Stef. et Georg. ) Stoj. et Stef. [Valerianaceae] /9709 R_ 19709 Bulgaria 19709 il Cephalanthera kotschyana Renz & Taub. [Orchidaceae] /2840 R 19873 Turkey 12840 Cephalaria amana Rech. fil. [Dipsacaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Cephalaria calcarea Alboy [Dipsacaceae] I former USSR 6930 Cephalaria dirmilensis Hub.-Mor. [Dipsacaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Cephalaria elmaliensis Hub.-Mor. [Dipsacaceae] 12840 R = 12840 Turkey 12840 Cephalaria hakkiarica Matthews [Dipsacaceae] 12840 R =: 12840 Turkey 12840 Cephalaria isaurica Matthews [Dipsacaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Cephalaria litvinovii Bobrov [Dipsacaceae] 5942, 20171 I 5942 Russia (E.Europe) - South 5942 Cephalaria lycica Matthews [Dipsacaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Cephalaria paphlagonica Bobrov [Dipsacaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Cephalaria salicifolia Post (Dipsacaceae] 12840 I 12840 Turkey 12840 Cephalaria scoparia Contandr. ex Quezel [Dipsacaceae] 1/2840 I 12840 Turkey 12840 Cephalaria sparsipilosa Matthews [Dipsacaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Cephalaria taurica Szabo [Dipsacaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Cerastium araraticum Rupr. [Caryophyllaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Cerastium dominici Kit Tan & R. Mill [Caryophyllaceae] /2840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Cerastium haussknechtii Boiss. [Caryophyllaceae] 12840 R= 12840 Turkey 12840 Cerastium krylovii Schischk. & Gortschak. [Caryophyllaceae] R former European USSR Cerastium macranthum Boiss. [Caryophyllaceae} 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Cerastium pisidicum Ayasligil & Kit Tan [Caryophyllaceae] /2840 R= 12840 Turkey 12840 Cerastium saccardoanum Dirat -16- Rol ate 6 ree urs) [Caryophyllaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Cerasus erzincanica Yildirimli [Rosaceae] 20618 R 20618 Turkey 20618 Cerasus hippophaeoides [Rosaceae] 20618 R 20618 Turkey 2061/8 Ceratophyllum tanaiticum Sapjegin [Ceratophyllaceae] 8000, 20171 I 11552 Russian Federation (western) 1/552 Chaerophyllum hakkiaricum Hedge & Lamond [Umbelliferae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Chaerophyllum karsianum Kit Tan ex Ocakverdi [Umbelliferae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Chamaecytisus anatolicus [Leguminosae] 20618 R 20618 Turkey 20618 Chamaecytisus blockianus (Pawl.) Klask. [Leguminosae] 8000, 20171 R former European USSR 8000 Chamaecytisus cassius (Boiss.) Rothm. [Leguminosae] 12840 R 20618 Turkey 20618 Chamaecytisus kovacevii (Velen.) Rothm. [Leguminosae] 5204, 20171 R 5204 Bulgaria (north) 5204 Chamaecytisus nejceffii (Urum.) Rothm. [Leguminosae] 8000, 20171 E Bulgaria 19847 Chamaecytisus paczoskii (V.1.Krecz.) Klask. [Leguminosae] 8000, 20171 R former European USSR 8000 Chamaecytisus podolicus (Blocki) Klask. [Leguminosae] 8000, 20171 ‘ R former European USSR 8000 f Chamaecytisus skrobiszewskii (Pacz.) Klask. [Leguminosae] 8000, 20171 R former European USSR 8000 Chesneya elegans Fomin [Leguminosae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Chionodoxa forbesii Baker [Hyacinthaceae] 12840 | R 19873 Turkey 12840 ‘ Chionodoxa luciliae Boiss. [Hyacinthaceae] 12840 Vv 12840 Turkey 12840 Chionodoxa sardensis Whittall ex Barr & Sugden [Hyacinthaceae] /2840 v 12840 Turkey 12840 Chondrilla spinosa Lamond et Matthews [Compositae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Chronanthus orientalis (ois) Heywood et Frodin [Leguminosae] 19873 R = 20618 Turkey 20618 Chrysochamela draboides Woronow [Cruciferae] 20171 Vv former European USSR : Chrysochamela noeana (Boiss.) Boiss. [Cruciferae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Chrysophthalmum dichotomum Boiss. & Heldr. jingle country endemic globally threatened plants Compositae: Chrysophthalmum [Compositae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Cicer echinospermum Davis [Leguminosae] 12840 R = 12840 Turkey 12840 Cicer floribundum Fenzl [Leguminosae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Cicer isauricum Davis [Leguminosae] 12340 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Cicer reticulatum Ladizinsky [Leguminosae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Cicerbita brevirostris (Schu.-Bip.exVis.&Panc) C. Jeffr [Compositae] /2840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Cirsium aduncum Fisch. & Mey. ex DC. ssp. bashkalense Davis & Parris [Compositae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Cirsium alatum (Gmelin) Bobrov ssp. pseudocreticum Davis & Parris [Compositae] /2840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Cirsium baytopae P.H.Davis & Parris [Compositae] 12840, 20171 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Cirsium boluense Davis & Parris [Compositae] 12340 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Cirsium cassium Davis & Parris [Compositae] 12840 R= 12840 Turkey 12840 Cirsium davisianum Kit Tan & Sorger [Compositae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Cirsium eliasianum Kit Tan & Sorger [Compositae] 12840 R = 12840 Turkey 12840 Cirsium ellenbergii Bornm. [Compositae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Cirsium hakkiaricum Davis & Parris [Compositae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Cirsium poluninii Davis & Parris [Compositae] 12840 R = 12840 Turkey 12840 Cirsium polycephalum DC. [Compositae] 12840, 20171 V = 12840 Turkey 12840 Cirsium pubigerum (Desf.) DC. var. paphlabonicum Petrak [Compositae] 12840 R = 12840 Turkey 12840 Cirsium simplex C.A. Meyer ssp. Satdaghense Davis & Parris [Compositae] 12840 R = 12840 Turkey 12840 Cirsium sipyleum O. Schwarz [Compositae] 12340 R =: 12840 Turkey 12840 Clypeola ciliata Boiss. [Cruciferae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Clypeola raddeana Albow [Cruciferae] 12840 ir 12840 Turkey 12840 Cochlearia amana Contandr. & Quezel [Cruciferae] 12840 R =: 12840 Turkey 12840 Colchicum baytopiorum C.D. Brickel [Colchicaceae] 12840 R = 12840 Turkey 12840 Az Colchicum borisii Stef. [Colchicaceae] 8000, 20171 Vv 5204 Bulgaria (South Bulgaria - one site only.) 5204 Colchicum bornmuelleri Freyn [Colchicaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Colchicum davidovii Stef. [Colchicaceae] 8000, 20171 Vv 5204 Bulgaria (east) 5204 Colchicum diampolis Delip. et Ceschm. [Colchicaceae] 5204, 20171 R 5204 Bulgaria (east) 5204 Colchicum micranthum Boiss. [Colchicaceae] 12840, 20171 Vv 19873 Turkey (Istanbul) 12840 Colchicum rhodopaeum Kov. [Colchicaceae] 5204, 20171 R 5204 Bulgaria (Southern Bulgaria - one site only .) 5204 Colutea melanocalyx Boiss. & Heldr. ssp. melanocalyx [Leguminosae] 12840 R 20618 Turkey 20618 Conioselinum boreale Schischk. [Umbelliferae] 20171 R former USSR 6930 Conioselinum victoris Schischkin [Umbelliferae] R former USSR 6930 Conringia grandiflora Boiss. & Heldr. [Cruciferae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Consolida armeniaca (Stapf ex Huth) Schrod. [Ranunculaceae] /2840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Consolida cornuta (Davis & Hossain) Davis [Ranunculaceae] /2840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Consolida cruciata (Davis & Hossain) Davis [Ranunculaceae] 12840 I 12840 Turkey 12840 Consolida lineolata Huber-Mor. & Simon [Ranunculaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Consolida olopetala (Boiss.) Hayek [Ranunculaceae] /2840, 20171 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Consolida staminosa Davis & Sorger [Ranunculaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Consolida stapfiana Davis & sorger [Ranunculaceae] /2840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Convolvulus holosericeus Bieb. ssp. macrocalycinus Hausskn. & Bornm. ex Bornm. [Convolvulaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Convolvulus phrygius Bornm. [Convolvulaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Convolvulus pulvinatus Sa'ad [Convolvulaceae] 12840 Vv 12840 Turkey 12840 Corispermum algidum Ijin [Chenopodiaceae] 8000, 20171 R former European USSR 8000 Corydalis rutifolia (Sibth. & Sm.) DC. ssp. kurdica Single country endemic globally threatened plants : Papaveraceae: Corydalis x FF FF RF BR a = ww wR So Sea AeA A x FF KF RF BR Cullen & Davis [Papaveraceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Corydalis sewerzowii Regel [Papaveraceae] Vv former USSR 6930 Corydalis solida (L.) Swartz ssp. tauricola Cullen & Davis [Papaveraceae] 1/2840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Cotoneaster tauricus Pojark. [Rosaceae] 2017] R former European USSR Cousinia agelocephala Tscherneva [Compositae] R former USSR 6930 Cousinia androssovii Juz. [Compositae] R former USSR 6930 Cousinia aucheri DC. [Compositae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Cousinia cataonica Boiss. & Hausskn. [Compositae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Cousinia cirsioides Boiss. & Bal. [Compositae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Cousinia davisiana Hub.-Mor. [Compositae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Cousinia decolorans Freyn & Sint. [Compositae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Cousinia eleonorae Hub.-Mor. [Compositae] 12840 R = 12840 Turkey 12840 Cousinia ermenekensis Hub.-Mor. [Compositae] 12340 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Cousinia euphratica Hub.-Mor. [Compositae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Cousinia hakkarica Hub.-Mor. [Compositae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Cousinia halysensis Hub.-Mor. [Compositae] 12840 Vi 12840 Turkey 12840 Cousinia intertexta Freyn & Sint. [Compositae] 12840 Vv 12840 Turkey 12840 Cousinia margiana Juz. [Compositae] R former USSR 6930 Cousinia nabelekii Bornm. [Compositae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Cousinia platystegia Tscherneva [Compositae] E former USSR 6930 Cousinia pseudolanata Popov & Tscherneva [Compositae] E former USSR 6930 Cousinia satdagensis Hub.-Mor. [Compositae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Cousinia sintenisii Freyn [(Compositae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Cousinia sivasica Hub.-Mor. [Compositae] 12840 R =: 12840 Turkey 12840 Cousinia vanensis Hub.-Mor. [Compositae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Cousinia woronowii Bornm. [Compositae] 12340 R =: 12840 Turkey 12840 — x 7 FR x eB RF FR Crambe tataria Sebeok var. parviflora (H.-Mor. Reese) Hedge & H.-Mor. Reese [Cruciferae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Crataegus aronia (L.) Bosc. var. dentata Browicz [Rosaceae] 12840 v 20618 Turkey 20618 Crataegus aronia (L.) Bosc. var. minuta Browicz [Rosaceae] 12840 R 20618 Turkey 20618 Crataegus davisii Browicz [Rosaceae] 12840 R 20618 Turkey 20618 Crataegus dikmensis Pojark [Rosaceae] 12840 I 20618 Turkey 20618 Crataegus karadaghensis Pojark. [Rosaceae] 20171 R former European USSR Crataegus pojarkovae Kossych [Rosaceae] 5942, 20171 I 5942 Ukraine - Crimea 5942 Crataegus ucrainica Pojark. [Rosaceae] 20171 R former European USSR Crepis amanica Bobcock [Compositae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Crepis aurea (L.) Cass. ssp. olympica (C. Koch) Lamond [Compositae] 12840 R = 12840 Turkey 12840 Crepis bithynica Boiss. [Compositae] 5204, 20171 R 5204 Bulgaria (Southem - two sites) 5204 Crepis hakkarica Lamond [Compositae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Crocus abatensis T. Baytop & Mathew [Iridaceae] 12840 Vv 14155 Turkey (L. Abant in Bolu) 12840 Crocus adanensis T. Baytop & Mathew [Iridaceae] 12840 R =: 12840 Turkey 12840 Crocus aerius Herbert [Iridaceae] 12840 R = 2840 Turkey 12840 Crocus asumaniae Mathew [lridaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Crocus baytopiorum Mathew [Iridaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Crocus biflorus Miller ssp. artvinensis (J. Phill.) Mathew [Iridaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Crocus cancellatus Herbert ssp. cancellatus [Iridaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Crocus cancellatus Herbert ssp. lycius Mathew [Iridaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Crocus cancellatus Herbert ssp. pamphylicus Mathew [lIridaceae] 1/2840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Crocus flavus Meston ssp. dissectus T. Baytop & Mathew [lIridaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Crocus gargaricus Herbert [Iridaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Crocus karduchorum Kotschy ex Maw [Iridaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 jingle country endemic globally threatened plants t cad I I I I I Tridaceae: Crocus Crocus kotschyanus C. Koch. ssp. cappadocicus Mathew [Iridaceae] /2840 R = 12840 Turkey 12840 Crocus kotschyanus C. Koch. ssp. hakkariensis Mathew [lIridaceae] 1/2840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Crocus leichtlinii (D. Dewar) Bowles [Iridaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Crocus olivieri Gay ssp. istanbulensis Mathew [Iridaceae] /2840 V = 12840 Turkey 12840 Crocus pestalozzae Boiss. [Iridaceae] 12840, 20171 Vv 19873 Turkey 12840 Crocus reticulatus Steven ex Adams ssp. hittiticus (T. Baytop & Mathew) Mathew [Iridaceae] /2840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Crocus sieheanus Barr ex Burtt [Iridaceae] 12840 R= 12840 Turkey 12840 Crocus speciosus Bieb. ssp. ilgazensis Mathew [Iridaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Crocus speciosus Bieb. ssp. xantholaimos Mathew [Iridaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Crucianella sorgerae Ebrend. [Rubiaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Cruciata mixta Ehrend. ex Schonb.-Tem. [Rubiaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Cuscuta obtusata (Engilmann) Trabut [Convolvulaceae] 12840 Vs: 12840 Turkey 12840 Cyathobasis fruticulosa (Bunge) Aellen [Chenopodiaceae] /2840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Cyclamen cilicicum Boiss. & Heldr. [Primulaceae] 12840 Vv 12840 Turkey (S. Anatolia) 12840 Cyclamen intaminatum (Meikle) Grey-Wilson [Primulaceae] 15934 V =: 19873 Turkey (WC & WS) 15934 Cyclamen kuznetzovii Kotov & Czernova [Primulaceae] 2/389 E 20655 Ukraine - Crimea 5942 Cyclamen mirabile Hildebr. [Primulaceae] 15934 Vv 14071 Turkey (south-west Anatolia) 8619 Cyclamen pseudibericum Hildebr. [Primulaceae] 12840 I 15934 Turkey (South, Amanus and Anti-Taumus) 12840 Cyclamen trochopteranthum Schwarz [Primulaceae] 12840 Vv Turkey (SW Anatolia) 15934 Cyclotrichium glabrescens (Bois.& Kot. & Rech. f.) Leb. [Labiatae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Cymbocarpum amanum Rech. f. [Umbelliferae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Cyperus melanorrhyncha Nelmes [Cyperaceae] 12840 R = 12840 Turkey 12840 -19- Cyperus noeanus Boiss. [Cyperaceae] 12840 I 12840 Turkey 12840 Cytisus acutangulus Jaub & Spach [Leguminosae] 12840 R 20618 Turkey 20618 Dactylorhiza chuhensis Renz & Taub. [Orchidaceae] 12840 E 12840 Turkey 12840 i Dactylorhiza nieschalkiorum H. Bauumann & Kunk. [Orchidaceae] 12840 R 19873 Turkey 12840 u Dactylorhiza osmanica (K\.) Soo var. anatolica (Nelson) Renz & Taub. [Orchidaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Daphne baksanica Pobed. [Thymelaeaceae] 5942 E 11552 Russia - North Caucasus 1/1552 Daphne sophia Kalen. [Thymelaeaceae] 5942, 20171 I 5942 Ukraine 5942 Delphinium anatolicum Misirdaii et al. [Ranunculaceae] /2840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Delphinium bithynicum Davis [Ranunculaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Delphinium cilicicum Davis & Kit Tan [Ranunculaceae] /2840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Delphinium cinereum Boiss. [Ranunculaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Delphinium cyphoplectrum Boiss. var. vanense (Rech.) Davis [Ranunculaceae] /2840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Delphinium dolichostachyum Chowdhuri & Davis [Ranunculaceae] /2840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Delphinium ilgazense Davis [Ranunculaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Delphinium munzianum Davis & Kit Tan [Ranunculaceae] 1/2840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Delphinium nydeggeri Huber-Mor. [Ranunculaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Delphinium puniceum Pall. [Ranunculaceae] 20171 Vv 11552 Russian Federation (Caucasus, west) 11552 Delphinium queneri Davis [Ranunculaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Dendranthema sinuatum (Ledeb.) Tsveley [Compositae] 5942 I 5942 Russia (Siberia) - Altai 5942 I 5942 Russia (Siberia) - Tuva 5942 Deschampsia turczaninowii Lity. [Gramineae] 5942 I 5942 Russia (Siberia) - Irkutsk (L. Baikal) 5942 Dianthus andronakii Woron. ex Schischk. [Caryophyllaceae] 12840 I 12840 Turkey 12840 Dianthus brevicaulis Fenzl var. setaceus Reeve [Caryophyllaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Single country endemic globally threatened plants : Caryophyllaceae: Dianthus R Dianthus cibrarius Clem. [Caryophyllaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 R Dianthus eldivenus Czecz. [Caryophyllaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 R Dianthus elegans Urv. var. actinopetalus (Fenzl) Reeve [Caryophyllaceae] /2840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 R Dianthus engleri Hausskn. & Bornm. [Caryophyllaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 R Dianthus eretmopetalus Stapf [Caryophyllaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 R Dianthus erinaceus Boiss. [Caryophyllaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 R Dianthus goerkii Hartvig & Strid [Caryophyllaceae] /2840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 I Dianthus hypanicus Andrz. [Caryophyllaceae] 5942, 20171 I 5942 Ukraine (west) 5942 R Dianthus lanceolatus Steven ex Rchb. [Caryophyllaceae] 8000, 20171 R former European USSR 8000 R Dianthus muschianus Kotschy & Boiss. [Caryophyllaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 R Dianthus recognitus Schischk. [Caryophyllaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 R Dianthus robustus Boiss. & Kotschy [Caryophyllaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 R Dianthus sessiliflorus Boiss. [Caryophyllaceae] /2840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 R Dianthus zederbaueri Vierh. [Caryophyllaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 R Dionysia teucroides Davis & Wendelbo [Primulaceae] /2840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 I Dioscorea caucasica Lipsky [Dioscoreaceae] 5942 I 5942 Georgia 5942 Vv Dipsacus cephalarioides Matthews & Kupicha [Dipsacaceae] 1/2840 v 12840 Turkey 12840 R Doronicum balansae Cavill. [Compositae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 R Doronicum bithynicum Edmondson [Compositae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 R Doronicum cacaliifolium Boiss. & Heldr. [Compositae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 R Doronicum haussknechtii Cavill. [Compositae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 R Doronicum macrolepis Freyn & Sint. [Compositae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 R Doronicum reticulatum Boiss. [Compositae] 12840 -20- Y=] v=] yx FF FF FR RF FR BR R 12840 Turkey 12840 Doronicum tobeyi J.R. Edmondson [Compositae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Dorycnium amani Zohary [Leguminosae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Dorycnium axilliflorum Huber-Mor. [Leguminosae] /2840 R= 12840 Turkey 12840 Dorycnium sanguineum Vural [Leguminosae] 12840 Vv 12840 Turkey 12840 Dorystaechas hastata Boiss. et Heldr ex Bentham [Labiatae] 20618 R 20618 Turkey 19873 Draba acaulis Boiss. [Cruciferae] 12840 R = 12840 Turkey 12840 Draba bruniifolia Stey. ssp. armeniaca Coode & Cullen [Cruciferae] 1/2840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Draba cuspidata M.Bieb. [Cruciferae] 20171 R former European USSR Draba elegans Boiss. [Cruciferae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Draba thylacocarpa (Nab.) Hedge [Cruciferae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Ebenus barbigera Boiss. [Leguminosae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Ebenus boissieri Barber [Leguminosae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Ebenus bourgaei Boiss. [Leguminosae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Ebenus cappadocica Hausskn. & Siehe ex Bornm. [Leguminosae] /2840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Ebenus depressa Boiss. & Bal. [Leguminosae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Ebenus haussknechtii Bornm. ex Huber-Mor. [Leguminosae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Ebenus laguroides Boiss. var. cilicica (Boiss.) Bornm. [Leguminosae] /2840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Ebenus longipes Boiss. & Bal. [Leguminosae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Ebenus pisidica Huber-Mor. & Reese [Leguminosae] /2840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Ebenus plumosus Boiss. & Bal. [Leguminosae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Ebenus reesei Huber-Mor. [Leguminosae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Echinophora carvifolia Boiss. & Bal. [Umbelliferae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Echinophora chrysantha Freyn & Sint. [Umbelliferae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Echinophora tirchophylla J.£. Smith [Umbelliferae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 single country endemic globally threatened plants /Umbelliferae: Echinophora R Echinops emiliae O. Schwarz ex Davis [Compositae] /2840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 t Echinops melitenensis Hedge & Hub.-Mor. [Compositae] /2840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 t Echinops onopordum Davis [Compositae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 t Echinops pungens Trautv. var. adenoclados Hedge [Compositae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 t Echinops vaginatus Boiss. & Hausskn. [Compositae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Edraianthus owerinianus Rupr. [Campanulaceae] 5942 I 5942 Russia - North Caucasus 5942 Elymus clivorum Melderis [Gramineae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Elymus erosiglumis Melderis [Gramineae] 12840 R =: 12840 Turkey 12840 Elymus lazicus (Boiss.) Melderis ssp. lazicus [Gramineae] /2840 R = 12840 Turkey 12840 Elymus longearistatus (Boiss.) Tzvelev ssp. Sintenisii Melderis [Gramineae] 12840 R =: 12840 Turkey 12840 Elymus nodosus (Nevski) Melderis ssp. gypsecolus Melderis [Gramineae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Elymus nodosus (Nevski) Melderis ssp. platyphyllus Melderis [Gramineae] /2840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Elymus sosnowskyi (Hackel) Melderis [Gramineae] 12840 R =: 12840 Turkey 12840 Epilobium tundrarum Sam. [Onagraceae] 20171 R former European USSR (Arctic) Eragrostis diarrhena (Schult. & Schult.f.) Steud. [Gramineae] 20/71 R former European USSR Eremogone cephalotes (M. Bieb.) Fenzl [Caryophyllaceae] 5942 I 5942 Ukraine 5942 Eremopoa attalica H. Scholz [Gramineae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Eremopoa mardinensis R. Mill [Gramineae] 12840 V = 12840 Turkey 12840 Eremosparton aphyllum (Pall.) Fisch. & C.A.Mey. [Leguminosae] 8000, 20171 Vv 11552 Russian Federation (Caucasus, west) 11552 Eremostachys pulchra Popov {Labiatae] R former USSR 6930 Erica bocquetii (H. Pesmen) P.F. Stevens [Ericaceae] 1/2840 R= 20618 Turkey 20618 Eriosynaphe longifolia (Fisch. ex Spreng.) DC. [Umbelliferae] 11552, 20171 Vv 11552 Russian Federation (western) 1/552 -21- = Fer a Pa Sk oti Se i ie pe A SR Aon x wm Erodium beketowii Schmalh. [Geraniaceae] 20171 E 20655 Ukraine (south-east) 20649 Erodium cedrorum Schott & Kotschy s.1. [Geraniaceae] 1/2840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Erodium hakkiaricum Davis [Geraniaceae] 12340 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Erodium leucanthum Boiss. [Geraniaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Erodium micropetalutum Boiss. & Hausskn. ex Boiss. [Geraniaceae] /2840 R = 12840 Turkey 12840 Erodium pelargoniiflorum Boiss. & Heldr. [Geraniaceae] 1/2840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Erodium sibthorpianum Boiss. ssp. sibthorpianum [Geraniaceae] /2840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Erodium somanum Pesmen [Geraniaceae] 12840 Vs: 12840 Turkey 12840 Erodium stevenii M. Bieb. [Geraniaceae] 5942 R 11552 Russia - North Caucasus 5942 Eryngium bornmuelleri Nab. (Umbelliferae] 12840 R = 12840 Turkey 12840 Eryngium ilex Davis [Umbelliferae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Eryngium isauricum Contandr. ex Quezel [Umbelliferae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Eryngium pseudothoriifolium Contandr. ex Quezel [Umbelliferae] 12840 Vs 12840 Turkey 12840 Eryngium thorifolium Boiss. (Umbelliferae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Erysimum amasianum Hausskn. & Bornm. [Cruciferae] 12840 I 12840 Turkey 12840 Erysimum caricum Boiss. [Cruciferae] 12840 R = 12840 Turkey 12840 Erysimum deflexum Cullen [Cruciferae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Erysimum degenianum Aznav. [Cruciferae] 12840 Vv 19873 Turkey 12840 Erysimum echinellum Hand.-Mazz. [Cruciferae] 12840 R = 12840 Turkey 12840 Erysimum leptocarpum Gay [Cruciferae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Erysimum leptostylum DC. [Cruciferae] 20171 R former European USSR Erysimum pallidum Boiss. [Cruciferae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Erysimum torulosum Hub.-Mor. [Cruciferae] 12840 Vv 12840 Turkey 12840 Erysimum ucranicum J.Gay [Cruciferae] 20171 R former European USSR Euonymus latifolius (L.) Miller ssp. cauconis Coode & Cullen [Celastraceae] 12840 R 20618 Turkey 20618 Euphorbia anacampseros Boiss. var. tmolea M.S. Single country endemic globally threatened plants : Euphorbiaceae: Euphorbia Ae en ee ie Khan [Euphorbiaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Euphorbia aristata Schmalh. [Euphorbiaceae] 5942 I 5942 Russia - North Caucasus 5942 Euphorbia austroanatolica Hub.-Mor. & M.S. Khan [Euphorbiaceae] /2840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Euphorbia davisii M.S. Khan [Euphorbiaceae] 12840 R= 12840 Turkey 12840 Euphorbia isaurica M.S. Khan [Euphorbiaceae] 12340 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Euphorbia pestalozzae Boiss. [Euphorbiaceae] 12840 R 17672 Turkey 12840 Euphorbia petrophila C.A. Meyer var. armena Boiss. [Euphorbiaceae] /2840 R 17672 Turkey 12840 Euphorbia pisidica Hub.-Mor. & M.S. Khan [Euphorbiaceae] /2840 R 17672 Turkey 12840 Euphorbia rhytidosperma Boiss. & Bal. [Euphorbiaceae] /2840 R 17672 Turkey 12840 Euphorbia sanasunitensis Hand.-Mazz. [Euphorbiaceae] 12840 R 17672 Turkey 12840 Euphorbia sclerocyathium Korovin & Popoy [Euphorbiaceae] 17672 R 17672 former USSR 6930 Euphorbia yaroslavii Poljakov [Euphorbiaceae] 17672 R 17672 former USSR 6930 Euphorbia zhiguliensis Prokh. [Euphorbiaceae] 17672, 20171] R 11552 Russian Federation (western) 1/552 Ferula amanicola Huber-Mor. & Pesmen [Umbelliferae] 1/2840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Ferula drudeana Korovin [Umbelliferae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Ferula glaberrima Korovin [Umbelliferae] R former USSR 6930 Ferula halophila 1. Pesmen (Umbelliferae] 12840 Vv 12840 Turkey 12840 Ferula huber-morathii H. Pesmen [Umbelliferae] 12840 Vv 12840 Turkey 12840 Ferula longipedunculata . Pesmen [Umbelliferae] 12840 Vv 12840 Turkey 12840 Ferula lycia Boiss. [Umbelliferae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Ferula moschata (Reinsch) Koso-Polj. [Umbelliferae] I former Asiatic USSR (Tien Shan) 6930 Ferula tenuissima Huber-Mor. & Pesmen [Umbelliferae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Ferulago antiochia Saya & Miski [Umbelliferae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Ferulago balancheana Post (Umbelliferae] 12840 v=] x7 FR R 19873 Turkey 12840 Ferulago bracteata Boiss. & Hausskn. [Umbelliferae] 12840 E 12840 Turkey 12840 Ferulago isaurica H. Pesman [Umbelliferae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Ferulago kurdica Post [Umbelliferae] 12840 E 12840 Turkey 12840 Ferulago latiloba Schischkin [Umbelliferae] 12340 R= 12840 Turkey 12840 Ferulago longistylis Boiss. [Umbelliferae] 12840 Vv 12840 Turkey 12840 Ferulago muglae H. Pesmen [(Umbelliferae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Ferulago pachyloba (Fenzl) Boiss. [Umbelliferae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Ferulago sandrasica H. Pesmen & Quezel [Umbelliferae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Ferulago silaifolia Boiss.) Boiss. [Umbelliferae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Festuca anatolica Markgr.-Dannenb. ssp. borealis Markgr.-Dannenb. [Gramineae] /2840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Festuca cappadocica (Hackel) Markgr.-Dannenb. [Gramineae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Festuca cataonica (Hackel ex Boiss.) Markgr.-Dan. [Gramineae] /2840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Festuca cratericola Markgr.-Dannenb. [Gramineae] 1/2840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Festuca cyllenica Boiss. & Heldr. ssp. uluana Markgr.-Dannenb. [Gramineae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Festuca decolorata Markgr.-Dannenb. [Gramineae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Festuca ilgazensis Markgr.-Dannenb. [Gramineae] 1/2840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Festuca lazistanica Alexeey [Gramineae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 - Festuca paphlagonica (St.-Yves) Markgr.-Dannenb. ssp. paphlagonica [Gramineae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Festuca pirinica Horvat ex Markgr.-Dann. [Gramineae] 5204, 20171 R 5204 Bulgaria (south) 5204 Festuca pontica (E. Alekseev) Markgr.-Dannenb. [Gramineae] /2840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Festuca puctoria Sm. [Gramineae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Festuca rubra L. ssp. pseudorivularis Markgr.-Dannenb. [Gramineae] 12840 ingle country endemic globally threatened plants Gramineae: Festuca R 12840 Turkey 12840 a Festuca woronowii Hackel ssp. argaea Markgr.-Dannenb. [Gramineae] /2840 R =: 12840 Turkey 12840 tq Festuca xenophontis Markgr.-Dannenb. [Gramineae] 1/2840 R = -12840 Turkey 12840 at Festuca ziganensis Markgr.-Dannenb. [Gramineae] /2840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Flueggea anatolica Gemici [Euphorbiaceae] 20698 E 20698 Turkey 20698 t Fritillaria acmopetala Boiss. ssp. wendelboi Rix [Liliaceae] /2840 R = 12840 Turkey 12840 Fritillaria alburyana Rix [Liliaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Fritillaria alfredae Post ssp. glaucoviridis (Turrill) Rix [Liliaceae] 1/2840 R = 12840 Turkey 12840 Fritillaria assyriaca Baker ssp. melananthera Rix [Liliaceae] /2840 R= 12840 Turkey 12840 Fritillaria aurea Schott [Liliaceae] 12840 R= 12840 Turkey 12840 Fritillaria carica Rix ssp. serpenticola Rix [Liliaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Fritillaria fleischeriana Steud. & Hoch. ex Sch.& Sch.f. [Liliaceae] 12840 R = 12840 Turkey 12840 Fritillaria forbesti Baker [Liliaceae] 12840 R= 12840 Turkey 12840 Fritillaria michailovskyi Fomin [Liliaceae] 12840 V =: 12840 Turkey 12840 Fritillaria minima Rix [Liliaceae] 12840 R = 12840 Turkey 12840 Fritillaria pontica Wahlenb. [Liliaceae] 5204, 20171 R 5204 Bulgaria 5204 Fritillaria sibthorpiana auct. balcan., non (Sibth. & Sm.) Baker [Liliaceae] 12840, 20171 R = 12840 Turkey 12840 Fritillaria viridiflora Post {Liliaceae] 12840 I 12840 Turkey 12840 Fritillaria whittallii Baker [Liliaceae] 12840 R = 12840 Turkey 12840 Froriepia gracillima Leute [Umbelliferae] 12840 R= 12840 Turkey 12840 Fumana trisperma Huber-Mor. & Reese [Cistaceae] 12840 R =. 20618 Turkey 20618 Gagea tenuissima Miscz. [Liliaceae] 12840 V =: 12840 Turkey 12840 mu Galanthus elwesii Hook.f. [Amaryllidaceae] 20171 I 5942 Ukraine 5942 Galanthus nivalis L. ssp. cilicicus (Baker) Gottl.-Tann. [Amaryllidaceae] 2/389, 17665 I 17664 Turkey (South west) 17665 -23- u Galanthus plicatus M. Bieb. ssp. byzantinus (Baker) D.A. Webb [Amaryllidaceae] 12840 Vv 12840 Turkey 12840 Galatella saxatilis Novopokr. [Compositae] 8001 R former USSR (Tien Shan) 6930 Galium angustissimum (Hausskn. & Bornm.) Ehrend. [Rubiaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Galium antitaurica Ehrend. [Rubiaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Galium aretioides Boiss. [Rubiaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Galium basalticum Ehrend. & Schonb.-Tem. [Rubiaceae] /2840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Galium baytopianum Ehrend. & Schonb.-Tem. [Rubiaceae] 1/2840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Galium bornmuelleri Hausskn. ex Bornm. [Rubiaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Galium campanelliferum Ehrend. & Schonb.-Tem. [Rubiaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Galium canum Reg. ex DC. ssp. antalyense Ehrend. [Rubiaceae] /2840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Galium ceratocarpon Boiss. [Rubiaceae] 12840 R= 12840 Turkey 12840 Galium cornigerum Boiss. & Hausskn. [Rubiaceae] 1/2840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Galium diechii Bornm. [Rubiaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Galium exsurgens Ehrend. & Schonb.-Tem. [Rubiaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Galium galiopsis (Hand.-Mazz.) Ehrend [Rubiaceae] /2840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Galium globuliferum Huber-Mor. & Reese [Rubiaceae] 12840 v 12840 Turkey 12840 Galium huber-morathii Ebrend. & Schonb.-Tem. [Rubiaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Galium hypoxylon Ebrend. & Schonb.-Tem [Rubiaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Galium isauricum Ehrend. & Schonb.-Tem. [Rubiaceae] /2840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Galium lasiocarpum Boiss. [Rubiaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Galium membranaceum Ehrend. [Rubiaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Galium olympicum auct. ital., non Boiss. [Rubiaceae] 12840, 20171 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Single country endemic globally threatened plants : Rubiaceae: Galium R Galium pamphylicum Boiss. & Heldr. [Rubiaceae] /2840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 R Galium papilliferum Ehrend. & Schonb.-Tem. [Rubiaceae] /2840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 R Galium parvulum Hub.-Mor. ex Ehre. & Scho.-Tem [Rubiaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 R Galium pseudocapitatum Hub.-Mor. ex Ehrend. & Schonb. [Rubiaceae] /2840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 R Galium pterocarpum Ehbrend. [Rubiaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 R Galium runcinatum Ehrend. & Schonb.-Tem. [Rubiaceae] /2840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 R Galium scopulorum Schonb.-Tem. [Rubiaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 R Galium setuliferum Ehrend. & Schonb.-Tem. [Rubiaceae] /2840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 R Galium siehanum Ehbrand. [Rubiaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 R Galium sorgerae Ehrend. & Schonb.-Tem [Rubiaceae] /2840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Vv Galium stojanovii Degen [Rubiaceae] 8000, 20171 Vv 5204 Bulgaria (south-west) 5204 R Galium tmoleum Boiss. [Rubiaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 R Galium tolosianum Boiss. & Kotschy [Rubiaceae] /2840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 R Galium tortumense Ehbrend. & Schonb.-Tem. [Rubiaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Galium tubiflorumg Ehrend. [Rubiaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Galium zabense Ehrend. [Rubiaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Genista burdurensis P. Gibb [Leguminosae] 12840 R 20618 Turkey 20618 Ex/E_ Genista libanotica Boiss. [Leguminosae] 20618 Ex/E 20689 Turkey 20618 R R Galium xylorrhizum Boiss. & Huet [Rubiaceae] 12840 R R R Genista lipskyii Novopokr. & Schischkin [Leguminosae] R former USSR 6930 R Genista lydia Boiss. var. antiochia [Leguminosae] 20618 R 20618 Turkey 20618 R Genista sandrasica Hartvig & Strid [Leguminosae] /2840 R 20618 Turkey 20618 I Genista tanaitica P.A.Smirn. [Leguminosae] 8001, 20171 I 5942 Ukraine 5942 -24- Genista tetragona Besser [Leguminosae] 5942, 20171 E 20655 Ukraine (southern) 20653 Gentiana boissierii Scott & Kotschy ex Boiss. [Gentianaceae] /2840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Gentiana dschungarica Regel [Gentianaceae] 10260 R former USSR (Turkestan) 6930 Geranium cinereum Cav var. elatius Davis [Geraniaceae] /2840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Geranium cinereum Cav var. palmatipartitum Hausskn. ex Knuth [Geraniaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Geranium cinereum Cav var. pisidicum Pesmen & Guner [Geraniaceae] 1/2840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Geranium cinereum Cay var. ponticum Davis & Roberts [Geraniaceae] /2840 : R 12840 Turkey 12840 Geranium davisianum Pesmen & Guner [Geraniaceae] /2840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Geranium eginense Hausskn. & Sint ex Knuth [Geraniaceae] 1/2840 " R 12840 Turkey 12840 Geranium glaberrimum Boiss. & Heldr. [Geraniaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Geranium platipetalum Fisch. & Mey. var. albipetalum Erik & Demirkus [Geraniaceae] 12840 i R 12840 Turkey 12840 fi Gladiolus humilis Stapf [Iridaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Gladiolus micranthus Stapf [Iridaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Glaucium acutidentatum Hausskn. & Bornm. Hi [Papaveraceae] /2840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Glaucium cappadocicum Boiss. [Papaveraceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 i Glaucium grandiflorum Boiss. & Huet var. turquatum Cullen [Papaveraceae] 1/2840 } Vv 12840 Turkey 12840 Globularia davisiana O. Schwarz [Globulariaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Globularia dumulosa O. Schwarz [Globulariaceae] /2840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Glycyrrhiza iconica Hub.-Mor [Leguminosae] 1778] E 17781 Turkey 17781 Glycyrrhiza korshinskyi Grig. [Leguminosae] 3000, 20171 R 11552 Russian Federation (western, western Siberia) 11552 Gnaphalium leucopilinum Schott & Kotschy ex Boiss. [Compositae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Goniolimon graminifolium (Aiton) Boiss. [Plumbaginaceae] 20171 ingle country endemic globally threatened plants Plumbaginaceae: Goniolimon Vv former European USSR Gonocytisus dirmilensis Huber-Mor. [Leguminosae] /2840 R 20618 Turkey 20618 Graellsia davisiana Poilter [Cruciferae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Grammosciadium confertum Huber-Mor. & Lamond (Umbelliferae] /2840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Gymnospermium odessanum (DC.) Takht. [Berberidaceae] 5942 I 5942 Ukraine 5942 Gymnospermium smirnowii (Trautv.) Takht. [Berberidaceae] 5942 I 5942 Ukraine 5942 Gypsophila adenophylla Bark. [Caryophyllaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Gypsophila aucheri Boiss. [Caryophyllaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Gypsophila baytopiorum Kit Tan [Caryophyllaceae] /2840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Gypsophila bitlisensis Bark. [Caryophyllaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Gypsophila brachypetala Trautv. [Caryophyllaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Gypsophila briquetiana Schischk. [Caryophyllaceae] /2840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Gypsophila confertifolia Huber-Mor. [Caryophyllaceae] /2840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Gypsophila curvifolia Fenzl [Caryophyllaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Gypsophila davisii Bark. [Caryophyllaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Gypsophila festucifolia Huber-Mor. [Caryophyllaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Gypsophila germanicapolitana Huber-Mor. [Caryophyllaceae] 12840 Vv 12840 Turkey 12840 Gypsophila glomerata auct., non Pall. ex Adams [Caryophyllaceae] 12840, 20171 R = 12840 Turkey 12840 Gypsophila graminifolia Bark. [Caryophyllaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Gypsophila hakkiarica Kit Tan [Caryophyllaceae] 12840 R= 12840 Turkey 12840 Gypsophila heteropoda Freyn & Sint. ssp. minutiflora Bark. [Caryophyllaceae] 12840 I 12840 Turkey 12840 Gypsophila lepidioides Boiss. [Caryophyllaceae] 12840 -25- I 12840 Turkey 12840 Gypsophila leucochlaena Huber-Mor. [Caryophyllaceae] 1/2840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Gypsophila nodiflora (Boiss.) Bark. [Caryophyllaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Gypsophila oblanceolata Bark. [Caryophyllaceae] /2840 Vv 12840 Turkey 12840 Gypsophila paniculata L. var. araratica Huber-Mor. [Caryophyllaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Gypsophila parva Bark. [Caryophyllaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Gypsophila perfiolata L. var. araratica Kit Tan [Caryophyllaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Gypsophila peshmenii A. Guner [Caryophyllaceae] 1/2840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Gypsophila pilulifera Boiss. & Heldr. [Caryophyllaceae] /2840 Vv 12840 Turkey 12840 Gypsophila pinifolia Boiss. & Hausskn. [Caryophyllaceae] /2840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Gypsophila simonii Huber-Mor. [Caryophyllaceae] 12840 Vv 12840 Turkey 12840 Gypsophila simulatrix Bornm. & Woron. [Caryophyllaceae] /2840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Gypsophila sphaerocephala Fenzl ex Tchihat. var. Syriaca (Sch.) Huber-Mor. [Caryophyllaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Gypsophila tuberculosa Huber-Mor. [Caryophyllaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Gypsophila uralensis Less. ssp. pinegensis (Perf.) R. Kam. [Caryophyllaceae] 800/ R 11552 Russian Federation (north western) 11552 Haberlea rhodopensis Friv. [Gesneriaceae] 5204, 20171 R 5204 Bulgaria (central & south) 5204 Halosciastrum melanotilingia Boiss.) Pim.& Tikhom. [Umbelliferae] I 5942 Russia (Far East) - Primorye 5942 Haplophyllum cappadocicum Spach [Rutaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Haplophyllum megalanthum Bornm. [Rutaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Haplophyllum pumiliforme Huber-Mor. & Reese [Rutaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Haplophylium suaveolens (DC.) G. Don var. cilicicum (Boiss.) C.C. Townsend [Rutaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Haplophyllum vulcanicum Boiss. & Heldr. Single country endemic globally threatened plants : Rutaceae: Haplophyllum Locate tt eet ee Mere b) Hiei col at he st aN Nees) [Rutaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Hedysarum antitauricum Wuber-Mor. & Yurdakulol [Leguminosae] /2840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Hedysarum aucheri Boiss. [Leguminosae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Hedysarum candidissimum Freyn [Leguminosae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Hedysarum cretaceum Fisch. [Leguminosae] 8000, 20171 R 11552 Russian Federation (south western) 11552 Hedysarum laxum Boiss. [Leguminosae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Hedysarum pycnostachyum Hedge & Huber-Mor. [Leguminosae] 12840 Vv 12840 Turkey 12840 Hedysarum rotundifolium Boiss. & Noe [Leguminosae] 1/2840 v 12840 Turkey 12840 Hedysarum ucrainicum Kaschm. [Leguminosae] 8000, 20171 R 11552 Russian Federation (western) 1/552 Hedysarum vanense Hedge & Huber-Mor. [Leguminosae] 1/2840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Hedysarum zundukii Pesch. [Leguminosae] 5942 I 5942 Russia (Siberia) - Irkutsk 5942 Heldreichia atalayi Kit Tan [Cruciferae] 12840 Vv 12840 Turkey 12840 Heldreichia bourgaei Boiss. [Cruciferae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Helianthemum antitauricum Davis et Coode [Cistaceae] 19873 R = _.20618 Turkey 20618 Helichrysum artvinense Davis & Kupicha [Compositae] 12840 R = 12840 Turkey 12840 Helichrysum chasmolycicum Davis [Compositae] 12840 Vv 12840 Turkey 12840 Helichrysum compactum Boiss. [Compositae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Helichrysum heywoodianum Davis [Compositae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Helichrysum peshmenianum Erik [Compositae] 12840 E 12840 Turkey 12840 Helictotrichon pubescens (Hudson) Besser ex Schult. & Sch.f ssp. longifolia (Boiss.) M. Dogan [Gramineae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Heliotropium ferrugineogriseum Nab. [Boraginaceae] 1/2840 I 12840 Turkey 12840 Heliotropium haussknechtii Bunge [Boraginaceae] 1/2840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Helleborus vesicarius Auch. [Ranunculaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Heptaptera cilicica (Boiss. & Bal.) Tutin -26- a ee A FF F F FF FF FF KF BR tc] a 7A RF FR ih} [Umbelliferae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Heracleum argaeum Boiss. & Bal. [Umbelliferae] 12840 R =: 12840 Turkey 12840 Heracleum ligusticifolium M.Bieb. [Umbelliferae] 20/71 R former European USSR Heracleum paphlagonicum Czecz. (Umbelliferae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Heracleum pastinaca Fenzl (Umbelliferae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Heracleum pesmenianum Ekim [Umbelliferae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Heracleum pubescens (Hoffm.) M.Bieb. [Umbelliferae] 20171 I former European USSR Heracleum sphondylium L. ssp. artvinense (Manden.) Davis [Umbelliferae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Herniaria olympica J.Gay [Ilecebraceae] 12840, 20171 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Herniaria pisidica Brumm. [lllecebraceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Herniaria saxatilis Brumm. [IMlecebraceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Hesperis aintabica Post [Cruciferae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Hesperis bottae Fourn. [Cruciferae] 12840 ¥ R 12840 Turkey 12840 Hesperis breviscapa Boiss. [Cruciferae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Hesperis campicarpa Boiss. [Cruciferae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Hesperis hedgei Davis [Cruciferae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Hesperis kitiana Davis [Cruciferae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Hesperis matronalis L. ssp. cilicica (Siehe ex “6 Bornm.) Cullen [Cruciferae] 12840 M, R 12840 Turkey 12840 i * Hesperis pisidica Hub.-Mor. [Cruciferae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Hesperis schischkinii Tzvelev [Cruciferae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Hesperis stellata Dvorak [Cruciferae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Hulthemosa guzarica Suzepczuk [Rosaceae] E former USSR 6930 Hyacinthella acutiloba XK. Pearson & Wendolbo f [Hyacinthaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Hyacinthella campanulata K. Persson & Wendolbo [Hyacinthaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 & Hyacinthella glabrescens Boiss.) K. Persson & Wendolbo [Hyacinthaceae] 12840 : R 12840 Turkey 12840 - 4 4 bingle country endemic globally threatened plants t ad aod Ll edl rv | il Land Hyacinthaceae: Hyacinthella Hyacinthella hispida (J. Gay) Chouard [Hyacinthaceae] /2840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Hyacinthella micrantha (Boiss.) Chouard [Hyacinthaceae] 12840 R = 12840 Turkey 12840 Hyacinthella pallasiana (Steven) Losinsk. [Hyacinthaceae] 8000, 20171 I former European USSR 8000 Hyacinthella siirtensis Matthew [Hyacinthaceae] /2840 R —:12840 Turkey 12840 Hyacinthus orientalis L. ssp. chionophilus Wendelbo [Hyacinthaceae] 12840 Vv 12840 Turkey 12840 Hypericum aviculariifolium Jaub. & Spach ssp. byzantinum (Azn.) Robson [Guttiferae] 12840, 20171 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Hypericum aviculariifolium Jaub. & Spach ssp. byzantium (Azn.) Robson [Guttiferae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Hypericum aviculariifolium Jaub. & Spach ssp. uniflorum (Boiss. & Heldr.) Robson [Guttiferae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Hypericum capitatum Choisy var. capitatum [Guttiferae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Hypericum crenulatum Boiss. [Guttiferae] 12840 R = 12840 Turkey 12840 Hypericum fissurale Woron [Guttiferae] 12840 R = 12840 Turkey 12840 Hypericum huber-morathii Robson [Guttiferae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Hypericum imbricatum Poulter [Guttiferae] 12840 V =: 12840 Turkey 12840 Hypericum kotschyanum Boiss. [Guttiferae] 12840 R =: 12840 Turkey 12840 Hypericum lanuginosum Lam. var. pestalozzae (Boiss.) Robson [Guttiferae] 12840 Vv 12840 Turkey 12840 Hypericum malatyanum Pesmen [Guttiferae] 12840 R = 12840 Turkey 12840 Hypericum marginatum Woron [Guttiferae] 12840 R= 12840 Turkey 12840 Hypericum minutum Davis & Poulter [Guttiferae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Hypericum monodenum Robson apud Poulter [Guttiferae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Hypericum neurocalycinum Boiss. & Heldr. [Guttiferae] 12840 R = 12840 Turkey 12840 Hypericum olympicum L. ssp. auriculatum Robson & Huber-Mor. [Guttiferae] /2840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Hypericum pamphylicum Robson & Davis [Guttiferae] 12840 , R= 12840 Turkey 12840 -27- x Fe FR FR =) x PF ®R SN ee Se ee Hypericum polyphyllum Boiss. & Bal. ssp. lycium Robson & Hub.-Mor. [Guttiferae] /2840 Vv 12840 Turkey 12840 Hypericum polyphyllum Boiss. & Bal. ssp. polyphyllum [Guttiferae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Hypericum pumilio Bornm. [Guttiferae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Hypericum salsolifolius Hand.-Mazz. [Guttiferae] /2840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Hypericum salsugineum Robson & Hub.-Mor [Guttiferae] /2840 V_—s:14197 Turkey 12840 Hypericum saxifragum Robson & Hub.-Mor [Guttiferae] /2840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Hypericum scabroides Robson & Poulter [Guttiferae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Hypericum sorgerae Robson [Guttiferae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Hypericum strictum Maleev [Guttiferae] R former European USSR (Caucasus) 6930 Hypericum ternatum Poulter [Guttiferae] 12840 R 20618 Turkey 20618 Hypericum thymbrifolium Boiss. & Noe [Guttiferae] 12840 R = 2840 Turkey 12840 Hypericum thymopsis Boiss. [Guttiferae] 12340 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Hypericum uniglandulosum Hausskn. & Bornm. [Guttiferae] 1/2840 R = 12840 Turkey 12840 Hypericum vacciniifolium Hayek & Siehe [Guttiferae] 12840 R =. 20618 Turkey 20618 Hyssopus cretaceus Dubj. [Labiatae] 5942, 20171 E 20655 Ukraine 5942 Iberis carica Bornm. [Cruciferae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Inula fragilis Boiss. & Hausskn. [Compositae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Inula helenium L. ssp. vanensis Grierson [Compositae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Inula macrocephala Boiss. & Kotschy ex Boiss. [Compositae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Inula sarana Boiss. [Compositae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Inula sechmenii Hardvig & Strid [Compositae] 12340 Vv 12840 Turkey 12840 Tris histrioides (Wilson) Arnott [Iridaceae] 12840 R= 12840 Turkey 12840 Iris junonia Schott & Kotschy ex Schott [Iridaceae] 12840 Vv 12840 Turkey 12840 Iris kolpakowskiana Regel [Iridaceae] Single country endemic globally threatened plants : Iridaceae: Iris R former USSR 6930 R Iris nectarifera A. Guner [Iridaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 R Tris pamphylica Hedge [Iridaceae] 12840 R 19174 Turkey 12840 V Tris paradoxa Steven [Iridaceae] V former USSR (Caucasus) 6930 R Tris purpureobractea B. Mathew & T. Baytop [Iridaceae] /2840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 I Tris schelkownikwii (Fomin) Fomin [Iridaceae] I former USSR 6930 Vv Iris sprengeri Siehe [Iridaceae] 3619 Vv 19873 Turkey 8619 Vv Tris stenophylla Hausskn. & Siehe ex Baker ssp. allisonii B. Mathew [Iridaceae] 12840 Vv 19873 Turkey 12840 E Tris susiana L. [lIridaceae] 8934 E Turkey 8934 Iris taochia Woronow ex Grossh. [Iridaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Tris timofejewii Woronow [Iridaceae] 11552 Vv 11552 Russian Federation (Caucasus) 1/552 Tris xanthospuria B. Mathew & T. Baytop [Iridaceae] 1/2840 Vv 12840 Turkey 12840 < < BB E Isatis arenaria Az. [Cruciferae] 12840, 20171 E 19174 Turkey 12840 Ex Isatis arnoldiana N. Busch. [Cruciferae] 6930 Ex 6930 former USSR 6930 Isatis aucheri Boiss. [Cruciferae] 12840 R 19174 Turkey 12840 Isatis bitlisica Davis [Cruciferae] 12840 R 19174 Turkey 12840 Isatis callifera Boiss. & Bal. [Cruciferae] 12840 R 19174 Turkey 12840 Isatis candolleana Boiss. [Cruciferae] 12840 R 19174 Turkey 12840 Isatis cappadocica Desv. ssp. alyssifolia (Boiss.) Davis [Cruciferae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 R Isatis cappadocica Desv. ssp. nurihakensis Davis [Cruciferae] /2840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 xa FF FR FR BR R Isatis constricta Davis [Cruciferae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 E Isatis davisiana Misirdali [Cruciferae] 12840 E 12840 Turkey 12840 Isatis demiriziana Misirdali [Cruciferae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Isatis erzurumica Davis [Cruciferae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Isatis frigida Boiss. & Kotschy [Cruciferae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Isatis huber-morathii Davis [Cruciferae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Isatis lockmanniana Kotschy & Boiss. [Cruciferae] 12840 x FF RF KF BR -28- x FF RF FR — zx 7 — R 19174 Turkey 12840 Isatis mardinensis Davis & Misirdali [Cruciferae] 12840 Vv 12840 Turkey 12840 Isatis pinnatiloba Davis [Cruciferae] 12840 E 19174 Turkey 12840 Isatis sivasica Davis [Cruciferae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Isatis spatella Davis [Cruciferae] 12840 R 19174 Turkey 12840 Isatis spectabilis Davis [Cruciferae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Isatis undulata Aucher ex Boiss. [Cruciferae] 12840 R 19873 Turkey 12840 Isoetes beringensis Komaroy [Isoetaceae] 5942 I 5942 Russia (Far East) - Kamchatka (Komandorskije) 5942 Jasione bulgarica Stoj. & Stef. [Campanulaceae] 19709, 20171 R 19709 Bulgaria 19709 Jasione heldreichii Boiss. & Orph var. papillosa , J. Parnel [Campanulaceae] /2840 E 12840 Turkey 12840 Jasione idaea Stoy. [Campanulaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Jasione supina Sieber ssp. akmanii Damboldt [Campanulaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Jasione supina Sieber ssp. supina [Campanulaceae] /2840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Jasione supina Sieber ssp. tmolea (Stoj.) Damboldt [Campanulaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Johrenia polyscias Bornm. [Umbelliferae] 12840 Vv 12840 Turkey 12840 Johrenia silenoides Boiss. & Bal. [Umbelliferae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Juncus arianus Krecz. [Juncaceae] I former USSR 6930 Jurinea brevicaulis Boiss. [Compositae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Jurinea elegantissima Dijin [Compositae] R former USSR 6930 Jurinea karatavica Njin [Compositae] I former USSR 6930 Jurinea lydiae Njin [Compositae] R former USSR 6930 Kalidiopsis wagenitzii Aellen [Chenopodiaceae] 12840 E 12840 Turkey 12840 Kitaibelia balansae Boiss. [Malvaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Knautia tatarica (L.) Szabé (Dipsacaceae] 20171 E former European USSR Kundmannia anatolica Huber-Mor. [Umbelliferae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 ingle country endemic globally threatened plants Umbelliferae: Kundmannia h Kundmannia syriaca Boiss. (Umbelliferae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Lactuca mira Pavlov [Compositae] 8001 R former Asiatic USSR (Tien Shan) 6930 ; Lagoseris purpurea Willd.) Boiss. [Compositae] 5942, 20171 E 20655 Ukraine - Crimea 5942 f Lagotis uralensis Schischk. [Scrophulariaceae] 20/7/ R former European USSR Lamium armenum Boiss. ssp. sintenisii R. Mill. [Labiatae] /2840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Lamium cymbalariifolium Boiss. (Labiatae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Lamium eriocephalum Bentham [Labiatae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Mill [Labiatae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Lamium garganicum L. ssp. pulchrum R. Mill. [Labiatae] /2840 R = 12840 Turkey 12840 Lamium glandulosidens Hub.-Mor. [Labiatae] 12840 R = _12840 Turkey 12840 Lamium lycium Boiss. [{Labiatae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Lamium microphyllum Boiss. (Labiatae] 12840 R = 12840 Turkey 12840 Lamium pisidicum R. Mill [Labiatae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Lamium purpureum L. var. aznavourii Gand. ex Aznay. [Labiatae] 1/2840 E 12840 Turkey 12840 Lamium sandrasicum Davis [Labiatae] 12840 R = 12840 Turkey 12840 Lamium sulphureum Hausskn. & Sint. ex R. Mill [Labiatae] 12840 R = 12840 Turkey 12840 Lamium tenuiflorum Fisch. & Mey. (Labiatae] 12840 R = 12840 Turkey 12840 Lamium veronicifolium Bentham [Labiatae] 12840 R= 12840 Turkey 12840 Lamyropsis lycia Kupicha [Compositae] 12840 R= 12840 Turkey 12840 Lappula echinophora (Pall.) Kuntze [Boraginaceae] 20171 R former European USSR Lappula glabrata Popov (Boraginaceae] R former USSR 6930 Laserpitium carduchorum Hedge & Lamond [Umbelliferae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Lathyrus bitlisicus Pesmen [Leguminosae] 12840 R= 12840 Turkey 12840 Lathyrus cilicicus Hayek & Siehe [Leguminosae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Lathyrus cyaneus (Stev.) Koch var. pinnatus Lamium garganicum L. ssp. nepetifolium (Boiss.) R. -29- Ex x we FR — Cae ee Davis [Leguminosae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Lathyrus dominianus Litv. [Leguminosae] 6930 Ex 6930 former USSR 6930 Lathyrus kersianus Davis [Leguminosae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Lathyrus layardii J. Ball ex Boiss. [Leguminosae] /2840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Lathyrus lycius Boiss. [Leguminosae] 12840 Vv 12840 Turkey 12840 Lathyrus phaselitanus Huber-Mor. & Davis [Leguminosae] /2840 Vv 12840 Turkey 12840 Lathyrus satdaghensis Davis [Leguminosae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Lathyrus stenolobus Boiss. [Leguminosae] 12340 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Lathyrus tauricola Davis [Leguminosae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Lathyrus trachycarpus (oiss.) Boiss. [Leguminosae] /2840 I 12840 Turkey 12840 Lathyrus undulatus Boiss. [Leguminosae] 12840, 20171 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Ledebouriella seseloides (Hoffmann) H. Wolff [Umbelliferae] I former USSR 6930 Lepidium caespitosum Desv. [Cruciferae] 12340 Vv 12840 Turkey 12840 Lepidium turczaninowii Lipsky [Cruciferae] 20654 R 20650 Ukraine - Crimea 8001 Leptopus colchicus (Fischer & C. Meyer) Pojark. [Euphorbiaceae] 5942 I 5942 Georgia 5942 Lilium carniolicum Bernh. ex W. Koch var. artvinense (Miscz.) Davis & Henderson [Liliaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Lilium caucasicum (Miscz. ex Grossh.) Grossh. [Liliaceae] 5942 I 5942 Russia - North Caucasus 5942 Lilium ciliatum Davis (Liliaceae] 12840 Vv 12840 Turkey 12840 Limoniopsis davisii BKokhari [Plumbaginaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Limonium anatolicum Hedge [Plumbaginaceae] 12840 Vv 12840 Turkey 12840 Limonium asterotrichum (C.E.Salmon) C.E.Salmon [Plumbaginaceae] 8000, 20171 Vv 5204 Bulgaria (central) 5204 Limonium effusum Boiss.) O. Kuntz [Plumbaginaceae] /2840 Vv 12840 Turkey 12840 Limonium iconicum (Boiss. & Heldr.) O. Kuntze [Plumbaginaceae] 12840 Vs 12840 Turkey 12840 Limonium lilacinum (Boiss. & Bal.) Wagenitz [Plumbaginaceae] 12840 Single country endemic globally threatened plants : Plumbaginaceae: Limonium Vv 12840 Turkey 12840 Limonium pycnanthum (C. Koch) O. Kuntze [Plumbaginaceae] /2840 I 12840 Turkey 12840 Limonium tamaricoides Bokhari [Plumbaginaceae] /2840 Vv 12840 Turkey 12840 Limonium vanense Kit Tan & Sorger [Plumbaginaceae] /2840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Linaria biebersteinii Besser [Scrophulariaceae] 20171 I former European USSR Linaria chalapensis (L.) Miller var. brevicalyx Davis [Scrophulariaceae] /2840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Linaria cretacea Fisch. ex Spreng. [Scrophulariaceae] 20/7] Vv former European USSR Linaria genistifolia (L.) Miller ssp. polyclada (Fenzl) Davis [Scrophulariaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Linaria kurdica Boiss. & Hohen ssp. eriocalyx (Boiss.) Davis [Scrophulariaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Lindelofia angustifolia (Schrenk) A. Brand. [Boraginaceae] 6930 Ex 6930 former USSR 6930 Linum anisocalyx Davis [Linaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Linum aretioides Boiss [Linaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Linum boissieri Asch. & Sint. ex Boiss. [Linaceae] 12840, 20171 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Linum ciliatum Hayek [Linaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Linum elegans Spruner ex Boiss. [Linaceae] 5204, 20171 R 5204 Bulgaria (south-west three sites) 5204 Linum empetrifolium (Boiss.) Davis [Linaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Linum hirsutum L. ssp. oreocaricum Davis [Linaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Linum hirsutum L. var. platyphyllum Davis [Linaceae] 1/2840 V —s:12840 Turkey 12840 Linum mucronatum Bertol var. gypsiocola [Linaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Linum mucronatum Bertol var. papilliferum (Huber-Mor. & Reese) Davis [Linaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Linum pamphylicum (Boiss.) Podp. [Linaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Linum pycnophullum Boiss. & Heldr. ssp. kurdicum Davis [Linaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Linum tauricum Willd. ssp. bosphori Davis [Linaceae] /2840 E 12840 Turkey 12840 Linum triflorum Davis [Linaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Liquidambar orientalis Miller var. integriloba Fiori [Hamamelidaceae] /2840 E 20618 Turkey 20618 Lonicera nummulariifolia Jaub. & Spach ssp. glandulifera (Huber-Mor.) Chamb. [Caprifoliaceae] 12840 R 20618 Turkey 20618 Lotus armeniacus Kit Tan & Sorger [Leguminosae] /2840 R =: 12840 Turkey 12840 Luzula deflexa Kozuharoy [Juncaceae] 5204, 20171 R 5204 ~Bulgaria (central & west) 5204 Malope anatolica Huber-Mor. [Malvaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Malus sylvestris Mill. var. microphylla Browicz [Rosaceae] /2840 Vv 12840 Turkey 12840 Marrubium bourgaei Boiss. [Labiatae] 12340 - R 12840 Turkey 12840 ‘ Marrubium globosum Montbret & Aucher ex Bentham ss micranthum (Boiss. & Heldr.) Davis [Labiatae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Marrubium vanense Hub.-Mor. [Labiatae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 , Marrubium vulcanicum Hub.-Mor. {Labiatae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 a Matthiola anchoniifolia Hub.-Mor. [Cruciferae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Medicago cancellata M.Bieb. [Leguminosae] 8000, 20171 Vv 11552 Russian Federation (Caucasus & west) 20628 Medicago rhodopea Velen. [Leguminosae] 5204, 20171 R 5204 += Bulgaria (mainly southern and eastern - eight sites) 5204 Medicago shepardii Post ex Boiss. [Leguminosae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Megacarpaea schugnanica B. Fedtsch. [Cruciferae] R former USSR 6930 Melampyrum arvense L. var. elatius Boiss. [Scrophulariaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Melandrium astrachanicum Pacz. [Caryophyllaceae} 5942, 20171 I 5942 Russia (E.Europe) - South (Astrakhan) 5942 Merendera rhodopaea Velen. [Colchicaceae] 5204, 20171 R 5204 Bulgaria (Souther Bulgaria - two sites.) 5204 Michauxia thyrsoidea Boiss. & Heldr. [Campanulaceae] /2840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 ; ingle country endemic globally threatened plants Campanulaceae: Michauxia anatolicum Wagenitz [Chenopodiaceae] 1778] E 17781 Turkey 17781 Micromeria carica Davis (Labiatae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Micromeria cilicica Hausskn. ex Davis [Labiatae] /2840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Micromeria cremnophila Boiss. & Heldr. ssp. amana (Rech.fil.) Davis [Labiatae] 12840 R = 12840 Turkey 12840 Micromeria cristata (Hampe) Griseb. ssp. carminea Davis [Labiatae] 12840 R = 12840 Turkey 12840 Micromeria cristata (Hampe) Griseb. ssp. orientalis Davis [Labiatae] /2840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Micromeria cristata (Hampe) Griseb. ssp. phrygia Davis [Labiatae] /2840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Micromeria cristata (Hampe) Griseb. ssp. xylorrhiza (Boiss. & Heldr.) Davis [Labiatae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Micromeria cymuligera Boiss. & Hausskn. [Labiatae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Micromeria dolichodonta Davis [Labiatae] 12840 R = 12840 Turkey 12840 Micromeria elliptica C. Koch. [Labiatae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Micromeria fruticosa (L.) Druce ssp. giresunica Davis [Labiatae] 12840 V = 12840 Turkey 12840 Micromeria serpyllifolia (M.Bieb.) Boiss. [Labiatae] 20171 R former European USSR (Crimea) 800/ Minuartia anatolica (Boiss.) Woron. var. lanuginosa McNeill [Caryophyllaceae] 12840 R = 12840 Turkey 12840 Minuartia anatolica Boiss.) Woron. var. phrygia (Bornm.) McNeill [Caryophyllaceae] 12840 R= 12840 Turkey 12840 Minuartia anatolica Boiss.) Woron var. scleranthoides (Boiss. & Noe) McNeill [Caryophyllaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Minuartia anatolica (Boiss.) Woron var. tetrastiche McNeill [Caryophyllaceae] 12840 R= 12840 Turkey 12840 Minuartia bilykiana Kiokov [Caryophyllaceae] 8000, 20171 I former European USSR 8000 Minuartia corymbulosa (Boiss. & Bal.) McNeill var. breviflora Boiss.) McNeill [Caryophyllaceae] 12840 E 12840 Turkey 12840 Minuartia corymbulosa (Boiss. & Bal.) McNeill var. gypsophiloides McNeill [Caryophyllaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Minuartia dianthifolia (Boiss.) Hand.-Mazz. ssp. cataonica McNeill [Caryophyllaceae] 12840 Microcnemum coralloides (Loscos et Parda) Font-Quer ssp. -31- R 12840 Turkey 12840 Minuartia dianthifolia (Boiss.) Hand.-Mazz. ssp. dianthifolia [Caryophyllaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Minuartia gracilis McNeill [Caryophyllaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Minuartia issaurica McNeill [Caryophyllaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Minuartia krascheninnikovii Schischk. [Caryophyllaceae] 8000, 20171 R 11552 Russian Federation (Ural Mts) 1/552 Minuartia mesogitana (Boiss.) Hand.-Mazz. ssp. lydia (Boiss.) McNeill [Caryophyllaceae] 1/2840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Minuartia mesogitana (Boiss.) Hand.-Mazz. ssp. macrocarpa McNeill [Caryophyllaceae] 12840 v 12840 Turkey 12840 Minuartia nifensis McNeill [Caryophyllaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Minuartia pestalozzae (Boiss.) Bornm. [Caryophyllaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Minuartia recurva (AU.) Schinz. & Thell. ssp. carica McNeill [Caryophyllaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Minuartia rimarum (Boiss. & Bal.) Mattf. var. multiflora McNeill [Caryophyllaceae] 12340 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Minuartia taurica (Steven) Graebn. [Caryophyllaceae] 8000, 20171 R former European USSR 8000 Minuartia umbellulifera (Boiss.) McNeill ssp. Sfimbriata McNeill [Caryophyllaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Minuartia umbellulifera (oiss.) McNeill var. kurdica McNeill [Caryophyllaceae] 12340 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Minuartia umbellulifera Boiss.) McNeill ssp. pontica (Bornm.) McNeill [Caryophyllaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Minuartia umbellulifera Boiss.) McNeill ssp. salbacica McNeill [Caryophyllaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Minuartia valedictionis McNeill [Caryophyllaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Minuartia verna (L.) Hiern ssp. brevipetala Hartvig & Strid [Caryophyllaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Moehringia hypanica Grynj & Klokoy [Caryophyllaceae] 5942, 20171 I 5942 Ukraine 5942 Morina persica L. ssp. decussatifolia Erik & Demirkus [Morinaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Morina subinervis Boiss. [Morinaceae] 12840 I 12840 Turkey 12840 Muretia aurea Boiss. [Umbelliferae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Single country endemic globally threatened plants : Umbelliferae: Muretia Vv Muscari discolor Boiss. & Hausskn. [Hyacinthaceae] /2840 Vv 12840 Turkey 12840 R Muscari latifolium Kirk [Hyacinthaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 R Muscari microstomum Davis & Stuart [Hyacinthaceae] /2840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Vv Muscari muscarimi Medik. [Hyacinthaceae] 12840, 20171 Vs: 12840 Turkey 12840 R Muscari sandrasicum Karlen [Hyacinthaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 R Myopordon thiebautii (Gently) Wagenitz [Compositae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 I Myosotis czekanowskii (Trauty.) Kamelin & V. Tikhom. [Boraginaceae] 5942 I 5942 Russia (Siberia) - Yakutiya (north) 5942 R Myosotis platyphylla Boiss. (Boraginaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 R Necranthus orobanchioides Gilli [Scrophulariaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 R Nectaroscordum meliophillum (Juz.) Stank. [Alliaceae] R former European USSR E Neogontscharovia mira (Lincz.) Lincz. [Plumbaginaceae] E former Asiatic USSR 6930 R Neogontscharovia miranda (Lincz.) Lincz. [Plumbaginaceae] R former Asiatic USSR 6930 Ex/En Neottia ussuriensis (Komarov & Nevski) Soo [Orchidaceae] 5942 Ex/E 5942 Russia (Far East) - Primorye (south) 5942 R Nepeta aristata Boiss. & Kotschy ex Boiss. [Labiatae] 1/2840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 R Nepeta baytopii Hedge & Lamond [Labiatae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Vv Nepeta conferta Hedge & Lamond [Labiatae] 12840 Vv 12840 Turkey 12840 R Nepeta crinita Montbret & Aucher ex Bentham [Labiatae}] /2840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 R Nepeta gontscharovii Kudrj. [Labiatae] R former USSR 6930 R Nepeta ladanolens Lipsky (Labiatae] R former USSR 6930 R Nepeta maussarifi Lipsky [Labiatae] R former USSR 6930 R Nepeta nadinae Lipsky [Labiatae] R former USSR 6930 Vv Nepeta nuda L. ssp. glandulifera Hub.-Mor. & Davis [Labiatae] 12840 Vs 12840 ‘Turkey 12840 R Nepeta nuda L. ssp. lydiae Davis -32- < 7 BF BR Aa FF RF RF BR [Labiatae] /2840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Nepeta obtusicrena Boiss. & Kotschy ex Hedge {Labiatae] /2840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Nepeta phyllochlamys Davis [Labiatae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Nepeta plinux Davis (Labiatae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Nepeta sorgerae Hedge & Lamond [Labiatae] 12340 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Nepeta sulfuriflora Davis [Labiatae] 12840 Vv 12840 Turkey 12840 Nigella arvensis L. var. oblanceolata Davis [Ranunculaceae] 12840 v 12840 Turkey 12840 Nigella lancifolia Huber-Mor. [Ranunculaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Nonea anomala Hausskn. & Bornm. [Boraginaceae] 12840 I 12840 Turkey 12840 Nonea karsensis M. Popov [Boraginaceae] 12340 I 12840 Turkey 12840 Nonea pulmonarioides Boiss. & Bal. [Boraginaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Olymposciadium caespitosum (Sm.) Wolff [Umbelliferae] 12840 Vv 12840 Turkey 12840 Omphalodes davisana Kit Tan & Sorger [Boraginaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Omphalodes ripleyana Davis [Boraginaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Onobrychis albiflora Huber-Mor. [Leguminosae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Onobrychis araxina Schis. [Leguminosae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Onobrychis argaea Boiss. & Bal. [Leguminosae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Onobrychis argyrea Boiss. ssp. isaurica Hedge & Huber-Mor. [Leguminosae] /2840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Onobrychis beata Sirj [Leguminosae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Onobrychis bornmuelleri Freyn [Leguminosae] 12840 Vv 12840 Turkey 12840 Onobrychis cilicica Kit Tan & Sorger [Leguminosae] 1/2840 Vv 12840 Turkey 12840 Onobrychis densijuga Hedge ex Huber-Mor. [Leguminosae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Onobrychis elata Boiss. & Bal. [Leguminosae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Onobrychis germanicopolitana Huber-Mor. & Simon [Leguminosae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Onobrychis halyensis Sirj [Leguminosae] 12840 single country endemic globally threatened plants Leguminosae: Onobrychis a I 12840 Turkey 12840 Onobrychis huetiana Boiss. [Leguminosae] 12340 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Onobrychis mutensis Kit Tan & Sorger [Leguminosae] /2840 Vv 12840 Turkey 12840 Onobrychis nitida Boiss. [Leguminosae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Onobrychis occulta Hedge & Huber-Mor. [Leguminosae] /2840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Onobrychis ornata Willd.) Desv. [Leguminosae] /2840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Onobrychis pallasii (Willd.) M.Bieb. [Leguminosae] 20/7] R former European USSR Onobrychis paucijuga Bornm. [Leguminosae] 12340 R = 12840 Turkey 12840 Onobrychis pisidica Boiss. [Leguminosae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Onobrychis podperae Sirj [Leguminosae] 12840 R = 12840 Turkey 12840 Onobrychis quadrijuga Hedge & Huber-Mor. [Leguminosae] 1/2840 R= 12840 Turkey 12840 Onobrychis radiata (Desf.) Bieb. [Leguminosae] 20/7] R former USSR Onobrychis sivasica Kit Tan & Sorger [Leguminosae] /2840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Onobrychis stenostachya Freyn ssp. krausei (Sirj.) Hedge [Leguminosae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Onobrychis stenostachya Freyn ssp. sosnowskyi (Grossh.) Hedge [Leguminosae] 12840 R= 12840 Turkey 12840 Ononis adenotricha Boiss. var. nuda Huber-Mor. [Leguminosae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Ononis basiadnata Huber-Mor. [Leguminosae] 12840 R = 12840 Turkey 12840 Ononis macrosperma Huber-Mor. [Leguminosae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Ononis sessilifolia Bornm. [Leguminosae] 12340 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Onopordum bracteatum L. var. arachnoideum Erik & Sumbul [Compositae] 12840 V_=s:12840 Turkey 12840 Onopordum caricum Hub.-Mor. [Compositae] 12840 R= 12840 Turkey 12840 Onosma affine Hausskn. ex H. Rield [Boraginaceae] 12840 Ex 12840 Turkey 12840 Onosma angustissimum Hausskn. & Bornm. [Boraginaceae] 12840 R = 12840 Turkey 12840 Onosma arcuatum H. Rield [Boraginaceae] 12840 -33- x Fe FR BR Ex le) x Fy RF BR BR ae m7 Rw ico] R 12840 Turkey 12840 Onosma argentatum Huber-Mor. [Boraginaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Onosma bozakmanii H. Ried) [Boraginaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Onosma briquetii Czecz. [Boraginaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Onosma cappadocicum Siehe ex H. Riedl [Boraginaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Onosma davisii H. Reidl [Boraginaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Onosma discedens Hausskn. ex Bornm. [Boraginaceae] 12840 Ex 12840 Turkey 12840 Onosma halophilum Boiss. & Heldr. [Boraginaceae] 12840 Vv 12840 Turkey 12840 Onosma helleri Greuter & Burdet [Boraginaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Onosma intertextum Huber-Mor. [Boraginaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Onosma linearilobum Hausskn. ex H. Riedl [Boraginaceae] 12840 I 12840 Turkey 12840 Onosma liparioides DC. [Boraginaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Onosma lycaonicum Huber-Mor. [Boraginaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Onosma neglectum H. Reidl [Boraginaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Onosma nigricaula H. Riedl [Boraginaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Onosma obtusifolium Hausskn. & Sint. ex Bornm. [Boraginaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Onosma papillosum H. Riedl. [Boraginaceae] 12840 I 12840 Turkey 12840 Onosma polyanthum DC. [Boraginaceae] 12840 R= 12840 Turkey 12840 Onosma proballantherum Rech.f. [Boraginaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Onosma proponticum Aznay. [Boraginaceae] 12840 E 12840 Turkey 12840 Onosma pulchrum Hi. Ried! [Boraginaceae] 12340 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Onosma rutilum Huber- Mor. [Boraginaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Onosma,sieheanum Hayek [Boraginaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Onosma sintenisii Hausskn. ex Bornm. [Boraginaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Onosma sorgeri Teppner var. sorgeri [Boraginaceae] 1/2840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Onosma Strigosissimum Boiss. [Boraginaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Single country endemic globally threatened plants : Boraginaceae: Onosma R rei uae: Ae x 7 KF BR Onosma subulifolium Ried| [Boraginaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Onosma tschichatscheyvii Popov [Boraginaceae] 12840 I 12840 Turkey 12840 Onosma velutinum Boiss. [Boraginaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 i Ophrys bornmuelleri M. Schulze ex Bornm. ssp. carduchorum Renz & Taub. [Orchidaceae] 12840 E 12840 Turkey 12840 Ophrys holoserica (Burnm. f.) Greuter ssp. heterochila Renz & Taub. [Orchidaceae] 12840 E 12840 Turkey 12840 Ophrys isaura Renz & Taub. [Orchidaceae] 12840 E 12840 Turkey 12840 ul Ophrys lycia Renz & Taub. [Orchidaceae] 12840 E 12840 Turkey 12840 i! Ophrys phrygia Meishm. & Bornm. [Orchidaceae] 1/2840 E 19873 Turkey 12840 Ophrys reinholdii Spruner ex Fleischm. ssp. leucotaenia Renz & Taub. [Orchidaceae] 12840 E 12840 Turkey 12840 Ophrys transhyrcana Czernjak. ssp. amanensis (Nelson) Renz & Taub. [Orchidaceae] /2840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Origanum amanum Post [Labiatae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Origanum bilgeri Davis (Labiatae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Origanum haussknechtii Boiss. (Labiatae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Origanum hypericifolium O. Schwarz & Davis [Labiatae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Origanum leptocladum Boiss. [Labiatae] 12840, 20171 R =: 12840 Turkey 12840 Origanum micranthum Vogel (Labiatae] 12340 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Origanum minutiflorum O. Schwarz & Davis [Labiatae] 1/2840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Origanum munzurense Kit Tan & Sorger [Labiatae] /2840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Origanum saccatum Davis [Labiatae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Origanum solymicum Davis (Labiatae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Ornithogalum nivale Boiss. [Hyacinthaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Ornithogalum sorgerae H. Wittmann [Hyacinthaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Orobanche armena Tzvelev [Scrophulariaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Orobanche hadroantha Beck [Scrophulariaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Orobanche sideana Gilli [Scrophulariaceae] 12840 v 12840 Turkey 12840 -34- | x FF FF FF RF RF BR xa FF RF RF BR Orobanche solenanthi Novopokr. & Pissjauka [Scrophulariaceae] E former USSR 6930 Oxytropis argyroleuca Bornm. [Leguminosae] 12840 I 12840 Turkey 12840 Oxytropis astragaloides A. Boriss [Leguminosae] R former USSR 6930 Oxytropis hippolyti Boriss [Leguminosae] R former European USSR Oxytropis kamtschatica Hulten [Leguminosae] R former Asiatic USSR (Far east) 6930 Oxytropis kateninii Jurtz. [Leguminosae] 21309 R 27309 Russia (E.Europe) - Northwest 21309 Oxytropis uniflora Jurtz. [Leguminosae] 21309 R 21309 Russia (E.Europe) - Northwest 2/309 Oxytropis uralensis (L.) DC. [Leguminosae] 20171 R former European USSR Oxytropis uschakovii Jurtz. [Leguminosae] 21309 R 21309 Russia (E.Europe) - North 21309 R 21309 Russia (E.Europe) - Northwest 2/309 Paeonia kavachensis Aznay. [Paeoniaceae] 6930 R 11552 Russian Federation (Caucasus) 1/552 Paeonia macrophylla (Albov) N. Lom. [Paeoniaceae] 5942 I 5942 Georgia 5942 Paeonia mlokosewitschii N. Lom. [Paeoniaceae] 5942 I 5942 Russia - North Caucasus 5942 Papaver argemone L. ssp. davisii Kaderit [Papaveraceae] 1/2840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Papaver atrovirens Petrovsky [Papaveraceae] 21309 R 21309 Russia (E.Europe) - Northwest 21309 Papaver bracteatum Lindl. [Papaveraceae] 5942, 20171 I 5942 Russia - North Caucasus 5942 Papaver guerlekense Stapf [Papaveraceae] 12840, 20171 Vv 12840 Turkey 12840 Papaver maeoticum Klokov [Papaveraceae] 20171 R former European USSR Papaver pilosum Sibth. & Sm. [Papaveraceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Papaver strictum Boiss. & Bal. [Papaveraceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Papaver tenellum Tolmatchew [Papaveraceae] R former USSR 6930 Paracaryum amani (Rchb.f) R. Mill [Boraginaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Paracaryum artvinense R. Mill [Boraginaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Paracaryum corymbiforme (DC. & A. DC.) Boiss. [Boraginaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Paracaryum erysimifolium Boiss. [Boraginaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Paracaryum kurdistanicum (Brand) R. Mill [Boraginaceae] /2840 5 * ingle country endemic globally threatened plants Boraginaceae: Paracaryum R 12840 Turkey 12840 Paracaryum leptophyllum (A. DC.) Boiss. [Boraginaceae] 12840 I 12840 Turkey 12840 Paracaryum lithospermifolium (Lam.) Grande var. erectum R. Mill. [Boraginaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Paracaryum paphlagonicum (Bornm.) R. Mill [Boraginaceae] /2840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Paracaryum polycarpum (Rech.f.) R. Mill [Boraginaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Paracaryum reuteri Boiss. & Hausskn. [Boraginaceae] /2840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Paracaryum shepardii Post & Beauv. [Boraginaceae] /2840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Paracaryum stenolophum Boiss. [Boraginaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Paronychia adalia Chaudh. [Mlecebraceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Paronychia anatolica Czecz. [Mecebraceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Paronychia angorensis Chaudh. [Ilecebraceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Paronychia arabica (L.) DC. ssp. euphratica Choudh. [Ilecebraceae] 1/2840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Paronychia argyroloba Stapf [Wlecebraceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Paronychia beauverdii Czecz. [Mecebraceae] 12840 R= 12840 Turkey 12840 Paronychia cataonica Chaudh. [Ilecebraceae] 12840 R = 12840 Turkey 12840 Paronychia condensata Chaudh. [Mlecebraceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Paronychia davisii Chaudh. [Ilecebraceae] 12840 R = 12840 Turkey 12840 Paronychia dudleyi Chaudh. [Mlecebraceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Paronychia galatica Chaudh. [Mlecebraceae] 12840 R = 12840 Turkey 12840 Paronychia kayseriana Chaudh. {llecebraceae] 12840 R _ 12840 Turkey 12840 Paronychia kurdica Boiss. var. fragilis Chaudhri [Illecebraceae] 12840 Vv 12840 Turkey 12840 Paronychia kurdica Boiss. ssp. haussknechtii Chaudh. [Illecebraceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Paronychia kurdica Boiss. ssp. montis-munzur Chaurhri [Illecebraceae] 12840 R= 12840 Turkey 12840 Paronychia lycica Chaudh. [Mlecebraceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Paronychia paphlagonica Chaudh. [lecebraceae] 12840 -35- Cob he cies Seen ~ Set eameny~ ema] b=] x FPF FR BR R 12840 Turkey 12840 Paronychia saxatilis Chaudh. [Mlecebraceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Paronychia turcica Chaudh. [IMlecebraceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Pastinaca armena Fisch. & Mey. ssp. dentata (Freyn & Sint) Chamb. [Umbelliferae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey. 12840 Pedicularis olympica Boiss. [Scrophulariaceae] /2840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Peltariopsis grossheimii N. Busch. [Cruciferae] R former USSR 6930 Petrocoma hoefftiana (Fischer) Rupr. [Caryophyllaceae] 5942 I 5942 Russia - North Caucasus 5942 Petrorhagia hispidula (Boiss. & Heldr.) Ball & Heyw. [Caryophyllaceae] 1/2840 Vv 12840 Turkey 12840 Petrorhagia lycica (Davis) Ball & Heyw. [Caryophyllaceae] 12840 R —:12840 Turkey 12840 Petrorhagia pamphylica (Boiss. & Ball.) Ball. & Heyw. [Caryophyllaceae] /2840 Vv 12840 Turkey 12840 Petrorhagia peroninii (Boiss. Ball. & Heyw. [Caryophyllaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Petrosimonia nigdeensis Aelien [Chenopodiaceae] /2840 Vv 12840 Turkey 12840 Peucedanum arenarium Waldst. & Kit ssp. urbanii (Freyn & Sint. ex Wolff) Chamb [Umbelliferae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Peucedanum mogoltavicum Korovin [Umbelliferae] R former USSR 6930 Phlomis angustissima Hub.-Mor. [Labiatae] 12840 R =: 12840 Turkey 12840 Phlomis brunneogaleata Hub.-Mor. [Labiatae] 12840 Vs: 12840 Turkey 12840 Phlomis carica Rech.fil. [Labiatae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Phlomis chimerae Boissieu [Labiatae] 12840 R 20618 Turkey 20618 Phlomis integrifolia Hub.-Mor. [Labiatae] 12840 Vv 12840 Turkey 12840 Phlomis leucophracta Davis & Hub.-Mor. [Labiatae] 12840 R 20618 Turkey 20618 Phlomis longifolia Boiss. & Bal. var. bailanica (Vierh.) Hub.-Mor. [Labiatae] 12840 R = 20618 Turkey 20618 Phlomis monocephala Davis [Labiatae] 12840 R 20618 Turkey 20618 Phlomis physocalyx Hub.-Mor. [Labiatae] 12840 R =: 12840 Turkey 12840 Phlomis sintenisii Rech.fil. [Labiatae] 12840 R = 12840 Turkey 12840 Phryna ortegioides (Fisch. & Mey.) Pax & Hoffm. Single country endemic globally threatened plants : Caryophyllaceae: Phryna < 7F RF RF BR [Caryophyllaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Physocardamum davisti Hedge [Cruciferae] 12840 R =: 12840 Turkey 12840 Physoptychis haussknechtii Bornm. [Cruciferae] 1/2840 R=: 12840 Turkey 12840 Picris campylocarpa Boiss. & Heldr. [Compositae] /2840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Pimpinella anisetum Boiss. & Bal. [Umbelliferae] 12840 R_ 12840 Turkey 12840 Pimpinella flabellifolia (Boiss.) Bent & Hook ex Drude (Umbelliferae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Pimpinella isaurica Matthews [Umbelliferae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Pinus sylvestris L. var. cretacea (Kalen.) Komarov [Pinaceae] 5942, 20171 I 5942 Ukraine 5942 Plantago anatolica B. Tutel & R. Mill [Plantaginaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Plantago euphratica Decne ex Barneoud [Plantaginaceae] /2840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Poa aitosensis Koz. et Stoeva [Gramineae] 5204 R 5204 Bulgaria (east) 5204 Poa davisii Bor [Gramineae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Poa pseudobulbosa Bor [Gramineae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Poa speluncarum Edmondson [Gramineae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Polygala inespectata Pesman & Erik [Polygalaceae] 12840 Vv 12840 Turkey 12840 Polygala pruinosa Boiss. ssp. megaptera Cullen [Polygalaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Polygonum afyonicum E. Leblebici & Y. Gemici [Polygonaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Polygonum aschersonianum H.Gross [Polygonaceae] 20/71 R former European USSR Polygonum paralongum Coode & Cullen [Polygonaceae] 12840 Vs 12840 Turkey 12840 Polygonum salebrosum Coode & Cullen [Polygonaceae] 12840 R= 12840 Turkey 12840 Polylophium panjutinii Manden. & Schischkin [Umbelliferae] 5942 I 5942 Georgia 5942 Potentilla aladagensis E. Leblebici [Rosaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 -36- x FF FR FR x FF RF F RF — Potentilla anadyrensis Juzepczuk [Rosaceae] R former USSR 6930 Potentilla armeniaca Siegfr. ex Th.Wolf [Rosaceae] 1/2840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Potentilla buccoana Clem. [Rosaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Potentilla buchneri Kit Tan & Sorger [Rosaceae] 1/2840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Potentilla cappadocica Boiss. [Rosaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Potentilla discipulorum Davis. [Rosaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Potentilla doddsii Davis [Rosaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Potentilla isaurica (Davis) B. Paw). [Rosaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Potentilla pulvinaris Fenzl [Rosaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Potentilla subpalmata Ledeb. [Rosaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Potentilla tauricola H. Pesmen [Rosaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Potentilla tollii Trautv. [Rosaceae] R former USSR 6930 Potentilla volgarica Juz. [Rosaceae] 11552 Ex 11552 Russian Federation (western) 1/552 Prangos denticulata Fisch. & Mey. [Umbelliferae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Prangos scrabifolia Post ex Beauv. [Umbelliferae] 12840 I 12840 Turkey 12840 Prenanthes glareosa (Scho.&Kotsc. ex Bois.) C. Jeff. [Compositae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Primula darialica Rupr. [Primulaceae] 5942 I 5942 Russia - North Caucasus 5942 Primula davisti W.W. Sm. [Primulaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Primula deorum Velen. [Primulaceae] 5204, 20171 R 5204 Bulgaria (Rila Mt.) 5204 Primula frondosa Janka [Primulaceae] 5204, 20171 R 5204 Bulgaria (central) 5204 Primula komarovii Losinsk. [Primulaceae] 20171 R former European USSR 6930 Primula longipes Freyn & Sint. [Primulaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Primula megaseifolia Boiss. & Bal. ex Boiss. [Primulaceae] 5942 I 5942 Georgia 5942 Primula minkwitziae W.W. Smith [Primulaceae] R former USSR 6930 Prunus cocomilia Ten var. puberula (Schneider) Browicz [Rosaceae] 12840 R =. 20618 Turkey 20618 Prunus kurdica Fenzl [Rosaceae] 12840 #3 Single country endemic globally threatened plants Rosaceae: Prunus : R 20618 Turkey 206/8 Pseudophleum gibbum (Boiss.) M. Dogan [Gramineae] /2840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Puccinellia anisoclada (V. Kreez.) V. Kreez. ssp. melderisiana Kit Tan [Gramineae] 12840 Vs: 12840 Turkey 12840 Pulicaria armena Boiss.) Kotschy [Compositae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Pulsatilla kostyczewii (Korsch.) Juzepczuk [Ranunculaceae] R former USSR 6930 Pyrus anatolica Browicz [Rosaceae] 12840 R 20618 Turkey 206/8 Pyrus hakkiarica Browicz [Rosaceae] 12840 R =. 20618 Turkey 20618 Pyrus salicifolia Pallas var. serrulata Browicz [Rosaceae] /2840 R =. 20618 Turkey 20618 Pyrus serikensis [Rosaceae] 20618 Vv 20618 Turkey 20618 Pyrus syriaca Boiss. var. microphylla Zoh. ex Browicz [Rosaceae] 206/8 R =. 20618 Turkey 20618 Pyrus yaltirikii Browicz [Rosaceae] 12840 R = 20618 Turkey 20618 Quercus robur ssp. imeretina (Steven ex Woronow) Menitsky [Fagaceae] 20283 I 20283 Russian Federation (in Georgia, Caucasus) 20627 Ranunculus bingoeldaghensis A. Engin [Ranunculaceae] 12840 ‘ R 12840 Turkey 12840 Ranunculus crateris Davis [Ranunculaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Ranunculus dissectus Bieb. ssp. ermenekensis Kit Tan & M. Vural [Ranunculaceae] /2840 R = 12840 Turkey 12840 Ranunculus dissectus Bieb. ssp. rigidulus (Boiss.) Davis [Ranunculaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Ranunculus guenerii Y. Ayasligil & Davis [Ranunculaceae] /2840 R= 12840 Turkey 12840 Ranunculus isthmicus Boiss. ssp. tenuifolous (Stev.) Davis [Ranunculaceae] 12840 R = 12840 Turkey 12840 Ranunculus munzurensis S. Erik & S. Yildirimli [Ranunculaceae] 12840 R =‘: 12840 Turkey 12840 Ranunculus poluninii Davis [Ranunculaceae] 12840 R = 12840 Turkey 12840 Ranunculus sintenisii Freyn [Ranunculaceae] 12840 R 19873 Turkey 12840 Ranunculus tempskyanus Freyn & Sint. [Ranunculaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Ranunculus vanensis Davis [Ranunculaceae] 12840 -37- x Fe FF KR BR — Ex x RF FR R 12840 Turkey 12840 Reaumuria badhysi Korovin [Tamaricaceae] R former USSR 6930 Reaumuria zakirovii Gorschk. [Tamaricaceae] R former USSR 6930 Reseda armena Boiss. [Resedaceae] /2840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Reseda balansae Muller [Resedaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Reseda coodei Huber-Mor. [Resedaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Reseda germanicopolitana Huber-Mor. [Resedaceae] /2840 I 12840 Turkey 12840 Reseda tomentosa Boiss. var. tomentosa [Resedaceae] /2840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Rhabdosciadium microcalycinum Hand.-mazz. [Umbelliferae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Rhamnus hirtellus Boiss. [Rhamnaceae] 12840 R 20618 Turkey 20618 Rhamnus kayactkii Davis & F. Yaltirik [Rhamnaceae] 12840 R 20618 Turkey 20618 Rhamnus nitidus Davis [Rhamnaceae] 12840 R 20618 Turkey 20618 Rhamnus pichleri Schneider & Bornm. ex Bornm. [Rhamnaceae] 1/2840 R 20618 Turkey 20618 Rhamphicarpa medwedewii Albov [Scrophulariaceae] 5942 I 5942 Georgia 5942 _Rhodothamnus sessilifolius Davis [Ericaceae] 12840 R =. 20618 Turkey 12840 Rhynchocorys odontophylla Burbridge & Richard [Scrophulariaceae] /2840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Ribes kolymense (Trauty.) Komarov ex Pojark [Grossulariaceae] 6930 Ex 6930 former USSR 6930 Ricotia davisiana Burtt [Cruciferae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Ricotia tenuifolia Sibth. & Sm. [Cruciferae] 12840 Vv 12840 Turkey 12840 Ricotia varians Burtt [Cruciferae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Roemeria carica A. Baytop [Papaveraceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Rorippa aurea (Boiss. & Heldr.) Hub.-Mor. [Cruciferae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Rosa dumalis Bechat. var. anatalyensis (Menden) O. Nilson [Rosaceae] /2840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Rosa dumalis ssp. boissieri var. antalyensis [Rosaceae] 20618 R =. 20618 Turkey 20618 Rosularia davisti Muirhead [Crassulaceae] 12840 Single country endemic globally threatened plants : Crassulaceae: Rosularia R x FPF RF FR BR R 12840 Turkey 12840 Rosularia haussknechtii Boiss. & Reuter [Crassulaceae] 1/2840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Rosularia serpentinica (Werdermann) Muirhead [Crassulaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Rubia davisiana Ehbrend. [Rubiaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Rumex amanus Rech. [Polygonaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Rumex bithynicus Rech. f. [Polygonaceae] 12840 Vv 12840 Turkey 12840 Rumex gracilescens Rech. [Polygonaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Rumex olympicus Boiss. [Polygonaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Rumex tmoleus Boiss. [Polygonaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Salix rizeensis [Salicaceae] 20618 R 20618 Turkey 20618 Salix trabzonica A. Skv. [Salicaceae] 12840 R 20618 Turkey 20618 Salsola anatolica Aellen [Chenopodiaceae] 12840 v 12840 Turkey 12840 Salsola chiwensis Popov [Chenopodiaceae] 6930 E former Asiatic USSR 6930 Salsola prostrata Pall. ssp. anatolica Aellen [Chenopodiaceae] 12840 v 12840 Turkey 12840 Salsola stenoptera Wagenitz [Chenopodiaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Salvia adenocaulon Davis [(Labiatae] 12840 Vv 12840 Turkey 12840 Salvia adenophylla Hedge & Hub.-Mor. [Labiatae] 1/2840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Salvia albimaculata Hedge & Hub.-Mor. [Labiatae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Salvia aucheri Bentham [Labiatae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Salvia cedronella Boiss. (Labiatae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Salvia chionantha Boiss. [Labiatae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Salvia cilicica Boiss. & Kotschy [Labiatae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Salvia divaricata Montbret & Aucher ex Bentham [Labiatae] 1/2840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Salvia eriophora Boiss. & Kotschy [Labiatae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Salvia euphratica Montbret & Aucher ex Bentham [Labiatae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Salvia garedji Troitsky [Labiatae] R former USSR 6930 -38- Salvia halophila Hedge [Labiatae] 12840 Vv 12840 Turkey 1/2840 Salvia huberi Hedge (Labiatae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Salvia kronenburgei Rech.fil. [Labiatae] 12340 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Salvia nydeggeri Hub.-Mor. [Labiatae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Salvia odontochlamys Hedge (Labiatae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Salvia quezelii Hedge & Ajzal-Rafri [Labiatae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Salvia reeseana Hedge & Hub.-Mor. [Labiatae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Salvia sericeo-tomentosa Rech.fil. [Labiatae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Salvia smyrnea Boiss. (Labiatae] 12340 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Salvia tigrina Hedge & Hub.-Mor. [Labiatae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Salvia tobeyi Hedge [Labiatae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Salvia vermifolia Hedge & Hub.-Mor. [Labiatae] /2840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Sambucus tigranii Troitsky [Caprifoliaceae] E former USSR Saponaria dalmasiia Boissieu [Caryophyllaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Saponaria halophila Hedge & Huber-Mor. [Caryophyllaceae] 12840 E 12840 Turkey ‘12840 Saponaria pamphylica Boiss. & Heldr. [Caryophyllaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Saponaria picta Boiss. [Caryophyllaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Saponaria pinetorum Hedge [Caryophyllaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Saponaria syriaca Boiss. [Caryophyllaceae] 12340 I 12840 Turkey 12840 Satureja bzybica Woronow [Labiatae] 5942 I 5942 Russia - North Caucasus 5942 Satureja cilicica Davis [Labiatae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Satureja parnassica Heldr. & Sart. ex Boiss. ssp. sipylea Davis [Labiatae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Satureja rumelica Velen. (Labiatae] 5204, 20171 R 5204 Bulgaria (central) 5204 Saussurea sovietica Komarov [Compositae] 5942 R 5942 Russia (Far East) - Primorye 5942 Saxifraga artvinensis Matthews [Saxifragaceae] /2840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Saxifraga columnaris Schmalh. [Saxifragaceae] 5942 I 5942 Russia - North Caucasus 5942 : [ ingle country endemic globally threatened plants ; Saxifragaceae: Saxifraga Saxifraga dinnikii Schmalh. [Saxifragaceae] 5942 I 5942 Russia - North Caucasus 5942 Saxifraga lactea Turcz. [Saxifragaceae] 11552 R 11552 Russian Federation (extreme south east) 11552 Scabiosa columbaria L. ssp. paphlagonica (Bornm.) Matthews [Dipsacaceae] /2840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Scabiosa hololeuca Bornm. [Dipsacaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Scabiosa kurdica Post [Dipsacaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Scabiosa olgae Albov [Dipsacaceae] 5942 I 5942 Russia - North Caucasus 5942 Scabiosa paucidentata Hub.-Mor. [Dipsacaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Scabiosa pseudograminifolia Hub.-Mor. [Dipsacaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Scabiosa rhodopensis Stoj. & Stef. [Dipsacaceae] 5204, 20171 R 5204 Bulgaria (Southern - two areas) 5204 Scabiosa sulphurea Boiss. & Huet [Dipsacaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Scaligeria capillifolia Post (Umbelliferae] 12340 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Scandix balansae Reuter ex Boiss. [Umbelliferae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Schivereckia berteroides Fisch. ex M.1.Alex. [Cruciferae] 8000, 20171 R former European USSR (Ural Mountains) Scilla atropatana Grossh. [Hyacinthaceae] R former USSR 6930 Scilla leepii Speta [(Hyacinthaceae] 12840 R = 12840 Turkey 12840 Scorzonera argyria Boiss. [Compositae] 12840 I 12840 Turkey 12840 Scorzonera aucheriana DC. [Compositae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Scorzonera boissieri Lipschitz [Compositae] 12840 R = 12840 Turkey 12840 Scorzonera davisii Lipschitz [Compositae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Scorzonera hieracifolia Hayek [Compositae] 12840 Vv 12840 Turkey 12840 Scorzonera inaequiscapa Boiss. [Compositae] 12840 R= 12840 Turkey 12840 : Scorzonera lacera Boiss. & Bal. [Compositae] 12840 R = 12840 Turkey 12840 Scorzonera lasiocarpa Chamb. [Compositae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Scorzonera mirabilis Lipschitz [Compositae] 12840 R = 12840 Turkey 12840 Scorzonera pisidica Huber-Mor. [Compositae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Scorzonera pygmaea Sibth. & Sm. [Compositae] 12840 R= 12840 Turkey 12840 -39- Scorzonera sandrasica Hartvig & Strid [Compositae] 1/2840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Scorzonera suberosa C. Koch. ssp. cariensis (oiss.) Chamb. [Compositae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Scorzonera violacea Chamb. [Compositae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Scrophularia amana Wall [Scrophulariaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Scrophularia bitlisica Lai [Scrophulariaceae] /2840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Scrophularia candelabrum Heywood [Scrophulariaceae] /2840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Scrophularia capillaris Boiss. & Bal. [Scrophulariaceae] /2840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Scrophularia carduchorum R. Mill. [Scrophulariaceae] 12840 R = 12840 Turkey 12840 Scrophularia gypsicola Huber-Mor. & lall [Scrophulariaceae] /2840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Scrophularia lepidota Boiss. [Scrophulariaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Scrophularia libanotica Boiss. var. antalyensis Y. Ayasligil & R. Mill. [Scrophulariaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Scrophularia libanotica Boiss. var. nevshehirensis R. Mill. [Scrophulariaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Scrophularia libanotica Boiss. var. oligantha Heywood [Scrophulariaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Scrophularia mersinensis Lall [Scrophulariaceae] /2840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Scrophularia pumilio Lali [Scrophulariaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Scrophularia scoplii Hoppe ex Pers. var. parryi R. Mill. [Scrophulariaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Scrophularia scopolii Hoppe ex Pers. var. burdurensis (H. Pesmen) R. Mill. [Scrophulariaceae] /2840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Scrophularia scopolii Hoppe ex Pers. var. longirostrata Heywood [Scrophulariaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Scrophularia serratifolia Huber-Mor ex Lall [Scrophulariaceae] /2840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Scrophularia subsequiloba Lali [Scrophulariaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Scrophularia versicolor Boiss. [Scrophulariaceae] 12840 Single country endemic globally threatened plants : Scrophulariaceae: Scrophularia R Ex R 12840 Turkey 12840 Scutellaria glophyrostachys Rech.fil. [Labiatae] /2840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Scutellaria heterotricha Suzepczuk & Vved. [Labiatae] R former USSR 6930 Scutellaria juzepczukii Gontsch. [Labiatae] R former USSR 6930 Scutellaria orientalis L. ssp. carica Edmondson [Labiatae] 1/2840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Scutellaria orientalis L. ssp. porphyrostegia Edmondson [Labiatae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Scutellaria orientalis L. ssp. sintenisii (Hausskn. ex Bornm.) Edmondson [Labiatae] /2840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Scutellaria orientalis L. ssp. tortumensis Kit Tan & Sorger [Labiatae] /2840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Scutellaria rubicunda Hornem ssp. pannosula (Rech.f.) Edmondson [Labiatae] /2840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Secale cereale L. var. ancestrale (Zhuk.) Kit Tan [Gramineae] /2840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Secale rhodopaecum Delip. [Gramineae] 5204 R 5204 Bulgaria (South Bulgaria - one site only.) 5204 Sedum borissovae Balk. [Crassulaceae] 2017] v former European USSR Sedum caroli-henrici Kit Tan [Crassulaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Sedum cilicicum Kit Tan & Vural [Crassulaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Sedum hewittii Chamb. [Crassulaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Sedum hispanicum L. var. planifolium Chamb. [Crassulaceae] /2840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Sedum kostovii Stef. [Crassulaceae] 5204, 20171 R 5204 Bulgaria (south) 5204 Sedum polystriatum R.T. Clausen [Crassulaceae] 12840 Ex 12840 Turkey 12840 Sedum sorgerae Kit Tan & Chamberlain [Crassulaceae] 1/2840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Sempervivum armenum Boiss. & Huet var. insigne Muirhead [Crassulaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Sempervivum brevipetalum Kit Tan & Sorger [Crassulaceae] 1/2840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Sempervivum furseorum Muirhead [Crassulaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Sempervivum gillianii Muirhead [Crassulaceae] 12840 -40- x 7 FR FR = R 12840 Turkey 12840 Sempervivum glabrifolium Boiss. [Crassulaceae] 1/2840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Sempervivum globiferum L. ssp. aghricum Kit Tan & Sorger [Crassulaceae] 1/2840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Sempervivum ispartae Muirhead [Crassulaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Sempervivum minus Turrill s.1. [Crassulaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Sempervivum pisidicum H. Pesmen & A. Guner [Crassulaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Sempervivum staintonii Muirhead [Crassulaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Senecio cariensis Boiss. [Compositae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Senecio davisii Matthews [Compositae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Senecio farfarifolius Boiss. & Kotschy [Compositae] 12840, 20171 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Senecio hypochionaeus Boiss. var. hypochionaeus [Compositae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Senecio jurineifolius Boiss. & Bal. [Compositae] /2840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Senecio karelinoides Winkler [Compositae] 8001 R former Asiatic USSR (Pamir-Alai) 6930 Senecio lazicus Boiss. & Bal. [Compositae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Senecio olympicus Boiss. [Compositae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Senecio ovatifolius Boiss. [Compositae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Senecio platyphyllus DC. var. glandulosus Mathews [Compositae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Senecio sandrasicus Davis [Compositae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Senecio tauricolus Matthews [Compositae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Serratula hakkiarica Davis [Compositae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Serratula lasiocephala Bornm. [Compositae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Serratula tanaitica P.A.Smirn. [Compositae] 5942, 20171 I 5942 Russia (E.Europe) - South 5942 Seseli degenii Urum. [Umbelliferae] 5204, 20171 R 5204 Bulgaria (north) 5204 Seseli lehmannii Degen [Umbelliferae] 2017] R former European USSR Seseli ramosissimum (Port.) Ces. [Umbelliferae] 12840, 20171 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Single country endemic globally threatened plants Umbelliferae: Seseli Seseli resinosum Freyn & Sint. [Umbelliferae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Seseli saxicolum (Albov) Pim. [Umbelliferae] 5042 I 5942 Georgia 5942 Sesleria araratica Kit Tan [Gramineae] 12840 R = 12840 Turkey 12840 Sesleria klasterskii Dey [Gramineae] R Bulgaria Sideritis albiflora Huber-Mor. (Labiatae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Sideritis amasica Bornm. [Labiatae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Sideritis argyrea Davis [Labiatae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Sideritis armeniaca Bornm. [Labiatae] 12340 R = 12840 Turkey 12840 Sideritis bilgerana Davis [Labiatae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Sideritis brevibracteata Davis (Labiatae] 12340 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Sideritis brevidens Davis (Labiatae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Sideritis cassia Huber-Mor. {Labiatae] 12340 R = 12840 Turkey 12840 Sideritis cilicica Boiss. & Bal. [Labiatae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Sideritis condensata (Boiss. & Heldr.) Bentham [Labiatae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Sideritis congesta Davis & Huber-Mor. [Labiatae] 12840 R_ 12840 Turkey 12840 Sideritis erythrantha (Boiss. & Heldr.) Bentham [Labiatae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Sideritis galatica Bornm. [Labiatae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Sideritis hispida Davis [Labiatae] 12840 R = 12840 Turkey 12840 Sideritis hololeuca (Boiss. & Heldr.) Bentham [Labiatae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Sideritis huber-morathii Greuter ex Burdet [Labiatae] 12840 R = 12840 Turkey 12840 Sideritis leptoclada O. Schwarz & Davis [Labiatae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Sideritis libanotica Labill. ssp. violescens (Davis) Davis [Labiatae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Sideritis lycia (Boiss. & Heldr.) Bentham [Labiatae] 12840 Vv 12840 Turkey 12840 Sideritis niveotomentosa Huber-Mor. [Labiatae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Sideritis phlomoides Boiss. & bal. [Labiatae] 12340 R= 12840 Turkey 12840 xy Fe FF BR Sideritis phrygia Bornm. [Labiatae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Sideritis pisidica (Boiss. & Heldr.) Bentham [Labiatae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Sideritis rubiflora Huber-Mor. [Labiatae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Sideritis serratifolia Huber-Mor. [Labiatae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Sideritis stricta (Boiss. & Heldr.) Bentham [Labiatae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Sideritis tmolea Davis [Labiatae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Sideritis trojana Bornm. (Labiatae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Sideritis vulcanica Huber-Mor. [Labiatae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Silene akmaniana Ekim & Celik [Caryophyllaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Silene anatolica Melzheimer & Baytop [Caryophyllaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Silene araratica Schischk. [Caryophyllaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Silene argaea Fisch. & Mey. [Caryophyllaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Silene armena Boiss. var. serrulata (Boiss.) Coode & Cullen [Caryophyllaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Silene azirensis Coode & Cullen [Caryophyllaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Silene birandiana Ekim [Caryophyllaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Silene bolanthoides Quezel,Coutaud & A. Pamukc. [Caryophyllaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Silene brevicalyx Hartwig & Strid [Caryophyllaceae] 12840 R= 12840 Turkey 12840 Silene capillipes Boiss. & Heldr. [Caryophyllaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Silene caramanica Boiss. & Heldr. [Caryophyllaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Silene cariensis Boiss. [Caryophyllaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Silene cartilaginea Huber-Mor. [Caryophyllaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Silene caryophlloides (Poiret.) Otth ssp. echinus (Bois. & Held.) Coode & Cullen [Caryophyllaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Silene caryphylloides (Poiret) Otth ssp. stentoria (Fenzl) Coode & Cullen [Caryophyllaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Single country endemic globally threatened plants : Caryophyllaceae: Silene I Ex Silene cretacea Fisch. ex Spreng. [Caryophyllaceae] 5942, 20171 I 5942 Russia (E.Europe) - South 5942 Silene delicatula Boiss. ssp. pisidica Coode & Cullen [Caryophyllaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Silene ermenekensis M. Vural & Kit Tan [Caryophyllaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Silene haradjianii Chowdh. [Caryophyllaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Silene hellmannii Claus [Caryophyllaceae] 8000, 20171 I 11552 Russian Federation (western, Ural Mts) 11552 Silene inclinata Huber & Mor. [Caryophyllaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Silene isaurica Contandr. & Quezel [Caryophyllaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Silene ispartensis Ghazanfar [Caryophyllaceae] /2840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Silene lucida Chowdh. ssp. glandulosa T. Ekim [Caryophyllaceae] /2840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Silene lycaonica Chowdh. [Caryophyllaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Silene oligotricha Huber-Mor. [Caryophyllaceae] 12840 Ex 12840 Turkey 12840 Silene oreades Boiss. & Heldr. [Caryophyllaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Silene paphlagonica Bornm. [Caryophyllaceae] 12840 _ R 12840 Turkey 12840 Silene pompeiopolitana J.Gay ex Boiss. [Caryophyllaceae] 12840, 20171 E 12840 Turkey 12840 Silene salsuginea Huber-Mor. [Caryophyllaceae] /2840 Vv 12840 Turkey 12840 Silene sangaria Coode & Cullen [Caryophyllaceae] 12840, 20171 Vv 19873 Turkey 12840 Silene scythicina Coode & Cullen [Caryophyllaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Silene sipylea O. Schwarz [Caryophyllaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Silene sordida Huber-Mor. & Reese [Caryophyllaceae] 12840 v 12840 Turkey 12840 Silene splendens Boiss. [Caryophyllaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Silene squamigera Boiss. ssp. vesiculifera (Gay ex Boiss.) Coode & Cullen [Caryophyllaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Silene surculosa Huber-Mor. [Caryophyllaceae] 12840 -42- R 12840 Turkey 12840 Silene tunicoides Boiss. [Caryophyllaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Smyrnium gelaticum Czecz. [Umbelliferae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Sobolewskia sibirica (Willd.) P.W.Ball [Cruciferae] 20/71 R former European USSR Solenanthus formosus R. Mill [Boraginaceae] 12840 R 2840 Turkey 12840 Sonchus erzincanicus Matthews [Compositae] 12840 Vv 12840 Turkey 12840 Spergularia lyciaularia Mounnier & Quezel [Caryophyllaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Sphaerophysa kotschyana Boiss. [Leguminosae] 12840 E 14155 Turkey 12840 Stachys aleurites (Boiss. & Heldr.) Bentham (Labiatae] /2840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Stachys amanica Davis (Labiatae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Stachys annua (L.) L. ssp. cilicica (Boiss.) Bhattacharjee [Labiatae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Stachys antalyensis Ayasligil & Davis (Labiatae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Stachys bayburtensis Bhattacharjee & Huber-Mor. [Labiatae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Stachys bombycina Boiss. [Labiatae] 12840 R= 12840 Turkey 12840 Stachys burgsdorffiioides (Bentham) Boiss. ssp. ladanoides Hand.-Mazz. [Labiatae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Stachys buttlerii R. Mill. (Labiatae] 12840 E 12840 Turkey 12840 Stachys cataonica Bhattacharjee & Huber-Mor. [Labiatae] 1/2840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Stachys chasmosericea Ayasligil & Davis [Labiatae] 1/2840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Stachys choruhensis Kit Tan & Sorger [Labiatae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Stachys cretica L. ssp. trapezuntica Rech.f. [Labiatae] 1/2840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Stachys distans Bentham var. cilicica Bhattacharjee & Huber-Mor. [Labiatae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Stachys euadenia Davis (Labiatae] 12840 R=: 12840 Turkey 12840 Stachys huber-morathii Bhattacharjee [Labiatae] 1/2840 R = 12840 Turkey 12840 Stachys inanis Hausskn. & Bornm. [Labiatae] 12840 : Single country endemic globally threatened plants ' Labiatae: Stachys II I R 12840 Turkey 12840 Stachys megalodonta Hausskn. & Bornm. ex Davis ssp. mardinensis Bhattacharjee [Labiatae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Stachys munzurdaghensis Bhattacharjee [Labiatae] /2840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Stachys pinardii Boiss. [Labiatae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Stachys pseudopinardii Bhattacharjee & Huber-Mor. [Labiatae] 12840 R_ © 12840 Turkey 12840 Stachys pumila Banks & Sol. [Labiatae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Stachys ramosissima Montbret & Aucher ex Bentham [Labiatae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Stachys rizeensis Bhattacharjee [Labiatae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Stachys sericantha Davis [Labiatae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Stachys subnuda Montbret & Aucher ex Bentham [Labiatae] /2840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Stachys tundjeliensis Kit Tan & Sorger [Labiatae] 7/2840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Staphylea colchica Steven [Staphyleaceae] 5942 I 5942 Georgia 5942 Stefanoffia insoluta Kijuykov [Umbelliferae] 12840 R = 12840 Turkey 12840 Stelleropsis caucasica Pobed. [Thymelaeaceae] 5942 E 11552 Transcaucasus (Georgia) 11552 Sterigmostemum sulphureum (Banks & Sol.) Bornm. ssp. glandulosum Hub.-Mor. & Reese [Cruciferae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Sternbergia candida B. Mathew & T. Baytop * [Amaryllidaceae] 17663 E 17662 Turkey (Nr Fethiye in Mugla Province) 12840 Sternbergia schubertii Schenk [Amaryllidaceae] 17663 I 12840 Turkey 12840 Stipa aktauensis Roshev. [Gramineae] R former USSR 6930 Stipa cretacea P.A.Smirn. [Gramineae] 8000, 20171 R former European USSR 8000 Stipa lithophila P.A.Smirn. [Gramineae] 5942, 20171 R 5942 Ukraine - Crimea 5942 Stipa longiplumosa Roshev. [Gramineae] R former USSR 6930 Stipa magnifica Junge [Gramineae] R former USSR 6930 Stipa trichoides P. Smirnow [Gramineae] R former USSR 6930 Stroganowia sagittata Karelin & Kir. [Cruciferae] 6930 Ex 6930 former Asiatic USSR 6930 Suaeda cucullata Aelien [Chenopodiaceae] 12840 -43- < w® FR — E 14155 Turkey 12840 Swida darvasica (Pojark.) Sojak [Cornaceae] E former USSR 6930 Symphyandra lazica Boiss. & Bal. [Campanulaceae] /2840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 ~ Symphyandra zangezura Lipsky [Campanulaceae] E former USSR 6930 Symphytum longipetiolatum Wickens [Boraginaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Symphytum longisetum Huber-Mor. & Wickens [Boraginaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Symphytum pseudobulbosum Asnav [Boraginaceae] 12840 Vv 12840 Turkey 12840 Symphytum savvalense Kurtto [Boraginaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Symphytum sylvaticum Boiss. [Boraginaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Syrenia talijevii Klokov [Cruciferae] 20171 Vv former European USSR Tanacetum akinfievii (Alexeenko) Tzvel. [Compositae] 5942, 20627 I 5942 Transcaucasus 5942 Tanacetum albipannosum Huber-Mor. & Grierson [Compositae] 12840 R= 12840 Turkey 12840 Tanacetum alyssifolium (Bornm.) Grierson [Compositae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Tanacetum argenteum (Lam.) Willd. ssp. canum (C. Koch) Grierson [Compositae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Tanacetum argenteum (Lam.) Willd. ssp. flabellifolium (Boiss. & Heldr.) Grierson [Compositae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Tanacetum cappadocicum (DC.) Schultz Bip. [Compositae] /2840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Tanacetum densum (Lab.) Schultz Bip. ssp. laxum Grierson [Compositae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Tanacetum densum (Lab.) Schultz Bip. ssp. sivasicum Hub.-Mor. & Grierson [Compositae] /2840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Tanacetum eginense (Hausskn. ex Bornm.) Grierson [Compositae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Tanacetum germanicopolitanum (Bornm. & Heimer!) Grierso [Compositae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Tanacetum haradjanii (Rech.fil.) Grierson [Compositae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Tanacetum haussknechtii (Bornm.) Grierson [Compositae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Single country endemic globally threatened plants : Compositae: Tanacetum R Tanacetum heterotomum (Bornm.) Grierson [Compositae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 R Tanacetum oltense (Sosn.) Grierson [Compositae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 R Tanacetum oxtstegium (Sosn.) Grierson [Compositae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 R Tanacetum paczoskii (Zefir.) Tzvelev [Compositae] 20/71 R former European USSR R Tanacetum praeteritum (Horwood) Heywood [Compositae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 R Taraxacum turiense N.1.Orlova [Compositae] 20171 R former European USSR R Tephroseris integrifolia (L.) Holub. ssp. karsianus Mathews [Compositae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 R Teucrium alyssifolium Stapf. [Labiatae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 R Teucrium antitauricum T. Ekim [Labiatae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 R Teucrium cavernarum Davis [Labiatae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Ex Teucrium leucophyllum Montbret & Aucher ex Bentham [Labiatae] 1/2840 Ex 12840 Turkey 12840 Vv Teucrium montbretii Bentham ssp. pamphlicum Davis [Labiatae] 12840 Vv 12840 Turkey 12840 R Teucrium odontites Davis & Bal. [Labiatae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 R Teucrium paederotoides Boiss. & Halkin [Labiatae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 R Teucrium pestalozzae Boiss. [Labiatae} 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 R Teucrium sandrasicum O. Schwarz [Labiatae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 R Thalictrum uncinatum Rehmann [Ranunculaceae] 20171 R former European USSR E Thermopsis turcica Kit Tan, Vural & Kucukoduk [Leguminosae] 1/2840 E 12840 Turkey 12840 R Thesium aureum Jaub. & Spach [Santalaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 R Thesium bertramii Aznavy. [Santalaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 R Thesium cilicicum Bornm. [Santalaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 R Thesium minkwitzianum B. Fedtsch. [Santalaceae] R former USSR 6930 R Thesium oreogetum hendrych [Santalaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Vv Thesium scabriflorum Davis [Santalaceae] 12840 Vv 12840 Turkey 12840 R Thesium stelleroides Jaub. & Spach -44- v ~] x FF FF [Santalaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Thlaspi aghricum Davis & Tan [Cruciferae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Thlaspi bornmuelleri (Rech.) Hedge [Cruciferae] 1/2840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Thlaspi cariense A. Carlstrom [Cruciferae] 12840 E 12840 Turkey 12840 Thlaspi cilicicum (Boiss.) Hayek [Cruciferae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Thlaspi crassum Davis [Cruciferae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Thlaspi densiflorum Boiss. & Kotschy [Cruciferae] /2840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Thlaspi dolichocarpum (Zobary) Greuter & Burdet [Cruciferae] 12840 Vv 12840 Turkey 12840 Thlaspi eigii (Zohary) Greuter & Burdet [Cruciferae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Thlaspi elegans Boiss. [Cruciferae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Thlaspi papillosum Boiss. [Cruciferae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Thlaspi sintenisii Hausskn. ex Bornm. [Cruciferae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Thlaspi watsonii Davis [Cruciferae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Thurya capitata Boiss. & Bal. [Caryophyllaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Thymbra sintenisii Bornm. & Azn. ssp. isaurica Davis [Labiatae] 12840 R 20618 Turkey 20618 Thymbra spicata L. var. intricata Davis [Labiatae] 12840 R 20618 Turkey 20618 Thymelaea cilcicica Meissner [Thymelaeaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Thymus argaeus Boiss. & bal. [Labiatae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Thymus aznavourii Velen. (Labiatae] 12840, 20171 E 14155 Turkey (Safrakéy, near Istanbul) 12840 Thymus binervulatus Klokov & Roussine [Labiatae] 3000, 20171 R former European USSR 8000 Thymus bornmuelleri Velen (Labiatae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Thymus borysthenicus Klokoy & Roussine [Labiatae]} 800/, 20171 R former European USSR (Black Sea) 8001 Thymus canoviridis Jalas [Labiatae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Thymus cappadocicus Boiss. var. cappadocicus [Labiatae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Single country endemic globally threatened plants : Labiatae: Thymus Thymus cappadocicus Boiss. var. globifer Jalas R Trichanthemis aurea Kraschen. [Compositae] 3001 a pp & [Labiatae] 12840 R former Asiatic USSR 6930 R 12840 Turkey 12840 R Trifolium apertum Bobrov var. kilaeum Zoh. & Thymus cariensis Huber-Mor. [Labiatae] 12840 lenr. [Leguminosae] /2840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Thymus convolutus Klokov [Labiatae] 12840 Vv Trifolium batmanicum Katznelson [Leguminosae] 12840 R 19873 Turkey 12840 \Y 12840 Turkey 12840 Thymus haussknechtii Velen. [Labiatae] 12840 R Trifolium davisii Hossain [Leguminosae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Thymus leucostomous Hausskn. & Velen. var. V Trifolium euxinum Zoh. [Leguminosae] 12840 argyllaceus Salas [Labiatae] 12840 V —s:12840 Turkey 12840 V_ 12840 Turkey 12840 R Trifolium longidentatum Nab. [Leguminosae] 12840 Thymus leucostomus Hausskn. & Velen var. gypsaceus R = 12840 Turkey 12840 Jalas [Labiatae] 12840 E Trifolium pachycalyx Zoh. [Leguminosae] 12840 Vv 12840 Turkey 12840 E 12840 Turkey 12840 Thymus pectinatus Fisch. & Mey. var. pectinatus R Trifolium roussaenanum Boiss. [Leguminosae] 12840 [Labiatae] 12840 R = 12840 Turkey 12840 Se natkeyy 12540 ‘ E Trigonella arenicola Huber-Mor. [Leguminosae] 12840 Thymus pubescens Boiss. & Kotschy var. cratericola E 12840 Turkey 12840 Jalas [Labiatae] 12840 R Trigonella cephalotes Boiss. & Bal. R 12840 Turkey 12840 é 3 [Leguminosae] /2840 Thymus pulvinatus Celak [Labiatae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 RR TEI R Trigonella cilicica Huber-Mor. [Leguminosae] 12840 Thymus revolutus Celak [Labiatae] 12340 R 12840 Turkey 12840 ee utkry 12600 ie Vv Trigonella halophila Boiss. [Leguminosae] 12840 Thymus sipyleus Boiss. var. davisianus V 12840 Turkey 12840 easel) 12340 R Trigonella lycica Huber-Mor. [Leguminosae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Thymus spathulifolius Hausskn. & Velen R _Trigonella pamphylica Huber-Mor. & Siri. [Labiatae] 12840 Fi [Leguminosae] /2840 R = 12840 Turkey 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Thymus talievii Kok. & Schost. [Labiatae] 3000 Vv Trigonella polycarpa Boiss. & Heldr. Vv former European USSR 8000 : : [Leguminosae] 12840 Tomanthea daralghezica (Fomin) Takht. [Compositae] V 12840 Turkey 12840 R : fommen SSH 16730 R Trigonella pseudocapitata Contandr. ex Quezel Tordylium elegans Alava & Huber-Mor. [Leguminosae] 12840 [Umbelliferae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 ee uekey 72840 R Trigonella rhytidocarpa Boiss. & Bal. Tordylium lanatum Boiss.) Boiss. [Leguminosae] 12840 [Umbelliferae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Ro! aid Gurkeye12330 R Trigonella rigida Boiss. & Bal. [Leguminosae] 12840 Tordylium macropetalum Boiss. [Umbelliferae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 R slg WEES Ha R Trigonella sirjaevii Huber-Mor. [Leguminosae] 12840 Tordylium pustulosum Boiss. [Umbelliferae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Bago 0) turkey: 12849 R Trigonosciadium intermedium Freyn & Sint. Torilis triradiata Boiss. & Heldr. [Umbelliferae] 12840 [Umbelliferae] 12840 R= 12840 Turkey 12840 a oe, tee 1280 R Trinia crithmifolia (Wild.) H.Wolff Tragopogon albinervis Freyn & Sint [Umbelliferae] 2017/ [Compositae] 12840 R former European USSR 2 RD TEES R Trinia kitaibelii auct., non M.Bieb. Tragopogon cretaceus S.A.Nikitin [Compositae] 20171 [Umbelliferae] 20171 Vv former European USSR R former European USSR Tragopogon fibrosus Freyn & Sint. ex Freyn Vv Tripleurospermum baytopianum E. Hossain [Compositae] 12840 [Compositae] 12840 R 19873 Turkey 12840 Vv 12840 Turkey 12840 Tragopogon oligolepis Hartvig & Strid R Tripleurospermum corymbosum E. Hossain [Compositae] 12840 [Compositae] 12840 R= 12840 Turkey 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Single country endemic globally threatened plants : Compositae: Tripleurospermum R Tripleurospermum fissurale (Sosn.) E. Hossain [Compositae] /2840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 R Tripleurospermum hygrophilum (Bornm.) Bornm. [Compositae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 R Tripleurospermum kotschyi (Boiss.) E. Hossain [Compositae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 R Tripleurospermum rosellum (Boiss. & Orph.) Hayek var. album E. Hossain [Compositae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 R Trisetum thospiticum Chrtek [Gramineae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 I Triticum timopheevii (Zhuk.) Zhuk. [Gramineae] 5942 I 5942 Georgia 5942 R Tulipa carinata Vved. [Liliaceae] R former USSR 6930 EK Tulipa fosteriana Irving [Liliaceae] E former USSR 6930 R Tulipa heteropetala Ledeb. [Liliaceae] R former USSR 6930 E Tulipa hoogiana B. Fedtsch. [Liliaceae] E former USSR 6930 Vv Tulipa korolkowii Regel [Liliaceae] Vv former USSR 6930 E Tulipa kuschkensis B. Fedtsch. [Liliaceae] E former USSR 6930 R Tulipa linifolia Regel [Liliaceae] R former USSR 6930 R Tulipa maximowiczii Regel [Liliaceae] R former USSR 6930 Vv Tulipa praestans Hoog [Liliaceae] Vv former USSR 6930 Vv Tulipa rhodopaea Vel. [Liliaceae] 5204 VY ——s-5204_—- Bulgaria (Southern Bulgaria - one site only.) 5204 R Tulipa rosea Vved. [Liliaceae] R former USSR 6930 R Tulipa schmidtii Fomin [Liliaceae] R former USSR 6930 Ex Tulipa sprengeri Baker [Liliaceae] 12840 Ex 12840 Turkey 12840 E Tulipa subpraestans Vved. [Liliaceae] E former USSR 6930 Tulipa tarda Stapf Liliaceae] R former USSR 6930 Tulipa urumoffii Hayek [Liliaceae] 5204, 20171 Vv 5204 Bulgaria (Rodopi) 8000 Tulipa wilsoniana Hoog [Liliaceae] Vv former USSR 6930 Tulipa zenaidae Vved. {Liliaceae} R former USSR 6930 Uechtritzia armena Freyn & Sint. [Compositae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Valeriana bolkarica Contandr. ex Quezel [Valerianaceae] /2840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 <4. 6h x we FR -46- Valeriana oliganthe Boiss. & Heldr. [Valerianaceae] /2840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Valeriana speluncaria Boiss. ssp. glabriuscula Contandr. ex Quezel [Valerianaceae] /2840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Velezia hispida Boiss. [Caryophyllaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Velezia pseudorigida Huber-Mor. [Caryophyllaceae] 12840 v 12840 Turkey 12840 Velezia tunicoides Davis [Caryophyllaceae] 12840 Vv 12840 Turkey 12840 Ventenata eigiana (H. Scholz & Raus) M. Dogan [Gramineae] 1/2840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Verbascum adenocarpum Huber-Mor. [Scrophulariaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Verbascum adenophorum Boiss. [Scrophulariaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Verbascum afyonense Huber-Mor. [Scrophulariaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Verbascum agastachyum Huber-Mor. [Scrophulariaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Verbascum amanum Boiss. [Scrophulariaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Verbascum anastasii Nab. [Scrophulariaceae] 12340 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Verbascum ancyritanum Bornm. [Scrophulariaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Verbascum anisophyllum Murb. [Scrophulariaceae] 8000, 20171 Vv 5204 Bulgaria (west) 8000 Verbascum antitauricum Huber-Mor. [Scrophulariaceae] /2840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Verbascum apiculatum Huber-Mor. [Scrophulariaceae] 1/2840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Verbascum ballsianum Murb. [Scrophulariaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Verbascum basivelatum Huber-Mor. [Scrophulariaceae] 12840 v 12840 Turkey 12840 Verbascum bellum Huber-Mor. [Scrophulariaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Verbascum biledschikianum Bornm. [Scrophulariaceae] /2840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Verbascum biscutellifolium Bentham [Scrophulariaceae] 1/2840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Verbascum bombyciferum Boiss. Single country endemic globally threatened plants | Scrophulariaceae: Verbascum [Scrophulariaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Verbascum bourgeauanum Huber-Mor. [Scrophulariaceae] /2840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Verbascum brandianum Huber-Mor. [Scrophulariaceae] /2840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Verbascum calycosum Hausskn. & Murb. [Scrophulariaceae] /2840 Ex 1/2840 Turkey 1/2840 Verbascum campestre Boiss. & Heldre. [Scrophulariaceae] /2840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Verbascum cariense Huber-Mor. [Scrophulariaceae] /2840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Verbascum cerinum Boiss. & Heldr. [Scrophulariaceae] /2840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Verbascum charputense Murb. var. adenophorum Huber-Mor. [Scrophulariaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Verbascum chazaliei Boiss. [Scrophulariaceae] 12840 Vv 12840 Turkey 12840 Verbascum cheiranthifolium Boiss. var. heldrechii Boiss. [Scrophulariaceae] /2840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Verbascum cheiranthifolium Boiss. var. obtusiusculum Huber-Mor. [Scrophulariaceae] 1/2840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Verbascum chionophyllum Huber et Mor. [Scrophulariaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Verbascum cholorostegium Bornm. et Murb. [Scrophulariaceae] 1/2840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Verbascum chrysorrhacos Boiss. [Scrophulariaceae] /2840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Verbascum cilicicum Boiss. [Scrophulariaceae] 12840 R = 12840 Turkey 12840 Verbascum cilicium (Boiss. et Heldr.) O. Kuntze [Scrophulariaceae] /2840 R= 12840 Turkey 12840 Verbascum coronopifolium (Boiss. et Bal.) O. Kuntz [Scrophulariaceae] /2840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Verbascum cucullatibracteatum Huber et Mor. [Scrophulariaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Verbascum cymigerum Huber et Mor. [Scrophulariaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Verbascum dalamanicum Huber et Mor. [Scrophulariaceae] 12840 Vs 12840 Turkey 12840 Verbascum davidoffii Murb. [Scrophulariaceae] 8000, 20171 V =: 5204 +=Bulgaria (south) 5204 -47- Verbascum davisianum Huber et Mor. [Scrophulariaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Verbascum decursivum Huber et Mor. [Scrophulariaceae] 1/2840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Verbascum degenii Halacsy [Scrophulariaceae] 12840, 20171 Vv 19873 Turkey 12840 Verbascum demirizianum Huber et Mor. [Scrophulariaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Verbascum detersile Boiss. et Heldr. [Scrophulariaceae] 12840 R_ 12840 Turkey 12840 Verbascum discolor Murb. [Scrophulariaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Verbascum diversifolium Hochst. [Scrophulariaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Verbascum drymophilum Huber et Mor. [Scrophulariaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Verbascum dudleyanum (Huber et Mor.) Huber et Mor. [Scrophulariaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Verbascum dumulosum Davis et Huber et Mor. [Scrophulariaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Verbascum eleonarae Huber et Mor. [Scrophulariaceae] 1/2840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Verbascum eriocarpum (Freyn & Sint.) Bornm. [Scrophulariaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Verbascum euphraticum Bentham [Scrophulariaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Verbascum exuberans Huber-Mor. [Scrophulariaceae] 12840 I 12840 Turkey 12840 Verbascum flabellifolium (Huber-Mor.) Huber-Mor. [Scrophulariaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Verbascum flavipannosum Huber-Mor. [Scrophulariaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Verbascum freynii (Sint.) Murb. [Scrophulariaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Verbascum germaniciae Hausskn. [Scrophulariaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Verbascum globiferum Huber-Mor. [Scrophulariaceae] 12840 R = 12840 Turkey 12840 Verbascum gracilescens Huber-Mor. [Scrophulariaceae] /2840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Verbascum hadschinense Freyn Single country endemic globally threatened plants : Scrophulariaceae: Verbascum [Scrophulariaceae] 12840 R = 12840 Turkey 12840 R Verbascum hajastanicum Bordz. [Scrophulariaceae] 800/ R former USSR 6930 Vv Verbascum helianthomoides Huber-Mor. [Scrophulariaceae] /2840 Vv 12840 Turkey 12840 R Verbascum heterobarbatum Huber-Mor. [Scrophulariaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 R Verbascum heterodontum Huber-Mor. [Scrophulariaceae] /2840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 R Verbascum iconicum Huber-Mor. [Scrophulariaceae] /2840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 R Verbascum inaequale Freyn & Sint. [Scrophulariaceae] /2840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 R Verbascum infidelium Boiss. & Hausskn. [Scrophulariaceae] /2840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 R Verbascum inulifolium Huber-Mor. [Scrophulariaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 R Verbascum isauricum Boiss. & Heldr. [Scrophulariaceae] /2840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Vv Verbascum jankaeanum Pancic [Scrophulariaceae] 8000, 20171 Vv 5204 Bulgaria (west) 5204 R Verbascum lachnopus Huber-Mor. [Scrophulariaceae] /2840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 R Verbascum latisepalum Huber-Mor. [Scrophulariaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 R Verbascum leiocarpum Murb. [Scrophulariaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 R Verbascum leiranthoides Murb. [Scrophulariaceae] /2840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 R Verbascum leptocladum Boiss. & Heldr. [Scrophulariaceae] /2840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 R Verbascum leuconeurum Boiss. & Heldr. [Scrophulariaceae] /2840 R= 12840 Turkey 12840 R Verbascum linearilobum (Boiss.) Huber-Mor. [Scrophulariaceae] /2840 R= 12840 Turkey 12840 R Verbascum linguifolium Huber-Mor. [Scrophulariaceae] /2840 R= 12840 Turkey 12840 Vv Verbascum lobatum Huber-Mor. [Scrophulariaceae] 12840 Vs: 12840 Turkey 12840 R Verbascum longipedicellatum Huber-Mor. [Scrophulariaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Verbascum luciliae (Boiss.) O. Kuntz [Scrophulariaceae] /2840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Verbascum luridifolium Huber-Mor. [Scrophulariaceae] 12840 R_ —12840 Turkey 12840 Verbascum lyratifolium Kochel [Scrophulariaceae] 1/2840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Verbascum maendri Bornm. [Scrophulariaceae] 12480 Vv Turkey 12480 Verbascum meincheanum Murb. [Scrophulariaceae] /2480 R Turkey 12480 Verbascum melitense Huber-Mor. [Scrophulariaceae] 12480 R Turkey 12480 Verbascum microsepalum Huber-Mor. [Scrophulariaceae] 1/2840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Verbascum murbeckianum Huber-Mor. [Scrophulariaceae] 12480 R Turkey 12480 Verbascum myrianthum Boiss. [Scrophulariaceae] 12480 R Turkey 12480 Verbascum napifolium Boiss. [Scrophulariaceae] 12480 R Turkey 12480 Verbascum nudatum Murb. [Scrophulariaceae] 12430 R Turkey 12480 Verbascum nudiusculum Huber-Mor. [Scrophulariaceae] 1/2480 R Turkey 12480 Verbascum obtusifolium Huber-Mor. [Scrophulariaceae] /2840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Verbascum olympicum Boiss. [Scrophulariaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Verbascum orbicularifolium Huber-Mor. [Scrophulariaceae] 1/2840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Verbascum pallidiflorum Huber-Mor. [Scrophulariaceae] /2840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Verbascum pellitum Huber-Mor. [Scrophulariaceae] 12840 R=: 12840 Turkey 12840 Verbascum pestalozzae Boiss. [Scrophulariaceae] /2840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Verbascum petiolare Boiss. & Kotschy [Scrophulariaceae] 1/2840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Mi Verbascum phrygium Bornm. [Scrophulariaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Verbascum pinardii Boiss. [Scrophulariaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 ingle country endemic globally threatened plants : Scrophulariaceae: Verbascum Verbascum pinetorum (Boiss.) O. Kuntze [Scrophulariaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Verbascum prusianum auct., non Boiss. [Scrophulariaceae] /2840, 20171 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Verbascum pseudoholotrichum Huber-Mor. [Scrophulariaceae] /2840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Verbascum pseudovarians Huber-Mor. [Scrophulariaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Verbascum pterocalycinum Huber-Mor. [Scrophulariaceae] /2840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Verbascum pterocladum Huber-Mor. [Scrophulariaceae] 1/2840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Verbascum pumiliforme Huber-Mor. [Scrophulariaceae] /2840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Verbascum pumilum Boiss. & Heldr. [Scrophulariaceae] /2840 V = 12840 Turkey 12840 Verbascum pyroliforme (Boiss. & Heldr.) O. Kuntze [Scrophulariaceae] /2840 Vv 12840 Turkey 12840 Verbascum reeseanum Huber-Mor. [Scrophulariaceae] 1/2840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Verbascum renzii Huber-Mor. [Scrophulariaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Verbascum rubricaule Boiss. & Heldr. [Scrophulariaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Verbascum serpenticola Huber-Mor. {Scrophulariaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Verbascum simavicum Huber-Mor. [Scrophulariaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Verbascum smyrnaeum Boiss. [Scrophulariaceae] 12840 Vv 12840 Turkey 12840 Verbascum songaricum Schrenk ex Fisch. & Mey. ssp. subdecurrens Huber-Mor. [Scrophulariaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Verbascum sorgerae (Huber-Mor.) Huber-Mor. [Scrophulariaceae] /2840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Verbascum spectabile Bieb. var. isandrum Huber-Mor. [Scrophulariaceae] 12840 R= 12840 Turkey 12840 Verbascum sphenandroides C. Koch. [Scrophulariaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Verbascum spodiotrichum (Huber-Mor.) Huber-Mor. [Scrophulariaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Verbascum stachydifolium Boiss. & Heldr. -49- [Scrophulariaceae] /2840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Verbascum stenocarpum Boiss. & Heldr. [Scrophulariaceae] 1/2840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Verbascum stenostachyum Huber-Mor. [Scrophulariaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Verbascum stepporum Huber-Mor. [Scrophulariaceae] 12840 Vv 12840 Turkey 12840 Verbascum subnivale Boiss. & Hausskn. [Scrophulariaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Verbascum subserratum Huber-Mor. [Scrophulariaceae] /2840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Verbascum tauri Boiss. & Kotschy [Scrophulariaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Verbascum tenue Murb. [Scrophulariaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Verbascum transolympicum Huber-Mor. [Scrophulariaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Verbascum trapifolium (Stapf.) Huber-Mor. [Scrophulariaceae] 1/2840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Verbascum trichostylum Huber-Mor. [Scrophulariaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Verbascum urceolatum Huber-Mor. [Scrophulariaceae] /2840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Verbascum urobracteatum Huber-Mor. [Scrophulariaceae] 1/2840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Verbascum vanense Huber-Mor. [Scrophulariaceae] 1/2840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Verbascum varians Freyn & Sint. var. stepporum Huber-Mor. [Scrophulariaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Verbascum varians Freyn & Sint. yar. trapezunticum Murb. [Scrophulariaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Verbascum vulcanicum Boiss. & Heldr. var. viridans Huber-Mor. [Scrophulariaceae] 12840 R = 12840 Turkey 12840 Veronica allahuekberensis Ozturk [Scrophulariaceae] 12840 E 12840 Turkey 12840 Veronica antalyensis Fischer, Erik & Sumbul [Scrophulariaceae] 12840 R = 12840 Turkey 12840 4 Veronica bombycina Boiss. et Kotschy ssp. bolkardaghensis Fischer [Scrophulariaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Veronica bombycina Boiss. & Kotschy ssp. froediniana Rech.f. [Scrophulariaceae] 12840 Single country endemic globally threatened plants R 12840 Turkey 12840 R Veronica cetikii Ozturk [Scrophulariaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 R Veronica cuneifolia D. Don ssp. massicytica Fischer [Scrophulariaceae] /2840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 R Veronica donii Rommpp [Scrophulariaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 I Veronica filifolia Lipsky [Scrophulariaceae} 5942 I 5942 Russia - North Caucasus 5942 R Veronica fredericae Fischer [Scrophulariaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 R Veronica fuhsii Freyn & Sint. [Scrophulariaceae] 1/2840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 R Veronica gentianoides Vahl. ssp. kopgecidiensis A. Ozturk [Scrophulariaceae] /2840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 R Veronica hispidula Boiss. & Huet ssp. ixodes (Boiss. & Bal.) Fischer [Scrophulariaceae] /2840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 R Veronica kotschyana Bentham [Scrophulariaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 R Veronica lycica E. Lehm. [Scrophulariaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 R Veronica macrostachya Vahl ssp. sorgerae Fischer [Scrophulariaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 R Veronica montbretti Fischer [Scrophulariaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 R Veronica oltensis Woronow [Scrophulariaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 R Veronica orientalis Miller ssp. carduchorum Davis [Scrophulariaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 R Veronica polium Davis [Scrophulariaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 R Veronica pusilla Kotschy var. erciyasdagi (Fischer) Fischer [Scrophulariaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 R Veronica quezelii Fischer [Scrophulariaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 R Veronica surculosa Bioss. & Bal. [Scrophulariaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 R Veronica tauricola Bornm. [Scrophulariaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 R Veronica thymoides Davis ssp. thymoides [Scrophulariaceae] /2840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 R Vicia canescens Lab. ssp. leucomalla (Bornm.) Davis [Leguminosae] 1/2840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 R Vicia glareosa Davis [Leguminosae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 R Vicia hololasia Woronow [Leguminosae] 11552 R 11552 Russian Federation (Caucasus) 1/1552 Vicia quadrijuga Davis [Leguminosae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Vicia splendens Davis [Leguminosae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Vincetoxicum rossicum (Kleopow) Barbar. [Asclepiadaceae] 2017/ R former European USSR 8000 Viola cilicica Contandr. ex Quezel [Violaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Viola crassifolia Fenzl [Violaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Viola dichroa Boiss. & Huet [Violaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Viola incisa Turcz. [Violaceae] 5942 I 5942 Russia (Siberia) - Altai (south) 5942 I 5942 Russia (Siberia) - Irkutsk (L. Baikal) 5942 I 5942 Russia (Siberia) - Krasnoyarsk 5942 Viola isaurica Contandr. ex Quezel [Violaceae] 1/2840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Viola oreades M.Bieb. [Violaceae] 8000, 20171 Vv 20655 Ukraine - Crimea 8000 Viola sandrasea Melchior [Violaceae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Zingeria verticillata (Boiss. & Bal.) Chrtek [Gramineae] 1/2840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Ziziphora serpyllacea M. Bieb. [Labiatae] 8001 R former Asiatic USSR (Caucasus) 800] Ziziphora taurica M. Bieb. ssp. cleonioides (Boiss.) Davis [Labiatae] 12840 R 12840 Turkey 12840 Zygophyllum darvasicum A. Boriss. [Zygophyllaceae] R former USSR 6930 | Zygophyllum kaschgaricum A. Boriss. [Zygophyllaceae] R former USSR 6930 Data sources for Single country endemic globally threatened plants 042 4071 Rackham, O. et al. (1983). Trees in the 21st century. Berkhamsted, A B Academic Publishers. 133p. Illus., maps. Velchev, V., Kozuharov, S., Bondev, I., Kuzmanov, B., & Markova, M. (1984). Chervena kniga na NR Bulgariya: izcheznali, zastrasheni ot izchezvane i redki rasteniya i zhivotni: tom 1. Rasteniya. [Red Data Book of the People's Republic of Bulgaria: v. 1. Plants]. Sofiya: Izdatelstvo na Bulgarskata Akademiya na Naukite. 447 pp. Bul (En, Rus). Illus., col. illus., maps. Borodin, A.M. et al. (1985). Krasnaya kniga SSSR: redkie i nakhodyashchiesya pod ugrozoi ischeznoveniya vidy zhivotnykh i rastenii. - izdanie vtoroe [2]: tom pervyi - vtoroi [1-2]. (2nd edition). [Plant Red Data Book for the USSR]. Moscow: Lesnaya Promyshlennost. Illus., col., maps. Vol. 1 - Animals; Vol. 2 - Plants. Takhtajan, A.L. (1981). Rare and vanishing plants of the USSR to be protected. Leningrad: Nauka. 202 pp. Tutin, T.G. et al. (eds.) (1964). Flora Europaea. (lst ed.). Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. 5 vols, 1964-1980. 2nd ed. vol 1 1993. Komaroy, V.L. & Shishkin, B.K. (1933). Flora URSS. Jerusalem, Israel: Academy of Sciences of the USSR, Moscow and Leningrad. 30 vols (1933-1964). Program for Scientific Translations. Vols 1-21 and 24 translated into English, 1963-1979, by N. Landau. Davis, P.H. (1965-1985). Flora of Turkey and the East Aegean Islands. 9 vols. Edinburgh: Edinburgh University Press. Illus., maps. Avishai, M. (1980). A list of oncocyclus Iris from the Middle East proposed for inclusion in the threatened plants survey. Includes notes on distribution. HMSO. (1895-1992). Index Kewensis plantarum phanerogamarum. Kew: Royal Botanic Gardens. Vols 1-2 published in 1895; 19 supplements up to 1993. CD-ROM version 1993 (Oxford University Press). Golovanov, V.D. et al. (eds.) (1988). Red Data Book of RSFSR, plants. Komarov, Moscow: Academy of Sciences of USSR, Botanical Institut of V.L. Rosagropromizdat. 591 pp. Col. illus., maps. Webster, G. & Huft, M.J. (1988). Revised synopsis of Panamanian Euphorbiaceae. Ann. Missouri Bot. Gard. 75(3):1087-1144. Ekim, T., Koyuncu, M., Erik, S., & Ilarslan, R (eds.). et al. (1989). Tiirkiye'nin tehlike altindaki nadir ve endemik bitki turleri. (Serie no: 18). [List of rare, threatened and endemic plants in Turkey prepared according to IUCN Red Data Book categories]. Ankara: Tiirkiye Tabiatini Koruma Dernegi [Turkish Association for the Conservation of Nature and Natural Resources]. 227 pp. Tu (En). Ekim, T. (1990). Letters to Chris Leon concerning Bern Convention - revision of Appendix I. 14155 14197 15934 17662 17663 17664 17665 17672 17781 19174 19266 19426 19709 19847 With data sheets. Anon. (no date). Annotated printout of Bern Convention - revision of Appendix I. 175 pp. Ekim, T., Koyuncu, M., Guner, A., & Vural, M. (1990). Conservation summary. Turkish species. Grey-Wilson, C. (1988). The genus Cyclamen. Portland, Oregon, USA: Timber Press. 147 pp. Mathew, B. (1992). Annotations to: Conservation status listing: Sternbergia. Mathew, B. (1983). A review of the genus Sternbergia. The Plantsman 5(1):1-16. Mathew, B. (1992). Annotations to: Conservation status listing: Galanthus. 3 pp. TPU printout. Walters, S.M. et al. (1986). The European Garden Flora. (1). 318 pp. Carter, S. (1992). Annotations to: Conservation status listing: Euphorbia. TPU printout. Morgan, V. & Leon, C. (1990). Bern Convention. Revision of Appendix I (Flora). Iriondo, J.M., De Hond, L.J., & Gémez-Campo, C. (1993). Current research on the biology of threatened plant species of the Mediterranean Basin aa Macaronesia: a database. (Preliminary Draft). Madrid, Spain: Commission for the Conservation of Plant Resources. Organization for the phyto-Taxonomic Investigation of the Mediterranean Area. (unpublished)209 pp. Includes database printout of 201 threatened species with details of the organisation undertaking research. Tutin, T.G., Burges, N.A., Chater, A.O., Edmondson, J.R., Heywood, V.H., Moore, D.M., Valentine, D.H., Walters, S.M., & Webb, D.A. (eds.). (1993). Flora Europaea Volume 1. (Second edition). Psilotaceae to Platanaceae. Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University Press. 581 pp. Anon. (1994). Correspondance with WCMC including list of plant species to be added to the CORINE Biotopes Project. Bulgarian Ministry of Environment. Peev, D. (1993). Convention on the conservation of European wildlife and natural habitats. Threatened plant species in Bulgaria including candidate species for Appendix I of the Bern Convention. Strasbourg: Council of Europe. Standing Committee, 13th meeting. Jordanov, D. (1976). Flora Reipublicae Populares Bulgarica (Flora of the People’s Republic of Bulgaria). Volume VI. Bulgaria: Jn Aedibus Academiae Scientiarum Bulgaricae. Data sources for Single country endemic globally threatened plants 19873 Atay, S. (1994). Annotations to WCMC printout entitled "Turkey - conservation status listing of plants” dated 21 June 1994. Includes list of corrections by Prof.Dr. Neriman Ozhatay. 20171 Tutin, T.G., Heywood, V.H., Burges, N.A., Valentine, D.H., Walters, S.M., & Webb, D.A. (eds.). (1995). Flora Europaea Vol 1-5. Electronic dataset supplied by R.J Pankhurst, Royal Botanic Garden Edinburgh, May 1995. 20283 Govaerts, R. (1994). Checklist of Quercus species world wide. 20618 Guener, A. (1995). Conservation status of Turkish woody plants. 12 pp. 20627 Degteva, S. (1995). Annotations to WCMC list of plants of the Russian Federation. 20628 Czerepanov, S.K. (ed.). (1995). Plantae vasculares rossicae et civitatum collimitanearum. St Petersburg: World and Family-95 Ltd. 990 pp. Russian Edition. 20649 Anon. (1936-1965). Flora of UkrSSR. Kiev: Publishing House of Academy of Sciences of Ukrssr. vol. 1-12. 20650 Andrienko, T.L. (1995). Annotations to WCMC list of plants of Ukraine, including new list of datasources for Ukraine. 20653 Anon. (1987). Determinant of higher plants of Ukraine. Kiev: Naukova Dumka. 546 pp. 20654 Anon. (1972). Determinant of higher plants of Crimea. Leningrad: Nauka. 560 pp. 20655 Anon. (1994). Red Book of the Ukraine. Kiev: Ukrainska Encyclopedia. part 1, animals part 2, plants in print. 20689 Nooteboom, H.P. (1985). Notes on Magnoliaceae with a revision of Pachylarnax and Elmerrillia and the Malesian species of Manglietia and Michelia. Blumea 31:65-121. 20698 Giiner, A. & Zielinski, J. (comps.). (1995). The conservation status of the Turkish woody flora. 17 pp. 21309 Talbot, S.S. (ed.). (1997). Rare Arctic Endemic Vascular Plants. (Draft 18/2/97 CAFF Plants). 84 pp. 21389 Davis, A.P. et al. (1997). CITES Bulb Checklist (Draft). For the genera: Cyclamen, Galanthus and Sternbergia. The Royal Botanic Gardens, Kew. 1-87 pp. 2: Globally threatened plants occurring in countries bordering the Black Sea R Abies koreana Wilson [Pinaceae] 15957 R 20761 Russia 15957 R 2076] Korea, South 15957 Acer heldreichii Orph. ex Boiss. ssp. visianii H. Maly [Aceraceae] 6062, 20/7] R 21091 Bosnia & Herzegovina 2/09] I 6062 Bulgaria (west) 8000 I 6062 (former) Yugoslavia 8000 Achillea oxyloba (DC.) Sch.Bip. ssp. schurti (Sch.Bip.) Heimerl [Compositae] 20/7] R 19947 Romania 17823 I 5942 Ukraine 5942 Alkanna primulifolia Griseb. [Boraginaceae] R Bulgana R Greece Alkanna stribrnyi Velen. [Boraginaceae] 5204, 20171 Vv 19426 Bulgaria (south) 5204 R (former) Yugoslavia Allium regelianum A.K.Becker [Alliaceae] 5942, 20171 E 11552 Russia (E.Europe) - South 11552 R 20655 Ukraine (south) 20649 Anthemis macrantha Heuff. [Compositae] 5204, 20171 R 5204 Bulgaria (west) 5204 R 19947 Romania 2063] Anthemis trotzkiana Claus ex Bunge [Compositae] 5942, 2017] I 5942 Russia (E.Europe) - South 5942 R 5942 Kazakhstan 5942 Arenaria rigida M.Bieb. [Caryophyllaceae] 8001, 20171 R 5204 Bulgaria (north-east) 5204 E 19949 Romania 2063] R former European USSR 800] Asperula suberosa Sibth. & Sm. [Rubiaceae] 5204, 20171 R 5204 Bulgaria (south-west) 5204 R Greece 8000 Astragalus arnacantha M.Bieb. [Leguminosae] 8000, 20171 R Bulgaria 8000 R 11552 Ukraine - Crimea 8000 Astragalus dasyanthus Pall. [Leguminosae] 3000, 20171 R Bulgaria 8000 V 20686 ‘Hungary 17786 R 20631 Romania 20631 R (former) Yugoslavia I Russia (E.Europe) - Northwest 8000 Betula raddeana Trautv. [Betulaceae] 5942 I 5942 Russia - North Caucasus 5942 I 5942 Georgia 5942 Biarum davisii Turrill [Araceae] 8000, 20171 Vv 1912] Greece (Simi) 19/21 Vv 1912] Turkey (south-west Anatolia) /9/2/ Buglossoides glandulosa (Velen.) R.Fern. [Boraginaceae] 5204, 20171 Vv 19426 Bulgaria (south) 5204 I 19417 Romania 19417 Buxus colchica Pojark. [Buxaceae] 5942 I 5942 Russia - North Caucasus 5942 I 5942 Azerbaijan 5942 I 5942 Georgia 5942 Campanula engurensis Charadze [Campanulaceae] 5942 I 5942 Russia - North Caucasus 5942 I 5942 Georgia 5942 Campanula transsilvanica Schur ex Andrae (Campanulaceae] 5204, 20/71 R 5204 Bulgaria (Southern and Western - three sites) 5204 Vv 19949 Romania 2063/ Carlina onopordifolia Besser ex Szafer, Kulcz. & Paw. [Compositae] 5942, 20/71 Vv 18216 Poland (south) 20800 I 5942 Ukraine 5942 Centaurea bagadensis Woronow [Compositae] 5942 I 5942 Russia - North Caucasus 5942 I 5942 Transcaucasus 5942 Centaurea carpatica (Porcius) Porcius [Compositae] 20/7/ R 19947 Romania 800] R 5942 Ukraine 5942 Centaurea taliewii Kieopow [Compositae] 1/552, 20171 I 5942 Russia (E.Europe) - South 5942 I 5942 Kazakhstan 5942 I 5942 Ukraine - Crimea 5942 Cladochaeta candidissima (M. Bieb.) DC. [Compositae] 800] I 5942 Russia - North Caucasus 5942 I 5942 Azerbaijan 5942 Colchicum fominii Bordz. [Colchicaceae] 8000, 20171 Vv 19949 Romania 8000 I 5942 Moldova 5942 I 5942 Ukraine 5942 Crambe steveniana Rupr. [Cruciferae] 5942, 20171 I 5942 Russia - North Caucasus 5942 I 5942 Transcaucasus 5942 I 5942 Ukraine - Crimea 5942 Crataegus taurica Pojark. [Rosaceae] 2017! R Ukraine - Crimea 8000 R former European USSR (Crimea) 8000 Crocus angustifolius Weston [Iridaceae] 5942, 2017! I 5942 Moldova 5942 I 5942 Ukraine 5942 i! Dactylorhiza kalopissii Erich Nelson [Orchidaceae] I 19425 Bulgaria 19425 R Greece Delphinium fissum Waldst. & Kit. [Ranunculaceae] 5942, 20/71 v 21091 Bosnia & Herzegovina 2/09] I 5942 Georgia 5942 I 5942 Moldova 5942 I 5942 Ukraine - Crimea 5942 Dianthus freynii Vandas [Caryophyllaceae] 6951, 20171 Vv 21091 Bosnia & Herzegovina 2/09] I Bulgaria 695] R (former) Yugoslavia 695/ Dianthus nardiformis Janka [Caryophyllaceae] 19266, 20171 R = 5204 Bulgaria (north & east) 5204 Vv 19608 Romania 8000 Dianthus pallidiflorus Ser. [Caryophyllaceae] 2017/ R Bulgaria I former European USSR Draba subcapitata Simm. [Cruciferae] 20850, 20171 I 20850 Canada - Franklin 20850 Globally threatened plants occurring in countries bordering the Black Sea : Cruciferae: Draba I Elytrigia stipifolia (Czern. ex Nevski) [Gramineae] 5942. 2017] I 5942 Russia - North Caucasus 5942 I 5942 Russia (E.Europe) - South 5942 I 5942 Ukraine 5942 I Epimedium colchicum (Boiss.) Trautv. [Berberidaceae] 5942 I 5942 Russia - North Caucasus 5942 I 5942 Georgia (Black Sea coast) 5942 Rut Epipactis pontica Taub. [Orchidaceae] 12840 I 19321 Slovakia 19321 R 19873 Turkey 12840 Vu Epipactis troodi Lindb.f. [Orchidaceae] 14230 Vv 19164 Cyprus 14230 Vv 19873 Turkey (Amanus mts.) 14230 I Erythronium caucasicum Woronow [Liliaceae] 5942 I 5942 Russia - North Caucasus 5942 I 5942 Georgia 5942 R Frankenia pulverulenta L. [Frankeniaceae] 17617, 20171 5204 Bulgaria (east) 5204 19949 Romania 20631 17617 China - Gansu (Mingqing) 11139 17617 China - Nei Monggol Zizhiqu (Ejinaqi) 11139 17617 China - Xinjiang Uygur Zizhiqu (Xingyun) 11139 R Fritillaria drenovskii Degen & Stoj. [Liliaceae] 8000, 20171 Vv 19426 Bulgaria (south west) 8000 7 RR<< R Greece (north east) 8000 R Fritillaria gussichiae (Degen & Dorfl.) Rix [Liliaceae] 8000, 20171 R Bulgaria 8000 R Greece 8000 R (former) Yugoslavia 8000 I u Galanthus alpinus Sosn. [Amaryllidaceae] 5942 I 5942 Armenia 5942 I 5942 Georgia 5942 Ru Galanthus lagodechianus Kem.-Nat. [Amaryllidaceae] 5942 R 11552 Russia - North Caucasus /1552 R 11552 Transcaucasus /]552 R Galium moldavicum (Dobrescu) Franco [Rubiaceae] 1/7762, 20/71 Vv 19949 Romania 20631 R former European USSR 800] I Gentiana paradoxa Albov [Gentianaceae] 5942 I 5942 Russia - North Caucasus 5942 I 5942 Georgia 5942 I Gladiolus palustris Gaudin [Iridaceae] 8000, 20171 Albania 8000 19710 Austria 8000 Bulgana 8000 2050 Czech Republic (Bohemia) /97/0 20528 France (east) 20528 19710 Germany 8000 19710 Hungary 8000 Italy 8000 14229 Liechtenstein 14229 18216 Poland 8000 Romania 8000 19710 Slovakia 19321 18154 Switzerland 8000 (former) Yugoslavia 8000 5942 Byelarus 5942 18216 Lithuania 17779 [2 Mem ilall col c2 Maal col c2 Maal cco iol 2 Mandl ciel * zoe I 5942 Ukraine 5942 Gymnospermium altaicum (Pallas) Spach ssp. odes; (DC.) E. Mayer & Pulevic [Berberidaceae] /0270 R 19121 Albania 19/2] E 14155 Greece (Peloponnisos) 20731] E 19949 Romania 8000 Haplophyllum balcanicum Vandas [Rutaceae] 5204, 20171 R 5204 Bulgaria (south) 5204 R Greece Heracleum carpaticum Porcius [Umbelliferae] 17823 20171 Vv 19949 Romania 2063/ R ‘former European USSR Tris acutiloba C. Meyer [lIridaceae] 5942 E 5942 Russia - North Caucasus 5942 E 5942 Azerbaijan (Caucasus) 5942 Jurinea taygetea Halacsy [Compositae] 20/7! Vv 19426 Bulgaria 19426 R Greece Koeleria sclerophylla P.A.Smirn. [Gramineae] 5942, 20171 I 5942 Russia (E.Europe) - South 5942 I 5942 Kazakhstan 5942 Lamium glaberrimum (K.Koch) Taliev [Labiatae] 2 E 20655 Ukraine - Crimea 20654 R former European USSR Larix decidua Mill. ssp. polonica (Racib.) Domin [Pinaceae] 20/7] Vv 18270 Poland (Carpathian Mts.) 18270 R 19947 Romania (Carpathian Mts.) 20650 E 20655 Ukraine (Carpathian Mts.) 20650 Laserpitium affine Ledeb. [Umbelliferae] 5942 R Turkey (Pontus range) 800] I 5942 Georgia 5942 Lathraea rhodopea Dingler [Scrophulariaceae] 5204, | 20171 R 5204 Bulgaria 5204 R Greece Lathyrus pancicti (Surisic) Adamovic [Leguminosae] 8000, 20171 Ex 5204 Bulgaria (west) 5204 R (former) Yugoslavia 8000 Leiospora exscapa (C. Meyer) Dvorak | [Cruciferae] 5942 I 5942 Russia (Siberia) - Altai 5942 I 5942 Kazakhstan 5942 Lepidium meyeri Claus [Cruciferae] 5942, 20171 I 5942 Russia (E.Europe) - South 5942 R 5942 Kazakhstan (north western) 5942 I 5942 Ukraine 5942 Lilium rhodopaeum Delip. [Liliaceae] 5204, 20171 | | Vv 19426 Bulgaria (south - one area and one site.) 5204 R 14000 Greece 14000 Liquidambar orientalis Miller var. orientalis (Hamamelidaceae] 206/8 R 20731 Greece - East Aegean Is (Rhodes) 2073/ E 20618 Turkey 20618 Malus florentina (Zuccagni) C.K.Schneid. [Rosaceae] 20/78, 2017] R 20178 Albania 20/78 Greece Italy Aw Globally threatened plants occurring in countries bordering the Black Sea : Rosaceae: Malus — R (former) Yugoslavia R 20678 Turkey (Anatolia) 206/8 Microcnemum coralloides (Loscos & J.Pardo) Buen [Chenopodiaceae] 8000, 20171 Vv Spain 8000 E Turkey 800] E former USSR 6930 Minuartia stojanovii (Kit.) Kozuharov & Kuzmanov [Caryophyllaceae] 5204 R 5204 Bulgaria (south-west) 5204 R Greece Moehringia jankae Griseb. ex Janka [Caryophyllaceae] 1/9266, 20171 R 5204 Bulgaria 19266 Vi 19949 Romania (Dolurogea) 19266 Najas tenuissima (A.Braun) Magnus [Hydrocharitaceae] 20673, 20171 20673 Finland 20673 5942 Russia (E.Europe) - Central 5942 5942 Russia (E.Europe) - Northwest 5942 5942 Estonia 5942 Nectaroscordum dioscoridis (Sibth. & Sm.) Zahar. [Alliaceae] 5942, 2017] I 5942 Azerbaijan 5942 I 5942 Ukraine 5942 Nectaroscordum tripedale (Trautv.) Grossh. [Alliaceae] 1/552 I 5942 Russia - North Caucasus 5942 Vv 11552 Armenia 1/552 Vv 11552 Azerbaijan 1/552 Onosma polyphylla Ledeb. [Boraginaceae] 5942, 20171 I 5942 Russia - North Caucasus (north) 5942 I 5942 Ukraine - Crimea 5942 Onosma rhodopea Velen. [Boraginaceae] I Bulgaria R Greece Ophrys argolica Feischm. ssp. elegans (Renz) Erich Nelson [Orchidaceae] /4230 \A 19164 Cyprus 14230 E 19873 Turkey 14230 te it Ophrys caucasica Woronow ex Grossh. [Orchidaceae] 5942, 20627 I 5942 Russia - North Caucasus 5942 I 5942 Armenia 5942 I 5942 Azerbaijan 5942 Ophrys oestrifera M.Bieb. [Orchidaceae] 5942, 20171 5942 Russia - North Caucasus 5942 5942 Armenia 5942 5942 Azerbaijan 5942 5942 Georgia 5942 5942 Ukraine - Crimea (south) 5942 Ornithogalum amphibolum Zahar. [Hyacinthaceae] 5942, 2017] R Bulgaria 8000 Vv 19949 Romania 8000 I 5942 Moldova 5942 Ornithogalum oreoides Zahar. [Hyacinthaceae] 8000, 20171 R Bulgaria 8000 I 19417 Romania 8000 I 5942 Moldova 5942 Paeonia steveniana Kem.-Nat. [Paeoniaceae] 5942 I 5942 Russia - North Caucasus 5942 I 5942 Georgia 5942 Papaver spicatum Boiss. & Bal. [Papaveraceae] 12840 — et bet Vv 17832 Norway 17832 R 12840 Turkey 1/2840 Phoenix theophrasti Greuter [Palmae] 3000. 20/7! Vv 14155 Greece - Crete 8000 Vv 20731 Turkey 20618 Picea koraiensis Nakai var. koraiensis [Pinaceae] /8270 R 18270 Russia (Ussuri River) 16386 R 18270 China - Jilin 16386 R 18270 Korea, North 16386 Pinus brutia Ten. var. pityusa (Stev.) Silba [Pinaceae] /8270 18270 Syria 18270 71552 Russia (Caucasus) //552 18270 Georgia (Black Sea coast) 18270 18270 Ukraine - Crimea 20654 Pinus densiflora Sieb. & Zucc. var. funebris (Komaroy) Liou & Wang [Pinaceae] /8270 Vv 18270 Russia (maritime province) 20497 R 18270 Korea, North 20497 Pinus peuce Griseb. [Pinaceae] /8270, 2017] E 20178 Albania 10370 R 18270 Bulgamra (west) 10370 R 18270 Greece (extreme north) 1/0370 R 18270 (former) Yugoslavia (south) /0370 Plantago schwarzenbergiana Schur [Plantaginaceae] 17786, 20/71 R 20686 Hungary 20686 R 19949 Romania 2063] I former European USSR Poa pirinica Stoj. & Acht. [Gramineae] 5204, 20171 R 5204 Bulgaria (south) 5204 R Greece Poa rehmannii (Asch. & Graebn.) Wol [Gramineae] 8000, 20171 R 19949 Romania 8000 I former European USSR 8000 Potentilla emilii-popii Nyar. [Rosaceae] 5204, 20171 R 5204 Bulgaria (North-eastern - two sites and one area) 5204 Vv 19949 Romania 2063] Pseudovesicaria digitata (C. Meyer) Rupr. [Cruciferae] 5942 5942 Russia - North Caucasus 5942 5942 Armenia 5942 5942 Azerbaijan (Caucasus Mts.) 5942 5942 Georgia (Caucasus Mts.) 5942 Pulmonaria filarszkyana Sav. [Boraginaceae] 17762, 20171 R 20631 Romania 20631 Vv former European USSR Quercus imeretina Stev. ex Woronow [Fagaceae] 5942 I 5942 Russia - North Caucasus 5942 I 5942 Georgia 5942 Ramonda serbica Pancic [Gesneriaceae] 8000, 20171 R 20178 Albania 20/78 R 5204 Bulgaria (north-west) 5204 Vv Greece R (former) Yugoslavia Rheum rhaponticum L. [Polygonaceae] 5204, 20171 R 5204 Bulgaria 5204 <<