Tr>ir>r?^'** ^^•--- ^ ^T"v ■^i'»«-'#*v,>- //^/y Z//^- LIBRARY OF 685-l©56 r^ 0--^ v,/ \ \ olO^ J'Ua rU/. tJ ^rji^ fUiiis/ied byLorowi.OL.mos/./la^-. Oijnf ^ ]:Sn>H-nJ.or>d^n.Juiu.i,k:-: AN INTRODUCTION TO ENTOMOLOGY: OR ELEMENTS OF THE NATURAL HISTORY OF INSECTS. WITH PLATES. By WILLIAM KIRBY, M.A. F.R. and L.S. RECTOR OF BARHAM, AND WILLIAM SPENCE, Esq. F.L.S. THIRD EDITION. ' VOL. I. I, LONDON: nUNTEU FOR LONGMAN, HUUST, REES, ORME, AND BROWN, PATERNOSTER ROW. 1818. Richard and Arthur Taylor, Printers, London. TO THE RIGHT HONOURABLE SIR JOSEPH BANKS, BARONET, ONE OF HIS majesty's MOST HONOURABLE PRIVY COUNCIL, KNIGHT GRAND CROSS OF THE ORDER OF THE BATH. PRESIDENT OF THE ROYAL SOCIETY, ETC. WHOSE UNRIVALLED LIBRARY AND PERSONAL COMMUNICATIONS HAVE FURNISHED MUCH OF THE MOST INTERESTING MATTER THAT IT CONTAINS, THE FOLLOWING WORK, IN WHICH AN ATTEMPT IS MADE TO COPY HIS ILLUSTRIOUS EXAMPLE, BY POINTING OUT THE CONNECTION THAT EXISTS BETWEEN NATURAL SCIENCE, AND AGRICULTURE, AND THE ARTS, IS, WITH HIS PERMISSION, MOST GRATEFULLY INSCRIBED BY HIS MOST OBLIGED AND OBEDIENT SERVANTS, THE AUTHORS. PREFACE. One principal cause of the little attention paid to Entomology in this country, has doubtless been the ridicule so often thrown upon the science. The botanist, sheltered now by the sanction of fashion, as formerly by the prescriptive union of his study with medicine, may dedicate his hours to masses and lichens without reproach ; but in the minds of most men, the learned as well as the vulgar, the idea of the trifling nature of his pursuit is so strongly associated with that of the diminutive size of its objects, that an entomo- logist is synonymous with every thing futile and childish. Now, when so many other roads to fame and distinction are open, when a man has merely to avow himself a botanist, a mineralogist, or a chemist — a student of classical literature or of political economy — to ensure attention and re- spect, there are evidently no great attractions to lead him to a science which in nine companies Out of ten with which he may associate promises VI PREFACE. to signalize him only as an object of pity or contempt. Even if he have no other aim than self-gratification, jei " the sternest stoic of us all Nvishes at least for some one to enter into his views and feelings, and confirm him in the opi- nion which he entertains of himself:" but how can he look for sympathy in a pursuit unknown to the world, except as indicative of littleness of mind ? Yet such are the genuine charms of this branch of the study of nature, that here as well as on the continent, where, from being' equally slighted. Entomology now divides the empire with her sister Botany, this obstacle would not have been sufficient to deter numbers from the study, had not another more powerful impediment existed — the want of a popular and comprehensive Intro- duction to the science. While elementary books on Botany have been multiplied amongst us with- out end and in every shape, Curtis's translation of the Fundamenia Entomologice, published in 1772 ; Yeats's Institutions; of Entomologij, which ap- peared the year after ; and Barbut's Genera Insec- torum, which came out in 1781 — the two former in too unattractive, and the latter in too expen- sive a form for general readers — are the only works professedly devoted to this object, which the English language can boast. PREFACE. VU Convinced that this was the chief obstacle to the spread of Entomology in Britain, the authors of the present work resolved to do what was in their power to remove it, and to introduce their countrymen to a mine of pleasure, new, bound- less, and inexhaustible, and which, to judge from their own experience — formed in no contracted field of comparison — they can recommend as pos- sessing advantages and attractions equal to those held forth by most other branches of human learning. The next question wasjin what way they should attempt to accomplish this intention. If they had contented themselves with the first suggestion that presented itself, and merely given a translation of one of the many Introductions to Entomology extant in Latin, German, and French, adding only a few obvious improvements, their task would have been very easy ; but the slightest examina- tion showed that, in thus proceeding, they would have stopped far short of the goal which they were desirous of reaching. — In the technical de- partment of the science they found much confu- sion, and numerous errors and imperfections — the same name sometimes applied to parts anato- mically quite different, and different names to parts essentially the same, while others of primary importance were without any name at all. And Vlll PREFACE. with reference to the anatomy and physiology of insects^ they could no where meet with a full and accurate generalization of the various facts connected with these subjects, scattered here and there in the pages of the authors who have studied them. They therefore resolved to begin, in some mea. sure, de novo — to institute a rigorous revision of the terms employed, making such additions and improvements as might seem to be called for ; and to attempt a more complete and connected account of the existing discoveries respecting the anatomical and physiological departments of the science than has yet been given to the world : — and to these two points their plan at the outset was limited. It soon, however, occurred to them, that it would be of little use to write a book which no one would peruse ; and that in the present age of love for light reading, there could not be much hope of leading students to the dry abstractions of the science, unless they were conducted through the attractive portal of the economy and natural history of its objects. To this department, there- fore, they resolved to devote the first and most con- siderable portion of their intended work, bringing into one point of view, under distinct heads, the most interesting discoveries of Reaumur, De Geer, PREFACE. IX Bonnet, Lyonet, the Hubcrs, &c,, as well as their own individual observations^ relative to the noxious and beneficial properties of insects; their affection for their young-; their food, and modes of obtain- ing it; their habitations; societies; &c. &c.: and they were the more induced to adopt this plan^ from the consideration, that, though many of the most striking- of these facts have before been pre- sented to the English reader, a great proportion are unknown to him ; and that no similar gene- ralization (if a slight attempt towards it in Smel- lie's Philosophy of Natural Hisiorij , and a confes- sedly imperfect one in Latreille's Histoirc Natu- rclle des CrusiacSs et des Insectes be excepted) has ever been attempted in any language. — Thus the entire work would be strictly on the plan of the Philosophia Eniomologica of Fabricius, only giv- ing a much greater extent to the (Econotnia and Usus, and adverting to these in the first place in- stead of in the last. The epistolary form was adopted, not certainly from any idea of their style being particularly suited to a mode of writing so difficult to keep from running into incongruities; but simply be- cause this form admitted of digressions and allu- sions called for in a popular work, but which might have seemed misplaced in a stricter kind of composition ; — because it is better suited to X PREFACE. convey those practical directions, which in some branches of the pursuit the student requires; — and lastly, because by this form, the objection against speaking of the manners and economy of insects before entering upon the definition of them, and explaining the terms of the science — a retrograde course, which they have chosen from their desire to present the most alluring side of the science first — is in great measure, if not wholly, obviated. Such is the plan which the authors chalked out for themselves — a plan which in the execution they have found so much more extensive than they calculated upon, that, could they have foreseen the piles of volumes through which it has entailed upon them the labour of wading, often to glean scarcely more than a single fact — the numerous anatomical and technological investigations which it has called for — and the long correspondence, almost as bulky as the entire work, unavoidably rendered necessary by the distant residence of the parties — they would have shrunk from an under- taking, of which the profit, if by great chance there should be any, could not be expected to repay even the cost of books required in it, and from which any fame must necessarily be confined to a very limited circle. But having entered upon it, they have persevered ; and if they succeed ia PREFACE. XI their grand aim, that of making' converts amongst tlieircountrvmen to a study equally calculated for promoting the glory of God and the delight and profit of man, they will not deem the labour of the leisure hours of six years ill bestowed. And here it may be proper to observe, that one of their first and favourite objects has been to di- rect the attention of their readers " from nature up to nature's God," For, when they reflected upon the fatal use which has too often been made of Natural History, and that from the very works and wonders of God, some philosophists, by an unaccountable perversion of intellect, have at- tempted to derive arguments either against his being and providence, or against the Religion revealed in the Holy Scriptures, they conceived they might render some service to the most im- portant interests of mankind, by showing how every department of the science they recommend illustrates the great truths of Religion, and proves that the doctrines of the Word of God, instead of being contradicted, are triumphantly confirmed by his Works. " To see all things in God" has been accounted one of the peculiar privileges of a future state; and in this present life, " to see God in all things/' in the mirror of the creation to behold and adore the reflected glory of the Creator^ is no mean at- XU PREFACE. tainment ; and it possesses this advantage^ that thus we sanctify our pursuits, and, instead of loving the creatures for themselves, are led by the survey of them and their instincts to the love of Him who made and endowed them. Of their performance of the first part of their plan, in which there is the least room for origi- nality, it is only necessary for the authors to say that they have done their best to make it as com- prehensive, as interesting, and as useful as pos- sible : but it is requisite to enter somewhat more fully into what has been attempted in the anato- mical, physiological, and technical parts of the work. As far as respects the general physiology and interior anatomy of insects, they have done little more than bring together and combine the obser- vations of the naturalists who have attended to these branches of the science : but the exterHor anatomy they have examined for themselves through the whole class, and, they trust, not with- out some new light being thrown upon the sub- ject; particularly by pointing out and giving names to many parts never before noticed. In the Terminology, or what, to avoid the bar- barism of a word compounded of Latin and Greek, they would beg to call the Orismology o^ \he sci- ence, they have endeavoured to introduce through- PREFACE. Xiii oulagreater degree of precision and concinnitj — dividing it into general and partial Orismology ; — under the former head defining such terms as relate to Substance, Resistance, Density, Propor- tion, Figure, Form, Superjicies, ( under which are introduced Scw/p/wre, Clothing, Colour, &c.) Mar- gin, Termination, Incision, Ramification, Division, Direction, Situation, Connection, Arms, &c. ; and under the latter those that relate to the body and its parts and members, considered in its great sub- divisions of Head, Trunk and Abdomen. In short, they may rest their claim of at least aiming at con- siderable improvement in this department upon the great number of new terms, and alterations of old ones, which they have introduced — in ex- ternal Anatomy alone falling little short of 150. If it should be thought by any one that they have made too many changes, they would remind him of the advice of Bergman to Morveau, when re- forming the nomenclature of Chemistry, the sound- ness of which Dugald Steward has recognised — " Nefaites grace ci aucunc denomination impropre, Ceu.v qui savent (lejci, entendront toiijours ; ceux qiii ne savent pas encore, entendront plutot." Throughout the whole publication, wherever any fact of importance not depending on their own authority is mentioned, a reference to the source whence it has been derived is generally XIV PREFACE. given ; so that;, if the work should have no other value^ it will possess that of saving- much trouble to future inquirers, by serving as an index to di- rect them in their researches. The authors are perfectly sensible that, not- withstanding all their care and pains, many im- perfections will unavoidably remain in their work. There is no science to which the adage, Dies diem clocei, is more strikingly applicable than to Natu- ral History. New discoveries are daily made, and will be made, it is probable, to the end of time : so that whoever flatters himself that he can pro- duce a perfect work in this department will be miserably disappointed. The utmost that can reasonably be expected from naturalists is to keep pace with the progress of knov^ledge, and this the authors have used their best diligence to accom- plish. Every new year since they took the sub- ject in hand up to the very time when the first sheets were sent to the press, numerous correc- tions and alterations have suggested themselves ; and thus they are persuaded it would be were tlioy to double the period of delay prescribed by Ho- race. But Poetry and Natural History are on a different footing; and though an author can plead little excuse for giving his verses to the world while he sees it possible to polish them to higher excellence, the naturalist, if he wishes to promote PREFACE. \X the extension of his science, must be content to submit his performances to the public disfigured bj numerous imperfections. In the introductory letter several of the advan- tages to be derived from the studj of Entomology are pointed out ; but there is one, which^ though it could not well have been insisted upon in that place, is too important to be passed over without notice — its value in the education of youth. AH modern writers on this momentous subject unite in recommending in this view. Natural His- tory; and if *'the quality of accurate discrimi- nation— the ready perception of resemblances amongst diversities, and still more the quick and accurate perception of diversity in the midst of resemblances— constitutes one of the most im- portant operations of the understanding ; if it be indeed the foundation of clear ideas, and the acquisition of whatever can be truly called know- ledge depends most materially on the possession of it: — if ^'^ the best logic be that which teaches us to suspend our judgements;" and " the art of seeing, so useful, so universal, and yet so uncom- mon, be one of the most valuable a man canpos- sess," — there can be no doubt of the judiciousness -of their advice. Now of all the branches of Na- tural History, Entomology is unquestionably the best fitted for thus disciplining the mind of youth; Xyi PREFACE, and simply from this circumstance, that its objects have life, are gifted with surprising instincts ad- mirably calculated to attract youthful attention, and are to be met with every where. It is not meant to undervalue the good effects of the study of Botany or Mineralogy: but it is self-evident ' that nothing inanimate can excite such interest in the mind of a young person as beings endowed with vitality, exercising their powers and facul- ties in so singular a way; which, as Reaumur observes, are not only alive themselves, but confer animation upon the leaves, fruits, and flowers that they inhabit; which every walk offers to view; and on which new observations may be made without end. Besides these advantages, no study affords a fairer opportunity of leading the young mind by a natural and pleasing path to the great truths of Religion, and of impressing it with the most lively ideas of the power, wisdom, and goodness of the Creator. Not that it is recommended to make children collectors of insects, nor that young people, to ihe neglect of more important duties and pursuits, should generally become professed Entomolo- oists; but, if the former be familiarized with their names, manners, and economy, and the lat- ter initiated into their classification, it will be an PREFACE. XVll excellent nietliod of strengthening their habits of observation, attention, and niemorj', equal per- haps, in this respect, to any other mental exercise: and then, like Major Gyllenhal, Mho studied En- tomology under Thunberg about 1770, and after an interval of twenty years devoted to the service of his country^ resumed his favourite pursuit vv^ith all the ardour of youth, and is at this time giving to the world a description of the insects of Sweden invaluable for its accuracy and completeness — they would be provided in their old age with an object capable not merely of keeping off that icedinm vit{S so often inseparable from the relin- quishment of active life, but of supplying an un- failing fund of innocent amusement, an incentive to exercise, and consequently no mean degree of health and enjoyment* Some, who, with an ingenious author*, regard as superfluous all pains to show the utility of Na- tural History in reference to the common pur- poses of life, asking '' if it be not enough to open a source of copious and cheap amusement, which tends to harmonize the mind, and elevatcjjt to worthy conceptions of nature and its Author? if a greater blessing to a man can be offered than happiness at an easy rate unalloyed by any dc- * Dr. Aikin. VOL. 1. b XVIU PREFACE. basing mixture ? " — may think the earnestness dis- played on this head^ and the length which has been gone in refuting objections, needless. But Entomology is so peculiarly circumstanced^ that without removing these obstacles, there could be no hope of winning votaries to the pursuit. Pliny felt the necessity of following this course in the outset of his book which treats on insects, and a similar one has been originally called for in intro- ducing the study even to those countries where the science is now most honoured. In France, Reaumur, in each of the successive volumes of his immortal work, found it essential to seize every opportunity of showing that the study of insects is not a frivolous amusement, nor devoid of uti- lity, as his countrymen conceived it; and in Ger- many Sulzer had to traverse the same road, telling us, in proof of the necessity of this procedure, that on showing his works on insects with their plates to two very sensible men, one commended him for employing his leisure hours in preparing prints that would amuse children and keep them out of mischief, and the other admitted that they might furnish very pretty patterns for ladies' aprons ! And though in this country things are not now quite so bad as they were when Lady Glanville's will was attempted to be set aside on the ground of lunacy, evinced by no other act PREFACE. XIX than her fondness for collecting insects, and Ray had to appear at Exeter on the trial as a witness of her sanity*, yet nothing less than line upon line can be expected to eradicate the deep-rooted prejudices which prevail on this subject. " Old impressions," as Reaumur has well observed, '•^are with difficulty effaced. They arc weakened, they appear unjust even to those who feel them, at the moment they are attacked by arguments which are unanswerable; but the next instant the proofs are forgotten, and the perverse association resumes its empire." The authors do /not know that any curiosity will be excited to ascertain what share has been contributed to the work by each of them ; but if there should, it is a curiosity they must be ex- cused from gratifying. United in the bonds of a friendship, which, though they have to thank Entomology for giving birth to it, is founded upon a more solid basis than mere community of scientific pursuits, they wish that, whether blame or praise is the fate of their labours, it may be jointly awarded. All that they think necessary to state is, that the oomposition of each of the dif- ferent departments of the work has been, as * See Harris's Aurelian under Papilio Cinxiq. XX PREFACE. nearly as possible, divided between them ;— -that though the letter, or series of letters, on any par- ticular subject, has been usually undertaken by one, some of the facts and illustrations have ge- nerally been supplied by the other, and there are a few to which thev have iointlv contributed : — and that, throughout, the facts for which no other authority is quoted, are to be considered as resting upon that of one or other of the authors, but not always of him who, from local allusions^ may be conceived the writer of the letter in which they are introduced, as the matter furnished by each to the letters of the other must necessarily be given in the person of the supposed writer. In acknowledging their obligations to their friends, the first place is due to Simon Wilkin, Esq. of Costessey near Norv^'ich, to whose libe- rality they are indebted for the numerous plates which illustrate and adorn the work ; the whole of which have been drawn and engraved by liis artist Mr. John Curtis, whose intimate ac- quaintance with the subject has enabled him to give to the figures an accuracy which they could not have received from one less conversant with the science. Nor is the reader less under obliga- tion to Mr. Wilkin's liberality than the authors;^ PREFACE, XXI who, if the drawings &c. had been to be paid for, must necessarily have contented themselves with 2,'iving; a much smaller number. To Alexander MacLeay, Esq. they are un- der particular obligations, both for the warm in- terest he has all along taken in the work, the ju- dicious advice he has on many occasions given, the free access in which he has indulged the authors to his unrivalled cabinet and well-stored library, and the numerous other attentions and acconmiodations by which he has materially as- sisted them in its progress. To the other friends who have kindly aided them in this undertaking in any way, they beg here to offer their best thanks. It now only remains that they should assign their reasons for sending the work into the world, contrary to their original intentions, in an imper- fect state, by the publication of the first volume only. One inducement to this course has been the occurrence of unexpected interruptions, which, though the bulk of the work has been long writ- ten, have hitherto precluded the completion of the entire plan ; but their principal reason has been the wish to render the physiological and anatomi- cal departments more perfect by the consultation of various continental works published within the last six or eight years, navy for the first tinie ac- XXU PREFACE. cessible ; and to ascertain, by the public recep- tion of this first part, whether it will be expedient to give the remainder that extension which was at one time contemplated, or to contract it within narrower limits. A history of Entomology, and a complete list of entomological works, (for which last Mr. Dryander*s admirable catalogue of Sir Joseph Banks's library affords the fullest mate- rials,) entered into the original plan, and the rough draught of both is completed ; but whether these (which are not essential to a work of this nature) will be published, must depend upon the judgement of the public as to the value of that portion now submitted to them. The contents of the remaining volumes will be nearly as follows. Societies of Insects, including the History of Ants, Wasps, Bees, &c. Motions of insects. Noises of insects. Means of defence from their enemies. Luminous insects. Hyber- nation of insects. Instinct of insects. Definition of theterm Jwsfc^. States of insects — Egg; Larva; Pupa ; Imago. Their general exterior Anatomy — Head ; Trunk ; Abdomen. Their interior Ana- tomy and Physiology — Sensation ; Respiration ; Circulation ; Digestion ; Secretion ; Generation, Diseases, &c. Senses of insects. Orismology and Definitions of terms. Characters of insects — ^ Class, Order, Family, Genus, Species, Variety, PREFACE. XXni Investigation of insects. Seasons in which they appear. Instruments and mode of taking and preserving them, — with other particulars which it is not necessary here to enumerate. The List of Authors quoted in this work will be found in the last volume. It was intended to have given with this all the plates illustrative of the orders, but only three could be finished in time : the remainder will appear in the second volume, and those which relate to the anatomy and definitions in the third and fourth. CONTENTS OF VOL. 1. Letter Page' I. Introductory,.. 1 — 20 II. Objections ans\yerecl5. ... i 21^--59 III. Metamorphoses of Insects,. 60 — 80 IV. Direct Injuries caused by Insects, 81—144 V. Indirect Injuries caused by Insects. 1. Injuries to our living aninaal Property, 145—167 VI. Indirect Injuries continued. 2. Injuries to our living vegetable Pro- perty, 168—214 VII. The same subject continued. — The Ra- vages of Locusts, 215 — 226 VIII. Indirect Injuries concluded. 3. Injuries to our dead Property, whe- ther animal or vegetable, 227 — 249 IX. Indirect Benefits derived from Insects, .. 250—300 X. Direct Benefits derived from Insects, .... 301 — 339 XL Affection of Insects for their Young, 340—383 XII. Food of Insects, * 384—404 XIII. The same subject continued, 405—^435 XIV. Habitations of Insects. 1. Of Solitary Insects, ** 436^477 XV. Habitations of Insects continued. 2. Of Insects in Society,. 478—519 ERRATA. Pao;e 104, note * line uU. after " had" insert " them." Page 841, line 27, insert as a note to " Comegen." " We learn from Hum- boldt {Travels, iii. p. 253, note*. Miss Williams's translation), that the insects called by this name in S. America are White Ants." Pa^e 421, note a line 1, for 405 read 407. AN INTRODUCTION TO ENTOMOLOGY. LETTER I. Dear Sir, '■ I CANNOT wonder that ah active mind like yours should experience no small degree of tedium in a situation so far removed, as you represent your new residence to be, from " the busy hum of men." Nothing certainly can compensate for the want of agreeable society ; but since your case in this respect admits of no remedy but patience, I ani glad you are desirous of turning your attention to some pursuit which may amuse you in the intervals of severer study, and in part supply the void of which you complain. I am not a little flattered that you wish to be informed which class in the three king- doms of nature is, in my opinion, most likely to answer your purpose ; at the same time intimating that you feel inclined to give the preference to Entomology, provided some objections can be satisfactorily obvi- ated, which you have been accustomed to regard as urged with a considerable semblance of reason against the cultivation of that science. VOL. I, B 2 INTRODUCTORY LETTER. Mankind in general, not excepting even philoso' phers, are prone to magnify, often beyond its just me- rit, the science or pursuit to which they have addicted themselves, and to depreciate any that seems to stand in competition with their favourite : like the redoubted champions of romance, each thinks himself bound to take the field against every one that will not subscribe to the peerless beauty and accomplishments of his own Dulcinea. In such conflict for pre-eminence I know no science that, in this country, has come off worse than Entomology : her champions hitherto have been so few, and their effbrts so unavailing, that all her rival sisters have been exalted above her ; and I believe there is scarcely any branch of Natural Histoi-y that has had fewer British admirers. While Botany boasts of myriads, she, though not her inferior either in beauty, symmetry, or grace, has received the homage of a very slender train indeed. Since therefore the merits of Entomology have been so little acknowledged, you will not deem it invidious if I advocate the cause of this di- stressed damsel, and endeavour to effect her restoration to her just rights, privileges, and rank. Things that are universally obvious and easy of exa- mination, as they are the first that fall under our no- tice, so are they also most commonly those which we first feel an inclination to study ; while, on the con- trary, things that must be sought for in order to be seen, and which when sought for avoid the approach and inquiring eye of man, are often the last to which he directs his attention. The vegetable kingdom stands in the former predicament. Flora with a liberal hand has scattered around u§ her charming productions j INTRODUCTORY LETTER. 3 they every where meet and allure us, enchanting usby> their beauty, regaling- us by their fragrance, and in- teresting us as much by their subservience to our luxu- ries and comfort, as to tlie necessary support and well- being of our life. Beasts, birds, and fishes also, in some one or other of these respects, attract our notice ; but insects, unfortunate insects, are so far from attract- ing us, that we are accustomed to abhor them from our childhood. The first knowledge that we get of them is as tormentors ; they are usually pointed out to us by those about us as ugly, filthy, ajid noxious creatures ; and the whole insect world, butterflies perhaps and some few others excepted, are devoted by one universal ban to proscription and execration, as fit only to be trodden under our feet and crushed : so that often, be- fore we can persuade ourselves to study them, we have to remove from our minds prejudices deeply rooted and of long standing. Another principal renson which has contributed to keep Entomology in the back ground arises from tlie diminutive size of the objects of Avhich it treats. Being amongst the most minute of nature's productions, they do not so readily catcli the eye of the observer ; and when they do, mankind in general are so apt to estimate the worth and importance of things by their bulk, that because we usually measure them by the duodecimals of an inch instead of by the foot or by the yard, insects are deemed too insignificant parts of the creation, and of too little consequence to its general welfare, to ren- der them worthy of any serious attention or study. What small foundation there is for such prejudices and misconception, I shall endeavour to show in the course b2 4. INTRODUCTORY LETTER. of our future correspondence ; my object now, as the champion and advocate of Entomology, is to point out to you her comparative advantages, and to remove the veil which has hitherto concealed those attractions, and that grace and beauty, which entitle her to equal ad- miration at least with her sister branches of Natural History. In estimating the comparative value of the study of any department in this branch of science, we ought to contrast it with others, as to the rank its objects hold in the scale of being ; the amusement and instruction which the student may derive from it ; and its utility to soci- ety at large. With respect to public utility, the study of each of the three kingdoms may perhaps be allowetl to stand upon nearly an equal footing ; I shall not, therefore, enter upon that subject till I come to con- sider the question Cui bono? and to point out the uses of Entomology, but confine myself now to the two first of these circumstances. As to rank, I must claim for the entomologist some degree of precedence before the mineralogist and the botanist. The mineral kingdom, whose objects are nei- ther organized nor sentient, stands certainly at the foot of the scale. Next above this is the vegetable, whose lovely tribes, though not endued with sensation, are or- ganized. In the last and highest place ranks the animal World, consisting of beings that are both organized and sentient. To this scale of precedence the great modern luminary of Natural History, notwithstanding that Bo- tany was always his favourite pursuit, has given hi« sanction, acknowledging in the preface to his Fauna Suecica, that although the vegetable kingdom isnobler INTRODUCTORY LETTER. 5 than the mineral, yet the animal is more excellent than the vegetable. Now it is an indisputable axiom, I should think, that the more exalted the object the more excellent the study. By this observation, however, I would by no means be thought to depreciate or dis- countenance the study either of plants or minerals. All the works of our Creator are great, and worthy of our attention and investigation, the lowest in the scale as well as the highest, the most minute and feeble, as well as those that exceed in magnitude and might. Nor ought those whose inclination or genius leads them to one department, to say to those who prefer another— *' we have no need of you" — for each in his place, by diffusing the knowledge of his works and adding to the stock of previous discoveries, contributes to promote the glory of the Great Architect of the universe and the good of his creatures. It is not my wish to claim for my favourite science more than of right belongs to her; therefore, when the question is concerning rank, I must concede to the higher orders of animals, I mean Fishes, Amphibia, Birds, and Quadrupeds, their due priority and prece- dence. I shall only observe here, that there may exist circumstances which countervail rank, and tend to ren- der the study of a lower order of beings more desirable than that of a higher : when, for instance, the objects of the higher study are not to be come at or preserved without great difficulty and expense ; when they are few in number ; or, when they are already well ascer- tained and known : circumstances which attach to the study of those animals that precede insects, while they do not attach to the study of insects themselves. O INTRODUCTORY LETTER. With regard to the amusement and instruction of the student, much doubtless may be derived from any one of the sciences alluded to : but Entomology certainly is not behind any of her sisters in these respects ; and if you are fond of novelty, and anxious to make new discove- ries, she will open to you a more ample field for these than either Botany or the higher branches of Zoology. A new animal or plant is seldom to be met with even by those who have leisure and opportunity for exten- sive researches ; but if you collect insects you will find, however limited the manor upon which you can pursue your game, that your efforts are often rewarded by the capture of some non-descript or rarity at present not possessed by other entomologists, for I have seldom seen a cabinet so meager as not to possess some unique spe- cimen. Nay, though you may have searched every spot in your neighbourhood this year, turned over every stone, shaken every bush or tree, and fished every pool, you will not have exhausted its insect productions. Do the same another and another, and new treasures will still continue to enrich your cabinet. If you leave your own vicinity for an entomological excursion, your pro- spects of success are still further increased ; and even if confined in bad weather to your inn, the windows of your apartment, as I have often experienced, will add to your stock. If a sudden shower obliges you at any time to seek shelter under a tree, your attention will bd attracted, and the tedium of your station relieved, ■where the botanist could not hope to find even a new ' lichen or moss, by the appearance of several insects, (driven there perhaps by the same cause as yourself, th3,t you have not observed before. Should you, as X INTRODUCTORY LETTRR, 7 trust you will, feel a desire to attend to the manners and economy of insects,and become ambitious of making discoveries in this part of entomological science, I can assure you, from long experience, that you will here find an inexhaustible fund of novelty. For more than twenty years my attention has been directed to them, and during most of my summer walks my eyes have been employed in observing- their ways ; yet I can say with truth, that so far from having exhausted the sub- ject, within the last six months I have witnessed more interesting facts respecting their history than in many preceding y^ars. To follow only the insects that fre- quent your own garden, from their first to their last state, and to trace all their proceedings, would supply an interesting amusement for the remainder of your life, and at its close you would leave much to be done by your successor ; for where we know thoroughly the history of one insect, there are hundreds concerning which we have ascertained little besides the bare fact of their existence. But numerous other sources of pleasure and informa- tion will open themselves to you, not inferior to what any other science can furnish, when you enter more deeply into the study. Insects, indeed, appear to have been nature's favourite productions, in which, to mani- fest her power and skill, she has combined and concen- trated almost all that is either beautiful and graceful, interesting and alluring, or curious and singular, in every other class and order of her children. To these, her valued miniatures, she has given the most delicate touch and highest finish of her pencil. Numbers she has armed with glittering mail, which reflects a livstre like 8 INTRODUCTORY LETTER. that of burnished metals '^; in others she lights up the dazzling radiance of polished gems'". Some she has decked with what looks like liquid drops, or plates of gold and silver*^; or with scales or pile, which mimic the colour and emit the ray of the same precious me- tals^. Some exhibit a rude exterior, like stones in their native state ^, while others represent their smooth and shining face after they have been submitted to the tool of the polisher : others, again, like so many pygmy At- lases bearing on their backs a microcosm, by the rug- ged and various elevations and depressions of their tu- berculated crust, present to the eye of the beholder no unapt imitation of the unequal surface of the earth, now horrid with mis-shapen rocks, ridges, and precipices — now swelling into hills and mountains, and now sinking into valleys, glens, and caves ^; while not a few are co- vered with branching spines, which fancy may form into a forest of trees ^, What numbers vie with the charming offspring of Flora in various beauties ! some in the delicacy and variety of their colours, colours not like those of flowers evanescent and fugitive, but fixed and durable, survi- ving their subject, and adorning it as much after death as they did when it was alive ; others, again, in the veining and texture of their wings; and others in the rich cottony down that clothes them. To such perfec- tion, indeed, has nature in them carried her mimetic art, a The Genera Eumolpus, F. Lamprima, Latr. Rynchites, Herbst. b A non-descript RynchcEnus, F. from Brazil. e Haperia Cipido, F. PapUio Passijlorcp, Lathonia, L. &c. A Pepsis /w semble tliem in their form, substance, and vascular structure ; some representing green leaves, and others those that are dry and withered*. Nay, sometimes this mimicry is so exquisite, that you would mistake the whole insect for a portion of the branching spray of a tree''. No mean beauty in some plants arises from the fluting and punctation of their stems and leaves, and a similar ornament conspicuously distinguishes nume" rous insects, which also imitate with multiform variety, as may particularly be seen in the caterpillars of many >^pecies of the butterfly tribe {Papilionidce)^ the spines and prickles which are given as a Noli me tarigere ar-» mour to several vegetable productions. In fishes the lucid scales of varied hue that cover and defend them are universally admired, and esteemed their peculiar ornament; but place a butterfly's wing under a microscope, that avenue to unseen glories in new worlds, and you will discover that nature has en- dowed the most numerous of the insect tribes with the same privilege, multiplying in them the forms'^, and diversifying the colouring of this kind of clothing be- yond all parallel. The rich and velvet tints of the plumage of birds are not superior to what the curious observer may discover in a variety o^ Lepidoptera ; and those many-coloured eyes which deck so gloriously the peacock's tail are imitated with success by one of our a Various species of the genera Locusta and Mantis, F. b Many species of Phasma, c De Geer, I, t. 3. /. 1—34, &c. 10 INTRODUCTORY LETTER, most common butterflies*. Feathers are thou.'jht to be peculiar to birds ; but insects often imitate them in their antennae'', win^*^, and even sometimes in the covering of their bodies '\ — We admire with reason the coats of quadrupeds, whether their skins ]>e covered with pile^ or wool, or fur, yet are not perhaps aware that a vast variety of insects are clotlied with ail these kinds of hair, but infinitely finer and more silky in tex- ture, more brilliant and delicate in colour, and more vanously shaded than what any other animals can pre- tend to. In variegation insects certainly exceed every other class of animated beings. Nature, in her sportive mood, when painting them, sometimes imitates the clouds of heaven ; at others, the meandring course of the rivers of the earth, or the undulations of their waters : many ere veined like beautiful marbles; others have the semblance of a robe of the finest net- work thrown over them ; some she blazons with heraldic insignia, giving tliem to bear in fields sable — azure — vert — gules — ar- gent and or, fesses — bars — bends — crosses — crescents — stars, and even animals'". On many, taking her rule and compasses, she draws with precision mathematical figures; points, lines, angles, triangles'^, squares, and circles. On others she pourtrays, with mystic hand, what seem like hieroglyphic symbols, or inscribes them with the characters and letters of various languages, often very correctly formed^; and what is more extra^ a Papilio lo, L. t> Culex, L. Chironomxts, Meig. and other TipulidtE. c PterophoniSy F. d Hairs of many of the Jpidce. Mon.Ap.Ang. I. /. 10, **cl. l./.l. b. « Plinus imperialis, L. f Tnchius delta, F. E PrioHUS iongimanus, F. Papilio C. album, L. Bjmbyx 4') Nodua y, F, INTRODUCTORY LETTER. 11 ordinary, she has registered in others figures which correspond with several dates of the Christian era^. Nor has nature been lavish only in the apparel and ornament of these privileged tribes ; in other respects she has been equally unsparing of her favours. To some she has given fins liiie those of fish, or a beak resembling that of birds'' ; to others horns, nearly the counterparts of those of various quadrupeds. The bull% the stag'\ the rhinoceros'", and even the hitherto vainly sought for unicorn *^, have in this respect many re- presentatives amongst insects. One is armed with tusks not unlike those of the elephant'; another is bristled with spines, as the porcupine and hedge-hog with quills'"; a third is an armadillo in miniature; the dis- proportioned hind legs of the kangaroo give a most grotesque appearance to a fourth'; and the threaten- ing head of* the snake is found in a fifth''. It would, however, be endless to protluce all the instances which occur of such imitations ; and I shall only remark that, generally speaking, these arms and instruments in structure and finishing far exceed those which they^ resemble. But further, insects not only mimic, in a manner in- finitely various, every thing in nature, they may also with very little violence be regarded as symbolical of beings out of and above nature. The butterfly, adorned a On the underside of the primary wings near the margin in Papili« Iglaia, Lathonia, Silene, &c. b Empis, f . Asilm, L. c Copris Taurus, F. d Lucanus Cervut, L. e Oryctes, Latr, f Geuirupcs Htrcules,F. S Melitta spinigera, Kirby. h Hispa, L, f Cclonia macropw^, Mus. Francil!. t Raphidia ophiopsis, h. 12 INTllODUCTORY LETTER. with every beauty and every g^race, borne by radiant wings through the fields of fether, and extracting nec- tar from every flower, gives us some idea of the bless- ed inhabitants of happier worlds, of angels, and of the spirits of the just arrived at their state of perfection. Again, other insects seem emblematical of a different class of unearthly beings : when we behold some tre- mendous for the numerous horns and spines projecting in horrid array from their head or shoulders ; — others for their threatening jaws of fearful length, and armed with cruel fangs : when we survey the dismal hue and demoniac air that distinguish others, the dens of dark- ness in which they live, the impurity of their food, their predatory habits and cruelty, the nets which they spread, and the pits which they sink to entrap the unwary, we can scarcely help regarding them as aptly symbolizing evil demons, the enemies of man, or of im- pure spirits for their vices and crimes driven from the regions of light into darkness and punishment^. The sight indeed of a well-stored cabinet of insects will bring before every beholder not conversant with them, forms in endless variety, which before he would not have thought it possible could exist in nature, re- sembling nothing that the other departments of the animal kingdom exhibit, and exceeding even the wild- est fictions of the most fertile imaginations. Besides prototypes of beauty and symmetry, there in miniature he will be amused to survey (for the most horrible creatures when deprived of the power of injury become a This idea seems to have been present to the mind of Linne and Fa- bricius, when they gave to insects such names as Beliebub, Belial^ Titans Tijpkon, Ninuod, Geryon, and tlie like. INTKODTJCTORY LETTERii 13 Rources of interest and objects of curiosity), to use the words of our great poet, all prodigious things Abominable, unutterable, and worse Than fables yet have feign'd, or fear conceiv'd, Gorgons, and Hydras, and Chiraaeras dire. But the pleasures of a student of the science to which I am desirous of introducing you, are far from being confined to such as result from an examination of the exterior form and decorations of insects; for could these, endless as they seem, be exhausted, or, wonder- ful as they are, lose their interest, yet new sourcesj exuberant in amusement and instruction, may be open- ed, which will furnish an almost infinite fund for his curiosity to draw upon. The striking peculiarity and variety of structure which they exhibit in their instru» ments of nutrition, motion, and oviposition, in their organs of sensation, generation, and the great fountains of vitality, indeed their whole system, anatomically considered, will open a world of wonders to you with which you will not soon be satiated, and during ycuir survey of which you will at every step feel disposed t6 exclaim with the Roman naturalist — '" In these being^ so minute, and as it were such non-entities, what wis;, dom is dis-played, what power, what unfathomable per- fection^!" But even this will not bring you to thfe end of your pleasures : you must leave the dead to visit the living ; you must behold insects when full of lif& and activity, engaged in their several employment?, • Plin. ffisf. »r.(f.l. ll.c.g. 14r INTRObUCiaRY LETTEIT. practising their various arts, pursuing their artioar^* and preparing habitations for their progeny : you must notice the laying and kind of their eggii, their wonder- ful metamorphoses ; their instincts, whether tKey be solitary or gregarious, and the other miracles of their history — all of which w ill open to you a richer mine of amusement and instruction, I speak it without hesita- tion, than any other departuient of Natural History can furnish. A minute enumeration of these particulars would be here misplaced, and only forestall what will be detailed more at large hereafter : but a rapid glance at a very few of the most remarkable of them, may serve as a stimulus to excite your curiosity, and induce you to enter with greater eagerness into the wide field to which I shall conduct you. The lord of the creation plumes himself upon his powers of invention, and is proud to enumerate the vari- ous useful arts and machines to which they have given birth, not aware that " He who teacheth man know- ledge"has instructed these despised insects to anticipate him in many of them. The builders of Babel doubtless? thought their invention of turning earth into artificial stone, a very happy discovery^; yet a little bee*' had practised this art, using indeed a different process, on a small scale, and the white ants on a large one, ever since the world began. Man thinks that he stands un- rivalled as an architect, and that his buildings are with- out a parallel among the w orks of the inferior orders of animals. He would be of a different opinion did he attend to the history of insects : he would find that a. Gen. xi. 3. b Slegachile wuraria, Latr. INTRODUCTORY LETTER. 15 many of them have been architects from time imme- morial ; tliat they have had their ho'L;.ses divided into various apartments, and containing staircases, gigan- tic arches, domes, colonnades, and the like; nay, that even tunnels are excavated by them so immense, com- pared with their own size, as to be t\^ elve times big£;er than that projected by Mr. Dodd to be carried under the Tiiames at Gravesend^. The modern fine lady, who prides herself on the Ir.stre and beauty of the scar- let hangings winch adorn the stately walls of her draw- ing-r^om, or the carpets tlmt cover its floor, fancying that nothing so riclj and splendid was ever seen before, and pitying her vulgar ancestors, who v.'ere doomed to unsightly white-wash and rushes, is ignorant all the while, that before she or her ancestors were in exist- ence, and even before the boasted Tyrian dye was dis- covered, a little insect had known how to hang the m alls of its cell with tapestry of a scarlet more brilliant than any her rooms can exhibit*', and that others daily weave silken carpets, both in tissue and texture infi- nitely superior to those she so much admires. Other arts have been equally forestalled by these creatures. What vast importance is attached to the invention of paper! For near six thousand years one of our com- monest insects has known how to make and apply it to its purposes'^; and even pasteboard, superior in sub- stance and polish to any we can produce, is manufiic- tured by another''. We imagine that nothing short of human intelkct can be equal to the construction of a a The while aiits. b Megachile Papaveris, I.a'r, c Tlie tomraoi) wusp. d Polisiei mdulans, Latr. 16 INTRODtrCTORY tETTER* diving-bell or an air-pump — yet a spider is in the daily habit of using the one, and, what is more, one exactly similar in principle to ours, but more ingeniously con- trived ; by means of which she resides unwetted in the bosom of the v/ater, and procures the necessary sup- plies of air by a much more simple process than our alternating buckets^ — and the caterpillar of a little moth knows how to imitate the other, producing a va- cuum, when necessary for its purposes, without any piston besides its own body*". If we think with won- der of the populous cities which have employed the united labours of man for many ages to bring them to their full extent, what shall we say to the white ants, which require only a few months to build a metropolis capable of containing an infinitely greater number of inhabitants than even imperial Nineveh, Babylon, Rome, or Pekin, in all their glory ? That insects should thus have forestalled us in our inventions, ought to urge us to pay a closer attention to them and their ways than we have hitherto done, since it is not at all improbable that the result Would be many useful hints for the improvement of our arts and manufactures, and perhaps for some beneficial dis- coveries. The painter might thus probably be fur- nished with more brilliant pigments, the dyer with more delicate tints, and the artisan with a new and improved set of tools. In this last respect insects de- sei've particular notice. All their operations are per- formed with admirable precision and dexterity ; and though they do not usually vary the mode, yet that ' a Aranea aquatica, L. b Phalcena Tinea serratella,h. INTRODUCTORY LETTER. 17 mode is always the best that can be conceived for at- taining the end in view. The instruments also with which they are provided are no less wonderful and va- rious than the operations themselves. They have their saws, and files, and augers, and gimlets, and knives, and lancets, and scissors, and forceps, with many other similar implements ; several of which act in more than one capacity, and with a complex and alternate mo- tion to which we have not yet attained in the use of our tools. Nor is the fact so extraordinary as it may seem at first, since "He who is wise in heart and wonderful in working" is the inventor and fabricator of the ap- paratus of insects ; which may be considered as a set of miniature patterns drawn for our use by a Divine hand. I shall hereafter give you a more detailed ac- count of some of the most striking of these instruments ; and if you study insects in this view, you will be well repaid for all the labour and attention you bestow upon them. But a more important species of instruction than any hitherto enumerated may be derived from entomologi- cal pursuits. If we attend to the history and manners of insects, they will furnish us with many useful les- sons in Ethics, and from tliem we may learn to improve ourselves in various virtues. We have indeed the in- spired authority of the w'sest of mankind for studying them in this view, since he himself wrote a treatise upon them, and sends his sluggard to one for a lesson of wis- dom ^. And if we value diligence and indefatigable in- dustry; judgement, prudence, and foresight; economy and frugality; if we look upon modesty and diffidence a 1 Kings iv. 33. Prov. vi. 6— 8. VOL. I. C ]8 INTRODUCtOllY tETTEK« as female ornaments; if we revere parental affection— of all these, and many more virtues, insects in their va- rious instincts exhibit several striking examples, as you will see in the course of our Correspondence. With respect to religious instruction insects are far from unprofitable! indeed in if his view Entomology seems to possess peculiar advantlages above every other branch of Natural History. In the larger animals, though we admire the consummate art and wisdom manifested in their structure, and adore that Almighty power and goodness which by a wonderful machinery, kept in motion by the constant action and re-action of the great positive and negative powers of Nature, main- tains in full force the circulations necessary to life, per- ception, and enjoyment ; yet as there seems no dispro- portion between the objects and the different operations that are going on in them, and we see that they afford •sufficient space for the play of their systems, we do not experience the same sensations of wonder and astonish- ment that strike us when we behold similar operations carried on without interruption in animals scarcely vi- sible to the naked eye. That creatures, which in the scale of being are next to non-entities, should be ela- borated with so much art and contrivance, have such a number of parts botli internal and external, all so highly finished and each so nicely calculated to answer its end ; that they should include in this evanescent form such a variety of organs of perception and instruments of mo- tion, exceeding in number and peculiarity of structure those of other animals ; that their nervous and respi- ratory systems should be so complex, their secretory and digestive vessels so various and singular, their parts iNTRODlTCTOUY LETTERi 19 bf generation so clearly developed, and that these minims of nature should be endowed with instincts in many cases superior to all our boasted powers of in- tellect— truly these wonders and miracles declare to every one who attends to the subject, " The hand that made us is divine." We are the work of a Being infi- nite in power, in wisdom, and in goodness. But no religious doctrine is more strongly establshedi by the history of insects than that of a superintending Providence. That of the innumerable species of these beings, many of them beyond conception fragile and exposed to dangers and enemies without end, no link should be lost from the chain, but all be maintained in those relative proportions necessary for the general good of the system ; that if one species for a while pre- ponderate, and instead of preserving seem to destroy, yet counterchecks should at the same time be provided to reduce it within its due limits ; and further, that the operations of insects should be so directed and over- ruled as to effect the purposes for which they were created and never exceed their commission : nothing can furnish a stronger proof than this, that an unseen hand holds the reins, now permitting one to prevail and now another, as shall best promote certain wise ends; and saying to each, " Hitherto shalt thou come and no further." So complex is this mundane system, and so incessant the conflict between its component parts, an observa- tion which holds good particularly with regard to in- sects, that if instead of being under such control it were left to the agency of blind chance, the whole must in- evitably soon be deranged and go to ruin. Insects, i^ 20 INTROOUCTORY LETTER. , truth, are a book in which whoever reads under proper impressions cannot avoid looking from the cause to the effect, and acknowledging- his eternal power and god- head thus wonderfully displayed and irrefragably de- monstrated : and whoever beholds these works with the eyes of the body, must be blind indeed if he cannot, and perverse indeed if he will not, with the eye of the soul behold in all hss glory the Almighty Workman, and feel disposed, with every power of his nature, to praise and magnify *'Hini first, llimlast. Him midst. Him without end." And now having led you to the vestibule of an august temple, which in its inmost sanctuary exhibits enshrined in glory the symbols of the Divine Presence, I should invite you to enter and give a tongue to the Hallelu- jahs, which every creature in its place, by working his will with all its faculties, pours forth to its great Crea- tor ; but I must first endeavour to remove, as I trust I shall effectually, those objections to the study of these interesting beings which I alluded to in the outset of this letter, and this shall be the aim of my next address. I am, &c. LETTER II. OBJECTIONS ANSWERED. In my last I gave you a general view of the science of Entomology, and endeavoured to prove to you that it possesses attractions and beauty sufficient to reward any student who may profess himself its vo- tary. I am now to consider it in a less alluring light, as a pursuit attended by no small degree of obloq^iiy, in consequence of certain objections thought to be urged with great force against it. To obviate these, and remove every scruple from your mind, shall be the business of the present letter. Two principal objections are usually alleged with great confidence against the study and pursuit of in- sects. By some they are derided as trifling and un- important, and deemed an egregious waste of time and talents ; by others they are reprobated as unfeel- ing and cruel, and as tending to harden the heart. I. I shall begin with the first of these objections — that the entomologist is a mere trifler. As for the silly outcry and abuse of the ignorant vulgar, who are always ready to laugh at what they do not un- derstand, and because insects are minute objects con- clude that the study of them must be a childish pur- suit, I shall not waste words upon what I so cor- dially despise. But since even learned men and phi- 22^ OBJECTIONS ANSWERED, losophers, from a partial and prejudiced view of tlie subject, having recourse to this common-place logic, are sometimes disposed to regard all inquiry into these minutisB of nature as useless and idle, and the mark of a little mind; to remove such prejudice and mis-; conceptions I shall now dilate somew hat upon the subr ject of Cui bono ? When we see many wise and learned men pay at- tention to any particular department of science, we piay naturally conclude that it is on account of some profit and instruction which they foresee may be de- rived from it; and therefore in defending Entomology I shall first have recourse to the Argumentum ad ve^ recundiam, and mention the great names that have cultivated or recommended it. We may begin the list v/ith the first man that ever lived upon tile earth, for we are told that he gave a, name to every living creature *, amongst which insects must be included ; and to give an appvopriate name ta an object necessarily requires some knowledge of its distinguishing properties. Indeed one of the principal pleasures and employments of the paradisiacal state was probably the study of the various works of crea-- lion ''. Before the fall the book of nature was the Bible of man, in which he could read the perfections and at-? tributes of the invisible Godhead'', and in it, as in a mirror, behold an image of the things of the spiritual world. Moses also appears to have been conversant with our little animals, and to have studied them with some attention. This he has shown, not only by being aware of the distinctions which separate the Gr^/lidce a Gen. ii> 19, b Linn. Fn. Succ. Prjpf. c Rotus i. 19, 20. OftJlCTtONS ANSWEttEO. 83 (Giyllits L.) into different genera% hiit also by no- ticing the different direction of the two anterior from the four posterior legs of insects; for, as he speaks of them as going upon four legs'", it is evident that he considered the two anterior as arms. Solomon, the wisest of mankind, made Natural History a peculiar object of study, and left treatises behind him upon its various branches, in which creeping things or insects were not overlooked*^; and a wiser than Solomon di- rects our attention to natural productions, when he bids us consider the lilies of the field "^j teaching us that they are more worthy of our notice than the most glo- rious works of man : he also not obscurely intimates that insects are symbolical beings, when he speaks of scorpions as synonymous with evil spirits'^; thus giving into our liands a clue for a more profitable mode of studying them, as furnishing moral and spiritual in- struction. If to these scriptural authorities we add those of uninspired writers, ancient and modern, the names of many worthies, celebrated both for wisdom and virtue, may be produced. Aristotle among the Greeks, and Pliny the elder among the Romans, may be denomi- nated the fathers of Natural History, as well as the greatest philosophers of their day ; yet both these made insects a principal object of their attention : and in more recent times, if we look abroad, what names greater than those of Hedi, Malpighi, Vailisnieri, Swammerdam, Leeuwenhoek, Reaumur, Linnc, De a Levit. ,\i.21,22. Lichtenstein in Linn. Trans, iv. 51,5?. b Levit. xi. 20. conf. Bochart. Ilicrozoic, it. 1. 4. c. 9. 497'«8. c 1 Kings iv. S3, d LuHe xii. 27. e ibid. x. 19, 20, 24 OBJECTIONS ANSWERED. Geer, Bonnet, and the Hubers ? and at home, what pliilosophers have done more honour to their country and to human nature than Ray, Willughby, Lister, and Derham ? Yet all these made the study of insects one of their most favourite pursuits ; and, as if to prove that this study is not incompatible with the highest flights of genius, we can add to the list the name of one of the most sublime of our poets, Gray, who was very zealously devoted to Entomology. As far therefore as names have weight, the above enumeration seems sufficient to shelter the votaries of this pleasing science from the charge of folly. But we do not wish to rest our defence upon autho- rities alone ; let the voice of reason be heard, and our justification will be complete. The entomologist, or, to speak more generally, the naturalist (for on this question of Cui bono? every student in all departments of Natural History is concerned), if the following con- siderations be allowed their due weight, may claim a much higher station amongst the learned than has hi- therto been conceded to him. There are two principal avenues to knowledge — the study of words and the study of things. Skill in the learned languages being often necessary to enable us to acquire knowledge in the former way, is usually considered as knowledge itself; so that no one asks Cui bono ? when a person devotes himself to the study of verbal criticism, and employs his time in correcting the errors that have crept into the text of an ancient writer. Indeed it must be owned, though perhaps too much stress is sometimes laid upon it, that this is very useful to enable us to ascertain his true meaning. But OBJECTIONS ANSWERED. 25 after all, words are but the arbitrary signs of ideas, and have no value independent of tJiosc ideas, further than what arises from congruity and l»arniony,the mind be- ing dissatisfied when an idea is expressed by inade- <|uate words, and the ear offended when their colloca- tion is inharmonious. To account the mere knowledge of words, therefore, as wisdom, is to mistake the cask for the wine, and the casket for the gem. I say all this because knowledge in words is often extolled beyond its just merits, and put for all Avisdom, while kno-n - ledge of things, especially of the productions of na- ture, is derided as if it were mere folly. We should recollect that God hath condescended to instruct us by both these ways, and therefore neither of them should be depreciated. He hath set before us his word and his world. The former is the great avenue to truth and knowledge by the study of words, and, as being the immediate and authoritative revelation of his will, is entitled to our principal attention ; the latter leads us to the same conclusions, though less directly, by the study of things, which stands next in rank to that of God's word, and before that of any work of man. And whether we direct our eyes to the planets rolling in their orbits, and endeavour to trace the laws by which they are guided through the vast of space, whether we analyse those powers and agents by which all the ope- rations of nature are performed, or whether we con- sider the various productions of this our globe, from the mighty cedar to the microscopic mucor — from the giant elephant to the invisible mite, still we are study- ing the works and wonders of our God. The book, to wliatever page we turn, is written by the finger of hira 26 OtiJECTIONS ANSWERED. who created us ; and in it, provided our minds be rightly disposed, we may read his eternal verities. And the more accurate and enlarged our knowledge of his works, the better shall we be able to understand his word ; and the more practised we are in his word, the more readily shall we discern his truth in his works; for, proceeding from the same great Author, they must, when rightly interpreted, mutually explain and illustrate each other. Who then shall dare maintain, unless he has the har- dihood to deny that God created them, that the study of insects and their ways is trifling or unprofitable ? Were they not arrayed in all their beauty, and surrounded with all their wonders, and made so instrumental (as I shall hereafter prove them to be) to our welfare, that we might glorify and praise him for them ? Why were insects made attractive, if not, as Ray well expresses it, that they might ornament the universe and be de- lightful objects of contemplation to man^? And is it not clear, as Dr. Paley has observed, that the produce tion of beauty Avas as much in the Creator's mind in painting a butterfly or in studding a beetle, as in giv- ing symmetry to the human frame, or graceful curves to its muscular covering T And shall we think it be^ peath us to study what he hath not thought it beneath a " Quaeri fortassc a nonmiUis potest, Quis Papilioiium iisus sit ? Re-e si>ondeo, Ad ornatuin Universi, et lit liominibus spectaciilo sint : ad riira, illustranda velut totbracteae iiiservientes. Quisenim eximiani eariim pul- chrkiidinem et varietatcm contemplans inira voliiptafe non afficiatiir ? Qiiis tot colornm et sehematum elegantias naturae ipsiiis ingenio excogi- ^tas et artifici jK'nicillo depictas curiosis oculis intuens,diviiia3 artis ves- tigia (iis iraprcssa non agnoscat et mirctur? " Rui. HijC^Ins. 109, b Na(. Tlicol. 213. OBJECTIONS ANSWERED. 27 him to adorn and place on this great theatre of crea- tion ? Nay, shall we extol those to tlie skies who bring together at a vast expense the most valuable specimens of the arts, the paintings and statues of Italy and Greece, all of which, however beautiful, as works of man, fall short of perfection ; and deride and upbraid those who collect, for the purpose of admiring their beauty, the finished and perfect chef-d'oeuvres of a Divine artist? May we gaze with rapture unblamed upon an Apollo of Belvedere, or Venus de Medicis, or upon the exquisite paintings of a Raphael or a Titian, and yet when we behold with ecstasy sculptures that are produced by the chisel of the Almighty, and the inimitable tints laid on by his pe^icil, because an in- sect is the subject, be exposed to jeers and ridicule? But there is another reason, which in the present age renders the study of Natural History an object of importance to every well-wisher to the cause of Reli- gion, who is desirous of exerting his faculties in its de- fence. For as enthusiasm and false religion have en- deavoured to maintain their ground by a perversion of the text of scripture, so also the patrons of infidelity and atheism have laboured hard to establish their im- piety by a perversion of the text of nature. To refiiter the first of these adversaries of truth and sound reli- gion, it is necessary to be well acquainted with the zoord of God; to refute the second requires an inti- mate knowledge of his works ; and no department can furnish him with more powerful arguments of every kind than the world of insects — every one of which ci'ics out in an audible voice, There is a God — lie isf 28 OBJECTIONS ANSWERED. Almighty, all-wise, all-good — his watchful providence is ever, and every where, at work for the preservation of all things. But since mankind in general are too apt to look chiefly at this world, and to regard things as impor- tant or otherwise in proportion as they are connected with sublunary interests, and promote our present welfare, I shall proceed further to prove that the study of insects may be productive of considerable utility, even in this view, and may be regarded in some sort as a necessary or at least a very useful concomitant of many arts and sciences. The importance of insects to us both as sources of good or evil, I shall endeavour to prove at large here- after; but for the present, taking this for granted, it necessarily follows that the study of them must also be important. For when we suffer from them, if we do not knoAv the cause, how are we to apply a remedy that may diminish or prevent their ravages ? Igno- rance in this respect often occasions us to mistake our enemies for our friends, and our friends for our ene- mies ; so that when we think to do good we only do harm, destroying the innocent and letting the guilty escape. Many such instances have occurred. You know the orange-coloured fly of the wheat (Tipula Tritici, Kirby in Linn. Trans. Cecidotni/ia, Latr.), and have read the account of the damage done by this little insect to that important grain ; you are aware also that it is given in charge to three little parasites to keep it within due limits; yet at first it was the general opi- nion of unscientific men, that these destroyers of our OBJECTIONS ANSWERED. S^ «»nemy were its parents, and the original source of all p- posed to generate lice^. Nine larvae of the moth of the wild teasel inclosed in a reed or goose quill have . been reckoned a remedy for ague *•. Matthiolus grave^ ly affirms that every oak-gall contains either a fly, a a Amoreuxi 276. b Rai. Cut. i^nt. 45. llht, Ins, Sih VOL. I, D 34 OBJECTIOWS ANSWERED. spider, or a worm, and that the first foretells war, th« second pestilence, and the third famine ^ In Sweden the peasants look upon the grub of the cock-chafer iis furnishing an unfailing prognostic whether the ensuing winter will be mild or severe : if the animal have a blueish hue (a circumstance which arises from its being replete with food) they affirm it will be mild, but on the contrary if it be white the weather will be severe : and they carry this so far as to foretell, that if the an- terior part be white and the posterior blue, the cold will be most severe at the beginning of the winter. Hence they call this grub Bemcirkelse-mask, or pro- gnostic worm**. A similar augury as to the harvest is drawn by the Danish peasants from the Acari which infest the common dung beetle (Scarahceus stercorarms, Ij.)j called in Danish Skarnbosse or Torbist. If there are many of these mites between the fore feet, they be- lieve that there will be an early harvest, but a late one if they abound between the hind feet*^. The appear- ance of the death's head moth {Sphinx Atropos, L.) has in some countries produced the most violent alarm and trepidation amongst the people, who, because it emits a plaintive sound, and is marked with what looks like a death's head upon its back, regarded it as the messenger of pestilence and death *^. We learn from Linne that a similar superstition, built upon the black hue and strange aspect of that beetle, prevails in Swe- den with respect to Blaps mortisaga, L.®; and in Bar- a. Comment, in Dioscor. 1. 1. c.23. 214- Lesser, i. ii. 280. to De Geer, iv. 275-6. c Detharding de Insectis Coleopteris Danicis, 9. d Reaum. ii. 289-90. e Faun, Suec 822. OBJECTIONS ANS^rERED. S5 1)ac!oes, according to Hughes, the ignorant deem the appearance of a certain grasshopper in their houses as a sure presage of illness to some of the family '^. One would not think that the excrements of insects could be objects of terror, yet so it has ])een. Many species of Lepidoptera, when they emerge from the pupa state, discharge from their anus a reddish fluid, which, in some instances, where their nvmibers have been considerable, has produced the appearance of a shower of blood ; and by this natural fact, all those bloody showers, recorded by historians as preterna- tural, and regarded where they happened as fearful prognostics of impending evils, are stripped of their terrors, and reduced to the class of events that happen in the common course of nature. That insects are the cause of these showers is no recent discovery ; for Sleidan relates that in the year 1553 a vast multitude of butterflies swarmed through a great part of Ger- many, and sprinkled plants, leaves, buildings, clothes, and men, with bloody drops, as if it had rained blood''. But the most interesting account of an event of this kind is given by Reaumur, from whom we learn that in the beginning of July 1608 the suburbs of Aix, and a considerable extent of country round it, were cover- ed with what appeared to be a shower of blood. We ni^y conceive the amazement and stupor of the popu- lace upon such a discovery, the alarm of the citizens, the grave reasonings of the learned. All agreed how- ever in attributing this appearance to the powers of darkness, and in regarding it as the prognostic and precursor of some direful misfortune about to befal a Nat, Hist, of Barbad. 85. b Quoted in Mouffet, 107. d2 30 OBJECTIONS ANSWERED. them. Pear and prejudice Avould have taken deep root upon this occasion, and might have produced fatal effects upon some weak minds, had not M. Peiresc, a celebrated philosopher of that place, paid attention to insects. A chrysalis, which he preserved in his cabi- net, let him into the secret of this mysterious shower. Hearing a fluttering, which informed him his insect was arrived at its perfect state, he opened the box in which he kept it. The animal flew out and left behind it a red spot* He compared this with the spots of the bloody shower, and found they were alike. At the same time he observed there was a prodigious quan- tity of butterflies flying about, and that the drops of the miraculous rain were not to be found upon the tiles, nor even upon the upper surface of the stones, but chiefly in cavities and places where rain could not easily come. Thus did this judicious observer dispel the ignorant fears and terror which a natural pheno- menon had caused*. The same author relates an instance of the gardener of a gentleman being thrown into a horrible fright by- digging some of the curious cases, which I shall here- after describe to you, of the leaf-cutter bees, and which he conceived to be the effect of witchcraft portending some terrible misfortune. By the advice of the priest of the parish he even took a journey from Rouen to Paris, to show them to his master : but he, happily having more sense than the man, carried them to M. Nollet, an eminent naturalist, who having seen simi- lar productions was aware of the cause, and opening one of the cases, m hile the gardener stood aghast at his a Reaam. i. 667 . OBJECTIONS ANSWERED. 37 temerity, pointed out the grub that it contained, and thus sent him back with a light heart, relieved from all his apprehensions ''. Every one has heard of the death-watch, and knows of the superstitious notion of the vulgar, that in what- ever house its drum is heard one of the family will die before the end of the year. These terrors, in par- ticular instances, where they lay hold of weak minds, especially of sick or hypochondriac persons, may cause the event that is supposed to be prognosticated. A small degree of entomological knowledge would re- lieve them from all their fears, and teach them that this heart-sickening tick is caused by a small beetle (Anobium tessellatMm, F.) which lives in timber, and is merely a call to its companion. Attention to Ento- mology may therefore be rendered very useful in this view, since nothing certainly is more desirable than to deliver the human mind from the dominion of super- stitious fears, and false notions, which having con- siderable influence on the conduct of mankind are the cause of no small portion of evil. But as Ave cannot well guard against the injuries produced by insects, or remove the evil, whether real or arising from misconceptions respecting them, which they occasion, unless we have some knowledge of tliem ; so neither without such knowledge can we ap- ply them, when beneficial, to our use. Now it is ex- tremely probable that they might be made vastly more subservient to our advantage and profit than at pre- sent, if we were better acquainted with them. It is the remark of an author, who himself is no eritomolo- s Reauui, vj. 99-100, Kirby 3Ion. Jj}. Jng. i. 157-8. ^ OBJECTIONS ANSWERED. gist : " We have not taken animals enough into alli- ance with us. The more spiders there were in the stable, the less would the horses sufi'er from the flies. The great American fire-fly should be imported into Spain to catch mosquitos. In hot countries a reward should be offered to the man who could discover what insects feed upon fleas ^." It would be worth our while to act upon this hint, and a similar one of Dr. Darwin. Those insects might be collected and pre-- served that are known to destroy the Aphides and other injurious tribes; and we should thus be enabled to direct their operations to any quarter where they would be most serviceable : but this can never be done till experimental agriculturists and gardeners are con- versant with insects, and acquainted with their pro- perties and economy. How is it that the great Being of beings preserves the system which he has created from permanent injury, in consequence of the too great redundancy of any individual species, but by employing one creature to prey upon another, and so overruling and directing the instincts of all, that they may ope- rate most where they are most wanted ! We cannot better employ the reasoning powers and faculties Avith which he has endowed us, than by copying his exam- ple. We often employ the larger animals to destroy each other, but the smaller, especially insects, we have totally neglected. Some may think, perhaps, that in aiming to do this we should be guilty of presumption, and of attempting to take the government and direc- tion of things out of the hands of Providence : but this js a very weak argument, which might with equal rea^ a Southey's J|a(?oc, Ito, Notes, 519, OBJECTIONS ANSWERED. 59 son be adduced to prove that when rats and mice be- come troublesome to us, we ought not to have recourse to dogs, ferrets, and cats to exterminate them. When any species multiplies upon us, so as to become nox- ious, we certainly have a just right to destroy it, and what means can be more proper than those which Pro- vidence itself has furnished ? We can none of us go further or do more than the Divine Will permits ; and he will take care that our efforts shall not be injurious to the general welfare, or effect the annihilation of any individual species. Again, with regard to insects that are employed in medicine or the arts, if the apothecary cannot distin- guish a Liytta from a Carabus or Cetonia, both of which I have found mixed with the former, how can he know whether his druggist furnishes him with a good or bad article? And the same observation may with still greater force apply to the dyer in his purchase of cochineal, since it is still more difficult to distinguish the wild sort from the cultivated. There are, it is probable, many insects that might be employed with advantage in both these departments : but unless Entomology be more generally studied by scientific men, who are the only persons likely to make discoveries of this kind, than it has hitherto been, we must not hope to derive further profit from them. It seems more particularly incumbent upon the professors of the divine art ot healing to become conversant with this as well as the other branches of Natural History ; for not only do they derive some of their most useful drugs from insects, but many also of the diseases upon which they aro consulted, as we shall see hereafter, are occasioned by 40 OBJECTIONS ANSWERED. them. For want of this kind of information medical men run the risk of confounding diseases perfectly distinct, at least as to the animal that causes them. It would be a most desirable thing to have professors in each branch of Natural History in our universities, and to make it indispensable, in order to the obtain^ ing of any degree in Physic, that the candidate should have attended these lectures. We may judge from the good effects that the arts have derived from the present very general attention to Chemistry, how bene-? ■ficial would be the consequence if Entomology were equally cultivated : and I shall conclude this paragraph with what I think may be laid down as an incontrOf vertible axiom : — That the profit we derive from the works of creation will be in proportion to the accuracy of our knowledge of them and their properties. I trust I have now said enough to convince you aiid every thinking man that the study of insects, so far from being vain, idle, trifling, or unprofitable, may be attended with very important advantages to manliind, and ought at least to be placed upon a level with many other branches of science, against which such accusa- tions are never alleged. o' But I must not conceal from you that there are ob^ jectors who will still return to the charge. They will say, "We admit that the pursuits of the entomologist are important when ho directs his views to the destruc- tion of noxious insects; the discovery of new ones likely to prove beneficial to man ; and to practical ex- periments upon their medical and economical proper- jties. But where {ire the entomologists that in fact pur*. OBJECTIONS ANSWERED. 41 sue this course ? Do they not in reality wholly disre- gard the economical department of their science, and content themselves with making as large a collection of species as possible; ascertaining tlie names of such as are already described; describing new ones; and arranging the whole in their cabinets under certain fa- milies and genera? And can a study with those sole ends in view deserve a better epithet than trifling ? Even if the entomologist adyance a step further, and invent a new system for the distribution of all known insects, can his laborious undertaking be deemed any other tlian busy idleness ? What advantage does the world derive from having names given to ten or twenty thousand insects, of whicli numbers are not bigger than a pin's head, and of which probably not a hun- dredth part will ever be of any use to mankind? " Now in answer to this supposed objection, which I have stated as forcibly as I am able, and which, as it may be, and often is, urged against every branch of Natural History as at present studied, well deserves a full consideration, I might in the first place deny that those who have the highest claim to rank as entomolo- gists do confine their views to the systematic depart- ment of the science to the neglect of economical ob- servations ; and in proof of my assertion, I might refer abroad to a Linne, a Reaumur, a De Geer, a Huber, and various other names of the highest reputation ; and At home to a Hay, a Lister, a Derham, a Marsham, a Curtis, a Clark, a Roxburgh, &c. But I do not wish to conceal that though a large proportion of entomolo- gists direct their views much further than to the mere nomenclature of their scienccj there exists a great nuoi- 4rZ OBJECTIONS ANSWERED. ber, probably the majority, to whom the objection wiii strictly apply. INow I contend, and shall next endea- vour to prove, that entomologists of this description are devoting their time to a most valuable end ; and are conferring- upon society a lienefit incalculably greater than that derived from the labours of many of those who assume the privilege of despising their pursuit. Even in favour of the mere butterfly-hunter — he who has no higher aim than that of collecting ?i picture of Lepidoptera^ and is attached to insects solely by their beauty or singularity, it would not be difficult to say much. Can it be necessary to declaim on the superi- ority of a people amongst whom intellectual pleasures, however trifling, are preferred to mere animal gratifi- cations ? Is it a thing to be lamented that some of the Spitallields weavers occu})y their leisure hours in searching for the Adonis butterflv, and others of the more splendid Lepidoptera^, instead of spending them in playing at skittles or in an alehouse ? Or is there in truth any thing more to be wished than that the cutlers of Sheffield were accustomed thus to employ their Saint Mondoj/s; and to recreate themselves after a hard day's work, by breathing the pure air of their surrounding hills, while in search of this "untaxed and undisputed game^;" and that more of the Norwich weavers were a Haivor!)! £f^;rf. Brit. 44. 57. b Oft h-xve 1 smiled the happy pride to see Of htmihle tradesmen in their evening glee. When of some pleasing fancied good possest. Each grew alert, was busy and was blest : Whether (he call-bird yield tbe hour's delight. Or magnified in microscope the mite ; Or whether tumblers, croppers, carriers seize The gentle mind ; they rule it and thifj please. OBJECtlONS ANSWERED. 4S fond of devoting their vacant time to plant-hunting, like Joseph Fox recorded by Sir James Smith as the first raiser of a Lycopodium from seed^?" Still more easy is it to advocate the cause of another description of entomologists — the general collectors. These, though not concerning themselves with the system, contribute most essentially to its advancement. We cannot expect that princes, noblemen, and others of high rank or large fortune, who collect insects, should be able or willing to give up the tinie necessary for studying them systematically: but their museums being accessible to the learned entomologist afford him the use of treasures which his own limited funds or opportunities could never have brought together. As to others of less consequence that content them- selves witli the title of collectors, they also have their use. Having devoted themselves to this one depart- ment, they become more expert at it, than the philo- sopher who combines deep researches with the collec- tion of objects ; and thus are many species brought together for the use of the systematist, that would otherwise remain unknown. There is my friend the weavei* ; strong desires Reign in liis breast ; 'tis beauty he admires : See to the shady grove he wings his way, And feels in hope the rapture of the day — Eager he looks, and soon to glad his eyes, * From the sweet bower by nature form'd arise Bright troops of virgin moths, and fresh horn butterflies. He fears no bailiiT's wralh, no baron's blame, His is untax'd and undisputed game. Crabbe's Z?oroi/^^, p, 110. ft Linn, Trans, ii. 315. 44 OBJECTIONS ANSWERED. But to proceed to the defence of systematic entomo- logists.— These may be divided into two g^reat classes : the first comprising- those who confine themselves to ascertaining the names of the insects they collect; the second, those who, in addition, publish descriptions of new species ; new arrangements of intricate genera ; or extrications of entangled synonyms ; and who, in other respects, actively contribute to the perfection of the system. Now with regard to the first class, setting aside what may be urged in behalf of the study of insects consi- dered as the w ork of the Creator, it is easy to show that, even with such restricted views, their pursuit is as commendable, and as useful both to themselves a^d the community, as many of those on which Ave look with the greatest respect. To say the least in their fa- vour, they amuse themselves innocently, which is quite as much as can be urged for persons who recreate their leisure hours with music, painting, or desultory read- ing. They furnish themselves with an unfailing pro- vision of that " grand panacea for the tcedium vitce^^ — employment — no unimportant acquisition when even Gray was forced to exclaim, with reference to the ne- cessity of "always having something going forward" towards the enjoyment of life, " Happy they who can create a rose-tree or erect a honey-suckle ; that can watch the brood of a hen, or see a fleet of their own ducklings launch into the water ^! " and like the pre- ceding class, they collect valuable materials for the use of more active labourers, being thus at least upon a par witl^ the majority of book-collectors and antiquaries, a Letter to Dr. Wharton. Mason's Li/e of Gray, y. 28, OBJECTIONS ANSWERED. 45 But this is the smallest half of the value of their pursuit. With what view is the study of the mathema- tics so generally recommended ? Not certainly for any practical purpose — not to make the bulk of those who attend to them, astronomers or engineers. But simply to exercise and strengthen the intellect — to give the mind a habit of attention and of investigation. Now for all these purposes, if I do not go so far as to assert that the mere ascertaining of the names of insects is equal to the study of the mathematics, I have no he- sitation in affirming that it is nearly as effectual ; and with respect to giving a habit of minute attention, su- perior. Such is the intricacy of nature, such the imper- fection of our present arrangements, that the discovery of the name of almost any insect is a problem, calling in all cases for acuteness and attention, and in some for a balancing of evidence, a calculation of the chances of error, as arduous as are required in a perplexed law- case ; and a process of ratiocination not less strict than that which satisfies the mathematician. In proof of which assertion I need only refer any competent judge to the elaborate disquisitions of Laspeyres, called for by one work alone on the lepidopterous insects of a single district — the Wiener Verzcichniss, which occupy above two hundred octavo pages ^, and must have cost the learned author nearly as much labour of mind as the Ductor Duhitantium did Bishop Taylor. Do not apprehend that this occasional perplexity is any deduction from the attractions of the science : though in itself, in some respects, an evil, it forms in fact to many minds one of the chief of them. The pur- a Illig. Mag' ii. 33. iv. 3. 4(5 OBJECTIONS ANSWEHESD. suit of truth, in whatever path, affords pleasure t but the interest would cease if she never gave us trouble in the chase. Horace Walpole used to say that from a child he could never bring himself to attend to any book that w as not full of proper names ; and the satis- faction which he felt in dry investigations concerning noble authors and obscure painters, is experienced by many an entomologist who spends hours in disentan- gling the synonymy of a doubtful species. Nor would it be easy to prove that the wordy researches of the one are not to every practical purpose as valuable as those of the other. We smile at the Frenchman told of by Manege, that was so enraptured with the stud>- of heraldry and genealogy, as to lament the hard case of our forefather Adam, who could not possibly amuse himself with such investigations'". But many an ento- mologist who has felt the delicious sensation attendant upon the indisputable ascertainment of an insect's name after a long search, Avill feel inclined to indulge in similar grief for the unhappy lot of his successor^, when all shall be smooth sailing in the science. But in behalf of those who are more eminently en- titled to be called entomologists — those who, not con* tent with collecting and investigating insects, occupy themselves in naming and describing such as have been before unobserved ; in instituting new genera or re- forming tlie old ; and, to say all in one word, in per- fecting the system of the science, still higher claims can be urged. Suppose that at this moment our dic- tionaries of the French and German languages were so very defective, that we were unable by the use of them a Andrews's Anecdotes, 152, OBJECTIONS ANSWERED; 47 to profit from the discoveries of their philosophers ; the labours of a Michaelis being- a sealed book to our theologists, and those of La Place to our astronomers. On this supposition, would not one of the most import- tant literary undertakings l)e the compilation of more perfect dictionaries, and would not the huni])lct5t con- tributor to such an end be deemed most meritoriously engaged ? Now precisely what an accurate dictionary of a particular language is towards enabling the world to participate in the discoveries published in that lan- guage, is a system of Entomology towards enabling mankind to derive advantage from any discoveries re- lative to insects. A good system of insects containing all the known species, arranged in appropriate genera, families, orders, and classes, is in fact a dictionary, putting it within our power to ascertain the name of any given insect, and thus to learn what has been ob- served respecting its properties and history as readily as we determine the meaning of a new word in a lexi- con. In order to impress upon you more forcibly the absolute need of such a system, I must enter into still further detail. Tliere is scarcely a country in which several thou- sand insects may not be found. Now, without some scientific arrangement, how is the observer of a new fact respecting any one of them, to point out to distant countries and to posterity the particular insect he had in view ? Suppose an observer in England were to find a certain beetle Avhich he had demonstrated to be a specific for consumption ; and that it was necessary that this insect, which there was reason to believe was common in every part of the world, should be admi- 48 OBJECTIONS ANSWEREIJ. Xiiatered in a recent state. Would he not be anxioas to> proclaim the happy discovery to sufferers in all quar- ters of the globe ? As his remedy would not admit of transportation, he would have no other means than by describing it. Now the question is^^ whether, on the supposition that no system of Entom&logy existed, he would be able to do this, so as to be intelligible to a physician in North America, for instance, eager to ad- minister so precious a medicine to his expiring pa- tient? It would evidently be of no use to say that the specific was a beetle : there are thousands of difterent beetles in North America. Nor would size or colour be any better guide : there are hundreds of beetles of the same size and the same colour. Even the plant on which it fed would be no sufficient clue ; for many in- sects, resembling each other to an unpractised eye, feed on the same plant ; and the same insect in differ- ent countries feeds upon different plants. His only re- source, then, would be a coloured figure and full de- scription of it. But every entomologist knows that there exist insects perfectly distinct, yet so nearly re- sembling each other, that no engraving, nor any lan- guage other than that strictly scientific, can possibly discriminate them. After all, therefore, the chances are, that our discoverer's remedy, invaluable as it might be, must be confined to his own immediate neighbour- hood, or to those who came to receive personal infor- mation from him. But with what ease is it made knowrt when a system of the science exists ! If the insect be already described, he has but to mention its generic and trivial names, and by aid of two words alone, every entomologist, though in the most distant region OBJECTIONS ANSWERED. 49 ^^whether a Swed^, a German, or a Frenchman ; whether a native of Europe, of Asia, of America, or of Africa, knows instantly the very species that is meant, and can that moment ascertain whether it be within his reach. If the species be new dnd undescribed, it is only necessary to indicate the genus to which it be- longs, the species to which it is most nearly allied, and to describe it in scientific terms, which may be done in few words, and it can at once be recognised by every one acquainted with the science. You will think it hardly credible that there should be so much difficulty in describing an insect intelligi- bly without the aid of system ; but an argumentum ad homirtem^ supported by some other facts, will, I con- jecture, render this matter more comprehensible. YoU have doubtless, like every one else, in the showery days of summer, felt no little rage at thej^ze^, which at such times take the liberty of biting our legs, and contrive to make a comfortable meal through the in- terstices of their silken or cotton coverings. Did it, I pray, ever enter into your conception, that these blood- thirsty tormentors are a different species from those flies which you are wont to see extending the lips of their little proboscis to a piece of sugar or a drop of wine ? I dare say not. But the next time you have sacrificed one of the former to your just vengeance, catch one of the latter and compare them. I question if, after the narrowest comparison, you will not still venture a wager that they are the very same species. Yet you would most certainly lose your bet. They are not even of the same genus — one belonging to the genus Musca {M. domestica^ L.), and the other to the VOL. I. E 50 OBJECTIONS ANSWERED. genus Stomoxys (S. calciirans, F;); and on a second examination you will find that, however alike in most respects, they diifer widely in the shape of their proboscis ; that of the Stomoxys being a horny sharp- pointed Aveapon, capable of piercing the flesh, Avhile the soft blunt organ of the Musca is j-erfectly incom- petent to any such operation. In future, while you no longer load the whole race of the house-fly with the execrations which properly belong to a quite diff*erent tri}>e, you will cease being surprised that an ordinary description should be insufficient to discri- minate an insect. It is to this insufficiency that we must attribute our ignorance of so many of the insects mentioned by the older naturalists, previously to the ^systematic improvements of the immortal Linne : and to the same cause we must refer the impossibility of determining what species are alluded to in the ac- counts of many modern travellers and agriculturists who have been ignorant of Entomology as a science. Instances without number of this impossibility might be adduced, but I shall confine myself to two. One of the greatest pests of Surinam and other low regions in South America, is the insect called in the West Indies, where it is also troublesome, the chigoe (Pulex penetrans, L,), a minute species, to the attacks of which I shall again have occasion to advert. This insect is mentioned by almost all the writers on the countries where it is found. Not less than eight or ten of them have endeavoured to give a full descrip- tion of it, and some of them have even figured it ; and yet, strange to say, it was not certainly known whether it was a flea (Pulex) or a mite (Acarus), till a com- OBJECTIONS ANSWERED. 51 petent naturalist undertook to investigate its history, ■ and in a short paper in the Szoedish Transactions'^ proved that Linne was not mistaken in referring it to the former genus. The second instance of the insufficiency of popular description is even more extraordinary. In 1788 an alarm was excited in this country by the probability of importing, in cargoes of wheat from North America, the insect known by the name of the Hessian fly, whose dreadful ravages will be adverted to hereafter. How- ever the insect tribes are in general despised, they had on that occasion ample revenge. The privy council sat day after day anxiously debating what measures should be adopted to ward oft' the danger of a cala- mity, more to be dreaded, as they well knew, than the plague or pestilence. Expresses were sent off" in all directions to the officers of the customs at the different outports respecting the examination of cargoes — di- spatches written to the ambassadors in France, Au- stria, Prussia, and America, to gain that information of the want of which they were now so sensible : and so important was the business deemed, that the minutes of council and the documents collected from all quarters fill upwards of two hundred octavo pages'". Fortu- nately England contained one illustrious naturalist, the most authentic source of information on all sub- jects which connect Natural History with Agriculture and the Arts, to whom the privy council had the wis- dom to apply ; and it was by Sir Joseph Banks's ento- mological knowledge, and through his suggestions, a Swartzin KongL Vet. Ac. Njci. band. ix.40. Plate XXIII. Fig. 10. b Young's Annals of As^rkuUure, xi. 406. e2 52 OBJECTIONS ANSWERED. that they were at length enabled to form some kind of judgement on the subject. This judgement was after all, however, very imperfect. As Sir Joseph Banks had never seen the Hessian fly, nor was it described in any entomological system, he called for facts respecting its nature, propagation, and economy, which could be had only from America. These were obtained as speedily as possible, and consi&t of numerous letters from indi- viduals; essays from magazines; the reports of the British minister there, &c. &c. One would have sup- posed that from these statements, many of them drawn up by farmers who had lost entire crops by the insect, which they profess to have examined in every stage, the requisite information might have been acquired. So far however was this from being the case, that many of the writers seem ignorant whether the insect be a moth, a fly, or what they term a bug. And though from the concurrent testimony of several its being a two-winged fly seemed pretty accurately ascertained, no intelligible description is given, from which any naturalist can infer to what genus it belongs, or w hether it is a known species. With regard to the history of its propagation and economy the statements w ere so various and contradictory, that though he had such a mass of materials before him. Sir Joseph Banks was unable to reach any satisfactory conclusion. Nothing can more incontrovertibly demonstrate the importance of studying Entomology as a science than this feet. Those observations, to which thousands of unscientific sufferers proved themselves incompetent, would have been readily made by one entomologist well versed in his science. He would at once have OBJECTIONS ANSWERED. 53 determined the order and genus of the insect, and whether it was a known or new species ; and in a twelvemonth at furthest he would liave ascertained in what manner it made its attacks, and whether it were possible that it might be transmitted along with grain into a foreign country : and on these solid data he could have satisfactorily pointed out the best mode of eradicating the pest, or preventing the extension of its ravages. But it is not merely in travellers and popular ob- servers that the want of a systematic knowledge of Entomology is so deplorable. A great portion of the labours of the profoundest naturalists have been from a similar cause lost to the world. Many of the insects concerning which Reaumur and Bonnet have recorded the most interesting circumstances, cannot, from their neglect of system, be at this day ascertained^. The former, as Beckmann '' states on the authority of his letters, was before his death sensible of his great error in this respect : but Bonnet, with singular inconsist- ency, constantly maintained the inutility of system, even on an occasion when, from his ignorance of it, Sir James Smith, speaking of his experiments on the barberry, found it quite impossible to make him com- prehend what plant he referred to''. So great is the importance of a systematic arrange- ment of insects. Yet no such arrangement has hither- to been completed. Various fragments towards it in- a No one knew Reaumur's AheiUe. Tapissiere until Latreille, happily - combining system with attention to the economy of insects, proved it to be a new species — his Mcgachile Piqmveris. — IJisl. de Fourmfs, 29T. b Bibliothek. vii. 310. c 'four on the Continent, ili. 150. 54 OBJECTIONS ANSWERED. deed exist. But the work itself is in the state of a dictionary wanting- a considerable proportion of the words of the language it professes to explain ; and placing those, which it does contain, in an order often so arbitrary and defective, that it is difficult to discover even the page containing the word you are in search of. Can it be denied, then, that they are most meri- toriously employed who devote themselves to the re- moval of these defects — to the perfecting of the system — and to clearing the path of future economical or physiological observers from the obstructions which now beset it ? And who that knows the vast extent of the science, and how impossible it is that a divided at- tention can embrace the whole, will contend that it is not desirable that some labourers in the field of lite- rature should devote themselves entirely and exclu- sively to this object ? Who that is aware of the im- portance of the comprehensive views of a Fabricius, an Illiger, or a Latreille, and the infinite saving of time of which their inquiries will be productive to their followers, will dispute their claim to rank amongst the most honourable in science ? II. No objection, I think, now remains against ad- dicting ourselves to entomological pursuits, but that which seems to have the most weight with you, and which indeed is calculated to make the deepest impres- sion upon the best minds — I mean the charge of inhu- manity and cruelty. That the science of Entomology cannot be properly cultivated without the death of its objects, and that this is not to be effected without put- ting- them to some pain, must be allowed ; but that this OBJECTIONS ANSWERED. 55 substantiates the charge of cruelty against US I alto- gether deny. Cruelty is an unnecessary infliction of suffering, when a person is fond of torturing or de- stroying God's creatures from mere wantonness, with no useful end in view ; or when, if their death be use- ful and lawful, he has recourse to circuitous modes of killing them, Avhere direct ones would answer equally well. This is cruelty, and this with you I abominate ; but not the infliction of death when a just occasion calls for it. They who see no cruelty in the sports of the field, as they are called, can never, of course, consistently allege such a charge against the entomologist; the tortures of wounded birds, of fish that swallow the hook and break the line, or of the hunted hare, being, beyond comparison, greater than those of insects de- stroyed in the usual mode. With respect to utility, the sportsman, who, though he adds indeed to the ge- neral stock of food, makes amusement his primary ob- ject, must surely yield the palm to the entomologist, who adds to the general stock of mental food, often supplies hints for useful improvements in the arts and sciences, and the objects of whose pursuit, unlike those of the former, are preserved and maybe applied to use for many years. But in the view even of those few who think inhu- manity chargeable upon the sportsman, it will be easy to place considerations which may rescue the entomo- logist from such reproof. It is well known that, in proportion as we descend in the scale of being, the sensibility of the objects that constitute it diminishes. The tortoise walks about after losing- its head ; and the 56 OBJECTIONS ANSWERED. Polypus, SO far from being injured by the application of the knife, thereby acquires an extension of exist- ence. Insensibility almost equally great may be found in the insect world. This, indeed, might be inferred d priori, since Providence seems to have been more prodigal of insect life than of that of any other order of creatures, animalcula perhaps alone excepted. No part of the creation is exposed to the attack of so many enemies, or subject to so many disasters ; so that the few individuals of each kind which enrich the valued museum of the entomologist, many of w hich are dearer to him than gold or gems, are snatched from the ravenous maw of some bird or fish or rapa- cious insect ; would have been driven by the winds into the waters and drowned ; or trodden underfoot by man or beasts, — for it is not easy, in some parts of the year, to set foot to the ground without crushing these minute animals ; and thus also, instead of being buried in oblivion, they have a kind of immortality conferred upon them. Can it be believed that the beneficent Creator, whose tender mercies are over all his works, would expose these helpless beings to such innumerable enemies and injuries, w ere they endued with the same sense of pain and irritability of nerve with the higher orders of animals ? But this inference is reduced to certainty, when we attend to the facts which insects every day present to us, proving that the very converse of our great poet's conclusion, " fhe poor beetle that we tread upon, In corporal sutiVrance finds a pang as gre^^t As when a giant dies," OBJECTIONS ANSWERED. 57 must be regarded as nearer the truth. Not to mention the peculiar organization of insects, which strongly favours the idea I am inculcating, but which will be considered more properly in another place, their sang froid upon the loss of their limbs, even those that we account most necessary to life, irrefragably proves that the pain they suffer caiuiot be very acute. Had a giant lost an arm or a leg, or were a sword or spear run through liis body, he would feel no great inclination for runninj^ about, dancing, or eating. Yet a crane-fly (T/pz/Za) will leave half its legs in the hands of an unlucky boy who has endeavoured to catch it, and Avill fly here and there with as much agility and unconcern as if nothing- had happened to it; and an 'liricct impaled upon a pin will often devour its prey with as much avidity as when at liberty. Were a giant eviscerated, his body divided in the middle, or his head cut off, it would be all over with him ; he would move no more ; he would be dead to the calls of hunger; or the emotions of fear, anger, or love. Not so our insects. I have seen the com- mon cockchafer walk about with apparent indifference after some bird had nearly emptied its body of its viscera : a humble-bee v/iii eat honey with greediness though deprived of its a])don:en; and I myself lately saw an ant, which had been brought out of the nest by its comrades, walk when deprived of its head. The head of a wasp will attempt to bite after it is separated from the rest of the body ; and the abdomen under si- milar circumstances, if the finger be moved to it, will attempt to sting. And what is more extraordinary, the headless trunk of a male Mantis has been known to 58 OBJECTIONS ANSWERED. unite itielf to the other sex^ These facts, out of hun- dreds that might be adduced, are surely sufficient to prove that insects do not experience the same acute sensations of pain with the higher orders of animals, which Providence has endowed with more ample mean^ of avoiding them ; and since they were to be exposed so universally to attack and injury, this is a most mer- ciful provision in their favour ; for, were it otherwise, considering the wounds, and dismemberments, and lin- gering" deaths that insects often suffer, what a vast in- crease v/ould there be of the general sum of pain and misery ! You will now, I think, allow that the most humane person need not hesitate a moment, whether he shall devote himself to the study of Entomology, on account of any cruelty attached to the pursuit. But if some morbid sentimentalist should still ex- claim, "Oh! but I cannot persuade myself even for scientific purposes to inflict the slightest degree of pain upon the most insensible of creatures — " Pray, sir or madam, I would ask, should your green-house be infested by Aphides, or your grapery by the semiani- mate Coccus, would this extreme of tenderness induce you to restrict your gardener from destroying them ? Are you willing to deny yourself these unnecessary gTatifications, and to resign your favourite flowers and fruit at the call of your fine feelings ? Or will you give up the shrimps, which by their relish enable you to play a better part with your bread and butter at breakfast, and thus, instead of adding to it, contri- bute to diminish the quantity of food? If not, I shall a Dr. Smith's Tour, i. 162. Journ. de Phys. x\v. 336. OBJECTIONS ANSWERED. 5t) only desire you to recollect that, for a mere personal indulgence, you cause the death of an infinitely greater number of animals, than all tlie entomologists in the world destroy for the promotion of science. To these considerations, which I have no doubt you will think conclusive as to the unreasonableness and inconsistency of the objections made against the study of Entomology on the score of cruelty, I shall only add that I do not intend them as any apology for other than the most speedy and least painful modes of de- stroying insects ; and these will be pointed out to you in a'subsequent letter. Every degree of unnecessary pain becomes cruelty, which I need not assure you I abhor ; and from my own observations, however ruth- lessly the entomologist may seem to devote the few specimens wanted for scientific purposes to destruc- tion, no one in ordinary circumstances is less prodigal of insect life. For my own part, I question whether the drowning individuals, which I have saved from destruction, would not far out-number all that I ever sacrificed to science. My next letter will be devoted to the metamorphoses of insects, a subject on which some previous explana- tion is necessary to enable you to understand those distinctions between their different states, which will be perpetually alluded to in the course of our corre- spondence : and having thus cleared the way, I shall afterwards proceed to the consideration of the injuries and bcnejils of which insects are the cause. 1 am, &c. LETTER III. METAMORPHOSES OF INSECTS. VYere a naturalist to ajinoimoo to the world the discovery of an animal which for the first five years of its life existed in the form of a serpent ; which then penetrating into tlie earth, aud Aveaving a shroud of pure silk of the finest texture, contracted itself within this covering into a body without external mouth or limbs, and resembling more than any thing else an Egyptian mummy ; and which, lastly, after remaining in this state without food and without motion for three years longer, should at the end of that period burst its silken cerements, struggle through its earthy co- vering, and start into day a winged bird, — what think you would be the sensation excited by this strange piece of intelligence ? After the first doubts of its truth were dispelled, what astonishment would suc- ceed ! Amongst the learned, what surmises ! — what investigations ! Amongst the vulgar, what eager cu- riosity and amazement ! All would be interested in the history of such an unheard-of phenomenon ; even the most torpid would flock to the sight of such a prodigy. But you ask, " To what do all these improbable suppositions tend ? " Simply to rouse your attention to the metamorphoses of the insect world, almost as METAMOUPIIOSES. 61 Strange and surprising, to which I am now about to direct your view, miracles, which, though scarcely surpassed in singularity by all that poets have feigned, and though actually wrought every day beneath our eyes, are, because of their commonness, and the mi- nuteness of the objects, unheeded alike by the ignor rant and the learned. That butterfly w hich amuses you with its aerial ex- cursions, one while extracting nectar from the tube of the honeysuckle, and then, the very image of fickle- ness, flying to a rose as if to contrast the hue of its wings with that of the flower on which it reposes — did not come into the world as you now behold it. At its first exclusion from the egg^ and for some months of its existence afterwards, it was a worm-like caterpillar, crawling upon sixteen short legs, greedily devouring leaves with two jaws, and seeing by means of twelve eyes so minute as to be nearly imperceptible without the aid of a microscope. You now view it furnished with wings capable of rapid and extensive flights: of its sixteen feet ten have disappeared, and the remain- ing six are in most respects wholly unlike those to which they have succeeded ; its jaws have vanished, and are replaced by a curled-up proboscis suited only for sipping liquid sweets; the form of its head is entirely changed, — two long horns project from its upper sur- face ; and, instead of twelve invisible eyes, you behold two, very large, and composed of at least twenty thou- sand convex lenses, each supposed to be a distinct and effective eye ! Were you to push your examination further, and by dissection to compare the internal conformation of 6g METAMORPHOSES. the caterpillar with that of the butterfly, you would witness changes even more extraordinary. In the former you would find some thousands of muscles^ which in the latter are replaced by others of a form and structure entirely different. Nearly the whole body of the caterpillar is occupied by a capacious sto- mach. In the butterfly this has become converted into an almost imperceptible thread-like viscus ; and the abdomen is now filled by two large packets of eggs, or other organs not visible in the first state. In the former, two spirally-convoluted tubes v/ere filled with a silky gum ; in the latter, both tubes and silk have almost totally vanished ; and changes equally great have taken place in the economy and structure of the nerves and other organs. What a surprising transformation ! Nor was this all. The change from one form to the other was not direct. An intermediate state not less singular inter- vened. After casting its skin even to its very jaws several times, and attaining its full growth, the cater- pillar attached itself to a leaf by a silken girth. Its body greatly contracted : its skin once more split asunder, and disclosed an oviform mass, without ex- terior mouth, eyes, or limbs, and exhibiting no other symptom of life than a slight motion when touched. In this state of death-like torpor, and without tasting food, the insect existed for several months, until at length the tomb burst, and out of a case not more than an inch long, and a quarter of an inch in diameter, proceeded the butterfly before you, which covers a sur- face of nearly four inches square. Almost every insect which you see has undergone a METAMORPHOSES. 6S transformation as singular and surprising, though va- ried in many of its circumstances. That active little fly, now an unbidden guest at your table", whose deli- cate palate selects your choicest viands, one while ex- tending his proboscis to the margin of a drop of wine, and then gaily flying to take a more solid repast from a pear or a peach ; now gamboling with his comrades in the air, now gracefully currying his furlfed wings with his taper feet, — was but the other day a disgust- ing grub, without wings, without legs, without eyes, wallowing, well pleased, in the midst of a mass of ex- crement. The " grey-coated gnat," whose humming saluta- tion, while she makes her airy circles about your bed, gives terrific warning of the sanguinary operation in which she is ready to engage, was a few hours ago the inhabitant of a stagnant pool, more in shape like a fish than an insect. Then to have been taken out of the w ater would have been speedily fatal ; now it could as little exist in any other element than air. Then it breathed through its tail; now through openings in its sides. Its shapeless head, in that period of its exist- ence, is now exchanged for one adorned with elegantly tufted antennae, and furnished, instead of jaws, with an apparatus more artfully constructed than the cup- ping glasses of the phlebotomist — an apparatus which, at the same time that it strikes in the lancets, compo- ses a tube for piunping up the flowing blood. The " shard-born beetle," whose " sullen horn," as he directs his " droning flight" close past your ears " " Ccenis etiam non vocatus nt Musca advo'.o." Aristophoii in Pi;- flia^orista apvA AtheniPiim. (Mouffel, 56.) 64 METAMORPHOSES. in your evening- walk, calling- up in poetic association the lines in Avliich he has been alluded to by Shake- speare, Collins, and Gray, was not in his infancy an in- habitant of air; the first period of his life being spent in gloomy solitude, as a grub, under the surface of the earth. — The shapeless maggot, which you scarcely fail to meet with in some one of every handful of nuts you crack, would not always have grovelled in that hum- ble state. If your unlucky intrusion upon its vaulted dwelling had not left it to perish in the wide world, it would have continued to reside there until its full growth had been attained. Then it would have gnawed itself an opening, and having entered the earth, and passed a few months in a state of inaction, would at length have emerged an elegant beetle furnished with a slender and very long ebony beak ; two wings, and two wing-cases, ornamented with yellow bands ; six feet; and in every respect unlike the worm from which it proceeded. That bee but it is needless to multiply instances. A sufficient number has been adduced to show, that the apparently extravagant supposition with which I set out may be paralleled in the insect world ; and that the metamorphoses of its inhabitants are scarcely less astonishing than would be the transformation ')f a ser- pent into an eagle. •* These changes I do not purpose explaining minutely in this place : they will be adverted to more fully in subsequent letters. Here I mean merely to give you such a general view of the subject as shall impress you w ith its claims to attention, and such an explanation of the states through which iusecty pass, and of the diffe- 'metamorphoses. 65 iceht terms made use of to designate them In each, as shall enable you to comprehend the frequent allusions which must be made to them in our future correspond- ence. The states throuiifh which insects pass are four : the €gg; the larva; the pupa; and the imago. The first of these need not be here adverted to. In the second, or immediately after the exclusion from tliQ egg, they are soft, without wings, and in shape usually somewhat like worms. This Linne called the larva state, and an insect when in it a larva, adopting a Latin word signifying a mash, because he considered the real insect while under this form to be as it were masked. In the English language we have no common term that applies to the second state of all insects, though we have several for that of different tribes. Thus we call the coloured and often hairy larvae of butterflies and moths caterpillars ; the white and more compact larvae of flies, many beetles, Sec. grubs or maggots^; and the depressed larvae of many other insects noorms. The two former terms I shall sometimes use in a similar sense, rejecting the last, which ought to be confined to true vermes; but I shall more commonly adopt Linnq's term, and call insects in their second state, larvce^. In this period of their life, during which they eat voraciously and cast their skin several times, insects a Gentils, or gentles, is a synonymous word employed by our old au- thors, but is now obsolete, except with anglers. Thus Tusser, in a pas- »age pointed out to me by Sir Joseph Banks : — " Rewerd not thy sheep when ye take off his cote With twitches and patches as brode as a grote ; Let not such ungentlenesse happen to thine Least flie with her gentils do make it to pine." b For the different kinds of larvae, sec Plates XYII. XVIII. XIX. TOL. I. r 66 METAMORPHOSES. live a shorter or longer period, some only a few da^s or weeks, others several months or years. They then eease eating; fix themselves in a secure place ; their skin separates once more and discloses an oblong body, and they have now attained the third state of their existence. From the swathed appearance of most insects in this state, in which they do not badly resemble in miniature a child trussed up like a mummy in swaddling clothes, according to the bartjarous fashion once prevalent here, and still retained in many parts of the continent ; Linne has called it the p?/j9a state, and an insect when under this form a pupa; — terms Avhich will be here adopted in the same sense. In this state most insects eat no food ; are incapable of locomotion ; and if open- ed seem filled with a watery fluid, in which no distinct oi^ns can be traced. Externally, however, the shape of the pupsB of different tribes varies considerably, and different names have been applied to them. Those of the beetle and bee tribes are covered with a membranous skin, inclosing in separate and distinct sheaths the external organs, as the antennae, legs, and wings, which are consequently not closely applied to the body, but have their form for the most part clearly distinguishable. To these Aristotle originally gave the name of «ymp/iCB% which was continued by Swam- merdam and other authors prior to Linne, who calls them incomplete pupa?, and has been adopted by many English writers on insects'*. Butterflies, moths, and some of the tWo-winged tribe, are in their pupa state also inclosed in a similar mem- branous envelope ; but their legs, antennae,. and wings, KUitL Ahim. 1. 5. c. 10. b Plate XVI. Fic. 6—9. METAMORPHOSESi 6t^ iare closely folded over the brecist and sides ; and the whole body inclosed in a common case or covering of a horny consistence, which admits a much less distinct view of the organs beneath it. As these pupae are often tinged of a golden colour, they were called from thi» circumstance chrt/salides by the Greeks, and aurelice by the Romans, both which terms are in some measure become anglicized; and though not strictly applicable t,o ungilded pupae, are now often given to those of all lepidopterous insects^. These by Linne are denomi* nated o6/ec?eff pupae''. a In explanation of the terms Lepidoptcra, Lepidopterous, Cokopteroi $cc. which will frequently or.cur in the following pages before coming regularly to definitions, it is necessary here to state that they have re- ference to the names given by entomologists to the different orders oF tribes of insects, as under: 1 Coleoptera consisting of Beetles. Plate I. Fig. 1 — 6. 2 Strepsiptera of the genera Aie>iosandS/yo|7S. Platell. Fig.l. 3 Dermaptcra of the Earwigs. Plate I. Fig. 7. 4 Orthoplera — of Cockroaches, Locusts, Grasshoppers, Crickets, Spectres, Mantes, S^'c. Platell. Fig. 2. 3. 5 He7niptern consisting of Uugsj, CicadcE, Water' scorpions^ Water-boat- men, Plant-lice, Cochineal Insects, &c. Plate II, Fig. 4. 5. 6 Trichoptera consisting of the flies produced by the various species o^ Case-worms, Phryganea, L. Plate III. Fig. 4. 7 Lepidoptera consisting oi Butterflies^ Hawkmotks,a.ad Moths, Plate III* Fig. 1-3. 8 Neuroptera consisting of Dragon-flies, ^nt-lions, Ephemeree, Sfc. Plate III. Fig. 5. 6. 9 Hymenoptera consisting of Bees, Wasps, and other insects armed with n sting ov ovipositor, av\A Ms valves. Plate IV. Fig. 1-^3. 10 Diptera consisting of Flies, Gnats, and other two-iei7iged insects, Plate IV. Fig. 4.5. Plate V. Fig. 1. 11 ^p^n»pierfl consisting of the FZea genus. Plate V. Fig. 2. 12 ^ptera of Mites, Lice, See. Plate V. Fig. 3*-6. b Plate XVI. Fig. 10—13, f2 68 METAMORPHOSES. I have said that most insects eat no food in the pupa state. This qualification is necessary, because in the metamorphoses of insects, as in all her other opera- tions, nature proceeds by measured steps, and a very considerable number (the tribe of locusts, cockroaches, bugs, spiders, &c.) not only greatly resemble the per- fect insect in form, but are equally capable with it of eating and moving. As these insects, however, cast their skins at stated periods, and undergo changes, though slight, in their external and internal conforma- tion, they are regarded also as being subject to meta- morphoses. These pupae may be subdivided into two classes : first, those comprised, with some exceptions, under the Linnean Aptera, which in almost every re- spect resemble the perfect insect, and were called by Linnc complete pupae ; and secondly, those of the Lin- nean order Hemiptera^ which resemble the perfect in- sect, except in having only the rudiments of wings, and to which the name o^ semi-complete pupae was applied by Linne, and that of semi-nymphs by some other au- thors^. There is still a fifth kind of pupae, which are not, as in other instances, excluded from the skin of the larva, but remain concealed under it, and were hence called by Linne coarctate pupae. These, which are peculiar to flies and some other dipterous genera, may be termed cased-nymphs^ . When, therefore, we employ the term pupa, we may refer indifferently to the third state of any insect, the particular order being indicated by the context, or an explanatory epithet. The terms chrz/salisj (dropping aurelia, which is superfluous), nr/mph, semi-nymph, » Plate XYI. Fig. 4. 5. b Plate XVII. Fig. 1—4. METAMORPHOSES. 69 and cased-ni/mphy on the other hand definitely pointing out the particular sort of pupa meant : just as in Bo- tany, the connnon term pericarp applies to all seed- vessels, the several kinds being designated by the names of capsule, silicle, &c. The envelope of cased-ni/mphs^ which is formed of the skin of the larva, considerably altered in form and texture, maybe conveniently called the /JWjsanMm'^.- but to the artifical coverings of difterent kinds, whe- ther of silk, wood, or earth, &c. which many insects of the other orders fabricate for themselves previously to assuming the pupa state, and which have been called by difterent writers, j^oc?*, cods^ husks, and beans, I shall continue the more definite French term cocon, anglicized into cocoon^. After remaining a shorter or longer period, some species only a few hours, others months, others one or more years, in the pupa state, the inclosed insect, now become mature in all its parts, bursts the case which inclosed it, quits the pupa, and enters upon the fourth and last state. We now see it (unless it be an apterous species) furnished with wings, capable of propagation, and often under a form altogether different from those wliich it has previously borne — a perfect beetle, but- terfly, or other insect. This Linne termed the imago Htate, and the animal that had attained to it the imago/ because, having laid aside its mask, and cast off its swaddling bands, being no longer disguised or confined, or in any respect imperfect, it is now become a true representative or image of its species. This state is in arLATEXVII. Fig. 2. b Plate XVII. Fig, 5— 10. 70 METAMOHPHOSliS. geiiferal referred to when an insect is spoken of with* out the restricting terms larva or pupa. Such being the singularity of the transformations of insects, you will not think the ancients were so wholly unprovided with a show of argument as we are accus- tomed to consider them, for their belief in the possi- bility of many of the marvellous metamorphoses which their poets recount. Utterly ignorant as they were of modern physiological discoveries, the conversion of a caterpillar into a butterfly, must have been a fact suffi- cient to put to a nonplus all the sceptical oppugners of such transformations. And, however we may smile in this enlightened age at the inference drawn not two centuries ago by Sir Theodore Mayerne, the editor of MoufFet's work on insects, ^' that if animals are trans- muted so may metals'*," it was not, in fact, with his limited knowledge on these subjects, so very preposte- rous. It is even possible that some of the wonderful tales of the ancients were grafted on the changes which they observed to take place in insects. The death and revivification of the phcenix, from the ashes of which, before attaining its perfect state, arose first a worTn (arxooXYj^), in many of its particulars resembles what oc- curs in the metamorphoses of insects. Nor is it very unlikely th?.t the doctrine of the metempsychosis took its rise from the same source. What argument would be thought by those who maintained this doctrine more plausible in favour of the transmigration of souls, than the seeming revivification of the dead chri/salis? What more probable, than that its apparent reassumption of life should be owing to its receiving for tenant the soul a Epis-t. Dedicat, . METAMQRPIiaSES. "71 of some criminal doomed to animate an insect of similar habits with those which had defiled his human tenement * ? At the present day, however, the transformations of insects have lost that excess of the marvellous, which might once have furnished arguments for the fictioiis of the ancients, and the di'eams of Paracelsus. We call them metamorphoses and transformations, because these terms are in common use, and are more expres- sive of the sudden changes that ensue than any new ones. But, strictly, they ought rather to be termed a series of developments. A caterpillar is not, in fact, a simple but a compound animal, containing within it the germ of the future butterfly, inclosed in what will be the case of the pupa, which is itself included in the three or more skins, one over the other, that will suc- cessively cover the larva. As this increases in size these parts expand, present themselves, and are in turn thrown off, until at length the perfect insect, which had been concealed in this succession of masks, is displayed in its genuine form. That this is the pro- per explanation of the phenomenon has been satisfac- torily proved by Swammerdam, Malpighi, and other anatomists. The first-mentioned illustrious natura- list discovered, by accurate dissections, not only the skins of the larva and of the pupa incased in each other, bnt within them the very butterfly itself, with a " A priest who has drunk wine shall migrate into a moth or fly, feed- ing on ordure. He who steals the gold of a priest shall pass a thousand times into the bodies of spiders. If a man shall steal honey, he shall be born a great stinging gnat; if oil, an oil-drinking beetle; if salt, a