oirs of The Torrey Botanical Club Volume 23 Number 1 December 1972 Editor William Louis Stem A REVISION OF THE GENUS GAURA (ONAGRACEAE) Peter H. Raven and David P. Gregory LI JAN 31 1973 RARY NEW YORK fiOTAKiCAL ;»Ar?DECM ' Memoirs of the Torrey Botanical Club Volume 23 Number 1 December 1972 Manuscripts intended for the Memoirs and related editorial correspondence should be sent to Professor William Louis Stem, Department of Botany, Univer¬ sity of Maryland, College Park, Maryland 20742. Manuscripts should be double-spaced throughout and follow the style in the most recent issue of the Memoirs. Subscriptions, advertisements, and claims for missing numbers of the Memoirs should be addressed to Dr. Gary Smith, New York Botanical Garden, Bronx, New York 10458. Requests for back numbers of the Memoirs should be sent to Walter J. Johnson, Inc., Ill Fifth Avenue, New York, New York 10003. Published for the Club by The Seeman Printery, Inc. Durham, N. C. A REVISION OF THE GENUS GAURA (ONAGRACEAE)i Peter PI. Raven and David P. Gregory Missouri Botanical Garden and Washington University, St. Louis, Missouri and Keene State College, Keene, New Hampshire 1 This paper is respectfully dedicated to Dr. Philip A. Munz, who ha soft. K°?i eidge °f Athe.,fa™>y Onagraceae during a lifetime of devoted stuc 80th birthday, 1 April 1972. contributed so much to on the occasion of his A REVISION OK THE GENUS GAURA (ONAGRACEAE) Among the 11 genera of Onagraceae, tribe Onagreae, Gaura can be recognized by the divided sporogenous tissue in its anthers; its predominant¬ ly vespertine flowering; nutlike, indehiscent capsules; and, in most species, the presence of a flap of sterile tissue near the base of each filament (Raven, Brittonia 16: 276-288. 1964; Carlquist and Raven, Amer. J. Bot. 53: 378-390. 1966). It is probably most closely related to the other genera with divided sporogenous tissue: Calylophus, Clarkia, Heterogaura, and perhaps Hauya. Like Calylophus, the genus Gaura centers in the southern plains of the United States and adjacent Mexico, especially in and around Texas, with a few mostly derivative species endemic beyond this region. Gaura first became known to science through one of these derivative species, G. biennis. Linnaeus grew this species in the botanical garden at Uppsala from seeds that were collected in eastern Pennsylvania and brought to him by his student Peter Kalm, who collected in the area from 1748 to 1750. Linnaeus described the new genus in a thesis defended by another of his students, Leonhard Joh. Chenon, and published it in 1751. Here and in his later references to Gaura, Linnaeus erroneously included as a synonym Plukenet’s “Lysimachia lutea angustifolia virginiana, flore minore,” a concept that Plukenet had presented in his Almagestum botan - icum ... in 1696. The Virginian plants that Plukenet had were actually the plant that we now know as Oenothera biennis L. or a related species, and it is clear that Linnaeus based his concept of Gaura entirely on the living plants that he had grown himself from Kalin’s seeds. Additional species of Gaura were discovered along the eastern seaboard of the United States, and by the expeditions associated with the names of Alexander von Humboldt and Martin de Sesse y Lacasta and Jose Mariano Mocino in Mexico. Still more were added by David Douglas, Thomas Nuttall, and Thomas Drummond, among others, in their botanical explor¬ ations west of the Mississippi. By 1864, Rothrock was able to list 13 species in his synopsis of the group (Proc. Amer. Acad. Arts 6: 347-354), in which he established the genus with its present circumscription bv separating the monotypic Californian Heterogaura and reaffirming the distinctive characteristics of Spach’s genus Stenosiphon. The latter comprises a single species of the southern plains of the United States which we consider more closely allied to Oenothera than to Gaura (Raven, Brittonia 16: 276-288. 1964), whereas Heterogaura is now usually considered a derivative of 2 A REVISION OF THE GENUS CAURA ( ONAGRACEAE ) Clarkia. They were confused with Gaura at one time only because of their nutlike, indehiscent fruits, which are in fact entirely different in structure. Joseph Rothrock was a prespicacious observer. The material he had has now been increased many hundredfold, and yet the 13 species he recognized are all included in the present revision, all but one with the same names. In addition, the main groupings of species he set up appear reasonable, although we have subdivided two of them in the light of a more complete understanding of the species involved. After the publication of Rothrock’s synopsis, a few more species of Gaura were discovered, and a great deal of information was accumulated about the species that he knew. In 1938, P. A. Munz provided a much more extensive revision as one of his invaluable “Studies in Onagraceae” (Bull. Torrey Bot. Club 65: 105-122, 211-228. 1938), presenting in convenient form a critical review of what had been accomplished in the more than 70 years since the publi¬ cation of Rothrock’s brief synopsis. In 1965, Dr. Munz emended his 1938 treatment slightly in reviewing the genus Gaura again, this time for his monograph of the North American species of the family (N. Amer. FI. II. 5: 1-231). Our own studies of the genus Gaura have occupied much of our atten¬ tion for the past 15 years. During the course of our work, we have studied all of the species in the field, usually at several or in some cases up to hundreds of localities. We have observed their pollination systems and floral biology at one or more localities. All of the species have been grown in the experimental garden, and hybrids have been made in many of the possible combinations. Hundreds of determinations of chromosome number and meiotic configuration have been made ( Raven and Gregory, Brittonia 24: 71-86. 1972). All of this information has been brought to bear in the present paper upon the taxonomy of the genus, and it has naturally made possible some consolidation and reorganization of the taxa, as well as the recognition of a few hitherto undetected species. Our experimental data will not, however, be presented in the current paper, which is designed to pro¬ vide a basis for subsequent publications on different aspects of the genus Gaura. PHYLOGENETIC RELATIONSHIPS We have in the current paper divided the 21 species of Gaura we recognize into eight sections. We visualize these sections as homogeneous groups of closely related species, and important evolutionary units. Insofar as possible, we have set them up so as to be directly comparable with the sections recognized by Lewis and Lewis in their outstanding monograph of the genus Clarkia (Univ. Calif. Publ. Bot. 20: 241-392. 1955). In his MEMOIRS OF THE TORREY BOTANICAL CLUB 3 1938 revision, Munz grouped the species of Gaura into only two sections, one including only G. mutabilis. Although this species has yellow flowers, a long floral tube, and is pollinated by hawkmoths, we do not consider it much more distinct than some of the other sections we have recognized here, and we believe that sections based upon small, closely related as¬ semblages of species provide a useful basis for discussions of a genus for which sufficient information is available to make the recognition of such sections possible. W ithin Gaura, a clumped, perennial habit is clearly primitive, and is shared with the more generalized members of the relatively closely related genus Calylophus. Rhizomatous perennials and also annuals are specialized in this respect. The fruits of all species of Gaura are fundamentally similar, with thick, tough walls and usually four ovules (occasionally up to eight) and very thin partitions between the loeules that do not persist to maturity. ^ ithin this fundamental ground plan, we have assumed that more complex morphologies have been derived: ornate shape (sections Campo gaura, Xenogaura), an evident stipe (section Stipogaura ), or obvious wings on the angles (section Pterogaura ). In addition, the obviously 4-angled fruits of section Gaura are held to be more specialized than the more nearly terete ones of what we would regard as generalized species. These two trends— in habit and fruit shape— are correlated not only with one another but also with other morphological features and with the geographical distribution of the respective groups in suggesting a pattern of phylogeny for the genus as a whole. Only a few species have elongate, subterete fruits lacking wings, stipes, or other obvious elaborations (figs. 1-4). Three of these-Gm/ra mutabilis (section Gauridium ) and G. macro- carpa and G. boquillensis (section Xero gaura)— are clumped perennials. These three species are colonial, occurring in scattered localities in west Texas, Nuevo Leon, and Coahuila, and south through Chihuahua to the Sierra Madre Occidental and the Trans-Mexican Volcanic Belt. Gaura mutabilis is the only species of the genus with yellow flowers. It has a floral tube that is very narrow and 26-42 mm long, in contrast to the other species of the genus, in which the floral tube is 1.5-15 mm long. At the base of each filament, there is no scale closing the mouth of the floral tube, as there is in all other species of the genus. This species is the only member of the genus that is regularly pollinated by hawkmoths, and it may be primitive in its long floral tube and lack of scales, as well as in its yellow flowers. All of these features are found in some species of the related genus Calylophus. The two species of section Xerogaura differ from Gaura mutabilis in their white flowers, relatively short floral tube, and scale at the base of each 4 A REVISION OF THE GENUS GAURA (ONAGRACEAE) FIGURES 1-15. Mature fruits of species of Gaura. Fig. 1. G. mutabilis.— Fig. 2. G. macrocarpa.— Fig. 3. G. boquillemis.— Fig. 4. G. parvifiora.— Fig. 5. G. coccinea.— Fig. 6. G. villosa subsp. villosa.— Fig. 7. G. villosa subsp. parksii— Fig. 8. G. calcicola. —Fig. 9. G. filipes.— Fig. 10. G. mckelveyac.— Fig. 11. G. sf nuata— Fig. 12. G. drum- mnndii (G. odorata of many authors).— Fig. 13. G. lindheimeri.— Fig. 14. G. angusti- folia, 4-sided fruit.— Fig. 15. G. angmtifolia, 3-sided fmit. MEMOIRS OF THE TORREY BOTANICAL CLUB 5 FIGURES 16—30. Mature fruits of species of Gaura, and of Stenosiphon. Fig. 16. G. neomexicana subsp. neomexicana.- Fig. 17. G. neomexicana subsp. coloradensis.— Fig. 18. G. longiflora (Marion Co., Illinois).- Fig. 19. G. longiffora (Harris Co., Texas). -Fig. 20. G. biennis.- Fig. 21. G. demareei.— Fig. 22. G. suffulta subsp. suffulta — Fig. 23. G. suffulta subsp. nealleyi (G. suffulta var. terrellensis ) .—Fig. 24. G. suffulta nealletji.— Fig. 25. G. hexandra subsp. gracilis.— Fig. 26. G. hexandra subsp. hexandra. — Fig. 27. G. brachycarpa— Fig. 28. G. triangulata, 3-sided fruit.-Fig. 29. G. triangulata, 4-sided fruit.-Fig. 30. Stenosiphon linifolius. 6 A REVISION OF THE GENUS GAURA ( ONAGRACEAE ) filament. Otherwise, they resemble G. mutabilis vegetatively and in fruit morphology and, like it, have nearly actinomorphic flowers. It is tempting to speculate that, with the transition from pollination by hawkmoths to pollination by noctuids and other medium-sized moths, predominant throughout the entire genus except for G. mutabilis, the floral tube was shortened and then the scales evolved because of their adaptive role in closing the mouth of the shortened floral tube against possible “illegitimate” visitors such as bees or flies. The change to white petals seems to have occurred at this time also, but its adaptive significance is not clear. One of the most interesting points of similarity among these three species, primitive on other grounds, is that they have flowers that are actinomorphic or essentially so (figs. 31-33). With one exception, all other species of the genus have zygomorphic flowers (e.g., figs. 35-36, 58-63), a floral trend that represents an obvious specialization. The exceptional species is the autogamous annual Gaura parviflora, the only member of section Schizocarya. The very small flowers of this species (fig. 34) do not have well developed scales at the base of the anthers, but, as pointed out by Rothrock (Proc. Amer. Acad. Arts 6: 348. 1864), they do have papillae in the position of the scales in other species. This, taken together with its very generalized fruits (fig. 4) suggests strongly that Gaura parviflora was derived from an ancestor comparable to G. macrocarpa. It grows in moist places, especially along streams in plains country, and is a rank weed that produces thousands of fruits under favorable circumstances, when the plants may be up to 3 m tall, with juicy stems 3 cm or more in diameter. Specialization of the flowers and a progressive modification of the fruit toward a more or less stipe-like base residted in the evolution of Gaura coccinea (section Campogaura ), widespread and variable throughout the plains from southern Canada to south-central Mexico. Morphologically, G. coccinea is similar to G. boquillensis; but unlike all species mentioned previously, it is a polyploid complex, comprising populations with n = 7, n — 14, n = 21, and n = 28. The extensive recombination associated with polyploidy may have played a role in the success of this species in achieving the widest range of any member of the genus. Section Stipogaura consists of five closely related species in which the base of the fruit is attenuated into a stripe, and in which the fruit is some¬ times also winged at the angles (figs. 6-11). Four species are clumped diploid perennials, and of these G. villosa is a large, densely pubescent perennial of the sand dunes of western Texas and adjacent states. One of the others, G. filipes, is characteristic of drv, sandy habitats in the south¬ eastern United States, thus occurring beyond the range of any member MEMOIRS OF THE TORREY BOTANICAL CLUB 7 of the genus mentioned up to this point. The fifth species of section Stipogaura, G. sinuata, is an aggressively rhizomatous tetraploid (n=rl4) that often becomes a weed in relatively rich, light soils, as in central Texas. The single species of section Xenogaura, G. drummondii (G. odorata of many authors) is uniformly tetraploid and also an aggressive rhizomatous weed. 1 o a certain extent, its fruits ( fig. 12 ) combine the characteristics of those of G. coccinea with those of section Stipogaura, and we visualize an allotetraploid origin for it between these two groups. The diploids of section Stipogaura are less tightly clumped than are the more generalized species of the genus, and some (e.g., G. mckelveyae, G. villosa ) have a tendency to become rhizomatous in light soils. The remaining two sections are relatively large and clearly specialized within the genus. Section Gaura has six species. Of these, only one— G. lindheimeri of the black-soil prairies of east Texas and adjacent Louisiana —is perennial. It may even be secondarily perennial, and one could readily imagine how its loose clumps could be derived from the persistence and budding of the sort of taprooted annual or biennial plants that make up the rest of the section. Of these, the self-incompatible G. longiflora (G. fili- formis) is widespread in the the central United States. Populations similar to it seem to have given rise to G. neomexicana, a self-compatible relict species found in several disjunct areas along the east flank of the Rocky Mountains from southeastern Wyoming to New Mexico; to G. biennis, a complex structural heterozygote that occurs in openings in the deciduous forest of eastern North America; and to G. demareei, a localized species of southwestern Arkansas. Less closely related is the autogamous G. angusti- folia, a very common species in sandy areas of the Coastal Plain of the southeastern United States. Gaura lindheimeri and G. demareei have departed from the usual mode of pollination in the genus. Their flowers open near sunrise, instead of near sunset, and they are pollinated by bees instead of by the medium- sized moths that visit the flowers of other white-flowered outcrossing species of the genus. Their flowers are larger than those of their immediate rel¬ atives, a factor that is probably correlated with the increased caloric reward that is necessary for their pollinators to be active at the lower temperatures of early morning (Heinrich and Raven, Science 176: 597-602. 1972). The final section of Gaura, section Pterogaura, consists entirely of an¬ nual species with winged fruits and some tendency (especially in G. suff ulta subspecies nealleyi) for the formation of a stipe also. Of the four species of this group, two have relatively large flowers and are outcrossing, and two are autogamous. The former center in and around Texas, the latter extend far beyond its borders, one (G. hexandra subspecies hexandra) as 8 A REVISION OF THE GENUS GAURA ( ONAGRACEAE ) far as Guatemala and the other (G. triangulata) into Oklahoma. Gaura triangulata is a complex structural heterozygote, and, with G. biennis (sec¬ tion Gaura), one of two that has originated independently within the genus. In both of the widespread autogamous taxa in section Pterogaura (G. hexandra subspecies hexandra, G. triangulata), 3-merous flowers predom¬ inate (figs. 26, 28, 29, 61, 63), and they are likewise common in G. angusti- folia (section Gaura). In our experience, these plants are virtually never visited by insects, and thus agree with other populations in Onagraceae ( Camissonia , Ludwigia; cf., Raven, Contr. U.S. Natl. Herb. 37: 376, 377. 1969 ) in which the evolution of flowers with reduced numbers of parts seems to have followed the elimination of insect visitors and rather strict autogamy. ACKNOWLEDGMENTS We are most grateful to Rancho Santa Ana Botanic Garden and to the Plant Biology Station of the Carnegie Institution of Washington, Stanford, for the use of their facilities in cultivating selected strains of Gaura during the past 15 years. This study was initially suggested by Philip A. Munz, whose encouragement and counsel have been invaluable. Harlan Lewis has kindly reviewed the entire manuscript. The fruits (figs. 1—30) were drawn by Marilyn Wright, and the maps were mostly prepared by Pamela Radford, who also provided expert assistance in other aspects of the project. Others who helped considerably with the plants in cultivation and with the processing of many thousand herbarium specimens were Michael Huxtable and Sarah Hornby. William Tai contributed a great deal of the information on chromosome numbers and interspecific hybridization; although these results are not reviewed in detail in this paper, they have affected the conclusions we are presenting here. The work has been supported generously by a series of grants from the U.S. National Science Foundation. Many individuals have contributed special materials for this study, comprising either herbarium specimens, seeds, or fixed buds for eytological study. Others have given us the benefit of their advice in critical matters of nomenclature or in the interpretation of the literature. Among those who helped us in these and other ways, we would like especially to mention H. E. Allies, D. M. Bates, D. E. Breed¬ love, E. T. Browne, Jr., K. L. Chambers, W. J. Cody, T. S. Cooperrider, E. L. Core, D. S. Correll, J. E. Dandy, D. G. DeLisle, D. Demaree, D. B. Dunn, R. A. Evers, J. Ewan, J. M. Fogg, Jr., R. K. Godfrey, C. G. Gunn, V. J. Hoff, N. Hotchkiss, A. Hunziker, M. C. Johnston, S. B. Jones, Jr., W. M. Klein, Jr., R. W. Long, R. McVaugh, R. H. Mohlenbrock, Jr., T. Mosquin, C. Nackejima, A. M. Powell, C. F. Reed, V. E. Rudd, J. Rzedowski, S. G. Shetler, L. G. Shinners, P. D. Sorenson, W. T. Steam, J. W. Thieret, H. F. Towner, D. B. Ward, W. A. Weber, and G. S. Winterringer. We are most grateful to the curators of the following herbaria, from which material has been made available for this study: Sid Ross State College, Alpine, Texas (SRSC); Iowa State College, Ames (ISC); University of Michigan, Ann Arbor (MICH); University of Georgia, Athens (GA); University of Texas, Austin (TEX); Indiana University, Bloomington (IND); University of Colorado, Boulder (COLO); Jardin Botanique de l’Etat, Bruxelles (BR); Pringle Herbarium of the University of MEMOIRS OF THE TORREY BOTANICAL CLUB 9 Vermont, Burlington (VI ); University of Cambridge (CGE); Gray Herbarium, Cam¬ bridge (GH); New England Botanical Club, Cambridge ( NEBC); Southern Illinois University, Carbondale (SIU); University of North Carolina, Chapel Hill (NCU); Field Museum of Natural History, Chicago (F); University of Cincinnati (CINC); Pomona College, Claremont (POM); Rancho Santa Ana Botanic Garden, Clare¬ mont (RSA); Texas A & M University, College Station (TAES); Botanical Museum and Herbarium, Copenhagen (C); Oregon State University, Corvallis (OCS); Southern Methodist University, Dallas (SMU); Duke University, Durham, North Carolina (DUKE); Michigan State University, East Lansing (MSC); Royal Botanic Garden, Edinburgh (E); North Dakota State University, Fargo (NDA); University of Arkansas, Fayetteville (UARK); Herbarium Universitatis Florentinae, Firenze (F); Colorado State University, Ft. Collins ( CS ) ; Agricultural Experiment Station, Gainesville (FLAS); Conservatoire et Jardin Botaniques, Geneve (G); State Uni¬ versity of Iowa, Iowa City (IA); L. H. Bailey Hortorium, Ithaca, New York (BH); Cornell University, Ithaca (CU); Kent State University, Kent, Ohio (KE); Royal Botanic Gardens, Kew (K); University of Tennessee, Knoxville (TENN); University of Southwestern Louisiana, Lafayette (LAF); University of Kansas, Lawrence (KANU); Komarov Botanical Institute of the Academy of Sciences of the U.S.S.R., Leningrad (LE); University of Kentucky, Lexington (KY); University of Nebraska State Museum, Lincoln (NEB); British Museum (Natural History), London (BM); University of California, Los Angeles (LA); Linnaean Herbarium, London (LINN); Texas Technical University, Lubbock (TTC); University of Wisconsin, Madison (WIS); Kansas State University, Manhattan (KSC); Institute de Biologia, Mexico, D. F. (MEXU); Institute Politecnico Nacional, Mexico, D. F. (IPN); University of Minnesota, Minneapolis (MIN); West Virginia University, Morgantown (WVA); Botanische Staatssammlung, Munchen (M); Tulane University, New Orleans, Louisiana (NO); New York Botanical Garden, Bronx (NY); University of Oklahoma, Norman (OKL); University of Notre Dame, South Bend, Indiana (ND); National Museum of Canada, Ottawa (CAN); Plant Research Institute, Ottawa (DAO); Museum National d’Histoire Naturelle, Paris (P); University of Pennsylvania, Philadelphia (PENN); Academy of Natural Sciences, Philadelphia (PH); Car¬ negie Institute, Pittsburgh (CM); Botanical Research Institute, Pretoria (PRE); Texas Research Foundation, Renner (LL); Missouri Botanical Garden, St. Louis (MO); California Academy of Sciences, San Francisco (CAS); Stanford University, Stanford, California (DS); National Herbarium of New South Wales, Sydney (NSW); Florida State University, Tallahassee (FSU); University of South Florida, Tampa (USF); Pennsylvania State University, University Park (PAC); University of Illinois, Urbana (ILL); Illinois State Natural History Survey, Urbana (ILLS); US. National Museum, Washington, D.C. (US); Naturhistorisches Museum, Wien (W); Botanischer Garten und Institut fiir Systematische Botanik der Universitat Zurich (Z). SYSTEMATIC TREATMENT GAURA L. Gaura L., [Diss. Bot. Nova Plant. Gen. (p.p. L. H. Chenon) 47 1751] Sp. PI. 1: 347. 1753; Gen. PI. ed. 5. 163. 1754. Gauridium Spach, Hist. Veg. 4: 379. 1835. Lectotype: Gauridium mutabile ( Cav. ) Spach = Gaura mutabilis Spach. 10 A REVISION OF THE GENUS GAURA ( ONAGRACEAE ) Schizocarya Spach, Nouv. Ann. Mus. Hist. Nat. 4: 325, 381. 1835; Ann. Sci. Nat. (Paris) II. 4: 170, 283. 1835. Lectotype: Schizocarya micrantha Spach = Gaura parviflora Dough Annual, biennial, or perennial herbs, sometimes woody near the base. Leaves gradually decreasing in size upward, the basal or rosette leaves largest, lyrate, and gradually narrowed to a winged petiole, the cauline leaves subsessile, usually with an acuminate apex; pubescence on leaves thickest or present only along the veins, especially the midrib, and around the margins. Inflorescence a spicate raceme, sharply delimited, not leafy, more or less conspicuously pedunculate, the flowers bracteate. Flowers home laterally, usually strongly zygomorphic, the petals opening to ap¬ proximately a flat plane and all held in the upper half of the flower, the stamens and style projecting slightly forward and mostly confined to the lower quarter or half of the flower, or more rarely the flowers actinomorphic. opening either near sunset or near sunrise and fading within a single day, usually 4-merous but less commonly 3-merous. Floral tube narrow, mostly 0.75-1.5 mm in diameter at its apex, usually lanate in upper half within, the lower half swollen and secreting nectar. Petals usually white, flushed with reddish after pollination, usually sharply clawed. Stamens twice as many as the sepals, subequal. Each filament usually with a scale ca. 0.3-0. 5 mm long near its base, these scales nearly closing the mouth of the hvpanth- ium; anthers usually reddish, the sporogenous tissue divided by sterile tissue into discrete packets. Style with the same sort of pubescence in the same area as the floral tube, the hairs interlocking. Stigma deeply 4-(3-)lobed, usually held beyond the anthers in outcrossing species. Fruit an indehiscent, nutlike capsule with hard, woody walls, basically 4- (3-) locular but the septa incomplete and fragile, not evident at maturity; fruit with 1 ovule per locule basically but the whole fruit often with only 1 ovule and occasionally as many as 8. Seeds ovoid, mostly 2-3 mm long and 1-1.5 mm thick, soft, smooth, usually flattened on some or all of the sides, top, and bottom by crowding within the fruit, yellowish to pale brown. Basic chromosome number, x = 7. Self-incompatibility characteristic of 13 of the 21 species. Type Species: Gaura biennis L. The sympatric occurrence of species of Gaura is indicated in table 1, which incorporates our own observations as well as those of Bryan (Southw. Naturalist 8: 10-14. 1963). Naturally occurring hybrids have been observed only between G. lindheimeri and G. longiflora (rather frequently) and be¬ tween G. calcicola and G. coccinea (one plant; Raven and Gregory, Brit- tonia 24: 71-86. 1972). They also probably occur at some localities where G. drummondii and G. coccinea grow together. The distribution maps presented in this paper generally include onlv TABLE 1. Sympatric occurrence of species of Gaura.1 m cc a u -a oj f- dddddddddddddd ddddd G. biennis • G. boquillensis o • G,' brachycarpa 0 o • G. calcicola 0 o o • G. coccinea X X X 2 • G. drummondii 0 0 X X 3 • G. hexandra gracilis 0 0 o 0 X 0 • G. h. hexandra o 0 0 0 X X 4 • G. lindheimeri o 0 o 0 o 0 0 0 • G. longiflora 5 0 o 0 X 0 o 0 6 • G. macrocarpa 0 0 o 0 X 0 0 0 0 o • G. mckelveyae 0 0 o 0 o 0 o 0 0 o 0 • G. mutabilis o 0 0 0 o 0 o X 0 o o o • G. neomexicana coloradensis 0 0 o 0 X 0 o 0 0 0 0 0 0 • G. n. neomexicana 0 0 o 0 X 0 o o o o o o o 7 • G. parviflora X 0 X X X X 0 o 0 X o X o X o • G. sinuata 0 o X 0 X X o 0 0 0 0 o o o 0 X • G. suffulta nealleyi 0 0 o o X 0 0 o o 0 X o 0 o o o 0 • G. s. suffulta o 0 X X X X o 0 0 o o o o 0 o X X 8 • G. triangulata o 0 o o X 0 0 0 0 o o 0 0 0 0 o X 0 X • G. villosa parksii o 0 X o o 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 o X o 0 0 0 • G. v. villosa 0 0 o 0 X o o | o 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 o X 0 9 • 1 Gaura a/ngustifolia, G. demareei, and G. filipes, which we have not observed growing with other species of the genera, are not included in the table. Numbers in the table refer to the notes. Unless otherwise noted, s signifies sympatric occurrence without hybridization. 2 One hybrid individual found; Raven & Gregory, Brittonia 24; 71-86. 1972. 3 Hybridization probable but difficult to confirm owing to close similarity of parents. 4 Autogamous and occurring in mixed colonies. 6 Sympatric occurrence and hybridization almost certain but difficult to confirm owin°- to very close similarity of parents. ® Hybridization frequent but species remain largely distinct. 7 Allopatric subspecies. 8 Broadly intergrading subspecies. 9 Allopatric subspecies. G. triangulata G. villosa parksii G. v. villosa 12 A REVISION OF THE GENUS GAURA ( ONAGRACEAE ) one record per county. Records from particular counties not included among the lists of cited specimens are available from Raven on request. The floral characters of Gaura have not been utilized to any great ex¬ tent in previous systems of classification, largely because the flowers wither and fade approximately 12-16 hours after they first open. The photographs of each taxon in this paper were taken of plants grown in the experimental garden at Stanford University within a few hours after the flowers first opened. We hope that these photographs and the drawings of mature fruits (figs. 1-30) will prove useful in conjunction with the key. KEY TO THE SPECIES Floral tube 26-42 mm long; petals yellow . 1. G. mutabilis Floral tube 1.5-15 mm long; petals white. Fruits with a slender stipe 0.5—10 mm long. Plants suffrutescent, conspicuously and densely soft-villous with long hairs . 6. G. villosa Plants herbaceous, not conspicuously and densely soft-villous with long hairs. Leaves deeply sinuate; plants sparsely villous and strigulose; south Texas and adjacent Mexico . 0. G. mckelveyae Leaves slightly to markedly sinuate; pubescence variable. Clumped perennials; apex of the inflorescence in bud slender, the buds small and well-spaced. Leafy portion subglabrous to sparsely strigulose, sometimes with admixture of longer hairs; stamens held in lower half of flower; west Texas and south into Mexico . 7. G. calcicola Leafy portion either strigulose or villous; stamens distributed around the perimeter of the flower; east Louisiana to Florida and South Carolina . 8. G. filipes Annual or rhizomatous perennial; apex of inflorescence in bud stout, the buds large and crowded. Coarse annual; inflorescence glandular-pubescent; stipe 0.2-2.2 mm long . 18a. G. suffulta subsp. nealleyi Mat-forming, rhizomatous perennial; inflorescence subglabrous or strigulose; stipe 3—8 mm long . 10- G. sinuata Fruits subsessile or with a thick, cylindrical stipe. Sepals 2-3.5 mm long; petals 1.5-3 mm long . 4. G. parviflora Sepals (2.5-) 4.5-17 mm long; petals 3.5-15 mm long. Flowers nearly actinomorphic; fruits fusiform, often curved, 8—17 mm long, 1-2.5 mm thick; Trans-Pecos Texas to central Chi¬ huahua, Coahuila, and western Nuevo Leon. Floral tube 9-13 mm long; flowers actinomorphic. 2. G. macrocarpa Floral tube 5-8.5 mm long; flowers somewhat zygomorphic 3. G. BOQUIELENSIS MEMOIRS OF THE TORREY BOTANICAL CLUB 13 Flowers zygomorphic, usually strongly so; fruits variable, 4-13 mm long, often thicker; widespread. F ruits more or less abruptly constricted to a thick cylindrical stipe nearly half the length of the body; perennial species. Plants from a branching woody caudex; fruits not conspicuously bulging above, 4— 8.5(-9) mm long, (1-)1.5— 3 mm thick; bracts 2—5 mm long, 0.4-1. 1 mm wide . 5. G. coccinea Plants aggressively rhizomatous; fruits conspicuously bulging above, 7—13 mm long, 3—5 mm thick; bracts 2—8 mm long, 0.8-2 mm wide . 11. G. drummondii Fruits not abruptly constricted to a thick cylindrical stipe; mostly annual or biennial species from a taproot. Flowers 3-merous; fruits 3-angled. Plant usually simple below, 6—18 dm tall; fruit narrowly ellipsoid or ellipsoid; coastal plain from Florida to North Carolina . 13. Q. angustifolia Plant usually branched at the base, 1. 5-6.5 (-10) dm tall; fruits ellipsoid or ovoid. Sepals very finely strigulose or subglabrous; pollen ca. 50 percent aborted; north-central Texas and Oklahoma . 21. G. TRIANGULATA Sepals strigulose or glandular pubescent; pollen mostly fertile. Sepals 3—10 mm long; inflorescence usually gland¬ ular-pubescent; Mexico and Guatemala . 19b G. HEXANDRA Subsp. HEXANDRA Sepals 10-15 mm long; inflorescence strigulose; Texas and adjacent states . 20. G. brachycarpa Flowers 4-merous; fruits 4-angled. Sepals with long erect hairs; flowers opening near sun¬ rise; petals 10.5-15 mm long; perennial; southeast Texas and Louisiana . 12. G. lindheimeri Sepals with appressed pubescence, or flowers opening near sunset and much smaller; annual or biennial. Biennial from a stout taproot; meadows of Colorado, Wyoming, and New Mexico . 14. G. neomexicana Annual, occasionally persisting through mild winters. Fruits broadly winged on the angles and deeply furrowed between the angles; plants rarely to 1 m tall, usually well branched from the base. Sepals 6-12 mm long, glandular-pubescent, sub- glabrous, or strigulose; Mexico to Arizona and New Mexico. .19. G. hexandra subsp. gracilis Sepals 10-21 mm long, glabrous or strigulose; Texas and adjacent states, but not known from Mexico or New Mexico. Sepals glabrous; bracts 2.5-6.5 mm long . 18. G. SUFFULTA subsp. SUFFULTA 14 A REVISION OF THE GENUS GAURA ( ONAGRACEAE ) Sepals strigulose; bracts 2-4 mm long . 20. G. BRACHYCARPA Fruits angled but not winged; plants often 1-4 m tall, usually unbranched from the base. Sepals 2.5-8 mm long; flowers often 3-merous and 4-merous on the same plant; coastal plain from Florida to North Carolina . 13. G. ANGUSTIFOLIA Sepals 8-20 mm long; flowers 4-merous; not on coastal plain. Flowers opening near sunrise; sepals 13—20 mm long; pubescence appressed; southwestern Arkansas . 17. G. demareei Flowers opening near sunset ( rarely near sun¬ rise in Louisiana and Alabama ) ; sepals 8— 18 mm long; pubescence appressed or spreading. Stems densely villous; inflorescence glandular- pubescent; pollen about 50 percent fertile (usually 35-65 percent) . 16. G. biennis Stems strigulose or villous; inflorescence ap¬ pressed- or glandular-pubescent; pollen usually more than 90 percent fertile . 15. G. LONGIFLORA SECTION I. GAURIDIUM Gaura sect. Gauridium (Spach) Endl., Gen. 1195. 1840. Gauridium Spach, Hist. Veg. 4: 379. 1835. Clumped perennial herb, the steins villous, hirtellous, and glandular- pubescent. Inflorescences erect. Flowers nearly actinomorphic, the petals spreading at right angles, the stamens and style projecting outward from the flower; flowers opening near sunset and withering rapidly tit next morning. Floral tube sparsely pubescent within. Petals yellow, flushed with red after anthesis, not clawed. Filaments lacking scales. Fruit not reflexing, narrowly ovoid or fusiform, rounded at the base and gradually tapering to a point near the apex, mostly terete but occasionally somewhat 4-angled, the ribs obscure but the 4 main ones broader. Self-compatible. Gametic chromosome number, n = 7. Type Species: Gaura mutabilis Cav. [Gauridium mutabile (Cav.) Distribution: Middle elevations in the Sierra Madre Occidental and Trans-Mexican Volcanic Belt of Mexico, south to the vicinity of Oaxaca; usually in pine or oak forest. , Gaura mutabilis, the single species of this section, has an array of what have been interpreted as generalized features within the genus: large, nearly actinomorphic, yellow flowers that lack scales at the base of the MEMOIRS OF THE TORREY BOTANICAL CLUB 15 35 36 FIGURES 31-36. Flowers of species of Ganra. Fig. 31. G. mutabilis. -Fig. 32. G. macrocarpa.- Fig. 33. G. boquiUensis. -Fig. 34. G. pam/lora.-Fig. 35. G. coccinea. -Fig. 36. G. drummondii (G. odorata of many authors). 16 A REVISION OF THE GENUS GAURA ( ONAGRACEAE ) filaments and have the longest floral tube in Gaura; elongate fruits that are superficially similar to the capsules from which they have been derived; and a Mexican distribution. Viewed in an ecological context, however, the interpretation of these characteristics becomes more difficult, for G. muta¬ bilis is the only hawkmoth-pollinated species of the genus, and all or most of the floral features could be associated with this. Furthermore, the species is self-compatible, an obviously secondary characteristic. Despite these cautionary notes, there is enough overall similarity in fruit morphology and habit to G. macrocarpa to suggest that G. mutabilis is at the very least an ancient offshoot of a primitive group of species of Gaura, and to leave it in its customary position at the start of the genus. 1. Gaura mutabilis Cav., Ic. 3: 30, pi. 258. 1795. Munz, Bull. Torrey Bot. Club 65: 107. 1938; N. Amer. FI. II. 5: 183. 1965. Figs. 1, 31. Oenothera anomala Curtis, Bot. Mag. 11: pi. 388. 1809. Based on Gaura mutabilis Cav. Gaura oenotheriflora Zucc., in Roem., Coll. 140. 1809. Lectotype: culti¬ vated, herb. Zuccagni (FI). Gaura mollis H.B.K., Nov. Gen. et Sp. 6: 93, pi. 529. 1823. Type: Mexico, 1803-1804, Alexander von Humboldt (P). Gauridium mutabile (Cav.) Spach, Hist. Veg. 4: 380. 1835. Gauridium molle (H.B.K.) Spach, Hist. Veg. 4: 380. 1835. Gauridium kunthii Spach, Nouv. Ann. Mus. Hist. Nat. 4: 375. 1835. Based on Gaura mollis H.B.K. Gaura grandiflora Rose, Contr. U. S. Natl. Herb. 12: 293. 1909. Type: Papasquiaro, Durango, Mexico, 7 August 1898, E. W. Nelson 4671 (US 332725. Isotype, K). Gaura gentri/i Standley, Field Mus. Nat. Hist. Bot. Ser. 17: 203. 1937. Type: On rocky outcroppings, Guasaremos, Rio Mayo, Chihuahua, Mexico, 26 September 1935, II. S. Gentry 1859 (F. Isotypes, GH, K, MO, PH, US). Gaura mutabilis Cav. f. glabra Munz, Bull. Torrey Bot. Club 65: 108. 1938. Based on Gaura grandiflora Rose. Munz, N. Amer. Fl. II. 5: 184. 1965. Clumped perennial herb with a heavy, woody, twisted rootstock; stems erect, branching near the base and again just below the inflorescence, 2.5- 8.5 dm tall. Pubescence of very long hairs 3.5-4.5 mm long near the base, scattered upward; shorter erect hairs on the stems, leaves (especially along midrib and margins), and sometimes in the inflorescence; and erect glan¬ dular hairs found all over the plant. Leaves narrowly lanceolate to lanceolate, sometimes narrowly elliptic, 1 —6 ( —8 ) cm long, 0.2-1.8 cm wide, sinuate- MEMOIRS OF THE TORREY BOTANICAL CLUB 17 dentate to subentire. Inflorescence unbranched, 5-25 cm long, glandular- pubescent with varying amounts of short erect eglandular hairs; bracts narrowly lanceolate to lanceolate, 2-9 mm long, 1-1.75 mm wide. Floral tube 26-42 mm long. Sepals 11-24 mm long, 1-2 mm wide. Petals 12-25 mm long, 6-15 mm wide. Filaments 5-18 mm long; anthers 3-5 mm long. Style 38-67 mm long. Fruit 7-13 mm long, 2-6 mm thick. Seeds almost always 4, 2.5-4.5 mm long, 1.5-2 mm thick, light reddish brown. Self¬ compatible, the stigma surrounded by the anthers at anthesis or held well above them. Gametic chromosome number, n = 7. Type: Described from plants cultivated in the Botanical Garden at Madrid, the seeds of Mexican origin. Distribution ( fig. 37 ) : Rocky slopes and outcrops in pine or oak forest, rarely in matorral, 2000—2800 m elevation, from the vicinity of Chihuahua and the upper Rio Mayo in Sonora scattered southward in the 18 A REVISION OF THE GENUS GAURA ( ONAGRACEAE ) Sierra Madre Occidental to the Trans-Mexican Volcanic Belt as far as southern Hidalgo and Puebla; collected once near Oaxaca. Flowers July to September. Representative Specimens Examined: Mexico, chihuahua. Colonia Juarez, Jones in 1903 (DS, POM); hills near Chihuahua, Pringle 1125 (BM, BR, COCO, F, G, CH, LE, MSC, RSA, US); high plains between Cusihuiriachic and Guerrero, Pringle 1244 (COCO, F, GH, MEXU, MIN, NO, NY, PH, RSA, US); Culebra Mts., Le Sueur in 1936 (GH, MO, SMU); e foothills of Sierra Madre 13 mi w of General Trias, 5900 ft, Ripley & Barneby 13887 ( DS, NY), durango. 3 mi ne of Otinapa, Maysilles 7305 (MICH, RSA); ca. 60 air miles sw of Durango, 2500-2650 m, Maysilles 7792 (MICH); ca. 50 km w of Durango near the highway to Mazatlan, 2550 m, McVaugh 21677 (MICH); near El Salto, Nelson 4570 (POM, US); Papasquiaro, Nelson 4671 (GH); Durango and vicinity, Palmer 270 ( BM, F, G, GH, MO, NY, US); Palos Colorados on railroad w of Durango, 2400 m, Pennell 18233 (PH, US); Sierra de Registro 13 mi nw of Nombre de Dios, 6300 ft, Ripley &■ Barneby 14165 (DS); 9 m w of Durango, Water¬ fall 12560 (GH, MICH, OKLA, US): 28 mi sw of Durango, Waterfall is Wallis 13563 (IA, OKLA, SMU); 5 mi sw of Durango, Waterfall 15416 (OKL, OKLA, SMU). Guanajuato. Guanajuato, Dtiges 303 (GH); Montapues, Guanajuato and vicinity, Duges 303 A (GH); Cerro de la Batea, Guillemin-T ardyre (K, LE, P); near summit of Montana de Cubilete, ne of Silao, 8000 ft, Straw 6- Forman 1450 (MICH, RSA). hidalgo. Hills near Marquez, 8000 ft, Pringle 7635 (POM, US); Cerro Ventoso, between Pachuca and Real del Monte, 2600 m, Rzeclowski 20622 ( DS, IPN, ISC, MICH, TEX); Cerro Santa Ana, 10 mi ne of Apam, West B-l (DS). Mexico. Santa Fe, Valley of Mexico, Bourgeati 296 (C, C»H, NY, RSA, L^S); 12 mi s of Tlapam, D.F., W. E. dr M. S. Manning 531051 (GH); lomas de Mixcoae, D.F., Lyonnet 1471 (US); Villa Obregon, w of San Angel, 8000 ft, D.F., Munz 15056 (GH, MO); Pedrigal, Valley of Mexico, Pringle 6661 (BM, BR, CM, F, G, C,H, IPN, ISC, LE, M, MEXU, MIN, MO, ND, NMC, NY, PH, US), morelos. Hwy. to Cuernevaca near Morelos Monument, Straw 6- Gregory 1076 (DAO, GY, MEXU, MICH, RSA). oaxaca. Near Oaxaca, Anclricux 384 (CH). puehla. Santa Barbara, Nicolas 259 (BY, F, GH, MO, NY, P, US); San Martin, Nelson in 1893 (US); vicinity of San Luis Tultitlanapa, near Oaxaca, Purpus 3388 (BM, F, CH, MO, NY, US); Puenta de Emperador near La Venta, 8300 ft., Sharp 44393 (RSA); Cerro Amalucan, 8 km al e de Puebla, Rzedowski 24135 (DS, IPN). sonora. Alamos Dist., Arroyo, Algodones valley, Gentry 468 ( DS, MICH); Arroyo del Auga Blanca, Distrito Alamos, Gentry 514 (MICH); Sierra de las Papas, Gentry 622 ( DS, MICH). Gaura mutabilis is sometimes called “noche buena,” this name con¬ trasting the late opening of its flowers (in full dark after sunset) with those of G. coccinea “linda tarde.” It has been in cultivation in botanical gardens ever since its first introduction in the 1790’s. In Mexico, it tends to be colonial, with individual populations widely scattered. There is a small amount of interpopulational variability, especially in pubescence, style length, and fruit shape, but no consistent patterns that appear to require formal taxonomic recognition. MEMOIRS OF THE TORREY BOTANICAL CLUB 19 SECTION II. XEROGAURA Herbae perennes confertae, caulibus strigulosis, scabris, glandulosis, vel villosis. Inflorescentiae subnutantes. Flores subactinomorphi, stylo subdeclinato, vespertini. Frueti fusiformes, saepe subcurvati, tereti, costibus 4 majoribus, 4 angustioribus. Clumped perennial herbs, the stems strigulose, scabrous, glandular, or villous, or with various mixtures of these pubescence types. Inflorescences slightly nodding. Flowers nearly actinomorphic, the style slightly declinate; flowers opening near sunset and withering the next morning. Fruit reflexing or not, fusiform, often slightly curved, terete, with 4 main ribs and 4 narrower ones. Self-incompatible. Gametic chromosome number, n = 7. Type Species: Gaura macrocarpa Rothr. Distribution: Washes and sandy flats from the Davis Mountains of west Texas to central Chihuahua, Coahuila, and western Nuevo Leon. The white, nearly actinomorphic flowers and elongate fruits of the two species of this section seem clearly to be generalized features within the genus. 2. Gaura macrocarpa Rothr., Proc. Amer. Acad. Arts 6: 353. 1864-1865. Munz, Bull. Torrey Bot. Club 65: 115. 1938; N. Amer. FI. II. 5: 186. 1965. Figs. 2, 32. Clumped perennial herb with a narrow woody rootstock usually branch¬ ing several centimeters below the ground level; stems with several branches from the base and occasional branches above, arching slightly outward from the base but then strictly erect, 2-10 dm tall. Pubescence of four kinds of hairs: 1. long (1-1.5 mm) erect hairs near the base of the plant; 2. short, appressed hairs everywhere but heaviest on the ovaries and usually least dense on the branches of the inflorescence; 3. short, scabrous hairs, thick at the base, common around edges of leaves but sometimes dense on stems also; and 4. short, erect, glandular hairs all over the plant, usually heaviest on the branches of the inflorescence. Leaves very narrowly elliptic or usually narrowly lanceolate, 0.5-8 cm long, 0. 1-0.8 cm wide, subentire to sinuate-denticulate, the apex mucronate. Inflorescence 10-25 cm long, often with a few branches near the base; bracts narrowly ovate, 1.5-3 mm long, 0.85-1.25 mm wide. Many flowers in a single inflorescence open at one time. Floral tube 9-13 mm long. Sepals 7-9 mm long, 1-2 mm wide. Petals 7-8 mm long, 3-6 mm wide. Stamens projecting forward from the flower. Filaments 4-4 mm long; anthers 4-5 mm long. Style 18-22 mm long. Fruit not reflexing, (9-) 13-17 mm long, 2-3 mm thick, with 8 ribs of about equal prominence, although 4 are slightly narrower; fruits sessile. 20 A REVISION OF THE GENUS GAURA ( ONAGRACEAE ) MEMOIRS OF THE TORREY BOTANICAL CLUB 21 Seeds (l-)3-4, 2-3.5 mm long, 1-2 mm thick, yellowish or light brown. Self-incompatible. Gametic chromosome number, n = 7. Lectotype: Limpia Canyon (“Valley of the Limpio”), Jeff Davis Co., Texas, 21-26 August 1849, C. Wright 1079 (US 59209. Isotypes, BM, GH, LE, M, P, PH); Munz, Bull. Torrey Bot. Club 65: 115. 1938. Distribution (Fig. 38): Sandy flats and washes, very local, vicinity of the Davis Mountains in eastern Jeff Davis Co., northeastern Presidio Co., and northern Brewster Co., Texas; near Gallego and Chihuahua, Chihuahua. Flowers, May to July. Representative Specimens Examined: Mexico, chihuahua. 7 mi n of Gallego, Breedlove 15729 (DS); Chihuahua, Palmer 195 (NY, US). United States, texas. Brewster Co.: Haley Ranch, Parks ir Cory 9278 (POM, TAES); Flats to Sunny Glen, Sperry T604 (GH, TAES, US); 2 mi e of Alpine, Warnock 8468 (LL, SMU); Bois d’Arc Spring, Warnock 127 (PENN). Jeff Davis Co.: Near Fort Davis, Palmer 34558 (GH, MO, NY, PH, US); 18.3 mi s of Toyahvale, 0.7 mi n of Wild Rose Pass, Gregory 165 (RSA); 5.8 mi s of Toyahvale, Gregory 252 ( RSA). Presidio Co.: 5 mi w of Alpine, Gregory 202 ( DS, RSA); 2.7 mi n of Marfa, T. 6- L. Mosquin 5651 (DAO). Gaura macrocarpa is known only from three disjunct regions and it seems likely, in view of its generalized features, that it is a relatively old species that has survived locally in a few favorable situations. It has been collected only twice in Mexico. 3. Gaura boquillensis Raven & Gregory, sp. nov. Figs. 3, 33. Herba perennis sublignosa copiose multiramosa, 2.5-10 dm alta, stri- gulosa saepe etiam glandulosa scaberulaque. Folia 0.5-6.5(-13) cm longa, 0.1-1 cm lata, basalia anguste oblanceolata raro spatulata, superiora angus- tissime elliptica vel anguste lanceolata, saepe linearia, subsessilia, sinuato- dentata vel subintegria, plerumque sinuata. Inflorescentia 8-37 cm longa, stricta, bracteis lanceolatis vel linearibus 1.5-3.5 mm longis, 0.25-0.5 mm latis. Tubus floris 3-8.5 mm longus, intus costibus hispidulus. Sepala 3-9 mm longa, 1-2.5 mm lata. Petala 4-10 mm longa, 2-4.5 mm lata. Filamenta 2-4.5 mm longa; antherae 2-4 mm longae. Stylus 6.5-15 mm longus, basin versus hispidulus. Fructus fusiformis, subarcuatus, 5.5-13 mm longus, 1-2.5 crassus, interdum parte tertia inferiora subattenuata stipaformaque; semina ( 1- ) 2-4, 1.5-2.5 mm longa, 0.75-1.25 mm crassa, obovoidea, straminea vel pallide brunnea. Numerus chromosomaticus gameticus, n = 7. Clumped perennial herb with a narrow, woody rootstock usually branch¬ ing several centimeters below the ground level; stems well branched at the base and above, often somewhat woody, the plant very full, 2.5-10 dm tall. 22 A REVISION OF THE GENUS GAURA ( ONAGRACEAE ) Pubescence very variable, of three kinds of hairs: 1. short, erect glandular hairs, absent or fairly dense on stems and leaves; 2. strigulose pubescence, common everywhere except the branches of the inflorescence; 3. short, scabrous hairs, thick at base, usually sparse on stems and leaves, sometimes dense, absent in inflorescence. Leaves usually narrowly oblanceolate near the base, becoming very narrowly elliptic or narrowly lanceolate upward, or often linear, 0.5-6.5(-13) cm long, 0.1-1 cm wide, sinuate-dentate to sub¬ entire. Inflorescence unbranched, 8-37 cm long; bracts lanceolate to linear, 1.5-3. 5 mm long, 0.25-0.5 mm wide. Floral tube 3-8.5 mm long. Sepals 3-9 mm long, 1-2.5 mm wide. Petals 4-10 mm long, 2-4.5 mm wide. Filaments 2-4.5 mm long; anthers 2-4 mm long. Style 6.5-15 mm long. Fruit often reflexing at maturity, 5.5-13 mm long, 1-2.5 mm thick, some¬ times slightly narrowed in the lower third and then approaching a stipitate condition. Seeds (l-)2-4, 1.5-2.5 mm long, 0.75-1.25 mm thick, yellowish or light brown. Self-incompatible. Gametic chromosome number, n - 7. Type: Mouth of Boquillas Canyon, Big Bend National Park, Brewster Co., Texas, 20 April 1960, D. P. Gregory 232 (RSA 145239. Isotype, NY). Distribution (fig. 38): Washes and sandy canyonsides in the drv moun¬ tains near the Rio Grande in southern Brewster Co., Texas, southward to central Chihuahua, Coahuila, and western Nuevo Leon. Flowers, May and June. Representative Specimens Examined: Mexico, chihuahua. Plains near Chihuahua, Pringle 1497 (GH, MEXU); 5 mi s of Gallego, Shreve 7930 (US), coahuila. 1 mi e of Muzquiz, Gould 11230 (DS); 3 mi above Socorro, Johnston 8840 (GII); Monclova, Marsh 1679 ( F, GH, OKLA, TEX), 1704 (GH); Muzquiz, Santa Anna Canyon, Marsh 483 (OKLA, SMU, TEX) 5.6 mi e of Saltillo, Towner 55 (DS); 12 mi e of Saltillo, Canedo et al. 9072 ( DS, DUKE, OKLA, SMU, TEX, TTC); El Puerto de San Lazaro, Wynal & Mueller 145 (A, FSU, ILL, MICH, MO, MSC, US); w slope of Sierra de San Vicente, Schroeder 132 (GH). nuevo leon. Sierra Madre Oriental, Monterrey, Mueller 218 (A, POM); 79.9 mi s of Tamaulipas border on road from Nuevo Leon to Monterrey, Towner 37 (DS). United States, texas. Brewster Co.: Boquillas Canyon, Harrison in 1919 (WISC), Warnock in 1937 (TAES), Cory 2139 (POM); Big Bend National Park, Webster 4481 (DUKE, G, OKLA, SMU, W); mouth of Santa Elena Canyon, A. 6- R. A. Nelson 5052 (GH), Innes et al. 503 (GH); banks of the Rio Grande, in Grand Canyon, Palmer 34224 (MIN, NY); Pinnacle Mts., Chisos Mts. area, Warnock 1055 (US). This distinctive new species has been confused with G. macrocarpa, but differs markedly in its smaller, more irregular flowers and shorter, somewhat stipitate fruits. It grows in the same general area as G. macro- carpa, and the two species may ultimately be found growing together near Gallego or Chihuahua. MEMOIRS OF THE TORREY BOTANICAL CLUB 23 SECTION III. SCHIZOCARYA Gaura sect. Schizocarya (Spach) Raven & Gregory, comb. nov. Schizocarya Spach, Nouv. Ann. Mus. Hist. Nat. 4: 325, 381. 1835; Ann. Sei. Nat. (Paris) II. 4: 170, 283. 1835. Rank annual herb, the stems glandular-pubescent with an admixture of villous pubescence. Inflorescences slender, nodding. Flowers actino- morphic, the petals open only to about 90°, the stamens and stigma erect; flowers opening near sunset and withering the next morning. Filaments with minute scales only. Fruit reflexing at maturity, fusiform, tapering more or less abruptly toward the base, terete, weakly 4-ridged and furrowed in the upper third, 8-ribbed below. Autogamous. Gametic chromosome number, n = 7. Lectotype Species: Gaura parviflora Dough ( Schizocarya micrantha Spach ) . Distribution: Weedy places and along streams throughout the central United States, south to central Mexico. Despite Rothrock’s accurate observation in 1864 (Proc. Amer. Acad. Arts 6: 348), the papillae to which the scales at the base of the filaments in Gaura parviflora have been reduced have generally been overlooked since. Their presence makes very likely the derivation of this rank annual weed from plants similar to those currently assigned to sect. Xerogaura highly probable, in view of the very similar fruits. Presumably the scales, which serve in most species of Gaura to exclude all but long-tongued in¬ sects from the nectar in the floral tube, have been greatly reduced in G. parviflora owing to its strict autogamy, very small flowers, and absence of nectar. 4. Gaura parviflora Dougl., in Hook., FI. Bor.-Amer. 1:208. 1833. Hook., Bot. Mag. 63: t. 3506. 1836. Munz, Bull. Torrey Bot. Club 65: 108. 1938; N. Amer. FI. II. 5: 184. 1965. Figs. 4, 34. Schizocarya micrantha Spach, Ann. Sci. Nat. (Paris) II. 4: 283. 1835. Lectotype: Austin, Travis Co., Texas, 1833-1834, Thomas Drummond 46 (G. Isolectotypes, GH, NY); Munz, Bull. Torrey Bot. Club 65- 110 1938. Gaura micrantha (Spach) D. Dietr., Enum. PI. 2: 1297. 1840. Gaura hirsuta Scheele, Linnaea 21: 580. 1848. Type: Prairies between Bastrop and Austin, Bastrop or Travis Co., Texas, 1846, Ferdinand Roemer (not seen). Gaura australis Griseb., Abh. Konigl. Ges. Wiss. Gottingen. 24: 132. 1879. 24 A REVISION OF THE GENUS GAURA ( ONAGRACEAE ) Lectotype: Entre Mina Argentina y Yerba Buena, en las cercanias del Cerro de Orcosu, Dpto. Minas, Cordoba, Argentina, 17 Feb. 1876, Hieronymus 399 (GOET. Isolectotype, CORD. Neither seen). Gaura parviflora Dougl. var. lachnocarpa Weath., Rhodora 27: 14. 1925. Type: Roadside, Austin, Travis Co., Texas, 18 April 1918, M. S. Young 95 (GH. Isotype, TEX). Gaura parviflora Dougl. var. tyjnca Munz, Bull. Torrey Bot. Club 65: 109. 1938. Gaura parviflora Dougl. var. typica Munz f. glabra Munz, Bull. Torrey Bot. Club 65: 110. 1938. Type: Deer Run, 4700 ft, between Kannah and Delta, Meso Co., Colorado, 11 June 1901, C. F. Baker 94 (POM 32745. Isotypes, GH, NY, US). Rank annual herb with a heavy taproot up to 3 cm or more in diameter; stems erect, usually unbranched or branching just below the inflorescence, thick and juicy, tapering gradually to the inflorescences, (2-)3-20(-30) dm tall, the basal leaves usually deciduous by the time of flowering and the lower stems then naked. Pubescence up to the base of the inflorescences dense, glandular, with fewer long, spreading hairs, both of which also occur along the main veins and margins of the leaves; surface of leaves strigulose. Leaves narrowly elliptic to narrowly ovate, mostly commonly acuminate, 2-12.5 cm long, 0.5-4 cm wide, slightly sinuate-dentate. Rosette leaves often broadly oblanceolate, up to 15 cm long and 3 cm wide, the blade gradually narrowed into a winged petiole. Inflorescence a series of subterminal dense, spicate racemes 5-45 cm long, glabrous (except for long hairs on edges of floral bracts) to densely covered with a mixture of glandular and eglandular, long hairs, then also with short erect hairs on the ovaries and loosely ap- pressed pubescence on the calyx; bracts narrowly lanceolate to linear, 1.5- 5.5 mm long, 0.25-0.5 mm wide. Floral tube 1.5-5 mm long. Sepals 2-3.5 mm long, 0.5-1 mm wide. Filaments 1.5-3 mm long; anthers 0.5-1 mm long, shedding pollen directly on the stigma at or before anthesis. Style 3-9 mm long; lobes of the stigma short. Fruit 5-11 mm long, 1.5-3 mm thick. Seeds 3-4, 2-3 mm long, 1-1.5 mm thick, reddish brown. Autogamous. Gametic chromosome number, n = 7. Type: Sandy banks of the Walla Walla River, Walla Walla Co., Wash¬ ington, 10-16 June 1826, David Douglas (K. Isotype, BM). Distribution (fig. 39): Weed of cultivated fields, pastures, waste places, and along streams, throughout the interior of North America; in the United States from Indiana, Iowa, southern South Dakota, Montana (very rare), and southeastern Washington to the lower Mississippi River; in Mexico, Nuevo Leon, Zacatecas, Durango, Sinaloa, and Baja California. Locally MEMOIRS OF THE TORREY BOTANICAL CLUB 25 FIGURE 39. Range of Gaura parviflora in the United States and Mexico. established in the United States in Alabama, California, Florida, Georgia, Massachusetts, and Tennessee. Introduced in Argentina (Cordoba, San Luis), China, Okinawa, and northern Australia. Flowers throughout the warm part of the year. In Argentina, Gaura parviflora grows in disturbed ground, near roads and houses, in ravines, and along intermittently dry streams at 500 to 1000 m elevation. The earliest collection we have seen from South America is that of Hieronymus, cited above, which was made in 1876. Representative Specimens Examined (outside United States only): Argentina, cordoba. Dpto. Calamuchita: Valle de los Reartes, Castellanos 48 (GH); La Cruz, ca. 850 m, Gutierrez 109 (BH). Dpto. Capital: Alrededores de la Ciudad de Cordoba, A. T. Hunziker 8108 (RSA); alrededores del cementerio, Stuckert 3610 (G, GH). Dpto. Isehilin: Quilino, Villafafio 76 (NY, TEX, US). Dpto. Punilla: Valle Hermoso, Carlson in 1940 (RSA); Sierra de Cordoba, Capilla del Monte, Barros in 1925 (GH); San Francisco, Sierra de Cordoba, Hieronymus 578 (NY); Sierra Chica, Losser 226 (BY, F, GH, MO, PH); Dolores, Valle de Punilla, Nicora 1673 (POM); San Salvador, 970 m, Rodrigo 364 (US). Dpto. San Alberto: Sierra Grande, Mina Clavero Burkhart 7328 (F, POM); Sierra Grande, 10 km below El Condor, 1000 m, Goodspeed 17242 (GH); Nono, O’Donnell 6- Rodriguez 714 (A). Dpto. San Javier: La Barranca, Castellanos in 1939 (RSA); Quebrada de Yacanto, Castellanos in 1927 (RSA); La Poblacion entre Yacanto y Luyaba, A. T. Hunziker 11462 (RSA). Dpto. Santa Maria: Alta Gracia, ca. 600 m, ]. H. Hunziker 1158 (RSA). 26 A REVISION OF THE GENUS GAURA ( ONAGRACEAE ) Australia, new south wales. Wiangaree, shire, of Kyogle, Mackatj in 1967 (NSW); banks of Richmond River, nw of Kyogle, Salasoo in 1963 (NSW'). Queens¬ land. Pittsworth, White 6662 (BY, GH, NY); Darling Downs District, Jandowae to Dalby road at Pirrinauri, Doherty in 1959 (K); Millars Vale Creek, Marvvale, Glen- gallen Shire Council in 1958 (K). China, chekianc. Chienteh, Ling 2738 (NY). Japan. Okinawa. Kadekaru, Kume-jima Island, 1966, Nakejima 1682 (DS) (seen since about 1954). Mexico, baja California. San Jose del Cabo, Anthony 330 ( BM, DS, F, GH, K, MENU, MIN, MO, POM, US); Miraflores, Jones in 1928 ( DS, POM); Todos Santos, Jones 24137 (DAO, DS, DUKE, F, MICH, MO, NY, POM, PH, RSA, SMU, TEX); Mision Guadalupe, near 26°54'N, 112°26'W, ca. 700 m, Moran 11788 (DS); Mulege, Palmer 11 (GH, US); Santiago, Thomas 7804 ( DS, RSA); ca. 19 mi w of Tecate on road to Tijuana, Wiggins 6- Thomas 471 (DS). chihuahua. 6 mi s of Ciudad Juarez, Breedlove 15727 (DS; 20 km s of Ciudad Camargo, 1300 m, White 2228 (GH, MENU, MICH); near Lake Santa Maria, Nelson 6406 (US); vicinity of Chihuahua, 1300 m. Palmer 185 ( F, GH, MO, NY, US); Valle de Rosario, Pennington 411 (TEX); Jimenez, Pringle 7529 (MEXU); 45 mi s of Ahumada, Moldenke 2088 (DS). coahuila. Viesca, Fisher 3725 (NY); near Saltillo, 1500 m, Hinton 16798 (GH); 1 mi se of Ocampo, Johnston 8884 (GH); Muzquiz, Marsh 946 ( F, GH, TEX); Monclova, Gloria Mts., Marsh 1667 ( F, GH, LL, OKLA, TEX); 6 mi w of San Pedro, 4000 ft, Munz 15041 (GH, MO, POM), durango. 10 mi sw of Ciudad Lerdo, Munz 15037 (C.H, MO, POM); Durango and vicinity, Palmer 102 ( F, GH, MO, NY, US), nuevo leon. Monterrey, 550 m, Arsene et al. in 1911 (NY, RSA); Poblado de Higueras, Hernandez et al 16M508 (TEX); 16 km w of Sabinas Hidalgo, Dominguez ir McCart 8266 (TEX), sinaloa. Culiacan, Rose et al. 14867 (NY, US); Las Palmas, Sinaloa, Gonzalez Ortega 4542 (MEXU). sonora. 7-9 mi w of Navojoa, Gentry 7976 ( DS, MEXU, MICH, US); El Desierto, Rio Mayo, Gentry 3044 ( F, GH, MEXU, MO, US); Cochuto, 5100 ft, Hartman 96 ( C.H, NY, PENN, PH, US); 35 mi w of Sonoyta, Keck 4227 ( DS, POM); Hermosillo, Maltby 254 (US); Alamos, Roe et al. 12961 (NY, US); Arroyo del Pulpito, near Colonia Oaxaca, White 777 ( DS, MICH); Bavispe, Rio Bavispe, White 2902 (GH, MICH); Horconcitos, Rio Huachinera, White 2968 (GH, MICH, PH); Colonia Morelos, 2600 ft, White 4419 (GH, MICH, NY, US); Moctezuma, White 299 (GH, MICH); 42 mi e of Caborca, Moldenke 1536 (DS). zacatecas. 26 mi se of Sombrerete, Breedlove 14341 (DS). Gaura jtarviflora was probably originally a native of the shortgrass prairie in the interior of the United States, and spread widely from there as a weed of cultivated and waste areas. Owing to its strict autogamy, it easily becomes established from a single fruit. It has been cultivated as a curiosity in botanical gardens since at least the 1840s. The small dif¬ ferences in pubescence that have been reflected in the naming in infra¬ specific taxa are consistent with what would be expected in an autogamous species and do not deserve fonnal taxonomic recognition. According to information kindly sent by Mr. S. L. Everist this species is now extensively naturalized in southeastern Queensland, Australia. The first known collection was made* at Charter’s Towers in the North Kennedy MEMOIRS OF THE TORREY BOTANICAL CLUB 27 District, where it has not persisted, in 1929. The Pittsworth collection, cited above, was obtained in 1930, and from this locality the plant has spread out over an extensive area. In 1950 it was eollected at Roma, in the Maranoa District, its westernmost station. It was first noted at Goon- diwindi in the Darling Downs District, its southernmost locality in Queens¬ land, in 1956, and had spread into the vicinity of Kyogle in New South Wales by 1963, as shown by specimens cited above. All of the collections from the north end of the range of this species in Queensland, excluding the 1921 record (where the plant failed to persist), have been made since 1960 and a collection from Mulgildie, now the northernmost limit of the plant in Australia, was made for the first time in 1969. Mr. Everist has suggested that it is quite possible that Gaura parviflora has still not reached the northern limits of its range in Queensland. SECTION IV. CAMPOGAURA Gaura sect. Campogaura Raven & Gregory, sect. nov. Herbae perennes confertae, caulibus subglabris vel strigulosis, saepe etiam villosis. Inflorescentiae nutantes. Flores valde zygomorphi, vesper- tini. Fructi 4-angulati, parte superiore 4-costato, 4-angulato, ad basin at¬ tenuate, tereto. Clumped perennial herb, the stems subglabrous or strigulose, often also villous. Inflorescence nodding. Flowers strongly zygomorphic, the stamens in the lower half; flowers opening near sunset and withering late the next morning. Fruit not reflexing, 4-angled, with 4 sharp ridges and 4 furrows alternating on the pyramidal upper half, constricted sharply below, the base terete, narrowing gradually toward the bottom but at least half the diameter of the top throughout. Self-incompatible. Gametic chromosome numbers, n = 7, 14, 21, 28. Type Species: Gaura coccinea Pursh This distinctive species of the prairies and plains (hence the sectional name) is clearly related to the species of sections Stipogaura and Xero- gaura. It is probably one parent of the tetraploid Gaura drummondii. 5. Gaura coccinea Pursh, FI. Amer. Sept. 2: 733. 1814. (Norn, nud., Frasers Cat. 1813.) Munz, Bull. Torrey Bot. Club 65: 220. 1938; N. Amer. FI. II. 5: 194. 1965. Figs. 5, 35. Gaura odorata Sesse ex Lag., Gen. et Sp. Nov. 14. 1816. Type: Described from plants cultivated in the Royal Botanical Garden at Madrid, the seed brought from Mexico in 1804 by Martin de Sesse y Lacasta. See discussion on pp. 54, 55. 28 A REVISION OF THE GENUS GAURA ( ONACRACEAE ) Gaura epilobioides H.B.K., Nov. Gen. et Sp. 6: 93. 1823. Type: Near Actopan, Hidalgo, Mexico, May 1803, Alexander von Humboldt ( P. Isotype, B. Photographs, F, GH, POM, US). Gaura coccinea Pursh (S? integerrima Torr., Ann. Lyceum Nat. Hist. New York 2: 200. 1828. Type: Major Long’s Creek, near Stead, Union Co., New Mexico, 1 August 1820, Edivin James (NY). Gaura parvifolia Torr., Ann. Lyceum Nat. Hist. New York 2: 201. 1828. Type: Major Long’s Creek, near Stead, Union Co., New Mexico, 1 August 1820, Edwin James (NY). Gaura? suffrutescens Moc. & Sesse ex Ser., in DC., Prod. 3: 45. 1828. Type: FI. Mex. Ic. (ined.), t. 374 (G-DC). Gaura bracteata Ser., in DC., Prod. 3: 45. 1828. Type: In gardens, San Angel, Mexico, Mexico, Fl. Ic. (ined.), t. 373 (G-DC). Gaura multicaulis Raf., Atl. Jour. 146. 1832. Based on Gaura coccinea Pursh (}? integerrima Torr. Gaura marginata Lehm., in Hook., Fl., Amer.-Bor. 1: 208. 1834. Type: Plains of the Saskatchewan River, Canada, T. Drummond (Isotvpes, BM, BR, NMC). Gaura glabra Lehm., in Hook., Fl. Amer.-Bor. 1: 209. 1834. Type: Vicinity of Fort Carleton, Saskatchewan, T. Drummond (Isotypes, BM, BR, LE). Schizocarya kunthii Spach, Nouv. Ann. Mus. Hist. Nat. 4: 383. 1835. Based on Gaura epilobioides II.B.K. Gaura coccinea Pursh var. glabra (Lehm.) Munz, Bull. Torrey Bot. Club 65: 224. 1938. Gaura spicata Sesse & Moc., PI. Nov. Hisp. ed. 1. 56. 1888. Type: Vicinity of Mexico City, D. F., Mexico, June. Gaura induta Wooton & Standi., Contr. U. S. Natl. Herb. 16: 153. 1913. Type: Dry, clay hills near Pecos, 2010 m, San Miguel Co., New Mexico, 15 August 1908, P. C. Standley 4933 (US 498956. Isotypes, CH, NY). Gaura linearis Wooton & Standi., Contr. U. S. Natl. Herb. 16: 154. 1913. Type: Gypsum soil near Lakewood, Eddy Co., New Mexico, 6 August 1909, E. O. Wooton (US 564593). Gaura coccinea Pursh var. parvifolia (Torr.) Rickett, Kew Bull. 1934: 57. 1934. Munz, Bull. Torrey Bot. Club 65: 223. 1938; N. Amer. Fl. II. 5: 196. 1965. Gaura coccinea Pursh var. typica Munz, Bull. Torrey Bot. Club 65: 221. 1938. Gaura coccinea Pursh var. epilobioides (II.B.K.) Munz, Bull. Torrey Bot. Club 65: 222. 1938. Munz, N. Amer. Fl. II. 5: 195. 1965. Gaura coccinea Pursh var. arizonica Munz, Bull. Torrey Bot. Club 65: MEMOIRS OF THE TORREY BOTANICAL CLUB 29 225. 1938. Type: Globe, Gila Co., Arizona, 17 May 1919, Alice East- wood 8657 (GH). Munz, N. Amer. FI. II. 5: 196. 1965. Clumped perennial herb, from a deep, thick taproot, often branching several centimeters below the ground and giving rise to underground stems, or branching only at the surface or not at all; underground stems often becoming horizontal or nearly so and giving rise to new plants; stems 1-12 dm tall, the plants varying from full and copiously branched at the base, little above, to strict and little branched at the base, copiously above. Entire plant densely strigulose with long spreading trichomes often present near the base to subglabrous with strigulose pubescence on ovary, out¬ side of floral tube, and sepals, and sometimes at edges of lower leaves also. Leaves linear to narrowly elliptic, 0.7-6.5 cm long, 0. 1-1.5 cm wide, entire to remotely and coarsely serrate. Inflorescence 8-47 (-65) cm long, the peduncle 1-6.5 cm long, strict or well branched; bracts subulate, 2-5 mm long, 0.4-1. 1 mm wide. Floral tube 4-11 (-13) mm long. Sepals 5-9 (-10) mm long, (0.75— ) 1-1. 5(-2) mm wide. Petals white fading to orange-red to deep maroon, very rarely pale cream, 3-7 (-8) mm long, 2-4 mm wide. Filaments cream, 3-6.5(-7) mm long; anthers yellow to light or deep red, (2.5-) 3-5 (-5.5) mm long. Style (9.5-) 10-21 (-21.5) mm long. Fruit 4- 8.5 (-9) mm long, (1-) 1.5-3 mm thick at the thickest point. Seeds (1-) 3-4, 1.5-3 mm long, 1-1.5 mm thick, light to reddish brown. Self-incom¬ patible. Gametic chromosome numbers, n = 7, 14, 21, 28 (with intermediate numbers and supernumerary chromosomes occasionally found). Type: Near Mandan, Morton Co., North Dakota, 22 June to 5 July 1811, John Bradbury (PH). Distribution (fig. 40): Frequent in light, sandy soil, usually at middle elevations and ascending to about 3000 m in Mexico; local in the Kootenay District of British Columbia, and from the valley of the North Fork of the Saskatchewan River at about 53°40'N lat. near Edmonton, Alberta, and about 52°40'N lat. near Battleford, Saskatchewan south throughout southern Alberta, Saskatchewan, and Manitoba, and through Montana, North Dakota, and western Minnesota south, mainly east of the Continental Divide to central Colorado, northwestern Missouri, western Oklahoma, central and western Texas, southern Utah, southernmost Nevada, and northeastern San Bernardino County, California, then southward through northeastern Sonora and the mountains of Chihuahua, Coahuila, Nuevo Leon, and Tamaulipas to the Trans-Mexican Volcanic Belt (where abundant); rare in southern Puebla and northern Oaxaca at about 17°N lat. Introduced and collected once each in Chiapas, Mexico, in Rio Grande do Sul, Brazil, and in Wales. Also a sporadic weed in Wisconsin, Illinois, Indiana, Michigan, New York, MEMOIRS OF THE TORREY BOTANICAL CLUB 31 coastal southern California, and in southern Ontario. Possibly native at Piute Creek, Kern County, California (6 June 1893, N. C. Wilson, DS, NO), but probably introduced. Flowers April to August. Representative Specimens Examined (from outside of the United States): Brazil, rio grande do sul. Porto Alegre, Reinick in 1899 (GH). Great Britain, wales. Carmathenshire: Adventive, Pembrey Burrows, Hollis in 1935 (K). Mexico, aguascalientes. Aguascalientes, Kuntze 23484 (NY). chiapas. Es- cuintla, Matuda 676 (MEXU, MICH, US), chihuahua. Santa Eulalia, pass between Velardena and Cristo mines, ca. 28°37'N, 105°53'W, Hewitt 294 (GH); near Charco, Johnston 8134 (GH); mountains w of Chihuahua, LeSueur 805 (F, NO, SMU, TEX); foothills of the Sierra Madre near Colonia Juarez, Nelson 6336 (GH, US); end of Sierra del Diablo, Stewart 1943c (GH); 7 mi s of junction of Casas Grandes Hwy. on Mexico Hwy. 45, Straw 6- Forman 1842 (MICH, RSA); Mpio. de Janos, 4800 ft, White 2572 (GH, MEXU, MINN); 12 mi s of Camargo, 400 ft, White 2229 ( GH, MICH), coahuila. Saltillo, 1600 m, Arsene 6- Adola 6346 (US); Parras, Kenoijer ir Crum in 1948 (A); Viesca, 3725 ft, Fisher 44108 (GH, MO, NSC, NY, SMU); Arteaga Road, Kenoijer 6- Crum 2659 (A, MICH); 10 mi e of Arteaga (ca. 20 mi e of Saltillo), Straw 6- Forman 1349 (MICH, RSA); 6 mi n of La Ventura on road to Saltillo, Johnston 7645 (GH); Muzquiz, Marsh 2119 ( F, GH); Monclova, Marsh 1704 (TEX); Sierra de Santa Rosa, s of Muzquiz, Marsh 2272 (GH, TEX); 13 mi s of Saltillo, McGregor 16713 ( DS, KANU); 6 mi w of San Pedro, Munz 15040 (C.H, MO, POM ) ; end of road from T. Armendaiz N. into the Sierra del Pino, Johnston ir Mueller 690 (GY); Sierra de las Cruces, Johnston 6- Mueller 231 (GH); 9 km s of Parras on Sierra Negra, Stanford et al. 240 (GH, ILL, DS, MEXU, MO, NY); Fraile, 59 km s of Saltillo, Stanford et al. 251 ( DS, GH, ILL, MEXU, MO, NY); 11 km ne of Jimuleo, 2100 m, Stanford et al. 20 ( DS, GH, MO, NY); 15 km w of Con¬ cepcion de Oro, Stanford et al. 537 ( DS, GH, MO, NY); 25 km s of Piedras Negras, Rinehart 216 (OKL); Carneros Pass, Pringle 3105 ( BR, CM, COCO, F, G, GH, LE, MICH, MEXU, MO, MSC, ND, NY, RSA, US); Canon del Indio Felipe, Sierra Hechiceros, Stewart 19 (GH); n of La Ventura, 6000 ft, Shreve 6- Tinkhorn 9610 (GH); Paila, Km 570, 1200 m, Aguirre & Reko 42 (NY); 8 km ne of Santa Elena, Stewart 1122 (GH); n slope of Sierra Planchada, 5 mi w of El Oro, White 1998 (MEXU, MICH); 60 mi w of Cuatro Cienegas, White 1955 (DS, GH, MICH). durango. Chupaderos n of Durango, Pennell 18181 (MEXU, PH, US); near Yerbanis, Shreve 9148 (GH); 11 mi n of La Zarca, Waterfall 12541 (GH, MICH, OKLA, US); 34-38 mi ne of Durango, Waterfall 13359 ( IKLA, SMU); 0.5 mi w of El Pino, ca. 10 mi w of Durango, Waterfall ir Wallis 13359 (IA, OKLA); 1 mi s of La Zarca, Wiens 3524 (COLO). Guanajuato. Acambaro, Duges 303 (GH); San Miguel Allende, Kenoijer 1913 (GH); Leon, Matuda M 19057 (F); Irapuato, Woodruf 144 (NY). hidalgo. Vicinity of Zimapan, Kenoijer 1058 (GH); Tulancingo, Cuautepec, Moore 1601 (BH); near Tequixquiac, Rose 6- Painter 6636 ( GH, US ) ; near El Salto, Rose 6- Painter 8031 (US); Hacienda Palmar near Pachuca, Rose i? Painter 8820 (NY, US), jalisco. Near Km 31 sw of Ojuelos on road to Aguascalientes, above Presa de Valerio, McVaugh 16891 (MICH, LIS); 1.5 mi s of Ojeulos, Winetraub 6- Roller 33 (MICH). Mexico. Alrededores de Atlahutenco, Mpio. de Ecatepec Morelos, 2250 m, Cruz 508 ( DS, MICH, TEX); Teotihuacan, 2200 m, Froderstrom MICH- TEX); Vera Cruz’ 8300 ft, Guadalupe Victoria, f, oES' Vs l NUE™ LE6N' Near Cerro GrantIe" ca' 3 mi s» “f Ascencion, 7000-8000 ft, Straw tr Forman 1400 ( MEXU, RSA); 67 km nw of San Roberto on ^ ,Rne 6 Mor‘ 50 (WISC>1 Sabinas Hidalgo, Ports in 1941 ( L); 38 mi se of Saltillo, Waterfall 16615 (OKL, OKLA, RSA, SMU). Oaxaca, Ua. o mi s of I amazulapan, Straw 6- Gregory 1038 (GH, MICH, MEXU, RSA). plebla. Rancho Posada, 2194 m, vicinity of Puebla, Arsetw 95 (US)- Cholula DTnm( US). SAN LUIS potosi. 16 mi e of San Luis Potosi,’ Breedlove 14364A (DS); 13 mi nw of San Luis Potosi, Breedlove 15471 (DS)- Charcas, Landed 5137 (MICH, NY, US), sonora. 23.5 mi ne of Bocoachic on road to Esqueda 4480 ft, Wiggins 11742 (DAO, DS, TEX, US), tamaulipas. Between Marcela and Hermosa, Stanford et al. 2662 ( DS, GH, MO, NY, RSA). tlaxcala. Hwy. to Veracruz ca. 9 km e of Mexico, Lambert 41-23 (PENN, PH); Km. 185 on road from Huamantla to El Carmen, Sohns 624 (US); 10 mi n of San Martin Texmelucan, Sohns 659 (US), veracruz. Mt. Orizaba, 4000 ft, Seaton 266 (GH)- Maltrata, Matuda 1219 (MEXU, MICH); Jalapa, Coulter 164 (GH). Zacatecas’. 32 mi nw of San Luis Potosi, Breedlove 15476 (DS); Pedernalillo, near Guadalupe, Dressier 306 (MO); Fresnillo, Knobloch 1030 (MICH, MSC); near Concepcion del Oro, Palmer 318 (GH, NY, US); 22 mi n of Zacatecas, Straw 6 ■ Forman 1493 (GH, MEXU, RSA); 2 mi se of Sombrereto, Waterfall 13804A (OKLA, IA). Gaura coccinea is commonly known in Mexico as “linda tarde” or hierba de and in Texas as wild honeysuckle. There appears to be nothing to be gained by ascribing this species to “Nutt, ex Pursh,” as Nuttall is not mentioned either by Pursh or in the Fraser Catalogue of 1813, even though we now know that Nuttall was the author of this anonymous catalogue (cf. Reveal, Rhodora 70 : 25-54. 1968). Pursh clearly based his species upon the Bradbury specimen cited above, and not on any Nuttall specimen; indeed he remarks that the habit of his plant differs from that indicated (by a sign) in the Fraser Catalogue, where the name is, in any case, a nomen nudum. Pursh did include in his protologue a reference to the Catalogue. We are indebted to J. E. Dandy for his remarks on this matter. As attested by its rather complex synonymy, Gaura coccinea is a variable species. Over much of its wide range, it is relatively uniform, with the plants low, usually 2-5 dm tall, branching mostly at and below ground and not much above, and often forming large colonies partly by means of vegetative reproduction. The inflorescence in such plants is usually less than 5 cm long. Plants from southern Nevada and northwestern Arizona are MEMOIRS OF TIIE TORREY BOTANICAL CLUB 33 taller but usually do not differ in habit, although they occasionally branch more than usual above. Such plants represent one end of a very gradual cline which begins in north-central Arizona. From west and central Texas north into the panhandle and southern Oklahoma, the plants are taller, usually 5-10 dm tall, unbranched or with a very few branches from the base, but well branched above, and occur in clumps, spreading very little by rhizomes. The more numerous branches are long, with the central leader generally more than 5 cm long and longer than that of the widespread race at a comparable stage of growth. There is a very gradual transition from this race to the more widespread one, with many populations and individual plants impossible to assign to one or the other. Under the circumstances, it does not appear desirable to reflect these differences in the formal taxonomy. Chromosoinally, Gaura coccinea is very complex, with diploid (n = 7), tetraploid (n=14), hexaploid (n = 21), and octoploid (n = 28) popula¬ tions. The most extreme expression of the “Texas” race is found in the diploids, which are confined to Trans-Pecos Texas and adjacent New Mexico, and are relatively uniform morphologically. In general, the diploids have the smallest flowers found in the species, although the ranges of measurements of flower parts overlap broadly. Tetraploids and hexaploids found in adjacent regions are in general intermediate in their characteristics between the diploids and the more widespread expression of the species. The transitions are often not gradual. For example, in the area of the Davis Mountains in west Texas, populations of hexaploids growing within a few miles of one another may represent one or the other extreme or various intermediates. Around Carrizozo in south-central New Mexico the same sort of mixture of distinctive populations is found among the tetraploids. On the other hand, north of the central Texas panhandle and south of the Rio Grande (the sampling is relatively poor in Mexico), the populations seem relatively uniform and to change gradually over vast areas. The octoploids occur locally as populations in predominantly tetraploid areas. They were presumably derived from tetraploid plants directly. Both tetraploids and hexaploids occur widely in the central and southern parts of the range of the species, and are, like the octoploids, indistinguish¬ able morphologically except occasionally on a very local basis. Neither pollen size nor pore number is useful in distinguishing chromosomal races in Gaura coccinea. The consistent occurrence of autopolyploid pairing in all polyploids of this species indicates a lack of chromosomal differentiation. The simplest explanation for the observed pairing would seem to be an initial stabilization of a diploid race of plants similar to those occurring in west Texas and a 34 A REVISION OF THE GENUS GAURA (ONAGRACEAE) tetraploid race with the characteristics of populations found in the central and northern parts of the species area. There is no reason to postulate an allotetraploid origin for the latter; indeed, the consistent autotetraploid association of its chromosomes and the presence of but one diploid in the complex militate against such an hypothesis. Nor can it confidently be asserted that the tetraploid originated from the diploid; cytogenetic evidence would be equally consistent with the opposite point of view ( cf., Raven and rhomson, Amer. Naturalist 98: 251, 252. 1964), and there appears to be no logical basis for distinguishing between these two theories. The re¬ striction of the diploid to an area where many related diploid species occur, however, lends credence to the idea that it may be ancestral rather than derived. Given the initial presence of these two races, it is a simple matter to visualize the development of the pattern seen at present. The origin of the tetraploids from diploids and of octoploids from tetraploids would be consistent with the geographical patterns observed and the lack of morpho¬ logical differentiation. The opposite processes may also have taken place occasionally. With the sort of chromosomal equivalence that prevails in Gaura coccinea, hexaploids can originate directly from the functioning of unreduced tetraploid gamete, from tetraploid-octoploid hybridization, or in the conventional way. Similarly, tetraploids can probablv be derived in one step from hexaploid-diploid crosses. The proliferation of polyploid races and the subsequent hybridization within and doubtless also between chromosomal levels is attested by the pattern displayed from this complex species and the impossibility of finding morphological discontinuities in it. In our survey of approximately 300 wild plants, approximately 5 apparent interploid hybrids were encountered (Raven and Gregorv, Brittonia 24: 71- 86. 1972). SEGTION V. STIPOGAURA Gaura sect. Stipogaura Raven & Gregory, sect. nov. Herbae perennes confertae vel rhizomatosae, caulibus strigulosis vel glandulosis, saepe etiam villosis. Infiorescentiae erectae. Flores valde zygomorphi, vespertini. Fructorum corpus ovoideum, lateribus concavibus, longe abrupteque stipitatum. Clumped or rhizomatous perennial herbs, the stems strigulose or glan¬ dular, and usually villous also. Inflorescence erect. Flowers strongly zygo- morphic, the stamens in the lower quarter or half or well distributed; flowers opening near sunset and withering early the next morning. Fruit reflexing at maturity, with the bodv ovoid, winged along the angles, the MEMOIRS OF THE TORREY BOTANICAL CLUB 35 sides concave with the upper half of each concavity forming a shallow trough, abruptly narrowed into a long stipe. Self-incompatible. Gametic chromosome numbers, n = 7, 14. Type Species: Gaura villosa Torr. Distribution: Sandy and rocky slopes and flats from southeasternmost Colorado and Texas south to eastern Durango, Coahuila, Nuevo Leon, and western Tamaulipas, Mexico. The five species of section Stipoguara are closely related to one another and present an interesting pattern of relationship. Three— Gaura calcicola, G. mckelveyae, and G. filipes— are medium-sized to small clumped diploids. They replace one another geographically, with G. calcicola on rocky slopes at moderate elevations in west Texas and southward into Mexico, G. mckelveyae on sandy plains at low elevations in and near the Rio Grande valley, and G. filipes in the southeastern United States. Gaura sinuata, an aggressively rhizomatous weedy tetraploid, was very probably derived following hybridization between G. calcicola (or the common ancestor of G. calcicola and G. filipes, which are extremely similar morphologically) and G. mckelveyae. It is somewhat intermediate ecologically and has spread rather widely as a weed of cultivated fields. The fifth species, Gaura villosa, is a large, handsome plant of the dunes and sandy flats in south and west Texas and adjacent states, apparently separated from the others by its extreme ecological specialization. It is listed first in the section not because woodiness is thought to be primitive, a dubious proposition, but rather because it is thought to have been a rather early offshoot of the common ancestor of the other species. 6. Gaura villosa Torr., Ann. Lyceum Nat. Hist. New York 2: 200. 1827. Munz, Bull. Torrey Bot. Club 65: 213. 1938; N. Amer. FI. II. 5: 192. 1965. Clumped woody perennial of dunes and sandy flats, from a deep, twisted, woody rootstock; stems sending up several branches near ground level and branching again where the inflorescences originate to form at maturity a full, leafy plant with long inflorescences rising above; stems 6-18 dm tall. Plants densely villous with hairs 2-3 mm long all over below the inflorescence, sometimes more sparsely so, and with a dense under¬ story of strigulose or glandular hairs; inflorescence strigulose, glandular- pubescent, or hirtellous; leaves densely covered with loose, strigose pu¬ bescence, rarely with a few glandular hairs below. Leaves oblanceolate to very narrowly elliptic or linear, 0,5-8 cm long, 0.15-2 cm wide, subentire or shallowly sinuate-dentate, occasionally markedly so, often undulate, acum¬ inate at the tip, sessile. Inflorescence generally well branched, 2o-127 cm 36 A REVISION OF THE GENUS GAURA ( ONAGRACEAE ) 44 45 46 FIGURES 41-46. Flowers of the species of Gaura sect. Stipogaura. Fig. 41. G. villosa subsp. villosa.— Fig. 42. G. villosa subsp. parksii.— Fig. 43. G. calcicola.— Fig. 44. G. filipes.— Fig. 45. G. mckelveyae.— Fig. 46. G. sinuata. MEMOIRS OF THE TORREY BOTANICAL CLUB 37 long; bracts narrowly lanceolate to narrowly ovate, 1-6 (-10) mm long, 0.75- 1.5 mm wide. Flowers with stamens in the lower quarter. Floral tube 1.5-5 mm long. Sepals 6-14 mm long, 1-2.5 mm wide. Petals 7-13 mm long, 4-6 mm wide. Filaments 4.5-11 mm long; anthers 2-4.5 mm long. Style 9-18.5 mm long. Body of the fruit 9-19 mm long, 1-3.5 mm thick, the stipe 2-10 mm long. Seeds (l-)2-4, 2-3(-4) mm long, 0.75-1.25 mm thick, yellowish to light brown or rarely reddish brown. Self-incompatible. Gametic chromosome number, n = 7. Type: Along the upper Canadian River, in Hartley, Oldham, or Potter Co., Texas, 4-9 August 1820, Edwin James (NY). Distribution (fig. 38): Dunes and sandy flats, Rio Grande Plain of south Texas; High Plains and Rolling Plains of northwestern Texas, eastern New Mexico, southeastemmost Colorado, southwestern Kansas (one station in Ellis Co.), and the western half of Oklahoma; locally naturalized in New Jersey. The two subspecies recognized in Gaura villosa have a disjunct distribu¬ tion but are so closely similar that it seems best to emphasize these sim¬ ilarities by maintaining them within a single species. 6a. Gaura villosa subsp. villosa. Figs. 6, 41. Gaura cinerea Wooton & Standi., Contr. U. S. Natl. Herb. 16: 152. 1913. Type: 20 mi s of Roswell, 1080 m, Chaves Co., New Mexico, August 1900, F. S. 6- E. S. Earle 533 (US 382592. Isotype, NY). Gaura villosa Torr. var. typica Munz, Bull. Torrey Bot. Club 65- 214 1938. Gaura villosa Torr. var. arenicola Munz, Bull. Torrey Bot. Club 65: 215 1938. Type: 5 mi ne of Portales, on sand dunes near U.S. Hwy. 70, Roosevelt Co., New Mexico, 14 June 1930, G. /. Goodman & C. L. Hitchcock 1124 (POM 171881. Isotypes, MICH, NY). Munz, N. Amer. FI. II. 5: 192. 1965. Plants with an understory of either strigulose or glandular hairs, the corresponding kind covering the ovaries, outside of the floral tube, and sepals more densely; branches of the inflorescence either glabrous or sparse¬ ly glandular-pubescent; leaves rarely with a few glandular hairs beneath. Leaves narrowly lanceolate to very narrowly elliptic or linear, occasionally narrowly elliptic to lanceolate or even narrowly oblanceolate toward the base of the plant, subentire or shallowly sinuate-dentate, occasionally mark¬ edly so. Inflorescence whiplash-like, comparatively stout. Floral tube 2-5 mm long. Petals 8.5-13 mm long. Filaments 5-11 mm long; anthers 2.5- 4.5 mm long. Style 10-18.5 mm long. Body of the fruit 9-18 mm long. 38 A REVISION OF THE GENUS GAURA (ONAGRACEAE) 2-3.5 mm wide, the stipe 2-8 mm long. Self-incompatible. Gametic chro¬ mosome number, n — 7. Distribution (fig. 38): Sand dunes and sandy flats, High Plains and Rolling Plains of northwestern Texas, eastern New Mexico, southeastern- most Colorado, southwestern Kansas (one station farther north, in Ellis County), and the western half of Oklahoma; locally naturalized in New Jersey. Representative Specimens Examined: United States. Colorado. Baca Co.: 23 mi s of Walsh, Stephens 6- Brooks 21792 ( DS, KANU); s bank of Cimarron River at se comer of county, Weber 5142 (COCO, COLO, DAO, DS, GH, KANU, NSC, OKL, RSA, SMU, TAES, TEX, US). Kansas. Barber Co.: 3 mi s of Medicine Lodge, Horr ir Franklin in 1940 (KANU). Clark Co.: 10 mi s of Ashland, Rydberg ir Imler 749 (KANU, NY). Comanche Co.: Coldwater, Rydberg ir Imler 678 (NY). Ellis Co.: Hays, Bondy in 1937 (OKL, UMO). Kiowa Co.: 5 mi n of Greensburg, McGregor 10634 (KANU). Meade Co.: 2 mi w of Meade Co. State Park, Horr 3668 (KANU). Morton Co.: 9 mi n of Elkhart, McGregor 5105 (KANU). Pratt Co.: Turkey Creek, Norris 193 (MO). Seward Co.: 20 mi ne of Liberal, Rydberg ir Imler 852 (KANU, NY). Stevens Co.: Hitchcock in 1897 (POM), new jersey. Cape May Co.: S of New England Road, Cold Spring, Brown in 1921 (PENN), in 1922 (PH), new Mexico. Chaves Co.: 30 mi s of Roswell, F. S. 6- E. S. Earle 533 (MIN, MO, NCU). Colfax Co.: W of Willow Bar, Fendler 213 (MO). Curry Co.: 9 mi s of Broadview, Stephens ir Brooks 25624 ( DS, KANU). De Baca Co.: Fort Sumner, Shinners 20924 (SMU). Guadalupe Co.: Santa Rosa, Cooley 3 (OKLA). Lea Co.: 3.3 mi e-ne of Hobbs, Shinners 20071 (SMU). Quay Co.: 3 mi s of Sand Springs, Wagen- knecht in 1957 (KANU). Roosevelt Co.: 5 mi ne of Portales, Goodman L~ Hitchcock 1124 ( GH, MIN, POM). Oklahoma. Alfalfa Co.: 1 mi nw of Gonot Salt Plains Dam, Waterfall 7834 (OKL). Beaver Co.: 2 mi e of Headquarters, Hindman 216 (NCU, OKLA). Blaine Co.: 3 mi s, 1.5 mi w of Watonga, Cox in 1954 (OKLA). Caddo Co.: E of Bridgeport, Munz 13576 (POM). Cimarron Co.: S of Walsh, Weber 5210 (COLO, NSC). Cleveland Co.: 6 mi nw of Norman, Bruner in 1924 (MIN). Comanche Co.: Wichita Mts., Marcy’s Expedition. Cotton Co.: 4 mi s of Randletter, Waterfall 7283 (OKL, OKLA). Custer Co.: 1/4 mi s, 2 mi e of Weatherford, Water¬ fall 2238 (OKL, OKLA). Dewey Co.: Near Canton, Stevens 871 ( DS, GH, ILL, MO, MIN, OKL, OKLA). Ellis Co.: Pack Saddle Bridge, Canadian River valley, Goodman 2591 (ISC, MO, OKL, POM). Grady Co.: 3/4 mi e of Juttle, Pearce 690 (OKL). Grant Co.: 20 mi w of Medford, Waterfall 7366 (OKL, OKLA). Greer Co.: 1 mi e of Magnum, Waterfall 7309 (OKI,, OKLA). Hannon Co.: 1.7 mi w of Vinson, Waterfall 7767 (OKL). Harper Co.: 4 mi s of Rosstown, A. ir R. A. Nelon ir Goodman 5319 (OKI,, TEX). Jackson Co.: 3 mi w of Altus, Hoj)kins 1010 (OKI,). Jefferson Co.: S of Terral, Goodman 7204 (OKL). Kingfisher Co.: 2 mi se of Dover, Byers 71 (OKLA). Kiowa Co.: 8 mi w of Snyder, Waterfall 13101 (OKLA). Logan Co.: Near Guthrie, Stevens 3262 1/2 (GH). Murray Co.: Davis, Arbuckle Mts., Emig 746 (CM). Payne Co.: 3 mi w of Stillwater, 5.5 mi s, Byler 141 (OKI \ Roger Mills Co.: Engleman 1624 (OKL). Texas Co.: Goodwell, Butler 119 (OKLA). Woods Co.: Salt Fork River near Alva, Stevens 2876 (ILL, MIN, OKLA, POM). Woodward Co.: Fort Supply, Potter in 1882 (GH). texas. Bailey Co.: 1.5 mi s of MEMOIRS OF THE TORREY BOTANICAL CLUB 39 Muleshoe, Cory 27499 (TAES). Baylor Co.: Seymour, Reverchon in 1879 ( F, GH, NY). Briscoe Co.: 3 mi s of Quitaque, Whitehouse 10010 (MICH, NY, SMU). Carson Co.: 3 mi w of Skellytown, Stephens 17341 ( DS, KANU). Collingsworth Co.: 5.5 mi n of Wellington, Parks ’ Th°™ b' Muenscher 8905 (in 948) (CU). Texas. Archer Co.: 2 mi w of Archer City, Shinners 18559 (SMU) Austin Co.: Industry, Wurzlow in 1894 (ILL). Bastrop Co.: Bastrop, Duval in 1928 (U3). Bee Co.: 5 mi ne of Beeville, Rios Cavazos 198 (LL). Bell Co.: Near Temple, Wolf 3555 ( F, TAES). Bexar Co.: San Antonio, Heller 1590 (CU F GH MICH, MIN, MSC, MO, NY, PH, US). Brazos Co.: Lindheimer in 1843 (MO)’ Brown Co.: Brownwood, Ewing 47 (SMU, TEX). Burnet Co.: 13 mi w of Burnet! Jones 8 (LL). Calhoun Co.: La Feria, Cannon in 1926 (MICH). Cherokee Co • Old Frankston Crossing, Stripling (FSU). Comal Co.: New Braunfels, Lindheimer 54 A REVISION OF THE GENUS GAURA ( ONAGRACEAE ) in 1848 (MIN, SMU). Crockett Co.: Ozona, Parks ir Cory 29669 (TAES). Dallas Co.: Oak Cliff, Mervin in 1953 (SMU, TEX). Dewitt Co.: Cuero, Howell 296 (US). Dimmit Co.: 5 mi se of Catarina, C. 6- V. C. Flores 171 (SMU, TAES, TEX). Duval Co.: San Diego, Croft in 1886 (NY). Erath Co.: Dublin, Maxwell 28 (F). Fayette Co.: Muldoon area, Ripple 51-589 (TEX). Frio Co.: Dilley, Drews 7 (TEX). Gillespie Co.: 30 mi s of Mason, Munz ir Gregory 23433 (RSA). Guadalupe Co.: Seguin, Gregory 286 (RSA). Harris Co.: N of Harrisburg, Eggert in 1899 (MIN, MO). Hay Co.: 3 mi s of Dripping Springs, Knodel